Search SBL
 







Meeting Abstracts

2006 Annual Meeting

Washington, DC

Meeting Begins11/18/2006
Meeting Ends11/21/2006

Call for Papers Opens: 12/15/2005
Call for Papers Closes: 2/28/2006

Requirements for Participation

  Meeting Abstracts


Feigning History: Zelophehad’s Fictional Daughters and the Erosion of Female Inheritance Rights
Program Unit: New Historicism and the Hebrew Bible
David H. Aaron, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion

Only four Pentateuchal passages frame laws as deriving from an actual “event” or “suit.” The most extensive narrative is that of Zelophehad’s daughters, who attempt to inherit their son-less father’s estate, only to have their alleged victory in Numbers 27 thwarted by their uncles in Numbers 36. Most scholars have related to Nu 36 as a subsequent “emendation” of the earlier Nu 27 law, passed in favor of the daughters. I shall argue that Nu 27 and 36 share a single author, who fabricated the fiction of Zelophehad in order to undermine what was standard fare in Ancient Near Eastern societies—female inheritance. As such, “history” is created in these passages as to provide a ruse for altering by means of an oracle what was otherwise commonly practiced. In this sense, both law and history are crafted to serve ideology. The reader accepts the “reality” of this ruse because of the author’s crafy narrative plausibility, but the ploy only lasts until the reader recognizes that no other law in the Pentateuch derives from so elaborate a literary scheme.


Liberating Childhood: Reflections on a Child Perspective Reading of the Early Christian Sources
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Reidar Aasgaard, University of Oslo, Norway

Children, and concerns about their position and rights, have received growing attention within modern research. This is also the case within the fields of religion and theology (cf. e.g. the AAR Childhood studies consultation). The issue of children has also been taken up in research on the ancient world, particularly in the works by B. Rawson (crystallised in her Children and Childhood in Roman Italy, 2003). During the last decade, childhood has also come within the focus of early Christianity scholars, some years ago in books by P. Müller and W.A. Strange, very recently in P. Balla’s The Child-Parent Relationship in the New Testament (2003) and O.M. Bakke’s When Children Became People: The Birth of Childhood in Early Christianity (2005). In various ways, these works address a number of issues related to children: on their roles and status within early Christianity, on ancient perceptions of childhood, and on the changes which the emerging Christian religion may have brought to children’s lives. In the paper, I shall present a brief survey of this literature and reflect on the challenges and potentials of further research on the topic. The paper will employ examples from my own research on childhood in early Christianity (particularly on Paul and the apocryphal infancy gospels), and address the question about the viability of a special children’s perspective on the reading of the New Testament and other early Christian sources. Is it in relation to this material and in the interest of children possible – and even essential – to speak of a specific “theology of childhood”?


The First Rural Christians: Excavating the Milieu of the Infancy Gospel of Thomas
Program Unit: Social History of Formative Christianity and Judaism
Reidar Aasgaard, Faculty of Theology, University of Oslo, Norway

The apocryphal Infancy gospel of Thomas (IGT), which narrates the childhood story of Jesus from age five to twelve, is an enigmatic text. Originating in a 2nd century Greek-speaking context in the 2nd century CE, it proved very popular, and has been preserved in a variety of recensions and versions. Because of its complicated tradition history, much scholarly effort has been spent on tracing its original form, but with little success. Only limited attention has been given to its actual contents. This lack of attention, however, is also very much due to views about IGT as aberrant and banal, not least because of its seemingly offensive depiction of Jesus. Thus, IGT has by many been regarded of little theological and historical significance, and it has often been made an object of denigration. This paper will in opposition to such views argue that IGT should not in any way be underestimated. Rather, it should be regarded an important testimony to the lives and thinking of a much neglected group: the large number of “mainstream” non-elite early Christians living in Mediterranean rural areas. This will be demonstrated through select examples from IGT, which address different, but central aspects in it: its oral character, narrative world, socio-cultural values, views of gender, and theological profile. Instead of being regarded inferior and peripheral, IGT may turn out to be a quality rustic produce of an early Christian milieu deserving far more attention than it has received. The gospel may in fact be an unadorned, yet precious gem in our heritage from the first rural Christians. The paper will, in addition to my own book on IGT, The childhood of Jesus (forthc.), build on the contributions by Hock (1995) and Chartrand-Burke (2001).


Symbolic Images of Endemic Childhood Trauma Embedded in New Testament Writings: Cultural Functions and Implications
Program Unit: Bible and Cultural Studies
Benjamin Abelow, Great Neck, NY

The patriarchal corporal punishment and abandonment of children has been historically widespread. These patterns of painful childhood experience form striking parallels with narrative and theological themes in the New Testament. For example, images of an innocent Son obediently suffering according to his Father's will, and concepts of religious sin as punishable disobedience to a divine Father, closely parallel ordinary experiences of childhood punishment. Similar parallels pertain to childhood abandonment, most strikingly in the Matthean cry of dereliction, which represents the dramatic insertion of a psalmistic lament of abandonment into the context of a Father-Son relationship. Taken together, these parallels appear to be too extensive and precise to plausibly be explained by chance. This fact suggests that these canonical parallels can properly be understood as textually embedded symbolic expressions about culturally sanctioned patterns of childhood trauma. Just as post-traumatic dreams can, for the individual, symbolically portray idiosyncratic traumas, so can canonical embeds of trauma function as a cultural mechanism for symbolically portraying stereotypical endemic traumas. Similarly, as post-traumatic behavioral and emotional repetitions can for the individual express, in action and affect, idiosyncratic traumas, so can canonical embeds function culturally to "lubricate" and socially coordinate responses to endemic traumas. Recognizing the presence of canonical parallels to patterns of endemic trauma can illuminate otherwise "invisible" norms of trauma and clarity their personal and societal impacts. Because significant parts of the Christian tradition are rooted in or associated with these parallels, the thesis presented here has broad religious implications. (In a complementary paper for the Psychology and Biblical Studies unit, I discuss the significance of these textual parallels for our understanding of New Testament origins.)


Culturally Endemic Patterns of Childhood Trauma Reflected in New Testament Narrative and Theology: Implications for New Testament Origins
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Benjamin Abelow, Great Neck, NY

The patriarchal corporal punishment and abandonment of children has been historically widespread. These patterns of painful childhood experience form striking parallels with narrative and theological themes in the New Testament. For example, images of an innocent Son obediently suffering according to his Father’s will, and concepts of religious sin as punishable disobedience to a divine Father, closely parallel ordinary experiences of childhood punishment. Similar parallels pertain to childhood abandonment, most strikingly in the Matthean cry of dereliction, which represents the dramatic insertion of a psalmistic lament of abandonment into the context of a Father-Son relationship. Some of these parallels are extensive and precise, suggesting that they did not arise by chance. In this paper, I explore the radical implications of these parallels for our understanding of New Testament origins. Specifically, I argue that central canonical traditions were shaped, without intention or conscious awareness, as a reflection of endemic childhood punishment and abandonment in the highly patriarchal world of the early Roman Empire. This shaping could have occurred through the “revelation” of internally produced symbolic images arising from childhood; through a social-evolutionary process occurring during oral transmission; or by other means. Psychologically, symbolization could have occurred through trauma-specific mechanisms such as dissociation; through distortions of early memory associated with childhood “amnesia”; or through normal processes of metaphorical thought such as those evident in dreams and linguistic metaphors. (In a complementary paper for the Bible and Cultural Studies unit, I discuss the implications of trauma-associated canonical parallels for later generations of believers.)


The History of Pentateuch Redaction and the Development of Sacerdotal Institutions
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Reinhard Achenbach, Ludwig-Maximilians Universität

The research on the redaction history during the last years has shown that it underwent several stages. According to the hypothesis of E. Otto and R. Achenbach we can trace a Hexateuch-Redaction, a Pentateuch-Redaction and a late phase of priestly revisions especially in the book of Numbers. The traditional Pg/Ps model is not sufficient to explain the differences of institutional concepts in Leviticus and Numbers. The paper wants to show that we have to draw into consideration the development of sacerdotal institutions during and after the exile which are intrinsically connected with the redactional process of the formation of the Pentateuch.


Women and the Religion of Ancient Israel
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Susan Ackerman, Dartmouth College

This paper explores the ways in which the rather sparse and fragmented biblical data concerning women's experiences and roles within the ancient Israelite religious community can be enhanced through reference to extrabiblical data. These data include archaeological data from Israelite and other ancient Near Eastern and eastern Mediterranean contexts and literary materials (especially mythological materials) from elsewhere in the ancient Near East and eastern Mediterranean. Case studies from the books of Judges and Samuel will be briefly explored.


Moses' Death
Program Unit: Bible, Myth, and Myth Theory
Susan Ackerman, Dartmouth College

For many commentators, the punishment God inflicts on Moses and Aaron in Num 20:12 -- that these two will not be permitted to enter into the land of Israel -- hardly seems to fit the crime of striking (twice) rather than speaking to the rock at Meribah. It is further unclear why Aaron then dies shortly thereafter, while Moses lives on only to die looking over the Jordan and into the "promised land." This paper argues that these difficulties can be explained only if we cease to analyze the story in terms of the covenantal logic of sin and punishment and instead attend to some of the key narrative features that structure the Exodus story and also some of the key narrative features that can structure the stories of religious heroes across cultures. In particular, Victor Turner's rites-of-passage paradigm, which many scholars have suggested might well help understand the Exodus story, can help us identify the importance of blood offerings (including Moses' death?) at crucial points of transition within the Exodus story; of additional use are the insights of Andre Droogers, one of Turner's followers, regarding the presence of persisting liminal features within the life stories of religious heroes.


Ethical Motivations and the Alexandrinus Text of 4 Maccabees
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Marcus Adams, Ashland Theological Seminary

This paper examines textual variants in the text of 4 Maccabees as it is presented in codex Alexandrinus. The specific variant trends from Alexandrinus discussed in this paper relate to the diminished rewards the martyrs receive for their bravery, the more graphic manner in which the torturers and torture acts are described and how the martyrs’ direct speech about these torture acts is presented. Rather than providing an etiology for these variants which might attribute them to scribal intentionality, this study seeks to show that the reader of Alexandrinus would be more likely to give assent to the author’s thesis, i.e., that pious reason is the supreme master of the passions, because of the manner in which the martyrs and their tortures are depicted in the text of Alexandrinus. This paper is thus focused on how the text of Alexandrinus would affect its reader differently than today’s eclectic text and attempts to understand this effect in light of the reader’s view of the martyrs’ motivations for acting nobly.


Ben Sira's Apologetic Response
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Samuel L. Adams, Yale University

The book of Ben Sira addresses a diverse set of perspectives during the Hellenistic period. This sage counters Qoheleth and perhaps others like him, who denied a comprehensible justice for humanity. Yet Ben Sira also argues against using eschatological language to answer ultimate questions. While acknowledging inconsistency in the human experience, Ben Sira affirms the adequate justice of God without recourse to apocalyptic language and/or a belief in the afterlife. Among the groups he seems to be in conversation with are those responsible for what existed of the Enochic corpus. While Ben Sira was probably familiar with 1 Enoch, this paper will argue that his project is much broader than a specific attack on speculative Wisdom. He seeks to prove that virtuous behavior will be rewarded by God and that traditional assumptions about act and consequence are still tenable. Like Qoheleth, Ben Sira stakes his own position on the finality of death and the relationship between determinism and free will, which seem to be intractable problems for both sages and pressing topics during this period. Ben Sira’s primary response is to focus on a good name: this theme functions as a way of refuting both the skepticism of Qoheleth and the emergent reliance on apocalyptic/eschatological beliefs. For this sage, a good reputation lasts in a way that nothing else can, including the human spirit. His instruction represents a critical witness to a tradition being challenged by propositions about God, creation, and eternal possibilities for the human soul. This paper will seek to explicate the complexity of the changing climate for sapiential discourse as revealed in the book of Ben Sira and the lengths that this particular author will go to defend traditional assumptions.


Linguistic Analysis and Cohesion in 2 Peter: Using a Discourse Approach to Determine Its Structure and Divisions
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Sean A. Adams, McMaster Divinity College

There has been some disagreement among scholars regarding the division and organization of 2 Peter. Unlike some other biblical letters, 2 Peter does not have strong boundaries between its different sections, but transitions using blended semantic themes. This blending causes difficulties for the translator, who looks to segment the text into smaller units. However, with the adoption of modern linguistic tools within biblical scholarship, new avenues have been opened to evaluate the composition and structure of a text. Using the OpenText.org model and other linguistic features, as well as incorporating a comparison of traditional syntactic mapping, I will evaluate how participant reference, verbal aspect and particularly semantic domains can be used to provide insight into the structure of 2 Peter. In addition, I hope to show that using a discourse approach to evaluating the composition of a text provides a more rigorous and insightful approach than the traditional syntactic mapping.


Approaching Targum as a Kind of Translation: An Interface between Translation Theory and Narratology
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Simon Adnams, University of Manchester

Targum scholars typically make a strong distinction between translational and non-translational material in the texts they study. Although there are many who would question the strength of this translation – non-translation distinction, it continues to be used in much secondary literature. From the perspective of contemporary translation theory, however, it is possible to argue that all material found in the targums can fit into the category of translation, just not in the way translation has usually been understood by scholars. The result is that the targums can be seen as documents that perform a specific cultural function: to present the biblical narrative to a culture or cultures that hold values quite different from those embodied in the Bible itself. To identify and describe the cultural values the targums attempt to reinforce and address, narratological analysis can be quite helpful. By breaking down the targumic narratives into their constituent parts, narratological analysis identifies what roles particular narrative elements play in the overall construction of meaning in specific narrative contexts. With the targums this allows for a precise articulation of how the targums differ narratologically from the Hebrew Bible. Similarly it raises many questions concerning how the targums might have functioned in their various social and historical contexts. Concrete examples will be given concerning how this approach can be used with the targums.


Project on the Textual History of 1 Samuel: Reconstructing the Old Greek and Deconstructing the Textus Receptus
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Anneli Aejmelaeus, Universität Göttingen

The task of preparing the critical edition of the Septuagint translation of 1 Samuel for the Göttingen series is like a huge jigsaw puzzle – with most of the pieces missing. Not only do the various recensions of the Greek text complicate our search for the original Old Greek, but other factors – such as the variations of the Hebrew text and the translation technique, including errors by the translator – have certainly also played a role. Obviously, the decision often has to be made on the basis of internal criteria, as already stated by Sebastian Brock. This also means a rethinking of what has been considered as the textus receptus until now. As far as the Hebrew text is concerned, deconstruction has been going on since the Qumran findings. But what about Codex Vaticanus being regarded as more or less the Old Greek? The picture of Vaticanus standing like a rock in the midst of the stream no longer seems to be tenable. In this paper I give some examples to demonstrate the kinds of problems encountered in the project on the textual history of 1 Samuel.


Matthew 7:21
Program Unit: New Testament Mysticism Project
Cameron Afzal, Sarah Lawrence College

*


The Portrayal of Aseneth's Religious Experience in “Joseph and Aseneth”
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Patricia Ahearne-Kroll, North Carolina State University

This paper concretizes the strategies which Amy Hollywood proposes in her paper, "Strategies for the Study of Women's Religious Experience," by analyzing the relationship between the bestowal of divine secrets and gender in the pseudepigraphon, "Joseph and Aseneth." This study complements other papers in the session, Women's Religious Experience in Antiquity, including Sarah Iles Johnston's "Women's Religious Experience in the Greek World," and John R. Levison's "Eve's Religious Experience in the Greek Life of Adam and Eve."


The Particle na’
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
John Ahn, Yale University

The particle na’ in BH has traditionally been rendered “please,” “pray,” (Lambdin) or left untranslated (Seow). This enclitic particle is often used after ??? and other exclamations or adverbs to denote a logical sequence, but almost never after a suffixed form (GKC). Even a recent edition of Biblical Hebrew by Pratico and Van Pelt suggest that the particle may or may not be connected to the imperative. In Akkadian, Caplice (and Huehnergard—non verbal forms) sees ma as a particle of emphasis ina mušimma “on that same night” or anakuma “I myself.” In this paper, I will suggest that the na’ particle in BH is honorifics, especially in the spoken context of narratives (thus its affix form with the cohorative in BH). The problem we have in the English translation is that we have no way of getting at its true meaning and significance since English does not inhabit honorifics. GKC was almost there when he pointed out the polite sense of the usage, but honorifics is more and beyond polite usage. In the truest sense, spoken honorifics (that which remains in select biblical pericopes, e.g. Gen 12.13; 18.21; 24.2, etc.) clearly demarcates hegemony—structured order, status, political relationship, and humble or servant disposition of the speaker before a respected or honored individual(s). I will provide narrative examples from the Book of Genesis to illustrate this. In the English translation then, we should leave the particle untranslated as Seow suggests. However, we must note and understand that honorifics is being uttered and preserved in the text. On the other hand, if BH is being translated into languages that continue to employ honorifics (Turkish, Korean, Japanese, etc.), it may be worthwhile to include such renderings in oral readings or even translations.


Isaiah 42:6b: "Light to Nations" not "Light to the Nations"
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
John Ahn, Yale University

In Second Isaiah, there is a major difference between “the nations” ????? Isa 40:17; 42:1; 43:9; 45:20; 52:10) or more specifically ????? “to the nations” (cf. Isa 42:1) and ???? “nations” (40:15; 42:6; 49:6, 22; 54:3). The former refers to the various nations of the known period while the latter lexeme without the definite article exclusively refers to Judah (42:6b and 49:6) or Judah and Israel. The purpose clause, “[So] that my salvation may reach the ends of the earth” (Isa 49:6), has been rendered and misunderstood as a message of universal salvation from the phrase “light to the nations” (NRSV). However, in light of the context of verse 6 of chapter 49, this message cannot reflect universal salvation—“For He [Yahweh] has said ‘It is too little that you should be my servant, in that I raise up the tribes of Jacob and restore the survivors of Israel: I will also make you a light of nations, that my salvation may reach the ends of the earth.” The purpose clause reflects the tribes of Israel and Judah who are now understood as nations of peoples—without the definite article as seen in the MT. The detriment is the careless insertion of the definite article (cf. the NRSV, RSV, NIV, ASV). The essential marker or the lack of the definite article is central in correctly transmitting the message of Isaiah 42:6-7. This definite article differentiates a universal reading from the more narrow and closed notion of nations, in an Abramaic sense, i.e., nations or peoples descending from Abraham (as the BDB suggests). K. Sparks, J. Oswalt, J. Blenkinsopp, C. Baltzer, among others, with poetic license, have freely inserted the definite article in their translations generating an ‘overly inclusive mission oriented’ universal message of salvation.


Jesus as Phantasm
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
George Aichele, Adrian College

In Mark 6:49, when the disciples see Jesus walk on the water, they think he is a ghost (phantasma) and they cry out in great fear. Their fear and astonishment, coupled with Jesus’s use of the significant phrase ego eimi, mark Mark’s passage as one of supernatural horror and the fantastic, an element that tends to be expunged from the other synoptic gospels and yet another textual site where the reader is excluded from the “secret” that is Mark. Mark is self-referential, announcing that its Jesus is a phantasm or simulacrum. This analysis draws on the work of Tzvetan Todorov and Gilles Deleuze, among others.


The Epistle to the Hebrews and the Re-collection of Memory in Flavian Rome
Program Unit: Mapping Memory: Tradition, Texts, and Identity
Ellen B. Aitken, McGill University

The Epistle to the Hebrews engages in a complex process of the mapping of memory for its inscribed audience. This paper investigates how this first-century text from the city of Rome configures a collective memory through the use of the scripturally informed remembrance of divine speech, the deployment of traditions about Jesus’ death, and an invocation of a people’s “past.” The text, moreover, cultivates certain poetics of remembrance—pathways for recalling the past, along with habits of forgetting—that equip the audience for negotiating an identity and ethos within Flavian Rome. This paper sets Hebrews’s acts of memory in relation to the Flavian monumentalization of a collective memory of triumph and restoration that reshaped the cityscape of Rome. The poetics of remembrance in Hebrews can therefore be understood as fostering a means for moving through that city as the bearers of a different memory.


Civic Administrative Vocabulary in the Septuagint
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
James K. Aitken, University of Cambridge

This paper will consider various terms describing civic organisation in Greek and their attestation in non-Jewish sources. A number of instances of terms in the LXX translations can now be clarified by their appearances in inscriptions and papyri, material that can throw much light on the understanding of the terms in the LXX. This can also in turn contribute to the social context of the translators themselves.


See God. See God Run. Teaching Seminarians to Read Scripture so That They Have Good News to Show in the Pulpit
Program Unit: Homiletics and Biblical Studies
O. Wesley Allen, Lexington Theological Seminary

*


The Rhetorical Function of Expressing a Desire for Peace during the Pursuit of War: Three Examples from the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Warfare in Ancient Israel
Frank Ritchel Ames, Colorado Christian University

The juxtaposition of references to war and to peace in narrative, legal, and poetic texts within the Hebrew Bible is common, for in the rhetoric of war, longing for peace often attends call to arms. This paper considers the rhetorical effect of expressing a desire for peace in war-related contexts and explores the use of the rhetorical strategy in the speech of the wise woman at Joab’s siege of Abel of Beth-maacah (2 Sam 20:14-22); the law governing Israelite sieges against distant cities (Deut 20:10-15); and a pilgrimage song that seeks the defeat of an unnamed, treacherous enemy (Psalm 120).


Who Prefers to Research Biblical Narrative in Israel?
Program Unit:
Yairah Amit, Tel Aviv University

This paper deals with the description of the research of biblical narrative in Israel from the early sixties of the 20th century to the present. I will try to explain the different motivations of scholars who prefer this research direction and to describe the different approaches and trends. The main representatives, their main works and their contribution to the general research of this subject will be described as well.


"Time, Time, Time. See What's Become of It": Factors on the Temporal Relation of Aorist Participles and Verbs in the New Testament
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Charles A. Anderson, University of Cambridge

This paper broadly aims to look for deictic markers in the New Testament that can help us understand the relationship of participles to a finite verb. More narrowly, it looks at the aorist participle dependent on a finite aorist verb, in two authors, Mark and Paul. The goal is to find, by means of an inductive examination of all instances of this construction, what markers these authors provide for determining whether aorist participles indicate time antecedent, simultaneous, or subsequent to the aorist main verb. The most significant deictic markers are genre, word order, and lexis. The difference between narrative and epistolary literature seems especially important, even though it has been noticed only infrequently. The difference between Mark and Paul with regards to whether the participle conveys antecedent or simultaneous action, regardless of word order, is 50%. This significant difference seems best explained by considerations of genre. A second deictic factor is word order, whether the participle precedes or follows the finite verb. Word order makes a significant difference in Mark but barely so for Paul: when the sequence of participle and verb are reversed, the Marcan figures change by more than 40%, whereas in Paul they fluctuate by around 15%. The value of this finding is lessened for Mark, though, by the small sample size of participles that follow a finite verb. A final factor for the temporal relationship between an aorist participle and aorist finite verb is lexis. Verbs of physical motion, sensory perception, and conceptually-related pairs all show particular tendencies toward either antecedent or simultaneous action. This paper represents only a portion of the research possible on this question in the New Testament, but it makes an initial contribution to delineating the syntactical relationship of time between participles and finite verbs.


Justice, Punishment, and Retribution in Eusebius and Lactantius
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Stamenka E. Antonova, Columbia University in the City of New York

Imagery of violence and the justification of human destruction permeate the historical accounts of the fourth century Christian apologists Eusebius (Ecclesiastical History) and Lactantius (De Mortibus Persecutorum; On Divine Anger). In providing detailed narratives of and rational for the infliction of cruel punishment of the opponents of Christians, both Eusebius and Lactantius refer to the conception of divine justice and retribution realized through the vehicle of human agency. While Eusebius focuses his historical account of the manifestation of divine justice (dike, krisis), anger (aganaktesis) and revenge (timoria; kolasis) through the judgment of the Jewish nation in particular, Lactantius chooses to focus on the ‘pagan’ opponents and persecutors instead. In my analysis of their portrayal of the infliction of cruelty and human annihilation, I contrast these accounts to similar imagery found in Christian and Jewish apocalyptic literature and emphasize the decidedly different symbolic meanings of generating and reinscribing images of violence in historical terms.


Towards a Comprehensive History of the Kingdom of Geshur
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Rami Arav, University of Nebraska, Omaha

The first scholarly attempts to portray the history of the elusive kingdom of Geshur, situated northeast to the kingdom of Israel, were made some 70 years ago, by W.F. Albright and by B. Mazar The information derived from the Bible and from one single El Amarna letter, were the only sources available for the researchers. Therefore, the approach employed, in this period, was naturally confined to the political history approach. There was no archaeology to provide further data to be considered. Since then a great amount of information was added through wide array of interdisciplinary studies including archaeology, geoarchaeology, zooarchaeology, archaeometry, and epigraphic research, including inscriptions and a thorough analysis of the Assyrian documents. This intensive scrutiny suggests a new environmental reconstruction of the Geshurite kingdom. Light was shaded on commerce and trade, society and religion and of course on the historical development of this region. The main significance of this kingdom lays in the state of preservation of its capital city Bethsaida. None of the capital cities of the kingdoms situated in the southern Levant was preserved to such as a state as Bethsaida, making it a role model for a 10 century BCE capital city. The Power Point presentation will focus on a brief synthesis of all these researches and portray the main traits of this forgotten kingdom in order to restore its significance and attempt to place it in the foreground of biblical scholarship.


Leopards and Vipers and Demons, Oh My! Fantastic Landscape and the Narrative Setting of Acts of Philip
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Gail E. Armstrong, Brown University

In Acts of Philip, the majority of the action takes place either in or around the city called Opheorymos/Hierapolis. The journey undertaken by Mariamne, Philip, and Bartholomew to this city winds through a fantastical and mythical landscape. This paper argues that landscape plays an important role in narrative and is as ‘scripted’ as the characters of narrative. Narrative landscape is a human construction and thus there is always an implicit meaning to place. What did/does the landscape of Acts of Philip evoke for the ancient/modern audience? While certain scholars posit a direct relation between narrative location and geographic location of textual communities, I am not convinced that this is so. Frédéric Amsler argues that the location of the action in Hierapolis points to a religious conflict in Phrygia between members of the “Acts of Philip” community and the cult of Cybele. While this may be a possibility, this paper seeks to understand the function of landscape within narrative, arguing that in the case of Acts of Philip, the fantastic and mythical landscape in which beasts talk and demons construct churches in the wilderness actually functions as a source of authority. I stand with Duncan and Ley who argue that landscape functions as a site on which ideology and power are negotiated. I argue, therefore, that the landscape in Acts of Philip is a site upon which intra-Christian ideology is played out. By placing the action within a symbolic landscape the author dislocates the events from a fixed time and place, and therefore from a fixed meaning. The narrative exists, therefore, beyond time and place. By using landscape to separate the narrative from ‘real’ time, and place it in the ‘mythical’ past, the author(s) is thus able to lay claim to an apostolic authority, which it could not otherwise do.


The Case for the Custom of Hospitality in Ancient Narratives
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Andrew Arterbury, Baylor University

Despite the fact that the custom of hospitality was practiced less commonly and less meritoriously than ancient authors would have liked (e.g., Odyssey 7.32-33), it appears that a variety of authors attempted to shape their societies by encouraging and exhorting their readers to extend generous hospitality on a routine basis. As a result, I will look at passages from the Odyssey, the Greek novels, Dio Chrysostom’s Seventh Oration, and Ovid’s Metamorphoses. At some level, each of these authors attempts to persuade his or her readers to embrace this custom more fully by narrating compelling accounts of hospitality. Yet, despite their common objective, these authors often rely upon a broad range of rationales when explaining why their readers ought to more readily and more meritoriously extend hospitality to travelers. Some of these diverse rationales include: demonstrating that hospitality promotes civility, depicting hospitality as being closely linked to the will of the gods, and demonstrating that the host often accrues personal honor and benefits through the act of hosting a guest.


Re-describing Greco-Roman Associations: Is a New Taxonomy Possible?
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Richard S. Ascough, Queen's Theological College

This paper will compare and contrast how various Greco-Roman associations were described in antiquity and how they have been described by modern scholars. Drawing upon the work of Bruce Lincoln and Jonathan Z. Smith, the paper will explore “cohesion” as a category for description both in antiquity and today. It will focus in particular on the use of myth, ritual, and function as a means of classifying associations. Neither the ancient writers nor the modern scholars seem able to fully escape their own social locations when attempting to describe these groups. This leads to asking whether it is possible, or even desirable, to attempt a taxonomy of Greco-Roman associations for use in the (re-)description of Greco-Roman antiquity.


An Unworthy Foe: Heroic Ethoi, Trickery, and Slander in Ephesians 6:11
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Jeffrey R. Asher, Georgetown College

This paper will argue that the term methodeias in Eph 6:11 reflects a heroic ethos that often carried negative connotations in antiquity, especially when it was juxtaposed to its antithesis, strength. Throughout the Greek and Roman eras, two principle heroic ethoi, strength and trickery, were often represented as conflicting values. Achilles (bie) and Odysseus (metis) became archetypes of these ethoi. In particular, Achilles became the champion of hoplite warfare and its associated attributes of strength, openness, and courage. In contrast, warfare by trickery or theft was often deprecated in the literary sources. When it is read in the larger context of Eph 6:10-18, the language of 6:11 strongly suggests this antithesis. When the author of Ephesians attributes an undesirable ethos to the devil in this paraenetic passage, he slanders him in a manner not unlike the verbal neikos of the Homeric heroes.


Ear Responsible Hermeneutics: The Role and Function of the Ear
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Hector Avalos, Iowa State University

This paper will examine medical texts from Mesopotamia, Anatolia, and Syria-Palestine in order to illuminate how biblical ideas about the ear and hearing compare and contrast to those of Israel's neighbors. In particular, the paper will explore possible reasons why, in some texts, the human being is divided into nine or twelve parts, with the ear usually recognized as one of those parts. Other texts relate the ear to various features of the physical cosmos, which is seen as a body in itself. In the Song of Ulikummi, preserved in Hittite literature, one finds the idea that deafness and lack of compassion are related. The paper will also explore the relationship between orality and textuality in the development of concepts about the value of hearing.


The Kingdom of Priests and the Priests of the Kingdom
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Richard E. Averbeck, Trinity Evangelical Divinity School

Recent scholarship has recognized the connection between the promise of Israel becoming a “kingdom of priests” in Exodus 19:6 and the covenant ratification ritual in Exodus 24:6-8, where the blood is splashed first on the altar and then on the people, as a kind of general ordination rite for the “kingdom of priests.” This is comparable to the ordination of the Aaronic priests in Leviticus 8:22-24, where the blood is first smeared on the horns of the altar and then on the right earlobe, thumb, and big toe of the priests (cf. Exodus 29:19-21). This line of argument can be extended further by comparing the blood manipulation of the guilt offering ritual for the cleansing of the skin diseased person in Leviticus 14:12-18, where the blood is applied to the common person’s right earlobe, thumb, and big toe in the same way. The guilt offering was required here because the skin diseased common person, who belonged to the “kingdom of priests,” had become desecrated away from the “holy nation” (cf. Exodus 19:6), having to live outside the camp (see Leviticus 13:46). The purpose of the guilt offering was to make atonement for desecration of sancta. Therefore, reincorporating the skin diseased person back into the community required a guilt offering, and the application of the blood to the body of the person reflected her or his reconsecrated status as a member of the “kingdom of priests.”


The Phoenicians as Foodstuff Providers in the Southern Levant
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Carolina A. Aznar, Saint Louis University, Madrid Campus

Ezekiel 27:12-22 describes the exchanges carried out by the city of Tyre ca. the beginning of the 6th century BCE. These exchanges included, among other commodities, olive oil from Judah and the land of Israel (v. 17) as well as Izalla wine from Damascus (v. 18), foodstuffs that would normally be transported in storage jars. In the past, little attention was paid to the trade of these commodities. In 1999, however, the finding of two deep-sea shipwrecks loaded with a total of ca. eight hundred almost identical Phoenician storage jars (Ballard and Stager et al. 2002) showed that Phoenician wine trade was probably significant from at least the 8th century BCE. A recent typological, contextual, and petrographical study of Iron Age II storage jars from the Southern Levant carried out by Aznar supports this conclusion and provides new light on the exchanges. Aznar’s study suggests that the Phoenicians may have been involved with the Philistines in foodstuff transportation in the early 10th century BCE (dates according to conventional chronology); that the Phoenicians started trading wine, as an elite product, as early as the 10th century BCE; that the Phoenicians used several storage jar production centers, perhaps involving other cities besides Tyre, from at least the 8th century BCE; and that the Phoenicians developed a highly specialized storage jar production, probably for a distinct type of foodstuff, perhaps olive oil, during the 7th-6th century BCE.


Digging for Shechem, Finding Nablus
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Alice Bach, Case Western Reserve University

Genesis 34 has presented the character of Dinah as a linchpin of personal and ethnic violence, particularly as read by feminists. This paper will explore the ethnic connection between biblical males: Shechem and the brothers of Dinah, and the modern connection between Nablus and the shards of Shechem.


Biblical Studies and Discipline Envy (Session 4)
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Alice Bach, Case Western Reserve University

The Mrs. Robinson phase of feminist readings of the Bible is winding down, like Mrs. Robinson herself. No longer the provocative and seductive element of biblical studies, many feminists, particularly those in the third-wave, are now questioning the depth of oppression that American and European women in universities are actually experiencing. While women of color still constitute a subordinate class, it is more from the barriers of race and ethnicity than gender. Back in the day, Mrs. Robinson feminism questioned the basic constitutive elements of female subjectivity and feminist scholars read and reread biblical texts, until we depleted most of these areas of investigation. Now we suffer less from penisneid than from discipline envy, to use Marjorie Garber’s term. This paper will examine the methods and strategies scholars in biblical studies deploy as we move from the hierarchy and prestige of linguistics, diachronic readings, and historical foundations to more alluring desires. Is it only linguistic study that is fading? How hot are the flames of feminist and cultural analyses when applied to biblical studies? I suspect that cultural studies in all its guises from film to podcast, from colonialism to cartooning will create a new synergy in which biblical studies as a scholarly discipline will be subsumed under the weight of contemporary cultures and multiple viewpoints. One might imagine Mrs. Robinson bored with seduction, no longer envying men their occupations and fast cars, but rather writing her own script, winking at the audience.


The Tower of Babel: A Critique of the Methodology of Literary Analysis
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Joel S. Baden, Harvard University

In his commentary on Genesis, Hermann Gunkel proposed that the Tower of Babel narrative was a combination of two originally separate strands, one about a city, and one about a tower. This idea was rejected almost immediately, with the most forceful rebuttals coming from a literary perspective (notably from Cassuto, Fokkelman, and Kikawada), focusing particularly on the wordplay, leitmotiven, and chiastic structure of the narrative. A careful study, however, reveals that in fact these literary analyses do not actually refute Gunkel's position, and may in fact unintentionally lend support to it. This result demonstrates the need to reassess the value of literary-critical approaches that emphasize textual unity as an effective opposition to the historical-critical approach.


Teaching Biblical Narratives Involving Sexual Violation
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Mary Bader, College of Wooster

This paper will explore essentials for teaching biblical stories involving sexual violation. My experience has shown that such texts frequently elicit or provoke memories from students. This can present an opportunity for some to deal with these issues in profoundly personal ways; it is a chance for all to address something that has plagued society for generations. It is indeed a powerful teaching and learning moment for all involved. I offer a number of suggestions for how faculty can be prepare themselves and the class to address this issue most effectively, appropriately, and sensitively. This paper is a chapter from my book, forthcoming this year from Peter Lang Publishing Company.


Dinah in the Midrash
Program Unit: Midrash
Mary Bader, College of Wooster

This paper will explore references to the HB character Dinah found in early Midrashic writings. Using Genesis 34 as a point of comparison for how later writers developed the character Dinah, we will discover details about her birth, marriages, reactions to and explanations of what happened to her at Shechem. This paper is currently a developing chapter in a manuscript of a proposal for my second book with Peter Lang Publishing Company.


Visual Representations in Pompeian Triclinia: What Do They Tell Us (if Anything) about Practices and Values at Greco-Roman Meals?
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
David L. Balch, Brite Divinity School, Texas Christian University

This paper attempts to raise issues and to propose hypotheses about the social function of art (especially wall frescoes and floor mosaics, perhaps sculpture) in the dining spaces (triclinia) of Pompeii, including some comparison and contrast with the literary tradition of symposia/convivia.


Jonah in Roman and Early Christian Art
Program Unit:
David Balch, Brite Divinity School, Texas Christian University

*


“The Touchstone Text:” Prolegomena to a History of Biblical Studies in the Liberal Arts
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Matthew C. Baldwin, Mars Hill College

Biblical studies classes prevail among course offerings in Religion and Theology, so much so that the Bible has been aptly termed "the touchstone text for the study of religion in the United States" (Rosengarten, 2004). And yet, an impending separation of the annual meetings of the AAR and SBL looms darkly overhead. For some, the separation raises questions about the "fit" of Biblical Studies in Religion departments. For others, it indicates confusion about the nature of our discipline. Clearly, Biblical Studies does belong in colleges; but how do we conceptualize and theoretically justify its "place" within the liberal arts? This paper was inspired by J.Z. Smith's seminal 1999 SBL plenary talk, "Bible and Religion" (Smith 2004). To frame an historical approach to these conceptual questions, two salient moments are examined: the present, when U.S. teachers of Bible courses are often associated with the SBL, and 1933, when the dominant organization was called the National Association of Biblical Instructors (the ancestor of the AAR; Smith 2004). As evidence for the "present," the paper examines the 2000 AAR surveys, recent work on college student engagement, instructor syllabi, and mainstream introductory Biblical Studies textbooks. For 1933, the main evidence is the first issue of the Journal of NABI, which was dedicated to pedagogical and definitional questions relating the Liberal Arts and Biblical Studies. The differences between "then" and "now" are striking: over the past six decades, our discipline has been profoundly transformed. The comparison highlights several tensions inherent in our work with college students, providing insight into the ongoing challenges which face Biblical Scholars working in the context of liberal arts colleges, and a key to conceptualizing and improving our own historically situated practices.


An Explanation of the Etiology of the Name Ammon in Genesis 19, Based on Evidence from Nabataean Aramaic and the Safaitic Arabian Dialect
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Elitzur Bar-Asher, Harvard University

In Genesis 19:36-38 we encounter the story of Lot and his two daughters as an etiology for the names of the two regional nations: Ammon and Moab. According to this story, these names originated with the names of the two boys who were products of an incestuous relationship between Lot and his two daughters. The narrator tells us that their mothers named them Moab and Ben-?ammi. However, explanations for their naming are missing in the Biblical story. While the name Moab could have been regarded as a folk etymology which means ‘from a father,’ signifying that the mother wanted to say that she had conceived with her own father, in the case of Ben-Ammi such a simple explanation is not apparent. The meaning of the word ?am in Hebrew and its cognate in the Semitic languages has occupied many scholars in the past one and a half centuries. Among possible meanings one can find that this word denotes in Nabataean and Safaitic also “grandfather” or some sort of ancestor. Surprisingly, no one has mentioned this meaning of the word ?am in the context of the Genesis story. Accordingly, it can be suggested that the name Ben-?ammi indicates the fact that the boy born was the grandson of his own father. In light of this suggestion, it becomes clear that the two sisters named their sons in such a way because they were products of incest: one emphasized the fact that the father of the child was her father, and the other that Lot was the grandfather of his newborn son. Thus, the possessive suffix was taken as if the boy himself tells his origin. It will be suggested that, based on linguistic evidence, the consequences of this interpretation can also point to a foreign origin of this myth.


Hoffman's Midrash Tannaim on Deutronomy: How Close Is It to the Original Tannaitic Midrash from the School of Rabbi Ishmael?
Program Unit: History and Literature of Early Rabbinic Judaism
Michal Bar-Asher Siegal, Yale University

D.Z. Hoffman was one the first scholars to recognize the 13th century Yemenite Midrash, Midrash Ha-Gadol, as a major source for the lost Midarshei Halacha. As part of his monumental life work he created Midrash Tannaim out of Tannaitic-looking paragraphs from Midrash Ha-Gadol on the book of Deutronomy. He distinguished, by using different size of fonts, between paragraphs that have parallels in the Sifre, the known Midrash Halacha on the book of Deuteronomy from the school of R. Akiva, and unparallel paragraphs. A small amount of fragments, found in the Cairo Genizah, helped assure that Midrash Ha-Gadol, indeed, used the Tannaitic R. Ishmael's Mechilta on the book of Deuteronomy, in his Midrash. Some scholars, including Hoffman himself, have warned against relying on Midrash Tannaim as a sure source for the Mechilta. Based on a thorough examination of one portion of Hoffman's Midrash Tanaim, this paper will try to suggest a few systematic tools to verify which paragraphs are indeed parts of the original Midrash from the school of R. Ishmael. For this purpose, on the one hand we have to trace a few known and lesser known terminologies and Midrashic techniques of the school of R. Ishmael, and verify their use in those paragraphs. And, on the other hand, we must explore some of the editorial methods and reworked materials of R. David Ha-Adani, the editor of Midrash Ha-Gadol, in composing his treatise. Based on this suggested methodology, it will be shown that at least in one Parasha, many paragraphs are not parts of the original Midrash, but rather later reworked material, mostly rephrasing of Maimonides' Mishne Torah. However, at the end of the day, we are left with close to three quarters of an unparallel Tannaitic Midrash, bearing distinct features of the school of R. Ishmael.


Josephus in Postcolonial Perspective
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
John M.G. Barclay, Durham University

What are the benefits and dangers in reading Josephus from the perspective of postcolonial theory? This presentation will outline some of the contributions postcolonial theory can make to understanding the place of Josephus and other Romanized Jews in the Roman empire, and the power dynamics inherent in writing under Rome on behalf of the Judean people. Can this give greater depth and subtlety to our readings of Josephus?


Israeli Archaeological Research of the Biblical Period Land
Program Unit:
Gabriel Barkay, Bar Ilan University

The paper will deal with the contribution of Israeli research to the study of the archaeology of the Land of Israel in the Biblical Period. We will discuss the influence of the political atmosphere on archaeological research in the early days of the State of Israel, in the 1970’s and in the present. We will analyze the influence of European and American research on the work of Israeli scholars, the unique nature of the Israeli research and its influence on scholars from abroad and their studies. We will also analyze the connections between biblical research and archaeology, during this period, from the early stages and up to the present.


Oxyrhynchus Papyri XV 1780
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Don Barker, Macquarie University, Sydney

Scholars such as Roberts et.al. have categorized the hands of early Christian writings as being 'reformed documentary' Haines-Eitzen has recently stated that Christian texts appear to be located in the middle range of hands, between professional and nonprofessional. However P.Oxy. XV 1780 ( a fragment of the Gospel of John) is highly calligraphic. Is this hand an abberation from the norm? and what does it suggest about our study of scribes who produced copies of Christian texts in the early Church? This paper will explore those questions and propose some tentative answers.


Earth Opens Her Mouth: The Ruin and Renewal of Earth in John's Apocalypse
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
David L. Barr, Wright State University Main Campus

Earth is a complex character in John's story, portrayed as a place, a people, and even as a self-conscious agent. After sorting out some of these narrative strands and seeing how the character Earth functions in relation to the great ecological disasters portrayed in this story, we will consider how modern interpreters use the Apocalypse to justify various attitudes toward the environment.


Tertullian and the Acts of Thecla or Paul? Readership of the Ancient Christian Novel and the Invocation of Thecline and Pauline Authority
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Jeremy W. Barrier, Texas Christian University

Numerous studies over the last several decades have highlighted the impact and importance that the Early Christian Novels had upon the development of early Christianity, but up to this point, there are still too few in-depth studies being performed on specific texts. In regard to the readership of this literary genre, who would have read early Christian novels? In an attempt to answer this question by asking specifically who would have read the Acts of Paul and Thecla, one is immediately drawn into a discussion over the meaning of Tertullian's statements concerning the appropriateness of the "Acts of Paul." In particular, Tertullian appears to be concerned with the issue of authority and the appropriate invocation of authority. On the one hand, there is an invocation to Thecla as an authority for the community, but on the other hand, there is also a plea for the invoking of the name of Thecla as an authority for the community. Within this essay, I will attempt to answer some of the questions concerning the social context of these early Christians who were in communication with Tertullian, as well as attempt to shed further light upon the community that would have been reading Paul and the Acts of Paul and Thecla.


Stigmata as a Language of Torture in Galatians 6:17: Paul's Body within a Postcolonial Optic
Program Unit: Bible and Cultural Studies
Jeremy W. Barrier, Texas Christian University

In Galatians 6.11-18, Paul records the conclusion to his letter as he makes his closing argument to the Galatian church. During his final arguments for Christians to become a new creation and to be willing to suffer for Christ, Paul refers to his stigmata in Galatians 6.17. The NRSV states, “From now on, let no one make trouble for me; for I carry the marks (stigmata) of Jesus branded on my body.” Paul is attempting to use his “marks” for the purpose of rhetorical leverage against those who oppose him. In mentioning his stigmata, Paul is hoping to arouse the passions of the Galatians as a weighty and final appeal. How one interprets these “marks” has the potential of changing how one understands Paul’s identity. In particular, I would like to investigate further connections between Slave Torture within the Greco-Roman Empire and Paul's concept of slavery in Christ. I am especially interested in an examination of Paul's stigmata through the lens of Postcolonialism as an optic for interpretation that illuminates the difficulties of Paul's own understanding of torture from/for Christ. As a rhetorical tool, Paul links his torture through stigmata as directly related to his own authenticity and as the touchstone for truth in speaking to the Galatians. If this is the case, then how does this resonate within the postcolonial reality of empire, neocolonialism, and torture as a contemporary method for the acquisition of truth?


The Representation of Speech in the Casuistic Laws of the Pentateuch: The Phenomenon of "Combined Discourse"
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Assnat Bartor, Tel aviv University

A narrative reading of the casuistic laws of the Pentateuch combines Biblical Law, modern legal theory and methods of narrative analysis. It is an interdisciplinary study which pursues questions that are identified as legal, by adopting and using notions and devices from other disciplines - literature and narratology. Viewing the casuistic laws as "miniature narratives," as a medium through which stories about people are narrated, the narrative reading of laws applies contemporary methods and approaches of "law and literature" theory. In order to trace and examine the narrative elements which are found within the casuistic laws, i.e., to focus on the phenomena and events that are described in the laws and on their mode of description, rather than on a legal theoretical analysis of abstract principles, the narrative reading carries out a systematic analysis of the casuistic laws according to three aspects of literary narrative texts - the "story," the "text" and the "discourse." Elements such as plot, character and characterization, discourse, point of view and focalization, the reading process, and the lawgiver's implication in the discourse are the focus of this reading. There are different ways of representing spoken discourse in the casuistic laws: direct or indirect speech, "combined speech/discourse" and inward speech. In the proposed paper I would like to present and demonstrate the phenomenon of "combined discourse" found within several casuistic laws, and to examine the effect this specific representation of utterance might have on the reader.


Imitatio Dei: A Note on the History of Exegesis based on Luke, Matthew, and the Rabbis
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Herbert Basser, Queens University

Burton L. Mack in The Lost Gospel : The Book Of Q & Christian Origins (San Francisco: Harper, 1993: 73ff) builds on his position that the gospels are based primarily upon Greco-Roman rhetorical models. In reconstructing Q behind Lk6 and Mt5 he omits intimations of specialized interpretations of key OT biblical verses. What we will note, in fact, is that the same subtle biblical allusions and exegesis discerned in Jewish sources occur in the two gospels. I begin by citing gospel passages that will form the essence of my argument that the gospels preserve and rework exegetical traditions that the rabbis preserve and rework in much the same ways. The biblical exegesis in these passages overlaps with rabbinic positions more than they overlap with each other. A brief example of several in the same unit: Mt 5:48 instructs: Therefore be perfect as your Father who is in heaven is perfect. Midrash Tehillim, Ps 119:1: And likewise Moses said to Israel: Be perfect with the Lord your God (Dt 18:13), [meaning] .... If you are perfect then you are with the Lord your God. --Why is this?-- Because he is also perfect.. It remains to show that Matthew is also reading Dt 18:13 in a specialized manner. Mack's reconstruction has omitted the center of these sermons which is Jewish biblical exegesis.


Jesus and the Bethany Family
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Richard Bauckham, University of St. Andrews, Scotland

Those sceptical of historical accuracy in John have usually thought that John knew nothing about the family of Mary, Martha and Lazarus except what he learned from Luke about the two sisters. He is supposed then to have identified Mary with the anonymous woman in Mark 12, and perhaps to have taken the name Lazarus from the parable in Luke 16. All else is free creation by the evangelist. This paper will argue that there is no good reason to doubt that this group of siblings living in Bethany really were disciples of Jesus to whom he was very close. Gerd Theissen's notion of 'protective anonymity' in Mark's passion narrative will be extended to explain why the woman who anointed Jesus is so remarkably anonymous in Mark and why the raising of Lazarus is so surprisingly (supposing it to be historical) absent from Mark (and thence from Luke and Matthew). The Bethany family fit into a plausible pattern of sources from which the Johannine traditions derive.


Postcolonial Aliens and Strangers in 1 Peter
Program Unit: Methodological Reassessments of the Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Betsy J. Bauman-Martin, Saint Norbert College

The primary claim of biblical postcolonial criticism is that the Bible is a colonial document. This can indicate the ways the Bible has functioned as colonial literature in later historical contexts, but also the attitudes toward empire and imperialism in the texts themselves. Building on the theoretical foundations of Edward Said and R. S. Sugirtharajah, and the postcolonial analysis of Revelation by Chris Frilingos, this paper will examine the ways in which the borrowing of the language of chosenness from Judaism operates as ideological imperialism in the First Epistle of Peter, and will explore how a post-colonial critique can offer new insights into supersessionism. While the more typical analyses of the Petrine author’s use of Jewish themes claim it as a means of assimilation (Balch) or separation (Elliott) vis-à-vis Greco-Roman expectations, my argument is that the author’s appropriation of identity markers, not of the colonizer, Rome, but of another oppressed group, the Jews, to place his group above that other oppressed group, is an ideologically imperialist linguistic move. This language, ostensibly of the victim, presupposes however the acceptability of a hierarchy of religious and ethnic groups, participates in the plundering of the ideological resources of another, possibly weaker group solely for the purpose of the creation and maintenance of a superior identity, and constructs a metanarrative of replacement and ascendancy.


Elias Bickerman as a Historian of the Jews
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Albert Baumgarten, Bar Ilan University

*


From Ruler to Teacher: The Extending of the Shepherd Metaphor in Early Jewish and Christian Writings
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Wayne Baxter, McMaster University

The shepherd metaphor was commonly used in the Ancient Near East to symbolize the relationship between a king and his subjects. While this meaning of “ruler” associated with shepherd metaphor is clearly reflected in the Hebrew Bible, the metaphor becomes extended in early Christian writings to include the meaning of “teacher.” This paper seeks to determine the precedents for this move from “ruler” to “teacher,” suggesting that there are two: a general thematic precedent of the depiction in the Hebrew Bible of YHWH as Israel’s ultimate shepherd and a textual precedent of the shepherd narrative in Zechariah 11:4-17.


Enoch, the Angels, and Heavenly Books
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Leslie Baynes, Missouri State University

The character of Enoch, the “scribe of righteousness,” is throughout Enochic literature associated with books and writing. In Second Temple Judaism writing is one of the occupations of the wise. At the same time, the production of heavenly books is an activity characteristic of apocalypses, where books are usually in the charge of angels. Indeed, Enoch himself, as he is interpreted and reinterpreted over time, is transformed into an angelic figure who is an omniscient writer. This paper explores the interactions of the character of Enoch with angels and heavenly books.


Waiting for the Kingdom: A Papyrological Analysis of the Lord's Prayer
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Giovanni Battista Bazzana, University of Milan

The theme of the paper is a comparison between the Q text of the Lord’s Prayer and the material available in Duke Database of Documentary Papyri: this analysis is going to be part of a wider project focused on a complete examination of Q to be published in the series Papyrologischer Kommentar zum Neuen Testament. Of course, the survey shows that the lexical structure of the prayer follows a twofold pattern: there is a remarkable influence of Septuagint usages, but it appears that the structuring was also guided by the everyday speech preserved in documentary papyri. One important comparison can take into consideration the prayer’s request for forgiveness of debts and the phrasing of Ptolemaic decrees of amnesty on important royal events such as throne accessions or victories in battle. Many lexical clues strengthen the hypothesis that at least the second half of the prayer was composed with reference to this kind of documents whose knowledge in the Land of Israel is confirmed by parallels in contemporary Seleucid and Hasmonean edicts. It is worth noting that amnesties constituted a relevant component of Hellenistic royal ideologies: they expressed the cosmic and social value of kingship since the king presented himself as savior and benefactor of his people. A Jewish parallel can be detected in the requirement of Jubilee forgiveness: on a social and economic level, this requirement should have been known to I century Jews in the Land of Israel since it appears in a Hebrew deed of loan found in Murabba’at. Arguably, the Lord’s Prayer plays a provocative reversal of current royal ideology, shifting one of its main features from an inner worldly level to divine transcendence


God's Judgment on the Nations: Theology and Translation in the Old Latin Dodekapropheton
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Giovanni Battista Bazzana, University of Milan

The paper focuses on the Old Latin translation of the Dodekapropheton with the aim of investigating its translation technique and its theological values: these observations might be useful in trying to assess the possible chronological and social location of this version. The twelve prophetic books contain many passages where the scene of God judging the world’s nations is depicted (eg. Hs 4, 2-3): it can be observed that the Old Latin translation emphasized the judicial aspect of these sections choosing to render some Greek expressions through Latin phrases of strong legal and trial tone. This peculiar feature seems to have been well known to African writers (mainly Tertullian and Cyprian), whereas the following revisions of the Old Latin Dodekapropheton, the so called “European text”, set aside it: it can be hypothesized that this feature is a useful marker for the oldest Latin translation of the twelve books in the second half of the second century in Africa. It is worth investigating whether this peculiar emphasis had any theological significance and ought to come from a community sharing a specific ideological allegiance. An observation of Jerome’s translational and exegetical practice on these texts can be very useful: it appears that the author of the Vulgata tried to deemphasize the judicial aspect of many passages where God promises revenge to Israel against the other nations. It seems reasonable to argue that Jerome feared the possible millenarian interpretations of these texts and their use by Jewish-Christian groups hoping for a distinctively “Jewish” eschatology. Since the Old Latin Dodekapropheton had followed a directly opposite path, it is safe to affirm that the probable origin of this translation was in Jewish-Christian millenarian circles.


Nehemiah as a Mosaic Heir: Nehemiah 13 as Appropriation of Deuteronomy 7
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Bob Becking, Utrecht University

In his recent monograph on the moral codes in the Hebrew Bible, Moses Erben, Timo Veijola defended the thesis that the deuteronomists should be seen as the predecessors of the Rabbinic scribes. In this thesis the figures of Ezra and Nehemiah play an important role. Veijola, unfortunately, did not elaborate the specifics of that role. In my presentation, I would like to investigate the role of Nehemiah as a Mosaic heir by paying attention to the way he solves the intermarriage crisis. In my view, this solution differs from the one narrated in the Book of Ezra. Both Ezra 9 and Neh. 13, however, should be seen as appropriations of the tradition to their own time. And is’nt that what heirs are supposed to do?


The Holy Spirit in the Cappadocians: A Reassessment
Program Unit: Christian Late Antiquity and Its Reception
Christopher Beeley, Yale Divinity School

Scholars have long recognized that the seminal period of late fourth-century pneumatology is fraught with difficulties and obscurities. Chief among them is the doctrine of the Cappadocian Fathers. Although their pro-Nicene commitments are now well documented, the major differences that exist among them on the Holy Spirit—and especially the central place of Gregory Nazianzen—are typically overlooked. As a proposal for new research, this paper will offer a reassessment of Cappadocian pneumatology in light of recent scholarship. Attention will also be given to the Council of Constantinople 381, the Theodosian settlement, and the nature of pro-Nicene doctrine.


Biblical Women in Stained Glass Windows in Metropolitan Washington, DC
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Alice Ogden Bellis, Howard University

Metropolitan Washington, D.C. is the home of many churches and synagogues, some of them national in nature, such as the National Cathedral (Episcopal), the Shrine of the Immaculate Conception (Roman Catholic), the National Presbyterian Church, the Church of the Pilgrims (unofficially the national church of the former southern branch of the Presbyterian Church, now united with the northern branch), the National Baptist Church, and others. Many of these buildings have stained glass windows depicting biblical scenes. This paper will explore this heritage with a special eye for scenes involving biblical women. Additionally, issues of ethnic portrayal will be considered. Not only churches that are primarily European, but African-American and Asian-American churches with stained glass windows will also be visited. The goal will be to assemble a diverse group of images of biblical women and to analyze them artistically, theologically, and biblically.


Plural Based Duals in Biblical Hebrew
Program Unit: Paleographical Studies in the Ancient Near East
Jason Bembry, Emmanuel School of Religion

While the vast majority of dual forms in the Hebrew Bible are built upon the singular base, there are 27 examples where the plural form is the base of the dual noun. The one occurring most often is the dual of delet ‘door.’ The inserted -a- vowel, a characteristic of plurals in North West Semitic, appears after the lamed in this word indicating that it is the plural base upon which the dual ending is added. Three other qvtl-type nouns that display this pattern are qeren ‘horn,’ ker‘a ‘thigh,’ and derek ‘road.’ Two additional dual forms appear on the word homah ‘wall’ and luah ‘tablet.’ Additional evidence of the presence of the pluralizing -a- vowel can be seen in some forms of delet in construct and with pronominal suffixes. These forms lack the daghesh lene which is normally present in other duals of qvtl nouns with a begedkepet letter in the third position. The Babylonian pointing system, as attested in the Cairo Genizah fragments, confirm that this phenomena is not limited to the Massoretic tradition of pointing. These forms are likely caused by an erroneous assumption that delet was not a qvtl noun but a III-he noun. On analogy with III-he nouns that present a medial -a- vowel in their dual forms, delet assimilated to this same pattern. Select qvtl nouns with a liquid consonant in the middle position followed the pattern of delet and thus created these inconsistencies. The pattern was then applied to two other non-qvtl nouns resulting in further inconsistencies.


YHWH's Coming of Age
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Jason Bembry, Emmanuel School of Religion

This paper is an examination of why Israel’s God, YHWH, is not explicitly portrayed with old age imagery in the early biblical traditions. The imagery used of YHWH is in many ways a compilation of features seen in the Ugaritic depictions of the gods El and Baal. Yet Baal is portrayed as a youthful warrior, while El is explicitly portrayed as old. Biblical writers preferred to resolve this tension by depicting YHWH as a youthful warrior. They thus avoided associating the deity with the weakness often seen as a concomitant feature of senescence. The second part examines the striking reversal in this tradition during the second century BCE, when YHWH is called “the Ancient of Days” in Daniel 7. Two trajectories may account for this transformation. First, there was a renaissance of cosmic or mythological themes in late biblical Israel: motifs once rejected because of concerns for orthodoxy were now welcomed into the tradition. The writer of Daniel 7 employs refracted motifs earlier attested at Ugarit to portray God in a new light. YHWH’s epithet, “Ancient of Days,” is reminiscent of the elderly El, who has a younger divine agent, Baal, who reigns with him; this younger agent in Daniel 7 is the “one like a son of man” figure. The second trajectory is the growing tendency to portray YHWH as a father. YHWH is only occasionally portrayed as a father in Israel’s early traditions, but paternal imagery re-enters the tradition at a later date. YHWH is thus portrayed as a father to David the king, to David’s descendants, and to the Israelite nation as a whole. The conjunction of these two trajectories produced the image of YHWH as the bearded and white-haired “Ancient of Days.”


Beyond Gutenberian Models in E-Publication: A Proposal for the Further Development of the Journal of Hebrew Scriptures
Program Unit: Computer Assisted Research
Ehud Ben Zvi, University of Alberta

Researchers, students and the general educated public have benefited much from excellent, open access, peer-reviewed, academic journals. These journals create broader, international communities of readers and provide fast dissemination of academic knowledge. They also are internationally-used teaching resources. But these journals can offer more. E-publication offers capabilities which are well beyond those of a Gutenbergian, bi-dimensional linear model of a printed page and its concomitant limitations. The present paper will discuss academic and technical aspects of a project aimed at adding a range of new digital capabilities to the Journal of Hebrew Scriptures and ways in which this project may serve as a model for other open access publications.


Imagining Josiah’s Book and the Implications of Imagining It
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Ehud Ben Zvi, University of Alberta

The story of the finding of “the book of the (divine) instruction” plays an important role in the book of Kings. Moreover, it has served key roles in critical biblical research for more than a century, and in construction of ancient Israelite history. This paper does not focus on the well-known debates on questions of historicity or lack thereof, nor on matters of redactional history of the book of Kings. Instead, it addresses the particular social memory of the event that the (present form of the) book of Kings not only shapes and reflects among its intended and primary readers in the postmonarchic period, but also asks them to reenact as they proceed in reading and rereading the Kings. Thus, the paper discusses, among others, the way in which the texts suggested them to imagine the contents of that ??? ?????, the role the book (and its finding) played in that locus of social memory, how these matters related to the readerships’ discourses and the light they may shed on the intellectual and ideological milieu of literati, within which the present book of Kings emerged.


Jubilean Chronology and the 364-Day Year
Program Unit: Qumran
Jonathan Ben-Dov, University of Haifa

Qumran writings make use of two time reckoning devices, both based on the number seven. The first device concerns the short-term calculations of the 364-day year, neatly divided into 52 weeks, 13 weeks per quarter etc. The second device concerns the long-term calculation of Daniel 9:27 and a variety of second temple texts, which is based on cycles of seven and forty-nine years. Although one would expect those two time reckoning devices to coalesce, in fact they stand apart from each other. The basic units of the 364-day year were the lunisolar 3-year period and the 6-year mishmarot cycle, which are incommensurate with the septenary models of the jubilean chronology. My paper examines two implications of this disharmony. First, there is no sign for the use at Qumran of jubilee cycles as a chronological device for real historical events, in contrast to later Jewish practice. This point finds proof in the "historical texts" 4Q331-4Q333, which make use of mishmarot dates but do not mention a jubilean chronology. The 'Otot' composition (4Q319) is the only calendrical document which combines the 364-day year with jubilean chronology, but this is not done for the purpose of dating real events. Second, we shall examine the point of beginning of the jubilee year. In Leviticus 25, as well as in the pesher 11QMelchizedek, the Jubilee ends (and begins) in Yom Hakippurim, in the autumn, as opposed to the spring beginning of the standard 364-day year. However, there is possible evidence for a spring beginning of the jubilee year in calendrical and chronographical documents: 4Q319 and 4Q379 frg 12 (Apocryphon of Joshua, recently discussed by Dimant). It is possible that the coercive force of the normative 364-day year took over the shemitah and jubilee legislations, which were originally committed to a different calendrical system.


The Words of God as a Tool for Political Debates in Israel
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Rachel BenDor, Hebrew University of Jerusalem

In Modern Israel, biblical texts are relevant in political debates and used by nationalist for proving patriotism. It was that thinking that moved me to use biblical texts when faced with the need to name the grassroots peace movement in Israel which I founded: “Four Mothers – Leave Lebanon in Peace.” Between 1997-2000 we lobbied the Israeli government to stop the war with Lebanon. The phrase “Four Mothers” is mentioned in the Passover Haggadah describing the most essential elements in Jewish history. Using this name tied us to the power of biblical motherhood, as well as to the Passover story. This connection enabled us to use ideas like “exodus” “freedom” and “survival” in relation to our protest against the war with Lebanon. During Passover we gathered at the border between Lebanon and Israel. At this event I read Jeremiah’s prophecy (31:14-16) as he referred to Rachel in his lament of the exile. The Lord says, “They shall come back from the land of the enemy.” As I continued to quote the Lord’s promise to Rachel, “and your children shall return to their own border,” the participants of the rally and television viewers become more supportive (according to newspapers’ surveys) of the idea to leave Lebanon in peace. Relating our motherhood to the Biblical mothers gave us the authenticity and the credibility to change public opinion regarding this war. The New York Times stated: "Many Israelis celebrated with the ‘Four Mothers’ one of the most successful grass-roots movements in Israeli history. The women took a classic Israeli stereotype -- the silent, suffering soldier's mother -- stood it on its head and dared to challenge the military." ( New York Times June 3, 2000).


The Conversation of John the Orthodox with a Manichaean: An Analysis of Its Sources and Its Significance for Manichaean Studies
Program Unit: Manichaean Studies
Byard Bennett, Grand Rapids Theological Seminary

This paper will discuss the Conversation of John the Orthodox with a Manichaean, a Greek anti-Manichaean work of the early Byzantine period which is extant in four manuscripts dating from the tenth to the thirteenth centuries. The paper will examine how much the author knew about Manichaeism and what literary sources he drew upon in constructing his critical account of the Manichaean faith and responding to its claims. To promote discussion, a draft translation of the Conversation (based on Aubineau's critical edition of the text) will be made available to seminar members in advance of the meeting.


Pentecostal Biblical Interpretation and Afrocentric Biblical Criticism: Sculpting a Paradigm for Afro-Pentecostal Biblical Hermeneutics
Program Unit: African-American Biblical Hermeneutics
Harold V. Bennett, Morehouse College

Pentecostalism, is its various expressions, is a mushrooming phenomenon on the local and international religious scenes. In, fact, this type of Christianity is one of the fastest growing subgroups of Christianity in the African-American community. What is more, the Bible plays a major role in theologizing and in moral philosophizing among Pentecostals. Noteworthy, however, is it that a dearth is present in the amount of critical scholarship on biblical hermeneutics in Pentecostal quarters. While Gordon Fee, Gordon Anderson, and Walter Hollenweger raise questions and propose strategies for interpreting the Bible among Pentecostals, none of these scholars sculpts a paradigm for understanding the Bible that reflects an awareness of developments in Afrocentric biblical criticism. Thus, the task that the present paper sets for itself is to introduce Afrocentric biblical criticism into the current conversation on Pentecostal biblical Hermeneutics. The thesis to be developed in this essay is that a model for reading the Bible, which grounds itself in an Afrocentric, Pentecostal perspective, offers a robust hermeneutic theory for interpreting and appropriating the material in the Bible, and for convincing a subgroup of persons for whom the Bible has significance that the critical study of this document is a worthwhile enterprise.


Daniel 9 and the Return to Zion: The Jubilary Logic of the "Seventy Weeks" of Years
Program Unit: Literature and History of the Persian Period
John S. Bergsma, Franciscan University of Steubenville

Many commentators incorrectly view Daniel's prayer (Dan 9:3-14) as a request for "exegetical insight" into Jeremiah's prophecy of seventy years of exile for Jerusalem/Zion, and, as a result, can give no explanation of *how* Jeremiah's seventy years of exile become the "seventy weeks" of years in Gabriel's message (9:24). This paper demonstrates that Daniel's prayer of penitence (Dan 9:3-14) is an attempt to fulfill the necessary condition for the return from exile according to Jer 29:12-14 and other biblical passages (Deut 30:2-5). Through the angel, God gives a qualified positive response to Daqniel: his prayer for Jerusalem will be answered, but will be delayed by a factor of seven, according to the priniciple of Lev 26:21: if God punishes but repentance is lacking, the punishment is increased sevenfold. The sevenfold increase of the period of exile results in 10 jubilee periods (cf. Lev 25:8), i.e. a perfect period before the eschatological liberation. Thus, there is a logic to the structure of Daniel 9 and its presentation of the delayed fulfillment of the promises to Jerusalem/Zion after the initial return from exile. The logic is based on careful (if pre-modern) exegesis of key prophetic and pentateuchal texts related to the exile (i.e. Jer 29, Deut 30, Lev 25-26), as opposed to arbitrary interpretation or "mantic exegesis." This paper contributes to an understanding of how some groups in Second Temple Judaism struggled with the mixed results of the return to Zion under Persian rule and sought to understand it through scriptural reinterpretation.


Using the Bible in Contemporary American Political Rhetoric
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Jacques Berlinerblau, Georgetown University

In the midst of what one historian has referred to as “the Fourth Great Awakening,” the Bible is making a comeback in contemporary American politics. Not since the nineteenth century has Scripture played such a large role in serving as the basis for social movements. One major factor--but not the only factor--influencing its reemergence is the centrality of the Bible to the Conservative Evangelical voting block that has played such a major role in recent elections. This partly helps to explain a recent and generally little noticed phenomenon: the increased use of scriptural citations and biblical allusions in political rhetoric. In this paper the use of Scripture in political oratory is examined with an eye toward identifying, the good, the bad and the ugly. It will be shown that successful use of sacred texts in politics requires not using it so generously so as to frighten advocates of Church/State separation, all the while speaking in “code” to one’s targeted religious audience. The rhetoric of George W. Bush, Bill Clinton. Barack Obama, and Joe Lieberman will be scrutinized. In addition, the essay will examine some of the difficulties that Democrats have had in turning their use of the Bible into electoral victories.


Of Moses and Montesquieu: A Constitutional Reading of Deuteronomy
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
Joshua Berman, Bar-Ilan University/Shalem Center

Most discussions of Deuteronomy’s constitutional elements focus upon Deut 16:18-18:22, the unit that describes the powers of the judiciary, the priesthood, the monarchy and the institution of prophecy. Yet these institutions must be seen within the broader social and theological context that Deuteronomy looks to create across its 34 chapters. As has been well noted, Deuteronomy severely attenuates the powers routinely granted to kings in the ancient Near East. As has also been noted, Deuteronomy rejects much of the traditional tribal hierarchy and kinship value system exhibited in the other books of the Pentateuch. This paper argues that both of these thrusts serve the same end: The formation of a fraternal and egalitarian citizenry, that is the foremost political body within the polity. Deuteronomy’s politics are illuminated through anthropological studies of pre-modern cultures where the centralized authority of an individual chief is eschewed in favor of collective bodies of authority. Primary attention is focused upon the ways in which the Book’s narrative frame, often considered a later accretion, integrally contributes to the developments of these ideas. The argument bears relevance for the history of political ideas. For Montesquieu it was inconceivable to imagine a classless society and a regime where the division of powers was purely institutional and instrumental. Hereditary nobility, was hardly a necessary evil, but indeed a boon to effective government. It is precisely on this score of the relation between the separation of powers and the question of class that Deuteronomy stands distinct. For the first time in history, and without parallel until the American founding fathers, we see the articulation of a division of powers along lines of institution and instrument rather than of class and kinship where office legitimizes pre-existing societal seats of power.


Kingship in the Priestly Writings
Program Unit: Theology of the Hebrew Scriptures
David A. Bernat, Wellesley College

The proposed paper considers the extent to which the theology, and the Weltanschauung more broadly, of the Priestly tradent (P), are influenced by royal structures and concerns. On one level, P can be considered a-monarchic, in that the Priestly Pentateuchal writings are almost completely devoid of explicit references to kings or kingship. I will argue, however, that conceptions of kingship are deeply embedded within the P corpus. The presentation will focus primarily on the dynamics of the relationship between YHWH and Israel. A related issue, P’s constructions of the priesthood and priestly succession, will also be treated. In the course of my discussion, I will address the theological and ideological underpinnings of P’s particular engagement with monarchic ideas and imagery. Additionally, the oft-debated question of an historical setting for the Priestly Torah will be situated within the context of the P-kingship inquiry.


Nabal in the Aramaic Versions of the Bible: Morally or Intellectually Deficient?
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Moshe J. Bernstein, Yeshiva University

The Hebrew noun nabal occurs eighteen times in a spectrum of biblical books, ranging from the Torah to the Prophets to poetry and wisdom books, as well as four times in the Hebrew of Ben Sira. Its range of meaning, according to the recent treatment in HALOT, covers “futile, worthless, godless, fool, unbeliever,” among others. This paper will survey the translations of this term in the Aramaic versions of Scripture, paying attention to the Hebrew context, and then focusing primarily on its classification as a moral or an intellectual deficiency. The resulting distribution will then be compared with the treatment of nabal in other ancient versions and modern translations and commentaries.


Joy or Jinx: Daughters in the Greco-Roman World
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Sharon Betsworth, Graduate Theological Union

This paper will explore daughters, ie, the young unmarried girls in families, in the world of the New Testament. One way to understand the significance of the daughters in the New Testament is to view their status as daughters in the ancient Mediterranean context. A social-historical reconstruction of the life of daughters in the Greco-Roman world, following scholars such as Susan Dixon, Susan Pomeroy or Ross Kraemer, yields a negative portrayal in many regards. For example, daughters were more likely to be abandoned at birth than sons were. If raised in the family, they were educated less than their brothers, and were also considered an expense when marriage is arranged. Sons were more important among the children in a family, carrying on the family name and property. In contrast to this historical evidence, representations of daughters in literary texts from this era offer a different portrait. In the Greek and Jewish novels, as well as in plays and poetry, daughters frequently are central characters around whom the plot revolves or are the catalysts for the action. I will examine both the social-historical and literary representations of daughters in the Greco-Roman world, and hypothesize why this difference exists. I will then briefly apply these findings to three daughters in the gospel of Mark, Jairus’ daughter (Mark 5:21-24, 35-42), Herodias’ daughter (Mark 6:14-29) and the Syro-Phoenician woman’s daughter (Mark 7:24-30) and suggests the ways in which they contribute to Mark’s inclusive social vision of the reign of God while further establishing Jesus’ role as the son of God.


From Archaeology to Exegesis: A Historical Record of the Rise and Fall of Aramean Hegemony in the Levant
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Harold Betton, Trinity College

The preacher is faced with the incorporation of multiple disciplines in biblical studies which provides exegetical illumination to the biblical text; yet the Bible provides such a scanty presentation of some of the subjects, most notably the rise and fall of the Aramean hegemony in the Levant. To this end a logical reconstruction of the information is necessary, interfacing with the biblical record, to provide a more cohesive picture of Levant history during the period between Rehoboam/Jeroboam and Ahaz. Most notably the answer to two questions are required: How did the united kingdom of Solomon lose its position of hegemony in the Levant? Does the archaeological record support Israel's fall and the Aramean rise? This study will incorporate the answers to these questions and provide arguments which will be intended to aide the preacher, regardless of theological persuasion, in the sphere of exegesis and homiletics.


Obadiah-Jonah-Micah in Canonical Context
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Mark E. Biddle, Baptist Theological Seminary at Richmond

The paper will evaluate the books of Obadiah-Jonah-Micah within the Twelve for the ways in which they relate to recurring themes and theological motifs (e.g. Zion and the nations, theodicy, sin/repentance) within and through the Book of the Twelve.


The Voice of the New Creation: A Future-Oriented Biblical Ecological Hermeneutics
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Reimund Bieringer, Catholic University of Leuven

In their effort to take into account the anthropologically oppressive bias of texts, many approaches to Biblical ecological hermeneutics focus on the past or the present as the locus of authority of the text. Our approach to Biblical ecological hermeneutics focuses on the future as the locus of authority in order to retrieve the voice and story of the non-human. Our approach, which we call normativity of the future, sees the revelatory quality of the scriptures in the horizon and vision which the texts project, e.g., the new creation or the new heavens and the new earth. Our focus is not on eschatological texts as human idealization of a transformed creation. Rather the normativity of the future approach sees in the text the projection of a horizon within which we can address the contemporary ecological crisis. Normativity of the future works with three dimensions of the future, namely the very possibility of a future, ethical claims of the future, and eschatology inbreaking. An exploration of future-directed metaphors allows us to hear the voice of members of the Earth community for today that is breaking into the texts, either implicitly as inclusive community or in spite of blatant exclusionary language. In this presentation we will first describe our future-oriented hermeneutical approach which goes beyond the text in uncovering new meanings guided by the horizon which the text projects. Second, we will apply this hermeneutical approach to two scriptural passages, Romans 8:19-23 and Ephesians 1:3-10. Third, we will draw out implications from this approach to interpreting the scriptures for a contemporary framework to guide ecological decisions.


Scripture against Roman: Christian Identity in Athenagoras
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
D. Jeffrey Bingham, Dallas Theological Seminary

Positive, detailed treatments of Scripture in Athenagoras of Athens have been lacking. Strong expressions of the absence of Scripture’s influence in his Legatio have seemed to rule the modern prejudice. With Pouderon’s 1994 essay some helpful headway toward recognizing the presence of Scripture within the apologist’s argument was made, yet Pouderon left undeveloped an analysis of how Scripture functions within the Legatio to contribute to an argument for Christian self-definition. This paper, then, will explore how Scripture, sacred teaching, influences Athenagoras in his attempt to answer the Romans for their perceived misconception of Christianity and the hardships with which they burden the Christians. In particular, this paper will demonstrate how biblical passages function to manifest a conception of God the Father which emphasizes God’s distinction from earthly things and God’s spiritual essence. This is the accepted rational view of the deity within the broader Roman context. This emphasis comes forth as Athenagoras reads and employs pagan philosophical and poetic texts within a pattern of belief and conception delimited by Scriptural teaching. Scripture certainly functions to develop the absolutely unique claims of the Christians, but significantly, it also informs, in a prejudicial manner, how Athenagoras will read pagan texts in a somewhat distinctive manner, yet also one which, within allowable parameters, holds commonality with his non-Christian culture.


Sectarian Gospels for Sectarian Communities? The Non-canonical Gospels and Bauckham's "Gospel for All Christians"
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Michael F. Bird, Highlands Theological College

This paper examines recent criticism of Richard Bauckham's "Gospel for All Christians" hypothesis. It presents a response to Margrat Mitchell, David Sim and Thomas Kazan who appeal to non-canonical Gospels (i.e. Gospel of Thomas, Gospel of Peter, and Jewish Christian Gospels) as evidence that the canonical Gospel were not intended to circulate among "all Christians" but were designed for internal consumption by the sectarian communities in which they were composed. This paper advocates that the canonical Gospels lack the "sectarian" features apparent in Thomas and that the creators of the non-canonical Gospels did intend their works to circulate just as widely the canonical Gospels circulated.


Who Comes from the East and the West? Luke 13:28–29, Matthew 8:11–12, and the Historical Jesus
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Michael F. Bird, Highlands Theological College

Since Joachim Jeremias’ Jesu Verheissung für die Völker (1956) it has often been assumed that in Matt 8.11-12 Jesus looked forward to the inclusion of gentiles into the kingdom at the eschaton. However, several recent studies, most notably by Dale C. Allison, have called this view into question and have instead advocated that the logion refers to the regathering of the Diaspora. The purpose of this study is to evaluate Allison’s arguments and to propose that a gentile reference is implicit in the logion based on: (1) the broader context of the inter-textual echoes of passages concerning the regathering of Jewish exiles; and (2) a wider ethnic membership for those who participate in the patriarchal banquet based on the reference to ‘Abraham’. Furthermore, the logion is interpreted in the historical Jesus’ ministry through the lens of a partially realized eschatology. As such the saying represents Jesus’ contention that Israel’s restoration was already becoming a reality and that gentiles were already entering the kingdom as an embryonic foretaste of their inclusion at the eschaton.


Lamented or Demented? The Psalmist-Subject and the Possession at Loudun
Program Unit: Biblical Criticism and Literary Criticism
Fiona Black, Mount Allison University

In an effort to investigate the poetic contours of lament as a consequence of subjectivity, the paper reads the lamenting subject in the Complaint Psalms against the backdrop of Michel de Certeau’s evaluations of the Ursuline nuns in the Possession at Loudun. The 17th-century nuns, possibly as part of a response to the major metaphysical event of a plague, began to exhibit signs of possession, and eventually an elaborate system of classification and exorcism developed around their illness. A major interest for Certeau, and for this paper is not, however, the actuality of demon possession, but the apparent creation, social control and management of alterity—in the nuns’ case, madness—in the psalmist’s case, (hysterical) lament. In the psalms, lamentation provides a means of articulating an alternative reality, one that has its own conventions and limitations. In this context, the lamenting utterance threatens to position the subject of the Psalms as a place of siege; the subject fights to be heard above the din of “normality” and the rigours of divine expectation. Moreover, his body is a contested site for enemies and illness, among other afflictions. On the other hand, though, the ultimate act of confession at the end of the Complaints threatens to undermine his existence, to make him vanish into that very context from which he initially differentiated himself as a speaking subject. The paper considers, therefore, the psalms’ alternative reality as the locus of a balancing act between the subject’s complicity and annihilation. This, in turn, is pondered within the context of poetic discourse, which might be viewed as an impulse to showcase—and manage—“possession.”


The Construction of Christian Identity through the Stereotyping of the Pharisees in the Gospel of Matthew
Program Unit: Construction of Christian Identities
Steve Black, Toronto School of Theology

By popular wisdom, stereotypes are the product of pathological thinking and serve only to further the prejudiced desires of the ones who utilize them. However, many theorists (such as Henri Tajfel, Vincent Yzerbyt and Russell Spears) argue that stereotypes are rather an inevitable way to categorize the social world. Stereotypes establish social maps that define “us” by delineating “them”. The stereotype of the others (the “outgroup”) functions as a marker for the social self (the “ingroup”) in such a way that it becomes constitutive. If one were to remove the stereotype of the outgroup, the identity of the ingroup would be challenged: without "them", we cease being "us". This paper will argue that the gospel of Matthew’s stereotype of the Pharisees as hypocritical is foundational within the Sermon on the Mount as well as throughout the gospel. This representation of the Pharisees is not incidental to the first gospel, but rather functions as an important means of identity construction for the Matthean community. This stereotype helped Matthew map his social universe so as to know appropriate and inappropriate modes of behavior and being. If one were to ask Matthew what is a faithful follower of Jesus looked like, he would be hard pressed to answer without reference to his Pharisaical stereotype. The Pharisees need to be what Matthew construes them to be for his vision of Christian identity to be maintained. This paper has direct relevance to early Christian identity construction. Beyond this, it also has important implications for early Jewish–Christian relation, as well as Christian anti-Judaism.


Pauline Histories, Biopolitical Futures
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Ward Blanton, University of Glasgow

This paper considers the way an understanding of Paul can both extend and critique Agamben's (extension and critique of Foucault's) diagnosis of "biopolitics." Among other things, Agamben is touchy about "apocalyptic" teleology in all of his writings. I will propose a reading of Paul that shows how apocalyptic imaginaries afforded crucial ground for a resistance to the biopolitical dimensions of Roman colonial power. I want to use this genealogical example to think through the question of whether the formalistic or "empty" dimensions of Agamben's thinking might gut its ability to DO the political work he wants the "messianic" to do.


David’s Rupture with God, Depression, and Recovery
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Adrien J. Bledstein, Chicago, IL

Reading only narrative, commentators have not appreciated King David’s depression following his crimes. When Psalms are integrated with narrative at every phase of his life, several insights emerge. From youth David’s passion was to serve YHWH. He knew the covenant, tried to live accordingly, and despised the wicked. After he was anointed he envisioned a temple where he would serve his Beloved. As king he brought the Ark to Jerusalem, the most ecstatic day of his life. His kingdom established, the country in relative peace, David determined to fulfill his dream. Instead, YHWH made him founder of a dynasty. A son of his would build the Temple. The latter news conflicted with David’s high expectations as a king in the ancient Near East. Sometime after this David fumbled in battle and stayed at the palace while his heroes went to war. He took Bathsheba. When his efforts to cover her pregnancy failed he arranged the death of Uriah. From David’s prayers and lack thereof it becomes clear he was deeply dispirited. In contrast to his hypergraphic anguish at the cave of Adullam when unjust circumstances drove him to despair, David was depressed following the rape of Tamar, death of Amnon, and exile of Absalom. This paper traces evidence of his depression and his recovery as he anticipated his penance was nearing an end.


The Intellectual World of Judaism in the Achaemenid Period
Program Unit:
Joseph Blenkinsopp, University of Notre Dame

*


The Mystery of the Missing Sons of Aaron
Program Unit: Social-Scientific Studies of the Second Temple Period
Joseph Blenkinsopp, University of Notre Dame

On the assumption, widely shared, that the Priestly material was compiled in the post-destruction period, the mystery is that neither Aaron qua priest nor Aaronid priests are mentioned in any pre-exilic text or indeed in any post-destruction texts with the exception of the same Priestly material, Chronicles and one or two psalms. This is true even of texts which have a lot to say about priests, for example Malachi and Ezra-Nehemiah (Ezra's Aaronid descent draws on the lists in Chronicles). The priests on the island of Elephantine are not called "sons of Aaron" either. This silence can hardly be coincidental and seems to demand an answer. One proposal for a solution will be offered.


How I Spend My Days: Archaeological Evidence for Iron Age Women at Home
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Elizabeth Bloch-Smith, Saint Joseph's University

The Bible provides frustratingly few details and specific terminology for pre-exilic houses – construction features, floor plans, built-in and mobile furnishings, and activity areas. However, recent publications of Iron Age (ca. 1200-586 BC) houses catalogue ceramic, botanical, and faunal assemblages by room enabling synchronic and diachronic reconstructions of the women’s domain, the house and domestic activities. Based on commonly attested features, many women spent their days - in dark, cramped quarters shared with animals - grinding grain, preparing food (cereals, legumes, fish, and fruits) for consumption and storage, and weaving.


Scriptural Allusions and Reminiscences in Private Christian Letters from Oxyrhynchus
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Lincoln Blumell, University of Toronto

While Oxyrhynchus is best known among scholars of Christian origins for its New Testament and Extra-Biblical fragments, what is not nearly as well known is the large number of private Christian letters it has produced. Beginning in the third century Christian letters begin to emerge from Oxyrhynchus and by the sixth and seventh centuries almost every extant letter is distinctly Christian. While these letters have not received nearly as much attention in scholarship as the New Testament or Extra-Biblical material, they too are an important source for elucidating and understanding Christianity at Oxyrhynchus. This paper will assess how the extant Christian letters from Oxyrhynchus from the third to fifth centuries allude to and employ scripture.


Narrative Resurrection in the Gospel of Mark
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Charles A. Bobertz, Saint John's University

This paper will argue that Mark begins with a narrative of the death and resurrection of Christ, the baptismal scene at 1:9-11, and then moves to other narrative constructions (4:35-41; 5:39-43; 6:47-52; 9:2-8) to express the same reality. Does the ending of Mark point one forward into a time of uncertainty, both hope and disappointment, or back into the narrative to hear again with new ears and see again with new eyes? Further, what might the portrayal of the death and resurrection of Jesus within the narrative of Mark indicate about an early Christian understanding of cultic time and narrative? If the death and resurrection of Christ were ritually enacted within the apocalyptically oriented community of Mark, might this help explain the narrative juxtaposition of eternity, the resurrected quality of Jesus, and historical time, the narrative portrayal of the passing of time in Jesus’ ministry as he moves toward his death? The early Christian acceptance, ritual initiation, and meal proclamation of the apocalyptic death of Christ (1 Cor 11:26) created an apocalyptic community at once outside of time (already crucified with Christ; history as already completed) yet within time. The narrative portrayal of Jesus in the Gospel of Mark must move Jesus toward his death so that the narrative can begin with resurrection. The narrative itself is both outside of time (and endless cycle of beginning to end and end to beginning) and the portrayal of eternity (resurrection) within time (the historical details of the ministry of Jesus). A reading of Mark which takes the cultic reality of the Markan community as its starting point would redirect the intonation of modern angst at the empty tomb back into the narrative of Mark itself.


The Blending of Sapiential and Apocalytpic Traditions in the Parables of Enoch
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Gabriele Boccaccini, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor

Early scholarship on apocalyptic literature argued vociferously that apocalyptic literature either grew out of wisdom literature or prophetic literature, not wanting to recognize that the apocalyptic tradition grew out of a blend of traditions. Similarly, texts are rarely "purely" wisdom texts or apocalyptic texts. This paper explores the blending of wisdom and apocalyptic traditions in the Parables of Enoch.


The Daughter’s Joy: Zion as Redactional Leitmotif in a Latter Phase of the Book of the Twelve
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Mark J. Boda, McMaster Divinity College, McMaster University

In the 1998 session of the Book of the Twelve group, Byron Curtis offered important observations on the role of the Daughter Zion oracles in the later redaction of the Book of the Twelve. In that contribution he focused much needed attention on the oracles in Zephaniah 3 and Zechariah 9, arguing that the Daughter Zion oracle in Zeph 3:14-18 was used as a redactional transition in the Book of the Twelve from the pre-exilic prophets to the restorationist prophets, in much the same way that the Daughter Zion oracle of Zech 9:9-10 was used to transition from the early to the later restorationist prophets in the Haggai-Malachi corpus. Building on these reflections, this paper draws the Daughter Zion oracle of Zechariah 2 into this discussion, using redactional and intertextual evidence to highlight the role of this oracle in the growing tradition of Zechariah, the Haggai-Malachi corpus, the Book of the Twelve and the prophets in general. The evidence suggests that the final shaping of the Zecharian tradition was written with a significant portion of the prophetic corpus in view.


Optical Allusions: Seeing the Literary Contribution of 4QSam
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Keith Bodner, Atlantic Baptist University

It is well-recognized that the Qumran scrolls of Samuel make a significant contribution to understanding the text-critical problems of this stretch of the Deuteronomistic History. The contribution is now poised to be further enhanced with the publication of the recent DJD volume edited by Cross, Parry, Saley and Ulrich. To this point, however, comparatively less attention has been given to examining the literary contribution of the Qumran material as far as understanding the literary dynamics of the narrative. In this presentation I argue that the 4QSam material presents alternative readings at several points that enhance one’s appreciation of the narrative artistry of the text. After reviewing several specific examples from 1 Samuel that pertain to the “visual” arena, I will move toward a conclusion with some points about the more general literary contribution of the Qumran scrolls and some future directions for this kind of research.


Political Myth, or, the Antinomies of Christian Zionism
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Roland T. Boer, Monash University

The contradiction at the heart of Christian Zionism is well-known -- the support by the Christian Right of the state of Israel is based on the removal of Judaism. This paper argues that it is more of an unresolvable antinomy than a contradiction that may be resolved. The paper also explores the way such an antinomy is both set up and undermined by the political myths of the New Testament.


Jael as a Physical Feminist
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Karla G. Bohmbach, Susquehanna University

"But Jael wife of Heber took a tent peg, and took a hammer in her hand, and went softly to him and drove the peg into his temple, until it went down into the ground. . . ." (Judg. 4:21). For many readers of Judges 4 (and 5), Jael's actions fascinate, even as they also provoke unease. Even feminist biblical scholars, who often otherwise bemoan the bible's lack of strong, positive female characters and images, may, upon reading this text, be left squirming -- literally, figuratively, or both. Does not Jael go too far? Aren't her actions just too violent and too aggressive? Part of the problem, of course, is the very physicality of Jael's actions. Early stages of feminist theorizing focused primarily on how patriarchy operated in and through cultural ideologies and how these, in turn, impacted the psyches of women and men. Only more recently has Elizabeth Grosz, among others, argued for the importance of theorizing the body, not only as a site of patriarchal subjugation but also as a potential site for resistance to that subjugation. And Martha McCaughey, in her book Real Knockouts: The Physical Feminism of Women's Self-Defense (New York University Press, 1997), insists that the women's self-defense movement fosters such bodily resistance. Indeed, this movement can help feminism take seriously the corporeality and pleasure of physical resistance to sexual discrimination and sexual violence; it demands that feminism get physical!(see pg. xiii) This paper proposes to re-read Jael's actions from the perspective of physical feminism. It will analyze how and to what extent we might value what she does physically in her attempts to withstand patriarchy's operations.


Who am I? And How Does that Matter When Faith Issues Enter into the Classroom?
Program Unit:
Karla Bohmbach, Susquehanna University

ho am I? I am: 1) a life-long Lutheran Christian teaching at a Lutheran college; 2) an ardent feminist whose scholarship focuses on some of the nastiest texts in the Hebrew Bible; 3) a woman who a few years ago negotiated with her school to reconfigure her full-time position into one shared with her (newly-married) spouse; 4) a wife who disagrees with her spouse on a huge number of theological, intellectual, and pedagogical issues (while sharing his passion for C. S. Lewis); 5) a religious doubter who serves as a regular supply preacher in local churches; 6) a co-leader with her husband of a student bible study at our home; and . . . Identities are complex and multiple and grow out of a history of changing responses to economic, political, and cultural forces, almost always in opposition to other identities² (Kwame Anthony Appiah, In My Father¹s House: Africa in the Philosophy of Culture. New York: Oxford University Press, 1992. Pg. 178). Indeed. And so I am wary of simplistic identity markers for either myself or my students, cognizant of how they oversimplify and what they elide. I am also wary of coercing my students into self-revelations about their identities even as I recognize how significantly our identities shape the questions we ask and the answers we perceive. My presentation will thus explore how these tensions and concerns play themselves out in my teaching. It will look at how they operate both in and out of the classroom, for both myself and my students, and how they have changed over time and under new circumstances (particularly the switch from a full-time position to one shared with my husband).


Isaiah and the Three Year Sunday Lectionaries: Post-Shoah Considerations of the Anamnesis of Public Worship
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Regina A. Boisclair, Alaska Pacific University

Contemporary Christianity dwells in the shadow of the Shoah. The contemporary three-year Lectionaries provide collections of readings for proclamation in public worship that are open to the anamnesis of classical teachings of contempt. After general observations pertaining to: 1) The Catholic, Episcopal and Revised Common three-year lectionaries currently in use, 2) The Christian understandings of Jewish scriptures, 3) The distinction between supersessionism and Christian re-reading. This study will focus the selections Isaiah and 1) Describe what is included from the Book of Isaiah in each lectionary 2) Indicate the dominant understandings of the selections 4) Explore where Isaiah functions as prototype, prediction, or foreshadowing in lectionary collections, 5) Identify when and how the Christian calendar provides additional hermeneutical influences. While the Churches cannot sacrifice essential teaching to the altar of interfaith sensitivities, after the Shoah they can no longer foster teachings of contempt. Lectionaries incorporate biblical understandings that must be reconsidered in light of post-Shoah consciousness.


Weaving the New Testament into the Semantic Web
Program Unit: Computer Assisted Research
Sean Boisen, SemanticBible.org

The World Wide Web, as a network of documents, has become a staple of everyday life, including Biblical scholarship. Recent activity by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) envisions moving beyond a web of HTML documents to a web of concepts and meaningful data called the Semantic Web. Foundational concepts include the use of Uniform Resource Identifiers (URIs) to describe resources, the Resource Description Framework (RDF) for describing properties of resources, and the Web Ontology Language (OWL), now a W3C recommended standard for representing ontological relationships in a web-friendly way. This paper will briefly overview what the Semantic Web is, and why it is relevant to Biblical scholars. It will also describe several Semantic Web projects underway at SemanticBible.org. For example, the NT Names project (http://www.semanticbible.org/ntn/ntn-overview.html) is producing a freely-sharable semantic catalog of people, locations, and other named objects in the New Testament, as well as various kinship, interpersonal, and locational relationships between them. Other projects address the creation of semantically-organized lexical resources, and semantic relationships within and between the Gospels. The paper will close with additional suggestions for how Semantic Web technologies can enable better integration, access, and search for Biblical data.


Renewing the Mind: Paul's Theological and Ethical Use of the Phren Cognate Group in Romans
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Lee Bond, Trinity International University

In this paper I argue that Paul has a clearly defined scheme of the Renewed Mind and that this concept is that which links the apostle's theology to his ethics. Romans 12.1-2 is one the most well known of all New Testament passages. Scholars generally agree that the passage serves as a kind of literary bridge, linking the more "theological" sections of the letter (chapers 1-11) to the more "ethical" sections (chapers 12-16). Moreover, scholars generally agree with Bultmann, Furnish and others that Paul's ethics are somehow based upon, and developed out of his theology. The question however is how the two are precisely connected. This paper argues that Paul's scheme of the renewed mind (and more precisely, the phren word group) provides the all important lexical bridge between the apostle's theology and ethics. After an introductory section which clearly defines the question and the various proposals, the paper endeavors to break new ground on the age old question of how Paul's theology relates to his ethics by showing how the Phren word group is used by Paul to link the theological and ethical sections together.


Deuteronomic Law in Maccabean Literature
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Francis Borchardt, University of Helsinki

This paper will be an introduction and short summary of my current dissertation work on the influence of Deuteronomic law and legal interpretation on the composition of 1Maccabees. While it has been pointed out in the past that torah/nomos plays a central role in the narrative, little has been done to actually identify how much influence there is, and exactly where in the pentateuch or other biblical literature that legal understanding originates. This paper attempts to provide answers to those problems through careful analysis of both the explicit and implicit interpretations of the law within the context of the narrative surroundings and the interpretations provided by the author. Through this method one can begin to see a heavy Deutronomic influence on the interpretation of the law, which indeed at times seems to be argued over and against rival interpretations. The presence of this sort of influence in a text of the early 1st century BCE which likely has its roots in the Temple scribal circles can help to form a clearer picture of the place and importance of the various sections of the Torah -especially Deuteronomy- at this important time in the history of Judea.


Self-Transformation and Communal Good: Genesis, David, Luke-Acts—and Homer
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Paul Borgman, Gordon College

With Homer as a foil, and with key selections from Genesis, the David story, and Luke-Acts—each considered as coherent and unified dramas—I will demonstrate the relationship between the self-transcending self and communal well-being. The dominant synergy between a self-transcending self and communal well-being indicates the role of such orally-based narrative in the formation and maintaining of cultural values. Abraham must change if Sarah is to bear a child and if blessing—instead of curse—is to come for a foreign people [Abimelech’s]); Joseph must repeatedly “go down” if he is to transcend his early braggadocio and dreams of lording-over toward the blessing of his own family, of Egypt, and of “all the families of the world”; David’s capacities for self-examination and “turn-around”—toward the recovery of communal well-being (three key repetitions, the most conspicuous in 2 Samuel 24 where David is at his worst but best when confronting himself for sin prompted by God). Such a self-transcending self is fundamental in the teachings of Jesus, as represented in Luke-Acts: the counter-intuitive must come to ascendancy if the self is to be “found” and community restored to the in-breaking of God’s idea of good community. By contrast, Homer’s Achilles, Hector, and Odysseus reflect cultural values quite different from such self-transcending selves; the epics promote values and characters characterized by stasis, as suggested by the frequent Homeric epithet. Such fixed selves—the wrathful Achilles, the foresighted Odysseus—have a tenuous or negative impact on their respective communities (the Trojan war in The Iliad; the need for Athena to act unilaterally in bringing ultimate peace, in The Odyssey). I will draw on my published work, including Homeric studies, and two books: Genesis, The Story We Haven’t Heard; and, The Way According to Luke: Hearing the Whole Story of Luke-Acts.


The Orally-Based Rhetoric of Luke-Acts, with a Glance at Homer
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Paul Borgman, Gordon College

Representing a full complement of narrative techniques culled from an oral culture, we find in Luke-Acts a coherent and unified drama of extraordinary genius and persuasiveness. I follow the lead of scholars versed in oral traditions and their rhetorical forms, among them Ong, Gerhardsson, Engnell, A. Lord, Culley, Foley, Niditch, and my own formalist work in Homer, Genesis, and Luke-Acts (books on the latter). Without recognizing Luke’s rhetorical "how," we miss his story's particular "what." I will demonstrate several techniques of repetition in passages from the beginning, middle, and end of both the gospel and Acts, passages suggesting Luke-Acts as an organic whole. (1) Paralleled dramatic scenarios: the contrast between Mary and Zechariah in responding to the angel, responses emerging as a key to the implicit moral vision of Luke’s two-volume story: “Listen to him [Jesus].” (2) Nine principles of the Way, chiastically arranged in the gospel’s central section as a journey to Jerusalem/kingdom (9:51-19:44, with mention of Homer’s very large chiastic structures); I will highlight the ring-composition’s center-point, 9a, “Kingdom” (13:18-19); 9b, “Jerusalem,” 13:31-35, and, between, the sandwiched “Striving To Enter the Kingdom” (13:23-30). (3) The last-words speech of Jesus in Luke 24 with its twin-foci on repentance and resurrection, followed up in Acts by the consistent repetition of the same in the seven speeches by Peter, and the seven by Paul. (4) Tandem speeches before radically diverse audiences—Athenian skeptics, Ephesian believers—representing Paul’s “full” gospel (17:22-31, 20:18-35). (5) Closing out Acts, Paul’s repeated use of the signal-word “kingdom”—a word like others in Acts that function metonymically for the whole of Jesus’ teaching represented in Luke’s gospel. Through patterns of hearing-clues, the plot of this orally-based text circles backward even as it moves forward, as I will demonstrate.


Narrative World and Real World in 1 Peter
Program Unit: Methodological Reassessments of the Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
M. Eugene Boring, Brite Divinity School, Texas Christian University

1 Peter is a genuine letter--not in the sense of authorship, but in that it functions by projecting a narrative world. This world can be identified and charted by listing and sorting the events mentioned and presupposed by the letter. The temporal location of writer and readers can be identified on the projected narrative timeline. How does this narrative world projected by the pseudonymous author correspond to the "real world?"


Burial Customs in Southern Judea in Iron Age II: Some Observations following the Excavations of the Cemetery at Tell Halif
Program Unit: Archaeological Excavations and Discoveries: Illuminating the Biblical World
Oded Borowski, Emory University

Most tombs from the Iron Age II that have been excavated were discovered as a result of construction work and thus their contents were disturbed. Furthermore, many of these tombs had been previously visited by tomb robbers or had suffered from other disturbing activities. While a group of tombs at Tell Halif from this period suffered from the same fate, enough materials were recovered from the tombs to enable the reconstruction of some of the burial customs employed there. This paper will use the tombs and their contents to illustrate what possibly took place at this cemetery during the period of its use.


"The Battle Hymn of the Republic": The Kingdom of God in American Politics
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
David A. Bosworth, Barry University

"The Battle Hymn of the Republic," composed by Julia Ward Howe at the start of the Civil War, draws heavily on apocalyptic language and imagery to present the Union Army as the instrument of God's just punishment of Southern slavery. It had since been applied generally to US military power in wars against various enemies (Nazis, communists, terrorists). The paper will articulate the biblical basis of the hymn and how its use has contributed to Americans' perceptions of our role in the world. For all its use of John's Apocalypse, I will argue that the imperialism fostered by the hymn is itself condemned by Revelation.


The Quotidian of Religious Experience: Aspects of Place and Visual Environment in Redescribing Greco-Roman Antiquity
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Pieter J. J. Botha, University of South Africa, Pretoria

A quick perusal of so-called background studies (in the sense of one- or two-volume overviews) reveals that two areas of the material world of the early Roman empire do not feature in descriptions of “religion”. These two neglected areas, I submit, are Roman art and the Roman house. Mention is made, mostly, of statues, and descriptive information about the layout of houses are frequent, but theoretically informed and explanatory analyses are lacking. In this presentation my aim is to argue that the Roman domus is about more than simply private life. The remains of houses from the Empire are a major resource for invesitgating how people living within the Roman world thought of themselves and how they communicted this self-image to the world. Secondly, as has been often pointed out, in the face of the epochal transformations — both in the structure of society and in the individual’s relation to that structure — that mark the history of the Roman empire, the functions of art changed. My suggestion is to hav e a look at Roman art as both a key to, and reflection of Roman syncretism, and to relate a cultural phenomenon which brought together an extraordinary variety of races, nations, art forms, styles and cults in romanitas. It seems that we still understimate how “secular” space was determined by evocations of the sacred. Taking up these two lines is part of an investigation of the “cultural ecology of early Christianity”. Early Christian texts cannot be seen as “entities” to be attached to “context”. They are configurations of each other — hence the interrelatedness of the activities we call description, interpretation, explanation and understanding.


Stages in the Reception History of Acts during the First Six Centuries C.E.
Program Unit: Book of Acts
François Bovon, Harvard University

*


Introduction to New Consultation, "Rethinking the Concept of 'Bible'"
Program Unit: Rethinking the Concept and Categories of 'Bible' in Antiquity
James E. Bowley, Millsaps College

Many scholars are aware of the serious problems in the nomenclature of 'biblical studies,' and many are interested in exploring and/or suggesting solutions. This presentation will intorduce the impetus and purpose of current and future sessions of this new SBL consultation.


From Greek Thought to Jewish and Christian Scriptural Allegory
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Daniel Boyarin, University of California-Berkeley

In this paper, I propose to work out in a general way some new thinking about continuity, rather than rupture, in the history of allegoresis, in particular I wish to locate allegorical thinking in some persistent themes of Greek thought of various types and argue then that it is not as foreign to rabbinic interpretation as once I would have claimed.


The Greek Psalter in Byzantine Judaism: The Evidence of the Greek-Hebrew Palimpsests in the Taylor-Schechter Genizah Collection
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Cameron Boyd-Taylor, University of Toronto

Materials have come to light, some very recently, indicating that some Jews continued to use the Greek language throughout the Middle Ages, and that, while the Hebrew Bible played a central part in their religious and cultural life, they also knew the Bible in Greek. The objective of the AHRC Greek Bible in Byzantine Judaism project in Cambridge is to make these texts available to scholars, together with the information necessary for an appreciation of their historical background. The textual corpus of the project will likely include palimpsest fragments of the Greek Psalter from the Taylor-Schechter Genizah collection, brought to Cambridge in 1898 from the Ben Ezra Synagogue in Old Cairo. Following a brief introduction to the project itself, I shall discuss the provenance of these Psalter fragments with a view to their significance for the study of Jewish religious culture in the Middle Ages.


"God Is Not in This Classroom" or Reading the Bible in a Secular School
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Christian Brady, Tulane University

Teaching biblical literature in a secular Liberal Arts environment requires allowing the texts to speak for themselves, so that students might hear what the texts have to say (which may not necessarily be what we want to hear). This is easier said than done since we must attempt to leave religious convictions, traditions, and specific agendas behind. At the same time, we must also recognize that we will not always be able to avoid our own historical context and bias. In light of these challenges and through my eight years experience as a Christian teaching courses in a Jewish Studies program at a secular university I have developed methods (and discarded others) for teaching the Hebrew Bible that include reading the texts critically as literary and historical sources while salting the course with Jewish, Christian, Islamic, and other interpretations. The goal is to use the potential handicaps of preconceived ideas and convictions as gateways into the material. God may well be in the classroom and miracles may well occur, but the students know that they have to determine that for themselves.


Mutual Joy: God and the People Rejoice, Zephaniah 3:14–20
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Robin Gallaher Branch, Sterling College

Jerusalem's sentence of destruction has been lifted. An unidentified voice commands her to rejoice and to sing aloud. Like a courtroom scene, announcement is made that her judgment has passed and her enemies are turned away. Her king is in her midst; there is no cause for fear. But this king is unusual. His presence spells peace rather than disaster. Furthermore, this king, God himself, speaks and actively rejoices over his redeemed ones. God's unparalleled joy transfixes the redeemed and heralds a new age. The oppressed, the lame, and the outcast will be restored. Captivity has ended and joy has commenced. This paper looks at the multiple levels and voices of joy in this text.


Is There a Gnostic "Henological" Speculation?
Program Unit: Rethinking Plato's Parmenides and Its Platonic, Gnostic, and Patristic Reception
Johanna Brankaer, Universite Catholique de Louvain

In the (Neo-) Platonic Parmenides reception, the One has acquired a status that transcends even Being. Ultimate source of reality, it is placed so far above it, that it has barely a relation to it (this is obviously an oversimplified view). Whether or not this is a valid interpretation of Plato and Parmenides (cf. e.g. the excellent study by J.-M. Narbonne, 2001), is not directly relevant to our question which is primarily concerned with Gnostic thought. But even though the Gnostics did not necessarily seek to interpret philosophical antecedents, they were confronted with similar questions. In Gnosticism (and especially the more "platonizing" texts), we find a way of exploring answers to the question of the derivation of multiplicity from initial Unity. This Unity does not seem to be described in the "henological" language of the Neo-Platonists (even if it sometimes tends to seem so in English translations), but they seem to stay on a purely "ontological" level, being in that way maybe even closer to Parmenides and Plato than the philosophical "schools" of that period.


Word Groups, Head Terms, and Modifiers in the Pastoral Epistles: Insight for Questions of Style?
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Rick Brannan, Logos Bible Software

OpenText.org have completed a preliminary syntactic analysis of the Greek New Testament. One level of their analysis is the Word Group level. A word group is a group of words that consists of, at minimum, a head term. It also contains any terms that modify the head term and additionally specifies the type of modification as that of definer, qualifier, relator or specifier. Heretofore, stylistic analysis has been largely bound to the word level, tracking criteria such as word usage and morphology. The OpenText.org Word Group analysis allows for stylistic analysis of the corpus at a different level. Does head term and modifier usage offer any insight for comparative studies of the Pastoral Epistles and the generally accepted Paulines? This paper will examine word group usage data for both the accepted Paulines and the Pastoral Epistles, and will offer preliminary comparisons between the results where results may offer insight for questions of style.


Johannine Tragic Dialogue and Comic Sketches
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Jo-Ann A. Brant, Goshen College

The realization has dawned that our silent, isolated readings of the Fourth Gospel, or any other ancient text for that matter, is a categorically different experience than that of those who first received the text as audiences of a performance. I contend that the author of the Gospel borrowed heavily from the conventions of Greek tragedy in his construction of his dialogues to suit the demands of a performance text. I will revisit my work on the use of tragic conventions in the trial scene and the recognition scene in the garden. I will then take my analysis in a new direction by exploring the significance of the construction of the scenes at the cross as discrete tableaux that drew upon conventions that informed the construction of Roman and Hellenistic comedy, in particular mime. However audacious it may seem to suggest that the Johannine crucifixion account could have been influence by early mime -- condemned by the early Church Fathers for its vulgarity -- we must accommodate in our readings the culture of spectacle and performance in which the gospel’s author and first audiences would have been steeped. Given that the event upon which the passion narratives was based was itself a calculated violent spectacle about which refined Roman authors hesitated to write, the gospel writer parodies the Roman theater of cruelty. Comparison with extant, comic performance pieces brings into sharper relief the art of representation of action and elements of resistance to Roman signification in Johannine story telling.


Teaching and Preaching Isaiah 6: A Comparison of Aquinas, Oecolampadius, and Calvin
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
James Brashler, Union Theological Seminary and Presbyterian School of Christian Education

This study will explore the interpretations of Isaiah 6 in the commentaries of Thomas Aquinas, Johannes Oecolampadius, and John Calvin. Focusing on renewed emphasis on the literal and historical sense of scripture as it was variously understood by each of these major interpreters, this presentation will demonstrate that the roots of Reformed hermeneutics developed by Oecolampadius and Calvin are to be found in the high scholasticism of the late middle ages and the humanism of Erasmus of Rotterdam.


Job, Lazarus, and the Juxtaposition of Pain and Hope in the Office of the Dead
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Brennan Breed, Emory University

The Pierpont-Morgan Library holds manuscript 1001, a fabulous late-fifteenth century Book of Hours from the vicinity of Poitiers, France, most famous for its gruesome portrayal of the seven deadly sins. Yet its little known image of Job on the dunghill, juxtaposed with the raising of Lazarus, which illuminates the Office of the Dead is equally striking for its theological and pastoral sensitivity, especially when compared to other images in similar books of Hours. The Job image reflects and participates in unusual interpretive traditions concerning Job’s wife, Job’s friends, and the role of death in the book of Job. The image thus questions many assumptions about the interpretation of the book of Job while it provides a hopeful and comforting message for those grappling with the difficult realities of bereavement. Furthermore, as a representative of the culture of death in the late middle ages, the image is an example of how biblical interpretation can reveal the social and historical context of the interpreter, but its theological and pastoral sensitivity reveals how biblical interpretation can diverge from, and possibly influence, the artists' context, as well.


Dead Man Walking: Job 19:25–27
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Brennan Breed, Emory University

So many interpreters have read Job 19:25-27 with strong presuppositions, whether formed by dogma, or by the prevailing trends in the history of reception, or formed in reaction to these forces, that the text can lose its place in the book of Job, disembodied in its relation to the flow of the poetry and the pace of the action. In the first section of this paper, I wish to address some of the general arguments about (a) what Job desires the outcome of his situation to be, (b) his characterization of God in his speeches, and (c) the idea of “resurrection” in exegesis concerning this text. I will then examine the text itself, in which I argue that Job is envisioning himself metaphorically in Sheol, in which God’s revivifying and reforming power arrives. It is my contention that in 19:25-27, Job is not speaking about his literal resuscitation, but, because his situation is so dire, he is calling upon the language of death and new life to communicate his only possible hope of God’s reversal of character. In other instances, Job conceives of himself metaphorically as already dead, which conveys the sense of helplessness in his seemingly irreversible descent towards death. Because Job is already a “dead man walking,” I claim that Job’s metaphor for his incredible and improbable hope for new life is cast in terms of a metaphorical post-mortem vision and revivification, a common occurrence in Hebrew lament poetry.


Literary Approaches to Genesis: The Last 30 Years
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Athalya Brenner, University of Amsterdam

An overview of the past quarter-century plus of literary studies in Genesis, highlighting the milestones of biblical literary analysis.


Pseudonymity and the Pastoral Epistles: An Evangelical Response to I. Howard Marshall’s “Allonymity” Proposal
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Wayne A. Brindle, Liberty University

Major thesis: The presentation (by I. Howard Marshall) of the authorship of the Pastoral Epistles as "allonymity" is unacceptable from an evangelical perspective. 1. As literature, allonymity derives from pseudonymity, differing only in the degree of ideas carried forward from the background source. Ancient writers saw pseudonymity as an attempt to deceive readers concerning the true authorship of a piece of literature. Orthodox Christianity in the second century strongly objected to it. The Pastoral Epistles emphasize the importance of preserving Christian tradition as truth without distortion. Those who propose allonymity cannot legitimately separate it from the faults of pseudonymity. 2. Every viable scenario for an allonymous composition of the PE assumes an unstated but deliberate deception on the part of the author. If Paul was not the writer, the author gratuitously and unnecessarily set out to deceive his readers concerning numerous historical and personal details. 3. The alleged purpose of allonymous Pastoral Epistles contradicts the actual needs and life situation of Timothy and Titus following Paul's death. At least in the case of Timothy, he did not need a fictitious Pauline commendation in order to gain acceptance by the church at Ephesus, as is clear from the descriptions of Timothy's co-labors with Paul in Acts and 1 Corinthians. [4. The arguments that have been advanced against the genuine Pauline authorship of the PE are faulty. The historical, theological, and ecclesiastical objections to Pauline authorship have been sufficiently answered. The stylistic/linguistic arguments are more complex, but are seriously overemphasized and do not rule out a genuine Pauline authorship.] From an evangelical perspective, arguments in favor of either pseudonymity or allonymity are historically suspect, are based on faulty presuppositions concerning the late first-century church, and fail to adequately explain the details within the Pastoral Epistles.


Introduction: Origins and Operation of the Project
Program Unit:
Laurie Brink, Catholic Theological Union

*


The Initial Columns of the Anonymous Commentary on the Parmenides
Program Unit: Rethinking Plato's Parmenides and Its Platonic, Gnostic, and Patristic Reception
Luc Brisson, National Center for Scientific Research, Paris

The interpretation of _Parmenides_ 137a-141a in the eight first columns of the Anonymous Commentary on Plato's Parmenides.


Agamben’s Pauline Benjamin and Benjaminian Paul
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Brian M. Britt, Virginia Polytech Institute and State University

Giorgio Agamben’s The Time That Remains is more than a commentary on Romans; it also offers commentary on Walter Benjamin’s allusions to Paul. This paper evaluates Agamben’s specific claims about Benjamin’s use of 2 Corinthians 12 in his "Theses on the Philosophy of History." While Agamben is correct that two key words in Benjamin’s text appear in Luther’s translation of Paul, there is reason to doubt the directness of the allusion, since other biblical allusions in the "Theses" do not match Luther’s vocabulary, and the correspondence Agamben claims could be explained in other ways. I propose an alternative, more contextualized way of understanding Benjamin’s biblical allusions that goes beyond traditional Jewish and Christian messianism and avoids strict dependence on Paul. Such a reading reflects Benjamin’s concerns with Christian anti-Jewishness. In the end, Agamben’s Pauline Benjamin may in fact be a kind of Benjaminian Paul; my paper will elaborate this suggestion in light of recent scholarship on Paul.


Bible Literacy, Secularism, and Public Education
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Brian M. Britt, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State Universit

The 2006 publication of a textbook called "The Bible and Its Influence" represents a broad-based effort to encourage teaching about the Bible in American public schools. The carefully-planned effort by the non-profit, non-partisan Bible Literacy Project has the support of prominent SBL-affiliated scholars, public and religious leaders. Democratic politicians in Georgia and Alabama have introduced bills supporting Bible instruction in line with the project’s recommendations, and the book itself promises students and instructors a competitive advantage in Advanced Placement and other standardized tests. Though it trades on the cultural capital of student advancement and the cause of anti-secularism, the textbook has also aroused controversy. Criticisms of the textbook have been leveled by civil libertarians and conservative theologians alike. This paper will discuss beliefs, practices, and knowledge about the Bible and debates on the textbook in the context of broader cultural conflicts over secularism. Informed by theoretical analysis of secularism by Talal Asad and William Connolly, as well as studies of the “secular Bible” by Jacques Berlinerblau and Jonathan Sheehan, I will suggest that this textbook misunderstands the peculiar and sensitive position of the Bible in contemporary American culture. "The Bible and Its Influence" may show that secularist anxieties about Bible instruction are exaggerated, but by avoiding such topics as historical criticism and literal interpretation of the Bible, it offers no resolution to the impasse between secularism and religion.


A Servant Like the Master: A Jewish Christian Hermeneutic for the Practice of the Torah
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
Edwin K. Broadhead, Berea College

There is a strong probability that Jewish Christians defended their faith and practice by citing a saying of Jesus from Mt. 10.24-25: "A disciple is not above the teacher, nor the slave above the master. It is enough for the disciple to be like the teacher, and the slave like the master." Several patristic writers note the use of this saying by the Ebionites. Other writers note the claim to imitate Jesus without citing Mt. 10.24-25. Different patristic writers connect the saying to different Ebionite practices, providing multiple attestation. The criterion of dissimilarity is also applicable, as is the criterion of embarassment. Patristic writers find it difficult or impossible to refute this claim, yet they persist in the effort. This makes it, by all critical standards, highly unlikely that this is a patristic invention. Some Jewish Christians claimed that their practice of circumcision, their observance of Passover, and their obedience to the Law are a conscious imitation of Jesus, and they supported this claim by citing Mt. 10.24-25. This is the most certifiable piece of historical data in all of the patristic representation of Jewish Christianity. This use of Mt. 10.24-25 unveils a central hermeneutical pattern used by Jewish Christians to interpret and practice the Torah. Such insights play a key role in the effort to define Jewish Christianity and to locate it on the religious map of antiquity.


Elijah-Elisha, Proto-Luke, Mark, Matthew, John, Luke-Acts: From Older Narrative to New
Program Unit: Formation of Luke and Acts
Thomas L. Brodie, Dominican Biblical Centre, Limerick

In 1971 Raymond E. Brown proposed that the best literary model for the gospels is to be found in the lives of the prophets, especially the life of Elisha ("Jesus and Elisha," in Perspective 12 [1971] 86-104). This paper integrates recent literary studies, especially concerning ancient methods of reworking texts, and turns Brown's general thesis into a specific literary form that is detailed and verifiable. The developed thesis provides evidence for three proposals: (1) The Elijah-Elisha narrative mirrored Moses, played a key interpretive role within the Hebrew/Septuagintal scriptures, and moved Hebrew narrative from from historiography towards prophetic biography; (2) Later, the Elijah-Elisha narrative provided a precise literary model for an early short version of Luke-Acts, and this short version--which may be called by the old term Proto-Luke--maintained the tendency to move from historiography towards biography; (3) Mark, while using the Elijah-Elisha narrative, especially at the gospel’s beginning, middle, and end, built on Proto-Luke and carried the transition towards biography/bios to a further decisive stage. a stage that provided a model for the other canonical gospels, first Matthew, then John, and finally canonical Luke-Acts.


Slavery: Yes! Same-Sex Love: No! Church Debates over Biblical Teachings
Program Unit: LGBTI/Queer Hermeneutics
Bernadette Brooten, Brandeis University

*


The Middle Name of Walter Benjamin: Tiling Jennings / Covering Derrida / Fleecing Paul
Program Unit: Semiotics and Exegesis
Virgil Brower, Northwestern University

Playing on the phonemes of Benjamin's middle name, "Schönflies," this paper addresses the projects of those that address his first name (Derrida) and his last (Jennings). The Schönflies serves as an oblique invitation to engage Jennings' text, Reading Derrida / Thinking Paul. The 'beautiful tile' [Schön Fliese] embodied by this text is but a singularity in a mosaic; one gesture in a montage of Jennings’ works. Jennings all but ignores the earlier texts of Derrida in this latest study. By investigating some of Jennings' earlier works one can glimpse the importance of earlier Derridean motifs. The use (or abuse) of Derrida in these earlier writings will be compared with Jennings' use of them while thinking Paul. The 'grand covering' [Schön Vlies] in Jennings text is that at no point does it address the shortcomings of Derrida's understanding of Paul. The one that 'rightly passes for an atheist' does not share a Pauline messianism-with-messianism. The Derridean Paul is always a betrayed Paul. There is a 'great swindle' [Schön Vlies] of Paul's motifs in Jennings' text. It is always already a certain Paul. Mention is made of the Pauline ideas that are left behind by this 'thief in the night' because of their abrasiveness. "Paul" serves as what Freud calls a "nodal point" for thinkers after the disenchantment of the world; especially the new postmodern cult of Paul (Agamben, Badiou, Zizek, & Jennings). Jennings' text specifically helps clarify how these diverse caricatures of Paul---as the ambassador of cosmopolitanism and universality---are less universal than they appear. They are (as Rudolf Bultmann would remind us) attempts to increase (the number) of the "chosen" people. An error of enumeration into which Derrida does not seem to fall.


Image-Editing Techniques for Recovering Manuscript Texts.
Program Unit:
Timothy Brown, Franconia, NH

Ancient manuscripts often contain text which has been defaced by use or time. Certain image-editing techniques have proven to be helpful in recovering this text. I will perform a live demonstration of the image-editing techniques J. Bruce Prior and I have used to determine the text our Washington manuscript transcriptions. This step-by-step demonstration of techniques we call reverse-image overlay and splice overlay will re-create the steps we took to recover the text of some specific problem passages in the Freer Gospels and the Washington Manuscript of Deuteronomy-Joshua. Since the same techniques can be applied to images of any ancient manuscript, this presentation will be of special interest to anyone in the field of textual criticism.


"Deep Calls to Deep": Retrieving the Liturgical Voice of the Many Waters
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
William P. Brown, Columbia Theological Seminary

Many studies, including a paper given last year in this consultation, have attempted to demarcate the varied roles, both positive and negative, that water assumes in the Hebrew Scriptures, particularly in the Psalms. This paper examines Psalm 42 and argues that despite a strong consensus to the contrary the discourse of the deep in v. 8 is not deemed inimical to either God or the psalmist but rather considered liturgical and instructive.


Confessions of a Gender Confused Prophet
Program Unit: Gender, Sexuality, and the Bible
Mark Brummitt, Partnership for Theological Education, Manchester

Jeremiah’s poems of lament have long been sites of scholarly dispute. But whether they be thought outpourings of a soul overwhelmed by his calling or imports of conventional liturgical songs, in the context of the text they perform an authorial voice and in so doing construct the prophetic subject. That the author is product rather than source of the writings is in some ways a contention of the book: constituted as prophet by the incoming divine word (ch. 1), later sacrificing sexuality for textuality, biological lineage for a prophetic heritage (ch. 16), Jeremiah is a creature composed entirely of text—a scroll of human parchment. In this paper, I begin turning the pages of the prophet alongside those of the writings of Michel Foucault and Judith Butler. Encouraging each to comment upon the others, I will articulate something of the text life of this Writing Prophet. Starting with the so-called ‘confessions’, and perhaps moving beyond, I shall take note of the forces which threaten to tear the text in two—forces set in motion by the division of loyalties demanded of a mediator position between the people and Yhwh; forces which—in the schema of prophetic metaphors—are inevitably gendered; and forces which result in the prophet feeling like he has been had (ch. 20). Warned not to break down lest he himself be broken (ch. 1), the demand that he faithfully fulfil his task nevertheless seems to threaten an inevitable breaching of his corpus.


A Stoic Understanding of Pneuma in the Gospel of John
Program Unit: Hellenistic Moral Philosophy and Early Christianity
Gitte Buch-Hansen, University of Copenhagen

In Johannine scholarship the event of Jesus’ anabasis to the father (20:17) is often dissolved into his ‘being lifted up’ (3:14; 12:32f: hypsôthênai) and dying on the cross. This understanding leaves chapter 20 as an odd appendix that scholars nevertheless justify by its ecclesiological focus on post-Easter faith. Instead, this paper examines Jesus’ anabasis in chapter 20 as an event in its own narrative right and concludes that is of major Christological importance. The thesis of the paper is twofold: First, it is argued that the anabasis consists of a transformation in which the whole person of the crucified and risen Jesus is transposed to and absorbed into the pneûma that constitutes the body (1:18: kolpos) of the father (4:24: pneûma ho theos). As transformed Jesus becomes one with the father and is accordingly designated God (1:18; 20:28). Thus understood the anabasis is the precondition of Jesus’ – and the father’s – eternal indwelling in believers. Second, it is claimed that Stoic physics and ethics constitute a proper analogy for the Fourth Gospel’s view of world and worship. Accordingly, the paper has two parts: In the first part I focus on an analysis of chapter 20 that shows how categories of space and gender are used as narrative indicators of the pneumatic transformation involved in the anabasis. In light of this analysis, a proposal for a Johannine cosmology is given that discusses the relation of God, cosmos, and human beings. Finally, Johannine concepts such as “kingdom of God” (3:3, 5), “worshipping in spirit and truth” (4:23), “doing God’s works” (3:21; 6:28f) and the new commandment of love (13:34; 15:12) are placed within this world view. In the second part I focus on the parallels between Johannine worship ‘in spirit and truth’ and Seneca’s epistle XLI: On the God within us.


"Draw Me After You” (Canticles 1:3) in Late Medieval Visual Art
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Christina Bucher, Elizabethtown College

This paper explores the imagery that lies behind a 15th-century colored woodcut that can be found in the Rosenwald Collection of the National Gallery of Art in Washington, DC. In the woodcut, Jesus stands bound to both his cross and the column of his flagellation. His body drips with blood. Opposite stands a tonsured male holding a large heart in his two hands. The male is naked except for a loincloth. Between the two figures stands a small, horned and hoofed creature. In one banderole are the words “O herr das will ich • das / beger ich darumbe / so soltu ziehe mich” (“O Lord, this I want, I desire it, for this reason thus should you pull me” ). The request “thus should you pull me” is visually imaged by a rope tied around the man’s waist, the other end of which is held by Jesus. It is a direct verbal and visual allusion to Song of Songs 1:3: “Draw me after you.” The heart held in the hands and the rope that binds the faithful to Christ are motifs that can be found in visual images of romantic love as well as images of spiritual love. This paper will explore both the allegorical interpretation of the Song of Songs in late medieval mystical literature and the visual imagery of the period, specifically that of the heart wounded by love and the rope that binds the faithful to Christ, in order to illumine the context of this woodcut.


The Angelomorphic Spirit in Early Christianity: Aphrahat the Persian Sage
Program Unit: Christian Late Antiquity and Its Reception
Bogdan Bucur, Marquette University

The title of this presentatin is a deliberate allusion to John R. Levison's seminal article entitled “The Angelic Spirit in Early Judaism,” which documented the widespread use, in pre- and post-exilic Judaism, of the term “spirit” as a designation of angelic presence. In the conclusion of his article, Levison challenged the scholarly community to investigate the intersection of angelology and Pneumatology in early Christian literature. Recent research has pointed out the existence of angelomorphic Pneumatology in the book of Revelation, the Shepherd of Hermas, and some of Clement of Alexandria's writings. The first part of this presentation will analyze certain passages instantiating an angelomorphic Pneumatology in the Demonstrations of Aphrahat the Persian Sage. Aphrahat’s statements about the Holy Spirit – severely criticized in later centuries as “unsound” – are extremely valuable for scholars interested in patristic Pneumatology: this author appears almost totally traditional in all that he says, and had as good as no contact with earlier writings of the Greek patristic writers (O. de Urbina, R. Murray, W. L. Petersen, A. Golitzin). Consequently, Aphrahat’s Pneumatology offers privileged insight into received (Syriac) traditions on this subject. Nevertheless, his statements about the Holy Spirit and, more importantly, the exegesis of specific Scriptural texts to support these assertions, also occur in the Shepherd of Hermas and in Clement of Alexandria. The second part of the presentation will, therefore, be dedicated to a presentation of these striking parallels, and propose a hypothesis on the larger tradition of angelomorphic Pneumatology in the early patristic era.


The Hymnographic Exegesis of Theophanies in the Christian East: Re-written Bible?
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Bogdan Bucur, Marquette University

The interpretation of Biblical theophanies holds an important place in the polemical and catechetical articulation of early Christianity's religious claims. While considerable attention has been given to the exegesis of theophanies in the New Testament and other early Christian (especially pre-Nicene) writings, the use of theophanies in Christian hymns has received far less attention. This is quite unfortunate, because by the very nature of its performative character, hymnographic material has enjoyed a circulation and reception superior to that of any single patristic writing. This paper will take into consideration Byzantine festal hymns of a distinct type, recognized as such in scholarship, whose roots stretch back to the second-century homily "On Pascha," by Melito of Sardes. The first part of my paper will discuss the hymnographic exegesis of specific Biblical theophanies (e.g., God's manifestation to Abraham, Jacob, Moses, Isaiah, Ezekiel, etc). The second part will be looking for a way of "categorizing" this type of exegesis. The Biblical interpretation present in these hymns is difficult to frame within the categories commonly used to describe patristic exegesis. As far as I can see at this point, possibly the closest parallels can be drawn to the category "rewritten Bible," coined by Vermes in 1961 and widely utilized since then to designate biblical interpretation occuring in Rabbinic midrash, the Palestinian Targum, or OT Pseudepigrapha such as the Book of the Watchers, the Book of Jubilees, or the Genesis Apocryphon.


University Bible Dictionary: A Free Collaborative Online Project
Program Unit: Computer Assisted Research
Tim Bulkeley, University of Auckland

The UBD aims to provide a Bible Dictionary freely available online prepared by scholars and up to date with current trends in biblical studies. The online format will allow continually updated bibliography, and permit greater participation by scholars outside North America and Europe. During 2006 a sample of approximately 100 articles is being placed online, to demonstrate both the concept and the need for such a resource. This paper will both describe the aims and progress of the project and demonstrate its possibilities.


The Human on the Throne of the Kabod: Ezekiel the Tragedian’s Throne Vision and Theomorphic Ideologies in Second Temple Judaism
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Silviu N. Bunta, Marquette University

This presentation proposes a close reading and analysis of the throne vision in Ezekiel the Tragedian’s Exagoge. Commonly the throne vision of Ezekiel the Tragedian has been read in the scholarship sympathetic to its connections to Ezekiel 1 from the perspective of the much later Hekhalot literature. This paper, while not oblivious to the evident connections (albeit indirect) of the text to these much later developments, is based on the observation that the sources that attest to interests in the vision of Ezekiel 1 in the Second Temple period reflect complex, distinct, and often conflicting ideologies. It consequently proposes a diachronic reading of the text within the context of previous and ongoing ideological developments. An analysis of earlier texts evinces continuing speculations about the theomorphic and iconic value of humanity. Within these speculations privileges of ancient Near Eastern monarchy have been democratized and ascribed to an idealized humanity in the exilic and Second Temple period. In its new status, idealized humanity was envisioned as bearing the form and representing the venerability of the divine. It is this particular association that transpires through the imagery of the throne vision of Ezekiel the Tragedian. The text also reflects an ideology related to subsequent speculations about Adam. Several motifs present in Ezekiel the Tragedian’s scene resurface in the later literature dedicated to the protoplast, such as the theomorphism of exalted humanity, its iconic value, and its veneration by astral beings/angels. The latter element of this theomorphic paradigm best attests to the complexity of Second Temple kabod speculations, to the divergence of this paradigm from and its polemics with repeated identifications of divine mediators as angelic beings.


"Am I My Brother's Keeper?" James "the Lord's Brother" as a Source of Authority in Early Christianity
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Matthew Burgess, Yale Divinity School

The world of early Christianity is a shadowy realm, filled with historical, cultural, and theological pitfalls that threaten all who attempt to unlock its secrets. One of its most enigmatic residents is James, commonly known as "James the Lord's brother" or "James the brother of Jesus" following the description provided in the Letter to the Galatians. Although this figure receives scant treatment in the gospels' descriptions of Jesus' ministry--so scant, in fact, that there has been an extended debate concerning the nature of his familial ties to Jesus--he bursts onto the scene in the latter portion of the New Testament, as a leader of the community in Jerusalem, a contemporary (and possibly an opponent) of Paul, and the author (real or imagined) of a letter that was ultimately adopted into the Christian canon of scripture. He is also associated with other early Christian literature, particularly the texts which scholars frequently characterize as "Jewish Christian" in nature. This paper will ask whether these and other contemporary sources are sufficient to identify James as a source of legitimate authority for some early Christian communities--and if so, what their choice of this particular source might reveal.


Handling the Diversity of Ethical Material within the New Testament
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Richard A. Burridge, King's College

The nature and the diversity of ethical material contained within the NT is often seen as a problem or a challenge to those interpreters who wish to use it in ethical debate today. Some specific concerns dealt with it in scripture are contingent upon the writers’ own day, such as carrying a legionary’s pack (Matt 5:41) or meat offered to idols (1 Cor 8; 10:18-33), while today’s ethical issues, such as nuclear war or embryo research do not feature at all. Furthermore the plurality of 27 books written by different authors in different genres to different audiences leads to variation or even contradiction on some issues. For those who want a “biblical ethic” or “NT witness,” theological interpretation needs to find a unity of scripture. Richard Hays sought such a synthesis through his “focal images” of cross, community, and new creation in his The Moral Vision of the New Testament (1996). This paper will examine some ways of bringing the “two horizons” of the text and contemporary ethical debate together, distinguishing the various modes, methods and genres of ethical material in the NT. It will also outline a possible method for handling such diverse ethical material within the Christian community, using the use of the Bible under apartheid in South Africa as an example.


Sin, Disease, and Spirit-Possession in Romans 7
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Brett David Burrowes, Siena College

Past scholarship on Romans 7 has often presupposed an Augustinian conception of sin as a corruption of human nature, despite the fact that Paul appears to distinguish indwelling “sin” from himself; “It is no longer I who do the sin, but the sin dwelling in me” (Rom 7:17, 20). In a different vein, a recent paper at SBL compared Paul’s understanding of sin to Plato’s conception of an irrational element in the soul. But Paul’s language is in fact far closer to the language of spirit-possession than to either Augustine’s or Plato’s language. If sin (and the passions to which sin gives rise) are conceived as a kind of disease of the body ( a common assumption in Hellenistic moral philosophy), it is possible to analyze the passage in terms of two common etiologies of disease present in that era. Disease (or the passions) could be the result of an invasive outside power (a spirit, daemon, or deity), or, on the other hand, the result of some imbalance in the human body. Often, though not exclusively, these differing etiologies were associated with different social classes, with the imbalance etiologies predominant in the philosophical elite. Paul’s language concerning sin and the resultant passions reflects a invasion etiology and therefore sin should be understood as an invasive spirit of slavery (8:15) rather than as an imbalance in human nature. Moreover, this conception of sin is rooted in Paul’s religious experience, as autos ego in 7:25 demonstrates, despite the largely rhetorical nature of Romans 7:14-25.


Greek Body Parts
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Randall Buth, Hebrew University of Jerusalem

Trying to internalize a language requires a person to be able to describe one’s immediate environment, including all of the common activities involving the body. However, if a student opens the GreekNT or Louw-Nida’s semantic domains, one immediately perceives accidental holes. Filling those holes and evaluating the resulting domains presents challenges. We need to be able to ‘wipe a runny nose’. We need to know which words are more generic or more specialized and which words are more common register or more formal. Fortunately, where biblical and/or mishnaic Hebrew may be missing a word, Hellenistic Greek attestations often provide more than one word. And yes, we need to know some of “ those” words. The challenge brings its own rewards. Widely-ranging texts become more accessible. Some of these texts include ancient humor with a glimpse into ancient world views, and sometimes a biblical text takes on a new perspective. Body parts and actions also provide a concrete basis for many metaphorical extensions in the language and a few euphemisms. Body parts and their actions provide an easy entrance into an immersion classroom. Half of the presentation will include skits and pictures that illustrate how teaching can take place, in the language. There is room for humor while a student (and teacher!) moves along a path toward internalization. We do many different things with our body parts so that there is no lack of practice with verbs or noun-cases. For one example among several in the presentation: coughing, spitting, sucking, talking, kissing, eating, bad breath, and yelling show how one little word STOMA can be a practical springboard into this ancient language. These are words that every little kid would know without second thought. It is not a bad idea if they are our words, too.


The Literacy Fetish in West Semitic Epigraphy
Program Unit: Archaeological Excavations and Discoveries: Illuminating the Biblical World
Ryan Byrne, Rhodes College

*


Slaughter, Fratricide, and Sacrilege: Cain and Abel Traditions in 1 John
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
John Byron, Ashland Theological Seminary

In 1 John 3:11-18 Cain symbolizes the antithesis of brotherly love. Scholars agree that as the first murderer Cain represents a compelling illustration of what it means to hate one’s brother. The figure of Cain stands in direct contrast to Christ. Cain took another’s life; Christ laid down his life for others. But an examination of how Cain was portrayed in contemporaneous Jewish literature suggests that there may be more to the illustration than has previously been appreciated. The choice of terminology used to describe the slaughter of Abel in 1 John retains the ritual overtones that pervade the original story in Genesis 4. While this terminology can communicate a violent type of death, it is more often used to describe a murder that is somehow linked to a ritual act or suggestive overtones. This slaughter language could also be used to describe the act of fratricide. Despite the fact that Cain is portrayed as a “murderer” in 1 John, some interpreters of the Genesis story preferred to identify him more specifically as the “fratricide”. In Jewish literature, fratricide was sometimes considered to be a more heinous crime than homicide and could be regarded as a form of sacrilege. Such an assessment of Cain is reflected in Philo of Alexandria. This paper will demonstrate that the description of Cain in 1 John reflects the common conviction among authors like Philo, Josephus and the Sybil that fratricide was an act of sacrilege. The ritual overtones in the passage help to emphasize the contrast with Christ. By linking those who “hate their brothers” with Cain, the author of 1 John was accusing them of an act that stood in contrast to the self-sacrificial act of Christ. Hatred of others meant they were guilty of communal fratricide, which is a sacrilege.


The Hands are the Hands of Jeremiah, but the Voice Sounds Christian to Me: Form Criticism and Ideology in "Call Narratives"
Program Unit: New Historicism and the Hebrew Bible
Mary Chilton Callaway, Fordham University

The term “call of the prophet” is so established in biblical scholarship that it appears in the notes of most annotated study bibles. Yet no Hebrew equivalent of the term call occurs in any of the passages so designated. A clear Greek equivalent does occur, however, more than a dozen times in various verbal forms in the New Testament, most notably in Paul’s allusion to Jeremiah 1:5 in Galatians 1:15. This paper traces the origins of the term “call” as a historical-critical designation from the early modern period to the end of the nineteenth century It also considers the implications of the call vocabulary that has been inscribed into the biblical text for scholars and laypeople alike. John Calvin’s commentary on Jeremiah (1559) may have been the first to apply the term call to Jeremiah 1. By replacing the priestly “sanctified” with his own word “called” Calvin anachronistically read his theology of predestination into the Hebrew text. Likewise, when Bernhard Duhm named the genre “Berufung,” using a noun form of the German verb Luther consistently used to translate kalew in the New Testament, he read his theology of discipleship into the Hebrew prophetic texts. Protestant theology had long favored the prophetic literature as the high water mark of Israelite theology. Because Duhm’s theology was presented in the context of the discovery of a new Gattung from ancient Israel, it added a “scientific” base to the developing Christian theologies of prophecy. Like Paul Ricouer’s “dead metaphor,” the term call is generally accepted now as representative of an ancient literary form. In fact it is a construction by theologians of the modern era that have read Christian theology of discipleship as well as assumptions about the self that are a product of modernity into the Hebrew text.


American Idol: The Material Bible as Bearer of Cultural Values
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Mary Chilton Callaway, Fordham University

The role of the biblical narrative in American history and in the shaping of the ‘American character’ is well documented. A related but less apparent phenomenon is the significant influence that the material book, “Holy Bible,” has had on this history. This paper will present three examples showing that the physical Bible as embodiment of divine approbation has played a role in the story of the formation and evolution of American identity. The first example is the eighteenth century law that required the presence of a Bible whenever an oath was sworn as part of testimony in civil procedures. This curious custom made the symbol of Protestant Christianity a central player in the proceedings of the American judicial system. The second, almost a century later, is the role that pictures of the Bible had in political cartoons, especially those of Thomas Nash, which fanned the flames of the anti-immigration riots of the 1840’s. The Bible had become part of a construction of American identity that excluded immigrant Irish Catholics, and even a drawing of a Bible fanned the flames of xenophobia. Finally, the production of large and elaborately bound Family Bibles signified the accommodation of Protestant spirituality to the possibility of comfortable wealth. Intended for display in the parlor, they signaled both piety and prosperity to all who entered. The blank pages bound in for family records allowed people literally to write themselves Bible. Just as the Bible in the courtroom merged an American ideal of justice with the divine law, the family Bible in the parlor merged a nineteenth century American ideal of the prosperous family with the story of the people of God. Taken together, these examples suggest the influence of the material Bible on American self-understanding; they also highlight tensions and contradictions in our national identity.


The Repentant Magdalene in the Work of Harriet Beecher Stowe
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Nancy Calvert-Koyzis, McMaster University

Harriet Beecher Stowe, known best for Uncle Tom's Cabin (1852), exemplifies the strong revival of interest in Mary Magdalene in the nineteench century through her books Women in Sacred History (1873) and Footsteps of the Master (1877). In both works Stowe characterizes Mary Magdalene as the repentant "sinner" from Luke 7:36-50. In this paper I will show how Stowe is characteristic of her era in this portrayal of the Magdalene and how she compares with other female writers of the time.


The Development of Pauline Traditions: ‘Adiaphorization’ in 1 Corinthians and Ephesians
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
William S. Campbell, University of Wales

Paul’s thinking concerning the adiaphorization of all things in Christ as in e.g 1Cor.7 has proved to be a focus of diverse interpretations as commentators such as e.g Anthony Thiselton clearly demonstrate. Some clarification is available from similar approaches to Paul in Stoic thinking, as recently noted by Will Deeming in his chapter in Paul in the Greco-Roman World. However, it would appear that Stoic thinking cannot fully account for Paul’s statements about remaining in the ‘calling’ in which one was situated at the point of call. There is also additional evidence that Paul’s differentiated thinking on the question of identity in Christ proved difficult even for close disciples such as the author of Ephesians. Though it is clear that this author shared many aspects of Paul’s thought on identity such as e.g the significance of the Jewish roots of the faith (as emphasized recently by Yee in his SNTS monograph), it is also evident that Ephesians does not simply repeat or replicate Paul’s thinking on adiaphorization in relation e.g to ethnic identity. In Ephesians, specially in ch. 2:11-22, the author developed a distinctive understanding of identity in Christ. It seems that Paul’s ‘relativization’ of circumcision and uncircumcision has always proved difficult to understand and practice so that the Pauline school soon interpreted this is a direction that assisted gentile identity at the expense of Jewish identity in Christ.


John of La Rochelle and "Divisio Textus"
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Aaron Canty, Notre Dame Seminary, Graduate School of Theology

As the teaching of Scripture shifted from monasteries to university classrooms in the late twelfth and early thirteenth centuries, several changes occurred which affected not only the content of exegetical works, but also the method of interpreting Scripture. Beryl Smalley was one of the first to point out the increased use of the literal sense in the thirteenth century as compared to the more spiritual readings of Scripture in the twelfth century. This appraisal has been qualified somewhat since then, but it served to make scholars aware of the changes in biblical commentaries in the High Middle Ages. One difference which has received little attention thus far is the use of the divisio textus, or the practice of dividing the text which arose with the advent of scholastic theology. It is a given that this method was used by Thomas Aquinas and others during this period, but there has been little interest in tracing its development. If one compares, however, the biblical commentaries of Aquinas and Bonaventure with those of their older peers, such as Hugh of St. Cher and Alexander of Hales, one notices that there is substantial difference between how the early Franciscan and Dominican theologians divided the biblical text and how their more famous students did it. The paper I am proposing to give will identify a key figure in this methodological transformation, namely John of La Rochelle. This Franciscan theologian taught at the University of Paris with Alexander of Hales and aided the latter in his theological projects. John’s writings, most of which remain unedited, show that he contributed greatly to the use of a more sophisticated kind of divisio textus than his predecessors had employed. Thus, the origins of the type of divisio textus used by Bonaventure and Aquinas can be traced to the work of this Franciscan author.


Qumran through (Real) Time: A Virtual Reconstruction of the Archaeology of Qumran
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Robert R. Cargill, University of California-Los Angeles

This paper will introduce the latest technology in three-dimensional virtual reality modeling research, and detail its application to the reconstruction of the settlement at Khirbet Qumran. It takes into account all theories regarding the history of Qumran, and proposes a theory of occupation for the settlement there based upon the archaeological remains. In short, this paper will argue that the main building at Qumran was originally established as a Hasmonean fortress. It was later abandoned by the soldiers and occupied by a sect of Sadducean dissidents, who broke away from the Temple in the mid second-century BCE to form their own priestly community. They brought with them a corpus of scrolls from Jerusalem and continued to produce their own. Over the next two centuries, their beliefs evolved and they developed their own distinct set of beliefs and disciplines. While they maintained among themselves that they were priestly Sadducees, others may have begun to distinguish them from the Jerusalem Sadducees, and call them by other names, including Essenes.


Luke’s Panel Technique for His “Orderly” Narration
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Stephen C. Carlson, Fairfax, VA

Luke’s prologue promises the reader that his account will be “orderly” (1:3), but Luke’s narrative hardly appears so to many modern scholars. For example, Luke mentions the imprisonment of John the Baptist (3:19-20) just before narrating the baptism of Jesus in the passive voice (vv. 21-22). As another example, Luke tells of Mary’s return home some nine months into Elizabeth’s pregnancy (1:56), just before he recounts John’s birth (1:57), leading commentators to calculate a difficult, ten-month pregnancy for Elizabeth or an equally difficult reckoning in lunar months. Fifty years ago, Robert W. Funk in his study of chronology in Acts, “The Enigma of the Famine Visit,” JBL 75 (1956): 130-136, discovered that Luke employs a panel technique, in which “Luke develops the narrative in block . . . preferring on the whole to complete a panel once has begun” (134). “This tendency to block out his material turns up,” Funk argued, “in the way he treats his characters. He is concerned as a rule to introduce his heroes and complete his account of each before moving on” (134). Accordingly, Luke’s chronology is partially ordered—although events within a panel may be chronologically ordered, events between different panels need not be. Thus, Luke relates John’s imprisonment before Jesus’s anonymous baptism to complete a John panel (3:1-20) before moving on to a new Jesus panel (3:21ff.) for literary reasons, not out of embarrassment. Similarly, Luke narrates Mary’s return to Nazareth in 1:56 to wrap up a panel on Jesus’s conception (1:26-56) before commencing a panel for John’s birth (1:57-80), without implying John’s birth occurred later in a ten-month pregnancy.


The Nineteenth Century Exemplar of “Archaic Mark” (MS 2427)
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Stephen C. Carlson, Fairfax, VA

Gregory-Aland no. 2427 is an unprovenanced, illuminated manuscript of the Gospel of Mark, written in what appears to be a medieval hand. Its illuminations have been found to contain a modern pigment, but that finding does not settle the question of its curious text, which is closer to Codex Vaticanus (B) than to any other manuscript. Ever since Westcott and Hort (1881), B has been considered one of the most important manuscripts of the New Testament, so 2427’s closeness to B has attracted the attention of textual critics. However, Westcott and Hort were not the first to base a critical text largely on B. Some twenty years earlier, Philipp Buttmann (1860) published a recension of the Greek New Testament based on Cardinal Mai’s edition of B (1857, 1859). In the Gospel of Mark, Buttmann’s text departs from B at about 90 variation units, with which 2474 agrees more than 80 times, except where 2427 has a singular reading. Significantly, 2427’s support for Buttmann’s departures include his mistakes that otherwise lack manuscript attestation. Even more significantly, 2427 contains scribal errors occasioned by the unique page layout of the 1860 Buttmann edition. This evidence shows that the exemplar of MS 2427 is the 1860 Buttmann edition of the New Testament or its stereotypic reprints.


Proverbs and Ancient Near Eastern Wisdom Discourse
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Eugene E. Carpenter, Bethel College

This paper examines on various levels several pieces of Mesopotamian and Hittite wisdom texts from a comparative/contrastive contextual perspective. The goal is to discover and demonstrate some key sapiential topics and issues, and the literary (poetics) strategies and argumentative devices used by these texts. And, finally, the paper seeks to bring the results of this study into conversation with selected pieces of biblical wisdom literature in several ways


Method in Dating Biblical Texts: The Case of “Solomonic” Literature
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
David McLain Carr, Union Theological Seminary

The “Solomonic” books, Proverbs, Ecclesiastes and the Song of Songs, are a useful case study for the use of different criteria for dating Biblical texts. Most scholars in the recent past have dated large portions of this literature -- e.g. Proverbs 1-9, Ecclesiastes and Song of Songs -- to the Persian or Hellenistic periods on the basis of linguistic and other criteria. This paper proposes three types of non-linguistic criteria to be considered in dating such Biblical texts: similarity to well documented examples of oral-written educational literature outside Israel, dissimilarity from major themes and topics at the center of later Israelite oral-written literature, various sorts of potential historical reference within each book, and relations of genetic dependence between texts in the “Solomonic” books and texts in other, datable Biblical texts. With regard to the latter criterion, the paper outlines criteria for both a) establishing the likelihood of genetic dependence of one text on another; and b) establishing a likely direction of dependence (if this can be established). Both broader criteria for dating and the specific criteria for analyzing intertextual genetic dependence are illustrated with cases from books attributed to Solomon, especially the Song of Songs. Preliminary analysis using these criteria suggests a much earlier dating for the Song of Songs and other “Solomonic” books than is typical of past discussions of the historical placement of these books.


Erasmus’s Readings of Romans 3, 4, and 5 as Rhetoric and Theology
Program Unit: Romans through History and Cultures
Laurel Carrington, Saint Olaf College

During his lifetime, Desiderius Erasmus (1469-1536) was noted for his elegant Latin, his expansive learning, and his mastery of Greek. He was also the proponent of a religious reform program based primarily on Scripture, stressing inner piety over outward ceremonies. Finally, he was famous as a biblical scholar, producing a series of editions of the New Testament in which he included an authoritative rendering of the Greek text, his own Latin translation, and an extensive set of annotations, which expanded from one edition to the next in response to critics. In addition, he published a set of paraphrases of the New Testament, aimed not so much at scholars as at educated readers. There were several principles on which Erasmus based his New Testament scholarship. He believed that the text itself must be as accurate as possible, and to this end he applied the skills of philology and textual criticism in selecting and comparing the best Greek manuscripts he could find. Throughout his undertaking he saw himself as being in continuous dialogue with other interpreters, primarily the Fathers. Most of all he saw the Bible as a work of rhetoric, a revelation couched in language that bridges heaven and earth. This paper will examine Erasmus’s hermeneutic and method through his readings of Romans 3, 4, and 5, in the context of Luther’s challenge to the doctrine, practices, and governance of the Roman church. Erasmus published his first edition of the New Testament in 1516 and his Romans paraphrase in 1517. Subsequent editions of the New Testament appeared in 1519, 1522, 1527, and 1535. In 1524, Erasmus directly attacked Luther in his De libero arbitrio, marshalling arguments from Scripture to support freedom of the will. These texts will be the basis for our discussion.


The Bible, the Church, and Human Rights in Contemporary Societies: Rdeflections from Latin American and Hispanic Experience
Program Unit:
M. Danny Carroll R., Denver Seminary

*


Yahwisms and Temples in Persion Period Yehud: Socioeconomic and Sociocultural Contexts
Program Unit: Social-Scientific Studies of the Second Temple Period
Charles E. Carter, Seton Hall University

*


John's Gospel and the Imperial Cult
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
Warren Carter, Saint Paul School of Theology

This paper notes the essential neglect of this question in previous scholarship, examines a few previous discussions, and frames further examination of the matter.


The Beauty of the Bloody God: The Divine Warrior in Prophetic Literature
Program Unit: Prophetic Texts and Their Ancient Contexts
Corrine Carvalho, University of Saint Thomas

This paper will examine prophetic texts that exalt God's portrayal as a warrior. This study will resist reading strategies that distance the reader from these violent images. Rather than view these texts as solely the product of a distant past that must be repudiated, this anthropological analysis starts from the universal popularity of violent images both in the modern and ancient worlds. The paper will attempt to apply a theory of aesthetics to the analysis of divine violence in the Bible. What is the attraction of violent images? In what ways are prophetic books like Nahum "beautiful"? How is the assignment of uncontrolled violence to goddesses such as Anat and Ishtar an expression of the attractive nature of violence? How does this approach help us read parts of the biblical prophets more empathetically?


Exhausted, Docile, Passive but Strong: The Disablement and Repair of the Joban Body in the Testament of Job
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
T. Scott Cason, Florida State University

The paper considers how cultural understandings of masculinity come to bear on literary depictions of the Joban disabled body in the Testament of Job. In looking at the figure of Job through the lens of disability, the project joins a growing body of literature concerned with the disabled male body. The aims of this paper are two-fold. First, the study pushes Mitchell and Snyder’s argument in Narrative Prosthesis that the disabled body often receives some form of “repair” by a story’s denouement, to inquire whether fragmented conceptions of gender brought about by the onset of disability also find repair in narrative. Job’s gender undergoes several transformations throughout the narrative based on the physical state of his body. First, Job as the “king of Egypt” is paradigmatic of the Hellenistic king who more than fulfills his masculine duties. The disablement and deformity of Job’s body renders his identity as a male ambiguous however. Job’s body becomes both docile and passive, leaving him unable to perform the physical tasks that Hellenistic society associated with masculinity. Yet, the text does not feminized Job. Rather, the Testament reframes the masculinity of Job to exhibit inner fortitude, corresponding to the masculine ideals of the Platonic philosophers. With the Lord’s command that Job “gird his loins like a man,” the narrative interweaves Job’s bodily restoration with his identification of himself as a man (T.Job 46:7-8). Job is not only cured of his diseased body, but it returns to a state indicative of the stereotypical masculine ideal (T. Job 52:1-2). Second, at the level of characterization and plot, the study asks how the Testament negotiates the gender of Job as a disabled male and how his disability functions within the scope of the overall narrative.


Delusions of Theocracy in Persian Period Yehud
Program Unit: Social-Scientific Studies of the Second Temple Period
Jeremiah Cataldo, Drew University

The scattered variety of proposals for government and governing structures in Yehud during the Persian period obscures any progress toward a more profound understanding of the social and political character of the province. What to this point has received the greatest consensus among these varying proposals is a belief that the Jerusalem priesthood enjoyed a prominent level of authority—a belief lending itself to proposals of theocratic structures. It is a belief with a significant tradition that is based upon the presumed accurate portrayal—i.e., by the Persian-period Hebrew (and Aramaic) texts—of both the priesthood's and the Jerusalem temple's relevance. This belief, however, is based in part on an inadequate definition of theocracy and a poor understanding of the social and political conditions necessary for such a structure. This investigation will argue that Persian-period Yehud was not a theocracy. It will argue that the Jerusalem priesthood did not control Yehud's politics and society, which would have been necessary for a theocracy. In general, temples were not power centers but were often imperial institutions, while continuing their local-cultic functions; the Jerusalem temple (when it existed) and the Jerusalem priesthood should not be perceived any differently than temples and priesthoods throughout the empire. The available evidence, external to the agenda-driven texts, weighs more heavily toward the continued function of governors within the province.


Reading First Peter in Light of Roman Imperial Cult
Program Unit: Methodological Reassessments of the Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Thomas Scott Caulley, Institute for the Study of Christian Origins

Drawing upon my earlier analysis of the structure of 1 Peter, this paper employs social description (social history) to shed light on a main concern of the letter, namely, “How should the recipients of 1 Peter deal with the disconnect between faith in their spiritual identity and the reality of their everyday social experience?” Whereas in the past this question has often been treated theologically (i.e., in light of the human condition and/or in eschatological terms), as well as sociologically (e.g., with categories such as “insider/outsider”), this paper addresses the problem starting from the historical and social context of the pervasive Roman imperial cult in Asia Minor in the latter part of the first century and early second century. With this background in mind, the paper explores three main passages in 1 Peter: First, the famous reference to Rome as “Babylon” in 1 Peter 5:13 reminds us of the Christians’ struggle against a hostile culture and government. Second, the reference to suffering “as a 'Christianos'” (4:16) confirms that some problems faced by these believers were based in religio-political realities. Third, the admonitions “be subject to every human institution,” and “honor the emperor” (2:13-17), do not represent a call to capitulation to the authorities, but imply a resistance to Roman imperial cult. Conclusions are drawn in terms of a unifying theme of 1 Peter, “The Call of God”—a description of these believers with both spiritual and social implications.


Priests and Society in Second Temple Judaism: Some Experiments with Sociological Theory
Program Unit: Social-Scientific Studies of the Second Temple Period
David Chalcraft, The University of Derby, UK

The paper will report on experimenting with various ideas from sociological theory as a means of interrogating the data/texts relating to priests and society in Second Temple Judaism. Within a context where the possibility of an historical sociological approach to an ancient society utilising ideas from the analysis of advanced societies in modernity as a methodological issue is not to be swept under the carpet but made use of analytically, I am particularly interested in approaching the data with questions, concepts and theories relating to professions, professional ethics and professional gaze; and relating to the creation and management of expert knowledge, and of social stigma, and the development of means of social control and technocracy. Sociological theorists drawn upon will include Max Weber, Anthony Giddens, Ulrich Beck, Michel Foucault and Erving Goffman. The list of ideas and of theorists at this stage is indicative since in the nature of 'experiment' one anticipates that some approaches will be more successful than others. Reflecting on that process is, I believe, also a valuable 'finding'.


Faith and the Discipline in the Classroom: A Crucial Dialectical Relationship
Program Unit:
Bradley Chance, William Jewell College

The critical study of religion, particularly the Bible (within my immediate area of specialty), often requires students of faith to wrestle with views of biblical origins that are at odds with many traditional views that tend to view human beings as passive instruments in the writing of Scripture. I have found that it is not sufficient to leave students dangling, wondering what "to do" with such new views of biblical origins. Over the years, I have increasingly brought into class discussion, either formally or informally, the theological implications of critical views of biblical origins, which focus attention on the historical, social, cultural, and human dimensions of the Bible. God's people, I teach, are co-authors and co-creators with God of the story of which the Bible speaks. In this way, the discipline "informs faith." But faith also informs the discipline (I find this to be increasingly so in my classes‹it comes with age, I think). I do not mean by this that faith trumps the critical scrutiny of evidence or casually fills gaps or legitimates the avoidance of difficult issues. Rather, this God who invites God's people to be co-creators and co-authors in the unfolding of the biblical story is, candidly, more present in my classroom discussions of biblical texts and issues than God was when I was a younger, more "objective" scholar. Questions of theodicy when studying the Deuteronomic History or Job or issues of Markan Christology and suffering are explored more explicitly than in a setting where "neutral description" of "the religion" of the ancient text is normative. My institutional context, a church-related (even though quite nominally in terms of any legal relationships) liberal arts college, invites and even encourages such theological engagement. This paper will discuss explicitly how one might think of God, given critical views of biblical origins, and how such thinking about God can inform and theologically enrich one's reading of the biblical texts in the specific classroom settings that comprise my specific contextual location and situation.


"All Judaism is Hellenistic Judaism": The Influence of Martin Hengel on Conceptions of Galilee
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Mark A. Chancey, Southern Methodist University

Few scholars would dispute Martin Hengel's famous dictum that "all Judaism is Hellenistic Judaism." Hengel's work has been especially influential in shattering the myth that Judaism in Palestine was somehow isolated from the cultural currents of the larger Greco-Roman world. Often, however, Hengel's work has been used to support problematic assumptions that "all Hellenistic Judaism was Hellenized to the same extent"--that is, Greek was widely spoken throughout Palestine; Greek architecture was common in all regions; etc. This paper will examine the influence of Hengel's ideas on scholarly understandings of Galilee. It will devote particular attention to the chronological development of Hellenistic culture, to the relationship between the processes of Hellenization and Romanization, and to the relevance of studies of the Romanization of other geographical areas within the Roman Empire.


The Aesthetics of Empire: The Depiction and Bracketing of Violence in the Assyrian Palace Reliefs
Program Unit: Prophetic Texts and Their Ancient Contexts
Cynthia Chapman, Oberlin College

Recognizing the Assyrian palace reliefs as celebratory records of empire building and assertions of earned power, this paper will examine the depiction and bracketing of violence in the representation of empire. While many have noted the exhaustive and unabashed depictions of military violence in the reliefs, it is equally important to consider the types of violence known from Assyrian and biblical texts on Assyria that remain visually unrecorded in the reliefs. For example, violence against enemy men, their horses, their military machinery, their landscapes, and their cities is reiterated across the reliefs. At the same time, violence against enemy women and enemy gods is usually bracketed from view. This paper will examine the implications of the aesthetic choices that determined which aspects of conquest and empire building were celebrated artistically and which were left unrecorded.


Second Wives and Their Rebellious Sons: Two Tales of Fratricide and Usurpation
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
Cynthia Chapman, Oberlin College

This paper will examine the role of the natal family in two cases of disputed dynastic succession (Judges 8:29-9:57 and II Samuel 13-19). The natal family is a term used within anthropological studies of kinship and designates the kinship unit comprised of a mother and her biological and adopted children. In a polygynous society such as that represented in the Bible, the “House of the Father” could contain several natal family units. Using both comparative ethnographies from modern polygynous societies and a literary critical approach to the biblical text, this study will demonstrate the central role of the natal family, or “House of the Mother,” in both Abimelech’s and Absalom’s attempt to usurp the throne. Both flee to their mother’s kinfolk in order to seek refuge from threats originating in the father’s house, and while sheltered in their mother’s house, they build a support base for an attempted coup. Anthropological studies of the natal family in modern polygynous societies show that in cultures that practice patrilineal descent and patrilocal, enodogamous marriage, a woman’s natal family continued to serve significant functions in her life after she “married out” of it. It served as a refuge to which she or her children could flee, and it formed the honor bound unit in cases necessitating blood revenge. Both of these patterns fit the evidence presented in the narratives of Abimelech and Absalom. The difference in the two men’s tactics and in the Deuteronomist’s portrayal of their efforts can be explained most fully by reference to the status of their mother in the house of their father.


"Cedere maiori": Flavian Works and the Jews
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Honora H. Chapman, California State University, Fresno

In De spectaculis, a work celebrating the opening of the Colosseum in 80 CE, the poet Martial concludes that the loser’s second-place “virtutis fama” is “to yield to the greater [foe].” This, in a nutshell, is the Flavian message to all its former enemies, including the Jews with whom they had just fought a war. Monumental works such as the amphitheater itself and the new Temple of Peace presented visible signs of Flavian ascendancy to all visitors at Rome. Two other prolific Flavian writers, Pliny the Elder and Josephus, are noticeably reticent about different aspects of the Temple of Peace, though, and both are completely silent on the existence of the Colosseum, despite Martial’s claim that “omnis Caesareo cedit labor amphitheatro.” In this paper I shall try to explain this silence while showing how these three Flavian authors’ approaches to these two particular monuments provide varying Roman and Jewish perspectives on Roman imperialism, its effects upon both the environment and people’s way of life, the status of Jews at Rome, and the idea of “peace” under the Flavian regime.


Reconsidering Supersessionist Hermeneutics
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Ellen Charry, Princeton Theological Seminary

The reason for insisting on the unity of scripture theologically is primarily to demonstrate that Christians worship the God of Israel and this in order to repudiate Manichean and Marcionite claims. The standard way that Christian theologians have held to the unity of their scriptures has been one or another form of supersessionism. There are many tools in this toolbox, some taken from the Second Testament itself. Paul both christologizes and typologizes scripture, and Matthew reads the scripture as prophesying the coming of Christ. Figural reading, including typology and allegory, became standard hermeneutical tools often relying on a promise-fulfillment hermeneutic. The result of these various methods has often been the emptying of meaning from the original text in order to locate it in Jesus and/or the church. There are several problems with supersessionist hermeneutics for sustaining the theological claim of the unity of scripture: (1) it is grounded in anachronism, (2) in some cases it requires historical distortion of the text, and (3) its reception by the church has morally compromised the institution through Christian relationship to and treatment of Jews and Judaism. For these reasons, alternatives to supersessionism are needed for understanding the unity of the two testaments, the Christian claims on the First Testament, and the exegesis of the Second Testament.


The Scribes and Texts of Freer MS V
Program Unit:
Malcolm Choat, Macquarie University

The Freer Codex of the Minor Prophets (MS V) presents a near-complete third century text of the dodekapropheton in Greek, and forms one of the most important early witnesses to these books. Invaluable ancillary data is stored in the margins: alongside simple corrections are variant readings written by a number of scribes, as well as Coptic glosses. At the end of the codex was copied a separate work, unknown but clearly non-biblical, of which only fragment remain. This paper analyses the marginal notations for what they can tell us about the circumstances of the codex's production and use, and presents a new analysis of the unidentified text.


Ecclesiastes in Reception: Understanding the Pervasive Appeal of the Preacher
Program Unit: The Texts of Wisdom in Israel, Early Judaism, and the Eastern Mediterranean World
Eric S. Christianson, University of Chester

The extraordinary instances of the reception of Ecclesiastes in world literature hint at the enormity of Qoheleth's literary and psychological appeal. Indeed it is bordering on a commonplace to suggest that Qoheleth speaks to people in all ages, or as robert Gordis put it fifty years ago, 'speaks to the modern age across an interval of two thousand years with the immediacy of contact of a contemporary'. Why is it, then, that countless authors have seen something of themselves so forcefully reflected in Qoheleth's words? Donne, Voltaire, Johnson and Thackeray all at least found an empathetic sparring partner in Qoheleth's personage. Readers have in some sense experienced an intangible emphathy, which this paper seeks to explore. The paper will also briefly ask about what exegetical and hermeneutical questions this particular reception history raises.


A Korean-American Contextual Approach to the Story of the Blind Beggar in Mark 10:46–52
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Sejong Chun, Vanderbilt University

*


Whose Fault Is It Anyway? Reading Esau’s Marriage from an Asian Perspective
Program Unit: Asian and Asian-American Hermeneutics
Il-Seung Chung, University of Sheffield

Just as Esau’s marriage with the Hittite women displeased Isaac and Rebekah, a number of Korean-American children, who do not live in their parents’ homeland, often come to displease their parents by marrying a person from other ethnic and cultural backgrounds. In regard to Esau’s exogamy, European or North American scholars tend to criticize Esau for his failure to recognize his parents’ expectations for a suitable marriage partner. This paper examines the question whether Asian readers or scholars would regard Esau’s choice of marriage entirely as Esau’s fault as a majority of Western scholars do. I contend that from an Asian perspective Esau’s exogamy can be regarded as a fault of his “parents”, Isaac and Rebekah, who have failed to properly instruct Esau not to marry a foreign woman. Western scholars seem to criticize Esau based on their own culturally affected view of judging who is responsible when a family problem occurs - children rather than parents. Asian cultural norms, however, still give great emphasis on the responsibility of parents concerning a family problem. While Abraham has arranged for his son Isaac an acceptable marriage to a kinswoman (Genesis 24) when Isaac was “forty years old” (Gen. 25:20), Isaac neglected to do the same for his own firstborn Esau when Esau was “forty years old.” Therefore, as a Asian reader, the editorial comment in Gen. 26:34 “when Esau was forty years old” stands out and draws my attention less to Esau’s failure to choose a suitable wife than to Isaac who has not fulfilled his obligation to arrange an appropriate wife for his eldest son. In this paper, I anticipate that an Asian reading of Esau’s marriage can bring a new and different perspective on Esau’s narrative role.


Purity Regulations in the Didache
Program Unit: Didache in Context
John J. Clabeaux, Pontifical College Josephinum

The acceptance, rejection, or transformation of Jewish purity regulations in Christianity has become a matter of serious scholarly attention, since Mary Douglas’ Purity and Danger was recognized as changing the paradigms for our understanding of these matters. There is much debate regarding Jesus’ views of purity regulations. I have been working on Paul’s. In this paper I will apply what I have learned from these discussions to the Didache, which contains passages involving purity regulations in chapters 6, 7, 9, 10, 13, 14, and 16. When purity concerns appear in Christian literature they are often dismissed by Christian scholars as "merely metaphorical." But what I have learned in my study of purity so far is that a purity system is a metaphorical system (or a symbolic system) by its very nature. Purity is part of an entire system of boundaries that mark what is holy from what is not. In certain Pauline letters purity is a dominant not a marginal concern. I want to see if it is any less of a concern in the Didache. My sense at this point is that the concern for purity it is not as strong in Didache as in Paul’s letters, but I wish to examine carefully all the passages and present a cogent view of Didache as a whole on this issue. This is vitally important for understanding the relationship between emergent Christianity and first century Judaisms.


Teaching Genesis through Cartoons
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Dan W. Clanton Jr., University of Denver

This presentation will focus on the challenges and benefits of using popular culture texts, specifically static cartoons, to facilitate the teaching of biblical literature, specifically the book of Genesis. I will begin by discussing the formal nature of cartoons, and why they are so useful in assisting students in our American context in grasping not only the content of Genesis, but also the approaches and results of later commentators. I will then present several of these cartoons, and indicate how they might be used in an undergraduate educational setting. Finally, I will conclude by reflecting on the effectiveness of incorporating popular culture texts into biblical studies classrooms.


Sent Ahead or Left Behind? War and Peace in the Apocalypse, Eschatology, and the Left Behind Series
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Ronald R. Clark, Jr., Cascade College

The 12 volume Left Behind series, by Tim LaHaye and Jerry B. Jenkins has not only sold over 12 million copies, it has impacted the way most Americans understand Revelation, Apocalyptic Literature, and world politics. The books and popular movies are accepted as popular commentaries on a controversial book. While LaHaye and Jenkins do not represent the most common scholarly approach to Revelation and Eschatology, they represent an ever-growing mindset in Evangelical America. While the series has some value in calling people to repentance, morality, and an awareness of world events, it is damaging to those of us who teach Apocalyptic Literature. This series uses a form of projective identification stemming from the cold war and days of the Red Scare. This form of transference can promote a sense of paranoia and distrust for attempts at world peace, Eastern-Europeans, Jews, and those who are not American. The writers also ignore the true historical setting of Revelation and the attempts of apocalyptic writers to provide hope in times of crisis. While Apocalyptic Literature uses projective identification to respond to a perceived threat and crisis, the authors of the Left Behind Series imagine and create a threat and crisis.


Biblical Graphic Novels: Adaptation, Interpretation, and Pedagogy
Program Unit:
Terry Clark, University of Colorado, Colorado Springs

*


Words That Endure: Using Fiction and Poetry to Teach the Bible
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Jaime Clark-Soles, Southern Methodist University

In the introduction to The Vintage Book of American Short Stories, Tobias Wolff writes: "That sense of kinship is what makes stories important to us. The pleasure we take in cleverness and technical virtuosity soon exhausts itself in the absence of any recognizable human landscape. We need to feel ourselves acted upon by a story, outraged, exposed, in danger of heartbreak and change. Those are the stories that endure in our memories, to the point where they take on the nature of memory itself. In this way the experience of something read can form us no less than the experience of something lived through" (xiii). If this is true, then surely fiction, poetry, and scripture have much in common. All are about the business of acting upon readers in order to shape them somehow, to suggest something about realities and possibilities. This presentation will attend not only to the reasoning behind using fiction and poetry in the biblical studies classroom, but also to the practical considerations.


Paleography and Philanthropy: Charles Lang Freer and His Acquisition of the Freer Biblical Manuscripts
Program Unit:
Kent Clarke, Trinity Western University

*


Intertext, Outertext, Context: Early Jewish and Christian Artistic Representations of the Sacrifice of Isaac
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Ruth A. Clements, Orion Center for the Study of the Dead Sea Scrolls

The earliest Jewish artistic representation of the sacrifice of Isaac is the well-known wall-painting found in the synagogue at Dura Europus, which shows (among other narrative details) a young Isaac supine on the altar awaiting the moment of sacrifice. In a recurring early Christian iconographic representation of the scene, however, Isaac has moved to a kneeling position beside a small (incense altar), hands bound behind his back, Abraham with knife (or sword) upraised, preparing to strike. A legitimate question to be raised in a session such as this one is: To what extent can these iconic differences provide a basis of comparison of Jewish and Christian interpretations of the biblical story of the Sacrifice/Binding? This presentation takes the Binding/Sacrifice as a test case, examining selected representations of this biblical scene, depicted in a variety of contexts, to explore the methodological issues and assumptions involved in our readings of these pictorial readings of the biblical text. Recent work of both Jewish and Christian art historians reminds us that any number of non-literary factors may intervene between the biblical text and its pictorial representation. In other words, it may be misleading to look for “influence” (or lack thereof) in either shared iconographic conventions or the presumed presence of shared “midrashic” motifs. Thus, this presentation considers the interplay between the biblical narrative, its literary interpretations, and the 2d-3d century cultural narrative of persecution and martyrdom, as well as the mechanics of artistic production in the ancient world, in tackling the question of what iconographic Isaacs can tell us about interaction between early Jewish and Christian readers of Genesis 22.


A Shelter Amid the Flood: Noah’s Ark in Early Christian Textual and Visual Interpretation
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Ruth A. Clements, Orion Center for the Study of the Dead Sea Scrolls

The earliest Christian iconography of Noah and/or his ark comes from the Christian catacombs of Rome, ca. late third century and on. Noah (solitary) stands in a square box, arms lifted and outstretched; sometimes a bird with a branch in its mouth is overhead. Traditionally this image, along with a number of other early catacomb images (Daniel and the lions, the three young men in the furnace, Susanna and elders, Isaac at the sacrifice/binding, Jonah [though this is more complicated]) is seen as one of thanksgiving for salvation/resurrection appropriate to the tomb setting. I want to complicate this reading by way of an intertextual/intercultural reading of the figure of Noah, to suggest that for their original viewers, these representations might have had a different significance. The recent work of classicist Jocelyn Penny Small, along with that of historians of Christian art like Paul Corbey Finney, reminds us that artistic representations of biblical scenes cannot be understood by taking a direct sighting from biblical text to visual icon. Certainly Noah-in-a-box does not “exegete” the story of a huge ark (however shaped) populated by four human pairs and hundreds of animals. This paper explores the complicated relationship between the cultural cohabitants of biblical text, Greek myth, the dynamics of artistic production in the ancient world, the iconography of an ancient coin, and the social context of persecution and martyrdom, in producing the solitary Noah. Such an exploration allows us to relocate Noah of the catacombs in a pantheon, not of salvation figures, but of models for martyrs (Daniel still between the lions, the three young men still in the fire, etc); i.e., models not of thanksgiving for present salvation (from death) but of confident steadfastness in facing certain death, for the sake of heaven.


One or Two Things You May Not Know about the Universe: The Cosmology of the Divine Speeches in Job
Program Unit: Biblical Criticism and Literary Criticism
David J.A. Clines, University of Sheffield

Everything that God knows about the universe in Job 38-39 the author of Job also knows-otherwise he could not be telling us. But to share the cosmological knowledge of the Joban author demands a careful study of his rather difficult Hebrew, and an appreciation of the structural development of the divine speeches.      For the Joban author, the earth is supported by pillars (different from the pillars of heaven), which rest on bases, which are sunk in primeval matter, perhaps the underworld sea. Crowning the whole work is its capstone (not its cornerstone).      Each morning, according to Job 38-39, is created afresh. The high god summons the lesser deity Dawn to bring the new day into being, which Dawn does by taking hold of the edges of the earth and shaking it like a blanket, as if to remove loose objects, which are the stars.      Light and darkness, entities independent of the heavenly bodies, exist in the same physical space and share the one dwelling. Above the firmament lie the heavenly storerooms, not only for snow and hail but also for heat. And many other facets of the physical universe, lightning, hoarfrost, ice, the relation of the stars to the weather, come into sharper focus as we explore the poetry of the speeches.


How Many Voices Does It Take to Perform Isaiah 40?
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
David J.A. Clines, University of Sheffield

There is much speaking in Isaiah 40, voices crying (vv 3-5, 6-8) and commands being uttered (vv 1, 9) and announcements being authorized (vv 6, 9) and questions being posed (vv 12-14, 18, 25-26, 27-28) and even once someone answering (v 6). Yet apart from the voice of Yahweh (vv 1, 5, 25) and the voice of Israel in complaint (v 27), all the speaking is anonymous. It is as if, in the upheaval at the return from exile, the prophet overhears a medley of voices but cannot put a name to the speakers. Can we? The first verse immediately plunges us into the puzzle: how many performers does it take to be realized? There is God, there is the people, there are the comforters, there are the addressees (“your”), there is the narrator (“says”) and the narratee (to whom the narrator is saying the verse). Add the author and the readers, the implied author and the implied reader, and the ideal reader, and the performance of an apparently simple biblical text becomes the task of a whole crew of speaking and non-speaking voices. The task of this paper will be to flesh out all of them.


Seduction or Rape? Examining the Fate of the Angels’ Wives
Program Unit: Gender, Sexuality, and the Bible
Kelley N. Coblentz Bautch, St. Edward's University

It has long been noted that the Enochic corpus elaborates upon a peculiar passage from Genesis 6:1-4 that concerns the union of the sons of God and mortal women. Enochic works understand the account to refer to rebellious angels who after deciding to mate with women leave their heavenly dwelling. While the author of 1 Enoch 6 accents the lustful nature of the angels and makes clear that the guilt for the sinful union lies with the angels alone and not the women, Jewish and Christian interpreters of Late Antiquity relate the very story of the watchers, or fallen angels, in such a way as to indict women for tempting the celestial beings. What explains such diverse readings of the account? Text variants in the Greek and Ethiopic manuscript traditions that concern the fate of the wives either serve to implicate the wives in seduction or exculpate the wives of any sexual deviancy. Following the Greek text known as Panopolitanus, the wives of the angels are to become sirens, mythological creatures often associated with seduction (1 En. 19:2). Ethiopic manuscripts preserve another reading: the wives of the angels will become peaceful. Which of these readings is correct? Further, as fragments of this Enochic work have been discovered in Aramaic, but the Aramaic is not extant for this particular verse, one should also consider which Hebrew or Aramaic word stood in the place of the Greek and Ethiopic readings. This study assesses the Greek and Ethiopic reading of 1 En. 19:2 and also explores what these readings communicate about women and sexuality.


The Grammar of II Samuel: Preliminary Findings
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Margaret E. Cohen, The Pennsylvania State University

While discrete sources within the biblical texts (and especially material that is historiographic in nature) are not usually the subject of grammatical analyses, epigraphic sources are routinely examined in this regard. And so we have grammars of most major inscriptions, comparisons of orthography and vocabulary and language of one inscription with another, and overall systematic analyses of each, unified text. The evidence preserved in each of these distinct corpora yields a particular grammatical structure which can be compared with other epigraphic material to determine relative dating and other relationships between the languages. This approach is not, however, currently applied to the biblical text in the same manner, and here a single unified linguistic corpus from the historiographic material of the biblical text is considered anew and alone, separated from other biblical sources, in an attempt to identify one point along the grammatical spectrum of ancient Hebrew. This project is a systematic analysis of the grammar of II Samuel, a unified narrative of text in context, not bound by the “average” grammar of Standard Biblical Hebrew, but rather an examination of the grammatical features particular to this text. By attempting a comprehensive grammar of this text, and not just a vocabulary or spelling study, this project aims to avoid some of the pitfalls of these less holistic methodologies. In establishing the grammatical reference point of this text along the Hebrew spectrum, the linguistic analysis may also shed light on the chronological issues surrounding the early Israelite monarchy. This project is a large undertaking and the subject of my doctoral dissertation, but here I would like to discuss my methodology and present preliminary findings of several indicative grammatical features that help to situate the II Samuel corpus along the larger Biblical Hebrew spectrum.


A User-Friendly Introduction to Minhat Shai
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Miles B Cohen, Jewish Theological Seminary of America

Jedidiah Solomo Norzi was a late-sixteenth-century masoretic scholar and grammarian, born in Mantua, Italy. He is best known for his masoretic commentary on the Bible, published in the mid-eighteenth century as Minhat Shai. Norizi compared Bible printings against reliable masoretic manuscripts in order to ascertain the most authentic readings. He brought a new and urgent critical eye to the study of the Masoretic Text during the decades following the appearance of the first significant printed editions of the Bible. A number of examples from Norzi's commentary will be presented. These will illustrate the usefulness of Norzi's work in explicating obscure or little-understood aspects of the Masoretic Text and will serve as an introduction to the great contribution that Norzi made to masoretic studies. Brief notes about Norzi's life and his methodology will also be discussed.


"They Thought It Was a Ghost:" Understanding an Absurdity in Mark 6:49–50
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Jason Robert Combs, Yale University

In Mark 6:49-50 the author dramatically defines the disciples' miscomprehension of Jesus through the insertion of the absurd: the belief that a ghost could walk on water. Exegesis of the pericope of "Jesus's Walking on Water" is enhanced by an understanding of ancient beliefs about ghosts, as described in tales of hauntings and other phenomena throughout Jewish, Greek and Roman sources. By identifying ancient literature analogous to the Markan account, one may detect how Mark initially establishes the expectation for a phantasmic appearance, and then diverges significantly to emphasize the disciples' misconstrual of Jesus' messiahship.


Nocturnal Apotropaism in the Bible and Its World
Program Unit: Israelite Religion in its Ancient Context
Blane W. Conklin, University of Texas, Austin

The fear of nighttime and its associated menaces (both natural and supernatural) and the religious measures taken to deal with this concern was a major preoccupation for people in ancient societies. While this phenomenon has been recognized in some passages of the Hebrew Bible, it appears that our interpretation of some biblical texts can benefit from a better understanding of this ancient preoccupation. This paper will survey textual and iconographical evidence from the ancient Near East and bring it to bear on some select biblical passages relevant to this aspect of household religion.


Paul and the Virility of the Cross
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Colleen Conway, Seton Hall University

This study analyzes the influence of the ideology of Roman imperial masculinity on Paul’s Christology, especially his interpretation of the death of Christ. From the perspective of the empire, corporeal punishment, and certainly execution was fundamentally emasculating treatment. This, at least in part, is the humiliation of the cross of which Paul speaks. If Paul is to bring others to belief in Christ, he must redefine the crucifixion as a demonstration of masculine virtue. Moreover, this “revirilization” of an emasculated Christ is integrally linked to the maintenance of Paul’s own masculine authority—his role as father among his churches. In promoting the “virility of the cross,” Paul shores up his own masculine status which is being challenged by his opponents. In the same way that Paul does not want the cross to be emptied of its power (1 Cor 1:17), he does not want to lose his own power over his followers. The argument begins with a brief summary of Roman aversion to corporal punishment as reflected in authors such as Cicero and Seneca. This is juxtaposed with Roman articulations of a manly death, one in which a man bears pain, suffering and death bravely, and for the benefit of others. Paul’s recognition of both perspectives is then analyzed in light of his redefinition of Jesus’ execution as a self-sacrificial and hence, manly, death. Paul’s identification with Christ in his suffering, and also his use of hardship catalogues are explored in light of the challenges to his own masculinity.


Two Different Approaches to the Septuating Proverbs: Using the Septuagint-Proverbs as a Text-Critical Resource
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Johann Cook, University of Stellenbosch

The Septuagint of Proverbs is, except for a few fragments from Qumran, the only textual resource besides the MT earlier than the Common Era. But it is a tricky translation for this purpose, and the way it should be used is open to debate. Granted that, as Cook has shown, LXX-Prov is an interpretative translation, can it nevertheless provide a witness to textual variants? Cook and Fox have debated this issue in various publications. In the present pair of papers, they enter into dialogue in order to sharpen the questions about the text-critical use of this resource and think through the constraints and possibilities of using such a document as a witness to variants. According to Cook, LXX-Proverbs is a freely translated rendering of a Semitic parent text that does not differ dramatically from the MT. Its translation technique is defined as one of diversity and unity and is so free that he finds it extremely difficult to retrovert this parent text. He also deems the Greek as the first exegetical commentary of the Hebrew. According to Fox, LXX-Prov provides a window to an ancient Hebrew text that differs significantly from the MT and that justifies a bolder text-critical use of the translation. Fox argues that, first, there are techniques for recognizing a Hebrew Vorlage, even when it cannot be fully recovered. Second, even when the critieria for a strong argument for a particular retroversion are not available, other factors can strengthen the grounds for the retroversion; and, third, the fact that a translation is “interpretive” does not mean that it is interpreting the MT.


Verbal Patterns in Psalms
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
John A. Cook, Eisenbrauns, Inc.

Many scholars view the grammar of Hebrew poetry as largely distinct from that of Hebrew prose. This view, reinforced by Ugaritic studies, tends to invalidate any grammatical study of Hebrew poetry that takes the grammar of Hebrew prose as its starting point. However, poetry universally assumes a certain degree of normative status for prose grammar as a foil for its "poetic" language, and therefore a grammatical analysis of Hebrew poetry should take a grammar of prose as its starting point. In this study, the model of the Hebrew verb outlined in Cook 2001 is taken as the basis for an examination of the verbal system in Hebrew poetry. The interaction of verbal forms with each other, their patterned usage within particular genre, and their role in Hebrew poetics are explored through a close examination of several exemplary psalms along with references to similiar constructions in other compositions. I demonstrate in this study that, allowing for certain archaic or poetic features (e.g., the use of a prefix non-narrative past form), the TAM of the Hebrew verbal system in poetry is not fundamentally different from that in prose.


Holiness Versus Reverence: Two Priestly Theologies; Two Priestly Schools
Program Unit: Social-Scientific Studies of the Second Temple Period
Stephen L. Cook, Virginia Theological Seminary

Two priestly theologies oriented on the idea of the Holy are attested in the literature of Israel's Second Temple period, for example, in Ezekiel and Third Isaiah. These two theologies of holiness display comparable emphases over against other priestly and prophetic thinking of the period, but also clear and apparent tensions with each other. For convenience these theologies may be labeled "Holiness Theology" and "Reverence Theology." Both emphasize God as Holy, completely Other, and numinous, but they differ greatly on how to conceptualize holiness, respond to it, and be transformed by it. Holiness Theology and Reverence Theology, I will argue, have separate sets of tradents, two priestly schools active in Second Temple times. I believe I can name these schools and associate them directly with priestly stands within the Pentateuch


Death, Kinship, and Community: Funerary Practices and the Khesed Ideal in Israel
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
Stephen L. Cook, Virginia Theological Seminary

The khesed ideal of the Hebrew Scriptures can be summarized as mutuality of persons enjoying physical, embodied community on earth. Israelite society’s traditional family and lineage bonds were natural tools for fostering this simple, yet powerful, ideal. Fully realizing khesed on earth, however, is an uphill battle. The powers of Sheol are constantly at work to sever human relationships and to dissolve community, contradicting khesed. Taking a stand against Sheol’s dissevering power, Israel’s mortuary ideals and practices betray a faith that death’s power can somehow be overcome. Final victory, these traditions suggest, will go to the bonds of lineage membership and land-vested community. These family bonds and bonds between lineage and territory are guaranteed permanent by covenantal faith. They are so permanent, in fact, as to transcend Sheol’s power and to point to Sheol’s ultimate defeat.


Saul the Pharisee and Paul the Master of Converts in Ambrosiaster
Program Unit: Social History of Formative Christianity and Judaism
Stephen A. Cooper, Franklin & Marshall College

The works of Ambrosiaster on the Pauline epistles contain a portrait of Paul the Pharisee that differs significantly from Augustine’s Paul. While Augustine read Paul as the man of “introspective conscience” (Stendahl) crucified between the demands of the Law and those of the “old man” within, Ambrosiaster portrayed Paul the Pharisee in a sympathetic light (along the lines of 1 Timothy 1:13) as a Jew whose opposition to the nascent church could be excused by his ignorance. This picture of the pre-Christian Paul clearly arises in part from Ambrosiaster’s supercessionalist theology, in which the Jewish Law gets granted the limited status of a “law of deeds” which functioned to keep the Jews fearing and obeying God until the time of Christ, when the long-promised justification could be actualized. On the other hand, Ambrosiaster’s notion of Saul as a Jew whose resistance to Christianity derived not from “malevolence” but from “ignorance”, also seems designed to present Paul as an exemplary convert. The intended audience for this portrait, I will argue, are not potential Jewish converts but pagans (Ambrosiaster’s time and place puts him at the beginning of a phrase of a major expansion of Christianity into the higher levels of Roman society). My claim will be supported by the numerous aspects of Ambrosiaster’s major exegetical works which both ridicule aspects of pagan spirituality (especially astrological determinism) and address pagan objections to Christianity grounded in apparent contradictions in the Bible and purveyed by a variety of pagan polemicists (Porphyry, Hierocles, and Julian). Thus Ambrosiaster would be using his image pre-Christian Paul to suggest that loyalty to the religion of one’s ancestors may have pious motivations yet be mistaken and in need of correction at the dawning of a new truth.


The Wise, the Simple, and the Apocalypse of Paul
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Kirsti Barrett Copeland, Stanford University

Given the connections scholars have found between wisdom and apocalypticism in early Judaism and early Christianity, it is remarkable that the Apocalypse of Paul (late 4th c. CE) never mentions “wisdom” or the “wise,” does not emphasize “seeking” after anything, does not engage in “two ways” discourse, describes nature observing humans and not humans observing nature, and exhibits little interest in cosmological secrets aside from detailing individual punishment and reward. The few times that a potential wisdom motif appears divorced from revelation, the text almost invariably demonstrates the failure of the individual to understand the obvious. Revelation remains the only certain means of encouraging individuals to repent and thus avoid the dismal fate of the hell-bound. Thus, the intended audience could be characterized as the passive recipient of Paul’s revelation, not the active seeker after wisdom or knowledge. This characterization of the audience may shed light on the social location of the Apocalypse of Paul. There are numerous monastic allusions in the text, and parallels with Pachomius’ visions of heaven and hell raise the Pachomian monastery as a potential social location for the composition of the Apocalypse of Paul. The rejection of wisdom themes in this apocalypse problematizes any connection with the Pachomian literature, particularly given that the Pachomian Instruction Concerning a Spiteful Monk opens with, “My son, listen and be wise, accept the true doctrine, for there are two ways.” Moreover, the Apocalypse of Paul rewards the “simple” who hear and understand a single verse of scripture with the greatest throne in the City of Christ, whereas the Pachomian Rules insist on literacy for monks. Close attention to the interplay of sapiential and apocalyptic themes may help further define the social location of the Apocalypse of Paul.


Women, Funerary Meals, and Lament, and the Origins of Early Christian Meals
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
Kathleen E. Corley, University of Wisconsin, Oshkosh

This paper presents a detailed overview of the role of women in ancient funerary practices, lament and funerary meals in Greek, Roman, Jewish and Christian traditions which serves as a new context for understanding women's roles in early Christian origins, meals and the creation and transmission of early Christian stories and oral tradition.


In Search of the Goddess in Ancient Syro-Palestinan Iconography
Program Unit: Israelite Religion in its Ancient Context
Izak Cornelius, University of Stellenbosch

Iconography as the study of visual representation is an important source in the study of the religions of the Ancient Near East and Syro-Palestine (cf. recently Ted Lewis in Neal Walls, Cult Image and Divine Representation) and more specifically Israel/Palestine. Recent studies have also emphasized the value of iconography with regard to the role of women in ancient society and their religious experiences. There have been various attempts to detect important goddesses like Anat, Astarte and especially Asherah (the so-called “Hebrew goddess”) in the iconographical record and identify specific goddesses known from the textual sources. This presentation takes a critical look at the way in which goddesses have been identified in Syro-Palestinian iconography. In the past scholars have sometimes been obsessed with finding a textually named goddess – Asherah being the prime example. One consequence of this emphasis on “naming” has been the neglect of investigating the religious and cultural function of the representation. The possibility that mortal women are represented must also be kept in mind – which does not make the value of iconography for a study of ancient religion (in the broadest sense of the word) of lesser value. Selected examples from the most important media (e.g. stone, metal and terracotta) dating from the earliest periods up to the end of the Persian period will be discussed to illustrate how the iconography of the goddess has been studied.


The Old Testament in the New and Ethics: Ephesians as a Test Case
Program Unit: Character Ethics and Biblical Interpretation
David Cortes-Fuentes, San Francisco Theological Seminary

*


The Roman Army as a Catalyst for Syncretism: Dura Europus
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Wendy Cotter, Loyola University of Chicago

Roman Army Life demanded a wide array of religious honours to the gods of the state, as well as regular worship of the Standards. But the army on the move into foreign territory was also obliged to perform religious rites at the borders of any new lands it intended to invade, the Counsul promising that Rome would worship the deities with greater pomp than could ever be offered by the indigenous population. Once stationed there, the ordinary soldiers adopted devotions to local deities to appeal for protection, and having been saved from death, brought these deities with them back home. In this paper, the evidence from the inscriptions connected to the Roman Fortress in Dura Europos of the second century will illustrate the Roman soldiers' role in the syncretism around the Mediterranean.


The Articulate Body: The Language of Suffering in the Individual Lament Psalms
Program Unit: Lament in Sacred Texts and Cultures
Amy Cottrill, Emory University

One way the psalmist of the laments represents himself as a sufferer is through the language of the distressed body. The psalmist portrays himself as diminished, wounded, and in pain that sometimes reduces him to inarticulateness. The language of the suffering body is, most obviously, a discourse of powerlessness. This language is not just one of powerlessness, however, but also a means of empowerment. Medical anthropologist Arthur Kleinman has done cross-cultural studies of the expression of pain and assumptions of personhood, society, and embodiment embedded therein. He argues that a particular culture’s somatic idiom of distress is a means of expressing real distress, but also a means of affording the sufferer a degree of power. Using Kleinman’s work to read the psalmist’s body language, I contend that the language of bodily suffering forms a disempowerment/empowerment discursive complex, in which these aspects of the language are unmerged and not mutually exclusive. The language of the body in the laments is multivocal, a language of vulnerability and powerlessness, yet also a language of authority and power. Finally, I explore the interpretive and ethical implications of reading the language of bodily powerlessness as part of a discourse strategy that simultaneously empowers the psalmist. How should the reader respond to the psalmist's physical suffering? Though there are ethical implications to remaining distant in the presence of suffering, there are also ethical implications to not maintaining enough distance. Reading the bodily suffering as a language of disempowerment and empowerment helps one sympathize with the psalmist and also recognize the discourse of suffering as part of a construction of identity that intends to persuade and accomplish a particular, often violent, social goal.


Shelter on the Mountain of God: Telling the Providential Family Story Backwards
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Thomas D. Craig, Brock University/International Communicology Inst

Described by enthusiastic supporters as philosopher, theologian, counsellor, prophet, and leading 20th century Christian thinker, Rev. Francis August Schaeffer IV offered to travelling seekers of truth a spiritual refuge in a small village in the Swiss Alps. Beginning in 1948 as the European Headquarters for a separatist fundamentalist mission board, L’Abri Fellowship International officially became its own independent Christian ministry within a few short years. In 2006 L’Abri continues to attract contemporary converts with over ten affiliate branches and multiple properties in seven countries throughout Europe, North America, and Korea. This presentation is part of a larger project in which I examine the fundamentalist appeal to the Bible as cultural capital for a separatist agenda of Protestant Christian colonization. Legitimated by the one-step hermeneutic of direct, divine authority, the L’Abri family story demonstrates the ongoing power of mythical consciousness and homeworld pragmatics (i.e., my pragmatic space and mythical world feeling as objective orientation on the world). In addition to a brief examination of the mountain of God reference (Is 2:2-3) which continues to inform the L’Abri missionary endeavour, I use a convergence of phenomenological and semiotic orientations (Paul Ricoeur, Richard Lanigan, Yuri Lotman, Ernst Cassirer) to help unravel the various inscriptions, embodied expressions, and normative logics that helped to constitute this particular collaboration of separatist fundamentalist mission. As I will demonstrate, the official narrative synthesis of the L’Abri story both hides and reveals a largely contested social drama with notable casualties in the battle for truth. In sum, while originally presented in its official version from heterogeneous signs to divine blessing, unravelling this grand narrative configuration (i.e., “telling the story backwards”) offers a prescient opportunity to explore the function of providential organizational politics across a cluster of semiotic spaces that cling to a “blessed rage for order.”


Shelter on the Mountain of God: Telling the Providential Family Story Backwards
Program Unit: Semiotics and Exegesis
Thomas D. Craig, Brock University/International Communicology Inst

Described by enthusiastic supporters as philosopher, theologian, counsellor, prophet, and leading 20th century Christian thinker, Rev. Francis August Schaeffer IV offered to travelling seekers of truth a spiritual refuge in a small village in the Swiss Alps. Beginning in 1948 as the European Headquarters for a separatist fundamentalist mission board, L’Abri Fellowship International officially became its own independent Christian ministry within a few short years. In 2006 L’Abri continues to attract contemporary converts with over ten affiliate branches and multiple properties in seven countries throughout Europe, North America, and Korea. This presentation is part of a larger project in which I examine the fundamentalist appeal to the Bible as cultural capital for a separatist agenda of Protestant Christian colonization. Legitimated by the one-step hermeneutic of direct, divine authority, the L’Abri family story demonstrates the ongoing power of mythical consciousness and homeworld pragmatics (i.e., my pragmatic space and mythical world feeling as objective orientation on the world). In addition to a brief examination of the mountain of God reference (Is 2:2-3) which continues to inform the L’Abri missionary endeavour, I use a convergence of phenomenological and semiotic orientations (Paul Ricoeur, Richard Lanigan, Yuri Lotman, Ernst Cassirer) to help unravel the various inscriptions, embodied expressions, and normative logics that helped to constitute this particular collaboration of separatist fundamentalist mission. As I will demonstrate, the official narrative synthesis of the L’Abri story both hides and reveals a largely contested social drama with notable casualties in the battle for truth. In sum, while originally presented in its official version from heterogeneous signs to divine blessing, unravelling this grand narrative configuration (i.e., “telling the story backwards”) offers a prescient opportunity to explore the function of providential organizational politics across a cluster of semiotic spaces that cling to a “blessed rage for order.”


Ezekiel 36–39 in P967 and the Rest: Theology Makes the Difference
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
Ashley Crane, Murdoch University

Our interest in P967 Ezekiel occurs because of the combination of its unique chapter order wherein chapter 37 follows chapter 39, and its significant minus of 36:23c-38. My research into P967 examines proposals by scholars, who see an erroneous omission by the scribe (or precursor), be that by parablepsis, a removed ‘leaf’ from the parent text, or by accidental loss of a leaf. Interestingly, none arguing for error relate the omission to P967’s unique chapter order. Yet both these issues must be considered together. Separately they are part of the problem, and one may arrive at two separate proposals for each issue rather than one plausible answer for both issues. We propose 36:23c-38 is a later inserted pericope supporting the chapter reorder found in the received text. P967’s chapter order, and the received chapter order, are both logical and plausible yet reveal two eschatological viewpoints. These are also reflected in Daniel, Revelation, and Targum Numbers 11:26. P967’s order has God leading the battle against Gog, but the dead on the ground may implicitly include Israel, requiring the physical resurrection of dry bones that follow this battle. P967’s David is a peaceful shepherd who prepares for the Lord’s sanctuary and building of the Temple. The chapter reorder to that of the received text appears to have been motivated by a call to arms in the Maccabean times, to match their reality that required an oppressed people to unite against their oppressors. This reorder required the supporting insertion of 36:23c-38 as a call to purity. Their Davidic leader reflects David of old. We propose P967 is not an innovative or maverick text, but rather representative of an existing earlier tradition and theology. It may be demonstrated that P967 reflects the Old Greek tradition of Ezekiel, and even the Hebrew Vorlage.


John the Baptist, Elijah, and Eschatological Hopes: One Age Arrives, yet Another Predicted
Program Unit: Matthew
Carl Cranney, Yale Divinity School

Matthew 11:9-14 is a passage generally thought to have come from the Q source and is comparable to Luke 7:24-30. A major difference between the two accounts is that Matthew adds a comment about John being Elijah, “who is to come.” This phrase has no parallel in any of the other gospels except Matthew 17:10-13, where Jesus says Elijah “is indeed coming.” The Greek vocabulary and forms in both passages imply a future event. There are a few reasons the author of Matthew might have inserted the additions to the Q source. He may have viewed John the Baptist as a reincarnation of Elijah. But given the little evidence for belief in reincarnation during that period, this is not likely. Or, Matthew may be using Elijah to invoke feelings of a new age with John the Baptist standing at the threshold. Further, he may be invoking feelings of two new ages—the first age coming with the ministry of Jesus, the second with the triumphant return of Jesus at the eschaton. The second and third possibilities best fit into the consensus about the author of Matthew’s themes and reason for writing. Following the destruction of the Temple, the author wished to reassure his readers not only that a new age had dawned with Jesus but that another age was still to come. He wants to invoke eschatological feelings for events both in the past and in the future. For this reason he suggests that John is Elijah, who is to come.


Egypt among the Nations
Program Unit: Egyptology and Ancient Israel
John Crawford, Johns Hopkins University

This paper proposes to examine the relationship between the Israelite peoples and Egypt by looking in particular at the manner in which Egypt is treated by the narratives of the Pentateuch in comparison to the treatment of other foreign nations. The amount of material devoted to Egypt is quantitatively much greater than that devoted to other nations and, this paper argues, it is qualitatively different also. This, in turn, seems to indicate a deeper relationship between Egypt and the Israelite peoples than is commonly assumed. By examining what Israel knew about Egypt and how Israel dealt with Egypt in the Pentateuch, Israel's own formative text, this paper seeks to elucidate the manner in which Israel distinguished itself from Egypt and the justification for this separation.


Your Homer or My Homer? The Dilemma of Christian Paideia
Program Unit: Future of the Past: Biblical and Cognate Studies for the Twenty-First Century
Raffaella Cribiore, Columbia University

*


Shenoute of Atripe, Archimandrite, Prophet, Leper: The Religious Experience of Illness in an Early Christian Monastery
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Andrew Crislip, University of Hawaii, Manoa

Shenoute of Atripe (d. ca. 465) led a federation of three monasteries near the ancient Egyptian town of Atripe (near modern Sohag) for nearly eighty years. During his eight decades of leadership Shenoute composed what is recognized to be the largest source of original writing in the indigenous language of Egypt, including at least seventeen volumes of writings as compiled by his disciples and Shenoute himself. Among the interesting episodes in Shenoute’s life was a period of chronic illness. Shenoute quarantined himself in a hermit’s cave beyond the monastery walls while he suffered a disfiguring and shaming (his own description) dermatological condition that would be classified among the many skin conditions that ancients termed leprosy. Yet Shenoute continued to minister to his community as Father or Archimandrite through a series of letters, now preserved in several of his Canons. Shenoute’s is among the most sustained first person narratives of the illness experience in antiquity, and sheds rare light on the way that the religious drew meaning from illness as both tool and site for spiritual development and transformation. This paper will draw on recent advances in medical anthropology and the anthropology of experience (for example, the work of Arthur Kleinman and Arthur Frank) to describe how Shenoute constructs a narrative of illness, and employs his own process of suffering, treatment, and recovery as a tool for spiritual direction. Specifically, by narrating his illness intertextually through readings of Leviticus, the Prophets, Job, and the letters of Paul, Shenoute interprets his body as the locus in which the sins of his monks are made manifest and punished.


Reflections on the Past, Present, and Future of the Field of Palaeography
Program Unit: Paleographical Studies in the Ancient Near East
Frank M. Cross, Harvard University

During the course of the 20th and 21st centuries, the field has witnessed many developments. This presentation will focus on some of these, including some of the most recent (and often problematic) proposals. Note from the Chairs of the Session: Professor Cross will be presenting either in person, or via video.


“Where No Feet Dare to Go”: Nabonidus, as-Sila, and the Decline of Edom
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Brad Crowell, University of Toledo

Edom is well known as the enemy of Iron Age Judah within the biblical texts, but much of its history is obscured by a lack of primary sources. Some questions that remain difficult are when and how did Edom cease to function as an independent polity in southern Jordan. With the discovery of the rock carved relief of the Babylonian king Nabonidus and its accompanying inscription, certain aspects of the decline of Edom are becoming clearer. This presentation evaluates the various published reports of the inscription along with other texts describing Edom in this period to propose that Nabonidus attacked the key symbolic center of the Edomite elite at Busayra, probably in the year 551 BCE, or the fifth year of Nabonidus.


Imperial Family Values and Fictive Kinship among the First Urban Christians at Rome
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Mary R. D'Angelo, University of Notre Dame

In Romans 16, Paul greets a surprising number of men and women, by name, and often with descriptors or epithets that suggest missionary labor. These names are addressed to individuals, to male-female pairs, to mixed groups, to one all-male group, and to one pair of two women and one of two men. This (slide) essay brings togther prosopographical readings of Romans 16 with studies of the funerary portraits porduced by and for freedpersons at from Rome in the very late Republic and early Empire. Examining Romans 16 in the social and political context of these portraits offers significant insight into social conditions and imperial propaganda that helped to form these groupings. These portraits illustrate the ways that freedpersons constructed and reconstructed families. The conjuncture of social displacement and innovation moral rectitude, of resistance and accommodation conveyed in the portraits is also a factor in Romans. The portraits can help illuminate the combination of social innovations reflected in Romans 16, concession to imperial power expressed in Rom 13:1-7 and moral strictures voiced in Rom 1:18-31.


Weighing the Pros and Cons in Choosing a Grammar of Biblical Hebrew
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Helene Dallaire, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion

Over the past decade, the market has been inundated with a wide selection of new introductory grammars of biblical Hebrew. These publications vary in the areas of pedagogy, content, format, terminology, type of exercises, integration of biblical text, audience, and price. Does this increase in new publications reflect an advance in Hebrew pedagogy, or are the new textbooks simply duplicating what is already available in the field? Do advancements in technology necessitate new introductory textbooks or should technology simply complement what is already on the market? How does a faculty member choose from such a wide variety of new and old grammars? This paper will seek to answer these questions, and will examine how learners of classical languages require the availability of multiple approaches in order to achieve Hebrew proficiency.


“A Blessed State of Existence":Tertullian on Sexual Renunciation and Refiguring the Christian Household
Program Unit: Early Christian Families
Carly Daniel-Hughes, Harvard University

Sexual renunciation could challenge well-to-do Christian households by undermining their hierarchically-gendered organization grounded in the relationship of paterfamilias and materfamilias. Focusing on Ad uxorem (Ux.) and De exhortatione castitatis (Cast.), this paper examines how one early Christian author, Tertullian, minimized the potential threat to household arrangements from sexual renunciation by insisting that even in widowhood or perpetual virginity, “blessed states of existence,” women remain under male authority. Sexual renunciation is not an ultimate danger to gendered social arrangements because gender and sex are permanent features of the self. He casts widowhood and celibacy as practices that discipline Christian bodies and souls for life in a resurrected body, a body no longer suffering from passions or procreation. But he avers that Christian bodies still manifest this essential hierarchical difference. Speaking from the position of a well-to-do householder, Tertullian exhorts his wife (Ux.) and a widowed brother (Cast.) upon the death of their respective spouses not to fret over the potential disruption their new state poses. For instance, defining the church as an extension of the household, he stresses that a Christian woman retains a new dominus for whom she must organize her domestic and ecclesiastical tasks. Similarly, a man should not worry about disbanding his household; Tertullian advises him to secure a non-sexual union with a Christian sister to run his estate smoothly. By keeping gendered labor divisions intact and rooting them in a mildly refigured household, Tertullian tries to insure the economic and social relationships upon which the upper-class members of his community relied.


The Strangeness of Home: African Women and Womanist Biblical Hermeneutics Through Homi Bhabha's Middle Passage
Program Unit: African-American Biblical Hermeneutics
Lynne St. Clair Darden, Drew University

African women and African American women have been doubly exploited and marginalized. They have been subject to racial discrimination, gender domination and colonial exploitation, and thus further pushed into the periphery. Many postcolonial critics assert that the systems of U.S. slavery/disenfranchisement/racism and European colonization must be read "contrapuntually as one intertwined and overlapping process", thus the experiences of African Americans cannot be separated from the experiences of the colonized. This paper, therefore, proposes to examine African women and womanist biblical hermenuetics through the prism of postcolonial theory as articulated by Homi K Bhabha. The paper will explore concepts of the "unhomely", negotiation, hybridity, enunciation and re-presentation in relation to the interpretive task, foregrounding plurality and ambivalence. In addition, as part of this exploration, an investigation of the continuities and discontinuities of European colonization and the practice of "internal colonization" in the U.S. will be made exposing the differences between these two oppressive systems. The paper will question how these differences influence how African women and womanist biblical scholars negotiate meaning. The paper will support the position that postcolonial theory as articulated by Homi K Bhabha provides a viable theoretical possibility for establishing future collaborative works between African women and womanist biblical hermeneutics. Thus the paper will further open up new avenues of plurality, destablize boundaries of self/other and woman/woman.


Ezra, John, and First-Century Visions of Judgment and Recompense
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Robin Darling Young, University of Notre Dame

At least two visionaries spoke as prophets of judgment after the destruction of the Temple, and their revelations are displayed in IV Ezra and the Apocalypse of John. In this paper I am interested in comparing their narratives of judgment and punishment or reward. How does each recast the previous prophecies of, e.g., Daniel? How do the lots and abodes of the righteous or wicked reflect the manner and kind of destruction suffered by Israel at the hands of the nations? How do these places refer conceptually to the absent Temple? What is the consequence for each of the appearance of the Messiah? By placing these two texts in conversation I hope to make initial explorations of the crucial role that the destruction of the Temple played in the formation of the otherworldly topography of the early Christian and Jewish traditions.


Reading Jeremiah 32 from a Nationalized Place
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Steed V. Davidson, Luther College

Jeremiah’s ambiguous purchase of property in 32:1-15 has been interpreted as a sign of hope for the restoration of the city. This view adopts the ideology of the final form of the book and the designation of chs. 30-33 as the “book of consolation.” Using postcolonial and spatial theories, this paper will read Jeremiah's actions as a marker of nationalist resistance. Chatterjee’s conception of the nation as divided along the lines of the outer and inner domain, the material and the spiritual, will serve as the framework for reading distinctions of space and place in the text. The assertion of subjectivity in the text will be read in the choice to purchase property in the face of a siege rather than to engage in military defense. This choice represents a defense of the inner domain that relates to religion, family, law, culture, etc. as the markers of the nation; nationalized place as separate from sovereign space. As a defender of nationalized place, Jeremiah’s purchase of property along the lines of ancestral law enacts a defense of the nation’s inner domain as a form of resistance to imperial incursion. The paper seeks to reframe the conception of the purchase as a sign of hope for restoration to be seen as a sign of resistance. In so doing it shifts the locus of reading from a preoccupation with protection and restoration of territoriality to the maintenance of national subjectivity, i.e. from space to place.


A New Teaching without Authority: Preaching the Bible in Postmodernity
Program Unit: Homiletics and Biblical Studies
Andrew Davies, Mattersey Hall Graduate School

The response of the citizens of Capernaum to Jesus’ proclamation in Mark 1:21-27 highlights the ‘paradigm shift’ that his ministry inaugurated in the sphere of preaching. In comparison with the teaching of the scribes, Mark tells us, Jesus taught with authority. This paper uses this underestimated pericope as a springboard to explore the concept of authority in preaching, particularly in the light of the postmodern distaste for external authority, and seeks to assess the need for a further remodelling of the preaching paradigm, in terms of its very conception as much as with respect to its style. Does reconceptualizing power structures in society in general mean the death of the teacher-pupil and preacher-listener binary oppositions? Is the concept of authority now so firmly embedded in our concept of preaching, not least as a result of the ministry of Jesus, as to make it inherently ‘modern’ and doomed to irrelevance? If so, can literary criticism and the postmodern emphasis on story offer a useful model for non-authoritarian preaching (presuming the latter is both possible and desirable)? On the way I will address the question of whether cultural-critical approaches and the present focus on literary and iconic reception of the biblical texts have been the primary contribution of academic biblical scholarship to the present poor health of expository preaching before concluding with some practical suggestions for the way ahead.


A Den of Robbers: The (Second) Temple in the Book of Jeremiah
Program Unit: Social-Scientific Studies of the Second Temple Period
Philip R. Davies, Sheffield University

Jeremiah's criticisms of the temple (especially ch. 7) are generally taken to refer to the First Temple, though their Deuteronomistic language makes it doubtful that they come from the prophet himself - or that they are datable to the monarchic period. I shall consider the possible social, political and religious background of such criticism in Second Temple Judaism, where it probably has its setting.


The First History of Israel
Program Unit: Prophetic Texts and Their Ancient Contexts
Philip R. Davies, Sheffield University

The distribution of traditions connected to Benjamin within the books of Joshua-Samuel suggests that a continuous historiographical narrative - probably in written form - concerning the origin of the kingdom of Israel in which Benjamin played a leading role. This tradition not only provides the content for much of the present DH in Joshua-1 Sam, but also supplies a motive for the composition of that history, as a Judean response to it. A historical setting for both of these compositions has already been identified and explored, and the paper thus adds a further dimension to a scenario that is already being considered by several scholars.


Israel in the Books of Kings
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Philip R. Davies, Sheffield University

*


Canonical Texts and Canonical Scholarship (or, Worms in Cans)
Program Unit: Rethinking the Concept and Categories of 'Bible' in Antiquity
Philip R. Davies, Sheffield University

'Canonical' biblical criticism entails more than the treatments of James Sanders or Brevard Childs, who have explicitly engaged with some of the issues involved in an approach that privileges the canon as a historical or hermeneutical category. The sub-discipline of 'biblical studies' itself promotes such a view, though paradoxically its growing independence from theology and its closer alliance with the human sciences have gradually reduced 'canon' itself to a social phenomenon, an aspect of human cultural activity that organizes and creates 'knowledge' - thus deprivileging it. Historical and comparative studies of canon have played a central role in humanizing and thus de-divinizing its role. But if canon represents the plant 'above ground', the subterranean roots remain intact (thanks to the institutional context of much of the teaching of biblical studies), and canonical biblical criticism persists using the labels of 'testimony' (e.g. Long. Longman, Provan) or 'Western civilization' (e.g. Dever), which bypass the question of 'canon' and attempt to engage directly with 'history'.


'Scripture' as Prophetically Revealed Writings
Program Unit: Rethinking the Concept and Categories of 'Bible' in Antiquity
James R. Davila, University of St. Andrews, Scotland

This paper will (1) present some reflections on how ancient Jews and early Christians spoke of the scriptures and scriptural authority and (2) will speculate on what might have led them to continue writing scriptures pseudonymously in the names of earlier prophets. It will draw on a wide range of Second Temple Jewish and early Christian texts from a history of religions and an anthropological perspective.


The Hekhalot Literature and the Ancient Jewish Apocalypses
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
James R. Davila, University of St. Andrews, Scotland

This paper explores the relationship between the Hekhalot literature -- the pre-Kabbalistic corpus of mystical texts that give instructions on how to ascend (or "descend") to God's heavenly throne-chariot and to compel the angels to grant revelations -- and the verifiably Jewish apocalypses of the early centuries C.E. and earlier. The article views the Hekhalot literature from the heuristic social-scientific model of the practitioner (the "descender to the chariot") as "shaman/healer" and examines the apocalypses to determine which elements of this model already existed in the earlier period and whether these indicate a genetic relationship between the apocalyptic visionaries and the descenders to the chariot.


Divorce and the New Testament: Midrash in Matthew 19:3–12
Program Unit: Midrash
Anne Davis, Trinity Southwest University

"The divorce passage in Matthew 19-3-12 has led to several possible interpretations but no consensus as to its meanin. Although others have suggested the presence of midrash in this passage, this is the first study to conduct an extensive analysis of the mechanics of the two midrashic arguments in order to clarify the final conclusion about the eunuchs in Matthew 19:11-12. An appendix describes ten steps that others may follow to identify ancient midrash in the New Testament and to clarify the deeper meaning to which it is pointing."


Early Indian Christianity in Archaeology and Texts
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Basil S. Davis, Notre Dame Seminary, Graduate School of Theology

This paper argues that Paul's letter to the Romans assumes that India has been evangelized by an apostle and that the Book of Revelation assumes the existence of a viable Christian community in India. This study focuses on the trade between India and the Roman Empire and uses archaeological and textual evidence. The archaeological evidence of slashed Roman coins found in great numbers in India is explained using the latest scholarly insights into the book of Revelation. Thus a phenomenon that had been first observed by archaeologists nearly two hundred years ago is explained using the results of New Testament scholarship. Other texts employed in this study are the Periplus Maris Erythraei, Pliny's Natural History, Strabo's Geography and the Tamil Sangam poetry. This paper shows that Indian Christianity is the key to some of the puzzling elements in the book of Revelation. Thus the marriage of texts and archaeology yields the positive fruit of bringing India into the domain of “biblical lands.”


Reading Galatians 4:12–20 as Polemical Parody: Paul’s Reinterpretation of Pentateuchal Demands for Obedience to the Law
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Kathy Barrett Dawson, Duke University

I will argue that several enigmatic statements within Gal 4:12-20 are clarified if we recognize that Paul utilized rhetorical parody within his deliberative argument. My study will begin by briefly contrasting rhetorical parody, evinced by Quintilian and others, with the theatrical parody that appeared in Greek Comedies and was associated with ridicule and buffoonery. Although theatrical parody does appear in literature contemporary with Paul (e.g. Philo, Flaccus, 36-40), numerous studies of the meaning and use of parody in the ancient world by Murray, Householder, Rose, and Genette indicate that many forms of ancient parody did not imply disrespect for the original work and that ancient parody was not limited to the ridiculous or burlesque. I will depend on Genette’s description of ancient rhetorical parody as the recognizable quotation of a familiar text that is distorted to the degree that the quotation is separated from its original context and given a new meaning. After demonstrating that rhetorical parody was a part of discourse and should be separated from the post-Enlightenment understanding of parody as a genre characterized by the ridiculous, the majority of my presentation will discuss Paul’s use of rhetorical parody in Gal 4:12-20. I will contend that Paul is polemically reinterpreting numerous Pentateuchal demands for obedience to the Law by sufficiently distorting the recognizable statements in order to combat his opponents’ insistence on the circumcision of Gentiles. Paul carries out his polemic against the rival missionaries by parodying writings that, in a strictly literal reading, could be used to support his opponents’ position. Since understanding Paul’s statements as a parodic reinterpretation of Scripture employs intertextual controls, some of the dangers of mirror reading can be avoided with this interpretation.


Reading Galatians 4:12–20 as Rhetorical Parody: Paul’s Reinterpretation of Pentateuchal Demands for Obedience to the Law
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Kathy Barrett Dawson, Duke University

I will argue that several enigmatic statements within Gal 4:12-20 are clarified if we recognize that Paul utilized rhetorical parody within his deliberative argument. My study will begin by contrasting rhetorical parody, evinced by Quintilian and others, with the theatrical parody that appeared in Greek Comedies and was associated with ridicule and buffoonery. Although theatrical parody does appear in literature contemporary with Paul (e.g. Philo, Flaccus, 36-40), numerous studies of the meaning and use of parody in the ancient world by Murray, Householder, Rose, and Genette indicate that many forms of ancient parody did not imply disrespect for the original work and that ancient parody was not limited to the ridiculous or burlesque. I will depend on Genette’s description of ancient rhetorical parody as the recognizable quotation of a familiar text that is distorted to the degree that the quotation is separated from its original context and given a new meaning. Ancient rhetorical parody should be understood as a figure of discourse and should be separated from the post-Enlightenment understanding of parody as a genre that deals with the ridiculous. Next, my presentation will discuss Paul’s use of rhetorical parody in Gal 4:12-20. I will contend that Paul is polemically reinterpreting numerous Pentateuchal demands for obedience to the Law by sufficiently distorting the recognizable statements in order to combat his opponents’ insistence on the circumcision of the Galatians. Paul carries out his polemic against the rival missionaries by parodying writings that, in a strictly literal reading, could be used to support his opponents’ position. Since understanding Paul’s statements as a parodic reinterpretation of Scripture employs intertextual controls, some of the dangers of mirror reading can be avoided with this interpretation.


"The Way Forward" or Two Steps Back? Assessing Davila's "The Provenance of the Pseudepigrapha"
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Chad Day, University of North Carolina, Charlotte

In his recent book, James R. Davila proposes an ostensibly more rigorous methodology than previously applied to determining original socio-religious contexts of Old Testament pseudepigrapha. In this paper I wish to problematize both this methodology and Davila’s overall approach to these often confounding texts. For instance, I charge that Davila’s program is plagued by outdated quests (e.g., authorial intention, “background” of the New Testament, motif history, etc.), disconcerting reifications of Judaism and Christianity, a welter of token definitions, and potential misrecognition of the import of Kraft’s “Setting the Stage and Framing Some Central Questions.” While Davila admits in his conclusion that his agenda “simply reinforces what we already thought we knew” and that “the methods developed here articulate far more clearly how we know what we know and what we do not know,” his approach, I argue, only demonstrates how much farther we have to go in effectively untangling the intertextuality (and context?) of various pseudepigrapha. Finally, I conclude my analysis by proposing more productive strategies and conceptualizations for future reassessments of these captivating parabiblical texts.


"Surely, He Has Not Spoken to a Woman"
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Esther A. de Boer, Theological University of Kampen, the Netherlands

From the abundance of early Christian images of Mary Magdalene it seems impossible to draw any conclusions about a historical figure. To be sure, she is portrayed as a witness of the crucifixion, the burial and the resurrection of Jesus. But the early texts differ in their stories about what exactly it is that she is a witness of and whether that would be important. In addition, according to some texts she has kept silent about her experiences, but in other texts she tells about them: reminding the disciples of what Jesus said to all of them earlier or bringing a new message which was revealed to her alone. After that, she either withdraws and nobody hears of her any more or like Paul she sets out to preach the gospel. However, several texts explicitly demonstrate that the general perception of the authority of women over men determines how Mary Magdalene is seen. When studying the early discussion about this theme the different images of Mary Magdalene fall into place.


Why Recover Women's Voices in the History of Interpretation?
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Christiana De Groot, Calvin College

Do women really interpret scripture differently than men? What contribution do women make in the history of exegesis? The paper explores the issue of universal women's experience, and what the distinctive features of women's contributions might be. The paper draws on the insights of second and third wave feminism to support the project of recovering women's voices in the history of interpretation.


Partial Repetition in the Book of Numbers and the Translator
Program Unit: Bible Translation
L.J. de Regt, United Bible Societies

Chapter 4 of the Book of Numbers deals with the duties of the Levite clans of Kohath, Gershon and Merari. Some translations not only divide this chapter into shorter sections (vv. 1-20; 21-28; 29-33; …), but formulate the section headings in the same way (“The Duties of the Levite Clan of Kohath / Gershon / Merari”, respectively). These headings wrongly suggest that the three Levite groups are on an equal level and are given equal tasks. The text of chapter 4 shows repeatedly that the duties of the clans of Kohath are more closely connected to the holy objects of the tent of meeting than are the duties of the other clans. Although Kohath was not Levi’s eldest son, his clans come first. Kohath, as Aaron’s grandfather, was a closer relative to Aaron the high priest than were Kohath’s two brothers. All this is borne out by the differences in phraseology between these sections. At times the repetition between the sections is only partial. For example, the Hebrew la`asôt mel’akhah ‘to do work’ (in the tent of meeting) only occurs in v. 3, in connection with the special clans of the Kohathites, to which Aaron and his sons belong. The phrase la`asôt mel’akhah does not occur in connection with the other Levite clans in vv. 23 and 30, where a more submissive formulation is used in the Hebrew: la`avod `avodah ‘to render service’ (in/of the tent of meeting). This seems to underline that their task is less central and perhaps more subordinate than that of the Kohathites. Few Bible translations actually show these differences. Analysis and comparison of phraseology has a bearing on the interpretation and translation of this chapter. If headings for shorter sections are used in a translation, they should be adapted accordingly.


Psalm 44: O God, Why Do You Hide Your Face?
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Nancy L. Declaisse-Walford, Mercer University

Psalm 44 is the first of eleven community laments in the Psalter. Its words suggest that people have gathered to cry out to God about a dangerous situation—military attack, political persecution, or some other action against them. Its rhetoric is unique among the community laments because only here does the entire congregation declare its innocence before God and claim undeserved suffering. Job and Psalm 73 wrestle with unjust suffering at an individual level. Psalm 44 wrestles with it at a community level. The people scrutinize themselves: Have we betrayed God? Should God turn away from us? The answer is a persistent: "No." God's people cannot reconcile their experiences with their understanding of God. Tradition links Psalm 44 to the persecutions of Antiochus IV Epiphanes. The Babylonian Talmud states that verse 23a, "Awaken! Why do you sleep, my Lord?" was, at the time of the Maccabees, sung daily by the Levites. But many times in the life of ancient Israel fit the message of Psalm 44: the Assyrian attack on Jerusalem in 701 BCE, the destruction of the temple in 587, the Israelite exile that lasted until 538 BCE. Abraham Heschel dedicated his work on the Prophets to the martyrs of the Holocaust by quoting from Psalm 44. Psalm 44 provides a glimpse into the rhetoric of ancient Israelite worship. People and leader alternate their voices in cries to the Lord, protesting their innocence in the face of danger and demanding that the Lord act on their behalf. Their pleas are based on the blunt accusation that God has, for no reason, withheld his power, not rescued, and not informed them of their wrongs because (they claim) none existed--God is reminded of God's hesed toward the community of faith.


Ideology Concerns Discourse: Inspiring Ideas from Vernon Robbins about Early Christian Tapestries, Textures, and Pre-gospel Traditions
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
April D. Deconick, Illinois Wesleyan University

*


Matthew 5:8 and 22:23–33
Program Unit: New Testament Mysticism Project
April D. Deconick, Illinois Wesleyan University

A commentary on Matthew 5:8 and 22:23-33 will be presented.


New Ethiopian Manuscripts in North America
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Steve Delamarter, George Fox University

Since February 2005, the presenter has located over 90 previously unknown Ethiopian manuscripts currently located in North America. These manuscripts are in the possession of four dealers, four private parties and one University. In each case we have made arrangements to photograph the manuscripts in high-resolution digital photography. In conjunction with Getatchew Haile of the Hill Museum and Manuscript Library (St. John’s University, Collegeville, MN) we have completed physical descriptions and catalogued the content of the manuscripts. The contents of the manuscripts range from Ethiopian Psalters and other biblical and service books and hymnals to historical works. Sets of images of the mss are being deposited at the HMML as well as other research libraries and institutions. This presentation will describe the process of acquiring the images, cataloguing the content and preparing the images for research.


Scribal Practices in Ethiopian Psalters as Expressions of Identification and Differentiation: An Illustrated Lecture
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Steve Delamarter, George Fox University

This study is based on a comparison of more than forty Ethiopian Psalter manuscripts which the presenter has photographed and catalogued (see the presentation “New Ethiopian Manuscripts in North America”). The Psalter of the Ethiopian Orthodox Church has many distinctive features which we will detail and illustrate. We will demonstrate in what way these features are expressions of community identity and differentiation. First, at the level of the canonical material (the Psalms of David and the Song of Songs), we will detail such issues as distinctive language, script, canon, textual affiliation, organization and content. Second, we will detail the distinctive features that fall into the category of para-canonical material such as the presence of the collection of biblical canticles, The Praises of Mary and the Gate of Light and the presence of the distinctive illuminations in Ethiopian manuscripts. We will show how it is that these materials create an interpretational context for the canonical material. Third, there are a host of distinctive features at the level of scribal practices, for instance, the distinctive layout of the Psalms of David in one column with one verse on one line, the layout of the Praises of Mary and Gate of Light in two columns, the special use of red ink for various purposes, the colometric layout of certain sections of the Biblical Canticles, the use of navigation systems in the codex, the preparation of the vellum, the layout and organization of quires, the binding of the codex often with tooled leather and enclosed in a mahdar (carrying case), etc. In closing, we will sketch a general theory of the significance and meaning of scribal practice as it relates to Biblical manuscripts.


The Cycle of Life in Ecclesiastes
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Katharine J. Dell, University of Cambridge

An exploration of the way the voice of earth is heard in a cyclical view of nature presented in Ecclesiastes, notably in passages such as Eccl. 1:4-8 and 11:3-5. Also an investigation into the way imagery is used from the natural world in the book as a whole, looking especially at the use of animal imagery, as from members of the earth community outside the human and yet integrally related to the human. Argument that instead of simply illustrating human life as part of the dualistic worldview of the book, e.g. in 3:16-21, that in many ways earth and its creatures define human life within the context of earths character, cycles and abundance.


Jeremiah: A Prophet's Engagement with Power and Politics
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Carol J. Dempsey, University of Portland

Persistent and courageous in the face of opposition and threat, the prophet Jeremiah is, perhaps, one of Israel's boldest and bravest prophets who not only addresses the political and religious leaders of his day but also interfaces with them. From a literary perspective, this paper explores selected speeches made by Jeremiah to the leaders of his day (e.g., 17:19-27; 22:1-30), as well as those passages that feature him interacting with leadership, e.g., his interaction with Pashur (20:1-6), Zedekiah (21:1-10; 38:14-28), Hananiah (28:1-17). Additionally, the paper examines Jeremiah's interaction with God, the Sovereign One (4:9-10; 5:1-19) who has appointed Jeremiah over nations and kingdoms. Lastly, the paper offers a hermeneutical comment that connects the character, times, and work of Jeremiah to life in the twenty-first century where contemporary power and politics beg an engaged prophetic response. Thus, a character of uncompromising strength and integrity, Jeremiah embodies the vocation and mission of a prophet par excellence and offers listeners today not only a vison of hope but also an alluring challenge resounded perennially in the prophetic question, "Whom shall I send?"


Isaiah 28: The Poetics of Prophetic Judgment
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Carol J. Dempsey, University of Portland

The prophets were skilled and creative poets whose messages were not only powerful and poignant but also highly imaginative. This paper explores the literary and rhetorical techniques such as imagery, metaphor, and irony found in Isaiah 28. Creative, imaginative, and persuasive, this woe speech (vv 1-4) and instruction (vv 5-29) attests to Isaiah not only as a prophet but also as a poet par excellence who delivers a provocative message to the political and religious leaders of his day whom he holds responsible for the community's degradation.


Zora Neale Hurston's Use of Biblical Studies in Moses, Man of the Mountain
Program Unit: African-American Biblical Hermeneutics
Deirdre Dempsey, Marquette University

Scholars who discuss the sources Zora Neale Hurston used for her 1939 novel _Moses, Man of the Mountain_ usually focus on African American folklore. Hemenway, in his biography of Hurston, mentions her use of Flavius Josephus; he, and other scholars, have also suggested that she might have read the first two chapters of Sigmund Freud's _Moses and Monotheism_, published first as articles in _Imago_. In this paper, I consider how Hurston might have used the academic biblical studies of her day. Specifically, I look at how Hurston seems to have known the Kenite Hypothesis, theories current at the time about the route of the Exodus, theories about the Hyksos in Egypt, and other biblical studies "standards" and incorporated these ideas in her novel, _Moses, Man of the Mountain_. I consider what sources Hurston might have read, both in her anthropology studies at Barnard and Columbia and after, when she was researching the novel in the mid-1930's.


Coming Soon to a Classroom Near You: Reflections on Using Pop Culture to Teach the Bible
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Nicola Frances Denzey, Bowdoin College

Using popular culture to facilitate discussion of biblical texts and themes is becoming increasingly common in contemporary classrooms. This paper will first consider the theoretical implications of such pedagogical strategies. It will then suggest ways in which cultural items such as clips from films, the Simpsons and Saturday Night Live, music and music videos, and internet sites may be used to teach the Bible. The presentation will conclude with a short teaching demonstration.


Out of Sight But Not out of Mind? Matthew's Use of Q in Matthew 5–7
Program Unit: Q
Robert Derrenbacker, Regent College

It is clear that Luke’s method of adapting Mark and Q on the Two-Document Hypothesis (2DH) is a relatively simple technique of taking his sources in large blocks, essentially preserving the order of the material as the evangelist finds it. Matthew’s Gospel presents a different set of problems for the 2DH. In Matthew’s case, there is significant reworking of the order of the material in his sources, particularly when it comes to Q. This paper will analyze Matthew’s use of Q at the Sermon on the Mount (Matthew 5-7) in light of the role that memory and orality played in literary composition in antiquity.


Blessed are the Baby Killers: Cognitive Linguistics and the Text of Psalm 137
Program Unit: Cognitive Linguistics in Biblical Interpretation
Mary Therese Des Camp, Graduate Theological Union

*


Seeing the World through John's Eyes: Rhetography in Revelation
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
David A. deSilva, Ashland Theological Seminary

"Rhetography," or the pictorial texture of texts, builds upon the insights of cognitive theorists that the mind's ability to "picture" what is spoken is essential to the cognitive processing of narrative and argument, and that these pictures, in turn, evoke social and cultural settings, patterns, and learned "logic" that nurture the argumentative force of the text. This paper explores the rhetography of Revelation 14:6-13 as a starting point for socio-rhetorical analysis of this passage.


Five Fragments of a Codex of Exodus in Greek
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
David A. deSilva, Ashland Theological Seminary

This paper seeks to make available five papyrus fragments of Greek Exodus, from the same codex as seven fragments previously presented (now available in VT 56/2), written in expert uncial script between the mid-fourth and mid-fifth century CE. Four of these fragments, when combined with fragments three and four from the previous collection, yield six consecutive, fragmentary pages bearing witness to the text of Exodus 10:24-13:7, the only extant papyrus witness to those chapters of Exodus. This manuscript continues to resist the temptation to harmonize the Greek text to the Hebrew (here, notably in the instructions concerning the observance of the Passover internally or with ritual requirements found elsewhere in the Pentateuch). Examining forty-nine places in the text where variant readings exist, these fragments diverge from each of the text types found in A, B, F, M, and the O-group more frequently than they align with the variant readings found in each, suggesting considerable independence of the major text families. These fragments recommend themselves as a valuable witness to the text of Exodus based on their independence of known text types, their non-revisionist character (in regard to the tendency to conform the Greek text to the MT), the general care exhibited by the scribe (whose errors are indeed few on these pages), and their antiquity. Their importance is augmented as the sole papyrus witness to the narrative of the first Passover, the tenth plague, and the instructions for the perpetual observance of the Passover. The presentation will include photographic scans, the critical texts of these five fragments, and an analysis of its variant readings vis-à-vis the critical editions of Rahlfs and Wevers.


Aseneth, Religious Experience, and Transformation: How an Egyptian Priest's Daughter Became a Jewish Seer
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Celia Deutsch, Barnard College/Columbia University

"Aseneth" presents a case study on the motif of transformation in the context of religious experience in early Jewish and Christian literature. In this late antique romance the author interprets Gen 41:45 to explain how Joseph, a patriarch in Israel, could marry the daughter of an Egyptian priest. S/he presents readers with a study in transformation enacted bodily in ascetical practices, cognitively/imaginatively in visionary experience, and socially in Aseneth's conversion, change of marital status and the use of scribal allusions -- usually ascribed to males -- to describe that process. A high-born woman undertakes a series of ascetical praxes (fasting, vigils, weeping, unbinding the hair, wearing sackcloth) and recites extended prayers. These performances induce and enact a state of liminality in which Aseneth is "between" idolatry and status in her father's house on the one hand and inclusion in the people Israel and status as Joseph's wife on the other. A heavenly Visitor descends and converses with Aseneth, using conventions from biblical and apocalyptic commissioning stories, as well as language redolent of late antique adjuration rituals. Aseneth becomes a sage and seer in Israel, as well as a matriarch. She is then described as disciple not only of the Visitor, but of the priestly scribe and seer Levi, and of her husband the patriarch Joseph. Conversion here involves the convergence of male and female gender roles.


Matthew 11:25–30
Program Unit: New Testament Mysticism Project
Celia Deutsch, Barnard College

A commentary on Matthew 11:25-30 will be presented.


Is the Goddess at Home?
Program Unit: Israelite Religion in its Ancient Context
William G. Dever, Emeritus, The University of Arizona

In West Semitic languages and conceptual worlds, a temple is the “house” of the deity—the place where the god’s or the goddess’s power and invisible reality is made palatably present. In ancient Israel, there was to be only one temple, that built by Solomon under divine command in Jerusalem, ideally the national cult center because Yahweh was uniquely and eternally present there. But we now know from archaeological evidence that many local shrines, cult centers, and even temples flourished in Israel and Judah, despite being prohibited by the official priesthood, prophetic reformers, and in time the canonical literature. And it is increasing clear that in “folk religion” a pair of deities could by be “housed” in the temple: Yahweh and his consort Asherah (even in Jerusalem). In addition to real life temples from the Iron Age, we now have a number of small terra cotta model temples, or naoi, both from Israel’s neighbors and from Israel itself. Yet biblical scholars and archaeologists have neglected them. This illustrated paper will discuss several 9th-7th cent. BCE naoi that have come to light recently, attempting in particular to interpret their complex iconography with what we know of the imagery connected with the Goddess Asherah. A figure of her may be missing in these naoi as preserved; but the goddess was once at home. And a proper appreciation of her long obscured role in West Semitic and Israelite religion can enhance our understand of the beliefs and practices of both “book” and “folk” religion.


Moses Allegorizes phusikôs: Reevaluating the Notion of Physical Allegory in Philo of Alexandria's Legum Allegoriae
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Steven Di Mattei, Ecole Pratique des Hautes Etudes

In trying to ascertain the meaning behind Philo‚s use of the adverb physikôs in his allegorical method, commentators have sought to compare this usage with Stoic allegorical procedures, thus concluding that Philo uses the term to denote some form of Stoic physical allegory‚ or more generally Scripture’s hidden physis.‚ It has also been claimed that such terms as physikôs and physiologia were used by both Stoics and Philo alike as technical terms which simply denoted allegorical interpretation.‚ This paper, however, through an analysis of Philo‚s use of the adverb physikôs in his Legum allegoriae, argues that the term more properly signifies that branch of philosophy which deals with the study of nature, that is physics. Thus, when according to the claims of Philo, Moses allegorizes physikôs, he is putting forth allegorically a philosophical doctrine pertaining to that branch of philosophy entitled physics. Thus physikôs is not some esoteric exegetical term but properly a philosophical term.


Synagogue-to-Church Conversions and the Archaeology of Jewish-Christian Hybridity
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Paul Dilley, Yale University

Despite much recent attention to the fate of temples in the Late-Antique Mediterranean, synagogue-to-church conversions have received only occasional study. In my paper, I review the literary evidence for this aggressive practice of monumental change, including neglected genres such as apocryphal literature and homilies. I argue that synagogue-to-church conversions became widespread immediately after the destruction or closing of prominent public temples in the early fifth century, concurrent with the declining legal status of Jews, who had become the sole remaining religious group alongside Christianity in many public urban landscapes. Both the Theodosian Code and Christian literature of the fifth and sixth centuries present an ambiguous portrayal of the Jew as simultaneously object of hatred and valuable potential convert, a tension reflected by the competing imperatives of "zealous" aggression and "legal" dialogue in narratives of synagogue-to-church conversion. I show how the figure of the converted Jewish patron in such narratives works as a response to these two models for religious interaction. I next turn to the remains of Christian basilicas which some scholars have identified as converted synagogues, and I discuss their different reasons for doing so. Although the literary evidence suggests that synagogues could become churches through eviction or purchase, there are frequent descriptions of a more destructive transition, including arson, robbery, and extensive if not complete architectural damage; I consider the relevance of both type of account for evaluating material culture. Finally, I discuss the option of reading Jewish symbols in Christian architecture either as evidence for Jewish-Christianity, or as spolia from a forced takeover. In this way, the question of violence enters the archaeology of Jewish-Christian hybridity.


Stagirius and the Trauma of Conversion: Demonic Epilepsy, Suicidal Tendency, and Monastic Self-Formation in Late Antiquity
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Paul Dilley, Yale University

John Chrysostom’s epistolary treatise To Stagirius, Demoniac, is unique in antiquity for its detailed presentation of a personal struggle with epileptic illness. Stagirius is a young aristocrat who has recently converted to the monasticism; before doing so he was healthy, but his new life is troubled by continual falls, foaming, and loss of consciousness in front of his fellow ascetics, incidents which are attributed to demonic attack. Driven to despair (athumia) and contemplating suicide, Stagirius seeks the help of his friend Chrysostom, who responds with this work in three volumes, which I analyze as a prominent example of consolation rhetoric (logos paramuthetikos) adapted to the Christian ascetic context of spiritual direction. In contrast to Greek medical attempts to effect a cure through a change in regimen, as represented by Galen’s Letter to an Epileptic Boy, Chrysostom, echoing ascetic theorists such as Origen and Nilus, argues that demonic attacks of illness are themselves a therapeutic measure sent by God which have already helped Stagirius improve his monastic practice. I show how Chrysostom attempts to reconfigure Stagirius’ shame for his illness, a sense of embarrassment which most medical writers take for granted, by shifting its focus to his feelings of depression and suicide, because they represent the controllable aspects of his condition, in contrast to the epileptic attacks. Chrysostom frequently describes Stagirius’ post-conversion experience of illness and demonic attacks in the language of trauma, making use of a widespread theme in ancient monastic literature; in conclusion, I argue that this emphasis on self-formation through repeated traumatic attacks provides an important alternative to William James’ classic model of conversion, followed by A. D. Nock and other scholars of ancient religion, as a cathartic shift from a “sick soul” and a “divided self” to a condition of “saintliness.”


Qumran Studies in Israel: Achievements and Prospects
Program Unit:
Devorah Dimant, University of Haifa

For more than fifty years Israeli scholarship on the Dead Sea Scrolls has distinguished itself by its unique and often pioneering contributions in five major areas of Qumran research: text editions and detailed commentaries of scrolls; analysis of the Qumran scrolls, particularly their theological makeup and their links with early Christianity; the calendar of the Qumran sectarians; the peculiar halakhah of the Qumran community; and the Hebrew language of the scrolls. This paper will trace the principal lines of research in these domains, and the achievement and characteristics of the scholarly works that were produced in Israel during this period. The presentation will wind up by a survey of on-going research and future trajectories.


The Composite Character of the Qumran Sectarian Literature as Indication of its Date and Provenance
Program Unit: Qumran
Devorah Dimant, University of Haifa

Recent studies have shown in great detail the composite character of the major Qumran sectarian works and the variety of their underlying sources (the Rule of the Community (1QS), Hodayot (1QHa), the War Scroll (1QM) and the Damascus Document). This calls for a new evaluation of the date and provenance of these sectarian texts. However, present critical discussions continue to assign the sectarian literature dating and origin proposed forty years ago, when only a handfull sectarian texts were known and their inquiry was at its infancy. The present paper proposes a diffirent and new approach for these problems.


A Hope for Status Inversion in the Acts of Thomas
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Edward Dixon, Yale Divinity School

This paper attempts to illuminate the social reality of those people who produced and first read the Acts of Thomas (AT), as well as the ideals for which these people stood. The paper contrasts the actual third century socio-political world of the Roman Empire with the very opposite story world of the AT. Specifically, I argue that the AT uses its stories of Thomas to establish a motif of subversion and inversion of well-established social hierarchies. Three stories in the AT resolve themselves with an inverted social order (the story of the king and his daughter in the first act, King Gundaphorus and Thomas in the second and third acts, and finally, the marriages of both Charisius and Mygdonia and King Misdaeus and Tertia, as well as the political relationship between Misdaeus and Siphor, in acts nine and following). By concentrating on well-defined power relationships (parents and children, kings and slaves, husbands and wives), the narrative clearly presents a story-world in which the lowly are raised and the raised are brought low. The status reversals depict a re-structured society that was unrealizable in the third century Roman Empire. I am suggesting that the motif of status reversal reveals the “community’s” bleak situation in the present age, but that the AT’s authors temper the present state of affairs by providing their readers with eschatological hope for an inverted social order. I conclude the paper by comparing this motif in the AT with the Gospel of Luke. I suggest that the hopes expressed by the AT place its producers and readers in a stream of eschatological thinking similar to Luke’s Magnificat (1:46-55).


Blessing in Text and Picture in Israel and the Levant: The Constellations of Khirbet el-Qom and the Stela of Yehawmilk of Byblos
Program Unit: Israelite Religion in its Ancient Context
Martin Leuenberger, University of Zurich

The paper investigates the nature and relevance of the blessing topic in Ancient Israel and the Levant on the basis of a comparison of two selected primary sources in order to clarify some key issues and problems of the research on blessing in general. (1) First of all, the selected examples allow for a concrete and specific description of two bless-ing phenomena. (2) With respect to method, there result two major insights in the ap-propriate sources for investigation: The importance and the potential of the so called primary sources gain evidence, especially in the context of OT exegesis. In the light of recent discussions in OT and Oriental research, the relevance of pictures in addition to and in combination with texts becomes quite indisputable. (3) In the Levantine context, blessing appears in different cases as a basic factor of religion – a factor that, at least in the treated examples, shapes the religious symbol systems and is characteristic for them: Distinct basic constellations of blessing are perceivable in their changing localizations in religious symbol systems and enable to trace the religious- and theological-historical transformations of blessing and theologies of blessing in ancient Israel and the Levant. From this one can derive first and tentative conclusions for a more general depiction of blessing and theologies of blessing in ancient Israel and the Levant.


Possible Halakic Traditions behind the Purity and Defilement of a Sacrifice According to Didache 14
Program Unit: Didache in Context
Jonathan A. Draper, University of KwaZulu-Natal

Chapter 14 of the Didache is widely regarded as late and redactional, and it is interpreted against the background of later Christian Eucharistic practice. However, it is not obvious at all why a quarrel should render a sacrifice impure. It is striking that considerations of ritual purity dominate the baptismal and eucharistic rites of Didache 9-10 as well as here. The occasion and reference of the kuriakh kuriou are obscure, as is the reference to breaking bread and giving thanks itself. The material refers primarily to sacrifice (thuo) and its ritual purity. The concern here lies with what would render such a sacrifice unclean, and the case of someone who has wronged her/his neighbour is a given as a test case. The text is explored against the possible background of Jewish halakah.


Matthew 12:6 and 18:20
Program Unit: New Testament Mysticism Project
Jonathan A. Draper, University of KwaZulu-Natal

A commentary on Matthew 12:6 and 18:20 will be presented.


The Latter-day Saint New Testament Electronic Database
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
Richard D. Draper, Brigham Young University

This report will describe the contents of a massive, full-text research database of virtually all LDS writings relevant to the New Testament.


Is Porphyry a Source of Marius Victorinus, Adversus Arium?
Program Unit: Rethinking Plato's Parmenides and Its Platonic, Gnostic, and Patristic Reception
Volker Henning Drecoll, Universität Tübingen

The paper will review Hadot's hypothesis that Marius Victorinus is deeply dependent on Porpyhry. Checking Hadot's arguments in front of the recent discussion about the date of the Anonymous Commentary in Plato's Parmenides as well as the possibility of other Platonic or even Gnostic sources the paper will compare the philosophical thoughts used by Victorinus with those of Porphyry's fragments and writings. The difference between these two philosophical approaches has to be integrated in a new view of Victorinus' method of writing. Kevin Corrigan and John Turner have been contacted.


Eve's Redemption: Rewriting Genesis and Re-visioning Womanhood in Late 19th Century America
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Kristin Du Mez, Calvin College

Protestants Katherine C. Bushnell and Lee Anna Star worked to combat the patriarchal traditions of Christian theology by constructing radical reinterpretations of the Christian Scriptures in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. This paper focuses on their reconstruction of the book of Genesis, particularly the accounts in which Eve appears, by situating Bushnell and Starr in their historical and cultural context. Through their reinterpretation of Eve, Bushnell and Starr contested Victorian understandings of morality, womanhood, and motherhood, and challenged the very foundations of the Victorian social order.


"Beloved": Reading Exodus 2 as a Text of Terror
Program Unit: New Historicism and the Hebrew Bible
Jaqueline Du Toit, University of the Free State

The relationship between mother and child is considered sacred by human society. This paper will suggest a reading of Exodus 2 as an example of infanticide. The politics of memory inherent to later biblical interpretation of this text seems to downplay the implied child neglect perpetrated by Moses’ mother. With no indication that she had any foreknowledge of the bathing practices of Pharaoh’s daughter, may this text be read as another example of the limited, but existing number of accounts of slave mothers killing their children in circumstances of utter desperation? Infanticide throughout the ages often became a marker of the “immoral”, more “primitive” and “deprived” “other”. This paper will consider this against the broader backdrop of child sacrifice in Syro-Palestinian religions and the Bible and compare this with the underplaying of this and other acts of violence in the representation of acts of violence in children's bibles.


Multi-layered Balanced Thought Structures in Psalm 24:4
Program Unit: Biblical Criticism and Literary Criticism
Rodney K. Duke, Appalachian State University

Psalm 24, once thought by some scholars to consist of three disparate sections, has been seen as a unitary piece, once it was viewed as a liturgical processional song. The second section may be seen as following a catechism-like structure of four parts: question, answer, result, and identification. Balanced-thought structures (“parallelism”) play a key role in the psalm. Recognizing the balanced structure of verse 6 (the “identification”), for instance, solves the problem of a difficult text that has led to emendation. More specifically in this paper I focus on the intricate layers of balanced structures in verse 4 (the “answer”). A close reading of this text shows how the literary artistry of the form was use to complement and reinforce the content and so create a greater communicative impact. Four different levels of “balance” are found in this verse, all of which emphasize the concept of the total purity that is expected from one who would enter the Temple to worship.


The Empty Tomb: Matthew as Memory-Maker and Memory-Breaker
Program Unit: Mapping Memory: Tradition, Texts, and Identity
Dennis C. Duling, Canisius College

In the context of the social memory wars, which reflect broader culture wars and philosophical issues surrounding universalism and constructionism, the Gospel of Matthew can be interpreted as social memory maintained, constructed, and contested. To arrive at a perspective within the context of social memory studies, critical decisions have to be made about matters such as genre, orality and scribality, sources, and reading, writing, oral performance, the potential for cynicism, and the Post-Modernist mood. These issues are especially important in the case of the guard at the empty tomb story, found only in Matthew. Generally, the gospel maintains a social identity with Israel that recalls archetypal heroes, events, norms, and practices. Yet, the gospel contests Israelite memories by dramatizing Jesus in a way that leads to conflict with “official” memory. Again, the gospel maintains a memory of Jesus that is in continuity with early believers’ oral traditions and sources; yet, it constructs a new image especially relevant for its own Israelite community. Specifically, a symbol of this continuity-discontinuity identity is the empty tomb. Against believers who doubt and non-believers who charge that the corpse was stolen, the truth defended is that the tomb was empty because Jesus was raised from the dead. That memory has been maintained, constructed, and contested over time. Examples are the Church of the Holy Sepulchre as a memory site and believers and modern rationalists who offer alternative explanations of the empty tomb. The paper will address these issues with attention to works on social memory from Halbwachs to the present.


Reading the Bible Brick by Brick
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Ruben Rene Dupertuis, Centre College

Illustrated and comic book Bibles are typically targeted at children and are designed to make the stories in the Bible appealing and understandable. Then there is the Brick Testament, an ongoing online project that translates the Bible into the medium of Lego blocks. The artist, Brendan Powell Smith, is at times playful, wickedly sarcastic and oddly respectful of the texts. In this paper I will explore the Brick Testament’s readings of several passages, and will suggest that Smith exploits his chosen medium’s association with children to underscore the decidedly alien and adult content of much of the Bible.


Piety and Authority: The Philosophers' Parresia and the Trial Scenes in Acts
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Ruben Rene Dupertuis, Trinity University

Language and imagery associated with philosophers became a significant literary topos in 1st and 2nd century C.E. Greek literature in part because of the ability of philosophers to symbolize pious resistance to tyrants. One aspect of this popular philosophical imagery, the parresia or boldness attributed to them, became, among other things, shorthand for speaking openly to power and challenging authorities despite the risk to their lives. In this paper I will look at the ways in which the topos is appropriated in the portrayal of the early Christian community’s resistance to the oppressive Jewish authorities in Acts 4-5 and again in the successive trial scenes in Acts 21-26. I will argue that the allusions to Classical Greek literary models (notably traditions associated with Socrates) clearly fit within the mimetic literary ethos of the period and that each appropriation presents a complex negotiation of cultural identity through the use of the categories and language of Greek paideia.


Golgotha to Abu Ghraib: Meaning and Torture
Program Unit: Bible and Cultural Studies
Nicole Wilkinson Duran, Trinity Presbyterian Church

The cross in Hebrews and the John may be a mystical, otherworldly sacrifice, but in The Gospel according to Mark it is torture and execution. This paper will first look at how Elaine Scarry’s insight that pain destroys language illumines the conflict of body and word in Mark’s gospel, where Jesus’ silence is most extreme and where the gospel itself seems loathe to speak, except of impending destruction. From there I will draw on Foucault’s Discipline and Punish to discuss how the meaning of a tortured body--whether it is Mark’s image of the cross, or photographs from Abu Ghraib--moves in two opposing directions. Even while they shock us with the brutality of state power, these images also serve to affirm and exaggerate the dimensions of that power. Finally, the public and secret dimensions of both contemporary torture and Mark’s presentation of Jesus’ death provoke questions of whose message these bodies are and who can hear them, if the tortured are by definition silent.


Discourse Analysis: Thematization, Topic, and Information Flow
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
James D. Dvorak, McMaster Divinity College

Overview of discourse concepts: Thematization, Topic and Information Flow with an application to 1 John


Noli me tangere: Intertextuality with the Song of Songs in John 20
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Bobbi Dykema Katsanis, Graduate Theological Union

The Da Vinci Code has captured the imaginations of American audiences in often wild and inflammatory ways, raising questions of the sexuality of the most holy person in Western cultural history, and of whether his biological descendants might yet be walking among us. These questions are not altogether new. Theologians and artists have for centuries recognized the sexuality of Mary Magdalene, as well as her relationship to Jesus, and have struggled to give form to that relationship in myriad ways. At once saint and whore, beloved and reviled, apostle and outcast, the Magdalene herself has inspired the imaginations of painters, sculptors, illuminators and printmakers since early in the Christian era. In this paper, I will examine the intertextuality of the Song of Songs and the resurrection account in John 20 in depictions of the Magdalene in Noli me tangere images from the northern Renaissance—images which are contemporary with Leonardo and yet in some ways more faithful to the biblical account than those of the Italian Renaissance. In their depictions of the encounter between the Magdalene and the risen Christ, northern Renaissance artists such as Albrecht Dürer and Hans Holbein the Younger have given us images of the holy in humanity, and vice versa, that speak to all of our humanness—not just spirit, but the body also. The characters in the scene recall other episodes in the sacred drama: Christ appears as the new Adam, tending the Garden of Eden; Mary is the new Eve, seeking after knowledge. Jesus is also the Beloved of the Song of Songs, with Mary his Lover, seeking after him in the heavenly garden. Such pictures can raise provocative questions of existential meaning that resonate across faiths and cultures, initiating a dialogue about our most basic inquiry: what it means to be human.


Which Persian Monarch Rebuilt the Temple: Artaxerxes or Darius?
Program Unit: Social-Scientific Studies of the Second Temple Period
Diana Edelman, University of Sheffield

I will summarize the main textual arguments in my 2006 monograph, The Origins of the 'Second' Temple: Persian Imperial Policy and the Rebuilding of Jerusalem (London: Equinox Press), for dating the rebuilding of the temple to Artaxerxes I, as part of the reorganization of the province of Yehud that included the moving of the district capital from Mizpah to Jerusalem. These include 1) that the genealogies in Nehemiah suggest at most a 30-year time gap between Zerubbabel and Nehemiah; 2) that the dates in Haggai and Zechariah 1-8 are secondary, as in all the prophetic books, and designed to show the historical fulfilment of Jeremiah's prediction of 70 years of devastation for the land of Judah (Jer 25:11-12; 29:10); and 3) that Ezra 1-6 has been composed using biblical sources only and is designed to show the fulfilment in real time of prophetic predictions about the rebuilt temple in Isaiah, Jeremiah, Ezekiel, Haggai and Zechariah 1-8. Finally, the reliability of the claim in 2 Macc 1:10-2:18 that Nehemiah rebuilt the temple will be evaluated.


World of Ideology and Social Reality in the Deuteronomic Family Laws
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Cynthia Edenburg, Open University of Israel

Deut 22:13-29 is a tightly knit literary unit, built upon a concentric framework into which the paragraphs have been arranged in order of severity. Thus, the section should not be viewed as a chance selection, but rather as a deliberately designed group of laws. At the same time, the laws in Deut 22:13-29 present a picture of women’s standing which is at variance with the social realities reflected by other witnesses in the Bible and ancient Near Eastern legal literature. This paper explores the ideologies which shaped the deuteronomic family laws in Deut 22:13-29, and examines the different literary and social contexts of similar legislation from the ancient Near East.


Rewriting, Overwriting, and Overriding: Techniques for Editorial Revision of the Deuteronomistic History
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Cynthia Edenburg, Open University of Israel

Study of the redaction of the DtrH over the last forty years has concentrated, to a large extent, on identifying various deuteronomistic redactional strands and reconstructing different editions of the DtrH. For the most part, change in theme (occasionally accompanied by change in style of language and composition) has served as the main criterion for analysis, while the nature of the editorial techniques for revision has largely gone neglected. Biblical authors could employ a variety of editorial strategies for revising pre-existing texts, all of which were considered valid for their purposes. An author could expand a narrative with new material reflecting his tendencies, and thus shift the reader’s perception of the text’s purpose, or he could rewrite it according to his own outlook, while omitting conflicting views. In a third, lesser-known method, an author refrains from revising the pre-existing material, and attempts to influence the reader’s stance toward the subject targeted by appending new blocks of narrative, which challenge the reader to question the concepts and ideals embodied in the previous meta-narrative. In this paper, I propose to examine how the different editorial techniques were employed in relation to the DtrH. Particular attention will be devoted to examining how the third technique served post-deuteronomistic authors, who restructured the historical narrative with new prologues and appendices, and thus contributed to the breakdown of the deuteronomistic meta-narrative. I will argue that these efforts at restructuring the historical narrative were aimed at redirecting readers’ attitudes regarding tendencies implicit in the DtrH, and in effect, challenged its claims of authority.


Recent Work in Galilee: A Village and Its Region
Program Unit: Archaeological Excavations and Discoveries: Illuminating the Biblical World
Douglas R. Edwards, University of Puget Sound

An extensive survey of sites was begun in the summer of 2005 in an area 10 km around the ancient village of Khirbet Qana (Cana of the Galilee). This paper presents the preliminary results of that study, which included survey of 20 of the over 200 sites in the area and initial work on the extensive archival information in the Israel Antiquities archive, which includes past surveys and excavations beginning with the mandate period. The paper also discusses the implications of recent numismatic work by Dr. Danny Syon as well as other surveys and excavations for the information they give regarding the social, cultural, and political character of Galilee, especially in the Roman period. The goal of the project is to discern the relation of villages to one another as well as to larger urban centers, notably nearby Sepphoris and Tiberias. Preliminary work indicates that villages were not isolated economically or culturally from the urban centers nor from one another. Nor is there evidence of strict cultural isolation from surrounding non-Jewish territories, although there are strong indications of cultural differentiation as evident in such features as stone vessels and miqvaot (ritual bathing pools).


Tyche, Gad, and Qoheleth
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Chad Eggleston, Duke University

While biblical scholars no longer posit a simple genetic relationship between “Hellenistic culture” and Qoheleth, many persist in privileging Greek ideals to the exclusion of ANE concepts in their readings of the work. Consider, for example, the surprisingly consistent appeals to tyche in attempts to understand Qoheleth’s conception of fate (miqreh). Though this focus on tyche has proven illuminating, the complexity of cultural interaction demands that readers think not only about Greek conceptions of fate, but also about ideals closer to Ancient Israel’s socio-historical context. Rather than seeking a single corresponding signifier, it is fruitful to consider a group of words from both Greek and ANE contexts. Towards that end, this paper attempts to broaden the conversation regarding Israel’s conception of fate by closely considering the concept of gad, like tyche a word that signifies in various historical periods both a general concept and a deity. Evidence from Palmyra, Phoenicia, and perhaps even Lachish suggest the worship of Gad as a god of fortune or chance from “long before the Hellenistic period” (Blenkinsopp, Isaiah 56-66, 278; AB 19). Moreover, the worship of the deity Gad appears in Isaiah 65.11, wherein Israelites are said to have forgotten the Lord’s “holy mountain” in their veneration of the deities Gad and Meni. If it is true that some Israelites were worshipping Gad in the post-exilic period and that such worship had been present in the Levant for centuries, why then do scholars turn so quickly to Hellenistic concepts to understand fate in Qoheleth? Taking a history of religions approach, this paper traces the evidence for gad in ancient Israel and seeks to place this concept next to tyche as another parallel concept by which one might understand Qoheleth’s use of miqreh.


Reading Paul’s ‘Hearing of Faith’ in Concert with Scripture and Feminist Theory
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
Kathy Ehrensperger, University of Wales - Lampeter

Power is a central concept for feminist theory. In recent years a wide variety of feminist perspectives on power have emerged some of which have moved beyond a concept of power as mere domination and power-over, or concepts restricted to a perception of power as being shaped according to a command-obedience model. It has been recognized that such models do not sufficiently account for the power of the powerless and subordinate, and also do not adequately encompass the diversity of forms of power that are present in social interaction. In response to this, feminist theorists (drawing on theories of e.g. Hannah Arendt) have been developing theories of power which are attentive to the empowering dimension of power as well as to its dominating aspects ( including their potential overlaps). Instead they propose a threefold perception of power as power-over, power-to and power-with. In this paper I will read the Pauline discourse of obedience, which has often been perceived as a discourse of domination, in concert with such threefold feminist perceptions of power. I will thereby pay special attention to the dimensions of power-to and power-with presupposing that Paul’s use of obedience language should be heard as being primarily rooted in a Jewish symbolic universe. His use of u(pakoh/ - u9pakou/ein and a)koh/ - a)kou/ein thus seen as being informed by the scriptural discourse of the Hebrew word stem ??? which is very much part of the covenantal discourse of the Scriptures, and thus part of a relational discourse. This discourse is constitutive of Israel’s identity as people of God and can thus legitimately be described as a relational and empowering discourse. The thesis advocated in this paper thus is that ( in) reading the Pauline discourse of obedience in concert with the scriptural discourse as well as recent feminist perceptions of power has much more positive potential than traditional readings of the Pauline discourse might imply. Kathy Ehrensperger University of Wales Lampeter 17.3.06


Imagining Mary Magdalene: The Discourse of the Hidden Past in Popular Culture
Program Unit: Q
Jodi Eichler-Levine, Columbia University in the City of New York

In this paper I analyze how Americans draw upon the authority of both ancient “hidden” texts and the authority of scholarly discourse, even overtly fictional scholarly discourse, in their imaginings of the “re-discovered” figure of Mary Magdalene. Dan Brown’s The Da Vinci Code has contributed enormously to the explosion of Magdalene devotion. Although I do not focus on the book, its presence hovers powerfully over the discourses I study. As case studies, I examine the literature of several communities that venerate Mary Magdalene (often identifying themselves as “Gnostic”), all of which have a strong presence on the World Wide Web. These are: “The Sophia Fellowship,” adherents of “Sophian Gnosticism,” which also holds meetings in Sacramento, California; the Magdalene Circle, based in Columbus, Ohio; the “Order of Mary Magdala,” an Internet site with lengthy, detailed prayers, creeds, and stories surrounding Mary; and “The Gnostic Church of St. Mary Magdalene,” which combines Marian worship with tarot, Gnosticism, and Kabbalah. I also take into consideration the bibliographies these groups compile, a pastiche of academic, popular, and ancient sources. By looking to “new ancient” scriptural authorities in order to re-present and laud or advance women's spirituality, many feminists are remaking the same move that more traditional authorities have long made to suppress women--- they are privileging the authority of antiquity and exoticizing the hidden, “mysterious” past. The imagery of ancient authority also echoes throughout the last decade of American popular culture. Whether Americans do so intentionally, as in the case of celebrating “Sophian Gnosticism” or reading The Da Vinci Code, or more obliquely, when watching Buffy the Vampire Slayer or The Lord of the Rings, they are drawn into a conversation that rests upon an ideology of hidden wisdom.


Paul the (Ex?)-Pharisee: Paul's "Conversion" Revisited
Program Unit: Social History of Formative Christianity and Judaism
Pamela Eisenbaum, Iliff School of Theology

Virtually all scholars assume that Paul did not simply adopt something new when he embraced the risen Jesus, he also rejected something old. Even for those scholars who argue that the apostle did not reject “Judaism as such,” it is generally understood that Paul rejected his identity as a Pharisee. Put briefly, it is not so much Paul’s embrace of Jesus that makes him a convert, but the rejection of his former self that causes the label “convert” to stick to Paul. I argue that the current image of Paul-the-Convert depends either on uncritical assumptions about what a Pharisee was, or on the tendentious use of historical evidence. From my assessment of various historical sources (the gospels, Josephus, the DSS, and rabbinic traditions), I will argue that, contrary to the image of the Pharisees as conservatives and “strict constructionists,” the Pharisees were best known for the way in which they accommodated Jewish scripture and tradition to real-life and often changing circumstances. The Pharisees were the “liberals” of their day. I intend to demonstrate that the accommodationist ethic of the Pharisees is evident in Paul’s letters, especially in his teachings on divorce and in his attitude toward idolatry in 1 Corinthians. Paul’s one reference to having been a Pharisee (Philp 3) is raised not so much to signal his rejection of Pharisaism but to let his audience know that he was schooled by the Pharisees, and thus show he is better credentialed that his opponents. While Paul rejects the status that supposedly adheres to the label “Pharisee,” he does not reject Pharisaism per se. In summary, I will argue that Paul never rejected his identity as a Pharisee, and thus should not be regarded as a convert.


Luke's Possible Progymnasmatic Improvement on Paul's Letter to the Romans
Program Unit: Formation of Luke and Acts
Paul Elbert, Church of God Theological Seminary

In this preliminary study I suggest that a progymnasmatically trained author could reasonably want to improve and clarify a previous respected letter that he expects his own readers to likely be familiar with. This procedure is briefly documented via such similar imitation and emulation by Apollonius, Aretaios, Galen, and Theon in the Greek tradition and by Seneca, Quintilian, and Cicero in the parallel Latin tradition. I set out the dozen or so textual comparisons or verbal agreements between Romans and Acts. I note occasions within the speeches by Paul in Acts where concepts developed in Romans seem to be recast in the new narrative format. I also note concepts mentioned discursively without exemplarity in Romans which receive a needed progymnasmatic clarification via examples and precedents in Luke-Acts. The cummulative impression may be that such identifiable traces of the Paul of Romans are intentional, so as to both portray and improve upon the historical Paul and his ideas in the most convincing narrative manner. I will suggest that the literary personification of the Lukan Paul is, in part, quite possibly formed with the Paul of Romans in mind and that perhaps other ideas developed in Romans are redeployed by Luke in a narrative-rhetorical manner.


Rabbinic Textures of Memory: The Case of the Temple Mount
Program Unit: Mapping Memory: Tradition, Texts, and Identity
Yaron Z. Eliav, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor

In a good deal of rabbinic literature the sages convey information, both directly and indirectly, about their past as individuals, a group, and a nation. Scholars in the last century and a half have invested tremendous effort in weighing the credibility of these records. This study explores a different angle of the historicity question, that of rabbinic collective memory, the set of conventions and images that organizes narratives and discourses about the past. Portrayals of the Temple Mount in tannaitic literature create the impression that they derive from the milieu of Second Temple Judaism. Rabbinic sages in the post-70 era present a picture of the Temple Mount as an essential part of the preceding Second Temple Jewish experience and an inseparable part of reality in that earlier generation’s consciousness. The current study refutes this wide spread notion; it maintains that the authors of rabbinic literature endowed a relatively peripheral biblical appellation, namely the term “Temple Mount,” with an aura of holiness and transformed it to represent a concept of sacred space. This innovative development led them to redesign their view of the present and at the same time remake their memory of the past.


Leviticus as the Groundwork for Christian Spirituality
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Mark Elliott, University of St. Andrews, Scotland

This paper will give examples of interpretation of Leviticus's Holiness Code through four ages: late antique ,medieval, early modern and modern, but also across four genres of reception: homily, canon law, commentary and catholic social teaching. It will aim to show a continuity of the receivers' view of biblical legislation as both positive and religious and yet at the same time natural and rational, and therefore to some degree timeless. The paucity of artistic representation of Leviticus should not make one think that the book has lacked cultural influence: if anything this has been arguably more profound and therefore more subversive. The issue of some parts of Leviticus encouraging and other parts offending against conceptions of natural justice will be explored.


“A Novel Dama to Undo Me:” Characters and Discourse in Achilles Tatius
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Scott S. Elliott, American Bible Society

Taking its title from a reference to Fortune’s recurring role in “scripting” the “drama” that befalls the protagonist, this paper analyzes characters and characterization in Leucippe and Clitophon to determine how these figures are constructed and the nature of their relationship to anything beyond the limits of the narrative. The paper first investigates the ways in which characters, like the novel itself, are pieced together by means of paradoxical admixtures, ocular positionings, and the alternating presence and absence of speech and action. After considering each of these modes in turn, I will suggest that the characters of Leucippe and Clitophon are ensnarled in the same crisis of representation as that of the novel itself. The paper then demonstrates that this crisis of representation in the novel is mirrored by the fundamental distinction between “story” and “discourse” that serves as the basis of contemporary narrative theory. Just as the way a story is told always threatens to subvert the story it intends to tell, the writer’s effort to make present that which is otherwise invisible is always at risk of falling short and unraveling. I conclude by arguing that fictional characters, in and of themselves, are devoid of any ability to either propel the plot or to exist outside of it. Rather, the narrative itself, by means of a plot, consigns figures to particular roles, and thereby simultaneously undermines any capacity they might seem to possess to perform those roles independently.


Empire as Metaphorical Family: God’s Family vs. Caesar’s Family
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
Susan Elliott, 1st Congregational United Church of Christ

The role of metaphor in political and moral discourse has recently been discussed by linguist George Lakoff, particularly in his work Moral Politics. He proposes that such discourse relies on the root metaphor of family, viewing the nation as a family. The key difference undergirding a frequent experience of mutual unintelligibility of liberal and conservative perspectives in contemporary discourse is the pattern of family relationships each is assuming. These patterns are designated as "Strict Father" and "Nurturant Parent" corresponding to conservative and liberal political and moral perspectives. The family metaphor is also a major element in the success of the Roman imperial cult as a binding force for the early Empire, relying on the form of "Strict Father" family assumed as the norm for the elites. Familial language in teachings attributed to Jesus reveals an alternative family metaphor both at the level of language and of family praxis. This paper will examine the household images in several parables and teachings in the gospel of Luke as illustrations of an alternative vision of family and the body politic.


Solomon's "Wisdom" Reconstructs David's Command (1 Kings 2:31–33)
Program Unit: Semiotics and Exegesis
Teresa Ann Ellis, Brite Divinity School

On his death-bed, King David orders Solomon to act according to his “wisdom” in killing Joab ben Zeruiah. When Joab takes sanctuary in the tent of the LORD and grasps the altar, Solomon must justify the execution. Solomon’s speech (1 Kgs 2:31-33) transforms David’s message. The speech incorporates a set of elements derived from David’s, using the element of ‘blood’ as the main tool in the reconstruction. Solomon’s speech shifts ‘blood’ from David’s images of physical gore into the abstract condition of ‘blood-guilt.’ The shift of blood-imagery bridges a discontinuity in David’s speech, transforming David’s personal vendetta into Solomon’s act of filial piety. Furthermore, the semantic artistry of Solomon’s speech transforms the necessary precondition for the establishment of a Davidic dynasty—David’s command that Solomon should “walk before” God becomes Solomon’s command that Joab should die. Solomon’s kingship ensures his victory over Joab, but it is not clear that Solomon has ‘won’ the encounter. Joab’s manner of death has forced Solomon to justify his actions—a position of moral power—and the less a reader believes Solomon’s justifications, the greater the moral power that accrues to Joab, who has exposed the falsehoods and raised troubling questions about Solomon’s “wisdom.”


From Poetry to Parshanut: An Intertextual Study on the Exodus Psalms
Program Unit: Poster Session
David Emanuel, Hebrew University of Jerusalem

A cursory glance through the Psalter reveals numerous allusions to events in Israel's literary history. While a range of literary and oral sources were obviously available to psalmists, the relationships between these sources and the psalmists' final work are more obscure. Concerning these relationships, numerous questions remain unanswered: how strictly did the psalmists replicate their sources, what kinds of alterations did they make (additions, omissions, etc.), did they alter the meaning of their sources in their own compositions? Departing from the more classical approaches to researching the psalms-engaging in the determination of Sitz im Leben and Gattungen-this intertextual dissertation addresses the aforementioned issues by focusing on a group of psalms associated with Israel's Exodus tradition (primarily 78, 105, 106, 135, and 136). Through a detailed comparison of lexical correspondences between the psalms and other locations in biblical literature, together with a relative dating of each psalm, the study identifies literary sources employed by the psalmists. It additionally includes a close reading of each psalm to establish the unity and meaning of each composition. After performing the aforementioned tasks, the study analyzes and categorizes lexical variances between each psalm and its sources, providing potential explanations for alterations found between the two, and revealing how the psalmists reinterpreted their biblical sources. Though the study has not yet been fully concluded, the impression received is that the psalmists were actively engaged in altering earlier biblical records in a variety of ways. Consequently, from the preliminary results it is possible to broaden our understanding of the psalmists' work and include them among Israel's earliest biblical interpreters.


A Stoic Understanding of Pneuma in Paul
Program Unit: Hellenistic Moral Philosophy and Early Christianity
Troels Engberg-Pedersen, Copenhagen University

Within the context of the Copenhagen project on “Philosophy at the Roots of Christianity”, the paper presents a reading of Pneuma in Paul that aligns it closely with Stoic cosmology. Two overlapping problems are identified to begin with: (i) the relationship in Paul between talk of cognition (e.g. in Rom 7:7-25) and talk of infusion of what looks like a material Pneuma (e.g. in Rom 8:1-13); (ii) the relationship between “philosophy” (e.g. in “sophia among the perfect” in 1 Cor 2:6-16) and “apocalypticism” (“revelation” and “mystery” in the same passage). The paper then argues in four stages that the problems may be solved by bringing in a Stoic understanding of the Pneuma. (1) Where Cicero in De Natura Deorum II presents a Stoic materialist cosmology and ontology, the two later Alexandrian Hellenistic Jewish text corpora of the Wisdom of Solomon and Philo show signs of moving from a Stoic starting point towards a Platonic, non-materialist understanding of God. Paul, who had read Wisdom, was acquainted with both the Stoic (cf. Rom 1:18-25) and the Platonic (cf. 2 Cor 4:16-5:10) world views. (2) However, 1 Cor 15:35-55 presupposes a materialist understanding of the resurrection body and its connected cosmology along Stoic lines. (3) Other passages in the Pauline conceptual network of Pneuma talk are in line with this. (4) The scope of this network is sufficiently large for us to conclude that Paul’s world view is on a par with the philosophical ones. Only, Paul did not take the Platonist step of his Jewish brothers but stayed with the Stoic world view. Within this framework there is no opposition between a cognitive and a materialist understanding, nor between “philosophy” and “apocalypticism”.


Immigrant Debt Practices and Biblical Interpretation, the Twain Shall Meet: (Up)setting the Price on koinonia in Reading Acts 4:32–5:11
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Juan Escarfuller, Vanderbilt University

To speak about a relationship between economics and biblical interpretations evokes an adage that never the twain shall meet. An analysis of koinonia in Acts 4:32-5:11 in the light of that relationship opens up worlds of meaning for both reading the New Testament and redressing public policy. An account of la tanda (an informal, micro-finance, rotating, savings and loan association among Latina/os in the US) provides a context for such a scriptural analysis. The hermeneutical aim of this paper is to highlight the potential of biblical narratives and economic praxis to orient each other toward an ethical awareness of their impact on the livelihood of real communities. This impact is a life-and-death matter for immigrant peoples who pay with their work lives to partake of a social system that results in the enrichment of a minority at the expense of the enslavement of the majority through debt. This paper interprets koinonia in Acts 4:32-5:11 in a way that offers a challenge and alternative to exacting this deadly price for immigrants to “make it” and belong in the US community. In light of Latina/os who seek alternative debt practices while paying with their lives to participate in US society, this paper raises a question of scripture: For what do Ananias and Sapphira pay with their lives in Acts 5:1-11 and lose membership in the fellowship of the community? This interpreter’s response converges koinonia, debt bondage and ethnic identity issues in reading Acts. The response makes the case that reading koinonia in Acts 4:32-5:11 adds to the political ecology debate on Latina/o debt bondage, and vice versa, that this debate adds to the history of interpretations on that text such that resistance to such bondage is an interpretive option for this text for particular readers.


From 'Exile and Restoration' to 'Exile and Reconstruction:' Surveying the Landscape of Interpretations
Program Unit:
Tamara Eskenazi, Hebrew Union College-Jewish Institute of Religion, California Branch

*


Social Identity and Therapeutic Stories in the Gospel of Mark
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
M. Elisa Estevez, Universidad Pontificia Comillas, Madrid, Spain

As Maurice Halbwachs has shown the collective remembering is central to the experience of a community. The markan community has put record of how the stories of healings were transmitted in the houses and the ways. The memory of which it has happened in the therapeutic encounter to Jesus constitutes a strategy to maintain and enhance group identity. The collective identities are nourished by collective memory pro­viding bonds with the past that are extended in the time until the future (retroactive and proactive memory). Some stories send to the healed ones to their houses, and in the case of the gerasene man with a concrete mission, to narrate what it has lived. The narration of these therapeutic encounters would offer a new significance to the family/house as a place where it is possible to follow Jesus too and that it is formed around the interpretation of the past according to Jesus’ group.


Feeding the Five Thousand and the Eucharist
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Craig A. Evans, Acadia Divinity College

The purpose of the present study is to explore the possibility that the feeding story of John 6, made up of the multiplication of the loaves and fishes and the “eucharistic” discourse, may constitute tradition that predates the Synoptic Gospels, where the feeding story is separate from the eucharist. Most interpreters assume that what is disparate in the Synoptics the fourth evangelist has combined. In John 6 we may have not a late combination of feeding miracle and discourse but early tradition that has been edited to reflected interest in Jesus as the giver of the new covenant. Thus, the bread of the eucharist has become the manna of the wilderness.


The Hezekiah-Sennacherib Narrative as Polyphonic Text
Program Unit: Bakhtin and the Biblical Imagination
Paul S. Evans, Wycliffe College

The Hezekiah-Sennacherib narrative of 2 Kings 18-19 has commonly been viewed as an incoherent narrative composed of multiple sources, necessitating a diachronic approach. However, this hypothesis is really only a heuristic model suggesting we read the pericope in this way. This study would instead suggest a Bakhtinian approach viewing this pericope as a polyphonic composition which will account for both the disjunctions within the narrative and its unity. This narrative can be seen as a dialogue of genres with 1) history-like narrative, 2) direct speech and 3) prophetic oracle all in implicit dialogue. This narrative may be read as “dialogic” as different voices intersect in this pericope revealing a plurality of viewpoints that cannot be explained by a single consciousness. This pericope juxtaposes: 1) the Rabshakeh’s first speech (“Yahweh has sent me and Hezekiah will deceive you”) which is in dialogue with Isaiah 10 (Assyria=Yahweh’s punishing rod); 2) Hezekiah’s response (“Sennacherib mocks the living God”); 3) the Rabshakeh’s second speech (“your God will deceive you and Yahweh cannot save you”); 4) Yahweh’s verdict (“I indeed sent him, but will also send him back”); and 5) the concluding narrated event (Sennacherib’s death). The conclusion of this polyphonic work is not definitive—was Assyria the rod of Yahweh’s punishment or was he merely an example of the fate of blasphemers? Lacking a monologic concluding comment by the narrator to state his viewpoint—though such comments are commonplace (cf. 2 Kings 18:12), perhaps our author here was intrigued by prophetic assertions that Assyria was God’s punishing rod and others claiming that Assyria’s defeat was God’s arrangement. Rather than stating in a monologic way the significance of Sennacherib’s defeat, he instead describes a dialogue and an event.


Back to the A-B-(Cs) of the Stade-Childs Hypothesis: The Application of both Source and Rhetorical Criticism to 2 Kings 18-19 and its Implications for Reassessing Historical Referents and Causal Links
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Paul Evans, Wycliffe College

This paper provides a close reading of the Hezekiah-Sennacherib narrative of 2 Kings 18-19 which, with the aid of a Rhetorical analysis, will: 1) reassess putative sources found in the text (questioning the traditional A and B source delineations); 2) reveal common misreadings of the biblical text (e.g., that a siege of Jerusalem is referred to and that Sennacherib’s army is said to be defeated outside the walls of Jerusalem); and 3) point to causal links heretofore unrecognized (e.g., why, in the narrative, the Assyrian emissaries come to Jerusalem when Hezekiah already capitulated). This study will then analyze the implications of these results for the use of this biblical text in historical reconstruction.


Service Learning in Undergraduate Biblical Studies Courses
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Janet S. Everhart, Simpson College

Service-learning is becoming more and more popular on campuses across the country and is increasingly recognized as a legitimate pedagogical approach within a wide range of disciplines. This paper will explore the advantages and challenges of integrating academic service-learning into undergraduate biblical studies classes, particularly in the Liberal Arts setting. How is learning enhanced when service becomes a lens for reading various biblical texts? How can this learning be effectively measured? What are the trade-offs in terms of other assignments/material covered in class? What new demands are placed on the teacher? How does the pedagogy of service-learning relate to emerging interpretive trends in the discipline of biblical studies? One hoped for outcome of this paper, based on the author’s growing experience with service-learning in a variety of biblical studies classes, is to stimulate dialogue among colleagues as we experiment with this pedagogy.


Aging Angels: Investigating the Date of Pseudo-Jonathan in Light of Rabbinic and Targumic Angelology
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
David L. Everson, Hebrew Union College

Among the various targums, Targum Pseudo-Jonathan (PsJ) is thought to preserve some of the earliest and latest material. Not surprisingly, PsJ has been dated as early as the time of Ezra (M. Kasher) and as late as the Crusades (D. Rieder). Some have dated it to the fourth century (cf. R. Hayward and P. Flesher), while most others have accepted a post-seventh century date (cf. M. Ohana, A. Shinan, D. M. Splansky, E. M. Cook, and J. A. Foster). This paper seeks to reconsider the issue of PsJ’s date in light of targumic and rabbinic angelology. The date of PsJ will be examined in light of the following categories: (1) rabbinic angelological contentions, (2) the attestation and use of angelic names, and (3) the development of angelic aggadah. Regarding category one, it is possible to determine, in part, the development of rabbinic angelology by examining the changing opinions of the rabbis on contested issues (e.g. the use of fallen angels to explain the origin of evil). Where does PsJ fit in light of this development? Regarding category two, more so than any other targum, PsJ provides a large number of angelic names (Uriel, Zagnugael, Jophiel, Metatron, Samael, Shamchazai, etc.). Where else do these names appear and what might that entail for PsJ’s date? Regarding category three, angels have prompted a staggering amount of rabbinic exegesis. What aggadic parallels do we find in PsJ’s treatment of angels and do those parallels hold any significance with respect to the date of PsJ?


Erotic Look and Voyeuristic Gaze: Looking at the Female Body in the Bible and Art
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
J. Cheryl Exum, University of Sheffield

Is the gaze voyeuristic (i.e., objectifying, looking that intrudes upon that which is seen)? When is looking erotic (looking that participates in that which is seen) and how different is the erotic look from the voyeuristic gaze? The paper investigates some of the ways looking at the body—in particular female bodies that are naked or partially clad—is represented in the biblical text by focusing on four examples: the story of Susanna and the elders, where looking is explicitly condemned, the story of David and Bathsheba, where looking is implicitly condemned, and the Song of Songs, in which looking is mutual and erotic, though perhaps not always so, and, by way of contrast, the story of Joseph and Potiphar’s wife, where a woman casts her eyes upon a man. To illustrate the suggestiveness, subtlety, and complexity of these texts in which looking features so importantly, the paper considers various ways artists have responded to textual clues; e.g., preserving the erotic look, turning the look into the gaze, reinscribing the voyeuristic gaze or introducing it or even, as in the case of Joseph and Potiphar’s Wife, reversing it.


Antichrist Superstar and Martyred Celebrity: Marilyn Manson's Appropriation and Transformation of Revelation's Beast and Lamb
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Thomas Fabisiak, Emory University

Through an analysis of interviews and lyrics from the late 1990's, I will explore the manner in which industrial/goth rocker Marilyn Manson appropriated and transformed two significant images in the book of Revelation, the Beast(s) of Revelation thirteen and the Lamb of chapter five. I will begin by briefly discussing how his appropriations are mediated by a dialogue with Evangelicalism, Satanism, Nietzschean philosophy, and Aleister Crowley’s occultism. The most significant part of the project, however, will be an exploration of the rhetorical functions and effects of his appropriations, and will in particular evaluate his work as a social critique. I will focus on the manner in which Manson situates the (American Evangelical) images of the Beast as Antichrist and the Lamb as model apocalyptic martyr firmly within a late twentieth century American culture of violence and celebrity. He recreates the character of the Beast as the “Antichrist Superstar,” the presumably excluded other who not only conditions the possibility of a systematic American soteriology, but simultaneously emerges from the inside of that system as the haunting necessity of its own eventual collapse. The Lamb becomes at once a parodic image for the American narrative of the martyred celebrity (Princess Di, John Lennon, JFK) and an image of resistance for those who resist socialization into mainstream American culture. I will end the paper by reflecting on how these transformed images challenge us to reimagine Revelation provisionally as a non-Christian social critique of late twentieth / early twenty-first century America. The point will be to see how images like the Beast can emerge in an apocalyptic vision of a parodied or absent God, for instance, as powerful parenetic forces for social transformation.


"Does He Not Resist You?" The Epistle of James, Economic Justice, and Activism
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
John W. Fadden, Iliff School of Theology

The Epistle of James is often neglected in the discussion of the Bible and activism. This paper looks at James 5:1-6 as a key passage for supporting economic justice activism. This support for activism depends on how the cryptic 5:6b is understood. By examining the passage in isolation, as part of the section 4:13-5:6, and as part of the overall letter, it becomes evident that the text does support economic justice activism.


The Use of Romans 12 in Reconstruction Theology
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Elelwani Farisani, University of Kwazulu-Natal

The main aim of this paper is to explore how Romans 12 can be used in a quest for an African theology of renewal, transformation and reconstruction. Accordingly, this paper’s main focus is on the sociological analysis of this text, with a view to appropriating such an analysis in a quest for a theology of renewal, transformation and reconstruction in Africa. This will be done in the following four steps. Firstly, we discuss Richard Horsley’s sociological analysis of biblical texts. Secondly, we present and critique certain African’s scholars’(e.g Jesse Mugambi, Ka Mana, Sam Kobia, Valentin Dedji) use of biblical texts in reconstruction theology. Thirdly, we attempt a critical study (literary and sociological analysis) of the text of Romans 12. And, finally, we spell out the significance of a critical analysis of Romans 12 for a theology of renewal, transformation and reconstruction.


Storytelling in Performance
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Pam Farro, Network of Biblical Storytellers

I will offer a storytelling event of a biblical narrative.


Cities, Villages, and Farmsteads: The Landscape of Leviticus 25:29–31
Program Unit: Archaeological Excavations and Discoveries: Illuminating the Biblical World
Avraham Faust, Bar Ilan University

The discovery that Israelite villages were surrounded by boundary walls allows us to gain insights not only into Israelite rural society, but also to the biblical text, and especially to the settlement terminology of Leviticus 25: 29-31, and the law of jubilee. Regardless of the question whether the law was ever applied, most interpreters have understood these verses as differentiating between urban and rural settlements, and viewed the existence of a city wall as having a legal significance: urban houses can be redeemed only within a year, while rural houses, or houses in unwalled towns, return to their original owner in the Jubilee year. The present paper argues that this view is very problematic, and that the archaeological evidence calls for a new interpretation of the verses.


William Foxwell Albright: Creating Order Out of Chaos
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Peter Feinman, Institute of History, Archaeology, and Education

William Foxwell Albright looms large as a figure of biblical scholarship in the 20th century. He was a prolific writer and the teacher of biblical scholars, some of whom continue to work to this very day. Since his death, his scholarship has been the frequent target of attacks but less attention has been paid to Albright the individual except by Burke O. Long. This paper takes the position that the conclusions of Albright in adulthood derive from the world of his youth, a claim that can be made about many people. Therefore, to truly understand the biblical scholarship of Albright one needs to fully understand the Midwest Methodist life at the dawn of the 20th century in which this Chilean-born son of missionaries was raised.


Baal versus El: Smackdown at the Cosmic Navel
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Peter Feinman, Institute of History, Archaeology, and Education

Baal gets poor press in the Hebrew Bible but for millennia it was the only press he received. In the 20th century thanks to discoveries at Ugarit, Baal finally was able to tell his own story and as Albright quickly realized, biblical studies were irrevocably changed. Baal appears frequently in the Hebrew Bible directly by name and sometimes indirectly in the attributes associated with Yahweh, a deity who does not appear in the Ugaritic texts. While the biblical scholarship often notes similarities in traits between Yahweh and Baal, the biblical relationship between El and Baal frequently is overlooked. Robert Miller briefly mentions the Abimelech story at the navel of the earth in Chieftains of the Highlands Clans. This site of Bronze Age temples and Iron Age capitals is an important one in understanding the transformation from Canaanite to Israelite settlement. A more extensive analysis of the story sheds light on the relationship between El and Baal to be king in the land of Canaan and the rise of the Israelite monarchy.


The Case of the Blasphemer (Leviticus 24:10–16) according to Philo
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Louis H. Feldman, Yeshiva University

Why does Philo expand so greatly the story of the blasphemer? The main point is that the blasphemer is an Egyptian. Philo, as a leader of the Jewish community in Alexandria, must have been aware of the attraction that the Egyptian way of life had for some Jews of his day. The fact that the blasphemer was the product of a mixed marriage between a Jew and an Egyptian must have recalled for him such products of mixed marriages with Egyptians who accompanied the Israelites in the Exodus from Egypt. Philo uses extremely strong condemnatory language in describing (De Vita Mosis 1.147) these products of mixed marriages as a bastard host. He likewise describes the blasphemer as a bastard.


How Much Christianity in Rabbinic Literature? A Critical Reevaluation
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Steven Fine, Yeshiva University

For centuries the question of how to evaluate explicit references to Christianity in Rabbinic literature has interested scholars. Academics working in European and American contexts--both Christians and Jews, have generally emphasized this relatively small corpus of sources, and based upon the assumed significance of Christianity in pre-Byzantine Palestine have adduced numerous less obvious responses to Christianity and Christian influences. With this lecture, I begin a thorough reevaluation of Rabbinic sources that have been adduced to refer to Christianity. I will suggest that Christianity is far less pervasive in Tannaitic and Palestinian Amoraic sources than has often been assumed. Interest in Christianity is clearly greater, however, in the Babylonian Talmud and in Byzantine period Palestinian sources, particularly in liturgical poetry (piyyut). Concluding this paper, I will discuss some of the historical and historiographic implications of this literary reevaluation.


The Holy Payment in Paul’s Soteriology
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Stephen Finlan, Drew University

Paul uses the metaphor of redemption to picture the saving effect of the death of Christ. The metaphor has biblical (Exodus) resonances, but I contend that the dominant reference is to the Greco-Roman practice of purchasing a slave’s freedom or paying a ransom for the release of captives. Further, Paul links redemption with sacrifice, thus bringing out the theme of payment inherent in sacrifice, while giving a ritual significance to redemption. The theme of purchase will be traced through several Pauline passages. Believers are “bought and paid for” in 1 Corinthians, utilizing an ordinary marketplace verb for purchasing (agorazo), rather than a verb with any Exodus resonance, and believers are also redeemed (exagorazo) in Gal 3:13; 4:5. Romans 3:24-25, where Christ is redemption (apolytrosis) and place of atonement (hilasterion), links redemption and sacrificial purification. The death pays the price to free the captives of sin, while purifying the stain of sin. By linking sacrifice redemption, Paul is re-joining ideas that were cognate in Hebrew (kipper, atonement; kopher, payment), thus bringing out the element of payment in Hebrew sacrifice, and implying that redemption has a ritual meaning. The death of Jesus accomplishes cultic cleansing and adequate ransoming. It constitutes a holy payment to God. There is a transfer of ownership, as in a commercial transaction, but this transaction has ritual sacredness. The approach to God is a ritual approach. The currency “spent” is a ritual substance, blood (Rom 5:9). Paul’s language of payment must be interpreted in connection with his cultic metaphors, placing the death of Jesus within a liturgical setting. Yet the image of God being paid off cannot be entirely expunged, even though Paul recoils from the idea: it is inherent in the redemption metaphor itself.


How Different Genres of Lists Function within the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Timothy David Finlay, Azusa Pacific University

The Hebrew Bible contains numerous genres within the larger category of "list" including catalogues, genealogies, itineraries, onomastica, registers, rosters, and rotas. Each of these genres has certain formulae typically associated with it and a standard function. However, the narratological goals of the larger literary setting containing the list sometimes modify both the formulae within the list and the function of the list. This paper summarizes the typical formulae associated with each type of list found in the Hebrew Bible and gives examples of how they are modified on occasion to serve a particular literary goal. Finally, this paper notes how lists can be an effective learning tool for beginning students of Biblical Hebrew to be able to read and translate considerable portions of the Hebrew Bible without requiring a large vocabulary base.


Dialogic Use of Zechariah 3 and 6 in the Gospel of Luke: Joshua and the Branch
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Bettina Fischer, University of Stellenbosch

Making use of Bakhtin’s criteria of locus, form, and degree of intertextuality, this paper explores how the figures of Joshua and the Branch both serve as forerunners to the figure of Jesus in the Gospel of Luke. It will show how the gospel, making use of the older text as a dialogic partner, first roots itself in it to then diverge from it, signalling a new era in terms of the communication between the human and the divine. While the encounter between Joshua and the devil in Zechariah shows two figures with no volition or text of their own, these characters have been expanded in the Gospel. The figure of Jesus enjoys centre stage in the Gospel. The figure of the devil has moved from silent challenger within the divine plan in Zechariah to become the antagonist with a kingdom of his own. The struggle between the two is responsible for the dramatic tension that underlies the gospel as a whole. Parallels between the Branch and Jesus in terms of their being serve to legitimize the latter as the chosen figure to fulfil the divine plan. The generic difference between the two texts in the way these figures are presented implies differences in discourse, creating a dialogic relationship between them with hermeneutic implications for the gospel. It also throws light on the genre of the gospel, and can be used to challenge the view of the Gospel of Luke as an ancient biography or bios.


Synagogue Influence on Paul's Roman Readers: Evaluating an Hypothesis
Program Unit: Paul and Scripture
Bruce N. Fisk, Westmont College

Paul's use of Scripture in Romans seems to presuppose substantial biblical knowledge on the part of his audience. Were Paul's (largely) Gentile Christian readers in Rome familiar with the Jewish Scriptures because of their prior (and possibly ongoing) participation in the synagogue(s) of the city? This paper will weigh the evidence for the "synagogue influence" hypothesis in terms of the content of Romans, synagogue practice in the diaspora and Jewish-Christian relations in 1st century Rome.


Jeremiah 10:5a: Finding the Scarecrow within the Field
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
John P. Flanagan, Universiteit Leiden

Jeremiah 10:5a is represented in a variety of ways in the ancient Versions. This is particularly evident between the divergent readings of the MT and the LXX. The goal of this paper will be twofold. First, the differences between the readings of the MT and the LXX will be analyzed. This will include an examination of what elements within the Greek text can and cannot be linked to the MT. Second, the other ancient Versions will be analyzed in an effort to examine how they might be connected to a consonantal text similar to the MT. It will be argued that deviations from the MT that are shared by two or more ancient translations might imply some text-historical relation.


Calling Down Heaven: Descent of the Hekhal in Second Temple Judaism as a Window onto Ritual Experience
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Frances Flannery-Dailey, Hendrix College

Early Jewish texts depicting a clear ascent to the heavenly Hekhal, the Temple/Palace of God, are well known and have received much attention in relation to apocalypses and mystical literature. In this paper I argue that several Second Temple period texts, including Daniel 7, 4 Ezra, Joseph and Aseneth, and the Testament of Abraham depict seers engaging in rituals that result in an experience of the descent of the hekhal. These texts utilize veiled and even allegorical language that can be fully deciphered only by readers familiar with the practices and themes of a style of mysticism attested in later Hekhalot literature. In this way, the encoded experience of entering the hekhal speaks to familiarity with mystical practice as a background for esoteric textual reception, if not for textual production. Futhermore, I use this instance to explore various theoretical treatments of ritual, arguing that literary descriptions of ritual can provide a window onto ancient experience in two ways: ritual practice itself produces a sense of sacred meaning through physiological effects on the brain and body, and ritual is embedded in a certain worldview (that it also helps enact), which functions to interpret the experience of ritual activity.


"Go Back by the Way You Came": An Internal Textual Critique of Elijah's Violence in 1 Kings 18–19
Program Unit: Warfare in Ancient Israel
Frances Flannery-Dailey, Hendrix College

The famous contest between Elijah and the four hundred and fifty prophets of Baal and the four hundred prophets of Asherah in 1 Kings 18:1-46 ends with Elijah slaying or ordering the deaths of the prophets of Baal (v. 40). The majority of interpreters of this passage interpret the brutal scene as Elijah acting in accordance with the will of God as dictated in Deuteronomy 13:3-6, which commands the death of prophets who urge apostasy. While the obvious ethical problems posed by the reading have led a few to brand the scene as “ugly” (Montgomery and Gehman, 1951), or to excuse the slaying as uniquely necessary (Wiseman, 1993), on the whole the discomfort of a few scholars on the point is generally perceived as “introducing contemporary moral sensitivity foreign to the text” (Cogan 444). I argue that the larger unit of 1 Kings 18-19 contains a sharp internal critique of the mass murder in 1 Kings 18:40, as evident through attention to literary clues, particularly a repeated chiastic structure. An implicit contrast between the characters and actions of Obedyahu and Eliyahu, the literary structure of the theophany of silence in 1 Kings 19, and God’s command to “Go back by the way you came,” suggest the prophet acted on his own and failed to recognize divinely offered alternatives for peace. Moreover, following Heschel (1962), who argued that God works in tandem with prophetic action and pathos, I propose that Elijah’s resolute stance in favor of warfare against the pagan prophets in turn determines God’s participation in the cycle of violence (1 Kings 19:15-18). Finally, I suggest some authorial and editorial contexts for the literary layers of the narrative.


The Christology of Q and the Pauline Kerygma
Program Unit: Q
Harry T. Fleddermann, Alverno College

The current debate on Q began with Heinz Eduard Todt's study of the Son of Man in the synoptic tradition which concluded that the passion-resurrection kerygma played no role in the Q community. Instead, the Q community saw the resurrection as a vindication of Jesus and his teaching, so that the community continued Jesus' proclamation of the kingdom of God without attaching any importance to the cross. In the sixties and seventies scholars like Robinson, Koester, Steck, and Theissen saw Q witnessing to an alternate early Christianity centered in Galilee that had a different orientation than that of the kerygma-centered Pauline communities. Developments of these positions continued to unfold in the eighties and nineties, but recently doubts have arisen about the legitimacy of these reconstructions, and the whole question of a Galilean Christianity independent of the Pauline kerygma needs to be reexamined. From the side of Q studies the place to start such a reexamination lies in the Cross Saying (Q 14:27). A close reading of the saying demonstrates that Q links the cross to salvation and connects the cross to essential features of Q's christology. The context of the saying near the end of Q reveals that Q's understanding of the cross does not differ in any important way from the understanding of the early passion-resurrection kerygma.


Harran and Der, Town and Tribe
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Daniel Fleming, New York University

Even the concept of rival cities envisions a world of polities defined by city centers. This can be a useful rubric for exploring political interaction in the ancient Near East, but it can also distract from other components in the regional network of peoples and power. Any analysis of political rivalries in early second-millennium Syria must account for both city-based states and large tribal alliances. Conflicts between towns were liable to follow tribal commitments. Ancient Mari was itself ruled by the king of the Binu Sim’al alliance, and its affairs were often colored by tribal identities. In order to illustrate the interplay of town and tribe in early Syrian political life, I have chosen two towns that are important less for any on-going rivalry than for one episode of outright conflict, as recounted in one letter to the king at Mari from a high official on diplomatic mission (ARM XXVI 24). Der was a small town of special significance to the Binu Sim’al peoples, so much so that it could count on military support from the king at Mari, even though it was outside the normal perimeter of his authority. In this text, the Binu Yamina peoples and their allies in the Zalmaqum coalition meet at the holy center of Harran to plan an attack on Der. Interestingly, Der seems to have special sacred value for the Binu Sim’al peoples. The conflict that is immediately focused on Harran and Der actually pertains to the more general rivalry between the Binu Yamina and the Binu Sim’al tribal associations. By examining this one crisis between towns, we gain a sense of the deeper lines of social organization and stress in ancient Syria of the Middle Bronze Age.


The Legacy of Israel in a Jewish Bible
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Daniel Fleming, New York University

The goal of this paper is to outline a broad tradition- and literary-historical framework for evaluating the possible relationship of biblical writing to cognate literatures. Too often, comparisons are made based on surface similarity without attempting to explain more precisely how such similarities came to be. I propose that the most significant categorization of biblical tradition is neither date nor genre but is rather basic political and cultural identity as derived from Israel or Judah. In the end, the whole Bible is a Judah product. Many of its contents began in Judah and were always the possession of its people, after the fall of the kingdom and beyond. Perhaps the most arresting feature of the Bible as a whole, however, is the fact that a collection treating the heritage of Judah’s people should define all its earliest roots in terms of something called Israel. A significant portion of the core Torah narrative, along with important elements of the history that follows, appears to be built around traditions that originated and were first preserved in Israel. Most of this material would have taken early form in what became a separate “northern” kingdom and probably was integrated into Judahite collections only after 722. Together, the Israelite traditions are more substantial and significant than generally recognized and deserve to be examined as a whole. Although Israel and Judah shared much, and many cognate comparisons may be relevant across both, analysis of how to locate any biblical phenomenon in the wider world benefits from this distinction. Judah was more politically and religiously centered, with easier claim to unitary authority. Israel had a long tradition of collective governance across more diverse constituencies. This contrast alone affects each culture significantly, including religion.


The Isha Zara in Proverbs 1–9 Masoretic Texts and the Septuagint: Allegory and Allegorization
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Tova Forti and Zipora Talshir, Ben Gurion University of the Negev

Ancient hermeneutics embedded in Qumran (4Q184), Rabbinic Jewish sources, and medieval commentaries identified the figure of the Isha Zara in Proverbs (2:16-22; 5:1-23; 6:20-35; 7:1-27) as representing abstract dangers, using allegory, or rather allegorization, as a legitimate hermeneutic tool. Modern scholars as well have interpreted the Isha Zara speeches in a variety of ways, being reluctant to admit that the texts mean nothing more than warnings against dangerous liaisons. This paper aims to retrieve the original meaning of the Isha Zara speeches, in both their MT and LXX forms, without reading into them either other texts, specifically Prov 9, or later interpretations. This would require setting aside methods such as intertextuality, that too often functions as a modern version of midrash, or allegorization, another form of Midrash that is a wonderful resource for sermons but illegitimate in philological analysis. In our view, the Isha Zara speeches do not differ from other issues of everyday life dominating the Book of Proverbs, such as family ethos, parental teaching, domestic harmony, and social stability.


The Coming One: The Eschatological Christology of Q
Program Unit: Q
Paul Foster, University of Edinburgh

It is well known that Q does not present a prominent titular christology. In this paper it will be argued that Q conceives a fundamental aspect of its christological understanding in terms of eschatological disclosure. This explanation of the future aspect of the revealing of the true status of the central figure of devotion in the Q community functions not only to instruct the group at a theoretical level, but also aids members pastorally by explaining the reason for their own liminal status and the non-acceptance of the claims they advanced in relation to Jesus.


An Ekklesia Filled to the Fullness: Context and Intertextuality in Ephesians 3:19
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Robert L. Foster, Southern Methodist University

This paper argues that the climactic petition of the prayer in Ephesians 3:14-19, asking for the Ephesian ekklesia to be filled to all the pleroma of God, refers to God's glory. The writer uses imagery from Jewish Scriptures describing God's glory filling (pleroma) the sanctuary so completely the priests cannot enter (Exod. 40; III Kgdms. 8). Ezekiel uses the pleroma/glory imagery to report God's departure from the sanctuary (ch. 10), though later envisioning God's glory filling the New Temple in the eschatological age (ch. 43). The author of Ephesians sees the Ephesian ekklesia as this New Temple and prays for their filling with God's glory. Aside from the shared pleroma terminology, several indicators support this thesis. First, the primary context of the prayer, 2:19-22, envisions the Ephesian ekklesia as a temple in which God "dwells," while the prayer asks for Christ to "dwell" in their hearts (3:17). Second, 2:21 speaks of the Ephesians built upon the "foundation" of apostles and prophets; the prayer views the ekklesia as rooted and "founded" in love (3:17). Third, the four dimensions of Christ's love--"breadth, length, height, depth"--find their only parallel in the Jewish Scriptures in the dimensions of the altar described in Ezekiel 43. Finally, the doxology mentions the desire for God to receive "glory" in the ekklesia (3:21). I draw two conclusions. First is the importance of the temple imagery in the central section of Ephesians. The Ephesian ekklesia, as God's temple (2:19-22) should be filled with God's glory (3:19), with the saints partaking in their own up-building (4:12, 16). Second, even with an important word like pleroma, the writer of Ephesians draws both from a Hellenistic background (1:23) and from Judaism and its Scripture (3:19).


The Septuagint of Proverbs as a Text Critical Resources: Two Different Approaches
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Michael V. Fox, University of Wisconsin, Madison

The Septuagint of Proverbs is, except for a few fragments from Qumran, the only textual resource besides the MT earlier than the Common Era. But it is a tricky translation for this purpose, and the way it should be employed is open to debate. Granted that, as Cook has shown, LXX-Prov is an interpretative translation, can it nevertheless provide a witness to textual variants? Johann Cook and Michael Fox have debated this issue in various publications (exx. below). In the present pair of papers, they enter into dialogue in order to sharpen the questions about the text-critical use of this resource and think through the constraints and possibilities of using such a document as a witness to variants. Cook: see separate abstract. According to Fox, LXX-Prov provides a window to an ancient Hebrew text that differs significantly from the MT and that justifies a bolder text-critical use of the translation. Fox argues that, first, there are techniques for recognizing a Hebrew Vorlage, even when it cannot be fully recovered. Second, even when the critieria for a strong argument for a particular retroversion are not available, other factors can strengthen the grounds for the retroversion; and, third, the fact that a translation is “interpretive” does not mean that it is interpreting the MT. Brief bibliography:M. V. Fox:"LXX-Proverbs as a Text-Critical Resource". Textus 22 (2005) 95-128. “The Challenge of the Oxford Hebrew Bible: Producing a Critical Text of Proverbs.” JNSL, forthcoming. J. Cook: “The Greek of Proverbs—Evidence of a Recensionally Deviating Hebrew Text?” Pp. 605-18 in Emanuel (FS Emanuel Tov), ed. S. M. Paul et al. Leiden: Brill, 2003. “The Text-Critical Value of the Septuagint of Proverbs.” Pp. 407-20 in Seeking Out the Wisdom of the Ancients (M. V. Fox Festschrift), edited by R. L. Troxel, et al., 2005.


How Broad Was the Rabbinic Umbrella? The Case of Targum and Rabbinic Literature
Program Unit: History and Literature of Early Rabbinic Judaism
Steven D. Fraade, Yale University

The question of the location of targum either within or without the textual polysystem of rabbinic Judaism has had a revealing history. On the one hand, notices of the ancient practice of targum derive entirely from early rabbinic literature, while the extant targumic texts appear to have been transmitted through rabbinic channels. On the other, for the last fifty years, scholars have sought to locate targum outside of rabbinic Judaism, as “pre-rabbinic,” “anti-rabbinic,” “extra-rabbinic,” or most recently, “para-rabbinic.” While introductions to rabbinic literature often omit treatment of targum entirely, the targumim incorporate exegetical traditions that find their closest parallels in rabbinic texts. Yet, the targumim also incorporate traditions and terminology that do not fit neatly within what we usually associate with rabbinic Judaism. Several recent studies by scholars of rabbinic Judaism build their theses largely on locating targum outside of rabbinic Judaism. Since there is substantial evidence for targum having functioned both in the synagogue and in the rabbinic “house of study,” targum raises interesting questions regarding the relationship between these two institutions. Is targum an expression of the “popular” Judaism of the synagogue, or a vehicle for the rabbinization of the synagogue (scholars having argued for both)? The present paper will explore these issues of targumic identity arguing that they have as much to do with our understanding of targum as they do with scholarly constructions of the boundaries of rabbinic Judaism and its literature. Should differences between targum and rabbinic literature be attributed to its lying outside the bounds of rabbinic Judaism? Alternatively, might its distinctive generic qualities and functions be accommodated within a broader, more fluid understanding of rabbinic Judaism in terms of the generic variety of its textual practices, rather than the unity of its sociology and ideology?


"The Orthodox Study Bible" and Orthodox Identity in North America
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Matthew Francis, Orthodox Church in America, Archdiocese of Canada

Originally published by Thomas Nelson in 1993, "The Orthodox Study Bible: New Testament and Psalms," which employs the New King James Version with Orthodox Christian study notes and essays, has found a degree of success within the Orthodox communities, and has been associated with recent cultural patterns in North American Orthodoxy. This paper explores the origins, reception, and ongoing research project associated with The Orthodox Study Bible. Of considerable significance is the fact that the main contributors to The Orthodox Study Bible represent the influx of Evangelical converts to Orthodoxy. The very production of a specialty Bible for a niche community typifies a market-savvy characteristic of Evangelicalism. The choice of Bible translation used as well as the tone of some of the study materials have been subject to some criticism from some Orthodox interpreters. This raises the question: Is The Orthodox Study Bible simply a colonization of this 'ancient-future' ecclesiastical space with the publication methodologies of North American Evangelicalism, as some critics have suggested? Or does the The Orthodox Study Bible project, with its ongoing research aims, embody an increasingly indigenous and 'organic' North American Orthodoxy?


The Function of Figurative Language in Isaiah
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Chris Franke, College of Saint Catherine

This paper will explore the uses of metaphor, simile and other figures common in Hebrew poetry, and discuss how they function in the poetry of Isaiah.


Violence and the Prurient Gaze: Dynamics of Fantasy in Martyrology and Eschatology
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
David Frankfurter, University of New Hampshire

Discussions of the representation of violence in Roman antiquity, whether against persecutors, martyrs, or babies, have shifted in recent decades from evaluating historicity to examining the narratives as types of spectacle that call for diverse emotional reactions. But even this approach tends to stop short of analyzing the voyeurism – the prurient engagement and enjoyment at others’ suffering – that the most protracted and sexualized scenarios of violence assume of their audiences. By introducing the category of fantasy, I want to confront directly the prurience and often erotic engagement invited by certain depictions of violence, while at the same time acknowledging the function of certain narrative frames – eschatology, martyrology, even heresiography and geography – to circumscribe pornographic scenarios as morally safe to contemplate.


Naomi the Other Job
Program Unit: African-American Biblical Hermeneutics
Naomi P. Franklin, St. Jerome Biblical Studies Institute, Basseterre, St. Kitts

This work examines the life and suffering of the main character in the Book of Ruth, Naomi, and it proposes that she is the other Job. Naomi is shown to be a model for African American women of faith within the context of suffering, faith and agency. The paper discusses faith and hope and the linguistic variations surrounding these two concepts as found in the text of the Hebrew Bible, and how Naomi uses them. Comparisons are drawn to prove that indeed, Naomi, like Job, suffered and that she can serve as a model for women of faith who have difficulty identifying with the man Job or even with Hagar. Reference is made to the faith of the African American Church and its historical Bible based faith traditions.


Adaptability in the Function of Lyric: The Akkadian Shuilla and the Psalter
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Christopher Frechette, Loyola Marymount University

Relevant to interpretation of genre in the Psalter, this paper addresses the relationships among particular texts, text-types, classes of text, and social function. It draws implications from my recent investigation of the Akkadian shuilla-rituals and the lyrical texts associated with them, texts long compared to biblical laments of the individual. Based upon my demonstration of the striking fluidity of context within which these texts were employed, I argue that such lyrical texts in Mesopotamia, and by cultural continuity possibly in Israel, were not associated with singular and stable social functions, but rather were assumed to have an adaptability of function.


Utopia and Apocalypsis
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Marco Frenschkowski, University of Mainz

Lucian is a major source of the ancient utopian tradition, even if his verae historiae are already a parody of that tradition. Have utopian and apocalyptic traditions been in contact? Influences are possible in both directions. The emphasis of the paper will be on images of heavenly cities and of the Isles of the Blessed, aiming not so much at an analysis of isolated motivs, but at comparing utopian and apocalyptic constructions of reality. Christian texts that will be considered at some length are the Apocalypsis of John and the Visio Zosimi (also called the History of the Rechabites). Some ideas from recent commentaries on v. h. (Peter von Moellendorff, Aristoula Georgiadou and David Larmour) will also be discussed.


Virgins in the Text: The Problematic Image of Virgins in Christianity
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Annal M. Frenz, University of Chicago

In recent years, many scholars have devoted themselves to exploring issues of sexuality and gender in the ancient Mediterranean world, especially the portrayal of women’s bodies and behavior as presented by the male writers. Since heavy attention is paid to women’s sexual status by both ancient writers and modern scholars, most expressions of female gender deal exclusively with the category of the sexually experienced woman, and elide the categories of girl and maiden (the parthenos). I would like to focus on virginity, a particular aspect of the body that has received relatively little attention. In fact, the transition from girl to maiden to woman is based on a sense of a sexual physical progression, both for the ancients and us. In consequence, sexual intercourse becomes a liminal experience for the virgin that confers adult status and a newly defined social identity. The virgin, then, is presented as someone who is not a truly sexual being, but as someone with a future of dangerous sexuality that has not yet been brought to fruition. Since the virgin is seen as a transitional object, she carries great potential as a conduit for the divine; however she also carries a disastrous potential that is grounded in her physicality. Christian writers recognized and shared this social construction of virginity, a construct that generated a continuing conflict over the (a)sexual nature of the virgin and reflected a concern over how to place the female body within a male social construct of gender. To cope with the problem presented by the virgin body, these authors found ways to simplify their construct (making her in some way more male) but could not escape the complicating factors of her sexual attractiveness and ambiguous status.


Jesus as a Member of the Galilean 'am ha-Aretz': Fact, Johannine Rhetoric, or Both?
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Sean Freyne, Trinity College, Dublin

John 5-12 portrays a number of conflicts between Jesus and "the Jews" of Judea, often at feasts in Jerusalem. This paper will consider the extent to which this Johannine literary theme may reflect actual historical tensions between Galilee and Judea in the first-century.


Erastus Disentangled
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Steven J. Friesen, University of Texas, Austin

An inscription found at Corinth mentions an Erastus who was aedile of the Roman colony. Many scholars have identified this Erastus with the oikonomos tes poleos (“city steward”) for whom Paul transmitted greetings in Romans 16:23. This identification has had a dramatic effect on social descriptions of the Corinthian churches since it would mean that the churches included a municipal aristocrat. This paper demonstrates that the whole identification argument was misguided. The inscription was published incorrectly and the identification is impossible. Paul’s Erastus was not a member of the city’s elite, but rather a functionary in the municipal bureaucracy, perhaps a slave, with financial means that placed him above the level of subsistence.


Evil-Merodach and the Deuteronomist: The Sociohistorical Setting of Deuteronomy in the Light of 2 Kings 25:27-30
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Serge Frolov, Southern Methodist University

Since the Deuteronomistic History ends with the release and exaltation of Jehoiachin by the Babylonian king Evil-Merodach (2 Kgs 25:27-30), there is little doubt that it could not be completed before 561 BCE; at the same time, few scholars are willing today to sustain Martin Noth's contention that the composition's finale also indicates its terminus ante quem. The paper argues that Noth's thesis, although poorly substantiated, was essentially correct. Of crucial importance in this regard is the aspect of 2 Kgs 25:27-30 that has thus far largely escaped scholarly attention, namely, the identity of Jehoiachin's benefactor. Given Evil-Merodach's sheer obscurity and insignificance, at any point after his fall in 560 BCE the audience was likely to see the episode as largely inconsequential. Lack of references or allusions to the fragment in post-exilic texts confirms as much. By contrast, with Evil-Merodach still on the throne it would be highly meanigful as a striking confirmation of the divine promise to David and its lasting validity, even against the background of Israel's total collapse. If the Former Prophets, where the Davidic promise and associated concepts play a pivotal formative role, is a (largely) Deuteronomistic composition, it means that Deuteronomistic literary activity, contrary to the recent tendency to extend it into the post-exilic period, ceased after Evil-Merodach’s fall. What is more, Deuteronomism as an ideological and literary phenomenon may be a product of Evil-Merodach's brief reign (562-560 BCE); although this hypothesis cannot be definitively proved, it offers a novel and promising way of accounting for the present shape of the Former Prophets, especially for the combination of homogeneity and heterogeneity, continuity and discontinuity in the corpus.


Social Atomization and Community Identification in Readers of the Left Behind Series
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Amy Frykholm, Colorado Mountain College

Drawing on a qualitative study of readers of the Left Behind series, this paper argues that readers use the books for three purposes:1) to form social bonds and develop a distinct communal identity 2) to raise and answer fears of social isolation and separation 3) to develop a vivid relationship with Biblical texts. The first part of the paper looks at the ways that readers read the Left Behind series in communities and networks. I argue that community identification formed a stronger passion for reading the series than the narrative found in the books themselves. Next I look at fears of social isolation that readers expressed in their interactions with the series. I examine the psychological effect of the phrase “left behind” on readers. Finally, I look at how reading fiction in social networks and raising fears of being “left behind” work to create a vivid and dynamic relationship with Biblical texts. I examine what readers mean when they say that the Left Behind series brought Revelation “to life.”


Biblical Feminisms: Diversity, Dialogue, Debate
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Esther Fuchs, University of Arizona

The last decade has witnessed a proliferation of both theoretical and interpretive readings of the Hebrew Bible. This energetic enterprise has resulted in anthologies and monographs that continue to elude systematic organization. Publications like Athalya Brenner and Carole Fontaine eds. Reading the Bible: Approaches, Methods and Strategies (Sheffield Academic Press, 1997) and Alice Bach ed. Women in the Hebrew Bible (Routledge, 1999) have captured the plurality and diversity of the field. This panel seeks to build on this wealth, by mapping out lines of debate and dialogue. This panel has both scholarly and pedagogic purpose: it seeks to translate the thinking of major voices in the field to the undergraduate and graduate class, and to map out the field so as to facilitate dialogue and debate, which have become the hallmark of the field of Women’s Studies in general. The panelists will explore disciplinary codes and (e.g. historical, literary, anthropological) and intersecting and ‘competing’ theories (e.g. postcolonial and cultural theory) and assess whether and to what extent we can identify an emerging consensus in the field of biblical feminist studies.


Zerubbabel's Return: An Examination of the Levitical and Priestly Lists in the Masoretic Text and the Septuagint Nehemiah 12:1–11
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Deirdre N. Fulton, The Pennsylvania State University

The book of Nehemiah contains many lists of the people who settled in the land of Judah. The texts of the MT and LXX Nehemiah 12:1-11 are particularly noteworthy since they focus on the priests and Levites who came out from the exiled Jewish community in Babylon with Zerubbabel. Interestingly, MT and LXX Nehemiah 12:1-11 reveal several differences in form and content, particularly concerning the names and number of people who left with Zerubbabel. The discrepancies in the number of settlers in Judea have both literary and historical implications. I will examine MT and LXX Nehemiah 12:1-11 in order to evaluate the nature and implications of these differences for understanding the history of postexilic Judah.


The Old Testament Prophets on the Other Half of Ancient Warfare
Program Unit: Warfare in Ancient Israel
Kathy L. Gaca, Vanderbilt University

Ancient visual artifacts and texts dealing with warfare in antiquity readily illuminate the widespread practices of armed aggression and defense among fighting men. But with several outstanding exceptions, they are far more reluctant to depict or divulge the methods and aims involved in the equally ubiquitous practices of warfare against women and girls taken captive through such aggression and conflict. To gain a sound grasp of the ethics and norms of warfare in antiquity, however, it is imperative to elucidate the norms of this long occluded other half--the dark side--of ancient warfare as waged by armed men against women and girls among the enemy. Passages in the Old Testament Prophets are among some of the outstanding exceptions from antiquity that do allow insight into this other half of ancient warfare, including Isaiah 13, Ezekiel 16 and 23, Hosea 13, Nahum 2-3, and Zechariah 14. The purpose of my paper is twofold. First, picking up where Kern leaves off (Ancient Siege Warfare, 1999, 62-85) I show that the Old Testament Prophets clearly support my broader thesis that warfare in antiquity is predominantly a gender-specific practice in two phases, first to kill off or incapacitate adult males in a community marked as enemy or alien, and second, to capture and subjugate surviving girls and women through sexual assault and related practices of debasement that focus on commandeering female sexuality, productivity, and creativity. Second, I demonstrate why this question concerning the ethics of warfare in ancient Israel and beyond is highly relevant to urgent humanitarian concerns about sexual violence in warfare in modern times, as suffered and witnessed, for example, by girls and women in the Balkans during the early and late twentieth centuries.


A 'Golden' Gospel of Matthew? Money, Economic Status, and Taxation in the Synoptics
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Aaron M. Gale, West Virginia University

Evidence is strong that ancient Galilee was prosperous and very involved in trade and commerce. Many goods were imported and exported to and from the region. In this paper I will argue that the Matthean community, itself a conservative Jewish-Christian group located in Galilee, was prosperous as well. In fact, when placed alongside the other Synoptic Gospels, Matthew alone clearly indicates a distinct and unique preference for money and wealth. I will begin by providing a brief sketch of ancient Galilean economic activity. From there I will focus on three related topics mentioned in Matthew and the other Synoptic Gospels: various denominations of coinage (Matt 10:9; 18:23; 23:16-17; 27:3-10), references to the rich and poor, or the lack thereof (Matt 5:3; 19:23; 20:29-34; 22:1-14), and the author's attitude towards taxes and taxation (Matt 17:24-27). By carefully analyzing how Matthew incorporates the above themes into his Gospel, it will become clear that the Matthean congregation must have been far wealthier than the communities associated with either Mark or Luke’s Gospel.


“I Went in Bitterness”: Theological Implications of a Trauma Theory Reading of Ezekiel
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
David G. Garber, Jr., McAfee School of Theology, Mercer University

Recent trends in scholarship of the exile, particularly on the book of Ezekiel, have been influenced by refugee and trauma studies. In addition, some evaluations of Ezekiel’s theology have decried the book’s misogynistic tendencies as well as one of the over-arching theological messages of the prophet: that the community in exile suffered dislocation and the destruction of the temple because of religious infidelity. This paper will explore the theological implications of a conversation between Ezekiel scholarship and literary trauma theory. A reading of Ezekiel that focuses on the way the text testifies to trauma provides room to explore the community’s articulation of its experience while acknowledging the possible dangers of its theological conclusions. This paper will discuss how the community that produced the text of Ezekiel was trying to construct a theology in light of its traumatic history.


Interpreting "Jerusalem" in the Passover Haggadah
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Zev Garber, Los Angeles Valley College

Interpreting the Passover Haggadah, a collection of documents on the deliverance of Israel from Egypt and considered authoritative by the Synagogue, is the problem of relating blocs of religious thought-patterns to the fluid, constantly changing life of the Jewish community. It is a question of old forms and new challenges. The aim of this paper is to assess the hermeneutics on the Passover Haggadah's ultimate charge, "Next Year in Jerusalem" (literal, allegorical, typological, moral, and historiosophical).


Beyond CATSS: Humanities Computing and Septuagint Studies
Program Unit: Computer Assisted Research
Juan Garces, King's College, London

This paper/presentation stems from the experience of participating in 'The Greek Bible in the Graeco-Roman World' project and presents subsequent thoughts on how to further profit from the application of Humanities Computing to Septuagint Studies. It will seek to do three things: (1) It will start by critically assessing the impact the well-known pioneering Computer Assisted Tools for Septuagint/Scriptural Study (CATSS) project has had on the research of the Septuagint, by giving an overview, discussing some relevant case studies, and asking the question whether computing approaches have presented more an evolution than a revolution. (2) It will show some of the potentials of Humanities Computing within Septuagint Studies by presenting the application of open source tools on the CATSS resources. After illustrating the transformation of these resources into standard-compliant formats, the presentation will demonstrate how a freely-available tool like the XML Aware Indexing and Retrieval Architecture (XAIRA) can open up the world of computer-aided Corpus Linguistics and Natural Language Processing to the Septuagint scholar. (3) It will identify the challenges posed by the digitization of the research environment, not only for the field of Septuagint Studies, but for the whole of Humanities. By discussing such issues as the role/impact of proprietary 'Bible software' in Biblical Studies (Are commercial interests and the dis/interested pursuit of knowledge reconcilable?), the impact of the new media on copyright law (Can an ancient text be owned?), and, more particularly, the competition of research paradigms (Will Humanities Computing change the questions we ask about texts?), this paper will try to map the limits and possibilities of the incipient yet already pervasive impact of the computer on the discourses and practices of the Humanities and Biblical Studies.


Authority and Individualism: A Misplaced Debate
Program Unit:
Ismael Garcia, Austin Theological Seminary

*


Resolviendo: Insights for a Feminist Cuban Hermeneutics
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Cristina Garcia-Alfonso, Brite Divinity School, Texas Christian University

In this paper I examine how the particularly Cuban concept of resolviendo (survival) offers insights for reading biblical passages from a Cuban feminist perspective. I explore the concept of resolviendo, its meaning and use in Cuba today. Then, I examine the philosophical ideas of Karl Jaspers on limit or boundary situation. Finally, I explore how resolviendo offers insights for reading the biblical texts of Genesis 38 and Judith 8-12. It seems to me that survival shapes the actions of many characters in the Hebrew Bible. Karl Jaspers’s philosophical concepts of limit or boundary situation shed lights on this issue.


The Infinitive Absolute as Substitute for the Finite Verb
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
W. Randall Garr, University of California-Santa Barbara

Conventionally, grammars of Biblical Hebrew note that the infinite absolute may replace any number of noninfinitive verb forms that would otherwise consititute the predicative core of a clause. This paper argues that almost all such infinitives absolute are secondary or co-predications.


Living in the End Times: Apocalyptic Prophecy and the Mayan Holocaust in Guatemala in the Early 1980s
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Virginia Garrard-Burnett, University of Texas at Austin

In the early 1980s, the military government of the Central American nation of Guatemala under the leadership of a born-again Pentecostal general, Efraín Ríos Montt, decimated the nation’s indigenous Mayan population in its attempt to eradicate a Marxist guerrilla movement. While most Mayans were not guerrillas, many, like the president himself, were Pentecostals. This paper will explore how the emergence of end-times theology during the Mayan holocaust contributed to the rapid expansion of Pentecostalism during this period, with particular emphasis on how Mayans interpreted government repression in terms of the fulfillment of the apocalyptic prophecies of the Book of Revelation. The paper will also examine the evangelical and millenarian themes in the public rhetoric of General Ríos Montt as expressed in his weekly discursos del domingo, or political “Sunday sermons,” in which Ríos Montt identified himself as God’s anointed agent and positioned the government’s scorched earth campaign within the framework of kairos, a Biblically prophetic historical moment.


The Didache and the Apostolic Decree
Program Unit: Didache in Context
Alan J. P. Garrow, Oxford Ministry Course, Cuddesdon UK

Many scholars agree that Luke’s account of the creation of the Apostolic Decree in Acts 15 is incompatible with Paul’s recollection of his meeting with the apostles in Galatians 2. Among other difficulties, why did Paul neglect to quote the decree if such a document had arisen at the council? This paper seeks to identify an early version of the Didache with the text of the apostle’s ruling on the basis of commonalities in date, authorship and purpose. Such an identification, it will be argued, serves to explain the disparity between the Lukan and Pauline accounts of the apostles’ Jerusalem meeting.


WWJD: The Exegetical Implications of John Chrysostom’s Synagogue Problem
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Joshua Garroway, Yale University

Did 4th century Antiochene Christians wear “What Would Jesus Do?” bracelets? Doubtful. But there is good reason to believe that the sentiment, if not the fashion, had indeed caught hold in the community. Chrysostom’s increasingly well-known Homiliae Adversus Iudaeos reveal unmistakably that one of the chief reasons given by Christians for attending the synagogue and participating in other Jewish rituals was the desire to imitate Christ’s behaviors in the flesh. Christ had been circumcised, frequented synagogues, and observed the festivals, and some Antiochene Christians felt compelled in some measure to follow suit. This study first examines Chrysostom’s strategy for combating this mimetic urge – why, on his reckoning, Christians should not do what Jesus had done. The second and more substantive section examines the exegetical implications of this social crisis for Chrysostom’s approach to the Jewishness of Jesus in the gospel narratives. Particularly in his commentary on the Fourth Gospel, one sees how Chrysostom acknowledges but subtly undercuts Jesus’ Jewish identity and his observance of Jewish rites.


Cubism, Quantum Physics, and the Historical Jesus: History as an Art and a Science
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Joshua Garroway, Yale University

The quest for the historical Jesus often presumes a distinction between the Jesus of history and the Christ of faith. Questers penetrate the portrait of Christ drawn up by Christianity and arrive at knowledge about Jesus “as he actually was.” True, the nature and even the viability of the distinction have long been debated, but as long as the quest(s) has persisted, the “historical” Jesus usually has possessed an epistemological equivalence to the “actual” Jesus, the “real” Jesus, the Jesus resulting from serious “historical” investigation. Recently, however, philosophers and literary critics have begun to challenge the methods and assumptions of history as a discipline, particularly with regard to the correspondence between history writing and “actual” reality. The arguments of these critics, led by Hayden White, despite the cogency of their claims, largely have fallen on deaf ears among historians, especially biblical historians. I wish to give these theorists a voice in our field, not in the interest of undermining or invalidating the quest, but enlivening it. How might new conceptions of “history” enhance our approach to the “historical” Jesus? This study finds its inspiration from a challenge posed by White himself: Historians, White claims, fancy themselves part-scientist and part-artist, but their understanding of (objectivist) science and (narrative) art are stuck in the 19th century. Embracing that critique, this study explores new conceptions of history in light of the most important artistic and scientific revolutions of the 20th century: Cubism and Quantum Physics. Having examined the ways in which reality is known and described in these discourses, in particular their understanding of the observer and the simultaneity of multiple truths, I will propose new possibilities for historical discourse and their implications for historical Jesus research. Though challenging, these implications are also promising, in terms of methodology, modes of presentation, and standards of evaluation.


Christ's "Dying for Sins" in Pauline Soteriology
Program Unit: Pauline Theology
Simon Gathercole, University of Aberdeen

*


Cheek by Jowl: Demotic Evidence for Fourth Century Religious Interactions in the Nile Valley
Program Unit: Manichaean Studies
John Gee, Brigham Young University

Assessments of religion in Roman Egypt in the fourth century typically use Greek, and sometimes Coptic evidence. In such discussions, it is often forgotten that Demotic texts were written until the fifth century. Demotic texts, nevertheless shed an informative light on interactions between adherents to Christianity and the native Egyptian religion. In this light, it is particularly informative to compare the Manichaen texts with Demotic texts from the same time and place. There are two aspects of the Demotic material that bear on the question of interactions between adherents of the Egyptian religion and Christianity in general and the Manichaean branch of Christianity in particular. The first is the references to Christianity in the Demotic texts which includes incorporation of Christian deities into Egyptian religion, the Egyptian use of Christian texts, and adapting Christian ritual for Egyptian temple worship. The second shows up in the language of the respective texts. Comparison of the Manichaean manuscripts from Narmuthis with Demotic material from the same time period from both Narmuthis and nearby Tebtunis shows that the grammar and syntax are basically identical; the religious distinctions appear in vocabulary and script. What is perhaps surprising is that the vocabulary differences are largely limited to technical items and that the basic vocabulary is the same, down to Coptic dialectical idiosyncrasies. Manichaean treatment of Egyptian religious vocabulary and Egyptian treatment of Christian religious vocabulary reveals the attitudes that the different religious groups had toward each other. Events in the fourth century reflect the differences manifest in the vocabulary.


The Export of the Egyptian Scribe
Program Unit: Egyptology and Ancient Israel
John Gee, Brigham Young University

Normal discussions of international lingua franca in the Ancient Near East confine themselves to Akkadian, Aramaic and Greek. While the Egyptian scribal tradition is well-known in Egypt, it is also attested outside of Egypt, from Kassite Babylon, and the Neo-Assyrian Empire, to ancient Israel. I will examine the appearance of ancient Egyptian scribes outside of Egypt. I will also examine what can be determined about the context of their exportation outside Egypt.


Anadiplosis Iterata or Literary-Rhetorical Criticism and Concentric Structure Revisited
Program Unit: Hebrews
Gabriella Gelardini, University of Basel

In the year 1963, evidently when the “linguistic turn” had taken hold of New Testament studies, Albert Vanhoye the linguistically trained catholic priest published a monograph entitled La structure littéraire de l’épître aux Hébreux. The manifold reactions to his refined literary-rhetorical approach and conclusions in favor of a concentric structure were by no means neutral—rather they oscillated between euphoric approval and offensive disapproval. Fact is, with his investigation—along with its translation into German (1979/80) and a decade later into English (1989)—Vanhoye influenced and stimulated Hebrews scholarship like no one else did in the 20. century. Much has been achieved since then despite the fact that regarding the riddle of Hebrews literary structure no consensus has been reached yet. Nonetheless, scholars moved to new chapters of Hebrews scholarship and introduced new approaches such as rhetorical criticism (e.g. Übelacker 1989), discourse analysis (e.g. Guthrie 1994), social science (e.g. deSilva 2000) and narrative criticism (e.g. Schenck 2003). Methodological considerations regarding literary structure ought to begin with the quest for the function which a particular method should fulfill and must clarify beforehand whether the method is apt for texts produced in and for oral societies. It is my aim to make a strong case for a modified literary-rhetorical criticism given that it excellently servers the goal to gain an exegetical pre-comprehension of a text. While addressing structural “problem zones” and discussing obvious literary structural markers, I want to demonstrate that the argumentation on the macro structural level is arranged in a concentric catena (or anadiplosis iterata). In correspondence to that the text on the micro structural level is arranged in concentric thought circles (Gedankenkreise) throughout the entire book as well. This inductive approach allows not only an interpretative comparison of sister paragraphs it also generates a hermeneutical key that is able to put all parts of the book into a logical and coherent whole.


Sabbath, Manna, and Tabernacle in the Pentateuch
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Stephen Geller, Jewish Theological Seminary

An examination of the literary-theological patterning of the institution of the Sabbath as presented in the Priestly tradition of the Pentateuch, especially in relation to the traditions of creation and cult. The Sabbath is used as a vehicle for the development of new and revolutionary concepts of sacred time and holiness that are basic to the views of the Priestly authors.


Tabernacle Taxonomies: The Logic of Tabernacle Social Space
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Mark K. George, Iliff School of Theology

Since the work of Menahem Haran, scholars have argued that holiness serves as a logical means of organizing and dividing tabernacle space. In this paper, I argue that tabernacle space is better understood to be organized by a set of interrelated social ideas and categories. Drawing upon recent work in critical spatial theory and the understanding of space as a social product, I argue that the tabernacle is social space, and as such encodes within it particular social categories and distinctions of the society or group that produced this space. As a product of the priestly writers, tabernacle space is logically organized, divided, and arranged on the basis of ethnicity, descent, and hereditary succession. It is these social factors that provide the conceptual arrangement of tabernacle space.


Who Peopled the Madaba Plains in the Iron Age?
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Lawrence T. Geraty, La Sierra University

"Who Peopled the Madaba Plains in the Iron Age?" At various times and places, scholars have suggested that the Madaba Plains were occupied by Reubenites, Ammonites, Moabites, and others. This paper examines the archaeological and epigraphic evidence for clues and make some suggestions for discussion.


Praise in the Ralm of Death
Program Unit: Lament in Sacred Texts and Cultures
Erhard S. Gerstenberger, Philipps Universität, Marburg

Since Sumerian times lamentations sometimes include hymnic elements (cf. Urnamma of Ur, Hymn A in: Esther Flückiger-Hawker, OBO 166, 1999, 93-182). Biblical psalmists in various places vehemently deny the possibility of praise from the netherworld (cf. Pss 6:6; 88:6.11-13), and the Book of Lamentation hardly shows any vestiges of eulogy to Yahweh (cf. Lam 5:19). On the other hand, some lamenting psalms (cf. Pss 44; 89) do pointedly employ hymnic language. What, then, may have been the function of doxological poetry in the framework of (cultic!) wailing and complaining through ancient Near Eastern literature?


The Literary Contexts of the Deuteronomic Code
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Jan Christian Gertz, University of Heidelberg

Both Deut 1–3 and 5:1–6:3 serve to integrate the formerly independent Deut-Code into an extant narrative context. Deut 5:1–6:3 conceptually coordinates the proclamation of the law on Sinai and the interpretive proclamation of the law in Moab. What guides the composition is the idea of gradual stages in the proclamation. In contrast to this, Deut 1–3 is concerned with a historical-geographical coordination. It presents the interpretive proclamation “on the other side of the Jordan in the valley facing Beit Peor” as a new edition of the account of Israel’s sojourn in Horeb. Deut 1–3 and Deut 5:1–6:3 appear to be the work of one and the same author. These texts represent the first attempt to historically position the Deut-Code in keeping with the older Hexateuch narrative. Yet it was not the first attempt in general to historically position the Deut-Code. My paper focuses on a still older attempt, which introduced the Code with Deut 4:45*; 5:1a*; 6:4. This version knows only of a proclamation of the Code during the Exodus of the Israelites from Egypt.


Who Influenced Whom? The Reciprocal Influence between the Septuagint and the New Testament Textual Witnesses
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Radu Gheorghita, Midwestern Baptist Theological Seminary

One of the most fruitful areas of the Septuagint research has been the multifaceted influence exerted by the LXX on the text and theology of the New Testament. While much recent effort has been directed toward examining the LXX textual and theological influence, a more fundamental aspect, the intricate, bi-directional relationship between the LXX and the NT manuscripts, particularly in the earlier stages of their transmission, has been overlooked. This study investigates the reciprocal influence and interference between the families of manuscripts of the LXX and the NT, with focus on the epistle to the Hebrews, in order to determine more precisely the direction of that influence. Consequently, the study will offer a more solid foundation on which the Septuagint’s theological influence can be analyzed and assessed.


Dialectical Negation in the Lord's Prayer: The Conundrum of Matthew 6:13a Revisited
Program Unit: Matthew
Jeffrey A. Gibbs, Concordia Seminary

This paper will survey the extent to which both ancient and modern readers of Matthew's version of the Lord's Prayer have puzzled over the meaning of Matt 6:13a, "And lead us not into temptation." The paper's argument will then combine the following elements: (1) analysis of the structure of Matt 6:9b-13; (2) the meaning of temptation and the character of God in Matthew s Gospel; (3) Parallels between the Lord's Prayer and Jesus' temptation in the wilderness (4:1-11); and (4) the rhetorical form of hyperbole known as dialectical negation, following the work of Heinz Kruze and Andrew Bartelt. Given the presence of dialectical negation elsewhere in Matthew's Gospel (Hos 6:6 in Matt 9:13, 12:7; Matt 10:20; Matt 10:34), the paper will propose that Matt 9:13a and b must be read together, with the following force: Do not only bring us into temptation, but even more deliver us from the Evil One. This understanding is consistent with the portrait of discipleship in Matthew wherein the disciple is not above his master, or a slave above his lord.


The "Bread" Petition in the Lord's Prayer: A Lack of Alas?
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Jeffrey B. Gibson, Harry S Truman College

Commentators have long assumed that the backdrop of the "bread" petition of the Lord's prayer (Matt 6:11 //Lk. 11:3) is a painful sense of deprivation either of the necessities of life or (especially when the Lord's prayer is seen to be an "eschatological prayer") of one of the anticipated joys of the messianic age. Because of this they have frequently argued that the petition's aim is for God to grant the petitioners something that they lack, whether this be ordinary bread or a place at the table in an expected "Messianic banquet". It is my contention, however, that once we set the petition within the interpretative context that seems most fitting for it -- namely, the stories set out in Ex. 17: Num. 11, 14; and Pss. 78 and 95 that tell us how the wilderness generation ultimately refused, to accept and be constrained by what God had deemed, and what its experienced had proven, was that generation's "necessary" bread -- it becomes clear that no sense of deprivation stands behind the petition for "bread". To the contrary, the petition assumes a previous and continuous provision by God of "bread". And if this is the case, then the petition is not a plea to gain something that has been lacking. It is in essence a request to God for help both to be content with the "bread" that he has already given and to avoid the kind of grumbling that Israel engaged in when they began to regard the food that God provided them as not sufficient for their needs.


Matthew 26:24 and 28:19
Program Unit: New Testament Mysticism Project
Charles A. Gieschen, Concordia Theological Seminary

A commentary on Matthew 26:24 and 28:19 will be presented.


Between Public and Domestic Space: The Pauline Ekklêsiai as New Space
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Carlos Gil, Universidad de Deusto

The most extended picture to understand meeting places for Pauline ekklêsiai is that of J. Murphy-O’Connor, who expanded the idea of Roman villa as common place for most of these meetings. Recently, some other interesting proposals have arisen (D. Horrell, A. Wallace-Hadrill, M. Trümper, etc.), maintaining the idea of domestic spaces for those meetings. There are, conversely, some details in the Paul’s letters that seem to point to non domestic meeting spaces. If this is true, the difficulties Paul suffered in Philippi, Thessalonica or Corinth, for instance, could find good account and, in addition, we could explain better the influence of some cults and philosophies and, simultaneously, recognize the politic dimension of Pauline theology and ethos.


Luke-Acts and the Second Sophistic: Roman Imperium and Subordinate Responses
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Gary Gilbert, Claremont McKenna College

The Gospel of Luke along with its companion Acts of the Apostles display an unmistakable interest in things Roman. Critical scholarship has long tried to account for this feature of the Lukan narrative. Early perspectives held that Luke-Acts was written to cement a positive relation between Christians and the Roman empire, and to render the life of Jesus and his apostles as an 'apologia pro ecclesia.' More recent analysis has largely dispensed with this understanding, but retains the basic position that Luke-Acts presents Christians and Christianity in a way that is essentially compatible with Roman rule. This paper analyzes references to Rome in the context of Greek imperial literature, particularly that of the Second Sophistic. The writings of Plutarch, Dio of Prussa, and others seek to make sense of Roman power and to understand their identity as Greeks in a world dominated by Rome. Like these writers, Luke uses his literary effort not only to make sense of Roman 'imperium,' but also to call into question the legitimacy of Rome and its imperial status. Rather than accepting Roman authority, Luke-Acts contests Rome's claims by mimicking Roman public expressions of power, transposing them to Jesus and the early church, and offering alternative models of world rule for his Christian audience. This analysis of power relations between dominant and subordinate cultures and the resistance to imperial power borrows both from contemporary Greek literature, and also modern political and post-colonial theories, particularly the concept of colonial mimicry


The Song of Asaph: A Performance Critical Analysis
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Terry Giles , Gannon University

The Song of Asaph in 1 Chronicles 16: 8-36 provides a wonderful opportunity to apply Performance Criticism to the Hebrew Bible. The song is a composite drawn from Psalm 105: 1-15 (vs. 8-22), Psalm 96: 1b-13a (vs. 23-33), and Psalm 106: 1, 47-48 (vs. 34-36). Since we are fortunate enough to not only have the song as composed by the Chronicler, but his sources from the Psalms as well, we have an opportunity to examine how the Chronicler’s use of his selected material changed that lyric by inserting it into a prose context. Further, since the Chronicler borrowed his narrative from 1 Samuel 5-6, we can also observe how the narrative material was changed by the Chronicler when the lyric was inserted. Our examination of the Song of Asaph will explore the nature of the Chronicler’s edits and their intended effect. The examination will use performative concepts such as iconic and dialectic presentation, communal audience, and memory and recycling.


Seeking to See Him at the Festival of Pascha: The Expectation of the Divine Glory in Early Christian Paschal Materials and Rabbinic Literature
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Dragos-Andrei Giulea, Marquette University

Two of the most ancient Christian Paschal homilies, one by Melito of Sardes and the other of unknown origin, preserved under the names of Hippolytus of Rome or John Chrysostom, testify to the expectation of the divine glory during the Paschal night. Rabbinic materials such as the Targums Neofiti 1 and Pseudo-Jonathan attest to a similar expectation on the night of the festival of Pesach. The salvific power of this light seems to constitute the first reason for this Paschal expectation. Since further investigation identifies similar elements in the writings of Philo of Alexandria, the present study proposes what might be called a “two-branched trunk” theory: one might reasonably suppose that both the Christian and the Jewish-rabbinic expectations of the salvific glory of Pascha may constitute two different developments of a common matrix in the Second Temple festival of Passover. Major doctrinal and ritual shifts emerge in the Christian worship where Jesus Christ took the place of Yahweh or of his Word. From a mystical perspective, these materials and others such as the Songs of the Sabbath Sacrifice and the Christian liturgies, reflect the existence of a form of mysticism that engages a whole community not solely an individual. For Jews and Christians, Pascha was therefore a communitarian form of mysticism. The liturgical celebration may be seen as the necessary step within which the mystical experience should find expression.


Good News to Slaves?
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
Jennifer A. Glancy, Le Moyne College

In the Gospel of Luke, Jesus preaches good news to the poor. Does he, therefore, preach good news for slaves? In the Gospel of Luke, Jesus proclaims woes to the rich. Does he, therefore, preach bad news for slaveholders? Although Jesus traditions in the Gospel of Luke are marked by their origin in the slaveholding culture of the eastern reaches of the Roman Empire, the Lukan Jesus does not acknowledge or promise to remedy the damages of slavery. Even more problematically, the Lukan Jesus does not condemn slaveholding or constrain the behavior of slaveholders. If we are to consider the ways that Jesus and those who followed him negotiated imperial structures, we must come to terms with their pervasive accommodation to the pernicious practice of slaveholding. The Gospel of Luke is a good place to start.


Magic and Miracle in Westcar Papyrus and in the Priestly Plague Narratives
Program Unit: Egyptology and Ancient Israel
Greg Schmidt Goering, University of North Carolina - Chapel Hill

Scholars have noted thematic parallels between the frame tales of Westcar Papyrus and ancient Israel's account of the exodus from Egypt (parting of waters, inanimate object transformed into a reptile, for instance). What has not been clearly recognized is the similar function of magic in the Westcar Papyrus and the Priestly strand of the Exodus narrative. A literary approach reveals several motifs which unite the individual tales of the Westcar Papyrus. Among these is the leitmotif of magic tricks as Demonstrationswunder. Repeatedly, characters perform magic tricks with the result that observers express marvel. As such, the wonder-inspiring acts serve to legitimate the person performing the magic. In the book of Exodus, the magic tricks performed by Moses and Aaron in P's plague narratives serve a similar function: to inspire wonder and thus legitimate Israel’s god and his designated leaders. The comparison suggests that the connection drawn between magic and miracle by the author of Westcar Papyrus persisted far into the first millennium BCE among Egypt's northern neighbors.


“Put Your Dread Upon All the Nations!” Petitionary Prayer and Creation in Sirach
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Greg Schmidt Goering, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill

The presence of an eschatologically fervent prayer for deliverance in Ben Sira’s otherwise measured discourse on wisdom has led some scholars to suggest that Sir 36 represents a secondary addition. The numerous lexical and thematic connections between the prayer and the preceding passage (Sir 34.21-35.26), however, suggest that Sir 36 is well-integrated into its present context. Nevertheless, even among scholars who desire to read the prayer as an authentic composition of Ben Sira, several issues have resisted satisfactory resolution. In what precise historical context during Ben Sira’s lifetime would such a petition make sense? Why does Sir 36 lack an acknowledgment of sin, such as those found in similar prayers from the post-exilic period (Ezra 9; Neh 9; Dan 9; Pr Azar; Bar 2; 4QDibHam)? Petitions for national deliverance in the book of Psalms (Pss 44; 74; 79; 80; 83) usually depict the miserable circumstances of the people; why is an equivalent statement absent from the Sirach prayer? Comparisons with similar prayers and petitions, however, do not tell us about the function of Sir 36 in Ben Sira’s book as a whole. Pss 8; 104; and 139 offer better parallels for understanding the connection between petitions for divine intervention and creation theology. In Ben Sira’s theology of creation, the presence of foreign occupiers in Judea represents the resurgence of primordial chaos, and, as such, their very existence questions YHWH’s sovereignty. Interpreting Sir 36 as the sage’s plea for the divine warrior to circumscribe once again the forces of chaos explains several puzzling features about the prayer, as well as its seemingly inharmonious setting in the book of Sirach.


The Making of a Rain-Maker: Humor and Sampling in 1 Kings 18
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Amy Gohdes-Luhman, Saint Olaf College

The Elijah/Elisha Narrative attracts much speculation on its literary formation and its relation to the Deuteronomic History. This paper adds to that conversation. Utilizing the tools afforded by Mieke Bal’s narratology, the story of Elijah as rain-maker is examined for its humor, its intertextuality or “sampling,” its literary formation and its placement in the Deuteronomic History. Special attention is placed upon characterization, which leads to a lively reading of the text and speculation on the relationship between the character of Elisha and that of Elijah. By way of humor and sampling, the audience is asked to engage and evaluate the prophetic character of Elijah in comparison with Elisha. Is Elijah’s rain-making to be understood as bringing Ahab’s kingdom back to life as Elisha brought to life the Shunammite’s son? What Elisha can do for a single boy, Elijah can do, not just for a widow’s son, but also for an entire nation.


Jerusalem of Gold
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Edward A. Goldman, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion

According to the rabbinic literature, the construction of the earth began at its center with the foundation stone of the Temple. The Temple in turn was at the center of the Holy City of Jerusalem, and Jerusalem was at the center of the Holy Land. Jerusalem has been at the center not only of Jewish geography but also Jewish theology, philosophy and religious belief for thousands of years. Because of its prominence in the rabbinic literature, aspects of Jerusalem as seen and understood by the Rabbis will be explored in this paper.


Exodus 4:13: Protest or Prayer?
Program Unit: Bible Translation
Galen Goldsmith, Cambridge University

Moses’ last words in his prophetic call narrative are: by-adwny shlch-n’ byd-tshlch. Throughout its translation history, Exod 4.13 has been freely interpreted as his final objection, “Send someone else.” But the consonantal text literally reads, “Send please in the hand You will send”, which, because the hand of God is an image for divine intervention in human affairs, in English idiom could as well mean “Please send (me) in Your power”. The purpose of this paper is to assemble the many reasons that Exod 4.13 can be read as an acquiescent prayer in the prophetic call narrative of Moses rather than as an objection, and consequently to assess v. 14-16 as a distinct and separate paragraph in the dialogue. Several approaches can be synchronized and brought to bear on this question, including analysis of narrative form, of grammar, of chiasmus, of participant reference patterns and syntactic evidence of paragraph divisions, of key words and leading words characteristic of extensive traditions, and of inner biblical exegesis. This discussion raises good and relevant questions about reading difficult or ambiguous passsages, and shows many possibilities for reading and interpreting texts beyond this particular passage.


The 'Adjusted Merkavah' in Early Monastic Authors: Some Reflections on 'Interiorized Apocalypse' in Early Monastic Literature, Its Context, Precedents in Prior Tradition, and Subsequent History
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Alexander Golitzin, Marquette University

Abstract forthcoming


Matthew 25:1–12
Program Unit: New Testament Mysticism Project
Alexander Golitzin, Marquette University

A commentary on Matthew 25:1-12 will be presented.


The Increasing Reverence for the Holy Writ in the Translation of Chronicles
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Roger Good, University of California, Los Angeles

The Greek translation of the Book of Chronicles naturally reflects some of the social and religious currents of the translation community in the Hellenistic-Roman period. Two translation strategies are especially interesting: the avoidance of the circumstantial participle and the historic present in Chronicles. These strategies are best explained as resulting from a trend toward a more literal translation of the Bible as opposed to the freer (but still literal) translation of Pentateuch and Samuel/Kings and the slavishly literal translation of Aquila. I will argue that these translation strategies were motivated by the desire to bring the reader to the source text and an increasing reverence for the holy writ. The resulting translation contains a much higher percentage of aorist indicative forms than typical Hellenistic Greek narrative. While this appears awkward to the Greek reader, it demonstrates the attempt of the translator to bring his reader to the Hebrew source as much as possible. However, the translator does not go to the extreme of using the same common equivalent for each distinct Hebrew verb form, which would have resulted in a nonsensical translation. He was sensitive enough to use non-standard Greek forms where the context dictated or suggested them, and occasionally he made minor adjustments within a basically literal approach.


Already Circumcised: Paul’s Letter of Rebuke to Apostate Galatians
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Mark Goodacre, Duke University

It is commonly assumed that the epistle to the Galatians is addressed to Gentile Christians who have not been circumcised, and that Paul is attempting to dissuade them from what he sees as a disastrous course of action. But the letter's substance and rhetoric are better explained on the assumption that Paul is rebuking churches in which the process of circumcision is already underway. This scenario is preferable to the standard view for several reasons: (1) 6.12 speaks of the agitators compelling the Galatians to be circumcised. ANAGKAZW is here used of successful and not attempted compulsion, as elsewhere in Greek literature, including Gal. 2.14. (2) The conditional sentence in 5.2 is misread when it is used to imply a process not yet underway. (3) The tense of Paul’s statements in 5.4 should be taken seriously “You have been severed from Christ . . . you have fallen from grace” (cf. 5.7). (4) Paul's language of astonishment (1.6), foolishness (3.1) and spells (3.1) tells the same story of successful coercion. (5) The Galatians are already keeping special days (4.10), which gives no hint that they would hold off on circumcision. (6) Paul’s picture of the agitators depicts them with knife in hand (5.12); they are practising circumcision as well as teaching it. (7) Nothing short of a new birth can turn this drastic situation around (4.19).


Archaeology of the Roman Martyrs in Medieval Rome
Program Unit: Christian Late Antiquity and Its Reception
Caroline Goodson, Birbeck, University of London

The cityscape of early medieval Rome included ancient buildings and new ones made of ancient materials. Early medieval builders reconstructed their urban environment with the bricks and marbles of the ancient city, conscious of the systems and structures of antiquity as well as the actual material structures of the Urbs Aeterna among which they lived. In just the same way new forms of religiosity melded the medieval present with the ancient past. I shall examine textual and material evidence for the Roman cult of saints in the early middle ages with special attention to Rome’s own martyrs. This examination will demonstrate the change in papal attitudes to the gesta martyrum in the ninth century in the context of a new found permissiveness of relic translations.


Justification by Crucifixion: The Logic of Paul's Soteriology
Program Unit: Pauline Theology
Michael J. Gorman, Saint Mary's Seminary and University

*


The Extremes of Esther: Midrash on the Megillah
Program Unit: Midrash
Dr. Isaac Gottlieb, Bar Ilan University

The Book of Esther is replete with reversals, exaggerations, and extremes. These are to be found in the events of the plot, the ironic style, and in the very motif of the work--"the opposite happened" (Est. 9:1). A sense of polar extremes is to be found also in the book's interpretation through the ages. The work has been understood as a kind of religious puppet -theatre in which all the characters are manipulated by Providence, yet also as a Wisdom tale of Machiavellian intrigues in which the wiliest win, while modern readings of the scroll see it as a carnival performance, a comedy, even a farce. Further, reactions to the book are extreme: distaste is a mild word for some commentator's feelings, while its popularity in other circles may account for an abundance of Jewish commentary, particularly Midrash. It is our view that extremes and exaggerations are also to be found in Midrash on this book. While this may seem natural in the Aggadic Midrash, we focus on the statements of an halakhic nature, to show that these too uncharacteristically include elements of paradox and exaggeration. The very fact that the Megillah is subject to halakhic midrash is in itself exceptional. We will try to show how the midrashic stance of exaggeration is primarily a form of defense, both for the Megillah and the holiday of Purim. We will suggest that several other scrolls whose interpretation was "at risk" also received the services of a defensive Midrash.


Structure and Origin of the Early Israelite and Iroquois "Confederacies"
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
Norman K. Gottwald, Pacific School of Religion

Since the widespread dismissal of Noth’s ingenious hypothesis that early Israel formed an amphictyony on analogy with amphictyonies in the classical world, there has been surprisingly little attention to what sort of supratribal organization may have characterized early Israel. Rather, it seems, the conclusion has generally been drawn that, if not an amphictyony, then early Israel will have lacked supratribal organization of any sort.. It is that assumption I am questioning, not only by reexamining the biblical text but by engaging in a number of studies comparing premonarchic Israel with pre-state or sub-state peoples that appear to bear some resemblance to early Israel in structure and/or origin, and that also exhibit a variety of confederate arrangements. Having previously examined the Icelandic Commonwealth, I now turn to a critical comparison of premonarchic Israel and the Iroquois league of Five Nations.. In this paper I will first describe what is known about the structure of the Iroquois confederacy in comparison with what is hypothesized about the structure of an alleged early Israelite confederacy, taking note of points of difference and points with sufficient similarity to warrant further examination. Next, I will describe what is hypothesized concerning the origin of the Iroquois confederacy in relation to what is hypothesized about the origin of the alleged Israelite confederacy. I will conclude by stating what I believe the comparative study of societies across cultures can accomplish and what it cannot accomplish. In short, in exploring the hypothesis that early Israel constituted an intertribal confederacy of some sort, comparative studies open up possibilities, sometimes strengthening what is already surmised and sometimes suggesting new lines of inquiry, but comparative studies, given the independence in time and/or space of the societies compared, can never establish certainties.


The End of the Beginning: The Development of Socio-rhetorical Criticism, 1975–1996
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
David B. Gowler, Emory University

Although Vernon K. Robbins did not use the term "socio-rhetorical criticism" until the first edition of Jesus the Teacher (1984), the foundations for socio-rhetorical analysis were laid years before. That 1984 work declared that socio-rhetorical analysis "emphasizes the wide range of strategies, both overt and covert, that constitute persuasive communication." Robbins's first musings about a socio-rhetorical method of analysis developed in 1975 during his study of the we-passages in Luke. The import of this study was that a well-known social convention could greatly influence the rhetoric of a literary narrative. This insight began to grow and mature in Robbins's publications until this initial, primarily intuitive approach became more programmatic. This paper will examine how social-rhetorical criticism developed in the writings of Robbins and how those writings led to the discussions of the four "textures" in Robbins's The Tapestry of Early Christian Discourse (1996) and the five "textures" in Robbins's Exploring the Textures of Texts (1996).


The Gestalt of the High Priest in the Second Temple Period: An Anthropological Perspective
Program Unit: Social-Scientific Studies of the Second Temple Period
Lester L. Grabbe, University of Hull

The place of the high priest as both religious and political leader in Judah during the Persian, Greek, and Roman periods is often taken for granted. However, the position of the high priest as a political or civil leader has recently been questioned. My aim will be to consider whether anthropology (whether historical or contemporary) provides models that might help us to understand better the high priest's position in Second Temple Judaean society.


"They Shall Come Rejoicing to Zion"-or Did They? The Settlement of Yehud in the Early Persian Period
Program Unit: Literature and History of the Persian Period
Lester L. Grabbe, University of Hull

The book of Ezra has an almost empty Yehud repeopled by returnees from the exile in the early Persian empire, and until recently this was widely accepted. Now, a variety of scenarios have been proposed. This paper aims to look at the possibilities of historical reconstruction in the light of text, archaeology, and the history of the wider Persian empire.


The Reception of the New Covenant Concept (cf. Jeremiah 31:31–34) in Early Judaism (especially Qumran) and in the Early Church (Barnabas, Justin, Irenaeus, Clement of Alexandria, Origen, and Aphrahat)
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Petrus Grabe, Regent University

The purpose of this paper is to trace the history of effect ("Wirkungsgeschichte" of the concept of a new covenant, found especially in Jeremiah 31:31-34, in early Judaism and early Christianity. A brief investigation of the new covenant concept in the Hebrew Bible will be followed by an investigation of the meaning of the phrase "new covenant in the land of Damascus" in the Qumran Damascus Scroll. Following an overview of the new covenant concept in the New Testament, the use of the new covenant concept in Barnabas, Justin, Irenaeus, Clement of Alexandria, Origin and Aphrahat will be discussed. It wil be pointed out that the term "kaine diatheke" ("new covenant") is used by Clement both to speak of the theology of salvation history and to designate the writings of the New Testament. In a similar way, Tertullian uses "testamentum" in certain contexts to refter to the biblical books and uses it elsewhere in a theological context to refer to "last will/covenant." In Origen's commentaries "kaine diatheke" refers, however, primarily to the New Testament. This development can be explained by discerning five phases in the way early Christianity used the new convenant concept. The paper will conclude with reflections on the implications of this textured history of effect on our current understanding of the new covenant concept.


Scriptural Citations on the Angels in the Hexaemeron of Jacob of Edessa
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Marina Greatrex, St Paul University

This paper will examine Jacob's quotations from the Peshitta and the Septuagint on the angelic beings in Memra I of his Hexaemeron. It will discuss which version he prefers to use, the changes he makes to the text, and the manner in which he organizes Scriptural citations to construct a detailed angelology. Jacob's citations are exhaustive, including both explicit and implicit references to the angels from Genesis to the Gospels. Sometimes he simply follows the order of references in the individual books, and other times he makes thematic links between the texts. The recurrent themes include: the angelic (in)corporeal nature and propensity to sin, their role as ministers of God sent to protect or punish his people, and their role in proclaiming Jesus Christ to the world. This paper will demonstrate that Jacob's exhaustive angelology is heavily dependent on the Cappadocian fathers, in particular Gregory of Nyssa. Gregory's picture of the ascent and descent of Christ is a motif that punctuates Memra I of Jacob's Hexaemeron, and it is linked to the mediational role of the angels, who link the divine to the human in a triadic hierarchy of being.


Use of Perfume in Jewish Burials
Program Unit:
Deborah Green, University of Oregon

*


Luke on Conversion/Repentance: A Cognitive Linguistic Assessment
Program Unit: Cognitive Linguistics in Biblical Interpretation
Joel B. Green, Asbury Theological Seminary

*


The Freer Joshua: Its Role in Constructing a Family Tree for the Greek Texts of the Book of Joshua
Program Unit:
Leonard Greenspoon, Creighton University

Manuscripts, like people, have closer, as well as more distant relatives. The DNA, as it were, of determining affiliation among manuscripts are distinctive readings. The text of the Freer Joshua has been claimed as both an early and a considerably later member of the family or transmitted for hundreds of years). We will see whether we can fix more firmly the Freer Joshua's place on its family tree--and how we go about doing so.


From Oral Epic to Writerly Verse and Some of the Stages in Between
Program Unit: Orality, Textuality, and the Formation of the Hebrew Bible
Edward L. Greenstein, Tel Aviv University

Research points to a certain continuity from the epic verse attested in Ugaritic to the early poetry of Israel and to the later poetry of Israel. Several literary conventions appear in both form and content in each of these three groups. At the same time, one can discern over time a certain breakdown in the conventions, especially in the direction of increased flexibility. In addition, certain later texts display types of sophisticated intertextual activity, such as parody. In the present paper, an attempt will be made to reflect on the relations between early Canaanite epic and early Hebrew verse and on the relations between early Hebrew verse and later biblical poetry. In the course of these reflections, an attempt will be made to sort out a variety of stages and types of oral and written literature, between the orally performed text that would in all likelihood have been orally composed, at one end of the spectrum, and a text with oral qualities that would seem nevertheless to have been written to be read, on the other. Illustrations will be adduced from diverse texts, from Ugaritic epic to the Book of Job.


“Have You Despised Jerusalem and Zion after You Had Chosen Them”? Explanations for the Destruction of the Second Temple in Jewish and Christian Writings from the Land of Israel in Late Antiquity
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Adam Gregerman, Columbia University

The destruction of the Temple and Jerusalem in 70 CE had profound theological implications for Jews and Christians. They shared a fundamental belief in God’s involvement in human history. It was therefore necessary to provide a religious explanation for an event of such enormous significance, one that all agreed was not random but somehow reflected the will of God. However, when it came to specific explanations, Jewish and Christian views sharply diverged, particularly regarding the issue of what the destruction revealed about the relationship between God and Israel. In this paper, I discuss two texts from the rabbinic midrash on Lamentations and then selections from writings by Origen and Eusebius. I do not argue that the two communities were in direct contact with each other, but I do believe that these texts illustrate different attempts to grapple with an event that brings up shared concerns about legitimacy and about which people are the true Israel. The midrashim support their claims by rejecting a traditional theodicy that makes Israel responsible for their own suffering, and even blame the destruction on God. The Christians offer precisely the opposite explanation for the destruction. They support a theodicy that links the Jews’ killing of Jesus with the terrible destruction a few decades later, and which legitimates the transfer of God’s favor from Jews to Gentile Christians.


Irenaeus and the Reception of Acts in the Second Century
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Andrew Gregory, Oxford University

This paper will be part of a panel discussion on the reception of Acts in the second century and beyond.


"That We Might Become the Righteousness of God”? Eschatology and Ethics in Pauline Soteriology
Program Unit: Pauline Theology
A. Katherine Grieb, Virginia Theological Seminary

*


“Keep up Your Transformation in the Renewal of the Mind:” Romans as a Therapeutic Letter
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Robin Griffith-Jones, Temple Church

Paul believed the gospel is the power of God for deliverance (Rom 1.16) – and here in the letter is that power in action, even as the reader reads or listener hears. Paul punctuated his letters with sets of verbal signposts he provided for those who must listen to the letter on its arrival. The most important signpost in Romans is Paul’s repeated description of and appeal to the mind, nous, of the listeners. As they have not reckoned to keep God in their awareness, God himself has consigned them to an unreckoning mind, to do all kinds of wrong (1.28). At first Paul skirts round the delinquency he diagnoses in the understanding and will of the Roman Christians themselves. He soon homes in. In the course of the letter Paul will (he hopes) heal each listener’s mind, and so the community of which they are members. Half way through the letter the mind is healed; the inner person is ready to endorse God’s law. Self-consciousness is growing. So then I myself serve the law of God with my mind – but with my flesh the law of wrongdoing (7.22-25). By 12.1 the healing is to be complete: its recipients are to have risen to new life as members of Christ’s re-united body. Keep up your transformation in the renewal of your mind, so that you might reckon aright what is the will of God (12.2). The recipients have been “healed” during their reception of the letter itself. They are now ready to hear Paul’s guidance, 12.1ff, for the healing of the Body of Christ of which they are members. Paul did not write to persuade his listeners through his letter, but to transform them. He wrote as a physician of the mind.


Thinking the Targum’s Thoughts after It: The Song of Hannah
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Douglas M. Gropp, Catholic University of America

It has been often observed that Targum Jonathan turns Hannah’s song of thanksgiving in praise of the LORD who reverses fortunes (1 Sam 2:1-10) into a prophecy about Israel’s future. Overall, 2:1-5 are interpreted in a historically particularlizing way (rooted in Hannah’s present in 2:1, leading ultimately to the fall of Rome and the establishment of Jerusalem), and 2:6-10 are interpreted in an eschatological way. We will explore the various factors and mechanisms for this prophetic interpretation. The reference to a future anointed one/Messiah in 2:10 as well as the phrase “my enemies” in 2:1 and “those who contend with Him” in 2:10 provide a framework within which to recount the history of the LORD’s deliverance of Israel from a succession of enemies (Philistines, Assyrians, Babylonians, Greeks, Romans, and ultimately Gog and its allies). Particular phrases in the Hebrew text seem to triggar associations with other Scriptures leading to the identifying of these particular enemies. we’ap serves as a formal cue for introducing an expansion, while beken serves as a pivot to return to a more straight forward translation of the Hebrew text. Interestingly, the struggle of Esther and Mordecai with the sons of Haman between the mention of the Hasmoneans and the Romans (out of their biblical sequence) raises the possibility that they are code names for Queen Shelamzion Alexandra, Shim'on ben Shetah, and the Sadducees respectively.


The Hebrew Bible and Political Theory: The State of the Scholarship
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
Steven Grosby, Clemson University

Two avenues for investigation should influence considerations of the relation between the Hebrew Bible and Political Theory. First, one obviously examines the politics of the Hebrew Bible to understand better the text itself and the history of Ancient Israel. However, when doing so, one may uncover implications of such a study for political theory, including the ways by which the reading of the Hebrew Bible has had a bearing on the political tradition of the Occident. Thus, this first avenue opens up the possibility of the study of the Hebrew Bible contributing to political theory. Second, one draws upon political theory, which includes the determination of what is politics, to elucidate our analysis of Hebrew Bible. This paper will examine briefly the state of the scholarship of this relation, how both the study of the Hebrew Bible has drawn upon political theory and the ways by which such a study has contributed to political theory.


A Passion for Jesus: Popular Re-readings of Scholarly Claims
Program Unit: Social History of Formative Christianity and Judaism
Maxine L. Grossman, University of Maryland

An analysis of popular portraits of Jesus that highlights their grounding in strong misreadings of academic scholarship allows for a better understanding of scholarly discourse, the romanticization of scholarship for popular consumption, and contemporary perceptions of Jesus on the part of both scholars and the general public, as well. This paper will demonstrate some of the ways that pop culture representations of Jesus, such as those found in The Da Vinci Code and Gibson's "The Passion of the Christ," actually trace back through surprising lines of connection to scholarly discourse itself.


Women's Voices in the Book of Micah
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Mayer I. Gruber, Ben Gurion University of the Negev

It is commonly asserted that three biblical texts--Gen 22; Judg 11; and 2 Kgs 3:27-- all attest to the fact that mothers bear children while fathers sacrifice them. Ironically, one of the rare texts in the Book of the Twelve Prophets that records a woman's voice, Micah 6:7, suggests that an 8th century BCE mother in Israel (or Judah) indeed contemplated sacrificing her son. However, she was talked out of this by a prophet. The proposed paper will demonstrate the philological basis for determining that it is indeed a mother rather than a father who proposes to sacrifice a first-born son in Mic 6:7. In addition, other women's voices in the Book of Micah (Mic 6:4; 7:6;) will be examined in the larger contexts of the Book of Micah, the Twelve Prophets, and the larger corpus of Hebrew Scripture.


Job 31:1, 9–12 Reconsidered
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Mayer I. Gruber, Ben Gurion University of the Negev

The otherwise virtuous Job seems to treat his wife as a mere object when he suggests that were he merely to look at another man's wife, she should compensate this men by giving him sexual favors. On the other hand, Job 42 portrays Job as eschewing patriarchal values when he bequeaths his real estate to sons and daughters alike, beyond Moses's allowing daughters to inherit real estate in the absence of male heirs (Num 27). Reading Job 31:1, 9-12 in the light of Hos 4; Matt 5:28 and Mishnah Sotah 9:9, the proposed paper will demonstrate the following: Job 31 attacks patriarchy, takes monogamy for granted, and suggests that the just punishment for a husband's philandering is for the wife to engage with impunity in extra-marital liaisons of their own, Consequently, the Book of Job belongs to a short list of Hebrew Scripture texts which advocate monogamy and a shorter list of Hebrew Scripture texts, which castigqte men who compromise mongamy.


Discourse Analysis: Prominence, Salience, and Grounding
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Steven Gunderson, University of Surrey Roehampton

An overview of key concepts of discourse analysis related to the analysis of prominence. Application from 1 John.


Goliath’s Head: Rendering Death in the Bible for Youth
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
David M. Gunn, Texas Christian University

This paper explores how David’s killing of Goliath has been viewed in popular illustration for youth, in Britain and North America, since the eighteenth century. Artists over the centuries have generally rendered some variation of: 1) David with his sling facing a standing (or falling) Goliath; 2) David atop a fallen Goliath, about to sever (or severing) his head; 3) David, Goliath’s head in hand, beside the truncated corpse; 4) David in procession, with Goliath’s head impaled on a sword or pole. My illustrated presentation traces the changing choices made for the visual consumption of the Bible by youth, and relates these changes to educational debates concerning age-appropriate depiction of violence and death, as well as to changing social attitudes towards public execution and decapitation. While most of the illustrations considered will be from printed materials, some will be drawn from other media such as film.


The Structure of Hebrews Revisited
Program Unit: Hebrews
George H. Guthrie, Union University

The concundrum of Hebrews' structure constitutes one of the most difficult of the difficult issues in contemporary Hebrews' research. This paper revisits the general proposal made in THE STRUCTURE OF HEBREWS: A TEXT-LINGUISTIC ANALYSIS, NovTSup, 73 (Brill, 1994), but incorporates insights from continued study and dialogue in scholarly forums over the past twelve years.


The Other Side of Israelite Religion: Goddess Tradition Survives through the Ages
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
SungAe Ha, GTU

The discovery and study of the ancient Near Eastern cultures and religions of Egypt, the Levant and Mesopotamia have conclusively shown that the religion of Israel did not arise in a religious vacuum. Rather it was rooted in the soil of Canaan, the cradle of Israelite religion and culture. This means that the religion of Israel is not a mere ‘counter-religion’, an independent and unique religious phenomenon, with respect to other ancient Near Eastern religions surrounding it. In fact, archaeological findings from the land attest to polytheistic, syncretistic, and iconic cult and religiosity in ancient Israel. However, this is a very different perspective from the writers of the Hebrew Bible. For polytheism and iconolatry are forbidden in the Hebrew Bible. This conflict and gap between materials always entails a possibility of new interpretation. This is where archaeological and iconographical studies and historical and textual studies can challenge one another and so produce a greater knowledge and understanding. Therefore, in order to arrive at a more comprehensive understanding of the Israelite religion than the officially admitted records allows, I will examine textual, archaeological, and pictorial data from ancient Near Eastern religious and cultural sources. The selected archaeological and the epigraphic findings as well as parallel textual evidence, investigated in this paper, will make it clear that religious life in ancient Israel was pluriform and varied. This examination also suggests how Israelite religion evolved from a polytheistic and syncretistic religious milieu and cult to the monotheistic religion of Yahwism. More significantly, I will present how through its evolution the religious and cultic tradition of goddesses in ancient Israel was suppressed, eradicated, transformed, and, in some ways, survived as well.


Mapping Violence in the Prophets
Program Unit: Prophetic Texts and Their Ancient Contexts
Robert D. Haak, Augustana College

‘Texts of violence’ are often found within the prophetic literature. This paper will attempt to ‘map’ the ways that violence is expressed in this literature and the potential theological responses to it. The claim is made that an understanding of these relationships will provide a framework for discussion of the relationship of prophets to power, especially political power. This discussion will raise questions about the nature of power and violence in our own thinking and our role as scholars in that conversation.


What Do Athens and Jerusalem Have to Do with Sioux Falls?
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Murray Joseph Haar, Augustana College

We are two professors of religion, one Jewish and the other Christian, teaching at a Christian affiliated liberal arts insitution. We are charged at our college to teach our religion courses in such a way that we encourage faith. But the context in which we do so, namely that of the liberal arts, places a premium on the freedom to challenge all assertions. Living within this tension we have made two observations. First, these two commitments are not always reconcilable. How does one simultaneously convey conviction and open-minded exploration? This dialectic has led us to reflect upon our different heritages. Here we have concluded that the Jewish approach seems to be more comfortable posing questions (Is God good?), while the Christian tradition has tended to seek answers (God is good). Can our respective religious backgrounds give us new paradigms for envisioning the task of teaching religion at a religious liberal arts institution?


Retrieving the Character/Voice of Earth in Genesis One
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Norman C. Habel, Flinders University

In the first symposium we focused on the anthropocentric dimensions of the text. In the second we explored possible identification with non-human characters in the story. In this, the third consultation, we ask whether if we view figures such as Earth as subjects in the narrative rather than objects of investigation, we can retrieve Earth’s own story and hear her voice in a text such as Genesis One. Earth and other domains of creation are given voice in the Psalms. Job invites us to ‘ask the birds of the sky’. Can we, by identifying with Earth, hear her suppressed voice in Genesis One? Can we, by reading the text from Earth’s perspective, uncover unseen roles and voices of a key character such as Earth?


Asherah and the Queen Mother
Program Unit: Israelite Religion in its Ancient Context
Judith Hadley, Villanova University

The position of Queen Mother, or "Great Lady", is the most influential position a woman could hope to achieve in ancient Israel. And yet most of the biblical accounts we have concerning them are negative. Perhaps the most intriguing account is that of Maacah, Asa's (grand)mother, whom Asa removes from being Queen Mother because she made a mipletset, or "horrid thing" for Asherah. What is this connection between Asherah and the Queen Mother, and what might the mipletset be? Some scholars have suggested that it could be connected to the asherah poles set up in the Jerusalem temple, whereas others have suggested the small pottery pillar figurines so common throughout Judah in the 8th century BCE. Furthermore, Jeremiah condemns the worship of the "Queen of Heaven", who is said to be worshiped by royalty, officials, and common folk alike. Many scholars have sought to identify this Queen of Heaven with Asherah. What is the function of this unnamed Queen of Heaven, and can she be associated with the royal court? How is Asherah connected to the Queen Mother, and could this association suggest something about the nature of the goddess and not just the Queen Mother? In other words, is this connection with Asherah an attempt to discredit the role of Queen Mother? Or is "Yahweh's Asherah" the consort of Yahweh, as has been supposed, or is she instead Yahweh's mother?


The Main Point of 1 Peter: A Proposal
Program Unit: Methodological Reassessments of the Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Scott Hafemann, Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary

What is the "main point" of a paragraph and how is it ascertained? Are there any methodological controls for answering these questions? If the basic unit of meaning is the paragraph, how does one read from paragraph to paragraph? Can this be done in 1 Peter? I. The Methodological Approach-To answer these questions, the paper will present a brief introduction to a modified form of Semantic Structure Analysis, which leads to a commonly used method of reading the rhetorical argument of a text called, for lack of a better name, "Discourse Analysis." The eighteen logical relationships that exist between propositions will be presented and the method of tracing the flow of an argument within a paragraph will be introduced. The final goal of exegesis, to read from paragraph to paragraph, will then be proposed. II. A Discourse Analysis of the Argument of First Peter - The body of the paper will present my understanding of the main point of each of the major, argument-furthering paragraphs of 1 Peter, as well as proposing the overarching rhetorical structure that ties them together into an argumentative whole. The paper ends by proposing the main proposition of 1 Peter. III. Understanding 1 Peter - As an exercise in "practical hermeneutics," the paper endeavors to show how "tracing the flow of an argument" from paragraph to paragraph elucidates the rhetoric of 1 Peter. It may be not be "novel" to pursue the main point of a text but it is certainly "new" in our day and age of atomistic reading on the one hand and broad-based rhetorical "labeling" on the other to build on such analyses by seeking the main point of an entire writing (and not just its "theme") via its grammar and syntax.


Teaching New Testament Greek Interactively on the Web
Program Unit: Computer Assisted Research
Raimo Hakola, University of Helsinki

The presentation introduces a multiform learning environment for New Testament Greek developed at the Department of Biblical Studies in the University of Helsinki. This learning environment, Kamu, was granted the Teaching Technology Award by the University of Helsinki in 2003 and the National Award of Excellence in the Web Learning Technologies at the University Level by the Finnish Ministry of Education in 2005. Kamu is accessible in Finnish at www.helsinki.fi/teol/hyel/opiskelu/y65/kamu. The presentation will include demonstrations of various interactive exercises and games in English. In addition to the web material, Greek classes and a new textbook are part of the multiform learning environment. By using Kamu students can study Greek flexibly according to their own individual study plans and schedules. Web exercises give students immeadite feedback on their performance and enables an unlimited amount of repetitions in exercises dealing with Greek alphabets, vocabulary, different grammatical forms and translation of texts. Kamu contains self-correcting tests that help students to evaluate the level of their own learning and the need of further exercises. The principal aim is to enhance the effectiveness of Greek teaching by stimulating students to use more time on independent study. Kamu also helps to develop the teaching of Greek from traditional teacher-centered lectures into a more student-centered, self-paced and interactive learning experience. The presenters hope to share experiences in teaching ancient languages using interactive computer tools and welcome new ideas for the further development of the learning environment.


The Land of Canaan, with Its Various Boundaries
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Chaya Halberstam, King's College, University of London

Law can be seen as both the creator and protector of societal boundaries; biblical law, and especially the levitical law codes, lend these boundaries a kind of sacred status. This talk begins with one of P's inviolable sacred boundaries--specifically, the holy/profane opposition--and connects it to a more commonplace biblical legal boundary: private property allotment. These two realms, which at first glance appear unrelated, converge under the rubric of the curious 'asham sacrifice which serves as reparation for, among other transgressions, the misappropriation of others' property and the desecration of temple sancta. Though many explanations for the rules of the 'asham have been offered, this talk argues that the category of property--boundary violation through appropriation--has been undervalued as a motivation for a special sacrifice, distinct from the more general 'sin' offering. The talk concludes by considering some of the implications of understanding private property within the cultural narrative of holiness, such that along with Yhwh's sancta it presents a sacred boundary that must not be violated.


Parenetic Apocalypticism as Exhortation against Apostasy in 1 John
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
John F. Hall, Brigham Young University

The First Epistle of John offers different meaning to its different audiences, different ways for different groups to live through the dire times ahead endeavoring to maintain koinonia of different kinds with the Father, through the Son. The LDS hermeneutic of continuing revelation and an ongoing apocalypticism is most significant for an LDS approach to elucidating the text of 1 John.


Matthew 13:35
Program Unit: New Testament Mysticism Project
Robert G. Hall, Hampden-Sydney College

A commentary on Matthew 13:35 will be presented.


Why Was the Second Temple Built?
Program Unit: Social-Scientific Studies of the Second Temple Period
John M. Halligan, St. John Fisher College

*


Exile as Metaphor in Second Isaiah: Isaiah 40:1–2 and 48:20–22
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Martien A. Halvorson-Taylor, University of Virginia

Even before historical criticism had proposed a setting for Isaiah 40-55, ancient interpreters understood Isa 40:1-2 and its inclusio, 48:20-22, to refer to exile metaphorically. While the language Second Isaiah uses to describe exile does have contact with the language of debt slavery, to read the verses exclusively as an economic reference fails to reckon adequately with the fuller import of the language as metaphor and the additional allusions to the end of exile as, for example, the satisfaction of a punishment or the resolution of the curse of exile. Indeed, in Isa 40:1-2, the language of debt slavery is significant precisely because it multivalent - it is neither a systematic nor an exclusively literal evocation of the situation of economic depravity - but is, rather, built on terms that simultaneously evoke other metaphorical descriptions of exile. The import of these simultaneous evocations is found in Isaiah 48:20-22, where the economic imagery nascent in Isa 40:2 is developed and attached to the larger pattern of debt slave release, one of the capacities of the go'el. The notion of Yhwh as a go'el who is capable of redeeming - and obligated to redeem - on a variety of levels may even be generative for Second Isaiah in that it, in turn, suggests a variety of metaphorical descriptions of exile. Indeed, the notion of the go'el appears to provide a sort of fulcrum for understanding the condition in which Israel finds itself. The release promises redemption on a variety of fronts, all of which can be delivered by the go'el. Exile, therefore, is rendered through a variety of metaphors each of which suggests a need for redemption; and, in the process, exile itself becomes a metaphor for the need for redemption.


Redactions of Exile in Poem One of Jeremiah’s Book of Consolation
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Martien A. Halvorson-Taylor, University of Virginia

The first poem of Jeremiah’s Book of Consolation, Jer 30:5-11, sets the tone for the Book of Consolation as a whole both by describing imminent destruction and exile and by holding out the promise of future restoration. Jer 30:5-11 also provides a window on the complex growth of the Book of Consolation, which includes older and newer strata. This paper traces how the concept of exile changes over the course of the poem’s redaction and the implications this has for understanding the description of exile in the Book of Consolation as a whole. Poem One opens with a fearful cry and an anguished description of the nation's distress, Jer 30:5-7. This oldest stratum asserts that the exile is final and may even have cast doubt on the notion that the people would be rescued. The poem looks beyond certain doom to the promise of divine rescue in its second half, Jer 30:8-11, variously attested in MT and LXX, so that what began in panic ends with consolation. The shift from understanding exile as a decisive end to understanding exile as a prelude to tantalizing possibility came as older strands of the tradition were redeployed to new audiences; the composition reflects a complex understanding of exile that engages and even reformulates earlier conceptions. The resulting hope of renewal, however, comes at a price: The more vivid the images of restoration, the more elusive their realization.


Divine Love on Brokeback Mountain
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Esther J. Hamori, Union Theological Seminary

This story of mountaintop revelation depicts a young cowboy, Jack Twist, and his deeply conflicted lover, Ennis DelMar. Struggles over what it means to be a man— cowboys, lovers, fighters, husbands, fathers—permeate the film. In the midst of these conflicts over varieties of masculinity, Jack is clothed in Jesus imagery. Neither set of issues or images is unique to this film; it is their intersection here that is intriguing. Early in the film, there are repeated shots of Jack carrying a lamb over his shoulders, in a familiar pose, up to Brokeback Mountain. Jack appears weak in his love, yet continually chooses to remain vulnerable, and over time it becomes clear that he is stronger than Ennis and the other men around him, such as his father-in-law. For example, Jack’s moment of greatest vulnerability, a passionate admission to Ennis after two decades (again on the mountaintop), is also his moment of greatest strength in standing up against Ennis’ conflictedness. In the end, Jack is violently murdered by some men who hate what he represents. Divergent images of masculinity are also woven throughout the film. In one telling scene, Jack’s patronizing father-in-law assumes the right to carve Jack’s Thanksgiving turkey. Jack finally claims his right to carve his own family’s turkey; at this moment, we cut to Ennis’ ex-wife’s mild-mannered husband using an electric carver. In the movie’s primary struggle, it is Ennis’ traditional strong masculinity that is portrayed as weak, always conflicted and withholding, and Jack’s homosexuality, secure and vulnerable, that is strong. After examining these intertwined issues in the film, this paper explores the theological possibilities available in broadening the varieties of masculinity attributable to God, especially in light of the breadth of divine characteristics portrayed in the Bible.


The Embodied God in Biblical and Near Eastern Literature
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Esther J. Hamori, Union Theological Seminary

This paper is an observation and analysis of a previously unrecognized category of theophany in the Hebrew Bible, and the significant differences between this type of theophany and related concepts evident in other ancient Near Eastern literature. In the remarkable texts of Genesis 18:1-15 and 32:23-33, God appears to a patriarch in concrete, embodied human form and is defined by the narrator as a “man,” both times with the Hebrew word ’ish. These two texts have each been the object of a wide variety of interpretations, and they have never been studied together with regard to this issue. I argue that these two texts in which God appears concretely as a man reflect the same Israelite religious phenomenon, namely the human theophany, or more precisely, the ’ish theophany. In these passages, the theophany is characterized not only by God’s appearance in human form, but by the utterly realistic nature of this form. Yahweh is portrayed in graphic human terms, and cannot be distinguished from a human male through any visual clues. In Ugaritic, Mesopotamian, and other Near Eastern texts, however, gods who appear to humans in anthropomorphic form do so unrealistically, with visual clues such as superhuman size and strength. The concept of the realistic human theophany cannot be categorized according to any known type of divine-human communication among Israel’s neighbors. This also touches on the wider problem of the nature of the relationship between early Israelite and Canaanite religion. While there is surely a strong family resemblance in very many areas, the phenomenon of the ’ish theophany, as seen in these Genesis texts, reflects a feature of religious thought not attested for Canaanite religion. The current understanding that early Israelite religious thought was essentially like Canaanite must therefore be nuanced.


Angels and Demons in the Book of Jubilees and Contemporary Apocalypses
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Todd Russell Hanneken, University of Notre Dame

The use of the apocalypse genre in the Book of Jubilees causes a reader to expect ideological content typical of contemporary apocalyptic literature, but in fact Jubilees treats the central issues of apocalyptic thought in atypical ways. This paper looks closely at one characteristic of apocalyptic thought, the significance of angels and demons in sin, suffering, and anticipated restoration. Jubilees fits with other apocalypses in that angels mediate revelation, both licit and illicit. Jubilees resembles the Book of the Watchers on the role of fallen angels in the antediluvian origin of sin. When one examines what Jubilees does with the demons after the flood, however, significant differences become apparent. The author of Jubilees introduces the demons only to diminish their number and significance. Although they remain as an explanation and type for idolatry, their significance for the faithful approaches zero. Similarly when one turns to restoration in Jubilees 23, one finds no battle between angels and demons or any angelic agency whatsoever. In the end, the differences might be characterized as a development within a linear model of apocalyptic thought, a major reform, a degree of opposition, or something else entirely. We do not know how the author of the Book of Jubilees thought of the difference between his view of demonic agency and the views of others. We do not know if he identified himself more with, or more against, or in any relationship to the authors of contemporary works. We can conclude, however, that Jubilees’ view of angelic agency does not neatly fit the modern description, “apocalyptic.” We should be prepared to reconsider the categorization and position of Jubilees in the history of Jewish thought.


Similarities Between the Ancient Egyptian Opening of the Mouth Ritual and the Book of Mormon
Program Unit: Poster Session
Eric Hansen, Fairless Hills, PA

There are intriguing similarities between the ancient Egyptian opening of the mouth ritual (EOM) and the Book of Mormon. Specifically, the EOM contains about 50 specific parallels to a 34-chapter section of the Book of Mormon (Mosiah chapter 25 through Alma chapter 29), a section that amounts to about one-sixth of the entire book. About half of similarities occur as strictly sequential parallels, among them the following: (a) a main priest's quick fall into a painful sleep; a blessing upon mouth, eyes, and limbs; the priest's vision of God; the priest awakening to bear testimony of what he has experienced, including having been snatched from the wrappings which had held him captive; (b) a process of rebirth which is similar to the fashioning of wood, especially engraving an image of the face of God; (c) seven smitings, followed by a main priest appearing as a great feline; (d) a first cycle of mouth-opening involving a slaughter scene and the severing of an arm; the arm and other "marvels" being presented to the king to open his mouth; calling upon God; a woman mourning; a visitation by the "beloved son" followed by a scene of surpassing joy; (e) a second, abbreviated, cycle of mouth-opening involving a wounded arm; (f) weapons of peace to combat wickedness of heart; (g) offering of multiple glorifications; (h) sacrifices of one thousands; and (i) an escort to safety by four sons of a king. Possible explanations for similarities are considered, including some that hypothesize a third text that influenced both the EOM and the Book of Mormon.


Door and Passageway: Calvin's Use of Romans as Hermeneutical and Theological Guide
Program Unit: Romans through History and Cultures
Gary Neal Hansen, University of Dubuque Theological Seminary

John Calvin asserts twice in the prefatory material to his commentary that the Epistle to the Romans was the door through which one should go to find the meaning of Scripture as a whole. He is not unique among the reformers of the sixteenth century in holding this view: This letter's attention to the doctrines of justification and faith meant that it was Scripture's most systematic treatment of what they viewed as the most central issues in humanity's relationship with God. This paper will examine how the conviction worked its way out in Calvin's biblical interpretation and theology. This will include what he learned from Paul's use of Old Testament texts, Calvin's use of Romans as a guide to interpretation of particular Old Testament texts, and the way Romans shaped the development of his Institutes of the Christian Religion. Calvin's use of Romans illustrates both the consistency and the flexibility of his approach to biblical interpretation.


Paul as Dramatic Character
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
James S. Hanson, Saint Olaf College

This paper will present insights into Paul's life, thought, and letters gained from my attempt to render Paul as dramatic character in a performed monologue. Analyzing the letters from the perspective of dramaturgy brings one into conversation with traditional questions about Paul's life and thought (issues of chronology, the concrete occasions for the undisputed letters, the question of the "center" of Paul's thought, etc.); but it also compels one to account for the diversity in thought and tone by constructing a character whose motivations and traits can be comprehended by an audience as a (relatively) unified personality. The quest for the center of Paul shifts from the attempt to ground his life and thought in a central idea from which all others emanate to the question of what constitutes his fundamental goal as a human character, and the means he chooses to strive for that goal. Moreover, in terms of individual passages from the letters, such an endeavor brings to the fore the essentially oral character of Paul's expression.


The Song of Songs and the Construction of Desire in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Kathryn Harding, University of Sheffield

Though tales of sexual desire are relatively few and far between in the Hebrew Bible, it is widely accepted, particularly among feminist scholars, that such tales are constructed to reflect and maintain the patriarchal values and hierarchical social structures of the biblical world. Thus they depict imbalanced and problematic relationships where women are subordinated and objectified (as in the so-called pornoprophetic marriage metaphor), or they warn men of the dangers of yielding to desire for a woman at the expense of loyalty to a man (as in the David and Bathsheba narrative), or they tell tales of devious and dangerous women who, by means of their sexual allure, will lead men to their destruction, and therefore must be resisted (for example, the stories of Samson and Delilah and Joseph and the wife of Potiphar, and the construction of desire in the book of Proverbs). The exception, according to many scholars, is the Song of Songs, in which desire is apparently mutual, egalitarian, and unfettered by patriarchal concerns. In this paper, I suggest that all of the various different constructions of desire in the Hebrew Bible might usefully be seen as different ways of responding to a clash of two competing sets of power dynamics: the hierarchical male-female dynamics necessitated by patriarchy, and the more complex, disruptive, oscillating and fluid exchange of power initiated by desire. This difficult and contradictory matrix of power underpins all of the different constructions of desire in the Hebrew Bible, providing a framework which links them fundamentally. I will explore the implications of this suggestion for understanding the construction of desire in the Song of Songs.


Cannibalistic Language in the Fourth Gospel: Ideology of Internal War
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
J. Albert Harrill, Indiana University

Previous scholarship on John 6:51–71 has focused exclusively on whether the language is “Eucharistic. I propose a new literary context in which to understand this imagery: the ancient narratives of internal (civil) war. In Greek and Roman culture, cannibalism was a traditional way of talking about threats to society. Internal threats and dissention among fellow citizens were believed to overturn the value system within which people think and to destroy the old linguistic and semantic world. We find the classic expression in Thucydides’ narrative of the revolt (stasis) at Corcyra during the Peloponnesian War. Rebels and conspirators distort and misuse words, and the disturbance of discourse leads to cannibalism being revalued, a complete inversion of civilization and savagery. Cannibalistic metaphors, allusions, and scenes were, thus, a favorite horror of ancient writers on the topic (Tacitus, Sallust, Dio Cassius, Lucan) because its sickening imagery of self-evisceration and the mauling of corpses best manifested for ancients the grotesque indistinguishableness of humans and beasts. My hypothesis is that the author of John turned the slander of cannibalism, with which synagogue leaders may have originally branded the rebel Jesus-confessing sectarians, into a tool for self-definition. I intend to explore both the author’s indebtedness to classic literary models as well as his deviation from them. The cannibalistic language does not belong to misunderstandings of the Christian Eucharist as such, but is a rhetorical category located in the specific discourse of internal war.


Purity Law in Ezra-Nehemiah
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Hannah K. Harrington, Patten University

The reinterpretation of biblical law in Ezra-Nehemiah, as the result of cultural constraints, is striking in the area of holiness and purity. There appears to be a maximal view of the two concepts in both Ezra and Nehemiah that includes not only the Temple and its priests but the laity as well (Eskenazi). As with other cultures perceiving an outside threat, purity law becomes exclusionary and penalizing (Douglas). The application of traditional impurity language and ritual to maintain ethnic purity appears for the first time in Jewish history and can be traced throughout the individual sources of both books (Olyan). Unlike earlier biblical purity laws, ritual impurity is applied in Ezra-Nehemiah to demarcate the unwanted person of foreign or mixed descent (contra Hayes, Klawans). These claims rest on an examination of holiness and purity terminology (e.g. the roots qdsh, thr, tm', m'l, and bdl) throughout Ezra-Nehemiah in light of their Pentateuchal antecedents.


Purity Rhetoric in Ezra-Nehemiah
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Hannah K. Harrington, Patten University

Building upon recent work in holiness and purity in Ezra-Nehemiah, this paper argues for a unity of authorship in these books. There appears to be a maximal view of the two concepts in both Ezra and Nehemiah that includes not only the Temple and its priests but the laity as well (Eskenazi). Furthermore, the use of holiness and purity terminology (e.g. the roots qdsh, thr, tm', m'l, and bdl) throughout E-N sheds light on the unique way in which impurity is used throughout (Hayes, Carter, Schoper, Smith), more exclusionary and penalizing than other biblical texts (Douglas). The application of traditional impurity language and ritual to maintain ethnic purity appears for the first time in Jewish history and can be traced throughout the individual sources of both books (Olyan). While I argue with details of the particular claims of these scholars, their analyses reveal a new approach to holiness and purity deeply rooted in and shared by Ezra and Nehemiah and cleverly employed by what seems to be a single author to the same end.


Halab, Ta'yinat and the 'Land of Padasatini': Shifting Centers of Power in a Dark Age
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Timothy Harrison, University of Toronto

Formed during the turbulent ‘Dark Age’ that followed the collapse of the Hittite Empire at the end of the Late Bronze Age, the small territorial states that crowded the political landscape of southern Anatolia and western Syria during the early centuries of the first millennium BCE have begun to receive intensified archaeological attention in recent years. While scholars have long assumed that these ‘Neo-Hittite’ states were linked culturally and linguistically to their Bronze Age Anatolian forbearers, thus far, only the ‘Great Kings’ of Carchemish have produced a dynastic line that actually bridges this political era, while the archaeological record is largely devoid of well-excavated cultural sequences for the period. The recent discovery of the Aleppo 3 Inscription has now presented the possibility of tracing the historical development of a second such state associated with the ‘Land of Padasatini’, as recently proposed by J.D. Hawkins, and raises the prospect of a decisive shift in the center of power in the region, following the collapse of the Late Bronze Age. Drawing on the results of recent excavations at Tell Ta‘yinat, the site of ancient Kunulua and capital of the later Iron Age Kingdom of Patina/Unqi, this paper will review the archaeological evidence for the foundation of a Neo-Hittite kingdom centered in the Amuq Plain that appears to have eclipsed ancient Halab and the powerful Bronze Age Kingdom of Yamhad during the Early Iron Age (ca. 1200-900 BCE).


Challenges to Teaching Biblical Literature as a General Education Requirement
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Stan Harstine, Friends University

What factors are involved in teaching at a self-defined "independent, Christian university" when the course is part of the general education curriculum? What do students bring to the class in terms of preconceptions and expectations of a general education course? How does the audience alter the approach to the topic? This presentation will reflect on the results of a survey conducted at Friends University in 2006 to assess student attitudes and expectations regarding the biblical literature courses taught within the general education curriculum.


Peter in the Gospel of John: A New Approach to an Ambiguous Figure
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Judith Hartenstein, Philipps Universität, Marburg

The characterization of Peter in the Gospel of John is notoriously difficult to grasp and the results in exegetical literature differ widely. In my paper, I view the portrayal of Peter as a dialogue between the gospel and its readers. The Gospel of John takes as assumed that Peter is known. The Johannine picture of Peter builds on this knowledge, but at several junctures offers new perspectives, even challenging the position of the reader. Depending on the starting point, readings may differ and formerly held opinions are subjected to modification. Readers who are critical of Peter are forced to consider positive traits of character, whilst those who view Peter in a positive light come up against criticism. The ambiguity of Peter in the Gospel of John cannot be reduced to simply positive or negative terms. Nevertheless, there are some general tendencies: the Gospel of John sees Peter as an important figure, but derives his authority from his death as martyr, not from his faith or from an appearance of the risen Lord, as other tradition does. On the other hand, Peter is seen as distinguished, but not as the sole authority in the Gospel of John. He is portrayed as a member of the group of disciples, depending on others and shouldering responsibility with others.


Mary Magdalene the Apostle: A Re-interpretation of Literary Traditions?
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Judith Hartenstein, Philipps Universität, Marburg

There are several gospels that portray Mary Magdalene as an apostle. The most important of them are the Gospel of John and the Gospel of Mary. She enjoys personal authority as a person commissioned by the Lord. Other writings, such as the Gospel of Luke, do not see her in this role. It is possible that in some writings, former tradition about Mary Magdalene the apostle has been disregarded or actively suppressed. In my paper I will argue for a different option: the view of Mary Magdalene as an apostle might be the product of a new interpretation of older tradition at literary level. The existent gospels attest to a tradition of an encounter between Mary Magdalene and the risen Lord. In my opinion, however, John is the first gospel that presents this encounter as an appearance granting apostolic authority. To substantiate my theory of a literary development in the Magdalene tradition, I will discuss the interpretation of the Gospel of John, as well as the evidence from other writings (Gospel of Mary) pointing to an apostle Mary Magdalene. A comparison with other aspects of the Magdalene tradition (Mary Magdalene as a disciple, her involvement with the nature of discipleship) will also be helpful. Finally, the Thomas tradition shows a similar literary development, although there are differences in respect of the figure of Thomas.


The Letter of James and the Heritage of Israel: A Christian-Jewish Document?
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
Patrick J. Hartin, Gonzaga University

This paper will examine the relationship of the Letter of James to the world of Second Temple Israelite thought and culture while at the same time demonstrating connections to the world of the followers of Jesus. Of fundamental importance in the study of the Letter of James is to take seriously the context of the eschatological hope expressed in the letter's address "to the twelve tribes in the Dispersion" (1:1). The letter speaks to a community that still views itself within the orbit of the house of Israel. This Christian-Jewish context for the letter of James is demonstrated further from a detailed examination of the use and meaning of the concept "law" (nomos) that occurs on three occasions (1:25; 2:8-12; 4:11-12). Nowhere does the writer explain clearly what is meant by the term. This paper aims at demonstrating that the writer has in mind the biblical Torah. Stemming from the vision that James had presented of the community as "the twelve tribes in the Dispersion," the writer presents the Torah as the basic guide according to which the community is to act. James sees his call to friendship with God (4:4) as a call to maintain the covenant relationship as the reconstituted people, God's twelve tribe kingdom, through obedience to the biblical Torah. This paper will further illustrate that the Torah serves as the framework for the ethics of the letter and operates in the same way as it does in Matthew's Sermon on the Mount. No references are made to cultic or ritual laws. Rather, it is the Torah as the expression of God's moral will for God's people where the law of love (2:8) lies at its heart.


Sight and Blindness as Characterization: A Look at the Blinding of Saul
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Chad Hartsock, Baylor University

In the ancient world, it was often believed that one could know something of a person’s inner moral character based on the person’s outward physical features. This study is known as physiognomy. Handbooks were written to index various physical attributes and their corresponding character traits. Thus, a common method of characterization was a physical description in which the description implies something about a person’s character. The most important bodily indicator for the physiognomist was undoubtedly the eye. Blindness, then, often carried a literary function beyond the obvious disability of the blind person; blindness was also used as a means of characterization. In most cases, especially in biblical literature, a character that is physically blind is likewise spiritually blind—the physical and spiritual conditions match. Greek literature has a few significant exceptions to this rule, and the paper would include discussion of those exceptions (one might think of the “blind prophets” such as Teiresias). The focus of the paper is twofold. First, the paper will explore examples of blindness in Greco-Roman literature in order to understand how blindness was generally understood in the literature of the world in which the NT grew up. Special attention will be given to the biblical literature and the ways in which blindness both fits and breaks the typical Greco-Roman usage. Second, the paper will explore the most notable example of blindness in the NT—the blinding of Saul. Saul, after his encounter with Christ, is curiously described: “though his eyes were open, he could see nothing.” The paper will suggest that in addition to the clear literal meaning, a symbolic and physiognomic reading might also be offered in which Saul’s physical condition has been made to match his prior spiritual condition.


Members Only: The Crushed, Cut, and Tolerated in Deuteronomy 23:1–8
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Jione Havea, Charles Sturt University

This paper focuses on Deut 23:1–8, a text that determines who can join YHWH’s assembly according to the state of his testicles, penis, parentage, and racial background, and reads it alongside cultural narratives involving eunuchs (e.g., the book of Esther, following Randall Bailey’s reading), bastards (a term, according to Driver, referring to both offspring born out of wedlock and offspring of an incestuous [or prohibited] union as in the stories of the Ammonites and Moabites), and outcasts who may be tolerated (e.g., the stories of people in the so-called mission field who are now being embraced). The energies of the paper will erupt in that last category and stories from the Pacific Islands will be drawn upon. From a postcolonial perspective, the contention is that, in the Pacific Island context, people who were once rejected are now embraced, as the Edomites and Egyptians are tolerated in Deut 23:7–18, but they are troubled by what may be waiting beyond the initial moments of their being tolerated. This paper, in a way, will lead to a sign that reads “Members only” where it hesitates, wondering if it is worth entering. Of course, read through Deut 23:1–8, “Members only” can mean many things…and no-things!


Reconfiguring Conquest: Recasting War in the Redaction of Joshua
Program Unit: Warfare in Ancient Israel
L. Daniel Hawk, Ashland Theological Seminary

The book of Joshua reflects a redactional program intent on ameliorating the militarism of Israel’s conquest traditions. This program can be detected by attention to three aspects of Joshua 2-12. First (following L. Stone), transitional comments recast military campaigns as defensive operations. Second, the narrative as a whole gradually redefines Israel’s “enemies” as the kings of the land rather than the peoples of the land. Third, anecdotes focused on identity issues have been attached to each of the first three, paradigmatic, battle accounts (at Jericho, Ai, and Gibeon). The anecdotes display structural and thematic parallels and, taken together, blur the distinctions between Israelites and Canaanites. The program overall constitutes an attempt to separate the conquest traditions from the ethnic antagonisms inherent within them and represents a recontextualization of these traditions in light of Israel’s experience in the land.


Land of the Pilgrim’s Pride: Joshua, Destiny, and Dispossession
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
L. Daniel Hawk, Ashland Theological Seminary

The book of Joshua employs themes of election and destinarianism to construct a sense of national identity and to legitimate Israel’s possession of Canaan. Joshua affirms that Yhwh brought the chosen people into the land in fulfillment of divine promises and gave Israel the land which Yhwh had won by right of conquest. Israel, for its part, was to drive out the indigenous inhabitants in order to create an arena for the fulfillment of national destiny. Corresponding themes configured the development of a national mythology in the United States. Here as well beliefs in election and national destiny framed victories over indigenous peoples as affirmations of God’s gift of the land and legitimated programs of dispossession and ethnic cleansing. Anxieties over religious and ethnic purity informed these programs and found their counterparts in Joshua as well. In brief, Joshua both implicitly and explicitly provided the biblical paradigm by which American identity could be constructed against the indigenous other.


Jeremiah’s Boiling Pot: A Cognitive Linguistics Approach to Communication and Conceptualization in Masoretic Text Jeremiah 1:1–6:30
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Elizabeth R. Hayes, Wolfson College, Oxford University

By using a cognitive linguistics approach, it is possible to demonstrate that frames, cognitive models and image schemas structure the early chapters of Jeremiah and provide a sense of unity for the text. The image of the boiling pot in Jeremiah 1.13 is the focus of this paper. While the image of the boiling pot is neither a full-form vision nor a literary metaphor, the sentence "I see a boiling pot, tilted away from the north," is both evocative and slightly menacing due to its underlying image schematic structure. The cognitive linguistics approach utilised in this paper employs a version of Langacker’s viewing arrangement diagram to re-conceptualize the relationship between author, text and reader. The re-conceptualization demonstrates that a combination of grammar, context, culture and embodied experience establishes connections between the originator and reader of text. The conceptualization of experience gives rise to cognitive models and image schemas. This paper will define and describe image schematic structure. It will examine several BH terms and constructions used to represent image schemas in Jeremiah 1.1-6.30, with particular emphasis upon the containment, force and path schemas that contribute to the boiling pot image and its explanation in Jeremiah 1.13-1.19. Finally, the paper will demonstrate that frames, cognitive models and image schemas occur across genres, which makes a cognitive linguistics approach useful for the analysis and description of BH prophetic text.


Can Narrative Criticism Recover the Unity of Scripture?
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Richard B. Hays, Duke University

It is sometimes supposed that the problem of the Bible's unity was created by the disjunctive reading strategies of modern historical criticism, and that a theological approach will yield a more unified account of the Bible's message. In fact, however, primary attention to theological concerns hardly suffices to guarantee a unified reading of Scripture's diverse texts. This paper will explore this issue and ask in a preliminary way whether a narrative hermeneutical approach can achieve satisfying solutions to the problem of the theological unity of the Bible.


"Obeying the Commandments of God"? How Do the New Testament's Readings of the Story of Israel Shape Christian Ethics?
Program Unit: Character Ethics and Biblical Interpretation
Richard B. Hays, Duke University

If it is true that the NT writings carry forward the story of Israel in hermeneutically diverse ways, what implications follow for Christian ethics? Most studies of NT ethics, including my own previous work, have paid insufficient attention to this question. This paper will seek to reflect upon some of the major ethical trajectories suggested by the NT authors' readings of Israel's Scripture.


Human Rights in the Bible? Some Critical Questions.
Program Unit:
Richard B. Hays, Duke University

*


Named Letter Carriers in the Documentary Papyri
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Peter M. Head, Tyndale House

This paper (part of a broader project to probe the role of named letter carriers in Paul's epistolary communication strategy) discusses the roles assigned to named letter carriers in around 40 personal letters among the Greek papyri contemporary with the NT.


Hort and Tregelles: A Study in Their Relationship
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Peter M Head, Tyndale House

This paper traces the relationship between F.J.A. Hort and S.P. Tregelles and its impact on the production of Westcott and Hort's New Testament. Manuscript sources in London, Cambridge, Manchester and St Andrews, including a reference letter that Hort wrote for Tregelles, letters between the two, comments in other letters, shared corrections to proofs, and correspondence between Hort and Mrs Tregelles after Tregelles' death, add depth and breadth to our understanding of their relationship.


The Business Activities of Neo-Babylonian Slaves
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Ronan J. Head, Johns Hopkins University

Abraham's slave, Eliezer, attests to the important station to which some ancient Near Eastern slaves arose. In Mesopotamia, certain slaves also enjoyed a degree of autonomy. This paper will consider the semi-independent slaves of the Neo-Babylonian period, particularly those owned by the Egibi family. We will discuss their business activities, both as agents of their masters and as holders of their own property--the peculium. This will allow us to consider important questions of property, rights, and freedom as they pertain to ancient Babylonian slavery.


What Does the Mob Want Lot to Do in Genesis 19:9?
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
R. Christopher Heard, Pepperdine University

Genesis 19:9 presents a curious, though rarely-discussed, philological and interpretive conundrum. The Sodomite mob is quoted as telling Lot "???????." Most English translations render this instruction as "Stand back," but a few interpreters have suggested quite the opposite sense "Come here." Clues from the immediate literary context and wider philological considerations are marshaled in this paper to try to resolve this semantic ambiguity. [Please note that this abstract contains Hebrew characters entered in Unicode. Just in case they don't transmit properly, the intended phrase is GESH-HALE'AH in Genesis 19:9.]


God in a Bind: The Dilemma of Divine Decrees in Dogma, the Bible, and Modern Theology
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
R. Christopher Heard, Pepperdine University

For all its irreverence, the movie Dogma raises some interesting theological questions that resonate with certain biblical texts and trends in modern theology. The presumed immutability and non-contradiction of divine decrees drive Dogma's plot, but these themes are complicated when referred to Amalek's annihilation and Saul's election and rejection. This paper will examine potential biblical and theological resources for addressing the problem that lies at the heart of the film.


Exile, Memory, and the Gospel of Matthew
Program Unit: Mapping Memory: Tradition, Texts, and Identity
Holly Hearon, Christian Theological Seminary

The construction of a common identity is dependent upon the cultivation of shared memories. Never neutral, the cultivation of shared memories is a constructive task, dependent both upon what is remembered and how it is remembered: where the narrative thread begins and where it ends, which events in between are ‘remembered’ or ‘not remembered,’ the sense of power or powerlessness that is evoked by the sequencing of events. Attentive to these features, this paper will explore how the writer of the Gospel of Matthew shapes the identity of the audience through memories of the exile and the relationship between this identity and the story of Jesus as narrated in the Gospel.


Elijah as the Voice of the Redactors of the Babylonian Talmud
Program Unit: History and Literature of Early Rabbinic Judaism
Karin Hedner–Zetterholm, Lund University

The Bavli and its redactors in particular, often seem to use Elijah to voice their views and concerns, presenting him as expressing support for the rabbis’ right to legislate and interpret the Torah, eliminating conflicts, or criticizing the behavior of some rabbis. A comparison with the Yerushalmi and amoraic midrashic collections shows that the aggadic passages where Elijah appears often lack parallels, suggesting that they are Babylonian inventions. The language further indicates that many of the additions where Elijah appears are reworkings or creations of the redactors. Seen against the background of the challenge to their authority that the rabbis experienced in the Amoraic period, demonstrated by other scholars, this paper explores the possibility of understanding the fact that the redactors use Elijah to voice their concerns, both as a symptom of the reduced authority that the rabbis felt, and as attempts to bolster that very authority through affirmation from God through Elijah. This claim is supported by other ways of attempting to bolster rabbinic authority expressed in halakhic passages where both Talmuds, and the Bavli in particular, are very anxious to exclude Elijah from the process of determining halakhah, asserting their authority over his divine knowledge and reducing his role to a theoretical argument used to clarify different rabbinic positions.


Flawed Heroes and Stories Jesus Told: The One about an Assassin
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Charles W. Hedrick, Missouri State University

The parable of the Assassin is one of two new parables attributed to Jesus in the Gospel of Thomas. It has been little studied by scholars. Studies to date almost unanimously treat it ias a gnostic allegory. Few have considered the possibility that it might be a story originating with Jesus of Nazareth. This paper will briefly survey published studies of the parable, offer a rationale for considering the parble as a story originating in a first-century Palestinian context, and propose an explanation of it from that perspective.


Food Fight: The Significance of Food in Genesis 37–50
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Katie M. Heffelfinger, Emory University

While the Joseph narrative’s garment motif has received some scholarly attention, the literature generally neglects the high concentration and thematic significance of food and meals in this text. This paper argues that the recurrent references to food in Genesis 37-50 constitute a leitmotif which points out the shifts in the sibling rivalry theme throughout the progress of the plot. It argues that presence of food imagery in both Joseph’s and Pharaoh’s dreams, the setting of the climax of the story within the context of famine, the allusion to Potiphar’s neglect of everything except attention to his food, and most importantly the two significant meals which frame the story - that of the brothers after throwing Joseph in the pit, and that at which Joseph hosts his brothers in Egypt - function to alert the reader to the presence of material relevant to the plot’s theme of sibling rivalry and to highlight the various changes in the status of that rivalry throughout the course of the plot.. Generally following George Coats’ analysis of the Joseph Cycle’s plot, the paper traces the occurrence and function of the food leitmotif through the plot’s various stages highlighting its shifts in significance which closely accompany the shifts in the brothers’ relationships. The paper highlights the ways in which the primary turning points in the plot occur in the context of meals and the ways in which the food imagery develops from highlighting dissension in the story’s early stages to illustrating familial reconciliation and blessing in the plot’s conclusion.


Paideia and Conversion in Lucian's "Hermotimos" and in Luke-Acts
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Christoph Heil, Universitaet Graz

Both Lucian and Luke relate failed attempts to convert Stoics. Although there are many differences between "Hermotimos" and Acts 17:16-34, there are some analogies also. (1) Both stories lack a scholarly form. They are written to enlighten and entertain a broader audience. (2) Both texts allude to the Socrates of Plato's dialogues and refer to other authoritative Greek traditions. (3) Both "Hermotimos" and Luke-Acts convey a very high regard for ethics and practical wisdom. (4) Both exchanges fail more or less. In Lucian's dialogue Hermotimos is not able to defend his dogmatic Stoicism against Lycinos' questions and arguments, but it is not justified to speak of a "conversion" of Hermotimos to Skepticism (pace H.-G. Nesselrath). Hermotimos just shows an "aversion" to the philosophical schools (according to C. Schäublin and P. v.Möllendorff). Neither Lycinos is able to convert Hermotimos to Skepticism nor can Paul convince the Athenian Stoics to become Christians. However, both protreptic stories do not end wholly negatively, but remain somehow "open". Although at the end Hermotimos has not really converted to a social life of common sense (koinòs bíos), he at least feels "saved out of the fog" by having turned away from Stoicism. In a similar way, some Athenian philosophers say to Paul, "We will hear you again about this", and a few indeed join Paul and become believers. Like Plato and Cicero in their dialogues, both Lucian and Luke try to motivate their readers to move on beyond the texts and to continue "paideia" and conversion in their own lives. This "open end" technique contrasts with the later Christian dialogues, for example "Octavius" by Minucius Felix (3rd cent.). Here a Skeptic philosopher finds the truth in Christianity and converts. In conclusion, Lucian's "Hermotimos" and Luke's two volumes share some features which shed new light on Luke-Acts.


New Implementations of Digital Resources for the Study of the Language and Literature of Ugarit
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
Michael S. Heiser, Logos Research Systems

Scholars who work primarily in the Hebrew Bible, the Greek New Testament, and other classical material have long had the capability of studying the grammar, morphology, and literature of their text corpus via commercial software programs. Efforts to move the study of Ugaritic into the electronic world to date have focused on digital reproduction of tablets and information storage and retrieval. The prodigious achievement of Laboratorio de Hermeneumatica (Instituto de Filologia) of Madrid, accomplished under the leadership of J. L. Cunchillos, J. A. Zamora and J. P. Vita, paved the way for new implementations of their data in a sophisticated, user-friendly software package. This presentation offers attendees the first look at the result of a recent licensing agreement between the Laboratorio and Logos Bible Software. The new software package not only allows searching of the Ugaritic corpus, but the results of those searches are fully integrated with digitized print works relevant to the study of Ugaritic.


Trust and the Spirit: Anticipating Scripture’s Unity
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Christine Helmer, Harvard Divinity School

The question of scripture’s unity is one usually left to theologians to solve, and theologians commonly appeal to prescriptive doctrinal concepts to argue for a unity not justifiable on historical grounds. It is my intention in this paper to outline a model for theological judgment-making that anticipates scripture’s unity while pluralizing subjective accounts of this unity. The argument involves both a psychological and a pneumatological aspect. The disposition of trust highlights the anticipatory dimension at the emotional level while the appeal to the Holy Spirit offers a theological determination of love as the hidden unity of scriptural multivalence.


Proverbs 1–9 and the Qumran Community Rule
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Charlotte Hempel, University of Birmingham, UK

This paper will examine a number of similarities in style, terminology and ideology between the prologue to the Book of Proverbs and the Qumran Community Rule. On a formal level, Michael Fox has drawn attention to the shared use of chains of infinitives of purpose in the Prologue of Proverbs and the Community Rule. The proposed paper will try to show that the relationship between both works is - perhaps surprisingly - close in a number of other areas too, such as the emphasis on ethical conduct which is esteemed more highly than sacrifices, the importance of council (esah), the stark choices available to those addressed and the threats that lurk and may side-track them along the wrong path. A noteworthy difference is the prominence of positive and negative portrayals of women in Proverbs over against 1QS. The most likely explanation for the shared features is to argue that the Qumran community has adapted and replaced the structures of learning and education previously practised in the home and school, but took over some of the language and framework. It is often argued that Proverbs 1-9 is addressed, at least partly, to young men on the brink of independence. Similarly, a case has been made that the Community Rule has a didactic purpose in helping new and old members making sense of their new identity as part of the community. More concretely we may have to allow for the possibility that the authors of the Rule themselves were part of the same educated and scholarly milieu as the one that produced Proverbs, and esp. Proverbs 1-9.


Discipleship after the Resurrection: Scribal Hermeneutics in the Longer Ending of Mark
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Suzanne Watts Henderson, Salem College

Readers of the first gospel have long viewed the resurrection as the dividing line between partial and full disclosure of Jesus’ messiahship in Mark. Especially under Wrede’s influence, they have inferred that the culpability of the disciples thus stems from their pre-resurrection vantage point. But is this the way in which Mark’s earliest readers would have viewed the disciples? My study examines the Longer Ending of Mark as an early scribal reflection on the gospel itself, and especially the gospel’s depiction of the disciples. This authoritative addendum moves the resurrection story beyond fearful, silent women, toward a complex portrait of Jesus’ followers that is entirely consistent with the original gospel depiction. Like the gospel itself, these verses combine the disciples’ unbelief with the story of their successful redeployment on Jesus’ behalf. In my paper, I intend to treat text-critical matters (including the anomalous Freer Logion) so as to highlight the interpretive fluidity of the text and to shed light on the historical circumstances promoting such revisions. Next I hope to explore the Longer Ending in light of the gospel itself, forging thematic ties that the scribes apparently aimed to develop. Finally, I shall suggest that the scribes’ own hermeneutical treatment of the gospel may offer a more profitable – and historically less strained – reading of Mark’s befuddling depiction of Jesus’ disciples than contemporary scholarship has generally presented.


A Study in Contrasts: The Message of the Story of the Two Prostitutes
Program Unit: Biblical Criticism and Literary Criticism
John W. Herbst, Union Theological Seminary, PSCE

The account of the two prostitutes in I Kings 3:16-28 has long been held to be an interpolation demonstrating King Solomon’s exceptional wisdom. But this understanding has difficulties. The first woman’s story seems implausible in many respects, yet the king does not question her, and the judgment itself does not consider at all the testimony presented. The second half of the story could itself display the king’s wisdom; most of the first half is unnecessary for this purpose. The entire account furthermore does not mention Solomon by name; the king is associated with Solomon purely through the story’s placement within the larger narrative. A close reading of the passage suggests that the focus lies with the women, rather than with their judge. Each of the two near-equal halves (verses 16 through 22, and 23 through 28) has a tight chiastic structure. The first half focuses on the contrast between the “false” mother, who kills her own child, then rises at night to deceive. The second half is centered on the feelings of the “true” mother, who surrenders claim to her son, in order to save his life. While Claudia Camp identifies Solomon as the king, it seems more helpful to relate Solomon to the child who can easily end up with either woman as mother. The women’s uneasy relationship is set up by the four-fold repetition of bayit (house) in verses 17 and 18, paralleling the situation introduced at the start of I Kings 3 as Solomon brings his first foreign bride to Jerusalem. The story of the prostitutes before Solomon then serves as part of the foundation for the larger Solomon narrative, in which the presence of non-Israelite wives creates danger for the king.


The Apocalypse in Codex Alexandrinus: Its Singular Readings and Scribal Habits
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Juan Hernández, Jr., Emory University

The last systematic analysis of the Apocalypse's singular readings in Codex Alexandrinus is now well over a century old. Although numerous subsequent studies of the Apocalypse have advanced our understanding of the MS tradition considerably, as well as afforded us additional MS material, a full-scale re-appraisal of this MS’s singulars has yet to be undertaken. This paper will attempt to fill this lacuna by offering a brief sketch of the text-critical research of this fifth century Codex, as well providing a fresh discussion of this MS’s singular readings in the Apocalypse. Moreover, comparisons will be made with the singular readings of Codex Sinaiticus in an effort to cast into bold relief the distinctive copying habits and theological concerns exhibited in each MS.


Digital Nestle-Aland: The Catholic Letters
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Luc Herren, University of Munster

The Münster Institute for New Testament Textual Research, Peter Robinson's Scholarly Digital Editions, Leicester, UK, and the German Bible Society, Stuttgart, cooperate in preparing the 28th edition of the Novum Testamentum Graece, known as Nestle-Aland, in digital form (funded in part by the German Research Foundation, Bonn.) The Catholic or General Letters part of the Digital Nestle-Aland will be presented in this session. The digital edition offers two main features not available in the printed book: transcripts of important Greek New Testament manuscripts (Nestle-Aland's 'consistently cited witnesses'), and a complete apparatus based on these transcripts. The comparison of any two or more manuscripts in any given verse has been made effortless. At every point, a careful distinction has been made between real variant readings and mere spelling differences so that the transcripts' apparatus is very easy to read (an original spelling collation is available as well.) At the same time, the digital edition is easier to use than the printed book, particularly for people new to the edition. There is no more any need to flip back and forth between the New Testament text and apparatus on the one hand and the book's introduction and appendices on the other, as the relevant information is made available by means of pop-up messages wherever critical signs, witness symbols, and abbreviations occur. Newly added features include an Expert Search function, a panel displaying dictionary entries for the Nestle text as well as the transcripts, and direct links from any given passage in a transcript to an image of the corresponding manuscript page whenever such images are freely accessible on the Internet.


Constructing Pseudonymity: The Pastoral Epistles between Claim and Criticism
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Jens Herzer, University of Leipzig

Critical scholarship on the Pastoral Epistles is one of the most interesting phenomena in New Testament studies. Despite of the consensus in their pseudonymity, the actual theories about the interpretation and the understanding of these three small letters are as opposite as ever. One major reason for this situation is the fact that the research on pseudonymity established by Wolfgang Speyer in the 1970s has not received the appreciation it deserved. The paper sketches recent trends in the research on the Pastoral Epistles and shows that only a new look at the phenomenon of pseudonymity in late antiquity leads to an appropriate understanding of their character. Thus, the paper also proposes a fresh approach to reconsider the relation between authenticity and pseudonymity.


Nazification through Neutrality: The University of Jena Theological Faculty as a Bastion of Aryanized Christianity during the Third Reich
Program Unit: Social History of Formative Christianity and Judaism
Susannah Heschel, Dartmouth College

The theology faculty at the University of Jena sought to become a self-proclaimed "stronghold of National Socialism" and it succeeded. Its professoriate during the Third Reich was dominated by professors who racialized the curriculum and by students who wrote dissertations supporting Nazi principles in theological language. The nazification was enabled not by a take-over by radical factions, but by the position of political neutrality adopted by Jena's most distinguished theologian, Karl Heussi. In the post-war years, as the Nazi professors were forced to resigned, Heussi reconstituted the faculty with ex-Nazis who made scrutiny of the Nazi-era complicity, and the Nazi-era PhD students went on to prominent positions within the post-war church.


The Intertextual Textures of Vernon Robbins
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
J. David Hester (Amador), Centre for Rhetorics & Hermeneutics

This paper will explore the sources and inspiration of Robbins' socio-rhetorical critical model: how they informed, shaped and constrained one of the most carefully developed methodologies of rhetorical criticism of the Bible to arise in the 20th century.


Averting the Apocalypse: The Horrors of Global Warming and the Rhetorical Power of the End
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Jacqueline Hidalgo, Claremont Graduate University

In the Fall of 2005, Al Gore lectured in Los Angeles about global warming as part of the production of the new documentary, An Inconvenient Truth. Gore compared some of the horrible plagues imagined in John's Apocalypse to the horrific repercussions of global warming around the world, repercussions which Gore demonstrated in a complex narrative of photographs, tables, and film clips. Through a focus on Gore's rhetoric of averting the global warming apocalypse, this paper explores the enduring prominence and power of the Apocalypse as it may be encountered throughout the US political imaginary. It is often recognized that Conservative Christians in the U.S.A. have used the horrific imagery of the Apocalypse in combination with the promise of an imminent End in order to shape politics, identities, and cultures. Many occupying different parts of the political Left have likewise turned to narratives of impending environmental doom and/or political totalitarianism. Given that such a variety of groups deploy these counterpoised apocalypticisms, what does this suggest about the social power of apocalyptic narratives over the social realities of different people? Successful deployment of the Apocalypse, and specifically of its horrors and end-time imagination, has been a significant source of social power for those who pursue it, and those who perceive themselves to be in situations of social distress often invoke apocalyptic rhetoric. Gore serves as an interesting example against this backdrop. Although he is part of the political mainstream, his speech comes at a time when many on the political Left feel disenfranchised. Is apocalyptic rhetoric most popular with groups who perceive themselves as disempowered or is it just such a central part of the US cultural imagination that it is hard to conceive of a historical trajectory outside of the Apocalypse?


A Reconsideration of Charles' 'So-called' Noah Interpolations
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Vered Hillel, Hebrew University of Jerusalem

The Book of Noah and Noah traditions have intrigued scholars since R.H. Charles first distinguished “Noah interpolations” in the Similitudes of Enoch in 1893. Using an explicit specific set of criteria, he determined that I Enoch 54:7-55:2; chapter 60; and 65:1-69:25 are such interpolations. While there has been considerable scholarly debate and a growing number of publications on the topic, there has been no systematic study of Charles’ work: scholars either adopt it without question or reject it without demonstrating why his conclusions are invalid. This paper examines Charles’ designated ‘Noah interpolations’ in the Similitudes in light of his own criteria and methodology to see if they are tenable. The study is approached from two perspectives: 1) an in-depth examination of one criterion, #5 the misuse of technical terms; and 2) an examination of one ‘so-called’ interpolation, 54:7-55:2. Charles claims that the author incorporates many terms and phrases from the Similtudes, but misuses technical terms and phrases in the Noah passages. This paper compares the use of the terms and phrases in the Similitudes and in the so-called Noah interpolations. I Enoch 54:7-55:2, one of the designated Noah interpolations, is also examined using all of Charles’ criteria and the results of both analyses are evaluated and presented.


“Some Principles of Biblical Rhythm in Poetry and Other Genres” by Benjamin Harshav (Hrushovski) and “How Ancient Hebrew Poetry Works: A New Proposal” by John Hobbins
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
John F. Hobbins, Trinity United Methodist Church

Abstract for Benjamin Harshav's paper: Rhythm in poetry and other genres always rests upon (or is related to, or deviates from) a "metrical" system of recurring proportions. Without the foundations of such a system no rhythmical effect is possible. This paper will discuss principles of rhythm attested in poetry and other genres of the literature of the Hebrew Bible. Abstract for John Hobbins' paper: This paper will offer a description of ancient Hebrew verse that builds on Harshavian principles. The text model to be presented is an attempt to stipulate the continuously operating principles of organization at work in ancient Hebrew verse. I will show by example how biblical Hebrew poetry instantiates a textual hierarchy and a set of prosodic regularities characterized by freedom within clearly definable limits. A fuller account of the proposal is available online at: www.ancienthebrewpoetry.typepad.com.


In Search of Prosodic Domains in Ancient Hebrew Poetry: An Illustration Based on a Limited Corpus (Lamentations 1–5)
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
John F. Hobbins, Trinity United Methodist Church

Texts instantiate prosodic hierarchies. Against the background of the work of Selkirk and Hayes on prosodic structures, this essay seeks to identify the prosodic domains of ancient Hebrew poetry. Traditions of unit delimitation preserved in the Masoretic text as decoded by Dresher and text models of ancient Hebrew poetry proposed in the past orient the quest but do not determine final results. A limited corpus, the book of Lamentations, serves as a basis of discussion. A full description of the text model I am proposing is available online at: www.ancienthebrewpoetry.typepad.com.


The Opening of the Gospel of Mark and Insights from the Progymnasmata
Program Unit: Future of the Past: Biblical and Cognate Studies for the Twenty-First Century
Ronald F. Hock, University Of California

*


How She Sits Alone: The Poetic Beauty of Grief in Lamentations
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Victoria Hoffer, Yale University

While there is not always agreement as to which Biblical passages are to be called prose and which poetry, the Book of Lamentations has enough textual features to easily grant it poetic status: its alphabetic acrostic form, tight versification, regular progression of open and closed paragraphs, its abundance and variety of parallelistic structures, vivid metaphors, different fugue-like voices and even its special melodic tones or trope give this book an elegance and rhythm that is almost hypnotic. The book's literary and sonant features are artfully entwined to express with poignant intensity the pain of the exilic experience, but at the same time, its very formality controls the outpouring of grief. This paper will discuss the poetic features of Lamentations, how they express a despair that seems to be almost without end, but yet is in tension with the devices that contain it.


The Meanings of 'Torah' in 4 Ezra
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Karina Martin Hogan, Fordham University

Torah, rendered as 'the law' in the extant versions, is a central theme of 4 Ezra. The original author of 4 Ezra had a much broader concept of 'Torah' than simply the Mosaic law; it can refer to all of Scripture, or, in Uriel’s speeches, to a more abstract entity associated with 'the way of the Most High.' Understanding Torah broadly as divine 'instruction,' the author of 4 Ezra raises the possibility of sources of Torah other than Scripture.


4QMMT and Paradigms of Second Temple Jewish Nomism
Program Unit: Qumran
Albert Hogeterp, Catholic University of Louvain, Belgium

The theological perspective of 4QMMT, in particular the hortatory part C, needs to be reconsidered in light of recent discussion about paradigms of Second Temple Jewish religion. The reigning paradigm of E.P. Sanders, covenantal nomism as the pattern of religion in Palestinian Judaism contemporary to Paul, has been criticised from different angles (e.g. D.A. Carson; E. Condra). Furthermore, the variegated landscape of Qumran studies since 1977 and of different notions of covenant need to be taken into account. Paradoxically, the evaluation of 4QMMT in connection with Sanders's ideas about Qumran soteriology has received relatively little scholarly attention, even though this document provides exact Hebrew equivalents to Paul's terms works of the Law and justification. It is the evaluation of MMT's perspective on Torah and righteousness, and the question of MMT's nomism which this paper sets out to undertake. The parameters of Sanders's ideas about soteriology are thereby checked against the evidence of MMT B and C, and of C in particular. Scriptural backgrounds and connections with other Jewish literature are further explored (e.g. Mal 2:7 and Josephus' Jewish War 2.145 in relation to MMT C 24) and previous scholarly notions of MMT's eschatology are taken into consideration. The evaluation further demonstrates that MMT C 26b-32 cannot be used to support the idea that MMT would reflect a 'legalistic' perspective on righteousness and justification. MMT's covenant theology comes closer to that of the Damascus Document than that of the Community Rule. (Since this is my first proposal for an Annual Meeting, but not for an International Meeting, I attach my paper of 10 pages in a separate e-mail directed to the Program Unit Chairs).


"Pethahiah, Advisor to the King": A New Effort to Understand Nehemiah 11
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Kenneth G. Hoglund, Wake Forest University

At the end of a listing of Levitical figures in Nehemiah 11, one finds the odd mention of a Judahite, one "Pethahiah." Moreover, Pethahiah is said to have "advised the king concerning all the affairs of the people." Past studies have sought to understand what role this might be in relation to the Persian court, the presumed mentioned "king." But such approaches failed to explain why the mention appears in this specific portion of the list. Taking the context of the list as a critical component for assessing the mention leads to some insights on the role of the list as well as the reason for Pethahiah's inclusion.


"Home Economics 1407” and the Israelite Family and Their Neighbors: An Anthropological/Archaeological Exploration
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
John S. Holladay, Jr., University of Toronto

All other factors being equal, despite recent ideologically-based arguments to the contrary (e.g., Bunimovitz and Faust's "Building Identity: The Four-Room House and the Israelite Mind" in Dever and Gitin eds.: "Symbiosis, Symbolism, and the Power of the Past..."), it should be axiomatic that “form follows function” in varying house styles as well as in, e.g., granary, storehouse, and stable styles (buildings for “storing” different sorts of items/commodities/entities), and shrine, temple, and palace styles (buildings for “worshipping and housing gods, God/s, and rulers”). Presumably, a variety of factors dictated the differing (and/or similar) physical organization and furnishing of space in both typical and atypical “Judaean/Israelite” house plans, typical Philistine and Babylonian (?) houses , and typical, but non-local, Middle Bronze II houses at Hazor in more-or-less the same “territory” (Philistine coast & plain, the Negev and Shephelah, Megiddo and Hazor, the latter two in relation to the Megiddo Plain and communication routes). The analysis will seek to discover the functionality and archaeoethnographic suitability to each of the four population groups of six distinctly different building plans. Determinants examined will include the archaeologically-preserved building remains themselves, building materials, inferrable and/or reconstructable economies (domestic, communal, agricultural, state [as opposed to “National Economies”, cf. Holladay in the forthcoming Dever Festschrift]), together with family makeup and, where inferrable, social organization, employing archaeological, textual/historical, ethnographic, and geographical approaches.


“Not as the Scribes:” Biblical Studies in the Liberal Arts Curriculum
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Glenn S. Holland, Allegheny College

The primary intention of the liberal arts curriculum is to provide exposure to a variety of academic subjects while cultivating in the student the skills of intelligent reading, effective speaking and writing, and incisive critical analysis. The Religious Studies instructor in this context is largely freed from the obligation to present comprehensive overviews and may instead deal with perennial issues of religious inquiry through selected examples taken from specific religious cultures. In the case of biblical studies, the instructor need not deal at length with critical methodologies or the history of interpretation of the biblical texts. Instead, she or he may focus attention on the sorts of issues and questions that arise when documents created in ancient cultural contexts become the definitive body of divine revelation for later religious communities. Lectures, discussions, assignments, and examinations all may concentrate on questions raised by particular passages or situations taken from the biblical texts, with the evaluation of responses based on the students’ ability to recognize and grapple with the central issues and present their conclusions clearly in speaking or writing. In this way, the course becomes a way for students to understand and practice how to investigate biblical texts in a way consistent with the skills and values of the wider liberal arts curriculum. This discussion will be supplemented with examples drawn from twenty years of teaching at Allegheny College, a traditional liberal arts institution.


Hathor and Isis in Byblos in the Second and First Millennia
Program Unit: Israelite Religion in its Ancient Context
Susan Tower Hollis, Empire State College, SUNY

Both Hathor and Isis appear in Byblos in various guises and under different circumstances during the second and first millennia BCE. In fact, we know of Hathor, the Egyptian goddess who received cult in many foreign locales, in Byblos in the third millennium. This discussion will explore their respective presence in Byblos, the circumstances under which each is definitely in the location, how and why each arrive there, and those times when it is assumed on or the other is there - but that reality might be questioned.


Seneca's Ad Helviam matrem and the Genre of Philippians
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Paul Andrew Holloway, Samford University

The letter of consolation is an established ancient genre, and Paul's letter to the Philippians is such a letter. It is rendered more or less unique, however, by the fact that it is Paul the sufferer (the prisoner) who is writing to console those grieving on his behalf, not the other way around. To my knowledge no ancient parallel for this exists, except Seneca's strikingly similar letter of consolation to his mother Helvia on the occasion of his own exile. In this paper I attempt to clarify Paul's consolatory strategy in Philippians with reference to Seneca's letter.


Coping with Religious Prejudice: 1 Peter in Social Psychological Perspective
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Paul Andrew Holloway, Samford University

1 Peter marks the earliest attempt by a Christian author to craft a more or less comprehensive response to pagan religious prejudice. Unlike later Apologists, however, the author of 1 Peter does not seek to directly influence pagan opinion. He writes, instead, for his beleaguered coreligionists, consoling them in their suffering and advising them on how to cope with their predicament. In this paper I compare the coping strategies recommended in 1 Peter to similar strategies for coping with prejudice as identified by modern empirical social psychology, which in the past decade or so has made considerable progress in understanding prejudice from the target's perspective. I argue (1) that a number of the major coping strategies identified by modern social psychologists are present in 1 Peter, (2) that the recognition of these strategies provides a coherent reading of the letter, and (3) that this reading promises to solve several long-standing exegetical problems, including the tensions identified in the Balch-Elliott debate.


“Illustrations Apposite and Useful”: Assyriology, Biblical Archaeology, and the Brattleboro Comprehensive Commentary on the Holy Bible, 1834–1838
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Steven W. Holloway, American Theological Library Association

America’s complex on-going affair with the Bible generated a precocious fascination with the Bible-lands and their material remains, as witness the fanfare surrounding the cuneiform bricks exhibited in NYC in 1817. By the 1830s, new technologies in print production, changing tastes in visual culture, a growing thirst for accurate historical contextualization, and the rise of a generation of American-born Orientalists in conversation with their European counterparts resulted in an influential Bible commentary boasting the latest word in cuneiform decipherment, aggressively marketed by John C. Holbrook of Brattleboro, Vermont.


Strategies for the Study of Women's Religious Experience
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Amy Hollywood, Harvard Divinity School

This paper offers significant strategies for the study of women's religious experience. Other presenters in the session, Women's Religious Experience in Antiquity, will interact with these strategies in their analyses of Greek women (Sarah Iles Johnston), the figure of Aseneth in Joseph and Aseneth (Patricia Ahearne-Kroll), and the figure of Eve in the Greek Life of Adam and Eve (John R. Levison).


The Sheikh Fadl Inscription and Its Literary Context
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Tawny L. Holm, Indiana University of Pennsylvania

This fragmentary tomb inscription of the fifth century B.C.E. was found by Sir Flinders Petrie near Sheikh Fall in his 1921-1922 campaign in Egypt. The genre of the inscription has been described as a tomb biography (Giron, Dalley), or as a piece of fictional literature (Lemaire, Porten). Lemaire in his editio princeps in 1995 related it to several Aramaic and Egyptian literary traditions, including H.or son of Pawenesh (in Aramaic and Demotic), the Cycle of Petubastis/Inaros (in Demotic), Setne Khamwas (in Demotic), the story of Ah.iqar (in Aramaic and Demotic), and the “Story of Two Brothers” from Papyrus Amherst 63 (Aramaic in Demotic script). Moreover, Egyptologists Vittmann and Ryholt have suggested that the key to understanding this inscription is to be found in the reading of the name of a character appearing in a broken context. They understand the name in question to be Ynh.rw (the Aramaic form of Inaros), rather than Snh.rw (as suggested by Porten and Yardeni) or Ynh.tw (as suggested by Lemaire). If so, the inscription may be the earliest story concerning Inaros, an Egyptian hero whose story cycle is set in the seventh century BCE, but who was previously known only from Demotic manuscripts dating to the late Ptolemaic and Roman periods. This paper explores the literary context of the Sheikh Fall inscription, especially its possible relationship to the Inaros stories —of which it would be the earliest representative— and its relationship to other Aramaic literature.


Westcott and Hort at 125 (and Zuntz at 60): Their Historic Legacies and Our Contemporary Challenges
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Michael W. Holmes, Bethel University

2006 marks not only the 125th anniversary of the publication of Westcott & Hort’s famous _New Testament in the Original Greek_ and its equally important accompanying volume presenting their introduction and notes on select readings (Macmillan, 1881), but also the 60th anniversary of the presentation of Günther Zuntz’s path-setting lectures on _The Text of the Epistles_ to the British Academy (1946; published 1953). This paper will offer an assessment of their continuing legacies and impact on the discipline of New Testament textual criticism, as well as the contemporary challenges their work poses for the discipline today, particularly with respect to the crucial (but widely neglected) matter of the history of the transmission of the text.


The Distribution of "'asher" and "sh" in Qoheleth
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Robert D. Holmstedt, University of Toronto

Previous investigations on the distribution of "'asher" and "sh" in Qoheleth have not succeeded in identifying either a convincing pattern of distribution or a plausible explanation for the presence of both relative words in the same book, which are at times interwoven in the same verse or set of verses. This paper will once again attempt to discern whether there may exist a rhyme or reason for the use of "'asher" and "sh" in Qoheleth. This study will build upon this researcher’s investigation of the syntactic, diachronic, and dialectal issues in relative clause strategies in ancient Hebrew, and will consider whether the use of the two relative words in Qoheleth is connected to “code-switching” for the literary purpose of advancing the royal persona for the voice of Qoheleth.


The Pseudo-Clementines and the Challenges of the Conversion of Families
Program Unit: Early Christian Families
Cornelia Horn, Saint Louis University

The Pseudo-Clementines narrate the story of a reunification, culminating in the recognition of Clement's family members of one another. This paper examines the transformations accompanying these events and their impact on the religious, social, cultural, and moral dimensions of family life. Challenges to family structures in the Pseudo-Clementines include the conversion of only some members of a given family to Christian moral ideals and faith. Where this leads to the breakup of families, the Psuedo-Clementines propose not to blame Christianity for anti-familial tendencies, but instead to acknowledge the new religion as the source of healing, restoration, and restructuring of the family by way of conversion of all family members. The texts promote adherence to Christianity as a means of reestablishing the legitimate governance of the father over his children and the respect of children for their parents. This alone guarantees eternal peace, symbolized in the advent of the "child of peace." Where families suffer separation through the death of a parent, the church functions as a surrogate parent, an aspect that contrasts with representations of Graeco-Roman deities as corruptors and destroyers of children. The Pseudo-Clementines encourage the transformation and renewal of sexual morality in family settings: no longer is the father to use his children as sexual objects. Chastity of the wife guarantees the childrens' right to know their own father and assures the father that his own children inherit his property. The Pseudo-Clementines also rely on the appeal to heavenly family structures in support of those on earth. Yet in the end, family coherence and community manifest themselves in the sharing of a common meal. The cultural acceptance of this ideal, coupled with the affection of family members for one another, facilitates the call to conversion to Christianity for all family members, thus overcoming family separation.


Tearing the Temple Veil: Ephraem the Syrian on the Holy Spirit and the Jews
Program Unit: Christian Late Antiquity and Its Reception
Cornelia B. Horn, Saint Louis University

Among Syriac-speaking Christians, the poetry of the fourth-century Ephraem the Syrian is at the heart of theological reflection, spirituality, and liturgical life. Early Christian communities recognized his impact and authority by distinguishing him with the epithet “Harp of the Spirit.” Recent studies (Horn, 2000 and 2002) have explored some of the liturgical, sacramental, and dogmatic dimensions of Ephraem’s pneumatology. Although Ephraem died in 373, his pneumatology was as sophisticated as that of the Cappadocian theologians and ultimately may have inspired the doctrine of the divinity of the Holy Spirit that is associated with the Council of Constantinople (381). Thus far however, contextual factors that shaped Ephraem’s thought on the Holy Spirit have not been considered appropriately. This paper contributes to the exploration of fourth-century pneumatology in Asia Minor and Syria by examining a central motif that Ephraem employs when he speaks of the infusion of the Spirit into the world. Throughout his metrical sermons (memre) and his poems (madroshe), Ephraem features the Spirit as tearing the veil of the Temple and leaving the Temple at the time of Jesus’ death. While the scene as such is based on a quotation from Matthew’s gospel, Ephraem added pneumatology and a critique of Judaism as two distinct elements to his biblical interpretation. This paper offers a twofold explanation for this phenomenon. It shows that both Rabbinic thought and earlier Christian interpretive traditions that are evidenced in patristic Latin and Greek sermons (Pseudo-Cyprian and Melito of Sardis) are sources for Ephraem’s thought, or at least are parallels to this interpretation. Taking account of recent research on traces of anti-Judaism in Ephraem’s work (Shepardson, 2003), this paper also situates Ephraem’s presentation of the Spirit as deserting the Jews within the context of the poet-theologian’s struggle on behalf of orthodoxy within his own community.


Sacred to Believe: Apocalypse and the Rhetoric of Fear
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
Tim Horner, Villanova University

Apocalyptic imagery and literature (whether Jewish or Christian) is universally seen by scholars as a coping mechanism which arises from small persecuted faith communities. Against the backdrop of future vindication and triumph, current persecutions are recast as a larger divine plan that will eventually shift suffering onto those who are now in positions of power. In the apocalyptic world, current trials are dwarfed by a future where God places the persecuted group into a permanent, privileged position in the heavenly realm. While this scenario is attractive in many ways, it does not, in my reckoning, bear the weight of the history. This paper will propose a different way of interpreting Christian apocalyptic writings that is more sensitive to the historical context out of which it arose. It is an interpretation that does not assume a constant state of persecution, cognitive dissonance, or theodicy. Far from attempting to bring comfort to beleaguered believers and restore faith in God’s ultimate plan for human history, Revelation can be seen as a rhetorical tool used to imbue fear and intimidation into its adherents as a way to strengthen allegiance and homogenize belief and behavior. By comparing two familiar of pieces apocalyptic literature – Qumran (Jewish) and Revelation (Jewish Christian) – it becomes evident that the Apocalypse of John turned the violence of the apocalyptic tradition on itself for the first time.


When Jesus Was Not Christian: Re-evaluating Early ‘Christian’ Texts
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Tim Horner, Villanova University

In the first century CE the lines between the early Jesus movement and Judaism were blurry, if not non-existent. Some NT scholars have asserted the necessity of an exclusively Jewish context and audience for many, if not all, of the books and letters of the Christian canon. But can we say that this carries over into the extra-canonical literature of the second or even third centuries of the common era? Conventional wisdom says that anything outside the canon that mentions Jesus is Christian. It is assumed that by the second century, Jesus can reliably be used to identify Christian communities. My research, however, does not bear this out. This paper will discuss two texts (Infancy Gospel of Thomas and the Protoevangelium of James) where the presence of Jesus does not necessarily indicate Christianity, at least not a form that is recognizable as such. The Apocalypse of John will also be considered. These ‘Jesus’ texts resonate more with the concerns and sensibilities of proto/early-rabbinic Judaism. They call into question the way historians determine the cultural provenance of a text and assign it to a ‘community’. They force scholars to examine the assumptions and prejudices that inform our conclusions about both Judaism and Christianity during these centuries of great change. This paper hopes to open a discussion of how scholars make distinctions between religious groups.


Worthy to Suffer Shame: A Gospel Call to Masochism
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Teresa J. Hornsby, Drury University

At the heart of the Gospel story is the trial and crucifixion of Jesus. It is not the centrality of the violent and gruesome events of the Passion, but the cultural fascination with and theological concentration on them that draw me toward ideas of masochism in the New Testament. We know from history (and from Mel Gibson) that crucifixion is the most gruesome of deaths. We also know that the Pauline and deutero-Pauline epistles espouse the value of suffering, of being a slave, of persecution, and of humiliation, all for the sake of Christ (e.g., Rom. 8.18; 1 Th. 3.3-4; 2 Th. 1.4-5; 2 Tim. 2.12, 3.12, 1.8; 1 Peter 2.21, 4.12-13,16). The idea of subservience and images of kneeling, bowing, of humbling oneself to power, and physical suffering are integral to a New Testament Christian ideal. It appears that the New Testament advocates masochism. This paper explores if there is a necessary relationship between New Testament Christianity and masochism. More, I will ask if there is a different valuation of masochism for men than for women in the New Testament. In order to get to these questions, I will first give a brief forschungsberichte of ‘masochism.’ I will also investigate how feminist biblical scholars (e.g., Jane Schaberg, Barbara Reid, Mary Daly) and theorists of sexuality (e.g., Marie Griffith, Pat Califia, Kaja Silverman, Judith Butler) have responded to images of masochism and to Christian masochistic ideals.


Conformity and Resistance: Beyond the Balch-Elliott Debate towards a Postcolonial Reading of 1 Peter
Program Unit: Methodological Reassessments of the Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
David G. Horrell, University of Exeter

The debate in the mid-1980s between John Elliott and David Balch was a high point in the discussion of 1 Peter, not least in relation to the differing ways in which social-scientific resources might be used to illuminate the dynamics of the relationship between the community and the world, as depicted and promoted in the letter. Building on the work of writers such as James C. Scott, who have studied the forms of everyday peasant resistance, and on postcolonial theorists’ analyses of the ways in which subject peoples relate to empire, this paper will set out new theoretical resources with which to conceptualise the relationship between community and world, church and empire, in 1 Peter. These resources may provide one way beyond the contrast between seeing 1 Peter either as promoting a sectarian opposition to the world or as encouraging assimilation to it. Analysing the letter in the light of this framework, the paper will seek to characterise the letter’s stance towards the empire, somewhere between conformity and resistance.


Legion and Beelzebul: A Medical Anthropological Approach to Spirit-Possession in Ancient Palestine
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Richard A. Horsley, University of Massachusetts, Boston

Medical anthropology may offer students of religious experience among the ancient Galileans and Judeans a less reductionistic approach than either standard modern European biblical studies rooted in Enlightenment reason or modern psychology. Medical anthropologists argue that both the “diagnosis” of “illness,” or “spirit-possession,” and the “healing,” or “exorcism” of spirits, are culturally determined. More recently, critical medical anthropologists have recognized that power relations also affect illness and possession. Several of their studies of particular cases or particular societies may be suggestive for a study of the stories about the demon whose name was “Legion” and “Prince of Demons,” whom the scribes called “Beelzebul.” With this less reductive approach and these comparative studies, I will explore these Markan stories, further building on what I have previously done my book on Mark. This exploration will involve gleaning whatever information may be available on ancient Judean and Galilean culture in order to understand the culturally defined experience of spirit possession and the reactions to it in Jesus’ exorcism and the scribes’ and Pharisees’ accusations.


The Herodian Temple and Jewish Responses to Roman Power
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Richard A. Horsley, University of Massachusetts, Boston

In order to understand the lives of Jews and other subjected peoples under Roman rule, we need a more multifaceted sense of how power operated in the Roman imperial order. Both Jewish and Christian interpreters have usually understood the Temple in Jerusalem primarily or mainly as one of two central institutions of ancient “Judaism.” When we attempt to ask a more complex set of questions about the historical context in which the Temple was situated, however, its role and attitudes toward it become much more complicated. From the foundation of the Temple and temple-state under the Persian imperial regime, it functioned as an instrument of imperial rule in Judea. In what way did that change, and perhaps become enhanced, when the Roman-appointed Herod massively rebuilt the Temple complex and installed his own creatures in high priestly office? Since Persian times, there had been dissenting voices among Judeans about the legitimacy and operation of the Temple. In what way did that change or continue under Roman and Herodian rule? The early Roman period was framed by massive popular revolts against the Herodians and high priests, who were Roman client rulers. How may that have been particular to Roman rule? In the broader context of the Roman empire, to what extent may the Herodian Temple have functioned as an institution designed partly for the Jewish diaspora under the conditions of Roman rule? And, finally, how may the response to the Temple among diaspora Jews have differed from that among Judeans and Galileans?


Bent-Over No Longer: Liberation as Luke’s Vision for His Community
Program Unit: Formation of Luke and Acts
Natalie K. Houghtby-Haddon, George Washington University

The story of The Bent-Over Woman has been largely ignored by New Testament scholars because it is found only in the gospel of Luke. I propose, however, that the passage is actually a key text for Luke, which describes, in narrative form, his social vision for his community. At first glance, the pericope seems to fit three standard genres in the gospels: exorcisms, miracle/healing stories, and Sabbath controversy stories. But there are several clues to suggest that it does not follow the typical pattern of these genres at all, and instead is a story carefully crafted by Luke to move forward the particular concerns of his literary composition. These issues will be examined in detail as I explore Luke’s purpose in including this story in his gospel. My contention is that Luke has several possible social alignments in view for his community. Drawing on his community’s familiarity with the Septuagint, Luke is inviting his community to think about how their life together is organized. Through the story of the Bent-Over Woman with its allusions to the sabbatical year legislation, the jubilee year, and the recognition that women and non-Jews are included in the command to keep Sabbath rest, Luke is inviting his community to imagine a radically alternative future for themselves. The Bent-Over Woman anticipates the Jubilee year when she is “immediately restored” as Jesus places his hands on her. Bent-over no longer, she becomes the living exemplar both of Mary’s Magnificat and Jesus’ inaugural sermon at the beginning of his ministry claiming that the prophecies of Isaiah 61 have been fulfilled "today."


Beyond Fables: Animal Speech as Revelation in Genesis 3 and Numbers 22
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Cameron B.R. Howard, Emory University

Animals who talk with humans, in the sense of communicating via human speech, appear only twice in the Hebrew Bible: the serpent converses with Eve (Genesis 3), and the ass rebukes Balaam (Numbers 22). In each case the animal is a prominent character in the narrative, and the animal’s speech changes the course of the story. Instances of direct discourse between human beings and animals are also rare in other ancient Near Eastern literature; animals frequently converse with each other, and occasionally with deities, but almost never with humans. Rather than recognizing the non-human to human speech in Genesis 3 and Numbers 22 as a unique literary phenomenon worthy of deeper consideration, most commentators dismiss an animal’s ability to speak as a generic convention of fables or of “primitive” literature. Re-reading Genesis 3 and Numbers 22 with particular attention to the voices of the serpent and donkey reveals that these two talking animals are no mere generic conventions. Instead, they share a unique literary function that, while not necessarily frequent enough to comprise its own form, nevertheless sets these two texts apart from the fable genre. The ability of the ass and serpent to converse with Balaam and Eve, respectively, is not a narrative elevation of the animals from subhuman to human capacities, but rather depicts their close affinities with the deity. The text of each story is saturated with the vocabulary of divine revelation; the speech of the animals, who see and know what humans cannot, mediates between God and the humans, giving humanity access to God. Rather than a primitive device used to introduce moralizing elements into texts, animal speech operates in Genesis 3 and Numbers 22 as a carefully constructed way to bring knowledge of the divine to humanity.


Psalm 88 and the Rhetoric of the Lament
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
David M. Howard, Jr., Bethel Seminary

The Psalter’s laments express the deepest of human emotions in rich, deep, and varied language. This paper attempts to show how the language of the laments is “rhetorical,” i.e., how it attempts to evoke emotive responses, to draw the reader into the “world” of the one(s) lamenting, and to draw God to respond. A special focus is placed on Psalm 88, the “darkest” of the laments, and suggestions for appropriation in the modern day are made.


Journey to Mount Horeb: Cognitive Theory and 1 Kings 19:1-18
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
J. Dwayne Howell, Campbellsville University

Elijah's jouney to Mt. Horeb in 1 Kings 19:1-18 portrays the struggles of a man who displays hopelessness. In 1 Kings 18:14-16 he had defeated the prophets of Baal at Mt. Carmel. Instead of bringing about national repentance, Elijah is threatened by the queen of Israel, Jezebel. Fleeing for his life, Elijah journeys 40 days to Mt. Horeb where he is confronted with the reality of the situation and is directed by God to return to Israel. Using Cognitive Theory as a base, the paper explores Elijah's experiences and God's response as described by the writer of the text. Beck's Negative Cognitive Triad (Beck 1997, 1987, 1967), which consists of a negative view of one's self, one's world, and one's future, provides the framework for understanding Elijah's sense of despair. God's directive response to Elijah is also consistent with the approach advocated by Cognitive Theory.


Embedded Letter as Rhetorical Exornatio in Acts 23:26–30
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Justin R. Howell, University of Chicago

That the embedded letters of Acts 15:23-29 and 23:26-30 are Lukan creations has long been proposed by scholars. While various answers to the question regarding whether Luke composed the letters in Acts have been offered, a satisfying answer to the question of why Luke would have composed the letters has not yet been given. Therefore, I propose that an answer to the latter question will greatly assist in providing an answer to the former. Recent scholarship on ancient epistolography—particularly that of interpreting letters embedded in a larger narrative—must be considered. Adolf Deissmann’s classic work—which remains a standard in its own right—must now be read alongside Patricia A. Rosenmeyer’s recent work entitled Ancient Epistolary Fictions. Particularly helpful for the present paper will be Rosenmeyer’s contribution to the role of embedded letters in narrative discourse and how this role might contribute to our understanding of the function of the embedded letters in Acts—particularly the letter of Lysias (23:26-30), which will serve as our test case. For the present paper, Chariton’s Callirhoe and Sallust’s The War with Catiline will provide contexts in which one is able to observe the way that letters function in narrative discourse. After considering briefly the role of embedded epistolary fictions in ancient literature and the likelihood that composing such fictions was a common part of ancient paideia, I shall argue that the letter of Lysias in Acts 23:26-30 is best contextualized and read via the ancient rhetorical technique of exornatio, as set forth primarily by Cicero and Quintilian. Reading the letter of Lysias as a rhetorical exornatio clarifies not only the likelihood of the letter as a Lukan composition, but also the motive and the purpose of composing the letter.


From Chagall's Creation to Blake's Apocalypse: Teaching the Bible through the Visual Arts
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Lynn Huber, Elon College

The Jewish and Christian sacred writings have inspired visual artists throughout the centuries, yielding an artistic tradition as varied as the biblical texts themselves. These works of art range from ancient frescos and mosaics to medieval manuscript illuminations to contemporary photography, reflecting not only different mediums and styles, but also different historical contexts and intentions. Using visual art to teach the Bible, consequently, can involve a number of specific strategies and a multiplicity of purposes. More importantly, using visual art in teaching the Bible offers a range of possible rewards, such as increased student engagement and understanding of interpretive problems. Drawing upon categories articulated by Katharine Martinez in an article on how historians employ the visual ("Imaging the Past: Historians, Visual Images and the Contested Definition of History" Visual Resources 11 [1995]: 21-45) and the work of Robin Jensen on early Christian art (Understanding Early Christian Art [London: Routledge, 2000]), this paper explores a number of ways in which visual art can be used in the classroom. These strategies include "reading" visual pieces that specifically illustrate a particular text to explore multiple meanings in a text and using non-figurative images as a way of engaging students to think about more abstract concepts related to biblical studies (such as using Pauls Klee's abstract oil painting Ancient Sound to think about canon formation).


Blood on the Water: Contextualizing the First Biblical Plague
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
John Huddlestun, College of Charleston

Arguably the most widely cited of biblical narratives concerning Egypt and its Nile is that relating the plagues on Egypt, specifically the first plague, where the river turns to blood. Biblical historians and Egyptologists, to be sure, have not been wanting when it comes to the seemingly endless explanations, scientific or otherwise, offered for these miraculously portrayed phenomena (e.g., the influential articles of Greta Hort and recent treatments of Hoffmeier and Kitchen). My purpose here is more modest: to examine critically the water-to-blood motif in the biblical text and especially within its larger ancient Near Eastern context, Mesopotamian and Egyptian, moving well beyond the handful of Middle Kingdom literary texts frequently cited in discussions of it (e.g., Admonitions, Neferti). Following a critical analysis of Hort and others, I consider links between water and blood in various contexts (e.g., military inscriptions, literary texts, magic and ritual, curse traditions, etc.) and argue that the use of this motif in the Exodus narrative derives less from any specific knowledge of Egypt and the Nile inundation and is more easily explicable as a common ancient Near Eastern symbol of destruction and devastation.


Missing Priests—Finding Identity
Program Unit: Social-Scientific Studies of the Second Temple Period
Alice Wells Hunt, Vanderbilt University

*


"The Righteous Generation": The Use of dor in Psalms 14 and 24
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Alastair G. Hunter, University of Glasgow

The language of Psalm 24.6 has long posed problems of translation, both in the distinctive ‘such is the generation of those who seek him’ and in its concluding, and somewhat baffling, ‘who seek your face, Jacob’. This paper examines the use of the key terms of this verse in parallel passages, particularly Psalm 14 and a striking and also problematic verse in Jeremiah 2.31. On the basis of a detailed linguistic analysis I propose that there is in this text a lost fragment of liturgy which may have formed part of the entrance ritual for those making a processional journey to the Jerusalem temple.


And the Word Was Made Flesh: Latter-day Saint Exegesis of the Blood and Water Imagery in John
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
Eric D. Huntsman, Brigham Young University

Both blood and water provide powerful images in the first half of the Gospel of John—water to wine at Cana in John 2:1-11; water and spirit being the source of the new birth in 3:1–21; water “springing up to everlasting life” in 4:4-42; the troubled waters of the pool of Bethesda being a source or, better, a type of healing in 5:1-16; Jesus’ blood being a source of life in the Bread of Life Discourse of 6:26-59; and rivers of living water flowing from those who believe on Jesus in 7:37-39. Critical to understanding this symbolism is the sign of the blood and water that stream from Jesus’ side as he hangs from the cross in 19:34-45, where it becomes apparent that they are symbols of Jesus’ dual nature: his ability to lay down his life as an offering for sin, but his continued ability to be the source of life for those who accept him. The high christology of John has particular resonance for the Latter-day Saints, where the Logos hymn of 1:1-18 accords with LDS teachings on premortality but in particular with the premortal identity and role of Jesus before the incarnation. In addition, several passages of restoration scripture and LDS teaching shape the hermeneutic that Latter-day Saints can bring to bear on the exegesis of the gospel, particularly the teaching of 1 Nephi 11:12-33 on the condescension; Doctrine and Covenants 93:2-22 on the incarnation and the mortal Jesus’ growing “from grace to grace”; and the significance mortal bodies quickened by blood and immortal, resurrected bodies quickened by spirit. These perspectives allow an interpretation of the blood and water imagery that makes these elements symbolic of mortality and eternal life, making them truly semeia of who Jesus was and what he did for mankind.


The Vessels of YHWH and the Debate over Divine Presence in the Second Temple: Downgrading a Divine Symbol
Program Unit: Social-Scientific Studies of the Second Temple Period
Victor Hurowitz, Ben Gurion University of the Negev

Temples in the Bible and the Ancient Near East were usually conceived of as divine residences housing some perceptible sign of divine presence. But was this was the case of the Second Temple as well? Investigation of the dedication ceremony described in Ezra 6:16-18 shows that in stark contrast to such occasions in the Bible and Mesopotamian writings, there is no hint of YHWH’s entry into the new building. In addition, the temple vessels, which certain recent scholars maintain are in fact representatives of YHWH or His presence, are never introduced into the temple. The vessels are enumerated in the part of the building account normally reserved in standard Biblical and ANE building accounts for describing the preparations in materials and manpower. These two anomalies suggest that the author/editor of Ezra 1-6 belonged to the camp of those who opposed the idea of an immanent divine presence in the Temple, and arranged the material in such a way as to downgrade the vessels from divine symbol to building materials symbolic of continuity with the previous temple.


The Freer Biblical Manuscripts: The Significance, Reception, and Neglect of an American Scholarly Treasure Trove
Program Unit:
Larry Hurtado, University of Edinburgh

The biblical manuscripts in the Freer Gallery of Art, six codices palaeographically dated from the third through the sixth centuries CE, comprise one of the most significant collections of such material in the world. Yet, after an initial frenzy of popular and scholarly interest after their acquisition in the early 20th century, they have only occasionally been studied seriously by scholars, and are widely unknown among the public. The project reported on in this session brings together the work of a group of scholars focused on these under-utilized manuscripts.


Piercing a Dead Dragon: Isaiah 51:9–11 and Deutero-Isaiah’s Conception of the Chaoskampf
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Jeremy M. Hutton, Princeton Theological Seminary

Several markers in four texts — three Biblical (Isa 51:9-11; Ps 74:14-15; 89:10-11) and one Ugaritic (KTU 1.3 III 38-46) — correspond closely in theme, vocabulary, and syntax. After consideration of the data we are justified not only in seeing the same imagery in these four texts, but also in positing an intermediate hypothetical text to which all four allude. Deutero-Isaiah’s appropriation of the earlier text was carried out with a two-fold subversion in mind. First, of course, was the direct contradiction of the theology espoused by the earlier text, in which it was Anat or Baal who had defeated the chthonic forces in the primeval Chaoskampf. Deutero-Isaiah performed a second level of subversion by couching a communal lament in the exact grammatical categories of the earlier Canaanite text, implying that the exiles’ belief in the radical intervention in history by the “arm of Yahweh” was itself a form of idolatry, and did not properly understand the nature of God’s work in the world.


The Corinthian Crises and Paul’s Use of Numbers in 1 Corinthians 1–5
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Jin Hwang, Fuller Theological Seminary

Despite the lack of an explicit citation from Numbers in the Pauline epistles, there are indeed a number of unquestionable allusions to Numbers in 1 Corinthians. Especially 1 Corinthians 10 is replete with such allusions (vv. 4-10). For instance, in 1 Cor 10:8-10 Paul mentions three tragic events written exclusively in Numbers 11:4, 34; 21:5-6; and 25:1-9. All of these are referred to as the negative examples to be avoided (cf. 1 Cor 10:6, 11). But Paul’s conscious use of Numbers is not limited to this chapter. The allusions to Numbers are made not only in the latter chapters (Num 11:29/1 Cor 14:5; Num 12:8/1 Cor 13:12; Num 18:8, 31/1 Cor 9:13; Num 21:3/1 Cor 12:3.) but also in the earlier chapters. In his insightful essay, “The Systematic Use of the Pentateuch in 1 Corinthians,” Thomas L. Brodie pays close attention to the affinities between the earlier chapters of 1 Corinthians and Numbers. Among others, he claims, situational similarity can be the most telling evidence of Paul’s dependence on Numbers in 1 Corinthians: like Moses who had to handle the various crises in the community of the people of Israel (Num 11-17), Paul as the founder of the Corinthian community had a similar need to deal with the various crises in it (1 Cor 3:1-5:8). The present paper aims to further develop Brodie’s idea and demonstrate how effectively Paul uses Numbers especially in 1 Corinthians 1-5 to handle these crises, including the crisis of his apostolic authority, at Corinth.


Echoes of the Book of Exodus in Ezekiel
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
Rebecca G.S. Idestrom, Tyndale Seminary

This paper will explore the thematic connections made between the book of Exodus and the book of Ezekiel. Both books emphasize the theme of knowing God through his divine acts. Other themes and motifs from Exodus found in Ezekiel including the call narrative, divine encounters, captivity, signs, plagues, judgment, redemption and tabernacle/temple will be considered. Several parallels between Moses and Ezekiel are noted, raising the question of whether Ezekiel was understood as a second Moses figure. Both were Levites who became prophets and leaders of God's people in a time of crisis. Finally, some of the implications of these connections for interpreting the book of Ezekiel will be highlighted.


A Historical and Socio-cultural Investigation of Amalek in the Old Testament
Program Unit: Poster Session
Pong Dae Im, Graudate Theological Seminary

Amalek is the archetypal enemy of Israel, ultimately becoming the symbol of anti-Semitism leading to the hereditary hostility between Israel and Amalek being considered as the “longest hatred.” In Jewish historical tradition, Amalek became the typus of the irreconcilable enemy of the Israelites, to be wiped out from the world. All the great persecutors of the Jewish people across the centuries are regarded as descendants of Amalek, including Antiochus, Titus, and Hitler. After the Persian War in 1992, Israeli bakeries sold “Haman’s ear,” a special pastry eaten on Purim, which was decorated to look like Saddam Hussein. In contrast, the Arabs regard Amalek as their oldest ancestor and themselves as the descendant of Amalek, since Amalek is mentioned in many Arabic writings. T. Nöldeke argues that the origin of the Arabic accounts about the Amalekites was rooted in the Old Testament and that Amalek had been mystified by the Arabs for their own purpose. Since both of the Jewish interpretation and the Arabic accounts of Amalek are based on the Old Testament from their own bias, we need to return to the Old Testament for a proper understanding of the origin of their long continuing hostility. The question is, why are the Amalekites singled out when so many nations attacked and oppressed Israel? It is surprising that there is no divine command to eradiate any nation except Amalek, regarding as irreconcilable evil. I will analyze the Biblical texts related to Amalek and then, in relation to the desert nomads in the Sinai Peninsula, I will investigate the socio-cultural difference and relationship between flock nomads and desert nomads in the early history of Israel. Also the post-exilic context of Israel will be considered, because some of the Biblical accounts could be added in the post exilic period.


The Jewish War and the Guilt of the Jews: The Creation and Development of an Christian Anti-Jewish Argument
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Sabrina Inowlocki, Hebrew University of Jerusalem

In this paper, I intend to focus on a particular case of Christian rhetorical violence against the Jews: the Christian claim that the miseries undergone by the Jews during the Jewish War (including the destruction of the Temple by the Romans) were a divine punishment sent to the Jews on account of their murder of Christ. This paper will attempt to show how actual violence (Jesus'death, James' martyrdom, and the destruction of the Temple) was exploited in order to be turned into rhetorical and theological violence. The accusation of the Jewish deicide was common from the beginnings in Christian circles; so was the idea that the fall of Jerusalem and of the Temple were a divine punishment against the Jews. However, the connection between the two only arises from Origen onwards. Interestingly, in the latter's works, this idea occurs on several occasions in relation to Josephus' supposed claim that the siege of Jerusalem was destroyed because of the murder of James the Just. Yet such a claim appears nowhere in our manuscripts of Josephus. It rather appears as a manipulaion of a passage from Hegesippus, preserved by Eusebius of Caesarea. Eusebius himself appropriated and further developed Origen's thesis. From then on, the idea spread both geographically and diachronically, generating endless rhetorical violence. By dealing with this topic, I hope to shed new light both on the use of rhetorical violence in a Jewish Christian context and on the particular development of a crucial Christian anti-Jewish argument.


"In Memory of Her," the Prequel: Prostitutes, Aphrodite, and the Anointing of Jesus
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Avaren E. Ipsen, University of California, Berkeley

Scholars argue about the Christological significance of Jesus’ anointing by an anonymous woman in Mark 14:3-9, Matthew 26:6-13 and Luke 7:36-50, but in John 12:1-8, named Mary of Bethany. Whether or not the woman was a prostitute or whether her act was decent is also at issue in much scholarship. Who are we to remember? This paper looks at the ancient texts of mythical and ritual anointing of Adonis by Aphrodite and the women who were thought to personate her in human life: prostitutes. In such a model for anointing, the ritual, symbolic and erotic significance of the event remembered in the gospels can be seen as one integrated act. Important to prostitutes is what history is remembered and whether the act of anointing Jesus is their history. This line of research was instigated by of the activist prostitutes of the Sex Worker Outreach Project (SWOP), in Berkeley California, with whom I have collaborated to read biblical prostitution from the standpoint of prostitutes.


Biblical Law, American Law: A Typology of Tactics for the “Restoration” of Conservative Christian Normativity in the United States
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Ipsita Chatterjea, Vanderbilt University

Within conservative Christianity in the United States today, the understanding of the rightful relationship between civic and criminal law and biblical normativity manifests itself in a variety of ways. This paper will examine contemporary rhetoric regarding the relationship between biblical law and “American law” (American criminal, civil, and constitutional law). The following questions will be asked: how are biblical and American law spoken of in relation to one another; and what are the strategies and legal tactics utilized and how do they vary in response to events? The underlying thesis is that, while there is a great heterogeneity of positions within conservative Christianity on the relationship between biblical law and American law, one objective remains the same, that is, a restoration (that presumes loss) of something akin to Christian biblical normativity as law. This study will examine the language utilized, the range of tactical positions taken, and the notions of loss and restoration in the intellectual history of the Christian conservative movement.


Christian Hebrews versus Egyptian Jews: Appropriation and Displacement of Ethnic Features in Eusebius’ Apologetic Writings
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Eduard Iricinschi, Princeton University

Eusebius composed Preparatio Evangelica and Demonstratio Evangelica as an apologetic work for the practice of verbal confrontation with the Greeks and the Jews. In his depiction of Christianity as a new ethnic and religious category, Eusebius makes room for two new rhetorical locations in the divide between Greeks and Jews, respectively the “Christians” and “Hebrews.” He then places Christianismos in a process devolving from the glorious Hebrews of the past, through the low point of Greeks and the depression of Jews, to Christians as future Hebrews drawn from all the nations. These new Hebrews supersede the Jews and recover the older, higher moral standards of the ancient Hebrews, whereas the Jews renounced these standards in Egypt, and having ignored their own prophets, put Jesus to death. I hope to show in this paper that Eusebius’ apologetic writings employ a rhetoric of appropriation and displacement of Jewish past and Hellenistic philosophy. Writing mainly for the pagan converts to Christianity, Eusebius grants the Greeks a high chance for integration in the Christian politeia. On the other hand, he relegates the Jews to a dispensable role in the chain of transmitting the Torah and prophetic Hebrew books, as well as the “genetic” information, from the Hebrews to Jesus Christ, and subsequently to the Christians. As a result, Eusebius guarantees Christianismos a place on the ontological map of oikoumene, whereas the textual category of “Hebrews” provides it with a secure archaic character, definitely pre-Jewish, through “ethnic argumentation.”


What Is in a Double Name? The Polemic against the “Hebrews” in the Gospel of Philip
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Eduard Iricinschi, Princeton University

This paper will attempt to analyze the role of the “Hebrews” in the gospel of Philip. Determined to gain proselytes for his community, the author of the Gospel of Philip attempts to demote other Pauline groups by attributing them the label of “Hebrews,” and representing their mission in terms of “Hebrew proselytizing.” His ancient readers were most likely to face the problem of discerning between the message of the Gospel of Philip group, spread around in decent, well-recognizable Pauline language, and the messages of its opponents, the “Hebrews” and their “slaves,” probably disseminated using the same decent Pauline metaphors. If religious messages look all the same, how is one supposed to distinguish between them, let alone choose the right one? The answer to this conundrum comes from the myth of double names in the world. Both the community of GPhil and their opponents use the words “God,” “the father,” “the son,” “the holy spirit,” “resurrection,” and “the Church.” According to the Gospel of Philip, the names used by the “Hebrews” function solely in this world, and cannot approximate their heavenly counterpart, because they were only chosen by convention to match the aeon. The theory of double names enables the author of the gospel of Philip to find an explanation as to why the discourses of his opponents, in spite of being probably very similar to his own, are irrevocably caught in the net of worldly misundertandings. Moreover, the theory of the double names allows our author to carve a hermeneutic niche in the Pauline dialogue on the delicate matter of resurrection, and present several rituals practiced in his community, such as baptism, chrism, and the bridal chamber.


Peasant Expectations, Provision for the Poor, and Moral Economy in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
John R. Jackson, Milligan College

Moral claims that wealthier members in agrarian societies have the responsibility to help insure the basic subsistence needs of peasants underlie both Pentateuchal laws concerning the poor and prophetic critiques of the rich. James Scott argues that such provisions for the poor, supported by moral claims and sanctions, are central to the "moral economy" that functions widely in agrarian societies. The third-year tithe (Deuteronomy 14) and the various provisions for the poor included in Deuteronomy 28-29 (prohibition of usury; payment of wages daily; exhortation not to deny justice to the vulnerable; gleaning rights) suggest that such a moral economy functioned in Israel. These laws reflect characteristic moral claims made by peasants in other agrarian societies: they focus primarily on prohibitions of exploitation; they provide no mechanisms for enforcement, but employ motive clauses to lay a moral obligation on the wealthy; and they do not eliminate exploitation or promote equality among all members of society, but provide help for peasants to meet their basic subsistence needs. Peasants in agrarian societies accept exploitation (grudgingly), but hold to a subsistence ethic which, when threatened, leads to conflict (though rarely in the form of violence). Instead, peasants engage in acts of resistance or employ rhetoric that aims to shame the wealthy or appeal to moral norms. This paper contends that such moral rhetoric operated in Israel and is reflected particularly in the kind of legal materials described above. Recent arguments that such legislation reflects conflict among elite groups within Israel rather than concern for the poor will be challenged. Even if such could be demonstrated, that there is a presumption that the vulnerable must be helped, even if only minimally, suggests that a moral ethic that respected the subsistence needs of peasants was operative in Israel.


Naming James: The Letter of James between Judaism and Christianity
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
Matt Jackson-McCabe, Niagara University

Though long fundamental to the critical study of the New Testament and Christian origins, the category “Jewish Christianity” is beset with problems. It has always been a highly ambiguous category, and never more so than in the wake of Daniélou’s influential work. The recent trend by a number of scholars to re-assert a narrow definition that identifies it as a class of Christianity distinguished by Torah observance is an understandable reaction to Daniélou's broad discourse-based definition. But it does not adequately address the basic problem highlighted by other recent critics, namely, the rationale for classifying any given ancient group or text as Christianity rather than Judaism. Using the Letter of James as its example, this paper will argue that the polythetic approach to classification advocated by scholars like Jonathan Z. Smith and Daniel Boyarin results in a much richer and more helpful redescription of those texts that seem to sit on the borderline between Judaism and Christianity than the notion of a “Jewish Christianity” defined by Torah observance allows. The first part of the paper will examine past classification of James in terms of “Jewish Christianity” with an eye to both varying constructions of the category itself and their impact on the interpretation of the text. The second part of the paper will present the outlines of a polythetic approach to classifying James. It concludes by suggesting that this particular work may be better understood as a form of (Christian) Judaism than of Christianity.


Secret Gospels, Gospel Thrillers, and the American Religious Imaginary
Program Unit: Q
Andrew S. Jacobs, University of California, Riverside

By the mid-to-late 1960s, as the contents of the Nag Hammadi and Qumran finds filtered outside of academia, fantasies about the possibilities of a gospel “smoking gun” began to fade from the popular imagination of an eager U.S. audience. Not coincidentally, perhaps, scholars of the time began popularizing other potentially electrifying gospel “discoveries,” such as the hypothetical gospel source document “Q” and the secret (yet somehow recoverable) counter-histories of The Passover Plot. Alongside the disappointments of the deserts and the paler compensations of academic reconstruction, I trace in this paper an additional front by which we might gauge the possibilities simmering in the American religious imagination during this period: the “gospel thriller,” a subgenre emerging in Anglophone markets from the 1960s onward, in which a newly discovered (often autograph) gospel threatens to shatter the foundations of Christianity. A race against time to prove (or disprove) the new gospel’s authenticity usually implicates (in modes both flattering and discomfiting) myriad scholarly and confessional interests. Unbounded by the quasi-scientific reconstructions of scholarship, “gospel thrillers” provided readers a means simultaneously to critique and endorse the productive imaginations of academic inquiry.


Favor and Disfavor: Two Dimensions of the Characterization of God in Jeremiah 29:1–23
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Mignon R. Jacobs, Fuller Theological Seminary

The book of Jeremiah depicts the people of God during and after the demise of Jerusalem in the 6th century BCE. In the midst of the crisis, the prophet Jeremiah posits God's involvement in taking the people to Babylon and keeping them there for an extended duration. Quite apart from this, many have used Jer 29:11 to comfort and reassure themselves of God's favor toward them. To whom was this reassurance directed? What insights does it offer about God's choice and plan? This verse depicts God as having plans that include the well being and hopeful future of God's people. Yet the reassurance of this people is immediately juxtaposed to the planned demise of others. It is no surprise, then, that those who readily embrace this verse and believe themselves to be the focus of the reassurance ignore the image of those who are disfavored. Even so, the conceptual framework of the text challenges any reconceptualization that ignores its characterization of the dimensions of God's character. This paper proposes that Jer 29:1-23 characterizes God's favor and disfavor as essential to God's plan and involvement in the repeated 'selection' and 'de-selection' of God's people. First, in order to understand the parameters of God's favor and disfavor, this paper looks at the designated audience of the reassurance. Second, it examines the dimensions of God's character as exemplified in the choice of whom to favor and disfavor. Third, it raises and addresses hermeneutical questions concerning the text's characterization of God and sketches some implicatinos for addressing these questions.


"Do I Lack Madmen That You Have Brought This Fellow to Rave for Me?" The Depiction of David's Feigned Madness (1 Samuel 21: 11–16) and Its Implications
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Naomi S. Jacobs, Durham University

The study of ancient depictions of 'madness' is frought with many of the same difficulties of any cross-cultural study. It is easy to fall in the trap of reading particular 'symptoms' and automatically linking them to a specific modern, Western diagnosis. 1 Sam. 21-11:16 is unusual in that (even more directly than Dan. 4) one is provided with an emic depiction of what the composer of the narrative clearly thought best exemplified 'madness'. The paper will comment upon the terminology used, on the motif of pretension of madness (e.g. Odysseus, Hamlet), and the broader function of the pericope in the story of David's rise.


"I Hear a Voice I Had Not Known": Multiple Speaking Voices in the Psalms
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Rolf Jacobson, Luther Seminary

In the psalms, frequent shifts in the implied voice or audience occur so commonly that one might identify these shifts as a rhetorical device. Similarly, the genre of certain psalms seems to switch in the middle of the poems wothout warning. Scholars have often tried to "solve" such shifts by positing historical life situations for the psalms that would make ense of dirrefent speakers, by positing mixed-type psalms, by re-dividing psalms. This paper resists such solutions and explores implications for interpreting the psalms that sees these switches as a literary-poetic device.


Onward Christian Soldiers: Religion as a Political Mobilizational Tool in Contemporary American Politics
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Khalil E. Jahshan, Pepperdine University, Seaver College

The use and abuse of religious imagery and symbols in politics, including American politics, is a well established historical fact. This paper will however endeavor to illustrate the growing tendency by American politicians to use religion to justify certain policies or political positions and mobilize public support for these policies. The paper will dwell on three main aspects of this relationship between the world of politics and the word of God:1. Is there anything new about the current mixing of religion and politics in American political life? 2. Many in the American religious establishment are willing partners in this emerging trend. Is the distinction between Church and State getting fuzzier in the 21st century? 3. Religion and politics have always been an explosive mixture. Unfortunately, however, religion is the weakest link in this formulation and is therefore more likely to get damaged again in the process.


Unraveling the Threefold Cord of Ecclesiastes
Program Unit: The Texts of Wisdom in Israel, Early Judaism, and the Eastern Mediterranean World
John Jarick, University of Oxford

The teachings presented in Ecclesiastes seem to go around in circles, with the writer returning again and again to the same places where his thoughts had taken him before. But if the various reiterated elements are gathered together, they can be set out in terms of a thesis ("all is vanity"), an antithesis ("eat, drink, and enjoy yourself") and a synthesis ("take hold of the one without letting go of the other"). An appreciation of this "threefold cord" that the writer has woven together leads to a better understanding of the dialogical dynamic within the book.


"As it is Written in the Prophets": The Use and Application of Prophetic Scripture in Qumran Legal Texts
Program Unit: Qumran
Alex Jassen, New York University

The Qumran community envisioned a progressive revelation of law beginning with Moses and finding its most recent expression among its own sectarian leaders. Whereas in rabbinic tradition in which the prophets function as the first group of post-Mosaic tradents of the Oral Torah (i.e., m. Abot 1:1), at Qumran the classical prophets are conceptualized as the second stage in the progressive revelation of law, whereby they amplify and supplement the Torah. For the Qumran community this provides an important methodological foundation regarding the importance of prophetic scriptural literature in sectarian legal hermeneutics. As prophets entrusted with the added task of lawgiving, the prophetic scriptural word is understood as a valid formulation of divine juridical desire. This model seemingly provides the background for the general tendency in Qumran legal texts to rely upon non-Pentateuchal prophetic sources as scriptural support for the establishment of post-biblical law. Scholarly assessment of the legal authority of prophetic scripture has ranged from the view that Qumran legal hermeneutics place equal legal force to Pentateuchal and non-Pentateuchal passages to the suggestion that non-Pentateuchal citations play a limited role in sectarian legal exegesis. In this paper, I gather together the legal uses of non-Pentateuchal scripture and examine the function of these citations. By drawing upon comparative Second Temple period legal material and rabbinic sources, I determine the exegetical role of the non-Pentateuchal passages and the nature of their application in the individual legal formulations. After looking more closely at the data, I offer some larger observations on the role of the ancient prophetic word in the legal system of the Qumran community. Finally, I call attention to the continuing traces of this debate in rabbinic tradition and ways in which the Qumran material can help frame this discussion.


Seeing the Image of the Invisible: Rhetography in the Epistle to the Colossians
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Roy R. Jeal, William and Catherine Booth College

"Rhetography," or the pictorial texture of texts, builds upon the insights of cognitive theorists that the mind's ability to "picture" what is spoken is essential to the cognitive processing of narrative and argument, and that these pictures, in turn, evoke social and cultural settings, patterns, and learned "logic" that nurture the argumentative force of the text. This paper will explore the rhetography of a passage from Colossians as a starting point for rhetorical analysis.


Herod Antipas in Galilee: Friend or Foe of the Historical Jesus?
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Morten Hoerning Jensen, University of Aarhus

The quest for the secrets of first century Galilee has become an issue of intense interest in recent research fuelling not least the at times heated debate about the cultural and socio-economic setting of the Historical Jesus. Especially a growing interest can be traced in Herod Antipas’ impact on the region’s socio-economic stability. Was he good or bad news for the ordinary rural peasant population and did his urbanization programme had a crucial impact on the Historical Jesus? No consensus has been reached and Antipas is presently being used as cornerstone in conflicting pictures of Galilee as being in good and stable conditions or under heavy economic pressure leading to increasing indebtedness and tenancy. Surprisingly, nevertheless, the reign of Antipas has only been treated incomprehensively the last three decades, since the dissertation of H. Hoehner from 1972, in which period intense archaeological activity has accumulated new insights on ancient Galilee. This presentation, building on a larger research investigation, therefore aims at surveying the sources to the reign of Antipas of both literary and archaeological nature in order to determine the socio-economic consequences hereof, and it will be argued that Antipas’ impact on early first century Galilee was most likely more moderate than many times assumed by Historical Jesus scholars.


Representations of Holy Sites in the Art of Late Antiquity
Program Unit: Christian Late Antiquity and Its Reception
Robin Jensen, Vanderbilt University

Depictions of holy sites commonly occur on funerary monuments, ivory plaques, reliquaries, and pilgrimage artifacts from the early fifth century onward. The iconographic presentations of various shrines on these objects not only gave tangible or concrete location to sacred narrative and presented a visual record of spiritual tourism, but also influenced the way that sacred places were imaginatively constructed and transmitted. For example, arguably the most important of such sites, the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem, was often represented as a small aedicula-type tomb with a gabled roof, and two partially opened doors – but in other instances shown quite differently, perhaps as a circular, open, colonnaded shrine. The degree to which any of these representations depicts an actual monument (or certain architectural details from some actual building) is a matter of debate. This paper, rather than trying to resolve the question of physical similitude, will focus on the way that architectural representation functioned symbolically, point out possible parallels on non-Christian Roman artifacts, consider the role of geographical site for anchoring a sacred narrative, and discuss the transmission of such architectural representation to different settings and circumstances.


Dining with the Dead in Late Roman Practice
Program Unit:
Robin Jensen, Vanderbilt University

*


Wrath and Violence in Paul's First and Last Letters (1 Thessalonians and Romans)
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Robert Jewett, University of Heidelberg

Does Paul change his view of divine wrath from 1 Thessalonians to Romans? Does he continue to think the same about believers resisting violence, and the non-violent co-existence of enemies? Is Romans 16.17-20 an interpolation which brings Paul's views back into line with 1 Thess 2.16?


Death at the Feast: Esther, Politics, and Purim
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Jannine Jobling, Liverpool Hope University

Allegedly established on the basis of the book of Esther, the feast of Purim is typically characterized by carnivalesque behaviour, role reversals, masquerading and excess. I examine some of the ways in which themes in the book of Esther are deployed in certain politically progressive contemporary interpretations and enactments of Purim, with particular attention to Purim’s underlying subversives notes. I approach this as one interested in the ways religious communities make use of scriptural and ritual resources to fund political agendas. Purim is used as a site for political resistances and subversions of various kinds. This analysis dialogues closely with the text of the book of Esther, intertwining a feminist and poststructuralist reading of it with a consideration of contemporary interpretations of Purim, and how these are performatively enacted. Examining Esther from this perspective, we can see it as embodying networks of power, identity and authority in the production of a carnivalesque satire. As I shall show, the desire for power, the inversion of power, and the exercise of power are dominant themes within the text - as also is the relationship of power to gendered and ethnic identity. And in Esther, we can see various networks of power and identity at play: the politics of gender, of ethnicity, of authority, of honour and of pleasure. Stalking this nexus of power plays is the politics of death. This is the ghost at the seemingly endless series of feasts.


Fidelity, Repression, and the Messianic: A Dialogue with the Pauline Secret
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Bradley Johnson, University of Glasgow

The paper is a dialogue between Pauline ethics and universality proposed respectively by Badiou and Žižek and rejected by Agamben. The dialogue concerns itself with the Pauline "secrets" (krupta) in Rom. 2.16 as the enabling condition for construing human activity as ethical. Here, because the value of human activity arises from the "secrets of the heart," the relation of (ethical) acts to their value is not available. The Pauline secret thus destabilizes any classification of behavior as either “good” or “bad.” In dialogue with Badiou, the secret describes the universal event of truth, inasmuch as the secret arises from the contingency of human activity and one's fidelity to it is the condition for living as an ethical subject. Žižek's sense of the secret presses Badiou’s fidelity into “struggle.” Here, though the truth/value of the secret emerges from the contingency of human activity and fidelity to it and is constitutive of subjectivity, what makes this truth/value universal is its inherent fragility. One is, then, most faithful to the secret, and to oneself as an ethical subject, only insofar as one remains loyal to the struggle and represses its resolution. Agamben, however, struggles with such claims of universality. Insofar as they highlight contingency and universality, he argues, such arguments miss Paul's point. In dialogue with Agamben, then, the Pauline secret is “messianic," and thus undermines its being particularized as an object or act. Here, the secret is inherently more (and less) than can be expressed in or by the ethical subject and act. Such then is the importance and vitality of the community of the secret, composed of those stripped of ethical identity and agency and who thus actualize the effects of the secret by living its inherent excessiveness and disruption.


The Jewish Feasts and Questions of Historicity in John 5–12
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Brian D. Johnson, Lincoln Christian College

The Jewish feasts mentioned in John 5-12 provide a thematic backdrop to the narrative’s action. The presentation of Jesus’ identity and his teaching allude to language and practices that are consistent with our understanding of the first century practice of these feasts. This paper will specifically examine what information these feasts give about the historicity of John’s presentation of Jesus. First, it will be suggested that the feasts can be understood as presenting a consistent chronology of Jesus’ ministry. The three accounts which mention the Passover are especially important for a reconstruction of the chronology of Jesus’ ministry. This paper will show that it is crucial to begin with the narrative purpose of the feasts as they are presented before attempting to understand any chronology they may present. Second, what does the Gospel of John’s strategy of using the Jewish feasts tell us about the historical setting relatively to the destruction of the Temple in CE 70? This paper will consider whether it is better to understand the accounts of Jesus’ actions at the feasts in light of the aftermath of the destruction of the Temple, or as recollections from before the destruction of the Temple. Third, this paper will build on Adele Reinhartz’ inquiry about “the Gospel of John as a potential source of knowledge of first-century Judaism” (Reinhartz 2005,110). Is the Gospel of John’s treatment of the Jewish feasts consistent with the trajectory of Jewish belief and practice throughout the Second Temple period?


Women and Glossolalia in Pauline Communities: The Relationship between Pneumatic Gifts and Authority
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Lee A. Johnson, Methodist Theological School in Ohio

The enthusiasm amongst feminist scholars for Paul's claim in Galatians 3.28 that began with Elizabeth Schussler Fiorenza's work continues to impact the vision of the place of women in the early Jesus movement. This paper seeks first to describe the ecstatic activity (glossolalia) of the Corinthian community by means of the social-scientific work of Felicitas Goodman on altered states of consciousness in various modern societies. Then, it will argue that Paul's relatively inclusive position towards the Corinthian women was compelled by their ability to engage in altered states of consciousness, and therefore their ability to "speak in tongues," somewhat in parallel with Philip Esler's work on tongues and the inclusion of the Gentiles. This thesis then challenges the position that the egalitarian ideal as stated in Galatians 3.28 was a foundational ethic for Paul, claiming rather that Paul's more traditional views of women were challenged by the ecstatic activity of the Corinthian women, which he interpreted as the work of the Holy Spirit.


Creative Problem Solving in Job
Program Unit: Poster Session
Michael Johnson, Buffalo State College

This poster shows the first application of a contemporary theory of creativity to the ancient Hebrew text that epitomizes the surprising resolution of an overwhelming tragedy, while raising major theological issues. Analyzing the text in terms of creativity theory puts these longstanding concerns in better perspective, while other issues emerge and receive their due at last. One theoretical approach to the formal study of human creativity (Rhodes, 1961) and a recent monograph that develops and applies it (Isaksen, 2000) underlie this new analysis of the book of Job. The poster applies the theory to the cardinal strands of the Job drama as a paradigm for wise behavior that encompasses social, practical, moral, and aesthetic concerns: in broader, albeit less familiar terms, these are the parameters for the positive exercise of creativity. An overview of the whole book shows how its structure is consonant with four basic questions that embody distinct facets of the formal study of human creativity. In terms of the “Four P’s” of the theory, those (concurrent) questions investigate what may be the best ‘Press’ (context), the most effective Process, the prerequisite Personal traits, and some useful criteria for appraising the Products of creativity. One by one the succeeding quarters of the text speak to these topics. The book of Job is concerned with more than an attempt to justify the ways of God to man: it also considers how humans, made distinctively creative in God’s image, are to justify themselves to their Creator.


Dalit Biblical Interpretation: A Paradigm Shift in Indian Christian Hermeneutics
Program Unit: Asian and Asian-American Hermeneutics
Rajkumar Boaz Johnson, North Park University Theological Seminary

Biblical interpretation in India, according to students of Indian Christian Theology, is going through a substantial paradigm shift. Until recently, there were two modes of thought which formed the framework of biblical interpretation in India. First, there was the colonial framework, espoused by those theologians who were trained in western methodology. Second, there was the brahamanical framework, which was espoused by a powerful group of theologians who came from the dominant caste of Hindu society. In more recent times Dalit theologians are getting a refreshing hearing. Dalit interpretation of the Bible seeks to interpret the Bible from the perspective of Pre-colonial, Pre-Hindu times. This paper will seek to explore the various dimensions of Dalit interpretation of the Bible, as found in the writings an increasing number of voices. These include brave theologians like Maria Arul Raja, Dhyanchand Carr, and V. V. Devasahayam, among others. It will seek to show how Dalit biblical interpretation is distinct from western methodology, as well as, brahamanical Indian methodology. Dalit methodology seems to be closely akin to Jewish intertextuality of Late Antiquity.


Women's Religious Experience in the Greek World
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Sarah Iles Johnston, The Ohio State University

This paper concretizes the strategies which Amy Hollywood proposes in her paper, "Strategies for the Study of Women's Religious Experience," by analyzing select aspects of women's religious experience in the Greek world. This study complements other papers in the session, Women's Religious Experience in Antiquity, including Patricia Ahearne-Kroll’s "The Portrayal of Aseneth's Religious Experience in ‘Joseph and Aseneth’” and John R. Levison's "Eve's Religious Experience in the Greek Life of Adam and Eve."


Narrating the End of the World: The Social and Psychological Function of Apocalyptic Literature
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Brian C. Jones, Wartburg College

Apocalyptic narratives offer socially marginalized groups a "world" wherein social dislocation is both understandable and commendable. Within such narratives, meaning and value for the marginalized is conferred by their membership within a community of the faithful whose identity is presently hidden and whose true meaning will be revealed at a divinely appointed hour. Suffering, both physical and psychic, is brought within a temporal framework by means of narrative and is thereby limited and given meaning by virtue of a projected telos. The power of the social bonding in such communities is demonstrated by their ability to survive the repeated failure of their predictions of the end of the world. The accuracy of the group's predictions is finally less important than the experience of fellowship. The fellowship, however, is in large part sustained by a keen expectation of the end, and the need for precise predictions to maintain the psychic intensity within the group is sufficiently pressing that new dates are set very soon after previous predictions have failed. The bonds of community in such groups need not be understood as oppressive and controlling, as is sometimes asserted. Nor is the metaphor "brainwashing" especially helpful. The potent social bond in apocalyptic groups is the result of the power of apocalyptic narrative to create a cohesive communal identity and intense fellowship and to underwrite self-sacrifice for the sake of the group. Group membership is solidified not through coercion but through the re-reading of the apocalyptic narrative and the interpretive mapping of the community into that narrative. Specific examples in the paper will be drawn from the history of communities formed by apocalyptic narratives, especially the Millerites.


Refocusing the Stories of the Kings: Identity Formation in the Books of Chronicles
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Louis C. Jonker, University of Stellenbosch

In a paper presented at the SBL International Meeting in 2005, I have proposed that the Books of Chronicles should be seen as "Reforming History". The ambiguity of the expression is intentional, indicating that the Books of Chronicles are simultaneously an attempt to reformulate and sanitize the older traditions about the past, as well as an attempt to reformulate the identity of God's people in the changed socio-historical circumstances of the late Persian era. This proposal contributes to the ongoing debate on the nature of Chronicles (which was also reflected in the discussion of two recent Chronicle commentaries – by Knoppers and McKenzie – at the 2005 SBL Annual Meeting). My present contribution will present more textual support for my proposal. My paper will discuss a number of the more crucial royal narratives in Chronicles in order to show how the communicative intention of these narratives was refocused from their Deuteronomistic versions. It will be shown how slight changes in the narrative structures resulted into a literature which shows continuity with the past, but also subtly contributes to a process of identity formation in the present of the late Persian era.


"Blessed is Whoever is Not Offended by Me": The Subversive Appropriation of Messianic Ideology in Q 3–7
Program Unit: Q
Simon J. Joseph, Claremont Graduate University

Jesus is never explicitly identified as the “messiah” or christos in Q. The conspicuous absence of this particular term—so frequently used in the Pauline letters and the Gospels—is often taken to mean that the Q community was uninterested in, unaware of and/or rejected kerygmatic traditions which understood Jesus as a “messianic” figure. Yet a careful analysis of the literary structure of Q 3-7 suggests that the redactor of Q both appropriated and subverted “traditional messianic expectations” of a popular warrior-king by framing Jesus’ baptism, temptation and Inaugural Sermon within announcement and confirmation passages that serve to both affirm and qualify Jesus’ relationship to “messianic” traditions. Located within a text dominated by the theme of eschatological reversal, the literary structure of Q 3-7 thus serves as a rhetorical apology in the redactor’s construction of a new identity for Jesus and the Q community.


A Little Spark, A Large Fire: The Acceptance and Spread of Arianism in the Fourth Century
Program Unit: Manichaean Studies
Kevin Kaatz, Macquarie University

Socrates Scholasticus, an historian writing a history of the church of the 4th and early 5th Century, stated that the beliefs of Arius spread and from a “little spark a large fire was kindled” (Eccl. Hist. I.6) throughout Egypt and parts of North Africa. He also stated that it spread because of Eusebius, the bishop of Nicomedia. It was Eusebius of Nicomedia who baptized Emperor Constantine at the end of his life and after his death, his son Constantius remained an Arian, while his two brothers, Constantine II and Constans, both remained Nicene or Catholic. Eusebius was a tireless supporter of Arius and his form of Christianity. We will examine the acceptance and spread of Arianism, mostly focusing on Eusebius of Nicomedia. Because of his efforts, Arianism spread not only in the East of the Roman Empire, but also north beyond its boundaries. This form of Christianity would come back into the Empire as these northern peoples traveled into the Roman West.


Paul at Nag Hammadi
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Michael Kaler, Universite Laval

Over a decade after its publication, Craig Evans’ Nag Hammadi Texts and the Bible: A Synopsis and Index (Leiden: Brill, 1993) remains a research tool of great value for those investigating the ways in which the authors of the Nag Hammadi texts used the New Testament. Thirteen years later, however, there is a need for it to be supplemented so as to take into account more recent findings, new editions, and so on. The purpose of this paper is to discuss the current state of the question in terms of the use of Pauline material among the Nag Hammadi texts, and to suggest modifications of or additions to Evans’ lists.


Monsters and Theology in the Book of Jeremiah
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Amy Kalmanofsky, Jewish Theological Seminary of America

Prophets employ a rhetoric of horror in order to convince their audience to reform their evil behavior. The prophet Jeremiah describes a monstrous enemy that approaches from the North to devour sinful Israel. No less monstrous is the image of wounded Israel, as the victims' bodies become food for the birds and beasts. Using horror theory, this paper examines the monsters of the book of Jeremiah and considers their rhetorical impact. Horror theorists Noel Carroll, Julia Kristeva, and Barbara Creed provide useful criteria for identifying and analyzing Jeremiah's monsters. In the book of Jeremiah, two distinct monstrous figures emerge--God the aggressor and Israel the vanquished. Careful examination reveals how the monsters of Jeremiah reflect the peculiar position of the prophet who stands between God and the people and the power of his rhetoric to address both. Monstrous Israel serves to warn Israel of what will happen if they do not reform. Monstrous God terrifies Israel, but also demonstrates the extent of God's anger and cruelty and works to modify God's behavior. The monsters of Jeremiah reveal God's power and the power of the prophet to affect God.


The “Word/Law” in James as the Promised New Covenant
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Mariam Kamell, University of St. Andrews

Often when discussing “law” in the NT, scholars gravitate to Paul, perhaps granting James a cursory look since he seemingly contradicts Paul (see, e.g., Sanders, Dunn, Wright). But before James introduces his (in)famous “faith and works” discussion in chapter two, he already discussed “hearing and doing” in relation to the word/law. It is my belief that a proper understanding of the word/law is crucial for interpreting James’ further imperatives and can be explained within a Jewish setting without looking further abroad for Greco-Roman philosophical links. James took prophecies of a “new covenant” (e.g., Jer. 31:31-34), texts that speak about righteousness or wisdom “rooted” in the heart (e.g., Sira 1:20; 4 Ezra 8:6; 1QHa XVI (VIII).10b-11a), and Psalms in praise of the law (e.g., 19; 119) and interpreted them in light of the Christ event. Oddly, these backgrounds have not been fully probed for how they can clarify James’ theology. James writes to a group of people who have had God’s “word implanted” within them, a “word” equated with the “law of freedom.” Tracing through the Jewish literature, we find a thread of promise that someday God’s law would be innate within his people. Allowing James to stand in the textual tradition moves his message of “faith and works” into a possible relationship with the theory of covenantal nomism. The gift and the requirement are united and James proclaims the fulfillment of all that has preceded: God’s eschatological time has come, the law is implanted, therefore actions reveal whether a person is part of the eschatological community. Thus the thread of promise elucidates James’ law as the Torah, interpreted and taught by Jesus, which now brings freedom and life as it becomes a part of believers’ very nature.


God of All the World: Universalism and Developing Monotheism in Isaiah 40-66
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Joel S. Kaminsky, Smith College

The relationship between the people of Israel, the Gentile nations, and YHWH, Israel's God, remains a central question in modern Jewish-Christian dialogue. Second Isaiah's description of Israel as a "covenant to the people, a light to the nations" has often been cited as evidence of a universal missionary impulse. Yet the larger context of 2nd and 3rd Isaiah, focused on the central themes of Israel's divine election and impending redemption, contains little interest in conversion of the nations. Rather, the nations are invoked as part of the universal exaltation of Israel's God. While the nations facilitate Israel's return and acknowledge the sovereignty of her God, they are not the recipients of an organized mission. Howevr, Second Isaiah's denial of the existence of foreign gods, challenging the views of Deuteronomy and DtrH which accorded some level of legitimacy to the gods of the other nations, has implications for the status of foreigners vis-a-vis Israel's God. In the latest pieces of 3rd Isaiah, 56 and 66, one finds Gentiles turning towards Israel's God in worship, not simply in acknowledgement of his exalted status.


Social Location and Formation in 4QInstruction
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
John Kampen, Methodist Theological School in Ohio

The nature of the particular circles in which the composition known as Instruction could find its origin and/or initial hearing and study remains an important issue. The particular relationship of these “non-sectarian” texts to one another and to those regarded as more explicitly sectarian remains the subject of considerable speculation. Through the comparsion of this composition with other works such as 1 Enoch and Ben Sira, works which have received considerable more attention with regard to the study of issues related to identity and social location, this paper proposes hints toward a social context for its initial composition and usage. Due to the prominence of this composition as represented in the number of extant mss. in the Qumran corpus, an analysis of its use and meaning within these contexts provides further hints for this proposal. Such an analysis provides the basis for identifying this composition’s particular role in the “social history” surrounding that literary corpus. Such an examination is considered an essential contribution to the development of a more comprehensive viewpoint on the nature of wisdom in Second Temple Judaism.


The Jewish Source in the Ascension of Isaiah
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Magnar Kartveit, School of Mission & Theology, Misjonshogskolen i Stavanger, Norway

James R. Davila, The Provenance of the Pseudepigrapha: Jewish, Christian or other?, states on p. 78 that the Ascension of Isaiah was "composed by a Christian in Greek in the second century, although it may incorporate an earlier Jewish source." The paper discusses the different attempts at delineating such a source, and the methods used in these attempts. The methodological proposals of Davila, pp. 64-66, are taken into consideration for AscIs. It is suggested that the Jewish part of the material in AscIs, unlike its parallels in the Talmud, reveals an anti-Samaritan bias. A further criterion for finding the Jewish origins of Old Testament pseudepigrapha transmitted by Christians is therefore proposed: the presence of Jewish polemics.


Project on the Textual History of 1 Samuel: Traces of the Proto-Lucianic Text
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Tuukka Kauhanen, University of Helsinki

Whether agreements between the Lucianic text and patristic quotations before Lucian’s time represent proto-Lucianic recension or original Septuagint is one of the classic questions concerning textual criticism of Samuel-Kings. If it is a question of the original Septuagint in some of these agreements, then B and the majority of manuscripts must be in error, either corrupt or revised to accord with the Hebrew text. The positions of, for instance, Dominique Barthélemy, Frank Moore Cross, and Emanuel Tov are very far from each other. The study of the proto-Lucianic readings should not, however, be restricted to those cases where external support is found in pre-Lucianic sources. The proto-Lucianic basis of the recension is certainly also visible in other readings, possibly following similar patterns. But how are these to be recognized? A meticulous analysis of those Lucianic variants that are not obviously recensional is called for.


Covenant and Contingence: The Historical Encounter between God and Israel
Program Unit: Bible, Myth, and Myth Theory
Robert S. Kawashima, New York University

Enuma Elish concludes with the founding of Babylon as the "center of religion" and the construction of Marduk's temple-home in its midst. It both establishes a mythic (eternal, necessary) relation between Marduk and his sacred abode and simultaneously creates a mythic relationship between Marduk and the Babylonians, who are created into an eternally fixed cosmic station, service of the gods. The Law Code of Hammurabi contributes to the same general picture. Hammurabi places his divine calling as king at the time Anu and Enlil "allotted supreme power over all peoples to the god Marduk," that is, at the time of creation. His law code, part of his mythic appointment as "pious prince, who venerates the gods, to make justice prevail in the land" spells out the principles of this justice enjoined upon his subjects. Biblical traditions deal with similar concerns, but due to Israel's "historical consciousness," it could not take its relation to Yahweh for granted. It is premised instead on a historical (temporal, contingent) encounter—one that takes place, as Lacan emphasized, "as if by chance." This encounter—or better, several encounters—is therefore conceived of as a covenant, a human political form—which in contrast to Hammurabi's reign, is established in human time. Thus, Yahweh and his people meet initially as foreign (alienated) parties. The contingent nature of their encounter and of the relationship they forge finds expression in the marked importance of apodictic law in their covenant: the divine "I" addresses a mortal "you." This is the encounter Althusser designates "interpellation": authority ("I") addresses and thereby constitutes its subject ("you"). As a result, biblical traditions usher in a new concept of human subjectivity, a contingent, historical subject not determined by a mythic cosmic station.


From Eschatology to Ethics and Back Again: The Coming Son of Man Revisited
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Thomas Kazen, Stockholm School of Theology

The history of interpretation of the synoptic Son of Man is a formidable swamp. There is no consensus coming up. One of the most interesting suggestions, however, is the “corporate” or collective interpretation of Manson, Moule and Gaston. This trajectory has been somehow left by the wayside, but it has certain advantages. It can be given a form that respects both the basic “generic” sense of an underlying Semitic expression and the Danielic kingdom imagery, without denying this expression for the historical Jesus. A collective interpretation makes it possible to ascribe not only present, but also suffering, and even coming Son of Man sayings, to the historical Jesus. This necessitates a particular kingdom eschatology, however, focusing not on an individual redeemer figure, but on the present manifestation of the Kingdom in community practice. The present paper attempts to demonstrate the plausibility for such an interpretation and discusses some suggestions for how a collective and “ethical” coming Son of Man could “mutate” so quickly into the idea of a second coming of Christ.


Operation Infinite Justice: The Righteousness of God in Paul
Program Unit: Pauline Theology
Sylvia C. Keesmaat, Institute for Christian Studies

*


Echoes, Ethics, and Empire in Colossians
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Sylvia C. Keesmaat, Institute for Christian Studies

*


Jesus and Hoi Grammateis: Scribal Literacy in John 7 and the Pericope Adulterae
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Chris Keith, University of Edinburgh

One of the most enigmatic pieces of tradition in the New Testament is the Pericope Adulterae. Further, within that story, Jesus’ action of writing has been a particularly salient object of scholarly speculation. This paper argues that, though PA is not original to John, it was inserted into the text originally at John 7.53 – 8.11 in order to provide an example of Jesus with an equivalent level of scribal literacy (if not a superior level) to his opponents. Displaying sensitivity to the narrative context, this addition to the Johannine text comments upon the efforts of the Jewish leadership and ‘the crowd’ to identify Jesus and establish his qualifications as a teacher in John 7. Scholarly speculation on the content of Jesus’ writing in the pericope has obscured both the fact that this is the sole location in the Jesus tradition where (kata)grapho is attached to Jesus and the connection of this claim with John 7.


Ethnography and Food: Interpreting the Diet of John the Baptist in the Gospel of Mark
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
James A. Kelhoffer, Saint Louis University

Oftentimes with little (or no) argument or historical analogy to support their interpretations, scholars have maintained that John the Baptist’s “locusts and wild honey” (Mark 1:6||Matt 3:4) highlight John as prophet, wilderness dweller, ascetic or ‘vegetarian.’ This paper focuses on the depiction of John’s food in the gospel of Mark. (The author has argued elsewhere that the possible meaning(s) of “locusts and wild honey” for the historical Baptist and the author of Matthew may have been different than that in Mark.) Hellenistic and Roman ethnographic depictions of ‘foreign’ locust eaters shed light on the interpretation of Mark 1:6. In particular, the descriptions of an Ethiopian locust-eating people by Diodorus Siculus (who may draw from earlier accounts by Agatharchides of Cnidus and/or Aristophanes of Byzantium), Strabo, and the Elder Pliny denote a connection between eating locusts and a proximity to the wilderness. These ethnographic depictions of ‘foreign’ locust eaters who live near the wilderness support the inference that the author of Mark has an analogous purpose of associating the Baptist with the wilderness through the foods John found in the desert. The Greco-Roman authors and texts discussed in the paper are of interest to scholars of Early Christianity, since they introduce to their audiences the culinary, clothing and cosmetic habits of numerous ancient peoples. The paper also suggests that ancient conceptions of food and culture merit additional attention in studies of early Christian self-definition.


Future Directions for the Study of Warfare in Ancient Israel
Program Unit: Warfare in Ancient Israel
Brad E. Kelle, Point Loma Nazarene University

A brief presentation of potentially fruitful future directions for the study of warfare in ancient Israel.


Democracy and Its Apocalypses
Program Unit: Character Ethics and Biblical Interpretation
Catherine Keller, Drew University

*


Caesarea in the Early Roman Period: Jews, Pagans, Christians
Program Unit: Archaeological Excavations and Discoveries: Illuminating the Biblical World
Kenneth G. Holum, University of Maryland

*


The Weighing of the Soul in Late Antique Art and Literature
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Meira Kensky, University of Chicago

This paper explores the literary and visual iconography of the psychostasia in Late Antique art and literature, focusing on the use of this motif in early Christianity. It is the contention of this paper that only by paying attention to the divergent uses of the motif in the literary sources alongside the archaeological and artistic evidence can we begin to understand the potency and flexibility of this imagery to different theological, cultic, and artistic purposes. Special attention will be paid to the Testament of Abraham and related apocalypses, as well as to the question of how a motif originally associated with post-mortem individual judgment became incorporated so frequently into depictions of the Final Judgment, both literary and visual.


Agrippa I and Alexandria: Diaspora Champion or Typical Roman Elite?
Program Unit: Josephus
Allen Kerkeslager, Saint Joseph's University

At one time it was common to describe the Judean king Marcus Julius Agrippa I as a defender of Jewish religious traditions. Contradictory evidence was accommodated by expressing skepticism about Agrippa's personal piety. In the last few decades support for this view of Agrippa has eroded. Scholarship has developed greater sensitivity to the source-critical problems, rhetorical agendas, and finer details of the ancient literary portraits of Agrippa. More attention also has been given to Agrippa's family heritage, his upbringing in Rome, his coins, his building projects, and other clues to his cultural priorities. As a result, Agrippa's proclivities increasingly appear much more typical of any other Hellenized elite who grew up in Rome and shared a similar mixture of Idumaean and Judean (and perhaps Phoenician) ancestry. But it also has become increasingly apparent that his interests were fundamentally Roman. In spite of these developments, scholars continue to assert that Agrippa acted as a champion for the beleaguered Judeans of Alexandria in the conflicts associated with his visit to the city in 38 CE. Through a survey of the evidence in Philo, Josephus, papyri, and other sources, this paper will demonstrate that Agrippa stubbornly refused to take on such a role. Agrippa's concern was to diminish the threat that these conflicts posed to his own privileged status in the Roman administration. This conclusion complements previous articles that have argued that the catalyst for the most devastating phase of the violence in 38 was a Judean crime against Rome.


Envisioning the Nilotic Landscape in Rabbinic Midrash and in Selected Paintings at the National Gallery of Art
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Rivka B. Kern-Ulmer, Bucknell University

I propose to examine the appearance of the Nilotic landscape in texts and in visual art. The Nile was equivalent to Egypt and the river was a major contributor to the development of Egyptian religion, culture and civilization, and it defined the Egyptian landscape. In both Judaism and Christianity Egypt and the Nilotic landscape are remembered as (1) the location of the biblical Exodus as well as (2) a place of refuge. The rabbis who created midrash "painted" scenes of Egypt and the Nile in their bible interpretations. Furthermore, midrash engaged in polemical descriptions of the Egyptian landscape, which was viewed as the landscape of the Other, although essential elements of the conceptual world of Egypt maintained their presence in midrash through the end of the era of midrashic activity in medieval Europe. The rabbis updated or integrated the memory of the Nilotic landscape with transcendental notions of the Nile and its waters. Generally, the depictions of the Nile in Christian paintings from the 16th/17th centuries are characterized by both the brevity of the narrative and the paucity of details. The artists rarely linger on the poetics of the Nilotic landscape; rather, the artists quickly proceed to the topographical meanings of the landscape which is integrated into the familiar European landscape. I will focus upon the depictions of the Nile in "The Rest on the Flight into Egypt" (c. 1510) by Gerard David; "The Finding of Moses" (c. 1570) by Veronese; and "The Finding of Moses" by Sébastien Bourdon (1616-1671). The ideological distance from Egypt that is manifest in these paintings is overcome by a modern painter, Marc Chagall (1887-1985), who utilizes midrashic motifs in his interpretations of the Egyptian landscape.


“If Anyone is Holy…” Didache 10.6 in the Light of Halakah
Program Unit: Didache in Context
Taras Khomych, Katholieke Universiteit, Leuven

The meal celebration described in Didache 9-10 has received a lot of scholarly attention. Until now, however, students of the Didache have not reached consensus about the nature and the form of this celebration. In this ongoing debate verse 10.6, more specifically, the admonitions: “If anyone is holy, let him come. If anyone is not, let him repent”, play a particularly important role. The scholarly opinion is divided into two groups: whether this passage introduces or concludes the eucharistic celebration. While defending the latter view, this contribution seeks to shed some more light on understanding this controversial passage by pointing out its connection with the Two Ways section of the Didache. This interpretation is further supported by several parallels between Didache 10.6, on the one hand, and the Jewish halakik literature as well as relevant early Christian sources, on the other.


“Cruciformity” or “Cosmoformity”? From the “Theological” to the “Classical” Virtues in the Pastoral Epistles
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Reggie McReynolds Kidd, Reformed Theological Seminary

Commenting on Titus 1:1-2 at a Disputed Paulines session (Orlando, 1998), Abraham Malherbe said that one of the things that troubles him about the Pastorals is the way they transform the apostle of ‘faith, hope, and love’ into an advocate of ‘faith, hope, and godliness’ (‘love’ being displaced by ‘godliness’). I’d like to explore the question of how we get from the approach to the (traditionally dubbed) theological virtues (‘faith, hope, and love’) in the homologoumena to the (traditionally dubbed) classical virtues (‘prudence/piety, justice, temperance, and courage’) in the Pastorals. Is there a shift in tone from the homologoumena to the Pastorals? If so, should it be judged a trajectory of Paul’s call to “cruciformity,” a translation of his ethical vision into terms meaningful in new believers’ social world? or a descent into worldliness, into “cosmoformity”? To shed light on the question, I intend to bring into consideration: 1) the work of Thomist philosopher Josef Pieper (who juxtaposes the ‘theological’ virtues and the ‘classical’ virtues in his two volumes, Faith, Hope, Love and The Four Cardinal Virtues); 2) the work of Michael Gorman (Cruciformity: Paul’s Narrative Spirituality of the Cross and Apostle of the Crucified Lord: A Theological Introduction to Paul & His Letters), whose treatment of ‘cruciformity’ in Paul draws largely from the homologoumena; and 3) the Acts of Paul and Thecla, as they offer an alternative vision of Paul’s ethical vision (as suggested by Dennis Ronald MacDonald [The Legend and the Apostle]).


Visions of Biblical Jerusalem Past and Present in Text, Archaeology, and Legend
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Ann E. Killebrew, Pennsylvania State University

This paper examines three visions of Jerusalem: the archaeological remains of a Bronze and Iron Age Jerusalem; the Holy City as presented in the Hebrew Scriptures; and the Jerusalem of song and legend as understood in its modern context. Can these three cities co-exist? Is it possible to find a biblical Jerusalem in its archaeological ruins? What are the implications of 21st century scholarly attempts to reconstruct an archaeologically and historically based Jerusalem?


Reading Hebrews in Light of the Targum: The Combined Concept of House and Rest in Hebrews 3–4 and Targum Psalm 95
Program Unit: Hebrews
Daniel Eunseung Kim, University of Aberdeen

In recent research, many have begun to compare the Epistle to the Hebrews to different branches of Judaism, and some have even found a few points of contact with the Targum. This paper investigates one possible parallel with the Targum in the author’s use of Ps 95. Virtually all who research Ps 95 in Hebrews do not consider the text immediately prior to the quote (3:1-6) in understanding the citation, despite the fact that 3:1-6 is structurally harmonious to the rest of the chapter. Presumably, this is because 3:1-6 (dealing with house/sanctuary) seems to be thematically divergent from the main idea of the psalm and the exposition following (dealing with “rest”). In light of TgPss 95, however, it appears that there was an accepted theology that conglomerated the ideas of rest and house/sanctuary. In the OT, even a brief glance reveals that a combined concept of rest and house began to emerge toward the latter stages of the OT literary period. Hence, both Hebrews and the Targum encapsulate a shared theology found originally in the OT.


Whose Voice Is This? Some Literary Implications for the Speaker’s Identity in Proverbs 8:32–36
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Hee Suk Kim, Trinity International University

Recent scholarship on Proverbs 1-9 has increasingly emphasized hermeneutical issues in the study of this section’s key metaphorical figures, such as Lady Wisdom, Lady Folly, etc. In this paper, I will argue that the change of literary voices in Proverbs 8:32-36 conclusively reinforces the invaluable nature of Lady Wisdom in Proverbs 8—as this passage is placed before Proverbs 9, where the reader is called to choose between Lady Wisdom and Lady Folly. The paper will be structured as follows: I. Relevant literature will be examined to highlight some principal debates related to Proverbs 1-9. II. The literary change of voices in 8:32-36 will be investigated exegetically, especially with respect to its co-text in Proverbs 8. III. Proverbs 3:13-18 and 7:24-27 will then be examined in greater detail, to argue that in alluding to these prior passages, Proverbs 8:32-36 intends to further radicalize the contrast between life and death. IV. Finally, the implication of the change of voices in 8:32-36 will be probed in relationship to Proverbs 9. I will mainly contend that this literary phenomenon enables Lady Wisdom to present herself in chapter 9 as the right choice for the path of wisdom.


Intertextual Time Capsule of Luke 4:16–30: The Import of Luke’s Two Significant Intertextual Additions for Understanding the Lukan Agenda
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Heerak Christian Kim, University of Cambridge

Luke 4:16-30 – often referred to as “Jesus’ Preaching in Nazareth” – is thought to be central to understanding the writings of Luke. Its import for the gospel tradition is evident in its attestation in other synoptic gospels (Matthew 13:53-58 and Mark 6:1-6a). What is significant in Luke’s pericope are the two Lukan additions; namely, Luke 4:17-21 and Luke 4:25-27. I would argue that these two additions shed invaluable light on Lukan theology and the use of the Old Testament in Luke. Luke 4:17-21 contains a quotation of Isaiah 61:1-2 and Isaiah 58:6. Morna D. Hooker writes: “The quotation follows that LXX of Isaiah 61, but omits one phrase (‘to heal the broken-hearted”) and includes another (‘to set at liberty those who are oppressed’) taken from Isa. 58.6; this minor variation is probably of no great significance” (“Beginning with Moses and from all the Prophets,” p. 222). I would argue that the variation is, in fact, very significant and points out the intertextual relationship between Luke and the Hebrew Bible. The addition betrays the perspective of a post-70 Christian interpretation of the antecedent Hebrew Bible. This intertextual Tendenz in Luke is confirmed in the second large addition in the Luke 4:16-30 pericope. Luke 4:25-27 does not contain a direct quote. However, it contains a strategic explication of antecedent Hebrew Bible traditions of Elijah and Elisha. This Lukan addition illustrates again a post-70 Christian interest in the use of antecedent Hebrew Bible texts. Containing both the use of quotes and paraphrase of Hebrew Bible antecedent texts, Luke 4:16-30 opens the door to understanding intertextuality in Luke and provides a window view into the direction of New Testament intertextuality.


Beloved as the Source of Redemption: Toni Morrison’s Contribution to the Phenomenon of Scripturalization
Program Unit: African-American Biblical Hermeneutics
Heerak Christian Kim, University of Cambridge

I am convinced that more conjunctive studies must be done on the concept of scripturalization as a phenomenon. This will help us better understand “scripture” and its relationship to the community which values it. There are shared traits in the scripturalization process of diverse communities throughout history as comparative religions scholars and anthropologists have shown. It is my argument that understanding the concept of scripturalization in the African-American community will help better understand scripturalization in ancient societies, including that of the earliest Christians. In this paper, I will explain the process of scripturalization in Toni Morrison’s “Beloved” with the understanding that there is active scripturalization in form and content of the literary work. I will particularly focus on the character of Beloved and her redemptive role. I would assert that Professor Morrison utilizes the genre elements of “horror” and “the fantastic” effectively to present Beloved as a source of redemption. Tzvetan Todorv’s The Fantastic: A Structural Approach to a Literary Genre and Rosemary Jackson’s Fantasy, the Literature of Subversion will serve in the identification of genre elements of horror and the fantastic. I will argue that Beloved’s redemptive role is significant in light of African-American history of slavery and oppression. Understanding the way Beloved functions in the scripturalization process will shed light on the phenomenon of scripturalization. Based on this paper, presented at the Society of Biblical Literature meeting in 2006, I intend to show at the following Society of Biblical Literature meeting in 2007 how this opens the door to better understanding of scripturalization in the New Testament.


Hybrid but Fatherless: A Reading of Jesus' Birth from a Postcolonial Context
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Jean K. Kim, Moravian Theological Seminary

If the virgin birth is not a historic event, what alternatives are there to explain the stories about the origin of Jesus? Through a deconstructive reading of biblical accounts regarding Jesus’ birth and life from a postcolonial perspective, this paper proposes that Jesus was born out of wedlock, possibly between Mary and a Roman soldier when Rome attacked at Sepphoris. As the son of Mary, possibly from a priestly family, the mamzer Jesus develops his hybrid/impure/mixed identity into a site of resistance, and eventually as a site of empowerment for the powerless. In a socio-historical context where unwanted children were cast out, Jesus’ conspicuous blessing of the children can be understood as his defense of fatherless children against social stratification in first century Jewish society. Just as many children were abandoned or outcast in first century Palestine, many Amerasian children today are cast out as street children (“children of the dust”), and their existence in our society is denied. By identifying the little children that Jesus blesses with “children of the dust” born to Asian women and US GIs during/after wars in Asia, this paper raises an issue of moral responsibility for the long-ignored “children of the dust,” and also invites us to participate in building God’s household to which they can belong.


A Syntactic-Analytic New Testament Greek Study with a Newly Promoted Pedagogical Consideration
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Sang-Hoon Kim , Chongshin University

The New Testament Greek has been for long a compulsory or pre-requisite subject in the theological seminary for the prospective ministers for the Christian churches. However, it has still remained so much heavy burden of unmanageable and insurmountable tool to most of the ordinary students in the seminaries. They have tried to learn, as hard as they can, and also to utilize it in their ministries, as possible as they can But unfortunately, most of them have failed to keep their ability to use the Greek after their graduation from the seminaries, as we who are called the teachers of the New Testament Greek, have observed with much pains. What is the problem? Are there useful tools to be re-invented or re-adjusted for this purpose so as to solve that current problem of the pedagogical method in the practical teaching-learning process of the New Testament Greek? We may say that the applied syntactic-semantic studies on the biblical texts from the modern linguistic point of view has, in some measure, contributed to this field. The biblical scholars with this linguistic perspective such as J. Louw, D. Stuart, W. Kaiser, G. Fee, W. Mounce, and others are the significant contributors as well as the initiatives and representatives in this area. But can we say that their efforts are sufficient in realizing to serve our students’ needs regarding the Greek? Is there any additional or re-adjusted, methodological consideration in setting-up the pedagogical modules of interpretive process on the Greek texts of the Bible? It is always necessary that all the methods of interpretation or pedagogy are properly evaluated, applied, revised, and readjusted for the practical purpose. The researcher is going to present a newly promoted, readjusted, syntactic-analytic Greek study model which has been actually taught to my students for many years.


The Problem of Jewish Christianity or How to Represent the Diversity of Early Christianity
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Karen L. King, Harvard University

The category of Jewish-Christianity has been notoriously difficult to define precisely, especially with regard to reconstructing the social history of ancient groups from literary texts. This paper suggests: 1) that the category has functioned more specifically with regard to representing the problem of early Christian diversity in terms of orthodoxy and heresy than in locating particular ancient social groups or in marking ambiguities in “the parting of the ways”; 2) that shifting the discussion of early Christian diversity from essentializing reifications to the analysis of practices of identity formation would put the discussion of the relationship between Judaism and Christianity on a sounder footing. The paper offers a brief history of the scholarship and contexts that domesticated the notion of early Christian diversity” and illustrates the proposed alternative approach through consideration of diverse ancient sources.


Critical Reflections on the Revival of Oral Q
Program Unit: Q
Alan Kirk, James Madison University

The turn to orality in gospel studies has been accompanied by the appearance of fresh attempts to absorb the double-tradition materials partly or wholly into oral dynamics. While affirming the crucial importance of the systematic engagement of gospels scholarship with oral tradition research, this paper develops some criticisms of some recent attempts, e.g. by James D. G. Dunn and others, to assimilate Q materials to oral processes. It draws upon research on orality, scribality, manuscript culture, and cultural memory to suggest a way forward in the study of orality and the history of the gospel traditions.


O Father, Where Art Thou? The God-Behind-the-Scenes in Cohen Brothers' Films
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
J. R. Daniel Kirk, Biblical Seminary

In two recent films Joel and Ethan Coen have transposed a previously-told story into the key of Southern American gospel culture. "O Brother, Where Art Thou?" (2000) retells Homer's Odyssey and "Lady Killers" (2003) is a remake of a 1955 film by the same name. In both films the transposition entails recasting the experiences of the main characters in a way that demonstrates the off-stage machinations of the god of the Bible. This paper will demonstrate the intentional retelling of the stories of both these films through an extensive contrast of the Coen brothers' film with the original stories. Highlighting the transformations and additions that they make to the stories will provide firm grounds for saying that the god behind the scenes is the god of the biblical narratives as that god has been written into the stories of Southern American gospel culture.


Late Antique Paganism Retreats to the Domus
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Bradford A. Kirkegaard, University of Pennsylvania

In this paper, I will explore the retreat of paganism from its civic expressions into domestic contexts. Drawing on archaeological evidence from the well-preserved city of Aphrodisias from the 4th to the 6th centuries CE, I will examine the pagan survivals from domestic settings placed within the context of a city in the midst of transforming its sacred spaces. Late Antique houses are a fascinating feature of the changing face of ancient cities during this period. These houses are typically richly decorated, new constructions within highly desirable urban locations. Diverse in character and form, the specific uses of these structures remain a matter for speculation. Houses excavated at Aphrodisias include the North Temenos House, the 'Bishop's Palace', the 'Philosopher's House', the Atrium House, and the Water-Channel House. These houses demonstrate the range of opportunities for pagan survival and they chronicle the reactions of Christians to paganism. In some cases these houses provide evidence that we might expect, such as pagan artistic images variously covered over and preserved, or statues destroyed. In other cases they give material form to important pagan developments that have often been recognized, such as the importance of philosophical schools while adding vivid images of the antagonism they could arouse in Christians. These houses also preserve surprises, though, particularly evident with finds like the cult statuette discovered in the Water-Channel House. In a time when civic paganism was increasingly problematic, houses offered spaces for ongoing pagan expression and cultic life. It is a grand irony that while Christianity moved away from its house-church origins to take new form in grand structures and gradually to lay claim to civic space, paganism was pushed into retreat, only to find lingering life in its domestic roots.


Executioner Deities in Akkadian, Hittite, and Hebrew Curses
Program Unit: Israelite Religion in its Ancient Context
Anne Marie Kitz, Kenrick-Glennon Seminary-Kenrick School of Theology

In the pantheons of the major civilizations of the Ancient Near East, rank among the deities is generally clear. The highest ranking gods and goddesses open any list wherever such catalogues are found. In many cases the names of other deities appear. While these may be recognized as lesser beings, their exact role and function in relation to the dominate gods is not always distinct. In the world of cursing, however, some of these minor deities can function as the executioners of the harm in a malediction. This paper will examine two Akkadian curses that illustrate a curious shift from a singular to a plural verb. This verbal change serves to emphasize both the derivative character and the independent nature of a curse’s many possible injuries. The relationship between the governing deity Shamash and the lesser god, Girra, found in some Maqlû maledictions clearly depends on this kind of affiliation. The Hittite linkiyantesh or ‘oath/curse deities’ operate along similar lines. Their corporate behavior and self-reliant traits may be appreciated best through a linguistic analysis. Interestingly enough the Hebrew Bible also preserves vestiges of such collective beings. This is especially the case in Deut 28:22 which displays the same peculiar verbal shift found in the Akkadian maledictions above. The collective nature of the injuries and their alliance with curses likewise associates them with the Hittite linkiyantesh.


The Bible in its Ancient Near Eastern Environment, I and II
Program Unit:
Jacob Klein, Bar Ilan University

All areas of ancient near eastern studies have taken root, come to bloom,and born copious fruit in Israeli academic institutions, and have had a profound impact on the study of the Bible and biblical Israel. Klein will discuss the development of Ancient Near Eastern Studies (especially Assyriology, Sumerology and Northwest Semitic languages and literatures) in Israel since the time of Torczyner (Tur-Sinai), Mazar and Cassuto over forty or fifty years ago. Hurowitz will review the influence of ANE studies on research in the fields of biblical history, religion, literature, and language, with prominence given to the work of Hayim Tadmor, Avraham Malamat and Moshe Weinfeld and their disciples. Israeli scholarship in both ANE studies and comparative research continues the scholarly traditions of its founders, and of prominent foreign scholars such as Benno Landsberger, Samuel Noah Kramer, Ephraim Avigdor Speiser, Cyrus Gordon, Moshe Held, H. L. Ginsberg and William H. Hallo.


To See or Not to See: Conflicting Visions of Reality in Job
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Lillian R. Klein-Abensohn, Bethesda, MD

*


“Not So Happily Ever After…”: Cross-Cultural Marriages in the Time of Ezra/Nehemiah
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Gerald A. Klingbeil, Adventist Intl. Institute of Advanced Studies

The study will provide an evaluation of the legal repercussions of cross-cultural marriages in the time of Ezra/Nehemiah in view of the legal code visible in the Hebrew Bible. After the definition of key concepts (such as “mixed” or cross-cultural marriage, etc.), the Pentateuchal legislation concerning cross-cultural marriages and its application in the time of Ezra/Nehemiah will be described. It is interesting to note that during other periods of biblical history, cross-cultural marriages seemingly did not evoke such a strong response as during the later postexilic period. In this context the close relationship between law and sociolinguistic pragmatics will be noted, which also seems to provide a helpful perspective for our understanding of this particular drastic action in Ezra/Nehemiah. Finally, relevant extrabiblical data concerning the realities of cross-cultural marriages from Palestine (Wadi ed-Daliyeh documents) and Egypt (Elephantine papyri) will be presented which seek to provide the historical context of the biblical narratives involving cross-cultural marriages in the time of Ezra/Nehemiah.


Over-Realized Expulsion? Historical Minimizations of a Johannine Anachronism
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Edward W. Klink III, Biola University

The “expulsion from the synagogue” in John 9 has been dominated for nearly four decades by reconstructed “glimpses” popularized in the two-level reading of the Fourth Gospel by J. Louis Martyn. While starting with the assumption that John has traditional material, hence the history in his “history and theology in the Fourth Gospel,” Martyn has made famous his reading of John’s reapplication of the traditional material, or the theology. The key insight Martyn provided the last generation of students of John is the anachronism in 9:22, an insight that although it has been criticized at the level of historical reconstruction (the official edict of the Jamnia Academy and the Birkat-ha-Minim), has dominated nearly every reading of the gospel. But Martyn has guided us to an over-realized reading of the “expulsion from the synagogue” passages, and his focus on the later Sitz im Leben of John has minimized the Gospel’s explicit interest in the past. Even the term “aposunagogos,” the key evidence for Martyn, reflects a historicity that has been too easily suppressed. This paper will argue that a fresh examination of the historical reflections in the “expulsion of the synagogue” passage in John 9 reveals not only John’s theological interest in the past, but also some potential “glimpses” on the life and ministry of the historical Jesus.


The Displacement of 1 Corinthians 14:34–35 in D, F, G, and the Latin Tradition
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Jeffrey Kloha, Concordia Seminary

The authenticity of 1 Cor. 14:34-35 is frequently disputed on the basis of transcriptional probability. Specifically, that there are no parallels for the displacement attested by D F G 88 915 and most of the Latin tradition (which moves the passage to the end of chapter 14). Gordon Fee has been influential in arguing that the best way to account for the displacement is that 14:34-35 are a marginal gloss in an early copy of the Corpus Paulinum, which subsequent copies placed either after v. 33 or after v. 40. This paper demonstrates that 1) There are other examples of shifts and insertions of blocks of text in the Corpus Paulinum, all of which are the result of harmonization to other passages; 2) D F G and the Latin tradition shift four blocks of text (Rom. 16:5, 16; 20; 1 Cor. 14:34-35) and make two insertions that are harmonizations to other passages (1 Cor. 16:19; Gal. 4:17); 3) Editorial style, theme, and manuscript attestation indicate that all six alterations derive from the same source; 4) The displacement of 14:34-35 fits a pattern of alterations made in order to bring women in general, and Prisca (Priscilla) in particular, under apostolic authority; 5) This editorial activity corresponds to “anti-feminist” tendency in the “Western” text of Acts, in particular in the account of Priscilla in Acts 18. This passage is the source of the insertion at 1 Cor. 16:19, which further connects the alterations in D F G to those in Acts. Recognition of this editorial activity in D F G and the Latin tradition renders the “marginal gloss theory” for the origin of 1 Cor. 14:34-35 unnecessary. As a result, arguments against the authenticity of 1 Cor. 14:34-35 must be made on a basis other than that of transcriptional probability.


Thinking about Composition of the Synoptic Gospels
Program Unit: Q
John S. Kloppenborg, University of Toronto

This paper will review the compositional models currently mooted (or tacitly presupposed) for understanding the ways in which Q was employed in the composition of Matthew and Luke--scribal, oral composition, rhetorical composition--and assess their respective viabilities for making sense of the Synoptic data.


Texts of Tears: The Dialogue of Intertextuality in Lament Psalms
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Sheri Klouda, Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary

A comparison of several lament psalms reveals consistent patterns of literary borrowing from specific earlier texts, indicating an internal dialogue operating beneath the surface of these compositions. The petitioners revisit certain texts in shaping their prayers, maintaining an ongoing conversation between a traditionally accepted group of source texts particularly suited to the concerns of the psalmist. A look at three representative examples, Psalms 79, 80, and 94, enables us to identify categories of textual preference in biblical allusion among lament writers, and provides an interpretive key to understanding psalms of need and grief.


The Poetic Transformation of Method and Message in Isaiah 60
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Sheri Klouda, Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary

Isaiah 60 and Psalm 72 sustain linguistic, conceptual, and thematic links which suggest literary borrowing. A comparative analysis of Isaiah 60 with the psalm reveals an appropriation and adaptation of poetic method by Isaiah from the composition, and the subsequent transformation of the message of realization in Psalm 72 into a prophecy of expectation. Brief consideration of three representative examples suggest that the prophet recontextualizes Psalm 72 as he draws on verbal parallels and structural features in stylistically innovative ways to reinforce the thrust and purpose of his message to his contemporary audience.


The Wolf and the Lamb Will Feed Together: Reflections on Isaiah's Jerusalem in Isaiah 60–66
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Sheri Klouda, Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary

The paper examines the Isaianic portrayal of Zion in light of chapters 60-66 from the perspective of a Christian biblical scholar who respects the contextual, historical, and grammatical moorings of the Hebrew text. The analysis seeks to initiate dialogue concerning the nature of Jerusalem as described by the prophet, and endeavors to answer the ultimate question: Who can enter her holy gates?


Learning, Liberty, and Libronix: How Multimedia Changes the Study of Ancient Israel's History
Program Unit: Computer Assisted Research
Jens Bruun Kofoed, Copenhagen Lutheran School of Theology

Combining insights from digital storytelling and cognitive theory on learning styles, the Danish Ancient Israel's History Multimedia Project seeks to enhance the student’s learning process by presenting a multimodal hypertext tool for the study of the Hebrew Bible, Israel's history and biblical archaeology aimed at introductory level theology and biblical archaeology. The project is a joint venture between teachers and master students at Copenhagen Lutheran School of Theology and Department of Communication at Aalborg University, Denmark. The project takes advantage of the Libronix Personal Book Builder (Standard Edition) which allows users to create Libronix compatible books that integrate seamlessly with the Libronix Digital Library System and allows the users to distribute created resources (without charge) to other Logos Bible Software users. The paper will present an outline of the theoretical arguments for using multimedia to enhance the learning process with a number of examples from the multimedia project.


The Aramaic of Hillel
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Aaron Koller, Yeshiva University

We can trace aspects of the history of Aramaic from early in the first millennium BCE, but our data is scarce for the Palestinian dialect of Middle Aramaic. Besides the Aramaic of Daniel, the Qumran Aramaic texts, the consonantal texts of Onqelos and Jonathan, and the Bar Koseba letters, there is another small source that has not been fully exploited yet: Aramaic statements in tannaitic literature. E.Y. Kutscher repeatedly stressed the meagerness of our knowledge of this dialect period, but wrote, “the few Aramaic words and sentences to be found in tannaitic literature…have to be used with care, since their text is not yet established. I purposely refrained from using the Aramaic material to be found in tannaitic literature, for [this] reason.” D. Talshir has seconded this opinion more recently, but has also laid down some methodological principles to point the way to future research on these texts. As a first step in this direction, I will analyze linguistically the Aramaic sayings of Hillel preserved in the mishnaic tractate Pirqe ’Avot. This must be based on an evaluation of the important manuscripts of this tractate to ascertain which version of these sayings is the most reliable. The work that has been done over the past half-century in studying and classifying the various manuscripts of the Mishnah, especially by Kutscher and M. Bar-Asher, is critically important for us, but it must be recalled that their studies relied on the Hebrew within the manuscripts. As Yochanan Breuer has shown, a manuscript’s preservation of distinct linguistic dialects—or, in this case, distinct languages—is a good test of the manuscript’s reliability. It would be particularly interesting if we could find either definitive Babylonianisms in Hillel’s Aramaic (in light of his traditional Babylonian origins), or conclusive Palestinianisms.


The Active Reader in Antiquity
Program Unit: Future of the Past: Biblical and Cognate Studies for the Twenty-First Century
David Konstan, Brown University

*


A Mother’s Love: Reading Rizpah in Popular Discourse
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Jennifer L. Koosed, Albright College

David’s political machinations are often worked out on the bodies of women; however, the political overlay on Rizpah’s story (2 Sam 21:1-14) is inconsistent, even nonsensical. Abner and Ishbaal’s conflict is dubious, there is no biblical account of Saul incurring bloodguilt with the Gibeonites, and there is a textual problem with the names of the men executed. Rather than clearly connecting to David’s power politics, the superimposition of the political on Rizpah’s story is an attempt to distract the reader from the gruesomeness of the tale. The text tries to control and contain the fleshiness of the story – Rizpah’s own as she sits in the desert skin burned, lips cracked, hair matted; and the men’s impaled flesh, decaying and rotting under the brutal summer sun. Rizpah’s story is not frequently examined in biblical studies. Even among feminist interpreters, Athalya Brenner’s recent interpretive monologue is the most sustained study. Rizpah has had more of an afterlife in certain popular contexts. She has been a model for women’s activism especially in Latin America where her actions are compared to the Mothers of the Disappeared. In Christian inspirational literature, she is a model of “undefeatable faith” which demonstrates maternal love at its most powerful. This paper will first examine the biblical writer’s attempt to fit Rizpah into the political story of David. Next, this paper will analyze the use of Rizpah in popular discourse, and the political ramifications of such discourse. In certain contexts, particularly the Latin American one, Rizpah’s story is read as a subversive assault on dangerous regimes; in others, her characterization is used to support the status quo by locating (and implicitly limiting) women’s power to their “natural” maternal instincts.


Politics and Perversion: Situating Žižek’s Paul
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Adam Kotsko, Chicago Theological Seminary

Žižek’s reading of Paul in The Ticklish Subject and The Puppet and the Dwarf is set in contrast to Badiou’s. The main points of Žižek’s reading are laid out, particularly Paul’s place in Žižek’s understanding of Christianity and of the contemporary political constellation. This reading is clarified in relation to Žižek’s overarching project of grounding ideology critique in a Lacanian reading of Hegel, setting the Pauline concepts of the law and the cross in relation to the “psychoanalytic cure” and Hegelian “Absolute Knowledge.” In conclusion, Žižek’s reading’s plausibility is assessed, together with the question of whether his reading is instrumental.


Symbolic Role and Social Location of the Widow at the Temple Treasury (Mark 12:41–44)
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Joseph Kozar, University of Dayton

The Markan Jesus' meeting with a widow at the Temple treasury appears as singularly out of place. Throughout much of the ancient world, women’7’s legal status was always inferior to men and widowed women had even fewer legal rights. Given their social location, widows had little to offer, yet in the Markan pericope a widow is praised for her "giving." In context, her generosity seems a symbolic action of total dedication in the most sacred place in Jerusalem. Jesus' purpose and mission mirrors the widow's proleptic action (see Mark 10:45). Investigation of the encounter of Jesus and the widow demands a look at not only what can be seen but what it is possible to see once the reader gazes beyond the bounds of convention. This paper is an examination of the unity created by the emergence of both Jesus and the widow within the sacred confines of the Jerusalem Temple. It explores whether there is evidence of a counter-memory to the documented tradition of the place of this woman. The encounter scene has no pre-established center in spite of critical readings which place the widow at the side of the action. How is the widow a sexed and gendered body within the confines of male priestly power? What response does Jesus' praise of the "giving" widow require of the Markan community?


Jewish Women's Resistance to Christianity in the Early Firth Century: The Account of Severus of Minorca
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Ross S. Kraemer, Brown University

Severus of Minorca's Latin Letter On the Conversion of the Jews purports to describe how the entire Jewish community of Minorca converted to Christianity, shortly after some bones of St. Stephen were brought to the island in the early 5th century C.E. The Letter is compelling for many reasons, including its apparent unique description of a late antique Latin-speaking diaspora Jewish community, and its extensive social relationships with Minorcan Christians. Particularly fascinating is its representation of several elite Jewish women as the last to convert. Narratives about individual Jewish women from this period who might really have lived are virtually non-existent: historians might easily sympathize with Scott Bradbury's acceptance of this portion of the Letter as historically reliable, and his admiration for the courage of the women who clung to their ancestral religion in the face of extraordinary pressure. Yet close analysis suggests that just as rhetorical strategies dictate much of the rest of the Letter, so, too, what Severus says about women has more to do with the uses of gender in the narrative than it does with actual Minorcan Jewish women. The paper focuses on Severus' depiction of four elite Jewish women. What appear initially to be descriptions of Jewish women resisting Christianity, emerges as the deployment of female characters for rhetorical purposes, relying on gender stereotypes and associations for various effects, including a subtle critique of Jewish men (and women) and the promotion of (Christian) gender roles and values. Women exemplify Jewish stubborness in the face of the reasonableness and truth of Christianity. Particularly telling is the construction of this female stubborness as marital insubordination and women's conversion as marital subordination (and subordination to divine and masculine authority). These uses of gender calls into question the historical utility of these particular stories.


Para-mania: Beside, Before, and Beyond 'Bible Studies'
Program Unit:
Robert Kraft, University of Pennsylvania

*


Recast, Reclaim, or Reject: Myth and Validity
Program Unit: Bible, Myth, and Myth Theory
Steven Kraftchick, Emory University

The issue of myth’s relationship to claims of truth has been, and remains, a controverted one. Knotty problems and knottier discussions surround the positions taken about myth and its capacity to embody reveal or conceal truth. As a result, questions about how to interpret myth and how to “translate” it into non-mythic expression (or whether it can be so translated) continue to perplex us. As Bruce Lincoln notes in the introduction to his volume on myth, “whenever someone calls something a ‘myth,’ powerful—and highly consequential—assertions are being made about its relative level of validity and authority vis-à-vis other sorts of discourse.” The purpose of this essay is to see how these assertions and understandings of myth’s relationship to truth effect our decisions concerning its interpretation. To that end, I will investigate the works of two biblical scholars who treat the issues of the New Testament and myth: Rudolf Bultmann and Gerd Theissen. After reviewing their perspectives on myth and the modes of interpretation they suggest for reading the materials of the New Testament, I will consider these positions in light of Lincoln’s theories concerning myth. While I do not expect to “solve” the questions of interpretation and myth’s relationship to other means of expressing truth, I do think that such an exercise will help us better understand the issues that are before us as interpreters of myth.


Bronze Age Israel: the Original Israelite (non-Hebrew) Language and Israelite Phoenician
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Charles R. Krahmalkov, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor

This paper introduces a book (now almost completed) on the languages and texts, religion (Yahwistic) and culture (Phoinic) of the first documented Israelite communities, those of the Middle and Late Bronze Ages.


'Exile and Restoration': Reflections on the Relation between History and Thought in Ancient Judaism
Program Unit:
Reinhard Kratz, Universitaet Goettingen

*


Miniature Books, Codices, or Formats? Categories, Contexts, and Conclusions
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Thomas J. Kraus, Willibald Gluck Gymnasium

Papyrus and parchment folios (categorized as specific groups by Eric G. Turner in his classic 'The Typology of the Early Codex' [University of Philadelphia Press 1977, pp. 22, 28-29]) have often been treated as something particularly special. Consequently, they have been classified in a certain respect (above all as amulets or being typical of Christian apocrypha). However, the manuscripts subsumed under the category of 'miniature' are quite individual in their features and do not fit automatic classifications. Thus, this paper focuses on the category itself as well as on the updating of Greek 'miniatures' based on Turner's. Finally, some mutual contexts of the data are presented and conclusions from it relevant for New Testament Textual Criticism are drawn.


Hebrews 3:7–4:11 as a Midrash on Psalm 94 in the Septuagint
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Wolfgang Kraus, Universität des Saarlandes

1. Ps 94 LXX and its relation to Numb 14:21-38: the relecture of a text within the OT. 2. Ps 94 LXX in Hebr 3-4: katapausis as the heavenly place of rest. 3. Hebr 11:8-16 and Hebr 12:22-29: a confirmation to the understanding of katapausis as heavenly place of rest.


The Birds and the Babes: The Structure and Rhetoric of Psalm 8
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Judah Kraut, University of Pennsylvania

For all its popularity, Psalm 8 has posed a number of notoriously difficult exegetical challenges for commentators from all eras who have sought to interpret it. Certain words in the psalm are not easily translated, the structure of the psalm is not readily apparent – neither is its genre nor its provenance – and various elements of the psalm seem to defy any obvious explanation as to their import. Faced with the many vexing exegetical conundrums posed by Psalm 8, scholars have often indulged in speculative exegesis more so than in compelling textual argument. Indeed, rare is the scholar who does not emend the text of Psalm 8 in some fashion or who dares interpret it on its own terms, without the necessary “elucidation” provided by another (or many other) biblical or extra-biblical text(s). Yet, however valuable the results, the efforts to interpret Psalm 8 in the light of more accessible (or hypothetical) texts have obscured the fact that the psalm, as is, possesses its own internal structure and rhetorical logic, which – properly considered – go a long way toward unraveling the textual enigmas that have long bothered biblical exegetes and readers. In short, the contention of this paper is that an appreciation of the very structure of Psalm 8 elucidates three key elements of its meaning: (a) the role of 3a (“From the mouths of infants and sucklings”) in the psalm; (b) the identity of the “Elohim” to whom man is compared in 6a (and the nature of that comparison); and (c) the rhetorical strategy and overarching message of the psalm as a whole.


Inside and Outside:The Psalm's View on the Temple
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Jutta Krispenz, University of Marburg

The Book of Psalms is a collection of prayers, whose liturgical character connects them with the cult and the temple. Some Psalms explicitly refer to the temple and these references display in the choice of the parts of the temple which they name a concept of the temple as the place, where the individual expects to meet God. The paper explores the symbolic architecture depicted in the Psalms by investigating references to architectural parts, their relation to profane architecture and the location of those, participating in the cult in that symbolic architecture. The paper will mainly focus on Ps 84.


Gustav Boström's Concept of "Paronomasia" and the Discussion on Criteria for Composition in the Book of Proverbs
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Jutta Krispenz, University of Marburg

In the last years, a number of monographs have explored the possibility of larger units, binding together several single sayings in the Book of Proverbs. These investigations resulted in different compositional units. The fact, that the results differed from one another, has however not led to a discussion on what criteria might be valid for establishing a compositional unit, nor has Gustav Boström’s concept of “paronomasia” been perceived in full as significant for proverbial compositions. The paper aims at putting Boström’s paronomasia in a framework, where it can be related to other stilistic features and wants to underscore the importance of phonetic repetition for understanding of biblical texts.


Did Job Repent?
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Thomas Krueger, University of Zurich

According to most English versions of the Book of Job, in his last words Job states that he “despises (or abhors) himself and repents in dust and ashes” (Job 42:6, cp. KJV, NKJV, RSV, NRSV, NIV). Accordingly, it appears that the rebellious Job of the poetic dialogues in ch. 3-42 has finally been tamed, and the protagonist of the book is again the pious sufferer of the preluding prose tale (ch. 1-2) who “did not charge God with wrongdoing” (1:22). However, a closer philological and exegetical examination of Job 42:6 in the context of the whole book shows that the most probable translation of Job's final statement is: "Therefore I will waste away, but I am comforted about dust and ashes." My paper will give reasons for this translations and explore the consequences for the understanding of the Book of Job as a whole.


The Future and the Illusion: Iamblichus and the Role of Images in the De Mysteriis
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Todd C. Krulak, University of Pennsylvania

Images of the divine play a major cultic role in the Mediterranean basin from its earliest history. Although their importance remains largely intact, the function of the image (along with other ritual activities) is called into question by philosophers of the second and third centuries C.E. In Book 3.28-30 of the De Mysteriis, Iamblichus of Chalcis, in the guise of the Egyptian priest Abamon, demolishes the work of those who create images of the gods for the purpose of divination. As alluded to, this is in continuity with the general trend of philosophers who are calling into question the utility of divine images in a variety of cultic practices (Maximus of Tyre, Porphyry; but cf. Plotinus Ennead 4.3.11 and Asclepius 37), Iamblichus’ reasoning differs from those who precede him. Further, Iamblichus is not entirely opposed to divine statues (cf. 1.9; 5.23-4) as they are an important part of the theurgic ritual. The purpose of this paper is to present and to analyze Iamblichus’ position regarding the use of images in both divinatory and theurgic ritual. Not only will this provide insight into the thought and ritual activity of the Neoplatonist, but it will also offer a snapshot of the continuing evolution of the image as Greco-Roman religious practice prepares to enter a phase in which the image would face new challenges.


Reflexes of Apocalyptic Wisdom in Jewish Liturgical Texts
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
David Kudan, Harvard University

In apocalyptic literature Wisdom functions in many ways, as an eschatological reward for the righteous, as the force that effects the daily renewal of the heavenly luminaries, and orders the stars on their courses, as the impetus for the distribution of water and light to the earth as gifts of God's Wisdom. A special aspect of Wisdom seems to be in evidence where the Parables of 1 Enoch portray the Messianic judge as the instrument of judgment, and thus his actions must be seen as manifestations of God's knowledge. Some aspects of wisdom are revealed to all humankind, others to particular groups or individuals. As is well known, in some works wisdom and Torah are equated, while in other works no such claims are made. Our goal will be to determine which of the sapiential conceptions characteristic of apocalyptic in its various streams are also in evidence in later Jewish texts, especially focusing on liturgy. We will be particularly alert to instances where the liturgy juxtaposes two or more conceptions of wisdom demonstrating the inheritance of apocalyptic streams of thought on the one hand, and the rejection of other apocalyptic doctrines on the other. For example, it is clear that the idea of Torah as the primary or exclusive source of divine Wisdom is grafted onto the texts of traditional Jewish prayers such as the Yotzer and the Ma'ariv Aravim, which begin by describing God's wisdom as active in the heavens, and then proceed with a prayer thanking God for His love of the people Israel and the gift of Torah. The rejection and disguising of apocalyptic views of divine Wisdom is but one of the many ways that later Jewish tradition distanced itself from practices and groups it considered anathema to its religous identity and worldview.


Concerning the Ontology of Ethics
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
Kathryn M. Kueny, Fordham University

In both Jewish and Islamic exegetical traditions, Cain and Abel are portrayed as twins; each with the other, or each with a sister. In most religious systems, twins represent a categorical anomaly; they challenge legal, ethical, moral, or natural proscriptions because of 1) the unusual circumstances surrounding their birth, and/or 2) their subsequent rivalries. For example, the Targum Pseudo-Jonathan and the Pirke de Rabbi Eliezer record that while Eve was frolicking in the Garden, Sammael rides past her on a serpent and she conceives Cain. After Eve copulates with Sammael, Adam comes to her, and she conceives Abel. As a result of these dual conceptions, Abel was begotten in the likeness of Adam while Cain was spawned from demonic seed. Cain, as we all know, went on to murder his brother. Contrary to these Jewish tales of the good vs evil twin, the Islamic corpus confirms that even though Cain was a twin, he was not spawned from demonic seed, nor was he destined to kill Abel. Using these and other stories of Cain and Abel, this paper will first place the mythical and biological phenomenon of twinning within its broader Jewish and Islamic scriptural, exegetical, legal, and medical context to explore how and why Jewish scholars treat twins as categorical anomalies, and Muslim scholars do not. Second, this paper will argue that while twins as anomalies ultimately confirm such privileged categories as “first-born son,” “patriarchal primacy,” and “moral geneticism” in the Jewish context, the exact opposite is true in the Islamic context, where the birth of twins poses no threat to established rules that ensure every individual is equal before his/her God.


Philo and the Problem of the Book of Genesis
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
James L. Kugel, Bar Ilan University

The very existence of the book of genesis posed a problem for Jews of the late second temp period: unlike the other 4 books of the Pentateuch, it had no laws or halakhic instruction per se. What was it there for? Along with the authors of Jubilees and other biblical pseudepigrapha, Philo of Alexandria wrestled with this question.


Shifts in Israelite War History: Early Jewish Historiography and Ethics of Plundering
Program Unit: Warfare in Ancient Israel
Brian S. Kvasnica, Hebrew University of Jerusalem

While Israelite warfare has been studied more conceptually (von Rad, Niditch), what has sometimes been overlooked in the history of scholarship is the pragmatics of warring. Using a socio-economic methodology (Y. Garlan, W.K. Pritchett), this paper will focus on one aspect of the practicalities of war, that of booty. In re-interpreting Israel's violent tradition, there arose in ancient Jewish interpretation of the Second Temple period a heightened sensitivity to the ethics of plunder, exemplified in the justification of the Exodus “plundering of Egypt” by Jubilees, Philo, Ezekiel the Tragedian. An additional example is found in the unique account of Judas Maccabaeus' pious plundering through his distribution of war-booty to disadvantaged—widows, orphans, and aged (2 Maccabees 8). Another example of this new sensitivity in plundering is expressed in Josephus whereby defrauding even an enemy is condemned. During the later Second Temple period, shifts in ideology of Israelite war history allowed Israel to be interpreted more piously which in turn encouraged its constituents to act accordingly.


Postmodern Preaching Based on a Process Model
Program Unit: Homiletics and Biblical Studies
Lynn M. Labs, United Theological Seminary

Contemporary homiletics has moved beyond the model of preaching the biblical text as a set of objective propositions that are explained to the congregation. It now engages a postmodern understanding in which the meaning of a text is constructed in an interaction between the text and its readers/hearers. One way to fashion a postmodern homiletic is through a model based on process hermeneutics. Using this model, this paper will approach the biblical text as a complex of proposals that act as "lures" for the reader/hearer, and consider the ways that such textual "lures" might be both identified and preached.


Isaiah and Ezekiel in Revelation 4–5: Cultic Deity into Cosmic Deity
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Lynn M. Labs, United Theological Seminary

Old Testament allusions are pervasive throughout the book of Revelation. For example, the throne room vision of Revelation 4-5 appears to be based on the similar vision of Ezekiel 1-2. Revelation 4:8, however, clearly alludes to Isaiah 6. This study investigates the interrelationship between the imagery of Ezekiel 1-2 and that of Isaiah 6 in Revelation 4-5. It will demonstrate that monarchical imagery from Isaiah transforms the mobile cultic deity of Ezekiel into the permanently enthroned cosmic deity of Revelation.


Hosea 1–3 and Jeremiah 31: Men Becoming Women and Women Becoming Men: Poetic Imagery and Patriarchal Critique
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Alice L. Laffey, College of the Holy Cross

The text of Hosea 1--3 contains not only patriarchal "men as God/woman as sinner" metaphor but also a message to men tha they are the sinner/woman. In a similar fashion, Jeremiah 31 depicts restoration as "women protecting/surrounding men." While this is usually interpreted as a poetic reversal, this paper suggests that the woman is dteremined to be capable of those things with which men had traditionally been associated, and that Jeremiah's new covenant in the Hebrew Bible plays itself out in a vision of equality (similar to Gal. 3:28). The paper also discusses the "unintended consequences"of these texts. Produced as they were in a patriarchal culture, Hosea 1-3 and Jeremiah 31 need to be read as texts of liberation.


An Anthropological View of Old Age in Early Christian Communities
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Mona Tokarek LaFosse, University of Toronto

Even though aging has become a “hot” topic in academia, few early Christian scholars have commented on the social context of age and aging in early Christian communities. Certainly fewer people in the ancient world grew old than we are accustomed to today in our society, but they did not consider it particularly unique to grow old (Parkin 2003). Utilizing insights from the anthropology of aging, this paper will argue that the category of “age” became more important as Christianity institutionalized. Though few texts in first and second century early Christian literature mention the concept of aging, especially old age, I will focus texts in which “age” as a social category is rather prominent, such as 1 Timothy and Titus. As the early church began to model itself on the Roman household (Verner 1983; Maier 1991), the resulting fictive kin support systems and hierarchical power typically provided functions for older members of the Christian community (the young-old). It also provided and encouraged care for older members who needed it (the old-old), reflective of parent-child obligations (filial piety) found in many cultures. In some cases the early church gave older people more security and importance than they would have had otherwise (e.g., widows). As in other cultures, however, conflict between older and younger members appears to be present as well.


Honor and Shame: A Call to Loyalty Under the Empire in Genesis 39
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Donna Laird, Drew University

In Genesis 39 interactions between the Jews and the Persian Empire are presented through the conventions of a moral story similar in plot to the Egyptian Tale of Two Brothers. Both tales demonstrate cultural assumptions regarding gender. In addition the experience of colonization influences Genesis 39's rhetoric. The chapter tries to resolve the status of Joseph who is colonized and exiled by using androcentric ideologies of male honor. In order to achieve this aim the text relies on negative stereotypes of women, tying them to a foreign woman who is to be rejected. Joseph’s honor is achieved by attributing shame to a woman. The rhetorical strategy of Genesis 39 viewed through the lens of tradition-history suggests an Israelite male, in service to the empire, gains honor when serving well. In fact YHWH blesses that service. Finding favor in the eyes of masters and gaining promotion to high levels is also appropriate. Taking what belongs exclusively to the other nation or to share intimately all that belongs to the empire is shameful. True shame, epitomized in Potiphar’s wife, lies with the empire that pursues the Hebrew. Problematically honor in this text is equated with maintaining boundaries by remaining loyal to male superiors (or the Emperor) and those who would bring dishonor to the empire are to be rejected. Thus the listener is called to both loyalty to Persian government and separation from Persian colonial culture.


Reading Repentance into the Bible: Some Medieval Strategies
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
David A. Lambert, Yale University

There has been a marked tendency within biblical scholarship to overemphasize the role of repentance in the Hebrew Bible. Phenomena such as fasting, supplication, prophecy, and confession are assumed to be closely wedded to repentance in most scholarly treatments. This undue emphasis can be traced to the belated advent of the notion that we now take to be repentance--a combination of regret for past sin and determination not to do so again. However, a large part of the penitential lens through which most contemporary interpreters peer was constructed in the Middle Ages by great medieval thinkers who perceived the need to integrate the mental process of repentance that had become essential within formative Judaism and Christianity with physical rites preserved from their shared biblical heritage. A detailed exploration of medieval discussions of repentance can serve as a vital prelude to a reconsideration of the biblical material. The medievals clearly identify those rites that came to be interpreted as penitential, and, more importantly, reveal the interpretive logic behind those associations. What emerges are not only methods of inserting spiritual content into physical performances but of reading absences in Scripture. That is to say, asserting the implied presence of repentance on the basis of its associated practices being mentioned. The work of the Jewish philosopher and legist Moses Maimonides (1135-1204) provides an ideal basis for such a discussion, for he clearly isolates a number of important methods, among them: viewing physical rite as an expression of the mental event and viewing the physical rite as leading to the mental event. These same reading strategies (problematic when imposed upon the world of ancient Israel in light of their assumed dichotomy between interior and exterior modes of behavior) are consistently, though unwittingly, employed in contemporary biblical scholarship.


Art in the Priscillan Catacomb: The Anthropology of Gesture in the Underworld of Rome
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Jason T. Lamoreaux, Brite Divinity School

The images found on the walls of the catacombs of Rome have caused much debate since the 15th century. This debate has focused on the dating of the catacombs, when Christ followers used them en masse, and what the images mean to both modern viewers and ancients. This paper proposes to add to the data already collected. Rather than attempt to connect the images with earlier ones in the Greco-Roman milieu, it is argued that the anthropology of gesture can help further our understanding by offering a heuristic tool to help modern viewers of the art understand what meaning an ancient Roman or Christ-follower may have gathered from the painting. The model is constructed on the one hand with modern anthropology, principally Adam Kendon and Andrea de Jorio’s work, and on the other hand, with attention to textual evidence that might enlighten the meanings of particular gestures. This model will not only take into account context in the painting; body position, limb position and hand position of the subjects; but also the context in which the viewer stands and the space around her. Furthermore, this paper will use the Capelle Graecae of the Priscilla catacomb as a test case for the model and its effectiveness. The art in this particular room is connected with many Hebrew Bible and Intertestamental stories, but the paintings recontextualize the meaning of these stories for 2nd century Greco-Roman Christ followers. The anthropological model of gesture will help to connect these works with their narrative sources and will further bring to light what meaning can be found in the recontextualization.


Can Words Be Violent or Do They Only Sound like That? A Study in 2 Corinthians
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Peter Lampe, University of Heidelberg

A study of the "violence" in Paul's language in 2 Corinthians


Unicode: The Future of Ancient Typography?
Program Unit: Poster Session
Darin Land, Fuller Theological Seminary

Many Biblical scholars have encountered the frustration of discovering unintelligible nonsense in the place of accurately accented Greek or correctly pointed Hebrew. The problem derives from early computing conventions. Since all computers rely on numbers to handle data, a standard system of equating numbers to letters was necessary. The resulting standard was known as ASCII (American Standard Code for Information Interchange). ASCII assigned a unique number to characters, punctuation, accents, and other symbols. In 1991, computer experts developed a new standard, called Unicode. Where ASCII had only 256 positions, Unicode has millions. There are enough Unicode numbers to allow every script to have a unique designation for each of its characters. For example, alpha and aleph have their own Unicode numbers (03B1 and 05D0, respectively). It is no longer necessary to use a specially designed font to replace a Latin character with the desired non-Latin one. In theory, it is possible to use a single font for all the typographical needs of Biblical scholars, including Greek and Hebrew. Even if a given computer does not have a particular font, Unicode aware programs automatically substitute the correct characters from a font the system does have. Therefore, documents composed with Unicode fonts will be intelligible on other Unicode-enabled computers. I propose a poster entitled, “Unicode: The Future of Ancient Typography?” The purpose of the poster will be to educate viewers about the Unicode standard. The poster will include brief information explaining what Unicode is, why Biblical scholars should become aware of Unicode, and the advantages and disadvantages of Unicode over the older ASCII standard. Even more importantly, graphics will describe how to install and use multilingual keyboard input methods. The poster, therefore, will have a pragmatic emphasis, explaining how to access Unicode capabilities on both Apple and Windows computer systems.


Computer-Assisted Stylostatistical Analysis for Non-mathematicians
Program Unit: Computer Assisted Research
Darin Land, Fuller Theological Seminary

Computer-assisted stylostatistical methods have great power for evaluating the authorship of disputed New Testament writings. Unfortunately, their use is primarily limited to large-scale investigation of stylistic traits beyond an author’s conscious control. Their complexity renders them impractical for confirming the subjective impression of style, even though they provide powerful tools for assessing authenticity. I propose a more modest approach to computer-assisted stylistic analysis. The goal of this approach is not to establish authorial identity but to verify assertions regarding distinctive stylistic features. The method is as follows: (1) identify a computer-searchable sign of the feature, (2) determine the relative frequency of the sign in the disputed and undisputed writings, (3) calculate the mean and standard deviation for the undisputed writings, and (4) compare the frequency in the disputed writings against the mean and standard deviation of the undisputed writings. The proposed paper explains this method and illustrates its use by evaluating six style features commonly attributed to Ephesians and Colossians (protracted sentences, abundance of subordinate clauses, profusion of genitival constructions, excessive use of ??, substitution of Pauline particles and prepositions for non-Pauline ones, and infrequent use of questions). Ephesians and Colossians are within the standard deviation of the undisputed Epistles for four and three features, respectively. Therefore, only two of these stylistic descriptions accurately differentiate Ephesians from the undisputed Pauline Epistles, and only three distinguish Colossians. While researchers cannot establish authorial identity using this technique, the method does provide an objective measure for discussing style. The method is accessible to New Testament scholars who may not have a strong background in mathematics or computer science. Moreover, scholars can evaluate a wide variety of stylistic features using this method and can expand the discussion to include a comparison of the styles of different authors.


Hostile Takeover: An Intertextual Reading of Luke 1–2
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
David Landry, University of Saint Thomas

*


Otherwise than Isaiah, or How Not to Understand
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Francis Landy, University of Alberta

Isaiah 6.9-10 is one of the most complex and difficult passages in the Hebrew Bible, as well as one of the most important. In it Isaiah is commissioned to instruct “this people” not to understand, and at the same time to forestall their comprehension. There are seven double binds here, enmeshed in ambiguities on the macro- and micro-levels. The people only understand when they do not understand, and vice versa; concomitantly, the prophet fulfils his mission only by failing to do so. However, the people’s ability to understand not to understand is undermined in the following verse by the transfer of the imperative to the prophet; if he controls their responses, they are automata, who cannot obey the divine command to understand not to understand. The double bind is subject to a regress, since we cannot know if the very words mandating incomprehension are themselves a trap, which mean other than they appear to say. The communication of the command not to communicate may be a transgression of that command, since informing victims of a deception results in its exposure, or it may contribute to the process of blinding. In this paper I intend to read Isaiah 6.9-10 in the context of the vision of ch.6, the relation of listening, reading and writing, the intimate initiatory scene and the unfolding text in history. The theoretical resources will include Elliot Wolfson’s Language, Eros, Being, in which the concealed is revealed, but only as that which is concealed in revelation. The secret is both homoerotic, the blinding, searing and healing encounter of prophet and God via the seraph, and the abjected, perverse and dissimulated heterosexual relation of god and goddess in v.13. Beyond this, however, and with a nod to Derrida, I will be fleetingly evoking Levinas’s Otherwise than Being, in which the face of the other can never be reduced to the same, to the said, and thus is an enigma, which one only sees through not seeing, not comprehending.


The Purifying Power of YHWH's Speech: The mis pî and pit pî Ceremonies in Isaiah
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Nathan Lane, Baylor University

This paper will analyze the images of “mouth” and “lips” as one major topos of Isaiah focusing on how these images give unity to the final literary form of the book. This literary analysis will be done against Isaiah’s ancient Near Eastern background, especially the practice of the mis pî (Opening of the Mouth) and pit pî (Washing of the Mouth) rituals for the dedication of idols. In the book of Isaiah, the people’s sinful and idolatrous mouths (6:5-7; 9:16; 57:14; 59:3) are contrasted with YHWH’s righteous and powerful lips/mouth (34:16; 40:5; 45:23; 55:11). The climax of the motif in the book comes in 51:16 and 59:21 as YWHW declares that he will place his words into the mouths of the people. This paper will argue that the movement of this motif is both an indictment of the people’s idolatry and an announcement of their future ritual cleansing by YHWH. This cleansing will allow the people to carry the message of YHWH. The paper will end with a short analysis of how this oracle would impact the social/political/economic scene. The power associated with being YHWH’s mouthpiece will be dispersed to all of the people who will now carry the words of the Lord.


Can a Lawyer Understand Mercy: Luke's Use of Scripture in the Parable of the Good Samaritan?
Program Unit: Formation of Luke and Acts
Nathan Lane, Baylor University

The thesis of this paper is that many interpreters have misunderstood the parable of the Good Samaritan (Luke 10:30-37) because they have failed to recognize an allusion to Exod 34:6-7. Interpreters most often believe that the lawyer’s response to Jesus’ last question showed that the lawyer did not understand the parable. Jesus asks, “Which of these was a neighbor?” They posit that the lawyer’s response, “The one who showed 'eleos',” shows that he hated the Samaritans so much he refused to mention his ethnicity. I hold that the lawyer’s response to Jesus’ parable is the most appropriate one. This paper contends that 'eleos' is an echo of the ancient Israelite creedal formula found in Exod 34:6-7. This creedal formula affirms the covenant fidelity and faithfulness of YHWH to the nation. Thus, the lawyer completely understood and affirmed that the point of the parable was that Jesus is calling for us to extend the same kind of love toward our neighbor that YHWH extended toward Israel. In the Old Testament, hesed (eleos in the LXX) became the signature attribute of the creed. Often times the creed was rehearsed with hesed functioning as a pars pro toto. The previous five times that eleos is used in Luke there are definite allusions to Exod 34:6-7. Those five prepare the reader for the sixth and final appearance in 10:37. Considering this allusion changes the force of the larger narrative surrounding the parable. The lawyer is a dynamic character that moves from good answers to even better.


Use of the Hebrew Bible in Jewish Magical Texts
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Peter T. Lanfer, University of California, Los Angeles

Within Jewish communities there was rich tradition of magical texts and charismatic/mystical characters that flourished in Late Antiquity. The late Second Temple period and the early centuries of the Common Era were characterized by the emergence of numerous individuals who displayed their special status based on their esoteric knowledge and their ability to put divine power into play. These charismatic teachers and religious ‘specialists’ became a gravitational center of Jewish religious activity. These specialists were often portrayed as magicians in Greek and Roman texts during this period of time. Early Christian writings similarly stereotyped the Jews as purveyors of magic, and holders of powerful and mysterious knowledge. Over time, this led to the widespread belief that the Hebrew language, Jewish legend and the Jewish divine names were imbued with particular potency. As a result, holy words and names became the province of Jewish sorcery. This was true in the time represented by Babylonian Aramaic incantation bowls and Palestinian Aramaic amulets as well as Jewish mystical literature. Within this emergent magical tradition, divine power was vested not in a particular class and its intellectual process, but in a potent name, ritual, or text. The magical use of Biblical texts therefore became a means of extending access to the divine power for all who desired or needed it.


“Considerable Proficiency ” (Let. Aris. 121): The Relationship of the Letter of Aristeas to the Prologue of Ecclesiasticus
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Armin Lange, University of Vienna

The Letter of Aristeas is central to Septuagint Studies as it provides the only substantial report about how the (Pentateuch)-Septuagint was created. Since H. Hody (Contra historiam Aristeae de LXX interpretibus dissertatio, 1685) the legendary and pseudepigraphic character of the Letter of Aristeas has been widely accepted. Hody’s study also initiated an extensive discussion about the question when the Letter of Aristeas was written. The proposed dates range from the 3rd cent. BCE to the 1st cent. CE. Relative chronology provides a new approach to this crux interpretum. Let. Arist. 121 describes the Septuagint translators in a way that resembles the praise of Ben Sira’s education in the Greek Prologue to Ecclesiasticus (verses 7-11). The Letter of Aristeas thus models the Septuagint translators after the blueprint of Ben Sira. Therefore, the Letter of Aristeas was written after the grandson’s Greek translation gained considerable prominence and authority in Alexandrian Jewry, i.e. some time in the 1st cent. BCE. A 1st cent. BCE date of the Letter of Aristeas raises the question why the Old Greek translation which was well established by that time needed special legendary authorization.


To Die For: When Martyrdom Sanctifies Scripture
Program Unit: Scripture as Artifact
Kasper Bro Larsen, Aarhus University

The paper presents a reading of selected early Christian martyr acts with the purpose of discussing how they perceive martyrdom to reflect ideal veneration towards scripture. When Diocletian in 303 CE announced his edict against the Christians, one of his principal weapons of attack against this rising religion was the confiscation and burning of its scriptures. Whereas some members of the clergy handed over the books in order to save their lives (the so-called traditores), the martyr legends recount how protagonists would rather die than surrender the sacred books to the fire (cf. for example The Martyrdom of Felix the Bishop). In these accounts, martyrdom is seen as a self-sacrificial practice that confirms the sacred status of the books (cf. the literal meaning of sacri-ficare, “to make holy.”) Through this practice, the books are identified as artifacts more valuable to society than the lives of individuals. As such, martyrdom reflects an artifactual perception of scripture that bears a certain resemblance to the use of scripture in ritual contexts where ritual performers by their acts and gestures intercommunicate their acceptance of the sacrality of objects (Roy A. Rappaport). This last aspect of performance and signification will be considered in relation to the selected texts.


Staging Stories: Re-figuring Social Strata as Late-Roman, Monastic Non-elites
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Lillian I. Larsen, Columbia University in the City of New York

The Sayings of the Desert Fathers (and Mothers) have historically been framed as a descriptive record of the formative period of early Egyptian monasticism (Bousset, 1923; Guy, 1956, 1974, 1993; Ward, 1975, 2003; Regnault, 1977; Gould, 1986, 1993; Burton-Christie, 1993; Harmless, 2004). In this paper I argue that placing the Sayings in conversation with extant archeological evidence troubles such positivist readings, drawing attention to significant, if less noted details of the narrative register. Complicating simplistic construals that portray boundaries between monastic elites and non-elites as clearly inscribed and largely uncontested, extant epigraphic and papyrological evidence foregrounds a more textured social reality. For example, archeological evidence from the Monastery of Epiphanius in Egypt includes correspondence between the weaver, Frange, and a cohort of fellow monastic tradesmen. One writes to ‘beg’ the loan of a loom, another to request a transportable wooden beam needed to fix his own loom in position. Elsewhere we learn that Frange is the superior of a community, and equally engaged in more intellectually substantive correspondence. Frange’s bi-vocational status suggests a monastic reality where conventional social demarcations have become decidedly porous. It likewise draws attention to subtle (and not so subtle) fissures in the narrative record that have long been overlooked. The semi-humorous, if pointed depiction of a monk who considers himself too spiritual to participate in manual labor, and elects instead to sit and read all day (Sayings, Discretion 69), takes on new resonance. Archeological remains underscore the way in which this saying is at once descriptive and prescriptive. Reframing the narrative window, epigraphical and papyrological evidence filters interpretive representation of the daily lives of early monastic non-elites in new ways.


Can You Hear Me Now? Deafness in Social Discourse in the Gospels
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Jason Larson, Syracuse University

This paper examines Jesus' healing of deafness in the twin contexts of Hebrew legal and prophetic traditions and Greco-Roman conventions. Deafness carried a social stigma in Greco-Roman society and was considered a ritual impurity in Hebrew tradition. In neither society were the deaf regarded as complete human beings, if indeed they were considered human at all; Aristotle, for example, is on record as having stated that “those who are born deaf all become senseless and incapable of reason”. Lucretius' de rerum natura announces that “to instruct the deaf, no art can ever reach, no care to improve them, and no wisdom teach.” In this paper, I point out that Jesus' interaction with and healing of the deaf function as embodied prophetic symbols that adopt images of deafness from Isaiah. I argue that Jesus' healings here serve as a “counter-discourse” to the prevailing conventions of social exclusion of the deaf. Moreover, this counter-discourse served a religio-political purpose as yet another example in Jesus' life that announced the dawning of a new age. My approach to these stories is a multi-pronged one, employing performance theory, medical anthropology, social/cultural memory, and the rhetorical use of poetic remembrance in an effort to gain a deeper appreciation for how “disability” was of paramount importance in the announcement that the “Kingdom of God is now at hand.”


The Construal and Use of Scripture in the African American Preaching Tradition
Program Unit: Homiletics and Biblical Studies
Cleo LaRue, Princeton Theological Seminary

*


Marrying Methods: Integrating Psychological and Literary Approaches to Characterization in Biblical Political Narrative
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Stuart Lasine, Wichita State University

Biblical characters sometimes act in ways which readers find surprising, inconsistent or even contradictory. Many scholars believe that there is no need to explain such behavior in psychological or literary terms because many biblical narratives are heavily redacted. Ironically, it is largely on the basis of unexamined psychological judgments about what constitutes behavioral incoherence that these scholars reject psychological explanations. In this paper I will argue that one should make a rigorous and sustained attempt to analyze surprising character behavior in psychological and literary terms before deciding that the portrayal is psychologically or narratively incoherent. The psychological approach is based on recent work in attribution and trait theory, as well as other branches of social psychology. The literary approach makes use of research on the long-neglected problem of character in narrative conducted during the recent “post-Theory” period of literary criticism. The paper also acknowledges an historical dimension to the problem by taking into account cases in which editorial changes were rhetorically designed to alter a character’s psychological traits for ideological purposes. The final sections of the paper give brief examples of integrated character analysis and evaluation in narratives dealing with political leadership, two focusing on kings (Jeroboam and Zedekiah) and two on prophets (Moses and Elijah).


Research and Development Project: Reading Biblical Poverty Texts in Context
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Kari Latvus, Diaconia University of Applied Sciences

Background of the project - The project started with an analysis of liberation hermeneutics (Latvus, Arjen teologia [Theology of everyday] 2002. Latin American liberation theology as well as British urban theology and Indian Dalit theology aimed to create models to do theology and especially biblical interpretation in context. Although several cultural, social and historical differences are obvious there are also certain structural similarities which can be described as a method of intercontextual biblical interpretation. The major issue is the interactive relation between biblical text and current context. Other key questions are the relation between the interpreter and context, tools to sense and analyse context, social inequality & justice, the role of community etc. Experimental part - In year 2004 a similar intercontextual methodology was used in academic teaching (Helsinki University). Students analysed psalms related to the theme of poverty. The task was twofold: to use traditional exegetical tools for analysis and to use exposure-method to find a connection to local reality (with poor and deprived people in Helsinki). Both success and difficulties were faced. For most students even a short but authentic contact with the world of the poor was heuristic both personally and for reading the psalms. On the other hand sometimes there was a danger for there to be a split between experiences and exegetical work. The best results were created in a dialogue between current context and biblical texts. Following phase - The new project will aim to read poverty texts in relation to Finnish reality. The results will be written in the form of a commentary. Intercontextual reading of biblical texts allows the study of current reality in interaction with biblical texts. Also the social contexts of biblical texts can be understood more deeply due to the study of current reality. Important step is collaboration between theologians and poverty researchers.


Ezekiel's View of the Netherworld in Comparative Perspective
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
Dale F. Launderville, Saint John's University

An examination of the topics of descent to the netherworld (Ezek 26:19-21; 27:27-36; 31:10-18) and rank in the netherworld (Ezek 32:17-32) in light of parallels from the Gilgamesh Epic, the Descent of Ishtar to the Netherworld, Homer's Odyssey, and other texts from Archaic Greece. The extent to which Ezekiel's mode of gaining knowledge of the netherworld resembles that of the shaman-like journeys of Odysseus and Gilgamesh will be examined. Also the issue of rewards and punishments in the netherworld in light of data from the Mesopotamian and Greek texts listed above will be addressed.


Les Devanciers (et Les Successeurs) de Field: Four Hundred Years of Hexapla Research from the Sixtine to the Twenty-First Century
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
T. Michael Law, Oxford University

In the study of the textual history of the Septuagint, the name of Frederick Field, and the phrase, “Field’s Hexapla,” saturates the literature. Indeed, it has been more than a century since a systematic presentation of the Hexaplaric materials has been attempted, and it is not yet forty years since S. Jellicoe bemoaned that although such a new collection would be welcomed, it was nonetheless an unrealistic hope in his near future. Because of this gap between Field’s work and the present day, nearly all of the literature on the Hexapla refers to Field alone. While it is true that Field’s is the greatest monument of Hexapla research to date, it is lamentable that so few know of the rich history of Hexapla scholarship that antedates Field by centuries. Focusing solely on the collections of Hexaplaric fragments, this paper will present that history in part, beginning in the late 16th century with the work of Petrus Morinus in the production of the Sixtine version of the LXX and concluding with my own research on III-IV Kingdoms which is part of the new work being carried out by The Hexapla Institute. The Hexapla Project is already underway and in the coming years will produce the definitive edition of the Hexaplaric fragments, thus replacing Field and joining the illustrious heritage of research on the Hexapla.


Renewing Self, Renewing Creation: The Rhetoric of Fasting in John Chrysostom's Sermons on Genesis
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Richard A. Layton, University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign

John Chrysostom preached eight Sermons on Genesis during Lent, probably in 386, shortly after his ordination as a priest in Antioch. Studies of early Christian exegesis have neglected these Sermons in favor of his later series of sixty-seven Homilies that spans the entire book of Genesis. I will argue that this early sermon series illumines the rich and dynamic interplay between ritual, audience, and exegesis in early Christian biblical interpretation. In the Sermons, Chrysostom frames Genesis 1 in the context of Lent by defining the spring fast as a renewal of creation. John lyrically depicts the liturgical season as a time of ritual rebirth rather than a period of ritual mortification. In so doing, he echoes ancient Syrian mythology which treated the springtime New Year festival as a renewal of Baal’s cosmogonic victory over the opposing forces of sterility and chaos. This correlation with ancient New Year mythology is reinforced by comparison with John’s Lenten sermons of 387, the Homilies on the Statues, in which the preacher employs more traditional agonistic images for the fast and urges his parishioners to undertake a sustained struggle against temptation. Comparison with the Homilies on the Statues suggests that the pastoral aim of defining the fast and the exegetical aim of explicating Genesis mutually inform John’s approach to the Sermons. For Chrysostom, Lent is more than the calendrical period in which Genesis is read, it is the mode by which the community’s place in the ongoing creation narrative can be understood. He creatively draws on deeply embedded cultural patterns to invite his hearers to approach the creation narrative as a story in which they participate rather than as a record of God’s activity in the remote past.


Jesus beyond His Genre: The Non-canonical Jesus Films
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Michael Leary, University of Edinburgh

There is an interesting sub-genre of "Jesus films" that relates well to the "treatment of biblical themes in films that are not expressly biblical." This genre is distinct both from films that attempt to directly adapt the canonical gospels to the screen, and from films that simply feature a discernable Christ figure as a central theme. The films that populate this sub-genre rest somewhere in between, being filmed narratives that have nothing else to do with Jesus other than the suggestion of a title, a set of visual themes, or an abstract yet fully intentional nod to the nature of Jesus. This paper will outline the contours of this interesting genre by looking at three of its most effective examples, and attempt to identify the hermeneutics at play in such profoundly inter-textual works of art.At first glimpse, Bruno Dumont's controversial realist masterpiece "La vie de Jesus" is only related to Jesus by title. But beneath the surface of the film lies commentary about mortality and materiality that expands to fill the Christological brackets set by Dumont in the title. Gus van Sant's recent film “Last Days” narrates the last few days of Kurt Cobain’s life in the context of a loosely fictional stand-in that becomes increasingly cloaked in Jesus imagery until a final resurrection scene. And finally, Bresson’s “Au hazard Balthazar” quite boldly turns a dilapidated donkey into a provocative metaphor for the odd presence of Christ in contemporary culture. All three of these films are intentional and provocative allusions to Jesus in decidedly non-biblical narrative worlds. This paper will track the reflective strategies of this "non-canonical" genre through these three close readings in their appropriate film theoretical context, and articulate the rich potential for re-narrating Jesus by means of the startling generic conflict embodied by these films.


Critical Biblical Hermeneutics of Li Jung-fang in the Socio-intellectual Context of China
Program Unit: Asian and Asian-American Hermeneutics
Archie Chi-Chung Lee, The Chinese University of Hong Kong

This paper aims to construct the biblical scholarship in China in the first half of the Twentieth Century (1900-1950), which has been neglected and buried at the early stage of its development by the various cultural and political upheavals in China. The main focus of the presentation will be on the struggles and contributions of Li Jung-fang (1887-1965), the first Chinese who underwent vigorous training in Western biblical scholarship and received his PhD degree from Drew University in 1918. Li taught the Hebrew language and biblical studies in Yenching University and critically appropriated the Hebrew Bible in the socio-intellectual world of the post-May Fourth China. Recently, 50 pieces of valuable manuscripts and handwritten notes of Li on biblical studies were discovered in addition to his 10 books and printed works. These will provide the bases for an assessment of Li’s method and contribution to critical biblical interpretation in the context of China’s quest for identity and modernization in the East-West cultural encounter.


A Contextual Reading of John 1:1–18
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Hyo Lee, Shenandoah University

John 1:1-18 outlines the entire Gospel with its multiple meanings and diverse ideologies. Yet, unlike the Synoptics it does not proclaim any good news forthright. No mention of euangelion evidenced in the prologue. When this text is read in the life-context of believers, what good news does or can it proclaim? With this question, the paper seeks to present a relevant contextual reading of the text by applying the tri-polar contextual criticism of Grenholm and Patte. Aiming this, the paper will first raise the life-context questions of today’s believers on the idea of Logos, the light, becoming children of God, the Logos indwelling, and grace and truth to see how these can be good news for today’s hurting and confused believing communities and the world. Second, the paper will analyze the text in the light of the reader’s religious and theological experience as a pastor of a local church and teacher in an undergraduate institution incorporating the Methodist doctrine of salvation and grace, to see how these doctrines can be affirmed and challenged by this text. Lastly, to draw out its critical meanings, the paper will engage in critical analysis of the text by focusing on its literary rhetoric as a narrative whole and on its cultural dimension as a document embedded in the pivotal values of kinship and marriage, patron and client, and honor and shame. With this contextual reading, the paper intends to argue that the prologue of the Fourth Gospel declares the good news of people becoming the privileged children of God and of Logos’ indwelling grace to the ones who respond in faith, apart from one’s biological, gender, ethnic, or national boundaries.


To Be Righteous in the End of Days: Sectarian Views in the Second Temple Period
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Kyong-Jin Lee, Yale University

It is a well-known maxim in the Hebrew Bible that “to be wise is to be righteous, and to be foolish is to be wicked.” Sectarian writings of the Second Temple Judaism, however, exhibit a transformation of such a theological paradigm when a vigorous interest on an apocalyptic restoration lays its emphasis on the attainment and control of esoteric information. This paper examines a new theological outlook on wisdom and righteousness in an apocalyptic framework as exemplified in the Damascus Document, Pseudo-Daniel, Book of Enoch and Wisdom of Ben Sirah.


Mapping Memory through Sound
Program Unit: Mapping Memory: Tradition, Texts, and Identity
Margaret E. Lee, Tulsa Community College

The ancient art of memory illustrates how memory encodes ideas and arguments in images. Because Hellenistic Greek literature was orally composed, published through speech and aurally received, sound served as memory's primary vehicle, creating and evoking remembered images. The sounds of an oral performance organized its structure and shaped its meaning. This paper will demonstrate ways in which memory is engaged in the reception of an oral performance through a systematic analysis of speech sounds encoded in the textual artifact.


Peter and the Transfiguration Event in 2 Peter and the Apocalypse of Peter
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Simon S. Lee, Harvard University

In this presentation, I would like to compare two 2nd century Christian texts, 2 Peter and Apocalypse of Peter. In both texts, Peter the apostle appears as the privileged witness of Jesus' Tranfiguration story and the Transfiguration story is explained in terms of the Parousia. Both texts present the Transfiguration as the evidence for the certainty of the Parousia. However, they have different socio-political contexts with different groups of people involved written in different genre. In Apocalypse of Peter Jesus answers in a narrative form Peter's question regarding the Parousia by saying that the glorious bodies of Moses and Elijah, which are attested in the Lukan version of the Transfiguration, stand for the resurrected bodies of believers. But in 2 Peter, the author argues against his opponents in a form of theological discourse by claiming that Jesus will come at the end with the glory shown in the Transfiguration. 2 Peter does not mention either Moses or Elijah. While in Apocalypse of Peter, the Transfiguration has something to do with Christian ontology at Parousia, in 2 Peter the Pasousia is related to Christology. How do these two texts have different understanding of the same Transfiguration story? Are there groups of people behind these texts who based their identity on Peter’s experience of the story? Do they belong to the same milieu or geographical locations? Or are they involved in the same debates, presenting the story differently against each other? Although it seems clear why Peter appears there – privileged witness of the event, is there further hint on Peter’s presence in those texts without James and John? Also, it will be interesting to explore whether we can reach a group of people who cherished Apocalypse of Peter, if there is any. Can we find any evidence in the text?


Genderless and Statusless Persons as Boundary Crossers
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
Carolyn Leeb, Valparaiso University

Crossing the boundaries between spaces which are differently gendered or differently statused entails risks, either to the boundary crosser, the occupants of the social space, or both, but these risks or affronts can be eliminated or mitigated by the operation of certain intermediaries. Although the role of brokers has been well explored for the ancient Roman and New Testament worlds, this paper will propose an alternative model for the world of the Hebrew Bible. In Hebrew Bible narrative, intermediation across boundaries between persons of differing statuses and differing genders was regularly accomplished by “non-persons”: individuals who were essentially without gender and without status and thus effectively invisible, individuals who were not “at home” in either high-status locales or in low-status ones and thus not out-of-place in either. Such persons could function as chaperones, ushers, escorts, guides, surrogates, and messengers without provoking an honor challenge. Understanding genderlessness and statuslessness helps to clarify the dynamics of certain HB narratives. For instance, Joseph is able to serve in the presence of an elite female (Potiphar’s wife) precisely because as a servant he is both without gender and without status. She unmasks the socially constructed fiction about him by pointing out, not that the emperor has no clothes, but that the servant Joseph is a real man. Similarly the model will be applied to the misunderstood role of Elihu in the book of Job. Elihu bursts on the scene out of “nowhere,” after Job has repeatedly requested an audience with God, and soon after Elihu’s appearance, Job does find himself in the presence of God. Elihu, then, would seem to be the broker who places the human client Job in the presence of the Divine Patron.


The Wives of Job in Text and Tradition
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Michael C. Legaspi, Harvard University

Ancient inquirers wanted to know: to whom was Job married? Job’s wife appears briefly in Job 2.9 to pose one question (‘Are you still holding fast to your integrity?’) and to offer one bit of advice (‘Curse God and die.’). The presence of a wife among Job’s second family in 42.12-17 is never made explicit. As a response to this paucity of information, a number of interpretive traditions grew up around the figures of Job and Job’s wife. One tradition, known from rabbinic commentary, the Targum of Job, and Pseudo-Philo, identifies the wife of Job with the Dinah of Genesis, the daughter of Jacob. Another tradition, witnessed principally in the Septuagint, identifies Job’s wife with a wretched woman named Sitis. The author of the ‘Testament of Job’ (100 BCE – 200 CE), however, creatively brings both traditions together in a way that solves a host of exegetical difficulties: he assigns Job two wives, first Sitis and then Dinah. The tragic career and bitter death of Job’s first wife Sitis, intimated in the Septuagint, is expanded upon in the Testament in order to dramatize the Joban ordeal. But when Job is restored later, he marries Dinah in a move that addresses a number of lingering questions: the fate of Dinah after the Shechem affair (Gen 34), the relation of Job to covenantal Israel, and the extraordinary character of Job’s daughters and their unlikely inheritance (42.14-15). For ancient interpreters, these lacunae both invited exegetical exploration and presented opportunities for edifying elaboration. The dynamic handling of tradition evident in the Testament shows how one author used two discrete exegetical motifs to address issues of ethnicity, gender, and spirituality within the context of Hellenistic Judaism.


The “Gnostic” Resurrection: The Dispute over the Resurrection of the Body as a Tool for Identity Building
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Outi Lehtipuu, University of Helsinki

The nature of the resurrection was one of the fiercest controversies among different early Christian groups. The writers representing the “orthodox” view laid heavy stress on the physical, bodily resurrection and accused their opponents, all those who held a more spiritual understanding of the resurrection, of falsifying the true faith. “For if the resurrection of the flesh be denied, the prime article of the faith is shaken,” writes Tertullian against the “heretical tenets of Valentinus” (Res. 2). The dispute was not only over theological issues but had significant political and social implications as well. This paper studies this controversy from the reverse point of view, provided by the Valentinian writings of the Nag Hammadi corpus. These texts make abundantly clear that there was no single “Gnostic” doctrine of the resurrection but different ideas may occur even within a single writing. Sometimes the topic is treated in a polemical context, suggesting that the question concerning the nature of the resurrection was also significant for the ideology and identity of the groups that produced the texts. The paper addresses, e.g., the questions how the view of the resurrection served their identity formation and how they envisioned the authority of the witnesses of the resurrected Jesus.


Peasant Revolt Redux: The Canaanite Exodus
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Mary Joan Winn Leith, Stonehill College

Thanks to ongoing archaeological work, it has become increasingly clear that the Israelites emerged from an essentially Canaanite cultural matrix. It is equally apparent that the Egyptian empire held sway over Late Bronze Canaan. By synthesizing what is known archaeologically about cultural continuity from LB to Iron 1 Canaan with aspects of XIX and XX Dynasty royal propaganda, a strong case can be made for a specifically Canaanite contribution to the biblical Exodus account.


Samaria Under the Persian Rule: New Research
Program Unit: Literature and History of the Persian Period
Andre Lemaire, Ecole Pratique des Hautes Etudes

After the latest publications in the field of Epigraphy, Numismatics, and Archaeology, this paper will try to show the new light they shed on the history of the Persian province of Samaria, especially during the IVth c. BCE, with special remarks concerning the problem of the extension of the province as well as its culture(s) and religion(s).


150 Years of War in Transjordan (c. 882–732 BCE)
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Andre Lemaire, Ecole Pratique des Hautes Etudes

Using three types of documents (Moabite and Assyrian inscriptions, as well as Biblical literature), this paper will present a provisory status quaestionis of what we know about the various wars in Transjordan during the IXth and VIIIth c. BCE. This will imply not only the study of the relations between the three Transjordan kingdoms: Ammon, Moab and Edom, but also with Israel and Juda in Cisjordan, Aram of Damascus in the North, and other kingdoms of Transeuphratesia as well as Assyria. Alliances between the various kingdoms were often changing!


Secrecy in the Book of Daniel and a Polemic with Mesopotamian Scholarship
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Alan Lenzi, University of the Pacific

It is an under-appreciated fact that the term raz, "secret," occurs almost exclusively in chapter two of the Book of Daniel (eight of nine attestations, with 4:6 being the one exception). I believe this distribution of raz is significant because two "firsts" occur in the chapter: chapter two is the first time Daniel receives revelation from the Hebrew deity, and it is also the first time we see the Jewish hero best his Babylonian scholarly colleagues, the ummanu, who are known from Akkadian sources to be the custodians of the secrets of the gods. In this paper I argue that the idea of secrecy in Dan 2 constructs a positive characterization of both the Israelite deity—he is a god who actively reveals divine knowledge—and the Israelite hero—Daniel is capable and worthy of receiving revelation. But secrecy also creates a point of conflict between Daniel and his Babylonian colleagues, the supposed experts in secret matters, and vividly shows the Israelite mediator their superior. By bringing these two uses of secrecy together, I believe Dan 2 intends to show that the Babylonian court scholars had failed to discover the secret they were asked to divine because they did not have the relationship Daniel had with the Hebrew god, the god who reveals secrets. Dan 2, therefore, shows some familiarity with and presents a polemic against the Mesopotamian scribal idea of court scholars as the possessors and guardians of the secret of the gods. In the opinion of the Jewish author, the ancient Babylonian scribal lore—the secret of the gods—proves ineffective in the face of the active, responsive, and direct revelation of the Hebrew deity to his chosen and trusted recipient.


Women, Magic, and the History of 1 Enoch
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Rebecca Lesses, Ithaca College

This paper will address the characterization of women as recipients of illicit knowledge - sorcery and divination - in 1 Enoch. It will discuss how the Book of the Watchers portrays women as those quintessentially involved in the evil of sorcery in contradistinction to the pure Enoch, who enters the otherworld while still alive.


Voice and Interiority: The Interweaving of Speaking Voices in Isaiah 21:1–2
Program Unit: Biblical Criticism and Literary Criticism
Barbara Mei Leung Lai, Tyndale Seminary

Isaiah 21:1-12 is notoriously complex in its interweaving of speaking voices. There are “pockets” of monologue in dialogue and “imaginary dialogues” in monologue. Employing literary-critical tools along with a psychological lens, this paper seeks to explore the function of the literary devices represented in this passage in general, and of the “first-person” projection of the “third-person” view in particular. As far as the Isaian persona is concerned, I shall further demonstrate that such a refined literary technique (the intertwining of speaking voices) is an effective and powerful means to bring something that is embedded and inward (the Isaian interiority) to the foreground.


Toward an Appropriation Theory: A Contextual Reading of the "Remembering" (Zakar) Motif in Deuteronomy
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Barbara Mei Leung Lai, Tyndale Seminary

The rationale behind this paper is the need of developing “theory” to shape our “practice” and of working out “practice” to enforce our theory. Therefore, the primary objective of this paper is two-fold. First, it provides a demonstrated example of a contextual reading of the prominent “Remembering” (zakar) Motif in Deuteronomy out of my own gender-culture-context-situatedness. Second, drawing from the insights of Ingrid Kitzberger (ed., The Personal Voice in Biblical Interpretation; and Autobiographical Criticism: Learning to Read between Text and Self) and Andrew Kelle (his theory of “appropriation” in Psychological Biblical Criticism, pp. 52-53), I seek to use this worked-out example to enforce and to further develop a version of the theory of “appropriation” (i.e. from “re-living” to “re-expressing” out of one’s “context”). While meaning is context-bound and context is boundless, it is hoped that this contextual reading of the “Remembering” Motif, to be explored in its relationship to the “go” and “take possession”(“Land” Motif), will enhance the meaning-significance of the text. This is done through appropriating its message to the collective, post-modern human and ecclesiastical life.


Jewish Art in Late Antiquity: Internal Needs or Challenges from the Outside?
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Lee Levine, Hebrew University of Jerusalem

The discovery over the past century of scores of Late Antique synagogues and cemeteries exhibiting heretofore unimaginable expressions of Jewish art has generated a great deal of scholarly and popular interest, revealing much about the nature of Jewish social, cultural, and religious life. In this paper we will focus on themes and motifs that were of specific interest to the Jews in Late Antiquity, i.e., biblical scenes, personalities, and recognizable Jewish symbols.


Reading the Bible in Nazi Germany: Gerhard von Rad’s Attempt to Reclaim the Old Testament for the Church
Program Unit:
Bernard Levinson, University of Minnesota, Twin Cities

*


Eve's Religious Experience in the Greek Life of Adam and Eve
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
John R. Levison, Seattle Pacific University

This paper concretizes the strategies which Amy Hollywood proposes in her paper, "Strategies for the Study of Women's Religious Experience," by analyzing Eve’s autobiographical narrative in the testamentary portion of the Greek Life of Adam and Eve (15-30). This study complements other papers in the session, Women's Religious Experience in Antiquity, including Sarah Iles Johnston's "Women's Religious Experience in the Greek World" and Patricia Ahearne-Kroll’s "The Portrayal of Aseneth's Religious Experience in ‘Joseph and Aseneth.’”


Who Led the Scapegoat in Leviticus 16:21?
Program Unit: Israelite Religion in its Ancient Context
Theodore J. Lewis, Johns Hopkins University

A celebrated passage in the book of Leviticus prescribes the ritual of public atonement for the collective sins of the Israelites, to be performed by Aaron, the high priest, as part of the Yom Kippur purgation. It involves two goats, one to be sacrificed as a sin offering and the other to be led out into the wilderness by a man called ‘itti. The term ‘itti is a hapax. The root is traditionally taken to be ‘et (“time, appointed time”), but translators have not succeeded in deriving a term from it that is appropriate to the context. Translations based on Talmudic tradition (NRSV: “designated for the task”) or the LXX hetoimos (JPS: “in waiting”) tell us nothing of consequence about the man who is to lead the scapegoat. We suggest that the description of the man involved was of great significance to the ritual and propose an entirely new interpretation. Our proposal is based on comparative Hittite and Greek traditions, which suggest that the person assigned this dangerous task had to be expendable. Accordingly, we also offer a different etymology of the word ‘itti, derived from Northwest Semitic (Phoenician, Syriac, Aramaic; cf. Ugaritic) and Arabic cognates.


Jerusalem of Gold: Holy City through the Ages
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Richard Libowitz, Temple University

Jerusalem sits high upon the mountainous spine of the Holy land, looking east to the desert and west to the sea. It has been the focal point for prayer, priest, pilgrim and plunderer for more than three millennia. This paper offers a physical history of the city, from its pre-Israelite origins through periods of growth (and decline) during the Monarchic, Persian, Second Commonwealth, Roman, Ottoman, Mandate and Modern periods. It examines changes in the city's dimensions, modern growth outside the walls and attitudes expressed by Jews, christians, and muslims for the "Holy City."


Matthew 23:13
Program Unit: New Testament Mysticism Project
Andrea Lieber Merwin, Dickinson College

A commentary on Matthew 23:13 will be presented.


Project on the Textual History of 1 Samuel: Looking for Fragments of the Syrohexapla
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Marketta Liljeström, University of Helsinki

The Syrohexapla of 1 Samuel is extremely poorly preserved. The fragments published by Baars, de Boer, and Goshen-Gottstein amount to only 56 verses, and those still unpublished do not add much. Even more fragmentary are the quotations in the works of Ishodad of Merw, Barhebraeus, and Andreas Masius, but they do shed some light on the Syrohexapla. Many of these fragments and quotations have been discussed by Sebastian Brock in his 1966 dissertation. In this paper I will discuss a few examples to demonstrate the nature and the problems of the Syrohexaplaric material in 1 Samuel. What kinds of texts lie behind these fragments and quotations? How reliable are they as Syrohexaplaric witnesses? Which column of the Hexapla are they reflecting if any?


A Superior Literary Version of Ezekiel: p967
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Ingrid E. Lilly, Emory University

Greek papyrus p967 is a literary version of Ezekiel superior to that presented in the MT. The MT version of the same material is formally disrupted and literarily episodic in comparison. I will argue that here the criteria of lectio dificilior is not adequate. Lectio Dificilior does not account for important factors in the production and transmission of literary complexes. Thus, p967 emerges as a crucial text for determining the earliest version of Ezekiel. The striking differences between the MT and p967 occur in chapters 37-39. Three important distinctions in p967 present themselves: a transposition, an omission and a unique gap in the otherwise continuously wrapped text. As a result, Ch. 38-39 features as a conclusion to the first 36 chapters of the book. Likewise, ch. 37 forms a fitting introduction to ch. 40-48. The two groupings, preserved in p967, produce a strikingly coherent, literary work. I demonstrate this on the basis of thematic words, plot progression, transitions, and formal congruity.


Images of "High/Low" and the "Way of the LORD" in Isaiah
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Bo Lim, Trinity Evangelical Divinity School

This study attempts to define the “way of the Lord” in Isaiah 40-66 by examining the related images of “high/low,” and “crooked/straight.” For a century the majority of scholars have interpreted the “way” of Second Isaiah as a literal road extending from Babylon to Palestine and Third Isaiah’s quotations of 40:3 as figurative, ethical, and spiritualized reinterpretations of this “way.” By understanding these images in relation to the “way” motif, the author argues that the “way” of TI is consistent with that of SI.


Honouring A. Graeme Auld
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Timothy H. Lim, University of Edinburgh

Honouring A. Graeme Auld


Overhearing David's Lament for Jonathan and Saul
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Tod Linafelt, Georgetown University

David's elegy for Jonathan and Saul in 2 Samuel 1 is introduced with the note, “it is written in the book of Jashar." If we can imagine encountering the poem in such an anthology it would serve as a particularly fine example of ancient Hebrew verse and would read as a genuine expression of David's grief over their deaths. But of course the elegy, as readers encounter it now, is not a freestanding poem, but has a particular context in the larger narrative of 1 and 2 Samuel. A close reading of the poem in its present context demonstrates a series of concrete echoes from the surrounding narrative which sustain a second, deeply ironic level of meaning to the poem. If the first level of meaning is a celebration of the former military prowess and unity of purpose of Saul and Jonathan and presents a moving expression of grief at the news of their deaths, the second level of meaning – mobilized by repeated allusion to the surrounding narrative, and reinforced by structure, diction, and imagery – is a consistent denigration of Saul and Jonathan, implying that Israel is in fact better off with them gone and David now in line for the throne. Particular attention will be paid to theories of poetic voice and of the apostrophic mode in order to get at the nature of poetic address as it relates to David's lament.


Israeli Historians and Biblical History
Program Unit:
Oded Lipschits, Tel Aviv University

In this paper I will describe the main areas of research, the trends and the historiographic intentions in the Israeli research of Biblical history from the 1950's to present days. I will compare it with the general tendencies in European and American research, and will demonstrate the similarities and differences, trying to explore what are the different methods, intentions and motivations of Israeli scholars.


By Royal Appointment: God's Influence on Influencing God
Program Unit: Theology of the Hebrew Scriptures
Diana Lipton, Newnham College

'When my father was a king/ He was a king who knew exactly what he knew,/ And his brain was not a thing/ Forever swinging to and fro and fro and to./ Shall I, then, be like my father/ And be wilfully unmoveable and strong?/ Or is it better to be right?/ Or am I right when I believe I may be wrong?' (The King and I). Must an all-powerful king be immutable, or can he open himself to influence in whatever form it might take? The King of Siam’s puzzle is precisely the one that interests me in relation to God. There is no Anna, not even an Asherah, but there is the choice to be influenced. Reading two biblical narratives on kingship (1 Sam. 12:12-25 and 2 Kgs. 18-19) in the light of two rabbinic parables on the same theme (Midrash Tanchuma Devarim on Metatron and the death of Moses, and Bereishit Rabbah 22.9), I suggest the biblical writers saw kingship both as a locus of God’s power and, more surprisingly, as a vehicle through which God allows himself to be affected (educated). My strategy requires discussion of some negative aspects of kingship. Alongside reassuring accounts of an idealized ruler are narratives that evoke an unfamiliar, all-too-human king. Through a close rereading of these texts, I show that the boundaries between divine and human kingship are more blurred than the standard account suggests, and that a constructive theological value emerges once we acknowledge this. The idea of divine kingship does not merely inspire awe and command respect for a God who is essentially remote. It holds out the hope that God is receptive to the needs of humanity, and offers a route by which he can be approached.


Sinai 1 and Sinai 2: Their Place in Biblical Manuscript Tradition
Program Unit:
Robert Littman, University of Hawai'i

Sinai Greek 1 and Sinai Greek 2, belonging to the 10th through 12th centuries, contain the Pentateuch and early prophets. While there are no colophons, nor indications of their origins, they are most likely copies of older mansucripts made by monks in St. Catherine’s Monastery. This paper will attempt to determine the Septuagint textual tradition to which these manuscripts belong, by comparing them to the three main Greek manuscripts, the Codex Vaticanus, the Codex Alexandrinus and the Codex Sinaiticus.


Ha-Hodes Ha-zeh: The Interpretive History of Exodus 12:1–2 from the Biblical through Medieval Eras
Program Unit: Poster Session
Andrea D. Lobel, McGill University

This poster presentation will trace the historical interpretive arc inspired by Exodus 12:1-2 and its commandment to observe the new moon of the month of Nisan and maintain a calendar so as to fix the festivals in their proper seasons. An examination of evolving religious sensibilities as filtered through the prism of these two Hebrew Bible verses, this presentation will outline manifold interpretations found in Jewish and early Christian literature from the biblical era through the medieval period. The literary sources to be examined will span the poetic and fanciful interpretations of Aggadic Midrash, the magical and astrological readings found in the Pseudepigrapha, Philo of Alexandria and Josephus, as well as the thematic reframing of lunar motifs in the Patristic literature. Other religious and literary writings to be summarized will include those of ancient Jewish commentators such as the Tannaim, Amoraim and medieval thinkers such as Rashi, Ibn Ezra, and Maimonides, as well as those of the Church Fathers and biblical faith groups such as the Samaritans. Throughout, the emphasis will be upon understanding the interpretive literary trajectory of these biblical verses, as well as upon the light these religious, calendrical and astronomical interpretations have shed upon the writers’ changing understanding of humanity’s place in the cosmos.


The Human's Naming of the Creatures as the World's (and God's) Open Future: A Conflict of Interpretations among Jews, Muslims, and Mormons
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
Michael Lodahl, Point Loma Nazarene University

*


True Israel: Passover and Purity in Chronicles and Ezra
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Dale Loepp, University of California, Berkeley

Recent scholarly investigation into the books of Chronicles and Ezra-Nehemiah has challenged the views of earlier modern exegetes who generally supported a theory of single authorship for these works. Newer scholars, the most notable of which are probably H.G.M. Williamson and Sara Japhet, initially founded their arguments for disparate authorship on linguistic and stylistic evidence. More recently however, arguments have been based on variants in the essential themes, ideologies and rhetoric employed by the texts. This paper focuses on one of these essential themes, that of varying attitudes toward purity as expressed through descriptions of the celebration of Passover: 2 Chronicles 30 and 35:1-19 versus Ezra 6:19-22. First, using the work of Emile Durkheim, Mary Douglas and others, I describe how ritual meals help create communal bonds and form identity within the bounds of particular purity rules. Even though Douglas’s work does not specifically address Passover, her essential components of the ritual meal fit well with the rules prescribed for Passover in Exodus 12 and Numbers 9. Then, using the aforementioned texts from Chronicles and Ezra, I show that when ritual meal purity is properly understood in its role as identity marker, the reader can see that the author of Chronicles is taking a radically different view toward those may celebrate the Passover than does the author of Ezra. These views, in turn, shape and are shaped by differences in each author’s more fundamental understanding of who constitutes the “true Israel.” I conclude by noting that both authors see recognition of Jerusalem-based worship as an essential part of national identity, but that they remain divided on the issue of participation within it. This important difference in turn supports the more recent scholarly work arguing for separate authorship.


Seeking Jesus: A Cultural Genealogy of Crossan and Reed, "Excavating Jesus"
Program Unit: Social History of Formative Christianity and Judaism
Burke O. Long, Bowdoin College

This presentation explores the political. ideological, and cultural dimensions of a popularized description of Jesus and first century Palestine as found in Crossan and Reed, _Excavating Jesus_. By analyzing the authors’ text in relation to the “archaeologically accurate” paintings included in the book, Long locates the genealogy of Crossan’s and Reed’s work in a cultural history of yearnings for the real, for a re-vitalized, domesticated and scrubbed-up Holy Land that is ripe for renewed religious experience.


Ephesians as Christ's Politeia? Wisdom Discourse in Communal Context
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Fredrick James Long, Bethel College

Wisdom Discourse in Mediterranean antiquity, which entails living the fruitful life, is expressed not only in personal-moral contexts as ethical-philosophical discourse, but also is articulated in communal-civic contexts as politeia or political discourse. Epictetus' Enchiridion as an example of ethical-philosophical wisdom discourse, Cicero's De re publica as an example of communal-civic wisdom discourse, and Paul's letter to the Ephesians as an example of early-Christian communal-ethical wisdom discourse, will be examined with respect to wisdom topoi and argumentative strategies associated with these topoi. This paper explores the relationship between communal-civic and individual-moral dimensions of wisdom discourse, with the goal being to identify wisdom topoi that are associated with each (communal and individual) and their possible interrelation.


Learning Christ: The Dynamics of Moral Formation in Ephesians
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Fredrick James Long, Bethel College

The letter to the Ephesians presents a grand vision of "walking" or praxis for the Ekklesia of Christ. Five “walking” sections are strategically elaborated in the final three chapters. Pivotal is the recognition of the progressive presentation of what the moral life consists, its relation to God's and Christ's agency in bringing about this life, and the communal/social dimensions supporting this life. Central to the specific actualization of moral living is the affirmation that the hearers "have learned Christ…as the truth is in Jesus” (4:20f). This learning is elaborated according to a three-step procedure involving repentance, renewal of the mind, and re-imaging according to God in true holiness and righteousness (4:22-24). This procedure can be correlated not only with other Pauline letters (e.g. Rom 12:1-2), but also the gospel tradition (Mark 8:34), and important portions of Hebrew Scripture (e.g. Psalm 1; Isa 1:16-17). This paper seeks to expound upon these and other moral formative dimensions of Ephesians through analysis of its rhetorical argumentation and structuring.


From Text to Claim: Teaching Homiletical Exegesis
Program Unit: Homiletics and Biblical Studies
Thomas Long, Emory University

*


1½ Reasons for Romans (Debt Owed Turned to Debt Owing)
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Bruce Lowe, Macquarie University

Why was Romans written? History provides many different answers. From the Reformation to today (Achtemeier, Keck), a strongly supported position sees it mainly about Paul’s own theology. Even more popular today though, is to see circumstances as central: whether Paul’s travels (to Rome, Spain or Jerusalem), or the Roman situation (e.g. Jew/Gentile conflict). Different combinations of these reasons have often been attempted to account for all the data, and yet rarely is the synchronisation totally satisfying. The Romans Debate is still open for discussion. I will propose in this essay that the reasons presented throughout history can be unified most smoothly when Romans is seen as an item of commercial value. Cicero’s ‘Topica’ provides evidence that letters from experts in their field of expertise, to those seeking such expertise were sometimes used like legal tender to pay debts, and even to incur debt –thus making it possible to request certain services from the recipient. I believe that apparent debt owed (first half-of-a-reason), turned to a debt owing to Paul (actual reason) is the unifying idea behind the letter. Paul states that he is in debt to the Christians at Rome, owing them the gospel (1:13-15). He is not sure when he might visit however (1:10), and so the letter serves as a substitute for his presence –a presentation of this gospel (see 1:16-17). Yet to increases its value he tailors his presentation to the audience’s needs (just as Cicero does). All this is rhetoric however, because by ch.15 he claims they didn’t need his instruction (15:14), or the gospel preached (15:20-21). No debt was required, but with a valuable letter in hand they now owe Paul (c.f. Phlm 18-19) support for Spain (15:24). This he illustrates to them by the debt paid by Gentiles Christians to his Jerusalem mission (15:25-27).


Is the Judgment Scene in The Testament of Abraham Egyptian?
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Jared Ludlow, Brigham Young University, Hawaii

As pointed out by many scholars including Dale Allison in his excellent commentary on the Testament of Abraham, there are puzzles from the judgment scene that have perplexed Testament of Abraham scholars. One difficulty is making sense of two pairs of gates with two different individuals enthroned between them. Another puzzle is the presence of one angel overlooking the weighing of the scales and another testing the souls by fire. Shouldn’t one method suffice? A further puzzle is how the text describes Abel asking for sins and good deeds to be read out of a book, but a recording angel is there writing down the sins and good deeds of the souls. As Allison queries, “What is the function of recording angels if sins and good deeds are already written in the book on the table?” In all these cases and others, a better understanding of the notion of judgment depicted in Egyptian sources might help answer some of these puzzles. The surface parallels between some aspects of Egyptian judgment and the Testament of Abraham have been mentioned by scholars, but a closer, detailed study of Egyptian texts and vignettes has usually been lacking. By more carefully examining the Egyptian milieu of the judgment of scales several possible puzzles of the Testament of Abraham might be answered. Although undoubtedly there were many influences on the Testament of Abraham’s judgment scene, I think we can conclude that an Egyptian judgment scene formed the core for the Testament of Abraham judgment scene. The author(s) of the Testament of Abraham then changed the identity of certain elements to fit their own worldview, but presumably they found enough value and/or similarity in the Egyptian judgment scene to appropriate it for their own purposes.


A Survey of Latter-day Saint Scholarship on John
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
Jared Ludlow, Brigham Young University, Hawaii

This paper will survey and examine LDS related works on the writings of John, with particular attention paid to the Gospel of John. Various works through the past couple of decades will be examined to see what approach or approaches LDS scholars typically have taken with John. Some representative questions that will be pursued include: What topics relevant to John have been of most interest to Latter-day Saint scholars? What assumptions have they made about John and his writings? What LDS conclusions or insights have been distinctive or significant? How have LDS doctrines driven or influenced those conclusions or insights? What influence has non-LDS biblical scholarship had on LDS approaches? Hopefully this survey will give a good overview on how LDS scholarship has approached the writings of John, what contributions they have made to better understanding John, and how their scholarship fits within the broader field of biblical studies.


Are New Testament Manuscripts Trash? On the Use and Disuse of Early Christian Texts
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
AnneMarie Luijendijk, Princeton University

Are New Testament manuscripts trash? The answer to this question, surprisingly, is: yes. New Testament and other early Christian writings played an important role in the life of their communities, but how were the actual manuscripts containing these texts regarded and how were they discarded? It is well-known that Jews deposited their disused writings in a genizah. Moreover, two important finds from the previous century show great care for the manuscripts: the Qumran scrolls hidden away in caves, and the Nag Hammadi codices buried in a jar. Yet not all ancient writings were packed away so carefully. Over the last one hundred years or so, parts of ancient Christian texts– canonical and non-canonical – have been discovered on the garbage heaps of ancient Egyptian cities such as Oxyrhynchus. These papyrus fragments rank among the earliest and most important witnesses for the text of the New Testament. Taking a social historical approach, this paper explores why Christian manuscripts ended up on these trash heaps and thus touches upon the question how ancient Christians used and treated their books.


Finding Discreet Sentential Structures in the New Testament
Program Unit: Computer Assisted Research
Albert L. Lukaszewski, St. Andrews, Scotland

For close to three decades, students of the New Testament have been able to search the Greek text morphologically. Recently, my work on the Lexham Syntactic Greek New Testament has made it possible to search the New Testament syntactically. The present paper considers how one may use this database to find discreet structures in the syntax of New Testament Greek. The sentential structures highlighted will include the internal syntax of subordinate clauses, frames of dialogue, the use of quotations, and the intertwining of relative and participial clauses as manifest in the Catholic Epistles.


New Light on the Nazarenes’ Anti-Rabbinic Slander and Birkat ha-Notsrim
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Petri Luomanen, University of Helsinki

At the end of the fourth century two Church fathers, Epiphanius and Jerome, started to refer to a Jewish-Christian ”heresy” of the Nazarenes. While Epiphanius’ description seems to be based mainly on his creative imagination (see Luomanen, “Nazarenes.” Pages 279–315 in Companion to the Second Century Christian ”Heretics.” Edited by A. Marjanen and P. Luomanen. Supplemets to Vigiliae Christianae 76. Leiden: Brill 2005), Jerome provides some reliable evidence of scriptures that were used by the Nazarenes: their Commentary on Isaiah and their copy of the Gospel of Matthew in Hebrew/Aramaic (Vir. ill. 3). Although scholars have noticed the Nazarenes’ anti-rabbinic polemics in the Commentary on Isaiah, the “Gospel of the Nazarenes” has not usually thought to be particularly anti-rabbinic. The contents of early Jewish-Christian gospels have to be reconstructed on the basis of fragments preserved by Church fathers. The present paper introduces a new reconstruction of the “Gospel of the Nazarenes” which challenges the widely accepted “Three Gospel Hypothesis” (which presumes the “Gospel of the Ebionites,” the “Gospel of the Nazarenes” and the “Gospel of the Hebrews”) and casts fresh light on the Nazarenes’ anti-rabbinic exegesis. The Nazarenes’ exegetical trickery twisted the wordings of Isaiah and Matthew against their rabbinic opponents and in the Nazarene version of Jesus’ trial (cf. Matt 27:15–48) the mob requires Pilate to release the “son of our Rabbi” (Jerome, Comm. Matt. 27.16). Overall, the Nazarenes’ exegesis shows how Matthew’s criticism of Jewish authorities and people—and especially the Matthean version of Jesus’ trial—was applied in the heat of later Jewish Christian debates. If the Nazarenes’ slander of the Rabbis was more developed than has been assumed thus far, this may also explain why Jerome notes that the Jews regularly ”curse” the Nazarenes in their synagogues (Jerome, Epist. 112.13).


How Different to Be Different? The Cases of Matthew and Revelation
Program Unit: Construction of Christian Identities
Edmondo F. Lupieri, University of Udine

The Gospel of Matthew and the Book of Revelation have a different geographical origin (resp. the Roman province of Syria and that of Asia) and seem to represent two different streams of Early Christianity. It is quite striking the diversity of their judgment on the city of Jerusalem, particularly in its eschatological dimension and especially when compared with its function in History of Salvation, as it appears in the Gospel of Luke and the Book of Acts. Meanwhile, Matthew and Revelation offer a striking analogy in their theological treatment of the use of money and the acceptance of a "market ideology" as opposed to the idea of free donation.


Adding Links to the Intertextual Chain: Early Reader Reception of Ezekiel's Allusions to the Holiness Code
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
Michael A. Lyons, University of Wisconsin, Madison

It is widely recognized that there are a remarkable number of shared words and phrases in the Holiness Code (Lev 17-26) and the Book of Ezekiel. The purpose of this paper is to examine how subsequent scribes and commentators responded to these intertextual connections by making further connections of their own between these two texts.


Depictions of the (Anti-) Ideal Person in the Book of Proverbs and the Egyptian Wisdom Literature
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Sun Myung Lyu, Korean Church of Chicago

Both the Egyptian Wisdom Literature (EWL) and the book of Proverbs use binary anthropology—the representation of humanity via literary characters that embody moral ideals and anti-ideals—as a key rhetorical device of their moral discourses. The silent man (or the Maat-person, to emphasize the Leitmotif of this character) and the righteous person share many traits including wisdom and repose. These ideal persons are set against the anti-ideal types of the hothead and the wicked person, respectively. Despite the structural similarity in their binary anthropology, however, EWL and Proverbs differ in the way they explain the importance of avoiding the anti-ideal person. While EWL explains the importance of avoiding the hothead from a utilitarian perspective, Proverbs recognizes the infectious potential of bad character as the chief danger of keeping company with such people. This divergence underscores the innovative features of the book of Proverbs vis-à-vis EWL, namely its keen interest in the formation of pious character and its insistence that pursuit of such moral formation is the essence of good life.


The Righteous Petitioner in the Psalter
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Sun Myung Lyu, Korean Church of Chicago

The petitioner in several psalms of Unschuldserklärung (declaration of innocence) proclaims his own righteousness as the basis of divine favor and rescue (See Pss 7, 17, 18, 26, 35, 38, 44, 86). This attitude is often taken, rather dismissively, as the petitioner’s trust in covenantal loyalty or his confidence in his status in the cultic community (von Rad, for example). However, this paper argues that these psalms demonstrate reasonably cohesive conceptions of righteousness that should not be glossed over by a Protestant doctrine of justification or other ideological bents. Rather, the Psalter’s depiction of the righteous petitioner is quite similar to the characterization of the virtuous person in virtue ethics, and finds its closest biblical parallel in the portrayal of the righteous person in the book of Proverbs. Definable through specific behavior patterns and character traits, righteousness touted in these psalms is then best understood as a virtue rather than a status. Although these psalms are not collectively linked to wisdom tradition, they nevertheless provide a useful interface between the Psalter and the wisdom literature for constructing a more balanced biblical anthropology, as both uphold human integrity to be more than just a soteriological corollary.


Why Q Vanished
Program Unit: Q
Dennis R. MacDonald, Claremont School of Theology

One of the great unsolved questions in New Testament scholarship is the absence of a single text of Q, the putative but likely source shared my the authors of the Gospels of Matthew and Luke in addition to the Gospel of Mark. Many scholars have taken this textual absence as evidence that it never existed; others attribute it to historical accident; others argue that Q’s community lost its distinctive identity; while others suggest that Q’s theology or literary form became passé after the composition of the Synoptics. This paper proposes that Q vanished because it made predictions about Jesus’ return before the destruction of the temple, predictions that the Jewish War proved to be wrong.


The Biggest Blunder Exegetes Make with Reading Ancient Narratives
Program Unit: Future of the Past: Biblical and Cognate Studies for the Twenty-First Century
Dennis R. MacDonald, Claremont School of Theology

*


Children and the Apologetic Function of the Household Code in Colossians and Ephesians
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Margaret Y. MacDonald, St. Francis Xavier University

This paper will explore the function of the instructions about children in teh household codes of Colossians and Ephesians.


Capital Cities in the Neo-Assyrian Empire: The Case of Assur
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Peter Machinist, Harvard University

Because the cities of the Assyrian heartland were so closely bound up with the Assyrian state as a whole, they have often been treated simply as a dependent variable of the state: simply as another manifestation of the workings of the central royal administration. The possibility that these cities had some autonomy and individual character, that they were home to different and differing groups, traditions, and ideologies, has only rarely been touched on, let alone explored. Two of the exceptions were A.L. Oppenheim and Paul Garelli in remarks focused upon the behavior of Assur, the original core city of the Assyrian state, at certain points in the Neo-Assyrian period. The present paper offers an assessment of Oppenheim’s and Garelli’s suggestions in the context of a broader, more systematic survey of the first millennium BC history of Assur, with special attention to the various literary works originating from and/or intended for that city. In so doing, the paper raises some general questions about the nature of the Assyrian imperial system and the complexity of the elites who controlled it.


The Study of Ancient Israelite History: Observations and Reflections on Two Recent Publications
Program Unit: Prophetic Texts and Their Ancient Contexts
Peter Machinist, Harvard University

To say that the study of Israelite history is in turmoil is to say something that by now is too obvious, even too banal to arouse any serious reaction. In a sense it has always been in turmoil, at least since the modern period of Biblical scholarship began some two and a half centuries ago, but no one would deny that in the last couple of decades, the debate has become particularly voluminous, loud, and fierce. Recently, two substantial volumes have appeared seeking to respond to this debate in the course of offering comprehensive syntheses of the history of ancient Israel: (a) Iain Provan, V. Philips Long, and Tremper Longman III, A Biblical History of Israel (2003); and (b) Mario Liverani, Israel’s History and the History of Israel (2005, translated from the Italian of 2003). The scholars involved are well known. Their volumes show them working out their historical syntheses with a mature awareness of the multifarious sources now available and of the complexities of evaluating those sources, pre-eminently, of course, the HB. But the volumes are not alike. Indeed, they take what might be regarded as opposite perspectives on the historical task at hand: Provan, Long, and Longman aiming, as their title advertises, at a deliberately Biblical history of Israel; Liverani, again indicated by the title, offering a more skeptical view of the Bible as an historical source, and designing his history accordingly. The present paper offers a description and evaluation of what these two volumes are about, as a way of reflecting on the larger debate over the study of Israelite history and how that study ought to proceed. In the process, I shall consider other prominent participants in this debate, including Nadav Na’aman, whose publications on Israelite history and historiography have been especially wide-ranging and discerning.


Reading Biblical Allusion and Bakhtin Theory in Flannery O'Connor
Program Unit: Bakhtin and the Biblical Imagination
Bula Maddison, Saint Mary's College

Against our readerly training to seek closure, Bakhtin teaches us to attend to the possibilities for irresolution in narrative. This paper presents a Bakhtinian reading of biblical allusion in “The River” and “Greenleaf” by Flannery O’Connor. Allusion is shown to be a form of double-voicing from a perspective in Bakhtin theory: in allusive language, two voices speak in one. Such dialogization writ large can render a conversation in one narrative between two language worlds. The paper proposes that in these stories, biblical allusions weave a scriptural subtext that contends with the secular storyworld on the surface of the text. The critical literature on both stories is contradictory, split between secular and religious interpretations: Some read the drowning of a child in “The River” as a critique of fundamentalist religion, others find the death an affirmation of exitus et reditus theology. Some conclude that the widow in the story “Greenleaf” dies as a comeuppance for her bad attitude; others feel that she dies as the beloved of Jesus, in his embrace. Some critics appear to be reading the modern, secular voice of the text, others the ancient, biblical voice of the subtext. But what Bakhtin holds to be the dialogical nature of truth is upheld in what I read as the stories’ wobble between contending worldviews. The reading of the O’Connor stories is consonant with some readers’ proposals that parable is her genre. The paper concludes with a look at the possible implications of the O’Connor readings for a Bakhtinian understanding of her exemplar in the parables of Jesus.


Apocalypsis and Messianism in the Back-Country of Brazil
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Antonio Magalhães, Methodist University of São Paolo

Apocalyptic and messianic-millennialism narratives have always been important in the making of Brazilian culture and of its diverse religious experiences. Since the old days of colonization it has been possible identifying interchanges and conflicts in the melting pot of so many different cultures, but in spite of confrontation and fights there was always dialogue. The author of this paper aims at reflecting on the apocalyptic images and the messianic-millennialism visions of a particular social movement called in Portuguese "Canudos", from press reports but chiefly from the great literary work of Euclides da Cunha, "Os sertões". A tentative translation of this title could be, "Arid and Remote Interior".


Alfred the Great and the Law of Exodus: The Afterlife of Biblical Law in Early Medieval England
Program Unit: Biblical Law
F. Rachel Magdalene, Augustana College

This paper will explore the afterlife of the laws of Exodus in early medieval English law. In particular, it will study the intersection of the Decalogue and Covenant Code with the law code of Alfred the Great who ruled the southern Anglo-Saxon kingdom of Wessex from about 871 C.E. to 899 C.E. Alfred was the first King of Wessex to declare himself “King of England,” thus making him of great importance in the history of the British crown. Alfred was a learned man, who was committed to education and who improved the kingdom’s legal system. In regard to the latter, he used prior Anglo-Saxon law codes, the Decalogue, and the certain provisions of the Covenant Code to write what is considered by many to be the first law code of England. This paper will compare and contrast the legal provisions of the Decalogue and the Covenant Code with Alfred’s legal provisions and then offer an analysis of Alfred’s interpretations of these important biblical texts. The methods used will be drawn from biblical narrative criticism, biblical cultural criticism, and legal history.


The "Foundation Deposit" from the Dura Europos Synagogue Reconsidered
Program Unit: History and Literature of Early Rabbinic Judaism
Jodi Magness, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill

The ancient (third century C.E.) synagogue at Dura Europos is famous for its stunning cycle of wall-paintings. In this paper I discuss a less well-known find: parts of human finger bones that were deliberately buried under the threshold of the main doorway leading into the synagogue hall. Carl Kraeling and others have assumed that these bones would have rendered the synagogue and people approaching it ritually impure. However, even if the Jews of Dura followed rabbinic halakhah (which is by no means certain), these bones would not have conveyed impurity. Kraeling interpreted the bones as a foundation deposit, a common phenomenon in the ancient Near East. But the Near Eastern parallels for this practice (all of which are pagan) are inconsistent with the Dura deposit. I believe that the placement of human bones under the threshold of the main doorway leading into the synagogue suggests apotropaic motivations. Perhaps the bones represent the remains of someone who the congregation hoped would intercede with God on their behalf. In this regard the relics of saints buried under the apses of churches might provide a better analogy than ancient Near Eastern foundation deposits, although obviously there are significant differences.


The Arch of Titus in Rome and the Spoils of Jerusalem Panel
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Jodi Magness, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill

The Arch of Titus in Rome and the Spoils of Jerusalem Panel In this paper I consider the spoils of Jerusalem panel in the Arch of Titus in relation to the following issues: 1) the route of the triumphal procession; 2) the location and date of the arch; 3) the reason for the prominent depiction of the menorah and showbread table.


Lost Space and Revived Memory: The Role of Female Personification of Space in Lamentations
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Christl M. Maier, Yale University

As the Katrina disaster has shown, the unexpected destruction of a space may generate enhanced efforts to establish a collective memory of the space that would help to promote its rebuilding. Yet, images of destruction will still remain part of this memory as will narratives about life before and after this event. The paper aims to analyze the role of Lamentations in forming a collective memory about Jerusalem’s fall and rise. It argues that the feminization of the space in the figure of weeping Zion shapes the memory of the readers in a twofold way. On the one hand, it gives voice to unspeakable suffering and feeds into rituals of mourning. On the other hand, it sustains the readers’ emotional connection to the space and generates new metaphors that become symbols of survival.


Daughter Zion: A Larger Than Life Portrait
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Christl M. Maier, Yale University

Although Daughter Zion is a literary figure, the plausibility of this metaphor partly stems from an accepted view of the life and behavior of a young woman and thus from a conscious or unconscious role model of the society in which the texts are written. The paper treats Daughter Zion as a female character and analyses its traits, speech and relations to other characters, esp. to God the (metaphorical) father by using insights of Mieke Bal’s narratological theory. This analysis also gives attention to Zion’s different portraits in the prophecies of Isaiah, Jeremiah, Micah, and Zechariah by interpreting each of these portraits with regard to each book’s overall message and setting. The goal is to determine the function of the female character for ancient readers alongside the following questions: Which voice(s) does Daughter Zion represent? What makes her character appealing or appalling? How do emotions play out in the portrait? What is, after all, the role model for a daughter mirrored in these texts?


Roman Imperial Iconography and the Social Construction of Early Christian Identity
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Harry O. Maier, Vancouver School of Theology

A recent topic amongst art historians has been the role of Roman imperial art in helping to promote the construction of elite and non-elite identities in the Roman Empire. How imperial images were viewed, and the ways they urged a particular kind of seeing, differed greatly according to the status of the viewer. To date this scholarship has not been applied to the study of Pauline literature and its audiences. This is surprising, especially since the majority of Paul’s audiences were constituted by impoverished illiterate people whose lives were surrounded by imperial imagery expressing forms of divinely appointed social domination. This paper takes up theories of audience reception of imperial art, especially of non-elite viewers, and then applies those insights to see what new light may be caste on Paul’s theological, social, and political ideals, and how the apostle positioned his viewing audience to a counter-imperial way of seeing.


Bush’s Apocalypse: Themes from Revelation in Washington, DC
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Harry O. Maier, Vancouver School of Theology

The President who chose that war horse of Revelation- inspired song, “The Battle Hymn of the Republic” for the Hymn of the Day to accompany the National Day of Prayer and Remembrance for the victims of 9/11 signaled that ideas close to or drawn directly from the Book of Revelation would have pride of place in the communication and shaping of foreign policy in the months and years to come. This paper explores, primarily through the analysis of President Bush’s speeches, how his administration draws upon the motifs of Revelation, and how its adaptations belong to a centuries’ long utilization of Revelation to promote a particular vision of American nationalism. While the President is too often associated in both the popular media and the Academy with pre-Millennialist themes of the Christian Dispensationalist Right, a closer analysis shows that Bush’s millennialism is an uneasy compatriot with his conservative supporters. The Bush Administration has created in its national and foreign policy formulations not only room for pre-millennialist interests, but also a Revelation-inspired power allegiance that in its resulting mythos offers a virtually unassailable world-view, and assures that the Book of Revelation will be in America’s political imagination for some time to come.


Silence and Voice; Success and Failure; (Wo)men along the Way in Mark
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Robert D. Maldonado, California State University, Fresno

This paper is an analysis of the ways in which different characters attempt to silence or give voice to other characters with varying degrees of success and failure in the Gospel according to Mark. This perspective provides a way to think about the values that may have contributed to the construction of such a narrative in such a way. Second, it provides a conversation node for reflecting on the dynamics of silence and voice in contemporary communities along sex/gender, race and class lines. Thus, the feminist methodological infusion of this paper is both literary historical and social critical. The results of this study suggest that, for example, the successes AND failures of Jesus to silence and elicit voice have interesting implications for thinking about power, silence and voice in the contemporary worlds. Finally, I explicitly situate this analysis within the context of teaching bible from a feminist perspective in a wildly diverse, polyglot, working class Hispanic Serving public comprehensive university and the various ways in which silence and voice are both and neither political stances in negotiating identity, my own and my students'.


Torturing the Demons: Exorcism, Terror, Violence, Destruction, and God
Program Unit: Bible and Cultural Studies
Robert D. Maldonado, California State University, Fresno

In Mark 5:7, the demons ask of and command Jesus, “What have you to do with me, Jesus, son of the highest god? I adjure you by god, do not torture me!” Tina Pippin has explored the dynamics of the ethics of the orgy of violence in the Markan apocalypse (Semeia 72). The violence unfortunately extends beyond. Here in Mark 5 the demons are apparently fair game for torture and their demise warrants an apparently gleeful and justified response on the part of the hearer. And who could disagree? They are, after all, DEMONS! Such discourse, however, begs the question as to what counts as demonic and who gets to say so. It raises the question of how this text can be and is read over and over without ever thinking about torture. The first part of the paper explores the dynamics of exorcism, violence and torture within the broader narrative framework of Mark. The second part develops the ways in which (anti)patriarchy gets caught up in attempts at justified/justifying as well as not noticing torture via demonizing the opposition. This then is brought in the final part into juxtaposition with current discourses on torture, state and human interests, the demonic, and the war on terror. The result shows the fraughtness in standing for justice of all in a world constructed by Good Guys/Bad Guys.


Solomon’s Wisdom and Wealth or Sidon’s Fall? Mixed Messages for the Traders
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Sarah Malena, University of California, San Diego

The chiefly positive image of Solomon as a successful trade administrator contrasts sharply with the predominately negative views of the traders themselves. Traders in the biblical texts are usually nomads and seafarers, often described as related to the Israelites through distant ancestors, but also perceived as foreign and hostile, and in the prophetic texts, the trader reaches his lowest depiction as an illustration of the basest of humans. What accounts for such a mixed opinion of the trader’s activities? Transmission of ideas and practices inevitably accompanies transmission of material goods. Israel’s involvement in trade activity brought not only economic advantages but also critical ideological challenges. This paper evaluates what we know of Israel’s role in interregional trade from textual and archaeological sources in order to assess the impact of such activity on Israelite life and why traders were remembered in such a contradictory manner in the biblical text.


The Efficacious Text: Implications of English Bible Folklore
Program Unit: Scripture as Artifact
Brian Malley, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor

English folk rituals involving Bibles provide the empirical ground for an exploration of the relationship between Bibles’ semantic properties—especially their relevance—and Bibles’ physical properties. While in literacy the material properties of a text are treated semantically, as serving the text’s meaning, in these English folk rituals the semantic properties of a text are treated as materially efficacious. Particular attention will be paid to the “Bible & key,” a widespread form of bibliomancy documented in several variants. The nature of the (structuralist) inversion of literacy and Bible ritual is analyzed in terms of current theories about the interaction of cognition and culture, with special attention to the ways in which such practices are transmitted.


Masked Anonymity in Theophanic Thunderstorm: Divine Act of Revealing and Concealing
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Daniel Maoz, University of Waterloo

In Amos 4:13 divine revelation and natural phenomenon coincide. Using this text as a case study, my paper explores to what degree each of theophanies in Amos reveal and/or conceal their source. It begins with definition and analysis of theophany in both ANE context and Hebrew Bible text before turning to what is specific to Amos and his world and word. Divine representation as storm-wind and thunderstorm is traced to other biblical theophanic traditions (e.g., Pss, Nah) as here and elsewhere in Amos (5:9; 9:5). I consider what antecedent and contemporary literary (see J-G Heintz, Oracles prophetiques et 'guerre sainte' selon les archives royales de Mari et l'Ancien Testament") and theophanic traditions existed outside of Amos' community and cultus (e.g., with Adad at Karkara; Amun-Re at Heliopolis and Ipet-Sut). Other considerations include reasons for inclusion of the latter reference if the concluding doxology has been added to a text that originally ended at 8:8 (see F. Horst, "Die Doxologien im Amosbuch," ZAW 47; J. D. W. Watts, "An Old Hymn Preserved in the Book of Amos," JNES 15). All set in a four-part hymn which is separated and balanced throughout the larger unit at 1:2, 4:13, 5:8-9, and 9:5, this particular theophany offers as primary emphasis of overall theme the harsh reality of a divine judge hidden?/revealed? in the equally harsh natural world.


Travel, Contact, and Argument in the Empire: Topics for a Feminist, Postcolonial Analysis of Philippians
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
Joseph A. Marchal, Austin College

This study aims to focus on the dynamics of travel and contact in the argumentation of Paul’s letter to the Philippians as part of an ongoing effort to develop a feminist, postcolonial analysis of Pauline letters. Conceiving of Philippi as an ancient, colonized “contact zone” and Philippians as possibly an instance of travel literature should aid in investigating the role of women, gender, and sexuality in historic and discursive colonization. Given Roman imperial control and the colonia’s place on an important route for travel, ancient Philippi brought people of disparate ethnic, cultic, political, and/or geographical origins together. Though this mixing involved conflict and asymetrical dynamics, the conditions of contact (rather than an empire’s “frontier”) emphasizes the mutual agency of colonized and colonizer. Such a conceptualization provides an opportunity, then, to develop further reflections upon and reconstructions of the role of women in the contact zone. Thus, renewed attention should be paid to the role of Euodia and Syntyche and the dynamic presented in the letter between Paul and these two Philippian women.


Boundaries, Binaries, and Belonging: Assessing and Engaging the Violent Rhetorics of Philippians
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Joseph A. Marchal, Austin College

An assessment of the argumentation of Philippians that moves towards hiearchy, conformity, othering and threats of violence.


A User-Friendly Introduction to Gérhard Weil’s Masora Magna
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
David Marcus, Jewish Theological Seminary of America

An introduction to Gérhard Weil’s Masora Magna, also known as Massorah Gedolah, which was published in 1971 to accompany the edition of Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia (BHS) by the Biblical Institute Press, Rome. This paper will illustrate how Weil’s Masora Magna is organized, and how it correlates with the Masoretic apparatus of BHS. The relationship of the Masora magna notes to the Masora parva notes will be discussed as well as demonstrating how Weil edited the Masora magna notes in the Leningrad manuscript for his edition. The paper will suggest some ways in which the Masora magna can be used as a tool in biblical research, and will illustrate the differences between the presentation of the Masorah magna notes in Weil’s edition as compared with their presentation in the new Biblia Hebraica Quinta (BHQ) edition.


Present and Absent: Women at Greco-Roman Wedding Meals
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
Susan Marks, New College of Florida

Did the bride figure in the imagination of guests at the wedding meal or did she, physically, make an appearance? Glimpses of weddings in Jewish, Christian and other sources provide conflicting answers to this question, as well as to questions concerning dining customs for women relatives and attendants. As the seminar examines practices involving women at funerary and other meals, the evidence from weddings proves invaluable.


Keep Your Distance: The Rhetoric of Travel and Patronage in Horace and Paul [Epistles 1.7 and 2 Corinthians 1–9]
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Timothy Luckritz Marquis, Yale University

This paper analyzes Horace’s Epistles 1.7 and 2 Corinthians 1-9 as two innovative uses of the epistolary motif of “travel plans” to manipulate the status implications of a patron-client relationship. Building on recent scholarship, this paper examines how Horace refashions his relationship with Maecenas by simultaneously changing travel plans, insisting on autonomy, and flattering a benefactor. In refusing to return to Rome, Horace manipulates his relationship with his patron by refashioning their respective personae, depicting himself as absurdly ungrateful and Maecenas as effortlessly generous. Horace flatters his patron and instructs his audience (both Maecenas and the public audience of his poem) about the autonomy which characterizes the socially unattached life. The poem portrays an intellectual client who enjoys the benefits of patronage while rhetorically pulling the strings of the relationship. Similarly, Paul writes 2 Corinthians 1-9 in order to manipulate his relationship with the community in light of a dispute rooted in uncertainty about the status implications of the relationship between an “apostle” and his community. Paul uses his altered plans to visit Corinth as an opportunity to simultaneously flatter the community by depicting them as an essential aspect of his mission and assert his authority evinced through his social self-lowering through tireless travel. Paul innovatively manipulates his relationship with the Corinthians by appealing to their emotions and re-contextualizing his relationship with them. A fuller understanding of each author’s rhetorical innovations requires some reflection on the nexus between pathos-arguments and the manipulation of social status in ancient rhetoric. Thus, this paper will draw insights from ancient rhetorical and epistolary theorists, as well as from contemporary social theorists (Bourdieu, Laclau and Mouffe, Schatzki), to help explain how generic and rhetorical innovations can work to form communities by refashioning various subject positions.


From Usurper to Dynast: Herod the Great and the Evolution of His Political Self-Presentation
Program Unit: Josephus
Adam Kolman Marshak, Yale University

This talk examines the evolution of Herod the Great’s political self-presentation, as he transformed from a supporter of Marcus Antonius and a successor to the Hasmonean dynasty to a partisan of Augustus Caesar and a Hellenistic Jewish king in his own right. By analyzing the literary evidence from Josephus and supplementing it with archaeological and numismatic material, this talk will reveal how Herod altered his self-presentation to suit his evolving political needs. When Herod ascended the throne, he was primarily concerned with creating and maintaining his own legitimacy. As such, he strengthened his connections with both Rome and the previous ruling dynasty, the Hasmoneans. During Herod’s early reign, he was an active supporter of Antonius, offering him military and financial aid as well as bestowing conspicuous public honors on him. Through his architecture, coins and familial maneuvers, Herod also presented himself as a legitimate successor to the Hasmonean dynasty, the family who had ruled Judaea for over one hundred years. The Battle of Actium was a watershed moment for both Herod and the larger Mediterranean world. Augustus’ triumph demanded a shift in political alignment and presentation. Herod immediately began asserting his new allegiance to the Principate through multiple media. He also used this opportunity to step out of the Hasmonean shadow and assert himself as a powerful and glorious Hellenistic Jewish king. Herod began his reign as a bankrupt usurper. He ended it as a wealthy and powerful king who founded a dynasty and brought Judaea to its greatest prominence and prosperity. As his political needs changed, so too did the way he presented himself to his public. By analyzing this shift in presentation, we can gain a better understanding of how Herod manipulated the political system and succeeded as King of Judaea.


Romancing the Eunuch: The Future of Socio-rhetorical Criticism
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Clarice J. Martin, Colgate University

Reflection on the future of socio-rhetorical analysis.


Paul and Agamben among the Postmetaphysicals
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Dale B. Martin, Yale University

In the past few years, several well known scholars who normally do not comment on the Bible have addressed the writings of Paul. Writing as philosophers, cultural commentators, or political theorists, these mainly "Continental" authors--Alain Badiou, Slavoj Zizek, and from the late 1980's, Jacob Taubes--have mined the letters of Paul, especially the Epistle to the Romans, for ideas and themes that may be applied to political and social problems of contemporary Europe. The recent appearance of the English translation of Giorgio Agamben's commentary on Romans, "The Time That Remains," provides an opportunity to compare Agamben's reading of Paul with those of other "postmetaphysical philosophers."


Homohermeneutics
Program Unit: LGBTI/Queer Hermeneutics
Dale B. Martin, Yale University

*


Identifying and Interpreting the "Favissae" of Persian Period Palestine, or, When it’s Not Just Another Pit
Program Unit: Literature and History of the Persian Period
S. Rebecca Martin, University of California, Berkeley

Pits or trenches containing re-deposited cult objects—especially figurines—have been identified throughout Palestine as “favissae”. No standard definition exists for these deposits but “classic” examples from elsewhere in the Levant have guided our opinions, particularly the Phoenician sites of ‘Amrit, Sidon and Kharayeb. Because these are all sanctuaries, archaeologists extrapolate that the generally much humbler “favissae” found in Palestine are markers of now-lost sanctuaries or temples. Further, when a “favissa” contains a number of imports, it may be interpreted as evidence of foreign influence on religious practices and/or foreign occupation at a site. Thus this broadly-interpreted deposit has become a critical marker of organized religion and religious identity in a period when other archaeological evidence, particularly architectural remains, is rare or nonexistent throughout much of the region. Distribution of the “favissae” of the Persian period favors coastal sites, and an examination of a few key deposits from the western border of Judah and on toward the coast will illustrate several of the interpretative challenges facing archaeologists. One key to refining the definition of the “favissa” is to determine how it differs from a pit—a “favissa” is a ritual deposit. Both the objects and the act of deposition will likely vary within a site (particularly over time) and between sites (owing to different religious practices). Nonetheless it is important to consider minimum standards of identification that do not rely solely on external corollaries: we should expect that every “favissa” contains at least some objects used in ritual. We should expect also that the act of re-depositing these objects would be ritualistic in the selection of a site and in the digging, filling and closing of the trench. Distinguishing ritual deposits from trash dumps containing ritual offerings is one important way to begin to refine our understanding of cult practices in the Persian period.


Called to the Ministry of Word in the Classroom
Program Unit:
Thomas Martin, Susquehanna University

While many college professors would describe their profession as a vocation, the presence in the classroom of ordained clergy who see this vocation as also a religious call has increasingly been viewed as problematic. I am a candidate for ordination in the Evangelical Lutheran Church of America. I hold a tenure track position at an ELCA related college. If my ³call² is successfully negotiated with the ELCA, I will be called to my faculty position. I view my place in the classroom as a ³ministry of word.² Yet, only a minority of my students are Lutheran, and the pluralism of North America means that there are always agnostics and atheists present as well. A further level of complexity is that I share my faculty position with my wife, who views the role of faith in the classroom rather differently. This creates interesting dynamics with students who have both of us as professors, prompting them to ask questions about our shared work and shared faith. This presentation will explore how it is that I negotiate my faith, my call, the religious pluralism of the contemporary classroom, and the dynamics of a position shared with a spouse. In part, James Fowler¹s stages of faith will help in explicating how I work to build and nurture faith ­ however a specific student might define its contents ­ in ways consistent with my understanding of my own faith positions. Most specifically, these issues will be discussed against the backdrop of my class on Paul, where, with a number of Lutheran pre-seminary students present, I am intent on teaching the ³new² Paul, leading to a deconstruction of primal Lutheran faith categories such as Law and Gospel and Justification by Faith. The means by which student faith perspectives, mine, and those of our reconstruction of Paul engage one another is proving to be a fertile area of faith development.


Inventing First Peter: Interpretive Insights from Rhetorical Criticism
Program Unit: Methodological Reassessments of the Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Troy W. Martin, Saint Xavier University

This paper surveys the practice of Rhetorical Criticism since Hans Dieter Betz's seminal work on Galatians in the late 1970s. It traces attempts of interpreters to identify the species of rhetoric in New Testament letters, to designate the rhetorical arrangement of these letters, and finally to explore the invention of the argument in these letters. This paper concludes that some of these attempts have been more useful than others in the interpretive process and concentrates on the interpretive insights of invention and in particular the analysis of arguments from ethos, pathos, and logos. This paper then investigates First Peter to illustrate the practice of Rhetorical Criticism and the interpretive insights this method provides for an understanding of this letter. It explores the difficulty of assigning First Peter to one of the three species of rhetoric and proposes that letter formulae are more appropriate than the parts of a speech in a formal analysis of the letter even though some functional similarities exist between the letter formulae and the rhetorical arrangement of speeches. This paper concludes that invention is the most useful aspect of Rhetorical Criticism for an understanding of First Peter, which develops ethical, pathetic, and logical arguments in its strategy of persuasion.


From Midrash to Masorah: History of the Transmissions of the Textual Traditions that Formed the Masorah
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Elvira Martin Contreras, Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas

The development of the masoretic notices is “sketched on the basis of vague hints and with much speculation” (cf. I. Yeivin, Introduction to the Tiberian Masorah, Missoula 1980, pag. 131). Even when the majority of scholars coincide in recognizing the soferim as the first to work in the preservation of the biblical text, the period between their work and the appearance of the Masorah (aprox. S. VI-VII) is vaguely outlined in the masoretic studies. The presence of textual notices in the midrashim and in the Talmud, is usually mentioned in the masorah studies just by bringing up a few examples from diverse sources. The identification and study of the commentaries based on textual details present in the midrashim Genesis Rabbah, Lamentations Rabbah, Sifre Numbers, Sifra Leviticus and the Mekiltah of Rabbi Yismael that I have carried out until the moment, stress the relevance of midrashim in general, and the haggadic one in particular, in the studies about the history and development of the textual traditions included in the Masorah. This paper presents my current research project that aims to analize and study the rest of the midrashim, both haggadic and halakic, dated prior to the appearance of the Masorah, with the goal of tracing the history of the transmission and of the evolution of textual traditions included in the Masorah in a period before its appearance (aprox. 6th to 7th century). The paper also examines the examples of the midrash Leviticus Rabbah in which a textual detail is commented in the language of the Masorah and the most relevant conclusions.


Is There a Whore in 4Q184?
Program Unit: Qumran
Jeromey Martini, University of Edinburgh

Since Allegro’s publication of 4Q184 in 1964, there has been much conjecture regarding the identity of the ‘wicked woman’. In this paper, I am not concerned with establishing who this woman is or what she represents, but only with how she is designated. The nature of the fragments obscures the woman’s designation—one can just make out a final ‘he’, and the construction ‘zonah’ (whore) is typically supplied, based on the author’s obvious dependence on Prov. 1-9. In Prov. 1-9, however, the ‘strange woman’ is nowhere designated a zonah: in 6.26, the zonah is preferred to the adulteress, and in 7.10 the strange woman is said only to wear a zonah’s garments. Furthermore, allegorical uses of zonah in the Hebrew Bible are typically self-designations meant to shame Israel into right behaviour; it is in later Christian rhetoric that the whore represents other peoples and powers. In 4Q184, the zonah does not appear to be a self-designation. With these observations, it is fair to ask if zonah is the best term for the lacuna in 4Q184. In the paper, I will reiterate evidence for the dependence of 4Q184 on Prov. 1-9 and show that the Christian tendency to conflate Proverbs’s ‘strange woman’ with the whore is not yet in evidence in second temple literature by example of Sirach 9.3 and 41.20. I will compare 4Q184 with other references to the zonah from the literatures at Qumran, demonstrating that the zonah is not there used in the sense of this allegory, and I will re-examine the MS photograph for additional clues for possible alternate designations. I will conclude by offering possible alternate designations for the woman in 4Q184.


Project on Ancient Cultural Engagement (PACE)
Program Unit: Computer Assisted Research
Steve Mason, York University

The Project on Ancient Cultural Engagement at York University (PACE) is a resource intended to encourage and assist reflection on problems of social, cultural, and ethnic identity in the Roman world. Since this was an articulated issue chiefly for members of the elite classes, we focus initially on writers who stood conspicuously at the confluence of cultures, and whose compositions were devoted in significant measure to working out problems of identity. Our first two authors are Polybius of Megalopolis and Flavius Josephus. Our site provides the complete Greek texts, each with two English translations, full historical-literary commentary, bibliography, scholarly books and articles, dissertations, images of places mentioned, archaeological summaries, tables of textual parallels, and notes on the history of reception. Such resources are available both as discrete modules (from the front page) and for the reader of the texts in situ. Membership in the Project, open to all qualified scholars, permits indefinite contribution to the site contents.


Sex, Death, and the Apocalypse: Evangelicals and Pornographic Entertainment
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Dan Mathewson, Wofford College

Many scholars argue that apocalyptic ideas emerge in social contexts of oppression and disempowerment, and represent forms of theodicy. This theory, however, fails to account for the popularity among contemporary Evangelicals of apocalyptic ideas, especially entertaining interpretations of Revelation exhibited well in the Left Behind novels. The popularity of apocalyptic ideas within this socially, economically, and politically empowered community likely has to do more with a general tendency in the West toward death entertainment, as articulated by the cultural anthropologist, Geoffrey Goror. According to Gorer, the contemporary era treats the topic of death as sex was treated in the Victorian era: as a taboo topic subject to the rules of social prudery. In contemporary times we tend to evade the topic of natural death in conversation and to regard the natural processes of bodily corruption with disgust. However, the taboo topic in both the Victorian and contemporary eras (sex and death, respectively) becomes the subject of fantasy in pornography, which in our era takes the form of death pornography – the titillation of the taboo, manifested as entertaining thrillers, war stories, horror comics, and more. In pornography the sensations of sex or death are enhanced – the grunts, groans, and images – while the emotions of the act are ignored – love and grief. According to this theory, Evangelical apocalyptic entertainment with its violent images of destruction and death would have little to do with a concern for theodicy, but would be a manifestation of a much larger cultural phenomenon in the West, that of death pornography. This conclusion has interesting implications for Evangelical censorship of various violent movies, video games, and song lyrics. Gorer’s theory suggests that the Evangelical impulse toward apocalyptic entertainment derives from the same source as those forms of entertainment it censures: pornography.


"Father, Forgive Them": The Rhetoric of Mercy in the Violence of Supersession
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Shelly Matthews, Furman University

In this paper I argue that by depicting Jesus and Stephen as praying for God to forgive the Jews who kill them, the second-century author of Luke-Acts is asserting an ethic of extreme Christian mercy as the flip side of his anti-Jewish polemic. Other early Christian authors concerned with establishing boundaries between Christians and Jews follow suit. I will demonstrate first how these assertions of extreme mercy are (ironically and tragically) built on a scaffolding of Jew vilification. I will then show how, in a further series of ironies, the authors and transmitters of these forgiveness prayers strive to mark them as inefficacious. A primary means of rendering them inefficacious is to read them “intransitively”—as indicating the perfection of the one who loves enemies/prays for persecutors, but as having no consequence for actual enemies/persecutors. Other strategies include attaching conditions to the forgiveness prayers that remain unmet by the Jews, and—in the case of Luke 23.34a—simply striking the prayer from the text. I conclude with some assessment of how the assertion of extreme mercy as a Christian proprium, along with its violent undertow of anti-Jewish polemic, continue to function in scholarship on early Jewish and Christian relations.


Hellenists, History, Ethics
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Shelly Matthews, Furman University

In this paper, I argue that Stephen (that is, stephanos or “crown”) is a fictional character, functioning for Luke as the ideal martyr, much in the way that Theophilus functions as ideal reader. Understanding the significance of stephanos as ideal or “proto-martyr” goes far to explain Acts’ eccentric position on early Christian martyrdom in general, and Acts’ silence on the question of Paul’s martyrdom in particular. My argument both builds upon and also seeks to modify the critiques leveled against traditional scholarly reconstructions of the Hellenists in the recent revised dissertations of both Craig Hill and Todd Penner. In particular, I take issue with Penner’s final conclusions on the impossibility of making a judgment on the historicity of the Hellenist pericope. This argument is not a defense of historical positivism, but owes rather to an ethical-rhetorical paradigm of historical reconstruction. It is not only reasonable to make historical judgments about the Hellenist pericope, but also necessary to do so.


Knowledge of Nature Lost or Gained? Open Spaces and Israel's Tribal Villages
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Alice Maung-Mercurio, University of Minnesota, Twin Cities

Integrated models of tribal village land management systems are presented based on a comparative botanical study of dryland ecologies and their agricultural communities. There is sparse paleobotanical data from the study of early Israel’s tribal village sites; however, comparative studies of small-plot agriculture and herding practices tells us that these semi-arid regions contain interstitial spaces of open territory that can provide a wide variety of edible plants such as wild grasses, various tubers, berries and other fruits and nuts that appear over an annual cycle. These areas are also home to a variety of animals and birds that can be hunted or trapped, and also provide additional water catchment systems wherein soil moisture, soil health and resistance to erosion (stability) of adjacent terraced farm fields are promoted. The hypothesized lower human population of the Late Bronze era hill-country of Palestine, which was separated from heirarchical political systems, may have allowed the return of a biodiverse system of plants and animals more closely resembling a pristine area, which is shown here to support the same plant families that have appeared in Israel. Besides cultivated food sources, the variety of available foods from gathering, hunting or trapping may revise our view of the socioeconomic patterns of ancient Israel and estimates of the population carrying capacity of this type of ecology. This study, based on research from the International Center for Research in the Dry Areas (ICARDA, Aleppo, Syria) and from the United Nations Convention to Combat Desertification, reveals the extent and variety of indigenous knowledge and techniques in managing these ecosystems, utilizing early agricultural techniques and long-term food supply stabilization in sustainable ways, providing these human communities sustenance over many generations.


Dryland Ecosystems, Early Israel, and Tribal Village Land Management Practices
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
Alice Maung-Mercurio, University of Minnesota, Twin Cities

Integrated models of tribal village land management systems are presented based on a comparative botanical study of dryland ecologies and their agricultural communities. There is sparse paleobotanical data from the study of early Israel’s tribal village sites; however, comparative studies of small-plot agriculture and herding practices tells us that these semi-arid regions contain interstitial areas of open territory that can provide a wide variety of edible plants such as wild grasses, various tubers, berries and other fruits and nuts that appear over an annual cycle. These areas are also home to a variety of animals and birds that can be hunted or trapped, and also provide additional water catchment systems wherein soil moisture, soil health and resistance to erosion (stability) of adjacent terraced farm fields are promoted. The hypothesized lower human population of the Late Bronze era hill-country of Palestine may have allowed the return of a biodiverse system of plants and animals more closely resembling a pristine area, which is shown here to support the same plant families that have appeared in Israel. Besides cultivated food sources, the variety of available foods from gathering, hunting or trapping may revise our view of the socioeconomic patterns of ancient Israel and estimates of the population carrying capacity of this type of ecology. This study, based on research from the International Center for Research in the Dry Areas (ICARDA, Aleppo, Syria) and from the United Nations Convention to Combat Desertification, reveals the extent and variety of indigenous knowledge and techniques in managing these ecosystems, utilizing early agricultural techniques and long-term food supply stabilization in sustainable ways, providing these human communities sustenance over many generations.


Embryological Themes in Platonic Ontogenesis
Program Unit: Rethinking Plato's Parmenides and Its Platonic, Gnostic, and Patristic Reception
Zeke Mazur, University of Chicago

This paper will explore the possibility that in certain late antique Platonic systems (academic, patristic, and Gnostic) the problem of the derivation of subsidiary ontological levels from a transcendent unity was conceived at least partially in terms of contemporaneous embryology and biological reproduction. In particular, the self-contraction model of ontogenesis, (one subset of the common derivational model involving a primordial self-reversion)-- occurring for example, in the Anonymous Commentary on Plato's Parmenides, the Nag Hammadi treatise Allogenes (according to Turner's reconstruction), Marius Victorinus' Adversus Arium, Plotinus, and elsewhere-- may be related to a prevailing embryological notion that human seed contracted (or breathed) into itself at the moment of successful conception (thus Galen, De Semine I.2.6; also, the Hippocratic On the Nature of the Child 12.1).


The Papyrological Commentary of the Gospel of Mark: Words and Themes Relating to Economic and Social History
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Roberta Mazza, Università di Bologna

The aim of the paper is to illustrate some aspects of the Papyrological Commentary of the Gospel of Mark that I am preparing for the series «Papyrologische Kommentare zum Neuen Testament/Papyrological Commentary of the New Testament» published by Vandenhoeck&Ruprecht. After a short introduction on the volume, I will analyse Mark’s words and themes on the subject of economics in the light of Greek papyri. I will consider the Commentary’s items which help to answer the following questions: Which social strata are represented in the Gospel? Which kind of economy existed in the embedded society at the time of the first Christians? And which kind of economic practices were used by the first generations of Jesus’s followers? From Mark perspective, which kind of economy was promoted by Jesus and his disciples? How could it have been perceived by the first Gospel readers? Even if the theme of economics has usually been seen as secondary in Mark’s Gospel, this material on the whole, compared to other sources, helps reconstruct the Gospel’s attitude towards the problem of social justice, and of poverty and wealth. Moreover it contributes to an understanding of how the first Christians were organized from a socio-economic point of view and how they supported themselves. It also clarifies which social strata they came from and who they invited to join their community. The analysis of the above will demonstrate the coexistence, in Mark, of two economic levels: the first is what I define as ‘economy of the groups’, i.e. the actual economic behaviour of the first Christians; the second one is what I quote as ‘the economy of the Reign’, i.e. an ideal economy or an economic theory, elaborated by the first Christians so as to answer important issues on social ethics and economic practices.


Interpreting the Bible with African Novelists Ngugi wa Thiong'o and Bessie Head
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Andrew Mbuvi, Shaw University

This paper continues the quest to figure out how the African biblical scholar can beneficially engage works of African literature, specifically African novels, in formulating pertinent issues in African theological discourse. African novelists, like the two discussed in this paper, do not shy away from appropriating the Bible in more than a cursory fashion in their writings which leaves the reader with the distinct sense that the Bible is being engaged at an interpretive level. For this purpose, this paper seeks to compare two African novelists whose extensive use of the Bible and biblical imagery plays a central role in their novels. We will be comparing what we perceive to be two divergent ways in which these authors have employed the Bible (narratives, theological terminology, imagery, etc) in their novels and what biblical scholars can glean from these works in relation to the emerging discipline of African biblical hermeneutics.


Israel as Nation in the Priestly Literature
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
J. G. McConville, University of Gloucestershire

My question is 'whether, for the priestly writing, Israel is really a special chosen people of God, or whether it is only a nation whose history is narrated as an example, even though, strictly speaking, a similar history would have to be traced for every nation on earth' (N. Lohfink, Theology of the Pentateuch, p. 129). The question turns on whether P regards Israel at worship in the tabernacle as fulfilling the divine mandate for humanity at creation. Further questions flow from this, namely whether P thinks the divine mandate is thus fully accomplished, or a stage in an ongoing story characterized by unresolved tensions; whether Israel, in fulfilling the mandate, moves in the direction of nationhood; and whether, consequently, it furnishes concepts that are useful in political discourse, such as a distinctive view of citizenship. While the deuteronomic literature has been explored well in connection with such questions (e.g. by Carriere, Grosby), the Priestly has been less so, even though paradigmatic functions have been widely attributed to certain laws of H, especially the Jubilee. Having previously attended principally to deuteronomic political concepts (God and Earthly Power, T&T Clark International, 2006), I wish to turn now to P, to consider in what respects it offers a distinctive view by comparison with Deuteronomy, and the Pentateuchal narrative broadly speaking. I will argue that P does add fruitfully to the biblical discourse on politics, and for a creative dialogue between P and Deuteronomy.


Valentinus Did Not Write the Gospel of Truth
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
J. Woodrow McCree, Wright State University, Main Campus

There are a number of differences between the thought of GTr and the fragments of Valentinus. For example, GTr's creation myth (17.14-20) is more negative in its attitude toward material creation than that of Valentinus in Stromateis IV.89.6-90.1. While this realm is lesser for Valentinus, it reflects the reality of the eternal realm through the grace of that realm; Valentinus would not call this world a "substitute for truth". More significantly, GTr displays a wide range of motifs which are similar to the teaching of later Valentinians, such as Ptolemy's disciples, Marcus and Heracleon. While any of these individual motifs associated with later teachers might be plausibly traced to Valentinus, it is incredible to suppose that ALL such motifs can be traced to the original teaching of the Master. The hypothesis is simply too unwieldy. We should choose the simplest theory. GTr contains a wide array of motifs from a later stage in Valentinian thought precisely because it was written later than the time of Valentinus.


High Priestly Patronage and Philanthropia in the Epistle to the Hebrews
Program Unit: Hebrews
Kevin B. McCruden, Gonzaga University

Integral to Hebrews' highly sacrificial portrait of the Christ event is a profound emphasis on the beneficent aspect of Christ's high priestly status. Hebrews depicts Christ as a "merciful and faithful high priest," (Heb 2:17) who actively "sympathizes" with the "weaknesses" of the faithful (Heb 4:15). This paper explores the exegetical connections to be made between such beneficent christology and the ideas surrounding the virtue of philanthropia as a both a royal and divine attribute in the roman imperial period. Particular attention will be paid to the following areas: the prominent place given to the virtue of philanthropia in relation to the Roman Caesars; the ancient testimonies concerning the beneficent activity of the god Asclepius; and lastly, Philo of Alexandria’s encomium on philanthropia in the De virtutibus. This paper will argue that ancient reflection on the virtue of philanthropia in both Greco-Roman and Jewish sources offers a new and fruitful vantage point from which to appreciate the highly beneficent dimension of Hebrews’ priestly christology. In essence, Hebrews depicts the exalted Christ as the divine patron Son, who in consequence of death is now presently and beneficently available to a beleaguered community likely residing in Rome.


Portraying a Distant Past: The Literary Effects of Genesis 1–11
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Mark McEntire, Belmont University

By all accounts Genesis 1-11 is composed of an odd and diverse set of materials. Traditional methods of reading these texts, such as source-criticism and form-criticism made significant progress in talking about the types of literature in this corpus, the potential settings from which the units may have emerged, and how each unit may be connected to others with similar language, theology, and ideology. These methods have declined in influence partly because they began to approach the limits of their explanatory power, and because they operated with assumptions that could no longer be taken for granted. A more fruitful area of inquiry now involves a shift away from asking “where did this text come from?” toward asking “what is this text doing here?” These two types of questions may not be as unrelated as they initially seem. Genesis 1-11 develops a unique narrative world, one which is obviously different from the world of our experience. Strange names, very long life-spans, indeterminate geography, strange creatures and plants, and a direct link between heaven and earth serve to develop a setting in the distant past which is mysterious and murky. What if the ability to contribute to this sense of dislocation was one of the reasons for choosing certain materials and shaping them in particular ways? What effect might this have had on the earliest readers of Genesis? This paper will examine passages in Genesis 1-11 and ask what they contribute to the construction of its world and how this aspect of those texts relates to some of the conclusions about them reached by historical-critical methods.


An Evaluation of the Reliability of the Synoptic Traditions Based on Investigations into the Long-Term Reliability of Eyewitness Memories
Program Unit: Mapping Memory: Tradition, Texts, and Identity
Robert K. McIver, Avondale College

The on-going study of long-term eyewitness memories allows an assessment to be made of the reliability of the traditions found in the Synoptic Gospels that derive from the collective memories of the early Christian communities. A number of separate studies have shown that flashbulb and other personal event memories, while vivid and believed to be reliable by those who possess them, are subject to the same types of hindsight bias and suggestibility as other memories. Like other memories, they are relatively, not absolutely reliable. This has been demonstrated over a period of months by the results obtained by Yuille and Cutshall's analysis of the eyewitness reports to a shooting which left the perpetrator dead, and the principal victim wounded. Their analysis showed an 80% reliability in the accuracy of details reported after 3 months. A lesser, but nevertheless remarkable reliability was discovered by Berntsen and Thomsen in the memories of Danish eyewitnesses of the German invasion of Denmark in 1940 and its liberation in 1945 when tested more than 60 years after the event. The characteristics of some of the traditions incorporated into the Synoptic Gospels reveals that they are likely to be examples of personal event memories that have made their way into collective memory, and thus a case could be made for considering their reliability to be similar to those reported for other long-term personal event memories.


Lying and Deceit in Families: The Duping of Isaac and Tamar
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
Heather A. McKay, Edge Hill College

Whereas in many societies lying to outsiders is regarded as acceptable and even, at times, praiseworthy, the practising of deceit upon insiders is considered to be a hostile act. To go so far as to deceive or betray members of one's own family is treated as utterly heinous and contemptible. As Goffman (1977) has shown, many human interactions take place encapsulated within acts of courtesy or courtship, but these may be of genuine or deceptive intent. With ambiguity built into them these interactions can provide 'slippage'; they can be planned in deceptive mode by the would-be manipulator/s and read and reacted to as if genuine by the intended victim. Two biblical stories provide us with clear examples of the malign power of this abuse of ambiguity where two conspire against one in a deceitful way. The stories of the Dispossessing of Esau and the Rape of Tamar will be analysed using insights from two theories of manipulation: Information Manipulation Theory (McCornack 1992) and Social Manipulation Theory (Peterson 2004). This will uncover the roles and methods of the paired conspirators practised against the unsupported victims.


The Codex Sinaiticus and the Codex Sinaiticus Digitization Project
Program Unit:
Scot McKendrick, The British Library

Produced in the middle of the fourth century, the Codex Sinaiticus is one the oldest surviving copies of the Christian Bible and particularly famous for its preservation of the earliest complete copy of the New Testament and numerous important early corrections.The present talk will outline the aims and present state of progress of an ambitious international project currently led by the British Library.This project aims to reunify in virtual form and make accessible to a global audience for the very first time all the surviving parts of the Codex, which are now divided between London, Leipzig, St Petersburg and Sinai.


The Trouble with King Jehoshaphat
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Steven L. McKenzie, Rhodes College

*


Open Readings of Genesis: Jacob Boehme’s Mysterium Magnum and Joseph Smith’s Books of Moses, Abraham, and The Book of Mormon
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
James M. McLachlan, Western Carolina University

*


Messianic Exegesis in Romans 9:30–11:32
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Jocelyn McWhirter, Albion College

In his book Messianic Exegesis, Donald Juel offers a compelling proposal concerning Paul’s interpretation of Gen 22:18 in Gal 3. He points out that convention permits Paul to interpret two passages together on the basis of shared vocabulary. Therefore, because both Gen 22:18 and 2 Sam 7:12 contain the word “offspring,” Paul can conclude that the “offspring” who extends the blessing of Abraham to the Gentiles is the “offspring” promised to David by Nathan—that is, the Messiah (pp. 85-7). Surely similar arguments can be made about biblical exegesis elsewhere in Paul’s letters. This paper makes such an argument about Rom 9:30-11:32, in which Paul attributes christological significance to fourteen citations in order to explain why so many of his Jewish compatriots remain “ignorant of the righteousness that comes from God” through faith in Christ (Rom 10:3). That Paul conflates half these citations on the basis of shared vocabulary (in Rom 9:33; 11:8-10, 26-27) suggests that the “messianic exegesis” proposed by Juel is indeed at work in this passage. I reconstruct Paul’s interpretive process beginning with Isa 52:13-53:12 and Ps 69, passages that can be understood as messianic prophecies due to verbal similarities with Ps 89, a lament over God’s “anointed one” (Juel, pp. 104-10, 131). Then, using words like “believe,” “report,” “word,” “mouth,” “stone,” “sin,” “lawlessness,”and “burning anger,” I show how messianic exegesis can extend from Isa 53 and Ps 69 to the twelve other citations in Rom 9:30-11:32. This enables Paul to make the audacious claim that, according to Israel’s Scripture, some Jews are made righteous by believing in Jesus Christ whereas the rest have stumbled due to their blindness and hardness of heart.


Political Proof Texts: Rhetorical Functions of the New Testament in American Presidential Discourse
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Martin Medhurst, Baylor University

This essay examines the ways in which the New Testament has been used in American political discourse. Drawing from the rhetoric of presidents and presidential campaigns, I posit six distinct functions served by New Testament references and then relate those functions to the larger demands of political communication in America.


Listening to Luke: The Author on the Old Testament in Luke-Acts
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
James A. Meek, Lock Haven, PA

The importance of the Old Testament in Luke-Acts has long been recognized. This paper seeks to provide a perspective on the role of the Old Testament in Luke-Acts and suggests two fruitful directions for exploration of this topic. The most substantial contributions to this discussion have focused on the role of the Old Testament in developing the work’s Christology. This paper seeks to develop a more comprehensive picture of the Old Testament in Luke-Acts by examining explicit appeals to the Old Testament as well as fourteen "summary statements" of Old Testament teaching that do not contain explicit citations. A careful study reveals that the prophetic significance of the Old Testament in Luke-Acts is found in five central themes: the suffering, death, resurrection, and exaltation of the Messiah; eschatological blessing; the rejection of Christ by many Jews; the coming judgment on unbelief; and the offer of forgiveness to all (Jew or Gentile) in the name of Jesus. Text concerned with these other themes (in addition to Christology) must be brought into the discussion of the Old Testament in Luke-Acts. In addition, considered as rhetorical devices, Luke’s Old Testament citations and summaries offer insight into his purpose--the authority of the Old Testament is brought to bear in order to bring Theophilus certainty concerning the things about which he has been instructed: particularly, Jesus is indeed the Messiah and that God has ordained the proclamation of the gospel to the Gentiles. This does not lead to a new conclusion about the purpose of Luke-Acts, but it does bring new evidence to bear on the question.


The Historical Jesus and the Prohibition of Oaths
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
John P. Meier, University of Notre Dame

Jesus' prohibition of swearing is a useful way to examine the claim that Jesus had no fixed hermeneutic when it came to Torah. As a charismatic prophet, he knew and proclaimed God's will concerning individual questions, but in the end it was all a matter of "Amen, say to you".....which is simply a solemn way of saying "It's so because I say it's so."


Geography and Bodily Movement: A Small Group Experiment in "Reading" the Bible
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Calvin Mercer, East Carolina University

The usual paradigm students use to approach the Bible is to read words on a page. The explicit purpose of this small group exercise is to shift the paradigm of approaching the Bible to one that gives awareness of geographical space and bodily movement. My anecdotal evidence, over several years of refining the exercise, suggests that this different “reading” indirectly challenges preconceived ideas about the nature of the text, with specific challenge to a fundamentalist/conservative tendency to obsess with the actual words of what is considered a verbally inspired text. The geography and bodily movement exercise is achieved by having a small group role play a biblical text while physically moving to predetermined locations that symbolically represent different geographical references in the text. Drawing upon the emerging methodology of performance criticism, learning theory in psychology, and theories of movement from the theatrical art of dance, I will provide a possible explanation of why the exercise seems effective in shifting basic hermeneutical perspectives on the Bible. I will discuss passages from both the Hebrew Bible and the New Testament that are effectively used in this exercise. Handouts will be provided that give the instructor all necessary information and materials to implement the exercise. The protocol leads students through a pre- and post-bodily movement reading of the text.


Emplotting Myth and History and Daniel 8
Program Unit: Bible, Myth, and Myth Theory
Amy C. Merrill Willis, Gonzaga University

This paper will use Daniel 8 as a point of re- entry into the long discussion of myth and history in apocalyptic literature. In recent scholarly discussions, there has been some ambiguity with respect to Daniel 8’s character on this count. While it is generally viewed as a more concrete and historically contextual version of Daniel 7’s mythicized history, some scholars have also noted its own distinctive mythic motifs. This paper will explore this ambiguity by focusing on emplotment, or how time is narratively configured in the vision report of Dan 8. In doing so, this paper will argue that Dan 8 contrasts with Dan 7 and Dan 2 in the way that it re-emplots familiar historical and mythic patterns. Moreover, in its emplotment, Dan 8 represents a significant challenge to some persistent distinctions between myth and history, particularly with respect to the ideas of time and change. Finally, this paper will explore the equipment that Dan 8’s mythic materials provide for narrativizing the maskilim’s concerns over imperial power and divine agency.


The Laws of Leviticus Employed in the Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Sarianna Metso, University of Toronto

The prevalence of the book of Leviticus in the Dead Sea Scrolls community is evident not only by the number of copies of this book found at Qumran, but also by the large number of quotations from Leviticus found in the non-biblical material. The book of Leviticus clearly was foundational in shaping the life and self-understanding of the priestly community at Qumran. This paper focuses on the interpretive traditions of Leviticus in the Scrolls, investigating the ways this book influenced Essene communal legislation and ideology. While the interpretive techniques used by Qumran scribes are of some interest, the primary aim of this paper is to discuss the broader motivations and ethos of the community members in creating a unique culture of elitist ritual purity with clearly defined boundaries toward the outside world.


Essene Interpretive Traditions of Leviticus
Program Unit: Qumran
Sarianna Metso, University of Toronto

The prevalence of the book of Leviticus in the Dead Sea Scrolls community is evident not only by the number of copies of this book found at Qumran, but also by the large number of quotations from Leviticus found in the non-biblical material. The book of Leviticus clearly was foundational in shaping the life and self-understanding of the priestly community at Qumran. This paper focuses on the interpretive traditions of Leviticus in the Scrolls, investigating the ways this book influenced Essene communal legislation and ideology. While the interpretive techniques used by Qumran scribes are of some interest, the primary aim of this paper is to discuss the broader motivations and ethos of the community members in creating a unique culture of elitist ritual purity with clearly defined boundaries toward the outside world.


Behind and Beyond the Bible: Feminist Ethnohistory and the Recovery of Israelite Women
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Carol Meyers, Duke University

The Hebrew Bible is an androcentric document produced largely by elite males in an urban environment; and it is more interested in national events and community values than in the lives of individuals. For these reasons and many others, it is an inadequate, incomplete, and distorted source of information about the lives of ordinary Israelite women. Nevertheless, assumptions based on biblical data are often used in making judgments about the lives and status of women in the biblical period. This paper will explore the ways in which ethnohistorical analysis, as an independent way for assessing the lives of Israelite women, can help bridge the gap between portrayals of women in the Hebrew Bible and the social reality of their lives.


Exile and Restoration in Light of Recent Archaeology and Demographic Studies
Program Unit:
Eric Meyers, Duke University

*


The Relationship of Pneumatology and Christology in the Polemics of Philoxenos of Mabbug
Program Unit: Christian Late Antiquity and Its Reception
David A. Michelson, Princeton University

“He was born of a woman that he might beget us of the Holy Spirit.” This paper examines the doctrine of the Holy Spirit in the writings of Philoxenos of Mabbug (d. 523). Philoxenos is better known for his voluminous participation in the Christological disputes following the council of Chalcedon. His Christological polemics were marked by repeated attacks upon specific inconsistencies of dyophysite theology. This theological orientation should not, however, lead one to conclude that defining the nuances of Christological doctrine was Philoxenos’ primary concern in opposing Chalcedon. He framed his polemic works within a larger spiritual context. This context comes to light in a previously unedited fragment (MS Vat. Borgia syr. 10) in which Philoxenos resorts to extreme rhetoric to explain the efficacious role of the Holy Spirit even in the face of blatant sinfulness. Nevertheless, he reserves one exception concerning the indwelling of the Spirit, the Spirit will depart from heretics at the moment of their apostasy. This exception provides an interpretive key for understanding Philoxenos’ Christological polemics. For Philoxenos, the Christological heresies were more than just doctrinal mistakes about Christ, they were part of a larger conflict between the Holy Spirit and Satan. Erroneous teaching about Christ’s incarnation was a Satanic effort to interrupt the Spirit’s role in the economy of salvation. Christ’s incarnation and the Holy Spirit’s indwelling were related. Denial of the former prevented the occurrence of the latter. The doctrine of Christ was not merely an intellectual question, it was a pressing spiritual matter with consequences for the work of the Spirit. In short, the urgency which Philoxenos assigned to defending the doctrine of Christ was a function of the importance he attached to the doctrine of the Holy Spirit. His concern for Christology was a product of his pneumatology.


Going Beyond the Myth of the Empty Land: A Reassessment of the Early Persian Period
Program Unit: Literature and History of the Persian Period
Jill Middlemas, University of Oxford

Since Robert Carroll and Hans Barstad brought the question of the biblical portrait of the period commonly known as the 'exile' under question, studies have turned attention to the potential for community renewal and literary activity in Neo-Babylonian or Templeless Judah (Vanderfhooft, 1999; Lipschits 1998, 2005; Middlemas, 2005). Accepting that the population in Judah may have been more active and productive during the sixth-century BCE has led to greater awareness of the issues related to the historical enterprise. In fact, a number of portraits generated by the biblical writers have been revised. Indeed the acceptance that the population in Judah may have been a centre of creative activity during the sixth-century has led to greater understanding of how literary strategies employed by the biblical writers created and sustained a reality—however unrealistic it may have been. Not only should our language used in reference to the sixth century be changed to take into account a more holistic representation of the communities that experienced the collapse of Jerusalem in 587, but interpretive models applied to the early "postexilic" or Persian period require reassessment in view of the evidence that has come to light. This paper offers some preliminary remarks about where to proceed from here. As such, it pays particular attention to issues of continuity, rather than schism. In addition, it looks forward to areas of study in need of renewed attention, for example, that the literature of the late Templeless period and the early Second Temple period attests the accommodation of two communities (from the homeland and from the Golah) and how texts functioned to encourage a return to Jerusalem as the capital.


God Is Not a Mortal He Should Repent: The Role of Samuel in God’s Rejection of Saul and the Shift to an Unconditional Covenant with David
Program Unit: Theology of the Hebrew Scriptures
J. Richard Middleton, Roberts Wesleyan College

Interpreters of 1 and 2 Samuel have long been troubled by God’s evident favoritism shown towards David, given God’s earlier summary rejection of Saul. But this macro-narrative tension in God’s attitude towards the first two kings of Israel is matched by an intra-textual tension in the story of Saul’s rejection. In 1 Samuel 15:10 God tells Samuel that he has “repented” of (or has changed his mind about) making Saul king (a statement reiterated by the narrator in 15:35). Then, when Saul confesses his sin and pleads for forgiveness, Samuel tells him (in 15:29) that God is not a human being that he should “repent” (that is, God will not change his mind about changing his mind). This paper will take as its starting point the evident contradiction between these two statements about God’s “repentance” in 1 Samuel 15 (which is unlikely to be unintentional in such an astute narrative) as a clue to interpreting the role of human and divine freedom in 1 Samuel 15 and beyond. First, the vexed question of whether (and to what extent) Samuel adequately represents God’s intent will be assessed, and this will lead to a hypothesis about why God shifts significantly (changes his mind) from his treatment of Saul (rejecting him and refusing him forgiveness) to his later treatment of David (entering into an unconditional covenant with him and immediately forgiving his sin when he confesses). The role of Samuel in both representing God’s will and precipitating a change in God’s modus operandi will be explored.


Satire and Ideology in Judges 3: Israel, Moab, and the Psychology of Ethnic Humor
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Johnny E. Miles, Texas Christian University

This paper explores the ideological borders of satire in Judges 3 as an effort to construe identity through ethnic humor. Literary elements such as scatology and characterization shape an Israelite narrative typecasting their ethnic kin, Moab, as “stupid.” But such a humor based on violence, ethnic slurs, and feminizing tendencies, now reified as sacred writ, reveals more about the group(s) resorting to such demeaning activities whether past or present. A consideration of the psychology of ethnic humor will demonstrate the ideological dimension to this satire as itself an act of transference whereby Judah projects an undesirable trait of itself onto another in an unconscious formation of identity. This unconscious formation of identity feeds into the pro-Judean political-ideological stance of the book of Judges wherein Judah is depicted as superior to, not like Israel-not “other.”


Triangulating Story, Ideology, and History: Politics, Religion, and Economics in the (Hi)Story of Jeroboam
Program Unit: New Historicism and the Hebrew Bible
Johnny E. Miles, TCU

This paper proposes a modified Marxist-ideological perspective on the (hi)story of Jeroboam in 1 Kings 11-14. An exploration of the semantic isotopies of politics, religion, and economics within this narrative reveals a conflict of class and ideology merely “papered over” by its ideological antinomies (i.e. contradictions). Ideologemes such as royal ideology and historical determinism reinforce this text's major role in this struggle with its simultaneous ideology of the rule(r)(d) being (ex)(re)pressed. With further consideration of this narrative's historical-ideological conceptualizations, various economic determinants emerge in this religio-political polemic by one segment of culture (i.e. Judah) asserting its dominance over another (more economically dominant) segment of culture (i.e. Israel) as Other in spite of its own marginalization as Other.


Devouring Dialogue: Salome and Jesus in the Gospel of Thomas
Program Unit: Bakhtin and the Biblical Imagination
Anna Miller, Harvard University

Mikail Bakhtin’ literary theory illuminates a brief but mystifying dialogue between Jesus and Salome in logion 61 from the Gospel of Thomas. There Salome responds to Jesus’ words that “Two will rest on a couch; one will die, one will live” with a statement that Jesus has eaten at her table. This dialogue is striking not only for its content, but for the manner in which Salome confronts Jesus within the exchange. In this conversation, Salome uses her own connection with Jesus in the context of a meal as part of an argument that fundamentally questions Jesus’ opening pronouncement about life and death. Moreover, unlike any of Jesus’ other followers in the Gospel of Thomas, Salome here names herself as disciple. Bakhtin’s theory on dialogic discourse and the polyphonic novel guides the discovery of distinct viewpoints or voices within logion 61 relating to themes of materiality in life and death, as well as the role of women as followers of Jesus. In Logion 61, Bakhtin’s work proves illuminating partly because Bakhtin has explored the meal itself as a location in literature for dialogue and embodiment. This paper suggests that Bakhtin can help us to see the characters of Salome and Jesus as “idea-images” who are caught up in the dialogue that the Thomas community heard in the world around it. While Jesus’ part in the dialogue devaluates the material world, Salome’ voice is a significant witness to views within the Thomas community supporting not only the presence of women as authoritative figures in the early Christian movement, but their ability to do so in an embodied, gendered state.


"Psalms Are Not Interesting": Learner-Centered Approaches to Teaching Biblical Poetry and the Psalms
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Charles William Miller, University of North Dakota

The literature of the Book of Psalms is among the most familiar of any of the biblical writings. Students, especially those with some church or synagogue background, will have encountered individual Psalms during a visit to their religious community. Others might have met with a biblical psalm (often without knowing it) in a novel they have read, a popular song they have heard, or from the mouth of a character in a television program they have watched. The Psalms, as evidenced even within our popular culture, continues to impact the lives of those who read or hear them. Nonetheless, many times our presentation of the Psalms - especially of the micro-structures (parallelism) and the macro-structures (genre) - tends to stupefy, rather than to excite our students. It is not totally the fault of our presentation, since we are often struggling against the perceptions of average students, who believe they hate poetry and can never hope to understand it. In my presentation, I offer a general overview of the process my class goes through in encountering biblical poetry. I focus specifically on two simple in-class exercises: (1) introducing the basic parallel structure of Hebrew poetry and (2) introducing the basic structure of a complaint psalm. In both exercises, the students are asked to write their own examples of the structures in question. These two exercises are grounded in learner-centered approaches to teaching and promote active engagement in the learning process.


The Syntax of the Vocative
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Cynthia L. Miller, University of Wisconsin, Madison

Vocatives (terms of address) are syntactically interesting items. On the one hand, they are intonationally part of a host sentence. On the other hand, they are only loosely linked syntactically with their host sentence and are not integrated into it as a clausal constituent. Previous descriptions of the vocative have largely considered the internal syntax of the vocative (that is, what kinds of constituents can be used as vocatives) or the sociolinguistic uses of the vocative. The external syntax of the vocative, however, has been mostly ignored. In this paper, I consider the external syntax of the vocative. I am especially interested in describing the locations in the host sentence that can serve as a niche for the vocative as an extrasentential element, and the significant ways in which prose and poetry differ in this respect.


Outside the Box: Feminist Biblical Criticism as a Pedagogical Tool in Women’s Studies
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Pamela J. Milne, University Of Windsor

While most feminist biblical scholars work and teach in the context of biblical, theological, ancient near eastern or classical departments or programmes, my work is done only in the context of a women’s studies programme at a secular (Provincial) university. The relevance of feminist biblical criticism is not obvious to many outside the field. This paper seeks to demonstrate how the range of methods, methodologies and ideologies that characterize feminist biblical scholarship on the Hebrew Bible can contribute positively to the development of the critical interpretive skills of undergraduate women’s studies students.


Recapturing the Prophet: Identifying Amos’s Call Narrative in 3:3–8
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Sara J. Milstein, New York University

Scholars typically pursue two courses of interpretation with regard to Amos 3:1-8. One set of exegetes interprets vv. 1-6 as a continuous unit focused on Israel’s inevitable destruction. In this reading, each metaphor in vv. 4-5 depicts the relationship between God, the vicious predator, and Israel, his deserving prey. Yet the content of v. 8b complicates this approach, for Amos no longer alludes to Israel’s annihilation, but instead refers to the inevitability of his prophetic mission. Scholars rationalize this dissonance by viewing v. 8 as ancillary, relevant only to the prophet’s role in conveying the message of destruction. The explicit import of v. 8 prompts a second faction to conclude that vv. 3-6 represent the inevitable nature of cause and effect that compels Amos to prophesy. In this analysis v. 8 serves as the culmination of the pericope, a pair of statements that stuns its spectators as they apprehend the inescapability of the prophetic mission. Although these scholars pinpoint v. 8 as the unit’s conclusion, they nonetheless associate the predator and prey with God and Israel. Thus Amos prefaces his discourse on prophetic responsibility with analogies that pertain not to his relationship with God, but rather to Israel’s predicament. A coherent analysis of the unit reveals that vv. 3-8 allude not to Israel but instead signify Amos’s inescapable call to prophesy. In a skilled oracular performance, Amos traps his listeners into expecting an assault, culminating with the prediction of disaster in v. 6. Yet when Amos unveils the thrust of his argument, his audience is astounded to discover that he, not Israel, is God’s defenseless prey. Amos 3:3-8 is not an oracle but instead represents the earliest and most riveting version of a prophetic call narrative.


Manichaean Magus: Letter-writing Rhetoric in P. Kell. 35 and the Papyri Graecae Magicae
Program Unit: Manichaean Studies
Paul Mirecki, University of Kansas, Main Campus

As Vales writes to Psais in the letter section of P. Kell. 35, his discussion of the accompanying amulet text demonstrates rhetorical devices that are standard fare in the Papyri Graecae Magicae (PGM). In such cases, a writer uses the form of the personal letter (actual or not) as the literary frame for a ritual text. The writer demonstrates high reverence for the transmitted text as well as his individual knowledge of and access to such texts – all of which Vales’ letter demonstrates – apparently suggesting a guarantee of efficacy through a tested chain of tradition. The Kellis letter seems to indicate that actual letters containing ritual texts – later to become editorial sources – could have worked their ways into later synthetic anthologies like the PGM, where the letter genre is obvious in well-known examples (see PGM ). This does not preclude the possibility that such texts were later edited in a variety of ways during the process of scribal transmission, leading to the “canonical” versions we now have in the PGM. Such correspondence, which also displays rhetorical similarities with the testament genre, reflects the relationship between the holy man and personal or professional beneficiaries and clients that formed an essential component of Late Antique religion.


Function of Imagery in Isaiah
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Peter D. Miscall, Aquinas Institute of Theology

This paper will focus on imagery in Isaiah and will discuss how it both binds and diffuses the poetry and vision of the poet.


Chronicles, Ben Sira, and Inserted Genres
Program Unit: Bakhtin and the Biblical Imagination
Christine Mitchell, St. Andrew's College

In this paper, I work with Bakhtin’s notion of “inserted genres” as part of his overall definition of heteroglossia. In order to work with this notion, I bring together Chronicles and Ben Sira. I problematize the relationship, and I look for possibilities of using Ben Sira (whose date and context are more easily determined) for furthering our understanding of the genre and context of Chronicles. I argue that the Chronicler was a broadly literate author (as was Ben Sira), who used a number of literary techniques in order to achieve his ideological aims. Although I use examples from the range of both books, my primary focus is on the so-called “Hymn to the Ancestors” in Ben Sira 44-50, and on the depiction of Asa in 2 Chronicles 14-16. The use of inserted genres in both books is the starting point for my reflections on the genre(s) of the books as a whole.


The Abercius Inscription: Re-imagining Context and Meaning
Program Unit:
Margaret Mitchell, University of Chicago

*


Divine Mutability and Human Depravity: The Meaning of the Flood Narrative
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Walter Moberly, Durham University

I propose to consider the meaning of the Flood Narrative as a whole, in its received form, via a heuristic exercise in redaction criticism. A preliminary consideration of characteristic construals will lead to a renewed consideration of the divine soliloquy in Gen. 8:21-22 as a possible key to the whole story. The theological tension between 6:5 and 8:21 is well recognized, in that the reason for Yhwh's decision to wipe out humanity is repeated in the context of the decision to sustain life upon earth. The tension, however, focusses entirely upon the clause in 8:21ay, 'for the inclination of the human heart is evil from youth'. I will argue that there are good grounds for seeing this clause as a distinct addition to an otherwise complete divine soliloquy, and then propose a reading of the story without this clause. When the clause is included, it highlights two issues that are otherwise less central within the story: divine mutability and human depravity. Possible reasons for adding the clause will be explored. The story will then be construed with the clause as integral. Special consideration will be given to the narrative tension constituted by the pronouncement of humanity's evil inclination when the only significant human in the context is the tsaddiq Noah. Some final remarks will consider the meaning and purpose of the narrative as a whole.


The Return of the Chaos Monsters: A Biblical Myth
Program Unit: Bible, Myth, and Myth Theory
Gregory Mobley, Andover Newton Theological School

Among the implied narratives in the Jewish and Christian Bibles is "the Return of the Chaos Monsters." In this back story of texts in Genesis, Hosea, Job, the Psalms, and Revelation, the ideas that Jon Levenson has written about in Creation and the Persistance of Evil are expressed in the idiom of personifying myth. Human virtue buttresses the fragile structures of cosmic order and human trespass leads to their erosion. In this paper, we will analyze Mesopotamian and biblical versions of this story in which humans cross thresholds barred to them, leaving cosmic doors ajar for the chaos monsters to escape.


"My Lord" in the Greek Psalms and in Luke’s Pentecost Speech
Program Unit: Greek Bible
David P. Moessner, University of Dubuque Theological Seminary

Of the three main citations of the Greek Bible in Luke’s Pentecost speech (Acts 2), Joel 3:1-5 (Acts 2:17-21), Ps 15:8-11 (2:25-28), and Ps 109:1 (2:34b-35a), commentators have the most difficulty in explaining why Luke would quote nine lines of Psalm 15 only apparently to find, in two short lines, one rather cryptic prophetic nugget of the resurrection from the dead of David’s future offspring and christos (Ps 15:10 = Acts 2:27). The reason for this confusion is that interpreters as a rule assume that Luke is referring to the Hebrew Psalm 16, a ‘Song of Trust,’ rather than the Greek Psalm 15 which is a very different “writing of David” and composes a psalm of David as ‘a suffering righteous one.’ --Psalm 15, in fact, serves as the linchpin for the rhetorical strategy of the whole speech. If Joel 3 illumines how it could be that the Pentecost pilgrims are experiencing the “wind and the flame,” and Psalm 109 forms an inclusio to show that Jesus, the exalted Messiah and Lord, is actually the “my lord” (Ps 109:1) who is pouring out the Spirit “in these last days,” then Psalm 15 explains how the people of Israel (“you,” pl.) could “execute” their own Messiah and Lord according to “the prescient plan and foreknowledge of God” (2:23). In the logic of Peter, the one who is now “exalted at the right hand” is precisely the one whom David “kept seeing” as “my Lord” (Ps 15:2!) “in his presence.” David’s suffering thus prefigures and prophesies the “plan” that leads to “the right hand” (Ps. 15:8-10 [2:25-27]). Peter is identifying the career of Jesus from the Greek psalms, “opened,” according to volume one, by the risen Lord and Christ himself (Luke 24:44-47).


Perpetua, Felicitas, Graphic Novels and the Possibility of Modern Hagiography
Program Unit:
Andrea Molinari, Creighton University

*


Ancient Text, Modern Norms, Postmodern Perspectives
Program Unit: Homiletics and Biblical Studies
Joy J. Moore, Asbury Theological Seminary

Homiletical theory in recent decades has shown receptivity to changing assumptions regarding authority, knowledge, and truth as it seeks solution to the continuing quest for how, what, and even why to preach. Some among both the clergy and laity question whether the era of pulpit proclamation can survive in a high-tech culture of virtual reality, instant global news, and portable movie theaters on DVD. How does one orally communicate from ancient texts to contemporary audiences whose alternative sources of information are multicultural, entertaining technological experiences? The quest for methods capable of effectively communicating religious concepts with compelling relevance has at times obscured both the consideration of the bible as a whole and the unfolding perspective rendered by its narrative accounting. In spite of recent homiletical shifts responsive to narrative sensibilities preaching remains constrained by the rhetorical format of argument. Methodological quests for preaching elsewhere pursued as a discipline of communication remain essential; however, each generation’s homiletic must address the challenge of what exactly Christianity proclaims for the existing culture. This paper is concerned with the potential of homiletics to make fuller use of postmodern hermeneutical approaches for considering the storied accounting intrinsic to the Genesis-to-Revelation narrative. Homiletical considerations from such a reading must embrace both the questions of our fragmented postmodern culture and the constraints of the final form of the Christian canon.


Fighting in Writing: Warfare and Battles in Current Historical Reconstructions of Ancient Israel
Program Unit: Warfare in Ancient Israel
Megan Bishop Moore, Wake Forest University

This paper examines historical reconstructions of ancient Israel from the past several decades and asks the following questions: What role does warfare play in the story of Israel’s past as currently understood? What battles, if any, are seen as significant to Israel’s story, and what level of detail is found in their reconstructions? What sources do historians use (or appear to use) to reconstruct ancient warfare, and, more specifically, do they view the Bible as a potentially reliable source? The paper then offers suggestions as to how evidence for ancient warfare can be used in both histories that narrate events and histories of Israelite society, and argues that the relationship of war to religion, economics, and even daily life in ancient Israel should not be overlooked.


The Laments in Jeremiah and 1QH: Mapping the Metaphorical Trajectories
Program Unit: Qumran
Michael S. Moore, Arizona State University

Contemporary biblical scholarship is increasingly aware of the exegetical possibilities generated by the discovery and publication of all the known Dead Sea Scrolls, and one sign of this awareness is the dramatic increase in intertextual studies of various biblical passages in recent years, influenced in part by the exegetical principles operating within the Qumran literature itself. In the same vein Second Temple scholars are cognizant of the almost exclusive dependence of the Qumran documents upon earlier material from the Hebrew Bible, and this knowledge has already produced several intertextual studies of various Qumran texts alongside biblical texts like Isaiah and the Psalms, as well as portions and sections of Targumim, Mishnah, Talmud, Josephus, the New Testament and other texts. Relatively few interpreters, however, have begun the process of examining the striking intertextual parallels between Jeremiah's laments and the brooding poetry of the Hodayot scroll from Cave 1 (1QH). The following study will attempt to put to both these poetic anthologies some basic intertextual questions: (1) What are the predominant metaphors common to JL and 1QH?, and (2) What factors might be responsible for adapting and, in some cases, transforming the metaphors in 1QH vis-à-vis those in JL?


“The Romans Will Come and Destroy…Our Nation” (John 11:48): Representing Empire in the Fourth Gospel
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Stephen D. Moore, Drew University

Rome is an object of extraordinary ambivalence in the Fourth Gospel. On the one hand, certain surreptitious elements in the Roman trial narrative embody the most scathing critique of Roman imperialism found in any of the canonical gospels, as this paper will contend. On the other hand, whether in 11:47-52—the most explicit interpretation in John of Jesus’ death as substitution—or the trial narrative, the primary object of propitiation is not the Jewish God but the Roman emperor. The subversion of Roman imperial ideology is further complicated by the absence of a dramatized parousia in John—a theological vacuum that Rome rushes in to fill, itself assuming apocalyptic agency: “the Romans will come….” In tacitly allowing Rome to survive, and further implying that it is destined to be transformed from within rather than replaced from without, the Fourth Gospel ultimately shows itself to be the charter document of imperial Christianity.


“I Looked, and I Saw”: The Imagery of U.S. Propaganda Posters in Dialogue with the Imagery of the Revelation
Program Unit: Poster Session
Stewart Moore, Drew University

The imagery of the Apocalypse of John is vivid, surreal and, to the members of many mainline churches, deeply confusing. However, most Americans are quite familiar with vivid and surreal imagery in another context: propaganda posters, especially those of World Wars I and II. Similarly, John’s Apocalypse is frequently thought of as a propagandistic tool, encouraging his communities to resist the imperial power of Rome. Both the posters and the Apocalypse deploy similar visual tropes: the enemy as a monster, the community as a woman, the participation of the individual in the struggles of the community. Comparing and contrasting the visual style and tropes of American propaganda posters in World Wars I and II to the Apocalypse will help evaluate two important questions concerning the ethical consequences of reading John’s text, then and now: (1) Was John simply mirroring imperial brutality in his own text, and (2) What effect is his text likely to have in the modern American empire? This comparative exercise reveals that John’s boundaries are much less clearly conceptualized than those of most of the posters, probably reflecting the fact that John had little or no chance to implement his boundaries as political policy, in stark contrast to the power of the Roman and American governments to do so. John’s more ad hoc boundaries, depending upon his personal authority as the arbiter of those boundaries, become potentially quite dangerous in a modern American context where Christians reading John can clearly imagine holding the power to transfer his imaginative categories into legal categories.


The Leader's Dilemma
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
Mira Morgenstern, City College of New York

This paper analyzes an alternate vision of political leadership in the context of the development of Israelite political leadership as this is presented in the Hebrew Bible. In contrast to the absolute power that inheres in (most of) the (Biblical) textual depictions of political leadership, the Hebrew Bible depicts power as an idea that is ultimately alienated and also estranging. This understanding of power is reflected in the Biblical portrayal of Israelite leaders as modeling their practice of power on the example of people who are themselves marginalized (i.e. estranged). In these terms, the ultimate challenge for the leader becomes the integration of this paradoxical quality of power in a way that coheres both morally and politically. However, this procedure is itself beset by conflict: if estrangement is central to both the concept and the exercise of power, what happens when alienation characterizes the very establishment of power relations; i.e., the founding of political community? The implications of this question, particularly in terms of its seemingly opaque and estranged treatment in the Concubine at Gibeah episode at the end of the Book of Judges, set the stage for the subsequent expressions of Israelite national identity, and continue to manifest their influences on contemporary crises of politics and power.


Exemptions, Execrations, and Exodus
Program Unit: Egyptology and Ancient Israel
Scott Morschauser, Rowan University

According to the Hebrew Bible, Israel's settlement in Egypt was predicated upon a royal decree, which allowed Jacob and his sons to dwell in the land of Goshen, further securing them jobs as "herdsmen" for pharaoh. Despite the "narrative" presentation in Genesis, the king's command and its provisions bear resemblance to ancient Egyptian donation texts, or royal charters. Well-attested, these legal documents typically contained stipulations exempting tenants on royal estates from outside labor. However, some examples also specified that such largesse and protections were to continue beyond the lifetime of the issuing monarch. In order to ensure compliance, "grants-in-perpetuity", were sometimes sealed with elaborate threats and curses implicating all parties that would violate their strictures, including future kings and advisors. The Biblical "plot" of Israel's sojourn, oppression, and departure from the Nile Valley very much resembles the "dynamics" of donation texts- - a feature that may especially be seen in the imagery and function of the plague cycle in Exodus. Rather than simply being manifestations of divine power, the disasters unleashed upon pharaoh are to be regarded as "dramatized curses", of the type found in Egyptian foundation charters. Indeed, the Biblical story is purposefully constructed to stress that the kings of Egypt had violated Israel's legal status through "breach of contract", thereby justifying the latter's demands for emancipation, as well as providing a cause for Yahweh's advocacy on its behalf.


The Defense of Michal: Pre-Raphaelite Persuasion in 2 Samuel 6
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Benjamin Morse, University of Glasgow

Michal the daughter of Saul lives childless to her death, and traditional criticism surrounding this biblical queen commonly plots her as one punished with barrenness or as one too disillusioned by mean-spiritedness to recognize the dignity in David’s dirty dancing. Feminist and womanist scholars attempting to rescue her from her screaming death can frame her in discourses of victimhood and passivity that often overlook potential readings of a more sympathetic and empowered character. The paper will borrow an exercise from art history lectures and project the image of Queen Guenevere (1858) by William Morris opposite the portrait of Michal in 2 Samuel 6. Morris subverted unforgiving Victorian attitudes towards adulteresses like Guenevere by painting a woman who knew God’s laws and the laws of love were greater than human social and moral codes. Like Michal, this figure stands by her window and contemplates the powerlessness of her situation in the world of men, but in Morris’ poem, The Defence of Guenevere (1858), his heroine triumphs over her accusers by casting light on their hypocrisy and retaining the moral high ground through the end. As a counterpart to the childless Guenevere, Michal is shown to mirror some of her strengths and to function in a subtle way as an agent in the Deuteronomistic History’s prophetic critique of kings. Intertextual readings will develop Michal’s appearances throughout the books of Samuel as more complex portraits than have been previously rendered. Robed as an Arthurian queen, Michal offers a vision of the barren mother as an ennobled and successful affront to the men around her and the excessive things they say in the name of God.


‘Time Passed’ and Other Sweet Stories: Conservative Cuteness in Today’s Children’s Bibles
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Benjamin Morse, University of Glasgow

The American children’s Bible market is saturated by timidly told versions which aim to render the scriptures as a non-threatening literal stream of watercolor tales and timeless truths. Though some illustrated versions display commendable sensitivity to historical details, the most significant evolution since the 1950s seems to have come in the form of cartooning the characters and letting Jesus’ hair grow back to its natural brown. Faced with the challenge of compressing all of those entangled stories into a palatable format, many authors have opted for 300-500 page abridgements (overestimating parents’ time and patience perhaps?) that sweep past the unsavory events with the wave of a hand. Other editions compile just a few disconnected stories. But almost all employ a sweetness of style that will either fade or congeal as the child grows up. The outmoded aesthetics of the trade and religious press editions will be shown to reflect particularly conservative inclinations to control the story. Their style snugly fits their function to depict an uncomplicated but uncompromising world in which God’s just have legitimately inherited the earth. There of course do need to be effective ways around certain stories, but overly sanitized versions pave the way for armchair religion and complacent escapism that is regulated through assuring sermons on ‘Scripture’s simple message’. The paper registers aesthetic and literary complaints against a market dominated by the status quo, and it critiques the anesthetizing effects of uncreative biblical interpretation. It will end with images from a children’s OT/Hebrew Bible written and illustrated by the presenter and currently under consideration for publication in America. The book’s collages dress biblical characters in ornamented papers and intend to show an abstract and recycled portrayal can better evoke the actual assemblages of biblical texts.


"Jesus Is Lord": Religious Experience and the Religion of Paul
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Christopher Mount, DePaul University

According to Paul in 1 Cor 12:3, “No one is able to say, 'Jesus is Lord,' unless possessed by the holy spirit.” “Jesus is Lord” is a performative utterance that constructs belief, spirit possession, and rituals that channel divine power in communities associated with Paul. This verbal confession constitutes the religion of the community that experiences the resurrected Jesus as cosmic ruler—a reality that restructures the cosmos in favor of those who believe, so that those who are possessed by the spirit declare, “ABBA,” in a ritual that collapses the separation between mortals and gods. With the confession “Jesus is Lord” the community imagines the cosmic defeat of death and a new social order in which the identity of one possessed by the spirit of Jesus is no longer determined by social dichotomies of the Roman Empire: Jew–Gentile, free–slave, male–female. In short, the ritual utterance “Jesus is Lord” constructs an experience of the power of God for individuals in a community saved from cosmic and social forces of oppression. The category of religious experience has enjoyed a certain revival in recent scholarly interpretations of the religion of Paul. This paper evaluates the use of the category religious experience to explain Paul and early Christianity by John Ashton (The Religion of Paul the Apostle), Larry Hurtado (for example, in Lord Jesus Christ: Devotion to Jesus in Earliest Christianity), and Luke Timothy Johnson (Religious Experience in Earliest Christianity: A Missing Dimension in New Testament Studies). These interpretations of Paul belong to a larger discourse about religion in which religious experience serves as a problematic category to connect material and transcendent explanations of religion.


Moving Students beyond Their Pre-understandings in the Introductory Course to the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
James C. Moyer, Missouri State University

Students bring many pre-understandings to the study of the Hebrew Bible. These pre-understandings often hamper students' willingness to entertain new ideas. This paper presents many of the strategies and pedagogical approaches I have used during my 36-year teaching career to help beginning students overcome their pre-understandings and increase their learning.


How Does Paul Read Scripture?
Program Unit: Paul and Scripture
Stephen Moyise, University of Chichester

This paper will investigate whether Paul's use of scripture is satisfactorily explained by positing a controlling scriptural narrative. It will consider the evidence for particular proposals, such as covenant, law and promise and new exile, both by examining selected portions of Paul's letters and the writings of other scripturally-minded exegetes. Finally, it will consider the relationship between such proposals and the narrative of the Christ-event and evaluate whether this is best described as continuity, discontinuity, or some form of mutual influence.


Paul’s Quotation in Romans 2:24 and the Question of Method
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Stephen Moyise, University of Chichester

Studies on Paul’s use of scripture have either focused on the (supposed) capabilities of the author (Hays, Wagner) or the (supposed lack of) capabilities of his first readers/hearers (Stanley, Tuckett). In the former case, Paul’s sophisticated interpretations of scripture are defended by reference to such passages as Romans 9-11, Galatians 3 and 2 Corinthians 3 and then extended to other passages. In the latter, reference to literacy studies and classical rhetoric are used to show that such sophisticated explanations are unlikely, as they require a level of reader competence which very few in the church (if any), would have possessed. The quotation of Isa 52:5 in Rom 2:24 offers an interesting case study to explore these issues since it is the first Isaiah quotation to appear in the book and thus comes before the extensive use of Isaiah in Romans 9-11. A reader-centred approach would not therefore import the background of Isaiah 52 into the meaning of the text since: (a) there is nothing to suggest it is required; (b) very few in the Roman church(es) would have known or had access to the original context; and (c) it does not immediately support Paul’s point anyway. On the other hand: (a) Paul does begin the letter to Romans by asserting that the gospel was ‘promised beforehand through his prophets’; (b) the reader will discover in Romans 9-11 that Isaiah is rather important to Paul, including a quotation from Isa 52:7; and (c) there is no reason to limit the meaning of a text to what is apparent on a first reading. The suggestion of this paper is that the only way out of this impasse is to adopt a hermeneutic that combines insights from author-centred and reader-centred approaches from the outset.


Origen and Jerome on Accusations of Jewish Angel Worship
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Ellen Muehlberger, Indiana University at Bloomington

In Contra Celsum, Origen defended the verity of Judaism because he saw that Celsus hoped to detract from Christianity by attacking Judaism as its progenitor (1.22). One part of Origen’s defense included denying Celsus’ claim that Jews worship angels (1.26, cf. 5.8-9). Several generations later, a writer with a complex knowledge of Origen’s thought took exactly the opposite position: in a letter explaining several points of doctrine to a widow, Jerome accused Jews of contenting themselves with worshipping angels after “rejecting the messiah” (ep. 121.10). I will compare these texts in my paper, not to ask whether there were Jews who worshipped angels—the very contrast between them points out the unlikelihood that either text describes a social reality—but rather to investigate why opposite answers could serve the shared apologetic and community-building impulses of these two Christian writers. The resolution lies in their different temporal and political worlds: while Origen’s support of Judaism was necessitated by Celsus’ two-pronged attack, his specific denial of the charge that Jews worship angels is aimed at illuminating Celsus’ inconsistency. Indeed, even as Origen cites scripture to prove that worship of angels is a violation of Judaism, he introduces cases in which God censures Israel for exactly such violations, calling into question the “defense” he offers. For Jerome, his charge that Jews worship angels is repeated to a woman seeking to understand Christian practice and scripture. Given that during Jerome’s lifetime, the Council of Laodicea legislated against Christians “naming angels and making groups” separate from their congregations (Canon 35), it is likely that Jerome marked the worship of angels as something “Jewish” in order to identify it as a practice anathema to Christians, capitalizing on the highly negotiated difference between “Jew” and “Christian” in place in fourth-century Christian literature.


The Use of Images in the Roman Imperial Cult as a Context for Hebrews 1:3
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Steven C. Muir, Concordia University, College of Alberta

Hebrews 1:3 calls Christ the charakter of God’s being. This term is unique in the New Testament, and rare in the Septuagint. The word is derived from the Greek verb charasso, which means to cut into, engrave, imprint. Usually the term in Hebrews is understood to be a metaphor for the divine nature imprinting itself on the person of Christ to produce an exact image of God. The Hellenistic Jewish writer Philo of Alexandria uses the metaphor in this way, to speak of the Logos of God as a stamp imprinting a measure of divinity on the soul of a human. While this specific and narrow context is important, I propose that our understanding of the issue will gain from considering a broader context, namely the use of images by rulers in the Greco-Roman Imperial cult. Rulers not only produced coins with their images; they also commissioned depictions of themselves on statues, busts, jewelry, crowns, and plaques. These distinctive portraits were deliberately circulated in the territory under the ruler’s jurisdiction to serve as visible representations – indeed, ‘satellite manifestations’ – of the person and authority of the ruler. Further, the combination of human and divine was a feature of the Imperial Cult. Thus the Imperial cult contained ready-made conceptual elements useful to a variety of theological explanations such as Philo’s view of God’s Logos and Hebrew’s hymn to Christ. Such a broad context has not been extensively explored in analysis of Hebrews. Further, icons in Orthodox Christianity originated in this ancient context, and by examining modern usage we may gain insights into first-century settings.


John, Jesus, and Metatron: Knowledge and Mediators in John's Gospel
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Phillip B. Muñoa, Hope College

While it is a scholarly truism that Christianity is indebted to Judaism, a growing number of studies are making it more apparent that early Christianity drew upon Jewish traditions when articulating its Christology. Research has established that canonical Jesus traditions share common interests with Jewish traditions that reflect mystical interests. John 2:25 is one such text. Commentators offer many suggestions for the meaning of John 2:25 and its reference to Jesus’ knowledge. Hugo Odeberg, in his partially completed commentary, The Fourth Gospel , paralleled Jesus’ knowledge with Metatron’s knowledge, the exalted angel of 3 Enoch, a text of merkavah mysticism that is also known as Sefer Hekhalot. This type of comparison is to be preferred because it places Jesus in the context of intermediary figures, many of them heavenly in origin, that were a focal point of Johannine theology and its interests. Jewish mysticism offers the best interpretive recourse for Jesus' knowledge in John 2:25: a heavenly figure equipped with divine knowledge. Encouragement for this comparison can be found in the writings of Justin Martyr, who in the second century identifies Jesus as God’s chief angel, and the interpolated synagogal prayers of book eight of the Apostolic Constitutions, which dates to the fourth century, where Jesus is identified as the “Angel of the Great Counsel.” Mounting evidence has made it quite clear that Jewish angelology was factor among some first century Jews, early Christian conceptions of Jesus as found in John’s Gospel, and that both Jesus and Metatron were depicted in similar ways.


Gentile Christian Judaizing: Another Point along the Continuum of Jewish-Christian Relations in Antiquity
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
Michele Murray, Bishop's University

The term “judaizer,” a noun derived from transliteration via Latin of the Greek verb ioudaizein, “to judaize,” frequently has been used incorrectly by scholars to refer to Jews, or, more typically, Jewish Christians who actively engaged in persuading non-Jews – usually Pauline Christians – to follow part or all of the Jewish law. I will argue that the correct understanding of the verb “to judaize” is that it refers to Gentile behaviour – that is, Gentiles who “lived like Jews” by observing various components of the Mosaic law, without fully converting to Judaism. Within the Christian context, Christian judaizing, then, refers to Christians of Gentile origin who combined a commitment to Christianity with adherence in varying degrees to Jewish practices, without viewing such behaviour as contradictory. From the perspective of certain Christian leaders, judaizers dangerously blurred the boundaries between nascent Christianity and well-established Judaism. As such, within attempts to suppress this phenomenon, Gentile Christian judaizers became the target of anti-Jewish rhetoric in various early Christian writings. I will examine evidence for Gentile Christian judaizers from two documents: Paul’s letter to the Galatians, and Justin Martyr’s Dialogue with Trypho. I will argue that the phenomenon of Gentile Christian judaizing represents a largely neglected point along the continuum of Jewish-Christian relations in antiquity, one that complicates the portrait of Jewish-Christian relations by adding another dimension. Indeed, not only were there Jewish Christians and Gentile Christians, there were Gentile Christians who lived like Jews.


The Magical Female: Accusations of Magic as Social Discourse
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Michele Murray, Bishop's University

Utilizing social and discourse theories, this paper will explore how accusations of magical practice during the Greco-Roman era targeting women in Jewish and Christian communities fostered group solidarity and facilitated the self-identity of the accusers, and thus had public, social, and political significance and function.


Albrecht Aldorfer and Martin Luther on the Passion of Christ in Woodcuts and Words
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Paul O. Myhre, Wabash College

Working in 1513 the German painter and printmaker Albrecht Altdorfer (1480-1538) created a series of woodcuts and drawings centered on the passion of Christ. His work presents viewers with an opportunity to discover methods of biblical and theological hermeneutics associated with the passion narratives of the Gospels during an age that would give birth to the Protestant Reformation in Germany. This paper will provide an analysis of Albrecht Altdorfer's biblical and theological interpretations of Gospel narratives of the passion of Christ by examining woodcuts and drawings he created in 1513. The prints and drawings are part of the permanent collection of the National Gallery of Art in Washington, D.C. The paper will also provide a comparison between Altdorfer's interpretations of select Gospel texts with interpretations of the same texts by his contemporary Martin Luther.


Didache and Christian Judaism
Program Unit: Didache in Context
Matti Myllykoski, University of Helsinki

In the scholarship of past decades, the recognition of the thoroughly Jewish character of the early Christian movement and the growing interest in Didache can be regarded as parallel phenomena. Didache points at Christian communities which transmitted Jewish traditions both in practice and belief. However, scholars have interpreted the Jewishness of Didache in various ways. This presentation aims to clarify with some examples how the stratification, source criticism and dating of Didache affect the discussion on the Jewish character of this document.


A User-Friendly Introduction to Ginsburg's Massorah
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Daniel S. Mynatt, Anderson University

Ginsburg's Massorah is a four-volume collection of masoretic lists and other material. It is beneficial as a reference source for comparing various versions of similar rubrics, or for identifying the texts which a masoretic list is annotating (they are not always self-evident!). This demonstration will explain the organizing principles for Ginsburg's Masorah and illustrate its use.


Response
Program Unit: Prophetic Texts and Their Ancient Contexts
Nadav Na'aman, Tel Aviv University

A response to preceding papers.


"Ain't I a Woman?" Differences, Similarities, and Collaboration between African Women's and Womanist Biblical Hermeneutics
Program Unit: African-American Biblical Hermeneutics
Sarojini Nadar, University of Natal

*


Loopholes in Dialogue: A Bakhtinian Reading of Luke 10:25–42
Program Unit: Bakhtin and the Biblical Imagination
Raj Nadella, Union Theological Seminary, Virginia

This paper illuminates some salient literary features of Luke 10:25-37 by employing the Bakhtinian concepts of dialogue and loophole. I call attention to the numerous loopholes in this pericope – the loophole in the law, the Samaritan’s loophole, and the lawyer’s loophole stemming from the scandalous nature of the parable - as well as to the manner in which these loopholes generate, and are in dialogue with, each other. I explicate how these loopholes enable the corresponding characters to remain unfinalizable. Although this paper is primarily devoted to explicating that pericope, the Good Samaritan parable in particular, attention is given also to its interconnectedness with the subsequent pericope, the story of Martha and Mary (10:38-42). While some scholars (Fitzmyer and Reid) see no link between the two pericopae, others (Green, Marshall, Talbert) interpret the link in terms of either Lukan juxtaposition of related episodes or inverse fulfillment of the two-fold commandment in 10:27. I argue that the two pericopae are linked dialogically and that the dialogue stems from the Lukan Jesus’ decision to employ a loophole by counterbalancing his emphasis on “doing” in 10:25-37 with his emphasis on “hearing” in 10:38-42, thus attenuating others’ ability to define him in finalizing terms.


Writing a Thesis in DocBook
Program Unit: Computer Assisted Research
Thomas Naef, University of Lausanne

The goal of the contribution is to summarize the advantages and disadvantages of writing a paper in DocBook. It has several advantages including style sheets and the xml file format for storing the files. Disadvantages include problems when transforming the xml files to PDF (with FOP) : Hebrew and Greek characters appear as "#" - so one must look for another software that transforms from xml (or fo) to PDF.


Paraphrasing Lamentations in 4 Ezra
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Hindy Najman, University of Toronto

The fourth vision of 4 Ezra paraphrases Lamentations. This paper explores the liturgical role of that paraphrase within the framework of the seven visions in 4 Ezra. It also considers the re-telling of Lamentations as a new lament in the context of a post-70 CE lament and in light of the claim throughout 4 Ezra that the seven visions are written in response to the first destruction in 586 BCE.


Grain, Wine, and Oil in the Northern Prophets: The Socio-economic Background of an Agricultural Metaphor
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Roger S. Nam, University of California, Los Angeles

This paper suggests that the shift from subsistence to cash-cropping occurred in the eighth century and met with significant criticism and resistance from the northern prophets. The first section builds on the work of Hopkins (1985) and Borowski (1987) in looking at epigraphic and archaeological evidence to suggest a major conversion in agricultural production strategies for northern Israel during the eighth century. The period of Assyrian withdrawal and relative economic independence allowed for northern Israel to participate heavily in economic trade, taking advantage of its amicable relationship with Tyre and proximity to the Via Maris and the King’s Highway in the Transjordan. In an attempt to create commodities suitable for trade, Israel converted much of its land from diversified subsistence agriculture to specialized cash-cropping, particularly with grain, wine and oil, the three major trade commodities in the ancient Near East. The second section analyzes the references to grain, wine and oil in the northern prophets of Amos and Hosea within the backdrop of this shift from subsistence to cash-cropping. For most of the Hebrew Bible, the usage of these terms is neutral or positive. However, these three commodities take additional ideological meaning in the northern prophets. Specifically, Amos and Hosea use these commodities as metaphors for curses, pointing to an implicit polemic against cash-cropping in the Northern Kingdom.


Psalm 2 and the Son of God in the Fourth Gospel
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Steven Nash, Faculdade Teológica Batista de São Paulo

Recent studies have drawn attention to the canonical shape of the Psalter. Without question, in its canonical form, Psalm 2 functions as a part of the introduction to the collection. The sinoptic Gospels overtly allude to the psalm near the beginning of the documents in the story of the baptism of Jesus. I will argue that John, in the first major section of the Gospel, makes two intentional allusions to Psalm 2, establishing a literary link between the titles King, Son of God, and Messiah, and the idea of a suffering Christ which appears in the Psalms of Lament.


“A Mad Passion for Idols”: Early Christianity and Cities of Statues
Program Unit: Christian Late Antiquity and Its Reception
Laura S. Nasrallah, Harvard University

Early Christian apologetic rhetoric almost always contains some arguments against idolatry and images. These arguments hint at a deeper crisis over representation, in terms of language, in terms of images, and in terms of what it means to have the “name” Christian—to represent Christ. Christian arguments against images drew not only from the traditions of Jewish scripture against idolatry, but also from ongoing arguments in the first centuries about what it meant to represent the human and the divine. Thus, in this paper I argue that we need to read early Christian injunctions against statuary in the context of similar injunctions by contemporaries who were neither Christian nor Jewish, especially in satirical or oratorical writings. Moreover, although some have thought it impossible to understand these injunctions in light of contemporary material culture, I conclude that we must read these texts in the context of the built environment of the city in antiquity, crowded as it was with its “other population” of statuary. This paper pays particular attention to those texts which claim to be written to emperors, analyzing how their rhetoric functions implicitly and explicitly to critique imperial involvement in the production of images and the empire’s claims to justice—claims that were physically manifest in something like the Forum of Trajan, with its basilica replete with statuary of bound prisoners and divinized emperors. It also pays particular attention to elite-funded building programs that sought to address the imperial family through statuary even as the early Christian apologists claimed to address the emperors through words. The paper concludes by showing how females and those of low status often become collateral damage not only in imperial depictions of triumphs in relief sculpture or statuary, but also in the rhetoric of elite early Christian authors.


The Pauline Correspondence: Struggling Subjectivities under Empire
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
Laura S. Nasrallah, Harvard University Divinity School

Feminist and postcolonial approaches to the interpretation of Paul often begin from different places. While biblical critics drawing on postcolonial theory tend to understand Paul to embrace egalitarian universalism in the face of an empire grounded in the logic of master-slave relations, or to embody the troubled yet morally paradigmatic hybrid of the empire, feminist interpreters often understand Paul as one among many interlocutors, who uses egalitarian arguments or arguments of resistance to empire when these are rhetorically effective or correspond to the deeply held principles of his interlocutors. This paper suggests that by utilizing a feminist reading of Paul’s authority and audience alongside a postcolonial analysis of power and empire, the Pauline correspondence itself becomes a powerful premodern example of subaltern peoples negotiating and struggling under empire. Influenced by strands of Lacanian understandings of subjectivity, postcolonial criticisms rarely attend to various concepts of subjectivity or colonization in time periods other than the modern or postmodern. Instead of seeing Paul as an object to analyze according to postmodern postcolonial theories, and instead of reading Paul as an exemplar of the hybrid subject who seeks to universalize, we argue that the Pauline correspondence is best read in light of both Paul and his interlocutors struggling with the formation of subjectivity under empire.


Genre Definition and Identity Formation in the Psalms
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Harry P. Nasuti, Fordham University

The last few years have seen a many-sided questioning of the form-critical consensus that dominated psalms scholarship for much of the past century. Both approaches that focus on the close reading of individual psalms and those that highlight those texts’ redaction in accord with the shaping of the larger Psalter have tended to downplay the importance of genre as an interpretive category. While such approaches clearly have broken important new ground, this paper will argue for the retention of genre as a key interpretive category, though one in need of significant reconceptualization. More specifically, this paper will argue that a greater appreciation of the psalms’ usage throughout history calls for an understanding of genre that is both descriptive and constructive. In support of this argument, the paper will take note of the ongoing importance of psalms groupings throughout the ages, as well as the way that such groupings have contributed to the formation of individual and group identity. The paper will also take note of the way that past interpreters and their communities have tended to define the genre of form-critically ambiguous psalms (such as those usually classified as “mixed types”). Finally, the paper will briefly consider the genre implications of the psalms’ liturgical usage. The paper will conclude that any attempt to understand the way that the psalms have functioned and continue to function must pay considerable attention to genre analysis, especially if the latter is understood in a more expansive way.


Embracing Icons: Byzantine Jewish Iconophiles
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Rachel Neis, Harvard University

The Qedusha Hymns in Hekhalot Rabbati (§§ 152-169, Schäfer, Synopse zur Hekhalot-Literatur, Mohr Siebeck, 1981) are liturgical performances. Their highlight is God’s embrace of Jacob’s icon as triggered by Israel’s utterance of the Qedusha. The Hymns quite deliberately set forth an ocular choreography whereby Israel’s eyes are to be raised heavenwards and God’s eyes are directed downwards, so that both parties gazing into each other’s eyes. The Hymns describe how Israel’s recitation of the Qedusha triggers God’s response in the form of his passionate embrace of Jacob’s icon. I argue that the liturgical performance that the text describes and prescribes is profitably read in the context of the period leading up to the Iconoclastic controversy.


Jesus Asks the Samaritan Woman for a Drink: A Dalit Feminist Reading of John 4
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Surekha Nelavala, Drew University

The story of the Samaritan woman has traditionally been interpreted as the offer of the gospel to the Samaritans, and has entailed all too ready questioning of the woman's moral character. Feminist scholars have done important work in reconstructing her character as an intelligent figure and challenging popular portraits of her. Reading the story of the Samaritan woman as a Dalit (untouchable) woman from India, what is striking to me is the basic fact that Jesus, a Jew, asks the Samaritan woman for a drink. This is a major step taken by Jesus in the process of liberation, but is not given sufficient importance in commentaries or interpretations. Thus I will partly depart from the recent and in itself laudable, tendency within feminist interpretation to highlight the theological conversation between the Samaritan woman and Jesus and defend her character. My paper will begin by asking what cultural dynamics are involved in Jesus' asking and accepting water from a Samaritan. Following Fernando Segovia's version of cultural studies, I will make explicit use of my own social location to bring the ancient text and context into my own present. Reading from the perspective of a Dalit women, I will challenge the text to respond to the particular oppressions suffered by the Dalits within the casteistic context. I approach the text not from general issues of Dalit women, however, but from the particular experiences of my own life situation. Thus my approach to the text in this paper will employ autobiographical criticism as well as cultural studies.


"Babylon the Great, Mother of Whores" (Revelation 17:5) in Postcolonial-Indian Feminist Perspective
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Surekha Nelavala, Drew University

This paper attempts to read the image of Babylon the Whore in Revelation 17-18 from a postcolonial feminist point of view, assuming that Revelation is written in the context of Roman imperialism and with a patriarchal mindset. From a feminist point of view, my paper will focus on the antithesis of whore and bride in Revelation, and question the binary approach of the author. From a postcolonial point of view, I will read the image of the whore intertextually from my own cultural context in India in which women are scripturally interpreted and treated as promiscuous beings, prone to whoring. I will also examine the themes of vengeance and the desire to annihilate opponents in Revelation, and pose and answer questions from a postcolonial perspective. Does the author intend to attack real people or a structure of imperialism? What are the ethical limits within which the oppressed may express their anguish? What is the ideal response of the oppressed who are brutally treated? What does the liberation of men and women in a (post)colonial context actually amount to?


"Power to the People!" Poetics and Politics in the Gospel Miracle Stories, A Soul Reading
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Michael Willett Newheart, Howard University

This “soul” reading will poetically play with power in the Gospel miracle stories. Power! Who’s got it? Who wants it? Who gets it? (Jesus? The religious authorities? The people who participate or witness the miracle? The Romans? God?) How would a first-century audience under Roman occupation have heard these stories? How would they have been empowered and disempowered by them? How do twenty-first century audiences hear them? How are they empowered or disempowered? How might these stories be heard for personal and social transformation? These questions and more (or less) will be addressed. All the usual suspects will be rounded up: Freud, Fanon, Lacan, Winnecott, Klein. Come and play with us in the miracle fields!


The Composition of Prayers and Songs in Philo's De Vita Contemplativa
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Judith H. Newman, University of Toronto

In contrast to Greek pagan prayer and in spite of its infinite variety, early Jewish prayers are marked by their interpretive engagement with Torah. How can we account for this production of scripturalized prayers? This paper compares the "philosophy" practiced by the Therapeutae at Mareotis with the nature and function of prayers at Qumran to argue that all such utterances were offered as manifestations of internalized torah, conceived through the prophetic gift of divine spirit.


Clinton, Koresh, Culpability, and Catastrophic Millennialism: The Book of Revelation, Negotiation, and the Waco Siege
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Kenneth Newport, Liverpool Hope University

The book of Revelation can be a dangerous text. Some have taken it to give so clear a vision of the world to come that they have become disengaged from, indeed even hostile to, the world that currently is. Perhaps no better example of this can be found than in the exegesis of the Branch Davidians, whose community, based at Mt Carmel near Waco in Texas, suffered a catastrophic sequence of events from 28th Feb to 19th April 1993. Despite the passing of some thirteen years since those events, arguments over responsibility for the death-laden outcome persist and, at least in an academic context, the prime responsibility has been seen to rest with US Government agencies, in particular the FBI and the ATF. In this paper I argue that this attribution of guilt does not accord with the known facts. Rather, I argue, the Branch Davidians themselves set fire to Mt Carmel and did so for a particular (theological) reason. That reason was not desperation, nor yet a response to some truly crass FBI tactics. Neither was the cause of the fire located in the presumed crazed mind of David Koresh. Rather, so I argue, the fire that took place at Mt Carmel was the outworking of apocalyptic expectation, based in substantial part upon a reading of the book of Revelation, that insisted that the end-time community must be ‘baptised by fire’ before returning as the army of Rev 19.16. The political furore that erupted after April 19th 1993 was then, so I argue, largely unnecessary since it was Koresh and others in the wider Davidian and Branch Davidian tradition, and not the FBI, who in the end were responsible for the catastrophic outcome of the 51 days of negotiation.


Character Ethics and Daniel
Program Unit: Character Ethics and Biblical Interpretation
Carol Newsom, Emory University

This paper will examine issues of moral formation in the book of Daniel.


Folklore and Feminism: Men's and Women's Stories in Genesis?
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Susan Niditch, Amherst College

There is a trajectory in folklore scholarship that deals in complicated ways with gender, voice, audience, genre, and, of course, the traditional narrative patterns of the tales. This paper will discuss some of this scholarship [including that of Margaret Mills and Margaret Beissinger] and then apply their obeservations to biblical material in Genesis.


Oral Literature and the Hebrew Bible: Applications and Misconceptions
Program Unit: Orality, Textuality, and the Formation of the Hebrew Bible
Susan Niditch, Amherst College

This paper reviews the history of scholarship in the field of early and oral literatures, especially as it pertains to the study of biblical literature, and points to a variety of misconceptions about oral literature and its relevance to the ancient Israelite corpus. The author then provides a few case studies, exploring some of the ways in which the approaches and assumptions of oral studies enrich and inform one's appreciation for the text, texture, and context of biblical literature.


Philo and Genesis Rabbah: Similar Questions and Answers
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Maren Niehoff, Hebrew University

A comparison between Philo's "Questions and Answers on Genesis" and Genesis Rabbah against the background of the genre of "Questions and Answers" in Homeric Scholarship. I shall discuss whether the exegetes in Genesis Rabbah raised the same or other questions and whether they may have been familiar with the genre as it appears in Philo's work.


Neither a Spear nor a Shield Be: Defining the Enigmatic ???
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Paul Nikkel, University of Sheffield

The ??? is an enigmatic term for weaponry in the MT that appears as part of Goliath's panoply in 1 Samuel 17. The Hebrew etymology of the word points towards its identification as an offensive weapon; however, the LXX and English translations almost unequivocally render it as a shield of some type, implying a defensive object. A closer examination of its use in the MT, as well as uses of the Akkadian cognate sinnatu, indicates that it probably was not a defensive weapon. This paper looks at alternate meanings for the term, including "spear," "spiked shield" and "pick-axe." The various contexts in which this terms appears in the MT will be examined, as well as possible chronological implications about its period of currency in combat and what light this might shed on its inclusion in 1 Samuel 17.


Ideological Interurbanism in Neo-Assyrian Prophecy
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Martti Nissinen, University of Helsinki

Prophetic activity is attested in several Neo-Assyrian cities. While Arbela assumes an outstanding position in the written documents of prophecy preserved to us, it is evident that prophets were part of the local cults in cities like Ashur, Calah, Nineveh, and Babylon. The sources do not report on major rivalries between prophets and their cultic traditions in different cities. On the contrary, the Neo-Assyrian prophets, at least according to the available documentation, seem to share the fundamental constituents of the Neo-Assyrian royal ideology, which gives the impression of a state-run inter-urban communication between prophetic communities in different temples of Ishtar. Only a few scattered pieces of evidence make some tensions discernible below the surface. Prophecy, hence, appears as a significant means of propagating the Assyrian imperial ideology in different cities as divine words surpassing local interests.


Hellenizing Phoenicia or Phoenicianizing Hellenism? Interpreting Evidence of 'Foreign' Cultures in the Persian Levant
Program Unit: Literature and History of the Persian Period
Jessica L. Nitschke, University of California, Berkeley

Modern reconstructions of the cultural history of the Phoenician cities in the Persian period frequently highlight the infiltration of ‘Hellenism’ as a central feature, relying on sculpture, architectural fragments, and the adoption of coinage as the primary evidence. In such characterizations, traditional Phoenician cultural tastes and behaviors are gradually replaced with increasingly Greek ones, culminating in a total ‘hellenization’ soon after Alexander’s conquest and the establishment of Greco-Macedonian overlordship. This paper challenges this conventional view, arguing that it has been perpetuated by an exclusive approach to the evidence that fixes on the Greek characteristics of cultural evidence and excludes or dismisses parallel evidence of Egyptian, Achaemenid, Cypriot and continuing Phoenician cultural traits. As such, the traditional interpretation has more to do with modern presumptions about the relationship between Greek culture and other Eastern Mediterranean cultures in the latter part of the first millennium B.C. than with a critical evaluation of the available evidence. A more inclusive approach to the material suggests that Greek influence on Phoenician culture in this period has been overestimated, and reveals a cultural picture that is much more complex than a simple linear transition from ‘Phoenician’ culture to ‘Hellenism’. This paper puts forward an alternative method of analyzing the presence of ‘Greek’ cultural features in the evidence, one that goes beyond simple identification and focuses on the context and transformation of the foreign elements as they are appropriated by the local culture. In doing so, it considers the scholarly trends that have habitually shaped the analysis of foreign cultural elements that appear in the Levant, and how these continue to impact our historical understanding of this region in this period.


Recurring Theological Motifs in the Book of the Twelve: Creating Points of Contact for Narrative, Dialogue, and Dissent
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
James Nogalski, Gardner-Webb University School of Divinity

Research in the past twenty years has surfaced several recurring motifs in the Book of the Twelve that may have helped create or resulted from traditions concerning the unity of this corpus. Much energy has been spent trying to determine the extent to which any or all of these motifs may have been the result of deliberate editorial shaping or collecting of the Twelve Prophets. This paper will explore the nature of these motifs and the way they intersect one another. The paper will also offer suggestions about the extent to which recognition of these constellations can aid readers in extrapolating strategies for dealing with the Twelve as a composite corpus which also invites readers to engage the writings in relation to one another and to the Sitz im Buch of the respective writings.


Contemplation of the Throne and Realized Eschatology in the Book of Revelation
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Paulo Augusto de Souza Nogueira, Universidade Metodista de São Paulo

The main body of the book of Revelation is framed by worship scenes in front of God´s throne ( Rev 4-5 and 19,1-9) and by hymn like texts inserted in the context of decisive judgment visions (12,10;15,3-4; 16,5-7). That literary form has been understood as a liturgical commentary on eschatological events and not so much as a basic structural component of the narrative. In support of this, the majority of scholars and interpreters have adopted the linear sequence of eschatological events in their studies and researches (for instance, in the zeitgeschichtliche interpretation). Our aim in this paper consists in discussing the hermeneutic implications of the point of view that all eschatological scenery is set in front of the throne of God and has been structured by liturgical material. Could we say that this implies a conception of realized eschatology which considers the judgment of the world mere consequence of the revelation of the true heavenly world? Do the picture of crowds of singing and worshipping people in the principal sections of the book as well as the account of John ascending to heaven as an exemplar heavenly traveler have something to say about the condition and meaning of cultic celebrations in the prophetic group of Revelation?


A Wild Ass of a Man: The Son of Hagar in Genesis 16 and 21: Competing Stories and Views
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Ed Noort, University of Groningen

Genesis 16:12 reads: ‘Indeed he will be a wild ass of a man, his hand against all, and the hands of all against him.’ What kind of world view does the author of this text have, looking at nomadic life full of amazement? Nomads and nomadic life are strange and dangerous. They are fighters, lonely ones, nowhere at home, living in widespread regions. On the other side those people are brothers. Distant brothers, but nevertheless family. Formcritically we have to do with a tribal story. The Assyrian Name Šumu’il renders a North Arabian tribal name S1ama‘’il which is without doubt the same name as Hebrew Jišma’el (Knauf). But historicity is not the main focus of the paper. The main character in Genesis 16 is the story of a self- confident, proud woman, using the favour of the moment. Sarai, her mistress, and Abram her bed partner and master are acting in the margin. The name of Ishmael is only used once. In ch 21 he is an anonymous throughout the story. In 16, however, he is the nomad-raider, in 21 he looks like a desert hunter. The differences between the Ishmael images reflect the different views on Hagar. In Gen 16 she was an active woman finding her own way through the desert. In Gen 21, she wanders aimlessly in the wilderness of Beer Sheba (V.14), a region with more water and food than the desert of Shur. The paper explores the literary relations between Gen 16 and 21 focussing on the different characters of Ishmael and Hagar. On the level of composition the divine intervention in both Gen 21 en 22 is studied.


The Imaginative Effects of Ezekiel’s Merkavah Vision: Chagall and Ezekiel in Creative Discourse
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Sally Norris, University of Oxford

This paper will consider the hermeneutical implications arising when text meets image in the art of Marc Chagall and the merkavah vision of the prophet Ezekiel (Ezek 1:1 – 3:15). The Hebrew Bible traversed Chagall’s life and art. He was fascinated by the pathos of the dramatic narratives of Genesis and Exodus; he was captivated by the sensuous eroticism of the Song of Songs; he was moved by the visions of hope announced by the Prophets. His initial biblical series, La Bible, was commissioned by Ambroise Vollard in the 1930’s and consisted of 105 engravings (originally gouaches) illustrating narratives from the first twelve books of the Jewish Bible (Genesis to Ezekiel). Engravings 104 and 105, depicting Ezekiel 1 and Ezekiel 2-3 respectively, conclude the series. The paper will (i) briefly introduce Chagall’s life, in particular his relationship with the Bible; (ii) consider the ‘text’ of the La Bible -- its composition, themes, and influences; and (iii) provide a detailed textual analysis of Ezekiel’s merkavah vision in relation to engravings 104 and 105. This discussion will demonstrate how Chagall’s anthropological hermeneutic re-orients the reading of Ezekiel’s vision from the theo-centric to the anthro-centric. In so doing, Chagall circumvents the iconoclasm of text and tradition, and re-directs the text away from the merkavah vision to a commentary upon his own life and the prophet Ezekiel himself. This paper is written neither with the expertise of an art historian nor as a Chagall scholar, but rather from the perspective of biblical scholarship. The primary purpose is not to gain a more complete understanding of Chagall as a biblical artist, but rather to uncover new interpretive dimensions within the Hebrew narrative as an example of the Wirkungsgeschichte of Ezekiel’s vision in the twentieth century.


The Discourse Structure of Balaam’s Oracles and the Problem of Verbal Tenses
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Tania Notarius, Hebrew University of Jerusalem

The semantic analysis of verbal tenses in a Biblical poetic text is not an easy task. The function of tense in poetic speech has been analyzed much less than that in prosaic narrative and discourse. A reason for this might be the lack of accurate pragmatic criteria, which would make an adequate semantic description possible. This paper attempts to analyze a given poetic text (the biblical oracles of Balaam) according to such general communicative categories as addresser and addressee(s), the core of the message, the pragmatics of the addresser’s speech, the communicative structure of the whole, etc. This approach allows one to define the collection of the oracles as a basically egocentric discourse, orientated to the moment of speech, directed by clear pragmatic rationales. With discourse conditions thus defined the semantic analysis of verbal tenses gets full basis. The analysis includes all the verbal forms in a predicate position. Some relatively archaic and rare uses are identified.


Jesus’ Jewish Hermenutical Method in the Nazareth Synagogue
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
R. Steven Notley, Nyack College

Much has been written about the importance of Jewish sources for our understanding of Jesus and the Early Church. There remains a lack of corresponding recognition about the contribution of the New Testament for our knowledge of Jewish life and thought in the Second Commonwealth. Luke’s story of Jesus in Nazareth is the oldest record of the Jewish custom to follow the reading of the Torah in the synagogue with a reading from the Prophets. The episode also provides a largely overlooked example of a Jewish hermeneutical method identified with Hillel (gezerah shavah). Little notice is given that in the entire Hebrew Scriptures only in the two textual blocks fused by Jesus (Isaiah 58:1-9; 61:1-4) can we find the phrase ratson la-YHWH. This verbal link is lacking in the Septuagint’s otherwise close Greek translation of Isaiah 58:1-9—Luke’s supposed source for the citation. In other words, Jesus’ creative verbal exegesis is possible only if he is using the Hebrew Scriptures. Through the window of this episode we explore how sacred texts were employed by Jesus and his contemporaries, and also what may have been the intended message that Sabbath in Nazareth. When the method and message of Jesus’ exegesis are clearly understood, we hear a voice articulating new trends in Jewish thought. These bold innovations were not always welcome. Can it be that the less-than-welcoming response in Nazareth was not a “rejection of Jesus” per se, but instead a reaction to the revolutionary ideas heard both in proto-Pharisaic Judaism and in the teaching of Jesus?


Was the Galilee No Longer Jewish in the Days of Aristobulus?
Program Unit: Archaeological Excavations and Discoveries: Illuminating the Biblical World
R. Steven Notley, Nyack College

One of the legacies from the short reign of Aristobulus I was his defeat of the Itureans. Their defeat required territorial concessions, but Aristobulus offered, if they wished to remain in their country, to be circumcised and to live in accordance with the laws of the Jews (Ant.13:318). There is no indication in the literary account for the borders of the Iturean territory, and some scholars have suggested that Aristobulus defeat of the Itureans is to be identified with the campaign of Antigonus, brother of Aristobulus in the Galilee (War 1:76). A frequently repeated scholarly opinion in the previous century maintained that a generation earlier Simon had evacuated all of the Jewish communities of the Galilee. As a result, the region remained (virtually or entirely) devoid of a Jewish presence and was subsequently populated by the Itureans until their defeat by Aristobulus (see Schrer, Vermes and Millar 1:217-218). This mistaken reading of Simons rescue of Jewish communities in western Galilee (1 Macc 5:21-23) served as the foundation for the incendiary assertion in some later pre-WWII continental scholarship that the Jewish settlements of the Galilee in the New Testament period were merely the descendants of Aristobulus campaign of coerced conversation, and that the Galilean population in the first century CE was not ethnically Jewish (including Jesus and his first followers). Recent archaeological data confirms the sparse but consistent historical testimony of a continued Jewish presence in the Galilee in the 2nd century BCE. This study will consider the evidence from recent archaeological efforts and offer a careful reading of the pertinent historical passages to determine the extent of Simons efforts and the question of a Jewish presence in the Galilee during the days of Aristobulus.


Can One Speak of Biblical Rights?
Program Unit:
David Novak, University of Toronto

*


A Polanyian Understanding of the Colossian Parenesis
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Patrick Novak, Senegal Theological Bible College and Seminary

This paper will argue that our understanding of the Colossian parenesis will be fundamentally deepened and enhanced by an appreciation and application of the epistemology of Michael Polanyi; a Polanyian epistemology provides a more natural, organic understanding of the parenetical material than the traditional discussions revolving around the the relationship between the indicative and imperative sections of the Pauline corpus. This paper will do this through a brief examination and application of Polanyian concepts such as discovery, tacit knowledge, subsidiary and focal awareness, indwelling, the society of exploerers, and the hierarchy of knowledge. This paper will demonstrate how Paul's parenetical instruction actually helps disciples "walk in a manner worthy of the Lord" (Col. 1.10). In demonstrating this, this paper explains more than the "what" of the parenetical material; it demonstrates "how" Paul's parenetical instruction actually helps form Christian disciples.


Turning the Other Cheek to a Perpetrator: Denunciation or Upholding of Justice?
Program Unit: Matthew
Lidija Novakovic, Bethel University, St. Paul

Jesus' demand to turn the other cheek to a perpetrator is the first of the four examples of how not to resist an evildoer (Matt 5:39-42). However, only turning the other cheek to an offender presupposes an arbitrary act of the latter that not only violates the victim's physical integrity but also, as a "back-handed" slap, degrades his humanness. Moreover, it presumes an asymmetrical social relationship and the innocence of the injured party. Jesus' call for a suspension of violent retributive urge of a victim of brutal injustice and humiliation can undoubtedly be understood as a call to end up the spiral of violence. Yet, his request to turn the other cheek sounds, at the first glance, as a plea to the victim to become an accomplice in his own oppression. I want to strengthen and further expand recent studies which have shown that Jesus advocates neither violence nor passivity, but active nonviolent resistance. In particular, I will argue that Jesus offers here an alternative vision of justice. This justice is not based on the equivalence of the offense and retaliation, but on the restoration of humanness of both the victim and the perpetrator. By refusing to be humiliated and dehumanized, the victim restores his human dignity by willingly offering the other cheek to the perpetrator. This gesture, in turn, offers a chance to the perpetrator to reconsider his act of violence and restore his lost humanness. The fact that the text is silent with regard to the effectiveness of this form of nonviolent resistance indicates that it is more concerned with attitude than its outcome. This understanding of justice, deeply rooted in the Jesus tradition and reinforced in the post-70 setting of the Matthean community, has potential to inform both our theology and our social practice.


Salomé in the Bible and Nineteenth Century Art
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Ela Nutu, University of Sheffield

Not even named in the biblical accounts, Salomé has become the epitome of the femme fatale. Does the Bible justify this reading of Herod’s young step-daughter? This paper examines depictions of Salomé by Henri Regnault, Gustave Moreau and Lovis Corinth and investigates the gender, psychoanalytical and signification tensions at play within the processes of reception and representation of the biblical character.


Whose Text, Whose Gaze, Whose Language? Judith, Women Painters, and French Feminists
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Ela Nutu, University of Sheffield

While the text depicts Judith as a righteous widow who saves her people from colonisation, she is mostly remembered for decapitating Holofernes, and many visual representations depict her as a femme fatale. This paper looks at the work of women painters and investigates the signification tensions at play within the process of interpreting Judith visually. What happens when women are both the object and the owner of the gaze? Is there special insight into the complexities of the biblical character?


Violent Pictures, Violent Cultures? The “Aesthetics of Violence” in Contemporary Film and in Ancient Prophetic Texts
Program Unit: Prophetic Texts and Their Ancient Contexts
Julia M. O'Brien, Lancaster Theological Seminary

In their analysis of the “aesthetics of violence,” scholars of contemporary film explore what artistic representations of violence both reveal and obscure about the societies that produced them. This paper considers how the categories developed within contemporary film theory might inform our understanding of what prophetic depictions of violence do—and don't—reveal about the ancient societies from which they come.


Recurring Themes in Nahum-Habakkuk-Zephaniah
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Julia M. O'Brien, Lancaster Theological Seminary

This paper traces the continuities and discontinuities between these books and others within the Twelve in regard to major themes and motifs. Primary focus is given to characterization of the nations and to constructions of gender.


If Only Tears Were Possible (Jeremiah 8:23–9:6 and 9:17–22)
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Kathleen M. O'Connor, Columbia Theological Seminary

Collective numbing is a common response among victims of disaster. One way the book of Jeremiah seeks to rebuild the community destroyed during the Babylonian Period is to cultivate expressions of grief. God's lament and the call for the services of the mourning women are aspects of that effort.


Recent Work on Biblical Hebrew Word Order
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Michael Patrick O'Connor, Catholic University of America

Discussion of word order in Biblical Hebrew has proceeded apace in recent years, but not always with enough attention to the findings of general linguistics. This paper will deal with a few relevant points. (a) The harmonic of head-first or head0last is always the most basic facet of word order, and further statement of a fixed word order for a given language or corpus may not be warranted by the evidence; more bluntly, arguments about whether BHeb is VSO or SVO may not be linguistically resolvable, notwithstanding the (possible) pedagogical utility of such formulations. (b) Since Hebrew does show facets of V2 order, a measure of clarity about the word order of the Germanic family, which is (broadly speaking) V2, would be useful. (c) The word order patterns and the related patterns of topic and focus found in ordinary prose texts are not to be found in poetic texts in most languages; the well-known case of Old Babylonian Akkadian makes that clear.


Interpreting Romans by Focusing on a Cross-Cultural Model of Holiness
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Peter Oakes, University of Manchester

In Romans, Paul represents the boundary of the Christian communities as a boundary between the holy and the ordinary. Consideration of holiness in cross-cultural terms leads us to draw together the following: separation from the ordinary; links with other holy entities; use of special terminology designating the holy. Coordinating these three features suggests patterns in Romans that are not evident in the more usual approaches via topics such as justification and faith.


The Reception of the Book of Daniel and Danielic Literature in the Early Church
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Gerbern S. Oegema, McGill University

Whereas cosmogony has traditionally been seen as a topic dealt with primarily in wisdom literature, and eschatology a field mostly focused uponin apocalyptic literature, the categorization of apocryphal and pseudepigraphical writings into sapiential, apocalyptic, and other genres has always been felt to be unsatisfactory. The reason is that most of the Pseudepigrapha share many elements of various genres and do not fit into only one genre. The Book of Daniel, counted among the Writings of the Hebrew Bible and among the Prophets in the Septuagint as well as in the Christian Old Testament, is such an example. Does it deal with an aspect of Israel’s origin and history or only with its future? The answer is that the author sees part of the secrets of Israel’s future already revealed in its past. This aspect is then stressed even more in the reception of the Book of Daniel as well as of that of writings ascribed to Daniel: if one wants to know something about Israel’s future in an ever-changing present situation, one needs to interpret the signs of the past. The interpretation of Israel’s place in political history, and how the rise and fall of world powers influence Israel’s fate, thus becomes a central focus of interest. This paper will focus on a few examples from the reception of the Book of Daniel in the Early Church, and specifically ask whether the analysis of a political situation from a faith perspective is an interpretation of a past, present, or future situation. Furthermore, do elements of political analysis and political theology serve a purpose of comforting a faith group in an ever-changing historical situation? And finally, what should one call such a political interpretation: typical cosmogonic, sapiential, eschatological, or apocalyptic exegesis, or are these and similar distinctions totally out of place?


Gerhard von Rad in Heidelberg: The Mystery of his Influence in Germany
Program Unit:
Manfred Oeming, University of Heidelberg

*


Legitimation and Delegitimation in Judges 9: Abimelech’s Rise and Demise
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
Gordon Oeste, University of Toronto, Wycliffe College

The story of Abimelech ben Jerubbaal in Judges 9 has been viewed by some as patently anti-monarchic and thus standing in stark contrast to the pro-monarchic ending of the Book of Judges. Other have suggested that Judges 9 reflects only upon the methods by which Abimelech seized power. This paper will utilize sociological and anthropological studies with regard to legitimation and delegitimation in state contexts in order to suggest that the negative characterization of monarchic rule in Judges 9:1-57 served to delegitimate Abimelech as a localized leader. This delegitimization functioned as part of a strategy to prevent fissioning by subverting local bases of power in favour of a centralized polity. Judges 9 then falls into step with the pro-monarchic arguments forwarded at the end of the Book of Judges.


Taking Segovia Seriously: Cultural Criticism, Exegesis, and Parish Preaching
Program Unit: Homiletics and Biblical Studies
Margaret Aymer, Interdenominational Theological Center

*


Diminutive Churches: Seeking the Clientele of Ephesos’ Chapels
Program Unit: Christian Late Antiquity and Its Reception
Ruth M. Ohm Wright, Franciscan School of Theology

The investigation and interpretation of chapels in Late Antique Ephesos, until recently, has been usurped by interest in the city’s illustrious basilicas of St. Mary and St. John. Yet small chapel structures, often adapted somewhat awkwardly into previously existing buildings, offer an exciting venue for exploring possible uses related to worship practices and participants. Particularly intriguing is the question of whether chapels reflect a reception and praxis of ancient Christianity alternative to the monumental basilicas. Textual sources, ranging from imperial legislative documents to patristic evidence, give us a window into the activities within some chapels, most notably those in domestic settings. While chapels in residences undisputedly belong to a certain segment of society in antiquity, those chapels not incorporated into upscale living arrangements may in fact draw a separate segment of the population. This paper surveys several Ephesian chapels in different architectural contexts and, with the assistance of textual sources, offers suggestions for their interpretation.


The Ambiguity of Interpretation: Paul and Thekla in Ephesos
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Ruth Ohm Wright, Franciscan School of Theology

Excavations in Ephesos have exposed a source for supplementing the narratives associated with Paul in both the canonical and apocryphal Acts of the Apostles. Exceptional interest was stimulated by the remains of an exquisite painting found in a cave located just outside the city center; the fresco expresses a delightful iconographic rendition of the legend handed down in the Acts of Paul and Thekla. This depiction of three primary characters known from the Acts of Paul and Thekla has generated different interpretations, which hinge on distinct features such as the size of the characters, their position relative to one another, their arm position and hand gesture. With respect to the larger vista of Theklan iconography, the relative rarity of images of Thekla and Paul in this narrative scene obfuscates this painting’s analysis. In addition to elucidating the content of fresco, other aspects begging explanation include the surrounding context of the painting, the (liturgical?) use of the cave, the type of visitors to the cave, the monument’s donor, and the continued use of the cave after this fresco was coated. This paper will present various challenges in recent study of the fresco, and offer suggestions for continued interpretation.


The Un-narrated Resurrection as the Climax of Mark: A Response to Clayton Croy
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Kenneth Olson, Duke University

Clayton Croy’s recent book The Mutilation of Mark’s Gospel aims to reopen the question of whether the original author of the Gospel According to Mark intended for his work to end at Mk. 16.8. Croy argues forcefully that such an ending, lacking the post-resurrection appearances of Jesus to his disciples, would be anachronistic. He claims ancient storytellers did not use the device of allowing the audience to complete the story nor did they suppress the climax of their narratives. This paper will examine Croy’s arguments and suggest that, first, the device of allowing the audience to complete the story is known in ancient drama and literature and, second, Croy has misidentified the climax of Mark’s gospel, which is the resurrection of Jesus and which is reported within Mark’s text.


The Divine Child: The Reflection of Roman Imperial Cult in Revelation 12
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Heike Omerzu, University of Mainz

Rev 12 contains several elements also known by Greco-Roman and Jewish legends of the endangered birth and childhood of important persons (cf. e.g. Horus, Apollo, Moses). My paper will draw special attention to the imagery of the woman clothed with the sun and the rescue of her son as he is caught up to God’s throne (cf. Rev 12:1-5). There is literary as well as numismatic evidence that this narration ironically reverses claims of the Roman Imperial cult. In particular, Rev 12 seems to reflect Domitian’s attempt to present himself as a god (during his lifetime!) by the deification of his deceased son. This investigation does not only corroborate the assumption of a formation of Revelation under Domitian but also contributes to a better understanding of its theological and admonishing issues: The Seer emphasizes that the claims of the worldly ruler for divinity and all emperor worship is blasphemy because the only one who deserves veneration is the son of the true queen of heaven, i.e. Christ.


Bullinger’s Reading of Romans
Program Unit: Romans through History and Cultures
Peter Opitz, University of Zurich

The crucial role of Romans in the Reformation does not need to be underscored. This is also true for Heinrich Bullinger. He called it a “Compendium philosophiae christianae.” Already in 1525 during his time as a young reformed teacher at the monastery of Kappel (Calvin was still studying the artes at that time) he gave a lecture on this Pauline epistle. Some years later, in 1533, shortly after becoming Zwingli’s successor in Zurich, he published a commentary on Romans which he then edited several times during the following years. Trained as a humanist, Bullinger employed all the humanist exegetical methods he had learned from Erasmus, Melanchthon, Valla, and others. But he managed to develop his own way of reformed exegesis. One main feature is that Bullinger took into account the fact that Paul was a Hebrew scholar. Probably like nobody else among the Reformers of the first and second generations, Bullinger argued with a Hebrew concept of “Heilsgeschichte.” He read the letter to the Romans, like the New Testament as a whole, as a “commentary of the Old Testament.” As a consequence, important concepts such as the word “faith” are explained by drawing on the Old Testament texts which had shaped Paul’s mind when he wrote to the Christians in Rome. Thus the chapters about Israel (Rom 9-11) are in Bullinger’s eyes not a timeless biblical doctrine about divine election and reprobation of individuals, but a warning of God, addressed first to Israel, his beloved and chosen people – and an expression of his never-ending faithfulness. Only in the mirror of this “story” between God and Israel should the Christian church interpret these chapters as an address to itself.


Matthew 4:1–11
Program Unit: New Testament Mysticism Project
Andrei Orlov, Marquette University

A commentary on Matthew 4:1-11 will be presented.


Women’s Patronage in Burial Practices
Program Unit:
Carolyn Osiek, Texas Christian University

*


What Kinds of Meals Did Julia Felix Have in Pompeii?
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
Carolyn Osiek, Texas Christian University

The "Praedium of Julia Felix" at Pompeii contains a variety of different meal and entertainment settings all in the same complex, all apparently owned and operated by a freedwoman. The arrangement is open to a number of possible interpretations which will be explored in the context of what we know about semi-public eating establishments and their social functions.


Mapping Identity onto a Biblical Landscape: Israelite Tradition and the Construction of Jewish Idumea in the Hellenistic Period
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Kevin Osterloh, Princeton University

By the time of the Great Revolt (66-70 CE), the legitimacy of the Idumeans as bona fide Judeans was widely accepted. Upon entering Jerusalem in 68 CE, Josephus (BJ 4.273-282) has their leader, Simon, declare the Idumeans’ desire to defend their common Judean metropolis, ancestral Judean customs, and, above all, the temple. There are few cases in the ancient world that illustrate the socially constructed nature of ethnic identity as well as that of the Idumeans, who evolved from implacable Edomite enemies of Israel in the biblical period to defenders of ancestral Judean custom, country and autonomy against Rome. Although initiated en-masse into the Judean ethnos, under the Hasmonean, John Hyrcanus, in 129 BCE, the process of becoming Judean, in my view, only gradually took shape over the following 200 years. This paper explores the dynamics of Idumean acclimation into the Hellenistic period Judean body-politic and the strategies employed in the ongoing negotiation of communal identity, in particular, the use of monumental architecture, and newly consecrated topography, at Hebron and Mamre, as a means of cementing legitimacy. This study also sheds light on Judean elite participation within the sociopolitical and cultural reality of the Hellenistic World, by demonstrating that a major motivational source for Idumean inclusion stemmed from Judean elite desires to reinvent their body-politic, not in opposition to, but rather in way that made sense within the Hellenistic World. Embracing their new identity as “Judeans” from Idumea, the inhabitants of Hebron and its surroundings reinvented themselves through the sacred Israelite topography where they resided. By settling the south of biblical Judah, the Idumeans chanced upon a veritable biblical theme park, ripe for future exploitation by new Judeans, eager to mask their former position as archenemies of Judah, and to stake a legitimate claim to the ancient Israelite heritage.


Isis Tyrannos and the Construction of Imperial Society: Globalization and Social Formation
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Panayotis Pachis, Aristotle University, Thessaloniki, Greece

*


Myth and Social Realia in Ancient Israel: Early Hebrew Poems as Folkloric Enchiridion
Program Unit: Bible, Myth, and Myth Theory
Hugh Rowland Page, Jr., University of Notre Dame

This paper will assess the strengths, weaknesses, and implications of the use of Early Hebrew Poems (EHPs) as a control group for the testing of single theories and methodological paradigms aimed at the reconstruction of myth, folklore, and social reality in ancient Israel. As an illustrative example, it will present an experimental reading of the early Hebrew corpus as a poetic enchiridion containing data that can be used to: (1) delimit the parameters of the divine – human relationship; (2) understand more clearly conceptions of personhood; and (3) determine the extent to which these poems may have been generative of both implicit and explicit spiritualities (broadly construed) from the 11th – 5th centuries BCE. The study will demonstrate that textual corpora, even those whose authorship, date, and provenance are contested, can be used to test hypotheses and promote creative scholarly engagement about the topography of ancient Israel’s intellectual landscape.


East Meets West: Caesarea Maritima in Josephus and the Acts of the Apostles
Program Unit: Book of Acts
R. Jackson Painter, Simpson University

While a significant amount of information about the city of Caesarea Maritima exists in literary, archaeological, and inscriptional sources, two literary works where Caesarea figures prominently are Josephus’ Jewish War and the New Testament book of Acts. Caesarea is not only one place among many in these works but its unique geographical placement and features allow each author to employ this city as a setting which helps to advance the plot of each work in particular ways. Broadly speaking, Caesarea functions as the intersection between the Jewish and Gentile worlds in both works. This paper examines the usage of Caesarea as a significant setting in these works, how each author uses this particular setting in the advancement of the story, and how these insights affect the interpretation of each work.


Romans 5 and 13 as Lenses into the Similarities and Differences of Melanchthon, Calvin, and Luther’s Romans Commentaries
Program Unit: Romans through History and Cultures
Sujin Pak, Garrett Evangelical Theological Seminary

This essay examines the commentaries of Philip Melanchthon, John Calvin, and Martin Luther on chapters five and thirteen of Paul’s Epistle to the Romans as lenses to compare and contrast their interpretive methods and theological emphases. Romans 5 provides a picture of their views on the fruits of justification, the role of suffering in the Christian life, and their definitions of sin and grace. Romans 13 reflects these three reformers’ view of the Christian’s relationship to governing authorities and the fulfillment of the law through love of neighbor. While many common correlations are found in Melanchthon, Calvin, and Luther’s readings of Romans 5 and 13, there are also some significant differences that speak to their particular theological emphases and interpretive methods. Luther more than the other two wants to speak of the freedom of the Christian. Calvin is far more concerned to follow carefully the authorial intention of the text—namely, what he sees to be the intentions of Paul—and is more apt to find and emphasize the doctrines of providence and election in these chapters. And Melanchthon sometimes appears to be more Lutheran than Luther himself in his emphasis on such distinctively Lutheran theological themes as Law vs. Gospel and justification by faith alone and attacks on Catholicism.


Zedekiah’s Fate and the Dynastic Succession
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Juha Pakkala, University of Helsinki

King Zedekiah’s fate has not aroused much scholarly discussion. This is surprising because Zedekiah was Judah’s last king and therefore the last reigning heir to David’s throne. As a son of Josiah, Zedekiah’s line would represent the Davidic dynastic line. There has been much more discussion about the deposed Jehoiachin and his alleged rehabilitation in 2Kgs 25:27-30. Most scholars assume that 2Kgs 24:18-25:7 represents a fairly historical rendering of Zedekiah’s final days and fate, but several inconsistencies suggest that the account is biased and unreliable. In addition, it is incompatible with some passages in the book of Jeremiah. It is probable that the author of Kings was not preoccupied with the Davidic kingship only because of his interest in the history of kingship and continuity of the dynasty. He wrote in an exilic context where two dynastic lines were in a position to justify their legitimacy to the throne, and he had a firm position in this conflict. He rejected Zedekiah’s line as a dead end in favor of Jehoiachin. This motive is significant for interpreting the meaning and message of the books of Kings.


Rereading Lachish 3: Oath Formulae and the Question of Literacy
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
Grace Jeongyeon Park, University of California, Los Angeles

Lachish 3 has been understood previously as a literate soldier’s defense of his ability to read, written in response to a superior officer who calls the soldier’s literacy into question. A new interpretation of lines 4-5 together with a detailed investigation the use of ’im in oath formulae yields a somewhat different meaning of the letter as a whole. The particle ’im in oaths traditionally signifies a negative assertion in the Hebrew Bible. Joüon and Muraoka explain the inverted meaning of ’im in oaths as a result of contamination by the self-curse. I however explain this usage of ’im as an extension of the rhetorical question (1 Kgs 1:27; Amos 3:6; Isa 29:16; Job 6:12), which is used to emphasize or assert something and frequently follows various oath formulae (see especially, Jer 38:16). Based on my reinterpretation, ’im in lines 9 and 11 can be seen as an indicator of negative assertion. We may then understand lines 9 through 13 as reflecting the helpless situation of a junior officer who is able to read, but unable to make sense of his superior’s letter. This situation is also reflected in the soldier’s request for further clarification in lines 4-5. These lines bear a great deal of similarity to 2 Kgs 6:17, where Elisha asks God to make Elisha’s servant see what he could not see before. Under this rereading of Lachish 3, we no longer find a soldier defending his literacy in the face of social stigma, but rather a clear acknowledgment of both his relatively low level of literacy and the absence of others at his post who could assist him in making sense of the content of his superior’s letter. This paints a rather different picture of the sociology of literacy in seventh-century Judah.


Politics of Boundary: Reading Scriptural Economics with the Grassroots People
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Rohun Park, Vanderbilt University

The early Christian Gospels’ most radical construction of economy relates to an alternative oikos and oikonomia in terms of the creation of extensive opportunities and freedoms over and against the economy of Rome and also writes its empowering effects into the present context of the grassroots people. Jesus’ oikonomia arises not from a moral of good economic discipline and earnings, but rather from real needs and real community under the mercy and grace of God, who levels all boundaries of “every valley” and “every mountain” (Luke 3:5). This essay uses the social memory of the Korean Minjung as a contextual, hermeneutical frame in order to reconstruct a pattern of scripture’s alternative way of living and interacting under the reality of empire (Luke 18:18-30; 19:1-10; cf. 17:11-19). Such configuration goes beyond individual relations and purely materialistic motivations in a market economy and does not allow for the division of costs from benefits, because they are interpenetrating and interdependent therein.


Remaking the Codex Sinaiticus: The Ancient Team and the Modern Team
Program Unit:
David Parker, University of Birmingham

The task of making a ‘virtual Codex Sinaiticus’ has strong analogies with the process of creating the ancient manuscript. Both are the work of a team, requiring the planning of the whole work and agreement of technical standards. The paper explores what this consisted of in the fourth century, including quality and preparation of parchment and inks, page size and lay-out, selection of script, presentation of ancillary material, and division of labour. It then addresses the parallels in the modern edition, and discusses the comparative merits of a manuscript and an electronic edition.


Yahweh's Asherah: A Local Manifestation of a Levantine Goddess
Program Unit: Paleographical Studies in the Ancient Near East
Heather Dana Davis Parker, King College

The precise nature of “Asherah” and her function within the cult of Israel continues to be the subject of debate. Naturally, of particular import in the discussion are the Old Hebrew epigraphic references to “Yahweh and his Asherah” (Kuntillet Ajrud and Khirbet el-Qom). Some within the field have argued that the “Asherah” referred to was the famed Levantine goddess attested at Ugarit (e.g., Dever). However, many have argued that the “Asherah” of the Old Hebrew epigraphic corpus is not the goddess, but rather a wooden cult object (e.g., Smith). It has also been argued that the term “asherah” in the Old Hebrew inscriptions should be affirmed to signify the “cultically available presence.” That is, “an abstract aspect of a male deity is hypostatized, personified, and worshipped as a goddess, who may be thought to function as a consort of that deity” (McCarter). This paper focuses heavily on the ancient Near Eastern textual evidence, especially the Akkadian, Phoenician, and Aramaic references to “local manifestations of deities” and then assesses the implications for the interpretation of the Old Hebrew epigraphic references to “Asherah.”


Women Warriors and Devoted Daughters: The Powerful Young Woman in Ugaritic Narrative Poetry
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
Julie Faith Parker, Yale University

This paper offers a feminist interpretation of Ugaritic narrative poetry and focuses on the sublime and stalwart young women in this literature. In the Baal cycle, a daughter bullies the most puissant patriarch (KTU 1.9 iv 53-55, v 1-4, 19-25) and conquers her brother’s chthonic killer (KTU 1.6 ii 4-37). In the tale of Aqhat, a daughter dons a dangerous disguise to avenge her brother’s devastating death (KTU 1.19 iv 28-61). In the story of Keret, a daughter receives her eldest brother’s birthright (KTU 1.15 iii 16) and personifies probity (KTU 1.16 ii 17-51). Whether deity or mortal, these young women venture beyond conventional distaff responsibilities, which their mothers dutifully fulfill. And so the daughters invite our curiosity. To explore the compelling roles of these characters (Anat, Pughat, and Thitmanit), I translate and comment upon sections from the Baal cycle and the stories of Aqhat and Keret. With this evidence, we can see how these women warriors and devoted daughters are critical to the drama that surrounds them. Further, the liminal position that Anat, Pughat, and Thitmanit share is the source of their power. Beyond the helplessness of girlhood and before the obedience of wifery, these young women are poised to be agents of destiny.


The Lawsuit Motif and Dramatic Recognition in the Gospel of John: Semeia and Anagnoresis Reconsidered
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
George Parsenios, Princeton Theological Seminary

This paper weaves together into a new pattern several strands of Johannine study which are currently perceived separately. Recent research has emphasized the thoroughly forensic character of key Johannine concepts like witness (marturia) and signs (semeia). Other research has illuminated with equal clarity that portions of John's plot resemble dramatic scenes of recognition (anagnoresis). These two approaches are pursued in isolation from, or even in opposition to, one another, and the present paper will show that they actually complement and support one another. For, ancient drama (both comedy and tragedy, in both Greece and Rome) was largely influenced by, and itself influenced, forensic rhetoric and the law courts. Comparing Aristotle's Rhetoric with the discussion of tragic recognition in his Poetics demonstrates this reality. Even more important, the tragedians regularly employ the language of rhetorical proof (marturia, semeia, tekmeria, etc.) as the language of deliberation and argument, and apply this language to more than merely recognition scenes. Debates and inquiries on various subjects assume a forensic form and adopt the language of forensic proof. But, forensic themes certainly appear in recognition scenes. When tragic characters evaluate evidence leading up to recognition, a phrase so apparently Johannine as "I believe the signs" (pisteuw ta semeia) can appear. This paper will explore how tragedians dramatize the evaluation of evidence and testimony in recognition scenes, in order to compare and contrast how the Gospel of John dramatizes the evaluation of evidence and testimony in the recognition of Jesus


The Impossibility of Communication in Seneca's Tragedies and the Fourth Gospel
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
George Parsenios, Princeton Theological Seminary

The following paper will attend to the interplay of rhetoric and drama in the tragedies of Seneca in order to clarify the dramatic presentation of rhetorical devices in the Gospel of John. Seneca follows Greek tragedians in staging one-lined question/answer scenes dubbed stichomythiai. These interrogation scenes derive from the law courts and forensic rhetoric and are a central feature of drama in both Greece and Rome. But in Seneca, the rhetorical undergirding of stichomythia is even greater, since his question/answer scenes often devolve into nothing more than characters hurling back and forth at one another the sententiae common in Roman declamation. Characters will conclude that their interlocutors are keeping silent, even after several lines of communication, because they have responded to questions only with sententiae. The sententia, then, obstructs real communication. The depiction of communication, in other words, underscores the impossibility of communication between a pair of characters. Depending on the circumstances, the cause of the divide between two people varies, but in many cases sententious stichomythia comes to represent the impossibility of communication. The Fourth Gospel also contains a great many such question/answer scenes. They cannot be profitably compared to stichomythia because the intrusion of the narrator interrupts the rapid-fire quality of the dialogue, although it must be said that John 1:21 has an urgency reminiscent of stichomythia. Regardless, the Johannine interrogations do indeed contain sententiae, which do not further communication, but impede it. In this way, John seems to be using the rhetorical sententia in much the way that Seneca does. In both authors, therefore, the forensic interrogation scene dramatizes, not a moment of communication, but, rather, the utter failure to communicate. Various ramifications of this circumstance will be explored.


The Problem of the Unity of Scripture: Reading the Bible for the Love of God
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Michael Pasquarello, III, Asbury Theological Seminary

This paper will offer selected exemplars from the Christian tradition, from persons who have viewed the unity of Scripture as constituted by the character and activity of God as disclosed in love of God and love of neighbor. I will provide a brief overview of interpretive practices in the reading of scripture from the work of Augustine, Bonaventure, and John Wesley. Rather than look for a textual or thematic approach, I will offer an alternative way of reading scripture that centers on the salvific nature of the Word of God, the Triune God’s self-communicative activity in Word and Spirit, and the participation of the church as enabled by divine love or charity in response to God’s self-disclosure in its liturgical life.


America’s Book of Kells: The Art and Theology of the Saint John’s Bible
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Michael Patella, OSB, Saint John's University School of Theology

Called “America’s Book of Kells, ” The Saint John’s Bible will be on display at the Library of Congress, 6 October – 15 December 2006. Over ten years in the making and still not complete, this latest endeavor in biblical art promises to be one of the great artistic and theological achievements of our time. My position as chair of the Committee on Illumination and Text for The Saint John’s Bible allows me to shape my paper to take fullest advantage of this fortunate concurrence of the SBL meeting with the exhibition. Just as the Book of Kells played a considerable role in defining the art and theology not only in Ireland but also in Western Civilization, many see The Saint John’s Bible taking on a similar role for faith and society today. What is the impetus behind writing and illuminating such a work by hand, 550 years after the invention of the printing press and at a time when most publication is done digitally? How do the artwork, theology, and worldview of The Saint John’s Bible differ from similar works in the previous millennium? While respecting the historical roots of the tradition of handwritten manuscripts, The Saint John’s Bible seeks new ways to present humankind’s ineffable encounter with God. The effort has fostered a hermeneutic that links image with text and Sacred Scripture with art. This paper discusses these issues by concentrating on the dialogue between the written word and the visual image. In so doing, it develops the means to break the narrow walls of biblical fundamentalism while opening contemporary scholarship to greater interpretive insight. The paper will involve examples from slides as well as references to the exhibition at the Library of Congress.


The Biblical Defense of Slavery
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Paul Finkelman, Albany Law School

This paper will explore the use of biblical law to defend slavery in the antebellum American South. At a time when a literal reading of the Bible was prevalent in Protestant denominations, debates concerning the issue of slavery raised crucial questions about the relevance of the Bible and biblical law to the circumstances of the United States in the mid-nineteenth century. In addition, questions were raised about the relationship between theology and biblical interpretation and the relationship between the Old Testament and the New Testament. This paper will trace the manner in which slavery was defended as biblically-based and the theological and cultural tensions that resulted.


Jerusalem of Gold: From Sumer to Sheme
Program Unit:
Shalom Paul, Hebrew University of Jerusalem

*


Opening the Bible: Open Canon and Openness Theology
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
David L. Paulsen, Brigham Young University

*


Jewish Wisdom and Apocalyptic in Gnostic Apocalypses
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Birger A. Pearson, University of California, Santa Barbara

This paper explores how Jewish wisdom and Jewish apocalyptic traditions are interwoven and re-interpreted in Gnostic apocalypses. The Gnostic apocalypses chosen for study belong to that variety of ancient Gnosticism often referred to as "Sethian" or "Classic" Gnosticism.


The Martyrs of Palestine as a Source for Jewish and Christian Relations in Fourth Century Palestine
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Elizabeth C. Penland, Yale University

The literary evidence for Jewish and Christian interactions is frustratingly and richly ambivalent in Eusebius’ local chronicle of fourth century Christian martyrs, The Martyrs of Palestine. On the one hand, there is an explicit relationship of emphatic enmity. Eusebius depicts the Jews of Palestine as bad examples of their own tradition against an historic enemy, the Egyptians—specifically Egyptian converts to Christianity. In another account, the Caesarean martyr Paul prays for the Jews, “our enemies,” along with the Samaritans and state executioners before his death. Yet there is a clear and unattributed narrative affinity with Jewish sources in Eusebius’ text, not only with Philo’s De vita contemplativa, which Eusebius uses to construct his own ascetic intellectual lineage, but also with contemporary Rabbinic accounts from Caesarea, of which the examinations of Saul Lieberman, in “The Martyrs of Caesarea,” and Daniel Boyarin, in Dying for God, are particularly interesting. This paper will place the narrative points of contact and divergence between Jews and Christians—and Jewish and Christian texts—in The Martyrs of Palestine within the larger construction of fourth century Palestine from Eusebius’ Christian, Caesarean perspective.


"Die Judenfrage" and the Construction of "Hellenistic Judaism": Foregrounding the Backgrounds Approach to Early Christianity
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Todd C. Penner, Austin College

In this paper I argue that relatively little reflection has been given to the historical and socio-cultural origins of the “religionsgeschichtliche” (history-of-religions) approach to the study of early Christian origins, literature, and motifs, a method that continues to hold profound sway in terms of how the field constructs and analyzes the ancient religious world. Using the framework of “Hellenistic Judaism,” I focus on some of the operative assumptions of the “religionsgeschichtliche” approach, paying particular attention to the formative role that the longstanding western preoccupation with the “Jewish Question” played in shaping (both explicitly and implicitly) the contours of the history-of-religions methodology in terms of how both early (Bousset, Bultmann) and later (Hengel) proponents constructed a Hellenistic Judaism that was, in some sense, predetermined by the approach’s discursive frame. In particular, the modern preoccupation (and anxiety) with “Die Judenfrage” tended to resurface in the creation of Hellenistic Judaism as a shadow of early Christianity, including, as well, its function as both a cipher and a “clearinghouse” for early Christian ideas, motifs, and religio-social practices. “Hellenistic Judaism” thus frequently became a trope of negotiation, which helped maintain purity lines in the conception of early Christian development. Such concerns are fundamentally of a modern kind, and have dramatically shaped the way that Hellenistic Judaism has been perceived (including which elements receive prominent emphasis) as well as the way in which early Christianity is imagined to have developed and grown. I suggest that both Hellenistic Judaism and early Christianity (as a Hellenistic phenomenon) have been significantly misconstrued as a result of the discursive framing of the “religionsgeschichtliche” approach, and that it is time to reassess the social-cultural assumptions and values embedded in that matrix of analysis.


Aspectual Markedness in the Gospel of Matthew: A Preliminary Sketch
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Jonathan T. Pennington, Southern Seminary

One implication of the recent revolution in our understanding of the Greek verbal system is the idea that the different tense-forms serve to communicate greater or lesser prominence in the discourse. So far most of the discussion of prominence and markedness has been theoretical and suggestive. A few studies have been done which seek to test the prominence theory on assorted texts, but much more of this type of research needs to be done. Responding to Robert Picirilli’s challenge for more testing, this paper inquires as to whether the pattern of verb usage in the Gospel of Matthew confirms or conforms to Porter’s theory of “backgrounding-foregrounding-frontgrounding”.


The Greek Romance Hero: An Elite Imperial Masculinity
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Judith B. Perkins, Saint Joseph College

Since Rhode (1914) censured the weakness of the weepy, suicidal hero of the Greek ideal romance, the genre’s construction of masculinity has been a focus of critical attention. This paper will locate the romance hero’s masculinity within the culture-wide negotiations around cultural identity that were taking place in early Roman imperialism. Haynes recently raised the question whether the genre’s powerless hero “was attractive to men who felt politically marginalised by the imposition of a new power structure” (2003: 99). This politically marginalized Greek subject, however, is a misreading of the politics of the period. As Ando notes, “Romans had always sought to govern their far flung empire through local aristocracies” (2001: 363). It is my contention that in these narratives focused on elite desire and the overcoming of threats to status, the Greek elites constructed a masculinity appropriate for exercising power under the aegis of Rome. The romance hero has been most faulted for his passivity, his failure to be a rescuer, or take concerted actions toward his goals. But by the narrative’s conclusion, all his goals are achieved; both the object of his desire, his beloved, and his life of status and privilege are reclaimed. The romance validates the hero’s lack of initiative; if he simply endures and keeps his eyes on the prize, things will go his way. This passive posture contests normative Greco-Roman masculinity, but ideally suits the Greek elite imperial subject who can maintain his power by acquiescing to and joining the new power configurations. The paper will also show that in their construction of this male imperial subject the narratives retain an allegiance to traditional masculine norms, to hegemonic patriarchy, —“a mechanism by which elite males can present a united front and subjugate non-elites and women” (Wananabe (2003: 32).


Timing Is Everything: Projected Violence
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
Judith B. Perkins, Saint Joseph College

This paper considers the often-gruesome violence in Christian fantasies of the judgment and punishment in store for opponents in texts such as the Apocalypse of Peter, various martyr acts, and Tertullian’s De Spectaculis. The paper’s central question is how does the futurity of this violence function for understanding its role in Christian discourse? The first section of the paper locates Christian fantasies within the cultural imaginings of the early Empire, where courts, trials and penalties provide an almost obsessive focus. The Greek romances whose florescence parallels the rise of Christianity feature numerous trials and punishments including torture, crucifixion and being burned. Imaginary courts and trials are also fundamental to the second sophistic, the movement that saw the educated of the first three centuries AD speaking and writing in the Greek style and language of fifth and fourth century BC. Throughout the empire, the elite vied for prestige and power in part on the basis of their ability to give fictitious law court speeches in an artificial language. A recent commentator (Schmitz) has offered that these sophistic exhibitions functioned to effect elite solidarity and to intimidate the masses. Imaginary courts and trials were part of the period’s discourse of power. Although the elites looked to the past and the Christians to the future, that both groups avoided the present in their contemplations of the courts suggest the formation of analogous mechanisms to find room to maneuver within the power matrix of Roman imperialism. The elite signaled their cooperation and acquiescence to Rome as they retained their privilege and position by accepting the present by looking to the past. Christians by placing their court outside of human time in the future indicate not so much their violent intentions, as their commitment to a future configured differently than the present.


“The Lord Is A Warrior”/ “The Lord Who Shatters Wars”
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Larry Perkins, Northwest Baptist Seminary

Moses’ Song (Exodus 15:1-18) celebrating God’s victory over Pharaoh, became one of the Odes appended to the Psalter. Within this ‘psalm’ the Hebrew text defined Yahweh as "man of war". The Old Greek translation rendered this phrase as "one who shatters wars" (15:3). Considerable discussion occurs in the literature proposing that the translator in fact reverses the meaning of the Hebrew signifying that “Yahweh shatters wars”, i.e. eliminates war. God is a peace-maker. This paper reviews the evidence within Greek Exodus for this hypothesis. It argues on the basis of context that the translator was faithful to the intent of the Hebrew text to celebrate God’s ability to win battles for His people. The usage of this phrase in Judith 9,7 and 16,2 carries a similar emphasis. God certainly has the capacity to bring peace to His people, but this was not the primary focus of the Greek translator’s rendering of Exodus 15:3. This implications of this conclusion for the use of this Greek expression in Isaiah 42,13 and several other Septuagint texts will be explored briefly.


From Holtzmann to Harnack: The Nineteenth-Century "Quest for Origins" and the Quest of the Historical Jesus
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Nicholas Perrin, Wheaton College

The nineteenth-century has been described as a period which nurtured an obsession with origins. To understand the historical origins of a phenomenon was to understand the essence of the phenomenon itself. The purpose of this paper is to explore ways in which this mentality and the related “quest for origins” movement influenced the so-called (First) Quest of the Historical Jesus. It will be argued that the strong assumptive correlation between authenticity and primitiveness in more contemporary historical Jesus research finds its roots in the philosophical outlook of this period.


The Thomasine Community and a Case of Double Identity
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Nicholas Perrin, Wheaton College

The collection of sayings that has come down to us in the Coptic Gospel of Thomas claims to have been written down by one Didymos Judas Thomas. This paper will explore the hermeneutical function of Thomas’s mediation of the sayings and how this may in turn shed light on the community behind Thomas. It will be argued that the invocation of Thomas not only points to the collection’s soteriological concern, that the reader become a twin to Jesus, but also suggests a community that was self-consciously “alternative” in its belief and social structure.


The Rhetoric of Hymns: Revelation 5:8–14
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Peter S. Perry, Lutheran School of Theology, Chicago

Very few Jewish apocalypses use hymns. Why does the Seer use hymns in the Book of Revelation? This paper argues that hymns were rhetorically effective for unifying First Century hearers as clients of the patron God and evoking common dependence, emotions and access to power. Revelation 5:8-14 establishes relationships between God, the cosmos, saints, and the world. These relationships are characterized by cosmic order, participation in God’s work, equal status among the saints, and the task of being kingdom and priests in the world. Therefore, the hymns provide a basis for believer’s endurance, witness and resistance.


Joyous Vanity: Qohelet's Spirituality
Program Unit: The Texts of Wisdom in Israel, Early Judaism, and the Eastern Mediterranean World
T. A. Perry, University of Connecticut

This paper explores what has proved to be the most neglected and elusive aspect of Qohelet, its role as a spiritual guidebook. Qohelet's focus on hebel or vanity is dual. First, vanity is seen as a human creation, and this perception leads to the liberating distinction between 'nothing' and 'no-thing'. Second, the spiritual state of vanity perception or no-thing-ness sponsors a meditation on the origins of creativity, joy, and even practical living. Both stages can be understood as driven by Qohelet's unexplored concept of repentance.


Conversation Analysis, Oral Tradition, and the Bible
Program Unit: Orality, Textuality, and the Formation of the Hebrew Bible
Raymond F. Person, Jr., Ohio Northern University

A survey of various studies applying conversation analysis to literature reveals that structures found in everyday conversation can be preserved in literary discourse. This observation complicates any discussion of the oral origins of literature, including the Bible, in that what might be considered “oral” features can also be found in literature from highly literate, modern cultures. Therefore, different strategies must be employed to address the question “How Should We Talk About the Oral Dimension of Biblical Texts?”


Project on the Textual History of 1 Samuel: How to Read the Greek Text behind the Sahidic Coptic
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Elina Perttilä, University of Helsinki

The Sahidic Coptic version of 1Samuel is one of the earliest daughter version of the Septuagint, and therefore important for the textual history of the Greek text. Even if this is self-evident, the use of a daughter version in the textual criticism of the Septuagint is a complicated issue, because each daughter version has a translation character and textual history of its own. The source language, the target language, and the translator – each of these factors has an influence on the translation. When discussing the translator, we usually speak of translation technique. In order to gain as exact and trustworthy a picture as possible of the translation technique of the translator, it is important to do research on different linguistic areas and different aspects of the translation. In this paper I will deal with one area of the language, namely the clause connections: What can we say about the Greek Vorlage of the Coptic daughter version in the area of clause connections?


Acts in the Suburbs of the Apologists
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Richard I. Pervo, St. Paul, MN

This paper will be part of a panel discussion on the reception of Acts in the second century and beyond.


The Quranic Tree of Life
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
Daniel C. Peterson, Brigham Young University

God’s command to Adam and Eve that they not approach “this tree lest you be among the wrongdoers” appears twice in the Qur’an (2:35; 7:19), much as it appears in the biblical book of Genesis. Although the similarities between the biblical account and the Qur’anic account are obvious, there are also significant differences between the narratives. The tree that Adam and Eve are advised to avoid, but from which they partake of the fruit, is called, in the Qur’an, the “tree of eternity” (shajarat al-khuld [20:120]). The “tree of life” is a distinct object, whose fruit would cause those who eat it to “live for ever.” By eating the fruit of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, Adam and Eve appear to have become mortal, but they have also become not like the angels but like God or the gods. (See Genesis 2:9; 3:1-24.) In the Qur’an, when Adam and Eve partake of the fruit of the shajarat al-khuld, have they indeed, as had been predicted, taken upon themselves the nature of angels? My paper will attempt to draw out the characteristically Islamic attitudes that are reflected in the distinctions between the Genesis narrative and the Qur’anic accounts. It will also survey the significance of the shajarat al-khuld, the “tree of eternity” or “tree of life,” in the Qur’an, in several of the classical commentaries, and in the ‘tales of the prophets” works of al-Kisa’i and al-Tha‘labi. The “tree of life” is a very ancient and well-nigh universal motif that can be identified in regions as disparate as early Mesopotamia, Viking Age Scandinavia, and pre-Columbian Mesoamerica. It clearly enters the Islamic tradition in something like its biblical form. My paper will attempt to clarify what the Qur’an takes over from earlier tradition and what it omits, and to suggest reasons for those choices.


Syriac-Speaking Judaism: They Who Read and Write in the (Syriac) Outside Books
Program Unit: History and Literature of Early Rabbinic Judaism
Sigrid Peterson, University of Pennsylvania

The History and Literature of Early Rabbinic Judaism Section has wisely chosen to focus on material and conceptions that challenge the boundaries of the academic model of Rabbinic Judaism. From Michael Weitzman's somewhat puzzled observation in his book, The Syriac Version of the Old Testament: An Introduction, that while the Peshitta translators were definitely Jewish, they lacked agreement with Rabbinic Judaism, to the further translations from Hebrew of the Psalms of Solomon, in Greek and Syriac, to the original Syriac versions 6 Macc and 7 Macc, we have evidence of non-rabbinic Jews first translating, and then writing, in Syriac in Late Antiquity. The challenging questions include "Is there evidences of rabbinic "attitude" toward such literary activity?" and "How do we account for Syriac Jewish (non-Rabbinic) literature, if Syriac is a Christian language?" The present consensus that the Peshitta Old Testament is the work of Jewish translators, early Syriac translations of the outside books and such pseudepigrapha as the Psalms of Solomon, and two original Syriac works on the Maccabean martyrdoms, 6 Macc and 7 Macc, lead us to suspect the continued existence of an unconverted Jewish community that supported and produced literary materials. Such a community may also be the source for the plethora of haggadic tales about biblical figures found in Syriac literature. By hypothesis, those materials that were attractive to Syriac-speaking Christians were preserved. The Jewish literary community for which we have this evidence in Syriac does not appear to have survived and preserved its own literature. Remnants seem to surface later in the folk tales of the Kurdistani Jews and in the brief materials anthologized by Jellinek and Wertheimer. This presentation will track the evidentiary trail for this “fifth column” of Judaism, outside the Rabbinic core, and discuss the possible signs of rabbinic hostility to its existence.


The Case for Christians in Synagogues: Methods and Evidences
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Taylor G. Petrey, Harvard Divinity School

Recent scholarly appraisals of the relationship between Jews and Christians in antiquity have sought to complicate traditional models of the “Parting of the Ways.” These models frequently relied upon a positivist historiography and ideological interests in drawing clear boundaries between “Judaism” and “Christianity.” In its place, many have pointed to the complexities of the formation of identity, emphasizing fluid boundaries between Christians and Jews. In particular, some have pointed to possible evidence that “Christians” and “Jews” worshipped together, which would greatly strengthen the argument for a muddied picture of social groups before the fourth century. Did Christians and Jews frequently worship together until the defenders of orthodoxy finally triumphed and forced a final separation? This paper will survey the relevant sources and show that the evidence for Christians worshiping with Jews in synagogues in the second and third centuries is extremely weak. Instead, we must look to the fourth century as the beginning of this phenomenon rather than the end. This inquiry provides a salient test case to examine larger theoretical issues, most importantly, the relationship between bodily and linguistic practices in constituting identity. This project hopes to demonstrate a necessary shift in focus from the purely textual and linguistic emphasis that some scholars’ recent work has taken. Instead, the evidence for second, third, and fourth century divisions between early Christian and Jewish worship points to a need to look at bodily practices as performative of identity.


Response to Bas van Os, A Mathematical Model of Early Christianity
Program Unit: Construction of Christian Identities
Philip Jenkins, Pennsylvania State University

*


Following Jesus in Galilee: Resurrection as New Exodus in the Gospel of Mark
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Ray Pickett, Lutheran Seminary Program in the Southwest

This interpretation of Mark’s resurrection builds on recent audience oriented readings which emphasize that the Gospel was written to be performed dramatically. The inclusio of the prologue informs hearers that the theme of the Gospel is that the “kingdom of God has come near”, and the Scriptural references and allusions in the opening lines indicate that the ministry, death and resurrection of Jesus are presented as the fulfillment of Isaiah’s new exodus. This reading of Mark relates the resurrection narrative to the depiction of God coming in strength to heal, restore, and liberate in Jesus’ Galilean ministry, and suggests that followers of Jesus who have been baptized and endowed with the same Spirit are directed to meet Jesus back in Galilee, the setting of the new exodus, where that same divine power is active through those who make a break with imperial society and commit to the alternative values and practices of the kingdom of God.


The Other Hand of God: God's Spirit in an Age of Scientific Cosmology
Program Unit: Christian Theological Research Fellowship
Clark Pinnock, McMaster Divinity College

This metaphor of Spirit as the “other hand of God” was employed by St Irenaeus to bring out the large scale of the mutual work of creation and redemption by the Spirit and the Son. If we put the doctrine of the Holy Spirit into dialogue with modern science, a door would open and an integration of science with faith would be possible. Science is not the enemy of faith but a source of insight into the truth about creation along with faith. For example, the long process of the world’s development or evolution does not imply atheism or materialism but does imply a process which is open to the Spirit's activity and guidance.


In Praise of "The Default Position", or Reassessing the Christian Reception of the Jewish Pseudepigraphic Heritage
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Pierluigi Piovanelli, University of Ottawa

It is well known that many ancient Jewish pseudepigrapha have been preserved in their integrality only through secondary versions and Christian late antique and medieval manuscript traditions. Building on such evidence, a large majority of specialists of Second Temple literature is still eager to identify newly discovered parabiblical narratives bearing no explicit Christian signatures with new Jewish pseudepigrapha. However, during the last two decades some authoritative voices – Marinus de Jonge, Robert A. Kraft, and Enrico Norelli, to mention just few of them – have begun to argue that early Christian authors could have written at least some of those texts. In the same vein, James R. Davila’s new monograph on The Provenance of the Pseudepigrapha (2005) provides us with a useful survey not only of Christian 'Old Testament Pseudepigrapha That Appear to Be Jewish' (Ch. 2) but also of 'Pseudepigrapha of Debatable Origin' (Ch. 4) that were previously deemed to be Jewish but that probably are of Christian origins. The plausibility of such a paradigmatic shift is independently confirmed by the major changes that another great specialist of Second Temple Judaism, George W. E. Nickelsburg, has just introduced into the revised and expanded edition of his 1981 masterful introduction to Jewish Literature between the Bible and the Mishnah (2005). In this new edition, some Pseudepigrapha are now relegated into a newly created limbo of 'Texts of Disputed Provenance' (Ch. 9), while others are purely and simply omitted. Following the same line of thought, I will discuss some examples of Jewish pseudepigrapha copied and translated by Christian scribes (the so-called Coptic Jeremiah Apocryphon), Christian rewritings of Jewish Pseudepigrapha (the Paraleipomena of Jeremiah), and Christian original compositions (the Melchizedek Story). This new approach will help us to emphasize the natural continuity existing between ancient Jewish and early Christian pseudepigraphic trajectories.


Royal and Family Etiquette and its Role in the Baal Cycle
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
Wayne T. Pitard, University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign

This paper proposes that issues of etiquette and protocol form a significant underpinning of the narratives of the Ugaritic Baal Cycle (CAT 1.1-1.6). It will focus on the episode of Baal’s building of his palace (1.3 –1.4) to examine how sensitivity toward the role of protocol within the royal court and dynamics of etiquette within a patrimonial household can illuminate the meaning of several of the key scenes within the episode.


Identity-Construction and Paraenesis in 1 Peter: A Semantic Analysis of Communal Terminology
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Andrew W. Pitts, McMaster Divinity College

With the inauguration of semantic field theory in cognitive and psycholinguistics and its recent applications to biblical lexicography, new possibilities have been opened for investigating lexical patterns in Ancient Greek discourse. An examination of lexical items in the context of their semantic domains and the patterns that emerge from those domains has proven to be illumining in the determination of the meaning and function of individual uses. This paper briefly lays out a rigorous corpus-based model for exploring lexical patterning at global and local levels of discourse through the use, expansion, and (at times) revision of the Louw-Nida lexicon. It then proceeds to provide an extended study of the organization, structure, and employment of communal terminology in 1 Peter, especially Domains 9 (People), 10 (Kinship Terms), 11 (Groups and Classes of Persons and Members of Such Groups of Classes), and 87 (Status) (particularly sociological instantiations). In addition to investigating the meaning and function of these terms, we explore their interaction with other semantic chains through, for example, collocation analysis and social deictic projection encoded in lexis. We conclude that communal terminology is used strategically by the author to create a sense of citizenship and belonging among a community of estranged Gentiles in order to provide the motivation and ground for a larger paraenetic agenda. The meaning of these terms, therefore, is sociologically and contextually conditioned. They are employed by the author as part of a global linguistic strategy to convince a community experiencing intense socio-religious and socio-political alienation of their community-of-God-status. This identity then serves as the platform from which the author issues his exhortations.


Case in Hellenistic Greek: A Systemic Approach
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Andrew W. Pitts, McMaster Divinity College

There has been much recent discussion of Greek cases from a linguistic perspective. An important preliminary issue that governs a significant portion of this discussion revolves around how cases should be defined. Should they be understood semantically, syntactically, in terms of functionality, or in some other way? Much of the recent research has proceeded from the inadequacies of traditional models in defining the semantics of Greek cases and consistently delimiting the functionality of individual case forms. But it seems that these linguistic proposals, like the traditional models they criticize, face serious definitional problems and have failed to establish a clear connection between the semantic meanings they posit and the formal realization of case in the Greek language. This paper suggests a systemic theory which attempts to account for the range of syntactical and semantic issues involved in formulating an adequate model of case and endeavors to address directly the ambiguity that has been introduced into the discussion revolving around case and meaning by proposing a semantic entry condition for the Greek case system. The meaning of individual forms is then explained in relation to the system of forms from which they are chosen. The theory proposed in this paper, therefore, attempts to establish an organic connection between morphological and semantic categories and seeks to delimit the functionality of cases in a variety of contexts based upon the semantics of the form.


James and Peter in the Apocryphon of James
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Catherine Playoust, Harvard University

As a revelation to James and Peter embedded within a letter written by James, the “Apocryphon of James” (NHC I,2) raises many questions about how to interpret the presence of these apostles (or disciples, as the text calls them). Peter’s awkward vanishing from narrative view toward the end of the text seems to be a rather superficial appeal to a famous name. The reference to “another apocryphon” that James sent earlier may, on the other hand, suggest a connection with James that existed prior to Ap. Jas. among the people for whom Ap. Jas. was written, who are inscribed into this text as “the beloved ones.” Yet in the literary realm much more can be said about how James is invoked. He is presented as the next link after Jesus in the multi-generational chain of teachers that culminates in the generation of “the beloved ones,” and this is a critical role for a text that treasures knowledge but considers that prophecy has ceased. Furthermore, the text sets aside the authority of the Twelve (excepting Peter and James) in multiple ways: it discounts their written memories of Jesus’ sayings; it dismisses their witnessing of Jesus’ ascension by claiming that this ascension was not successful; and it reduces the tradition of worldwide apostolic mission to their dismissal by James after they were displeased about the revelation concerning the beloved ones.


“Written in the Book That I Prophesied Publicly”: The Discernment of Apocalyptic Wisdom according to the “Ascension of Isaiah”
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Catherine Playoust, Harvard University

Reference to the book of Isaiah to elucidate and develop teachings about Jesus was not unusual in Early Christianity, but the “Ascension of Isaiah” takes it to an extreme. This work depicts the prophet Isaiah as a visionary who ascends through the heavens to learn about “the Beloved” (Jesus) and the saving role he will play in Isaiah’s future. Isaiah is eventually killed by Manasseh, under Satan’s influence, for refusing to retract his vision or say that Manasseh’s sinful ways are good. Isaiah reserves the full revelation of his experience (told in Asc. Isa.) for a select few, but indicates it obliquely in the scriptural book of Isaiah. Thus Asc. Isa. implicitly invites its Early Christian readers to delve into canonical Isaiah in order to deepen their Christological and eschatological knowledge. That is, it uses the apocalyptic genre of a heavenly journey to encourage the pursuit of wisdom through the social practice of exegesis. If these readers emulate their hero Isaiah well, however, theirs will be no mere “armchair theology,” just as practising wisdom could be life-threatening for the sages of old. According to their understanding of what is concealed, their perception of how the future of the Church and the world will unfold, they will be called upon to be faithful to the Beloved by prophesying truly and resisting idolatry just as Isaiah did, even up to martyrdom.


Ammonius’s Praise of the One (Plutarch, On the Delphic E): Alexandrian Neopythagoreanism or Academic Scepticism?
Program Unit: Rethinking Plato's Parmenides and Its Platonic, Gnostic, and Patristic Reception
Zlatko Plese, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill

The paper reexamines the figure of Ammonius, the teacher of Plutarch, and his ontological interpretation of the Delphic inscription, ‘Thou Art’, in Plutarch’s On the Delphic E (391E–394C). The core of Ammonius’s argument is organized around the ‘orthodox’ Platonic distinction between the realms of being and of becoming, as well as the deduced claim that, with the exception of the supreme deity identified with the transcendent ‘One’, all other entities belong to the “perishable realm” and therefore provide only a “dim and unstable image and apparition” of the divine being (De E 392A–D). Modern scholars have been divided over the source(s) of Ammonius’s discourse of praise. Some have argued for its Platonic Pythagorean background, more specifically for Eudorus’s ‘Neopythagorean’ exegesis of the Timaeus. Others, again, have emphasized the predominance of sceptical Academic themes in the speech: most notably, its strong anti-empiricist stance which rejects any firm truth about the sensible world on both epistemological and metaphysical grounds, and which, as a result, reevaluates the relationship between god and the sensible world in terms of the absolute transcendence of the divine principle. The paper argues for Ammonius’s (and Plutarch’s) indebtedness to the sceptical Academy, and especially to Carneades’ anti-Stoic polemic as outlined in Cicero’s works (On the Nature of Gods, On Divination). By drawing on interesting textual parallels in Philo of Alexandria and Seneca, the paper will also assess the possible impact of Plato’s Parmenides on Ammonius’s equation of the Delphic god with Unity (to hen) and Being (to on).


The Linguistic Study of Biblical Hebrew: The Israeli Connection
Program Unit:
Frank Polak, Tel Aviv University

The intellectual sources of the linguistic study of Biblical Hebrew are extremely diverse, ranging from the broken-from world of the Yeshiva rabbinic tradition (Ben Yehudah and Yellin), through the Central European schools of historical linguistics (Epstein, Torczyner [Tur-Sinai], and Ben Hayyim), to English and Italian philology (Segal, Ginsberg, Cassuto) and British functional linguistics (Rabin). In the Israeli context the language of the Bible was not the focus of the study of Hebrew. One of the central preoccupations was the study of the language of the Mishna and Tosefta, the Midrashim and the Piyyut, which affected our understanding of Biblical Hebrew (e.g., Yellin, Yalon, Kutscher, Morag and Kaddary). A second focus was the study of the various pronunciation traditions of the communities reunited in Israel, placing the punctuation schools of BHeb in the stream of the language tradition, and leading to new insights in ancient Hebrew dialectology (Morag). This paper will trace how, from these beginnings, and by whom, the linguistic study of biblical Hebrew in Israel developed, eventually to incorporate also syntax, semantics, discourse analysis and sociolinguistic dimensions and to contribute much also to our understanding of biblical poetics and stylistics.


Changing Perspectives in the Study of Medieval Jewish Bible Exegesis
Program Unit:
Meira Polliack, Tel Aviv University

Israeli scholarship on the vast corpus of biblical exegesis from the High Middle Ages (8th – 15th centuries) has hardly left a mark beyond the closed circle of scholars who have dedicated themselves to its research since the 1950's. Despite the extensive study of the Cairo Genizah and other medieval manuscript collections held in Israel throughout the past decades, the research on medieval Bible exegesis has mostly been engendered and conducted in academic institutions abroad, with some offshoots (Nehama Leibovich; Avraham Qafih; Avraham Melamed; Uri Simon; Sarah Kamin) in Israel. Surprisingly, the field is still distinguished by its heterogeneous and fragmentary nature, lack of an overall systematic approach and, consequently, lack of attempted synthesis of pre-modern Jewish approaches to biblical interpretation. I will survey these developments and offer to explain them together with their cultural context, such as the place of the medieval tradition within the Zionist narrative and other preconceptions concerning the nature of medieval Judaism (including Karaite Judaism). The problematic nature of the secular and religious stances towards the intellectual history of medieval Judaism, as divided into the separate histories of individual communities or separate centers of the Islamic world (Mizrah), Christendom (Ashkenaz) and Muslim/Christian Spain (Sefarad), will be discussed. Some other artificial distinctions (such as Karaite versus Rabbanite exegesis), together with the problematic implications of the codification of the medieval Jewish exegetical tradition in the classical Rabbinic Bible known as Mikraot Gedolot, in the 16th century, will be highlighted. The paper will conclude with some suggestions for a re-evaluation of the field.


Reading the Human Body: Physiognomics and Astrology in the Dead Sea Scrolls and Hellenistic-Early Roman Period Judaism
Program Unit: Poster Session
Mladen Popovic, University of Groningen

*


The Archaeology of Community in Early Moab
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Benjamin Porter, University of Pennsylvania

The Bible’s partial and untrustworthy history of early Moab requires scholars to depend on archaeological evidence for a more robust telling of the polity’s earliest moments. Yet only in the last few decades has a sufficient amount of archaeological evidence become available for scrutiny. In this paper, I explore emerging evidence for early Moab and argue that these settlements present a productive venue for examining the intersections of community, production, and power in Iron I Southern Levantine social life. I first draw on useful but problematic representations of Iron I authority in Judges and 1 Samuel, employing them as historical analogues in the reconstruction of community leadership. I then cast this model against the available architectural, agricultural, and ceramic evidence in order to measure the extent to which leaders dominated social life in their communities. While the architectural and agricultural evidence suggests leaders played an important role in organizing social life, archaeometric analyses of ceramic vessels indicate vessel production went unorganized despite their importance in storage practices. My analysis concludes that although social life in early Moab can be characterized as “complex,” leaders encountered limits to their authority. Not only does my investigation fill a problematic void in Moabite history, but it also presents a more nuanced perspective of social life in the Iron I southern Levant.


Paul and His Bible
Program Unit: Paul and Scripture
Stanley E. Porter, McMaster Divinity College

This paper will explore issues related to the use of Scripture by Paul, including such matters as the text that he used, and the ways in which he used it both in his letters and in terms of personal use. Comparison will be made to other ancient practices for collection, transmission and utilization of ancient texts, especially those considered to be of special or sacred value.


Discourse Analysis: Introducing the Field and Core Concepts
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Stanley E. Porter, McMaster Divinity College

An overview of the core concepts of discourse analysis with an application to 1 John.


"A Calf, a Body That Lows?" The Qur'anic Golden Calf Reconsidered
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
Michael E. Pregill, Columbia University

As defense against Christian arguments that Israel’s idolatry at Sinai abrogated their covenant with God, rabbinic commentators on the biblical Golden Calf episode promoted various apologetic claims in their interpretation of the story, including that the Calf had been magically brought to life to lead Israel astray. This notion is attested in various midrashim, and it has long been held that this is the conception of the Calf to be found in the Qur'an and Muslim commentary as well. While the classical Muslim exegetes’ unanimity regarding the Calf’s animation is indisputable, we will argue that the brief comments in the Qur'an to this effect—particularly its description of the idol as “a calf, a body that lows” (Q. 7:148/20:88)—have been misunderstood by classical exegetes and modern scholars alike, and that the Qur'an does not in fact presuppose the view that the Calf was alive. The apparent anomaly in Late Antique interpretation of the Calf episode thus presented by the Qur'an will be addressed through a reconsideration of the relationship between the rabbinic midrashim, the Qur'an, and the early Islamic commentary tradition.


Jesus and John Redivivus: Mark 6:7–13 and the Meaning of "Raised from the Dead" in the Second Gospel
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Mark Alan Proctor, Houston Baptist University

*


Popularising a Prophet (Isaiah) in Parliament: The Bible in Post-Apartheid, South African Public Discourse
Program Unit: Bible and Cultural Studies
Jeremy Punt, University of Stellenbosch

The surprising but continuing presence of the Bible in South African public discourse was recently emphasised by the explicit references to the prophet Isaiah in the speech of South African president, Mr Thabo Mbeki at the opening of parliament (February 2006). Various other, opposition parties followed suit and in their replies to Mbeki’s speech also made, albeit it quite different, references to Isaiah. An analysis of the use of the Bible by country’s head of state in post-Apartheid, multi-religious South Africa shows the major significance and intriguing role played by religious texts and the Bible in particular in South African public life. Upon further investigating the presence of the Bible in public discourse, two particularly interesting features emerge. On the one hand, and the different passages from Isaiah notwithstanding, the broader hermeneutical approaches of the politicians show remarkable similarity. On the other hand, the different texts of Isaiah which were used in parliament betray a careful process of selection and require further exploration. And finally, the ethical implications and complications of a popularised Bible in party-political discourse and the biblicisation of politics in the particular context of post-Apartheid South Africa are considered.


Sarah's Presence in the New Testament: Comparing Galatians 4 and 1 Peter 3
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Jeremy Punt, University of Stellenbosch

Sarah, wife of Abraham and mother of Isaac, occupies an important place in the narratives of the Hebrew Bible. A few direct and indirect references to her are found In the New Testament also, but it is soon noticed that she is appropriated in vastly different ways by the New Testament authors. The variegated portrayals of Sarah is obviously related to the different purposes the authors had with their writings, but can also if partly be explained with reference to the variance found among the New Testament authors in using Scripture. The comparison of Sarah’s portrayal in Gal 4 and in 1 Pt 3 renders interesting results, requiring further explanation of differences which amount to more than addressing distinct epistolary exigencies. Attention to the two documents reveals that while their use of Scripture adhere broadly to the prevailing norms, Gal 4 and 1 Pt 3 differ in the rationale for their references to Scripture, the authors’ interpretive interests and the ideological settings of the documents.


Irrealis in Biblical Stories: Why Know What Didn't Happen?
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Frederic Clarke Putnam, Puttenham Academy

In a very early article ("Kinds of Information in Discourse") Joseph Grimes notes the presence of *irrealis* in stories--authors mention that something did not happen. If authors tell us "what happened", why do they also tell us what did not happen? This paper demonstrates the vital role of irrealis in biblical narrative by examining negation in an extended story, and develops a theory of the narrative function of irrealis.


Daniel Among the Dursleys: Childhood and Colonialism in Biblical Literature
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Hugh S. Pyper, University of Sheffield

Reading the book of Daniel brings to mind two seemingly contradictory and perhaps unlikely generic parallels: children's literature and postcolonial literature. This paper uses a comparison of Daniel with Harry Potter to explore the links between these two genres and the particular way in which they are brought together in the book of Daniel and its history of interpretation. The colonial view of the colonised as 'childish' and the appeal of complicity between children and resistance to the dominant adult world in successful children's literature suggest a point of contact which offers some new theoretical perspectives. The book of Daniel proves to be a peculiarly potent example of the ambivalence of this relationship which can serve either to celebrate the infantilisation of the reading community or offer costly strategies for achieving the double-edged freedoms and responsibilities of adulthood or communal independence.


Taking Acts on the Road: Performing the Acts of the Apostles as Suspenseful Epic
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Philip A. Quanbeck, II, Augsburg College

Ancient travelers and pilgrims sometimes gathered together in the evenings and shared stories. This paper is based on the experience of a travel seminar that went from Athens to Istanbul. During this travel course the Book of Acts was performed in sequence on alternating evenings with performances of the Argonautica of Apollonius. This paper will describe how Acts functions in oral performance and can be divided up into ten episodes with “cliffhanger” endings and the effect this serial reading has on an audience. This paper will also describe how the parallel reading of the Argonautica enriches the audiences understanding of epic stories and sea travel in the ancient world and the social and literary context of the Acts of the Apostles. This paper will also address the issue of trusting the story to tell itself.


Some Parallels between Manuscript Appreciation and Wine Tasting Using W032 and B03 in Matthew as a Test Case
Program Unit:
Jean-Francois Racine, Jesuit School of Theology at Berkeley

*


Pseudo-Dionysius’ Sun and Socrates’ Day (Parmenides 131b): A New Christian Reading of the Parmenides and Its Implications
Program Unit: Rethinking Plato's Parmenides and Its Platonic, Gnostic, and Patristic Reception
Andrew Radde-Gallwitz, Emory University

In his treatise On the Divine Names, Denys sets forth a vision of theological language according to which God both is all attributes and transcends all attributes. That is, he associates the First and Second Hypotheses of the Parmenides with the same God. To this end, he uses the analogy of the sun (div. nom. 5.8) as an example of something that causes multiple effects (which must somehow preexist in their cause) and is numerically one (i.e., transcendent of their multiplicity). In this paper, I will argue three theses that specify Denys’ reading of the Parmenides and place it in historical context: (1) Denys fashions the sun analogy from a combination of Platonic sources: (a) Parmenides 131b and (b) Republic 508-509d. Proclus mentions a similar intertextual combination in his discussion of Parmenides 131b. (2) Denys’ reading of the First and Second Hypotheses is an attempt to rehabilitate the Parmenides for Christian use after the fourth-century Trinitarian controversies rendered an older reading of it suspect. His orthodoxy disallows the interpretation of Clement and Origen. (3) By placing affirmation and negation on the same level of divine being, Denys apparently undermines the law of non-contradiction. Both p and not-p can be true at the same level of being. The cumulative effect of these theses is that Denys’ theology demonstrates (mediated) engagement with both the first and second parts of the Parmenides. I will conclude by asking whether Denys’ new reading has fatal consequences for theological coherence. I will ask whether Denys’ “sun” analogy falls victim to the same consequences as Socrates’ “day”: each Form or divine attribute both is and is not what it is supposed to be.


Mesha in Ninth Century Geopolitics: Syntax, Geography, and History
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Anson F. Rainey, Tel Aviv University

The sources for Ninth Century BCE history include 2 Chron. 20, 2 Kgs 3 and the Mesha inscription. Geographical allusions in each of these sources are crucial for understanding the course of events and the relationships between the local political entities in the southern Levant. Such geographical references in these sources must also be coupled with syntactical analysis of their contexts, especially in the Mesha Inscription itself. When clause structure is properly understood, an amazing geographical picture of the Moabite campaign to free Moab from foreign domination emerges. Even in the biblical passages, some simple statements have usually been ignored or misinterpreted leading to muddled confusion.


New LIGHTing on the Amarna Tablets
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Anson F. Rainey, Tel Aviv University

Some especially interesting results from collation of the Berlin, London and Paris collections of the Amarna tablets will be presented along with photographs from the West Semitic Research team led by Bruce Zuckerman and Marilyn J. Lundberg. Macro photographs of individual signs will be used to illustrate new readings resulting from Rainey's collations.


Before Vespasian: Josephus on the Julio-Claudian Emperors
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Tessa Rajak, University of Reading

The paper aims to provide an overview of the material in Josephus concerning the Julio-Claudian emperors and to tease out the implications of his inclusions and omissions. My analysis of the relevant passages will concentrate on the historian's language and tone in relation to the emperors and on remarks made ostensibly in propria persona. I shall be concerned less with the sources of his information (though this question can't be altogether ignored) and more with his self-positioning. I shall attempt to locate Josephus' stance within the spectrum of responses of elite provincials to the Roman government. I shall be responding to and building upon a number of contributions to the important recent volume on 'Flavius Josephus in Flavian Rome' (edd. Edmondson, Mason and Rives), which make it possible to look at the historian's 'Roman' discourse from new angles.


Threats, Punishment, and Hope: Jeremiah Interpreted by Origen to Support the Doctrine of Apocatastasis
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Ilaria Ramelli, Catholic University of Milan, Italy

Origen in his homilies interprets passages of Jeremiah, and Luke, to show God's paedagogical attitude toward us, the meaning of his threats, the message full of hope contained in the Hebrew Bible, which in his view forms one and the same body with the NT. In the Bible we always find death first and life after, for God even gives death, if this is useful for the sinner, but only to give a better life: death, either physical or spiritual, never is the ultimate reality, according to the Bible; to the perspective of a thanatos aiônios Origen opposes the announcement of the resurrection of the dead present in the Bible: oukh horas en tais Graphais apaggelian anastaseôs nekrôn? This anastasis coincides, in his view, with universal restoration in the end.


When Infancy Gospels and Popular American Fiction Meet: Considering Anne Rice's "Christ the Lord"
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Margaret Ramey, University of St. Andrews

Humans have always been story-tellers, so it is no wonder that ever since Jesus first appeared performing mighty deeds and announcing the kingdom of God, people have narrated incredible stories about him. After his death, followers began to record many of these stories, the most famous of those being the four canonical Gospels. Four witnesses, however, were not enough to satisfy the curiosity of those first Christ-followers. Apocryphal gospels began appearing as some of the first efforts of pious Christians seeking to fill in the gaps of Jesus’ early years. Two thousand years later, one still finds many trying to fill in the gaps of Jesus’ story. Authors today are rapidly expanding already existing stories surrounding Christ’s life and inventing new ones. Since many readers form their ideas of Christ based on such popular fictional accounts of the New Testament world, it is important to evaluate what these authors are trying to achieve. One of the most recent offerings in the historical fiction genre is Anne Rice’s Christ the Lord: Out of Egypt. In this coming of age tale, Rice uses first person narration through the eyes of the seven-year-old Jesus as he struggles to control his miraculous powers. He journeys physically from Alexandria to Nazareth while also making an emotional journey to discover the secret of his birth and what lies ahead in his future. In writing her novel, Rice makes use of both canonical and apocryphal infancy narratives, such as the Protevangelium of James, The Gospel of Thomas, and others. The aim of this paper is to present Rice as a primary example of how popular American authors are using such sources and developing various Christologies based on conflations of the infancy accounts.


What Would a Deaf Hermeneutics Look Like?
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Rebecca Raphael, Texas State University, San Marcos

Hermeneutics understands understanding as a dynamic between a situated text or artifact and a situated recipient. The situation of both text and reader contribute to possibilities of understanding and misunderstanding. This paper will examine and critique the unconscious and virtually universal assumption that the situation of biblical readers includes the sense of hearing. To that end, I will posit a deaf or Deaf reader and show what deafness (and hearing) bring to the hermeneutic circle. Discussion will focus on selected biblical passages in the Hebrew Bible and New Testament (e.g. Ex 4:11; Lev 19:14; Is 6:9-10, 29:18, 35:5; Ps 115; Mk 7:31-37), as these have been read and experienced by deaf or Deaf readers. I will drawn on the scholarship on Deafness, publications by and interviews with deaf or Deaf practitioners of Judaism and Christianity, and my own experience as a deaf scholar in a hearing classroom. This study is partly in the tradition of feminist, African-American, and queer hermeneutics; however, I also intend to critique normative scholarly assumptions that the main point of such endeavors is to propose identity-positive re-readings. Instead, in the spirit of J. Berlinerblau’s _The Secular Bible_ (2005), I argue that the task of a scholarly deaf hermeneutics should be first to analyze what the text does and does not say about deafness, and secondly to reflect on the role of hearing or deafness in the construction of biblical interpretations. Finally, I suggest that the study of deafness in the Bible and in biblical interpretations has broad implications for scholarship on religion and embodiment. I will conclude with an outline for avenues of research in deafness and biblical studies.


Psychology and the Bible: What Hath Freud Wrought?
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Ilona Rashkow, SUNY, Stony Brook

Until recently, reading the Bible was thought to be a rather straightforward procedure. The goal was to respond “properly” by trying to “understand” the text and grasp the “meaning.” This changed once psychology became a more accepted form of biblical exegesis, Now shifts in the discipline of biblical studies, along with the increasing influence of psychological perspectives on the culture in general have made psychological approaches to the Bible more visible and as a result. No work is being done on the application of feminist theory to psychological approaches. As I have argued elsewhere, the use of psychology in interpreting biblical texts is no more a conceptually unified critical position in biblical studies than in literary studies generally. The term is associated with scholars who examine the writer, the biblical characters, or the reader. Further, the approaches are neither monolithic nor mutually exclusive. But biblical scholars who use psychology seem to agree that “meaning” does not inhere completely and exclusively in the text and that the “effects” of reading Scripture, psychological and otherwise, are essential to its “meaning.” Ultimately, this type of literary criticism yields in biblical studies a way of looking at biblical narratives and readers which reorganizes both their interrelationships and the distinctions between them. As a result, recognizing the relationship of a reader to the biblical text leads to a more profound awareness that no one interpretation is intrinsically “true:” the “meaning” of biblical narratives is not waiting to be uncovered but evolves, actualized by readers. Although this paper looks at various psychological approaches to biblical study I focus most heavily on psychoanalysis and the bible from the perspective of psychoanalytic literary theory.


On Sociological Approaches to Nag Hammadi Texts
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Tuomas Rasimus, University Of Helsinki

The social reality behind Nag Hammadi texts has been notoriously difficult to uncover, many texts being essentially mythological narratives. Some scholars have applied various sociological models to these mythological texts, but the results have not necessarily been convincing. One problem in applying sociological theories to mythological texts is that we need some sociological “input data” to start with. Another problem is that the results may vary considerably depending on which theory is used and how it is used. For example, Scott suggests that in light of Stark&Bainbridge’s model, Sethianism is a deviant, non-schismatic “audience cult.” This is based on Scott’s understanding that the Sethian authors were comparable to astrologers, selling their products on religious market by appealing to ancient figures and odd secret doctrines. First, such an understanding derives from false assumptions: Scott appears to underestimate both the polemical relationship the Sethian authors had with Judaism, and the self-understanding of belonging to a unique group (“seed of Seth”). Second, whereas the model of Stark&Bainbridge essentially measures socio-cultural tension between a given religious group and the surrounding society, other models (e.g. Wallis) add another important variable: a claim to possess the truth. Such models seem to fit Sethian and related mythological evidence better. Third, the results vary depending on the point of view/comparison, as Williams and Spence have noted. For example, one and the same group may be seen either as a “sect” or a “cult,” or it may contain both “sectarians” and “cultists.” The era and geographical location also have an impact on the results. This paper argues that we are indeed able to filter valuable sociological information out of Nag Hammadi texts, but only if we are careful about our starting assumptions and our use of sociological models.


On Earth, Not in Heaven: Paul’s Scriptures and the Political Salvation of Israel in Romans 9–11
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Mark Reasoner, Bethel University

While Neil Elliott, Richard Horsley and N. T. Wright are effectively helping us hear the political resonance of Paul’s letters, no one has yet examined the political contexts of Paul’s scriptural citations. When the scriptural citations (e.g. Isa 8:14 in Rom 9:32-33) or images (“Esau” of Mal 1:2 in Rom 9:13, cf. Geza Vermes, Post-Biblical Jewish Studies 223) are read in their scriptural and first century contexts, it becomes clear that Paul’s unspecified grief over Israel (9:1-5) and hope of their final salvation (11:25-27) includes political vindication on earth. Richard Bell (Irrevocable Call of God 379) writes on Romans 11 that “although Paul’s argument is primarily concerned with salvation I wonder whether one can exclude the concrete promise of the land (and of ‘seed’).” Once one has carefully considered the use of scripture in Romans 9-11, Bell’s statement can be revised so that Paul’s concept of salvation definitely includes political deliverance. Jacob Taubes’s instincts on the political edge of Romans (Political Theology of Paul 16) at least give us an initial push to examine Paul’s scriptural citations in Romans 9-11 through a political lens and help us rethink what “salvation” means for Paul. Even changes that Paul makes in the texts he quotes, e.g., “from Zion” in the quotation of Isa 59:20 in Rom 11:26, become more understandable when read with the political dimension of salvation for Israel in mind. This paper argues that the scriptural citations from LXX Ps 43:23 in Rom 8:36 through the rapid-fire occurrences in Romans 9-11 and on out to the closing catena of Rom 15:9-12 point to a political dimension in Paul’s concept of the plight of Israel and her coming salvation.


Recurring Themes and Motifs in Haggai, Zechariah, and Malachi
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Paul L. Redditt, Georgetown College

Haggai and Zechariah 1-8 predict the reestablishment of the pre-exilic institutions of the temple in Jerusalem and the monarchy in Judah. Zechariah 9-14 and Malachi explain the failure of the religio-political leaders in Judah during the Persian period. Their failure precluded the arrival of the new day envisioned by prophets both inside and outside the Twelve. This article will undertake a systematic survey of a number of themes common to the Twelve, noting the particular colorings Haggai, Zechariah 1-8, Zechariah 9-14, and Malachi give to each. These themes include the role of priests, potential kings, the relationship between Israel and Judah, the day of YHWH, theodicy, the relationship between Judah and the nations, repentance, the fertility/infertility of the land, and punishment and restoration. The article will also note the function of Zechariah 9-14 and Malachi in closing the Twelve.


Beyond Revealed Wisdom and Apocalyptic Epistemology: The Redeployment of Enochic Traditions about Knowledge in Early Christianity
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Annette Yoshiko Reed, McMaster University

This paper will consider the combination of sapiential and apocalyptic approaches to knowledge in the writings of early Christian authors (esp. Justin Martyr and Clement of Alexandria) by focusing on their use of Enochic traditions to understand their intellectual predecessors, both Jewish and Greek. To explore the role of Jewish Wisdom and Apocalyptic traditions in the development of Christian epistemological systems, I will focus on the various ways in which heavenly secrets were conceptualized with reference to Enochic traditions about the revelation of forbidden heavenly secrets by the fallen angels, on the one hand, and the revelation of salvific heavenly secrets to and by Enoch, on the other. In Enochic writings such as the Book of the Watchers, we find an early Jewish approach to epistemology that blurs the boundaries between the attitudes towards human speculation traditionally associated with Wisdom and Apocalypticism respectively. Accordingly, an analysis of the Christian Nachleben of these Enochic traditions may help to illumine the development of early Christian attitudes towards the human capacity to learn about otherworldly realities.


Between 'Biblical' and 'Parabiblical': Pre-canonical Perspectives on Writing, Reading, and Revelation
Program Unit: Rethinking the Concept and Categories of 'Bible' in Antiquity
Annette Yoshiko Reed, McMaster University

Focusing on the early Enochic literature and book of Jubilees, this paper will reflect on the reception of our earliest "OT pseudepigrapha" in pre-70 Judaism and Ante-Nicene Christianity, asking whether and how we can move beyond traditional dichotomies -- biblical/post-biblical, canonical/extracanonical -- to recover the broad range of ways in which early Jews and Christians encountered sacred or revelatory texts.


Anti-Violence, the Gospel of John, Banditry, and the Roman Empire
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
David A. Reed, Regis College, University of Toronto

It has often been said by Johannine scholars and NT ethicists alike that the Gospel of John has little to say about violence. This is often exacerbated by the problem of the "Cleansing of the Temple" in John 2:13-23, which for some, seems to advocate a kind of "righteous violence." On the contrary, this paper will argue that from John 1:12-13 to John 10:1-6 and on through the Johannine passion narrative a consistent ethic of non-violence is presented in John's Gospel. Furthermore, this paper will suggest that John's anti-violence ethic is a critique not only of Jewish banditry in the late first-century CE but also of Roman imperial violence.


What Sex Has to Do with Empire: Rethinking 1 Corinthians 7 in Light of the 'Lex Julia' and the 'Papian-Poppaean Law'
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
David A. Reed, University of St. Michael

Though numerous scholars have suggested that Paul's directives in 1 Corinthians 7 concerning virginity were monumental for the first-century Greco-Roman world, especially when we consider that marriage and the production of children was the norm for the Empire, this paper will take things a step further and show how Paul's rhetoric in 1 Corinthians 7 about marriage, sex, and virginity was in fact undercutting what we might call "the family values" movement of the Augustan Age. In order to accomplish this feet this paper will take a look at 1 Corinthians 7 alongside the "Lex Julia" laws of the Augustan period as well as the "Papian-Poppaean" laws. We shall see that the family and sexual values established by Paul for the Corinthian community was entirely at odds with the values of the larger Empire. Thus, this paper will argue that a chapter in Paul's writings often thought to defend ecclesiastical celibacy or to advocate celibacy as a higher, spiritual norm, was in fact coded rhetoric that struck at the value system the Empire held so dear. This paper shall close with a few remarks regarding "value systems" in modern day empires.


Prophetic Capital: Left Behind with Pierre Bourdieu
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Randall Reed, Whittier College

The “Left Behind” series has had tremendous success in the world of publishing, it has sold well over 20 million volumes and spawned two spin-off series. In this paper I will examine the goal of the “Left Behind” series as a modern apocalypse. I will argue that the text functions as a principal form of “prophetic capital.” Here I am applying the notion of capital in the work of Pierre Bourdieu, who distinguished different forms of capital within the larger category of symbolic capital in a particular field. I will argue that the “Left Behind” series functions as a form of fantasmic currency within the field of apocalyptic fundamentalism. The books offer a vision of what happens when apocalyptic fundamentalists are at last proved right, starting with the advent of the rapture. In the novels every analysis of events by the characters is ultimately vindicated, and the characters predict the future with complete accuracy. In the pre-rapture environment then, these texts function as a form of exchange: believers exchange present doubt for future certainty. The fundamentalist cottage industry which identifies signs that have come to pass or prophetic precursors that are present in current life (the formation of the EU, the re-emergence of Russia as a power, etc.), is part of the creation of prophetic capital. While this capital is always provisional, the continual acquisition of this prophetic capital is a strategy for success within the apocalyptic field by perpetuating a feeling of imminent arrival of the end coupled with a feeling that “the signs are all pointing” toward apocalyptic fulfillment. The Left Behind series then is the Fort Knox of this exchange and, through its narrative, provides for complete certainty which is always (if only temporarily) deferred to the future.


Further Textual Evidence Pertaining to the Enigmatic ‘Mani-Citations’ of Severus of Antioch
Program Unit: Manichaean Studies
John C. Reeves, University of North Carolina, Charlotte

The 123rd Cathedral Homily of the early sixth-century Monophysite patriarch Severus of Antioch features a series of textual citations drawn from a Manichaean work. Modern scholars have noted certain affinities these citations share with materials contained in prior Christian polemicists such as Titus of Bostra and Theodoret, and they have offered largely speculative suggestions about the possible identity of the written source. The present paper seeks to advance the critical discussion surrounding this source by calling attention to the existence of what appear to be ‘later’ versions of this same source in Arabic language testimonia about Mani and Manichaeism.


"A Demonstrably Jewish Text"? Reconsidering the Similitudes of Enoch
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
John C. Reeves, University of North Carolina, Charlotte

This paper reviews and critically assesses the arguments put forward by James R. Davila in his recent *The Provenance of the Pseudepigrapha: Jewish, Christian, or Other* (Leiden: Brill, 2005) in favor of a ‘Jewish’ authorship of and subsequent reliance upon the so-called Similitudes of Enoch (1 Enoch 37-71).


Notes on the Architecture and Stratigraphy of the Residences in Edomite Buseirah in the Late Iron and Persian Periods.
Program Unit: Literature and History of the Persian Period
Ronny Reich, University of Haifa, Israel

Buseirah, which is identified with biblical Bozrah, was excavated in the 1970s by C.M. Bennett. The final report was published recently by P. Bienkowski (2002). Bennett identified in Area A two large edifices, constructed one upon the ruins of the other. Bienkowski suggested now a totally different understanding of the architecture of this area, the main change being by merging both buildings into a single edifice. The lecture will deal with the problems arising from this suggestion, with the aim to restore Bennett's observation. The later building, dating most probably in the 6th century BCE will be compared with other similar buildings (like in Hazor, Area B, No. 3002).


Matthean Perspectives on Bloodshed, Obedience, and Bearing Arms
Program Unit: Matthew
Barbara Reid, Catholic Theological Union

Matthean Perspectives on Bloodshed, Obedience, and Bearing Arms. Three unique features in Matthew’s Passion Narrative open up questions about the appropriate responses of Christians to a call to war. (1) Matthew’s theme of accountability for the shedding of blood (by the religious leaders, 23:35; 27:6-10; by the one who hands Jesus over, (27:1-5); by the people as a whole 27:24-25), juxtaposed with Jesus’ offer of the cup at the Last Supper as his ‘blood of the covenant, poured out for many for the forgiveness of sins’(26:28) invites discussion about accountability for bloodshed in war and whether such is forgivable. (2) Matthew’s scene in Gethsemane (26:36-46) uniquely underscores Jesus’ obedience as ‘Son of God’ (27:40, 43) and invites discussion about whether obedience or resistance is the response to be given to powers that would sacrifice beloved sons and daughters in war. (3) Jesus’saying, ‘all who take the sword will perish by the sword’ (26:52) poses the question of whether bearing arms is possible for a Christian.


What Are Demons of Error? The Meaning of s\ydy @t(wt)and the Concept of Israelite Child Sacrifice
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Bennie H. Reynolds, III, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill

The Hebrew Bible contains several references to the mlk-sacrifice (or, sacrifice to Molek). There is significant debate about the identity of the recipient(s) of the mlk-sacrifice, but the options in the Hebrew Bible include Baal, YHWH, and Molek. A divergent account of Israelite child sacrifices is found in a fragmentary Aramaic text from Qumran: Pseudo-Daniel (4QpsDana-b ar). In contrast to most biblical descriptions of Israelite child sacrifices, 4QpsDana-b ar claims that children were sacrificed ????? ????? “to the demons of error.” This paper will investigate the meaning of the term ???? ????? and examine its significance in light of other accounts of child sacrifices in the Hebrew Bible and Second Temple Jewish literature. I will begin with some introductory comments on the manuscripts of 4QpsDana-b ar. Next, I will do a linguistic analysis of the two lexemes that compose the phrase ???? ????? “demons of error.” In the final part of my paper I will draw some conclusions about the meaning of “demons of error” in 4QpsDana-b ar and its implications for 1) Second Temple conceptions of Israelite child sacrifices and 2) Second Temple demonology.


Implications from the Book of Samuel for the Linguistic Dating of Biblical Literature
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Robert Rezetko, University of Edinburgh

*


1 Peter's Reuse of Jeremiah's Letter to the Exiles
Program Unit: Methodological Reassessments of the Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
E. Randolph Richards, Palm Beach Atlantic University

Following R. Hays' paradigm for Paul's letters (Echoes), with attention to Ann Jervis' points (JBL 112), I will suggest that when 1 Peter chose to write to Christians as "exiles in the Diaspora," he chose to reapply the original Diaspora letter. After arguing 1 Peter develops the same themes in the same order, I will ask, Is it midrash (like the rabbis) or pesher (like Paul)? E.g., God has a word for his people in exile (Jer 29:1-2 and 1 Pet 1:1-2). To mold his people, God has allowed a foreign empire to conquer them (Jer 29:4 and 1 Pet 1:3—2:10). They must submit and live in peace (Jer 29:5-7 and 1 Pet 2:1—4:11). God’s plan (Jer 29: 10-14 and 1 Pet 4:12) includes suffering (Jer 29:15-23 and 1 Pet 4:12-16), warnings/judgment (Jer 29:24-32 and 1 Pet 4:17—5:9), and a promise of restoration (Jer 30:1—31:20 and 1 Pet 5:10). Lastly, although they live in Babylon, they are aliens there (Jer 31:21-26 and 1 Pet 5:12-14). A survey of 1 Peter will show how he compresses or elaborates themes in Jeremiah to suit his needs. E.g., Jeremiah briefly states they are to submit to the empire and to live in peace (29:5-7). 1 Peter elaborates how this should be done, Greco-Roman household codes, etc. (2:12—3:16). Jeremiah warns about false leaders among the people (29:15-32). 1 Peter mentions no false leaders in the church but rather briefly admonishes the elders to lead wisely and not for sordid gain (5:1-9). Jeremiah describes at length the coming restoration (30—31), while 1 Peter makes only a passing comment (5:10). Commentators have long noted sermonic qualities in 1 Peter, is 1 Peter re-preaching Jeremiah's message to the exiles, and is he doing midrash or pesher or a hybrid?


Welcome and Introduction
Program Unit:
Kent Richards, Society of Biblical Literature

*


"For I Received from the Lord What I Also Handed on to You...": Pedagogy as Traditioning
Program Unit: Homiletics and Biblical Studies
Sharon H. Ringe, Wesley Theological Seminary

*


Laying Down Life for God: Johannine Christology and the Martyrdoms of Isaac in an Imperial Context
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
Jason J. Ripley, Saint Olaf College

Greco-Roman noble death traditions, particularly those found in the early Jewish interpretive expansions of Genesis 22, illuminate John’s unique portrait of Jesus, especially his triumphant march to death. John’s evocation of the only Son as a consummate(d) martyr like Isaac highlights his cruciform configuration of Torah, subverting other early Jewish applications of Genesis 22 to undergird execution of “sinners” and armed revolt in response to imperial domination. The Johannine relexification of dominant notions of military honor and glory around Jesus’ “noble crucifixion” similarly dethrones violent imperialistic values found in the rhetoric of noble death.


Rebuilding Jerusalem: A Vision within Visions
Program Unit: Literature and History of the Persian Period
Ken Ristau, Pennsylvania State University

While the temple and the administration of the new community figure prominently at the center of Zechariah 1-8, visions pertaining to a restored Jerusalem serve as book ends. The language employed in Zechariah for Jerusalem is among the most exalted in all biblical writings. The city’s restoration is presented both in terms of renewal of its past glory and also as a future, utopian expectation. The literary-theological messages are conveyed in a series of visions through motifs or tropes of the measuring line, election and holiness, and the city as axis mundi. This paper will explore and elucidate Zechariah’s visions of Jerusalem through an intertextual and comparative lens with a view to understanding the communicative intent for the community in Yehud.


Rhetography: A New Way of Seeing the Familiar Text
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Vernon K. Robbins, Emory University

Socio-rhetorical interpretation was first most fully presented using the figure of a many-textured "tapestry." Attention was given to inner texture, intertexture, social and cultural texture, ideological texture, and sacred texture as the warp and woof of a text. This paradigm needs to be revised to include "pictorial texture," or the "rhetography" of a text, the ways in which a text evokes a series of particular mental images, themselves embedded in social and cultural locations, as the matrix for communication and persuasion. This paper will present the theoretical background for this emerging exegetical strategy, and demonstrate its usefulness in the exploration of a passage from the Gospel of Luke.


The Problems in Reconstructing Coptic Manuscripts
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Gesine Schenke Robinson, Episcopal School of Theology

Not all Coptic manuscripts survive as more or less complete books. Compared to the Nag Hammadi texts, the so-called Berlin Coptic Book was in a dire state. It had to be pieced together from about 3000 scattered fragments. Though I introduced this manuscript at the beginning of the reconstruction work, the task is now complete and a very interesting text, a Coptic translation of an early 2nd century theological treatise, emerged. Another significant manuscript still awaits reconstruction: an incomplete 4th century Coptic papyrus book with several apocryphal texts, among them a version of the well-known Testament of Job. Although this text survived in other languages, the Coptic version would be by far the oldest attestation of this very important pseudepigraphic work of Judaism.


Ultimate Moonshine: Distilling Faith through the Prophetical Priestly Perspective from the Exile
Program Unit:
Nicolae Roddy, Creighton University

This paper proposes an approach to the Hebrew Bible/Older Testament (HB/OT) that offers undergraduate students in both confessional and non-confessional college or university settings a way of applying rigorous critical methodologies to the text that incidentally permits discovery of how it may be that this collection of ancient texts became the foundational pillar for western world culture, nourishing living religious and cultural traditions over two millennia. The approach views the HB/OT through the lens of what I have termed the Prophetical Priestly Perspective (PPP) from the Exile, which, as its name suggests, adopts sixth century BCE Babylon as its vantage point. It presupposes that at that time and place a relatively small group of displaced, prophet-friendly royal and priestly personages, standing at the end of their own national history, laid aside previous differences and engaged in collective reflection on what had gone so terribly wrong. They set about collecting earlier traditions, both oral and written, and edited and shaped them in such a way that it helped to make sense of their present situation, resulting in the first of two major stages in the formation of the Hebrew Bible (the second of which takes place at the time of Ezra). In short, a close literary-critical reading of the Law (Torah) and Prophets (Nevi¹im) both reflects a Babylonian setting and shows the group to be very critical of any human institution or endeavor that does not have God at its center. This includes their own priestly and royal leadership, the fortified city, military means of national defense, and (anachronistically speaking, of course) the ego self. Understanding the self-negating anti-history of the Prophetical Priestly Perspective creates an opportunity to objectify faith based on certain humanistic values that just happen also to be biblical.


Monarchy vs. Priesthood: Josephus, Justus of Tiberias, and Agrippa II
Program Unit: Josephus
Zuleika Rodgers, Trinity College, Dublin

If Josephus' account of the Judean constitution and its history is understood as pro-priestly while Justus of Tiberias wrote from the perspective of a monarchist, perhaps any historiographical rivalry between these authors is based on competing claims for these institutions.


Reading Jesus Reading: Text and Performance in Luke 4:16–30
Program Unit: Mapping Memory: Tradition, Texts, and Identity
Rafael Rodriguez, Johnson Bible College

This paper imports the insights and exegetical consequences of research into social memory and oral-traditional performance into the discussion of “the historical Jesus.” In particular, the model of past-present interaction developed by Barry Schwartz and questions of “textualization” (or “text-fixation”) raised in the works of John Miles Foley and Gregory Nagy undermine many of our assumptions regarding Jesus and the evangelists’ portrayal of him. Specifically, the image of Jesus reading from an Isaiah scroll represents an anomaly in the synoptic tradition; nowhere else is Jesus presented with such force as reading a written text. This image, therefore, is typically regarded as peculiarly Lukan, without referent in the actual life and activity of Jesus, stemming as it does from Lukan redaction of Markan tradition. Instead, this paper will argue that the more Luke strains to portray Jesus reading, the clearer it becomes that this text remembers not a literate Jesus but one who stands near the heart of the complexly written-and-oral tradition of late-Second Temple Judaism. The result, finally, is an awareness of the sources of Luke's theologizing as he programmatically portrays Jesus in Nazareth.


Non Linguistic Criteria in Dating Biblical Texts
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Alexander Rofé, Hebrew University, Jerusalem

*


The Scribal Apparatus of Ancient Ammon: Sophistication, Assiduousness, and Productivity
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Christopher A. Rollston, Emmanuel School of Religion

For some time, there has been substantial research focusing on the subject of formal, standardized education in ancient Israel.  However, there has not been much discussion of the scribes of ancient Ammon.  Within this presentation, the emphasis will be on Ammonite Monumental (and Royal) inscriptions, a research focus that also serves as a window into various aspects of the general "elite culture" in ancient Ammon.


Writing, Literacy, and Scribal Activity in Ancient Israel
Program Unit: Archaeological Excavations and Discoveries: Illuminating the Biblical World
Christopher A. Rollston, Emmanuel School of Religion

This paper argues, on the basis of detailed analysis of the Old Hebrew epigraphic corpus, that Israelite scribes underwent substantial and rigorous formal, standardized education. Special attention is devoted to the subject of Old Hebrew palaeography, orthography, numeric conventions, and conventional formulae. In addition, there will be some reference to modern data about the time it takes to become proficient in one's first modern alphabetic writing system (with some comparison of languages with deep and shallow orthographies).


"The Law of Yahweh Is with Us": Actualization of Legal Traditions in Early Sixth Century BCE Prophetic Literature
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Dalit Rom-Shiloni, Hebrew University, Jerusalem

Pentateuchal legal traditions function extensively in both poetic and prose passages in Jeremiah and in Ezekiel as part of the discourse between the prophets and their contemporaries. This study examines the major allusive and exegetical techniques (analogy, adaptation, expansion and reversal), which provide diverse, at times contradictory, perspectives in ideological conflicts amongst the Judahite communities of the early sixth century BCE. Actualization, including the freedom to re-interpret the laws of Deuteronomy, the Priestly sources, and the Covenant Book, demonstrates the authoritative status of the Law on the eve of destruction and in the early exilic period.


Marital and Political Metaphors of God: Interchangeable Metaphors Manipulated by Ezekiel to Serve an Internal Judahite Conflict
Program Unit: Theology of the Hebrew Scriptures
Dalit Rom-Shiloni, Hebrew University of Jerusalem

By the early sixth century BCE anthropomorphic metaphors of the marital and the political spheres function in descriptions of God as King, and they both illustrate the covenant relationship between God and his people. Studying Ezekiel 16 and 20, this paper suggests that Ezekiel differentiates between these otherwise interchangeable metaphors, and employs each of them to substantiate his arguments on the God-people relationship in the conflict between the Jehoiachin Exiles and Those Who Remained in Jerusalem. Life and death, continuity and annihilation, ingroup and outgroup perspectives, are all demonstrated through the prophet’s usage of these metaphors of God as King, sovereign or husband.


The Death of the Deuteronomistic History and the Birth of the Decalogue
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Thomas C. Romer, University of Lausanne

*


The Biblical Concept of “Pride”: The Difference between the Hebrew and the English Concept
Program Unit: Bible Translation
Mirja Ronning, Home for Bible Translators and Scholars in Jerusalem

The Biblical Concept of “Pride”:The difference between the Hebraic concept of g'h "pride" and the English concept of "pride"- reducing the artificiality of the cognitive context of the biblical scholar/translator It has been increasingly recognized that in an act of communication the cognitive contexts of the participants play a significant role (Ernst-August Gutt, 2006). In the written communication of ancient texts, such as the Hebrew bible, the scholar/translator is faced with the largely unfamiliar cognitive context of the Biblical writer. While interpreting such a text, the scholar/translator will naturally tend to decipher the text from the artificial cognitive framework that fits the conceptual framework of his/her own mother tongue. This research paper aims to increase the cognitive resemblance between the biblical text and the reader’s understanding. The concept of pride was chosen because very little semantic research has been devoted to it. Comprehensive research was done by examining all the occurrences of the root g'h and its derivatives in the Hebrew Bible. The semantic network of Hebrew synonyms was also checked. The results of the research indicate an important cognitive difference between the Hebraic concept of g'h and the English concept of pride. This fact has ramifications for the understanding and interpretation of the Biblical text for the scholar and theologian, but especially for the translator.


Parable and Reality in Jesus' Galilee
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Bradley W. Root, University of California, San Diego

Since the publication of Joachim Jeremias’s seminal work on the parables of Jesus, most New Testament scholars have rejected allegorical interpretations of the parables in favor of more literal ones. Because some of the parables in the synoptic gospels are also found in the Gospel of Thomas, and because the parables are more likely than other portions of Jesus’ teachings to have been preserved in the oral traditions that predated the written gospels, many argue that the parables are among the most reliable sources for Jesus’ life and his environment. In fact, most consider the parables to be authentic portrayals of Jesus’ criticisms of the socio-economic conditions that he believed had destroyed the traditional Galilean way of life and rendered his compatriots destitute. Although this view has become dominant in New Testament scholarship, the assumption that Jesus’ parables offer an accurate depiction of social conditions in first century Galilee is problematic for two major reasons. First, these parables were most likely adapted to the gospels so that they would have appealed to a more geographically diverse audience than the original hearers of Jesus’ parables. Therefore, it might be difficult to determine when a parable reflects the social conditions of the Galilee and when it reflects those of the gospel authors. Second, in order to make the stories more dramatic, Jesus’ parables often relate extraordinary events (as in the parable of the talents) that would not have reflected everyday life. Modern scholars must be careful not to mistake these embellishments for accurate reflections of Galilean social conditions. This paper will attempt to address these difficulties by answering two questions: 1) How can scholars determine which of the parables reflect Jesus’ social environment? 2) What can the parables tell modern researchers about the socio-economic conditions of first century Galilee?


Authentication of Early Christian Texts: Hebrews 13:20–25 as Pauline Forgery
Program Unit: Hebrews
Clare K. Rothschild, Lewis University

In its earliest attestation in the Chester Beatty papyrus (P46) (3rd cent. C. E.), the Epistle to the Hebrews is found in a collection of Pauline letters after Romans, indicating Pauline authorship. This position on authorship represents a mid-second century assessment of Hebrews by the Eastern church in Alexandria. Clement and Origen both discuss this view, acknowledging issues of style and content most likely as a means of defending the presence of Hebrews in their Pauline corpus (Hist. eccl. 6.14, 25). In the West, too, prior to the Muratorian Fragment, Pauline authorship of Hebrews was probably accepted. References to Hebrews alongside Romans and 1 Corinthians in 1 Clement suggest that this author, writing to a Pauline church, knew all three in association with each other as Pauline. By the fifth century, both Augustine (Civ. Dei 16.22) and Jerome (De vir. illust. 5.59) adopt this earlier consensus on Pauline authorship represented by 1 Clement and the Chester Beatty papyrus, securing the tradition until the Enlightenment. Since the Enlightenment, however, this view is rejected and today the question of how Hebrews rose to and maintained Pauline status for over a thousand years lays dormant. This paper presents the status quaestionis of the role of Heb 13:20—25 in this debate, arguing that these few verses in isolation were not composed de novo. Rather, the author of Hebrews deliberately adopted words and phrases from a collection of accepted Pauline materials to imply apostolic authorship for the work overall. The goal of this forgery was to foster a perception of the book’s often radical views as orthodox. The present discussion is informed by, but also attempts to move beyond, the latest understandings of pseudonymity among early Christian texts.


Average Families? The Problem of Variability in Iron Age Houses
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
Bruce Routledge, University of Liverpool

Discussions of both the four-room house and biblical representations of the family, rely heavily on models of the “typical” or “average”, whether it is a question of household composition or of patriarchal authority. The regular form of the four-room house and the overriding egalitarian ethos of the Hebrew Bible certainly encourage scholars to emphasize what Iron Age families had in common. However, when one looks closely at actual excavated houses from Iron Age contexts in the southern Levant, one finds significant levels of variability in size, internal arrangements, and artifact assemblages between houses. At the moment, such variability remains largely unexploited as a means of examining both village and household relations in an historically dynamic manner. In this paper I will attempt both to highlight the scale and nature of this variability and to show the potential for new insights into Iron Age social life that arise from taking variability seriously.


“God Made Him Both Lord and Christ” (Acts 2:36): The History of Exegesis and the Context of Interpretation
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
C. Kavin Rowe, Duke University Divinity School

The christological problem embedded in the phrase “God made him both Lord and Christ” (Acts 2:36) has divided both ancient and modern interpreters over the question “when?”: when did God make Jesus both Lord and Christ? Close attention to the various answers offered by the history of interpretation reveals the need to probe carefully the wider hermeneutical contexts in which exegesis operates. The answer to the “when” question and the concomitant sense of Acts 2:36 are inextricably bound to the larger interpretive structures in which the verse is read. Through a juxtaposition of major patristic figures and modern New Testament scholars, this paper thus analyzes a particularly significant verse in the history of exegesis in effort to reflect upon the distinctive conceptual frameworks for interpretation and the resultant hermeneutical insight for present scholarly work.


A Synopsis of Mysticism in Matthew: Matthew 18:10–12
Program Unit: New Testament Mysticism Project
Christopher Rowland, University of Oxford

A synopsis of mysticism in the Gospel of Matthew will be presented, followed by a commentary on Matthew 18:10-12.


The Corrections of the Freer Gospels Codex (W, 032)
Program Unit:
James Royse, Graduate Theological Union

An analysis of scribal corrections in the Freer Gospels codex with a view to what they tell us about the purposes and influences that helped to shape its text.


On Milk, Meat, and Mothers: Some Observations on Gender in Cultic Food Regulations
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Nicole J. Ruane, Portsmouth, NH

This paper considers three groups of texts: (1) the prohibition on boiling a kid in its mother’s milk (Ex. 23:19; 34:26; Dt. 14:21) (2) the statute that a baby animal must remain with its mother for seven days before being slaughtered and the following prohibition on slaughtering a parent and child animal on the same day (Lev. 22:27-28) and (3) the prohibition on consuming a mother bird along with her eggs or newborn offspring (Dt.22:6-7). The paper will show that these laws share the common motif of safeguarding a nubile female source of food, but also of proscribing female substances and some aspects of female reproduction from the cult. This exclusion of some food and its sources is a continuation of the larger phenomenon of excluding female sexuality from the sacred, though the cultic treatment of animal reproduction is strikingly different from that of humans. The three groups of laws also show the preference for male meat as cultic food and in that process underscore the violence and danger of masculinity, for both humans and animals, in the sacrificial cult.


Partnership between Biblical Scholars and Storytellers
Program Unit: Poster Session
Philip Ruge-Jones, Texas Lutheran University

In the summer of 2003 the Network of Biblical Storytellers invited Biblical scholars of the Society of Biblical Literature to work with well-trained and professional storytellers to shape a new partnership in order to explore how performance in both the ancient world and the contemporary world might affect our understanding of the nature of the biblical narrative. For three consecutive summers almost twenty scholars and storytellers have gathered in the summer under the name “NOBS Scholars” to discuss such topics as the oral context of the ancient world, the relationship between oral and written stories, the contributions of other traditional and contemporary schools of biblical criticism for our task, the distortions in biblical interpretation that results when the primary medium of performance is neglected, the pedagogical value of storytelling methodology in universities and seminaries, the role of gender in storytelling, contemporary biblical scholarship with digital media, and, above all, the value of performance for understanding the nature of the biblical material. This poster will document this amazing process of partnership and share the developing direction of Performance Criticism in light of these on-going experiences.


Performance Criticism as Anti-imperial Pedagogy
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Philip Ruge-Jones, Texas Lutheran University

Performance Criticism as a methodology provides a way of redressing many of the forms of contemporary “imperial practices” that violate the integrity and wholeness of life. It joins other academic criticisms in combating the pernicious interpretive strategies of fundamentalist religion by exposing students to multiple, coherent ways of faithfully interpreting biblical stories. Through a pedagogical practice by which communities embody biblical stories in diverse ways, students learn to appreciate and experience the texts as opening up interpretive possibilities rather than reducing all interpretations to one uniform truth. Yet while Performance Criticism joins other forms of biblical criticism in challenging fundamentalism, it also challenges traditional biblical criticisms whose methods often drive a wedge between scholars and other interpreters, academic and faith communities, interpretation and praxis, thought and embodiment, faith and politics. Alternative practices may emerge through Performance Criticism that conform to the egalitarian and holistic values of the reign of God.


Apocalypse at the Ends of the Earth: A Clash of Colonial Eschatologies?
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Jean-Pierre Ruiz, Saint John's University

Postcolonial readings of the Revelation to John have shed new light on the ways in which that apocalypse functioned to nourish resistance against the Roman Empire in the province of Asia in the waning years of the first century CE. In Revelation 7:15, heavenly voices announce: “The kingdom of the world has become the kingdom of our Lord and of his Messiah, and he will reign forever and ever.” Examination of the influence of John’s Apocalypse through a postcolonial optic also yields important insights into the re-deployment of apocalyptic rhetoric in the European colonization of the Americas. This paper will begin to explore the ways in which the apocalyptic eschatology that nourished the European colonization of the Americas beginning in the fifteenth century encountered and was encountered by the eschatologies of indigenous populations of the Americas. Special attention will be given to the role of apocalypticism in the Spanish colonial enterprise.


Laughing with the Commentators in Genesis 17, 18, and 21
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Nina Rulon-Miller, Rowan University

In 1991 Mieke Bal wrote that the Bible is a “dangerous” book. In my research I have found that the standard commentators have also written dangerous books, books that validate and perpetuate the annihilation of the Canaanites, the glorification of Abraham and the Israelites, and the denigration of Hagar and Ishmael, Egypt and “Arabs.” Even contemporary feminist critics often advise their readers to “see the commentaries,” using the phrase as a kind of shorthand to refer to additional, and implicitly accurate, information on the biblical texts they discuss in their own work. For example, Phyllis Trible often writes “see the commentaries” in her endnotes, where she refers her readers to Speiser, Von Rad, Driver, Gunkel, and Westermann. Esther Fuchs also sends readers to the commentaries with no critique, e.g., to Nahum Sarna’s "Understanding Genesis" and E. A. Speiser’s "Genesis." However, the interested general reader is bound to be led astray when turning to the standard commentaries. In this paper I discuss the commentators’ biased responses to Abraham’s and Sarah's laughter in Genesis 17, 18, and 21. I also take the audience through one of Speiser’s commentaries on Ishmael, where I demonstrate that, in his eagerness to denigrate Ishmael, Speiser blithely mistranslates the Hebrew texts. My critique of Speiser’s commentary is important because his book is the most widely used by non-specialist English-speaking readers. First published by Doubleday in 1964, Speiser’s "Genesis" was in its fifth printing in 1989. Between 1989 and 2001, 8,150 volumes were printed. Unfortunately, it is often the only commentary on Genesis to be found on the shelves of public libraries as well as on those of many secular colleges and universities.


"Take Up the Cross": Discipleship as a Death March in Early Christianity
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
John G. Rumple, University of Edinburgh

This paper will explore the preservation and application of the "cross saying" (Lk 9:23 and par.) in earliest Christianity. The paper first examines how the saying functioned in its earliest possible setting, noting its implications for discipleship in the Roman-controlled world. An answer will be sought for the question: Did the earliest Christians fundamentally understand the cross saying as a call to martyrdom/political action? It will be noted that successive generations continued to find this saying meaningful, some developing novel applications related to a more spiritual/metaphorical Christian religious expereince (e.g., Gal 2:20, etc.). Finally, the various presentations of Jesus' death as paradignmatic for discipleship in the Synoptic gospels are examined, with suggestions for its meaning during the time of their composition (post-Neronic).


The Syriac Commentary on Ben Sira by Dionysius bar Salibi
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Stephen Ryan, Dominican House of Studies

This paper surveys the reception of Ben Sira in the Syriac tradition and examines the commentary on Sirach 24 by the Syrian Orthodox scholar Dionysius bar Salibi. Particular attention will be given to identifying Bar Salibi's Greek and Syriac sources and the nature of his biblical citations.


The Foundation Stone: Reflections on the Adoption and Transformation of ‘Primordial’ Myth in Rabbinic Literature
Program Unit: Midrash
Steven Sacks, Cornell College

The ‘foundation stone,’ or Even Shetiyah, of rabbinic thought has been an important trope within the academic study of religion, as well as in the study of Judaism from the perspective of the history of religions. Mircea Eliade, A.J. Wensick, and other comparativists sought out this myth in order to elucidate cross-cultural tropes and to outline a morphology of world myth. These comparativists situated the rabbinic ‘foundation stone’ in relation to two models of ‘foreign’ myth: the foundation stone was the center of the world, or “axis mundi, ” or represented the primordial battle against chaos, or “agon” model, as can be perceived in the Babylonian Talmud Yoma 54b. In these broad cross-cultural categories, these scholars offered genealogical models for the ‘influence’ of foreign cultures upon Judaism or universal religious paradigms of divine creation or sacred space. Nonetheless, the development of the ‘foundation stone’ in subsequent rabbinic thought demonstrates that these early references to the image are symbolic discourse, in which the mythic value of the Even Shetiyah reverberates beyond these typological readings and cross cultural formulations. Traditions found in works such as Pirke de-Rabbi Eliezer and Zohar exemplify a more explicit expression of ‘foundation stone’ imagery that is informed by the mythic value of the patriarch Jacob, and one which works in concert with the tenor of rabbinic symbolic discourse. My examination of the ‘foundation stone’ tradition will occur within the context of the tropes’ correlation to the patriarch Jacob, and will demonstrate that these ‘foreign’ traditions are situated within the semiotic development of rabbinic myth. Consequently, this paper will argue that rabbinic development of ‘shared’ or ‘borrowed’ traditions about the Even Shetiyah can inform our understanding of symbolic and exegetical developments within rabbinic literature, and the use of rabbinic tropes for the comparative exercise.


A Neglected Version of Judas: Manichaean Readings of the Betrayer
Program Unit: Manichaean Studies
Tudor Sala, Yale University

The disciple who betrayed Jesus intrigued and fascinated not only Manichaean intellectuals but also the common believers. His presence in dogmatic treatises, homilies and religious hymns displays an intense meditation on the figure of the twelfth apostle. The “Manichaean Judas” appears as a polymorphous figure at the crossroads of cultures and religions, a part of the Manichaean religious identity from Egypt to Central Asia.


Proto-Lucian and 4QSama
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Richard J. Saley, Harvard University

[Please note: in both the title and abstract, the second "a" of 4QSama should be superscript.] There is probably no more vexing problem in Septuagint Studies today than that of Proto-Lucian, not only with regard to its definition and origin, but also with regard to its relationship with the texts of the Qumran scrolls. Using the publication of 4QSama in DJD 17, this paper examines every reading in the non-kaige section of Samuel where 4QSama agrees with the Lucianic text against the Old Greek and Masoretic texts. The aim is to assess the strength of the affinity between the Lucianic tradition and 4QSama in such instances.


Pagans and Christians in the Late Antique Rome
Program Unit: Manichaean Studies
Michele Salzman, University of California, Riverside

One of the signs of the continued vitality of the pagan cults in the post-Constantinian century is the persistence of Christian apologetics directed against pagans. Several of these texts date from the last quarter of the fourth century, including the Carmen Contra Paganos, the Pseudo-Cyprian Carmen ad senatorem ex Christiana religione ad idolorum servitutem conversum, the Pseudo-Paulinus Carmen ad Antonium, and the Consultationes Zacchaei et Apollonii, recently attributed to the 390s. Examination of these texts reveals certain persistent themes that emerge, too, in Symmachus’ famous Third Relatio which called for the return of the Altar of Victory to the Roman Senate House. This paper will focus on the contested areas of public religious life revealed by these apologetic texts. Indeed, the texts underscore not only the concern of pagans to preserve traditional state cults, but highlight as well Christians who were intent on maintaining a respectful attitude toward the imperial cult. In the late fourth century city, such attitudes were deemed more than appropriate as these different religious groups vied for dominance in the city.


Clear as Day: Metaphorical and Literal Readings of Scripture in the Open Theism Debate
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
John Sanders, Huntington College

*


Writing on the Tablet of the Heart and the Writing on the Wall: Tel Zayit and the Implications of Israelite Literacy
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Seth Sanders, Cornell University

This paper attempts to provide the first interpretation of the significance of the Tel Zayit inscription in light of theories of Israelite literacy and statehood. Recent years have seen a series of new studies of the meaning and social location of writing in Israel, including major works by Nadav Na’aman, William Schniedewind, Mark S. Smith, and David M. Carr and forthcoming books by Karel Van der Toorn and the presenter. The discovery of the Tel Zayit abecedary affords a precious opportunity to reflect on the theories’ claims in light of new evidence. Is this alphabet evidence of “formal scribal training … a result of a rapidly developing Israelite bureaucracy in Jerusalem”? Is it even in Hebrew, and what would it mean for a text to be “in Hebrew” in the 10th century BCE? Both theory and evidence will be examined for their historical, epigraphic and exegetical dividends. Theoretically, the strongest and most sweeping claims are those of Carr, who postulates a common pan-Mediterranean set of practices around writing spanning from Ebla to Egypt to Athens. Epigraphically, texts such as Tel Zayit represent privileged examples for exploring the significance of this work. For example, can we understand the peculiar physical context of the Zayit inscription as a result of an ancient Israelite “numinous” view of writing postulated by both Carr and Susan Niditch? Exegetically, how do the new theories and evidence about writing affect our reading of the Bible? For example, how do representations of early writing in the Torah such as Deuteronomy’s command to inscribe divine words on plaster square with this evidence? The paper is intended to contribute to a growing dialogue between archaeology, social theory and Biblical interpretation.


Dwellers at Qumran: Reflections on Their Literacy, Class, and Identity
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Juhana Saukkonen, University of Helsinki

Despite the growing number of dissenting voices, the majority of scholars still sees Qumran as a site where a more or less radical Jewish group studied and copied sacred writings – and also authored religious compositions of their own. These scrolls were placed in the nearby caves, either to hide them from the Romans or simply to store them as a kind of a library, or both. Accepting or rejecting this overall picture has implications for our estimation of the inhabitants' literacy rate, as well as more general considerations pertaining to their class and social status. One can, and possibly should, however, approach these issues from a different, if not opposite, angle. This paper aims to investigate the material evidence from Khirbet Qumran from the viewpoint of class and literacy in particular. It seems demonstrable that the majority of the dwellers at Qumran lead a very simple, non-luxurious life. Many of them must have spent most of their waking hours in the mundane and typically non-elite tasks of agriculture, food preparation, and, e.g., pottery manufacture. On one hand, the inkwells found on the site attest to at least some amount of writing activity – but still, we have very little evidence of extensive scroll production at Khirbet Qumran. While studying of writings does not necessarily leave a clear archaeological record behind, archaeological and textual parallels can shed light on the likelihood of Qumran being a hub of scriptural study in the Second Temple period. These reflections will obviously not suffice to solve the question of the identity of the inhabitants, but might provide us with a small patch of firmer ground.


The Hermeneutical Circle of Christian Community: Biblical, Theological, and Practical Dimensions of the Unity of Scripture
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Charles J. Scalise, Fuller Theological Seminary

This study surveys some of the major questions that emerge for the theological interpretation of Scripture following the hermeneutical circle of Scripture, theology, and practice and explores a possible model for community response. It investigates the possibility that for those Christians who view Scripture as the primary source of religious authority the development of a hermeneutical circle of community provides a way to develop a useful theological perspective on the problem of the unity of Scripture. Such a community would practice a canonical hermeneutic of biblical interpretation and employ a blended diversity of theological models to connect Christian doctrine and practice.


A User-Friendly Introduction to the Major Tiberian Bible Manuscripts
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Harold P. Scanlin, IOMS

Fundamental to any study of masora is an understanding of the major codexes of the Hebrew Bible that represent the high point in the work of the great masoretes. Scholars are familiar with the basic characteristics of the two most famous codexes, Aleppo and Leningradensis, but a greater appreciation of their contents and role in the history of the Biblical text is fundamental to a better understanding of the Masoretic text. Other early and important Tiberian manuscripts will be discussed in relation to the establishment of the Tiberian system. The presentation will also consider: Factors that led to the triumph of the Tiberian system over Palestinian and Babylonian traditions; The (rival) Tiberian sub-systems, namely ben Asher and ben Naphtali; Prospects and pitfalls in utilizing electronic resources available for manuscript and textual studies.


Magdalene Christianity: A Collection of Fragments, or an Actual Reality in Early Communities?
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Jane D. Schaberg, University of Detroit Mercy

My position is that Mary Magdalene was an historical figure, a member of the movement associated with Jesus, and a witness to his crucifixion, burial, and empty tomb. The arguments for this are detailed in my book, The Resurrection of Mary Magdalene, and will not be rehearsed here. In this paper, I will build on this position, by revising and expanding my chapter in On the Cutting Edge, in which I hold that there was an alternative early form of Christianity or Christian Judaism (not Pauline, not Petrine, not Thomasine, not Jamesian) that (1) flowed from the witness of women; (2) maintained the effort to balance women’s roles and authority with men’s; and (3) kept alive the consistence of such ancient elements as women’s prophecy, focus on wisdom, a high valuation of the mystical experience of ascent as a apocalyptic foretaste of resurrection, and a corporate Human One (son of man) Christology.


The Illegitimacy of Jesus after Twenty Years
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Jane D. Schaberg, University of Detroit Mercy

Critical reflections on the reception of The Illegitimacy of Jesus: A Feminist Theological Interpretation of the Infancy Narratives (San Francisco: Harper and Row, 1987)


Genesis 1:26–27, the Divine Presence, and Biblical Anthropology
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Joachim Schaper, University of Aberdeen

This paper will explore the significance of Gen. 1:26-27 from a completely new angle. It centers on the semantics of the term selem, seen against the background of the Hebrew term and its Akkadian cognate salmu, and new research on representation in cultic images in Mesopotamia conducted by assyriologists and art historians. It will attempt to show that the concept underlying the famous verses cannot be grasped by the classic Western mimetic model. What is true of the Assyro-Babylonian concept of salmu, i.e. that ‘[t]he relationship between salmu and reality is not one that was considered to be unidirectional, as we might describe the functional movement of the mimetic image’ (Z. Bahrani, The Graven Image) – is true of the Israelite concept also. This has far-reaching consequences for our understanding of the biblical concept of divine presence and of biblical anthropology.


Recurring Themes in Hosea, Joel, and Amos
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Aaron Schart, University of Duisburg

The paper will evaluate the writings Hos, Joel, and Amos within the Twelve for the ways in which they relate to recurring themes/motifs within and through the Book as a whole. Several recurring elements have been noted in recent literature, and will be evaluated to see whether and in what ways they function within the first section of the Twelve. Within this section the Fate of Israel is contrasted to that of Judah. In Northern Israel and in Judah (Joel) the Day of YHWH is prophetically announced. However, only in Judah YHWH does postpone that day. Other themes include: Theodicy, the relationship of God’s people and the nations, Sin/Repentance, the fertility/infertility of the land, and Punishment and Restoration. In the end it will be reflected upon the implications the findings may have for a theological reception of persons of faith today.


Psst—Do I Have a Bible FOR YOU!!!!! Bible Sales' Strategies and the American Public
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Linda S. Schearing, Gonzaga University

Selling Bibles is not an easy task. When the overwhelming majority of American households already contain a Bible, what’s a publishing house to do? This presentation will examine how two innovative strategies (niche marketing and the creation of the “Bible-zine”) became the answer of choice for some publishers. Such strategies, however, are extremely problematic. Whereas niche marketing, for example, is often blatantly based on (and perpetuates) cultural stereotypes, the “Bible-zine” is a prime example of scripture repackaged to meet popular culture's reading appetites. Such accommodation, however, comes at the cost of the text's own structural integrity.


The Shipwreck Tale
Program Unit: Formation of Luke and Acts
Kenneth L. Schenck, Indiana Wesleyan University

Scholars have often suggested that a travel narrative might stand behind Paul’s journey to Rome. Boismard and Lamouille have actually suggested two sources behind the story. The possibility that we might at least have two oral traditions mixed here raises numerous possibilities. In particular, the similarity between this shipwreck and one mentioned in 2 Corinthians 11:25 is tantalizing. Has Luke transplanted an earlier tale of shipwreck to this point in the narrative? Further, might the Pastoral Epistles contain relevant historical memories? Presuming Paul dies “at the end of Acts,” does 2 Timothy allude to a more precise itinerary of Paul’s final trip to Rome (through Miletus and Corinth), perhaps even the historical continuation of the story at Acts 27:5? Indeed, Titus would make more sense if Paul had visited Crete at some point. Thus the hypothetical tale: Did “Luke” want a more climactic ending to Acts than an original journey across Greece to Rome? Did he pass over the shipwreck tale earlier as a distraction to the progress of the narrative, much as he did Paul’s disheartening second visit to Corinth (2 Cor. 12:14; 13:2)? Has he merged two tales in Acts 27 (as perhaps Acts 15 has)? Paul and Titus set out from Asia Minor around the time of Paul’s stay at Ephesus. In the process of journey they eventually find themselves off the southern coast of Crete (cf. Acts 27:7). They spend “a night and a day in the deep” in the environs of Cauda. A mission to Crete ensues. Acts 27 becomes two stories combined, that of Paul’s trip to Rome and an earlier shipwreck near Crete.


Wisdom and Law in Proverbs
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Bernd U. Schipper, Universitat Bremen

The "relecture" of older traditions in post-exilic literature has been discussed for a long time. The paper deals with the interplay between wisdom and law in proverbs. From a methodological point of view both traditions should be seen as an example for a cultural discourse which links the book of Proverbs with post-exilic prophetism and the Esra-Tradition.


Constructing the “Other” in David’s Rise to Power
Program Unit: New Historicism and the Hebrew Bible
Jeremy Schipper, Siena College

This paper argues that the imagery of physical difference plays an important part in the poetics of David’s rise to power. Such imagery provides one means of minimizing differences in people groups that are quite diverse and grouping them together as “other”; the correlative to a normative Davidic “us.” The images of physical difference are not simple, transparent, or isolated character descriptions that strive for accurate depictions of particular bodies. Rather, they reflect carefully choreographed images of cultural ideals. The David Story decontextualizes and choreographs physical difference into a contrast between the “fit” body of David’s house and the “unfit” bodies of those who oppose David.


How David Overinterprets Nathan's Parable in 2 Samuel 12:1–6
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Jeremy Schipper, Siena College

A general consensus among scholars holds that David misunderstands Nathan’s parable in 2 Sam 12:1b-4. Most scholars assume this misunderstanding results from David’s treatment of it as an actual legal case rather than as a parable. This paper argues that David does in fact recognize Nathan’s story as a typical prophetic parable (cf. Isa 5:1-7; Ezek 17:1-10) but that he does not interpret it as Nathan intends. Rather, a close reading of David's response suggests that he overinterprets the parable and then tries to condemn Joab for the murder of Uriah in vv. 5-6.


The Book of Psalms as Text and Artifact in Jewish Tradition
Program Unit: Scripture as Artifact
Marianne Schleicher, Aarhus University

The paper discusses the function of the biblical Psalms in Jewish tradition from Antiquity until today. The discussion rests upon insights from various approaches to scripture where scripture is not only thought of as text, but also as artifact. Thus, the paper distinguishes between a hermeneutical and an artifactual use of scripture: 1. A hermeneutical use of scripture is taken to imply a Gadamerian fusion with the horizon of the text, thereby enabling the user to consider whether the text’s proposed religious worldview should be transposed into the user’s own worldview. 2. An artifactual use is taken to imply an emphasis on the non-semantic aspects of scripture (particular binding and embellishment, specifications for spelling, recitation, ritual handling and storage, etc.). Artifactual use seems to promote an understanding of scripture that is governed by personal and cultural representations where these representations are subsequently and much more subconsciously transposed into the user’s worldview. Based on an analysis of various examples of Psalmic use in Jewish tradition, the paper discusses what kind of scriptural use dominates in what kind of situations and to what effect.


Abraham's Faith in Romans 4: Genesis 15:6 and Its History of Reception in Second Temple Judaism and Paul
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Benjamin Schliesser, Tuebingen, Germany

A study of Paul's conception of faith that bridges the divide between the "Lutheran" Paul and his critics, showing how justification and participation concepts coincide.


Does God Suffer as Humanity Suffers? A Linguistic Examination of Evidence in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Poster Session
Matthew R. Schlimm, Duke University

Abraham Heschel, Walter Brueggemann, and Terence Fretheim have conducted important studies of the suffering of God in the Hebrew Bible, but there are two key areas that need further exploration. First, there is a need to classify the textual evidence that they use. Though these three rarely admit it, some texts refer to divine suffering much more clearly than others. This presentation helps fill this void by tabulating the texts in the Hebrew Bible that refer to divine suffering into three categories: (1) passages that refer explicitly to divine suffering, (2) passages that merely imply that God suffers, and (3) passages that make potential reference to divine pathos but are clouded by some element of ambiguity. This table not only allows one to understand which texts refer the most clearly to divine pathos, but also it shows in what ways different parts of the Hebrew Bible speak about God’s suffering. Second, there is a need to examine whether God suffers as humanity suffers. Heschel, Brueggemann, and Fretheim make different claims about this issue. Heschel strongly differentiates God’s suffering from humanity’s, Brueggemann sees little difference between the two, and Fretheim aims to find middle ground. This presentation evaluates their claims by analyzing passages that refer explicitly to divine pathos, charting whether (and where) similar language is used to express human suffering. By classifying types of textual evidence and examining similarities between the human and divine, this presentation promotes a deeper understanding of the extent and nature of God’s suffering.


Abraham’s Sacrifice: Gerhard von Rad’s Interpretation of Gen 22
Program Unit:
Konrad Schmid, University of Zurich

*


Re-considering Paleographical Judgments about the Freer Gospels Codex
Program Unit:
Ulrich Schmid, Free University, Amsterdam

The Freer Gospels Codex was dated paleographically by H.A. Sanders to the early fifth or late fourth century CE. In this presentation, I discuss subsequent data and rationale for re-considering this, and I propose that the Gospels Codex may more appropriately be dated to the sixth century CE.


Gold Mine or Coal Mine? Teaching the Hebrew Bible in the Undergraduate Classroom
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Susanne Scholz, Merrimack College

This paper investigates the complexities of transforming the undergraduate Hebrew Bible curriculum from the "coal mine" approach of content management and historical-literal presentation to the "gold mine" approach that views Hebrew Bible courses as opportunities toward the development of intellectual-religious maturity, historical-cultural understanding, and literary-ethical engagement.


The Role of Reading in the Textual History of the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Stefan Schorch, Kirchliche Hochschule Bethel

In pre-Masoretic times, the written transmission of Hebrew biblical texts was basically restricted to the consonantal framework. All further information necessary to read the text, especially vowels and accents, had to be supplied by the reader, be it due to his general knowledge of the Hebrew language, or be it due to an oral reading tradition known by heart. The act of reading, therefore, was obviously an important factor for the constitution of the text. It even influenced and changed the written tradition in many cases. The paper will demonstrate this influence with the help of examples from different textual traditions (Masoretic text, Samaritan pentateuch, Septuagint). Moreover, it will provide a systematic description of the different ways in which the act of reading influenced the textual history of the Hebrew bible.


The Library of Caesarea, (Christian) Intertexts, and the Construction of “Jewish Literature"
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Jeremy Schott, University of North Carolina, Charlotte

The Caesarean Library figured critically in the formation of late ancient biblical and historical scholarship. Recent efforts to reconstruct the library’s catalogue, however, leave aside interesting questions as to how the collection was deployed by ancient Christians. I draw on Gerard Genette’s conceptualizations of inter-, meta-, and paratextuality to explore how Eusebius processed one portion of the library’s holdings—the set of texts usually designated “Hellenistic-Jewish Literature” (Eupolemus, Artapanus, Aristobulus, Philo, etc.)— to fashion “Hebrew-Literature” as a literary and historical category. Eusebius’ Preparation for the Gospel is a bricollage of textual fragments. Setting a series of these fragments in explicit and implicit comparative relationships in Books 7-9, Eusebius differentiates between “Hebrew” literature, represented as a “preparation” for Christianity, and “Judaism,” understood as a fundamental mis-reading of “Hebrew” literature. This differential relationship between “Hebrew” allegory and philosophy and “Jewish” literalism and legalism, I go on to argue, has significantly influenced modern scholars, who, in distinguishing between (syncretistic) Hellenistic Judaism and (anti-syncretistic) Palestinian Judaism in their historical narratives, replicate a Eusebian dichotomy. The modern categorization and study of ancient “Jewish Literature” is mediated not by any “accident” of preservation, but by the deliberate preservation of specific texts in particular collections of texts and their subsequent dissemination in specific intertextual relationships in the work of Christian bricolleurs (especially Eusebius and later, Jerome). If Genette’s “open structuralism” reveals the “transtextual” logic of ancient and modern construals of “Jewish Literature,” the insights of theorists such as Julia Kristeva and Homi Bhabha suggest a move away from the ascription of fixed religious identities to texts and towards a consideration of the productive (and disruptive) effects of textuality on the formation of religious and ethnic identities.


Interpreting Domestic Space at Corinth: Problems and Prospects
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Daniel Schowalter, Carthage College

This paper critiques recent attempts to classify the architecture and other evidence for domestic space in Roman Corinth. In light of the material remains from the colonial period, how much can be ascertained, and to what extent can it be related to literary references and archaeological evidence from other contemporary urban areas? These considerations will also be used as a lens for further analysis of the structure and function of “house churches” in Paul’s community.


Monastic Parenting Practices: Children Endangered and Protected in Early Egyptian Monasteries
Program Unit: Early Christian Families
Caroline T. Schroeder, Stanford University

The Apophthegmata Patrum alphabetical collection recounts a simultaneously horrifying yet iconic story about parents and children in early Egyptian monasteries. A father who seeks to join a monastery is commanded to throw his son in the river as a requirement of admission. He is halted at the last minute, and he then abandons his son to become a monk. The story, which clearly draws on Abraham’s sacrifice of Isaac, exemplifies the extent to which one must embrace the ascetic imperative to renounce one’s biological family in order to join a new ascetic family. Yet, the story also leaves unanswered the fate of the son—this despite the evidence that early monasteries reared many children. This paper will examine the roles of children in early Egyptian monasteries based on documents from the fourth- and fifth-century communities of Pachomius and Shenoute. Although the monastery provided an alternative means of rearing children—and for some children from impoverished families a means of survival—the presence of children also posed complications. Children required protection from hazards posed by the physical labor and corporal punishment endured by adults as well as from sexual advances by other monks. Children were novices, and yet much more vulnerable than adult novices. Monastic leaders had to integrate these children who would become monks into the ways of the community — into their new ascetic families — and to accommodate their communities to the challenges posed by their presence.


The Text in its Own Right: Gerhard von Rad's Attempt at Defining “Theol-ogy of the Old Testament”
Program Unit:
Andreas Schuele, Union Theological Seminary, Richmond

*


The War Scroll, the "Kittim of Asshur", and Numbers 24:15–24
Program Unit: Qumran
Brian Schultz, Bar Ilan University

In the opening lines of the War Scroll we read that among the enemies of the Sons of Light are the “Kittim of Asshur” (1:2). This collocation, unique to the War Scroll, is particularly surprising, because in all other biblical and post-biblical literature where the Kittim and Assyria are mentioned together, they are in direct conflict one with another. This is especially true in Num 24:24, the passage from which the term “Kittim” is believed to have inherited its eschatological valence. Also intriguing is that outside of the War Texts at Qumran, the Kittim always refer to a Maritime people group of the Mediterranean world west of the land of Israel. In addition, column I of the War Scroll is structurally and thematically dependent upon Daniel 11, and uses the expression “king of the Kittim” (1:4, cf. 15:2) for Daniel’s “king of the North”. This is done in spite of the fact that in Dan 11:30, the Kittim are the ones who opposed the “king of the North”. How then is it that the author of War Scroll coined this expression when it contradicted two of his main source texts? A survey of the use of Balaam’s fourth oracle (Num 24:15-24) in Second Temple Period literature suggests that the Qumranites may have been the first to give this passage an eschatological dimension, with the War Scroll being one of the earliest attestations of this development.


Heading for Home: The Literary and Theological Functions of the Highway Image within the Book of Isaiah
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Richard Schultz, Wheaton College

Previous studies of the ‘highway’ image within Isaiah have focused either on its redactional function in linking major sections of the present book (especially O.H. Steck) or on its place within the ‘New Exodus’ theme (first discussed by A. Zillesen in 1903), often historicizing the motif as referring exclusively to the exiles’ future return from Babylon. Both of these approaches tend to focus on a few texts in which the key Hebrew words from the semantic field of ‘highway’ (müsillâ / maslûl and the related terms derek [sg.] and nütîbâ) occur to the exclusion of others. In this paper, all of the passages containing the highway image will be analyzed and categorized, giving primary attention to 11:16, 19:23, 35:8, 40:3, 42:16, 43:16 + 19, 49:11, 57:14, and 62:10, in an attempt to determine its distribution and literary function within the book of Isaiah (e.g., in passages that either open or conclude major units within the book), as well as its theological significance (i.e., as describing not simply the Israelites’ return to the land but rather their return to Yahweh).


Lying Down with the Lamb: Michael Riffaterre, Intertextual Theory, and Preaching Isaiah 65:17–25 Polyphonically
Program Unit: Homiletics and Biblical Studies
Richard Schultz, Wheaton College

For nearly three decades, intertextual theory, as initially developed by Bakhtin and Kristeva, has been applied to the analysis of biblical texts. This theory typically leads to the conclusion that the “tracing out of intertextual relations is endless and, quite literally, pointless” (T.K. Beal). Such a theory would appear to have little usefulness in homiletical approaches to a biblical text in which clarity and brevity of communication are highly valued. However, intertextual theory as developed by the French literary scholar Michael Riffaterre suggests a way forward. In this paper, Riffaterre’s intertextual theory will be explained briefly, including his insistence upon both an “initial, linear 'learning' reading, and [a] subsequent, retroactive hermeneutic reading" (Worton and Still). Riffaterre’s potential contribution to homiletical practice will then be illustrated using Isaiah 65:17-25. Gen 1, Lev 26 and Deut 28, Isa 11, 2 Pet 3, and Rev 21 will be noted as illuminating intertexts, in addition to the Sumerian Dilmun myth and modern Utopian conceptions, including the American Quaker Edward Hicks’ paintings, each helping to enrich a sermonic treatment of Isa 65:17-25.


Ezekiel, P, and the Other Pentateuchal Sources
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
Baruch J. Schwartz, Hebrew University, Jerusalem

Ezekiel's familiarity with the priestly source is textual; he shows awareness of P in its written form--the Holiness legislation as well as earlier P; narrative as well as law. As for the other Pentateuchal sources, including D, Ezekiel exhibits no literary knowledge of them.


The Priestly Narrative of Israel's Descent into Egypt
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Baruch J. Schwartz, Hebrew University, Jerusalem

Scholars have long been troubled by what appear to be glaring gaps in P at the end of Genesis. Many have viewed this as evidence that P was never an independent and complete literary source but is in fact a redactional stratum, created in order to be superimposed on the non-priestly narrative. Their opponents have pointed out that the absence of a Joseph saga analogous to that found in non-P does not necessarily lead to this conclusion. In this lecture, I shall propose further methodological arguments, along with a few text-critical, source-critical and exegetical refinements in the analysis of this portion of P, in an attempt to respond to the claim (voiced most recently by John Van Seters) that the meager P material in Gen 37–Exod 1 cannot be read as part of an independent literary work, and to assert that here, as elsewhere, P indeed told a full and coherent story—but one that differed from that told by the other sources.


From "Jews" to "Judaeans" and the Period That Just Wouldn't Fit In: Heinrich Graetz on the Second Temple Period
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Daniel S. Schwartz, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem

Anyone who notices that Graetz's 11-part Geschichte der Juden divides all of Jewish history into a "first" period (until 160 BCE) and a "third" period (from 70 CE to the eighteenth century) but never terms the centuries in between -- the Second Temple period -- the "second" period; that between the 1863 and 1878 editions of the volume on that period he changed all the "Juden" into "Judäer"; that his introduction to the period waffles as to whether it is one of religious or political history; and that he left this introduction out beginning with the fourth edition, realizes that Graetz had his difficulties with this period, although he loved it. Understanding Graetz's considerations and difficulties, on the background of the birth of neutestamentliche Zeitgeschichte, of Jewish polemics about Josephus, of institutionalized anti-Semitism in Germany, and of Graetz's extended visit in Palestine in 1872, will help us understand the genesis of views which were long to remain fundamental for the study of Jews and Judaism in the Graeco-Roman period.


Can We Learn about Community Rituals from Narratives? Acts 2-5 as a Test Case
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Jonathan D. Schwiebert, Washington University

Ritual practices are part of the fabric of many ancient Mediterranean narratives, whether they derive from 'pagan,' Jewish, or early Christian contexts. Scholars working on early Christian narratives tend to assume either that these ritual practices are simply what was done or - conversely - that these ritual practices have little if any light to shed on the interpretation and persuasive function of these narratives. Taking Acts 2-5 as a test case, this paper examines the ritual practices woven into this narrative. How might these rituals interact with actual early Christian experience, to what extent are they idealized, and how might they represent an effort to speak to (rather than record) ritual practices "on the ground" in the intended audience of the text? By raising such questions as sharply as possible, we hope to initiate a dialogue about this interpretive problem in the study of such early Christian narratives.


The Common Worldview of Egypt and Mesopotamia
Program Unit: Egyptology and Ancient Israel
Steven Scott, University of Ottawa

In this presentation, I argue that though Egypt and Mesopotamia had very different mythologies, they had the same worldview. By examining the texts of Egypt and Mesopotamia, I argue that there are seven key points of similarity in the basic way of how both the Egyptians and Mesopotamians understood the world was created and maintained. They are as follows: 1) In the beginning there was watery chaos. 2) Within this chaos the creator God emerged and overcomes chaos in combat. 3) Creation comes about through the Command and Wisdom of the creator God. 4) Creation was seen as Order, Truth, Justice and Righteousness imposed on chaos. 5) This Order was seen as light. 6) Creation had to be maintained and supported against chaos. 7) There was an understood covenant between the gods and humans in regards to maintaining the order of creation. Understanding this common worldview provides valuable insight as it provides the foundation of how they understood the world around them. Understanding the ANE Worldview provides a theological understanding that makes comprehension of concepts such as Truth, Righteousness, Justice, Faith, and Wisdom in the ANE clearer and more precise. This holds true not only for Egypt and Mesopotamia, but for Israel, and by extension, Early Christianity. The presentation will not only outline the worldview from the primary sources from Egypt and Mesopotamia, but will also briefly explain how it makes the Hebrew understanding of Faith and the Day of the Lord clearer. I would like to have the full paper available (through me via email) for those interested to allow for a better critical response to the presentation.


Marduk and His Enemies: City Rivalries in Southern Mesopotamia
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Joann Scurlock, Elmhurst College

As the Babylonian Creation Epic tells us, the rise of the god Marduk to the head of the pantheon was the result of a unanimous, if somewhat drunken, decision on the part of the assembly of the gods. However, Neo-Assyrian commentaries to the Babylonian New Year’s Festival paint a far less rosy picture, indicating that Marduk became king of the gods by defeating and burning, flaying or dismembering his rival gods Anu, Enlil and Ea. This impression is confirmed by the surviving instructions for this festival from Seleucid Babylon. As might be guessed, these battles of gods were reflected in enmity between the cities that served as their seats and, indeed, if undying support for Marduk and Babylon is a sign of Babylonian patriotism, then Anu’s Uruk and Enlil’s Nippur were no patriots. Marduk, for his part, treated the divinites of Babylonian cities which dared to rival Babylon in characteristic bullying fashion. But, as we shall see, it is Anu of Uruk who may have had the last laugh.


The Disputed Pauline Traditions and the Quest for the Historical Paul
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Robert Paul Seesengood, Drew University

Given the contextual quality of most of his writings, reconstruction of the "historical Paul," though rarely described in such terms, certainly occupies a central role in Pauline scholarship. As scholars, we inquire into Paul's underlying, "coherent" theology, Paul's Jewishness, Paul's "Romanness," Paul's hybridity and Paul's fundamental personality. Much like modern attempts to reconstruct the historical Jesus, scholarship has not only failed to produce a singular image of Paul, but even failed to identify a singular methodology. Also, reconstructed images of Paul (and his polemic) often reveal more about the interpreter's location than Paul's. Unlike quests for the historical Jesus, however, in Pauline studies we do not have texts primarily about Paul, but texts arising (or purporting to arise) from Paul. Further, unlike Jesus research, which tends to produce historical "Jesuses" who differ primarily in emphasis but not openly incompatible (Jesus the philosopher, the healer, the political rebel, the Torah sage), reconstructed images of Paul are often wildly divergent (Paul the anti-Semite, the good Jew, the homophobe, the closeted gay, the misogynist, the egalitarian, the convert from Judaism, the Roman, the Pharisee). Further, Pauline pseudepigrapha and later traditions obviously present unique problems. This paper will explore these issues, concentrating on how scholarship, itself, complicates the question. I will compare and contrast the alternate strategies and scholarship behind historical Jesus research and Pauline coherence, noting how data from disputed Paulines both complicates the process and offers a glimpse into the first "quest for the historical Paul."


Matthew 17:1–8, 28:1–10, and 16-17
Program Unit: New Testament Mysticism Project
Alan Segal, Barnard College, Columbia University

A commentary on Matthew 17:1-8 and 28:1-10, 16-17 will be presented.


The Resurrected Body in Luke-Acts
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Turid Karlsen Seim, University of Oslo

In the Lukan appearance stories the continued physicality of the risen Jesus is emphasized. He may appear and depart in wondrous ways, but he is recognisable, he proves to the disciples that he is flesh and bone, and they watch him eat. Is this a portrayal of the prototypical resurrected body? In the paper I will critically examine this question by exploring other passages in Luke-Acts where the resurrected life is qualified. Here 'resurrection' interplays with ideas of immortality and also of transformation in ways that correlate eschatological and protological reflections and employ a blend of temporal and spatial categories. Several (Hellenistic) Jewish texts show similar features. Finally, in pursuing the spatial dimension I will discuss how the unique ascension story in Luke-Acts, transferring Jesus' resurrected body from earth to heaven, may involve requalification and transformation.


Possession and Inspiration: Two Neurological Modes of the Spirit
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Colleen Shantz, University of St. Michael's College

Many societies explicitly distinguish between two types of socially relevant trance practices: one which is the result of the spirit(s) possessing the individual and the other(s) resulting from the individual "mastering" the spirit(s). Furthermore, the phenomena accompanying these differing trance practices (e.g., ecstatic amnesia vs. memory retention, displacement of personality vs. persistent identity) suggest that they are the products, in part, of distinct neurological states. This paper examines the ways in which Paul's counsel to the Corinthian assembly aligns with the medical and social anthropology of trance. While much exegesis of 1 Corinthians 12-14 imagines an ecstatic and irrational practice pitted against a controlled and rational one, Paul does not make such a distinction. Instead, Paul's own distinctions coordinate quite neatly with the differences between possession trance and other forms and the distinct social roles attributed to their practitioners. Reading the situation and his advice through the lens of medical anthropology reveals a more sympathetic, and complex exchange than often imagined.


Contested Hermeneutics: Theological Reflections on the Undecideability of Micah 2:12–13
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Carolyn J. Sharp, Yale University

Micah 2:12-13 presents a complex set of interpretive problems that bear directly on the issue of the theological coherence of the book of Micah as a whole. Are the images in 2:12-13 intended to represent actions of divine deliverance or judgment? These verses have been read in a number of markedly different ways by interpreters ancient and contemporary. The majority view is that these verses constitute a straightforward oracle of deliverance. But some have interpreted the passage as an oracle of judgment, others read it as an unreliable oracle of redemption mouthed by the false prophets, and yet others discern two contrasting oracless, with verse 12 threatening judgment and verse 13 proclaiming a proleptic word of hope. I will analyze the semantic possibilities and ambiguities of Mic 2:12-13, engaging the passage as a polysemous textual locus for contested views about the construction of the prophetic voice in Micah 1-3. Affirming the minority view that 2:12-13 in fact constitute a prophecy of judgment, I will argue that the ambiguous rhetoric of Micah here performs an ironic destabilization of the implied audience's hermeneutical ability to recognize false prophecy. Finally, I consider theological implications of this reading in light of John Caputo's hermeneutical insights regarding the undecideability of texts.


In Search of Jewish and Hebrew Bible Study: A View from Within and Without
Program Unit:
Yaacov Shavit, Tel Aviv University

According to conventional wisdom, Jews were latecomers in the field of modern Biblical studies, especially those that were influenced by higher criticism. According to this view, inherent inhibitions prevent even "free-thinking" Jews from taking this 'heretic' approach to Holy Scripture. This view is consistently based on the lack of studies on the history of modern Jewish study of the Bible. But, in fact, it ignores a vast corpus of writings from the mid-19th century onward written in response to the challenges of Christian biblical study, and which at the same time tried to offer a "Jewish science of Bible". I intend to begin my paper by describing the few studies that deal with parts of the history of modern Jewish biblical study. I will primarily offer a short revised review of Jewish scholarship in Germany, and a more detailed survey of the writings of both academic and "second track" scholars in Israel since the 1920’s and their efforts to establish a "unique Hebrew biblical study," efforts which not only comprise an important part of the history of biblical studies, but also manifest the cultural and intellectual history of modern Jewish society.


Falling for Paul (Acts 20:5–12): Imitation and the Politics of Leadership
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Chris Shea, Ball State University

This curious little episode in the canonical Acts provides interesting fodder for the critic who is focusing on the interplay of Greek, Roman, and early Christian cultural values in the early Roman Empire. Here, the author of Acts seems to have imitated a Roman imitation of a Greek work and to have tooled his imitation to act as a critique of the political value systems of both the Greeks and the Romans. That Eutychus' fall from the window is based on Elpenor's fall from the roof in Odyssey 10 has been noted by others including the Ancient Narrative section's own Dennis MacDonald. But Augustan apologist Vergil has imitated Elpenor's fall as well--twice, in fact--as, again, some commentators have noted. In this paper I will argue that the author of Acts has not imitated Homer so much as Vergil, and not imitated Vergil's versions in their details so much as in their critique of the politics of Odysseus' leadership. In this the author of Acts will be laying the foundation of the "Empire of God" of the early Christian communities by reworking a piece of political propaganda central to the foundation of Augustus' empire. In my argument, I will give a nod to Tim Whitmarsh's Greek Literature and the Roman Empire: The Politics of Imitation (although he does not, in fact, discuss this passage in that work).


Competing for Congregants: John Chrysostom and the Politics of “Christian” and “Jewish” Space
Program Unit: Manichaean Studies
Tina Shepardson, University of Tennessee

In his homilies “Against the Judaizers,” John Chrysostom attempted to redefine Antioch’s religious spaces in order to dissuade “Christians” from having any attraction to “Jewish” places and practices. In the rich “religious marketplace of the fourth century,” Jewish festivals, synagogues, and scripture apparently appealed strongly to some in Antioch whom Chrysostom called Christian. In order to combat what he understood to be unacceptable (and harmful) religious intermingling, Chrysostom employed careful rhetorical strategies to redraw the city’s geography in a way that cultivated a fear of “Jewish” spaces, where robbers and “demons dwell” (1.6.6), and highlighted the safety of “Christian” spaces. In the language of geographer Yi-Fu Tuan, Chrysostom combated his audience’s desire (topophilia) and respect for the synagogue by using it instead to inspire fear (topophobia). Fourth-century Antioch was the site of significant religious and political struggles to define and control religious space: opposing Christian leaders vied for control of churches; Christians and pagans competed for space at nearby Daphne; and some Christians frequented the synagogues. In the face of the multilayered and highly politicized significance of these religious spaces, John Chrysostom attempted to regulate “Christian” boundaries by identifying these complex intersections as places of clearly positive or negative value. Examining Chrysostom’s discourses against Jews and Judaizers will demonstrate the fervor with which he attempted to attract congregants to his church and to keep them securely (and exclusively) there once they attended. In a context of intense religious competition, Chrysostom’s Christian exhortations struggled to define and control religious space, patrolling the boundaries of Christian orthodoxy by identifying where in Antioch “orthodox” Christians should and could not go.


Twilight of the Idols: Genesis 31 in Postexilic Yehud
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Phillip Michael Sherman, Emory University

The brief account of Rachel’s theft of her father Laban’s teraphim (Gen 31:19f.) raises a large number of interpretive issues. Among these are the nature and function of the teraphim, the ambiguous characterization of Rachel and her theft and the nature of patriarchal (in this case, matriarchal) religious practice. The marked lack of overt justification (or even explanation) for the theft of the teraphim has always been a narrative problem—and very often a theological one as well. While briefly touching on all of these traditional issues, the focus of this work will be strongly redactional in nature. A correct understanding of the teraphim and the motivation for Rachel’s theft will not be sought in etymological theories or in the adducing of ancient Near Eastern parallels, but rather in the narrative role the objects play in a specific literary, social and historical context.


The Torah in Negative Frames of Reference? ‘The Abolishing of the Law’ in Ephesians 2:15
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
Minna Shkul, University of Sheffield

This paper will evaluate the way the Torah is framed within the discourse of Ephesians and what bearing this has on emerging Christianity reflected in the text. The paper assesses if the discourse can be labelled as a representative of “Jewish Christianity” or whether it resists such categorisation. Ephesians’ selective representation of Jewishness and meanings drawn from the Christ-event are the key components of an ideological foundation, on which theological principles, societal values and constructions of identity are positioned. The innovative Christ-centred ethos provides paradigms for the way Israelite heritage and socio-cultural expressions of Jewishness are viewed and represented. The observance of the law is associated with a group labelled as ‘the circumcised’ whom the writer observes within a discourse of ethnic conflict concerning membership in the people of God and the terms of belonging (2.11-22). The analysis proceeds by a critical assessment of the author's renegotiation of Jewish heritage and the resulting socio-religious positionings of ‘Israel’ and the ‘Torah’ in the text. The paper will consider textual creation of ‘Israel’ that serves the ideological purposes of the letter, as well as means of distancing the discourse from societal conflicts and unwanted social counterparts. The paper will also discuss the ambiguity within the text that causes a reader to connect its gaps and process its meaning and what bearing this has on conceptualisation of categories of Jewish Christianities and Ephesians. Finally, the social implications of communal values and religious orientations of the text will be considered in order to understand what impact such seemingly critical Torah discourse has on intercommunal relations and how this might have constituted Torah-intolerant Christianness.


Tandem Speech in the Poetry of Prophetic Discourse
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Kenneth W. Shoemaker, Canadian Theological Seminary

Often in the poetry of prophetic discourse there appears to be a random mixture of divine and prophetic speakers. Closer analysis, however, may reveal the patterns of “tandem speech:” the deliberate pairing of divine speech with prophetic speech which together present a discourse unit on a single topic. These cooperative speeches may occur within the same strophe, or they may be sequential strophes. The difficulties of recognizing and delimiting speaker boundaries in “tandem speech” verse can be reduced in part through attention to three connective devices embedded in the poetry: (1) the epexegetical waw; (2) scene-setting; and (3) repetitions, or catchwords.


What’s Wrong with Politics? A Reexamination of the Meaning and Message of Hosea 5:8–6:6
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Avi Shveka, Hebrew University of Jerusalem

Since Alt’s work of 1919 it is commonly held that the prophetic unit Hosea 5:8-6:6 refers to a war between Israel and Judah, a war that historically took place during the period of Pekah and Ahaz (“the Syro-Ephraimite war”). According to this view, the main theme of this prophecy is to condemn both nations for the mutual hostility between them. The aim of this paper is to reexamine this opinion. As will be shown, the proofs that Alt presents for his theory – which are found only in the beginning of the prophecy (5:8-10) – must be rejected, since, on a purely exegetical basis, his interpretation to vs. 8-10 cannot stand. Consequently, there is no reason to interpret the rest of the prophecy as relating to a war between Israel and Judah, as is commonly done without real basis in the text. It is not the issue of the relationships between the two nations that occupies Hosea’s thought, but rather the relationship between each of them and God. The sin of both kingdoms is that they run a “normal”, down to earth, foreign policy, not recognizing that whatever happens to them is the result of God’s actions and that their fate is solely in his hands. Unlike other prophets, who usually criticized the policy taken by the rulers in order to suggest a different one, Hosea seems to have objected to politics as such. The return to God was not, in his eyes, an imperative condition to success in policy; it was itself the only legitimate policy.


Paul's kopos kai mochthos: Working Hands and Apostolic Identity
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Catherine Sider Hamilton, Wycliffe College, Toronto School of Theology

As an apostle, Paul insists on working with his hands. Manual labor and gospel proclamation together constitute the ministry that he describes, to the Thessalonians, as kopos kai mochthos: toil and trouble, labor and pain. Paul stands, in the Christian tradition, as a figure of authority and stature. Biographies of Paul suggest that his social standing and apostolic authority in his own day mirrored his prestige in ours. Paul’s claim to manual labor, however, throws this picture into confusion. Manual labor, and the laborer, were despised in Paul’s world: to be a ditch-digger, or an artisan, was to be not powerful but weak, of low status and low repute, more beast than thinker, more slave than leader. Scholars who take note of Paul’s manual labor and its attendant hardships and humiliations nonetheless see in it the sign of the philosopher and sage – the sign of a certain power. In the tradition of Simon the Shoemaker (and Socrates), Paul uses his workshop to teach (R.F. Hock) or, in the manner of the Stoics, treats his hardships as a proof of virtue (J.T. Fitzgerald) or again, Paul’s trial-by-labor imitates the heroic Hercules, model for the Cynics (F.G. Downing). This paper argues that Paul’s labor is indeed key to his apostolic identity. But the real scorn with which the first-century world regarded the laborer, and the menial nature of work labeled kopos in Greco-Roman literature, undercuts the virtuous narrative found by scholars in Paul’s working hands. In his working apostleship, Paul discovers a tale not of the conquering hero or the sage, but of the suffering slave. He is, by his own description, weak: precisely as such a one, Paul proclaims the crucified Christ.


Sinai 1 and Sinai 2: Their Contents and Significance
Program Unit:
Father Justin Sinaites, St. Catherine’s Monastery

The photography of the Sinai manuscripts with a high resolution digital camera allows them to be studied in detail. Sinai Greek 1, dated to the tenth-eleventh century, contains the text of Genesis to IV Kings. Sinai Greek 2, dated to the eleventh-twelfth century, contains the text of Genesis, Exodus, and Leviticus. The scribe has left generous margins, and added commentary in a minute script. An examination of the scholia that accompany the third chapter of Exodus, drawn from the writings of Philo, Cyril of Alexandria, Eusebius of Emesa, and Theodoret of Cyrus, allows insights into the significance of this text.


Conception, Birth, and Earth’s Voice: Job 10 and Psalm 139
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Alice M. Sinnott, University of Auckland

Emanating from Job 10 and Psalm 139 are human voices vigorously contending that their conception and birth were the work of God. Both claim that their personal creation reflects an unconditional commitment by God to preserve and uphold them; that God’s creation of the individual is the mark of a divine pledge of sustenance and protection. Personal creation is a life and loyalty agreement by which God becomes bound to a particular life ensuring that the individual flourishes. Conception is a giving of “life and loyalty” (Job 10:12). This paper argues that, as the above texts propose, the conception of human life is a covenantal undertaking by God, the same may be said of the earth and all the Creator brings into being. When Job 10 initiates a discourse on Job personal conception and birth with the startling declaration “I loathe my life,” he has reached a point where he wishes he had not survived his birth. His reflection on his creation as a human being, his complaints and self-loathing (10:3-13, 18-19) parody the praise and wonder expressed by the speaker in Psalm 139. For both, creation in the womb constitutes an act of divine commitment, a guarantee to protect the individual throughout life. Both praise the intricate beauty and complexity of their physical bodies as designed by the Creator. Both acknowledge how they were conceived and nurtured in the womb, the place of creation and sustenance. Job’s plea, “remember that you fashioned me like clay; and will you turn me to dust again?” (v. 9) reminds the Creator of the intimate relationship initiated by the Creator at his conception and throughout his development, and seeks to persuade God that there is a divine responsibility to all creation.


Wisdom and Apocalyptic Discourse in Q
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Russell B. Sisson, Union College

One of the difficulties we have found emerging again and again in our conversations is the relationship of a rhetorolect to a literary genre, particularly when the terminology overlaps so much (particularly in regard to wisdom, apocalyptic, and prophetic discourse). By focusing on "wisdom discourse" and the blend of discourses that constitute passages of "wisdom literature," we will potentially clarify the difference between the rhetorical category and literary genre and help the group and other interested parties escape the assumption that "wisdom literature" de facto provides the context of "wisdom discourse." This paper explores the blending of wisdom discourse and apocalyptic discourse in the sayings source Q; the results of the study may have import for the tendency to separate Q into layers of tradition (i.e., a "wisdom" layer that is later overlaid with "apocalyptic" discourse), suggesting that these two streams of tradition were already woven together in the composition of Q.


Wisdom of Solomon and Plato's Symposium
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Russell B. Sisson, Union College

This paper pursues a comparative analysis of Wisdom of Solomon 7-9 in relation to wisdom discourse in Plato's Symposium, with a view to exploring what this comparison might reveal about wisdom topics and the social situations supporting them.


Losing the Things We Do Not Have: Interpreting the Parable(s) of the Talents and Pounds
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Douglas Sivers, Drew University

Parables are often today interpreted primarily in terms of their meaning in their original social contexts. However, even when there is agreement about the general nature of that social context, commentators still produce a multiplicity of plausible, yet mutually exclusive, interpretations. What is the significance of this fact for the interpretation of parables in general? To address this question, we focus specifically on the Parable of the Pounds, in Luke’s Gospel (19:12-27), and the Parable of the Talents, in Matthew’s Gospel (Mt. 25:14-30) as a story; further, we focus on the presentation of the characters of the story, as a way of focusing on a multiply attested narrative. In so doing, we will find that this story presents at least two major problems for interpreters in any context. First, the master appears to suggest that the last servant, who hid the entrusted money, should have broken Torah; but in such parables, such a figure always seems to be standing in for God. Second, the parable includes an independently circulating logion of Jesus; deprived of its antecedents in the parable, the logion becomes an unanswerable paradox. We suggest that these two incommensurables within the story point to the impossibility of any final interpretation of the parable, and thus lead to the multiplicity of plausible interpretations which we find. What we conclude from this is that a reader’s context (for example, within an ancient or modern faith community) is an essential intepretive tool, but not finally determinative: the interpretation of this parable from within one context does not preclude the correctness of a different interpretation in another context. Therefore, we advocate for contextual readings that are brought into a perpetual dialogue with each other and the text.


A Byzantine Judaism: Towards a New Category
Program Unit: History and Literature of Early Rabbinic Judaism
Alexei Sivertsev, DePaul University

This paper will address the nature of Judaism that developed in Byzantine cultural and religious contexts in the course of late fifth through ninth centuries. Over the past several decades scholars have emphasized a number of unique characteristics that distinguished this form of Judaism from that of an earlier period. These characteristics include the rise of new ideals of religious piety (such as priestly piety, martyrdom, mysticism, and apocalyptic messianism) and the development of new pietistic and “sacramental” trends in the interpretation of halakhic regulations. Such differences between Byzantine and “classical” rabbinic Judaism of the third – fifth centuries have prompted many scholars to wonder if using the term “rabbinic” to describe Byzantine Judaism is indeed appropriate. For example Peter Schäfer has suggested the term “post-rabbinic” to characterize mystical Hekhalot texts. Others emphasized the role of priests and mystics in shaping post-fifth century Jewish traditions and religious values. My paper will attempt to summarize characteristics of post-fifth century Byzantine Judaism as they emerge from the recent scholarship on the question. It will also engage the question of similarities and differences between post-fifth century Judaism and classical rabbinic Judaism of third – fifth centuries. I will argue that Peter Schäfer’s definition clearly merits a second look as it reflects a unique combination of classical rabbinic and innovative elements in the religious culture of Byzantine Jews. I will further propose the term “Byzantine Judaism” (on analogy with "Byzantine Christianity") to distinguish the Judaism of fifth through ninth-century Byzantium from a “classical” rabbinic (or late antique) Judaism that was essentially a late Roman phenomenon. The Byzantine Judaism developed in the context of mature Byzantine Christianity and reflected the same blend of interests in individual mystical piety, apocalyptic expectations, and sacramental ecclesiology as Byzantine Christianity of the time.


Adam in Eden and Sanhedrin
Program Unit: Midrash
Willem Smelik, University College, London

In the rabbinic act of interpretation, the importance of fore-knowledge emerges from the briefness of quotation, the omission of the prooftext's focus in the quotation, and from the selection and deployment of available traditions. The traditions about the first human in Sanhedrin attributed to Rav Yehudah in the name of Rav are triggered by the claim in Misnah Sanhedrin, that the human was created alone. Whilst they are introduced by a mnemonic marker, it is not at all obvious what these four traditions are doing here, and why here, instead of somewhere else. They prompt the questions whether they belong together at some level and how they fit in with the Bavli's deployment of scriptural interpretation. The series of interpretations in Sanhedrin 38b were not a cardboard box of indexes turned upside down. The gemara weaves Mishnah, Genesis and Psalm 139 together and explores human's creation in the image and likeness of God. In the process, traditions which may or may not have had an anti-gnostic or non-Jewish origin are recycled, are transplanted from their seedbeds.


The Rhetorical Function of Refutation in Acts 6–7, 10–15
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Julien C. H. Smith, Baylor University

The rhetorical handbooks of Quintilian and Ps-Cicero, as well as the progymnasmata of Aelius Theon show that the art of refutation (anaskeue) was considered a powerful weapon in the arsenal of the ancient orator, the refinement of which was a principle aim of elementary education. Luke’s skillful use of refutation is central to his argument in Acts 6–7 and 10–15. Rhetorical analysis shows these sections to be argumentative discourse concerning the identity of the true inheritors of Israel. In chs. 6–7, the author weaves the themes of place (topos), law (nomos), and custom (ethos) into a complex reworking of scriptural tradition, in order to refute the claim that Stephen (and the messianists) were abnegating Mosaic customs and speaking against the Temple. In chs. 10–15, he crafts a progressive refutation of the view that Gentiles should not be admitted to the messianist community unless they observe the customs of Moses. Thus, the rhetorical strategy in these sections is driven by the need to legitimate both the messianist Jews in the eyes of non-messianist Jews, and the admission of Gentiles into the messianist community.


The Use of Scripture in the Epistle of Barnabas: Suppression, Legitimation, and Creation
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Julien C. H. Smith, Baylor University

During the period 70-135 C.E., the Christian movement evolved from a largely Jewish movement, to a heterogeneous Jewish-Gentile-movement, to a largely Gentile movement. What phase during this trend does Barnabas represent, and what kind of an effect does its message have upon the trend—does Barnabas function to draw Jews and Gentiles together, or push them apart? Using a methodological approach derived from the sociology of knowledge, this paper analyzes Barnabas’ use of scripture to negate basic matters of Jewish identity. By asserting that correct interpretation of scripture depends not upon a coherent method of exegesis, but rather upon one’s location within the correct interpretive community, the author is subtly laying claim to the very means by which reality is properly defined. At the symbolic level of the text, this represents the author’s attempt to suppress a competing Jewish symbolic universe, thereby legitimating the Christian symbolic universe of the audience. Yet, with the suppression of the Jewish symbolic universe, the author has created a problem, which he then must also address. If the audience (some of whom are of Jewish origin) can no longer find its ethnic identity within the Jewish symbolic universe, how will it henceforth construct its ethnic identity? Barnabas functions creatively to resolve this social tension by proposing that God has created a new ethnos in which one’s membership does not depend upon the traditional matters of Jewish identity. Barnabas, then, represents a transitional identity for the Christian community, which is well on its way to considering itself as a “third race,” as attested by later writers, such as Tertullian.


The Bible as Myth?
Program Unit: Bible, Myth, and Myth Theory
Mark S. Smith, New York University

Since the mid-1970s, myth has been affirmed as a category in the discussion of the Bible against older discussions that sought a privileged place for the Bible against ancient Near Eastern myth or for the Bible's deity over and against ancient Near Eastern deities. (The most sustained expression of this shift is Michael Fishbane's Biblical Myth and Rabbinic Mythmaking, 2003.) Some critics have noted problems with applying this term to the Bible. This presentation will note some problems, first in general terms and then as they apply to the Bible, in particular its first chapter.


Micah 1–2: On The Pleasures of Prophetic Judgment
Program Unit: Prophetic Texts and Their Ancient Contexts
Daniel Smith-Christopher, Loyola Marymount University

Using Micah, Chs. 1 and 2 as a basis for comparison to other Prophetic literature, this paper examines the tendency in some Prophetic literature to not only report on God's impending judgment, but to apparently relish in the poetic description of destruction and suffering. In an attempt to approach this study with cross-disciplinary insights, we examine helpful aspects of literary, psychological, and sociological literature of anger that may shed further light on this form of literature, which only grows more colorful (emotional?) in the rise of early Proto-Apocalyptic Literature (Zechariah) and Apocalyptic texts such as Enoch.


"You Will Build a House but Not Dwell in It, You Will Plant a Vineyard but Not Drink Its Wine": Siege Warfare Imagery and the History of a Biblical Curse
Program Unit: Warfare in Ancient Israel
Jeremy Smoak, University of California, Los Angeles

Images of building and planting hold a profound significance in the discourse of biblical literature. One of the more notable biblical expressions of building and planting imagery occurs in the form of a wartime curse, which threatens the desertion of homes and the devastation of agriculture. The classic formulation of the curse appears in Deuteronomy 28:30, which states: You will build a house, but you will not live in it. You will plant a vineyard, but you will not harvest its fruit.” This particular curse occupies an especially prominent role in biblical discourse concerning warfare and its consequences, as indicated by the extensive attention that it receives in biblical literature (see Amos 5:11, 9:14; Zeph 1:13; Jer 6:2, 29:5, 31:4; Deut 20:5-6; Isa 65:21; Ezek 28:26). Scholars have long noted that the threat of war forms the obvious background of the curse. Neo-Assyrian iconographic and textual sources, however, provide a more specific background against which to understand the origin and persistent importance of this curse in the Hebrew Bible. These sources suggest that the prominence of the curse can be traced to specific military tactics associated with siege warfare, such as mass deportation and the destruction of subsistence systems, which left an indelible imprint upon biblical memory. A survey of the earliest inner-biblical discourse of the curse highlights the impact that these military tactics had upon ancient Israelite and Judean societies during the eighth-seventh centuries BCE.


Building Houses and Planting Vineyards: The Early Inner-biblical Discourse of an Ancient Israelite Wartime Curse
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Jeremy Smoak, University of California, Los Angeles

Notions of building and planting hold a profound significance in the discourse of biblical literature. One of the primary indications of this is the inner-biblical discourse of a wartime curse, which threatens Israel in the following words, “You will build a house, but you will not live in it. You will plant a vineyard, but you will not harvest its fruit.” This particular formulation of the curse occurs in Deuteronomy 28:30 among a litany of curses encouraging compliance with the laws of the previous chapters (12-26). Unlike most of the curses in Deuteronomy 28, however, this particular curse also appears in a number of prophetic texts, which reapply and reformulate it for new historical circumstances (Am 5:11; 9:14; Zeph 1:13; Jer 29:5,28; 31:4; Isa 65:21; Ezek 28:26). A survey of these texts reveals that this particular curse held an especially enduring significance in the discourse of ancient Israel. The following study traces the early inner-biblical discourse of the curse in several prophetic texts by relating its different formulations to various historical processes during the pre-exilic period. Placement of the literary history of the curse against certain historical moments allows one to see the ways in which various historical processes influenced its different biblical formulations. A study of the historical motivations behind the different formulations of the curse also points to its attractiveness as a motif in the discourse of biblical literature.


The Priestly Son of Man in Mark
Program Unit: Poster Session
Rob Snow, University of Manchester

A priestly understanding of Mark's Son of Man, based on his priestly status in Daniel 7, contributes to explaining why Jesus as the SM not only atones for the sins of Israel through his death (which renders the cultic system of the existing Temple futile) (10:45) but also establishes a new temple, not made with hands, when the priestly SM comes in/with the clouds (13:26; 14:62; cf. 8:38), which is reminiscent of his coming to the heavenly Temple in Daniel 7:13. Consequently, Mark's SM is almost consistently rejected by the Temple leadership (8:31; 9:31; 10:33-34). The priestly status of Mark's SM is programmatically evident in the first appearance of the SM which prefigures the futility of the current cultic structure and highlights the SM's cultic authority as one who has "authority" to forgive sins on earth (2:10). The SM's act of offering forgiveness is not unlike the sanctuary priests who could forgive the sins of Israel (Leviticus 10:17). I realize I am a day late but hopefully you could still accept this as it constitues the thesis of my Ph.D. dissertation which I will be submitting in December 2006.


Isaiah 63:7–64:12: A Psalm of Intercession
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
LeAnn Snow Flesher, American Baptist Seminary of the West

In this Psalm of Intercession the prophet has woven together penitential prayer and lament. The prophet’s penance for the people has become a rhetorical device that has been combined with other poetic elements typical to the lament to build to the petition for deliverance. This complex prayer contains a unique rhetoric, in that the people’s continued propensity for sin is attributed to God’s hidden ness. Thus, the prayer for deliverance begins with a petition that God would reveal God’s self in power as in the days of old. The entire prayer stands as the prelude to the apocalyptic hope for God’s deliverance through the creation of new heavens and a new earth as found in the poetry of Isaiah 65:17. Consequently, this paper will provide a study of the poetic intersection of penitential prayer, lament and the development of the apocalyptic hope.


Third Corinthians: An Orthodox Production of Scripture
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Glenn E. Snyder, Harvard University

Third Corinthians is a pseudepigraphic epistolary correspondence between Paul and the Corinthians dating from the mid- to late second century C.E. Theologically, 3 Corinthians includes the kind of vocabulary and topics attested by “apostolic fathers” like Ignatius and Polycarp. Indeed, from a theological perspective, the text may be understood as reworking 1 Corinthians 15 in order to provide an anti-docetic argument for the resurrection of the flesh. However, the text is more than a theological treatise. For scholars who have studied 3 Corinthians, the text is also understood to represent several communities: a community represented by “the Corinthians,” a community represented by “Paul,” and a community represented by the “opponents” whose teachings are described the Corinthians and denied by Paul. While this is an interesting way to read the text, I propose that there is a better way to read it: namely, as a pseudepigraphic whole representing just one opinion. When the text is read thusly, it is possible to discern that 3 Corinthians sets forth a heresiological ideology in which Paul is both exalted as apostolic authority and yet subordinated to general apostolic tradition. How does it do so? First, 3 Corinthians uses the heresiological trope of Simon and Cleobius as originators of false teachings. Second, it establishes their teachings as antitheses to apostolic tradition. And third, it does so through a narrative in which the Corinthians ask Paul, while he is still in the flesh, to help them evaluate recent teachings, and Paul responds by telling them simply to remember what he had received from those who were apostles before him. Thus, in 3 Corinthians Paul is portrayed as part--just one part--of the true apostolic tradition.


Paul and the Jew: Gentile Dichotomy
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Glenn E. Snyder, Harvard University

The New Perspective on Paul has done well to deconstruct some of the categories that have been applied to Pauline studies, especially the “rejection-replacement” view that Paul converted from Judaism to Christianity and then repudiated his former religion (Gager). Despite this advance in scholarship, we continue to reinscribe the dichotomy of “Jews” vs. “Gentiles”--a rather ideological translation of hoi Ioudaioi and ta ethne. Thankfully, we are beginning to admit that sometimes “Judeans” is a better rendering of Ioudaioi. But we regularly maintain the converse: that ta ethne are non-Ioudaioi, in an ethnic or cultural sense. For Paul, was this so? What I propose is to re-survey Paul’s use of the terms Ioudaioi and ethne, starting with the latter. To begin, I will consider the use of ethne in broader Hellenistic-Roman literature; and then, I will consider its use in Paul’s intertexts (“sources”). With those two contexts in mind, I will argue that Paul’s own uses often assume a geopolitical meaning of ethne, such that ethne refers to the nations in general or to nations outside of Israel (then-Judea). Next, I will analyze Paul’s use of Ioudaioi. Here I will argue that, for Paul, the counterpart to ta ethne is not hoi Ioudaioi, but rather is Israel. In fact, I will argue that Paul’s ideology--and self-understanding--is broadly Israelite, not “Jewish.” Implications for the term Ioudaioi are that, when contrasted with Hellenes, it has primarily a cultural sense; otherwise, it has a geopolitical or rather particular ethnic sense. For these reasons, it is time to re-map our understanding of Paul as apostolos tois ethnesin. Paul was not an “apostle to the Gentiles”; he was an ambassador to the nations--including the Ioudaioi and other Israelites in diaspora.


Collective Memory as a Hermeneutical Framework: A Partialized Reading of Ezra-Nehemiah
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Gerrie Snyman, University of South Africa

A collective memory is a recollection of the past that is determined and shaped by the group. It is partial (some memories have greater resonance than others) and material (it is expressed by narratives and embodied in individuals or objects). One particular collective memory in South Africa is the theological justification of apartheid. The collective memories of the victims of apartheid have drawn attention to the issue of subjectivity, urging the perpetrators to take stock of their own reading practices. Ezra’s sending away of the strange women and children and Nehemiah’s separation of the people from strangers echo the apartheid regime’s policy of separate development. National identity became confused with religious identity. In the light of this collective memory, i.e. what the enforcement of the Prohibition of Mixed Marriage Act of 1949 and the Immorality Act of 1950 did to communities and families, Ezra and Nehemiah’s actions seem utterly reprehensible. For the past perpetrating community, the victims’ collective memory queries the authenticity of Ezra and Nehemiah’s leadership. In the process, the moral vision of the biblical text is questioned, rendering the authority of the biblical text difficult to assess. This paper intends to elucidate the role of collective memory as a hermeneutical framework for a bible-reading community struggling to come to terms with its perpetrator legacy and seeking to participate in constructing a new social order guided by a human rights framework. It asks the following question: In what way does an apartheid collective memory allow a perpetrator community to employ Ezra and Nehemiah in his or her own everyday reconstruction of society? The following aspects will be discussed: the nature of collective memory, opposing memories of victim and perpetrator, theologies of (re)construction and an ideological reading of Ezra and Nehemiah.


Cultic Discontinuity in Roman Corinth: The Sanctuary of Demeter and Kore on Acrocorinth
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Barbette Stanley Spaeth, College of William and Mary

This paper examines cultic continuity in Corinth from its destruction by the Romans in 146 B.C.E. to the establishment of the Roman colony in 44 B.C.E. and its subsequent development. Scholarly consensus holds that the Roman colonists revived some of the Greek cults in the colony's early years. This consensus is based on two ideas: the major divinities of the Greek period were also important in the Roman colony, and some of the cult sites of the Greek period, such as the Sanctuary of Demeter and Kore on Acrocorinth, were rededicated to the same divinities by the Romans. Two problematic assumption underlie this interpretation: Roman gods with Greek “equivalents” are the same as the Greek gods, and Roman cults are equivalent to Greek ones. I will argue that if one wishes to argue for cultic revival at certain sites in Roman Corinth, one needs to show that the same rituals and cultic connections were present at these sites in the Roman as in the Greek period. If, however, significant differences existed, then one should suspect that the cults were Roman. I will illustrate this contention by re-examining the evidence for the cult at the Sanctuary of Demeter and Kore. I will first summarize the evidence for the Sanctuary in the Greek period and then show how the evidence from the Roman period indicates a change in ritual and hence in cult. I will propose that the new Roman cult was that of Ceres, Liber, and Libera and show how the characteristics of this cult can help to explain the changes made in the Sanctuary under the Romans.


Israelite Ethnicity in the Light of Ancient Jordan
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Kenton Sparks, Eastern University

According to modern archaeologists, the ancient Israelites were very similar culturally to their neighbors in Ammon, Moab, and Edom. This is one of those unusual cases where modern and ancient perceptions concur, for the Israelites certainly recognized their ethnic proximity to the peoples in ancient Jordan. This paper will explore the similarities and alterities in this dialectic of perception, giving attention to the way that Israel viewed Ammon, Moab, and Edom and also to the way that they viewed Israel. I will then draw out some of the implications of the discussion for the origins of these ancient peoples.


Lest We Forget: The Utilization of Memory and Identity in Second Temple Jewish Festivals
Program Unit: Mapping Memory: Tradition, Texts, and Identity
Mary Spaulding, University of Manchester/Nazarene Theological College

Social memory theory examines corporate recollections of the past that influence a group’s identity, authority structures, cultural norms and social interaction. Annual commemorations provide a community with powerful mnemonic practices that cement identity into the cultural memory of a group through calendrically observed verbal and gestural repetitions. Though memory theory studies have flourished in other venues, this theory has only recently begun to be applied to biblical studies. I will utilize memory theory to analyze Jewish festivals during the Second Temple Period. These festivals furnished a platform for the propagation of the exodus/exile narratives as well as a periodic point of unification in cultural identification among the many diverse “Judaisms” of the time. Two festivals will provide examples of cultural identity formation and transmission, that of the Pesach (Passover) festival and the Hanukkah (Dedication) festival. Memory associations will be analyzed as well as the transmission of festival elements over time. Because periods of crisis and trauma are also necessarily times of abrupt change in group identity and cultural awareness, particular attention will be given to the destruction of the temple in 70 CE. Discontinuity and continuity aspects of the two festivals during and after this traumatic period will be studied to determine how those in leadership attempted to cope with the crisis in collective identification during this time of profound cultural change.


The Greek Dionysiac Thiasoi of Thessalonika and Iobacchi of Athens: A Comparison
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Richard Albert Spencer, Appalachian State University

By means of careful analysis of the 3rd century C.E. inscription IG10.2.1.260 ("The Testament of the [Dionysiac] Priestess of Thessalonika") and the late second century C.E. statutes of the Iobacchi of Athens, I shall engage in an assessment of the cultural and religious cross-fertilization of the two local groups. The requirements of members, the officers, rituals and prescribed duties indicated in the primary texts of each group appear to reveal a mixture of the Latin festivals for the dead (Rosalia and Parentalia) and the Dionysiac belief in immortality. The large Roman and considerable Jewish population of Thessalonika, interacting with the surrounding populations in Macedonia and traders from throughout the Mediterranean made the city rich in cultural, sociologial and religious diversity. This study assesses that diversity on the basis of primary texts and concrete socio-religious practices.


Neither Grandmother nor Mother Was a Widow: Reflections on Pastoral Epistles from a Caribbean Perspective
Program Unit: African-American Biblical Hermeneutics
Althea Spencer-Miller, Claremont Graduate University

*


Oral Subjectivity Theory: Impact on Interpretation of Biblical Myth
Program Unit: Bible, Myth, and Myth Theory
Althea Spencer-Miller, Claremont Graduate University

In the books, "The Homeric Epics and the Gospel of Mark," and "Does the New Testament Imitate Homer? Four Cases from the Acts of the Apostles," Dennis MacDonald explores the use of rhetorical mimesis in the composition of biblical pericopesto produce transvaluations in the hypertext that have cultural implications. His commentary on these implications is sporadic and brief. The Christian scriptures are community texts so the reception of transvaluation as cultural issue is important. Acts 8-10 has identifiable Homeric styled mythemes. While it is true that the educated ancient reader would recognise these allusions and the hypotext it is a less plausible hypothesis that the receiving communities were predominantly educated communities. Yet the efficacy of transvaluation within these communities must be accounted for. I propose that literacy and orality produce two different subjectivities. Further the folkloric nature of oral subjectivity contains an a priori disposition toward oral intertextuality that contains its own hypo/hypertext dynamic. The work of myth theorists such as Wendy Doniger have blurred the generic distinctions between folklore and myth thus making the folkloric approach more amenable to mythic literature. Moreover literary (hence biblical) mythology is arguably a misplaced orality. Replacing myth and mythemes within their natural environment of oral subjectivity allows access to analysis through oral subjectivity and its intertextual behaviour. This replacement allows us to see the ground of transvaluation in oral subjective intertextuality and can help to account for the success of transvaluating migratory mythemes in community received literature thus broadening the scope for understanding reception history and the social function of myth in the biblical texts. Subsidiary implications of this approach include reflections on the limits of empirical approaches to history and devising new considerations of the ontology of literary texts.


Tuna Redivivus: Dried Fish Returned to Life in Herodotus, the Alexander Romance, and the Acts of Peter
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Janet Elizabeth Spittler, University of Chicago

In the Acts of Peter 13, the apostle Peter, having been asked by the crowds at Rome to show them a sign, takes a dried fish from a nearby window, prays to Jesus, then tosses the fish into a pool; the fish returns to life, swims around, and eats the bread tossed to it by the amazed crowd, many of whom immediately come to believe in the Lord. While this episode seems particularly suited to a Christian context (inasmuch as it plays on themes of resurrection, the fish as symbol for Christ and/or Christians, and Peter as “fisher of men”), there are at least two close parallels in non-Christian texts. In Herodotus’ Histories book nine, the hero Protesilaos causes dried fish to return to life as a sign to the doomed Persian Artauctes. In the Alexander Romance, a dried fish returns to life when washed in a river of immortality at the ends of the earth. This paper analyzes the Acts of Peter 13 in light of these and other parallels, drawn from Plutarch, Athenaeus, and ancient natural history sources.


Why Can't "The One Who Does These Things Live by Them?" Paul's Use of Leviticus 18:5 in Galatians 3:12
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Preston Sprinkle, Aberdeen University

Galatians 3.10-14 has proved to be one of the most difficult passages in Paul. The problem lies with Paul’s enigmatic use of Scripture, especially Leviticus 18.5 which Paul cites without further comment. This paper will examine this citation in Galatians 3.12 while giving attention to Paul’s broader argument in 3.10-14. I will argue that Paul cites this text negatively (despite some recent proposals) and does so in order show that the Old Covenant Law is in essence a conditional offer of life; an offer that has been a proven failure (cf. Gal 3.21). In order to support this, I will briefly examine some early Jewish uses of the Leviticus passage which provide the availability of this understanding.


Does the Covenant Collection Have a Fallow Law? Clarifying the Grammatical and Lexical Ambiguity in Exodus 23:10–11
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Jeffrey R. Stackert, Brandeis University

Though its imagined application continues to engender debate, a strong consensus exists regarding the basic meaning of Exodus 23:10-11: these verses command the Israelite farmer to fallow his land in the seventh year, allowing the poor and the animals to eat its aftergrowth. However, while such an interpretation emerges clearly from the LXX’s rendering of this law and can be construed by harmonizing the Covenant Collection and Holiness Legislation seventh-year laws, lexical and grammatical ambiguities in the MT of Exodus 23:10-11 cloud its meaning. Through a close reading of these verses and by recourse to comparative evidence, this paper offers a new and more plausible interpretation of Exodus 23:10-11—one that clarifies this law and sheds important light upon its literary heirs. To preview its conclusions, this study contends that the LXX translator and the Holiness author understood Exodus 23:10-11 differently. LXX understood these verses to command a seventh-year fallow. In so doing, the translator approximated his Hebrew Vorlage and created a text that, while internally consistent, misconstrues Exodus 23:10-11. The author of Leviticus 25:2-7, by contrast, recognized that Exodus 23:11 actually expects the Israelite farmer to plant in the seventh year. The law’s real concern is the handling of the ensuing seventh-year produce, which it requires the farmer to harvest and to leave for the poor, an interpretation corroborated by an important Neo-Assyrian lexical parallel. Offering a different view, this Holiness author replaced the root $mT in his source with the root $bt, introducing the ideology of Sabbath in order to enact a seventh-year fallow. Thus the claim for substantial continuity between Exodus 23:10-11 and Leviticus 25:2-7 misunderstands the Covenant Collection law and fails to recognize the extent of the Holiness author’s legal revision.


Estimating the Biblical Literacy of Paul's Audiences
Program Unit: Paul and Scripture
Christopher D. Stanley, St. Bonaventure University

Scholars who study the use of Scripture in Paul's letters routinely assume that Paul wrote for audiences with a high degree of biblical literacy. Most seem to think that Paul expected his audiences to recall the precise literary context of his biblical references, reconstruct the reasoning behind his his often opaque readings of Scripture, and approve the validity of his hermeneutic. This paper will identify a number of problems with this way of viewing of Paul's audiences and argue for an alternative model that is more consistent with the social realities of Paul's day.


The Post-Ontological Paul?
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Timothy Stanley, University of Manchester

In Martin Heidegger’s lectures of 1920-21 published in English as Phenomenology of Religious Life (Gesamtausgabe, 60), he differentiates Pauline primordial Christianity from metaphysical inquiry. Heidegger cites the patristic commentaries on Romans 1:20 as examples of how Greek metaphysics crept into Christian theology. In response, Heidegger turns Romans 1:20 on its head by exegetically demonstrating Paul's polemic attitude towards Greek metaphysics. What becomes apparent is how Heidegger’s engagement with Paul’s epistles influenced his thought pathway (Denkweg) which consistently differentiated theology from metaphysics right through to his later essay “The Onto-theo-logical Constitution of Metaphysics.” In “The Reply to the Third Question at the Seminar in Zurich, 1951” Heidegger gives the clearest statement of his thoughts on theology: “If I were yet to write a theology – to which I sometimes feel inclined – then the word ‘being’ would not be allowed to occur in it.” Given the varied attempts to write a theology in this exact way (see for instance Jean-Luc Marion’s, God without Being), how might biblical scholars respond to Heidegger’s Pauline roots? Is Paul's thought essentially post-ontological in its outlook? Or, as Matthew Levering puts it in his Scripture and Metaphysics, "Why would not the revealed God of Scripture either completely transform prior notions of 'metaphysics,' or else be utterly beyond the conceptual realm of metaphysics?" Deciding upon these issues requires that biblical scholars renew an interest in metaphysical reflection. In many ways, Levering’s book may provide a paradigmatic example for this task.


The Political Economy of the ‘New Jerusalem’ in Trito-Isaiah, Haggai, and Zechariah
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Gary Stansell, Saint Olaf College

The prophets of the Persian Period, in looking back on a devastated Jerusalem, did not despair of its glorious future. A restored Zion was surely to be expected, given the graciousness of Israel’s God and his ancient promises of blessing to the Holy City. But it was especially in the literature of so-called Trito-Isaiah that a future Jerusalem was envisioned in economic terms. However else the city was to attain and indeed surpass its former glory, Trito-Isaiah presented the image of a city renewed especially in economic power and wealth. Indeed, it would be the “wealth of nations”—-a phrase that occurs no less that four times in Isaiah (60:5, 11; 61:6; 66:12)--that would stream to Zion and place it at the center of world economic activity. Trio-Isaiah’s expectation of future wealth for Jerusalem was matched by Haggai (2:7) and Zechariah (14:14). This essay not only explores the connections between these prophecies but will particularly focus on how economic anthropology helps elucidate Jerusalem’s restored honor and its position of pre-eminence among the nations.


Transforming Initiatives of Just Peacemaking Based on the Triadic Structure of the Sermon on the Mount
Program Unit: Matthew
Glen Stassen, Fuller Theological Seminary

Based on the summer 2003 JBL article, "The Fourteen Triads of the Sermon on the Mount: Matthew 5:21-7:12," I will interpret several of the triads in the Sermon as calling for peacemaking initiatives in first-century context and then for analogous peacemaking initiatives in our present context. In setting the Matthean context, I will point to Willard Swartley's major new book, The Covenant of Peace: The Missing Peace in New Testament Research. Despite complexities in suggesting analogies across twenty centuries, I will argue for a consistent thrust in the triads of the Sermon on the Mount toward an ethic of transforming initiatives and not only what is often assumed to be an ethic of renunciation. Because much interpretation of the Sermon has been dyadic, readers have derived an ethic less helpful, less accessible, and less effective than the Sermon on the Mount suggests, or have passed by in bafflement. The transforming initiatives point by analogy (not without need for careful interpretation) in the direction of several of the practices of just peacemaking as in Just Peacemaking: Ten Practices for Abolishing War (Pilgrim Press: 1998/2004). I hope to stimulate more of that careful interpretation.


Succession in the New Testament World
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Perry L. Stepp, Kentucky Christian University

Current discussion of the authority relationships in the New Testament is hampered by the lack of a historically grounded understanding of succession and its function in ancient texts. Today’s interpreters generally understand succession in terms of apostolic succession, the passing on of apostolic office from predecessor to successor, as practiced in the Catholic and other traditions. But succession in ancient texts functions in a much more flexible way. These texts use the language and typology of succession to describe the handing on of a variety of objects: authority, tradition, a craft—not just office. Further, they depict varying levels of replacement in these exchanges, from the delegating of a task to predecessor redivivus, in terms of succession. In this paper, I describe my survey of ancient texts (from ancient Jewish, Christian, and Graeco-Roman literature) which depict succession. How do these ancient texts depict succession? And how should this depiction affect our reading of authority relationships in the New Testament, in particular Timothy’s and Titus’s relationship to Paul as depicted in the Pastoral Epistles?


Idumaea in the Persian Period According to the New Archaeological Data
Program Unit: Literature and History of the Persian Period
Ian Stern, Archaeological Seminars

Until recently, scholars have suggested that an entity or province of Idumaea may have existed in the Persian period, but there has been no attempt to quantify the material finds in this period nor to define its parameters. We have gathered information from the relevant surveys (primarily those of Avi Ofer and Yehuda Dagan) and excavations , in order to help define the borders of Persian period Idumaea as well as clarify the region's ethnic makeup at the time. The ethnic makeup of the territory is primarily based upon published ostraca that have come to light in the past two decades.


Burial Practices in Roman and post-Roman Carthage
Program Unit:
Susan T. Stevens, Randolph-Macon Woman's College

*


Excavations of a Catacomb Church at Lamta (Tunisia)
Program Unit: Archaeological Excavations and Discoveries: Illuminating the Biblical World
Susan Stevens, Randolph Macon Woman's College

The paper summarizes findings of the excavation of an unusual underground Christian burial complex connected to an above-ground Roman cemetery on the eastern outskirts of the ancient town of Leptiminus (modern Lamta). The builders of the complex removed four meters of friable bedrock in order to build the masonry walls and concrete vaults of an underground church and its annexes. Its users cut tombs into the floors marking them with polychrome mosaics. The excavation has also confirmed the findings of a ground penetrating radar survey that identified conventional rock-cut catacomb tunnels attached to the underground church. Unlike the catacombs in Rome, Carthage and Sousse, disturbed over hundreds of years, those underlying Lamta have been neither systematically robbed nor scientifically explored until now. The excavation is an unparalleled opportunity to explore an unusual and well preserved Christian archaeological site five meters underground and to study the interface of Roman and Christian burial practice, the development of a catacomb system in a well-understood Roman context. This paper reports on the work conducted under the direction of Susan Stevens (R-MWC), Nejib Ben Lazreg (Institutnational du Patrimoine, Tunis), and Lea Stirling (University of Manitoba).


The Politick Text: Seventeenth Century Text-Reception of Leviticus in English
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
David Tabb Stewart, Southwestern University

When Henry VIII seeks the annulment of his marriage to Catherine of Aragon (1526-33; she was his deceased brother’s widow), Leviticus emerges as a critical and instrumental text for English divines to mine. What medieval monks had once found a template for priesthood, and sixteenth century dissenting translators gloss with anti-clerical notes, 17th century English commentators and sermonizers open for political morals. For example Thomas Case, in a series of sermons in 1643, preaches from Lev. 26:25 that “Covenant violation” is the “top or sum of all … evils”; whereas Thomas Worden embraces both a private and public application. The “leper” of Lev. 14 becomes both symbol of the believer (“the State and Condition of a Sinner’s becoming a Saint”) and church (“the Cleansing or Destroying of any particular Church”). If Henry VIII’s bishops made good use of Leviticus’ forbidden degrees of relation for marriage, what sexual concerns agitate the 17th century? What excites Gervase Babington, the preeminent Pentateuchal commentator at the time of King James’ translators, is adultery—a concern that apparently kept him out of the translators’ company. To his own question as to “whether a man may marrie her whom formerly he hath adulterously abused in her husbands life time?” he answers “no.” It is not a surprise then that Andrew Willet, another key commentator of the era, should also excoriate adultery but condemn bestiality as “the most abominable sinne.” Ironically, all these and others pass over without comment the key texts for the (U.S.) politics of our era—those on homosexuality. The paper will discuss 17th century English interpretation of the parturient (Lev 12), sexual prohibitions (Lev 18), and the treatment of the raped slave girl who is “promised” to another (Lev 19:20-22) as exemplars of the political history of Leviticus text-reception.


Deafness and Temple Service: Why the Priests Don’t Need to Hear
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
David Tabb Stewart, Southwestern University

The linguistic history of the two terms of the Hebrew word pair, cheresh we’illem ‘deaf and mute’, are intertwined. Each may serve as a metonymy for the other and so may stand as the head term for a category of disabilities. In the most significant instance where cheresh labels a category—that of Lev. 19:14—one finds a surprise. The term stands for disabilities that do not impair a priest at the altar when he offers sacrifices with fire, or when he enters behind the sanctuary curtain (Lev. 21:18-23). Deafness is not a disqualifying blemish. This is so, biblically speaking, not just because God has made muteness and deafness (Exod. 4:11), but because speech and hearing are not needed in the sanctuary. Yehezkel Kaufmann capsulized this notion in his famous dictum: “the priestly temple is the kingdom of silence.” That is, every important sacrificial act is done without incantation, blessing, singing, or other speech. What remains is a gestural language—the officiant “waving,” raising and lowering things, and making significant hand placements. The rejection of deafness and muteness as “blemishes” is a confirmation of Kaufmann’s, and later Israel Knohl’s, thesis of a “sanctuary of silence.” Yet outside the sanctuary, and in the people’s transactions with the priests, there is speech. The popular cultus is filled with singing and prayer. The two sacred realms—one sanctioned and silent; one popular and noisy—set the stage for the later inversion of hearing-people as “deaf” (Isa. 42:18-19; 43:8). Deafness in 2nd Isaiah becomes entangled in polemic against popular religion. Though such “deaf” people may ultimately hear even “written words” (Isa. 29:13), it is the mute suffering servant whom 2nd Isaiah ultimately valorizes (Isa. 53:7).


Rembrandt on and as Paul
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Todd D. Still, Truett Seminary of Baylor University

Hans Martin Rotermund once suggested that Rembrandt displayed little interest in the Apostle Paul. The extant work of the famed Dutch artist suggests otherwise. In fact, Paul served as a subject for as many as eleven Rembrandt works. This presentation will examine nine such pieces (eight paintings and one drawing), including a c. 1657 painting of the Apostle Paul that is housed and is presently on display in the National Gallery of Art in Washington, D.C. By way of conclusion, this paper will explore possible reasons for Rembrandt's apparent fascination with Paul.


Tell Me What You Read and I'll Tell You What You Are, or: When Did Christianity Cease to Be a Jewish Sect?
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Daniel Stoekl Ben Ezra, Hebrew University

Daniel Boyarin and others have argued for a postponement of the split between Judaism and Christianity. If we take the title of the recent volume "The Ways That Never Parted" seriously, we could even speak of a postponement ad infini tum. Among others, Judith Lieu has bemoaned the difficult y to get data beyond the statements of ecclesiastical / rabbinical authorities that might portray rather wishful thinking for an early parting of the ways. This presentation approaches the question of Jewish Sectarian identity from a fresh direction through a comparison of the composition of the Qumran Sectarian library with that of the Christian and Jewish papyri from Egypt. In a landmark study, Devorah Dimant has analyzed the Qumran scrolls distinguishing between Hebrew Bible, sectarian texts and non-sectarian texts. A similar analysis of the Jewish and Christian papyri from second and third century Egypt reveals a much higher ratio of “Christian sectarian ”literature than in Qumran. Compared to Qumran, it seems therefore, that Christianity ceased to be a “Jewish ”sect and develop its own distinctly Christian identity quite early, long before Constantine , at least if we speak of Egyptian Christians with literacy.


Old Caves and Young Caves: Two Qumran Collections?
Program Unit: Qumran
Daniel Stoekl Ben Ezra, Hebrew University

An examination of the average age of the scrolls of each of the Qumran caves shows a huge gap between the "old" caves 1 and 4 (average age between 37 and 44 BCE) and the "young" caves 2, 3, 5, 6 and 11 (average age between 5 and 25 CE). A statistical analysis proves that the manuscripts from caves 1 and 4 cannot come from the same collection as those found in caves 2,3,5,6 and 11 (p less than 0.0001 for a Kruskal-Wallis test, similar numbers for a series of T-Tests), at least not as random samples. The scenario that all or most caves served as emergency hiding places for the Qumran collection around 68 CE has therefore to be discarded or fundamentally modified. Devorah Dimant has shown that the caves are intimately connected by genre and "Sectarianism." Most probably, therefore, the "old" caves 1 and 4 represent the manuscript collection of the same group as the "young" caves 2,3,5,6,11 but at an earlier point in history. Assuming Qumran was destroyed by fire around 4 BCE, caused most probably by an attack (Jodi Magness), I try to address the question how manuscripts older than that fire survived. I therefore suggest the following scenario: cave 4 was an emergency hiding / library / depository around 4 BCE, and the mss from cave 1 were hidden also at that time. The young caves 2,3,5,6,11 represent the Qumran library at the second attack and fire around 68 CE. Cave 4 either served as "stacks" during period II or was a kind of Geniza, therefore we find some but not many CE mss in cave 4. If the old manuscripts from cave 4 were already mutilated around 4 BCE, this could explain why they remained in that cave during period II.


How to (Un)Do Things with Sex: Queer Performativity and Biblical Interpretation
Program Unit: LGBTI/Queer Hermeneutics
Ken Stone, Chicago Theological Seminary

*


Exegesis of Song of Songs in 4 Ezra
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Michael E. Stone, Hebrew University, Jerusalem

A few points in 4 Ezra exhibit a dependence on Song of Songs. In these passages, Song of Songs is understood in an allegorical way. Intriguingly, R. Akiba b. Yosef lived and exegeted Song of Songs allegorically in exactly the time period in which 4 Ezra was written. Notably, 4 Ezra's allegorical exegesis differs from that of R. Aqiba in its basic referents. Shiur Qomah speculation is claimed to come from the allegorical interpretation of the bridegroom in Song of Songs, but experts are wary of attributing the origins of Shiur Qomah to R. Aqiba. Therefore, in the first century CE at the latest, allegorical explanation of Song of Songs was current, as is clear from the Aqiba material. 4 Ezra 4:37 shows that there may have been competing allegorical explanations, of which the pseudepigraphical apocalypse preserves a different or variant form from that dominant in rabbinic circles. Insufficient evidence is available at present for us to sketch the structure of that allegorical explanation, but its very existence in an apocalypse contemporary with Rabbi Aqiba opens up exegetical and religion-historical perspectives not generally in the purview students of the apocalyptic or the Jewish mystical literature.


Scripture as Artifact: Early Implications of Canonization in Biblical Hebrew Literature
Program Unit: Scripture as Artifact
Terje Stordalen, University of Oslo

Recent studies in comparative religion and cognitive psychology alike have emphasized a tendency in religious traditions to treat books holding authoritative texts in particular ways: the book with the holy text becomes an artifact. Certain passages in the Hebrew Scriptures reflect a practice of treating books as artifacts. The scrolls thus treated clearly could not have contained the present Hebrew canon. Still, these passages attest to an ongoing canonizing process, and they are indeed among the earliest evidence for such canonization of Hebrew material. Most importantly, these reflections of books as artifacts may provide important hints as to the social setting(s) for that canonizing process, and hence for the religious significance of the Hebrew scripture-to-be.


Fantasies of Violence as a Hidden Transcript in Sibylline Oracles 2
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
Kimberly Stratton, Carleton University

Sibylline Oracles 2 comprises a Jewish eschatological compilation from Asia Minor that was redacted by Christians before the middle of the second century. It contains oracles of doom and judgment directed primarily against “sinners” in the author's community rather than against foreign nations. The oracles predict the familiar litany of eschatological violence—earthquakes, floods, and plagues—as punishment for sins of the wicked. Additionally, they describe human forms of punishment among the acts of divine vengeance—scourging with fiery whips, binding in chains, and throwing to the beasts of Gehenna. I suggest that these last three forms of punishment reflect a deliberate appropriation of Roman spectacle. Recent scholarship illuminates the ideological importance of the arena in ancient Rome; acts of torture and public executions functioned as performances that reified Roman social ordering and legitimated the state’s authority. This paper argues that Sibylline Oracles 2 used violence in its eschatological fantasies mimetically, appropriating Rome’s own mechanisms of ideology and control. Through the visionary power of these depictions, Sib. Or. 2 narratively recreates the spectacle of violence and the performance of power in the minds of its audience. Elaine Scarry further illuminates the integral relationship between torture, pain, and power: in pain, a person's world shrinks—only pain occupies consciousness. With the shrinking of the victim's world, the world of the torturer, and consequently his power, inversely enlarges, explaining why violence and tools of torture convey power in repressive regimes. Employing also James Scott’s work on “hidden transcripts,” I propose that Sib. Or. 2 deliberately employed Roman symbols of power as a subversive discourse, commandeering Rome's monopoly on the right to inflict injury and harm on human bodies; by attributing this power to God, the author harnessed fantasies of violence in the service of social control and ethical exhortation in his community.


Mary’s Elizabethan Connection (Luke 1)
Program Unit: Formation of Luke and Acts
Casimir Stroik, Briar Cliff University

The story of Mary’s vision, visit to Elizabeth, and epideictic flourish (Luke 1:26-55) rightly has been considered as dependent upon the story of Zechariah’s vision and loosened tongue (Luke 1:25-25, 56-80). That these Mary episodes were added to an existing Zechariah cycle of episodes has been commonplace in redaction criticism. This paper first surveys recent analyses of the connection between these episodes. It then offers a reading that builds upon the insights of narrative criticism. Using the criteria of narrative tension and resolution, a map of the essential elements of the story is discerned. This reading presents narrative criteria that will aid future discussions about the redaction of Luke’s Infancy Narrative.


Alexandrian, Western, Byzantine? The Theory of Local Text Types: A Plea for a Paradigm Shift in New Testament Textuals Research
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Holger Strutwolf, Institute for New Testament Textual Research

The theory of local textforms was first developed by J.A. Bengel and is still influential in current textual criticism. In my paper, after reconstructing the history of that theory, I will argue that the theory of texttypes is not valid anymore. The vast amount of new material, that is available in the Editio Critica maior, askes for a new theory.


A North-American Reading of Philippians: Re-imagining Diversity and Power Relations
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Monya A. Stubbs, Austin Presbyterian Theological Semionary

*


Reading the Prophets as Meaning-Making Literature for Communities under Siege
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Louis Stulman, University of Findlay

Building on recent developments in the interpretation of the Latter Prophets this paper makes the following suggestions: 1) the prophetic literature is at-risk literature for communities under siege and on the verge of symbolic, cultural, and geo-political collapse; 2) this corpus shows marked signs of liminality, danger, and palpable disease due to hegemonic forces; 3) written prophecy is a rich and varied response to this massive disjunction and symbolic wreckage; 4) more specifically, the Latter Prophets function as meaning-making maps, and often as tapestries of hope, intended to help devastated communities survive massive, unwieldy loss; 5) while these tapestries/maps are polyphonic and wide-ranging, they are not formless. One can speak of "an anatomy of meaning" in the prophetic literature.


St. Paul's Therapy of Desire
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Dale Sullivan, North Dakota State University

Hellenistic philosophies—Stoicism, Epicureanism, and Skepticism—were attempts to heal the soul, to extricate the individual from turmoil of soul. As Martha Nussbaum explains, Philosophers from these schools believed that turmoil of soul came about because people had misdirected or excessive desire because they held faulty views of reality. Each philosophical school developed therapies based on their own world views that were supposed to bring their students/patients into calmness. Several scholars have explored the resonances of Christianity with these Hellenistic schools. If St. Paul’s letter to the Philippians is read in the context of these therapies of desire, a distinct therapy of desire emerges, one that does not replicate any of the Hellenistic schools completely because the ultimate world view of Christianity differs from theirs; nevertheless, it is clear that many of the passages in Philippians are closely related to, and may even emerge out of, Hellenistic preoccupation with directing desire in such a way as to give peace of mind and heart. This paper explore's Paul's paraenesis as a therapeutic rhetoric of praise and therefore as a species of epideictic rhetoric.


Matthew 16:17–23
Program Unit: New Testament Mysticism Project
Kevin Sullivan, Marquette University

A commentary on Matthew 16:17-23 will be presented.


Mapping Exile in the Book of Daniel
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Carla Sulzbach, McGill University

This paper seeks to explore the dynamics of exilic spaces as exemplified in the Book of Daniel and to solve some of the conundrums arising from the narrative such as the contrast between Daniel’s spaces and those of the Babylonian kings and what may have prompted the final editor to compile the text the way he did. This will be done by applying critical spatial theory, especially Edward Soja’s trialectic of Firstspace, Secondspace, and Thirdspace to the text. A specific problem presented by Daniel is that, as formally the narrative takes place outside the Land of Israel, everyone operates outside of Jewish sacred space. Yet, the underlying narrative very much is centered in the Land of Israel and the subtext of that underlying narrative deals exactly with the issue of contamination of the most sacred place. We could thus ask: how is a reality of impurity in a pure environment reflected in a narrative situation of purity in an impure environment? From the perspective of the Land of Israel, the City of Jerusalem, and the Temple representing gradations of sacred space, exile, by definition is not sacred space. Rather, it is a non-space, or a profane space as in Eliade’s terms. However, in it “bubbles” of sacred space may “irrupt”. For instance, Daniel’s domestic space becomes a sacred space where he can perform his liturgical obligations and communicate with the divine. It is in this place where he has his visions. Further, in the view of some, Exile may be extended in time and space and become a condition that can affect the true sacred space of the Land, the City, and the Temple.


Lot and His Daughters in Early Modern Europe
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Karla Suomala, Luther College

How should we read the story of a man who unwittingly (seemingly) impregnates not one, but both of his daughters in a remote cave? The story of Lot and his daughters in Gen. 19:30-38 has caused much puzzlement and speculation among scholars trying to understand its meaning and function in the larger context of Genesis. European artists, particularly during the 16-18th centuries, also appear to have been fascinated with this scene and the questions it evoked. In fact, there are at least 50, if not more, paintings that treat the subject of Lot and his daughters during this period. In my presentation, I will evaluate the various depictions the biblical characters in these pieces, and outline the answers that the artists provide to the following questions: 1) what was Lot’s role in these acts of incest (did he initiate, was he passive, was he taken advantage of)? 2) what were the roles of the daughters (did they initiate, were they victims)? and 3) what sort of moral or lesson is to be gained from this story, if any? In order to answer these questions, more than a close analysis of the paintings themselves will be necessary since the artists who produced paintings connected to Gen. 19:30-38 did not treat this biblical theme in isolation. Their interest, at least in some cases, appears to have been motivated by a fascination with incest in Greek mythology and the role of incest generally. Finally, I will conclude by highlighting the innovative interpretations of this passage that emerged.


Hugo Odeberg's Pharisaism and Dejudaized Christianity Anno 1943
Program Unit: Bible and Cultural Studies
Jesper Svartvik, Lund University

Dr. Hugo Odeberg, Professor of Biblical Studies at Lund University in Sweden 1933-64, wrote in 1943 the notoriously influential book Pharisaism and Christianity. The purpose of the book, which has been translated into Danish, Norwegian, Finnish and English, was to describe the essential difference between two religious types. His book has influenced Jewish-Christian relations in Scandinavia during the last century more than any other theological work. Odeberg has gone down to posterity as a foremost connoisseur of Semitic languages, Jewish texts and Jewish mysticism. Therefore, this book has often been thought of as an objective presentation of the factual difference between “Pharisaism” and Christianity — wie es eigentlisch gewesen. However, at the time of his writing this book during the Second World War, Odeberg was the President of a pro-Nazi Swedish-German Society. This paper examines its theology in the light of a number of lectures which Odeberg held at conferences in the Third Reich, published in the series of the Institute zur Erforschung und Beseitigung des jüdischen Einflusses auf das deutsche kirchliche Leben. The paper seeks to demonstrate that Odeberg during the early 1940’s was so heavily engaged in a pro-Nazi construal of a dejudaized Christianity that it must affect our understanding of the book Pharisaism and Christianity. Whereas his political affiliation has been known for some time — although its extent has not been recognized hitherto —, this paper will also expose that Odeberg actually plagiarized a German anthology published in the 1920’s with ancient and modern Jewish sources translated from Aramaic and Hebrew into German. This embarrassing piece of information explains some of the inconsistencies in the book. A critical examination of Pharisaism and Christianity helps us understand the impediments which the study of Judaism and Jewish-Christian relations in Scandinavia are still facing.


Philonic Allegory in Hebrews
Program Unit: Hellenistic Moral Philosophy and Early Christianity
Stefan Nordgaard Svendsen, University of Copenhagen

For decades, biblical scholarship has been divided over the question whether or not the author of Hebrews was intellectually influenced by Philo of Alexandria. According to some interpreters, the author was entirely unfamiliar with Philo's work whereas others claim that he must have belonged to the circle around the Alexandrian at some point of his life. In spite of this disagreement, however, practically all scholars agree that he was not influenced by Philo's hermeneutics. Philo, it is argued, read The Old Testament allegorically whereas Hebrews applied typology. The paper challenges this consensus by arguing that the hermeneutics of Hebrews are in fact allegorical and deeply influenced by the Alexandrian philosopher. In the first part of the paper it is argued that the author adopted a number of Philo's allegorical readings (those of the Promised Land, the tabernacle and the Jewish high priest) and developed his argument around them. However, since he operated within an apocalyptically inspired outlook on the world, which differs significantly from Philo's Platonic metaphysics, the allegorical method is transformed in important ways by the author. These changes are identified and explained. In the latter part, it is discussed how the insights into the author's hermeneutics may help us understand the letter's rhetorical aim. It is argued that the author used the allegorical method principally as a means to expose the worthlessness of the Jewish religious institutions in order to dissuade the the recipients from supplementing their Christian faith with observance of the Torah.


Race Reading and Ethnic Stereotype in Romans 2:17–29: A Postcolonial Analysis
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
Diana M. Swancutt, Yale University

This paper is a postcolonial analysis of Romans 2 on two levels that are compared.The first level is the modern creation of Romans 2 as a racial discourse of (European) Christian supercession of Judaism (as the Christian race's primitive other). The ethnic essentialism of that reading remains in current scholarship on "religion" in Paul generally and Romans 2, specifically. The second level is a postcolonial historical reading of 2:17-29 against this grain, as Paul's Greco-Roman stereotype of Judeans as misanthropic, legalistic lawbreakers. Paul invokes this stereotype of Judeans in order, ultimately, to overturn it. He does so in two steps. First, he stereotypes his Judean rival, a fellow teacher of Greeks, as a Greek-hater who arrogantly proclaims the supremacy of Judaism to the way of his Greek and Romans 'betters.' By censuring his Jewish rival in terms his Greek rhetorical audience would applaud, Paul undermines the Judaism of his rival. But Paul then deploys a Romanized, Stoic philosophic discourse of 'spirit' to redefine Greek believers ethnically as internal Jews of the spirit, who are obligated to embrace their Jewish identity (over against Romanitas) and self-lower for their circumcised kin. Romans 2:17-29 is therefore a colonial discourse of ethnic self-making that mimics Roman ideology in order to resist its hold on Greek believers.


Scripture Reading and Identity Formation
Program Unit: Paul and Scripture
Diana M. Swancutt, Yale University

This paper examines instances of Paul's use of Scripture as moments in an ongoing process of identity formation of Greek believers into Pauline Jewish messianic communities. Particular attention is paid to the ways the identity of Paul's rhetorical audiences determine the questions we ask, and answers we give, to the subject of "Paul's use of Scripture"; the meanings of "scripture" in Paul's rhetoric; and to the methodological issues raised by reading the letters both for evidence of social group-formation, and as moments of rhetorical self-definition.


From Rome to Washington and Back Again
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
C. Jan Swearingen, Texas A&M University

This paper will examine the Biblical allusions in George Bush's second inaugural, especially, his references to America's historical destiny, its duty to bring freedom and democracty to all the world, and its dedication to overcoming slavery and tyranny with liberty. In shifting from the language of the war on terror that had predominated since 9-11 in American political invective, Bush returned to the language of the Declaration of Independence, and its doublets: tropes opposing slavery and freedom, tyranny and liberty, the rights and equality endowed by the Creator. Behind and beyond these now-familiar tropes lay two hundred years of anti-English Scottish invective, and numerous colonial sermons which drew on passages from Isaiah, Jeremiah, Romans, and Galations. These sermons influenced political speeches denouncing tyranny and unjust laws, and asserting the right and duty to overthrow a delinquent ruler, a ruler who was not serving his people. In reverting to the language of the Declaration, Bush's inaugural explicitly affirmed the religious roots of American democracy, and alluded to several of its Biblical sources. Revisiting the transmission of these tropes of independence can remind us that much as the founders relied upon both classical and Biblical sources for their doctrines and language, today's orators sometimes use the Declaration as, in Pauline Maier's terms, "an American Scripture."


Dating Prophetic Texts
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Marvin A. Sweeney, Claremont School of Theology

This paper will consider criteria for dating prophetic texts apart from linguistic grounds. It will examine a number of texts from Isaiah (Isaiah 10-11; 46); Jeremiah (Jeremiah 33); Ezekiel (Ezekiel 37); and the Book of the Twelve (Micah 4-5; Zephaniah 1; Zechariah 9) in an effort to determine their respective historical contexts. Criteria employed include formal characteristics, historical allusions, and intertextual citations or allusions. Although problematic, the paper will argue that such criteria provide some basis for dating prophetic texts.


Cognition, Culture, and Reading Ancient Texts
Program Unit: Cognitive Linguistics in Biblical Interpretation
Eve Sweetser, University of California, Berkeley

*


The Messias and Eschatology in EccR
Program Unit: Midrash
Jaroslav Eliah Sykora, South Bohemian University

The fundamental article of Christian faith, which establishes its existence and gives it its proper confessional content, is a simple statement: Jesus is the Messiah. That became the credential proprium of Christianity as a whole. However, as it is worldwide known, the messianic idea per se is much broader than many Christians are willing to admit. To see it as a theme in its length and genesis, we should go back to the historical and theological background of the Hebrew Bible, and continue our survey through the Dead Sea Scrolls, Pseudepigrapha to the tannaic and amoraic period which this study does not aim to undergo. The messianic theme and its aspects have already been studied in many ways in both Judaism and Christianity. Scholars, theologians, reverends and rabbis are quite prolific in producing careful analyses of the Messiah theologumenon. Along with them and with regard to them, my study does not intend to present either synthesis or syncresis of all of them. However, my study would like to present a contribution to the debate on the Messiah, messianic expectations and the concept of eschatology viewed from the rabbinic collection of haggadic discources originating from 3rd-7th century C.E. known as Midrash Ecclesiastes Rabbah (EccR). The discussion will be based upon all four avalaible discources of that piece.


The Blending of Rhetorolects in Wisdom of Solomon
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Dennis Sylva, Saint Francis Seminary

While commonly ascribed to the genre of wisdom literature, Wisdom of Solomon exhibits a high degree of blending between wisdom, apocalyptic, prophetic, and even pre-creation traditions. This paper explores that blending of rhetorolects with a view to clarifying the difference between "wisdom discourse" and "wisdom literature," such that all the topoi native to examples of the latter are clearly seen not to belong to the former.


Wisdom Discourse in Wisdom of Solomon and Plato's Gorgias
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Dennis Sylva, Saint Francis Seminary

This paper pursues a comparative study of Wisdom of Solomon and Plato's Gorgias, with special interest in the ways in which topics of post-mortem judgment, reward, and punishment function within wisdom discourse.


Pedagogue of the Groaning Creation: The Law in Martin Bucer’s 1536 Romans Commentary
Program Unit: Romans through History and Cultures
Edwin Tait, Asbury Theological Seminary

Martin Bucer’s 1536 Romans commentary is his most monumental work of Biblical exegesis, arguably the closest he came to a thorough and systematic statement of his theology. It coincides with the Wittenberg Concord which (as far as Bucer was concerned) ended the conflict with the Lutherans over Eucharistic theology. The Romans commentary also reflects Bucer’s rapprochement with Wittenberg in its treatment of soteriological questions. This paper will focus on Bucer’s understanding of the function of the Law as found in the Romans commentary, with the Gospel commentary (first written in 1527 and revised for the last time in 1536) as a standard of comparison. While Bucer accepts the Lutheran distinction between Law and Gospel, he subordinates it to an understanding of law as doctrina—divinely revealed teaching that functions (in Paul’s famous image from Galatians) as a pedagogue to bring us to faith in Christ. For Bucer, once the pedagogue’s authority is over, the pedagogue remains as a friend and guide. Through faith we receive the Holy Spirit and are liberated from the condemnation of the Law. Yet we continue to be guided by it as we learn to walk in the spirit and progress toward final union with God. The ultimate goal, for Bucer, is the transformation of all creation through the self-giving love of God, implanted in believers by the Holy Spirit. The more clearly one perceives God’s goodness, the more one will be transformed into the image of this goodness. The teaching function of the Law is therefore vital in the work of sanctification, which will ultimately result in an eschatological community characterized by love of neighbor with no trace of self-seeking.


The Son's Participation in the Human Plight: The Believer's Participation in Christ: Complementary Aspects of Pauline Soteriology
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Robert C. Tannehill, Methodist Theological School in Ohio

One of the most remarkable aspects of Pauline thought is the strong emphasis on the believer’s participation in Christ and his saving acts, expressed through such formulations as being baptized into Christ, putting on Christ, dying and rising with Christ, and being in Christ. These are soteriological statements, for dying and rising with Christ, for instance, means release from the old slavery to sin and entry into a new redeeming relationship. How is this relationship established? One clue is the motif of the sending of God’s Son to participate in the human plight so that humanity can be released from bondage (see Rom 8:3-4; Gal 4:4-5). This is an act of identification of the divine with humanity in its need (see also Phil 2:6-8). It makes possible participation in freeing divine power. This participation is made clearer in passages that refer to an exchange of divine and human attributes through gracious divine action (see 2 Cor 5:21; 8:9). Another clue is found in passages that relate faith to participation in Christ and in his death and resurrection (see Gal 2:19-20; Phil 3:7-11). Study of these passages should modify our understanding of faith. For Paul, faith in Christ includes identification with Christ and with his journey through death and resurrection, an identification with Christ made possible by divine identification with humanity in its need. As Douglas Campbell has recently argued, the language of participation has a central place in Pauline soteriology. Themes such as righteousness through faith cannot be fully explained apart from Paul's conviction that believers participate in Christ and in his death and resurrection.


The Narrative Unity of Luke-Acts: Response to Patricia Walters
Program Unit: Formation of Luke and Acts
Robert C. Tannehill, Methodist Theological School in Ohio

The various narrative elements common to both the third gospel and to Acts will be explored. An argument for the narrative unity will be advanced. The evidence to the contrary will be addressed. The common ethics in both documents will be discussed.


Jennings with Hardt and Negri
Program Unit: Semiotics and Exegesis
Jan William Tarlin, Capital University

In Reading Derrida / Thinking Paul: On Justice Jennings frequently reminds his readers that Romans is a letter addressed to people living in the heart of a world empire inviting them to leave the security of their imperial citizenship and risk joining a community answerable to the claims of a justice beyond that empire’s laws. This paper will argue that Jennings book is another such missive: an appeal to privileged citizens of an emerging 21st century global empire to negotiate the risk of giving their primary loyalty to the justice figured by the Derridian phrase “a democracy to come” while living in a world governed by the laws of late capitalism. Jennings achievement will be assessed by placing his book in dialogue with Hardt and Negri’s Empire, another scholarly appeal to think and act beyond the present world order while still enmeshed within it.


Immoral Immolation: The Degradation of Human Sacrifice in Near Eastern Scholarship
Program Unit: Israelite Religion in its Ancient Context
Jason Tatlock, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor

The practice of human sacrifice by the ancient inhabitants of the Middle East and North Africa has long fascinated the academic community. At times, this interest is coupled together with ethical and emotional repugnance to such an extent that the disdain a scholar might have towards human immolation has led him or her to deny the very existence of the custom within a particular cultural setting, such as ancient Israel, Carthage, or Mesopotamia. Such disdain has also fostered the desire to deflect the origins of the practice onto other people groups, i.e., the Canaanites, thereby distancing certain social entities from what is perceived as immoral. The concepts of disdain, denial, and deflection are evident in the scholarly discourse devoted to the Hebrew Bible. This paper attempts to free human sacrifice from the negativity that so often surrounds it with the hopes of promoting a new understanding of this ancient act of piety.


“So That We [Jews] Might Receive the Promise of the Spirit”: The Mutual Interdependence of the Eschatological Blessing of Jews and Gentiles in Galatians
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
John W. Taylor, Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary

Three key passages in Galatians have unexpected changes in person (Gal 3:13-14, 3:25-26, 4:4-7) which are frequently set aside. A fresh reading suggests that these changes have an identifiable pattern, signifying a substantive point in Paul’s argument. Paul makes the eschatological blessing of Jews and Gentiles mutually interdependent. Gentiles are sons of God because Jews are set free by Christ from the curse of the law. Jewish believers receive the Spirit because of Gentile inclusion: This paper shows that these passages can bear the weight of this exegesis, and provides a suggested explanation. Paul counters agitators in Galatia who insist that Gentile converts must be circumcised. Gentile blessing is only within Israel, and thus is secondary. Paul instead advocates the eschatological interdependence of Jew and Gentile. The existence of an underlying narrative behind Galatians 3 and 4 has been addressed by Richard Hays. This paper differs in suggesting that the first person plurals in Gal 3:14 and 4:6 are better read as references to Jewish believers (a suggestion made before for Gal 3:14 by N. T. Wright). This paper develops the evidence further. For Paul the Abrahamic covenant of Gen 12:1-3 is fulfilled in Christ such that both the blessing to the nation (Gen 12:2) and the blessing to the families of the earth (Gen 12:3) are equal necessary. The language of “sonship” is applied to the Gentiles, granting them equal status with Israel. Jewish reception of the Spirit is emphasized as a fulfillment of prophetic promises of a new covenant for Israel. These ideas may also be echoed in Romans 11. What is expressed as theological interdependence in Galatians is translated by Paul into salvation historical terms in Romans.


Josephine Butler, 1828–1906: Reading the Bible in a “Motherly or Womanly” Way
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Marion Taylor, Wycliffe College

Josephine Elizabeth Butler who led the successful campaign to repeal the Contagious Diseases Acts in Britain (1870-1886) was looked upon as one of the great founding mothers of modern feminism by a number of Edwardian suffragists. Her achievements as a social reformer and women’s activist are well known, but her work as a feminist interpreter of the Bible has been forgotten. In this paper, I will examine Butler’s interpretive work with a view to recovering her hermeneutical approach that she calls a “Motherly or Womanly” way of reading the Bible.


The Exegetical Function of the Abram/Ravens Narrative in Jubilees Reconsidered
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Andrew Teeter, University of Notre Dame

Among examples of so-called "Rewritten Bible," Jubilees is remarkable for the degree of its adherence to the wording of the biblical text. Deviations or expansions are never arbitrary, and can usually be explained as reflecting underlying interpretive issues. However, the pericope of Abram and the ravens in Jubilees 11 has proven resistant to explanation in terms of "exegetical function." The present study demonstrates that this narrative in Jubilees cannot be adequately explained as an exegetical response to Gen 15 triggered by perceived theological or textual difficulties (as recently argued by C. Crawford), nor can it be reduced to an etiology of the seed-plow (as suggested by S. P. Brock). Rather, it must be understood as part of a larger retelling strategy within Jubilees and its construal of Genesis/Exodus. It is closely related to structurally determinative texts in Jubilees (chapters 1, 23, and 50) and is concerned with fundamental thematic elements that are characteristic of the author's viewpoint (e.g., demons and evil forces in the world, separation from Gentiles). Given the function of the pericope within this broader compositional strategy, both the placement and the specific form of the raven tradition are very likely the creation of the author of Jubilees himself. This has important implications for our understanding of other reflexes of the tradition (e.g., the Syriac sources discussed by Brock). This broader narrative function must be accounted for in any attempt to explain the specific exegetical function of the pericope.


Rethinking the Ritual Significance of the 'Base of the Altar' in the LXX and the Temple Scroll: On the Hermeneutics of a Halakhic Variant
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Andrew Teeter, University of Notre Dame

On three occasions the Greek Pentateuch requires sacrificial blood to be eliminated at "the base of the altar" where the feature of "the base" is textually absent from the MT (Lev 1:15; 7:2; Deut 12:27 // 11QT 52.20-21). The broadly accepted explanation of P. Dion (1987) that these passages reflect a halakhic concern, attested in the Mishnah, to prevent blood contact with the ramp leading to the altar fails to explain the occasional nature of these insertions. Why is additional reference to "the base" deemed necessary only at these three locations while other texts that presumably imply an equal or greater hazard are left untouched? Careful attention to the textual particulars of each of the three passages suggests a different kind of solution. The exegetical procedures by which the alterations were made in these specific texts are best understood as driven primarily by harmonistic or intertextual concerns (relating two or more scriptural texts), rather than by the impulse to bring the biblical text into conformity with known (extra-textual) practices, as Dion suggests. This recognition has potentially profound implications for understanding the hermeneutics of "halakhic variants" elsewhere in the transmission of the Pentateuch.


Kings Revisited. Kingship in Deuteronomy and the Deuteronomistic History
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Rannfrid Irene Thelle, Luther College

This paper focuses on the relationship between Deuteronomy and the Deuteronomistic History on the theme of kingship. Scholars have noticed the discrepancies between the view of the authors of Deuteronomy and the view expressed in the books of Joshua thru Kings, and have offered various explanations and debate. Together with other topics, such as the justice system, prophets, and the central cult site, this paper will argue that the topic of kingship points in the direction of the need for a reassessment of the common understanding that the composition of Deuteronomy precedes, as a whole, the work of Joshua thru Kings. Through an examination of the contributions on the topic of kingship/monarchy, this paper will offer a discussion of the idea that Deuteronomy represents a composition that is contemporary with, if not later than, the ‘Former Prophets’. By prefacing them, Deuteronomy provides a new prism through which the following books are understood, that allows for a ‘failed’ history to be salvaged.


Matthew and the Apocalypse of Abraham: A Similar Response/Approach to the Destruction of the Temple?
Program Unit: Matthew
Michael Theophilos, University of Oxford

Several commentators have noted the connection between Israel’s covenantal infidelity and the destruction of the temple in intertestamental Jewish literature. One such work is the Apocalypse of Abraham. Most modern discussions of the Apocalypse of Abraham concerns the redactional puzzle of chapter 29, which many have seen as a Christian interpolation (Philonenko 1975: 204-211; Rubinkiewicz 1979: 137-151; Stone 1984, 414-419; Hall 1988, 107-109). Notwithstanding the complexities of this debate, our attention in this paper will focus upon the structural arrangement of material preceding ApAb 27 (the destruction of the temple) and the affinity it displays toward its Matthean equivalent (context of Mt 24). The manner in which this contributes to Matthean studies is relatively clear. Matthew joins a similar theological trajectory in associating the destruction of the temple, not ultimately to a pagan cause, but to inappropriate Israelite worship and cultic activity. One such interesting parallel are the catalogue of sins, which in Apocalypse of Abraham 24:3-25:2 are presented as a series of seven. It is significant to note that the seventh sin is elaborated upon in chapter 25. What is immediately apparent is that this sin occurs within the temple and is related to the sacrificial system or, in this case, the sacrificial system’s perversion. Instructive in this regard are the religious authorities, who are indicted for the desecration of the temple. This is to be compared to Matthew’s seven woes against the Scribes and Pharisees (Mt 23) which directly precedes the Matthean eschatological discourse, and indeed provides a framework for Matthew’s Jesus prophetic denunciation of the temple.


Wisdom of Solomon and Cleanthes's Hymn to Zeus
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Johan C. Thom, University of Stellenbosch

There is general consensus that Wisdom of Solomon shows clear signs of Stoic influence, while Cleanthes’ Hymn to Zeus is one of the best representative texts of early Stoicism. It is therefore not surprising that these two texts have important central topoi in common, such as the role of Reason (Logos) or Wisdom (Sophia) in structuring and maintaining the cosmic order, and the moral problem presented by people who do not recognize God’s providential care of the world. The two texts use comparable strategies to address these issues: both contain hymnic celebrations of the divine beings responsible for the world order, as well as a protreptic element in which human beings are exhorted to recognize and obey the divine dispensation. There are, however, also important differences: the Hymn to Zeus focuses on how to save bad people and restore the divine order, while Wisdom, on the other hand, provides strategies for dealing with the problem bad people causes the righteous. The two texts will therefore be compared with a view to identify the similarities and differences in topoi and rhetorical strategies, and to relate these to the social situations of the texts.


Staying Greek in the Roman East: Hybridity as a Cultural Strategy in Civic Religion
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Christine M. Thomas, University of California, Santa Barbara

Antiquarian interest and nostalgia for the Greek past characterize the literature of the Greek-speaking eastern provinces in the high Roman empire. On the level of civic religion, one can similarly find during this period a revived interest not only in “Greek” religion, but even in peculiarly local cults, attested in the inscriptions, iconography, and cult architecture of the cities of the eastern Roman empire. Examples from the city of Ephesos will illustrate that it was the provincial elite, rather than new Roman settlers, who were instrumental in transforming the city’s religious heritage to express a new identity within the Roman empire. These changes presented a hybrid identity expressing varying strategies of accommodation, resistance, and appropriation in the face of the Roman program of colonization. Among other things, precisely the insistence on the Greek character of their religious heritage assisted the provincial elite in boundary maintenance that, by stressing their differences from Rome and her inhabitants, also developed the terms of interaction with them, and allowed the Ephesians to retain a distinct cultural identity in the face of political dominance and potential cultural assimilation.


Samson Went Down to Timnah: Ethnicity, Kinship, and Sexual Relations in Judges 14
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Christine Neal Thomas, Harvard University

Samson’s encounters with the Philistines begin with his desire for a Timnite woman. When he leaves Zorah and goes down to Timnah, Samson is not crossing a border as much as he is making that border more distinct. By dramatizing the clash between Israelite and Philistine, Judges 14 shapes these ethnicities and delineates the differences between them. This paper will present archaeological research and studies of ethnicity that confirm the conception of Samson’s adventures as a “border epic” that seeks to impose order on the conflicts between two emerging ethnic groups in the Shephelah. Furthermore, by drawing on additional work in structural anthropology and folklore, I will argue that sexual desire and competition are the means through which the ethnic identities Israelite and Philistine are worked out in Judges 14. While feminist scholars have done much important work to recover the agency and subjectivity of women in such exchanges between men, a feminist approach should also strive to demonstrate the contingency of male identity. A close examination of the social and material world of the Shephelah in Iron Age I reveals that systems of patrimonial kinship are only as stable as the human relationships through which they are formed. Economic hardship, loss of land, migration and ecology can dramatically alter the dynamics of self-ascription and differentiation that forge ethnicity. It is not simply a marriage or thirty sets of garments that is at stake in the battle of wits between Samson and his hosts. The struggle over who gets the woman and on what terms is a struggle over the boundaries between Israelite and Philistine, Danite and Timnite.


Hidden Spaces and Utopias: Spatial Discourse and Practice as Early Christian Identity-Markers
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Christine M. Thomas, University of California, Santa Barbara

The propensity of early Christians to meet in domestic spaces is well-known and has been investigated extensively from a number of disciplinary and theoretical perspectives. This was a comprehensible choice given the lack of access that early Christians had to civic space, or to the means to construct monumental and durable structures devoted specifically to their religious practices. In a real sense, early Christians were living in spaces they did not make. Yet this did not absolve them of the need to understand and provide a logic about their habitual practices. Early Christian discourse about sacred space through the first three centuries is characterized by inversion, negation, and temporalization. The early Christians consciously valorize utopian constructions of sacred space, and in their actual practice, prefer the “hidden” or “occult” spaces of private homes, cemeteries, and caves. Lines of analysis developed by Henri Lefebvre suggest that their spatial discourse is in direct engagement with the dominant ways of understanding the relationship between civic, domestic, and sacred space in the Roman empire, sometimes accepting but often subverting it. By valorizing an inverted civic map, early Christians were able to “make a difference” and draw a boundary between themselves and other groups in the Roman empire. To a considerable degree, Christians maintained this characteristic discourse even when they developed access to political power, which helps explain the unusual choices of late antique Christians in their establishment of sacred spaces. When late antique traditional religion retreated to domestic spaces, this represented a contestation of an early Christian identity-marker, resulting in Christian responses ranging from fear to open conflict.


Letting the Word Run Free: Luther's Lectures on Romans and Popular Reception
Program Unit: Romans through History and Cultures
Deanna Thompson, Hamline University

As one church historian put it, the most pervasive image of the Reformation is the liberated Word of God. While Luther's Lectures on Romans is often considered among his 'pre-Reformation' writings, when examined alongside his sermons and disputations of the same period, we see clear evidence of 'the Word breaking free' from academic structures and seeping into popular consciousness in dramatic ways. The character of Paul and the freedom of the Christian under the cross move beyond the academy and into public spaces, where this tune of freedom gets heard - especially by peasants - in ways Luther never imagined.


The Fourth-Century in Cyber Space
Program Unit: Computer Assisted Research
Glen L. Thompson, Wisconsin Lutheran College

While important collections of documentary sources are available on the net for many aspects of history, the early church is represented mostly by versions of the nineteenth century edition of the Ante-Nicene, Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers. The Perseus website is of immense value for making classical sources available in the original languages for the study of the ancient classical world, but nothing similar exists for the early Christian historian. Thus, there appears to be a need for web resources for both the general student and the scholar of patristics. What might such a web resource look like for the Christian fourth century, and what resources might it include? The paper will present some ideas for both content and design for such a website as it is currently being piloted by students and staff at Wisconsin Lutheran College. The website is envisioned as including a significant repository of e-texts of primary source material, in the originals and contemporary English translation. In addition it may include lists and other more technical information that will be of use to researchers. Since additions and corrections can be made very quickly, such lists can be an up-to-date repository receiving input from scholars worldwide. It is hoped the discussion period that follows will give important feedback to the initiators of the project and stimulate thought about similar efforts.


Listen Up: Proposing a "Silent Period" for Elementary Grammars
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Jeremy Thompson, University of Stellenbosch

Several modern approaches to language learning (e.g. the Natural Approach and the Lexical Approach) have proposed a ‘silent period’ during which learners begin to acquire skill in pronunciation by listening without being asked to pronounce anything themselves. There appears to be support for a ‘silent period’ in both applied linguistics and theoretical linguistics literature. Problematically, elementary Biblical Hebrew grammars almost invariably have learners begin pronouncing without having a period primarily devoted to listening. In this paper, I will discuss what constitutes a ‘silent period,’ why such a period might be more effective than requiring students to pronounce from the beginning of a language course, examine the presentation of pronunciation in elementary Biblical Hebrew grammars, and make suggestions for how a ‘silent period’ might be incorporated into Biblical Hebrew instruction.


Communication with the Spirit World: Religious Experience among the Earliest Christians
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Clint Tibbs, Catholic University of America

The paper attempts to argue that the religious experience of the earliest Christians involved communication with a spirit world inhabited by spirits who identified themselves as "holy spirits" or "spirits of God" by their acclamations through a medium "Jesus is Lord" (1 Cor 12:3) and "Jesus Christ has come in the flesh" (1 John 4:2). Religious experience here is defined as "contact with the divine," i.e., "the spirit world," with the intention of being instructed by the spirits. This definition is based on the Latin religio, the binding of humans with the gods. While spirit possession is many times depicted in the negative context of demonic possession in the gospels, "divine spirits" and "holy spirits" are described possessing persons and speaking by the use of their vocal chords in Josephus, Philo, and Pseudo-Philo. This evidence is briefly analyzed with the intention of exploring like phenomena in 1 Corinthians 12 and 14, the Didache, Shepherd of Hermas, Mandate 11, and descriptions of Montanism. By the time of Origen, only evil spirits were believed to possess persons. This change in attitude toward divine communication from the spirit world was partly out of fear of being deceived by spirits. The proposal of many holy spirits in the light of the Christian theology of "the Holy Spirit" will be discussed. It will be concluded that early Christians experienced not "the Spirit" but rather "the spirit world" within their Jewish background.


Philo's Legum Allegoriae I–III: The Thread of the Argument
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Thomas H. Tobin, S.J., Loyola University of Chicago

Philo’s Legum Allegoriae I–III is an allegorical interpretation of Genesis 2–3. But the three treatises also contain interpretations, sometimes quite extensive, of a variety of other biblical texts. Because of this the continuity of his allegorical interpretation of Genesis 2–3 can easily be lost. The purpose of this paper is to analyze the allegorical interpretation of Genesis 1–2 to make clear what the continuity of Philo’s argument is.


"Living among the Tombs": Society, Mental Illness, and Self-Destruction in Mark 5:1–20
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Holly Toensing, Xavier University

Cultural Studies approaches to biblical interpretation call for speaking in one’s own tongue. This call poignantly reaches those who struggle under societal taboos not to talk about certain topics, such as mental illness and its common connection to suicide. More specifically, Disability Studies offers insights that encourage the voice that these taboos silence. Examining the demoniac story of Mark 5 using the lens of Disability Studies, this paper brings focus to a) the powerfully debilitating, potentially even self-destructive experience of mental illness, and b) the social and cultural factors that shape a community’s judgment of and responses to mental illness.


Torture, Trauma, and Truth: The Scandal of Crucifixion
Program Unit: Bible and Cultural Studies
David Tombs, Trinity College, Dublin

Crucifixion was a form of execution so shameful as to be almost unspeakable in Roman society. The early Christian movement was acutely aware that the scandalous manner of its leader’s death would be a stumbling block for many. Early Christian writers downplayed the details of Jesus’ execution, even when early martyrs suffered similar indignities. Christian artists did not represent crucifixion until the fifth century, more than a century after it had been abolished by Constantine. This paper explores the traumatic scandal of crucifixion by highlighting the gendered dynamics of crucifixion in the context of the Roman Empire, with its political dynamics of state terror, its gender dynamics of male power, and its cultural symbolism of bodily penetration. It then asks why the sexual dimension to crucifixion receives so little attention, despite the emphasis on stripping Jesus in the gospel texts and the frequency of sexual humiliation and violence in so many torture practices. In this context, Mel Gibson’s desire to portray a ‘macho’ Christ on the cross in ‘The Passion of the Christ’ represents one of the most recent and obvious examples of a Christian willingness to embrace some aspects of the physical trauma of Christ, whilst at the same time failing to confront crucifixion as a form of sexual humiliation and torture. The paper concludes that the real scandal of the cross now lies in the evasion and denial of this experience. It suggests that crucifixion provides a clear case-study in how unspeakable traumas can generate denial, and argues that this denial impedes the effective development of a Christian theological and biblical response to contemporary torture practices.


SOM(e) Reflections in Daniel and the Similitudes
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Carl N. Toney, Loyola University, Chicago

The branching trajectory of the reinterpreted “Son of Man” SOM imagery used for the seer and enthroned heavenly figure begins with Ezekiel, further develops in Daniel, and further develops in the Similitudes. All three works have a seer seeing an enthroned man-like, heavenly figure. Ezekiel sees YHWH as “like a man” (Ezek 1:26), Daniel sees a collective symbol of holy people as “like a son of man” (Dan 7:13), and Enoch sees an individual figure representing righteous people as “like a son of man” (1En 46:1-3). With these identifications, there is a move from God being the sole ruler of the cosmos (Ezekiel) to sharing rule with his people (Daniel) to sharing with a representative of his people (Similitudes). In addition, all three works have the seer being addressed as “son of man” by a heavenly figure. In all three works, the address indicates the seer’s special prophetic role and relationship to YHWH (Ezek 2:3; Dan 8:17; 1En 60:10). Both Daniel and Similitudes move further by making the seer the premier righteous person identified with the SOM (Dan 8:17; 1En 60:10). Further, the Similitudes (1En 71:14) move beyond the promise of exaltation and identification of the seer (found in Daniel) when the seer actually receives heavenly exaltation and identification with the “son of man” at the conclusion of the Similitudes. By looking at the relationship between the seer and the heavenly figure in both Daniel and the Similitudes in light of Ezekiel, we are able to see both a continuity and development of the SOM imagery in these works. Finally, a few suggestions for further exploration will be made regarding how the Gospels pick up on aspects of the SOM imagery from each of these books.


Nature Groaning in Pain
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Sigve Tonstad, Sykehuset Asker og Baerum

In a revealing New Testament passage Paul writes that “the whole creation has been groaning as in the pains of childbirth right up to the present time” (Rom 8:22). He also asserts that “the creation was subjected to futility” (Rom 8:20), resorting to the Greek word mataiotes, translated ‘futility.’ This word carries with it the distant drumbeat of the wisdom literature in the Old Testament, the “vanity of vanities” that the ancient wisdom seeker pronounced on his failed quest for meaning (Ecc 1:2ff.). In the context of Paul, this ‘futility’ means that nature does not relish the burdensome role assigned to her. As the reading of the Good News Bible has it, “creation was condemned to lose its purpose” (Rom 8:20). Paul recognizes in nature an intense longing to be delivered from the present unworthy condition. While in her yearning for restoration nature turns from the unfeeling human ruler to fix her hopes on the Creator, the paper will probe for ways for contemporary believers to perceive nature’s plight and to act in ways that might relieve its burden in line with the Creator’s purpose.


Blood "as High as a Horse's Bridle": The Devil Is in the Details
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Sigve Tonstad, Sykehuset Asker and Baerum

The proposed paper is an outgrowth of my doctoral thesis, “Saving God’s Reputation: The Theological Function of Pistis Iesou in the Cosmic Narratives of Revelation,” at the University of St. Andrews, to be published by T. & T. Clark in 2006. I propose to show that when the cosmic dualism of Revelation is given its due, it changes the perception of the book’s message. Revelation’s dualism has been eclipsed either by the historical foreground of the Roman Empire or by the tendency to monist readings. In this respect the Devil is indeed in the details even where God seems to be the subject of the action and the instigator of the blood that reaches “as high as a horse’s bridle.” For instance, in the trumpet sequence the opposing agent of deception and destruction is remembered as a fallen star, recalling his heavenly origin and the primordial aspect of the story that is told. The trumpet sequence gives the fallen star a broad mandate (9:1), allowing Satan to implement his design in the world. Seeing this and related expressions merely as a circumlocutions of divine activity is inadequate in view of the cosmic conflict in Revelation. In the trumpet sequence it is the activity of the opposing side that is depicted, in contrast to views that see the calamities accompanying the trumpets primarily as God’s judgments on human beings who are disobedient. Failing to identify and to heed the central role of the satanic agency in the calamities that are reported carries the risk that those who experience such calamities in real life and those who read about them in Revelation together make the mistake of sending the bill to the wrong address.


Do Superheroes Read Scripture? Finding the Bible in Comic Books
Program Unit:
G. Andrew Tooze, Winston-Salem, NC

*


On Not Unbinding the Lazarus Story: The Nexus of History and Theology in John 11:1–54
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Derek M.H. Tovey, St. John's College

This paper argues for a historical core to the story of the raising of Lazarus, based on multiple attestation of resurrection miracle stories in the Synoptic gospels (Mark 5.21-24, 35-43; Luke 7.11-17), other traditional material e.g. Q (Luke 7.22//Matt 11.5), and historically plausible detail. The paper also argues on the basis of speech-act theory, that the nature of the assertions made depend upon a claim to the reality of the resurrection of Lazarus: as, for example, in assertions made by Jesus to the disciples (11. 7-15) and to Martha (11.23-26, 40). Therefore, both external tradition history and internal narrative dynamics argue for a historical core that points to a historical event where a resurrection occurs. Thus far the paper will build upon and develop positions widely argued within Johannine scholarship. Nevertheless, as is also widely recognised, the evangelist has elaborated upon this historical core to produce a narrative that serves his theological purposes, and the narrative shape of his overall presentation of Jesus. The paper argues that difficulties arise in scholarship when an attempt is made to sever the nexus of history and theology in this narrative, by separating out historical detail from narrative dynamic and theological purpose. An argument is mounted that such an attempt misunderstands (and undermines) the nature of “historical discourse” as interpretation upon event. On analogy with historical fiction, and perhaps other forms of history-writing, the argument is made that the evangelist produces a theological-historical narrative. The overall illocutionary act is to provide an interpretation of the historical Jesus that establishes his historic significance. This act, then, is as much a part of history writing as of theological reflection. The Lazarus story is part of a wider story that culminates in the resurrection story par excellence, that of Jesus the Christ.


Christianismos: Ignatius, Judaism, and the Christianoi
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Philippa Townsend, Princeton University

In his letters, Ignatius of Antioch exhorts his readers to choose Christianismos over Ioudaismos. But what would the neologism Christianismos have meant to Ignatius and his audience? In this paper, I address that question through an exploration of the origin of the Christian name and the implications of its usage in the first and early second centuries. I argue that the term Christiani was coined originally by the Roman authorities as a Latin translation of Paul’s Greek phrase hoi tou christou. It referred specifically to Pauline Jesus-followers, who, as non-Jews, were particularly conspicuous and therefore vulnerable to the hostile attention of outsiders. Subsequently, it came to be reabsorbed into the language of the communities themselves, its negative connotations subverted by its re-appropriation. The name denoted a particular subset of gentile Jesus-followers, then, rather than Jesus-followers in general. Ignatius, writing at the beginning of the second century, deploys the category Christianismos in his attempt to provide a normative definition of what it means to be a true follower of Jesus. The elements that he draws out as essential to this definition are precisely those that had first set the Christianoi apart: their non-Jewishness and their particular vulnerability to persecution by the Roman authorities. Challenging many Jesus-followers’ continuing identification with or attraction to Judaism, Ignatius struggles to establish the particular values and practices of the Christianoi in its place. Not only must the Christianoi no longer orient themselves towards Ioudaismos, he claims, but Jews who believe in Jesus must now adopt Christianismos and become Christians. Ignatius’s letters, then, provide intriguing evidence of an attempt to establish an identity for Jesus-followers that did not center on Judaism; but they also demonstrate the extent to which, at the beginning of the second century, this was still a controversial project.


Reading a Page of the Freer Gospels Codex
Program Unit:
David Trobisch, Bangor Theological Seminary

*


Winning Finally and Dominating Time: Apocalyptic Resistance in Contemporary Melanesia and New Testament Times
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Garry Trompf, University of Sydney

The author of this paper has already insisted that, for theories of millenarism to be adequate, distinctive forms of retributive logic and macrohistorical visioning require an accounting. With select Melanesian new religious movements and ancient apocalypses in view, this paper analyses projections of a final victory by spirit forces for an elect (or group of resistants), along with talk of divinely structured time bending toward a consummate resolution to 'history as a whole.'


Philonic Allegory in Mark
Program Unit: Hellenistic Moral Philosophy and Early Christianity
Henrik Tronier, Copenhagen University

On a superficial view the earliest and supposedly most primitive of the four Gospels seems to constitute a strong argument against finding philosophy at the roots of Christianity. However, when Mark is read in the context of contemporary Jewish allegorical hermeneutics another impression surfaces. In this paper it is argued that Mark’s biography of Jesus was written the way Philo interpreted the biblical narratives about the lives and journeys of Abraham and Moses, the founders of the Jewish people. They are stamped images of God’s logos and sophia in history; their journeys are the outward appearance of the interpretive activity of logos-transformed, perfected knowledge, which the allegorical reader will recognise as the defining mark and nature of God’s elected people; the various locations, people and persons along the journey constitute deficient or lower levels of knowledge and ethics in the unified epistemological, cosmological and anthropological framework that is plotted in the geo-, ethno- and topographical space of the narrative. The various literary strategies by which Mark construes the allegorical level of meaning and guides the readers to an allegorical interpretation of the surface story are analysed in the light of Philo’s interpretive strategies. Finally, the paper discusses the different ethnic strategies involved in the allegorical hermeneutics of Philo and Mark. Here it is argued that Mark’s aim is in line with Paul’s allegorical interpretation of Jewish identity markers. At crucial points Mark’s biography of Jesus is an allegorical inscription of Pauline concepts, including his cosmologically framed idea of Christ as God’s wisdom, into the scattered historical traditions about Jesus.


Contemporization or Fulfillment-Interpretation?
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Ronald L. Troxel, University of Wisconsin, Madison

When Seeligmann observed that LXX-Isaiah "repeatedly reflects contemporaneous history," he spoke equally of the translator's belief that his era was the "time for the fulfillment of ancient prophecies." In practice, however, Seeligmann did not distinguish these phenomena in his discussion of the translation, so that his term "contemporization" came to represent both phenomena.Subsequently, Arie van der Kooij reclaimed Seeligmann's initial distinction, referring, on the one hand, to "Modernisiergungen" and, on the other, to what he called "Erfüllungsinterpretationen" the latter of which he considered the most salient characteristic of the translation.This paper propounds criteria (with their rationale) for distinguishing "fulfillment-interpretation" from simple identification of ancient places, peoples, and customs with their equivalents in the translator's day (contemporization). As a case in point, this paper will consider the translation of "Tarshish" as "Carthage" in Isaiah 23, asking whether this is a case of "Erfüllungsinterpretation" or simply reflects the translator seeking an equivalence his audience could recognize. (N.B. I will submit this proposal to the consulation on the Greek Bible, also.)


A Possession for the Hedgehog and a Place for Ostriches: God, Land, and Animals in Isaiah 1–39
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Peter Trudinger, Flinders University

The writings attributed to the Eighth Century prophet Isaiah paint a very mixed picture of the relationship between God and Earth. The opening vision is one of desolation, with Jerusalem standing alone in a wasted landscape. A motif of desolation recurs in the following chapters, for Jerusalem and for other cities. Balancing this is a motif of a plentiful Earth, full of God’s glory (6:3). While humans are always in view in these visions as the primary recipients of God’s judgment or generosity, another group frequently makes an appearance – the animals. This paper examines the role of animals in Isaiah 1-39. The first move is to extract them from the anthropocentric interests of the text. Then the part they play is highlighted. Animals are frequent beneficiaries of the actions of God, whether these are in judgment or restoration. In this regard, their situation is in contrast to that of land and cities.


The Performance of Psalms in the Rituals of the Second Temple
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Peter Trudinger, Flinders University

The constituents of a religious ritual interact dynamically with each other. In an effective ritual, words, actions, and context all resonate to generate in the participants a consciousness that something super-mundane is happening. This paper analyzes the interaction between biblical psalms performed in two rituals of the Jerusalem Temple in the late Second Temple period (Herod’s Temple) and the accompanying actions and setting. The two rituals considered are the daily morning worship, the Tamid, the foundational rite in the Temple, and Sukkot (Booths), the premier festival in Temple times and an occasion of great pilgrimage, pomp, and rejoicing. The rituals can be partially reconstructed through critical use of information from the Bible, contemporary writings (e.g., Josephus, Qumran) and later rabbinic works. Psalms were performed in both rituals: for the Tamid, a set of seven psalms one for each day of the week (Ps 24, 48, 82, 94, 81, 93, 92), and for Sukkot, the Hallel (Ps 113-118) and the psalms for the six intermediate days of the festival (Ps 29, 50, 94, 81, 82). The paper draws on a modified form of Briggs’ classification of the contextual features of a verbal performance, to link the psalms to (a) their immediate ritual setting, (b) the interactions that surround their performance and (c) the general conditions of the period. The psalms of the Tamid reinforce the sense of Temple as sacred space and reassure the participants of the validity of their worship. For Sukkot, the psalms portray the power of God in judgement. The two sets of psalms overlap, so that recollection of Sukkot is imported into the daily rituals of the Jerusalem Temple throughout the year.


Sarah and the Sacrifice of Isaac: The Matriarch in Early, Medieval, and Modern Readings of Genesis 22
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Melissa Tubbs Loya, Boston College

For centuries before the dawn of modern biblical scholarship, Jewish and Christian interpreters asked why particular persons in the patriarchal family were absent from the Akedah. Sarah received the most attention in this regard. While Sarah’s involvement in the binding of her son is not the main concern of such commentators, there are more than a few discussions about the matriarch’s absence from the biblical account. Many modern commentators do not find it necessary to discuss Sarah’s absence, although there are those who ask after the missing matriarch. In this examination of early, medieval, and modern retellings of Gen 22, I will argue that the matriarch, inserted into the terrific account of Isaac’s binding, serves as a foil for Abraham and Isaac, and as a mouthpiece for readers of the Akedah. What Abraham and Isaac cannot say as faithful participants in the biblical drama, Sarah is made to say in various interpretive attempts to wrestle with the fear and trembling caused by the required sacrifice. Sarah gives voice to the moral and religious questions that, if posed by Abraham or Isaac, would tarnish the faith of the father and son. Yet these questions, faithful or not, rise up from the biblical text as if to test the reader along with those bound to perform the sacrifice. By including Sarah as one so bound, pre-modern interpreters give voice to various responses to the demand for sacrifice that differ from the silent obedience shown by Abraham in the biblical account. In this way, early and medieval commentators on the Akedah explore the myriad questions raised by the laconic biblical text. A brief look at modern commentary on Sarah and the Akedah will show that modern interpreters use methods like those employed by their predecessors, although they arrive at different conclusions.


“Therefore the Land Mourns”: The Grievance of the Land in Hosea 4:1–3
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Melissa Tubbs Loya, Boston College

Past examinations of Hos 4:1-3 have often focused on the pericope as a rîb brought against Israel by Yahweh, who argues his case using a list of offenses that are amongst those outlawed in the Decalogue. Interpretation of this portion of Hosea, then, has been dominated by a concentration on the crimes of humanity and their prosecution. More recently, studies have begun to emerge that consider the role of the land and its non-human inhabitants in Hos 4:1-3. Investigations by Brueggemann, DeRoche, and Hayes, for example, have helped to demonstrate the degree to which the created order has been neglected in past readings of the pericope. More work on the role of creation in Hos 4:1-3, however, remains to be done. I propose to reread Hos 4:1-3 with two purposes in mind: first, to chart the role of the land in God’s rîb (noting, for example, that the land is mentioned as often as Yahweh/Elohim, and more often than human beings), and secondly to consider the connection between the human crimes inventoried in v. 2 and the response of the land in v. 3. Based on this reading, I will argue that creation is the active agent through which Yahweh’s judgment is rendered. Yahweh acts in bringing the rîb; creation, however, acts in bringing about its consequences. It is the land, and not Yahweh, that acts in v. 3, where nothing less than a systematic undoing of creation is described. The land does not act outside of Yahweh’s purposes, however. Rather, the land is governed not only by physical laws, but also the moral order built into creation by Yahweh at its inception. The mourning, languishing, and perishing of the land and its inhabitants are consequences of Israel’s breach of this moral order through their disregard of the covenant.


Hortatory Discourse in the Psalter: An Initial Inquiry
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
W. Dennis Tucker, Jr., Truett Seminary--Baylor University

For nearly two decades Hebrew scholars have made use of linguistic studies in attempting to identify observable patterns within the Hebrew of various types of discourse. The initial work of Robert Longacre (subsequently-Bryan Rocine, Barry Bandstra, D. A. Dawson) identified four discernible types of material: historical narrative; hortatory speech; procedural speech; and instructional speech. With each type, or discourse, Longacre identified a profile of the verbal and syntactical constructions found prominent in each. For example, the imperative and other volitive forms serve on the mainline in hortatory discourse. Longacre and others have noted that their work derived from a careful reading of Hebrew narrative and that such a reading of poetic texts remains necessary. Longacre and Rocine have suggested that embedded prayer within Hebrew narrative may be termed hortatory discourse. The purpose of this study is to begin an analysis (discourse/ text-linguistic analysis) of the Psalter, and the hortatory speech found therein. The chief aim of hortatory discourse/speech, in general, is that of altering or changing the outlook or behavior of another (Rocine). The primary question under consideration is not does the Psalter do this, but how does the Psalter express such an intention? In other words, this is not a question of form criticism (lament psalm, imprecatory psalm, etc), but a more particular question concerning linguistic structure within the psalms themselves. Are there verbal and syntactical constructions that figure prominently in this type of direct speech? Are there ways in which the psalmist may structure the poem to heighten the sense of hortatory discourse? And does the psalmist shift to other forms of discourse (historical narrative; expository discourse; instructional discourse)? If so, what are the implications of those shifts in the overall hortatory nature of the psalm itself?


The Use of the Hebrew/Aramaic Scriptures in the Articulation of the Self within the Qumran Hodayot
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Marc V. Turnage, Durham University

The Selbstbewußtsein articulated by the author(s) of the Qumran Hodayot is outstanding among the Qumran library as well as Judaism of the Hellenistic and Roman eras. The hymnist or hymnists of the Hodayot utilized language and vocabulary drawn from the Hebrew/Aramaic Scriptures in both the formation and articulation of his self-consciousness. The manner of the intertextuality that appears in the Hodayot further conveys the elevated profile of the “I” in the hymns. As opposed to offering direct citation of the biblical material, the hymnist(s) creatively wove the biblical vocabulary into the fabric of each individual hymn expressing his self-perceived continuation of the tradition of thanksgiving hymns originating in the Hebrew/Aramaic Bible. Moreover, in a very sophisticated manner, the hymnist(s) joined biblical passages creating the discourse of the Qumran hymns as well as his self-discourse. The discourse created by the hymnist(s) reflected the Qumran sectarian reaccentuation of the biblical language, and his own self-consciousness was intricately connected with the intertextuality of the Hodayot serving as a principle manner for the articulation of speaker’s self. This paper analyzes the manner, method, and result of the intertextual discourse created by the hymnist(s) of the Qumran Hodayot as a means for the articulation of the self-consciousness of the speaker(s), as well as his use of intertextuality as a means of reflecting on the character and nature of others, both divine and human.


Creating a Profile of the “I” of the Hodayot: Implications for the Study of the Qumran Hodayot Documents
Program Unit: Qumran
Marc V. Turnage, Durham University

Recent analysis of the Hodayot assumes the division of 1QHa into the categories of “Teacher Hymns” and “Community Hymns,” where the “I” of the hymns has no autobiographical referent but rather functions as a cipher for the Qumran community. This division of the hymns grows partially out of the myopic focus and interest in the “Teacher Hymns” as witnesses to the history of the community and the allusive figure, the Teacher of Righteousness. Such a systematic division of the hymns contained in the Hodayot documents struggles to explain the unmistakable unity of style and vocabulary that permeates the Hodayot. One of the primary gaps in scholarship on the Hodayot is the absence of a systematic analysis of the “I” of the hymns: a profile of the persona or personae of the “I” of the Hodayot. What profile(s) of the “I” emerges from a thorough analysis of the Hodayot; who is the hymnist(s) of the Hodayot? Is there a consistent persona within the entire collection of Qumran hodayot, or are there multiple personae reflected in the sectarian psalms? The centrality of this figure, or figures, to the Hodayot requires that these questions be initially answered, then afterwards one can begin to address questions of historical authorship, the compositional/redactional history of the Hodayot documents, and the form critical questions of the role and purpose of the Hodayot within the Sitz im Leben of the Qumran community—fundamental questions that remain to be satisfactorily answered. This paper will present the synthesis of a systematic analysis of the persona(ae) of the “I” of the Hodayot, and the implications of such an analysis for understanding the history and development of the Qumran Hodayot.


"I'll Be the Traitor, You Can Be the Proselyte": Teaching Christian History through Role-Playing
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Ayse Tuzlak, University of Calgary

This presentation will introduce the audience to a recent party game that takes Christian origins as its central theme, then it will use that game as the basis for a discussion on the value of play in pedagogy._The Last Supper_ was designed by Eric Finley in 2005, and won an award in the "Iron Game Chef" competition. Players take on the roles of Jesus and the apostles on the last night of Jesus' life. Through their conversations in-character, they sketch out the doctrines that will shape Christianity’s history. The assumption behind the game is that every statement the apostles make will have a tangible effect on future Christian doctrine. It invites players to ask themselves how our world might look today if the conversation at the Last Supper had gone a different way. After exploring an example of play with the group, I will invite discussion on some of the pedagogical challenges involved in adapting games like these for classroom use. The questions I have in mind include: How can an instructor transform a game that was originally designed for a handful of players into something engaging for twenty or even fifty players? Can Christian students enjoy these games without feeling like the instructor is trivializing their faith? Is it best for the instructor to stand aside, to get involved as a player, or to take the role of a referee? Can games that are designed to be played over the course of an evening reach a satisfying conclusion in the hour allotted to an undergraduate class? Most importantly, how can these games make a serious and memorable point about the historical forces at work in Christianity's early development?


Theory and Literary Appropriations of Paul
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Jay Twomey, University of Cincinnati

Literary versions of the life and ministry of Paul abound, but have received less scholarly attention than is accorded rewrites of the Gospels. The reasons are many, including the most obvious: Jesus sells. But the recent work of Agamben, Badiou and others can, I think, contribute to a much broader scholarly appreciation of Paul’s literary heritage. With this end in mind, I will discuss a number of fictional Pauls (by Johnny Cash, Pasolini, MLK, Gore Vidal and others) in the terms deployed by theorists of Paul, especially Abamben. Agamben’s non-universalizing ‘messianic time’ goes to the heart of recent literary appreciations of the radically disruptive potential Paul represents (for good or ill). A secondary goal of this presentation is to inject a more vigorously critical element into the scholarship on biblical appropriation by establishing a dialogue among the parties (in literary studies, biblical studies, and theory) interested in such questions.


Wrestling with and for Paul: Efforts to Obtain Pauline Support by Marcion and the Author of Acts
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Joseph B. Tyson, Southern Methodist University

This paper will be part of a panel discussion on the reception of Acts in the second century and beyond.


Terminology for the Developing Scriptures in the Second Temple Period
Program Unit: Rethinking the Concept and Categories of 'Bible' in Antiquity
Eugene Ulrich, University of Notre Dame

The trajectories of the various works that end as our biblical books should be mapped to gain focus on their development from oral tradition and Israelite literature to Jewish-Christian Scripture. The categories of the different stages should be clarified as well as the terminology used to describe them.


Diogenes' Doggerel and the Poetics of Homeric Quotation
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Mark Usher, University of Vermont

This paper examines Diogenes the Cynic’s parodic quotations from Homer (preserved in the Life compiled by Diogenes Laertius). It makes two related observations about these quotations: 1) the way Diogenes reworks Homer suggests that he possessed a deep familiarity with the themes, structures, and compositional techniques of Homeric poetry and reproduced it spontaneously as a composing poet or rhapsode might have done in performance; 2) a close analysis of the larger context in which the quoted passages occur in the source text sheds light on the intent/meaning of these quotations (many of which, to date, have not been adequately explained).


Jerusalem: The Temple Mount during the First Temple Period: An Archaeologist's View
Program Unit: Prophetic Texts and Their Ancient Contexts
David Ussishkin, Tel Aviv University

The royal acropolis of the First Temple period in Jerusalem was built on the Temple Mount. Unfortunately, there are no available archaeological data regarding the compound and its buildings. The archaeologist attempting to reconstruct the compound has to rely on topographical data, the biblical text, comparable archaeological material and general considerations. It seems that the Davidic compound was smaller than the later Herodian compound. It was probably rectangular, resembling in plan and character the Omride enclosures of Samaria and Jezreel. It was fortified, and contained the royal palace and the temple. In my view the palace was built to the north of the temple. The biblical text and comparable archaeological material give us some idea on the two building complexes, their plans and character. The royal acropolis, the palace and the temple as described above formed parts of the large city of Jerusalem which was fully developed by the later part of the 8th century BCE. As to the Temple Mount in the 10th and 9th centuries BCE there are several possibilities of reconstruction based in the main on the historical and textual data and their interpretation.


Reading Galatians 3:28c in the Light of Genesis 1:27 LXX? Critical Questions Concerning a Supersessionist Interpretation from the Perspective of Gender Concern
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Gesila Uzukwu, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven

Identifying the task: According to some Pauline scholars the text of Gen 1:27 LXX should be given a central role in the interpretation of Gal 3:28c. To support their view, they point out the obvious linguistic parallels between arsen kai thelu epoiesen autous (Gen 1:27 LXX) and arsen kai thelu (Gal 3:28c). On the basis of this link, their interpretations assume that the gender difference the creation of which is described in Gen 1:27 is overcome in a biological, social, Christological or ecclesiological sense according to Gal 3:28c. We hold that, defending this in Paul claims on the obliteration of race, class and gender amounts to a suppersessionist representation of the Old Testament in relation to the New Testament. With respect to Jewish - Christian relations, such interpretation does conflict with the intrinsic value of the people of God of the old covenant. Admittedly, arsen kai thelu are literally identical in both texts. But, is that enough to assume the entire creation context of Gen 1:27 in Gal 3:28c? In order to evaluate the hypothesis that Gal 3:28c is an allusion to Gen 1:27 LXX, a closer study of how the LXX interprets its Hebrew Vorlage is needed. In view of the aforementioned concerns, a fresh interpretation of Paul understanding of gender difference in Gal 3:28c will be undertaken by situating this verse in the context of the Galatian community.


True or False? The Authenticity of the Jewish Scriptures in Early Christian Writings
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
Kevin M. Vaccarella, Florida State University

The issue of Jewish Christianity has been approach in numerous ways, and yet it has remained an elusive entity to categorize. The growing acceptance of the “ways that never parted” paradigm of ecclesiastical history has illuminated the dynamic nature of Jewish Christian relations. Recent scholars of Jewish Christianity, such as Daniel Boyarin, have recognized how Christian and Jewish groups exist along a continuum that exists between these the two poles of Christianity and Judaism. Christian writings offer various representations of what is means to be a Christian. Yet, scholars such as Judith Lieu recognize that Christian identity cannot be defined by adhering to any one text’s boundaries since the borders are drawn differently according to each text. Jewish Christian identity may be further illuminated by examining the role of the Torah as portrayed within a range of Christian writings. My paper is an analysis of a selection of Christian texts which represent a particular phenomenon characterized by false scripture – inferior or counterfeit passages that appear alongside the ‘true’ words of God. This rhetorical argument disputes the authenticity of portions of the Jewish scriptures by claiming they are contrary to God’s original laws, thereby contesting the ability and authority of other Christian, Jewish, and Jewish Christian communities to interpret Torah. The list of texts includes Ptolemy’s Letter to Flora, the Pseudo-Clementine Homilies, and the Didascalia Apostolorum. These texts represent a range of religious categorization (Gnostic, Jewish Christian, and ‘proto-Orthodox’) from the second through fourth centuries; and each manifests a unique variation of this literary phenomenon by discussing the specific contents of the false scripture, their origin, and the means of their discernment. A comparative analysis of the literary tactic of false scripture testifies to the concern over the Torah and Jewish Christianity in establishing religious identity.


Fonua-e-moana: Re-[en]vis[ion]ing Oceanic Hermeneutics
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Nasili Vaka'uta, University of Auckland

This paper offers, on the one hand, a brief critique of existing views on contextual hermeneutics, and it seeks, on the other, to sketch an alternative position from Oceania, by articulating the dual concepts of fonua (land) and moana (ocean). These two combined provides a guide for reading texts from an Oceanic perspective. The paper therefore deals with the following areas:• delights and pitfalls of indigenous hermeneutics • politics of knowledge construction and its impact on the reading task • recovery and reconstruction of indigenous knowledge, and its bearings on hermeneutics The revival of indigenous epistemologies/hermeneutics should be more than just a mere ‘leap-into-cultures’ and a blind return to the ‘good old ways.’ A critique of culture must be an integral part of this venture. Given the tyrannical nature and hierarchical setup of many island cultures, any search for indigenous/contextual hermeneutics should be done with attentiveness to the well-being of those who exist within those cultures. Failure to critique the cultures that shaped indigenous hermeneutics is as problematic as the imperial/colonial leanings we are trying to depart from.


The Tower, the Titans, and the Temple: Reading Sibylline Oracle 3
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Katy Valentine, Graduate Theological Union

This paper explores a socio-literary reading of Sibylline Oracle 3. I propose that the stories of the tower of Babel, the Greek account of the Titans and the list of kingdoms should be read as one literary unit (vss. 97-161), which foreshadows the development of the eschatological temple later in the oracle. This paper gives a literary and intertextual reading of the tower of Babel, the Titans and the kingdoms. I propose that vvs. 97-161 exonerate the Jews from culpability in the introduction of evil and warfare to the world, while preparing for the later exaltation of the Jews in the oracle. The paper also explores the role of the temple in Sib. Or. 3 and postulates a literary relationship between the impermanent tower of Babel and the permanent eschatological temple. Sib. Or. 3. contributes to our understanding of Judaism in the Greco-Roman time period. First, it gives us one picture of the importance of the temple in Jerusalem to Diaspora Jews. Sib. Or. 3 may be one response to the upheaval of the temple by various groups. Second, Sib. Or. 3 presents the relationship of a section of Diaspora Jews to Greco-Roman culture. It is telling that the Jewish Sib. Or. 3 is comfortable including the story of the Titans alongside the story of the tower of Babel. The eventual welcoming of the Greeks at the eschatological temple, and the rejection of the Romans, is revelatory of the relationships and antagonisms of Diaspora Jews in this time period. Third, part of the purpose of Sib. Or. 3 was as propaganda for an inter-Jewish audience; this document gives us clues concerning the conversations among Diaspora Jews in this time period.


The Use of the "Pronomen Abundans" in the Fourth Gospel
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Gilbert Van Belle, Catholic University of Leuven, Belgium

It is widely accepted in Johannine research that “remarkable repetitions are typical of John”, where we find different repetitions and variations: synonyms in vocabulary and grammatical constructions; repetitions of parts of sentences and ideas; rhetorical figures and literary devices, such as epanalepsis or “Wiederaufnahme”, chiasm, prolepsis and analepsis, parallelism, and inclusions. In continuation of my earlier research into the parentheses or asides in John’s gospel, the use of prolepsis and the use of the proleptic pronoun "autos" this paper will demonstrate that the so-called pronomen abundans in John, i.e. “a personal or demonstrative pronoun which repeats the relative pronoun in a single-limbed relative clause” (W.F. Bakker) is also a form of repetition or intensification, and thus characteristic of the stylistic and grammatical unity of the Gospel of John. Note: A full paper will be delivered before the conference.


The Letter of James in the Light of Didache and Jewish Derekh Erets Tracts
Program Unit: Didache in Context
Huub van de Sandt, Tilburg University

In Jas 4:1-4 the author of the Letter of James accuses his readers of being responsible of wars and battles being fought among them. He also charges them with murder and adultery. Is James really accusing members of a Jewish Christian community of crimes like these? This paper will show that Jas 1:13-21; 2:8-11 and 4:1-4 provide materials which are closely akin to the ‘child-section’ in Did 3:1-6, a unit consisting of five small textual units, each of which warns against minor sins in order to prevent the danger of slipping away into trespassing of one or more ‘fundamental laws.’ Did 3:1-6 belongs to the Jewish Two Ways which, for the most part, is covered by the first six chapters of the Didache. The Jewish Two Ways document also circulated in some form separately from the rest of the Didache in the first century. Interestingly, Did 3:1-6 exhibits close affinity with the ethical principles of a particular stream of Rabbinic tradition found in early Derekh Erets treatises. These oral treatises do not reflect a strict legal, halakhic approach to the Law but a moral, personal and ethical attitude to life. In this paper it will become clear that James 4:1-4 might be considered as a further development and radicalization of the warnings in Did 3:1-6.


Discourse Particles in a Biblical Hebrew Reference Grammar: The Case of Hen and Hinne
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Christo H.J. van der Merwe, University of Stellenbosch

Discourse particles are defined as linguistic devices that help to structure discourse. Unlike nominal or verbal items they are not primarily identified on the basis of their morphological or morpho-syntactic features. They are typically categorized and sub-categorized on account of the discourse function(s) they fulfill, e.g. indicating speaker’s attitudes, organizing the flow of information, facilitating the taking of turns. What their meaning potential is, which aspects of their meaning are activated when, however, is often not certain. The problem this paper addresses is the following: which aspects of the discourse particles hen and hinneh, should be accounted for in a Biblical Hebrew reference grammar for scholars of the language? This implies the following questions: which semantic model should underlie a description of the particles and how should the results of an analysis in terms of this model by presented in a reference grammar? The hypothesis that this paper defends is that basic insights from Cognitive Linguistics provides a justifiable framework for a more comprehensive description hen and hinne. For these purposes it is firstly illustrated that the proposed semantic model can be utilized as a heuristic instrument to critically evaluate current description of the particles. Secondly, it is shown that a cognitive perspective requires a systematic description of the particles that go beyond that of a systematic listing of their morphological, syntactic, semantic and pragmatic features. Instead notions like "semantic potential," "prototypical use" and “conventionalized expressions” come into play to identify more adequate categories of description for hen and hinne. In the process it will, among other things, become evident that hen and hinne are not absolute synonyms. Furthermore, differences in the pragmatic distribution of hinne and wehinne, cannot be ignored. The same apply to differences in the pragmatic distribution of hinne+pronominal suffix and hinne + independent pronoun.


Ammon, Moab, and Edom: Tribal Kingdoms in the Iron Age
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Eveline van der Steen, East Carolina University

The kingdoms of Ammon, Moab and Edom figure largely in the biblical narratives, from the exodus to the Persian period. Archaeological and textual sources, both from Transjordan itself and from the Babylonian and Assyrian empires give each of these states a historical framework, albeit not an undisputed one. Both their chronological and their geographical boundaries are still subject to debate. Recent research has focused increasingly on the social and political organization and development of these kingdoms, within the larger discourse on early state formation. This paper discusses the processes of early or secondary state formation in the Iron Age, and the archaeological, textual and ethnohistorical sources that throw light on it. The kingdoms of Ammon, Moab and Edom are seen as originating in a basically tribal society, and will therefore be defined as tribal states. In this paper I want to address what this means in terms of the social organization of these states, their interaction, and how they responded to the coming of the Assyrian empire.


God: Lost and Found; Lost Again and Found Anew
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Hans J.M. van Deventer, North-West University, South Africa

In his latest novel entitled Praying mantis (Secker & Warburg, 2005 – short-listed for the 2006 Africa region Commonwealth Writers’ Prize) the acclaimed South African author, André P. Brink, gives a vivid account of the clash between different cultures and belief-systems on the African continent. In the novel, which has a definite picaresque slant, the prime character is a historical figure by the name of Cupido Cockroach. The novel is set in the Cape Colony (in Southern Africa) during the early nineteenth century. The plot centers on the conversion of Cupido, a Khoi man, to the Christian faith as a result of the missionary endeavors of the London Missionary Society. He becomes the first black missionary in the Colony, but at his isolated out-post he realizes that Christianity is unable to bridge to cultural divide created by the colonial authorities. This paper investigates the way in which the novel portrays the Bible to be understood through the eyes of Cupido one the one hand, and the white missionaries on the other hand. It seeks to highlight the role that context plays in the interpretation of texts. The contexts so brilliantly portrayed in this novel are that of an integrated Khoi worldview and an arrogant Western worldview.


The Use of Metaphors in Job’s Self-Description
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Pierre J.P. Van Hecke, Tilburg University

Few biblical protagonists have undergone the same suffering that Job has. On different occasions in his replies to his friends, Job describes his physical and mental agony. Very often, he does so making use of metaphors. This should come as no surprise. As recent cognitive-linguistic research in metaphorical language has explained, metaphors are used very frequently in the description of emotional experiences, which can hardly be expressed in direct language (Lakoff, Johnson, Kövecses). In recent biblical research, the role of metaphor has received growing attention. Usually, however, this metaphor research concentrates on Psalms and on prophetic literature, whereas Wisdom literature, that contains no less metaphorical language, is often overlooked. In the present paper, I propose to examine the different metaphors that Job uses in his self-description and, more in particular, in the description of his mental and physical suffering. It will be shown that metaphors of light and darkness play an important role in Job’s self-description, as do metaphors that describe mental suffering in physical terms. Special attention will be paid throughout to the metaphorical conceptualization of God’s perceived role in Job’s suffering.


Scriptures and Piracy: Textual Politics in Public Intellectual Property Discourse
Program Unit: Bible and Cultural Studies
Katrina Van Heest, Claremont Graduate University

This paper will examine the role of scripture in the melding of religious and commercial interests to strengthen U.S. intellectual property law. For some years, the film and music industries have constructed a causal link between the preponderance of internet peer-to-peer file-sharing networks and the decreases in entertainment revenue. The polemic has been embraced by the Christian recording industry, which supports the corporate rhetoric with scriptural references and faith-based morality. Scriptures offer a patina of divine truth that often does not attend legal code in the mind of the average consumer. More importantly, any presumed eternal relevance of scriptures lends anti-piracy efforts the solidity that they desperately need. As absolute authorities, scriptures can comment decisively on the shape-shifting phenomenon of digital content transfer. The deployment of scriptures in the growing anti-piracy movement transforms the political discourse and U.S. society by morally and legally criminalizing behavior that is increasingly common.


The Kingdom of God: A Spiritual Interpretation: In Discussion with Rudolph Bultmann, Marcus Borg, and Elaine Pagels
Program Unit: Bible Translation
Wali van Lohuizen, Amsterdam, The Netherlands

Sometimes the Kingdom of God (KoG) is taken as an eschatological concept, either as imminent or referring to the Last Day (e.g. Bultmann, Theologie des NT), sometimes as a social and political future reality (e.g. Marcus Borg, The Heart of Christianity), either directly at hand or maybe as a utopia. Or does it refer to a presence here and now, and of all times, revealed by Jesus, as is suggested historically by Elaine Pagels in Beyond belief? Is it open and obvious, or does it require a transformation process in order to see and realize it (e.g. Marcus Borg again)? According to the Gospel of Thomas the KoG is both within and without. The Gospel of Luke seems to confirm the former as he uses entos, although generally this is translated by ‘among’. This paper will analyze the synoptic gospel texts as well as the Gospel of Thomas on this issue: to what extent the KoG may be understood as a here and now, and as a call for transformation in order to realize it. It will adopt the stance of mysticism where the central theme is about Presence, about a loving relationship with that Presence, and about transformation processes both as a prerequisite to and as an effect of that Presence. The focus of the paper will be to what extent pericopes about the KoG stand in that tradition, or do they contradict it? Sacred texts often are characterized by different layers of meanings. The paper will have an open eye for this when scrutinizing the pericopes about the KoG.


A Mathematical Model of Early Christianity
Program Unit: Construction of Christian Identities
Bas van Os, University of Groningen

Mathematical modelling can be an additional tool to enhance our understanding of the demography of early Christianity. Models are often misunderstood in their apparent scientific precision. But their real value lies elsewhere: an interactive can help any researcher to evaluate the numerical effects and logical consistency of his or her assumptions. In the presentation of the model, I will first discuss plausible ranges for the input assumptions, and then show interactively (with computer and beamer) what this means for inter alia:- growth and age profile over time- growth and ethnic profile over time- presence of the 30s generation and their descendents in the communities over time. Analyzing the range of plausible outcomes may enhance our understanding of issues like: How long was there a significant presence of those who had become believers in the 30s CE? When and where did non-Jewish believers become dominant? What was the effect of wars and persecutions? How large was the Christian presence in a region or city?


The Social Setting of the Gospel of Philip
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Bas van Os, University of Groningen

This paper wil build on my previous work regarding the Gospel of Philip. In Philadelphia (2005) I presented the case for the work as notes of a baptism instruction. This allows us to read the document as a single composition within a specific rhetorical setting. In Edinburgh (2006), I will argue that the work is not from Eastern Syria, but from one of the main Greek speaking cities in the first half of the third century, like Alexandria or Rome. In my third paper on this work I will apply socio-rhetoric analyses to assess the social setting of the work: how does it define the identity of the group, who are insiders and who are outsiders? What are the relationships with Gentiles, Jews and other (groups of) Christians? What is the position of the baptism candidates? What type of social response is promoted towards the outside world? What does the community teach about gender, social status, children and slaves? What is the background of the teacher(s)? Time permitting, I will correlate these results with the results of Peter Lampe for Valentinians in Rome, Henry Green for Gnostics in Egypt, and the description of the Valentinians in North Africa by Tertullian.


The Minor Versions and the Text of Ezekiel
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Harry F. van Rooy, North-West University, South Africa

While working on the text of Ezekiel for the Oxford Hebrew Bible project, the resources to be used for reconstructing an older form of the text of Ezekiel than the one contained in the Masoretic Text remain a problematic question. It is generally accepted that the text of the Septuagint frequently represents a different tradition to the one contained in the Masoretic Text. Many of the differences between the Septuagint and the Masoretic Text are related to these two different traditions, with the result that the text of the Septuagint can frequently not be used for the reconstruction of a tradition underlying the Masoretic Text. The question thus arises whether the minor versions can serve a special function in the process of reconstructing the Hebrew text. The Targum is an expansive translation in the case of Ezekiel, making its use quite problematic. The Vulgate and Peshitta are quite close to the Masoretic tradition. This question will be discussed, using examples from Ezekiel 1-5. The question is made more difficult by the possibility that, in instances where the Vulgate and/or Peshitta agree with the Septuagint, the Septuagint may have influenced these two versions. One will have to look first at instances where these two versions agree against the Septuagint and then at the instances where one of them disagree with the Septuagint, especially in instances where the Hebrew is problematic. The following examples will receive special attention: 1:1, 3, 6, 12, 14, 16, 26; 2:5, 7, 9; 3:1, 4, 6, 18, 22; 4:2, 12; 5:6, 11 and 15. The discussion will show the importance of these two minor versions, with special importance accorded to those cases where the Pesitta agrees with the Septuagint.


Biblical Sources for the History of David: A Critical Review
Program Unit: Prophetic Texts and Their Ancient Contexts
John van Seters, University of North Carolina

In order to evaluate critically the history of David’s reign and the period of the so-called United Monarchy, this paper will asses and compare the recent contributions of Nadav Na’aman and Baruch Halpern. It will consider the various literary components that make up the biblical story of David within the complex account of his “rise to power” and the “court history,” in 1 Sam 16–1 Kgs 2, as well as the comparative materials from Near Eastern historiography that have been used to judge their historicity


Language of Sentiment
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Ellen J. van Wolde, Tilburg University

We ordinarily take our emotions and the emotions of others as natural. In American and European popular culture, love, anger, fear are understood as if they are universally equally constructed. Recent research of, e.g. American and Japanese approaches of love and anger, demonstrate the huge differences in cultural constructions. Can these new cultural, cognitive and linguistic insights help us to develop a kind of research of the language of sentiment in the Hebrew bible? This paper will focus on the emotions of anger, fear and love, as expressed in biblical Hebrew and in biblical texts.


Psalm 137 Reexamined with a View to Voice
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Donald R Vance, Oral Roberts University

This paper offers a strophic structure for Psalm 137 that is based on voice. That is, it structures the poem in light of the speaker and addressee as revealed in the grammatical persons of the Hebrew forms the poem contains. The resultant four-strophe structure is contrasted with David Noel Freedman's five strophes that he delineated in his article "The Structure of Psalm 137." By treating seriously the distribution of voice in Psalm 137, this four-strophe analysis also reveals a chiastic arrangement of the strophes. This paper demonstrates the clarity that attention paid to voice brings in analyzing the structure of a poem and, consequently, the aid it offers in interpreting a poem.


Changing the Name of the Lord
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Caroline Vander Stichele, University of Amsterdam

This paper will explore the translation ethics embedded in the choice for gender inclusive language in modern bible translations. I will consider how bible translations serve as discursive sites, reflecting as well as shaping cultural paradigm shifts. I will analyze the power dynamics and strategies used to negotiate changes in translation policy. Taking the debate about the rendering of JHWH in the New Dutch Bible Translation (2004) as a particular case study, I will also analyze the ideological power struggle reflected in this debate and the interests involved in both changing and sticking to the traditional rendering of JHWH with Lord.


Tracing the Pauline Corpus in and out of the Canon
Program Unit: Gender, Sexuality, and the Bible
Caroline Vander Stichele, University of Amsterdam

Our investigation will focus on aspects of comportment, containment and (re)configuration of the body as reflected in both the Pauline corpus and in the NT book of Acts read alongside the Acts of Paul and Thecla. We will more specifically examine the gendered nature of that interaction and suggest that the patterns emerging in terms of how the body itself is comported and/or restrained reflect broader discursive engagements in early Christianity. A particular cohesion of bodily configuration can further be noted between the Pauline letters and canonical Acts that is transgendered/disrupted, in some respects, by the APT, in terms of tensions and strains within this other text. We conclude that the Pauline corpus evidences a particularly potent expression of binary body construction, providing its embedded (and embodied) apostolic corpse a hegemonic authority, which, strategically, is mimetically reproduced in the process of canonization and interpretation of the early Christian texts themselves and thus secures its own legacy.


A Comprehensive Database of the Yehud Jar Stamp Impressions: New Paleographical, Typological and Archaeological Findings
Program Unit: Paleographical Studies in the Ancient Near East
David S. Vanderhooft, Boston College

The authors have undertaken to produce a complete catalogue of the Yehud Jar Stamp Impressions from the Persian and early Hellenistic eras. This corpus of impressions is one of the largest groups of epigraphic data from Yehud; over 500 such stamps are known, almost all of them from legal excavations. The impressions have never been studied as a group, primarily because they have been published as isolated exemplars (or not at all) and are housed in widely disparate collections around the world. Several advances in analysis of the entire corpus have resulted from renewed study. Most notably, paleographic analysis has corrected or improved the reading of previously known stamps along with others that were undecipherable. In addition, a more precise assessment of the typological development of the Aramaic lapidary script has become possible. This new typology and an improved relative chronology for the corpus may have wider benefits for epigraphists and numismatists. Furthermore, a review of the stratigraphical data associated with the stamps improves their usefulness as a comparative data set for future excavators. Finally, statistical analysis of the distribution of stamps by type and by site allows for the development of new hypotheses about the historical and economic development of Yehud during the Persian era.


Subverting Narrative Qualities in Second-Century Retellings of “Pagan” Myths
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Zsuzsanna Varhelyi, Boston University

From the comparative perspective of “pagan,” early Christian and Jewish narratives, retellings of myths in the Roman Empire are of interest both as texts with transcendental referents and as potentially highly normative narratives. While the limited benefit in the import of transcendental aspects has already been established (esp. Beard in Graf 1993), in this paper I focus on the literary nature of narratives in which myths appear. Examining such Greek and Latin texts from the late first and second centuries C.E., I argue that most retellings subvert the potential narrative qualities of these stories and thereby mark them as prior (to use Whitmarsh’ phrase), strongly crystallized and meaningful only on further interpretation. On a most basic level, antiquarian summaries and euhemeristic rationalizations referred the stories exclusively back into the past. More importantly, ekphrastic descriptions (referring to representations that have become standardized), as part of or even replacement of the full story, could challenge the very concept of a meaningful narrative flow; especially if the ekphrastic depiction might have only referred to a select part of the story or not been fully appropriate for the larger narrative context (as in the majestic, elegant depictions of the otherwise angry and revengeful Venus in Apuleius’ Cupid and Psyche episode). Paradoxographic aggrandizement of lesser subjects as quasi-mythological stories was a further way of questioning the unique significance attributed to mythical narratives, as in Fronto’s praise of smoke and dust. Even the most positive of contemporary responses to mythic traditions, allegory, was subversive to the very concept of narrative in claiming that the real meaning of the stories was hidden behind their entertaining facades. I conclude by exploring some potential implications of this subversive attitude to mythological narratives especially in connection with contemporary philosophical and rhetorical constructions of lives and possibly even selfhood.


The Birkat ha-minim in the Last Decade:The Benediction of the Heretics in Research Since 1994
Program Unit: Poster Session
Matthew Versdahl, George Fox University

In the discussion of Christian origins and Judaism the Birkat ha-minim remains an important element. Some have contended that it had a role in the initial separation of Christianity from Judaism during its nascent years. The most recent summary of research on this topic appeared in 1994 in an article published by Van der Horst. Since then, scholars have continued to discuss the issue; some have proposed ideas that vindicate it from any involvement in the initial separation. Others have argued that it was not implemented during the most serious debates between Jews and Christians, while others have continued hold to the idea that its involvement is evident in the gospels, especially John. In this paper I seek to outline, briefly, research on the Birkat ha-minim since Van der Horst’s article, particularly as it relates to John. Following the outline of information I offer a suggestion on how to move on in the conversation, especially as it pertains to the gospels; the issue must be reconsidered in light of recent research by Richard Bauckham and company on gospel audiences. In their work, they challenge the current consensus that the gospel authors wrote to specific communities. They argue that the gospel audiences were not limited to a single homogeneous unit (i.e. Johannine community, Matthean community, etc.), but rather general Christian audiences in the wider church body. By arguing for a general audience it is impossible to determine if only one group experienced the Birkat ha-minim. Also, if one argues for a theological interpretation of the passages evidencing the benediction’s involvement in the separation presents a significant challenge to its culpability.


Ambiguity in Sovereignty: The Intersection of Divine Providence and Human Agency in the Book of Ruth
Program Unit: Theology of the Hebrew Scriptures
John W. Vest, University of Chicago

The Book of Ruth is a central text for the study of biblical theologies of God’s activity in human history, what systematic theologians discuss in regard to the concepts of divine providence and sovereignty. Bringing together previously unconnected insights regarding the literary structure and creative use of language in Ruth, this paper argues that the structurally central location and ambiguous wording of Naomi’s speech in Ruth 2:20 provide the interpretive key by which we can appreciate the author’s understanding of the coordination of divine providence and human agency. Ruth is not a story of autonomous human actors solely responsible for their own destinies; neither is it a strictly scripted account of divine orchestration. Instead, the author of Ruth suggests that divine providence and human agency, when the latter is characterized by hesed, are so closely bound that the phenomenological experience of each merge together. When the intertextual connections and canonical (LXX) location of Ruth are taken into consideration, this theolexical investigation goes far beyond an exercise in abstract speculation. Much more than an election story attempting to legitimate the Davidic dynasty or a narrative transition from the pre-monarchic traditions of Judges to the monarchial accounts of Samuel-Kings, the Book of Ruth is an important voice in the inner-biblical debate over the theological legitimacy of kingship in Israel. On the question of whether or not human kingship challenges divine sovereignty, the Book of Ruth argues that the two need not be mutually exclusive—human agency can be construed as a manifestation of divine providence and divine providence can be understood through the actions of human agents. This ambiguity in the conception of sovereignty is reflected in the various acts of hesed in the story of Ruth and interpreted by the suggestively ambiguous words of Naomi.


That We May See and Believe—Not!
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
James W. Voelz, Concordia Seminary

The issue of the resurrection in the Gospel of Mark is intimately tied to the issue of the gospel's ending. As currently accepted by the majority of scholars, the narrative ends at 16:8, with no resurrection appearance(s) but with (only) a report of Jesus' resurrection (16:6). Such an ending brings critical questions concerning textual criticism, grammar, style, and general literary appropriateness (e.g., do books/stories end this way?) to the fore. After a brief review of such issues, this paper will focus upon the literary appropriateness of ending Mark at 16:8 with (only) a report of Jesus' resurrection, in the context of Mark's telling of the story specifically. It will argue that such an ending is appropriate from two points of view: 1. the perspective of a reader/hearer, and 2. the development of the narrative itself. The argument will entail an attempt to demonstrate that Mark is a mature telling of the story of Jesus, not a straightforward or early attempt, that it assumes a knowledgeable reader, not an uninitiated one, that its linguistic usage is sophisticated, not simple or crude, and that one important pericope within the gospel is formulated in such a way as to assume that there will be no resurrection appearance later in the narrative.


Christ and Alexander the Great
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Samuel Vollenweider, University of Zurich

Philippians 2 compared with Plutarch's Tractates De Alexandri magni fortuna auf virtute


A Blended Tapestry: Seeing 1 Corinthians 6:12–20 through Socio-rhetorical Interpretation
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Robert H. von Thaden, Jr., Mercyhurst College

In this paper I examine how the images Paul uses in his argument against sexual immorality (1 Cor 6:12-20) are meaningful and how they serve his overarching rhetorical goals in the pericope. After beginning the argument with a pair of gnomic sayings concerning the proper relation of freedom to virtue and self-mastery, Paul employs a series of images to demonstrate to the Corinthians the incompatibility of sexual immorality [porneia] with the Christian body. In 6:13-14 he uses images of meats, the belly, and their destruction alongside those of the body, Christ, and their shared resurrection to illustrate two sides of the same apocalyptic reality. In 6:15-17 Paul introduces the figure of the “whore” [porne] and her body in a graphic argument against bringing Christ and the believer’s body into contact with this low status, impure, and malevolent character. Finally, in 6:18-20 Paul argues that the Corinthians should flee sexual immorality due to the sanctified nature of their bodies, which he illustrates using the images of temple and God’s holy spirit dwelling therein. By focusing on the rhetorical effect of these three groups of images, I believe that I am able to use the insights of conceptual integration theory to elucidate how the progressive texture of Paul’s argument functions in this pericope. Especially useful for this analysis is the notion of how conceptual blends compress vital relations. That Paul’s rationales for avoiding sexual immorality rely so heavily on images should come as no surprise to conceptual theorists. In marshalling the rhetorical power of images, Paul is able to attain the main goal of conceptual blending: achieving human scale. The images Paul uses allow his rhetoric to move away from abstract categories and to activate rich emotions in his very human audience.


4QMMT – The Composite Text of the Epilogue: An Alternative Arrangement
Program Unit: Qumran
Hanne von Weissenberg, University of Helsinki

The purpose of this presentation is to present an alternative arrangement of the text of the third section of 4QMMT, the epilogue. It is important to stress that the composite text can serve as a helpful tool, even though it may not accurately correspond to the original text form of the epilogue. All manuscripts attesting the final section of 4QMMT, the epilogue, contain variant readings witnessing scribal license and redactional activity. Apparently, the text form of the epilogue was not fixed and varied from scribe to scribe. The exact text form of the epilogue was not identical in the different manuscripts of 4QMMT – increasing the uncertainty of a composite text of this section. While working with 4QMMT, one should always consult the individual manuscripts and not rely on the composite text alone.


Jacobean Fusion: The Blend of Rhetorolects in the Epistle of James
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Wesley Hiram Wachob, Candler School of Theology

The Epistle of James is a written instance of deliberative rhetoric, a discourse that seeks to persuade its addressees to think and act in particular ways. Sometimes called "the" wisdom book of the New Testament, Jame's letter is an energetic blend of at least three early Christian rhetorolects: wisdom, prophetic, and apocalyptic. This essay will focus primarily on James's use of the topics of wisdom, and how these are blended with those of prophecy and apocalyptic into an energetic exhortation to speak and do the faith of Jesus Christ (Jas 2:1).


Jude 5: "...eidotas ymas apax panta oti Iesous laon ek ges Aigyptou sosas...": On the Reconstruction of the Initial Text Using the Coherence Based Genealogical Method
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Dr. Klaus Wachtel, University of Munster

According to an ancient strand of the manuscript tradition, the Letter of Jude says in v. 5 "that Jesus saved a people out of the land of Egypt". The recent 4th installment of the Editio Critica Maior renders this reading as the initial text of the passage (the 27th edition of the Nestle-Aland has: "the Lord saved"). The difficulty of Jude 5 led to a large number of variants and, consequently, to controversial text critical discussions in our times. It is, therefore, an excellent example for a demonstration of the Coherence Based Genealogical Method (CBGM) that was developed by Gerd Mink at the Münster Institute for New Testament Textual Research. This method has two predominant features. The first is the concept of coherence which re-defines and differentiates the criteria for assessing the attestations of variants, the so-called external criteria, in a way that was not possible before textual critics could use databases. The second feature is the ability to integrate the traditional textcritical methods and use them in combination with the newly based external criteria. The paper will show how the CBGM makes use of the total of textcritical assessments of variants in the Letter of Jude for a fresh analysis of the problems of one particularly difficult passage.


In Quest of Survival: The Implications of the Reconstruction Theology of Ezra-Nehemiah
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Robert Wafawanaka, Virginia Union University

*


The Impurity of Spirits in the Synoptic Gospels
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Clinton Wahlen, AIIAS Theological Seminary

One of the more puzzling features of early Christian attitudes toward purity is the frequent reference in the Synoptic Gospels to spirits as impure, particularly in view of the absence of similar expressions in Greco-Roman literature up through the second century C.E. Summarizing some of the findings of my dissertation (Clinton Wahlen, Jesus and the Impurity of Spirits in the Synoptic Gospels [WUNT 2/185; Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2004]), this study explores the dissimilar language employed by the Gospel writers, examining how each Gospel’s distinctive portrayal of unclean spirits fits within its overall perspective on purity. In Mark’s Gospel the description of spirits as "impure" has a dual significance. The exorcisms among Jews magnify the holiness and power of Jesus as the Son of God to drive away unclean spirits. The exorcisms among Gentiles reach beyond traditional boundaries, showing that Jews and Gentiles can eat from the same messianic "table." The exorcisms in Matthew’s Gospel illustrate the healing power of Jesus as the messianic son of David. Unclean spirits appear only in relation to Israel, suggesting a clash of kingdoms whereby the nation’s destiny hinges on its response to the Spirit of God. The Gospel of Luke utilizes Jewish ideas of ritual purity to address moral issues. Demon-possession, like physical illness, is symptomatic of Satanic oppression from which Jesus brings messianic release in accordance with the larger portrayal of salvation history. The clear reluctance of the Synoptic writers to abandon traditional categories in their characterization of demonic activity suggests that they write from a standpoint less removed from Judaism than is sometimes supposed.


Unbound Hair and Ointmented Feet
Program Unit: Gender, Sexuality, and the Bible
Elaine M. Wainwright, University of Auckland

In a recent article, Charles Cosgrove has undertaken an intertextual reading of Luke 7:36-50 in relation to the unbound hair of the woman of Luke 7:36-50. He concludes that one of the many possible ways in which the woman’s unbound hair can be understood is in terms of the “sexual suggestiveness” of her letting down of her hair. A little earlier, I undertook to read intertextually with Athenaeus’ Deipnosophistae, Mark 14:3-9 the woman who pours out ointment over the head of Jesus in the context of a study of the genderization of healing in early Christianity. The focus of this study was the pouring out of an alabaster jar of perfumed muron over the head, an action that Athenaeus characterizes as typical at the beginning of the symposium following a meal or deipnon. The woman of Luke 7:36-50 brings an alabaster flask of ointment with which she anoints the feet of Jesus and in the Johannine tradition Mary of Bethany likewise anoints Jesus’ feet with ointment of pure nard. Each woman wipes Jesus feet with her unbound hair. In this paper, I propose to bring together the symbolism of both the unbound hair and ointmented feet. By way of an extended intertextual study, I will examine the ways in which both gender and sexuality are being constructed in relation to these women of unbound hair who ointment male feet. A socio-rhetorical reading of texts will be brought into dialaogue with constructivist theories of sexuality and gender.


Honey from the Rock?
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Arthur Walker-Jones, University of Winnipeg

Feminist hermeneutics of the Bible has long recognized that male metaphors for God legitimize patriarchy. Feminist hermeneutics is suspicious that even female images may serve patriarchal functions, but attempts to recover female metaphors. An ecological hermeneutics recognizes that human metaphors for God legitimate anthropocentrism and ecocide. An ecological hermeneutics should be suspicious that ecological metaphors may have been co-opted by ecocide, but should seek to recover the voice and story of Earth. This paper uses current reflection on metaphor and contemporary myth theory to develop a similar analysis of ecological metaphors for God and their role in the transformation of Earth community. Rock is an essential element of Earth and a common metaphor for God in the Bible. An investigation of the images and narratives associated with God as Rock in the book of Psalms assists in recovering the voice, character, and role of Earth, and suggests ways they might be connected to contemporary narratives in ways that would empower Earth community.


Images of Death and Destruction in the Apocalyptic Art of Basil Wolverton
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
John Walliss, Liverpool Hope University

For centuries the images of death and destruction found within the Book of Revelation have inspired artists such as Dürer and Bosch to create works of both beautiful and shocking in equal measure. In this paper, I examine one much more recent attempt to render the apocalyptic images of Revelation within art: the illustrations of Basil Wolverton that accompanied Herbert Armstrong’s publication ‘1975 in Prophecy!’. The artwork, I argue, demonstrates how the images of apocalypse continue to play a role within popular culture, and I explore the ways in which the text - and, in particular, the images of death and destruction found within it - are re-read in the light of 1950s Cold War paranoia and Armstrong’s own particular understanding of prophecy and the End Times.


Stigmata: The Sayings of the Hollywood Jesus
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Richard G. Walsh, Methodist College

While quoting the Gospel of Thomas (3, 77), Stigmata, a 1999 religious horror film, characterizes Thomas differently than most scholars do: (1) Stigmata’s Thomas is a first-century Aramaic gospel; (2) it is Jesus’ ipsissima verba; and (3) the institutional church “hid” this threatening gospel. This interpretation translates Thomas into the Hollywood gospel which hallows Jesus and the individual’s freedom of religious expression but vilifies institutional religion. This ethic plays a major role in both popular and intellectual American religion, and it also reflects the Hollywood convention of arraying the lone, true hero (though here a romantic duo) versus the corrupt institution. Stigmata’s use of St. Francis and the stigmata follows this convention and depicts Jesus and the film’s heroes in terms of the beleaguered individual at the sacred center of modern mythology and the Hollywood gospel. Accordingly, Stigmata privileges sayings that emphasize the kingdom or divinity within the individual believer. Thus, the spirit that haunts the film’s stigmatic is not a traditional daimon, but a more modern deity, a heroic individual who will not let death itself thwart his mission (cf. Thomas 1, 111). For the most part, Stigmata simply ignores elements of Thomas that do not fit this Hollywood gospel: (1) passages expressing a disdain for this world (Thomas 27, 56, 110-11); and (2) passages idealizing androgyny (Thomas 22, 106, 114). Instead, as required by the Hollywood gospel, Stigmata idealizes the romantic duo. Most intriguingly, Stigmata rewrites Jesus’ sayings in the film genre of religious horror. Economics plays a role here, as horror was the best venue for religion before Gibson’s revival of the religious epic, but the result bears comparison to the scholarly assumption that the sayings of Jesus were eventually canonically housed in passion (should we say horror?) gospels.


Hallowing or Horrifying the Cross? St. Mel of the Cross
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Richard G. Walsh, Methodist College

The gospels hallow the cross by reading that spectacle of imperial torture as an act of divine providence. Ritual, art, and (Jesus) film complete the transubstantiation of this death into gospel and into the peculiar Christian aesthetic. Now taken almost for granted, the hallowing trend even transfigures the deaths of Hollywood characters like John Coffey in The Green Mile. Given the discourse’s banality, the relentless, close-up focus on Jesus’ passionate sufferings in Gibson’s The Passion of the Christ is, dare we say it, quite refreshing. Gibson’s visuals take us closer to the horror that the gospels so glibly hallow by relying heavily upon two Hollywood film conventions, both of which are attractive to audiences and steeped in violence: (1) the convention of the “death wish” hero (cf. Gibson’s Braveheart); and (2) the Hollywood convention of reprising religion in the genre of horror (e.g., Stigmata). The Passion’s horror is evident not only in Gibson’s androgynous Satan and in Judas’s demonic torment but also in the film’s introductory scenes and in the supernatural events at the cross, which suggest that God – as Stigmata does not – is the true source of suffering. Following Gibson’s suggestion, we can see the gospel horror even more clearly if we turn to Jesus films like those of Arcand or Jones whose plots substitute misfortune for the gospels’ providence. Their demythologizing does not end human suffering (cf. the films of Bresson or Pasolini’s La ricotta), but it does show by eliminating God from the story the divine culprit at the heart of the gospel, as well as the horror therein of the crucifixion of the world (cf. Dali’s St. John of the Cross). At that point, we may say with a character in Flatliners, “Death is beautiful. What a bunch of crap.”


Banqueting Restrictions and Keeping Your Converts: Reading 1 Corinthians 11:17–34 in Light of the Lex Coloniae Genetivae CXXXII
Program Unit: Social History of Formative Christianity and Judaism
James C. Walters, Boston University

This paper relates the restrictions on banquets found in the colonial charter of Urso, a Roman colony in Spain, to the restrictions Paul places on the ‘banquets’ of Christ-believers in Roman Corinth. A significant portion of the colonial charter survives in an inscription on bronze tablets that was found on the ancient site in the Baetis river valley. Although the inscription is dated to the late first century CE, the colony was established in 44 BCE. Chapter CXXXII forbids what might be called “general hospitality” in the setting of the election of magistrates. The law seeks to limit bribery or influence peddling though banquets and gifts. The paper argues that “general hospitality” and “influence peddling through banquets” are helpful constructs though which to read 1 Cor. 11:17-34 since Paul is so concerned in the Corinthian correspondence with the influence rivals have over his converts in his absence.


The Gilded Hypothesis Revisited: The Authorial Unity of Luke and Acts
Program Unit: Formation of Luke and Acts
Patricia Walters, Beloit College

This paper re-examines the almost universally held assumption that Luke and Acts were written-edited by a unitary author. The unquestioned premise rests on three shaky pillars for support: (1) the preface of each book dedicated the work to the same person, Theophilus; (2) second-to-fourth century teachers of the early Church who simply reinforce the claim; and (3) subsequent scholarship on Luke and Acts, which in fact presumes common authorship when analyzing linguistic, stylistic, and theological patterns and motifs. My paper proposes a fresh examination of the question in three stages. First, I search for key passages in each book virtually certain to be authorial, i.e., the seams and summaries, as identified by major modern scholars. Second, I analyze the seams and summaries in Greek by means of criteria found in ancient critical works on prose composition, i.e., criteria such as euphony among sentence elements (e.g., hiatus), prose rhythm, and word arrangement as they functioned in antiquity. Third, after a detailed analysis, I use stylometrics (statistical testing) to determine whether the differences found are statistically significant. The results are thus impartially compared with respect to the way in which the composition of each book’s seams and summaries cohere, in details of rhythm and harmony of sentence elements as well as in the overall sentence structure and logic. In the end, I show the authorial unity of Luke and Acts must be called into question. [***To the Reader: This paper derives from my dissertation (May 2005); upon satisfactory completion of certain revisions it is to be published by the Society for New Testament Studies Monograph Series and Cambridge University Press.***]


Death as Begetter
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Stanley D. Walters, Tyndale University College, Toronto, Canada

The semantic range of the two nouns chebel "cord, snare, portion" and chebel (usually plural) "pains, pangs," is distinct enough that the two do not usually get confused with one another. But there is a group of four instances of chebel "cord" (2 Sm 22:6, Ps 18:5, 6, 116,3) where the masoretic vocalization appears deliberately to encourage a reference to the homophone. The plural construct appears anomalously vocalized with a seghol instead of with a patach (as, e.g., Josh 17:5, Is 5:18). The effect is to understand "the pangs of death" instead of "the cords of death." The LXX follows with odines "pangs," to which Ac 2:24 alludes. I suggest an intended wordplay which regards death not as that which immobilizes, but as that which births into a new existence: death as begetter rather than terminator. The word-play joins other intimations in the Hebrew Bible of a life to come.


Seeing Paul's Point: Rhetography in 1 Corinthians
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Charles A. Wanamaker, University of Cape Town

"Rhetography," or the pictorial texture of a text, builds upon the insights of cognitive theorists that the mind's ability to "picture" what is spoken is essential to the cognitive processing of narrative and argument, and that these pictures, in turn, evoke social and cultural settings, patterns, and learned "logic" that nurture the argumentative force of the text. This paper will explore the rhetography of a segment of 1 Corinthians as a starting point for socio-rhetorical analysis.


Moses on Mt. Sinai: Rethinking 'Rewritten Bible'
Program Unit: Rethinking the Concept and Categories of 'Bible' in Antiquity
Tammie R. Wanta, University of North Carolina, Charlotte

The presentation employs a tradition-history approach and features Hebrew Bible and Dead Sea Scrolls.


Paul and Job in Philippians 1:19
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
James P. Ware, University of Evansville

The intertextual allusion in Philippians 1:19 to Job, the paradigmatic righteous sufferer, greatly enriches Paul’s hortatory self-description in Philippians 1:18b-20. Previous analysis has focused almost exclusively on MT Job as the context of Paul’s allusion. However, Paul’s citation of Job 13:16 is from the Old Greek (LXX) version, not the MT, and thus draws on the conceptual background of this passage in the LXX, which is very different from the MT. In LXX Job 13:14b-16 the ground of Job’s assurance of salvation is not, as in MT, his boldness to argue his case forthrightly in God’s presence, but his bold speech and reproof before the ruler who seeks to put him to death. The echo thus functions to highlight Paul’s confrontation, through his bold witness to Christ, with Roman imperial power in the person of the emperor Nero. Moreover, LXX Job, in contrast to MT, explicitly portrays Job’s reversal of fortunes as culminating in his resurrection from the dead (LXX Job 42:17). Strikingly, Paul in Philippians also alludes intertextually to several other texts which are major focus points of theological reflection on the resurrection in ancient Judaism (Daniel 12:3, Wisdom of Solomon 2-5). Paul’s echo of LXX Job in Philippians 1:19 thus functions in Philippians within a web of allusions to key second temple texts which highlight the resurrection of the dead. Taken together, these echoes serve to enrich and deepen Paul’s explicit teaching on the resurrection within the letter (3:10-11; 3:20-21). When Philippians is read intertextually, both the counter-imperial force of Paul’s exhortation, and the related theme of the vindication of the suffering righteous through resurrection from the dead, are much more central and pervasive in the letter than previously recognized.


A Brotherhood at Qumran? Searching for Fictive Familial Language in the Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Early Christian Families
Cecilia Wassen, Wilfrid Laurier University

The language of son-ship in the Dead Sea Scrolls, particularly 'the Sons of Light' versus the 'the Sons of Darkness,' has generated much scholarly discussion. At the same time, other, less prominent expressions of fictive kinship relations, such as 'brothers' and father-son metaphors, have received less attention. This study will locate where family imagery is found in the Scrolls and explore how fictive familial language is used to explain various relationships, i.e., that between members, between members and outsiders, and between humans and God. We will discuss whether different family metaphors indicate egalitarian or hierarchical social structures and whether there is evidence of a negative stance toward the biological family. Aspects from the social identity approach will illuminate the various levels in which familial language works. Among the documents that will be examined are serakhim (1QS, CD,M), sapiential texts (e.g., 4Q185), pesharim and hymns. The study will offer points of comparison with the early Christian groups.


Narrative Bludgeons: The Clash of Values in the Life of Aesop and the Gospel of Mark
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
David F. Watson, United Theological Seminary

Historians are faced with a relative paucity of written documents that reflect the particular perspectives of lower-strata people in the first century world. The Life of Aesop and the Gospel of Mark, however, not only reflect lower-strata perspectives and experiences, but provide boldfaced critiques of the accepted values and practices of the upper strata. In the Life of Aesop, the slave Aesop repeatedly dishonors his master in very serious ways and is presented as his master’s superior. Although this work is generally presented as a comic novel, it is also an affront to the values of the wealthy and educated elite. Slaves would have found this tale quite satisfying, but their masters would have found it deeply offensive. The Gospel of Mark also subverts values that favor the elite, although in different ways than the Life of Aesop. Mark’s Jesus offers teaching that holds up slaves and servants and undermines the status of the wealthy, the “great,” and the “first.” Further, the centrality of the cross in Mark’s gospel would have been particularly offensive to high-status individuals who considered themselves above even the mere mention of the word “cross.” The upshot of this analysis is that the Life of Aesop and the Gospel of Mark offer glimpses into the ways in which lower-strata individuals dealt with and perceived their own status and honor vis-à-vis members of the higher strata. These works represent a kind of narrative bludgeoning of the values of the upper class. Through the easily remembered and reproduced vehicle of narrative, they offer a social vision in which those conventionally on the lower end of the social spectrum are given precedence over those conventionally on the upper end.


Rhetoric of Ritual Narrative in Leviticus 10
Program Unit: Pentateuch
James W. Watts, Syracuse University

Much ink has been spilled in efforts to find the historical or literary meaning of the story of Nadab and Abihu in Leviticus 10:1-3. This paper focuses rather on the story’s rhetorical effect. By asking what persuasive purpose the story of the Nadab and Abihu, and the rest of Leviticus 10, was intended to achieve, the chapter appears in a different light. Rather than standing in literary opposition to the celebration of Aaron in Leviticus 8-9, the chapter’s shocks and ambiguities turn out to reinforce his prestige. Leviticus 10 demonstrates the dangers to which priests expose themselves and shows God granting them the interpretive authority that allows them to perform their duties successfully. The fact that the reader/hearer cannot understand either the nature of the danger in 10:1-3 or the logic of the Aaron’s ruling in 10:16-20 only increases the mystique of the priestly office. Rhetorically, Lev 10:1-3 does not function deconstructively more than any other P texts, but rather reinforces the monopolistic claims of the Aaronide priests. The mistake of both modernist and postmodernist readers of Leviticus 10 has been to assume that the purpose of the story is to promote understanding of the cult. Ritual texts serve a far larger range of rhetorical purposes than just didactic instruction. This chapter, just like its context, aims to persuade its audience that the Aaronide priests hold a legitimate monopoly over Israel’s cult.


Advantages and Disadvantages of Working with Multi-Spectral Images.
Program Unit:
Thomas Wayment, Brigham Young University

*


"Suffering Violence" and the Kingdom of Heaven (Mt. 11:12): A Matthean Manual for Life in a Time of War
Program Unit: Matthew
Dorothy Jean Weaver, Eastern Mennonite Seminary

Matthew the Gospel Writer has much to say on the theme of “suffering violence.” As Jesus comments to his listeners (11:12), “From the days of John the Baptist until now the kingdom of heaven has suffered violence, and the violent take it by force.” Jesus’ words are surely true. But the truth they express extends well beyond the temporal framework delineated by “the days of John the Baptist” on the one hand and the “now” of Jesus’ own ministry on the other. In fact the “violence” portrayed in Matthew’s Gospel reaches all the way from “the blood of righteous Abel” (23:35) to the “great suffering” that precedes the end of the age and the parousia (24:21, 29; cf. 24:30-31). Through the narrative rhetoric of his Gospel Matthew offers multi-layered perspectives to his readers on life lived in the face of ongoing violence. These perspectives reflect (1) the lived experiences of the “righteous ones,” (2) the words of Jesus depicting or predicting the sufferings of himself and others, (3) the words of Jesus calling people to faithful responses to the violence they encounter, and (4) Matthew’s own narrative rhetoric offering theological reflection on the suffering of the righteous. This study will examine the topic of “suffering violence” in three stages: (1) Part one will focus on the nature and cause of the violence faced by the "righteous ones" within Matthew’s narrative. (2) Part two will focus on the words of Jesus calling his followers to faithful and strategic response to the violence they encounter. (3) Part three will focus on the rhetorical strategy of Matthew’s narrative vis-à-vis the question of violence and assess Matthew’s theological reflections on the suffering of the righteous. It will conclude with reflections on the present-day implications of Matthew’s text for “living in a time of war.”


Intertexture and Rhetorical Strategy in First Peter’s Apocalyptic Discourse: A Study in Socio-rhetorical Criticism
Program Unit: Methodological Reassessments of the Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Robert L. Webb, McMaster University

This essay examines the role of intertexture within 1 Peter’s apocalyptic discourse and the contribution this makes to the letter’s rhetorical strategy. The methodological framework used for this analysis is socio-rhetorical criticism as developed by Vernon K. Robbins. The author of 1 Peter draws prominently on apocalyptic traditions from the Jewish scriptures and Second Temple literature as resources for oral-scribal intertexture which are recontextualized to interpret the significance of Jesus’ suffering and death as well as the suffering being experienced by the readers. This provides an interpretive framework for the readers to respond to the author’s exhortations and instructions. The analysis in this essay demonstrates the significant role played by apocalyptic discourse within the rhetorical strategy of 1 Peter.


Reader-Response Analysis of 1 Peter
Program Unit: Methodological Reassessments of the Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Randall C. Webber, None

This study describes some methods and possible results of an examination of the early reception of 1 Peter. The method postulates an hypothetical, second century audience in accordance by recourse to recognized criteria from the social anthropology of traditional Mediterranean cultures and then examines the epistle as a written artifact read aloud to such an audience. The examination concludes that (1) purported authorship by a figure about whom Paul had expressed an equivocal opinion plays little or no role in the understanding of the epistle’s content and (2) the epistle’s behavioral instructions are entirely comprehensible within a social and intellectual milieu defined by the social norms of classical antiquity and clarified further by an hypothetical Pauline, deutero-Pauline, and Pastoral literary context.


Qoheleth and His Creator
Program Unit: The Texts of Wisdom in Israel, Early Judaism, and the Eastern Mediterranean World
Stuart Weeks, Durham University

In some recent work there has been a greater willingness than in the past to recognise a distinction between Qoheleth, as character or protagonist, and the actual author of the book which bears his name. Some interesting potential interpretations of the work open up if we explore the possibility that the author is not simply using this character as a mouthpiece for his own views, but as a way of caricaturing and satirising a world-view with which he disagrees.


Noah Breaks His Silence: The Case of the “Book of Noah” in Light of the Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Qumran
Matthias Weigold, University of Vienna

One of the major challenges in the interpretative history of the biblical story of Noah and the Flood arises from the fact that Noah does not utter a single word in the whole Flood story. Although in Gen 6:9 and 7:1 Noah is characterized as exceptionally righteous, he does not intercede for his fellow human beings at all. This paper deals with a whole book, in which Noah breaks his silence, i.e. the “Book of the Words of Noah” as attested in the Genesis Apocrpyhon (1QapGen ar v 29–xviii 23). The heading “Book of the Words of Noah” in 1QapGen ar v 29 as well as comparison between the section entitled “Book of the Words of Noah” on the one hand and the ancient references to Noachitic writings on the other hand argue that in 1QapGen ar v 29–xviii 23 either a copy of an ancient Book of Noah or an epitome is preserved. This Book of Noah gives a first-person singular narrative of Noah’s whole life. In its genre it reminds of other rewritten bible compositions such as the Book of Jubilees, Aramaic Levi Document or the Book of Watchers. The Book of Noah is to be dated either in the 3rd or the late 4th century B.C.E. Thus, it is the first preserved document in which Noah breaks his silence.


King of Babylon, Loyal Shepherd: Some Thoughts on the Life and Times of Nebuchadnezzar II (604–562 B.C.E.)
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
David B. Weisberg, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion

This paper seeks to explore the question: What brushstrokes can we use to fill in the portrait of the man who, according to one Greek historian, was "more powerful than Hercules"? We shall investigate whether—or to what degree—we can profitably use biographies of other rulers from the ancient Near East and the Hellenistic world in order to draw parallels with that of Nebuchadnezzar and flesh out his story. What are the benefits and disadvantages of looking at later literary "Images" of Nebuchadnezzar; and can we apply a "biblical" perspective to evaluate what Kipling in another context called "The Savage Wars of Peace" of an ancient conqueror?


A User-Friendly Introduction to Okhlah we’Okhlah
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Judy Weiss, Jewish Theological Seminary of America

Okhlah we’Okhlah is a collection of hundreds of masoretic notes which catalogue a wide variety of lexical, grammatical, orthographical, intertextual, and syntactic phenomena of the Hebrew Bible. The work, probably first edited in written form in the 9th or 10th centuries, takes its name from its incipit, the first two items listed in its first note. The treatise, however, was also often called by the name Ha-Masoret Ha-Gedolah “The Great Masorah.” By presenting a few case studies of masoretic notes, we will acquaint participants with the different recensions of Okhlah we’Okhlah, its various modern editions and associated tools as well as the masoretic terminology needed to use this treatise.


Biblical Iconography and Yearnings for the Temple Cult in Ancient Synagogue Art
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Zeev Weiss, Hebrew University of Jerusalem

The lecture will discuss the various biblical depictions incorporated into the mosaic floors of ancient synagogues, arguing that the selection of themes focused on those characterizing the Judaeo-Christian controversy and expressing the beliefs of the Jewish community and its hope for the redemption and restoration of the Temple cult.


The Transition from Sleep to Death: Iconographic Approaches to the New Testament
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Annette Weissenrieder, University of Heidelberg

Alongside the traditional concentration on textual, historical-religious sources, there has developed in recent years an interest in visual sources in the ancient world. Images and texts are part of culture, and hence also part of its symbol system, and it is with the use of such symbolic systems that people communicate. In some New Testament texts, there is a connection between sleep and death (eg. 1 Thess 4:13-15) that can be illustrated by iconographic images. On the basis of examining three different approaches to the interpretation of iconography, it becomes clear that the transition between sleep and death is fluid. The iconological analysis of Erwin Panofsky interprets visual images on the basis of the intellectual history of the time. The Motif-Analysis of Otmar Keel investigates the thematic constellation in visual images. The semiotic analysis of Tonio Hölscher seeks to interpret the logical deep structure of images.


True Doctrines and Character Flaws: Damaskios’ Standards for Regulating and Generating Neoplatonic Identities in the Late Antique Empire
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Tennyson Wellman, University of Pennsylvania

In the surviving fragments of Damaskios’ Philosophial History (a wide-ranging gazetteer or philosophical Who’s Who), the final holder of the Platonic Succession at Athens attempted to police and integrate the diverse positions held within the Neoplatonic communities. This was an unusual variation of the doxographical literature, in that it focused on the generations immediately preceding and including the author. The specificity and catholicism of the textual in-gathering of his geographically dispersed community inverted earlier Platonists’ (such as Noumenios of Apamea or Plotinos and Porphyry) frequent use of finely pointed invective or broadly painted descriptions of opponents. Damaskios’ own biography shows that he intended to create a unified social body capable of survival and resistance within a Christian empire, and developed a psychological and doctrinal model of the ideal philosopher to guide and inspire that social group. Variations of this process of idealization, regulation, and codification are familiar from the comparative study of religion. I will examine the contexts of Damaskios’ project and the strategies he employed, and compare them with the formation of modern orthodox Sikh identities (as detailed by Harjot Oberoi). The variations in socio-political contexts and models of group identity available determined the regulatory strategies used, as well as their implications, in both instances.


Prayer as Prophylactic against Demonic Forces in Mark
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Rodney Werline, First Christian Church, Greensboro, NC

As is well known, the Gospel of Mark contains several exorcism stories. Drawing on an apocalyptic framework, these stories see the arrival of God’s kingdom in Jesus’ ministry as the signal of the defeat of demonic powers. However, these demonic powers do not give up easily, and they continue to manifest themselves in the world, especially, as Horsley and Meyers argue, in Roman imperial rule. Less frequently recognized, however, is that Mark connects the ability to confront, oppose and withstand these demonic forces to the practice of prayer. In my paper I will first establish Mark’s connection between prayer and resisting and confronting demonic forces. Second, drawing on medical anthropology, I will explore the social, political, and psychological aspects of illness/possession in Mark in order to explain the way in which those who suffer are described as experiencing the oppressive social structures in their bodies. The text, of course, imagines their problems as a religious struggle, which in Mark is of cosmic proportions. Because the author conceives the illness/possession as basically religious, he offers the practice of prayer as both a preparation for confronting these demonic forces and a prophylactic against their powers. As I will show, this role for prayer is not unique to Mark. Texts in Tobit, 1 Enoch, Jubilees, and the Qumran scrolls also call on prayer in the struggle against demonic powers.


When is a System Not a System?
Program Unit: Qumran
Ian Werrett, Saint Martin's College

The argument that the Dead Sea Scrolls contain a cohesive sectarian purity system is based upon three premises: (1) that all of the documents from Qumran can and should be read in light of one another irrespective of any differences in age, author/redactor, or genre; (2) that the scrolls exhibit a strict or stringent interpretation of the legal material from the Torah; and (3) that the texts are in overwhelming agreement on the subject of purity. Although we agree that the documents from Qumran contain many similarities and common concerns, one questions the accuracy of an approach that minimizes or ignores important factors such as dating and genre. Furthermore, while it is true that the scrolls frequently exhibit a stringent interpretation of the biblical material, one wonders if this is the most precise way to establish a concrete relationship between these texts. As for the premise that the scrolls are in overwhelming agreement on the subject of purity, an independent and comprehensive examination of the ritual purity rulings from Qumran reveals that there is nearly as much explicit disagreement in the scrolls as there is explicit agreement. In the following paper, which is an outgrowth of my doctoral dissertation on the concept of ritual purity in the Dead Sea Scrolls (University of St Andrews, 2006), it will argued that the documents from Qumran fail to exhibit a cohesive sectarian purity system. This conclusion will be supported through a detailed analysis of those places in the scrolls which appear to exhibit explicit agreement and explicit disagreement that goes beyond the witness of Scripture.


The Elegy for Saul and Jonathan in Its Prose Context
Program Unit: Lament in Sacred Texts and Cultures
Jan Wim Wesselius, Theological University Kampen

There has been a lot of discussion about the question whether the elegy which David pronounces in 1 Samuel 1:17-27 originally belongs in its present narrative context. I will attempt to show that at least three of the common literary patterns in classical Hebrew prose texts are to be found in this poetical composition also: (a) ambiguity at the beginning of an episode or composition; (b) disruption of the expectation pattern of the reader or hearer; (c) discontinuous insertion of the most important piece of information to be conveyed to the reader (in this case the verses 1:25-26), compensated by additional indications of continuity. We shall then see that all this goes a long way towards explaining the present literary form of this elegy and its place in the flow of the narrative.


The Poetry of Job as a Resource for the Articulation of Embodied Lament in the Context of HIV and AIDS in South Africa
Program Unit: Lament in Sacred Texts and Cultures
Gerald O. West, University of Natal

The HIV/AIDS pandemic is smothered in silence. Breaking the silence usually results in stigma and discrimination, sometimes even death. Even the churches are silent in the face of HIV and AIDS. And yet those who have courageously chosen to know their status long to be able to talk about their situation. While the Bible is generally used tofuel stigma and discrimination, there are sites in which the Bible is being used to enable an articulation of the embodied 'theologies' of those struggling to live positively with the virus. This paper will explore two sites, one a contextual Bible study support group among those living openly as HIV-positive and one the art work of artist Trevor Makhoba. Both are South African sites in which the poetry of Job has been appropriated in an attempt to try to talk theologically about HIV and AIDS.


Contending with the Bible: Biblical Interpretation as a Site of Struggle
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Gerald O. West, University of KwaZulu-Natal

The Bible cannot be abandoned to the biblical studies academy, nor can it be allowed to be used in an uncontested way by 'right wing' ecclesial and political forces. The struggle for life against the idols of death demands that those of us with 'left' agendas take up the Bible, in contexts where it is a significant text, as one of our weapons of struggle in collaborative acts with those at the forefront of particular social struggles.The paper begins with the current South African context in which the state, led by a liberation government, wants to limit the religious realm to the moral; in which civil society, embarrassed by religious talk, wants to read the constitution and not religious texts; and in which churches have retreated to confessional concerns and therefore limit their public pronouncements to issues of corruption and morality. These three publics, then, have conspired together to constrain the role of the Bible in South African society. And yet South Africa has a long history of the Bible as a weapon of struggle and biblical scholars as socially engaged organic intellectuals. So the paper explores our current moment, caught as it is between these two trajectories, and affirms a place for the socially engaged biblical scholar in the socio-political realm. The paper will draw on three case studies, the struggle against unemployment, HIV/AIDS, and violence against women and children, as sites in which to examine what it means to contend with the Bible, both in South Africa and more generally.


A Discourse Analysis of the Letter to the Hebrews: Relationship between Form and Meaning
Program Unit: Hebrews
Cynthia Long Westfall, McMaster Divinity College

The structure of the book of Hebrews has been the subject of an ongoing debate, particularly over the last fifty years. In fact, G.E. Rice complains that since Vanhoye opened his discussion on structure in 1963, the message of Hebrews has become a victim of “structural push and shove” (“Apostasy as a Motif and Its Effect on the Structure of Hebrews,” AUSS 23 [1985], 29-35, see 29-30).” Certainly the discussion has recently been enriched by a variety of approaches to New Testament criticism and interpretation that form the bases of various proposals. Among these, George Guthrie has introduced the relatively new discipline of discourse analysis to the discussion, a methodology that shows great potential in offering a new perspective on old debates. Discourse analysis involves the application of linguistics and its research methodology to the discourse. It offers the potential to synthesize various areas of biblical as well and linguistic investigation into one model in the consideration of structure. The model utilized in my approach is distinct from Guthrie’s. It is primarily based on a form of systemic functional linguistics, but is informed by other linguistic studies. But the focus here is not on the methodology, but on the product of the process: a coherent description of the design or structure of the book of Hebrews. While no a priori preference was given to any previous proposal for the structure, my results support a tripartite asymmetrical structure that climaxes with the relocation of the readers in the Holy of Holies in the sanctuary in heavenly Jerusalem. The proposed message or mental representation of the discourse will be different from the traditional offerings, but it will be drawn from the author’s own words and it will account for all of the texts in the discourse. Furthermore, it will be a message that was relevant for a community in crisis.


Discourse Analysis: Chunking and Cohesion
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Cynthia Long Westfall, McMaster Divinity College

Overivew of concepts from discourse analysis related to the structuring and arrangement of text, including chunking and cohesion. An example application is presented from 1 John.


"The Hands of David": A Reconstruction of the System of Gestures Underlying the Masoretic Accents
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
John Wheeler, King David's Harp, Inc.

As early as the Babylonian Talmud, there is a connection drawn between the word “te`amim” and the use of gestures to mark the punctuation of the Hebrew verbal text. Various ancient synagogue communities still use such gestures. According to later “reader’s manuals”, the written te`amim of the Masoretic Text are transcriptions of such gestures. The manual translated into French as the Manuel du Lecteur by Jules Derenbourg (1870) gives an incomplete list of such gestures. In her original French book (La musique de la Bible révélée), Suzanne Haik-Vantoura cited some of Derenbourg’s translations of the descriptions of those gestures. Only after I edited the English translation of Haik-Vantoura’s book (The Music of the Bible Revealed) did I obtain a full copy of the Manuel du Lecteur (in Hebrew and French). It became clear that Derenbourg’s translations were often inexact. On further study, I came to believe that a complete reconstruction of the system of gestures (chironomy) behind the written te`amim was possible. Far from proving to be “child’s play” as Haik-Vantoura suggested in her book, the task took me four years of work to complete. Haik-Vantoura, however, thought that the results of my work were “both ingenious and judicious”. At the very least, the reconstructed gestures illustrate how Haik-Vantoura’s “deciphering key” to the written notation functions – especially to the non-musician. Haik-Vantoura suggested that the Psalms in particular were conducted by such gestures, in keeping with the nuances of the Hebrew text of 1 Chronicles 25 and other passages in 2 Chronicles and Ezra. Accordingly, I follow biblical precedent in calling my reconstructed gestures “the hands of David”. But such gestures could have arisen much earlier; similar gestures were used to conduct vocal and instrumental music in ancient Egypt since before Mosaic times.


Grace Aguilar and the Women of Israel: A Study in Subtlety
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Ellen White, University of St. Michael's College

Grace Aguilar (1816-1847), a 19th century Sephardic Jew in England, was convinced that she could make a contribution to the world of theological studies and promote the Jewish faith at a time and place where it was not well regarded. Others were not so sure. Therefore, she found creative ways to use the socially acceptable methods to promote her insightful, ecumenical, and sometimes radical views. This is particularly true of her theories on separate sphere feminism that she develops based on the lives of the women of the Bible and is presented in her book The Women of Israel. By adopting an inconspicuous means for her message, she was able to reach a larger audience and have a greater impact on history.


Old Greek Psalm 119 (= MT Psalm 120): Translation and Hermeneutics
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Wade White, University of Toronto

*


Resisting the Past: Ancient Israel in Western Memory
Program Unit: Mapping Memory: Tradition, Texts, and Identity
Keith W. Whitelam, University of Sheffield

Why have particular images of ancient Israel become so ingrained in Western popular and political imagination that they appear so natural as to be self-evident? Why has recent research on the history of ancient Israel and Palestine found it so difficult to disturb these images? The paper will explore some of the deep-seated images that are part of western collective memory from the fifteenth century onwards. It will also explore how these images of the past have been resistant to analysis but also how alternative images have become sites of resistance to dominant memories of the past.


Tertullian’s Images of Self and Other: The Rhetorical Construction of Ancient North African Christianities
Program Unit: Construction of Christian Identities
David E. Wilhite, Seattle Pacific University

Given the rhetorical style of early Christian apologists, scholars often have difficulty identifying exactly who the intended audience is in any given work, much less identifying the so-called heretical groups under attack. This problem becomes even more acute in a writer like Tertullian where two factors influence our understanding of his identity: 1. virtually nothing is known about him biographically with reference both to his own works and to his witnesses, 2. Tertullian himself often attacked “heretics,” only later to be condemned as a “Montanist heretic” by other Patristic writers. While the second aspect is often cited as a source of confusion regarding Tertullian’s identity, I would like to suggest that this could actually provide the most promising insights into the author’s writings. Although it is true that Tertullian offers little, if any, biographical information in his oeuvre, his tracts against the so-called heretics do exhibit contested Christian identities in both his ecclesial and regional spheres. Within those works Tertullian’s construction of his religious “Other” mirrors his self-portrayal and his construction of his own Christian ingroup. While scholars have located Tertullian within the broader movements of the Roman Empire, few have explored the North African milieu in particular as they relate to Tertullian’s writings. In order to contribute to this area, I will apply social identity theories from the discipline of Cultural Anthropology which destabilize many of our taxonomies of identification. Much work has recently been done in this approach by Classicists studying Roman Africa. By locating Tertullian within the various resistance movements found in North Africa, one can reread his works against “heretics” in light of the identity politics that were already invoked, thereby adding to the discussion of the “Early Christianities” competing with one another in these communities.


"Hermeneiai" in Manuscripts of John's Gospel and the Art of Bibliomancy
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Kevin Wilkinson, Yale University

Several fragmentary papyrus/parchment manuscripts of John's Gospel are laid out in an unusual fashion. Each page contains a portion of text followed by the word "hermeneia" and a banal sentence. Among the scholarly theories advanced to explain this peculiar feature, the one that initially triumphed was that these "hermeneiai" formed a running biblical commentary at the foot of the page. In the mid-twentieth century, however, O. Stegmueller, using J. R. Harris' research on similar phenomena in codices Bezae and Sangermanensis, argued that the "hermeneiai" were in fact oracles and had nothing to do with the biblical text. His argument was subsequently endorsed by H. Quecke and B. Metzger and is the current opinio communis.While it is undoubtedly correct (and an important advance in our understanding) that the "hermeneiai" are oracles, it does not follow that they are unrelated to the Gospel text. Indeed, I can demonstrate that they form a single oracular system that was closely tied to John's Gospel, mainly through catchwords. (This has been obscured until now by certain corruptions that occurred very early in the ms tradition.) This crucial observation enables us to understand the original function of the "hermeneiai". They are not simply random oracles scrawled into the margins of biblical texts, but rather an aid to bibliomancy. The inquirer arrives by some means at a random number, opens the Gospel of John to the passage bearing that number, reads the biblical text, and then consults the subsequent "hermeneia" (which can now be properly understood as both oracle and "interpretation") in order to learn how that passage applies to his or her situation. I shall conclude with some thoughts on the social location of the practice reflected in these manuscripts.


Spiritual Possession in Judaism and Paul's Relationship with Christ
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Guy Williams, University of Oxford

While certain scholars have attempted to define Paul's relationship with Christ in terms of 'possession', their arguments have mostly failed to convince the wider scholarly community. The reason for this lies in the failure to relate the argument to the range of beliefs about possession in Second Temple Judaism or to give a precise definition of what possession might mean in the Pauline context. So, seeking to give a more convincing account of this interpretation, a survey of Jewish beliefs about beneficent spiritual possession will be offered. This identifies a wide variety of beliefs attested in many different contexts. Possession by a good spirit was not considered to be odd but was valued as a potential source of inspiration, authority, and power. With these results in mind, it seems quite plausible that Paul could have believed something similar of himself. We examine a range of passages and find that spiritual possession sheds significant light upon the meaning of the text. We also find a number of points in common between Paul's discussion of his relationship with Christ and the Jewish data on possession. Christ is literally present within Paul. As difficult as it is to understand, this forms a core part of Paul’s religious experience.


Spelling Matters: A New Source of Information for New Testament Textual Criticism
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
P.J. Williams, University of Aberdeen

The spelling of words in the Greek New Testament generally attracts little attention since it is seen as something that is or no theological or historical significance. Editors of Greek New Testaments have often therefore made global decisions about the spelling of words and not given adequate consideration to the fluctuations in manuscript support for various spellings across different texts. In fact the spelling of words is important because (a) it represents a vast reserve of unexplored data, (b) there are strong grounds for believing that it is sometimes a source of genealogical information, (c) it is generally independent of reconstructions of theological disputes, and (d) it can give us information about canon history and the circulation of books as collections.


Exile and -- Restoration?
Program Unit:
H. G. M. Williamson, University of Oxford

*


The Aramaic Documents in Ezra Revisited
Program Unit: Prophetic Texts and Their Ancient Contexts
H. G. M. Williamson, University of Oxford

The book of Ezra includes a number of official documents in Aramaic whose authenticity has long been debated. In the middle years of the last century the majority opinion had become established that most of them, if not all, were indeed what they purported to be. The present author published an article in 1983 which supported this consensus by using the form of Achaemenid Aramaic documents to help explain a number of textual difficulties and oddities in the Biblical text. In recent years, however, a number of major studies have appeared which have posed significant challenges to this position. This paper will therefore seek to take stock of where the debate now stands and to offer some reflections to take the discussion forward.


The Conceptual Root of Futility in Qohelet
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Robert Williamson, Jr., Emory University

In her study of death in Qohelet, Shannon Burkes proposes that the conceptual root of Qohelet's perception of the futility of human endeavor is death. While there can be no doubt that Burkes has correctly identified death as one of the central foci in Qohelet's futility, others merit attention as well: 1) the wearying repetiiousness of existence without fulfillment, 2) the injustice of life itself, 3) the instability of the act-consequence relatonship, and 4) the inability of humankind to know or control the future. While each of these, including death, is a contributing factor to Qohelet's since of futility, none is at the root. Rather, each of these is an expression of the underlying conceptual root of Qohelet's since of futility: the inscrutability and unpredictability of an all-powerful and fickle God.


Lamentations 5: A Hidden Transcript of Communal Suffering
Program Unit: Lament in Sacred Texts and Cultures
Robert Williamson, Jr., Emory University

It has long been noted that while Lamentations 5 has the form of a communal lament, it diverges from that form in significant ways: the length of the complaint, the brevity of the turn toward God, and the absence of a vow of praise. While these three digressions from the form have often been noted as difficulties in interpretation, they are in fact the keys to its meaning. Employing the notions of “public transcript” and “hidden transcript” as developed by J. C. Scott in Domination and the Arts of Resistance, I will argue that Lamentations 5:1-21 represents the “public transcript” of the communal voice as it expresses its suffering before YHWH. These verses attempt to contain the community’s anguish within the acceptable, “public” form of discourse with the Deity, the communal lament. However, as the digressions of form described above indicate, the community’s suffering stretches and bends the communal lament form until it finally breaks, issuing forth in the “hidden transcript” expressed in 5:22. The twenty-one preceding verses have been a restrained expression of the community’s disgrace and suffering, choked back to fit within the acceptable form of the communal lament. Finally, with the utterance of this last verse, the community publicly expresses its private truth: “You have rejected us and are angry with us beyond measure.” It is an explicit challenge to YHWH’s lordship, a public proclamation that the community is no longer willing quietly to submit to the disgrace and humiliation that YHWH has brought upon them. It is, in Scott’s terms, a declaration of war, a communal act of resistance against the arbitrary punishment of an Absolute Power.


Matthew's Messianic Shepherd-King: In Search of the Lost Sheep of the House of Israel
Program Unit: Matthew
Joel Willitts, University of Cambridge

Unique to the First Gospel are two sayings of Jesus that have proved controversial. The controversy arises not least because of the exclusivity of their contents. In two places in the Gospel (Matt 10:5b-6; 15:24) the Messianic mission of Jesus and the mission of his disciples is limited to a group that Jesus himself calls ‘the lost sheep of the house of Israel’. This study investigates these logia in order to determine the identity of the group. In light of Matthew’s intense interest in Jesus’ Davidic Messiahship, it is argued that the way forward in ascertaining the meaning of the logia is within the trajectory of the Jewish Shepherd-King traditions surrounding King David. While not a widely used motif in the Second Temple period, the Messianic Shepherd-King motif did function significantly for at least one sectarian Jewish community in first century Palestine, namely, the community who composed and edited the Psalms of Solomon 17. The motif functioned as a vehicle of hope for a political-national restoration of the Kingdom of Israel; vital to the motif is a belief in the territorial restoration of the Land of Israel. Read against this background of a concrete expectation for the restoration of Israel, the thesis of this study is that the ‘lost sheep of the house of Israel’ in Matthew 10:6 and 15:24 refers to remnants of the former northern kingdom of Israel who continued to reside in the northern region of the ideal Land of Israel. Thus, the Matthean Jesus’ Messianic missional scope was limited geographically to those who were residing in the northern region of the Land.


The Route of Paul's First Journey to Pisidian Antioch
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Mark W. Wilson, Asia Minor Research Center

The recent opening of the St. Paul Trail in southern Turkey from Aksu to Yalvaç and accompanying publication of a trail guidebook has renewed popular and academic interest in the route of Paul’s first journey to Pisidian Antioch. Acts 13:13–14 records that, after making landfall at Perga, Paul and Barnabas traveled inland from Perga to Pisidian Antioch. Acts 14:24 states that the apostles returned to Pamphylia through Pisidia. Scholars have proposed three possible routes–-eastern, central, and western–-for the journey. These routes will be illustrated using a PowerPoint presentation. The paper will examine the viability of the suggested routes and their variations through the lens of literary, topographical, archaeological, and epigraphical evidence. It will also look at how Bible atlases as well as maps in volumes about Paul have inadequately charted this journey. After reviewing the evidence, the paper will present a fresh hypothesis regarding the route.


Setting the Agenda
Program Unit: Signifying (on) Scriptures
Vincent L. Wimbush, Claremont Graduate University

2006 programming will center on the theme "Scripture(s) and Race". Sessions will primarily address issues that are perduring and wide-ranging, and the discussion will move far beyond the probing of 'race' as it occurs within texts understood as 'scripture(s)'. Conversation will engage 'race' as an invented category, racialisms/racisms as they relate to 'scripture' in explicit or indirect ways, and how 'race' is masked in or determinative of scriptures. The international panel represents a variety of disciplinary fields, backgrounds, and academic interests and will bring a rich diversity of perspectives to bear on the chosen theme.


The Translation of “Polis” in the New Testament: Literary and Archeological Arguments for an Adequate Translation
Program Unit: Bible Translation
Marlon Winedt, United Bible Societies

The word 'polis' is used about 160 times in the New Testament. Many translations have struggled with the translation of this word and often resort to a concordant translation in the sense of “city”. We know that the concept has a long history in Greek philosophy and that it denoted a pretty much independent and probably walled city-state at first. Of course there is also the socio-political meaning in terms of its status and social organization. New archeological excavations in Galilee have given us more insight into the historical realities of places like Capernaum and other “poleis” as mentioned in the Gospels. The information regarding the important Herodian polis of Sephoris, whose absence in the NT record, is rather baffling, also helps to gain a better grasp of the meaning of this word. Furthermore, we will also take into account the discussion as to whether the Gospel tradition shows a deliberate use/non-use of this and other related terms within the framework of the specific theology of the Synoptics. This will include the implications for translation. After giving an analysis as to the possible meanings of the word in question and other related words within the realm of settlement, an attempt will be made to provide some specific guidelines for translation. Specific guidelines for translation will also focus on the actual translation of these key terms in real translation projects like in the Patamuna, Akawaio languages in Guyana and Sranan Tongo, a Creole language, from Suriname. Thus, the paper will have a historical-archeological component, a literary-theological component, and a translational component.


Life and Death as Poetry
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Michael Winger, New York, New York

Among the metaphors in Paul’s letters, a series employing terms for life and death provide a test case for how to understand Paul’s metaphors. Traditionally, Paul’s interpreters have sought to translate his metaphors into plain, declarative statements—sifting multiple meanings and choosing one that seems to fit best. As an alternative to this simplified re-writing of Paul, we can try to read his metaphors as we would a poet’s, accepting that Paul sometimes chooses allusive expressions over plain ones. Writers on metaphor beginning with Aristotle show how metaphor, in both poetry and rhetoric, serves purposes beyond those of propositions. As Donald Davidson says: “We imagine there is a content to be captured when all the while we are focusing on what the metaphor makes us notice . . . and much of what we are called to notice is not propositional in character.” A writer uses metaphor to invoke the reader’s imagination, not to specify a single definitive meaning. Paul uses language of life and death in different ways, often in the same passage. Sometimes his metaphors are concrete and physical, sometimes they are highly abstract. They depend largely on the standard network of ideas associated with life and death, rather than distinctively Christian themes of death and resurrection. In Romans 5-8, life and death figure in a series of distinct passages, shifting throughout. This language draws attention to the overriding importance of the matters under discussion, and also to the fundamental simplicity of the alternatives presented: only two. At the same time the twists and turns of Paul’s language suggest that these alternatives are not what they seem. Which is death, which is life? Paul’s paradoxical presentation illustrates a radical remaking of the cosmos.


Conflict and Paradox in Matthew
Program Unit: Matthew
Michael Winger, New York, New York

How are we to make sense of Matthew’s instructions for dealing with conflict? “Do not resist evil.” “Turn the other cheek.” “Love your enemies.” What reason is given for following these commands, so absurd on their face?Matthew seems less concerned with justifying these difficult sayings than with flaunting their difficulty. Compassion could be invoked in support of love of enemy, but it is not; indeed, the specific examples given, such as submission to an assailant, might have been chosen to eliminate any thought of compassion. Or it could be claimed that non-resistance is an effective strategy, as it was in the hands of Gandhi and King; but the texts offer no such suggestion. And how could it serve a useful purpose for a defendant to give a plaintiff more than he seeks? Rhetorically, the chief feature of these passages is paradox, which is woven into the hard sayings themselves. The association of love and enemies is paradoxical: enemies are exactly those we do not love, and these two terms cannot be put together without destroying the sense of at least one of them. The paradox is no rhetorical trick, but part of the meaning, which cannot be expressed without paradox. It is the same with “Do not resist injury” (the proper translation). These paradoxes invoke others associated with Christian belief, and also irony, with its attention to the gap between appearance and reality. Paradox and irony have an inherent appeal, resting on the conception that one should expect reality to differ from appearance, and God’s wisdom to resemble foolishness. The difficulty of Jesus’ hard sayings is at the same time, paradoxically, a key to their strength.


Sources from Jerusalem and the Formation of Luke-Acts: A Reception-Critical Approach
Program Unit: Formation of Luke and Acts
Mikael Winninge, Umea University

The characteristic features in Luke-Acts can be explained with reference to a creative author. However, it is a crucial question how Luke’s sources influenced the formation of Luke-Acts. In this investigation I confine myself to Luke’s special material (L). I focus on such parts of this material that in different theories have been connected to hypotheses of sources from Jerusalem. This applies to some of the material behind Luke 1–2 and some passages in Acts. The passages in Acts that refer to common ownership of property (Acts 2:42–47; 4:32–5:11) are an intriguing example. The Qumran material (eg. 1 QS VI, 13–23) makes it plausible that Luke’s ideals are not pure invention. The sources might reflect early Christian practice. With such examples the source hypotheses can be critically assessed. In addition to the source-critical perspective the investigation involves a synchronic analysis of relevant texts, in order to understand the narrative. As a third step the socio-rhetorical situation indicated is analyzed. For example, Luke probably tried to promote a program for caring for the poor among the Christian communities in his own time. Since there is evidence that Greek and Roman authorities and individual benefactors tried to supply the poor with at least some grain in times of famine, it is quite likely that Luke wanted to encourage a more equal and brotherly Christian model for charity and the sharing of God’s gifts. Thus the reception of sources from Jerusalem in Luke’s own time and milieu is the main focus of this investigation.


Re-reading the Great Commission (Matthew 28:16–20) in Imperial Context
Program Unit: Matthew
Sean F. Winter, Northern Baptist College

There is general agreement that Matthew 28.16-20 forms the climax to Matthew’s gospel, drawing together numerous key Matthean themes and alluding to several earlier passages in the gospel narrative. It is also clear that what Luz calls the “encompassing scope” of this text is shaped by allusions to the Greek Bible and, potentially, the wider contextual environment of the Roman empire.This paper uses these three contexts (imperial; intertextual and narrative) to address a key contemporary contextual question. To what extent does the so-called “Great Commission” narrative legitimate complicity or active participation in diverse imperial and hegemonic discourses and activities? After a brief review of the way in which postcolonial critics have interpreted this text, I offer a reading, which provides resources for resistance to such imperialist claims.I argue that recent work on the anti-imperial focus of Matthew’s gospel (Carter et al) is of some assistance in this regard and has particular relevance for our understanding of Jesus’ claim to universal authority in Matt 28.18. However, I also argue that a recognition of the LXX Daniel allusion in this verse invites us to read that claim in the light of the earlier gospel narrative; specifically the Son of man sayings and exousia motif. The command to go and disciple panta ta ethne should not be detached from the claim to universal authority (pasa exousia) that the risen Jesus makes. But such authority is the fulfilment of that which is present in the earthly ministry and future parousia of the Son of man. This connection serves to relativise any imperial claims made by Jesus’ followers and remind them that their mission must be characterised by the suffering servanthood of the risen Lord whom they now worship.


Weighing the Johannine "I am" Sayings as History
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Antoinette Wire, San Francisco Theological

If the "I am" sayings were not spoken as such by Jesus of Nazareth (a recent scholarly consensus kept under wraps), they were probably a product of the prophetic spirit as the stories of Jesus' life were retold to incorporate the continuing impact of Jesus' presence. Does this cancel out their truth in Christian history and expose them as false witness since they claim to be spoken by Jesus of Nazareth? Or does this limit the significance of these sayings to the time and setting of their prophetic pronouncement in Johannine communities? Or does it rather indicate that historical truth must be revisioned as an evolving reality in the life of a movement, especially so in a movement that begins by announcing God's kingdom about to arrive?To weigh the historical significance of texts in which the prophetic spirit speaks for Jesus, I will focus on one "I am" predication and draw on recent study of prophecy, "relecture" theories about John's gospel, and social memory study. Yet I do not want to skirt the difficult question of what constitutes evidence of historical truth, especially at points where spiritual interpreters of past events contest each other and lack of power leaves many voices unattested.


Who Crucified the Lord? And Where? Some Thoughts about Revelation 11:8
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Stephan Witetschek, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven

The ministry and death of the Two Witnesses of Rev 11 is located in V. 8 in "the great city that is spiritually called Sodom and Egypt, were also their Lord was crucified". This remark often makes exegetes forge a connection of the whole pericope - including the measuring of the temple in 11:1-2 - with the historical city of Jerusalem, which leads to interpretations of Rev 11 that are sometimes a bit helpless, sometimes slightly strange, sometimes downright anti-Jewish. This paper adopts the minority view that understands Rev 11:8 in accordance with the other references to "the great city" in the Book of Revelation. Thus, Rev 11 can be seen not as bizarre combination of half-digested traditions, but as meaningful and important for the whole Book of Revelation. The consequences of this understanding for the Temple imagery in Rev 11:1-2 are of particular interest.


What Did John Hear? Literary Preparation and Christological Framing of the Baptist's Question (Q 7:18–23)
Program Unit: Q
Stephan Witetschek, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven

In their respective redactions of John the Baptist's question from Q 7:18-23, Matthew and Luke both charge the narrative introduction with christological titles: In Matthew 11:2, John hears of "the works of the Messiah" (mentioned at least in chapters 8 - 10), while in Luke 7:18-19, he sends two of his disciples "to the Lord" (having heard "about all these things"). The reconstruction of the Q text is notoriously difficult. This paper will try to tackle two questions: (1) Could there have been a similar christological reference in Q? (2) How has the Baptist's question been motivated in Q? Or rather: Does Q, in its composition, tell a story? The paper does not claim to provide full stops, but rather to clarify the question marks.


The Historical Figure of the Beloved Disciple in the Fourth Gospel
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Ben Witherington, Asbury Theological Seminary

There have always been problems with discerning the identity of the Beloved Disciple, not least because this figure is nowhere clearly identified with any named person in this Gospel, not even John son of Zebedee, from Jn. 13 on. The internal evidence in this Gospel in fact suggests a very different conclusion about the identity of this person than the traditional one. It has too seldom been noted however that there is a named person in this Gospel who is called "the one whom [Jesus] loves", namely Lazarus in Jn. 11. This study will explore the possibility of Lazarus being the Beloved Disciple, and investigate the explanatory power of this suggestion. We will suggest that it clears up a number of mysteries about this Gospel including: 1) its Judean focus and character; 2) the locale of the Last Supper; 3) how the Beloved Disciple could have ready access to the High Priest's house; 4) why none of the special Zebedee stories found in the Synoptics are included in this Gospel; 5) the ending of the Epilogue in Jn. 21 which suggests there was a tradition that this disciple would not die (again); 6) how a male could be standing at the cross in Jn. 19 when the Synoptics suggest none of the Twelve were present; and 7) how the Beloved Disciple could take Mary into his home in Judea, in this case nearby Bethany.


The Formation and the Intention of the Haggai-Zechariah-Corpus
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Jakob Wöhrle, University of Münster

Because of the similar dating system in the books of Haggai and Zechariah, it has been presumed since the end of the 19th century, that these two books once formed an independent collection - the Haggai-Zechariah-Corpus. But up to now, the formation and the intention of this corpus have only been inadequately defined. The paper will show, that - on a diachronic level - not both books, as often supposed, but only the book of Zechariah has been redacted in the course of the composition of this „Book of the Two“. And on this basis, it will be shown, that - on a synchronic level - the Haggai-Zechariah-Corpus can be understood as a work, that reacts to the decreasing hope for divine salvation in the fifth century. Despite the negative experiences in this time, the Haggai-Zechariah-Corpus adheres to the promises of the early pre-exilic prophecy. But just in order to adhere to these promises, it defines the conditions for their fulfillment.


Future Directions for the Study of Warfare in Ancient Israel
Program Unit: Warfare in Ancient Israel
Jacob Wright, University of Heidelberg

A brief presentation of potentially fruitful future directions for the study of warfare in ancient Israel.


Matthew's Antitheses: Hyperbole and Its Ambiguous Surplus
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
B. Diane Wudel Lipsett, Wake Forest University

The Gospel of Matthew in key passages is characterized by remarkable rhetorical extravagance, hyperbole, and paradox. What some have termed Matthew’s “rhetoric of excess” appears, for example, in the Sermon on the Mount’s antitheses with their culminating imperative to be teleios, perfect or complete (5:21-48). Interpreters often respond to hyperbole by mitigating its extremes, as both ancient and contemporary theorists note. Seneca, for instance, observes, “Hyperbole never expects to attain all that it ventures, but asserts the incredible in order to arrive at the credible,” while Derrida (as Stephen Webb has pointed out) suggests that hyperbole, “the absolute opening, the uneconomic expenditure,” is always re-embraced and overcome by an economy. Yet perhaps more can be said about the complexities and ambiguities of Matthew’s rhetoric in this passage. I propose a rhetorical study of Matthew 5:21-48, situated in the context of ancient discussions of extravagant rhetoric and the trope hyperbole, and also shaped by modern theorists of rhetoric. Among ancient writers on rhetoric, I draw particularly from the critic known as “Longinus” and his treatise “On the Sublime.” Longinus’ analyses of the relations between extravagant figures of speech and the quality he terms “sublimity” are provocative for a study of Matthean rhetorical extravagance. Among more recent theorists I turn, in particular, to Kenneth Burke to examine how hyperbole in Matthew 5:21-48 not only intensifies the appeal to communal identification but also destabilizes its own enticements to community. Matthew’s hyperbole here generates a tension between what is too much and what is enough, not only rhetorically but ethically – and that tension disrupts both complacency and interpretive closure.


The Mythic Mind Revisited
Program Unit: Bible, Myth, and Myth Theory
Nicolas Wyatt, University of Edinburgh

In a 1998 paper (published in 2001 in SJOT 15:3-56) I suggested that myth is not a (literary) genre, being altogether too polymorphous to fit any such formal definition, but rather a mind-set. The opposition often discerned by biblical scholars between myth and history had led to extravagant claims concerning the non-mythic nature of Old Testament narratives, on the ground that their basis often lay in "historical fact". On the other hand, the status of history in the Old Testament has become almost as contentious in some recent scholarship. This paper raises some fundamental problems, and examines some current tendencies in both areas, and will ask whether it is possible to reach some *modus vivendi*, in which scholars of diverse persuasions may find some common ground, instead of continuing to talk past each other.


Use of a Layered Hebrew Parser for Enhanced Cantillation Learning
Program Unit: Computer Assisted Research
George Yaeger, Aster Institute

The author will provide the ASTER Hebrew Layered Clause Parser tool to a graduate level Hebrew Cantillation class at Gratz College, PA and assist them in using the tool to help them better understand the text which they are canting and connect the cantillation with the Hebrew linguistics. This will add a new dimension to the cantillation teaching process and provide a linguistic basis for musical interpretation of the text including dynamic levels, and using linguistic divisions to enrich the cantillation disjunctions. The author will relate the connection between disjunctive cantillation marks and linguistic boundaries for phrases and clauses from a previous SBL paper. Modifications will be made to the tool to maximize the learning benefit of the cantillation course students and instructor. New uses of the tool for cantillation instruction will be recorded and presented in the paper. In addition student and instructor feedback will be solicited at the end of the semester and reported. Lastly future possibilities for both modification and new pedagogical uses of the parser tool will be discussed.


The Christian Ideal of Marriage in the Apocryphal Acts of Andrew and the Writings of Clement of Alexandria
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Mariko Yakiyama, Claremont Graduate University

This paper explores two writings from second century (CE) Alexandria as newly emerging Christian writings: a writing of Clement of Alexandria and the apocryphal Acts of Andrew, especially concerning their interest in procreation among married couples. The overall goal of this paper is to place Maximilla’s story, written in the apocryphal Acts of Andrew, in the correct context for fully understanding why Maximilla, after converting to Christianity, is willing to maintain her chastity, and even to die for it. First, this paper argues that the Acts of Andrew was written in Alexandria around the second or third century CE, at the time which coincides with the writings of Clement of Alexandria. Second, this paper proposes that the ideal of Clement concerning Christian married couples is under the influence of the Augustan reformation which occurred 200 years earlier. The Augustan reformation introduces chaste ethics among married couples, encouraging them to have more than three children in order to maintain the ideal number for aristocratic families. Third, this writer concludes that the story of Maximilla is completely opposite to the writings of Clement or the Pastoral Epistles in regard to procreation. Then, this writer pursues the reason why the story of Maximilla opposes the traditional interest in establishing both the stable family and society. This paper’s writer argues that Maximilla’s story as a whole shows the author’s reaction against the existing social system and the social order, by adopting the concept of purity of body and soul under the influence of Platonism. In the comparison of the story of Maximilla and the writings of Clement of Alexandria, this writer observes that Christianity in Alexandria is divided between traditional family values witnessed in the writings of Clement of Alexandria and the ascetic interests evidenced in Maximilla's story.


Orientalizing Esther and Others in Art
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Gale A. Yee, Episcopal Divinity School

This presentation will discuss how the Male Gaze intersects with the Colonial Gaze in art: the Orientalizing of the female body and mistress/slave relations as they are fantasized in the male Western imagination in bath and harem scenes. It will then turn to the different ways in which depictions of biblical women in art follow Orientalizing conventions in displaying the female body.


A Linguistic and Discourse Analysis of Exodus 19
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Mark Yelderman, Dallas Theological Seminary

It has been notoriously difficult to reconcile Moses' multiple trips up the mountain in Exodus 19. Traditionally commentators have argued for multiple sources. Niccacci, Muraoka, and Talstra, following Robert Longacre's work, provided an improvement using a "verbal rank" based methodology (Narrative Syntax and the Hebrew Bible: Papers of the Tilburg Conference 1996). Although Longacre's tagmemic methodology provides identification of embedded text in Genesis, it lacks sufficient precision to discriminate the scene seams in Exodus 19. Exter-Blokland supplemented Longacre's tagmemic methodology with actant (participant) tracking and validated the technique in Kings. (In Search of Text Syntax, 1995). Using Exter-Blokland's technique and giving attention to recognized stylistic elements, we have analyzed Exodus 19 and have identified multiple levels of embedded texts. Some segments are aperture or summary scenes. Some segments are repetitively-resumed in later Exodus chapters. We can justify three unique Moses-YHWH encounters in Exodus 19, only two of which are certain trips up the mountain.


The Old Greek's Rendering of 'wlel in the Book of Lamentations
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Kevin J. Youngblood, Freed-Hardeman University

For the most part, the translator of the Greek Lamentations rendered verbs in his parent text with a fair degree of lexical precision and contextual sensitivity. There is, however, a recurring example of an equivalent that does not fit its context at all. The Hebrew verb 'wlel occurs four times in the MT of Lamentations (1:12b; 1:22a; 2:20a; 3:51) in contexts clearly requiring the meaning "to treat harshly." The translator, however, rendered the verb on three occasions with forms of epifulizein "to glean" or poiein epifullida "to make gleanings" (1:22a; 2:20a; 3:51) and once with a form of ginesthai (1:12b-c). Since elsewhere the translator demonstrated sensitivity to context, naturally the question arises as to why he opted for this inappropriate equivalent in these instances. It is possible that the translator seized an opportunity to allude to passages that employ the metaphors of a vineyard and of gleaning grapes in association with the exile and destruction of Jerusalem. The most obvious connection is with the Old Greek of Jer. 6:9 where the same Hebrew word is rendered appropriately by kallamaomai used figuratively of the deportations of large segments of Judah's population. Other texts which may have influenced the translator's use of this odd equivalent are OG Judges 8:2, Micah 7:1, and Obadiah 1:5. This paper will analyze each occurrence of this odd equivalent in Greek Lamentations and will explore the possibility that it was motivated by passages employing the gleaning metaphor. After drawing conclusions regarding the nature of the use of this equivalent in the Greek Lamentations the paper will discuss implications for Septuagint lexicography.


The Ammonites: A View from the Other Side of the Jordan
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Randall Younker, Andrews University

This presentation will summarize what is known about the Ammonites from archaeological excavations in Jordan, with a special focus on the recent findings of the Madaba Plains Project at Tells Hesban, Umayri, and Jalul. In addition to a review of Ammonite material culture, the socio-poliical development of Ammon, along with its tie-ins to biblical tradition will be discussed.


"Spoiling the Egyptians": Exodus 3:22 at the Crossroads of Christendom and Empire
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Rev. Colin H. Yuckman, Princeton Theological Seminary ('05)

The Exodus story is undoubtedly the pivotal event in the life of God’s people. Often overlooked in the Exodus story, however, is God’s command for the Israelites to “despoil the Egyptians” (Ex. 3:22). A curious mandate, it does not receive much attention in subsequent biblical literature. On the other hand, early Christian interpreters from both East and West went to great lengths to explain this part of the story. Some, including Origen, Basil, and Augustine, made this sidebar the basis of an attempt to relate their Classical heritage to Christianity. The “spoils of the Egyptians,” went one view, represented pagan ‘instruments’ or ‘valuables’—like philosophy or astronomy—which, with the proper provisos, could be appropriated for Christian purposes. Other interpreters contributed, helping to develop a tradition of interpretation around Exodus 3:22. What made this historical debate so relevant was precisely Christianity’s relationship with Classical culture. In the West, Rome, which had for so long embodied the ideals of the (neo-)classical era, began to crumble; and in the East, the Byzantine Empire was taking shape. On the one hand, Augustine, perhaps the most voluminous exponent of the spoliatio motif, struggled with the morality of the Egyptian ‘riches’. Basil and Gregory, on the other hand, had little difficulty reconciling Egyptian spoils with Christian belief. This paper looks at how various church fathers answered Tertullian’s famous, but rhetorical question: Quid Athenae Hierosolymis? Their answers, we will find, however divergent and conflicting, centered on interpretations of God’s command to “despoil the Egyptians” (Ex 3:22). Furthermore, the roads that took these interpreters to their views were heavily influenced by the social setting of the 3rd and 4th centuries, including a noticeable lack of Christian schools and general perseverance of classical education well into the Christian era.


The Influence of Old Greek Daniel 7:13–14 on Matthew's "Son of Man"
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Danny Zacharias, Acadia Divinity College

The Old Greek version of Dan 7:13-14 is significantly different than its MT and Theodotion counterparts. Regardless of how the OG came to be this way during transmission, the textual witness to the OG equates the "son of man" with the "Ancient of Days." I contend that the distinctives of OG-Dan 7:13-14 had a formative influence on the author of Matthew and best explains how Matthew portrays the "son of man" riding on the clouds, judging the nations, sitting on the glorious throne, with angels in subservience to him.


The Poetics of Ambiguous Personae in Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Naama Zahavi-Ely, College of William and Mary

The meaning of a passage of poetry depends a great deal on its speaker – the persona who expresses it. This is especially the case when the focus of the passage is on attitude -- delight, complaint, fear, or threat -- rather than on factual information or timeless truths. I would like to suggest that, precisely for that reason, the composers of Biblical Hebrew poetry often keep the identity of the speaker away from us, either temporarily or permanently. A verse can be read as the complaint of an individual, of the suffering people, of their long-abused land, or of their long-suffering God; the meaning of the text in its context -- the part it plays in the overall composition -- changes according to our perception of the speaker. At times a passage could be attributed to any of several possible speakers, until one gets close to its end and is pushed decidedly in a particular direction – yet not before other possibilities occur to the listener or reader, eventually to be discarded, but contributing to the overall impression. First person in Hebrew allows for ambiguity of gender, as second or third person do not. As long as one avoids adjectives applied to the speaker’s own self (rather than metaphors), one can’t tell whether the presumed speaker is masculine or feminine. The use of collective personae speaking as single individuals – the country or the people – is prevalent, adding poetic possibilities. Labels such as “says the Lord” at the end of a passage may be later editorial insertions, yet often the passage itself provides cues at its end that are clearly part of its content, rather than a possible add-on. This paper will explore the mechanics of ambiguous personae in specific passages of Biblical Hebrew poetry.


The Status of 4QReworked Pentateuch: Methods and Limitations
Program Unit: Qumran
Molly Zahn, University of Notre Dame

Since their publication, the five manuscripts designated “Reworked Pentateuch” (4Q158, 4Q364–367) have generally been understood as fragments of a non-authoritative, interpretive composition. More recently, several scholars have suggested that at least some of these manuscripts should instead be classified as “biblical” texts (i.e., copies of the five books of the Pentateuch), since they differ from the Masoretic text in the same manner as do recognized versions such as the Septuagint and the Samaritan Pentateuch. In this paper, I will provide empirical support for this claim by comparing the types of additions and rearrangements found in the 4QRP manuscripts with those found in texts recognized as manuscripts or versions of biblical books. This procedure will demonstrate that the ways in which 4QRP reworked its Vorlage are entirely consistent with the ways in which the developing biblical text was reworked in its various manifestations. Thus the possibility must be considered that 4QRP indeed represents a version of the Pentateuch. However, such an empirical investigation does not tell the whole story, since similar exegetical techniques might also be found in texts such as Jubilees and the Temple Scroll, which, though probably authoritative, do not represent copies of books later included in the Bible. Therefore, I will also explore the (admittedly hazy) boundary line between “biblical” and “non-biblical” texts at Qumran, and consider what sorts of evidence, besides parallels in manner of reworking, might permit such a distinction. Unfortunately, the fragmentary nature of 4QRP probably precludes a firm decision about whether it should be classified as a copy of the Pentateuch. Despite such tentativeness, however, the methodological parallels between 4QRP and texts firmly classified as “biblical” must nevertheless be taken seriously in debates over the status at Qumran of what later became the biblical text.


Jerusalem Fell After Bethar: Narrative and History in Lamentations Rabbah
Program Unit: History and Literature of Early Rabbinic Judaism
Holger Zellentin, Princeton University

The fourth-century Palestinian rabbinic text Lamentations Rabbah tells the storis of the several cities' destruction, most prominently that of Jerusalem and that of Bethar. In 1971, Yitzhak Baer argued for anti-Christian tendencies in the accounts of the destruction of the Temple. Recently, Israel Yuval has taken up Baer’s work and shown references to Christian legends in almost all of the aspects of the rabbinic narratives of the fall of Jerusalem. In this paper, I will argue that the rabbinic narrative of the fall of Jerusalem not only constitutes a full-fledged response to Christian polemics on the Temple’s destruction, but also reinterprets the more recent siege that historically lies much closer to the core of rabbinic Judaism: the fall of Bethar during the Bar Kokhba revolt. My literary analysis leads to a chronological inversion of the rabbis’ memory formation of the two sieges and allows an approach to history that highlights the narrative aspect of its sources. The secondary nature of Jerusalem’s fall in turn suggests dating the rabbinic legend of its destruction as late as the fourth century.


The Bavli's View of Palestinian Dream Interpretation
Program Unit: Midrash
Holger Zellentin, Princeton University

Dreams as a basis for mantic power in Babylonian rabbinic culture held a status fundamentally different from that in Palestine. The Palestinian rabbis used dreams as raw material on which to apply tools very similar to their scriptural exegesis, and explicitly favored the liberty and genius of acclaimed rabbinic dream interpreters. The Babylonian rabbis refuted this Palestinian culture of dream interpretation in almost all its aspects. Instead, they combined Hellenistic and scriptural aspects in a rabbinic oneirocriticon, and sought guidelines to turn dream interpretation into a safe and benign science to which laymen and rabbis should have unmediated access. Instead of reading dreams as Scripture, they read them through Scripture: they used scriptural verses to limit the range of meanings one could attribute to dreams and moreover stressed positive over negative interpretations. The Babylonian rabbis also imitated and criticized Palestinian dream interpretation and dream interpreters, at times taking a parodying turn.


Paul, the Torah, and the Conversion of Gentiles
Program Unit: Social History of Formative Christianity and Judaism
Magnus Zetterholm, Lund University

This paper will explore the implications that the most radical views of Paul will have for our understanding of the relations between Jews and non-Jews within the early Jesus movement and for the applicability of the concept of “conversion”. According to the traditional paradigm, Jews and non-Jews merged together into a “third race”. This is usually thought to be a consequence of Paul’s view of the Torah: if Paul argued that Jews, as well as non-Jews, should not express their religiousness through Torah observance, Jews and non-Jews are believed to have developed a common religious behavior. Contrary to the traditional picture, I will argue that Paul’s view of the Torah was part of an intra-Jewish discussion of whether non-Jews should be involved in Torah observance or not. Early rabbinic literature indicates that two opposing views on the relation between non-Jews and Torah observance existed during the second century C.E. I suggest that Paul was influenced by an ideology that opposed non-Jewish involvement in the Torah and that his anti-nomistic discourse was directed to non-Jewish Jesus believers who may have been influenced by Jewish groups who encouraged them to observe the Torah. From this perspective, Paul appears to have been involved in trying to establish a clear demarcation line between Jews and non-Jews. From Paul’s perspective, the Jesus movement was a Jewish faction that was concerned also about the salvation of the non-Jews. During the first century C.E., there was simply “Christianity” that anyone could to convert to. It was only possible to convert to Judaism, and as far as we know, Paul strongly opposed such behavior. The concept of “conversion” in the context of the early Jesus movement is part of the Christian construction of the rise of Christianity and is probably of little use in historical analyses.


Scratched Silver and Painted Walls: Dating Biblical Texts Archaeologically
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Ziony Zevit, University of Judaism

Dating biblical texts relatively as well as absolutely is crucial for almost every branch of academic biblical study because aside from some literary and hermeneutic approaches, most biblicists working with humanistic and social science paradigms engage diachronic matters directly or tangentially in their research. Indeed, the date of a text’s composition or redaction is often the first matter that has to be settled before it is factored into discussions of thought, cult, poetics, history, and the like. This reflects the turn to historical concerns by the beginning of the twentieth century that marked the beginning of modern biblical studies. But, with the collapse of orthodox Wellhausianism and its evolutionary scheme of Israelite religion and thought, and as a consequence of ongoing discoveries from the ancient Near East, dating texts has become a complicated matter. Working within the parameters of a session entitled “Dating Biblical Texts by Non-Linguistic Means (but not Exclusively),” this paper undertakes to determine the type of statements that can be made about chronology when inscriptions having literary affinities with biblical texts are found. Among the archaeological discoveries that I consider are the silver amulets from Ketef Hinnom, Papyrus Amherst 63, and wall inscriptions from Deir Alla and Kuntillet Ajrud. Using these as test cases, this paper addresses the following concerns: scholarly skepticism vs. academic cynicism; distinguishing between theoretically possible explanations and probable ones; and establishing a terminus a quo and terminus ad quem for a given text in light of individual discoveries.

 
 


JOIN   |  DONATE   |  CONTACT   |  SBL TWITTER   |  BIBLE ODYSSEY TWITTER   |  PRIVACY POLICY

© 2024, Society of Biblical Literature. All Rights Reserved.