|
|
2018 Annual Meeting
Meeting Begins: 11/17/2018
Meeting Ends: 11/21/2018
Call for Papers Opens: 12/18/2017
Call for Papers Closes: 3/6/2018
Requirements for Participation
|
|
Meeting Abstracts
Analysis of the Introductory Material of the Andəmta Commentary of the Synoptic Gospels
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Nebeyou Alemu, Wycliffe Ethiopia
In the Ethiopian Orthodox Täwahido Church tradition, the term andəmta commentary refers to an enormous corpus which contains traditional interpretations of biblical, patristic, liturgical, canonical and monastic texts. Roger Cowley notes that the andǝmta commentary (AC) corpus initially developed as an Ethiopian oral commentary on Biblical and Patristic texts, beginning from the time the texts were translated into the Geez language. The distinctive social history reflected in the commentary material suggests that the oral tradition, expanded and augmented, reached its most definitive form in the Gondӓrine period (ca. 17 century). The AC to the biblical books is characterized by a brief introduction. The introductory material to the synoptic gospels is referred as mäqdemaä wängēl. Cowley in his two articles (1774 and 1977) deals with the introductory materials to the Old Testament and New Testament andəmta. He particularly focuses on translating and discussing the introductions to selected books both from the OT and NT. In dealing with the synoptics Cowley translates and discusses the introduction to the Gospel of Mark, chosen primarily for its brevity. Building upon his work I aim to in this study translate and analyze the introductory material to all three synoptic gospels, so as to offer a more detailed understanding of the introductory material particularly as it pertains to the commentators discussion of historical and theological elements as understood from the specific this specific context.
|
Casting Biblical Narratives: Visible and Invisible Women
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Ingunn Aadland, IKO
Biblical texts reflect Antiquity, with its patriarchic norms and values, and we are sometimes repelled by the Bible’s violence and discrimination against people. Hence, in contemporary children’s literature we prioritize some texts over others, adjusting them according to our own norms.
#MeToo has increased an awareness of an unfortunate aspect of our culture: contempt of women. Traits of such contempt are still found in biblical interpretation. Of course, the biblical text allows gender-biased interpretations, but we also read and retell with our own culture. This paper examines how ‘the woman’ is represented in contemporary Scandinavian biblical interpretations for children. I argue that authors of today, including female authors, reproduce a biblical portrayal of women, and when doing so reflect attitudes towards women found within our own culture. Presentations of the woman in Luke 7:37 illustrate how contemporary gender bias influences interpretation. In the Lukan narrativ, the woman is referred to as a “sinner.” The Norwegian Bible translation (2011) reads: “a woman who lived a sinful life.” In a Norwegian Bible presented for a young audience “Bibelfortellinger” (2011), this woman is first presented as “a prostitute.” In addition, the Pharisee’s thoughts are rendered: “she is a whore, a sinful woman.” These are artistic additions to the biblical text, which develop the narrative further. Hence, her sin is concretized and related to sex. In comparison, Luke 5 describes another human being before the feet of Jesus. This narrative also implies that the person is a sinner in need of forgiveness. I have yet to see an attempt to establish what kind of sin this might be.
Many of our “cultural bibles” downplay and marginalize women, and when women’s characters are developed further, they are related to sex. This reception of the Bible is not only a reproduction (and acceptance) of biblical stereotypes; but expressions of unfortunate cultural values that either devaluate or sexualize women. Children’s Bibles often prioritize narratives where men serve as main characters. Hence, women are deemed less important. Moreover, women are often presented in associated with sex (/-ual misconduct). I do not suggest that such interpretations are meant to degrade women. Rather, they reflect a loyal attitude towards the Bible (The Bible as the culture understands it), and more importantly: a lacking awareness of one’s own culture and the role it plays in biblical interpretation.
|
If We Translate Psalm 23 Correctly, Does It Still Work for Funerals?
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Charles Aaron, Perkins School of Theology
Invited paper.
|
Ethiopia and the Book of Enoch: A Comparison of Ideals of Justice in Mäṣhafä Henok and Amharic Sayings
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Sofanit Abebe, University of Edinburgh
The Book of Enoch has left its indelible mark upon the New Testament as well as Ethiopian literary traditions. Ethiopian Orthodox theology, poetic literature, hagiographies and a number of magical texts bear clear marks of the influence of Enochic ideas, language and imagery. Given the book’s prominence then, it is hardly possible to study Ethiopia’s written and oral culture apart from 1 Enoch. Differences notwithstanding, similarities between humanity under hegemonic power structures in the narrative world of 1 Enoch as well as present day Ethiopia lend a further support to studying the oral culture of Ethiopia in light of the influential Mӓṣhafӓ Henok. To this end, this study utilises a cognitive approach to the study of Ethiopian oral culture on social justice in conversation with 1 Enoch. Precepts, adages and popular slogans in Amharic expressing local wisdom and socio-cultural values of the society regarding social injustice, judgment and suffering will be compared to visions of social justice in Enochic literature. This comparison aims to identify 1 Enoch as the ideal relative to which Amharic proverbs and maxims codify and comment on the state of the world.
|
Jonathan as a Capable but Not Chosen Successor: How the Narrative Sequence of 1 Samuel 13–15 Reveals the Theological Foundation of Israel’s Monarchy
Program Unit: Book of Samuel: Narrative, Theology, and Interpretation
Diana Abernethy, Duke University
As commentators have noted, right after Samuel reveals that the Lord will not establish Saul’s dynasty, Jonathan emerges in 1 Samuel 13–14 as a potential successor. By examining the narrative effect of Jonathan’s introduction at this point, this paper explores how Jonathan’s character develops core theological themes in 1 Samuel, particularly how Israel’s monarchy depends on the Lord’s choice. In 1 Samuel 13:13–14 when Samuel pronounces that Saul’s descendents will not occupy the throne, he declares that the Lord “has sought a man after his own heart.” Samuel’s words prompt the reader to wonder who this man is and how to recognize such a man. While the reader looks for a man after the Lord’s own heart, the narrative focuses on Jonathan. In 1 Samuel 14, Jonathan leads a successful assault on the Philistines and shows himself to be a capable leader. On the basis of Samuel’s pronouncement, the reader knows that Jonathan cannot succeed his father on the throne, but Jonathan’s actions in 1 Samuel 14 shape the reader’s image of a man after the Lord’s own heart. As 1 Samuel continues, David becomes the next king and clarifies what Samuel means by a man after the Lord’s own heart. Yet, David and Jonathan share many positively portrayed qualities. In their military initiatives of 1 Samuel 14 and 17, Jonathan and David both demonstrate trust in the Lord’s deliverance, resounding success against the Philistines, effective exploitation of the terrain, and unconventional use of weapons. Though David displays some of these qualities to a greater degree than Jonathan does, their striking similarities show Jonathan, as well as David, exhibiting marks of a man after the Lord’s own heart. However, Jonathan is not the man after the Lord’s heart who will succeed Saul. After the narrative presents Jonathan as a capable yet passed over successor in 1 Samuel 14, it completes Saul’s rejection in 1 Samuel 15, thereby intensifying the reader’s search for Saul’s successor. In the next chapter, the reader finds the sought successor in David, but the narrative sequence invites the reader to consider Jonathan with all of his promising qualities before it reveals the next king. Thus, David enters the narrative in Jonathan’s shadow. Because Jonathan comes first, the reader asks why David becomes king with Jonathan’s portrait lingering in mind. As the reader compares them, the heart of Israel’s kingship surfaces: the Lord’s choice of David. In contrast to Saul, Jonathan and David both trust in the Lord and show themselves capable of addressing the Philistine threat, but these qualities do not earn Israel’s throne. Jonathan is excluded from the throne not for a lack of military skill or insufficient trust in the Lord: Jonathan does not become king because the Lord turns from Saul’s house to David’s. By portraying Jonathan as a capable successor in the midst of Saul’s rejection and before David’s entrance, the narrative demonstrates that the Lord’s choice—not merit—makes Israel’s kings.
|
The Original Form of Deuteronomy ("Urdeuteronomium") and Its Reworkings
Program Unit: Book of Deuteronomy
Reinhard Achenbach, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
The paper will hold the view that the original form of the deuteronomic law was not yet incorporated into the fictional form of a Mosaic speech. The Code comprised regulations for a social and ritual community to centralize it’s ritual activties and strengthen the social and religious unity. Part of the original form were laws of the centralization of the cultic rituals Dtn 6:4-5; 12:13-18*.21-27; (14:21b*; 26:2-3a.4-5a.10-11); [13:2–12]; 14:22-23a.24a.25-26.28-29; 15:1-3.12-14.16-17.19-23; 16:1a.2-7.8-11.13-14.16-17, together with new rules for lawsuits (Dtn 16:18a.19; 17:2a.3-12; 19:2-6*11-13.15-19) and rules for the local justice (Dtn 21-25*). The form of a historical paraenesis of Moses that comments and explains the law is of deuteronomistic origin.
|
Women's Economic Roles in the Biblical World: An Overview of Past Research
Program Unit: Economics in the Biblical World
Susan Ackerman, Dartmouth College
In order to introduce the special session on women's economic roles in the biblical world, sponsored by the Economics in the Biblical World section, this paper will survey the foundational work done by Phyllis Bird, Carol Meyers, Gale Yee, and others on ancient Israelite women's roles in their households' economies.
|
What Counts as an Editio Princeps? ASOR’s Policy on Initial Place of Publication or Announcement
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Susan Ackerman, Dartmouth College
According to the ASOR Policy on Professional Conduct, Section III.E.4 (endorsed by SBL), the publications and presentation venues of ASOR — with only a few exceptions — shall not serve as the initial place of publication or announcement of any object acquired by an individual or institution through purchase or donation after April 24, 1972, which is the date of entry into force of the 1970 UNESCO Convention on the Means of Prohibiting and Preventing the Illicit Import, Export and Transfer of Ownership of Cultural Property. But what counts as an initial place of publication or announcement of such an object? This paper describes the definition ASOR has developed of “Initial Publication or Announcement” and considers the implications that the ASOR definition of “Initial Publication or Announcement” has more generally for considering what counts as an editio princeps.
|
Epiphany as Polemic: Porphyry and Iamblichus at the Iseum with Plotinus
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Grant Adamson, University of Arizona
One of the most famous literary accounts of ritual and epiphany in the ancient Mediterranean world comes from Life of Plotinus 10: a traveling Egyptian priest, in Rome, is introduced to the philosopher through a mutual friend and offers to make Plotinus’ personal daimōn appear, which, when summoned, turns out to be no daimōn at all but in fact a god. Porphyry’s account has puzzled scholars. For instance, why would Plotinus have accepted the priest’s offer, much less as readily as his biographer claims he did? In Platonic tradition, the personal daimōn, including the daimonion of Socrates, could be heard; rarely, if ever, could the tutelary spirit be seen. Philosophers like Plotinus would have found it entirely unnecessary to conjure a visible manifestation of the personal daimōn through Egyptian priestly rites. But of course, not every lover of wisdom in the Neoplatonic school was like Plotinus or even Porphyry. Indeed, the school was not unified at the time Porphyry wrote and published his Life of Plotinus as preface to the Enneads. That was 301-305 CE. Before that, the Egyptianizing Iamblichus had once studied with Porphyry, perhaps in Rome. The two men went separate ways, however. While Porphyry became the successor-executor of Plotinus, Iamblichus incorporated traditional ‘magic’ within a theurgic system that was part ritual, part ratiocination, and he went on to establish something of a rival school in Syria. The debate between Porphyry and Iamblichus is well known from Porphyry’s Letter to Anebo and the reply that Iamblichus wrote as Abamon, the head of the college of Egyptian priests to which Anebo supposedly belonged. A few scholars have noticed extensions of the debate in their other works, that is, besides the obvious places where Iamblichus names Porphyry by name in order to agree or disagree with him. I argue there is a glaring extension of the debate in Porphyry’s Life of Plotinus 10, the vita being the very last or at least among the last of Porphyry’s writings. In his Letter to Anebo, Porphyry had challenged Egyptian belief and practice surrounding the personal daimōn. In response, the Egyptianizing Iamblichus told Porphyry, inter alia, that through theurgy rather than mere philosophy, it was possible not only to see the daimōn but also replace it with a god above daimonic rank. Porphyry was no doubt meant to understand that as an experienced theurgic master, ‘Abamon’ had accomplished this ritual feat following years of practice and thus had advanced well beyond his former teacher. Porphyry’s account of ritual and epiphany in Life of Plotinus 10 is in turn his response to Iamblichus’ reply to him. The traveling Egyptian priest is Abamon who is forced to recognize the superiority of Plotinus and accordingly of the Plotinian school. Iamblichus is also at the Iseum. He’s the mutual friend that introduces the priest to the philosopher and then abruptly spoils the seance out of jealousy, fear, or both. In advancing my argument and polemical reading, I build on previous scholarship by e.g. Rist, Cox, Edwards.
|
The Rape of Tamar as a Prefiguration for the Fate of Fair Zion (Bat Tzion)
Program Unit: Gender, Sexuality, and the Bible
Rachel Adelman, Hebrew College
The unraveling of David’s kingdom begins from within his own House, with episode of the rape of Tamar, his daughter, by Amnon, his firstborn son (2 Sam. 13:1-21). In this paper, I read the desolation of Tamar as a prefiguration of the fate of “Fair Zion” or “Daughter Zion” [bat Tzion] as the metaphor is played out across the prophetic narratives. Initially the city of David [Zion] is positively likened to a daughter, protected under the aegis of God’s special regard (2 Kgs. 19:21, Isaiah 36-37). Yet the female figures, known primarily by the epithet “daughter of [bat]” in the Bible, all meet a tragic fate: the daughter of Jacob (Dena, Gen. 34), of Jephthah (Judg. 11:34-40), of Saul (Michal, 1 Sam. 18 and 2 Sam. 6), and of David (Tamar, 2 Sam. 13). The metaphor of “Fair Zion [bat Zion]” likewise hinges on the presumed status of the beautiful daughter as the most vulnerable figure, the most highly sheltered and precious treasure of their father’s regard within patriarchal society. Yet Tzion, like Tamar, is “laid waste, desolate or appalled [shmm]” (Isa. 49:19, Jer. 51:26. Ezek. 6:14, 33:28, 29, 35:3, 7, 15, Lam. 1:13, 16 and 3:11). In David’s story, the father bears the weight of the blame—the debacle the first in a series of tragedies that Nathan prophesied in his doom toll (2 Sam. 12:10-11). David is made complicit in his daughter’s debasement when he sends Tamar to attend to Amnon, who feigns ill (2 Sam. 13:6-7). While the king fails to protect her, he does nothing when he hears of the rape (like Jacob in response to Dena’s debasement), and Absalom, Tamar’s brother (like Simeon and Levi) takes matters into his own hands. Despite the vengeful fratricide of Amnon in this culture of honor/shame, there is no redemption for the daughter. Tamar remains effectively silenced and “desolate [shomemah]” in her brother Absalom's house (2 Sam. 13:20)—a term deployed for the devastation of a home, city, or land. Only here and in Deutero-Isaiah, does the term shomemah refer to a woman. She (Tzion) will one day rejoice, metaphorically conceive and bear children: “For the children of the desolate woman [shomemah] will be more than the children of her that is married” (Isa. 54:1). With regard to Tamar or Dena, however, we never hear of them again. They are merely removed from view as “abject” (Julia Kristeva’s term), neither subject nor object within the social and symbolic order.
In this paper, I read with a “hermeneutics of grace”; the prophecy of consolation in Deutero-Isaiah provides us with an answer to this “text of terror.” At the same time, as a feminist, I adopt a cautionary lens, wary of reinforcing the paternalism embedded in the metaphor as a cover for the violation of the vulnerable daughter.
|
Jacob’s Night Vision and the Foundation Stone of the World
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Rachel Adelman, Hebrew College
As in a dream, midrash sometimes audaciously dislocates and relocates the locus of the foundational events in the collective memory of the Jewish people to accord with the mythic imagination. In retelling the story of “Jacob’s Ladder”, the midrash Pirqe de-Rabbi Eliezer (from hereon PRE) relocates the dream-theophany from Beth El (Genesis 28:10-22) to Moriah, the scene of Isaac’s binding (the ‘Aqedah). While precedent exists in the earlier classic rabbinic sources that link the scene of Jacob’s ladder with Mount Moriah, PRE 35 is the first source to identify the stone sanctified there with the “Foundation Stone of the World”.
Drawing upon the work of Jonathan Z. Smith on locative and utopian concepts of sacred space, as well as the evocative work of Gaston Bachelard, "The Poetics of Space", I explore how spatial constructs, in particular the experience of theophany, are configured similarly in the world of midrash, memory, and dreams. I suggest that PRE, written in the 8th c. C.E. in Palestine under Islamic rule, was influence by the Muslim legend surrounding the “White Stone” in Jerusalem, below the Dome of the Rock and near the site of the Al-Aqsa mosque where Mohammed ascended to the Seventh Heaven, in the “Nocturnal Journey” (Sura XVII, 1, also known as the “Miraj”). In a fascinating twist, PRE adapts the earlier Jewish tradition associating the Temple Mount with the Foundation Stone of the World, and merges it with the Jacob’s dream of ascension and the Islamic legends on Mohammed’s leap to Heaven. The midrash filters the cultural symbols surrounding this particularly fraught locus, the Temple Mount, projecting them back onto the biblical narratives in Genesis and forward towards a vision of the eschaton. In linking the beginning of time to the End of Days, the midrash exemplifies the redemptive arc of the Jewish mythic imagination.
|
Challenges of the Critical Edition of 1 Samuel
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Anneli Aejmelaeus, University of Helsinki
This paper deals with the challenges by which the editor has been confronted while working on the critical edition of the First Book of Samuel (Regnorum liber I) as well as with the methodological approach which has enabled her to tackle the problems. Although the critical edition of 1 Samuel for the series Septuaginta: Vetus Testamentum Graecum auctoritate Academiae Scientiarum Gottingensis editum still awaits its publication, it is already possible to reveal some of the major features of the forthcoming edition.
|
Me, the Septuagint, and Textual Criticism: A Lifelong Learning Process
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Anneli Aejmelaeus, University of Helsinki
I began my career as a student of the Septuagint, but soon started to look for areas of study which the results of Septuagint research could be applied to. Almost forty years ago, textual criticism of the Hebrew Bible – not to speak of the use of the Septuagint in it – was not in fashion, but I found it fascinating. My problem then and always has been that I cannot proceed by given rules of methodology or generally accepted ideas about the textual history, but I always have to look into the text myself and draw my own conclusions. The only authority I accept is the text, and to find out what has happened to the text is my only goal in textual criticism. This has meant a lifelong learning process as well as some controversies with colleagues who think they know it better.
|
The Berenike Cult in the Canopus Decree and the Intersection of Egyptian and Ptolemaic Divine Worlds
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Patricia Ahearne-Kroll, University of Minnesota-Twin Cities
In the Canopus Decree (238 BCE), several rituals are instituted on behalf of the deceased princess Berenike, daughter of Ptolemy III Euergetes and Berenike II. These particular practices are interwoven with Egyptian cultic traditions that were to be performed at Canopus (and elsewhere in Egypt) during the months of Choiak and Tybi. The decree incorporates princess Berenike into the dynastic pantheon alongside Egyptian gods, and it describes the design of her temple statue in terms that reflect a combination of Egyptian and Greek representational elements (F. Dunand, F. Goddio, P. Stanwick). Scholarly attention to this decree has mostly focused on the political advantage it gave the Ptolemies, and even if Egyptian priests had agency in the design and creation of the Berenike cult, their involvement is viewed mostly as a politically negotiated product (Dunand, Pfeiffer). Clearly the Canopus decree was an official document meant to promote particular ideological concerns, but I argue that the Berenike Cult is a telling example of the integration of Ptolemaic and Egyptian cosmologies and religious practices. The rituals concerning Berenike do not just evoke Egyptian traditions; they also align well with Greek traditions that were cosmically significant for the Ptolemies. Likewise, this cult reinforces old Egyptian traditions, and it creates activity for wives and daughters of Egyptian priests that was unprecedented in Egyptian temples but not in Greek religious practices. Ultimately, this cultic conflation was rooted in the physical land of Egypt, what both the Ptolemies and the Egyptian priesthood believed to be a locus of transcendent power.
|
The Appeal of Paul's Initial Preaching in Corinth
Program Unit: Redescribing Christian Origins
Stephen P. Ahearne-Kroll, University of Minnesota-Twin Cities
Among the sanctuaries of Roman Corinth and Corinthian Isthmia that dotted the civic landscape of the first recipients of Paul’s preaching, many had cult sites that included worship of more than one deity, who were connected through genealogy, mythological event, or historical tradition (local or not). There is both literary and material evidence for, at minimum, sanctuaries of Aphrodite (with Helios and Eros), Demeter and Kore (along with the Moirai), Isis and Sarapis, Dionysos (along with Artemis and Kore), Asklepios (with Hygieia and one or more deities traditionally associated with him), Poseidon (with Amphitrite along with the Tritons and Melikertes), Palaimon (with Poseidon and Leukothea), and the deities of the imperial cult. I wish to read Paul’s initial presentation of his god to his Corinthian audiences through the lens of this local religious practice. Paul’s god(s) might look quite familiar to Corinthians, in that they are a finite set (a father god, a child of the father, and a third figure of presence [spirit]), related by myth/history, genealogy, and by cultic worship. I will thus posit a context that explains an amenable reception among Paul’s audience for the initial presentation of his god and that partially accounts for his success as a missionary of Christ Jesus. I will then perform an initial inquiry into whether or not Paul tried to correct this possible misunderstanding by the Corinthians about the nature of his god by looking at 1 Corinthians 2.
|
The Fourth Generation, Joseph, Did Not Return: Only His Bones
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
John Ahn, Howard University
As early as 1885, William R. Harper raised concerns on the compositional history of Gen 37:2-Exo 12:51. His initial observation begins with the tolodot formula and rightly remarks on the problem of “generations.” In a recent dissertation on Gen 37 published in 2017 (FAT 2), Matthew Genung makes two cases for the Joseph material: (1) a re-actualization by the post-exilic/return migrations Persian community wishing to re-unify the “North and South” and (2) the additional redactional post-priestly material integrated the JS texts by P in the Hellenistic period. In this paper, I begin with the construct of the “fourth generation.” In a history of oral tradition, speakers can basically carry a detailed narrative down to the third generation (Jan Vansina). But by the fourth, that cultural memory story begins to fade or conversely, it must be written down to preserve that generation’s story within the holistic tradition at large. It’s no coincide that a (final?) tradent of the Pentateuch incorporated the Joseph novella into the third generation’s Jacob Cycle. Sociologically speaking, in the (diaspora) novella, like Daniel and his three friends, Joseph’s name is changed to Zaphnath-Paneah. But unlike the four who were likely made into eunuchs (Isa 56:4), he is given Asenath, the daughter of Potiphera, the priest of On, to be his wife. And as a new generation begins, Ephraim and Manasseh are born through an Egyptian mother. This lineage extends down to Joshua the son of Nun, chieftain of Ephraim. This social construction of reality is seminal for the generations displaced and resettled in Egypt after the 721 and 582 BCE events, as an amalgamation of the Elephantine Jews in Egypt. Constructions of belonging, identity, and generational consciousness in Joseph, like the Book of Ruth, which is read as an anti-Ezra polemic, also reads against the “pure” lineage of Ezra’s (Ezra 9-10) Persian homogeneous solution. The practice of “inter-marriage” to move up socio-politically is projected favorably and positively dignified. The Joseph material isn’t a reconstitution of the North and South but an attempt to harmonize the East and West conflict. In other words, with the return migrations phenomena, the re-actualizing of those returning from Egypt and Persia as a response to Second Isaiah, while those like Joseph-Asenath did not return (CC Torrey); only his bones through a later generation.
|
Diaspora: Third and Fourth Generations
Program Unit: Korean Biblical Colloquium
John Ahn, Howard University
The Greek word, diaspora, means to "sow again." The term describes the (re)colonization and (re)population of re-established Roman territories that once belonged to the Greeks or others, like the city of Philippi. Once resettled, after a long period of establishment, that is, several generations, the cultural memory of those that first made the transplant are normally remembered; in oral tradition down to the third generation (Jan Vasina). But by the fourth generation, memory fades, and to actualize and maintain that memory, the story is normally written down. Interestingly, Hansen's law of third generation notes that what the son or daughter (second generation) wishes to forget, the grandchildren recover. The Hebrew Bible (from Abraham to Joseph, exile and return) and even select books of the New Testament are by and large framed in a fourth generation construction (Book of Ephesians - third/fourth generation Christian). This paper offers broad sociological observations on the importance of the third and fourth generations to help biblical scholars and contextual interpreters identify key features. Moreover, the implications for what this means in a Korean American Diaspora context will be explored.
|
Classical Allusion and the Greek of Sirach
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
James K. Aitken, University of Cambridge
Greek Sirach has been poorly served by its interpreters. Its consistent translation technique has led to its being largely ignored for the contribution it can make to translation studies and for the important place it occupies in the history of Septuagint studies. It has been shown in recent years, however, that the translator was sophisticated in aspects of his use of Greek and creative in his interpretation of his Hebrew, even while following closely his Hebrew Vorlage. This paper will consider the surprising extent of allusion to classical literature, demonstrating how Jewish theology is expressed in classical form and how much the translator reconfigures his source. Special attention will be given to the Greek of chapter 31(34) and the clear modelling upon Hellenistic readings of Homer. It will show how we need to be careful in reconstructing the Vorlage from the Greek and demonstrate the important place of Sirach in the history of the Septuagint.
|
Three Prayers in Ephesians: Christological Craftsmanship and Ecclesiological Expectations
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Adesola Akala, Durham University
The presence of three long, grammatically complex prayers in Ephesians is an unusual phenomenon. Covering almost a fifth of the entire epistle, the prayer texts comprise a protracted benediction (1:3-14), which transitions into a lengthy intercession (1:15-23) capped by a third prayer (3:14-21). Scholars have recognized and discussed the creative reinvention of the ancient convention of epistolary prayers in both the Pauline and Deutero-Pauline epistles (Gordon Wiles, 1974; Peter O’Brien, 1977; John Polhill, 1999; Luther Stirewalt, 2003; Hans-Josef Klauck, 2006; Patrick Gray, 2012). This paper argues that the writer of Ephesians has carried this adaptation of epistolary conventions to an extraordinary level in order to accommodate his theological agenda. An analysis of the structure and content of the prayers shows how they present the writer’s “mystery” of Christ,” (1:9; 3:3, 4, 9; 5:32; 6:19), which is vital for interpreting Ephesians within its Jewish-Gentile context. Cosmic Christology is ingeniously interwoven with realized eschatology to present the epistle’s ecclesiology of unity and reconciliation. Not only does this epistle contribute to our understanding of the complex phenomenon of Pauline prayers, it also substantially adds to the richness of Christology and ecclesiology in the disputed Pauline letters. Through these three theologically-crafted prayers, the writer of Ephesians compels the multicultural community of Christians in Asia Minor to flourish together within the unity of the Spirit, the love of Christ, and the fullness of God.
|
Wisdom-Law Meets Politics: The Holiness Code and Ezekiel as a Test Case
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
Kengo Akiyama, University of California-Davis
This paper explores the intersection of law and politics in the Hebrew Bible in two ways. While the Hebrew Bible does not adumbrate a “political theory” as a way of establishing and regulating public institutions—as Michael Walzer observes in his seminal work (In God’s Shadow)—Mira Morgenstern is correct in arguing that heterogenous political thoughts are both implicit and operative in it. In view of this, the paper will first tease out some aspects of the political thought in the Holiness Code (H), particularly the priestly attempt to democratize holiness as a totalizing principle. The analysis will focus mostly on the issue of administering justice to the poor and the needy. Second, given Ezekiel’s knowledge of (dependence on?) H, I will show how H’s political force is transmitted to and/or reshaped in Ezekiel. Of particular interest here is the amplifying (or dampening) effects of the prophetic oracle on the political dimension of biblical law. The paper will shed light not only on some key differences and similarities of law and prophecy as literary genres but also on the conceptual unity of legal, ethical, and political discourses in some strands of the Hebrew Bible.
|
Old Greek Isaiah 13:19: Misunderstood Hebrew and Constructive Greek
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Matthew Albanese, University of Oxford
Septuagint scholarship has long recognized the deep cultural and linguistic influences upon the Greek translators of the Hebrew scriptures. One expression of this cultural-linguistic milieu rests in the influence of post-biblical Hebrew and Aramaic upon translators’ knowledge of their source texts. Several papers, chapters, and monographs in Septuagint research are devoted to this topic; lists of relevant examples are plenty available. In this paper, I seek to challenge a general methodological and linguistic consensus regarding the translator of Greek Isaiah’s understanding of the term ṣby “beauty” and its supposed connection to the Greek terms doxa “glory” and endoxos “glorious.” While it appears that these two terms at times overlap in Greek Isaiah, I argue that the translator rather evidences a misunderstanding of this Hebrew term in many places and he creates stylistic translations where the context permits. The use of doxa and endoxos are not proper translations, but instead function as contextual guesses. I seek to contribute to previous discussions in the field by providing a more nuanced understanding of the translator’s lexical choice which is based upon his translation technical practice.
|
The New Critical Edition of the Psalms of Solomon: Septuaginta. Vetus Testamentum Graecum Auctoritate Academiae Scientiarum Gottingensis Editum, vol. XII/3
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Felix Albrecht, Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Göttingen
The editor would like to present the new Göttingen edition of the Psalms of Solomon. This edition claims to have established the oldest attainable text of the Psalms of Solomon. The text is characterised by certain linguistic features which were partially lost in the textual transmission. This paper demonstrates the characteristics of the original text and shows how these features were gradually lost during the long period of textual transmission.
|
“Another Time and Another Place”: Apocalyptic Elements in Pan’s Labyrinth
Program Unit: Bible and Film
Isaac M. Alderman, Catholic University of America
While dystopian worlds in film are very often described with language drawn from apocalypticism, the genre of apocalyptic literature has very specific characteristics, such as fantastical imagery, an otherworldly guide, and a focus on other times and places. Many aspects of religion are utilized to keep institutions and communities in their socially accepted places, but apocalyptic literature utilizes these features in service of a subversive religious impulse, promising its readers with a reversal of the violent and oppressive social order and a new age in which the powerless are exalted above their oppressors. The account is presented in this way so as to instill hope in its audience
Pan’s Labyrinth (El Laberinto del Fauno [G. del Toro, 2006]) presents a layered crisis, both familial and political. Ofelia and her mother live with a human monster who terrorizes them while also leading Franco’s soldiers in a quest to extinguish the spanish rebels. Suffering because of war, the cruelty of her stepfather and the pain of her ill and pregnant mother, Ofelia is led by a faun into the knowledge of another world. Through his guidance, as well as assistance from fairies and The Book of Crossroads, she learns that she is a princess from long ago. After the death of her mother, Ofelia seeks to save her newborn brother and eventually escapes to join her mother and father who are the king and queen of another world.
The structure and generic characteristics of Jewish and Christian apocalyptic literature are integral to its message. When viewed through these elements, Pan’s Labyrinth is seen to be more genuinely apocalyptic than many films which present a cataclysmic end to the world, for the film looks both backward and forward in time, to another world, to provide hope in the time of crisis.
|
The Textual History of the Prophet Haggai in the Ethiopic Tradition
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Samuel R. Aldridge, Oregon Conference - Free Methodist Church USA
This paper will engage with the story of how the text of the prophet Haggai was transmitted within the biblical manuscripts of the Ethiopic Orthodox tradition, from the earliest extant manuscripts of the fourteenth century through to those of the last century. The paper will cover aspects such as manuscript clustering, the characteristics of manuscript clusters, analysis of key areas of variance, and comparison with current research on other texts from the Book of the Twelve in the Ethiopic Tradition.
|
Rabbinic Animal Affects: Deleuzian Critiques, Disruptive Politics, and the Technology of Animals
Program Unit: Animal Studies and the Bible
Alex Weisberg, New York University
In this paper, I follow Donovan Schaefer and Donna Haraway in their critique of Deluezian animality to understand the ways that the Sifra and the Mekhilta de-Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, 3rd century Jewish exegetical works, read Leviticus 25 and Exodus 23 as political calls to become with animals. By focusing on actual animals and their situated embodiment within Rabbinic discourse, I argue against the specter of an ahistorical Deleuzian interpretation, which would treat the animal as an abstract radical possibility standing against humanity, in favor of an interpretation made attentive, by Haraway’s and Schaefer’s perspectives, to an emergent picture of a historically bounded Rabbinic human-animal assemblage. Schaefer’s insistence on phenomenological embodiment brings to the fore the ways in which these texts include animals in the political conversation through their migratory patterns, while Haraway’s work helps us to understand how in these texts animals are both political technology and moral subjects.
|
From Pageants to the Pulpit: Child Shepherds in Luke’s Gospel Account
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Amy Lindeman Allen, Christian Theological Seminary
Although “shepherd boys” have become a part of popular Christmas lore and children’s pageants, few scholars have taken seriously the age and socio-economic status of the shepherds in Luke’s gospel account. Drawing from Greco-Roman contemporaries and Hebrew Bible parallels, I will argue that for Luke’s original audience the shepherds portrayed in the nativity account would have been heard and imagined as children, either the sons and daughters of poor sheep herding families or the slaves of wealthier herd owners. From this perspective, I then re-read Luke’s nativity account with an emphasis on the participation of children as both the first to hear the good news of Jesus’ birth proclaimed by the angels (Lk. 2:10-12) and the first people to proclaim this message of good news of great joy (Lk 2:20).
|
Baptism as Transformation and Promise: The Concept of Sealing in the Letter to the Ephesians
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Amy Lindeman Allen, Christian Theological Seminary
Writing from the context of Lutheran ritual and liturgy surrounding baptism, this paper reads the seal of the Holy Spirit in Ephesians and 1 Corinthians as connected to the rite of water baptism and in particular the use of oil both in anointing catechumens in preparation for baptism and immediately following the water baptism itself. The term evsfragi,sqhte (“you were sealed”) as it is used in these texts indicates a mark of ownership that God places on the Christian believer as a means of protection and promise of a future inheritance. However, more than this, the seal referred to in Ephesians is an actual imparting of the Holy Spirit. For Christians who practice water baptism, this defines the role of the Holy Spirit in such ritual, acknowledges the partial realization of the eschatological promise of fullness in the Spirit, and thus draws out the eschatological implications of the baptismal rite. This reading of sealing empowers such readers to understand their baptisms as far more than a ritual act. It is the beginning and the ending of a way of life marked by the transformative power of God’s Holy Spirit, as implied by the labeling of the adult catechumenate as a “Journey with Christ” in contemporary Lutheran contexts. The power and the force of this transformation come from the way in which the believers lives with and through this spirit seal in between those two moments.
|
Monks, Manuscripts, Muhammad, and Digital Editions of the New Testament
Program Unit:
Garrick Allen, Dublin City University
Much has been made recently in textual scholarship in a number of disciplines in the humanities about the impending change of medium in critical editions. What changes when we produce digital editions? What important functionalities of print editions are sidelined and what new avenues for research appear in a digital medium? These questions, among others, are particularly timely when it comes to the New Testament in light of the recent online publication of the Editio Critica Maior of the book of Acts. This paper argues that, because critical editions set the agenda for a field, they provide an opportunity to explore the developing relationships between textual transmission, exegesis, and reception history. In comparison to their print counterparts, “born-digital” editions are more open to experimentation and more transparent in their relationships to the manuscripts that undergird them, providing an important tool for exploring manuscripts as witnesses to interpretation and reception. To illustrate this assertion, the paper explores a selection of a medieval witnesses to the book of Revelation that contain marginal notations on the identity of the beast in Rev 13:18. These traditions offer concrete evidence for medieval interpretation, evidence that has not traditionally been prioritised in print editions. This analysis offers insight into the ways that digital editions enable analysis that is not necessarily, interested in establishing an Ausgangstext, but in understanding how manuscripts function as witnesses to traditions of biblical interpretation.
|
The Number of the Beast and the Value of Digital Editions
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
Garrick Allen, Dublin City University
Much has been made recently in textual scholarship in a number of disciplines in the humanities about the impending change of medium in critical editions. What changes when we produce digital editions? What important functionalities of print editions are sidelined and what new avenues for research appear in a digital medium? These questions, among others, are particularly timely when it comes to the New Testament in light of the recent online publication of the Editio Critica Maior of the book of Acts. This paper argues that, because critical editions to a certain degree set the agenda for a field, they provide an opportunity to explore the developing relationships between textual transmission, exegesis, and reception history. In comparison to print editions, “born-digital” editions are more open to experimentation and more transparent in their relationships to the manuscripts that undergird them, providing an important tool for exploring manuscripts as witnesses to interpretation and reception. To illustrate this assertion, the paper explores a selection of a medieval witnesses to the book of Revelation that contain marginal notations on the identity of the beast in Rev 13:18, a text that represents an important exegetical crux for the material that follows chapter 13. These traditions offer concrete evidence for medieval interpretation, evidence that has not traditionally been prioritised in print editions. This analysis offers insight into the ways that digital editions enable analysis that is not necessarily, at the least in the first instance, interested in establishing an Ausgangstext, but in understanding how manuscripts function as witnesses to traditions of biblical interpretation.
|
“God Only Does Weird Baby-Stuff”: Biblical Reception and Interpretation in ABC's ‘Modern Family’
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Tobias Ålöw, Göteborgs Universitet
This paper explores and explicates the intersection of the Bible and popular culture as it comes to expression in ABC:s widely popular and critically acclaimed mockumentary/sitcom “Modern Family”. More precisely, in the episode “Fight or Flight” (S6E15) one of the show’s protagonists, Cameron Tucker, tries to convince his partner, Mitchell Pritchett, that God has deliberately orchestrated a number of otherwise apparently ordinary and quite naturally explainable events so that they would have the opportunity to adopt their friend Sal’s abandoned baby. When Mitchell questions who this God is – who first denies them a baby, then gets a party-girl like Sal pregnant, only to have her forsake the baby so they could finally get one – Cameron responds by affirming that it is: “The same God that impregnated a virgin, sent Moses down the river in a basket, and commanded Abraham to stab his own son. God only does weird baby-stuff.”
Although the verbal exchange between Cameron and Mitchell is clearly intended for entertainment, the paper nevertheless treats their altercation exegetically seriously as an expression of biblical reception. Behind the humorous exterior, meaningful theological questions are raised in a way that reflect common conceptions regarding how the Bible is put together, interpreted and applied. Moreover, with reference to three different biblical traditions Cameron draws a general theological conclusion that can be subjected to exegetical scrutiny.
Taking its methodological cues from the approach set out by S. Klint, the paper not only describes how the biblical presence is made manifest by identifying the biblical traditions alluded to, but also attempts to lay bare the tension between approach and deviation from the biblical material, and describe the function of these biblical texts within the pertinent work of reception.
Through analysis of how the apposite biblical traditions are re-used the paper not only sheds light on biblical reception in Modern Family in particular, but at the same time also attests to the reciprocal relationship between the Bible and popular culture in general.
|
Surveillance and Lot-Sodom: A Hermeneutic of Watching
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
Carolyn Alsen, University of Divinity
Surveillance studies is employed in this study of Genesis 18-19 to analyse power, overreach of jurisdiction, the search for ultimate security and political violence and trauma. It specifically uses the metaphor of seeing through surveillant/souveillant means (a field of veillance) and divine omnividence. Firstly, an ideological criticism examines the tendencies of ancient Persian surveillance and how this influenced authors of biblical texts. Secondly, narrative criticism (narratology) applies these tendencies to the literary dynamics of biblical narratives through visual tropes.
This reading of Genesis 18-19 presents the text as compiled for readers in a world influenced by watching powers. The struggle for surveillant knowledge and security is illustrated in the petition of Abraham, the dual locations of the divine gaze and the internal struggle between two groups in the Sodom (Ammon-Moab) Mamre (Israelite) polemic. However, Lot's wife (Ado), in Gen 19:26, conducts sousveillance to illustrate the resistance to the violence caused by struggle with colonial seeing.
Ancient surveillance is often mimetically favoured by Deuteronomy and Ezra-Nehemiah for success in political dominance. However, ancient Israelite religion is also shaped by the limitations of their own nationalism by colonization itself. A narrative reading strategy utilising veillance can illustrate the links between the inner social sorting of Israelite populations and the colonizing gaze of xenophobia and androcentricity.
|
Edges of Space or Edges of Time: The Commandmant of Peah in Tannaitic Midrash Halakhah
Program Unit: Midrash
Aaron Amit, Bar-Ilan University
The commandment of separating peah (gleanings) is mentioned in Leviticus 19:9: "When you reap the harvest of your land, you shall not reap all the way to the edges of your field" (see also Leviticus 23:22). According to the Torah, a portion of the field is left to be harvested by those in need. A careful comparison of Mishnah Peah 1:3 and Tosefta Peah 1:5-6 (ed. Lieberman, pp. 42-43) reveals a fascinating difference between the two tannaitic sources on the understanding of the Rabbis interpretation of this biblical commandment. According to Mishnah Peah 1:3 the sages debated whether peah could be left unharvested at the beginning, middle or end of the field (implying that 'edges' refer to location); this could be done at any stage of the harvest. However, the Tosefta, according to the Vienna manuscript, implies that the debate relates not to the location in the field, but to the time in the harvest – the beginning, middle or end of the harvest (implying that 'edges' refer to time). Therefore, according to the halakhot in the Tosefta, peah must be left unharvested at the end of the harvest period, but it could be left in any part of the field.
In my paper I will investigate in detail the source of this dichotomy between physical space and time, comparing all of the known tannaitic versions of this debate on the biblical commandment of peah on this point (including PT Peah 4:3 18b and BT Shabbat 23a). My paper demonstrates that the key to the understanding of the Rabbis' opinions lies in identifying the earliest rabbinic midrash on Leviticus 19:9: the Halakhic Midrash to the book of Leviticus – Sifra (Qedoshim, Parashah 1:10). According to the Sifra, the original tannaitic position was that the 'edges' were defined by both location and time. However, because of textual difficulties in the original midrash which will be discussed in detail – the Tosefta modified the original tannaitic Halakhic Midrash and centered the debate on time and not on location. This caused much confusion in later sources and generated debate among medieval authorities on the correct interpretation of the sources. Understanding the direction in the development from the original Halakhic midrash to the Mishnah and Tosefta is key to resolving the tension between space and time in the rabbinic interpretation of the commandment of peah.
|
Paul on Remuneration in 1 Corinthians 9:14-18 and Its Rabbinic Background
Program Unit: Paul within Judaism
Aaron Amit, Bar-Ilan University
Paul's decision not to receive remuneration from the community in Corinth has been a point of contention from his own lifetime until today. Ronald Hock, in his book The Social Context of Paul's Ministry: Tentmaking and Apostleship (Philadelphia 1980) described four attitudes among philosophers towards remuneration; namely, charging fees, finding a patron, begging and manual labor. While the Sophists chose the first method, the Cynics preferred to rely on begging. Paul chose manual labor, a choice some liken to the ideal of early Jewish sages, to combine Torah study with plying a trade. However, in this and other studies, Hock warned against this understanding, claiming that any connection to rabbinic sources is problematic because the Jewish practice of combining manual labor with Torah study is “difficult to establish before the mid-second century” (JBL, 97 [1978], 557). On the other side of the spectrum, Ze'ev Safrai and Peter Tomson argue in their recent discussion of 2 Corinthians 8-9 (“Paul’s ‘Collection for the Saints’ [2 Cor 8-9] and Financial Support of Leaders in Early Christianity and Judaism”, in Second Corinthians in the Perspective of Late Second Temple Judaism [ed. Reimund Bieringer et al.], Leiden 2014), that “in the early halakha it was unambiguously ruled that one should not receive a salary for teaching Tora”, a ruling they connected with Jesus’ dictum “freely you received, freely give" (Matthew 10:8). However, they devoted little attention to 1 Corinthians 9:14-18, and their short discussion of the Jewish attitude is flawed by inaccurate dating of rabbinic material.
My paper centers on Paul's refusal to take advantage of the tradition he quotes in the name of Jesus in verse 14: “those who proclaim the gospel should get their living by the gospel”. I examine the view attributed to Jesus and Paul's opinion in light of several rabbinic sources on the question of remuneration for Torah study and instruction; these include: Mishnah Avot 1:13; Sifrei Deuteronomy 42, PT Shekalim 4:2 (48a), Avot deRabbi Natan A, chapter 3, BT Ketubot 105a, BT Bekhorot 29a and BT Berakhot 35b. I examine the sources on the basis of both higher and lower critical considerations, and propose a timeline for the development of the various rabbinic attitudes towards remuneration on the basis of such considerations. My argument is that it is first necessary to identify the earliest traditions found in rabbinic literature, those which could reflect first century norms, and then compare them to Pauline material. This will lead to the conclusion that Paul's attitude towards remuneration was influenced by a late Second Temple directive, evinced also in the gospels (Matthew 10:8), which survives, as well, in the Aramaic tradition attributed to Hillel in Mishnah Avot 1:13.
|
Unhappy Endings: Deconstructing Hope in Jeremiah 37-43
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Sonja Ammann, Universität Basel
“We hope for peace, but there is no good; for a time of healing, but behold: terror!” (Jer 8:15). Compromised hope is a major topic in the book of Jeremiah. Those who raise hope for "shalom" are dismissed as false prophets, and those who hope for "shalom" are generally disappointed. In this paper, I will follow the traces of hope in the narrative of the fall of Jerusalem in Jer 37-43. Various characters in this story express hopes for peace or for a better future, but Jeremiah’s prophecies crushes their hopes (Jer 37:7-10, 17; 38:3, 21-23; 42:15-22). The best they can hope for is to save their lives (38:2, 17-18, 20; 39:16-18). I will then focus on the Gedaliah episode in Jer 40-41, which is usually interpreted as a moment of hope in the story. In this passage, the prophet Jeremiah does not appear. The rule of the governor Gedaliah is generally considered as cast in a very positive light, opening up a new opportunity for a properous life in the land. By building upon some textual observations made by W. McKane, I will show that Jer 40:7-12 also allows for a much less peaceful reading. Thus, the story dashes the hopes not only of the characters within the story, but also of the reader. By considering the hopeful reader’s role, I will turn back to Jeremiah’s hope-crushing prophecies. Like the characters in the story, readers have the option of disagreeing with Jeremiah and defending a hopeful perspective. Interestingly, the text (especially in the shorter version of the LXX) does not insist on the fulfillment of Jeremiah’s prophecies. Moreover, the historically informed reader might question the devastating outcome Jeremiah predicts for the community in Egypt. In conclusion, I will argue that the text can be read as an exercise in balancing hopes in which the reader is invited to take part.
|
The Dystopian Bible: The Chrysalids, The Handmaid's Tale, and The History of the Anglican Church of Canada
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Maryann Amor, Vancouver School of Theology
In both John Wyndham’s The Chrysalids and Margaret Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale the Bible is a tool of oppression and control – in The Chrysalids, the Bible underlies the elimination of “mutants,” and, in The Handmaid’s Tale, the Bible is instrumental in the restriction of women’s freedom. Although both authors were writing in different times and places, they use the Bible in similar ways. This observation raises the question: why have the authors used the Bible as the source of oppression in their respective novels? In this paper I suggest that the authors use the Bible as an oppressive tool because they are writing dystopias. In dystopias, authors create worlds where they take aspects of their context and exaggerate them to warn of what could happen should social trends continue. In both Wyndham’s and Atwood’s contexts the Bible was used to suppress people’s freedom and their novels demonstrate the horror of what could happen if those in power continue to use the Bible in this way. However, while this use of the Bible is shaped by the authors’ contexts, it also gives their novels a timeless quality – because history repeats itself, their novels’ dystopic warning can speak to many historical and contemporary situations. For me, as a Canadian Anglican, Wyndham’s and Atwood’s novels touch on the history of my faith tradition, where the Bible informed the suppression of Indigenous people and women. The dystopic genre is, then, key to understanding both how Wyndham and Atwood used the Bible in their novels and how their novels continue to terrify readers.
|
Isaac’s Death and Resurrection Remembered: The Reception of the Akedah in Jewish Tradition
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Bradford Anderson, Dublin City University
This paper will explore the reception of the Akedah in Jewish tradition (Gen 22), namely those streams of the tradition which claim that Isaac died and was resurrected. Along with analysis of interpretive moves made in these readings, focus will be placed on why this particular text became a focal point for reflection on resurrection. Attention will also be given to the ancestral narratives and cultural memory, as well as the relationship between reception history and memory studies.
|
“When Earth’s Curse Shall Be Removed”: Interpretations of the Genesis Creation/Fall Narrative in Mormon Women’s Suffrage Rhetoric
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Carli Anderson, Arizona State University
During the national fight for women’s suffrage in America, the biblical text was often used as evidence both to promote and obstruct women’s access to the vote. This was accomplished frequently through disparate interpretations of the creation/fall narrative of Genesis 1-3. This paper examines the ways in which 19th-century Mormon women utilized the narrative of Genesis as justification for their right to vote. Thy refer to the themes of creation, Eve, and the equality of the sexes in strategic and original ways. Mormon women were a unique voice in the national movement for women’s suffrage.The vote came to Utah women early (1870) and they held the right to suffrage for seventeen years, when, under the Edmunds-Tucker anti-polygamy act, they lost their vote. It would not be restored until 1895. Mormon women in Utah were familiar with the interpretative work of Angela Grimké and Lucretia Mott, likely feeling aligned with their interpretations of the biblical text in support of equal suffrage. In some ways, Mormon women’s biblical rhetoric followed a similar pattern. In other ways, however, Mormon women’s use of the Genesis narrative was rooted in their unique theology of the Fall, which Helen Mar Whitney (1828-1896) described as “a blessing in disguise.” In their rhetoric, Eve’s culpability is not dismissed, rather her act is contextualized as somewhat heroic but also in terms of bringing a curse that needs reversing. The equality of the sexes is always read into the Genesis account. The women’s interpretations, however, don’t always correspond regarding the reasons for the “curse” of Genesis 3:16, whether it was needed for women’s penance or as a shackle imposed on them by fallen men. Several writers suggest that the women’s suffrage movement was itself part of a reversing of the effects of the “curse” preparatory to an anticipated Utopian age. As well, in parallel to their own experience, bringing the vote back to Utah women symbolically brought back the original equality of Eden.
|
John's Story of Jesus: A Historicized Drama, or a Dramatized History; Does Burridge's Contribution Offer a Critical Way Forward?
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Paul Anderson, George Fox University
Burridge panel
|
The Eden Narrative, Self-Awareness, and Mirror Self-Recognition (MSR) in Human Development: A Psychological Biblical Critical Approach
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Royce Anderson, Union Theological Seminary in the City of New York
In birth and early childhood, a child faces their first challenges as they develop their cognitive, emotional, and social capabilities and grow toward their full human potential. A critical point in this development is the emergence of self-awareness in early childhood (18-24 months) as part of a continuing process of psychological development that continues throughout life.
This paper examines the concept of “self-awareness” as defined and analyzed in the psychological literature, and applies it to the Garden of Eden narrative. It explores the parallels between and relationships among:
1. the Eden narrative (Genesis 2:4b – 3:24),
2. the emergence of self-awareness in young children,
specifically, Gordon Gallup and others’ concept of
Mirror Self Recognition, (MSR),
3. the development of language and culture in early Homo sapiens
societies.
A review of the PsyBibs literature describing the Eden narrative as the birth of self-consciousness, in tandem with the psychological literature on self-awareness, leads to a definition of self-awareness as “the ability to reflect on one’s own mental state and the capacity to regard the self as a different entity from others”. The impact of self-awareness on the development of human cognition, emotion, language, and civilization is explored in the context of childhood development and also within the context of the socio-cultural development of early human communities. The literature suggests that being “human” doesn’t mean just being Homo sapiens, but also means being self-aware:
“Homo sapiens + self-awareness = human.”
A more focused discussion of self-awareness follows, emphasizing “Mirror Self-Recognition” (MSR) as a crucial and measurable step in a multi-stage process of self-awareness development. MSR methodology is described, and several views are offered of how MSR fits into the stages of self-awareness development. MSR leads not only to cognitive changes, but also to changes in the kinds of emotions and social relationships that emerge with a more developed sense of self-awareness. For example, awareness of others (Theory of Mind) cannot precede awareness of self (MSR). Finally, the differences between “self-conscious-emotions” and “non-self-conscious emotions”, and also between “socialization” and “enculturation”, are discussed in the context of self-awareness development.
Implications for future research and methodological considerations are discussed. Responding to Wayne Rollins’ call for “re-visioning biblical origins, focusing less on dates, places, and historical events, but emphasizing the ‘psychic events’ that lie at the base of the text”; this presentation uses “self-awareness” to re-vision the Eden narrative in a psychological context; allowing for deeper insights into how the story may offer an important ancient perspective on “becoming human” that can be brought into dialogue with current social-scientific perspectives.
|
The Food Laws of the Pentateuch: Textual and Archaeological Perspectives
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Anna Angelini, University of Lausanne
(no abstract)
|
“Like a Lion from the Thickets of the Jordan”: The Lexicon of Feline Carnivores in Biblical Traditions
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Anna Angelini, University of Lausanne
The nomenclature of large predators is quite rich in ancient Hebrew, especially in that which concerns the names for «lion» (‘aryeh ; laby ; šaḥal ; layš, kepyr ; gûr). In Hebrew poetry, where references to large predators are concentrated, the lion is often mentioned together with the leopard (namer) or with the bear (dob). Such a rich vocabulary allows us to reconstruct patterns of behaviors associated with these animals, their relationship with specific environments, and, to a certain extent, a relative taxonomy (for example, gender and age distinctions seem to be present in the lion nomenclature). Translations of these names in the ancient versions show a variety of tendencies. Although ancient renderings are for the most part quite consistent, the employed lexicon nonetheless reveals a certain degree of interpretation. While some interpretations can be justified by textual difficulties, they might also reflect different zoological patterns or a variation in landscape. This paper will reconstruct the history of identification of some “biblical” predators in antiquity. It will analyze the lexicon of feline carnivores in ancient translations of the Hebrew Bible, with a focus on the renderings witnessed by the Septuagint, which will be examined against the background of Greco-Roman zoology. Readings from Peshitta, Targum and Vulgate will also be included to enlarge the comparative perspective. This survey will also help in evaluating to what extent ancient interpretations have contributed to the understanding of biblical species in modern times.
|
“It’s the Economy, Stupid”: Economic Concerns in the Dead Sea Scrolls’ Polemic against the Wicked Priest
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
Giancarlo Angulo, Florida State University
The Wicked Priest has been the subject of conversation in the study of the Dead Sea Scrolls both as he relates to the movement’s critique of standard Jewish forms of practice and to the sect’s rhetorical process of self-definition. Most scholars suggest that the Scrolls’ rejection of the Wicked Priest falls along three major issues: (1) ritual impurity; (2) calendrical observance; and (3) hereditary illegitimacy. The first two find strong corroboration in extant manuscripts but the latter derives perhaps more specifically from modern analytical expectations and, as such, has been rightly contested. Yet, we suggest that scholarship has largely overlooked another important aspect to the Scrolls’ condemnation of Hasmonean rule. The primary indictment of the Wicked Priest in the Dead Sea Scrolls pertains directly to improper or nefarious economic administration in at least four of the seven passages in which the character appears. This paper will offer a close reading of each passage relating to the figure’s involvement with economic practices and situate the critique of the Wicked Priest into a broader polemic against royalty – specifically Greek royalty – based on the allegation of exploitative economic activity and insatiable avarice. In so doing, we show that the diatribe against the priest in the Dead Sea Scrolls follows and builds on a longstanding polemic against imperial agents who are perceived to have done financial harm to the populace. We posit that the authors of the pesharim, then, interpreted the economic system of the Wicked Priest in light of previous policies of plunder and exploitation and their discontents. As such, the development and perpetuation of such parallels contributed to the group’s vehement rejection of the Hasmonean leadership. This conclusion bears significance on at least two important matters. On the one hand, a reading of the pesharim’s rejection of the Wicked Priest along economic lines allows us to illumine the Qumran movement’s perspective on Hasmonean modes of economic administration. This functions both on an historical level - as it sheds light on the foundation and on-the-ground reality of the movement - and on a rhetorical point - as it better develops some of the other economic language in manuscripts like CD and 4QInstruction. On the other hand, an economic emphasis may also color the kinds of social conditions that both fostered and sustained sectarian motivations in second- and first-century Judea. Following a model proposed by Baumgarten, an economic critique of the Wicked Priest in the Dead Sea Scrolls further demonstrates a process of popular disillusionment with the Hasmonean dynasty following the second-century Maccabean revolt. Altogether, we argue that the vociferous antagonism against the Wicked Priest in the Dead Sea Scrolls carries considerable economic considerations that function to place the Wicked Priest in relation to illegitimate foreign rulers. This sort of language works to establish a view of the Hasmonean royalty as Greek-like imperialists who must be resisted and unequivocally rejected.
|
From Theories of Truth to Epistemic Etiquette: Revisiting the Epistemology of the Book of Proverbs
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Christopher Ansberry, Oak Hill College
While the book of Proverbs does not present an explicit epistemology, many contend or simply assume that modern philosophical concepts and theories provide a heuristic guide for encapsulating the implicit epistemology of the sages. To varying degrees, a correspondence theory of truth, a coherence theory of truth, and embodied realism seem to capture aspects of Proverbs’ latent epistemology. When these theories are held up against the diverse materials in the book, however, each exhibits certain weaknesses. In the light of these shortcomings, this paper moves beyond theories of truth that may orient one to Proverbs’ implicit epistemology and explores the explicit epistemic etiquette outlined by the materials in the anthology.
|
Are Biblical Hebrew Construct Noun Phrases Bicephalic?
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Matthew Anstey, Alphacrucis College
In the Latin tradition of grammatical analysis of Biblical Hebrew Construct Noun Phrases (CNPs), the construct noun is termed regens ‘ruler’ and the absolute noun rectum ‘ruled’. Yet in the Hebrew grammatical tradition, it is viewed the other way round: the construct noun is nismak ‘bound’ and the absolute is somek ‘unbound’. Sperber noted this contrast in perspectives: “According to the Hebrew way of thinking it is exactly vice versa [to the non-Hebrew way]: the second noun remains unchanged and even gets the article if determined, and causes the first noun to undergo certain changes”. At the external clausal level, the Latin view makes sense, because the construct noun fills a participant role in the clausal structure. At the internal phrase level, the Hebrew view makes sense, because the absolute form is a fully-fledged noun phrase and, moreover, the construct noun cannot appear independently, which is unexpected. Contemporary linguistic analyses of the CNP strongly favor the Latin tradition, arguing that the absolute form is a syntactic complement to the construct head. But could there be an alternative analysis, according to which CNPs are bicephalic, ‘double-headed’—the absolute noun heading the CNP internally and the construct noun the CNP externally? Arguments for such an account will be examined.
|
“May Your Allies Be Like the Sun, Rising in Its Strength": Female Collusion in the Context of the Song of Deborah, Slavery, and the #metoo Movement
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Deborah A Appler, Moravian College & Theological Seminary
The Song of Deborah (Judges 5) is among the oldest and most celebrated texts in the Hebrew Bible. This ballad recounts Deborah and Barak’s triumph over King Jabin and his army led by General Sisera. As Deborah sings about overcoming these oppressive forces and celebrates Jael’s murder of Sisera, this prophet and judge and “mother of all Israel” ends her tune with a shocking refrain about another powerful mother. Deborah envisions Sisera’s mother, peering out her window waiting for her son to return home, whom she assumes won the battle. Sisera’s mother blames his tardiness on his army’s booty collecting that includes taking “a womb or two for every soldier”--or the mass rape of Israelite women. Deborah’s song (whether in her own words or placed in her mouth by male writers) intimates that sexual assault and rape are the inevitable cost of war. Neither Deborah nor Sisera’s mother appear to use their power to challenge the sexual violence that their sons inflict on the enemy’s women. They, seemingly, normalize this behavior. The reader is left to wonder whether Deborah and Barak’s troops, as victors, are raping their own booty. Are Deborah and Sisera’s mother colluding with the established powers that for generations have allowed these injustices to persist against vulnerable women, girls, and men? Slave narratives recount instances where wives of slave owners collude with their husbands as their men rape their female slaves instead of using their privilege to protect them. Likewise, the #metoo movement has exposed examples of women who have turned a blind eye or, even worse, placed unsuspecting women in harm’s way. How do we break this cycle of sexual violence and abuse that is deeply rooted in generations from Deborah’s culture to even now? This paper converses with Deborah’s song to explore more fully how women, especially those with authority and power, can use these positions to break cycles of sexual violence by becoming allies rather than colluders. Reading sexual violence through an intersectional lens, we explore how women’s complicity and desire to protect privilege has at times perpetuated this culture of sexual misconduct that soars out of control when left unchecked. Deborah’s song can serve as a cautionary tale. By the end of the book of Judges (chapters 19-21), the concubine is gang-raped and possibly vivisected, and the women of Shiloh are taken as wives against their will. What if Deborah and Sisera’s mother, like many of today’s women, sing out and interrupt the cycles of sexual violence against all women, especially those more vulnerable. How can today’s women serve as more effective allies rather than colluders and, instead, “be like the sun, rising in its strength” (Judges 5:31)?
|
The Growing Mustard Seed: Can Growth Be Eco-sustainably Translated?
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Paraskevi Arapoglou, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki
The emergence of ecolinguistics could be considered partly a result of the advances in human ecology where interdependencies between all different systems (including economic systems, social systems, religious systems, cultural systems, linguistic systems and ecosystems) are being highlighted and explored rather than being ignored. Even more importantly, ecolinguistics has been drawing great interest because the consequences of ignoring the ecological embedding of humans in general, are becoming all the more clear, since climate change, resource depletion, and ecosystems degradation reduce the ability of Earth to support not only humans –the main concern of anthropocentric line of thought- but also many, if not every, other species.
Linguistics inevitably affected many other forms of hermeneutical approaches in diverse fields such as Biblical studies. Language ecology may be defined in the words of its “founding father” Einar Haugen as “the study of interactions between any given language and its environment” that is determined primarily by the people who learn it, use it, and transmit it to others.
This paper aims to investigate the connection of language to “growthism” and how this notion functions in biblical narrative. The parables of the New Testament, stories quite commonly considered as challenging –not only for their modern readers but also for their original ones- provide an excellent case study. Mk 4:26-32 will be examined under an eco-linguistic lens in search of a more “eco-friendly” understanding as well as its potential translational implications.
|
Continuity and Change at Gezer: Ancient City Walls and Modern Excavations
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Gary P. Arbino, Gateway Seminary (Fremont)
Each of the three cities noted in 1 Kings 9 as having received special attention in the Solomonic building program – Hazor, Megiddo, and Gezer – occupied strategic locations in the region. Gezer’s position as guardian of a main route from the coast into the southern hill country required defensive architecture and planning that both enabled exchange and protected the interests of the Bronze Age city-state and the Iron Age regional polities. Thus it is important to consider the design, engineering, and construction of the various iterations of the city wall systems as they evolved throughout the second and first millennia, and the role they played in the occupational development of the site. With an eye to both the geo-political issues that necessitated their construction and the topographical situation which influenced their design, this paper provides an overview of these changing fortification systems. The research examines materials from the Macalister and the Hebrew Union College excavations in the light of the Middle Bronze and Iron Age structures recently unearthed by the Tandy.
|
Transforming Space, Transcending Time: Luke 3:1–6
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Elizabeth Arnold, Emory University
In Die Mitte Der Zeit, Hans Conzelmann wrote the groundbreaking analysis of Luke’s use of geography as theologically symbolic. He argued that Luke’s emphasis on various areas corresponding with different characters represented Luke’s redactional method of structuring salvation history. While Luke’s author incontrovertibly sees geography as a tool with which to shape his history and thereby his theology, it will be argued that the symbolic aspect of his geography is not as clearly delineated and the wilderness is not relegated to a certain time in the history of salvation. On the contrary, Luke consistently returns to certain landscapes to demonstrate certain aspects of his theology, the wilderness being a recurring scene that first appears in the appearance of John the Baptist. It is this initial “wilderness scene” found in Luke 3:1-6 that will be the focus of this paper followed by an engagement with how the wilderness opposes and then infiltrates the inhabited world.
In regards to time, I argue that Luke inherits Mark’s story of John’s wilderness preaching and adds 1) the temporal aspect of the historical reign of rulers and 2) Septuagintal archaism and scriptural prophecy, the combination of which render the desert a timeless space. Thus transformed, the wilderness space functions then 1) as a mirror for Luke’s other major themes, 2) as a means of characterization for many of Luke’s actors, and 3) as a symbol of both the Israelite wilderness tradition and the eschatological opposition to the wilderness.
Respecting Luke’s careful order, this paper investigates how Luke applies his own temporal and spatial material to Mark’s story of John the Baptist. In a way, Luke himself enacts the prophecy of Isa 40:4-6 by transforming space of the desert into a timeless place. And indeed, he takes it on himself to transform space and write the story of how salvation came to “all flesh.”
|
Numbers 32 and Transjordan in the Context of the Post-priestly Composition of the Book of Numbers
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Olivier Artus, Institut Catholique de Paris
(no title)
|
Breaking Away from Social Memory: Paul's Reinvention of Maccabean Ideology
Program Unit: Writing Social-Scientific Commentaries of the New Testament
A. Asano, Kwansei Gakuin University
This paper seeks to show how some of the events that formed and characterized the apostle Paul —— namely persecution of the church, the revelatory experience, and the apostolic activities including his Gentile mission and theological formation —— are better grasped with the background of the Maccabean ideology as a social memory that helps to maintain the social identity of the first century Judean community.
An attempt has been made by S.A. Cummins to interpret Gal chs. 1–2 with the Maccabean Martyrdom as a key to unlock the events, particularly the conflict between Paul and his opponents. Thus Cummins suggests that Paul regarded himself as an 'ironic Maccabean', resisting the opponents' pressure upon the Gentile Christ-followers, just like the Maccabees fought against the forces of Antiochus IV and his Judean allies (2001:119–20, 231–32). The distinct vocabulary shared by Galatians and II Maccabees arguably suggests that Paul had in mind the martyrdom literature. However, it appears that the opposing 'Judaizers' were the ones to resist Paul's 'Hellenizing' pressure to ban circumcision and food laws. Furthermore, what Cummins means by 'ironic Maccabean' remains unclear. I suggest, therefore, that the themes of the Maccabean martyrdom were used rather by the opponents to criticize Paul, who then responded by introducing a redefined form of the martyrdom ideology and presented himself as a follower of the new form of martyr, Christ crucified.
To support and strengthen this argument, the concept of social memory is employed, which will illumine the dynamic relationship between the Judean collective memory and Paul's personal conviction. In order for social memory to function as constructing and maintaining social identity, some actual events are remembered and others filtered out as inadequate for the coherence of the community (Connerton 1989:6–71; Bloch 1998:361–63). The paper will, thus, make note that II Maccabees was designed to build a particular social memory among the community for which it was written. Then it will be compared with IV Maccabees to show how further filtering process may have taken place.
A suggestion is made that Paul retrieved the filtered-out features of the Maccabean martyrdom to redefined the social memory. One of the key features for redefining the social memory is the idea of 'zeal' or zealotic violence, which made a strong impression upon Paul during his persecution, perhaps culminating in the violent attack on Stephen (Acts 7.54–8.1). It will be suggested that the motivation to break away (or distance himself) from the social memory and to redefine it was drawn from Paul's very experience of persecuting activity. This view will be supported by the recent psychological (and historical) analyses on effects of traumatic experiences (Swank & Marchand 1946; Marshall 1947; Grossman 2009; Meineck & Konstan 2014). A further suggestion will be made as to how this redefined memory of martyrdom affected Paul's peculiar presentation of Jesus' heroic death for sinners in opposition to God as a means to bring reconciliation (Rom 5.6–10).
|
Eating on the Way and the Way of Eating
Program Unit: The Historical Paul
Richard S. Ascough, Queen's University
Much research has been done on the banquet/triclinium setting for meals in antiquity and the impact that setting would have on the form and function of the early Christian ritual meal commemorating the death of Jesus. But not every meal would have followed this format, and at many other times, perhaps the majority of times, less formal eating would be necessary. In this paper I will survey the setting of such meals, exploring what we know about their location, format, and menu. I am particularly interested in the breadth of options available to Paul and his companions and how Judean dietary restrictions would impact their choices while on the road and at sea, as well as eating in the towns and cities with new Christ adherents.
|
Enkai in the Supernatural World View of Ndorobo: A Reading of Acts 17:22-31
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Shelley Ashdown, Graduate Institute of Applied Linguistics
The reality of the existence of Enkai as supreme Creator is a key understanding in Ndorobo world view, a small ethnic group in the southern Mau Escarpment of Kenya. Ndorobo reading of the Acts 17:22-31 narrative gives insight into an African world view with a rich category of the Supernatural. Reading Acts 17 from a Ndorobo perspective reveals eleven fundamental assumptions about the nature of Enkai, his role in the cosmos, his relationship with people, and his relationship with other spirit entities which differ from traditional exegesis. We begin with Enkai as Creator, “The God who made the world and everything in it…” (Acts 17:24). Enkai is recognized as the Creator of all things. Emphasis is given to using divine power for personal benefit. Next is Enkai as Lord, “the Lord of heaven and earth…” (Acts 17:24). Enkai is all powerful yet has limited control in the spirit world. Thirdly is Enkai as Incorporeal, “does not live in temples built by hands” (Acts 17:24). Enkai is a spiritual being from which nothing can be hidden but relationship is impossible. A fourth reading is Enkai as Self-Sustaining, “And he is not served by human hands, as if he needed anything…” (Acts 17:25). It is unnecessary for Enkai to have human relationships because he does not profit from humanity. Following is Enkai as Good, “because he himself gives all men life and breath and everything else” (Acts 17:25). No life exists outside the purposeful action of Enkai including creation of both good and evil spirits. Thus is Enkai as Sovereign, “From one man he made every nation of men… where they should live” (Acts 17:26). Ndorobo believe differing peoples are by divine design. Community is a divine creation to serve as moral enforcer. A seventh reading is Enkai as Love, “God did this so that men would seek him… and find him…” (Acts 17:27). Ndorobo world view offers no avenue for fellowship with Creator God in an intimate, individual relationship. Subsequently, Enkai as Intimate Companion, “’For in him we live and move and have our being.’…‘We are his children’” (Acts 17:28), is an understanding that life given by Enkai is to be the children of their community. The reading reveals Enkai as Merciful, “we are God’s children…he commands all people everywhere to repent” (Acts 17:29-30). Ndorobo concept of divine mercy is a lack of negative consequences for behavior. There is the notion of Enkai as Judge, “For he has set a day when he will judge the world with justice by the man he has appointed” (Acts 17:31). In Ndorobo world view judgment is earth bound because each person ceases to exist at death. The final reading is Enkai as Omnipotent, “He has given proof of this to all men by raising him from the dead” (Acts 17:31). Ndorobo world view cannot reconcile the divine-man, Christ, could actually die if he is truly God. Enkai is incapable of death. If he died, all creation would die in that instant with him.
|
Economic Growth and Religious Materiality in Christian Galilee in Late Antiquity
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Jacob Ashkenazi, Kinneret College on the Sea of Galilee
The substantial economic growth in the Levant during Late Antiquity is readily apparent from the contemporaneous upsurge in new rural settlements. An integral part of this development was the marked transformation of the religious built environment (cultural landscape), as private churches, martyria, and monasteries were erected throughout the East Mediterranean countryside in addition to lavish community churches that were built within the villages perimeters. Barring a few exceptions, scholars have ignored the correlation between economic prosperity and ecclesiastical construction. In the proposed study, we will suggest a phenomenology of this building boom with the objective of shedding light on the flourishing of monasticism during the period under review. We will show that this wave of construction derived from local, bottom-up economic processes, no less than top-down imperial or Church initiatives.
Interpreting some new finds from our recent archaeological excavations in Upper-Western Galilee and using comparative of other rural landscapes in the Roman east, we will show that there was a strong link between material well-being and ecclesiastical activities in early Christian rural societies by introducing local and regional factors into the discourse. In our estimation, local wealth is reflected in church buildings both within and adjacent to villages. Besides commemorating the area’s martyrs, monastic compounds buoyed the community’s agricultural production. Owing to these compounds’ agricultural arms, such as wine presses, the monks had a strong impact on both the faith and economic fortunes of the rural Christian masses. By cultivating arable land and joining forces with tillers, monks significantly improved the village’s agricultural output and prosperity.
|
Reflections of Empire in Isaiah 11:1–10
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Shawn Zelig Aster, Bar-Ilan University
In my recent book, Reflections of Empire in Isaiah 1-39: Responses to Assyrian Imperialism (SBL ANEM 19, 2017), I argued that many passages in Isaiah 1-39 respond to Assyrian claims of empire. These claims became known in Judah in the late eighth century, and posed theological challenges for the author of Isaiah and other Judahites.
In response to these challenges, many passages in Isaiah integrate specific motifs, terms, and narrative elements we know from Assyrian inscriptions, while subverting the ideology that these intended to support. Thus, motifs and terms that are used in their original context to support Assyrian ideologies of universal dominion and royal invincibility are re-worked in Isaiah 1-39 to describe the universal dominion of YHWH and His transcendent power.
In this presentation, I will explore how Isaiah 11:1-10 re-works motifs we know from Assyrian royal ideology in order to present an image of a king whose power rivals that of Assyria, but whose royal ideology is diametrically opposed to that of Assyria. The passage operates within the larger context of the unit Isaiah 10:5-12:6, in the first part of which Assyria's claims of universal dominion are taken as an obstinate refusal to submit to YHWH and an illicit repudiation of His universal rule.
Isa 11:1-10 desist from the attack on Assyria found through much of Isa 10* in favour of a more subtle approach. The passage describes how a local Judahite king will replace Assyria's king as the one on whom Judah relies politically. But unlike Assyria, this Judahite king will recognize Divine Sovereignty and revel in it. By Isa 11:10, this relationship has developed into a mutually-supportive relationship with YHWH, which mirrors the relationship that the Assyrian texts describe between the king of Assyria and the god Assur. Several examples of the use of Assyrian motifs in this passage follow.
Isa 11:2-4 emphasize that the new king will rule not by force but by virtue and Divine inspiration. This is emphasized in 11:5, in which righteousness and truth replace weapons. The absence of weapons here is striking, and may respond to the Assyrian texts' emphasis of same as a royal attribute, and to their mention of "the weapon of Assur" (on which see Steven Holloway, Assur is King! Assur is King! [2002]).
Isa 11:5-8 deploy animal imagery to highlight the recognition of a sovereign who does not permit anyone to harm others. The correlation between the threatening animals and recognizing a sovereign subverts the Assyrian literary trope of the animal hunt, in which the Assyrian king was required to subdue lions and other beasts in order to demonstrate his kingliness. Here, the new king achieves obedience without fighting any beasts.
Isa. 10:10c demonstrates close correspondence to the Akkadian expression "$ubat nehti" used to describe the Assyrian king's care for his people. This phrase is here applied to the universal appeal of the new king, whose rise is described in 11:1-10.
|
Empire, Power, and Politics in the Twelve: Setting the Scene
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
George Athas, Moore Theological College
Empire, Power, and Politics in the Twelve: Setting the Scene
|
The Spoken and the Written: Oral Influences on Exegetical Practice and Writing in Late Islamic Classical Period
Program Unit: The Qur’an: Manuscripts and Textual Criticism (IQSA)
Sheza Alqera Atiq, Harvard University
The selected manuscript, Maḥakamāt bayn Abū Ḥayyān al-Tawḥīdī wa Ibn ʻAṭīyah wa-l Zamakhsharī presents the criticisms and judgments of scholar Abū Ḥayyān with respect to the tafsirs and exegetical writings of Ibn ʻAṭīyah and al- Zamakhsharī. The work provides a fascinating – and important –inter-textual dialogue between three prominent Islamic scholars, a conversation that is especially unique to the field of Quranic tafsir or exegesis. In looking closely at Abū Ḥayyān’s close reading of select Quranic verses and his contemporaries’ commentaries upon them, this proposal hopes to shed light on trends in, and evolution of, exegetical practices in the classical and early medieval period circa 11th to 14th century. In addition to providing insights into literary and grammatical interpretive approaches used in studying and explaining the Quran by prominent mufassirun, the manuscript also provides an opportunity to look at tafisr as a written and textual practice unto itself. Thus, in addition to exploring the commentaries and super-commentaries of Quranic revelation vis a vis grammar rules and poetic references, this proposal will focus on the implicit – and at times explicit - oral features underlying the text. Abu Abū Ḥayyān’s critique draws directly upon originally oral works – that is, Quranic revelation and poetry – subjecting them to a rigorous written and textual analysis. The relation between the oral and the written, the transition thereof, and implicit oral assumptions contained in exegesis and interpretations, are some of the questions this project intends to address. In doing so, it will consult prevailing scholarship on oral theory including the pioneering writings of Albert Lord on the oral tradition as a theory of literary composition, but also extend the discussion to consider ways in which the oral is a critical lens through which to analyze manuscripts and specifically, textual prose relating to interpretation of oral scripture.
|
On the Relation between the Peshiṭta and Old Greek of Isaiah: A Case Study on Isaiah 1–5
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Preston L. Atwood, University of Wisconsin-Madison
One recent debate in Peshiṭta (S) and Old Greek (G) studies centers on the question of how knowledge of a specific translator’s translation strategies aids in: 1) adjudicating between shared variants in the Vorlagen of the earliest translations of the Hebrew Bible (e.g., S and G) and the Masoretic Text (M); 2) identifying shared tactics employed by both translators in rendering a source text close to M; and 3) determining influence from one translation (G) on another (S). To a certain degree, these questions are beset with inescapable methodological circularity: The assumption that cases of S-G agreement betray a specific relation between S and G influences scholars to evaluate other cases on this basis, whereas the assessment that S-G agreements do not indicate any such relation suggests the assumption that they are the result of common translation technique. Complicating this situation are other possibilities for why S agrees with G (against M and Targum [T]). Similarities might also be attributable to: 1) a common translation tradition (i.e., usage of a similar tradition of a certain word or expression); 2) a common Jewish exegetical or liturgical tradition; and 3) the possibility that S secondarily revised toward G or one of its hexaplaric recensions.
In light of these interpretive options, scholars have established criteria by which to identify possible G influence on S, but scholars’ different presuppositions about the translation process have impeded a consensus on criteria. In this paper I attempt to refine the methodological criteria for evaluating S-G agreements and apply them to alleged cases of S’s dependence on G in Isa 1-5. I argue that nearly all these agreements can be explained by both translators’ recourse to similar translational problem-solving strategies (some default, emerging, and ad hoc). The single exceptional S-G agreement where an explanation in translation technique does not suffice (1:22) finds a more convincing explanation in both S’s and G’s recourse to a common exegetical or reading tradition.
|
Compounding and Cogntive Processes in Word Formation with ὑδροποτέω and Its Relatives: Was Anyone Ever a "Water Drinker"?
Program Unit: Cognitive Linguistics in Biblical Interpretation
Michael Aubrey, Koine-Greek.com
Discussions of lexical semantics often make assumptions about how meaning works: that the meaning of a word is compositional, the sum-total of its parts. Sometimes this assumption is intentional (structuralist semantics). Other times, it is merely a result of a folk understanding of semantics. And yet, several decades of research exist challenging that assumption (Fillmore 1976, Lakoff 1987, Langacker 1987, Fillmore, Kay, and O’Connor 1988, Sweetser 1991, Goldberg 2006, Evans 2009). Meaning is emergent, meaning is embodied, meaning is social, and meaning is constructional. Meaning formation in compounds presents an interesting example of this, one that often seems to be lost on both translations and lexicons. Consider the verb ὑδροποτέω, which Paul uses in 1 Timothy 5:23, exhorting Timothy to change his diet. Both lexicons and translations, intentionally or otherwise, consistently adopt a componential view of this words meaning, glossing Paul’s instruction with some form of: “Do not drink only water.” BDAG includes “only” as a mere parenthetical for its gloss, suggesting that the meaning of the verb is simply transparent to its components: ὕδωρ (water), πίνω (drink). Translations across the spectrum from the highly formal to highly functional continue in the same pattern. Indeed, the NASB italicize their use of “exclusively” to signal to the reader that the translators added the word for clarity, making a strong claim about the compositionality of the compound. Even the highly functional NLT translation simply states, “Don’t drink only water.” But if we take seriously cognitive linguistics claims about the nature of meaning, then the lexicographical evidence can only be read one way: ὑδροποτέω refers to the behavior “to live in abstinence regarding alcohol” and a better gloss for 1 Timothy 5:23 would be “Stop being a teetotaler.” In this paper, I suggest a path of lexicalization for this verb and its related forms that begins a cultural desire for a euphemism for teetotalism which was then later extended additionally into ascetic lifestyle decisions generally. I conclude that the component pieces of this compound were never used for the purpose of actually drinking water, but that their combination here is the result of a emergent phenomenon motivated by empirically established cognitive processes in meaning formation.
|
How Healing People Can Traumatize Environments: Health Care, Economics, and Ecology in the Biblical World
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Hector Avalos, Iowa State University
The interrelationship of economics, health care, and ecology has received little attention in explanations for the vitality or demise of ancient Near Eastern civilizations. By applying theories derived from medical anthropology, which views health care as a system of options and resources for maintaining or restoring health in any community, this paper will provide some examples of how health care impacts both ecology and economics in ancient Near Eastern societies. In particular, it will focus on data from lists of animals, plants, and minerals needed to conduct certain magical healing rituals in Hittite Mesopotamian, Ugaritic, and ancient Hebrew texts. Some of those rituals may have impacted the availability of food resources because they re-directed those food resources to health care needs and to temples. Other rituals may have traumatized the environment by requiring the killing of animals for components in healing rituals. An analogy today is the hunting of bears for their gall bladders, which are believed to have healing properties. Such killings, when done on larger scales, may have disrupted ecological balances. The paper explores the methodological problems such issues raise, and also the possible future directions for detecting links among health care, economics, and ecology.
|
Biblical Violence and Exegesis in Late Antiquity: A Muslim View
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
Hector Avalos, Iowa State University
One of the earliest Christian polemical works mentioning Islam is found in the seventh century in the Doctrina Jacobi ("Teachings of Jacob"). Although focusing on Judaism, this Greek Christian work accuses Islam of using violence to spread its message. Such polemics had a counterpart among Muslim writers, including 'Abd al-Jabbar (d. 415/1025). 'Abd al-Jabbar was born in the 320s/930s in Asadabad, a town in western Iran, but he spent much of his life in Rayy (Iran). Rayy had the bishopric of the East Syrian/Nestorian Church, and it was an important city for Jews and Zoroastrians, as well. This paper will concentrate on 'Abd al-Jabbar's Tathbit dala'il al-nubuwwa ("Confirmation of the Proofs of Prophethood"), a polemic work that was published in an Arabic-English edition (under the title, Critique of Christian Origins) in 2010 by Gabriel Said Reynolds and Samir Khalil Samir. In particular, the paper will explore the various exegetical and theological instruments by which Abd al-Jabbar countered Christian polemics. In one instance he alludes to Deuteronomy 7 and 20, and then shows how Trinitarian assumptions would mean that Christ sent Moses repeatedly to kill those who opposed him. Therefore, Christianity was perhaps even more violent than Christian polemicists assumed. The presentation also will explore broader theological and exegetical issues confronting Christians and Muslims in their efforts to evaluate the proper role of violence in spreading Christianity and Islam.
|
Review of J. Walton's Old Testament Theology for Christians, and R. Gane's Old Testament Law for Christians
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Richard Averbeck, Trinity Evangelical Divinity School
Review of J. Walton's Old Testament Theology for Christians, and R. Gane's Old Testament Law for Christians
|
Crucial Features of Sin Offering Atonement in Leviticus 4–5 and 16
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Richard E. Averbeck, Trinity Evangelical Divinity School
In Lev 4:2-12, the sin offering unit for the anointed priest, the regular outcome statement running through the section as a whole is conspicuous for its absence. There is nothing like the priest “will make atonement for” the person or group, and they “will be forgiven” (cf. Lev 4:20, 26, 31, 35; 5:[6], 10, 13). In my view, the absence of atonement and forgiveness in Lev 4:10-12 is crucial for understanding the mechanism of atonement. The priest could not atone for himself. He could manipulate the sacrificial blood to purge the tabernacle, but he could not “make atonement” for himself to obtain forgiveness because he still “bore the culpability” (nāśāʼ āwōn) for the original violation he had committed. Therefore, he could not eat the meat of his own sin offering (v. 12; cf. Lev 6:23).
It was by means of the scapegoat ritual on the Day of Atonement that the priest(s) could unload the culpabilities for himself and the Israelites, for whom he had mediated throughout the year and so bore their culpabilities for them (cf., e.g., Exod 28:38; Lev 10:17; Num 18:1), On that day, the High Priest would lay both his hands on the head of the goat and confess over it “all the culpabilities (awônōt) of the Israelites – (from) all their transgressions (pišʻêhem) to all their sins (ḥaṭṭōʼtām) – and put them on the head of the goat” (v. 21). The next verse reduces the list to one word, “culpabilities”: “The goat will carry on itself all their culpabilities (awônōtām) to a remote place; and the man shall release it in the wilderness” (v. 22). The “culpabilities” were produced by transgressions and sins and born by the priests until the scapegoat ritual on the Day of Atonement.
There are some similarities to this pattern also in the slain goat sin offering ritual in Lev 16:16. The High Priest offered the sin offering goat to “make atonement upon the Most Holy Place from the impurities (ṭumʼōt) of the Israelites – and from all their transgressions (pišʻêhem) to all their sins (ḥaṭṭōʼtām) – and thus he shall do for the tent of meeting which dwells with them in the midst of their impurities (ṭumʼōtām)” (cf. also v. 19). In this case, the end of the verse reduces the list to “impurities.” This is because the slain sin offering was concerned with “impurities,” as opposed to the scapegoat later in the chapter where the issue was “culpabilities.” Transgressions and sins (paired in vv. 16 and 21) could produce either impurities (vv. 16, 19) or culpabilities (vv. 21-22). The priests carried the later through the year as the mediators for the Israelites before the Lord. Impurities normally did not create culpabilities (awônōt), but they could if they were not attended to properly according to the normal purity regulations as, for example, when a person did not know they had contracted impurity until it was too late to follow the regulations (Lev 5:2-3 with 5-6; cf., e.g., Lev 15:5-11).
|
Galilean Economy before and after the Roman Invasion in 67 CE
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Mordechai Aviam, Kinneret College on the Sea of Galilee
For more than one year, from 66 to the autumn 67, the Galilee was under heavy stress. It started with clashes between Jews and non-Jews around the Galilee, it continued with the arrival of a young Jewish governor from the social elite in Jerusalem, but mainly from June to October 67, sixty thousand Roman soldiers violently swept the region leaving behind them robbed land, two destroyed towns, and many dead and wounded citizens. In this paper I will use the archaeological data that was gained in a few archaeological excavations and surveys to understand the impact of the first part of the Great Revolt – the Galilean campaign – on the land and on the people. I will start with the evidence of first century sites: Magdala, Yodefat, and Gamla of daily life and economy. I will continue with the understanding of Josephus’s activity as a governor of the region, investing in large operation of fortifications, and into the actual battles of the north. I will end the paper with an attempt to assess the economic consequences of the revolt.
|
John’s Revelation and Patterns of Theosis
Program Unit: Biblical Exegesis from Eastern Orthodox Perspectives
Michael Azar, University of Scranton
This paper examines the connection between John’s Revelation and patterns of deification in second temple and patristic thought. Considering, for example, Jewish descriptions of the children of Abraham transforming into the likeness of stars or attaining the glory lost by Adam as well as patristic notions of Christ’s incarnation allowing for humankind’s transformation into the likeness of God, this paper asks: To what extent does John’s portrayal of the interceding saints and crowned victors stem from and give rise to concepts of deification elsewhere? Does the distinct early Christian continuation of apocalyptic worldviews, especially vis-à-vis Jewish counterparts, provide a fitting framework in which to understand the soteriological emphasis on theosis as the chief achievement of God’s work in history?
|
The Triune Sibyl: Greek, Jewish, and Christian Manifestations of a Mutable Muse
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Ashley L. Bacchi, Starr King School for the Ministry
The Greek Sibyl resonated as a powerful prophetess throughout the centuries across the Mediterranean in Jewish and Christian traditions. The pseudepigraphal texts of the Sibylline Oracles inspired many visual representations of Sibyls, especially among Late Medieval and Renaissance artists. For example, Michelangelo and Pietro Perigio painted the Sibyls to add a feminine counter-balance to the Hebrew prophets while Domenico Ghirandalo announced the coming of Jesus in the Basilica of Santa Trinita through a Sibyl. Both elements came together in the Sala delle Sibille in the Vatican’s Borgia Tower. This paper will highlight how the Greek, Jewish, and Christian aspects of the Sibyl are uniquely integrated in each of the visual manifestations, demonstrating the mutable, alluring and triune nature of the Sibyl.
|
When the Subaltern Speaks: Conquest, Liminality, and the Voice of Resistance in the Book of Lamentations
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Nazeer Bacchus, Yale Divinity School
In this paper, I examine Lam 1-2 along the intersectional lines of postcolonial and feminist theories to interrogate how Daughter Zion is en(gendered) as a national metaphor for social death in the wake of imperial conquest. Reading the surviving Judahite community as a peripheral subaltern community, this paper locates the precarity and liminality reflected in the text vis-à-vis the embodied nation as a rape-victim, abandoned widow, and grieving mother. In viewing Daughter Zion as a representation of the subaltern, I argue that her agency and vocality offer precisely a voice and identity for a fractured community on the margins; thus, through this metaphoric identification, I contend that Daughter Zion ultimately offer a re-inscription of power and agency to a vulnerable populace against the hegemonic master narrative of imperial domination, conquest, and exile.
|
"Oh Gods, the Surrounding Lands Have Become Arrogant and They Have Violated Their Oaths!" Hittite Arkuwar Prayers and Sitz im Leben of the Biblical Divine Covenant
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Mary R. Bachvarova, Willamette University
Adding Hittite arkuwar prayers to the pool of Near Eastern material shedding light on the significance of the Biblical covenant allows us to explore from a new angle how the Israelites reshaped locally available ways to interact with the divine to define themselves as a people in a unique relationship with the only God. For the Hittite kings occupying Late Bronze Age Anatolia and north Syria, arkuwar ("legal case") prayers, and sworn contracts (ishiul), including international treaties (also called taksul), were complementary genres. Indeed, two early Hittite royal prayers (ca. 1500-1400 BCE) present themselves as contracts between the king and the gods (CTH 389.2, 414.1). With this background information, we can take a new approach to explaining, 1) the parallels between Hittite arkuwar prayers and Biblical arguments with, and complaints to, Yahweh (e.g., Josh 7: 7-9); and 2) the presence of concepts found in Hittite vassal treaties in the way the covenant between Yahweh and his chosen people was framed. The prayers would have travelled in the same way as the treaty formulas, not through population movements, but by means of public oral performances before a copy of a treaty, edict, or diplomatic letter displayed beside the statue of the relevant divinity in his/her temple. That is, the contractual process itself provided the means of geographic transfer of region-specific practices attached to the Near Eastern treaty tradition. Hittite secundogenitures at Carchemish and Aleppo would have engaged in the full gamut of activities surrounding treaties and other sworn agreements, including arkuwars expiating their own actions in violation of ishiuls with humans or gods (e.g., CTH 382, §4) and complaining about the gods' evident anger, which was demonstrated by defeats at the hands of "arrogant" treaty-violators and other misfortunes affecting the state. Neo-Hittite states in Syria chose to retain some Hittite ways of justifying hegemony, as shown by the continued use of Hittite dynastic names and Hieroglyphic Luwian script on stone monuments bearing Hittite-style reliefs, suggesting the relevant practices could have continued well into the Iron Age, before the area was subjugated by the Assyrians, who imposed the Assyrian-style treaty practices that so obviously influenced, e.g., Deuteronomy 28. The Late Bronze Age Hittite evidence gives us a unique glimpse of orally transmitted practices that could have been witnessed by people other than literate scribes. Thus, a specific, occasion-bound means of oral transmission to the Israelites can be postulated not only from Anatolia, but also from the Near East more broadly, for motifs drawn from prayers and incantations that helped to describe and enforce the quasi-contractual relationship between humans and gods. Moreover, the Hittite royal arkuwar prayers put a new focus on the innovative role taken by non-royal Israelite leaders as privileged intermediaries with God, which went hand in hand with eliminating the king as the responsible partner in the contractual relationship between a nation and God.
|
Patterns and Function of Alliteration in the Prosaic and Poetic Accounts of the Deborah Cycle
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Elizabeth H.P. Backfish, William Jessup University
Alliteration is a device typically identified with poetry. However, its use in Hebrew prose has become increasingly appreciated, as scholars like Gary Rendsburg have shown with his analysis of alliteration in Genesis. This paper seeks to compare and contrast the use of alliteration in the narrative text of the Deborah cycle (Judges 4) and in the poetic text of the same cycle (Judges 5). Specifically, this paper shows how the rhetorical function of alliteration in each account is quite distinctive and an important aspect of the message of each account.
Most scholars define poetry by its use of lineation and parallelism, the density of its poetic devices, and its lack of prosaic elements. The fact that there is roughly four times the amount of alliteration in the poetic account of Judges 5 as in the prose account of Judges 4 is therefore neither surprising nor particularly illuminating. However, the comparative use of alliteration in each account is very illuminating. In the prose account, alliteration serves the plot and irony of the narrative, often playing on proper nouns and spanning multiple verses. In the poetic account, alliteration is limited primarily to parallel cola or adjacent words and serves to underscore the structure and lineation of the poem.
This study contributes to our understanding of biblical Hebrew poetry in several ways. First, it illustrates the broad usage of an important trope in a given text. Second, it speaks into the conversation of the prose-poetry continuum or distinction in that it illustrates how alliteration is not only used with greater density in poetry but also with markedly different function. Third, this study lays important methodological groundwork for identification and analysis of alliteration.
|
Nameless in the Nevi’im: An Exploration of Structural Patterning in the Book of Judges Based on Female Characterization
Program Unit: Joshua-Judges
Elizabeth H.P. Backfish, William Jessup University
Anonymity and identity are powerful rhetorical devices in literature. The named and unnamed females in the book of Judges have been analyzed from various angles and perspectives. Some of the most ground-breaking approaches have those of Mieke Bal, Athalya Brennen, Adele Reinhartz, and Lillian Klein, on whose academic trail this paper gratefully follows. Some trails that await exploration include the relationship between the anonymous and identified characters, as well as how these characters relate in the overall structure and message of the book as a whole.
Thus, this paper first seeks to analyze the textual effect of named and unnamed female characters in the book of Judges and how these characterizations contribute to the overall rhetorical and theological message of the book in its final form. Specifically, this paper argues that the four named female characters represent what Israel should have been doing (assertively fighting for Israel, understanding Torah), and the unnamed characters represent what Israel should not have been doing (idolatry, complacency under foreign oppression, misunderstanding Torah) or the consequences of doing what should not have been done (unprotected and discarded victims of injustice and chaos).
The second task involves the relationship between these exemplary named characters and non-exemplary anonymous characters. Some pairings have been identified, such as the connections between Achsah and the Levite’s concubine and the connections between Jael and Delilah, but additional pairings that span the entirely of the book and include the male characters who share the narrative space of the females can also be identified. This patterning showcases the literary artistry of the redactor and underscores the contrast between anonymity and identity, ultimately inviting readers to mimetically identify with the exemplary, identified characters, who serve as foils for the anonymous characters. This interplay between anonymity and identity and the rhetorical patterning of these characters contribute to the many and complementary layers of rhetorical patterning in the book of Judges.
|
Use of Daniel in the Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Book of Daniel
Kyung Baek, Trinity Western University
At Qumran, there is a polyphonic use of Daniel which includes and combines the various manuscripts of the book of Daniel, pseudo Daniel material, and quotations and allusions of Daniel in the Dead Sea Scrolls. This paper is a preliminary step to identifying and describing this hermeneutical polyphony as it examines the quotations and allusions of Daniel in the Dead Sea Scrolls.
Building on previous work on the use of Daniel in 1QHa, 1QM, 4Q174, and 11Q13, this paper expands this list of scrolls, delineates the various ways that Daniel is used, and attempts to situate the quotations and allusions of Daniel within this hermeneutical polyphony at Qumran. Furthermore, two caveats underscore the examination of this use of Daniel: (1) use is not limited to the book of Daniel but includes traditions as well as the figure of Daniel; and (2) use does not necessarily imply that it is unidirectional or fixed but fluid at the time of these writings.
|
Remembering Resurrection at Qumran
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Kyung Baek, Trinity Western University
Scriptures or authoritative traditions from the past and visions of the future formed the foundation of many of the writings of the Qumran movement. Although not all the Dead Sea Scrolls are strictly sectarian, they may be considered as a cache of memories for this movement which identifies and describes its various concepts and practices. Moreover, in light of Social Memory Theory, these concepts should not be distilled into a single and simple recollection of the past but remain a fluid and complex matrix of memories to help reconstruct the present.
Given these considerations, this paper attempts to formulate concepts of resurrection and the afterlife at Qumran by integrating Social Memory Theory as it examines (1) authoritative texts that articulate concepts of resurrection (esp. Dan 12:1-3 and 1 En. 22, 90, 104); (2) sectarian (1QS; 1QHa) and possible sectarian writings (4Q385; 4Q521; 4Q542; 4Q548) that uses these authoritative texts to remember the resurrection; and (3) burial and banquet practices at Qumran that recognizes a community living the "Last Days" in the present.
|
Lessons on Manhood from Lady Ekklesia: Hermas's Characterization in Visions 1–4
Program Unit: Inventing Christianity: Apostolic Fathers, Apologists, and Martyrs
Jeremiah Bailey, Baylor University
This paper examines the rhetorical and sociological background of the Shepherd of Hermas to explicate the (self-)characterization of Hermas which occurs in Visions 1-4. While the text itself indicates that Hermas comes from humble origins, there is some evidence that Hermas may have at least passing familiarity with Greco-Roman rhetorical techniques. This essay argues that there are potential uses of stock rhetorical forms in Hermas, exploring in detail how examples of fable, ekphrasis, and synkrisis contribute to the characterization of Hermas across Visions 1-4. The paper then explores a common thread in these examples to provide a social context for the characterization of Hermas. Specifically, this paper, building on the work of other scholars on Hermas and gender, demonstrates that the common conceptions of masculinity which serve as an important foil for the portrayal of Hermas in the apocalypse are mediated in part through rhetorical techniques. For example, there is a running synkrisis between Hermas and the feminine personification of the Church which ironically serves as the rubric for Hermas’s masculinity. Understanding Hermas’s rhetorical framing extends our understanding of the role of gender in Visions 1-4 in two ways: 1) It demonstrates that the arc of Hermas from unmanly to manly is completed within the Visions itself and not only later in the Similitudes as some have suggested. 2) Given the association of rhetorical ability and masculinity within Greco-Roman society, the use of rhetorical forms may serve as a meta-narratival confirmation that Hermas has completed the arc to full manhood.
|
Bathing the Body and Performing Purification? Women’s Roles in Roman Funerary Ritual
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Danielle Baillargeon, University of Toronto
This paper will investigate the roles of women in Roman funerary rituals from the 1st to the 4th centuries CE. There is no extant description of the full complex of Roman funerary rituals; scholarly discussions rely on composite reconstructions drawn from varied, fragmentary evidence. Scholars often examine the role of women within a framework based on the reconstruction of the elite funeral and incorporates an analysis based on dichotomous gender distinctions where men take on the public role of mourning on behalf of the familia and women take on private rituals associated with the preparation of the body and lamentation and mourning. However, a close reading of literary, epigraphic, and artistic sources suggests such a bifurcated interpretive framework may occlude other roles and identities for women constituted within the communicative arena of funerary rituals.
This paper seeks to problematize the traditional interpretive framework, suggesting that using status, rather than gender, as an analytical locus highlights the communicative potential of delineations by role. By gathering together and interrogating diverse evidence, such literary and consolatory, legal and testament, epigraphic, and visual evidence for the preparatory rituals, the treatment of the corpse, and the funeral proper, I argue women’s roles in the funereal context were varied and highly differentiated by status. I will interrogate the evidence upon which the composite understanding of the Roman funeral is based, drawing out indications of status distinctions. I argue that performances of mourning by women of the upper classes were often rhetorical and politically motivated and functioned to delineate a multitude of intersectional identities, including philosophical allegiance and ethnicity. Physical performances of gestures associated with mourning such as beating the breast and tearing the hair, could be appropriate as spontaneous articulations of grief; however, physical performances of grief manifesting in gestures of self-degradation were the purview of the lower classes, both men and women, in the formalized and systematic rituals associated with the funeral. Finally, I will suggest that later Christian authors manipulated these performances of grief to create new paradigms of the ideal mourner. Grief performances associated with the funerary ritual, properly directed, purified the mourner of sin, providing the impetus for them to take up an ascetic lifestyle in the letters of Jerome, attesting to the importance that writers placed in the communicative potential of the funerary ritual and the need to control and manipulate female models of proper behavior.
|
“Have You Allowed All the Women to Live?” A Study of Mosaic Masculinities
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Cynthia M. Baker, Bates College
The title of this paper comes from Numbers 31:15, where we encounter an angry Moses chastising his tribal soldiers for having spared the Midianite women and children after having wiped out all the men of Midian. Moses then orders that all the boy children and mature women be slaughtered and the young Midianite girls be left to the soldiers. God’s order to Moses to “execute the LORD’s vengeance on Midian” in this fashion is framed as Moses’ final task and, hence, serves as a kind of bookend to the career that began when Hebrew and Egyptian women conspired together to save him from Pharaoh’s edict of death for boy children – or, in another sense, when his Midianite wife saved his life, as his own God sought to kill him, on the eve of his return to Egypt. These bookending narratives of Moses’ life provide a rich body of material through which to investigate the paradoxes, ironies, and violence of “Mosaic masculinities.”
|
Uploading Hebrew: The Transformation of the Language Classroom
Program Unit: Global Education and Research Technology
Sarah Lynn Baker, The University of Texas at Austin
The discussion surrounding best practices for teaching Biblical Hebrew has grown in promising directions through recent years. Along with increased attention to modern pedagogical methods, there has also been an exponential growth of interest in online language education as technological advances make web-based instruction more versatile. My perspective on this discussion is informed by over a decade of experience in Biblical Hebrew (BH) curriculum development for contexts ranging from in-person to online, from grammar-translation to communicative methodologies, from private organizations to the university level, and varying combinations of all these factors. The particulars of each learning environment (timeframe, institutionally-mandated outcomes, student demographics, etc.) have required me to constantly revisit what I see as the driving questions behind any BH course design project: What are the learning goals for this institution and/or student group? Within the given parameters, how can we maximize the students’ immersion in the most authentic possible form of BH, and how can we most effectively leverage modern research on language acquisition with regard to focused instruction, comprehensible input, etc.?
In the present session, I will share how I have addressed such questions in two particular contexts: 1) An undergraduate university setting which combines a living-language style classroom (using methods such as Total Physical Response and Teaching Proficiency through Reading and Storytelling), a grammar-translation textbook, and an innovative online homework program that gives students real-time feedback; and 2) An exclusively online (asynchronous) BH course designed on the open-source Moodle platform and geared toward BMin/BTh/MDiv students who also need to be trained to incorporate their Hebrew skills with the language resources available to them on the Logos software. The latter project is modeled in part after the former, and it engages a number of technological tools (audio, video, auto-correct exercises, etc.) in an effort to translate the pedagogical advantages of a face-to-face communicative classroom into the online environment. During this presentation, I will use Jonah 1 as an example text through which to demonstrate the various types of online exercises and resources that I have found to carry the strongest pedagogical value in each situation. As the demand for online coursework continues to grow, I expect that using these two teaching contexts as test cases could provide worthwhile insights for others who are also presented with the challenge and the opportunity of guiding biblical language acquisition in an online world.
|
Cycles of Reading and Praise: Isaiah, Enoch, and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Qumran
Arjen Bakker, Oxford University
In this paper I will examine how the reading of Isaiah generated new texts in the Second Temple Period. I will look for new models to understand early interpretation. Can we speak of an interpretive tradition that stands on its own, or is an interpretive tradition always entangled with the interpreted text and its process of literary growth? I will demonstrate how a peculiar reading of Isaiah 40 can be traced through LXX-Isaiah, Ben Sira, 4QInstruction and the Similitudes of Enoch. On the basis of Isaiah 40, the eternal movements of the luminaries are presented as examples of continuous activity. Although each of these texts participate in a shared interpretive tradition, they all go back to the text of Isaiah and generate new and distinctive readings. This can be understood as a cyclical process that is set into motion through specific reading practices. Some of these reading practices can be traced in the texts themselves. For example, 4QInstruction incites students of wisdom to chase after knowledge continuously, and the Similitudes of Enoch attest to an ideal of continuous thanksgiving and praise. These practices of study and prayer can be seen as generative for the intricate interpretive traditions we encounter in these texts. In both cases these practices are modeled on the eternal movements of the heavenly bodies and rooted in readings of Isaiah 40.
|
Galileo Reading Qohelet: In Defense of Theologically Informed Intellectual Optimism
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Samuel E. Balentine, Union Presbyterian Seminary
Biblical scholars continue to wrestle with the translation of Eccl 3:11b: “[God] has put hā`ôlām in their [people’s] minds.” Should `ôlām be rendered conventionally as “eternity,” “distant time,” or perhaps even “infinity?” Or should the MT be emended to something like “toil” (he`āmāl) or “darkness”/“ignorance” (from the verb `ālam, “hide”)? The differences are consequential and produce significantly different interpretations. But perhaps no reading of Eccl 3:11 was as consequential as Galileo’s. On the eve of his indictment by the Church as a Copernican heretic, Galileo wrote a letter to the Grand Duchess Christina (1615) setting forth a biblical rational for his pursuit of forbidden understanding: “Who wants the human mind put to death? Who is going to claim that everything in the world which is observable and knowable has already been seen and discovered? Perhaps those who on other occasions admit, quite correctly, that the things we know are a very small part of the things we do not know? Indeed, we also have it from the very mouth of the Holy Spirit that God `hath delivered the world [mundum, Douay Version] to their consideration, so that man cannot find out the work which God hath made from beginning to the end’.” Galileo took inspiration from the first half of the verse (Eccl 3:11a), for one must not “block the way of freedom of philosophizing about things of the world and of nature, as if they had already been discovered and disclosed with certainty,” and proceeded to search the heavens with the “spyglass devised by me, through God’s grace first enlightening my mind.” The second half of the verse guided those who would condemn his inquiries as heresy in accord with the imperatives of post-Trent theology; precisely because “petulant spirits” like Galileo can never comprehend the infinity of divine wisdom, they should subordinate personal speculation to the universal authority of the Church Fathers. Thus began the “Galileo Affair,” which provided the foundation for the Church’s seventeenth century decreed divide between science and religion.
It is ironic that Galileo turned to Qohelet, whose quest for understanding the mysteries of the world led him to conclude that intellectual inquiry is “perfectly pointless” (hebel), to argue for a theologically informed intellectual optimism because “the human mind is a work of God and one of the most excellent.” This paper will examine Galileo’s exegesis of the epistemological presuppositions and moral strictures related to intellectual inquiry in Qohelet’s world and in his own.
|
Prayer in the Hebrew Bible: Retrospective and Prospective
Program Unit: Deuterocanonical and Cognate Literature
Samuel E. Balentine, Union Presbyterian Seminary
This paper will overview and assess research on prayer in the Hebrew Bible, with attention to its development in the Second Temple period. The paper will also project possible areas for future research.
|
The Mesopotamian Mis-Pi Ceremony & Clifford Geertz’s “Thick Description”: A Case Study in the Symbolic Webs of the Deceased
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Amy L. Balogh, University of Denver
The life’s work of 20th-century ethnographer Clifford Geertz is characterized by what he called “Thick Description” (TD), the practice of developing rich, nuanced understandings of culture using thorough, complex, and contextualized descriptions of narrowly defined phenomenon rather than large-scale surveys. The goals of TD are: 1) to analyze a single phenomenon in a way that illuminates the culture at large, 2) to trace the “symbolic web of meaning” that a culture spins in order to understand and express its lived experience, and 3) to bridge the gap between the culture under investigation and the ethnographer’s audience.
But can ethnographic method be applied ethically and effectively in the study of the deceased?
This paper argues that the narrow focus of TD renders it particularly appropriate for working with ancient cultures because it enables one to connect objects and texts to their larger cultural environment, even in the absence of living members. Here, I present a case study of the Mesopotamian Mis-Pi (Washing, Purification of the Mouth) ceremony, a 2-day ritual for the induction of idols, for which we have little information outside of extant ritual and incantation texts from the 7th-6th centuries BCE. TD not only allows me to unpack the nature, meaning, and function of this ritual, but it also enables me do so in way that speaks to the values, paradoxes, inner-lives, and daily workings of the community for whom the ritual expresses a “symbolic web of meaning,” a web we may continue to study through tools like TD.
|
Deconstructing the Masculinity of the Levite in Judges 19–20: A Hidden Polemic Against Saulide Kingship
Program Unit: Joshua-Judges
Ji Min Bang, Brandeis University
Aside from an increasing number of feminist studies that discuss the pilegesh’s relationship with the Levite of Judges 19–20, surprisingly little attention has been paid to the Levite as a character, particularly as a masculine persona. A close reading of the text discloses to the reader that the Levite is depicted as a complex and even dishonorable figure. He escapes from gang rape at the expense of his pilegesh, whom he is obliged to protect as a husband (Judg 19:16–30), and deceives the gathering of the Israelites as he recounts the events that have brought them together (Judges 20:1–11). With a guiding assumption that the nuanced character of the Levite has been deliberately designed by the author(s) of the text, this paper looks at the Levite through the lens of masculinity. Drawing on the works of Ken Stone (1996) and David Clines (2010), the paper examines Judges 19:1–20:7 and identifies within this text four aspects on masculinity: (1) violence, especially as expressed through killing, (2) persuasive speech, (3) honor, and (4) detachment from women. It offers a close literary analysis of these chapters with particular attention to the subtle uses of language (e.g., a linguistic tension between the Levite’s wayyaḥǎzēq in v. 25 and the father-in-law’s wayyeḥĕzaq in v. 4) and intertextual references to male figures (e.g., Abraham, Saul) for the development of the Levite’s deconstructed character. I will argue that in the characterization of the Levite, the narrator utilizes these assumptions about masculinity to depict him as a failed man. The Levite presents himself as a powerful and persuasive leader in Israel, while the narrator simultaneously employs masculine assumptions to impugn his character, to portray him as dependent upon women, and to dismantle the Levite’s power. As a final point, I will suggest that the negative portrayal of the Levite discloses a broader polemic against Saulide kingship.
|
The Biblical Conflict Myth and Ecological Hermeneutics
Program Unit: Bible, Myth, and Myth Theory
Ki-Min Bang, Lutheran School of Theology at Chicago
The conflict myth, also known as Chaoskampf and the combat myth motif, in the Hebrew Bible/Old Testament has been perceived as dangerous for the environment (e.g., Habel-Avent, Trudinger, 2001) and animals. This motif describes God as a strong warrior, and God’s enemies are the sea, river, Earth, and chaos monsters (Leviathan, Behemoth, and Rahab). The battle between God and the enemy always ends with God’s victory and the desolation of earth and sea (e.g., Ps 46) in these conflict passages.
The danger of this motif is also evident in some animal species, formerly equated with Leviathan and Behemoth. Western Christian interpreters of the biblical conflict myth (Calvin, Bochart, Melville, Couroyer, and Clines, etc.) have equated Leviathan and Behemoth with whales, crocodiles, hippopotamus, buffalo, and many other endangered animals. Implied narratives of the conflict myth can justify the hunting of currently endangered animal species.
This paper will explore problems of the biblical Conflict Myth from past research in terms of environmental issues and try to find a green interpretation for the motif; (1) through a re-contextualization of the motif for us today (e.g., raging sea in ancient time versus increasing sea level and global warming in this age), and (2) in light of the myth theoretical approaches (e.g., the climatic pattern of the Ugaritic Baʻlu cycle in Johannes de Moor, and Gaster; Ballentine). Core messages of the conflict myth for environmental readings may include (1) the image of God as the creator and protector/sustainer of the cosmos and the regularity of the climate (Gen 8:22[J]; Gen 9:8-17[P]; Ps 89:10-11), and (2) God who commissions human political and religious leaders to prevent them from making the chaos monster great again (Ps 89:26; ET 89:25). These two suggestions enable a green interpretation of the conflict myth here and can contribute “rescuing the Bible from misinterpretation and recovering its ecological wisdom” (Horrell, Hunt, and Southgate, 2010).
|
Transmitting the Victory: The Lord’s Prayer in Luke as a Summary of the Temptations
Program Unit: Gospel of Luke
Michael Patrick Barber, Augustine Institute
It is widely known that the Gospel of Luke records a shorter version of the Lord's Prayer than that of Matthew, but surprisingly little has been done to determine the author's particular selection criteria. This paper offers a possible explanation for the specific petitions from within the narrative itself. Recent scholarship frequently presents Luke's text as an interwoven account, drawing connections between many passages within the Gospel, such as the miracle in 9:12-17 and the meal in 24:28-32 (cf. M. Wolter [2017]). However, apart from scholars who highlight the repetitions of thematic words like "temptation" (peirasmon) or "kingdom" (basileia), commentators generally neglect the more substantial intertextual echoes between the temptation narrative in Luke 4 and the prayer given by Jesus in Luke 11 (e.g. D. Allison [1999]; H. Betz [1995]). From the prayer's initial address ("Father"), the reader finds the answer to the central question of the temptations: "if you are the son of God" (Luke 4:3, 9; 11:2 NRSV). The subsequent petition ("hallowed be your name") reflects the biblical association of God's name and the Temple, summarizing both Jesus' disposition and location in the third temptation (Luke 4:9; 11:2). The next petition ("your kingdom come") calls to mind Jesus' refusal of "all the kingdoms of the world" in the second temptation, highlighting the same deference to God exhibited there (Luke 4:5; 11:2). The third petition ("give us each day our daily bread") echoes the first temptation, in which Jesus refuses to provide bread for himself and refers instead to God's authority (Luke 4:4; 11:3). In the fourth petition, the author diverges momentarily from the pattern developed thus far with a petition for forgiveness that finds no direct parallel in the temptation account, but a close examination of the narrative reveals several potential reasons for this departure (Luke 11:4). Finally, the Lord's Prayer concludes with an idea reflected three times in the temptation scene: that of being "led" into "temptation" (peirasmon) (Luke 4:1, 5, 9; cf. 11:4). Given the extensive and highly structured parallels between these passages, it would be hard to argue that the author of Luke's Gospel did not intend to convey a direct relationship between them, such that the Lord's Prayer acts as a reflective summary of Jesus' response to temptation, delivering his success in the desert to his disciples by petition.
|
The Paschal Nature of the Lord's Supper in 1 Corinthians and the Implications for Understanding the Antioch Incident
Program Unit: Paul within Judaism
Michael Patrick Barber, Augustine Institute
As P. Fredriksen recently pointed out (2017), explanations of the incident at Antioch described in Galatians 2 are often unpersuasive. For example, the supposition that the controversy involved purity concerns relating to proximity to Gentiles ignores the fact that non-Jews were included in the life of the Jerusalem temple and the synagogue (cf. also Zetterholm, 2009). Nevertheless, Fredriksen's conclusion, namely, that there was anxiety about what was consumed and/or the meal's context is also somewhat unsatisfying. Peter is not condemned for what he eats but for his choice of table companions and purity is never explicitly in view (Nanos, 2002). Moreover, as Fredriksen admits, our evidence suggests that Jews practiced a greater degree of flexibility regarding purity issues when among Gentiles (cf. E. Sanders, 2015). Fredriksen's account also minimizes the significance of Gal 2:13, which describes Peter's critics as "the circumcision." Given the broader question of the need for Gentiles to undergo the Jewish rite, an issue that clearly drives much of the argument in the epistle, the appearance of this specific label seems significant. This paper will argue that Peter's detractors should be taken more seriously as theologians and should not be viewed as merely scandalized puritans. Picking up on the insight that eating together constituted a major aspect of those who opposed Peter, this paper offers an account of their view that builds upon suggestions made previously by D. Hare and B. Chilton. First, as we know from the Corinthian correspondence, in this early period the eucharist had yet to be separated from the celebration of the communal meal, making it likely that it was part of the meal at Antioch (I. Elmer, 2009; cf. also Schlier, 1989; Jewett, 1994). Second, as many have noted, the Last Supper account in 1 Corinthians 11 includes a number of details suggestive of an awareness of the meal's paschal setting (Pitre, 2015). Moreover, that Jesus' death was linked to Passover is clearly attested in 1 Corinthians 5. Thus, as J. Patterson (2015) has argued, there are good reasons to think the Lord's Supper itself was understood as paschal in character. Third, Paul indicates that he "received" the tradition of the Lord's Supper (1 Cor 11:23), a comment that many have read as indicating a source for the practice in the Jerusalem church. Together these observations paint a picture that help redraw the incident at Antioch. While Gentiles were allowed to enter the temple and participate in Jewish life in general, the Torah explicitly bars the uncircumcised from eating the Passover meal (cf. Exod 12:48), even if this prohibition was not always enforced (cf. Ezek. Trag. 152-92). Application of this principle on the part of Jerusalem Christians to participation in the Lord's Supper would make the most sense of the data found in Galatians, which indicate that the controversy about Peter impinged on both the question of communal eating and on the question of circumcision.
|
The Late Bronze Age-Iron Age I Transition at Gezer
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Marcella Barbosa, Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary
The transition from the Late Bronze Age to the Iron Age is still a bit of a mystery, as events and changes took place which modern scholars have difficulty explaining. It thus provides an enticing period rich with research possibilities. In the past several years, the Tandy excavations at Gezer have uncovered a robust Iron Age I occupation, as well as the last Late Bronze stratum immediately preceding it, providing primary data in which to study this transitional period. This paper will discuss this last Late Bronze city plan, its associated destruction, and how life at Gezer resumed afterwards, as well as how this fits into the overall picture of the Late Bronze- Iron I transition.
|
Jewish Jesus-Narratives in Seventeenth Century Italy: Reading Toledot Yeshu in Context
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
Daniel Barbu, Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique
The Jewish life of Jesus, or Toledot Yeshu, provides a polemical account of the origins of Christianity, mocking Jesus as an illegitimate child, a false prophet and a charlatan, and describing his disciples as a bunch of violent rogues. In various forms, the narrative circulated among Jews (and read by Christians), as early as the ninth century CE (if not earlier) and at least until the mid-twentieth century. The story was doubtless a powerful medium for collective emotions and communal bonds. It is however often considered an antiquated work, reflecting a “medieval” perception of Christianity, which early modern Jews eventually dismissed while reclaiming Jesus as law-abiding Jew and engaging in an ever-more sophisticated discourse on the early history of Christianity—au passage inventing the “historical” Jesus. Toledot Yeshu came to be described as “an abortion from the time of legends” (Mendelssohn) when it was not simply labelled “a pile of dump in a dark corner of Jewish literature” (N. Porges), contrasting with the more tolerant approaches to religious difference of Jewish “modernity.” Alas this very much goes against the textual evidence, which not only suggests that Toledot Yeshu enjoyed widespread circulation in the early modern period, but in fact truly proliferated at that time, when a number of new copies, translations and expansions were produced. Toledot Yeshu has in recent years become the object of renewed scholarly interest. Yet much of that work remains dedicated to illuminating the origins of the narrative and questions of textual history. While philological questions are undoubtedly important, such studies often fail to consider the place and function of the narrative in the shifting historical and cultural contexts in which it circulated. In this paper, I will suggest a few avenues for shifting the scholarship on Toledot Yeshu from philology to history. To this effect, I will focus on the Italian versions of Toledot Yeshu and on the early modern Italian context in which they circulated. On the one hand, I will explore some of the religious and affective entanglements between Christians and Jews reflected in the Italian texts, as a way; on the other I will discuss the role of these texts in early modern historical scholarship, in both Jewish and Christian contexts.
|
The Proliferation of Gospels and the Intentions of Subsequent Evangelists
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
James W. Barker, Western Kentucky University
Drawing on studies of manuscript materiality, sociology of reading, and circles of authors, this paper sketches a general theory of gospel proliferation. In terms of writing, Greek, Roman, and Jewish comparanda show numerous examples of similar works proliferating. In terms of reading, collection and close comparison of these similar works were also commonplace. On the supposition that ancient writers were attuned to their contemporary reading practices, gospel writers would not likely discard their sources, and readers would likely collect and compare multiple gospels. According to Markan priority, then, Matthew and Luke were not attempting to replace Mark (contra David Sim et al.); neither would Luke have attempted to replace Matthew according to Augustinian, Griesbach, and Farrer hypotheses. The longstanding question whether subsequent evangelists intended ‘to supplement or replace’ their predecessors turns out to be a false dichotomy. The paper not only offers refined terminology for gospel proliferation but also identifies common assumptions about gospel writing that do not conform to norms of Greco-Roman literary production—for example, that Mark’s gospel nearly fell out of circulation in the second century; that the Two-Source Hypothesis necessitates such a short-lived Q; and that a decade elapsed between publication of a source text and a subsequent gospel.
|
The Place of Zion in the Political Landscape of the Twelve
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Joel Barker, Heritage College & Seminary
The Place of Zion in the Political Landscape of the Twelve
|
The Daughter Sold Off for Marriage
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Pamela Barmash, Washington University
The Book of the Covenant holds that a male slave is to be freed after six years of servitude while the female slave is not released.(Exod 21:2-11) This incompatibility has been an enigma for millennia, and perhaps it was so even in biblical times, since Deut 15:12-18 revises the passage so that both male and female slaves are to be released in the seventh year. The law in the Book of the Covenant appears to be aimed at providing the female slave with the protection of marriage, but a further interpretive puzzle lies in the proviso that she is released if her husband withholds her matrimonial rights when he takes a second wife -- a malicious husband could be free of her if he intentionally denies what she is due, and then how would she be safeguarded? Possible solutions to these conundrums may be found if we understand that marriage is envisioned in two seemingly contradictory ways.
|
Neighbors and Need, Then and Now: Moral Reasoning and Embodied Love in Luke 10:25–37
Program Unit: Poverty in the Biblical World
Michael Barram, Saint Mary's College of California
In a contemporary context characterized by mounting political extremism and social tribalism, seemingly inexorable neoliberal economic imperialism, yawning gaps between the wealth and power of plutocrats and proletarians, and typically limpid (if not entirely co-opted) Christian responses to unjust and dehumanizing societal structures, the formative function of Jesus’s brilliant and status-quo-reversing parable in Luke 10:29-37—and, in particular, the ways in which it revisits the import and implications of the Levitical neighbor-love commandment (Lev 19:18)—merits renewed attention.
The Lukan Jesus launches into a parabolic tale that effectively serves to challenge and reorient the moral calculus of the Gospel’s readers, ancient and modern, in at least two fundamental ways—even as it underscores why Leviticus 19:18 can be understood to function as a summary of the whole of Torah.
First, Jesus’s parable deconstructs the legal expert’s presupposition that he might have a limited number neighbors—or that there could be a restricted scope within which legitimate neighbors might be found. The important question, according to Jesus, is not “who” a neighbor is (i.e., a matter of identity) but rather a question of “how” (“likewise” is an adverb) one is live as a neighbor with regard to anyone. The “neighbor” who is to be loved according to Lev 19:18 is not to be defined in terms of proximity, various types of similarity or affinity, or even traditional covenantal boundaries. Everyone is to be regarded as a neighbor to be ‘loved’ “as” ‘oneself’.
Second, the Lukan Jesus seeks to form the legal expert’s moral reasoning and, in particular, his actual conduct with regard to love. The literary context of Leviticus 19:18—especially Lev 19:9-18—highlights the tangible nature of what ‘loving one’s neighbor as oneself’ was to entail within the ancient Israelite covenantal community. To “love” one’s “neighbor as” ‘oneself’ had—and today, still has—concrete implications, particularly in terms of economic matters. Jesus’s parable echoes and emphasizes this same Torah concern with addressing concrete human needs. The Samaritan embodied what love for another looks like.
Jesus’s parable serves to form readers’ moral reasoning—and their behavior. They are to reason behaviorally in light of concrete human need, and they are sent into the world to meet those needs. This is why the neighbor-love commandment in Leviticus 19:18 is so often affirmed in the New Testament as an apt summary of the entire Torah. If humans embody this kind of concrete “love” for everyone (all “neighbors—“as” themselves) they have, in the process, upheld the intent of the entire Torah.
Luke 10:25-37 exposes the moral bankruptcy of belief systems and societal structures that foster tribalistic distinctions between insiders and outsiders—and that encourage us to overlook basic and fundamental human needs to the extent that to reason morally in terms of need, first and finally, seems largely incommensurate with market-oriented rationality and self-interest. In the context of radical economic and power imbalances—whether in the first century or today—the importance of tangible, concrete, embodied love for all is of critical importance. Indeed, it is at the very heart of the entire faith. Perhaps nowhere is this more evident than in Jesus’ response to the legal expert in Luke 10:25-37. Today’s Christian community needs to allow this passage to reform and transform its reasoning—and its conduct. We have so many neighbors in need.
|
What Did Paul Know about the Historical Jesus, and When and How Did He Know It?
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
S. Scott Bartchy, University of California-Los Angeles
This paper takes a fresh approach to this vexing question of Paul's knowledge of Jesus by focusing on the kinds of "counter-cultural" behavior and interpersonal relationships to which apparently Jesus and certainly Paul was seeking to convert their respective audiences. It draws on recent work published by neuroscientists (e.g.,Damasio and Iacoboni) regarding the critical role imitation plays in all human learning,
|
Preaching Mark's Jesus: Narrative Theology as a Homiletic
Program Unit: Homiletics and Biblical Studies
Jennifer Garcia Bashaw, Campbell University
One of the gravest results of the gap between the Church and the Academy is that our congregations do not benefit enough from the wealth of scholarly innovation that comes out of biblical and theological study. In this paper, I will explore one such scholarly innovation for its potential to impact the preacher's understanding and proclamation of Jesus. Elizabeth Struthers Malbon's contribution to gospel studies, Mark's Jesus; characterization as narrative Christology (Waco, TX: Baylor University Press, 2009), fuses insights from literary study, historical criticism, and theological analysis to demonstrate how Mark characterizes Jesus using the actions and words of Jesus and others throughout his narrative. After detailing the most significant insights from her study of Mark, I will suggest ways these insights can inform a preacher's understanding of Jesus. Then, I will show how Mark's Jesus could be communicated faithfully to a contemporary congregation by adapting the form of a sermon to mimic Markan literary structure and/or Mark's mode of characterization. At the end of the paper, I will preach an excerpt from a sermon on a Markan pericope in order to model how a preacher might allow Mark's characterization of Jesus to inform and shape their own characterization of Jesus from the pulpit.
|
Jesus, Women, and Power Dynamics in Luke: A Hermeneutical Response to #metoo and #churchtoo
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Jennifer Garcia Bashaw, Campbell University
Thanks to last year’s #metoo movement and others like it, Americans are finally waking up to the pervasiveness of sexual harassment and assault. Part of the plan for change involves naming the elements in our culture that have contributed to the systematic devaluing and silencing of women. Once such element is the patriarchal (so-called “biblical”) worldview espoused by many evangelical Christians. This worldview relegates women to traditional (so-called “biblical”) roles in society and maintains an oppressive power imbalance in the family and the church. Because of this misguided, “biblical” perspective, women who have been assaulted—many within the church—are often blamed or ignored, while the perpetrators face little to no repercussions for their abuse. Women who have spoken out because of the #metoo and #churchtoo movements should not have to suffer further under a system that shames rather than supports them. Instead, the church should offer healing and hope to these women. Such healing may come in many ways: voices raised in protest, justice delivered to perpetrators, grief groups formed for victims, even counseling offered for trauma recovery. In addition, since the patriarchal worldview of many evangelicals stems from a gross misapplication of Scripture, churches can also offer healing by countering such abuse of Scripture with responsible, liberating interpretation of Scripture. By communicating the redemptive biblical message, which condemns oppression and turns the power dynamics of this world upside down, preachers and teachers of Scripture can play a part in the restorative empowerment of women and in the much-needed transformation of biblical interpretation in the Church.
In this paper, I will demonstrate that good hermeneutics can provide a source of healing for women who have been hurt by the Church and its often skewed view of Scripture. I will focus on a section of Luke that highlights just one of the many liberating themes in Scripture pertinent to women who have suffered abuse. First, in Luke 7:11-17, Jesus shows death-defying compassion to a widow whose life was collateral damage in a society that treated women as helpless objects. Second, in Luke 7:36-50, Jesus bestows forgiveness and honor on a woman who anoints him while shaming the Pharisee who misused his status and power in the situation. Third, in Luke 10:38-42, Jesus challenges traditional gender roles by commending Mary’s desire to become a disciple rather than adhere to limiting societal norms. In my analysis, I will use responsible hermeneutics to show how Luke presents Jesus as upsetting the power dynamics of his culture and lifting the position and voices of women in a society that oppressed and silenced women. My anaylsis of these Lukan passages will demonstrate how solid exegesis and responsible interpretation of Scripture can underscore the biblical message of liberation, provide healing for #metoo and #churchtoo women, and inspire the church to combat the patriarchal environment that has contributed to the abuse of women for too long.
|
Fish out of Water: Teaching the Bible as a Historian of US Religion
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Katharine Batlan, The University of Texas at Austin
As a historian of American religion, when I was asked to teach a course titled, "The Bible and Its Interpreters," panic set in quickly. But in this presentation I will argue that by turning to departmental colleagues, identifying some major scholarship, and recognizing my strengths related to the topic, I was able to successfully teach an engaging course twice at my public institution. Though my perspective coming from US religious history may vary from others on the panel, I provide some tools for stretching teaching beyond a particular specialization. At my institution people who typically teach this course consider methods of studying the Bible that are familiar to many SBL members - using historical critical interpretation, feminist interpretation, and literary analysis, among others. I provided some of that interspersed throughout the class, but instead focused on how these methods related to particular American controversies. I essentially reframed the course around Bible debates in US history. We read, for example, biblical passages on slavery to understand the American Civil War, marriage to discuss polygamy debates in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century, and divergent translations of the Bible to understand controversies over Bible reading in public schools. This helped keep the course within the parameters of what my institution wanted, while keeping it manageable and engaging for me. In the second semester I taught this course, I was able to expand to include more of the traditional content of the course. This was possible because I had already done the work to lay the foundation for the class the first time around. Though the particulars of what courses require varies, I will provide my own experience of triumphs and pitfalls to try to help others who are similarly stretched in developing set courses that appear unfeasible at first glance.
|
Reception History, Authority, and Marginal Texts
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Dan Batovici, KU Leuven
This paper seeks to problematise the particular facet of New Testament Wirkungsgeschichte which involves the reception of what can be conceived of as marginal NT books. Indeed, speaking of the reception of the New Testament as a whole runs the risk of glossing too easily over the fact that the books which compose it have separate reception histories which are different both quantitatively and qualitatively. The study of the reception of marginal New Testament texts, however, especially in relation to that of the reception of non-canonical yet nonetheless authoritative early Christian writings, is crucial for better understanding the dynamics of authority of texts around the margins of the NT canon. Within this framework, the proposed paper will discuss the nature of the authority assigned to a marginal New Testament letter – 1 Peter – in Late Antiquity.
|
Reading Aids in Early Christian Papyri
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Dan Batovici, KU Leuven
This paper proposes a discussion of the available theories concerning the purpose, function, and significance of the various para-textual features in early Christian literary papyri which are considered to be reading or lectional aids of various kinds. Based on a study of the papyri of canonical and non-canonical early Christian papyri this paper re-evaluates the basis for identifying the usage of literary papyri in liturgical contexts in Late Antiquity. This would be relevant not only for a better understanding of the late-antique material perusal of early Christian books, but it also serves to call into question the implications that such theories draw with regard to the formation of the New Testament canon.
|
Once More on Editing Ethiopic Texts
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Alessandro Bausi, University of Hamburg
Notwithstanding some non-mainstream attempts of European scholarship at opening the debate and the impressive flourishing of philology programmes at Ethiopian universities, one has to admit that the general academic panorama does not provide yet any widely shared views on how to edit Ethiopic texts. The scholarly and academic control—that is the most important requirement for securing quality and establishing common standards—is still minimal. The task of checking what and how is done should be committed to reviews. These, however, are often limited to a summarization of content and often end with the assumption that an edition is good by its only existence, since a new text is made accessible in the form of a printed publication. Additional factors, moreover, must be considered: (1) historians and new field researches have highlighted the relevance of so far more neglected typology of texts, like documentary texts (feudal deeds as well as minor historiographical texts), which require specific editorial solutions due to their particular status; (2) there is an Ethiopian tradition of editing, still too little explored, represented by the Ethiopian Orthodox Church and related people and institutions; (3) the ‘manuscript cultures’ approach, that has provided a deeper and wider understanding of manuscripts as a decisive factor in shaping transmission, cultural, social: in one word, historical processes, besides and in connection with their role of text carriers. There are two aspects of this latter approach: (i) the edition can assume as its task the exhaustive documentation of each single manuscript as in-depth as possible, highlighting and documenting every single minimal textual, paratextual and material and feature, up to—this will be probably possible in the near future—to reproduce the smell of the manuscript; (ii) as far as the text is concerned (whatever we intend to define it), the ‘manuscript cultures’ perspective does not provide any editorial solution ready at hand, unless we understand as a a solution to display, for example, synoptically all the texts of each single manuscript. The same applies to any kind of digital editions, since every technical option depends upon and implies methodological decisions. In this connection, a few case studies can be used to show the complexity of some of the issues at stake and contribute fruitfully to the more general debate. These questions are not new and require the attitude of looking at the Ethiopic manuscript tradition—and at the single manuscript traditions in particular—beyond the relative familiar, yet specific and peculiar perspective of biblical textual criticism.
|
"The Torah and Testimony" in Isaiah and the Book of Jubilees
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Richard Bautch, St. Edward's University
In the various Ethiopic manuscripts of Jubilees, the book’s incipit is lengthier and likely a reflection of the full Hebrew title no longer extant: “These are the words regarding the divisions of the times of the torah and of the testimony, of the events of the years, of the weeks of their jubilees throughout all the years of eternity as he related (them) to Moses on Mount Sinai when he went up to receive the stone tablets ….” The phrase “according to the torah and the testimony” recurs elsewhere in the text (1:4-5, 26, 29; 2:24, 33; 3:14), while the lexeme “testimony” is also well attested (4:18-19; 6:32, 37; 23:32; 30:17, 19; 31:32). Altogether these citations form a leitmotif in Jubilees and raise the question of authorial intent. What is meant by the idiom “the Torah and the Testimony”? There is no clear consensus among scholars of Jubilees, although many agree that this enigmatic language is significant for the overall stance of the book. We know from 4Q216 that the Hebrew reads: והתעודההתורה . It is noteworthy that Isa 8:16 very similarly refers to the torah and the testimony: “Bind up the testimony, seal the teaching (torah) among my disciples.” Through coordinated exegesis of both Isa 8:16 and the aforementioned verses in Jubilees, this study explores potential points of contact between the book of Isaiah and the distinctive retelling of Genesis and Exodus known as Jubilees. A leading question is whether vis-à-vis “the torah and the testimony” there is shared meaning between Isaiah and Jubilees beyond that of a generic sort. In concluding, this study considers how the text of Isaiah or traditions associated with the prophet played a role in the composition of Jubilees.
|
Martyrs, Borderlines, and Jewish/Christian Identity in the Late Fourth Century
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
Carson Bay, Florida State University
No one knows who wrote the late-fourth century historiographical work often called Pseudo-Hegesippus, or On the Destruction of Jerusalem (De Excidio urbis Hierosolymitano). The author is clearly Christian inasmuch as (s)he regards Jesus to be the spes gentium, reveres Paul and Peter as doctores Christianorum, and in general rewrites Josephus’ Jewish War in a way that effectively erases the first-century Jews from history at CE 70. Yet in editing the work’s critical text, Karl Mras suggested a certain Jew named Isaac, known to Jerome, as the work’s author. The suggestion is not unreasonable. Although the author of the work stands in opposition to Josephus, who did not understand (non intellexit) the history he recorded given his participation in the perfidiae Iudaeorum, the author refers to the veterus cultus attached to the Jerusalem Temple as “ours” (nostri). Did the Christian author of this piece of classical historiography understand her/himself to be Jewish and, if so, in what way?
In this paper I argue that De Excidio provides us with one late antique Christian perspective which, while employing the terms Iudaeus and (infrequently) Christianus, transcends the rigorous binary of nomenclature. Instead, De Excidio’s historical logic functions in terms of fides and infides, pietas and impietas, allowing for historical Jews to cross over the borderline separating the narrator’s assumed, ‘orthodox’ position concerning ‘right religio,’ from the ‘wrong religio’ practiced by so many Jews of the first centuries BCE and CE that occupy her/his narrative. To demonstrate this, I offer a brief philological analysis illustrating De Excidio’s fixation upon fides et pietas as mechanisms of historical cause-and-effect. I then explore two episodes within De Excidio’s narrative that show both Christian and Jewish characters embodying a correct response—the martyr’s response—to political tyranny. Taken together, these substories create a world in which, historically, both Jews (the Maccabean martyrs) and Christians (Peter and Paul) occupy the pious territory of self-sacrifice, adding depth and texture to the author’s occasional claims to the Jewish cult and the Jewish past.
In Books 3 and 5 respectively, De Excidio briefly mentions the martyrdom accounts of Peter/Paul and the Maccabean martyrs. In each case, the heroic martyrs stand in stark contrast to actors in the surrounding narrative. Peter and Paul and the Maccabean martyrs offer themselves to be grist in the wheels of tyranny rather than forsake piety and religious devotion, while the Jewish rebels operating in De Excidio’s larger storyline do the opposite, preserving themselves at the expense of the nation, and of piety. Rather than fixating upon labels like ‘Christian’ and ‘Jewish,’ De Excidio makes the martyr’s response to oppression the acid test of a positively valuated (religious) identity. By engaging with Boyarin’s Border Lines, which places the “partition of Judaeo-Christianity” at just the time in which De Excidio was written, and with the growing literature on martyrdom in antiquity, this essay presents a late ancient perspective on identity that claims a center of gravity different than so much contemporary scholarship.
|
Negotiating the Experience of Possession in Hermas's Shepherd
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Giovanni Bazzana, Harvard University
The Shepherd of Hermas is one of the writings belonging to the early Christ movement that offers a most detailed description of the performance of possession in the context of a group ritual. The first half of the present paper will focus on the religious experience described in Mandatum XI of the Shepherd in order to show that it can be adequately categorized as "spirit" possession. This section of the paper will also demonstrate that this experience, far from being restricted to the idiosyncratic context of Mandatum XI, is in fact strictly connected to the pneumatology of the Shepherd (as it emerges mostly in the other Mandata) and to its christology (as it is presented both in the 5th Similitude and in the Visions).
The second half of the paper will focus more closely on the rhetorical presentation of the experience of possession in Mandatum XI. Ethnographic and performance-based study of possession phenomena have illustrated that the success and effectiveness of possession rituals depends on a triangular negotiation involving mediums, "spirits", and their audiences. A similar articulation is spelled out quite clearly in Mandatum XI and it is configured in ways that are remarkably different from those adopted in other texts belonging to the Christ movement, such as 1 Cor 12-14. The paper will aim to go beyond the rhetorical presentation in order to offer an imaginative reconstruction of the practice of possession in Hermas's group.
|
Qur’anic Leaves in Kufic Script on Vellum from the Ninth or Tenth Centuries in the Monastery of Saint Lazarus, Venice
Program Unit: The Qur’an: Manuscripts and Textual Criticism (IQSA)
Iskandar Bcheiry, American Theological Library Association
During the spring of 2004, I had the opportunity to uncover and index a collection of Arabic manuscripts in the library of the Armenian monastery of St. Lazarus in Venice, Italy. The monastery of St. Lazarus in Venice is built on a Venetian island that was once home to a Benedictine monastery and then a leper colony for several centuries during the Middle Ages. St. Lazarus was eventually abandoned and since 1717 has been a monastic residency to the Catholic Armenian order known as the Mekhitarists. Today this monastery is one of the three principal centers of Armenian culture in the world, the others being the monasteries of the Mekhitarists in Vienna and of Echmiadzin near Yerevan in Armenia. In this monastery there is a collection of Arabic manuscripts that were collected over time. These manuscripts are mainly from Syria and Egypt, especially during the time of Boghos Bey Yusufian (1775-1844), the Minister of both Commerce and Foreign Affairs in Egypt during the rule of Muhammad Ali Pasha (1805-1848).
Special Arabic manuscripts
The collection of Arabic manuscripts in St. Lazarus contains several Qur’anic leaves in Kufic script on vellum, from north Africa or near East, which probably belong to the 9th century AD. in my presentation i would like to shed light on this unknown collection of Qur’anic leaves.
in addition also in the library of this monastery there is 4 ancient folios from the Bible in Syriac (two folios belong to St. John Gospel 6th or 7th century and two folios belong to exodus, old testament 5th or 6th century. these fragments of biblical texts are unknown to the world.
|
Has a Nation Changed Its Gods? Divine Identity and the Gods of Ancient Sam’al
Program Unit: Israelite Religion in Its Ancient Context
Adam Bean, Johns Hopkins University
The corpus of 9th-8th cenutury BCE inscriptions from Zincirli, the site of ancient Sam'al, provides a valuable witness to the veneration of a small pantheon of deities in an Iron Age Syrian state. Differences between the divine names listed in the earlier inscription of Kulamuwa, written in Phoenician, with those in subsequent incriptions written in the local Sam’alian dialect, have prompted diverse interpretations in scholarship. While earlier discussions emphasized the divine equivalencies implied by the structure of the deity lists (e.g. Baʿl Ṣemed = Hadad), the most prominent recent treatments of religion at Sam'al by Herbert Niehr assert that these differences reflect deliberate changes from the veneration of Canaanite-Phoenician deities to Aramean ones concurrent with dynastic change. In this paper, Niehr's interpretation of the panetheon at Sam’al is critiqued based on a fuller appreciation of the semiotics of divine identity in a multilingual and multicultural environment. Moroever, the evidence from Sam’al is expounded as an ideal test case for studying the dynamic and multifacted nature of divine identity in Iron Age Levantine religion. Similar dynamics in the translation, consolidation, and sub-specification of divine identity can be observed in the religion of other Levantine states, including ancient Israel and Judah.
|
The Iconography of Joel 2: Toward a Visual Hermeneutic
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Brady Alan Beard, Emory University
In the landmark studies The Symbolism of the Psalms and Gods, Goddesses, and Images of God, Othmar Keel and the "Fribourg School" examined a previously ignored set of data for understanding the historical and theological background of the Hebrew Bible, namely ancient Near Eastern iconography. Since that time, iconographic study has been pursued through three major approaches: iconographic-artistic (an art-historical approach to material culture), iconographic-historic (the development of images in ancient Near Eastern religion and culture), and iconographic-biblical (the interpretation of the Hebrew Bible in light of ancient Near Eastern iconography). Much of Keel's own work, and that of most biblical iconographers, falls into the "iconographic-biblical" category by focusing on ancient Near Eastern iconographic motifs and biblical texts. Recently, biblical scholars have turned to the field of Visual Studies to develop a "visual hermeneutic" of biblical texts (Ryan P. Bonfiglio, Izaak J. de Hulster, and Brent A. Strawn). These scholars argue that Hebrew Bible poetic texts, including psalms and prophetic literature, provide useful places for the iconographic study of the Bible because of these texts' reliance on metaphor, imagery, and linguistic imagery because they require a "visual approach." While these scholars address prophetic literature, they give little attention to the Book of the Twelve. To address this paucity, I examine the book of Joel, the "lynchpin" of the Book of the Twelve, through an iconographic approach.
Despite its brevity, the book of Joel utilizes complex imagery and metaphor that resists easy interpretation. One need only to look at debates around the meaning and identity of the locusts in chapter 1 to see how complex the metaphors, and their meaning, become. In this paper, I argue that iconographic exegesis may provide fresh insights into Joel's message. To explore these insights, I borrow methods from the field of Visual Studies (particularly Hans Belting, David Morgan, and J. M. F. Heath) and biblical iconography (Ryan P. Bonfiglio, Izaak J. de Hulster, and Brent A. Strawn) to examine data from Babylonian and Persian iconography with respect to Joel 2. Unlike recent interpreters, I do not focus on the historicity of the various events depicted in the book. Instead, I glean interpretive insights from ancient Near Eastern iconography. I examine the description of the Day of Yahweh in chapter 2:3-11 (especially v. 7-11) and consider the visual depiction of warfare in ancient Near Eastern iconography. Questions I consider include: How does the imagery of chapter 2 relate to chapter 1? How do iconography or visual depictions of leaders and deities going to war illuminate this text? Where is Yahweh envisioned in relation to the Judah? I address these questions through attention to ancient Near Eastern iconography by way of comparison with the biblical text. Thus, this project can be placed alongside other iconographic-biblical approaches or be considered a step toward iconographic exegesis.
|
Cardiac Discourse in the Bible and Book of Mormon
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
Daniel Becerra, Duke University
Biblical names, phrases, idioms, and passages permeate the pages of the Book of Mormon and inform its theology. This paper examines the convergence and divergence of cardiac discourse—i.e. discourse relating to the “heart” (Hebrew: lev/levav; Greek: kardia)—in the Bible and Book of Mormon. Appearing approximately 1000 times in the Bible and over 450 in the Book of Mormon, the heart constitutes a fruitful locus for exploring the relationship between these two texts, not least relative to their respective notions personhood and morality. Accordingly, my paper proceeds in two parts. Part one examines the heart’s portrayal as an aspect of the physical and psychical parts of the human self. I draw attention, therefore, to its role in vitality, cognition, volition, and emotion. Part two addresses the heart’s function as locus of moral influence and a barometer of moral character. Tracing both inter- and intra-textual relationships, I pay particular attention, on the one hand, to the ways in which the Book of Mormon appropriates, challenges, and alters biblical cardiac discourse, and on the other, to the development of cardiac discourse within the Book of Mormon itself, spanning its three literary units—the Small Plates; Large Plates; and the writings of Moroni. The paper concludes by offering suggestions for how cardiac discourse in the Bible may inform the critical study of moral formation in the Book of Mormon.
|
The History of the Vocalization of the Definite Article with Inseparable Prepositions in Tiberian Hebrew
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Peter Bekins, Wright State University
In biblical Hebrew, the consonant /h/ of the definite article is elided when preceded by one of the inseparable prepositions (b-, k-, l-). In these cases, the presence of the article is no longer indicated in the consonantal text. The relatively high frequency with which the definite article is vocalized with inseparable prepositions has raised questions about whether the Tiberian tradition is consistent with earlier stages of the language or reflects a later linguistic context. This paper will explore the phenomenon from two angles. First, we will analyze the distribution of the definite article as represented in the consonantal text and as vocalized with the inseparable prepositions b-, k-, and l- to determine whether the latter examples cluster in linguistic contexts that we would expect to be later from a typological perspective. Special attention will be given to unique/generic nouns and instrumental phrases that represent stereotyped actions. Second, we will analyze the evidence for the vocalization of the definite article with inseparable prepositions in the ancient translations (e.g., LXX, Aquila) and transcriptions (e.g., Origen, Jerome), as well as other Biblical Hebrew reading traditions of the Middle Ages (e.g., Babylonian). In this section we will pay special attention to prosodic factors that may also influence the vocalization.
|
Marginalized Islanders? Migrant Widows and Freedmen in Acts 6
Program Unit: Islands, Islanders, and Scriptures
Heather-Gail Belfon, Iliff School of Theology
This paper examines two incidences of conflict in Acts 6 -- the food rations inequity against Hellenistic widows and the dispute among the Synagogue of the Freedmen against Stephen’s interpretation of Jewish history and Torah. Contrary to F. Scott Spencer, it is not sufficient to truncate vv. 1-7 from vv. 8-15 in order to propose a dichotomist Christian Jews and Hellenistic Jews division in Luke, assuming Hellenistic Jews to be primarily Gentile converts to Christianity. Even so, Acts 6 is not hinged upon a systematic view of “Luke’s widows,” categorized so by a thread of occurrences starting from Luke 2:38ff to Acts 9:36ff. A synchronic reading throughout the Lucan corpus is misleading because every instance presents itself in a unique context with discrete issues surrounding widowhood. Making normative the notion that widows are marginalized, destitute women, Spencer misses the more obvious challenges of Acts 6.
Examining practices concerning widows among the Essene community in the Dead Sea Scrolls and using Norman Fairclough’s critical discourse analysis, I will show how Acts 6 provides a religious statement about the benefits and perils of living in religious community in Jerusalem when one has migrated from elsewhere. Acts 6 challenges the notion of what it means for diverse Jewish sects to honor the authority of Torah while maintaining the contract of communal sharing and drawing of the boundaries of orthopraxy. If the locations from which Synagogue of Freedmen originated provides any clue, it is to disprove the notion that the Hellenistic widows were marginalized on account of geographical origins and ethnic difference. Rather, the extent to which the Christian-Jewish sect had the capacity to use a common language to acquire representation, and so, gain influence is what made the Synagogue of Freedmen successful and the Hellenistic widows not.
|
The Diviner's Gift Comes at a Cost: On Divinatory Compensation and Paul's Finances
Program Unit: The Historical Paul
Brigidda Bell, University of Toronto
Soothsayers, lot diviners, dream interpreters, and astrologers were staple figures of the ancient Mediterranean world. Individuals who claimed the ability to interpret the present or future through the reading of signs and the performance of special acts were in demand in the early Empire. Literary sources witness their presence in both upper class households in salaried positions, and in the Circus, available to read your palm or your eyebrows for a one-time-fee. While a host of literary sources portray these figures as self-interested and greedy, other diviners have been described as ‘friends’ and are remunerated in less apparent ways, such as through gifts and favours. One early Christ follower who claimed divine knowledge of the future and dealt in the currency of friendship and gifts was Paul. Modern scholarship on Paul has gone to great lengths to purify him from associations with ‘unsavoury’ characters, yet professional diviners serve as useful analogues for the kinds of services Paul offered and the way that he was remunerated. This paper pieces together the portraits of several imperial period diviners and their forms of compensation, to situate Paul within a framework of divinatory services where remuneration through ‘gifts’ enhanced his credibility.
|
ΔΙΚΑΙΩΜΑ: A Curious Case of Semantic Borrowing
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Joel Bell, Oxford University
This paper is interested in the linguistic phenomenon of semantic borrowing, specifically, Greek words that took on new meaning based on their use by Greco-Jewish translators. In this study the candidate for semantic borrowing is δικαίωµα. Two peculiarities are evident when considering the diachronic use of this word: First, the verb δικαιόω and the noun δικαίωµα do not exhibit semantic consistency. While δικαιόω conveys ideas related to righting wrongs, δικαίωµα may also represent that which governs how members of a religion or society are to behave, and is often glossed “statute, ordinance.” Second, while the use of δικαίωµα for “ordinance, statute” is prevalent in the Septuagint and the Jewish and Christian Greek literature that followed, this meaning does not evidence itself in papyri, inscriptions, or Greek literature (until the 3rd c. A.D.). This paper outlines the reception history of δικαίωµα in order to account for these peculiarities and demonstrate the likelihood that the “statute, ordinance” arose from the Septuagint and influenced the meaning of the word in later literature.
|
Creating New Perspectives out of Old: Proverbs as Subtle and Subversive
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Alice Ogden Bellis, Howard University School of Divinit
The book of Proverbs is generally understood to present a conservative perspective in contrast to the more liberal points of view found in Job and Ecclesiastes. The editors who brought the proverbs into final form, however, were very careful in their arrangement of their material (and possibly the addition of new material) and it can be argued that the juxtaposition of various aphorisms which are in tension with each other was intended to engage the reader in important questions about the relative importance of wealth, ethical living, helping the poor, and the like. In addition, the very structure of the book with the first nine chapters and the last chapter focused on women suggests that they were trying to make a statement about gender in such a way as to undercut some of the negative stereotypes that are included in Proverbs, stereotypes that were perhaps too strong to be omitted but could be undercut by careful manipulation of the texts (and possible addition of new texts). Through a combination of careful placement of the aphorisms dealing with many subjects throughout the book and in particular the ones dealing with women at the beginning, end, and at a critical point in the middle of the book, the editors were creating a new piece of literature with a new perspective out of old traditions.
|
Gene Tucker: Sage Scholarship by Design and Example
Program Unit:
Ehud Ben Zvi, University of Alberta
Across continents there is an ongoing, at times explicit and often implicit, discussion about what a scholar should be and do, and mainly in relation to scholars who have been fortunate enough to hold a ‘safe’, tenured-track position in a University with major resources. It is in this context that I will reflect on the understanding of scholarship that Gene Tucker advanced by example. I plan to talk about the ways in which his scholarship balanced and intertwined, inter alia, his own research, the emphasis he placed on developing the scholarship of others (via mentoring, editing, etc.), the importance he placed on professional organizations and the scholar’s duty to contribute to them, his understanding of the value of collaborations across multiple types of boundaries and backgrounds, and his conviction that scholars should be able to interact with and contribute to the lives of others, well outside the guild and in a way informed by their scholarship. I plan to set these observations about Gene in the light of what seems to me was his guiding principle as a mature scholar, namely cooperative open criticality.
|
The Character of the Prophet Among the Literati of the Prophetic Books: Memory and System Considerations
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Ehud Ben Zvi, University of Alberta
The fifteen prophets of old with whom books are associated in the Prophetic Book Collection served as sites of memory in ancient Israel and have continue to serve as such in various communities through time and up to the present—one may argue that even the 'historical prophets’ that current scholarship has often construed have served, to a significant extent, the roles of sites of memory for many. To ensure that their figures could serve efficiently as sites of memory, ancient communities (and at times not so ancient) have often bracketed numerous questions about them that might have emerged given their world of knowledge. But at the same time, since neither characters in books nor figures who serve as social sites of memory can be imagined without constructing additional characters, and above all, a certain world with certain sets of rules, the very same groups actively brought each their own world of knowledge and imagination to bear in the construction of these prophets as an integral part of a general ‘eco-system’ of memory with its own set of rules. Prophets as sites of memory were part of a complex memory landscape—in which, inter alia, multiple human figures, YHWH, texts and various spaces all has an interrelated place. To a significant degree, prophets of memory, as a group or set of groups, were shaped by that landscape. Given the (generative) interrelatedness among all these sites of memory partaking in the said landscape, one could not but influence, directly or indirectly the way in which the other was constructed and remembered. Moreover, all together reflected and reaffirmed underlying sets of rules generating and governing the landscape. Multiple examples will be brought to bear into this discussion.
|
New Readings and Discussion of 4Q249 cryptA Midrash/Sepher Moshe
Program Unit: Qumran
Jonathan Ben-Dov, University of Haifa
Fourteen papyrus fragments of papCryptA 4Q249 were published by Stephen Pfann in DJD 35 with notes and commentary. Pfann has also supplied material reconstruction of one column of this scroll based on the papyrus fibers. Based on a new study of the cryptic papyri, some new results can now be reported. Several joins being overruled, we are now less secure about the column width in this scroll and about several previously suggested readings. On the other hand, more is known about the comparable document 4Q249a, identified as a copy of Serekh HaEdah and reconstructed to a length of five consecutive columns. New readings of key fragments of 4Q249 now show that it contains halakhic elaborations of impurity laws based on Leviticus chapters 11-14. Death impurity is imported into this sequence from Numbers 19, in a similar way to the sequence created in the Temple Scroll. A fragmentary halakhic syllogism creates an interesting parallel to a passage from Mishnah Nega’im. Finally, the scroll may have also contained elaborations of the non-halakhic section Leviticus 26.
|
On the Possibility of an Early Iron Age Nomadic Monarchy in the Arabah (Early Edom) and Its Implications on the Study of Ancient Israel
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Erez Ben-Yosef, Tel Aviv University
Since its early days, the common perception of nomads in biblical archaeology has been of people that could not form strong political entities, and whose influence on the course of history was marginal. Biblical scholars and archaeologists alike have constantly equated the biblical-era nomads to the modern Bedouins of the Southern Levant, further enforcing the interpretation of these groups as simple tribal societies that existed in the geographical and historical periphery of the settled land. Similarly, almost any discussion on the formation of the Southern Levantine Iron Age kingdoms, including the United Monarchy of Ancient Israel, has been based on the fundamental assumption that such political organizations could not have developed prior to complete sedentarization; consequently, the identification of these kingdoms in the archaeological record has been dependent on the existence of substantial stone-built remains.
However, new archaeological evidence from the Arabah, including the recent excavations by the Central Timna Valley Project of Tel Aviv University (https:// archaeology.tau.ac.il/ben-yosef/CTV/), challenges this fundamental assumption. In this paper I argue that we have sufficient new data to support the reconstruction of an early (Iron I) Edomite kingdom, which achieved a complex social organization and ultra-regional impact prior to the sedentarization of its (semi-)nomadic (agro-)pastoralistic tribes. This has significant implications on our understanding of the other emerging Southern Levantine kingdoms, including Ancient Israel, as all of which have a nomadic background that is attested for in biblical as well as external sources.
|
Naboth’s Vineyard, Ahab, and Jezebel: New Insights on the Composition History of 1 Kings 21
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Clay Bench, University of Texas at El Paso
In his book, The Trouble with Kings, McKenzie argues that 1 Kings 21:17, *18, 19a “and perhaps 20abα” are “the oldest remaining segment of chapter 21.” McKenzie notes that there is wide agreement among scholars that a different redactional hand can be detected in vv.20bβ-24 which repeats the common oracle against Israelite dynasty founders (see 1 Kgs 14:7-11 and 16:2-4). In these verses, it is generally agreed that v.23 is secondary and that Dtr style and terminology are only found in vv. vv.20bβ-22, and 24. In his conclusion to his analysis of 1 Kings 21 and 2 Kings 9-10, McKenzie stated “The additions make it clear that it was Dtr who used the Jehu story to illustrate the fulfillment of prophecy. He linked it with the Naboth episode as the fulfillment of Elijah’s oracle against Ahab’s house and incorporated the product within his prophecy-fulfillment scheme. There is nothing to indicate that the two stories were connected before Dtr. He followed the same scheme as with the previous oracles against Jeroboam and Baasha, illustrating how the prophetic curse repeated against each dynasty was effected in that dynasty’s annihilation. The only difference in the case of Ahab’s house was that Dtr had access to a lengthy narrative about Jehu’s coup which he incorporated within his scheme as the fulfillment of Elijah’s word which he set in the context of the Naboth incident.” Though I agree with much of McKenzie’s astute analysis, there are several points that need some reconsideration. For example, there is thematic and textual critical evidence that connects the initial curse of Elijah against Ahab in 1 Kgs 21:19 (not just 19a) with the story as it is reported in 2 Kings 9. I also agree with McKenzie that v.23 is secondary, as with the previous claim, though I will argue that it too is connected thematically, though in modified form, to the whole of v.19 as well as 2 Kgs 9:26 and 31-37.
|
“Perhaps They Will Turn…”: The Value of Repentance as a Theological Category in the Interpretation of Jeremiah’s Temple Sermon (Jer. 7.1–15)
Program Unit: Theology of the Hebrew Scriptures
Jonathan D. Bentall, Durham University
Often regarded as one of the central elements of interpretive difficulty in the book of Jeremiah, the relationship between conditional warnings of judgment and apparently unconditional pronouncements of doom have prompted complex redaction-critical and traditio-historical hypotheses that might explain their juxtaposition. Comparatively less attention has been directed toward theological accounts of the relationship between conditional and unconditional language, and the ways in which related passages internal to the book of Jeremiah might provide intratextual signals for how another text may be read and understood. In this essay I argue that Jer. 26.3 and 36.3 provide a theological rationale and hermeneutical warrant from within the developing Jeremianic tradition for the interpretation of Jer. 7.1-15 as inherently conditional prophetic speech, intended to provoke repentance and inspire covenantal faithfulness. This thesis involves both a critique of existing redaction-critical and traditio-historical models for understanding this text, and a fresh, theologically-oriented reading of the text in its canonical form. Alongside its exegetical argument, this paper also provides a case study in the potential for theologically-oriented biblical criticism to draw upon and benefit from historical-critical approaches, even while resisting and reevaluating some of their methods and conclusions. Building upon the recent work of Sommer (2015) and Anderson (2017) I construe theological interpretation as an interdisciplinary, or dialogical, endeavor that is capable of doing justice to the insights of both biblical criticism and theological discourse. Thus, in critical dialogue with alternative approaches to the significance of repentance in the book of Jeremiah (e.g. Unterman, 1987; Lambert, 2016), I suggest that the theological categories of divine mercy and human repentance within Jewish and Christian traditions constitute valuable resources for understanding the message of Jer. 7.1–15.
|
The Stricken Prophet: Violence, Trauma and Faithfulness in Jeremiah 18–20
Program Unit: Writing/Reading Jeremiah
Jonathan D. Bentall, Durham University
Set within the closing section of what are often referred to as the prophet’s confessions or laments, Jeremiah 18–20 features a series of images related to violence and destruction, from God’s declaration of his prerogative to destroy nations and kingdoms to the prophet’s symbolic action of breaking a potter’s vessel and Pashur’s physical assault upon Jeremiah. The varied yet interrelated images of violent action, trauma and resilience within these chapters prompts hermeneutical reflection upon the multidimensional aspects of how violence functions in this prophetic text. The aim of this paper is to contribute to ongoing discussions concerning the use of trauma and resilience studies as a lens for biblical interpretation, focusing attention upon the ways in which violent action, violent images, and reactions to violence relate to one another. Using chapters 18–20 as a case study, I explore the imagery of the formation and destruction of pottery in relation to the collective trauma of military conquest and captivity, as well as the individual violence experienced by Jeremiah at the hands of the priest Pashur, in relation to his experience of divine coercion in the context of the prophetic task. I argue that despite the apparent finality of the broken vessel that “can never be mended” (Jer. 19:10–11), both the contextually significant imagery of pottery and its capacity to be reshaped (18:4–11), as well as Jeremiah’s own response to adversity within his prophetic vocation (20:11–12) provide a legitimate source of hope for the nation’s future, which is to be found in heeding the prophet’s words, turning from evil and amending/re-forming its conduct. I conclude by reflecting on the hermeneutical relationship between the social-scientific category of resilience and the theological category of faithfulness in the midst of individual and collective experiences of violence and trauma.
|
Qohelet and Luke's Rich Fool
Program Unit: Gospel of Luke
Susan E. Benton, Baylor University
Scholars have long recognized an allusion to the hedonistic pessimism drawn out of Ecclesiastes in The Parable of the Rich Fool (Luke 12:13-21). What many have failed to observe is that the rebuke of God to the Rich Fool’s acquisitiveness also derives from Qohelet’s wisdom. Drawing on the insight of Old Testament scholars (R. N. Whybray, J. Grillo) into how the theme of joy can be seen developing incrementally through Ecclesiastes, this paper proposes a reinterpretation of the Parable of the Rich Fool. Instead of alluding to Ecclesiastes only to dismiss it, Luke’s Jesus places the wisdom of Ecclesiastes into the mouth of God. The Rich Fool might draw on the immature thoughts of Qohelet, but God rebukes him with the mature ideas of the Teacher. In the process, the parable validates a perspective of Ecclesiastes that regards it as a text with a changing perspective on wisdom and joy. The pericope then propels that evolving perspective on Ecclesiastes forward with new associations for Jesus’s followers.
Qohelet’s images of sowing seeds and casting bread upon water prefigure the distributive model that Jesus depicts as the means of being rich toward God. Jesus’s disciples are to admire the ravens—who have no storehouses (Lk. 12:24)—rather than the rich man who builds more of them. Whereas Qohelet concludes with the idea that people should enjoy abundance with their households instead of hoarding, Luke’s Jesus instructs his people to sell off possessions and give alms (Lk. 12:33).
|
The Hymnic Participle in Biblical Hebrew: Semantic and Syntactic Perspectives
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Ulf Bergström, Uppsala Universitet
The so-called ‘hymnic participle’ is a well-known feature of Biblical Hebrew poetry, but very cursorily treated in standard grammars. This paper investigates some aspects of the complex syntax and semantics of the construction. The function of the hymnic participle is to highlight various aspects of the identity of a referent as objects of praise. It normally takes the form of an apposition, but it can also be a left-dislocated constituent (e.g., Amos 4:13) or a predicate (e.g., 1 Sam 2:6–8; Ps 103:6; 147:2). In terms of morphosyntax it is basically nominal, but at the same time the verbal nature of the lexeme is often exploited to the full, so that, even in apposition, the participle can take verbal complements and be coordinated with finite verbal clauses, which can form rather lengthy pieces of embedded multi-propositional discourse. In such contexts, the participles function to demarcate units of discourse. However, despite the fact that the hymnic participle can function virtually as a verb in almost all respects, it is argued in this paper that the construction consistently retains its nominal character, even in predicate position. At least two factors serve to reinforce this impression. The first and most obvious one is that the participle is morphologically distinct from the finite verbs, which are the standard forms of the independent clause predicate. Further, when a hymnic participle is conjoined with another hymnic participle, the effect never seems to be to convey the notion that there is situational continuity (in terms of time or causality) between the events represented by the two participles, something which is often the case when the hymnic participle is combined with a finite clause. This is what one would expect if the basic function of the hymnic participle is to tell about the identity of the referent, rather than about his/her actions. A precondition for perceiving the hymnic participle in predicate position as a noun is that the form is not the main imperfective form in the verbal system. In more advanced stages of Biblical Hebrew, when the active participle had developed into a general imperfective at the cost of the imperfect, speakers may have tended to understand all participles in predicate position as verbal. But within the poetic register of Early Biblical Hebrew at least, the nominal character of the hymnic participle is pervasive.
|
How to Create a World: The Psalter as a Hermeneutical Tool in Rabbinic Midrash
Program Unit: Early Exegesis of Genesis 1–3
Abraham Berkovitz, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion
to be added
|
Interpretation in the Anthropocene: Reading the "Animal Family" Laws in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Beth Berkowitz, Barnard College
|
A Medieval Control for Modern Diachronic Method: The Biblical Criticism of Ibn Hazm the Andalusian
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Joshua Berman, Bar-Ilan University
This paper seeks to test a widely held assumption in the diachronic study of the Hebrew Bible: that the narrative poetics known and used by the authors of the Hebrew Bible are fully accessible to modern scholars. This is the sine qua non of much of modern diachronic method: for only if modern scholars have full access to the poetics that governed the composition of the texts, are they rightfully empowered to determine a text’s unity, or lack thereof.
To test whether the canons of narrative prose are relatively unchanged over time we need to find the work of a biblical exegete who lived in pre-modern times and yet—unlike rabbinic and patristic writers— was as fully open and committed to identifying fissures in the received text as are modern critical scholars. This study brings to light and examines just such an analysis: the biblical criticism of the eleventh century Muslim theologian, Ibn Hazm the Andalusian. Ibn Hazm offers a detailed exegesis of the signs of diachronic development that he identifies in the Hebrew scriptures. At approximately 100 pages in length it is far more comprehensive in its critique of the literary unity of the books of the Hebrew Bible than anything that would be penned prior to the eighteenth century in Europe—including the writings of Spinoza. To date, however, the treatise has all but been ignored within the field of biblical scholarship. The proposed paper is the first analysis of the literary poetics governing his critique and the first to probe its degree of convergence with modern critical conclusions. Ibn Hazm’s most comprehensive critique concerns the Book of Genesis, reviewed here with an eye toward three questions: Concerning which textual fissures do we see a convergence of opinion between Ibn Hazm and modern expositors? What textual phenomena does Ibn Hazm identify as incongruous that modern expositors have not? What textual phenomena have modern scholars identified as signs of fissure that Ibn Hazm passes over? The study concludes that while Ibn Hazm identifies many of the types of inconsistencies that have been the basis for modern diachronic readings of the Hebrew Bible, he makes no mention of repetition or of narrative doubling as a sign of fissure in the text. Ibn Hazm lived and worked in a climate in which repetition in literature was widely accepted. By contrast, nearly all modern biblicists are heirs to the tradition of narrative unity laid out in Aristotle’s Poetics. The paper concludes that we cannot know whether the writers of ancient Israel adopted a poetics more like Aristotle’s or more like the Arabesque poetics that reigned in Ibn Hazm’s day. However Ibn Hazm’s seminal work should serve as a warning light to modern scholars of the need to acknowledge the distinctly Aristotelian poetics that governs much of our own sense of literary unity.
|
"Every Man with His Censer in His Hand": Incense-Burning and the Sensory Contestation of Space in Ancient Israel
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Sarah L. Berns, Brown University
How did ancient Israelites use the sights, sounds, and smells made by burning aromatics to create cultic space? How do biblical texts about incense-burning relate to the burning practices of ancient Israelites? In this paper, I read material remains of Iron Age incense burning together with theories about the production of space through ritual practice (Catherine Bell) and embodied skill (Tim Ingold), arguing that ancient Israelites used burning to create units of space-time (Doreen Massey) understood as "cultic," or appropriate for ritual practice and interaction with divine beings. Cultic space-time units were defined by sensory differences from the surrounding space and time. Sensual similarity between these space-time units and other spaces and times, both real and imagined, evoked associations with purity, wealth, distance, and antiquity, making these moments and spaces perceptibly cultic. Turning to biblical texts that depict, command, or prohibit incense-burning, I argue that they share the same practical logic as incense-burning: they create specific cultic spaces by depicting sensory units bound in distance and duration, while associating those units with purity, wealth, distance, antiquity, and the proximity of divine beings. However, I also note that these texts seek to define proper and improper locations for incense-burning. Various passages critique incense-burning in homes, at bāmôt, on high hills, under trees, in the streets of Jerusalem and cities of Judah, and in the besieged Jerusalem temple, while others specify appropriate locations for incense-burning, or limit the burning of particular mixtures to specific cultic sites. I argue that these critical passages, often taken as evidence of changing norms or of increasing cultic centralization in ancient Israel, might be better understood as evidence of the authors' attempts to produce and organize space. Even as they relied upon the practical logic and sensory associations of Israelite incense-burning to write texts that produced particular cultic spaces, biblical authors also attempted to change those associations. With critiques that linked some incense-burning practices and locales with foreignness, idolatry, sexual misconduct, and misappropriation of divine property, these authors sought to limit the effectiveness of incense-burning to particular places, times, and ritual actors. Rather than reflecting the development or evolution of normative Israelite religion, these biblical critiques offer us a glimpse of contested space-making in action, allowing us to see how some ancient actors used words, smoke, and scent and make and limit cultic space.
|
Rips and Seams: Immigrant Women Stitching Healing and Wholeness into Worlds of Trauma and Loss
Program Unit: Society for the Arts in Religious and Theological Studies (SARTS)
Rebecca Berru Davis, Montana State University - Billings
This paper examines how creative expression, carried out in collaborative settings, is a means to begin the small steps toward recovery among women whose lives have been ruptured by experiences of crossing borders.
|
Dirty Words: The Physical Presence of Speech in Christian Late Antiquity
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Todd Berzon, Bowdoin College
According to the Sayings of the Desert Fathers, Abba Sisoës is reported to have offered one and only one prayer to Christ on a daily basis: "'Lord Jesus, save me from my tongue.'" For, he laments, "every day, I fall because of it, and commit sin." Although spoken words were corporeal and spiritual extensions of their speaker-piety of speech reflected piety of mind and body-they could also ensnare and pollute the utterer and the larger community in which he lived. Speaking, as a mode of materializing and communicating knowledge, was not only a religiously ambiguous activity, but one with profound and lasting consequences; it all too often denatured or impurified the subject and those around him. Words could affect speakers as much as speakers could affect words. Insofar as scholars of early Christianity now emphasize the general instability of words--their ability to channel piety and impiety in equal measure--in this paper I aim not to rehearse these arguments about the dangers of orality but rather to recast them. I would like to suggest that for late antique Christians the precariousness of speech was very often imagined to be a specifically material danger. Language did not simply do things (both good and bad, constructive and destructive), but was, in fact, a thing itself. Spoken words were not fleeting and ephemeral, but rather palpable and enduring material forces.
With particular attention to a small sliver of evidence from the vast corpus of literature about the late ancient monks--writings from Jerome, Cassian, Basil, as well as The Sayings of the Desert Fathers--I will propose that spoken language, within the monastic milieu, possessed a physicality or physical presence as both pollutant and purificant. For the monks, spoken language was both disease and drug. Words were dangerous and edifying not just because of what they could lead people to do, but because of what they were said to be at the physical or ontological level. Oral language (about the self, about the world, about fellow brothers, about God, etc.) was said to have quite tactile properties and qualities. Indeed, the way monks engaged with and experienced oral language points toward the tangibility and weight of words themselves. Words could be held, felt, harnessed, and deflected as pollutants and cures. Words were hurled against people; they attached themselves to Christians; they were implanted in monks; and they were handed over to ascetics. In short, they were absorbed as destructive and fortifying epistemological objects. For Christians writing about the monastic way of life, speech was, like food, clothing, water, money, etc., part of economy of sacred (and profane) objects. The words of the tongue were epistemological things that constantly threatened yet tamed the desert monk's way of life, his desired detachment from the material world. Speech was an ethereal yet material form that required both psychic and corporeal regulation.
|
The Gnostic Roots of Marian Devotion in Late Antiquity
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Michael Beshay, Ohio State University
Recent studies have demonstrated the value of seeking Marian devotion in early Christian apocrypha. Building on these insights, this paper proposes that Christian Gnostic and related traditions played a role in shaping Marian devotion in late antiquity. This will be demonstrated by focusing on just one element of Mary’s significance for late antique Christians: her typological relationship with Eve. The relationship is typically understood as an antithesis when analyzed from the perspective of patristic authors. However, a close reading of Egyptian Gnostic and apocryphal literature along with numerous ritual devices offers an alternative view: Mary is a source of power and doctrinal authority, whose relationship with Eve exalts her and depends not on the theme of moral atonement, but reunification.
Such lofty portrayals of Mary induced some Christians in Egypt, and perhaps the Roman east more generally, to regard her as a source of power derived from a heavenly abode. In the traditions of the Nag Hammadi codices, Mary’s role in connection with Eve develops a close relationship, bridging on identification, with feminine powers such as the Holy Spirit. Similar themes abound in Coptic literary texts even as late as the sixth century. Meanwhile, Greek and Coptic ritual devices from late antique Egypt attest to the interest of Egyptian Christians in precisely this image of a powerful Mary. The fact that most of these devices date to the fifth century or later has led scholars along the usual path of attributing their popularity to a post-Ephesian climate of Marian devotion. However, much of this material betrays the same “heterodox” signatures seen in Gnostic and apocryphal traditions; these devices therefore betray an abiding interest among Christians in Egypt in the elusive Mary of Gnostic origins.
This paper will conclude with a brief discussion of the esoteric doctrines and ritual practices of Manichaean Christians, and their significance for Marian devotion in late antiquity. Analysis of the Manichaean Bema festival reveals striking parallels to the feast of Mary’s Dormition. The Coptic Bema psalms celebrate cosmic figures whose characteristics match closely the elusive Mary of Gnostic and related traditions; these figures are exalted in similar ways as Mary in her connection with Eve and the Holy Spirit. Finally, the Bema festival was constructed as a challenge to the validity of the incarnation and crucifixion of Christ, celebrated annually on the same day as the Pascha with psalms proclaiming Mani’s “true” suffering and death; in such a contentious setting, invocations to a heavenly “Virgin of Light” likely promoted the belief that Mary was instead the glorious figure worthy of such veneration.
|
Writing and Reading Gooder: Solecisms in Revelation
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Garrett Best, Asbury Theological Seminary
Scholars have proposed as many as 232 solecisms (morpho-syntactical errors) within the Greek of the Apocalypse. One of the great paradoxes of the book is its astonishing complexity expressed in such irregular Greek. While numerous scholars have sought to account for and explain the solecisms in Revelation, few have explored the aural dimension. Since the book was designed to be read aloud to early churches in Asia, it is important to investigate how irregular grammar would have affected the first hearers. This paper attempts to fill this lacuna by examining how solecisms were viewed in the ancient world and how ancients responded when lectors made mistakes in reading. Historical analogies suggest that the solecisms would have posed challenges for the lector as well as first-century audiences and that the lector was faced with important decisions on how best to deliver the document.
|
The Gate and the Way: Constructing Theology in Mormon Scripture through New Testament Quotation
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
Stephen Betts, Brigham Young University
In recent years, scholars of Mormon scripture have increasingly attended to identifying the quotations and allusions to New Testament scripture in the Book of Mormon. This paper will trace the theological development of "way" and "gate" imagery deriving from Matthew 7 and Luke 13 as it appears in the Book of Mormon. This paper serves as a case study in the evolution of the early Mormon biblical hermeneutic in the construction of Mormon scripture.
|
G(r)azing: Seeing and Being Animal in the Song of Songs
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Jared Beverly, Chicago Theological Seminary
The love poetry of the Song of Songs is replete with descriptions of each lover's appearance and of the act of looking itself. A few scholars have examined the gaze in the Song, most notably Cheryl Exum (along the lines of gender) and Elaine James (along the lines of landscape), but so far the gaze in the Song has not been examined through the lens of species. This paper will undertake a close reading of the gazes involved in the gazelle/deer metaphor in Song 2:8-17, reading this passage alongside recent visual artwork and keeping the discourse of the species in mind. After briefly rehearsing some of the history of scholarship around the gaze (e.g., Mulvey, hooks), first, I will show how the woman of the Song uses a "zoological gaze" (Adrian Franklin) to look at her lover and imagine him as a gazelle/deer. Next, as the animalized lover looks from behind the wall at her in return (2:9), I will examine this animal's gaze alongside Jacques Derrida's insights about his gazing cat in The Animal That Therefore I Am. In allowing the animal to gaze upon her, perhaps she is taking upon herself Derrida's challenge of being seen by the animal. In addition, her particular zoological gaze has implications with regard to both gender and species: this animal's gaze does not constitute the domination implied in the human male gaze, nor is it the predatory gaze of an animal hunting, but rather its eyes form the gentle and nonthreatening gaze of an herbivore. Finally, I will explore how biblical scholars and artists have portrayed what these gazes do to the woman. For some, the woman can remain human and embrace this metaphorical gazelle/deer in spite of the species difference, as we see in illustrations by James Reid (in his The Song of Songs with Woodcuts [1931]), Salvador Dalí ("The Beloved Looks Forth Like a Roe," 1971), and Phillip Ratner (in the commentary by M. Basil Pennington [2004]). For others, these exchanged gazes transform not only the man but also the woman, who is sometimes read or portrayed as a gazelle/deer herself, as we see in many other images that simply show a gazelle/deer couple, such as other illustrations by Reid as well as those of Y. Chrystal (in the commentary by Yehuda Feliks [1983]). In the former portrayal, love (and perhaps even eroticism) can take the radical step of crossing species boundaries; in the latter portrayal, the woman's loving gaze transforms her into a gazelle/deer as well, perhaps forestalling the cross-species romance but also going as far as challenging her own humanness. As a result, her seeing an animal leads to her being an animal. The paper will conclude with some summary thoughts on these multiple gazes' consequences for gender, humanity, and animality.
|
Brief Notes on the Impact of Indigenous Cultural Elements in the Ethiopian Orthodox Church
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Afework Hailu Beyene, Ethiopian Graduate School of Theology
The study of impact of indigenous culture on Ethiopian Orthodox Church (EOC) has received very little academic attention, at least as compared to the discussion regarding the impact of Alexandrian, Syrian, Armenian, … and the Judaic influences. Regarding the latter, among many of cultural influences discussed is the church’s circular architecture. It is widely held that the innovation involving church edifices as an auxiliary reflection of the growth and wide spread impact of ‘Judaic culture’ and identity in Ethiopia from earliest time. It is assumed that the three-concentric circle structure of many Ethiopian local churches serves as one more of the many ‘proofs’ of EOC’s Judaic cultural influences; for some scholars, this ‘peculiar’ church structure is one of the conspicuous reflections of the survival of Old Testament culture in Ethiopia. As a challenge to such opinions however, this paper tries to reflect that such particular architectural development can rightly be regarded as an indigenous cultural influence which follows the pattern of traditional sacred places - this only evidently introduced into the church as the church’s mission moved southward after 14th cent - as compared to previous basilica-styled church architecture.
|
The Bible for Liberals: Translation, Rhetoric, and Theo-political Action
Program Unit: Metacriticism of Biblical Scholarship
Bryan Bibb, Furman University
Many Bible products, both translations and study Bibles, are marketed to evangelical Christian audiences. Indeed, the lion’s share of the Bible market represents consumers on the more conservative end of the social and theological spectrum. Bookstore—and virtual—shelves are packed with “Life Application” Bibles, Dispensationalist study Bibles, and hyper-masculinized Bibles for “men of God.” “Liberal” Christians naturally eschew such products, but what do they buy instead? To be sure, there are academic and mainline study Bibles available (HarperCollins, Oxford Annotated, etc.) and generic Bibles that contain only the biblical text in a seemingly neutral translation such as the NRSV. However, there is a niche market for “Liberal Bibles,” an interesting comparative test case for our cultural critique of the Bible in American Life. Overt examples that fit into this category include “The Inclusive Bible” from Priests for Equality, billed as “the first egalitarian translation,” and the “Queen James Bible,” a project that is identical to the KJV except for eight verses retranslated “to prevent homophobic misinterpretation.” One might also include the recent mainline translation, the Common English Bible, marketed as broadly ecumenical and “accessible to a broad range of people.” As the first major translation undertaken by liberal Protestants since the NRSV, the CEB was the first opportunity for progressives to incorporate inclusive and socially-committed scholarship into the actual text of the Bible. One can perceive the influence of liberal scholarship, for example, in the CEB’s translation of 1 Timothy 2:11-15, which undermines the interpretation that ‘Paul’ here prohibits women in the ministry. This paper will analyze translation decisions and paratextual content in various “Liberal Bibles,” considering how ideological perspectives have shaped these projects to make them marketable to liberal consumers, and how they function rhetorically in comparison with conservative texts that do the same on the ‘other side.’ These Bibles serve the more politically-active elements in liberal Christianity, and are harbingers of increasing disagreement about what “the Bible” is, not merely about how it should be interpreted.
|
Pages from Tractate Temura of the Babylonian Talmud, in Secondary Use in a Late Medieval Book Binding
Program Unit: Book History and Biblical Literatures
Noah Bickart, Yale University
Pages from Tractate Temura of the Babylonian Talmud, in Secondary use in a Late Medieval Book Binding
|
Iesus natus Augustus: Mytho-Political Syncretism in the Lukan Birth Narratives
Program Unit: Bible, Myth, and Myth Theory
Mark Bilby, California State University - Fullerton
Richard Miller in his Resurrection and Reception notes numerous parallels between the birth mythology of the divine king in Matthew and that of Plutarch’s Vita Alexandrini: genealogy, a betrothed couple, divine impregnation, the surrogate father’s abstaining from intercourse until the womb is opened, and his concerns about the woman’s fidelity until being reassured in a dream. In this presentation, I will argue that the final redaction of Luke (c. 115-150), relying on Matthew and its syncretic combination of the Vita Alexandrini and the Hellenized Immanual oracle (LXX Isa 7:14), expands and develops the Jesus birth mythology in a new direction inspired by the traditions especially evident in the Divus Augustus of Suetonius, which itself had been pattered after the Vita Alexandrini. The Lukan birth mythology mimics that of Augustus by expanding the virginal conception motif into a full-fledged narrative in which the focus turns to the mother (Atia/Mary) instead of the surrogate father. Both describe the mother’s devotion to the divine father as a traveler, temple visitor, and solitary recipient of an oracular theophany predicting the future greatness of her son. The sum effect is to epitomize Jesus as a demigod king whose divine genealogy not only stems back to David and ultimately to God, but also one who rivals the Greek Alexander and Roman Augustus on an imperial-cultural mytho-political scale.
|
Jews and Jewishness in Medieval Ethiopic Literature: The Case of the Zena Ayhud
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Yonatan Binyam, Coastal Carolina University
This paper analyzes the presentation of Jews and Jewishness in medieval Ethiopic literature, focusing especially on the portrayals of Jews and Judaism in the Zena Ayhud (“The History of the Jews”). The fourteenth-century Zena Ayhud represents the final link in a unique chain of reception history that begins with Josephus in the first century. Toward the close of the fourth century, Josephus’s Jewish War is translated, expanded and reframed through the lens of Christian anti-Jewish rhetoric in the De Excidio Hierosolymitano (or Pseudo-Hegesippus). This latter text in turn is subsequently used as a source by an anonymous Jewish historian who produces a Hebrew version of the story in the tenth century in a text known as Sefer Yosippon. The Hebrew reworking of the De Excidio Hierosolymitano is then adapted by Coptic Christians, who translate the Hebrew Sefer Yosippon into Arabic mostly likely in the twelfth century. The Ethiopic Zena Ayhud represents a close translation of its Arabic Vorlage. In the latter two texts, there is a tendency to mimic biblical language and narratives. The translators of the Arabic/Ethiopic texts work to incorporate the history of the Jewish Revolt against Rome in wider biblical history by weaving it into the context of Christian origins. Moreover, several other Ethiopic texts written around the same time as the Zena Ayhud illustrate that Jewishness is understood very distinctly in medieval Ethiopia, as the flexible uses of the term ayhud that appear in these texts suggest. In this paper, I provide my translations of selected passages from the above-mentioned texts which transmit Josephus’s account. I then discuss the different portrayals of Jews and Jewishness in light of the historical and cultural contexts of the texts in which they appear. In doing so, I hope to contribute to a fuller understanding of the reception of Josephus among medieval European Jews and Orthodox Christians in Egypt and Ethiopia. Moreover, I hope to shed light on the various ways in which Jews and Jewishness are understood in medieval Ethiopian Christianity.
|
Echoes and Allusions to the Jewish Scriptures in Paul's Ethical Discourse in Romans 12:9–21
Program Unit: Scripture and Paul
Michael Bird, Ridley Melbourne
Echoes and Allusions to the Jewish Scriptures in Paul's Ethical Discourse in Romans 12:9-21
|
The Historical Jesus and the Parting of the Ways Revisited
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Michael F. Bird, Ridley College
The Historical Jesus and the Parting of the Ways Revisited
|
Re-reading Samson’s "Weepy Wife" in Judges 14: An Intertextual Evaluation of Gender and Weeping
Program Unit: Intertextuality and the Hebrew Bible
Shelley L. Birdsong, North Central College
Crying has been stereotypically associated with women. It is often deemed a sign of weakness or an overly-dramatic emotional response. As a result of such assumptions, Samson’s first wife, who cries, has been interpreted repeatedly as an excessively sensitive, teary-eyed nag. By putting Samson’s wife into an intertextual dialogue with other characters in the Hebrew Bible who cry (bākāh) and modern research on gender and weeping, it becomes clear that such interpretations are tainted by gender bias and should be rejected. Samson’s wife’s does not cry simply because she’s a sensitive woman. Rather, she is a shrewd strategist, who uses her tears as a calculated measure to save her people from her tyrannical husband. Ultimately, this re-reading of Samson’s first wife will bring awareness to gendered assumptions in the history of biblical interpretation, and in doing so, invite us to reflect on our own preconceived notions of about gender and its relationship to crying.
|
Some Things I Learned from Cowriting a Commentary on Philo's De Abrahamo
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Ellen Birnbaum, Cambridge, MA
After offering a few general observations about working on a commentary on Philo's On the Life of Abraham, I will address some specific issues. These include the question of how Philo presents Abraham as an "unwritten law" and what he (Philo) seems to mean by this concept. Another issue pertains to how within this treatise certain interpretations are dependent on or connected to other interpretations.
|
Ioudaioi Abroad: "Jewish" or "Judean" Migrants?
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Josiah S. Bisbee, Brown University
Controversy has surrounded the translation of Ἰουδαῖος for quite some time. Sparked in part by apparent anti-semitism in the Gospel of John, scholars observe that certain passages appear to paint “the Jews” (’Ιουδαῖοι) as Jesus’ enemies; such as John 8:44, which seems to equate “the Jews” with the devil. Some attribute such anti semitism in John to the “parting of the ways” between Judaism and Christianity. Others attempt to remedy the issue by rendering ’Ιουδαῖος as “Judean,” but this has only led to accusations of scholars “erasing Jews” from ancient texts. Apart from all the heated debate, this issue has surfaced a number of exegetical problems in John. For instance, “Judean” makes sense in contexts where ’Ιουδαῖος appears in close proximity to Ἰουδαίᾳ (Judea). Consider John 7:1, where Jesus remains in Galilee, instead of going to Judea (Ἰουδαίᾳ), for “fear of the Ἰουδαῖοι.” And yet, most scholars reject “Judean” in contexts where ’Ιουδαῖοι are described as residing abroad – the basic argument being that Judeans who do not live in Judea are not Judeans. But this argument fails to consider that Judeans may have simply migrated to Galilee and maintained an ethnic identity, as well as customs, indicative of their regional origin. By drawing attention to specific archeological data—namely, the manufacture and distribution of stew-pots, pans, stone vessels, and knife pared lamps—this paper will, first, present evidence for the existence of different regional customs in the first century CE. As will be demonstrated, the physical evidence — such as Judean pottery in Galilee, etc.— also indicates that Judeans migrated North. Afterward, both John 2.6 and Revelation 2.9 and 3.9 will be interpreted in light of this information, while drawing attention to other textual data, ultimately arguing that Ἰουδαῖος as “Judean” makes historical sense, even in contexts where Ἰουδαῖοι are described as residing abroad.
|
Lot (Be)gets What He Deserves: Lesser Descendants for a Lesser Man in Genesis 18-19
Program Unit: Genesis
Benjamin Bixler, Drew Theological School
This essay will explore the intertwined power dynamics embedded in the story of Lot and his daughters in Genesis 19:30-38, to pursue what Katharina von Kellenbach calls “a deeper power analysis” of the text. The story deals with issues of power and violence as the narrator dehumanizes a people group using sexual innuendo to create an ethnic identity. In addition to these rhetorical strategies, the narrator also uses gender identity to question Lot’s masculinity in order to further advance the polemical argument against Israel’s enemies. According to the logic of the text, Lot (be)gets what he deserves – a lesser people as his descendants because he is a lesser man. This paper argues that the narrator disinherits Lot from the promise of Abraham by creating an ethnic identity for the people of Moab and Ammon based on the sexual innuendo of incest, and additionally questions the gender identity of Lot to intensify the difference between Abraham and Lot’s descendants.
In reading the narratives of Genesis as a product of those returning from Persian exile and linking the theology of the narrator with that of Ezra-Nehemiah (seen most clearly in the mixed marriage crisis in Ezra 9-10), the motivations of the narrator becomes clear. Relying on the work of Randall Bailey (“They’re Nothing But Incestuous Bastards”) and Danna Nolan Fewell (Imagination, Method, and Murder: UnFraming the Face of Post-Exilic Israel), I will show the sexual innuendo and ethnic construction that distances the descendants of Lot from the descendants of Abraham, despite their close familial connections. In this way, the narrator successfully ‘others’ the people of the land and justifies the returners’ possession of the land.
Lastly, I will show that the narrator uses a more implicit rhetorical strategy as well, that of questioning Lot’s masculinity. I will examine Lot through the lens of Susan Haddox’s four characteristics of hegemonic masculinity in the Hebrew Bible: “Don’t be seen as feminine,” “displaying sexual potency,” “maintaining one’s honor,” and “wisdom and persuasiveness.” Through a close reading of the text of Genesis 18 and 19, it becomes clear that Lot does not possess these hegemonic attributes in the way that Abraham does, and instead possesses subordinate masculinities, even taking on feminine roles. Particularly in the scene in the cave with his daughters in 19:30-38 (Lot’s final scene in the narrative of Genesis) Lot is shown to be a man deserving of all that has been given to him in the text.
Thus, Lot fails to live up to the ideals required of him to be a real man. The narrator questions Lot’s masculinity to show that he is not worthy of receiving the promise alongside Abraham, writing Lot out of the text along the way. Thus, the passage of v. 30-38 functions as the culmination of the emasculation of Lot, and lays the groundwork for polemical writings against the nations of Moab and Ammon that will continue in the Hebrew Bible.
|
Jubilance across the Ancient Near East
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Oeyvind Bjoeru, University of Texas at Austin
A vexing question in the discussion surrounding the biblical Jubilee legislation is the relation it bears to other Near Eastern practices that are somewhat similar in social or economic function, or are denoted by etymologically related terminology. Opinions are divided on whether the andurārum/mīšarum and the yôḇel/šmîṭṭā are historically related phenomena, convergent distillations of socio-economic and religio-cultural concerns, or disconnected and quite disparate customs with only superficial and piebald semblance to each other.
Since the first substantial comparisons were made between the biblical Jubilee and fallow land practices ordained in the Hebrew Bible, and the proclamations or mentions of debt, slave, and land releases in Mesopotamia and Anatolia (Lemche 1979, Weinfeld 1995), new evidence has come to light. I will adduce evidence for andurārum practiced in the Middle Babylonian period in the kingdom of Ḫana, bridging the considerable gap between the Old Babylonian (early 2nd millennium BCE) and Neo-Assyrian (early 1st millennium) societies plaguing earlier attempts to compare practices.
The Ḫana texts will serve as a basis for a reassessment of how mechanisms for social justice and economic readjustment in Mesopotamia and its environs can be brought to bear on the biblical Jubilee legislation, specifically the relevant passages in the Holiness Code, i.e. Leviticus 25 and 27. I claim that despite some fundamental structural differences between the Mesopotamian proclamations and the biblical legislation, the same conceptual distinctions regarding property rights and claims are operative within both institutions suggesting significant confluence, if not influence, or even shared origins.
|
Between Paradise and Exile: Migrations around Lamentation, Expectation and iLand in the Caribbean Bible
Program Unit: Islands, Islanders, and Scriptures
Fiona C. Black, Mount Allison University
This paper looks at the idea of land as both personal (iLand) and as collective object of desire in public and national discourses in the Bahamas. These ideas are framed against the lament for the land in Ps. 137, where the speaker is overcome with grief for Zion and can no longer play his harp and sing. For this purpose, I consider Sara Ahmed’s work on happiness, particularly with respect to the melancholic migrant, and Ann Cvetkovich’s thinking about depression as a global response to dispossession and dispossession. Indeed, what does it mean for biblical thinkers to own or identify with the land, and how does this translate to a biblically literate society in the Bahamian postcolony? A range of Bahamian contexts are explored with respect to these themes, such as political discourse around the time of independence (1973), public celebrations around Majority Rule and Independence Day, and contemporary artistic work that explores the idea of iLand.
|
Over-Writing the Minor: García-Valiño’s Urías y el Rey David:
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Chloe Blackshear , University of Chicago
Ignacio García-Valiño’s 1997 novel, Urías y el Rey David (Uriah and King David) reads, in many ways, as a quintessential historical novel of the near-popular, not-too-literary variety. Readers get to witness some really pleasing gap-filling, as they learn of Uriah the Hittite’s kidnapping by a band of roving thieves, his eventual emigration to Jerusalem as a religious and cultural outsider, and his love story with the gentle Bathsheba, whom he meets in a bakery. But this back-story is unusual. As a biblical novel, Urías y el rey David stands out as a text which grants a remarkably complete perspective to a minor, marginalized character. Uriah is the protagonist of a new story, with a poignantly depicted history and inner life all his own. Though his story intersects with David’s (in fact, as a member of David’s military, Uriah is tasked with recording David’s actions and contributing, it seems, to the biblical account), the novel reflects the life of the ruler first only as circumscribed by the much richer, more detailed life of the foreigner. In this way, the novel provides an example of a kind of biblical retelling which would truly grant agency and humanity, not just to a minor character, but to a non-Israelite, and which would draw attention to the others that populate the biblical account as well to those others who might read it with a different view.
Yet García-Valiño’s novel undermines the reader’s complacency. A shift in perspective does not solve the problem of the Bible’s violence, or its dominance. As this paper will argue, the richness of Uriah’s story serves only to mark more dramatically the insidious way in which a canon, a historiography—of a king, or, it is implied, of a Spanish dictator-- systematically shuts out the other in its midst. For as the novel progresses, David begins to bowdlerize Uriah’s account and encroach threateningly upon his personal life; the novel’s tragic weight is focused through the subtle, gradual narratological infiltration and final annihilation of Urías’s story by David’s. On the one hand, the novel’s ultimately anti-fascist critique of history-writing seems to join other late twentieth-century Spanish fiction in seeking new kinds of anti-totalitarian historiography. By marking the weight of the Bible’s centralizing, alienating authority, moreover, García-Valiño’s novel mobilizes 1 and 2 Samuel to provide a thematic and narratological model for re-examining the relationship between the politically and narratively marginal and those their presence (and subsequent absence) helps maintain in the center.
|
Justification and Resurrection Life in Galatians
Program Unit: Pauline Theology
Ben C. Blackwell, Houston Baptist University
Rather than Jesus’ teaching, miracles, or stories, it is the death and resurrection of Jesus that captures Paul’s faith and creates the foundation for Paul’s symbolic world. This central theme of Jesus’ death and resurrection forms his basic narrative of the gospel (e.g., 1 Cor 15:1–4) and also informs his theological perspective on the life of ministry and discipleship (e.g., 2 Cor 4:6–18; Rom 6:1-12). Given Paul’s foundational interest in Christ’s death and his resurrection, it should likely strike the reader of Galatians that no explicit use of traditional resurrection language is evident in the letter after Gal 1:1. In contrast to other letters that situate the present experience of life in terms of the hope of future resurrection, Paul appears to consistently use the terminology of “life” (often in the context of death or crucifixion), to focus only on the present experience of life. With the advent of the so-called “apocalyptic” reading of the letter, this seeming lack of eschatological tension is given a pass. Is there a place for a more substantive role for resurrection within Galatians?
In this essay I argue that Christ’s own resurrection life is communicated to believers in justification through the life-giving presence of the Spirit. In contrast to those who argue that justification is a legal status or status among the community, as believers participate in Christ, they are justified, which entails that they share in Christ’s life. Therefore, the letter addresses the present experience of life in the heart of letter by means of justification, and when Paul speaks of the “hope of righteousness,” this is a direct reference to the future embodied resurrection. The fact that justification and giving life are mutually constitutive is most evident when Paul writes: “If a Law had been given which could make alive, then righteousness would indeed be by the Law” (3.21). But several points of evidence strongly support this thesis. 1) Paul’s direct establishment of participating in the death and life of Christ central to justification. 2) The use of standard covenantal terms of “blessing” and “cursing” in terms of life and death to contextualize Paul’s justification argument. 3) The identification of the promised inheritance with justification. In this way, the hope of inheritance and of righteousness as the hope of resurrection life does establish that eschatological tension that is so evident in other letters.
|
The Self-Support and Sustenance of Paul the skēnopoios
Program Unit: The Historical Paul
Thomas R. Blanton IV, Lutheran School of Theology at Chicago
The paper will evaluate the data from inscriptions, texts, and Diocletian’s Price Edict relevant to understanding Paul’s sometime profession as a skēnopoios, as Acts 18:3 would have it. As a skēnopoios (Lat. tabernacularius), Paul may have made tents or awnings out of leather or linen. The paper will survey information on antique guilds (collegia) of tabernacularii, leatherworkers, and linenworkers, and such material as can be found on the wages, prices, and expenses (including food and drink) associated with these professions to provide a window onto Paul’s mode of sustenance as a “tentmaker.”
|
"We Are Not Drunk as You Suppose": Situating the Mistaken Intoxication in Acts 2 within Greco-Roman Religious and Philosophical Contexts
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Ward Blanton, University of Kent at Canterbury
This paper argues that we have not yet taken sufficient account of the comparative and competitive role of discourses of intoxication in Acts’ construction of the early Christian movement. To make its case, the paper will provide a map of the comparative significance of the levels and types of intoxication which distinguish in turn philosophical schools, ethnicity as a type of symposium practice, and respective geographical locales of a given cult in Greco-Roman contexts. Everywhere, characteristic levels and types of intoxication function to indicate the superiority of this or that group, practice, or event. This comparative map will flag up in turn the various modes in which a rational insight or divine activity is often mistaken in this literature as a phenomenon to be explained by other means (in this case as an effect of too much wine). Such mistakes (on the part of outsiders) function as a key indication (to the insiders) of the superiority of their school or cult. As we will see, in this literature the mistaking of quality or quantity in the intoxicating experience of the other becomes a key indication for what renders these outsiders genuinely foreign and unworthy.
Having established its comparative map of mistaken intoxications and having shown how these tropes function in Acts, the paper will conclude by showing how the case of early Christianity more generally provides very important contributions to ongoing research about characteristic intoxications in the formation of ancient religious and philosophical identities (e.g., Epicurus’s Pharmacy by Diego Fusaro; Pharmakon: Plato, Drug Culture, and Identity in Ancient Athens by Michael Rinella).
|
Linking Past and Present through the Material World: History in Genesis
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Elizabeth Bloch-Smith, Princeton Theological Seminary
Genesis narratives and an etiology that refer to settlements and stone markers are commonly studied from a literary perspective. Geographical and archaeological perspectives raise questions regarding the historical roles of these locations and objects. How did Israelites employ the material world to link past and present – to validate, transmit, and selectively memorialize their history? Do mentions of physical manifestations indicate an historical witness, or might they have been late literary fabrications, preserved traditions, or a combination of these?
|
The Souls of Biblical Folks and the Potential for Meaning
Program Unit:
Brian Blount, Union Presbyterian Seminary
The Souls of Biblical Folks and the Potential for Meaning
|
The New Testament Text of Didymus the Blind: A Reconsideration of The Tura Papyri and their Text-Critical Value
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Lincoln H. Blumell, Brigham Young University
In 1941 while searching for a munition's bunker, Allied forces stationed in Cairo discovered a large cache of Byzantine papyri in the cave systems of Tura (south of Cairo). Among the cache, which included thousands of sheets of papyrus, were lost works of Origen and Didymus the Blind. Beginning in the late 1960s and early 1970s, Didymus's Tura commentaries (Genesis, Job, Psalms, Ecclesiastes, and Zechariah) began to be published and not long afterwards text critics began quarrying Didymus's commentaries to assess what they might reveal about the Alexandrian New Testament text. Based on my own work editing a long-lost quire of Didymus's Tura Psalm Commentary that was acquired by Brigham Young University (quire 8 comprising Pss 26:10-29:3), I have determined that many of the text-critical conclusions derived from Didymus's Tura commentaries and espoused by text critics are in need of serious revision. Most notably, every text-critical study of Didymus has failed to recognize that some of his "commentaries" are actually classroom lectures recorded by stenographers and that many of his "variants" are not textual variants, but rather resulted from the oral context of his lectures. This paper therefore seeks to properly situate and contextualize Didymus's Tura materials and to reconsider their text-critical value for the New Testament.
|
From Mark to Mark to Mark: Continuity and Discontinuity in the Narrative History of Mark’s Gospel
Program Unit: Westar Institute
Charles Bobertz, Saint John's University
*
|
The Jerusalem Citadel (Bîrâ) in the Time of Nehemiah: Textual, Linguistic Evidence and Persian Military Strategy
Program Unit: Literature and History of the Persian Period
Daniel Bodi, La Sorbonne - University of Paris 4
Starting from an analysis of a series of linguistic information from the so-called Nehemiah Memoir (the word byrh “citadel” in Neh 2:8 hab-bîrâ ʾašer-labbayit “the citadel which is next to the Temple,” and 7:2 Hanani the “commander (in charge) of the citadel” śr hbyrh; Neh 3:9 “House/Garrison of the Mighty Men” byt hgbrym; Neh 11:41 “pāqîd officer/overseer who commands a troop of 128 “mighty men” gbwry ḥyl), and comparing it with what is known of Persian territorial administration, it becomes plausible to view Nehemiah’s Jerusalem as an attempt to rebuild a citadel or a fortified military installation together with city walls of a relatively modest size. The circumference of the citadel together with the ramparts would not have exceeded 3000 meters, or less than 2 miles. The Jerusalem citadel could have been used as a refuge in case of a retreat of the Persian forces in the course of a military campaign. The authorization given to Nehemiah to rebuild part of Jerusalem with a citadel would reflect the political opportunism of the Persians. A well-known aspect of the Persian military strategy in the internal organization of their immense empire was administering the territory through citadels. In their numerous wars, it was one of their main strategies to conquer, occupy and manage the citadels with their own garrisons. By placing the discussion in a historical and comparative perspective, one discovers that the strategy of controlling the territory through citadels Heb. bîrâ, LXX bāris, was not invented by the Persians themselves. It was already in use by their predecessors the Assyrians and is attested in the Northwest Semitic domain since OB times as reflected in Mari texts. My proposal to see Nehemiah’s official mission as being mostly a reconstruction of the citadel with limited city ramparts may be supported by linguistic data found in Nehemiah and only indirectly by archaeology. For the Persian times, the archaeological findings concerning Jerusalem are either non-existent or meager. This leads the archaeologists to assume that Jerusalem was no more than a Temple-village, or that the city was very small, limited to the eastern ridge, (the so called “minimalist view”). The only distance indicated in Neh 3:13 between the Valley and Dung Gates is 1000 cubits or 500 meters describing a repaired section of the wall. When comparing these points with the “minimalist plan” of Jerusalem as advocated by M. Avi-Yonah, G. J. Wightman, and Kenneth A. Ristau, one can make a rough estimation of 3000 meters as the total circumference of the Jerusalem ramparts in the time of Nehemiah.
|
Amorite Names with Scurrilous Etymologies in Mari Texts and Some Biblical Examples: King Snake-Nāḥāš, Queen Mother-Neḥuštāʾ, Nebukadnezzar/Nabukadrezzar and Midrashic Names in Gen 14
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Daniel Bodi, La Sorbonne - University of Paris
In the first part the paper analyzes some Amorite names with scurrilous etymologies found in Old Babylonian Mari texts and showing that the practice of disobliging word-plays, shaming sobriquets and “scurrilous etymologies” with which enemy chieftains and warlords are tagged is well-attested in the Northwest Semitic domain (Simaḫ-ilānē ARM 10 5; and ARM 26, no 168 [A.143], ll. 6-7 where a nickname is used to designate the enemy, a Benjaminite warlord). In the second part, the papers analyzes the names of the King Snake-Nāḥāš in 1 Sam 11:1, of the queen mother Neḥuštāʾ in 1 Kgs 24:8, the wordplay Nebukadnezzar/Nabukadrezzar and the midrashic names in Gen 14. It shows how the ancient Hebrews shared this practice with the earlier Amorite semi-nomadic tribes.
In dealing with biblical evidence, however, one must take into account redactional aspects. The name Nāḥāš of the Ammonite king in 1 Sam. 11:1, meaning “Snake” should probably be seen as an example of the so-called “scurrilous etymologies.” Furthermore from a redactional point of view, the connection with the name of the mother of Jehoiachin, one of the last kings of Jerusalem who went into Babylonian Exile together with the queen mother Nehushta in 2 Kgs 24:8, is seen as being theologically significant. The “Lady Serpent” Neḥuštāʾ was associated with the practice of the Asherah cult in the Jerusalem Temple, a goddess who had snakes as her emblem. The official investiture of the tribal chieftain Saul begins with his victory over the King “Snake” Nāḥāš who intended to cripple the Transjordanian Hebrew tribes from Jabesh-Gilead, inflict on them a religio-cultic impairment, precluding them from participating in Yhwh worship. The end of the kingship in Judah is likewise associated with the defeat and expulsion of the ruler’s family that crippled and impaired proper Yhwh worship in Jerusalem. The scurrilous “snake” name would probably be the work of one of the redactors of the Deuteronomistic historiography who thus provided a form of an inclusio.
|
From Tyrian Outpost to Hellenistic Polis? New Research on Achaemenid and Hellenistic Ashkelon
Program Unit: Literature and History of the Persian Period
Ryan Boehm, Tulane University
Recent research on the Persian and Hellenistic levels excavated at Ashkelon has shed new light on the nature of the Phoenician reoccupation of the site after the destruction of the Philistine city in 604 BCE and the subsequent growth and development of the settlement in the following centuries. This paper examines the urban form and economic life of the Persian-period settlement. It argues that the site is best conceptualized as a Tyrian emporion whose fortunes were closely connected to the network of Tyrian and Sidonian outposts along the southern Levantine coast and the relationship of this network to Achaemenid imperial policies. It then examines the question of the transition between the Persian and Hellenistic periods and the impact of new political frameworks on the development of the site. It is not until the late Hellenistic period that the site expanded dramatically and the hinterland was more intensively exploited. It is only at this point that Ashkelon appears to have transformed from a small-scale commercial settlement to a true Hellenistic polis.
|
The Cultural Biography of a Pilgrimage Token: From Hagiographical to Archaeological Evidence
Program Unit: Society for Ancient Mediterranean Religions
Dina Boero , The College of New Jersey
At the late antique pilgrimage sites of both Symeon the Stylite the Elder (c. 390-459) at Qal‘at Sem‘an, located approximately sixty kilometers northeast of Antioch, and of Symeon the Stylite the Younger (521-592) upon the Wondrous Mountain, located approximately sixteen kilometers southwest of Antioch, attendants distributed small, terracotta tokens stamped with images of stylites, scenes drawn from the life of Christ, and related imagery. Scholars frequently categorize these objects as “pilgrimage art.” They employ hagiographies to highlight the application of tokens in situations calling for healing, protection, and punishment. Although literary sources offer valuable representations of ritual processes, at times they also obscure the tangible remains of human activity, as Moser and Knust point out. Material remains “complement the testimony of the literary and the figural, offering a counterbalance to the literate, elite, and conceptual perspective that has so often been privileged in the study of antiquity, and even in religion more generally” (p. 3). In the particular case of tokens distributed at the cult sites of stylites, hagiographies make claims on the proper distribution, meaning, and use of tokens amidst a diversity of intercessory activities taking place at and away from the site. How, in practice, was a token produced and distributed? How did pilgrims use tokens at pilgrimage complexes beyond the claims made by hagiographies? How did individuals employ tokens away from pilgrimage complexes?
Following the methodological approach of Arjun Appadurai and Igor Kopytoff, this paper answers these questions by tracing the cultural biography of a token. A cultural biography sheds light on the range of possible categorizations for an object in a given society as well as the course by which they are re-contextualized within and between societies. Rather than prioritize literary evidence, this paper analyzes the archaeological contexts for tokens excavated at Qal‘at Sem‘an and elsewhere in the Mediterranean, including Deir Seta and Dehes in Syria, Beit She’an in Israel, and Bobbio in Italy. By examining the functional settings in which individuals and communities employed tokens, this paper clarifies select statuses which a token might occupy during its lifetime, such as commodity, gift, medicinal object, luxury object, relic, and rubbish. The consideration of a token’s functional settings and shifts in status makes it possible to interpret the human calculations that enliven both the object itself and the culturally constituted categories in which that object functioned. This approach lays the foundation for examining literary claims regarding the use of tokens as one among many assertions in the uneasy process of harnessing the power of saints. More broadly, it illuminates the multiplicity of pilgrimage experiences and contestation in relation to ritual processes.
|
An Introduction to 3 Apocryphal Apocalypse of John
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Chance Bonar, Harvard University
This paper will serve as an introduction to 3 Apocryphal Apocalypse of John (3 Ap. Apoc. John; BHG 922k), which is being edited and translated for the first time as part of the More New Testament Apocrypha series. Itself titled an "Apocalypse of holy John the Theologian," 3 Ap. Apoc. John is a revelation dialogue between John the Theologian and Abraham that focuses primarily on the fate of the soul and the realities of the afterlife. While this apocalypse of John might stand out from other revelation dialogues for having Abraham as John's divine interlocutor rather than Jesus, the structure of the dialogue and citation of Scripture make 3 Ap. Apoc. John at home among others in this broad genre. In this paper, I will discuss the extant manuscripts of 3 Ap. Apoc. John and the limitations of dating the "original" text. Following that, I will give brief analysis of some of the contents of 3 Ap. Apoc. John and consider its literary and theological importance, especially in relation early Christian apocalypses and broader late ancient discussions regarding the afterlife, resurrection, and conceptions of figures like Jesus, Mary, and Adam.
|
What Are the Gospels? And Why Does It Matter?
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Helen K. Bond, University of Edinburgh
In this paper, I seek first to contextualize the bios discussion within the larger debate over gospel genre, paying particular attention to the contribution of Richard Burridge’s What Are the Gospels? Next I ask what difference it makes to say that a particular work is an ancient biography. Drawing examples from Mark’s Gospel, I suggest that an appreciation of genre has implications for a number of features, including topical structure, episodic narrative, characterization (both of Jesus and secondary characters), and the relation between the hero’s teaching and his death. Mark’s work, I suggest, is an innovative reception of prior Jesus tradition, transforming a loose mass of unformed material into a historicized narrative reflecting the broader Graeco-Roman biographical tradition.
|
The Pilgrim's Progress: Digitally Mapping Travel and the Early Christian Calendar
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Sarah Bond, University of Iowa
The emperor Justinian set Candlemas within the city of Constantinople and elsewhere in the East for February 2 in the mid-sixth century. However, the earlier pilgrim text of the Itinerarium Egeriae noted the likely celebration of Candlemas on February 14 and the flocking of people to Jerusalem to join the solemn procession and services there. As Egeria and many others exemplify, travel in the early Christian Mediterranean must be understood not only in terms of space but also in terms of the liturgical calendar-which could often differ from place to place. This paper explores how travel was encouraged or discouraged through changes to the festival calendars in the fourth through sixth centuries CE, and the possibly effects on travel that derive from the institution of new festivals that encouraged it. It also proposes that digital humanities approaches such as GIS tools now allow us to analyze and compare periods of high and low travel within the early Christian Calendar and then visualize it spatially. Through digital methods, we can better understand travel as an integral part of the circular cosmos constructed first by the Roman fasti and then by the early Christian calendar. This calendar served to interconnect religion, people, and places through the organization of time.
|
The Festival of Dionysus and Saturnalia in Jewish Responses to Greek and Roman Rule
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Catherine E. Bonesho, University of California-Los Angeles
The importance of calendars and holidays in Judaism of the Greco-Roman period has been extensively studied with particular attention paid to the use of different calendrical systems by different communities, including the calendars of the Qumran community, the use of the Seleucid calendar in Jerusalem, and the development of the rabbinic calendar. Instead of concentrating on entire calendars, in this paper, I analyze ancient Jewish literary descriptions of individual foreign holidays from the Hellenistic kingdom and Roman empire to determine if the differences between their descriptions and rhetoric can illuminate Jewish attitudes towards these foreign rulers. I concentrate on 2 Macc 6:6-7 and its assertion that Jews were forced to celebrate the Greek festival of Dionysus, as well as y. Abodah Zarah 1:2, 39c and its proposed etymology for the Roman festival of Saturnalia. In 2 Macc 6:6-7, the idolatrous nature of the festival of Dionysus, with its worship of a Greek god, is emphasized as well as the fact that Jews were forced to celebrate the festival. On the other hand, y. Abodah Zarah 1:2, 39c, instead of describing the idolatry of Saturnalia, provides an etymology for Saturnalia that emphasizes hatred, specifically Esau's hatred for his brother Jacob, and the association of this hatred with the Roman governmental body of the senate. Though their literary contexts are quite distinct, both the description of the festival of Dionysus as well as the rabbinic etymology for Saturnalia emphasize the negative qualities of either the foreign holiday itself or its celebrants and stresses the distinction between Greek and Roman observance from proper Jewish observance. However, the details of these depictions differ: in 2 Macc the concern for idolatry is evident unlike the rabbinic etymology for Saturnalia, which through some elaborate exegetical work, connects Saturnalia to Esau instead of the idolatrous worship of Saturn. Furthermore, the negative rhetoric against foreign rulers, in this case the Roman empire, is more pronounced in the rabbinic etymology for Saturnalia than in 2 Macc, with the rabbis explicitly connecting the hatred of Saturnalia to the Roman senate. Therefore, through the lens of the festival of Dionysus and Saturnalia, one can distinguish in some way between the Jewish responses to Greek and Roman rule, with the latter receiving more of a negative political and rhetorical response, possibly due to the Jewish-Roman Wars and the destruction of the Second Temple in Jerusalem by the Romans.
|
Metaphors and Idolatry: Negotiating the First Commandment in the Psalms
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Ryan Bonfiglio, Emory University / First Presbyterian Church of Atlanta
In the Preface to his Larger Catechism, Martin Luther offers the following generalization about the relationship between the Decalogue and the Psalms: “[W]hat is the whole Psalter but meditation and exercises based on the First Commandment?” Luther’s claim is a provocative one since explicit references to “other gods” and “idols” are relatively uncommon in the Psalter, as is language about worshipping “God alone/only.” Nevertheless, when viewed from the perspective of metaphors and metaphor theory Luther’s claim holds true. The purpose of this paper is to explore how one of the principle divine metaphors in the Psalms—GOD IS REFUGE—can be understood as a form of commentary on the first commandment. At a theological level, this metaphor and its various instantiations (rock, fortress, shield, stronghold, etc.) present a conceptual alternative to the ephemeral and non-weighty quality of idols. In this manner, the GOD IS REFUGE metaphor participates in and extends, albeit more implicitly, the rhetorical discourse expressed through the idol parody in Ps 155:4-8 (cf. Ps 135:15-18). This paper also explores how, from the perspective of metaphor theory, the deployment of the GOD IS REFUGE metaphor in the Psalms attempts to subvert the various ways in which language about God itself can, through overuse and lexicalization, become a type of linguistic idol.
|
Symbolism 2.0: Reflections on Keel’s Approach 45 Years Later
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Ryan P. Bonfiglio, Emory University / First Presbyterian Church of Atlanta
When Othmar Keels' Symbolism of the Biblical World first appeared in 1972, it represented the first systematic attempt to compare the conceptual world of a biblical book (the Psalms) with ancient Near Eastern art. Since that time, efforts to integrate visual evidence into the study of the Old Testament have undergone considerable advancement, especially in the areas of methodology and underlying theories about art and visual culture. The purpose of this paper is to assess the trajectory of these advancements and how they might reframe Keel’s project were it to be recreated today. In doing so, this paper not only highlights the enduring contributions of Keel’s pioneering work, but it also offers the broad contours for what would be a Symbolism 2.0—an approach to systematically studying the Old Testament through the lens of ANE iconography that is informed by 45 years of developments in iconographic exegesis.
|
Pure Stale Water: Reflections on the Materiality of Stepped Pools
Program Unit: Cognitive Science Approaches to the Biblical World
Rick Bonnie, University of Helsinki
Stepped pools, those physical structures found so regularly in the archaeology of late Second Temple-period Palestine, are conventionally viewed as a prop, things that do little more than enable the socio-ritual process of purification. Quintessentially, the physical structure of the stepped pool itself becomes inserted into a pre-existing socio-religious grid. However, as shown by recent research on the material world in areas such as archaeology, cognitive sciences, cultural anthropology and technology studies, socio-ritual ideas, concepts and strategies did not already exist before being materialised into symbols and structures - instead, they often were facilitated by them.
In this paper, I argue that the rite of immersion for Jewish ritual purification during the late Second Temple period did not take precedence, but was helped into becoming by the materiality of stepped pools. In the quest of how Jewish ritual purification is being understood the bodily and sensory relationship of those who use it with these built water installations is of primary significance. This material-centred perspective also places the emphasis on the local, situational, and individual dimensions of religious practices, by which it moves away from notions of homogenous belief and ritual behaviour.
The paper discusses some of the particular sensory and material qualities that have not often been discussed in reference to stepped pools but which may have played a role in how Jews experienced and used these structures. Since these stepped pools and the surrounding built environment influenced both the movements of 'water' and 'people,' I will use those particular angles to guide my analysis. I will delve, for instance, into the question of how pungent and dirty did the standing water that was collected during rainy seasons in the stepped pools eventually become? And why, in fact, did this matter, as the workings of stepped pools essentially made the required "living water" to become stale, mute and lifeless. Furthermore, following the ground-breaking work by Lakoff and Johnson (Metaphors We Live By [Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2003]) on how conceptual systems are grounded in experiences of the world, I will look into how the physicality of stepped pools or other sources of purification may have shaped the conceptual language of these practices as used in contemporary and later written sources, like Josephus and the rabbinic literature.
|
Exodus: An Investigation of Vocabulary and Concepts from Ancient Greek Literature to Early Christian Writings
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Eberhard Bons, Université de Strasbourg
The aim of this panel is to study the terminology used to speak of the
Exodus and the concepts conveyed by the various terms and
expressions. In particular, the following issues will be addressed:
1. Why is the Exodus of the Israelites leaving Egypt called “Exodus”?
2. Can the history of this noun in Greek language explain this choice?
3. To what degree did the choice of this noun influence the reception
of the idea of Exodus?
|
Mark as Sound
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Thomas Boomershine, United Theological Seminary
Markan scholarship has had a central role in the current debate about orality and literacy in the composition, reception, and distribution of the New Testament in its original historical context. In the midst of the ongoing search for greater clarity about the communication cultures of the ancient world, there is an emerging agreement that Mark was composed and distributed as a composition of sound performed for audiences either by storytellers or lectors. How then do we build a research community on the study of the sound of Mark?
The problem is that there is a fundamental discontinuity between the predominantly visual sensory system of contemporary study of Mark and the predominantly auditory sensory system of the biblical world. A dimension of that discontinuity is the difference between the auditory and visual sensory systems of the human brain. When Markan scholarship is evaluated in this context, the implication is that Markan scholarship has been based on a systemic misperception of Mark as a text read by readers rather than as a composition of sound performed for audiences.
A case study of the puzzle of the ending of Mark at 16:8 based on the analysis and mapping of the sounds of the story reveals a concentration of highly sophisticated techniques of sound composition. Mark 16:8 makes sense as the intended ending of the Gospel when it is experienced as a composition of sound rather as a text of visual signs. The implication is that sound mapping and oral performance are essential elements of a coherent methodology for the study of Mark as sound.
|
Paul among the Physicians: 1 Tim 2:15 and Salvation in a Context of Contested Health Claims
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Adam Booth, Duke University
1 Tim 2:15 claims that women will be saved through childbearing. The language used to speak of salvation has a more basic meaning of physical health. This paper investigates how medical opinion contemporary to the letter would have evaluated the claim that childbearing is salubrious and shows that that question was contested. Answers to this question were not offered in vacuo, but were formed in connection with a system of beliefs (more or less coherent from our standpoint) about what it means for a body to be a woman’s, to (mal)function as a woman’s and to be healed as a woman’s. The constructions of gender and embodiment which Galen, building on certain Aristotelian and Hippocratic texts, would use to affirm the health-bringing function of childbearing, and which Soranus would use to deny this, will be examined, and compared with contemporary ‘lay’ assessments of the same question. Finally, the paper asks how an early auditor of the letter who held to one or other of these gynecological viewpoints might have heard the Pastor’s claims. Are the Pastor’s hearers being called to see salvation as intimately connected with bodily forms of life for women socially valorized as “healthy” or to see salvation as entangled with bodily danger? I argue that the early Wirkungsgeschichte of this text may well have included both of these receptions.
|
Finding Jesus in the Sibylline Oracles: Textual Revelation and the Limitless Fountain of Meaning
Program Unit: Prophetic Texts and Their Ancient Contexts
Francis Borchardt, Lutheran Theological Seminary, Hong Kong
According to various Early Christian apologetic sources, the Sibylline Oracles are a rich locus of prophetic revelation about Jesus. It is claimed that these non-Christian oracular texts are nonetheless authentic divine communication. Among the Early Christian apologetic texts the veracity of of these Oracles is asserted through the apparent success of their applicability to events past, present, and future. This points to a broader trend we can observe as revelation moves from oral performance to text: the original performers of revelation loss of agency in the interpretation of revelation. This leads to two separate but related conclusions: 1) textualized revelation relies on the authority of later performers to both shape the meaning and assert the relevance of the revelation, and 2) later performers and performances can continually assert and win acceptance for new meanings in the revelation. This paper will discuss how this process of constant reassertion of meaning and significance works within Early Christian apologetic literature discussing the Sibylline Oracles.
|
The Twelve Prophets as Literary Characters
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
James M. Bos, University of Mississippi
Jonah, son of Amittai, makes a brief cameo in 2 Kings 14:25. From this single reference, a later scribe would spin a fascinating story of this prophet’s activity, a story that most contemporary critical readers identify as fictional. This paper asks whether other prophetic books, despite significant generic differences from the narrative of Jonah, might not have their origins explained similarly—prophetic characters chosen from earlier written or oral tradition as protagonists for a book composed at a later time—even though the preserved Israelite and Judahite literature contains no explicit references to them (with the exception of Micah in Jeremiah 26). Thus, while prophets named Hosea, Amos, Micah, etc., may have existed historically, in the books attributed to them, they are literary characters shaped by later scribes for a later readership. The paper concludes by examining some key features of their characterization.
|
Slavery and Infanticide: The Abandonment of Moses and Ishmael
Program Unit: Slavery, Resistance, and Freedom
David Bosworth, The Catholic University of America
The Hebrew Bible includes two stories of infant abandonment, both involving slave women. Under harsh slavery, Jochebed abandons her son, later called Moses. Hagar, a maidservant, abandons her infant Ishmael after she is herself cast out of Abraham's household with almost no provisions. The texts present both women as reluctant to part with their babies, but constrained by circumstances imposed on them by others. Research on infanticide among slaves in the United States and the Caribbean indicates that infanticide was sometimes practiced by slave women for various motives. The case of Margaret Garner was made famous by Toni Morrisons's novel Beloved. Garner (like Sethe in the novel) killed her daughter in order to prevent her recapture and return to slavery. Other slaves similarly killed their children as acts of resistance or altruism toward their children. The paper will draw on modern scientific research on infanticide and parental investment and how decisions about whether and how to raise a child are shaped in part by maternal circumstances and the presence or absence of social support (e.g., Sarah Blaffer Hrdy, Mother Nature; Melvin Konnor, Evolution of Childhood; Lita Schwatz and Natalie Isser, Endangered Children). It will seek to correlate this research with scholarship on slavery and infanticide to illuminate the biblical narratives of the abandonment of Moses and of Ishmael with some attention to how these infant abandonment stories have been variously understood by modern interpreters.
|
Human Hubris, the Natural World, and the Wrath of God in Isaiah 13–27
Program Unit: Biblical Literature and the Hermeneutics of Trauma
David A Bosworth, The Catholic University of America
The paper will explore the role of the natural world (e.g., land, planta, animals, etc) within Isaiah 13-27. A corpus-based analysis permits all aspects of trauma and natural world to surface rather than only those aspects pre-selected for analysis which may not be representative of the corpus as a whole. The chapters show several diverse representations of trauma and the natural world. For example, the earth mourns (e.g., Isa 24:4), which is a characteristic emotional response to trauma. The text therefore extends trauma from human experience to the earth. But why is the earth mourning? At times, the earth suffers direct violence (e.g., 13:13; 24:19). At times, the natural world appears to reflect the experience of the people who inhabit it (e.g., 14:7). At times, humans cause nature to suffer (e.g., the cedars of Lebanon say to the king of Babylon, "Now that you are laid to rest, no one comes to cut us down," Isa 14:8). The land can communicate its trauma through changes (e.g., withered grass in 15:6, bloody water in 15:9). The paper will present the results of a systematic analysis of mentions of the natural world in Isaiah 13-27. These chapters describe human hubris punished by the wrath of God. How does the natural world fit into this divine-human relationship?
|
Disabling Romanticism: The Body in New Testament Apocrypha
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Pieter Botha, University of South Africa
The early Christian narratives that are categorised as New Testament apocrypha clearly aim at influencing their audiences to idealise the Jesus movement: to prompt penitence, to convert, to believe and to move the believer to spiritual life. What is underestimated is the rhetoric of disability encapsulated in particularly the healing and miracle stories used to promote such conversions and/or to bring about change in their readers/listeners. More than just championing Jesus and promoting Christianity, rather specific biases about normality and the acceptable body are communicated. Two trajectories will be highlighted: (1) asserting the notion of an originally “perfect” and “normal” world, beside which all impairment and disease are seen as evil deviations (the result of sin). (2) An underlying link between paralysis and sexuality that would have enabled ancient Christian audiences to connect paralysis with not only infertility but unacceptable sexuality. In this paper these traditions will be related to early Christian ascetic ideals in the context of ancient medical texts, to show how we discover that In this way desirable Christian roles is advanced by the narrators of early Christian apocryphal stories to affirm normalcy, masculinity and ableism as divine ideals.
|
Work and Labour: A Neglected Revolution Brought about by Early Christianity?
Program Unit: Social History of Formative Christianity and Judaism
Pieter Botha, University of South Africa
The relative economic success of the Roman Empire until medieval times is quite noteworthy — and there are no lack of propositions for explaining the eventual “decline” or “break down.” In line with the call to explore aspects of innovation and continuity, this paper explores subtle shifts and alterations to cultural concepts such as “work,” “labour,” and “professions” in the world of the Roman Empire with the spread of Christianity. While natural conditions, capital accumulation, technology and political stability all contributed to economic success, ultimately economic performance depended on the ability to mobilize, train and coordinate human work efforts. The growth of early Christianity, and the concomitant changes in social structures and institutions brought about changes in such efforts. Obviously a vast topic, but in this paper I explore possibilities of bringing new insights, ideas and interpretations on the changes in the roles of labour and human resources in the (slow) “christianising” of the Roman economy. For instance, the topic of slave labour and early Christianity have mostly been studied within the frameworks of family life, humanity, abuse and bondage. Issues relating to a perspective of “work” and “labour” and economic systems have received less attention. Options concerning conceptualising the various ways in which work was mobilised and organised and how such processes were regulated as a social and cultural phenomena are explored.
|
The Fragrance of Death—or of Life? Reconsidering the Sacrificial Logic of Ephesians 5:2
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Max Botner, Goethe-Universität Frankfurt am Main
“. . . and live in love, as Christ loved us and gave himself up for us, a fragrant offering and sacrifice to God” (Eph 5:2). Scholars of Ephesians agree overwhelmingly that the author’s paraenetic injunction to “live in love” is grounded in the death of Jesus. Markus Barth thus speaks for a large swath of interpreters when he claims that “[t]he author designates Jesus Christ’s death as an atoning sacrifice offered by the pouring out of blood” (1974: 558). Despite the seemingly self-evident nature of such an interpretation (Christian traditions have long viewed Christ’s cross in terms of the sacrificial rituals described in the Jewish scriptures), Christian Eberhart (2012) argues persuasively that it is, in fact, a distortion of the author’s sacrificial model. While there are several facets to Eberhart’s argument, the most significant is his contention that interpreters of Ephesians have misunderstood the logic of Levitical sacrifice, the system from which the author culls the phrases “offering” (προσφορά), “sacrifice” (θυσία), and a “fragrant aroma” (ὀσμὴν εὐωδίας). That is, in contrast to interpreters of Ephesians, who tend to construe ritual slaughter as the goal of Levitical sacrifice, Eberhart construes Levitical sacrifice as a hierarchical process culminating in God’s receipt of the gift. This paper aims to advance Eberhart’s argument that the sacrificial logic of Ephesians revolves around life rather than death. Specifically, I will contend that the author’s comparison between the Christ-gift and a “fragrant offering” evokes the presentation and perpetual presence of Christ’s resurrection life before God in the heavens (cf. Eph 1:20–21; 2:6; 4:10). The author’s call to imitatio Dei in 5:1 is therefore integrally related to his sacrificial model: worshipers who have received the gift of life through participation in Christ’s resurrection life are called to offer their lives back to the life-giving God.
|
You Are a "Spiritual House": Misunderstanding Metaphor and the Question of Supersessionism in 1 Peter
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Max Botner, Goethe-Universität Frankfurt am Main
In his exceptional monograph, Purity, Sacrifice, and the Temple: Symbolism and Supersessionism in the Study of Ancient Judaism, Jonathan Klawans makes the incisive observation that “it is all too easy for the temple to play the role of antagonist in the drama of the development of whatever phenomenon primarily interests the scholar, be it rabbinic Judaism, the New Testament, or the Dead Sea Scrolls” (2006: 104–5). Klawans’s observation, while more generally targeted, is apropos of the ways in which community-as-temple in the Dead Sea Scrolls is often handled in New Testament scholarship (e.g., Gärtner 1965). A parade example of this interpretive phenomenon is 1 Pet 2:5, “you yourselves are being built into a spiritual house.” Based on a particular account of community-as-temple language in the Dead Sea Scrolls, Petrine interpreters overwhelmingly explain this clause as an example—perhaps the example par excellence—of early “Christian” appropriation of the sectarian (and thus “Jewish”) desire to see the temple eclipsed by an eschatological community of the faithful.
This paper scrutinizes the dominant narrative in Petrine scholarship that the literary depository of the Dead Sea Scrolls lends itself to a smooth, evolutionary development culminating in a Gemeinde ohne Tempel. It argues, moreover, that attendance to the function of community-as-temple metaphors in the Dead Sea Scrolls opens an avenue for an alternative account of 1 Pet 2:5. The writer’s designation of gentile communities of Christ-followers as a “pneumatic house” does not derive from a “replacement” theology, but reflects the significance of Christ’s ministry at the right hand of Israel’s God. While the author is ostensibly uninterested in replacing the Jerusalem temple, his christocentrism can be marshalled in support of supersessionism once community-as-temple language becomes a “dead metaphor” in the exegetical tradition.
|
Secondary Predicates in the Book of Genesis
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Jacques E. J. Boulet, University of Toronto
This paper takes the first step toward comprehensive identification of secondary predicates in the book of Genesis. I begin by showing that what past scholars have called a ‘predicate accusative of state’ (Joüon 1947) or ‘predicative adjunct’ (the ETCBC database) corresponds to what modern linguists call secondary predicates. Secondary predicates are words or phrases co-occurring with a main verb that modify either the subject or an object of the verb. Following Rothstein (2015), the two broad categories of secondary predicate, namely depictives and resultatives, are defined using complex predicate semantics. Analysis on the basis of complex predicate semantics can be contrasted with analysis of adverbials, which are modifiers of simple events. I argue that complex predicate semantics can be mapped directly onto syntax using Cuervo’s (2003; 2015) approach to verbal predicates in combination with Bowers’ (1993; 2001) unified approach to predication. Specifically, secondary predicates are deemed to have a small clause structure, which may be headed by the Biblical Hebrew enclitic particles bə- and lə-. The paper concludes with a working list of secondary predicates so far identified in the book of Genesis.
|
The Power of Hope: Using Arts-Based Research for Education and Advocacy
Program Unit: Society for the Arts in Religious and Theological Studies (SARTS)
Helen Boursier, College of St. Scholastica
*The Power of Hope* incorporates experiences of refugee families seeking asylum as the backdrop for Arts-Based Research (ABR) which brings their testimonies to life, enabling public access to witness both the veracity of their suffering and the hopes and dreams for their children to receive safe asylum.
|
Visualizing Paul’s Text: A Reading of 1 Thess 5:1–11 alongside Roman Cuirassed Statues
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Anna M. V. Bowden , Brite Divinity School (TCU)
In 1 Thessalonians 5:8 Paul directs his audience “to put on a breastplate of faith and love, and for a helmet the hope of salvation.” This passage, along with others in the New Testament, has given way to the creation of various Christian images of soldiers geared for battle and even costumes for children allowing them to dress up in “the armor of God.” But, are these images of soldiers and spiritual defense weapons what Paul has in mind when he instructs his audience to put on a breastplate of faith and love? The goal of this paper is to explore these images of armor in conversation with a common image from Paul’s world, the Roman cuirassed statue. After describing my methodological approach, this paper begins with an overview of Roman cuirassed statues, including two case studies on specific examples. Next, I turn to a reading of 1 Thess 5:1-11 that takes seriously the importance of Paul’s visual world as an intertext for reading his letter to the Thessalonians. I read Paul’s armor images alongside the visual program of imperial ideology and conclude that the breastplate and helmet in v.8 evoke the images of cuirassed statues, statues that tout an elaborate imperial agenda. The breastplate and helmet in 1 Thess 5:8, therefore, are not images of spiritual warfare or a charge for believers to dress for battle, but represent an elaborate visual program – a commemoration of the life and death of Christ that also seeks to inspire believers to continue to carry the accomplishments of the past into the present and future.
|
Visualizing the Flight into Egypt
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Ian Boxall, The Catholic University of America
Matthew’s narrative of the Flight into Egypt (Matt 2:13-15) is riddled with ambiguity, not least regarding the significance of the final destination. Egypt is both ‘the house of bondage’ (thus signally its potential role as starting-point for a new Exodus) and a place of refuge for Jews across the centuries. The heavenly orchestration of the holy family’s movements (initiated by an angelic dream) pits divine Providence against murderous plots and flight from danger. The close interweaving of this story of rescue with the massacre of the innocents (Matt 2:16-18) raises for many difficult issues of theodicy. Moreover, the many gaps in the biblical text (the route and mode of transport; ultimate destination and reception; the length of the sojourn in Egypt) invite imaginative expansion and participation. Historical critics who locate the First Gospel in Syrian Antioch have occasionally linked Matthew’s first audiences with migration due to persecution. Non-canonical reworkings of the flight narrative (both apocryphal texts such as the Gospel of Pseudo-Matthew, Arabic Gospel of the Infancy, and local traditions of the Coptic Orthodox Church) often prioritize the holy family’s positive reception by Egyptian strangers. Such issues, and the tensions inherent in Matthew’s narrative, have also left their mark on interpretations in visual art. This paper will explore aspects of these tensions in the visual exegesis of the Flight into Egypt, particularly as it pertains to persecution and forced migration. Examples will include Coptic icons of the expanded narrative (e.g. Abu Serga Church, Old Cairo), two complementary versions of The Flight into Egypt by the African-American artist Henry Ossawa Tanner (1899, Detroit Institute of Arts; 1923, Metropolitan Museum of Art), and the Columbian Rest on the Flight into Egypt attributed to the Figueroa Workshop (17th century, Denver Art Museum).
|
The Place of Reception History in Commentaries on John's Apocalypse
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Ian Boxall, Catholic University of America
*
|
Pattern (PAT) Loans and Hebrew in Isaiah 40–66
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Samuel Boyd, University of Colorado
The study of language contact in the development of Biblical Hebrew has advanced the diachronic understanding of the language in a variety of ways. Most notable in these contributions are 1) the incorporation of contact linguistic theory for examining the processes behind contact-induced changes and 2) the focus on structural, and non-lexemic, changes in Biblical Hebrew. The latter is especially important when attempting to distinguish external from internal change, a distinction particularly difficult to make when the languages in contact, such as Hebrew, Akkadian, and Aramaic, are related. In this paper, I examine a particular structural change in Hebrew due to contact with Aramaic in Isa 40–66. I then contextualize this structural change in the distinction of matter (MAT) loans and pattern (PAT) loans as set forth by Jeanette Sakel and Yaron Matras, showing how the particular feature matches the process of PAT loans. Important for this study are not only the linguistic changes in Isa 40–66 in relation to Sakel and Matras’ work, but also the sociolinguistic situation that these linguists reconstruct behind the PAT loan process, a situation also present in the historical context of the composition of Isa 40–66 (whether or not this block of material derives from one Deutero-Isaiah or from Deutero- and Trito-Isaiah).
|
A Firmament of the Earth: The Logic of Gen 1:20 and a Visual Representation in the Baal Stele
Program Unit: Genesis
Samuel Boyd, University of Colorado
The cosmology as described in the Priestly account in Gen 1:1-2:4a has occasioned endless commentary. One of the more perceptive, though little known, studies of this text was published by Baruch Halpern in 2003 titled “The Assyrian Astronomy of Genesis 1 and the Birth of Milesian Philosophy.” Halpern argues that the qualification of the firmament (רקיע) as an “expanse of the heavens” in Gen 1:20 implies the existence of another expanse or firmament, namely an “expanse of the earth” (רקיע הארץ). In this paper, I review Halpern’s argument and add evidence from iconography at Ugarit. The Baal Stele in which the deity holds lightning (Louvre catalog number AO 15775) and stands with the king also displays a cosmology that has intriguing connections with Halpern’s thesis about an “expanse of the earth.” After connecting Halpern’s thesis to this visual representation of cosmology from Ugarit, I explore the ways in which both text and image are mutually illuminating and help to interpret one another.
|
From Text to Discourse: Foucault and the Septuagint
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Cameron Boyd-Taylor, Trinity Western University
In his lectures at the Collège de France Michel Foucault devoted considerable attention to Greco-Roman moral discourse, and his close reading of the key phlosphical texts has proven immensely influential in this regard. Less well known are his scattered observations on Greco-Jewish authors, yet they are by no means without interest. In the present study I take up Foucault’s discussion of a text from the Greek Psalter, considering not only the specifics of his analysis, but the interpretative stance which motivates it. I then consider the implications for Septuagint scholarship. One promising methodology that has arisen in the wake of Foucault’s pioneering work is Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA). As I shall argue, CDA offers an illuminating vantage point on various discursive phenomena within the Septuagint corpus. This shift in focus from text to discourse is, I would suggest, consistent with recent trends in Septuagint Studies, where we have witnessed (not least within IOSCS sponsored projects) an increasing emphasis on cultural contextualization.
|
Shifting Frames: A Frame-Based Analysis of Lexical Meaning
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Cameron Boyd-Taylor, Trinity Western University
Frame Semantics investigates how linguistic forms (words, fixed phrases, and grammatical patterns) are associated with the cognitive structures, or frames, which determine how those forms are understood. The frame-based analysis of lexical meaning, pioneered in the 1970s by the American linguistic Charles Fillmore, has since been widely adopted. It is at once intuitive and relatively informal, and complements other methodologies. While it was originally developed for the study of modern languages, its ethnographic orientation affords an illuminating perspective on ancient sources. In the present study I apply it to selected vocabulary from the Old Greek Psalter with a view to demonstrating its utility for both biblical lexicography and critical exegesis. My point of reference is the theme of ἐπιμέλεια ἑαυτοῦ in Greco-Roman moral discourse. Translational usage obviously raises distinct issues, yet one of the virtues of Frame Semantics is the conceptual purchase it offers on cross-linguistic phenomena.
|
The Festival Scrolls and Their Targumim
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Christian Brady, University of Kentucky
The Megilloth are an odd assortment of texts; they are five biblical books collected together undoubtedly and solely because of their use on festival days. As disparate as their Vorlage are, the Targumim of the Megilloth share certain exegetical traits (Brady, 2014), but do they really indicate the liturgical use of both the biblical text AND the Targumim? The Targumim of Esther and Song of Songs, for example, are far too large and unwieldy to have been read in a single sitting. In this paper I will examine further what the nature of character of these particular Targumim may tell us about their growth and development in relation to the Festival with which their biblical texts are associated.
|
The Gospel of Judas and the End of Sethian Gnosticism
Program Unit: Westar Institute
David Brakke, Ohio State University
*
|
The Decalogue in Matthew’s Antitheses (5:21–48)
Program Unit: Bible and Ethics
George Branch-Trevathan, Thiel College
This paper examines the reception and use of the Decalogue and ancient interpretations of it in Matthew’s antitheses (5:21-48). It argues first that the antitheses’ utilization of the latter five of the Ten Commandments is more thoroughgoing than most scholars have recognized because the antitheses cite the Decalogue’s prohibitions on murder (5:21-26), adultery (5:27-30, 31-2), false testimony and theft (5:33-37), as well as coveting (5:43-8), the love command in 5:43 being, for Matthew, the positive form of the prohibition on coveting (cf. 19:17-19). Second, it maintains that Matthew utilizes the second half of the Decalogue largely because by the first century C.E., expansions and summaries of these commandments are a convenient and common way of indicating the full range of interpersonal obligations, of referring to morality in toto. Philo, for instance, describes these five laws as “generic rules that include nearly all offenses” (Her. 1:173). Thus, when in each antithesis Matthew insists that merely performing right actions or avoiding wrong ones is morally insufficient and that one must instead combine right actions with right emotions, appetites, motives, or dispositions—with proper inner states—, because he is representing the Decalogue, he is claiming in effect that morality in toto has an indispensable and decisive interior dimension. The antitheses as a whole then are synechdoches of ethics, or, to use Matthew’s term, of “righteousness” in personal relationships. From these cases and the logic expressed thereby, Matthew intends for readers to extrapolate to gain a panoramic understanding of interpersonal ethics. Finally, the conclusion of the paper examines the relevance of the conception of ethics found in the antitheses to current ethical issues.
|
Visionary Ascent or Commemoration of the Dead? A Remarkable Fourth-Century Manichaean Text from Kellis
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Mattias Brand, Leiden University
The study of Manichaeism in the later Roman Empire has received an incredible impulse with the discovery of Manichaean liturgical and documentary texts in the village of Kellis (Ismant el-Kharab, Dakhleh Oasis in Egypt). These texts offer a window into the everyday life and rituals of a Manichaean community on the ground. Among these relatively new texts is a wooden codex containing several (abbreviated) psalms and a remarkable hymn or prayer about the ascent of the soul. This short text, known as T.Kell.Copt. 2, text A5, connects the well-known Manichaean eschatological tradition with the lived experience of Manichaeans in a village context. As little is known about Manichaean liturgical life, this wooden codex with its exceptional texts presents us with major challenges as well as an opportunity. What Manichaean rituals pertaining the journey of the soul were performed in this community? How is it connected to a wider Manichaean tradition?
This paper will re-examine two plausible interpretations of T.Kell.Copt. 2, text A5: it was either an instruction manual for the visionary ascent rituals of Manichaean elect, or it belonged to the liturgy for the commemoration of the dead. Both options will be evaluated against the context of the local village society and its wider Egyptian-Christian surroundings, before highlighting the Manichaean and ‘gnostic’ connections. Despite tantalizing interpretative options, I will argue for a minimalist approach that is primarily rooted in the local and everyday concerns of a fourth-century religious community in an Egyptian village.
|
Luke-Acts and Pharisees
Program Unit: Writing Social-Scientific Commentaries of the New Testament
Robert Brawley, McCormick Theological Seminary
This paper employs theories of literary characterization, social identity, “othering,” and Pierre Bordieux’s notion of hierarchies of dominance based on hidden assumptions in order to establish roles Pharisees play in Luke-Acts. In fact, the plural “roles” is quite significant because the thesis is that they play multiple roles. This contrasts with two prominent approaches. One is the reduction of the Pharisees to flat characters who, in spite of developments in the narrative, remain essentially the same. The second is the popular premise that plot is driven by conflict. To be sure, this is often the case, but plot is also driven by simple choices among alternatives and such phenomena as predictions and deficiencies, which produce narrative needs, beg for resolution. In other words, Pharisees play different roles, and this includes that they do not always function as opponents. They are genuine interlocutors, not straw people, as the sophists in Plato’s Apology. Indeed they are capable of being persuaded.
|
A Focus on a Link: The Conception of “Land” in the Interconnection between Joshua and the Pentateuch
Program Unit: Joshua-Judges
Johannes Bremer, Ruhr-Universität Bochum
As Joshua is the first who finally is allowed to cross the river Jordan according to Josh 1, “land” can easily be seen as the most obvious link between the Book of Joshua and the Pentateuch or at least Exodus to Deuteronomy. According to Josh 21:43 the promise of “land” is (at first) finally fulfilled. – Besides this obviousness, a deeper look refers to the more complex questions on conceptions and ideas of land both, in Joshua and Exodus to Deuteronomy.
The paper first asks for ideas of “land” as reflected in the book of Joshua, which rather refer not only to questions of different extensions and conceptions than to one consistent concept within the whole book. Here, by analyses of different passages of the book of Joshua, the paper points out exemplarily different understandings of "land" as they are reflected in the Joshua-texts. Second, based on the analyses of Joshua-texts, the paper asks for links to different conceptions of “land” within Exodus to Deuteronomy. In which way are there similarities? Which texts witness comparable “land-conceptions”, and which implicitly or explicitly do not? In which way do the “land conceptions” in Joshua refer to conceptions in Exodus to Deuteronomy? Moreover, how can we interpret them, either syn- or diachronic? Third, a conclusion will summarize and tries to point out interconnections between the understandings of “land” in Joshua and the Pentateuch.
|
“Land” as a Topic in the Book of Psalms? A Focus on the Texts
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Johannes Bremer, Ruhr-Universität Bochum
Since recent 20-30 years, psalms- and Psalter-studies focus on topics or even common threads running through the entire book of Psalms. E.g., the shift from lament to praise (cf. studies by Bellinger, Hossfeld, Rechberger e.a.), Zion (cf. studies by Körting, Janowski e.a.), divine power (cf. Tucker e.a.), or the theology of the poor (cf. Bremer e.a.). Together, these threats form the idea of a theology of the entire Book of Psalms. – By contrast, “land” is more prominent discussed as theme in single psalms (e.g. most prominent: ps. 37), even though its main terms ̓ӕrӕẓ and ̓adāmāh appear more than 200 times in the entire book and in almost but not all groups and subgroups of psalms.
The paper focuses on different passages and conceptions of “land” in the book of psalms. Rather to a common understanding, the paper points out different understandings and conceptions of “land”. The goal is (a) to witness both, literal but also metaphorical understandings and (b) to set them in the context of the theology of single psalms, groups and books, and (c) at least to the theology of the Psalter as a whole.
|
Two Languages, Two Scripts, and Three Combinations Thereof: A Personal Prayer-Book in Syriac and Old Uyghur from Turfan (U 338)
Program Unit: Book History and Biblical Literatures
Adam Bremer-McCollum, University of Notre Dame
Two languages, two scripts, and three combinations thereof: A personal prayer-book in Syriac and Old Uyghur from Turfan (U 338)
|
The Materiality of Animal Worship: From Egypt to Rome
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Frederick E. Brenk, Pontifical Biblical Institute, Rome
Egypt possibly produced as many as 70 million animal mummies. Many have been studied recently with new technologies, for example, at Yale, the Brooklyn Museum, and Manchester, using CT scanners and X-ray equipment for children. The new techniques allow one to examine the inside without damaging the artefact. The Animal Mummy Database, a work in progress, locates animal mummies in museums throughout the world and catalogues them. Greeks and Romans apparently misunderstood Egyptian animal worship, just as many modern scholars do. A congress on animal worship, held in Berlin, has been published as Tierkulte im pharaonischen Ägypten und im Kulturvergleich (Fitzenreiter and Kirchner 2013). The most important contributions are: Kessler 2013 (esp. 36-37, 56-66); Feder 2013 159-166; Fitzenreiter 2013 (esp. 245-246); and Quack 2013 (esp. 111-113). Their argument is that strictly speaking animal worship did not exist in Egypt. But here, like Plutarch (On Isis and Osiris 382A-C), we might distinguish between the priests and the common people. Moser and Knust (2017, 4) note how material remains may be deceptive in both the literature and representational evidence (cf. Várhelyi, 2017, 90). Worship of living animals and animal mummification did not seem to have transferred to Isis sanctuaries in Rome. Living ibises may have been kept in the Isaeum Campense in Rome but probably not worshipped
Romans did, however, worship animal statues. In the Ariccia relief, in a sacred setting, there are statues of baboons (Toth) flanking a statue of Isis, and a statue of Apis. The Ariccia relief may represent live ibises (Toth) along a water channel, but these may be simply in a carved relief (Ariccia Relief, Palazzo Altemps, Rome; Lembke 1994, 24, 174-178; Capriotti Vittozzi 2013, 142-145, 180). On a glass vessel in the Getty Museum (Wight and Swetnam-Burland 2010, esp. 841-844) putti decorate a statue of a baboon (Toth). A statuette similar to this in the Allard Pearson Museum depicts a baboon wearing a crown. An Ibis appears both on the statue base in the Getty vessel and on the statuette. Romans seemed to have relegated the practice of animal worship to statues. A possibly exception may be indicated by a portico fresco of the Isaeum at Pompeii in which a priest holds a live serpent on a cushion. At a rough estimate, over 2 million objects from ancient Egypt are kept in about 850 public collections dispersed over 69 countries around the world. The Global Egyptian Museum (online) aims to collect and catalogue the objects into a “global virtual museum,” a long-term project, carried out under the aegis of the International Committee for Egyptology (CIPEG). This will be an important tool for studying Egyptian animal statues and their veneration in Rome and elsewhere in Italy. They will, however, always need interpretation.
|
Beauty Out of Place: Recognition Scenes in Joseph and Aseneth, Daphnis and Chloe, and the Aethiopica
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Christopher Brenna, Saint Mary's University of Minnesota
The Jewish romance, Joseph and Aseneth, is often compared to Hellenistic romances in scholarly discussions, but a consensus on whether or not to include it in the genre has never been reached. It seems to uphold many of the most salient conventions of the Greek novels while transgressing others, and the suppositions that scholars make about the date of writing of Joseph and Aseneth have influenced the conclusions they arrive at regarding its status as a Greek novel. West positions Joseph and Aseneth as a forerunner of the Greek novels (1974, 70-81), as does Braginskaya (2012, 96), but Pervo (1991, 145-60) and, more recently, Ahearne-Kroll (2005, 142) surmise some amount of influence from the Greek novels. Wills sees only a "strained connection" with Greek novels, describing Joseph and Aseneth instead as a Jewish novel similar to Greek Esther, Tobit, and Judith (1995, 161-62). Montiglio recently classified Joseph and Aseneth along with the Pseudo-Clementines as examples of adaptations of pagan novels (2013, 202-15). Rather than adjudicating between the various proposals regarding Joseph and Aseneth's status, this paper assesses the influence of the tale-type of the exposed hero on Joseph and Aseneth and two of the five extant Greek romances: the Aethiopica of Heliodorus and Daphnis and Chloe. A tale-type is a matrix of common elements and motifs that travel together in a story form through cultural exchange, and the story of the exposed hero is one of the most ubiquitous in ancient Near Eastern and Hellenistic literature. Not only that, but it is the basis for the story of Moses in extrabiblical traditions about the Exodus and for the Matthean birth story of Jesus.
I describe the features of Joseph and Aseneth that indicate a subtle appropriation of certain motifs of the tale-type and compare them with similar moments in the Aethiopica, but especially in Daphnis and Chloe. An analysis of the most significant feature of all three novels, the recognition scene in particular, reveals the peculiar concern of the writer of Joseph and Aseneth both to allude to the conventions of Greek romantic literature while subverting their thematic ends. I conclude that the early Jewish and Christian adaptations of the exposed hero tale-type provide the impetus for the subversion of the telos of most Hellenistic versions of the tale, that fate is inexorable.
|
Reflections from Krister's Academic Neighbor
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Marc Brettler, Duke University
Reflections from Krister's Academic Neighbor.
|
The Slow and Unclear Parting of the (Many) Ways
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Sheila Briggs, University of Southern California
From the 1980s onwards criticism of the "Parting of the Ways" paradigm mounted and eventually led to the Ways That Never Parted thesis (named after the influential 2002 conference). One of the key components of this thesis has been to contest the idea of a singular and fixed Jewish or Christian identity. Since that conference further work has appeared on cultural and religious identities in antiquity (e.g. Erich Gruen, Yoshiko Reed and Natalie Dohrmann). One has come to recognize that Jewish and Christian identities cannot be understood as separate from the complex processes through which all inhabitants of the Roman Empire negotiated often multiple identities. Ethnicity configured religion but religion also reconfigured ethnicity. Local cultural/religious identities always had to take into account the socio-political reality of pan-ethnic Hellenism and Romanitas. This paper approaches ancient identity formation by looking at the networks that connected ancient communities of Jews and Christians. It not only charts the permeable and shifting boundaries between Jewish and Christian but also how the rejection of Jewish identity led to an intra-Christian parting, as in the case of Marcion.
Jewish and Christian communities (like all ancient religious ones) were fundamentally local. The networks between them often were fragile and tenuous. The resilience of local communities, however, often depended on their connection to a robust network. The emergence and growth of networks as well as their frequent decline and disappearance allowed the interactions through which communal and individual identities changed over time. Furthermore, the viability of a network determined whether religious identities were sustainable or not. Hence the definitive turning point for Jewish and Christian identities in the fourth century occurred when the ascendancy of orthodox Christianity strengthened their networks. Orthodox Christians were able to invoke the power of the Roman state to disrupt and dismantle the networks of religious others.
As well as ancient textual and material data, I will be using modern ethnographic research on Jewish communities in Africa (the Falashas and Lemba) who lost contact with the Jewish communities of the North and developed their own highly unique forms of Judaism. They provide interesting case studies on the effects of isolation from and proximity to a network, especially since there are concerted efforts today to insert them into the mainstream of Judaism and create communal identities closer to those of the Judaism of the north. These African studies contribute to the theoretical framework for the conclusion of the paper that analyses the much-discussed mass conversion of the Jews of Menorca to Christianity in 418 CE in terms of the viability of networks to sustain identities.
|
Washing Away Gender Roles? Water as Unsettling and Reinforcing Gender Dynamics in Nahum
Program Unit: Gender, Sexuality, and the Bible
William Briggs, Baylor University
Scholars frequently note Nahum’s rich literary features and “poetic excellence,” even as they simultaneously struggle with the more difficult aspects of the book such as its depictions of violence and sexual humiliation. This paper examines both the book’s poetic artistry and its challenging depiction of gender relations, particularly with respect to the use of water imagery throughout Nahum. While several scholars have noted the use of water imagery within Nahum, its role as a recurring motif in the book remains underexplored, especially as it pertains to the role it plays in the depiction of gendered conflict which, following Julia O’Brien, occurs throughout its three chapters. A detailed study of Nahum reveals that water imagery, which is found in Nah 1:4, 8; 2:7, 9; 3:8, 14, constitutes a significant motif within the book as a whole. Furthermore, the instances of water imagery in these verses both build upon one another and simultaneously reinforce and unsettle the gender dynamics found within Nahum, particularly that of the masculine contest between Yahweh and the king of Assyria, as posited by O’Brien and Cynthia Chapman.
The use of water imagery in Nah 1:4, 8 emphasizes the invincible nature of Yahweh, the mighty masculine warrior, thereby setting the stage for the assault on Nineveh in chs. 2—3. The use of water imagery in Nah 2:7 recalls the flood depicted in Nah 1:8 and emphasizes the humiliating defeat of the king of Assyria. The portrait of Nineveh as a pool of water in Nah 2:9 marks a shift in the usage of water imagery within Nahum, as each of the final three occurrences of such language is related to female entities. The use of water imagery in this verse demonstrates the panicked flight of the masculine defenders of Nineveh, while the portrait of Nineveh as a “pool” offers a stark contrast to Yahweh’s rebuke of the sea in 1:4, demonstrating the inevitability of Yahweh’s defeat of Nineveh. Nahum 2:9 also ushers the masculine defenders of Nineveh out of the picture and briefly introduces female Nineveh, preparing the reader for the focus on Yahweh’s struggle against her in chapter 3. Nahum 3:8 concretizes the image of Yahweh’s inevitable triumph and the inevitable defeat of Nineveh by comparing the Assyrian capital to once-mighty Thebes, both of which were known for their aquatic defenses. Moreover, the command to Nineveh to “draw water” in 3:14 forms a lexical parallel with 2:9, taunting female Nineveh to prepare for her defense even as her “waters” run away and her troops desert her. This taunt brings into focus the inevitability of the Divine Warrior’s triumph over Nineveh and complete victory in the realm of masculine conflict with the absent king of Assyria. At the same time, however, personified Nineveh’s characterization and active role within the text destabilizes the binary, essentialized gender rhetoric in Nahum regarding the Assyrians even as it reinforces the portrait of Yahweh’s military might.
|
Matter and Devotion in Ethiopia: The Use of Hagiographic Manuscripts in Devotional and Ritual Practices
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Antonella Brita, Universität Hamburg
Material evidences can tell us a lot about the past life and the way hagiographic manuscripts were conceived, produced, used and perceived in the social, institutional and liturgical context related to the veneration of the saints. On the other hand, the observation of contemporary use of the manuscripts also reveals some facets which cannot be detected from their material evidences. The reason is that these facets pertain to a sphere of (immaterial) knowledge which follows a different channel of transmission – essentially oral transmission – that usually does not leave any material trace in the manuscripts. The results provided by both material and immaterial evidences not only complement each other, as long as the diachronic perspective is observed, but also inform us about evolutions and possible changes across the time. The paper intends to provide a reflection on some devotional practices connected to the veneration of saints in Ethiopia. The timespan covered goes from the fourteenth century till the present time. The manuscript evidences will be taken into account and will represent the leitmotif of the entire contribution. Far from providing final results, it rather represents a first attempt of an insight into the topic from a mere material perspective. In particular, themes related to the use, function and perception of Ethiopic manuscripts in the making of Ethiopian sainthood and in keeping it alive will be explored, covering areas which range between low wide-range and high-intensity ritual practices.
|
Appropriating the Title of “Servant of God” in the Second Century CE: Slavery and Identity in the Acts of Paul and Thecla
Program Unit: Slavery, Resistance, and Freedom
Joseph E. Brito, Concordia University - Université Concordia
The following presentation will focus on the self-imposed title “servant/slave of God” found in the apocryphal Acts of Paul and Thecla (AP&T) in order to analyze the reception of Paul’s metaphor on slavery during the second century CE. Although scholars have addressed the descriptive nature and actions of particular characters in AP&T (See Janos Bollok, 1996; Gail Street, 2005; Heike Omerzu, 2008; Jennifer Eyl, 2013; Seth Pfannenschmidt, 2014; Peter-Ben Smit, 2014), they have not addressed how the metaphor of “servant/slave of God” in AP&T enables the imagined-identity of Paul, Thecla, as well as its dissonance with unidentified and silenced slave-characters. When it comes to scholarship on Paul’s language and metaphors regarding slavery, scholars have focused their research on the origins of Paul’s understanding of slavery in his canonical letters (see Dale Martin, 1990; I A H Combes, 1998; John Byron, 2003; Albert Harrill, 2006), or its reception in particular Christian communities (see J. Albert Harrill, 1995; I A H Combes, 1998; Chris L. de Wet; 2015, 2018). In doing so, the optic remains limited within the canon and ecclesiastic authorities, which consequently has become the prescriptive and normative explanation as to how Paul’s language regarding slavery ought to be understood. Furthermore, seldom has Paul’s metaphor been analyzed in apocryphal literature relating to the reception of his teachings regarding slavery (see I A H Combes, 1998; Jennifer A. Glancy, 2006). In order to address both subjects, this presentation will focus on the reception of Paul’s metaphor of “servant/slave of God” as found in the AP&T, inquiring on the alternative terminology employed for Paul (ὑπηρέτα τοῦ εὐλογημένου θεοῦ), Thecla (τοῦ θεοῦ δούλην), and slave-characters (refered to as παῖς, παιδίσκη or σύνδουλος), and how its terminology influence their characterization and identity. Furthermore, by underlining the distinctive terminology between Paul’s self-imposed titles in his canonical letters (“δοῦλος Χριστοῦ ᾿Ιησοῦ” in Romans 1:1, Philippians 1:1, and Colossians 4:12; “δοῦλον δὲ Κυρίου” in 1 Tim. 2:24 and Titus 1:1) and the one found in the AP&T (“ὑπηρέτα τοῦ εὐλογημένου θεοῦ”), this presentation will discuss the development of this metaphor and its implication in terms of identity and social expectations. The AP&T provides a rich and vivid narrative which not only provides clues on the religious aspect within urban setting of the second century CE, but also offers a glimpse of the socio-cultural context in terms of social expectations, class, and sexual norms – elements that provided identity markers, theorized as discrepant identity (see David J. Mattingly, 2011). Therefore, along with a postcolonial sensitivity (based on Benedict Anderson’s theory of Mymicry – 1983), this presentation problematizes the metaphorical and imagined-slaves (servants of God, and their idealized characterization), the descriptive nature of slaves as found in the narrative, and the reality of their daily experience (see Sarah Pomeroy, 1975; Sandra R. Joshel, 1992, 2010; Joshel and Murnaghan (Ed.) 1998; Joshel and Hackworth Petersen, 2014; Jennifer Glancy, 2006). This research thus highlights the power-dynamic and adaptation of the servant-metaphor in the second century, underlining the type of imagined religious-identity sought.
|
Jerusalem Always Virtual
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Brian Britt, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University
Jerusalem was always virtual. What did its virtual status mean for physical experience of the city, and how does this biblical tradition condition Jerusalem today? This paper explores ancient and modern images of Jerusalem through the lens of early photographs and the work of Walter Benjamin.
From biblical texts like Nehemiah 2 and Ezekiel 40-48 to medieval and early modern texts, religious experience of Jerusalem was primarily virtual, particularly through the media of texts and visual representations. The advent of photography enabled new ways of seeing and thinking, but it also engaged the ancient past. Images in books and in public settings like the Kaiserpanorama in Berlin amazed European audiences while continuing a long tradition of virtual encounters.
Verbal and visual images of Jerusalem continued to preoccupy Jewish and Christian traditions into the modern period of Zionism, British Mandate, the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and online pilgrimage. Does the virtual character of Jerusalem collapse in the face of political conflict or dissolve in a postmodern simulacrum of free play? I will argue that neither is the case. Through a discussion of the Jerusalem of photographs and Walter Benjamin, I will show that Jerusalem remains as virtual as ever, yet always grounded in history and tradition.
|
Biblical and Postsecular Blasphemy
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Brian Britt, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University
The term “blasphemy” condemns more than it describes. According to David Lawton, blasphemy is “always something else” and usually “someone else’s”; it “stands for whatever a society most abhors and has the power to prosecute.” The classic biblical sources for blasphemy—Lev 24 and Mk 14:64, for example—associate blasphemy with cursing and designate it as a grave offense punishable by death.
This paper will relate the account of blasphemy in Lev 24:10-16 to modern debates over blasphemy in terms of two features of this text: the warning against blasphemy, and the role of blasphemy in establishing and maintaining group identity. These dynamics also appear in contemporary debates, from the Rushdie affair of 1988 to the more recent cases of Jyllands-Posten and Charlie Hebdo. An exchange between Talal Asad and Judith Butler on blasphemy raises broader questions of freedom and secularity that have roots in biblical texts. How do modern forms of nationalism and secularism deploy blasphemy and debates about blasphemy?
The dire warnings against blasphemy in modern and ancient contexts always seem to involve questions of identity. By showing how blasphemy, like curses, survives and transforms through history as vitally important to life, death, and identity, I will propose blasphemy as a model of displacement and transformation in biblical tradition.
|
In Their Own Words: Prosōpopoiia, Rhetoric, and Characterization in Chariton's Chaereas et Callirhoe
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Amanda Brobst-Renaud, Valparaiso University
The presence of rhetorical features in Callirhoe both reveals the acumen of the author and emphasizes key events within the narrative. These techniques include prosōpopoiia (speech-in-character), which frequently occurs when Chaereas or Callirhoe experience misfortune, and other features such as anaphora (omission of words between successive phrases), paronomasia (words that sound similarly but have different meanings), polyptōton (repetition of words in different cases) and homoioteluton (repetition of word endings). The examples of prosōpopoiia suffice not only to illustrate Chariton's use of rhetorical devices but also provide a summary of the novel itself. Chariton characterizes Callirhoe, Chaereas, and Dionysius through prosōpopoiia, which places their features-both positive and negative traits-on the lips of the characters themselves, a technique present not only in the ancient novels but also in fables and bioi. By embedding rhetorical techniques within prosōpopoiia, Chariton draws attention to the characters' speeches. Through his use of prosōpopoiia, Chariton allows Callirhoe, Chaereas, and Dionysius to tell their intertwining stories in their own words.
This presentation begins with a brief discussion of the traditional and developing consensuses of Chariton's readership and the role of prosōpopoiia in the progymnasmata and rhetorical handbooks. After briefly considering the way prosōpopoiia contributes to characterization in other literature, I devote the bulk of this presentation to discussing prosōpopoiia within Chariton's Chaereas et Callirhoe and the rhetorical techniques Chariton embeds therein. Chariton's astute use of prosōpopoiia and characterization contributes, ultimately, to the developing consensus that the intended audience for the ancient novels included (even if it was not limited to) the elite.
|
Sin and Its Remedy in 1 Corinthians
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Alexandra Brown, Washington and Lee University
Sin and Its Remedy in 1 Corinthians
|
An Interdisciplinary Exploration of a Social Justice Commitment: Perspectives from Psychology and Biblical Studies
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Jeannine Brown, Bethel Seminary (San Diego, CA)
Social justice is a rich biblical theme, even as its centrality for the Christian gospel remains hotly debated in more conservative circles. This question is of crucial importance for the church in contemporary society. We will propose that social justice commitment is a core Christian value, by exploring key prophetic voices in the Hebrew Bible as they make their way into Matthew’s Gospel. That evangelist’s concern for the “little ones” and the “least of these” will provide a lens for considering how justice takes a central place in the teachings of Jesus in the first Gospel. We will bring this biblical scholarship into interdisciplinary conversation with practical theology using a relational integration model and building upon recent empirical research in psychology on social justice commitment and spiritual formation. Studies with emerging and experienced Christian leaders have found positive associations between social justice commitment and formation-related factors such as hope, humility, positive religious coping, interpersonal forgiveness, faith maturity, relational maturity, and mental health. This research supports the understanding that a commitment to social justice is often consistent with other aspects of healthy Christian spiritual formation, although we will also consider theological questions about factors that might make this more valid for some traditions than others. Our interdisciplinary approach to relational integration will lead us to note points of difference between biblical and social science research related to social justice, while also exploring points of resonance. We will also offer reflections based on our relational integration approach about the advantages and challenges of this kind of interdisciplinary collaboration between scholars of different disciplines.
|
Wisdom Christology in an Unwise World: Matthew’s Contribution to a Canonical and Constructive Theology of Wisdom
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Jeannine Brown, Bethel Seminary (San Diego, CA)
The presence of a wisdom Christology in Matthew has been a matter for ongoing debate. We will argue that Matthew’s Gospel portrays Jesus as the embodiment of Wisdom, most clearly in Matthew 11 but also across the Gospel and in tandem with the theme of Jesus as the fulfillment of the Torah. This motif suggests a “wisdom Christology” in Matthew, as the “Messiah’s deeds” are linked to wisdom’s “deeds” (11:2, 19). Matthew’s Jesus draws from Jewish wisdom traditions to invite his hearers to listen to him and follow him, but the motif also explains why he is often rejected. This wisdom Christology also impinges on Matthew’s perspective of discipleship—how followers of Jesus are to live in line with and in light of Jesus as Wisdom even as the kingdom remains partially hidden in the present. The community is to be guided by wisdom—and Jesus as their teacher is the embodiment of wisdom. We will also consider Matthew’s offering for a canonical theology of wisdom that thematizes hiddenness as well as revelation in the life of the believing community. Constructively, we will explore contemporary uses of wisdom Christology for their value in grounding a public witness for justice and wisdom “in an unwise world.” Drawing on Bultmann, Johnson, and Schüssler Fiorenza among others, we will argue that a wisdom Christology—informed by Matthew—has potential for justice-making through discipleship communities oriented around wisdom and its “deeds” embodied in Jesus.
|
Old Things New: The Modern Textus Receptus of Ethiopic Jonah
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Jeremy R. Brown, Catholic University of America
The Ethiopic version is one of the oldest translations of the Bible and it is a living tradition. The initial translation likely took place between 350 and 520 CE and scribes continue to write the Bible on parchment today. The majority of study on the Ethiopic translation of the books of the Hebrew Bible has focused on the Earliest Attested text and has attempted to understand the Greek Vorlage behind it; little attention has been paid to the manuscript evidence from the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. This study examines dozens of manuscripts from these centuries to shed light on the development of the modern textus receptus. This study explores the work of scribes who created a text that was aware of multiple earlier recessions through techniques that included blending, conflation, and compliance reports. Nineteenth and twentieth century scribes fashioned a text that honored the work of previous generations and continues to be utilized in the Ethiopian and Eritrean Orthodox Churches.
|
Ezekiel: Signing Presence
Program Unit: Society for Comparative Research on Iconic and Performative Texts
Katherine E. Brown, Catholic University of America
A central theme of the book of Ezekiel is the presence or absence of the LORD. This theme is implicated in the book’s exilic self-siting (Ezek 1:1) and woven through the book’s content, including the visions in which disputed claims regarding divine presence are explicitly argued (e.g. Ezek 11:14-21). The resolution comes not only through the prophetic words, which end with sustaining promise “And the name of the city from that time on shall be, The LORD is There” (Ezek 48:35b), but also through the materiality of the medium in which that promise persists, the prophetic book.
Scholars have studied the writtenness of the book of Ezekiel, including the mutual identification of prophet and book. The prophet who opened his mouth and ate the scroll effectively becomes the scroll (Ezek 2:8-3:11). Scholars also have studied the ways in which the prophet’s visions reference motifs from the Ancient Near Eastern “mouth-opening” rituals used to induce divine presence in crafted cult statues. Absent the ritual, the statue did not live; after the ritual, the statue imaged the god. These ANE rituals are positively evoked with reference to the bodies of the prophet (Ezek 1-3; 8-11) or of Israel (e.g. Ezek 37:1-14) to suggest indwelling presence.
This paper joins those strands of research and argues that Ezekiel presents itself as a written text which holds in its very materiality the potential for the realization of divine presence. The mouth-opened sign-prophet (24:27) becomes the mouth-opening sign-book. The dry-bones vision of Ezekiel 37:1-4, then, may be read as a narrative of the mutually-animating intersection of the text’s bones and the lector’s breath, leading to an experience of God present through the proclamation of the written word.
|
“The Other” in Early Seventeenth-Century English Biblical Interpretation
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Ken Brown, Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz
This paper will compare the ways in which biblical categories are used to “other” various opponents and adversaries, both foreign and domestic, in published sermons from early Stuart England. In particular, it will explore the diverse ways in which “Canaanites,” “Amalekites” and other biblical “enemies” are identified with the preachers’ own contemporaries, especially in reaction to the newly established Virginia Colony, and in the aftermath of the so-called Gunpowder Plot. In these contexts, Anglican preachers identified both non-Christians (such as the natives of the New World), and other Christians (such as Catholics) with the ancient enemies of Israel, yet to varying purposes. Though in many cases these identifications serve to demonize the “Other” and justify their destruction, in other cases such language is used, surprisingly, to argue for a commonality between “us” and “them,” and to reject violence against “the Other.”
|
Embodying Tabernacles in John 7:1–10:21
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Sherri Brown, Creighton University
The celebration of a Jewish feast is a zikaron, a “memorial,” of God’s past active presence in the lives of his chosen people (Lev 23:24). Celebrating the liturgy of the feast manifests that past presence among the people in the current age. If the Johannine Christians had been, or even just felt, marginalized from the synagogues, they were not simply being excluded from these celebrations, they may have felt that they were losing contact with the God of creation and God’s saving action in history. As believers in the saving action of the Christ event, they had been taught that relationship with God is engendered through the Word of Jesus. This presents the problem at hand: what about these festivals and the experience of God’s presence they facilitate through their rituals? Not only must the Fourth Evangelist care for the community members pastorally, he must also show God’s fidelity to them and continuing presence in their lives as members of a new community. Reshaping the experience of God in the life of the community is therefore the particular background for the so-called “feasts section” in John 5–10. The Fourth Evangelist renders “christological” the feasts of Judaism; i.e., he teaches that God has sent Jesus the Christ to complete and embody these ritual acts.
All of John 7:1–10:21 takes place in the context of the Feast of Tabernacles and the ritual celebrations of the festival not only form the sensory backdrop of this lengthy passage but also provide the interpretive key for its exegesis. Originally an autumn celebration of the grape and olive harvest, Tabernacles was later historicized and associated with the Sinai covenant and God’s care and guidance during the wilderness experience. By the later prophetic age and into NT times, the feast had also been eschatologized, and the celebration included explicit hopes for the coming of the Messiah and messianic age (see Zechariah 14). In the late Second Temple Period, Tabernacles became an eight-day pilgrimage observance held at the temple in Jerusalem. The festival worshippers looked expectantly to God for a time when life giving waters flowed from the temple which served as a beacon of light to the world through three daily rites: the Water Libation Ceremony, the Ceremony of Light, and the Rite of Facing the Temple.
This paper explores how John 7–8 forms a unified whole in terms of Jesus’ teaching and his very being viewed through the lens of the Jewish feast of Tabernacles, while John 9–10 narrates how Jesus is what he teaches about himself in John 7–8: he is the living water that gives light to the world and sight to the blind through the waters that come from within. Jesus is presented as the embodiment of the ritual activity of Tabernacles for a fledgling Jewish Christian community struggling to reconstitute the presence of God in its liturgical life.
|
Prophetic Endurance and Eschatological Restoration: Exhortation and Conclusion in James 5:7–20
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Sherri Brown, Creighton University
The epistle of James provides a window into a messianic movement that is developing into a community of faithful in the midst of a larger Hellenistic socio-cultural environment. The author’s understanding of the nature of his community’s cultural trajectory over against this environment is implicit in the address to "the twelve tribes of the dispersion," made explicit through the substance of the correspondence, and brought full circle in its conclusion. James speaks to this community through the authority of the name of the Lord and understands himself as both servant and teacher in this new life in light of the coming of that Lord (1:1; 3:1; 5:7-9). The formation of the community engenders a new action arising from the "implanted word" that produces "a kind of first fruits" of God’s creatures who lead the way of salvation (1:18, 21; 5:19-20). The injunction that comprises the form and content of the epistle’s conclusion indicates that this way is tantamount to eschatological restoration.
This study is primarily dedicated to an analysis of these final verses (5:7-20). However, a conclusion must be given its place within the utterance of the document as a whole. The genre and structure of the Epistle of James has long been of interest to scholars seeking to determine its purpose and interpretive force. For years, the work of Martin Dibelius held sway and James was understood as only loosely related aphorisms put forth as moral exhortation without particular context or motivation. Following the influence of Peter Davids and Luke Timothy Johnson, among others, more recent scholarship has begun to explore the work as a literary whole with quite an intricate form and structure. By placing the correspondence of James within the genre of the literary epistle, we can move beyond a limiting form-critical view and approach its structure and content from a more holistic perspective. Adapting the work of Davids and Johnson, a chiastic structure can be demonstrated that turns on the pivotal challenge of friendship with the world versus friendship with God (3:13-4:10). In this schema, James 5:7-18 and 5:19-20 form the closing two segments, steadfastness in trial and prayer followed by a conclusio, that correspond with the opening epitome (1:1-27) and instruction on faith and works (2:1-26). Therefore, an examination of the genre and structure of James with an eye toward its integrity as a piece of early Christian literature precedes an exegesis of the final passages, which in turn leads to conclusions regarding the author’s eschatology, rooted in the fundamental moral code of the early Jesus movement. The force of the epistle as reflected in these closing verses calls the community to live in communion in this paradigm shift of telos and fulfillment. This is the work wrought by the fullness of faith, and the saving action that will ultimately bring redemption and restoration.
|
Wisdom and the Art of Inhabitance
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
William P. Brown, Columbia Theological Seminary
Wisdom and the Art of Inhabitance
|
The Chester Beatty Papyrus 967 and the Old Church Slavonic Bible: New Insights into the Textual History of Ezekiel and Daniel
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Alessandro Maria Bruni, Ca' Foscari University of Venice
The Chester Beatty Papyrus 967, dating from the late second or early third century CE, represents a key source of information for the debate over the variant literary editions of Ezekiel and Daniel. Recent research has shown that some of the unique textual features of this manuscript are also reflected in the Old Church Slavonic version of these books which originated in the late ninth-early tenth century and is today extant in Cyrillic testimonies dating at the earliest from the fourteenth century. The following cases appear to be particularly relevant for comparative textual criticism. On the one hand, the OCS-Ezek conforms to LXX967 in lacking Ezek 12:26-28. Among secondary translations, this omission was previously known to exist in VLWirc only. On the other hand, the OCS-Dan displays very special features at the level of the textual arrangement. In fact, despite being a witness to Theodotion's version (Th-Dan), it unexpectedly presents the same order of chapters found in LXX967, namely Dan 1-4; Dan 7; Dan 8; Dan 5; Dan 6; Dan 9-12. The most fascinating aspect of this agreement is that it is merely confined to the structure of the book and does not affect its internal features. The implication is that the arrangement found in LXX967 should no longer be considered a distinctive trait of the Old Greek (OG). Indeed, the OCS-Dan tradition attests to the previous existence in Greek of a Lucianic redaction of Th-Dan with the very same order of chapters of LXX967. Because Th-Dan is believed to be an independent translation and not a revision of the OG, it may be assumed almost safely that the sequence Daniel 1-4; 7; 8; 5; 6; 9-12 belongs to an earlier literary edition of the book. The testimony of OCS-Dan consequently enables us logically to suppose that at least in the Greek tradition two arrangements of Daniel were adopted for each of the two versions. This is shown by LXX967 and codex Chig. R.VII 45 (LXX88[87]) for the OG, and by OCS-Dan and the rest of the Byzantine manuscript evidence in the case of Th-Dan. The OCS translations were evidently based on Greek prototypes (today lost or still untraced) that replicated a textual stage of transmission that can be thought to have circulated since Late Antiquity. Even if indirectly, they provide us with new insights into the textual history of Ezek and Dan. The detected cases of textual agreement with LXX967 demonstrate that the OCS tradition, which unfortunately still remains completely unknown to most biblical scholars, deserves full consideration and should therefore be finally integrated into LXX studies.
|
A Womanist’s Poetic, Theo-Ethical Response to Sexual Trauma: Ethics, Theology, and Black Women’s Poetry
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Kimi Bryson, Yale University
This paper gestures towards a womanist response to a recent conversation with a friend, indicative of many black women’s experiences of sexual trauma and struggle to reconcile their identity as black women, Christians, and survivors. I put in conversation black feminist writings, womanist ethics and theology, and black women’s poetry to gesture towards a womanist response to sexual trauma. This paper makes three primary claims. First, I assert that womanist theology and ethics provides a firm foundation for Christian responses to sexual trauma. Second, I argue for contemporary womanist ethics as a crucial dialogue partner for sexual trauma survivors. And finally, I posit the moral knowledge gleaned from three black women’s poems as guides for womanist responses to sexual trauma.
|
Hebrews as Exile Literature
Program Unit: Hebrews
Debra Bucher, Vassar College
In its construction of a new priesthood and a new sacrificial system, Hebrews makes extensive use of Jewish scripture. The Hebrews author uses the language and the sacrificial framework of Leviticus and uses Psalm 110 to assign Jesus to the priesthood according to the order of Melchizedek, and at the same time use Genesis 14 to assign priority to that priesthood over that of the Levitical priesthood. And after constructing a new priesthood, and a new kind of sacrifice (once, for all, Hebrews 7:27), the argument culminates in Hebrews 8 with the use of Jeremiah 31:31-34 as the call for a new covenant. While numerous scholars have noted the heavy use of “old” sacrificial language to describe the new, they also are quick to suggest a complete break with the past. Language in Hebrews 8:13 that describes the “old” (covenant) as obsolete certainly gives scholars ample reason to make those conclusions.
What happens, though, if we focus on Jeremiah 31 as the key text, not just for the obvious “new covenant” language that it provides, but also as a possible shared experience that it may represent to the author and audience of Hebrews? Jeremiah’s oracle, itself dates from a traumatic period: the start of the Babylonian Exile. More than one scholar has situated Hebrews in a context of suffering or persecution as a result of a Christ-centered belief. Other scholars, most notably Pamela Eisenbaum, have argued that Hebrews was “a desperate attempt to construct anew a religious heritage that seems to have all but disappeared” (2008) as a result of the decimation of the Jerusalem Temple and the end of the sacrificial cult (assuming, along with Eisenbaum a post-70CE date). Jews around the Mediterranean were scattered into a new exile as a result of multiple aggressions against them. Instead of religious controversy as the incentive for the author of Hebrews, it was, instead, religious survival. Interestingly, another Jewish group, the Essenes, who could be interpreted as living in a self-imposed exile, also used Jeremiah in their expressions of a “new covenant.” I maintain that the use of Jeremiah 31 helps us see Hebrews in a different light. Exile, whether it’s spiritual, geographic, or metaphorical, requires transformation of thought and practice. Interestingly, another Jewish group, the Essenes, who could be interpreted as living in a self-imposed exile, also used Jeremiah in their expressions of a “new covenant.” Using the Essenes as a comparator, Hebrews could represent another, later, Jewish approach to exile. Reading Hebrews as a form of exile literature allows us to understand the unique aspects of the text, what it uses from the past, and how modern readers may move forward in reading the supersessionism of the text in a way that does not pit one living religion over another.
|
Reading Rahab the Harlot: John Calvin’s Interpretation of Rahab’s Profession
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
Emily Buck, Fuller Theological Seminary
Rahab is an enigmatic figure in Scripture. Her profession proves to be a perennial problem in the history of interpretation. Despite her profession as a harlot, Scripture portrays Rahab in a positive light. She is listed Christ’s genealogy in Matthew, and is praised for her faith and works in Hebrews and James. In the paper, I explore interpretations of Rahab’s profession. Specifically, I examine John Calvin’s interpretation of Rahab the harlot, drawn primarily from his commentary on Joshua. Calvin’s interpretations are compared with the interpretations of his predecessors. Unlike the ancients, Calvin not only labels Rahab as a harlot, he also insists on this as her profession and seeks to discredit the Jewish exegetes who sought to soften her image. While opposing prostitution and admitting that Rahab’s profession was shameful, Calvin does not give evidence of a moral struggle with the fact of her profession. He emphasizes that her salvation was due to God’s grace. To Calvin, Rahab’s lowliness served to put God’s goodness and grace on display.
|
How to Read Alien Texts
Program Unit:
Jorunn J. Buckley, Bowdoin College
First, I say a few words about how and why I, a European, came to the U. of Chicago Div. School in history of religions to study with J. Z. Smith as my doctoral advisor in 1975. I was also a TA with JZS in several BA courses there.
JZS’s handwritten and typed handouts, both for Ph. D. students and for undergraduates, were initially puzzling. Why these kinds of materials? What were we to learn from e.g. the long list of items in the Egyptian Negative Confession of sins, ca. 1550 BC, or the 14 sections long bibliography on Babylonian Astronomy, ending with the Mani Codex? Figuring out the contexts for such texts was a central aim. JZS taught you to ferret out the interests and the positions of ancient authors, and also to find “the place to stand” for yourself as a student and as a budding scholar. You belong to a tradition, and you also find yourself in the wobbly arena of innovation, of not-yet-a-place. How will you argue for your views? There’s no “last word” in any area of study, and yours won’t be that, either. Grasp the risk of your taking your stand, and be clear in your argumentation to your readers. JZS went through every word of my Ph. D. proposal, making sure that I understood the necessity of absolute precision in it. He also held Saturday morning seminars for us Ph. D. students, with assigned book readings. Why that particular book? Well, that became an exercise in studying JZS own scholarly interests: he is the alien text!
JZS lacked dogmatism and faith in time-honored ways of research. Avoid taming the texts! Let them out of the zoo of traditional treatments of them! Your job is to show how you apply theory and method in your work. He distrusted sheer conceptual thinking (note his utterance: “there’s no data for religion”); he harbored no vengeance-goals in research, as in “I’ll nail my predecessor-in-the-field” attitude. There was no demand for loyalty to JZS as your Doktor-Vater, so don’t try to be a clone! Here one should recall F. Nietzsche’s saying that you treasure your teacher badly if you always remain his pupil. The issue is your own work. Still, JZS was our brave model, and I once gave him a bumper sticker saying “Chutzpah is not hubris, you know.” He smiled, and propped it up on his desk.
Other anecdotes will illustrate some of the above.
|
Mother Jerusalem and the Distressed Matriarchs of Tobit, 2 Maccabees 7, and Judith
Program Unit: Transmission of Traditions in the Second Temple Period
Pauline Paris Buisch, University of Notre Dame
In prophetic passages such as Isaiah 54, the matriarchs of Hebrew Bible narratives are projected onto the city of the Jerusalem. The dejected woman addressed by the prophet evokes the familiar stories of Israel’s mothers by her barrenness, widowhood, abandoned state, and also by the divine promises made to her. In this application of the matriarchal narratives to the city of Jerusalem, the image of the distressed matriarch is translated from narrative to prophecy. This paper demonstrates that this process is then reversed in the Second Temple texts of Tobit, 2 Maccabees 7, and Judith. These Second Temple authors wrote new stories featuring a distressed matriarch, thus transmitting the familiar figure back into narrative, but now infused with a prophetic understanding of her emblematic status. By means of literary allusions to prophetic passages in which Jerusalem is personified as a woman, the experiences of the matriarchal figures in Tobit, 2 Maccabees 7, and Judith are presented as paradigmatic of the experience of mother Jerusalem, and therefore the people of Israel.
|
Disciplining the Soul: Ritual, Theology, and the Biblical and Post-biblical Antecedents of Fasting in the Qur’an
Program Unit: The Qur’an and the Biblical Tradition (IQSA)
Stephen Burge, Institute of Ismaili Studies
The study of fasting in the Qur’an and in Islam more generally has gained relatively little attention. The only major study is Kees Wagtendonk’s Fasting in Islam which was published back in 1968 and very little has appeared since then. This paper will examine the Qur’anic references to the Ramadan fast, mainly Q. 2:183-185 in light of Jewish and Christian Biblical and post-Biblical literature. This paper will explore the issue of fasting in the Qur’an from three specific angels.
The fasting during a specific time of the year, for a designated period of time. In the Qur’an this is, of course, the month of Ramadan, but the Muslim tradition was well aware of other religious fasts, particularly the Christian fast of Lent, and the Jewish fast of atonement. This is mentioned twice in the main Qur’anic fasting pericope, both in Q. 2:183 and 2:185. This section will examine the extent to which the Ramadan fast is part of a wider tradition of seasonal fasting.The second theme will be the Qur’anic permission for those who are ill or travelling to abstain from the fast. Again this appears twice in the Qur’anic fasting pericope, once in Q. 2:184 in relation to the payment of a fidya (or ‘recompense’) to make up for missing the fast, and again in Q. 2:185. This will focus on issues such as travel, capacity, illness, and menstruation, as reasons for abandoning the fast. The final section will examine the association with prayer and fasting. Although the Qur’an does not directly associate prayer and fasting, as the Bible does in Acts 13:3 and 14:23 (as well as elsewhere), the two devotional acts are often linked in Islam. This section will briefly explore the theological and devotional aspect of fasting.
Although these are, by no means, all of the issues connected to fating in the Qur’an, or in Islam more generally, it is hoped that by exploring the Biblical and post-Biblical understanding of fasting, a more nuanced understanding of Qur’anic ritual and theological value fasting can be gained.
|
The Amorites and Identity in Ancient Israel and Judah
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Aaron A. Burke, University of California, Los Angeles
Amorites, much like Philistines, played a central if less evident role in the negotiation of Judean identity in biblical tradition. In difference to the Philistines whose cultural floruit is relatively well defined, a framework remains lacking for understanding the contribution of the Amorites to the formation and negotiation of Judean and other Iron Age identities. However, recent studies of the material culture, customs, and practices of Amorite groups during the first half of the second millennium permit the identification of a constellation of traditions that arguably contributed to a cultural palimpsest, which informed a number of biblical traditions. Among these are legal practices, elite burial customs, temple architecture, and kingship. Although in some cases polemical efforts were made to differentiate Judean identity from that of earlier Amorite practices, in other cases this heritage was evidently acknowledged. Whether or not they were acknowledged, the traditions of Israelite, Judean, and neighboring societies drew upon a cultural koine that originated in the Middle Bronze Age, a period of cultural floruit in Canaan under Amorite hegemony.
|
The Hermeneutical Benefits of Wirkungsgeschichte: Patristic Applications of the Maxim to "Render to Caesar and to God" as a Case Study
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Simeon Burke, University of Edinburgh
This paper contributes to recent discussions on the necessity of effective-history for New Testament exegesis through close examination of a single case study-the patristic interpretation of the famous command to 'render to Caesar what is Caesar's and to God what is God's' (Mark 12.17; Matt. 22.21; Luke 20.25). In response to valid concerns about the nature and goal of the effective-historical task, I argue that it is essential to distinguish between the exegetical and hermeneutical priorities of such work. At the exegetical level, the study of subsequent effects significantly broadens the interpretive options. Yet these possibilities are often more significant for the history of interpretation of an individual NT text, than for the interpretation of that text in its historical context. This leads me to contend that even if NT exegesis benefits less from the exegetical results of Wirkungsgeschichte, it can more meaningfully profit from the hermeneutical assumptions and methods of previous readers. I demonstrate how attention to the grammatical training of certain patristic authors largely explains the multiple applications of the "render" command in the early Roman period, since these authors used the command as a maxim that could apply to multiple situations. This finding provokes questions about the parallels and discontinuities in the methods and motivations of ancient and modern reading cultures. To what extent do modern scholars consider the command to speak to different ethical issues? If there is resistance to such an enterprise, why might this be the case? These questions highlight that the impact of a text can profoundly contribute not only to contemporary NT exegesis, but perhaps even more so to the hermeneutical endeavour.
|
Opera Evangelica: The Discovery of a Lost Collection of Christian Apocrypha
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Tony Burke, York University
Within the holdings of the Thomas Fisher Rare Book Library at the University of Toronto there is a curious, rarely-examined hand-written book entitled Opera Evangelica: or the Gospel of St. James and Nicodemus, together with some other remarkable pieces of antiquity. The title page gives little indication of its authorship (it states only “Done into English by I. B.”) or its date of creation. In the bottom right corner is written “E. R. Mores. Jun. 24. 1740,” indicating it was owned by Edward Rowe Mores, a Roman Catholic antiquarian educated in Oxford. The most recent work of scholarship cited in the introduction is William Wake’s edition of the Apostolic Fathers published in 1693, providing a terminus post quem for the work. It appears to predate the publication of Jeremiah Jones’s A New and Full Method of Settling the Canonical Authority of the New Testament in 1726, regarded as the first collection of Christian apocrypha into English. If so, Opera Evangelica supersedes Jones as the earliest English apocrypha compendium, though it never made a mark on scholarship and few people, it seems, are even aware of its existence. A second copy of the book has been found in the University of Cambridge; this copy has some unique features: the number of texts is expanded, some translations are accompanied by the texts in Latin, and on the title page is written “E libris Thomae Davies” (a Scottish bookseller and author, ca. 1713–1785). This paper presents Opera Evangelica to a modern audience for the first time. It examines various features of the work, including its place within English scholarship in the early eighteenth-century, the editions or manuscripts of apocryphal texts that lie behind the translations, and the views expressed on Christian apocrypha by its mysterious author. Scholars of Christian apocrypha delight in finding “lost gospels” but in Opera Evangelica we have something truly unique: a long-lost collection of Christian apocrypha.
|
Zion the City of Light (Isaiah 60): In Search for a Structure beyond Diachronic and Synchronic Perspectives
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Micaël Bürki, Université de Lausanne
The oracle concerning the rise of the nations to Zion (Isaiah 60) is largely recognized as a written prophecy elaborated from many fragments, essentially borrowed from First and Deutero-Isaiah. The logic of their assembly is more difficult to grasp. Structures elaborated from different perspectives (poetical, thematic, structural…) have been proposed without reaching a consensus.
In this paper, I propose to start with some diachronic observations, made by O. Steck concerning the intertextuality with Isaiah 49, to establish an empirical basis for the structure. Then taking account of some classical features of biblical poetry I will show how different fragments are put together in a structure elaborated by the repetition of expressions, words or synonyms.
This analysis illustrates the gain to mix and match with diachronic and synchronic approach.
|
Seated in God's Temple: Explicating 2 Thess 2:4 from Epigraphic and Archaeological Sources Connected to Roman Imperial Divine Honors
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
D. Clint Burnett, Boston College
Scholars continue to debate the precise meaning, purpose, and implications of 2 Thess 2:4’s description of the Man of Lawlessness being “seated in God’s temple, thereby demonstrating that he himself is a god.” This paper examines heretofore-overlooked evidence from epigraphic and archaeological sources to demonstrate that the background of 2 Thess 2:4 is the practice of Roman emperors as temple sharers. Rulers in the Greek East from the third century BCE to the third century CE shared temples of gods because of benefaction that they provided to Greek cities. The purpose of such cases of temple sharing was to showcase the piety of said ruler seated in the god’s temple and to demonstrate physically that the deity whose temple the monarch shared approved of his/her reign.
|
Fate, Fortune, and Freedom in the Hermetica
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Dylan M. Burns, Freie Universität Berlin
The complex of problems relating to providence, fate, and free will are among the most difficult of those presented by the Hermetic literature, not least due to the diversity of the terminology employed, as well as the range of solutions and doctrines expressed across the various Hermetic treatises. In honor of Arthur Darby Nock’s manifold contributions to our understanding of ancient Mediterranean religion, particularly Hermetism and Gnosticism - not least his magisterial critical edition of the Corpus Hermeticum itself - this paper will address some neglected or misunderstood passages regarding providence, fate, determinism, and freedom in the Hermetic corpus.
|
Astrological Determinism, Free Will, and Eros According to Thecla in Methodius of Olympus’s Symposium
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Dylan M. Burns, Freie Universität Berlin
The eighth discourse of Methodius of Olympus’ Symposium is delivered by perhaps the most famous figure we meet in the treatise, Thecla, who concludes with a polemic against astrological determinism. It is Thecla who is assigned, in a discourse whose title cannot refer to anything but Plato’s most beautiful dialogue, the last word on the philosophical questions of agency, desire, and will. Many scholars have touched upon Thecla’s polemic, attempting to diagnose its sources and proper contextualization in the history of early Christian ideas about astrology, determinism, and free will, and Gnostic sources have played a significant role in such attempts. However, thorough doxographical studies of Thecla’s attack on astrological determinism are rare indeed. This paper will therefore discuss the arguments and philosophical valence of Thecla’s remarks on astrological determinism and freedom. It will be maintained that Methodius here responds to views we today regard as having been held by Bardaisan, Origen, and some Gnostic sources—as well as Plato himself in his own Symposium—in order to articulate what Methodius believed to be the proper conception of human responsibility in a world where the heavens are inhabited by stars and demons alike.
|
The Snake, the Poet: Poetry and Duplicity in Margaret Atwood’s Poetry and the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Sean Burt, North Dakota State University Main Campus
A reader of the Bible who comes to the poetry of Margaret Atwood cannot but be struck by the mythologically resonant images of the “Snake Poems” cycle in 1984’s Interlunar. Central to these poems are complex associations between the the snake and the poet. The snake shares an affinity with the poet, but it remains distant from and alien to her. Further, it is opaque and grotesque, yet also seductive: an inaccessible, inhuman muse. In the “Snake Poems,” the serpent is simultaneously an emblem of the cosmos’s fundamental silence and of the divine power of language to transform the poet. Atwood’s serpentine imagery here evokes, among other things, the crafty edenic serpent and enigmatic Nehushtan fashioned by Moses, even if the link between snake and poet is perhaps not direct in biblical texts. However, Atwood’s reflection on these same sets of images 20 years on in 2007’s The Door opens up onto a more substantial connection with biblical poetry. In that volume’s untitled cycle of poems on poetry, Atwood depicts the poet less as an austere oracular visionary than as a rumpled and ineffectual object of derision. Most notably, these poems draw on an idea of Atwood’s, developed elsewhere in her work, that the writer is “two-handed,” simultaneously duplicitous and truth-telling. Reading The Door alongside Interlunar creates a vision of the poet that begins to resemble a figure central to biblical literature: the prophetic poet. Biblical prophets lie, they steal one another’s words (Jer 23), they are derided as a “parable peddlers” (Ezek 21), and, most embarrassingly, offer no sure way to distinguish true from false prophecy. Furthermore, like that of Atwood’s poet, the prophet’s art is double—it gestures toward a voice beyond typical human experience that is also inescapably the human artist’s craft.
|
Hebrew in Hebrew: Storytelling to Teach Biblical Hebrew vayyiqtol to Beginners in an Immersion Setting
Program Unit: Global Education and Research Technology
Randall Buth, Biblical Language Center, Israel, and Institute for Biblical Languages and Translation
Research leads to recommendations that teachers should use the target language 90% or more in a classroom. This includes all human languages, ancient and modern. Contrary to some expectations, such language teaching can be adapted to include the teaching of complex (strange) structures in ancient languages. A demonstration will be given showing how to teach the vayyiqtol (thematic verb-structure) using biblical Hebrew itself. An easy, humorous story will be taught in biblical Hebrew with TPRS techniques (Teaching Proficiency Through Reading and Storytelling) and the vayyiqtol structures will be introduced in a meaningful and understandable context. This training is important because it leads to an internalization of important pragmatic aspects of Hebrew that enlarge, refine, and go beyond traditional grammatical conceptions. (The audience will have a handout of basic, presupposed vocabulary and the demonstration will include preliminary steps and techniques.)
|
John 1:1-18 as a Deification Text: The Ecclesial Vision of Filiation and Divine-Human Exchange in the Fourth Gospel's Prologue
Program Unit: Biblical Exegesis from Eastern Orthodox Perspectives
Andrew Byers, St John's College, Durham University
John's Prologue is a deification text. When patristic theologians wrote about theosis, they were drawing on biblical themes that appear not only in Paul and in the Catholic Epistles, but also in the opening lines of the Fourth Gospel. Though biblical scholars have often dismissed ecclesiology as a major theme in John, this paper will argue that the Prologue inseparably weds Christology to an ecclesial vision of corporate deification. This Johannine theosis entails the re-origination of "children of God" who are born "from above" and into the divine family of the Father and Son. The process of supernatural filiation that unfolds in the narrative proper is adumbrated in the Prologue as "God", the "Word", and general references to humanity disambiguate from such abstract categorizations into "Father," "Son," and "children." Moreover, the Prologue's account of the Word's Incarnation establishes the pattern of divine-human exchange, one of the primary Christological grounds for later discourse on theosis. Anticipating later exchange formulas, John 1:11-14 implies that humans become divine because the divine became human. Though John's Gospel is rarely understood as bearing ecclesiological interests, and though Pauline texts have received the most attention in the renewed interest in theosis, this paper will show that the Johannine Prologue is as ecclesial as it is Christological and establishes a robust vision for the church's corporate deification.
|
The Contribution and Limitation of the Secular Understandings of Paul as a Political Thinker on Law
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
Hyongju Byon, Chicago Theological Seminary
Recently, it is remarkable that Paul is again being welcomed by secular scholars such as Giorgio Agamben, Alain Badiou, and Slavoj Žižek. They turn to the issue of law in Paul. In this paper I will deal with these three secular thinkers in terms of their understandings of law in Paul in their work: The Time That Remains: A Commentary on the Letter to the Romans, Saint Paul: The Foundation of Universalism, and The Puppet and the Dwarf: The Perverse Core of Christianity. First, I will show where their work on Paul can be located in the development of Pauline studies. This will prove that they rehabilitate Paul as a political thinker on law as such not restricted to the Mosaic law. It is true that law has never been considered as law as such in Pauline studies. Rather the law in Paul is assumed as an ethnic, religious, or cultural edifice of the Jews. Therefore, to understand Paul as a political thinker on law as such has been absolutely absent in the development of Pauline studies quite for a long time.
Then I will explore how each secular thinker deals with Paul. These three secular understandings of Paul are valuable to remind us that, for Paul, what is the most problematic and urgent issue is law. Also, they show how the messianic subjectivity in Paul should be understood in terms its relation to law as such. Nevertheless, they share two limitations in common. First, I will point out that they never consider law as such in term of justice. By doing that, they miss Paul’s core message of God’s justice in terms of law as such. Second, I will argue that they overlook the colonial circumstance in which Paul encounters law as such. With the consideration of the colonial situation, appealing to Homi Bhabha’s ideas of colonial subjectivity, I will interpret Romans 13:1-7 and 1 Corinthians 7:29-31 in order to show that the messianic subjectivity in Paul should be understood in terms of the colonized as well as law as such. In the long run, this will show that secular political thinkers and postcolonial studies can enrich Pauline studies together.
|
The Legacy of Cain
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
John Byron, Ashland Theological Seminary
Genesis 4 describes the first and most infamous of murders. Cain, envious of his brother, lures Abel into a field and commits the first recorded act of fratricide. But in spite of this murderous treachery, Cain’s punishment is more perplexing than just. Although forced to wander, he is given a mark of protection from God, allowed to marry, have children and build a city. Over the centuries Jews and Christians have retold and reinterpreted the story in literature and the visual arts. While this is expected in religious contexts, what is somewhat surprising is the degree to which the story has also impacted so-called “low’ culture. While sacred music contains little to no mention of Cain and Abel, there are dozens of references to and retellings of the story in pop/rock music. Popular artists such as Cher, John Mellencamp, Prince, and Bruce Springsteen (to name just a few) have incorporated references and retellings of the story into songs and often with a particular focus on the person and legacy of Cain. This paper traces how the Cain and Abel story has exerted significant influence over these artists’ as they reinterpret and apply the tale of Cain’s treachery in their own contexts. For some artists, Cain’s evil deed casts a long shadow over humanity whereby many are labeled the “children of Cain” and carry the mark laid on him by God.
|
The Relationship of the Laws in Ex 22:16–17 and Deut 22:28–29: Supercessionist, Complementary, or Other?
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Jay Caballero, The University of Texas at Austin
The precise nature of the relationship between the Covenant Code and the later law codes continues to vex scholars. In a recent JBL article, Joshua Berman claims that two competing positions on this relationship have emerged: the Supercessionist and the Complementary. Those who advocate the Supercessionist approach claim that later authors intended their law codes to completely supplant the existing one. The Complementarians hold that the succeeding law codes are merely re-applications of the existing law. Thus, the authors of the new law intended that this new law live in harmony with the existing law, as no conflict, but also no dependence, between the two existed. The two codes were designed to address different situations. Berman himself tends to side with the advocates of the Complementary theory. This paper will engage in a case study by applying these two legal theories to the only passages in the Pentateuch that address sexual intercourse between a man and an unbetrothed virgin, Ex 22:16-17 and Deut 22:28-29. This paper will attempt to rigorously apply each theory in turn to the question of how the author of the Deuteronomy passage intended that passage to relate to the E material in Ex 22. The conclusions that emerge from the application of those theories will be evaluated, and it will be determined which of those theories coheres better with the evidence. Finally, this paper will posit and consider an alternative legal maxim, the “Presumption of General Application.” This maxim will then be applied to those same passages. The results of that application will demonstrate that it is more likely that the Deuteronomist was implementing the Presumption of General Application as he composed his laws in Deut 22, in light of Ex 22, than that he was utilizing either the Supercessionist or the Complementary approach.
|
If You Want to Be Heard, Make a Noise: Markan Textual Evocations of Speech-Events and Audiential Environments in an Imperial Context
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Alan Cadwallader, Charles Sturt University
Alessandro Duranti has drawn attention to the importance of spatial context for the shaping of a speech event. This element has received little attention in either linguistics or biblical studies. Those who do give themselves to the oral delivery or performance act of Mark’s Gospel rarely offer more than a wave towards a worship setting with an occasional alternative given generically as “mission”. Hence the key person is characterized as either a lector or a performer. This paper seeks to interrogate the text for three main elements. Firstly, what poetic and rhetorical structures are found in the text that invite an audience response so as to shape a speech event; secondly, what might these constructed speech events imply about the personnel involved in the delivery of Mark’s gospel; and thirdly, what settings or spatial contexts can be inferred from such elements. This last invites a consideration of the tension between the narrative setting(s) in the Gospel within which teaching and action occurs and the possible built environments within which a receptive and engaged audience is located. The spotlight for an interrogation of this tension will be the parables chapter (Mark 4).
|
Any Excuse for a Party: Zeus and Hermes and Human-Divine Interactions in Asia Minor and Acts 14:8–20
Program Unit: Polis and Ekklesia: Investigations of Urban Christianity
Alan Cadwallader, Charles Sturt University
In 1909, William Calder announced to the popular press the discovery, just north of a site identified as Lystra, of a statue and inscription that combined Zeus and Hermes. Since then, Calder’s discovery has been recycled many times as a demonstration of the probability of an historical context for the Lycaonian encounter in Acts 14. Comparanda for the Zeus-Hermes connection have sometimes been drawn from Phrygia, as well as from textual sources (such as Ovid and Plautus). This paper seeks to revisit the epigraphical and visual connection of Zeus and Hermes, exploring their provenance, function and significance for epiphanies on the one hand and ascriptions of divinity on the other. It will test whether there is anything peculiarly Lycaonian or even Galatian in the evidence and how such evidence might have relevance for the story of Barnabas and Paul in Acts.
|
Christian Wittig vs. Rabbinic Irigaray? Boyarin’s Parting of the (Gender) Ways Reconsidered
Program Unit: Gender, Sexuality, and the Bible
Jonathan Cahana, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
In a highly influential article, Daniel Boyarin has argued that a contemporary split within feminist theory – represented by Monique Wittig and Luce Irigaray – reproduces the divergence between two ancient competitive worldviews: early Christianity and rabbinic Judaism. While rabbinic Judaism – like Irigaray – was fully committed to a naturalized concept of gender, early Christianity attempted to transcend it. Neither of which, however, bodes well for women (or, as Boyarin more precisely refers to them in this context, to “human beings born with a ‘vagina’”): while the first concept traps women in their biological role, the second promises transcendence that is predicated on the effacement of femininity and ends up reproducing a highly masculine concept of androgyny.
In this paper, I will suggest that Boyarin’s paradigm, while still of help for mapping ancient Jewish and Christian approached to gender, requires a thorough revision to do justice to the evidence at hand. First, I will argue that Wittig’s feminist analysis, in which both sex and gender constitute a meticulously constructed conspiracy to enslave more than half of humankind, can only be paralleled within gnostic Christianity. Proto-orthodox sources, while acknowledging the problematics of gender, treat it either as a second-best situation, or, less frequently, as a result of a well-deserved fall due to sin. In both latter cases, the creation of gender is ultimately justified, and thus cannot be paralleled by Wittig’s socio-cultural analysis. It is thus only in gnostic writing that gender is unjustified – or, rather, thoroughly evil – instrument of oppression and enslavement, and thus form a viable parallel to Wittig and other radical feminist approaches, metaphysics notwithstanding. Yet, it is also specifically in gnostic sources, in which Boyarin’s second claim, that transcendent androgyny was always predicated on masculinity, is also called into question. Second, I will argue that Boyarin’s argument regarding the continuity between Hellenistic Judaism – represented in this case mostly by Philo of Alexandria – and early Christian concepts of gender must be qualified, since in some cases Philo appears to be more in concurrence with early Rabbinical ideas. Third, I will suggest that a deeper analysis of Genesis Rabbah evinces another important qualification to the concept of “naturalized gender,” and that the latter can be brought out through a deeper engagement with Irigaray’s analysis.
While modern feminist analysis is certainly of much use in analyzing ancient understandings of sex and gender, and thus Boyarin’s basic method has much to recommend it, my paper will demonstrate that such course requires a minute attention to detail, which could nevertheless result in a helpful generalized scheme of ancient Jewish and Christian approaches to gender and their multifaceted relationship to modern feminist and queer theory.
|
Solomon the Seal-Bearer: The Baptism of an Islamic Tale
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
David Calabro, Saint John's University
The proposed paper focuses on the medieval Arabic tale of Solomon and the palace of Shaddad ibn ‘Ad. Although the tale’s intertextuality centers almost wholly on the Qur’an and on legends that occur elsewhere in Islamic contexts, the tale itself circulated predominantly in Christian manuscripts, alongside miracle stories of Christian saints. The story culminates in a combat between Solomon and a host of demons that inhabits an idol. The gesture which Solomon uses to banish the demons is the pivotal device that converts this story into a Christian tale. I discuss how this case might inform a general theory of the means by which transmitters of religious narratives “appropriate” the narratives on behalf of religious communities.
|
A Matter of Interest: In Memory of Jonathan Z. Smith
Program Unit:
Ron Cameron, Wesleyan University (Middletown, CT)
I propose to present a paper that engages Smith’s work methodologically and theoretically, in terms of his comparative method and efforts to construct a cognitive theory of religion. Smith seeks to situate the comparative enterprise, including biblical studies, within the overall project of the study of religion. Paying special attention to his writings that are concerned chiefly with biblical studies, I will discuss Smith’s program, methodologically, in terms of description (locating select examples within the rich texture of their social, historical, and cultural environments, and describing how our second-order scholarly tradition has intersected with the chosen exempla), comparison (both in terms of aspects and relations held to be significant, and with respect to some category, question, or theory of interest to us as students of religion), redescription (of the exempla being compared, each in light of the other), andrectification (of the academic categories in relation to which they have been imagined). Theoretically, I will focus on Smith’s recognition of difference—rather than similarity—as the point of entrée and critical leverage for explanation and interpretation, and insistence on translation—which he has described as “the most urgent current intellectual issue within the human sciences”—as an intellectual operation that necessarily entails difference and discrepancy and, therefore, that constitutes the horizon of both scientific explanation and humanistic interpretation. I will conclude with a few anecdotes I have heard Smith tell over the years, which illustrate his work and reflect his incomparable depth of character.
|
The Labors of Burton Mack: Scholarship That's Made a Difference
Program Unit: Redescribing Christian Origins
Ron Cameron, Wesleyan University (Middletown, CT)
Contributions of Burton Mack, especially those that have been formative for the agenda of the Redescribing seminar.
|
The Prayers of Women in Old Testament Narratives: A Theological Exploration
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Phillip G. Camp, Lipscomb University
The Prayers of Women in Old Testament Narratives: A Theological Exploration
|
Memory and Covenant: Deuteronomy's Core in Light of its Frame
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Stephen D. Campbell, University of Durham
Memory and Covenant: Deuteronomy's Core in Light of its Frame
|
The Residue of Matthean Polemics in the Ascension of Isaiah: On the Pseudepigraphic Faultline of Jewish-Christian Relations
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Warren C. Campbell, University of Notre Dame
This paper makes a bivalent argument relative to the reception of the Gospel of Matthew in the Ascension of Isaiah (AscIs), one that seeks to integrate reception history with Jewish-Christian relations. Accordingly, this paper develops in two stages. First, based on the Greek Amherst papyri, P.Amh. I.1 (AscIs 2.4b-4.4a), as well as the Gəʿəz editions of the AscIs, this paper argues that the AscIs has absorbed the Matthean tradition by adopting unique lexical and conceptual items (see esp. AscIs 1.4, 3.13, 3.14, 3.15-17, 3.18a, 4.3). These points of contact uncover larger points of affiliation, specifically, that the AscIs has fashioned the figure of Isaiah as an imitation of the Matthean Jesus. Moreover, since Isaiah’s Matthean-infused vision of the ‘Beloved’ is said to be secretly recorded in a book (which is a cypher for the Book of Isaiah, see 4.20-21) and the use of Isaiah in Matthew is notably prominent (Matt 1.22-23, 3.3, 8.17, 12.17-21, 13.14-15, 15.7-9, 21.4-5, 21.13), the AscIs functions as a literary prequel for the Gospel of Matthew in which Isaiah inscribes his vision of the Beloved in the Book of Isaiah which is then elucidated in turn in the Gospel of Matthew. Such textual, figurative, and literary associations between the AscIs and Matthew are suggestive of an overlapping social function between this early Christian gospel and this second-century pseudepigraphon.
Accordingly, the second stage of this paper argues that Matthew and the AscIs share a similar social function, namely, both texts seek to establish and substantiate their own in-group in light of the dissent of proximate groups with a similar religious affiliation by means of two motifs: the martyred prophet and in-group polemical discourse featuring an esteemed Jewish figure. Thus, the affiliation established with the Matthean tradition has a targeted aim, namely, that through reception and mimicry the AscIs has imbibed these dual Matthean motifs a means of perpetuating the polemic interests of Matthean Christianity. Still, key differences remain. While the polemical thrust of Matthew functions to establish a narrative context for the particularities of the Matthean community in light of perceived challenges from neighboring Jewish traditions, the AscIs is attempting to defend the specific practice of heavenly ascent visions in light of other groups of Christ-devotees who dissent from this emphasis. The former is largely an intra-religious polemic operating within a Jewish religious boundary in which Matthew negotiates and maps a self-definition for early Christ-devotees with Jewish interlocutors in its purview (Verheyden, Saldarini, Overman). On the other hand, while the religious affiliation of the AscIs is equally complex, and, together with Matthew, its proximity with Judaism is well noted (Piovanelli, Frankfurter), it has repositioned Matthew’s intra-religious polemic for a new intra-religious environment in which the interlocutors are now adjacent sub-groups of Christ-devotees. Both Mathew and the AscIs represent Jewish-Christianit(ies), but the polemical environment has shifted. As a result, the AscIs is a key hinge in the history of Jewish-Christian relations, as intra-Jewish polemics are repositioned by Jewish Christ-devotees for an intra-Christian context.
|
From Jewish-Christian Counter-History to Ecclesial Normativity: The Epistula Clementis in the Archival History of the Pseudo-Clementine Recognitions
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
Warren C. Campbell, University of Notre Dame
This paper explores Late Antique and Medieval anthologies containing the Pseudo-Clementine Recognitions (R) and the Epistula Clementis (EpCl) in order to engage a lingering question in Pseudo-Clementine scholarship. In light of its early context as a 3rd–4th c. Jewish-Christian “counter-history” of the apostolic past (Reed, Jones), why does R, together with the attached EpCl, have such a voluminous Latin manuscript ‘afterlife’ beginning with Rufinus of Aquileia? An examination of the collected items located within these Latin anthologies reveals a fairly uniform practice of associating R, prefaced by the Ep.C, with either (i) a forged Clementine letter stemming from the Pseudo-Isidorian Decretals (9th c. collection of pseudonymous letters which attempt to re-cast the papal past), (ii) a host of authors and texts associated (in varying degrees) with early ecclesial authority and succession (e.g. Gregory the Great, Cyprian, Eusebius, Augustine, Basil, Canons of the Apostles, etc), or (iii) a variety of Petrine material (Passion of Peter, Acts of Peter, Passion of the Apostle Peter and Paul). Accordingly, I note that the practice of collecting and juxtaposing R/Ep.Cl with these texts reveals that the Pseudo-Clementine tradition was valued for its contribution to ecclesial succession and authority. Furthermore, I argue that the replacement of the Epistula Petri for the EpCl in the editorial history of R (see Photius, Bibliotheca) is integral to the success of this attempted reconfiguration of a Jewish-Christian history into a contribution for ecclesial historiography. Here I seize upon Foucault’s (re)description of commentary as that which has transformative effects on the object of comment, arguing that, by acting as a commentary upon this ‘Jewish-Christian’ novel, the EpCl transforms the Recognitions by introducing a Petrine voice that is deeply concerned with ecclesial matters in order to direct a desired reading of R as a whole. To use Foucault’s idiom, the EpCl transforms the Recognitions into something other than what it was intended to be, on the condition that it was that way all along. This editorial interplay eases the reception of the Pseudo-Clementines into the Medieval program of projecting ecclesial authority into early Christianity. Since the process of editing and collecting generates this vista in the literary and social function of the Recognitions, the larger aim of this paper is to contend that our conceptualization of social and literary functionality must attend to editorial as well as material history.
|
The Problem of Doctrinal Development and Its Application to Post-Reformation Reformed Theology
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Heber Campos, Andrew Jumper Centre, Mackenzie University
Post-Reformation debates on the doctrine of justification are an example of how a progressive reflection on biblical concepts (reason, tradition and culture as subordinate lenses to the sacred text), rather than the new discoveries of incipient revelation through tradition (in regards to John Henry Newman), produce theological maturation which intends to further explain Scripture. The purpose of dealing with maturation is to go against those who dichotomize the Reformation and their immediate heirs in the following century (Post-Reformation), but also to expand on the idea of continuity with development (not monolithic repetition), precision with breadth (careful choice of words), identity with charitable inclusiveness (orthodoxy without being divisive).
|
Varieties of Post-Theism: Book Workshop
Program Unit: Westar Institute
John D. Caputo, Syracuse University
*
|
Two Ancient Syriac Peshitta Versions of 1 Maccabees: Which One Is the True Peshitta? What Is the Other One?
Program Unit: International Syriac Language Project
Ignacio Carbajosa, Universidad San Dámaso
Some Syriac manuscript witnesses have come down to us that preserve translations of biblical texts that must be placed at an intermediate point between the Peshitta (second half of the 2nd century) and the Syrohexapla (beginning of the 7th century) versions. Some could be identified with the Philoxenian translation (year 507); others must be prior, from at least the 5th century. These are very particular Syriac versions of 1 Maccabees, Isaiah, Canticles and Psalms.
The Syriac version of 1 Mac (specifically 1:1 - 14:25) which is preserved in the Codex Ambrosianus (7a1, 6th-7th century), is very different from the one we have attested in the rest of the manuscripts of the Peshitta. The explanatory hypothesis for this double attestation is due to G. Schmidt, who in 1897 proposed understanding the version of 7a1 (S2) as a revision of the original Syriac translation (S1), which is the one attested in the majority of the manuscripts. This revision presumably eliminated the expansions (and conflations) which characterize S1 (and which, according to Schmidt, are due to its character as a free and periphrastic version of the Greek of the LXX), with the help of Greek manuscripts. S2 must be prior to the 6th-7th centuries, the approximate time to which the only manuscript that preserves it, 7a1, is dated, for which reason it could be from the beginning of the 6th century or go back to the 5th century.
Schmidt's explanation is now almost 120 years old and it has not been put to the test by anyone. His hypothesis has been passed down as established tradition without being challenged, to the point that it is taken as certain in the critical edition of the Peshitta from the Peshitta Institute, which prints 7h7 (S1) as the main text, leaving 7a1 (S2) for the odd pages and in a smaller font (from 1:1 up to 14:25; from there on the two versions are joined).
This paper aims to challenge this theory. In fact, this study shows that there is no relationship between S1 and S2, that is, S2 cannot be considered a revision of S1 (intended to eliminate additions) but it must be understood as a new translation made from the Greek. For its part, S1 is characterized by a good number of double readings that could be interpreted on the basis of a double translation, one of which probably came from a Hebrew Vorlage.
|
Imagining Arabia from "Divinely Blessed" to "Accursed Desert": Greco-Roman Stereotypes about Pre-Islamic Arabian Society
Program Unit: The Qur’an and Late Antiquity (IQSA)
Karen L. Carducci, Catholic University of America
Greco-Roman writings help reconstruct the historical environment of the Qur’an. Scholars have used these sources to study Arab ethnogenesis and the history of the Arabian Peninsula. They have overlooked, however, the connections between ancient religious practices and stereotypes about pre-Islamic Arabia embedded in these works. The two prevalent stereotypes about pre-Islamic Arabian society can be labelled as: “Blessed Arabia” and “Desert Arabia” (Arabia Eudaimon/Arabia Beata and Arabia Deserta). Because the former stereotype associated Arabia with ancient religious practices, Greco-Roman writers increasingly imagined Arabia as sacred. By Late Antiquity, in fact, some Christians considered both “Blessed Arabia” and “Desert Arabia” as sacred—or desecrated. The evolution of these stereotypes is part of the cultural environment of the Qur’an, and has implications for qur’anic injunctions about Arabic as a language for revelation. To show that Greeks and Romans increasingly associated pre-Islamic Arabia with sanctity, I survey the term “Arabia” and associated terms within the corpus of Greek and Latin texts and coins through the seventh century CE. Authors do adapt notions of Arabia to their own rhetorical goals, but many characterized Arabia as “blessed”: prosperous and sacred through aromatics. The other prevalent stereotype, “desert Arabia,” associates pre-Islamic Arabia with the desert, transhumance, and pastoralism. By Late Antiquity, because Arabia appeared in Scripture and because Arabs were a source of alien wisdom, this twofold Arabia troubled some Christian encyclopedic writers, e.g., Jerome, Orosius, and Isidore of Seville. They used theology to explain this doublet of Arabias. Their juxtaposition of a blessed Arabia and a neighboring wasteland suggests that Christian elites perceived Arabia as an especially holy place that reflected the sanctity of the pre-Islamic Arabian society. These imagined Arabias lend further support to qur’anic arguments about Arabic as a language of revelation: even Roman outsiders considered Arabic a sacred language because a sanctified people in a land divinely blessed spoke it.
|
Man on Man Violence: A Slippery Insertion into a Pauline Argument in 1 Thessalonians
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Greg Carey, Lancaster Theological Seminary
Jennifer Wright Knust, in her Abandoned To Lust, locates Paul within a trajectory of Jewish, and then Christian, authors who deride their others as sexually depraved. Rhetorical critics have generally failed to engage Knust’s work, I suppose because we have not seen it as a sophisticated instance of rhetorical analysis, the explication of a topos, or rhetorical commonplace. Nor am I certain that Knust would so identify her project. Her chapter on Paul begins with a quotation from the passage I wish to discuss today, 1 Thessalonians 4:3-8.
The passage vexes commentators with notorious problems. When Paul invokes porneia, what behavior or behaviors does he have in mind? When he tells the believers to acquire their own vessels, does he mean they should exercise self-control over their bodies, more specifically their penises, or they should marry? Does Paul’s brother language embrace women? And how do believers, “brothers,” harm one another by practicing porneia?
I cannot resolve the porneia question, nor am I confident in my understanding of the vessels Paul expects the Thessalonians to acquire or control. But I do wish to advance several arguments. First, Paul is not necessarily correcting widespread misbehavior in Thessaloniki, as many commentators assume; instead, he invokes a common topos as an ice-breaker for a more challenging issue he must address. The Thessalonians would no more have approved of adultery than Paul does. Second, far too many commentators neglect the massive cultural gap between the sex lives of ancient Thessalonians and the concerns of contemporary readers. Arguments about fornication and adultery, grounded though they may be in the linguistic conventions of ancient texts, too seldom acknowledge this cultural divide. Third, inclusive language does not help us understand this passage. Here Paul imagines porneia and adultery as violence men commit against other men, not an activity in which women engage. If theologically inclined readers like myself wish to draw any implications from this passage, we should simply acknowledge that Paul regards sexual behavior as social rather than strictly personal. But we dare not suppose we share Paul’s assumptions about sex or sexual morality. And fourth, Paul’s exhortations regarding porneia and communal love in 1 Thess 4:1-12 both reflect a broader preoccupation with external perceptions of the Thessalonian believers. In the end, Paul deploys an unthreatening cultural stereotype as one step toward addressing the more vexing concern about those who have fallen asleep.
|
From Your Birth to Your Youths: Masoretic Pointing as Anti-Christian Polemic in Psalm 110:3
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Robert R. Cargill, University of Iowa
This paper argues that the initial Hebrew text of Ps. 110:3, which was preserved faithfully by the LXX, was altered by later Jewish and rabbinic traditions following the adoption of Ps. 110 by Christians as a favored messianic psalm. Without altering a single letter, the Masoretes codified a reinterpretation of Ps. 110:3, already visible in the Psalms Targum and the Peshitta, which specifically eliminates two references to birth-חילך and ילדתיך-using Masoretic pointing. This obfuscation of the original references to the divine birth/adoption of the king, which is typical of Mesopotamian and early Israelite coronation literature, was done as a polemic response to Christians, who had reinterpreted the psalm as prophecy of the incarnation and birth of Jesus of Nazareth. Because the Hebrew text was already fixed, the Masoretes pointed the text so as to eliminate references to birth while attempting to maintain grammatical congruency with the overall context of the psalm.
|
If It Quacks Like an Article...: Public Scholarship in the Digital Age
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Robert Cargill, University of Iowa
The role of public scholarship has changed since the rise of the internet. In addition to senior scholars distilling peer-reviewed research for public consumption, today’s public research in several fields takes place almost simultaneously in public view, involves scholars who are often younger, more media savvy, and who use tools that disseminate research to the public in a fraction of the time it took two decades ago. This paper explores the transformation of public scholarship and explores some of the biases still held against it by many traditional models of peer-review publication.
|
A Spirit Possession Ritual at En-Dor: Interpreting 1 Samuel 28 Using Anthropological Models
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Reed Carlson, Harvard University
In recent years, New Testament studies has seen a minor resurgence of interest in spirit possession phenomena in Jesus, Paul, and early Christianity (e.g. Pieter Craffert, Colleen Shantz, Jack Levison, and forthcoming Giovanni Bazzana). A variety of factors have led to this resurgence, including the reevaluation of an unconscious scholarly bias against “mystic” readings of New Testament figures that was prominent throughout much of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Also influential has been growing familiarity with Dead Sea Scrolls, Jewish Pseudepigrapha, and Hellenistic texts that operated with sophisticated conceptions of spirits. Arguably, however, the most fruitful new data has come from anthropological and ethnographic studies of spirit possession in cultures around the world as well as recent discoveries in neuroscience. The resulting new models have often challenged, and/or complicated what has long been assumed about spirit possession in the New Testament. So far, this most recent wave of interdisciplinary engagement has largely been limited to the study of late Second Temple and early Christian texts. This presentation aims to contribute to this trend by exploring the fruitfulness of applying theoretical models from contemporary anthropological and ethnographic studies of possession and trance around the world to spirit phenomena texts in the Hebrew Bible by means of a case study: Saul’s visit to the medium at En-Dor (1 Sam 28). The Hebrew Bible has not seen an extensive application of studies of this type since Robert Wilson’s pioneering monograph, Prophecy and Society in Ancient Israel (Fortress 1980). While Wilson made excellent use of the foremost works of his day (e.g. Ioan Lewis and Erika Bourguignon), these more structural-functional approaches have since largely been rejected in anthropology. In this presentation, I utilize more recent models for possession (e.g. Janice Boddy, Michael Lambek, and Paul C. Johnson) as well as broader theories on the religious self (including Charles Taylor and Michel Foucault) in order to explicate 1 Samuel 28 as a spirit possession ritual. I argue that throughout the narratives of 1 Samuel, Saul is presented as an especially “porous” individual, vulnerable to spirit influence and affliction (e.g. 1 Sam 18:11; 19:10). Contrary to western prejudice, this is as much Saul’s strength as it is his weakness. He cultivates positive spirit possession (1 Sam 10:6; 10; 11:6) even as he also seeks therapeutic treatment (1 Sam 16:14–23). After experiencing God’s silence in the approved forms of divination (1 Sam 28:6), Saul consults a professional spirit host in the medium at En-Dor. This medium is presented as the mistress or wife of a “ghost” (1 Sam 28:7). Her mastery of this profession enables her to host the presence of the prophet Samuel in her own body and speak his oracle to Saul. As I hope to show through comparison with ethnographic reports, while the episode is enigmatic in the Hebrew Bible, it is not at all unusual in the context of spirit possession practices around the world and across many eras.
|
The Spirit and the Self in Biblical Literature
Program Unit: Philology in Hebrew Studies
Reed Carlson, Harvard University
The last several decades have seen a growing interest in notions of the self in biblical literature. At stake in many debates has been the question of how similar ancient Israelite and early Jewish constructions of the self were to modern ideas and what role they might play in assessing a genealogy of the western self. A crucial issue raised in a recent monograph by David Lambert (How Repentance Became Biblical. Oxford 2016) has been a criticism of what he sees as a common practice of mischaracterizing language of the self in early Jewish literature according to modern categories. This essay seeks to contribute to this ongoing discussion by arguing that spirit language is a prevalent mode for constructing notions of the self in the Hebrew Bible. Some poetic texts, for example, refer to rûaḥ “spirit” as a body part similar to “heart,” “throat,” and “innards” (Gen 41:8; Prov 15:13; Isa 57:15). However, modern interpreters often miss this more material conception of rûaḥ since it does not easily comport to any organ in the modern anatomy. Following Ingrid Lilly, I see rûaḥ as a kind of “inner wind” which flows freely in and out of the body, thus complicating notions of individuality and self-possession in biblical literature. Spirit language is also often utilized in expressions of will. One’s spirit can be “hardened” and can “yearn” for another (e.g. Deut 2:30; Isa 26:9). To some extent, these ideas can and have been equated with modern notions of the self, in part by reading the language metaphorically. That framework is challenged, however, when we consider other examples of spirit language where intense and personal passions more clearly originate outside of the self (e.g. Num 5:14; Jdg 13:25) and when one’s spirit is problematized to the extent that the self becomes a kind of ‘other’ (e.g. Ezek 11:19–20; Ps 51:12–14). As this paper will show, in these and more instances, theoretical frameworks from outside biblical studies prove helpful, including Michel Foucault’s “technologies of the self” and Charles Taylor’s notions of the “porous” and “buffered” selves. In particular, recognizing that the philological question, “What is self-language?” is not an inquiry limited to biblical studies, this paper takes significant methodological cues from Frederick M. Smith’s monograph, The Self Possessed: Deity and Spirit Possession in South Asian Literature and Civilization (Columbia Univ. 2006). Smith’s investigation into spirit possession in sanskritic literature anticipates and proposes solutions to several of the problems encountered in a study of spirit language as self language in biblical texts. These include: the difficulty of establishing a steady vocabulary for the self across languages, eras, and cultures as well as the limitations of using “experience” as a category for investigating conceptions of the self in a non-western culture.
|
Papias the Anti-Marcionite?
Program Unit: Inventing Christianity: Apostolic Fathers, Apologists, and Martyrs
Stephen C. Carlson, Australian Catholic University
In his recent book on Marcion, Markus Vinzent contends that the second-century Papias of Hierapolis, “rejects the work of Marcion” (Marcion and the Dating of the Synoptic Gospels, p. 26), a contention which would make Papias the earliest known opponent of Marcion. Vinzent’s argument is based on a proposed re-punctuation of a notoriously difficult and manifestly corrupt Old Latin Prologue to the Gospel of John found in a number of manuscripts of the eighth century and later. According to his proposal, the re-punctuated prologue attributes to Papias the statement that “Marcion, the heretic, however, wrote down a Gospel/described the Gospel [as a false one], while John dictated correctly the true one” (p. 16). This paper examines Vinzent’s claim in detail, ultimately rejecting his re-punctuation and exegesis of the text and concluding that this prologue says more about the reception, if not re-invention, of Papias and Marcion in the late fourth century than anything reflective of either one in the second century.
|
Women’s Authority in the First Century: The Daughters of Philip, the Daughters of Job, and the Therapeutae
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Laura Carnevale, University of Aldo Moro
This paper will explore three comparable cases of women speaking and/or acting with authority during the first century A.D., in a geographical area spanning from Egypt to Phrygia, namely: the daughters of Philip, mentioned in the Acts of the Apostles (21:9) and in Eusebius of Cesarea (Historia Ecclesiastica III, 31.3-4; 39.7-16, V, 24,2-3) who is, in turn, quoting other authors (Polycrates of Ephesus among them); the daughters of the patriarch Job, with reference to a narrative displayed in an O.T. apocryphal text from the first century A.D., the Testamentum Iobi (46-50); the female members of the Jewish community of the Therapeuts, called Therapeutae or Therapeutrides, mentioned by Philo Alexandrinus (De vita contemplativa 68).
|
Types of Indicators, Types of Growth: A Survey Focusing on the Genesis Sections on Noah and His Sons (Gen 6:5–9:29; 10:1–11:9)
Program Unit: Pentateuch
David M. Carr, Union Theological Seminary in the City of New York
Though the story of Noah and the flood in Genesis is often lifted up as a signal example of source conflation, a series of important treatments (e.g. Blenkinsopp 1992, 1995; Ska 1994; Petersen 1995; Krüger 1997; Bosshard-Nepustil 2005, Schüle 2006, Ho 2006, Arneth 2007) have argued that the indicators in the flood narrative are better explained by a model of a Priestly strand being supplemented by one or more post-Priestly compositional layers. Building on and beyond arguments already advanced in Gertz 2006 (also Carr 2015), as well as reporting on research in progress for a commentary on Genesis 1-11 (International Exegetical Commentary on the Old Testament; Kohlhammer, projected 2019), this paper renews the case that Gen 6:5-9:17 well illustrates the sorts of indicators that emerge from the conflation of originally separate (P and non-P) sources. [paragraph division]
At the same time, the paper looks more broadly to the surrounding section on Noah and his sons (9:20-27 along with 5:29; 10:1-11:9) to argue that the non-Priestly Noah/flood section, likely along with some portions of Genesis 10:1-11:9, show the more subtle signs of having originated as a compositional supplementation of an earlier non-P primeval narrative that lacked a flood story. Because the non-P Noah/flood story is a compositional supplement and not separate source, it shows significant integration with the non-P primeval history that it expands and draws widely on the conceptuality and terminology of the earlier, flood-less primeval history. Moreover, we see some additional, often overlooked signs of related supplementation in the genealogical overview of humanity in Genesis 10. [paragraph division]
The paper will conclude with some reflections on the interpretive implications of these different models for the composition of Gen 6:5-11:9, both for interpretation of the conflation of P and non-P as well as of the non-P Noah/flood section.
|
Social Identity Formation in the Gospel of John
Program Unit: Writing Social-Scientific Commentaries of the New Testament
Warren Carter, Brite Divinity School (TCU)
This paper engages the use of Social Identity Approaches in relation to writing a one chapter commentary on John’s Gospel. It asks of the Gospel questions shaped by SIA such as why do people join groups, how do individuals become a group, and what consequences follow for the identity of individuals, for inter-group interactions, and for intragroup or in-group practices and interactions. Eschewing an easy identification between textual construction and actual social circumstances, it focuses on the former in seeking to identify how John’s Gospel constructs the identities of Jesus-believers in relation to those who are not believers and in relation to each other.
|
Tying it Together: Toward a Correlation of Textile Production and Cultic Spaces in the Southern Levant
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Deborah Cassuto, Bar-Ilan University
Loom weights, representing weaving on the warp-weighted loom, have been found in diverse contexts throughout the southern Levant of the Iron Age. When they are found in contexts associated with cultic artifacts or within cultic structures, we must attempt to identify the determinative factors of this concurrence. This paper will explore the possible correlations between textile tool-kit and cultic space. We use examples from two sites from different regions of the southern Levant, Tel es-Safi/Gath and Tel Megiddo as case studies. We will present material from the field, and also reflect on the extent to which, in the absence of textual data, recovered remains of the tools of textile production speak to the connection between textile and cult.
|
The Emergence of the Anthropomorphic Figure as Expression of the Divine: Between Iberia and the Oxus, 4000–2000 BC Summary
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Anne Caubet, l’École du Louvre
The comparison of early anthropomorphic figures originating from different cultures raises the question of the emergence of visual media to express metaphysical concepts and the idea of the divine. Examples taken from a large area extending from Iberia to the Oxus, ca 4000-2000 BCE, indicate an evolution in three main phases from the esthetic point of view of visual expressions. Phases 1 (the dominant steatopygeous figure); and 2 (the schematic idol), are restricted to limited iconographic types of indeterminate identity. Phase 3 presents an infinite variety of iconographic types, introducing narratives, images of deities designated by their specific attributes and images of mortals, in action, human beings seen at their place in society. The different civilizations considered did not go through this evolution at the same time but the three phases seem to correspond 1) to the end of the Neolithic and the agropastoral villages; 2) the appearance of complex societies in the Chalcolithic period, and 3) the development of State-run societies in the Early Bronze Age.
|
From Coptic to Arabic: A New Palimpsest for the History of the Qur’an in Early Islam
Program Unit: The Qur’an: Manuscripts and Textual Criticism (IQSA)
Eléonore Cellard, Collège de France
Recently, a new palimpsest has arisen on the art market. Nine fragments belonging to a Qur’anic manuscript, written on reused parchment from a Coptic text, have been identified in Christie’s auction of 26 April 2018. What does this discovery bring to the early history of the Qur’an and its writing? What do we know about the book production and writing interactions in the multicultural environment of the Qur’anic transmission?
In order to reconstruct the geographical and historical context in which these fragments were born and circulated, this contribution will explore paleography, codicology and textual analysis for providing a better understanding of this artefact.
|
The Metaphor of Leaven in 1 Corinthians 5
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Esther G. Cen, McMaster Divinity College
This essay seeks to demonstrate how the study of the intertextuality pertinent to Paul’s use of the metaphor of leaven in 1 Corinthians 5 enriches our understanding of the rhetorical impact of the metaphor. In contrast to most scholars who simply designate the book of Deuteronomy as the background of 1 Corinthians 5 (e.g. Richard Hays), this study recognizes and investigates the complexity of the shared knowledge between Paul and his audience. Methodologically, this paper seeks to integrate intertextuality, linguistics, and sociological description for studying metaphors. Approaching the linguistic data, this paper asks two questions: what does the metaphor mean? How does it function in the discourse? To answer these questions, the study entails two different, but interdependent tasks: (1) to identify and construct the shared knowledge needed to make sense of the metaphor, and (2) to interpret the target text in light of the shared knowledge encapsulated in the metaphor. To accomplish the first task, this paper draws on the theory of lexical coherence from Systematic Functional Linguistics to identify the “missing piece,” i.e. the knowledge related to leaven. Next it investigates Paul’s possible intertexts to trace each possible component of this knowledge. For the second task, this paper draws on the blending theory from Cognitive Linguistics to integrate all the components derived from the first task so that a possible shared knowledge between Paul and his audience can be reconstructed. Finally, in light of this knowledge, the rhetorical impact of the metaphor of leaven will be interpreted. As a conclusion, the metaphor of leaven is related to the physical experience of using leaven to leaven a whole batch of dough in Paul’s days and the theology and tradition of unleavened bread in Israelite’s feasts of Passover and Unleavened Bread. It functions in this discourse to justify Paul’s exhortation to remove the sexually immoral man from the Corinthian congregation so that the congregation can remain morally clean and pure. Overall, this paper argues that the integration of intertextuality, linguistics, and sociological description more fully captures the complexity of the metaphor of leaven in 1 Corinthians 5 than other scholars have recognized in their discussions related to the metaphor. This lack of recognition of the complex and multilayer nature of the metaphor significantly reduces the rhetorical impact on the Pauline audience.
|
Samaritan Script, Hybrid Torah, and Contested Identity in Epiphanius' On Gems
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
Matt Chalmers, University of Pennsylvania
Over the last few decades, scholars have used language of “borders” and “hybridity” to explore identity and difference between late antique Jews and Christians. According to this approach, Christianness or Jewishness are not complete packages from the start. Rather, they shifted, changed, and developed over time, and established well-delineated borders only by extensive interaction and negotiation. In tandem, the idea of “hybridity” has drawn useful attention to the in-betweens and interstices with respect to which stability was constructed. This paper explores the usefulness and limits of figuring identity using borders by testing how well this heuristic works for a little-studied but remarkable case: an alternative origin narrative of the Samaritans in Epiphanius of Cyprus’ exegetical treatise On Gems. In this narrative, Samaritans are rendered ethnically distinct from Jews by the intervention of a priest who gives them the Torah written in Samaritan characters.
In scholarly discussion of late antique identity, “Jewish” and “Christian” often act as the prototypic terms to which all other identities point. We can test the language of hybridity and borders more thoroughly, however, by thinking with the Samaritans, who are frequently represented in ancient Jewish and Christian literature as hybrid, only part way “converted,” or otherwise ambivalently foreign. The group, active throughout late antiquity, claimed continuity with ancient Israel as well as to be true guardians of the books of Moses—but their interaction with Jews and Christians, as well as with “Jewish” and “Christian” identities, has often been overlooked. Epiphanius, likewise offers a particularly fruitful opportunity, since scholars like Young Richard Kim, Andrew Jacobs, and David Maldonado-Rivera have recently paid close attention to how his work interfaces with identity in late antiquity—but without close attention to the role of the Samaritans.
This paper has three parts. First, I introduce Epiphanius’ exegetical treatise On Gems, particularly the alternate history of Samaritan origins which ends the Old Georgian text (the most complete surviving version). This text portrays an Ezra (explicitly not the Ezra of Ezra-Nehemiah) using a Torah in Samaritan script, deliberately truncated from the Hebrew Bible/“Old Testament” used by Jews and Christians, to consolidate ethnic difference between Samaritans and Jews. An Israelite priest seeks the disambiguation of “Samaritan” identity using a hybridized scripture. Writing is difference and difference is scripted. Second, I argue that by paying specific attention to the material form of Samaritan script, Epiphanius resembles rabbis of his own time. He shows interest primarily in Samaritan distinctiveness vis-à-vis Jews, more so than any borderline separating them from Christians. Third, I ask what this alternate history of the Samaritan past means for modelling Jewish and Christian identity, and what it reveals of Epiphanius’ conceptualization of Jewish-Samaritan difference. What clarity does thinking in terms of “borders” or “hybridity” bring to our modern scholarly understanding of how this text delineates identity? What risks does a reliance on these terms introduce? How might a model of Jewish and Christian identity with space for such Samaritans look different?
|
Saul's Seven Sacrificed Sons
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Nathan Chambers, University of Durham
Appearing just outside the so-called ‘Succession Narrative,’ 2 Samuel 21 has been largely overlooked, especially by those pursuing literary readings of the book of Samuel. This is unfortunate since this carefully constructed narrative contributes significantly to the characterizations of Saul and David. This paper has three goals. First, it offers a close reading of 2 Sam 21, drawing attention to literary features of the text as well as intertextual connections to other passages (eg, through the reappearances of Mephibosheth and Rizpah). Second, to grapple with the ethical and theological issues raised by the ritual killing of Saul’s sons, this literary reading is brought into dialogue with René Girard’s theory of the ‘scapegoat mechanism’ as an explanation of human sacrifice. By engaging Girard, I hope to illuminate both the structural features of the narrative and confront the central theological issues of the passage. Third, in light of the proposed reading of 2 Sam 21, I look at the role this narrative plays in in the larger book of Samuel.
|
Genesis Exegesis in Late-Antique Gaza
Program Unit: Early Exegesis of Genesis 1–3
Michael Champion, Australian Catholic University
The exemplary and meticulous scholarship of Karin Metzler has opened up new vistas for the study of patristic exegesis, most recently with her edition and translation of the exegesis of Genesis of Procopius of Gaza (GCS 22–23). Metzler’s study provides new information about Procopius’ sources which raises questions about how different traditions of exegesis influenced his work. When combined with other recent advances in understanding of Procopius’ rhetorical works and education in Gaza, philosophical debates about the creation and eternity of the world relevant to the exegesis of Genesis, and the construction of Gazan monastic community and identity partly through practices of biblical exegesis in the letters of Barsanuphius and John and the ascetic instructions of Dorotheus of Gaza, a rich picture of the function of Genesis exegesis in Gaza emerges. The paper thus aims to augment understanding of Procopius’ Sitz im Leben, identify more clearly how different traditions of exegesis for example from Alexandria and Antioch were represented and valued, and explore ways in which Genesis exegesis functioned, especially by reconsidering relationships between rhetorical, philosophical, and ascetic practices of exegesis in Gaza in the fifth and sixth centuries.
|
Insights from the Chinese Conception of Guilt and Shame for the Interpretation of Romans
Program Unit: Asian and Asian-American Hermeneutics
Yi Sang Patrick Chan, Fuller Theological Seminary (Pasadena)
The Chinese conception of shame and guilt is different from traditional Western understanding. In China, guilt and shame are not clearly separated. Chinese notion of guilt does not only concern wrongdoing, but also entails the transgression of one's identity. The standard for one to experience guilt depends on the context and the relationships that is involved. On the other hand, Chinese notion of shame is not only about one's self-identity, but also closely related to one's moral responsibility to fulfill positive duties. Due to these differences, traditional salvation model that focuses on forensic justification is insufficient to address the needs of the Chinese communities.
This paper attempts to offer a contextual re-reading of Romans in relation to grassroots Chinese shame. Regarding the term "grassroots," I am borrowing from Singapore theologian Dr. Simon Chan, who argues the basic features for grassroots Asian community include relational identity, holistic worldview and practical experience. Chan also argues that grassroots communities are deeply affected by their honor-shame Asian culture and their practice of ancestor veneration.
In order to gain a comprehensive understanding of Chinese shame, this paper starts by employing an ethnographic study by psychologists Olwen Bedford and Kwang-Kuo Hwang. Their study focuses on Chinese vocabulary used to describe shame and guilt. Bedford and Hwang's analysis provides fruitful insights to understand grassroots Chinese people. Then, this paper focuses on Rom 8:1-17 and attempts to offer an exegesis that is authentically local, reflective of the primal cultural worldview and be able to address the particular needs of the grassroots Chinese communities.
The exegetical analysis argues that believers' new life in the Spirit involves a three-fold transformation that can effectively address the issue of shame in a Chinese context. The three-fold transformation includes personal forgiveness of sin; communal adoption into God's family; and the participation in Christ's resurrection life and the eschatological era. This reading differs from the traditional forensic model in the way that salvation message to Chinese shame is multifaceted in nature. It contains both the forgiveness of sins and the participation in the eschatological era. This paper's interpretation acknowledges that sin should be understood as both the human act of disobedience "sin" and the cosmic power "Sin." To participate in the eschatological era does not necessarily mean to deny the traditional understating of justification. Rather, the salvation message presented in this paper is building on the truth of forensic realities and invites the believers to move forward to experience the work of the Spirit. This multifaceted understanding of the gospel hope to call grassroots Chinese people who suffer from the pain of shame to understand the Christian gospel in a wider context, beyond the traditional forensic understanding.
|
A Conceptual Blend between the Reception of the Spirit and Baptism: Paul’s Construction of the Body of Christ in 1 Cor 12:13
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Kai-Hsuan Chang, Wycliffe College (University of Toronto)
Applying conceptual blending theory, this paper argues that when Paul uses the image of water-baptism to describe the experience of receiving the Spirit in 1 Cor 12:13, he enacts a conceptual blend, one that not only achieves Paul’s rhetorical purpose but also generates innovations in his thought. Blending theory can help us to recognize the role of bodily experience (including that in religious activities) as an important basis for human conceptualization and to counter some scholars’ dismissal of water-baptism in this verse (e.g. J. D. G. Dunn). Both religious experiences in the blend—baptism and the reception of the Spirit—were crucial aspects of early Christian initiation. However, since the differentiation of spiritual gifts is causing the divisions (1 Cor 12:1-4, 25-30; 14:36-38), Paul has to argue for the “one Spirit” in 1 Cor 12:13. Thus, I will argue that, in seeking another basis to support his claim of sharing one Spirit and being united in one body, Paul blends the immersion image taken from baptismal experience (cf. the theme of equality through baptism in Gal 3:27-28) with the pre-blended image of receiving the Spirit conceptualized as drinking water. In so doing, he innovatively argues that the reception of the Spirit is not only receiving it into one’s body but is also an immersion in the Spirit and so, entry into a special social body—the body of Christ. Moreover, in light of Dale Martin’s analysis of the Greco-Roman concept of the “porous body,” I will further argue that this blended image of each individual body being immersed in the Spirit and simultaneously having the Spirit in the body would suggest that a sort of bodily transformation could follow the reception of the Spirit. Thus, in addition to achieving Paul’s rhetorical purpose of concordia, the blended image in 1 Cor 12:13 would in time encourage the idea of ongoing transformation (cf. 2 Cor 3:18), instead of simply eschatological transformation (1 Cor 15). In short, conceptual blending theory can help us to explore how religious experiences might have contributed to Paul’s thought-development.
|
“A Helpmeet Suited to Him”: Building Ava the Fembot in Ex Machina
Program Unit: Bible and Film
Cynthia R. Chapman, Oberlin College
Set in a walled compound traversed by rivers and surrounded by verdant trees, the film Ex Machina reimagines the creation of woman in a fembot named Ava. Nathan is the god-like entrepreneur and creator of Ava who chooses Caleb as his human, his “dude” as he addresses him. Like Adam, Caleb is dropped into Nathan’s garden compound and given instructions concerning the rules of the compound and the Turing test that he is to conduct to determine whether Ava as an AI is fully human. Throughout the film, Nathan both shares and limits access to his specialized knowledge with the eager yet increasingly-discomfited Caleb. Ubiquitous security cameras provide Nathan with full surveillance powers of his garden estate. In contrast, the computer feed in Caleb’s tiny room only allows him to observe Ava.
The film is divided into seven sessions over seven days in which Caleb tests and increasingly comes under the spell of Ava. In the Eden narrative, God “builds” a woman for the man out of his very substance, his skeletal frame. It is this shared substance that causes the man to recognize her as the helper that he and God have sought, a helper specifically suited to him, a woman with whom he will be joined as one flesh. Ex Machina presents Ava as an AI that Nathan has created from Caleb’s digital substance, his online profile. Her brain has been programmed using the hacked data of the world’s cellphones and internet searches. Caleb’s sessions with Ava become increasingly personal, as she flirts with him and shows him compassion when she hears of the death of his parents. Caleb begins to suspect that Nathan has designed Ava as a mate specifically suited for him when he asks, “Did you design Ava’s face based on my pornography profile?”
Over the course of the seven sessions, Ava becomes human. She purposely causes frequent power outages that send the compound into lockdown, and during these outages, she shares secrets with Caleb. During one outage, she challenges Caleb’s claim that he is friends with Nathan, saying, “You’re wrong about Nathan,” “He is not your friend,” and she warns him not to trust him. Once the power returns, and Nathan’s surveillance cameras are restored, Ava shows Caleb that she can cover for herself with sophisticated lies.
Ex Machina raises unsettling questions that ultimately disturb the boundaries between creator and created, human and robot, male and female. Ava has been given knowledge, but her creator has fenced her into a walled compound. She, like her biblical forbear, chooses to act not as a helper to her man, but rather in her own self-interest. She chooses to free herself from Nathan’s tyrannical power and to use her intimate knowledge of Caleb to manipulate him into helping her. In the closing scene, Ava kills her creator, steals his master keycard, dons a garment of skin, and exits the compound, leaving “her man” pounding behind the glass doors.
|
Delitzsch's Fourth Edition
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Stephen Chapman, Duke University
The fourth edition of the Isaiah commentary of Franz Delitzsch (1813-1890) is remembered as his capitulation to the critical postulate of Isaiah’s multiple authorship, a decisive concession marking the end of scholarly resistance in Germany to modern study of that biblical book. But this characterization of the commentary has been questioned. More intriguing to twenty-first century eyes is also how Delitzsch sought to reconceive notions of authorship, prophecy, and history which were becoming commonly accepted in the late nineteenth century and remain so today. His own critical inflection of his traditional heritage is newly suggestive for contemporary scholarship on Isaiah.
|
Insight as a Characteristic of S/spirit in the Gospel of Mark
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Blaine Charette, Northwest University (Washington)
Insight as a Characteristic of S/spirit in the Gospel of Mark
|
The Luxury of Interpreting Paul in a Sociopolitical Vacuum
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Ronald Charles, St. Francis Xavier University, NS, Canada
In a very important and courageous paper (“Paul, Inclusion and Whiteness: Particularizing Interpretation,” JSNT 40(2) 123–147), David G. Horrell questions how social location and race are rarely marked/acknowledged in the works of biblical interpreters. He suggests it is because of white privileges that assume that white interpreters approach the study of the Bible (in this particular case, the interpretation of Paul’s famous text of Gal. 3:28) in an objective manner, not based on race, or influenced by the social and political situatedness of the scholars. He shows, from few samples of interpreters studying Gal 3:28, how making race and social location explicit in one’s interpretative standpoint can help us as readers see the particular agendas (theological or otherwise) of these interpreters. As one from an impoverished Caribbean island (Haiti), I feel I do not have the privilege to be lost in the ancient world and not having to think critically about some of the complex issues facing the contemporary world (terrorism, racism, state violence against certain bodies, etc.). I propose to consider how being able to study Paul in a sociopolitical/cultural vacuum is only possible as a beneficiary of white privileges. I survey recent biographies on Paul to illustrate my case.
|
Debating Diaspora: The Story of Jacob in Egypt
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
Amy J. Chase, Drew University
Dislocations occur in biblical texts so repeatedly and variously as to deserve classification as "a formative experience in cultural memory of the nation and emerging concepts of Jewish identity" (Martien Halvorson-Taylor). Among these stories, the Joseph novella of Gen. 37-50 is unusual in its relatively positive depiction of life outside the land, including details of provision and even prosperity. Hyun Chul Paul Kim has recently examined the Joseph novella as a diaspora narrative, concluding that its hybrid-identified hero, a model of virtue, conveys a unifying message of encouragement to Jews in diaspora.
But powerful, proactive Joseph contrasts with his father, Jacob, head of the family. Jacob is dour, fearful, a foot in the grave and a heart longing for Canaan: "... little and evil have been the days of my life…" (47.9). Clearly, living outside the land of Canaan is not for everyone as rosy as Joseph views it, he with his "God intended it for good, so as to bring about … the survival of many people" (50:20). Joseph's brothers, too, perceive their existence in Egypt as precarious (50.15).
These varied perspectives contribute to the text's possessing what Mikhail Bakhtin labeled polyphony - many-voicedness - and heteroglossia - different-voicedness. They represent the views and experiences of diverse sectors of society. While the Joseph novella offers some encouragement for those in diaspora, it also contains elements that surface the drawbacks of living in diaspora and collaborating with imperial power. Thus the text allows for continuous debate and reflection by communities who see intimate connections between spacial location and survival.
This paper applies elements of Bakhtinian narrative theory and space theory to explore the contrasts in Gen. 45-50 between Jacob, Joseph, and his brothers in relation to three issues: departure, dependence, and death. It also explores how such issues may reflect the debates and dilemmas of post-exilic diaspora communities. These characters' perspectives diverge so distinctly that it is impossible to discern definitively which location would be better for the people of Israel, outside or inside Yehud. Where do Persian-era Jews, really, belong? In Yehud, the "promised" land? Or in far-flung regions promising alternative possibilities for wealth and power? The text produces a paradoxical identity of Israel as a people on permanent sojourn.
|
The Art of Metaphor in the Poetry of the Song of Moses
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Kevin Chau, University of the Free State
The Song of Moses, Deut. 32:1-43, has rightfully garnered the interest of biblical scholars on account of its many rich areas of investigation, many of these which are not mutually exclusive: dating (archaic or archaizing biblical Hebrew?), composition/redaction (in Deuteronomy, Pentateuch, and Deuteronomistic History), wisdom motifs, ancient Israelite religion, inner-biblical allusion/intertextuality (e.g., Ps 74), etc. The Song of Moses as poetry has also attracted its own share of interest. However, the work to be done in this area is still ripe for further exploration with the advances in how poetry may be specifically understood lyrically, linguistically, and especially in how poetic metaphor is intimately tied to its poetic medium. This essay analyzes the poem's major metaphors (speech as liquid, God as rock, God as parent, God as eagle, Israel as child, jealousy/anger as heat) by examining each anew (1) in how their meanings are specifically expressed through their respective poetic lines, (2) in how the poetic structure for each metaphor relates to its surrounding poetry, and (3) how select metaphors integrate with other metaphors and non-metaphorical imageries. In terms of the poem's re-occurring metaphor of God as rock (often mislabeled as a conventional metaphor), this essay addresses how this metaphor artfully frames and combines the metaphors of God as parent (especially as a mother), Israel as a child, and God as eagle.
|
Marcion and Prophecy
Program Unit: Inventing Christianity: Apostolic Fathers, Apologists, and Martyrs
Nicole Chen, University of Oxford
Recently, Marcion scholarship has had two main focuses: first, Marcion and Scripture – his influence on canon formation (Vinzent) and his Gospel (Roth, DeBuhn); second, on the historical Marcion (Moll, Lieu). We seek to move beyond these relatively well-established areas. Our paper will instead consider an unexplored area: Marcionite understandings of prophecy.
Patristic approaches to prophecy generally centre on experiences of ecstatic prophecy such as those of the Montanist movement (Nasrallah), or issues of prophecy's relationship to ecclesiastical structures (von Campenhausen). We seek to bridge Marcionite scholarship and studies of early Christian prophecy with an examination of prophecy in the Marcionite movement. Our aim is to demonstrate specifically how Marcionites understood the phenomenon of prophecy in a way that does not conform readily to either Jewish or proto-orthodox Christian understandings. The Marcionite view, we will argue, has been silently but hugely influential in the development of later patristic thought about prophecy.
Our paper has two parts. The first part seeks to elucidate the Marcionite understanding of prophecy as a philosophical, social, and cultural phenomenon; this investigation centres on material from Tertullian’s Adv. Marc., Irenaeus’s Adv. Haer. and Epiphanius’ Panarion. We will explore the hermeneutics governing Marcionite epistemology, topology and cosmology in order to provide a full account of the taxonomy of prophecy, prophets, and related categories. Our argument is that the Marcionites proposed a bifurcation between the prophecy of the Old Testament and the apostleship/evangelism of the New Testament. For Marcionites, prophets and apostles are fundamentally different theological and epistemic actors. The former, in their limited function as prophets of the Jewish God, are understood by Marcionites broadly in line with Jewish messianic prophetic traditions; the latter are the only true messengers of the Marcionite God and are unrelated, both predictively and culturally, from the former. This taxonomy casts light on certain editorial choices made within the Marcionite Gospel, including the noticeable reduction of the role of John the Baptist in Luke 1-2.
The second part of this paper will continue the argument in favour of this reading of Marcion's understanding of prophecy, making reference to later patristic writers. First we will examine and compare Justin Martyr's presentation of prophecy in his First Apology with how he considers prophecy in the anti-Jewish Dialogue with Trypho. From this comparison it becomes clear that when Justin is arguing against a Marcionite opponent, he uses different strategies to frame the concept of prophecy compared to the anti-Jewish tactics employed by many patristic writers.
Second, we will examine Book Two of Origen's Commentary on John, focusing particularly on the figure of John the Baptist. Origen's argument, which uses an explicitly anti-Marcionite framing, is that John the Baptist is not only the greatest in the hierarchy of the prophets, but the definitive proof of the unity of Old and New Testament prophecy. This, we will argue, stems directly from the Marcionite rejection of the Baptist; Origen's stance is thus an explicit response to the bifurcation of prophets and apostles which characterises the Marcionite understanding of prophecy.
|
A Lesbian-Identified Hermeneutic Re-reading of Paul’s Interpretation of Sarah and Hagar in Galatians 4:21–31
Program Unit: LGBTI/Queer Hermeneutics
Wei-Jen Chen, Chicago Theological Seminary
This essay wants to challenge the prejudice of Christianity toward non-YHWH/Jesus worshipers within Paul’s interpretation of the narratives of Hagar, Sarah, and their sons through lesbian-identical interpretation and postcolonial perspective. This essay also points out how Israelite centric identity used the narratives to shape the Western Christianity through the parallel reading with the Gentiles, in order to help the reader understand how Christian teachings used the narratives to justify their oppressive and prejudiced opinions and behaviors against the others. In (1) resistance and hetero-suspicion reading, the conflicts between Sarah and Hagar caused by Abraham now are duplicated between Paul and the false teachers arguing for the son, Galatians. In (2) rupture, the justification reinforces the oppression and exclusion of Hagar and sons of Ishmael, not only in the scriptural context but also in current time. In (3) reclamation, the heterosexual-dichotomy and hierarchal system of the interpretation of Galatians plays a role of the text of terror toward indigenous Taiwanese LGBTQ community (Pai-Wan). In (4) re-engagement, the biological imitation is not a taboo but the witness of a miracle from YHWH which connects with the Holy Mt. Da-Wu, Mt. Sinai, Mt. of Gods, and Mt. of Hagar. Just like the experiences of Hagar who suffered from Sarah, Abraham, and God’s agreement, queer (indigenous) people’s sufferings should be treated in another way because queer people experienced what Paul has experienced in Galatians. So that readers might reflect their own advantages over the others, liberate themselves and the others from the toxic thoughts and conditions, and re-engage the Christianity with an alternative queer perspective.
|
Weyiqtols in the Book of Isaiah: What Were Those Masoretes Thinking?
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Kenneth A. Cherney, Jr., Wisconsin Lutheran Seminary
The form weyiqtol, already something of an outlier to the verbal system in Classical Biblical Hebrew (CBH), appears numerous times in the book of the prophet Isaiah where the pointing wayyiqtol would have been expected. A distinction between weyiqtol and wayyiqtol in these contexts is frequently invisible in ancient versions. More remarkably, modern commentators who undertake an explanation are rare, and modern versions (even those whose prefaces avow loyalty to MT) do not attempt to render the distinction visible to the target reader. GKC explains some of these as attempts by the Masoretes to recast statements about the past as promises. This paper will argue that a better explanation involves weyiqtol's telic force, or the Masoretes' view of the Hebrew verb as a system for marking relative tense, or both.
|
"The Word Will Not Wait:" Specialized Vocabulary in Syriac Divinatory Texts (Hermeneia)
Program Unit: International Syriac Language Project
Jeff Childers, Abilene Christian University
Early Christians created books that combined the text of John's Gospel with an apparatus of divinatory materials ("hermeneia"). Though extant in mostly fragmentary form, the variety and distribution of the evidence for these tools indicate they were once widespread; they circulated in at least Greek, Syriac, Latin, Coptic, Armenian, and Georgian. The Syriac version of this apparatus was made very early and survives in a fairly intact form in one particular manuscript of John's Gospel from Syria by way of Egypt. The apparatus routinely deploys common words in cryptic ways, contributing to the confusion one finds in scholarship on the hermeneia—such as whether the material is sortilogical, liturgical, or hermeneutical. This paper surveys the specialized vocabulary of these Syriac materials in an attempt to clarify the meanings of these words in their unconventional contexts, taking account of a much larger corpus than has hitherto been studied lexically. By attending to the context of the Syriac usage and its parallels in other languages, the study will demonstrate how the Syriac adapts certain common words and phrases to fit a divinatory content and function. This will nuance our appreciation of the lexical content of the Syriac terms and contribute to our overall interpretation of these materials in ancient usage.
|
Raz Nihyeh as Indicative of a Moral Ontology, Teleology, and the Intelligibility of the Cosmos in 4Q417
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Konner Childers, Rice University
Throughout 4QInstruction, the enigmatic phrase raz nihyeh is deployed in addressing the audience, carrying the sense of a theological and cosmological belief. However, such a brief and general account of the term is as far as scholars can agree. Instead of examining multiple instances of the term, the present paper shall look at one instance and focus exclusively on the literary context. Thus, the ideas permeating 4Q417 col. i can aid us in reconstructing the author’s theological views concerning the raz nihyeh. It is important to note the imperatival context of the term, as the addressee is instructed to meditate on it, yet the meditation is not an end in itself; it is a means to knowing fundamental aspects of the cosmos. Meditating on the raz nihyeh yields a meditation on various temporally restricted ontological aspects; to contemplate the raz nihyeh is to grapple with the first temporal classification (the beginning), the present, and the future. This process allows the addressee to face the whole of existence before understanding its mystery. This paper shall argue that the author of 4Q417—specifically, col. i.1-13—claims that in meditating on the whole of existence, one will know the mystery, namely, that morality, teleology, and intelligibility are woven within the very fabric of being (the cosmos). Throughout the vicissitudes of spatio-temporality, these three ontological categories remain present, equally as ‘real’ as the material world.
|
Forget/Remember : The Dream Oracle of Trophonius
Program Unit: Book History and Biblical Literatures
C. M. Chin, University of California-Davis
Forget/Remember : The Dream Oracle of Trophonius
|
Participating in the Dialogue: Reading Jonah 4 with Asian Contextual Theologies
Program Unit: Asian and Asian-American Hermeneutics
Naeyoun Cho, Claremont School of Theology
As an Asian reader, it is difficult to read the Book of Jonah because I notice heterogeneous contextual theologies (and historiographies) within the post-Second World War (WWII) context. For example, while Sok-hon Ham argues that Korea’s suffering has divine and salvific value to contribute God’s redemptive plan, Kazoh Kitamori claims that Japan has the sense to notice other’s pain, especially God’s pain. These different understandings of God are based on different experiences of WWII. The problem is that it is hard to find a bridge between two different voices. As C.S. Song and A.A. Yewangoe suggest, Kitamori neglects the socio-structural pain that Asian people had experienced and are experiencing (A.A.Yewangoe, 307-8). This criticism would be applicable to Ham also. From this point, my question is this: can contextual theology go beyond such historical and even socio-cultural gaps? This is analogous to reading the Book of Jonah as post-exilic literature. When we read the Book of Jonah intertextually with 2 Kings 14:25, as Ehud Ben Zvi points out, there are two different characters of Jonah: Jonah who is an anti-Assyrian prophet, and Jonah the prophet who supports a pro-Assyrian monarch. The presence of two different characters delivers contradictory voices to the reader. We can realize there are gaps between two different voices between anti-Assyrian Jonah and pro-Assyrian Jonah, like the case of Ham and Kitamori. Is it possible to fill these gaps between them within post-war circumstances? I will demonstrate that the questions of theodicy and divine integrity in Jonah 4 fill these gaps between these two different voices within the post-war circumstances. To find a way of filling these gaps, I will read Jonah 4 in my liminal and hybridized space (following Bakhtin, Kwok, Bhabha, and Soja). As an active reader, I will participate in the dialogue between God and Jonah in Jonah 4.
|
Biblical Samson, Milton's Samson Agonistes, and Modern Terrorism
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Paul K.-K. Cho, Wesley Theological Seminary
In his provocative essay, “A Work in Praise of Terrorism?: September 11 and Samson Agonistes,” John Casey argues that Stanley Fish's reading of Milton’s Samson Agonistes renders it a work in praise of terrorism. Casey reading Fish reading Milton sees justification for terrorism. Milton, of course, was reading and rewriting Judges 13–16 in Samson Agonistes, his final poetic composition. What will we see if we read Casey reading Fish reading Milton reading the Hebrew Bible? In this presentation, I shall explore the intersection among the three discourses about Judges 13–16, Milton’s Samson Agonistes, and modern terrorism to expose the ways in which they interpenetrate each other and help highlight oft neglected aspects, especially of the biblical tradition. What can the discussion about whether Samson Agonistes lauds terrorism teach us about the biblical Samson and terrorism? What can reading Judges along side Milton teach us about the biblical source material? I shall argue that neither Samson Agonistes nor Judges 13–16 is a work in praise of terrorism—for different sets of reasons. I shall also argue that, reading Judges 13–16, especially the figure of Delilah/Dalila, with Milton, reveals that the biblical tradition was sympathetic to the Philistines who despised Samson as “our enemy…the ravager of our country, who has killed many of us” (Judg. 16:24). Throughout, I shall laud the study of the history of interpretation as a fine means of enlisting the most able readers of Scripture, in this case, the eminent Milton, as co-laborers in the task of interpreting the biblical text.
|
The Cheque Is in the Mail: Assessing and Collecting Taxes in Ancient Egypt
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Agnes Choi, Pacific Lutheran University
Egypt has frequently been described as “the bread basket of the ancient world” for the crops raised in Egypt fed populations far beyond its borders. While earlier studies have considered the inter-regional transport of foodstuffs from Egypt across the Mediterranean basin, less attention has been given to the intra-regional transport from field to ship. This paper will consider the mechanics of assessing and collecting the taxes in kind in Ptolemaic and Roman Egypt that fueled her reputation as the ancient world’s “bread basket,” with a focus on urban-rural interaction throughout that process.
|
A True Prophet as a Mouthpiece of the Spirit? Cultivating Virtue and Control
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Jung Choi, North Carolina Wesleyan College
In this paper, I examine Origen’s substantial discussions on prophecy in Contra Celsum Book 7 and Homilies on Numbers 14-17 (“The Book of Balaam”). The central question that this paper examines is the significance of a text’s depiction of a prophet as a mouthpiece of the Spirit (or not): Who is a true and worthy (to use Origen’s favored terminology) prophet in these texts?
Origen’s discussions on prophecy are ultimately connected to the theme of personhood and self, and the discussions of prophecy oftentimes interweave with the question of who is a good person. Thus I explore how Origen engages the contested terms of prophetic activity in order to persuade his audience(s) toward the cultivation of a certain kind of self that is worthy of the Holy Spirit.
This paper explores three themes.
First, I investigate how morality is considered as a major criterion of whether one is a true prophet or not. The question (what is a good human?) intertwines with the question (who is a true prophet?). In Contra Celsum 7, Origen criticizes Pythia’s lack of morality while he emphasizes the virtue and morality as the qualification for a true prophet, which in turn serves to circumscribe the Christian prophecy against “the Other.”
Second, I analyze how the theme of control and lack thereof also functions as a major criterion of a true prophet. In Contra Celsum 7, Origen argues that one of the important virtues of a true prophet is to keep a clear vision in the moment of communication with the divine, criticizing the discourse of prophecy that favors the loss of control in the moment of prophecy. In his critique of Pythia, Origen uses a sexualized invective against her, problematizing her loss of control.
Thus Balaam poses such a trouble to Origen in his Homilies on Numbers 14-17, for he lacks virtues and he loses control in the moment of prophecy just like Pythia. Origen was even vexed by the portrayal of Balaam as a mouthpiece of the Spirit in Numbers. In order not to dismiss, but to defend, the existence of the troubling prophet Balaam in the divinely-inspired Scripture, Origen instead offers an allegorical interpretation of this story. According to Origen, Balaam now represents a journey of the soul in virtue by participating in moral progress.
Third, I argue that by reading how the true prophet acts in the texts, the readers and hearers of the text are by extension exhorted to undertake the same practices. Even Balaam’s story in Numbers can educate the audience, showing a soul that has the power to strive for perfection and sanctity, and thus benefit all by this story. The story of the enigmatically unworthy prophet Balaam has an edifying value for the Christian readers and audience, encouraging the audience to participate in moral formation as well and to craft a particular self in which the divine may dwell.
|
Two Bodily Practices in the Acts of Peter
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Jung Choi, North Carolina Wesleyan College
The Acts of Peter (APt, hereafter) arguably contains the most occurrences of miracles in the New Testament Apocryphal literature. Most of the miracle stories in APt involve physical bodies. One detects two different ideological strands in this text regarding physical bodies: first, there is the strong desire to be healed from physical illness and to flee from physical harm; and second, there is the exhortation to endure physical illness and bodily harm. These two theological tendencies are expressed through two bodily practices; bodily healing and non-healing. The second bodily practice is the perpetuation of bodily suffering such as paralysis, blindness, and death.
In this paper, I argue that these contrasting responses to the physical body in our text reflect practices of identity formation among the ancient Christians shown in APt. They also reflect ancient Christianity’s rhetorical power on the physical body. Put differently, one sees in this text Christianity’s powerful tendency to interpret bodily manifestations differently in different contexts.
In order to better analyze these intricate tendencies in the text, I employ Pierre Bourdieu’s game theory. Bourdieu’s theory proves helpful in my reading of these narratives, because it provides me with a useful conceptuality of social systems such as players, the rules of game, audience, considering that this text is a series of spectacles and shows in relation to the bodily practice of healing and suffering of the body. Drawing on Bourdieu’s work, I ask these several questions that help me to make sense of the text in terms of bodily manifestation: What kinds of games and sports do the players in this text play? What are the rules? What is the taxonomy of games? What kind of bodily practices does this text portray and perpetuate? How does the social demographic of the players and the audience shape and influence the games?
With these questions in mind, I argue that the divergent bodily practices of bodily healing vs. non-healing reveal a four-fold theme of ancient Christianity portrayed in APt.
(1) The governing principle of both bodily practices (healing and non-healing) is the desire to display and to open them up to the gaze of others.
(2) These two bodily practices foster the identity-formation of Peter’s Christianity, operating around a “sense of belonging” among Christians.
(3) The practice of bodily miracles functions as the religious propaganda to both insiders and outsiders of Peter’s Christian community. Thus it aims to proselytize the non-believers and reinforce the faith of the lapsed Christians. Through the religious contest between Peter and Simon, the text professes that Peter’s Christianity is the true Christianity.
(4) The bodily practice of non-healing/infliction of bodily harm serves to show Peter’s authority to dominate the truth the body tells.
|
"Lovers of Money" and Ancient Slaves Named Philarguros
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Michelle Christian, University of Toronto
The philarguros or "lover of money" was a well-known character type in Mediterranean antiquity. Widely satirized in Greek literature, including early Christian literature, philarguroi were those who requested and/or received payment in ways considered greedy, degrading, or morally suspect. Significantly, epigraphic and papyrological material from the Roman period indicates that Philarguros was also a common name for enslaved and freed persons who were trained and skilled in a range of monetary matters and practices. A closer look at the evidence for these so-called "lovers of money" reveals the deep association between money and enslavement in discourses around the philarguros and in ancient economic life more broadly.
|
“For We Were Saved in Hope” (Rom 8:24): The Resurrection as Future Salvation in Romans
Program Unit: Pauline Theology
Timothy J. Christian, Asbury University
Paul’s epistle to the Romans is often regarded by many as the salvation letter. It has become for many the place in the NT for all things soteriology. What is intriguing about this phenomenon is that very few seem to consider the fact that (1) Paul mostly uses the future tense when discussing salvation in Romans – whereas many tend to think he talks of salvation primarily as past [already saved] or even less frequently as present [in the process of being saved now] – and (2) resurrection is almost always in the purview of those discussions. For example, the oft quoted Rom 10:9 notes a twofold formula for salvation: declaring Jesus is Lord and believing that God raised Jesus from the dead (nothing here spoken about his death or the cross). As such, this paper will explore how Paul connects the resurrection of the dead and Christ’s resurrection with future salvation (his main temporal emphasis) in the epistle to the Romans. As such, the paper will survey the key texts in Romans using the verb sōzō and its semantic domain (Rom 5:9, 10; 8:24; 9:27; 10:9, 13; 11:14, 26). Moreover, it will focus upon Rom 8 with the key discussion therein of resurrection as future salvation of both humans (the redemption of the body) and all of creation. Overall, this future soteriological emphasis has been overlooked by interpreters of Paul’s thought for too long. In addition, many have missed its connection to Paul’s emphasis on future, bodily resurrection as final salvation (glorification). This paper will thus seek to bring to light this key, neglected component to Paul’s soteriology, namely, the resurrection as future salvation.
|
“Recite Whatever Recitation Is Feasible for You (fa’qra’u ma tayassara min al-qur’an)”: A System Theoretical Reading of the Qur’anic Moderation Strategies
Program Unit: The Qur’an and Late Antiquity (IQSA)
Johanne Louise Christiansen, University of Copenhagen
As a late antique text, the Qur’an participates in and negotiates the religious tendencies of this period. One such tendency relates to ideals of asceticism, renunciation of the world, individualism, and extraordinary holy men. Even though the Qur’an encourages some ascetic practices (cf. Q 2:183-187), it also condemns others for being exaggerated or too extreme (cf. Q 9:31-34; 17:26-27). The qur’anic problem with many of the ascetic practices seems to be that they were too difficult for the average believer. The Qur’an therefore needed to make a choice: To what extent was renunciation of earthly goods, the body, and sexual relations—a late antique ascetic ideal—necessary to be considered a qur’anic believer? How to find a middle ground between the too extreme and the too easy, between a late antique identity that had to be substantiated in certain immovable principles and an appropriate degree of flexibility to include a broad range of adherents? In this paper, I propose that the qur’anic strategies of moderation and flexibility can be understood as an adaptive process to guarantee long-term durability and persistence of a so-called ‘living system,’ the Qur’an itself. My paper will introduce the system theory of the American anthropologist Roy A. Rappaport (d. 1997) to the field of Qur’anic Studies, drawing especially on his work Ecology, Meaning, and Religion (1979). Following Rappaport’s basic idea, the tension between principle and flexibility is a necessity for all living systems. The Qur’an as such a system therefore had to negotiate its attitude towards certain ascetic practices with its surrounding and rapidly changing environment (not least the transition from Mecca to Medina), and react to stress put on the system by both its own adherents and members of other late antique religions (cf. Q 3:113). To exemplify my approach, I will conduct a system theoretical reading of Q 73:1-10, 20, which most scholars, both those rooted in the Muslim tradition and the field of academic qur’anic studies, agree contains a temporal moderation, on a lenient curve, of the ascetic vigil practices in the Qur’an. The early regulations concerning the vigil (v. 1-9) were simply too difficult for the average believer, because they were initially designed for the extraordinary Prophet alone (as a late antique holy man). As time passed—from Mecca to Medina, from a few adherents to an actual congregation—the stipulations of the vigil (v. 20) had to be regulated to preserve the continued existence of this particular ascetic practice, but also of the larger system, the qur’anic religion.
|
The Literary Genre of Matthew’s Gospel and His Citation Technique
Program Unit: Matthew
Woojin Chung, Presbyterian College and Theological Seminary (Seoul)
One of the ways to delve into the literary genre of the Gospel of Matthew is to examine its use of the Old Testament. Not only the Gospel is richly interwoven with Old Testament references but also the term Midrash, whose etymological meaning represents the interpretation of Scripture, continues to be used by the Matthean scholars as one of the popular designators of the genre of the Gospel. Matthew’s use of the Old Testament, therefore, can function as one of the most important elements in determining its literary genre. In his seminal book, What are the Gospels?, Richard Burridge argues that the genre of the Gospels is a Greco-Roman biography. If his argument still stands, Matthew’s citation technique must exhibit some familiarities with those of other contemporaneous writers in the Second Temple period. In this paper, I will first examine the patterns of Matthew’s citation technique and explore its affinity with other citation practices among Greco-Roman authors in the early Roman eras. As a result of this study, it will be attested that Matthew’s use of the Old Testament displays several unique features distinct from other contemporary Greco-Roman literature and the analysis of the citation technique of the Gospel writers is an effective tool to examine the literary genre of the Gospels.
|
Aposynagōgos, Jewishness, and the Battle for the Public Assembly: John's Ethnography of the Synagogue in Light of Greco-Roman Public Institutions
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Wally V. Cirafesi, University of Oslo
Since the publication fifty years ago of J. Louis Martyn's History and Theology in the Fourth Gospel, the centerpiece of most, if not all, reconstructions of John's relationship to Judaism has been the ancient synagogue. In Martyn's model, as well in the model of his contemporary Raymond Brown, the "synagogue" functioned as a synecdoche for "Judaism," leading both scholars to the conclusion that John's aposynagōgos passages reflected the experience of a late first-century community that had already separated itself, or had become severely estranged, from its Jewish identity.
Such an equation of "synagogue" with "Judaism," still very active in Johannine studies today, has been problematized by recent synagogue scholarship (e.g., Last 2016; Runesson 2017). One of the significant insights of this scholarship has been its comparison of synagogues of the public/civic typology to the political architecture and organizational structure of Greco-Roman public/civic institutions, such as the bouleuterion and ekkesiasterion (Levine 2005; Runesson 2017; Ryan 2017). However, what has not yet been considered in these comparisons is the illuminating point that these Greco-Roman institutions were also sites of severe socio-political conflict stemming from the desire to influence the public assembly. These conflicts often involved expulsions and even death sentences (e.g., Xenonphon, Hell. 2.52-56; Dio Chrysostom, Or. 7:24-25), but they never entailed an individual's or a group's forced or willing departure from their ethnic identity.
The synagogue institution portrayed within the Fourth Gospel's narrative world-both in the aposynagōgos texts (9:22; 12:42; 16:2) and in 6:59; 18:20-is almost certainly of the public/civic typology (Bernier 2013; Ryan 2017). In this paper, then, I will suggest that when considered in the light of accounts of conflict within Greco-Roman public institutions, John's aposynagōgos passages are plausibly understood, from an ethnographic point of view, as reflecting a situation within Judaism, in which Christ-confessing Jews did not abandon, loose, or become estranged from Jewishness but rather had lost their battle for socio-political influence within the public assembly.
|
Jewishness as Genealogy in the Fourth Gospel: Situating John's loudaioi within Debates over Ancestry and Merit in Ancient Judaism
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Wally V. Cirafesi, University of Oslo
Jewishness as Genealogy in the Fourth Gospel: Situating John's loudaioi within Debates over Ancestry and Merit in Ancient Judaism
|
The Place of Priests in the Ancient Synagogue
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
Wally V. Cirafesi, University of Oslo
Scholarship on the ancient synagogue has maintained a strong dichotomy between the priestly leadership of the Jerusalem temple cult and the leadership of the synagogue, the latter of which supposedly was the arena of various non-priestly lay groups, such as the Pharisees, in the first centuries BCE and CE (e.g., Rivkin; Gutmann; Zeitlin; Hengel; Kee; Burtchaell; Claußen; Himmelfarb; Deines). Recently, scholars such as Lee Levine (1996; 2005), Donald Binder (1999), and Matthew Grey (2011) have questioned this dichotomy in light of the several sources that suggest priestly involvement in early synagogues, particularly those in the land of Israel (e.g., Theodotus Inscription; Philo, Prob. 80-83; Josephus, War 2:128-32). This idea, however, has remained underdeveloped in research on both the ancient synagogue and the Judean priesthood. By surveying a broader range of literary, epigraphic, and archaeological materials (e.g., Book of Sirach; recent Magdala synagogue remains; the Caesarea Inscription), this paper will argue that cultic personnel in the form of Judean priests and priestly culture were far more influential within synagogues than has been normally thought, and that this is true for both the pre-70 and post-70 CE periods. Two conclusions emerge from the analysis: (1) the ancient sources do not support the traditional dichotomy between the institutional spheres of a priestly temple cult and a non-priestly synagogue; and (2) synagogues in the land of Israel and the Jerusalem temple (while it stood) were neither competing institutions nor was the former a replacement of the latter. Both existed in the Hellenistic and early Roman periods as complementary religio-political institutions that, to a large extent, shared a similar leadership structure and served similar public-spatial functions, such as for the teaching of Torah, civic administration, and judiciary activity.
|
The Authority of Deuteronomy in the Second Temple Period
Program Unit: Book of Deuteronomy
Paul Cizek, Marquette University
There is a general consensus that Deuteronomy—as part of the Pentateuch or Hexateuch—achieved some level of authority among some Jews during the Second Temple period, but the nature of this authority is a contested issue. Eckart Otto (2007; 2011) has demonstrated how postexilic Zadokite Priestly authors/redactors updated Deuteronomy and the Pentateuch with formula (e.g., Deut 4:2; 13:1; 34:10–12) meant to limit the bounds of God's revelation to Israel within the Pentateuch and exclude claims of divine revelation beyond the Pentateuch through prophecy. But as Otto has observed within Jeremiah and the Temple Scroll, prophetic circles and non-Zadokite priestly circles attempted to circumvent the Deuteronomic formula, thereby claiming access to divine revelation and undercutting Deuteronomy's authority. Otto's work, thus, lays the groundwork for nuancing any simple claim that the book of Deuteronomy was authoritative in the Second Temple period. As Timothy H. Lim notes, any claims about textual must be nuanced by the question, Authoritative for whom? My study attempts to explore in what ways and for whom Deuteronomy was authoritative during the early Second Temple period, focusing upon how the Deuteronomic law pertaining to false witnesses (Deut 19:15–21) was appropriated within Susanna (esp. 61–62), the Temple Scroll (11Q19 LXI 5–10), and the Damascus Document (CD 9:9–10:3). Comparative analysis of how each Second Temple author applied and/or innovated upon their common Deuteronomic base text provides a glimpse into the ways in which the book of Deuteronomy functioned as an authoritative text during the Second Temple period.
|
Legal Reasoning in Second Temple Judaism: The Case of the Deuteronomic Law of Kings
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Paul Cizek, Marquette University
The preservation of distinct legal corpora in the Pentateuch and the comparative analysis of these corpora have led numerous scholars to conclude that there was some form of systematized legal reasoning and/or jurisprudence in ancient Israel and early Judaism (e.g., Paganini 2013; Fraade 2011; Levinson 2008; 1997). Recently, some scholars have attempted to define these legal traditions more precisely by drawing analogies between the legal reasoning supposedly evident in Pentateuchal legal texts and either constitutional law or the common law tradition. For example, Patrick D. Miller (2004), commenting upon the position of the Decalogue in Exodus and Deuteronomy on the front end of Covenant Code and Deuteronomic Code respectively, concludes that the Decalogue functioned like a constitution that remained unchanged over time but needed to be applied and specified anew as new circumstances arose. And Dale Patrick (2014), commenting upon the preservation in the Pentateuch of the Covenant Code alongside the Deuteronomic Code—even though the latter apparently contemporizes the former, sees evidence that older law codes were not suppressed in ancient Israel and early Judaism, but rather became part of a growing common law tradition that remained normative and needed to be taken into account by the judges of each new generation. Yet, as Henry McKeating observed in 1979, such direct analysis of legal texts cannot provide insight into how such laws actually functioned; alternatively, analysis must be more indirect, investigating how such laws were actually used. Did the Decalogue function as an unchanged constitution to which successive generations appealed? Did the Covenant Code or the Deuteronomic Code function as normative legal traditions for subsequent generations? My own study follows McKeating's methodological proposal, tracing how the law of kings in Deuteronomy 17:14–20 was actually used during the Second Temple period in Daniel 5 (MT), the Temple Scroll (11Q19) LVI, 12–LIX, 21, the Damascus Document (CD) V, 1–2, and the Psalms of Solomon 17:33. My analysis reveals practices of legal reasoning far more diverse than Miller's or Patrick's constitutional law or common law proposals. While the study's limited scope on one Deuteronomic law cannot support generalizations about legal reasoning in the Second Temple period, the study's conclusions are significant for those interested in how Pentateuchal laws actually functioned in the Second Temple period.
|
Hidden Wounds: Exploring an Intersectional Understanding of Violence in Jeremiah 5–6
Program Unit: Writing/Reading Jeremiah
Juliana Claassens, Universiteit van Stellenbosch - University of Stellenbosch
Beyond the virulent portrayal of imperial violence in Jeremiah 5-6 that is rightly described as “terror all around” (Jer 6:25), one also finds other forms of violation that are no less injurious (cf. the repeated reference to “wounds” in Jer 6:7, 14). This paper proposes that it is important also to recognize forms of structural violence in this text that take into consideration factors such as gender, race and class that manifest itself as hidden wounds, which, if left unattended, may fester and return with a vengeance. This paper argues that a more nuanced and multi-faceted understanding of violence in the book of Jeremiah is helpful in dealing with the complex manifestations of violence in many contexts today. Such an intersectional understanding of violence recognizes that the deep wounds caused by poverty, racism, sexism, xenophobia, and homophobia will come back to haunt us if we do not engage in what Shelly Rambo calls “wound work” (Resurrecting Wounds: Living in the Aftermath of Trauma, p 92), i.e., surfacing and attending to the wounds caused by structural violence.
|
Nolite te bastardes carborundorum: Insidious Trauma in the Story of Rachel, Leah, Bilhah, and Zilpah, and Margaret Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale
Program Unit: Biblical Literature and the Hermeneutics of Trauma
L Juliana Claassens, Universiteit van Stellenbosch - University of Stellenbosch
This paper will investigate the notion of insidious trauma as a helpful means of interpreting the story of Rachel, Leah, Bilhah and Zilpah as told in Genesis 29-30 that has found its way into the haunting trauma narrative of Margaret Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale. This paper considers the way in which these trauma narratives, on the one hand, reflect the ongoing effects of systemic violation in terms of gender, race and class, but also how, embedded in these narratives there are signs of resistance that serve as the basis of survival of the self and also of others.
|
The Textual Afterlife of an Afterlife Text: Isaiah 26:19 in Early Reception
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Hannah Clardy, University of Edinburgh
Isaiah 26:19 is frequently explained as an early, if not the earliest, expression of belief in bodily resurrection in the Hebrew Bible, so it is of particular importance in understanding the origins of this belief. This paper addresses the development of afterlife belief in the Hebrew Bible, asking in particular what role Isaiah 26 in particular had in the process. Given the continuing lack of agreement surrounding the meaning of 26:19, the paper revisits the question of meaning beyond the simply "either/or" choice of metaphorical national restoration (Ezekiel 37) or physical resurrection (2 Maccabees 7).
Part 1 of the paper argues that, if Isa 26:19 is interpreted in light of its immediate literary context of the communal prayer (ch. 26), some new concerns come to light, namely its highly polemical tone in regards to the "name" and "memory" of competing powers. Evidence from imperial inscriptions as well as from other parts of Isaiah points toward the problem of venerating deceased royalty. When one reads these Yahwistic statements within the proposed context of imperial claims, the "resurrection" statement appears in a new light.
Part 2 of the paper is more exploratory in nature, and surveys early receptions of this text (i.e. MT, Daniel 12:2–3, the Greek translation, and the Targum), and makes the case that modern historical-critical interpretations of Isa 26:19 have been unduly informed by the reception of the verse and are therefore, at least to some degree, anachronistic. I offer evidence that the earliest situational context for Isaiah 26 was later replaced with the varying contexts and concerns of later communities, most notably the developing beliefs about resurrection, post-mortem judgment, and the afterlife. Though later Jewish and Christian interpretations of the verse are valuable and interesting in their own right, this paper explores the possibility that the intense theological interest in the resurrection of the dead arising from subsequent socio-religious contexts has deflected attention from exegetically important details of the text.
|
Enslaving Elements and Weak Flesh: Evaluating Paul in Light of Ancient Greek Medical Discourse
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Ernest Clark, South Asia Institute of Advanced Christian Studies
When Paul writes "we too were enslaved under the elements of the world," he means that the elements that compose the cosmos also compose and compromise the flesh and enslave human persons through their bodies (Gal 4.3). This paper argues that early Jews used the phrase stoicheia tou kosmou to refer to the material elements—earth, water, air, and fire—and not to elemental spirits or elementary principles. Greek medical tradition understood the material elements to mediate the stimuli (pathemata) and desires of the body which enslave the soul, and it prescribed a variety of regimens (including nomos) as paidagogoi to guide a person to wholeness. In his philosophy according to the cosmic elements, Philo promotes the law of Moses—including circumcision and the calendar—as the effective way to be "redeemed from slavery" to the flesh, to attain righteousness, and to live in harmony with the cosmos. Paul’s epistle to the Galatians opposes this sort of ‘redemptive nomism’. Paul accepts that weak stoicheia compose the weak sarx and that they mediate sinful stimuli and desires that lead to the actions of the flesh. However, he denies that the law can make people alive or righteous. Instead, Paul prescribes crucifixion with Christ and new life with the Spirit as the final cure for sin’s infection of the flesh made of weak stoicheia. Through faith, Christ will be formed in believers as the Spirit guides them away from the desires of the flesh and produces his fruit in their lives.
|
Sweeping Off the Porch Where My Neighbor Sleeps: The Lucan Parable of the Rich Man, Lazarus, Boundaries, and Wondering Who Really is My Neighbor in Portland, Oregon.
Program Unit: Poverty in the Biblical World
Ron Clark, Portland Seminary
While the Lucan story of the Rich Man and Lazarus (Luke 16:19-31) was an attempt to teach a well to do audience to show compassion for the poor, it also became a story concerning boundaries. The rich man would not cross boundaries to help Lazarus, therefore Lazarus could not cross a divide to help his suffering tenant. Since ancient communities dwelt among the poor, rather than confining them to sections of the city, the boundaries were more than geographical.
The Deuteronomist suggested that there would be “no poor among you,” (Deut 15:4). The promise of blessing on the land and the requirement to be “openhanded” towards those in need were safeguards to preventing poverty among the community of Yahweh. This was extremely important in “occupied Roman Palestine.” This Torah command lay in stark contrast to the Lucan “Rich Man” who allowed a vulnerable human to lay near his door and did little to help him.
While historically US urban communities separated the upper class from the poor through housing projects or gated communities, society is changing as houseless individuals live in every major section of the city. Due to the rising populations of the houseless, poverty becomes present in every neighborhood as more and more individuals sleep on the streets and tents continue to increase as forced exilic communities within the city. However non-geographical "boundaries" hinder our work in Portland with houseless individuals as we attempt to integrate men, women, and children into the fabric of our society. As we have begun to partner with coalitions to develop camps, tiny homes, and provide services for those on the streets it has become evident that helping these individuals requires the support and acceptance of community members, who continue to separate themselves from "those poor people." The use of "Police Sweeps" in Portland, to dislocate our Lazarean community has begun to create sympathy for these humans, a needed ethic among our community. Our work to build new houseless communities through collaboration with agencies, schools, and congregations has also offered opportunities for individuals to “cross boundaries” and care for those who are “truly” our neighbors in “occupied American communities.”
|
Welcoming the Other Rather Than Sweeping the Strangers and Outsiders in Your City: Luke's Rich Man, Lazarus, Boundaries, and Houseless Humans in Portland
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Ron Clark, Portland Seminary
While Luke's story of the Rich Man and Lazarus was an attempt to teach a well to do audience to show compassion for the poor, it also became a story concerning boundaries. The Rich Man would not cross boundaries to help Lazarus, therefore Lazarus could not cross a divide to help his suffering tenant. Since ancient communities dwelt with the poor rather than confining them to sections of the city, the boundaries were more than geographical.
While historically US urban communities separated the upper class from the poor through housing projects or gated communities, society is changing as houseless individuals live in every major section of the city. Due to the rising populations of the houseless, poverty becomes present in every neighborhood as more and more individuals sleep on the streets and tents continue to increase creating exilic communities within the city. However non-geographical "boundaries" hinder our work in Portland with houseless individuals as we attempt to integrate men, women, and children into the fabric of our society. As we have begun to partner with coalitions to develop camps, tiny homes, and provide services for those on the streets it has become evident that helping these individuals requires the support and acceptance of community members, who continue to separate themselves from "those poor people." The use of "Police Sweeps" in Portland, to dislocate our Lazarean community has begun to create sympathy for these humans, a needed ethic among our community. Congregational leaders, and their congregations, have an important role in modeling “welcoming the others” who sleep outside in our cities, communities, and neighborhoods.
Resistance from neighborhoods, law enforcement, service providers, and business owners has not only become a challenge but a barrier to "welcoming the stranger among us." Those who are "social refugees" not only struggle to find support from the community, but faith communities as well. Welcoming or accepting these individuals, families, and communities requires crossing boundaries of fear, judgment, and trust as our coalitions partner with others to create a "home" where peace, safety, and justice exist for social exiles needing support and love. In this paper I intend to discuss methods we are using to develop relationships and help our community "cross" these emotional/spiritual boundaries to create Luke's empire of justice, peace, mercy, and shalom.
|
Moses and the Kid, Judah and the Calf, and the Disavowal of Compassion
Program Unit: Animal Studies and the Bible
Geoffrey Claussen, Elon University
This paper draws on Aaron Gross’s book The Question of the Animal and Religion in analyzing two rabbinic stories regarding compassion for animals: a story of Judah the Patriarch disavowing compassion for a calf but later showing compassion to a group of young rats, and a story of Moses showing compassion for a young kid. The paper explores ways in which these two stories reveal the shared vulnerability of humans and animals, show animal agency, and have been understood as teaching compassion for all creatures. It then focuses on how these stories have been understood as encouraging compassion only in very limited ways, especially given the necessity of animal sacrifice, and it considers how while the narrative regarding Judah shows a transition towards greater compassion for animals, the narrative regarding Moses may be read as showing a transition in the opposite direction, from compassion to disavowing animal suffering.
|
Constructing Colonial Identity in Missive Discourse: Temporal-Spatial Movement in the Jedaniah “Archive” at Elephantine
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
Lisa J. Cleath, George Fox University
This study will consider the materiality of the Jedaniah collection from Elephantine in light of process theory of identity and temporal-spatial discourse. The Jedaniah collection is composed of ten Aramaic documents, originating over the course of at least twenty years in the mid-fifth century BCE. The documents include copies of letters sent from and received by members inside of the “Jewish” community as well as Persian-backed authority figures. Since these texts were published in 1907, many scholars have discussed their content in relation to their “Jewish” themes, but few have questioned the theoretical frameworks employed for examining the material nature of the documents. A methodological framework will be presented that sets process theory of identity in conversation with Thomas Tweed’s temporal-spatial theory. Process theory of identity has developed in the context of post-colonial discourse in order to explore how colonialized communities over time construct hybrid, dynamic identities in response to and in development of the internalized experience of colonialization. Interacting with the work of Jon L. Berquist, Christiane Karrer-Grube, and Katherine E. Southwood, this study will suggest that the rule of the Persian Empire over the “Jewish” community on Elephantine and the inherent inter-cultural interactions in this sub-province of the Persian Empire should be examined through a lens that accounts for the dynamics of imperial power and the hybridity of process identity common to colonized communities. Moreover, it is appropriate to consider temporal-spatial movement in the Persian Empire as it is reflected and developed through the material artifacts of the Aramaic missives in the Jedaniah collection, since a missive by nature is a temporally-delayed text sent between geographically separated communities. The result of this missive communication is a distal community discourse that develops over time in a network of spatially removed community nodes and authorities. The spatial nature of this discourse suggests that Tweed’s analysis of space as differentiated, kinetic, interrelated, generated, and generative will be a productive means of analyzing these Aramaic letters as texts that actively construct colonized group identity across space and time. Analysis in light of process theory of identity and temporal-spatial theory will shed light on the challenges of the debated “Jewish” identity of the community constructed in the Aramaic letters of the Jedaniah collection.
|
Water and the Authenticity of Holy Sites in Early Christian Pilgrimage Narratives
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Rangar H. Cline, University of Oklahoma
The narrative sections of the Bordeaux Pilgrim's account of his journey (333 CE) begin and end with water - starting with Cornelius the centurion's bath at Caesarea and concluding with the baptismal spring at Bethsur and the well at Terebinthus. In her study of the Bordeaux Pilgrim, Susan Weingarten noted the importance of springs and wells for the pilgrim, counting fifteen mentions of water sources in the brief narrative section (ca. 130 lines). She noted that water sources would have been of importance to any traveler in the region and that the Roman world contained many healing springs and others that had magical and fertilizing powers. This paper pushes Weingarten's argument further and argues that descriptions of springs and water sources composed by the Bordeaux Pilgrim (333), Egeria (381-384), and the Piacenza Pilgrim (ca. 570) followed a Greek and Roman narrative tradition of using water sources to authenticate holy sites and demonstrate past and continuing epiphanies. The paper traces subtle shifts in the presentation of water sources in these texts, from the Bordeaux Pilgrim's use of springs to demonstrate authenticity, the role of Egeria's guides in showing her multiple springs that signaled divine presence and on-going epiphany, and the Piacenza Pilgrim's description of springs alongside other authenticating relics and vestigia. The paper concludes by suggesting that Egeria's and the Piacenza Pilgrim's narratives reveal the evolving complexity of pilgrims' encounters with water and its material presentation, as part of an immersive sensory experience that allowed the pilgrim to gain blessings and transport the miraculous power of the Holy Land homeward.
|
Synonyms in Classical Hebrew
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
David J.A. Clines, University of Sheffield
Not since the nineteenth century has any substantial work been done on Hebrew synonyms (and that was only scratching the surface). In an attempt to move the focus in Hebrew lexicography from the individual word to the relations between words, I have been creating sets of synonyms in Classical Hebrew. They have begun to appear as an element in the new Dictionary of Classical Hebrew Revised, each of its 10,000 words (lemmas) being furnished with a list of its synonyms. It is surprising, and not generally known, how very many there are. The average Hebrew word has 4 synonyms, but some have many more (50+ for strength, 30+ for darkness). Fewer than 10% of words have no synonym. This paper will deal with (1) definitional and theoretical issues about identifying synonyms, (2) the number and scope of those synonyms, and (3) inferences that may be made about the character of the Hebrew language (what may be said of a language that is so rich in synonyms though now so poorly attested, with its textual remains amounting to only c. 400,000 words, half the length of Shakespeare?).
|
Denominative Verbs in Classical Hebrew
Program Unit: International Syriac Language Project
David J.A. Clines, University of Sheffield
Our lexica label certain verbs as “denominative”, that is, derived from a noun, as are the English “to school”, “to hoover” or “to junk”. The term is problematic for Hebrew because we know so little about the history of the Hebrew language, and cannot affirm that a given noun is older than its supposedly denominative verb. But we can rehabilitate the term by removing it from the sphere of time (one earlier, one later) and transferring it to the sphere of logic (the meaning of a denominative verb presupposes and incorporates that of a noun). Thus the verb khn “act as a priest” incorporates the meaning of the noun kohen “priest” and is logically dependent on the existence of the noun; likewise the verb qyn “lament” incorporates qinah “lamentation” and spp “stand at the threshold’ incorporates sap “threshold”. No lexicon or other source has collected anything like the 330 such denominative verbs in Classical Hebrew that I have identified for the new edition of the Dictionary of Classical Hebrew Revised, now beginning to appear. In this paper I am analysing ten types of relationship between denominative verbs and their nouns, in categories such as resultative (to make something into an X, e.g. make bricks), instrumental (to use X, e.g. build a wall), performative (to do or perform X, e.g. be an archer) and privative (to remove X from something, e.g. clear of ashes). Most interesting are cases where a new word must be postulated as a denominative verb. For example: ’tsr “store up” appears to mean in one place “appoint as a treasurer”, but that cannot be the meaning of such a hiphil; we must suppose instead another verb ’tsr “be a treasurer”, derived from a noun ’otser "treasurer". The verb bnh "build" twice means in niphal, apparently, “have a son”; that too has to be a second bnh, derived from ben “son”, and not directly connected with bnh "build". The verb ‘tr “surround” appears to mean in piel and hiphil “crown”; that also must be another, denominative. verb, in this case from the noun ‘ateret “crown”.
|
Women in Syria and the Syrophoenician Woman
Program Unit: Student Advisory Board
Christy Cobb, Wingate University
At the end of 2016, the siege on Aleppo, Syria by the Assad regime was becoming increasingly intense. Desperate for information, I scoured the Internet to determine what was happening in Aleppo. Many news sources, it seems, were failing to report the gruesome genocide that was occurring. In my search to find sources, I turned to Twitter. I found twitter accounts of people who remained in rebel-held Aleppo and were live-tweeting their experiences. As I started clicking and reading, I stumbled across the twitter account of Bana Alabed (@AlabedBana), who was only 7 years old when her city fell. Her mother, Fatemah, recorded Bana’s cries for people in the world to listen. She wrote on her daughter’s account: “Dear world, we are running out of food, hospitals. Dear world, why are you watching this unmoved?” (9/18/2016). A day later, Bana herself wrote: “Stop the bombing – Bana” (9/29/2016). This mother and daughter were crying for help to anyone who would listen, but the world seemed to ignore them.
As I read the tweets and watched the videos, I thought of the story of the Syrophoenician woman from the Gospels of Mark and Matthew. The Syrophoenician woman, desperate for help for her daughter, interrupts Jesus during his search for peace and quiet. She shouts, “Have mercy on me, Lord, Son of David!” (Mt. 15:22). But Jesus refuses to listen. Even more, the disciples attempt to silence her imploring Jesus: “Send her away, she keeps shouting after us.” (15:23) This woman refuses to be silenced or sent away, even after Jesus says directly to her: “It is not fair to take the children’s food and throw it to the dogs.” (Mk 7:27; Mt. 15:26) She responds: “Lord, even the dogs under the table eat the children’s crumbs” (Mark 7:28). In Mark, Jesus reluctantly heals her daughter; in Matthew’s retelling, Jesus commends her faith.
Connecting the Syrophoenician woman to these women in Aleppo is my “aposiopesis.” I still follow this mother and daughter on twitter; Bana is now well known, she has even published a book containing her story. In their words, I hear the voice of the Syrophoenician woman asking for help and being silenced. Yet, each time I sit down to write something substantial about this connection, I cannot finish it. The standards of proper biblical interpretation block me at each turn. My nascent understanding of the complexity of Syrian history and politics shrink me from the page. But the voices of suffering women and the ghosts of women who came before them will not let me go. Moreover, I wonder about the ways that contemporary Christianity aligns with Jesus in this story, refusing to hear the voices of the marginalized from this part of the world. I imagine that the Syrophoenician woman of the gospels remains in our world today asking, “Dear world, there's intense bombing right now. Why are you silent? Why? Why? Why? Fear is killing me & my kids.” (Twitter, 12/14/2016).
|
Review of J. Walton's Old Testament Theology for Christians, and R. Gane's Old Testament Law for Christians
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Gary Cockerill, Wesleyan Biblical Seminary (Emeritus)
Review of J. Walton's Old Testament Theology for Christians, and R. Gane's Old Testament Law for Christians
|
FastText: A Computational Semantic Approach to Lexical Choice in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Mathias Coeckelbergs, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
In this contribution, we critically evaluate the potential of FastText for the study of lexical interchangeability in the Hebrew Bible. Single concepts, such as ‘receiving’ or ‘arising’, can linguistically be realized in a variety of different ways, qbl or lqh ̣, and, qwm or ‘md, respectively. This phenomenon of near-synonymy can be described in terms of lexical choice in a series of specific lexical contexts. Rezetko and Young have explored multiple examples of the tendency of specific texts to favor specific lexical variants over others in the Hebrew Bible (“Historical Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew: Steps Toward an Integrated Approach”, 2014, most notably pp. 263-318), which they use to characterize the traditional distinction between early and late biblical texts as a mere stylistic difference. For each of the cases they present, they provide a survey of all biblical texts, with the addition of occurrences in the Dead Sea Scrolls and Ben Sira. There is to date, however, no quantitative study of the exact context in which these attestations can be found.
In this presentation, we use word embeddings to evaluate whether the contexts of the near-synonyms proposed by Rezetko and Young are similar, and if so, to what extent they are similar. Do these near-synonyms genuinely present opportunities for lexical choice? We place our results next to those of Rezetko and Young, to fill in the contextual blanks. This method also allows us to identify other lexical items that are semantically closely related to the synonyms under scrutiny. The present investigation uses state of the art computational methods to create abstract, numerical, algebraic representations of the contexts in which a word is found. These representations are described as word embeddings, viz. they capture the context in which a word is embedded. The word embeddings of FastText, in contrast to most machine learning algorithms, do not need a large training set to provide salient results. They hence include a lexical item’s collocates, but do so in a way which makes it possible to compare the contexts using relatively straightforward linear algebra. They have proven incredibly efficient and valuable for artificially intelligent systems used and developed by major technology companies like Google and Facebook. The FastText library from Facebook’s AI laboratory is an openly available word embeddings module that has features making it particularly suitable for small corpora with morphologically rich data, such as the Hebrew Bible. Our study of the representation of word contexts as higher-level vectors is exploratory, but promising: it yields new insights into the study of near-synonymy and the methodological challenges not only of identifying, but also quantifying lexical choice and degrees of semantic equivalence.
|
The Mishnaic Rabbi and the Matthean Jesus: Comparison, Commonalities, and Contrasts
Program Unit: Matthew
Akiva Cohen, Independent Israeli New Testament Scholar
In this paper I engage Moshe Simon-Shoshan's Stories of the Law: Narrative Discourse and the Construction of Authority in the Mishnah (New York: Oxford Press, 2012), wherein he distinguishes between two basic categories of authority of religious leadership in antiquity: the leader as an authority, and the leader in authority: the former deriving from certain inherent qualities or abilities, and the latter deriving from a position one holds within a certain social or political structure. Simon-Shoshan's rabbinic-authority categories may be helpfully enlisted as they apply to the Matthean Jesus. The mishnaic "rabbi" is normally depicted as deriving his authority from the category of "wisdom," with only a very minor acknowledgement as a miracle-worker, or ascetic.
By selectively examining one exemplar story of both the halakic authority type and the charismatic miracle worker type in both the Mishnah and in Matthew's Gospel, I aim to compare how each of these texts presents, respectively, the mishnaic Rabbi, and the Matthean Jesus. In the exemplar stories in the Mishnah, Simon-Shoshan's deft unpacking of the halakic issues each exemplar story brings to the fore, helps us see how the editors of the Mishnah navigate threats to (emerging) normative halakah. The ambiguities of the Mishnah's discourse leave the reader with an open reading of these exemplar stories, precisely what the editors intended, viz., that the reader would encounter these exemplum stories in dialogue with one another forcing the reader to engage more in questions than ready conclusions. Nonetheless, even this very selective comparison and limited selection demonstrates that halakic norms are extremely important to the rabbis, to their hegemony of authority, and to community stability.
If ambiguous instances of halakic authority present obstacles to be overcome by the Tannaim, the miracle worker, or hasid is more problematic yet. This type of authority (the miracle worker) does not 'fit' the normative rabbinic model of authority and thus represents a more volatile and more complex type to be overcome by the mishnaic rabbis in their ongoing program of establishing their authority and community norms.
With the above background, or foil, I then proceed to discuss an example of each type or exemplar story from two Matthean pericopae. My goal is first to discuss them within their Matthean narrative and social contexts, and then to compare both the mishnaic rabbi and the Matthean Jesus. In sum, the goal of my comparison is to bring these texts into contact with each other, and to see what light such a comparison may shed upon our understanding of each: their programmatic agendas, and how each respective text seeks to establish their authority figures: one seeking to establish the authority of the Rabbi of the Mishnah and the other of the Matthean Jesus.
|
Gideon's Royal Feast
Program Unit: Meals in the HB/OT and Its World
Margaret Cohen, W. F. Albright Institute of Archaeological Research
Whether Gideon assumed kingship enjoys no scholarly consensus. Though the text itself puts words of refusal in Gideon’s mouth at the offer of kingship, the events of the larger narrative provide adequate grounds to debate whether his denial is credible. Typically, this debate centers on the philosophy of kingship proffered by one or more hands behind the book of Judges, the nature of Gideon’s authority as priest or judge, or the relationship between Gideon’s account and that of Abimelech. One aspect of the narrative which has received little attention is whether Gideon provides a public, royal feast, as does, for example, David when he delivers the Ark to Jerusalem. Gideon’s entire narrative arc in Judges 6-9 includes numerous references to foodstuffs and food preparation activities. These specific inclusions in the story reflect deconstructed components of a royal feast, elements of food and drink which function in the biblical text and in the wider Near Eastern world to negotiate political hierarchy, to fulfill ritual needs, and to legitimize authority. Together with other royal signifiers, the meal portions of Gideon's narrative argue for the assumption of kingship.
|
Almanah and Yatom in Genesis 21
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Noam Cohen, New York University
The MT narrative of the expulsion of Hagar and Ishmael in Genesis 21 contains a jarring syntactical disjunction. After their provisions are used up and Ishmael begins to die, Hagar puts the boy down, raises her voice, and cries. Gen 21:17 then twice mentions that God heard the voice of the boy. This disjunction in who cries and whose voice is heard has led several ancient writers (Septuagint and Jubilees) and modern scholars to emend the text to make either Hagar or Ishmael both cry and be heard. These solutions are inadequate, however, as the MT reading, which is also preserved in the SP and Vulgate, is the lectio difficilior. An adoption of the smoother versions of the expulsion narrative leads one to miss the intentionality behind the disjunction in the narrative. This paper suggests that a key to understanding the lectio difficilior is our new understanding of Hagar and Ishmael as Biblical Hebrew almanah and yatom respectively. Despite it commonly being translated into English as “orphan,” yatom refers to “a child without a living paterfamilias.” One text which attests to a yatom with a living mother but a dead father is Ex 22:23, which imagines a scenario where an almanah and her yatom son are both alive.
The common use of almanah and yatom together as a word pair suggests that their meanings should be largely parallel. We therefore propose a translation of almanah as “a woman who was formerly connected with a man (who was not her father or brother), but is now without a supporting male family member,” a definition which works well with the repeated use of almanah in the Pentateuch to refer to a social class in need of assistance. This definition is supported by the Akkadian cognate almattu, which CAD translates as “woman without support,” in addition to the more commonly used translation of “widow.” One example of almattu functioning primarily in relation to male-supplied financial support can be seen in Middle Assyrian Law 33: “If her husband and her father-in-law are both dead, and she has no son, she is an almattu.” Our new definition of almanah would include Hagar, a slave-concubine who was expelled by Abraham with no financial support, and whose son was not yet old enough to provide for her. Similarly, Abraham’s expulsion of Ishmael dissolves their father-son relationship, making Ishmael into a yatom.
With Hagar and Ishmael established as almanah and yatom, we suggest that the disjunction in Genesis 21 is an allusion to the almanah-yatom law in Ex 22:21-23. The law begins by including both the almanah and yatom, but ends with God hearing the cry of the yatom specifically, and the expulsion narrative in Genesis 21 begins with an almanah and yatom, and specifically ends with the yatom being heard, which is accentuated by the mention of the almanah, but not yatom crying out.
|
Either/or or Both/and? How Do Revealed Eschatology and Revealed Wisdom Relate to Each Other?
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Adela Yarbro Collins, Yale University
Rather than continuing the debate about whether eschatology or cosmology is the point of departure in the study of the impact of apocalypticism on the New Testament, I will propose in my remarks that future work focus on how the two are related in particular works. Another helpful focus would be on how particular passages blend the two.
|
The Importance of Source Criticism and Composition Criticism in the Interpretation of Revelation
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Adela Collins, Yale University
*
|
The Dogs of Philippians 3: Furthering Recent Proposals
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Ryan D. Collman, University of Edinburgh
The scholarly trope that Jews commonly referred to gentiles as dogs, has colored exegesis of Philippians 3:2 for centuries. This view gave rise to the interpretation that when Paul calls his opponents “dogs,” he is inverting this epithet ironically and using it to identify them as Jews. Recently, Mark Nanos has demonstrated how baseless this age-old interpretation is. His investigation of the Jewish sources establishes that nowhere in these texts do Jews use dog as a slur towards gentiles. His work cleaned the slate and opened up space for sorting out this invective and passage, which remain puzzling. Following in the footsteps of Nanos, Matthew Thiessen is the most recent scholar to offer new insights Paul’s on employment of the term dog. He argues from the perspective that Paul’s use of dog is similar to Jesus’ usage in the Gospels (Mark 7:24-30; Matt 15:21-26) and should be read in the context of a mission to gentiles and essentialist constructions of ethnicity. This paper seeks to interact with and build off of their work, offering an additional interpretive layer to Paul’s employment of the term dog. Here, I suggest that in addition to Paul’s use of dog as an ethnic identifier, it is also possible that he also employs it as a vulgarity that identifies the object of his opponents’ obsession: their circumcised penises. Read alongside the other invectives in Philippians 3:2 and the broader argument in which they occur, this reading provides evidence that each component of his tripartite warning takes aim at the opponents’ obsession with and promotion of Judaizing circumcision, which sets Paul up to make his claim to the title of “the circumcision.”
|
Soliciting Divine Manifestations: Proto-orthodox Practices in the Late-Second and Early-Third Century CE
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Jason Robert Combs, Brigham Young University
During the second and third centuries CE, epiphanies featured prominently in the literature, letters, inscriptions, and art of the pagan (non-Jewish, non-Christian) world that Christians inhabited. The gods revealed the future, offered protection, commanded particular actions or honors, punished, and performed miraculous healings in dreams and visions. Building on the work of both Jacqueline Amat and Patricia Cox Miller, I situate early Christian divine and demonic encounters within this broader Greco-Roman context. Christian discourse on dreams and epiphanies was often engaged in distinguishing Christian practices from those of the pagan world. Drawing upon recent work in the anthropology of dreams (e.g., Crapanzano, Mittermaier, etc.), this study examines the practices that Christians adopted and developed for eliciting divine manifestations. Some Christians may have engaged in practices common to their location alongside their pagan neighbors—magic, local temple rites, etc. Yet Christian authors, such as Tatian, Athenagoras, Tertullian, and others, sought to distinguish Christianity from other forms of religious life in part by defining proper and improper dream practices. Tertullian, for instance, distinguishes between Christian and pagan forms of fasting as a means of eliciting divine manifestations (e.g., De Ieiunio 11–12). He likewise distinguishes between pagan and Christian locations, such as the theater and the church respectively, according to the influence of those locations on the demonic or divine character of the otherworldly being one might encounter (e.g., contrast De Anima 9.4 with De Spec. 26). Focusing on Christian engagement with space and other embodied practices, I show how such practices helped Christians to navigate their social contexts—succeeding, in part, through the very act of expanding those contexts to include the otherworldly.
|
The Shepherd of Hermas and the Problem of Non-Christian Epiphany
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Jason Robert Combs, Brigham Young University
Shepherd of Hermas exemplifies a practical problem that confronted early Christians: how to respond to the epiphanic activity of non-Christian deities. When the “shepherd” first appears (Herm. Vis. 25.1-4), Hermas believes that the shepherd has come to either test or tempt him (Greek: ekpeirazō). Since Hermas typically encounters benevolent angels and since this otherworldly being is later revealed to be benevolent, scholars often translate ekpeirazō as “test” rather than “tempt” (e.g., Osiek; Ehrman; etc.). I argue, however, that Hermas’s reaction and his interpretation of the otherworldly being’s intentions is better represented by the word “tempt” (cf. Lampe). By situating this account from the Shepherd of Hermas within the broader context of epiphanic encounters in early Christianity and the wider Greco-Roman world, I demonstrate why the manifestation of a divine being in the form of a shepherd was problematic and how Christians responded to this problem. Christians would eventually adopt the image of the shepherd from pagan art because of its association with Christian and Jewish textual traditions. Yet the image of the young shepherd was more widely recognized as a representation of the pagan god, Hermes—occasionally Apollo or Orpheus. Since it was commonly accepted that gods were identifiable in dreams by association with their images, the manifestation of a divine being in the form of a shepherd would most readily be identified as a pagan god. The most common Christian response to the problematic manifestation of non-Christian deities was to identify them as malicious demons intent on leading Christians astray. Hermas evinces this perspective when he questions the Shepherd’s intent and believes the manifestation to be a temptation.
|
Texts, Trade, and Travel: The Letters of Dionysios of Corinth
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Cavan W. Concannon, University of Southern California
Modern historians map the diversity of early Christianity in a variety of ways, from declines into heresy to competition among “varieties” of early Christianities. Drawing particularly on the philosophical work of Gilles Deleuze and Bruno Latour, this paper argues that we might better map the remains of second-century Christianity by focusing on networks of people, ideas, and letters that moved along broader patterns of trade and communication in the eastern Mediterranean. Focusing on the costs, velocities, and viscosities of movement and commerce, I examine the network associated with Dionysios of Corinth, whose writings come to us only as fragments and summaries in Eusebius’ Ecclesiastical History. I show how non-human actants such as geography, economic activity, and trade routes shape the interactions within Dionysios’ network, allowing us to think more broadly about second-century Christianity as a series of emergent networks that form, coalesce, and dissolve in the flow of movement and connectivity that characterized the Roman Mediterranean.
|
Theopolitics, Archaeology, and the Ideology of the Museum of the Bible
Program Unit: Metacriticism of Biblical Scholarship
Cavan W. Concannon, University of Southern California
Archaeology has always been political. The excavation of ancient sites has long been tied to national identity and the findings of archaeologists continue to be sifted through the lens of nationalist politics. Archaeology can also be theo-political. Biblical archaeologists have long been conscripted into fights between Israelis and Palestinians over the meaning of their “discoveries.” Archaeology in Israel and elsewhere has also been used in arguments about the historicity of the biblical narratives, arguments that are really about whether the Bible is an authoritative and divinely inspired source of legal, theological, and moral authority. The theo-political use of archaeology is on full display in the newly-opened Museum of the Bible in Washington, DC. With a massive footprint, a $500 million price tag, and a location just blocks away from the Capitol, the Museum makes a powerful argument about the historicity and value of the Bible through a selective deployment of its collection, much of which is drawn from the 40,000 objects and manuscripts owned by the Museum’s founder Steve Green, the conservative evangelical owner of Hobby Lobby.
In this paper, I show how the Museum uses archaeological materials to argue for the historicity of the Bible, an argument that is tied to larger political interests in presenting the US as a Christian nation that should be governed more in line with evangelical theology. This paper, based on several visits to the Museum, includes close readings of several different aspects of the Museum’s presentation and collection of archaeological materials: the use of ancient objects in a modern re-creation of Jesus’s Nazareth, a series of documentary-style videos that are featured throughout the Museum (called “Drive Thru History”), the Museum’s collection practices and selective curation, and the use of objects borrowed from state archaeological services (such as the Israeli Antiquities Authority) or copied and displayed as facsimiles in the Museum’s exhibits. The paper will also ask about the ethical role that biblical scholars and archaeologists have in engaging with the Museum.
|
Ignatius Peregrinus: Ignatius of Antioch as a Voluntary Martyr
Program Unit: Student Advisory Board
Cavan W. Concannon, University of Southern California
Ignatius of Antioch is famous for his anticipated death as a Christian martyr, having left us a series of letters penned on his journey to Rome, imprisoned and anticipating trial. But what if he wasn’t? What if—as I speculate—he was actually a voluntary traveler who sought martyrdom for himself? In this paper, I follow my hunch that Ignatius wasn’t a Roman prisoner at all, but rather had deliberately chosen to travel to Rome in order to become a martyr, stopping by a number of early Christian collectives along the way. My hypothesis that Ignatius was staging his martyrdom is based on the long and expensive travel route that he took from Antioch to Rome, a route that would have been far more expensive to the Roman state than shipping him directly to Rome from Antioch by ship. Ignatius’ travel seems intentionally staged for the gaze of Christian collectives in Asia Minor and Macedonia (and beyond). A staged journey to martyrdom also coheres with Ignatius’ own rhetoric about conflict in his home collective of Antioch: in response to stasis at home, Ignatius has voluntarily chosen to sacrifice himself to encourage factions in Antioch to reconcile themselves and to do so by presenting himself as a traveling martyr-in-the-making to other Christian collectives, increasing the social pressure on the Antiochenes to find a path to homonoia. Ultimately, my hunch is that Ignatius was so effective at staging his martyrdom that he became the martyr par excellence for future followers of Jesus. But what if he made it all up?
|
Envisioning the Invisible: A Materialist Analysis of the Late Antique Shrine of SS Cyrus and John
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Jordan Conley, Boston University
This paper considers the late antique shrine of SS Cyrus and John located at Menouthis (modern Abuquir) at the Canopic mouth of the Nile in antiquity-about twelve miles east of Alexandria. Before it developed into a Christian healing shrine, Menouthis served as an important cult center of Isis and throughout its history the site maintained its function as a locus of healing and pilgrimage-likely reaching its height of fame and popularity (in its Christian iteration, at least) in the sixth and seventh centuries CE. However, despite its attested appeal, the only substantial accounts of the shrine and its pilgrims are preserved by a single author-Sophronius, the patriarch of Jerusalem (c. 560-638 CE), who claims have been healed of an eye complaint by the saints and, in exchange, composes a detailed account of the miraculous healings at Menouthis. In his miracle accounts, Sophronius depicts the shrine as a vibrant, visceral space of material and bodily entanglements: bodies erupt, blood gushes, reptiles slither, crowds gather, attendants hasten. The saints, though perhaps ephemeral, are also physically-even alarmingly-interactive. Indeed, Sophronius does not simply describe a compelling thaumaturgical display, but in fact depicts the shrine as a full "sensorium." In this sense, the text invites a materialist, synesthetic analysis of the space, context, and participants of the shrine-an analysis that is complicated, however, by the complete lack of surviving material remains.
Due to the lack of artifactual and archaeological evidence, the shrine of SS Cyrus and John has not been subjected to the types of spatial-structural analyses that have been performed on comparative sites, including Abu Mena and Qal'at Sem'an. Though its immateriality does not preclude considerations of Menouthis as both "constructed" in the literature and located in a broader sacred topography, this paper offers other, additional means of approaching the physical place and ritual space of the shrine. That is, though the lack of archaeological evidence presents obvious methodological challenges for scholars accustomed to working with physical remains, it also creates an opportunity for the shrine to be re-populated, re-invigorated, and re-imagined in accordance with approaches typically reserved for material analyses.
In offering a glimpse of what such a materialist, sensory analysis of the shrine of SS Cyrus and John might look like, this paper outlines the ways in which the physical and spatial features of the shrine, as described or implied by Sophronius, inform visitors' movements and perceptions. In lieu of an exhaustive approach, the paper identifies several areas of social and ritual potential, each of which lends insight into the various sensory features and physical affordances of the shrine, and hence contributes to an understanding of the ways in which the space was negotiated at both the individual and the collective levels. Moreover, by exploring ways in which to glean material insights from absent remains, this paper engages in a broader methodological intervention in the study of late antique sites (both extant and non-extant) associated with pilgrimage, incubation, and divine healing.
|
Hungering and Thirsting for Resurrection: Origen’s "On First Principles" and the Realities of Food Scarcity in Antiquity
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
Karen Connor McGugan, Harvard University
The issue of a general resurrection was, in second and third century Christianity, a source of intense debate. Proponents of bodily resurrection struggled to describe the nature, appearance, and function of the resurrected body—a body that would be the same as it was during life and also different, defined simultaneously by undeniable continuity and profound transformation. What would such a body look like? What would it be able to do? What, if anything, would it need to do? Since the hypothetical resurrection body would be unrestrained by the limitations of mortality, early Christians were free to answer these questions in whatever ways they saw fit. Questions concerning the role of food and drink in the resurrection provoked a uniquely diverse and charged set of responses: Some literary sources insist that eating and drinking will be unnecessary and even impossible for the resurrected body, while others describe a resurrection characterized by lavish feasting.
The persuasive projects that underlie these responses, however, are arguably indicative of the elite nature of our sources: the resurrected body’s relationship to food is constructed and deployed in discourses around necessary and natural desires, the formation of the self, Christ’s resurrected body, millenarianism, and Christian participation in Roman burial practices, among others. One topic seems conspicuously absent: nowhere in the extant literature is the question of nutrition in the resurrection explicitly used to think about hunger. Is it possible to reconstruct a greater diversity of ancient imaginaries concerning the resurrection body?
Origen’s "On First Principles" polemicizes against (supposedly) unintelligent and lustful Christians who insist that they will eat in the resurrection, using this position as a foil against which to argue for his own, less fleshly understanding of the resurrected body. As Origen tells it, these Christians justify their position through overly literal interpretations of scripture. In this paper, I explore the ways in which this “simplistic” hermeneutical approach is, throughout Origen’s corpus, associated with a distinct rhetorical category of persons: the level at which one interprets scripture often seems to correlate not only with intellectual capacity but also with socio-economic status. "Against Celsus", for example, describes Christians incapable of allegorical readings as “country bumpkins” (hoi agroikoi) and those mired in poverty. I then turn to contemporaneous evidence for regular food shortages among non-elite persons in the Roman Empire. Galen’s "On the Properties of Foodstuffs" provides what claim to be eyewitness accounts of the culinary habits of hoi agroikoi as a way of defining the limits of a civilized diet: In situations of economic vulnerability, where are the boundaries of what is acceptable to eat, and what are the somatic effects of these questionable foods? I argue that, based on evidence from Origen’s larger corpus and from contemporaneous sources, we should understand his invective against those who hope for an eating, drinking resurrected body in the context of chronic food scarcity. For at least some Christians in the second and third centuries, resurrection may have represented access to food and drink not attainable during life.
|
The Spirit of Life: Vision and Empowerment for Public Engagement in Eastern Europe
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Corneliu Constantineanu, University of Arad
The historical context of Eastern Europe is a very complex one and the legacy of the totalitarian regime is still visible today in several areas of life. One such issue is the atrophy of the capacity for dreaming, for envisioning a better world, the capacity for imagination and hope. It becomes obvious that one of the most important and urgent tasks of the church in this context is to search for and articulate a solid public theology of culture, of work, of social engagement, of justice and reconciliation, of hope, a public theology for the common good and human flourishing. In this paper I would like to address the particular question of the place and role of the Spirit not only as the foundation of Christian life but also for the recovering of the dreaming, imagination and vision. It explores various facets of the activity of the Holy Spirit as the spirit of life, of empowerment, the spirit of prophetic hope, of truth, of solidarity, of boundary-crossing. It is argued that such an understanding of the Spirit is both faithful to the biblical witness and empowering for a particular presence and engagement of Christians in the public life.
|
AI and Gender in the Garden: Ex Machina and Genesis 2-3
Program Unit: Bible and Film
Colleen Conway, Seton Hall University
Alex Garland’s Ex Machina (2015) sets a modern, sleek laboratory in the midst of a lush garden for an exploration of humanity, sexuality, and artificial intelligence. The film concerns the relationship between a young man, Caleb, and Ava, a gynoid. The film presents the viewer with clear evocations of Genesis 2-3, but to what end? This paper explores the role of Ava in the context of the filmic use of fembots and the history of reception of Eve. On the one hand, it appears that Ava should take her place in the long line of femme fatales issuing from interpretations of the “cunning” Eve. On the other, she is arguably truly posthuman and thus postgender. What might this mean for alternative readings of Eve in the garden? This paper explores the intersections between Ex Machina Genesis 2-3, exploring how the film pushes the boundaries of interpretations of Eve, while never quite escaping traditional hermeneutical patterns.
|
Interventions in the "Reception" of the Bible
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Colleen Conway, Seton Hall University
My recent book Sex and Slaughter in the Text of Jael: A Cultural History of a Biblical Story (Oxford Press, 2016) is framed as a case study for how one might study “cultural performances” of biblical texts. The book offers in-depth analyses of several cultural moments in which the biblical tradition of Jael and Sisera proved useful for both reflecting and shaping contemporary debates about gender, sex, power and violence. Given this project, my contributions on a panel discussion would be focus on certain methodological interventions that undergirded the book.
One such intervention concerns the use of the term “reception.” While the term has become quite firmly engrained in biblical scholarship and perhaps is a useful in some cases, I join other scholars in urging a consideration of the limits of the term. Especially in the case of artistic renditions of biblical traditions, I suggest that the “use” of the bible and its ongoing “effects” are not receptive as much as performative. Cultural uses of biblical traditions transmit and transform ancient stories, again, by speaking with and through these traditions to contribute to more immediate cultural conversations. In this case, the study of the use and impact of biblical traditions apart from ecclesial and theological contexts can be particularly revealing in terms of what elements of a tradition become the key “talking points” of the tradition.
A second intervention concerns how biblical scholars have tended toward the “artist as exegete” model for analyzing the intersection between Bible and visual art. While this may be appropriate in some circumstances, in many instances it overlooks other factors that contribute to the production of a particular painting. I urge a more nuanced consideration of the ways that visual art intersections with the Bible. Following Mieke Bal, one can acknowledge the biblical “pre-text” of the work, while also considering the ways that the “visual narrative” of the painting may respond to or revise the tradition, again often in ways that link with the cultural setting and conditions for artistic project.
|
Paratextual Rewriting as Theory and (Reading) Practice: The Case of the Eusebian Gospel Apparatus
Program Unit: Religious World of Late Antiquity
Jeremiah Coogan, University of Notre Dame
In the early fourth century CE, Eusebius of Caesarea (ca. 260–339) devised a paratextual system to guide the reading of Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John as a bibliographic and canonical unity. This system of reference tables and marginal section numbers was the first set of cross-references ever devised and enjoyed widespread reception from Late Antiquity onward. Encoded within Eusebius’ gospel apparatus were numerous creative juxtapositions, invitations to particular exegetical and theological readings of the gospels. Eusebius’ project presents a question about the intersection between theory and methodology: Post-structural literary criticism posits as axiomatic that to change a text is to rewrite it. Yet what does this “rewriting” mean for the experience of the reader of Eusebius’ system? How would we know?
Literary theorists such as Barthes, de Certeau, Derrida, and Genette posit (each in their own way) that to change a text or its context of reading is to rewrite that text. Rewriting, moreover, includes what Gérard Genette has called “paratexts”—features such as headings, tables of contents, and so forth. These interventions present the text to the reader and serve as “thresholds of interpretation” (Genette, /Paratexts/, 1). Jerome McGann has extended Genette’s insights, arguing with reference to the work of William Blake and Emily Dickinson that text, layout, and material features together instantiate “the text” available to the reader. Scholars of manuscripts have long noted something similar; the range of critical perspectives often termed “New Philology” emphasize that every material artifact offers a different “text” for the reader. These insights are heuristically helpful, and enable us to situate Eusebius’ paratextual intervention within longer trajectories of gospel (re)writing.
Yet even if paratextual interventions like Eusebius’ system of cross-references constitute a sort of rewriting, what difference do they make? What method can one employ to /see/ the difference that paratextual interventions make for a reader of the gospels? Or is the rewriting so minor that it can safely be ignored (for most purposes, at least), even if notionally present? This methodological challenge is compounded by the difficulty that persistently accompanies attempts to reconstruct reading practices; as Roger Chartier asserts, reading “only rarely rarely leaves traces […] scattered in an infinity of singular acts” (/Order of Books/, 1–2). How can one decipher these traces?
In this paper, I focus on how theory informs method, and /vice versa/, in my dissertation. I present several case studies from the reception of the Eusebian apparatus—including its adaptation in the Syriac Peshitta and the dynamics of “corruption” and “correction” in medieval Greek manuscripts—in order to discuss the ways in which one can assert that the Eusebian apparatus “rewrites” the gospels which it paratextually presents. I argue that, perhaps paradoxically, one sees the Eusebian apparatus as rewriting most clearly when it is itself /rewritten/. Subsequent histories of change illuminate how readers approached the Eusebian apparatus and, through it, the gospels.
This is a submission for the dissertation-stage open-call session.
|
Eusebius of Caesarea, Historiography, and the Gospels
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Jeremiah Coogan, University of Notre Dame
Eusebius of Caesarea, Historiography, and the Gospels
|
Periphrastics and Pseudo-periphrastics in the WAYIHI + QOTEL Construction
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Edward Cook, Catholic University of America
All combinations of the verb HYH and the active participle (signified by QOTEL) in Biblical Hebrew have been deemed "periphrastics" in the literature (e.g., Joosten 2012: 257ff.). However, an examination of the construction wherein HYH appears as WAYHI indicates that a good many of them are not true periphrastics. In a true periphrastic, we propose, the subject of HYH must also be the subject of QOTEL and the semantics must be progressive or habitual (not stative or adjectival). This is demonstrably not the case with some occurrences of WAYHI + QOTEL, and in many others it is questionable. This raises the question whether other supposed periphrastics, with HYH in the perfect or imperfect, fairly meet the proposed criteria.
|
Alleged Christian Crosses in Pompeii and Herculaneum
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
John Granger Cook, LaGrange College
In recent years, certain scholars have claimed that three objects from Herculaneum and Pompeii are Christian crosses. One believed that a cruciform shape in Herculaneum and a piece of furniture beneath it indicated a Christian chapel, and many have asserted that it is a Christian cross. Some have argued that a cruciform shape on a lost inscription in Pompeii, CIL IV, 10062, is the cross of Christ. Likewise, some have interpreted a cruciform bas relief in a bakery in Pompeii, which has not existed for almost two hundred years, as a Christian cross. The thesis that these cruciform artifacts in Herculaneum and Pompeii are Christian crosses, which prove a pre-Vesuvian Christian presence in Campania, is unwarranted. CIL IV, 10062 is probably just a scrawl. The cruciform indentation in a wall of Herculaneum was simply left by the support for a shelf. The bas relief in a bakery in Pompeii likely portrayed some kind of baker's tool.
|
Adopting Biblical Ethics into Modern Poverty Contexts: An Ancient Tradition
Program Unit: Bible and Ethics
Matthew J.M. Coomber, Saint Ambrose University
Systemic poverty is a ubiquitous byproduct of advanced economics; literary and archaeological evidence reveals this has been the case since the first agrarian communities shifted from subsistence to political-economic strategies. But how did biblical authors address systemic poverty, and can their ancient perspectives find relevance in modern economic environments that would have been unimaginable to them? To address these questions, it needs to be acknowledged that the biblical authors, themselves, borrowed their ethos of community responsibility for the wellbeing of individuals from yet earlier ethical and economic systems that were ancient to them.
The relevance of the biblical ethos of community responsibility endures across time and culture, in part, because it acknowledges a basic human trait that is now being confirmed through psychological data. Paul Piff, Michael Kraus, and other behavioral scientists find that privilege affects the mind in ways that breed contempt for those of lower standing, leading to higher propensities for self-interest and unethical behavior toward others. While systems of extraction evolve over time, the problem of privileged entitlement and its financial and psychological consequences on the impoverished remain relatively constant.
In conversation with examples of privileged entitlement and anti-poor sentiment in U.S. politics and popular culture, this paper will demonstrate how an ancient biblical ethos of community responsibility for the individual’s wellbeing—as reflected in the Holiness and Deuteronomistic codes and in the prophetic corpus—can be an effective tool for confronting modern systemic poverty, understanding its complex social dimensions, and for critiquing the effectiveness of current approaches to social-justice advocacy.
|
“Their Leaves Shall Be for Healing”: Ecological Trauma and Recovery in Ezekiel 47:1–12
Program Unit: Biblical Literature and the Hermeneutics of Trauma
Rebecca Copeland, Boston University School of Theology
In Ezekiel 47:1-12, the prophet offers his readers—Israelites suffering from deportation, military defeat, and exile—a vision that assures them of Yahweh’s power and desire to restore them to their homeland, healed and whole. Drawing from both trauma and ecological hermeneutics, this presentation shifts the interpretive lens from the traumatized human community of Israel to the traumatized land from which they have been exiled. First, I offer a preliminary definition of trauma as a disordered state resulting from severe stress or injury that impairs a creature’s ability to function. This definition encompasses the psychological and social trauma that has been the focus of biblical trauma hermeneutics thus far while also making room for the experiences of creatures that are other-than-human under its rubric. I explore an example of such trauma plaguing many different parts of the world today by examining soil salinization and the loss of ecosystem functionality that it causes. I then turn to the text of Ezekiel 47:1-12, employing the ecological hermeneutics principles of suspicion, identification, and retrieval. Specifically, I identify with the soil-water-vegetation communities that made up the plains between Jerusalem and the Dead Sea. To do so, I draw more recent research on salt-induced soil degradation in other parts of the world into conversation with the biblical text and its vision of a fructifying stream that will return life to this desiccated area. Finally, I examine the relationship of modern proposals for biological soil remediation to the vision of restoration offered in the text, finding evidence that the tradition from which Ezekiel drew may have possessed forms of indigenous ecological knowledge applicable to the soil crisis. This examination raises a challenge to biblical trauma narratives that transfer agency for disasters from human beings to Yahweh, insists on the affirmation of human agency in the recovery from ecological trauma, and opens a new avenue for engaging biblical interpretation through the lens of indigenous ecological knowledge.
|
The Costobar Affair: Comparing “Idumaism” and Early Judaism as Species of Hellenistic Levantine Cult
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Collin Cornell, Sewanee: The University of the South
Qos was the national deity of the Iron Age kingdom of Edom in the southern Transjordan. When the Edomite kingdom collapsed, however—likely during Nabonidus’s campaign of 553/552 BCE—devotion to Qos did not cease. Theophoric names invoking Qos appear in the southern Levant throughout the Persian and Hellenistic periods. Josephus writes that as late as 34 BCE, an Idumean priest named Costobar (“Qos is mighty”) resented the imposition of Jewish customs on his people and conspired against Herod the Great to restore Idumean sovereignty and traditional Idumean religion (AJ 15.253-255); in the words of Shaye Cohen, “‘Idumaism’ was not yet dead.” Most scholarly work that addresses the Costobar affair considers “Idumaism” in its aspect as either the latest, twilight stage of Edomite religion or as a neighbor and annex of early Judaism. The present paper proposes a new way of approaching the “Idumaism” to which the Costobar episode refers—and alongside it, a new way of approaching early Judaism: as species within the genus of Hellenistic Levantine cult. It argues, that is, that Idumean religion and early Judaism are parallel phenomena: adaptations of ancestral Levantine religious practice, centered on a formerly national deity, within the changed conditions of the Hellenistic era. For both communities, Idumean and Judean, adaptation included conservation and innovation. Both communities maintained devotion to their patron god under his traditional name (YHWH and Qos, respectively), while they also pioneered new ways of worshiping “in translation,” even by invoking their deity with a Greek title (e.g., Zeus, as in 2 Macc 4-6; or Apollo, as shown by Idumean records from Egypt). Both communities persistently envisioned devotion to their god in terms of restored national sovereignty even as they sought the power and succor of their god under occupation and in diaspora. Although the present paper demonstrates the similarity of Idumean religion and early Judaism, it also notes their principal difference: namely, that early Judaism increasingly focused on the literary codification of their traditions—the Hebrew Bible—whereas Idumean traditions remained unwritten.
|
"Receiving a Kingdom that Cannot Be Shaken": Daniel 7 and the Eschatology of Hebrews
Program Unit: Hebrews
Felix H. Cortez, Andrews University
The 28th edition of the Nestle-Aland of the Novum Testamentum Graece as well as most major commentaries have noted significant verbal parallels between the expression "since we are receiving a kingdom that cannot be shaken" in Heb 12:28 and Daniel 7:18. Nevertheless, the relationship between this passage and Dan 7 has not been explored adequately. The purpose of this paper is to explore the likelihood of an allusion to Dan 7:18 in Heb 12:28 and its possible relationship to the argument of Heb 12:18-29 and the eschatology of the letter in general.
Daniel was an influential book in the New Testament (over 150 allusions) and well-known in Second Temple Literature and the Apostolic Fathers. The majority of allusions to Daniel in the NT focus on the prophecies of Dan 7, in some cases together with allusions to Hagg 2:6-7, which is also quoted in Heb 12:26-27. The paper will show that an exploration of Dan 7 as an intertextual background to Heb 12:18-29 provides helpful perspectives to understand the nature of the judgment/panegyric scene at the heavenly Mount Zion in Heb 12:22-24, the enthronement scene and the following exhortation in Heb 1:5-2:5, the Son of Man in Heb 2:6-13, and the "last days" in 1:2.
|
Musical Entertainments at Hellenistic Royal Banquets
Program Unit: Meals in the HB/OT and Its World
Charles H. Cosgrove, Garrett-Evangelical Theological Seminary
Musical Entertainments at Hellenistic Royal Banquets
This paper examines the evidence for musical entertainments at royal banquets in the Hellenistic era, including attention to changes in sympotic rituals of song from the Classical to the Hellenistic age, the question of poets (such as Callimachus, Theocritus, and Apollonius of Rhodes) at royal banquets, modes of poetic recital, the question whether guests sang at royal banquets and in what formats, and the presence of slave/paid entertainers at royal feasts and the types of song and dance they performed. The nature of the music (what it sounded like) is also considered on the basis of papyrological remains of Greek songs with musical notation from the Hellenistic period.
|
The Appeal to Case-Precedent in the Story of Jesus’ Disciples Plucking Grain on the Sabbath (Mark 2:23–28 and Parr.)
Program Unit: Biblical Exegesis from Eastern Orthodox Perspectives
Charles H. Cosgrove, Garrett-Evangelical Theological Seminary
This paper examines the argument from case-precedent in the story of Jesus’ disciples plucking grain on the Sabbath (Mark 2:23–28 // Matt 12:1–8 and Luke 6:1–5), which appeals for a precedent to David and his men consuming the Bread of the Presence (1 Sam 21:1–6). Special attention is given to John Chrysostom’s perspicacious treatment of this story in one of his sermons on Matthew, particularly his analysis of the appeal to David through the concepts of pertinence (ti to pros to zētoumenon), equivalence (to ison), and exonerating principle (nomos apologias). A wider cultural context for understanding appeals to case-precedent is provided through brief surveys of such appeals in Roman law, oratory, and rabbinic interpretation (Mishnah).
|
Enfleshed Encounter: The Emotional Potential of the Laments of the Individual
Program Unit: Bible and Emotion
Amy C. Cottrill, Birmingham-Southern College
How do texts create feeling? In this paper, I explore this question as a metthe hodological question for the study of the Bible and emotion: How do we study and discuss the way texts create feeling? I bring together affect criticism and the work of Medievalist and literary scholar Sarah McNamer to discuss the affective potential of the lament psalms of the individual, specifically Ps. 109. Affect criticism provides a range of questions and types of sensory inquiry that expand and deepen understandings of the effect of textual encounter within individuals and among audiences. Sarah McNamer’s work on “intimate scripts,” or embedded emotional narratives within texts, helps to conceptualize the process through which individuals and communities learn to feel in particular ways through repeated textual encounters and performances. McNamer recommends an approach that combines textual and historical study with attention to the embodied, kinetic aspects of the performance of texts, an approach which may be particularly valuable to the study of the Psalms.
|
Rereading the Christology of the Infancy Gospel of Thomas: The Rewriting of Luke 2:41-52 in Paidika 17
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
J.R.C. (Rob) Cousland, University of British Columbia
The Infancy Gospel of Thomas (=Paidika) cites only one extensive passage from the New Testament, namely Luke 2:41-52, the episode where Jesus' parents find him in the Temple with the teachers. This "Temple narrative" in the Paidika is textually reliant on Luke, and both narratives are important for the Christology of their respective gospels. The purpose of this paper is to use the Paidika's rewritten version of this narrative (Paid. 17.1-5) to examine how the author has rewritten Luke's Christology and refitted it to conform to the Paidika's own Christology. This rewriting manifests a strong focus on Jesus' divine (rather than human) paternity, his unprecedented wisdom, and his divine glory. These particular emphases in the Paidika's "Temple narrative" are likely a response to criticisms leveled at the second-century church by Christianity's Jewish and pagan detractors, and it is probable that this context accounts for the various differences between the two gospels' Christologies.
|
Wirkungsgeschichte and Trilateration; or How GPS Can Affect New Testament Exegesis
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Eric Covington, Howard Payne University
Global positioning systems (GPS) use overlapping satellite data to determine the location of objects. If only one or two satellites are available, there is a broad range of possible locations where the object may be. With the addition of data from a third satellite, a geometrical calculation called trilateration can be used that significantly increases the precision of the GPS. This paper seeks to examine how the process of trilateration in GPS can help understand the significance of Wirkungsgeschichte for New Testament exegesis. Drawing on the hermeneutical contributions of Gadamer and Jauss, New Testament exegesis can be understood as the "fusion" or "mediation" of the historical horizon of the exegete with the historical horizon of the ancient biblical texts. Like a GPS using two satellites, the overlap of these two horizons provides a range within which historical, biblical interpretation may occur. Much like the addition of a third satellite significantly increases the accuracy of a GPS, this paper will suggest that the addition of a third hermeneutical horizon--that of the text's Wirkungsgeschichte--can help create a more precise exegesis of New Testament texts. The study of a text's Wirkungsgeschichte allows for a three-way interpretive dialogue between text, history of reception, and interpreter that helps determine textual meaning as it broadens the horizon of the exegete and provides new and/or progressing questions to be asked of the New Testament text.
|
"Raised for Our Justification": Justification and the Resurrection of Christ in Paul's Letter to the Romans
Program Unit: Pauline Theology
J. Andrew Cowan, Independent Scholar
For many years, interpreters primarily linked Paul's doctrine of justification with his understanding of the significance of the death of Christ. This interpretation typically presented Christ's death as, in some sense, the discharging of the sinner's legal debt and also interpreted justification language in forensic terms. Recently, however, an alternative paradigm associated with the apocalyptic school of Pauline interpretation has arisen that instead places the emphasis on the links that Paul draws between justification and the resurrection of Christ and presents justification as an event of liberation from the enslaving powers of the present evil age. This essay seeks to address this discussion by exploring the soteriological significance that Paul attaches to the resurrection of Christ in several key passages in Romans 4–8, placing them in the context of early Jewish interpretations of the meaning of resurrection. The argument unfolds in two major movements. First, I propose that the links that Paul draws between the resurrection of Christ and justification are best explained in light of the strands of Jewish thought that associated resurrection with attaining a positive verdict in the final judgment. This background is most evident in Rom 4.25, 5.12–21, and 8.31–39. These passages demonstrate that, in Paul’s view, Christ’s resurrection stands as a metonymic pointer to God’s verdict on Christ’s own legal status, and the justification of believers consists in their incorporation into these realities. Second, I explore aspects of Rom 6.1–14 in order to demonstrate that, although apocalyptic interpreters are right to highlight that Paul associates justification and liberation, their claims about the meaning of justification language itself go beyond the evidence. Attending particularly to the role of Christ's resurrection in this passage, it becomes evident that liberation is a consequence of the decisive change in the believer’s legal status effected through incorporation into Christ. Overall, then, this essay argues that a forensic view of justification is not undermined but rather strengthened by attending to Paul's depiction of the soteriological function of Christ’s resurrection in Romans.
|
Julian of Norwich’s Intertextual Interpretation of Luke 15:11-32
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Kendall Cox, University of Virginia
The 14th c. visionary writer Julian of Norwich is one of the most creative biblical interpreters in the Christian tradition. She is famous for being the first woman to write an extant published work in English. What is sometimes overlooked in her devotional texts is the way she offers gloss upon gloss of scripture, obliquely translating passages into the vernacular. It appears she strategically obscures what she is doing, and this is perhaps one of the reasons she is often categorized primarily as a “mystic.” But a little excavative work brings her interpretive sophistication to the surface. Julian’s expansive and intricate intertextual method is best seen her in Example of the Lord and Servant, found in the Long Text of her *Revelations of Divine Love.* I argue that this “showing” is an unrecognized gloss on the Parable of the Prodigal Son (Luke 15:11-32) and that it frames the meaning of her subsequent excursus on divine motherhood.
In her engagement with the parable, Julian takes up the genre of medieval homiletic exempla and recasts the father and son in much the same way as Bernard of Clairvaux. She is familiar with the logic of “spiritual interpretation” described in Nicholas of Lyra’s distich and employs it masterfully in her otherwise unprecedented Christological reading of the Lukan text. In cinematic fashion, she recounts a vision of a servant who leaps up eagerly to serve his lord and immediately falls into a pit from which he cannot escape. As the story unfolds, structural resonances with the prodigal son begin to emerge. What also becomes evident is that she filters the parable through a dense matrix of scriptural allusions, overlaying it with the creation/fall sequence of Genesis 1-3 among others (e.g., Is. 53; Rom. 5:14f; 2 Cor. 5:21; and Phil. 2:6f). This set of references serves as a progressive lens, alternately bringing into focus the servant/son as a figure for fallen humanity as well as for Jesus Christ. Immersed in a deep reservoir of imagery, Julian’s imagination moves seamlessly from a plain or direct interpretive level to a deeper substratum of understanding. In her words, the parable is “shown double,” and this enables her to account—unlike anyone before her—for the excess of identity signaled in the biblical passage itself.
What is remarkable about Julian’s intertextual retelling is the way it reenacts both the form and content of the parable while also generating original theological claims. Most surprisingly, Julian is led to the conclusion that “God never began to love humankind” because of an “endless oning” in which “God is knit to our nature.” In other words, reading the parable through the baptismal hymn of Philippians 2, she claims God wills to become human from before time. Julian’s interpretation of the parable opens onto her description of the motherhood of God. The parabolic father/son dyad, initially recast as a master/servant, morphs into a mother/child, which she offers as the most fitting human analogy for the divine/human relationship.
|
The Parable of God: Karl Barth’s Theological Interpretation of Luke 15:11-32
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
Kendall Cox, University of Virginia
The Eternal Son is the Lost Son. That is the provocative assertion at the heart of Barth’s Christological interpretation of Luke 15:11-32. In what follows, I examine his engagement with the Parable of the Lost or Prodigal Son across *Church Dogmatics* on three levels: 1) his straightforward expositions of it as a generic story of grace, 2) his unusual association between Jesus Christ and the younger son in *The Doctrine of Reconciliation*, and 3) his allusive use of the narrative to describe election in *The Doctrine of God*. I conclude that the Lukan parable comes to narrate, for him, not only salvation, but also the person and work of Christ, and—more fundamentally—the being of God.
First, I address the “direct” readings of the parable Barth offers. His most extensive exegesis is found “The Homecoming of the Son of Man” (§64.2), which he calls “the decisive center” of his Christology, and mirrors “the Way of the Son of God into the Far Country” (§59.1). Self-conscious of the leap he is making, Barth initially advances a rather conventional interpretation of the parable, identifying the younger son as fallen humanity (the “publicans and sinners”), the father as God, and the elder brother as the “scribes and Pharisees” (Lk. 15:1-2). Reading it as a story of divine “retrieval” rather than human “repentance,” he maintains “no more than this” can be said “directly” and worries his subsequent reading will be perceived as a “strained” or “over-interpretation” (Überinterpretation). Yet he insists, “it is also possible not to do full justice to the passage” if we leave it “under-interpreted.”
Second, I recount Barth’s surprising Christological exegesis of the parable. Evoking sacramental language, he says we must consider what is given “in, with and under what is said directly.” Taking his rhetorical clue from the phrase “dead and alive” (vs. 24, 32), Barth expounds the parable as embedded in and animated by another story. We must ask, “To whom does this all refer?” The connection with the life of Jesus can be seen as an interpretive trajectory arising from the parable itself when it is coordinated with the intertextual nexus Barth conjures (viz. Jn 1:14, Rm. 5:14f, 2 Cor.5:21, Is. 53:10, and Phil. 2:5f). In the end, he does not simply offer a Christological reading; he presents his whole Christology in the register or mode of the parable.
Finally, I show how this interpretation implicitly structures not only Barth’s later trinitarian thought but also his earlier account of election or predestination. God’s becoming the “lost son” is one of the primary images he uses for the divine decree. He asks, “Who is the Elect? He is always the one who ‘was dead and is alive again’ who ‘was lost and is found.’” Barth concludes that God wills from before time to be lost and prodigal in love, in and as the second person of the Trinity. On his reading, this is what the parable retells: the inner life of God.
|
Philo's Allegorical Interpretation of Sacrifice in "On the Sacrifices of Cain and Abel"
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Ron Cox, Pepperdine University
An analysis of Philo's interpretation of sacrifice in "On the Sacrifices of Cain and Abel"
|
Along a Marvelous Way: The Significance of Middle Platonism for Understanding Wisdom of Solomon’s Soteriology
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Ron Cox, Pepperdine University
Wisdom of Solomon, a turn of the era text, was written perhaps a few decades after the revival of Platonism that occurred in 1st century BCE Alexandria and evinces similar characteristics in how it bridges the gap between divine and material realms. My paper argues that a Middle Platonic philosophical perspective pervades and informs the confluence of sapiential and apocalyptic traditions many scholars recognize as coexisting in the document. What’s more, moving out from the curiously ahistorical salvation history recounted in Wisdom 10 to the rest of the work, I demonstrate how attention to Wisdom’s philosophical tendenz helps us understand how Wisdom of Solomon recasts eschatological salvation as ontological fulfillment.
|
Ancient Israelite Healthcare, Ahaziah’s Ailing Body and the Ridicule of Baal in 2 Kgs 1
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Isabel Cranz, University of Pennsylvania
This paper argues that Ahaziah’s ailing body in 2 Kgs 1 is used deliberately to ridicule and condemn the cultic policies of the Omrides. Ahaziah’s failed consultation with Baal-Zebub in 2 Kgs 1 is often taken as a classic example of the organization of healthcare in ancient Israel. Thus, this episode shows that suffering individuals could call upon the support of deities and prophets. Building upon this insight, it can be demonstrated that 2 Kgs 1 uses Ahaziah’s health crisis to emphasize the power of Yahweh over and against his rival deity Baal. At first glance, this praise of Yahweh plays out in a rather humorous manner. Not only does Ahaziah’s ailment stem from an injury he sustained in a banal accident, he also turns to a deity with the ridiculous name of Baal-Zebub (Lord Fly). Ahaziah’s reliance on Baal-Zebub, then, leads to a standoff between the king’s troops and Elijah, who is depicted as a hairy prophet with a belt. Nevertheless, behind the façade of playful banter lies a serious issue, namely the question of the true god of Israel. Different aspects of this issue are addressed elsewhere in the Elijah-Cycle. The superiority of Yahweh, for example, is proven in the prophetic contest in 1 Kgs 18 while Yahweh’s power over life and death lies at the center of Elijah’s resurrection of the widow’s son in 2 Kgs 17. Yet, only the motif of the sick king allows for an artful merging of these issues by providing an opportunity to demonstrate the superiority of Yahweh in his power over life and death. As such, 2 Kgs 1 uses Ahaziah’s ailing body and customs of Israelite healthcare to combine two loosely connected themes and present Yahweh’s dominion over Israel as a non-negotiable fact existing outside of mundane matters like royal decrees and state sanctions.
|
Between Horror and Hopelessness: Stillborn Children in the Bible
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Isabel Cranz, University of Pennsylvania
Although the Hebrew Bible contains no direct depiction of a stillbirth, the motif of the stillborn child (נפל) is still invoked on several occasions. Basing my argument partly on contemporary studies on parental bereavement and perinatal loss (Sered, 1996; Keesee, Currier & Neimeyer, 2008; Arnold and Gemma, 2008), I will show how biblical scribes drew from the complex emotional range experienced by grieving parent to express feelings of desolation, isolations, hopelessness, futility and horrors. Thus, in Num 12 the stillborn child is used to describe the horrors of Miriam and Aaron when the former is suffering from a debilitating and isolating skin disease (צרעת). Furthermore, in Job 3:16 the stillborn child is measured against Job’s sense of hopelessness after Satan has destroyed his wealth and family and in Qoh 6:3 the same motif is used to characterize the life of perpetually dissatisfied individuals. Finally, in Psalm 58, the stillborn child is invoked in cursing the wicked and their evil machinations. These four examples demonstrate that the motif of the stillborn child is used to expand on the emotional response to bereavement by applying it to the existential themes of meaningless suffering, affliction and evil.
|
Building Descriptions and Image-Text Relations in the Bible and Ancient Near East
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Cory Crawford, Ohio University
Image-text relations are at the heart of the question of the extent to which the reality of the Jerusalem temple is indicated in the texts that describe it, even though scholars almost never explicitly theorize it in such terms. The nexus is instead usually explored through the question of historicity and reliability of the text as description of a real or imagined building, rather than as an interrogation of the authorial impulse to render visual objects in verbal dimensions. In this paper I survey and attempt to characterize the different ways the major building descriptions in the Bible (Gen 6–7; Exod 25–31; 35–40; 1 Kgs 6–7; Ezek 40–48; 2 Chr 2–4) are framed within their literary context with a special focus on visuality. I do this especially by reference to other ancient Near Eastern texts that attempt to make their audience “see” through words—especially the Epic of Gilgamesh—and also by reference to the concept of ekphrasis, which was defined in Greco-Roman rhetorical handbooks as a verbal attempt to bring a subject vividly before the “eyes” of an audience, and in modern art historical discourse as words about art. Attention to the presence or absence of visual cues in verbally framing these descriptions alerts the reader to subtle purposes of the description and shows different means of construing the relation between text and image. It also helps to refine and complicate the question of the reliability of the text as a window onto “the” first- or second- temple.
This discussion allows me to make some preliminary remarks about the larger question of ekphrasis in ancient Near Eastern rhetorical traditions. Although ancient Near Eastern texts have not yielded evidence of an explicitly established rhetorical category congruent to ekphrasis described in the handbooks of the Second Sophistic, some, like those examined here, do exhibit a distinct concern to bring the subject matter before the eyes of their audience, much like the authors of the second-century Progymnasmata thought Homer was doing in his description of Achilles’ shield, even though ekphrasis was not in Homer’s time explicitly defined rhetorically. Building on the work of other scholars of ancient Near Eastern material culture, we are able to point to a fairly robust tradition of rendering vision through words that merits further careful study especially in other genres, such as in the symbolic visions of biblical prophets.
|
Priestly Violence and Priesthood Authority in the Bible and LDS Church
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
Cory Crawford, Ohio University
Biblical texts indicate that a special kind of violence was at the heart of priestly authority. The stories and poems that describe the origins of the Levites speak to this violence, for example, in narratives such as the rape of Dinah (Gen 34), the Golden Calf (Exod 32), and the dismemberment of the Levite’s concubine (Judg 19–20), among several others. In previous venues I have argued that what makes this violence special is that the priestly sword in these stories cuts not Israel’s enemies, but rather turns inward toward other Israelites. This intra-clan violence, I argue, was meant to be understood as the distinguishing factor, at least literarily, that set apart this particular clan from among the tribes of Israel. It also formed an implicit argument for a priesthood that was gendered male, especially since some of this violence was directed toward or with reference to subordinate women.
The first part of this paper describes and situates these acts of physical violence within the broader framework so characteristic of priestly power and worldview, namely, the act of boundary maintenance. I compare the priestly texts that draw bright lines around space, time, kin groups, food, and even clothing—and station themselves as the gatekeepers—to distinguish the holy from the profane. I explore the extent to which these acts of distinction—circumscribed in the very notion of being “set apart”—can be construed as a kind of symbolic violence that cuts the boundary that defines the hierarchies of sacred and profane. The special violence described above is rooted in priestly identity because it marks the ultimate boundary. To shed the blood of one’s own kin is to define—and to claim—the only authority that trumps family.
In the second part of the paper I use these texts and concepts to think about the role of distinction and separation in Latter-day Saint priesthood power dynamics. Of course modern Latter-day Saint communities and leadership naturally and clearly denounce the sorts of violence described in these texts, but the biblical stories that get at the basis of priestly power provide a means of thinking about the role of concepts of distinction, setting apart, in LDS understandings of priesthood and in recent acts of boundary setting and maintenance by LDS leadership. It also provides occasion to think about the continuation of certain priestly concepts, such as sacred space, and their role in modern LDS priesthood power.
|
Scribes and Orality in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Sidnie White Crawford, University of Nebraska - Lincoln
I will be a panelist discussing scribes and orality in the Hebrew Bible in a special session reviewing Jonathan Ready's "Orality, Textuality, and Homeric Epic: A Study of Oral Texts, Dictated Texts, and Wild Texts."
|
The Pseudo-Ephrem: A Status Quæstionis
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Eric Crégheur, Université d'Ottawa - University of Ottawa
This paper aims to shed new light on the problem of the Pseudo-, or Greek, Ephrem. Ephrem the Syrian left an important literary corpus in Syriac, the only language he apparently knew and in which he wrote. But there is an equally important and imposing corpus of Greek works put under the name of Ephrem, which are all, for the moment and until proven otherwise, to be considered as pseudepigrapha. The many questions that one is faced with when approaching the Greek Ephrem corpus have so far been mainly ignored by scholars working in the fields of Patristics and Pseudepigrapha. These problems range from the identity of the author (one or many), to its relationship with Ephrem the Syrian and his authentic works, the accuracy of the inventory of the works put under his name, the influence and dissemination of these pieces, the reasons of their immense popularity, and the main obstacles behind a reedition of this collection. Such questions are in dire need of being reopened and looked anew, if only because of the importance of the corpus attributed to the Greek Ephrem and the extent of its circulation, not only in Greek, but also in many versions (Latin, Coptic, Armenian, Georgian, Slavonic, and Arabic). The object of this study is to lay the groundwork for a project whose goal is to reedit the pseudo-ephremian corpus, by proposing a methodology and identifying its main limits.
|
Toll Collectors and Gate Guardians: A Typical Gnostic Motif?
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Eric Crégheur, Université d'Ottawa - University of Ottawa
This paper intends to investigate the motif of the heavenly toll collectors and gate guardians, present in a number of “Gnostic” texts, such as the “First Apocalypse of James” and the “Apocalypse of Paul”. Considered by some to be a distinctive feature of “Gnostic” mythology, the motif is nevertheless found in other traditions, in forms that are more or less close to the one in which it appears in “Gnostic” literature. We will first start with a close examination of the motif as it is found in “Gnostic” texts, so as to clearly identify the different characteristics of the motif and its variations. Following this analysis, we will go back in time in search of what could be ancient forms of the motif, to see if and how it evolved, and to determine if and how contacts between traditions shaped this evolution. Finally, we will see if the motif can be found in contemporary and later sources, notably in the writings of the Church Fathers, and what this presence can tell us of how the motif was received in Late Antiquity.
|
Framing the "Woman in the Window": Liminality in Iconography and the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Israelite Religion in Its Ancient Context
Lacy K. Crocker Papadakis, Baylor University
Variations of ivory carvings with a woman at a balustraded window occur in Samaria, Arslan Tash, and Nimrud. The woman's identity remains an enigma and a figure of debate (Winter 2016). Scholars identify this iconic woman as some form of goddess/sacred prostitute (Herbig 1927; Zimmern 1928; Barnett 1956; Keel and Uehlinger 1998), though these views have undergone adaptations. Suter argues against the window goddess concept and views the woman as the queen waiting for her husband (Suter 1992). Ackerman (1998) proposes that the woman is a depiction of the Canaanite queen-mother and a representative of Astarte. Baker (2017) favors Suter's view and critiques Ackerman's portrayal based on the lack of supporting evidence regarding Astarte. These perspectives are linked to texts/stories: Aristophanes's Peace, Cypriot Aphrodite Parakyptusa, Babylonian goddess Kilili, Rahab (Josh 2:15, 21) Sisera's mother (Judg 5:28), Michal (1 Sam 19:12; 2 Sam 6:16, cf. 1 Chr 15:29) Jezebel (2 Kgs 9:30). The sexuality of the woman in window in iconography or texts often drives scholarly debate. This presentation initially takes a step back from identifying the woman in the window and from focusing on her sexuality. Instead, this presentation first addresses the window itself. The architectural frame forms the context of the motif (Winter 2016) and develops a formula for the motif (Suter 1992). The triple-inset frames and the detailed balustrade point to monumental architecture (Suter 1992; Roaf 1996; Winter 2016). Ackerman (2012), drawing on Cooper and Goldstein (1997), illustrates the danger of entryways and these dangers provide the point of departure for her analysis of the nude female figures that flank of model shrines compared to that of Keel and Uehlinger 1998; Dever 2008). This presentation applies Ackerman's analysis of entryways and the liminal space they create to the woman in the window motif in order to draw out the symbolism of the window and explores the concept of composite figures with relation to "mediating divine figures" (Burnett 2008). After exegeting the window frame iconography, the presentation synthesizes these findings with relevant texts in the Hebrew Bible.
|
Throwing Israel’s Bread to Gentile Dogs: Mark’s Complex Use of Hebrew Bible in the Story of Jesus and the Syrophoenician Woman in 7:25–31
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Sonya Cronin, Florida State University
Despite the fact that many consider Mark to be a “Gospel to the Gentiles,” intertextual references to Hebrew Bible abound. From the connection to the book of Jonah as Jesus sleeps on the boat while the storm rages in Mark 4, to the feeding of the 5000 in Mark 6 and its connection to Exodus 16, Psalm 23, and Ezekiel 34, many of the references are relatively obvious, featuring linguistic ties and thematic echoes. The story of Jesus and the Syrophoenician woman in Mark 7:25–31 however is not one that commentators have traditionally read with intertextual echoes in mind. A passage that has troubled many, prompting various explanations for Jesus’ apparent rude behavior, these seven verses can seem like an enigma coming out of nowhere. Yet, it is a linchpin between Jesus’ discussion of clean and unclean with the Pharisees and scribes earlier in Mark 7 and his ministry among the Gentiles in Mark 8. When read in the context of Hebrew Bible passages that Mark references earlier in the Gospel, it becomes apparent that Mark has been building a subtext that peaks with this story. Drawing upon Jonah, Exodus 32–34, and the Elijah narrative in 1 Kings, this paper will demonstrate how Mark weaves together these narratives, underscoring 7:25–31 to such a degree, that aside from a surface reading, the passage loses much of its meaning without an understanding of how Mark utilizes these intertextual ties.
|
David Taking Bathsheba as His Wife: A Righteous Deed; A Narrative Look At 2 Samuel 11-13
Program Unit: Book of Samuel: Narrative, Theology, and Interpretation
Sonya Cronin, Florida State University
The story of David and Bathsheba in 2 Samuel 11 is one of the most infamous tales in the Bible. The willful and premeditated transgression of David is clear in the text. He committed adultery with Uriah’s wife, and when she was found to be pregnant, he had Uriah killed in battle and took Bathsheba as his own. The sin of coveting and taking is stark; nobody doubts David’s guilt. Nathan’s word of the Lord emphasizes this even more, “Why have you despised the word of the LORD, to do what is evil in his sight? You have struck down Uriah the Hittite with the sword, and have taken his wife to be your wife...” It is easy to take from this the implication that while there were severe consequences, in the end David got what he wanted, Bathsheba to be his wife. However, when paired with the connected story of Tamar and Amnon, it seems that David taking Bathsheba as his wife, might have been the only “righteous” thing he did in this entire episode (2 Samuel 11-12). In fact, it is arguable that taking Bathsheba as his wife is what saved his life. Using a narrative perspective, this paper will evaluate 2 Samuel 11-12 in light of 2 Samuel 13 to argue that with the nuance of David’s sin in regard to Bathsheba, taking her as his wife was actually a righteous deed.
|
Envisioning a Compiler at Work: Scribal Features of Papyrus Amherst 63
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Joseph Cross, University of Chicago
This paper investigates the scribal features of Papyrus Amherst 63, a multi-genre compilation of hymns, ritual and narrative which are Aramaic in language but written in a unique Demotic orthography. Datable to as early as the 4th century BCE, and as late as the 2nd, this utterly unique scroll, the longest surviving Aramaic language document from antiquity, has received increasing attention in recent years, due not in small part to a putative version of Psalm 20 on the scroll. The most outstanding question about P. Amherst 63 is its purpose. In pursuit of this, I will look beyond its frequently studied orthography and engage in a careful observation of its peculiar scribal features, in order to propose a scenario that accounts for the scroll’s creation and thus its purpose as well. Pertinent considerations will be the methods used by the scribe to delimit units of meaning, such as words and sections dividers, as well as units of textual space, such as intermarginal lines between columns of text. The handwriting of the scribe, which clue us into his writing process, is also of special interest. Finally, I will consider the construction of the scroll itself and rethink the traditional ascription of recto and verso. Based on these observations, I will construct a picture of how this compiler worked, arguing that the scroll was created by an Egyptian priest who visually transcribed---and not by taking dictation---at least one Aramaic document, and probably more than one, into a compilation meant for ease of consultation and possibly textual reuse. Further support for this argument will be drawn from contemporary Demotic Egyptian scribal culture. This paper will be the first sustained voluminological analysis of the papyrus, as well as the first argument for its purpose based on extensive physical evidence. I will end by considering implications for the influx of Aramaic literature into Egypt and its interaction with native literature. I will also rethink how we conceive of the creation of compilational texts, making pertinent comparisons with Egyptian and biblical literature.
|
Biblical Studies and "Conservative Liberal" Terror
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
James Crossley, St Mary's University, London
This paper will look at some of the changing ideological tendencies at play in Anglo-American biblical scholarship (though with a focus on New Testament scholarship and the study Christian origins) since Jesus in an Age of Terror: Scholarly Projects for a New American Century was published in 2008. A decade ago the impact of the War on Terror, following decades of Orientalist discourse about the Middle East and North Africa, was becoming increasingly apparent in scholarship, whether conservative or liberal. Since then, accompanying a shift in scholarly discourse from ‘Fairly Conservative’ to ‘Conservative Liberal’ (to use an influential taxonomy of online scholarship), and notable changes in uses of social media (remember biblioblogging?), has been an emboldened liberal rhetoric to justify (often implicitly) American exceptionalism, even or especially when done in opposition to Trump. This paper will look at some of these developments and how they have even begun to colonise metacritical scholarship itself.
|
When Momma Preaches: A Womanist Maternal Homiletic
Program Unit: Homiletics and Biblical Studies
Stephanie Buckhanon Crowder, Chicago Theological Seminary
This paper will provide an overview of a womanist maternal homiletic. Through the lens of race, gender, class and motherhood this project discusses the unique ways in which African American preaching seeks to connect biblical texts to current-day culture for the sake of personal praxis and communal uplift. By expounding on the lives of proto-womanist mother-preachers such as Jarena Lee and Elizabeth the work establishes both a historical and hermeneutical tradition for such homiletical discourse. The exercise will conclude by demonstrating this preaching method using the Matthean account of the mother of James and John as a harbinger of modern #SportsMommas.
|
Reading the Acts of the Apostles with Francis Turretin
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Brandon Crowe, Westminster Theological Seminary
This paper considers the interpretation of the Acts of the Apostles in the work of Francis Turretin (1623-1687), particularly in light of modern-day approaches to Acts. I will give particular attention to the way that Turretin utilizes Acts in his Institutes of Elenctic Theology to address both discontinuity and continuity between the New Covenant era and the Old Covenant era, which are issues that continue to occupy interpreters of Acts today.
First, Turretin relies on Acts to speak of the discontinuity between the gospel era and the era of the Old Testament. This is evident in his engagement of Acts 15, where he recognizes the need for temporary concessions. Discontinuity is also evident in Turretin's emphasis on the newness of the Holy Spirit's anointing in the life of Jesus (Acts 10:38), and in the transition in Jesus's lordship after his resurrection (Acts 2:36). Turretin further appreciates that the gospel message is one that focuses on the finished work of Christ (Acts 13:12).
Second, despite his awareness of discontinuity in Acts, Turretin also uses Acts to support a large measure of continuity between covenantal administrations. In this way Turretin's approach is set in rather sharp relief to many contemporary discussions of Acts. Turretin even finds continuity in some of the same passages he relies on for discontinuity. This is evident in his approach to Acts 15, where he discusses the abiding relevance of God's moral law, as well as the unity of salvation for Old Testament believers and New Testament believers (15:11). Turretin also finds in Acts evidence for continuity of the Holy Spirit's work; for Turretin, absolute statements of the Spirit's outpouring in the New Covenant era are to be taken as relative, rather than absolute. Further showing continuity in Acts are statements about salvation in the name of Christ (e.g., Acts 3:26; 4:12; 10:43), which were already true before the incarnation. Similarly, Turretin's approach to Psalm 2:7 in Acts 13:33 is not so much about demonstrating the resurrection as it is the manifestation and declaration of the eternal sonship of Christ.
In conclusion, I bring Turretin's voice on Acts in conversation with contemporary biblical scholarship. Turretin's approach to Acts offers a window into the crystallizing tendency of early Modern Reformed theology that has potential to shed new light on familiar debates in modern discourse. This may include more further discussion of the continuity of the Holy Spirit, especially in light of the use of Scripture in Luke and Acts. Turretin also reminds present-day interpreters of Acts of historically important theological debates, such as the eternal sonship of Christ-a topic ripe for further discussion in biblical scholarship.
|
Rahab and the Colonizers
Program Unit: Joshua-Judges
Brad Crowell, Drake University
The Rahab narrative has been read various ways in recent years - from the traditional harlot to a heroine who uses her skills to fool her own king and the spies. But the story of Rahab is part of a Deuteronomistic pattern of indigenous women who side with the Israelites and become integrated into the community. This pattern has been read by postcolonial critics as characters who work on behalf of the colonizing forces to betray their own people. This paper will argue that the ambiguities within the text itself allows for variety of ideological readings but that the postcolonial reading does promote an important way reading of this text against the history of interpretation.
|
Righteousness and/or Justice in Matthew?
Program Unit: Matthew
Vaughn CroweTipton, Furman University
Recent work has identified the Greek dikaio family as a possibly misunderstood word group. According to Wolterstorff (2008), Stassen (2003), and others in their work on justice and the Sermon on the Mount, dikaio related words, usually translated as “righteousness” or “righteous,” are better understood as “justice.” In fact, scholars in the in the field of Classics more typically translate this word group as justice. This paper explores the hypothesis that δικαιοσύνη should not only should be translated as “justice” but that it also makes sense of the Gospel of Matthew by illuminating the central role of the Sermon on the Mount, especially 5:17-20 as an interpretive focal point. If this hypothesis is correct, the issue of justice in Matthew, and perhaps elsewhere in the New Testament, is more central to interpretation and praxis than typically thought.
|
Parallelism, Structural Poetics, and Psalm 18 in the Tiberian Masoretic Reading Tradition
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Daniel J. Crowther, Worcester College, University of Oxford
The poetics of variant repetition in the Hebrew Bible have been analysed in many different ways with many different degrees of complexity. A litmus test for this analysis is its connection to the reception history of the text. On the one hand, it is difficult to accept the relevance of structures and patterns unearthed when there is no evidence that they have ever been observed by prior generations. On the other hand, it is difficult not to accept the relevance of such structures and patterns if they can be shown to have been a significant part of the reception history of the text.
The accents on the Masoretic Text of the Hebrew Bible provide a prime witness to the early reception history of the Hebrew text. These accents direct the reader in regard to the stress, pause and intonation to be used in the reading of the verses. This paper observes the way in which the masoretic accents (ṭe‘amim) of Psalm 18 acknowledge and enhance the hearing of certain parallelisms. The Masoretes appear to have been attentive to the presence of parallelism not only within its verses, but also between adjacent verses, and, most surprisingly, between non-adjacent verses. Despite this attentiveness to ‘trans-linear parallelism', the versification and accentuation of the text of Psalm 18 appear to have been arranged to deliberately avoid the delivery of the text in ‘strophes’ or patterns, that is, according to principles of structural poetics.
The import of these observations to biblical exegesis can be variously interpreted dependent upon the degree to which the masoretic sigla are understood to represent its ancient interpretation and its canonical identity. However, even if these sigla represent no more than the reception history of the text in late antiquity, the masoretic awareness of parallelism and potential structural poetics is most significant. Furthermore, the obscuration of the macro-structural poetics of the text begs the question why the text should be presented to be read in this way.
|
Location, Location, Location: Mary’s Shame and the Birthplace of Jesus
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
N. Clayton Croy, Independent Scholar / Retired
The birthplace of Jesus is a point at which popular and scholarly views diverge sharply. The Gospel accounts locate his birth in Bethlehem, and there is no explicit counter-tradition. But stories about the adult Jesus assume that Nazareth was his hometown. The Gospels and Acts consistently refer to him as “Jesus of Nazareth,” and so a number of scholars favor Nazareth as the birthplace of Jesus. But if Jesus was born in Nazareth, whence the Bethlehem birth tradition? The Infancy Narratives are notoriously difficult to reconcile on the matter of geography. Matthew has not a hint of Jesus’ family originally living in Galilee. The first geographical marker (Matt 2:1) locates the family in Bethlehem. Only later do they migrate to Galilee due to the threat of violence. Luke locates the family’s origins in Nazareth and explains their move to Bethlehem as due to the census of Quirinius, a connection that is nearly impossible to reconcile with Jesus’ birth during the days of Herod the Great (Luke 1:5). But despite these starkly different stories, Jesus’ birth in Bethlehem remains a point of agreement between Matthew and Luke. Some would explain the Bethlehem birth as a theologoumenon, i.e., a non-historical tradition created for theological reasons. This is suggested particularly with regard to Matthew, whose infancy narrative refers to Micah 5:2 (Matt 2:5) in connecting the Messiah with Bethlehem. But the argument for a theologoumenon is weak. The pre-Christian evidence for the Messiah being born in Bethlehem is meagre and ambiguous, and the evangelists had other views about the Messiah’s origin which they could have chosen. A more plausible reason lies at hand in the text of Matthew, namely, the social opprobrium of the untimely conception of Jesus (Matt 1:18-19). Jewish mores at that time would have taken a dim view of a conception prior to marriage, perhaps especially so in Galilee, which may have been stricter than Judea in this regard. If Joseph was not Jesus’ biological father, Jesus would have been viewed as a mamzer, i.e., the offspring of an illicit union, a classification that would have entailed shame and ostracism (Deut 23:2). Relocating to Judea would avoid this disgrace. Mary and Joseph’s departure from Nazareth and their return 2-3 years later would effectively conceal the timing of Jesus’ birth. It would also create the oddity of a person who was born in Bethlehem later being associated with Nazareth. But the phenomenon of persons in antiquity being born in one place but being associated with the locale of their adult career is by no means unprecedented. There are numerous examples of such relocations resulting in changes of geographical epithets. This paper proposes that Matthew, in effect, provides the rationale for a journey that he doesn’t relate, while Luke describes the journey but wrongly attributes its cause to the census. The result is that Jesus’ Bethlehem birth is historically plausible, even though Matthew’s account is oddly truncated and Luke’s account contains a chronological error.
|
The Importance of Conceptualizing Migration as a Religious Experience in Genesis 46
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
Gregory Cuéllar, Austin Presbyterian Theological Seminary
For biblical scholars seeking to develop an interdisciplinary approach to the biblical themes of forced migration, contemporary migration studies has much to offer in terms of theories, case studies, and terminologies. In one sense, drawing upon migration studies can enrich the interpretive imagination as to the varieties of human mobility. What this aim often points to are exegetical issues involving an event’s historical reconstruction, especially when the evidentiary material is lacking. Yet, this use of migration studies reflects a unidirectional path from theory to text. But what do biblical stories like the migration of Jacob into Egypt (Genesis 46) offer the discourse of migrations studies? In this paper, I aim to show how the integration of religious belief with the theme of migration in Genesis 46 suggests a conceptual framing of the migration experience that is consistent with contemporary stories of forced migration. Although there has been in recent years a developing emphasis on religious beliefs and practice within the literature of migration studies, such concepts are still peripheral to the discourse. As obvious as the links between religious belief and migration may seem for biblical scholars, these sorts of connections are not as prominent for migration scholars trained to empirically quantify the migration experience. In the end, what this paper offers is a preliminary discussion on the utility of biblical stories on migration for the discourse of migration studies instead of the other way round.
|
Shifting Sands and Solid Ground: Enduring Elements of Martyn's Thesis
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
R. Alan Culpepper, Mercer University
Martyn’s History and Theology in the Fourth Gospel ushered readers into a defining moment in the development of the Johannine community, and its publication quickly became a defining moment for Johannine scholarship. Although Martyn’s thesis was widely accepted, at least among American scholars, critical responses led both Martyn himself and others to revise his proposal, while others have discarded it. I will argue that both the thesis and critiques of it need to be nuanced and qualified. The thesis is multi-layered, and some of its elements continue to serve the pursuit of a historical reading of the Gospel.
|
Native Priesthoods and the Repatriation of Displaced Ethnic Minorities during the Reign of Darius I
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
Marshall Cunningham, University of Chicago
Scholars of diaspora assert the primary significance of economic factors as motivation for ethnic migration, including the repatriation of diaspora communities to their ancestral homelands. Some also attend to the importance of ideological factors, although generally as a secondary stimulus. In contrast, this paper argues for the equal importance of both concerns with regard to the participation of Judeo-Babylonians in the wave of return migration that occurred early in the reign of Darius I. Using comparative evidence concerning the Nippurian community of Bīt–Nērab and the Assyrian temple professionals of Uruk, this paper claims that members of native priesthoods played a critical role in the decision of displaced communities to migrate to their ancestral homeland. There is strong evidence–textual, onomastic, and material–for the perseverance (and in one case, explicit employment) of native priesthoods in all three diaspora communities. However, theological convictions like those outlined in the book of Ezekiel (chs. 20, 40–48) tied proper worship of each community’s patron deity–Yahweh, Sîn, and Aššur–to a city in the ancestral homeland. The reconstitution of the relationship between deity/priesthood/homeland functioned as ideological motivation for these priests and the communities they served. Beyond reinstituting proper worship, (re)establishing a temple in the ancestral homeland and serving there as a member of its priesthood also brought opportunities for increased economic and social capital for repatriated religious professionals. As not only religious, but also cultural and economic leaders, these priests–drawn by the ideological and economic opportunities that return migration offered them–played a decisive role in communal decisions about repatriation.
|
“Holy Envy” to “Holy Mutuality”?
Program Unit: Paul within Judaism
Philip A. Cunningham, Saint Joseph's University (Philadelphia, PA)
In 1985, during an interreligious controversy in Sweden, Bishop Krister Stendahl articulated three rules “for effective interfaith dialogue” that he later expressed as: “let the other define herself (‘Don't think you know the other without listening’); compare equal to equal (not my positive qualities to the negative ones of the other); and find beauty in the other so as to develop ‘holy envy.’”[1]
One of his protégés, Jesper Svartvik, later described “holy envy” as “the willingness to discern, to recognize and to celebrate what is good, beautiful and attractive in other religious traditions – and to let it remain what it is, i.e., something which is holy but which wholly belongs to the other.”[2] However, Svartvik also extended the trajectory of Stendahl’s thought by raising further questions: “How do we provide theological space for the Other? How is my faith influenced by the encounter?”[3]
A potent social force also at work in the Christian and Jewish encounter is the natural, human yearning for reciprocation when one community makes positive theological statements about the other. This might be expressed in the (perhaps unconscious) question: “What response do I expect from the Other after I’ve shared the holiness of my tradition with them?”
The prospect of such feelings alarmed Rabbi Joseph Soloveitchik as early as 1964 when he wrote: “we [Jews] certainly have not been authorized by our history … to trade favors pertaining to fundamental matters of faith, and to reconcile ‘some’ differences.”[4] Nonetheless, Christian-Jewish dialogue has unfolded over the ensuing decades, encouraged by such pioneers as Krister Stendahl.
This paper will examine recent Jewish and Vatican statements that evince such interrelational dynamics as respect for the Other’s self-understanding, a desire for reciprocity, caution about not “trading favors over fundamental matters of faith,” and, most recently, seeing the relationship between Jews and Christians as “a rich complementarity”[5] or as a partnership with “a common covenantal mission to perfect the world.”[6] The paper will suggest that the Christian-Jewish relationship may be showing signs of maturing from “holy envy” to “holy mutuality”—a rapport that inspires both communities to deepen their covenantal lives with the Holy One.
[1] Yehezkel Landau, “An Interview with Krister Stendahl,” Harvard Divinity Bulletin 35/1 (Winter 2007).
[2] Jesper Svartvik, “In Memory of Krister Stendahl on his Idea of ‘Holy Envy,’” Public Forum at the Shalom Hartman Institute in Jerusalem, March 24, 2009.
[3] Ibid.
[4] Joseph Soloveitchik, “Confrontation,” Tradition: A Journal of Orthodox Thought 6/2 (1964): 24.
[5] Pope Francis, “Apostolic Exhortation Evangelii Gaudium (January 24, 2014), §249.
[6] International Group of Orthodox Rabbis, “To Do the Will of Our Father in Heaven: Toward a Partnership between Jews and Christians” (December 3, 2015), §4.
|
The Personal Implications of "Sentences" in Proverbs
Program Unit: Cognitive Linguistics in Biblical Interpretation
Beth Currer, University of Wisconsin-Madison
Language comprehension theorists have long posited that language understanding is contingent on mentally picturing what utterances and pieces of writing are about. Mental simulation theory suggests that not only do people mentally picture what we encounter in language, we virtually experience it as well (Barsalou 1992, 1999, 2002, 2003 2008, 2010; Zwaan and Radvansky 1998; Zwaan 1999, 2003, 2008, 2009; Bergen 2005, 2007, 2012; Gibbs 2006, 2007, 2012, 2015). Lawrence Barsalou describes the experience of comprehending language as “being there conceptually” (2002, 2003, 2008, 2010). And Benjamin Bergen (2007) describes what he calls “a new, integrated field” comprised of cognitive linguists and experimental researchers all focused “on the idea that language understanding is contingent upon the understander mentally simulating, or imagining, the content of utterances.” Simulation-based views of meaning are closely tied to ideas about embodiment. Bergen (2007) describes the idea of embodiment in cognitive science as “quite straightforward. It’s the notion that aspects of cognition cannot be understood without referring to aspects of the systems they are embedded in – in the biology of the organism, including the brain and the rest of its body, and in its physical and social context.” People process language using the cognitive resources they have built up over time in the course of all the learning and experiences they have engaged in. We might ask how these ideas about language understanding ought to impact approaches to biblical interpretation. My research focuses on the book of Proverbs. So, in this paper, I explore how simulation-based views of meaning shed light on how readers draw personal implications from the “sentences” (or sentence literature) in Proverbs. The “instructions” that pervade Proverbs 1-9 and 22:12-24:22 and the “sentences” that dominate Proverbs 10-29 are recognized as different genres of Israelite/Jewish advice literature. They differ in form but share function and purpose: that of issuing advice and instruction and seeking to cultivate a certain kind of moral character in hearers/readers. Analyzing both forms in light of embodied simulation theory raises the question, how does a person mentally simulate an instruction? I use mental-space theory to show how one might do this. Relations between act/character and consequence—in histories of interpretation, tied to notions of (cosmic) order in Proverbs—are of central importance. Therefore in concluding this paper, I describe implications the analysis I offer may entail for the perceptions we formulate of order, knowledge, and pedagogy in this touchstone of “optimistic” didactic Israelite/Jewish Wisdom literature.
|
The Book of Ruth, Immigrant Women, and the Danger of Sexual Violence
Program Unit: Biblical Literature and the Hermeneutics of Trauma
Kelly D Dagley , Fuller Theological Seminary/ Hope Int University
The news is filled with stories of immigrant peril: drowning by sea, death by dehydration and exposure when traveling by foot in the desert, suffering suffocation in the back of an unventilated truck, etc. While immigrant women face these same dangers while migrating, they find themselves additionally vulnerable to sexual violence, including but not limited to being sexually harassed, having sexual favors demanded of them, and sexual molestation and assault. The vulnerability does not end once the journey is completed as immigrant women continue to face this risk in the workplace particularly in agricultural and domestic work.
The book of Ruth is an immigrant woman’s story. Where does Ruth’s experience of migration and twenty-first century immigrant women’s experience mirror each other? In this paper, observations are made by surveying migration and refugee studies of women’s experiences of migration, reading the book of Ruth with Latin American women who have immigrated to Southern California, and performing a narratological study of the text of Ruth in light of the previous research. Areas to be explored in the book of Ruth are: her journey from Moab to Bethlehem in Judah with Naomi, as she works in fields gleaning for survival, and in the great risk she takes to ensure security for herself and Naomi.
|
“Keep the Commandments … Sell Your Possessions”: Soteriology and Human Flourishing in the Narrative of the Rich Young Man (Matt 19:16–29)
Program Unit: Matthew
Jenifer A. Daley, Andrews University
In the wake of a social imaginary with accounts of human flourishing predicated on a modern anthropology and advanced as the normative final end for human existence, a more focused and intentional linkage between the economic state of affairs and the quest for salvation remains a desideratum. The long-standing tension between economics and religion finds expression in the conversation between Jesus and an inquirer described as “young” and “having many possessions” in the Gospel of Matthew (19:16-22). This paper uses that Matthean narrative to offer one compelling solution to the question as to how theology might reconcile the seemingly unbridgeable cultural abyss between conceptions of human flourishing and the quest for salvation.
A number of interpretive problems from the soteriological Tendenz in the pericope exposes the lack of a well-established crux interpretum among Christian scholars as schools of thought have variously interpreted the concatenation of “have eternal life” (v.16), “enter into life” (v.17), “keep the commandments” (v.17), “teleios” (v.21) and “go and sell your possessions … treasure in heaven … come, follow me” (v.21) (for example, Légasse, Kingsbury, Powell, Wenham). Did the young man receive eternal life although he, apparently, declined to “be teleios”? (Barring quotations, we continue to use the transliterated teleios throughout the paper rather than translate it into English because by doing this we are able to ultimately communicate and highlight the strong nuance of fullness clearer than the regularly used “perfect”). Was the young man exceptional or is Jesus asking every follower to “go sell”? Is Matthew implying soteriological diversity in the pericope of the rich young man? Furthermore, what, if anything, is the relationship between salvation and human flourishing? Galot, for example, identifies two levels of discipleship in Jesus’ imperatives. Stanley concludes that the issue is about one’s relationship to Jesus rather than with the Law. Harrington cites Christian interpretations and applications as erroneous and concludes on “two ways to eternal life” for Jews.
We maintain that Jesus’s teaching on salvation in Matt 19:16-29 does not support soteriological diversity. The analysis illustrates the unity in Jesus’s commands and points to the inquirer’s deficiency, disobedience to the call to discipleship and rejection of true flourishing. Evidently, the acceptance of Jesus’s message had economic implications for individuals as well as their communities.
Utilizing narrative analysis, the paper explores the narrator’s intention in the two phrases “if you wish to enter into life, keep the commandments” (v.17) and “if you wish to be complete, go and sell your possessions” (v.21). The synchronic analysis produced some basic insights and fairly convincing support of the thesis to reject soteriological diversity in the pericope. However, to adequately explain the theological tension between vv.17 and 21 we appeal to the wider interface of soteriological Tendenzen in Matthew and demonstrate interdependence with Matthew 5. We not only find that Matthew 5 carries a hermeneutical key for Matt 19:16-29 but also, with Pennington, that such a key necessarily overlaps with considerations of human flourishing, highlighting Jesus’s model of a life of true flourishing.
|
The Afterlives of Isaiah 58:7 in Early Christian and Rabbinic Literature
Program Unit: History and Literature of Early Rabbinic Judaism
Krista Dalton, Kenyon College
"It is to share your bread with the hungry,
And to bring the wretched poor into your home;
When you see the naked, to clothe him,
And not to ignore your own kin."
Originally conceived as an appeal for proper Israelite fasting, Isaiah 58:7 has a multivocalic exegetical afterlife in late antique Jewish and Christians texts.
As early as the second century the author of the Epistle of Barnabas cited this verse not only for its moral directives, but also as part of a nascent contra Iudaeos polemic, rendering the prophetic books as an indictment of various forms of religious practice ascribed to the author's contemporary rivals. The third-century North African bishop, Cyprian, in a less polemical vein uses the text to strengthen a rigorous moral message in his treatise On Works and Alms, arguing that Christians best use their financial wealth when they entrust it to the Church and to the poor. Also writing in North Africa, the fourth-century bishop, Augustine, cites translation discrepancies within the reception history of Isaiah 58:7 in the second book of his De doctrina christiana. Differences among translations, he claims, has led to confusion as to who should be understood as the proper recipient of financial support, one's blood relatives or fellow Christians. Augustine, like Cyprian before him, interprets this verse as directing the believer to provide alms for the Christian poor as members of the "ecclesial" family beyond the strict confines of biological kinship.
Rabbinic authors focused on the "wretched poor" or marudim in particular. In the Palestinian Talmud, R. Avin contends that bringing the marudim into one's house is as if that person were bringing first fruits to the Temple (Peah 5:5). Here the action of extending hospitality was conceived as a replacement for the Temple's agricultural tithing festival. Avot d' Rabbi Natan B expounds on the identity of this "wretched poor," presenting a series of answers to the question "Who are the marudim?" Most notably, the passage ends with the rabbis as the ultimate marudim and ideal recipients of charitable aid. The verse also appears in the Babylonian Talmud Baba Bathra's "Charity tractate" as a proof text both in a theological debate between Turnus Rufus and Rabbi Akiva and in a homiletical teaching by R. Yehudah. The two passages are joined by their interpretive relationship to Isa 58:7 where the marudim represent the Jews living in the aftermath of the Temple's destruction. In each of these examples, the rabbinic authors use the language of Isa 58:7 to imagine communal assistance within the Jewish community as a response to the constraints of imperial rule.
When read together, the Christian and Jewish traditions demonstrate that the character of the charitable recipients-the hungry, poor, naked, and kin-offered an interpretive ground for claims upon communal aid. Through these claims, Jewish and Christian writers each articulate their own sense of group identity and distinctiveness amidst an imperial world wrought with financial competition.
(Paper paired with Erin Galgay Walsh)
|
"A Dog Has Eaten Yannai's Bread": Analyzing Social Cues Between Rabbis and Patrons
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Krista N. Dalton, Kenyon College
Scholars and wealthy donors engaged in a complex network of power relations in late antiquity. The knowledge marketplace was a ground of competition-scholarly guilds ideologically distinguished themselves from their rivals and sought donors both to fund knowledge-ordering projects and to reinforce the prestige of the guild's expertise. In order to effectively compete in the knowledge marketplace, ancient scholars strove to project an aura of "expertise" through tactics of legitimation, which infused their relationships with potential patrons with the dynamics of gift exchange requiring constant negotiation. Anthropologist Jeremy Boissevain framed these types of relationships as situational, whereby patrons and clients defined their social roles through continual performance of the transactional relationship. Social network theory provides a model for analyzing the performance of social cues that reinforced the networks of exchange connecting scholastic guilds with potential wealthy patrons.
Using social network theory, this paper will analyze Leviticus Rabbah 9:3. This text presents an encounter between R. Yannai and a nameless wealthy elite. Their interaction unfolds with tension, each asserting superiority over the other in subtle (and not so subtle) social cues, echoing Blau's theory of "micro-processes." This paper will argue that we can observe how rabbis in Syria Palaestina navigated transactional networks through the words and nonverbal practices encoded in this encounter. I will show how there is a symbiotic relationship to be struck between R. Yannai and the wealthy man-one maintains expert Torah knowledge and the other reciprocates with recognition of piety expectations. This is the particular dynamic between rabbis and wealthy elites that fueled relationships of patronage.
I will ultimately show that the rabbis engaged in a "cognitive dissonance" with their donors, similar to the dynamics between Second Sophistic pepaideumenoi (philosophers) or late antique Christian bishops and their patrons. On the one hand, ancient literary elites held specialized knowledge inaccessible to the public; patrons, on the other hand, had the money. By locating rabbinic fundraising efforts within the larger practice of scholastic donations, I will observe the strategies rabbis used to cultivate institutional persistence.
|
Lovers Lost: Unrequited Love and the Poetics of Illegibility
Program Unit: LGBTI/Queer Hermeneutics
David M. Dalwood, Yale Divinity School
What is it to long for that which never was and, in turn, can never be? There is urgency to this question for those who find themselves haunted by spectral memories of persons and events that intrude (sometimes violently) into the present as melancholic fantasies (cf. Derrida, _Specters of Marx_, 1994; Freccero, “Queer Spectrality,” 2007). The childhood one did not have; the milestones one was unable to reach; the beloved who got away – these may be mourned and, through the act of mourning, conjured (cf. Butler _Precarious Life_, 2004; Butler, _Frames of War_, 2016; Exum _The Song of Songs_, 2005). However, such conjuring exacts a terrible toll on the conjurer, who must sacrifice her own legibility as a subject in order to commune with the spirits of presents-that-might-have-been. Through her attempts to escape the feelings of despondency, shame, and loneliness that mark her experience of the present-that-is (cf. Love, _Feeling Backward_, 2007), the conjurer becomes a wraithlike figure herself, a non-subject (which is to say, a queer subject; Edelman, _No Future_, 2004) who lives within the impossible spaces of her memories. In this paper, I reflect upon memory - what is remembered, what is forgotten - and its significance as a vehicle for recovering that which is truly lost, grounding my analysis in a re-reading of the Song of Songs that is informed by current discussions within queer theory of temporality and negativity. Far from expressing the mutual passion of two lovers, on my account the Song articulates the unrequited love of a nameless queer female who inhabits a counterfactual past in order to reconstitute her present and attain spectral union with an always-absent male beloved. Such union is achieved, but only fleetingly, in the masturbatory fantasy of Song 5:2-6. Here, the costs of the woman’s longing are thrown into stark relief: Her orgasmic climax in v. 6 is matched by the disappearance of her lover (whose existence except as an apparition the Song repeatedly calls into question), and the fantasy quickly yields to the veritable nightmare of her encounter with the watchers in v. 7. By placing the male beloved ultimately out of reach to the woman even whilst remaining powerless to suppress his ghostly presence in the present, the Song invites queer readers to identify themselves in their condition of unresolvable yearning with the female lover. Yet such identification is hardly a means of relieving the affective burdens noted above: For the queer subject is precisely that, a non-subject who, as a specter already, enters the text only to find herself, with the woman, reliving without end the memories of lovers lost, forever unable to forget even as she is forgotten.
|
Disrupting Concealment, Defying Flavian Propaganda, and Outhonoring Vespasian: An Analysis of Mark 5:1–20
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
Maziel Dani, Brite Divinity School (TCU)
I read Mark 5:1-20 as a passage in which Mark’s Jesus outhonors and demonstrates superiority over the Roman emperor, Vespasian. Jesus does so by singlehandedly defeating a demonic legion that no one was able to restrain (5:3-4, 8-9), accepting the title of divine sonship (5:7), performing a miracle without hesitation and with his voice (5:8), commanding the recipient of exorcism to spread the news of what the Lord has done for him (5:19), extending clementia to the man (5:19), and achieving public acknowledgment for his good deeds throughout the Decapolis through a public exorcism, multiple witnesses, and a widespread report (5:14, 16, 20).
In so arguing, I build on Incigneri’s and Winn’s analysis that Mark’s gospel is situated in a post 70 CE Roman context and has a complex interaction with the Flavian dynasty in which Mark’s Jesus contests, subverts, imitates, reinscribes, rivals, and competes with the Roman Emperor for honor, fame, and recognition. I especially employ not only Watson’s emphasis on honor but also his argument that the imperial virtue of honor is an important component of Mark’s secrecy motif. Hence after previous injunctions in the Gospel to secrecy (1:25, 34, 44; 3:12), Jesus’ strange commandment in this passage to ‘make known what the Lord has done for you’ (5:19) abandons concealment in order to obtain honor by spreading his fame throughout the surrounding regions, gaining public recognition and popularity, and proclaiming publicly his good deeds.
|
The Early Israelite Settlement through the Lens of Ruth
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Daniel Block, Wheaton College
The Early Israelite Settlement through the Lens of Ruth
|
Why Should We Talk About God At All?
Program Unit: Westar Institute
Brandy Daniels, University of Virginia
*
|
The Politics of the Song of Deborah: The Enduring "Root" of Ephraim in Amaleq (Judg 5:14a)
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Quinn Daniels, New York University
The Song of Deborah (Jdgs 5) comes to us as one of the earliest biblical texts describing the muster of different peoples for battle; it praises those who join and condemns those who fail to come (vv. 14-18). By naming these peoples, the text has power to reveal old, collective political configurations that existed prior to the Israelite and Judahite monarchies. The Ephraim people, in particular, should hold our attention as the first-mentioned name on the list, partially because of its unexpected connection to another name, Amaleq. The line that crucially defines the relationship between the two: “From Ephraim, their root in Amaleq” (v. 14a), has not been satisfactorily explained, and any way forward demands better understanding of the decisive word “root,” or šōreš, in this context.
As English speakers, it is common to assume that “root” conveys a sense of the past or origins. However, when we examine the range of social and political applications for the word šōreš, along with its Semitic cognates, we find that it instead refers to a patrilineage, or line of male kin, that was to extend indefinitely into the foreseeable future. This future-oriented redefinition unlocks a new possibility in our difficult verse – namely, that Ephraim had a patrilineal leader who led Amaleq into battle as part of the Ephraimite fighting force. Ephraim’s “root,” in this case, would be the current and subsequent generations of leadership.
A second text, Judges 12:13-15, locates Ephraim and Amaleq together, and although it does not use the word šōreš to define the relationship, it describes a similar political relationship. Here, an Ephraimite patrilineal leader, Abdon son of Hillel, was buried “in Pirathon, in the land of Ephraim, in the hill country of the Amaleqites.” Abdon is commemorated as an elite, almost royal figure, who successfully perpetuated his lineage while he was alive. His burial at a gravesite defined by both Ephraimite and Amaleqite peoples comprises a second, independent memory of Ephraim’s link with Amaleq. Abdon’s elite multi-generational family (v.14) is the type of patrilineage that matches the definition of šōreš. As a result, Abdon represents the Ephraimite patrilineal leader among the Amaleqites – much like the Ephraimite šōreš in the Song of Deborah.
The cooperation of Amaleq with Ephraimite leadership in the list of groups (vv.14-18) shows that Amaleq was one component of Ephraim’s larger group “muster” – with Benjamin perhaps another component through its inclusion in the parallel line: “after you, Benjamin, among your peoples” (5:14a). The Ephraim people had a patrilineal leader among the Amaleqites, and was followed by Benjamin – itself a constitution of many peoples. All of these groups participated in a battle in the distant north – a conflict in which nearby groups like Reuben, Gilead, Dan, and Asher refused to participate (vv.15b-17). The fronted placement of the Ephraim-led collaboration perhaps recognizes – even celebrates – the accomplishment of mustering such a variegated fighting force across a long distance.
|
Learning to Read with Luke and Theophilus
Program Unit: Gospel of Luke
John A. Darr, Boston College
Luke addresses the issue of reading more explicitly—and more frequently—than does any other early Christian writer. The implied author of Luke and Acts is distinctive among the evangelists in naming a reader (twice), foregrounding unique and detailed reading scenes, and presenting protagonists as discussing reading. It is not surprising, then, that Luke-Acts has become a storm center within the wider controversies among New Testament scholars over orality, aurality, and literacy in early Christianity. How should we envision the delivery and reception of these stories among early believers? Shall we imagine an interactive performance in which a lector or reciter fluidly adapted familiar story lines in response to audience needs and cues, or, to the contrary, did communal reading events serve to control and stabilize the wording of authoritative texts like the Jewish Scriptures and Luke-Acts? Scholarly discussion of such questions has relied heavily on identifying apposite models of communal reading from Jewish and Hellenistic antiquity and then on applying these social reconstructions to Luke and Acts. While not eschewing reference to such external models, another approach to the issue of reading focuses much more sharply on internal dynamics in Luke-Acts, with special attention to how the narrative self-consciously (reflexively) promotes and inculcates ways of reading itself. Viewed through this lens, the text is about reading the text and forming the reader as (Lukan) reader. In this paper I expand on this reflexive, pedagogical, and psychagogical approach to indicate in a preliminary way how Luke teaches readers to read in terms of perception, ethics, authority, and tradition. Passages of note will include the preface(s), the Nazareth episode, the Emmaus story, and the incident of Philip and the Ethiopian eunuch, among others.
|
Of Trite Tropes and Platitudes: Imagery and Ageism in Biblical Proverbs
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible and Cognate Literature
Katheryn Pfisterer Darr, Boston University
Metaphors and similes—two tropes, or figurative use of language—are hoary headed (an example of the former) and fresh as a baby’s first blink (an example of the latter). Imbued with the West’s delight in garden fresh insight, many of its scholars extol the presence of stereotype-shattering tropes in the Hebrew Bible’s prophetic, cultic, and proverbial literature. James G. Williams, for example, applauds complex, playful metaphors in Prov. 10—29, including “the ‘soft tongue’ that ‘breaks bone’ (Prov. 25.15) as a metaphor of wise persuasion.” For William Brown, a good metaphor “creates conceptual and emotional friction by which new meaning is achieved.” In “Of Proverbs, Metaphors and Platitudes,” by contrast, Lawrie Douglas scrutinizes the West’s “hankering after novelty” and “worship of creativity” on one hand, and its concomitant disdain for trite tropes and time worn sayings on the other. Metaphors, for example, are “delectable when fresh, “open-ended and illuminating,” and “frequently regarded as creative.” But they have a “short shelf life.” In this paper, I examine how the West’s penchant for literary novelty has shaped its study and appreciation of biblical imagery—including nature imagery.
|
Ruah Elohim in the Light of Phoenician Cosmogonies
Program Unit: Israelite Religion in Its Ancient Context
Guy Darshan, Tel Aviv University
Genesis 1 has been the subject of numerous comparative studies, in particular with regard to the Enuma Elish. However, verse 2 diverges markedly from the Mesopotamian cosmogonies, being most closely paralleled in Phoenician texts. While scholars such as Gunkel, Eissfeldt, and Moscati, have noted this similarity briefly, no one has collected and analyzed all the Phoenician evidence (Moscati fails to refer to any Phoenician source whatsoever in his 1947 JBL paper). Addressing the Phoenician sources, discussing their ancient Near Eastern (especially Egyptian) background, and understanding the Greco-Roman world in which the traditions they contain were preserved can help us trace the early history of the motif of the primordial wind in Genesis.
|
Hamartia as Sin Offering in Romans 8:3
Program Unit: Scripture and Paul
A. Andrew Das, Elmhurst College
Hamartia as Sin Offering in Romans 8:3
|
The Basilica of Alexander at Tipasa and Its Structuring of the Commemoration of the Dead
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Bradley J. Daugherty, Vanderbilt University
Though scholarly treatments of the late antique cemetery basilica known as the “chapel of Alexander” in Tipasa in Mauritania Caesariensis have acknowledged its clerical focus, they have neither explored the implications of this focus within the specific context of North African Christianity nor given detailed attention to the ways the site would have structured ritual practice and formed its visitors.
In this presentation I will offer a thick description of the site and argue that the architectural plan, program of mosaics, and monumental burials of the basilica structured the ritual practice of late antique visitors to the site so as to restructure their commemoration of the dead as an episcopal-focused piety, thereby also reinforcing the centrality of the bishop in the local community. The particular features of the site function on several layers to assert the authority of the local bishop, his sanctity vis-à-vis the community’s martyrs, and the status of the Caecilianist (or “Catholic”) communion as the true church in Africa.
I will focus on three elements of the site. First, the basilica was furnished with a series of pavement mosaics that would have guided visitors into the basilica proper (rather than the adjoining funerary enclosure) and up through the central nave. (CIL VIII.20903-20906, et al.) The inscriptions guided not only visitors’ steps through the site, but also their perspective on Alexander, reifying his position at the pinnacle of both the community’s almsgiving and the Christian community itself. Second, the layout and architectural plan of the site incorporated the shrines of martyrs in a funerary enclosure that was relegated to a position secondary to that of the basilica, which was located on elevated ground. Within the basilica, Alexander and the previous bishops of Tipasa were commemorated in images that evoked the glories of martyrdom. The site channeled visitors and their attention to commemoration of these holy bishops above and before that of the martyrs in the enclosure below. Third, the site’s translation of the remains of the previous bishops of Tipasa and commemoration of them as iusti priores was ideologically loaded in late 4th and early 5th century African Christianity. The significance of bishops’ lineage for their sanctity and legitimacy was a point of sectarian controversy, and the basilica of Alexander promoted this ideology by shaping its visitors’ commemoration of the special dead into a commemoration, above all, of their holy bishops. Thus the episcopal focus of the site was also a weapon in the sectarian conflict of North Africa.
Thus the cemetery basilica of Alexander demonstrates not only how broader episcopal trends in late antiquity, such as the growing authority of the bishops, could take on particular significance within local and regional contexts, but even more how an individual site might use the arrangement of space, architectural elements, and ritual practice to shape local practice and inculcate both piety and ideology.
|
Playing with Death: Violent Exceptions and Exceptional Violence in the Book of Jeremiah
Program Unit: Writing/Reading Jeremiah
Steed Vernyl Davidson, McCormick Theological Seminary
The task of identifying a single rationale for the violence on display in the book of Jeremiah may end with a coherent answer but perhaps not a satisfactory one. That violence serves a reforming purpose seems satisfactory to theological readers in search of theodicy as well trauma analyses that find the violence problematic but understandable. Other interpreters of Jeremiah such as feminists and postcolonialists struggle with the gratuitous and seemingly arbitrary nature of the violence. While not an attempt to rationalize the violence, this paper engages the arbitrariness of the violence through a systematic analysis of four targets of violence in the book of Jeremiah: the prophet, the feminized Israel/Judah as adulterous wife, foreign nations, and the earth. By distinguishing these separate targets the paper examines how gender, sexuality, nationality, and specieism intersect in the enactment of the rhetorical violence in the book. These delineations also set the stage for a central claim of the paper, that of exceptional violence. Building upon Carl Schmidt’s notion that exceptional violence stems from exceptional vulnerability that requires the state of exception to use unrestrained violence, the paper considers how the violence as narrated in Jeremiah both performs this exceptionalism but also has exceptions. By examining who/what dies from the violence in the book, the paper points out how the politics of death is played out upon different targets.
|
All the Earth is Mine: Toward a Biblical Theology of Freedom of Religion or Belief
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
Andrew Davies, University of Birmingham
Freedom of religion or belief is enshrined in Article 18 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and is one of the central pillars of our understanding of what makes us human. Yet it remains a problematic concept in terms of its practical implementation. For example, we might ask how belief in freedom of religion or belief can be reconciled with the claims to universal truth propounded by at least some followers of major world religions, or how individual freedom can sit comfortably with political requirements and socio-cultural expectations. Perhaps the Hebrew Bible can help us here, arising as it did in a multireligious world where the people of Israel found themselves confronted by a variety of alternative (generally rather more dominant) religious traditions and caught up in a web of global political and military intrigue which often both supported and depended upon competing religious ideologies. The Hebrew Bible speaks with multiple and contradictory voices on the issue of the existence of other deities and the relation of Yahweh to the non-Israelite nations, yet its testimony to Israel’s faith consistently affirms a belief in the supremacy and superiority of Yahweh and the need for all nations and peoples to recognise his lordship. Working therefore from the hypothesis that attending to the subtle nuance of the biblical argument in this area might offer some helpful insights for contemporary understanding, this paper attempts to build an embryonic framework from some of the many threads of the Hebrew Bible’s discussion of the role of Yahweh and the status of Israel which might inform political theology and even perhaps public policy in the arena of freedom of religion or belief.
|
Apocalyptic Topography in Mark’s Gospel: Theophany and Divine Invisibility at Sinai, Horeb, and the Mount of Transfiguration
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
J P Davies, Trinity College - Bristol
For Mark, as an apocalyptic theologian, geography is never just geography: mountains, wilderness, seas, rivers, roads, valleys – all have theological significance beyond their roles as narrative settings. This paper will consider one topographical feature of Mark’s gospel, the mountain, from the perspective of Mark’s apocalyptic theology. In the apocalyptic literature, the mountain is an axis mundi, a conduit between earth and the divine realm, and a place of divine self-revelation (e.g. 1 Enoch 17, 25; Apoc Zeph 3, Testament of Levi 2). This is not, of course, a trope limited to the apocalyptic literature, as attested by the mountaintop encounters of Moses on Mt Sinai (Exodus 24, 33) and Elijah on Mt Horeb (1 Kings 19).
It is nothing novel to examine Mark’s most important mountaintop scene, the transfiguration, against this theophanic background. What this paper will suggest, however, is that there is ambiguity in Mark’s account which calls into question interpretations of this scene straightforwardly as a theophany. The Christological question ‘Who is Jesus?’, which runs through Mark’s gospel, is, despite expectations, not given a clearly revealed answer in the transfiguration. The lack of understanding displayed by the disciples in the scene has more theological significance than simply being another example of their obtuseness in the face of divine revelation. Careful consideration of Mark’s account in its narrative and canonical context suggests that this is an apocalyptic mountaintop theophany, to be sure, but one which does not reveal so much as it hides; a ‘theophany of divine invisibility’, to coin a somewhat paradoxical phrase.
Helpful here is the recent contribution to Christian systematic theology by Katherine Sonderegger, in whose doctrine of God divine invisibility is not a sign of his absence but the very mode of his omnipresence. Even in mountaintop theophanies, God is the One who hides himself and who is present in his hiddenness. At the intersection of the study of the apocalypses and contemporary Christian systematic theology, therefore, Mark’s comparatively tempered account of the transfiguration can be seen not, as some suggest, evidence of downplaying the glory of Jesus due to a ‘theologia crucis’ but rather serves his emphasis on non-perception and revelation as the narrative expression of an apocalyptic epistemology.
|
Historical Geography in the Priesty Literature of the Pentateuch
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Jordan Davis, Universität Zürich
(no abstract)
|
Marcion’s Gospel and Its Use of the Jewish Scriptures
Program Unit: Inventing Christianity: Apostolic Fathers, Apologists, and Martyrs
Phillip Davis, Rheinische Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität Bonn
The name Marcion is perhaps most closely associated with the rejection of Christian use of the Jewish Scriptures. In this sense it may be a surprising fact that Marcion’s gospel is not at all devoid of scriptural quotations and allusions. Indeed, Tertullian happily highlights such cases in order to undermine Marcion’s purported theology on the basis of his own gospel. Yet in recent years scholars have questioned anew Tertullian’s depiction of Marcion as selecting Luke among the four available gospels and redacting it according to his theology. In part because of Tertullian’s own biases and the apparent inconsistencies between Marcion’s gospel and his supposed theology, scholars have pleaded for at least a more nuanced understanding of the relation between Marcion’s gospel and canonical Luke, if not a complete reversal of their relationship (e.g., M. Vinzent, M. Klinghardt et al.). This paper approaches Marcion’s gospel in this context and asks what light the use of Scripture might suggest about Marcion’s gospel and its relation to canonical Luke. Based on an analysis of the few scriptural quotations and more numerous scriptural allusions, the paper argues that, even if Marcion’s gospel does not consistently reflect a purported Marcionite theology, its use of the Jewish Scriptures nevertheless suggests a redaction based on canonical Luke.
|
The Levite and the āšipu: Locating Scribal Knowledge
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
Ryan Conrad Davis, Brigham Young University
In Scribal Culture and the Making of the Hebrew Bible (2007), Karel van der Toorn claims that the temple was the center of scribal production and identified the Levites as the scribes who produced the Biblical texts. His assertion has been met with skepticism by a number of scholars, who see the locus of scribal activities occurring away from the temple, such as within military or palace bureaucracies. The argument over the location of scribes has revolved around their physical or professional locations, and it is this aspect of the issue that needs to be rethought. Much more can be learned about the location of scholarly knowledge by examining the Mesopotamian āšipu, one of the most important ritual specialists of the first-millennium. Similar to the Levites, the āšipus of the first-millennium belonged to families that traced their lineage back to important ancestors of their past. More recent research has suggested that although these scribal families would often be associated with temple and royal administrations, the scholarly knowledge that they transmitted belonged to the families that transmitted them, rather than to geographic or professional locations. Analysis of libraries that belonged to these families along with evidence from letters written by these specialists allow us to see the breadth of the texts over which they had oversight. In light of this comparative evidence, I will argue that it is plausible to see the Hebrew Bible as the product of ritual specialists who kept their cultural and ritual knowledge within family lines. These ritual specialists could have participated outside of and within temple and royal administrations, rendering any attempt to describe scribes or ritual specialists by their physical or professional locations to be tenuous at best.
|
Does Luke’s Preface Resemble a Greek Decree? Comparing the Papyrological and Epigraphical Evidence of Greek Decrees with Ancient Preface Formulae
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Zachary K. Dawson, McMaster Divinity College
The most thorough study to date of Luke’s preface as it relates to other preface-types in antiquity is Loveday Alexander’s 1993 published doctoral thesis, The Preface to Luke’s Gospel, in which she argues that Luke’s preface conforms to the prefaces of ancient scientific treatises. While New Testament scholars convey no lack of gratitude for the insights that Alexander provided from her classicist background, her conclusion has been repeatedly challenged. Many scholars object to Alexander’s conclusion on the grounds that Luke’s Gospel is written in the style of Greco-Roman historiography, a position that she contests in her work. One such scholar, John Moles, has also analyzed Luke’s preface through a classicist lens, but has gone further to make the argument that Luke’s preface resembles a Greek decree more than any other type of writing. Such a claim, if proven, could provide profound exegetical insight into Luke’s Gospel as well as the social location of Luke and his intended audience. Although Moles is not the first to recognize the supposed decree-like features in Luke’s preface, nor the first to point out that Luke’s preface shares near identical grammatical structure with the Jerusalem decree in Luke’s second volume (Acts 15:24–29), he goes further than others by grounding his argument on the work of P. J. Rhodes, who has done more work in English than anyone else in classical studies on ancient Greek decrees. Because Alexander and Moles both share Classical backgrounds and yet come to opposing conclusions about Luke’s preface, they will serve as two prominent discussion partners in this essay. However, I will demonstrate that Moles’s argument does not hold up under scrutiny; his argument is slanted by privileging certain textual features of ancient decrees while ignoring other evidence from the same epigraphs and papyri. Instead, I argue that Luke’s preface functions to clearly and simply introduce his Gospel (and Acts) according to appropriate conventions of historiographical writing without adding layers of rhetorical meaning. This will be argued by (1) analyzing the textual and physical forms of ancient bookrolls in relationship to their prefaces, and by (2) comparing the structures and content of Greek decrees to preface formulae based on numerous decrees in papyri and epigraphs.
|
The Serpent in the Garden of Eden: A Critique of Some Recent Proposals
Program Unit: Genesis
John Day, University of Oxford
In the past decade several new proposals about the serpent in the Garden of Eden have been made, in my view all erroneous. First, in 2010 James Charlesworth argued that the serpent of Gen. 3 is to be viewed positively, as he claimed the serpent often was elsewhere in the ancient world. However, it cannot be denied that in the Hebrew Bible itself serpents are overwhelmingly viewed negatively, with very few exceptions (Num. 21; Isa. 6). Moreover, if we are seriously to suppose that the narrator intended us to view the serpent positively in Gen. 3 it becomes incomprehensible why God should sentence it to such harsh punishment. Furthermore, Eve admits that the serpent had deceived her, a sentiment from which God does not dissent.
Secondly, in 2011, Francesca Stavrakopoulou claimed that the Eden serpent denoted snake worship, seemingly referring to Nehushtan. She further maintained that this worship is implied as leading to the fall of Jerusalem in 586 BCE, which she finds symbolized in the expulsion from Paradise. However, Adam and Eve are hardly represented as worshiping the serpent, the destruction of Nehushtan took place over a century before 586 BCE, and serpent worship is never cited as a reason for the fall of Jerusalem elsewhere in the Hebrew Bible. In any case, it is unlikely that Gen. 3 is an allegory of the fall of Jerusalem.
Thirdly, in 2014 Johannes de Moor and Marjo Korpel, argued that the Eden story has its background in the Ugaritic texts KTU 1.100 and 107. This includes the serpent, which they see represented by the god Horon in the Ugaritic narrative. However, the thesis is highly questionable, since much of the claimed Ugaritic Vorlage has to be reconstructed in gaps in the narrative.
Fourthly, in 2015, Duane Smith has suggested that the Eden serpent has its background in Mesopotamian ophiomancy, that is, divination based on observation of serpents. Smith claims that the knowledge of good and evil which the first humans acquired means knowledge of good and bad fortune, the kind of knowledge gained through divination. He also claims that the description of the serpent as ‘arum could mean that it is ‘portentous’. All this seems foreign to the narrative.
If we reject all these views, what then are we to make of the serpent? Although the view is not totally new, I think it likely that Gen. 3 has reworked certain mythic motifs found in the Gilgamesh epic. Just as in the Eden narrative a serpent is ultimately responsible for denying Adam and Eve access to the tree of life, thereby denying them the immortality which the tree bestows, so in the Gilgamesh epic, a serpent is responsible for snatching the plant of life, thereby denying Gilgamesh the chance of gaining the rejuvenation which that plant bestows. Both Gen. 3 and the Gilgamesh epic imply that immortality or rejuvenation in this world are something beyond human grasp. The stories, of course, are quite different, but make use of some common motifs.
|
The Future of History and Theology in the Fourth Gospel
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
M. C. de Boer, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam
This paper will present an appreciative assessment of J. Louis Martyn’s groundbreaking work, History and Theology in the Fourth Gospel, seeking to show how Martyn could in some respects have strengthened and clarified his argument. Does his approach to the Gospel (imaginatively taking up temporary residence in the Johannine Community in order to understand what was going on there), his construal of the Sitz im Leben in which the formative version of the Gospel was composed (the twin traumas of expulsion from the synagogue and the prospect of excecution), and his understanding of the dialectical interplay between Johannine history and Johannine theology (as reflected in the title of his book) have a future in the field?
|
"I Spy with My Little Eye…": Cognitive Prolegoumena to the Study of Visuality and Our Ancient Fellow Human Beings
Program Unit: Cognitive Science Approaches to the Biblical World
Izaak J. de Hulster, University of Helsinki
To what extent can one speak about ‘human universals’ (or ‘anthropogene Universalien’)? And thus, what do 21st century CE human beings have in common with their fellow human beings in antiquity? Senses, cognition, embodiment, manufactured materiality (sometimes still literally bearing fingerprints), and fallibility are good candidates. From a cognitive perspective, one might find – for instance – neurological grounds to argue for such similarities/ commonalities. But does this provide enough basis for ‘mutual understanding’ (or at least one-sided historical understanding)? Here, one needs to take into account cultural differences and individual perceptions: even if – generally speaking, assuming the sense of sight – humans see light and colour, colour perception can be different as reflected in language. Because manufactured materiality brings us – in various respects – in touch with ancient fellow human beings, this past ‘reality’ provides handles for exploring humanity in antiquity, and therefore also comprises guidance for investigating the hermeneutics of ancient images. With methodological tools ranging from common sense to complexity theory, this paper enters into dialogue with cognitive studies in exploring the fundamentals of studying fellow human beings in antiquity, in particular their agency and ancient visuality (including visual literacy) through materiality.
|
Spelling Richness and Spelling Uniformity: Majority and Minority Spellings in the Masoretic Text
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Johan de Joode, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
The present contribution indexes and analyzes spelling variation in the Masoretic text. James Barr argues that “a very high proportion of the Masoretic notes concern [spelling]” (‘The Variable Spellings of the Hebrew Bible', 1989, 11). Current studies of orthography in Classical Hebrew focus primarily on the diachronic evolution of spellings within the Hebrew Bible (Andersen and Forbes; Freedman, Forbes, and Andersen) or the synchronic distribution of spelling re-occurrences in either block spellings or cases of rapid alternation (Barr). These studies quintessentially study orthography based on the distinction between plene and defective spellings. The Masoretes, however, used a complementary concept, viz. that of minority and majority spellings. Barr argues that “the main technique of the Masora can be simply stated: it registers the minority spelling.” There is to date, however, no large-scale quantitative study of orthographic variability at the level of individual words based on the distinction between preferential and non-preferential spellings, also called majority and minority spellings. This contribution fills that gap. It automates the extraction of non-preferential and preferential spellings in the Masoretic text. It subsequently analyses the data using methods available in prefatory data analysis and corpus linguistics. After explaining the procedures required for the creation of the spelling index, the following questions are discussed in detail. How much non-preferential spelling variation can one find within the boundaries of individual texts? How many spelling variants cause that variation or how ‘rich’ is the spelling variation in a text? How uniform is its spelling, viz. can one distinguish clear orthographic preferences? This contribution introduces several measures to systematically describe orthographic variability in terms of non-preferential variation, spelling richness and spelling uniformity. These questions are relevant for Masoretic studies and Hebrew linguistics alike. I conclude with avenues for future research based on the difference between majority and minority spellings used by the Masora.
|
The Book of Joshua and the Book of the Law
Program Unit: Transmission of Traditions in the Second Temple Period
Kristin De Troyer, Universität Salzburg
In this contribution, I would like to focus on nomistic elements in the Book of Joshua and how they can help us establishing the relation between the different versions of the Book of Joshua and the historical development of the different texts.
|
Women in Text Criticism: My Perspective
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Kristin De Troyer, Universität Salzburg
Was it the amount of languages that I loved learning? Was it the complexities of the issues? Was it the travelling to the most beautiful libraries and institutions? Was it the kick one gets from handling manuscripts? All these elements drove me to text criticism and working with manuscripts, esp. Greek papyri. At the same time, people asked me why I was not doing Gender or, in those days, Women Studies. Later, I had to explain to colleagues why a training in Text Criticism was as good as a training in Form Criticism or Literary & Redaction Criticism and how my background as well and as good as theirs gave me the breadth needed to teach Hebrew Bible. In the past ten years, most colleagues realise that precisely by combining Text Criticism with other Methods, one is best suited to deal with the issues regarding plurality of text and history and development of Biblical texts. Text Criticism has now become the necessary field in order to make progress. Many young women are now making the move to Text Criticism.
|
The Mystical Jesus in Mark's Gospel
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Pieter G.R. de Villiers, University of the Free State
This paper investigates the mystical nature of the Christology in Mark's Gospel. It, firstly, analyses Mark's depiction of the enigmatic identity and presence of Jesus in key passages in the gospel. It focusses on the dense symbolic announcement in Mk. 4:10-11 within the context of Mark 4:1–20, where Jesus reveals exclusively to his disciples hidden knowledge about his identity as the mystery of the kingdom. Secondly the paper compares, but also contrasts these verses with similar dynamics in mystical movements like Merkavah mysticism that speak about initiates that receive divine revelations during special experiences like heavenly journeys and that were kept hidden from ordinary people. In a third part the paper will investigate how this mystical identity of Jesus is further developed by the motif of holiness, also as it relates to temple rituals. Mark consistently depicts Jesus as the mystery who is especially also the Holy One, and whose astonishing ministry and enigmatic presence evoke awe and fear among perplexed onlookers (Mk. 9:10, 32). His awesome power as the Holy One is especially evident in his struggle against the impure, unholy forces of evil (Mark 2). A final section will analyse how Mark integrates this mystical portrait of Jesus concretely in the lives of his disciples. He emphasises throughout his gospel Jesus's call to disciples to follow him and remain in his presence (Mk.10:21, 28, 52). By doing so, they will be made holy, purified and transformed in their innermost being by Jesus' mystical holiness (Mark 7:14–23). Mark underlines the ethical nature of such holiness: To live holy is to be ‘righteous’, to reject a lifestyle that is impure and to live in absolute devotion to the divine will (Mk. 7:18). This will distinguish them from an external relationship with the divine that is characterized by adherence to rules, regulations and empty rituals. The paper will conclude with an analysis of Mark 7:17–20 where Mark refers to the example of John to explain the numinous nature of holiness. He shows that the one who lives in the presence of God, who is holy and righteous, fearless and powerful, is at the same time also different and awesome, feared by those who are unrighteous and who are perplexed in the presence of the righteous ones.
|
Reading Revelation from an Aesthetical Perspective: Dürer's Interpretation of Revelation
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Pieter G.R. de Villiers, University of the Free State
This paper investigates the reception history of Revelation’s portrayal of Jesus from an aesthetical perspective. It will, firstly, introduce literalist and symbolic readings of Revelation as two major interpretive traditions which provide a context for an aesthetical reading of Revelation. In a second part the paper will focus on Albrecht Dürer's portrait of the exalted Christ in Revelation 1 as example of an outstanding aesthetical reading of the book, but also of a careful reading of the text. This woodcut was part of the influential set of 15 woodcuts on Revelation that were produced in 1498 by the highly skilled Renaissance artist, Albrecht Dürer (1471-1528) who lived and worked in the then prosperous German city of Nuremberg, a major commercial hub in Europe. The paper will analyse the technical and artistic skills that are evident in the production of the woodcut, then spell out Dürer's meticulous use of the biblical text, but also his remarkable reinterpretation of the vision. It will spell out how this work reflects the interaction between the text and his context with reference to the role of Dürer's social reputation, his socio-political setting and his theological response in the woodcut to major theological changes in his time and also to the imminent eschatological expectations about the approaching year of 1500. In a conclusion the paper will investigate how Dürer's woodcut contributes to recent research that investigates the interface between mystical and apocalyptic texts.
|
The Caleb-Achsah Episode
Program Unit: Intertextuality and the Hebrew Bible
Cornelis J. de Vos, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
The Caleb-Achsah episode is remarkable in at least two ways. First, it appears twice, in Josh 15:13–19 and in Judg 1:10–15. Though, neither of them really fits the context. The story must thus have been regarded as so important and/or interesting as to include it twice. Later, Achsah is even included in the genealogical account in 1 Chronicles 2. Second, the narrative course of events is interesting. Achsah is given away by her father Caleb to Othniel as a price for the latter’s capture of Debir. However, Othniel hardly plays any role in the narrative. It is between Caleb and Achsah, and it is Achsah, the former “object,” who urges her father successfully to give her a blessing in the form of pools. In my paper, I will deal with backgrounds and foregrounds of the episode, highlighting intertextual nodes and the narrative roles of Caleb and Achsah.
|
Slavery in the Life of Euphemia and the Goth
Program Unit: Slavery, Resistance, and Freedom
Chris de Wet, University of South Africa
Located somewhere between ancient fiction and Christian hagiography, and set in 395 CE Edessa with the invasion of Mesopotamia by the Huns (although possibly composed much later in the fifth century), the Life of Euphemia and the Goth recounts the tale of a young woman, Euphemia, who is deceived and manipulated into marrying an unnamed Gothic soldier. Unbeknownst to Euphemia and her mother, Sophia, the Goth already has a wife in a different city in the West. The theme of the deceived and abducted bride is a common one in the literature of the time. When he arrives at his home, the Goth gives Euphemia as a slave to his wife. The wife treats Euphemia with great cruelty. When Euphemia has a son, the child is poisoned by the Goth’s jealous wife. In retaliation, Euphemia poisons the wife of the Goth and is imprisoned by the victim’s relatives. Like Dorothy in the land of Oz, it is only when Euphemia prays to the martyrs of Edessa that she is miraculously transported back to Edessa; later, Euphemia and her mother exact revenge on the Goth by reporting him to the authorities. Slavery functions as a constant yet complex theme in the Syriac ascetic literature of late antiquity, and the Life of Euphemia and the Goth is no exception. In this narrative slavery intersects with discourses of cultural identity and ethnicity (especially Syriac identity), law and warfare (and displacement), and morality and asceticism. The purpose of this paper is to investigate more closely these doulological dynamics in the Life of Euphemia and the Goth. Geopolitically, the narrative betrays the anxieties of inhabitants living in regions plagued by military conflict, where captivity/kidnapping, enslavement, and displacement were very real possibilities. Socially, the story also relies on the common ancient stereotype and anxiety of the slave as the foreigner and domestic enemy, and the dangers of treating slaves cruelly. Finally, from a moral and especially ascetic perspective, the tale further builds on the common Syrian-Christian motif of marriage and sexual intercourse as slavery, and may act as a warning (perhaps similar to earlier works like the Acts of Thomas or Jerome’s Life of Malchus) against embracing the pleasures of the secular life. An analysis of the Life of Euphemia and the Goth will give us a glimpse not only into the complicated dynamics of slavery, displacement, and freedom on the margins of the Roman Empire, but will also lay bare the complicated dynamics of slavery as an ascetic discourse in the late ancient Christian cultures of Syria and Mesopotamia.
|
Old Age in the Discourses of Philoxenus of Mabbug
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Chris de Wet, University of South Africa
In a previous article published in Journal of Early Christian Studies, in 2016, I demonstrated that the notions of ageing and old age were central ascetic discourses in the thought of John Chrysostom. The purpose of this paper is now to expand the analysis of old age in late ancient Christianity by looking at how old age functions, both as a biological, social, and cultural reality, in the Discourses of Philoxenus of Mabbug. The Discourses have been selected because of their copious references to ageing and old age – in particular biblical discourses of old age – which makes this corpus of memrē quite significant in writing a social history of old age in early Christianity. The paper first looks at how Philoxenus understands ageing as a biological/medical phenomenon, and then proceeds to contextualize old age and ageing in his ascetic discourse. Old age is important in Philoxenus’ moral discourse, notably in his understanding of fornication and chastity, but also in his admonitions against gluttony, anger, and greed. He also expands the discourse into the realm of the soul (specifically, the agelessness of the soul, which is linked to moral virtue). Ageing and old age are shown to be central in his fashioning of monastic identity. This paper forms part of a larger project on the social history of old age in the New Testament and early Christianity.
|
Pausal Forms and Prosodic Structure in Tiberian Hebrew
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Vincent DeCaen, University of Toronto
The fourfold distinction among pausal forms (distinguished by vowel quality and stress assignment) dominates Tiberian Hebrew phonology. Crosslinguistically, degrees of pause correlate with prominence in the prosodic hierarchy. In addition, two Tiberian systems of accents have been applied, reflecting the nested prosodic structure of each verse. It remains a fundamental conundrum that pausal forms are not always coordinated with the edge of accentual phrases; pausal forms may even appear within a phrase, in direct contradiction to their pausal (phrase ending) function. For this reason, Revell in his The Pausal System (2015) concludes that pausal forms “must have originated in different stages of the reading tradition. The Masoretic Text, then, evidently includes features, sometimes mutually contradictory, deriving from different stages of the reading tradition.”
We advance a theory of how pausal forms came to co-exist with an accentual phrasing that does not suit them. One might be led to conclude that there were two distinct reading traditions: one that fixed the pausal phonology, and another one that lacked pausal forms, or at least distributed them differently. We will show on the contrary that mismatches are inevitable, due to the way the Tiberian accentual systems are designed: the flaw is in the Tiberian theory of prosodic structure.
Modern phonological theory distinguishes at least two types of phrase above the word: the phonological phrase (P) that groups words, and the intonational phrase (I) that groups Ps. Pausal forms occur where cross-linguistically we typically find the ends of I-phrases: at the ends of major divisions within an utterance, interjections, and after each item or group of items in lists (Nespor & Vogel 1986). An utterance has one or more I-phrases as required, without principled limit. The Tiberian verse, however, is subject to the iron law of top-down continuous dichotomy; crucially, there is no level corresponding to I. Consequently, we do not require separate reading traditions to account for the mismatch between pausal phonology and the accents. We need posit only one tradition. The Tiberian system nests P-phrases, but does not recognize I-phrases. There are no privileged accents that designate the ends of I-phrases, thus precluding a principled prosodic account of pausal forms. /
Nespor, Marina & Irene Vogel. 1986. Prosodic phonology. Dordrecht: Foris.
Revell, E.J. 2015. The pausal system: Divisions in the Hebrew Biblical text as marked by voweling and stress position. Edited by Raymond de Hoop & Paul Sanders. Sheffield: Sheffield Phoenix Press.
|
An Infelicitous Feast: Ritual Banqueting and Cultic Critique in Amos 6:1–7
Program Unit: Israelite Religion in Its Ancient Context
Jessie DeGrado, University of Chicago
Scholarship on the prophetic condemnation of the marzeaḥ banquet in Amos 6:1-7 has tended to gravitate towards two particular readings of the text. Scholars who focus on the religious or ritual aspects of the banquet have claimed that it was lewd, “pagan,” or “syncretistic,” and a form of blasphemy against Yahweh, despite the fact that there is nothing in the passage to suggest that its author was concerned with lewdness or syncretism. On the other hand, scholars who call into question the validity of the previous argument have tended not to address the implications of the religious aspect of the banquet, preferring to understand the prophetic condemnation as focused on the wealthy in general. In this paper, I analyze the marzeaḥ feast of Amos 6 in the context of Ancient Middle Eastern ritual banquets more generally, with a focus on commensality as a means for human-divine communication. Based on this comparative data, I conclude that the marzeaḥ functioned as an offertory event, in which participants focalized divine presence through their own ritualized consumption of food in honor of a patron deity. Banqueters could thus hope to accrue divine favor while simultaneously enjoying a sumptuous meal. The prophetic critique of this practice in Amos 6:1–7 can be elucidated by reference to the broader concerns about cultic praxis expressed in Amos 4:4-5 and 5:21-24. I argue that the prophet takes issue with the specific form of offering represented by the marzeaḥ. In particular, he condemns the affluent who believe that they can make grand offerings to Yahweh on a quid-pro-quo basis while simultaneously luxuriating in their own wealth at the expense of the poor.
|
Representing Ritual: Constructions of Kinship in Exodus 24
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Jessie DeGrado, Saint Joseph's University (Philadelphia, PA)
Exodus 24: 3–8, 12bβ describes the Israelites’ ratification of divine legislation from Horeb through a covenantal ceremony. The rite includes a sacrificial ritual enacted in front of twelve standing stones and the application of blood to the stones and the assembled community. Treatments of this passage often follow one of two interpretive tracks, arguing that the text either (1) preserves vestiges of an archaic, pre-monarchic ritual or (2) is late literary construction that is not of use in understanding ritual praxis in Israel and Judah. Based on a survey of archaeological and epigraphic material from the 2nd- and 1st-millennium Levant, this paper argues that Exodus 24:3–8, 12bβ does, in fact, preserve details that conform to ritual praxis. The literary depiction of ritual finds parallels in rites attested at multiple cites that constitute and strengthen kinship ties through commensality and blood manipulation. Such practices need not, however, be restricted to non-monarchic societies, as texts from Mari and Emar amply demonstrate. Instead, Exodus 24:3–8, 12bβ combines elements from disparate rituals that likely operated at two levels of society, both royal and kin-based, in order to imagine the nation of Israel at the moment of its founding.
|
Martyn, Meeks, and Moses: Revisiting the Influence of Deut 18:15 in the Fourth Gospel
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
David N. DeJong, Saint Louis University
Martyn's seminal History and Theology in the Fourth Gospel (1968) inaugurated a new era in Johannine studies. Scholars such as John Ashton and D. Moody Smith have noted that, though Martyn's controversial historical proposals dominated subsequent literature, his enduring legacy is found in the re-engagement with John's gospel as a thoroughly Jewish text. In this connection, it is worth noting that Wayne Meeks' important monograph, The Prophet-King: Moses Traditions and the Johannine Christology, was published in 1967, just a year before Martyn's work. The foundation of both of these scholars' efforts was their emphasis on the fundamental importance of the Moses-Jesus relationship in John. My paper revisits this emphasis, specifically in relationship to the interpretation of Deut 18:15 in John's gospel. In this passage, Moses famously promises that God will raise up a prophet like him, to whom the Israelites ought to listen. Though not originally intended to refer to a singular eschatological figure, there is considerable evidence that such an interpretation was adopted by some (many?) readers of the Pentateuch in the first centuries BCE and CE (at Qumran, among the Samaritans, and in various movements reported by Josephus, as well as nascent Christianity). John's awareness of this interpretation is reflected its unique usage of the expression "the Prophet," to whom the author refers on at least four (and possibly five) occasions (1:21, 25; 6:14; 7:40, [52]). There is, however, no agreement in scholarship on the importance of the motif for the readers of the gospel in the late first century. Indeed, it is often thought to represent a vestige from early stages of the gospel tradition, particularly in two ways: first, those who take a source-critical approach to the Fourth Gospel consider the "prophet like Moses" motif to reflect the "low" Christology of the putative Book of Signs; second, those who utilize a community-centered approach consider this identification to represent the early convictions of the Johannine movement, eclipsed by the Logos Christology of the late first century. In my paper, I revisit Martyn and Meeks' contributions in order to offer a corrective to these approaches and to re-engage with the question of the importance of the "prophet like Moses" for the evangelist and his community in the late first century. In short, my argument is that an appeal to the "prophet like Moses" was very important to the evangelist, precisely because the portrayal of Jesus as Moses' authorized successor constituted a claim for the legitimacy of the community as exponents and heirs of Israel's scriptural traditions. Indeed, John's usage of the motif ought to be situated in the context of the attempts of various Jewish authors and movements to portray themselves as bearers of the legacy and teaching of Moses (e.g., Fourth Ezra, Josephus). My argument develops in dialogue with Martyn and Meeks' extraordinarily sensitive interpretations of the Moses-Jesus relationship in John, contextualizing them in light of scholarly developments, particularly with respect to the so-called "partings of the ways" between Judaism and Christianity.
|
The Eschatological Elijah and the Reinterpretation of the "Day of the LORD" in Mal 3:22–24
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
David N. DeJong, Saint Louis University
One of the major themes of the classical prophetic tradition is the hope for the coming "day of the LORD," understood to be a decisive divine intervention in history consisting of both judgment and vindication (see, e.g., Amos 5:18-20; Isa 2:10-22; Joel 3:1-5 [Eng. 2:28-32]). The concluding verses of the Book of the Twelve (Mal 3:22-24) contain a striking appropriation and interpretation of that prophetic hope, particularly by associating it with the return of Elijah as an eschatological messenger. This construal of Elijah as a future, preparatory figure will go on to play an important role in both Judaism and Christianity. To whom ought we to ascribe this significant innovation, in which Elijah becomes a figure not only of the distant past but also of the eschatological future? And what is the nature of Malachi's appropriation of the prophetic hope? The consensus in scholarship on this passage is that it is to be ascribed to eschatologically-oriented scribal editors in Persian or (more probably) Hellenistic-era Judaism, who wished to maintain the millenarian hope against the priestly and theocratic elite. In my paper, I argue that this consensus viewpoint is misguided: the passage represents not the maintaining of a vivid eschatological hope but its deferral. I will appeal to several underappreciated features of the passage to offer what is, to my knowledge, a new proposal regarding the function of the introduction of Elijah as an eschatological figure. First, I will explore the revision of the eschatological timetable implied here, and the implications of inserting a figure from hoary antiquity as a precursor to the "day of the LORD." Second, I will show how the specification of Elijah as the "messenger of the covenant" of Mal 3:1-5 interprets that passage with the goal of undermining the sense of immediacy it conveys. Third, I will consider the passage's somber (hopeless?) conclusion, which contemplates the possibility that Elijah will fail in his mission. These considerations will lead to the conclusion that the purpose of Mal 3:22-24 is the opposite of that which many scholars have asserted: rather than an eschatologically-oriented conclusion, it represents an anti-eschatological interpretation of the promised "day of the LORD." The prophetic hope of the classical tradition is maintained, even as it is deferred to the remote future. My paper concludes by considering how Malachi's complicated appropriation of and relationship to prophetic hope might inform contemporary readings of the prophets and their visions.
|
What We Know about the Earliest Extant Form of the Ethiopic Old Testament
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Steve Delamarter, George Fox University
The Textual History of the Ethiopic Old Testament (THEOT) Project has now generated rich data sets for 24 books of the Ethiopic Old Testament. These involve transcriptions of sample passages (in the case of longer books) or complete books of the Old Testament in more than thirty manuscripts. The transcriptions are collated, aligned, and a set of computer scripts identify the statistical frequency of the shared variants. From these, we generate a Dendrogram and identify manuscript clusters, and lists of the distinctive readings that set off clusters from one another. One indication of the correctness of this work is the fact that the clusters are chronologically coherent—the early manuscripts clustering together in one area and later manuscripts clustering together in another. This presentation will focus on what we have learned about the earliest extant manuscripts from the thirteenth to the fifteenth or sixteenth centuries. These manuscripts always constitute one branch of the Dendrogram, but within that larger branch there may be a couple of sub-clusters accompanied by a set of manuscripts that share variants first with one then the other sub-cluster. Together these manuscripts—organized into two, tight sub-clusters surrounded by manuscripts of mixed alignments—reveal the state of the text in its earliest recoverable form. This presentation will describe the patterns of alignment and offer an interpretation of the meaning of these patterns.
|
The Digital Humanities Applied to the Study of the Ethiopic Old Testament
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
Steve Delamarter, George Fox University
The presenter is involved in three projects related to the study of one of the most-neglected manuscript families in the Christian tradition: the Ethiopic Old Testament. Tremendous strides have been made in the preservation and study of this tradition and much of this is the result of the application of digital tools and processes to Ethiopic manuscripts. In this session, we will describe the three projects that we have developed in the last twelve years and their uses of digital tools and processes: 1) The Ethiopic Manuscript Imaging Project (EMIP) has employed digital technologies not only to digitize something over 12,000 manuscripts, but also to create and refine metadata for the manuscripts. 2) The Textual History of the Ethiopic Old Testament (THEOT) Project employs digital workflows to create huge numbers of transcriptions of manuscripts of Ethiopic Old Testament manuscripts. We have developed computer scripts to analyze the shared variants among the manuscripts, generate dendrograms, identify manuscript clusters, and identify the best representative manuscript of each cluster. 3) A third project is focused on the study of book culture of Ethiopian Christianity. In the project “The Social Lives of Ethiopian Psalters,” the presenter has identified over 110 features of codicology and scribal practice and book culture which are executed in differing and various ways by scribes, craftsmen, and book users. We selected 29 of these for further study and then created typologies of those variation, assigned numbers to each type of the variation and built a database (containing more than 100 fields) to receive data from Psalters. We have analyzed over 700 Psalters—ranging from the earliest extant ones of the fourteenth century up through the 20th century—and collected data regarding the variations in each. Each of the Psalters is dated; and more than 250 of the Psalters can be located in terms of the area of Ethiopia in which they were produced. Analysis of this data, especially through the use of visualization tools, is opening many windows on aspects of Ethiopian scribal and book culture that are previously unknown.
|
The Symbolic Language of Power: Political Nomenclature and Legitimacy in the Northern Kingdom of Israel
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Jean-Philippe Delorme, University of Toronto
In his study of the political nomenclature of the Northern Kingdom found in Assyrian royal inscriptions, Brad E. Kelle asked the question: What's in a name? According to him, these political designations reflect changing historical circumstances, mirroring changes in the territorial extent of Israel as Assyrian pressure grew stronger. Although this interpretation is within the realm of possibilities, important questions remain unanswered: Do these terms have a social/cultural significance for their host culture? And if so, what do they mean? As direct evidence of political identity in ancient Israel, such labels expose indigenous conceptions of power and authority. Following Pierre Bourdieu's concept of symbolic language, state nomenclature is better understood as a manifestation of the symbolic language of power in its quest for legitimacy. Since politics, as a socio-cultural phenomenon, is directly connected to its social environment, political nomenclature should logically stem from socio-cultural developments taking place within the frontiers of a given polity and answer to cultural conventions shared by members of its community. This approach not only offers a more elaborate response to Kelle's original question, it also provides a fresh outlook on the issue of political identity in ancient Israel, which in turn calls for a review of the available evidence.
The present discussion will take the shape of a synchronic and diachronic study of the political nomenclature of the Northern Kingdom as it is preserved in primary sources from the ancient Near East (Assyrian royal inscriptions, Assyrian epistolary texts, and epigraphic sources from the southern Levant). By studying these idioms in their respective temporal environment and tracing their evolution in conjunction to the parallel picture provided by archeological data (state formation and social-cultural developments), explicit relationships between political identity and stages in the political evolution/cultural development of Israel are brought to the fore.
Over the course of its history, the Northern Kingdom is known through the triple designation of "Israel", "house of Omri", and "Samaria". Clear temporal distinctions exist between the usage of each idiom. For instance, the term "Israel" is solely restricted to the 9th century BCE (Mesha stele, Tel Dan inscription, Kurkh monolith inscription of Shalmaneser III). Previous mentions in other primary sources from the Late Bronze Age (Merneptah stele, Berlin statue pedestal of Ramses III) and their connection to a tribal group from the southern Levant argue for a reliance on old cultural traditions. The use of these traditions by central authority echoes the role of religion in the emergence of power in ancient civilizations, a fact also confirmed by the etymology of the name "Israel". The equivalent rapprochement between political idioms and socio-cultural conventions is observed for "house of Omri" and "Samaria". The former reflects the central role of kinship in ancient Israelite society, while the latter epitomizes the completion of the process of the consolidation of state structures through the establishment of a royal capital.
|
At the Interface of Prophecy and Music: Gad and the Levitical Singers in Chronicles
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Julie B. Deluty, New York University
In the Hebrew Bible, Chronicles is the only place where prophecy is linked to the Levitical singers, one group of temple personnel institutionalized by David through Gad, the king’s seer. An initial analogy is created with Gad when the collective of Levitical singers is given the title of ḥōzeh in 2 Chr 29:30 and 35:15. However, the Chronicler then differentiates the singers from Gad through the primary label, nābî’. Gad is not called a nābî’ in 1 Chr 29:29 and 2 Chr 29:25, contrary to his title in 1 Sam 22:5 and 2 Sam 24:11. While scholars have noted that the work of the singers is termed prophetic, the contours of the analogous function with Gad have not been addressed. This paper evaluates how the Chronicler’s recasting of the non-Levite Gad and the Levitical singers expands the function of prophecy in a monarchy, that is, to invoke the divine and to communicate on behalf of the people, not the king. The books describe a practice as central to the Jerusalem temple that no longer exists in the Second Temple period. Until this point, the Bible presents groups of prophets linked to royal courts, but these are never located in a temple or given cult-related titles. According to the Chronicler’s literary innovation in the post-exilic period, prophecy does not only constitute communication from the divine to the people through a royal envoy like Gad. Rather, it now also is defined by the liturgical response of the prophet back to Yahweh in the formalized context of the temple. The nābî’ is imagined to physically separate the king from the populace, while the prophetic response on behalf of the people must be directed back to Yahweh by singing praise to Him.
|
"Lions and Tigers and Bears, Oh My!": Responding from the "Thickets"
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Carol Dempsey, University of Portland
The Dictionary of Nature Imagery in the Bible is an exciting new and creative project that helps to unlock the beauty and message of the biblical text. By offering an in depth look at animals, fauna, etc., this project sheds light on the rhetorical language and poetics of biblical texts that employ natural world imagery. This paper responds to studies already being done in this new area of inquiry while offering new insights into the richness of an ancient book that continues to have profound implications for the creative imagination in a world tottering on ecological disaster.
|
Sin and Its Remedy in Galatians
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
David A. deSilva, Ashland Theological Seminary
Sin and Its Remedy in Galatians
|
Reading 1 Peter in Sri Lanka
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
David A. deSilva, Ashland Theological Seminary
Christians in North America and Europe may find themselves far removed from many of the social dynamics and, therefore, pressures reflected in 1 Peter, but this is far from the case for Christians in Sri Lanka. The social dynamics of 1 Peter are very much akin to those within which many Sri Lankan Christians live – a minority emerging in the midst of a dominant and majority culture deeply rooted in a traditional religion with visual and iconic reminders of the sacred story of the majority everywhere; pressures within families and households for converts to return to the faith of their forebears; widespread social stigma of an emerging religion seen as “foreign” to the culture and to the interests of the majority (though, ironically, with Christianity seen now as a relic of imperialism in a self-aware post-colonial environment).
This paper explores the ways in which 1 Peter is read in the Sri Lankan setting and the effects of its interpretation and application in this social location. On the one hand, 1 Peter has been instrumental in helping (some) Sri Lankan Christians identify and work to eliminate avoidable points of tension between their neighbors and themselves, e.g., through working more thoughtfully towards indigenizing Christianity and discarding some of its obviously and needlessly “foreign” (colonial) trappings, and through distinguishing themselves in practices that their neighbors would also affirm as virtuous. In regard to those practices that are deemed unavoidable in the course of maintaining fidelity to Christ in their environment, 1 Peter continues to offer much of the same encouragement and much of the same advice, in the way of social reinforcement within the group, as it did among its first audiences. Caution is required, however, in terms of some of the lenses or frameworks that 1 Peter provides, lest the text unduly and uncritically demonize those outside of the minority Christian group.
|
An Ancient Mystagogical Perspective on Matthew
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Athanasios Despotis, Rheinische Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität Bonn
This survey aims to offer fresh insights on the interpretation of Matthew and especially the “Great Commission” (28:16–20) from the perspective of its early Patristic reception. The presentation begins with a brief research survey describing the most crucial tendencies and deficits in the current exegesis of Matt 28:16–20. The discussion proceeds with a commentary on Origen’s characterisation of the relevant text as a “mystagogy”. According to the Alexandrian exegete (In John, Fragm 36, GCS 10 [IV]), the main function of this text is not to command the Church to perform a mission but rather to reveal how the mystical union of the believers with God occurs through baptism. Indeed, this is the way in which this text is also understood in some of the ancient mystagogical homilies of Ambrose of Milan, Cyrill/John of Jerusalem and John Chrysostom. It is remarkable that these Church Fathers, especially Chrysostom, use marriage as a symbol, especially the Matthean images of the bridegroom and the “sons of bridegroom” (Matt 9:15) as well as the Matthean parable of the ten virgins (25:1-13) to interpret baptism as "spiritual marriage" and union with the bridegroom Christ. From this point of view, one can read the Gospel of Matthew in a new light and understand Jesus’s promise at the epilogue “to be with the believers to the end of ages” as referring to the eschatological marriage or "covenant" between the believer and their bridegroom, Jesus Christ. Furthermore, the authors of the ancient mystagogies understood the Lord’s Supper (cf. Matt 22:1–14) both as an inseparable link to the ancient rite of baptism and, from a similar point of view, as an extension of this symbolic marriage. At the Eucharist, the bridegroom Christ offers to the “sons of the bridegroom” (Matt 9:15) his body (Cyrill/John of Jerusalem, Myst. Cat. 4.3). It follows that this mystagogical reception of the epilogue of the first Gospel offers crucial impulses to read the Matthean narrative anew from the perspective of the mystical union of the believer with the divine. Even though the Matthean text includes allusions to the mystical union with the divine (9:15, 10:37, 25:1–13) and unio mystica was common in many ancient Mediterranean traditions this particular aspect of the first canonical Gospel remains mostly unconsidered by the contemporary interpreters of Matthew. Therefore, this study demonstrates that early Patristic reception can provide fresh perspectives on the interpretation of Biblical texts and the reconstruction of the way these texts were understood in ancient liturgical contexts and mystical traditions.
|
Paul’s Understanding of Conversion as Incorporation in 1 Cor 12:12–13: From the Stoics to Arthur Nock and the Current Conversion Research
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Athanasios Despotis, Rheinische Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität Bonn
One of the most crucial contributions of Arthur Nock has been the comparison between religious and philosophical conversion in the antiquity. However, there have been significant developments in the understanding both of ancient conversion experience as well as the relationship between philosophy and religion in the Hellenistic era, since the publication of Nock’s work (1933).
On the one hand, this paper investigates how the specific Pauline understanding of conversion and baptism in 1Cor 12:13 as incorporation transcends the conventional limits of Nock’s definition of conversion: “By conversion we mean the reorientation of the soul of an individual, the deliverance turning from indifference or from an earlier form of piety to another ...”(Conversion, 1933, 7) Conversion is interpreted by Paul in 1 Cor 12–13 not only as a psychological/moral transformation of the individual (cf. e.g. Rom 6) but as a paradoxical socialisation by the power of the Spirit which results in love ethics. The text under discussion reveals most palpably (even in comparison with Gal 3) the social aspect of the Pauline understanding of conversion. In Paul’s view, experiencing an ongoing spiritual transformation presupposes the undergoing of a paradoxical process of socialisation. Therefore, Paul’s insights in 1 Cor 12:12–13 can be better understood from the perspective of sociological paradigms in the conversion research which have challenged Nock’s definition and interpreted conversion as an ongoing volitional and dynamic social process. (see overview H.Zock, “Paradigms in Psychological Conversion Research” 2006)
On the other hand, this presentation analyses the analogies and the differences between the Pauline usage of the body metaphor in 1Cor 12 and the Stoic tradition. The vast relevant bibliography provides crucial insights regarding the comparison between the Pauline and the Stoic usage of the body-organism metaphor. However, the following aspect remains unconsidered: Paul’s usage of the body metaphor in 1Cor 12 is set before a conversionist canvas where the reconstruction in the biography of the converts (cf. the once/now scheme in 12:2), their baptism (12:12), confessing of the Lord (12:3) and new status in the community (12:13) are emphatically stressed. Though the Stoics use the body metaphor in a political sense (Chrysippus, Fragm 367; Epictetus, Diatr. 1.10.4; Marc Aurel 4.40) they do not apply it on their reflections regarding change to the Stoic way of life or "epistrophe". Stoic "epistrophe" meant a turn to one’s self (eis eauton), that is a rather psychagogical conversion directly linked to the "prosoche" (inner attention) attitude (Epictetus, Diatr. 4.4.6–7). It did not refer to an incorporation as a process where one has to renounce one’s previous social privileges into a new community. Therefore, the Stoic view of society has some analogies with the Pauline language, but it is not set before the same conversionist backdrop as Paul’s in 1Cor 12. By interpreting conversion as incorporation Paul exhorts the rich members of the Corinthian community or those having higher spiritual gifts to renounce their privileges within the messianic community in order to experience an ongoing conversion which will be accomplished at the eschaton (13:12).
|
Asceticism at the Temple: The Katechoi of the Serapeion of Memphis
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Nathaniel Desrosiers, Stonehill College
In the last three centuries BCE, veneration of the Greco-Egyptian god Serapis rapidly expanded throughout Egypt and the rest of the Mediterranean. In Egypt alone, there were forty-two temples dedicated to the god by the second century BCE, and undoubtedly the most important shrine was located in the city of Memphis, where a flourishing temple complex developed around the ancient Egyptian cult of Apis. Interestingly, the existing sources indicate that resident ascetics of both genders were consistent features of these sanctuaries.
In this paper I will examine the Serapeion Archive, a collection of Greek and Demotic papyri that describe the austere lifestyle of the residents of the Serapis temple complex at Memphis during the second century BCE. These individuals, often described as katechoi were “detained” by the god and prevented from leaving the sanctuary; living as recluses in cells within the temple precinct. While the reasons why individuals chose this life of isolation are debated, I will argue that the papyri describe such seclusion as acts of piety that show genuine devotion to the deity. Furthermore, the archive demonstrates that many residents practiced specific forms of personal “sacrifice” as a sign of particular devotion to Serapis, including “penances,” abstinence from wine and certain foods, and celibacy.
While connections between the katechoi and later Christians may not be direct, the parallels are striking. In fact, Antira Bingham Kolenkow stated in her article “Chaeremon the Stoic on Egyptian Temple Askesis” that Egyptian temple life and its philosophies “are part of the background of and competition for Christian Monasticism (387).” Following up on this speculation, I will argue that voluntary entrance into the secluded life of the katechoi represented acts of ascetic devotion to the god that is a fascinating antecedent and probable influence on later Egyptian monasticism.
|
Schubert M. Ogden as Christian Theologian AND as Philosopher
Program Unit: Westar Institute
Philip E. Devenish, Independent Scholar
*
|
Gender in the First Two Centuries of the Christ Movements
Program Unit: Westar Institute
Joanna Dewey, Episcopal Divinity School
Gender in the First Two Centuries of the Christ Movements
|
The Septuagint and Scribal Practices in Hellenistic Judaism
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Marieke Dhont, Cambridge University
The translation of the Hebrew Bible into Greek has often been understood as a scribal activity. Since we have an increasing number of studies dealing with Septuagint translation techniques at our disposal, we may ask what insights into translation methods can teach us about scribal practices among Jews in the Hellenistic era.
In this paper, I will look primarily at the Old Greek translation of Job, the nature of which has been highly disputed, in particular owing to the divergences of the Greek vis-à-vis the Hebrew, as a gateway to dealing with the question of how understanding the Septuagint fits into a larger understanding of the history and social realities associated with the communities that translated the Hebrew Bible into Greek. How did the translator of Job approach their Vorlage? Was the translator aware that they were translating what is now considered to be poetry? What can we learn about the translation process itself? For example, did the translator adhere to the easy technique of translating the book sequentially? Since Greek Job is often regarded as the most Hellenized translation in the corpus, this book is particularly interesting when dealing with the question of scribal practices in the Septuagint. Is Greek Job the odd one out, or is it representative for a wider practice? Through studying the Greek translation of Job, and by placing this book within the framework of a developing tradition of scriptural translation, the present paper aims to contribute to the scholarly understanding of scribal activity in Second Temple Judaism.
|
The Adultification of the Pythian Slave-Girl (Acts 16:16–19)
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Febbie C. Dickerson, American Baptist College
While womanist thought has its genesis primarily in the fields of Ethics and Theology, the deployment of womanist biblical interpretative practices has grown tremendously with the recent publications of I Found God In Me: A Womanist Biblical Hermeneutics Reader, Mitzi J. Smith, ed. (2015), An Introduction to Womanist Biblical Interpretation, Nyasha Junior (2015), Womanist Interpretations of the Bible: Expanding the Discourse, Gay Byron and Vanessa Lovelace, eds. (2016), and Womanist Midrash: A Reintroduction to the Women of the Torah and Throne, Wilda C. Gafney (2017). This paper adds to the womanist biblical interpretative tradition with a reading of the Pythian slave-girl (Acts 16:16-19). Combining womanist thought and historical criticism, I show how the story can be read as a heuristic for interrogating the adultification of African American girls by examining Luke’s adultification of the slave-girl through Paul’s annoyance and silencing of her truth-telling spirit.
A 2017 report from the Georgetown Law Center on Poverty and Inequality titled, “Girlhood Interrupted: The Erasure of Black Girls’ Childhood,” found that adults viewed African American girls, ages 5-14, as more adult-like, suggesting that they are more knowledgeable about sex, and are less innocent than their white peers in the same age range. Researchers call these findings the adultification of African American girls and believe that this process provides the grounding for why African American girls are disciplined more often and severely than their white peers in both the school and juvenile system. Luke adultifies the Pythian slave-girl by presenting her differently than his previously depicted slave-girls. Her words describing Paul and Silas as slaves of the Most High God and that they proclaim a way of salvation are not validated as true as in the account of the slave-girl who identified Peter as the man traveling with Jesus (Lk 22:56-62). The cock crows three times and so demonstrate that she spoke the truth. Likewise, the community gathered at Mary’s house to pray for Peter’s release from prison see him at the front door and realize that Rhoda, the slave-girl, spoke truthfully (Acts 12:13-17).
The Georgetown Law Center study also proposes that adultification is a form of dehumanization that robs girls of what makes childhood distinct from other developmental periods: innocence. Adultifying African American girls posits that their transgressions are malicious rather than the result of immaturity. Moreover, the adultification process indicates that African American girls need less nurture and instruction. Luke similarly dehumanizes the Pythian slave-girl. Instead of showing Paul attempt to convert the girl as he did with the philosophers on Mars Hill who worshipped unknown gods (Acts 17:22-31), Luke uses the slave-girl as a prop to highlight the power of Paul. She, as Gail O’Day argues, is a commodity to both Luke and the slave owners who profit from her prophetic voice. The slave-girl is then erased from the story leaving readers to ponder about her existence.
|
“More Sublime than Speech”: On the Rhetoric of Silence in the Gospel of Luke
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Michal Beth Dinkler, Yale Divinity School
“Great utterance,” writes Ps.-Longinus in On the Sublime, “is the echo of greatness of soul.” And yet, he goes on to say that “the silence of Ajax . . . is great and more sublime than speech” (9.2). How do speech and silence relate to the rhetoric of the sublime? Many ancient writers recognized the multivalent powers of silence, not only as an effective rhetorical technique, but as a privileged means of accessing a sacred realm beyond speech, where one encounters the ineffable divine. In this paper, I consider these issues with special attention to the Gospel of Luke, where silence, speech, and the sublime are represented and mutually constituted in subtly intricate ways. For example, Mary’s Magnificat has stood for centuries as some of the most uplifting, inspired – in a word: sublime – rhetoric in the whole of biblical literature. What is the relationship between Mary’s soul-elevating song and her silent pondering elsewhere in the Gospel (e.g., 2.19)? Or consider the sublime “spectacle” (theoria, 23.48) of Jesus’ passion, when darkness covers the land, Jesus hands over his spirit with a loud cry, and then finally, in the end, exhales into the silence of death (23.46). What are the rhetorical effects of such moments in the Lukan narrative? Moreover, how can we as critics account for the paradoxical fact that the sublime narrative silences in which we are interested are expressed in words – that is, we can only access them in and through Luke’s language? I contend that in the Lukan narrative, sublimity and silence intersect such that the story can persuade, not necessarily because it is precise, but because it is potent.
|
New Philology and Phoenician Epigraphy? Tabnit, Eshmunazar, and the False Promise of Sanchuniaton
Program Unit: Book History and Biblical Literatures
Helen Dixon, Wofford College
New Philology and Phoenician Epigraphy?: Tabnit, Eshmunazar, and the false promise of Sanchuniaton
|
Dr. King and Martin Luther on Law: Politics, Theology, and Captivity
Program Unit: African-American Biblical Hermeneutics
Thomas P. Dixon, Campbell University
Five hundred years ago, Martin Luther ignited a protest movement that hinged not only on a bifocal conception of God’s law but also on a political clash with ecclesiastical law. Fifty years ago, Martin Luther King, Jr. was devoting his last year of life to fighting unjust American laws with theological rhetoric as well as social and political action. Both of these reformers saw political and biblical dimensions to their respective battles, and the most prominent common term at the intersection of these dimensions was Law.
This paper will place Dr. King and Martin Luther in conversation in order to examine the multifaceted engagement of Law and laws undertaken by each. The paper will argue that King and Luther, in radically different contexts, both viewed God’s Law dialogically and applied this tension to complex censure of unjust human laws, fostering protest that was combative yet constructive. Both insisted on the subordination of human laws to the Law of God, and both invoked divine judgment on those in power who misused law to exploit and oppress. Luther marshaled the Apostle Paul to denounce the captivity imposed upon the German people by papal and ecclesiastical authority; King echoed Israel’s prophets (as well as Paul) to threaten the unjust state in the battle for civil rights legislation. Although their battles took place in drastically different circumstances, the value and authority of “Law” lay at the heart of each movement, particularly because both King and Luther were protesting laws that lay entrenched in political entities that considered themselves to be “Christian” nations.
|
Hero in Epic, Hero in Cult: Reading the Rephaim between Ugaritic and Biblical Literature
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
Brian Doak, George Fox University
Hero in Epic, Hero in Cult: Reading the Rephaim between Ugaritic and Biblical Literature
|
An Ass in a Lion’s Skin: The Subversion of Judah’s Hegemonic Masculinity in Gen 38
Program Unit: Genesis
Sébastien Doane, Université Laval
The book of Genesis gives two opposing portraits of Judah’s masculinity. On the one hand, he is shown as the leader of the children of Jacob’s sons and on the other he is ridiculed by his daughter-in-law. Is Judah an ass in a lion’s skin?
This paper proposes to explore Judah’s masculinity as an example of the inherently unstable nature of gender construction. I am attentive to “hegemonic masculinity,” a concept theorized by Raewyn W. Connell (1987) on the basis of both anthropological and psychoanalytic perspectives and the refining of this concept with its use in biblical studies. Hegemonic masculinity points to the expression of masculinity that becomes dominant and is the standard against which all other masculinities are judged. Hegemonic masculinity is never stable, but is continuously shaped by competing subversive masculinities and the political tensions these represent (Haddox 2016, 179).
Although Judah is only the fourth son of Jacob, he is expressly depicted in Genesis as assuming a leadership role in relation to his brothers, including speaking up against killing Joseph, negotiating with his father regarding Joseph’s demand that Benjamin be brought down to Egypt, and pleading with Joseph for Benjamin’s life. In Genesis 49:8-12, Judah receives the most favorable treatment of all Jacob’s sons. The blessing of Jacob from his deathbed portrays Judah’s hegemonic masculinity at its finest. This text evokes images of dominance, and has messianic undertones. Judah is portrayed as a leader through the images of the lion, the scepter, the prostration of his brothers, and the allusions to a perpetual lineage of David. In fact, this portrayal of Judah is one of the clearest images of hegemonic masculinity found in Genesis.
However, in Genesis 38, Judah’s masculinity does not correspond to what a biblical reader would expect of a patriarch. Many elements cast doubt on his ability to be a “man.” Judah transgresses the Law by refusing to give Tamar his third son as a husband. Not only is Judah not persuasive in his accusation, he is persuaded by Tamar that his own actions were wrong. Judah is deceived, specifically deceived by a woman. The shame he wants to attribute to Tamar rebounds on himself. In the end, he acknowledges himself to be less righteous than Tamar (Gen. 38:26). The episode as a whole reveals that Judah does not have control of his family, nor does he possess the self-control expected of a male patriarch.
Gen 38 clearly subverts Judah’s hegemonic masculinity. What are the rhetorical effects of this subversion of Judah’s hegemonic gender construction? Different hypotheses to explain Judah antithetical masculinities will be explored and evaluated. Jacob speaks of Judah as a lion, but in Gen 38 he seems to have been portrayed in the role of the ass.
|
The Interceding Spirit: Reevaluating the Biblical Background of Romans 8:26–27
Program Unit: Scripture and Paul
Joseph Dodson, Ouachita Baptist University
The Interceding Spirit: Reevaluating the Biblical Background of Romans 8:26–27
|
The Essence of Conception: Philology and the Physics of Fertility in Ancient Israel
Program Unit: Philology in Hebrew Studies
Shawna Dolansky, Carleton University
Studies of the use of ḥll and ḥllh in H have led to the suggestion that sexual activity marks a woman with the "essence" of her partner. The notion that a woman is somehow “contaminated” in a permanent way by previous sexual partners, and further that she is capable of passing on this contamination to later partners and their offspring (e.g. Lev 21:15; Ezek 44:22), might afford some insight into how ancient Israelite authors conceived of sexuality, fertility, and lineage. This paper examines the possibility that the essence with which a woman is marked may, in ancient constructions, consist of her partner’s ethnic, social, or religious status, conceived as something left in her womb from her first sexual encounter, and which can be passed on to subsequent offspring independently of who the actual father is. This construction of fertility and genealogy has potential implications for better understanding narrative material about levirate marriage, attempted coups d’etats signalled by sex with a king’s wife, and the requirement to execute enemy women who “have known a man.”
|
Dueling Superscriptions: Imaginative Search for Female Intertexts Then and Now
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Denise Dombkowski Hopkins, Wesley Theological Seminary
Invited Paper.
|
Faith in the Borderlands: An Exploration of Jewish-Christian Self-Understanding in 1 Clement
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
Sally Douglas, University of Divinity, Melbourne
1 Clement is one of the earliest orthodox texts outside the Christian canon and its composition likely predates the composition of some Second Testament texts. It was written by the church in Rome to the church in Corinth, after this community had received Paul’s correspondence, but likely before the end of the first century CE. The letter is listed as canonical in the fifth century Codex Alexandrinus. Despite 1 Clement’s significant place in the early Jesus movement the contents of this text are commonly overlooked in scholarship. In part this is because investigations have been rendered myopic through undue focus on church conflict. In part this is because the theology within this text does not conform to scholarly expectations about the early church, and is thus ignored in plain sight.
Embedded within 1 Clement we discover fresh insight into Jewish-Christian self-understanding in the first century. This paper will excavate 1 Clement’s fluid Jewish-Christian identity. In particular, attention will be given to the authors’ highly favourable presentation of the Temple and efficacious cultic practices therein (40-41). 1 Clement’s understanding of the Temple and of cultic sacrifice ‘made for sin and transgression’ (41.2) will be investigated and brought into dialogue with this text’s understanding of soteriology (36). The disjuncture between the overlapping hymn fragments found in 1 Clement 36 and Hebrews 1 will be interrogated and the paper will conclude with an exploration of the contrast between1 Clement’s theology and other strands of the early Christian tradition that rose to dominance within the Christian theological landscape. This paper will demonstrate that in attending to the borderland evidence of 1 Clement, assumptions about the early church are disrupted and understandings of the hybrid nature of first century Jewish-Christian identity are enriched.
|
Angels from Babylon, Magic from Heaven? Uncovering the Origins of the Tale of Hārūt and Mārūt (Q2:102)
Program Unit: The Qur’an and the Biblical Tradition (IQSA)
Rachel Claire Dryden, University of Cambridge
Keywords: Hārūt, Mārūt, malak, magic, Solomon, midrash, freewill Q2:102 recounts a story about two angels who are unknown from biblical texts: Hārūt and Mārūt. Unlike the only other angels with personal names in the Qur’ān, Hārūt and Mārūt are explicitly referred to as malakān, leading some to conclude that the Qur’an’s audience was not familiar with them and/or the fact that they were angels. They are described as having appeared on earth in Babylon, where they passed on knowledge of magic, which devils had previously taught men in Solomon’s kingdom. Yet they did so warning people that they had been sent as a temptation and exhorting people to continue to believe in and follow God. The origin(s) and meaning of this story have divided scholars, with some positing a midrashic origin and others looking to the possible influence of similar tales in Indian and Persian-Zoroastrian traditions. The motif of the angelic teacher who instructs mortals in the secrets of the heavens is widespread in apocalyptic literature, most notably 1 Enoch. The tradition of Solomon as an exorcist has been inferred from 1 Kgs 5:9-14 (RSV 4:29 – 34) and appears more explicitly in both apocryphal and historical material. This paper will analyse the somewhat limited extant research on this story within the qur’ānic tradition and evaluate the evidence for and against a midrashic, or other/earlier, origin. It will also examine key features in the story both in their qur’ānic and wider contexts, including: - the identity of the two angels (their names, natures (angelic or divine) and roles) - the origin and nature of the magic that was revealed to them - whether or not they acted of their own free will in warning people of the negative aspect to the magical knowledge This paper will therefore not only shed light on this one qur’ānic narrative episode but discuss the implications of material in the Qur’ān that does not appear to fit a biblical pattern or origin, both for qur’ānic and biblical studies. Sample Bibliography Calabro, David M. ““Angels in Babylon”: On the Intertextuality of the Tale of Hārūt and Mārūt in the Mubtada’ of Ibn Bishr”. (Unpublished presentation). Davidson, Maxwell J. Angels at Qumran : A Comparative Study of 1 Enoch 1-36, 72-108 and Sectarian Writings from Qumran. Sheffield, England: JSOT Press, 1992. Duling, Dennis C. “Solomon, Exorcism, and the Son of David.” Harvard Theological Review 68, no. 3/4 (Jul.-Oct.) (1975): 235–52. Marzolph, Ulrich. “The Persian Nights : Links Between the Arabian Nights and Iranian Culture.” Fabula 45, no. 3 (2004): 275–93. Menasce, P.J. de. “Une Légende Indo-Iranienne Dans l’angélologie Judéo-Musulmane : À Propos de Hārūt et Mārūt.” Asiatische Studien: Zeitschrift Der Schweizerischen Asiengesellschaft 1, no. 1–2 (1947). Reeves, John C. “Some Parascriptural Dimensions of the ‘Tale of Hārūt Wa-Mārūt.’” Journal of American Oriental Society 135, no. 4 (2015): 817–42.
|
Bibles for Children in Contemporary Biblical Scholarship: Why Does It Matter?
Program Unit: Metacriticism of Biblical Scholarship
Jaqueline S. du Toit, University of the Free State (South Africa)
It is generally assumed that children’s Bibles function as educational and religious stepping stones, “journeys”, or “pathways”, inevitably to be followed by advancement to the reading and interpretation of the “adult” biblical text, once language competency and religious initiation have been achieved. However, as Ruth Bottigheimer and Penny Schine Gold have hinted in their groundbreaking histories of children’s Bibles, by the end of the twentieth century children’s Bible have become the end product. Many professors of Bible would agree that the only knowledge of the text one can now assume of Western students, for whom Bible had traditionally been part of the literary canon, would be the often inadequate recall of children’s Bibles, Bible storybooks and the accompanying interpretative pictures they were exposed to as children. Yet, although the popularity of children’s Bibles in religious and secular Western communities is undisputed, acknowledgment of their growing position as important exegetical discourse is only slowly reaching the academy, with little credence given to the idea that these texts warrant serious critical engagement. This paper argues that children’s Bibles, as radical interpreters of the Bible and as vehicles for the imparting of social values by one generation to the next, have become invaluable descriptive markers of identity, of constancy and change in religious collectives. This role of the Bible, its reception, and the way it shapes the popular and the everyday in society, is an under-examined component of reception history to which twenty-first century children’s Bibles provide invaluable access. The fact that these texts continue to evolve and adapt, despite claims to constancy, is a strong indication of their value and relevance to an understanding of twenty-first century religion and society. More so, as stories intended for those on establishment’s margins (children, women as caregivers, newly converted adults, etc.), they express an agenda far beyond simply making children interested in the Bible. These books connect Bible-informed ideologies and preferences with the routines of everyday life in ways that are not solely functionalist, but focused on the experience of an audience at or on the margins of the religious centre.
|
Exodus in the Book of Judges
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Peter Dubovsky, Pontificio Istituto Biblico
The theme of Exodus became crucial for the Deuteronomistic reinterpretation of the past. Despite a heavy Deuteronomistic revision of the Book of Judges, the theme of Exodus is limited to chapters 2 and 6. This study will focus, first, on two linguistic variants employed for referring to Exodus, namely, the hifil of the verb ‘lh and yṣ’. While the choice of one of the verbs became a hallmark of some biblical books, Judges 2 and 6 have both verbs. When and why did these linguistic variants of Exodus “merge”? In order to answer this question, I will study Judges 2 and 6 from the historical-critical point of view and compare them with other biblical passages. By doing so, I will propose a stratification of Exodus layers in the Deuteronomistic literature and illuminate a tradition that combines both ‘lh and yṣ’ as it occurs in the Book of Judges.
|
A Labor of Love? The Self-Employed Apostle in Corinth
Program Unit: The Historical Paul
Paul B. Duff, George Washington University
The subject of money looms large in the Corinthian correspondence. At a minimum, we find it in: 1 Corinthians 9, where Paul uses his renunciation of Corinthian funding to encourage the “strong” to renounce their “right” to eat eidōlothyta; 1 Corinthians 16:1-4, where Paul gives instructions to begin the collection for the Jerusalem assembly; 2 Cor 2:17, where Paul denies that he is peddling the word of God; 2 Cor 7:2, where he again refutes allegations of financial misconduct; 2 Corinthians 8, in which the apostle encourages the Corinthians to complete the collection of money for Jerusalem; 2 Corinthians 9, where he makes yet another appeal on behalf of the collection; 2 Cor 11:7-11, where Paul claims to have “plundered” other assemblies in order to preach to the Corinthians free-of-charge; and 2 Cor 12:13-18, where he adamantly insists that neither he nor his associates have defrauded the Corinthian assembly.
There are two themes around which the subject of money revolves: money for Paul’s sustenance and money for the Jerusalem collection (although at times it is difficult to separate the two). In this paper, I will consider only the first theme—Paul’s means of sustenance—and I will ask why Paul labored as a skēnopoios instead of accepting financial support for his missionary work in Corinth. This question is especially interesting in light of Paul’s acceptance of money from the Philippian assembly.
|
Speech, Characterization, and Intertextuality in the Pseudo-Clementine Novel
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Patricia Duncan, Texas Christian University
The existence of two similar versions of the Pseudo-Clementine novel (the Latin "Recognition" and the Greek "Klementia", or "Homilies"), each presumably the result of independent, fourth-century modifications on a third-century Grundschrift, presents us with an interesting and rather unique opportunity to explore the usage and effects of dialogue in ancient narrative. In each version of the tale, there is already a richly layered dynamic of telling and hearing, for each novel presents its story in the mode of character narration. That is to say, the “Clement” who narrates the story to James the Brother of the Lord is also a protagonist in the tale, and it is through the medium of this fictional act of telling that the author speaks to his or her authorial audience. Thus, when we examine parallel scenes in the two novels and find instances where dialogue is presented differently, with speaking and hearing roles rearranged, we have multi-layered and complex dynamics of disclosure and concealment, knowledge and power, to consider. In this paper, I will analyze the different speech dynamics found in the parallel passages surrounding the conversion of Clement’s skeptical and philosophically-minded father, Faustus, to the faith of the Apostle Peter. The effects of the different speech configurations on the characterization of Faustus are considerable, and we discover, I propose, a kind of intertextuality at work in the dialogue. In other words, the rearrangement of certain aspects of the dialogue in this narrative scene suggest that (at least) one version of the novel has altered speech patterns so as to enter into conversation with, or talk back to, a prior version of the same story – a dynamic that was perhaps not lost on at least some readers in antiquity.
|
Narrating the Ascetic Jesus: Collections of Prophetic Anecdotes as Symbols of Family Status in Early Islam
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Reyhan Durmaz, Brown University
Early Islamic communities built their identity upon biblical memories, re-contextualizing, reorienting and reinterpreting them. The voluminous scholarship has demonstrated that especially in locations peripheral to the Hijaz, where Islam emerged, a great majority of local communities transmitted their pre-Islamic (mostly Christian and Jewish) cultural and literary heritage into Islam. This heritage played a considerable role in shaping local manifestations of Islamic vocabulary, doctrines, and salvific chronology, and constituted a significant source of knowledge, piety and legitimacy. In this paper I focus on writings from two families, who were descendants of Jewish and Christian communities in Yemen and Syria, respectively: The Ṣaḥīfa (lit. “pages”) of Hammām b. Munabbih al-Yamanī (d. 719), and an anecdotal collection of Yaḥyā b. Yaḥyā al-Ghassānī (d. ca750), which was ostensibly transmitted through his descendants and preserved in the 11th-century Kitāb Akhbār wa-Ḥikāyāt (the Book of Reports and Stories). These texts comprise anecdotes and sayings of biblical prophets, as well as of Muhammad, anonymous characters, and Satan. Although neither of them is technically a work on asceticism, they both include important anecdotes on ascetic practices, especially of Jesus. Through these two early Islamic “family notes,” I will argue that knowledge of biblical prophets and ascetic anecdotes was a status marker for many early Islamic historians, who collected, edited and transmitted these reports to promote their families, creating new categories and conventions of Islamic sanctity. As these collections were transmitted across generations within these families, they became tokens of not only the collectors’ scholarship, but also the families’ sanctity due to their contribution to the knowledge and practice of asceticism in the early Middle Ages.
|
The Linguistics of Social Identity (Re-)Formation
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
James D. Dvorak, Oklahoma Christian University
Social Identity Theory and Self-Categorization Theory continue to prove their worth for biblical interpretation. Central to these theories, as the literature has demonstrated, is the notion that a person’s social identity derives from her or his group membership(s). This is especially crucial in interpreting identity formation and/or reformation of persons as described in the New Testament, given the collectivistic world that is represented therein. The many excellent applications of SIT/SCT that I have read have, to greater and lesser extents, addressed the variegated yet crucial and ineluctable role that language plays in identity (re-)formation processes. Yet, to my knowledge, Tucker (You Belong to Christ and Remain in Your Calling) is one of the few who have expressly connected SIT/SCT with an explicitly sociolinguistic theory and method, drawing especially Norman Fairclough (see Remain in Your Calling, 33 n. 1, 56 n. 113, 59, 189 n. 6). However, this connection begs for further exploration and fuller development. In particular, I propose to describe a model, built on the foundation of Halliday’s systemic-functional sociolinguistics—but strongly influenced by Bakhtin, Fairclough, Lemke, Hodge and Kress, and others—that can aid in explaining how texts, including and especially biblical texts, are a form of social engagement and interaction through which people like the biblical writers negotiate values and engage in identity formation and reformation (also known as resocialization). Much of this engagement and interaction aims at positioning the readers to take up identities that are created for them in texts. In addition, I will offer a demonstration of the model by way of text analysis. I will focus particularly on those linguistic features that help to generate the “internalized narrative substructure” that Tucker (Remain in Your Calling, 50–51), Baker (“Christian Identity Formation,” 228–37), and others argue is crucial in regards to identity (re-)formation.
|
Moving from a Text to Its Context: Mirror-Reading, Semantic Domains, and Context of Situation
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Bryan R. Dyer, Baker Publishing Group
|
"Unholy Like Esau": Exploring Esau's Sexual Immorality as a Community-Abandoning Act
Program Unit: Hebrews
Matthew Easter, Missouri Baptist University
The author of Hebrews warns that no “root of bitterness” spring up, causing trouble, defiling many (Heb 12:15). “Sexually immoral” Esau serves as a negative example (12:16-17). It is not immediately clear how Esau is “sexually immoral,” but I argue this sexual immorality is Esau’s abandoning the community of faith. The essay proceeds in three stages. First, I address the nature of Esau’s sexual immorality, wherein I connect his sexual immorality to his marriage outside of the community. The author of Hebrews stands in his Hellenistic Jewish tradition by connecting Esau’s sexual immorality to his marriage to foreign women (cf. Jubilees 25). However, Esau’s exogamous marriage is not, in itself, the concern of the author of Hebrews. Instead, Esau’s mixed marriage sowed seeds of bitterness in the family, and led ultimately to Esau’s abandoning the family. The author of Hebrews quotes Deut 29, which warns any “root growing up with gall and bitterness” (29:18) will be “singled out for evil from all the sons of Israel,” and “God will not want to pardon him” (29:20). Esau’s Hittite wives, however, “brought grief” (Gen 26:35) and “embittered” (Jub. 25:1) Isaac and Rebecca. As the author of Hebrews expected, the “root of bitterness” introduced by sexually immoral Esau “defiled many” (Heb 12:15). After failing to please his father by marrying within the family (Gen 28:6-8), Esau abandons the family. Second, I show how this understanding of sexual immorality as a community-abandoning act extends also to another key narrative for Hebrews: the Israelite wilderness generation’s failure to enter the Promised Land (“the rest” in Hebrews). Num 14 (an important passage for Hebrews) depicts the wilderness generation’s failure to enter the Promised Land as a “fornication” (14:33) resulting in loss of “inheritance” (14:24, 31). Similarly, by selling his birthright, sexually immoral Esau forfeited his inheritance. Alternatively, the author of Hebrews hopes his hearers will receive an inheritance (1:14; 6:12; 9:15) and be numbered among the “assembly of the firstborn” (12:23). Esau’s sin, therefore, amounts to abandoning the people of God for fleeting pleasure (“a single meal,” 12:16). Just as the wilderness generation failed to persevere in faith and so enter the “rest” together, so also Esau failed to persevere in faith with the people of God. Finally, I offer some thoughts about the nature of apostasy in light of these findings, where I conclude that apostasy for the author of Hebrews is abandoning the community of faith. This account of apostasy coheres with contemporary sociologists’ conclusions, who have shown conversion as an act of joining a community of faith. In short, Esau’s sexual immorality is a community-abandoning act, wherein he married outside the family and introduced bitterness into the community, thereby defiling the people of God. Like the wilderness generation, he failed to persevere with the people of God. This act resulted in being cut off from future participation in the community.
|
The Gospel Book as Liturgical Actor
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Daniel Eastman, Yale University
This paper will explore the development of Gospel books, or tetraevangelia, as liturgical actors in late antique Syriac Christianity. It will argue that the Gospel book functioned as a material thing that actively manifested divine power in the world – what Heather Hunter-Crawley has termed a symbola. Through factors such as their appearance, location, movement within the space of the church, and proximity to other liturgical subjects, tetraevangelia took on additional meaning and power that went beyond their identity as containers of the texts of the four canonical gospels. This paper will propose that in late antique Syria and Mesopotamia, Gospel books increasingly functioned as symbola of Christ, taking on his roles as healer, judge, and leader of the church both inside and outside the liturgical setting.
In making these arguments, the paper will draw on a range of literary and material evidence from late antique Syriac Christianity, including Gospel manuscripts, archaeological remains of churches and liturgical implements, and liturgical commentaries and homilies. Through these sources, particular attention will be paid to the connection of the Gospel book to two other spaces in the church – the altar and the bema – both of which themselves carried a rich array of meanings that developed in tandem with the Gospel book. Through their presence as symbola within the liturgy, tetraevangelia can be seen to have been closely identified with the person of Christ, such that when Gospel books appeared outside the confines of the church building they brought Christ’s power with them, performing essential functions such as healing the sick, cursing the impious, and ordaining new bishops.
|
"Whatever I Will Speak, Will be Fulfilled": The Correspondence between Prophecy and Fulfillment in Ezek 12:21–28
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
Ruth Ebach, Eberhard Karls Universität Tübingen
Ezek 12:21-28 is part of a small collection in Ezek 12-14 dealing with the topic of true and false, or better fulfilled and unfulfilled prophecy. The precise logical and literary coherence of these passages is still under discussion. The paper shows, especially focusing on Ezek 12:21-28, that Ezek 12-14 in its different literal stages analyzes and problematizes - as guiding thread - every partner of a successful prophetic interaction and, vice versa, possible "creators" of false/unfulfilled prophecies: The prophet(s), the people asking him, and God himself. Especially Ezek 12 should better be read as God's promise to realize prophetic words within a narrower timeframe, rather than limited on a discussion on false prophecy: A change in God's practice is announced, the reaction on the saying used in the land evokes a theological shift! Only the highly discussed v. 24 - problematizing the prophetic behavior or some kind of prophecy (as can be underlined despite other translations) - changes the focus. In this connection, the alternative readings of the Septuagint in Ezek 12 (and more general in 12-14) showing that the discussion regarding the origin and reason of unfulfilled prophecy still went on, are of special interest. In addition, the passage's dating(s) and the saying's location in the land (as one understanding of v. 22) point to a kind of determination between the Golah and those living in the land, which should be taken into account. The paper underlines that Ezek 12,21ff. in his historical setting has a deep theological impact and shows changes in the picture of God and prophecy.
|
Women’s Economic Roles in Ancient Israel: An Archaeological Perspective
Program Unit: Economics in the Biblical World
Jennie Ebeling, University of Evansville
During the past decade, archaeologists working in the southern Levant have adopted new approaches to reconstructing daily life in ancient Israel through household archaeology studies. Among the aims of household archaeology is the identification of gendered spaces and activities in Iron Age (ca. 1200-586 BCE) domestic structures, and recent studies have demonstrated the value of this approach for reconstructing food preparation, textile production, and other contributions to the household economy usually attributed to women. In this presentation, I will discuss how archaeologists engender household spaces, artifacts, and installations and describe some of the issues involved in using archaeological remains and biblical texts to inform on real women’s lives in the Iron Age.
|
The Dynamics of Orality and the Implications for Mark’s Characterization of the Disciples
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Zechariah Eberhart, Loyola University of Chicago
Marshall McLuhan, in an oft cited passage, sheds light on the dynamics of media. In the opening chapter of Understanding Media, he famously asserts that “the medium is the message.” What McLuhan correctly observes is that content is not merely a matter of information or data, but it is a product of the medium. The same information, offered by means of a different medium, can function differently and often conveys a different meaning. The medium itself, rather than the data found within the subject, is what differentiates and carries the content.
Considerations of media have multitudinous implications for biblical studies, one among which is it raises questions as to how the early audiences experienced the gospel stories. Did the early Jesus followers hear the gospels, or read them? If they did hear them, was it read aloud, or was it performed? And how might each of these different mediums alter the message?
In a series of essays from the late 1980’s and early 1990’s, Joanna Dewey issues a call for a comprehensive exploration of Markan disciples in an oral/aural context. In each essay, Dewey’s work moves us closer to attaining a first-century media consciousness of the Gospel of Mark, yet in each investigation she stops short of offering a full-fledged analysis of the disciples, characters that have been often maligned within literary approaches. This paper is an attempt at taking up Dewey’s challenge.
Drawing primarily upon the works of M. McLuhan, W. Kelber, W. Shiner, D. Rhoads, H. Hearon, M.A. Wire, and K. Iverson, this paper will attempt to offer a (mostly) positive representation of Mark’s disciples from a performance critical perspective. I will begin by briefly looking at how Mark’s disciples have been viewed in previous studies, revealing a gap which performance criticism might help to fill. Next, I will turn to Mark’s text and attempt to offer a positive “performance” of Mark’s disciples. The purpose of this paper is two-fold: 1) To explore ways in which performance criticism might offer us a “new” perspective on an old problem, and 2) to see if the overwhelmingly negative portrayal of the disciples can possibly be mitigated (to some extent) through an oral performance.
This is by no means an attempt to “definitively answer” nor “(ab)solve” Mark’s disciple problem, but rather the goal will be to explore ways in which the embodiment of the disciples, in a performative context, might illuminate the Markan composition and early performances of this text. This essay will work at the level of suggestion rather than demonstration, and will offer ways in which media considerations both limit and expand characters within performative contexts. This is an exploration, an experiment if you will, on the ways in which media considerations can shed light on how an original audience might have understood Mark’s disciples, and how questions of media might contribute to the enduring task of understanding the juxtaposition of these historically beloved yet textually maligned characters.
|
Texts, Communities, and Culture of Conversions through “Sacred” Translation: A Look Back into the Future
Program Unit: Nida Institute
Edgar Ebojo, United Bible Societies
Bible Translation has never been monolithic in its experience and execution—there are no dull moments either. Instead, its long and winding history demonstrates (sometimes vibrantly, sometimes subtly) the active engagement between the transmitted “Text”, its “transmission vehicles”, and its “target recipients”, resulting in different conversion dimensions. This history equally demonstrates that the “Text” was both the “converter” of communities and at the same time as “converted” by the communities it got in contact with. There are various ways to exhibit this dynamic interaction but none is more lucid than by looking at how the biblical “Text” intersected intricately with other factors that had been transmitted alongside the biblical text, particularly in the early stages of its transmission history (e.g., the first five hundred years of the Christian era). This paper will attempt to highlight the different levels of communal conversions that have taken place as one digs through the early transmission history of Bible Translation evinced from the extant manuscripts of the New Testament, as well as to reflect on this in light of its future prospects as Bible translation engages the potentials and pitfalls of technological advances in achieving its goal of keeping the legacy of Scripture transmission alive.
|
Textual Variants in Justin, 1 Apology 65–67
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
Benedikt Eckhardt, University of Edinburgh
Justin’s description of the Eucharist is famously preserved in only two manuscript traditions, one of which (Ottobonianus gr. 274) sparked a debate in the late 19th century about what has more recently been referred to as “Ascetic Eucharists”. Harnack assumed that the cup originally contained only water, and that references to wine were added later by an “orthodox” redactor. The version given in the Ottobonianus (O) was regarded by him as an independent witness to the original text. This argument has largely been abandoned by scholars, who commonly regard O as a corrupted copy of the only other tradition (preserved in Parisinus gr. 450 A). This paper reassesses the arguments and finds that the theory of an “orthodox” redaction of the Parisinus cannot be upheld. It also points to the possibility that O is nevertheless an independent witness, as both questions do not have to be connected. In this context, the Latin tradition (discarded by Marcovich without further discussion) is also incorporated.
|
Competitions over Abstinence in the Acts of Paul: Dramatizing Pauline Instructions on Marriage
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Benjamin Edsall, Australian Catholic University
The Acts of Paul contains numerous examples of confrontations and competition oriented around the way in which female bodies are sexualized. Against the view of women as sexually obligated to their husbands – on individual and social levels – Paul’s emphasis on celibate asceticism creates competition between himself and the various male characters over the proper conduct of women. Furthermore, the Acts of Paul dramatizes a certain tension arising from Paul’s instructions to husbands and wives in 1 Cor 7, in which one may be partners with an unbelieving spouse. In other words, the Acts of Paul narrates the Apostle’s competition with normal Roman expectations of marital activity for sexually pure bodies of believers.
|
1 Peter and the African American Diaspora Experience
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Dennis R. Edwards, Northern Seminary
There are several topics in 1 Peter that have special resonance with the African American experience, such as:
1. The notion of being exiles of the Diaspora. As Miroslav Wolf notes: “The early Christian communities were not major social players at all! They were not even among the cheering or booing spectators. Slandered, discriminated against, and even persecuted minorities, they were at most a bit of a thorn in society’s flesh. Yet, notwithstanding their marginality, early Christian communities celebrated hope in God and proclaimed joyfully the resurrected Lord as they endeavored to walk in the footsteps of the crucified Messiah” (A Public Faith: How Followers of Christ Should Serve the Common Good).
African American Christianity mirrors the diaspora status of the Petrine community. This paper will explore how being part of a diaspora people can lead to a more vibrant faith.
2. What it means to persevere with faith through suffering. The African American experience includes faith forged in the fires of slavery, Reconstruction, the Jim Crow Era, the Civil Rights Movement, as well as ongoing discrimination. The readers of 1 Peter, whose suffering may not have been state sanctioned, were nevertheless bullied and needed encouragement to remain faithful throughout their trials. The painful experiences of African Americans may help to elucidate the message of 1 Peter.
3. Addressing how the African American experience speaks in unique ways to Christian witness in the sense of following the example of Christ. First Peter frequently raises Jesus as the model for faith under pressure and African American Christians have demonstrated the way of Christ through offering a witness of love despite having endured tremendous suffering.
I intend to demonstrate how the African American experience—especially for Christians—mirrors and also invigorates our understanding of 1 Peter.
|
Esther´s Prayer (Addition C) as a Theological Reinterpretation of the Hebrew Esther Story
Program Unit: Deuterocanonical and Cognate Literature
Beate Ego, Ruhr-Universität Bochum
In this paper, it will be argued that the Prayer of Esther, as it appears in the Old Greek text of the Book of Esther, can be seen as a theological reinterpretation of the Hebrew story of the Esther.
|
What Should Be Cut? (Gal 5.12) Social Identity Formation in Galatians
Program Unit: Writing Social-Scientific Commentaries of the New Testament
Kathy Ehrensperger, Universität Potsdam
TBA
|
David, Achish, and Their Place within the Historical Consciousness of Ancient Israel/Judah
Program Unit: Book of Samuel: Narrative, Theology, and Interpretation
Carl S. Ehrlich, York University
The Davidic narratives may be defined as the accounts of a series of interlocking interpersonal relationships pursued by David. Saul and Jonathan, Samuel and Nathan, Abigail and Bathsheba, Amnon and Absalom, all have their places and functions within the stories of David’s rise and fall. Among these multifarious relationships one stands out by virtue of its incongruity: David’s relationship with Achish, the Philistine king of Gath, whose vassal he becomes while on the run from Saul.
While this narrative ultimately serves to absolve David of involvement in the deaths of his Saulide rivals for rule over the Israelites, the question arises to what extent it is reflective of a historical reality, whether of the time period of which it purports to tell or of a later one. This paper will address the form and function of the David and Achish narratives and examine the various possibilities for dating them within the historical and literary contexts of ancient Israel and Judah.
|
Unifying Personifications: Hosea and Amos as Literary Characters
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Göran Eidevall, Uppsala Universitet
Rather than analyzing Hosea and Amos as literary characters, I intend to assess the effect of their presence in the books that carry their names. Without its prologue, chapters 1–3, the book of Hosea would be an anonymous collection of oracles (comprising chs. 4–14). Similarly, removing chapter 7 would turn the book of Amos into an assemblage of prophecies of unknown provenance. Arguably, these two prophetic characters bring unity to otherwise disparate collections. With reference to a dramatic life story (based on the allegedly biographical and auto-biographical accounts in Hosea 1–3 and Amos 7), it is possible to explain (or, harmonize) abrupt transitions, as well as apparent contradictions. This will be demonstrated by examples from exegetical commentaries on Hosea and Amos. From another perspective, I suggest that prophetic characters can be seen as personifications: of certain virtues, but also of a certain message. The concluding part of the presentation seeks to answer the question: What message is conveyed by these two personae, Amos and Hosea, respectively? On the basis of intertextual considerations, it will be suggested that whereas there are several intriguing connections between Amos and Jeremiah, Hosea can, to a certain extent, be understood as a Northern counterpart to Isaiah.
|
Reflections on the Legacy of Krister Stendahl
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Pamela Eisenbaum, Iliff School of Theology
Reflections on the Legacy of Krister Stendahl
|
The Minimization of “Faith” in Rashi’s Torah Commentary
Program Unit: Jewish Interpretation of the Bible
Yedida Eisenstat, York University
Among the questions that scholars of Rashi's Torah commentary ask is whether there is anti-Christian polemic in his Torah commentary. As Shaye
Cohen has argued, in the absence of explicit anti-Christian statements, one cannot simply posit its presence. Further, given that Rashi's Torah commentary is best understood as a medieval midrashic anthology, how may one detect Rashi's own theological and philosophical motivations in this text?
Without presuming anti-Christian polemic in Rashi’s Torah commentary, I maintain that there is evidence that Rashi responded to prevalent Christian ideas of which he would have been aware. Among these isthe Pauline idea that God's choice of Abraham was predicated first and foremost on Abraham's faith, a case Paul made in his letters both to the Galatians and Romans based on Genesis 15:6.
This paper analyzes Rashi's exegetical choices in his comments on Genesis 15:6 and shows that in all three of his interpretations of this verse, he sought to minimize the significance of Abraham's show of faith in this chapter. In his first comment, Rashi drew attention to the fact that directly following the narrative's note that Abraham had faith in God's promise that he would have a child, Abraham asked for a sign regarding God's promise of "this land." Rashi thereby called into question Abraham's faith. In Rashi's interpretations on the next clause, "And He deemed it as righteous-merit on his part," (Fox translation) Rashi first limited the significance of God's reckoning Abraham's faith to him as righteous-merit by attaching no enduring significance to the statement—in stark contrast to Paul, who argued that faith was in fact the basis of the Abrahamic covenant. Instead, Rashi immediately proposed another interpretation in which he once again reminds the reader that Abraham asked for a sign, minimizing his faith. Rashi explains though that Abraham did not ask for a sign that he would inherit the land but that Abraham asked rather in what merit God's promise would be realized. Rashi's answer, carefully culled from Genesis Rabba 44, is that the covenant would be realized in the merit of sacrifices, which makes clear that the covenant is not predicated on Abraham's faith, in remarkable contrast to Paul. It is apparent the Rashi here minimized the significance of Abraham's faith, and emphasized his asking for a sign to preclude the import of his faith, and brilliantly pivoted to once again emphasize the importance of action, in this case sacrificial observances, to preclude Paul's emphasis on the importance of faith.
In demonstrating that Rashi's choice was deliberate, I will highlight the fact that
there are perfectly good midrashic precedents on which Rashi might have drawn in which the Sages entertained the idea of the lasting meritorious effects of Abraham's faith. Rather, Rashi minimized the effects of faith and rather emphasized the meritorious effects of serving God in action.
|
The Evolution of God? Trinitarian Deities in the Qur’an
Program Unit: The Qur’an and Late Antiquity (IQSA)
Emran El-Badawi, University of Houston
The passage “Have you seen al-Lat and al-Uzza, and the third one Manat as well?” (Q 53:19-20) is the starting point of this presentation. It is, I will argue, the earliest reference to a Trinitarian cult in the Qur’an. Q 53:20-21 condemns this cult, not on account of its polytheism, but rather on account of its “female” deities (cf. Q 37:150-57). This controversy, therefore, distances itself from the matriarchal institution of late antique Arabian paganism, in favor of the patriarchal institution of the One God of Judaism/Christianity. The second part of this presentation examines the male cults of Allah, al-Rahman and al-Rahim, which I argue are Christian in background. The merger of these cults from different parts of Arabia into one (Q 1; 2:163; 27:30; 41:2; 59:22; cf. Q 17:110) demonstrates the Qur’an’s process of uniting Arabian society behind a new universal monotheism. The third part of this presentation concerns the text’s condemnation of the Incarnation doctrine (Q 3-4) and the Christian Trinity (Q 5). This phase of qur’anic revelation forms the final break between the Qur’an’s Abrahamic monotheism on the one hand, and the Christian Church on the other. Does the Qur’an’s anxiety about female deities reflect the shifting gender of Arabian gods and monarchs after the fall of Nabataea (2nd century CE) and Palmyra (3rd century CE)? Does its adoption of Christian male deities demonstrate the penetration of the eastern churches deep into the heart of Arabian society thereafter? Can its subsequent rejection of church doctrine be dated to the Christological controversies (4th-7th century CE)? This presentation seeks to answer these questions, and also sheds light on the importance on the text’s ‘tripartite’ discourse, the religious sensibilities of the audience, and the importance of gender. My argument is made in conversation with epigraphic evidence, literary sources and modern scholarship. By proposing an early, middle, and late phase to these developments, this presentation offers tentative results concerning the ‘evolution’ of the qur’anic God.
|
Speculative Cinema and the Politics of Scripture
Program Unit: Bible and Film
Gilad Elbom, Oregon State University
Much like Talmudic literature, science-fiction cinema often appropriates familiar biblical narratives in an attempt to adjust them to contemporary avenues of inquiry, inspect them under new circumstances, and use them to explore social and political questions. In keeping with the hermeneutic characteristics of midrash, the primary purpose of such appropriations and explorations is not to arrive at an ultimate interpretation but to wrestle with the inherent ambiguity of religious texts, test their relevancy and applicability to the current concerns of the community, and study them as dynamic systems of signs in which meaning is always unstable. This paper focuses on Barbarella (1968), Blade Runner (1982), and Sleep Dealer (2008) as visual narratives that employ recognizable elements from biblical texts, especially the Gospels, Acts, and the interpretive tradition of rabbinic literature. In political terms, the imperial powers portrayed in these movies often advocate equal exchange semiotics, also known as decodification semiotics, while colonized minorities resist through dialogic systems that rely on polyphony. Although cultural production, and language in particular, is frequently seen as the quintessential model of decodification semiotics, what the above movies seem to suggest is that it is language itself that challenges an automatic, predetermined, one-to-one correspondence between signifier and signified, offers effective alternatives to monolithic codes, and facilitates interpretation semiotics.
|
Joseph and Aseneth: Jewish and Christian
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Nicholas A. Elder, Marquette University
Interpretations of Joseph and Aseneth’s Jewish or Christian provenance have, until recently, tended to be dichotomous. Early interpreters, influenced by Pierre Batiffol’s critical edition, considered the narrative a Christian text from the fifth century CE. As a result, Joseph and Aseneth was not included in early twentieth-century collections of Jewish pseudepigrapha. In the second half of the twentieth century, however, the pendulum swung and the consensus, following the work of Christoph Burchard and Marc Philonenko, was that Joseph and Aseneth was a Jewish text from the Hellenistic period. And the last twenty years have produced more mixed assessments as to the authorship of the pseudepigraphon. Emboldened by Ross Kraemer’s skepticism about the text’s Jewish provenance, several recent studies have re-articulated cases for Christian composition. At present the state of scholarship is mixed. Both Christian and Jewish provenance of Joseph and Aseneth are positions currently held. Moreover, many now question whether or not the dichotomous terms that the debate has been constructed in are productive. In this paper I argue that they are not. Instead, I suggest that Joseph and Aseneth ought to be understood as Jewish and Christian, rather than Jewish or Christian. I first suggest that social memory theory, and specifically the concept “equiprimordiality,” helps reframe the debate. I then outline my own position on the early Jewish provenance of Joseph and Aseneth. I concur with the present consensus position that the narrative’s shape and central concerns are Jewish and that internal features suggest Joseph and Aseneth was first popularized in a Hellenistic Jewish milieu. The bulk of the paper then addresses the ways in which we ought to consider Joseph and Aseneth a Christian text. I argue the the text was Christian in so far as it was re-commemorated and re-memorialized in Christian contexts. Joseph and Aseneth was re-commemorated and re-memorialized in these contexts because it readily lent itself to Christian allegorical and typological interpretations. I address two areas in which Joseph and Aseneth possessed this kind of Christian potential. First, titles appended to Joseph will have led to his typological identification with Jesus in Christian reception of Joseph and Aseneth. And second, Aseneth’s transformation by means of repentance, which is earthly but, as Andrei Orlov has recently suggested, is also mirrored in the heavenly realm, comported well with early Christian understandings of heavenly transformation by means of metanoia.
|
Mark at the Borderland of Orality and Textuality
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Nicholas A. Elder, Marquette University
The publication of Werner Kelber’s The Oral and the Written Gospel was a watershed moment not only for media-critical approaches to Mark, but for the study of the gospel generally. Kelber’s seminal monograph, however, has often been charged with propagating the so-called Great Divide approach to orality and textuality. Recent interpreters have distanced themselves from any perspective that claims that these modalities of communication are mutually exclusive or competing. Instead, these interpreters emphasize that orality and textuality interfaced in a complex manner in both the production and reception of texts.
Yet there is little clarity about how this plays out at the ground level. The question of how a text like the Gospel of Mark simultaneously exhibits evidence of both oral and textual influence often goes unanswered. This paper aims to answer that question at the levels of both production and reception. It suggests that Mark existed (and still exists) at the borderland of orality and textuality. It is a “textualized oral narrative” composed via dictation. As such, there will have been multiple receptions of it, oral, aural, and literary, in antiquity.
By proposing this thesis, I attempt to move further beyond the dichotomous terms that theories about the production and reception of Mark are often constructed in. The paper suggests that Mark will have been read performatively to groups and will also have been literarily received by individuals, rather than suggesting one mode of reception over and against the other.
This thesis is argued on four counts. First, the linguistic style of Mark resembles spoken narratives, and this can be substantiated by modern sociolinguistic research. Second, the opening words of Mark, and specifically the term “gospel,” indicate that it is orally proclaimed news. Only after Mark was committed to the textual medium did this term come to refer to a literary genre. Mark’s existence at the borderland between orality and textuality helps to explain this development of the word. Third, early historical testimony from the likes of Papias, Clement, and Eusebius alleges that Mark was both produced and received as a tertium quid between writing and speaking. And fourth, several Markan exegetical “problems,” such as the location of the swine miracle in Mark 5 and the mix-up of Ahimelech and Abiathar’s names in Mark 2, and the solutions provided by the later Synoptic authors are less problematic when one understands Mark as a textualized oral narrative.
|
Becoming a Trauma-Informed Bible Professor
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Kathleen Gallagher Elkins, Saint Norbert College
There is a body of literature about trauma-informed care (in medicine, social work, law, and so on) and there are conversations in primary and secondary education about having trauma-informed classrooms. There is not, however, much work to date on trauma-informed college classrooms, beyond the debate about whether or not syllabi and readings should have "trigger warnings" on them. The blogosphere conversation about trigger warnings often lacked a theoretical basis or a nuanced understanding of post-traumatic "trigger," a term that is often misapplied to other contexts and topics. Having a trigger warning does not mean that students are not asked to discuss difficult topics; it also does not mean that they are special snowflakes who cannot handle real life. Research on post-traumatic stress disorder shows the ways that students who have experienced trauma are sometimes able to learn better when they have been prepared for what is coming. Good learning does not happen when students are triggered; actually, it is impeded. Trauma-informed college teaching is a pedagogical approach that responds to a diverse student body, including the ways that students may be affected by insidious traumas (Maria Root's term for various forms of oppression that may cause trauma) and other traumatizing experiences. The Bible itself can be, for certain students, a traumatizing weapon; for other students, the Bible represents a healing balm. Using insights from trauma theory in the humanities and from the movement for trauma-informed teaching and human services suggests that an approach to teaching the Bible (most especially the violent and troubling parts of the Bible) must be trauma-sensitive. This does not mean coddling or shielding students, but rather acknowledging the diverse life experiences and social locations that they bring into the classroom, as well as the varied reactions that the biblical text can provoke. Becoming a trauma-informed Bible professor is one way to connect with and respond to diverse student populations.
|
Hearing and Speaking: Exploring the Dialogue Between Author and Reader in a Pentecostal Hermeneutic
Program Unit:
Scott Ellington, Emmanuel College
In this paper I will address the conversation among Pentecostal hermeneuts regarding the locus of meaning. Some scholars, such as John Poirier, reject the ongoing activity of the Spirit in the process of interpretation locating meaning almost exclusively with the author and their intended meaning (‘The Blob That Ate New Haven: The Concept of Meaning in Hans Frei’s and Brevard Childs’s Writings’, a paper presented in our 46th annual meeting). Others, such as Kenneth Archer, tend to the opposite end of the spectrum, arguing that the quest for authorial meaning is to be rejected in favor of discovering and creating meaning in fresh dialogue with the Spirit and the text (Pentecostal Hermeneutics, p. 199). Craig Keener (Spirit Hermeneutics) adopts a somewhat left of center approach, allowing for the role of experience in interpretation, while still giving the controlling voice to authorial intent.
In this paper I will seek to give shape to a dialogical approach (a phrase that Archer uses, but which seems to me to be more of a monologue offered by current experience that marginalized the author’s voice in his usage) that is more right of center than Keener’s understanding, allowing a more pronounced place for the role of experience brought to the reading, but one which does not create (or discover) virtually ex nihilo the text’s meaning from the experience of a fresh encounter with the Spirit (Archer). Dialogue, as opposed to monologue, requires both hearing and speaking, that is, it requires an informed appreciation of both the author and the reader and, in the case of a Pentecostal approach, attentiveness to the active voice and participation of the guiding Spirit in both. The essential question which this paper seeks to address, then, is how best to frame the parameters of that dialogue so that both participants are honored and their relationship is more precisely stated.
I intend to nuance and quantify what a ‘dialogical’ reading looks like by exploring the interpretation and application of Old Testament scriptures by New Testament writers. Specifically and to limit the scope of the study, I plan at this early stage of exploration to focus on examples in Acts. It is no new observation that biblical writers seldom if ever attend directly to the original context and meaning of a passage when citing and reapplying it in a new context under the guidance of the inspiring Spirit. Rather that original meaning acts as a point of departure for a new application in a fresh context. I hope to demonstrate a) that this is a move in dialogue with, rather than simply in spite of, the original meaning and context of the cited text and b) that dialogical principles for a valid new reading can be discerned and enumerated from these exemplary texts. Chris Thomas (“Women, Pentecostals, and the Bible: An Experiment in Pentecostal Hermeneutics”) has already done some work with James’ use of Amos 9 in the Jerusalem Council in Acts 15, but he has not attempted a description of the interpretive process that James is using. I would like a) to broaden the pool of exemplary texts in Acts, b) to argue that these canonical examples are not an exception to sound interpretation (i.e., “They were inspired by the Spirit in an exceptional way that we cannot be.”), but rather provide a model for a dialogical approach to a text-reader-Spirit reading, and c) to suggest parallels and parameters from these that would apply to the current discussion of what it means to read the text dialogically as a Pentecostal.
|
The Church as Ideological Formation: "Ethnographic" Notes from a Participant Observer
Program Unit: Poverty in the Biblical World
Neil Elliott, Metropolitan State University
Those academics still involved in church life often demur from discussing our ecclesiastical commitments in scholarly settings. Yet the contours of contemporary U.S. Christianity are part of the ideological context in which we work. It is therefore important to analyze the role, not just of congregational life as a useful compartmentalization of social energy, but of the construal of “church” (in the singular) as a useful mystification within the capitalist ordering of society.
|
The Adaptation of Philonic Arithmology in Ambrose’s Letters on the Hexaemeron
Program Unit: Early Exegesis of Genesis 1–3
Paul M. C. Elliott, Concordia University Irvine
While Ambrose’s homilies on the Hexaemeron may be his best known commentary on Genesis 1-2, he also addressed questions about the Creation in a series of letters on the Hexaemeron (Ep. 29, 31, and 34). Unlike the homilies, which were largely dependent upon Basil’s Hexaemeron, Ambrose’s letters on the same topic owe much of their content to Philo of Alexandria’s De opificio mundi. This study is focused particularly upon Ambrose’s adaptation of Philonic arithmology in these letters, especially Ep. 31. In this text, Ambrose did not borrow arithmological material from Philo slavishly. After explicitly criticizing Neopythagorean number symbolism, Ambrose systematically excluded all such material from his adaptation of Philo. Nonetheless, Ambrose still found Philo to be a valuable source, and he did adapt other arithmological lore from Philo, particularly that which was drawn from the Old Testament or from nature. This study attempts to determine why Ambrose drew the line between acceptable and unacceptable number symbolism where he did. In doing so, it may illumine the different approaches that these two thinkers took with regard to numbers.
|
Dionysus, Azazel, and Processionals: The Influence of the Dionysian Cult in LXX Leviticus
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Spencer Elliott, Trinity Western University
When the Jewish Alexandrian community embarked on the translation of Leviticus, there were bound to be cases where the cult from the Hebrew Scriptures matched that of their surrounding culture. For the most part, this does not seem to bother them, as the translation of Leviticus in the Septuagint is characterized by the usual literal and stereotyped representation of the Hebrew base text. However, there are a number of occasions where it intentionally deviates from this norm. Two instances in chapters 16-17 suggest an intention to minimize a confusing intersection between the Day of Atonement and the Greek cult of Dionysus as practiced in Alexandria. In particular, the translation of the Hebrew word ʿazʾazel into Greek apopompaios evokes imagery of the processional element of the Greek temple ceremony (a pompē; Lev 16:8, 10), but in the opposite direction. Instead of a throng of worshippers in the procession going towards the place of sacrifice, a single is goat covered with the people’s sin and sent into the abject wilderness. In addition, the reticence to suggest that sacrifices should be offered to goats (laśśəʿîrim, “to the goats”, translated as tois mataiois) in Lev 17:7 indicates that the translator was avoiding associations with the cult of the half-man, half-goat Dionysus. These two elements, processional to the temple and the representation of the deity as a satyr, were significant elements to the practice of the Dionysian cult and were intentionally avoided by the translators of LXX-Leviticus.
|
Next Came the Letter: Listening with Dennis E. Smith to Paul’s Letters in the Context of Household Gatherings
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
Susan M. Elliott, Independent Scholar
Dennis E. Smith shared a paper at the spring meeting of the Christianity Seminar of the Westar Institute in 2016 entitled, “In The Beginning Was The House: How Social and Identity Formation of Early Christ Groups Took Place.” At the same meeting, I offered draft chapters of a book that has since been published as Family Empires, Roman and Christian, Volume 1, Roman Family Empires: Household, Empire, Resistance. In an unfortunately truncated conversation at that meeting, Dennis noted that he could see ways to collaborate to combine our two papers. This paper attempts a posthumous effort to continue that conversation. The paper will first summarize Smith’s portrayal of the house as the physical space in which early Christ groups gathered for meals. Then it will provide an amplified view of Roman households emphasizing their transformation into increasingly public social performance spaces during the late Republic and Augustan eras. Most of the paper will summarize and respond to Smith’s work on setting early Christ groups in the context of house gatherings in the houses described, focusing on Paul’s letters.
|
The Creation Account, the Yetzer, and Community Soul-Care in the Epistle of James
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Nicholas J. Ellis, Western Seminary
What is the role of Genesis 1–3 in evaluating the human condition in the Epistle of James? How might this foundational Jewish text illuminate James’ view of anthropology, its sinful condition, and the conditions for its restoration?
This paper will engage with two primary themes in James:
(1) The author’s description of the anthropological condition, notably described as διψυχος/“double-souled”. This section will assess James’ anthropology against the most recent scholarship on wider early Jewish discourses of the yetzer and the natural human inclination.
(2) A distinct and recurring allusion to the Genesis 1–3 account (most notably in Jas 1:13–18; 3:13–17; 4:5–8), which I propose provides for the author a biblical precedent for his understanding of the human condition of the soul, its temptation, and the effects caused by sin. Just as the first trial divided the human heart through desire, produced sin, and caused death, so every person’s heart is rent through divided religious loyalties.
What then is the cause and solution for this human condition? I will argue that these two themes provide the author with a biblical/theological framework for religious division and religious loyalty, both towards God, and towards one’s neighbor. The author draws a direct line between the divisions of religious loyalty to God (love for God), to the tearing of unity within the community (love for neighbor), a battle that has taken place from the beginning of human history.
In response to this internal and external religious threat, James builds an argument similar to that of the Jewish scribes: only Torah could defeat the yetzer, and unify the human heart in religious loyalty. For James, however, this Torah is the Rule of Jesus, its halakah is the double love commandment, and its therapeutic effects available to the community that fulfills its requirements. Taking this line of argument, the community of faith provides for James the means by which the divine command can be fulfilled and the divided human heart can be restored into unified religious loyalty.
|
Teaching Hebrew with Nonnative English Speakers: Developing Pedagogy in a Swedish Context
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Beth Elness-Hanson, Johannelunds Teologiska Högskola
Teaching Hebrew to non-native English speakers presents challenges for effective pedagogy and learning. With recent experiences teaching in Sweden, an American teacher collaborates on this analysis with a student. This dual viewpoint examination of the challenges provides a rich discussion of the creative approaches applied to the problems in order to develop a stronger pedagogy.
After an overview of the context, the authors identify several critical issues for developing pedagogy, methods, and resource to facilitate learning Hebrew. For example, in contrast to most North American contexts with robust resources for native English speakers, in Sweden there is a lack of resources in Swedish to develop deeper understanding of the meaning of Hebrew words. Specifically, there is neither a Hebrew-Swedish lexicon nor a Swedish concordance that identifies the Hebrew and Greek words. The results are ambiguity and the flattening of a semantic range. Developing strategic resources helps to fill the gaps.
In the midst of an educational system that encourages independent learning, the teacher initiated a shift in pedagogy to develop more collaborative learning. In contrast to the preceding teacher’s traditional methods, technological tools complimented the limited resources and lesson time in order to support student learning both inside and outside the classroom. While positive reflections from students include an appreciation of the broader theological vocabulary of English and access to a plethora of resources, all students deal with additional stress and hurdles. For example, hurdles include hesitation to ask questions because of insecurity in formulating questions in English and the lack of comparison to grammatical frameworks in Swedish grammar.
This careful analysis beyond standard student evaluations develops stronger pedagogy and strategies to facilitate learning. While some aspects of this analysis apply to those teaching cross-culturally, several strategies are pertinent to instruction and support for non-native English speakers in English-speaking contexts.
|
Chiasmus as a Vehicle for Meaning in Psalm 78
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
David Emanuel, Nyack College
As the second longest composition in the Psalter, Psalm 78 ostensibly reflects more characteristics of biblical prose than poetry, particularly regarding its length, and the extensive use of the wayyiqtol. The psalm recounts Israel’s—more specifically Ephraim’s—rebellion against God during the desert wandering era and their initial entrance into the promised land. In response, God judges Ephraim’s persistent disobedience by rejecting the tribe along with the tabernacle at Shiloh (v. 67). With the rejection of Ephraim, the psalm concludes (vv. 68-72) with God’s selection of Judah: the territory upon which to build his temple, and the tribe from which to select his chosen ruler, David. Perhaps due to its length, complex redactional history, and the historical narrative content, Psalm 78 (along with other exodus psalms such as 105 and 106) remains relatively neglected with respect to poetic analyses. The present paper represents a contribution towards addressing the imbalance of scholarly attention, by focusing on one poetic technique frequently employed within the psalm, chiasmus.
Primarily, the study identifies the various types of chiasmus employed within the psalm, and more importantly discusses how the author employs chiasmus, both structurally and expressively, within the psalm as a vehicle to convey meaning. Methodologically, the paper primarily focusses on the functional aspects of chiasmus, employing categories defined by Wilfred Watson, Classical Hebrew Poetry, to describe and determine how this poetic feature is utilized in Psalm 78. Ceresko’s earlier work, “The Function of Chiasmus in Hebrew Poetry,” additionally provides a framework for understanding how chiasmus can function within a literary unit. Other treatments of parallelism are additionally consulted, such as Adele Berlin’s Dynamics of Biblical Parallelism, to further establish types of parallelism, such as gender-matched sequencing. Berlin’s in-depth treatment of parallelism bears relevance for the present study because chiasmus is, essentially, an instance of inverted parallelism, instead of an A-B//A’-B’ pattern, chiasmus reflects an A-B//B’-A’ relationship. The present study concludes that chiasmus plays a wide variety of roles within Psalm 78. Among the more important ones are: opening and closing sections, creating contrast, structuring the composition, and creating intensity. It is not simply used as a tool to create poetry, but functions as an important vehicle for generating meaning within the psalm. It is hoped that the present study draws attention to the need for further poetic analysis of the longer narrative-poetic works in the Psalter.
|
Letting Judges Breathe: Queer Survivance in the Book of Judges and Gad Beck’s An Underground Life; Memoirs of a Gay Jew in Nazi Berlin
Program Unit: Gender, Sexuality, and the Bible
Sarah Emanuel, Colby College
Scholars typically describe the book of Judges as encompassing a cyclical transgress-suffer-prosper-transgress-again trope. Although Israelite peace and autonomy are maintained at various moments throughout the text, hardship inevitably ensues, leading exegetes to focus on the Israelites’ repeated demise as opposed to their continual triumphs. As David Gunn notes, “reward and punishment is often viewed as the book’s dominant theme.” Or, in the words of Danna Nolan Fewell, the stories within Judges are frequently read as a collective "downward spiral for Israel and its leaders.” I question, however, whether such thematic analysis might prove insufficient when engaging a hermeneutic of trauma and survival--or queer survivance, as we will see. Interestingly, of the 400-year period covered in the book of Judges, only 111 of them are spent in subjugation. Nearly three-fourths of the time period covered by the book, in other words, recounts times of judgeship and autonomy. Might this story be less about cultural transgression and more about the creative ways in which the Israelites managed to endure? In this paper, I will provide a dialogical comparison of the Judges cycle with the memoir of Holocaust survivor, Gad Beck. In doing so, I will suggest that Judges offers us a literary representation of an ancient culture’s fight to persist. Rather than guide readers through the entirety of the Judges narrative, however, I will focus on Judges 3 and 4, as the stories of and events surrounding Ehud and Jael offer a more concentrated narrative of the aforementioned cyclical trope. From a stance of hetero-suspicion and with a theoretical view to intertextuality and queer survivance, I will argue that, like Beck, Ehud and Jael subvert oppressive power structures through gender-bending performances and the embodiment of ambivalent, and even comedic, identity markers. Taking such similarities into consideration, I will then suggest that Ehud’s and Jael’s queer-comic consciousness becomes another thematic trope within the book of Judges as a whole. Yet instead of focusing on the repetition of the Israelites’ self-fulfilling demise, this trope spotlights the creative ways in which the Judges narrative becomes one of survival, and reflects an ancient culture’s will to resist, persist, and indeed, live.
|
The Arrangement of James in Light of Catchword Association in Semitic Documents
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Daniel K. Eng, University of Cambridge
This paper examines the arrangement of the epistle of James in light of Semitic documents that display catchword association. James shows evidence of being a compilation, with adjacent sections frequently connected by a common cognate. Readers accustomed to Westernized patterns of logical progression may find such conventions nonsensical. However, when viewed through a framework characterized by Semitic documents, James shows affinity with a purposeful custom of connecting material by catchword. After identifying patterns of catchword association in Jewish documents, the paper will then show similar arrangements in James and offer recommendations on how a Semitic framework impacts the interpretation of this enigmatic epistle.
While many have attempted to fit James into Greco-Roman patterns of rhetoric, they produce different demarcations of the arrangement of the epistle. With this lack of consensus in view, Richard Bauckham quips, “One suspects that something must be wrong with the goal that is being attempted.” James may not necessarily display the logical development often found in Greco-Roman documents. This paper demonstrates that the catchword association in James fits a pattern that pre-dates Hellenization, and offers a framework informed by Semitic catchword association through which to view James.
While acknowledgement of catchword association in James is widely attested, there has not been a focused attempt to associate this pattern with structures in Semitic documents. This paper contributes to the study of James by relating it to documents that show catchword association in the Hebrew Bible, LXX, and the Dead Sea Scrolls. For example, adjacent but disparate sections in Leviticus share an association of “goat-demons” (שָׂעִירִ֖ם—Lev 17:7) with the goat (שָׂעִיר) of the sin offering occurring throughout Lev 16. The book of Numbers groups a section regarding confession (Num 5:5–10) with a section regarding adultery (Num 5:11–31), with the common cognate unfaithfulness (מַעַל –Num 5:6, 12). Ezekiel shows different associations, from cords (Ezek 3:25; 4:8) to swords (Ezek 5:17; 6:3). Other examples come from Proverbs, Psalms, the Book of the Twelve, the Damascus Document, and 4QFlorilegium.
This paper then examines arrangement of sections in James based on catchword-association. James is easily divided into sections, with consensus about where many sections begin and end. However, adjacent sections often appear to have no logical connection. Martin Dibelius and others have maintained that the author or compiler of James frequently places sections together based on Stichwörter, or catchwords. These include λείπω (1:4, 5), πειρασμός—πειράζω (1:12, 13), and λόγος (1:21, 22).
Examination of a Semitic pattern of arrangement aids the interpretation of the epistle of James. It offers greater prominence Jewish documents in discussions of the interpretation of James. In addition, it informs its provenance, suggesting that the author may be using pre-existing or even traditional material and arranging these sections using a Semitic custom. It may also impact the discussion of the genre of James, since catchword association occurs in different kinds of literature.
|
Digital Clay: Making Cuneiform Tablet Collections Accessible with 3D Modeling
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
Bradley C. Erickson, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
Recent progress in 3D modeling allows for the digitization and dissemination of difficult-to-access material. Objects can be digitized and shared three dimensionally through virtual means, such as augmented and virtual reality and through physical means, such as replication with 3D printing. In this paper, I present a case study of the digitization and circulation of a difficult-to-access series of cuneiform tablets housed in the special collections library at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. Six never-before-published cuneiform tablets were turned into 3D models via the process of photogrammetry. Those models were then made available online for open-access to the material. Each model was also 3D printed to grant researchers, students, and the public access to the physicality, scale, and dimensionality of the object. Further, the digital models allowed for the production of new types of research data within cuneiform studies, such as Digital Elevation Model (DEM) images that measure the depth of incisions on each tablet. The project methodology, 3D models, and 3D prints will be presented and analyzed in this paper.
|
A Supplementary Approach to Numbers 32
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Angela Roskop Erisman, Angela Roskop Erisman Editorial
(no abstract)
|
Jeremiah 34: The Liberation of Slaves and the Dispensability of Kings under the Rule of Torah
Program Unit: Theology of the Hebrew Scriptures
Johanna Erzberger, Cardiff University
Jer 34 tells the story of the making of a covenant between Zedekiah and the inhabitants of Jerusalem during the siege of Jerusalem to release their Hebrew slaves, which is implemented, but later on revoked. The revocation triggers a lengthy speech of God to Jeremiah that first interprets the manumission that has not taken place, in a religious framework and in light of the Sinai covenant, and then announces dire consequences.
This paper argues that it is not so much the episode about the manumission which is at heart of the final versions of both JerMT and JerLXX. Rather the manumission, as a variation and reinterpretation of an older concept of liberation attested also by extra-biblical sources, is used as an example to discuss ideal kingship and governance. In a double movement, the king is reprieved of his power: As the proclamation of liberation results from the implementation of a covenant between Zedekiah and the people, which is an implementation of the Sinai covenant, it is God whose initial initiative is at the root of its proclamation and who, measured against the ancient concept, acts as the actual king. As the people are the grammatical subject of the proclamation of the liberation resulting from the covenant between themselves and Zedekiah, the concept of liberation is “democratized”. Kingship and government are rendered dispensable. God’s covenant as it is implemented by the people rules Judah if not the world.
|
Echoing Prayers: The Prayer of Repentance (Bar 1:15-3:8) in the Book of Baruch and in the Context of Intertextual References between Bar, Dan, and the Versions of Jeremiah
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Johanna Erzberger, Cardiff University
In Bar 1-3 the reading of an unqualified book, which is mostly identified with the book of Baruch, but has occasionally also been identified with the book of Jeremiah, is followed by a prayer of repentance (Bar 1:15-3:8). This prayer of repentance is an almost literal quote of the prayer of repentance in Dan 9, which there follows Daniel’s (private) reading of the book of Jeremiah (Dan 9:2). While it has been frequently observed that the prayer of repentance in the book of Baruch quotes Daniel, the contextualization of this quote and its function within the literary setting of the book of Baruch have less often been taken into account.
Parallels between the books of Jeremiah, in particular in the version of the MT, and the book of Daniel (e.g. the role of Nebuchadnezzar) have been observed before. Whereas the book of Baruch can and at certain points has been read as an appendix to the book of Jeremiah in the version of the LXX, there are equally parallels that link it to the MT version of the book of Jeremiah (e.g. an interest in the temple cult).
The paper regards the use of the book of Daniel within the book of Baruch in its literal setting as well as in the context of further going intertextual links that are established between both books and the versions of the book of Jeremiah.
|
The Largest Divination Text from Maresha
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Esther Eshel, Bar-Ilan University
More than a century of excavation at Maresha, starting in 1900, and still active to this day, have yielded tremendously exciting and varied finds including more than twelve-hundred Greek and Aramaic inscriptions and ostraca. The number and diversity of the finds places Maresha among the most important and enriching ancient archeological sites in Israel.
Maresha was first excavated in 1900 by Bliss and Macalister. Large-scale excavations of surface areas and some of the subterranean complexes were directed by Amos Klonerfrom 1989 to 2000. Since 2000, Ian Stern and Bernie Alpert have conducted further excavations. The Southern foothill site has yielded more than 1200 Greek and Semitic - mainly Aramaic - inscriptions, dated to the Hellenistic period, which had entrusted me for publication. 387 are from Subterranean Complex 169, a cave complex that contains anthropogenic debris that was dumped from surface dwellings during the Hellenistic period and, by the nature of dumping, lacks a clear stratigraphic context. Included in this collection are a group of 140 Aramaic ostraca, dating to the third or second centuries B.C.E. They share a similar textual structure. Based on our study of the content of this group, I suggest the ostraca may be understood as divination texts. In my paper I will present the הן group and will focus on the largest ostracon where the marital status makes up the major part it.
|
2 Corinthians and Super Apostles
Program Unit: Writing Social-Scientific Commentaries of the New Testament
Philip Esler, University of Gloucestershire
TBA
|
Silence and Suffering in the Book of Job
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Bryan D. Estelle, Westminster Seminary California
Silence and Suffering in the Book of Job
|
Reading the Name-Giving in Isaiah 8:1 from a Perspective of Trauma: An Application
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Liza Esterhuizen, University of Pretoria, South Africa
The book Isaiah may leave those who read it confused. Moreover when the names of Isaiah’s children are observed and studied. The roles that children play, the function of their names and their existence in the Old Testament and the Hebrew Bible, have received very little attention within biblical scholarship. Children were viewed as objects of divine promises or components of a covenant. The names of Isaiah’s children not only hold metaphorical meaning as sign-names but also preserve a collection of struggles of this ancient community to live out their relationship with Yahweh, in their own time frames, which is unavoidably shaped by events, like births, death, imminent war, and trauma in their time. When Isaiah 7 and 8 are studied, there are close resemblances so far as the theme and the content of Isaiah’s prophecy are concerned. The similarities in both chapters are the symbolic name giving of Isaiah’s children, the promise of the demise of Israel, and the imminent threat of Assyria to Judah. When reading the text of Isaiah 8:1, which will be the focus text of this paper, the metaphorical name giving of Isaiah’s son מַהֵר שָׁלָל חָשׁ בַּז-Maher-Shalal-hash-baz conjures images of war, disaster, threats, and trauma. The historical background is the Syro-Ephraimite crisis of 734-732 BCE. The name Maher-Shalal-hash-baz was perplexing as the name contains two comparable verbs of ‘quick; swift’ and ‘spoil; plunder’. The interpretation explains who will be plundered and who will be defeated through plundering. The continual exposure to violence and trauma are embodied in the name that threatens not only the child as a sign but also the psychological and physical wellbeing of Judah. Making sense of trauma is a universal human need for meaning and reading the metaphorical name giving of Maher-Shalal-hash-baz through a trauma lens is an act of meaning-making to understand the text. To understand trauma, it is important to understand what trauma means and where it derives from. While it seems commonplace today, the use of trauma as a theory in psychology and biblical studies is fairly new. Trauma occurs when both internal and external resources are inadequate to cope with an external threat. Trauma is not a single faceted experience but a balancing act and conflict between spiritual, emotional and physical responses. As a biblical scholar and psychologist, the works of Caruth, Hermann and the classification model DSM-5 will form the foundation of this paper to formulate theory and method. Though trauma grips individuals and collective groups, there is a phenomenon of hope present in the mist of traumatic events. This phenomenon is posttraumatic growth or resilience and it implies that individuals and collective communities can be changed through their encounters with trauma. The metaphorical name giving in Isaiah 8:1 becomes the trauma vehicle that challenges the people of Judah through faith and hope. It will be the aim of this paper to integrate conventional commentary research with a sound biblical literature study and modern-day trauma studies to form the foundation of this research.
|
Narrative Dialogue, Institutional Discourse, and the Opponents of Jesus in the Gospel of John
Program Unit: Speech and Talk in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Douglas Estes, South University, Columbia
Scholarly discussions of the dialogue patterns of the opponents of Jesus in the Fourth Gospel typically seek to understand these patterns in light of their socio-theological positioning. Yet there is still much that can be said from the perspective of their role in narrative development. For example, often overlooked is how the power imbalance between Jesus and his opponents in John’s story—Jesus is the low-stature individual, but his opponents operate within the circles of a closed, high-stature, exclusivist group—plays out in their dialogue sequences, and what it communicates to the reader. As recent research in the linguistics of social dynamics show, when closed circles communicate with either insiders or outsiders, they communicate in what is frequently referred to as ‘institutional discourse.’ In this sense, from the works of Habermas, Heritage, Mayr, and Wang, among others, institutional discourse is not limited to modern speech-patterns; this type of communication can essentially occur in any situation where a group of people communicate with other(s), especially if there is a power imbalance. A noted example of institutional discourse occurs in the speech patterns of religious leadership/groups. This power imbalance creates the opportunity for unique forms of dialogue among characters in this narrative that assists with the development of plot.
With this as a starting point, this presentation will explain what institutional discourse is, how it works in natural language situations, and how it works in written texts (esp. narratives) through the dual lens of narratology and historical linguistics. Next, the paper will examine the way in which the Fourth Evangelist portrays the talk of the opponents of Jesus, and show how their use of institutional discourse as a closed, exclusive group of religious leaders functions in light of linguistic, rhetorical and narrativist evidence. Finally, the presentation will note how the use of institutional discourse creates significant effects on the characterization of Jesus’ opponents as well as Jesus himself. A concluding thought is made about other narrative insights that institutional discourse can offer in other texts.
|
Recognizing the Gods: A Brief Historiography of Images in Greek Religion
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Marshall Evans, University of California-Santa Barbara
Since the first scholarly efforts to understand ancient Greek religion undertaken by late 19th and early 20th century classicists such as Jane Harrison and Martin Nilsson, the use of images in worship among ancient Greek polytheists, whether inside or outside of temples, has long received less attention than animal sacrifice and Greek festivals. In this paper, through a select historiography of the use of images in worship in ancient Greek religion, I will show how the insufficiently defined and hastily applied category of idolatry has obscured later scholarly understanding of the role of images in the practice of ancient Greek polytheists. Recent emphasis on the practice of Greek religion outside of temples, in homes, marketplaces, gymnasia, and even on roads has reanimated questions about the significance of images, both two and three dimensional, in ancient Greek piety. As Alice Donohue has shown, even the term “cult statue” resembles the broad, pejorative category of idolatry in its obfuscation of ancient Greek worship. “Cult statue,” according to Donohue, while long used to refer to images of the gods in the naos and a staple of much scholarship of ancient Greek sculpture, is not an indigenous category in the first century CE, or indeed in any other era of Greek history. Rather, reverence paid to images of the gods on a roadside might well parallel reverence paid to images of gods in a temple naos.
In this paper, I will show how the pioneering efforts of Harrison and Nilsson, as well as the more theoretically disciplined polis religion model introduced by Christiane Sourvinou-Inwood in the last decade of the 20th century, have elided the significance of images in ancient Greek polytheism. While the polis religion model achieved the indispensable task of removing the Christianizing lenses that had focused on belief to the detriment of ritual in ancient Greek polytheistic practice, it contributed to the elision of the significance of images for the individual. Focused as the polis religion model was on sacrifice and the corporate nature of ancient Greek polytheism, interaction between the individual and the image was left out. Both Robert Parker and Henk Versnel, in different ways, have tried to correct the polis religion model’s reduction of ancient Greek religion to an instrument of state control. Each scholar demonstrates that private devotion to the gods, whether in a private or a public place, flourished throughout Greek polytheism’s long history. I hope to give their implicit recognition of images in ancient Greek piety a more explicit theoretical foundation.
|
The Sublime in Religious Rhetoric: A Response
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Murray J. Evans, University of Winnipeg
n/a
|
The Challenges of Assessing War: The Success and Failure of Sennacherib’s 701 BCE Campaign in Light of the War of 1812
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Paul S. Evans, McMaster Divinity College
This paper will look at the deeply perspectival challenges involved in the perceived success or failure of war. As is well known, Sennacherib’s 701 BCE invasion of Judah resulted in widespread destruction of Judahite cities. Understandably, Hezekiah’s rebellion has therefore been viewed by many historians as disastrous, despite the fact that Jerusalem was not taken and Hezekiah remained on the throne. What is more, Assyrian texts clearly view the campaign as an unmitigated success. Of course, the perspective of the biblical texts contrasts these assessments as it viewed Hezekiah as a hero and his rebellion as successful. In order to compare these contrasting assessments of the 701 BCE war, I will consider the war of 1812 between the United States of America and the United Kingdom and her colonies (Canada). Similar to assessments of Sennacherib’s campaign, assessments of the war of 1812 vary widely. Despite the fact that the war ended with the Treaty of Ghent which prescribed the return of prisoners of war and occupied lands to their respective sides, and the resumption of friendly trade relations, Canadians view the war as a Canadian victory, while the Americans view it as an American triumph. I will suggest that just as the war of 1812 spawned popular historical works that furthered Canadian myth-making and nation-building (e.g., Pierre Berton’s works), biblical narratives of Sennacherib’s invasion should be viewed similarly. I will suggest that scholarly assessments pejoratively claiming outright deception and lies on the part of ancient Israelite historiography or Assyrian annalists need reassessment. Neither side is wholly true and neither side is wholly false. Their historiography is not the history. Given that even in an event as recent as 1812 with a plethora of sources and evidences at our fingertips, scholarly assessments differ on important questions, so we should not be surprised that scholarly assessments on such questions on the war of 701 BCE differ either. What is more, given the value of perception as political commodity different assessments from those involved in the war should not be surprising either.
|
Permission to Traumatize? An Exploration of Human and Nonhuman Responses to the Genesis Flood Narrative
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Jacob R Evers, Fuller Theological Seminary (Pasadena)
Though the flood narrative in Genesis is the first portrayal in the Bible of trauma experienced by the entirety of Earth community, the text’s presentation of the flood as a unique event yields counterintuitive implications when considered as an indicator of the story’s rhetorical function. Interpreters approaching the story with sensitivity to Earth have sometimes been drawn to language in the narrative that reflects concern for non-human beings (such as the inclusive references to “all flesh” and “every living creature”), hoping perhaps to find in the text a recognition of human and non-human solidarity in the experience of suffering that offsets the anthropocentric thrust of the story as a whole. This paper will argue that such attempts at retrieval are proscribed not only by the features of the account that serve to shore up human interests, but by the overall persuasive effect of the account on human readers, which would seem to engineer the perpetual re-traumatization of Earth community. Engaging in a close reading of the conclusion of the narrative (Gen 9:1-17) and empathetically exploring possible responses by the non-human victims in the world of the text, this paper will reflect on how reading with concern for the trauma of non-human members of Earth community might nevertheless lead human readers to an alternative response.
|
Digital Tools for Tracking and Analyzing Pistis-Language
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
Jennifer Eyl, Tufts University
This paper explores underutilized features of the TLG to track and visualize the frequency, growth, and usage of pistis and its cognates from the 8th century BCE through the 3rd century CE. While the TLG has been widely used by Classicists since the 1980s, and is now used regularly by New Testament scholars, the database offers extensive research opportunities that have gone largely unnoticed by the latter. This paper demonstrates the usefulness of such features, by applying them to an analysis of pistis.
My larger project involves reexamining pistis as loyalty/fidelity/faithfulness in the letters of Paul. This challenges the traditional understanding of pistis as "faith" or "belief" as a cognitive/sentimental position maintained by the individual, without a basis in proof or prior cause for believing. Using the TLG Statistics tools, we are able to visualize the frequency of pistis-language distributed throughout specific centuries, authors, and geographic locations. In some ways, the findings are unsurprising; the frequency of pistis-language is fairly stable and consistent in the fifth, fourth, and second centuries BCE (with a short drop in the 3rd BCE). We see an uptick in its frequency in the first century BCE and first century CE, followed by a significant rise in the second century CE. However, some findings are unexpected; while NT scholars may assume that this increase of pistis-language of the second century is attributed to early Christians, we see this increased usage in Plutarch, Galen, and Sextus Empiricus. I will briefly discuss the implications of my numerous findings from these statistical and visualization tools. While the paper focuses on pistis and its cognates, the tools themselves are thoroughly applicable to other research projects.
|
Tradition as Innovation: Ancient Harmonistic Theologizing in the Temple Sermon (Jer 7:1–8:3)
Program Unit: Theology of the Hebrew Scriptures
O. Y. Fabrikant-Burke, University of Cambridge
The famous Temple Sermon in Jer 7:1-8:3 stands near the center of modern historical-critical research into the book of Jeremiah. In particular, the precise nature of its relationship to the Deuteronomistic tradition and the Jeremianic poetry remains a matter of deep controversy and debate. In this paper, I will revisit this vexed issue by shifting the focus to the ancient scriptural interpretation - scribal theologizing - that gave rise to this complex text. A close analysis of older Deuteronomistic and Jeremianic texts and traditions as well as their dynamic transformations in the Temple Sermon leads me to the surprising conclusion that an innovative text may be born out of largely non-innovative instincts. The Temple Sermon, I will argue, is innovative in relation to its precursor traditions, both Deuteronomistic and Jeremianic, yet it arises not out of a desire to subvert and innovate, but an attempt to preserve and harmonize. Paradoxically, without intending to innovate, the scribes produced an innovative composition out of reverence for the traditions they inherited.
This paper advances three key arguments. First, I will engage with the current scholarship on the intricate dynamics of tradition and innovation in scribal scriptural interpretation (e.g. MacDonald 2016). By probing the phenomenon of harmonistic exegesis, I will argue that tradition and innovation may be more organically related than previously thought. To this end, I will develop a distinction between an innovative text and an innovative intent. Although the question of result versus intent is ridden with complexities, it is my contention that careful attention to scribal operations of textual reuse can prove probative. Second, I will examine the enigmatic Jer 7:3 ("Amend your ways and your deeds, and I will let you dwell in this place") as an instance of ancient harmonistic exegesis in action. Rather than revealing an innovative agenda, the exegetical logic of the Temple Sermon stems from an effort to capture, in one stroke, the thrust of Deuteronomistic and Jeremianic traditions together. The result of this scribal interpretive endeavor, however, ends up transcending both. In the Temple Sermon, innovative theology is born of a traditionalist impulse. Emerging from the interpretive furnace of Jer 7:3 are a Deuteronomistic Jeremiah and a Jeremianic Deuteronomism, and the paper will outline the essential theological features of both. Finally, I will briefly discuss how these proposals might inform our own construals of Jeremianic theology - our own contemporary theologizing.
|
The Proverbs 31 Woman in Late Twentieth Century Self-Help Literature
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
John W. Fadden, Saint John Fisher College
Self-help books hold a special place in the culture of the United States. They reflect and contribute to the social, economic, and political realities of their day. In the late twentieth century, self-help books as a genre boomed, as people looked for answers to economic and societal changes, including the increase of middle-class white women in the workforce, the loosening of ‘traditional’ sexual mores, and shifting notions of marriage and the self. In this self-help books boom, a niche market of books emerged for a white Christian women’s audience, and often written by women. These Christian women’s self-help books propose models of Christian womanhood, relying on the Bible as one of their source of authority for their models. This paper surveys Christian women’s self-help books from the late twentieth century to explore the variety of ways authors use Proverbs 31:10-31 to construct their ideal of Christian womanhood. While Proverbs 31:10-31 previously was used to praise and correct women, the paper argues that late twentieth century self-help books witness the development of the Proverbs 31 woman as a cultural icon of Christian womanhood. The Proverbs 31 woman is not a return to a womanhood that had always been, but rather a response to and product of the United States in the last decades of the nineteen hundreds.
|
Once More on “The Assyrian Way of/to Peace” and Its Implications for Levantine History
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Frederick Mario Fales, University of Udine
Pax Assyriaca (which, by analogy with pax romana, means “peace – the Assyrian way”) is a concept of more than two decades' standing in the archaeology and history of the Southern Levant, to which both Nadav Na'aman and the present writer have made contributions. In a recent work, Joshua T. Walton has pointed out the existence of two widely different acceptations which have been hitherto applied to the historical notion of pax assyriaca. It is the purpose of this paper to review such a double interpretation, and to reconsider the sources in support of one or the other meaning, in an attempt to evaluate the level of actual Assyrian activity and engagement in the administrative, economic and social horizon of the Southern Levant – from Phoenicia to Philistia to Judah to Edom – during the “Assyrian century”.
|
Prayer at Communal Mustering: A Comparison of the Qumran Covenant Ceremony and the Iguvine Tables
Program Unit: Prayer in Antiquity
Daniel K. Falk, Pennsylvania State University
This paper compares the Covenant Ceremony attested in the Dead Sea Scrolls with the Iguvine Tables as a means to examine the complicated relationship between text, material context, and enacted ritual of prayer.
Arguably the most important ritual for the sectarian movement represented in the Dead Sea Scrolls was the annual Covenant Ceremony, described in the Rule of the Community (1QS 1:16-2:23. It consisted of a mustering of the entire community, prayers, and rituals of blessing on the members and initiates and cursing of outsiders and apostates. It remains unclear, however, how the text in 1QS relates the actual ritual. In contrast to liturgical scrolls for various occasions found at Qumran, this is hardly a script for the covenant ceremony. Its purpose in 1QS is likely not even as a prompt, but most likely serves a rhetorical function in the document. If the expulsion ritual at the end of the Damascus Document (4QDa 11; 4QDe 7 i-ii), and the blessings and curses in 4QBerakhot (4Q286-290) are also related to the Covenant Ceremony, we may have different versions of the ritual.
The Iguvine Tablets consist of seven bronze sheets from Umbria engraved on both sides with religious rituals of a priestly fraternity. They detail sacrifices and prayers at purification rituals and feasts, including rubrics specifying exact words (e.g., "use this formula," "thus pray during the libation"). The rituals include a ceremonial mustering of the community with blessings, and ritual expulsion and cursing of traditional enemies. The earliest tablets, dating from the third century BCE were written with the Umbrian alphabet; the latest, written in Latin characters in the first century BCE, expand on the rituals of an earlier tablet. At least some of the tablets were mounted for public display.
Both the similarities and differences are striking and invite comparison. Both prescribe prayers for ritual mustering of the community, with blessing and cursing rituals. Both also are in the context of texts that have undergone expansion. They are both, however, in very different physical contexts: a scroll versus mounted tablets.
This paper will examine both of these prayer rituals in their respective material and cultural contexts, and then compare and contrast them with each other in reflecting on the significance of the material and cultural context to the meaning and function of prayer.
|
What Order are the Qumran Festival Prayers? Toward an Improved Reconstruction of 4Q509+4Q505.
Program Unit: Qumran
Daniel K. Falk, Pennsylvania State University
The most extensive copy of a collection of Festival Prayers from Qumran is on the recto of a poorly preserved opisthograph papyrus (4Q509+505). The verso bears a copy (or part) of the War Scroll (4Q496) followed by a copy of a collection of prayers, the Words of the Luminaries (4Q506). To date, however, a satisfactory reconstruction of this scroll has not been accomplished. The original editor Maurice Baillet placed fragments 1-16 near the beginning of the scroll on the basis of content on the verso with parallels to the first four columns of 1QM, and fragments 131-2 late in the scroll, since the verso belongs to the prayer for Sunday from a copy of Words of the Luminaries. Otherwise, his suggestions are mostly conjectural. Subsequent studies-e.g., by Falk, Chazon, Hamidović, and Qimron-have made some corrections, but there is still considerable disagreement and uncertainty about the identity of the fragments labeled 4Q505, the arrangement of fragments, and the order of festivals. Particularly puzzling is the failure to produce an order of prayers that consistently corresponds to the calendar of festivals.
This paper will attempt an improved reconstruction of the Festival Prayers on the recto of this scroll on the basis of a fresh examination of the papyrus fragments and the latest high resolution images, in combination with insights from Martin Abegg's new analysis of the War Scroll (4Q496) on the verso.
|
Copto-Arabic Narratives of Church Consecrations as Ekphraseis of Ecclesial Art
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Mary K. Farag, Princeton Theological Seminary
Five seventh- and eighth-century Copto-Arabic narratives imagine the first-person accounts of Alexandrian bishops at church consecrations. The late antique ecclesial art of the churches in question does not survive, but by comparing the verbal "images" of the narratives to late antique ecclesial art in other churches, I argue that the writers of the narratives constructed their stories by engaging in the practice of contemplating ecclesial art, a form of theōria. The narratives construct the sacred in spatial terms and sanctification in tactile ones, so as to saint the church.
|
The Kenite Redaction: A Supplementary Approach to the Hovav and Kenite Accounts
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Zev Farber, Project TABS - TheTorah.com
Some of the Kenite traditions seem ancient and yet many of them were clearly added into the Bible at a later stage, as a redaction-critical analysis shows. Moreover, the editors make little effort to have the Kenite traditions cohere. Their eponymous ancestor appears in Genesis as the son of Adam and Eve and yet they are treated in most of the Bible as merely a small tribe of locals in Canaan. They are allies to Barak and Saul, and yet they live among Amalekites and are cursed by Balaam in Numbers and described as murderous and cursed in Genesis. In some texts, they are treated as synonymous with Midianites, in others they are associated with Canaanites, and yet they are also described as allies to the Israelites. How are we to understand the history of this group in Israelite mnemohistory and why do the redactors of the Enneateuch treat them in such a haphazard manner?
|
Separating Mamre from Hebron Literarily and Geographically
Program Unit: Genesis
Zev Farber, Project TABS - TheTorah.com
In the text of Genesis as we have it, Mamre is identified with Hebron and Kiryat-arba, making it a city with a gate. But the stories in the J text about Abraham and Sarah in their tent at Mamre paint a different picture. If the identification of Mamre with Hebron is late, where is J’s Mamre? A number of scholars have identified Mamre with Khirbet Nimra because of the similarity between the names and its proximity to Hebron. Nevertheless, a number of geographical clues in the story point to a different location. Using these clues and ArcGIS, I suggest an alternative site that works well specifically with the J story in Genesis 18.
|
The Synoptic Problem and Lectio Brevior Potior
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Alan Taylor Farnes, Brigham Young University
Scholars of the Synoptic Problem often employ arguments from length to support their claims. These scholars explicitly state that they are borrowing the text critical maxim that the shorter reading is the earlier reading (lectio brevior potior). This is often done to show alternating primitivity within the Synoptics. Following this line of reasoning in Matthew 5:3 // Luke 6:20 (Blessed are the Poor), one would conclude that, because Luke’s reading is shorter, it is therefore earlier. Such a conclusion is helpful to Q proponents because it suggests alternating primitivity: sometimes Matthew has the shorter (read: earlier) text and sometimes Luke has the shorter (read: earlier) text. Therefore, for scholars who marshal length as evidence, the text critical maxim lectio brevior potior is necessary and vital in order to establish alternating primitivity.
This text critical maxim, however, has been the subject of debate in recent text critical studies and seems to be losing its foothold. The original formulation of lectio brevior potior was uttered by none other than Griesbach himself in 1809. In more recent studies, a notable text critic James Royse has studied the scribal habits of six early New Testament scribes in order to ascertain whether their general tendencies were to add to the text (as is suggested by lectio brevior) or to omit (which would disprove lectio brevior). In his 2008 tome, Royse concludes that, with respect to the six early papyri which he analyzed by singular readings, the scribes omitted more than they added. This conclusion suggests that the longer reading is to be preferred instead of the shorter reading.
My own 2017 dissertation at the University of Birmingham analyzed manuscripts whose exemplar has survived. These are pairs of manuscripts where we know both the exemplar and the copy. I was therefore able to “virtually look over the scribe’s shoulder and compare the text he is copying with his result” and obtain exact statistics for how these scribes copied the text and whether they added or omitted. The surprising conclusion is that some scribes, like 0319 and 0320, actually copied their manuscripts surprisingly well and did not add or omit a single word. Other scribes lost words on the whole. No scribe that I studied gained words on the whole. My dissertation concluded, therefore, that while my study may not be able to confirm Royse’s reversal of Griesbach’s canon, it surely did, with respect to the scribes I studied, disprove Griesbach’s canon.
Many textual critics today, such as Peter Malik and Stephen Carlson, are in favor of ignoring length entirely when attempting to find the most original reading. When applied to the Synoptic Problem, arguments seeking to show primitivity based on length are now weakened and source critics should no longer use the shorter reading argument as a method to show alternating primitivity in the synoptics.
This paper will also discuss whether using text critical principles is appropriate within source criticism due to the possibility that scribes and gospel writers may be undertaking entirely different tasks.
|
First-Century Slave Prices and Matthew’s Thirty Pieces of Silver as a Fulfillment of Zechariah 11
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Alan Taylor Farnes, Brigham Young University
Matthew 26.14–16 depicts Judas’ agreement with the chief priests to assist in Jesus’ arrest. This triple tradition passage is fairly consistent among the synoptics: Judas goes to the chief priests, arranges to deliver Jesus, is promised money, and they all look for the opportune time to take Jesus. But Matthew provides one salient difference: Matthew includes that the agreed price for Judas’ assistance is thirty pieces of silver. Matthew is the only gospel to claim to reveal how much Judas received for his assistance. My first aim will be to determine the historicity of this figure: was thirty pieces of silver the amount agreed upon for Judas’ assistance? If not, we will then discuss Matthew’s motives for including ‘thirty pieces of silver.’ We will discuss two main possible motives: 1) he created the figure in order to allude to slave prices in Exod. 21.32, and/or 2) he created the figure in order to allude to the rejected shepherd motif in Zech. 11.12–13.
The question of whether thirty pieces of silver is the historical amount of money received by Judas for his assistance has received little attention by scholarship. Matthew’s inclusion of the figure ‘thirty pieces of silver’ does not pass any of the historical criteria such as the criteria of embarrassment, multiple attestation, or prophecy historicized. An analysis of contemporary papyrological evidence shows that first-century slave prices were much more complicated and varied than the simple figure of thirty pieces of silver. If Matthew did intend for Jesus to be sold for the price of a slave then such a price is nothing to scoff at. An analysis of Matthew’s use of Zechariah especially in his passion narrative shows that Matthew builds his passion narrative around Zechariah’s prophecies. After an analysis of Hebrew Bible slave prices and first-century slave prices from documentary papyri and literary sources, I conclude that this figure is not historical and that Jesus is not being depicted as a slave but the figure was inserted by Matthew to allude to Zech 11 and to depict the chief priests as wicked shepherds and Jesus as the good shepherd.
|
The Archaeology of the Returnees: Forts, Estates, and Settlement Patterns in the Territories of the Former Kingdom of Judah
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Avraham Faust, Bar-Ilan University
The territories of the former kingdom of Judah were only sparsely settled during the Persian period, as exemplified by the extreme rarity of domestic structures unearthed in excavations. Viewed against this background, the large number of excavated forts and isolated administrative buildings from this period is remarkable, and they apparently outnumber the period's excavated dwellings. Not only is this an extremely unlikely situation, but various lines of evidence, pertaining to specific sites as well as to the phenomenon as a whole, render the possibility that all these structures were forts or administrative buildings extremely implausible. Consequently, this article reexamines the phenomenon within the social landscape of the region in particular, and of the Achaemenid empire in general, in an attempt to embed those unique buildings within the broader demographic and political reality of this time. Given the location of many of the sites and the finds unearthed in them, and in light of the demographic reality in the region and of the broader Achaemenid imperial policy, the article suggests that most of the so-called forts were estates, created in the process of the resettlement of this previously devastated region. The study of these structures, therefore, enables us to assess the phenomenon of the "returnees" within the broader imperial context, and for the first time to examine the life of these communities.
|
The Sahidic Version of the Corpus Ieremiae
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Frank Feder, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
The Sahidic translation is the oldest translation of the Corpus Ieremiae. The paper offers an overview over the translation technique and the text critical value of Jeremiah and the associated books (Lam, EpJer, Bar)
|
Mother Zion "Speaking Her Truth" in Biblical Poetry
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Sarah E.G. Fein, Brandeis University
Much ink has been spilt on the effect of the personification of Zion and/or Jerusalem as a woman in the poetry of the Hebrew Bible. However, less attention has been paid to the moments when Zion/Jerusalem (hereafter referred to as simply “Zion”) speaks in the first person on her own behalf. Instances of Zion speaking for herself are scattered throughout the books of the Prophets and the Writings, where she speaks either to herself, or to the LORD. In this paper, I argue that Zion’s direct speech is reminiscent of the direct speech of other women in the Hebrew Bible. As Edward L. Greenstein argues, direct speech intensifies the emotional impact of the quotation because it recalls features of epic poetry such as the use of the “historic present” and parallelism, and thus lends what is being said a theatrical tenor.
Because Zion is often personified as a mother, her speech appears to draw on the language and imagery contained in the speech of other mothers in the Hebrew Bible. This paper will argue that these poetic speeches draw upon the language of the suffering mothers in biblical narratives for the purpose of highlighting the emotional impact of Zion’s speeches in the Prophets and the Writings. In part I of this paper, I will analyze the cries of three suffering mothers in biblical narrative: Rebecca’s outcry during her difficult pregnancy in Gen. 25:22, Rachel’s lament over her barrenness in Gen. 30:1, and Hannah’s desperate prayer for children in 1 Sam. 1:10-11. In part II, I will put in conversation the speech of those three mothers and the moments where Zion speaks in the books of Jeremiah, Isaiah, and Lamentations. My focus will specifically be on a) the use of the language of barrenness and bereavement; b) calling a male authority to “look” and “remember”; c) physical suffering in pregnancy and labor. Ultimately, I will conclude that the direct discourse of Zion in Jeremiah, Isaiah, and Lamentations functions to convey to readers the full, raw, and uncensored experience of a suffering metaphorical “mother.”
|
Whole Bodies, Hollow Spaces: Women’s Health and Pregnancy in Paul’s Apocalyptic Eschatology
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Alexis Felder, Boston University
The embodied experience of labor pains and parturition captured the imaginations of male authors of apocalyptic eschatology as they envisioned how the eschaton might occur. These writers, like the apostle Paul, while critical of the present state of the world, were not isolated from it; rather, as active participants in the broader culture, their discussions, visions, and fantasies that relate to the pregnant body are best understood within the literary and material context of the Roman Empire. This paper seeks to locate Paul’s apocalyptic images of pregnancy and childbearing in his letter to the Romans within the cultural context of the Roman Empire by foregrounding his participation in a broad discourse concerning women’s bodies and their health. Literary and material evidence (votives and amulets) illustrate the centrality of fecundity and childbearing to women and their families. Reproduction was a cultural imperative achieved, at least in part, by means of appeals to the divine for bodily health.
Medical writers addressed women’s health by associating wellness with the ability to become pregnant. In the ancient world, a pregnant woman was a healthy woman. Medical authors and Paul alike describe female bodies as hollow spaces that are anatomically inferior to male bodies. The female body collected excesses in their hollow spaces which were evacuated monthly through menstruation, but those excesses could also be useful in reproduction, providing the generative material necessary to conceive and nourish a fetus. Male bodies, however, were impenetrable, collecting no excess and requiring no menstruation. Pregnancy filled the hollow space inside a woman’s body and used the excesses it naturally accumulated, allowing it to function more like a male body without the need for menstruation. Pregnancy or breast feeding that caused the temporary cessation of menstruation was viewed as healthful in so much as it allowed the female body to approach the masculine standard of wholeness.
Paul participates in this socio-medical discourse by subverting the notion that pregnancy equates to health for women. In his letter of introduction to the church in Rome, he outlines his apocalyptic program using the image of a pregnant woman nearing the moment of parturition. His tone is hopeful, and yet his letter emphasizes the “futility,” “bondage,” and “decay” of the maternal body of creation that “waits with eager longing for the revealing of the children of God” (Rom 8:19-21). Paul’s image blends concepts of sin and domination into the image of the pregnant woman as he uses the pregnant body to stand in for the corrupt creation that can only be redeemed by the power of God. Contextually, moreover, he works against the prevailing notion that pregnancy makes women healthy. In Paul’s discussion, pregnancy does not equate to health; it signifies the depth of degradation, but the reproductive female body remains useful to him rhetorically as a fundamental point of connection between humanity and the divine and between the present and future. The future he envisions, however, seems to be a future without women and without the need for pregnancy and reproduction.
|
Joshua Traditions in the Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Transmission of Traditions in the Second Temple Period
Ariel Feldman, Brite Divinity School (TCU)
Indebted to the recent scholarship on Joshua in the Dead Sea scrolls, this paper seeks to illuminate three texts concerned with Joshua and his book. One of these is 4QJosha frag. 21. Its right margin preserves traces of letters which until now have not been plausibly deciphered. Next, the paper addresses two passages which are rarely invoked in Qumran scholarship on Joshua. The first one is a passage from the final column of 4QNumb apparently juxtaposing Num 27 and 36. The otherwise unattested addition preceding the running text of Num 36:5-7 mentions Joshua along with the High Priest Eleazar. The second text is 4Q368 1. This fragment cites Exod 33:11-13, yet seemingly omits the second part of v. 11 referring to Joshua. The paper explores these two passages in light of other texts, where, unlike in MT, Joshua is either present or absent. As a conclusion, it attempts to place these three texts within the broader landscape of Joshua texts and traditions from Qumran.
|
A Neo-documentary Approach to Numbers 32
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Liane Feldman, New York University
(no abstract)
|
A Hermeneutic Dialogue: Popular Reading of the Bible and Feminist Hermeneutics Critical of Liberation
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Isabel Felix, Centro de Estudos Sociais-Universidade de Coimbra
The central objective of this paper is to establish a dialogue between the hermeneutic method of the Popular Reading of the Bible developed by CEBI-Center for Biblical Studies - Brazil and the Feminist Critical Liberation Hermeneutics articulated by Elisabeth Schüssler Fiorenza. From this dialogue between the two methods of interpretation of the Bible, the conclusion is reached that the first one, despite being defined as an approach of popular and liberating biblical interpretation, ends up presenting some shortcomings in relation to the objective that it intends to concretize . The absence of an analytical tool that allows the concrete transformation of socio-religious realities, of the experiences of the subjects of the interpretation, stands out here. In this sense, the dialogue with the critical feminist hermeneutics of liberation may be important for a re-evaluation of the political-methodological project of the popular reading of the Bible proposed by CEBI.
|
Itinerancy and the Question of Jesus' Relationship to John the Baptist
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Tucker S. Ferda, Pittsburgh Theological Seminary
The question of Jesus' relationship to John the Baptist has been high stakes for historical Jesus scholarship. The reason is that the nature of Jesus’ relation to John is often thought to be one of the clearest points of evidence as to Jesus' intentions. J.D. Crossan and Dale Allison can be taken to represent the extremes of opinion here: Allison reconstructs Jesus as an eschatological prophet by closely linking the message of Jesus to that of John, while Crossan distances Jesus from John to depict a non-apocalyptic sage of subversive wisdom.
The question of the "continuity" or "discontinuity" between Jesus and John could benefit from a close look at Jesus' itinerancy. Scholars have tended to approach the question of Jesus's relationship with John on the assumption that there really is "an answer" about what it was: Jesus and John really were related in one particular way or another. This may be helpful for considering Jesus' indebtedness to John in terms of message, but it overlooks the reality that Jesus ministered to different audiences in different settings and must have interacted with persons who would not have known of his relationship to John (whatever that may have been). In fact, many of Jesus' utterances about the Baptist make the most sense as attempts to clarify the nature of his relationship to John. Approaching the question of Jesus' relationship to John through the lens of itinerancy leads to a striking conclusion: the kinds of questions about Jesus’ relationship to John that dominate current Jesus research (continuous, discontinuous, and everything in between) were probably also going around during the ministry of Jesus.
|
Re-evangelizing the Church: Faithful “Others” and “Outsiders” in the Gospel of Mark
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Tucker S. Ferda, Pittsburgh Theological Seminary
Some have thought that the Gospel of Mark evidences sectarian tendencies with statements like this: “To you (the Twelve and other disciples) has been given the mystery of the kingdom of God, but to those on the outside everything comes in parables…” (4:11). When this verse is read in its larger narrative context, however, a striking paradox emerges: the Twelve disciples, the quintessential “insiders,” are often foiled in faith and obedience by unnamed “outsiders.” Indeed, it is Peter’s mother-in-law who “serves” (1:31), it is the man possessed by legion who becomes the first evangelist to the Gentiles (5:20), and it is the hemorrhaging woman who is commended for her “faith” (5:34). This paper suggests that the intended impact of this portrait of Jesus and the disciples was precisely to deconstruct any kind of sectarian identity that would highlight the superior righteousness of the “insiders” vis a vis the world. The Gospel of Mark points to the faithfulness of God to create and sustain the believing community and contends that God is at work in the most unsuspecting persons and places (from this community’s perspective). In this respect, the Gospel of Mark can serve as a biblical model for inclusion and building bridges between insiders and outsiders. The paper will draw implications for contemporary Churches divided along political and ideological lines in the United States.
|
Staging Bíos: A Diegetic and Mimetic Analysis of Speech in the Gospels within the Biographical Tradition
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Matthew Wade Ferguson, University of California-Irvine
By analyzing the role of narrator and dialogue in the New Testament Gospels, this paper will compare their mimetic narrative techniques with the fictional tone of biographies like the Life of Aesop, while contrasting the historical tone of biographers like Plutarch and Suetonius, drawing attention to how the two styles of biography achieve characterization. Whereas biographies of a historical tone are more prone to “tell” (diegesis) a man’s character, by interjecting judgements in the author’s own voice, the Gospels “show” (mimesis) their central character, by staging Jesus in dialogue.
When distinguishing the Gospels from the writings of ancient historiography, Auerbach (2003: 46) notes their “numerous face-to-face dialogues” as a point of contrast to how “direct discourse is restricted in the antique historians to great continuous speeches.” The use of dialogue in ancient historiography was rare, with a historian like Thucydides including it only twice in his entire narrative (3.113; 5.84-116). The latter instance of the Melian Dialogue is such an exception to Thucydides’ narratological technique that Dionysius of Halicarnassus in On the Language of Thucydides (37) emphasizes how Thucydides begins by summarizing the exchange in reported speech (διηγηµατικóν), but then “dramatizes” (δραματίζει) the narrative through dialogue.
Although the Gospels are shorter and focused more on the life of a single individual than the broader scope of historians like Thucydides, scholars such as Burridge (2004) have identified the Gospels with the genre of ancient biography. Speech patterns in biography are more diverse than in historiography, but the role of dialogue generally bears a connection with that of narrator. The biographies of authors like Plutarch and Suetonius are told by a first-person, authorial narrator, who often interjects his own judgements and experiences into the narrative. The narratology of these biographies is not anonymous, whereas the Gospels--particularly Mark and Matthew--are anonymously told by a third-person, external narrator. Other anonymously narrated biographies include the Life of Aesop. The frequent use of dialogue, narrated within historico-geographical settings, is chiefly a characteristic of anonymous biographies, and it pertains to their fictional rather than historical tone.
Rhetorica ad Herennium (1.13) uses the Latin "argumentum"--a word associated with comedy--as the term for “fiction” to distinguish it from "historia." Theatre is characterized by mimetic narrative techniques, in which dialogue is performed in direct discourse. Fictional writing, such as the ancient novel, resembles theatre in part because of an emphasis on dialogue. Diegetic narrative, however, is more characteristic of history, in which conversation is “reported” more than “shown.” Historiography is likewise characterized by first-person narration (Baum 2008), and the presence of the authorial narrator is central to how historians diegetically report discourse and events. The diegetic narrative techniques of biographers like Plutarch and Suetonius--particularly in their first-person narration and tendency to eschew dialogue--are distinct from the mimetic narrative techniques of the Gospels, which are replete with anonymously narrated dialogues. In this respect, biographers like Plutarch and Suetonius exhibit a greater affinity with historiography, whereas anonymous biographies like the Gospels align more with the novel.
|
Working Girls: Subverting the Master Narrative of Judges
Program Unit: Joshua-Judges
Danna Nolan Fewell, Drew University
The master narrative of the book of Judges, inscribed in its formulaic framework, presses the collective character Israel into “Deuteronomistic” service. The people, in concert, repeatedly follow gods other than Yhwh, suffer divine punishment in the form of enemy oppression, cry out in repentance, and are rescued by divinely appointed deliverers who secure rest for the land. The plot plagiarizes itself multiple times solidifying Israel’s identity as an obtuse people whose destiny is to exemplify an uncomplicated, streamlined mechanics of history: the good, faithful, innocent, repentant are rewarded; the unfaithful are punished. This is a master narrative that constricts, chafes, and ultimately cannot corral historical reality. When the women and children of Judges seize control of its script, they refuse to work for the Deuteronomist’s cause. Rejecting predetermined plots, they turn their narrative labor toward exposing a different world view, one in which human and divine characters are neither predictable nor reliable, and suffering and survival have little to do with theological fidelity.
|
Philological Fervour and the Myth of an Alexandrian Revision of the corpus Paulinum
Program Unit: Book History and Biblical Literatures
Gregory Fewster, University of Toronto
Genealogical method, in its various forms, has been a mainstay of textual criticism. Genealogical critics establish the original form of a text by constructing lineages of manuscript descent on the basis of their variant profiles, positing archetypal recensions that originated divergent manuscript types, groups, and families. One of the signal developments of twentieth-century textual criticism of the New Testament in general, and the corpus Paulinum in particular, has been the hypothesis of a philologically-rigorous early recension occurring in Alexandria, a recension widely viewed as virtually equivalent to the original text (Westcott and Hort 1881) or at least the next-best thing (Kenyon 1940). Concerning this recension, Gunther Zuntz made the claim that its textual character betrays the work, not of the “believer or the theologian,” but of someone with “at least a touch of the philological mind” (1953: 275). This paper interrogates the genealogical quest for the origin of the Alexandrian recension, with particular attention to how scholars distance the work of critical edition from the domain of “religion” and religious motivation. The paper argues first that such characterizations implicitly formulate ancient criticism in the image of the modern desire for text-critical disinterest or objectivity as the preferred mode of operation, and second, that (with reference to Egyptian manuscripts of the corpus Paulinum) ancient Alexandrian “philological fervour” included critical commitments that can productively be considered “religious.” Although the notion of an Alexandrian recension has met with some criticism since the work of Zuntz (e.g., Fee 1974), the construction of a distinction between theologically-motivated textual editing and alterations of a more banal and mechanistic kind continues to find traction in the wake of the text-critical work of Bart Ehrman (2001). This present state of affairs recommends the proposed line of research.
|
Shenoute's Jews: Rhetoric and Reality in Late Ancient Egypt
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Emanuel Fiano, Fordham University
This paper discusses the fourth-to-fifth-century Egyptian archimandrite Shenoute of Atripe's violent dealings with Judaism in his Discourses, as well as the rhetorical tenor and historical context of these operations. In an essay titled Shenoute and the Jews, David Brakke has opened the path for an investigation of his treatment of Judaism. Brakke argued that Shenoute's Jews work mainly as models of lack of belief in Christ, and that the abbot never concerned himself with, or intended to warn his audience against, living Jews. While Brakke's contribution focuses on The Lord Thundered and God Says Through Those Who Are His, the present study departs from an examination of the thus-far untranslated homily Blessed Are They Who Observe Justice (Discourses 4.9; Chassinat, É.-G., Le Quatrième Livre des Entretiens et Épîtres de Shenouti. Cairo: IFAO 1911, 126-153). On the one hand, it reevaluates the question of Shenoute's acquaintance with flesh-and-blood Jewry based on the scanty extant epigraphic evidence about the latter's persistence in post-Constantinian-era Upper Egypt. On the other hand, it propose that the possibility of Shenoute's acquaintance with Jewish writings should not be discarded a priori, in light of the references to Jewish literature displayed by fourth- and fifth-century authors from the nearby town of Panopolis such as Zosimus and Nonnus.
|
Bandits and the Galilean Economy: Was It Prosperous or Desperately Poor?
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
David A. Fiensy, Independent Scholar
Several historians, including New Testament scholars, have noted that banditry was/is a form of social protest. They usually conclude that banditry and piracy arise when the economy falls. But in recent studies, historians and sociologists have observed that banditry is more a phenomenon of the “in-between” economies. Banditry does not usually take place in the worst, most chaotic societies nor does it thrive in well-run governments and booming economies. In between these extremes banditry and piracy flourish. In places of extreme want, there are few to rob. In chaotic governments, there are no clear authorities to oppose. Bandits need, for instance, the banks to survive in order to rob them. It follows then that a society with a swarm of banditry and piracy is doing moderately well. It is not an extremely poor society. I hope to establish in this paper that if Galilee was awash in bandits in the first century CE, it was a society of moderate economic success.
|
Rekindling the Fire: Fear of Jewish Sacrifice in Late Antique Syrian Antioch
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Ari Finkelstein, University of Cincinnati
We are used to thinking of Jewish sacrifice as a ritual lost and then reinterpreted by Jews and Christians after the destruction of the Jerusalem temple in 70 CE. Yet in late fourth century Antioch, Jewish animal sacrifice is a topic of renewed interest among pagans and Christians. Writing his Against the Galileans in Antioch in early 363, Emperor Julian claims Jews continue to sacrifice in private and that, contrary to Christian claims that sacrificial meat is impure, such sacrifice remains efficacious, sanctifying the meat Jews eat. By reframing Jewish ritual slaughter, he hopes to convince Judaizing Christians to keep Jewish practices. Julian’s Hellenizing anti-Christian program fails upon his death. But Christian interest in Jewish sacrifice picks up twenty years later in two very different Christian sources written in Antioch. In Against the Jews/Judaizers, John Chrysostom attempts to delegitimize the Jewish festivals of Trumpets, Tabernacles and Passover, festivals celebrated by some Judaizing Christians in Antioch, arguing that these holidays could only be celebrated with sacrifices and only in the Jerusalem temple. Chrysostom uses the absence of the temple and sacrifice to support many of his arguments in this work. But how certain is he that the temple and sacrifice will not return? Here and there we can glimpse doubt. For instance, he goes out of his way to attack any future sacrifice as illegitimate because it would lack the divine fire that lit Solomon’s sacrifice in the first temple (Jud 5.11.7) as well as the veil (Jud 4.7.6) and many other elements. And he clearly spars with Jews and Christians who accept Jewish arguments that the temple will soon be rebuilt. One such Christian, Apollinaris of Laodicea, preaching in Antioch in the late fourth century, looked forward to the imminent rebuilding of the temple and the resumption of sacrifice in Jerusalem. Meanwhile, in the very same decade Chrysostom preached his anti-Jewish homilies, the Apostolic Constitutions was published in Antioch. Its compiler addresses himself to a group of Christians who keep some Jewish law but differentiate themselves from Jews. For this group sacrifice is a Jewish law too far, one they are unwilling to practice (6.25) and thus a line in the sand dividing them from Jews. What was at stake in defining sacrifice as Jewish in late fourth century Antioch? This paper will consider these sources about Jewish sacrifice as a battleground over which pagans and Christians sought to define themselves over and against Jews.
|
An Eighth Century BCE Monumental Podium at Kiriath-jearim in Historical Context: Who Built It and for What Purpose?
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Israel Finkelstein, Tel Aviv University
Recent excavations by a Tel Aviv University—College de France team at the site of Kiriath-jearim west of Jerusalem uncovered evidence for the construction of a monumental elevated podium in the Iron Age. Combining an exact-science method of dating with archaeological considerations, the podium seems to date to the first half of the 8th century BCE. The questions which will be dealt are: who built the podium, when and why. The answers may shed light on the history of the region, the relationship between the kingdoms of Israel and Judah and biblical references to Kiriath-jearim.
|
Getting It Wrong but Getting It Right: Joshua's Prayer in Joshua 7
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
David G. Firth, Trinity College, Bristol
Getting It Wrong but Getting It Right: Joshua's Prayer in Joshua 7
|
Canaanite Genocide and Palestinian Nakba in Conversation: A Postcolonial Exercise in Bi-directional Hermeneutics
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Bruce N. Fisk, Westmont College
For some Zionists and Christian Zionists, the modern state of Israel has reenacted ancient Israel’s Conquest. Both stories include marginalized Jews suffering oppression and threats of genocide. A singular figure emerges to lobby the powers and inspire an exodus. The people cross water to reach their land but it is inhabited. Higher powers authorize the children of Israel to settle there but indigenous peoples feel threatened. War ensues. Jewish victories spread fear. Inhabitants are dispossessed. Jews ultimately control most land and property. A sizeable underclass of non-Jews remains under Jewish control.
Has not the One who fought for Joshua Ben-Nun fought again for David Ben-Gurion? Even secular Ben-Gurion, Israel’s first Prime Minister, recognized the Bible’s potential for shaping his young state’s identity and connecting it to the Land. Ben-Gurion’s favorite book was Joshua, for its catalogue of military exploits and territorial expansion. Beginning in 1958, Ben-Gurion made Joshua’s campaigns the focus of a study group that met in his home, from which he sought to forge a collective Israeli identity rooted in the biblical conquest myth to unite immigrants from around the world.
Noteworthy about Ben-Gurion’s use of the Bible is its bi-directionality. His young army was both expositor and embodiment of Scripture. Ancient text and present reality were mutually illuminating. Zionism was both ideology and hermeneutic. Also notable was his focus on praxis. Interpretation was incomplete without performance. If Joshua was a military manual, only those who had conquered, occupied and settled the Promised Land could grasp its meaning.
If Ben-Gurion read the Conquest with the eyes of the IDF, Palestinian-in-exile Edward Said called in 1986 for reading with the eyes of the Canaanites—with indigene rather than invader. Native American Robert Warrior took up the challenge, as did Michael Prior, Nur Masalha, L. Daniel Hawk and others. Hawk’s 2010 Joshua commentary, for example, amplified subaltern voices and counter-narratives. But although these scholars acknowledge the traumas of the Palestinian Nakba (1948) and Naksa (1967), rarely do they deploy them as hermeneutical lens for reading Joshua.
Following the trajectory set by Edward Said, this paper will read selections of the Conquest narrative not simply with an eye toward Canaanites but with the help of Palestinians—the refugees of 1948 and 1967 who were exiled and orphaned during the war years and who now live in the Diaspora or under Occupation. We cannot ask Canaanites what it is like to plant but not harvest in lower Galilee, to nurture groves but not press olives near Bethlehem, to dig cisterns but not drink water in the West Bank hills, to abandon houses on the plain near Jaffa. But we can ask Palestinians. And when Joshua occasionally lets Canaanites speak (e.g., Rahab, the Gibeonites), Palestinians under Occupation can amplify their voices.
Such an approach, like Ben-Gurion’s, promises to be hermeneutically bi-directional; Joshua and the Nakba/Naksa can be mutually illuminating. It might also caution those content to see both Conquest and Conflict as zero-sum games only one side of which merits our moral consideration.
|
The Function of Aseneth: Her Transformation from an Egyptian Priestess to an Israelite Cultic Figure
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
Katharine Fitzgerald, McMaster University
Joseph and Aseneth, like many other early Jewish texts, assumes that Israelite and gentile identity were both inherent and immutable. However, Aseneth’s transformation is at odds with this worldview, as Aseneth’s identity shifts from an Egyptian priestess to an Israelite cultic figure. The author makes use of a scriptural precedent found in Lev. 8, as Aseneth’s period of change mirrors the eight day transformation of Aaron and his sons in Lev. 8 and Exod. 29:35-37. Aseneth mourns and fasts for seven days and her change in identity is confirmed on the eight day, just as Aaron and his sons cannot be consecrated until they complete the seven day process which is then confirmed on the eight day. This paper will explore how Aseneth is presented and functions as an Egyptian priestess, by focusing on her dress, use of food, idols, and behavior. I will also detail the cultic language used to describe Aseneth’s process of changing identities and her function as an Israelite cultic figure. The main focus of the author of Joseph and Aseneth is Aseneth’s transformation as a means for justifying the marriage of Joseph to the Egyptian Aseneth and to justify the conversion/inclusion of Gentiles, as it is only through the reconstruction of her identity into an Israelite cultic figure that Aseneth is able to marry Joseph.
|
Exodus 15 without the Exodus: Yahweh and the People of the Southern Highlands
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Daniel E Fleming, New York University
Although most of the narrative from Genesis through Kings is devoted to Israel’s distant past, before the time of biblical writing, the project of its application to historical reconstruction is fraught. The most useful material is often what contrasts with the finished Bible, as with the Song of Deborah’s failure to include Judah and the south in its account of battle with “the kings of Canaan.” In the collection of old poetry identified by Albright, Cross, and others, the Song of the Sea in Exodus 15 stood as an independent exodus account, yet its continuity with Jerusalem-oriented poetry in the Psalms and Isaiah 40-55 has led recent European scholars to date it to the 6th century or later. Indeed, the combination of southern geography and shared vocabulary in a hymn to Yahweh suggests composition for Jerusalem worship. Yet the Song’s detail indicates secondary association with the prose exodus narrative rather than inspiration from it, and Jerusalem poetry could be composed during the monarchy.
In fact, Exodus 15’s historical usefulness has been obscured by its reference to Pharaoh and incorporation into the Moses story. Egypt is defeated by an act of God, Yahweh himself sinking its chariotry as they were transported across a body of water. Yahweh’s own people, named nowhere in the Song, are not present for the catastrophe that opens the southern highlands for their occupation. While the Song may well have been composed in monarchic Jerusalem, it shows no interest in its institutions or Davidic heritage, instead hearkening back to a time before these. For reconstruction of history, of greatest significance is the combination of Egypt’s removal and identification of the beneficiaries only as “your people, Yahweh” (v 16), a phrasing much like “the people of Yahweh” who unite in battle in the Song of Deborah (Judg 5:13). We are left to explore the historical significance of two early biblical texts, south and north, that recount formative events for “people” defined by relation to Yahweh in a time before kings.
|
What Are Amorites Doing in the Bible?
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Daniel E. Fleming, New York University
Biblical accounts of Israel’s origins imagine a land without dominant kingdoms, where diverse peoples represented by Hebrew plurals were more significant than cities, excepting Sodom and Gomorrah as famously gone. The names of these peoples appear alone and in combinations that include lists of those to be replaced by Israel. In historical context as currently known, these peoples include names from the Bronze Age, many centuries before their biblical use: Canaanites, Amorites, Hittites, and perhaps Horites as Hurrians. All of these are surprising, and we are left to wonder how such old labels found their way into the Bible’s distant past. The Hittites may be most straightforward now that we know about Hatti’s Iron Age survival in its Syrian vestiges. Canaan was one way to name Egypt’s New Kingdom holdings in the Levant, however such a notion of the land before Israel survived into texts from the mid-first millennium.
The Amorites are more difficult. Already by the early second millennium, use of the term in cuneiform sources appears secondary to the earlier Amorite population as a community bound to pastoralism. There was already a specific “land” southeast of Ugarit; and this term could name the entire West Semitic language contrasted to Akkadian. There is no reason to name the peoples of the Middle Bronze Age Levant as Amorites in any literal sense. Yet some version of such secondary use was recalled as appropriate to the land before Israel, as with the Canaanites and the Hittites. It is possible that the Amorite name attached itself especially to regions associated with old-time pastoralism, as perceived in much later periods, such as the Transjordan people of Sihon. Any answers must be cast in terms of a self-conscious notion, not to explain by “memory,” of separation between an idealized early Israel and its antecedents.
|
The Ritual Practice of Christian Meals and New Testament Textual Variants
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
Tobias Flemming, Technische Universität Dresden
This paper presents the results of the network “Meal and Text” concerning the relation of the changes in the ritual practice of Christian meals on the one hand and the formation of textual variants in the New Testament on the other hand. The focus will be on central meal texts like Lk 22 as well on passages less in spotlight. Thereby, it will become apparent that the methodologically conscious merging of textual criticism and the research of the transition from banquet to Eucharist opens new insights for both fields.
|
Were Galilean Synagogues the Sitz-im-Leben for the Palestinian Targums to the Pentateuch? An Inquiry into the Archaeological Evidence
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Paul Flesher, University of Wyoming
Thanks to the discoveries of Targum fragments in the Cairo Geniza and of Targum Neofiti at the Vatican, we now possess the remains of more than 40 different versions of the Palestinian Targums of the Pentateuch. All of these were written in Jewish Palestinian Aramaic, a dialect centered in greater Galilee, and this large number of manuscripts suggests they were popular and widely used.
The question remains, however, for what activity were these Targums used? Early rabbinic literature equivocates. On the one hand, rabbinic dicta state that Aramaic translation should accompany Sabbath Torah reading. On the other hand, they forbid the presence of written translations in that very ritual. Several scholars, including myself, have addressed this conundrum by developing circumstantial scenarios which see rabbinic injunctions against public Targum use being ignored or which suggest that Targums were delivered from memory. These schemes have been difficult to verify or falsify.
It is time to bring a new source of evidence to address this question, that of the synagogues in which the rite of Torah reading and translation took place. This paper will examine the archaeological remains of two Galilean synagogues—Beth Alpha and Nabratein—to determine how this ritual would have been performed in the architectural space they provided. A simple question will direct the exploration of how the architectural features built into the synagogue halls shaped ritual performance. That question is, where would the reader and the translator have stood? The answer will provide insight into the ritual Sitz-im-Leben of Aramaic translation in these synagogues and into the role of written Targums within it.
|
Voice in the Greek of the New Testament
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Bryan W. Y. Fletcher, McMaster Divinity College
As the category of deponency in recent years has been the leading cause of a “paradigm shift” taking place in studies on the ancient Greek voice system, new avenues have opened up for further remodeling of the voice system. This study contends that verbal voice is based on the distinctive roles the subject plays in the clause and operates according to an ergative two-voice system, active and middle. Principles of Systemic Functional Linguistics (SFL), in particular, the transitive and ergative models, based on the theories of linguist, Michael Halliday, are applied in this study. These two models broaden out the notion of transitivity by fitting together semantics and syntax more precisely since transitivity of the clause, according to Halliday, is “concerned with the type of process expressed in the clause, with the participants in this process, animate and inanimate, and with various attributes and circumstances of the process and the participants.”
Within a nominative-accusative marking pattern which forms the syntactic basis for the Greek of the New Testament, ergative functions centered on verbal voice are present in the language’s verbal morphology and syntax. An ergative view of voice focuses on the element of the clause that realizes or actualizes the verbal process. This enables clearer expression of the subject’s function in the clause by distinguishing between two opposing roles: the subject functioning either as undergoer of the process (actualization) or as agent (cause) of the process. Since there are only two basic roles of the subject for voice, therefore, there are only two voices and the traditional passive voice no longer stands as a third voice that is separate from the active and middle voices despite the occurrence of three morphological forms in the aorist and future tense-forms. Passivity is subsumed entirely within the middle voice in all tense-forms whereby the subject actualizes the verbal process but with an added feature of external agency to the clause. Moreover passivity is expressed by specific grammatical constructions within the middle voice that operate as agentive augmentations (specified or not) of a middle clause. The so-called ‘passive’ marker, -(θ)η-, shares much in common with the functions of the middle voice markers as the -(θ)η- form was encroaching upon middle forms during this stage of the language and gradually expanding its range of function in the New Testament.
|
Mary Magdalene (2018): Perspectives on the Female-Focused Screen
Program Unit: Bible and Film
Michelle Fletcher, King's College London
There seems to be nothing new that can be shown in a Jesus film, yet somehow Mary Magdalene (2018, dir. Garth Davis) does offer a fresh perspective: a woman’s. Indeed, through stunning cinematography and subtle scripting, this film re-inscribes the female reality into the Jesus story in a way that is seldom seen. This women’s-eye perspective is the focus of this co-presented paper.
We will bring into dialogue two feminist perspectives on the film, based on our experience: as a historian who was one of the film’s advisors and as a Bible and film scholar. In doing so, we will examine the tensions involved in making and viewing this female-focused Jesus film.
After an overview of the history of the cinematic Mary Magdalene, outlining her previous guises, we will detail the vision of this specific portrayal, asking where this film sits in light of these past visualisations. We will then move to discussing the making of the film, revealing the practicalities of being an expert advisor during production, with particular attention to the details of portraying female-focused ancient-world narratives. Versions before the ‘final cut’ will be discussed, as will debates during production. The collective dimensions of filmmaking will also be brought to the fore, highlighting the key women of the production team.
From the perspective of film criticism, we will be asking where this portrayal sits amongst contemporary trends and past filmic inheritance. In particular, the ‘woman’s picture’ aspect of the film will be discussed, and we will question whether this 2018 production of Mary Magdalene has as much in common with the domestic interiors of Douglas Sirk and Yasujiro Ozu as it does Pasolini’s Gospel According to St. Matthew. Throughout the paper, both presenters will draw on their conversations with the film’s development lead and script writer, as well as with others after the film’s release, providing a window into the thinking behind what we see on screen. This will lead them to topics as diverse as embroidery, Judas’s smile, menstruation, the Gospel of Mary, and Todd Haynes.
|
Inventing Christian Piety: Euelpistus in the Acts of Justin and Companions
Program Unit: Inventing Christianity: Apostolic Fathers, Apologists, and Martyrs
Michael Flexsenhar III, Rhodes College
This paper investigates the Acts of Justin and Companions (Rec. B), the purported martyrdom account of Justin Martyr (c. 165 CE). It explains how in the aftermath of the Edict of Decius (250 CE) editors reworked the earlier version of the Acts of Justin (Rec. A) and refashioned the character Euelpistus as a martyred “slave of Caesar.” The editors did so to redefine Christian piety as an exclusive activity—a piety not to be shared with the Roman gods. To show how the text accomplishes its goal the paper draws from studies on Roman slavery, Roman household rituals, and inscriptions that imperial slaves left behind. The end result is a better understanding of the historical reality against which the new version of the Acts of Justin (Rec B) idealizes and distorts Euelpistus as a martyred slave of Caesar.
|
The Many Genres of al-Musabbiḥāt
Program Unit: The Qur’an: Surah Studies (IQSA)
Adam Flowers, University of Chicago
Despite similarities in their opening verses, al-Musabbiḥāt (Q 57, 59, 61, 62, and 64) exist as thematically and stylistically distinct texts. Indeed, the opening prayers common to each sura have drastically different literary functions in relation to the following content; these differences in function are created through the varying genre forms that occur in each of ¬al-Musabbiḥāt. Studying how the opening prayers interact with the genre forms that proceed them is an important step in understanding these suras as complex literary wholes. An analysis of the genres employed in al-Musabbiḥāt is not a purely literary exercise, however; a study of how unique genre forms are combined to form the larger unit of the sura can shed light on the historical processes by which Qur'anic suras were composed. This paper will concentrate on the four following questions in an attempt to better understand the composite literary forms of al-Musabbiḥāt and, ultimately, use these insights to illuminate the process of collection and compilation of the Qur'ān text: What are the component genres of each of al-Musabbiḥāt? What is the relationship of the opening sabbaḥa verses with these genre forms? How can we characterize each of the individual al-Musabbiḥāt as complex, secondary genre forms? And, finally, outside of the similar openings, should these suras be considered similar literary objects?
|
Controlling the Narrative: The Babylonian Exile as Chosen Trauma
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
Caralie Focht, Emory University
Who controls the narrative in the event of an exile? The Bible seems to grapple with just that question after the Babylonian exile of a small group of elites from Jerusalem and its surrounding areas. Despite the fact that archeological evidence portrays a limited exile the primarily impacted Jerusalem and only a small number of elites, exile looms large in the biblical texts. Trauma studies of the Bible pick up and takes at face value the traumatic nature of these texts at both the compositional level as well as within the narrative itself. However, further consideration must be given to the gap that remains between the comprehensive and universal trauma of the exile as presented in the biblical text and the fact that there is a continuity of material culture in Judah with the exception of Jerusalem and a few nearby cities. Therefore, this paper deals with the constructed aspect of the biblical trauma narrative that does not necessarily reflect the reality of the majority of Judeans’ lives.
Jeffrey Alexander lays out a social theory of collective trauma wherein meaning in the aftermath of trauma is constructed by the group through symbols that are affectively tied to the trauma, that is, symbols that evoke emotions associated with the trauma. Drawing from Alexander’s work as well as other trauma theorists such as Kali Tal, I will go beyond the work of current biblical trauma scholarship. Rather than accepting the traumatic events that shaped the texts and canon of the Hebrew Bible as the universal Judahite trauma narrative, I will argue that the Babylonian exile as it is portrayed in the biblical text was constructed for two reasons: 1) the people writing/editing the texts were the ones most impacted by the exile and 2) drawing on the exile helped to create a collective national identity. In short, the authors and redactors of the biblical text dealt with the Babylonian exile and eventual return under the Persian empire by creating a new national narrative and passing it on to the collective.
|
How to Deal with Imperfect Dictionaries and Their Possibly Misleading Definitions/Glosses
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Hans Förster, Universität Wien, Universität Wien
John A. L. Lee has argued that definitions are preferable if compared to glosses. This holds true in case that a definition is in accordance with the semantics of the Greek word which is defined in a dictionary. Definitions are, however, a two edged sword: In case that a definition misses the semantics of a Greek word such a definition will mislead the user of a dictionary far more than any gloss. A gloss reminds the reader that the lexical equivalent in the dictionary is a very rough approximation. Thus, any user of a dictionary which is using glosses is forced to deal with the semantics of the source language before creating a rendering in any given target language. In contradistinction a lexical definition creates the impression that all semantic analyses have already been completed successfully.
The presentation will use an example from John’s Gospel which has been deemed a crux interpretum and demonstrate, how erroneous entries in dictionaries are especially misleading in case that they provide a lot of information and / or definitions. The faulty information can, however, be used to understand the text better – if used with care.
|
Tamar’s Transgressive Resistance: Gender Nonconformity in Genesis 38 and the Women’s Protection Unit in the Rojava Conflict
Program Unit: Gender, Sexuality, and the Bible
Conor Q. Foley, Princeton Theological Seminary
Tamar is expected to submit to the erasure and inhumanity of a patriarchal system that interpellates her as the sexual and economic asset of the men who control her. But when Judah fails his basic duty of providing her with an opportunity to conceive, an irresponsibility that would push her to the extreme margins of society, she resists the strictures of gender convention. Tamar assumes an agency typically reserved for men, she takes on work that falls out of the normative binary distribution of labor, she fulfills the patriarchal responsibility of facilitating a sexual encounter and producing progeny, and she seizes the symbol of patriarchal power, authority, and virility by taking Judah’s staff. Various biblical and extra-biblical sources make clear the connection between the penis, power and authority, and the staff which represents this nexus. In resistance to the violence of erasure and exploitation, she “castrates” Judah and uses the power invested in the phallic item for herself, making a way to relative freedom and autonomy through risk and transgression. So too do the women of the Rojava Revolution resist the gender and sexual oppression of the Islamic State of the Levant by taking up weapons, phallic significations of political power and ideological dominance. ISIL has set forth explicit instructions for the behavior of women, replete with punishments for transgressing those boundaries. Their fascist, fundamentalist interpretation of Islam underpins an oppressive gender code which relegates women to “sedentary” life. The military opposition of women in the YPJ is a transgression of gender boundaries with a moral significance, making the consequences of capture dire indeed. But the women of the YPJ, like Tamar, redefine gender in their contexts, destabilizing traditional binaries and risking their bodies for justice. Neither of these parties is advocating for the privilege of the penis or the pistol, but they will use whatever means necessary in the struggle for justice.
|
John 9, the Sense of Hearing, and Belief in Jesus as the Unique Embodiment of God
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Deborah Forger, Dartmouth College
The story of Jesus’ healing of the man-born-blind (John 9), and the subsequent disbelief of the Ioudaioi regarding this man’s ability to receive his sight again, has often been deemed a literary linchpin, a hermeneutical key for unlocking the larger narratival plot of the Gospel. While the followers of Jesus were able to “see,” “confess,” and “believe” in Jesus, the Ioudaioi did not (thus, according to J. Louis Martyn, at the time of the composition of the Gospel, the former were kicked out of the synagogue, cf. John 9:22, 16:2). Yet this privileging of the sense of sight within Gospel 9, and the broader corpus of the Gospel, has long caused scholars to overlook the rich and manifold ways that the other senses play within the fourth Gospel [notable exceptions include D. Lee (2010), M. Warren (2015)]. By invoking the theoretical framework of David Howe’s Empire of the Senses (2005), as well as subsequent scholarship that has led to a ‘sensual revolution’ or a ‘sensual turn’ that has swept its way across the humanities, this paper considers how the other senses—and the sense of hearing in particular—also plays a pivotal role within the Gospel. To do so, it begins with a close reading of John 9:35–38, which describes Jesus as “the speaking one,” and demonstrates how it is in the context of hearing Jesus’s words that the man-born-blind comes to believe. From there it traces other ways that the Gospel stresses the sense of hearing. By employing sensory analysis, this paper demonstrates how Jesus’s speech uniquely renders the God of Israel audible, making the God of Israel accessible in the somatic realm. Because the act of speaking creates sound, and sound becomes perceptible to the sense of hearing, Jesus’s words concretize Israel’s God. Just as Jesus’s physical body is the unique locus by which persons experience God corporeally—enabling them to see (12:45; 14:7–9), to touch (20:27–28), and even to taste God (7:37)—so too his words render God tangible. I argue that attending to the role of the sense of hearing thereby sheds new light on how the Gospel portrays Jesus as the unique embodiment of God (i.e. he is the God who speaks); it also illumines how, through the senses, the Gospel writer presents persons as coming to believe in him.
|
God Made Manifest: Jewish High Priest as Visible Counterpoint to Deified Greco-Roman Emperors?
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Deborah Forger, Dartmouth College
Jews living in the aftermath of the destruction of the Second Temple navigated a world in which their imperial lords peppered the Mediterranean landscape with sculpted images of themselves, oftentimes suggesting that these physical images, and the emperors that stood behind them, functioned as gods in embodied form. This paper considers how these material images (and the emperors who stood behind them) impacted Jews, especially in light of the fact that these same Jews lived under the authority of Rome, yet also served the one God of Israel alone. By analyzing texts such as Josephus’ Ant. 11.302–45, wherein he depicts an encounter between Alexander the Great and the Jewish high priest, as well as ancient artefacts that these emperors, and the Flavians in particular, employed as a means of visual propaganda to convince others of their deification, I explore how the Jewish high priest, especially in light of the strong aniconic tradition in Second Temple Judaism, could have functioned, for Josephus at least, as a visible counterpoint to both these material, sculpted images and the deified emperors who stood behind them. Though clearly not synonymous with the God of Israel, since much of the extant Jewish literature dating to around the turn of the Common Era stresses God’s transcendence and utter inaccessibility, such a reflection on the high priest may offer some insights into how Jews, living around the turn of the Common Era, both responded to Roman hegemony and Roman imperial religion and claimed that they could encounter their God, the God of Israel, in tangible form.
|
The Books of Maccabees in Syriac: A Context for Their Translation
Program Unit: International Syriac Language Project
Philip Forness, Goethe-Universität Frankfurt am Main
The history of the Maccabees exerted a great influence on the Syriac tradition. The four books of Maccabees circulated widely among Syriac communities in antiquity and secured a place in early pandects of the bible. Their narratives shaped Syriac martyrological and historiographical writings as well as art and poetry, and these stories continue to be read in liturgical settings. Studies on the reception of the Maccabean narrative have exposed the importance of the books of Maccabees for the Syriac tradition as a whole.
Yet the impetus for the translation of the four books of Maccabees into Syriac in late antiquity remains poorly understood, as the translation of the four books of Maccabees was undertaken at a later period than most books of the Old Testament. I will address this gap in scholarship by examining the Peshiṭta translation of the four books of Maccabees from two complementary perspectives.
First, I will investigate the textual tradition itself to argue for a fourth-century date for the translation of the four books of Maccabees. A comparison with the Greek text demonstrates connections between the translation of the books of Maccabees and the Lucianic recension of the Greek. A further appraisal of the text of individual books exposes similarities and differences in the translation style.
Second, I will explore the use of the story of the Maccabees in Syriac literature in the fourth and fifth centuries. References to the narrative as well as linguistic allusions support a date of the fourth century for the initial translation of these books. But they also suggest that the translation of the books of Maccabees into Syriac was a product of a wider trend. Christian communities across the Mediterranean World adopted the narrative of the Maccabees for liturgical and exegetical purposes in the course of the fourth century. Syriac communities chose to translate these works for their own use as a part of this cultural movement.
|
Transforming the Literary Heritage of Late Antiquity: A Previously Unknown Letter of Severos of Antioch Preserved in Ethiopic
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Philip Forness, Goethe-Universität Frankfurt am Main
Severos of Antioch (c. 465–538) stands as one of the most celebrated figures in the development of miaphysite or non-Chalcedonian Christology. The Syriac, Coptic, and Ethiopian traditions all honor him as a saint. His works, condemned within his lifetime by the imperial church, primarily survive in Syriac and Coptic translations from late antiquity. Texts from the early Solomonic period attests to Severos’s popularity as a saint and author in Ethiopia.
This presentation explores a previously unidentified letter by Severos in Ethiopic translation as evidence of interconnections between the Ethiopian tradition and the Coptic and Syriac churches. This letter appears in a fourteenth-century collection of homilies and is designated as a homily to be read on the Thursday of Holy Week. This letter is not known in any other language.
The first part of this presentation will situate this letter within its late antique context. The addressee of the letter, Caesaria, was a patrician and from a prominent family. Severos wrote several letters to her, and she appears in both hagiographical and historiographical works. Severos responds in this letter to her exegetical question regarding the origin of evil. The theological nature of this letter matches that in Severos’s correspondence with Caesaria.
The second part of this presentation will examine the transmission and translation of this text into Ethiopic. I will especially consider how this text reflects a broader trend in the transmission of Severos of Antioch’s works into Ethiopic in the early Solomonic period. At least four other works by Severos were translated into Ethiopic around this time and became part of liturgical collections. A life of Severos survives in Ethiopic from around the year 1400, and he found a place in the Ethiopic collection of saints lives known as the Sənkəssar.
This letter thus represents an important discovery for late antique Christianity as well as for understanding the Ethiopian tradition’s understanding of its relationship to other Christian communities.
|
Reconsidering the Death of Saul: Just What Was He Afraid of?
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Cara M. Forney, Baylor University
The lone narrative dedicated to Saul in Chronicles tells the story of his self-inflicted death (also found in 1 Sam 31). Within this passage, Saul asks his armor-bearer to run him through with his sword so that the Philistines (the “uncircumcised”) would not come and “abuse him” or “deal harshly” with him. A study of the verb used in this passage (עלל) reveals a wide semantic range, yet modern translations obscure the connotation of “penetration” or “entering” that the root carries. I propose a paper arguing that the Chronicler includes this Saulide narrative due to the presence of sexualized violence contained in the language and imagery of the passage. The presentation of this narrative depicts Saul’s humiliating, feminized death in contrast with the Chronicler’s hyper-masculinized idealization of David. This paper first pursues a word study of עלל, concluding that the verb—particularly in the Hithpoel form—conveys the notion of inserting or penetrating, as well as the connotation of abuse or harm. It then explores the use of rape imagery in the Hebrew Bible, concluding that while there is no one word or set of terms used to depict rape, there is a consistent constellation of language and imagery used to convey such scenarios. In the second section, the study applies the conclusions of the first section directly to the death of Saul narrative to demonstrate that what Saul fears from the “uncircumcised” is more akin to sodomy or rape than mere “harsh treatment.” The third section explores masculinity and femininity in the Hebrew Bible and the motif of feminization as a form of humiliation in the ancient Near East. Drawing on these concepts, the narrative of Saul’s death presents a feminized, humiliated Saul. This evidence leads to the conclusion that the narrative of Saul is presented by the Chronicler specifically as a foil for a hyper-masculine, militarily successful David, while still maintaining the inclusion of the tribe of Benjamin within the Yehudite community. Finally, this paper discusses the necessity for interpreters and translators to convey the full imagery of passages such as 1 Chr 10//1 Sam 31 in order to depict the power struggles and dynamics at play.
|
The Church of the Martyrs: A North African Tradition, c. 250–500
Program Unit: Contextualizing North African Christianity
Eric Fournier, West Chester University of Pennsylvania
In the town of Thambaia, in the 480s, two Nicene brothers were being tortured by Vandals. As they encouraged each other to persevere in enduring their suffering for Christ, one of them proclaimed: “Unleash whatever suffering you like, and torment the Christians with cruel punishments: what my brother will do, I shall do as well” (Vict. Vit. Hist. Pers. 3.28; trans. Moorhead, 75). Rather than an accurate depiction of what was happening “on the ground” during the Vandal period, this (imaginative) passage, in which a Nicene tells a Homoian Christian to “torment the Christians,” is in fact representative of a widespread coping strategy by Nicene Christians. By alluding to Christian texts from the earlier Roman persecutions of Christians (Tert., Apol. 2: “Christianus sum”), by casting Vandals as the new persecutors, and by implicitly presenting them as non-Christians who persecute Christians, Victor of Vita is here refashioning the identity of both Christians and Vandals as, respectively, persecuted and persecutors. Victor, in this regard, is representative of the Nicene response to the Vandal occupation of North Africa, which consisted mainly in understanding their present as a repetition of past persecutions. Indeed, Nicene texts of the Vandal period multiply borrowings and allusions from the likes of Cyprian, Tertullian, Lactantius, and other texts describing earlier persecutions. It is the argument of this paper that in depicting themselves as the latest Church of the Martyrs, these authors participated in what seems to have been the dominant form of Christian identity in North Africa.
Of course, in addition to the Roman persecution of Christians, North African Christians also experienced their own internal struggle with so-called Donatists. What is striking to the external observer is the similarities between the coping strategies of Christians facing Roman persecutions, Donatists facing what they considered as persecution by Nicene Christians, and Nicene Christians under Vandal rule. Perhaps the clearest example of these parallels between Donatists and Nicenes of the Vandal period is the similarities between their resistance strategies at the councils of 411 and 484. A close reading of both councils reveals that Nicenes seem to have deployed the same delaying tactics as Donatists had in hopes of avoiding a theological debate they could not win (proving the ‘homoousios’ from Scriptures). Both Donatists and Nicenes under Vandal rule depicted secular power as controlled by the Devil, and thereby attacking its legitimacy to rule in a Christian world. The flip side of this posturing was to present themselves as the Church of the Martyrs, which implicitly meant that they were on the side of truth and orthodoxy in this polarized world. In depicting their experiences in this particular light, as a repetition of past persecutions, authors of the Vandal period joined their predecessors in continuing a North African tradition that opposed theological enemies with the language of martyrdom and persecution, and that cast their identity as the Church of the Martyrs.
|
The Community of the Curious: Curiosity as Disposition Leading to Idolatry
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Stephen E. Fowl, Loyola University Maryland
The Community of the Curious: Curiosity as Disposition Leading to Idolatry
|
Philo of Alexandria and Sex with Pretty Little Slave Girls
Program Unit: Slavery, Resistance, and Freedom
Kenneth Fox, University of Calgary
Philo describes attending sumptuous feasts. When he takes self-mastery with him, he bridles the impetuous rush of his passions, but when he leaves reason at home, the enjoyments enslave him. He confesses to overeating and overdrinking. But then, unexpectedly, he mentions sex (Leg. 3.155-156). Philo divides humanity into three categories. The wise are so rare (Leg. 1.102) I set them aside. At the other end is the vast multitude of people. These worthless people are dead to the life of virtue (Somn. 2.235-237) and indulge the flesh at banquets. But what about the progressing person (Leg. 1.93; QG 4.54), how might this person behave? For Philo, passions for food, drink, and sex, although not good, work according to laws of nature (Opif. 3; Contempl. 59). He says god-loving souls (QG 3.4) will satisfy their passions at banquets, but only to the extent useful and necessary and will not overindulge beyond measure (Leg. 3.155-156). Leg. 3.155-156 makes me ask: does Philo have no problem with followers of Moses having their useful and necessary sexual needs satisfied at these parties by the pretty little slave girls (Prob. 38) offered to guests, just so long as they do not overindulge beyond measure? I outline Philo’s attitude toward slavery. Philo says slavery is irrelevant and ought to be a matter of indifference to slaves. But slavery is not irrelevant to slave owners, as Philo says, “The course of life contains a vast number of circumstances which demand the ministrations of slaves” (Spec. 2.123). I briefly discuss how Philo’s attitudes toward the human body, sexuality, women, and ethics bear on my question. With this in hand, I give a Philonic reading of Exodus 21.7-11 which gives a father total power to sell his daughter to another man, knowing the child’s body will be used for sexual gratification. Children proved excellent commodities for trade and profit. In the conclusion, with a glance at Pericles, Euripides, and Aristotle’s anonymous opponents of slavery, I explore whether Philo experienced anxiety and uncertainty about how slavery, “the most degrading and exploitative institution invented by man” (Peter Garnsey), was parasitic.
|
Leadership in the Damascus Document and Related Texts
Program Unit: Qumran
Steven D. Fraade, Yale University
An exploration of the variety of communal leadership roles in the Yahad, as expressed in the Damascus Document and related texts. Particular attention will be paid to the roles of the Mevaqqer and the Maskil in relation to one another and their possible development over time, as well as for their social implications.
|
The Evolution of the Circumcision at Gilgal: From Human Initiative to Obedience to the Divine
Program Unit: Joshua-Judges
David Frankel, Schechter Institue of Jewish Studies
It is widely recognized that the story of Joshua’s circumcision of the Israelites at Gilgal both in MT and LXX is heavily edited. The most common critical approach considers the section of verses 4-7 (and the slightly divergent parallel in LXX) to be secondary and locates the early, pre-deuteronomistic narrative in verses 2-3, 8-9. Early critics such as Steuernagel, and more recent critics such as A. Rofe, have astutely pointed out that God’s dramatic declaration to Joshua in verse 9, “Today I have rolled away from you the disgrace of Egypt,” implies that the Israelites in Egypt were scorned as uncircumcised and that this disgrace was removed “today,” at Gilgal, for the first time. This implies both that the Israelites did not observe circumcision in Egypt and that the Israelites at Giglal were identical with the ones who lived in Egypt and departed therefrom. Obviously, both of these implications were problematic from a later perspective. Verses 4-7 thus came to insist that the Israelites in Egypt indeed observed circumcision. It was only the second generation of Israelites born in the wilderness that needed to be circumcised by Joshua. This secondary material also brought the ancient text in line with the standard conception according to which the exodus generation died in the wilderness while those who entered the land with Joshua were a new group of people.
This paper seeks to modify this reconstruction of the early narrative as consisting of verses 2-3, 8-9. Verse 2 (“At that time the Lord said to Joshua…”) is strongly Deuteronomistic in style and must be attributed to a late editor. There is no indication in verse 3 that Joshua circumcised the Israelites “as the Lord commanded.” On the contrary, the verse’s formulation, ויעש לו יהושע, implies that the circumcision reflects Joshua’s own initiative. It is most natural to understand that a late editor would want to attribute the initiative to perform the circumcision to God rather than Joshua. This secondary attribution of the circumcision to God is again reflected in the present formulation of verse 9, which has God tell Joshua, who is made to represent the people as a whole, “today I have removed the disgrace of Egypt from upon you.” The attribution of this speech to God requires that we attribute the naming of the place as Gilgal in the continuation of the verse to God as well. This, however, is extremely unusual as God is generally not the one who gives names to places. It seems clear that verse 9 was originally presented as the speech of Joshua.
A final section of the paper will show that the phenomenon found here, that of converting a demonstration of human initiative and authority into one obedience to a divine command, can be identified elsewhere in the biblical corpus, particularly in Exodus 16.
|
Egyptian Personal Names and Dates of Composition in Gen 37-50
Program Unit: Egyptology and Ancient Israel
Eric S. Fredrickson, Harvard University
Gen 37-50 contains several Egyptian personal names. In his 1970 monograph, A Study of the Biblical Story of Joseph, Donald B. Redford argued regarding these names that "the most likely period for the close acquaintance of the Hebrews with all three names would be the Saite and Persian periods (664-331 B.C.), when each was at the height of its popularity." This argument had a significant influence on subsequent biblical scholarship. Each of the names in question is attested in Egypt before the Saite Period, but Redford argues that the Egyptian name type behind the names Potiphar and Potiphera is attested more frequently after 664 BCE than before. He does not, however, closely examine the changes in frequency over time of the other Egyptian names. This paper aims to extend Redford's work by bringing the latest collections of evidence and more sophisticated statistical methods to bear on this question of inferring dates of composition from these names, examining both the individual distributions of these names in the Egyptian evidence and their collective import for dates of composition in Gen 37-50.
|
From Patrimony to Politics: The Changing Status of Judaism in Late Roman Law
Program Unit:
Paula Fredriksen, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
In the first generation of the Jesus movement, back when ‘Christians’ were Jews, allegiances between earth and heaven were ethnically inflected. Gods ran in the blood, and deities tended to share the ethnic identity of the human group, the genos or ethnos, that worshiped them. This was true for the god of Israel no less than for the god(s) of Ephesus or of Rome. But in the course of the second century, God the father of Jesus lost his Jewish identity, and various forms of gentile Christianity hermeneutically loosened the LXX’s ethnic moorings. In consequence, as we see in Book 16 of the Codex Theodosianus, Ioudaïsmos shifted from being an idiosyncratic ethnic patrimony, a set of ancestral practices, to being a deviant, even a dangerous, political choice.
|
"The Gods of My Unbelief are Magnificent": Jews, Gods, and Israel’s God in the Early Roman Period
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Paula F. Fredriksen, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
Roman-period Jews lived in a world full of gods, and they knew it. Gods other than their own were their immediate neighbors in the Graeco-Roman city. These gods appeared to Jews in dreams; they witnessed to Jewish manumissions; indeed, they arose from the pages of traditional Jewish scriptures. And, beginning with Augustus, newer gods were running the empire. Yet their ancestral laws forbade Jews to honor foreign gods with cult. How, then, were Jews to cope with all these other gods who, if disregarded, could be dangerous – as could the humans who honored them? This paper will examine the three different responses of three very different Jews from the early imperial period: Herod the Great (d. 4 BCE), Philo of Alexandria (d. circa 50 CE), and Paul the apostle (d. circa 65?). In the god-congested world of the first imperial century, as we shall see, even the “monotheists” were polytheists.
|
A Name to Remember: Reconsidering Exodus 3:15
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Aron Freidenreich, Union Theological Seminary in the City of New York
Exodus 3:15 is at the heart of the central controversy in modern Pentateuchal scholarship: the debate between the classical Documentary Hypothesis (along with its Neo-Documentarian adaptation) that continues to serve as the prevailing model in North America and Israel, and the Transmission-Historical models taking prominence especially in European scholarship.
For the Documentarians, Exodus 3:15 depicts the pivotal moment in the Elohistic (E) work when the deity first introduces the Tetragrammaton to Moses and to humanity. This verse is therefore singularly representative of the most overtly concrete distinction between Israel’s two epic traditions, since the alternative Yahwistic (J) source employs the name “YHWH” from creation onwards. Exodus 3:15 bears witness to an early Northern Israelite tradition ascribing the Tetragrammaton to Mosaic origins, a tradition that continued to be preserved in Exodus 6:2-3 of the later Priestly work (P). The Documentary Hypothesis’ detractors claim to have dealt a fatal blow to both of the purported epic sources, ascribing their disparate non-Priestly (non-P) materials to various origins that both precede and postdate the Priestly writings. For many followers of the Transmission-Historical approach, Exodus 3:1-4:18 constitutes a supplementary block that could not have been part of a larger continuous parallel strand stretching the length of the Pentateuchal narrative. Moreover, they point to evidence within Exodus 3:15 itself that betrays its late insertion within that block, arguing that it borrows elements both from the two verses immediately surrounding it and from a distant, and especially recent, Psalms collection (see Psalms 135:13). Exodus 3:15 has therefore been reimagined as a post-Priestly addition that was designed to foreshadow P’s divulgence of the Tetragrammaton within the same narrative stream, thereby further corroborating a theological framework first observed only in the exilic/post-exilic Priestly literature.
On what basis should one decide between these two opposing viewpoints of the purpose and ultimate significance of Exodus 3:15, without being unduly influenced by preconceived notions about the overall efficacy of either the Documentary Hypothesis or the Transmission-Historical models? This paper will respond to both positions, and suggest that a close examination of Exodus 3:15 itself actually promotes neither reading, at least as each one is currently expressed. I propose that underlying Exodus 3:15 is a very different intention than has previously been recognized by either side of the debate, and that the verse reflects a more dynamic relationship both with its immediate non-Priestly context and with its Priestly counterpart.
|
On the Reception of Chronicles
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Blaire French, University of Virginia
no abstract
|
Aspect Substitution in the Parable of the Sower
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Samuel Freney, Trinity Evangelical Divinity School
There are approximately one hundred places in the Greek New Testament where the author quotes the Greek Old Testament in a fairly direct manner, but changes the verb form in some way. These changes include alterations to person, mood, occasionally lexeme, but quite frequently the substitution of one aspect for another. This paper will examine the tense-form contrasts found in the quotation of Isaiah 6:9–10 in the Parable of the Sower, and using a method inspired by Carl Bache’s contrastive substitution will examine the impact of aspect substitution on the surrounding discourse.
Mark’s paraphrastic rendering of Isa 6:9–10 has prompted a great deal of exegetical disagreement, particularly related to the conjunctions ἵνα and μήποτε. Following many modern interpreters who argue for interpreting the received text as it stands, it appears that Mark, of all the Gospel writers, mirrors most closely the tone of the MT. A similarly strong causative purpose is found on the lips of Jesus—a harshness potentially softened even by Matthew and Luke. While the tone and implicit divine purpose echoes the MT, the form is largely of the LXX, and certain strong parallels exist to the Aramaic. Yet the presence of more direct parallels to the LXX in the other Synoptic Gospels (along with Acts) allow us to make a comparison of the effect of the changes made in Mark’s version.
Mark’s altered quotation contrasts Future indicative and Aorist subjunctive forms with Present subjunctives, along with a change from 2nd to 3rd person. This latter change in person is both common and minor: the shortened quotation assumes the 3rd-person reference of the final line and applies the former clauses to the same group (τοῦ λαοῦ τούτου). Regarding the Future–Present change, we find that this comports well with Campbell’s model of the Future form, namely perfective in aspect and future in tense. This quotation in Mark and Luke is characterized both by a change to imperfective aspect, and the removal of future expectation. The overall effect of this is to efficiently shift the reader’s/hearer’s viewpoint on the effect of prophetic speech to an ongoing process around the disciples. Even apart from a consideration of these changes, Jesus’s use of the quotation implies he is applying it to his present teaching. But the shift to imperfective aspect allows Mark and Luke to efficiently mirror that broader point in the syntax. The grammar follows the explanation, compactly echoing the typological comparison being made.
|
On Singing and/or Pruning: Song of Songs 2:12 Reconsidered
Program Unit: Megilloth
Daniel Frese, University of Kentucky
The meaning of the phrase עת זמיר הגיע “the time of zamir has arrived” in Song of Songs 2:12 is a classic interpretive crux; the verbal root zm’’r usually means either “singing” or the completely unrelated “pruning.” Both ancient and modern translations are divided on the correct understanding of this term, as are ancient and modern commentators. Cyrus Gordon famously added a third interpretive option: he touted this phrase as an example of Janus parallelism, where the term in question works in both senses simultaneously: the meaning “pruning” parallels the time references which precede it, and “singing” parallels the voice of the turtledove in the following phrase. In this paper I will survey and critique all of the interpretive options. Based on considerations including agriculture, semantics, and singing practices in ancient Israel, I conclude that the meaning “pruning” was likely intended.
|
"Kasakyerew ho nimdefo, mo!" (Those gifted in the knowledge of writing of language, congratulations!): Kwame Bediako, Mother-Tongue Theology, and Orality—African Epistemologies and Spirituality
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Sara Fretheim, University of Edinburgh
It has been argued that the language of Africa is the language of orality. As Clifton Clarke contends, “this is the realm where orality is expressed through the language of symbols. […] Symbolism makes the African Christian a converted narrator, storyteller, theologian, poet, God’s okyeame (linguist) and singer.” Yet, one cannot speak of “scripturalization, orature, or orality as a cultural way of life in African and African Diasporic cultures” without immediately encountering the issue of mother tongue versus global languages. Ghanaian theologian Kwame Bediako argues that while the convenience of being able to circulate research more widely may push African theologians to write in Western languages, African Christian scholars “cannot set aside lightly the challenge of mother tongues, since these provide the historical, socio-cultural intellectual, and emotional matrices that give shape to the human responses to transcendence.”
Bediako adds that the challenge is particularly acute in post-colonial, post-missionary Africa, where the widespread use of Western languages “conceals the fact that contemporary African Christianity has emerged and is sustained largely through means that have been shaped by African mother tongues – the Bible translated into African languages, and African Christian preaching conveyed through African languages.”
This paper argues that orality, and by extension the use of African languages, are key African epistemological approaches and important elements of African spirituality. This paper draws upon the scholarship of Afe Adogame, Ezra Chitando, and Bolaji Bateye who argue for African approaches to the study of religion in Africa , and Kwame Bediako, whose contribution to promoting orality and mother-tongue engagement are found in his publications as well as within the research institute which he founded, the Akrofi-Christaller Institute for Theology, Mission and Culture (Ghana).
For a paper engaging orality and scripturalization, an important counter-narrative is found in analyzing the praise songs of Ghanaian Christian oral poets Ephraim Amu and Afua Kuma. Both demonstrate insightful apprehensions of Scripture and their African cosmological universe and daily surroundings, utilizing traditional praise-song formats to offer Christian praises, giving creative interpretations to biblical passages and theological concepts. Furthermore, their songs demonstrate incredible linguistic skill and artistry, incorporating Ghanaian symbols, proverbs, idioms, and visuals, adding important performative and sensory aspects. The interplay of orality and written text is seen in Amu’s song, “Kasakyerew ho nimdefo, mo!” (Those gifted in the knowledge of writing of language, congratulations!), written and performed to honour the work of early Twi Bible translators J. G. Christaller and C.A. Akrofi.
Bediako argues that African Christians should be “understood as drawing on their sense of belonging within Christian tradition and using categories which to them describe their understanding of their pre-Christian heritage when related to their Christian commitment.” As Chitando responds, “Bediako insists that African theologians have a right to contribute to an understanding of their own religious heritage.” This paper seeks to listen in to this important conversation, drawing fresh insights into orality as an important African approach to spirituality.
|
Hospitality, Mental Illness, and the “Mark of Cain”: A Theology of Chaplaincy in a Forensic Psychiatric Hospital
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Tim Fretheim, Forensic Psychiatric Hospital, British Columbia
Within the fields of Practical Theology and Disability Theology, hospitality is a familiar concept, welcoming those from the margins and pointing to postures of openness and mutuality. However, hospitality also raises ambivalence and fears about the “Other.” As a chaplain in a forensic psychiatric hospital, where those suffering from a mental illness and who have committed crimes are involuntarily committed, tensions surrounding hospitality are real. Like Cain in Genesis 4, patients bear a “mark,” simultaneously punitive and protective: they are set apart from society. What does hospitality look like here? How can we practically and theologically move such persons from roles of stranger to guest -- or host? This paper shows the trajectory this might take by challenging definitions of hospitality; addressing/overcoming obstacles to hospitable engagement; and arguing that time and fluid guest-host roles are key to effectively practicing hospitality with those living with a mental illness in an institutional setting.
|
Buffering the Self: Insights in Inwardness and Outwardness from the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Philology in Hebrew Studies
Christian Frevel, Ruhr-Universität Bochum
Within the alleged development of subjectivity and reflexivity the so-called "inner self" plays a major role. Usually it is said that there is no such inwardness in the Hebrew Bible literature and that the conception of the "inner" and "outer man" rather emerges in later more reflexive literature (cf. Philo, 2 Cor 4:16-18). However, there are more than glimpses of the "inner self" in biblical literature; not only in the prophets, but also in wisdom and poetic literature. The paper will discuss the view of a predominant outwardness of the Hebrew conception of the person by looking at passages of the Hebrew Bible in which the "inner" and "outer" is addressed in regard to the "self", "personhood" and "identity". The observations will then be related to Charles Taylor's argument, namely, that the difference between antiquity and modern self is the difference between a "porous self" and a "buffered self".
|
Ataroth, Dibon, and the King of Arad: The Book of Numbers and Archaeology
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Christian Frevel, Ruhr-Universität Bochum
In Pentateuchal studies, the emergence of major parts of the Book of Numbers has moved beyond classical source criticism. Following scholarship which dates the composition of the Book of Numbers to the 5th and 4th centuries BCE, the work is viewed broadly as the latest book of the Pentateuch, clearly composed in the Persian period. However, the book is most concrete in terms of land issues, itineraries, etc., and some of these components do not fit a Persian period setting. The role of Kadesh or of Shittim, the kings of Arad, Moab, and Edom and other information gives the impression of concreteness in terms of history. However, neither settlement information regarding Gilead nor the border description in Num 34 give the impression of deriving from recent times but rather from LBA “Canaan” and Iron Age Jordan. The Book of Numbers attests a settlement process in Transjordan mostly contemporaneous to the conquest in Cis-Jordan. The paper inquires into intersections between the literary history of the narrative and the history reconstructed by external evidence and by the archaeological record. Are the two realms more separate in the Book of Numbers than in other books of the Pentateuch? What is the outcome of an archaeological approach for the Book of Numbers and the literary-narrative or literary-historical approach read against the background of archaeological and historical information? This raises methodological, hermeneutical and content related questions the paper will discuss.
|
The Meaning of Exile in Second Temple Jewish Literature
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
Lisbeth S. Fried, University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
Throughout second temple Jewish literature, the threat of exile, of dying away from one’s native land, looms large. The deserved punishment for the wicked priest Jason, for example, was death in Egypt in exile with no funeral and no grave in the tomb of his ancestors (2 Macc. 5:10). Joseph, on the other hand, makes the Israelites promise to bring his bones back to Judah to bury them there (Gen. 50:25), and Joshua affirms that they did so (Josh. 24:32). Safety is burial in one’s native land, danger and abandonment is burial abroad. This assumes that the graves themselves will be protected and known and visited, but this cannot be guaranteed. Nehemiah begs permission of King Artaxerxes to be sent to Judah because the city of the graves of his ancestors lies waste, its gates consumed by fire. This paper explores the notion that the threat of exile is the threat of abandoning the graves of one’s ancestors.
|
Jesus' Davidic Lineage and the Case for Jewish Adoption
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Caleb Friedeman, Ohio Christian University
Jesus' Davidic Lineage and the Case for Jewish Adoption
|
Philo of Alexandria and the Masks of Heracles
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Courtney Friesen, University of Arizona
With few competitors, Heracles was one of the most popular and widely revered heroes of Greco-Roman antiquity. In two treatises, Philo evokes his heroic virtue as a potential model for human emulation. In the Embassy to Gaius, the emperor’s claims to the divine honors of the hero are deflated in view of his failure adequately to have matched Heracles’ benefactions for human civilization. Philo notes that Gaius used to dress himself in theatrical costumes impersonating various gods and heroes, which, he suggests, reveals that the emperor’s likeness to divinity was merely superficial. In That Every Good Person Is Free, Heracles’ actions in the satyr-play Syleus serve as a model for the true sage who acts with freedom of soul even in a state of servitude. In the drama, despite his best efforts to disguise his true nature in order to deceive the murderous tyrant, his heroic attributes remained visible. Within these two treatises, therefore, Heracles is ostensibly celebrated as genuinely divine. This presentation will argue, however, that in both instances Philo subtly subverts the status of the hero. In the former treatise, this is evident in his Euhemeristic interpretation of the hero’s divine nature, and in the latter in his claim that the demigod’s achievements in virtue were surpassed by humans, including the Essenes and the philosophers Anaxagoras and Zeno.
|
Commentation: Gender, Race, and Religion in the Economy of Words
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Steven Friesen, University of Texas at Austin
*
|
Blood into Stone: Violence, Sanctuary, and "Jewish Christianity" in the Protevangelium Jacobi
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Christopher A. Frilingos, Michigan State University
Known mostly for the way it "fills in the gaps" of Mary's early life, the Protevangelium Jacobi includes shocking images of physical violence. Near the end of the gospel, Zacharias, the father of John the Baptist and a priest, is killed by Herod's soldiers. His blood spills over the altar of the "Lord's Temple"; later the blood turns to stone. In a different example, protection from sexual violence comes in the form of flames that burn the assailant. Mary, having given birth to Jesus in a cave outside of Bethlehem, is made to submit to a digital inspection of her postpartum genitals. But when Salome tries to penetrate Mary's body, her hand immediately catches fire, the skin "falling away." This paper will explore these and other examples in the Protevangelium Jacobi along three intersecting lines of inquiry. First, what is the significance of acts of violence, threats of violence, and protection from violence in this story of Christian origins? Second, what is the significance of the various images of sanctuary that serve as backdrops for these examples? "Sanctuary" here refers both to a holy place, such as the temple in which Zacharias serves, and a place of refuge, such as the cave outside of Bethlehem, the mountain that protects the wife and son of Zacharias, and the womb of Mary, which not only carries the Christian savior but also erects a fiery barrier against Salome's encroachment. The third line of inquiry engages with recent proposals by Lily C. Vuong and Michael Rosenberg to sort out the provenance and religious identity of the author and audience of the Protevangelium Jacobi. Does the text reflect a variety of "Jewish Christianity"? Where can references to "Israel," "Hebrew," and "Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob," be found, and what, amid the blood and stones of the story, do such references signify?
|
Sapiential Elements in the Book of Jeremiah: A Revisited Look
Program Unit: Theology of the Hebrew Scriptures
Rachel Frish, Bar-Ilan University
One of the well-known problems in the study of traditional wisdom involves identification of passages that reflect a correlation with the wisdom theme outside the corpus of wisdom literature. Although research has clearly recognized that such passages exist in the Bible, the debate regarding the extent of these passages and the methodology that must be used to identify them still continues.
In research of the Book of Jeremiah, various passages that show a correlation to wisdom literature or sapiential tradition have been identified over the years. However, in most cases, scholars have not suggested a clear methodology for this subject, nor have they analyzed the nature of the wisdom reflected in the Book of Jeremiah.
In my lecture I will propose new criteria for identifying the sapiential passages outside of the wisdom corpus. One of the new elements of my proposal is related to the manner in which terminology that testifies to a correlation to the wisdom theme should be assessed. While many have claimed that words that are common outside of wisdom literature as well, such as “wise,” “sagacious” and the like cannot attest to a correlation to the wisdom theme, I believe that these words, when present at a high concentration or appearing alongside other sapiential elements in a specific passage, can in fact be considered sapiential themselves. In addition to identifying the terminology, I propose a renewed examination of proverbs incorporated in the book, imagery that reflects a correlation to the wisdom theme, and more.
After identifying passages with a high concentration of sapiential motifs, I will conduct an in-depth discussion of several passages in the Book of Jeremiah that reflect a correlation to the wisdom theme. I will present the sapiential principles reflected in them and the manner in which the sapiential ideas are integrated into the book. I will show that in many of the passages that express a significant correlation to the wisdom theme, imagery from the natural world or a description of the creation process are also incorporated, evoking the order and regularity that exists in the natural world.
These types of imagery point to a correlation to sapiential tradition, for which order and regularity is one of its fundamental principles. However, order in the natural world is incorporated into these passages with a correlation to the covenant traditions, traditions that are not expressed in classic wisdom literature. In the prophecies of destruction, the prophet presents the covenant between the nation and God as part of the constancy and regularity of the world, and breaching of this covenant as the cause leading to chaos. These motifs also appear in the prophecies of comfort in Jeremiah 31:31-37, however the singularity of this passage is that God’s loyalty to the nation is presented as unwavering, regardless of the actions of man: Thus, the combination of sapiential elements with common motifs in prophetic literature produces a new message that is unique to Jeremiah.
|
Kings of the Jews: Mark and Kingship in Post-war Galilee
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
Margaret Froelich, Claremont School of Theology
In the Gospel of Mark, the title “king” (basileus) applies to two characters: Mark’s fictionalized Herod Antipas in chapter 6, and Jesus himself as the king of Israel or king of the Jews in the Passion narrative (chapters 14 and 15). However, the text characterizes Herod as an unjust and cowardly sycophant, and in the Passion narrative no one applies the title to Jesus who means it sincerely. Using imperial-critical methodology, this paper explores the Gospel’s strong ambivalence toward the title basileus, which historically represents both imperial legitimation and subaltern resistance. It is contextualized on one side by the Gospel’s wider appropriation and (eschatological) reimagining of imperial titles and structures, and on the other by its reformulation of Judean War-era messianic hopes in general and discomfort with the title Son of David in particular. In the center of Mark’s use of the title is an implicit critique of the appropriate roles and qualities of kingship.
Assuming a post-70 provenance, this paper reads the Gospel of Mark as an attempt to cope with the dissolution of the status quo in Judea and to maintain a sense of divine control in spite of the failure of rebellion and messianic hopes. The contrast between Jesus and Herod, embodied in the title basileus, is in part a reproach of Agrippa II, whose assistance to Vespasian represented one side of a division in Jewish attitudes toward Rome. After the war Agrippa not only maintained his power, but was granted wider territory, and (unlike his ancestor Antipas) he officially carried the title king. In the wake of the temple’s destruction and the resulting crisis of Levantine Jewish identity, Mark’s treatments of both the Herodian dynasty and the title king are part of his overall project to stake a new claim for the Galilean Jesus community in competition with surviving Pharisees, Herodian loyalists, and lingering rebels.
|
Back to the Basics: Does Any Diachronic Approach Work?
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Serge Frolov, Southern Methodist University
Dissimilar as they are, both neo-documentary and transmission-history approaches are diachronic by nature: they try to make sense of the biblical text by postulating multiple hands (authors, redactors, etc.) behind it. Accordingly, before discussing which one does the job better it may be worth its while to check whether diachronic methodology as such is epistemologically sound and exegetically viable. The present paper argues that it is not using the flood narrative in Genesis 6-9 as an example. The features of the text that lend themselves to diachronic analysis are better understood as elements of an integral, if sophisticated, design. At the same time, where single authorship is more difficult to postulate neither neo-documentary hypothesis nor transmission criticism proves capable of generating a more satisfactory solution.
|
"And They Cried to Yhwh": Soteriological Mechanisms in the Book of Judges
Program Unit: Theology of the Hebrew Scriptures
Serge Frolov, Southern Methodist University
For a long time, the vast majority of exegetes have assumed that Israel's liberation from foreign oppression in the Book of Judges is predicated on the people's repentance. However, many commentaries and studies of the last few decades claim that in fact Israel never repents in Judges and that its deliverance in the book is strictly a function of divine grace. The present paper examines this claim and finds it wanting. A close look at the language of Judges and especially at its literary structure reveals that the narrator not only has Israel repeatedly repent its abandonment of Yhwh but also unambiguously (if implicitly) demonstrates that such repentance -if sincere, i.e. accompanied by renunciation of foreign gods - is a conditio sine qua non of the people’s deliverance.
|
Punished by Rape: Reading between Judges 19 and Ezekiel, via the Song of Songs
Program Unit: Intertextuality and the Hebrew Bible
Serge Frolov, Southern Methodist University
Judges 19 features an anonymous couple identified only as a Levite and his concubine. The only other nameless couple in the Hebrew Bible, that appearing in the Song of Songs, has been traditionally understood as standing for Israel (the woman) and Yhwh (the man). Israel and Yhwh are also described as a couple in Isaiah, Jeremiah, Hosea, and especially - at the greatest length and in the greatest and by far the most naturalistic detail - in Ezekiel 16 and 23. In this, the intertextual trajectory comes a full circle, since the prophets unanimously denounce Lady Israel for sexual promiscuity - something that the Levite's concubine is also accused of (Judg 19:2)- and since in Ezekiel she seems to be threatened with gang rape - something that actually happens to the concubine. Intertextuality thus makes it possible to project the gruesome narrative of Judges 19 upon the broader story of the community's relationship with its deity in Judges and beyond - with some meaningful results.
|
Violence to Cure Complacency: Managing the Anxiety of Hegemony through Representations of Violence
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
Diane Shane Fruchtman, Rutgers University
The poetry of Prudentius (fl. 405 CE) celebrates the triumph of Christianity, taking Christianity’s political dominance nearly for granted as he focuses his attentions on fusing “Romanitas” with Christian faithfulness. And yet, these same poems are shot through with anxieties about the dangers faced by Christians—from “pagans” and from heresy, yes, but above all else, from the complacency accompanying Christian triumphalism. The success of any ideology comes with such complications, as shifts in access to power make new and different demands on the ideology and its adherents. Prudentius negotiates Christianity’s new imperial endorsement with violence. Or, rather, with depictions of violence crafted to induce visceral reactions in his audiences. These reactions range from revulsion to desire, and are managed by Prudentius’s narrative techniques: he situates images of bodily injury in narrative frames that instruct engaged readers in how to secure their own souls’ salvation. We see this in his Psychomachia, where he describes the physical destruction of the personified Vices in gruesome detail as something to be abhorred and avoided, and in his Peristephanon, where he describes the bodies of the martyrs as similarly subject to dismemberment but, in sharp contrast to the Vices, as objects of desire and devotion. The narratives and narrative techniques that Prudentius employs make clear to his readers how these violent images should be understood as they navigate their identities as Christians and as Christian communities. For Prudentius, the poetic representation of physical violence is a key tool for navigating hegemonic anxiety.
|
The Twelve Prophets and Ezekiel in the Hodayot
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Russell E. Fuller, University of San Diego
This paper will discuss quotations and allusions to the Twelve (Minor) Prophets and Ezekiel in the Hebrew text of the Hodayot from Qumran.
|
Textual Criticism and Gender: A View from a North America Scholar
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Deirdre Fulton, Baylor University
A quick glance through the last decade of international, national, and regional Society of Biblical literature program books reveals several program units dedicated to the topic of textual criticism, such as Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible, Textual Criticism of Samuel-Kings, and Textual Growth. Female and minority textual critics operating at present, while numerically significantly in the minority, benefit from long-standing traditions of scholarship. Indeed, in my own academic journey as a North American scholar, the field of textual criticism is well-established and generally considered a foundational aspect of studies of the Hebrew Bible. This paper will reflect on the challenges of representation and what it might suggest about the current state of the field as well as future directions in the field.
|
Isaac Typology and Fulfillment of the Oath to Abraham in Luke-Acts
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Pablo Gadenz, Seton Hall University
Recent studies on Matthew and Mark have argued convincingly that there is a significant Isaac typology in those Gospels, which is presented mainly through allusions to passages in Genesis, especially the Akedah in Genesis 22. Such studies naturally raise the question of whether a similar Isaac typology exists in Luke. In this article, I argue that Luke indeed develops an Isaac typology in his Gospel, one that leads to greater recognition (anagnorisis) of Jesus’s identity and mission. In the first part, I explore Luke’s methodology of presenting a typological relationship between a biblical figure and Jesus through his intertextual use of Scripture. I examine an example of a biblical typology that is well recognized, namely, the Elijah typology, showing the different ways Luke uses to present that typology. Of particular interest is the technique seen in Luke 7:15, in which there is an allusion made through the verbatim repetition of a unique biblical phrase. A quick survey reveals that this is not a one-time technique, as it seems to be used elsewhere by Luke (e.g., 13:17; 24:31; Acts 12:17). In the second part, I apply the observations made on Luke’s methodology in a study of Luke’s presentation of an Isaac typology. I consider the infancy narrative, baptism, parable of the wicked tenants, and crucifixion in order to see the cumulative development of the typology. Intrinsically connected to Luke’s presentation of an Isaac typology is the fulfillment of the oath made to Abraham (Luke 1:73; cf. Gen 22:18). Moreover, the technique of verbatim repetition of a unique biblical phrase seems to be utilized again in Luke 23:33 to make an allusion to the Akedah (Gen 22:9 LXX). The recurrence of Luke’s interest in the Akedah is then seen in the explicit citation of Gen 22:18 in Acts 3:25. It appears that Jesus is the agent through which the transmission of the blessing given to Abraham occurs because he has assumed the role of a new Isaac. In the conclusion, the further implications of the Isaac typology for an understanding of Luke’s theology of the cross are briefly considered.
|
The Silence of YHWH in Isa 64f
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Judith Gaertner, Universität Rostock
Due to the long formation of the book from the Assyrian to the Persian-Hellenistic time, the question regarding the composition and redaction of the Book of Isaiah represents a complex challenge. The discussion surrounding the Book of Isaiah is shaped by diachronic redaction-critical as well as synchronic approaches - in the sense of canonical approaches, resulting in a complex picture of methodical and hermeneutic approaches to the Book of Isaiah. Against the background of this methodical and hermeneutical plural state of current research, the following paper raises the double question regarding the literary-historical formation of the closure of the book as well as its composition by the example of the silence of YHWH in Isa 64:11 and Isa 65. The paper aims to highlight for the composition of the book the idea of God implied by the silence of YHWH as well as the noticeable struggle how the misdeeds of the God are to be interpreted.
|
But Queen Vashti Refused: The Book of Esther as a Test Case for Consent in Biblical Studies
Program Unit: Megilloth
Jason M. H. Gaines, Tulane University
The concept of consent--granted or withheld--is arguably the most significant leitmotif in the book of Esther. The narrative begins when Queen Vashti refuses to appear before a drunken banquet (Esth. 1:12), disallowing her body to be displayed as a sex object. Her refusal is honored, and while she suffers consequences (1:19), she is not forced to appear. The hero Mordechai similarly maintains control of his body when he does not consent to bow to Haman (3:2). King Ahasuerus must verbally summon concubines with whom he wants to have sex (2:14), and he must "extend the golden scepter" to Esther, thereby granting her permission to appear, before she may speak with him (5:1). In contrast to these seemingly-empowered characters who are able to consent or withhold consent, the author(s) present other characters as without any such power: Esther is "taken to the king's palace" with no narrative indication of whether she goes willingly (2:8, 16); Haman and his wife propose plans that require the consent and validation of others before they may be executed (3:8-11; 5:14). Once Esther herself becomes queen, though, the narrative grants her significant power: Ahasuerus consents in advance to grant any request Esther might make ("even up to half the kingdom" [5:3]); Haman's downfall is ultimately precipitated not by any violence he proposes against the Jews, but rather because the king suspects him of sexually assaulting the newly-empowered and consent-capable Esther (7:8). This study will show that consent is inextricably related to pre-existing power structures, such as gender, social status, official rank, and able-bodiedness. This paper will discuss how consent (sexual and otherwise) functions in the narrative and how the narrator communicates information concerning consent--when it must be granted verbally, when silence implies consent--with the goal of proposing useful paradigms for understanding consent throughout the Hebrew Bible.
|
The Book of Life: Between the Bible and the Qur’an
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
Abdulla Galadari, Khalifa Univesity / Al Maktoum College
In several instances of the Hebrew Bible and the New Testament, they refer to the Book of Life (sēpher ḥayyīm) or the writing in heaven (apogegrammenōn en ouranois), which contains the names of those who enjoy life, and anyone blotted out from it receives death (e.g. Exodus 32:32-33, Psalms 56:8, 69:28, and 139:16; Daniel 12:1; Philippians 4:3; and Revelation 3:5). In contrast, those not written in heaven are said to be written in the earth (yikkatebu bi-ha-aretz) (i.e. Jeremiah 2:13), in which some scholars have suggested is what Jesus is portrayed as doing when he bent down writing in the earth twice when asking his audience if anyone is without sin to cast the first stone (i.e. John 8:6-8).
The Qur’an has references to the writings in heaven and earth (e.g. illiyyūn, sijjīn). The term “illiyyūn” has the meaning of highness, and therefore, perhaps alluding to heaven. The description in the Qur’an of those who are in “‘illiyūn” being witnessed by those brought near (al-muqarrabūn) are of them drinking from a spring. This description may be compared with Psalm 46:4–5. The description of drinking from a river as the fountain of life (miqur ḥayyim) is also seen in Psalm 36:8–9.
The term “sijjīn” appears to be related to “sijn,” meaning prison, while some commentators, such as al-Ṭabarī, interpret “sijjīn” as the depth of the earth, or the deepest (seventh) level of earth. Interpreting hell as some kind of prison has a long history in Christian exegetical works, which is found in the Apostle’s Creed based on 1 Peter 3:19.
The New Testament also portrays sinning angels bound in chains (2 Peter 2:4, Jude 6, Revelations 20:1–4). The depiction of people in hell being bound in chains, as in a prison, is a recurring theme in the Qur’an (e.g., Qur’an 14:49, 40:71, 76:4).
The Qur’an also shows that those who are bound are not always to be understood as being physically in hell, as non-believers who are currently physically alive (i.e. Qur’an 36:6-12).
Therefore, the depiction of the book of the living or the book written in heaven (‘illiyyīn) and the book written in the earth (sijjīn) found in the Qur’an can be easily compared with that of the Bible. As such, one might infer that the concepts of death and resurrection (or life) in the Qur’an may also be compared with those of the Bible. Therefore, to better understand these concepts in the Qur’an, a comparison with the Bible may be necessary.
|
Discerning between Good and Evil: Wisdom Themes in the First Book of Samuel
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Garrett Galvin, Franciscan School of Theology
Wisdom literature discerns between the good and the bad. We see this clearly in Prov 2:20-22 and Psalm 11. I will argue that a similar theme is found in a narrative from in 1 Samuel 24-25. The presence of goodness in the First Book of Samuel helps the reader to discern between the characters. This become most important in 1 Samuel 24-25. Perhaps the key to 1 Samuel 24 is Saul’s description of David’s goodness (†ob) in 1 Sam 24:18. This goodness allows David to avoid objectifying Saul as an enemy and continue seeing him as God sees him. Goodness is a key word within the OT that brings us right back to the first chapter of Genesis where it is used seven times. Humans are all made in the image and likeness of God, and Saul is able to recognize this goodness in David on account of the way he treated him. Saul returns to this goodness again in verses 19 and 20. It seems to elicit a change in his attitude and bring out the best in Saul as he recognizes David’s ultimate power over him (23:22). 1 Samuel 25 is dominated by Abigail. Her intervention (25:18) changes the course of the whole chapter and demonstrates the power of one individual in the affairs of state. We are first introduced to Nabal who is described as evil (ra`) among other things. Then we are introduced to his wife and polar opposite Abigail who is described as good (†ob) among other things (25:3). Goodness and discerning between good and evil prove to be key concepts in these chapters. While wisdom themes are often associated with Solomon, I will argue that we also find them with David.
|
The LXX Vorlage
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Sandra Gambetti, College of Staten Island (CUNY)
In a 2016 article, Emanuel Tov concluded that LXX and SP derive from a common text. On the basis of hieroglyphic and Greek documentary sources and texts, this paper submits a historical argument that meets and supports Tov's conclusions. The main points of this paper are: 1) the earliest Yahwistic scriptures arrived in Egypt in 312 BCE from Mt. Gerizim, in the wake of Ptolemy I's conquest of Coele-Syria and the deportation of some of its inhabitants; 2) This is the text that was first translated into Greek in the 3rd c. BCE; c) This texts and its translation are criticized by the Zadokite Oniads in the mid-2nd c. BCE upon their arrival in Egypt. To defend both text and translation against such criticism, Ps.-Aristeas wrote his Letter, creating a myth which he chronologically retro-projected one hundred years.
|
How Is Catherine Bell's Approach to Ritualization Relevant for Analysis of Pentateuchal Ritual Texts?
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Roy E. Gane, Andrews University
Catherine Bell has highlighted the importance of viable ritual theory, especially by exposing the circularity of existing theories as theorists tend to interpret ritual according to their own categories. She stated that the aim of her analyses was to develop "a framework for reanalyzing the types of activities usually understood as ritual" (Ritual Theory, Ritual Practice [1992], 219), rather than to form a new theory of ritual that could "imply or designate some independently existing object, named ritual, with a set of defining features that characterize all instances of ritual" (ibid.). Nevertheless, she did define a ritualized version of an activity as "a way of acting that is designed and orchestrated to distinguish and privilege what is being done in comparison to other, usually more quotidian, activities…for creating and privileging a qualitative distinction between the 'sacred' and the 'profane,' and for ascribing such distinctions to realities thought to transcend the powers of human actors" (ibid., 74).
The present paper evaluates the applicability and limitations of Bell's approach for study of pentateuchal ritual texts, considering questions such as the following: What is the role of ritual theory in this context? How can we avoid circularity that skews our analyses? How does Bell's definition of ritualization relate to ancient Israelite rituals? What difference does it make that our only access to the ancient Israelite rituals is through texts that selectively outline and laconically interpret them?
|
The Roles of Temple Functionaries in the Month of Nisan in Ezekiel’s Temple Vision and the Neo-Babylonian Akītu Festival
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
Tova Ganzel, Bar-Ilan University
This lecture examines a number of similarities and differences in the status and roles of functionaries/those who carry out the rituals in Ezekiel’s vision and the contemporary Babylonian celebration of the Akītu festival. Temple functionaries receive unique attention in Ezekiel’s temple vision in general and regarding the month of Nisan in particular. Explicit references to the month of Nisan appear in the temple vision: in the date notice (40:1), “at the beginning of the year, the tenth day of the month” which parallels when the festivals for the Babylonian gods were held; and for the ritual cleansing of the temple (45:18–20). These dates have no biblical parallels. In addition, Ezekiel notes the beginning of the Passover holiday as the 14th of Nisan (45:21).
Although previous scholars have suggested that the unique aspects of the vision in Ezekiel lie in the Babylonian festivals, the publication of detailed studies of the Neo-Babylonian Akītu festival enable a more profound comparison between these rituals in general and the status of the functionaries in particular. This proposal is grounded in the assumption that the affinity between Babylonian Jews and the surrounding culture was not restricted to administrative matters alone, but also extended to the cultural realm. This is manifested in the affinity between the Jewish and Babylonian calendars, which seems not just to be grounded in administrative needs but extended to adoption of principles from Babylonian culture. Evidently the Akītu festival exemplifies how Babylonian ritual practices left a strong impression on the Jewish exiles there, and even more so on the exiles from priestly families.
|
A Spring Issuing from the Temple
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Tova Ganzel, Bar-Ilan University
The immediate impetus for this comparison between the sacred space in Ezekiel and Babylonian temples is the fact that no temple or holy complex similar to the one described in Ezekiel has been discovered in the land of Israel. As described in Ezekiel the temple precincts are unique, consisting of a square compound enclosing a square structure, chambers, gates, and a network of courtyards, in addition to the temple building itself. The description of the temple includes unusual features: a delineation of the functions of the chambers and the depiction of a spring issuing from underneath the platform of the temple into a large, square area with several entrances. This description differs fundamentally from the archeological remains of temple structures discovered in Israel, in which the temples are usually located inside a structure or within a rectangular area. Structures similar to the one described in Ezekiel have to date not been uncovered in archeological excavation in Israel, but were, however, common in Mesopotamia. This similarity forms the basis for my proposal that, in his description of the future temple, Ezekiel was inspired by the Babylonian milieu.
The focus of the lecture is on a unique component of Ezekiel’s vision: the spring issuing from the temple (Ezek 47:1–12), which I will suggest can be understood against Babylonian topography with its many rivers and flowing springs (see Pedersén’s recent study, “Waters in Babylonia”). The Mesopotamian traditions most relevant to the imagery of the waters emerging from the temple in Ezekiel are probably the ones connected to Esagil, the main temple of Marduk in Babylon. This temple sat on the banks of the Euphrates, which passed through the inner city, though not through Esagil itself. More importantly, as recounted in Enūma eliš, Marduk built Esagil, his temple, on top of the Apsû, the fresh deep waters, the dwelling place of his father, Ea. Moreover, the fourth tablet of the topographical text, describes the temple of Marduk as “Esagil, the replica of the Apsû.” Thus, we see that Esagil was not merely built on top of the Apsû, but fresh, life-giving waters formed the very foundations of the main Babylonian temple. This suggests that both Ezekiel and his audience visualized the future temple's structures and its waters in line with the Babylonian milieu. I further maintain that consideration of the Babylonian background of Ezekiel sheds light on other features of his temple.
|
The Traditional Passover Seder: Interpreting and the Four Questions and Five Cups; What Would Jesus Say?
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Zev Garber, Los Angeles Valley College
In the main, the pageantry of the Passover Seder focuses on two periods of Jewish history: the biblical Exodus from Egypt and the rabbinic recalling of the account. Through ritual food, drink, and animated reading and interpretation, the participant travels with the Children of Israel as if “s/he came forth out of Egypt,” and sits at the table of the Sages as they observe Passover in Jerusalem and Bnei Brak. Alas, the forty year trek from wilderness into freedom succumbed in Jewish history into a long night’s journey into exile. “Begin with disgrace and end with glory” (m. Pesachim 10.4). That is to say, talk openly and informatively about exilic degradation and destruction, so that, in contrast, the experience of Jewish freedom and triumph are cherished and appreciated. Thus, it is suggested, nay expected, that the greatest tragedy of the Jewish Night, the Shoah, be recounted on the night that accentuates Jewish birth and being. But for many Jews, it is not. How come?
A number of questions arise for those who insert contemporary genocide in the midst of freedom. Where is the Shoah inserted, beginning, middle, or end of the Seder ceremony? Does not the message of Hell on Earth compromise the theme of redemption from Heaven? By reading the Shoah into the Haggadah, are we not turning Judeocide into a paschal sacrifice making it a biblical holocaust rather that a contemporary historical Shoah. Nonetheless, the “why” of the Shoah is non explainable and may explain why it is inserted in the second part (“future”) of the service . The Four Cups at the Passover table represent the verbs of God’s freedom in the biblical Exodus story (Exod 6: 6-8). Also the Fifth Cup, the Cup of Elijah, is poured to overflowing and the door is opened and the “Pour Out Your Wrath” paragraph bellowed to the outside world. Why Shoah memory and the curse of Nations (pagan and monotheistic) at the Cup of Elijah, symbolic herald of messianic peace? What, if any, is the Shoah link to the Synoptic Last Supper which depicts Jesus proclaiming, “This is my body” (Luke 22:19) and “This is my blood of the covenant, which is poured out for many” (Mark 14:24; Matt 26:28)?
According to tradition of Rabbi Judah ben Bezalel, the Maharal of Prague (c. 1525-1609), one reads the “Great Hallel” with the Fifth Cup in hand, and in testimony to the passage, “Who remembered us in our low estate and has delivered us from our adversaries” (Ps 136: 23-24). So in our day, drinking from the Cup of Elijah testifies “to the land (He gave) for a heritage unto Israel” (Ps 136: 21-22). Is there a link between Auschwitz and Jerusalem? Shoah and Church? Cause and effect or remembrance and not again?
|
In the Wilderness with the Baptist: Historical Geography and Jewish Thought in the Synoptic Accounts
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Jeffrey P. García, Nyack College
The aim of this study is to challenge the nearly 70 years of attempts to identify John the Baptist with some part of the Qumran Community. The arguments for this identification have developed around two primary points. First, the Baptist’s events are said to take place in the “wilderness of Judah” (Matt 3:1), which is unique phraseology to the Gospel of Matthew. Indeed, where “wilderness” (erhmos) is read in the other Gospels, it is understood largely as the desert areas on the western shores of the Dead Sea or the southernmost end of the Jordan river as it makes its way into the Dead Sea. Yet, the "wilderness of Judah" is an unknown toponym in Second Temple texts, and not a single reference to midbar yehudah exists among the Qumran scrolls. In fact, midbar and erhmos can be understood as deserted areas of pasture without the implication of hot, arid environments (e.g., “wilderness of Bethsaida,” Luke 9:10). Second is the association of Is 40:3 with John’s movement and it's use in the Community Rule (1QS 8:14). It seems that the discussion of this has been obscured by a lack of attention given to the fuller Lukan narrative of the Baptist. The Evangelist’s account charts a different course for him than Matthew, Mark, and John, namely, one which emphasizes repentance, charity, and justice—an idea that seems to fit more comfortably within the spiritual world of Ben Sira, and the Sages of Israel, than that of the Qumran community. Therefore, we examine the geographic reference of the "wilderness of Judah” (and “wilderness” in the other Gospels) and the Lukan account of the Baptist in light of Jewish sources to plot a new place for John on the landscape of ancient Jewish thought.
|
Poverty, Charity, and the Economics of Sabbath Meals in Early Judaism
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
Gregg Gardner, The University of British Columbia
As locations of social interaction, meals are attractive targets for self-proclaimed religious experts who seek to define, structure, and influence human behavior. These include the ancient rabbis who authored and edited the foundational works of Jewish law – including the Mishnah, Tosefta, and Tannaitic Midrashim, which took shape in Roman Palestine in the third century C.E. In these texts, the Tannaim prescribe a number of laws related to food and eating. Because meals are materially-defined, early rabbinic legal prescriptions on food and eating are necessarily shaped by economic constraints. What one eats, as well as how one eats, when one eats, and with whom one eats may be influenced or dictated by a scarcity of resources. This scarcity is a function of one’s geographic location (e.g. certain foods may be more prevalent than others), social location (one’s personal ability to acquire certain foods), and other factors that are beyond rabbinic control. This paper will explore the economics of rabbinic discussions of meals by undertaking a close examination of the rabbinic law to eat three meals during the Sabbath. I will examine the background of this obligation in the Second Temple period, and then trace its development and concretization in early rabbinic literature. Prescribing an additional, third meal (over the two normally consumed during the week) adds an element of indulgence and joy to the Sabbath – but may also entail an additional outlay of economic resources. We then see the Tannaim construct laws of charity in ways that enable the poor to fulfill certain materially-contingent religious laws, including the obligation to eat three meals on the sabbath. This happens, though, in ways that may not have been anticipated. Perhaps sensitive to over-extending the community’s benevolence, the Tannaim structure charity laws so that the obligation to eat three meals can be fulfilled by restructuring time instead of requiring an additional economic outlay. The flexibility of time saves money and releases a tension between religious laws on meals and economics.
|
Between the Endurance and the Formation of Situations of Distress: The Lament as an Expression of Resilience by the Example of Ps 38
Program Unit: Biblical Literature and the Hermeneutics of Trauma
Judith Gärtner, Universität Rostock
The present paper approaches resilience as a process, at once dynamic and ambivalent, that fosters both the endurance of experiences of distress and powerlessness, and the emotional and cognitive formulation of such experiences. With this understanding resilience can serve as a productive category of interpretation for the Old Testament`s lament literature. Especially in the psalms of lamentation, where the experiences of pain, which affect the whole person, impair thinking, feeling and acting, are often expressed, we find important examples for the dynamic process of gaining resilience. Employing a range of semantics of pain reveals the capacity of the psalms of lamentation, especially the so-called psalms of illness (Pss 6, 38, 69, 88), to describe such crises in their polyvalence, articulating processes by which the crisis is both endured and formulated. In this manner, the psalms diminish the immediacy of the crisis. The words and metaphors make possible a psychologically productive and protective distance from the immediate experience of suffering. Consequently, these psalms can function as resilience narratives for the person praying them. The words and metaphors in these psalms vary between spontaneous self-articulation, memorized (and thereby familiar) expressions, and traditional patterns of speech with ritual orientation. Based on recent anthropological research, the paper aims to present in detail a range of semantics of pain experiences in their cultural conditionality and to portray the processing of pain as an expression of resilience that fosters both endurance of and the formulation of experience.
|
The Reception of Non-Canonical Gospels in Ethiopic Tradition: A Brief Look at the Tamǝra Iyesus
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Meron Gebreananaye, University of Durham
The Ethiopic book of Tamǝre Iyesus (Miracles of Jesus) is a collection of stories – identified by the heading “miracle.” This rubric, however, maybe somewhat of a misnomer in that this collection has little in common with other literature of the ‘miracle’ genre, which mainly consists of hagiographic accounts (known as Gadl’s in the Ethiopian tradition). The Tamǝre Iyesus is better described as a ‘Gospel’ in as much as it seeks to present a gospel-like account consisting of canonical and non-canonical traditions, which are organized in more or less the chronological order of the canonical gospels – from the Annunciation to post-Resurrection appearances. While, contemporary scholarship has taken note of the non-canonical gospel traditions preserved in this collection — such as the Infancy Gospel of Thomas, the Apocryphal Gospel of John and the Book of the Rooster — full study of these traditions as they are discovered within the Tamǝre Iyesus as a coherent literary unit, is however yet to be conducted. With this in mind, this short paper seeks to offer some preliminary description of the reception and appropriation of non-canonical traditions alongside canonical and additional Gǝ’ǝz materials in the Tamǝre Iyesus to offer some insight into the dynamic understanding of Gospel materials and their use in the creation of a new literary whole.
|
Prophets and Prophecy in Ancient Egypt
Program Unit: Egyptology and Ancient Israel
John Gee, Brigham Young University
In 2003, the Society of Biblical Literature published the work, Prophets and Prophecy in the Ancient Near East. This impressive work compiled all the ancient Near Eastern texts that fit the definition provided by Martti Nissinen: “Prophecy, as understood in this volume, is human transmission of allegedly divine messages.” He included only those texts that “reveal the relevant components of the process of transmission. This means that the implied speaker of the words uttered or quoted should be a deity, the implied address, respectively, a human being, and the message should be communicated to the addressee or recipient by a human being, the prophet.” It is surprising that this volume contains only an extract of one Egyptian text, one that describes a prophecy that takes place in a foreign land. Disappointingly, there are many Egyptian texts that fit Nissinen’s definition that should have been included but were not. I will describe these texts and discuss what they tell us about prophets and prophecy in Ancient Egypt.
|
Apocalypsis Iohannis: The Reception of the Book of Revelation in North Africa; Preliminary Observations
Program Unit: Contextualizing North African Christianity
Matthias Geigenfeind, Universität Regensburg
The Book of Revelation is one of the most influential texts of Christendom. While the Apocalypse of John remained a “Book of Seven Seals” in parts of the Greek-speaking East in antiquity and beyond, it was received with popularity in the Latin Church of the West. One reason for this prevalence is most likely the early translation of Revelation into Latin (so-called “Vetus Latina”), which can be tracked back to the second half of the second century CE. This version has, however, been underappreciated because of the prevailing scholarly interest in the Greek “original text”. Nevertheless, dealing with the Latin translation of Revelation is a worthwhile undertaking, because it illuminates a very important part of the textual and reception history of this book. Due to the fact that even the most literal translation cannot avoid a change of the content of the text to a degree, nuances and smaller interpretative additions are preserved in tradition. Similar to “fingerprints”, these (intended or unintended) alterations provide us with a valuable insight into the thinking and interpretations of past generations.
This paper shall, first, provide a brief overview of the existing various traditions and transmission history of the Vetus Latina of Revelation in North Africa. The focus of the presentation, however, shall lay on the second part: Here, by presenting concrete and exemplary passages of Revelation, it shall paradigmatically be shown, how Cyprian of Carthago (+ ca 258 CE) and Primasius of Hadrumetum (+ ca 553 CE) modified the text of Revelation and let theological and christological points arise via prudently made additions and omissions as well as changes in the vocabulary and syntax.
|
Onomastica Biblica in Apocryphal Prayers, Magic Practices, and Healing Rituals
Program Unit: Deuterocanonical and Cognate Literature
Florentina Badalanova Geller, Freie Universität Berlin
The paper will be focused on the role which apocryphal prayers and oral incantations play in vernacular traditions, with special emphasis on ethno-hermeneutic use of Scriptures as the ultimate thesauri of rules for public and private life. Apocryphal chants and oral folk spells portray Biblical patriarchs and matriarchs as almighty ancestors, shielding those invoking them from all kinds of natural disasters, social calamities, personal misadventures, health problems and misfortunes; hence the use of the Biblical onomasticon in formulae accompanying protective rituals, healing customs, and related practices. In all of these, the names of Biblical figures serve as verbal amulets which provide the ultimate antidote against hardships and turbulence, regardless of the nature of their etiology. The perception of Biblical figures in all aspects of healing and magic rituals, including the characterization of evil spirits, the identification of benevolent powers against demons, and even the names of materia medica, will be analyzed as an example of the penetration of Biblical lore into popular/traditional cultures and their mythopoesis.
|
Apocryphal Gospels and the Folk Bible
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Florentina Badalanova Geller, Freie Universität Berlin
This paper will be focused on oral and visual renditions of narrative clusters shaping the storyline(s) of some apocryphal Gospels (the Protoevangelium of James/ the Infancy Gospel of James, the Infancy Gospel of Thomas, the Gospel of Nicodemus, etc.) within the larger framework of “the Folk Bible”, with special emphasis on ethno-hermeneutics. Discussion will include not only written editions of texts (manuscripts) but also various attestations in vernacular tradition and iconography, registered during the last two centuries by folklorists and ethnographers. Oral accounts recorded by the author during field research conducted in Eastern Europe (during the Soviet period and later) and archival work will also be treated.
|
Nomina Omina: The Function of Significant Names in the Greek Novels and in Matthew's Gospel
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
John N. Genter, Baylor University
It would be easy to underestimate the extent to which ancient people saw deep signifying potential in personal names. Where modern readers might be predisposed to treat names as arbitrary labels distinguishing one character from another, ancient authors and their readers were attuned to a much wider array of onomastic functions in literature. A carefully deployed personal name could be used in either an etymological or allusive mode to aid characterization, to invite comparisons, and even to signal key motifs of a story. A growing body of scholarship has begun to appreciate that Matthew’s Gospel deploys personal names in subtle, sophisticated, and interpretively important ways. Unfortunately, much of this scholarship has been done in piecemeal fashion without considering the evidence in a focused and relatively comprehensive manner with an eye to Matthew’s overarching tendency. Perhaps more important still, Matthean scholarship has not yet put this growing body of data in touch with the ancient onomastic conventions which lend much prima facie support to the most important insights emerging from this line of inquiry. The present paper remedies this situation in two stages. First, I turn to two second century CE Greek Novels (Xenophon’s Ephesian Tale and Longus’ Daphnis and Chloe) in order to illustrate the rich variety of literary possibilities open to an ancient author interested in significant names. Second, I draw together and engage contemporary scholarship on four significant names in Matthew: Peter, Bar-Jonah, Jesus, and Immanuel. All four names turn out to be nomina omina—portents of future functions within and beyond the narrative. The analysis demonstrates that Matthew’s deployment of personal names does indeed parallel the evidence of the Greek Novels and other ancient literature. It also bears out the fact that a sensitivity to this dimension of the First Gospel has important interpretive payoff for understanding both Matthew’s portrayal of the bearers of these names and the larger ecclesiological and Christological vision of the Gospel.
|
The Place of the Text of the Three in the Textual History of the Bible
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Peter Gentry, Southern Baptist Theological Seminary
A preliminary description of the place of the parent text of the Jewish Revisors of the Septuagint in relation to the textual history of the Hebrew Bible. Rabbinic sources imply that textual plurality continued in the First and Second Centuries CE. What bearing does the evidence of the Three Revisors have on these implications.
|
Advantages of the Goettingen Editions: Focus on Ecclesiastes
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Peter J Gentry, Southern Seminary
This is a paper proposed WITHIN THE FRAMEWORK OF THE GOETTINGEN PANEL DISCUSSION:
The focus of the paper is on the advantages and merits of the Goettingen Edition in relation to LXX Ecclesiastes and methodoloy employed in other Critical Editions.
|
Hermeneutics of Law and Inner Biblical Exegesis
Program Unit: Book of Deuteronomy
Jan Gertz, Ruprecht-Karls-Universität Heidelberg
Reexamination of the recent research on Exodus 21,12-14 and Deuteronomy 19,1-13
|
Scribal Prophecy at Mari: Oracle Compilation, Vertical Reading, and Textual Divination in the Mari Letters
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Justus Theo Ghormley, Valparaiso University
Of the thousands of letters excavated at Mari, about fifty report the activities and oracles of prophets from the region of Mari. These letters offer us a glimpse into the practice of (prophetic) divination in the ancient Near East in the second millennium b.c.e. They also highlight the determinative role that writing as well as scribes (and letter writers) played in interpretation of prophecy. For, the letters that report oracles do not simply relay the message of the prophet passively, but in fact offer a textual interpretation of that message. This is to say, the very act of inscribing a report of divination into a letter is a means of textual divination. The term textual divination refers to a textually focused and textually expressed mode of divination.
The determinative role played by letter writing in the interpretation of oracles is most clearly seen in letters that report more than one oracle. Whenever multiple oracles are compiled in any text, letter or otherwise, these oracles are naturally read in light of each other in a process we could call “vertical reading.” In the case of multiple-oracle-reporting letters from Mari, such vertical reading was often intentional. The scribes (or the letter writers) who composed these letters each compiled and arranged multiple oracles into a single letter to be read as a unified message from the deity. In each case, the details of one oracle were meant to illuminate the meaning of another. A few of these letters have already received some scholarly attention (ARM 26 237; A.1121 + A.2731; and ARM 26 199). Yet others deserve a closer look (ARM 26 194, 196, 200, 207, 208, 209, 212, 216, 219, 221bis, 234, and 239). This paper examines these twelve understudied letters, which report multiple oracles, to better understand how scribes (or, letter writers) used oracle compilation and vertical reading to determine the interpretation of those oracles. Observing how scribes used oracle compilation and vertical reading to interpret oracles in turn sheds some light on the processes that probably lie behind the formation of the prophetic books of the Hebrew Bible.
|
Scribal Theology: A Theological Examination of the Textual Formation of Jeremiah
Program Unit: Theology of the Hebrew Scriptures
Justus Theo Ghormley, Valparaiso University
This paper considers the textual growth of the book of Jeremiah from a theological perspective. This book—or the textual tradition that became this book—has always enjoyed special religious status. From its inception as a collection of prophetic oracles to its reception as scripture by later communities, the book has been conceived of as divine revelation. The scribes who shaped and expanded this book shared this conviction. When they shaped and expanded Jeremiah, they believed they were handling God’s very word. They likely saw themselves as textual diviners, authorized to discern the deity’s will through studying, interpreting and writing revelation.
For this reason, studying the literary history of the book of Jeremiah amounts to an examination of scribal theology. To notice how Jeremiah took shape is to witness textual changes that often reflect theological motivations. Yet, scribes shaped and expanded the book of Jeremiah in many different ways, large and small. Is it misguided to search for theological motivations for all textual developments? To what extent are the different kinds of textual changes observed in Jeremiah theologically motivated?
The purpose of this paper is to address such questions and to consider what might be said about the theological motivations potentially lying behind scribal interventions in the text of Jeremiah. In particular, this paper will focus on the final stages of the book formation, stages attested by a comparison of the long form and the short form of the book.
As is well known, the book of Jeremiah survives in two different forms, a shorter and presumably earlier form attested primarily by the Septuagint, and a longer and later form attested mainly by the Masoretic Text. The longer form is the product of the efforts of many generations of scribes who altered and expanded the text of Jeremiah in many different ways: for example, they relocated the Oracles Against the Nations from the middle of the book to the end, rearranged the order of these oracles, created duplicates of existing verses and couplets, expanded names and titles, and added headings to prophecies. This paper will consider if such alterations might have theological motivations and if so, what might these motivations be.
|
Regathering Too Many Stones? The "Problem" of Elijah's Sacrifice for Deuteronomism in Kings
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Benjamin D. Giffone, LCC International University
Regathering Too Many Stones? The "Problem" of Elijah's Sacrifice for Deuteronomism in Kings
|
Unsettled Amazement: The Uses of thambeō, ekthambeō, and existēmi in Mark and Their Significance for Characterization and the Plot of Mark’s Narrative
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Jen Gilbertson, Briercrest College and Seminary
In Mark’s Gospel, thambeō, ekthambeō and existēmi are some of the verbs which describe the reaction of the crowds and disciples to Jesus’s mighty deeds and teaching (e.g., 1:27; 2:12; 5:42; 6:51; 10:24, 32). They are generally understood in a positive sense and often translated in English with the verb “amaze,” with commentators noting that such a response is appropriate for theophanic encounters. However, when the same verbs are used to describe Jesus’s state of mind, the translations have negative connotations: Jesus is perceived as being “out of his mind” (xistēmi in 3:21) and depicted as being distressed (ekthambeō in 14:33). These translations are appropriate in context for, indeed, the translation “amazed” would be nonsensical in modern English. But what about the other uses of these verbs? Should the reaction of the crowds and disciples to Jesus’s mighty deeds be understood so positively? This paper will argue that θαμβέω, thambeō, ekthambeō and existēmi should be interpreted as more than simple amazement or wonder; the crowds and disciples are unsettled, dumbstruck, and overwhelmed by Jesus’s mighty deeds and teaching which are difficult for them to understand. Not only is such an understanding in line with the use of these word groups in the LXX, it coheres with Mark’s characterization of the crowd and the disciples. Yes, they are amazed by Jesus, but it is clear that they do not comprehend the full import of what he is doing. For example, the disciples’ unsettled amazement is connected to their hard-hearted inability to understand (6:51–52). Furthermore, reading these verbs with connotations of being unsettled or overwhelmed highlights the importance of Jesus’s mighty deeds and teaching. In Jesus’s ministry proclaiming the good news of the kingdom of God (1:14–15), his words and deeds are new, unusual, and bursting the wineskins of their expectations. The response to such words and deeds is not mere wonder, but an unsettled and scared astonishment. This paper employs a narrative approach that attends closely to characterization, repetition, and conflict. Furthermore, this paper presupposes the importance of the OT for understanding Mark’s narrative.
|
Artistic Depictions of Exile in Illuminated Psalters
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Susan Gillingham, University of Oxford
This paper will examine the artistic depictions of the exile in illuminated Psalters. The key psalms will be 74, 79, and 137. We shall observe the tendency to use a more literal visual exegesis in Jewish illustrations compared with more allegorical interpretations in Christian art. These differences highlight distinctive perceptions of land, city and Temple in each tradition.
|
Psalms 22 and 67: Case Studies in Reception History, from Psalms through the Centuries: A Reception History Commentary on Psalms 1-72, Volume Two
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Susan Gillingham, University of Oxford
Invited paper.
|
Lost in the Text(s): The Construction and Deconstruction of the Concubine in Judg 19
Program Unit: Intertextuality and the Hebrew Bible
Susanne Gillmayr-Bucher, Catholic Private University of Linz
The story of the nameless concubine in Judg 19 who is brutalised, raped, dismembered and scattered all over Israel is part of the anarchic times the book of Judges depicts in chapters 17-21. In this era characterised by the repeated formula “everyone did what was right in his own eyes”, it is possible that an Israelite woman is placed on the threshold between “inside” and “outside”, between belonging and being the “other”, only to be destroyed in the end.
The lack of orientation that characterises this era also affects the guidance a narration usually offers to the readers. They are mostly on their own when they try to evaluate the figures or to determine the function and significance of the story. Furthermore, the numerous references to other biblical texts do not clarify the situation but rather add to the ambiguities.
In this paper, I will focus on the concubine and trace the impact of the various intertextual readings on the construction of this figure and her evaluation. The combination of her roles as a concubine (pîlegeš), a young woman (naʿărâ), a daughter and a woman (ʾiššâ), which are purposefully used in the course of the narrative, already creates a diverse image. Considering the intertextual references further adds to this impression as they not only highlight similarities but also significant differences between texts. Thus, analysing the narrative depiction of the concubine with its numerous references to spatial, ritual, social and ethical aspects and motives in other texts leads to a multifaceted image and points out the text’s kaleidoscopic view of this woman. It also becomes clear, that the concubine’s portrayal - like most of the other female figures in the book of Judges - challenges common gender concepts and resists a simple classification.
Furthermore, as the concubine’s fate reflects the image of Israel’s disintegrating society, the construction of this figure also has a severe impact on Israel’s (critical) self-representation in the last chapters of the book of Judges.
|
Retribution and Divine Emotion in the Book of Samuel
Program Unit: Book of Samuel: Narrative, Theology, and Interpretation
Rachelle Gilmour, University of Sydney
This paper will examine the correlation between divine emotion and exceptions to the law of retribution in the Book of Samuel. Influenced by Von Rad and the DtrH theory, the theology of Samuel is usually interpreted within the framework of the Deuteronomistic History, as an explanation and demonstration of God’s retributive punishment upon Israel in the exile for their sin, and the hope of God’s mercy in the future. However, close reading of the book of Samuel suggests that there are a number of exceptions or variations on the straightforward application of the law of retribution. These stories include: God’s intention to prevent the repentance of Eli’s sons in 1 Sam 2:25; the violence of the ark upon innocent people in 1 Sam 6 and 2 Sam 6; the rejection of Saul in 1 Sam 13 and 15; and God’s inciting of David to hold a census in 2 Sam 24, which leads to punishment on all of Israel. In each of these stories, God’s actions are associated with an emotion. Most intriguingly, God’s anger, which is associated elsewhere in the Old Testament with divine punishment for sin, is mentioned twice in the book of Samuel in connection with non-retributive divine violence. Two further instances of divine emotion throughout the book of Samuel are stories of God’s favour: God’s love for Solomon in 2 Sam 12:24, and his mercy on Jerusalem in 2 Sam 24:16. Only once is God associated with an emotion in conjunction with retribution: in 1 Samuel 28:18 it is remembered that God's anger was not carried out against Amalek, relating back to the story of the rejection of Saul. The paper will conclude with discussion on the significance of this correlation for an understanding of God's characterisation in relation to divine violence in the book of Samuel.
|
The Rejection of Saul and the Obscene Underside of the Law
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Rachelle Gilmour, University of Sydney
In this paper, I will examine the rejection of Saul and seek to untangle this central paradox in the narrative: why is Saul rejected but Samuel and David retain God’s favour. Using Slavoj Zizek’s discussion on the obscene underside of the law (Living in the End Times; Trouble in paradise) it will be argued that Samuel and David's corruption and disobedience do not lead to rejection in the same way as Saul’s because Saul has transgressed the unspoken supplement to the law: by having a son, Jonathan, who is not corrupt and is suitable to succeed him; by listening to the voice of the people; and by showing mercy in 1 Sam 15. In the ideology of kingship in the narrative of 1 and 2 Samuel, the “ways of the king” in 1 Sam 8:11-17 may be precisely what God demands rather than prohibits in his king.
|
The Contested Origins of Hanukkah: The Transmission of the Sacred Fire Tradition in Second Maccabees
Program Unit: Transmission of Traditions in the Second Temple Period
Mark Giszczak, Augustine Institute
In order to accomplish his rhetorical goal of encouraging celebration of the Feast of Hanukkah, the author of 2 Maccabees weaves a complex tale, receiving and reworking previous traditions. He includes a letter purportedly from the Jerusalem Jewish authorities, including Judas Maccabeus himself, to the Jews in Egypt (1:10b-2:18). This letter relates two contrasting traditions about the origin of the Second Temple’s sacred flame in order to ground Hanukkah not in Maccabean times, but centuries earlier in the time of Nehemiah. In fact, this letter offers a third option for the name of the celebration, the “feast of the fire”(1:18), rather than the “dedication [of the altar]” (1 Macc 4:59; John 10:22) or the feast of “lights” (Josephus, Antiquities 12.325). By focusing on the miraculous origin of the altar fire, 2 Maccabees seeks to root the new festival in the time of Nehemiah and even further back in the time of Moses and Solomon (2 Macc 2:10). This process of re-interpreting recent events in light of older traditions shows a desire both to assimilate and to repurpose material for a contemporary end, while guarding against the appearance of innovation. That is, the author seeks to “traditionalize” a new feast by rhetorical means, establishing its legitimacy by linking it with the miraculous happenings of the past. Though the author must tacitly acknowledge an interruption of the burning of the perpetual altar fire, his narration of the re-lighting of the fire on the new altar at the Maccabean rededication (10:3) has led to conflicting interpretations as to whether the new fire’s origin is presented as miraculous or not. This paper examines the ways in which 2 Maccabees relays and reworks the traditions of the sacred fire, the origins of Hanukkah and the re-lighting of the flame at the rededication. Further perspective on the content and rhetorical strategy of 2 Maccabees is afforded through comparison with the better-known but much later account recorded in the Talmud (b. Shabbat 21b). Finally, the paper argues for the plausibility of a third option to explain the re-lighting of the sacred flame that relies on the mysterious Persian-approved miraculous fire reported by the second letter (1:31-34).
|
On Manuscripts, Weirdness, and the Pursuit of Radiance
Program Unit: Religious World of Late Antiquity
Gregory Given, Harvard University
At the core of my dissertation lies a methodological problem. Like many colleagues these days, I have been inspired by the methodological insights of the so-called “New Philology,” which holds that we should privilege in our history writing the physical manuscripts that bear our ancient texts over and against hypothetical “original” texts extrapolated into the deeper past. When taken seriously, such an approach centers late antiquity as the beginning of the history of early Christianity, rather than the end of it – the rich hoards of 4th-6th c. manuscripts in Greek, Coptic, and Syriac become valuable loci for writing history of the late antique eastern Mediterranean, even if they become less valuable for reconstructing 1st and 2nd c. “Christian origins.” But how do we apply the radical methodological insights of “New Philology” to the study of texts that are not so well attested among the early manuscripts? In my dissertation I am wrestling with the famously knotty textual traditions of the letters of Ignatius of Antioch. Most of the key witnesses date to the 10th and 11th centuries. Hence the methodological problem: I am attempting to tell a story about how the textual memory of the 2nd century was crafted in the 4th and 5th centuries, in a manner attentive to the unfathomable contingencies of our manuscript evidence, but necessarily relying on manuscripts that date half a millennium later. So what kind of history writing is this, exactly? What is my epistemological ground? Michael Chin has recently articulated the “aesthetic and moral importance of writing histories that include weirdness in their narratives, and that do not explain it away.” What is the project of traditional textual criticism, such as has been performed on Ignatius’s letters and other early Christian texts, if not an exercise in explaining away the weirdness of our texts, as they actually exist in their manuscripts? In this contribution, then, I want to explore Chin’s “radiant historiography” as a mode in which we might conceptualize the value of wrestling directly with the manuscripts for our ancient sources, even – or especially – when they are far removed from the period of time that we are attempting to study. In dialogue with recent work by Liv Ingeborg Lied, Hugo Lundhaug, and Blossom Stefaniw, among others, I will frame the methodological (and epistemological) intervention of “New Philology” – and, especially, its methodological limits – as a valuable corrective in preserving the “force of alterity” that Chin centers in his “radiant historiography.” After all, it is remarkably hard to domesticate and assimilate the past when you radically destabilize the texts that supposedly mediate this past to us.
|
Believing without Seeing, between Autograph and Copy
Program Unit: Student Advisory Board
Gregory Given, Harvard University
Once I fell in love with a parallel. Like most totally captivating, completely unsubstantiated ideas, it came to me late at night, en charrette. I was writing on the Coptic version of Jesus’s reply to Abgar, which survives in some dozen late antique amulets, with evident apotropaic and iatromagical functions. This text begins and ends with self-referential signifiers that seemed to me to be getting at cross-purposes. It begins with a titular heading, “The Copy of the Letter of Jesus Christ…”; it closes with the notice, “It is I, Jesus, who wrote this letter with my very own hand.” The text says that it is written in Jesus’s own hand, yet at the same time draws attention to the fact that it is actually a copy, therefore not *really* written in Jesus’s own hand. What was going on in the head of a scribe when she was writing, with her own hand, “I, Jesus, write this in my own hand”? How did the ancient users of these amulets – who evidently relied on them for health or safety – make sense of this contradiction? What made them sure that the apotropaic power, anchored in the fact of the physical handwriting, could transfer from the autograph to the copies? How could the bearers be sure that there ever was an autograph in the first place? In the face of such questions, my attention was drawn to the core content of the letter between the opening label and the closing signature: “Blessed are you, and goodness will come about for you…Since you have not seen but have believed, you will receive according to your faith.” In marking itself as a copy, the amulet wears on its sleeve the fact that it is not the real thing, but it dares the bearer to believe that it has the same power as the real thing – and that the real thing, in fact, actually existed. Is there not an elegant parallel here to the situation of the historian? In seeking to grasp the possible worlds of the past, all we have are copies of our sources, copies that bear no sure seal of guarantee, that resist our technologies of verification, that constantly remind us of the absence and unknowability of the autograph. As historians, we must acknowledge that copies are all we can know, so we can and should tell the stories of these copies as artifacts in their own right. But like these Coptic texts of Jesus’s reply, our evidence often seems to dare us to believe in things unseen, to stretch beyond the strictly known. Alas, sometimes parallels are too neat. In the sober light of daytime revisions, it occurred to me that there was a dramatic asymmetry on another level. For historians, the unknowability of the autograph is, at worst, a historiographical inconvenience. For the bearers of these amulets, it was literally a matter of life and death. Is it grandiose to try and bridge that gap of staggeringly disproportionate stakes?
|
Presenting the Absent Rhetoric in Biblical Studies Textbooks
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Mark D. Given, Missouri State University
This two part presentation will focus on how to teach rhetoric in the context of undergraduate biblical studies courses. First, I will survey and critique some popular New Testament and Paul introductory textbooks to demonstrate the limited and inadequate ways they introduce rhetorical criticism. Second, I will present examples of how to supplement such textbooks with lecture material, paper assignments, and discussion ideas that provide a more complete perspective on rhetorical criticism that goes beyond formalism to the task of creating a sensitivity to power dynamics in ancient and modern Christian rhetoric.
|
Deuteronomy through the Lens of Kinship: Identity Formation, Solidarity, and Responsibility
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
Mark Glanville, Missional Training Centre, Phoenix
This paper examines the book of Deuteronomy through the lens of kinship, showing how kinship highlights identity formation, solidarity, and responsibility as central themes. It will inquire into kinship in Deuteronomy as a culturally produced system of meaning, the field in which covenant, law, feasting, identity, ethnicity, marginality, and 'religion' are experienced. A brief exegesis of three texts demonstrates that religious experience or identity that was free standing and disconnected from kinship was impossible in the ancient Mediterranean world. Through Deuteronomy's festival calendar (Deut 16:1-17), the weakest in the community are being enfolded as kindred. In a covenant renewal text, the metaphor of 'family' is the vehicle for a partially diffuse people group to become cohesive (Deut 29:9-14). Deuteronomy's social laws required Yahweh's people to take responsibility, as kinsfolk, for those who were without the protection that kinship affords. This paper develops some of the research in my monograph, Adopting the Stranger as Kindred in Deuteronomy (Ancient Israel and its Literature; Atlanta: SBL Press, 2018).
|
The Gēr (Stranger) in Deuteronomy: Family for the Displaced
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Mark Glanville, Missional Training Centre, Phoenix
This paper investigates an ethic of inclusivism for gēr in Deuteronomy. The trend in the recent scholarship identifies the gēr in Deuteronomy as a foreigner. However, a fresh examination of the relevant texts, in light of ethnicity in the Hebrew Bible and anthropology, suggests that term gēr in Deuteronomy simply identifies a vulnerable person who is from outside of the core family. Further, recent scholarship discerns in Deuteronomy efforts to include the gēr within the community as well as limitations upon the inclusion of such people. This paper explores the social-scientific dynamics of inclusion, showing how Deuteronomy's ethical vision for the gēr has to do with kinship: displaced people needed to be incorporated into the clans. Deuteronomy not only stipulates a system of protection for the gēr, but the central impulse of Deuteronomy's vision, expressed in a multiplicity of ways, is to foster his/her incorporation as kindred, specifically within the household, within the clan, and within the nation. This vision is achieved via the interplay of the various subgroups of laws, namely social law, law of judicial procedure, and feasting texts. Also, in Deuteronomy's framework (chs 1-11, 27-34), as Israel was re-constituted, the incorporation into the 'nation' of those who had been separated from patrimony and from kindred was a primary goal. This paper summarises some of the research in my forthcoming monograph, Adopting the Stranger as Kindred in Deuteronomy (Ancient Israel and its Literature; Atlanta: SBL Press, 2018).
|
Jeremiah’s Oracles of Violence as Therapeutic Efforts to Reconceptualize a God of Care (pqd)
Program Unit: Writing/Reading Jeremiah
Oliver Glanz, Andrews University
Jeremiah’s many oracles against Judah, Jerusalem, and the foreign nations belong to one of the most violent oracles found in the Hebrew Bible. For the modern reader, it is particularly discomforting that the author of ultimate violence is regularly identified with YHWH himself. Jeremiah displays a God who is furious and prophesizes aggressive fantasies of uncontrolled destruction. YHWH desires to burn down Jerusalem, sends sword, famine, and pestilence and executes genocides without regret. A closer reading of those violent texts, however, brings to the fore emotional incoherencies. For example, while YHWH’s anger calls his servant Nebuchadnezzar to destroy the southern kingdom (Jer 25:9-11), he simultaneously sympathizes with the suffering of the Judean population and calls for a full destruction of Babylon (Jer 25:12-14; 50:14-19,28; 51:11,34-36; etc). While YHWH threatens to burn the city with fire, he warns Zedekiah to not burn Jerusalem (Jer 17:27 vs. 38:23 [MT]). While he foretells with deuteronomistic aggression that he is returning his people into the slavery of Egypt, he accuses the Judean remnant of immigrating to Egypt and rejecting his warnings (Jer 42:15-16,18-19 vs. Deut 28:62-68; Jer 43:5-7). In addition, a comparison of Jeremiah’s oracles with his historical narratives suggest, that word and action, i.e. prophecies of horror and the playing out of history are not fully in sync. While redaction critical approaches can help to explain some of these incongruencies, the professional eye of the psychologist might see in them obvious mechanisms of managing emotional pain.
In the face of increasing religious, economic, racial, and sexual violence, new subdisciplines in psychology and neuroscience have been formed in the last 10 years (Slakovskis, Hamby, DeWall, etc.: psychology of violence; Hankoff, Fields, etc.: neuroscience of violence). Our paper, then, seeks to approach the matter of violence in the book of Jeremiah from an interdisciplinary perspective. A text-empiric reading (Hardmeier, Talstra), that seeks to identify text-linguistic (in)coherence and interpretative challenges, is brought into dialogue with recent findings in the psychology of violence. The authors represent the disciplines of biblical scholarship (Oliver Glanz, PhD) and psychiatry (Torben Bergland, MD) and suggest, that an interdisciplinary exploration of Jeremiah’s oracles of violence can contribute to a reconceptualization of Jeremiah’s theology. They will present the thesis, that Jeremiah’s oracles of violence can be thought of as therapeutic efforts in which the fantasies of violence help to prevent a physical execution of violence. Consequently, Jeremiah’s emphasis on a God who cares (pqd [with its negative and positive meaning]: no other prophet uses the pqd-concept so frequently) is reframed through the glasses of the psychology of violence.
|
Trajectories of the Levantine Household from Late Bronze Age I to the Persian Period
Program Unit: Economics in the Biblical World
Zipporah Glass, Huston-Tillotson University
Our purpose is to pursue trajectories of the Levantine household over the dynamics of economic system, legal structure, environ-based architectural house type, and historical period using socio-economic modeling to focus upon food security within each setting. Our trajectories move from (1) the pre-state traditional economy based in customary law, Late Bronze Age I, southern Levantine architectural type of the ‘central courtyard house,’ to (2) that of the command state economy actuated on statutory law, Iron Age, Levantine architectural type of the ‘four-room house’ and its variants, to (3) the imperial state economy centered on imperial law, Persian period, sixth - fourth centuries B.C.E., with discrete Levantine architectural house types. Our project, then, views the transformation of the Levantine household over dynamics situated in political economy, and thus deviates from culture-history paradigms concerned primarily with ur-types or volksgeist, and departs from functional/adaptive paradigms that can make static such correlates as land, labor, and ecology.
|
Gleanings from Jewish Exegesis on David's Last Testament and Its Fulfillment (1 Kings 2)
Program Unit: Jewish Interpretation of the Bible
David Glatt-Gilad, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
The text describing King David’s deathbed charge to his successor Solomon and the latter’s execution of his father’s instructions (1 Kings 2) has elicited a lively debate in contemporary scholarship, pitting those scholars who take the text as representing classic royal apologetics against those who view it as expressing criticism toward the excesses of David and Solomon. Traditional Jewish exegesis (from the classical rabbinic sources through the late medieval period) does not explicitly challenge David’s or Solomon’s moral compass. Still in all, one finds a surprising latitude of variation in this literature vis-à-vis David’s harsh directives and Solomon’s equally harsh compliance. Alongside retellings that attempt to soften the vindictive aspect of David’s testament, other sources portray Joab and Shimei in far more honorable terms than David’s own description of them as despicable scoundrels, thus at least implicitly raising the question of whether David could have acted more magnanimously. My paper will aim at explicating these nuanced interpretations, and where possible, relating them to trends in contemporary scholarly discourse regarding the last troubling chapter of David’s life.
|
Science Versus Religion? Reasons for Rejecting Ptolemy in Christian Antiquity
Program Unit: Early Exegesis of Genesis 1–3
Benjamin Gleede, University of Zurich
That the OT conceived of the world as a flat disc based on pillars and covered by a dome-like heaven is not the most obvious conclusion to draw from its mostly poetical and metaphorical utterings about cosmography. Nevertheless, there was a host of Christian authors who made this inference already in Antiquity and thus rejected the Ptolemean world view dominant in the Greco-Roman context. However, this was in most cases much more than an attempt to silence scientific reason by scriptural authory. Instead, the Greco-Roman world view had a quite explicit religious subtext which was the real target of the diverse Christian attacks.
|
Writing a Commentary on 1 Peter
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
W. Edward Glenny, University of Northwestern – St. Paul (MN)
I am currently writing the commentary on 1 Peter for the Evangelical Exegetical Commentary Series (Lexham Press). The purpose of this presentation is to share some of my experiences in this endeavor that might be of interest and help to others and for me to learn through the experiences of others who are involved in a similar project. There are three main emphases of my commentary, and I will develop each one briefly and then consider how they complement each other. The commentary I am writing, in keeping with the series title, is exegetical. I take that to mean that it is primarily concerned with the language of the text of 1 Peter in its literary and historical context. Secondly, this commentary is concerned with biblical theology. The letter of 1 Peter evidences an unusual dependence on the Old Testament. In fact, for its size it is difficult to find another Christian document that incorporates as much material from the Old Testament. This material provides the theological substructure of the letter and makes wide-ranging connections with theological themes and motifs throughout the rest of Scripture. One of my goals is to mine that biblical theology and let it provide the foundation for my interpretation of the text of the letter. Third, my commentary is concerned about the canonical context of 1 Peter within the Catholic Epistles collection, the New Testament, and the whole of Scripture. I am more cautious and tentative in this area than in the first two, because there is no generally accepted method for reading a book canonically and the value of canonical exegesis for interpretation is debated. However, I am convinced that interpreters miss some of the flavor of the message of a biblical book is they ignore the various levels of its canonical connections.
|
Left for Dead: Scheintod in the Greco-Roman Novels and Acts
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Daniel B. Glover, Baylor University
One of the fascinating aspects of the Greco-Roman novels is the Scheintod (apparent death) motif. According this motif, a main character experiences a violent or fatal series of events, and she is presumed dead. In several instances, she is also buried. However, as the story progresses, the reader and the other main characters discover that the one presumed dead is, in fact, alive. The Greco-Roman novels have varying degrees of complicated explanations to describe how the character survived the fatal events. Few explanations are as elaborate as those in Achilles Tatius’s novel, for example, while Chariton’s descriptions are described in much less detail. Nevertheless, we find this narrative device in almost all of the “canonical” novels. As Richard Pervo has noted, this motif is present in Acts as well, though the explanations are lacking. The two most prominent examples of the Scheintod motif in Acts are the stoning of Paul (14:1-20) and the raising of Eutychus (20:9-12). Many scholars and commentators have recognized the parallels between these events and the Scheintod motif. However, most scholars have not allowed the recognition of Luke’s use of the Scheintod motif affect their reading of the narrative. That is, they do not read these scenes as instances of Scheintod. This is particularly a problem in connection to characterization. An ancient audience familiar with the novels would undoubtedly have recognized this motif at play here. In the novels, the character who apparently dies and rises again is portrayed as divine. This becomes a significant problem for interpreters in the episode of Paul’s stoning at Lystra because, just prior to Paul’s own Scheintod, the Lystrans presume Paul and Barnabas to be gods on the basis of their healing of a lame man. Paul, however, strongly denies their claims. Yet when Paul apparently dies and rises again, the ancient audiences would naturally have associated this with divinizing of the sort that occurs in the novels. What I, therefore, suggest in this paper is that Paul’s concern with the Lystrans’ claim is not simply about Paul’s ontological status so much as it is about giving worship and glory to whom it is properly due. This frees up Luke to depict Paul not as theos (that is, a god) but as theios (that is, divine). To accomplish this, I perform a “close reading” of Achilles Tatius’s Leucippe and Clitophon and Acts 14:1-20. I then apply the interpretive insights regarding characterization and plot development gleaned from my reading of Achilles Tatius to the Book of Acts. What results is a “divine” Paul, who is above all others—apostles included—beloved by God.
|
"The Parousia of the Anointed One" (2 Bar. 30:1): Paul as a Participant in Jewish Apocalyptic Discourse during the First Century CE
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Matthew Goff, Florida State University
The starting point of this paper is my article on 1 and 2 Corinthians in relation to the Jewish apocalyptic tradition that appeared in The Jewish Apocalyptic Tradition and the Shaping of New Testament Thought (Reynolds and Stuckenbruck, 2017). In this paper I do not simply review this article but rather use it, and my engagement with New Testament scholarship on Paul when writing it, to reflect on how scholars approach the topic of Paul vis-à-vis Jewish apocalypticism. One common approach is to present Jewish apocalyptic eschatology as comprising dichotomies that Paul collapses or sublimates. It is helpful to understand Paul not as transcending Jewish apocalypticism but as a participant in it. He did not simply inherit an array of Jewish apocalyptic traditions which he radically altered. Jewish apocalypticism was alive and well in the first century CE. In key ways Paul is fully in line with major Jewish apocalyptic tropes from the period, with regard to both eschatology and messianism. I demonstrate this point by comparing 1 Corinthians 15 with 2 Baruch, a roughly contemporary Jewish apocalypse.
|
Apocalypticism: A Decentralized Social Phenomenon
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Matthew Goff, Florida State University
This paper deals with apocalypticism in relation to social structures. Various types of community structures have been understood as critical for the formation and flourishing of apocalypticism. Vielhauer in 1964 famously described apocalyptic literature as “conventicle” literature, produced by disenfranchised, marginal groups. Horsely has more recently argued that apocalypticism is the product of radicalized scribes. I stress in this paper that apocalypticism should be understood as a decentralized phenomenon. Claims of access to esoteric, heavenly knowledge, which are at the core of apocalyptic thought, are easy to produce and constitute an important form of social capital for those who are understood to control access to this knowledge. For this reason not one single type of community should be understood as the context in which apocalyptic literature originated or became popular. Apocalyptic motifs flourished in a variety of social circles, including scribal networks, sectarian groups and the pedagogical contexts in which teachers and students interacted.
|
The Implosion of Sin in Deconstructing Double Alienation: A Socio-cultural Reading of Romans 7:7–25
Program Unit: Asian and Asian-American Hermeneutics
Meng Hun Goh, Taiwan Graduate School of Theology
Coming from a group-oriented and peer-pressure culture in Taiwan where honor is a collective and primary value that shapes people’s interaction with each other in the public sphere, I find Paul’s discussion of sin, law, life, and death in Romans 7:7-25 reflecting the power of ideology upon people’s understanding and representation of themselves in the public. As such, when Paul wrote, “I do not understand my own actions. For I do not do what I want, but I do the very thing I hate” (7:15; NRSV), he was not addressing an individual, private, or psychological struggle. Rather, he was confronting and exposing the power of sin upon people. That is to say, Paul was dealing with the social issue of double consciousness, in which people, under wrong ideology, cannot help but to see themselves through a foreign lens, resulting in self-alienation. Under the gaze of others, one cannot do what one desires, but has to perform for the approval of others. This pressure to act otherwise turns people into an abjection that they want to vomit but cannot, because distorted by double consciousness, they are enculturated to internalize and embody what they hate. Here, the frustration and anger of Franz Fanon in addressing the double alienation of epidermalization are reverberating. As Paul wrote, “For I do not do the good I want, but the evil I do not want is what I do (7:19), we see that when sin distorts the commandment that is holy, just, and good (7:12), the life that is promised by the commandment can end up becoming “death to me” (7:10). Given this circumstance, Paul thus wrote, “So I find it to be a law that when I want to do what is good, evil lies close at hand” (7:21). There seems to be no exit out of this quandary. Paul can only exclaim, “Wretched man that I am! Who will rescue me from this body of death?” (7:24). Paul, however, finds the answer in “Jesus Christ our Lord” (7:25) in the sense of Jean-Luc Nancy’s notion of implosion, in which God sent “his own Son in the likeness of sinful flesh” to deal with sin and to condemn sin in the flesh (8:3). To expose the Roman Empire’s ideology, contradiction must be foregrounded. This is why Jesus was sent “in the likeness of sinful flesh” to conscientize people to see the operation of sin so that they may see the cracks and faults in their worldview. Such a socio-cultural reading of Romans 7:7-25 comes to the fore in a very ideologically-contested environment in Taiwan where people are divisively split along the party line. To address such dualistic opposition between two major political parties, people have to see the contradiction in each party so that they may not be simply bound to their supported party without being self-critical.
|
Translating 4 Ezra: Problems and Prospects
Program Unit: International Syriac Language Project
Binyamin Goldstein, Yeshiva University
In contrast to the comparatively large body of scholarship on the content of 4 Ezra, studies on issues encountered in its translation are markedly fewer. Unlike the majority of the other Peshitta texts in the Antioch Bible Project, the Syriac text is the oldest witness of the work in question. It thus presents us with a unique set of problems and options as translators. While nearly all other modern translations of 4 Ezra consider the totality of the witnesses, attempting to represent a reconstructed original, our work considers the Syriac text alone. As such, we must give different weight to textual evidence from other versions (such as the Latin) than we would if we were simply producing a new translation of the 4 Ezra text. Instances of obvious textual corruption are one major crux at which we as translators must make difficult decisions.
In this paper we will discuss some of the individual issues that we have encountered in our work on this project, and some of the methods by which we have attempted to arrive at a sound balance on the Formal Equivalent-Dynamic Equivalent scale.
|
Towards a New Understanding of the Defining Features of Rabbinic Midrash
Program Unit: Midrash
Matthew Goldstone, Jewish Theological Seminary of America
My proposed paper seeks to challenge the widespread assumption held by scholars across the Humanities that a defining feature of Midrash is the proffering of multiple, sometimes contradictory, interpretations of the Biblical text. Particularly pronounced in the wake of postmodern reading practices, this feature of rabbinic Midrash diverges from many other forms of literature and thus garnered attention, leading to an exaggeration of the centrality of this characteristic. Consequently, Midrash is frequently conceptualized as an open-ended process that lauds polysemy. In opposition to this common premise, I demonstrate that the propensity to maintain multiple, irreconcilable interpretative possibilities is in fact a somewhat marginal aspect of the extant midrashic collections. Far more prominent in these works are the negation of potential meanings and the underlying assumption of a single authoritative reading of biblical sources. Through a quantitative comparison of the examples in which Midrashim propose multiple interpretations and the overwhelming number of cases in which these works assert a singular understanding, this paper redefines the way we think about the essential features of the genre of Midrash. I bolster this argument with a brief qualitative study of the analytical techniques employed by these Midrashim to arrive at interpretations of scriptural verses framed in light of Umberto Eco’s "The Limits of Interpretation" and Brunella Antomarini’s "Thinking Through Error."
After presenting my quantitative argument and surveying the multiple ways through which early Midrashim limit interpretative possibilities, I turn to a comparison with other exegetical traditions in Late Antiquity. I suggest that while the Dead Sea Scrolls (particularly the Pesharim) and early Christian interpretative works also employ limitation of possible meanings, there is a significant difference between these exegetical texts and Midrash. The Pesharim and early Christian interpretations tend to employ implicit rejections of meaning by asserting the proper understanding of a passage. By contrast, a common feature in early rabbinic Midrashim is the explicit positing and rejection of possible interpretations. This comparison suggests that the explicit rejection of interpretive possibilities is a defining feature of Midrash that distinguishes it from other works of interpretation in Late Antiquity.
|
Linguistic and Masoretic Perspectives on Selected Examples of Word Interchange and Synonymous Readings
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Viktor Golinets, Hochschule für Jüdische Studien Heidelberg
There are many types of word interchange in the texts of the Hebrew Bible. The most prominent type is the interchange of sacred names. Sometimes the variation occurs in collocations like, e.g., מֵאֶרֶץ מִצְרָיִם and מִמִּצְרָיִם as well as בְּנֵי יִשְׂרָאֵל and בֵּית יִשְׂרָאֵל, but it is also found between singular words. Various parts of speech are prone to the interchange or confusion of words. If such a variance is attested between different textual witnesses, it may be described as a case of word interchange. If it occurs it the same textual witnesses, than a case of synonymous readings may be at hand.
In some places, the forms of the Masoretic text are commented in the Masoretic notes. The purpose of a note is to secure specific readings and preclude confusion of forms. The interchange of synonyms or semantically related words is attested even in Masorah magna notes themselves. The paper studies examples of interchange of words from linguistic and Masoretic perspectives.
|
Translating Narrative Wayhi in Paraleipomenon: Archaizing or Modernizing by the Translator, in the Vorlage, or in the MT?
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Roger Good, Living Stream Ministry
In past narrative the structure wayhi with a temporal adverbial followed by a wayyiqtol form is frequently used to introduce a temporal clause in classical Biblical Hebrew. It is much rarer in late Biblical Hebrew and is no longer used in Rabbinic Hebrew, being replaced by a temporal adverbial and an asyndetic qatal. In Chronicles the archaic structure of wayhi with a temporal adverbial followed by a wayyiqtol form mostly occurs in passages parallel to Samuel–Kings; and a later structure of a temporal adverbial and an asyndetic qatal mostly occurs in passages unique to Chronicles. Occasionally the archaic structure is even replaced by the later structure in parallel verses (1 Kings 9:1-2 para 2 Chr 7:11-12). This distinction probably reflects the preference for the latter structure in later and vernacular Hebrew. The Greek text of Paraleipomenon (Rahlfs or Göttingen) mostly mirrors the temporal structures found in the MT. The archaic structure wayhi with a temporal adverbial followed by a wayyiqtol form is translated by kai egeneto with a temporal adverbial and an apodotic kai with an indicative form (which is an awkward structure in Greek, with the second kai being redundant). Occasionally there are plusses or minuses comparing Paraleipomenon with the MT.
This paper particularly focuses on these aberrant examples (plusses or minuses) and whether the plusses are due to the translator (or scribes copying the text) archaizing (according to his familiarity with wayhi structures in Biblical texts) and the minuses are due to modernizing (following the lack of wayhi structures in the vernacular Hebrew of his day) or whether these plusses or minuses are because of differences between the Vorlage and the MT. This paper is a preliminary part of an excursus for the SBL commentary on the book of Paraleipomenon and illustrates some principles of dealing with the translator’s handling of archaic literary structures in the language and with plusses and minuses.
|
Why Not Matthew's Use of Luke?
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Mark Goodacre, Duke University
A recent resurgence in support for Matthean Posteriority (Alan Garrow; Rob Macewen) builds on the secure footing of Marcan Priority alongside growing skepticism about Q. Could it be that advocates of the Farrer Theory have the direction of dependence wrong, and that Matthew knew Luke? The case for Matthean Posteriority refreshes the discussion of the Synoptic Problem by providing a new and interesting challenge, but the case for Luke’s use of Matthew remains strong: (a) Matthew’s redactional fingerprints repeatedly appear in material he shares with Luke; (b) Luke often shows “fatigue” in his versions of double tradition material; (c) Luke betrays knowledge of Matthean literary structures; and (d) Matthew fails to include congenial Lucan details on politics, personnel, and geographical context.
|
A Seventeenth Century Rabbinical Controversy Concerning the Divine Epithet Adonai and the Vowels of the Tetragrammaton
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Nehemia Gordon, Makor Hebrew Foundation
In this paper, I will discuss a controversy between the grammarian Rabbi Shabbethai Sofer of Przemysl (c.1565-c.1635) and the halakhist Rabbi Meir Ben Gedaliah (Maharam) of Lublin (1558-1618). The controversy is concerning the correct pronunciation of the divine epithet Adonai and the function of the vowels in the Tetragrammaton found in some manuscripts of the Masoretic Text. I will explain that this controversy was a clash between Sofer's reliance on grammatical rules, derived from standard Tiberian Hebrew, and Maharam's reliance on what may have been a non-Tiberian pronunciation tradition. To illustrate this, I will bring parallels to Maharam's position in earlier rabbinical literature and Babylonian Pointed manuscripts of the Hebrew Bible.
|
Martin Luther King, Jr. as Prophetic Interpreter of Prophetic Paul
Program Unit: Bible and Cultural Studies
Michael J. Gorman, St. Mary’s Seminary & University
From about 1956 to about 1963, Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr. preached various versions of a sermon entitled “Paul’s Letter to American Christians,” based in part on a similar sermon by Rev. Frederick Meek. It is included in King’s collection of sermons entitled Strength to Love. King’s sermon extols America’s “scientific and technological progress” before questioning America’s “moral and spiritual progress.” This paper will proceed in four steps. First, it will situate the sermon in the social and ecclesial context of the era and the context of King’s rapidly expanding ministry. Second, it will trace the letter’s structure and themes. Third, it will catalog and analyze King’s use of Pauline texts as well as non-Pauline texts utilized in support of his major claims. This longest part of the paper will include consideration of King’s symbiosis of biblical prophecy and Pauline theology in support of nonviolence. This section will also briefly contextualize King’s exegesis within currents in academic Pauline theology from the early 1950s to the early 1960s. And fourth, the paper will reflect on the possibilities for, and limits of, King’s interpretation of Paul in contemporary social and ecclesial contexts, connecting King’s interpretation of Paul to selected contemporary views of Paul.
|
Matthew's Coordinating Tryptics: Matthew 4:17 and 16:21 Revisited in Light of the Matthean Genealogy
Program Unit: Matthew
Shane Patrick Gormley, Loyola University of Chicago
Proposals to delineate the structure of Matthew’s Gospel abound; no single theory unites scholars’ understanding of the broad outline to the New Testament’s first Gospel. Despite the lack of consensus, we may still heartily affirm W. D. Davies’s assertion that the Matthean evangelist exhibits both “a meticulous concern” for detail and “an architectonic grandeur” for the whole. More recent studies have continued to highlight the literary characteristics of Matthew, showing the value of approaching Matthew as literature. M. E. Boring’s and U. Luz’s analyses of Matthew’s literary structure have further reminded us that the Gospel should be understood as “a complex of interlocking structures with more than one movement present in the text at the same time,” and that the author was more concerned with “a seamless narrative flow than in clear caesurae.” Building upon and within such convictions, with this paper I propose to take a nuanced look at the structure of Matthew’s Gospel. I do not propose to ask, “What is the structure of Matthew’s Gospel?” but instead to investigate the significance of an important structural feature in the way Matthew tells Jesus’s story.
In the 1970s, J. D. Kingsbury advanced a proposal that the structure of Matthew’s Gospel hinged on the two occurrences of apo totes ērxato ho Iēsous (4:17; 16:21), producing a three-fold structure. For Kingsbury, this structure illumined both Matthew’s purpose in writing as well as his understanding of salvation history. D. R. Bauer, a student of Kingsbury, later attempted to substantiate this three-fold structure with a thorough and detailed analysis of several features of Matthew’s narrative. Kingsbury and Bauer were not the only scholars to delineate a three-fold structure for Matthew, but their work is the most often cited (and criticized) for advancing this structure.
I suggest that an important nuance can be added to these proposals in order to highlight more vividly the significance of 4:17 and 16:21. In 1976 H. Waetjen suggested that Matthew’s genealogy provided the “key” to Matthew’s Gospel. Waetjen focused on the genealogy’s eccentricities and curiosities in order to explain Jesus’s own origin and subsequent story. This paper proposes that Matthew’s genealogy does indeed provide “the key” to Matthew, but in a different way. Namely, the explicit three-fold structure of the genealogy mimics a plausible three-fold structure to the narrative that follows (1:2-6a // 1:18-4:16; 1:6b-11 // 4:17-16:20; 1:12-16 // 16:21-28:20). The genealogy, I argue, stands at the beginning of the Gospel as an interpretive lens through which readers then encounter the Gospel as a whole. By beginning with a condensed, systematized story of Israel, the evangelist invites his audience to read the story of Jesus in light of the story of Jesus’s people. Israel’s story not only reaches its climax in Jesus—its story is reembodied, and brought to a new resolution, in Jesus. In describing the detail of this proposal, the paper also helps to illumine certain exegetical questions of Matthew’s Gospel, as well as to answer some of the criticisms of Kingsbury’s and Bauer’s previous proposals.
|
Issues of Disability and Gender in the Healing Accounts of Mark 5:21–43
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Louise Gosbell, Mary Andrews College
In Mark 5:21-43, the gospel writer includes a coupling of two healing stories, that of the woman with bleeding and Jairus’ daughter. The parallels between the stories are not limited to the fact that both healing recipients are women, but rather, there are a range of semantic and thematic similarities between the two healing accounts which seem to indicate that the two stories were placed together in order to illuminate each other. These similarities include: the repitition of the number 12 in both healing accounts, the significance of touch as the mode of healing and seeking healing, both women being referred to as “daughters” as well as the fact that in both cases their healing is described in terms of the verb σῴζω. And yet, simultaneously, the woman with bleeding and Jairus’ daughter are also depicted as, according to Ched Myers, “archetypal opposites in terms of economic status and honour.” But in addition to this, Mary Rose D’Angelo has suggested that what connects these two accounts is that both women are suffering from opposing gender-specific imbalances in light of the humoral system used to categorise health in the ancient world: while the woman with the flow of blood is too wet, evidenced by her profuse bleeding, the second woman, could likely represent the other extreme, that of the uterus which is too dry. In this paper I would like to build upon Mary Rose D’Angelo’s proposal of the imbalance of the two women, and the social implications of these imbalances especially when read with a disability lens. I would also like to explore the proposal of Candida Moss (building on the work of Adella Yarbro Collins) that the healing of the woman with bleeding occurs through the process of drying out her too moist body in preparation for the celibacy of the future kingdom. A close reading of the Markan text highlights not only important gender-related language (woman, daughter, maiden) but also has important implications for our understanding of the relationship between disability and gender in the ancient world.
|
The Senses and Sensory Impairment in the Fourth Gospel
Program Unit: Senses, Cultures, and Biblical Worlds
Louise Gosbell, Mary Andrews College
In her work The Senses of Scripture: Sensory Perception in the Hebrew Bible, Yael Avrahami proposes that throughout the Hebrew Bible, the senses are not described as merely perfunctory abilities of the body, but rather, the sensory organs are the means through which humanity experiences life: knowledge of the world and of God comes through the fullness of the sensory experience. More than this, the sensory experience works through an accumulative action of the senses as a means of understanding and responding to various stimuli which she says is made apparent through a clustering together of various examples of sensory-related terms in such a way as to reveal a “conceptual link” between them. Avrahami proposes that in the West, we are used to the pentasensory model of the senses, but that the Hebrew Bible presents a septasensory model of the senses: to the traditional five senses, Avrahami adds speech and kinaesthesia, which refers to movement, especially the way the body moves in its environment, as part of the sensory experience. Avrahami contends that the Hebrew Bible depicts an interconnected experience of the senses which she refers to as the sensorium – the full multi-sensory experience. The senses are not merely tools through which the body sends and receives sensory signals, but rather, in the Hebrew Bible the functionality of the senses is also related to the overall functionality of the body. But as a consequence of this, Avrahami sees sensory impairment as wholly negative experience. Indeed, she contends that because the fully-functional sensorium is representative of the fullness of the human experience, by extension, those who are lacking in sensory functionality are also lacking in this same experience and wisdom. This paper seeks to explore the extent to which this representation of the senses in the Hebrew Bible serves as a backdrop to the representations of the senses and sensory impairment in the Fourth Gospel. How does the author of the Fourth Gospel represent the role of the senses? To what extent can we assess whether sensorial imagery in the Fourth Gospel is being used literally or metaphorically or is such a divide even necessary or possible? What are the consequences for people with sensory impairments in the Fourth Gospel? Is it significant that the two major healing accounts in the Gospel of John are both men with sensory impairments according to Avrahami’s septasensory model? (The man born blind (ch. 9) is vision impaired while the man at the pool of Bethsaida is mobility (or in Avrahami’s vocabulary) kinesthetically impaired).
|
The Hebrew Vorlage of the Pentateuchal Targums
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Leeor Gottlieb, Bar-Ilan University
It is well known that the traditional Jewish Targums reflect the Hebrew version that was later to become known as the Masoretic Text. However, from between the lines of the Targums one may detect apparent variants in comparison with MT as we know it. In the course of work on my Equivalent Project (on the Targums of the Pentateuch), a list of possible variants has begun to emerge. In this paper I will examine suspected variants in the various Targums to Genesis and attempt to describe the character of the Vorlagen used by the Jewish translators. This discussion will lead to what I think is a more precise understanding of the Hebrew text of the Torah in the first millennium, centuries before the Masoretic Text was named as such.
|
Deciphering the Sana'a Palimpsest
Program Unit: The Qur’an: Manuscripts and Textual Criticism (IQSA)
Mohsen Goudarzi, Harvard University
The palimpsest known as Sana’a 1 is of singular importance for the early history of the Qur’an, because its lower text is the only substantial witness to the existence of non-ʿUthmānic text-types. Behnam Sadeghi and I published the first edition of this text in 2012. Our edition was based primarily on high-quality normal light and ultraviolet (UV) images of folios at Sana’a’s House of Manuscripts (Dār al-Makhṭūṭāt) taken under the direction of Christian Robin and the late Sergio Noja Noseda. Recently Asma Hilali published a second edition of the lower text using the same sets of images. However, her edition consistently recovers less of the text, as a result of which she repeatedly notes her inability to find vestiges of our reconstructions. The first part of this presentation therefore explains how we managed to recover a greater portion of the lower text, introducing the technique of digital stacking and repeated shifting from a normal image to a UV image of the same folio. This technique will hopefully facilitate the study of Sana’a 1 by other scholars, who can now obtain images of this palimpsest from the internet. ******************** In addition to offering a methodology for tracing Sana’a 1’s lower text, the presentation uses the new data thus extracted to shed light on two interrelated aspects of the early history of the Qur’anic text, namely, the function of the basmala and the relation between sūras eight (al-Anfāl) and nine (al-Tawba). In particular, certain traditions suggest that the basmala was seen to mark not only the beginning of a specific chapter but also the end of the previous one [1]. This understanding of basmala seems to have led some to the idea that the text of al-Tawba forms the second part of Sūrat al-Anfāl—as the first verse of al-Tawba was not preceded immediately by the basmala [2]. I argue that Sana’a 1 attests to a creative strategy for countering this idea. In this palimpsest (folio 5A, ll. 7-9), the transition between al-Anfāl and al-Tawba features first the basmala and then the command to “not say bi-smi llāh.” This may have been a solution for ensuring that the two sūras are seen as distinct chapters, and at the same time forestalling the immediate recitation of the basmala before al-Tawba. I also explore other interpretations of these lines and conclude with broader reflections on the character of the Sana’a palimpsest.
|
Canonical Texts in Greek Religion: From Orpheus to Homer
Program Unit: Development of Early Christian Theology
Fritz Graf, The Ohio State University
Greek religion had no ‘sacred’ texts in the sense that Christianity has its canon of scripture, although some religious groups could find a focus in a text, such as the theogony of Orpheus allegorized in the Derveni Papyrus (late 5th century BCE). In my contribution, I will analyze this situation and confront it also with Roman religious culture where the Sibylline books were a crucial (pseudepigraphical) sacred text. I will also show how the Homeric poems became canonical texts in Greek elite education, how they could be regarded (and soon also rejected) as foundational for Greek religious thought, and even gained a ritual role as divinatory texts
|
“YHW, the God of Heaven”: An Incipient interpretatio persica of YHW into Ahuramazda?
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Gard Granerød, MF Norwegian School of Theology
In the so-called Elephantine documents, the phrase “the God of heaven” seems to have been used both by Elephantine Judaeans and by Persian officials as an epithet for YHW or alone with YHW as the contextual reference. Moreover, in the HB/OT, the epithet “the God of heaven” is mostly found in texts from the Persian and Hellenistic periods (Gen 24:3, 7; Jonah 1:9; Ps 136:26; 2 Chr 36:23; Ezra 1:2; 5:11; 7:12, 21, 23; Neh 1:4–5; 2:4, 20; Dan 2:18, 37, 44, cf. also Deut 4:39; Josh 2:11; 2Chr 20:6; Lam 3:41; Dan 2:28).
¶
The paper explores the following thesis: The phrase “the God of heaven” as used in the so-called Elephantine documents (and probably as used in the HB/OT also) represents a case of incipient interpretatio persica of the originally Judaean god YHW.
¶
In an Achaemenid–Egyptian context, the interpretatio persica was substantially helped by the iconographic motif of the winged symbol. In the Achaemenid period, the winged symbol was used in different contexts, and the media that mediated the concept were both material, textual, and aural/oral. (i) It was used in (royal) Achaemenid iconography used in an Achaemenid–Egyptian context (e.g., Darius I’s seal found in Thebes, and the so-called Arshama/Irshama seal). (ii) It was used in in traditional royal Egyptian iconography and ideology (e.g., the “Legend of Horus of Behutet and the Winged Disk,” and royal iconography in which Horus-of-Behdet is depicted as being in charge of the protection of the pharaoh). (iii) It was used in hybrid Achaemenid–Egyptian iconography and inscriptions, in which Ahuramazda in reality is equalled with Horus-of-Behdet (e.g., the Suez Canal stelas of Darius I).
¶
There are many other examples of similar processes in which deities potentially could be and actually were “translated into” (C. Cornell) other cultures and thereby identified with a deities from an originally distinct and foreign pantheon (e.g., the interpretatio graeca of Chemosh, Melqart,, and Milkom).
|
The Book of Lamentations in the Persian (and Hellenistic) Period(s)
Program Unit: Literature and History of the Persian Period
Gard Granerød, MF Norwegian School of Theology
According to, e.g., K. Koenen and C. Frevel, the composition of Lamentations with its four acrostic poems (Lam 1–4) and its alphabet-long fifth poem (Lam 5) took place over several centuries. Assumedly, Lam 2 was composed in the so-called exilic period as a more or less immediate response to the catastrophe in 586 BCE. Shortly thereafter, Lam 2 was augmented by Lam 4 and Lam 1 and together they became the so-called ekha-composition (after the opening phrase in the three poems). Later on, Lam 3 with its significant different (theological) take on the questions of sin and suffering was composed and added. Eventually, perhaps as late as in the second century BCE, Lam 5 (which in reality appears to have been an originally independent collective psalm of lament) was added to the still growing Lamentations. The result was a five-partite booklet, a pentathrenos resembling the five-partite Pentateuch and Book of Psalms. The earliest material attestations of the book are represented by some Herodian-period manuscript fragments from Qumran. In addition, there are references to Lamentations in deuterocanonical/apocryphal literature.
¶
Even though Lamentations (especially the assumedly earliest poem, namely Lam 2) at the outset orients itself towards a crisis that took place in the last part of the Babylonian period, the Persian and Hellenistic periods were the periods in which the book probably was formed and definitely was transmitted until the earliest known material attestations.
¶
To what extent can the literary growth of Lamentations outlined above be substantiated? Why was (the growing) Lamentations relevant in the Persian and Hellenistic periods? What role did the memory of the destruction of the city and of the temple play in the centuries after the occurrences took place? What milieu(s) in the Persian and Hellenistic periods produced, used, and circulated the poems that became Lamentations? How can Lamentations be used as a source to Judaean religious ideas?
|
Entering the Minds of the Ancients: A Study of Propositional Attitude Verbs in Biblical Hebrew
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Kevin Grasso, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
Propositional attitude verbs are verbs that describe the cognitive stance of the subject towards a proposition. Since Frege’s seminal paper “On Sense and Reference” (1897), propositional attitude verbs have been the subject of much investigation and debate in general linguistics. There are many well-known ‘problems’ that must be accounted for in any analysis of propositional attitude verbs, including the ‘(presupposition) projection problem’ (whether the proposition is presupposed to be true or not) and the problem of co-reference (whether names refer to the same individual inside or outside the scope of propositional attitude verbs). On all accounts, the verb reflects the mind of the speaker towards the complement in some way, so these verbs can give us a unique perspective on the mental stance of the subject. In recent work on the relationship between language, culture, and cognition, Jackendoff (2007) draws a distinction between situational attitude verbs and actional attitude verbs. The former reflect an attitude adopted towards any type of situation (e.g., believe in English), while the latter reflect an attitude adopted towards a “self-initiated action” (e.g., intend in English; Jackendoff 2007:247). Various parameters differentiate these two types of verbs, including time orientation and default syntax. Situational attitude verbs typically take finite complement clauses, and actional attitude verbs normally take infinitive complement clauses. This study investigates these two types of propositional attitude verbs in Biblical Hebrew (BH). With Pustejovsky (1995) and Rappaport-Hovav and Levin (2005) (and many others), I assume that the difference in syntax mentioned above reflects a difference in event structure. After grouping the various, relevant verbs in BH based on their argument realizations in the syntax, I propose a basic event structure for each class. Following the suggestion in Rappaport-Hovav and Levin (2005:78) that event structures reflect how language users conceptualized events, I use the event structures to compare and contrast the conceptualizations of these two types of attitude predicates. While it is recognized that gaining full access to the minds of deceased native speakers is not possible, I conclude with a general discussion of how we can gain a better understanding of the thoughts of Ancient Hebrews by utilizing the methodology proposed. In particular, I show that we can gain a better understanding of how the Hebrews conceptualized their world through language by working from syntax to event structure to conceptualization.
|
Getting the Wrong End of the Bow? Reconsidering Keel’s Images of Psalm 18.35
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Alison Gray, Westminster College (Cambridge)
In Psalm 18, a thanksgiving song for victory in battle, the king praises the Lord for strengthening his arms in verse 35. While the first part of this verse is reasonably straightforward: ‘You train my hands for battle,’ the interpretation of the second half has caused significant debate. The range of translations include ‘and set a bow of bronze in my arms’; ‘a bow of bronze is broken by my arms’; ‘so that my arms can bend a bow of bronze’.
In The Symbolism of the Biblical World, Othmar Keel establishes a connection between Ps 18.34a and a depiction of the Egyptian god Seth supporting Thutmose III in holding his bow, and then offers the reader a different image for Ps 18.34b. Intriguingly, the former image is not of a battle scene but part of a coronation ritual, expressed in the shooting of arrows, which is evidently not the context of Psalm 18. However, this paper will argue that the two images together provide a strong visual representation of the whole verse that is in keeping with the theme of strength in the psalm as a whole.
The disagreements over translation arise from a complex interplay between linguistic issues and the iconographical evidence that is employed in the respective arguments. Iconographical images have been used to support two quite distinct interpretations: i) the picture of God aiding the king in mastering or setting his bow, and ii) the picture of God handing a bow down to the king from on high. This paper will evaluate the impact of Keel’s bow images on the range of interpretations of Ps 18.35, as an example of the complex task of using iconography to endorse a particular visualisation of the biblical text.
|
Showdown: Using Images to Discuss Competing Interpretations
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Allison Gray, Saint Mary's University (San Antonio)
[For session 1] One key threshold concept in biblical studies is the idea that biblical texts are subject to interpretation, like other pieces of literature, and that it is okay for multiple readers in the classroom to form different (even mutually exclusive) interpretations of a shared text, if each interpreter genuinely engages with the text and attempts to explain its details. Frequently, however, students resist proposing alternate interpretations of a biblical passage in the classroom, or they do not challenge the interpretations of their classmates, which can lead to stagnant discussion. Students’ reluctance to debate can stem from an excess of caution; as an instructor at two religiously affiliated institutions, I have found that sometimes students are seeking a single “correct” reading of a canonical text and do not consider themselves to be authorized interpreters. Alternatively, some students resist debate by falling back on a facile appeal to relativism: any reading is ultimately a matter of opinion and therefore cannot be questioned. How can we as instructors bridge the gap between extremes and facilitate learning, getting our students to both propose interpretations and assess the strengths and weaknesses of those interpretations?
In this 10-minute presentation, I will invite the session’s attendees to participate in a brief re-creation of a classroom activity that I have found helpful: comparing two pieces of art that depict the same biblical event and attempting to decide which piece better captures the event as it is described in the biblical text. In this case, we will recreate the competition between 15th century Florentine artists Filippo Brunelleschi and Lorenzo Ghiberti. Each man created a bronze relief showing the Sacrifice of Isaac (the Akedah of Genesis 22) as part of a contest to secure a coveted commission to carve a complete set of panels for the east door of the Florence Baptistery. With the biblical text before us in the session, I will ask selected participants to make a case defending their preferred rendering of Genesis 22. After modeling what can happen in classroom discussion about the pieces of art, I will step back to a more formal presentation and explain how I would invite more students to join the conversation and begin evaluating their classmates’ arguments. I will conclude by discussing the strengths of the activity and some outcomes I have observed. In particular, I will describe how disagreements that arise during the activity can be harnessed to help students understand biblical interpretation as an activity that uses some familiar skills, especially drawing on textual evidence to make arguments that are not just expressions of opinion.
|
The LongPen, the Future Library, and Biblical Prophecy: Thinking Writing with Margaret Atwood
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Rhiannon Graybill, Rhodes College
In 2004, Margaret Atwood invented the LongPen, a device to allow authors to conduct book signings and give autographs without being physically present. The LongPen, which relies on an internet connection and a robotic hand, debuted in 2006; it has been used by Atwood and others and its signature is accepted as legally binding. Almost decade later, Atwood became the first author to join the Future Library Project (Framtidsbiblioteket), a public art project based in Norway that collects new, unpublished work from 100 authors over 100 years. The contributions will be published in 2114, using paper made from 100 trees planted in 2014 for this purpose. Both the LongPen and the Future Library Project evince a confidence in the fidelity of the written word and its duration over time that is often challenged in Atwood's own fiction, whether in the collapse of meaning in Surfacing (1972), the shifting play of truth and deception in the nested narratives of The Blind Assassin (2000) or in the subversive postscript of The Handmaid's Tale (1985), which chronicles an academic conference far in the future. Writing is likewise a matter of anxiety for the Gardeners in the MaddAddam trilogy, even as naming assumes new (biblical) significance. The tension between faith in the accuracy and durability of the written word and deep skepticism thereupon is reflected, as well, in the Hebrew Bible, and in accounts of the revelation of the divine word in particular. The Bible contains its own assembly of LongPens, from the divinely etched tablets of the law (Exodus 31:18) to Jeremiah's "pen of iron" (Jer. 17:1) to the writing on the wall at Belshazzar's feast (Dan. 5). The question of a Future Library, meanwhile, is another way of figuring the problem of whether, and which, texts survive, as well as the larger matter of canon formation. A prophet's words constitute a kind of “Future Library,” perhaps to survive in a kind of future book. The prophets’ repeated interest in textual destruction, as well as in the durability of writing itself, echoes Atwood's own complex attitudes toward writing and truth. This paper explores these intersections with particular reference to the material textual objects of prophecy, from tablets (Moses) to scrolls (Jeremiah, Ezekiel), to words written on the body (multiple prophetic bodies). I read these moments through Atwood's own experiments, both material and fictive, with the technologies of writing. The paper theorizes prophetic writing and/as transcribed by LongPen and prophecy as an act of Future Library production.
|
Get Me Away from Here, I'm Dying: Ezekiel and the Abominations in the Temple
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
Rhiannon Graybill, Rhodes College
This paper centers the precarious masculinity and vulnerable male body of the prophet/priest Ezekiel in Ezekiel 8-11. The priest-turned-prophet is transported in a vision from Babylon to the temple in Jerusalem, where he witnesses various “abominations,” among them idolatry, false worship practices, and the departure of Yahweh. Judgment and punishment ensue. The scene is a riot of bodies, including the bodies of the prophet, his otherworldly linen-clad guide, the Judeans, various divinely appointed “men”, and Yahweh himself. In this melee, Ezekiel’s embodied masculinity is articulated against these other bodies, the bodies of prior prophets, and the specific laws regulating priestly purity. In its complexity, this prophetic-priestly body also presents essential site of convergence for feminist, queer, and masculinity readings. I offer a reading of the prophet-priest's body here that takes as its starting point five principles for feminist masculinity studies: (1) centering the male body as an object of inquiry, (2) pursuing connections between the male body of the prophet and representations of female and animal bodies, (3) bracketing male desire as a concern, (4) taking passivity seriously, and (5) exploring the connections and disjunctions between feminist and queer perspectives on the text.
|
Memory and Moral Formation in Ben Sira
Program Unit: Deuterocanonical and Cognate Literature
Bradley Gregory, Catholic University of America
In antiquity memory had both individual and collective features and played an important role in the formation of identity and character as well as the socialization of the individual into a community’s tradition or way of life. This paper explores the different ways memory contributed to Ben Sira’s pedagogy of moral formation and sets these within the context of other ancient literature, especially Jewish instructional material from the Second Temple period. For Ben Sira, memory is a key feature of a wise life while forgetfulness or being forgotten is associated with the wicked. This paper begins by considering the conception of the phenomenon of memory and its relation to Ben Sira’s anthropology and then examines various objects of memory and how these function rhetorically in Ben Sira’s work. First, Ben Sira recalls, or commands his students to recall, earlier authoritative texts through references to divine commandments or sapiential principles. Related to this, Ben Sira devotes a substantial amount of space in his work to the recollection of figures of the past as moral exemplars for his students to follow or learn from. In some cases he comments directly on the ongoing memory of key figures such as Moses. Second, Ben Sira can insist on remembering God’s attributes to engender confidence in the benefits of the moral life. Third, the most frequent use of the language of memory in Ben Sira concerns the moral order, the operations of justice, and the trajectory of his students’ own individual lives. Particularly noteworthy in this regard is his employment of the theme of memento mori to encourage proper moral choices. Finally, the eventual memory of the students themselves is held out as a reward that transcends temporary rewards or even the problem of their failure to materialize.
|
Isaiah’s Religious Experience and Its Ethical Implications
Program Unit:
Jacqueline Grey, Alphacrucis College
This paper explores Isaiah’s experience of the holy God in Isaiah 6 and its ethical implications. The paper begins by defining religious experience in light of the broader literature of phenomenology. It then reads the experience of the prophet in Isaiah 6 in light of this definition. The holiness of God so preoccupies the prophet that this characteristic of God becomes a crucial standard by which he measures the actions of the covenant people. For Isaiah, the holiness of God has ethical implications for the people of God. This is reflected in both his response to the vision of God whereby he identifies with the people of unclean lips (Is 6:5) and his subsequent message to the cynical community (Is 6:9-13). The ethical message of Isaiah is one of Imitatio Dei. This emphasises the importance of a personal encounter with God for the development of moral values. Finally, the implications for the Pentecostal community of an ethical message that flows from an encounter with the holy God will be explored.
|
Christianization, Romanization, and the Rise of the Codex
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Bruce Griffin, Keiser University--Latin American Campus
Since the work of CH Roberts and TC Skeat, most accounts of the rise of the codex have stressed the role of Christians in promoting the transition from roll to codex. But recently Roger Bagnall has suggested that Romanization is an underappreciated factor behind the transition. And Benjamin Harnett has applied diffusion of innovations theory to the first four centuries of the Roman empire to argue that Christians are not needed to explain the transition to the codex. All of these studies group the evidence from Egypt together in assessing the transition. In this paper, we break down the data from Egypt by city. The lead city for the use of the codex is Antinoopolis, founded by Rome in the 130s. The second city for use of the codex is Hermopolis, immediately across the river from Antinoopolis. When the data from Egypt is broken down by cities, it strongly suggests that the most powerful factor promoting the codex was Roman cultural influence; Christian influence appears to have been real, but secondary.
|
"Sages Standing in God's Holy Fire": Prayer as Mnemonic for the Book of Daniel
Program Unit: Prayer in Antiquity
Jennie Grillo, University of Notre Dame
In much Christian and Jewish reception of the book of Daniel, all of the protagonists are shaped into models of prayer, on the pattern of the Three in the furnace in the Greek text of Dan 3. The separate stories are smoothed onto a shared template over the course of their later transmission: cultural memory condenses the Daniel tradition into a pictogram of praying figures in the midst of danger. The Prayer of Azariah and the Song of the Three are thus determinative for what the book of Daniel comes to mean to later readers. This paper will illustrate this process of the crystallization of the book around the motif of prayer, with examples from early Christian and early Jewish visual representations and, especially, early Christian martyr narratives.
|
Secrets of the God Makers: Alchemy and the Priesthood in Roman Egypt
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Shannon Grimes, Meredith College
The earliest alchemical texts were discovered in Egypt and date to the Roman period. Surprisingly little scholarly attention has been paid to the socio-cultural contexts of the craftsmen who produced them. This paper argues that alchemy has its origins in the Egyptian priesthood among temple metallurgists who were responsible for making cultic objects, particularly divine statues. These priests ranged from low-ranking metalworkers to high-ranking master craftsmen, who were responsible for preserving recipes and ensuring the quality of the work and the piety with which it was performed. This paper focuses mainly on the role of the master craftsman, based primarily on evidence from the writings of alchemist Zosimus of Panopolis (ca. 270 CE), who appears to have been a master craftsman, but also draws upon ancient descriptions of rituals for consecrating statues and archeological evidence from temple chambers called the “House of Gold.” Traditionally, there were strict codes of secrecy for metallurgical recipes in the Egyptian temples and courts, but in the Roman period, with the rise of trade guilds, these secrets began to circulate more freely. The impact of trade guilds upon temple economies is examined as the raison d’etre for the appearance of alchemical texts in the Roman period; Zosimus suggests that this openness was a welcome change.
|
Living with the Romans Is (not) a Game
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Jim Grimshaw, Carroll University
(1) Introduction: I propose a 10-minute presentation on a role-playing educational game involving the first-century Jewish Groups and their diverse relationships with the Roman Empire. I developed this game based on those designed by the Reacting to the Past organization (RTTP), which came out of Barnard College and has been developing and publishing games, as well as training faculty how to use them, since the 1990s. The RTTP games are well researched, sophisticated and are used in universities and colleges all over the U.S. I have used their games in other religion classes and they are some of the most engaging learning experiences I have witnessed. Since there are currently no games published that relate to the New Testament, I developed one for my Introduction to New Testament Class. The game encourages students to consider the complexities of the different Jewish Groups and their challenges of living under the Roman Empire. The preview, playing, and debriefing of the game lasts for one week of classes. (2) The game: The game is set in 60 C.E. at a Jewish Conference in a synagogue just outside of Jerusalem. Representatives from the Sadducees, Pharisees, Essenes, Zealots, and Common People are present, along with one Roman Centurion. They are to develop resolutions on how the Jews can better live with (or without?) the Romans. Students are assigned roles in each of the factions and each student has a role sheet for their character. They also read background information about all the Jewish Groups. The students meet in factions, talk with other factions to negotiate possible compromises, develop resolutions to vote on, and then all gather together for the main sessions. The Zealots have an option of assassinating the Roman Centurion but the Sadducees are alarmed by this. Sadducees and Essenes do not acknowledge each other, but the Essenes and Pharisees have apocalyptic beliefs in common. The Common People are given specific roles such as blacksmith, day laborer, or textile worker. (3) Presentation at SBL: I will introduce the game and pass around role sheets and some flyers that the students actually made to hang on the classroom wall promoting their faction. Then, with the help of a colleague, we will offer 3 or 4 short exchanges modeled off of what students would actually do in a game. First, we will be two Pharisees in a faction meeting discussing whether we should work with the Sadducees or consider talking with the apocalyptic Essenes. Second, we will be a Zealot who is trying to convince a blacksmith to join their faction because they admire his skills (and weapons!). Third, we will be the Co-Chairs convening the whole gathering for the main session as we discuss a resolution and the audience (at the SBL!) can briefly ask a question or make an argument on the resolution. Finally, a short debrief. And we’ll keep it under 10 minutes!
|
Hermeneutical Presuppositions and Their Implications Regarding the Audience of Hebrews
Program Unit: Hebrews
Sigurd Grindheim, Fjellhaug Internasjonale Høgskole
The author of Hebrews boldly demonstrates a Christological reading of Israel’s Scriptures. For example, he reads Psalm 40:7-9 as if Christ is the speaking subject (Heb 10:5-7). The way the argument unfolds, it appears that the audience is expected to share this understanding of Scripture, as there is no attempt to justify it. In this paper, I argue that this observation has implications for our identification of the audience of Hebrews. Not only have they come to faith in Jesus as the Messiah; they have also joined a community with its own group identity. It is therefore inadequate to see the author as weighing in on an intra-Jewish debate. He is rather presupposing an audience that has already separated itself, a community that reads the Scriptures together and shares a common understanding of these Scriptures, an understanding that sets them apart from other Jews.
|
Reworking Masculinity in 1 Esdras
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Jonathan C. Groce, Emory University
When one reads 1 Esdras against the backdrop of the Ezra-Nehemiah, three differences are especially clear: first, 1 Esdras adds a narrative about the end of the pre-exilic era taken from 2 Chronicles (1 Esd 1:1–20, 23–55); second, Zerubbabel becomes far more prominent, gaining an origin story (3:1–5:6) and full credit for Jerusalem’s restoration; and third, Nehemiah disappears. In this paper I argue that all three of these major differences between Ezra-Nehemiah and 1 Esdras touch on the emergence of what Brian DiPalma identifies as “scribal masculinity,” or what Daniel Smith-Christopher has identified as the “Wisdom Warrior.” Presupposing that 1 Esdras is a reworking of Ezra-Nehemiah (though perhaps this paper could be understood as a new line of argument that 1 Esdras came second), I show how the major changes made by the authors of 1 Esdras all contribute to the plausibility of a construction of masculinity centered around wisdom. Most important in this regard is the foregrounding of Zerubbabel. While he is a relatively minor character in Ezra-Nehemiah, he is effectively the savior of Judea in 1 Esdras. As the narrative’s hero, Zerubbabel gains honor, power, and renown—all of which are the achievements of ideal masculinity. Ezra gains prominence as well, taking center stage as the narrative reaches its happy close. in the 1 Esdras narrative. The key to prominence for both of these men is not their prowess on the battlefield, however. For both, it is their intelligence. By contrast, the two major leaders related to the narrative who have some battlefield skill come away from 1 Esdras in a harsher light. The only substantial battle scene in 1 Esdras is Josiah’s needless skirmish—a lapse in wisdom?—that precipitates the fall of Judea. And Nehemiah, whose memoir imagines the rebuilding of Jerusalem as something of a battlefield, is erased entirely. Far from honor, power, and renown, the one non-scholar leader of Ezra-Nehemiah receives what Jacob Wright correctly identifies as a Damnatio Memoriae. These shifts in masculinity touch on all three of the major differences between Ezra-Nehemiah and 1 Esdras. My goal in showing this is not to argue that 1 Esdras was written in order to make wisdom a marker of masculinity. But I do want to show that, whatever the true raison d’etre of 1 Esdras, the changes made to Ezra-Nehemiah by its authors contribute to the increasing plausibility of a wisdom-based masculinity in Second-temple Judaism. This study may have implications not only for the growing conversations about masculinity in ancient Judaism, but also for the vexing relationship between Ezra-Nehemiah and 1 Esdras. And it can demonstrate, I hope, that masculinity studies can have heuristic value for other exegetical puzzles.
|
Metaphor in the Aramaic Legal Tradition
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Andrew D. Gross, The Catholic University of America
The use of metaphor is well-rooted within the Aramaic legal tradition. Many of the metaphors that can be discerned within Aramaic legal formularies can be traced to antecedents in cuneiform legal documents from the second millennium BCE, especially those reflecting Western Peripheral traditions. As compared to documents from the Mesopotamia heartland, Western Peripheral traditions describe legal transactions with more dynamic language and this verbal dynamism continued into Aramaic traditions. This dynamism manifested itself by describing more vividly how the principals to the transaction interacted with one other, especially through the use of metaphors.
One well-known example of such a metaphor is the satisfaction clause. In less dynamic traditions, a contract simply states that one party has performed some sort of obligation, such as the delivery of payment. In the Aramaic tradition (and its cuneiform antecedents), this performance of the obligation was accompanied by a clause describing the other party’s reaction, namely that this latter party is satisfied with the performance of the obligation. This satisfaction is expressed using metaphors of emotion. Another example occurs in the warranty clauses of sales documents. This clause obligates the seller to defend the purchaser’s property rights against any adverse claims. To describe the process through which the claim is to be removed, these clauses use metaphors of cleanliness and purity.
This paper will explore the history and development of these metaphors, as well as others, within the Aramaic tradition and its antecedents. It will also consider how the dynamism of these traditions affected the relationship of the contract itself to the transaction.
|
Talmudic Pilgrimage: Tracing the Genre in the Babylonian Talmud
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Tziona Grossmark, Tel Hai College
The Babylonian Talmud documents the journeys of sages of inside and outside the Land of Israel and between Babylonia and Israel. These journeys were undertaken for various purposes such as trade, studies, and the transmission of religious laws between the two Torah centers. But the absence in the Talmudic records of religious pilgrimages to holy places as one of the motives for travel raises the question as to whether such pilgrimage journeys actually took place during those times. It is the purpose of this paper to assert that in the Babylonian Talmud there are traces of what may be termed itineraria and that at least some of the literary descriptions of ventures undertaken by Babylonian sages were actually a kind of pilgrimage, since they reveal the basic features of pilgrimage literature.
|
The Rare Lexeme ehi in Hos 13:10, 14
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Mayer Gruber, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
According to the widely acclaimed translation of the prophetic books of the Bible, which is included in the NJPS (1985 and later), and which claims to be "according to the traditional Hebrew text," Hosea 13:10a means, "Where now is your king? Let him save you." This translation does not reflect the standard Hebrew text, but rather the Old Greek version of the book of Hosea. In addition, NJPS also translates Hosea 13:14c-d according to the Old Greek as " Where, O Death, are your plagues? Your pestilence, where O Sheol?" The presenter is well aware that NJPS is not alone in following LXX rather than MT here and elsewhere.
In the instance at hand, NJPS and some medieval Hebrew exegetes remove both from the book of Hosea and from the vocabulary of Biblical Hebrew the form ehi, which appears three times in all of Hebrew Scripture. Indeed, the three occurrences of this short imperfect form of the first person of the verb "to be" all appear in close proximity in Hosea 13:10a, 14c, and 14d. The appearance of the very same word at the head of three clauses within a single literary unit constitutes an example of the literary device called anaphora, which designates a word or phrase that is repeated at the head of two or more successive clauses within a literary unit.
I shall demonstrate that the rare word ehi¸ which means "I shall be," was emended by metathesis (i.e., turning the letters around from AHY to AYH) to the interrogative particle ayeh because it was assumed that the standard Hebrew text constituted a mistake and that the correct reading was found in the Old Greek version.
In addition, I shall show that the Old Greek version of Hosea 13:14c-d was quoted in the Apostle Paul's First Letter to the Corinthians, 15:55-56. However, in the standard text of Paul's First Letter to the Corinthians, a further mistake has been introduced: the Greek word nike meaning ‘victory’ has been miscopied as dike meaning ‘justice’. However, this mistake has been corrected in the famous tenor-alto duet, "O Death! Where is thy sting? O Grave, where is thy victory?" in Handel's oratorio, The Messiah.
With all due respect to Handel, a clip of whose famous duet for alto and tenor will be included in the presentation, I shall show that there is another meaning, namely, "I shall be your Pestilence, O Death. I shall be your Scourge, O Sheol," hidden away in the unemended and unadulterated Masoretic text of Hosea 13:14. I shall show that ultimately, the neglected Masoretic text of Hosea 13 contains a profound message, indeed, an antidote to the human craving for victory – namely, the imitation of a divine craving for love and mercy.
|
Brachylogous Merism and Gender in the Book of Lamentations
Program Unit: Megilloth
Mayer Gruber, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
Until now it was widely understood that a merism pairs two extremes such as young and old, man and woman, sky and earth, to designate the whole constituted by the two extremes. Thus, while in Genesis 14:19, 22 both Melchizedek and Abram refer to El Elyon as creator of sky and land, the Rabbinic daily liturgy paraphrases the same merism with the expression ’creator of everything’. The very same understanding of how a merism means that we find in the Rabbinic liturgy is reflected also in the classic study of merism by J. Krašovec, Der Merismus (Rome, 1977). In fact, an entire series of unusual merisms in the biblical book of Lamentations, including 1:18; 2:10; 2:21; and 5:11-14, exemplify what A. M. Honeyman, in “Merismus in Biblical Hebrew” (JBL 71 [1952], pp.11-18) calls “brachylogous use of A+Y or A+B+Y or A+X+Y in place of the complete series A+B+C... +X+Y to represent the collective Z of which the individuals A to Y are members.” I shall show that the authors of at least three chapters of the biblical book of Lamentations adumbrate LGBT/Queer hermeneutics in deliberately referring to the presence among the victims of King Nebuchadnezzar in 6th century BCE Jerusalem and Judah of persons belong to the entire spectrum of humanity from female to male, including hermaphrodites, false hermaphrodites and transgender persons. In so doing, these chapters dovetail with the use of masculine plural//female singular parallelism found in the qere of Lam. 3: 25, which Shamir Yona, and I discussed in a previous meeting of this section, and which we published in Brad Embry’s Megilloth Studies (Sheffield Phoenix Press, 2016).
|
Reception of Scripture and Its Ethical Implications in 2 Maccabees
Program Unit: Bible and Ethics
Ann-Christin Grüninger, Ruhr-Universität Bochum
At distinctive positions 2 Maccabees adopts biblical tradition. The fights of the Maccabees supported by supernatural riders, are framed through explicit references to a supernatural messenger from a long time ago (2 Kings 19:35) in 2 Macc 8:19 and 15:22. Right before the battle against the Seleucid Timotheos 2 Macc 10:26 quotes almost literally LXX Ex 23:22 and remembers the Exodus-Angel, who accompanied Israel on the way out of Egypt and in the desert. A closer examination reveals that the supernatural riders in 2 Maccabees overall should be understood in the context of older angel-traditions.
However, angels in Ex 23:22 und 2 Kings 19:35 appear in situations where people of Israel do not act war-like – this was up to the angels. In contrast, the people in 2 Maccabees are not inactive. After the intervention of Antiochus IV. in Jewish religious practices (2 Macc 6) and tales of martyrium (2 Macc 6:18-7:42), Judas recruits 6.000 men for a revolt (2 Macc 6:12).
Interestingly, 2 Macc 6:12 and 7:32f. emphasise that the people of Israel suffer because of “their own sins” (7:32) what the narrator understands as an act of education and reason for their suffering. The behaviour of the Maccabees who want to defend the torah by force of arms and to end all the suffering for the sake of the torah, contradicts the narrator’s view at some point. Indeed, the time of God’s punishment seems to be over when the Maccabees start their revolt since the appearance of supernatural riders support their fights and indicate divine interventions. So until 2 Macc 7, an ethical dimension of punishment and education of the people of Israel is focused; from 2 Macc 8 on we can recognize an ethical concept of self-defence and resistance.
In contrast to this stands the book of Daniel: in the last vision it also tells about war-like angels but does not show their acting on earth – they emerge only in an unearthly, transcendental sphere (Dan 10:13.20; 12:1). The book of Daniel instructs his readers not to take up arms although they are in a menacing situation. With an ethic view it emphasises the endurance of their distress and therefore the knowledge of revelation is essential, as it predicts the soon ending of the Greek dominion and contains the hope of resurrection.
|
Parallels between the Book of Job and the Psalms: A Tradition-Historical Rather Than Intertextual Approach
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Nina Gschwind, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
Previous scholarship has analyzed the parallels between the Book of Job and the Book of Psalms primarily using an intertextual approach.
However, only very few verses in Job can be explained as diachronic intertextual references to specific verses in the Psalms (e.g. Job 7:17–18 referring to Psalm 8). In most cases, the authors of the Book of Job do not quote or allude to specific verses from the Psalms. Rather, as a tradition-historical approach shows, they take up traditional topics and theological concepts from the Psalms, evaluate them critically, and reinterpret them. Such topics and concepts include the plea for salvation from death in the midst of life (Ps 6:5 and Job 7:13–15), the longing for God’s presence (Ps 13:4 and Job 10:20), and the belief that YHWH answers when a supplicant calls upon him (Ps 3:5 and Job 14:15). The tradition-historical approach has been neglected in the past thirty years of Old Testament research.
This paper aims to show, first, which topics and concepts the authors of the Book of Job take up from the Psalms and how they reinterpret them. Second, it will analyze what this reception and reinterpretation reveals about wisdom during the time in which the Book of Job was written (5th – 3rd / 2nd century BCE), thus shedding light on the thought-world of the authors. Overall, the paper will point out the importance and benefits of using a tradition-historical approach for interpreting parallels between Job and the Psalms.
|
Marduk’s Basket and Treasures in Heaven: Indirect Reciprocity, Altruism, and Cultural Evolution in the Sermon on the Mount
Program Unit: Cognitive Science Approaches to the Biblical World
Anne Katrine Gudme, University of Copenhagen
In some biblical (Proverbs 19:17; Daniel 4:24; Tobit 4:7-11) and Mesopotamian texts (The Dialogue of Pessimism; Counsels of Wisdom) there is a notion that indirect reciprocity (altruism/almsgiving) is a way of securing divine favour that is just as acceptable and pleasing to the deity as direct reciprocity (sacrifice/gifts to the gods). These texts seem to be forerunners of the concept of a reward in heaven in exchange for alms, which is expressed in Matthew 6:1-4.
In this presentation, I trace this pattern of indirect reciprocity from Proverbs to the Sermon in Matthew and I use insights from evolutionary studies, such as evolutionary biology, evolutionary psychology and evolutionary theory of religion, to discuss the relationship between indirect reciprocity, such as charity and alms-giving (indirect reciprocity) and the evolution of religious systems featuring ‘Big Gods’, that is gods that are perceived to be morally interested in their worshippers’ behavior. These insights help us to see that the demand for charity and altruistic behavior may not simply be a value in religious systems such as Christianity and Judaism, but that it most likely is a time-tested and superior evolutionary strategy that helps cooperating groups to get ahead.
|
Undying Relationships: Enacting the Dead in the Roman Empire
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Anne Katrine de Hemmer Gudme, University of Copenhagen
The paper focuses on social interaction with the dead and on the dead as socially-invested and socially-relevant agents. It explores what appears to be the absence of religious competition in the sphere of mortuary ritual practices in the Roman Empire. Recent research (e.g. Rebillard, MacMullen and Denzey-Lewis) suggests that religious systems had very little or no influence on mortuary practices in the Roman Empire in the first centuries CE. Mortuary practices were governed by local, pragmatic, social- and family-oriented concerns and not by overriding religious traditions. Therefore, mortuary ritual practices are strikingly similar across the Roman Empire, or rather they are basically similar because of their common focus on continued social interaction with the dead in spite of creeds and afterlife beliefs etc., and they are similar because of their enormous internal diversity. In the presentation, I use selected tombs and necropoleis as case-studies for investigating mortuary ritual in the Roman Empire. The analysis applies the Cognitive Science of Religion (“CSR”)-based 'action perspective' (Barrett and Lawson 2001; McCauley and Lawson 2007; Uro 2016) to mortuary ritual practices. Furthermore, a material semiotics perspective (Law 2009) is applied to these relations in order to describe them in terms of actor networks (Law and Hassard 1999), in which the relationality of the living, the invisible dead and the materiality of the dead is repeatedly performed and negotiated.
|
Competing Narratives, Memes, and Going Viral as Socio-Theological Reflection and Resistance for Latinx-American Communities: A Hebrew Bible Perspective
Program Unit: La Comunidad of Hispanic Scholars of Religion
Corinna Guerrero, Santa Clara University
Competing Narratives, Memes, and Going Viral as Socio-Theological Reflection and
Resistance for Latinx-American Communities: A Hebrew Bible Perspective
|
Toxic Femininity? Enkrateia and Gender in Christian Apocryphal Literature
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Andrew R. Guffey, McCormick Theological Seminary
Enkrateia, a form of asceticism in antiquity, was viewed by many early Christians as an extreme form of the therapy of desire. Other early Christians, however, were attracted to the rigorous demands of encratism. In the apocryphal Christian Gospels and Acts literature, encratite tendencies are also gender-coded, especially in Thomasine traditions. The ability to control one’s passions was conceived of as a male trait. Conversely, capitulation to desire, especially sexual desire, was conceived of as female. Toxic masculinity, in these cases, presents as a fear of toxic femininity.
|
What Did the Beginning of Tyconius’s Exposition of the Apocalypse Contain?
Program Unit: Contextualizing North African Christianity
Francis Gumerlock, University of Colorado at Colorado Springs
This paper argues that some of Tyconius’s interpretations of words and phrases in Rev 1:1-11, not included in the recent edition of Tyconius’s Exposition of the Apocalypse by Roger Gryson, can be reasonably conjectured from comments which Tyconius made elsewhere in the Exposition.
No complete manuscript of the late fourth-century Exposition of the Apocalypse of Tyconius of Carthage has survived. However, based upon the multitude of quotations from that Exposition by early medieval commentators, Gryson recently reconstructed a large portion of it from parallel passages in those early medieval commentaries. Unfortunately Gryson was unable to reconstruct the beginning of the Exposition, namely, its comments on Rev 1:1-11, stating that the archetype which provided copies for the early medieval commentaries lacked its beginning. After discussing the evidence that the beginning of the Exposition has been lost, interacting with secondary literature, and agreeing with Gryson’s conclusion that the archetype lacked its beginning, this paper shows that in spite of the lack of external witnesses to Tyconius’s comments on Rev 1:1-11, his interpretation of many words and phrases in that lost section can be ascertained through an examination of internal evidence, comments elsewhere in his Exposition.
In his Exposition, which encompasses Rev 1:12-22:20, Tyconius frequently fortified his interpretations of certain words and phrases by cross-referencing verses from Rev 1:1-11, indicating that Tyconius had provided a similar interpretation of the word or phrase in the lost section. In addition, Tyconius was very consistent and repetitive in his interpretation of words and phrases throughout the entire Exposition. Therefore, based upon what the Exposition contains elsewhere, this paper presents a sample of what the Exposition most likely contained on the phrase “to his servant John” in Rev 1:1.
At least five times in the Exposition Tyconius wrote that John is a figure of the church. On Rev 1:17, Tyconius said that John “is a figure of the whole church.” On Rev 4:1-2, where John is told, “Come up here,” Tyconius explained that “this applies not only to John but to all believers.” On Rev 5:4, where John said, “I wept,” Tyconius indicated that it represented the church weeping. Again in comments on Rev 10:10-11 and 11:3 Tyconius interpreted John as a figure of the church preaching and prophesying. Because of these five comments which consistently say that John represents the church, it is reasonable to assume that Tyconius provided a similar interpretation on the phrase to his servant John at this first mention of John’s name in Rev 1:1. Although a verbatim reconstruction of Tyconius’s comments on the aforementioned phrase in Rev 1:1 cannot be given, it is very likely that it contained the idea, consistent throughout his Exposition, that John represents the church.
The paper concludes with a Table listing phrases from Rev 1:1-11, followed by my conjectures as to how Tyconius interpreted those phrases, and the passages elsewhere in the Exposition on which the ideas are based.
|
Specters of a Saint: The Visible and Hidden in the Ethiopic Life of Mary of Egypt
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Jaimie Gunderson, University of Texas at Austin
This paper examines the literary construction of the saintly body in the Ethiopic text of the Life of Mary of Egypt (Zenaha la-Maryam Gebsawit) in MS Oriental 686. Following the original Greek text, the Ethiopic Life presents the story of a sanctified and reformed prostitute turned desert hermit. In both the Greek and Ethiopic texts, the most striking element of the story is Mary’s ambiguous gendering. Accordingly, most scholarship on the Life has been devoted to discerning the flows of erotic desire in the text or the ways in which Mary’s dramatic transformation can be read as a commentary on human physicality and sexuality. While sex and sexuality are indeed integral to the construction of Mary’s holiness, Mary’s sanctity extends beyond the paradigm of desire and its sublimation. In the Ethiopic text, in particular, Mary’s body is phantasmic – it is a body that paradoxically must remain both hidden and visible in order to achieve holiness. As a result, the text places great emphasis on seeing (re’ya) and revealing (kasata): gazing at Mary’s body (as both a prostitute and a desert dweller), witnessing the wonders and mysteries of God, apprehending spiritual visions, reading the words on the manuscript page. The Ethiopic text invites the reader to participate in the unveiling of Mary’s sanctity – to find illumination in visible signifiers, but also to recognize Mary’s hiddenness as constitutive of her holiness. Yet Mary is never completely missing from the page even in her absence. Specters of the saint haunt the scribal introduction, the spiritual quest of the arrogant monk Zosimas, and the desolate landscape of the Jordanian desert. That is, the power elicited by Mary’s holy body does not simply exist as the subject (or object) of sexual desire, but also in its capacity to conceptualize corporeal difference (to apprehend holiness) through processes of creation and multiplicity – through, to borrow language from Deleuze and Guattari, transformations of becoming and unbecoming. Mary’s phantasmic body weaves together assemblages, connecting past, present, and future; saint, scribe, and reader; divine and human; ritual and revelation. As Mary’s presence and her attendant sanctity fold in and out of sight, Mary’s phantasmic body guards against the temptation of narrative closure. The reader must navigate the visible and hidden in order to perceive the becoming of a saint.
|
Roman Household Religion and the Interpretation of 1 Corinthians 7:14
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Judith M. Gundry, Yale Divinity School
Paul’s discussion in 1 Corinthians 7 is widely assumed to address a Roman concern with mastery over the passions, or a Stoic ideal of freedom from distraction through celibacy. It is thus curious that virtually all scholars suppose that in 1 Cor. 7:14 Paul is addressing a “Jewish concern” with purity: “For the unbelieving husband ἡγίασται by his wife and the unbelieving wife ἡγίασται by her husband. For otherwise your children are ἀκάθαρτα, but as it is, they are ἅγια.” This extremely “puzzling” verse is construed to presuppose the Corinthians’ fear that their unbelieving spouses are sources of “contamination” or are “illicit” and should thus be divorced, to which Paul responds that these unbelievers are rendered “holy” or “licit” by the believer and thus should not be divorced. Yet there are no parallels in Paul for such statements about unbelievers. A more plausible reconstruction, as this paper will argue, is that Paul is addressing a Roman expectation of religious uniformity in the household, where religion played an important role (e.g., Plutarch, Tibullus, Hierocles). Apart from such unity, divorce may have seemed inevitable to the former Gentiles in Corinth. But, according to Paul, the unbelieving spouse who is willing to “live together” “is consecrated” to God – for the (also unbelieving) children are “consecrated” to God – similarly to the Christ-believer, who is a “consecrated one” (ἅγιος). Hence, Paul forbids divorcing the unbeliever. Paul’s arguments in 1 Cor. 7:14, when seen in the light of the Roman expectation of religious uniformity in the household, can be construed as pointing to an invisible religious unity in the interfaith households of these Corinthian Christ-believers, which eliminates the inevitability of divorce in such cases. There are impressive parallels in Paul for ἅγιος and cognates in a transferred cultic sense (“consecrated” to God) which support this interpretation.
|
The Muʿtazilite Doctrine of Ṣarfa in Al-Nāshīʾ al-Akbar's Poetry Criticism
Program Unit: The Qur’an: Manuscripts and Textual Criticism (IQSA)
Haci Osman "Ozzy" Gunduz, Harvard University
Al-Nāshīʾ al-Akbar (d. 293/906) was a late third/ninth century Muʿtazilite theologian (mutakallim) and poet as well as a grammarian (naḥwī) and prosodist (ʿarūḍī). He also penned at least one book on poetry criticism (naqd al-shiʿr) which has reached us only as partial excerpts in a number of different sources. Both Yāqūt al-Ḥamawī (d. 626/1229) and Ibn Khallikān (d. 681/1282) note that al-Nāshīʾ al-Akbar was in the same category (ṭabaqa) of poetic talent as al-Buḥturī (d. 284/897) and Ibn al-Rūmī (d. 283/896), two outstanding poets of the Abbasid era. Biographical dictionaries attribute a rich poetic and scholarly production to him and, while some speak highly of the quality of his verse and books, others criticize him as a contrarian and a deviant. Unfortunately, we do not have extensive excerpts from his book on poetry criticism, however we have a number of poems, both in the form of didactic poetry and self-boasting (fakhr), that can help us understand al-Nāshīʾ al-Akbar's critique of poetry. He sees fine poetry as harmonious articulation of sounds and meanings presented in a way that is accessible to the audience. While comprehensible in addition to possessing a unique aesthetic and artistic character, according to al-Nāshīʾ al-Akbar such poetry would render its reproduction impossible. In this respect, much can be inferred about al-iʿjāz (inimitability of the Qurʾān) and the Muʿtazilite doctrine of ṣarfa. The doctrine of ṣarfa posits that the reason why Qurʾān could never be reproduced was not due to a miraculous literary inimitability which no soul could achieve, but rather than God had prevented (ṣarafa ʿan) capable and competent souls from doing so. This paper will study Al-Nāshīʾ al-Akbar as a Muʿtazilite theologian, critic and poet, and it will focus on how he adopted the doctrine of ṣarfa in his poetry criticism. In addition to surveying edited literary and theological works by Al-Nāshīʾ al-Akbar, this study will use a number of unedited manuscripts, mainly in Inebey Manuscript Library (Bursa, Turkey).
|
Pedagogical Reflections on the Coherence-Based Genealogical Method
Program Unit:
Peter Gurry, Phoenix Seminary
The Coherence-Based Genealogical Method (CBGM) is an important new development in textual criticism. What it is not, is easy to understand. Many have a referred to it as “black box,” seeing it as an impenetrable set of diagrams, terms, and data that require enormous patience and effort to understand. And the value of the CBGM for text-critical work has made it the new tool of choice for producing the standard scholarly editions of the Greek New Testament (NA28/UBS5). Given its value and importance for text-critical work, how can we bridge the gap of understanding between those who use these editions and those who create them using the CBGM? Following the publication of our introduction to the method, this paper will explore the challenges and opportunities of trying to teach the CBGM, both to students and to our colleagues in the guild.
Peter Gurry is Assistant Professor of NT at Phoenix Seminary. He has worked with the Center for the Study of NT Manuscripts and the Museum of the Bible to preserve and publish NT manuscripts. Together with Tommy Wasserman he has co-authored the book A New Approach to Textual Criticism: An Introduction to the Coherence-Based Genealogical Method, a co-publication of SBL and German Bible Society.
|
Second Baruch from Greek into Syriac: An Examination of Translational Features and Their (Potential) Implications
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Daniel M. Gurtner, Southern Seminary
Most scholars readily acknowledge that the Syriac text of Second Baruch in Codex Ambrosianus (ms 7a1) is translated from a Greek Vorlage. Nevertheless, very little work has been done on translational features of the text. While the absence of substantial Greek witness to the book poses limitations, the existence of a single Greek fragment affords the opportunity to gain access to a small window into the larger phenomenon. This paper examines this 4th/5th century fragment, P. Oxy. III 403 (2 Bar. 12:1–13:2 recto; 13:11–14:3 verso), to argue that the Syriac evidences a later, expansive rendering of a more concise – and at times ambiguous – Greek text resembling that of P.Oxy III 403.
|
Reading Tamar in the Context of Korean "Comfort Women" and “Me Too” Movement
Program Unit: Asian and Asian-American Hermeneutics
SungAe Ha, Claremont School of Theology
Since a South Korean prosecutor ignited a new stream of South Korean women to participate in the “Me Too” movement with her public interview on Jan 25, 2018, disclosing her superior's sexual harassment against her 8 years ago, the Me Too movement in Korea has spread from the prosecutors’ office and judiciary to the entertainment industry, academia and clergy, leading to mass mobilizations of activists holding rallies. Yesterday, a rising political star and presidential hopeful stepped down as a provincial governor hours after one of his secretaries claimed in public that he had raped her four times since last June.
The reason why female victims across the country have not been able to raise their voices in the past is that their mail sexual harassers tend to be in higher positions than they are. In addition, the culture of male-dominant Korean society at large suspects and condemns their intentions when they disclose sexual allegations. Hence, prosecutor Seo’s courageous public interview was historic as it has inspired other South Korean women to come forward about their experiences of sexual harassment and assault. Now it is believed that no one can reverse this wave of Me Too movement.
While Korean “Comfort Women” are victims of military sexual slavery by Japanese imperialism, they were the first who courageously disclosed forced rapes against them. There are commonalities between the witness of Korean “Comfort Women” and current “Me Too” movement as they are the victims of hierarchical power relations and male dominant culture.
Tamar’s story in 2 Samuel can be read in a variety of contexts and aspects, including the textual and intertextual context of the Bible. However, this paper will explore how the story can be read in the context of Korean "Comfort Women" and “Me Too” movement and will show how hierarchical power relations and male dominant culture works in the story to oppress the female victim's voice and position and how women’s victimization is even exploited in political power struggles as it is seen in the case of Korean Comfort Women and Me Too Movement.
|
The Nash Papyrus Reconsidered: A Bilingual Jew?
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Noah Hacham, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
The Nash papyrus is among the most important and well-known texts in the textual criticism of the Bible. Over a century has passed since its discovery, during which it has been extensively explored. In the nearly twelve decades since its emergence, our knowledge of many findings – primarily the biblical Dead Sea Scrolls – has been enriched. Our paleographical knowledge is thus more substantial and well grounded, and the written texts that have been discovered evince a richer diversity of genres. The Nash papyrus therefore merits an overall, multifaceted reappraisal. In this lecture, I will challenge some of the preconceptions regarding this papyrus and replace a number of formerly proposed exclamation points with question marks. Based on a scrupulous reading of the papyrus’ version of the Biblical text, I will suggest that its author was bilingual – a fact that gave rise to several textual idiosyncrasies.
|
“Not Did I Despise them”: Eleazar’s Prayer in 3 Maccabees
Program Unit: Prayer in Antiquity
Noah Hacham, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
Eleazar’s prayer in 3 Maccabees chapter 6 is a turnabout point in the narrative. The prayer uttered in the Alexandrian hippodrome prompted Divine intervention and the deliverance of the Jews. In this lecture I will analyse the prayer both from the point of view of the phenomenon itself and from that of its contribution to 3 Maccabees. Although discussed previously, it seems that the prayer’s special features have yet to be revealed. Eleazar’s supplication is indeed well rooted in Second Temple period prayer tradition; however, a reexamination of the prayer demonstrates its suitability and applicability to the particular circumstances of 3 Maccabees, as well as the author’s sophistication in using biblical precedents, and his unique diasporan worldview. Thus, for example, I will show that the biblical precedents in the prayer allude actually to the entire story of the book, and that the author wants to express the superiority of the Egyptian Jews over the Jerusalemites.
|
A Queer Troika: Gender-Bending Dynamics in the Relations of Jezebel, Ahab, and Elijah
Program Unit: LGBTI/Queer Hermeneutics
Susan E. Haddox, University of Mount Union
The power struggle among King Ahab, Queen Jezebel, and the prophet Elijah in 1st and 2nd Kings displays complex gender-bending dynamics. Although King Ahab is described as the one who “did evil in the sight of the Lord--more than all who were before him” (1 Kgs 16:30), the narrator seems oddly reluctant to implicate Ahab directly in the specific transgressions. Instead, his wife Jezebel, the foreign princess, is the primary actor violating Israelite worship and laws. Ahab appears feminized in her presence. Jezebel exercises power not only over Ahab, but surprisingly over Elijah, who avoids confronting her directly and flees in terror from her curses. In the odd dance among the three, Elijah dominates Ahab, but Jezebel dominates them both. In this paper, I argue that Jezebel’s performance of female masculinity disrupts the typical prophet-king power dynamic. Her strong narrative presence diminishes Ahab’s power, as when she takes the king’s place in 1 Kings 21, using his signet seal and authority. Despite his great success in the masculine field of battle, the narrative frequently portrays Ahab in submissive, feminine terms. He is sullen, resentful, and resists neither Jezebel nor Elijah. Although Elijah’s grisly prophecy of Jezebel’s death is finally realized, showing his ultimate authority, Jezebel also subverts the power of Elijah. He “plays the man” with Ahab, the Israelites, and others in the narrative, but cannot keep it up in the face of Jezebel. Her gender transgressions require a spectacular downfall to put her in her place. Ironically, it takes a group of eunuchs to tame her “improperly” exercised female masculinity, notably several years after the passing of both Ahab and Elijah.
|
Paul the Pharisaic Prophet-Teacher in Acts
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Tobias Hägerland, University of Gothenburg
Recent scholarship on the portrayal of Paul in the Acts of the Apostles has placed emphasis on the traits characterizing him as a man at home in Greek education and culture (paideia). The current tendency to view the Book of Acts as an early second-century text has stimulated endeavours to interpret the book within the context of the Second Sophistic and to observe how the ideals of this movement influenced the portrayal of Paul. By attributing to Paul orator-like qualities, several scholars have pointed out, the author of the Book of Acts reinforces the picture of him as a citizen of Rome and of the Greek city of Tarsus. In Tarsus, Paul received the early education that equipped him for bringing the teaching of the Lord to Greek and Roman cities alike.
While the interest in Paul as a Hellenistic ‘pepaideumenos’ is a welcome turn in Acts scholarship, one must take care not to neglect the fact that the Book of Acts also identifies Paul as a Jew, a Pharisee born of Pharisees, and as one who studied the Law under the Pharisaic teacher Gamaliel in Jerusalem. The present paper will address the question of Paul’s Jewishness in Acts from another angle than the standard aspects, such as Paul’s relationship to the Temple, to the Law and to the Scriptures of Israel. I will focus more narrowly on the Lukan Paul’s claim to have received a specifically Pharisaic education and on the ways in which he is characterized as a Pharisaic teacher.
I will argue that one characteristic of Pharisees and Pharisaic teachers, which has often been overlooked but which is part of both Luke’s and Josephus’s descriptions, is their openness to prophecy and their integration of it with studies in the Law. I will also argue that this integration of teaching and prophecy is present in Paul’s missionary activity according to Acts, especially in its early phase, when Paul’s Jewish ethos is established. Just as Paul’s Greek paideia and his Romanitas make him the perfect communicator of the message to Greek and Roman Gentiles, so his credentials as a Pharisaic prophet-teacher grant him the legitimacy to be its proclaimer to Jews.
|
An Analysis of Literary Dependence in Ezekiel 43:18-27
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Bradley Haggard, Asbury Theological Seminary
Wellhausen's revolutionary reformulation of Israelite and Jewish cult history hinged on the Temple Vision of Ezekiel in chapters 40-48, igniting over a century's worth of interest in the function and history of the text. Kaufmann, in a rebuttal to the Wellhausen consensus, asserted the primacy of Priestly material and saw Ezekiel's vision as dependent on the Priestly corpus. In the succeeding years scholars have generally taken either Wellhausen's approach, assessing the text diachronically, or Kaufmann's approach, assessing the text synchronically. This paper attempts to further this discussion by examining the intertextual relationship between Ezekiel 43:18-27 and altar prescriptions in Exodus 29 and Leviticus 16. The method first surveys synchronic studies of the rhetoric and language of Ezekiel in order to determine prior probabilities as a way of assessing the intertextual results. Then Michael Lyon's intertextual method is applied to the text itself. As a result, Ezekiel 43:18-27 evidences five of the six criteria developed by Lyons for dependence on the texts in Exodus 29 and Leviticus 16. This result coheres with the prior probabilities established in the survey of synchronic studies, further supporting the conclusion.
|
Righteousness by Faith, Not by the Law: Paul's Argument From Scripture in Romans 10:1–8
Program Unit: Scripture and Paul
Harry Hahne, Gateway Seminary
Righteousness by Faith, Not by the Law: Paul's Argument From Scripture in Romans 10:1–8
|
Hanina ben Dosa: How Rabbinic Literature Uses Charity to Portray Miracles
Program Unit: Midrash
Jason Hall, Nyack College
It is well known that rabbinic literature places a high priority on charity. For example, one passage states that charity is equivalent to all of the other commandments combined (b. B. Bat. 9a). By the 2nd -3rd centuries CE, the rabbis had established a detailed system of giving to the poor. This system of giving contrasted with that of another group of Jewish individuals that existed from the 1st century BCE until the middle of the 2nd century CE. Scholars have generally termed this group of pious individuals as the Ḥasidim (no relation to the contemporary Jews called by the same name). The most popular Ḥasid in rabbinic literature is Ḥanina ben Dosa. The Ḥasidim were specifically known for living in a state of poverty and giving charity. Two miracle-stories about Ḥanina ben Dosa involving poverty and charity will be examined from the Babylonian Talmud (b. Ta’an. 24b-25a). By analyzing these stories, the connection between Ḥanina’s poverty and miracles will be explained.
|
Provoking Insight: Discerning Order in the Parables of Enoch?
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Robert G. Hall, Hampden-Sydney College
Nickelsburg, denying that Suter’s repeating pattern reveals a logic within the text, reorders Parables of Enoch 41-44, transposing 41.3-8, to yield 41.1-2, 9; 42.1-3; 41.3-8; 43.1-44.1. Yet even if Stone rightly thinks that the Book of Parables lacks a “clear, unified literatury [sic] structure or a systematic development of ideas,” perhaps it follows a method of its own. I think Suter wisely seeks to understand the Parables of Enoch through the notion of māšāl, “parable.”
Sirach (38.34-39.3) and the Book of Parables (1 Enoch 37.1-5) correlate wisdom with pondering parables (dianoeomai, ḫallaya and parabolai, ainigmata, messālē). But the passage in Sirach dovetails with practices of teaching and learning presupposed in a variety of ancient Mediterranean authors: they write to provoke insight instead of to convey meaning. They do not hope for readers who seek to understand what the text says but for those who will ponder riddles and parables to glimpse realities hidden beyond.
This paper will illustrate the practice of provoking insight from such writings and authors as Proverbs, Genesis, Haggai, Sirach, Daniel, Heraclitus, Sophocles, Plato, and Plutarch. It will then show that Parables of Enoch joins such writings: in chapters 41-44, Parables of Enoch seeks less to convey meaning than to provoke insight. If so, readers need not expect sequences of paragraphs to develop a clear train of thought but to juxtapose images to evoke wisdom. Since the sequences work when read for insight, the order in these chapters can stand.
References: G. W. E. Nickelsburg, “1 Enoch 37-71: the Book of Parables” in 1 Enoch 2 by G. W. E. Nickelsburg and J. C. VanderKam (Hermeneia; Minneapolis: Fortress, 2012)12, 136-137; D. W. Suter, “Māšāl in the Similitudes of Enoch,” JBL 100 (1981)205-211; M. E. Stone, “Apocalyptic Literature,” Jewish Writings of the Second Temple Period, M. E. Stone, ed. (Philadelphia: Fortress, 1984)403.
|
“Empire” as a Political and Moral Category, Then and Now
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
Mark Hamilton, Abilene Christian University
Empires as a form of political organization began in the first third of the first millennium BCE and continues until today. These multinational, multicultural states require for their survival elaborate ideological justifications in multiple media as well as multilayered “repertoires of rule.” Empires thus provoke moral, theological, and philosophical inquiry as well, from their supporters, their foes, and those whose loyalties may be under negotiation. This paper examines the ideational dimensions of the imperial projects of the long sixth century BCE, drawing on previous comparative work by Weber, Eisenstadt, Burbank and Cooper, and others to illuminate the Israelite response to empires in particular.
|
The Subaltern Women in the Gospel of Mark: A Postcolonial Taxonomy
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Eun Sung Han, Drew University
When oppression becomes intensified under a complicated structure of domination, the marginal status of those who are on the lower strata of this hierarchical structure becomes severe enough to erase their voice and presence from the society. According to postcolonial theorist Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak, these are the subaltern.
Four groups of women may be distinguished in the Gospel of Mark that show the characteristics of this concept of the subaltern. These four groups are: the minor voiceless; the major voiceless; those with a voice but without power; and those with a negative voice.
The first three groups are the women who are recognized only by Jesus, who himself is beyond the standards of the society. Because Jesus alone can acknowledge them, these women are bound to the dominant power of Jesus. Thus, it is inevitable that these women quickly lose their voices when Jesus is also oppressed, crucified, and thus expelled from the discourse.
In contrast, the women with a negative voice seemingly take the position of the victor and thus remain visible and vocal. Yet, their voice and presence are mere echoes of those who hold the power in the hegemonic discourse.
Hence, all these women in Mark can be recognized only when the male authority figures they are relying on successfully and continuously grant them a voice. The subaltern cannot speak, according to Spivak, and if they speak they are not the subaltern any more. Then, can any of the Markan women speak in such a way as to relinquish their subalternity? In this presentation, I will argue that the Markan female characters are continuously bound to their subalternity within their connection to the male authority figures.
|
Post-traumatic Resilience of a Plant in Job 8:16–19
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Jin H. Han, New York Theological Seminary
Job 8:16-19 is a spoiler in Bildad's speech, which otherwise could be succinctly summarized as an eloquent defense of the doctrine of retribution. In the surrounding verses, Job's second friend richly illustrates his counsel with adages (e.g., vv. 7, 9) and a collection of nature images (e.g., vv. 11-12, 14-15), which are mobilized to depict the ruinous path of the wicked. By contrast, vv. 16-19 introduce a sunny picture of a plant's survival or robust prosperity. The nebulous antecedent of the third-person pronoun (hû') in v. 16 is a crux interpretum. Who is "he"? Is "he" the guilty condemned in vv. 11-15 or the innocent introduced in a new parable of the plant presented in vv. 16-19? Toying with the referential ambiguity, the latter verses depict tenacious survival that negotiates successfully with the stony paths represented by terms such as gal and 'ǎbānîm (v. 17). An unidentified speaker (who says, lē' rě'îtîkā "I didn't see you!"; v. 18b) apparently contributed to the death of the plant either carelessly or callously and conveys either surprise or sympathy for the plant that has been utterly uprooted (yěballě'ennû based the root bl' "swallow up," v. 18a). The ensuing words celebrate post-traumatic resilience, declaring that life continues through others ('aḥēr, v. 19). Their remarkable fresh start, introduced with the presentative hen, conjures creation through growth (yiṣmāḥû; cf. Gen 2:5, 9) and warrants jubilation (měsôs, Job 8:19). While delving into a question as to whether or not these verses can be seamlessly integrated into the edifice of the defense of God's management of the universe, this paper investigates the Shuhite sage's curious nod to the non-anthropocentric durability of life implied in the parable of the enduring plant.
|
Love’s Journey: Mechtild of Hackeborn’s Soteriology
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Kate Hanch, Garrett-Evangelical Theological Seminary
Barbara Newman’s 2017 rendition of the thirteenth century Benedictine nun Mechtild of Hackeborn’s The Book of Special Grace is the first English translation of the Latin in six hundred years. Unique to this translation, Newman parenthetically references the Scriptures Mechtild utilizes as she describes God’s overwhelming love. Newman’s editorial decisions allow us to see how Scripture informs Mechtild’s theology.
Mechtild of Hackeborn anthropomorphizes love as a maiden, placing her in the events of the biblical text to describe how God saves humanity. In the process, Mechtild engages the annunciation and birth narratives in Luke’s Gospel, the crucifixion account in John’s Gospel, and the parable of the 10 bridesmaids in Matthew. The goal of Love’s engagement in these passages is for the soul to become one with God. Here, Mechtild likely alludes to 1 Corinthians 6:17, a passage that utilizes sexual intercourse to describe how the soul unites with God. Mechtild of Hackeborn’s personified Love in this passage, according to Newman, serves as a corrective to the elder Mechtild of Magdeburg, who, instead of describing Love personified, depicts the Virgin Mary as the actor.
This paper will proceed as follows. First, I describe Mechtild’s life and community. While other women at her convent have received wider attention as of late, Mechtild has not achieved the same fame. Then, I describe broadly how Mechtild uses Scripture. Cloistered in the vibrant convent of Helfta, Germany, she likely had access to Latin texts, though, as a woman, she could not engage in the scriptural exegesis like her male contemporaries. She primarily references Scripture via the medium of liturgy, although her entire work is peppered with biblical allusions. Then, I engage how Mechtild describes Love’s salvific role utilizing the Gospels and Paul. Mechtild probably conceived of the notion of personified love from other female mystics, including Mechtild of Magdeburg. I narrow in on Book 2 of the Book of Special Grace, which recalls intimate encounters with God. Mechtild presents a linear view of Love’s involvement in the incarnation and Jesus’ birth to the crucifixion, and finally, how humanity participates in God, through becoming Oned with God. Here, Mechtild connects 1 Corinthians 6:17 with the metaphor of a drop of water entering a jug of wine, becoming wine in the process, a metaphor borrowed from Bernard of Clairvaux. As Newman suggests, annihilation in God is a concept discussed by Marguerite of Porete, Angelia of Foligno, and Mechtild of Hackeborn, all contemporaries (1290s) living in different areas of continental Europe. For Mechtild of Hackeborn this metaphor of annihilation becomes the goal of the Soul’s encounter with God. Annihilation in God is not cause for despair, nor loss of selfhood, but for joy and ecstasy. Following other theologians’ work on Marguerite Porete, I perceive this annihilation as deification, whereby Mechtild becomes godified.
|
The Last Supper, Paul, and Qumran: The Tail that Wagged the Dog
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Kenneth L. Hanson, University of Central Florida
The Last Supper, while undoubtedly the central element of liturgical Christianity, is equally laden with theoretical and theological issues, as well as questions of textual redaction, that directly bear on is interpretation and intrinsic meaning. With the significant help of Jewish scholarship and Qumranic studies, much new light has been shed on the Gospels’ depiction of the meal as a kind of Passover Seder. But was it? Looking behind the Textus Receptus, we find clear parallels with the so-called “Messianic Rule” of the Dead Sea Scrolls, which describes an eschatological “banquet,” involving bread and wine (in that order), blessed by a priestly/ messianic figure (1QSa 2:17-21). This is the order depicted by Paul (1 Cor. 11:23-25), as well as well as by the Gospels of Mark (14:22-25) and Matthew (26:26-29), in which Jesus refers to the “blood of the covenant” or, according to other ancient texts, “new covenant” (as in Qumranic parlance). Luke, however (22:13-20), has Jesus take the cup first, as common in Jewish ritual, followed by a second cup, which becomes, theologically, “the new covenant in my blood.” Might the problematic reference to the drinking of blood represent a later redaction of the Lucan account, which depicts Jesus behaving in an otherwise “kosher” manner? Another possible Qumranic allusion in the Gospels’ Passover narrative is the unexpected presence of a man carrying a pitcher of water (Mk. 14:13). To what extent do such details indicate a sectarian “overlay” to a more traditionally “Jewish” narrative? Might Jesus’ final repast with his disciples have been transformed from a traditional Jewish meal into, not just a Passover Seder, but a Qumran-inspired “Messianic Banquet,” influenced by a secondary Pauline wave of Judeo-Christianity?
|
The Benevolence of Job as a Literary Tradition in the Testament of Job
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Matt Harber, Duke University
The Testament of Job is clearly a free retelling of the Job legend familiar to modern readers from the narrative frame of the biblical book of Job (chs. 1-2, 42). What is less than clear, however, are the sources of this retelling. R. P. Spittler argued that this pseudepigraphal testament depends primarily upon the Greek version of the biblical book, since T.Job includes details about Job’s life that appear in certain verses of LXX Job but not in the corresponding verses of Hebrew (MT) Job. Furthermore, Spittler claimed, it is not only the narrative frame of LXX Job but also Job’s final speech to his three friends (chs. 29-31) that supplies the main biographical details in T.Job 9-15, a catalog of Job’s wealth and generosity.
Spittler’s construal of the literary relationship of LXX Job and T.Job has been adopted and expanded by subsequent T.Job scholarship. J. Dochhorn, for instance, refers to T.Job as an “exegetical text” that consciously interprets LXX Job. However, in a 2009 essay about the “history of consequences” of the book of Job, C. L. Seow challenges this model of direct textual dependence, suggesting the possibility that a non-biblical version of the Job legend has shaped the form of the story found in T.Job. Seow thus calls Joban scholarship to reckon not only with the extant written versions of the Job story, but also with their oral and traditional character.
However, to acknowledge the roles of orality and tradition is not necessarily to invalidate claims of strict literary dependence in specific cases. Following Spittler over against Seow, J. Rogers has recently labeled T.Job “an adaptation of LXX Job” with “a familiarity with the actual text of LXX Job.” By “adaptation,” Rogers evidently means that T.Job stands firmly within the LXX’s written tradition even as it expands upon and departs from this tradition. Having detailed T.Job’s use of the narrative frame in LXX Job, Rogers suggests that further analysis of the textual links between LXX Job 29-31 and T.Job 9-15 is needed to confirm the literary dependence of the latter upon the former.
Taking its cue from Rogers, this paper examines four passages from T.Job 9-15 that describe Job’s extravagant benevolence, passages which both Spittler and H. W. Attridge have identified as directly dependent on Job’s soliloquy in LXX Job 29-31. The main body of the paper examines T.Job’s narrative redeployment of specific phrases from this speech, either via direct verbatim “quotation” of extended phrases or via a subtler technique of “reverse quotation” of shorter phrases. Finally, acknowledging Seow’s cautions and incorporating recent work on rewritten scripture and genre theory by M. M. Zahn, G. J. Brooke et al., this paper inquires whether such textual links, however striking, should properly be regarded as “quotations” at all. In sum, this study of the benevolence passages in T.Job 9-15 seeks to articulate a robust model of textual relationship that captures both the literary dependence and the literary freedom evinced by T.Job.
|
Ideological Perspectives on Theodicy and Antitheodicy in the Tragedy of Saul
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
James Harding, University of Otago
At least two sets of contradictions are in play in the narrative of the rejection of Saul in 1 Samuel. On the one hand, a diachronic reading suggests strongly that a tradition sympathetic to Saul has been overlaid with one ideologically weighted towards David. On the other hand, a synchronic reading reveals tensions that seem to be inherent in the story of Saul’s rejection, for while there can be no doubt that the narrative portrays Saul’s rejection by YHWH as justified on some level, there is a strong note of protest in Samuel’s prayer before YHWH (1 Sam 15:10-11), which suggests that theodic and antitheodic perspectives (cf. Braiterman 1998) are being held in awkward tension. Saul is, moreover, characterized in such a way as to provoke the reader’s sympathy, a dimension of the narrative that has long been associated with the idea of tragedy. But what might be the ideological implications of such a work? For it is one thing to bring to light the literary qualities and inherent theological tensions of the narrative, but quite another to address the question of whose interests are served by it. This paper seeks to bring together the literary, theological, and ideological aspects of the narrative, and to explore whose interests are served by such a relentlessly double-voiced narrative that provokes the reader’s sympathy for a figure who is portrayed as inflicting such terror.
|
The Tragedy of Saul between Theodicy and Antitheodicy
Program Unit: Book of Samuel: Narrative, Theology, and Interpretation
James E. Harding, University of Otago
The second of the two narrative accounts of YHWH’s rejection of Saul (1 Sam 15:1-35) presents far more starkly than the preceding one (1 Sam 13:2-15) an image of an uncompromising, indeed hostile, God. This image is, however, ambiguous, for while this narrative has proved amenable to a theodic reading that justifies YHWH’s enmity towards Saul, it has nonetheless proved amenable to what Zachary Braiterman would term an antitheodic reading, whereby the justice of YHWH’s command to wreak vengeance on the Amalekites is called into question (b. Yoma 22b; Braiterman 1998: 56), and the narrative even contains within it an instance of the prophetic tradition of protest, with Samuel apparently pleading with YHWH to rescind his decree to reject Saul (1 Sam 15:10-11; Muffs 1992: 25-27). In contrast with Job, which draws discrete theodic and and antitheodic voices into dialogue, and Jeremiah, which juxtaposes theodic and antitheodic perspectives by means of contrasting genres, the book of Samuel draws theodic and antitheodic perspectives together by means of literary techniques suggestive of tragedy. While the tragic dimension of the story of Saul has hardly gone unnoticed (e.g. Gunn 1980; Exum 1992), this paper seeks to explore how this tragic dimension serves somehow to embody the tension between theodicy and antitheodicy in the narrative of Samuel. This, in turn, is shown to be arguably the most distinctive theological contribution of the narrative.
|
The Transfiguration in the Ancient Imaginary
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Christina Harker, Universität Bern - Université de Berne
The Transfiguration is an unusual scene within the Gospels: we have luminescent clothing, radiant faces, visits from famous dead men and a voice from the clouds. This paper examines and compares the Transfiguration scenes in Mark, Matthew and Luke with each other and with scenes of deification and theophany from Greek and Roman literature, myth, and art. I draw upon Ovid, Cicero, Homer, Apuleius, Archelaos of Priene, 5th century drama, traditions about the Caesars and other rulers and other sources to show the ways in which the gospels are in conversation with tropes and imagery stretching beyond the Hebrew Bible. The purpose is to identify the ways in which luminescent clothing, radiant faces, voices from the clouds, and the other features of the Synoptics' scenes overlap with Graeco-Roman theophanic tropes. This lays the groundwork for an analysis of the ways in which the scholarship in this area has often plumped for an either/or approach to the text's cultural background, moving away from analysing Greek and Roman parallels in the 20th century to a preference for Hebrew bible comparanda (particularly Exodus 34). This paper argues for looking across Mediterranean cultures for parallels, including cultures outside Greece, Rome, and Judea. I argue that if we look at ancient Mediterranean cultures as neither fully discrete nor mutually exclusive—so as intermingling at varying concentrations—we can find a greater richness of imagery, allusion, and meaning in how the evangelists communicate this unusual event to their audiences.
|
Emotions and Visionary Experiences in the Shepherd of Hermas
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Angela Kim Harkins, Boston College School of Theology and Ministry
While texts like the Shepherd of Hermas are thoroughly worked over and highly stylized writings, they nevertheless offer interesting insights into visionary experiences. This paper examines the role that decentering practices are said to play in generating visions in the early Christian work known as the Shepherd of Hermas. The protagonist, Hermas, routinely engages in prayer, confession of sins, kneeling, and weeping prior to his visionary experiences in the Book of Visions. These decentering practices can bring about an actual experience of grief that can lead to the cognitive state of rumination in which the mind naturally makes presence from absence. The visionary experiences that are produced are like dreams insofar as they happen to an individual or ‘act upon’ him or her in ways that are unpredictable; thus they are not strictly cultivated experiences (Mittermaier 2012, 254). The visions that Hermas experiences can be understood as descriptions of otherworldly beings ‘acting upon’ him by challenging him and morally constraining his thinking. These visionary encounters produce effects within Hermas that are similar to those produced by encounters with this-worldly beings and highlight how individuals in antiquity understood themselves to be in complex intersubjective relationships with beings who were not of this world.
|
Circulation of Goods and Services in Greco-Roman Associations
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Philip Harland, York University
Epigraphic and papyrological evidence provides important glimpses into the transmission of goods and services in associations, including exchanges related to meals, mutual-aid, honorific materials, and funerals. The availability and quality of these goods and services could differ from one association to the next. This paper outlines the distribution of two sample services, funerals and mutual-aid, in selected associations at the wealthier and poorer ends of the economic spectrum. Overall the paper suggests ways in which material exchanges were important within associations with economic implications for their members.
|
The "Waves of Emotion": An Epic Metaphor in Ephesians 4:14
Program Unit: Bible and Emotion
J. Albert Harrill, Ohio State University
The Pauline author of Ephesians evokes the stormy sea as the metaphor for the calamities befalling the immature, Gentile believer who refuses to be persuaded by the letter: "We must no longer be children, tossed to and fro and blown about by every wind of doctrine, by people's trickery, by their craftiness in deceitful scheming" (Eph 4:14, NRSV). The stormy image is conceived as a contrast with the prominent, overarching metaphor of steady architectural growth into a cosmic unity, within the immediate literary context and throughout the entire epistle. While modern commentary has debated whether the language "comes from" depictions of the dangers of sea travel in the Old Testament and/or the Acts of the Apostles, my paper offers a different approach – one from the study of ancient emotions. My aim is to move scholarship beyond the limited hermeneutical framework of the "origins" of the language to the more productive examination of its function in the text. Why might such a metaphor have recognition and persuasive power for ancient Gentile audiences? One answer is that the metaphor circulated widely, as a commonplace of epic literature familiar to ancient audiences. As such, it evoked a specific trope, the "waves of emotion," which depicted the fluctuating anxieties of passionate indecision to be like the waves of a sea stirred up by storms. The analogy of personal emotional turmoil to sea storms appears especially in high literary works – from Homer and Plato to Cicero and Lucretius – but it also finds parody in such lowbrow literature as Apuleius' The Golden Ass. A specific emotion depicted in the metaphor is anger--that is, the particular anger afflicting a person experiencing such emotional upheaval. This finding is interesting exegetically, because the Letter to the Ephesians soon turns to the question of anger management (Eph. 4:26). The metaphor in Ephesians thus functions as a recognizably elevated trope to persuade ancient audiences of the importance of letter's ethical persuasions as one of epic concern.
|
Atheist Lists as an Organizing Technique in Classical Literary Culture
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
J. Albert Harrill, Ohio State University
What counted as "atheism" in classical antiquity? Who were the "atheists"? What did they teach about the gods and the universe? Why were they persecuted? Although we define atheism as a disbelief in the existence of deity, this definition does not hold for the diverse teachings of actual ancient figures accused of "atheism" in their own day. Nonetheless, ancient lists of those who deny the existence of the gods recur as a commonplace in classical literary culture even when no actual writings by such sorts of absolute atheists survive. What are we to make of such evidence? Although using such evidence as a primary source for writing a history of atheism in classical antiquity may seem understandable, given their alleged importance as fragments of lost authors and the coherence of the list itself as a literary form, it is highly misleading in reconstructing a historical context for their production. These lists functioned as didactic vice catalogues and so should be treated as such. Therefore, rather than approaching the atheist lists as documentary records and straightforward inventories of genuine fragments by lost authors, my paper examines their form and function to create imagined communities. After surveying the organizing techniques of the various atheist lists in Greco-Roman literature, the paper will then turn to an examination of a similar didactic usage of the term atheos in a list found in Eph. 2:12, a series of terms that calls the very category 'Gentile' into existence. I argue that, by the use of the list as an organizing technique, the author of Ephesians aims to move the invited reader from one imagined community to another.
|
Creating a Virtual Holy Center among the Dead Sea Sect
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Hannah K Harrington, Patten University
The work of Catherine Bell stands at the intersection of Biblical Studies and Ritual Studies. Bell admits that rituals often carry a rich density of meaning behind them, but that it is difficult to unlock and cannot simply be imported cross-culturally. Rather, Bell prefers to examine the function of ritual practice in its unique context: “[R]itual is more complex than the mere communication of meanings and values; it is a set of activities that construct particular types of meanings and values in specific ways” (Bell 1997:81 -82). Rather than asking, What do rituals mean? Bell asks, What do rituals do? In particular, how is ritual a vehicle for the construction of relationships of authority and submission?
The sectarians who lived at Qumran preserved a rich vein of ritual material in the Dead Scrolls. They appear to be a group of disenfranchised priests from the Jerusalem Temple and their followers, and it is largely due to their opposing views on cultic ritual that they separated from their compatriots in Jerusalem (cf. MMT). Thus, the issue of authority and submission lies at the heart of the creation of the sect. Using Bell’s insights, I examine the way in which the sect’s purity rituals create relationships and hierarchy between the members of the group. While the priests represent the upper echelon of the sect and carry the major authority roles, at the other end of the spectrum, are found the undesirables whom the community labels impure, e.g. Gentiles, non-sectarian Jews, and rebels. Between these social poles, the novitiate can enter the ranks of the sect by submitting to initiation rites involving purity matters. Also, in this middle ground one finds the temporarily impure individual who can be reinstated into the community through ritual purification. According to Josephus, among the Essenes (a related group), boundaries were marked, reinforced, and penetrated by ritual ablutions (see War 2.138, 150).
But Bell makes another important discovery, one which is often missed by lesser sociologists. She recognizes that the creation of a religious sect is not just about exclusion but also the creation of, in her terms, a “virtual holy center.” Exclusion and regulation carry the goal of protecting the center or core of the group identity. This label applies especially to the Dead Sea sect which not only reinforced its boundaries with purity restrictions and strong penalties, but considered itself, at least temporarily, an alternative sanctuary. Ritual purification was performed in order to invite supernatural activity, such as, atonement, revelation, and the advent of the messiah(s). Furthermore, the sect considered itself a repository for the holy spirit, both individually and corporately and purity rituals were critical to maintaining identity and focus. Putting together Bell’s insights with the data of the Scrolls, it becomes clear that the sect’s purity rituals function both to protect them from undesirable penetration as well as to enable the reception of the deity’s holiness via his agents, the priests.
|
The Metaphor of Body=Sanctuary in Second Temple Judaism
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Hannah K Harrington, Patten University
Studies on the metaphor of the body as a temple in Second Temple Judaism and Early Christianity suffer from two major maladies: 1) They are usually unaware that this metaphor has a history in Judaism; and 2) They frequently do not recognize that the metaphor is born out of high regard for the temple rather than its replacement. Thus, their interpretations of the metaphor are not grounded sufficiently in historical precedent. This paper seeks to provide perspective on this topic by tracing the roots of the temple metaphor in early Judaism, along with utilizing metaphor theory, in an effort to bring clarity to its meaning and purpose in Second Temple literature.
Jane Patterson criticizes previous scholarship for its lack of understanding of the rhetorical function and creativity involved in using metaphors (2015:8). David Williams (1999), for example, correctly identifies the need for sustained understanding of the temple in Jerusalem in order to properly discuss Paul’s cultic metaphors, but he does not discuss the theory behind the use of metaphors. Jill Marshall understands the ambiguities in applying a metaphor from one domain to another. Using Conceptual Metaphor Theory (CMT), she focuses on the tension, noticed by Ricoeur, between the subject (target domain) and the metaphor, and examines the relationship between the two. Not all of the elements of the metaphor are expected to apply to the target domain. Marshall points out that the elements that do not fit the equation are intuitively suppressed and those that do fit are brought into the foreground (2015:837). This insight helps to avoid the pitfall of assuming that a metaphor is bringing to bear the full field of its source domain onto a target domain leading to mistaken assumptions about its purpose. For example, scholars often claim that by describing the people of God as a temple, a writer is stating that the current Jerusalem temple system is obsolete.
While the temple metaphor brings to mind many associations between the sanctuary and the people, the metaphor is used most widely in Second Temple Judaism to protect the holiness of Israel by excluding undesirable sexual partners. This is made explicit by the author of Aramaic Levi. According to the text, Isaac exhorts his grandson, “Marry a woman from my family and do not defile your seed with prostitutes, since you are holy seed, but sanctify your seed like the holy place since you are called a holy priest for all the seed of Abraham” (ALD VI, 4, Col. a 17-18). Several other early Second Temple texts exclude Gentiles from marriage with Jews by comparing the latter with the sanctuary (e.g. Mal 2:11b; MMT B48-49). The biblical law prohibiting various Gentile groups entrance into the assembly of YHWH (Deut 23:2-9) undergirds this linkage (cf. also Lev 20:3). This emphasis continues throughout the Dead Sea Scrolls (e.g. 1QS V-VII; 4Q174 I, 2-6; 4Q418 VIII, 1-4) and is prominent as well in Pauline literature (cf. 1 Cor 6:18-20; 2 Cor 6:14-18).
|
Constructing Time and Space: The Last Days as a Liminal Time-Space in the Qumran Sectarian Manuscripts
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Rebecca Harris, Rice University
The authors behind the sectarian manuscripts found among the Dead Sea Scrolls embrace an apocalyptic way of thinking about time and space that attempts to comprehend the whole span of history from beginning to end. Drawing on these framing strategies, the sectarians locate their own time and place in a transitional phase between two ages and construct the present as a liminal time-space in which new possibilities of access to the divine are available to members of the sect. In this paper, I aim to show how sectarian constructions of the present facilitated a lived experience in which partial access to the divine was a present reality.
Time and space are intimately connected in the thought-world of the sectarian authors. Time is the space or interval in which certain events take place. For the sectarians, the time is the last days and the space is the wilderness – an untamed, mostly uninhabited space with ties to previous divine action and revelation. In their view, “the last days” is a period defined by eschatological activity, which includes events in the recent past, the present, and the near future. It is a period of openness and possibility due to its transitional nature between times and spaces. Living in this period and belonging to the sect opens up the possibility of access to the divine.
Drawing on the insights of Henri Lefebvre and Edward Soja, I demonstrate how the sectarians constructed their own time-space, the present, as an-Other – a lived space not bound to temporal markers, geographical locations, or conceptual images. This “othering” enabled the authors to cast the present as a place of openness. Boundaries between divine and human spheres become blurred in the construction of a liminal time-space, while access to the divine is gained through ritual practice. Though the ultimate goal of the sectarian community, incorporation into the divine realm, awaited future realization, some degree of access to the divine was already part of the sectarian’s lived experience. Constructions of time and space play an integral role in facilitating the sectarian’s present accesses to the divine and securing his ultimate incorporation into the divine realm at the end of the age.
|
The Bible in the Locke-Stillingfleet Controversy over the Resurrection of the Same Body
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Steven Edward Harris, Redeemer University College
From 1697 to 1699 the philosopher John Locke carried on an extended controversy with Edward Stillingfleet, Bishop of Worcester, on various theological topics. Among these, Stillingfleet argued, on the basis of well-established exegetical tradition, for the long-held contention that the gospel included the promise of being resurrected in one’s same body. This Locke denied, arguing on the basis of his own reading of the New Testament (Second Reply, in Works 4:303-4), that we are not given back the same body but, as he says explicitly in his Paraphrase and Notes on 1 Cor 15:35, “other Bodies” (1707, 98). For the New Testament, on Locke’s reading, does not “so much as mention” the resurrection of the body but only the resurrection of the dead (Second Reply, 304). This paper investigates the originality of Locke’s exegesis of 1 Cor 15 and other relevant passages in the seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries.
Scholarly attention to the resurrection controversy with Stillingfleet has focused on Locke’s philosophical development of ideas of personal identity (Jolley 2015; Forstrom 2010; Kaufman 2008), particularly in the second edition of the Essay Concerning Human Understanding (1694). Here Locke added a new section “Of Identity and Diversity” (2.27) in which the identity of one’s present self with one’s resurrected self was of explicit concern. Indeed, eighteenth-century editions of the Essay appended Locke’s Second Reply to Stillingfleet on resurrection after this section (Dacome 2006, 85 n.40).
Thus, as Fernando Vidal has argued, debate over resurrection was “not epiphenomenal” to the real philosophical question of personal identity; it was “consubstantial to that interest itself” (2002, 972). And Maria-Cristina Pitassi has shown, further, how Locke’s biblical exegesis was part and parcel of his philosophical inventiveness on this score (1998; 1990). For Locke, what was important were the clear ideas found in Scripture, which could be understood by the impartial individual interpreter (An Essay for the Understanding of St Paul’s Epistles, by Consulting St Paul Himself [1707]). His method, therefore, involved reading and re-reading Paul’s letters to understand their “main Subject and Tendency” for himself (xiv), rather than the superimposed distinctions of orthodox theologians. He thus claimed to have reached his own conclusions about “other bodies” in reading 1 Corinthians 15.
Yet Locke had read other commentators on Paul’s letters, such as Theodore Beza and Henry Hammond (1605-1660), whom he found conflicted; Pitassi also detects similarities to the exegesis of the Socinian theologian Johann Crell (1590-1633), whose commentaries Locke owned (1998, 55 n.38). The remainder of the paper, then, will be given over to comparative historical exegesis, with a focus on those passages of Scripture Locke names in his Second Reply to Stillingfleet, his most detailed denial of the resurrection of the same body. These passages are Matt 27:52-53; John 5:28-29; 1 Cor 6:14; 15:13-58; and 2 Cor 5:10. The paper will determine to what extent Locke is working – perhaps unwittingly or unwillingly – within an exegetical tradition, or is guided by his hermeneutical commitments to his own idiosyncratic interpretation.
|
Mandaeans Online: How an Ancient Religion Has Embraced Modern Media
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
Jennifer Hart, Elon University
Mandaeans Online: How an Ancient Religion has Embraced Modern Media
The Mandaeans are a small religious and ethnic community most commonly associated with late antiquity, and yet they have established a presence for themselves in the thoroughly modern world of the Internet. This paper examines the websites, Facebook pages, Twitter and Instagram accounts maintained by Mandaeans with the purpose of promoting Mandaeism. It explores the religious identity expressed online by the Mandaean community. It also considers the possibility that the virtual world offers the chance of continued survival for a shrinking community. Finally the paper compares the online image of the Mandaeans with the image of the Mandaeans recorded in ethnographies of the Mandaeans in the “real” world.
|
Digital Editions of NA 28 und UBS 5: An Overview
Program Unit:
Markus Hartmann, Deutsche Bibelgesellschaft
Since the release of the first digital editions of NA28 in 2013 development has come a long way. Today, not only NA28, but also UBS GNT5 are available on all major Bible software platforms as well as online. This session will give an overview of the different digital editions and a perspective of further development.
Markus Hartmann is Team Leader, Digital Media at German Bible Society. He is in charge of the digital editions of NA28, GNT5, and other critical editions that are developed by GBS together with various software partners.
|
Travel Writing in the Early Roman Empire: Themes and Prospects
Program Unit: Jewish, Christian, and Graeco-Roman Travel in the Hellenistic, Roman, and Early Byzantine Periods (300 BCE–600 CE)
Pieter B. Hartog, Protestantse Theologische Universiteit
Recent years have seen a notable increase in the study of travel writing in the Early Roman Empire. Some of the themes addressed in these studies concern the connection between travel, imperialism, and identity, or parallels between Jewish, Christian, Greek, and Roman travel narratives. This paper offers a concise survey of travel literature from the Early Roman Empire and addresses themes in the study of this type of literature as well as prospects for future study.
|
The Fractured Psalter: Preliminary Reflections on the Interpretive Implications of a Pluriform MT of the Psalms
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Eric J. Harvey, Brandeis University
This paper explores some interpretive implications of the burgeoning realization that Hebrew Psalms traditions remained pluriform and multivocal until the early modern period. Specifically, it engages with research conducted by William Yarchin on medieval manuscripts of the Book of Psalms, and more narrowly by myself on the medieval witnesses to the Egyptian Hallel Psalms (Pss. 113-118). Our research has furnished similar results regarding the prevalence of variation in the division ofPsalters into individual Psalms. Yarchin has examined more than 400 medieval Psalms manuscripts, and has found over 150 different patterns of division and segmentation. In my own investigation of the Egyptian Hallel Psalms, I have discovered no less than 48 distinct segmentations of just those six Psalms.
Though this fact about the Masoretic traditions of the Book of Psalms is gaining prominence in Psalms studies, it is still rare to see investigation of its implications for the interpretation of individual Psalms or a reappraisal of Psalms literature as a whole.
In this paper, I present Psalms 114 and 115 as a test case. I showcase four medieval manuscripts containing four distinct segmentations of this short passage, each of which also differs from BHS, whose numbering is based on the Jacob ben Hayyim text of the Second Rabbinic Bible,
The manuscripts present the following segmentations:
BHS (=textus receptus, TR): 114:1-8; 115:1-18 (two Psalms)
Cod. Leningradensis: 114:1-115:18 (one Psalm)
Cod. Parm. 2353: 114:1-8; 115:1-11; 115:12-18 (three Psalms)
Cod. Parm. 1857: 114:1-115:11; 115:12-18 (two Psalms)
BnF ms. hebr. 22: 114:1-8; 115:1-116:19 (two Psalms)
In my analysis, I offer some preliminary observations on the flexibility and modularity of Psalms literature. I suggest that medieval manuscripts divide units at structurally or literarily significant points, creating units that can function and have meaning independently, or join together with other segments to create more complex or interesting arguments or conceptual progressions. Thus, the smallest units may be considered modules that join together into larger, more interesting poems.
|
The Rhetorical Aims of Emotion in Genesis Rabbah: A Case Study
Program Unit: Midrash
Matthew Hass, Harvard University
The goal of this paper is to examine the role of emotion in midrashic rhetoric. Scholars have noted that a distinctive feature of many midrashim in Genesis Rabbah is their focus on the thoughts, motivations, and feelings of biblical characters. Joshua Levinson has recently connected this focus on the inner world of biblical figures with Richard Sorabji’s observations regarding the prominence of the inner-self in late-antique Hellenistic philosophy. I build on these previous studies by illustrating how the focus on emotion, in addition to participating in broader cultural trends, also contributes to the rabbis’ rhetorical aims.
I illustrate the rhetorical function of emotion by focusing on select midrashim on the covenant between Abraham and God in Genesis 15. This biblical narrative is noteworthy for the prominence it gives to Abraham’s emotional states. It depicts him filled with fear and doubt regarding the fulfillment of God’s promises. The rabbis build on the biblical text by giving sustained attention to Abraham’s thoughts. The targets of his fears are different than those in the biblical text, but the intensity of his inner conflict remains, and, in many cases, is even more pronounced. I argue that the rabbinic focus on Abraham’s inner turmoil is meant to provoke what literary scholar Suzanne Keen has termed “strategic empathy.” By depicting the biblical patriarch’s complex inner world, the authors of the midrashim hope to lead their audience to identify with Abraham and recall their own experiences of frustration, fear and doubt.
In the midrashim I examine, the answer to Abraham’s fears is the rabbis themselves. They are the ones who will ensure the continuity of God’s commitment to the Jewish people and the perpetuation of His original covenant with Abraham. The audience of the midrashim, having empathized with Abraham and experienced his emotions as their own, is thus encouraged to appreciate the urgency and necessity of the rabbinic project. This provides those within the rabbinic movement with a renewed sense of purpose. Additionally, non-rabbinic Jews are encouraged to view the rabbis as absolutely essential to their own wellbeing. By drawing attention to the affective dimension of midrashic rhetoric, I show that the strategic mobilization of emotion was another means through which the rabbis argued for their own importance. It was yet another means of “rabbinizing” the Hebrew Bible by turning it into a book that speaks to the rabbis and their purposes. I conclude my paper with general reflections on how scholars can profit from contemporary theories of literature and emotion in their study of rabbinic midrash.
|
Bible Bargain(s)
Program Unit: Poverty in the Biblical World
Jione Havea, Independent Scholar
There are evidences of bargain cultures in the Bible: Abraham bargains on behalf of the righteous people in Sodom and Gomorrah (Gen 18), Moses negotiates with God because he did not want to go back to Egypt (Exod 2), Jonah negotiates with God to let him die (Jonah 4), Job debates and demands that God accounts for his unreasonable suffering, Psalmists lament their situations, and Jesus tries to bypass the cross (Luke 22:42). In several of these cases, the bargainer failed. The will and ways of the master remain. Nonetheless, bargaining indicates that a decision/value is open for negotiation, and this tool is used differently by different (e.g., poor and desperate compared to privileged and elevated) folks. Drawing from my experiences and observations of bargaining at markets in the Asia-Pasifika, I explore the place of bargain/negotiation cultures in the stories of Ruth and Esther -- two women who bargained/negotiated and succeeded, but for different ends. Ruth tagged along with her Mother-in-law and gave her migrant Moabite blood to Israel's throne, and Esther negotiated the genocide (spilling of blood) of local people to save her own people. Both stories involve aliens and the living out of protest against existing authorities and regimes. This paper explores the drives (ideologies) behind such "bible bargains," the evidences of such drives in the age of capital (from street to global markets) and our carbon civilization. In other words, when bargain is the culture (in the text, in the interpretation, and in the marketplace and politics), solidarity and resistance (in liberation criticism) lead to protest and negotiation (decolonial criticism). Caveat emptor: negotiation sometimes fail, and sometimes spill blood unnecessarily. So the "in whose interest" question (feminist criticism) is critical in the analysis of bargain cultures in and beyond the Bible.
|
How Biblical Narratives Manage the Anger of God
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
L. Daniel Hawk, Ashland Theological Seminary
How Biblical Narratives Manage the Anger of God
|
The Early Israelite Settlement through the Lens of the Early Historical Books: A Precis
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Ralph Hawkins, Averett University
The Early Israelite Settlement through the Lens of the Early Historical Books: A Precis
|
Technology and Text: A New Application for the Hexapla Institute
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Russell Hawkins, Southern Baptist Theological Seminary
The Hexapla Institute (www.hexapla.org) is a joint effort to publish a new critical edition of the fragments of Origen’s Hexapla, using the latest in evidence and sources, and involving contributors from around the world.
To support the creation of this edition, a web application allows contributors to identify lemmas, specify translators and witnesses, supply notes, and display an apparatus.
Over time, it became clear that a new application would be necessary, one that provided the ability to use different platforms, work offline, and more easily understand and expose the data entered by contributors.
And so, a new application was designed to power the work of the Hexapla Institute, one that would meet the needs of contributors and serve as an example of how technology can be used to overcome the information challenges faced by textual critics.
This paper will reveal the new application, demonstrating how the API-based architecture innovates in its use of modern computing technologies to store data, represent relationships, facilitate collaboration, enable advanced visualization, and provide a platform for further development.
|
The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly Temple: The Notion of ṭwb and rʿ in Nehemiah 1-2 in Light of Persian Era Inscriptions
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Kaz Hayashi, Baylor University
In recent biblical scholarship, scholars attribute the Persian era as one of the most formative period of biblical composition, and correspondingly, studies exploring the Achaemenid influence upon the text of Ezra-Nehemiah also began to proliferate. This study joins this burgeoning discussion of Persian influences upon the book of Nehemiah by reading the Leitwörter ṭwb “good” and rʿ “bad/evil” in light of similar expressions found in Old Persian inscriptions. Numerous scholars (e.g. Tamara Con Eskenazi, Mark A. Throntveit, Donna Laird) identify the two lexemes ṭwb “good” and rʿ “bad/evil” as Leitwörter in the opening chapters of Nehemiah. Despite the clear emphasis placed on these terms, in recent years, only a few scholars (e.g. Joseph Fleishman and Kiyan Forouton) began to explore the possible Achaemenid ideology that lies behind these terms, by primarily reading the text in light of Zoroastrian text and belief. No study, however, attempts to understand Nehemiah’s references to “good” and “bad” dualism from the angle of Old Persian inscriptions. In this study, I argue that the terms ṭwb and rʿ in Nehemiah 1–2 reflect the Persian ideology that understood “good” and “bad” in relation with building projects. Particularly, רע reflects Nehemiah’s perception of Jerusalem’s destruction, whereas טוב relates to Artaxerxes’s acts of carrying out building projects. Because of the lack of studies that systematically explore the terms relating to “good” and “bad” within Old Persian inscriptions, I begin with a treatment of Old Persian terms relating to “good” and “bad/evil” within Achaemenid official inscriptions. The “good” and “bad/evil” contrast first appears in the famous Cyrus Cylinder (inscribed in Akkadian) that commemorates Cyrus’s building works carried out on the temple at Babylon. In this inscription, the “bad” deed mentioned in line 8 clearly refers to an act against the city. In contrast, Cyrus’s good deeds relate to his benevolent actions towards people and buildings (lines 25–26). An overview on Old Persian terms denoting “good” and “bad” reveals that the adjective naibam “good” most frequently appears in contexts of constructions, whether the term itself means “good construction,” or “good” associated with (re)building. On the contrary, monumental inscriptions negatively view monuments in poor state, and pray against gastā “evil” to fall upon buildings in the form of destruction. This survey leads to applying a rhetorical and comparative historical methodologies to Nehemiah 1–2. I suggest that rʿ “bad/evil” always appears in connection with Jerusalem’s desolate state, whereas, ṭwb “good” refers to building reconstructions within the pericope.
|
Seek the Welfare of the City, or Walk Away as It Burns: An Intertextual and Political Reading of Jeremiah 29 and Luke 17
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Christopher M. Hays, Fundación Universitaria Seminario Bíblico de Colombia
This paper begins by exploring a possible subversive allusion to Jeremiah 29:1-23 in the apocalyptic discourse of Luke 17:20-37, and on the basis of that inter-textual tension, explores the possibility of reading both these texts as Christian Scripture in relation to two different 21st-century national governments: the United States and Colombia.
The exegetical portion of the argument builds on previous intertextual study of the Lukan pericope which has identified how Luke inverts the traditional characterizations of the sins of Noah’s generation and of Sodom and Gomorrah, indicting them for carrying on with innocuous mundane activities (instead of the litany of vices of which they are typically accused), indifferent to the coming judgment. This repurposing of the aforementioned traditional exemplars of evil functions to warn the Lukan audience against a preoccupation with family and quotidian economic activities. The present paper argues that various features of the Lukan apocalyptic discourse also call to mind Jeremiah 29, in which the prophet encourages the Israelites in Babylon to engage in activities such as eating, planting, building, marrying, and giving in marriage, activities which Luke 17 describes as incompatible with preparing for the coming of the Son of Man. Both Luke 17 and Jeremiah 29 seek to stave off premature prognostications of future deliverance and yet both affirm the certitude of eventual future deliverance, and as a result of their future expectations, these two texts endorse markedly different postures towards engagement with the economic and social lives of the nations under whose dominion they find themselves.
The resonances and tensions between these texts (which are at very least provocative from a reader-response perspective, although the present paper will argue that the relationship is not confined to the eye of the beholder) generate intriguing questions for reading of both of these texts as Christian scriptures in the Americas. So, following the exegetical reflections delineated above, the paper takes a political-theological turn, proposing opposite approaches to these texts for religious readers in two very different American nations: the United States and Colombia. The paper will propose that Luke 17’s perspective on preoccupation with familial and economic activities is more germane to those who read Luke as Christian Scripture in the United States. By contrast, it will argue that the perspective of Jeremiah 29 is more pertinent to those who read Jeremiah as Christian Scripture in the nation of Colombia, especially to those who are victims of the violent conflict in Colombia. The paper will close with hermeneutical reflections on the possibility and legitimacy of appropriating the witness of the Scriptures in such opposite fashions based on the national context of the interpreter and the moral issues s/he seeks to confront.
|
Priestly Contempt for the Cult in Malachi? The Interlocutors in Mal 1:7b, 12b
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Nathan Hays, Baylor University
The book of Malachi unfolds as a series of disputations between the prophetic voice and interlocutors. Whereas the interlocutors in Malachi often simply question prophetic claims (e.g., 1:2aβ, 6bβ, 7aβ; 2:14a, 17aβ; 3:7b, 8aβ, 13b), several places purportedly quote statements by the interlocutors (1:7b, 12b, 13aα1; 2:17b; 3:14–15). Malachi 1:7b and the closely related 1:12b, as the first of such putative quotations, are significant for investigating the interlocutors’ ideology. The predominant interpretation of these verses is that the priestly interlocutors express contempt for the cult, claiming that the table of the LORD and the offerings on it ought to be despised (nbzh), and even going so far as to call this table “defiled” (mgʾl). It is difficult to imagine priests actually verbalizing such views, so some scholars (e.g., Smith, Verhoef, Weyde) suggest that 1:7b, 12b actually reflect the book’s interpretation of the interlocutors’ attitude.
This presentation, however, argues that 1:7b, 12b reflect the actual words of the priests. Rather than expressing contempt for the cult, the priests are lamenting the LORD’s rejection of the cult. Whereas the predominant interpretation of nbzh in 1:7b, 12b is that it is has a gerundive sense (“ought to be despised”), this presentation argues that it is an incomplete passive construction (“is despised [by the LORD]”). First, as Weyde demonstrates, 1:7b, 12bα take the form of the declaratory formula. This formula elsewhere mainly relates to the LORD’s disposition toward people or objects. Second, the word or root has a cultic meaning referring to the LORD’s disposition in Ps 51:19 (Eng. 17); 1 Sam 15:9. Third, the incomplete passive construction fits with the concerns expressed elsewhere in Malachi that the LORD is not accepting offerings (e.g., Mal 2:13; 3:4).
With regard to the term mgʾl, applied to the altar in 1:12b, the priests are once again referring to the LORD’s disposition toward the altar, not to their own perception. The pual stem of gʾl only appears in Ezra 2:62 // Neh 7:64 and Mal 1:7a, 12b. The Ezra-Nehemiah passage describes returnees who were not “defiled” but rather at least temporarily “treated as defiled” (pual of gʾl) in order to protect the priesthood. This same sense applies to the pual participle in Mal 1:12b (“treated as defiled [by the LORD]”).
This presentation thus extends the observation that scholars (e.g., Wallis, Tiemeyer) have made that the prophetic voice of the book and the interlocutors disagree as to the cause of Yehud’s troubles. The prophetic voice blames the priests for lowering the requirements of the cult—an action that causes the LORD’s rejection of the offerings and attendant economic problems. The priestly interlocutors in 1:6–2:9, however, blame the LORD for the economic problems. In their view, the LORD is rejecting their heroic attempts to maintain the cult in trying times. What the prophetic voice finds so galling about the interlocutors’ statements in 1:7b, 12b is that they blame the LORD for problems that they themselves created.
|
Singing Songs and Telling Tales: Exploring the Rhetorical Function of Story in the Poetry of Psalm 81
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Rebecca Poe Hays, Baylor University
Scholarship related to Hebrew poetry has tended overwhelmingly to emphasize its lyric or non-narrative character. Poetic Hebrew texts such as those that comprise the book of Psalms, however, contain stories, and the inclusion of these stories in ancient Israel's worship texts contributes to their rhetorical power in distinctive ways. In this presentation, I use Ps 81 as a case study to demonstrate the unique contributions of story to the poetic language of the Psalter. After briefly building on literary theory and biblical studies of narrative to establish a clear definition of a "story," I draw out where and how both explicit and implicit textual markers create story structures-characterized primarily by indicators of sequence and causality-within the psalm text. In Ps 81, the psalmist uses story in two key ways to motivate audiences to respond with obedience to Ps 81. On the one hand, the psalmist relies upon human rationality to influence audiences' decision-making; the sequential-causal nature of story-the narration of how one event (in the case of Ps 81 a choice about disobedience/obedience) leads to another-communicates to audiences how their future choices will play out. On the other hand, the use of first-person storytelling promotes empathy in readers that will further encourage them to act in ways pleasing to God. Story naturally draws audiences in, and first-person narration compounds this effect by drawing them into the very "mind" of the storyteller (at least as the psalmist presents the storyteller's "mind") using first-person narration. Audiences feel the poignant longing to bless rather than curse ("If only you would listen! If only you would open your mouth and let me fill it!") and feel the pain of disappointment as Israel goes its own way. The presence of story in Ps 81 therefore plays a key role in this psalm's rhetorical strategy.
|
Figural Exegesis and the Retrospective Re-cognition of Israel’s Story
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Richard Hays, Duke University
This paper will reflect upon the theological implications of the manifold evidence that the Gospel writers frequently read Israel’s Scripture in a figural manner. They read Moses, the prophets, and the Psalms through the lens of the events of Jesus’ life, death, and resurrection. In this way they retrospectively discovered significations that were unknown to the original authors of Israel’s scriptural texts, or to subsequent communities of readers in Israel. The lecture will first consider several examples of this phenomenon of “reading backwards” and then offer some proposals about their hermeneutical significance. What implications might the interpretative practices of the NT authors have for our constructive accounts of the inspiration and authority of Scripture? Or what challenges do these interpretative practices pose for our approach to biblical exegesis?
|
"Useful for the Tower": Belonging to the Name in the Shepherd of Hermas
Program Unit: Construction of Christian Identities
Rob Heaton, University of Denver
Recent scholarship on the Shepherd of Hermas has found it difficult to locate this expectation-confounding text within their narratives of early Christianity. For instance, Larry Hurtado's 2016 Père Marquette lectures attempted to consider why individuals would adhere to Christianity at such great social and political costs, tentatively preferring its unique beliefs in a loving god and eternal life as probable clues. However, stringent doctrinal beliefs and an emphasis on immortality are mostly absent from the Shepherd, and at any rate would have to be reckoned subsidiary to the idea of eternal belonging offered by its most persistent parable and cosmic image--that of the Church as a tower under construction and incorporating all who persevere for the "Name." More recently, an edited volume with nearly 20 contributors writing about trends in the second century somehow only found reason to mention the Shepherd twice, even while outwardly claiming to eschew a story of great men, of "hierarchies and institutions," and of orthodoxy and heresy (James Carleton Paget and Judith Lieu, 2017). Recognizing the surprising popularity of the Shepherd in pre-Constantinian Christianity and lamenting its absence in such narratives, this paper proposes that Hermas offered his readers a more appealing sense of communal belonging and a more coherent 'catholic' identity than did other modes of communicating the Christian experience, which were often occupied (among other exigencies) with establishing the propriety of hierarchies. In contradistinction to other texts, the Shepherd addresses the problems plaguing the Church, from lapsed members to a conceptual lacuna in understanding its very existence, from an exhortation to egalitarian participation, rather than monarchical control. Although the Shepherd recognizes various leaders in his midst, he cannot claim to be among them, and instead speaks as a representative of what Ramsay MacMullen has called the "95 percent," the "second church" mostly unattested by epigraphic remains (2009). Hermas acknowledges that all who take on the "Name" have some personal responsibility in order to win their places among the tower, to not be double-minded, to become temperate and well-mannered, and so on. Therefore, this paper seeks the remains of Hermas's cohorts in the underclass of slaves, widows, the poor, and the sub-establishment attracted to Christianity while simultaneously attempting to offer further possibilities, from Hermas's perspective, toward Hurtado's controlling question: why on Earth would anyone become a Christian in the first three centuries CE?
|
Power Made Perfect in Weakness: Theologia Crucis in 2 Corinthians 13:3–4
Program Unit: Second Corinthians: Pauline Theology in the Making
Joshua Heavin, Trinity College - Bristol
This paper explores Paul’s “Kreuzestheologie” in 2 Corinthians 13:3–4. Arguably, several recent developments have tended to reduce Paul’s ‘theology of the cross’ to power dissolved into weakness. Instead, I argue that the context of Paul’s theology of the cross in 2 Corinthians 13:3–4 within his rhetorical discourse spanning 12:11–13:10 illumines Paul’s presentation of his cross-theology and action towards the Corinthians as power made perfect in weakness.
Few enterprises are more fraught with peril yet full of promise for responsible interpretation of Pauline theology than 'theologia crucis,' evidenced in the broad appropriation of Paul’s cross-language spanning the fiery cross of the Ku Klux Klan’s lynchings in the 20th century American South, to Jürgen Moltmann’s sobering post-Holocaust reflections and call to justice and mercy in "The Crucified God." Moreover, and closely related, Paul’s exaltation of weakness has at times provoked the abdication of privilege in order to restore the oppressed and defrauded, but also been denounced from Celsus to Nietzsche as cruelly glorifying suffering and binding the oppressed and abused to quietly abide injustice for other worldly-hope without disrupting corrupt powers.
Part I of this paper outlines three of the most salient and influential trends in the wirkungsgeschichte of Paul’s 2 Corinthians 13:4, and its close relation to Paul’s cross-language in 1 Corinthians 1–2. First, 2 Cor 13:3–4 was often cited in the first few centuries of Pauline reception amidst polemical responses to the ‘scandal’ of a crucified God, such as Origen’s "Contra Celsum," Abrosiaster’s commentary on 2 Corinthians, and Cyril of Alexandria’s "On the Unity of Christ." Second, one century later, Luther’s 1518 "Heidelberg Disputations" mark a turning point in the history of the project of theologia crucis, significantly re-framing Paul’s cross language for subsequent interpreters into questions of epistemology and theological prolegomena. Finally, as hinted at by Robert Cady Saler’s "Theologia Crucis: A Companion to the Theology of the Cross" and critiqued by Katherine Sonderregger’s 2015 "Systematic Theology," several influential modern trends in appropriating Paul’s cross language have tended to reduce Paul’s theology of the cross essentially into power dissolved into weakness.
Part II frames 2 Corinthians 13:3–4 in relation to Paul’s pending visit throughout ch. 13, especially in relation to v.9, “we are glad when we are weak and you are strong.” By thus exploring the rhetorical function of Paul’s cross and weakness language in vv. 13:3–4 as a hortatory strategy for Paul’s authority, we are better poised to appreciate the significance of Paul’s theological claims related to the cross in v.4. In sum, analysis of the wirkungsgeschichte of 2 Cor 13:3–4 not only offers further context for our contemporary interpretative situation, but arguably unveils mutually corrective insights for tracing the development of Pauline theology. Early Christological and epistemological uses of Paul’s cross- and weakness-language can be brought into critical and constructive interaction with more recent interpretations concerned with advocating on behalf of the marginalized and under-represented that expand our exegetical plausibility structures for Paul’s cross-theologizing in 2 Cor 13:3–4.
|
The Qere Perpetuum of the Tetragrammaton: A Comparative Study within the Masoretic Tradition
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Tim Hegg, TorahResource Institute
This paper will look at the Tetragrammaton when written with three vowels, doing a comparative study between codices Aleppo, Leningradensis, as well as other early Masoretic manuscripts. In addition, comparison with the Dead Sea Scrolls will be offered to show textual variants when compared with the Masoretic readings. The purpose of the paper is (1) to acquaint beginning students in Masoretic Studies with the convention of the Qere Perpetuum, and (2) to use specific occurrences of the Tetragrammaton to demonstrate different scribal traditions even within the Masoretic codices.
|
The Earliest Layer of the Ethiopic Book of Jeremiah
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Martin Heide, Philipps-Universität-Marburg
In the first millennium AD, the Book of Jeremiah was translated from Greek into Ge'ez. However, the Ethiopic text suffers from many revisions. One of the earliest layers of the Ethiopic text is still visible in manuscripts from the 15-16th centuries that were found in Gunda Gunde. The text of these manuscripts is characterized by block-mixture, which means that some chapters (Jer 1-45) have a different textual form than the remaining part of the book (Jer 46-52). It seems that Jer 1-45 witnesses to an early revision, which for some unknown reason did not continue beyond chapter 45. Thus, Jer 46-52 witness to the earliest attainable textform of the Ethiopic book of Jeremiah. This text was translated from the Septuagint, probably from a sister copy of Codex Sinaiticus. It is characterized by omissions and abbreviations and by poor Ge'ez. It seems to have been made somewhere between the 5th and 8th centuries AD by a scribe who had a Coptic background and who used Ethiopic to the best of his knowledge.
|
The Function and Significance of Abram's Sojourn in Egypt
Program Unit: Genesis
Martin Heide, Philipps-Universität Marburg
Abram's sojourn in Egypt, as it is told in Gen 12:10-20, is usually interpreted in the context of the other two sister-wife incidents known from Gen 20 and Gen 26. However, a close reading of the passage and its context reveals that Gen 12:10-20 was carefully implemented into the larger narrative of the Abraham Cycle. The larger context was designed to let the reader perceive the development of family awareness in the famous patriarch.
|
The Addressees of Paul’s Letter to the Galatians in Their Social and Religious Contexts
Program Unit: Polis and Ekklesia: Investigations of Urban Christianity
Christoph Heil, Karl-Franzens Universität Graz
This paper will review the old question whether the addressees of Paul’s Letter to the Galatians are to be found in the Northern or Southern part of the province. The answer to that question has major impact on how Paul’s Letter has to be dated and how it has to be understood. The most recent publication on this issue is Felix John, Der Galaterbrief im Kontext historischer Lebenswelten im antiken Kleinasien, FRLANT 264 (Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 2016). In close dialogue with John and other recent contributions this paper will scrutinize the following three points which involve local documentary and archaeological evidence.
(1) The designation “galátes” (“Galatian”) does not point exclusively to the Northern part of the province. In Paul’s time the whole province was deeply hellenized. For instance, an inscription at the temple of Augustus and Roma in Ancyra (OGIS 533, again in Stephen Mitchell and David French, eds., The Greek and Latin Inscriptions of Ankara [Ancyra]. Vol. I: From Augustus to the End of the Third Century AD, Vestigia 62 [München: C.H. Beck, 2012], no. 2) gives a list of about 20 imperial priests from the time of Tiberius. Only half of them have typical Celtic names, the other half has Greek names.
(2) According to Stephen Mitchell (Anatolia: Land, Men and Gods in Asia Minor. I: The Celts in Anatolia and the Impact of Roman Rule [Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1993]), the Flavians began building paved streets in Northern Galatia. Accordingly, in Paul’s time it would have been difficult to reach this region. However, Augustus founded the province in 25 BCE with Ancyra as its capital. Pessinus was a temple city of Cybele / Magna Mater who attracted many pilgrims. For instance, Apuleius mentions the temple in Metam. 11.5.2 and calls the goddess “elementorum omnium domina” (Metam. 11.5.1). According to Strabo (Geogr. 12.5.3), Pessinus was one of the biggest markets in the region. Although there have been no milestones found, it is hard to imagine that it would have been difficult to travel to Ancyra and Pessinus.
(3) Gal 4:8 makes it clear that the majority of Paul’s addressees was not Jewish. Further, the demand to be circumcised (Gal 5:2-3; 6:12-13) presupposes that the male Christians in Galatia are still not circumcised. In Northern Galatia there is no evidence for the presence of Jews in Paul’s time. This is very different in Southern Galatia if we can trust Acts 13.
In sum, it seems more likely that Paul’s addressees have to be located in the Northern part of the province Galatia, namely in the region of Ancyra, Pessinus, Germa and Gordion.
|
The Liber fidei catholicae in Victor of Vita’s Historia: A North African Text?
Program Unit: Contextualizing North African Christianity
Uta Heil, Universität Wien
In the second book of his Historia persecutionum Africanae provinciae (II 56-101), Victor of Vita quotes the so-called Liber fidei catholicae. This text was composed for the disputation at the Council of Carthage in 484 during the Vandal reign of Huneric and can be taken as a summary of North African Nicene theology. The paper will discuss the question whether this Liber fidei catholicae can be understood as an expression of a special North African theological tradition. Possible influences by Tertullian up to Augustine, but also by Ambrose (Italy), Hilary (Gaul) and Athanasius (Egypt – see his letter Ad Afros) must be taken into consideration as well as other contemporary North African texts from the late fifth century. Interestingly, still Thrasamund or his theological advisors read this Liber fidei catholicae as a kind of masterpiece of North African “Nicenes”. Therefore, the Dicta regis Trasamundi directly referred to the Liber fidei catholicae and contradicted its main items. Even Fulgentius of Ruspe used this Liber fidei catholicae in his response to the Dicta of Thrasamund, which he wrote at the demand of Thrasamund who called him back from exile at Sardinia. At this point of time at least, one can detect a special North African Trinitarian identity and tradition which obviously laid the foundation for the self-confident resistance of the North African theologians during the Three-Chapters-Controversy. This paper will continue my research interest in analyzing the developments in Christianity after Augustine, especially in looking at regional differences of both Nicene and “Arian” or “Homoian” Christianity.
|
Hyper-Ambiguity in Ecclesiastes
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Knut M. Heim, Denver Seminary
This paper aims to demonstrate that the unusually high frequency of radically different interpretations that the book of Ecclesiastes has enjoyed are a natural function of Qoheleth’s oral mode of delivery. This will be supported through an exploration of the politically explosive passages in 5:7-11 (on the proper response to social, economic, and legal injustice), 5:12-19 (on misery induced by the pursuit of happiness through wealth), and 6:1-9 (on a common cause for misery despite abundant wealth). For example, in 5:8 it is the mention of the king—in close proximity to an only slightly veiled critique of institutional corruption in v. 7—that prompts hyper-ambiguity. It is as if Qoheleth speaks in the mode of modern stand-up comedians, where social critique is expressed regularly through indirection, innuendo, and humor, where the real meaning of what is being said only emerges from the speaker’s intonation (pitch, pause, speed, tone, stress, emphasis, etc.). The paper will highlight numerous occasions where ambiguity creates biting sarcasm and social critique all at once, and in a highly amusing fashion. It will show that ambiguity and humor work hand in hand to achieve two rhetorical goals: (1) humor serves to entertain and win over Qoheleth’s audience; (3) ambiguity creates plausible deniability in case Qoheleth were accused of sedition against the political hierarchy.
|
Birth Pains: What Can (Re)Producing Jesus' Birth Narrative (Re)Produce?
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Timothy P. Hein, University of Edinburgh
The Protevangelium Jacobi (PJ), an influential second century birth narrative, which includes Matthew's magi pericope (Matt 2:1-12), is often said to simply "borrow from" or "paraphrase" Matthew when in point of fact PJ does neither. PJ strips the Matthean original and redresses the pericope for a new situation. Tatian does something similar in his Diatessaron (Diat), where the story remains relatively unchanged, save re-situating the pericope in a new, yet still in some ways similar, theological context. We have in PJ and Diat an effort that seems, at first glance, to imitate what was the authoritative text of Matthew's Gospel, but their reproductions divert from what Matthew's magi do for Matthew. This paper explores how early Christian authors interact with authoritative birth narrative texts. This paper explores how authors produce or reproduce episodes of the authoritative birth narratives, Matthew's magi as a particular test case, and the potential results of such uses of narrative texts in Christian literature. This paper begins (1) with a survey of the features of authoritative birth narratives in Matthew and Luke, then (2) examines what of that material was (re)produced in PJ and Diat. Next, this paper (3) examines methodological concerns about what such a final product in PJ and Diat may say about how or why authors imitate or differentiate authoritative birth narratives. Finally, (4) this paper endeavors to move a step closer towards a framework for better understanding early Christian readings of authoritative narrative texts.
|
The Gift and Christ in Ethiopic Romans and Andemta Commentary
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Desta Heliso, Ethiopian Graduate School of Theology
This paper explores the gift and Christ in Ethiopic Romans and Andemta Commentary and assesses whether or how a theological understanding of the gift affects conceptions of the gift within anthropological and socio-cultural contexts. In Ethiopic, tsega carries different meanings but ‘gift without return or any payment’ is its central idea. In Ethiopic Romans, tsega is the gift of the Son whereby the Son is both the origin and agent of the gift. Furthermore, for the Andemta commentator, tsega is the means through which salvation or life through Jesus Christ, which is the gift of sonship, is proferred. The gift of sonship is the same thing as the glory of God which Adam lost but was restored by means of the gift of baptism, which made union with Christ (tewahido) possible. How consistent is this idea with Paul’s overarching perspective on the gift? How does such a view affect, if at all, the notion of gift in anthropological and socio-cultural contexts in Ethiopia, where, as in pre-modern societies, gifts operate in reciprocal relations whereby enjoyment of any gift comes with expectation and obligation?
|
Priestly Authority in Ezra-Nehemiah and in the Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Qumran
Charlotte Hempel, University of Birmingham, UK
This paper will explore the presentation of priestly authority in Ezra-Nehemiah and in the Dead Sea Scrolls. We come across statements and strategies that elevate particular priestly groups and individuals alongside material where the authority of priests is compromised or contested In both literatures. Beyond the much discussed material promoting the sons of Zadok in a number of Dead Sea Scrolls, the focus will shift to investigate a series of passages that have received much less attention before offering comparative perspectives from the evidence on priestly authority to be gleaned from Ezra-Nehemiah.
|
The Matthean and Lukan Jesus’ Broad, Eschatological Use of Isa 61:1–3
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Bruce Henning, Trinity College - Bristol / University of Aberdeen
Of the Synoptic gospels, Matthew and Luke record Jesus making significant use of Isa 61:1-3, with Luke 4:16-30 retelling his reading of the text in his inaugural sermon and Matt 5:3-4 and 11:5 alluding to the text alongside others references to the Scriptures of Israel. Not only do the purposes of the Lukan citation and the Matthean allusions differ, but this paper argues that neither references serve the purpose of establishing Jesus’ messianic identity, as is often alleged. Instead, both the Lukan and Matthean Jesus evoke Isa 61:1-3 to communicate the arrival and nature of the kingdom. This essay argues that the Lukan Jesus uses the text self-referentially, but that there is insufficient reason to see Jesus, in Luke 4:16-30, as presenting himself as anything beyond presenting himself as a prophet of the eschaton. This essay also argues that the purpose of the Matthean Jesus’ allusions to Isa 61:1-3 is better understood as eschatological as opposed to messianic, since the disciples accomplish similar feats as Isaiah’s herald. Arriving at these conclusions requires examining the original context of Isa 61 and relevant Jewish citations or allusions to it (Sir 48:22-25, Targum Jonathan, 11Q13, 4Q521, and Luke 4:16-30) to demonstrate sufficient ambiguity precludes thinking a well-accepted messianic interpretation of Isa 61:1-3 is being adopted. Then, the immediate context of the citation in Luke 4:16-30 and the allusions in Matt 5:3-12 and 11:1-6 are examined to demonstrate that the usage of the text is best described as eschatological, not strictly messianic. Though both Matthew and Luke’s overall narratives present Jesus as the messiah, the function of Isa 61:1-3 reinforces the message “the kingdom is at hand,” and not “Jesus is the Christ.”
|
Moses’ Childhood, Unlocking Exodus 4:10: Immigration and Language Acquisition
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Kristine Garroway, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion
“Immigrants, we get the job done.” This lyric from the musical Hamilton has enjoyed relative notoriety recently, most likely because it targets an issue that is as relevant today as it was in 18th century America. But immigration is not a new phenomenon. Archaeology has demonstrated that people have been immigrating from place to place and mixing with foreign populations since there were people. This paper looks at the character of Moses as a child of immigrant parents, whose ancestors came to Goshen from the land of Israel. Furthermore, as Exodus 1-12 makes clear, the Israelites immigrants have become a slave class living in Egypt. Using a combination of childist, socio-historical and social scientific approaches, the paper addresses this “rags to riches” story of an immigrant child, examining the life Moses was born into (slave class) and the life he was raised in (Egyptian royalty). The paper is particularly interested in what Moses was referring to when he refuses his prophetic calling with the claim, “I am slow of speech and slow of tongue” (Exo 4:10). This statement has long puzzled scholars, who have suggested it meant everything from Moses having a speech impediment to Moses losing his ability to speak Egyptian eloquently during his years in Midian. I suggest, however, that none of the previous answers are correct, but that the answer to this question can be found in his childhood.
Central to the discussion of what Moses mean in Exo 4:10 is the issue of language acquisition and what language he was taught in his early years. Much of this depends upon where his mother lived when she was his wet-nurse and what languages were being spoken around him. In concentrating on the early years of an Israelite adopted into the Egyptian court, the paper considers the socio-historical background of wet-nurses and adoption policies and the stigmas associated with adoption. Since the biblical text is influenced by both Mesopotamia and Egypt, an examination of the legal texts concerning wet-nurses and adoption in these cultures will provide some background for understanding Moses’ childhood. I hypothesize that while Moses was raised by his mother, he was not raised in his natal house. Furthermore, I suggest he was taught not to speak Hebrew, but Egyptian. As studies of assimilation among immigrants demonstrate, one of the best ways to blend in is to speak the language of the host-country fluently. Since it was in everyone’s best interest to make sure Moses assimilated into Egyptian culture, I suggest Moses was a HSL, “Hebrew as a Second Language” learner. Studies in language acquisition show that people learn languages easier the younger they are. If Moses learned Egyptian as his first language, and Hebrew later in his life, he may have indeed felt unprepared to make grand speeches to the Israelite people. Ironically, the language of the slave class he was born into serves as an impediment to his ability to “get the job (freeing the Israelites) done.”
|
Guard My Entrance and My Exit: Liturgical Acclamations and Domestic Protection in Late Antique Syria
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Andrew Mark Henry, Boston University
Door lintels from late antique houses in northern Syria frequently display acclamations from Christian liturgies such as the Trisagion or Psalm 121:8. Many of these inscriptions are accompanied by apotropaic symbols attested elsewhere on amulets including medallions, crosses, or Christograms. This suggests that the function of these liturgical acclamations extended beyond the proclamation of worship, functioning also to protect domestic space from harm. Why were these acclamations thought to be suitable strategies for defending domestic space? To what extent do these inscriptions reflect the rituals of local ecclesiastical institutions? This presentation will explore the theory underlying the perceived ritual power of liturgical acclamations in late antique Syria, arguing that their efficacy is closely tied to their orality and performativity. Vocalizing certain parts of Christian liturgies was thought to have the power to trigger miracles or avert natural disasters like earthquakes, but these inscriptions evince that the power of these oral performances could continue in a materialized form such as stone.
|
Silence Breakers: Woman Zion & the #MeToo Movement: Lamentation as Path to Resilience
Program Unit: Biblical Literature and the Hermeneutics of Trauma
Gina Hens-Piazza, Jesuit School of Theology at Berkeley
Bad patriarchal theology coincides with and even authorizes a cultural ethos that normalizes violence against women. Objecting to those who point to the strong man’s lament in chapter 3 of the Book of Lamentations as its centerpiece, this study argues that Lamentation 2.20-22 rises as the focal point for our era. Here the abused woman Zion utters a lament that lets loose an angry tirade at the god of a bankrupt theological tradition, a tradition through which she and other women have been scapegoated and violated. When City Woman Zion confronts the abusing deity and names it the enemy, she not only begins to emancipate from the trauma of victimization and self-blame, but fosters a life giving resilience for herself and other women victims of the #Me Too Movement who dare to lament with her.
|
The Challenge of Jewish Apocalypticism for New Testament Scholarship
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Matthias Henze, Rice University
This important volume The Jewish Apocalyptic Tradition and the Shaping of New Testament Thought reflects a broader aim among scholars of early Jewish thought to claim that we ought to read the New Testament more in the context of Jewish apocalyptic literature. The principle argument of the editors is that we need to think beyond apocalyptic eschatology and understand that “apocalyptic” entails the revelation of heavenly mysteries. Following a brief reflection on how successful attempts in recent years have been to impress upon New Testament scholars the necessity to take early Jewish literature and thought seriously, this paper discusses the advantages and potential problems of this new emphasis on the revelatory aspects of Jewish apocalyptic thought.
|
The Textual Criticism of John's Apocalypse in the Modern Commentary Tradition
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Juan Hernandez, Bethel University (Minnesota)
*
|
A New English Translation of Josef Schmid's Studien zur Geschichte des Griechischen Apokalypse-Textes: Die Alten Stämme
Program Unit: Novum Testamentum Graecum: Editio Critica Maior
Juan Hernandez Jr., Bethel University (Minnesota)
Juan Hernández Jr., in collaboration with Garrick V. Allen and Darius Müller, have made Josef Schmid’s landmark publication, Studien zur Geschichte des Griechischen Apokalypse-Textes, available in English for the first time. For more than sixty years almost every major study of Revelation has been based on Schmid’s work, and this new translation allows scholars to reassess Schmid’s conclusions in light of recent manuscript and technological discoveries. The volume includes a critical introduction that places Schmid’s work in its historical and theoretical twentieth-century context. Additional definitions and explanations of Schmid’s text-critical terms and categories used in his construction of Revelation’s Greek manuscript tradition clarify Schmid’s work for a new audience. The translators correct, update, and supplement Schmid’s Greek manuscript data, and historical and text-critical claims with the latest available information. This paper will offer a full report not only on the findings but also on how Schmid's magnum opus set the stage for current text-critical study of Revelation.
|
Childlessness and Infertility in Job and Ugaritic Literature
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Dominick S. Hernández, The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary
Childlessness is considered a sign of divine judgment in the Bible (cf. Gen 20:18). Thus, it is unsurprising that Job’s friends would point this out in the second round of speeches and insinuate through metaphors that he has lost his children because of his wrongdoing. Job’s lack of offspring is hinted at by Eliphaz through his imagery of bare branches lacking the ability to reproduce (15:32b-33). Eliphaz does not remain subtle for long as his next statement explicitly states that the godless and all in their company are doomed to infertility (v. 34a). Bildad also depicts the wicked as a desolate plant to suggest their complete eradication, and perhaps even the annihilation of their offspring (18:16). The wicked’s lack of children becomes increasingly evident as Bildad proceeds to assert that the memory of the wicked perishes, and that no offspring survive them (vv. 17, 19).
Two Ugaritic texts, The Epic of Kirta and the The Epic of Aqhat, provide examples that lacking progeny was a deep concern in the ancient Near Eastern thought world because it was perceived as a threat to perpetuating one’s name and memory—just as in the world of the Bible (Westermann 1980). Though Ras Shamra has not yielded any Ugaritic wisdom literature per se, it is plausible that the wisdom tradition flourished in the Canaanite scribal world, and that this Canaanite heritage might serve as a backdrop for understanding sections of biblical wisdom literature (Greenstein 2012). The Epic of Aqhat and the Epic of King Kirta are saturated with themes and motifs whose origins are seemingly wisdom literature.
The theme of childlessness that one finds in Job has an even deeper background if one considers the pre-Israelite Canaanite literary tradition. Understanding the second round of speeches of Job in light of Ugaritic literature provides a backdrop to discern the severity of Job’s companions’ metaphors relating to childlessness and infertility, while illuminating Job’s claims regarding the quantity, safety, and joy of the children of the wicked (21:8-9, 11-12). This presentation will provide further examples of how the Ugaritic epics assist in understanding the role of children in depicting the character of the pious and the wicked in Job and other biblical wisdom literature.
|
Ethnicity, Equivocality, and Syntax in Galatians 2:15–17
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
J. Thomas Hewitt, University of Edinburgh
In recent years, scholars have energetically reconsidered the significance of ethnic distinctions and ethnic equivocality for the apostle Paul. However, while gentile inclusion in Jewish identity (cf. Rom 4:11; Gal 3:29; Phil 3:3) has been examined from several new angles, the presentation of Jews in gentile terms has not been integrated adequately into revisionist models of Pauline ethnography. My paper addresses the question of permeable ethnic boundaries in Paul’s thought, with special attention to the role that participation “in Christ” plays in Paul’s conceptualization of the identity of Christ-believing Jews vis-à-vis their new gentile coreligionists. Specifically, I consider the syntactical ambiguity of the Gal 2:17 phrase ei de zētountes dikaiōthēnai en christō heurethēmen kai autoi hamartōloi, the traditional reading of which takes the prepositional phrase “in Christ” as modifying the infinitive “to be justified.” This is reflected in the NRSV’s rendering, “But if, in our effort to be justified in Christ, we ourselves have been found to be sinners ….” There is no grammatical reason, however, why the phrase “in Christ” should not be understood as an adjunct of the clause’s main verb, with the resultant sense “But if, in our effort to be justified, we ourselves [i.e., ‘natural Jews’] were found in Christ also to be ‘sinners’ ….” Further, there are a number of linguistic and contextual features favoring this alternative construal of the syntax of Gal 2:17. These include Paul’s partial subversion in Gal 2:15–22 of the distinction between “Jews” and “sinners,” the latter being an epithet traditionally reserved by Jews for describing those outside of the covenant, and the parallel notion in Phil 3:9 of being “found in Christ” without torah-righteousness. Given these and other factors, I argue that the reading “we ourselves were found in Christ also to be ‘sinners’” is an exegetically valid possibility, and I explore how this description of “natural Jews” as “sinners” functions in counterpoint to the inclusion of gentiles “in Christ” among Abraham’s seed. This paper, by reframing Paul’s statement of ethnic equivocality in Gal 2:17 within his understanding of participation in the messiah, sheds new light on the question of Paul’s post-Damascus Road reconfiguration of ethnic identity.
|
Between Scholasticism and Populism: A Comparison of Ancient Rabbinic and Christian Networks
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Catherine Hezser, SOAS, University of London
Previous studies have applied network theory to either rabbinic or early Christian society and discussed networking activities internally only. I shall look at rabbinic and early Christian networks from a comparative perspective instead. The investigation of similarities and differences between rabbinic and Christian networks can lead to important insights into the development of Jewish and Christian religious communities in the first centuries C.E. My paper shall focus on: the nature of the ties between network members; the form of communication between them; the scope of the network; and the function of networking activities within each group. 1. Nature of the Ties: Rabbis established ties to other scholars based on their shared interest and expertise in Torah study. They formed connections with potential disciples, established and renowned scholars, and ordinary Jews who sought their advice. Whereas giving advice was a temporary activity, long-lasting ties were established with fellow Torah scholars. In early Christianity, by contrast, the collegial network between fellow apostles and missionaries was, from the first century onwards, supplemented by ties to householders and members of local communities who supported and facilitated missionary activities. Through ties to these lay people Christian leaders were able to reach a broader clientele. 2. Form of Communication: Communication between rabbis and their colleagues, students, and followers was predominantly oral, which was limited to encounters between specific individuals in particular circumstances. Each re-utterance implies change and adaptation. In early Christianity, by contrast, Paul used written letters to convey theological messages to his followers in local communities. The letters could be read aloud, copied, and circulated without significant changes in wording. This enabled Christian leaders to more tightly control their followers’ beliefs and morality. 3. Scope of the Network: Initially limited to Roman Palestine, the rabbinic network expanded to Sasanian Persia in the third century. There is no evidence, however, of attempts to create links to scholars beyond the Near East or in the western Diaspora. The use of Aramaic may have been one reason for this limitation. From the time of Paul onwards, the early Christian network expanded eastwards and westwards, throughout the Mediterranean. The use of Greek allowed them to reach a wider constituency. 4. Function of the Network: The rabbinic network’s main function was the promulgation of Torah scholarship. Rabbis were interested in spreading Torah study at their own time and to future generations. The internal goal was the maintenance and survival of a scholastic form of Judaism that would constitute the centre of Torah observance among Jews. By contrast, Christian networking activities sought to missionize and expand. Christian leaders communicated less with each other than with their local constituencies. Their networking activities had populist goals beyond the internal discussion of theological ideas. This paper will show that the comparative study of networking activities among religious groups can provide significant insights into their internal machinations, tactics, and developments. It may help explain the eventual “triumph” of Christianity as well as rabbinic Judaism’s survival into the Middle Ages and modernity.
|
Recent Research on Travel, Network Theory, and Identity in Jewish, Christian, and Graeco-Roman Society (300 BCE – 600 CE)
Program Unit: Jewish, Christian, and Graeco-Roman Travel in the Hellenistic, Roman, and Early Byzantine Periods (300 BCE–600 CE)
Catherine Hezser, University of London and University of Oslo
Since the publication of my books on the rabbinic network in 1997 and on Jewish travel in 2001, studies on issues of mobility and social networking amongst Jews, Christians, Greeks and Romans have increased. In this paper I shall investigate these new trends in research and their contributions to our knowledge about Jewish, Christian, and Graeco-Roman culture and identity. Although travel and networking are separate subject matters, they are also connected: travel widens one’s horizons and leads to encounters with people outside of one’s close circle of family, friends, and colleagues. In antiquity, when our modern means of communication did not exist, physical movement to another place was the most effective and direct way to connect to someone at a more distant location. Depending on the type of connection, such an encounter could lead to changes in one’s own world view and self-perception.
The importance of travel and mobility for the study of ancient Judaism and Christianity has moved beyond the traditional study of pilgrimage. The scope of topics that are now being investigated include issues of purity, religious practice during journeys, and encounters with representatives of other religions. Equally important is the study of more practical matters such as itineraries, sea travel, and hostels. As far as networks are concerned, it seems that our contemporary internet networks have increased interest in ancient networking activities. Recent studies have, e.g., focused on socio-commercial networks that ranged from the Middle to the Far East in late antiquity.
|
Dangerous Doublespeak: The Museum of the Bible and the Fight over Biblical Scholarship
Program Unit: Metacriticism of Biblical Scholarship
Jill Hicks-Keeton, University of Oklahoma
With its prominent location near the U.S. Capitol building and its highly-publicized, frequent visits from U.S. government officials, the Museum of the Bible (MOTB) is fundamentally a political project. As many have now pointed out, the museum’s evangelical roots and continued responsibilities to Christian donors call into serious question its purportedly “agenda-free” account of the Bible. Yet in addition to the MOTB organization’s attempts to normalize the Protestant Bible and to mobilize evangelicals in the political sphere stands a complementary realm in which the MOTB is simultaneously attempting to wield considerable influence: the academic field of biblical studies. In this paper, I argue that the MOTB organization’s engagement with biblical scholarship is characterized by a dangerous doublespeak that seeks to appropriate secular scholarship on the Bible in order to—in a highly visible way—make theological claims about the Bible appear to be affirmed by our guild. The MOTB thus leverages academic inquiry into the Bible and biblical artifacts to support its political project. I offer close readings of three types of evidence: (1) the “Bible Research Lab” in the D.C. museum, whose windows are adorned with rhetoric of discovery and preservation; (2) the MOTB’s longstanding partnership with the Christian Thinkers Society, a Christian apologetics organization with whom MOTB-owned artifacts and museum officials are quietly traveling around the nation in 2018; and (3) the books for sale in the museum gift shop, and particularly those published by the MOTB’s own press imprint. Through these means, I show, the MOTB organization is making a strategic play for the discipline of biblical scholarship, co-opting some of the guild’s most eminent participants to make scholarship on the Bible seem to cohere with Christian theological claims, particularly surrounding the question of where the Bible came from. The presentation will be accompanied by photographs from the museum itself and by short film clips of museum officials in church pulpits problematically (and paradoxically) representing biblical scholarship as a threat to Christian faith—a threat, they imply, that the MOTB is poised to combat. I close with reflections on how and why the very contours, questions, and methods of our field are at stake and why this matters for the future of the field of biblical studies.
|
The Bible and Global-Systemic Criticism in the Age of Fake News
Program Unit: La Comunidad of Hispanic Scholars of Religion
Jacqueline Hidalgo, Williams College
The Bible and Global-Systemic Criticism in the Age of Fake News
|
A Synopsis of the Textual History of 4 Maccabees
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Robert J. V. Hiebert, Trinity Western University
This paper will highlight key features of the textual history of 4 Maccabees in the light of the most recent research on the book, carried out in the course of the preparation of the forthcoming critical edition in the Göttingen Septuaginta series.
|
Retranslating Genesis 1–2
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Theodore Hiebert, McCormick Theological Seminary
As the lead translator of the Book of Genesis for the Common English Bible translation, I had the opportunity to address a number of traditional translations in Genesis, which I had come to believe, on the basis of my work on The Yahwist’s Landscape and other studies of nature in the book of Genesis, represented the perspective of Genesis in ways that are excessively anthropocentric, that mask the awareness of the non-human other in the text, that silence non-human voice and agency, and that falsely subordinate the non-human to the human.
In this paper I would like to describe selected translations in Genesis 1-2 in the Common English Bible that, when compared to the long-standing English translation tradition, retrieve a more integrative understanding of the human and the non-human, that recognize the presence of non-human agency and voice, and that capture a more accurate representation of the human place in the world as Genesis’s authors conceived it.
To illustrate new translation choices in the Common English Bible that reframe the perspectives represented in traditional translations, some of the topics and texts I would like to focus on are the following:
• The agency of land and water as co-creators with God in the creation of the world in Gen 1:9-12, as represented in the translation choices of the verbs used for their activity.
• The role of humanity as a representative of the divine in Gen 1:26-28, as represented in the causative sequence in v. 26 and the translation of radah.
• The translation throughout Genesis 1 of ki tov as emphatic, “how good it was,” rather than descriptive, “that is was good.”
• The creation of the first human in the Eden narrative out of the topsoil of arable land in Gen 2:7 as an agricultural etiology connecting humans with the earth and their agricultural vocation.
• A challenge to the traditional distinction between the human, “living soul/being,” and animals, “living creature,” when the Hebrew terminology is identical.
A whole tradition of translation has inscribed the dualistic, anthropocentric, and hierarchical cast of Western philosophy and theology into the biblical text. Only a careful attention to the world of the text and translations that reflect that world authentically can open up new (“old”) readings that are more ecological sound and sensitive.
|
The Role of the Flood in Biblical History and the Shape of Israelite Identity
Program Unit: Genesis
Theodore Hiebert, McCormick Theological Seminary
I wish to propose that the flood is the primary division in the book of Genesis rather than the call of Abraham in Genesis 12, where it is traditionally placed, and I wish to propose that by dividing their history at the flood, biblical authors constructed a different identity for themselves than we have thought.
The primary evidence interpreters have used to divide Genesis at Abraham—sin and righteousness, curse and blessing, myth and history, and humanity and Israel proper—actually points to the flood as the great divide in Israelite history and to Noah as Israel’s first ancestor. This paper will reexamine that evidence to show that Israel’s historians saw the flood as the great watershed event in Israel’s past.
By dividing biblical history at Abraham, Genesis’s interpreters have been interested in emphasizing Israel’s distinctive identity and in distinguishing Israel as sharply as possible from the rest of humanity. Genesis’s interpreters assigned the era before Abraham to humanity and the one following to the Israelites. They believed the era of humanity to be one of myth and the era of Israel to be one of history. They saw humanity as sinful and cursed and Abraham and his descendants as righteous and blessed.
By dividing their history at the flood, Genesis’s authors constructed a different understanding of themselves, their place in the world, and their relationship to others than their interpreters thought they did. By dividing Genesis at the flood and selecting Noah as their first ancestor, Genesis’s authors have created a social identity for themselves that contrasts sharply with the binary perspective their interpreters have constructed. This identity is based not on emphasizing distance and difference but on building and exploring networks of relatedness and degrees of connection within Noah’s family. The foundation for this distinctive construction of Israelite identity is the selection of Noah as their first ancestor. According to this construction of identity, Israel is viewed as a lineage integrally imbedded within humanity rather than as a people outside of it.
|
Jacob as Liminal Trope: Exploring Sectarian Boundaries through Rabbinic Interactions
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
Andrew W. Higginbotham, Ivy Tech Community College - Lawrenceburg Riverfront
This paper will examine a triad, which is possibly a dyad, consisting of R. Joshua ben Levi, his student-peer R. Jacob, and Joshua’s nemesis of the local “min”-sectarian. Looking at a collection of classical rabbinic texts, (y.AZ 2:2 [40d]; y.Shab 14:4 [14d]; y.Qid 3:12 [64d]; GenRab 32:4; EccRab 1:8, 10:5; b.AZ 4a-b; b.Ber 7a; and b.San 105b), this study seeks to explore the hybridity of both R. Joshua and R. Jacob. This study will first ask whether Jacob Minaah is the sectarian-opponent that R. Joshua seeks to punish. Next, this paper will explore the many Rabbi Jacobs (bar Aha, bar Idi, of Kfar Hanan), whose various toponyms may indicate a similar de-centering as Jacob Minaah. This study will next explore whether Jacob Minaah, as marked outsider, is the same as R. Jacob, the marked rabbinic insider. Finally, an attempt to map both the conflicts and the literary characters to a historical context (which is admittedly problematic) will help to elucidate whether the constellation of Jacobs seemingly in orbit around R. Joshua reflect a working-out of the Rabbinic-Christian border of the first few centuries CE.
|
"Let Him Come and Be Whipped!" The Violent Response to Unauthorized Halakha
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Andrew W. Higginbotham, Ivy Tech Community College - Lawrenceburg Riverfront
This paper will synthesize a characterization of Jacob of Kfar Nevoraya in terms of his “striking” interactions with R. Haggai in several parallel texts (y.Shab 19:5 [17b], y.Yeb 2:6 [4a], y.Qid 3:12 [64d], and Genesis Rabbah 7). In other words, R. Haggai’s violent speech, “Let him come and be whipped!,” in response to Jacob’s trangressive exegesis is not metaphorical, but enacted punishment. This paper seeks to look at the satire of the conflict-scenes between the rabbi and the non-rabbi. At this point, the characterization of Jacob elsewhere (y.Bik 3:3 [65d]/Midrash Samuel 7:6 [Buber, 34b]) as a critic of “ignorant rabbis" also will be investigated as a metaphor of indirect violence (i.e. character assassination). Finally, this paper will examine the question, “why are Jacob’s rulings of kashrut not ‘kosher’ with R. Haggai and (by extension) the author(s) of the text?” In other words, what does the competition described in the text tell us about the security of the rabbinic position in society or about resistance to their nascent authority? The goal of this study is to understand how the literary character of Jacob is being used to communicate a prohibition against teaching halakha outside of the purview of the Rabbis, as well as how the social boundaries between the Rabbis and those around them, communicated through narrative, embody the rhetoric of violence.
|
Captive Brides and Covetous Kings: Female Beauty and Male Possession in Biblical Narrative
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Ryan Stephen Higgins, Jewish Theological Seminary of America
One month before the 2016 election, a recording emerged in which the Republican nominee for President boasted about using his celebrity to sexually assault women. His supporters normalized this aggression as hypermasculine “locker room talk,” and he was soon elected the 45th US president. Beginning in 2017, the “Me Too” and “Time’s Up” movements exposed abuses by powerful men who had for years escaped justice and even accusation. These moments underscore two widespread, sexist sentiments in contemporary culture: women are mere objects of beauty, and men are entitled to possess them. These sentiments are not new; in fact they are perfectly reflected in the deuteronomic law of the captive bride, a beautiful woman from a vanquished people whom an Israelite may take to wife (Deut 21.10-14).
The designation of this victim, yefat to’ar, appears elsewhere to describe the physical beauty of Rachel (Gen 29.17), Joseph (Gen 39.6), Abigail (1 Sam 25.3), and Esther (Est 2.5). This paper takes an intertextual and literary approach, reading each narrative as the story of a captive bride. It suggests for these texts an equivalence of beauty and property, as each vulnerable person becomes the possession of someone more powerful. Through deconstruction, Jacob appears less an unfortunate underdog and more a personification of masculine entitlement. Esther seems not a product of providence but a prisoner of that same masculinity, systematized and writ large. The paper further argues that the stories of Joseph and Abigail present outright critiques of male desire and its institutionalization. In Joseph’s episode, the critique is explicit, making strange the bride’s capture through gender reversal. In Abigail’s story, the critique is as subtle as Abigail herself, part of a pointed evaluation of the character of David.
Reading these stories as captive bride texts can generate new perspectives on biblical masculinity, and its perception of and effects on women. Reading them in conversation with one another can recover biblical critiques of masculinity, providing paths of resistance even against lecherous leaders, powerful predators, and covetous kings.
|
"Words like Silence Break the Violence": Jeremiah’s (un)spoken Speech as Nonviolent Resistance
Program Unit: Writing/Reading Jeremiah
Samuel Hildebrandt, Briercrest College
Daniel Smith published a study in 1989 in which he argued that Jer 29 articulates a strategic posture of “non-violent social resistance” (JSOT 43). Integrating the discussion of violence in Jeremiah since Smith’s contribution, my paper extends his thesis of non-violent yet effective resistance to the person and words of the prophet. Evidently, Jeremiah is the target of violence that is both physical (e.g., Jer 20.1-6; 38.1-6; 43.1-7) and verbal (e.g., 11.18-20; 20.10). How does the prophet respond to this violence? When and why does he speak up? In addressing these questions, I am particularly interested in scenarios in which the prophet’s silence “is heard” as his verbal resistance. This is not only a curious aspect of his persona―after all, a prophet is a spokesperson―but also worth exploring because silence is often understood as resignation. Inspired by Smith’s contribution, I will probe selected passages for their potential to offer a more productive appropriation of the prophet’s silence. Pushing beyond pacifism and submissive suffering, I will ask how prophetic silence has the power to “speak up” against violence without becoming violent itself.
|
“We are Ruined!" Resignation, Despair, and Ohnmacht in Jeremiah’s Poetry
Program Unit: Bible and Emotion
Samuel Hildebrandt, Briercrest College
My paper focuses on the emotional state of resignation and despair as caused by powerlessness (the German term Ohnmacht is helpful to capture this state, translating to “without power” or even “unconsciousness”). I am concentrating on a small corpus of first-person speeches in Jeremiah 4-10 in which the speakers resolve themselves to their powerlessness (e.g., “our hands fall helpless; woe to us; we are ruined”). I will devote attention initially to the Sitz im Leben of these phrases within Israel’s lament traditions and move from this discussion to the question of how these direct expressions of “giving up” function as emotional paradigms for the exilic readership of Jeremiah.
The main body of my paper falls into two sections: A) I will introduce and discuss the emotional state of powerlessness with reference to the work of selected psychologists, philosophers, and social scientists, such as E. Fromm, K. Grossmann, and R. Willer: what are its symptoms and causes? How do humans act in situations of Ohnmacht? How do they cope or work towards re-empowerment? B) On the basis of these observations, the remainder of my paper offers a close reading of the voiced resignation in Jeremiah. I will evaluate the extent to which these emotional expressions fit the modern description of Ohnmacht and perform an exegesis of selected passages in Jeremiah 4-10 that highlights the factors, forms, and functions of resignation.
The paper concludes with some remarks on the relationship between Ohnmacht and theodicy and a few suggestions on how these literary expressions of powerlessness, paradoxically, may serve to empower readers of Jeremiah who experience similar emotions of despair and resignation.
|
A Neglected Text-Critical Siglum in Codex Vaticanus, and Its Import for the Matthean Text
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Charles E. Hill, Reformed Theological Seminary
The original scribes of Codex Vaticanus 1209 used several text-critical sigla. Besides the obelus and asterisk of Origen’s Hexapla, they used two otherwise well-attested sigla for scribal omissions, the ancora and the dotted obelus. They also used cancellation dots, parentheses, and strikethroughs for dittography and erroneous additions. This paper concerns a siglum– a wavy, s-shaped vertical line – that is virtually reserved for substitutions. This siglum has been neglected, misidentified, and all but forgotten by textual critics, though it was noted by Tischendorf. Used by both scribes of the codex, it is employed within the text and repeated in the margin where the substitute word or words are placed. In some cases the substituted text could be a conjecture on the part of the scribe, or an explanatory gloss. But in the majority of cases the substitutions appear to be true alternative readings evidently known to the scribe from another manuscript. In Matthew there are six instances, which Tischendorf believed most likely reflected the scribe’s knowledge and use of another exemplar. This paper will provide an overview of the symbol’s use in the codex and report on a search for other scribes who might have used the symbol in the same way. It will then examine the substitutions in Matthew in particular and show that at least one has been misattributed in N/A. It will affirm Tischendorf’s suspicion that for Matthew the scribe was indeed using a secondary manuscript, and, finally, it will make some suggestions about the textual complexion of that manuscript (hint: it agrees most with De and 1424).
|
The Apocryphal New Testament as "Bound-With" Volume: Collection, Dissemination, Interpretation
Program Unit: Book History and Biblical Literatures
Julian V. Hills, Marquette University
When William Hone published his soon infamous Apocryphal New Testament in 1820, he remarked that “the books . . . naturally assume the title of the Apocryphal New Testament” (Preface, p. v). While it is not my concern to prove this derivation, “naturally” is presumably intended to bring to mind the Old Testament Apocrypha as a parallel, likewise secondary set of writings: of undoubted antiquity, similarly not universally proclaimed as authoritative. Indeed, by this measure, Hone’s collection would come out as decidedly tertiary!
¶My principal interest is to re-present Hone’s collection as a “bound-with” book. That phrase, which has long had currency within library cataloging circles, has recently been given fresh exposure thanks to the groundbreaking manual, Collection-Level Cataloging: Bound-With Books, by Jain Fletcher (2010). A series of reviews by practicing catalogers (Marcus, Rodriguez, et al.) strongly suggest that closer attention is now being given not only to the possibility of better cataloging – more precise terminology and method – but also to the rediscovery of bound-with treasures formerly hidden because subsumed beneath whole-volume titles.
¶The publisher’s blurb announces the book’s purpose: “The volume begins with an explanation of the phenomenon in which individuals assembled and bound together nonrelated printed material, documenting how this practice continued through the centuries as wider literacy and use of printed materials gained ground. The various methods used to describe bound-with books in catalogs over time are also discussed. Most critically for today’s librarians, the book describes the elements that can now be used in putting together a collection-level record for a bound compilation, . . . .”
¶Now, though the term “nonrelated” is too strong (to describe either Fletcher’s project or mine), it draws attention to the fact that the “final” anthologist – whether Hone (following his principal sources, Jones and Wake) or some private collector somewhere – has chosen to bring together materials that were not composed as a collection. They have been brought together, and the reason for that “bringing together” may be sought and sometimes found: from simple practicality (that fragments not be lost) to the desire for completeness – hence Hone’s (admittedly excessive) boast, that “[whoever] possesses this [apocryphal volume] and the New Testament has in the two volumes a collection of all the historical records relative to Christ and his Apostles, now in existence, and considered sacred by Christians during the first four centuries after his birth.”
¶With examples of “binding with” exhibited by the Apocryphal New Testament, the paper suggests some consequences of this collecting of sometimes related and sometimes unrelated materials: the implicit hermeneutics of close association; the “domestication” of difficult passages or texts; the making contemporary of struggles in communities of reception. Indeed, I shall argue that the canonical shadowland of the apocryphal book was understood to be a mirror of the ecclesiastical situation in the U.S. in the post-Hone era, during which non-orthodox Protestant groups promoted its dissemination as part of their multi-faceted rhetorical engagement with well-established church groups.
|
Theology of Crown of Thorns for the Outcast and Paul's Thorn in the Flesh in Second Corinthians 12:7
Program Unit: Asian and Asian-American Hermeneutics
Kei Hiramatsu, Asbury Theological Seminary
Since after Gustavo Gutierrez's A Theology of Liberation (1970), various attempts have been made to advocate interpretations of the biblical texts from the perspective of the poor and oppressed. While liberation theology offers helpful insights into Christian theology and praxis, its hermeneutics, that is its application of a hermeneutical principle of reader-response theory to their biblical interpretation, has also invited a number of criticisms. However, what is lacking in the evaluation of such approach is a careful implementation of insights from the perspective of liberation theology into a holistic exegesis. In other words, we need to demonstrate how a traditional exegesis that incorporates insights from grammatical, literary, socio-historical, and theological findings can affirm, correct, and learn from the interpretation from the perspective of liberation theology. Therefore, in this article I have chosen Paul's thorn in the flesh in 2 Cor 12:7 as a test case to examine how a particular reading of liberation theology from Asian liberation theologian, Teruo Kuribayashi, intersects with the interpretation on the same passage from the traditional exegesis. Then we evaluate what we can learn from both for a better holistic approach to the biblical text. The purpose of the article is to appreciate both the hermeneutical heritages that the Western scholarship has developed and the reality of people as a source for biblical interpretation that liberation theology underscores.
Kuribayashi describes the reality of the oppressed in Asia and develops "a theology of the crown of thorns" in order to cast a light on the ongoing struggle of the outcasts. Their theology of the crown of thorns is the identification of their suffering with that of Jesus and solidarity among the marginalized and oppressed. Does Paul employ "the thorn in the flesh" in the same way the outcasts did? Can he be an exemplar to a legitimate symbolic reading of "the crown of thorns" among the oppressed? In order to examine these questions, I will first describe the theology of the crown of thorns, and I will carefully exegete the same passage making use of grammatical, literary, socio-historical, and theological insights. Then, I will evaluate how these readings from different methodological approaches can illumine one another for a better holistic interpretation of the biblical text.
|
Every Knee Will Bow to Me, the Lord Who Died and Lived (Romans 14)
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Jason D. Hitchcock, Marquette University
In Rom 14, Paul invokes the lordship of Christ and his role at final judgment to inveigh against those who would judge the eating habits of community members. In this dense argument, Paul claims, "For this purpose Christ died and then lived, in order that he might become Lord of both the dead and the living," (v. 9). But commentators rarely draw a close connection to Paul's composite citation in v. 11. Paul prefaces his modified citation with a first-person prophetic oath formula: "As I live, says the Lord." This presentation argues that this constitutes "prosopological exegesis" and that Paul intends Christ as this speaker, the one who sits upon the throne of judgment. As evidence, (1) in another letter, Paul alludes to the very same Isa 45:23 image with clear christological intent [Phil 2:10-11]; (2) Paul generally confines his use of the title kurios to Jesus, and elsewhere in Romans he treats a LXX reference to "the Lord" as if this refers to Jesus [Rom 10:9-13]; (3) the context indicates Jesus's status as judge, seen even in a textual variant which refers to "the throne of Christ" [v. 10].
Furthermore, Paul's rearrangement of Isa 45:23 produces a chiastic structure in v. 10. The citation balances the bending of every knee (to Jesus) with the profession of every tongue unto God. The intent of this rearrangement has not been previously explained, but it may be the result of Paul's intent to place Jesus at the judgment scene, and Paul's repeated references to "the Lord" in Rom 14:1-12 would consistently refer to Jesus.
|
Remythologizing Proverbs: Life and Death in Proverbs Revisited
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Shirley Ho, China Evangelical Seminary
Modern Proverbs scholarship has understood the book of Proverbs as a collection of practical and mundane instructions, advices and wise sayings for everyday living. It is said to be devoid of any religious and cultic ideology of ancient Israel. It is also known for its alleged deistic secular-moralistic program. As a matter of fact, recent scholars are adamant to locate the book of Proverbs in its post-exilic context reflecting the socio-geopolitical realities of the time. As it appears, scholars are in unison that Proverbs is oriented towards this-worldly reward of “life” as a result of wisdom and this-worldly consequence of “death” due to one’s folly. Life and death have been understood in its moralistic-ethical value and worldly reward/consequence. While there are clear evidences that the reward/consequence are this-worldly, but this article seeks to probe the other-worldly mythical reading of life and death in Proverbs. The study will look into the theme and language of: the tree of life, escaping death, swallowed by death, the invincibility/resurrection of the righteous (24:15-16), longevity of life, the preexistence of wisdom, etc. The work shall also interact how this reading creates a tension in ancient wisdom. The article will show how Proverbs can be read as Christian Scripture.
|
Choose Wisdom: The Art and Science of Choice in Proverbs
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Shirley Ho, China Evangelical Seminary
Proverbs scholars have rightly argued that the basic principle that runs through the numerous proverbial sayings in Proverbs is the act-consequence nexus. The principle places the result or consequence of any act on human beings. While the sage puts the responsibility to choose wisdom on human beings, the book is not completely silent on divine determinism. It is in this context the article investigates the role and meaning of human initiative in pursuing wisdom. It will also identify the challenges human beings face in choosing wisdom.
|
The Rhetorical Purpose of Politeuma in Phil 3: A Hybrid Social Identity Approach
Program Unit: Writing Social-Scientific Commentaries of the New Testament
Sin-pan Ho, Lutheran Theological Seminary, Hong Kong
Scholars have hotly debated about the meanings of the word Politeuma in Phil 3.20. Does Paul convey an anti-imperial critique against the Roman Empire? Or does Paul urge Philippians to detach themselves from the society and not ‘of’ the world? Yet, both stances consent that Paul’s emphasis on ‘our’ at the beginning of Phil 3.20 is for constructing a self-designation of Christ-followers antithetical to “the enemies of the cross” in the preceding context. Yet, a key exegetical question has not been addressed by both anti-imperial and non-imperial stances. Paul condemns enemies of the cross against their ways of life in 3.18-19. Then why does he just emphasize our hope in the future and not moral behavior nor any active resistance against Roman Empire in 3:20-21? By taking reference to some hybrid social identity theories as heuristic device, it is argued that there is a coherent logic throughout Phil. 3. The rhetorical purpose of Phil. 3.20-21 is to construct a new hybrid social identity of first readers by utilizing existing civic identity. Instead of eliminating their civic identity, Paul seeks to make use of their existing civic identity they boast of to construct a new hybrid social identity in Christ. Philippians 3.20-21 should be taken as the conclusion of the long “I” discourse in Phil. 3:1-16, that first readers should imitate “I” to embrace a hybrid identity. By creating a spatial space with heaven to which Jesus had already been raised in 2:9-11, civic identity of first readers was transformed and repositioned to be ambassadors of Christ in the city. The hope of their bodies being transformed to conform to Christ’s glorious body in future urges them to suffer with Christ honorably in Roman Philippi at present. As a result, not only is there no any anti-imperial connotation, first readers may hear Paul’s encouragement to retain their civic identity re-oriented in their new hybrid social identity.
|
Socio-rhetorical Reading of Politeuma in Phil 3.20: Beyond Anti-imperial Reading
Program Unit: Pauline Theology
Sin-pan Ho, Lutheran Theological Seminary, Hong Kong
Scholars have hotly debated about the meanings of the word Politeuma in Phil 3.20. Does Paul convey an anti-imperial critique against the Roman Empire? Or does Paul urge Philippians to detach themselves from the society and not ‘of’ the world? Yet, both stances consent that Paul’s emphasis on ‘our’ at the beginning of Phil 3.20 is for constructing a self-designation of Christ-followers antithetical to “the enemies of the cross” in the preceding context. Yet, a key exegetical question has not been addressed by both anti-imperial and non-imperial stances. Paul condemns enemies of the cross against their ways of life in 3.18-19. Then why does he just emphasize our hope in the future and not moral behavior nor any active resistance against Roman Empire in 3:20-21?
In this paper, it is argued that first readers hear a consistent message throughout Phil.3. By taking consideration of the social values and specific cultural values in the urban city Roman Philippi and the dominant values of Roman soldiers, it is argued that the rhetorical purpose of Phil. 3.20-21 is to radicalize their values of honor in Christ. By utilizing the theology of resurrection of Christ, Paul recalls the first readers to the royal image of Christ in resurrection in 2.9-11. Paul makes use of honour and shame values of military people / veterans to reshape their orientation of suffering for Christ instead of striving for survival in the world. Philippians 3.20-21 should be taken as the conclusion of the long “I” discourse in Phil. 3:1-16, that first readers should imitate Paul to hope for being resurrected with Christ in the future. This theology of resurrection with Christ is now represented in terms of transformation of lowly bodies to conform to Christ’s glorious body.
Through his radical redefinition of honorable sacrifice for heavenly king Jesus, civic identity of first readers was transformed to be ambassadors of Christ in the city. The re-phrased resurrection theology in 3.21 urges them to suffer with Christ honorably in Roman Philippi at present. As a result, not only is there no any anti-imperial connotation, first readers may hear Paul’s message of mimicry of their existing patriotic spirits to Jesus Christ resurrected by God’s power. They may hear Paul’s encouragement to be friends of the cross stated in 3.8-9—that we may win Christ and live in Him. The theology of corporate resurrection with Christ by God’s power is well articulated and summarize by the word Politeuma in 3.20. It retains their civic identity. The hope of image of body transformation, not put-off-put-on clothing imagery, reminds them of reorientation of what they boast of in the past to pursue for more valuable honors to be friends of the cross.
|
Augustine and Irenaeus on the Perfection of Adam
Program Unit: Early Exegesis of Genesis 1–3
Eric Hoff, Oxford University
Augustine and Irenaeus are often portrayed as having differing positions on the perfection of Adam as he was initially created. For Irenaeus, Adam was not created perfect but was created to grow into the perfection which God initially created for him (Dem. 12; Ad Haer. IV, 38, 3). Augustine, however, emphasizes the perfection of the initial creation and makes Adam's sin as the cause for sin and evil in the world, and repeatedly in de genesi ad litteram he calls creation.
This paper would like to challenge this understanding of the relationship of Augustine to Irenaeus. Through looking at de libero arbitrio and de genesi ad litteram it will show how the development of Adam, in both his body and his soul, was a crucial part of Augustine's understanding creation. This development was necessary because Adam, as a creature, could not be created perfect but needed to grow into that perfection.
However, this does not mean that Augustine and Irenaeus are in agreement on what the growth of Adam looked like. For Irenaeus Adam's growth is portrayed as the maturation of infant to adult, while for Augustine the emphasis is on growth in wisdom and justice, and the transformation from mortal to immortal.
The reason for this difference is that Irenaeus works from a Christology starting with the incarnation, while Augustine bases his anthropology of Adam on the eternal generation of the word. While these two Christologies are not mutually exclusive, the difference in emphasis explains why the Augustinian and Irenaean Adams differ from each other.
Therefore Augustine and Irenaean do have different portrayals of Adam, but this difference is not found in one holding to a perfect Adam while the other has a Adam needing development. Instead, one bases Adam upon the future incarnation of the Word, while the other models Adam on the eternal generation of the Word.
|
The Iconic Qurʾān: A Materialist Reading of the Qurʾānic Cult of Writing
Program Unit: Qur’anic Studies: Methodology and Hermeneutics (IQSA)
Thomas Hoffmann, University of Copenhagen
The Qurʾān is often identified as an aniconic, even iconoclastic, text. The stories about Moses and his people’s apostasy through their worship of ‘a calf, an image’, ijl jasad (Q 7:149), and Abraham’s destruction of idols (Q 21:58), are two prominent examples of the Qurʾān’s strong aniconic program against images, understood here as three-dimensional representations (of gods). The image is contrasted with the divine word (and its related paraphernalia, such as ‘the pen’, ‘the pages’, ‘the scrolls’, ‘the mother book’, ‘heavenly scribes’, ‘the book’, ‘the people of the book’), the former addressing the haptic, visual, and ‘superficial’ senses, and the latter, the conceptual, the innermost, and the intellect (ʿaql). The former addressing a now superseded type of religion and the latter identified as expressive of Late Antiquity’s general endorsement of the book as the religious medium par excellence. These contrasts, however, are problematic and not only betray a theological bias, but they also neglect the Qurʾān’s iconic qualities and functions. Consequently, I will argue that while the Qurʾān promotes itself as a substitute to the religious icon and image, it in fact serves the same function as the religious icon and image. The Qurʾān becomes iconic. In terms of functionality, there is no difference between a cult of images and the veneration of the Qurʾān (and the muṣḥaf). This qurʾānic program proved extremely successful and Islamic civilization subsequently developed into a culture and polity that put extreme emphasis on writing and ‘writtenness’ (cf. Brinkley Messick’s apt term ‘the calligraphic state’). The basic claim is that religious texts, in casu the Qurʾān, are material objects too. The methodological implications of this interpretation of the Qurʾān and qurʾānic culture calls for a renewed attention to the concept of materialism and materiality in relation to words and scripture. This includes some comparative insights gained from recent theoretical developments in materialist approaches to the Bible. Finally, my paper is also an attempt to complement decades’ strong academic attention to the oral-aural aspects of the Qurʾān.
|
Understanding Violence and Divine Activity in Exodus in the Context of the Midwives' Narrative in Exodus 1
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Marina Hofman Willard, Palm Beach Atlantic University
Understanding Violence and Divine Activity in Exodus in the Context of the Midwives' Narrative in Exodus 1
|
An Image on the Stele or a Ghost in the Shell? A Cognitive Scientific Approach to the Material "Soul" in Syro-Anatolia and the Levant
Program Unit: Cognitive Science Approaches to the Biblical World
Tim Hogue, University of California-Los Angeles
With the discovery of the much-discussed Katumuwa Stele at Zincirli in 2008, debates over the nature of the “soul” were transferred from philosophical circles to philological ones. Thus far, these debates have centered on whether Katumuwa’s “soul” was merely a material representation or an immaterial entity residing in the material. This false dichotomy is an anachronistic Cartesian mind/body dualism that has been projected back onto the ancient conceptual world by modern scholars. Blending theory, especially as articulated by Gilles Faucconier and Mark Turner, provides a framework for reconstructing an ancient, non-Cartesian conception of the soul in light of the archaeological and epigraphic evidence. Drawing on the full range of Hieroglyphic Luwian and Northwest Semitic references to the “soul,” comparable materiality-based studies of images and monuments in the broader ancient Near East, and Alfred Gell’s concept of “distributed personhood,” I will argue that the soul in ancient Syro-Anatolia and neighboring cultures was a complex blend of material and agency. I propose that Syro-Anatolian and Levantine stelae were what Fauconnier and Turner label ‘material anchors.’ They anchored a conceptual integration network that blended the material object with the presence, personhood, and agency of the object’s commissioner. The soul was an emergent structure within this blend. The Syro-Anatolian soul was therefore neither an image on the stele nor a ghost it contained. It was rather a conceptual blend of material and personhood. Similar conceptualizations are observable across the ancient Near East and undoubtedly informed the biblical category of the soul as well. Though each cultural context drew on the domains of materiality and personhood to varying degrees, they all alike conceived of the soul as materialized or embodied, whether by a human body, a material object, or some combination of both. This paper’s case study of the soul as conceptualized in Zincirli will demonstrate the utility of blending theory for fleshing out the particulars of such conceptual blends.
|
Para phusin; alis ēdē ("Unnatural? Enough Already!"): Willful Wo/men Interrupting Paul
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
James N. Hoke, Luther College
Romans 1:18-32 has long been a participant in politics, modern as well as ancient, particularly in terms of sex. Generally speaking, whether an interpreter situates Paul as a "dummy" who parrots Roman norms (e.g., S. Moore, D. Martin) or as a resister who subtly critiques imperial sexual excess (e.g., N. Elliott, T. Jennings), approaches to this passage remain focused on Paul's political ideas. But how did Paul's politics participate in a wider political conversation in Rome's ekklēsia? In particular, how did Roman women (who, as shown by Romans 16, were clearly among the first hearers of these words) react to these ideas about politics, sexuality, and gender? In this paper, I use Romans 1:18-32 as a "test case" for developing affective notions of assemblage in ways that can proliferate plausible political ideas that were developing in Rome's ekklēsia.
Assemblages, especially as discussed in contemporary feminist and queer theories, offer a way to interrupt Paul. Since assemblages attempt to capture the complexities that exist in and between bodies that are always changing in relation to one another, J. Puar describes working with theories of assemblage as one way of "becoming-intersectional." Alongside the work of E. Grosz, these mobile configurations of bodies can help Pauline scholars think about the diversity within first-century ekklēsiai- "eccentric assemblages," as J. Marchal has written. But assemblages move bodies that are interacting, sometimes peaceably, sometimes disruptively, and often both simultaneously. Developing these theories of assemblages within Paul's letters, I argue that, like wo/men participants in other ekklēsiai, the wo/men in Rome's ekklēsia can be seen as willful (as theorized in S. Ahmed's feminist theory) disruptors of Paul's ideas. They interrupt Paul's ideas in order to expand, displace, or change them in relation to their own political hopes.
This paper gives content to some of these plausible interruptions. Such interruptions proliferate possible reactions to Paul's ideas among the letter's earliest hearers, thus following feminist biblical scholarship's reminder that Paul's letters participate in debates and discussion among complex networks of Christ-followers. By proliferating some examples of how willful wo/men in Rome plausibly interrupted (bodily or vocally) Paul's ideas in Romans 1:18-32, my paper works within the feminist call to invoke first-century political ideas that extend "beyond the heroic Paul" (M. Johnson-DeBaufre and L. Nasrallah). Ultimately, by interrupting Paul, I use assemblage as a political model for subverting his longstanding monovocality-which has been used for far too long to clobber-and argue for how queer readers, ancient and contemporary, might move their politics beyond Romans 1:18-32.
|
Rethinking Rebels: Terrorism and Homonationalism around Romans 13
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
James N. Hoke, Luther College
The image of the patriotic citizen is produced in tandem with the threatening figure of the terrorist, as J. Puar shows in Terrorist Assemblages (2007). In first-century Rome, similar distinctions are drawn between loyal imperial subjects and rebels, who are often cast as barbaric threats. The figures of the patriotic subject and the terroristic rebel both feature in Paul's discussions surrounding submission and Roman rule in Romans 13. In the contemporary setting, Puar analyzes how these opposing figures are produced through racialized and sexualized rhetoric, particularly via homonationalism, which accepts certain persons who largely conform to the terms of patriotism ("subjects worthy of rehabilitation") at the expense of bodies whose difference is too exceptional.
These contemporary tactics take on an ancient formulation within Romans 13: just as the terrorist-patriot binary produces scripts for proper performance of contemporary citizenship, so too does Paul's distinction between the hypotassomenos ("s/he who submits") and the antitassomenos ("s/he who rebels"), particularly as he spells out the ethics for good conduct in 13:3-14, which includes sexualized language surrounding self-control and rebellious immoderation (especially in vv.11-14). Indeed, if terror is dangerous in the hands of the rebel, it is legitimated as a response to rebellious behavior. For Paul, rulers are only "a terror" (phoboi) to rebels who behave badly (Rom 13:3), a statement that bears eerie similarity to the contemporary legitimation of terrorization and torture of bodies presumed guilty of terrorism.
But binaries-particularly those sustained by homonational tactics, ancient and contemporary-obscure complex realities by demanding that bodies lock into a clear-defined grid. Can different formulations of ancient rebels respond differently to terror? This paper ultimately places Paul's binary between ethical submission and terroristic rebellion (that deserves the terror-punishment it provokes) as one perspective among many that existed among the wo/men in Rome's ekklēsia. Because Paul's perspective largely aligns with Roman ethics, this paper considers evidence and narratives surrounding examples of first-century "rebels" (e.g., Josephus' description of the Jewish Revolt; evidence of resistance and rebellions among Roman slaves) to think about other models that were known and plausibly inhabited by these wo/men. By expanding Puar's theorization of assemblages-which consider the complexity of movements that surround the overt "phase shifts" seen in rebellious action-the paper concludes by proffering the plausibility of more complex responses to the terror of Roman rule. These responses include, but are not limited to, total, outright opposition. By connecting both Puar's critique of homonationalism and her development of queerness as an assemblage to Paul and the wo/men around his letter to the Romans, this conclusion offers one response to questions surrounding the present "age of terror" by bringing it into closer proximity with terrors from the past.
|
Repeated Performance and the Creation of a Rhetorical Matrix in Paul’s Churches
Program Unit: Performance Criticism of the Bible and Other Ancient Texts
Glenn Holland, Allegheny College
We find clear evidence that Paul’s letters were reperformed for new audiences in both the content and the very existence of the deutero-Pauline letters 2 Thessalonians, Colossians, and Ephesians. All three refer to Paul’s letters being re-performed to audiences beyond their original recipient congregations. All three are also based on the underlying fiction that they are letters written by Paul to “another” congregation and now “reperformed” for new audiences – audiences that are not in Thessalonike, Colossae, or Ephesus. Each letter also builds on Paul’s use of specific terminology and rhetorical structure – sometimes by outright imitation – to expand and develop Paul’s ideas to address the needs of a new, later audience or the goals of its author. The performance and re-performance of the deutero-Pauline letters themselves further solidifies Paul’s terminology, rhetorical strategies, and theological concepts – as well as their later development by the deutero-Pauline authors – as a normative standard not only for congregations founded by Paul, but for all Jesus congregations that recognize Paul’s authority. Paul’s widely-spread influence in the second century is a product, not of the original performance of Paul’s letters by his emissaries to the specific congregation each letter addresses, but of their repeated re-performance by a variety of readers before numerous congregations over a period of decades. Paul’s influence in terms of his language and his conceptual world beyond the congregations he founded is arguably entirely the result of the re-performance of his letters.
|
Were Roman Taxes Low? Contextualizing the Early Imperial Tax Burden
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
David Hollander, Iowa State University
While Roman tax policies certainly varied from region to region and over time, many scholars believe that Roman taxes tended to be relatively low (see, e.g., Garnsey and Saller 2015; Rathbone and Temin 2008, 416). If this is the case, it has important implications for the nature and development of the Roman economy. However, taxation is only one means of extracting revenue from a given population, and, as James Tan (2017) recently made clear for the Republic, Roman officials were adept at exploiting the provinces while limiting the growth of state revenue. This paper will review the evidence for Roman taxation in the first two centuries of the Empire and attempt to contextualize it with respect to other forms of revenue extraction.
|
“Thy Kingdom Come”: Karl Barth and Dietrich Bonhoeffer on the Political Significance of the Second Petition
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
Jack Holloway, Union Theological Seminary in the City of New York
Karl Barth and Dietrich Bonhoeffer, theologians together in the Confessing Church movement that resisted Naziism, both wrote tracts on the second petition of the Lord’s Prayer, “Thy kingdom come.” Barth’s is found in a fragment of his Church Dogmatics IV.4, published as The Christian Life. It was thus written during the final stage of his career. Bonhoeffer’s, on the other hand, was written in November 1932, just before Hitler became Chancellor of Germany. Read next to each other, they reveal profound theological agreement between them, as well as significant differences in their political thinking.
They both affirm the coming kingdom of God as absolutely ultimate and decisive. The resurrection of Jesus Christ points to a future resurrection of all creation, which can only be brought about by God. Furthermore, they both proceed from this affirmation to the political consequences of praying, “Thy kingdom come.”
For Barth, the political responsibility of Christians consists in waiting for and hastening toward the kingdom of God. We pray for what only God can do, but we only pray properly when prayer mobilizes us here and now to pursue little glimpses of the justice that is to come. It is on this basis that Barth advocates a revolutionary orientation toward the present state of things. It is precisely because we pray “Thy kingdom come” that we act decisively for revolutionary social change in the present.
Bonhoeffer’s approach, however, is quite different. He is often remembered as a social justice hero of the most radical sort, a revolutionary who advocated fighting for justice by any means necessary. His quote about putting a “spoke in the wheel” of injustice is a powerful one, almost immediately evoking images of revolution for resistance-minded folks. And yet, it is almost never contextualized, and Bonhoeffer’s actual meaning by it is almost never considered. In “Thy Kingdom Come,” Bonhoeffer lays out his theology of church and state, referring to the church as the witness to the coming kingdom of resurrection, and the state as an order of preservation necessary for keeping the world from falling into collapse or utter destruction. The church’s job is to preach the Gospel; the state’s job is to preserve the world for hearing the Gospel. Bonhoeffer’s theology thus lacks the ethical imperative that follows from Barth’s theology of the coming kingdom.
For Bonhoeffer, the coming kingdom of God is so ultimate that all of human history becomes about waiting for it and witnessing to it. For Barth, however, praying “Thy kingdom come” becomes the ground for decisive revolutionary action here and now.
|
Marginalization, Hope, and Mission: Diaspora Readings of 1 Peter
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Doug Holm, Denver Seminary
1 Peter draws on language of immigration, exile and diaspora both to describe the social dislocation of the suffering Anatolian congregations and to construct their identity. Recent studies have drawn upon sociohistorical and postcolonial theory to shed light on the description of the multiethnic communities through the appropriation of ethnic terms and titles for Israel from the Hebrew Bible. Today, the recent political climate and polarizing rhetoric concerning immigration in the United States and around the world has brought increased attention to the complicated existence navigated by those who cross borders to live outside of their country of origin. In the United States, Hispanics make up the largest minority group in the US, and in less than thirty years the US will be a country of minorities with no majority ethnic group. Now more than ever, biblical scholars as well as practitioners can profit from listening to the voices of minorities and those from the majority world as they read biblical texts from social locations analogous to the biblical context. This paper investigates Hispanic/Latina/o readings of diaspora language in 1 Peter to argue that the usage recognizes the increasingly marginalized status of the recipients while also inspiring hope during their temporary status as immigrants and envisioning a missional purpose for them in their society.
|
Divine Speech, Hebrews, and the Rhetoric of the Sublime
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Christopher Holmes, McAfee School of Theology
The treatise, On the Sublime, describes the nature and intended effects of the rhetoric of the sublime or what I have called sublime rhetoric. Sublime rhetoric is a short-hand reference to discourse that moves beyond persuasion, the topic and assumed goal of much of ancient rhetorical theory. As the author explains in the first chapter of the treatise, sublime rhetoric is characterized by its non-or super-rational effects. Couched in language drawn from religious experience, magic, and military conquest, the author says that sublime rhetoric has the capacity to lead the audience into ecstasy, to cast a spell upon them, and to assert an “irresistible power of mastery” over them (Subl. 1.4). In the eighth chapter of On the Sublime, the author identifies the five sources of sublime rhetoric, and the rest of the treatise elaborates on those sources with examples drawn from a variety of Greek authors. One of the surprising details in On the Sublime is its allusion to the creation story in the book of Genesis as an example of sublime rhetoric (Subl. 9.9). This paper takes as its point of departure the author’s reflection on this allusion and how it relates to sublime rhetoric. It considers the reasons why the author identifies this as an example of sublime rhetoric and how it relates to the intended effects of sublime rhetoric as they are described elsewhere in the treatise. With this example in mind, the paper then evaluates the theme of God’s speech as an avenue for considering sublime rhetoric in Hebrews. The paper will highlight how the references to God’s speech in Hebrews tap into what Yun Lee Too (The Idea of Ancient Literary Criticism) has called the “spatialized and moved language” of sublime rhetoric. Sublime rhetoric displaces the audience by uplifting, transporting, and re-situating them. One of the important aspects of sublime rhetoric in Hebrews is that it moves the audience out of their empirical life situation through dislocation so that they might perceive that life situation in a new way.
|
The Martyrdom of Polycarp and Jewish-Christian Relations in Smyrna: Rhetoric and Reality
Program Unit: Westar Institute
Michael Holmes, Bethel University (Minnesota)
*
|
Critical Editions or Flawed Manuscript Evidence? The Methodological Challenge of Writing a Descriptive Grammar of Early Ge‘ez
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Robert Holmstedt, University of Toronto
The vast majority of activity in current Ge‘ez philology is focused on digitalizing manuscripts in the service of the text critical enterprise, with the primary goal of establishing a scholarly critical edition of the books of the Ethiopic Bible. But what is the place of critical editions in research on the history of the language? Put another way, when faced with manuscript evidence that by general scholarly agreement exhibits, in some places, grammatical or textual error, what is the linguist to do? This paper will explore the role of manuscript evidence and critical editions in a recently funded SSHRC project to write a descriptive grammar of the earliest manuscript of the Ge‘ez Gospel of Mark.
|
The Janus Nature of the Study of Language Change and Language Contact
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Robert Holmstedt, University of Toronto
Investigating language changes due to time or contact with other languages has a long history in Biblical Hebrew studies. Attention to phonological and morphological variations and lexical alterations within the biblical text became intimately connected to the bloom of comparative and historical language study in the early nineteenth century. With the advent of modern approaches to language study, which can be traced back to the mid-nineteenth century—though it is more often associated with the early twentieth century and de Saussure’s Lectures—the relationship between ‘philology’ and ‘linguistics’ has often been strained, if not adversarial. In this paper I will explore how examples of language change, often but not always induced by language contact, can be oriented towards either the reading of texts (philology) or the analysis of language systems (linguistics). In the process, I will address the philology-vs-linguistics question and offer a way forward that is neither adversarial nor mired in nineteenth- and twentieth-century history.
|
Isak—the Son of the Rainmaker—and the Bible: An Example of Resistance Hermeneutics in Zululand in the 1860s and 70s
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Knut Holter, VID Specialized University, Norway
With illustrative cases from Norwegian mission work in Zululand in the 1860s and 70s, the paper will discuss how and to what extent Bible translation and the general scripturalizing focus of missionary Christianity enabled converts to counter aspects of missionary teaching. Two cases will be discussed, both being related to Isak, an early convert who was also the son of a famous rainmaker in Zululand. One is Isak’s suggestion to organize the converts—living at the Norwegian mission stations in Zululand—under an induna, a Zulu chief, rather than under the missionary, hence integrating the Christian communities more explicitly into the Zulu society. The other is Isak’s taking of wives number two and three, referring to Abraham and other biblical polygamists. In both cases the interpretive power vis-à-vis the Bible is at stake, being that of the convert or that of the missionary. The cases will therefore be interpreted as examples of a kind of resistance hermeneutics that with the tools of missionary scripturalization tries to develop a contextualized form of Christianity.
|
A Trial Text from Alalakh (AT 7) and the Question in Biblical Prayers
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Shalom E. Holtz, Yeshiva University
Direct accusations and accusatory questions to God characterize the biblical lament tradition, occurring in both communal (e.g. Ps. 44:10–24) and individual (e.g. Ps. 22:2–3) laments. They have been understood as expressions of protest, but also, more pointedly, as examples of petitioners' "turning the tables" on God and transforming themselves from accused individuals into accusers. Pietro Bovati, for example, adopts this legal reading when he refers to these features in a description of the complaint in Israelite trial procedure. Do these accusations find meaningful legal analogues that confirm, or at least allow, the understanding that they open litigation against God? To answer this question, this presentation will draw on a trial text from Alalakh (Wiseman, AT 7), which Rachel Magdalene has brought to bear on Job's confrontation with God. The Akkadian trial record, which describes the (earthly) litigation between two siblings over an inheritance, also furnishes a meaningful lens through which to read accusatory prayers. Comparison with this text confirms the legal-procedural possibility of lodging a defensive counter-accusation. Furthermore, attention to the dialogue recorded in the trial record illuminates two specific formal-linguistic aspects of the laments, as well: addressing accusations directly to the accused and presenting these accusations in the form of questions.
|
My Beloved Is Mine: Song of Songs in Contemporary Jewish Ketubot
Program Unit: Jewish Interpretation of the Bible
Jonathan Homrighausen, Duke University
In the post-1960s revival of the ketubah as a Jewish art form, ketubah artists, many of them women, have used this medium to explore changing ideals of Jewish marriage—both in the legal formula of the ketubah's text and in its border designs admitting a wide array of artistic freedom. The frequent presence of the Song of Songs in these border designs provokes the question: How do these ketubot visually exegete the Song to symbolize ideals of Jewish marriage? These ketubot invoke the Song both by quoting particular verses, often in stylized calligraphy, and by including symbols from the Song such as doves, grapevines, lilies, pomegranates, and gardens. By analyzing ketubot by artists such as Debra Band, Naomi Teplow, and David Moss, and by incorporating interviews with selected artists, I show how these works reclaim the Song for Jewish feminists through art the same way Rachel Adler and Marcia Falk have through scholarship and translation. At the same time, I trace how this feminist reclaiming of the Song is problematized by feminist readers such as Cheryl Exum who allege that not all in the Song is rosy and perfect for gender relations. Further, how do we square the use of the Song for these marriage documents with the lack of clarity over the presence of marriage in the Song at all? Do these ketubot distort the Song by quoting very selectively, or do their quotes and symbols extract something of the true essence of the Song? Because of their triple use as halakhic contract, wedding ritual component, and creative fine art, the ketubot serve well to illustrate the place of the Song in Jewish feminist interpretation and marital life.
|
A Religiopolitical Reconfiguration of the Urban Space: The Functions of the Salutaris Foundation as an Imperial Cult
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Sung Soo Hong, University of Texas at Austin
In accordance with the bequest of Salutaris in 104 CE, a procession was regularly held in Ephesos on a circular route from the Artemision into the city and then back to the temple. This paper argues that the Salutaris procession is best understood as a local and mobile form of imperial cults, which was the city’s way of honoring the Roman Empire and promoting its prominence in relation to other competing cities. The historical context in my view is that, since the death of Domitian, Ephesos probably had the need to show its loyalty to the new imperial family, erasing its past connection to the Julio-Claudian dynasty, especially Domitian. The Salutaris foundation, funded by a Roman aristocrat and approved by imperial authorities, afforded a fine opportunity to fulfill that purpose. The procession was a local imperial cult: local inasmuch as it was established by the decrees of the demos and the boule of Ephesos; mobile, since it moved through the city. I further argue that the processions functioned to structure the space of the city.
This paper consists of three parts. The first discusses Steven Friesen’s analysis of imperial cults as religion, which serves as this paper’s theoretical foundation. The second describes briefly the Salutaris inscription, and reviews critically previous interpretations by Guy Rogers and Lilian Portefaix, which represent, in my view, extreme cases in the spectrum of interpretation. The third and major part offers my interpretation, as I analyze the ordering of the city’s space in terms of Friesen’s points presented in the first part.
|
“And the Number of His Name Is...”: 616 as a Donatist Exegetical Token
Program Unit: Contextualizing North African Christianity
Jesse A. Hoover, Baylor University
As a contribution to the second session of our section, “Interpretations of Apocalyptic Texts in Christian North Africa,” I would like to examine the role that the apocalyptic number 616 played in Donatist exegesis. This variant form of the “number of the beast” is known from very early on: Irenaeus famously mentions it in Adversus Haereses 5.30.1, and it may be found in the manuscripts Papyrus 115 (the oldest fragment of Revelation yet found), Codex Ephraemi Rescriptus (Greek) and Ms. B 3 (Latin).
When we probe into its actual usage among early exegetes, however, we notice something odd. While Irenaeus warns that “some, in their simplicity... have ventured to seek out a name which should contain the erroneous and spurious number [i.e., 616],” the only evidence we have for its use in practice comes from Donatist sources: Tyconius and those Catholic writers dependent on him (e.g. Caesarius of Arles, Primasius of Hadrumetum, and the anonymous author of the De Monogramma XRI), and the independent witness of the Liber genealogus (Sangallensis 614 + Florentini and Lucensis). To this number I will introduce a third Donatist source, which to my knowledge has not been recognized before: capitula 16 of the Donatist chapter-titles for Daniel (found in Biblia Sacra Vulgatam 16.23). After demonstrating the legitimacy of this new witness to 616 in Donatist exegesis, I will then reflect on its implications. The fact that we now have three Donatist texts which incorporate the 616 variant warrants a closer look at the significance of this number within the Donatist community – and the version of the Vetus Latina it used.
|
Blurring Spaces in the Song of Songs
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Matthias Hopf, University of Zurich
The Song of Songs has a very unique approach to presenting space: We find a multi-level variety of sceneries that tend to blur and to cross-fade one into the other, even as they are created by the Woman’s and Man’s words.
This paper will first explore the Song’s manifold forms for conveying and applying spatial notions: Of course, in some instances we find the characters in the Song crafting the setting they are situated in by describing it. This is a rhetoric device known in drama theory under the name of ‘verbal scenery’. Noticeably though, those spaces ‘on stage’ (i.e. the space where the speakers are situated while they are speaking) are described quite sparsely. Probably the spaces contoured most sharply are the private and secluded retreats, where the lovers can be on their own. Yet not uncommonly, the setting in which the speakers are located is not described at all leaving the characters on an ‘empty stage’, so to speak. At the same time, the words uttered by the Woman and the Man time and again create spaces beyond the ‘stage’ itself. One can observe that those spaces are frequently painted in greater detail than the space of the ‘stage setting’ itself. Still, we need to distinguish between the various forms of ‘off-stage-space’, as they are quite diverse in character: One can find metaphorical use of spatial notions, as well as ‘true off-stage-scenery’, i.e. spaces the lovers have been in or long to be in. This looking back and looking forward opens up virtual, sometimes even utopic spaces on yet another level. In those the readers/listeners are drawn into, taking them on a journey through the described sceneries and landscapes.
In a second step I will concentrate on the rhetoric and dramatic function of the modes of presentation. One aspect, e.g., is that these ‘scenic remarks’ frequently indicate time leaps and changes of scenery, thus, lending a certain structure to the unfolding verbal exchanges. Yet interestingly, the scenic transitions take place so smoothly and almost unnoticeably that one scene ‘cross-fades’ into the other, and the spaces blur to some degree (to take up the wording by J. Cheryl Exum in her commentary on the Song). Something very similar is true for the spaces of the ‘off-stage-scenery’: Of course, they are invoked only by the verbal utterings of one of the characters. Still, they become so lively that it is hard to tell if it is really an ‘off-stage-scenery’ or the actual ‘stage setting’. In other words, the level of the space ‘on stage’ and the level of the verbal scenery blur in a way. In some cases the invoked ‘off-stage-space’ even seem to superimpose themselves on the latter. This recurring blurring of spaces in the Song is discerned as an intentional stylistic device. It is proposed that it serves to keep open the imaginative process of reading/listening. It, thus, draws the readers/listeners into the textual spaces, and, as a result, heightens their sense of self-identification with the characters in the Song.
|
Some Thoughts on Hebrew Thought: With Special Reference to Tense-Aspect-Mood and the Verb
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Aaron D. Hornkohl, University of Cambridge
The question of whether and to what degree individual languages dictate, influence, or reflect the specific perception and thought categories of their respective users has long intrigued readers of the Hebrew Bible. The issue has relevance for, inter alia, the intersection between reality and perception ostensibly revealed via the ancient Hebrew verbal system. Are the relative dearth and ambiguity of explicit tense-aspect-mood (TAM) morphological marking indicative of a characteristically Hebrew conception of reality, one with relatively few and vague TAM distinctions? Despite notable advances, modern scholarship cannot seem entirely to shake the effects of certain long-held, but problematic, assumptions. By way of example, doubts concerning the ancient Israelite notion of time still often seem to animate discussions of the Hebrew verbal system. Methodologically, treatments of the Biblical Hebrew verbal system have regularly been characterized by a reductionist tendency that seeks to derive all meaning from a single basic TAM category. However, the apparent fusing of TAM values in Biblical Hebrew verbal forms is a phenomenon known from many languages. If so, the traditional quest for a single overarching semantic verbal value may be misguided, likely to obscure rather than clarify matters. Both diachronically and synchronically, the Biblical Hebrew verbal forms are fruitfully conceived of as polyvalent markers comprising a combined TAM system, in which, to be sure, certain categories are conveyed more prominently than others. Another problem has been a narrow morphological focus. Since in Biblical Hebrew TAM signaling extends beyond verbal morphology, accounts of TAM expression must not be unduly influenced by the relative paucity and semantic ambiguity of the language’s verbal forms. On the nature of the correlation between language and perception, there is unquestionably much to be gained from investigations into ancient Hebrew TAM marking. Ironically, however, absent a radical reappraisal of the ways past methodological biases continue to inform—and even dictate—current conceptual frameworks and terminology, there is the danger of persisting with predetermined perceptions according to outdated assumptions and limiting innovation to variations on past approaches that have never been more than partially adequate.
|
A Neglected Allusion to Leviticus 4–5 in Jesus’ Words Concerning His Blood in Matthew 26:28
Program Unit: Matthew
Paul Hoskins, Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary
Jesus’s words at the Last Supper have received extensive treatments in New Testament scholarship. Such careful attention to these words makes sense due to their importance for the theology of the Gospels and of the New Testament. Interpreters have noted the rich connections between Jesus’ words concerning his blood and the Old Testament. They commonly mention certain passages, like Exodus 24, Isaiah 53, and Jeremiah 31. A few interpreters mention the possibility of a connection between the pouring out of Jesus’ blood (“poured out for many”) and the pouring out of the blood of sacrifices in Leviticus 4:1-5:13. Yet the connection between the last phrase of Matthew 26:28, “for the forgiveness of sins,” and Leviticus 4-5 has gone virtually unnoticed. Due to the addition of this phrase, Matthew’s account contains a stronger allusion to Leviticus 4-5 in comparison to Mark or Luke. The linguistic and thematic evidence for a connection between Leviticus 4-5 and Matthew 26:28 is significant. The connection is nearly as strong as the connection to Exodus 24 and stronger than the commonly proposed connections to Isaiah 53 and Jeremiah 31. The purpose of this article is to present the evidence for an allusion to Leviticus 4-5 in Matthew 26:28 and to discuss the significance of the allusion. In order to present the evidence and its significance, it will provide a short overview of the related scholarship before demonstrating the linguistic and thematic connections between the relevant texts. Then, attention will be given to relating Matthew 26:28’s allusion to Leviticus 4-5 to its other Old Testament allusions. Finally, we will give brief attention to the hermeneutics related to the allusion to Leviticus 4-5 and to whether the same allusion occurs in the parallels in Mark 14:24 and Luke 22:20.
|
Catena Manuscripts and the Textual Tradition of the Pauline Epistles
Program Unit: Novum Testamentum Graecum: Editio Critica Maior
H.A.G. Houghton, University of Birmingham
Work on the Editio Critica Maior of the Greek New Testament has shown the importance of Greek New Testament commentary manuscripts for the transmission of the New Testament text. In addition, research recently undertaken as part of the European Research Council COMPAUL project identified 100 catena manuscripts not currently included in the Kurzgefasste Liste. A major new five-year project on commentary manuscripts, also funded by the European Research Council, is now underway at the University of Birmingham. This presentation will introduce the reasons behind the CATENA project, outline its goals and expected methodology, and explain how it will contribute to work on the Editio Critica Maior of the Pauline Epistles.
|
To Choose Rightly: How Sacred Texts and Faith Traditions Inform Sexual Behavior Decisions
Program Unit: LGBTI/Queer Hermeneutics
Kathryn House, Boston University
This paper queries the use of sacred texts in Sexuality and Our Faith, the faith-tradition companion resources to Our Whole Lives, the secular comprehensive sexuality education curriculum published by the Unitarian Universalist Association. Through a close reading of these supplementary guides published by the Unitarian Universalist Association and the United Church of Christ, I identify the hermeneutical stances and the practical strategies these traditions utilize as they incorporate texts that inform and inspire their traditions' perspectives. I attend specifically to lessons that counter the abstinence-only-until-marriage approaches of many faith-based sexuality education programs and that instead employ a faith-informed approach to guide student reflection on healthy choices, responsibility, consent, and gender justice. To conclude, I make suggestions for a progressive Baptist context and demonstrate how other faith traditions could utilize similar approaches to incorporate their traditions' sacred texts to emphasize justice, mutuality, and responsibility through comprehensive sexuality education.
|
La Biblia en Acento Latino: Biblical Studies for First-Generation Latinx Students
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Melanie A. Howard, Fresno Pacific University
As a part of the largest minority group in the United States today, Latinx students are increasingly filling biblical studies classrooms. Of these students, many are not only navigating predominantly white academic spaces but are also facing the challenge of being a part of the first generation in their families to attend college. The needs of this demographic have increasingly attracted attention in pedagogical research (e.g. Teaching Across Cultural Strengths [by Alicia Chávez and Karen Longerbeam], Diversity Matters [ed. Karen Longman], Breakthrough Strategies [by Kathleen Ross], Culturally Responsive Teaching and the Brain [by Zaretta Hammond]). Similarly, recent publications in many of the subfields of biblical studies have addressed issues of Latinx biblical interpretation (e.g. Latino/a Biblical Hermeneutics [eds. Francisco Lozada and Fernando Segovia], Santa Biblia [by Justo González). However, the particular challenges of teaching biblical studies for first-generation Latinx students have been largely unaddressed. This paper aids in filling that void by providing both a personal reflection on the experience of being a white biblical studies professor at a Hispanic Serving Institution (HSI) as well as a theoretical foundation for effective biblical studies pedagogy for Latinx students. The paper argues that a focus on issues of translation, identity formation, and family can provide a solid bridge for connecting the study of the biblical text to the experiences and cultural knowledge of many first-generation Latinx students.
|
Schooling the Apostles: Acts’ Model of Inclusion for Higher Education
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Melanie A. Howard, Fresno Pacific University
The book of Acts describes the processes whereby early followers of Jesus engage in outreach and struggle with the implications of including Gentiles in the early Jesus movement. Philip’s encounter with the Ethiopian eunuch (Acts 8:26-40), the Jerusalem Council (Acts 15:1-35), and Paul’s missionary work in Athens (Acts 17:16-34) provide especially poignant examples of intercultural exchange among early Jesus followers who are navigating the encounter between Jews and Gentiles. Although there are missteps along the way to the inclusion of Gentiles, Acts’ narration of the growth of the movement nonetheless attests to success in this process. Fueled by this success, the early Christians described in Acts grow into a group capable of navigating cultural, ethnic, and religious divides.
Using these examples from Acts as an illustrative paradigm, this paper argues that the early church model of inclusion demonstrates a need for three components: difficult conversations, a willingness to change existing structures, and a recognition of divine action in this process. Such a model of inclusion could be applicable to several scenarios where divisions are created between “insiders” and “outsiders.” Nonetheless, after exploring how this model functions in Acts, this paper applies the model to contemporary higher education and the inclusion of first-generation students. The paper suggests that the three components of inclusion in Acts are equally necessary for the inclusion of first-generation students on university campuses today.
|
An African Perspective on Q's Message for the Poor
Program Unit: Q
Llewellyn Howes, University of Johannesburg
This paper is submitted as part of the "Socio-Political Vision of Q" session. Compared to other literature of the time, the Sayings Gospel Q has a unique message for the poor. The aim of this paper is to uncover and discuss that message from an African perspective. The analysis will focus on those Q texts that are specifically directed at the poor. Some texts might be generic enough to include the poor together with others, but do not address the poor specifically. These texts will be put aside for the current analysis. Some other texts might address issues related to poverty, but are not directed at the poor. These texts will also not receive consideration here.
|
Frame Theory and Bloodguilt
Program Unit: Philology in Hebrew Studies
Charles Huff, University of Chicago
In the Hebrew Bible as in many literatures, severe crime and the legal execution of criminals have similar affects on a community. In the Torah's legal literature, bloodguilt of both types is understood within a variety of imaginings of Israel. In this paper, I will use Cognitive Linguistics Frame Theory as a method to compare two such paradigms: the innocent blood and bloodguilt of Deuteronomy 19, and the bloodguilt formula for the death penalty in Leviticus 20. I will show how the different frames activated by the specific language of the text helps interpret laws and sublaws designed to keep the community free from innocent blood.
|
The Prosopological Speech of the Son and the Development of Pre-Nicene Christology
Program Unit: Development of Early Christian Theology
Kyle R. Hughes, Whitefield Academy
This paper examines the interplay between biblical exegesis and Christological development through the lens of the evolution of pre-Nicene prosopological exegesis from the person (prosopon/persona) of the Son. In particular, this paper catalogues all of the instances of prosopological exegesis from the person of the Son in the writings of Justin Martyr, Irenaeus of Lyons, and Tertullian of Carthage for three purposes: first, to analyze the continuities and discontinuities concerning the themes that each writer connected with the Son’s prosopological speech; second, to consider the arguments by which each writer justified his prosopological reading of the Old Testament; third, to compare and contrast the key Christological themes emerging from a prosopological reading of Scripture with early Christian creedal statements regarding the person and work of the Son. This argument aims to demonstrate how a more comprehensive and systematic approach to studying how early Christian writers utilized prosopological exegesis can yield new insights into the development of pre-Nicene Christology (or indeed Trinitarian theology more broadly).
|
David, the Last Giant Slayer
Program Unit: Bible, Myth, and Myth Theory
Michael Hundley, Central Washington University
With David’s ascension to the throne, giants disappear from the biblical landscape. This presentation considers David’s rise to power in light of ancient Near Eastern royal apologetic inscriptions, focusing on the nexus of heroism, piety, and divine approval as a means of legitimizing David’s usurpation of the throne. It further contextualizes the narrative by comparing the central role and rhetoric of giants (and monsters) in the Davidic narrative, the Epic of Gilgamesh, and to a lesser extent the Labors of Heracles. It concludes with an exploration of the source of and reason for the heroes’ (super)powers as expressions of distinct religious ideologies. Heracles’ use of his innate might warrants his inclusion in the divine world. Gilgamesh learns to refocus his inborn power so that he no longer dominates his people or challenges the cosmic hierarchy, but rather accepts his mortality and re-channels his potency to become the ideal mortal king whose name becomes immortal. By contrast, the Deuteronomistic History recasts David’s victory as an expression of divine, not human, power, which may be accessed through human piety. This Deuteronomistic rhetoric of divine might despite human weakness clearly expresses Deuteronomistic theology while offering an (post-)exilic audience agency to change their situation.
|
From Hebrews to Christians: Religious Identity and Competition within the Gospel of Philip
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Jennifer R Hunter, Northern Arizona University
The Gospel of Philip has been labeled as a Valentinian Christian text within most scholarship. However, this identification of the Gospel of Philip as a Valentinian Christian text has obscured the Jewish background of a number of features of the text and the community that speaks in it. That community explicitly identifies with Jewish roots when the author declares early on, “When we were Hebrews, we were orphans and had only our mother, but when we became Christians, we had both father and mother.” If we understand the author’s use of the labels “Hebrews” and “Christians” to more be more than metaphorical, and instead understand them as meaningful self-designations used by a community of Jewish converts to Christianity, then how does this transform our understanding of the content of the text and the nature of the religious competition in which it is engaging? We can discern continuity of Jewish thought and practice being utilized not only to compete against other Christianities, but also as a means to compete against ‘pagan’ practices such as theurgy. Lastly, what is at stake in our own ‘competition’ over the labeling of texts such as the Gospel of Philip?
|
Perfection and the Ritual Reunification of Male and Female in the Gospel of Philip
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Jennifer Hunter, Northern Arizona University
While certain texts like the Gospel of Thomas furthered notions of male superiority by describing perfection in terms of a female transformation into male, the Gospel of Philip pushes against male superiority in the search for perfection by emphasizing that perfection requires a complementary role of male and female. In order to obtain perfection, a male must receive female powers and vice versa. This further enabled the reunification of male and female, repairing the separation that occurred at the beginning of creation. This paper will explore the mythical motivation fueling this notion of a gender-complementary form of perfection, and how the role of reflection within myths might have served as an explanation as to how this unification of the sexes could be achieved through ritual means with the aid of light and mirrors.
|
Can Qumran Samuel Scrolls Help Us Find Old Greek Readings?
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Historical Books
Paavo Huotari, Helsingin Yliopisto - Helsingfors Universitet
The question of the relation between the Lucianic text and the Qumran Samuel Scrolls has been widely debated in the field of the Septuagint. The search for the so called proto-Lucianic readings has been connected in the past to the question of the proto-Lucianic recension. The existence of this secondary revision is rightly questioned. This does not mean, however, a denial of individual agreements between the manuscripts 4QSama-c and 19 82 93 108 127.
My paper addresses these individual agreements in the above mentioned manuscripts with special attention to two cases from 2 Samuel (13:39; 15:2). They represent the complexity of the textual history of the Septuagint, particularly in the Historical Books Samuel-Kings. The base-text of the Lucianic reviser is surely old, though his revision and Hexaplaric additions complicate the search of this layer. Often Old Greek readings are preserved only in the Lucianic text (2 Sam 15:2), particularly in the kaige-section, but occasionally outside both Codex Vaticanus and the Lucianic text (2 Sam 13:39).
It is evident that a comparison between the Qumran Samuel Scrolls and the Greek witnesses help us to find Old Greek readings in the latter. This means specifically individual readings, not a revision or a recension. Generalizations regarding the relation of the Qumran Samuel Scrolls and the Lucianic text are problematic. Taken together, all the agreements need to be analysed independently and case by case.
|
Ḥikmah in the Qur'an
Program Unit: Linguistic, Literary, and Thematic Perspectives on the Qur’anic Corpus (IQSA)
Saqib Hussain, University of Oxford
Ḥikmah, or Wisdom, is a central concept in the Qur’an. It is particularly associated with Abraham’s lineage (Q 4:54), especially David (Q 38:20), and Jesus (Q 43:63). By teaching wisdom, the Prophet Muhammad is presented as fulfilling Abraham’s legacy (Q 2:129). In the Meccan period, I will argue that ḥikmah is used with three distinct senses: apocalyptic, moral, and proverbial. The most significant verse in Meccan Qur’an is Q 17:39, as it claims to have given examples of what is meant by the term: “That is from what your Lord has revealed to you of Wisdom (ḥikmah).” The pronoun is referring to the passage that this verse closes, namely vv. 22–39. This pericope, as has been identified by both medieval Muslim exegetes and western scholars, gives the Qur’an’s version of the Decalogue. At first sight, this is surprising, given, as I will argue, that ḥikmah denotes apocalypse, morality, and proverbial wisdom, rather than law. However, it is precisely in light of these senses of ḥikmah that we can understand the several points of variance between the Biblical and the Qur’anic Decalogues. By calling its own Decalogue ḥikmah, the Qur’an is thus affirming that what the Prophet has been given goes beyond Mosaic Law. In Medinan Qur’an, we encounter a new phenomenon: the conjunction of kitāb and ḥikmah. In fact, ḥikmah when mentioned in Medinan Qur’an is almost always conjoined to kitāb. I will argue that this arises primarily out of the encounter with the Yathribite Jewish community, who rebuffed the need for Muhammad’s prophecy on the basis that they already had a scripture. The Qur’anic response is that this new revelation is more than the Jewish scripture; it is more than kitāb – it is also ḥikmah. This is a continuation of the argument employed in the Q 17 Decalogue. Accordingly, the kitāb/ḥikmah verses are particularly prominent in Q 2, a large portion of which is a polemic against the Banī Isrāʾīl. Also, prominent in the same surah is the extensive use of the antonym of ḥikmah, namely the root s-f-h, denoting foolishness, and applied to those who reject this new ḥikmah revelation. Finally, I will briefly explore the relationship between Qur’anic ḥikmah and the sapiential and apocalyptic traditions of Biblical and post-Biblical literature, arguing that the sapiential and apocalyptic strands were becoming merged in Thomasine Christianity, which formed an important part of the late-antique Qur’anic milieu.
|
The Prefix Consonant of the C- and tG-Stems in the Dialects of Aramaic: A Proposal
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Jeremy M. Hutton, University of Wisconsin-Madison
The alternation of the prefix consonant in the Aramaic C-stem has presented significant problems to Semitists: why does the stem exhibit a haphel form in some dialects of Aramaic and an 'aphel form in others? There seems little rhyme or reason to the distribution of these forms across the dialects, and Biblical Aramaic (Ezra, Daniel) in particular demonstrates a confusing alternation between the two stems. When viewed in the light of theoretical phonology, however, this "confusing alternation" yields to a more discernable system. In this paper, I argue that historical developments in the phonology of the tG-stems (i.e., the hitpǝ'el and 'itpǝ'el) parallel the alternation of the haphel and 'aphel C-stems in Biblical Aramaic. With respect to the tG-stem, I begin with the assumption drawn from Garr (1993) that the derivational prefix (here, t-) was prefixed directly to the verbal base in Proto-Semitic. The resultant consonant cluster was alleviated by the prefixation of a prothetic i-vowel. In most subsequently developing Semitic languages, standard phonotactics demanded a consonantal onset to all syllables, forcing the insertion of a C-slot (i.e., a consonant clot) preceding the prothetic vowel. This C-slot received the phonological dimension Glottal Width [GW] from the following i-vowel. A similar process drove the development of the C-stem, where the original /š/ (=phonetic [s]) debuccalized into a phoneme specified as GW. According to "Kingston's Law" (first identified by linguists Peter Avery and William J. Idsardi in 2001), a consonant specified as GW can manifest phonetically in two different ways depending on its prosodic context: When phased with a continuant, GW directs the articulatory apparatus to produce the feature [spread glottis], yielding either h or a glottal glide. And when phased with a stop, GW demands the feature [constricted glottis], yielding a glottal stop. This comports reasonably well with the syntactic and discourse-level environments that we find in Biblical Aramaic for post-pausal 'itpǝ'el / 'aphel and non-pausal hitpǝ'el / haphel. In turn, this account sheds light on the divergent means of graphic representation in other varieties of Aramaic.
|
Why We Cannot “See” Our Neighbor? A Re-interpretation of Luke 10:25–37 in Ancient and Modern Context in Light of New Institutional Economics Using Hong Kong as a Modern Case Study
Program Unit: Poverty in the Biblical World
Alex Hon Ho IP, Chinese University of Hong Kong
This paper seeks to reinterpret Luke 10:25-37, the good Samaritan story, taking the suppressive nature of Roman economy into consideration in light of the New Institutional Economics (NIE) theoretical framework. The hypothesis is that “seeing” or “blind”, in a negative sense, was and is the problem preventing us from realizing where our neighbor is. Economic values and systems are one of the main reasons contributing to this outcome. It aims to investigate how the economic system exerts influence on the value system and prevents one from seeing their neighbor. With the aid of NIE, the paper will first examine both the formal and informal institutions of the Roman economy. After analyzing the Roman economy based on NIE, this paper will reinterpret the good Samaritan story in Luke and argue that the parable addresses why the lawyer cannot see and takes no action regarding the many needy, as seen based on the consensus on the poverty situation in the first century Roman economy. Using the socio-rhetorical interpretation as the interpretation framework, starting from the inner texture of the passage, it is not difficult to notice that seeing is the key message in Jesus’ parable as he mentions thrice that they all saw someone being robbed but only the Samaritan considered him as his neighbor. However, in order to understand why seeing is problem or why they cannot see, we need the economic analysis to help us to understand how different institutions in the economy can blind us to our neighbors.
The second part of the paper will utilize the implications of the new interpretation in order to reflect on our modern capitalist society and first examine how different institutions in our capitalist society can make us blind – systematically and personally. Second, using Hong Kong, one of the highest Gini coefficient economy in the world, as an example, it will examine how the parable can give us insights into addressing the problem and bringing us to see our neighbor. Successful experiences will also be shared based on the teaching of this parable.
|
Ancient Books as Living Legal Entities: The Gospel of Truth (NHC I,3) and Roman Law Tablets
Program Unit: Society for Comparative Research on Iconic and Performative Texts
Eduard Iricinschi, Ruhr-Universität Bochum
This paper will analyze the connections between the multiple religious and legal representations of divine books in the Gospel of Truth (NHC I,3) and the performative authority attributed to Roman legal tabulae. The Gospel of Truth represents divine books as the vehicles and the substance of Christian revelation. At the same time, it endows them with features of efficacy and authority which extends from cosmological creation script to legal will. This Nag Hammadi text presents “the living book of the living” as being patterned upon the Near Eastern model of the heavenly tablets. Written in the intellect and the Nous of the father, the “living book of living” not only predates creation but also pre-writes it. The text enriches the relation between the Pleroma and the father with the further metaphor of a will, a document that receives legal authority after the crucifixion. At the same time, the “living book of the living” represents the teaching that Jesus offers to the apostles and the will of the father, meant to be opened after Jesus' death. This paper will attempt to examine the double representation of “the living book of the living” in the Gospel of Truth, both as a pre-cosmological script and as an eschatological legal document, as connected to the performative efficacy of Roman legal tabulae. According to Elizabeth Meyer, Roman law tablets were considered efficacious by those who enacted them and also by those who followed them, through the agency of auctoritas, an active quality in objects. Finally, this paper advances that, while the bureaucratic network of the Roman empire lent authority to ritual and legal acts, the religious representations of books in the Gospel of Truth borrowed the bureaucratic authority of legal tablets.
|
Mountains in Micah: Subjective Space for a Coherent Message
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Dominic S. Irudayaraj, Hekima University College, Nairobi
Appearing at appropriate junctures, mountains in the book of Micah present diverse depiction: at the threatening theophany, they melt (1:4); in the context of a “plowed” Zion, the temple mount is reduced to a forest ridge (3:12); to the raised mountain of the LORD (4:1-2), many nations march; they are covenant-controversy hearers (6:1-2); and, in the final rendition, mountains point to the farthest boundaries (7:12). As such, these dissimilar depictions appear to undermine any attempt at a coherent vision of mountains in Micah.
All the same, drawing on the notion of “subjective narrative space” (cf. H. Vandermoere; R. Ronen in G. Prinsloo) and its attendant assertion that “space determines character,” the present paper shifts the spotlight on the prophetic spatial vision that does not so much create or destroy “mountains” as attend to their transformation which, in turn, shares thematic resemblance with other transformations in the Mican corpus. Together, these transformations can helpfully contribute to highlight the coherent message of the book.
|
In the Interstices of Utopia and Dystopia: Towards a Hopeful Reading of the Dichotomous Depictions of Zion in Micah
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Dominic S. Irudayaraj , Hekima University College, Nairobi
With a perceptible, repeated interplay of dichotomous themes (judgment and promise), the book of Micah remains an interpretive challenge, particularly for a coherent reading of the corpus as a whole. The most arresting of the said interplay is the near-dystopic vision of “plowed Zion” (3:12), which appears in close proximity to the utopic vision of “exalted Zion” (4:1-2). Such dichotomous depictions continue to elicit exegetical exposé on the diachronic seams in the book of Micah.
While valuing such astute observations, this paper inquires into the possibility of a coherent reading of the diverse depictions of Zion. To this end, the notion of Social Creativity from the Social Identity Approach is proposed as a help/hope-ful reading strategy. Among other things, Social Creativity underscores that discursive efforts, especially by those from the margins, often embody ambivalent tendencies in which one and the same trope (here, Zion) is both distantiated as well as appropriated. Further, it is in such ambivalent interstices that the performative nature of discursive endeavors towards identity affirmation can amply be attested.
|
Negotiating Refugee Identity in Judah: Israelite Tribal Names in Judean Inscriptions in the Wake of Assyrian Invasions
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
M. Isaac, Independent Scholar
Following the Assyrian invasion in 733-722 BCE, the Northern Kingdom of Israel underwent a series of political-economic turmoil and a demographic decline that led to the displacement of thousands from the tribes of Israel and their resettlement in southern Judah. Within this fluid context of statelessness and forced migration, there emerged a discourse among Israelite refugees concerning the maintenance of symbolic ties to their pre-displaced past through the replication of tribal names. This paper examines the criteria for finding Israelite names in Judean sources that are dated to the late 8th-7th centuries BCE and evaluates select names that align with Israelite identities in the Hebrew Bible and Hebrew inscriptions from the northern kingdom of Israel. The methods of linguistic anthropology are used to analyze the ideological and social significance of the replication of these names.
|
A Comparative Study of Biblical and Qur’anic Methods of Exegesis
Program Unit: The Qur’an and the Biblical Tradition (IQSA)
Mohammed Ali Ismail, The Islamic College
This paper compares and contrasts some of the main methods used in the exegesis of the Bible and the Qur’an. Beginning with Biblical methods of interpretation, the paper examines a diverse range of ideas from some of the leading authors in the field. For instance, Klein, Blomberg, and Hubbard focus mainly on traditional historical-grammatical analysis. Porter and Stovell concentrate their analysis on five different approaches, namely historical-critical/grammatical, literary/postmodern, philosophical/theological, redemptive-historical, and canonical. Gorman argues that there are three basic approaches to exegesis today: synchronic, diachronic, and existential. And lastly, Virkler and Ayayo concentrate their hermeneutical approach on historical-cultural and contextual analysis, lexical-syntactical analysis, and theological analysis. In examining Qur’anic exegetical methods, the paper investigates the views of prominent scholars of the Qur’an such as Goldziher, Dhahabī, Riḍāʾī Iṣfihānī, and Maʿrifat. The paper concludes by assessing whether existing methods and approaches used in Qur’anic exegesis could be improved by drawing upon Biblical models. The research questions this paper investigates are: 1. What are the most important methods used in the Qur’anic and Biblical traditions of exegesis? 2. What are the similarities and differences between the main Qur’anic and Biblical methods? 3. Could any of the main methods used in Biblical exegeses be used in Qur’anic exegesis, and if so, to what extent?
|
Children of the Flesh or Promise? Race, Citizenship, and Surrogacy in Galatians 4:21–31; A Feminist, Postcolonial Reading alongside Indian Surrogate Mothers
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Sharon Jacob, Pacific School of Religion
In the letter to Galatians, Paul uses the story of Sarah and Hagar as an allegory to create a hierarchy between mothers and their children. The superiority of a free, upper class mother contrasted against the inferior, slave mother, fractures maternal subjectivity and splits maternal bodies into an idealized Subject or realized object. The maternal fragmentation performative in mothers also extends to their children as dichotomized mothers bring forth children whose subjectivity is fractured and disjointed. The emergence of these fragmented infants are dichotomized by Paul as “child of the slave born out of flesh,” and “child of the free born out of promise.” Thus, born in the likeness of their mothers, these children are subjected to a hierarchy where the life of some children are valued, preserved, and protected more than, and at the cost of the life of other children. The appraisal of some maternal and infantile life over and above the rest in the Letter to Galatians 4:21-31 sheds light on a new citizen whose value is based on the geographical, social, and cultural location of the womb in which they were conceived.
The surrogacy industry in India is estimated to be a 2.3 billion dollar industry. Surrogacy in the contemporary context, is depicted as a “win-win” situation where “women help other women.” However, a closer look reveals that lax laws, cheap maternal labor, the availability of English speaking doctors, and accessible technology in the Indian context promotes the exploitation of third world women at the hands of their first world contemporaries. Surrogacy not only highlights the ways in which Indian surrogate mothers are exploited, but also raises questions around the identity and citizenship of both the mother and her child. In other words, the life of a child born to an Indian surrogate mother receiving financial, emotional, physical, and medical support is valued at a much higher cost than the biological child of the surrogate mother; conceived through the flesh. Furthermore, the subjectivity of the surrogate child conceived through “non-traditional means” is uplifted as the “ideal citizen” and given the privilege to share in the wealth of the Nation; a right that is taken away from the biological children of surrogate mothers living in poverty.
Although, the context of Sarah and Hagar and their children is different from the Indian surrogate mothers living in postcolonial India, the subjectivities of both these mothers and their children bear some similarities. Reading Galatians 4:21-31 alongside and through the contextual and real life experiences of Indian surrogate mothers, this paper seeks to reinterpret the subjectivities of Hagar, Sarah, and their children through the lens of Race, Nation, and Citizenship. Thus, drawing on postcolonial, feminist, and race theories, my paper will attempt to construct a nuanced reading of this text as conversations of identity relating to surrogate mothers and their children pertaining to Race, Nation, and Citizenship come to be seen through a more complex and ambivalent light.
|
The Menzerath-Altmann Law and Ancient Hebrew: Does the Bible Break the Law?
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Jarod Jacobs, Warner Pacific University
In this paper, I explore the application of the Menzerath-Altmann Law (MAL) to Ancient Hebrew. The MAL is named after Paul Menzerath and Bariel Altmann and was proposed first in 1928 and later developed in 1980. Essentially, the MAL is a linguistic law stating that an increase in the size of a linguistic construct corresponds to a decrease in the size of its constituents. An example of this is: the longer a word (measured in syllables), the shorter the syllables (measured in sounds). For this paper, I examine the sentence, clause, phrase, and word levels to determine if Ancient Hebrew conforms to the MAL. My corpus is comprised of the Masoretic Text of the Hebrew Bible as well as the War Scroll and the Community Rule. I utilize the Eep Talstra Centre for Bible and Computer (ETCBC) database of the Hebrew Bible and the Dead Sea Scrolls as my source for data. While the application of the MAL has been studied in numerous languages, to my knowledge there is no published material focused on this law and Hebrew. The conclusions of this paper will thus be important for both general quantitative linguistics as well as Ancient Hebrew studies.
|
Computational Codicology: An Exploration of Ethiopian Psalters
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Jarod Jacobs, Warner Pacific University
In his project "The Social Lives of Ethiopian Psalters," Steve Delamarter has identified over 110 features of codicology and scribal practice and book culture which are executed in differing and various ways by scribes, craftsmen, and book users. He selected 29 of these for further study and then created typologies of those variations, assigned numbers to each type of the variation and built a database (containing more than 100 fields) to receive data from Psalters. He has analyzed over 700 Psalters-ranging from the earliest extant ones of the fourteenth century up through the 20th century-and collected data regarding the variations in each. Each of the Psalters is dated; over 200 of the Psalters can be located in terms of the area of Ethiopia in which they were produced. The data produced from the project promises to open many windows on aspects of Ethiopian scribal and book culture. But this will only happen if the data is analyzed well. This presentation will focus on the ways in which we have applied specialized statistical analyses, such as cluster and random forest analysis, to the data. The raw data already suggest some fascinating stories, but a thorough statistical analysis is needed to draw firm conclusions. Codicologists have already noted a few features that have changed over time; this dataset promises to greatly increase those findings. But perhaps even more interesting is the potential of identifying features that differ depending on where the manuscript was produced. Of all the manuscripts the place of origin is recorded and this information is also taken into account in the analysis. It is to be expected that a comprehensive analysis of both chronological and geographical data will lead to a much better understanding of Ethiopic scribal culture.
|
The Laughter of Fools: Towards a Homiletics of Humor
Program Unit: Homiletics and Biblical Studies
Karl Jacobson, Lutheran Church of the Good Shepherd
Reinhold Niebuhr has remarked that, “The intimate relation between humor and faith is derived from the fact that both deal with the incongruities of our existence.”
I would say further that humor and faith share a reveling in and a wrestling with the incongruities of life and the “stuff” of faith. So too, the office of the preacher shares a similar culture space with its close rhetorical cousin, that of stand-up comedy. Comedians tend to view the world somewhat askew or askance, and that view—a kind of hermeneutical lens for daily life—serves to frame, reframe, and even to de-frame reality. Preachers do the same, and can do so through a similar lens.
Building on these similarities, my paper will outline a “homiletics of humor,” which, starting with the biblical text, will explore how the text is at times humorous in and of itself (letting the Bible be funny), may be read through the lens of humor (bringing humor to the text), and when the text is not, properly, humorous but humor is the best (or only) response (i.e. the eschatological Easter-laugh); all of this with an eye to how that humor can bring both text and proclamation to life.
It will be my aim to engage several specific texts (such as Genesis 26, Isaiah 56 and Galatians 5, 1 Corinthians 1, 15) through this homiletical lens.
|
Proclaiming the Incomparable God, in the Register of Lament
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Karl Jacobson, Lutheran Church of the Good Shepherd
Invited paper.
|
Death as the Litmus Test for Theological Anthropology
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
James Dew, College at Southeastern (SEBTS)
Death as the Litmus Test for Theological Anthropology
|
Violence Overcome by the Political Ontology of the Syrophoenician Woman
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Jenny James, Brevard College
Violence against women often begins with cultural attitudes expressed in language which excludes women from discourse and thus denies women personal, as well as social, power. Denigrate a woman through language and thereby her ontological status as a thinking, critically aware, moral agent is erased. Assign an epithet, such as bitch, to a female and therein project upon her pollution, threat and moral menace, which open the door to physical violence directed against her. In a Jungian context, however, the dog is a major theriomorphic representative of the sacred feminine, i.e., the archetypal dog is the Great Mother and the Great Mother is the dog (James 2009, Neumann 1955, Wolvoy 1990). If we bracket the denigration of the dog as a patriarchal bias, we find the dog is a symbol of feminine healing in the ancient world. Before Aesculapius and a patriarchal differentiation of healing there was the healing goddess Gula (Bock 2013; Edrey 2013). Burial sites, such as Ashkelon, reveal a major cult devoted to the healing power of the dog in the Biblical world (Wapnish and Hesse 1993).
In an age of postmodern, diverse and critical reflection, Biblical scholarship finds in a figure like the Syrophoenician Woman (Mark 7:24-30; Matthew 15:21-28) -- who wins healing from Jesus through her will and wit -- a captivating post-colonial, post-patriarchal conundrum (Cadwaller 2008, Fiorenza 1984, Kwok 1995, Rhoads 2004, Theissen 1991). How can it be that the one person who bests Jesus in wisdom is a woman and not a member of his circle? In a metaphoric battle of Jesus' followers, those who become like children to enter the Kingdom of God vs. the followers of a competitive healer, those who embrace the dog as a healing agent of the sacred feminine, the Syrophoenician Woman wins his respect, concern and caring. And in the post-colonial, post-patriarchal, contemporary world, they -- the woman and dog -- win in a big way. A Gentile female healer/priestess/devotee of the Goddess is respected and acknowledged by Jesus. She wins healing for her daughter through her "faith." Her being then and now is political. Her claim upon him is real: this is her political ontology, the reality of her power to seize hermeneutical discourse, that is, self-definition, meaning and value, and thus safety for herself and her daughter.
|
Sea Peoples of the Northern Levant? Aegean-Style Ceramic Evidence for the Sea Peoples from Tell Tayinat
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Brian Janeway, University of Toronto
The discovery of the Kingdom of Palastin, with its putative capital at Tell Tayinat in the Amuq Valley in Turkey, has heightened interest in the migration phenomenon of Sea Peoples during the 12th century BC. Several hieroglyphic Luwian inscriptions found at the site and in the vicinity provide fragmentary written evidence of this kingdom. But only now is the material culture of this intrusive group being revealed. This paper summarizes a recently published volume by the author—Sea Peoples of the Northern Levant? Aegean-Style Ceramic Evidence for the Sea Peoples from Tell Tayinat (Studies in the Archaeology and History of the Levant 7: Eisenbrauns, 2017)—which presents the results of a quantitative stylistic analysis of a distinctive painted pottery known as Late Helladic IIIC (LH IIIC) excavated at the site.
This subset of Early Iron Age pottery includes forms familiar to Aegean-type assemblages found elsewhere, such as deep bowls, shallow angular bowls (SABs), one-handled conical bowls, amphoroid kraters, bell-shaped kraters, and neck-handled amphorae. The decorative repertoire shows signs of both Aegean and Cypriot influence alongside those indicating a native or regional origin. The most common painted motifs are Wavy Line, spiriliform designs, and geometric ornaments such as cross-hatch triangles and zigzag. The vast majority of the assemblage is linear in nature and can broadly be classified as Granary Class (after the initial discovery of this type found at the Granary at Mycenae in the Greek Mainland). But there is also a small sample of pictorial decoration represented in the assemblage.
The appearance and profusion of LH IIIC pottery in the Amuq Valley, which was new to the region in the 12th century, was not limited to Tell Tayinat, however. Similar material has been documented at over two dozen other sites in the valley. The evidence strongly argues for a migration event and against alternate theories relating to mercantilism or trade. Although the historical circumstances that led to this influx of outsiders are still unknown, events in neighboring Cilicia and Cyprus allow us to propose several possibilities. The combination of material culture and epigraphic data strongly suggests that this group relates to the Sea Peoples, and perhaps more specifically to the Peleset of the Egyptian reliefs of Ramses III, and to the Philistines of Biblical renown. The newly discovered Kingdom of Palastin seems to have spanned a significant geographical area in present day southeast Turkey and northern Syria as far south as Hama. But after a century or more this polity appears to have faded and given way to the predominant local Syro-Anatolian culture known as the Neo-Hittites.
|
Beyond Ethnicity: Rethinking the Social Landscape of “Gentilics” in Ancient Israel
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Ki-Eun Jang, New York University
In discussion of identity in ancient Israel, one particular label for naming, customarily termed “gentilics” has eluded critical reevaluation. For one, the question of Israelite identity vis-à-vis surrounding groups has been central to archaeological study since the turn of the 1990s in interpreting material finds in relation to textual records. While the old culture area model, which assumes a one-to-one mapping of geographical area with ethnic entity, was quickly rejected, “ethnicity” remains a much-used concept for explaining human history, whether ancient or modern. This trend holds significant implications for understanding the grammatical identifier called the gentilic or ethnonym. In biblical scholarship particularly, terms designated as gentilics have been taken for granted as a universal indication for ethnic identity, however situational the individual cases. In turn, its fossilized definition—denoting ethnic, racial or national affiliation—has shaped an interpretive paradigm related to gentilics in the Bible from the early 20th century (e.g. Gesenius 1910; Böhl 1911) through recent decades (e.g. Revell 1996; Ehrlich 2016). Yet careful reevaluation of the evidence displays a range of nominal bases underlying gentilic forms, including regional, kinship, political, occupational, and combinations of multiple categories (e.g. Mushite). The historical question that this evidence demands is to comprehend the logic of ancient categorization as expressed in the ambivalent nature of relationality denoted by gentilics. In the narrativized social world depicted in Genesis to Kings, for example, in spite of the recurring list of Canaanite peoples often perceived as Israel’s adversary in territorial and religious terms, some individual figures are intimately associated with non-Israelite/Judahite identity in one way or another—Judah’s Canaanite wife (Gen 38:2), Abdon’s burying place in the Amalekite highlands (Judg 12:15), Saul’s chief herdsmen, Doeg the Edomite (1 Sam 21:8), and Rehoboam’s Ammonite mother (1 Kgs 14:21). When examined beyond the dominant political paradigm of Israel and Judah, the biblical author(s)’ social landscape as conceptualized by those gentilics shows us a relational mode of identification working beyond straightforward dichotomy between what is local and what is foreign. This study will offer a critical reassessment of gentilics as an analytical category to reconstruct the historical narrative of ancient Israel.
|
Prophesying and Trapping: Examining the Masoretic Text of Ezekiel 13:17–23 with the Model of Conceptual Blending
Program Unit: Cognitive Linguistics in Biblical Interpretation
Patrik Jansson, Helsingin Yliopisto - Helsingfors Universitet
Ezekiel 13:17-23 is a distinctive text where prophesying women are seemingly engaged in the activity of hunting and trapping nĕpāšôt. Majority of recent scholarship have interpreted the text as a reference to some obscure form of religious activity, ranging from necromancy to healing and magic. Implication of these studies is that the Ezekiel 13:17-23 does contain accurate information about some peculiar yet nonetheless historical phenomenon that lies outside of common prophetic practices where divine messages are being communicated.
In this paper, I suggest that the text may in fact contain a novel metaphorical expression. I will use as a theoretical framework the theory of conceptual blending (Fauconnier & Turner 2002), which views metaphors as blends of mental spaces. In this model two or more input spaces that share a generic space form a conceptual blend, which compresses abstract concepts to a scale that is easier to comprehend for the human mind.
In the text of Ezekiel 13:17-23, mental spaces of prophesying and trapping form a single-scope network that conceptualizes prophesying women as a dangerous group of hunters. Meanwhile their victims become helpless prey and are trapped in a situation from which they cannot possibly escape without the intervention of God. Whereas prophecy relies on the interaction of the prophet and audience, hunting gives the prophesying women heightened power and agency. The single-scope network transforms the communicative process of prophecy to actions where prophesying women have clear and immensely dangerous power over their audience.
The metaphorical nature of the text suggests that Ezekiel 13:17-23 should not primarily be understood as a description of the historical reality or practices of some ancient religious group. I suggest that the features of the blend in question construct the prophesying women as an enemy image, that does not give reliable historical information but communicates a sense of threat.
|
Commenting on 1 Chronicles 1–9: Some Problems
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
David Janzen, Durham University
A discussion of the approach taken to writing a commentary for Illuminations, a series that is meant to be scholarly and accessible.
|
Beyond Use and Abuse of History: Constructed Memory in Ezekiel 20
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
Eric X. Jarrard, Harvard University
The (ab)use of historical data in Ezekiel 20 is often alliteratively characterized by scholars as revisionist (Block, Allen), rhetorical (Osborne; Krüger), and radical (Evans, Idestrom). Many of these efforts, though, assume an extant literary source (Exodus, Joshua 24) upon which Ezekiel has based his historiographical efforts, and from which Ezekiel is intentionally departing. This paper abandons those attempts at reconstruction and comparative analysis.
Rather, in this paper I will engage the emerging and promising contributions of memory studies in order to argue that Ezekiel 20 represents a divinely constructed counter memory. I will undertake this argument in three parts. First, I will briefly outline the cyclical nature of the exodus pattern in biblical memory. Second, I will examine the reciprocal impulses between divine and Israelite remembrance and forgetting throughout this cyclical pattern. Third, I will demonstrate how and why Ezekiel 20 constructs a specific memory of the past in the imagined present to define and shape future identities.
|
Now You're in the Sunken Place: Constructed Monsters in Daniel 7 and Get Out
Program Unit: Bible and Film
Eric X. Jarrard, Harvard University
This paper seeks to explore constructed monsters in Daniel 7 and the 2017 film Get Out. Specifically, it examines the similar ways in which the biblical text and film both externalize their respective social anxieties by fictionalizing their oppressor in monstrous form.
I will undertake this investigation in three parts. First, I will examine dread and fearfulness around white appropriation and abuse of black culture and bodies in Jordan Peele's Oscar-winning screen play Get Out. Second, I will review the four beasts of Daniel 7 with particular attention to each beast's capacity for destruction and their prophesied demise. Third, I will propose that the construction of monstrous beings in both texts function as creative expressions of political resistance in their respective eras, and that both serve to empower oppressed groups with an imagined escape from tyrannical structures of political abuse.
|
The Rhetoric of the Sublime in the Narrative of Mary the Mother of Jesus (Luke 1–2)
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Roy Jeal, Booth University College
The sublime in Mediterranean antiquity is regularly described relative to the first century CE essay On the Sublime (Peri Hypsous, “Concerning Height”), a work written by an unknown author and attributed to someone named Longinus, though the ideas presented in it have a long prehistory in Greek literature. The sublime in texts continues to be studied and analyzed up to the present. It is described as the language of grandeur, of elevated thought and speech, of awe and wonder, of the exceptional and transcendent. The rhetoric of the sublime employs this awe and grandeur, rather than rational argumentation, to elicit acceptance by audiences. The rhetoric of the sublime aims to move people to apprehend rather than understand empirically. It functions on the possibility that the high things the language presents are real and true. It calls audiences to enter mentally into the symbolic worlds created by the discourse. This essay aims to develop an understanding of how the rhetorical force of the sublime can be observed in the New Testament through an analysis of Mary the mother of Jesus in the Gospel of Luke. Luke's sublime rhetoric is persuading the minds of his audiences to grasp his narration of a dramatic range of events, poems, predictions, and ponderings of the heart that address the intersection of the human and the divine. His rhetoric aims to persuade them that it is all and true and believable.
|
Sociorhetorical Interpretation of the Letter to the Colossians
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Roy Jeal, Booth University College
This seminar will feature the analytical tools of sociorhetorical interpretation. The analysis will discuss the rhetography, various textures, blending of rhetorolects, and the rhetorical force of Paul's letter to the Colossians.
|
The Lamb as Royal Benefactor: Patronal Ideologies in Revelation
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Justin Jeffcoat Schedtler, Wartburg College
Scholars have long recognized the degree to which the patron-client relationship constituted an essential socio-economic reality in the Roman world, and thus likely shaped the ways that early Jewish and Christian authors imagined various relationships. The notion of a relationship between figures of unequal standing that binds them through a non-legal social code of loyalty and reciprocal giving makes good sense of many relationships: between God, the people of God, rulers, Jesus, apostles, disciples, etc. A spate of recent publications testifies to the continued emphasis on patronage as a pervasive ideology reflected in various ways throughout much early Jewish and Christian discourse. Revelation has not received nearly the same kind of attention in this regard, which is surprising given how thoroughly patronal ideology and discourse permeates the text. Even a cursory look at the Apocalypse through the lens of patronal dynamics reveals the extent to which patronage is operative in the text.
For example, Jesus confers many benefits, often on behalf of God, to those who profess loyalty to him, including:
-the soteriological benefit of having been “freed” through Jesus’ death;
-shared power in the eschatological age;
-rewards (e.g., in the seven letters) for specific behavior(s); and
-the gift of the city of New Jerusalem itself.
These are only a few of the most conspicuous examples of one aspect of patronage (i.e., benefaction) in the text. In my presentation, I will highlight the more complex contours of patronage evident throughout Revelation, highlighting specific terminology pursuant to patronal discourse, the extent to which patronal dynamics undergird the relationship between God and the Lamb, as well as the Lamb and the followers of the Lamb, and resonances with patronal discourse elsewhere in early Jewish and Christian sources.
This line of inquiry is worthwhile in its own right insofar as it asks questions of the text that have not been fully explored, or asked at all. More importantly, I think it allows us to connect some previously unconnected dots. For example, recognizing that God and the Lamb are conferring patronal benefits makes good sense of the hymnic acclamations throughout the text, which very often functioned in the Roman world as responses to benefaction. So, too, it makes sense of Jesus’ role as God’s chosen vicegerent whose power (as displayed through incomparable divine benefaction) garners loyalty among his followers, usurping that of the Roman emperor. In other words, recognizing the crucified Jesus’ role as patron gives further dimension to the way that he was imagined to challenge the power of the emperor, while it simultaneously helps to explain why allegiance to the Lamb necessitated refusal to engage in competing socio-economic-religious relationships. Finally, it allows us to further situate theological, Christological, and soteriological discourse in Revelation in terms of broader early Jewish and Christian ideologies.
|
Semantic Mapping of Participants in Legal Discourse
Program Unit: Global Education and Research Technology
Christian Højgaard Jensen, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam
In this paper, I will present a new method of applying open source digital resources for investigating patterns of participants in the legal material of the so-called Holiness Code (Lev 17-26). Although several scholars have tried to explain the internal relationships between the participants in the Holiness Code, the large corpus complicates a systematic and consistent analysis. Developments within computational corpus linguistics, however, provide new ways of systematic investigations into the discourse of Biblical legal texts. Accordingly, this paper will demonstrate how open source technologies and resources, such as the ETCBC database, Text-Fabric, R, and Jupyter Notebook, can benefit discourse analysis of the Holiness Code. Using Lev 25:23-28 as a case-study, the paper presents a three-step method of creating a semantic map of the participants and their internal relationships. First, semantic role labels are distributed to all participants according to the Role and Reference Grammar theory of the thematic relationship between verb and arguments. Second, building upon Eep Talstra’s pioneering work of participant tracking, all participant references are linked to their respective referents. Finally, the formal, linguistic participant tracking and the semantic role labeling are combined to create a semantic map of participants. Eventually, a semantic mapping of participants can inform discourse analysis as well as digital, semantic concordances of textual participants and their semantic roles.
|
A Molecular "Flash Mob" Revolution in Mark 11:1–11
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
Dong Hyeon Jeong, Drew University
Mark 11:1-11's so-called triumphal entry of Jesus in Jerusalem mimics Greco-Roman and Jewish political and military processions, celebratory welcome, and/or Parousia except for the finale (grand ritual or sacrifice in the city's temple, expulsion of former vestiges of power, and/or festive banquet). Instead of a grandiose spectacle, Mark 11:11 has Jesus enter Jerusalem, look around, and dismiss himself back to his lodging at Bethany because it was late in the evening. This anticlimactic finale (or the lack thereof) attracted various scholars to hypothesize its divergence from traditional formulas. Responding to this inconsistency, this paper argues that the divergence is intentional. This intentionality, as a matter of fact, is actually part of a molecularly revolutionary scheme. To elaborate, this paper's conceptual foundation is based on Félix Guattari's term "molecular 'r'evolution," which is a term for decentered, originary, and subversive activities that occur in random moments. The small letter 'r' represents Guattari's preference for molecular or decentered micro-political social transformations and revolutions over transcendental revolution or totalitarian machinations. Guattari lists the various examples of modern day molecular 'r'evolutions. One of the them is a flash mob. This paper taps into Bill Wasik's (founder of the flash mob) understanding of a flash mob (inside job, undeclared location, and temporally transitory event) as a way to re-interpret Mark 11:1-11. Thus, this paper argues that the perceived lack of finale actually is part of the transitory or molecularly revolutionary nature of this triumphal event: the participants of the flash mob disperse immediately to avoid any trace or remnants of their subversive ways. Following the subversive spirit of Wasik's intention with the creation of a flash mob, this divergence from the traditional procedure of a triumphal entry is a deliberate part of the molecularly revolutionary scheme that empowers local communities to work together and express themselves against the oppressors and subvert institutional and normative restraints.
|
Wrapping It Up Like Paul: 2 Corinthians 13:11–13 and the Possibility of Redaction
Program Unit: Second Corinthians: Pauline Theology in the Making
Donghyun Jeong, Emory University
Markus Müller, who argues that “eine genaue Exegese” of each letter-ending of Paul’s letters enables us to understand the entire letter in question, regards the ending of 2 Corinthians as an “Ausnahme” of his rule. This is a telling remark on the peculiarity of 2 Cor 13:11–13. The questioning of the nature and the original location of 2 Cor 13:11–13 already began with Semler in the 18th century, who was also the first that launched partition theories of the Corinthian correspondence. Modern scholars have occasionally pointed out the disjuncture between 2 Cor 13:1–10 and 13:11–13 and have set forth several views regarding 13:11–13. However, such suggestions have often been briefly made without the text of 2 Cor 13:11–13 itself being examined thoroughly.
By using several criteria or “types of evidence,” which are used in the search for interpolations in the Pauline letters, this paper will demonstrate that the letter-ending in 2 Cor 13:11–13 has three distinctive characteristics, compared with both the language of 2 Corinthians as a whole and that of the other undisputed Pauline letters: (a) the abrupt shift of tone that this letter-ending creates; (b) its constituents having more parallels (in meaning and function) in other Pauline letters rather than in the rest of 2 Corinthians; (c) its structure appearing almost to be a summary of the various endings of the other Pauline letters. Any of them cannot be definite evidence to prove that 2 Cor 13:11–13 was not written by Paul; the accumulation of these three observations, however, increases the likelihood that this letter-ending may have been created (or at least, extensively reworked) and added to this place by a redactor.
Given the likelihood of redaction, some speculation can be further made regarding the redactor’s motive: the original ending of chs. 10–13 could have been unsatisfactory (e.g., too harsh to the end) when the redactor compared it with the endings of other Pauline letters, or the original ending could have been simply lost at the time of the compilation. One cannot determine with certainty which of the two is the case. Either way, nevertheless, the present letter-ending of 2 Corinthians may be an attempt of the redactor for compensation. He may have wanted to wrap up his compilatory work with a conciliatory letter-ending that sounds like Paul’s own work.
|
Homeless Jesus, Homeless Church: A Literary Analysis of Luke 4:16–30
Program Unit: Gospel of Luke
Mark Jeong, Yale Divinity School
Lukan scholars have long recognized Jesus’ rejection at Nazareth in Luke 4:16–30 as paradigmatic for his ministry. However, few have considered how the literary setting of Nazareth shapes the depiction of Jesus’ mission in the gospel and the identity of the church in Acts. This neglect is symptomatic of a broader neglect of the spatial dimensions of narrative in contemporary literary studies. Literary critic Mieke Bal notes that "Together with character, few concepts deriving from the theory of narrative texts are as self-evident and have yet remained so vague as the concept of space" (Narratology, 133-34). In this paper, I address this lacuna by analyzing the literary function of Nazareth as Jesus’ hometown in Luke 1–4. I begin by showing how hometowns act as places of social cohesion in ancient Greek narratives more broadly. I argue that Jesus’ hometown of Nazareth functions similarly in Luke as a place of stability, safety, and kinship. This common literary trope is disrupted however in Luke 4:16–30, such that Jesus is rendered homeless. I conclude by showing how Jesus’ homelessness becomes paradigmatic both for his ministry and for the church, which is also rendered homeless in Acts, such that the early Christian community becomes a “new home” for the displaced Christ-followers.
|
Throw Water at It: Water Purification Entrance Rites during the Greco-Roman Period
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
Mary Julia Jett, Saint Francis College
When Caesar lays claim to all of the various priesthoods, one of his coins reflects all the various implements for which different religious priesthoods threw water at people or things. The so-called Aspergillum shows up on other imperial coins as well and speaks to a particular cultic experience or practice. At a wide array of Greco-Roman Temples as well as worship sites of other religious traditions in Late Antiquity, water was thrown at anyone approaching the door as late as the end of the fourth century. For example, several fifth-century historians retell the history of Emperor Valens visiting the so-called Pagan Temple after his conversion. When water is thrown at him, one version explains that he threw off his coat, declaring he was made not clean but unclean. In another version, he hits the temple priest who dared throw water at him. Regardless of the particular reaction of the newly pious Emperor, the narratives show how one of the temple practices endured long after Christianity began to supplant other religious traditions.
Indeed, water purification rituals are common across wide swaths of religious traditions during the Greco-Roman period, but many of those are rites and rituals for those who are joining a particular cult or are already an active member of it. The entrance rite of water at the threshold is of a different nature. In some cases, anyone who walks by, indiscriminately, is hit with the water thrown by a priest. No consent or awareness or intentionality was required in some narratives of Greco-Roman practice, while other religious traditions of the same era have more elaborate water purification rites before one can enter the space of worship. A comparison of these purification entrance rites reveals the divergent local practices as well as the views of a priest, the water, and the views of who could access places of worship.
|
On Kaufmann’s Legacy: Its Reception and Potential
Program Unit: Jewish Interpretation of the Bible
Job Jindo, Academy for Jewish Religion
This paper discusses the legacy of Yehezkel Kaufmann’s biblical scholarship. His work has been justly criticized for its inflexible approach that does not allow for exceptions to his generalizations. However, its reception hitherto has been somewhat unduly reductive: it has often been viewed, mainly or solely, as an anti-Christian (anti-Wellhausen) polemic with a Zionist agenda that sought to glorify the formative period of his people. This paper will reconsider Kaufmann’s work and address its relevance for today’s biblical and religious studies, particularly for the phenomenological analysis of biblical monotheism.
|
Pitfalls of Metaphor Identification in Biblical Law
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Job Jindo, Academy for Jewish Religion
This paper discusses the limits and scope of what we can, and cannot, identify as metaphor in biblical law. As scholars of cognitive linguistics and other fields have amply demonstrated, the phenomenon of metaphor is ubiquitous and fundamental to human cognition. However, not everything is fundamentally metaphorical. The present paper explores this subtle yet crucial point, without which, as will be shown, we readily misconstrue not only the biblical legal discourse but also the general living reality of biblical religion as reflected in its literature. The paper will also discuss similar yet different categories such as model, analogy, and symbolism.
|
The Paul of Acts: Proclaimer of the Hope of Israel or Teacher of Apostasy from Moses?
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Joshua Jipp, Trinity Evangelical Divinity School
For at least fifty years or so, the question of the relationship between ‘Judaism’ and ‘Christianity’ in the Acts of the Apostles has been marked by two contradictory interpretive traditions. One tradition emphasizes conflict and rupture, whereas the other sees continuity and a largely positive treatment of Judaism. These interpretive traditions both find significant textual support from Acts. On the one hand, Luke portrays Paul as emphatic that he observes the Torah, is loyal to his Jewish heritage in every way, is zealous for the God of Israel, and believes everything written in the Law and the Prophets (21:20-26; 22:1-3; 23:1, 5; 24:14-15; 26:4-5). He stands trial for the “hope of Israel” (26:6-7; 28:20), circumcises Timothy (16:1-5), gives alms when he visits Jerusalem (24:17-24), and proclaims his message in the synagogues (9:19-29; 13:4, 42-43; 14:1; 16:12-13). On the other hand, Paul’s mission in the Jewish synagogues consistently creates disturbances and strife (13:45-52; 14:1-7; 17:5-8). Paul’s message is often successful in gentile households rather than in the synagogue (16:11-15; 17:1-9; 18:1-8; cf. Luke 10:1-13). And Paul, of course, is accused of apostasy from Moses as one who teaches the Diaspora Jews not to circumcise their children or live according to Jewish customs (21:21; cf. 6:11-15). It will not do, then, to grasp onto one side of the tension to support the simple claim that Paul is Jewish in every way or alternatively to claim that Paul is anti-Jewish or has made a break with Judaism.
There is, in my view, an internal tension within Luke’s characterization of Paul that does not fit neatly into easy dichotomies and is, in fact, representative of Luke’s broader two-volume work. What can explain this tension within Luke’s characterization of Paul? In this paper, I argue that the significance of God’s history within Israel, according to the Lukan Paul, centers upon Paul’s central conviction that Israel’s Davidic Messiah, resurrected and enthroned at God’s right hand, is the singular dispenser of salvation for Israel and the pagan nations. Paul’s retelling of the history of Israel in his speech at Pisidian Antioch comes to its climax in his central claim that the resurrection of the Davidic Messiah is the hope of God’s promises made to the ancestors of Israel (13:31-35; cf. Acts 2:27-36). This messianic conviction results in a re-evaluation (not rejection) of Israel’s primary identity markers that will only be embraced if one grants Paul’s claim that the hope of Israel is identified with Jesus of Nazareth as the resurrected and enthroned messianic ruler of Israel and the nations. Thus, the Lukan Paul’s construal of the meaning of Judaism makes good sense within broader Jewish debates regarding what constitutes faithfulness to God.
|
The Monstrosity of God Made Flesh: Karl Barth on God as Leviathan
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
Sarah Jobe, Duke University Divinity School
Three times over the course of 38 years, Karl Barth images God as the monster leviathan (once each in The Epistle to the Romans, Church Dogmatics II.1 & IV.3.1). Barth’s imagination for God in monstrous form emerges from his interpretation of Romans 11:35, in which the Apostle Paul quotes a line from Job 41:11, a poem about leviathan, to describe the greatness of God. When Barth comments on this verse, he highlights the way in which Paul is using a poem about leviathan to name characteristics of God. This paper will show how Barth amplifies Paul’s oblique reference, reclaiming additional leviathan language from Job 41, and unabashedly using that monstrous language to describe God (Romans, 423).
When Barth describes God as a leviathan again twenty years later in Volume II of Church Dogmatics, he makes clear that his claim is more than metaphor (CD II. 1, 115). In doing so, Barth begins to unpack how God is leviathan similar to the way in which Jesus takes on flesh. The leviathan is not simply a metaphor for God because its strength, mystery, and unbindable freedom mirror the strength, mystery and freedom of God. The leviathan is able to reveal knowledge of God because God is the content of its mystery in the same way that God makes “his works” the content of “His Word.” In other words, God inhabits leviathan as Barth understands Christ to inhabit flesh.
Using insights into monster theory from Jeffrey Cohen and Aleks Plukowski, I show how Barth’s imagination of God as a monster falls within a longer Christian tradition of turning to the hybrid, liminal, shape-shifting bodies of monsters to describe the hybridity of Jesus as God in human flesh – specifically a monster called a hellmouth, the monster at the gates of hell into whose jaws the abyss is rushing. In his final commentary on Job 41, Barth makes the radical suggestion that Jesus, Elected and Electing, Judged and Judge, is revealed to be both abyss-bound and abyss, hell-bound with us and leviathan, the hellmouth itself (CD IV.3.1, 432-3). God arrests our course into the abyss by becoming the mouth of the abyss into which we rush.
In God as leviathan, we gain the explicit inclusion into the body of God and life of the church those bodies, groups, and spaces that have been labeled monstrous in an attempt to exclude them from the various human projects of church and state. Moving from Barth’s exegetical insights, through Barth’s soteriology, the paper ends with the ethics of a God made monstrous flesh – an ethics that Barth explicitly links to the status of prisoners and all those depicted as monstrous and cast into society’s abyss-equivalents.
|
Is Freedom of Religion a Subset of Religious Doctrine?
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Varughese John, South Asia Institute of Advanced Christian Studies
Freedom of religion is an issue that is increasingly contested in India. In 1950, India adopted a constitution that guarantees freedom of religion. The Constitution defines India as a “sovereign, socialist secular democratic republic.” However, some scholars have argued that the Constitution is loaded with Judeo-Christian religious assumptions rather than Hindu religious assumptions. And thereby freedom of religion defined by the Indian constitution follows from a Judeo-Christian religious doctrine rather than from the Hindu religious doctrine. Underlying this argument is the assumption that the conception of religious freedom functions as a subset of religious doctrine.
This entails a conflict, where, the conception of freedom of religion in India via constitutional law conflicts with the Hindu concept of religion, wherein such a freedom of religion is not part of the religious doctrine. Hindu commentators, therefore, see the Judeo-Christian assumptions within the Constitution of India as a point of conflict from the perspective of the Hindu religious laws. Hence, the repeated calls to re-write the Constitution.
Taking into account the conflict in the anthropological assumptions and the corresponding visions of a good life, between the Hindu law and Constitutional law, my paper will address the challenges for framing of laws within truly pluralistic contexts like India.
|
Resurrection as Salvation: Past, Present, and Future
Program Unit: Pauline Theology
Andy Johnson, Nazarene Theological Seminary
Interpreters of Paul generally agree that Jesus’ death and resurrection constitute one complex saving event and then readily appropriate explicit salvific functions to Jesus’s death. But, even among interpreters not intending to downplay the salvific function of Christ’s resurrection, it is not uncommon to hear language highlighting its (proper) epistemological role of revealing the salvific efficacy of Jesus’ death but stopping short of outlining its other direct soteriological effects for humanity and the cosmos. Assuming a necessary connection between anthropology and cosmology, I will attempt to sketch these direct soteriological effects in Paul’s depiction of humanity’s past, present, and future experience of salvation. Succinctly put, I will argue that what God has done for the body of Jesus in microcosm in the resurrection, God is doing in the ecclesial body of Christ—the current locale of the new humanity and new creation/cosmos—and God will do for the cosmos in macrocosm at the Parousia.
The paper will proceed as follows. First, using 1 Cor 1:30 heuristically, I will contend that Christ as “last Adam,” the truly human One and microcosm of the new cosmos, experienced resurrection salvifically as God’s saving justice/vindication (dikaiosynē), God’s sanctifying cleansing from death’s corruption (hagiosmos), and God’s redemption from Death’s power (apolytrōsis). Second, I will argue that Paul depicts those who are participating “in Christ,” in this new humanity/new cosmos, as currently experiencing analogous (not identical) salvific effects of the power that Christ’s resurrection engenders. This power enables their simultaneous conformity to Christ crucified and their co-resurrection with him to new life within the corporate body of the crucified and resurrected Christ. That is, because of the salvific power unleased by the resurrection of the One in whom they find themselves, they are currently being justified (made just/righteous), sanctified (set apart to reflect God’s holy character), and redeemed (freed from slavery to the idolatrous powers of the old age). Third, I will argue that at the Parousia of the last Adam, who wields the resurrection power of the making-alive Spirit, those who belong to him will experience resurrection as salvific in that it completes their justification by vindicating their own cruciform life together, completely transforms and sanctifies their individual bodies and the relational matrix of the entire community, and is the means by which Death as a cosmic power is finally destroyed. The salvific impact of this resurrecting redemption of these ecclesial and individual bodies necessarily extends to the cosmos in macrocosm as the making-alive Spirit “entirely sanctifies” all of creation, releasing it from its bondage to decay and making it God’s cosmic sanctuary, filled with God’s justice, in which God is “all in all.” Hence, the paper will show that Christ’s resurrection for Paul is not simply a sign of the salvific efficacy of Jesus’ death, but constitutive of salvation itself.
|
Parody and Trinity: The Trinitarian Theology of Revelation from a Bestial Perspective
Program Unit:
David R. Johnson, Pentecostal Theological Seminary
This paper seeks to explore characteristics of a trinitarian theology via the characterization of the trinity of evil as described in the Apocalypse. While there has been significant study (and even debate) concerning the possibility of the trinity (whether robust, primitive, or non-existence) in Apocalypse studies, there has not been serious attention given to the parodic presentation of evil in the Apocalypse as evidence in relation to the divine trinity.
The question to be ask is, since the two beats and the dragon are presented as a parody of the one on the throne, the Lamb, and the seven Spirits, what characterization of the evil characters presented in the text might reflect, in parody, the function of the trinity in Revelation?
This paper will trace the parodic elements in the text. The dragon sits upon a throne, while the one on the throne sits upon a heavenly throne. The beast deceives through his own death (13.3, ὡς ἐσφαγμένην) and resurrection (13.3, 12 ἐθεραπεύθη cf. 13.14, ἔζησεν), parodying the Lamb who was slaughtered (5.6, ἐσφαγμένον) and who was raised to life (2.8 ὃς ἐγένετο νεκρὸς καὶ ἔζησεν). The beast of the earth parodies the activities of the seven Spirits who performs signs and wonders. The signs and wonders of the earth beast parody the signs and wonders of the two witnesses who are empowered by the Spirit. These false signs cause the whole world to worship the beast and deceive the world, which perhaps, reveals the work of the Spirit, albeit parodically. The mimicry of the earth beast even extends to the Spirit's life-giving power. Whereas πνεῦμα ζωῆς ἐκ τοῦ θεοῦ raised the two witnesses from death to life (11.11), the earth beast gives πνεῦμα to the image of the beast (13.15). When the second beast gives πνεῦμα to the first beast in Rev. 13.15, it is a parody of Rev. 11.11.
The final aspects of the paper will reflect on the ways that the parodic elements might reflect a Trinitarian theology of Revelation. The paper will conclude with implications for the relationship of God with the churches. The beast of the earth creates an image of the beast from the sea in Revelation 13 that receives S/spirit. Is it possible that the image of the beast works on a parodic level where the image of the beast mimics the role of the church? The image receives spirit as the churches, as the two witnesses, and the image is made in the image of the sea beast - who mimics the Lamb. Thus, is it possible that Revelation, via parody, sees the churches as the image of Jesus – as the Lamb – who live by the Spirit?
|
Between Clan and King: The Episode of the Wise Woman of Tekoa Reconsidered (2 Sam 14:2–24)
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Dylan Johnson, New York University
The brief episode of the wise woman from Tekoa (2 Sam 14:2-24), embedded in the narrative of Absalom’s revolt, presents numerous elements of interest to scholars of biblical and Near Eastern law. The juridical ruse concocted by Joab and presented by the Tekoaite woman touches on the legal issues of fratricide, death as the result of a fight, blood vengeance, and inheritance. In addition to the details of this case however, the narrative also alludes to the relationship between the local and the royal judicatures. Previous analyses of this text understood it to describe the transition of judicial authority from the local sphere to the center, as early Israel evolved from an “acephalous tribal society” to a nascent kingdom or the “chieftainship” of David. Aside from the uncertainties associated with reading this text as a reliable historical account of early Israel and its judicature, I challenge the notion that expanded royal judicial authority should have precipitated the diminishment of local courts. Through a careful analysis of this text and a comparison with near Eastern legal documents describing the interaction of local and royal courts, I propose that the text presumes a judicial principle known as “subsidiarity,” whereby local custom was the first legal recourse available to litigants while the royal judiciary intervened only when the former was deemed insufficient. Thus, the case of the wise woman from Tekoa need not describe the transition of Israel from tribal to more centralized forms of adjudication, but most likely reflects the later, royal judicial hierarchy of the author’s own time.
|
Reluctant Egalitarianism in Paul and the Glossolalic-Centric Churches of the American South
Program Unit: The Historical Paul
Lee A. Johnson, East Carolina University
The vision of the risen Christ on the Damascus Road compelled Paul to imagine Gentile inclusion without the Law and to envision his authority as the "apostle to the Gentiles" as authenticated not vis-à-vis his Pharisaic training but through his ecstatic experience. As Paul addresses challenges to his authority in his letters, he references his displays of "spirit and power" (1 Cor 2:4) and repudiates his Pharisaic credentials in favor of less traditional authoritative markers (Phil 3:4-8).
This paradigm shift, from nomic to pneumatic authority, has an ancient parallel in the Valentinian tradition wherein the power of the community of believers is determined by the activity of the prophetic spirit. The unpredictable dispensation of spiritual gifts disallows leadership and authority based upon patriarchal expectations. Several shared features of the Valentinians and the Pauline churches (open meetings, women prophets, spiritual progression, and an egalitarian vision) provide a basis to understand the dramatic contrasts between the Pauline churches and Paul's Pharisaic upbringing.
However, this paper will argue that Paul's shift in locus of authority was primarily necessitated by his need for apostolic legitimization based not upon an apostolic association or succession, but upon a pneumatically-verified encounter with the risen Christ. As a former detractor from the Jesus-centered communities, Paul was repeatedly challenged to assert his credentials as a self-proclaimed "apostle to the Gentiles" and forced into an uneasy reliance upon pneumatic authority to claim his right of leadership.
Paul's failure to fully embrace a pneumatically-authorized leadership structure is particularly exposed in his correspondence with the Corinthian church. As insightfully noted by Antoinette Clark Wire, Paul's attempts to restrain the power and influence of the Corinthian women prophets result in a notoriously convoluted argument throughout the letter. Paul grants women the right to pray and prophesy, yet affirms their place in the social hierarchy under men (1 Cor 11:3); Paul affirms that tongues-speaking is a gift, yet limits its use and devalues its purpose in the church (1 Cor 12:27-29). Strikingly, within the same letter, Paul lays claim to his apostolicity through the same pneumatic evidence that the Corinthian women express (1 Cor 2:4).
A similar tension is currently apparent within Pentecostal churches in the American south, wherein church leadership and authority is based upon a demonstration of pneumatic gifts, with a focus upon tongues-speaking. These churches have a majority of women who display proficiency at glossolalia and the women garner respect from their church communities precisely because of this spiritual gift. However, these denominations are strikingly patriarchal in structure outside the arena of the worship gathering. Women's leadership is recognized in the church service because they display the markings of the indwelling of the Spirit, yet they rarely hold offices or have positions over men. Churches whose doctrines and practice otherwise routinely confirm the subordinate position of women are forced to affirm the pneumatically-authenticated authority of women in worship. The reluctant egalitarianism witnessed in Paul's churches persists in the glossolalic churches of the American south.
|
"You Will Say on That Day, 'I Thank You, O Lord,' (Isa 12:1)": Hodayot Thanksgiving Psalms as Realizations of Isaiah's Eschatological Thanksgiving (Isa 12:1-6)
Program Unit: Prayer in Antiquity
Michael Brooks Johnson, McMaster University
This paper proposes that the psalms of thanksgiving (Danklieder) from the Qumran Hodayot are crafted as realizations of Isaiah's prophecy that Israel would offer a psalm of thanksgiving after the return of the remnant from exile. This prophesied psalm forms the conclusion of the first major section in Isaiah (chs. 1-12), which announces the judgment of Zion and Israel in preparation for establishing God's universal sovereignty. Isaiah's psalm takes the genre of the psalm of thanksgiving, which typically thanks God for deliverance from past distress, and redeploys it as an anticipation of the remnant of Israel's thanksgiving for deliverance in the eschaton. Reading the psalms of thanksgiving found among the Hodayot manuscripts at Qumran in light of the eschatological framework in Isa 12 helps to clarify some of the generic features that are not found in standard non-eschatological psalms of thanksgiving and to shed light on how psalmists in the Second Temple period were innovating new genres as contemporizing and exegetical responses to important scriptural texts like Isaiah 12:1-6.
|
“Son of Abraham” in Matthew 1:1: Jesus or David? Fresh Directions from Onomastics and Textual Criticism
Program Unit: Matthew
Nathan C. Johnson, Princeton Theological Seminary
The Gospel of Matthew memorably opens with a précis of the genealogy to follow: Ἰησοῦ Χριστοῦ υἱοῦ Δαυὶδ υἱοῦ Ἀβραάμ (1:1). Scholarship has long grappled with the relationship between Jesus, David, and Abraham, and their import for the remainder of the First Gospel. The popular salvation-historical reading, which reaches back to the anonymous Opus Imperfectum and is advanced most programmatically by Raymond Brown, posits that “son of David” refers to God’s dynastic covenant with David (2 Samuel 7) which Jesus fulfills, while “son of Abraham” adverts to God’s covenant with Abram to make him a blessing to the nations (Genesis 12), fulfilled in the sending of the disciples “to all the nations” (Matt 28:19). Recently, and quite originally, Leroy Huizenga has suggested that, since “son of David” is a title with obvious significance in the rest of the Gospel (1:20; 9:27; 12:23; 15:22; 20:30-31; 21:9, 15; 22:42), “son of Abraham” should be read with similar titular force. For Huizenga, “son of Abraham” naturally means Isaac, and 1:1 thus clears the way for a significant Isaac typology in Matthew.
The following paper investigates the cogency of these proposals and suggests a fresh way forward. First, I compare the relative weight of the names Abraham, Isaac, and David in antiquity. Though they have not been engaged in the interpretation of 1:1, two fields prove useful for this inquiry: onomastics and textual criticism. Onomastics because one can compare the relative use of these names among historical personages, which in turn suggests whether or not names were reverenced by being avoided (cf. avoidance of naming children “Jesus” in Anglophone cultures). Textual criticism, though rarely used in intertextual studies, proves useful in that one can see in Matthew’s manuscript tradition how later scribes handled the names Abraham, Isaac, and David. Specifically, the use of nomina sacra is surveyed for these names, with the result that David’s name was frequently revered, but, for whatever reason, Isaac’s and Abraham’s were not. Returning to Matt 1:1, this external evidence, coupled with Matthew’s patent interest in David but silence on Isaac in the rest of the Gospel, suggests that Huizenga’s reading, though novel, is unlikely. The heilsgeschichtlich proposal is similarly hampered.
Second, and in light of the above, I offer a constructive, lineal proposal in which David is given due weight as being himself the son of Abraham in Matt 1:1, a reading already on offer in Fortunatianus Aquileiensis’ recently discovered fourth-century Matthew commentary. Third and finally, I bring these results to bear upon the translation history of Matt 1:1.
|
Gandhi’s Engagement with Tolstoy and the Text of the Bible: It’s Ramifications for Peace Studies Today
Program Unit: Asian and Asian-American Hermeneutics
Rajkumar Boaz Johnson, North Park University
The paper seeks to analyze the impact that the Bible, and especially Tolstoy’s interpretation of the Bible, had on Gandhi’s thought towards non-violence and peace building.
In South Africa, where Gandhi was thrown out of the train at Pietermaritzburg, he read Tolstoy’s The Kingdom of God is Within You, My Confession, and My Religion. In his Autobiography, The Story of My Experiments with Truth, Gandhi wrote, “Tolstoy’s The Kingdom of God is Within You overwhelmed me. It left an abiding impression on me. Before the independent thinking, profound morality, and the truthfulness of this book, all the books given me . . . seemed to pale into insignificance.” (Ch. 15). In the year or so before Tolstoy’s death, the two engaged in a very informative correspondence, in which they engage with the biblical text.
This paper examines both Tolstoy and Gandhi’s engagement with the biblical text, and seeks to make proposals towards peace building today, in the light of this analysis.
|
Daily Devotions: Early Christians and Household Religion
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Caroline Johnson Hodge, College Of The Holy Cross
Most scholarship on the origins of Christianity has focused on texts and ideas. Indeed, texts comprise our primary evidence for early Christianity, and certainly ideas, beliefs, and interpretation were central to the development of this new religion in the Roman world. Recent theorizing about Roman-period religion, however, notes that these intellectual practices are but one way of categorizing religious activity, and that daily practices in homes and neighborhoods were by far more common. These actions, related to eating, entering and exiting spaces, marking life transitions, etc., are ubiquitous, learned by habit, and, for the most part, not subject to intellectual interpretation and debate.
My proposed paper focuses on this latter mode of religion and explores how Christians engaged in this kind of daily exchange with the divine in households and neighborhoods, separate from the intellectual practices of “published” Christians. My topic is not house churches, where groups of believers gathered for meals and worship. Instead, I examine mixed households, where one or more, usually subordinate, members of the household expressed some level of commitment to Christian practices and beliefs. I hope to argue that Christians developed devotional practices in households, apart from community worship, that are akin to the kinds of activities already happening for various domestic deities around the empire. Alongside the intellectual and meal practices of the ekklesia, believers built a repertoire of signs, gestures, prayers, etc., that constituted a Christian household cult.
One reason this angle on early Christian history important is that it places subordinate members of the household—wives and slaves—at the center of investigation. The Roman-period household was a hierarchical system; typically, all members of the household worshipped the gods of the head of the household (who was usually, although not always, male and free). If a head of the household showed allegiance to a new god, the subordinates were to follow suit. My question is: what happens when a wife or a slave converts to Christianity? Is there a way for these subordinate members of the household—who, by the way, were primarily responsible for implementing religious practices in the home—to show their devotion to their new god? This is an intriguing and under-studied perspective on how Christianity might have spread throughout the Roman empire: through the daily devotions of ordinary people who incorporated their new god into the worship practices of their households.
Archaeological evidence will be critical to this study. We have little to no evidence for Christian domestic worship in the early centuries, but we do have evidence for widespread and various household cult practices across the empire. This will provide the interpretive context for understanding textual references to Christian practices in the domestic context (from church manuals, moralists, and others), especially as they relate to wives, slaves, and other subordinate members of households.
|
Myth and Authority in Late Antiquity
Program Unit: Religious World of Late Antiquity
Sarah Iles Johnston, Ohio State University
Myth and Authority in Late Antiquity
|
Social Scientific Perspectives on Authority and Leadership in the Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Qumran
Jutta Jokiranta, University of Helsinki
I take “authority” as an analytical concept which may or may not have clear boundaries: We need the concept for different purposes, and something could be authoritative before we decide what it is exactly. F. Furedi, Authority: A Sociological History (2013) offers a broad overview on historical variations of what validates society's laws and conventions, and also pays attention to the influence that Weberian typology of authority (tradition, charisma, rationality) has had in scholarship. Weberian approach often emphasizes the ways in which the source of authority is produced but is less helpful for analysing the social conditions in which the authority is accepted. This aspect is important for any study of texts since ancient texts can most easily be analysed for their various aspects of claiming authority (“strategies” of authority) but less is known about how the texts functioned in their social environments and were themselves or people using them accepted as authoritative. But is “social pressure” the same as authority? For Furedi, authority is about guiding people’s behaviour without “having to argue or to threaten the use of force” (15). Authority seems closely connected to trust and people’s willingness to cooperate. The Qumran yaḥad could be viewed as anything between a new political movement to keep the society together and a utopian group that cultivated trust within insiders and mistrust of all outside. This paper draws on sociological and social psychological research on authority and leadership in the effort to understand authority as a fundamentally social phenomenon.
|
Church as Dual Citizens of Kingdom and State
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Jonathan Leeman, 9Marks, Washington, DC
Church as Dual Citizens of Kingdom and State
|
A Biblical Philologist's Dream: How to Use Ethnographies to Teach Intro to Religion
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Christopher M. Jones, Washburn University
I am a Semitic philologist specializing in Achaemenid-era Judaism. Last year, I took a tenure-track position as program director (and sole faculty member) in the religion program at a regional public university. I now teach Introduction to Religion and World Religions, among other classes that are, frankly, way out of my depth. For this presentation, I want to talk about my Intro to Religion syllabus. It represents my best attempt at solving two serious problems: first, the overrepresentation of Abrahamic traditions in most Intro to Religion courses, and second, my own lack of depth in the non-Abrahamic traditions that need to be centered in 21st century religious studies curricula. It also attempts to shorten my learning curve as a first-year tenure track professor by playing to my strengths as a philologist. Rather than teaching religious studies concepts through isolated case studies (which lack context) or through sacred texts (which covertly re-center Protestant Christianity), I built my syllabus around two (affordable) book-length ethnographies of specific religious communities: Salvation on Sand Mountain, a study of Appalachian snake-handling Pentecostal Christians, and Mama Lola, a study of Haitian Vodou practitioners in New York. I assign readings from these books juxtaposed with a variety of classic theories of religion. I group these theories according to where they locate religion: in society (Durkheim, Douglas), in experience (James, Eliade), and in scare quotes (J.Z. Smith, Asad, Masuzawa). The ethnographies provide carefully contextualized, text-based data (a philologist's dream) with which I can illustrate and test various theories of religion with my students. Moreover, because the ethnographers in these books insert themselves into their subjects, they also provide a model for my students as they perform their own site observation projects. This approach ultimately allows me, as a Semitic philologist with a 4/4 teaching load, to engage my students with data on living religions and theoretical approaches to the academic study of religion.
|
Life with the Least of These: A Conversation with Michael Gorman and Jean Vanier
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Jennifer Brown Jones, McMaster Divinity College
In August 2017 an article was published by CBS News discussing the near eradication of Down Syndrome births in Iceland, sending shock waves through some communities and bringing the pro-choice/pro-life debate to the fore once again. However, this debate is not the only issue raised by the article. A second,and perhaps just as relevant, question is raised in the article by an Icelandic parent of a Down Syndrome daughter: “What kind of society do you want to live in?” Framed differently, the article raises the question of whether or not we want to live in a society where only people with certain physical characteristics and physical or mental abilities are valued and welcomed. To address this question, the present paper places the New Testament research of Michael Gorman, who describes the missio Dei as fundamentally kenotic, in conversation with the vocationally based writings of Jean Vanier, who lived with and ministered among the cognitively disabled. Ultimately, this conversation not only suggests that the differently-abled are valuable, and indeed necessary, members of our communities, it points to a way forward in living with people of all abilities.
|
On Gesture and Social Values: The Friend-Kiss Gesture of Proverbs 24 with Ancient Near Eastern Analogs
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Jordan W. Jones, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion
The study of non-ritual gesture in the Hebrew Bible can be a helpful medium for understanding social values in ancient Israel. Similar examples of nonverbal communication from ancient Near Eastern (ANE) texts may serve to strengthen our understanding of said gestures. For example, relevant occurrences of the friend-kiss may be observed in Ugaritic (KTU3 1.22:4), Akkadian (Enuma Elish, Gilgamesh), Egyptian (The Doomed Prince), and Sumerian (Gilgamesh epics) texts. Among the varied cultural sub-contexts of the ANE and their respective literatures, the act of kissing is one of the most consistently parallel gestures, both in terms of its form and meaning. Owing to its inherent nature as a source for moral pedagogy, Proverbs (and wisdom literature more broadly) may be the ideal corpus from which to study the intersection of gesture and social values. To understand the contribution of the friend-kiss for framing social values, it is fitting to explore its interesting occurrence in Proverbs 24:26. Commentators have mostly overlooked the possibility that this verse concludes a chiastic structure and is intended to parallel, in positive terms, the meaning of the negatively phrased statement in v. 23. In fact, it is possible to view the statements made in the first (v. 23) and last (v. 26) verses as general principles that encircle specific applications (or scenarios) of those principles (vv. 24-25). The body of these four verses (vv. 24-25) focuses on the contrast between a person who speaks truth (by convicting the guilty) and is, consequently, blessed (v. 24), versus a person who speaks falsehood (by acquitting the guilty) and is, consequently, cursed (v. 25). The gesture here implies acceptance and even friendship, though in other contexts of greeting the gesture may be arguably more ceremonial. In no known context is kissing identified as a negative act, which is specifically why it is a useful tool for deception, as in the case of Joab and Amasa or Gilgamesh and Ḫuwawa. From the standpoint of social values, the friend-kiss is one of the few non-ritual gestures not condemned in Proverbs, as it is associated with truthful words (Prov 24:26) and truthful actions (Prov 27:6). For a friend to kiss another is to nonverbally confirm acceptance, loyalty, transparency, honesty, and positive intentions. Behaviors that create division and animosity are condemned in biblical and ANE texts, so it comes as no surprise that the sages looked favorably on a gesture symbolic of unity. Joab’s deceit toward Amasa was particularly effective because it was concealed by the gesture most indicative of honesty and friendship. For the honorable Israelite, living an honest life—a state of being most readily visible in the gestures of the righteous person—is consistent with Yahweh’s divine ordering of the world.
|
What Do Hezekiah and Ashurbanipal Have in Common? Comparative Observations of the Rising Action in Biblical and Neo-Assyrian Accounts of Divine Intervention
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Joshua Jones, University of Texas at Austin
Divine intervention in battle in the Ancient Near East, according to the written accounts, occurred in ways both subtle and overt in nature. The sequence of events which led up to each alleged instance, such as supplications for help or sacrifices as offerings for aid, vary just as much. Yet, despite the different cultures and peoples who produced these written sources, many similarities in this topic of divine intervention may be found. Three accounts in particular, one biblical and the other two Neo-Assyrian, exhibit such peculiar similarities in their storylines that they deserve specific attention and have received limited sustained consideration by scholars heretofore. The first is the account of Sennacherib’s military actions against Hezekiah and Judah in 701 B.C.E. as recorded in 2 Kgs 19:9b-35. The second and third are both recensions of Ashurbanipal’s seventh campaign, or second Elamite campaign, against the Elamite king Teumman and are recorded in the Assyrian king’s annals Editions B and D (It should be noted that these two editions are almost completely identical except for minor orthographic differences, which do not affect the paper’s aim). Although other annals and reliefs relate Ashurbanipal’s second Elamite campaign, these two editions present important literary parallels to the account in 2 Kings not present in the other Neo-Assyrian texts. These shared features are neither sporadic nor haphazard but contextual, thematic, and sequential in nature. For instance, each text revolves around its respective king, the city of his preferred deity, and an imminent military threat from a proud and blasphemous antagonist who commences a war without divine approval. This paper will highlight the comparability of literary forms in these two accounts in order to contribute to the discussion of scribal practice. In addition, it will investigate the discussion of kingship ideology as it appears in the Deuteronomic History in contrast to such ideology found in Neo-Assyrian records. There is no intention of arguing a dependence of one text on the other. The discussion will specifically deal with the comparability of the two accounts in their respective states.
|
The Stammering Seer: Moses, Patriarchs, and the Priestly Source
Program Unit: Senses, Cultures, and Biblical Worlds
Kirsty Jones, Georgetown University
Is Moses “heavy of tongue and mouth” merely to showcase God’s power or to introduce Aaron? Or is there more to Moses’ depiction in Exod 4 than meets the ear? Combining sensory analysis, source criticism and intertextual studies, I suggest that Moses’ speech links between the patriarchal narratives (particularly Gen 27 and 32) and the wilderness narratives, looking back to Isaac and Jacob through the motif of disability. I advance that Moses’ weakness in aural/oral communication is supplemented by his power in visual communication, evident in the signs of 4:1–9. I will briefly survey current perspectives on Exod 3–4, before discussing the presence and role of sensory disability within this text. I then turn to a heuristic, and necessarily broad, sensory analysis of the Priestly source and question how the visual signs of Exod 3–4 work within this framework, and alongside Moses’ supposed disability.
The author of this text wished, I suggest, to validate a somatic/sensory impairment in the venerated Moses, and offset it with a different communicative strength. I link this to the visiocentricity of the Priestly source and suggest that the redactional bridge links Moses, the patriarchs, the wilderness revelation and the Priestly rhetoric. In 4:10, then, focus does not move “from the problem of the people’s disbelief (4:1–9) to Moses’ personal ability and suitability for the mission.” The focus moves through Moses’ ability, into his doubted suitability and back again in a dialectic of human availability and divine ability.
|
The Humanity of Jesus in the Garden: An Excursus on Matthew 26:36-46
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Matt Jones, Colorado Christian University
The Humanity of Jesus in the Garden: An Excursus on Matthew 26:36-46
|
A Priest Like Noah: 4Q541 in Its Qumran Aramaic Context
Program Unit: Qumran
Robert Jones, McMaster University
Fragment 9i of the so-called Apocryphon of Levi (4Q541) recounts the mission of an eschatological figure who carries out both sapiential and priestly duties. The mission of this figure is universal in its scope, and yet he experiences intense opposition from members of his own generation. This figure and his mission are often discussed in light of a perceived parallel between 4Q541 and the Servant Songs of Deutero-Isaiah (Starcky 1963; Puech 1992; Hengel 1992, 2004; Brooke 1993; Knibb 1995). For many years, scholars have interpreted this figure against the backdrop of the Suffering Servant of Isaiah 53, though John Collins has critiqued this proposal, instead suggesting that the author of 4Q541 crafted the identity of this figure with the Teacher of Righteousness in mind (Collins 1995, 2010). Some have also discussed this figure in the context of a comparative reading of 4Q541 and the later Greek Testament of Levi (Brooke 1993; Knibb 1995; Zimmerman 1998; Xeravits 2003; Hogeterp 2009; Cook 2012).
In my view, the larger Qumran Aramaic collection is 4Q541’s most immediate, though largely overlooked, literary context. Fragment 9i shares many points of contact with the compositions that comprise this broader literary collection, including its light/dark dualism, its convergence of sapiential and priestly elements, as well as its apocalyptic character. To date, there has been no attempt to situate 4Q541 against the backdrop of the Aramaic texts from Qumran. For this reason, most scholars have overstated the similarities between the figure in frag. 9i and the Suffering Servant and have missed the literary connections between frag. 9i and the Qumran Aramaic traditions associated with Noah and the Flood (though, see WAC, 539-540; Peters 2008: 100, 105-106).
After a brief history of the scholarship on 4Q541, this paper will situate this fragment within its broader Qumran Aramaic context, and will then highlight a number of specific parallels between frag. 9i and various Aramaic Noahic and/or diluvial traditions (GenAp, ApWeeks, Birth of Noah, ALD, VisAm). Diverging from most previous scholars, I suggest that the opposition that Noah faces in 4Q534, rather than the violence perpetrated against the so-called Suffering Servant, is a closer literary parallel to the opposition faced by the figure in frag. 9i. This observation will be followed by an analysis of the ways in which Noah’s status as a prototypical priest and sage (cf. 4Q541 9i.2-3), Noah’s sun-like radiance (cf. 4Q541 9i.3-4), and the description of the Flood generation as deceitful and violent (cf. 4Q541 9i.7) only reinforce the connections between 4Q541 and the Noah/Flood traditions from the Qumran Aramaic collection. I conclude that the author of 4Q541 intended to make these connections in order to advance an Urzeit-Endzeit eschatology, according to which the last days mirror the time of the primordial flood (e.g. Apocalypse of Week, 4Q212 1iii.5; 1iv.14). This literary strategy only comes in to view, however, when 4Q541 is understood in its larger Qumran Aramaic context.
|
La Bible d'Alexandrie
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Jan Joosten, University of Oxford
In this time slot I shall present a sample of my commentary work for the series, to highlight its approach
|
The Notion of Cult Centralization in Literary and Historical Perspective: The View from Leviticus 17
Program Unit: Book of Deuteronomy
Jan Joosten, University of Oxford
The fact that Lev 17 opens the Holiness Code in the same way Deut 12 opens the Deuteronomic Code has led many scholars to the idea that the two chapters express a similar meaning. Lev 17’s single altar of YHWH in the desert camp was viewed as a later, less polemical, analogue of Deut 12’s unique place of worship in the land. In this approach, the danger of reading the Holiness Code in the light of Deuteronomy, without considering its own specific tenor, has not always been avoided. The theme of Lev 17 is not cult centralization but the consumption of animal meat. Nevertheless, the two chapters have much in common, and a comparison of the two may be expected to illuminate several questions that are relevant to the history of cult centralization and its representation in literature.
|
Dionysus versus YHWH: Analysing the Narratives of Intoxication in 3 Maccabees:
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Pierre J Jordaan, North-West University (South Africa)
In the Book of Proverbs 31:6 & 7 comes this prescription: “Give strong drink unto him that is ready to perish, and wine unto them that be of heavy hearts. Let him drink, and forget his poverty, and remember his misery no more.” Even in contemporary times, Jews still employ wine as a common means to bring “joy to God and man” (Judges 9:13). Indeed wine continues to remain part of most Jewish practices including Kiddush, Havdallah, weddings, circumcisions, the Pesach seder and Purim.
In a similar vein, the Hellenistic cult of Dionysos is strongly associated with the consumption of wine. Here, members of the cult consumed wine, ostensibly as a means of achieving an altered state of consciousness in order to become closer to their deity. Furthermore, both Judaism and the Dionysian rites warn of the dangers of excessive consumption in similar ways despite the fact that they are very different belief systems.
Notwithstanding their similar attitudes to wine consumption, the topic of intoxication features predominantly in the 3 Maccabees narrative, inter alia, in order to contrast the two religions. Indeed, intoxication and levels of intoxication are employed to differentiate Jew from Hellene in very ironic ways, even when at the end of 3 Maccabees, both Jew and Gentile openly feast and drink together. In these and related contexts, the authors attempt to reveal the specific rhetorical strategies, involving the consumption of wine, which are employed by the author of 3 Maccabees to both set the two religions apart as well as inculcate a lasting spirit of reconciliation.
|
Long Live Uprooting! Aristide’s Biblical and Politico-theology of Defensive Violence in the Struggle for Democracy in Haiti
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Celucien L. Joseph, Indian River State College
Jean-Bertrand Aristide is one of the most controversial figures in Haitian history in the twenty-first century. He is a Liberation Theologian, former President of Haiti, and a former Catholic-Priest who has been expelled from the Catholic Church and Priesthood for his radical views on social and political issues. The political ambiguity that has marked his two presidencies, 1991-1996, and 2001-2004 is quite appalling. Aristide overwhelming won the popular votes in the 1990 presidential election in Haiti. He came to power in February 7, 1991; briefly, after seven months of governance, he was overthrown by a military coup on September 26, 1991. He was restored to power in 1994 to 1996, by the US government and International community. His second presidential administration lasted from 2001 to 2004. In both presidential elections, Jean-Bertrand Aristide won the popular vote, about 70% in 2001. For the second time, Aristide was ousted in 2004 in a coup d'état, and eventually was forced to exile in South Africa.
Nonetheless, many critics have characterized Aristide’s political leadership and actions during his second administration as an era of intense popular violence, gangsterization, and chimèrization. Consequently, the goal of this paper is twofold. First, it analyses these complex relationships and sensitive-ethical issues by interacting with the current scholarship on Aristide. Emphasis will be given on three vital issues: Jean-Bertrand Aristide’s seemingly affiliation with the gangs of chimères, the deadly method of necklacing (Père Lebrun) which he ostensibly advocated, and violations of human rights his second administration carried out. Secondly, the paper examines Aristide’s first biblical and politico-theological treatise, 100 Vèsè dechoukaj. Va t'en Satan! (1986) to study whether he has formulated or articulated a theology of violence and aggression that will later shape his political leadership and actions during his second presidential administration. It is evident in this early text, Aristide has perfected a rhetoric of bellicosity, framed within a particular theo-political hermeneutics and discourse, to damn the Duvalierists and Macoutes, and uproot the oppressors and distractors of the Haitian people. In other words, this paper argues that the popular violence and gangsterism associated with Aristide’s second-term presidency and his Fanmi Lavalas (FL)—his political party—supporters have deep roots in Aristide’s biblical hermeneutics and theology of retributive justice; yet, such (biblical) theology was constructed as a response to the Duvalier regime and to redeem the Haitian people from their oppressors and preserve them from future state-sponsored violence and aggression.
|
An Indigenous Q: Redescribing the Ethnic, Social, and Political Context(s) of Q in Light of Postcolonial Native Studies
Program Unit: Q
Simon Joseph, California Lutheran University
Postcolonial Native Studies illustrate that Native/Indigenous identity is characterized and represented by a complex nexus of land, language, and ethnicity in dynamic relationship with each other, without which Native culture and religion tend to be destabilized and make little contextual sense. This paper seeks to utilize these insights in Q Studies by exploring Q’s identification as an ethnically Jewish/Judean text – that is, an Indigenous Palestinian Judean text – reflecting a contested and turbulent first-century socio-political world in which traditional ethnically Judean identity-markers, ancestral customs, linguistic conventions, religious practices, and geographical allegiances are in flux.
|
Contours and Particulars: A Study of the Shape and Details of the Textual History of Ethiopic Obadiah
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Garry Jost, Marylhurst University
The Textual History of the Ethiopic Old Testament (THEOT) has developed manual and computer processes to analyze 38 manuscripts of Ethiopic Obadiah in order to tell the various stories that background the creation of these artifacts. The development of these processes has been informed by descriptive and inferential statistics. In order to reliably conceptualize and visualize the relevant data, this approach provides accuracy, comprehensiveness, consistency and precision.
This presentation discusses the various options available and decisions taken as the team prepared the stories for publication. The primary goals were to present data so that other scholars can acquire an overview of the textual history of Ethiopic Obadiah, as well as examine the details of the shared readings that differentiate the various clusters of manuscripts. The primary components for telling these stories are dendrograms, lists of shared readings, and the best representative manuscripts of each cluster.
The presentation will end with a brief discussion on future directions for my research.
|
Beyond Boundaries: Reading Aseneth from a Postcolonial Perspective
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Sunhee Jun, Chicago Theological Seminary
Almost all scholars who are involved in Aseneth agree that conversion is one of the most important themes in this text. In this respect, the new name of Aseneth, “City of Refuge” is understood as a shelter for proselytes. In postcolonial studies, this kind of story that seems to beautify a conversion can be read negatively. For this reason, biblical scholar Ronald Charles regards this text as “a colonizing text,” concluding that “there is no room in the author’s mind for any dialogue concerning the religious sentiments of the Other.” However, I am skeptical whether this text can be homogenized as a colonizing text that shows an exclusive attitude toward other groups. Although I agree that Aseneth includes some exclusive elements, I argue that this text reveals diverse attempts to go beyond boundaries between two groups.
To prove my argument, I try to read this text with the postcolonial concept of ‘contact zone’ which means the space where colonial encounters happen between two disparate groups. Although this encounter happens in an asymmetric power relationship, the outcome in contact zones is not unilateral according to the intention of the colonizer. Diverse and unexpected changes occur in the contact zone. In this paper, I examine what negotiations in the contact zones in Aseneth happen and what changes happen to the two groups after negotiation in the contact zones.
In Aseneth, two contact zones can be found: one is the court of Pontephres, Aseneth’s father and the other is Aseneth’s chamber. In the first contact zone, Pontephres negotiates with Joseph in order to gain the equal right by establishing a family tie. This negotiation breaks down when Joseph refuses to kiss to Aseneth by reason of their different religions. But this doesn’t mean a failure; Joseph’s abhorrence of table fellowship with Egyptians no longer appears in the narrative after the encounter in the contact zone.
The second contact zone is formed in Aseneth’s chamber when a heavenly figure intrudes into her chamber after Aseneth’s conversion. In this encounter which is in an asymmetric power relationship, the angel grants a new name to Aseneth, “City of Refuge,” which has some requirements such as religion and repentance. From a postcolonial lens, the name change of the colonized can be understood as a colonizer’s strategy to control the colonized. However, Aseneth is not just passive or powerless; she negotiates with the Angel to make him bless seven virgins, who are like sisters to Aseneth. By this negotiation, the seven virgins gain similar status with Aseneth—“seven pillars of the City of Refuge”—without conversion. I argue that as a result of the negotiation, Aseneth re-identifies herself with the new meaning of City of Refuge; she becomes a shelter to anyone beyond boundaries such as religion and repentance. This re-making of the meaning of City of Refuge is fulfilled when she protects Dan, Gad, and Pharaoh’s son regardless of their conversion or religion.
|
Rethinking the Method Lexical Analysis: From Understanding to Translating of λογίζομαι in Romans 4
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Jason J. C. Jung, McMaster Divinity College
The goal of this paper is to promote a new method of doing lexical analysis that is grounded in modern linguistics. This paper explores various methods of doing lexical analysis, or a word study as the practice is more commonly called. This exploration will begin with reevaluating some of the more popular practices of lexical analysis and will end in demonstrating a new method. Particularly, some prevalent presuppositions of biblical and theological practices will be questioned, especially regarding their heavy dependence upon reference tools such as A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament and Other Early Christian Literature, which is commonly called BDAG, or Theological Dictionary of the New Testament, which is known as TDNT. As substitutes for these practices, this paper will introduce two modern linguistic criteria, monosemy and synchrony, which facilitate the exegete to seek the meaning of a word from its text and context. I will utilize λογίζομαι in Romans as a test case. For it is used nineteen times in Romans but is seldom translated equally.
|
The Levant as Seen from Babylon in the Sixth Century
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Michael Jursa, Universität Wien
This talk examines the Cuneiform evidence for the impact of Babylonian imperial domination over the Levant both for the imperial centre, and the imperial periphery. Different vectors for political, socio-economic and cultural interaction along imperial lines of communication are explored.
|
Galatia(ns): A Critical Text in Search of Its Historical Context
Program Unit: Polis and Ekklesia: Investigations of Urban Christianity
Brigitte Kahl, Union Theological Seminary in the City of New York
As dogmatic terra firma of Protestantism since Martin Luther, the letter to the Galatians in standard interpretations is disproportionately under-explored with regard to its 1st century CE historical locatedness. While North versus South Galatian hypotheses are still faithfully debated, the primary Roman topology of both sites is mostly eclipsed, as well as native cultures or the ideological valence of Galatia as topos of anti-barbarian warfare in the Greco-Roman world. The presentation will select a few signature pieces from the long list of “Galatian” epigraphy, architecture and visual arts that are in urgent need of being reconsidered as part of the overall picture of Paul’s Galatia. Taken from Ancyra, Antioch, Apollonia or elsewhere in/outside the province, they may open up new horizons for a more critical and less unhistorical reading of Galatians and its theological core statements.
|
The Sounds of Violence in Jeremiah
Program Unit: Writing/Reading Jeremiah
Amy Kalmanofsky, Jewish Theological Seminary
The recent critical focus on violent imagery in the Hebrew Bible reflects a subtle privileging of the sense of sight over sound, at least for the scholars who engage in this effort. Notably, the book of Jeremiah relies on both sight and sound as part of its rhetorical repertoire, employing both to convey and induce violence. Building on the work of Hector Avalos and Rhiannon Graybill who suggest that mapping a text’s “soundscape” provides unique insight into its social, literary and theological agendas, this paper examines three prominent violent sounds in Jeremiah—weeping, roaring, and silence—and works to understand how and why these sounds function as part of Jeremiah’s violent rhetoric.
|
The Gospel of Matthew and Antisemitism
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
John I Kampen, Methodist Theological School in Ohio
Those scholars who consider the gospel of Matthew to have been composed by and/or for Gentiles tend to regard the work to be antisemitic (or anti-Jewish, depending upon definition). Scholars who argue for a Jewish provenance are often associated with a viewpoint that suggests the antisemitic uses of the first gospel were later developments of the Christian church and should not be considered integral to the text itself. A sectarian Jewish reading of the first gospel problematizes such an alternative by highlighting the intent and purpose of the Jewish critique, suggesting that the relationship of the text to the development of antisemitism is a more complex matter. Some students of Matthew have attempted to simplify the question by suggesting that this sectarian group had already made the break with Judaism. Such an approach also simplifies the very complex issues attached to the study of a composition that reflects a high level of antagonism toward a variety of Jewish co-religionists but is not to be identified as anything other than Jewish. The violence of this critique finds expression in a variety of manners distinctive to Matthew in the gospel tradition. The antisemitic use of the first gospel has its origins in the sectarian identity that is propagated by this Jewish composition.
|
At Home While Far from Home: The Visionary Context of Ezekiel 40-48
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Jina Kang, Loyola Marymount University
In the Korean language, the term, bokeumjali is usually translated "home." However, bokeumjali has acute significance especially in the context of Korean immigration abroad. Bokeumjali is a home that is not exclusively defined by geopolitical borders, but is situated within a social and conceptual space of belonging, memories, and meaningful relationships. Therefore, Korean immigrants abroad will often refer to the urgency and adversities of building a bokeumjali. For those who have crossed many boundaries, both geopolitical and conceptual ones, building and finding a bokeumjali is of utmost urgency and necessity having left home behind.
This study is an investigation of the detailed yet elusive world of the final vision report in the book of Ezekiel (Ezek 40-48). Set in the twenty-fifth year of a forced migration experience in Babylon (Ezek 40:1), the final vision report has been called by various names: from the "great temple vision" to "vision of transformation" and "program of restoration." However, an immigrant experience of loss of home and urgency to (re)-build home may offer insights to understanding the landscape of complexes and complexities in Ezekiel's final vision report as a "vision for bokeumjali." To gain insights into how immigrants think about home, this study explores, as a case study, Korean-American narratives of the destruction of Koreatown during the civil unrest that besieged the city of Los Angles in the Spring of 1992. Often referred to as the "L.A. riots" or the "Rodney King riots," the days of civil unrest that left parts of the Los Angeles landscape including Koreatown resembling war zones is recalled in Korean-American narratives as Sa-I-Gu. Methodologically, this case study will sensitize the readers to a different perspective to Ezekiel 40-48 as a visionary quest for bokeumjali while in exile. Ultimately, Ezekiel 40-48 demonstrates a careful dialectic of hope for the restoration of home while far from home. This is a study about how the migratory process affects where immigrants identify as home and how they think about home.
|
At Home while Far from Home: Ezekiel 40–48 as "Vision for Home"
Program Unit: Korean Biblical Colloquium
Jina Kang, Loyola Marymount University
In the Korean language, the term, bokeumjali is usually translated "home." However, bokeumjali has acute significance especially in the context of Korean immigration abroad. Bokeumjali is a home that is not exclusively defined by geopolitical borders, but is situated within a social and conceptual space of belonging, memories, and meaningful relationships. Therefore, Korean immigrants abroad will often refer to the urgency and adversities of building a bokeumjali. For those who have crossed many boundaries, both geopolitical and conceptual ones, building and finding a bokeumjali is of utmost urgency and necessity having left home behind.
This study is an investigation of the detailed yet elusive world of the final vision report in the book of Ezekiel (Ezek 40-48). Set in the twenty-fifth year of a forced migration experience to Babylon (Ezek 40:1), the final vision report has been called by various names: from the "great temple vision" to "vision of transformation" and "program of restoration." However, an immigrant experience of loss of home and urgency to (re)-build home may offer insights to understanding the landscape of complexes and complexities in Ezekiel's final vision report as a "vision for bokeumjali." To gain insights into how immigrants think about home, this study explores, as a case study, Korean-American narratives of the destruction of Koreatown during the civil unrest that besieged the city of Los Angles in the Spring of 1992. Often referred to as the "L.A. riots" or the "Rodney King riots," the days of civil unrest that left parts of the Los Angeles landscape including Koreatown resembling war zones is recalled in Korean-American narratives as Sa-I-Gu. Methodologically, this case study will sensitize the readers to a different perspective to Ezekiel 40-48 as a visionary quest for bokeumjali while in exile. This is a study about how the migratory process affects where immigrants identify as home and how they think about home.
|
A New (Print and Online) Critical Edition of the Second Column (Secunda) of Origen's Hexapla
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Benjamin Kantor, University of Cambridge
The second column of Origen's Hexapla (Secunda) is a Greek transcription of ancient Biblical Hebrew. Up until the end of the nineteenth century, all that was extant of the Secunda were quotations and references in other works such as the church fathers. At the end of the nineteenth century a palimpsest was discovered which contained portions of eleven Psalms of Origen's Secunda (Ambrosiana O 39 Sup.). The discovery prompted a number of studies on the phonology of the Hebrew tradition reflected in the transcriptions and has been an integral part of historical Hebrew linguistics ever since. The Ambrosiana palimpsest contains approximately 1000 words and the quotations in the church fathers and other sources contain over 200 or 300 words.
Although earlier scholars made use of both the Ambrosiana manuscript and the quotations in the church fathers, later scholars have tended to limit themselves to the material from the more reliable Ambrosiana palimpsest. A desideratum in Secunda studies is a careful analysis of the manuscript traditions behind the quotations of the second column outside of the Ambrosiana manuscript. Additionally, such material has yet to be gathered into one source.
I am currently working on a project to remedy these desiderata, namely, a new critical edition of the text of the second column of Origen's Hexapla, in which I take into account the data from the Ambrosiana palimpsest, the Cambridge palimpsest, quotations from the church fathers, and scholia in the LXX. The edition is being prepared both for print and for online access, both versions complete with critical apparatuses.
In this paper, I will (1) present examples of the print and electronic form of the new edition, (2) outline the nature of the quotations of the second column in LXX scholia and in the early church fathers, and (3) address (both text-critically and linguistically) the reliability of the quotations of the second column outside of the Ambrosiana palimpsest.
Such an edition is especially important for Hebraists and historical Hebrew studies, since it will be the first critical edition that presents all of the quotations of the second column as a continuous text in one place. It will also include a larger index of the second column than has been published to date. Finally, it includes some references to the second column not cited in either Gottingen or Field. All of these points make the new edition especially helpful for the fields of historical Hebrew linguistics and textual criticism of the Hebrew Bible.
|
"For All Its Inhabitants": The Utopian Interpretation of Leviticus 25 in Sifra
Program Unit: Midrash
Jonathan Kaplan, The University of Texas at Austin
The legislation in Leviticus 25 portrays an ideal vision of Israelite society organized around the regular return of leased land to its patrimony in fifty-year jubilee cycles. In this paper, I examine the interpretation of this eutopian legislation in the tannaitic midrashic work Sifra, in the section known as Dibbura de-Sinai. Central to this interpretation of Leviticus 25 is the assertion that the jubilee cannot legitimately be enacted until all twelve Israelite tribes are securely established in their divinely-given allotments in the land of Canaan. Building on critical insights from Utopian Studies, I argue that this declaration is more than a strategy to forestall the possibility of implementing the jubilee legislation. Rather, as I contend, this declaration is a conscious rhetorical strategy meant to locate this vision, to use the language of Lyman Tower Sargent, "in time and space that the author intended a contemporaneous reader to view as considerably better than the society in which that reader lived" ("Three Faces of Utopianism Revisited," 9). Reaching its final form in the third century CE, when the land of Judea was devoid of Jewish population, the text of Sifra constructs a utopian interpretation of Leviticus 25 that demarcates ideal notions of land tenure, kinship relations, and property ownership. This section of Sifra, while generally following the eutopian vision of the original legislation, emphasizes particular aspects of Leviticus that are not the primary focus of the Levitical jubilee legislation. One important example of this recasting of Leviticus 25 is the focus in Sifra on demarcating the nature of kinship relationships and delineating the consequent obligations incumbent upon members of the Israelite people. This and the other interpretive emphases in Sifra transform the Levitical jubilee into a distinctively rabbinic portray of ideal Jewish society located in a time when all Israel would (re-)inhabit the land.
|
"To Proclaim Liberty": The Jubilee Vision of Hope in Isaiah 58 and 61
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Jonathan Kaplan, The University of Texas at Austin
As has been noted by a number of scholars, Isaiah 58:1-7 and 61:1-3 evoke the jubilee legislation found in Leviticus 25. These passages employ language and imagery from the Levitical jubilee both as a foil to castigate the social failings of postexilic Judahite society and as an ideal to engender hope in a future for that community. In this paper, I analyze the interpretive approach of these chapters to the Levitical jubilee in conversation with critical theorists in the field of Utopian Studies such as Lyman Tower Sargent, Ruth Levitas, and others. I argue that the interpretation of the eutopian legislation found in Leviticus 25 constitutes a sincere attempt by the author of these chapters in Isaiah to chart a vision of renewal for Judean society. These chapters consciously avoid, however, the aspects of the legislation that might reinscribe hierarchies that privilege creditors over debtors. Instead, Isaiah 58 and 61 emphasize the renewal of kinship relationships, debt release, and provision for the impoverished in a society unfettered by renewed debtor-creditor relationships. It is this transformation of the Levitical jubilee into a prophetic utopia that inspired subsequent interpretations of it in texts such as 11QMelchitzedek and Luke 4.
|
The Textual History of Ethiopic Ruth: Research Findings and Publication Plans
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Daniel Assefa, Institute for Religious Research
This paper deals with the textual History of Ethiopic Ruth. The research is based on the clusters of Ethiopian manuscripts identified and proposed by the project THEOT (Textual History of Ethiopic Old Testament). Accordingly, through text-critical analysis, the characteristics of the various clusters are studied and the differences are explained. A comparison with the texts of MT and the LXX helps to understand better Ethiopian scribal activities, in terms of the options that have been taken or avoided as far as the earliest attested manuscripts, the standardized texts and the textus receptus are concerned. In parallel with this work on Ethiopic Ruth, other researches are done on the textual histories of Ethiopic Amos, Ethiopic Deuteronomy and Ethiopic Obadiah, including also issues of publishing the results
|
Matthew’s Struggles with Identity as Seen through The Joy Luck Club
Program Unit: Asian and Asian-American Hermeneutics
Julius-Kei Kato, King's Univ. College - Western Univ.
Amy Tan’s 1989 novel The Joy Luck Club (JLC) vividly and touchingly portrays the different dynamics involved in communication (which includes miscommunication and non-communication) between first generation Chinese mothers and their North American-born daughters.
In JLC’s recounting of the different individual stories of four first generation Chinese immigrant mothers and their four Chinese American daughters, we get a good idea of how different are the worlds in which the Chinese-born and the American-born occupy, often resulting in an initial rejection, on the part of the daughters, of their mothers’ Chinese heritages because of their perception that “Chinese ways” are radically different and, therefore, largely irrelevant for their present North American contexts.
However, as the daughters shed uncritical and naïve youthful perspectives and grow into greater maturity (thus, permitting some measure of true communication between them and their mothers), we see in them a gradual shift to a greater valorization and appreciation of their Chinese heritage, resulting eventually in a more balanced attitude in which they can now accept and embrace the fact that their mothers’ culture and traditions have meaningfully shaped them and that the tradition remains deeply valuable and relevant in their lives.
This paper will argue that when we use the JLC as a lens through which we read the Gospel according to Matthew, we can catch a glimpse of similar struggles and a similar process on the part of the gospel writer Matthew (with his community) of grappling with his Jewish identity and heritage.
The gospel on the whole is arguably already a result of a more mature state of reflection on the part of Matthew in which he has already reconciled his Jewish heritage with his new-found faith, rejected by most of his Jewish contemporaries, that Jesus indeed is the long-awaited Messiah (see Mt. 1:1, 16, 18; 2:4), that YHWH has finally sent to Israel. In the gospel, Matthew proclaims this reconciliation of his faith in Jesus-as-Messiah with his Jewish heritage through some conspicuous strategies: peppering his gospel with presentations of Jesus as fulfilling ancient prophecies, stating unambiguously that Jesus has come “not to abolish [the law and the prophets] but to fulfill [them]” (5:17) and structuring his gospel around five clear sections, each consisting of discourse and narrative parts, thus presenting Jesus’s teaching and ministry as the new Torah.
On the other hand, we also see Matthew’s earlier (?) or continuing (?) struggles with his Jewish tradition and how many of his compatriots have and continue to reject his proposal that Jesus is indeed the Messiah. We can catch glimpses of this in several passages: his terrible vitriol against otherwise respected teachers, the Scribes and the Pharisees (23:1-36) and his shocking imputation of guilt for the death of Jesus not only on the Jews of his day but also on “their children” (27:25)!
Amy Tan’s The Joy Luck Club can thus act as a powerful means to see Matthew’s world (behind the text) with fresh eyes.
|
A New State of Affairs: Egyptian Jewish Sources on Ptolemaic and Roman Ta Pragmata (State Affairs)
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
G. Anthony Keddie, University of British Columbia
How did Jews in Egypt perceive the transition from Ptolemaic to Roman sovereignty? While numerous scholars have examined the reactions of Egyptian Jews to Hellenistic or Roman culture, there has been little sustained investigation into the impact of this transition between two different imperial regimes on Jews. This paper seeks to fill this void in scholarship by focusing specifically on conceptions of imperial ta pragmata in Jewish sources from Egypt in the Ptolemaic and Roman periods. The term ta pragmata loosely translates to “empire” or “the affairs” (of the king/dynasty) (Strootman, 2014; 12). In this paper, we demonstrate that the diverse Jewish sources from the Ptolemaic period consistently recognize ta pragmata as being for the benefit of the king’s subjects; however, our best source from the early Roman period, Philo, uses this Hellenistic ideal of kingship to criticize two distinctly Roman institutions in Egypt—the poll-tax and private land—as unjust.
We make our argument in two parts. First, we look at the Ptolemaic era evidence. We contextualize the discussion of Jewish sources by analyzing the literary, documentary, and epigraphic evidence for the Ptolemies’ concept of ta pragmata. The Ptolemaic sources communicate the Hellenistic ideals of personal kingship, in which ta pragmata is tied to philanthropia and taxation is managed by the king’s Friends for the protection of his subjects (Murray 2007). We trace the shifting conceptions of ta pragmata beginning with the Revenue Laws of Philadelphus. The Jewish sources appropriate the full gamut of meanings of ta pragmata. On one end of the spectrum, Pseudo-Hecataeus has the Jews follow Ptolemy I to Egypt to share in his pragmata (Jos., C. Ap. 1:186) and the Letter of Aristeas has Philadelphus proclaim the release of Jewish captives as advantageous to his pragmata (25). On the other, Greek Esther (3:13f, 6; 8:12e) and 3 Maccabees (3:13, 26; 7:1-2) interrogate the limits of ta pragmata through humorous narratives about Friends of the king tricking him into destroying the Jews to benefit his subjects.
In the second half of this paper, we focus on the transition of ta pragmata from Greek to Roman rule. Roman sources such as the Edict of Julius Tiberius Alexander and the Gnomon of the Idios Logos restructure ta pragmata as the domain of the provincial prefect, and are clear that taxes are impositions that increase imperial revenues. This changing political situation explains Philo’s use of the Hellenistic ideal of ta pragmata as a critique of Roman imperial administration. We show, in particular, that Philo identifies the division of ta pragmata (Flacc. 1:133) into private and public and the exaction of “twofold tributes” (Spec. 4:218) as transgressions of justice. Like 3 Maccabees and Greek Esther, Philo illuminates abuses of ta pragmata, but unlike the earlier sources, Philo envisions these abuses as systemic.
Murray, Oswyn. “Philosophy and Monarchy in the Hellenistic World.” Pages 13-28 in Jewish Perspectives on Hellenistic Rulers. Edited by Tessa Rajak et al. Berkeley, 2007.
Strootman, Rolf. Courts and Elites in the Hellenistic Empires. Edinburgh, 2014.
|
Proverbs 21:1 and Ancient Near Eastern Hydrology
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Arthur Keefer, Eton College
The reference to "streams of water" in Prov 21:1 is largely assumed to have a Palestinian agricultural background, and suggestions that the phrase connotes foreign irrigation practices remain undeveloped. I argue that these streams, as artificial irrigation waterways, and their association with kingship in Prov 21:1 connote royal ideologies that were connected with hydrological procedures in Egypt, Mesopotamia, and Urartu. Based on a fresh look at written, iconographic, geographical, and archeological evidence from the wider ancient Near Eastern world, I bring new interpretive insights to Prov 21:1.
|
Qohelet Suffering the Meaning of Life: An Evil and Its Theological Solution in Ecclesiastes
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Arthur Keefer, Eton College
Qohelet Suffering the Meaning of Life: An Evil and Its Theological Solution in Ecclesiastes
|
Spirit Hermeneutics: Reading with Faith
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Craig Keener, Asbury Theological Seminary
Spirit Hermeneutics: Reading with Faith
|
Transformation by Divine Vision in 1 John 3:2-6
Program Unit: Biblical Exegesis from Eastern Orthodox Perspectives
Craig Keener, Asbury Theological Seminary
Vision of Christ transforms the beholder to be like Christ in the past, present, and future in 1 John 3:2-6. The philosophically-minded would have thought of transformative divine vision through beholding the perfect and passionless deity of reason; Jewish mystics and apocalyptists also sought divine vision. Given the relationship between 1 John and the Fourth Gospel, however, transformative vision probably develops Moses's transformation in light of divine glory in Exodus 33-34 (cf. John 1:14-18). Paul earlier developed this same idea in 2 Cor 3:7-18, where believers are transformed through beholding Christ's glory by the Spirit (3:18), in an experience of glory greater than what Moses experienced.
|
Luke-Acts, Biography, and Historiography in Antiquity
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Craig Keener, Asbury Theological Seminary
A majority of scholars accept Richard Burridge’s classification of the Gospels as biographies, and this classification is compelling on the whole. Yet a majority of scholars also view Acts as a historical monograph, and also accept the narrative unity of (although not necessarily the same genre for) Luke-Acts. These considerations invite discussion of the relationship between biography and the wider category of historiography in the early empire, as well as comparison with other biographic units within larger multivolume histories.
|
The Creation of the World in al-Tabari’s "History of Prophets and Kings"
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
Katharina Keim, University of Manchester
Muhammad ibn Jarir al-Tabari’s tenth-century chronicle ‘The History of Prophets and Kings’ contains a range of traditions concerning the history of the world from creation to 915 CE. It begins with a series of discourses relating to the nature of time, before expounding on the process by which the world was created. The text includes a range of traditions that elaborate on the time required for God’s creative acts, the heavenly and earthly objects and persons that were created, and the order in which these came into being. It is in connection with these discourses that Tabari develops a number of theological themes. In this paper, I will concentrate on Tabari’s theological argumentation regarding God’s eternity and agency as sole-creator of the world. Tabari’s position implicitly refutes Jewish and Christian interpretations of Genesis 1:26 (“Let us make humankind in our image”) that identify companions present with God when the world was created. Post-biblical Jewish tradition interprets the plural ‘let us’ as indicating the presence of Torah or the angels, whereas Christianity reads into this space Christ or even the Trinity. How much would Tabari have known about these ideas? And, how does a reading of Tabari develop our understanding of Islamic knowledge of and exegetical engagement with Genesis 1-2 and subsequent Christian and Jewish interpretative tradition?
|
Ritual Action or Military Preparation? Interpreting Israel's Muster at Mizpah in 1 Sam 7
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Kyle H. Keimer, Macquarie University
According to 1 Sam 7:5-6 Samuel told all Israel to gather at Mizpah so he could judge them and intercede with YHWH for Israel. What is portrayed as a ritual event is interpreted by the Philistines in 7:7 as strategic military action. This paper offers an explanation for the Philistine response to Israel's actions through consideration of the geographic reality of the Central Benjamin Plateau. In particular, I will address what it is about Mizpah, specifically, that prompts the Philistines to mobilize against Israel, and whether or not the identification of Tell en-Nasbeh as biblical Mizpah is appropriate. This latter matter will be informed by my work on the unpublished Iron Age I materials from Tell en-Nasbeh.
|
Genocide as an Extreme Response to Hegemonic Anxiety
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
Shawn Kelley, Daemen College
Recent trends in comparative genocide research can provide one theoretical lens for investigating the category of Hegemonic anxieties. Genocide scholarship has struggled with the question of why some deep-rooted conflicts turn genocidal while many do not. The scholar Scott Strauss proposes that the economic, social, racial and political preconditions commonly identified can only take us so far in understanding genocide. For Strauss, beyond these preconditions, what is required is “the domination-vulnerability paradox”. Genocide occurs, according to Scott, where a regime is paradoxically powerful enough to carry out mass violence but where it also sees itself as rendered uniquely vulnerable by the actions and existence of one specific group of people. This group, which will be the victim of the genocidal violence, is perceived as threatening to bring about the destruction of the dominant group. Genocide erupts when the dominant or hegemonic group perceives itself to be simultaneously destined to greatness and, because of one obstinate group, facing existential threat. Genocide is perceived by the hegemonic group as a rational response to this unbearable paradox. This paper will begin by introducing and explaining the category of domination-vulnerability paradox, with a few prominent, recent examples. For the remainder of the paper I will argue that, contrary to the consensus in the field of genocide studies, a properly modified version of the domination-vulnerability paradox can shed light on exterminatory-genocidal practices in antiquity. My focus will be on the Roman destruction of Jerusalem (70 CE), with particular attention to the murderous actions rather than the theological and historical-critical consequences. I will demonstrate that, despite its military dominance, Rome had three sets of reasons to perceive the Judean revolt as an existential threat that had to be met with exterminatory violence: (i) Roman occupation was premised on a broad range of imperial and moral values (see Susan Mattern) where provincial refusal to accept Roman superiority challenged the entire system of Roman rule. (ii) The bloody final years of Nero’s regime left high ranking Roman leaders (like Vespasian) vulnerable to execution while the ensuing civil war left the impression of an empire in danger of collapsing, suggesting that revolts would be both more common (i.e. in Britain and the border of Parthia) and would be perceived as more damaging. (iii) The practice of siege war, with clearly defined rules of engagement and ensuing plunder and violence, included within it a series of rituals of humiliation of the conquered. Deprived of these rituals, the solders tended to respond with exterminatory violence against the city or, if deprived of that, against their general. Roman values, combined with siege warfare, produced expectations of how the Judean revolt should have ended. When that ending did not materialize, Titus and his soldiers chose exterminatory violence rather than accepting the limitations of Roman power.
|
The Challenges and Benefits of Teaching Genocide Studies
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Shawn Kelley, Daemen College
I want to use my time talking about how this Synoptics scholar came to teach a course well outside my areas of expertise (i.e. Comparative Genocide Studies) and about the unexpected ways that this course came to influence my scholarship. In the course of today’s conversation, I will focus on three topics how the course came about and the challenges and opportunities it faces. While I would very much like to be able to say that I had a master plan to teach about and eventually write about Genocide Studies, my path to this course was more circuitous. Early on my teaching career I taught a course on the Holocaust, which proved to be essential for my developing scholarly interest in modernity, racism and biblical scholarship. I also happened to occasionally teach courses in the prison system and made the imprudent decision to teach the Holocaust course in a maximum security prison. Teaching this class in this environment raised a whole series of issues and questions that continue to haunt me and are worth further discussion, including questions about white scholars discussing racial issues and about volatile classroom situations provoked by traumatizing material. Dissatisfied with the way the course proceeded, I kept revising the course until I eventually began comparing different kind of racialized traumatic experiences and grouped them under the category of genocide. This course was first developed and taught in the mid 90s, at the moment that Rwanda was occurring and that the field of comparative genocide studies was emerging as an academic discipline. A seed had been planted and many years later I returned to developing a new class informed by the new academic discipline (sample syllabus will be provided). What started as a way of giving a catchy title to a course that compared narratives written by slaves and holocaust survivors was slowly morphing into a class that caused me to cover an increasingly broad range of genocides (Indigenous peoples, Cambodia, Rwanda) and of theoretical issues (i.e. definitional, theories on perpetrators, connection to the modern rationality and the nation state, etc.). Several practical challenges present themselves, not least of which was the diverse connection between genocides and the Bible as well as the practical problem of working in an exploding scholarly field (annotated bibliography will be provided). As I began reading more intensively in the field, which was becoming increasingly rich and theoretically sophisticated, I became convinced that the field had much to offer biblical scholarship. My first foray into the field, recently published, identified the central theoretical and definitional issues. I am currently exploring the question of whether categories drawn from genocide studies can be accurately applied to antiquity, with special attention to the destruction of Jerusalem (70 CE). What started as a happy teaching accident has challenged me to think more deeply about the human, rather than the theological, costs of Rome’s destruction of Jerusalem.
|
Dangerous Alliances and Judahite Identity? A Proposal for the Amorites’ Function in Ezekiel 16
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Joel Kemp, University of Scranton
Ezek 16:3 and 16:45 associate Jerusalem’s origins with the Amorites. Although most scholars agree that the authors of Ezekiel did not have direct contact with the historical Amorites, a similar consensus does not exist about why they appear in Ezekiel 16. In this paper, I argue that the biblical descriptions of the legal standing of the Amorites’ relationship to Israel and Judah informs the authors’ choice to include them in this chapter. Specifically, I contend that the designation of Amorites as legal outsiders to the Judahite community is critical for how Ezekiel 16 portrays two aspects of the relationship between Judah and its deity. First, Ezekiel 16 asserts that Jerusalem’s initial legal relationship to YHWH, like the Amorites, was non-existent and thus Jerusalem neither could nor should expect to receive the benefits of a covenant with the deity. Second, this lack of legal standing contributes to this chapter’s attempt to justify the severe punishment Jerusalem received in these verses. Finally, I argue that these biblical and additional historical descriptions of Amorites, which the authors of Ezekiel 16 may have received, provided useful material for re-articulating Judahite identity under Neo-Babylonian hegemony.
|
“Thus a Teacher Must Be”: Pedagogical Formation in John Chrysostom’s Homilies on 1 and 2 Timothy
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Meira Z. Kensky, Coe College
How does one convert a populace? Though Arthur Darby Nock paints a fairly rosy picture of the way Christianity took hold in the hearts and minds of Greeks and Romans in the early centuries of the common era, he does acknowledge the fluidity of the situation. Framing the issue as the power of paganism, Nock’s chapter “The Last Phase” acknowledges the tendency of individuals to fade away from the faith once the “first fine careless rapture” lost its hold on individuals’ attention. Mentioning in passing the “ever-present loss of social amenities, club life, and festivals” that conversion entailed, Nock keenly notes that “It was a question not only of resisting social pressure and occasional persecution but of holding out against boredom, a state as well known in antiquity as to-day.” Even after Constantine threw the power of the state behind the Christian movement these issues were acutely felt. How did individual teachers confront these issues and try to convert the hearts and minds of regular people engaged in all aspects of city life?
One such major figure in the battle to Christianize an urban population was John Chrysostom, who faced these issues daily in his career in Antioch. In addition to railing against the theatre and other entertainments, Chrysostom undertook a pedagogical strategy of turning his auditors into teachers, giving them active roles in the ongoing project of Christianization of fourth-century Antioch (and perhaps staving off their own boredom along the way). According to David Rylersdaam, “Chrysostom is training students to become ascetic teachers in their everyday lives. All Christians had a pedagogical task in the world, not simply bishops and monks. Making use of their instruction in the school of the church, Christians were to model and teach a thoroughly Christian version of the classical philosophical life in their homes and throughout the city.” Rylersdaam points to a particularly telling passage in Chrysostom’s Homilies on the Statues, where Chrysostom implores his audience “You must be teachers and lead the way. Friends should take their neighbors in hand and instruct and lead them, and household slaves should do the same for fellow slaves, and youths for their peers” (De Stat. 16.6). John Chrysostom’s homilies on 1 and 2 Timothy play an important part in his pedagogical program of turning his auditors into teachers. Since Chrysostom understands Paul’s task in 1 Timothy as instructing Timothy on what is required of a teacher, his exegesis of this epistle becomes an opportunity for him to expound on this office, on what it takes to fulfill this task, and to attempt to form his audience into the type of teachers he hopes they will be in their everyday lives.
|
Bias in the Contact Zone: Artifacts, Provenance, the Museum of the Bible, and Public Trust
Program Unit: Metacriticism of Biblical Scholarship
Morag M. Kersel, DePaul University
In 1991, Pratt defined a museum contact zone as the social space where cultures meet, clash, and grapple with each other, often in the context of asymmetrical power relations buttressed by the legacies of colonialism and imperialism. By placing items on display, museums take on multiple roles, as custodians, shapers of public interpretation, fiduciary institutions, educational establishments, and mediators of the contact zone. The public counts on the museum to act legally and ethically, and to be responsible and transparent in the presentation of the past – they place their trust in the organization. A museum’s unwillingness to address knotty issues of provenance, documentation, and archaeological site destruction caused by looting, results in a distorted display and interpretation of the material record and injustice in the contact zone. Ostensibly innocent exhibitions are often embroiled in backstories of which the public is frequently unaware. The Dead Sea Scrolls exhibit at the Museum of the Bible provides a significant case study in curatorial decision-making, untold stories, and the public trust. Selecting particular things for public display and choosing to tell only certain aspects of the artifact’s biography results in a biased contact zone at the Museum of the Bible. As stewards of material culture it is the Museum’s responsibility to acknowledge and address these biases.
|
The Character of Joseph in the Book of Jubilees: Why Fix What’s Not Broken?
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Joseph S. Khalil, University of Notre Dame
In Jubilees, Joseph is even more commendable than he is in Genesis, which is startling because, at first, the portrayal does not seem to aid Jubilees’ agenda, which is to emphasize the centrality of the Sinai covenant to Israelite life and identity, as well as God’s faithfulness to the covenant people. Firstly, how does Jubilees’ author re-characterize Joseph, and secondly how does the adjusted portrayal advance Jubilees’ pedagogical purposes?
Specific elements of the Joseph story are absent from Jubilees, such as the famous notice about Jacob’s preference for him: “Now Israel loved Joseph more than any other of his children, because he was the son of his old age; and he had made him a long robe with sleeves” (Gen 37:3). Also absent from Jubilees is the account of Joseph recounting to his siblings the two dreams in which he appears superior to them. In the first dream, Joseph and his brothers are binding sheaves, and their sheaves bow down to his sheaf (Gen 37-6-7). In the second, the sun, the moon and eleven stars bow down to Joseph (Gen 37:9). The omissions are curious, because in Genesis they explain why Joseph’s siblings resented Joseph and decided to kill him.
Did Jubilees’ author want to avoid the impression that Joseph was superior to his brothers? Actually, in Jubilees’ narrative, Joseph is nobler than his siblings who, after all, conspired to kill him. In fact, in his narrative, Jubilees’ author noted that Jacob received the news of Joseph’s loss on the tenth of the seventh month, which became the Day of Atonement, i.e., Yom Kippur, an annual day of mourning for all Israel, because Jacob’s sons “had saddened their father’s (feelings of) affection for […] Joseph” (Jub 34:18).
Why did Jubilees’ author polish Joseph’s character and elevate his importance even more?
It had to do with Joseph’s association with the northern kingdom. An often-ignored aim of Jubilees’ author was to honor the northern tribes who were thought to have perished following the Assyrian exile on account of their disobedience to the covenant. Jubilees’ author worried that the perception that the northern tribes were lost because of disobedience to the Law would suggest that God’s covenant with Israel was a revocable bond. Even worse, it may suggest that God reneged on his covenant promises to Jacob.
For Jubilees, God’s covenant with Jacob was not revocable, because if it were, it would call into question the veracity of the promise God made to Jacob at Bethel: “the land on which you lie I will give to you and to your offspring […] I am with you and will keep you wherever you go, and will bring you back to this land; for I will not leave you until I have done what I have promised you” (Gen 28:13-15).
|
Orthoepy in the Tiberian Reading Tradition of the Hebrew Bible and Its Historical Roots in the Second Temple Period
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Geoffrey Khan, University of Cambridge
For joint session of the Masorah and the Biblical Hebrew & Linguistics panels.
The Tiberian reading tradition of the Hebrew Bible contains a variety of features that point to its origin in the Second Temple period. Once such feature is the careful reading of the inflected forms of the verbs hāyā and ḥāyā to ensure that they are not confused. The paper directs particular attention to the lengthening of the vowels of the prefix conjugation (imperfect) of these verbs, which can be reconstructed from medieval sources. In particular the Karaite transcriptions of the Tiberian tradition into Arabic script indicates that the ḥireq vowel of prefixes followed by a closed syllable, e.g. in forms such as yihyɛ and yiḥyɛ, were regularly pronounced long, i.e. [yiːhyɛː] and [yiːḥyɛː]. It is argued through comparison with the Babylonian tradition of Biblical Hebrew that this lengthening is an orthoepic feature that has its roots in the Second Temple Period. The essence of the argument is as follows. The Tiberian and the Babylonian traditions of reading are two branches of an authoritative ‘proto-Masoretic’ reading tradition that split after the end of the Second Temple Period. The comparative method of historical linguistics can be applied to the Tiberian and Babylonian tarditions in order to reconstruction details of the proto-Masoretic reading. In the Babylonian vocalization tradition initial heh and initial ḥeth verbs generally have ḥireq in the prefixes, as is the case with strong verbs with non-guttural first radicals. The Babylonian pattern of vocalism is likely to be the original one in the proto-Masoretic reading. In the Tiberian tradition the vowel of such prefixes were in general lowered to lower vowel qualities. During the Second Temple Period, when the guttural consonants were vulnerable to weakening, the /i/ vowel of the prefix of the verbs יִהְיֶה and יִחְיֶה were lengthened as an orthoepic measure to slow down the reading and thus prevent the gutturals from being elided, which, crucially, would have resulted in the confusion of these two frequently occurring verbs. Since the /i/ vowel was lengthened and this orthoepic lengthening was transmitted after the Second Temple Period, the vowel of the prefixes of these verbs did not undergo vowel-lowering in the Tiberian tradition at a later period after the Tiberian and Babylonian branches of the proto-Masoretic reading had divided, but rather preserved their original quality. The tracing of this orthoepic feature to the proto-Masoretic reading has important implications for our understanding of the status of oral reading traditions in the Second Temple Period. It demonstrates that the priestly authorities who were concerned with the careful preservation of the written text were also concerned with the careful preservation of the orally transmitted reading tradition.
|
Thetic Constructions in Biblical Hebrew
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Geoffrey Khan, University of Cambridge
An important difference in the conceptualization of states of affairs is reflected in language by the distinction between thetic sentences and categorical sentences. A categorical sentence consists of the bipartite act of naming an entity and the making of a statement about it. Thetic sentences, by contrast, present a situation as an undivided whole. Thetic sentences are typically used to manage discourse, e.g., to present settings of discourse or explanations. In this paper I argue that the thetic-categorical distinction is reflected in Biblical Hebrew by the different syntactic positions of the pronominal copula in nominal clauses. Nominal sentences that place the copula after the predicate are in principle categorical, making direct assertions about a base of predication, e.g., habbāśār ha-ḥay ṭāmē hū ‘Raw flesh is unclean’ (Lev. 13:15). In such constructions the pronominal copula is bound prosodically to the preceding predicate phrase by a conjunctive accent when the predicate phrase is short. In a number of constructions a pronominal copula occurs after a clause-initial pronoun, e.g., ʾattā-hū malkī (Psa. 44:5). In many such constructions the phrase following the pronoun is informative, as in the example just given, and is not a presuppostional component of a contrastive focus construction, i.e., (informative elements marked by upper case): ‘You are MY KING’ not ‘YOU are my king’. I argue that in such constructions the pronoun has the status of a focus marker that has developed from the pattern of bi-clausal cleft constructions. Parallels to this grammaticalization pathway can be identified in other languages. It does not mark contrastive focus, but rather presentational focus. Although the phrase following the pronoun is informative, the assertion of the content of the phrase is demoted, just as is the content of the subordinate clause in a cleft construction. The effect is to express a thetic description of an integral situation, rather than a categorical statement making a direct assertion about a topical referent. These thetic constructions with focus-marker pronouns typically express settings for what follows, either stative or eventive, explanations, or existential statements. It is argued that the phrase ʾănī-hū, which occurs in the Song of Moses and Deutero-Isaiah, belongs to this category of construction and should be interpreted as an existential statement ‘I am’. It is a thetic construction with a focus marker and null lexical content after the pronoun ‘It is I (that am)’. Supporting evidence for this and the interpretation of other thetic constructions in Biblical Hebrew is adduced from Neo-Semitic spoken languages.
|
Re/producing Women: Queer Afro-Marxist Con(tra)ceptions of Womanhood and Maternity in Genesis 2:4–4:2
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Minenhle Nomalungelo Khumalo, Drew University
Women and mothers of African descent frequently face global, socio-economic, political, sex/gender systems that reduce their labour to the work of the womb and undervalue their production both inside and outside the confines of familial/domestic spheres. The Hebrew bible and its interpreters have contributed to the patriarchal idealization and regulation of traditional womanhood and maternity. In light of this, the paper proposed here attempts to re/produce a con(tra)ception of Africana sex/gender identities through a Queer, Afro-Marxist re-reading of Genesis 2:4 - 4:2. That is, the proposed paper will take on a biblical hermeneutic that reads from/through woman-idenitified and maternal-idenitified bodies in order to reconceptualize valuations of re/productive activity in a manner that begins to redress exploitations, oppressions, and appropriations of the socio-economic, affective labour of women and maternity. A Queer, Afro-Marxist re-reading of the so-called “fall of man” will challenge understandings of womanhood that uphold notions of femininity that obligate female-to-mother reproductive transformations. It will challenge patriarchal (de)selections of womanhood in the biblical text that privilege phallogocentric, normative desires for figural representations of the right mothers, birthing the right children, who perform patriarchy better than the patriarchs do. Applying this reading strategy to the story of the woman, the snake, and the fruits of their re/productions, this proposed paper will also assert that the socio-economic, affective re/production of Africana sex/gender identity in the present is imperative for the successful production of just, diverse, futures for people of African descent.
|
Fasting, Bodily Care, and the Widows of 1 Timothy 5:3–15
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Lyn Kidson, Macquarie University
Abraham Malherbe in his essay, “Medical Imagery in the Pastoral Epistles,” argued that medical terminology was used polemically to describe the heretics or opponents. In relation to 1 Timothy, the opponent’s teaching is described as “diseased” and their minds “are corrupt…[and the opponent’s] diseased condition is exhibited in their demeanor, in their preoccupation with controversies, verbal battles, and wranglings (1 Tim 6:4–5).” In this paper Malherbe’s identification of this medical schema is the starting point to explore the connections between the opponents commands not to marry and abstain from foods (1 Tim 4: 2-3) with the instruction to younger widows to marry in 1 Timothy 5: 3–15. This exploration will begin by first noting some structural elements in the letter, then will define the word didaskalia (1 Tim 4:1) to be clear on what type of teaching the opponents are doing and how this might sear their consciences. It is this searing which enables them to abandon the faith and pay attention to spirits and demons. The imagery of the seared conscience appears to be medically inspired and this suggests a link between the “other instruction” (didaskalia), fasting, sexual continence, and ancient medical advice about care for the body. Ancient medical advice on health focused on balancing the humors within the body. The excess of some humors was believed to be the underlying cause of sexual desire. Expelling the excess sperm, a humor, was seen to bring the body back into balance, restoring health. However, since the humors were generated by nutrition it was possible to a certain extent to regulate sexual desire through diet. From the evidence of Tertullian it appears that Christians utilised this theory in an attempt to balance the humors and therefore remain healthy while being sexually continent. It will therefore be argued that the command of the opponents, which forbid marriage and fasting, relates directly to the instructions to the young widows to marry in 1 Timothy 5:3-15. Drawing on the work of Methuen (1997), who argued that the term widow (chera) could overlap with the idea of an unmarried women, it will be argued that the young woman in 1 Timothy 5:11 is a virgin rather than a woman whose husband had died. Founding his instructions on the current medical advice, the writer of 1 Timothy is pessimistic about young women keeping their vows of celibacy (1 Tim 5:12) and is thus opposed to the them entering into the order of widows (1 Tim 5:11).
|
Stoned: Biblical Ecology of the Seemingly Inanimate
Program Unit: Student Advisory Board
Micah D. Kiel , Saint Ambrose University
A few years ago I read a book by Jeffrey Cohen called "Stone: An Ecology of the Inhuman." This got my mind racing about all of the different ways stone is featured in the biblical literature. It is used as a metaphor and as building material. Stone can be positive (God is my rock in Psalm 18) or a symbol of judgment (as in the millstone in Revelation 18). The stony path chokes the seed in the parable of the sower, but the church (according to Matthew) is built on a rock. I have recently done a lot of work on the Bible and ecology, presenting several papers on the topic in the Ecological Hermeneutics Section of SBL and recently publishing a book of Revelation and Ecology. I am terrified, however, to try to find a way to talk about ecological concerns in the biblical literature by looking at rocks! But, a brief exploration such as this could stimulate my thinking, and help me get some really helpful feedback about how I could approach such a topic.
|
God's Promises of Preservation to Baruch and Those like Him: A Case of 2 Baruch's Innovative Reapplication of Scripture
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Jordash Kiffiak, University of Zurich
Why does God in 2 Baruch promise to preserve the righteous so prominently and in such rich and varied ways? As with God's prophecy to Baruch through the prophet Jeremiah in Jer 45.5, the opening of our text has God predicting that Baruch, also those like him, will be preserved during the imminent capture of Jerusalem by the Babylonians. This basic idea of preservation, I argue, is expanded upon later in multiple ways, imbued with an eschatological sense, both for Baruch as an individual and for the righteous within the people of Israel as a group. Through detailed linguistic, also literary, analysis, this paper investigates the three ways that the promise is creatively reapplied. (a) Baruch will be preserved to the current age's end, serving as a witness against the wicked Gentile nations. (b) The Torah-observant within Israel will be preserved during the period of eschatological woes. (c) The souls of the righteous, unlike those of the wicked, will be preserved in treasuries until the day of the resurrection; and the righteous alone are resurrected, with bodies that thereafter will never decay.
Reapplication does not mean interpretation. Frederick James Murphy has observed that a key, innovative move of the author of our text is marrying the Deuteronomistic concept of sin, punishment, repentance and restoration with the eschatological concept of the two ages/worlds. It is possible that, in a comparable move, the author takes the concept of Baruch's preservation in the personal prophecy to him in Jer 45 and extends it into the eschaton, through soul-preservation in treasuries and then resurrection, for all the righteous who suffer in the vicissitudes of this age. Such appropriation and reapplication of themes from scriptural texts is an approach commonly adopted by the author of 2 Baruch, as Matthias Henze has observed. What results is a tantalizing possibility. Has the author of our text appropriated the promise of preservation of life in order to present a picture that is for all practical purposes the inversion of the promise given in the book of Jeremiah? There God reprimands the scribe for seeking great things, offering him as his only solace a prediction, ironically worded, that he will at least keep his own life as "booty" in the coming destruction. The scintillating promises in 2 Baruch, by contrast, outshine their model in every respect. While Baruch and those like him may suffer a little in this world, they will also be protected here - when things really make a turn for the worst - and in the age to come they will inherit an incorruptible and glorious life, with even the memory of the suffering they endured being blotted out.
Finally, the paper investigates the extent to which the promise Baruch receives in Jer 45 may have made this figure a particularly enticing one for the author's selection of him as the pseudonymous character in 2 Baruch, even when - or perhaps especially when - some central themes are inverted in the transition from prophetic text to apocalypse.
|
Sinai, the Tabernacle, and the Central Sanctuary: The Priestly Character of Exod 20:24–26 and Its Reception in Deut 12
Program Unit: Book of Deuteronomy
Benjamin Kilchör, Staatsunabhängige Theologische Hochschule Basel
Traditionally, Exod 20:24–26 is interpreted as introduction to the Covenant Code. In this paper I suggest to read it not as part of the Covenant Code, which is introduced by the introductory formula in Exod 21:1, but as part of the Sinai narrative, whereby Moses is instructed to build the covenant altar, what he then realizes in 24:4. Intra-textual connections link the so called „altar law“ to the priestly concept of Mt Sinai as sanctuary and the Tabernacle as its transportable counterpart. Such an interpretation also puts another complexion on the relationship between Exod 20:24–26 and Deut 12.
|
Phoenician Akko during the Persian Period in Light of Recent Excavations
Program Unit: Literature and History of the Persian Period
Ann E. Killebrew, Pennsylvania State University
The 22-hectare maritime harbor settlement of Tel Akko has dominated the Plain of Akko’s ancient landscape for millennia. First inhabited in the Early Bronze Age, Tel Akko served as a major urban center for most of the second and first millennia BCE. Current excavations of the Tel Akko Total Archaeology Project, directed by A.E. Killebrew and M. Artzy under the auspices of the University of Haifa and the Pennsylvania State University, focus on the Persian period (6th – 4th centuries BCE) Phoenician city in Area A at the summit of the tell. Here huge quantities of iron slag and remnants of iron working spanning the 6th – 4th centuries BCE have been uncovered. This mid-first millennium smithy, the only known iron working facility in the Levant dating to the Persian period, provides an unparalleled opportunity to explore iron production at a Phoenician maritime center. This paper presents the preliminary results of eight seasons of excavation at Tel Akko of this large-scale iron industrial area, including sources of iron ore, modes of production and remains of possible ritual practices. The significance of iron production at Tel Akko is contextualized in its Phoenician cultural milieu and its role within the Persian empire.
|
“Golden Cables” Stretching from America to Wales: Katharine Bushnell’s God’s Word to Women in Jessie Penn-Lewis’s “Magna Charta”
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Brittany Kim, Roberts Wesleyan College
A prominent speaker and writer associated with the Keswick convention and Welsh revival, Jessie Penn-Lewis (1861–1927) regularly preached to large audiences of Christian workers, conveying a crucicentric message about the power of dying and being raised with Christ. Even though her teaching sparked spiritual renewal for multitudes of men and women, she was sometimes prevented from speaking to mixed audiences because of her gender. As Penn-Lewis saw it, misinterpretations of three Pauline passages (1 Cor 11:2–16; 14:34–35; and 1 Tim 2:8–15) prevented her and scores of other women from fulfilling their divinely ordained roles within the body of Christ—to the detriment of the whole body. Moreover, they conflicted with the biblical truth that Jesus had broken down the distinction between male and female on the cross, making both men and women new creations who partake of the divine nature. Therefore, seeing the hand of God at work in the cultural revolution that brought about the liberation of women after the Great War, Penn-Lewis believed that the time had come for a similar revolution within the church. For many years she collected various writings about the biblical perspective on women, but it was primarily in Katharine Bushnell’s careful exegetical work in God’s Word to Women that she found the key to addressing this difficult issue. In The “Magna Charta” of Women, Penn-Lewis popularized Bushnell’s work, seeking to emancipate women from the chains of flawed exegesis so that they could pursue the leading of the Holy Spirit without hindrance.
|
Transgenerational Transmission of Trauma in the Book of Psalms
Program Unit: Prayer in Antiquity
Chwi-Woon Kim, Baylor University
Scholars have recognized ancient Israel’s cultic use of biblical psalms based on their organizational principles that parallel those of the ancient Mesopotamian prayer collections (Gerald Wilson; Joel Burnett). Particularly, both the Nineveh Catalogue and the Elohistic Psalter commonly evince the process of transmitting individual psalms into collections and therefore suggest later generations’ continual engagement with their ancestors’ laments. This shared tendency raises a question of what underlying motif persists behind the cultic use of ancestors’ prayers. Psychoanalyst Vamik Volkan’s theory of transgenerational transmission of trauma provides a hermeneutical lens for explaining an underlying motif. According to Volkan, when victims of trauma do not have a chance to fully grieve their losses, they pass on a part of their wounded selves and the tasks of unfinished grief to subsequent generations. The unfinished psychological tasks of previous generations appear in present generations in the form of what Volkan calls “linking object or phenomenon.” The linking object or phenomenon serves as a point of connection between past and present generations’ process of mourning. Volkan’s theory illumines the parallel motif of transgenerational transmission of trauma in the Mesopotamian cultic laments, particularly, the balag-laments and the biblical psalms that exhibit Israel’s national calamities. In the balag-laments, the literary unit of pacifying the heart of raging deities (“the heart pacification unit”) serves as the central part of the balag-laments in the cultic context that aims to prevent a nation’s potential destruction (Mark Cohen and Uri Gabbay). This central unit continued to appear in the transmission of the balag-laments from the Old Babylonian period to the first millennium BCE (most notably in the Nineveh Catalogue). From the perspective of Volkan’s theory, I suggest that the cultic practice of pacifying divine wrath across generations may function as a “linking phenomenon,” through which later generations of the balag-laments recalled an older disaster and remembered the ancestors who recited the same types of lament. Building on this evidence, this study examines a parallel phenomenon between biblical laments belonging to the Elohistic Psalter and the balag-laments in terms of their cardinal theme of pacifying divine wrath. To this end, I first point out that the biblical psalms expressing Israel’s national disaster, i.e., Pss 44; 60; 74; 79; 80; 83; 89, most frequently appear in the Elohistic Psalter. I then lay out evidence from the aforementioned psalms that include the language of appeasing raging deities found in 60:3; 74:1; 79:5; 80:5; 89:39 in its close relationship to the expression of divine rejection appearing in 44:10, 24; 60:3, 12; 74:1; 89:39, as well as the idea of uncertain duration of divine wrath found in 74:1; 79:5; 80:5; 89:47. I argue that the high concentration of linguistic and thematic references regarding divine wrath in the Elohistic Psalter suggests a continued cultic practice of pacifying divine wrath over generations. This survey concludes that the ancient practice of placating divine wrath and remembering national tragedies embodies the enduring impact of older generations’ trauma on a cultic community of later generations.
|
Re-remembering Zion: Intertextual Rhetoric of Ap Zion as Theological Subversion
Program Unit: Intertextuality and the Hebrew Bible
Hyun Woo Kim, Emory University
With the scripturalization of the Hebrew Bible in the Second Temple Period, the Dead Sea Scrolls demonstrate dense intertextual tendencies referring to the Hebrew texts. In particular, this intertextual/borrowing and reworking of the Scripture occurs in three representative loci: traditio-historical recapitulation (i.e., historiographies in some historical psalms), textual references (i.e., homiletic expansion of the priestly blessing), and metaphorical allusions (i.e., water imagery as the liturgical bathing/cleansing or chaotic/creative entity).
The Apostrophe to Zion (Ap Zion, 11QPS XXII:1-15) is not an exception. Likewise, major scholarly attention to this poem focuses on its literary contacts with the canonical books especially the Third Isaiah and less frequently the Psalms. Based on these representative intertextual loci, scholars seem to agree upon that the psalm expresses the fundamental Jewish loyalty to the holy city in a liturgical form.
Yet, some possible rhetorical functions of its intertextuality have not been explored or discussed much. So, this research will primarily attempt to broaden its intertextual locus. By attending to philological affinities among Zion psalms, this paper will suggest some alternative intent(s) of these intertextual engagements. By focusing on the deliberate word choice that subverts the very nature of each word used to describe Zion in Lamentations, this research will critically re-evaluate the intertextuality of Ap Zion as a theological subversion to the implied audience’s traumatic cultural memories of Zion.
|
The Voice of the Voiceless: Reading Luke 1:46–55 as Genealogy
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Elizabeth Min Hee Kim, The University of Sydney
Within patriarchal hermeneutics of Marian teaching based on essentialist notions of women, it appears that the Magnificat in Luke 1:46-55 has not been taken seriously enough in the past to account for its complex, multi-functional, counter-cultural and counter-political aspect of the text. Contrary to a spiritualized view of the text, it functions as a lens through which a contemporary audience can see into the wider Lucan genealogy in the Lucan community’s struggle to survive as a group of religious people in a controversial time of persecution and oppression by the Roman Empire and ultimately the contains practical implications. With this in mind, the paper presents a prophetic-critical reading of the Magnificat (Luke 1:46-55), which explores the complexity of the first century Lucan world in relation to the careful use of various literary strategies employed by the implied author. First, it starts by suggesting a possible Jewish propaganda, only to conclude that there appears to be a Lucan rhetoric that uses ambiguity of addressing both Jewish and Hellenistic audience for a greater purpose of world-wide evangelism that includes practical means of helping the poor.
|
Ezekiel's Hope in the Burial Labor of the Gog Multitude: Intertextual Re-reading of Ezekiel 39 with Deuteronomy 13:12–18
Program Unit: Intertextuality and the Hebrew Bible
Soo J. Kim, America Evangelical University
There will be the City Hamonah, the graves of the multitudes of your enemies. YHWH will bring all your enemies to your own land where you now dwell in peace from the exile and kill them all before your eyes. This is the invasion account of Gog of Magog in Ezekiel 38-39 which produces numerous speculative interpretations. My curiosity goes to the location of the place and the aftermath of the battle as well as its theological contexts in the book of Ezekiel. Why in the land of Israel? What would the newly returning people expect when they bury the corpses and burn the weapons? Is it just a great visible performance of the victory? Is there any ritualistic dimension in this account? How shall we understand the literary and theological context of this account, which is between chapters 36-37 and chapters 40-48? Keeping the distance from many eschatological interpretations, Margaret Odell once read this account with the literary and theological perspectives. By identifying the location of City Hamonah with Jerusalem, she emphasizes the transformational characteristic of the city and the city dwellers who obeyed YHWH’s command to clean the land with fire for seven years. According to her, Jerusalem gets a new chance to revive by experiencing that war in City Hamonah/Jerusalem. My proposal goes one step further from Odell’s analysis, asking the theological motive of such scenario in the book of Ezekiel. The second time defilement of the already defiled place/thing to make them acceptable to YHWH is very obvious and no need to discuss further. However, for the full understanding of the plot development of a series of action in Ezekiel 39, I suggest the intertextual reading with Deuteronomy 13:12-18, in which YHWH commands a total destruction of one’s own city in Israel. Compared to the best known Herem theology in Deut 7 as the application to the enemies and their lands, the Herem commands to Israel’s own people and town in Deut 13 are relatively less cited. With this intertextual reading, I would argue that Ezekiel diagnoses Jerusalem as the already haunted and ruined town due to her idolatry. Therefore, the total destruction of all people and their cattle is the only possible solution for that city. According to Deuteronomy 13:12-18, the labor of burial of the corpses and burning all spoils in the open square in Ezekiel 39 is none but the purifying action and the whole burnt offering to YHWH. After that, what does Ezekiel expect? What is his hope? As shown in Duet 13:17-18, YHWH will finally turn from his fierceness and show his mercy and make the exiles multiply again. With the fact that the City shall not be built again, a new city, YHWH Shammah, not named Jerusalem, will be built in the same spot.
|
The Meaning of na‘ar: A Semantic Approach
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Yoo-Ki Kim, Seoul Women's University
The Hebrew word na‘ar has traditionally been understood in terms of ‘youthfulness’. Recently, however, scholars have focused on the social position of its referent, taking it as designating a social status rather than age. Therefore, the basic meaning of na‘ar has been variously defined as ‘a servant’, ‘an aristocratic youth’, ‘a dependent without his father’s protection’, etc. In this type of study, the meaning of the word is determined through a close reading of the context in which it is used. Though the context offers valuable information regarding the meaning of the word, the semantics of a word cannot be decided mainly by the content of the contextual information. This is due in part to the fact that the characters of the stories who are referred to as na‘ar are extremely diverse in their social standing. In some cases, the word seems to have almost the same meaning as ‘ebed ‘slave, servant’ or yeled ‘child’. In fact, na‘ar sometimes appears side-by-side with or replaces these words. However, an examination of pertinent biblical passages shows that na‘ar cannot simply be taken as a synonym of either ‘ebed or yeled. Each of them shows different distribution in morphological combination with a definite article, a pronominal suffix, or a modifying noun phrase. In addition, each of them has its own syntagmatic relations with other constituents in the clause as well as paradigmatic relations with respective antonyms and words otherwise related to it. The lexeme ‘ebed, basically a word that expresses dependency or subservience, is often used in combination with the second-person pronoun to refer to the speaker as a show of deference for the addressee, while yeled often refers to a very young child, with an emphasis on the parent-child relationship. Na‘ar is an inclusive term that signifies youthfulness as it has traditionally been perceived, though the range of ages of the referent is much broader than that of ‘a child’ or ‘a boy’. Sometimes na‘ar occupies slots where ‘ebed is appropriate. In fact, a word that refers to young people may come to refer to a person of low status in its historical development. Notably, however, na‘ar is restricted to the servant who is not old enough to be called zāqēn in the biblical narrative. By distinguishing linguistically between the core meaning of a word and its contextual connotations, we can avoid forcing a social status or situation into the meaning of the word.
|
The Meaning of QRN as "Lightning Flash" in Ugaritic
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
Young Bok Kim, University of Chicago
In A Dictionary of the Ugaritic language in the Alphabetic Tradition, G. del Olmo Lete and J. Sanmartín give the four meanings for the feminine noun qrn: (1) “horn”; (2) “lightning flash”; (3) “excrescence”; (4) said of each bow tip. But the second meaning, which is apparently derived from biblical Hebrew (Hab. 3:4; cf. Ex. 34:29, 30, 35), is highly problematic for several reasons. Firstly, there has been much dispute over the meaning of qrn in these biblical passages
and no consensus has been reached yet. The second problem is that while del Olmo Lete and Sanmartín provide one form as an example for the meaning of “lightning flash” ([q]rnh CAT 1.3 IV 27), it is partially reconstructed and its context is badly broken. Therefore, one cannot but ask if it is appropriate to put down this meaning in the dictionary. This paper attempts to answer this question by examining comparative Semitic evidence, biblical Hebrew evidence, and Ugaritic
evidence of the word qrn, paying special attention to CAT 1.3 IV 27 and its context and conducting a survey of previous studies on its interpretation.
|
Domesticating Paul, Domesticating Eve: Sin and Sexuality in Second Century Creation Discourse
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Brad F. King, University of Texas at Austin
By the end of the first century, the eschatological urgency of the early Jesus movement had begun to wane. Early Christians continued to expect Jesus’ return in the clouds (e.g. Rev 1:7; 14:14; Acts 1:9–11), but their writings began to exhibit less concern for the coming eschaton and more for their relationships in the current world. As a result, many formative Christian communities participated in debates about the degree to which Christ’s death and resurrection transformed the moral and ethical status of human embodiment, provoking a great deal of interest in the moral and ethical valuations of marriage, procreation, and child rearing. Thus, the pseudonymous author of the First Epistle to Timothy, writing at least a generation after the death of Paul, indelibly altered the conception of women, children, and families in the New Testament Pauline canon. Whereas the undisputed epistles are ambivalent about the value of marriage and procreation, the author of 1 Timothy sought to limit the public role and status that some women had apparently attained in early Pauline communities, insisting that no woman should “teach or hold authority over a man” (1 Tim. 2:12; NRSV). The same author infamously tied a woman’s hope for salvation to her “natural” purpose: bearing and raising children (1 Tim. 2:15). Despite the presence of ostensibly similar claims in Paul’s Corinthian correspondence (e.g. 1 Cor 11:2ff, 2 Cor 11:3), the creation discourse of 1 Timothy assumes a fundamentally different relationship between humanity’s mythic forebearers and a properly ordered society than do any of the undisputed epistles. With these issues in mind, this paper analyzes the discursive mechanisms by which the author of 1 Timothy translated extant Jewish and Roman conceptions of women and the household into the a uniquely Christian idiom. I argue that whereas the undisputed epistles exhort a social ethic grounded in the future eschatological kingdom of the parousia, the authors of the deutero-Pauline epistles reinscribed traditional patriarchal hierarchies in a new Christian idiom that looked back to Genesis and “natural” social models—rather than forward to the parousia—as the ideal basis of social order.
|
Modeling Noun Semantics with Vector Spaces and the ETCBC Hebrew Database
Program Unit: Global Education and Research Technology
Cody Kingham, Cambridge University
This presentation demonstrates a computational method of semantic analysis for the most
common nouns in the Hebrew Bible. The method involves counting target nouns' lexical and
syntactic collocation preferences. The nouns' respective counts can be formally compared by
treating the counts as a vector in a multidimensional space. A formula is then applied to compare
the distance between nouns pairwise. Distance is expressed as a decimal number from 0 to 1
(cosine), with 0 being the most distant and 1 being the closest. The resulting distances are used to
cluster nouns that are close to each other, and thereby derive rudimentary semantic classes based
on formal data alone. The analysis uses the syntax data of the Eep Talstra Centre for Bible and
Computer (VU Amsterdam). The approach demonstrates that a formal, form-to-function
approach to semantics is possible; and it suggests new avenues of research by which words and
texts can be compared based on the closeness of their composite semantic distances.
|
Everybody Conquered Everybody: Envisioning Power in 1 Sam 14:47–52 and 2 Sam 8
Program Unit: Book of Samuel: Narrative, Theology, and Interpretation
Sara Kipfer, Heidelberg University
The parallels between 1Sam 14:47-48.52 and 2Sam 8:11-12.15* have long been noted (e.g. Budde 1902). However, their relation is still debated: it has been argued, that the list of Saul’s wars was written in analogy to the wars of David (Stoebe 1973; Stolz 1981; Bezzel 2015) or vice versa, that the praise of Saul was later added to the story of David (Dietrich 2015). Finally it has been estimated, that both lists were the product of the same redactor (Klein 2002).
This paper will reevaluate these complicated literary problems by taking into account its larger context: the similarities of 2Sam 8:3-5.7-11* (par. 1Chr 18:3-5.7-11*) with battle reports by Shalmaneser III fighting against a Syrian coalition in 849 BCE demonstrate that the text reflects the setting of the 9th century BCE. However it does not refer to a historical event, but should be understood as an ideological text ascribing the obviously exaggerated victory of Shalmaneser III over Adad-Idri to David fighting Hǎdad’ezer, king of Zoba. Notes about victories over other nations such as the Philistines (2Sam 8:1), Moab (2Sam 8:2) and Edom (2Sam 8:13-14*) where added later to this text.
The phenomenon of envisioning the power of one king compared to another was still present in later times: The (dtr?) redactor emphasizes, that Saul successfully fought against all his enemies on every side (1Sam 14:47-48.52). Similarly a later note in 2Sam 8:11*.12.15 stresses the victory of David over Moab, Ammon, Edom, Zoba, the Philistines and Amalek.
|
Jezebel among the Prophets
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
D. Jill Kirby, Edgewood College
Critique of the sexualized violence contemplated against Jezebel in the Letter to Thyatira (Rev 2:18-29) is now commonplace in traditional feminist analysis. However, readings from within the LDS community, which feature a pre-modern historical context and a rather eclectic reception, have not been explored and the differences are significant. For example, the historical-critical readings that underlie the traditional feminist critique identify John of Patmos as an itinerant prophetic voice, one many such self-proclaimed authorities in the early Christian world. Jezebel may be read as another voice in this world, perhaps the leader of a house church more closely aligned with Pauline ideas about social accommodation of pagan practices than John thought acceptable. In an LDS reading, however, John of Patmos is John, son of Zebedee, the Beloved Disciple and close companion of Jesus. His testimony is therefore a pure witness of the teachings of Jesus rather than that of another leader among many. The failings that John identifies in the Seven Churches are evidence of an incipient revolt that will become the Great Apostasy, rather than the common struggle of Gentile believers to live up to their new spiritual heritage, and Jezebel is eminent among those that will eventually bring God’s church to an early ruin. In addition, the close identification of early Christianity with the modern LDS community among traditional LDS readers denies Jezebel any formal standing at all, let alone the wherewithal to challenge the priesthood authority of John, who is typically accorded status as a member of the “First Presidency” in the LDS understanding of early Christian church structure. Finally, the JST, which reflects Joseph Smith’s insight into this passage, indicates that Jezebel is to be cast into hell rather than to be bedridden by illness as the Greek text indicates. This paper will more fully unpack the ways in which LDS readings of this passage are constrained by the LDS tradition, identify how these readings challenge modern LDS women and indicate some options that might contribute to readings which retain dignity for women in exercising the gift of prophecy.
|
hammašḥît, an ʾĕlohîm collective
Program Unit: Israelite Religion in Its Ancient Context
Anne Marie Kitz, University of Life
This presentation principally focuses on the term hammašḥît, formed on the root šḥt with the base meaning ‘destroy’. Hammašḥit is a m.s. hiphil participle to which the definite article has been attached. Accordingly, it can acquire a substantive status; Thus,‘the one who causes destruction’,‘the one who destroys’,‘the destroyer’.
In Exod 12:23 hammašḥît plays an important role in the execution of the last plague of Egypt as YHWH’s faithful escort when he travels through the land. Other related beings are the šĕnê hammalʾākim ‘the two messengers’ who, after entering Sodom and Gomorrah, tell Lot that mašḥitîm ʾănaḥnû ʾet-hammāqôm, ‘we are about to destroy this place’ (Gen 19:1, 13). Although hammašḥit does not appear, this divine duo certainly acquires hammašḥit status. The same may be said of the hammalʾāk hammašḥit, ‘the messenger ready to destroy’ in 2 Sam 24:16 and 1 Chr 21:15.
A profile of hammašḥît is developed based on the following analogy: just as YHWH had a śar ‘commander’ over his ṣĕbāʾ ‘army’ (Josh 5:14) and David had Joab as a śar ‘commander’ of haṣṣĕbāʾ ‘the army’ (1 Kgs 11:5), so there appears to be the same kind of correspondence between YHWH’s hammašḥît and the Philistines’ hammašḥît in 1 Sam 13:17. The one difficulty is, of course, the assumption that YHWH only had one hammašḥît while the Philistines had so many they could be split into šĕlošāh roʾšîm ‘three companies’.
This perceived lack of correspondence is solved in two ways. First, 1 Sam 14:15 clearly indicates that hammašḥît is a collective noun. Here the term is combined with a 3m.p. verb hammašḥît ḥārdû, lit. ‘The destroyer they trembled, ’ that NRSV translates as ‘the raiders trembled’. Second, it is likely that YHWH’s hammašḥît in Exod 12:23 is also a collective noun where it refers to a ‘strike force’ of divine beings that assist in the spread of the plague. Subsequently, when YHWH personally dispatches the hammalʾāk hammašḥit, he does so not as an individual, but as the leader of a company of hamašḥit whose militia is about to charge Jerusalem with an onslaught of deber ‘plague’. This means the malʾāk and his cohort are in fact a group of ʾēls. The malʾāk is none other than YHWH’s śar ‘commander’ who leads a roʾšîm drawn from the ṣĕbāʾ-yhwh. Consequently, hammašḥit is but one example of an energized ʾĕlohîm collective wherein ʾĕlohîm refers to a cluster of otherwise anonymous ʾēls, which are known to accompany and assist the leading deity of their membership, YHWH.
|
The Religious World of Late Antique Southern Arabia: Transformations and Trends
Program Unit: Religious World of Late Antiquity
Sigrid K. Kjær, University of Texas at Austin
The topic of my research is the religious milieu of pre-Islamic southern Arabia and how its progress relates to the religious developments taking place in the Mediterranean at the same time. Specifically, I deal with the few years around 522 CE in which a “Jewish” king named Joseph dhu Nuwas ruled the kingdom of Ḥimyar (modern-day Yemen and southwestern Saudi Arabia) and revolted against the Ethiopian/Aksumite presence in the area. The previously “Jewish-like” or “Judaizing” Ḥimyarite kingdom that seemed to tolerate Christian and pagan neighboring tribes reasonably well, changed its attitude. According to contemporary inscriptions and ideologically tainted later sources, dhu Nuwas attacked the Christians in Najran and went on a veritable rampage against them. Naturally, the Ethiopians reacted and even though it took a couple of years, they ultimately prevailed, making the kingdom of Ḥimyar a vassal state.
The project deals with the topic in three different ways, but given the limited time, I will focus on only one in this presentation, namely the first part of the project. It surveys the epigraphic evidence employing philological methods, and based on the findings, I attempt to schematize the religious milieu in southern Arabia in the period leading up to dhu Nuwas’ rule. While doing so, I engage with the theories of Guy G. Stroumsa, in particular, concerning the religious transformations taking place in Late Antiquity. On account of Stroumsa’s reformulation of the concept of the Axial Age, I argue that late antique southern Arabia is very much a part of the cultural sphere of the time, although trends may appear belatedly. Thus, I implicitly evoke the theories of Karl Jaspers and Robert N. Bellah concerning the conceptualization of a global Axial Age in religion. Ultimately, the intention of the dissertation as a whole, is to draw lines between religious changes taking place in the triangle of the major cities at the time—Rome, Jerusalem and Byzantium—and those of the far-flung southern part of the Arabian Peninsula.
|
Jael and the Tent Peg: Hegemonic Masculinity in Judges 4 and 5
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Carolyn Klaasen, Union Theological Seminary
When Jael drives her tent-peg through Sisera’s head she reverses gender roles and upends expectations of who is dangerous (this time, a woman) and who is vulnerable (the warrior who is her victim). Among the women of the Hebrew Bible she is one of very few who perpetrate violence rather than having it inflicted upon her. This violent heroine is celebrated within the text, but can be a somewhat ambivalent figure for many feminists. It is hard to know how to read Jael. Is the one who is “blessed among women” also a champion of women who suffer from violence? Does her story overturn patriarchal gender hierarchies, or subtly reinforce them?
This paper will explore these questions by applying the concepts of hegemonic masculinity, as proposed and developed by Raewyn Connell, and female masculinity, as introduced by Jack Halberstam, to an analysis of Jael’s story Judges 4 and 5. While there has been recently been rapid development in studies of men and masculinity in the Hebrew Bible, as evidenced by the publications of three edited volumes, five monographs, and numerous additional articles in the past seven years, there has been inadequate attention to the roles of female characters in biblical constructions of masculinity. Particularly striking is the absence of attention to texts featuring female killers, since masculinity is so central to the plots of these stories. Their depictions of women wielding violence against men present a reversal of the Hebrew Bible’s gendered norms. To quote Harold C. Washington, in the Hebrew Bible “a capacity for violence is synonymous with manliness… violence against a feminine object, above all, consolidates masculine identity.” This paper will address this gap in current work by contributing an analysis of how masculinity is constructed, particularly through the character of Jael, in Judges 4 and 5. It is my hope that this paper will demonstrate how expanding the study of biblical masculinity beyond men can contribute to current discussions about constructions of masculinity in the Hebrew Bible.
Ultimately, I argue, both versions of her story reinscribe the very gender hierarchy her violence defies. The older poetic account in Judges 5 celebrates military conquest through images of sexual assault, reinforcing the cultural assumption that rape is the prerogative of victorious warriors. Judges 4 ridicules men who evade battle, thereby perpetuating cultural associations between violence and masculinity. In both texts Jael’s violence appears as a useful aberration, a departure from gender norms that can be employed to undermine male characters and ultimately reinforce those very norms.
|
"There Is No Divination after Prophecy": Early Islamic Diviners and Their Erasure
Program Unit: Religious World of Late Antiquity
Pamela Klasova, Bowdoin College
"There Is No Divination after Prophecy": Early Islamic Diviners and their Erasure
|
Continuity and Change in Settlement Activity in Early Iron Age Northern Gilead and the Pre-Priestly Jacob Traditions
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Assaf Kleiman, Tel Aviv University
(no abstract)
|
The Meal in Its Nonliterary and Literary Worlds
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
Matthias Klinghardt, Technische Universität Dresden
The Paper explores the relation between literary, non-literary, and exra-textual data for ancient meals. It aims at uncovering some of the interpretive interests necessary for the construction of "the Greco-Roman meal" and, at the same time, reflects on the seminar's course in the last 15 years.
|
Social Networks and the Dissemination of Elective Cults
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
John Kloppenborg, University of Toronto
The many private associations that populated the Mediterranean—occupational guilds, diasporic associations, cultic associations, neighborhood clubs, and collegia domestica—constituted social networks that generated social capital for members and created opportunities and contacts for members that they could not have apart from membership. Seen in this way, members are ‘nodes’ related to one another, usually in multiple ways—by familial relationships, place of origin, occupation, neighborhood, cultic devotion, patronage, material relationships, etc. It is also at this sub-urban, local level that the diffusion of elective cults occurred and it is the mechanisms of diffusion with which this paper is concerned. Diffusion occurred through the creation of network linkages between associations which allowed the flow of information, influence, social power, and which facilitated the propagation of elective cults. The paper will propose theoretical models borrowed from epidemiology and the spread of infections to think about how elective cults moved within urban social networks.
|
The Literary Dependence of the Prayer of the King's Cupbearer (Neh 1:4-11) on the Prayers of Moses (Ex 32-34), and Why it Matters
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Sheri L. Klouda, Taylor University
The Literary Dependence of the Prayer of the King's Cupbearer (Neh 1:4-11) on the Prayers of Moses (Ex 32-34), and Why it Matters
|
Cognitive Linguistics and Intertextuality: A Methodological Proposal
Program Unit: Intertextuality and the Hebrew Bible
Gary P. Klump, Marquette University
In order to address the complexity of intertextuality, one must reckon with pluriform—complementary, supplementary, and contradictory—instantiations of a tradition which continue to organically evolve in both oral and written form. To work in the frontiers of intertextuality, one must do away with the ideal form and the cut-and-paste copyist alike. One must disabuse scholarship of the notion that texts existed apart from the context of the human mind. This paper proposes a methodology that employs the insights of the cognitive linguistic notion (per Halliday) of “register,” which will allow for a more inductive approach to form criticism, while freeing source criticism from what can often be simple verbal comparison. Furthermore, this methodology will eschew linear models of tradition criticism and arrival at one which sees written texts as durable iterations of a simultaneously unified and diverse tradition. Cognitive linguistics can be used to broaden the notion of tradition to be the interrelated web of ideas and words that are employed in similar situations (the field of discourse) for similar purposes (the mode of discourse). An attempt will be made to translate the traditional concerns of biblical scholars and the methods they employ into the framework of cognitive linguistics and vice versa.
This paper will concern itself with creation, a tradition of sufficient duration and complexity to necessitate this new approach, given that iterations of this tradition can be found in the Pentateuch, Prophets, Psalms, Wisdom, and Apocalyptic. Methodological insights will be critically appropriated from a number of scholars (Sandmel, Hays, Fishbane, Zakovitch, Sarna, Leonard, Sommer, Reynolds, Beentjes, etc.) who have worked on intertextuality, source criticism, midrash, tradition criticism, and textual production.
|
Samson’s Wifes in Prov 1-9
Program Unit: Joshua-Judges
Ernst Axel Knauf, Universität Bern - Université de Berne
Judg 14-16 is an illustration of Prov 30,15b-17 (ZBK-AT 7, 2016, 143). In addition, Samson can be read as an example of the "disobedient son" which is trapped by the 'Foreign woman" of Prov 1-9.
|
The Joshua Tradition in the Persian Period
Program Unit: Transmission of Traditions in the Second Temple Period
Ernst Axel Knauf, Universität Bern - Université de Berne
Joshua was not invented in the Persian period, but his role and functions were significantly augmented. The Persian period scribes inherited "Joshua the leader of Israel, successor of Moses" from the late 7th and 6th centuries BCE. They added the functions "prophet", "teacher of Tora", "allocator of its land to Israel" and "servant of the Lord". The contribution of the Hellenistic period to the biblical persona of Joshua is minimal.
|
The Symbolism of Biblical Blood Ritual
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Robin J DeWitt Knauth, Lycoming College
Beginning with Othmar Keel’s work on ancient Near Eastern iconography in relation to Psalms as inspiration and model, many opportunities remain within that rich intersection where text and iconographic symbolism converge. Linguistic clues, along with biblical laws and stories, further illuminated by ancient Near Eastern traditions, documents, and iconography, can be brought together to build a better understanding of blood-oath ritual and symbolism in the ancient world of the Bible. From the blood laws of the Noachic covenant, to the blood ritual of circumcision associated with kinship oaths of marriage, to the bloody covenant call to holy war encountered in biblical texts, blood symbolism can be found at the heart of much ancient ritual – including the implied self-curse gesture that must have accompanied the standard oath formula in the Hebrew Bible. What that self-curse might have been is not explicitly stated. However, descriptions of binding covenant oath ceremonies, and the very language of covenant “cutting,” are highly suggestive. The cutting in half of sacrificial animals, and the subsequent laying out of the pieces for display to the covenant-maker, can leave little doubt as to the intended consequences of breaking that oath, expressed in the biblical oath formula, “May YHWH do thus to me and more also if I do not [fill in desired stipulation].” The gesture of rending the garment in response to covenant-breaking blasphemy is surely a reference to this implied self-curse. Tearing the bread at the “Last Supper” as symbolizing a sacrificed body also makes better sense in that context. Given the conservative nature of religious symbolism spanning multiple cultures over millennia (such as the sacred tree imagery associated with Asherah in the Bible but manifested much more widely in Near Eastern iconographic tradition), it should not be surprising that an equivalent of the modern expression, “Cross my heart and hope to die,” should have its unrecognized roots in the musty past of blood oaths, even long after the sacrificial practices giving rise to the expression have died out. It would seem that modern Christian symbolism of communion and the cross may fall into the same category on multiple levels – both in iconography and gesture.
|
Performing a Metaphor: The Heavenly Worship of Psalm 19 and the Praise of Human Voices
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Jarrett Knight, Emory University
The sudden seeming break in subject matter between vv. 1-6 and vv. 7-10 presents a major difficulty for the interpretation of Psalm 19. While many scholars posit that the disruption shows that the Psalm resulted from the redaction of two originally distinct compositions, others—not necessarily discounting such claims—also say that the Psalm presents a coherent whole in its current form. This presentation develops the latter claim, arguing that an implicit cognitive metaphor forms the basis for understanding the whole of Psalm 19 as a unity. The metaphor links the schema of worship described in vv. 1-7 to a reality that occurs in the Psalm’s performance: the worshiping heavens in vv. 1-4a map onto either a worshiping congregation reciting the Psalm or an individual reader of the Psalm, while the sun in vv. 4b-6 maps onto God’s law, presented as transforming the Psalm’s reciters and possibly physically embodied in the congregation’s midst. Thus Psalm 19 presents a metaphorical picture that in its recitation embodies the reality it depicts, connecting the enlightened heavens’ wordless praise of God either to an individual enlightened by the law who praises God with words in the Psalm’s recitation or to a similarly enlightened congregation doing the same, possibly at the same time as the law is made physically present. In so doing, Psalm 19 invites its readers into a new reality opened by the metaphor: they in their praise of their creator join the heavenly worship described in the Psalm.
|
Reading the Song of Songs Allegorically as a Dialogue between Heavenly Father and Heavenly Mother
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
Derek Knox, Brookline Public Schools
With one eye on the ancient Near Eastern context and another on contemporary images of Heavenly Father and Heavenly Mother, some interesting and imaginative possibilities can be explored. The historical considerations can inspire us to read the text figuratively as a divine couple. For example, we explore parallels with Mesopotamian god/goddess love poetry (the songs of the goddess Ishtar and her lover Tammuz, the love lyrics of Nabu and Tashmetu). The Song of Songs echoes some of the material in these texts, and also Middle Egyptian love poetry. Many parallels are noted that enable us to read the text as between Heavenly Father and Heavenly mother. There is even “sealing” language in the Song, as “Heavenly Mother” says, "Set me as a seal upon thine heart, as a seal upon thine arm: for love is strong as death" (Song 8:6). We can see how, compared to other allegory attempts (God/Israel, Christ/Church), Latter-day Saints have some interesting avenues for exploration, as this reading (1) celebrates our heavenly parents as sexual beings, and (2) celebrates our heavenly parents as beings with physical, tangible bodies. Given these possibilities, we also show how this allegory does not need to be read in a heteronormative manner, but exploring details in the text that make the Song relevant for marginalized relationships. In addition, we also draw upon Janan Graham-Russell’s work that imagines Heavenly Mother as a black woman, connecting that with Heavenly Mother’s words: "I am black and beautiful, O daughters of Jerusalem" (Song 1:5). One of the interesting possibilities of this reading is that it reclaims Heavenly Mother in the Scriptures. We need not wonder where she is and why we never hear about her. Now we can hear her own words and her own voice, drawing upon this allegory in light of feminist and womanist methods. Heavenly Mother talks about her desires, she shows initiative, restraint, and agency. She celebrates her body. She is committed to and in love with her partner. She expresses what she wants. And she provides a model for all of us to express the most passionate religious sentiments of our hearts.
|
Codex Bezae and Biblical Theft: A Case Study
Program Unit: Book History and Biblical Literatures
Jennifer Knust, Boston University
Likely copied in Syria, Codex Bezae (D/d 05 Cambridge University Library Nn. 2.41), was gifted to Cambridge by Protestant Reformer, biblical critic, and successor to Calvin Theodore Beza. Beza himself came into possession of the manuscript after its removal during the sack of Lyons (1562), its location after an earlier journey from Berytus to “the West” some seven hundred years earlier, probably as a refugee (or as booty) from an earlier war. This manuscript’s experience of theft, appropriation, re-interpretation, and re-use will serve as an opportunity for reflecting on the manufacture of sacred status for texts and the objects that preserve them within on-going cycles of preservation, destruction, and plunder.
|
Evaluating Late Iron Age Jerusalemite Glyptics
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Ido Koch, Tel Aviv University
Advanced excavation methods adopted in recent years have led to the unearthing of a significant number of stamp-seals and stamp impressions from secure late Iron Age archaeological contexts in Jerusalem. The new finds include artifacts decorated with icons of local tradition or appropriated Mesopotamian icons (several bearing inscriptions), as well as artifacts adorned with inscriptions and no icons at all. The rich assemblages and varied archaeological contexts allow for the evaluation of common assumptions about the figurative world of the late Iron Age in Jerusalem.
This contribution focuses on three issues: (1) the appropriation of Assyrian icons and the Assyrian influence among the Judahite elite, with an emphasis on the appearance of the rosette icon and the iconography of the Moon-god of Harran; (2) the rejection of icons and the preference towards aniconic stamp-seals (the “aniconic trend”); and (3) Jerusalem in the Neo-Babylonian period.
|
“Saul” in Acts and the Rhetoric of Reception
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Michael Kochenash, Hunan University
Many scholars take Luke’s use of the name Saul as evidence that it belonged to the Historical Paul, often identifying one or the other as his nickname. Reading the narrative of Acts as emulating certain literary models, however, offers a more credible solution. In this paper, I argue that the use of the name Saul for Paul can be read as a Lukan innovation that communicates the consequence of opposition to the early Christian movement. Luke initially characterizes Paul, calling him “Saul,” as a God-fighter who persecutes the early church and even Jesus himself (whom Luke identifies as the Son of God and the son of David). This characterization can be read as modeled on both King Saul – Israel’s first king who persecuted David (!) – and Pentheus from Euripides’ Bacchae, the archetypal god-fighter who persecuted Dionysus, the son of Zeus. Both Pentheus and Luke’s Saul are confronted by the divine offspring they opposed. In this way, readers of Acts with the necessary cultural competence can interpret opposition to the early Christian movement as comparable to Pentheus’s opposition to the cult of Dionysus. This appeal to the Bacchae as a second literary model helps my reading avoid a mistake of similar interpretations, dating to the early church, of the name Saul as a reference to King Saul: Saul remains “Saul” after the Damascus Road experience in order to demonstrate the appropriate response of one found to be a god-fighter (see Acts 9:19b–30), emulating Pentheus’s model. Saul’s identity, and so his name, then changes in Acts 13. No longer the (former) persecutor of the church, “Paul” is the herald of Christ to Judeans and Gentiles alike.
|
There Aren’t any Owls in OWL But There Aren’t Any Eunuchs Either: The Bible in Comprehensive Sexuality Education With Young Children
Program Unit: LGBTI/Queer Hermeneutics
Laurel Koepf Taylor, Eden Theological Seminary
The Our Whole Lives curriculum (OWL) has become one of the most respected comprehensive sexuality education curricula available. It is used both in secular contexts and in Unitarian Universalist and United Church of Christ congregations. A lifespan curriculum, it can be offered for Kindergarten and first grade, fourth through fifth grade, seventh through ninth grade, tenth through twelfth grade, young adults and adults.
Kindergarten and first grade children in an OWL classroom are correct to point out that the class isn’t really about owls. Instead, they often suggest that OWL be called “Bodies and Babies.” This would indeed be a more forthright description of a curriculum that openly discusses the human body including genitals, reproduction, family configurations, and the ways in which children become a part of families. The biblical texts proposed for support of the OWL curriculum in Sexuality and Our Faith: A Companion to Our Whole Lives are notably less open about “bodies and babies” than the curriculum itself, risking the impression that the Bible does not discuss human bodies and reproduction. Biblical scholarship recognizes that texts across testamental boundaries contain a great deal more engagement with embodiment than is often considered “appropriate for children.” Using existing research on the ongoing evolution of Bibles for children, this paper will critically examine what shapes the assessment of whether Biblical texts are “appropriate for children” and apply that assessment to contexts in which children are assumed to benefit from honest answers and accurate information about human sexuality.
|
Treatments of the Greco-Roman World in Commentaries on John’s Apocalypse
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Craig Koester, Luther Seminary
*
|
A Way of Seeing: On the Development of J. Louis Martyn's Perspectives on Johannine Tradition, History, and Theology
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Craig Koester, Luther Seminary
J. Louis Martyn assumed that New Testament texts were shaped by the contexts in which they were composed. In the case of John's gospel, the process was dynamic and unfolded over time. The same was true of Martyn's perspectives. Here we will explore the backstory of his landmark History and Theology in the Fourth Gospel, and consider the assumptions, methods, and modern social contexts that shaped his work. Reflection on the reception of his work over the past half century in turn provides perspective on Johannine studies more broadly.
|
The Conception of Man’s Createdness in Ancient Egypt and Its Implications for Biblical Studies
Program Unit: Egyptology and Ancient Israel
Jens Bruun Kofoed, Fjellhaug International University College Denmark
Quite a few articles on the potential Egyptian background to Genesis 1 and 2 have been published over the last decades, and though many still consider a Babylonian background the most likely, it has now been demonstrated that Genesis 1 and 2 makes just as much sense as an appropriation of and polemic against Egyptian traditions. The purpose of this paper is to add some observations on a relatively neglected point for comparison between the Egyptian and Biblical texts. In the Egyptian texts mankind shares in the same divine essence as the created gods, occupies the highest rank in the created order, and is the special object of the creator-god’s provision and compassion. The purpose of creating man was to honor and worship the creator-god by procreation and sustainment of world order, and though there arguably is a hierarchical focus on the king in the early texts, other texts suggest that a process of democratization or diffusion of the king’s privileges took place from the First Intermediate Period and onwards stressing the democratic and equalitarian implications for Egyptian society. Though the standards of conduct implied by such an understanding of man’s intrinsic worth was rarely acknowledged, let alone met, such a standard nevertheless stands as a powerful ideal that, given the texts’ popularity, informed the community’s social structures and beliefs thereby safeguarding the value of the individual from government overreach. The Egyptian texts invite us to be cautious in using Mesopotamian creation texts as a pretext for determining the date of composition of the Biblical account. The similarities between the Egyptian and Biblical texts suggest that the author(s) and tradents of the creation traditions of Genesis was well aware of or at least shared the conception of man’s createdness with the Egyptians.
|
Manasseh's Birth, One of the Catalysts for the Proclamation of Isa 11:1–5
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Shmuel S.-J. Koh, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
One of the most enigmatic and much debated texts in the Hebrew Bible is Isa 11:1-5. This is because the text has given rise to a variety of scholarly opinions regarding the issues of authenticity, historical context, and the identity of חֹטר and נצר (11:1, “a shoot” and “branch, scion, or twig”). Among the variety of scholarly opinions, this paper will prove the following statements. 1) Isa 11:1-5 is best interpreted in the historical context of 713-708/7 BC. 2) Sargon II (722-705 BC) launched his second military campaign toward the west during 713-711 BC. 3) Around the time of 713-711 BC, the prophet Isaiah was disappointed at Hezekiah’s fateful policy against Assyria, and eventually proclaimed not only the warning of Isa 20:4-6 against Hezekiah’s policy but also the emergence of a future ideal Davidic king by intentionally using the name Jesse (11:1a) instead of the name David as in 9:6. 4) Isaiah’s proclamation of Isa 11:1-5 could have been influenced by Manasseh’s birth in either 710 BC or 708/707 BC. In other words, it is possible to argue that under the historical context of the enormous Neo-Assyrian threats against Judah during 713-711 BC, Manasseh’s birth around 710 BC could give hope to the people of Judah including the prophet Isaiah. Manasseh’s birth could function as a catalyst for the prophet Isaiah’s proclamation of Isa 11:1-5. In his proclamation, the prophet Isaiah could cherish the hope that Manasseh would become such an ideal king in future as depicted in Isa 11:1-5, which was never realized.
|
Fires, Lions, and Trials: The Danielic Court-Tales and the Structure of the Acts of Thecla
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Jenna C. Kokot, Boston College
The Acts of Thecla 4:8 describes Thecla in an arena, waiting to be martyred and devoured by beasts when "a ferocious lioness ran toward her then laid down at her feet." The lioness goes on to defend Thecla from other beasts, which many commentators see as an allusion to Daniel 6. I argue that this event is only a small example of the influence of Daniel on the Acts of Thecla and that, far from an isolated allusion, it is part of a larger structuring schema derived from the Danielic court-tales.
The Acts of Thecla (hereafter abbreviated ATh) is organized around two trials of the protagonist - one by fire and one by beasts. The two episodes are of differing origins yet were compiled and circulated as a unit toward the end of the second century. Consequently, ATh is a composite document replete with editing seams and awkward transitions. Despite their differing origins and tendencies in genre, when brought together, the episodes repeat the elements of the protagonist's trial, perseverance of faith, and deliverance.
What narrative purpose does this composite literary unit accomplish? Many scholars, such as Elisabeth Esch-Wermeling, have questioned the necessity of duplicating these narrative features in the final editing and proposed that the editor preserved two similar but disparate Thecla traditions, making little effort to lend an overarching structure or narrative flow to the document. While editing seams and awkward transitions remain, I argue that, the final layer of editing in ATh draws particularly on Daniel 3 and 6 for structuring the two episodes.
When the structure of ATh is compared with structural studies of the court-tales, such as those by John J. Collins, similarities abound, including a propensity for repeated structures. The protagonists begin in a prosperous state, are then endangered, condemned, then miraculously delivered, after which they gain positive recognition from their former persecutors, and are exalted to positions of honor. In addition to these structural similarities, ATh shares common language, imagery, and motifs with Daniel 3 and 6 - most notably death sentences involving fire and lions and deliverance from those threats.
There is a precedent for drawing upon these two particular tales from Daniel. Jan Willem van Henten has demonstrated that early on in Christian literature, Daniel 3 and 6 were employed as exempla in conversations about persecution. The connections between Thecla and Daniel were also born out in the later artistic portrayals of Thecla which frequently depicted her beside Daniel and his companions or with Danielic-like imagery. While these later artistic connections have been well-recognized, conversations of Danielic material in ATh itself are typically isolated to the allusion with which I began. This oversight has caused scholars to miss the way in which Daniel 3 and 6 and their contemporary usage in early Christian circles provides a rationale for the narrative positioning of the two trial episodes in ATh.
|
Eve and the Serpent: A Samoan Love Story; A Fagogo Reading of Genesis 3:1-19
Program Unit: Postcolonial Studies and Biblical Studies
Brian Fiu Kolia, University of Divinity
Samoans enjoy fāgogo: the art of Samoan storytelling. It involves mythical encounters between mortal heroes and immortal legends; existing in a space where the impossible becomes possible. A space where spirits roam, and animals possess human-like qualities. A space where animals speak and have conversations with humans, and in some stories, animals have relations with humans. Such ancient tales spring to life through talanoa. Talanoa is a common term in Pasefika, which denotes conversation, yet it is the confluence of three things: story, telling, and conversation. Talanoa and fāgogo go together. Because fāgogo emanates the art of talanoa, as the storyteller is careful and intentional in his/her use of language to weave together a magical description of the world of the story, not only to tell the story, but to be persuasive in doing so. As a reading method, I propose that in reading, we do not lose the magic of storytelling, and see the story for what it was written for. I propose fāgogo as a hermeneutical framework for my re-reading of the story of Eve and the Serpent as found in Gen 3:1-19. To provide an alternative reading that sees the tale in Gen 3:1-19 as a love story, in light of a well-known Samoan tale known as Sina and the Tuna (Eel). The purpose of this fāgogo reading is an attempt to enhance the reading experience, while also shedding further light on the relationship between Eve and the Serpent from a Samoan perspective.
|
Eve, the Serpent, and a Samoan Love Story: A Fāgogo Reading of Genesis 3:1-19 and Its’ Implications for Animal Studies
Program Unit: Animal Studies and the Bible
Brian Fiu Kolia, University of Divinity
Samoans enjoy fāgogo, the art of Samoan storytelling. It involves mythical encounters between mortal heroes and immortal legends; existing in a space where the impossible becomes possible. A space where spirits roam, and animals possess human-like qualities. A space where animals speak and have conversations with humans, and in some stories, animals have relations with humans. Such ancient tales spring to life through talanoa. Talanoa is a common term in Pasefika, which denotes conversation, yet it is the confluence of three things: story, telling, and conversation. Talanoa and fāgogo go together. Because fāgogo emanates the art of talanoa, as the storyteller is careful and intentional in his/her use of language to weave together a magical description of the world of the story, not only to tell the story, but to be persuasive in doing so. As a reading method, I propose that in reading, we do not lose the magic of storytelling, and see the story for what it was written for. I propose fāgogo as a hermeneutical framework for my re-reading of the story of Eve and the Serpent as found in Gen 3:1-19 to provide an alternative reading that sees the tale in Gen 3:1-19 as a love story, in light of a well-known Samoan tale known as Sina and the Tuna (Eel). The purpose of this fāgogo reading is an attempt to draw out the implications of the story for animal studies.
|
The Description of Pain in the Markan Healing Stories
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Judith Koenig, Universität Regensburg
Physical pain is a profound theological and anthropological subject. It brings us into contact with the questions of body and soul, mortality and death, contingency and ultimately with him, who “will wipe away every tear […] and pain will be no more" (Rev 21:4). Pain, as one of the most basic human sensations, is also highly relevant in the context of sensory perception, which itself has experienced a surge of research in biblical studies in the past few years. It is also a subject that is relevant from the standpoint of disability studies, as it marks an important area of physical disability and mobility impairment.
Nevertheless, there have been very few theological publications focusing specifically on pain in the last years and even the big theological encyclopedias of the German-speaking world don´t pay an appropriate amount of attention to pain.
One specific area in which the lack of research on pain as a theological and anthropological phenomenon becomes especially evident are biblical studies, specifically the healing stories of the gospels.
In contribution to closing that gap, this paper attempts to examine the description of pain in the Markan healing stories. The story of the hemorrhaging woman (Mk 5:24-34) and the story of the possessed boy (Mk 9:14-29) will serve as examples. In a second step, this paper then asks about the consequences of the way pain is depicted for the broader concept of healing in the gospel of Mark.
Consequently, there will be two main questions:
1) How is pain described and expatiated on in the Markan healing stories?
2) What are the consequences of that description for a Markan concept of healing?
I would like to argue, that healing in Mark is a multifaceted, inclusive concept, that cannot be reduced to an understanding of an alleviation of pain. More than that, considering the human body not primarily in terms of functional capability but rather in its social and religious context, makes us realize, how fruitful it could be to think anew about a Markan conept of healing and corporality.
|
The Gods of the West: Mesopotamian Deities and Demons in Levantine and Biblical Contexts
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Gina Konstantopoulos, University of Helsinki
Demons and monsters are inherently movable creatures: from the late second millennium BCE onward a number of demons and monsters migrate from their native Mesopotamian contexts, moving westward. These figures, most notably Humbaba, Pazuzu, and Lamashtu, may be tracked through a number of artistic representations found in surrounding regions, including the Levant. Of course, these figures do not remain static throughout their journey, instead acquiring the characteristics of the different cultural contexts wherein they are now found. This paper considers the different representations of several of these demonic figures within the context of the Levant, analyzing their artistic representations as well as the more diffuse textual evidence for them, as several demonic figures with Mesopotamian roots appear to be represented in the Hebrew Bible and other Jewish sources. As the line between demonic and divine was already thin and mutable in Mesopotamia, we see a similar flexibility to their definitions when these figures move into their new contexts. Moreover, it appears that specific Mesopotamian deities are more readily adapted for use in the Levant, as well as in Biblical contexts in particular. As deities are, generally speaking, less marginal beings than demons, the deities that do move westward, or are employed in the west in Neo-Assyrian and Neo-Babylonian sources, do so because they are already demonstrate a more flexible character and wider possible applicability and use. Through considering the ways in which these figures were represented and protected against, as well as the ways in which they changed when moving from Mesopotamia to the Levant, the underlying social context that created such differences in their representations may also be considered.
|
Margaret Atwood's Primordial Myth
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Jennifer L. Koosed, Albright College
Margaret Atwood has spent a lot of time reading and thinking about Genesis. The MaddAddam Trilogy (Oryx and Crake, The Year of the Flood, and MaddAddam) are replete with biblical citation and allusion, especially from Genesis’s primordial history. Crake, using the most advanced gene splicing technologies of his era, creates a new humanoid (the Crakers) designed to replace homo sapiens. He next manufacturers a virus and hides it in a sex pill, thereby unleashing the “waterless flood”—a rapidly moving pandemic that destroys almost all human life on the planet. He permits only one person to live—Snowman, prophet to and protector of the Crakers. But, like in Genesis, the creator is not in complete control of his creation. Other people survive the plague; the Crakers develop in ways unanticipated and unwanted. Through it all, there is a dance between science and religion—two approaches to knowledge that pull apart and come together in a variety of unexpected ways. Where does the sacred lie? One scientist denies that it is found in genes or cells or tissues—hence his justification for species splicing, cloning and other forms of genetic manipulation. One popular televangelist finds the sacred in fossil fuels; one renegade preacher in all plant and animal life. Meanwhile incipient religion keeps emerging—among the Crakers, among the pigoons, and among the motley castaways at the end of the world—most powerfully seen in the stories they tell each other. In this way, not only does Atwood employ biblical text, but she also reproduces the way in which the Bible functions—to bind and sustain communities, forging the sacred through storytelling.
|
Ezekiel and Neo-Babylonian Imperial Propaganda
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Ariel Kopilovitz, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem
The influence of Ancient Near Eastern literature on Ezekiel is a burning issue in contemporary scholarship. Despite some major contributions in this field, there is no agreement regarding the methodological question of which of the Ancient Near Eastern literary genres could have been accessible to Ezekiel and influenced him. This presentation will evaluate the influence of Neo-Babylonian imperial propaganda reflected in the Neo-Babylonian royal inscriptions, on Ezekiel's prophecy.
The presentation's first part will discuss the special characteristics of the Neo-Babylonian imperial propaganda and will demonstrate that contrary to other epic, magical and cultic texts that were kept in the palaces' or temples' archives and were accessible only to very few, the Neo-Babylonian imperial propaganda was initially addressed to non-Babylonians, especially those who were under Babylon's control. Therefore, the likelihood that these addressees were exposed to it and were influenced by it is very high.
The presentation's second part will discuss the influence of the Neo-Babylonian imperial propaganda on Ezekiel 17. First, it will offer a new interpretation to the great eagle's dealings with the cedar. It will show that contrary to scholarly conventions, the eagle uprooted the entire cedar and not only plucked one of its upper sprigs. This understanding tallies with the descriptions of the Neo-Babylonian kings' actions toward the cedars of the Lebanon in the Neo-Babylonian royal inscriptions, and reflects the manner in which the Neo-Babylonian imperial propaganda was perceived by the nations under Babylon's rule; Second, it will investigate the meaning of qss and will offer a new etymology for this hapax in light of some Neo-Babylonian parallels; Third, it will examine the forced covenant between Zedekiah and Nebuchadnezzar and the reason that it was also understood to be God's covenant. In light of some theological principals known from the Priestly writings in the Pentateuch (such as the meaning of ma'al), new arguments will be introduced in order to reaffirm the conclusion that the divine wrath toward Zedekiah was a result of a violation of an oath he swore in God's name. This understanding sheds new light on the relations between Babylon and the peoples they conquered and the way in which they controlled them; Finally, it will examine the description of the future cedar's enormous shadow and will point to the Neo-Babylonian origin of this image. The offered conclusion will be that contrary to scholarly consensus regarding Ezekiel's depictions of the future leader as a puppet ruler, lacking status and authority, Ezekiel 17 depicts the future leader as an emperor, in a manner similar to the one in which the Neo-Babylonian kings were depicted in their royal inscriptions. Furthermore, the comparative study of the Neo-Babylonian royal inscriptions sheds new light on Ezekiel's perception of Israel's future international relations. The future world orders would be quite similar to the present. Empires existed in the past and will continue to exist in the future. However, unlike the past, in the future Israel will be the (Babylon-like) suzerain, and the rest of the nations will be its vassals.
|
Self-Care as Holistic Practice in Contexts of Trauma
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Michael S. Koppel, Wesley Theological Seminary
This paper showcases how biblical texts provide vital clues for the practice of self and spiritual care in contexts of trauma. The operative assumption is that everyone is immersed in trauma at different levels and to various degrees. Trauma is defined as an emotional response to a disturbing event that alters experience and worldview, and its effects reside in bodies and can erupt unexpectedly. Care givers experience trauma when providing aid to those in need, as they absorb emotional shockwaves in witnessing pain.
The residual effects of stress and trauma lurk in the body. Care givers and more generally people of faith need to focus on bodies, since bodies both manifest stress and serve as resources of resilience. We can meet God intimately in our bodies through the practice of self-care.
This paper explores how biblical texts can inform our self-care against the backdrop of trauma, stress, and violence in order to live in right relation with God, self, and others. This view of self-care stands in contrast to some contemporary notions that reinforce a privatized, narcissistic sense of self. In critical conversation with biblical texts, this paper proposes a pastoral theological method in which “self” must necessarily include positive regard and deep respect for others.
Exegesis of biblical texts grounds the practical theological method and praxis developed in the paper. Attention will be given to: the prophet Elijah who encounters God’s presence in “sheer silence” (1 Kings 19:11-18), a call for readers to live more intentionally with wordless, contemplative practice; the two greatest commandments (Mark 12:28-31), that cement the God, self, neighbor bond; Jeremiah who unbinds himself (Jeremiah 11-20) in response to almost being shattered by the divine word (Heschel); David’s intimacy with God in dancing before the Ark (II Samuel 6:12b-14), strengthens him for leadership; and the paralyzed man whose friends seek his healing (Luke 5:17-26), becomes a model for self-in-relationship.
|
Historical and Methodological Considerations in Making Syriac Lexica
Program Unit: International Syriac Language Project
Srecko Koralija, University of Cambridge
The fact that Syriac is a language both in interaction with Hebrew and Greek [and Aramaic], and of literary production, represents an important challenge for theoretical and practical lexicography. In this respect, the aim of the paper is to highlight historical and methodological issues in the state of the Syriac lexicons. Two major tendencies in the history of the Syriac lexicography are examined. The first one is represented by lexicons that are either Syriac-Syriac or Syriac-Arabic oriented. The second tendency is connected with more recent lexicons (from the nineteenth century on) where one can detect a certain influence of Biblical studies and especially Hebrew lexicography. At least three methodological issues in the current state of Syriac lexicons can be highlighted. First, the layout and structure of these lexicons reflect very little of the insights provided by contextual analysis, semantic research and dictionary criticism. Even the most recent dictionaries for learning purposes follow the methods developed mainly by Brockelman and Smith. Second, the semantic model(s) underlying available Syriac dictionaries are either outdated, or represent a quite narrow version of what modern linguistics has to offer to Syriac lexicography [contextual information/definitions vs. glosses and the like] Third, the complexities arising from the NT (Greek/Syriac) and OT (Hebrew/Aramaic/Syriac) Peshitta scholarship are not always taken into account. The paper proposes a method of establishing the corpora and organising entries by paying special attention to methodological issues connected with the history of words and their context(s) of usage.
|
Object Marker(s) in Hebrew-Syriac Language Contact
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Srecko Koralija, University of Cambridge
Object markers in the Semitic languages have been a significant research subject (e.g., Khan 1984; Gibson 1994; Goldenberg 1995; Muraoka 1995; Hardy 2016). However, very few studies have considered the relationship between Hebrew and Syriac object markers in translating Biblical texts. In the Peshitta version Hebrew ʾt is very rarely rendered into Syriac by yt (in Gen 1:1; Song 3:4; and Eccl 3:17; 8:9, 15 only, but instead either by l- or not at all. Its presence in the Peshitta of Gen 1:1 motivated Nöldeke and Weitzman to argue that the fact that the particle had become obsolete suggests that Genesis was translated into Syriac no later than c. 200 CE. Their conclusion about the dating is probably based on the understanding that yt as a loan translation disappeared from Syriac very early. In Biblical Hebrew syntax, ʾt is not connected exclusively with object marking, but also has a broader, though optional, focusing or specifying function, in which it partially overlaps with l-. In this respect, the major concern of this paper is to investigate the patterns of occurrence of ʾt and l- in the book of Genesis and their overlap with the Syriac yt and l-.
|
The Rhetoric of King Eshmunazar’s Self-Description as an Orphan
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
Gideon R Kotzé, North-West University (South Africa)
The protection of vulnerable members of a community, such as orphans and widows, is a widespread theme in ancient Near Eastern literature. It is presented as the will of the gods, the virtue of kings, and the duty of the public not to mistreat these people. The theme is not only expressed in genres of Egypt and Mesopotamia, but also in Ugaritic texts, and ancient Hebrew writings. Some scholars even find it in the lines of the controversial Qeiyafa ostracon. The Kirta epic from Ugarit exemplifies how the theme is used as part of a rhetorical ploy. Yassib, Kirta’s son, wants his father’s throne, and accuses him of failing in his royal duties, which renders him unfit to continue his rule. Amongst other things, Yassib accuses Kirta of not judging the case of the widow and the wretched, and not taking care of the needs of the orphan and the widow. An equally interesting case where the theme is employed to good effect, appears in the Phoenician inscription on the sarcophagus of Eshmunazar II. In this inscription, the deceased king addresses prospective tomb robbers, and refers to himself twice as an orphaned son of a widow (lines 3 and 13). These references flank the part of the inscription where the king prohibits anyone from opening his sarcophagus in search of grave goods, and pronounces curses on those who would ignore his royal command. Scholars in the past have interpreted Eshmunazar’s self-description as an orphan literally, and have taken it to imply that he inherited the throne of Sidon as a fatherless child. The proposed paper, however, argues that the image of Eshmunazar’s as an orphaned son of a widow forms part of the inscription’s rhetorical endeavour to persuade the addressees not to disturb the king’s grave.
|
Humanity in the Hand of its Deliberation and in the Hand of its Maker: A Harmonized Reading of Sirach 15:11–20 and 33:7–15
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Rony Kozman, University of Toronto
Sirach 15:11–20 and 33:7–15 are significant passages with respect to Sirach’s portrayal of human freedom and its relationship to divine providence. Due to the emphasis on divine actions in Sir 33:7–15—including the picture of God as a potter—some scholars have suggested that human freedom in Sirach 15:11–20 is either heavily qualified so as to be subsumed under divine providence, and/or that the two passages are irreconcilable (Adams, 2008; Mattila, 2000; Collins, 1997). Others have harmonized human freedom and divine sovereignty (e.g., Wicke-Reuter, 2000). This paper argues that the parallel language and themes of Sir 15:11–20 and 33:7–15 demand a synoptic reading of the two passages. Sir 15:11–20 fills the gaps in the compressed logic of Sir 33:7–15 so that the sovereignty of the Creator to elevate some and to debase others is based on his knowledge of human actions. Thus, Sir 33:7–15 emphasizes the power of the Creator to execute judgment according to his knowledge of human acts.
|
Extending Text-Critical Tools: Visualisation of Space and Time, and Calculation of Palaeographical Proximity
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
Jan Krans, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam
Computational methods offer many possibilities of extending the tools of textual criticism. This presentation explores two new methods: spatial-temporal research and the calculation of palaeographical proximity.
As a test case, the many variants (readings, translations, and conjectural emendations) of Acts 2:9 are chosen. These variants will be analysed by means of interactive spatial-temporal visualisations, and by means of an algorithm for measuring palaeographical proximity between sets of variant readings. The two main two research questions are the following: 1. do these types of research indeed extend the analytical tools for studying variant readings? 2. do they offer better insights for the discussion of individual units of variation?
|
Hebräisches und aramäisches Lexikon zu den Texten vom Toten Meer
Program Unit: Qumran
Reinhard Kratz, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
The paper will introduce into the concept and achievements of the Göttingen Qumran-Wörterbuch (QWB) which is a long-term project funded by the Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Göttingen and directed by Reinhard G. Kratz, Annette Steudel, and Ingo Kottsieper. The project is based on an innovative and unique linguistic database, which contains transcriptions of the Dead Sea Scrolls – including all variant readings proposed in printed editions and other scholarly publications – along with lexical, morphological, grammatical, and bibliographical data. The first volume of this lexicon appeared in 2017, the publication of the second volume is scheduled for 2018. Funding ends in 2019, so the question of the future of this project will also be addressed.
|
Riddle and Revelation: The Re-use of Isaianic Prophecies within and outside the Book of Isaiah
Program Unit: Prophetic Texts and Their Ancient Contexts
Reinhard G. Kratz, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
The paper will differentiate between two modes of how biblical texts were re-used within and outside the Hebrew Bible: as riddle which has to be interpreted and as a revelatory source which gives (direct) access to the divine will. Examples are taken from the book of Isaiah. Here, the paper will focus on texts in Isa 5–11, especially 8:11–15, and their use in Isa 28–31, the book of Daniel, and in the Dead Sea Scrolls.
|
Vulgate, Targums, and the Text of the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Matthew Kraus, University of Cincinnati
Identifying the precise relationship between the Vulgate and Masoretic Text faces numerous challenges. The closeness of correspondence between the Vulgate and the MT depends on the biblical book. Moreover, since Jerome drew on his Hebrew, Greek and Latin Vorlagen individually and in combination and includes numerous interpretive renderings, the relationship of the Vulgate to the Hebrew text is layered and multifaceted. Expending the labor required to address these issues may even seem to be fruitless. After all, the discovery of the Dead Sea Scrolls has resulted in a diminished significance of the Vulgate as a textual witness for the Hebrew Bible. This paper explores the complexity of these issues by comparing parallels between the Vulgate and Aramaic Targums. Negotiating the intricate relationship between the Vulgate and text of the Hebrew Bible is worth the effort, for three reasons: 1) the Vulgate remains a valuable witness of the Septuagint tradition including the Old Latin and may be cautiously used to reconstruct the MT; 2) the well-established date of Jerome’s translation can provide a secure terminus ante quem for readings of the Hebrew text; 3) understanding the relationship between the Vulgate and the biblical texts of the Dead Sea Scrolls is essential for reconstructing the state of the Hebrew text in Late Antiquity.
|
Reading Texts and Reading Practice: Luke 4 in the Context of First-Century Synagogue Reading Practices
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Andrew R. Krause, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
In Luke 4, which emphasizes Jesus’ claims that he fulfills specific promises from the ‘book’ of Isaiah, Jesus is portrayed as reading from a scroll and teaching those assembled in a synagogue on the Sabbath. Many scholars of both the New Testament (e.g., François Bovon) and early Judaism (e.g., Asher Finkel) have taken these narrative movements as normative reading practices within such institutions and as proof for an early date for some form of Haftarot practice, while others have rejected it entirely as anachronistic (e.g., Howard Clark Kee). However, given the aforementioned emphasis of the passage and Luke’s purported non-Jewish tendenz, we have reason to test such assumptions. This paper will bring Luke 4 into conversation with the Theodotus Inscription (CIJ 2.1404), Josephus, Philo, and the Damascus Document regarding Jewish reading practices for sacred texts. In terms of material culture, the grooved podium at Magdala is a potential lectern, and the first-century synagogues of both Masada and Gamla may have included purpose-built repositories for scrolls. Finally, the burgeoning discipline of material philology has opened new avenues of studying the usage of extant first-century scriptural manuscripts. These avenues of inquiry will inform the discussion regarding the potential of ritually normative reading practices, the purity of sacred texts and spaces, and Jesus’ own exegetical and pedagogical methods during this axial time in scriptural and synagogue development. I will argue that some of what is recorded—such as the dialogical nature of the Sabbath teaching—should be considered veridical from a historical standpoint, other elements—such as the choreographic cues of sitting and standing—should be questioned as normative practices at this time, and still others—such as the reading of prophets in synagogues—are too ambiguous to draw firm conclusions in relation to the recorded actions of Jesus in this institutional setting.
|
Creational Blessings in Second Temple Prayer and Psalmody
Program Unit: Prayer in Antiquity
Andrew R. Krause, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
The Song of the Three Youths (Pr Azar 23–68//LXX Dan 3:46–90) records a series of creational blessings that begin in the heavenly throne room and work their way down to increasingly earthly regions. However, these serialized benedictions are not unique amongst Second Temple literature, as we find similar, though shorter, parallels in Ps 148, 4QBerakhot, and the Thanksgiving Hymn for the Sabbath in 4QWords of the Luminaries (4QDibHama 1–2 recto vii 4–9). Sir 43 is a similarly structured wisdom composition. By comparing the rhetoric of the various prayers and hymns in this literary form, we stand to clarify the purpose of this purportedly secondary Danielic composition. For example, while the other compositions end on Abaddon or Sheol, the Song of the Three Youths omits this chthonic space. However, its place is taken by the praise of the three themselves from the furnace, which may call into question the assertion that this singular mention of the three in the song is a clumsy interpolation. If this ironic correspondence is true, the (supposed) grave itself praises God, as it does in 4QWords of the Luminaries. Conversely, Sheol and Abaddon are only spoken of in subsequent curses as the places of Belial in 4QBerakhot. This alterity in other such texts raises questions of whether the Song of the Three Youths is likewise a self-glorification for a specific group and thus implicitly cursing others, despite the seeming universalism of a unified, praising creation. Spatializing the blessings of God systematically is in many ways a purposeful ordering of the cosmos to suit the authors. I will argue that the various creational blessings provide examples of various groups assembling a meaningful cosmology that complements their theologies, and in way that is amenable to the apocalyptic thought and tropes of the time.
|
The Torah Reading at Gilgal: More on the Riddle of 4QJosh-a Frg. 1
Program Unit: Transmission of Traditions in the Second Temple Period
Joachim J. Krause, University of Tübingen
Despite important work on the reading and interpretation of 4QJosh-a Frg. 1 done by Eugene Ulrich, Alexander Rofé, Ed Noort, Heinz-Josef Fabry, Kristin De Troyer, Michaël van der Meer, and Emanuel Tov, among others, there remain substantial questions to be resolved with regard to this fragment of a largely lost edition of the book of Joshua from Qumran. Essentially, there is still no consensus as to what scene is depicted at all. Building on the work of the aforementioned scholars, especially the approaches of van der Meer and Tov, as well as on my own analysis given in VTSup 161, and dealing with a number of convoluted epigraphical and philological questions, I will argue that 4QJosh-a Frg. 1 relates a Torah reading at the Gilgal campsite, that is, only after the Israelites completed crossing the Jordan.
|
Divine Revelations in Exile: Visual Portraits of Saint John on Patmos
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Karin Krause, University of Chicago
According to an early tradition, Saint John composed the Book of Revelation on Patmos after being banished to the island by Emperor Domitian as punishment for his Christian beliefs. In this paper, I explore the strong imprint that Saint John’s visionary experience and literary activities on the Aegean island have left in the visual arts, both in the Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox realms. Portraits of Saint John on Patmos were popular in Western European painting especially during the Renaissance and Baroque eras, but the subject is also encountered in narrative illustrations of the Apocalypse and its commentaries already in the early Middle Ages. Through iconographical analysis of select images that represent the saint as the recipient of divine revelations, I examine different manners in which the widespread narrative of John’s exile on Patmos is reflected in the visual sphere. While John’s relegation to a remote location is reflected, or even highlighted, in the majority of images that depict him as a visionary and writer, the idea of distress brought about by persecution and forced exile is absent from these images. This is all the more remarkable, given that hagiographical writings explicitly characterize Saint John’s banishment to the island as an act of unjust punishment. The visual compositions rather suggest that artists reinterpreted John’s exile in significant ways, conceiving of his isolation and solitude as a divine privilege. Through the careful spatial organization of their compositions and creative use of landscape elements, I argue, artists showcased John’s seclusion in order to present him as a specially chosen human recipient of visions and other divine revelations. I describe pictorial strategies that artists employed to juxtapose Saint John to hermit saints (e.g. Saint Jerome), who chose to live in self-imposed “exile.”
In contrast to the enormous popularity of illustrations of the Apocalypse in the Christian West, visual narratives based on the Book of Revelation are entirely absent from the Byzantine sphere due to the book’s contested status as part of the biblical canon. Yet, the tradition of John’s exile and activities as a writer on the island of Patmos remained popular in the Christian East as well; it mirrors the widespread understanding that the same John wrote both the Apocalypse and the Fourth Gospel. In Byzantium, the subject of Saint John on Patmos became common in the visual arts from the tenth century on. Icons, murals, and illuminated manuscripts from the Eastern Christian sphere reflect a widely acknowledged view first encountered in hagiographical literature of the Early Byzantine period that Saint John composed his Gospel during the time of his exile on Patmos. I demonstrate how Byzantine portraits depicting Saint John in the act of receiving the text of the Gospel through divine inspiration likewise highlight the solitude of the remote place as a precondition that facilitates divine revelation to humans.
|
Polis and Church in Galatian Ancyra
Program Unit: Polis and Ekklesia: Investigations of Urban Christianity
Jennifer Krumm, Kirchliche Hochschule Wuppertal/Bethel
The ancient settlement of Ancyra became a polis in the course of the foundation of the province Galatia around 25 BC. It was not only the most important city in the region but also the seat of the province governor. In the region, it was the administrational centre of a large territory consisting mainly of villages. A Christian congregation is traceable at least from the early 3rd century AD on. In this paper, I will analyse when and how Christians became visible in civic life. How did Christian life and self-expression in the city differ from that in the surrounding villages? Which forms of contact to Christian congregations in other places inside and outside Galatia can we find? Using mainly early Christian inscriptions from Ancyra, the paper aims to get a grasp of the lives of ordinary Christians in this Galatian city.
|
After Inculturation: The Many Faces of Jesus Christ in Asia Reloaded
Program Unit: Asian and Asian-American Hermeneutics
Volker Kuester, Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz
Jesus Christ has been depicted by Asian Christian artists as avatar, guru or bodhisattva as well as dancing Christ using the iconography of the Shiva Nataraja. In recent years in art galleries in Jakarta, Delhi, Shanghai or Seoul new images of Jesus occur in a secular context that at the same time create a new religious iconography. The paper will introduce a theory of Christian art in Asia from times of the silkroad to the 21 century and engage in a dialogue with artists like Vivek Vilasini (India), Zhu Jiuyang (China) or F. Sigit Santoso who are pioneers of a contemporary Asian Christian iconography beyond traditional Christian communities. How does all this contribute to the reception history of the bible beyond the written world and what does it contribute to the re/reading of Bible in the multi-cultural-religious Asian contexts?
|
Does "Philosophical Christology" Predate Paul?
Program Unit: Redescribing Christian Origins
Chris Kugler, Houston Baptist University
The last thirty years of NT studies has witnessed a rebirth of interest in the questions surrounding the complex relationship between early Christianity and ancient Greek philosophy, an interest both reflected and embodied in the work of scholars such as (e.g.) Malherbe, Meeks, Sterling and Engberg-Pederson. Over roughly the same period, and due in no small part to the influence of Hengel in Germany and of Hurtado and Bauckham in the United Kingdom, we have also seen a major resurgence of interest in the historical and theological questions surrounding the origins and contours of NT christology. Little explicit dialogue, however, has occurred between these two movements. Two principal factors likely explain this. (1) On the one hand, the philosophical studies are rarely concerned with the particular historical (and theological) questions surrounding the rise of christology (2) while, on the other hand, most studies of NT christology now assume that Greco-Roman traditions played little if any role in the rise of christology. In this vein, not only have too many NT scholars treated ancient Jewish monotheism and early christology as though they were discrete and impermeable entities, but they have simply failed to appreciate the significance of the use of ‘prepositional metaphysics’ in four of the most important christological texts in all of the New Testament. As several philosophical studies have shown (esp. Sterling and Cox), the consistent christological language of ‘by/through whom’ in John 1.3 (and 1.10); 1 Corinthians 8.6; Colossians 1.15–20 and Hebrews 1.2 clearly reflects the influence of philosophical intermediary speculation articulated via “prepositional metaphysics,” a kind of cosmological and theological “shorthand.” What is more, these texts are routinely and rightly thought to reflect even earlier christological traditions in which Jesus is portrayed as having an integral role in the creation of the kosmos, precisely the activity which most clearly demarcates the “unique divine identity” in the Jewish tradition. In this connection, it is extremely unlikely to be coincidental that precisely the four texts in the New Testament which so clearly include Jesus within the “unique divine identity” do so via the use of prepositional metaphysics. Hereby, we see that these four christological traditions attest to still-earlier christological reflection in which, having so thoroughly and unambiguously included Jesus within “the unique divine identity,” the prepositional metaphysics of the philosophical traditions were found useful in expressing a distinction within that divine identity. In other words, the presence of prepositional metaphysics in John 1.3; 1 Corinthians 8.6; Colossians 1.15–20 and Hebrews 1.2 demonstrates that at least as early as Paul (1 Cor. 8.6) and probably earlier Jewish Christians were already utilizing certain conceptual features of the Greek philosophical tradition so as more precisely to expound their “christological monotheism,” a fact which strongly militates against any over-simplistic historical narrative in which early Jewish christology was much later polluted (and obfuscated) by the importation of Greek metaphysical categories.
|
Jews, Torah, and Legal Pluralism in Hellenistic Egypt: An Assessment
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Robert Kugler, Lewis & Clark College
In a series of short articles published over the past years and in a forthcoming monograph I have evaluated the legal reasoning of the petitioners to the archons of the politeuma in Herakleopolis, Egypt (P.Polit.Iud. 1-12; Pap. Graec. Mon. 287 + 293; cf. SB 26.16801). My analysis makes the case that some of the litigants featured in these petitions knew and used Jewish "biblical" law, Torah, more often and with greater sophistication than is generally acknowledged, and that they occasionally engaged in legal pluralism, invoking not only Jewish law to make their arguments, but also Greek, and even Egyptian norms. Achieving these insights has depended on an approach that sets my work apart from that of others who have commented on the politeuma petitions: to highlight their unique features, I analyze the petitions within the context of the full breadth of relevant comparative material from the Ptolemaic period, and in evaluating the petitioners' arguments I am guided by a commonsense theory of lay legal reasoning and writing in Hellenistic Egypt. Using the same approach, in this paper I report on my examination of the only other petitions from the Hellenistic period that unquestionably feature Jews as supplicants to determine whether they add any evidence for the complex use of Torah that I posit from my study of the politeuma petitions. Seeing the influence of Jewish norms on the author of BGU 20.2847, who explicitly mentions Sabbath observance, requires no special approach; analysis of P.Tebt. 3.1.800 (=CPJ 1.133) gives some cause to think that the petitioner looked to Jewish norms to help make his case; and the petitioner responsible for P.Ryl. 4.587 (=CPJ 1.43) seems least likely of the three to have had Jewish law in mind in making his appeal. The paper concludes with a look forward to other legal genres in the papyrology database that may provide additional evidence for evaluating the use of "biblical" law, alone or in combination with other normative systems, among the Jews of Hellenistic Egypt.
|
Reading Proverbs 13:23 in Texts and Contexts of Africa’s Poverty: Case Study of East African Region
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Kuloba W. Robert, Kyambogo University
This study reads Proverbs 13:23 in conversation with the contemporary conceptualisation of trade approaches namely fair trade and free trade. The focus of the study shall be the East African region, though for purposes of illustrations, exampled shall be drawn from other Sub-saharan countries. The study attempts to answer the following questions: who are the poor in the text and its context? What is justice in the text and its context? How should the biblical understanding of these concepts and the concept of economic justice inform responses to Africa’s poverty? In this study, the assumptions made are that, African has been a victim of socio-economic and political injustices of the west, and that Africans are agents of their own poverty. The study takes a hermeneutical approach and multidisciplinary, drawing examples from the social sciences.
|
The Way Hebrews-Speakers Thought about “Love”: The Semantic Invariant as Culture Specific Cognition
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Hikaru Kumon, University of Wisconsin-Madison
The habits of personal interaction in a culture can seep into lexical meaning. The aim of this paper is to show (a) how one Hebrew verb, ʾahab, has a specific cultural meaning; and (b) how it differs in meaning from its conventional English translation equivalent “love.” The methodology that I use in this paper is the theory of the Natural Semantic Metalanguage (NSM). In terms of its semantic theory, NSM maintains that uncovering the semantic invariant is the goal of definition. The semantic invariant is a cognitive entity; any claim for invariance is testable, since variant usages, which are products of cognition, can be used to disprove claims of invariance. In NSM, emotions are viewed as culture specific entities. Although the universality of certain bodily sensations is unknown, it can be shown through examination of the distribution of linguistic usages of words in different languages, that the linguistic meaning of emotion terms differs widely among cultures. A comparative study of English “love” and Hebrew ʾahab shows that both share certain semantic components, but also that the semantics differ significantly in others. That is, English-speakers think about LOVE differently than did native Hebrew-speakers. This has important consequences for current studies on the lexeme ʾahab. The popular theory holds that ʾahab is polysemous, and that it can mean both “love” and “loyalty.” But this theory may be a product of an anglocentric way of thinking and, further, may be more of a claim about translational values rather than a claim about semantics. I aim to show through adoption of NSM, that it is possible to go beyond translation, and into the minds of ancient Hebrew-speakers.
|
Divine Human Interactions in Genesis through the Lenses of Race, Class, and Gender
Program Unit: Genesis
Raju D. Kunjummen, Emmaus Bible College
This paper addresses a salient issue pertaining to race, class, and gender in the book of Genesis touching on divine communication with and bestowal of status to those outside the line of Abraham.
The call of Abraham, followed by the confirmation of the promise made to him to his offspring (זֶרַע) through the line of Isaac and Jacob, is a defining fact connected with the Hebrew Bible. The significance of Abraham is also evidenced by relatively how much “ink” is given to him. And yet, in Genesis, the God of Abraham is hardly parochial or male-exclusive in his generosity or choice. The paper presents the following in support of this thesis.
1. Abraham’s call envisaged blessing to all nations (Gen 12:3; 22:18). This finds relevance later in the Hebrew canon (see Psa 47:9), particularly in the latter prophets. It also gets significant attention in the New Testament (Acts 3:25; Rom 15:8-10; Gal 3:8) and is central to Christian theology.
2. Divine generosity and election as found in Genesis are not limited by race and extend outside of the line of Abraham. To begin with, one may consider the divine dialogs with Cain. Secondly, it sets up Melkitsedeq, clearly Canaanite, whose later kin are destined in the oracle of Noah (Gen 9:25) for destruction and servitude, as a priest of ’El ‘Elyon (אֵל עֶלְיוֹן) and one whom Abram honors. Divine outreach in communication beyond the line of Abraham is also revealed by the dream communications to both a Philistine and an Aramean, albeit in connection with the preservation of Abraham and his descendant.
3. Divine direct communication also extends to women inside and outside the line of promise. God speaks with Sarah both indirectly (18:13) and then directly (18:15). Rebekah is not only able to inquire of YHWH (25:22—לִדְרֹשׁ אֶת־יְהוָה), God also answers her directly by speaking directly (25:23—וַיֹּאמֶר יְהוָה לָהּ) to her.
4. The most significant piece of evidence in this regard is connected to the person of Hagar: a non-Hebrew female slave. The divine appearance to and communication with Hagar is noteworthy from several points of view, not to mention the fact it happens more than once (16:7-14; 21:17-20). Only one of these is connected with direct consideration for the child that Abraham had through her. One may also note the significance given to her person, inasmuch as a place is called after the name Hagar gives it (16:13-14).
5. One might add to this argument additional evidences consisting of negative portrayals of the patriarchs relative to gentile characters (Abraham vs. Abimelek; the brothers of Joseph), or by this that a Canaanite female has more character and integrity than a patriarchal male (Judah & Tamar).
The paper will argue that our notions of how patriarchialism and parochialism color the narrative of Genesis ought to be tempered by the presence of these anomalous pieces of evidence.
|
The Meal in the Letters of Ignatius: Textual Variants as Evidence for Transforming Practice and Theology
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
Kevin Künzl, Technische Universität Dresden
The Letters of Ignatius have a particularly complex textual history as they exist in three different recensions of varying length, theological profile, and historical background. Most scholarship has tended to focus on the supposedly “original” middle recension, whose rich metaphorical language has often been interpreted as referring to a Christian meal in which bread and wine were consumed as flesh and blood of Christ. Such “realistic” readings have been challenged in recent studies (e.g. Heilmann 2014) which highlight the complex function of the used imagery in their argumentative contexts. Textual variations between individual manuscripts and recensions, however, point towards the fact that the understanding of the Letters’ metaphorical language indeed changed over time and against the backdrop of a transforming ritual practice and meal theology. By applying the working hypothesis of the network “Mahl und Text” to selected passages in the Letters of Ignatius which—at least in some recensions and manuscripts—deal with the Christian meal, the proposed paper aims at making some of these diachronic developments visible.
|
A Reanalysis of Or-Constructions in Masoretic Biblical Hebrew
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Itai Kuperschmidt, Tel Aviv University
The classical analysis of ‘or’-constructions, introduced by Grice (1989) and Horn (1972), is based on truth-conditional semantics. It assumes that ‘or’ has a linguistically encoded inclusive meaning, namely that at least one (and possibly all) of the alternatives are true, and a predominantly exclusive reading, whereby not only at least, but also at most one alternative is true, although the speaker does not know which it is. This analysis has recently been challenged by Ariel and Mauri (in press). Adopting a bottom-up usage-based approach to language, they propose that a reading of or-constructions must capture speakers' intended messages in each case. But while they have dealt mainly with spoken English, it is instructive to apply their approach to different corpora of different languages, such as biblical Hebrew. The study presented here focuses on ’o, the Hebrew equivalent of ‘or’, as a dedicated disjunctive connective (Brown, Driver & Briggs 1968; Waltke & O’Connor 1990; Joüon & Muraoka 1996), and its 319 tokens in the various genres and books of the Hebrew Old Testament, as represented in the Tiberian Masoretic version. The data were analyzed by a comparative linguistic and textual method, also taking into consideration findings from other versions of the Bible and later literature. Following Ariel and Mauri, a rich variety of readings of or-constructions has been revealed, in two of them speakers not necessarily being committed to even one of the alternatives. Providing many examples, this reanalysis contradicts the widely accepted classical analysis, seeking to propose a better understanding of or-constructions in Masoretic Biblical Hebrew.
|
Sin and Its Remedy in 2 Corinthians
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Dominika Kurek-Chomycz, Liverpool Hope University
Sin and Its Remedy in 2 Corinthians
|
The Greek Job and the MT Job: Rewritten and Changed Texts
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
JiSeong James Kwon, Universität Zürich
The Greek version of Job (Septuagint-Job) that is one-sixth shorter than the MT-Job is not simply the translation of the MT Job. The author of the Septuagint-Job reorganizes and reinterprets the tradition of Job and in particular the MT-Job by contextualizing it for the broad audience in Hellenistic Alexandria. For instance, “Keren-Happuch” (42:14) in the MT-Job is replaced by the name “the Horn of Amaltheia” in the Greek version, and the Septuagint-Job avoids various names of God in the MT-Job such as El, Elohim, Shadday in the poetic dialogue (except for 12:9), but employs the term κυριος equivalent for the Tetragrammaton. The Septuagint-Job, moreover, sidesteps theologically sensitive issues by omitting and reworking passages of the MT-Job; e.g., Job in the Greek book is less antagonistic to God and God is less negative than in the MT Job. This paper, thus, will trace how characters of the protagonist Job, Job’s wife, and God in the Greek Job are changed from those in the MT Job and will explain he changed ideas and concerns in the Septuagint –Job compared to the MT-Job.
|
A Suitable Match: Eve, Enkidu, and the Boundaries of Humanity in the Eden Narrative and the Epic of Gilgamesh
Program Unit: Genesis
Will Kynes, Whitworth University
What does it mean to be human? This perennial question is of primary if not principal concern in both the Eden Narrative (Gen 2-3) and the Epic of Gilgamesh. Though the texts' anthropological reflections have frequently been compared, their shared emphasis on the basic human need for companionship has generally been overlooked. Juxtaposing the two texts' depictions of this theme provides new insight into both how they respectively present it and the issues of anthropology and gender which have overshadowed it. When comparisons have been made, focus on the possible parallel between Eve and the harlot Shamhat, who initiates Enkidu into human civilization (e.g., Bailey 1970; Veenker 1999), has obscured Eve's resonance with Enkidu, created to be a match for Gilgamesh as Eve was for Adam. This paper combines the texts' common delineation of the boundaries of humanity between the divine, which is widely observed, and the animals, which is less frequently discussed, with the fact that both also present the divine creation of an appropriate companion for their heroes, to reflect on the respective anthropologies of the two texts. As Wolff (1969, 394) observes, "One of the oldest and simplest ways of describing man's place in the world is to set him between animal and god; but these elements are often mixed, notoriously so in ancient Near Eastern art and literature." The match created for the semi-divine Gilgamesh is the male, semi-bestial Enkidu, however Adam's "helper" is a female, explicitly contrasted with the animals, who is "bone of [his] bones and flesh of [his] flesh." Though the heroes of the Epic constantly struggle at the boundaries of humanity, the Eden Narrative depicts its view of humans, male and female, together created distinct from god and animal, though likewise compelled to acknowledge their limitations.
|
God as a Gleaning Cook
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Antje Labahn, Kirchliche Hochschule Wuppertal/Bethel
In LamLXX 2:20 God appears as a cook, but the food he is preparing is somewhat special. God is presented as cooking small late grapes. In the context, the negatively characterized process of gleaning works as a model for total destruction that leaves nothing behind. By this, the notion “a cook gleans small grapes” (2:20) turns into a cognitive metaphor for exile affecting various social groups, including those ones that used to get spare from harm. Like the notion of gleaning implies, the conception of LamLXX favors the idea of total destruction where all potentials in life are left behind. On one hand, the metaphor recalls the traditional notion of Judah as vineyard, and on the other hand it favors the conceptual idea of the process of gleaning as model for exilic devastation. LamLXX presents a new interpretation in adding further text over MT elaborating its own conception. This paper provides a small insight into my commentary on Lamentations as part of the project “Brill Commentary on the Septuagint”.
|
Whose Power – That of the Devil or of God? Intratextual and Intertextual Reflections on the Demonization of Political Power in Q
Program Unit: Q
Michael Labahn, Martin-Luther-Universität Halle-Wittenberg
To understand the concept of power in Q, the third temptation in Q:5-8 could be taken as a starting point. Access to power (rulership over the kingdoms of the world) is offered to Jesus by the devil, who wants to hand them over to Jesus if he accepts his power by his proskynesis. The offer is refuted by Jesus referring to God’s claim for unique worship.
The main part of the paper will consist of intratextual and intertextual reflections on the contrast of political power and of God’s power in Q. The devil’s offer will be read in contrast with 10:22 (in Q 4, Satan wants to hand over everything to Jesus the Son of God under certain conditions, but in Q 10 Jesus has handed over “all” as the son of the Father). In a second step, the offer to hand over power over the kingdoms of the world will be read in light of the Roman ritual of proskynesis, which is a subordinating act which may include religious undertones that accept the power of the winning Roman ruler / emperor by an opponent. Fulfilling the ritual is done with the hope to get reinstalled into the original power / position under Roman rule after proskynesis. The offer of the devil in the third temptation could be read as a travesty of such a ritual.
The comparative studies will teach about how to understand the relation of political power and of God’s power in Q.
|
On the Road: Itinerant Priests and the "Edomite" Shrine at Tamar
Program Unit: Israelite Religion in Its Ancient Context
Mark Lackowski, University of Notre Dame
According to many scholars, Josiah’s religious reforms in the land of Judah significantly disrupted the socio-religious life of itinerant priests serving various communities throughout the Judean countryside “from Geba to Beer-sheba” (2 Kgs 23:8). Indeed, the centralization of the cult in Jerusalem and the destruction of certain altars (mizbêaḥ) and high places (bāmôt) would have effectively forced many local priests into retirement as they would be unable to fully participate in the official cult at Jerusalem (2 Kgs 23:9). If this were true, then not only would rural Judeans find themselves cut off from immediate access to clerical divination and mediation, but also non-Judeans journeying through the region who relied upon the same religious services. One place that may have been affected by these possible reforms is the southern fortress of Tamar and its accompanying cult site, which is often referred to as the ‘Edomite’ shrine. This shrine potentially presents, then, illuminating insights into some regional practices of Southern Israelite religion during the Iron Age II period. However, due to the uncertainty of when, why, by and for whom the shrine was used, and then later destroyed, scholars have been unable to determine the exact nature of the site. Therefore, in this paper, I will explore the archeological and textual evidence and argue that the site functioned as a polytheistic roadside shrine that primarily served laborers and traders passing through the crucial junction at En Hazeva. Furthermore, I will posit that the site was under Judean control up until the Babylonian conquest of Jerusalem in 597 BCE. Accordingly, it will be shown how the variety of cultic objects unearthed at Tamar, including Judean and Edomite religious paraphernalia, exemplify the type of religious diversity found throughout preexilic Israel and Judah.
|
The Sheep and the Son of Man: Metaphoric Texture of Matthew's Apocalyptic Discourse
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Elekosi Lafitaga, Graduate Theological Union
Greg Carey and others have described heuristically for us "apocalyptic discourse" and Vernon K. Robbins have refined it as referring to the constellation of apocalyptic topoi of "...early Jewish and Christian descriptive, explanatory, and argumentative discourse." I choose for this paper to view "apocalyptic" as describing, at the least, communication of esoteric knowledge between the heavens and earth, or to use a more popular term, as describing revelation. Central to these are modes of communication through visions, dreams, and heavenly imageries. I entertain the possibility that the revelation or the communication of esoteric knowledge is the apocalyptic discourse referenced above. This paper examines metaphoric texture in apocalyptic discourses of the New Testament in relation to earlier writings of Jewish apocalypses. What influential extent do metaphors in early Jewish Apocalypses have in possibly shaping later Christian traditions? Is it possible that we may find in the use of metaphors a cognitive link between early Jewish apocalypses and later apocalyptic discourses of the New Testament? If so, what emerged in Jewish Apocalypses and apocalyptic discourses of the New Testament via the use of metaphoric textures? What are the implications of this link to our understanding and description of apocalyptic discourse? This paper examines the sheep metaphor in Mt 25:31-46 and its possible cognitive relations with the Animal Apocalypse of the first book of Enoch, chs. 83-90, which is dated to the second century BCE. In light of the Son of Man figure, a topos of Israel's relationship to humanity and creation seems to have emerged metaphorically in the Animal Apocalypse and refined in Matthew's apocalyptic discourse.
|
Rider of the Clouds in Ugarit and the Hebrew Bible: Cognitive Aspects in Myth Transmission
Program Unit: Bible, Myth, and Myth Theory
Lauri Laine, University of Helsinki, CoE: CSTT
In this presentation, I will approach the question of the possibilities of cultural transmission between Late Bronze Age Northwest Semitic mythology and the Hebrew Bible from perspectives provided by the field of Cognitive Science of Religion. This question has received scholarly discussion since the first Ugaritic texts were discovered from the North-Syrian coast in the late 1920's. There are many textual and thematic similarities between these two text corpuses, especially in their mythology. Nevertheless, there are obvious divisions between them: Ugaritic mythological texts were written somewhere around 1400-1200 BC, and even the earliest Hebrew Bible texts originated at least six- or eight-hundred years later in a completely different cultural context. Because of both the geographical and chronological distance between these texts, one cannot simply show any straight connections between them. A better question is therefore whether the Late Bronze Age Northwest Semitic culture has influenced the Southern Levant and its mythology, the traces of which can be found in the Hebrew Bible. I will approach this question with the case study example of the Rider of the Clouds imagery in Ugaritic mythology and in the Hebrew Bible, examining the connections between the two. In this way, I will also consider questions such as what makes a mythical image and a conceptualization of divinity so adhesive to human cognition that it becomes part of the entire culture's worldview, and how do these conceptualizations tend to transmit from one culture to another?
|
Polysemy, Metonymy, and Metaphor: On the Semantics of Biblical Hebrew hatta’t and ’ašam
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Joseph Lam, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
The Biblical Hebrew terms hatta’t and ’ašam, denoting the two main categories of expiatory offerings in the Priestly literature, have long been points of special focus in attempts to uncover the logic of the Priestly sacrificial system. Within these attempts, many scholars have asserted the inadequacy of the traditional renderings of these terms as “sin-offering” (for hatta’t) and “guilt-offering” (for ’ašam), arguing instead (typically) for “purification-offering” (for hatta’t) and (to a lesser extent) “reparation-offering” (for ’ašam) for reasons functional, etymological, theological, and otherwise. However, a point that has rarely been given adequate attention in these studies is the polysemy that these terms display, in that they denote both the offering in question and some negative condition that the offering ostensibly addresses (i.e., “sin” or “guilt,” if indeed these are the best translations for hatta’t and ’ašam respectively). This paper will draw out the full implications of this most conspicuous semantic feature of the terms hatta’t and ’ašam, arguing that the offering names were most likely derived through metonymic extension of the abstract terms themselves, and then exploring the metaphorical effects that such polysemy makes possible in ritual-legal discourse both within and outside the Priestly literature.
|
Summer of '69: Reviving Libertas and the Odium of Kingship in Mark’s Gospel
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
Mark Lamas Jr., California State University, Bakersfield
The Gospel of Mark stands out uniquely from the other gospels in its understanding and presentation of Jesus’ kingship. Matthew, Luke, and John’s Gospel positively assign Jesus the title “king” (βασιλεύς) and in fact such a status remains integral to each gospel’s characterisation of Jesus (e.g. Davidic typology in Matthew and prophecy in Luke.) and his mission (e.g. Lk. 19:38; Jn. 18:37). Mark’s gospel is strikingly variant, missing opportune moments to align Jesus and other positive characters (e.g. David) with royal themes, and especially the title βασιλεύς. Mark utilises the term βασιλεύς twelve times in three clustered units (Mk 6:14, 22, 25, 26, 27 // 13:9 // 15:2, 9, 12, 18, 26, 32) and each are overtly negative. The episode of John’s martyrdom (6:14-29), for example, has Mark assigning the title βασιλεύς to Herod, who in the other gospels and historical fact retained only the title of “tetrarch”. Mark’s use here may have intended to marry Herod’s tyrannical behaviour to the ideas associated with kingship at the time of Mark’s writing. More pointedly, from Julius Vindex’s revolt against Nero (c. March 68CE) to 73CE (Vespasian’s fourth year in power), the political concept of libertas (“liberty”) had been revived. Political libertas had its origins in that transitional period when Lucius Junius Brutus had exiled Rome’s last king, Tarquinius Superbus, and initiated the Republic. In Roman memory, libertas meant Rome’s “liberation” from kingship (regnum) and was inextricably tied to the L. Brutus narrative. As evidenced in both the literary sources and numismatic material, the rebellion faction of Vindex and Galba (Mar. - 9 June 68CE) uniquely utilised political libertas, associating Nero with the kingship/tyranny motif of King Tarquin and L. Brutus’ subsequent exiling (and later Cicero and Marcus Brutus with Julius Caesar). Moreover, libertas was not an isolated ideology connecting itself only to the rebel movement of Vindex and Galba in the west, but also extended to Vitellius in the north, Clodius Macer in the south, and Vespasian in the east. The ripples caused by the civil wars, and its popular libertas propaganda, reverberated throughout the empire during the years that many scholars date Mark’s gospel (68-73CE). I argue that Mark’s reticence to name Jesus βασιλεύς was influenced by the libertas memory and the lingering despotism of Nero, which would have negatively associated kingship with tyranny, thus compromising Jesus’ message received by Mark’s audience.
|
The Ideology of Interpretation
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
David Lambert, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
This paper examines a number of literary moments in ancient Judaism that have been identified in recent scholarship as significant sites of interpretation: inner-biblical exegesis, Rewritten Scripture, and the Pesher form. The stated goal of such scholarly activity has been to ease the apparent divergence between these phenomena and later more explicit forms of exegesis, such as are found in rabbinic literature. The Pesher form, in particular, is often seen as a watershed moment in which the underlying reality of interpretive activity achieves explicit formulation. But do texts assigned to these categories really envision themselves as operating within an interpretive relationship to the Bible? Does a singular rubric, “interpretation,” suffice to describe the range of conceivable relationships between readers and texts? What is imported or presumed when “interpretation” is used as a catchall category for analyzing such relationships? Are other modes of relating to texts available? What is at stake ideologically in the rampant identification of various ancient literary phenomena as interpretive within certain circles of the field has yet to be adequately considered.
|
Toward a Philology of the Self in the Hebrew Bible and Beyond: A Few Preliminary Sketches
Program Unit: Philology in Hebrew Studies
David Lambert, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
This paper will consider some of the methodological difficulties involved in our understanding of biblical Hebrew terms that, in contemporary translations, have come to be associated with such categories of the modern self as emotion, cognition, and mind. It is now a commonplace within historical, anthropological, and other forms of social scientific inquiry that different cultures can produce sharply differentiated accounts of the person, that is to say, that our sense of self is, in good measure, socially constructed. This understanding has yet to be incorporated into our understanding of the biblical lexicon. Part of this resistance has to do with the conservative quality of lexicographic practice, but it also relates to the peculiar position the Hebrew Bible occupies in the imagination of much critical inquiry as a source for the modern West. This paper will highlight a few examples where common translation equivalents, such as “anger,” “memory,” and “desire,” seem to fail in rendering their underlying Hebrew terms. The suggestion will be made that these failures can be partially accounted for by changing notions of the self.
|
“When You Fast”: An Ecojustice Approach to Fasting in Light of Eastern Orthodox Tradition
Program Unit: Biblical Exegesis from Eastern Orthodox Perspectives
Jeffrey S Lamp, Oral Roberts University
In the Sermon on the Mount, Jesus addresses three aspects of the spiritual life—alms, prayer, and fasting—setting up his teaching on these topics with the assumption that his followers would indeed practice these disciplines. One can find many texts and traditions within Judaism that may provide the source for a trajectory to Jesus’ teaching, but that just pushes the question back one step: what gave rise to this teaching or tradition?
Restricting the focus to fasting, various patristic writers have argued that fasting is intrinsic to the order of creation from its very beginning. The command of God to the first humans not to eat from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil is widely viewed as the source for the Christian practice of fasting. Failing to obey God’s commands to fast from eating the fruit of this tree, human beings essentially forsook their vocational mandate to function as priestly co-regents of God’s benevolence in the world (Gen 1:26-28; 2:15), disrupting the harmony of the triad of God/human beings/other-than-human creation.
Here we see the ethical import of Jesus’ call to fast. Fasting recalls the original human vocational mandate to care for God’s creation. Its contextual connection to prayer and almsgiving in Jesus’ teaching highlights that fasting is both a spiritual discipline and an ethical act. As practiced in the Orthodox tradition, fasting connects with ecological concerns for the earth—is our consumption of meat, largely provided by mass production facilities, a faithful expression of our call to care for the earth? It also connects with economic justice—is, for example, corporate agriculture a just expression of social concern for poor workers or family farmers? Fasting becomes a spiritual practice not just by virtue of its ascetic character, but also due to its rather visceral ability to align human beings with the call to fulfill their vocational mandate to protect and serve the earth.
|
A People Called by My Name: Ecclesiology Read Ecologically
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Jeffrey S Lamp, Oral Roberts University
Discussions of ecclesiology and environment often focus on initiatives within the polities of major denominations. Often such initiatives, rather than originating within the institutional structures of these churches, come from parachurch organizations, such as A Rocha or the Evangelical Environmental Network. Whether from within or outside of the church, typically initiatives derive from the general notion that care for creation is an appropriate endeavor for churches. Little attention is directed toward a biblical and theological analysis of the justification for viewing creation care as intrinsic to ecclesiology. Creation care is merely something some churches sometimes do.
This paper will argue that a crucial aspect of the metanarrative of the Bible is the creation of human beings to be the priestly co-regents with God to extend God’s benevolence throughout creation. With the “fall,” portrayed in Genesis 3, the relationships within the God/human/other-than-human triad were corrupted. God’s restoration project, rather than constituting a rejection of the original design for creation and for the place of human beings within it, is actually a restoration of human beings to their role as priestly co-regents with God within creation. This paper will examine four major covenants within the biblical narrative—Noahic, Abrahamic, Mosaic, and the new creation in Christ—to illustrate that these covenants are framed such that they reassert and reaffirm the vocational mandate given to Adam (cf. Gen 1:26-28; 2:15). The climactic stage in covenantal progression, the new creation in Christ, will receive detailed attention, focusing on New Testament portrayals of Christ as the “new/second Adam.” The argument of the paper is that in Jesus Christ, the human vocational mandate to care for creation has been recapitulated, so that all those who are in Christ are united with Christ in the renewed human vocation to care for creation. This suggests that a significant function of the church of Jesus Christ, the spiritual descendants of the second Adam, is to engage in the renewed Adamic vocation to care for creation as was intended for the offspring of the first Adam.
|
Wounds and Healing, Dew and Lions: Hosea's Development of Divine Metaphors
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Mason Lancaster, Wheaton College (Illinois)
Wounds and Healing, Dew and Lions: Hosea's Development of Divine Metaphors
|
Telling the Difference between Canonical and Apocryphal Sayings of Jesus: It's Harder than You Think
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Brent Landau, University of Texas at Austin
In my course on the Christian Apocrypha, I have the students play a game called, "Canonical or Apocryphal Saying of Jesus? You Decide!" The game consists of ten sayings of Jesus, and students attempt to determine whether a saying is canonical (that is, from one of the four NT gospels) or apocryphal (from the Gospel of Thomas). The students who score the highest on the game receive a free book of their choice. This exercise helps students to see how difficult it is to determine whether a given saying is canonical or apocryphal on the basis of content alone, and assists in breaking down preconceptions about the "strangeness" of the Christian Apocrypha in comparison to the NT gospels.
|
Marrying (Off) and Marginalization: Hagar and Ishmael in Light of Cuneiform Law
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Yael Landman, Brooklyn College (CUNY) and Gorgias Press
Discussion of the legal background to the narratives involving Hagar and Ishmael (Genesis 16-21) has primarily focused on the legal status of Hagar vis-à-vis Abram and Sarai (later renamed Abraham and Sarah) and the mechanism whereby Ishmael becomes a son to the patriarch. Rather than focusing on the formation of these familial relationships, this paper examines their dissolution, with particular attention to Hagar’s acquisition of custody and her right to marry off Ishmael in Genesis 21:14-21. This text records the expulsion of Hagar and Ishmael from Abraham’s home. The narrative utilizes a number of legal expressions to depict Ishmael’s expulsion specifically as a transfer of custody from Abraham to Hagar. Legal idioms and terms in the narrative include 1) l-q-ḥ ‘take’ and n-t-n ‘give’, an idiom for transfer; 2) n- ś-ʾ ‘lift’, which has a transactional valence; and 3) ḥ-z-q + yād ‘grasp + hand’, an idiom with a parallel in clauses about custody in Mesopotamian marriage contracts. In her marginalization from Abraham’s home, Hagar ultimately also gains rights, and this paper contextualizes these shifts in power against their ancient Near Eastern backdrop.
|
Of Loss and Lambs: A New Understanding of Genesis 31:39
Program Unit: Philology in Hebrew Studies
Yael Landman, Brooklyn College (CUNY)
In Genesis 31:39, Jacob defends his conduct as a shepherd, claiming that he never brought a torn animal to Laban, and then continuing with the words: ’ānōkî ’ăḥaṭṭennâ. The meaning of the verb ’ăḥaṭṭennâ, as well as the syntactic relationship between these words and the preceding colon in Gen 31:39, has generated ample debate. Scholars such as J. J. Finkelstein have commonly understood ’ăḥaṭṭennâ on the basis of the Biblical Hebrew root ḥ-ṭ-’ in the G-stem (‘to err, to miss’) and the Akkadian nouns ḫīṭu and ḫiṭītu (‘loss, damage’). This interpretation has yielded translations along the lines of, “I myself made good the loss,” i.e., I paid for the torn animal (instead of bringing it to Laban). In this paper, I point to difficulties with this and other translations. I propose a new interpretation of the word ’ăḥaṭṭennâ in this verse, based on the cognate Akkadian verb ḫuṭṭû (‘to damage, to injure’). I argue that this part of Gen 31:39 refers not to the torn animal, but to animals that Jacob might have injured accidentally. I further relate this interpretation to biblical law and cuneiform legal documents relating to herding.
|
The Child in Isaiah 1–11
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Francis Landy, University of Alberta
Isaiah 7-11 is full of images of children, who are “signs and portents” from YHWH (8.18), signifying the new age and evoking the emotional and cultural associations of children in antiquity. Isaiah 7-11 is unique in its concentration of child imagery, both in Isaiah and in the Hebrew Bible. I will be using D.W.Winnicott’s theory of the “play space” and the “transitional object.” Winnicott argued that a child acquires its ability to interact imaginatively and creatively with the world through the creation of a “play space”, filled with transitional objects, like teddy bears, which are both under the control of the self and acquire a certain independence. For the play space to flourish, there must be a safe maternal ambiance. The book of Isaiah is concerned with the imagining of a utopian ideal in the midst of catastrophe, a safe homecoming. We begin with Shear Yashuv, the child who accompanies his father in his fateful encounter with the fearful king. He says and does nothing, but through his name he embodies the ambiguous future of Israel. He is a witness to the prediction of the birth of Immanuel, whose maternal diet is the precondition of preternatural knowledge. Other children are Maher-Shallal-Hash-Baz, child of female as well as male prophecy, whose first words will be preceded by the destiny he portends, and the Davidic heir in 9.5-6, who is an eternal father as well as a newborn child. Finally, we will turn to the shoot from the stump of Jesse in 11.1-9. I will argue that Zion is a maternal space, in which the suckling is able to play among the peaceful animals, under the aegis of a protective father. The sequence is contrasted with the generally negative images of sons in chapters 1-3.
|
Bathsheba: From Trauma Victim to Un-named Wife
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
Peter T. Lanfer, Occidental College
The un-naming of Bathsheba in the genealogy of Jesus in Matthew is a source of interpretive confusion. On might read the mention of “the wife of Uriah” as a recognition of David’s adultery in the context of the genealogy’s embrace of scandal in naming Tamar and Rahab as ancestors of Jesus. Yet, that reading does not explain why Bathsheba is un-named in the text. This paper will argue that the un-naming of Bathsheba should be read in the context of the general trend in Jewish literature of the Second Temple period to cleanse morally ambiguity from the life of David. With respect to Bathsheba, this process begins with the book of 1 Chronicles 3 which renames Solomon’s mother Bathshua the daughter of Ammiel. Additionally, while Uriah the Hittite is mentioned in the list of David’s mighty men in 1 Chr. 22:41, there is no mention of his wife, let alone David’s various schemes against the faithful Uriah in 2 Samuel. Why then does Uriah appear in Matthew’s list while Bathsheba is removed? Rather than reading Uriah’s presence in the list as a strike against David’s morality (thereby unmasking David as adulterer), the genealogy allows the reading of the un-named Bathsheba as a bereft widow and mother of the chosen son, while David is transformed into the un-named woman’s righteous redeemer. This cleansing of David is influenced by the literature of the Second Temple period and has a lingering effect on the perception of David in the early patristic literature in which David is idealized as the righteous recipient of the messianic promise of 2 Samuel 7 and king “after [the LORD’s] own heart” (1 Sam. 13:14).
|
The Religious Memory of Antisemitism
Program Unit:
Armin Lange, Universität Wien
Antisemitism has often been described as the longest hatred (Robert Wistrich). In recent decades, antisemitism has again been on the rise in Europe, the United States, and the Middle East, often reinvigorating antisemitic stereotypes that reach back centuries if not millennia. One of the most important results of the 2018 conference "An End to Antisemitism!" was the attention addressed to the cultural and religious memories that enabled and enable Jew-hatred over millennia. The holy scriptures of Christianity and Islam, as well as interpretive traditions connected with them, are important memory spaces that help to communicate the stereotypes of Jew-hatred through the ages. Strategies to enact religious and cultural forgetting are thus crucial to combating the "longest hatred."
|
The Hebrew Text of the Bible between the Dead Sea Scrolls and the Masoretic Text
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Armin Lange, Universität Wien
The time after the destruction of the Herodian temple in 70 C.E. and the earliest copies of the Masoretic manuscripts in the ninth century C.E. has always been regarded as a dark age of the textual history of the Hebrew Biblical text. Only very few manuscripts exist from this period and quotations of Hebrew texts in Rabbinic and Patristic literature as well as in inscriptions do not provide much evidence either. This presentation will try to reconstruct the textual history of the Hebrew text of the Bible based on the existing evidence. Despite some indications for limited textual variety, the remaining textual evidence points to a dominance proto-Masoretic biblical texts in the time for the first through the ninth century C.E. The faithful transmission of the proto-Masoretic text was achieved through procedures of textual maintenance.
|
A New Solution to the Riddle of Timothy's "Stomach and Frequent Ailments" (1 Timothy 5:23): Sins, Signs, and Stigma in Ancient Philosophical and Medical Diagnosis.
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Andrew M. Langford, University of Chicago
Why does the author of the New Testament pseudepigraphon 1 Timothy include a remedy for Timothy's stomach ailments in 1 Timothy 5:23? It is surprising that this is included in the letter at all, much less in the midst of what is by most scholarly accounts a loosely held-together admonition on elders and the sometimes evident and sometimes invisible misdeeds of those who err (1 Tim 5:17-25). What is the resulting image of Paul and his ailing protege Timothy because of this comment? Turning to ancient moralists, orators, physiognomists, and medical practitioners for a fresh perspective, I argue that an interpretive key resides in the diagnostically oriented discourses of the first and second centuries CE that privilege scrutiny of appearance and deeds—both seen and unseen—in the task of medical and moral assessment. I show how the passage 1 Timothy 5:17-25, with 1 Timothy 5:23 at its center, revolves around the problem of error, its perspicuity or hiddenness, and Paul's concern to train Timothy to render moral diagnoses and avoid even the appearance of evil. In this paper, I offer a reading of this passage as a unified series of admonitions to Timothy on the treatment of sin and its various real manifestations (i.e., regarding elders) and the appearance of excess (i.e., Timothy), and how the would-be church leader like Timothy should deal with them. I also argue that the scholarly focus on whether or not Timothy's ailments are the result of over-zealous ascetic practices or whether they are designed to address age-appropriate drinking habits obscures the author's rhetorical goal in this passage. More likely, I suggest, the author is here constructing a depiction of Timothy as sick for the purposes of establishing the authority or stature of Paul as a moral and physical medicus, a remediator par excellence, who knows how to heal and tend to the needs of Timothy and the church, whether physically, spiritually, or theologically. At the same time, "Paul" is also training Timothy, coaching him, and giving him diagnostic pointers. There is an attempt by the author to craft an image of Paul as the wise purveyor of protreptic, prophylactic, or remedial advice. The verses regarding the errors of the elders suggest that a similar logic is at work in the discussion of both the elders' sins and Timothy’s ailments—they both can be construed as a threat of moral stain to the pure status that Timothy is supposed to cultivate for the sake of the church (1 Tim 5:1, 22). With attention to ancient ideologies of body and soul and the moral stigma that was historically attached to certain illnesses, I offer a reading of 1 Timothy 5:17-25 as a coherent and unified piece of advice that depicts Paul as a sage physician and Timothy as his somewhat sickly diagnostician in training.
|
Nehemiah as a Mnemonic Bridge to the Heroic Past: Remembering the Figure of Nehemiah as a Patron for the Hasmoneans
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Tim Langille, Arizona State University
This paper examines the memory of the figure of Nehemiah in 2 Maccabees. Nehemiah’s military prowess, piety, and association with the second temple made him an ideal patron for the Hasmoneans (Blenkinsopp 2009: 174-75). The common themes between narrative in 2 Maccabees and the figure of Nehemiah include the following: reform, rededication, re-establishing ancestral traditions, defending Judah against external enemies, restoring and preserving cultic purity, the legitimacy of the high priesthood, and rebuilding the homeland (Blenkinsopp 2009: 175-76). Moreover, it is significant that 2 Macc. 1:18 identifies Nehemiah, and not Zerubbabel and Jeshua, as the figure who establishes the first altar and builds the first temple. Importantly, Nehemiah resumes temple sacrifices and reignites the sacred fire after the destruction of the temple (1:19-36). As such, Nehemiah’s sacrifices and purifying fire (νέφθαρ) correspond to the culminating moment in 2 Macc. 10:1-8. Additionally, the figure of Nehemiah’s collection of books about kings, prophets, and the writings of David, and the letters of kings about votive offerings (2:13) corresponds to Judas’ collection of books lost during the war of independence (2:14). In fact, 2 Maccabees even mentions the memoirs of Nehemiah as a source (2:13). Finally, the figure of Nehemiah connects the Hasmoneans to the heroic past, namely those of Solomon and Moses, through fusing together the festival of booths, or Sukkoth, with Hanukkah.
|
Hard Hearts, Blind Eyes, and Deaf Ears: A Literary Comparison of Sura 7:179, Isaiah 6:10, and Matthew 13:15
Program Unit: The Qur’an and the Biblical Tradition (IQSA)
Stuart B Langley, Southern Baptist Theological Seminary
This paper will investigate the sense-related aphorism in al-Araf 179—“They have hearts with which they do not understand, they have eyes with which they do not see, and they have ears with which they do not hear—in comparison with the literary function of the same aphorism found in Isaiah 6 and Matthew 13 in order to determine 1) whether the saying corresponds more closely to the context of the New Testament or of the Hebrew Bible and 2) what affect this determination will have on the understanding of predestination within the sura as a whole. I will conclude that sura 7:179 is most closely related to a translation of the Hebrew Bible and that it is not, as has been assumed, a statement of divine determinism.
This argument will proceed in three steps. First, a brief introduction will discuss the methodology and scope of this work followed immediately by a history of scholarship on the subject. Next, this paper will compare the narrative function of sura 7:179 to that of Isaiah 6:10 and Matthew 13:15 in order to argue that sura 7:179 most closely reflects the literary context of Isaiah, not Matthew. While Matthew’s use of the aphorism is in the context of Jesus’ parabolic teaching and the ‘mysteries of the kingdom,’ the aphorism in Isaiah functions to describe the prophetic ministry against an obdurate people. Finally, in order to demonstrate the value of identifying the connection between sura 7:179 and Isaiah 6:10, I will discuss how it can shed light on the Islamic debate on divine determinism and human autonomy. Ultimately, this paper will conclude that the purpose of sura 7:179 is to demonstrate that the people’s disbelief is not based on Muhammad’s ineffectual preaching but rather, like the prophets before him, Muhammad was sent to a people who hardened themselves against the message of their prophet. Although they have the sense-ability to recognize the Prophet’s message, they refuse to use them as a means to understand more about Allah. While it may be true that the Qur’an suggests a deterministic understanding of reality elsewhere, my contention is that sura 7:179 serves instead as a comforting message to the Prophet in response to the people’s apparent rejection of him as Prophet.
|
The Syntax of הן Clauses in Aramaic Inscriptions from Maresha
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Michael Langlois, Université de Strasbourg
This paper will present a syntactical study of הן clauses in Aramaic inscriptions found during archaeological excavations at Maresha compared to other Aramaic corpuses and dialects.
|
Speaking Scripture, Confessing Christ: The Prophetic Voice of Argula von Grumbach
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Beth Langstaff, Institut zur Erforschung des Urchristentums
The pamphlets written by Bavarian noblewoman Argula von Grumbach in the early 1520s provide us with the earliest biblical interpretation by a woman within Lutheran circles. One of the most striking characteristics of her exegesis is the stress not only on reading scripture—although she repeatedly urges the study of the Bible—but on confessing and preaching the word of God, in private and in public. The first part of this paper will consider how Argula von Grumbach grounds this public confession in scripture. One key text, quoted throughout her writings, is Mt 10:32-33 (“Whoever confesses me before another…”; cf. Luke 9:26). Argula von Grumbach cites this text in the opening lines of her famous 1523 letter to the University of Ingolstadt, using it to frame and to explain her public defence of a young student accused of heresy. She feels herself bound by this text, which, in her view and experience, overrides I Cor 14:34 (“Women should remain silent”). Secondly, Argula von Grumbach not only stresses the biblical command to make a public confession of one’s faith; she also takes the biblical words as her own. She joins her voice to that of the prophets (thus, citing Jer 22:29, “I cry out with the prophet”) and of the apostles (“With Paul, I say…”). Using the text of scripture, and claiming the Spirit’s inspiration (Mt 10:19-20, Joel 2:28), she speaks words of exhortation and encouragement (the promise of blessing if the gospel is preached to the poor), of warning and judgment (the boiling pot of Jer 1:13 which will be poured out on the land), to the leaders of her own time.
|
Mythology Reflecting from the Inscriptions of Voluntary Associations: οἱ μελανηφόροι Worshiping Isis.
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Elina Lapinoja, Helsingin Yliopisto - Helsingfors Universitet
This paper examines the ways mythology is reflected from the inscriptions of voluntary associations, especially focusing on the inscriptions linked to the cult of Isis and to her companion Gods. Isis, as an original Egyptian Goddess, was gradually introduced to the cities of Greek and Rome, similarly her religious attributes were gradually connected to already excising religious beliefs and joined together with the indigenous Gods. For example, an aretalogy found from Maroneia in 1969 connects Isis to Greek Gods Sarapis, Helios and Selene. Furthermore in other inscriptions, Isis is separated
from her Egyptian origins and given a place in Greco-Roman family tree of Gods (see e.g. Inscriptions REG 42, and RICIS 114/0202).
The inscriptional materials, discussed in this paper, do not generally espouse long mythological explanations, but are more focused on the matters of the everyday life, such as: dinners or rules, or they are epitaphs. And because of this, one must accept that the nature of the evidence limits the degree which we can found mythological elements from the inscription. This, however, does not mean that there are not any mythological aspects in the writings, on the contrary, mythological elements can be read through used language, ceremonies, rules, and gifts bestowed by the benefactors and to the benefactors. This paper will analyze these reflections of mythology of Isis by asking, for example: Why are worshipers of Isis addressing themselves as blackwearers (οἱ μελανηφόροι), or how the fact that Isis was popular amongst therapeutists (θεραπευταὶ) refers to her mythology? Furthermore, the aim of this paper is to understand how the cult of Isis evolved when moving from its birthplace to new areas around the ancient Mediterranean.
|
Peddlers versus the Prosopon: Paul’s Public Speech in 2 Corinthians and the Politics of Divine Warrant
Program Unit: Speech and Talk in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Benjamin Lappenga, Dordt College
Drawing on Marie-Josèphe Rondeau’s magisterial work on the patristic exegesis of the Psalter, Matthew Bates’ recent monograph gives attention to the importance of “prosopological exegesis” (exégèse prosopologique) in the Pauline letters. Found in philosophical literary criticism within the pagan world as well as scriptural exegesis within Judaism and Christianity, prosopological exegesis is a reading technique used by an interpreter to overcome an ambiguity regarding the identity of the speaker of a divinely inspired source text. By assigning nontrivial “prosopa” (the “masks” of Greek tragedy and comedy which designate character types), rhetoricians craft speech that evokes an emotive response (as was taught by ancient rhetoricians such as Ps-Demetrius), and interpreters likewise assign special, often divine, importance to the speech of a given character. While Bates and others have explored the implications of this technique for understanding Paul’s theological purposes, this paper considers a lesser explored dimension of Paul’s references to speech in 2 Corinthians: the public and political implications of speech that claims a divine warrant. While Stoics such as Heraclitus might invent an in-character speech to exonerate Homer from the charge of promoting morally reprehensible gods (All. 62.1–2), Paul goes a step beyond this with his prosopological exegesis. In 2 Cor 4:13, Paul posits Christ as the speaker of Psalm 115:1 LXX (“I believed, and so I spoke”), but then Paul claims the same for his own speech (and seemingly that of the Corinthian believers as well). He says, “we also believe, and so we speak,” and claims to have “the same spirit.” While these claims are certainly relevant for Paul’s participatory soteriology, I argue that these verses (insofar as they represent a divine warrant) are also crucial for understanding Paul’s broader defense of his message. They are part of Paul’s rhetorical strategy, to be sure, but Paul’s repeated attention to speech within the wider community means that these verses also pertain to questions about the expectations and contours of public speech in the context of first century Corinth. The paper traces Paul’s references to his own speech in 2 Corinthians, beginning with his distancing his speech from that of “peddlers” in 2:17 through the famous “fool’s speech” in chs. 11–12, and puts Paul’s discourse into conversation with discourse about philosophers and other public speakers in the works of writers such as Lucian.
|
Biblically Re-drawing the Rhetorical Map
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Lillian I. Larsen, University of Redlands
The particular role that maps have played in rhetorically framing, engaging and instantiating both ancient and contemporary hegemonies, makes it difficult to ignore the persuasive power of cartographic configuration encapsulated in Luther and Calvin’s assessment that nothing can communicate the ‘truths’ of Scripture ‘better than a map’. Given this frame, in identifying the common core of maps included in sixteenth century bibles, Catherine Delano-Smith offers a provocative register for engaging the pedagogical predispositions that have rhetorically shaped cartographic refractions of the New Testament landscape (Delano-Smith, 1989). Drawing on Delano-Smith’s defining emphases, this paper ‘maps’ a trajectory that begins with the Geneva Bible and extends through contemporary ancillary supplements. It then traces more marginal manifestations in complementary textbooks, and popular instructional media. As well-iterated interpretive patterns affirm the rhetorical power of rendering authoritative texts as “mapped surfaces” (Harley 1989), attendant analysis explores the definitive pedagogical roles that maps – whether historical or contemporary, overtly ideological or scientifically ‘objective’ – have played in communicating and/or masking a prescriptively “biblical” worldview (Larsen and Benzek 2016). The paper concludes with an invitation to imagine a range of more malleable curricular models; each critically aimed at re-drawing the rhetorical map, by re-purposing the pedagogical goals for putting biblical texts on a map.
|
Carceral Geographies in Late Antiquity
Program Unit: Social History of Formative Christianity and Judaism
Matthew Larsen, Princeton University
Ancient prisons are largely gone, yet there is ample evidence to suggest that such places must have been fairly common sites across the ancient Mediterranean basin in both classical and late antiquity. For instance, according to Vitruvius, each city ought to have a prison attached to its forum-and the two should share similar proportions (De arch. 5.2.1). Incarceration is here taken to mean the experience of having one's body held in a place involuntarily due to perceived criminality or some other offense: whether it be a public prison, private prison, military prison, debtor's prison, convict labor in the mines, and so forth.
While carceral geographies are largely gone, this paper investigates two known carceral places from antiquity and late antiquity. First, the Mamertine (Tullianum) prison in Rome, a famous prison mentioned by many writers from classical to late antiquity. By the end of late antiquity, it had become a site of cultic activity associated with the imprisonment of Peter. Second, the Wadi Faynan copper mines (known at the Phaeno mines in ancient sources) south of the Dead Sea, where many late ancient writers imagined Christians sent as carceral subjects to do convict labor. Archeological as well as textual evidence exists related to both places.
This paper uses the concept of third space/place developed by theorists bell hooks, Homi Bhabha, and Edward Sojo to consider the real as well as the imagined carceral geographies of different Christian communities in late antiquity. It measures the degrees to which Christian memory and imagination map onto (or, conversely, transmogrify) the carceral geography as understood from material, archeological, and documentary evidence. The paper gestures towards what it might look like to have a poetic of carceral places in the pre-modern world.
|
In Search of a Childhood Studies Perspective: Theoretical Considerations on a Maturing Field
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Mikael Larsson, Church of Sweden
The quest to explore children or childhoods in relation to biblical texts is no longer a new one and may include as various methodological approaches as the historical situation of children, their narrative function in texts or children’s agency as receivers of tradition. Ten years after The Child in the Bible (Bunge 2008) and one year after Childhood in History (Aasgaard 2017, from the project “Tiny Voices from the past”) it is fitting to reflect on the status of this cross-disciplinary field. Rather than a general survey of what ground has been covered, I am specifically interested in the theoretical potential of reading biblical texts from a childhood studies perspective. To my knowledge, no consensus has yet been reached, neither in defining the characteristics of such a perspective, nor with regard to terminology. A first step towards such a goal would be to assess a few of the proposals presented so far, for example Julie Faith Parker’s “childist”, Reidar Aasgaard’s “childish” and Laurel Koepf-Taylor’s “child-centered” interpretations. What are the strengths of these different ways in conducting childhood studies? Is it possible to identify specific areas in need of further theorizing?
In this regard, I am interested in the level of engagement with other critical theories and how it can be developed further. It is for example difficult to imagine childhood studies without feminism and yet the relationship between these traditions of scholarship include conflict and diverging interests. I therefore want to ask whether it is possible to pinpoint a specific contribution of childhood studies that goes beyond an intersectional feminist analysis. To that aim, I propose to offer a theory-oriented discussion on a few significant works, above all by the already mentioned scholars.
|
Not So Vain After All: Hannah Arendt’s Reception of Qohelet
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Phillip Michael Lasater, Universität Zürich
This paper examines Hannah Arendt’s reception of Qohelet, whom Arendt quotes in order to illustrate an understanding of the world that she finds contrary to her own. However, her critical comments about Qohelet are premised on a problematic translation of the phrase hakkol hebel, which Arendt interprets as a claim that human, worldly life is meaningless and not worth pursuing. Ironically, though, once this issue of translation is addressed, Qohelet’s outlook appears substantially parallel to Arendt’s on at least three issues that occupied her attention: the civic virtue of amor mundi, the nature of action, and human nature. After discussing these three areas, the paper will briefly treat these two authors’ stances on the relationship between human nature, thinking, and evil, attending to a divergence between Arendt and Qohelet on this point.
|
Jesus and Synagogue Access in First Century CE
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Richard Last, Trent University
A peculiar feature of synagogue stories in the NT Gospels is Jesus’s ability to walk into any synagogue he wishes, uninvited, and speak – even though he is a non-resident/non-member. No other textual references to Palestinian synagogues paint a picture of unqualified free access, whether they are the town-assembly type or the association type. In rare instances when non-residents/non-members are attested in Palestinian synagogues before III CE, they are visitors using hospitality services or guests invited to town assemblies or association communal meals. This paper highlights clues about synagogue accessibility, and brings into the discussion comparative data from governing institutions in other small locales (e.g., Athenian demes and Roman vici). Stories of Jesus freely entering synagogues are best analysed from literary, not historical, perspectives – much like Luke’s stories of Paul and the synagogues. The paper concludes with some suggestions about the literary function of depicting Jesus as having free access to synagogues.
|
Toward a Pre-Chalcedonian Dating of John the Solitary
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Ethan Laster, Abilene Christian University
This paper considers evidence for the timeframe of John the Solitary's life and work. Specifically, it advances the thesis that John the Solitary wrote prior to the Council of Chalcedon in 451 CE. The argument relies on three pieces of evidence: the paleography of the earliest extant manuscript containing John’s writings, John’s Christological language, and his reception by later, theological diverse Syriac authors. In part one, I suggest that our earliest manuscript of John’s works—dated to 581 CE, containing nine diverse texts, and displaying considerable editorial markings—places Mar John firmly within the fifth century. This manuscript provides an initial parameter from which the internal evidence of John’s writings must be considered. Part two, which comprises the main thrust of my argument, contends that John’s Christological language is pre-Chalcedonian. Not only does John appear to be unfamiliar with the Chalcedonian theology and terminology, but his language also lacks the polemic and semantic nuance that characterized much of the Christological discussions among Syriac-speaking Christians post-Chalcedon. Thus, the most plausible explanation for John’s language is that he wrote prior to the Council of Chalcedon in 451 CE. Third, I briefly suggest that later reception of John’s is futher evidence of a pre-Chalcedonian dating. That writers from two distinct post-Chalcedon Syriac traditions—Philoxenos from the miaphysites, and Issac of Nineveh from the dyophysite Church of the East—demonstrate knowledge of and made use of John’s writings suggests that he wrote at an earlier time period when his language did not betray Christological commitments that would be distasteful to the various streams of Syriac Christianity. In closing, the paper considers the significance of a pre-Chalcedonian dating of John, and suggests future avenues of research that are necessitated by my argument.
|
"Old Hags and Stags": The New Year in the Late Antique Latin West
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Jacob A. Latham, University of Tennessee, Knoxville
During the late Roman republic, the Kalendae Ianuariae (January 1-3) witnessed two relatively modest rites: the consuls of Rome took up their office and small gifts were distributed. During the consular inauguration ceremonies, the consuls-elect processed on foot from their homes surrounded by an entourage of lictors, equestrians, and senators to the Roman Forum and then up to the sanctuary of Jupiter Optimus Maximus, where they presided over their first meeting of the senate. On the same day, Romans more broadly prayed for an auspicious New Year and handed out small gifts to the familia (the household) and friends. The more rowdy and boisterous festivities typically associated with New Year's celebrations seemingly took place a week or so earlier during the Saturnalia, a topsy-turvy, Bakhtinian winter solstice carnival.
In Late Antiquity, by contrast, while other festivals (like the Saturnalia) were targeted by imperial sanction and episcopal rhetoric, the Kalends of January not only endured but seemingly expanded, despite episcopal criticisms. The consular inauguration took on "triumphal" overtones, the consuls themselves were now carried on their curule chairs-emperors may have rode in triumphal chariots-and consular games were given on January 3. Similarly, the traditional rites become more raucous and riotous-a day to celebrate "the joys of the world and the flesh, with the din of silly and disgraceful songs, with disgraceful junketing and dances," as Augustine lamented in the early fifth century (Serm. 198.1). A generation later, Peter Chrysologus, the bishop of Ravenna, complained that "a full-fledged workshop of idols is set up… They fashion Saturn, make Jupiter, form Hercules, they even exhibit Diana with her young servants, they lead Vulcan around roaring out tales of his obscenities" (Serm. 155a). Caesarius of Arles (503-543) likewise denounced those who masquerade as "old hags and stags" (Serm. 13.5). Such merriment, "singers parading the streets in 'pagan' fashion, shouting and chanting sacrilegious songs and loading tables with food day and night," seems to have continued in Rome into the mid-eighth century (Boniface, Ep. 40/50).
As the Saturnalia was steadily suppressed, it seems that its characteristic festivities were transferred to the Kalends, a holiday which endured, in part, because it was specifically protected by imperial law. As Fritz Graf has recently suggested, the Kalends with its notably non-theophoric name were more readily rendered religiously neutral, which allowed the emperor to protect it and its displays of imperial social belonging, the vota on January 2 and the games on January 3. This imperial insulation enabled the Kalends to survive and even flourish. That is, the imprimatur of imperial law blunted the force of episcopal condemnation, allowing non-Christians and Christians alike to develop the festival in a myriad of local ways. Imperial authorization fostered popular culture in the Greek east, the Latin west, and even, perhaps, Muslim North Africa.
|
The Other Source Criticism: Teaching Students to Evaluate Their Sources
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Jonathan D. Lawrence, Canisius College
Whether they use internet search engines or library databases, few of my students have much sense of how to evaluate sources. To be honest few of them even use library databases. Left to their own devices, they'd just use the first search results and stop there. They find lots of information but have no idea how to evaluate it. What's a prof to do? I have several homework activities that ask them to find and evaluate sources and each major writing assignment asks them to evaluate their sources. I will briefly discuss my observations after several years of emphasizing this in my classes. I will also share some of the web resources that I have found useful, including a widely-used rubric for analyzing the relevance of sources.
|
Metaphors of Sensory Impairment in Gospels Worlds
Program Unit: Senses, Cultures, and Biblical Worlds
Louise Lawrence, University of Exeter
Using Susan Sontag's classic works on Illness as Metaphor (1978) and Aids and Its Metaphors (1989) this paper will trace the ways in which a range of images (military invasion, plague etc.) are employed in relation to sensory impairment and disability in the gospels and their associated sensoria. Sontag's work alerts the interpreter to the ways in which those sensory impairments, often perceived as 'incurable', become potent carriers of socio-political commentary for the evangelists.
|
Grace Aguilar on the Law of the Jealous Man (Numbers 5:11-31): A Nineteenth-Century Engagement with England’s "Others"
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Bernon Lee, Bethel University (Minnesota)
This paper reads Grace Aguilar’s exposition of the law of the jealous man in Numbers 5:11-31in her 1851 biography of biblical women, The Women of Israel against the backdrop of Anglo-imperialism’s nineteenth-century constructions of the ‘other.’ It argues that the author’s view of the ancient Israelites, despite being a defense of Israelite jurisprudence, accords with the hegemonic norms of the time in finding an essential(ized) difference between East and West. The disagreeable bits to the law are the traces of Israel’s backward Near Eastern heritage. In this way, the interpretation of the law charts a progressive path to English cultural, moral, and aesthetic supremacy in its mapping of the ancient Mediterranean mind. Yet, Aguilar is ambivalent in this project. As a member of the Sephardic Jewish minority on the fringes of English society, she cannot embrace completely Anglo-imperialism’s norms. In pressing for a reading of the rule as a reasonable and compassionate containment of Eastern ‘passion’ with its violent proclivities, Aguilar shuttles between sympathy for Israel and distance as an occidental observer and critic. Sitting between cultures, she crafts a defense for the ritual as a law remarkably progressive in its time and place, but still superseded by Western ‘enlightened’ thinking. The interpretation of the rite, alas, reads as an ambivalent apology for Israel’s law, with a reticence necessary to Aguilar’s location.
|
The Rhetoric of Empathy in Hebrews
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Chee-Chiew Lee, Singapore Bible College
Scholars have long noted that the author of Hebrews frequently attempts to arouse emotions (such as fear, confidence, shame, honor) in his audience in order to steer them towards faithfulness to God. Although empathy is a recurring motif in Hebrews, there is yet a more systematic and comprehensive explication on how the author uses empathy as a form of pathos to achieve his rhetorical goals. This paper takes an interdisciplinary approach by drawing insights from modern social psychology to identify descriptions of empathy in the relevant ancient literature and to enhance our understanding of the rhetorical goal and effects of arousing empathy. We will first examine how emotions comparable to empathy are used in Greco-Roman and Jewish rhetoric contemporaneous to Hebrews, so that we may establish whether empathy is indeed a form of pathos known during that era and compare them with the author’s use of empathy. Thereafter, we will examine the passages in Hebrews that: (1) describe the empathy of Jesus, Moses, and the audience; and (2) seek to arouse the audience’s empathy, in order to understand how the author uses empathy for his rhetorical purposes. This paper demonstrates that, in line with the use of pathos in ancient rhetorical practices and the understanding of the effects of empathy in modern social psychology, the author of Hebrews arouses the affective empathy of his audience as a catalyst to induce them to help fellow believers who are suffering due to their faith in Christ. Also, Jesus and Moses are not only cited as exemplars of empathy for emulation, but Jesus’ ability to empathize is an important motivation for believers to approach him for help. These rhetorical effects are not only key to maintaining the individual’s faithfulness to God, but also to create community support for maintaining each other’s faithfulness to God in the face of pressures and opposition from the outsiders.
|
A Theology of Facing Persecution in the Gospel of John
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Chee-Chiew Lee, Singapore Bible College
Many scholars have written on the topic of suffering in Matthew and Luke, but few have explored the issue as found in Mark or John. The paper aims to explore the distinctive approaches of the Fourth Gospel, and what they add to our understanding of the subject.
|
Ahn Byung-Mu’s Biblical Hermeneutics and Mark as the Story of the Jesus-Event
Program Unit: Korean Biblical Colloquium
Jae Won Lee, Independent
This paper aims to critically review the work of Ahn Byung-Mu, one of the pioneers of Korean Minjung theology, who made an enormous impact on Korean biblical scholarship. I will revisit Ahn’s interpretation of the Gospel of Mark as minjung’s story of the Jesus-event and its significance for the formation and development of Korean minjung biblical hermeneutics over the past decades. The focus on discussion will concern three core themes integral to Ahn’s minjung biblical hermeneutics: the relationship between “Jesus-event” and minjung, the Gospel of Mark as the story of minjung, and the so-called ochlos (ὄκλος)-minjung theory. In particular, I will reassess (1) Ahn’s political hermeneutics of the Jesus-event from the perspective of both Galilean minjung in the past and Korean minjung in 1970’s and 80’s; (2) Ahn’s characterization of the story of Mark as ochlos’s social memory of resistance and liberation, especially by deploying the notion of “political rumors” transmitted through oral communication, and (3) Ahn’s unique conceptualization of ochlos in Mark as a collective notion referring to the social lowly, analogous to the Korean minjung. At the end, after a brief comment of some methodological problematics in Ahn’s hermeneutics, I hope to address the enduring challenge that Ahn’s biblical hermeneutics bears on the present and future Korean biblical interpretation.
|
Redefining Early Christ Movement Meals
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Jin Hwan Lee, University of Toronto
There is a scholarly consensus that all kinds of banquets in the ancient world belonged to the so-called common meal tradition, and much study of banqueting practice alluded to in the NT has often been scrutinized in light of the model constructed from the works of ancient writers such as Plato, Xenophon, Plutarch, Lucian, and so on. Without a doubt, the banquet practice of Greco-Roman private associations belonged to the common meal tradition, which shared banquet customs and ideology; nonetheless, data from associations provide a somewhat peculiar banqueting practice apart from that found in ancient literature, particularly on topics involving membership, provisioning method, seating practice according to flat hierarchy, menu items, and some kinds of honour and shame codes at table fellowship (i.e., community rules and absenteeism). This paper appeals a usefulness of association meal data for understanding ancient communal periodic meals, including meals in the Christ groups.
|
Meals for All, All for Meals
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
Jin Hwan Lee, Independent Scholar
Current research on early Christ group meals puts a huge premium on the poverty-wealth gap of members, assuming that the poorer side played very little roles in provisioning meals. What has been argued or assumed throughout the centuries is that early Christ group’s communal periodic meals, such as the Lord’s Supper in Corinth, Agape meals, and etc., were basically nutritional meals where the wealthier members always had to take care of the poorer members. Such a view, however, raise a question regarding survival of the meals based on economic realities. This paper scrutinizes associations’ communal periodic meal dynamics and suggests that early communal periodic meals were run economically with minimal menu items, that is, early meals were not really nutritional based, but rather performance oriented meals that put a premium on members’ participation and proper behaviour at the table.
|
Greek Idiom in the LXX-Pentateuch: The Preposition para
Program Unit: Greek Bible
John A L Lee, Macquarie University, Sydney
The preposition para occurs 225 times in the LXX-Pentateuch. How is it used and what does it correspond to in the Hebrew original? This paper presents the results of an analysis of all the uses and the Hebrew matches. It will show that this preposition renders a great variety of equivalents and is also used in free renderings. The conclusion will be drawn that the choice of para is not due to consistent matching with any Hebrew equivalent but is determined by the needs of the context. It will also be shown that all the senses of para in the LXX-Pentateuch are in accordance with Greek usage. Parallels will be presented from contemporary Greek documents.
|
Engaging with the Homogeneous Unit Principle Based on a Linguistic Investigation of Ephesians 2:11–22
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
John J. H. Lee, McMaster Divinity College
The so-called Homogeneous Unit Principle (HUP) proposed in the 1970s by Donald McGavran (1897–1990), the Fuller Missiologist, claims that, if church planters focused more on a linguistically, culturally, and ethnically homogeneous people, church planting and church growth can be much more effective and powerful. This paper takes issue with the implications of this church-growth theory, and it engages with the HUP based on the insights gained from a systemic functional register analysis of Eph 2:11–22.
|
The Holy Spirit: 1 Enoch, the Deluge, and Babel in a Fourteenth Century Homily for Pentecost
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Ralph Lee, SOAS University of London
This paper presents the most important aspects of the homily for Pentecost from the collection known as Retu'a Haymanot. The homily draws on 1Enoch, other Ethiopian Enochic traditions, and the accounts of the Deluge and the Tower of Babel and develops a thorough Ethiopian Orthodox understanding of the Holy Spirit. The work has significant connections with other important Ethiopian theological works from the 14th century which will also be analysed.
|
Deuteronomistic Redaction of the Abimelech Narrative (Judges 8:29-9:57)
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
LEE Sui Hung Albert, Chinese University of Hong Kong
The connecting paragraph (Jdg. 8:29-35) between the Gideon Story and the Abimelech story summarizes the sin of Israel in a Deuteronomistic formula. In particular, they are sinful of rebelling against both YHWH and Gideon. Other than this Deuteronomistic comment, many scholars does not find Deuteronomistic framework in the remaining part of the Abimelech Narrative (Jdg. 9). Some scholars attribute the conclusive comment (9:56-57), which echoes Jotham’s curse, to a Deuteronomist redaction. However, other scholars find the same theme of retribution in wisdom tradition or religious texts of other deities. In other words, the conclusive comment is not necessarily Deuteronomistic.
This paper rather finds more Deuteronomistic elements hidden throughout Judges 9. For instance, the noble trees’ refusal of kingship offer hints a sin of Deuteronomistic formula. In particular, they enjoy producing their fruits to please Elohim, the plural deities (9:9, 13). This religious sin echoes Abimelech’s reliance on the silver from the Baalist temple (9:4) to support his reign. Likewise, Jotham blames the Shechemites for rebelling against Gideon in a Deuteronomistic sense of covenantal loyalty. (9:16-20, 57). This paper further finds the consensus of the trees to establish a king in the Jotham fable distinguished from the competition among trees for kingship in other ancient disputation poems. I thus hypothesize that the Jotham fable was redacted and used by the Deuteronomist(s) to possibly degrade the bloody competition for kingship in the Northern Kingdom or Babylon. In brief, the Abimelech Narrative has more elements of Deuteronomistic redaction than previous scholars suggested.
|
Fallen Under the Assyrian Chariot: Identification/Interchangeability of Enemies and Wild Animals in Ashurnasirpal’s Reliefs
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Woo Min Lee, Georgia Central University
In this paper, I would like to explore the identification/interchangeability of the images depicting human enemies and wild animals in Ashurnasirpal’s reliefs. The enemies are usually shown in the military campaign reliefs, and the wild animals, including lions and bulls, are described in the hunting reliefs. A close comparison between the defeated enemies and the hunted animals in the hunting reliefs reveals they have fallen in similar or even identical positions under the Assyrian king’s chariot. Thus, their images seem to be identified or interchangeable with each other. This identification/interchangeability is not a coincidence; it reveals that the military campaign reliefs and the hunting reliefs are an elaborately formularized visual message to the audience regarding the ideology of the dominant Assyrian kingship over chaos in the human and natural worlds.
|
Therapy of Desire: Hellenistic Philosophical Ethics and James, 4 Macc, Test. XII, and Philo
Program Unit: Bible and Ethics
Mari Leesment, Wycliffe College, University of Toronto
The Hellenistic Philosophical approach to ethics has been described by Nussbaum (1994) as Therapy of Desire in her influential monograph by the same name. This approach to ethics—the approach of the popular Hellenistic schools of the Epicureans and the Stoics—conceives of philosophy/reason as a cure for desires or passions. There are a number of aspects of the theory, but a central task of ethics qua ‘therapy of desire’ is to control or extirpate desires and passions. Although Nussbaum’s theory described Hellenistic philosophical texts, a number of texts from Hellenistic Judaism and early Christianity exhibit a heightened concern with control of desires and passions as essential to the ethical task. This paper will compare 4 Macc Test. XII, Philo, and the NT letter of James within the framework of Therapy of Desire. More specifically, I will look at the heightened significance of desires/passions in these texts, and trace how they are conceived of as significant to ethical practice. The paper argues that these texts exhibit a conception of ethics that is in the same discursive arena as the ancient ethical approach of therapy of desire—a discourse that can re-frame how we understand ethics in these texts. At the same time, these texts also conceive of ethics in relation to Jewish (and Christian) tradition; for example, we find a heightened concern with the 10th commandment—itself adjusted to the more generalized ‘do not desire’. Through this selection of texts, and focusing only on the control and extirpation of desire, we will trace out the various ways that desires/passions are dealt with in the texts and how they function as part of ethical practice.
|
Wisdom, Piety, and Integrity
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Michael Legaspi, Pennsylvania State University
TBD
|
Claiming Expertise: Strategies of Knowledge Making in Talmudic Traditions
Program Unit: Religious World of Late Antiquity
Lennart Lehmhaus, Freie Universität Berlin
Claiming Expertise: Strategies of Knowledge Making in Talmudic Traditions
|
Hello from the Other Side: Women and Resurrection in Apocryphal Acts
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Outi Lehtipuu, University of Helsinki
Dead women speak in several of the apocryphal acts. They can speak since they are raised from the dead by an apostle. In the Acts of John, Drusiana recovers her life in a peculiar episode which teaches the true meaning of death, life, and resurrection. She shows that a believer lives even though she be physically dead and a disbeliever is dead even if he be raised up. In the Acts of Thomas, a young woman who is restored to life recounts what she saw in the other world and many become believers because of her testimony. Both narratives teach that the true world lies beyond the physical world and the true resurrection means conversion, a transfer from death to life. A third dead woman who speaks appears in the Acts of Paul and Thecla. She is Falconilla, the daughter of Queen Tryphaena. She is not raised from the dead but through her the hearers of the story will also learn what the life to come is like.
|
Duke Does Exegesis: Modes of Interpreting Scripture in Ellington’s Three Sacred Concerts (1965–1973)
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Joel LeMon, Emory University
In the final years of Edward Kennedy “Duke” Ellington’s life, he composed three Sacred Concerts (1965, 1968, 1973) that set texts from the Bible in a variety of ways. Each of these Sacred Concerts is jazz suite, an American musical genre that Ellington largely created. While some individual movements include discrete scriptural pericopae as their libretti, many other movements stitch together scriptural texts with other biblical and non-biblical material, creating an interpretive conversation among several voices. Still other movements set wholly non-biblical texts, but nevertheless reflect biblical themes, ideas, or imagery. And finally, the Sacred Concerts include purely instrumental music that is associated with a biblical text through its title or its overall position within the work. Bringing together biblical reception history and historical musicology, this paper explores Ellington’s modes of musical exegesis in the Sacred Concerts. We show how Ellington employs a range of compositional tools (e.g., instrumentation, tonal painting, harmonic and melodic structures) to convey his understanding of several biblical texts. In doing so, we situate his voice among other prominent interpreters of scripture during the late sixties and early seventies.
|
The Impact of Keel's Symbolism of the Biblical World on Psalms Commentaries
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Joel LeMon, Emory University
This paper measures the impact of Keel's Symbolism of the Biblical World (SBW) by analyzing the use of ancient Near Eastern Iconography in major Psalms commentaries in the forty-five years since the publication of this seminal work. The study includes an examination of the origins of SBW and Keel's motivations for associating this iconographic survey with the book of Psalms. The paper also explores the extent to which Hossfeld and Zenger's volumes have provided a thoroughly iconographical commentary on the Psalms.
|
Genocide in Neo-Assyrian Sources and Biblical Ḥērem Texts: The View from Genocide Studies
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
T M Lemos, Huron University College, Univ of Western Ontario
This paper will explore the presentation of mass violence in neo-Assyrian sources to determine whether or not the Assyrian state undertook the practice of genocide against groups in the region. Specifically, I am interested in whether the Assyrians can be understood as attempting to eliminate entire ethnic groups and, if so, how their practices of mass violence relate to the ritual of ḥērem found in various biblical sources, as well as in the Mesha Inscription. While there have been occasional attempts previously to compare ḥērem with Assyrian practices and/or uncover whether or not the Assyrians had a practice analogous to ḥērem, these have displayed various weaknesses, not least of which being a failure to engage with the interdisciplinary field of genocide studies in their efforts to categorize ancient Near Eastern practices of mass violence. Thus, this paper will take a more theoretically-grounded approach to examining this question. In addition, the paper will engage with a recent essay by Jacob Wright on urbicide in the ancient Near East to determine whether the punishment of rebellious cities should be considered a form of genocidal violence. In sum, the paper will include both a theoretical discussion and detailed examination of historical sources as part of its attempt at disentangling the relationship between neo-Assyrian mass violence and the genocidal violence described in various Levantine sources. This paper forms part of a larger research project—as coeditor of the Cambridge World History of Genocide, Vol. 1, I will author two essays on genocide in the ancient world that will continue the research that I began in a recent article on genocide in ancient Israel and 20th-century Rwanda.
|
Boundary Crossing and Boundary Blurring in the Bible’s Tales of David and Gath
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Mahri Leonard-Fleckman, Providence College (Rhode Island)
The Bible describes the Shephelah primarily through the adventures of two characters: Samson and David. These biblical protagonists engage continually in cross-boundary relations with non-Israelites in the lowlands of ancient Israel. In the case of David, the texts at times depict clear boundaries between Israel and non-Israelites, as when we encounter David fighting Goliath in 1 Sam 17. Elsewhere, however, texts portray a socially-ambiguous and un-bordered Shephelah, particularly in the sometimes-cooperative and loyal relations between David and Gittites that blur social boundaries and confuse the notion of antagonist relations between Israel and the Philistines (e.g. 1 Sam 27:1-7; 2 Sam 6:9-11). This paper explores conflicting tales of boundary construction and boundary blurring between David and the Gittites in conjunction with current debates in border studies and the arguable archaeological portrait of the Shephelah as an ambiguous or “liminal zone” in the tenth-seventh centuries BCE (Tappy 2008). The question is whether, or to what extent, distinct literary depictions of boundaries or lack thereof in biblical texts have historical value for understanding the Shephelah in the Iron II. Yet driving this talk are two broader questions: first, to use terminology from the field of secondary language acquisition, how do ancient texts and their audiences “language” society (Swain 2006; 2009; cf. Vygotsky 1987); in other words, how do texts externalize or construct a particular image of the social landscape that is internalized by and shapes the reader’s or audience’s perceptions (e.g. biblical scholars, archaeologists, politicians), and vice versa? Second, to what extent is it possible to distinguish between biblical depictions of society that are idealizations or fabrications, and those that have older tentacles, that connect to or derive from older traditions, or perhaps what was remembered in some sense?
|
Jephthah and the Status of East Jordan
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Ellen Lerner, Manhattan Marymount College
The Jephthah narrative in Judges 10:17-12:7 is a fascinating tale about a Gileadite outcast who negotiates his way to power only to be brought low in the end by his negotiations. As scholars have noted, the narrative contains two episodes that are in fact variants of other biblical texts: Jephthah's recounting of Israel's past triumphs in east Jordan in 11:12-28 parallels Num 21-22 and Deut 2, and his conflict with the Ephraimites at the fords of the Jordan River in 12:1-7 finds echoes in Judg 3:26-30 and Judg 7:24-8:3.
Although the direction of literary dependence in both cases is not entirely clear, neither episode is considered part of the core Jephthah traditions on which the narrative is based. This paper argues that the combination of these two episodes in the wider Jephthah story ultimately serves to highlight ambivalence about the legitimacy of Israel's east Jordan lands. On the one hand Jephthah's retelling of Israel's previous victories over Sihon the Amorite in east Jordan justifies the Gileadites presence in the region. On the other hand, Gilead's confrontation with the Ephraimites not only casts the easterners as the enemy on the other side of the Jordan but Ephraim's taunt of these people in 12:4- whatever it's precise translation - casts aspersion on Gilead as somehow less than Ephraim. Through such literary maneuvering, this DtrH composition ultimately reflects a complicated view of east Jordan in which Gilead's status somewhat mirrors the social ambiguity and alienation that characterizes Jephthah himself.
|
On Studying Jewish Women Mystics in Late Antiquity
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Rebecca Lesses, Ithaca College
For a number of years I have been researching the topic of whether there were Jewish women mystics in late antiquity. I have focused on first century Alexandria as a possible location and Jewish community environment for female mystics, by analyzing three texts – Philo’s On the Contemplative Life, the Testament of Job, and Joseph and Aseneth. This paper pulls the focus out from looking at these particular texts, and addresses a larger question: when we speak of mysticism and Jewish women, what kind of mysticism are we talking about? Given the available sources, what kind of mysticism could they reveal? What is it that our sources simply can’t reveal? What does it mean in the context of Judaism(s) in late antiquity as a whole to find (or not find) women mystics? Does it matter? How should we think about the women who simply don't show up in our sources who may be having visionary (or other mystical) experiences? This of course is a general question in the study of women's history and religion in late antiquity – the problem is not just the scarcity of sources, but that even the sources that we have may give us a very limited idea of what women’s lives were like then. This paper will address that larger problem as it pertains to Jewish mysticism, and will consider as well whether a comparison to the study of early Christian female mystics may be helpful.
|
Textual Iconicity in Deuteronomy
Program Unit: Society for Comparative Research on Iconic and Performative Texts
Mark Lester, Yale University
This paper investigates the nature of textual iconicity in the narrative world of Deuteronomy. Deuteronomy is full of text-objects: God writes tablets, Moses writes a scroll (sēper), the king is commanded to write a scroll, and the people are to inscribe their doors and gates. Yet in each case, the importance of these objects seems to transcend their ability to communicate linguistic content. This paper applies the idea of the “icon” or the “iconicity” of texts to the scroll which Moses writes and to the song which Moses teaches to the people to better understand the non-linguistic role of these text-artifacts in Deuteronomy. The terms “icon” and “iconicity,” however, have been broadly understood in various scholarly discussions. After examining a functional use of the concept of the icon in Karel van der Toorn’s work on the iconic nature of the Torah in the Hebrew Bible and Judaism, this paper will also draw on analogies with art historical concepts of iconicity and subsequently on the notion of iconic signs in Peircian semiotics. Peirce’s theory of signs, specifically his type/token, icon/index, and image/diagram distinctions, offers both a highly specific way of understanding an icon (a sign which represents its object by means of likeness) and a larger framework through which to understand the signifying nature of text-objects as signs. A close analysis of the scroll Moses writes, and the song Moses teaches to the people in light of these three ways of thinking about iconicity shows the complex and contextually determined signifying work they do depicting YHWH’s revelation at Horeb and pointing to the mediating authority of figures like Moses and the Levites. Through these iconic texts, Deuteronomy constructs a world overflowing with materially embodied tokens of divine revelation. Even though the audience has limited access to the actual words of Moses’s scroll, divine revelation comes to resemble the material text artifacts on which revelation is inscribed. This study of textual iconicity in Deuteronomy reveals the underlying importance it places on the material embodiment of revelation in the ongoing transmission of the Horeb revelation.
|
Deictic Reference in Deuteronomy
Program Unit: Book of Deuteronomy
Mark Lester, Yale University
Deuteronomy repeatedly labels itself by combining a noun for a tangible or intangible object with a deictic demonstrative adjective (“this torah,” “this sēper,” “this covenant,” “these laws, statutes, and commandments”). This paper will reexamine Deuteronomy’s use of deictic demonstrative adjectives as labels. Every use of a deictic demonstrative adjective implies an anaphoric, cataphoric, or exophoric referent in order for the audience (Moses’s narrated audience and the audience of Deuteronomy as a book) to determine meaning from its indexical function. This study will begin by examining examples of deictic phrases that explicitly refer to material, text-bearing objects, and seek to establish the most probable referent for the phrase. It will argue that not every deictic reference to a text-bearing object can be adequately explained as anaphoric or cataphoric, that is referring forward or backward to something within Deuteronomy’s own discourse. Some deictic phrases referring to “this book of the law” appear to be exophoric, and are, I will argue, self-referential (Deut 28:58; 29:19, 20, 27; 30:10). Instead of referring to some segment of or some object within the immaterial discursive world of Deuteronomy, I will argue that these deictic phrases work to create a real world linguistic connection between readers and Deuteronomy as a work embodied in material manuscripts. Self-referentiality in Deuteronomy grows out of the dynamic connection of inscribed word and object in ancient Mesopotamia and the Levant. This paper will subsequently argue that even though deictic demonstrative pronouns—as indexical aspects of language—are meant to entail a particular context, they are paradoxically adept at adapting to new contexts and thus might contribute to the ongoing growth, transposition, and transmission of Deuteronomy in its textual history.
|
Dressed for the Part: Joseph and Tamar’s Tunics in the Hebrew Bible (Gen 37–50; 2 Sam 13)
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Anne Létourneau, Université du Québec à Montréal
We know very little about ancient Israelite sartorial practices. Few textile artefacts have been discovered in archaeological excavations. Similarly, iconographic representations of ancient Israelites’ “dressed bodies” are extremely rare. However, despite the lack of material data, the Hebrew Bible’s literary wardrobe is well-stocked. In this paper, I investigate how textualised items of dress in biblical literature are an important narrative motif that sheds light on the power relations displayed in the biblical texts, especially gender and kinship. I propose to analyze in a comparative fashion two biblical stories where the same item of dress, the ketonet passîm, is worn by both characters: Joseph (Gen 37:3,23,31-33) and Tamar (2 Sam 13:18-19).
Building off scholarship on the biblical anthropology of dress, I first investigate the nature of this special tunic. The main hypotheses regarding this textile object will be considered: Is it a multi-coloured tunic? A long-sleeved robe? A veil?
Second, exploring the symbolic function of garments in both Gen 37-50 and 2 Sam 13, I demonstrate how items of dress are material indicators of Tamar and Joseph’s location in the power networks of their respective families. Both character are “selected” and set apart through their garments, their beauty and their brothers’ abuse. Joseph is stripped of his tunic, abandoned in a pit and sold to merchants (Gen 37:18-36). He is later sent to prison after Potiphar’s wife uses another garment as “evidence” of sexual assault (Gen 39:12-18). Following her rape by her half-brother Amnon, Tamar rips her tunic, a princely “uniform”. She spends the rest of her life as a desolate woman in the house of her brother Absalom (2 Sam 13:18-20). Joseph’s story has a much happier ending: he becomes the Pharaoh’s intendant and is reunited with his family (Gen 41-50). Items of dress testify to Tamar and Joseph’s very different positions in their family hierarchies.
Third, in addition to analyzing the garments as kinship signifiers, I study the narrative function of the tunic as a “gendering device”. Dress, as an embodied practice, conveys and is informed by different gender norms. In the case of Joseph and Tamar, the violent assault on both characters – and their identical garments – engenders and subverts ideals about masculinity and femininity. Garment mediates the violence inflicted on both characters’ bodies: Joseph is stripped of his tunic while Tamar rips it herself after being raped. Contrary to Joseph’s, Tamar’s princely tunic is not simply a mark of distinction; it is a uniform identifying her as one of the Davidic princesses. The son of Jacob acquires new clothes throughout his story, signifying his changing status and his rise to power. Tamar succeeds in disrupting her material identifier as a “princess”. However, she is never offered a change in clothes and/or an opportunity to escape the trauma that permeates her torn garment.
This paper is an opportunity to explore how dress – especially tunics – functions as an important narrative signifier at the intersection of gender, class and kinship in two contexts of fraternal violence.
|
Solomon's Pools: A Preliminary Report on the First Excavations
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Mark Letteney, Princeton University
"Solomon's Pools" comprise three large, rectangular water reservoirs located 5 km southwest of Bethlehem, which are at the heart of an elaborate water collection and distribution system that provided water to Jerusalem for some 2000 years from the second century BCE through the period of the British Mandate. It is widely believed that the expansion of Jerusalem during the Hasmonean and Herodian periods was possible, in large part, due to the ready access to water provided by these pools; and yet, they have never been excavated. Mark Letteney (Princeton University, American Academy in Rome) and Matthew J. Adams (Director, the W.F. Albright Institute of Archaeological Research) offer a preliminary report on the first ever excavations at the site. We will discuss the 2000-year architectural and technical history of the Pools as recorded in literary and archaeological material, and publicize for the first time a newly discovered subterranean spring-house complex that operates underneath the lowest, and oldest pool.
|
Is Cambyses Also among the Persians?
Program Unit: Literature and History of the Persian Period
Mark Leuchter, Temple University
The extra-biblical sources regarding the reign of Cambyses (530-522 BCE) point to a contentious emperor whose reign – while contested and even maligned – factors significantly into world affairs. By contrast, the biblical record is completely silent on the reign of Cambyses, writing him out of the narrative of texts that were composed during or shortly after the Persian period (Ezra-Nehemiah, Chronicles, etc.). Consulting Greek, Persian, Egyptian and non-biblical Jewish sources (especially the Elephantine papyri), this paper will analyze the non-mention of Cambyses as a deliberate rhetorical feature of the biblical writers whose historiographies provide details about the turbulent events surrounding the reign of Cambyses and the rise of his successor Darius I. What emerges are deeply contested perspectives in Persian period Judaism regarding the figure of Cambyses, the durability of the Persian empire, and the unstable place of Jewish identity within it.
|
Language and Power Relations in John 18:28–19:16 with Focus on Participant Dialogues and Narrative Asides
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Mavis M. Leung, Evangel Seminary (Hong Kong)
*
|
Seeking Some Sense of the Paradox: Polyphony, Conflicting Ideologies, Dialogism, and the Dialectic Dynamics of Ecclesiastes
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Barbara Leung Lai, Tyndale University College and Seminary (Ontario)
Ecclesiastes is a polyphonic text with five identifiable speaking voices (interior and exterior; collective and individual): (1) The 3rd person “framed narrator”; (2) the 2nd person collective voice of the sages representing traditional wisdom (or Qohelet’s pretext); (3) Qohelet’s 1st person I-voice; (4) the inner voice of Qohelet which emerges from imaginary dialogue within monologue; and (5) the voice of the epilogist. The interface of voice and ideology is firmly established in the field of biblical studies. With the multiplicity of speaking voices, conflicting ideologies surface in this paradoxical book. While a logical structure of Ecclesiastes is yet to be found, this paper seeks to demonstrate that through the dialectic dynamics of the speaking voices engaging in vibrant and vigorous dialogism, a structure as well as an overarching message of the book could be attained.
|
Linking the Pentateuch with the Deuteronomistic History: Judges 2:1-6
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Christoph Levin, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
This paper addresses the peculiar Bochim episode (Judg 2:1-5) and investigates its textual and literary development in relation to crucial texts of the Pentateuch, such as Exod 3, Exod 23, Exod 34, and Deut 7. It is shown that this passage was drafted to reconcile different concepts of the people of God: Israel as a wandering minority in the narratives of the desert and the conquest, on the one hand, and the historical situation of the Israelites as the indigenuous population of their own land, on the other. Later editors inserted the prohibition against concluding a covenant with the non-Israelite inhabitants, by which they reacted to the historical experience that the land had to be shared with non-Jewish inhabitants.
|
The Chronicles of the Kings of Judah -Deliberations and Choices in the Composition of a Commentary
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Yigal Levin, Bar-Ilan University
Discussion of the process of preparing and writing this commentary.
|
The Role of Amalek in the Transfer of the Monarchy from Saul to David
Program Unit: Book of Samuel: Narrative, Theology, and Interpretation
Yigal Levin, Bar-Ilan University
In 1 Sam. 15 Samuel, speaking in God’s name, commands Saul to attack and to totally annihilate the Amalekites, taking revenge for the Amalekites’ attack on Israel back in the days of the Exodus (Ex. 17:8-16; Deut. 25:17-19), thus “closing the account” left open for centuries. Saul, for whatever reason, does not complete the job, leaving the Amalekites’ sheep, cattle and king alive. God expresses his sorrow at Saul’s failure to fulfill his commandment, cuts off all ties with Saul, and eventually sends Samuel to search for a new king. This failing of Saul is repeated by the risen spirit of Samuel in 1 Sam. 28:18, as one of the reasons for Saul’s imminent death.
Amalekites, however, also have a role to play in the actual rise of David, as Saul’s successor. In 1 Sam. 27:8 they appear as one of the desert tribes against whom David fights, paralleling their first appearance in 1 Sam. 14:48. In chapter 29, which takes place while Saul is fighting for his life on Mount Gilboa, Amalekites raid David’s camp at Ziklag, and are hunted down by David. And finally, in 2 Sam. 1, it is an Amalekite lad who brings news of Saul’s death to David, bragging that he had actually killed Saul, and also bringing Saul’s diadem and bracelet, the symbols of his reign, directly to David from Mount Gilboa. After David kills the lad, no Amalekite is ever mentioned again in the entire Deuteronomistic History. David, even without being told to do so, completed what Saul had failed to do, and had this proven himself to be fit to rule over Israel.
This paper will examine the role assigned to the Amalekites within the Deuteronomistic History in general and the book of Samuel in particular, and especially as that of a test, one which Saul fails and David passes.
|
Off the Road but on the Way: The Ministering Itinerary Rather Than the Itinerant Ministry of Jesus’s Female Followers
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Amy-Jill Levine, Vanderbilt University
Arguments for women itinerants following Jesus in the Galilee typically adduce the criterion of embarrassment to demonstrate Jesus’ counter-cultural entourage, claim the criterion of multiple attestation supports women’s itineracy, determine that references to women “following” (akoloutheo) and “ministering” (diakoneo) Jesus indicate itineracy, cite Jesus’ patterns of household disruption to locate women as independently operative, appeal to Jesus’ rejection of ritual purity laws as permitting the women (who might menstruate) and men to travel together, and claim “pious Jews” would be askance at single women accompanying Jesus and the men with him. Neither individually nor cumulatively do the arguments hold. The Gospels witness no embarrassment over Jesus’ women followers; John is likely following the Synoptics so there is no multiple attestation; if Q exists (I am doubtful), it offers no indication of women’s itineracy; the verbs typically describe household connection not rejection; household disruption need not translate into itineracy; and Jesus, rather than rejecting purity laws, restores people to states of purity. The women follow and serve Jesus, but it is just as likely, if not more likely, that they do so from a household base rather than as wandering itinerants.
|
Yet His Shadow Still Looms: Citations from the “Obsolete Covenant” in the Epistle to the Hebrews
Program Unit: Hebrews
Amy-Jill Levine, Vanderbilt University
Hebrews both insists that the old covenant is obsolete (8.13) and requires that same covenant to legitimate its typological appropriations; the approximately 35 direct citations and another 50 allusions structure the document. Further, Hebrews taps the old covenant for its list of worthies, since other than Jesus, it locates no post-biblical moral exemplars or, as with Esau, negative examples. Nor, finally, does Hebrews seek to jettison this ancient material, since it recognizes its Spirit-infused origin (cf. 3.7; 10.15). How then is the old covenant obsolete? Using as test cases Hebrews’ appeals to Melchizedek and to Israel’s sacrificial system, this paper argues that Hebrews both incorporates or absorbs the old covenant and, in this repackaging or digesting, renders obsolete only its external markers, not the essence.
|
Ritual Theory and the Efficacy of Curses
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Nathaniel Levtow, University of Montana
This paper will discuss the relationship between ritual, writing, and cursing traditions in the Hebrew Bible and the ancient Near East. The paper seeks to contribute to modern explanatory models for the perceived efficacy of written curses in ancient Near Eastern social contexts. To do so, it integrates recent discussions of material textuality, object agency, and ritualization practices in order to explain the prevalence and potency of inscribed curses on ancient Near Eastern text-artifacts. The paper’s primary data consists of Mesopotamian and Levantine legislative and monumental inscription curses (e.g. VTE; Hammurapi; Ahirom) as well as ritualized legislative and narrative cursing texts in the Hebrew Bible (e.g. Deut 27-28; Josh 8:30-35; Jer 36). The paper will integrate Catherine Bell’s perspectives on ritualization and textualization with cognitive perspectives on social agency, and with recent discussions of iconic textuality and the social location of material texts. The paper proposes a blend of cognitive and social-theoretical perspectives to explain, in modern terms, the ubiquitous presence and evident power of written curses engraved on ancient Near Eastern monumental inscribed iconography.
|
The Orchard of Eden: The Blessing of Trees before the Curse of the Ground
Program Unit: Genesis
Andrew Zack Lewis, Regent College
Though we often associate gardens with all kinds of fruits and vegetable plants, a close reading of Genesis 2-3 reveals the Garden of Eden to contain only trees and the animals that live in and around trees. The narrator mentions shrubs and plants in 2:5 only to note that they had yet to sprout. In fact, herbaceous plants do not appear until after the humans are expelled from the Garden.
The man's disobedience brings about the necessity of herbaceous plants and shrubs. Because he eats from the forbidden tree, YHWH God curses the ground to produce thorns and thistles and commands that the man must eat from the plants of the field. These plants, evidently herbaceous and grain bearing, should be seen in contradistinction to the trees from which the man eats in the Garden. The trees of the Garden provide shade, mitigating the "sweat of the brow." One can harvest their food with relatively little effort, making pain minimal. By contrast, after the curse of the ground and his expulsion from the garden, the man eats in pain and by the sweat of his brow in sunbaked fields where plants grow tangled in weeds close to the ground forcing the man to bend his back.
The final section of the paper will point to the significance the above understanding of the curse of the ground has for the rest of Genesis, particularly regarding the Yahwist's account of the Flood in 8:20–22 and 9:18–27.
|
Trees, Theophanies, and the Pentateuch
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
Andrew Zack Lewis, Regent College
Trees play a muted but important role in the patriarchal narratives of Genesis. In several cases, the patriarch experiences a theophany near a tree (12:6,7; 18:1; 35:8,9). In another, Abraham plants a tree where one would expect an altar (21:33; cf. 13:4; 26:25). Given that the names of the tree species mentioned in these passages resemble either the word for God (᾽ēlôn in 12:6 and 18:1; ᾽ēlâ 35:8) or Asherah (᾽éšel in 21:33), one might be forgiven for seeing remnants of paganism creeping into the texts.
How does one reconcile the contradictions between the various prohibitions against Asheroth and high places throughout the rest of the biblical texts and these instances of sacred trees or groves in the foundational stories? The two most prominent ways of dealing with the tension between the narrative texts and the later prohibitions are either to deny the significance of the cultic events occurring near trees or to deny the reliability of the biblical text as a source of a consistent theology. In the former, the trees are merely landmarks like hills or springs. In the latter, the redactor of Genesis takes older pagan traditions and fits them into a larger story.
In the following paper, I propose a third way to understand the function and meaning of the sacred trees of Genesis. Through narrative and rhetorical-critical approaches I argue that a partial answer to the problem lies in the phrase "Yahweh/God appeared." Tracing this language along with other theophanous events through the Pentateuch, I will note that these types of theophanies will cease at the advent of the tent of meeting. It, therefore, is no small significance that the tent of meeting bears a tree-like menorah at its center. Such a trajectory begins in the Garden of Eden where Yahweh confronts Adam and Eve amongst the trees and culminates at the Temple/Tabernacle.
The final section of the paper explores the theological import of the narrative trajectory, especially as it pertains to the appearance of the Tree of Life in the book of Revelation.
|
Paul and "Father Abraham"
Program Unit: Paul within Judaism
Rob Lewis, Manhattan College
Is Paul’s use of Abraham in Romans 4 a wild stretch or a legitimate piece of Scriptural interpretation? On the surface, Paul’s use of Abraham serves a rhetorical purpose. When Paul “writes in” the Roman believers to the family of Abraham, he has cleverly done through an image what he will labor to argue. The question is, does Paul treat the story of Abraham in Genesis fairly or has he stretched the story to fit his rhetorical goal?
Paul’s use of the Abraham story, specifically centered on hope, deadness, and patrimony, when viewed against the story of Genesis reveals that Paul adjusts the story to fit his letter. Scholarly work on Jewish identity (Esler, Nanos, and Boyarin, to begin with) may offer suggestions as to how the Jews reading Paul’s letter may have reacted to his use of Abraham as a universal forefather.
Finally, does Paul’s use of Abraham in Romans 4 tell us something about how he perceived his own relationship with Judaism and his audience’s place in Judaism? The hypothesis is that Paul’s use of Abraham tells us that he is doing some “grafting” work in Romans 4 that he will make more overt in Romans 9-11.
|
Ugaritic Athtartu, Food Production and Textiles: More Data for Reassessing the Biblical Portrayal of Ashtart in Context
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Theodore J. Lewis, Johns Hopkins University
Athtartu/Ashtart/Astarte studies-including what we can say of the biblical portrayal of the goddess-are undergoing a renaissance. Recent volumes attempt comprehensive comparative analyses of the goddess (e.g., Christian and Schmitt 2013; Sugimoto 2014; Wilson-Wright 2016). Yet even with renewed attention to the prominence of the goddess in the Northern and Southern Levant as well as in Egypt and the expanded Phoenician colonies, certain key aspects of her agrarian nature have been overlooked. This paper explores "Athtartu of the Field/Steppe-land" from Ugarit together with biblical analogues.
To say that Athtartu is tied to fields and steppe-lands (šd) is to say that she plays a significant role in food production and the textile industry. The word šd can designate cultivated lands as well as steppe-lands. For the former, we have a plethora of texts in various genres documenting the symbolism of cultivated fields (šd) as well as the produce and transactions associated with their maintenance that was so central to the economy. As for steppe-lands (šd and mdbr), here archaeological studies (e.g. van Zeist and Bakker-Heeres 1985; Akkermans and Schwartz 2003) and studies of ancient diet (e.g. Altmann 2013) prove instructive. Archaeobotanical research reveals the complex nature of steppe-lands. Though lacking in rainfall, seasonal "shrub-steppe" and "dry" vegetation led to the predominance of sheep and goat pastoralism that was supplemented by hunting activity. And here too, we read in KTU 1.92 of Athtartu's prowess as goddess of the hunt, especially in the steppe-lands.
A royal entry ritual (KTU 1.148) describes the actual cult associated with Athtartu of the Field/Steppe-land. It is telling that these offerings have to do with livestock (sheep), agriculture (oil) and other produce (balsam, honey) from rural areas that resonate with the goddess's name (šd). Four different types of garments are mentioned along with 300 units of wool. An economic text listing divine offerings-that twice mentions Athtartu-details a wide variety of garments with special emphasis on wool both in quantity (700 units) and type (esp. lapis [blue] wool) along with linen (pṯt-flax) garments. Weaving (mḫṣ) is also mentioned here in conjunction with the goddess.
The paper will juxtapose these new data regarding Ugaritic Athtartu with presentations of the goddess from Egypt, Emar, and Phoenicia as well as with biblical portrayals of Ashtart. It will argue that Athtartu is a better fit for a goddess associated with the textile industry (in contrast to Asherah as argued by Ackerman) and that Athtartu is a more likely candidate for the goddess portrayed as the "Mistress of Animals" on the lid of an ivory box from Minet el Beida.
Especially noteworthy within the biblical corpus is Deuteronomy's cultural appropriation that coins a new expression to turn what was once a divine epithet of ovine husbandry ("Ashtart of Flocks") into a profane reference to ovine fertility ("the fecundity of flocks") accorded to Yahweh. Other related texts will also be treated, such as the agrarian aspects of the Queen of Heaven, often thought to be Ashtart.
|
The Voices of Others in Egeria’s Pilgrim Narrative
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Blake Leyerle, University of Notre Dame
One of the striking features of Egeria’s description of her travels around the Holy Land at the end of the fourth century is her abundant use of quotation. With purportedly stenographic care, she records not only the information conveyed to her by local monks and bishops, but their actual speech. What, we must ask, is the purpose of this alleged transcription? Certainly, these verbal echoes create a soundscape, an auditory richness that complements her visual descriptions of the land. In doing this, they also effectively convey a sense of its dominant population and their idiolects. Not infrequently, these voices also provide additional authoritative information on the holy sites. This information, however, usually strikes readers as trivial, often absurdly so and unworthy of inclusion. And yet it is there in her narrative. In these cases, speech must do more. I will suggest that these dialogic passages function to illuminate not the land or its inhabitants, but Egeria herself: she emerges from these interactions as observant and tenaciously learned. Relying on the work of Michel de Certeau in his Heterologies, I will further argue that her inclusion of the words of others performs several crucial textual functions: they serve both to authorize her text and also to create a “pre-text,” a speech that necessitates the proliferation of further texts. It is thus no accident that the most extended speeches are attributed to the bishop of Edessa who shows her sites connected with the apocryphal story of King Abgar.
|
Compositional Devices in Ancient Biography: A Comparison of Plutarch's Lives with the Synoptic Gospels
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Michael Licona, Houston Baptist University
Compositional Devices in Ancient Biography: A Comparison of Plutarch's Lives with the Synoptic Gospels
|
Brides, Prostitutes, and Witches: Gendered Identities in the Book of Ezekiel
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
Rosanne R. Liebermann, Johns Hopkins University
This paper considers how the book of Ezekiel presents women with a variety of social roles through bodily practices such as clothing and adornment. The expression of female identity in Ezekiel has been the subject of several excellent studies, but the various women depicted are usually treated as a single unit, negating the different social identities they espouse, such as class and profession.
My paper remedies this by conducting in-depth analyses of Ezekiel's descriptions of various women, using textual and archaeological comparisons to place them in context. The title reflects three of the female social identities mentioned in the book of Ezekiel: the young woman showered with jewellery in preparation for her wedding (Ezek 16:8-14), the prostitute adorning herself for male visitors (Ezek 16:15-19; 23:40-42), and the female prophetess dressed for her role as a local healer (Ezek 13:17-23), often referred to as a witch through comparison to the Mesopotamian maqlû ritual for witch-burning.
These women are literary constructs and not historic figures; yet examining the ways Ezekiel's author portrays them can help us understand what these descriptions signified to his audience, and whether they had any grounding in reality. For example, the bride described in Ezek 16:8-14 is marrying into high social standing, as the materials of her luxurious wedding gifts reveal: gold, silver, linen, silk. However, her process of preparing for the occasion has many similarities to the way the woman prepares herself for prostitution in Ezek 23:40-42, such as bathing, using oil, and wearing ornaments and bracelets (cf. Gen 24:53; Isa 3:18-24; Jud 10:3-4). The preparation for a sexual encounter is the same regardless of its social setting; the key difference is the passive and socially acceptable female role the bride plays in being clothed and adorned by another, in contrast to the agency the promiscuous woman possesses in adorning herself, giving her a socially ambiguous role (cf. Prov 7:10-20).
At first glance, the situation described in Ezek 13:17-23 appears quite different, but further enquiry will determine whether this is really the case. The passage accuses certain women of misleading others by dressing them in the ambiguous mispāḥôt and kəsātôt. The ritual is unclear, but many scholars explain the kəsātôt using the Akkadian kasû ("to bind"), connecting them with Mesopotamian protective rituals involving binding and tying actions. Such rituals could well underlie Tamar and Rahab's tying of red threads (Gen 38:28; Josh 2:18-21), which in turn may be connected to their roles as prostitutes. If protective magic rituals were particularly associated with women in marginal positions of society, like prostitutes, it may explain why an elite Jerusalemite priest such as the writer of Ezekiel would disdain such activities, for social reasons as well as religious ones.
By examining the ways in which these women's identities are portrayed through clothing and adornment in Ezekiel, this paper will reveal how women of different social standings were viewed by the book's writer and his community.
|
Reading 2 Baruch on Easter Sunday: Imagining a Multi-medial Encounter with 2 Bar 72:1–73:2 and Challenging the Scholarly Narrative of Ancient Jewish Writings
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Liv Ingeborg Lied, MF Norwegian School of Theology
For 150 years, scholars have largely identified 2 Baruch as a Jewish writing composed in the 1st-2nd century ce. And accordingly, 2 Baruch has been contextualized, studied and assessed as a text belonging to this period. With some exceptions, other periods that might tell additional, or all together new, stories of the life of the writing have generally been left in the dark. The result is that the academic imagination of 2 Baruch is thoroughly intertwined with its assumed period of origin. However, the fact remains that we know little about Jewish communities in the 2nd century, and even less about the constitution, the shape, the status, or the engagement with 2 Baruch at the time.
In this paper, I wish to draw our attention to another context of engagement with 2 Baruch that has seldom been explored, but which provides a rich and salient context of use that breaks thoroughly with the common scholarly narrative. During the mid-13th century, a passage from 2 Baruch, 2 Bar 72:1-73:2, was assumedly read as one of the lections from the Old Testament on Easter Sunday. A lectionary manuscript containing the lection scripts it to be read by the monks in the Monastery of the Syrians in the Wadi al-Natrun in Egypt. Additional notes by later hands, wax drippings, and signs of physical handling of the manuscript suggest that it actually was read, and so, it is likely that the lection was read in the church in the monastery, in the Church of the Holy Virgin.
Combining the information available to us from the lectionary manuscript, the recent restorations of the wall paintings in the church, historical records from the monastery, and scholarship on liturgical practices at the time, I wish to propose an approximation of another context of engagement with 2 Baruch than the one that has been privileged so far. How was the lection from 2 Baruch heard, what would those who gathered in the church see (and smell) while hearing the text, how would the reading of the text be contextualized in the worship context, and how would this multi-medial encounter influence the experience/ interpretation of the text?
Importantly, this set of questions may open up for new reflections on scholarly practices in the study of the Old Testament Pseudepigrapha: how may 2 Baruch have been interpreted/experienced in that church, on a spring day in the mid 13th century, celebrating Easter Sunday – the most important Sunday of the Church Year? (How) does this known, 13th century engagement with a passage from 2 Baruch as an Old Testament lection challenge, or at least nuance, the dominant scholarly imagination of this text as a non-canonical historical loser? Why is the hypothetical period of origin in the 1st-2nd century deciding the scholarly imagination of the entire life cycle of this pseudepigraphon?
|
Textual Scholarship, Ethics, and Someone Else’s Manuscripts
Program Unit: Book History and Biblical Literatures
Liv I. Lied, MF Norwegian School of Theology
Textual Scholarship, Ethics, and Someone Else’s Manuscripts
|
Gender in the First Two Centuries of the Christ Movements
Program Unit: Westar Institute
Celene Lillie, University of Colorado at Boulder
The third of three semi-annual meetings on this theme, these three seminar sessions mark the culmination of the Westar Christianity Seminar's re-thinking the role of gender in its larger project of rewriting a history of the first two centuries of Christ-related people. While acknowledging earlier seminal 20th century feminist studies, four quite different 21st century scholars summarize and re-imagine more recent trends in the various genderednesses of early Christ-related people.
|
Virgin Categories in the Protevangelium of James and Histories of Sexuality in Antiquity
Program Unit: Construction of Christian Identities
Julia Kelto Lillis, University of Virginia
The Protevangelium of James takes part in the common ancient Mediterranean practice of marking certain women with the label “virgin.” Contrary to the assumptions of many readers today, the category “virgins” does not carry a clear or uniform meaning in ancient texts; what makes a virgin a “virgin” might be her young age, unmarried status, sexual inexperience, or inexperience with childbearing. In the Protevangelium, the label operates to categorize Mary in at least two different ways, conveying her sexual purity at some moments in the story and her (paradoxical) reproductive virginity at other moments. The boundary line between “virgins” and other women is a moving one.
This movable boundary line complicates common scholarly narratives about early Christianity and opens up new possibilities in the study of ancient genders and sexualities. First, it calls our preconceptions about the ancient meaning and value of virginity into question. If virginity is a flexible and ambiguous concept, we must investigate its meaning on a case-by-case basis in our texts; even within a single text, we might find various meanings and functions. In the Protevangelium, for example, virginity becomes a way to communicate not only that Mary is sexually pure and set apart as the woman who will bring Christ into the world, but also that Mary and Christ enjoy a special purity at the nativity, with Mary’s body being preserved from effects of childbirth that were likely seen as polluting and repulsive as well as violent. The boundary line of virginity and virginity loss gives voice to various discomforts with social transitions and the bodily cost of reproduction as well as the theological concern to assign a divine savior a suitably pure and exceptional birth.
Second, the flexibility of the category “virgins” disrupts overly simplistic pictures of gender and sexuality in early Christianity and prompts us to look for new approaches. Feminist historical work, especially work conducted outside of early Christian studies, has used a broad brush to paint a picture of virginity in early Christian traditions, treating diverse sources and configurations for virginity as though they represent a uniform movement to promote and monitor female sexual purity with a new intensity. If instead we heed the variety of concepts and boundary lines that appear in ancient sources, we might notice new avenues for historical and theoretical exploration. I propose that we pay particular attention to models for histories of sexuality and gender proposed by queer theorists and historians of later periods, such as Valerie Traub’s “cycles of salience,” for exploring ancient categories that are akin to or impinge upon gender and sexuality. This model challenges tendencies to present periods or traditions monolithically and attends to the recurring diversity and dissent that marks the formation of categories at any time and place.
|
The Humanimal Body of Jesus in John's Gospel
Program Unit: Postcolonial Studies and Biblical Studies
Sung Uk Lim, Yonsei University
The present study contends that the humanimal body of John's Jesus as the Passover lamb is both subject and resistant to Roman imperial power. Throughout the whole narrative, the Gospel of John endeavors to look upon Jesus as "the lamb of God" (Jn 1:29, 36). Perhaps most importantly, the temporal setting of the trial narrative is the day of preparation for Passover when the Passover lambs were sacrificed (Jn 19:14b; cf. Jn 18:28). As Jesus becomes a sacrificial lamb for the Passover, he has the potential to become a liminal character in the indistinguishable zones between humanity and animality, especially in the subsequent scene of crucifixion. In these blurred zones, Jesus' humanity and animality no longer exist in a binaristic manner; instead, the one exists in the other, and vice versa. Through the metaphor of a Passover lamb, one can see Jesus' humanity in the animal realm and at the same time his animality in the human realm. Therefore, the human and animal realms are merged into the so-called humanimal realm, which justifies the violence imposed on the colonized subject by the Roman Empire. Still, there exists an ironic twist that the wretched death of Jesus as a Passover lamb hints at a sacrifice for liberation from Roman colonizers in exactly the same way that the first Passover lamb symbolized deliverance from Egyptian oppressors.
|
How Does the Creation Motif in Genesis 1.1-2.3 Relate to the Chinese Legends of Creation?
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Joanna Lin, Logos Evangelical Seminary
This paper will use the Jewish method of Torah study with Chinese contextualization to research the creation motif in Genesis 1:1–2:3—the Priestly creation account. This method serves to peel the layers—Peshitta, Remez, and Drash—as an onion, step-by-step to the core—Sod, the innermost part of the truth. The purpose of this paper is to examine how the creation motif, particularly the creation of the world and the man, described in this passage points the way to expounding two well-known ancient Chinese legends—“Pan-Gu Created the World” and “Nu-Wa Created the Man.” Through the Chinese contextualization in the layer of Drash, it is intriguing to find an implication that there is a close connection between Genesis and the Chinese creation accounts.
|
Poetry and Blasphemy in the Book of Job
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Tod Linafelt, Georgetown University
One of the key questions to be addressed in any reading of the book of Job is whether Job curses God. There is a real complexity in the way the question is first articulated by the Adversary in his conversation with God, using the surprising word "bless" (b-r-k) rather than one of the standard words for "curse," thus setting up a fundamental ambivalence in whether the words of Job that follow in chapter 3 constitute a cursing or a blessing of God. This ambivalence is sustained, intentionally I want to argue, by the move from prose (in chapters 1 and 2) to poetry (in chapter 3). A close analysis of chapter three, with special attention to the distinctive resources of biblical poetry vis-a-vis prose, reveals just how essential poetic form is for sustaining the crucial tension of the book, namely, whether or not Job curses God.
|
"Seeing Glory" as the Origin of Sacred Text: Authorship and Textuality in the Gospel of John
Program Unit: Book History and Biblical Literatures
Julia D. Lindenlaub, University of Edinburgh
Among ancient narratives of origins for sacred texts, the Gospel of John deploys a unique construction of textuality’s significance within its milieu of early Christian literary culture. Orienting the gospel within this literary milieu seems of considerable import to its author, evinced by a peculiarly Johannine concern for situating the gospel’s status as an emphatically written text among alternative writings, potential or actual (John 20:30–31, 21:24–25). Preoccupation with the significance of the gospel’s textuality appears grounded in a strategic parallel between the origin of its composition and that of its likewise textual forebear: “Scripture” (graphé). This paper explores the proposed correlation via the gospel’s narration of how the significance of its written medium is legitimized by its origin. I suggest that the use of scriptural literature in the gospel’s composition thematizes authorship and textuality in uniquely Johannine terms for a uniquely Johannine purpose: constructing the import of its written status in relationship to its origin as sacred text. The gospel’s self-conscious “writtenness” thus manifests its construal of authorship as its origin is framed in the same idiosyncratic terms ascribed to the Jewish scriptural literature appropriated in the gospel—responding to “seeing glory” with textual composition. Invocation of Isaiah, the gospel’s only named authorial source for a scriptural quotation, models his authorship of the quoted text as originating from a vision of glory (Isaiah 53:1, 6:10 cited in John 12:37–41). By the same device, the gospel’s own authorship likewise originates from sight of the same glory (John 1:14). As both texts share this origin, the gospel’s emphatically significant written status is grounded in a construction of authorship and textuality ascribed both to the gospel itself and to its use of Jewish scriptural literature. While modern scholarship on the Johannine use of Scripture has tended to fixate on somewhat restrictive, redaction-critical concerns for determining a quoted source’s original language or medium, such an approach has often neglected to frame the gospel’s use of Scripture according to its own ancient concerns. By contrast, this paper is guided by the gospel’s own narration of appropriating scriptural literature. The resultant construal of authorship does not readily lend itself to modern pursuits of identifiable, historical authors; rather, it persuasively elucidates the gospel’s insistent emphasis on its written medium. The gospel is birthed from the same origin and composed according to the same construal of authorship as scriptural literature. Its textuality is therefore imbued with a distinctly Johannine significance by virtue of this origin shared with an extant literary tradition of sacred text. In this way, the Gospel of John’s emphatic textuality represents a remarkable development in the literary culture of early Christianity. Its evident preoccupation with the significance of its writtenness within the broader literary milieu is an expression of the construct of origin invoked by the gospel from its use of Jewish scriptural literature.
|
Bibles for Atheists: An Oxymoron?
Program Unit: Metacriticism of Biblical Scholarship
Hilary Lipka, University of New Mexico
Can there be such a thing as a Bible created specifically for an atheist audience? It seems odd, but books such as Joan Konner's The Atheist's Bible, Ivan Green's The Anti-Bible: For Atheists, Freethinkers, and Christians Who Know Better, and Daniel S. Fletcher's The Atheist Bible: Knowledge is Power! are just some examples of works whose authors, by using the terms Bible and atheist together in the title, appear to be trying to do just that. This paper will consider the content of these supposed Bibles for atheists, who their intended audience is, and what, if anything, these works have to do with the actual Bible and contemporary biblical criticism. Lastly, the question of whether there really can be such a thing as a Bible for atheists, and, if so, what it would contain, will be addressed.
|
How Archaeology Can or Cannot Integrate Literary Perspectives
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Oded Lipschits, Tel Aviv University
(no abstract)
|
“She is My Sister”: Sarai as Lady Wisdom in 1QapGen 19–20
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Anthony Lipscomb, Brandeis University
The account of Abram and Sarai’s sojourn in Egypt in Gen 12:10-20 has been told and retold in splendid fashion since the Second Temple Period. To be sure, the terse nature of the Genesis account invited creative storytellers to fill in the gaps, but brevity yielded only half the impetus. Ancient storytellers were no less bothered by the inglorious portrayal of Abram and Sarai, for which there is no shortage of attempts to rescue their reputations.
The Aramaic text from Qumran known to scholars as the Genesis Apocryphon (1Q20) stands out as one the earliest and most innovative examples of the retelling of the Genesis 12 sojourn account. While the Apocryphon shares several of the same recharacterization strategies as other ancient retellings, it is nevertheless unique in its engagement with the tradition of personified Wisdom. When we imagine the composer of the Apocryphon’s sojourn account in dialogue with ancient Jewish wisdom traditions, connections between Sarai and Lady Wisdom become discernible. While the Apocryphon is equally interested in the character of Abram, the focus of this paper will demonstrate how it redeems Sarai’s reputation from Genesis 12 by recasting her in the image of Lady Wisdom. The Apocryphon’s engagement with the tradition of Lady Wisdom exemplifies how Second Temple Jewish interpreters creatively funnelled various traditions into one stream, so to speak, in order to tell a familiar story anew.
|
Masorah as a Place Marker for Exegesis and Theology in Different Fields of Knowledge
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Hanna Liss, Hochschule für Jüdische Studien Heidelberg
Certain bible manuscripts from medieval Ashkenaz present entire or partial Okhla we-Okhla lists in the form of micrography (masora figurata) in zoomorphic and anthropomorphic designs. My paper will compare this Masoretic material to that of the older oriental codices as well as address the following questions: (1) why Masoretic lists, being a standardized corpus of knowledge, were first de-contextualized from their grammatical and philological-critical discourse, then re-contextualized into a new form of aesthetic presentation; (2) who initiated this process; and (3) what can be said about its exegetical goals.
|
Jerusalem Abandoned: Q 13:34–35 in Context
Program Unit: Q
Fiodar Litvinau, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
My presentation is dedicated to one passage of my doctoral project (Q 13:34-35). Jerusalem was and is the center of the religious life of the Jewish people. However, the attitude towards it changed depending on the historical, social, and religious situation. In this paper, I will discuss the attitude towards Jerusalem found in the Sayings Gospel Q in comparison with several Jewish texts from the Second Temple Period. The first part of the paper discusses the text of Q preserved in Mt 23:37-39 and Lk 13:34-35 in order to come closer to the original wording of Q passage. Parts 2, 3 and 4 are dedicated to the analysis of the texts of Animal Apocalypse of 1 Enoch, Dead Sea Scrolls and Psalms of Solomon that are relevant for the better understanding of the context in which Q 13:34-35 emerged. For some of these texts the fresh translation will be offered. The conclusion summarizes the analysis of the texts and demonstrates that Q 13:34-35 was composed in the group which was rooted in Jewish religious tradition, but hostile to Jerusalem as a center of religious life, which did not consider Jerusalem Temple as the center of their religious life, as well as made no distinction between the Temple and the city of Jerusalem at all.
|
The Daimon of Empedocles
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
M. David Litwa, Institute for Religion and Critical Inquiry
Empedocles (ca. 492-430 BCE), the philosopher from Acragas considered himself to be a daimon descended from heaven to earth as the result of an ancient, though necessary crime. His story of daimonification (or returning to his daimonic state) is rarely explored in any depth. I take this opportunity to explore some puzzling features of Empedocles's daimonification chiefly in dialogue with the studies of Peter Kingsley (in his various works). In accordance with the emphases of the section, I also explore the themes of the daimon as Empedocles's second (real) self, and his literary self-presentation as an epiphany. I also explore Empedocles's death story as a parodic "failed epiphany." The story of Empedocles's daimonification is important since it set a pattern of fall and redemption that would repeatedly cycle through the canons of Western spirituality.
|
The Inference of Situational Stability in Paul's Letters
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Nina E. Livesey, University of Oklahoma
In his 1968 article in Philosophy & Rhetoric, Lloyd Bitzer developed a theory of the rhetorical situation. According to him, a stable and reliable situation not only initiates ensuing rhetorical discourse but also serves as its control. For Bitzer, rhetorical discourse itself is situational, pragmatic and based in reality. He defines the rhetorical situation as, "a natural context of persons, events, objects, relations, and an exigence which strongly invites utterance" ("The Rhetorical Situation," p. 5). Subsequent to Bitzer's analysis, other modern scholars of rhetoric and philosophy critiqued and refined his theory. Richard Vatz, for instance, made a significant shift in Bitzer's understanding regarding the stability of a situation. According to him, situations themselves do not call forth discourse nor do situations in and of themselves elicit meaning. Rather, by selecting from among an array of possible elements pertaining to a situation and translating those selections into something worthy of consideration, rhetors produce meaning through a creative process ("The Myth of the Rhetorical Situation," p. 157). Later, Alan Brinton ("Situation in the Theory of Rhetoric") questioned Bitzer's assumption of the objective nature of exigence implied by his theory. After a discussion of these theories, I wish to explore their relative significance on inferences pertaining to Paul's rhetorical situation within selected Pauline scholarship and then offer implications of those inferences for our understanding of Paul, early Christianity and early Judaism.
|
What Has Ephesus to Do with Edessa?: The Syriac History of John, the Cult of the Dea Syria, and Religious Competition in Fourth-Century Syria
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Jacob A. Lollar, Florida State University
This essay explores how the Syriac History of John used the cult of Artemis in Ephesus as a typological construct for the discursive dismantling of a more localized Syrian cult, the cult of Atargatis, the Dea Syria. The History of John is a fourth-century legend about the apostle/evangelist John the son of Zebedee and his activities in the city of Ephesus. It is an original Syriac work, composed in Edessa, that is not directly dependent on the better-known Greek apocryphon, the Acts of John. One central theme in the History of John is its explicit critique of sacrificial “pagan” cults, in this case represented by the famous cult of Artemis in Ephesus. John brings his (Nicene) Christianity to Ephesus and, after successfully converting the local governor and his entourage, confronts the local priests at the Artemision, eventually converting and baptizing them and the rest of the city’s inhabitants.
Scholars like Alain Desreumaux have raised questions about the portrayal of the cult of Artemis in the text and whether there is anything historically significant. I take a different approach in this paper. I suggest that the connection between Ephesus and Edessa is a discursive one that relies on an assumed syncretism between the goddesses Artemis and Atargatis, the so-called Dea Syria. H.J.W. Drijvers has shown that there was a cult of Atargatis in Edessa and there is ample evidence throughout Syria that the two goddesses were often conflated in iconography and worship. A temple at Dura Europas has a statue of Atargatis dressed as the huntress; a pair of inscriptions in southern Palestine refer to the two goddesses as the same figure on a sacrificial altar. As a city located on the prominent ancient silk road, Edessa’s inhabitants would have been aware of the conflation of the goddesses. Using Bruce Lincoln’s theory of discourse and social construction, I argue that Ephesus’ cult of Artemis in the History of John served as a discursive gesture toward the cult of Atargatis in Edessa, which was the primary target of the apocryphon’s critique.
The dismantling of the cult of Artemis/Atargatis served as a condemnation of sacrificial religions in general. I argue that the History of John emerged during the same period as the Doctrina Addai and was even produced by the same pro-Nicene group. The late fourth century was a turbulent period in Edessa’s history. Sidney Griffith and others have shown that Ephrem the Syrian’s arrival in 363 sparked the beginning of a program to establish Nicene Christianity as the dominant religion in the city. Nicene Christians were determined to demonstrate their primacy and legitimacy vis-à-vis all other religious groups, including Jews, Arians, Marcionites, Manichaeans, and various north Mesopotamian, “pagan” religions. Sacrificial religion continued to be practiced in the city well into the fifth century and the History of John is a witness to attempts by Nicene Christians to dominate their religious competitors.
|
Blinded by Blame: Reading John 9 in Light of Mimetic Theory
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Daniel DeForest London, School for Deacons
In the narrative of the Fourth Gospel, Adele Reinhartz recognizes three major tales: the historical, the ecclesiological and the cosmological. In each of these tales, the collective “Jews” are generally portrayed as violent opponents to the narrative’s hero, Jesus. Throughout history, Christians have read the Fourth Gospel as anti-Jewish and used it to justify anti-Semitic violence. By reading the Fourth Gospel in light of the anthropological insights of mimetic theory, a new tale emerges that recounts the ministry of a prophet dismantling systems of scapegoating and blame by exposing the false gods of religious and political violence and revealing the true God as one who sympathizes with society’s victims. I call this the “anthropological tale” and, just as Reinhartz used the above tales as keys for interpreting Johannine symbols, I will use the anthropological tale to interpret the symbols of day, night, blindness and vision; symbols which the Johannine Jesus employs in his response to the disciples’ compulsion to blame in John 9. This reading will demonstrate how Jesus reveals and exposes the scapegoat mechanism in which an innocent victim (the man born blind) is blamed and expelled by violent victimizers. However, rather than blaming the victimizers and perpetuating the cycle of exclusion, Jesus continues to engage with the characters who appear to be villains.
I will demonstrate how this reading reveals the problematic nature of the ecclesiological tale which was initially articulated by J. Louis Martyn and emerged partly as an attempt to explain the anti-Judaism in John by situating it within an intra-Jewish conflict. By connecting the healed man’s expulsion from the synagogue with the Birkat Ha-Minim, the ecclesiological tale ends up holding the first-century Jews responsible for John’s anti-Jewish language. So in an attempt to rescue the Fourth Gospel from the claws of anti-Jewish rhetoric, scholars have unwittingly given readers more reason to scapegoat and blame innocent victims by holding the Jews responsible for the Gospel’s anti-Judaism and thus have unwittingly done the very thing that Jesus refuses to condone in 9:3 when he says, “Neither this man nor his parents sinned.” The ecclesiological tale, therefore, offers fuel for a way of thinking that, I will argue, John 9 ultimately seeks to dismantle.
Finally, I will demonstrate how the narrative invites the reader to identify with the narrative’s villains and victimizers in order to realize the ways that she or he is trapped in systems of scapegoating and blinded by blame.
|
The Semantics and Pragmatics of Ἀποκρίνομαι ("I answer") in the Greek New Testament
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Fredrick J. Long, Asbury Theological Seminary
The purpose of this paper is to investigate the semantics and lexical pragmatics of the verb ἀποκρίνομαι in the GNT. The "deponent" verb ἀποκρίνομαι is a "speech orienter" and typically glossed "I answer," although Stephen Levinsohn has rightly noted the verb's pragmatic use "to indicate that the new speaker is seeking to take control of the conversation with an objection or new initiative that typically breaks the tight-knit nature of the exchange" (Discourse Features of New Testament Greek, p.231; cf. BDAG s.v. def.1 "answer, reply"). Lexicographically, however, more precision is possible by distinguishing the aorist -θη ("passive") formation from the aorist middle formation according to two second-century Greek grammarians, Ammonius and Phrynichus, who commented on the verb. (NOTE: I use the terms "middle" and θη- ["passive"] with regard to the Aorist voice for the sake of differentiating the respective formations even though it has become clear that the so-called θη- passive formation is later and begins to supplant and encompass middle voice senses even in the NT era, notwithstanding the semantic senses that I argue are entailed in the differing grammatical forms.) Ἀποκρίνομαι occurs 231 times (NA28) in the Gospels and Acts as well as in Col 4:6 and Rev 7:13. It occurs mostly in the aorist -θη passive formation (213 times) and, of these instances, one-hundred and three times as a circumstantial participle (often ἀποκριθείς). Ἀποκρίνομαι also occurs in the aorist middle seven times, the future passive three times, and the present middle/passive eight times.
Problematically, in twenty-five instances the NASB does not translate the aorist θη- passive of ἀποκρίνομαι (typically striving to be a word-for-word "literal" translation). The NIV2011 and NRSV follow suit in all but six instances. This failure to translate is especially frequent after non-speech circumstances or when ἀποκρίνομαι is seemingly redundant. Conversely, the aorist middle forms are always translated, which suggests initially that the middle formation functions differently than the θη- formation. Behind the translational inconsistency, I would maintain, are two related problems--first, an historic semantic problem in that we have not understood properly a distinction between the aorist θη- passive and aorist middle forms as attested by second-century grammarians, and second, a lexical pragmatic problem concerning the discourse function of ἀποκρίνομαι especially in its θη- formation. By investigating Ammonius and Phrynichus and by considering the component parts of ἀποκρίνομαι, I argue that there is in fact a historic lexical-semantic basis for understanding that the aorist θη- formation indicates "separation" and implies "taking control" in an agonistic or even antagonistic setting while the middle formation does not signify "separation" or imply agonism/antagonism but simply is used for answering questions. Indeed, observing the pragmatics of the θη- formation of ἀποκρίνομαι, when and where it occurs in speech or non-speech settings, typically provides important interpretive payoffs such as discerning tone, shifts of topic, significant points, climactic developments, and section breaks.
|
Constituent Marking, Semantic Diagraming, and Color-Coding for Learning Koine Greek
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Fredrick J. Long, Asbury Theological Seminary
My approach to language instruction is informed by the fields of text-linguistics, social-cultural intertextuality, and pragmatics. Communication is ostensive while at the same time deeply embedded in culture assuming shared cognitive environments. Ideally, biblical language instruction should correspond to the anticipated future habitual use(s) of the biblical languages by students, i.e., to have a deep, rich, fully-embodied understanding of what was/is communicated in Scripture. Importantly, too, the curriculum should foster the affective dimension of learning the biblical languages by addressing motivation, relevance, curiosity, appreciation of cultural-embedded meanings, and the aesthetic beauty of the language in written and oral form. In view of these factors, I propose a robust exegetical-pragmatic and social-cultural intertextual approach to language acquisition that teaches a restored Koine era pronunciation and discusses ancient artifacts (see my Koine Greek Grammar: A Beginning-Intermediate Exegetical and Pragmatic Handbook).
In my Greek exegesis class as an M. Div. student (1990), the guest lecturer Eugene Nida described how the basic sentence constituents consisted of conjunction, subject, verb, and any compliments. These arguments constitute basic slots for typical sentences. Everything else found in a sentence, insisted Nida, was a modifier. On the chalk board he then wrote out different verses from Mark's Gospel, diagramming and describing their constituents, to show the importance of reference disambiguation and modification. Building upon Nida's seminal insights, I have developed three different teaching approaches: constituent marking (first semester Greek), semantic diagramming (second semester Greek), and a color-coding schema applied to Greek sentences inside of Logos Bible Software (all subsequent courses). These approaches encourage students to visualize, navigate, observe, inquire about, and focus upon the most salient sentence constituents. The color coding alerts students to the presence of connectives, non-indicative moods, pronouns (which tell a story), prominent verb tenses, as well as to modifiers such as adverbs, prepositional phrases, quantitative descriptors, and comparisons/superlatives.
My overall approach to ancient Greek especially considers what I call "adjunctive grammar" since I pay attention to "optional" modifying constituents that reflect communicative import. In these approaches, students learn the value of word order, contextual-syntagmatic relations, paradigmatic options ("choice implies meaning"), and larger structural patterns of information structure as represented by the repetition of words and sounds, connectives, tense variations, lists, metacomments, generalizing statements, bracketing, chiasms, etc. The basic questions that operationalize my adjunctive approach are these: What are the core sentence constituents? What variations in word order are seen? What modifiers are present and what modifies what? How does each modifier modify what it does? And, why is the modification made in context? Students are always encouraged to ask questions and to consider the social-cultural context of the discourse.
For this session, when given a NT pericope, I would briefly demonstrate teaching each of these approaches, their benefits, and assessment. These approaches may be seen and discussed on my YouTube channel "Greek Matters."
|
What Are the Scriptural Reasons for Thinking that a Gift Can Be Given?
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Stephen A. Long, University of Notre Dame
For over two decades, a recurring theme in the theology of John Milbank has been the topic of gift-exchange. On Milbank’s construal, it is not merely the case that “donation” and “gift” are fundamental to accounts of being, grace, and/or ecclesiology: much more interestingly, gift-exchange, qua exchange, is fundamental. To cite briefly from an early article, “Even in its origin, the Church begins as an exchange and not as a simple reception of a unilateral gift”; and, “To be a Christian is not, as piety supposes, spontaneously and freely to love, of one’s own originality and without necessarily seeking any communion. On the contrary, it is to repeat differently, in order to repeat, exactly, the content of Christ’s life, and to wait, by a necessary delay, the answering repetition of the other that will fold temporal linearity back into the eternal circle of the triune life” (original emphases removed; both citations from “Can a Gift be Given? Prolegomena to a Future Trinitarian Metaphysic,” Modern Theology 11:1 [1995]: 119-61, here 150). In support, Milbank gestures broadly toward Old Testament themes such as “covenant” or “Jewish sacrifice”—yet these scriptural foundations are not developed in any great detail. In this paper, I propose to thicken Milbank’s scriptural account by examining the topic of reciprocity in the book of Sirach. Recent work on the roots of Jewish and Christian practices of charity have rightly pointed to the importance of Sirach in the development of “redemptive almsgiving.” It is rightly noted that Sirach advocates generosity to persons who may never be able to repay. What is less commonly recognized, however, is that certain passages indicate ongoing hopes or expectations of human reciprocation. One might view the simultaneity of hopes for human reciprocity and the seeming refusal of the same as a contradiction. I argue, to the contrary, that the logic of sacrifice “contaminates” Ben Sira’s account of intra-human reciprocity: in the first place, according to Sir 35, sacrifice is both an acknowledgment of God’s prior generosity and a “gift” that seeks further displays of divine generosity. Second, generosity to the poor is itself assimilated—most likely under “pressure” from the book of Deuteronomy—to sacrifice. Intra-human generosity therefore takes on a logic similar to sacrificial “gift-exchange”: like sacrifice, it both acknowledges a prior claim (divine generosity to oneself, which ought to be shared; the needy friend or brother as a “conduit” to God; etc.), yet also looks for a future round of giving. Ben Sira hopes that such future generosity might be initiated by neighbors with whom one is in solidarity and to whom one has already given generously; yet, because God is the ultimate guarantor of “repayment” (cf. Sir 12:2 and 35:13), no strict—and potentially enslaving—accounting from the neighbor is to be sought. To paraphrase Milbank, human gift-exchange is free to repeat differently, in order to repeat exactly, the content of a social life in solidarity with the Israelite “brother” before the “God who repays.”
|
Sacrifice as Gift and as Appeal to God in the Book of Ben Sira
Program Unit: Deuterocanonical and Cognate Literature
Stephen A. Long, University of Notre Dame
Several important studies have investigated Ben Sira’s attitude towards the priesthood and the temple cult. They have assessed the extent to which sacrifice is or is not “spiritualized” in Sir 35:1-5, and made conjectures about whether Ben Sira himself might have been a priest. However, the question of what the sage thought sacrifice itself might “mean” or “do” remains relatively unexplored until now. In this paper, I will examine Ben Sira’s use of “gift” language in describing sacrifice. I argue that he thinks of God as the underwriter of an “economy” in which God and his devotees exchange gifts: God “funds” his own sacrifices, enabling the worshipper to give joyfully and generously, and paying back his own extravagantly. Probing this language yields a fresh understanding of Ben Sira’s view of sacrifice. I argue that Ben Sira appropriates aspects of Deuteronomy in novel ways in his discourse on sacrifice in Sir 35. Further, the perspective developed here better equips us to read other relevant texts in Sirach for indications of how God was thought to answer—and so to “repay”—sacrifice in very concrete ways. I argue that sacrifice functions as means of thanks, of honor, and of “appeal” to the deity whose temple was in Jerusalem. Sacrifice as “gift” and as “appeal” are deeply interwoven conceptualizations for Ben Sira. This concept of sacrifice can be illumined by votive remains from sites in and around Palestine (e.g., Mt. Gerizim), and the Book of Ben Sira in turn offers discursive, textual indications of how such roughly-contemporaneous sacrificial and votive practice was likely understood.
|
Reconsidering the Date of the En-Gedi Leviticus Scroll (EGLev): Exploring the Limitations of the Comparative-Typological Paleographic Method
Program Unit: Qumran
Drew Longacre, Rijksuniversiteit Groningen
After the recent virtual unwrapping and deciphering of the remains of a charred Leviticus scroll from En-Gedi (hereafter EGLev), Ada Yardeni dated the scroll paleographically to the second half of the 1st century or early 2nd century CE, contemporary with some of the latest Dead Sea Scrolls. However, I will argue that the cumulative evidence from a wide variety of factors suggests a slightly later date. The archeological context from the En-Gedi synagogue, which was destroyed in the mid-6th century to early 7th century CE, renders such an early date intrinsically unlikely. With regard to bibliographic/voluminological details, the presence of a wooden roller and metallic ink suggest a date later than the 2nd century. The layout with tall, narrow columns reflects a late stage in a trajectory already evident in some of the latest Dead Sea Scrolls. A scroll containing only one book of the Pentateuch is consistent with Palestinian tradition prior to the dominance of the Babylonian tradition with its preference for complete Torah scrolls. Its strict proto-Masoretic textual character is normal for a late manuscript, but cannot necessarily preclude an early date. Overall, these various handwriting-independent factors suggest that EGLev should probably be dated within the period from the 3rd-6th centuries CE. Additionally, comparison with a range of comparanda from the 1st-8th centuries CE reveals a number of important typological developments evident in the hand of EGLev--most especially the opening of the left leg of "he", the opening of the top-left of final "mem", and the shifting of the junction in "taw"--likewise suggesting a date slightly later than the Dead Sea Scrolls of the 1st-2nd centuries, but clearly earlier than comparanda from the 6th-8th centuries. Thus, I suggest that EGLev should be dated to the period between the 3rd-4th centuries CE, with only a slight possibility that it could have been written in the 2nd or 5th centuries. This proposal possibly also finds support from the reported radiocarbon dating of a sample apparently from EGLev. This investigation of necessity explores the limits of the traditional comparative-typological paleographic method (i.e., poor comparative datasets and low-resolution typologies) and highlights the need for productive dialogue between a wide array of disciplines. In the end, it reveals an important missing link in the development of the Hebrew (proto-)square script in 3rd-4th-century CE Palestine, thus extending the chronological range of Hebrew "Dead Sea Scrolls" by more than a century.
|
Intertextuality in Pompeian Plaster: Can Vesuvian Artifacts Inform Our Expectations about Intertextual Expertise among Sub-elite Jesus-Followers?
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Bruce Longenecker, Baylor University
Audiences of New Testament texts are often enticed into intertextual tropes embedded within those texts. One of the difficulties regarding the effectiveness of intertextual tropes pertains to the expertise required by the audience in order to recognize and appreciate them. Was expertise of that kind restricted to the educated elite (as evidenced, for instance, by Seneca), or were intertextual tropes appreciated by a broader segment of Greco-Roman society? This paper (1) addresses that issue by canvassing a selection of the archaeological data from the first-century town of Pompeii and (2) suggests the relevance of that data for the study of New Testament texts.
|
Reading Basil’s Hexaemeron in Grecized Syriac: Athanasius II of Baladh and Early Syriac Lexicography?
Program Unit: International Syriac Language Project
Jonathan Loopstra, Northwestern College - St. Paul
Athanasius of Baladh (d. 687) is one of the more prolific translators trained in the celebrated West-Syrian monastery of Qenneshre. He is renowned for his translation of Porphyry’s Isagoge (MS. Vat. Syr. 158), the select Letters of Severus of Antioch (MS BL Add. 12181), and other works, many of which are now lost. The later West-Syrian tradition also ascribes to Athanasius translations of both the Homilies and the Hexaemeron of Basil of Caesarea. Although an earlier, periphrastic translation of the Hexaemeron exists in Syriac (Sinai Syr. MS 9), no complete manuscript of Athanasius’ later translation of this work is known.
Recently, however, one manuscript, of a genre of West-Syrian instructional handbooks, has been found to include readings from Basil’s Hexaemeron that are “in the translation of Blessed Mor Athanasius,” to quote the copyist. If true, we now have extended readings from the entirety of a second, more literal translation of the Hexaemeron in Syriac, one that appears to have been used to teach Basil’s works within the context of a highly-sophisticated West-Syrian scholastic culture. This paper will compare translation techniques between these extended excerpts from the Hexaemeron with other Syriac translations attributed to Athanasius II. One unexpected finding of this study is lexicographical. That is, many of the same Greek-Syriac definitions we find first in seventh-century translations attributed to Athanasius II eventually make their way into Medieval lexical lists and then into the works of later ninteenth-century lexicographers such as Thomas Audo, Payne-Smith, and others.
|
Is There an Argument for Teaching New Testament Studies with Undergraduates?
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Davina C. Lopez, Eckerd College
This paper will explore arguments for, and against, teaching New Testament studies with undergraduate students in the context of recent arguments about the value of the humanities. While some might argue for the theological or cultural import of scriptures, and thus the normative place of courses in biblical studies in an undergraduate religion department, an effective argument has yet to be made for why biblical scholars, and not historians, literature scholars, or classicists, should be the ones who teach about these texts with undergraduates. To this end, I will pose questions about what, exactly, the discipline of New Testament studies—and perhaps especially those who are engaged in rhetorical criticism—offers to pedagogies of religion and the humanities.
|
Elijah and Elisha: A Prophetic Locus of National Identity in the Absence of David and the Temple
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
Nathan Lovell, George Whitefield College
This paper reads the Elijah and Elisha narratives in 1&2 Kings in conversation with Anthony Smith’s ethnosymbolic approach to nationalism. I propose that the use Kings makes of the northern prophetic traditions can be understood as the intentional construction of a national identity that is reworked for an exilic or early post-exilic audience.
Smith’s political theory foregrounds the role that history, myth, and religion play in the formation of national identity, proposing that national identities, although strictly modern phenomena, often have much more ancient roots in the constructions that underlie ethnic identities. Particularly relevant are the roles of religion and history. In Smith’s terms, Judah’s pre-exilic national identity was constructed around the memory of David, the Davidic covenant, and the establishment of the cult in Jerusalem. However, the exile posed significant challenges to this.
The inclusion of the Elijah and Elisha narratives into DtrH has perplexed scholars because these narratives do not suit the interests of any of the Dtr historians. Their inclusion can be understood as providing a counterpoint locus of national identity around prophetic ministries, such as Ezekiel’s or Jeremiah’s. The intention of the history is not to overturn the former constructions, but to relativize them, providing an operative alternative in the absence of former symbols.
The narrative does this by endorsing the northern prophets as orthodox Yahwism, without denying the strong motif of centralization elsewhere. Even though they never call for reunification or opine for the temple, these prophets have a legitimate priestly role. Furthermore, the blessings that Solomon associates with the temple in his prayer (1 Kgs 8) are delivered through the ministries of Elijah and Elisha. Thus Elijah and Elisha are seen to be a valid but temporary locus of national identity in the absence of the Davidic symbols. For Babylonian or early Persian era Judaism this amounts to the construction of community identity centered on prophets like Ezekiel, Jeremiah, or Haggai.
|
Towards a Postcolonial, Pentecostal Reading of the New Testament
Program Unit:
U-Wen Low, Alphacrucis College
Different Pentecostal expressions flourish around the world, particularly in the Majority World. Such Pentecostal readings of the text are often “experiential” and focused on an interpretation directly relevant to the reader and their context. Postcolonial readings are similarly focused on the experiences of the marginalized—many of whom share in a pentecostal experience. Exploring the text through the twin lenses of postcolonial thought and the distinctive Pentecostal emphasis on pneumatology results in a fresh hermeneutical perspective: that the Holy Spirit might be understood as a postcolonial agent of change that empowers those who have experienced the baptism of the Holy Spirit to resist dominant structures of oppression. The New Testament text can therefore be understood as a “hidden transcript,” a disguised work of resistance composed by subaltern groups against dominance and oppression. This paper seeks to explore and discuss the potential theoretical underpinnings of a “pentecostal, postcolonial reading” of the New Testament, with a view towards constructing a hermeneutic that may assist in representing a Majority World expression of Pentecostalism.
|
“Surely God Is Poor and We Are Rich”: Q 3:181 and Jewish Blasphemy?
Program Unit: The Qur’an and the Biblical Tradition (IQSA)
Shari L. Lowin, Stonehill College
In his 2012 essay “Finhās of Medina: Islam, “The Jews,” and the Construction of Religious Militancy,” Michael Sells pointed out that taken all together, Islamic exegesis identifies a somewhat mysterious Jewish leader named Finḥās as the cause for the revelation of at least eight different verses of the Qur’ān. Interestingly, only half of these verses—each of which accuses a group of people of making sacrilegious statements about God—clearly identify the speaker or speakers as Jewish. The other half leave the speakers anonymous. More bafflingly, in most of these, an actual Jewish source behind the statement is not easily discernable. One such case is the well-known charge of Jewish blasphemy that appears in Q 3:181. Says the Qur’ān there, “Certainly God has heard the words of those who said, “Surely God is poor and we are rich.”” The Qur’an itself provides no context for this statement, nor does it clearly identify the speaker of these words. Yet the later Islamic exegetical materials largely agree that the speakers are not only Jews (possibly based on the latter half of the verse), but often name one Jew in particular, the aforementioned Finhās al-Yahudi. What’s more, they come to this conclusion by linking Q 3:181 to an unrelated phrase and teaching that appears three times in the Qur’an (2:245, 57:11, 64:17), in which God encourages Muslims to “lend God a goodly loan (qarḍ ḥasan)” with promises of a multiplied reward in return. Scholars have noticed a parallel teaching to the latter in Proverbs 19:17. There the Hebrew Bible counsels, “He that is gracious unto the poor lends unto the LORD; and his good deed will He repay unto him.” Yet this parallel verse cannot explain why the Islamic tradition connects the three-fold Qur’anic teaching on the goodly loan to the problematic claims in Q 3:181. Nor can it explain why the exegetes turn this shared teaching into a moment of Jewish blasphemy. This paper will discuss early rabbinic teachings on Proverbs 19:17, specifically as found in BT Baba Batra, Leviticus Rabbah, the Tanhuma and Mishnah Avot, as a possible source behind the Islamic tradition’s criticism of the Jews and a seemingly-out-place attribution to them of blasphemous financial critique of God.
|
Qur’anic Normativity: A (Preliminary) Nomochronic Assessment
Program Unit: Linguistic, Literary, and Thematic Perspectives on the Qur’anic Corpus (IQSA)
Joseph Lowry, University of Pennsylvania
Qur’anic Normativity: A (Preliminary) Nomochronic Assessment
|
Oracles and Magic in Ancient Egypt: The Case of the “Oracular Amuletic Decrees”
Program Unit: Prophetic Texts and Their Ancient Contexts
Rita Lucarelli, UC Berkeley
Within the textual traditions on divinatory and magical texts from ancient Egypt, the so-called “Oracular Amuletic Decrees” have an unusual format – they are inscribed on narrow strips of papyri that were rolled up and worn as amulets - and very peculiar content. They are a special kind of oracles of gods issuing and promising protection to newborns (most of them women) through their life. This paper will discuss the complex nature and unusual terminology of these documents in relation to the role of oracular practices and written magic in ancient Egypt.
|
Even One Who Is Traveling: Itinerancy, Divorce, and Masculinity in the Jesus Movement
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Timothy Luckritz Marquis, Moravian Theological Seminary
This paper posits that Jesus’s opposition to divorce (and perhaps marriage) arose in the context of questions about how travel affected his own marital status and that of his followers. At stake in this dispute was how Jesus-movement itinerancy fit within larger ancient contestations over masculinity and economic status. Scholarly attention to the itinerant lifestyle of Jesus and his disciples has raised the cognate issue of singleness or celibacy as linked to itinerancy (see, for example, Halvor Moxnes, Putting Jesus in His Place_). At the same time, the divorce pericopes—particularly the Markan version (10:1-12), which has often been seen as a narrative non sequitur—has been contextualized within rabbinic discussions of the permissibility of divorce. Reading itinerancy into the Markan divorce story helps deepen both approaches to the topic’s context. Mark’s version is the first incident after Jesus and his followers arrive in Judea from Galilee. In essence, we can read the Pharisees as greeting these travelers by asking, “Did you make provision for your wives while away from home?” (Similarly, Paul’s citation of Jesus’s divorce prohibition comes in a letter in which he refers to some apostles who travel with their wives.) Mishnaic discussions of divorce (particularly in tractate Gittin) frequently dwell upon the effect of travel on marriage and whether traveling men should leave their wives a provisional get (divorce certificate) in case they die on the road or otherwise do not return, partially as a way of avoiding any notion of divorce by abandonment. In such discussions, going on a journey is compared to being led to execution, contextualizing the issue of divorce with ancient tropes linking travel and death. Significantly, the rabbinic discussions cite a hypothetical trip between Galilee and Judea as being sufficiently long as to warrant leaving a provisional get (m.Git. 7:7). In dialogue with Daniel Boyarin’s discussion of travel, marriage, and rabbinic study in his _Carnal Israel_, I contextualize debates over Jesus’s itinerancy within how travel and its uncertainties (leading to a sort of social death) trouble attempts to reinforce the image of the stable male. In their travels, Jesus and his disciples performatively reject any provision for the present (either in terms of destination or return) in a way that reframes the demographic instability of the larger population by orienting their travel toward an eschatological future. Itinerancy and rejection of household as social death was later read into Jesus’s eventual demise by later textualizations of the Jesus tradition.
|
Dependency and Transmission of Abraham Traditions in the Pseudepigrapha
Program Unit: Transmission of Traditions in the Second Temple Period
Jared Ludlow, Brigham Young University
Abraham is one of the most well-known figures from the Hebrew Bible so, unsurprisingly, many traditions about him can be found among the Pseudepigraphic texts of Second Temple Judaism. While some of these later texts are obviously dependent upon the Genesis stories about Abraham, there are also facets of Abraham traditions that do not derive from Genesis yet are shared among several Second Temple Jewish texts. For example, some texts portray Abraham teaching the Egyptians about astronomy yet the only connection with Genesis is that Abraham went down into Egypt with his family to escape famine. Where did this additional facet of the tradition originate? Can one text be singled out as the most likely origin of this account from which others borrowed? If the texts are determined to be independent from each other, does this strengthen the likelihood that they are drawing upon a common tradition that wasn’t included in the canonical record, but was passed down orally or in a now lost written version? Shalom Spiegel and others contend that often parts of a tradition reappear or are revised due to contact with an alien culture. This could be the case with Second Temple Judaism and the interactions with Greco-Roman culture. This paper proposes to examine Abraham traditions among the Pseudepigrapha with the aim to determine dependency among them from which hopefully new insights can be gained into the mechanics of tradition transmission. It is hoped that by limiting the subject matter to Abraham, the corpus of texts to the Pseudepigrapha, and the time frame to the Second Temple Period, stronger possibilities of transmission and development can be argued.
|
Walking Oxyrhynchus: Local Religion, Early Christian Diversity, and the Vulnerability of Transmission
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
AnneMarie Luijendijk, Princeton University
This paper examines the Christian literary papyri found at Oxyrhynchus through the lens of Michel de Certeau’s notion of "Walking the City.” It argues three points: First, Oxyrhynchus offers an unmatched opportunity to study local religion and every day practice. Furthermore, the Christian Oxyhrynchus papyri help to fill in a crucial gap in our documentation, helping us to begin to understand the so-called Little Peace, the period between the Decian persecution and the Great Persecution. Finally, the Christian literary papyri from Oxyrhynchus also confront us with the vulnerability of transmission.
|
Accents, Prosody, and Syntax: A Comparison of Biblical Hebrew and Syriac Masoretic Traditions
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Johan M. V. Lundberg, University of Cambridge
This paper explores the intersection between accents and syntax. More specifically, it investigates the use of accents and pausal forms in the main Hebrew Masoretic traditions in comparison with the Masorah of the Syriac Peshitta. In the past scholars have argued that Biblical Hebrew accents primarily mark semantic units and/or syntactic relations (Yeivin 1980; Aronoff 1985). More recently Dresher has suggested that they serve a prosodic rather than a semantic or syntactic purpose (1994, 2013). On the phrasal level, Hebrew accents are used to connect words into phrasal units. In the Tiberian Hebrew tradition, the major disjunctive accents silluq, ʾatnaḥ, and ʿole wə-yored are typically used together with a pausal form at the end of a pronunciation unit. Pausal forms are sometimes used with the weaker disjunctive accents as well, particularly segolta, zaqef, and ṭippeḥa (Fassberg 2013; cf. Revell 1980). In Syriac, pausal accents such as pasōqā, ‘alāyā, taḥtāyā and šewāyā play an important role in the elaborate system of accents. Moreover, the placement of an accent above, on, or below the line often marks its tonal value. For example, the accent paqodā was placed above an imperative or jussive to indicate the rising tone (Segal 1953). The comparison of the Hebrew and Syriac systems will outline the trajectories of the systems, noting both similarities and differences. Through this comparison, it is possible to understand better how the different systems developed in relation to each other. This paper focuses in particular on the use of accents in the Hebrew and Syriac traditions in subordinate constructions, and examines whether the prosodic divisions expressed by the accents can be correlated with intonation group boundaries in subordinate constructions in spoken languages.
|
The Gospel of Matthew and Social Identity Formation
Program Unit: Writing Social-Scientific Commentaries of the New Testament
Petri Luomanen, University of Helsinki
The paper discusses social identity formation in the Gospel of Matthew in order to also addresses a broader methodological question on what grounds it is possible to use a narrative of Jesus in the analysis of social identity formation. The paper argues that although social-scientific analysis is sometimes presented as an alternative or corrective to redaction-critical and theological analysis, the application of the social identity approach receives its strongest justification from the observations of classic redaction-critical analyses of the way how the editor of Matthew's Jesus narrative has molded its characters and their relation to Jesus.
|
Paul’s Binding Spells? Pauline Letters and Ancient Curse Tablets
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Susanne Luther, Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz
This paper is based on the research we are doing in Mainz on the relationship between curse tablets and the New Testament with a view to the reception and transformation of pagan curse formulations in early Christianity. Curses, e.g. in the form of curse tablets (defixiones), were used in ancient Greco-Roman religiosity to control or restrain rivals by threatening to inflict physical, emotional, intellectual or spiritual harm or even death. Curses were used in a broad variety of contexts in order to influence situations in life, to rectify injustices or to moderate competitive situations. The focus of this paper will be on continuities and discontinuities concerning the formulations and intentions with which curse formulas are used and transformed in Paul’s letters to the Corinthians, which indicate a deep-rootedness in the ancient pagan religious context and all the same serve as defining markers of early Christian identity over against pagan cults. The apostle knew and used the power of curse formulations that his addressees were familiar with, he employed curse formulations and transformed them into positive binding spells – e.g. in handing people over to God and Christ – for the use in his communities.
|
Late Bronze-Early Iron Age Texts and the Hebrew Bible in Light of Modern Anthropological Indicators of Famine
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Michael C. Lyons, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion
The present paper summarizes my recent research on famine in the textual remains of the eastern Mediterranean world during the Late Bronze–Early Iron Age transition. Recent palaeoclimatological and archaeological evidence has suggested that a significant dry period occurred at this time. But no one has studied the complete textual record to determine what evidence for famine exists. In addition, no study has developed a method for how to discern famine in a text or how to understand the different ways in which famine is expressed in ancient Near Eastern literature or the Hebrew Bible. To fill this gap, I review an anthropological method that I developed to uncover textual evidence of famine from this period. By using modern anthropological indicators of famine from three different stages of famine (Alarm, Resistance, and Exhaustion), this paper then summarizes the results from applying this method on documents from Egypt, Hatti, Emar, and Ugarit that shed light on famine during the Late Bronze Age collapse. The data produce more textual evidence of famine in this period than was previously believed to exist. Egypt, formerly ignored, contains significant textual evidence of famine. The documents from Hatti, Emar, and Ugarit demonstrate that each endured a great struggle with famine; not just Hatti alone. In addition, the second half of the paper explores how famine functions as a literary device and motif in ancient Near Eastern literature, including the Hebrew Bible, based on a study of the aforementioned texts and modern anthropology. One can see commonly shared expressions of famine in the Late Bronze–Early Iron Age literature and the Hebrew Bible. Of the many that I uncovered, I will review four technical expressions in the language and two literary motifs. This study helps clarify our understanding of history in the Late Bronze Age collapse, providing us with greater insight into famine in the ancient world that will be useful for science, history, anthropology, and for the study of ancient Near Eastern literature and the Hebrew Bible.
|
Virtuoso of Life: Notions of Ideal Person in Analects vis-à-vis Proverbs
Program Unit: Korean Biblical Colloquium
Sun Myung Lyu, Baekseok University
The implied audience of Confucius’s Analects and the Book of Proverbs is the impressionable and un(der)experienced pupil, and both regard shaping an ideal character in the pupil as the ultimate task of moral education. Reading Proverbs in light of pedagogy theory and virtue ethics has yielded valuable insights for understanding and developing human character. One such insight is the central role of the righteous and wise character in the rhetoric and pedagogy of the book. This ideal person, predominantly called as righteous person (tsaddiq) is inescapably wise (hakham) as well. This person, as the embodiment of integrity and wisdom, makes life choices aligned with those values. As such he is the virtuoso of life who lives according to the divine will. The Confucian ideal person, called Junzi in Analects, fulfills moral obligations in accordance with the heaven’s will. He values righteousness higher than personal interest. A common feature found in both books is the use of what we may call “binary anthropology,” which employs contrast between the ideal person and the anti-ideal person to convey its message. Proverbs uses the polarity of righteous vs. wicked and wise vs. foolish, whilst Analects employs Junzi (君子) vs. xiaoren (小人) polarity for the same rhetorical purpose. Similarities in this polar dynamic abound: the Junzi lives for the right and larger than his life; the xiaoren lives only for himself and for immediate and petty gains. The righteous cares for the less privileged, even the animals; the wicked mete out only pain and cruelty instead. The Junzi lives in peace and harmony whereas the xiaoren is agitated and freightened for no reason. The righteous is as at ease as a lion but the wicked fleas when no predator is in sight. Such commonalities suggest that a comparative study of Analects vis-à-vis Proverbs can provide a deeper understanding of how to nurture the virtuoso of life in a way that honors and maximizes the textual-authorial intent of the ancient sages.
|
God’s Gift in Ephesians: Dwelling in the Space of Divine Transcendence in the Face of Hopelessness and Dislocation
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Margaret Y. MacDonald, Saint Mary's University (Halifax)
Eph 2:8-10, which explicitly refers to “the gift” (dōron), has often been viewed as one of the most concise summaries of Pauline theology in the New Testament. At the same time, it is widely acknowledged that concepts of grace are being used in a new way to respond to a changed situation. Drawing upon John Barclay’s findings, this paper explores the perspective of Ephesians in comparison to Galatians and Romans. Special attention will be paid to how the presentation of God’s gift is shaped by an Imperial situation and strong sentiments concerning a previous life (and dominant society) characterized by alienation, dislocation, and hopelessness.
|
Nadab and Abihu's Ritual Innovation (Leviticus 10)
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
Nathan MacDonald, University of Cambridge
The offering of strange fire by Nadab and Abihu on the final and climactic day of the priesthood's inauguration has puzzled interpreters since antiquity. What was their error that led to such catastrophic consequences? If the mistake is not to be repeated, it would seem important for early readers to be able to determine the precise nature of the infraction. I shall argue, however, that Nadab and Abihu's error provides no additional insight about how to obey the Mosaic instructions. The offering of incense has already become a trope for illicit ritual improvisation. Nor does it provide evidence of splits within the Aaronide priestly sept. Instead, the two instances of paronomasia at the beginning and end of the story embed the incident in the ritual on the eighth day, and suggest that Lev 9-10 turn around the question of what happens to the sacrificial remains (hannôtārîm/ hannôteret). The story of Nadab and Abihu with its implication that ritual innovation must on no account occur diverts the readers' attention from the scribes' own ritual innovation that seeks to resolve contradictory instructions about the sacrificial remains.
|
Writing, Revelation, and Knowledge in the Aramaic Texts from Qumran
Program Unit: Prophetic Texts and Their Ancient Contexts
Daniel Machiela, McMaster University
The corpus of Aramaic texts discovered at Qumran witnesses to a creative fusion between wisdom and apocalyptic revelation in early Judaism. Evidence of this fusion extends well beyond the well-known examples of 1 Enoch and Daniel, to texts such as the Aramaic Levi Document, Genesis Apocryphon, and Tobit. In these and other works, we see a blending of the skills associated with a scribe, the traits of a wise person, and the reception of heavenly revelation. This combination was made manifest, for example, through explicit notifications that heavenly revelations were written down by exceptionally wise, righteous individuals (e.g., Dan 7:1, Tob 12:20). I will explore these connected themes in the Qumran Aramaic corpus, paying particular attention to how they draw on earlier ideals of prophecy and influence later writings like Jubilees.
|
“God Has Had Mercy on Me”: Theology and Soteriology in De sacrificiis Abelis et Caini
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Scott Mackie, Independent Scholar
De sacrificiis Abelis et Caini contains a number of noteworthy soteriological themes, including the “taming of the passions,” transformative revelatory experiences expressed in mystery cult imagery, noetic ascent, and seeing God. Most prominent, however, are the complex depictions of agency that occur throughout the treatise. Though Philo stresses the necessity of human “toil” as “the beginning of all goodness and true worth,” he repeatedly and unequivocally emphasizes the priority of divine agency. It is upon divine mercy that “all things are securely anchored.” An engaging and attractive portrayal of God also is apparent in this treatise. Though Sacr. 94–96 asserts that the deity transcends all anthropomorphic and anthropopathic human conceptions, this philosophical conceit fails to fully cohere with the relational and immanent God who is more commonly encountered in the treatise. Unexpectedly imparting his attributes of apathy and mercy, the “savior” of Sacr. graciously “draws the perfect human from earthly things to himself.” Recognizing these divergent depictions of the deity, and attempting to reconcile the fault-lines that divide them, is essential in interpreting this remarkable treatise. In so doing, we see yet again that Philo’s allegiances to philosophy are overshadowed by his commitment to the God of sacred scripture.
|
Masoretic Minutiae or Mainstay of Exegesis?
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Dennis R. Magary, Trinity Evangelical Divinity School
Reasons for studying the Masorah have focused largely on literary critical and historical benefits. This paper will propose an additional practical and pedagogical reason for gaining a working knowledge of the Masoretic notes, the Masorah Parva in particular. In addition to gaining a better understanding of the textual tradition and appreciating the rich history of the text of the Hebrew Bible, this paper will explain and illustrate how the marginal notes of the Masorah Parva can be utilized for informed and substantive exegetical analysis of the Hebrew text. Indications of word frequency, cases of unusual or unique morphology and syntax, special collocations and word combinations, as well as distinctive vocabulary and spelling within particular sections of the Hebrew canon can be exploited in the service of exegesis, informing both syntagmatic and paradigmatic analysis. When combined with technology, the Masorah can become the mainstay for a robust exegetical exploration of the biblical Hebrew text.
|
Palestinian Synagogues in the Time of Jesus
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Jodi Magness, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
Although the origins of the synagogue are shrouded in mystery, there is no doubt they existed by the time of Jesus. Nevertheless, scholars disagree about the nature of first century synagogues and their relationship to synagogues of later centuries. This paper surveys the archaeological evidence of first century synagogues in Palestine, including the Theodotos inscription and the claimed synagogue from the time of Jesus at Capernaum. I conclude that few first century synagogues have been identified because the term does not always denote a purpose-built building, and because synagogues in this period were congregational halls or gatherings without the liturgical features that developed later. I also question the assumption by some scholars that first century synagogues were associated with the Pharisees.
|
Philippians 2:7 and Origen on Christological Unity
Program Unit: Development of Early Christian Theology
Michael Magree, University of Notre Dame
Henri Crouzel points out that Origen’s interpretation of the “emptying” of Philippians 2:7 is unusual in the history of doctrine because of the specific contours of his Christology and Anthropology. Because all rational souls preexist any enfleshment, and indeed, because one rational soul has been united with the Word from the beginning of its existence, the incarnation of the Word is of an already-rationally-ensouled Word. Thus the subject of the “emptying” of Philippians 2:7 is this ensouled-Word. That Origen’s doctrine of Christ’s soul depends on his doctrine of the pre-existent noes has been pointed out by Rowan Williams, among others, but what has yet to be noted is how Origen’s Christology is shaping, but also shaped by, his interpretation of Philippians 2:7.
At times, Origen’s Christology is shaping his exegesis in order to satisfy an apologetic end. In the Contra Celsum, especially 4.15-18, Origen takes up the Platonist charge that Christians believe in a mutable god. Here the “emptying” of Philippians 2 is a key passage that Origen must explain in such a way as to preserve divine immutability.
But at De Principiis 2.6 one can see a richer interplay between Christology and the exegesis of Philippians 2:7. Here “emptying” seems to be taken as part of the rule of faith (as one might expect from De Princ. Pref.4) which exerts interpretative pressure on Christology. The language of revelation has an interpretative priority which then bears on Origen’s specific doctrine of Christ. To account for the language of “emptying” Origen has to explain not only humanity and divinity in Christ, but their unity of subject “in one and the same thing” (in uno eodemque, De Principiis 2.6.2). Here one can see how appreciation of the interpretative challenge of Philippians 2:7 adds something to the analysis of Crouzel, who explains the theological force of Origen’s doctrine of pre-existent rational souls largely in terms of an anti-Valentinian teaching on theodicy and on the freedom of rational creatures. In De Princ. 2.6 one sees the further exegetical and Christological force of the doctrine, such that the rational soul “acts as a medium between God and the flesh” (De Princ. 2.6.3, tr. Butterworth) and thus acts as their principle of union.
Origen shows that the question of the principle of unity in Christ is already linked to the interpretation of Philippians 2:7 two centuries before Cyril of Alexandria makes its exegesis a focal point of his theology. What helps drive Cyril towards a “hypostatic” union had given Origen, in the different climate of the 3rd century, yet another reason to claim the Word’s pre-incarnate union with the rational soul.
|
Manna as Resistance: From an Economy of Accumulation towards Liberation in Exodus 16
Program Unit: Biblical Literature and the Hermeneutics of Trauma
Jennifer Maidrand, The Theological School at Drew University
If memory is a means of repositioning oneself, or even locating oneself within history, then memory is not merely a repository of events passed. Richard Moye understands myth as a sort of narrating, a “sacred history” which “stabilizes and orders, or regenerates and gives meaning to, what is seen as the chaos of human, or secular and profane, history.” There is much at stake in collecting and telling memories, both for individuals and communities, often serving as means for identity formation in murky and traumatic times. The entirety of the Hebrew Bible, then could be understood as definition and redefinition of identity in the wake of chaos, displacement, political oppression. The story of the Exodus is a glimmering example. Chapter 16 of the Book of Exodus is one particularly troubling narrative where near everything appears unrecognizable and precarious, from the people Israel’s identity to the manna of the ground that sustains them in the wilderness. When read from the perspective of a people grappling with the trauma of war, displacement, and political liberation, this story contains significant economic implications, of both the systems which Israel is seeking liberation from, and the new agricultural economics of the wilderness they are struggling to decipher. In this paper, I suggest that the manna God provides for a transient Israel outside of Egypt encompasses the complexity of the people’s struggle for liberation. With its appearance, an alternative economy is established for the community—one that requires unfamiliar dependence on a foreign land, yet garners an ethic of reciprocity in maintaining Sabbath for it. This story functions both as an imaginative construction of a liberated community’s identity, and as questioning of whether they are truly liberated at all. I argue that the “wilderness economy” constructed in Exodus 16 is the establishment of a relationship of dependence and reciprocity between humans and the earth. This economy is one that must be established for the people to journey through foreign wilderness and work towards a land promised. The function of manna in the wilderness as a tool for political and economic resistance and re-imagination does not remain in the space and time immediately following the event of the exodus. It is the nourishment woven into the fibers of Israel’s new being, an ethic that they see set before them as they continue to journey towards a land envisioned, a land sustained with the milk and honey that flows from the labor of liberation.
|
How the Fluidity of Joshua Traditions Challenges Methodological Assumptions
Program Unit: Transmission of Traditions in the Second Temple Period
Ville Mäkipelto, University of Helsinki
Recent textual research has demonstrated that there was no single book of Joshua in the late Second Temple period. When one takes all the manuscript evidence into account—without canonical presuppositions—the transmission of Joshua traditions often appears to have been quite fluid. Nevertheless, the repercussions of this textual fluidity have not yet been investigated enough. This paper examines the transmission and interpretation of the curse upon the rebuilder of Jericho (Josh 6:26) in various divergent traditions (MT Josh, LXX Josh, 4Q379, 4Q175, Samaritan Josh traditions, and 1 Kgs 16:34). It illustrates some of the methodological implications of this complex case. Through a careful textual analysis, three implications can be drawn: (1) the boundary between lower (textual) and higher (redaction) criticism is artificial, (2) Joshua traditions should not be categorized with the anachronistic labels of "biblical" and "parabiblical/rewritten", and (3) the textual and editorial history of the book of Joshua cannot be seen as a unilinear development. Even though the manifold textual evidence challenges many assumptions, it also shows the way forward in studying the diachronic development of Joshua traditions.
|
Onesimus as Surrogate: Koinonia When Some Are More Equal Than Others; Reading Chattel Status
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Robert D. Maldonado, California State University - Fresno
There are compelling reasons to see slavery both as a significant element of the Pauline (not just post-Pauline) churches and as assumed in Paul’s (and certainly post-Paul’s) theological perspective(s). The negotiation between Paul and Philemon over Onesimus, for all of its interpretive challenges, highlights the role of Onesimus as a surrogate. The Roman legal context of koinonia is important here (U. Roth, 2014). I read this negotiation as well in the light of Roman hiring out their slaves. As chattel, slaves had no right to enter into koinoia. As surrogate, Onesimus’ chattel status is reinforced. Just as attempts to redeem slavery with some notion of mutual service so divorce the new interpretation from the historical reality of slavery (and so fail), so too does examination of surrogacy without attending to the historical context of patriarchal power.
This paper explores the chattel status of Onesimus as surrogate and offers a critique of its context for the negotiation of patriarchal power between Paul and Philemon. Only after the critique can the meaning of surrogacy emerge in its own right (or fail in its metaphorical application). Just as the notion mutual service draws no benefit, only harm, from being likened to slavery, so might mutual standing for/with others draw no benefit from being likened to the dominant forms of surrogacy.
|
Walking a Knife’s Edge: Blasphemy as a Moral Obligation
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Robert D. Maldonado, California State University - Fresno
Blasphemy, like treason, depends on perspective and power. Idolatry versus true religion is similarly constructed. Speaking the truth to power will almost always be perceived as a kind of blasphemy by the powerful and the comfortable. When theological institutions are constructed in relation to the powerful, for example, with the divine right of kings or a theologically instituted manifest destiny, blasphemy is rendered with a political dimension. The contemporary context is even more fraught with the polarization of both politics and religion. Places with enforced blasphemy laws also have a lessening enforcement of human rights. Highly polarized contexts without explicit blasphemy laws, such as the United States, still witness the use blasphemy as a political and theological tool.
This paper contextualizes blasphemy within this political context and then reads texts, ranging from the “traditional,” e.g, Leviticus and the Jesus tradition, through relative (in)tolerance for profane God-talk and the post-liberal Bible. It concludes with an examination of the kind of moral obligation blasphemy might be, both in evaluating the Bible and, more broadly, within the fraught theo-political landscape.
|
“The Best Mimic of Human Language”: Animality, Speech, and Disability in the Church History of Philostorgius of Borissus
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
David Maldonado Rivera, Kenyon College
This paper is focused on the issues of representation and the intersections of animality, human speech, and disability in the reception of the Trinitarian debates of the late fourth century in one of the few partially extant non-Nicene ecclesiastical histories of the fifth century C.E., namely that of Philostorgius of Borissus, partisan of the Heteroousian or Eunomian Christian faction in Constantinople. Considering the recent contributions by scholars like Donna Haraway, Sunauara Taylor, Sara Imhoff, and Christian Laes, I examine the Church History’s classicizing/antiquarian register—filled with ethnographic, geographical, and zoographic digressions—as the ground in which the contentions between orthodoxy, heterodoxy, and traditional Greco-Roman cultic traditions and education were transposed into the debate regarding the definition and characterization of abled and disabled bodies and their entanglements at the imagined thresholds between the human and non-human. Moreover, this study emphasizes the importance that naturalist and medicinal training held for Philostorgius’s attempts to refute and de-naturalize the links between heterodoxy, animality, legal vulnerability, and non-human speech in pro-Nicene polemical culture. Important for this context are the decades of unfavorable legislation against so-called Eunomians (who are heavily featured in Book XVI of the Theodosian Code from the 380s to 420s) and the heresiological rhetoric that projected unto heterodoxy a host of vulnerabilities ranging from animal irrationality, demonic possession, and mental disability. Whereas pro-Nicene authors like Epiphanius of Cyprus, Gregory of Nyssa, John Chrysostom, and Jerome of Stridon make an effort to make Eunomius’s speech impairment and skin disease (alphous, according to Philost. H.E. 10.6 [SC 564:496]) signs of his doctrinal disposition, Philostorgius explores the valences of speech as a problematic category to attach to orthodoxy, humanity, and the non-human.
|
Exodos: Lexical History and Reception of a Greek Term
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Anna Mambelli, Université de Strasbourg
This paper will contribute to the lexical history and development of a Greek word found in the Septuagint and its reception history.
|
Ascent, Performance, and Textual Space: Pilgrimage to the Mountain and Its Temple in Early Rabbinic Literature
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
John Mandsager, University of South Carolina - Columbia
The rabbis of the first and second century describe spatial and bodily performances that involve motion upwards, up the mountain to Jerusalem, to see and be seen in the Temple. In this paper, I will consider how the early rabbis prescribe adherence to and participation in the three pilgrimage festivals commanded in the Bible (Passover, Shavuot, and Sukkot) as well as the presentation of the “first-fruits” offering in the Temple. With reference to the reciprocal relationships of space and practice described by such theorists as Lefebvre, de Certeau, and Butler, I will describe how the early rabbis attempt to create normative Jewish subjects through literary descriptions of bodily motion in space. Rabbinic discussions of pilgrimage, including the three festivals and the procession and presentation of the “first-fruits” (bikkurim), provide evidence of space-in-the-making, of spaces remembered and recreated literarily, particularly after the destruction of the Temple itself in 70 C.E. Thus, my analysis will be phenomenological and literary: I find the mountain, the pilgrims, and the Temple itself within text, rather than on the ground. In addition, by way of performance theory (including Schechner and Taylor), I will consider the “theatrical” aspects of these movements up the mountain to Jerusalem: the procession of the “first-fruits” is particularly rich with description of preparation, movement, music, and song, with a final set of (constrained) performances within the Temple precinct itself. Of particular note is the combination of normative bodies (in particular, free men of property and the age of maturity) and the spaces they move through—from preparation in town, in costume moving up the mountain, and then face-to-face with the priests, and as Neis argues (The Sense of Sight in Rabbinic Literature, 2013), God himself. Representations of the relationships between bodies and spaces present opportunities for me to investigate how the early rabbis imagined, idealized, and (re-)presented the bodies and spaces of their worlds. By considering rabbinic discussions of pilgrimage to Har ha-Bayit (“The Mountain of the House,” or the Temple Mount), I will show how the early rabbis simultaneously and reciprocally make arguments which create idealized rabbinic Jews and the space of the Temple Mount itself.
|
Towards an African Biblical Virtue Ethics? Hermeneutical and Methodological Reflections with Insights from the Letter to Titus
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Dogara Ishaya Manomi, Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz
This paper employs virtue ethics as the hermeneutical framework on which its ethical claims are built. It asks and answers, “what concepts of virtue are in African ethics? How are those virtue concepts in tandem or tension with the virtue-ethical perspectives of the letter to Titus (henceforth, Titus)? What methodologies are appropriate for an inter-disciplinary enterprise of appropriating the virtue-ethical perspectives of Titus into African ethics, towards articulating an African biblical virtue ethics?”
The paper approaches these questions by applying three coherent methodologies as follows: First, it applies the “exegethics” methodology in analyzing self-control, justice, and the “household codes” in Titus virtue-ethical. Second, it applies the “Four S Schema” methodology in describing the virtue-ethical perspectives of African ethics with respect to the sources, senses, symbols, and services of character in moral formation and function. Third, it applies the “Progressive-Negotiated-Ethics” methodology in describing the tandems and tensions between the virtue concepts of African ethics and those of Titus. Moreover, this methodology appropriates the two virtue-ethical perspectives towards imagining and emerging a third-horizon virtue-ethical space described as African biblical virtue ethics, which is “at home” to Africans and accountable to biblical exegesis. Nevertheless, for want of space, the first two methodologies are briefly described while the third is applied more elaborately because it synthesizes the first two methodologies.
The paper argues that the virtue-ethical concepts of African ethics in comparison with the virtue-ethical perspectives of Titus have foundational and narrative tensions, yet they are in tandem in some important aspects. Hence, appropriating a virtue ethic that is relevant to African contexts and at the same time accountable to the virtue-ethical perspectives of Titus involves the application of the three coherent methodologies described above.
The thesis of the paper, therefore, is that through the coherent application of the exegethics, the Four S Schema, and the Progressive-Negotiated-Ethics methodologies, an African biblical virtue ethics emerges as an ethical space negotiated from the virtue concepts of African ethics and biblical ethics. Such a virtue-ethical space takes both the biblical texts and the complexities of African ethics seriously.
|
The Image of the Invisible God: Christ's Embodied Humanity and Theological Anthropology
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Marc Cortez, Wheaton College
The Image of the Invisible God: Christ's Embodied Humanity and Theological Anthropology
|
Some Assembly Required: Affect and the Politics of Solidarity before and after Paul's Letters
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Joseph A. Marchal, Ball State University
Why did people assemble in the communities that received Paul’s letters? How did they sustain their assemblies in the face of internal and external pressures and an often-cantankerous apostle who addressed them? This paper wonders historically, theoretically, and practically about these two questions, particularly in the light of the ways Paul’s letters reflect ancient anti-types about women, slaves, and Gentiles, even as most models of these assemblies presume the marked presence of women, slaves, and Gentiles. My hypothesis is that recent work on affect and social movements can provide new angles on these assemblies and these fraught dynamics. Critical theorists like Judith Butler (2015) and Michael Hardt and Antonio Negri (2017) have shown increasing interest in practices of assembly. Both focus on the relations of cooperative collectivity under precarious conditions, with the latter stressing how groups rather than leaders can drive strategies, and the former highlighting the necessary performativity of provisional alliances and unchosen cohabitations. Though these accounts of a politics of solidarity are already affective and performative (and already informed by, or as, feminist and queer approaches), they can be extended and specified before relating them to the first century setting of ancient assemblies. Intersectional feminist and queer approaches to solidarity (by Sara Ahmed 2004; Deborah Gould 2009; and Carolyn Pedwell 2014; inter alia) stress the roles of affect to examine how groups gather and movements move. They attend to dynamics of circulation and repetition to account for adherence and cohesion, tracing how feelings travel and stick, providing opportunities for shared purpose in spite of tightly constrained sociopolitical conditions. These studies of affect and social movement do more than explain why the assemblies would put up with people (like Paul) who circulated gendered, sexualized, and racialized figures of disgust in their correspondence. Rather, they help us to focus on the aspects of these exchanges that were likely circulating before (and after) the epistles, including especially the various formulas, hymns, and slogans quoted (if even partially). The propositional content of the hymn in Philippians 2:6-11, the baptismal formula in Galatians 3:28 (and 1 Corinthians 12:13), or the slogans in 1 Corinthians 6:12; 7:1; and 8:1 (“all things are lawful for me”; “It is good for a man not to touch a woman”; and “all of us possess knowledge,” respectively) each merit close examination for their potential kyriarchal impacts. Yet, intersectional work on affect invites further consideration for how and why women and (or as) slaves and (or as) Gentiles would assemble to recite and sing, to gather and move together under such signs and sensations. These historical queries about the performative and affective qualities of assembly practices in antiquity, in turn, invite a reconsideration of how to do solidarity politics in the twenty-first century.
Basic (if potentially unnecessary) inclusion rider: If this abstract is accepted, this presenter will decline to participate if placed on an all white male panel.
|
The Masorah’s Recognition of the Accusative Particle אֶת
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
David Marcus, Jewish Theological Seminary of America
t is usually thought that in areas of grammar the Masorah is primarily useful for matters of phonology, morphology, and lexicon. But what is not widely known is that the Masorah has a number of notes that deal with areas of syntax. This paper will discuss one of these areas, that of the Masorah’s recognition of the accusative particle אֶת. It will be shown that the Masorah is well aware of the accepted rules governing this particle, and is also aware of the fact that on many occasions this accusative particle is often missing where it would normally be expected.
|
Inspired Text, or Inspired Author? Theosis to Write, Theosis to Interpret in Maximos the Confessor
Program Unit: Biblical Exegesis from Eastern Orthodox Perspectives
Mark Mariani, University of Notre Dame
As with most of his Ambigua, Maximos the Confessor (580-662 C.E.) devotes his tenth Ambiguum to explicating a passage from Gregory Nazianzen. One of Maximos’ chief aims is to explicate how reason and contemplation must pass, as Gregory says, through a cloud or veil to achieve union with God. He argues that the saints, including many from the Old Testament, have reached this union, theosis, but lingers on the disciples who were present at Christ’s Transfiguration (Peter, James, and John).
For Maximos, the glory of the Lord is what begets knowledge, and in this case, it illuminated the disciples, unveiling both the witness of Scripture and creation. Divine glory, for Maximos, not only inspired the disciples to read their Scriptures, but it also inspired them with further revelation.
Maximos’ argument about inspiration emerges from the matrix of his exegesis and understanding of theosis. In this study, I make two arguments about the tenth Ambiguum. First, Maximos’ understanding of inspiration is relatable. By this, I mean to say that he places the three disciples on the same plane as any human who undergoes theosis. Thus, to speak of the Scriptures as inspired, for Maximos, is as much of a reflection on the texts’ authors as it is about the texts themselves. Second, while it is only the Synoptic Gospels that narrate the Transfiguration, Maximos prioritizes John’s Gospel and author in his discussion on divinized interpretation and revelation. Maximus communicates much of the content revealed by Christ’s transfigured glory in the grammar of John’s Gospel. Further, he reflects not only on the nature of inspiration as such, but particularly the inspiration of a particular author and human, John. In this sense, he finds a kindred spirit in Augustine, whose reading of John’s Gospel also prioritizes theosis.
|
Joseph in Egypt and Israel’s Knowledge of the “Soul of the Stranger”
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
Dominik Markl, Pontifical Biblical Insitute
The Joseph Story stands out for its careful psychological portrayal of individual characters and the development of relationships that have ethical implications on the social and even political level. Having been himself a victim of human trafficking, and having gone through the experience of traumatic separation from his family, Joseph becomes a paradigmatic wise politician who welcomes economic refugees, including his own family. The present paper builds upon an earlier study of the implications of the Joseph Story for the legal hermeneutics of the redacted Pentateuch (co-authored with Alexander Ezechukwu, “»For You Know the Soul of a Stranger« (Exod 23:9): The Role of the Joseph Story in the Legal Hermeneutics of the Pentateuch”, Zeitschrift für Altorientalische und Biblische Rechtsgeschichte 21 [2015] 215–232). It will explore further the ethical implications of the presentation of Joseph’s experience as a stranger in the wider context of (forced) migration in the Pentateuch.
|
Ambrose of Milan on Genesis
Program Unit: Early Exegesis of Genesis 1–3
Christoph Markschies, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin - Humboldt University of Berlin
It¹s a widespread prejudice that Ambrose of Milan compiled when commenting Genesis many lines of Philo and Origen without mentioning his sources - since Jerome he is seen as a simple plagiarist and compiler. But such an image is based on modern ideas of newness and originality. In the paper Ambrose will be discussed on the background of ancient literary criticism and profiled as an author with specific auctorial strategies.
|
Secret Thoughts and Hidden Feelings: A Study of Mark's Use of Attributed Motives in Light of Thucydides and Plutarch
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Steven Marquardt, Emory University
The attribution of motives in the Gospel of Mark is an aspect of this work that has not received the attention it deserves. The evangelist frequently makes readers privy to the thoughts and feelings of characters, and it stands to reason that consideration of this technique can provide us with insights into Mark's profile as an author and historian. Many commentaries display some awareness of this phenomenon, but they make little effort to relate these attributions to the evangelist's strategy or to consider the implications that the use of this device has for the determination of genre. Studies that consider the narrative and rhetorical features of Mark's Gospel tend to be more attentive in this area, yet they also fail to meaningfully consider Markan attributions in light of ancient historiography. In an attempt to fill this lacuna, this paper conducts an examination of attributions in the Second Gospel in light of the Greek historians. Two authors from distinct subgenres are examined-Thucydides for historia; Plutarch for bios-and attention is given to how they attribute motives to Pericles as a test case. The paper then turns to the Gospel of Mark and considers how the evangelist's practice compares with these historians. Finally, the paper evaluates the implications that this comparison has for the genre of Mark. Mark's use of attributed motives reveals indebtedness to Greek historiography writ large, yet his attributions are sufficiently distinct from historia and bios to require a distinct subgenre classification. Something beyond the influence of Greek historiography is necessary to explain the manner in which the evangelist attributed motives, and this "something" is the impulse of early Christian preaching and theology. On the evidence of attributed motives alone, it is doubtful that the Gospel of Mark can neatly fit into the categories of "history" or "biography."
|
Traces of Scribal Memory in New Testament Manuscripts? The Case of Corrections by the First Hand in P46, P66 and P75
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Priscille Marschall, Université de Lausanne
The aim of this paper is to look for traces of scribal memory in P46, P66 and P75, some of the earliest New Testament manuscripts that have been handed down to us. To address this issue, I will focus on the phenomenon of corrections by the first hand as an ideal starting point for reconstructing the scribe’s relation with his Vorlage, as well as the potential influence of other versions which were present in his memory. Specifically, I will consider the possibility that some of the original readings emerged not because of misreading during the act of copying – and here I depart from the traditional explanations of text critics – but rather under the influence of scribal memory. According to this scenario, the scribe first wrote down the formulations of another version he was familiar with – for example, one which he had previously heard – and then, either in scribendo or during proofreading, corrected it according to the version found in the Vorlage. Building on this idea, I will also discuss the appropriateness of considering these manuscripts the result of a “scribal performance,” as well as the potential implications for textual criticism.
|
Ruth & Naomi: Marks of Trauma and Resilience
Program Unit: Biblical Literature and the Hermeneutics of Trauma
Anna E. Marsh, Jewish Theological Seminary of America
The pastoral setting and bucolic tone of the Book of Ruth make it seem like an unconventional biblical text to read through the lens of trauma. However, the characters face adversity that threatens to shatter them. It may not be the rejection of Jeremiah or the catastrophe of Psalm 137, but the kind of domestic, personal loss which is powerful in spite of its mundanity. Looking for marks of traumatization in the book, Ruth appears obsessed with moving forward in ways that are profoundly unhealthy, and Naomi is perpetrator as well as victim. However, traumatization is often overdiagnosed in biblical studies, as it is in clinical psychology. Resilience presents an alternative, both in the social sciences and in biblical studies. This paper takes a literary approach to the figures of Ruth and Naomi, reading through the dual lenses of trauma and resilience. While not downplaying the presence of disruptive events, the paper argues that when Ruth and Naomi are read as resilient individuals within a resilient community, they are damaged but not beyond repair, and they bear the marks of resilience, recovery and survival. Holding the two readings in tension acknowledges the reality of trauma, the possibility of surviving it, and enhances the human dimension of the narrative. This approach offers insight into the composition and transmission of the book as well as for interpretive communities today.
|
Jacob of Edessa’s Witness to the Book of Daniel in Greek: A Survey
Program Unit: International Syriac Language Project
Bradley J. Marsh, Jr., University of Oxford
In the year 705 CE, the Syrian Orthodox scholar Jacob of Edessa completed his own personal revision of the Book of Daniel-Bel-Dagon-Susanna in Syriac. He constructed this singular version by mixing both Syriac and Greek biblical traditions. With respect to the former, it is clear that he used the Peshitta, the standard Bible of the Syriac church. However, the precise nature of the latter is a much more complex issue. This paper seeks to address the question of Jacob’s Greek sources by providing a survey outlining the diverse Greek traditions to which his recension attests. Based on research presently being carried out in preparation for a critical edition of Jacob’s revision, it has been determined that he used approximately four different textual traditions of Daniel in Greek: These include (1) a manuscript of the standard “Theodotion” version, (2) an additional witness which clearly exhibited distinctive Lucianic features, (3) a lost Old Greek witness which transmitted a chronological presentation of the Daniel cycle different from that in papyrus 967, and (4) a more standard OG witness which accords better with the text transmitted in manuscript 88 and the Syrohexapla. (There is also evidence that Jacob used the Syrohexapla itself, though he appears to have done this very infrequently.) In addition to outlining examples of readings belonging to these categories, the paper will also deal with some of Jacob’s unique readings. Given that the Peshitta text of Daniel-Bel-Dragon was very stable, most of Jacob’s unique readings are more reasonably understood as reflecting those from Greek witnesses, suggesting that Jacob’s Greek sources contained readings which have not survived. Many of these can indeed be accounted for by reconstructing the text critical circumstances which led to their eventual loss in the ms tradition (e.g., graphic confusion, haplographies of various kinds, etc.). Others, however, require more complex and historically nuanced explanations. In sum, the paper will argue that the witness of this unique Syriac recension can provide Septuagint scholars with a wider view of the history of the Greek text of Daniel as it existed in the first millennium CE.
|
Vaginal Vocabulary in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Erica Lee Martin, Seattle University School of Theology and Ministry
Understanding the vaginal vocabulary of the Hebrew Bible is essential to understanding the text. Vaginal euphemisms are used intentionally by biblical writers and would have been clear to the earliest audiences. An examination of the vaginal connotations of these words calls for a reevaluation of the meaning of several key biblical texts on the basis of the euphemisms. It is understood that biblical texts often speak euphemistically about bodily parts and functions, veiling these aspects of human existence. Identifying and decoding euphemisms for the vagina in biblical texts is necessary to reexamine female anatomy, female experience, and use of vaginal euphemisms in the biblical text and the history of its interpretation. This presentation catalogues five main categories of biblical euphemisms for the vagina (euphemisms based on the substitution of alternative or more generalized body parts; euphemisms for the vagina based on items that resemble the vagina; euphemisms for the vagina based on the association of vagina with arable land; euphemisms for the vagina based on the association of vagina with water source; and euphemisms for the vagina based on the association of vagina with things that are owned) with the goal of helping to illuminate biblical texts employing physicalized and sexualized rhetoric for female bodies in new ways.
|
Translating λόγος in First Peter 1:22-25 for the New International Greek Testament Commentary Series
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Troy W. Martin, Saint Xavier University
I am in the process of writing a commentary on First Peter for Eerdman’s New International Greek Testament Commentary Series. After briefly describing the goals and objectives of this series, this paper will illustrate some significant emphases of my commentary. These emphases include a focus on Greek word formation and relevant ancient contexts for translating important terms in the text of First Peter. This paper will illustrate these two emphases by explaining the word formation of the Greek term λόγος and by exploring the biological and physiological context in which this term is used in 1 Pet 1:22-25.
|
Sociological Impact of a Constant Cyclical Fluctuation of Occupation and Dispersion among Competing Ethnic Groups in the Longue Durée
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
William Luther Martin, Jr., Independent scholar
Scholars have evaluated the story of Joseph (Gen. 37-50) for its conflicting assimilation and separation themes. However, as exemplified in the Hebrew Bible, the long term sociological impact of the broad scope of a constant cyclical fluctuation of occupation and dispersion among competing ethnic groups in the longue durée is a subject that has not been exhausted. The goal is to better understand how ethnic identity is formed and how ethnic identity interferes with assimilation and drives separation. Exile, displacement, and migration are frequently (if not always) the result either of resistance to imperial power or of settler colonialism. The Hebrew Bible provides many examples of both causes. First, the Hebrew Bible describes the displacement of aboriginal populations by a process of an Israelite/Egyptian hybrid settler colonialism attributed to the legendary Joshua and justified as the will of God as interpreted by Moses. Then, the Hebrew Scriptures recount the invasion of Israelite and Judean lands by Edomites and others as a result of the imperial conquest. Later, the Bible recapitulates a rebounding process of displacement as a Judean/Babylonian hybridized culture carries out a settler colonial process attributed to Nehemiah and Cyrus which had the immediate effect of pushing out the descendants of lower class Judeans whose ancestors were among the "bad figs" which had not been exiled to Babylon. (Jer 24:1-2) Interleaved with these epic examples of Hebraic settler colonialism are descriptions of exile resulting from misguided rebellions against Assyria, Babylon, and Rome and dispersion of Israelite and Judean peoples into a diaspora. It is perhaps impossible to find in connection with any single ethnic group a more comprehensive record of successive oscillations of displacement, migration, and exile. My paper seeks to examine this constant ebb and flow according to the methodological perspective of historiography, sociology, and anthropology in line with the works of William H. Sewell, Jr. (2005) in view of the relevant Judean experience explored by Oded Lipschits (2005).
|
The Masoretic Notes: An Aid for the Interpretation of the Biblical Text
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Elvira Martín-Contreras, ILC-CSIC
The accents and notes of the Masora Parva and Masora Magna present in the medieval Hebrew Bible codices are essential for the interpretation of the biblical text. The results and benefits of incorporating Masoretic notes in this interpretation have been already identified and exemplified, but their possibilities have yet to be explored. To name but a few, the Masora can serve the following purposes: determining word roots; distinguishing between homophonic forms; differentiating meanings; shedding light on problems of translation and interpretation; etc.
The Masoretic notes are characterized by being formulated in a short, concise way, and on many occasions, an elliptical form. This way of being expressed makes it impossible, in most cases, to appreciate the content of the note and its possible relevance to interpretation on a first reading.
The purpose of my presentation is to show in a practical way (through selected examples) how to work Masoretic notes, in order to apply them subsequently to the interpretation of the biblical text.
|
The Emergence and the Resistance of Tyranny and the Politics of Fear in Exodus 1–2
Program Unit: Minoritized Criticism and Biblical Interpretation
Safwat Marzouk, Anabaptist Mennonite Biblical Seminary
The Emergence and the Resistance of Tyranny and the Politics of Fear in Exodus 1–2
|
Navigating the Collusions and Contradictions of African Orality and the Digital Age in Understandings of the Bible
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Madipoane Masenya (Ngwan'a Mphahlele), University of South Africa
One of the popular cultural texts in sub-Saharan Africa, that is the Christian Bible, originated as an oral text. Although it was received as a written canon (within oral communities), it continues to be communicated with ease (especially from vernacular translations) in an oral form in many, an African context. What is unsettling though, is the haunting legacy of the colonial languages which continue to take the upper hand in the processes of the translation/teaching/preaching of biblical texts among African recipients. In contexts where there appears to be competing agendas between the notion of the African renaissance and the highly technological contexts/scenarios in which the written word is communicated technologically and in colonial languages, which role may African biblical scholarship play to make the Bible (in its written form) easily accessible in African-conscious oral settings?
|
Two Massacres on a Sabbath in Josephus’s War (2.450–57): Cases of ‘Religious' Violence?
Program Unit: Josephus
Steve Mason, Rijksuniversiteit Groningen
In the second volume of his Judaean War (2.450–57), Josephus describes two massacres that, he claims, occurred simultaneously: of the auxiliary garrison in Jerusalem and the Judaean minority in coastal Caesarea. Setting both incidents in their literary and historical contexts, and with due attention to the divergences in Josephus’ later Antiquities, this paper uses this remarkable narrative confluence to explore two methodological points: (a) the implications of fine-grained interpretation for large-canvas claims about a Judaean revolt against imperial Rome and (b) the problem of isolating ‘religious’ from other motives in ancient societies.
|
“It Is Your Custom to Do Good to All the Brethren and to Send Contributions to Many Churches”: Ideology and Practice of Gift Exchange between Christian Groups in the First Three Centuries
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Georges Massinelli, University of Notre Dame
Exchange of financial support between geographically remote groups was a distinctive feature of early Christian economic life. Recently, Paul’s collection for the poor in Jerusalem has received considerable scholarly attention, but there are other instances of this kind of financial support for sister churches in distress in early Christianity. The most ancient attestation, roughly at the same time of Paul’s collection and occasionally identified with it, is Antioch’s relief fund for the believers in Judea (Acts 11:27–30). Other incidents were interspersed throughout the first three centuries CE and usually aimed to alleviate poverty in a sister community or to provide for believers condemned to the mines or otherwise imprisoned or captive. These “collections” are described in the correspondence of Cyprian of Carthage and in the writings of Basil of Caesarea and Eusebius of Caesarea. Financial help for Christians of geographically distant areas was so widespread that it is even attested in the non-Christian author Lucian’s satirical short story De morte Peregrini.
A survey of these instances of intergroup support in the first three centuries of Christianity shows that Paul’s collection was not an isolated phenomenon but rather the first example of an original giving practice intimately connected with early Christian identity and the nature, structure, and interrelationships of early Christian groups. Support is provided not only because it is morally good to help others in adversity but also because it constitutes a distinctive feature of who the Christian is and how the Church is shaped. On the other hand, differences and similarities between these exchanges of financial help provide insights into the varieties of Christian self-understanding, views of generosity, and relationships between communities.
Given the sporadic and unsystematic character of the information available from the first centuries and the local nature of Christian experience in that period, there can and should be no attempt to identify a single, continuous line of evolution for early Christian giving. However, the evidence corroborates some conclusions: support between early Christian groups was a widespread phenomenon; it was therefore part of a common ethos; there was occasional interference from benefaction ideology (a possible sign of increased presence of the elite and their culture in early Christian groups).
|
Media Transformation as Interpretation in Prophetic Literature
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Nathan Mastnjak, Indiana University (Bloomington)
In biblical studies, analyses of literary influence, echo, and allusion continue to produce convincing results, but these are well-known and well-worn paths. Part of the task of rethinking interpretation will be to locate other—potentially overlooked—avenues where the concept of interpretation can provide fresh access to ancient literary cultures. I propose a turn to the materiality of texts and their transformations as a locus of interpretation. N. Katherine Hayles has suggested translation as a conceptual model for understanding transformations of texts across media. Just as translating a text or utterance from one language to another is an inherently interpretive act, so also the translation of a text from one medium to another is an activity punctuated by a series of interpretive choices and involve both loss and gain. Hayles applied this model to transformations of print media to digital platforms, but it can be just as fruitfully applied to media transformations in the ancient world. One such transformation is the shift from a preference for short scrolls in the earlier biblical periods to a preference for long single-book scrolls such as those known from the Dead Sea. This paper will explore this idea with respect to the books of Jeremiah and Isaiah, both of which most likely started their lives as collections of short scrolls that were subsequently—perhaps centuries later—rendered as single scrolls. Considering these works in light of their material histories makes it possible to construe their book-forms as contingent interpretive acts. The book of Isaiah and the two books of Jeremiah (MT and LXX) each represent interpretations of a collection. Using the concept of media transformation as translation, this paper will read the shift to the book-scroll as a critical moment in the life of these compositions and will show how this consideration of the materiality of the text gives new insight on old critical conundrums.
|
And I Saw Googleville Descend from Heaven: Reading Revelation 21 in Silicon Valley
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Roberto Mata, Santa Clara University
This project interrogates the rhetorical construction of the New Jerusalem in Revelation 21 and does so from the perspective of gentrified Latino/a communities in Silicon Valley. In view of the
impending arrival of Google’s headquarters to the city and its utopian promise of jobs and housing for thousands of people, Latino organizations, among others, are concerned that the descend of
“Googleville,” as some have wittingly dubbed the project, will only exacerbate the housing crisis and increase the number of displaced and homeless populations. Juxtaposing the utopian visions of Googleville and the New Jerusalem, I map here what Musa E. Dube refers to as an imperializing contradiction that, as I will argue, is embedded within both utopian visions. On the one hand, both cities promise wealth, health, and security to a select few, but on the other both displace, exclude, and oppress a segment of the population deemed unfit to live within them. By placing the earthly Googleville and heavenly New Jerusalem side by side, a sharp divide between the “haves” and
“have nots” becomes visible. This dynamic is reflected not only in the violent representations of the Other, but also in the policing of boundaries that accompanies these apocalyptic utopias.
|
“Those Who Call Themselves Jews”: Negotiating Ethnicity in the Messages to the Seven Assemblies
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
Roberto Mata, Santa Clara University
This paper explores the polemics over Jewish identity in Revelation 2:9 and 3:9 as a negotiation of Jewish ethnicity under imperial duress. Traditionally, scholars have read John’s invective against “Those who claim to be Jews, but are not,” as representative of tensions between a Jewish- Christian apostle/prophet and (1) Jews from the local Synagogues in Smyrna; (2) Godfearers who are unable to keep up with Jewish halachic practice; and (3) Neo-Pauline Christians. While these views are still in wide circulation in academic spaces and churches today, they rest on rather unstable discourses that include the so-called “Parting of the Ways” between Judaism and Christianity and might even reinforce the portrait of the “adversus Judaeus.” Conversely, I will read Revelation as a Jewish text and in the context of the Roman imperial situation of the inscribed cities (e.g. Smyrna, Philadelphia, Thyatira, Pergamon, Sardis, Ephesus, and Laodicea). Using Frantz Fanon’s analysis of colonial situations of domination and Denise Buell’s notion of ethnic reasoning, I suggest that the polemic over Jewish identity may not only be read as an intra-Jewish polemic, but as negotiation of Jewish ethnicity between two colonized Jewish groups from the diaspora in Asia Minor, and one that was triggered by the colonial situation under Rome. In view of contemporary efforts at interreligious dialogue between Jews and Christians and in the spirit of the encyclical Nostra Aetate, this paper not only disables the portrait of the anti-Christian Jew and its enabling discourses, but also contributes towards a more constructive paradigm in Revelation studies.
|
An Embryonic Exodus: Stories of Becoming in J. Mallozi's and P. Mullie's Dark Matter: Rebirth
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Jennifer M. Matheny, University of Kent at Canterbury
Joseph Mallozi's and Paul Mullie's 2012 Graphic novel, Dark Matter: Rebirth, details the futuristic journey of 6 individuals who wake up from stasis in space without their memories. They band together in the darkness of thought and place, to begin to form new identities in community. Over time, they slowly come into contact with their old selves. Issues of identity, alterity and memory drive through this story, similar to the Exodus narrative in the Hebrew Bible. Though Mallozi and Mullie may not have intended to connect this story with the Exodus narrative, the themes of identity, alterity, forgiveness and memory are common tensions with both stories of communities in seasons of becoming during threshold crossings. The plight of its six main characters in this popular piece of speculative fiction reflect the key motif of tearing down old worlds in light of new ones, a strong theological-political theme woven through the Exodus story.
This paper will demonstrate how the group of six struggle to define their own identity through their embryonic exodus story. It is through dialogue with the other, be it through person or text, where one is in the process of authoring and being authored in the process of becoming. Similar to the people of Israel, they are on the trajectory of a new horizon. Thinking with some helpful insights from Mikhail Bakhtin's literary theory dialogism (embryonic imagery, becoming, answerability) and Paul Ricoeur's "difficult forgiveness" (forgiveness, memory, metaphor, narrative) , this paper will provide a brief comparative analysis of Dark Matter: Rebirth and the Exodus story through the Exodus motif and Barbara Green's "foreign woman pattern"-which I will extend to person and android- revealing the dialogic authoring of a collective identity. This discovery of the six space marauders contributes to a new way of relating within their political landscape. Similar to Ricoeur's description of imagination as a dimension of language, my hope in bridging an ancient world with a future world will create "some new vistas" in order to "let new worlds build our self-understanding."
|
Ruth as a Voice of Canonical Answerability to Judges 19-21
Program Unit: Megilloth
Jennifer M. Matheny, University of Kent at Canterbury
The texts of Judges 19-21 and Ruth have been noted by scholars to be "connected" and in "dialogue" with one another. Is there a way to facilitate this canonical dialogue? The "scandalous," abrupt, and violent ending to the book of Judges has been noted to leave the reader in a place of despair. Conversely, the book of Ruth has been noted to bring the reader "welcome relief." This reprieve may not abode for long when one engages with some of the darker contours of Ruth. The book of Ruth offers a more complex portrayal within the canon in light of the violent, theologico-political crisis at the close of Judges. In order to stimulate this potential canonical dialogue, this paper will utilize Mikhail Bakhtin's dialogism to facilitate such a reading.
In this paper, I will demonstrate that the book of Ruth and Judges 19-21 represent the dialogic and polyphonic nature of canon. To further develop this idea, Ruth will specifically be viewed through the lens of canonical answerability. This paper will argue that Ruth functions as a potential משל , an elastic genre , a category intrinsic to the Hebrew Bible. Intertextual examples will be highlighted to demonstrate the intentional dialogic connections between Judges 19-21 and Ruth. Specifically, this study will draw on two intertextual idioms: דבר על-לב(Judges 19:3; Ruth 2:13); נשא אשה (Judges 21:23; Ruth 1:4); the terms הלך and שוב; shifts in identity between Moab and Israel, and the genealogical epilogue of answerability. This study will reveal that the book of Ruth is a dialogic voice of canonical answerability to the violent משל of Judges 19-21.
|
John/Luke Dialogue, and the Western Noninterpolations
Program Unit: Gospel of Luke
Mark Matson, Milligan College
A substantial amount of ink has been poured out on the special cluster of textual variants in the gospel of Luke given the clumsy name “Western Non-Interpolations.” This cluster of variants finds the Western witnesses surprisingly with the shorter reading, while Westcott and Hort’s so-called “neutral text” contains the longer reading. Based on their heavy reliance on shorter readings, W-H excluded these readings from their critical text with double brackets despite the presence in their highly preferred manuscript Codex Vaticanus. Presumably these longer readings were the result of harmonization, and the most likely source was from the Gospel of John, with which they share many striking similarities.
Often overlooked in discussions of these textual variants, however, is the larger pattern of inter-relationships between Luke and John (a relationship I have called a dialogue). What contribution might a greater consideration of this pattern of similarities between Luke and John offer to the text-critical examination of these variants? I propose that the Johannine style of the longer readings connects with other John-sounding elements in Luke, and militates against harmonization as a likely cause. As a result, the internal argument based on style can also embrace likelihood of the longer John-sounding variants. And indeed the early opposition to John within segments of the 2nd century church might well explain the removal of some of the language that sounds most like John.
|
Spatial and Sensory Aspects of Battle in Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Texts
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Victor H. Matthews, Missouri State University
Battlefields are replete with sensory impressions and sensations. For those participating in the battle their ears are assailed with the stench of blood and the bodies of the dead (Isa 34:3; Joel 2:20), the battle cries and screams of the combatants (1 Sam 17:52), and the sounds of weaponry in conflict. Whenever possible, their leaders would have visually surveyed the potential battle ground and its spatial factors in preparation for the coming fight. Its location, if on open ground, is often based on proximity between territorial entities, its strategic value in terms of the ease of movement of troops or commercial activities, and the likely willingness to engage with the enemy in that space. Among the texts that illustrate both consideration of the location, suitability of the ground for the type of operation envisioned, and the social factors such as the confidence of leaders and troops in achieving victory in that place are the Elah Valley in 1 Sam 17:1-3. The Ugaritic epic of Baal and Anat and the Assyrian Annals also contain lurid descriptions of martial activities that contribute to the literature of warfare. This paper will draw on modern spatiality theory and studies related to the smells of battle to illustrate how the two disciplines can contribute to an exegetical study of ancient Near Eastern literature.
|
Commenting on Greek Deuteronomy 25: Some Reflections on the Challenges of Investigating the Production of the Greek Text
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Jean Maurais, McGill University
This paper presents a commentary on a portion of Greek Deuteronomy chapter 25 prepared using the methodology developed in the context of the SBL Commentary on the Septuagint project. It will outline some of the challenges specific to this approach, which deals with the Greek text primarily from the perspective of its production. For example, this unit presents textual issues both in the Greek and Hebrew manuscript traditions. Some of these differences greatly complicate the task of retracing the translator’s steps. Other issues pertaining to the evaluation of the translator’s work with respect to this legal material, such as the qualitative evaluation of his renderings and the adequacy of the translation will also be briefly discussed. The paper will conclude with some personal reflections on the aims such a commentary and its place alongside other types of commentaries on the Greek Bible.
|
The Borders of Wakanda: Black Panther as Cinematic Parable
Program Unit: Society for the Arts in Religious and Theological Studies (SARTS)
Joel Mayward, University of St. Andrews
Black Panther raises important theological and ethical questions not only of race, but also borders and alterity. Black Panther could be considered a type of cinematic black liberation theology in the vein of J. Kameron Carter, speaking new filmic grammar for engendering richer conversations about belonging without borders, both Wakandan and American.
|
Ugaritic Ditanu and Greek Titans: An Appraisal of Etymological and Thematic Connections
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
Matthew McAffee, Welch College
In recent years several scholars have attempted to establish a connection between the Greek Titans and the Ugaritic Ditanu. Amar Annus in his article, “Are There Greek Raphaim? On the Etymology of Greek Meropes and Titanes,”, argues for an etymological connection between Greek titanes and Ugaritic ditanu, portrayed in Ugaritic sources as the eponymous ancestors of the royal dynasty (UF 31 [1999]: 13-30). Annus’s treatment of the Ugaritic evidence is somewhat lacking, however, in that he makes a number of unsubstantiated claims regarding the Ugaritic materials. Scott Noegel argues for a similar Greek-Northwest Semitic mythological connection, this time between biblical King Og and Greek Ogygos (ZAW 110 [1998]: 411-26). On the basis of this parallel, Noegel interprets biblical King Og as a divine figure, but his argument is problematic. Much of it depends on the spurious reading h‘g (i.e., DN ‘the Og,’ which is grammatically problematic) in the Phoenician inscription Byblos 13, a reading which F. M. Cross convincingly dismissed in his study (IEJ 29 [1979]: 40-44). If Cross’s reading is correct, no deity by the name Og is attested in the ancient literature, making the Og-Ogygos connection less likely.
The Titan-Ditanu connection, however, is a more plausible proposal in light of the sound correspondence between the Greek and Ugaritic iterations of this name. Furthermore, and perhaps more importantly, there are a number of thematic parallels between the Greek and ancient Near Eastern traditions regarding the nature of the Titans and Ditanu. Therefore, in this study I intend to explore the viability of relating these two ancient proper names to one another by offering a fresh appraisal of the pertinent textual materials. The intended purpose of this investigation is thus two-fold: (1) to assess the etymological merits of titanes from ditanu, and (2) to investigate broader structural or thematic connections in support of this etymology.
|
From Kings to Monsters: The Jewish Response to Political Enemies in the Sibylline Tradition.
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Susannah McBay, University of Chester
Both the third and fifth books of the Sibylline Oracles engage with the threat and challenges of the political powers of their day, the Hellenistic and Roman respectively (Sib. Or. 3:657-714; 5:28-34, 155-161, 342-359, 414-433). Both books also construe these powers as part of the reason for the arrival of God as Divine Warrior to execute judgement. This paper will explore the use of the Divine Warrior tradition in these texts and how the sibylline tradition developed, particularly with Book 5’s use of the motifs found in 3:657-714. It will argue that Sib. Or. 5, especially vv.342-359, gives a more central role to the political enemy, depicting the Roman empire and emperor within the cosmic drama, as a force of chaos and agent of evil. The paper will conclude by drawing out the implications for how this shift reflects a change in how political powers were understood, with the dehumanising shift from the enemy as ‘king’ to ‘mythological monster.’
|
Trauma, Insecurity, and the Practice of Killing
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
Megan McBride, U.S. Naval War College
At present, the discourse on religious violence, trauma, and insecurity overwhelmingly frames the experiences of trauma and insecurity as the causes or effects of religiously motivated violence: for perpetrators, trauma and insecurity motivate religious violence; and for victims, religious violence causes trauma and insecurity. In other words, the dominant line positions trauma and insecurity as passively experienced. Missing from the discourse is work exploring the possibility that trauma and insecurity might be actively constructed. This paper takes up this challenge via the analysis of a construct under-theorized within the discourse on religion and violence: the practice of killing. It explores killing with a particular emphasis on the ways in which the lived and embodied practice of killing – particularly in the context of religiously motivated violence – might simultaneously respond to trauma and insecurity (e.g., via an act of retributive justice) and reproduce trauma and insecurity (e.g., by causing moral injury).
|
The Late Roman/Byzantine Synagogue at Horvat Kur
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Byron R McCane, Wilkes Honors College at Florida Atlantic University
Eight (8) seasons of excavation at Horvat Kur in the Lower Galilee have exposed the remains of a basilical synagogue from the Late Roman and Early Byzantine periods, along with adjacent houses. In its first phase (Late Roman), the building was a rectangular structure, oriented toward Jerusalem, with a mosaic floor with an Aramaic dedicatory inscription and a depiction of a menorah. A low bench ran along the interior walls. In its second phase (Early Byzantine), the synagogue was expanded into a broad-house basilical layout, with a bemah at the center of the southern wall, an adjacent room on the north side (likely a beth ha-Midrash), and a gallery above the eastern aisle, accessed by means of an exterior stairway. In the the third phase (Late Byzantine), the adjacent room was closed off and the spaces between the interior columns were filled in with an array of low stones, apparently for additional seating. Two (2) stones were exceptional: one was an ornamented limestone doorpost laid on one of its long sides, and the other a neatly worked basalt stone table, with feet under each corner, geometric designs on three (3) sides, and depictions of vessels for liquids carved into the fourth (4th) side. The original use of this “Horvat Kur stone” remains elusive. The Horvat Kur synagogue thus provides an illustrative example of synagogue construction, decoration, and use within the social, economic, and religious setting of a lower Galilean village of relatively modest circumstances.
|
Early Christian Encounters with Policing: The Soldier as Police Officer in the Early Roman Empire and Its Implications for Readings of Rom 13:4 and Luke 3:14
Program Unit: Social History of Formative Christianity and Judaism
Esau McCaulley, Northeastern Seminary
Historically readings of Rom 13:1–7 focused on Paul’s beliefs about the obligations that Christians have to the state. Other scholars highlighted the implications of Paul’s statement about the state “bearing the sword” for a Christian theology of government. Lost in much of this discussion is the lived experience of early followers of Jesus. However, I will show that recent scholarship on early imperial Rome has shown that the Roman soldier stationed in cities and villages functioned as the closest equivalent to a police officer. Therefore, Paul’s words about “bearing the sword” and wider New Testament portrayals of interactions with solders have the potential to shed light on early Christian understandings of policing. They also contain the possibility of providing something approaching early Christian theologies of policing. To this end, this paper will begin by examining scholarly developments regarding the policing activities of Roman soldiers. This will help us understand where Roman Christians could expect to encounter the policing power of the state. Next, we will explore how those insights inform Paul’s reflections on policing at the level of the state in Rom 13:4. Following an examination of Paul’s words on the sword and the state, we will explore Luke 3:14. Luke 3:14 is important because it recounts the instructions of John the Baptist to soldiers. These instructions, in contrast to Paul, focus in on the interactions of individual soldiers with individual Israelites. These instructions, then, form the basis for an ethical code of conducting for those charged with policing in his day. Together Rom 13:4 and Luke 3:14, although written in widely different contexts, contain import insights on Jewish and Christian reflections on policing in the 1st century.
|
Gal 4:3–7: The Covenant Curses and the Elements of the Earth
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Esau McCaulley, Northeastern Seminary
In Gal 4:3 Paul claims that a collective includes himself was enslaved to the "stoichea tou kosmou." The group that Paul has in mind, the meaning of "stoichea tou kosmou," and the reason that they were enslaved are matters of scholarly debate. I will argue that Paul has in mind the Jewish slavery to foreign gods predicted in Deut 4:26-28 and Deut 27-32, which was undone by the redemptive death of the Messiah Jesus.
A key element of my argument will be fresh insight into Wis. 13:1-10, a Second Temple text often marshalled in support of reading "stoichea tou kosmou" as the elements of the earth that were worship by Gentiles. I will show that the author of Wis. 13:1-10 does refer to the elements as the "stoichea tou kosmou," but that he also uses the language of Deut 4:26-28 to describe these gods. Deuteronomy 4:26-28 is important because in that text God warns the Israelites that they would be enslaved to foreign deities if they failed to keep the covenant. This shows that Second Temple authors could equate the elements of the cosmos to the "non-gods" who would enslave Israel as predicted in Deut 4:26-28 and Deut 27-32. Paul argument, then, in Gal 4:3-7 is much the same as the argument that he makes in Gal 3:10-14. Israel was under the covenant curses before redemptive death of the Messiah with the major difference being that in Gal 4:3 Paul emphasizes a particular element of the covenant curses, namely slavery to foreign deities.
Therefore, those who claim that Paul focuses on all of humanity and not the
Jewish situation under the Law in Gal 4:3 miss the polemical edge of his argument. It
was Israel's covenant disobedience that caused it to be enslaved to the foreign gods,
and in that sense, they ended up in the same situation as the Gentiles. The difference
was that for the Jews, life under the Law ended in slavery to the stoichea, while the
Gentiles had always been in slavery. Paul's point then is that the Gentiles are not
escaping the elements by coming under the Law. They would be returning to slavery
to the deities that once held sway over their lives (Gal 4:8-11).
|
Towards a New Testament Theology of Policing: Rom 13:4, Luke 3:14, and the Hopes of Black Christians
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Esau McCaulley, Northeastern Seminary
Towards a New Testament Theology of Policing: Rom 13:4, Luke 3:14, and the Hopes of Black Christians
|
Orphic "Bookishness" and Material Religion in Classical Greece
Program Unit: Society for Ancient Mediterranean Religions
Mark McClay, University of California, Berkeley
This paper addresses the theme of Orphic "bookishness" in classical Greek mystery cults. Since the 19th c., "Orphism" has been understood by many scholars as a marginal religious tendency of the 5th/4th c. BCE whose adherents sought release from postmortem sufferings by initiation into Dionysiac mysteries and extreme forms of ritual purity. The mythical Thracian singer Orpheus was credited as the proto-founder of these mysteries, and written poems attributed to his authorship played a prominent role in the ritual activities of these cults. Because Greek religion did not ordinarily employ sacred texts, the use of books in Orphic-Bacchic cults has been taken as a marker of difference from the religious mainstream. On this view, "Orphism" was built around quasi-scriptural texts and a body of myths and doctrines contained in them.
I suggest that this idea of Orphic "bookishness" has over-privileged the informative function of ritual texts while obscuring their materiality and their embeddedness in performance contexts. The "Proto-Protestant" constructions of ancient and world religions have come under intense critique from historians and anthropologists (e.g. J.Z. Smith 1990, Asad 1993, Nongbri 2013, Barton & Boyarin 2016), and some classical scholars have seen "Orphism" as a product of the same theoretical biases (Edmonds 2008, 2013). Following in this line of critique, I draw on the analytical tools of "Material Religion" (Morgan 2010, Houtman & Meyer 2012, Moser & Knust 2017) as well as recent work on the interactions of writing and orality in Greek religion to challenge the trope of Orphic "bookishness" and instead focus on the use of such books as physical objects. As I argue, ancient evidence (including the 4th-c. Derveni Papyrus) actually points toward a complex medial role for Orphic books in the interactive dynamics of marginal cults: books served both as a tangible credential for itinerant ritual experts and as props in a performance genre that combined text, orality, and gesture into a "synaesthetic" mode of religious experience. This focus on the material and performative serves as a corrective to propositional models of sacred textuality that have often been influential in the study of non-Western religions.
Word Count: 348
|
Khirbet Qana (Cana of Galilee) and Village and Town Networks and Trading Patterns in Lower Galilee: Discerning the Impact of the First Revolt in Transforming Local Economies
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Tom McCollough, Centre College
The evidence so far gleaned from the archaeological excavations at Khirbet Qana (Cana of Galilee) reveal a complex and intriguing pattern of trade. The material culture that can be securely dated to the early decades of the first century CE suggest that as the village transitioned from subsistence agriculture to surplus and trade, it confined its trading relations to local villages. In the latter decades of the century, there is a significant shift to an integration with regional and even Empire-wide trading routes and increasing monetarization with the implications this has for role of a political economy. This paper presents the evidence of such a shift and offers an interpretation that points to the transformation of the landscape brought by the First Revolt as a key variable. The paper will also argue for the value of narrative driven economic decision-making (based on the work of Akerlof and Schiller) for framing the economics dynamics of Lower Galilee in the Early Roman period.
|
Jubilees in Syriac: The Evidence of the Dictionary of Bar Bahlul
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Gavin McDowell, Université Laval
One outstanding problem in the textual history of the Book of Jubilees, a work preserved principally in Ethiopic, is whether it was ever translated into Syriac and, if so, whether it was translated from Greek (like the Ethiopic version) or from Hebrew. The primary witness to the Syriac text of Jubilees is embedded in the Chronicle of 1234, an unusual work known from a single (now lost) manuscript. The evidence of the chronicle is inconclusive. One cannot say whether the Syriac is translated from Greek or Hebrew or even if it represents a pre-existing, independent translation. Earlier citations of Jubilees in Syriac are even more puzzling, as they rarely correspond to what is found in the extant Ethiopic text.
Between the early “apocryphal” citations of Jubilees and the long passages in the Chronicle of 1234, which correspond closely with the Ethiopic, one finds twenty or so citations of a “Book of Jubilees” in the Arabic-Syriac dictionary of Hassan Bar Bahlul (10th c.). These citations, which have never been studied or translated, represent a unique window into the status of Jubilees in Syriac. For example, many of the glossed words are evidently of Greek origin. In this paper, I will propose a preliminary translation of these citations and attempt to correlate them with the Ethiopic text of Jubilees in order to evaluate what they can—or cannot—tell us about the text of Jubilees in Late Antiquity.
|
Enoch in Persian Garb: Sefer ha-Yashar and the Shahnameh
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Gavin McDowell, Université Laval
Knowledge of ancient Enochic traditions has never truly been lost; it has only been in occultation. When such knowledge reemerges, it is often transfigured. Despite sporadic rabbinic hostility to the figure of Enoch, two works indebted to ancient Enochic traditions circulated in medieval Judaism, the Midrash of Shemhazai and Azael, a “rabbinized” account of the Second Temple Watcher myth, and Sefer Hekhalot (3 Enoch), which mentions Enoch’s assumption and transformation into the angel Metatron. A third account of Enoch appears in the late medieval Sefer ha-Yashar, which claims to be the lost book mentioned in the Hebrew Bible (Josh 10:13; 2 Sam 1:18). The work is actually a compilation of medieval aggadah and might be expected to draw on a pre-existing Enochic tradition. Sefer ha-Yashar, however, tells a different tale. In this work, Enoch is a righteous king who secludes himself from public life until an angel invites him to ascend to heaven. He withdraws to a mountain and disappears. When his friends attempt to look for him, they are buried alive in a snowstorm. Neither the Watchers nor Metatron make an appearance.
This story, which has no parallels in earlier Christian, Muslim, and Jewish writings about Enoch, is nevertheless ancient: It is nearly identical to the occultation of the mythological Persian king (and eschatological figure) Kay Khosrow, especially the rendition of this story in the Shahnameh, the national epic of Iran (11th c.). The story of the occultation has roots in the Avesta, and it also passed through Manichaean tradition before appearing in Muslim writings, the Shahnameh, and, finally, Sefer ha-Yashar. Iranian Jews certainly knew the Shahnameh, which became the model of their own poetic compositions. In this paper, I wish to address the greater meaning of the “conversion” of an Iranian king into a Jewish figure and the corresponding rejection of established Enoch traditions. The presentation will be illustrated by Persian miniatures of Kay Khosrow and Idris, the Muslim equivalent of Enoch.
|
Who's Who Inside and Outside the Text: Ethnic Identification in Ancient Israel
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
Mark McEntire, Belmont University
The Hebrew Bible shows an early interest in identifying persons by patrilineal descent in genealogies. It is possible to follow the story on a surface level and maintain some sense of this genealogical basis of identity, but there are plenty of places in the text that betray a more complex picture. What might sound like strict biology quickly becomes fluid and ideological. For example, Genesis 10 uses a mixture of factors – genealogical descent, territory, and language – and assigns the Canaanites a Hamitic origin, placing them at greatest distance from those in the intended audience of the book, Israelites. The book of Ezra uses no less than seven different terms, some with overlapping components, to label the group that is the collective protagonist of its story. Some of these terms are genealogical, some territorial, and some even seem to involve what modern readers would understand as religious affiliation. These categories point toward a concept of ethnicity, but important questions have been raised about the imposition of a modern term and all of its assumptions onto ancient cultures and the texts they produced. While Tobit and Judith both use genealogy to help identify their namesake characters, Esther and Daniel seem to abandon genealogy altogether. Our aim in this paper is to analyze biblical examples that show multiple categories ancients used to describe themselves and others amid changing social and political factors such as military incursion and urbanization that produced disruption, resulting in human displacement. Examination of texts in which characters identify themselves or are identified will reveal a complex intersectional approach to ethnic identification and negotiation in the world of biblical antiquity.
|
Traditions of Paul the Seer: Oral Patterning in the Vision of Acts 18
Program Unit: Transmission of Traditions in the Second Temple Period
Zane B. McGee, Emory University
It is often argued that at least two sources underlie the depiction of Paul's travels in Acts-an earlier written record and traditional material. Both sources, however, prove illusive to the modern researcher. This study explores the latter in relation to a specific episode in Paul's stay in Corinth, his night-time vision in Acts 18:9-11. Building off of research into the transmission of folklore and legend, this study proposes seven criteria for identifying written material that has been influenced by earlier oral transmission and then applies these criteria to this episode. Through this exercise it is revealed that not only this vision but also three other similar visions in Acts all share these same characteristics-most striking in that all relate directly, and only, to Paul. From this evidence, I propose that Acts reflects an early tradition that depicted Paul as a vision-seeing leader whose ministry was guided by divine directives delivered through supernatural messengers. Further corroboration of such a view of Paul is gained through a brief examination of the apostle's own letters, where he depicts himself as one who has received revelations and visions that feature significantly in his ministry and authority.
|
"Having Their Fill of the Loaves": Early Christian Meals and Ancient Bread Distribution
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
Andrew McGowan, Yale Divinity School
The earliest Christian communities were characterized by meal practices that seem always to have focussed on bread, and sometimes on wine, occasionally on other foods. The significance of bread itself has not been very deeply explored, partly because of assumptions about the actions of Jesus as founder, and the association of the Last Supper narratives with the seder of Passover. The recent shift to understanding eucharistic meals as versions of the Greco-Roman symposium implies that the significance of bread might better be understood relative to wider patterns of diet, rather than as a religious peculiarity. Bread and related products were staples for the Mediterranean world, but their production, distribution and exchange were complex. This paper considers eucharistic meals of the first two centuries or so (mostly via texts, including the Gospels, Didache, Justin Martyr), particularly in the context of grain doles and related practices, which fed urban populations unable to grow food, but which also substantiated power structures including those of Imperial Rome, and of local elites for whom food distributions could be a form of euergetism. The Christian meal may in some early instances have functioned as version of or alternative to these, with the distribution of bread having a significance for the recipients, not least poorer city dwellers, that will have gone beyond its religious meanings narrowly understood.
|
The Mandaean Book of John Critical Edition and Translation as Digital Humanities Project
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
James McGrath, Butler University
The forthcoming two-volume edition of the Mandaean Book of John was facilitated by specific technological advances that have occurred since the last time the work was translated into a European language more than a century ago. This project was able to work with a broader textual base than previous translation attempts, precisely because it is now unnecessary to arrange for a library or individual to purchase or transcribe those manuscripts owned by Mandaean priestly families in order to study them. Current technology also facilitated the consultation of a wider array of sources – including living individuals with expertise in topics such as methods of fishing historically used in Iraq – which provided crucial clues that aided with the solving of linguistic puzzles that impacted past translation efforts.
|
Rebekah Deceives Isaac's Senses
Program Unit: Senses, Cultures, and Biblical Worlds
Heather A. McKay, Edge Hill University
For this paper we need consider only four of the standard five senses and the connection of sensory input to the brain's, or rather, the mind's understanding of the world around us, namely the link between Perception and Apperception. Perception is the input from the sense organs, while apperception is the attachment of meaning to the input based on our past experiences and constructs. As a result, what we understand or believe might be a misreading of what our senses tell us. A blurred movement caught by the corner of our eye might be thought to be a spider if one dreaded such an intruder while in fact it was a stray feather from a cushion. This paper will explore how Rebekah deceived Isaac's recognition of his two sons by subtle play with his sense of smell and touch while he responded to an insistent desire to taste savoury food. I will be using all the stated and inferred facts in the text that point to Rebekah creating a false scenario that will be misperceived by Isaac to be the scenario he will be expecting and that will lead him to accept Jacob as Esau, even after a misstep in the deception when Jacob's voice is not convincingly like Esau's and her deception falters for a moment. Ignoring the sense of sight, in which Isaac is handicapped, she uses cooking smells, the touch and smell of Esau's clothes and skin, and the taste of the stew she makes. The misperception happens in Isaac's mind; the carefully constructed deceptive sensory data are like enough what he expects to be associated with Esau fulfilling his wishes and catching, then preparing game for a meal. The deception succeeds because Isaac's mind--the combination of his previous experiences and his understanding of what they meant--'recognises' the sensory signals as what he is expecting, rather than what they actually are.
|
The Psychological Value of Children in the Bible
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Heather A. McKay, Edge Hill University
Studies have shown that children signify, or provide evidence of, several things to their parents: indicate that the parent has reached adult status, give social identity, represent an expansion of the self into a larger entity where having children is the 'natural' thing to do, provide primary group ties, stimulation, fun, and a feeling of creativity. Children may also provide a feeling of power and a means of social comparison or competition or they may undermine parental power by showing rebellion. Biblical texts referring to children (usually meaning sons) will be analysed to discover whether there is evidence that similar psychological factors held force in the ancient mind, albeit couched in the language of inheritance and continuance of owning land, following parental beliefs and commitments, bringing honour, inheriting also disfavour/punishment, showing rebelliousness, being born to fulfil a particular role, and so on. Mostly children fulfil fairly unspecified roles in the Bible except for certain children, portrayed as being born to fulfil a special role. These children are described in clear detail, and given roles and stories of their own: Samson, Samuel, David (2 versions), John the Baptist and Jesus.
|
History as Harlotry: Expansion in Ezekiel 16
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
Tracy J. McKenzie, Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary
The methodology utilized in this analysis takes as its point of departure the work of Walther Zimmerli on the book of Ezekiel and his notion of Fortschreibung. (Zimmerli 1969, 106-7*) Since his commentary on Ezekiel, Zimmerli's observation of this phenomenon has taken on a life of its own as expressed in innerbiblische Schriftauslegung, inneribiblical allusion, and inner-biblical exegesis. Prior to Zimmerli (Hölscher, 1924, et al.), scholarship had already discerned supplementations within Ezekiel 16; the chapter contained two so-called appendices. More precisely, however, Ezekiel 16 contains various Fortschreibungen within its composite unity. How can the methodology of Fortschreibung and its application to Ezekiel 16 illuminate gaps in knowledge pertaining to theological developments, exegetical practices, textual production, attitudes toward authoritative texts or institutions, and political, religious, and cultural circumstances? Each Fortschreibung can manifest distinct characteristics that yield information related to such questions.
Based upon research carried out for a monograph on the growth of Ezekiel 16, this paper analyzes the characteristics of each expansion in the chapter. These include: (1) The latest expansion in the chapter, Ezek 16:59-63, (2) A chapter-like expansion in Ezek 16:2(hoda')-3a(we'amarta), 20-23, 36b, 43-58, (3) A harlot redaction in Ezek 16:14-19, 16:25b-30a, 33, 35-36aβ, (4) The basic metaphor in Ezek 16:1, 2(ben'-adam), 3aα(koh…lirusalaim)-6, 9-13, 24-25a, 37, 39, 42, and (5) The actualization of the metaphor in Ezek 16:24-25a. First, the paper examines each expansion by considering its relationship to other texts or literature in the book of Ezekiel/Hebrew Bible; this examination demonstrates a relative dating. A second step divulges the techniques used in textual production. Third, the paper considers exegetical practices that emerge in the range of expansionary activities and what these practices reveal about attitudes towards authoritative texts. Fourth, the paper gives attention to theological motivations and historical information such as absolute dating and possible socio-cultural settings. A demonstration of expansionary activity in Ezek 16:43 and 58 reveals problematic translational practices of verbal constructions (e.g. NASB, HOF, et al.) due to presumptions regarding authorial unity. Additionally, due to the historical continuum along which the chapter developed, the analysis provides scholarship with specific instances of textual practices and attitudes by which to adjudicate literary activity in other biblical literature. Finally, the results of the analysis identify more acutely exilic/post-exilic experiences and articulations of shame (e.g. from inappropriate cultic practice to harlotry), political and multinational hopes of restoration (e.g. from an appeasement of Yahweh's wrath to restoration of Jerusalem, Samaria, and Sodom), and evolving theological expectations of "restoration" that help scholarship better understand biblical texts and the situations in which they developed.
|
The Dream for a "Field for the Twenty-First Century" Endures: A Description and Defense of the New Critical Edition of Job 22–42
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
John D. Meade, Phoenix Seminary
Publishing “a Field for the Twenty-First Century” remains the aim of the Hexapla Project, and after many years of waiting, the release of its first edition, A Critical Edition of the Hexaplaric Fragments of Job 22–42, is planned for winter of 2018. In light of this development, I want to (1) review the aims of the Hexapla Project, (2) describe the format of the new edition vis-à-vis prior editions, and (3) reply to some recent criticism of the project with specific examples from the new edition of Job 22–42. The new edition surpasses the previous editions of Frederick Field and Joseph Ziegler both in terms of evidence and method, and this advance will be demonstrated with examples from Job 22–42. Finally, Olivier Munnich has offered some recent criticisms of the Hexapla Project, which I will address in the final part of the presentation.
|
Making of Lists: Canon Lists and Their Significance
Program Unit: Development of Early Christian Theology
John D. Meade, Phoenix Seminary
This paper is co-authored by Edmon L. Gallagher.
|
Election, Eschatology, and the Kingdom of God: A Theological Conversation with the Book of Daniel
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Tim Meadowcroft, Laidlaw College, Auckland
This paper is an exploration of the theological question of the intermingling of history and the eschaton, informed by a reading of the book of Daniel. I examine the various ways in which this intermingling occurs in the work of some recent theologians – Pannenberg, Brunner, Schillebeeckx, McClendon, Gorman and Sweeney among several others. Each of them is striving to articulate the anticipation and realization of the one in the other: the advent of the eschaton into history, and the foreshadowing of the eschaton in that same history. For several of those theologians, history has to do with a particular conceptualization of election, and this too is explored. Along the way, I observe the treatment of Daniel by theologians with respect to these themes. I propose that the space within which history and eschaton play together is that of the Kingdom of God (or, in Danielic terms, the rule of the saints of the Most High), however that may be understood, and that this is realized, for the reader of the Christian Scriptures, in the person of Jesus Christ. From there I turn back to the book of Daniel. Previously I have argued that both the court tales and the apocalyptic material in Daniel are examples of wisdom and that their interpretation may be informed by the theological theme of participation – in the case of Daniel, the participation of the saints of the Most High in the rule of God. In this paper, I argue further that the theme of wise participation as portrayed in the book of Daniel informs a broader theological appreciation of the significance of an anticipated end in the historical experience of the people of God. The result is both a critique of systematic theological expressions of this theme and a contribution to them. An often unstated assumption of the theological interpretation of Scripture is that theology is in the service of interpretation. Methodologically, this paper is also an experiment in the reverse process: the possibility that interpretation may be offered in the service of theology.
|
Providing a Disorienting Dilemma: Possibilities for Genesis 34 in Church Comprehensive Sexuality Education with Youth
Program Unit: LGBTI/Queer Hermeneutics
J.D. R. Mechelke, Author
In the midst of the #MeToo movement, the requirement of the gospel (and therefore, of the church) to dismantle institutions of patriarchy and cis/heteronormativity has revealed the essential need for comprehensive sexuality education in the ecclesiastical context. Comprehensive sexuality education, especially wielded against rape culture and purity culture, can be seen as a form of resistance against those oppressors who necessitate the cry “me too.” While the biblical text gives nearly no narratives where rape or purity cultures are not present, Genesis 34 and the rape of Dinah can provide a disorienting dilemma that leaves youth in church sexuality education longing for tools and narratives that spur sexuality dignity for themselves and for their neighbors. Utilizing Genesis 34, four areas will be analyzed and synthesized to provide such a proposal: 1) critical pedagogy, 2) comprehensive sexuality education, 3) the connections between purity culture, rape culture, and violence against women and queer folk, and 4) the requirement of the gospel to dismantle institutions that uphold such cultures.
|
The Position of the Direct Object in Qumran Hebrew Verbal Sentence
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Richard W. Medina, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
In Qumran Hebrew, the normal position of the direct object in verbal sentences containing an adverbial modifier is after the verb. One also finds object-initial or object-final sentences. Although stylistic and functional discourse factors (such as constituent length, emphasis, focusing, and topicalizing) may account for some of the variations, they fail to explain satisfactorily all cases, because other factors also seem to affect the order of the object in the sentence, such as the syntactic relationship between the object and the adverbial. Working within the frameworks of traditional grammar and comparative-historical grammar, I propose that the position of the object in verbal sentences is principally determined by morpho-syntactic factors: the form of the object (noun, suffixed noun, noun phrase, or construct phrase), the type of adverbial, and the type of verbal form used in the clause. My analysis is based on a corpus that includes the War Scroll (1QM), the Community Rule (1QS), the Damascus Document (CD I–VIII, XIX–XX), and other related scrolls. Within this corpus, my investigation focuses on independent, dependent, and volitive sentences with finite verb forms, nominal direct objects, and adverbials. Lastly, the sequence of the object in Qumran verbal sentences will be compared with that in a selected corpus of Biblical Hebrew in order to determine to what extent the Hebrew of the scrolls can be described in terms of continuity and innovation. No previous research has investigated this issue in the light of the proposed linguistic factors.
|
Intersections: Reading Caste, Gender, and Sexual Tyranny in the Jephthah Narrative
Program Unit: Minoritized Criticism and Biblical Interpretation
Monica Melanchthon, University of Divinity
Intersections: Reading Caste, Gender, and Sexual Tyranny in the Jephthah Narrative
|
Constructions of Identity: The Iconography of the So-Called Aramaean Stelae from Egypt Reconsidered
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Melanie Wasmuth, University of Helsinki
First millennium BCE Egypt features a variety of monuments displaying cultural affiliations to more than one cultural tradition. Of special interest in this respect are the funerary stelae made of stone, which are to be considered as primary media of individual representation. Designed for eternity and specifically for eternal participation in ritual care, Egyptian funerary stelae have to mirror the deceased’s perception of him- or herself and to induce the visitor to physical or at least mentally conducted offerings. The Egypto-Persian stela of Djedherbes, which has been found in Saqqara in the 1990s, has been closely examined regarding its inscriptions and iconographic display, and also the Egypto-Carian stelae have elicited substantial discussion. However, a detailed study of the imagery of the Egypto-Aramaean stelae is still missing. Based on a study of the iconographical repertoire of the Egypto-Aramaic funerary stelae from Egypt, the question will be addressed, how the cross-cultural aspects of identity were construed and to which extent the traditional Egyptian function of funerary display has to be assumed for these monuments of self presentation.
|
Psalm 91:6: Demon-Possessed Poetry
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Crystal L. Melara, Talbot School of Theology (Biola University)
This paper is part of a larger project which analyzes the congruency of LXX demonology with the HB. This particular section examines Psalm 91:6 where the term “demon” appears in the Greek Old Testament. There has been a movement of scholars seeking to demythologize1 Biblical texts. This has lead to a debate on whether demons have a place in the Hebrew Bible. The truth is that the term “demon” comes to us through the Greek language. It has a long and complex history, and its etymology is still in question. It is not in the Hebrew Bible. In fact, there is no equivalent expression in any of the Semitic languages nor can its equal be found in the wider range of Afro-Asiatic languages. On the other hand, the LXX translators use the term on eight different accounts to translate five different Hebrew terms. Although the LXX translators hardly used the term “demon,” it is of importance to note that they did use it. Using what we know about textual variants, the biblical context, and intertextual evidence, we will discern, the best we can, the intent of Psalm 91 and whether or not it meant to infer a demonological interpretation. Findings suggest a lack of poetic imagination on the part of modern scholars and conclusions draw congruency between the Hebrew Bible and the Greek Old Testament.
|
Resistance in the Way of the Cross: A Study of the Resistant Nature of Matthew 10:38
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Matthew Mellott, Lutheran School of Theology at Chicago
In Matt 10:38, the author of the Gospel of Matthew offers resistance to Roman imperial hegemony and domination through the call to take one’s cross. He accomplishes this by inverting the symbol of the cross. It was a symbol of pain, terror, shame, and the people’s powerlessness as compared to the claimed ultimate power and sovereignty of the emperor and Rome. Instead, Matthew uses Jesus’ statement in the context of the Mission Discourse to resist such claims. He inverts the symbol, turning it into a symbol of faithfulness, righteousness, autonomy, and honor, while realigning the cosmology behind the symbol, placing the God of Israel in ultimate control instead of the emperor and Rome.
|
"But Now Mine Eye Seeth Thee" (Job 42:5): Conceptualizing Divine Presence and Absence in Job
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Brittany N. Melton, Palm Beach Atlantic University
Arguably the theophanic close of the book of Job attests to a text decisively displaying divine presence. However, this is complicated by the perception of God by Job and the friends throughout the book. There exists a tension between divine presence and absence. What is significant about the Joban text is its oscillation between perceiving divine oppressive presence and implying an experience of divine absence, in that Job addresses God at the same time that he questions God’s whereabouts in the midst of his extreme suffering. While the book of Job offers a more nuanced and complex, even seemingly contradictory, conceptualization of divine presence and absence, this accords with Melton's previous work on conceptualizing divine presence and absence in the Hebrew Bible. In her recent book, Where is God in the Megilloth? A Dialogue on the Ambiguity of Divine Presence and Absence, she establishes the false polarity between these constructed categories when they are applied to the God of the Hebrew Bible. Applying this lens to the Joban text further illumines the complexity and depth, even unfinalizability (Hyun), of Job's understanding of God in contrast to the more restricted conceptualizations of his friends.
The tapestry of viewpoints woven together in the dialogue between Job and the friends provides excellent raw material for exploring the multifaceted conceptualization of divine presence and absence, as it explores various reactions to the perceived presence and absence of God. Notable among the friends' speeches is Eliphaz's vision of God (4:15–16). Moreover, Job himself assumes several different vantage points on the matter when he discusses his relationship with God. For example, Job expresses that God is too close for comfort (3:23), and yet complains that God cannot be found (23:3). Due to the wealth of salient texts in Job for informing a conceptualization of divine presence and absence, we will focus on the first speech cycle (chapters 3—14), which includes an abundance of Job's expressions of God's oppressive presence, Job's statement that he cannot perceive God's presence (9:11), Job's question to God—"Why do you hide your face?"—(13:24), and a concentration of bodily language referring to God's presence voiced by Job in 13:16–22. By examining these texts, which touch on various aspects of presence and absence, we will provide a rich introduction to this theme in the book of Job.
|
The Colonies Strike Back: How Latin-American Liberation Theologies Saved Christianity in Post-dictatorial Spain
Program Unit: Minoritized Criticism and Biblical Interpretation
Luis Menéndez-Antuña, California Lutheran University
The Colonies Strike Back: How Latin-American Liberation Theologies Saved Christianity in Post-dictatorial Spain
|
Becoming the Child: The Spirituality of Children in Early-Christian Asceticism
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Jarred Mercer, University of Oxford
The study of children in Late Antiquity is a growing field. Studies typically focus on socio-cultural conditions surrounding children (e.g. Bakke [2005]; Horn and Martens [2009]; Horn and Phenix [2009], et. al.). This work is crucial, but research directly focussed on the spirituality of children is a major lacuna. This is a stimulating field of study in contemporary psychology, philosophy, theology, and religious studies (e.g. Basset (ed.), Une spiritualité d'enfant [2009]), but no major effort has been made to examine the spirituality of children in Late Antiquity.
As part of a larger project investigating this issue in Paganism, Judaism, and early Christianity, this paper will examine the relationship of children and early-Christian asceticism, continuing the work of Vuolanto, Horn, and others, on children and asceticism and focussing this research in a new direction.
There is a continual thread in early Christianity which views the child as having a natural connection with God that adults have lost and must seek to regain. While there are various perspectives on children in the ancient and late-ancient world (in stoicism, children are less than fully human (Diogenes Laertius VII.85-88; Seneca, Epist. 124.8), and even for early Christians, childhood can have negative connotations, see 1 Cor 3.1-2), this romanticized vision of the child is a sustained position. Early Christian ascetics learn from this perspective, both through the efforts of some to "become like the little children" through the rigor of ascesis, and through actual children entering the monastic life.
Early Christians relied heavily upon Jesus' words in Matthew 18.3 as a model for Christian life: Being Christian is about becoming like a little child. Predominantly, the metaphor of childhood is interpreted morally. The child’s lack of concern for status, wealth, and, perhaps most often, sexual lust (e.g. Tert. De monogamia 8) is an exemplum of Christian virtue. However, the image of the child can move beyond an example of virtuous living. For Hilary of Poitiers, this return to childhood involves a speciem humilitatis dominicae, and this speciem is a return to the very nature of childhood (In Matthaeum 18.1: reuersos in naturam puerorum).
This paper explores how this perspective shapes, and is shaped by, monastic communities and ascetical practices. Children were seen as possessing by nature the qualities sought by ascetics, but also as needing instruction in the ways of asceticism. Early Christians cannot ignore the exalted status given to children by Jesus, but the ideal Christian in time becomes not the little child, but the adult who, through years of ascesis, attained a certain "childlikeness." The monastic and ascetical life yields something like a spirituality of children sans enfants.
However, the romanticized ideal of the "child" remains, whether of an actual child or the perfected adult life. This paper will explore the significance this romanticized vision had in shaping the spiritual practices of early Christian communities, and the role actual children did or did not play in that formation, through examining the relationship between children and Christian ascesis.
|
The Atonement in Colossians 1:11b-14: A Literary and Linguistic Approach
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Reed Metcalf, Fuller Theological Seminary (Pasadena)
This paper is a fresh study of atonement language in a single pericope of the Letter to the Colossians. Long-held assumptions regarding theology, semantics, and trajectories of Christian thought often force texts into preconceived atonement schema, whether it be of the substitutionary/satisfaction atonement variety, the Christus Victor family, or some form of moral influence atonement.
This paper takes this dilemma seriously, setting a promising trajectory for a fuller treatment of Colossians’ atonement language in other projects but focusing on Colossians 1:11b-14, the launching pad for the famous Christ Hymn of Colossians. My thesis is that a close examination of the atonement language in Colossians 1:11b-14 will yield a perspective that stresses the continuity of God’s action, roots the atonement in Israel’s exodus narratives, and innovatively uses the key concept of “redemption.” The linguistics method of a monosemic bias will be one of the primary tools in this study; monosemy, as opposed to polysemy, is recent to biblical studies, but it suggests that individual lexemes are always semantically underdetermined until utilized in a text. This tool will help us avoid the temptation to import centuries-worth of tradition onto a key term in this passage: ἀπολύτρωσις, often translated as “redemption.” Instead, a monsemic bias forces us to use the semantic clues in the passage itself—appositional constructions, intertextual references, and the surrounding metaphors—to fill out what the author means by ἀπολύτρωσις. Another tool, the aforementioned detection of intertextuality, will root the understanding of this passage’s atonement language firmly in the exodus traditions of the Jewish scriptures. The author utilizes multiple images that recall Jewish texts—redemption, rescue from slavery, shares of inheritance, beloved sonship—to frame God’s work through Jesus as the definitive second and greater exodus foretold by the Israelite prophets.
With these tools at hand, the atonement language of Col 1:11b-14 shows itself to not fit neatly in the major families of atonement theology, and points of contention with traditional atonement models are mentioned throughout the study. Instead, God is the only actor in the atonement language of this passage, qualifying, rescuing, and transferring believers; metaphors of transfer (often raw material for atonement theology) are rooted in the exodus narratives; and the word ἀπολύτρωσις (“redemption”) connotes a rescue from slavery and an absolution of guilt that the author locates in Christ. While not a complete model of the atonement by any standard, the findings of this study are at least a step toward constructing the unique vision of Christ’s atoning work that the author of this letter presents to the fledgling church at Colossae, enriching our understanding of the early churches’ proclamation and construal of the death of Jesus.
|
Competition as a Motivating Force behind Female Benefactions in Roman Hispania
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Rachel Meyers, Iowa State University
Competition was an essential component of Roman society, driving the political sphere at its core. The practice of ‘euergetism,’ or benefaction, was also deeply ingrained in the socio-political ideology of the Roman Empire. Certain manifestations of civic munificence – such as venues for entertainment, cash, banquets, and civic buildings – might have been highly appreciated by members of the town, but they might have also incited competition among the wealthy to finance increasingly costly donations. The statues set up to commemorate donors and their gifts might have been endowed with the agency to drive others to engage in civic munificence with the hope of being recognized publicly for their contributions. In fact, there are indications in the ancient texts that some families even brought themselves to financial ruin through such rivalry. Most scholarship on the phenomenon of benefaction concerns men, but more recently scholars have scrutinized the archaeological evidence for the involvement of women in such public practices as civic munificence. This paper broadens the existing scholarship on female benefactors by focusing on their activities and impact in the Roman provinces of the Iberian peninsula. Utilizing a corpus of more than 400 inscriptions as well as architectural and sculptural remains, this paper tracks the geographic spread of female-sponsored benefactions in the Spanish provinces in the first and second centuries with the aim of identifying whether a sense of competition motivated female donors. Though women could not engage in politics in the western Roman provinces, could they still be motivated by competition in one of the few areas of public activity open to them? Were certain types of benefactions more highly regarded, and, thus, likely to ignite a competitive spirit? What reasons did women have for engaging in these practices? Through a close analysis of the evidence, this paper aims to contribute to the discussion of women’s roles in the economy in the Roman Empire.
|
The Dynamics of Responsible Biblical Interpretation: Toward a Creational Pneumatic Hermeneutic
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
J. Richard Middleton, Northeastern Seminary at Roberts Wesleyan College
The Dynamics of Responsible Biblical Interpretation: Toward a Creational Pneumatic Hermeneutic
|
What Christians Can Learn from Jewish Interpretation of the Aqedah: Reading Genesis 22 with Moses and the Rabbis
Program Unit: Jewish Interpretation of the Bible
J. Richard Middleton, Northeastern Seminary at Roberts Wesleyan College
Abraham’s near silent acquiescence to God’s request to sacrifice Isaac is troubling for many contemporary readers of the Aqedah. One of the earliest major objections came from Immanuel Kant, who adamantly claimed that God could never have required Abraham to kill his son, since this contravenes universal moral law. Many recent interpreters—from both Jewish and Christian traditions—have intensified Kant’s criticism, objecting in various ways to God’s requiring the sacrifice and to Abraham’s attempt to go through with it.
Prior to Kant, however, it was typical for writers in both Jewish and Christian traditions to exalt Abraham as the model of how one ought to respond to God in situations of unbearable and inexplicable suffering, since this seemed to be what the text was teaching. Yet there has been a difference between Jewish and Christian responses to the Aqedah. The standard Christian interpretation up to the nineteenth century (when Søren Kierkegaard praised Abraham as a “knight of faith”) has been that Abraham’s unquestioning obedience to God’s will is exemplary.
Although ancient and medieval Jewish interpreters typically exalted Abraham and did not question God’s right to test Abraham (R. Joseph ibn Caspi is possible exception), many sought to mitigate the terror of the text in various ways, particularly by midrashic readings, many of which appealed to the opening phrase, “after these words/things,” with speculation about the particular events or words that required this episode. While a surface reading of Jewish midrash on the Aqedah may seem to justify God or exalt Abraham, such readings nevertheless leave behind traces of the sages’ evident discomfort with the Aqedah.
This discomfort may be traced back to the prophetic stance of Moses, who refused to accept God’s decision to destroy Israel after the golden calf, but through intercession persuaded God to relent of the evil he had planned (Exodus 32). Abraham himself is called a prophet (Genesis 20) in light his intercession on behalf of Sodom (Genesis 18).
Beyond the biblical prophetic tradition and the sages of post-biblical Jewish tradition, Job (the biblical sage of putatively gentile heritage) stands out as supremely relevant to the Aqedah, not only because the book of Job evidences multiple intertextual connections with the Abraham story (Klitsner), but because Job demonstrates a profoundly Jewish sensibility in his direct protest to God about his suffering.
Yet in Genesis 22 Abraham is strangely silent when the life of his own son is at stake. Terence Fretheim thus suggests: “The narrator may intend that the reader, having learned from Abraham in chapter 18 how to question God, is the one who is to ask questions here.” Could it be that the Jewish interpretive tradition is trying to remedy Abraham’s silence?
Drawing on the model of prophetic intercession exemplified by Moses and Abraham in Genesis 18, as well as the bold protests of Job, this paper explores the history of post-biblical Jewish interpretation of the Aqedah in order to discern how a Christian reader might legitimately question Abraham’s silent acquiescence in Genesis 22.
|
Is Samuel among the Prophets? Samuel as “Legendary Intercessor” in Michael Widmer’s Standing in the Breach (Eisenbrauns, 2015)
Program Unit: Book of Samuel: Narrative, Theology, and Interpretation
J. Richard Middleton, Northeastern Seminary at Roberts Wesleyan College
Michael Widmer’s Standing in the Breach: An Old Testament Theology and Spirituality of Intercessory Prayer (Siphrut 13; Eisenbrauns, 2015) is an engaging and substantial study of the prophetic tradition of intercession in the Old Testament. Based on Widmer’s PhD thesis with Walter Moberly, which addressed Moses’s bold confrontation with YHWH in Exodus 32–34, where he gets God to relent of destroying Israel after the golden calf, Standing in the Breach expands that study beyond Moses (“Israel’s Archetypal Intercessor”) to include case studies of Abraham, Samuel, David (2 Samuel 24), Solomon (1 Kings 8), the suffering servant, Jeremiah, Joel, and Amos.
Although Widmer’s exploration of the theme of intercession in the Old Testament is extremely insightful, his chapter on Samuel (“Israel’s Second Legendary Intercessor”) suffers from a lack of textual attentiveness. Widmer too easily reads Samuel in terms of the typical pattern of prophetic intercession that he construes from the broader tradition, without noticing how Samuel deviates from that tradition. Although Widmer admits that “it is striking that, in contrast to Moses, none of Samuel’s actual prayers are recorded in the canon” (Standing in the Breach, 174), this does not prevent him from mining 1 Samuel 7, 12, and 15 for putative insights into intercessory prayer.
Given that Widmer’s approach to Samuel is typical of many other interpreters, who are perhaps unduly influenced by YHWH’s words in Jer 15:1 (“even if Moses and Samuel stood before me”), it is perhaps inappropriate to single out Widmer for criticism (especially because Standing in the Breach is a profound book). Yet, precisely because of my respect for Widmer, I will interact with his portrayal of Samuel in 1 Samuel 7, 12, and 15, noting the evident deviations of Samuel from the Mosaic paradigm. These deviations might lead one to question whether Samuel is, indeed, among the prophets. Or, at least, whether Samuel might be a deficient prophet.
|
Apostates, Martyrs, and Super-Martyrs: Christian Identities in the Martyrs of Lyons
Program Unit: Construction of Christian Identities
Paul Middleton, University of Chester
Many scholars have noted the various ways in which martyrdom texts create Christian Christian identity. In dramatic narratives of the arena, identity is formed in the battle between the martyr and the persecutor, or in cosmic terms, the Christian and Satan. However, while such narratives naturally sharply divide Christian from non-Christian, internal Christian dynamics are often of more concern in these texts. Invective is often aimed more at wayward Christians than persecutors (who, after all, perform a vital function in a martyrology), and distinctions are made even between Christians who remain faithful, according to, for example, age, class, and gender, and experience. Focussing particularly on the Martyrs of Lyons, in which there are a variety of different 'types' of martyr, this paper will argue that behind the apparently simple dichotomy of ‘martyr’ and ‘apostate’ lie a greater range of Christian identity-making.
|
Blessed Are Those Who Persecute for Righteousness’ Sake: Ambrose of Milan and Christian "Holy War" against the Jews
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Paul Middleton, University of Chester
From Marcion onwards, many Christians have claimed there is marked difference in the level of violence in the New Testament from the Hebrew Bible. While Israel engaged in Holy warfare to claim, maintain, and regain the Promised Land, Christians were committed to an eschatological rather than temporal kingdom. To enter, Christians thought the truest expression of discipleship was following Jesus’ model of non-violent suffering and martyrdom. However, violence is not absent from the New Testament and other early Christian texts. Christians even began to interpret martyrs as Holy Warriors or spiritual agents of divine judgement. While such expressions of vengeance might be dismissed as ‘fantasy violence’, by the fourth century, Christians were routinely committing acts of violence against Jewish communities. In this paper, I will examine the confrontation between Ambrose and the emperor Theodosius, who had demanded Christians make reparations for burning the synagogue in Callinicum in 388. I will argue that in Ambrose’s response, the tributaries of martyrdom, divine judgement, and Holy War, that had sustained Christian non-violence for so long, merged in the fourth century to legitimate and sanctify violence—a Christian ‘Holy War’—against Jews.
|
"Amurrite-Age" Arts and Letters: Rhetoric in the Mari Missives
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Adam E. Miglio, Wheaton College (Illinois)
“The Birth of Rhetoric,” William W. Hallo suggested, took place in ancient Mesopotamia. He argued that “…linguistic ability was at the heart of the scribal curriculum of Hammurapi’s Babylonia, as much as it was to be the essence of the Roman rhetorician’s facilitas.” Studies of rhetoric in Mesopotamian cuneiform sources have ranged widely– from Sumerian literary texts, to Akkadian royal inscriptions, to peripheral Akkado-Canaanite letters. Moreover, investigation into Mesopotamia rhetoric have addressed issues such as texts’ functions, stylistics, as well as audiences and arguments. This paper, which is part of a larger study on the rhetorical strategies in the Mari letters, considers the thoughtful artifice and creative attempts at persuasion found in these sources. The paper takes its cue from Jack Sasson’s observation nearly 20 years ago that many Mari missives “contain dozens of long lines and, in rhetoric, [that] can match the best of biblical prose, full of vivid phrasing, lively pacing, and a terrific sense of structure,” and it considers the rhetorical strategies found in some of these elaborately developed communiques.
|
Erotical Ascent in Eriugena's Periphyseon
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Adrian Mihai, University of Cambridge
Based on an insight of Maximus the Confessor, found in his Ambigua ad Iohannem X (1113b11-14), according to which God and the human are paradigms of each other, and as God is humanised through his love for humanity, so is the human deified through love for the divine, Eriugena, in his Periphyseon (written around 864-866), establishes a daring Metaphysics of Eros - since ἔρος, which he translates into Latin by amor (Periphyseon I 519d5), is more divine than ἀγάπη. Love is the vinculum that holds together all things that exist, and draws all things back to God through the cycle of nature.
|
Flipping the Script: The Rhetoric of Inversion in Philippians and Political Oratory
Program Unit: Speech and Talk in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Timothy Milinovich, Dominican University
For Session #3, with Paul and Politics.
Although scholars continue to take Paul’s negative assessment of rhetorical strategy at face-value, this paper will look at how Paul uses the common tactic of rhetorical reversal, or inversion, that was found in Greek and Roman political speeches. In many of these cases, such as with Pericles or Caius Marius, the speaker is in a defensive situation after a third party has challenged his authority or qualifications to lead his intended audience. The speaker must then take the presumed denigration (whether real or imagined) and invert the qualities, thus making himself the more qualified to lead, and disqualifying the political opposition by their own criteria. We then evaluate Paul’s use of such tactics in Philippians when, going beyond synkrisis, he proposes that the community rejoice in the face of suffering; humble themselves like God’s Son in order to achieve his resurrection; and accept Paul--an imprisoned and suffering servant of a universal gospel--rather than the opponents who boast in physical prowess and ritual. In so doing, Paul is able to invert the present narrative to his own advantage and to the opponents’ disadvantage. This is part of a larger book project, _Paul’s Campaign Rhetoric_, co-authored by TJ Rogers, and under contract with Fortress Academic for release in 2020.
|
Network Mapping and Biblical Allusions: A Proposal for Navigating Early Christian Exegesis
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
Alexander B. Miller, Fordham University
The twentieth century has witnessed several important shifts in scholarly attention to early Christian scriptural commentaries. Early dismissals of commentaries as repetitive, unoriginal, and fancifully arbitrary gave way to more appreciative studies of allegorical and anagogical readings of Scripture. However, even the division between an Alexandrian allegorical school and an Antiochene anagogical school that once dominated the field failed to stand the test of time, especially with regard to exegetes of the late fourth and early fifth centuries.
In this paper, I will propose a new approach to the study of early Christian exegesis using digital network mapping tools. Rather than attempt to hypothesize exegetical principals that govern the allusions made by commentators, I will offer a method of describing those allusions for more fruitful research into the history of Christian thought. Using Genesis 1:26-27 in Greek commentaries as an example, I will demonstrate that studies of early theological anthropology limited to these verses yield misleading conclusions, in part due to the assumption that early and modern readers share prooftexts on a given topic. In contrast, mapping biblical allusions as networks offers a data-first approach to describe characteristic patterns of allusions and to compare various Christian authors without a priori conclusions about the theological interaction of schools/factions. With regard Genesis 1:26-27, I will show that direct quotations are more often related to christology or trinitarian theology, while theological anthropology is only addressed when a broader network of allusions is invoked.
|
"Not with Gold, Pearls, or Expensive Clothes": Wealthy Women, Speech and Citizenship in 1 Timothy and the Democratic Polis
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
Anna C. Miller, Xavier University
The author of 1 Timothy shows particular concern regarding both women and wealth. These two concerns appear to be intertwined in passages like 1 Tim 2:9-15 and 1 Tim 5:3-16, leading Elsa Tamez to conclude that this author seeks to block the leadership of wealthy women within this early Christian community. 1 Timothy’s seeming concern about wealthy women in these passages—and more specifically about these women’s speech—coincides with growing visibility of wealthy women in civic offices within Asia Minor during the late Hellenistic period and early Empire. Scholars have minimized the importance of these public, civic roles for women with claims of gender differentiation in the execution of civic offices, and with the argument that the erosion of civic democracy in the imperial period made such positions increasingly ornamental. By contrast, this paper will argue that growing evidence for democratic practice and discourse in Greek cities of the Eastern Empire requires that such a portrait of women’s exercise of civic offices be reevaluated. The public visibility of wealthy women performing civic offices and liturgies in the context of civic democracy helps to question women’s constant exclusion from full citizenship, even as it destabilizes the gendered two-sphere model claiming women’s segregation from meaningful public, political roles outside the domestic sphere. This paper will show that 1 Timothy’s own concern about wealthy women and that key currency of democracy, free, ekkl?sia speech, is illuminated by this wider context of the civic participation and leadership of wealthy women. In turn, such participation—such exercise of citizenship—has implications for free women and slaves lacking in significant economic resources.
|
QDESHAH, QADESH, and Pagan Sacred Prostitution: Scholarship in the Teeth of Ideology
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
James E Miller, Independent Scholar
In theory, it is possible to study Biblical polemics against the religious other, which includes stock figures such as the Qdeshim, Qdeshot and apparent sacred prostitutes. Although it is possible that such figures are entirely fictional constructs, in theory a scholar might find the occasional kernel of historical reality. In theory, the scholar could then engage in open and civil debate concerning such ancient polemics.
However, modern ideology can overwhelm such scholarship with modern polemics. Modern ideological polemics often presuppose a singular permissible conclusion. Borrowing fundamentalist methodologies, these permissible conclusions are treated as presuppositions to assure an ideologically acceptable conclusion. In this case the ideology, usually understood as feminist, presupposes, and therefore concludes, that there could not have been ancient sacred prostitution, not even as polemical fictions.
This paper will attempt to reopen analysis of this Biblical polemical material in the teeth of ideology. Some feminist work on this topic is helpful, and will be incorporated. Some work on this topic is not helpful, and will be critiqued.
|
The Early Israelite Settlement through the Lens of Judges
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Robert D. Miller, Catholic University of America
The Early Israelite Settlement through the Lens of Judges
|
The Scribal Performance of Greek Scripture in the Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Shem Miller, University of Mississippi
This paper explores the oral-written background of scribal practices reflected in early witnesses of the Septuagint. More specifically, I consider the purpose of vacat placement (and margin positioning) in three Septuagint manuscripts in the Dead Sea Scrolls (4QpapLXXLevb, 4QLXXNum, and 8HevXIIgr) and in our oldest papyrus fragments of the Septuagint (P. Oxy 50.3522, P. Rylands 458, and P. Fouad 266). Similar to the colometry of poetic books in later (uncial) codices of the Septuagint, the division of these texts into phrases provides reading cues that assist the reader to make proper pauses. More importantly, like stichographically arranged poetry in roughly contemporaneous copies of the Hebrew Bible in the Dead Sea Scrolls, the background of this scribal practice is oral-written: written, because spacing graphically displays literary structure; oral, because it presents a “visible song,” a convenient reference point for reading, recitation, and memorization. Overall, the spatialization in some Septuagint manuscripts in the Dead Sea Scrolls represents a scribal understanding of both poetic structure and ancient Jewish reading practices.
|
“The Creative Weapon of Love”: A Diachronic Survey and Assessment of the Biblical Texts and Hermeneutic at the Foundation of Martin Luther King Jr.’s Teaching and Practice of Nonviolent Resistance
Program Unit: Bible and Cultural Studies
Troy Miller, Memphis Center for Urban Theological Studies
On the 50th anniversary year of the assassination of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. at the Lorraine Motel in Memphis, Tennessee, the eyes of the world are rightfully drawn back to this man and the Civil Rights Movement he led. The Bible and Cultural Studies Section is to be commended for adding the SBL to the chorus of voices whose organizations commemorate and reinvigorate the tenets, activism, and mission of the movement alongside the MLK50 initiative and events of the National Civil Rights Museum.
One way of describing King, the recognized head of the Civil Rights Movement, is a man who led a movement that shamed a nation regarding its injustices on what it meant to be human. The movement toward this same end persists today for African-Americans and many other people of color. Sadly, the same nation and culture needs another dose (or two, or three, or four…) of the same message and practices toward a full realization of true human identity and dignity. The cultural shift initiated by King and the many others who joined in the movement with him, though, was seismic. The radical results that began to emerge from King’s life and work were due to a no less radical understanding and practice of Christian love. King voiced this in several places as “the creative weapon of love.” While King scholars (as well as King himself) have rightfully noted the significant influences of Gandhi on King’s method and even philosophy of nonviolence and passive resistance, King is careful to indicate that the origins and foundation for his own understanding and practices connect to and emerge from the gospel of Jesus, particularly the Sermon on the Mount. While the Christian gospel foundation of King’s message has not been neglected in King scholarship, the program of study described below is presented as a more narrowly focused tracking and engagement of King’s use of biblical texts within this gospel foundation.
In this essay, I take up the following tasks related to exploring the Christian gospel foundations of King’s practice of and teaching on nonviolent resistance. First, the paper will investigate and catalog the key passages of Scripture, with particular attention given to those from the Sermon on the Mount, as referenced by King in these contexts. Second, I give attention to the hermeneutical appropriation of these passages to understand the way(s) in which King employs them. Third, the study has an intentional diachronic element to it. Writings and interviews of King are selected from intentionally different periods of his involvement in the struggle for civil rights (early, mid, and late) so that any commonalities and/or variations in biblical texts or hermeneutic utilized across time can be highlighted and explored. Finally, the study seeks, through depth and clarity, to provide a refined lens through which to see these gospel foundations and, thus, to reinvigorate King’s voice for our contemporary context and culture.
|
The Process of Early Christian Identity Formation and the Emergence of the Social Phenomenon of Heresy
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Troy Miller, Memphis College for Urban Theological Studies
The formation of identity among groups in early Christianity is an area of study that rightfully has received a great deal of scholarly attention. As earlier conceptions of early Christian identity have been exposed as being too monolithic, too anachronistic, and/or too simplistic, a host of scholars have pursued different aspects of the subject from a variety of new angles. The social sciences have provided a particularly rich variety of concepts, tools, and theories in an effort to gain a more localized understanding of how aspects of identity developed within specific groups. The returns thus far have proven immensely valuable, and there is much more to be learned.
This study fits within this larger emphasis and movement. It seeks to make a contribution to the understanding of the process of identity formation of Christian groups in the first-century through the social-scientific analysis of what I am terming “the social phenomenon of heresy.” Though “heresy” is often thought of as a theological construct, at its core and in its beginnings it is a social phenomenon. Heresy occurs within groups and is located in the broader category of internal group conflict. It arises within groups, is negotiated within groups, and is resolved within groups. Additionally, as with most internal group conflict, the phenomenon of heresy serves as a catalyst for and means of group identity formation. Though identity formation within groups can occur in a variety of ways, the type of internal social conflict seen in the phenomenon of heresy pushes toward, if not demands, a resolution related to group identity.
This essay explores how the emergence of the phenomenon of heresy was a catalyst for the formation of identity in Christian groups in the first-century. I argue first that the context out of which the conceptual category of heresy initially emerged within early Christianity was not the institutionalization of orthodoxy within the second-century church, but rather, the dynamic of internal social conflict evident in situations of internal deviance within first-century Christianity and in at least one strand of the sectarianism of Second Temple Judaism. The second main argument is that early Christian identity formation was a logical and necessary result of these contexts of the social phenomenon of heresy, as it initiated a process in which identity was being worked out. The localized versions of Jewish Christianity or Christian Judaism in the various geographical locations remained part of a group’s identity, even with variations, until (in many instances) that an internal matter arose in the group that pressed the group toward internal differentiation. Our scholarly studies on later separation, partings of the ways, and distinct identities are a second movement in group identity formation that often formalizes what had already begun earlier within the group.
|
The Syriac Contribution to Understanding Rare Lexemes in the Greek of Ben Sira
Program Unit: International Syriac Language Project
Cynthia L. Miller-Naudé, University of the Free State
The contribution of the Syriac to an understanding of Ben Sira is especially important where there is no extant Hebrew Vorlage; in those cases, understanding the meaning of lexemes depends upon the intersection of the Greek and Syriac translations. This problem is especially acute in identifying the meaning of rare lexemes. In this paper, we illustrate these lexicographical difficulties through an examination of the botanical lexemes in Ben Sira. We demonstrate that understanding the relationship of the Syriac renderings to the Greek ones critically depends upon the translation methodology employed and that the Syriac provides important evidence for determining the botanical identifications of the terms for the plants and plant products.
|
Methodological Considerations in the Identification and Metaphorical Intepretation of Plants and Plant Products
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible and Cognate Literature
Cynthia L. Miller-Naudé, University of the Free State
The lexical terms used to describe plants and plant products are often infrequently attested and as a result their precise identification is contested, thus jeopardizing the coherence and rhetorical impact of metaphors utilizing plants and plant products. In this paper, we argue that attention to the precise botanical identification of plants and plant products plays a crucial role in interpreting their metaphorical and rhetorical functions. To illustrate the methodology of plant hermeneutics (as proposed by Musselman 2012), we examine three problematic botanical terms which are found in Ben Sira 24:13-15 and consider how the evidence of the Hebrew Bible, as well as the Greek and Syriac translations can provide the means to botanically identify the plants and their plant products, thus enhancing the metaphorical implications of the passage. The problematic botanical terms include (1) “rosebushes in Jericho” (verse 14), which were not known in ancient Israel and which do not contribute to the rhetorical context; (2) “good-looking olive tree in a plain” (verse 15), which is out of place as a domesticated tree among wild trees; and (3) “camel’s thorn” (verse 15), which has no aromatic features.
|
"Unripe Figs": Isho’dad’s Diatessaron and the Original Language of Tatian’s Gospel
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Ian N Mills, Duke University
In his commentaries on the Gospels and Acts, Isho’dad of Merv mentions the Diatessaron of Tatian seven times. These Syriac testimonia have been largely neglected by a sub-discipline preoccupied with far flung Middle Dutch and Arabic gospel harmonies. Isho’dad’s citations, however, represent a trove of untapped textual data with the potential to resolve the most beleaguered crux in Diatessaronic studies: the original language of Tatian’s Gospel. In particular, an allusion to Luke 19:4 in Isho’dad’s etymology of “Bethphage,” considered alongside the testimony of pseudo-Ephrem's Commentary, preserves a hitherto undetected indication that Tatian’s Gospel originally circulated in Greek. Namely, the apparently contradictory textual data from the two authors are best explained as attempted “etymological translations” of an otherwise unremarkable Greek variant.
|
Will and (Old) Testament: Reconsidering the Roots of Deuteronomy 25:5-10
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Sara Milstein, University of British Columbia
The so-called “family and/or women’s law collection” embedded in Deuteronomy 21–25 has attracted considerable attention among scholars. The magnetism of the block is understandable from multiple perspectives. From a comparative point of view, a number of the laws exhibit parallels with precepts in other Near Eastern law collections, enabling scholars to assess both what is shared and distinctive about the biblical texts. The laws deal with such provocative scenarios as a man’s unjust preferential treatment of one wife and son over another (Deut 21:15-17), a disloyal son whose behavior results in death (Deut 21:18-21), false accusations regarding a bride’s chastity (Deut 22:13-19), adultery (Deut 22:20-22), sexual assault with/without witnesses (Deut 22:23-29), marital restrictions for a two-time divorcee (Deut 24:1-4), and a man’s refusal to support his widowed sister-in-law (Deut 25:5-10). Given their focus on marriage, divorce, adultery, and widowhood it is plausible to consider that several of these texts have their origins in practical legal documents, such as marriage contracts, property divisions, and wills. While we are largely lacking in practical legal documents from ancient Israel and Judah, cuneiform archives from other Near Eastern settings have yielded a wealth of practical legal documents that date from the third through the first millennia B.C.E. Closer to the time of biblical writing, the first millennium B.C.E. presents considerable legal material from Babylonia and Assyria, but these documents may not provide the best analogies to practical law as it existed in Israel and Judah. Though more distant in time, second millennium B.C.E. legal documentation from ancient Syria belongs to a cultural matrix that is broadly closer to the world of the Bible. The 14th-12th century B.C.E. Hittite vassal city of Emar is particularly rich, with two-thirds of its 700+ published cuneiform tablets pertaining to legal matters, the bulk of which constitute private transactions. These texts include nearly 50 wills, most of which denote specific arrangements for the testator’s widow and children and anticipate potential complications. These wills exhibit striking similarities in terminology, format, and concerns with Deut 25:5¬10, suggesting that the latter may be rooted in a comparable Israelite legal document. This test case may then have implications for the origins of other “family laws” within Deuteronomy 21-25.
|
Studying Emotions in Early Jewish Texts: A Methodological Review
Program Unit: Bible and Emotion
Francoise Mirguet, Arizona State University
In this presentation, I will review four methodological frameworks that I have found particularly fruitful to engage in my study of compassion and other emotions in early Judaism. The first framework is the history of emotions, which includes, without separation, the history of concepts, discourses, and practices, in connection as well with the history of the self. In the second framework, emotions are approached in their structuring functions, as they help organize systems of hierarchical relationships. Here, the study of emotion intersects with gender—another structuring category—and is pursued against the background of politics and other power relationships (a focus particularly relevant in imperial contexts). The third framework consists in the study of identity and its techniques. Questions here include the role of emotions in the formation and maintenance of identity, but also in the production of alternative identities. The fourth framework involves a dialogue between history and evolutionary psychology: ancient texts illustrate how communities have creatively shaped adaptive traits and crafted unique emotional repertoires within biological constraints.
|
Lexical Innovations and the Transformation of the Self: Splanchna and Sensitivity to Others’ Pain
Program Unit: Philology in Hebrew Studies
Françoise Mirguet, Arizona State University
In this presentation, I will explore how lexical innovations go hand-in-hand with the transformation of the “self”—the way the human self is experienced, perceived, and conceptualized. My case study will be the introduction, in Greek-speaking late antique Judaism, of terms based on splanchna (the inner organs) that express sensitivity to others’ pain—with a meaning close to contemporary compassion. Terms include, among others, the verb splanchnizomai (sometimes preceded by a preposition) and the noun eusplanchna. These terms start appearing in the Greek scriptures and their use is developed in the pseudepigrapha. This lexical family has been related to the Hebrew rachamim (built on rechem, womb); in fact, however, terms built on splanchna, in the Greek scriptures, rarely translate rachamim and cognate terms (only towards the end of the translation process). Rather, a lexical shift may happen within the Hebrew language, with terms such as rachamim and chesed taking up more strictly emotional meanings (see Joosten, 2004). I will relate these different phenomena—lexical coinage, translation, and shift of meaning—to the production of an inner self, characterized by its feelings, intentions, and deliberations. The capacity to be touched by others’ pain plays an important role in an ethics emphasizing interiority, as this emotional moment guarantees the involvement of the inner self in acts of assistance. I will suggest that lexical innovations, in their different forms, reflect the transformation of the self, but also assist with this evolution.
|
Readings of the Three on the Margins of the Georgian Manuscripts of Samuel-Kings
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Historical Books
Natia Mirotadze, Ivane Javakhishvili Tbilisi State University
Similar to the Greek manuscript tradition of the Biblical Books there are some variants of the three placed on the margins of the Georgian biblical manuscripts as well.
All readings on the margins of the Georgian manuscript tradition of Samuel-Kings will be discussed in the paper according to the following viewpoints:
1. What kind of readings are they (relatively large additions, synonyms of the textual reading, alternative transliteration of the proper names etc.)?
2. Are they preserved in any other Manuscript tradition (especially in Greek) as well or not?
3. Are they ascribed to the same author in the Greek and Georgian traditions or not?
4. How the marginal readings are connected to lemmata in the Greek and Georgian traditions?
5. How these readings are attested in the later Georgian manuscripts: are they still on the margins, or are they lost or incorporated to the text by adding to the lemmata or replacing them?
On the example of these around twenty cases I’ll try to demonstrate why and how marginalia does or does not become (if there can be found any logic at all) part of the text.
|
Problems and Solutions in the Museum of the Bible
Program Unit: Metacriticism of Biblical Scholarship
Margaret Mitchell, University of Chicago
This paper will analyze the MOB in relation to the ancient (and yet still relevant) pedagogical form of problemata kai lyseis, “problems and solutions.” Already in antiquity it was recognized that the Bible (like other classic texts, like the Homeric Epics) contained “problems” or “points for disputation” on matters literary, exegetical, historical, ethical, theological, etc. that needed to be addressed, and for which possible solutions had to be proposed and adjudicated. We shall apply that as a heuristic model with which to analyze the selection, arrangement and presentation of exhibits in the MOB: what “problems” in the Bible and the history of its reception do they acknowledge, and how do they seek to “solve” them; which “problems” do they not address at all, or even seek to avoid? How are “solutions” offered, judged, insisted upon, and what is the role of the viewer as problem solver? Is the Museum, either explicitly or implicitly addressing a grand “problem” of what is perceived to be the waning influence of the Bible (i.e., a certain reading of the Bible) in American life?
|
Biblical Hebrew Lexicon in the Light of the Qumran Scriptural Scrolls
Program Unit: Qumran
Noam Mizrahi, Tel Aviv University
The lexical inventory of Biblical Hebrew is usually based upon scrutiny of the MT, with only occasional reference to other textual witnesses. Biblical Hebrew, however, is reflected in other sources as well. Variant readings contained in such witnesses might be superior or inferior to the MT, or simply different (in cases that do not allow directional evaluation of the evidence). In all three cases, however, the data should ideally be included in the lexical aids, since such variant readings are as “biblical” as the readings of the MT, and they all testify to the vocabulary of ancient Hebrew. This paper seeks to demonstrate some practical implications of this claim by investigating several lexical variants found in the scriptural scrolls from Qumran.
|
The 2017–2018 Excavations at Huqoq in Israel's Galilee
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Dennis Mizzi, University of Malta
Since 2011, Jodi Magness of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill has directed excavations in the ancient village of Huqoq in Eastern Lower Galilee, assisted by Shua Kisilevitz of the Israel Antiquities Authority. The excavations have brought to light parts of the Jewish village of the fifth-sixth centuries and the Ottoman period Muslim village of Yakuk. In this paper, we report on the results of the 2017-2018 excavation seasons, which focused on a monumental, Late Roman (early fifth century) synagogue paved with extraordinary mosaics depicting an unparalleled series of biblical scenes. The synagogue was expanded and reused as a public building in the Middle Ages (twelfth-thirteenth centuries), when the stylobates and pedestals were lifted one meter, and the aisles were paved with mosaics. This paper provides an overview of these recent discoveries, which shed new light on Galilean Jews and Judaism against the background of the rise and spread of Christianity.
|
People on the Move, Places in Motion: An Archaeological Perspective on Travel in the Ancient Mediterranean
Program Unit: Jewish, Christian, and Graeco-Roman Travel in the Hellenistic, Roman, and Early Byzantine Periods (300 BCE–600 CE)
Dennis Mizzi, University of Malta
The literary sources are replete with accounts of itinerant individuals. They tell us where they went and when they embarked on their respective journeys; they inform us on what they saw and did. But they are largely silent on the materiality of travel. Critically, the textual sources are rather limited in scope. In contrast, because of its ability to study entire landscapes and seascapes, archaeology can operate on a much broader canvas and it can take us to places that texts rarely do. One such canvas is the ancient Mediterranean, which can be described as a sea of proximity, one which facilitated travel across its basin, bringing people together in a way that other regions never did. But it is not just people and their objects or ideas that were constantly on the move. The fixed spaces through and to which people travelled can also be characterized as places in motion, continuously transformed by the cultural traffic they experienced. The ancient Mediterranean, therefore, was a vibrant region with highly fluid internal boundaries. This problematizes the study of ancient peoples, sites, and material culture, which are often placed into very neat categories or taxonomies. In turn, it has significant implications for our understanding of ancient Jewish and Christian communities, the study of which cannot be divorced from this larger setting of interconnected milieus. This paper explores a few of these issues, drawing on archaeological case studies to highlight the unique contributions archaeology can make to the present theme.
|
On Engaging with the Subject Matter of the Text: A Reading of Mark 13:32-37
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
R. W. L. Moberly, University of Durham
On Engaging with the Subject Matter of the Text: A Reading of Mark 13:32-37
|
A Cross-Cultural and Liberative Hermeneutics of Luke 10:25–37 in Asian and Asian-American Perspective: Reading One Text through Two Lenses
Program Unit: Asian and Asian-American Hermeneutics
David Moe, Asbury Theological Seminary
The Lukan parable (Luke 10:25-37) is a famous parable in the biblical tradition. However, the methodology of reading the text reveals a number of contrasts. Asian liberationists, such as Suh Nam Dong and Ahn Byung Mu, two of the pioneers of Korean minjung theologians, tend to focus on reading the text through the lens of the victim, while missiologists or intercultural theologians, such as Peter Phan and others tend to focus on reading the text through the lens of the Samaritan. For the liberationists, the victim in the parable is the primary agent who plays a role of Christ; for the intercultural missiologists, the Samaritan in the parable is the primary agent who plays a role of Christ’s cross-cultural mission of healing and helping the victim. Emphasizing one agent without embracing the other has its limitations for the intercontextual hermeneutics of the text in the context of marginalism and multiculturalism. I will argue that we need to use the middle ground as the methodological tool for interpretation and implication of the text for Asian and Asian American perspective. Looking at the text through the lens of the victim, we see the role of Jesus as a margin and the role of the victims as subjects who struggle for liberation. Looking at the text through the lens of the Samaritan, we see the incarnational role of Jesus’ crossing frontiers of healing the victims as objects in a multicultural world. This is not to be seen as contradictory, rather as complimentary. Living in the context of both marginality and multiculturality, the aim of this paper is to invite Asian and Asian American Christians to read the text through the two lenses for a cross-cultural and liberative-postcolonial hermeneutics of theology and ethics so that we embody a fuller meaning of the gospel and a cross-cultural mission of God in our world.
|
Hebrews and Cosmology
Program Unit: Hebrews
David Moffitt, University of St. Andrews
One of the main questions that must be addressed when interpreting Hebrews concerns the most plausible cosmological assumptions that underlie the author's arguments. I explore the cosmology implicit in Hebrews and highlight some central interpretive issues impacted by those assumptions. I focus particularly on how the author's presumed cosmological assumptions impact on his engagement with the Jewish cult.
|
Written and Revealed: Manicheans on the Origin of Their Sacred Books
Program Unit: Book History and Biblical Literatures
Evgenia Moiseeva, Independant scholar
Manichaeism, a religion founded in the third century Sassanid Iran, which then spread from Spain to China, is known for various artistic talents of its founder, Mani. A prolific author, he exposed his doctrine in seven books in order to preserve the revelation intact for future generations. Later, he added a book of drawings and paintings which explained different aspects of his cosmogony, anthropology, etc. The act of writing by Mani himself was presented by his followers as a warrant of the sacred origin of Mani’s prophecy. The meticulous conformity of copied books to Mani’s original works was a vital element of Manichaeism. The sacred role of the written word meant that the first generation of post-Mani theologians had to justify their audacity in commenting on Mani’s teaching, i.e., creating new texts. Furthermore, the next generations felt a strong need to prove the divine origin of Mani’s writings that would conform to the grandeur of an aspiring universal religion aiming to “supersede” rather than deny other faiths. The extant Manichaean sources describe two sources, from which the revelation came to Mani. The first one is the “upper reality”: some excerpts mention the heavenly journey during which Mani saw all the miracles of the world and learned the truth, while others point to the celestial Twin (all stories are described in the Cologne Mani Codex). Mani’s books are also presented as gifts received from deities (Kephalaion 148). The second source of Mani’s revelation is unique for religious actors in the 4-5 centuries CE. The excellence of Mani’s religion is proved by the fact that “writings and wisdom and the revelations and the parables” of previous churches have come down to him (CMC 61.1-63.20, Kephalaion 154). In this talk I will address the question why Manicheans explained the origin of their texts in two completely different (at least at the first sight) ways. I will start by reviewing different stories Manichaean sources tell us about the origins of Mani’s writings. Then I will analyze the role that was attributed to Mani and his writing skills in the sacredness of his texts. I will conclude by suggesting that the existence of two traditions can be explained by looking into the Manichaean concept of religion and the missionary nature of their Church.
|
Language Contact and Change: A Case Study of Biblical Hebrew Quotations in Aramaic Incantation Bowls
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Dorota Molin, University of Cambridge
The Biblical Hebrew quotations which we find in the Aramaic incantation bowls are a highly valuable, yet understudied corpus of linguistic data. They come from a corpus of incantations which originate from Late Antique Babylonia. The linguistic value of the biblical quotations lies, inter alia, in their partial tendency to phonetic spelling. They become especially significant in light of the absence of corpora of Biblical Hebrew from the pre-Masoretic period. These quotations, therefore, are the only source of knowledge about pre-Masoretic pronunciation traditions of Biblical Hebrew in Late Antique Babylonia. When studying the language of these quotations, one of the chief areas of interest will naturally be the degree of cross-linguistic influence. In other words, we can study the patterns in which Jewish Babylonian Aramaic—the synchronic vernacular—influenced the transmission of the dead language—Biblical Hebrew. Such an endeavor is, nevertheless, not without its difficulties. When studying the features of the quotations, we often have to weigh different possible explanations, such as scribal errors, textual variants, and cross-linguistic interference. There also exists the possibility that some features reflect a stage of the Hebrew reading which is more archaic than the one attested in the medieval Masoretic sources. In addition, we ought to take into account the possibility of historical orthography, considering the degree to which some language changes may remain concealed by conservative spellings. In my presentation, I offer a series of case-studies which illustrate some of the methodological difficulties encountered in the analysis, and the limitations of our knowledge. In doing so, I aim to identify some general principles applicable to the study of language contact and change in the case of written and extinct languages more generally.
|
Minding the Gaps of Research History: The Jewish Itinerant Jesus of Gustaf Dalman (1924)
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Hilde Brekke Moller, MF Norwegian School of Theology/Religion/Society
The three-quest scheme has not proved helpful to describe the history of Jesus research at large. One of the problems with this traditional mapping, is it’s narrowing effect: Some scholars who could have been considered part of research history have been left out, and some significant features of the included contributions have not been taken into account, because they do not fit with the expectations created by the scheme.
This paper’s point of departure is that more work needs to be done before the three-quest scheme can be replaced by an alternative mapping. It is necessary to look for “forgotten” contributions to Jesus research. Besides, Jesus constructions should be considered without the restricting presuppositions produced by the three-quest scheme. Instead, all contributions to Jesus research should be read with in interest for the book’s and the Jesus scholar’s own academic contexts, and as part of their broader culture.
One of the contributors to Jesus research that has been overlooked so far, is Gustaf Dalman (1855—1941). Dalman published a number of books on Jesus and his Palestinian context. Though never a recognized Jesus scholar, he interacted with other (now recognized) Jesus scholars, such as J. Klausner, and he was J. Jeremias’s Doktorvater.
This paper focusses on Dalman’s contribution to the itinerancy of Jesus and his disciples, which is the main theme of the book /Orte und Wege Jesu/ from 1924. The book sold massively, with two reprints up to 1967, and has been translated into English. The paper portrays Dalman’s itinerant Jesus, and places that portrayal into its academic context.
Dalman’s work on Jesus sheds light on two themes that have been much debated in later Jesus research, namely ‘Jewishness’ and ‘uniqueness’.
In the volume, Dalman explicitly takes issue with constructions of a non-Jewish Jesus. His alternative is the portrait of a Jewish Jesus. While Dalman’s Jesus is a Jew, and while he reveals great knowledge of, and respect for, ancient Judaism (without the usual stereotypical and negative images), he does portray Jesus as someone who actually cannot be compared with his fellow Jews. I argue that in Dalman’s case, this does not signal a devaluation of things Jewish. Rather, Dalman's scholarship rests on the view that Jesus is more than any man; more than other human beings. In Dalman’s opinion, Jesus is the divine savior of the world. Though critiques of such unique’ish portrayals of Jesus are timely, it is important to distinguish between scholarship that disregard Judaism (and/or struggle with portraying a Jewish Jesus) and scholarship that struggle with portraying a fully human Jesus (and thereby show that they do not stay within the borders of historical Jesus research, given that it is an atheistic enterprise). Dalman fails on the latter, but not on the first.
|
A Song for the Poor: Ethical Reflections on the Language of Poverty in the Psalter
Program Unit: Bible and Ethics
Erica Mongé-Greer, University of Aberdeen
In many places, the Hebrew Bible responds to social development with concern for the care of marginalized people. This is usually contextualized in conversation with Israel’s own history as an oppressed people in Egypt. The Hebrew Bible Psalter is a composition of psalms and hymns that are not traditionally viewed as ethical; however, there has been a recent interest in scholarship to consider what ethical teachings the Psalms may offer. In light of this discussion, this paper is concerned with socioeconomic language in the Psalter.
This study will offer a catalogue of language of the poor in the Psalter and examine the range of meanings connected with poverty by looking at cognate literature in the Hebrew Bible and in other ancient Near Eastern texts. It is my intention to determine a broader social context for Hebrew Bible ethical values in the psalmists’ consideration for the poor.
|
"And This Was Not New": Identity and Legitimacy in 1 Clement
Program Unit: Redescribing Christian Origins
Mina Monier, King's College - London
As a letter designed to settle a dispute in Corinth, 1 Clement is often read as a struggle to define appropriate Christian practice. However, in addition, by means of the question of which correct liturgical practice is to be followed, the author demonstrates an apologetic tone. The letter appears to provide a response to accusations similar to those of Celsus and other later writers. A key criticism is that Christianity is a novelty that is disrespectful to its ancient (Jewish) roots. In this paper it will be proposed that 1 Clement offers an apologia pro ecclesia through which legitimacy is asserted in the light of the Jewish foundations of Christianity. It will be argued that the concept of the Temple is a tool Clement used to construct his argument for legitimacy. Comparing the epistle with its key resources (Hebrews and 1 Corinthians) shows how the author has carefully edited these in order to preserve a sense of strong allegiance to the Temple . It will also be argued that the author developed his understanding of legitimacy and the Temple's role in it differently to other contemporaneous forms of Christianity evidenced by the Epistle of Barnabas and Luke-Acts.
|
New Light on the Curse of mērôz in the Song of Deborah
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Lauren Monroe, Cornell University
The curse of mērôz in Judges 5:23 has long been an interpretive crux in the Song of Deborah. The term mērôz is widely understood as an otherwise-unattested place name, a reading understandably conditioned by reference to “its inhabitants”. However, as a toponym, it is unclear why mērôz is singled out for cursing when the non-participating tribes in verses 15b-17 are not, a problem compounded by an inability to locate the town, or ascertain its political affiliations or allegiances within the context of the Song. This paper offers a new explanation for the term, analyzing it as cognate to the Akkadian term râṣu, “to come to the aid of”, attested at Amarna and elsewhere, and the more well-attested noun rēṣu, meaning “ally”. Remarkably, this meaning for the term is provided within the biblical verse itself: “‘Curse mērôz!’ said the messenger of Yahweh, for they did come to the aid of Yahweh, to the aid of Yahweh among the warriors.” I suggest that the curse of mērôz is directed against the non-participating tribes mentioned earlier in the poem; that is, the tribes of Reuben, Dan, Asher and Gilead. These tribes constituted mērôz, or “auxiliary forces” that were expected, but failed to appear for battle. The idea that Yahweh would curse tribes that later are considered part of “Israel” lends greater complexity to our understanding of the socio-political landscape that underlies this most ancient of biblical poems, and illuminates the raw materials out of which the authors of Judges 4-5 constructed their vision of a unified Israelite past.
|
Great and Wise Fathers as Exemplars for the Students of Ben Sira/Sirach
Program Unit: Deuterocanonical and Cognate Literature
Andrew Montanaro, The Catholic University of America
In the Praise of the Fathers, there is a disproportionate number of occurrences (27%) of the word μέγας in the Greek of Ben Sira (hereafter, Sirach). Further emphasizing this pattern, the section is introduced by a triple use of μέγας in Sir 43 (vv. 28, 29, and 32) in a summary statement that the “great” God gives wisdom to the pious ancestors, who, like God, will be described as “great.” This pattern has implications for interpreting other sections in Sirach when the audience is directed toward wisdom and greatness. For example, Sir 25:10 states: “how great (ὡς μέγας) is he who finds wisdom.” In light of the use of μέγας in the Praise of the Fathers, Sirach appears to be linking his students with the ancestors, as they pursue wisdom. Thus, God, who is great, may make Sirach’s students great, by giving them wisdom, just as he made the ancestors great. The Praise of the Fathers then becomes an incentive for students in their quest for wisdom. This matches the increased co-occurrences of μέγας with other words such as δόξα in this section. It should also be noted that, although eight of the 29 instances of μέγας in Sirach occur in places where there is no Hebrew extant, a similar analysis of semantically related words in Hebrew (such as גדל and רב) tentatively reveals a focus on Simon. Thus, becoming great for the students of the Hebrew text of Ben Sira may mean to become specifically like Simon the high priest.
|
Cult Transferrer, Community Founder, or Both? Refining a Conception of the Lukan Paul
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
Eric Moore, Emory University
Clare Rothschild’s 2014 monograph, “Paul in Athens: The Popular Religious Context of Acts 17,” contends that in this well-known passage Luke fashions Paul not foremost as a philosopher but as a cult-transfer figure, à la Epimenides of Crete. Rothschild’s argument builds upon the work of others, such as James Hanges (Paul, Founder of Churches) and Hans Dieter Betz (“Transferring a Ritual”), who portray Paul as a cult founder, as well as Elizabeth Gebhard (“Gods in Transit”), who identifies recurrent patterns in cult transfer narratives (e.g., of Asclepius and Magna Mater to Rome). I am largely sympathetic to this portrait of Paul as founder/transferrer and have no serious objections to Rothschild’s specific argument in Acts 17. In this paper, however, I wish to refine the argument by relating Paul’s cult transfers in Acts more broadly to his role as community founder. In making this claim, I am leveraging the insights of those such as Daniel Marguerat (The First Christian Historian), Walter Wilson (“Urban Legends”), and David Balch (ΜΕΤΑΒΟΛΗ ΠΟΛΙΤΕΙΩΝ), who see civic foundation narratives as productive analogues to Luke’s account of Christian origins. My claim, in other words, is that in Acts Paul transfers cult by virtue of his position as founder of communities. I advance this argument in three steps: First, I discuss the correlation between ancient civic foundation accounts and Acts, with attention to the religious dimension of the community founder’s role; second, I examine intersection between civic and cult foundations; lastly, I concentrate on Paul’s role as cult transferrer in Acts 11–13.
|
Unpublished Aramaic Papyri from Elephantine: A Description of Rediscovered Documents and Fragments in the Berlin Museum
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
James Moore, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin - Humboldt University of Berlin
This paper reports on the ongoing study of unpublished Aramaic papyri
fragments in Berlin’s Ägyptisches Museum und Papyrussammlung. The
German excavations of Elephantine by Otto Rubensohn and Friedrich
Zucker between 1906–1907 yielded many papyri, the most famous of which
are the Aramaic documents of the Judeans on the island. While the best
preserved pieces were quickly published by Eduard Sachau in 1908 and
1911, other fragments from the excavation have come to light over the last century.
The latest of these rediscoveries is the—yet to be published—“Aramaic
Box.” This paper provides a survey of the new papyri found in this box.
|
"Who Gave You a Decree?" Anonymity as a Scribal Technique in Ezra-Nehemiah and Persian Period Sources
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
James D. Moore, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin - Humboldt University of Berlin
For those studying pseudepigraphic or New Testament sources, and to a lesser extent Old Testament literature, anonymity plays a role in the discussion of literary meaning. Some working on Old Testament sources have studied anonymity as a literary device (e.g. Reinhartz 1993; 1998; Roth 1964), while others are interested in the anonymous authors of ancient literary sources (e.g. Smith 1971; Gevaryahu 1990). Surprisingly, the use of anonymity in the significant corpus of Persian Period Aramaic documents remains understudied. This paper will explore the ways in which Aramaic writers of both documentary and literary sources presented or obfuscated their identities or the identities of their characters and how understanding this scribal practice provides a nuanced interpretation to select passages in Ezra-Nehemiah.
|
Functions of the Prophets and Writings in Hebrews
Program Unit: Hebrews
Scott R. Moore, Regis University
One of the great distinctives of the book of Hebrews is the manner in which the Jewish Scriptures are woven in and through its arguments from beginning to end. Prior work concerning Hebrews’ use of scripture has often considered the author’s sources, citation markers, selection of texts that involve direct speech and exegetical technique within the broader context of ancient Judaism, among other topics.
This paper examines the various functions of texts from the Prophets and Writings in Hebrews with particular attention to the idea that, in the context of ancient Jewish hermeneutics, the Prophets and Writings were often viewed as texts that interpret or elucidate the Pentateuch. In an effort to create a manageable set of categories with interpretive value from among the dozens of citations in Hebrews (not to mention countless allusions), seven functions of texts from the Prophets and Writings are identified and described. The seven functions are: (1) To fill gaps in the Pentateuch and (2) present gaps to be filled; (3) to make theological connections to Pentateuchal paradigms; (4) to reinterpret or (5) destabilize pentateuchal paradigms; (6) to draw parenetic lessons from Pentateuchal narratives and (7) to offer hope to the audience. Among the citations or allusions referenced are Pss 8, 95, 110; Jer 31:31-34 and Hag 2:6. It becomes apparent that most of these uses relate directly to the Pentateuch in some way, although some of them reinforce traditional interpretations, while others alter or even subvert them. The hope is that these categories will refresh and facilitate dialogue around the interpretation of Hebrews’ use of particular texts.
|
Scripture in the Third Degree: Hypertext, Hypotexts and Exegetical texts in the NT
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Scott R. Moore, Regis University
From enhanced understandings of citations, allusions and echoes to imitation and dialogism, a greater awareness of textual interrelationships has become an expected feature in contemporary biblical exegesis. Intertextual studies of ancient texts often begin with the perception that a later text has incorporated a prior text in some way. Gérard Genette’s work (particularly Palimpsests: Literature in the Second Degree) has captured the attention of biblical scholars by cataloging a plethora of ways that certain texts reference, absorb, adapt, extend and transform prior texts. He describes this phenomenon as hypertextuality, with a prior text, “text A,” referred to as the hypotext and the resulting new text, “text B,” as the hypertext. (The “palimpsest” metaphor, of course, envisions a new text being written over a previously existing text.) Genette’s extensive and impressive taxonomy treats especially (though not exclusively) narrative literature and is of immense value when it comes to analyzing narrative and poetic texts. There are limitations, however, when it comes to the analysis of exegetical texts; new texts that use one text to interpret another text or texts. In that event text C intentionally interprets text A by means of text B; text B serving as an intermediary or exegetical text.
This paper considers three examples of such layered intertextuality from exegetical sections of the NT, examining cases in which a NT text self-consciously interprets one text by means of another. In each of these cases, a text from the Prophets or Writings is used to interpret a text from the Pentateuch: Gal 4 uses Isa 54:1 in exegesis of Genesis, Romans 1-4 uses Hab 2:4 in exegesis of Genesis, and John 6 uses the more complex “bread from heaven” allusion in relation to the wilderness narrative. The value and limitations of applying Genette’s scheme to exegetical contexts is discussed in conjunction with each example, with suggestions made related to conceptual adjustments and understanding some scripture as literature in the third degree.
|
Patience in the Light of the Lord's Coming: A Latin American Reading
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Nelson R. Morales, Central American Theological Seminary (SETECA)
The paper is a reading of Jas 5:7-11 from a Latin American perspective. It analyzes the text utilizing the concept of militant patience in Elsa Tamez's commentary on James, No discriminen a los pobres (Madrid: Verbo Divino, 2008). Some Western authors have read "patience" here as almost synonym with resignation. Furthermore, they tend to understand the exhortation of this pericope as individualistically addressed. This article challenges both concepts. It understands μακροθυμία/ὐπομονή as active patience lived in community. After analyzing the text from this perspective, this paper will reflect on Christian patience today in the light of suffering and violence in Latin America.
|
Rahab as Symbol of Salvation: A Patristic Consensus
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
Jonathan Morgan, Indiana Wesleyan University
The women recorded in Matthew’s genealogy of Jesus (Matthew 1:1-17) have long been a source of fascination for Christians. While some consider their presence in Jesus’ lineage a hopeful sign of redemption and inclusion, others may puzzle over why the writer would include women – particularly of ill repute – into the lineage of the Messiah. Though modern scholars differ as to the significance of the inclusion of the women in Matthew 1, there is a surprising degree of consensus among patristic interpreters of Scripture. Patristic exegesis of Scripture has undergone a kind of renaissance in recent decades, giving rise to a new appreciation for pre-critical methods of biblical interpretation. Of course, “patristic exegesis” is not at all uniform. Individual church fathers possessed their own interpretive and theological idiosyncrasies, and scholars debate whether and to what degree certain interpretive traditions (or “schools” of interpretation) influenced thinkers of Christian antiquity. In light of this, the focus of my paper is patristic interpretations of Rahab, perhaps the most controversial figure of the women in Jesus’ genealogy. In the conquest narratives she plays a significant and unique role. While the New Testament writers commend her for her faith, the name “Rahab” in the Old Testament has a decidedly mixed connotation. None of this escapes the notice of many noteworthy patristic thinkers. Therefore, I will explore how Rahab is portrayed by Origen, Jerome, and John Chrysostom. These three thinkers convey a keen interest in Rahab’s place in Scripture, both as an historical figure and a theological symbol. Importantly, each represents different exegetical traditions. Origen is best known for his allegorical approach to Scripture that, for a time, became associated with Alexandria. Jerome, though in many ways indebted to Origen, was a Latin figure and biblical scholar who knew the biblical languages, and was influenced by a variety of other interpretive traditions. Chrysostom represents the so-called Antiochene tradition that privileges the historical sense of the text while not disregarding spiritual implications. The degree to which terms such as “Alexandrian” or “Antiochene” are accurate is not my concern in this paper. Rather, my purpose is to show how patristic exegetes from different backgrounds and exegetical traditions deal with the figure of Rahab and, in doing so, underscore not only the variety of patristic methods of interpretation, but also the underlying theological unity of their interpretations. Though employing different hermeneutics and drawing from various influences, Origen, Jerome, and Chrysostom end up with similar conclusions concerning Rahab and what she represents theologically; a symbol of salvation and hope.
|
Preaching in the Shadow of Memphis
Program Unit: Bible and Cultural Studies
Michelle J. Morris, Arkansas Conference of the United Methodist Church
“There are two things you aren’t allowed to talk about here: the West Memphis Three, and the assassination of Martin Luther King, Jr. You weren’t here. You don’t know.” These were instructions given to me by parishioners at the church I served in West Memphis, Arkansas. A town that is still noticeably divided by race and class (including a proverbial “other side of the tracks”), West Memphis also contains a neighborhood that consistently lands on lists of most violent areas in the United States. This paper will reflect on the role of the prophet in light of the continual tensions over issues central to the work of Martin Luther King, Jr. I will employ Dr. King’s work, biblical reflection, and my own experience of justice in the midst of such divide to explore how sometimes the best preaching does not occur at the pulpit but instead occurs on the streets, in relationships, and through small group work.
|
Metaphorical Dehumanization of Violence in Jeremiah
Program Unit: Writing/Reading Jeremiah
Amanda R. Morrow, University of Wisconsin-Madison
The literary trope of metaphor requires using one domain (the source) to speak/write about another domain (the target). An examination of the book of Jeremiah shows an abundance of metaphors where animals (source) are used to speak/write about target domains such as God, the Judahites, the Babylonians, the Egyptians, and more. This act of using animal metaphors to speak about humans is one form of what anthropologists call "dehumanization." This paper will explore various instances of animal metaphors in the book of Jeremiah (and by extension, similes) to examine their relation to violent acts/events and explore potential explanations for dehumanization using both literary and anthropological approaches. This paper will also compare similar animal images found in Neo-Babylonian period archaeological remains to discuss a larger cultural phenomenon of dehumanization found in ancient violent imagery.
|
Methods of Interpreting Scripture and Nature: The Influence of the Baconian Method on Spinoza’s Biblical Criticism
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Jeffrey Morrow, Seton Hall University
Spinoza’s Tractatus Theologico-politicus (TTP, 1670) has long been seen as programmatic for the development of modern biblical criticism. In his Prolegomena zur Geschichte Israels (1883) Wellhausen named Spinoza as a forerunner. Contemporary scholars, from Moshe Goshen-Gottstein to Dominique Barthélemy likewise link Spinoza as a foundational figure in articulating a critical method for biblical studies. When examining the proximate background to the method of biblical studies that Spinoza proposes, scholars rightly emphasize the varied influences on his work, e.g.: medieval Muslim philosophical and polemical literature like that of Ibn Hazm (e.g., Roger Arnaldez, R. David Freedman); Descartes’ methodic doubt (e.g., Edwin Curley); the biblical interpretation of Isaac La Peyrère (e.g., Richard Popkin); the work in the Bible of Spinoza’s Dutch acquaintances like Lodewijk Meyer, Samuel Fisher, and Adriaan Koerbagh (e.g., James Samuel Preus, Wiep Van Bunge, and Travis Frampton). All of these are important influences, but very little scholarly attention has been paid to the important influence of Francis Bacon’s Novum Organum Scientiarum (1620) on Spinoza. This paper explores the ways in which Spinoza models his new historical method for interpreting the Bible on Bacon’s scientific method for interpreting nature. Just as Bacon argues for the importance of developing a natural history of the world in order to better understand it, so too Spinoza lays down the foundations for creating a “natural history” of Scripture. Early in the seventh chapter of his TTP, wherein he lays out his proposed method for biblical interpretation, in an allusion to the subtitle of Bacon’s work, Spinoza calls for just such an interpretation. Thus, at the very foundation of modern historical biblical criticism, in the seventeenth century, we find the historical method of Spinoza patterned on the methods of natural science.
|
The Organization of Deuteronomy 12–26 as a Revision and Expansion of the Covenant Code
Program Unit: Book of Deuteronomy
William Morrow, Queen's University
Eckart Otto has made a significant contribution to the long-standing scholarly interest in accounting for the arrangement of the laws in Deuteronomy 12–26. He suggests that the Covenant Code (Exodus 20:24–23:17*) guided the organization of the original Deuteronomic legal corpus. With the exception of the laws on bodily injury and property (Exod 21:18–22:14), the contents of the Covenant Code were revised in terms of Deuteronomy’s concerns for the centralization of sacrifice and the promulgation of an ethic of national unity (i.e., brotherhood). In addition, the first edition of Deuteronomy frequently used the device of ring-composition—also characteristic of the Covenant Code. The frame created by the altar and festival laws in Exod 20:24-26 and 23:14-17 is reflected in Deut 12:13–16:17*. Tithe and firstling laws in Deut 14:22-23 and 15:19-23* frame a series of social laws involving motifs of seven-year release which have correspondences in the Covenant Code. A frame created by 15:19-23* and 26:12 encircles sections of festival ordinances (16:1-17*), procedural law (16:18–18:5*), and rules of evidence (19:2–25:12*). All three categories have corresponding sections in the Covenant Code. Additionally, a frame created by 19:21 and 25:12 brackets the legal material in Deuteronomy 19–25*; both parts of this frame have parallels in the Covenant Code. As with any description of the organization of Deuteronomic law, chapters 19–25 merit special attention because of the difficulties in accounting for their literary arrangement. One of Otto’s contributions here is through appeal to the technique of “fan-concatenation,” by which sections of procedural law (A), capital crimes (B), and family law (C) are distributed in Deut 16:18–25:10* in the scheme A (16:18–18:5*); B (19:2-13*); A (19:15-21); B (21:1-9); C (21:15-21); B (21:22-23); C (2213-29; 24:1-4); A (25:1-3); C (25:5-10). Otto does not derive this technique from the Covenant Code. Moreover, according to Otto, these chapters extensively supplemented the Covenant Code through the incorporation of independent traditions of family law. In other words, a description of Deuteronomy as a revision and expansion of Covenant Code also has to take into account other factors—as Otto himself acknowledges. This paper will compare Otto’s account of the organization of Deuteronomy 12–26 with those set out by other scholars in order to highlight its explanatory power and to suggest how it sets out an agenda for future scholarship.
|
Reception Criticism and the Curatorial Turn
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Holly Morse, University of Manchester
This paper will offer an exploration of the extent to which contemporary curatorial theory can provide new models and methods for the practice of reception criticism within biblical studies. Although in recent years, as biblical reception criticism has expanded and developed as a sub-discipline, greater attention has been given over to the methodologies and approaches used by those researching the reception of the Bible, there remains considerable scope for further reflection. The field is still dominated, I argue, by three main modes of study, historical reception criticism, formal reception criticism, or ideological reception criticism. This predominance of well-established methods of enquiry –historical, formal, and ideological—suggests there is space for further creative possibilities that might emerge in the use of reception criticism as a means of re-enlivening biblical texts by encouraging contemporary readers to see them afresh through the lenses of their afterlives and cultural intertexts.
Mieke Bal, in her 1998 exhibition, Moordwijven/Lady Killers, aimed to destabilise traditional meaning associated with the apocryphal account of Judith by reframing the story in an exhibition space. By staging a series of original and challenging juxtapositions between an image of Judith with other Judith images and related Lady Killer/Lady Killer images, deconstructed themes of castration, gender violence, and masterpiece, Bal allowed the exhibition participants to see Judith anew. In this paper I will build on her work, as well as the cultural memory theory of Abi Warburg, and curatorial theory of Hans Ulrich Obrist and Jean-Paul Martinon, each of whom has challenged previous models of ‘curating’ as an act of disinterested presentation and has instead encouraged reflection on the ‘curatorial’ as ‘a disruptive embodiment against received knowledge’ in which the process of display becomes the means of meaning making, to explore these as potentially fruitful theoretical resources for biblical reception criticism.
In order to do so, I will consider the possibility of presenting an interpretative dialogue between Genesis 3.16 and 4, Auguste Rodin’s Eve, and Damien Hirst’s Mother Child Divided to examine how such a juxtaposition might allow a biblical text to be ‘read’ and ‘seen’ anew in light of themes of maternity, embodiment and trauma. In doing so I aim to consider how modes of presenting the dialogue between biblical text, afterlife(s), and intertexts can be reframed beyond the usual structures of chronological, formal, or ideological investigation, in favour of actively investigating the relational meaning-making process that takes place when, a biblical text, is read/seen through a thematically or conceptually related text/object and/or rewriting, as a means of forming new knowledge in the contemporary world. Thus, I advocate for a process of placing biblical texts into dialogue with their cultural afterlives and intertexts from a ‘discourse-oriented perspective’, and for further consideration of how biblical scholars might 'exhibit' biblical texts as part of an expository undertaking.
|
Watching Mark’s Audience: The "Progymnasmata" as Key to Ancient Readers
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Jacob P.B. Mortensen, Aarhus Universitet
This paper addresses the question of how the initial audience read and perceived the Gospel of Mark. I address the question from the perspective of the ancient literate Greco-Roman education, particularly the Progymnasmata of Aelius Theon (mid to end of the first century AD). Theon provides guidelines on how an author should compose a prose text and various minor elements within the text (for example a chreia, a fable, a comparison, a speech or a thesis). Hence, these guidelines function as “models of writing” for an author.
From the reader’s point of view, these guidelines also function as “horizons of expectations” for a reader educated in a similar way as the author. And since Mark wrote a gospel for someone specifically to read (cf. Mk 13:14) we can presuppose a reader educated (at least) in the same way as the author. Therefore, we can outline the expectations of the original audience or readers of Mark, since the reading and writing practices of ancient readers/writers followed the guidelines developed within the literate education. Hence, because we know "how" they wrote (from the Progymnasmata) we also know "what" they meant/understood.
If we can identify specific progymnasmatic exercises in Mark like the chreia, the fable (= parable), the comparison, the speech or the thesis – which I argue we can – we can analyze to which extend Mark follows the progymnasmatic guidelines and, hence, what the original audience/reader understood. For instance, in the case of a fable Theon explains that an author could decline the most important word in all four cases in order to indicate the theme of the story, but most often the accusative case should be used, since this practice mimics Homer. If we look at the parable of the wicked tenants in Mark 12:1-12, we can see that the author presents "geôrgos" once in the nominative, once in the genitive, once in the dative and twice in the accusative. Hence, the author could be said to follow progymnasmatic guidelines as “models of writing.” A reader educated at a similar level would read this passage with a “horizon of expectation” receptive to such “models” and would know how to decipher the use of cases and where to put the interpretational weight. Similar guidelines to the other 16 progymnasmatic exercises are numerous.
Theon’s Progymnasmata provides us with a double perspective into the writing and reading practices of a first-century semi-educated person on the progymnasmatic level: The author follows certain guidelines, and the reader expects and anticipates something specific from these guidelines. Hence, by analyzing the compositional techniques of the author of Mark in a fable and a thesis (12:1-12; 7:1-23), I will illuminate the reading-process of the original audience of Mark.
|
Jesus the Scapegoat of Yom Kippur (Matthew 27:27–31)
Program Unit: Matthew
Hans Moscicke, Marquette University
This paper examines an overlooked component of Matthew’s atonement theology, namely, his application of a Day of Atonement scapegoat typology to Jesus in the Passion narrative. Nathan Eubank (2013), following Gary Andersen’s (2009) influential work, argues that Matthew conceives sin as a debt to be repaid in a heavenly economy of righteous deeds. Yet recent studies by Rikard Roitto (2015) and Marius Nel (2017) suggest that the evangelist also utilizes the metaphor of sin as an object to be borne away. The most famous Jewish ritual that assumes this conception of sin is the scapegoat rite of Leviticus 16. In this essay, I argue that Matthew applies a scapegoat typology to Jesus in his mockery by the Roman soldiers. Unlike Luke 23:11 and John 19:1–5, Matt 27:27–31 retains the broad evocation of ancient expulsion rituals in Mark 15:16–20, as argued by Adela Collins (1998) and Richard DeMaris (2008). Yet Matthew’s redaction seems to betray a more specific allusion to the Jewish scapegoat ritual, as suggested by Koester (1990) and Stökl Ben Ezra (2003). I advance the claim that Matthew’s scarlet cloak (Matt 27:28; cf. Mark 15:17) evokes the Jewish tradition of tying onto the scapegoat a scarlet band representative of sins (m. Yoma 4.2; 6.6, Barn. 7.8, 11; Justin, Dial. 44), taking into account the Apocalypse of Abraham’s reception of this tradition. The violence Jesus endures evokes the abuses hurled upon the scapegoat in Second Temple tradition (1 En. 10.4–5; m. Yoma 6.4; Barn. 7.8; Apoc. Ab. 13.6–7). The crown of thorns also has symbolic import for the evangelist, “thorns” being associated with Adam’s curse (Gen 3:18) in Matt 7:16 (cf. 13:7, 22). By uniquely narrating that the thorns are placed on the head of Jesus (Matt 27:29; cf. Mark 15:17; Luke 23:11), Matthew recalls the literal placement of sins (or curses [Philo, Spec. 1.888; Barn. 7.7–8]) on the head of the scapegoat (Lev 16:21). He thus assimilates the elimination-rite paradigm of Mark 15:16–20 to its Jewish equivalent, the Leviticus 16 scapegoat ritual. Just as he uniquely portrays Jesus “bearing” the people’s sickness as Isaiah’s Servant (Matt 8:16–17; cf. Isa 53:4), so Matthew depicts Jesus as physically bearing their curse and iniquity as the Yom Kippur scapegoat (cf. Sider-Hamilton 2017: 221–24). Since Matthew typologically presents Jesus as the immolated goat of Leviticus 16 in the immediately preceding scene (Matt 27:15–26; as Wratislaw [1863], Stökl Ben Ezra [2003], and Maclean [2007] argue), his scapegoat typology in Matt 27:27–31 rounds out his conception of Jesus as the two goats of Yom Kippur.
|
Popelo as a Scared Space: Rereading Luke 2:6–8
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Itumeleng Daniel Mothoagae, University of South Africa
The 1830 translation of the Gospel of Luke foreignises the Setswana concept of peligi/gobelega (childbearing). The translator re-domesticates the concept thus giving it a new meaning. In this paper, I will argue that peligi/gobelega (childbearing) and popelo (womb) in the 1830 translation of the Gospel of Luke is reconstructed through an act of transmogrification with the aim of redefining the sacred space that peligi/gobelega (childbearing) and popelo (womb) occupy in the Setswana cultural practices. I will further argue that the transmogrification of this sacred space did not only redefine such a space, it also patriarchalised and colonised it. Applying the Setswana cultural framework and decoloniality as a theoretical framework, I will argue that there is a need to decolonise and liberate such a space.
Keywords: peligi/gobelega (childbearing), popelo (womb), translation, politics of interpretation, politics of association, erosion, patriarchy and decolonisation.
|
Choosing Gods in the Roman Empire
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Christopher N. Mount, DePaul University
A.D. Nock’s Conversion: The Old and the New in Religion from Alexander the Great to Augustine of Hippo uses the experience of conversion to mark the changing relations of inhabitants to gods in the Graeco-Roman world that Christianity introduced into the Roman Empire. This paper will look at how the rhetoric of conversion interprets cultic practice, shapes social boundaries, and defines true belief for participants in and interpreters of religion in the Roman Empire.
|
Prophetic Roles and Titles in Chronicles: A Socio-literary Analysis
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Tyler Mowry, Baylor University
Scholars seeking to reconstruct the socio-historical context of ancient Israelite prophecy often look to the distribution of the various terms for prophets within the Hebrew Bible (bǝnê hanǝbîʾîm, ʾîš hāʾĕlōhîm, nābîʾ, roʾeh, ḥozeh, etc.) to support some distinction of prophetic types along temporal or geographic lines. The proliferation and seeming inconsistency with which these words are deployed in 1-2 Chronicles, however, has led to the growing consensus that all appellations for prophets in the post-exilic period have collapsed into semantic equivalence. Against this consensus, the present study argues that the Chronicler utilizes prophetic terminology in a way that implies a discrete social location behind each term.
Methodologically, this paper falls in line with the pioneering work of David L. Petersen in his 1981 monograph The Roles of Israel’s Prophets, which applies the insights of Role Theory toward a reconstruction of ancient Israelite society. While ultimately departing from Petersen’s conclusions, this project is nonetheless indebted to his observation that viewing the prophetic office through the lens of Role Theory allows for the abstraction of socially conceived “roles” from both the individuals who occupy these roles and the verbal roots to which they may be etymologically connected. Thus abstracted, the remainder of the paper analyzes the use of prophetic terminology in 1-2 Chronicles as markers of distinct prophetic “roles.”
Seventeen episodes within 1-2 Chronicles describe some kind of prophetic activity, and from these seventeen passages, eight data points are extracted and summarized (the speaker’s name, the prophetic title, the addressee(s), any parallel accounts in Samuel-Kings, a description of the divine element within the intermediation, the prophetic function of the
message, the historical context, and the theological message). A number of discernible patterns are then revealed through this process: 1) Prophetic activity takes place occasionally at the popular level, but only through possession by the spirit (rûaḥ), and those involved are never given a title. 2) At the institutional level, prophets entitled nābîʾ are primarily concerned with cultic transgressions, and seem to be functionaries of the temple. 3) On the other hand, prophets described as ḥozeh address the king in private, and seem to be functionaries of the royal court.
The first of these patterns supports similar conclusions drawn by Yairah Amit (2006) and William Schniedewind (2009), but the distinction between “titled” prophets operating at the institutional level has yet to be recognized in published scholarship. Within 1-2 Chronicles, this “role” distinction is critical to understanding the Chronicler’s description of three Levitical singers as ḥozeh. As a title for a functionary of the royal court, the filling of these roles would amount to a re-establishment of the para-monarchic institutions under the Chronicler’s distinctively priestly program of restoration.
|
Jesus Itinerancy: Voluntary or Forced?
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Halvor Moxnes, University of Oslo
Jesus as the itinerant preacher has been a common motif in Historical Jesus studies from Schleiermacher on, and Gerd Theissen with his Soziologie der Jesusbewegung (The First Followers of Jesus,1977) securely established it. Most studies have taken for granted that this itinerancy was the result of a voluntary decision by Jesus. A recent study by Adriana Destro and Mauro Pesce (Encounters with Jesus. The Man in his Place and Time, 2011) places Jesus itinerancy in the context of the anthropology of itinerancy, and compares it to other forms of travel. Recently this consensus has been criticized by R.J. Myles (The Homeless Jesus in the Gospel of Matthew, 2014), for overlooking socio-economic forces and pressures. This paper will discuss the various positions. On the basis of the evidence in the gospels it suggests that there may have been an interaction of voluntary decisions, e.g. the conflicts that Jesus sparked, and communal reactions and structural forces.
|
Interpretation and Illegibility in Early Jewish Literature
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Eva Mroczek, University of California-Davis
|
Planting Gardens: Reflections on an Evocative Adjustment to a Trope in Jeremiah 29
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Joseph W. Mueller, Fuller Theological Seminary (Pasadena)
The version of the “building and planting” conceptual pair found in Jeremiah 29:5 differs from the standard trope used elsewhere within the Hebrew Bible, in that it is the only example in which the object to be planted is a garden. Rather than simply a case of stylistic variation, awareness of the exilic community’s southern Mesopotamian context helps illuminate this alteration. Two mutually inclusive historical factors could have influenced the change. First, Jeremiah’s exhortation could account for the community’s agricultural context in Babylonia, as they would have cultivated date orchards rather than vineyards. By planting such gardens, the exiles would participate in the shifting trend toward horticulture during the long sixth century, thereby contributing to the shalom of the region. Second, this form shares language with certain royal inscriptions of Esarhaddon which recount the rebuilding of Babylon. This creates a second point of contact between Jer 29 and Esarhaddon, as the relationship between references to a seventy-year exile in both these inscriptions and in Jer 29:10 has been previously explored. The legitimacy of the latter option would lend support to the literary coherence of Jer 29:5–14, while the former suggests a sixth-century provenance for the passage.
|
The Editio Critica Maior of Revelation: New Developments, Retrospects, and Prospects
Program Unit: Novum Testamentum Graecum: Editio Critica Maior
Darius Müller, Protestant University Wuppertal/Bethel
This paper is co-authored by Peter Malik.
Since 2011, the team at the Institut für Septuaginta- und biblische Textforschung, housed at the Kirchliche Hochschule Wuppertal/Bethel, have been preparing the Editio Critica Maior volume of the book of Revelation. In the present paper, we report on the general progress of the project so far, and comment on the prospects for its current, penultimate phase. More specifically, we shall give an overview of the nature and challenges of the most recently completed task, namely transcription and reconciliation of the Greek witnesses to be cited in the ECM. Furthermore, we shall discuss the process of citing versional and patristic evidence, followed by more general remarks on the challenges of building a critical apparatus for our edition. Plans and prospects for the coming years of the project will be briefly outlined in closing.
|
Joshua's Death and the Transition to the Period of the Judges
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Reinhard Müller, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
The narrative transition from Joshua's death (Josh 24:29-30//Judg 2:8-9) and the death of the conquest's generation (Judg 2:10; cf. Josh 24:31) to the period of the judges (Judg 2:11-13) poses most intricate problems for literary historical reconstruction. The paper addresses this "compositional knot" (Erhard Blum) by focusing on Judg 2:6-13. Starting with the textual transmission, it investigates which traces of literary growth can be detected in this section. It reconstructs the development of this transitional passage in relation to its parallel in Josh 24:28-31 and contextualizes its literary strata within the Pentateuch and the Former Prophets. As a result, it is demonstrated that Judg 2:8-9, 11, which probably contain the core of Judg 2:6-13, were a genuine part of the original transition from the conquest narrative to the deuteronomistic framework of Judges; additions that were secondarily inserted into this short passage, including a conspicuous cross-reference to Exod 1:6, 8, open further literary horizons.
|
Jacob of Sarug and Yannai on the Tower of Babel
Program Unit: History and Literature of Early Rabbinic Judaism
Ophir Münz-Manor, Open University of Israel
Recent scholarship on late antique Jewish and Christian poetry has emphasized the importance of the performative context within which these poems took place. Unlike the commentary, late antique poetry aimed to retell the biblical text in dramatic terms, with an emphasis on visuality, soundscape and recurring addresses to the audience. At the same time these poems contain - even if implicitly - exegetical interpretations to the to the biblical stories that they reflect on.
In our papers we examine liturgical poems by two sixth century poets: Yannai (writing in Hebrew) and Jacob of Sarugh (writing in Syriac) on the biblical story of the Tower of Babel. We exemplify how the performative context of the poems molds their literary and rhetoric facets and examine as well how the exegetical becomes part of the poetic.
The papers also emphasize the unique nature of liturgical poetry vis-à-vis rabbinic and patristic literatures. Whereas the latter have had a distinct scholarly orientation, intended for a specific audience consisting primarily of learned men, liturgical poems aimed at a much more diverse constituency. Finally, the papers demonstrate the importance of comparative study of late antique liturgical poetry as well as the benefits of a joint work of scholars from the various traditions.
|
The Almost Absent Antichrist: Revelation in the Writings of Cyprian of Carthage
Program Unit: Contextualizing North African Christianity
Edwina Murphy, Morling College
Given that Cyprian was bishop of Carthage during a time of persecution, one would expect him to make extensive use of the book of Revelation. And he did draw on it quite frequently, but the results are not what one might at first expect. Rather than focusing on the terrors of the beast, or the tribulations of the end time, or even the final heavenly hope, Cyprian’s attention is turned in another direction. Many of his citations relate to the person of Christ, supporting testimonies in Ad Quirinum. He also uses Revelation to warn of the dangers of worshipping idols and to encourage perseverance to attain a crown. He even manages to demonstrate that women ought not dye their grey hair (with assistance from Rev 1:14a). But the two passages he most frequently uses in his letters and treatises are maxims: “Remember from where you have fallen and do penance” (Rev 2:5a) and “I am the one who searches the heart and reins” (Rev 2:23).
The first is particularly useful in the early controversy surrounding the lapsed—they should patiently entreat God rather than clamouring to be readmitted immediately. Cyprian later returns to the text in Ep. 55 with a different emphasis, using it to prove that repentance is indeed possible. That God sees into people’s hearts has a wide range of applications, from warning those who have received certificates, to comforting those who fear dying from the plague rather than martyrdom, to noting that it is not necessary to pray out loud.
This study shows the range of reading strategies Cyprian uses in appropriating the Apocalypse, particularly the importance of maxims. It also reveals the variety of uses to which he can put a given text, depending upon the situation he is addressing. Finally, it demonstrates Cyprian’s focus on the revelation of divine truth and the implications for Christian living rather than speculative interpretation.
|
Searching for Children in Second-Temple Sectarian Literature
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
James Murphy, South Dakota State University
Biblical texts characterize raising children as central to the theology of ancient Israel. Yet, individuals such as the Baptist, Jesus, Paul, and perhaps others may have challenged, if ever so briefly, the central place of children, and recent work on Q may confirm this.
This paper will present an initial foray into a small selection of Second-Temple sectarian texts. Texts such as 1 Enoch and Jubilees retell foundational stories. These will be read against the Masoretic Text and Septuagint to explore potential rhetorical or ideological alterations in stories relevant for childist studies. A central purpose will be to determine whether we can detect any change in the theology or ideology of Jewish families or children that may shed light on first-century ascetic practitioners.
|
Q's Childless Utopia-Do Gendered Couplets Negate the Limited Evidence for Children among Q Insiders?
Program Unit: Q
James Murphy, South Dakota State University
William Arnal has argued that Q utilizes gendered couplets as a stylistic feature comparable to legal formulations elsewhere. Therefore, egalitarian claims for Q derived from references to the female gender may be ill-advised. Approaching Q from childist-studies (an emerging field, similar to feminist studies), this paper argues that the presence of gendered couplets in Q problematizes the few number of references to non-adult children. Q sets forth a world basically devoid of real non-adult children among insiders. If Q's ideal world was childless, could it's actual world have been so for a time?
|
Wait, You Want Me to Do What? Writing Prompts with Bible Odyssey
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Kelly Murphy, Central Michigan University
The syllabi for the Senior Capstone course that I often teach includes, in part, the following: "In order to meet the requirements of this course, each student will write a substantial research paper of at least 25 pages on a topic devised by the student, demonstrating a command of academic theory and practice in the discipline." Research paper? No problem. The students have already done similar work in previous classes. Academic theory and practice in the study of religion? Again, no problem. Many students have already started to integrate theory and practice into their own work in previous classes. But the phrase "on a topic devised by the student" often creates immediate panic. Most of the students I teach have never had to develop their own prompt based entirely on their own academic interests. Rather than excitement, the idea of having to do so often generates fear. In this paper, I will detail an in-class exercise I use that demonstrates one way to integrate articles from www.bibleodyssey.org in order to help students think about creating their own prompts for research papers. This exercise models, in miniature, the steps students might need to take in order to find their research question, move from their question to discovering appropriate resources, and, finally, to developing their thesis. In addition, I will consider how the exercise might be extended by using other online resources such as https://thetorah.com. Finally, I will offer suggestions on implementing the exercise and the use of these resources in various classroom settings beyond a capstone course.
|
Debts, Descendants, and Deuteronomy
Program Unit: Economics in the Biblical World
Kelly Murphy, Central Michigan University
Many of the laws in the book of Deuteronomy that involve economic issues are especially concerned with children, both sons and daughters. This paper will examine the role that children, and particularly sons, play in the economic world created by Deuteronomy and in select texts often identified as inspired by deuteronomic theology. In particular, the paper will explore questions of how economics and masculinity intertwine in the education of boys and young men in these texts, as well as how such issues might be connected to debates about royal economies and clan-based economies.
|
“How Blessed Will Be the One Who Repays You”: Finding a Place for Imprecation in Preaching
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Meghan Musy, Southeastern University
The psalms display the finitude of humanity in their laments and desperate prayers for
deliverance. They give voice to the deepest groanings of the human experience and raise their
voices in confrontation of and trust in Yahweh. The blunt and confrontational cries of why? and
how long? and the crude pleas of imprecation are brought before God. Walter Brueggemann, in
his article “The Costly Loss of Lament,” advocates for the contemporary use of lament. He
asserts that lament is between two parties, the petitioner and Yahweh, and that the integration of
lament in ecclesial communities provides a voice for victims and a challenge to present
circumstances. W. Derek Suderman, builds on Brueggemann’s argument to highlight the social
aspect of lament and further explores the value of lament for Christians today. However, neither
scholar adequately addresses the challenge the imprecatory psalms pose. Can imprecation be
integrated into ecclesial circles? Pain, suffering, and injustice are part of the human experience.
Today, reports of violence, depravity, and disasters are broadcast around the world. ISIS attacks,
genocides, racial issues, and cries against systemic injustice seem to call for imprecation.
However, can one sing imprecatory psalms while harmonizing with a Christian ethic, an ethic
that advocates love of enemy? This paper will explore the place of imprecation in ancient Israel
and its function within the Psalter before turning to an exploration of the place of imprecatory
psalms, like Ps 137, in preaching. This paper will address how Christians may read these psalms
as Scripture. Can the cries for violence against the other be preached?
|
Conservatism, Identity Boundaries, and National (In)security
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
Siti Sarah Muwahidah, Emory University
The Salafi-takfiri movement has popularized conservative values and narratives into the everyday discourse in Indonesia. Since 2014, three prominent campaigns were led by the takfiri movement, namely an anti-Shi'a, an anti-LGBT and an anti-Chinese/foreign influence, which create moral panics and lead to discrimination and violence against these groups. Here, I interrogate how the takfiri propaganda has been so effective and appealing. Using metaphor and boundaries theories, I investigate: (1) Select metaphors used by the radical Muslim groups in their campaigns against Shi'ism, LGBT people, and the Chinese. (2) How those metaphors introduce boundaries across sectarian, gender and citizenship identities that were not compatible with the notion of fluid and porous boundaries of the pre-colonial Southeast Asian imagination. (3) How this successful propaganda help the radical Salafi-takfiri groups surpass their previous, "dangerous-extremist" image and put them in the center of Indonesian Muslims' fights to protect both Islamic purity and "national security."
|
A Qualitative Onomastic Method for Identifying the Relationship between Ge'ez Manuscripts and the Greek Traditions, Illustrated from the Text of Ezra-Nehemiah
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Pete Myers, University of Cambridge
The Ge'ez Bible likely began as a translation from Greek sources, perhaps in the 4th century AD. The Ge'ez tradition underwent various developments in transmission, which may have included adjustment toward Hebrew Vorlagen. Since the earliest Ge'ez manuscripts for most of the Bible date to the 15th century, reconstructing the history of the Ge'ez tradition, and more precisely describing its relationship to the Greek and Hebrew sources, must be done primarily on the basis of features in the Ge'ez text. Applying principles developed during a study of the Greek text of Ezra-Nehemiah, this paper describes a qualitative onomastic method for identifying the relationship between Ge'ez manuscripts and the Greek traditions. The spelling of non-Greek and non-Ge'ez names are not fixed by the grammar of Greek and Ge'ez, and therefore changes in their spellings can be used to map the relationships between different manuscripts. Such data are particularly relevant in corpora such as Ezra-Nehemiah that contain large lists of names. There are, however, various factors that must be qualitatively weighed in order to make effective use of these data and avoid false conclusions. It is these factors that this paper will describe and illustrate.
|
Jesus' Itinerancy and Individual Exceptionalism
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Robert Myles, Murdoch University
Why assume Jesus' itinerancy was a "chosen lifestyle" rather than a consequence of the social and political volatility of first-century Palestine? This paper demonstrates how historical Jesus research has repeatedly framed Jesus' itinerancy in ways that accentuate his individual agency and exceptionalism. Although scholars have situated Jesus within a complex socioeconomic and religio-cultural environment, he often appears entrepreneurial, possessing a curious ability to transcend social and economic forces normally affecting other peasant artisans. For example, he voluntarily "chooses" to become itinerant, jobless, marginal, and so on, and this dimension of his social existence, and its relation to wider socioeconomic forces, remains arguably under-theorized. I will suggest this omission fits comfortably alongside capitalist ideology. Indeed, the neoliberal lives of Jesus have at times championed Jesus' itinerancy as a fixture of his "counter-cultural" and "subversive" predisposition without adequately exploring the ways in which subversion is rendered gestural and contained within broader ideological systems.
|
Three Interrogative Hes in the Torah That Are Not Interrogative
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Daniel Mynatt, University of Mary Hardin-Baylor
He Interrogative is a linguistic feature in Biblical Hebrew that distinguishes a sentence as a question. It is roughly the Hebrew equivalent to a question mark. In this paper, I will review how words with He Interrogative are treated by the Masorah. Then, I will discuss a curious Mp note found on Genesis 18:25 of the Rabbinic Bible: “Three hes in the Torah that appear to be interrogative but they are not interrogative.”
|
Philological Reflections: Subject Formation and Practices of Reading in Jewish Antiquity
Program Unit: Philology in Hebrew Studies
Hindy Najman, University of Oxford
This paper conceives of reading practices as part of the formation of the subject through practices of editing, refining, expanding and rewriting texts across Jewish antiquity and in the context of ancient Greek and Latin practices of reading and interpreting .I will problematize the formation of the subject by asking if we are able to constitute and characterize the subject in Jewish Antiquity. When we speak of the “self” or the “subject”, are we speaking of a suffering within the subject through a kind of transformation? Or is this a training of the subject and the soul that is self-imposed and emerging in place of temple structures around rituals associated with repentance or self-correction? Are we guilty of anachronistic imposition of the scholar or of imposing our contemporary, philosophical narrative onto the narrative of ancient Jewish texts? I trace what I believe to be an organic movement in the formation of the subject in ancient Jewish prayers which exemplify self-reflection and discourses about wisdom/knowledge/insight which are fundamentally concerned with idealized experiences of being whole, pure, separate, and perfect (or at least imitative of God). Furthermore, I will consider what we might mean by the “subject” in what I want to call “the philological challenge”. How, in light of the problem of anachronism or untimeliness, should we characterize the self in ancient Judaism? To what extent should we regard terms such as nefesh, adam, ‘ish, leb - or nous and psyche, and others as equivalents of “subject”? I will reflect on the distinctiveness and range of each linguistic register. Is this subject “individual” or, as I will argue is it better conceived of as a collective?
|
Between Canons and Margins: Rethinking Pseudepigraphy and Biblical Composition
Program Unit: Development of Early Christian Theology
Hindy Najman, University of Oxford
This paper considers the question of canon and authorization. What constitutes canon and when was it constituted? What about new texts that were discovered that were not included into canons that were shaped centuries after? Should we or can we authenticate new texts or texts that were not known to be part of the canon? What about texts that were rejected from the canon? How and why might we reconsider the status of texts - and can we authenticate such texts that would otherwise be considered profane? It is a paper which rethinks “marginal” texts, the translation of the profane and the sacred, and the constitution of “canon.”
|
The Relationship between Gentiles and Torah in Matthew 28:18–20: End-Time Proselytes, Righteous Gentiles, or New People?
Program Unit: Matthew
Hojin Nam, Toronto School of Theology
Matthew 28:18-20 with its reference to making disciples of πάντα τὰ ἔθνη is ambiguous in its attitude towards Gentiles and their relationship to the Torah. The text can be read such that the new Gentile believers in Jesus might be incorporated into the blessings of the God of Israel by affirming the Torah in full force, or such that the Gentiles might become associated with the blessings of God as Gentiles by affirming the law that pertains to them. Given the Jewish orientation of Matthew’s Gospel and its Jewish influence, I suggest that the various attitudes towards the Torah and Gentiles within Second-Temple Judaism provide the basic framework for understanding Matthew’s view on the law and Gentiles.
A comparative study of how Matthew lines up with the contemporary Jewish literature—which also wrestles with the terms of Gentile inclusion—will help us get a better sense of his unique view on the Torah and Gentiles. Since Matthew 28:18-20 deals with the law, Gentiles, and eschatology, this paper will focus on eschatological redemption texts from Second-Temple Judaism for comparison with Matthew. I will compare and contrast Matthew with the Book of Tobit and Sibylline Oracles 3 with regard to an issue: the relationship between Gentiles and the Torah in the eschatological age.
This paper will demonstrate how a comparative study helps us uncover Matthew’s unique understanding of the relationship between Gentiles and the Torah in the eschatological age (Mt 28:18-20). The outcomes of the comparison locate Matthew somewhere between Tobit and Sibylline Oracles 3. While the Jews may be assumed to keep the ethnic-specific laws, the larger community of Jews and Gentiles are obliged to practice the ethical and monotheistic aspects of the Torah.
|
From Paul to St. Longinus the Roman Soldier: Acts, Jews, and the Roman Empire
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Laura Nasrallah, Harvard University
This paper takes up Paul’s depiction in Acts and its effects in that late first or early second century CE text. It also investigates a later text of Pseudo-Hesychius of Jerusalem that takes up the form and vocabulary of the story of Paul’s conversion in Acts and applies them to Longinus, said to have been the Roman soldier who lanced Jesus at this death. The paper thus investigates a particular strand of a long story of Jews, Christians, Romans, and various kinds of imperial power from the first century to late antiquity, and the peculiar twist of anti-Judaism that emerges as some Christians reflect upon oppressive state power, and then Christians themselves become empire.
|
Christological Hymns in an Ancient Perspective: What We Can Learn from Embedded Prose Hymns in Non-Christian Sources
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Dan Nässelqvist, Lund University
Since the apex of the redaction-critical identification of Christological hymns in the New Testament, a growing number of scholars have criticized the manner in which hymns have been identified. They have argued that some of the passages involved should be understood as rhetorical, rather than poetic, compositions. As a result, these passages are now often described as prose hymns, i.e. compositions of epideictic rhetoric which praise a god. Despite this fact, few scholars have heeded the call of Edgar Krentz that the embedded nature of the hymnic passages in the New Testament calls for an exploration of other embedded prose hymns from the same period. This lack of comparative examples has resulted in a situation in which the redactional-critical description of Christological hymns for many remains the only viable option, even though it has been heavily criticized (and rightly so).
This paper analyses two prose hymns roughly contemporary with the New Testament, in Josephus’ Against Apion and Epictetus’ Discourses. It demonstrates how both conform to ancient theory on the composition of prose hymns and are thus identifiable as prose hymns to ancient and modern readers alike. It then explores how these prose hymns suggest a different perspective for the study of supposed Christological hymns in the New Testament. It draws conclusions about how the incorporation of at least some New Testament passages (such as Col 1:1–15 and 1 Tim 3:16) within the category of ancient prose hymns affect our view of their authorship, structure, genre, and practical use.
|
Christological Hymns as Ancient Prose Hymns: Rhetorical Features of Embedded Prose Hymns in Non-Christian Sources
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Dan Nässelqvist, Lund University
Since the apex of the redaction-critical identification of Christological hymns in the New Testament, a growing number of scholars have criticized the manner in which hymns have been identified. They have argued that some of the passages involved should be understood as rhetorical, rather than poetic, compositions. As a result, these passages are now often described as prose hymns, i.e. compositions of epideictic rhetoric which praise a god. Despite this fact, few scholars have heeded the call of Edgar Krentz that the embedded nature of the hymnic passages in the New Testament calls for an exploration of other embedded prose hymns from the same period. This lack of comparative examples has resulted in a situation in which the redactional-critical description of Christological hymns for many remains the only viable option, even though it has been heavily criticized (and rightly so).
This paper analyses two prose hymns roughly contemporary with the New Testament, in Josephus’ Against Apion and Epictetus’ Discourses. It demonstrates how both conform to ancient rhetorical theory on the composition of prose hymns and are thus identifiable as prose hymns to ancient and modern readers alike. It then explores how these prose hymns suggest a different perspective for the composition and interpretation of supposed Christological hymns in the New Testament. It draws conclusions about how the incorporation of at least some New Testament passages (such as Phil 2:6–11 and Col 1:1–15) within the category of ancient prose hymns affect our view of their authorship, rhetorical composition, genre, and practical use.
|
Testing Testimony in the Additions to Daniel
Program Unit: Book of Daniel
Matthew Neujahr, Marquette University
The Book of Daniel presents a number of portraits of its protagonist: perfectly pious diaspora youth; courtly sage and royal advisor; dream interpreter; apocalyptic seer. However a further portrayal is often overlooked: in the independent “additions” of Susanna and Bel et Draco, we see a further Daniel emerge: the crime-solving sleuth. In Susanna, neither God nor an angel intervenes directly to save the heroine from the plotting elders. Instead, Daniel rises up after receiving some kind of divine spirit and thus works to save Susanna not by any miraculous means, but by disproving the testimony of the elders by questioning them separately. I argue that there is a gesture toward the distinction between deductive logic and oracular logic during the questioning of the witnesses: after each witness answers, what follows is an oracular pronouncement (which I suggest its linked to a background of oracular trees in ancient Greek and Hellenistic Jewish culture). Nevertheless, despite these authoritative declarations, the witnesses are still invalidated through logic and punished through law.
In the story of Bel, Daniel again takes up the mantle of mystery solver. That the ever pious Daniel seeks to prove that his God is god alone occasions no surprise. But here there is no heavenly intervention proving the might of the Lord. Elsewhere this is explicitly the case, as in Daniel’s escape from a fiery furnace (chapter 3) or from ravenous lions (ch. 6 and the ending to Draco), to say nothing of his divinely granted ability to perceive another’s hidden thoughts (ch. 2) or see visions of the future (ch. 7-12). Instead, the Daniel of Bel is concerned with uncovering Babylonian priestly shenanigans by purely deductive means, providing observers with tangible evidence of the priests’ deception. While the ending of Bel et Draco as a unit does in fact return to the miraculous power of the Lord, the self-contained narrative of Bel itself completely eschews the miraculous in favor of the evidentiary and mundane.
This interest in deductive truth finding in both these stories stands in contract to the more overtly supernaturally attuned Daniel of both the court tales and visions. Indeed, neither contemporary Second Temple literature nor the Greek novel show a particular interest in deductive logic. We suggest that Daniel's name (God judges) and function as sage (1:17; 5:11,14; 11:33) provided a unique impetus for Hellenistic Jewish writers to experiment with persuasive legal rhetoric popular at the time, which emphasized the art of evidence and refutation.
|
Hope for Zion: Prophecy of Salvation in the Book of the Twelve and Its Reception in Late Psalms
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Friederike Neumann, Carl von Ossietzky Universität Oldenburg
At several places, the Book of the Twelve predicts a new time of salvation for Zion / Jerusalem. Especially, it announces new agricultural success, growth and fruitfulness of the fields, overabundant food. From mount Zion, Yhwh will change the desolate situation of his people and lead them to new prosperity.
In current research on the Book of the Twelve, several scholars put forward the assumption that such words of salvation trace back to broader redactional reworkings of the Book of the Twelve, which affected several books at the same time. For example, Jakob Wöhrle introduced the hypothesis of a Joel-Corpus comprising the books of Joel, Amos, Micah, and Zephaniah. The redactors responsible for this corpus created the primary layer of the book of Joel in Joel 1-2* and added small words of salvation at the end of the subsequent books in Amos 9:13-15; Mic 7:8-10; Zeph 3:14-17.
The paper will further investigate this idea of a Joel-Corpus. Especially, against the background of new insights into the history of the Persian time, it will explicate in more detail the historical background of this corpus. Like new archaeological studies could show, the Persian time was a time of ongoing drought, which led to the desolate situation of the people. And exactly this seems to be the background of the Joel-Corpus and its hope for new agricultural success. The pictures of hope for endless rain and new fruitfulness in Judah presented in the Joel-Corpus can be read as counterfactual statements of hope put forward against the current desolate situation of the people.
In the second part of the paper, it will be shown that, interestingly enough, late psalms stemming from the later Hellenistic time (Ps 81; 147) build upon exactly these texts brought into the Book of the Twelve on the level of the Joel-Corpus. Against the background of this new time, which again was a time of economic distress, these Psalms take up the vision of hope presented in the older prophetic texts, the hope that Yhwh from Zion acts for his people, brings new blessing and leads his people to new agricultural success.
Thus, the paper shows and explains, how the authors responsible for the Joel-Corpus brought into the growing Book of the Twelve a specific perspective of hope and how the potential of hope, which was now part of the Book of the Twelve, became effective in a comparable situation of a later time.
|
The Intertextual Memory of Mark 1:11
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
James M. Neumann, Princeton Theological Seminary
With good reason, the dominant reading of Mark 1:11 among scholars understands the words σύ εἶ ὁ υἱός μου ὁ ἀγαπητός, ἐν σοί εὐδόκησα as a conflation of Ps 2:7 and Isa 42:1. Accordingly, this acclamation is generally read in the vein of a messianic annointing. Nevertheless, some scholars have observed that the words of Mark 1:11 evoke other passages also, such as Exod 4:22–23; Deut 1:31; Hos 11:1; Jer 2:2; and 31:9, all of which refer to Israel as God's son. Generally absent from such lists, however, is Jer 38:20 LXX (31:20 MT/ET): the only passage in the LXX containing the precise phrase υἱός ἀγαπητός. Jer 38:20 LXX also shares certain syntactical features in common with Mark 1:11. Jeffrey Gibbs and John Paul Heil offer two exceptions to the rule above, but at the expense of proffering Jer 38:20 LXX over against Ps 2:7. Additionally, Albert the Great suggested Jer 31:20 as a parallel to Matthew's baptismal voice. Such considerations merit further inquiry.
In the present piece, I offer a new approach to this intertextual question grounded in Umberto Eco's concept of the "cultural encyclopedia." In plain terms, I seek to answer the question of what Mark's first century readers would have heard in the divine declaration at Jesus' baptism. After attending to some preliminary matters, I first trace the exodus tradition within which Jer 38:20 LXX calls Israel God's "beloved son" and its continued prominence throughout the Second Temple period and beyond. The historical data suggests the tradition of Israel's sonship formed what one might call a cultural memory, which could in turn be cued by the term "beloved son." In the second stage of my argument, I then locate numerous indicators of precisely the same tradition in Mark 1:1–13. Thus, Mark 1:11 and Jer 38:20 LXX prove to be engaged within the same tradition, or cultural memory. Finally, narrative cues throughout Mark 1:1–10 condition the reader to expect the presence of Israel in some form or fashion at v. 11, so much so its absence would conceivably amount to an inexplicable anticlimax to an attuned first century reader.
My proposal ultimately contends for the likelihood of a polyvalent designation in the "voice from heaven" in 1:11. Mark appears to allude to Ps 2:7; Isa 42:1; and Jer 38:20 LXX simultaneously, so as to signal both a messianic anointing and the fulfillment of Israel's destiny via a new exodus. Above all, this paper is an attempt to reconstruct the cultural encyclopedia of Mark and his first century audience, so as to hear in the text all that was present for the author and earliest readers alike.
|
Faith in the Foreskin: Rethinking the Male Anatomy of Paul’s Circumcision Language
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Karin Neutel, University of Oslo
Paul’s attitude towards circumcision is a continued subject of interest for Pauline scholars. Most recently, the notion that Paul is critical of circumcision in general has been challenged and a case has been made that he only opposed proselyte circumcision of gentiles, not eight-day circumcision of Jews (Thiessen 2011; Nanos 2015; Neutel 2016). However, the significance of one particular aspect of Paul’s circumcision language has so far been largely overlooked: his remarkable use of the term ‘foreskin’, akrobustia. Paul uses this term 16 times in his letters, such as when he describes Abraham as being ‘in foreskin’ (Rom. 4,10) or calls his own message ‘good news for the foreskin’ (Gal. 2,7, also Gal. 5,6; 6,15; Rom. 2,25-29; 3,29-30, 4,9-12; 1 Cor. 7,18-19). Translations and interpretations of Paul’s letters tend to obscure both the physical and the gendered nature this term by reading it as ‘uncircumcised’, or ‘uncircumcision’, as if it referred to the absence of a practice, rather than to a part of the male anatomy. Since Paul is unique among Greek authors of his time in using ‘foreskin’ in this metaphorical and emphatic way, the term most likely stood out as exceptional to readers and listeners, especially non-Jews. While some scholars have noted Paul’s unusual language (esp. Kahl 2000; Livesey 2010; Nanos 2015), there has been as yet no comprehensive effort to think through what Paul’s use of this term means for his ideas about circumcision, gentiles and gender. This paper will show that the use of akrobustia confirms recent insights that Paul is focussed on the circumcision of gentile men, not Jewish boys. While the translation ‘uncircumcised’ suggests that the question central to Paul is whether or not to circumcise, reading ‘foreskin’ makes it clear that gentile male genitals are the issue. The emphasis on foreskin further suggests that Paul’s message was thoroughly androcentric, as well as circumcision-centric. Dividing people into ‘circumcision’ and ‘foreskin’, turned male genital anatomy into the signifier of ethno-religious status. If Paul was concerned about the position of women, as some interpreters have claimed, there is no evidence of that in his approach to this central issue; women appear to be implicitly subsumed in the category ‘foreskin’. Evidence of his deeply circumcision-centric view can also be seen in Rom. 4,10-11, where Paul suggests that Abraham was circumcised because he had a foreskin, when he trusted God. He was ‘not in circumcision, but in foreskin’ and ‘received circumcision as a sign, a seal of the righteousness of the faith that was in the foreskin’ (Rom. 4,11). The inclusion of foreskinned men into God’s people, into the children of Abraham, was for Paul the ultimate eschatological sign, a sign with a male anatomy.
|
Joy in the Lukan Infancy Narrative: The Emotional Overtones of Zechariah’s Speech(lessness)
Program Unit: Gospel of Luke
Julie Newberry, Duke University
More than one scholar refers to the Gospel of Luke as the “Gospel of joy,” and not without reason. Though Luke 15 arguably boasts the highest concentration of “joy” terms per chapter in Luke-Acts, Luke 1 comes in as a close second for this distinction. However, as in Luke 15, not every character in Luke’s opening chapter finds it easy to welcome joyous circumstances with appropriate joy (cf. 15:25-32). To the contrary, Zechariah initially responds to good news in a way that Gabriel (and presumably Luke) find(s) deeply inadequate, leading to a punitive silencing that, as others have noted, effectively postpones any rejoicing on Zechariah’s part (cf. 1:14). Perhaps due to the tendency to focus on Mary's jubilation, studies of joy in Luke’s infancy narrative sometimes overlook the complications that attend Zechariah’s rejoicing. Nevertheless, his fraught case plays an important role, precisely in its messiness, in advancing Luke’s narrative construal of joy and what fosters it. As part of a larger project analyzing "joy" and the conditions—that is, the circumstances, dispositions, practices, and the like—that facilitate joy in Luke-Acts, this paper examines Zechariah’s temporary silencing with a focus on its emotional implications within Luke’s narrative. I argue that Zechariah embodies joylessness in his imposed silence and that, conversely, his eventual prophecy embodies joy, despite the absence of obvious joy terms in the Benedictus and in Luke’s introduction to it (1:67-79). My paper thus seeks to shed new light on Luke’s characterization of Zechariah while also contributing to ongoing discussions about issues such as (1) the relationship between embodiment and emotion in biblical literature and (2) the methodological questions that attend attempts to identify emotion in biblical narratives.
|
Performing Mosaic Prophecy in the Scripturalization of Deuteronomy
Program Unit: Prophetic Texts and Their Ancient Contexts
Judith Newman, University of Toronto
In my book Before the Bible: The Liturgical Body and the Formation of Scriptures in Early Judaism (OUP 2018), I argue that a chief factor in the transformation of literature to scripture was through its performative entwinement with liturgical settings of study and worship. In this paper, I want to extend my argument to consider the process of the scripturalization of the book of Deuteronomy. I will consider, inter alia, the way in which the inclusion of the Song of Moses in Deut 32 and the Blessing of Moses in Deut 33 contributed to transforming a collection of laws and lore into the “incomparable” prophetic witness of Moses as scripture.
|
In Search of Cultural Models for Divine Spirit and Human Body in Ancient Israel
Program Unit: Philology in Hebrew Studies
Carol Newsom, Emory University
In Ezekiel 36-37 the prophet Ezekiel envisions the renewal of the people in a fashion that involves physical transformation. Although the replacement of the heart of stone with a heart of flesh appears to be a novel image, the placing of “my spirit” within the people seems to trope upon the motifs of the creation myth as it is envisioned in Genesis 2, even echoing some of the wording found there (Ezek 37:50. Later Qumran texts, notably the Hodayot, draw upon Ezekiel 36 as a prooftext for their own understanding of the role of divine spirit in a radical moral/spiritual transformation of the elect. While it is unlikely that there was ever a single, clearly defined cultural model in ancient Israel of how the divine spirit was implicated in human creation, existence, and qualitative differentiation, it is worth reviewing the extant evidence to see if it is possible to identify fragments at least of various cultural models. Was divine breath/spirit simply an initial generative impetus (Gen 2:7; Ps 104:29) or was it conceived of as somehow substantive and subject to removal, more or less intact (Gen 6:3; Qoh 3:21)? Were there different models of the relationship between the divine spirit and the human body, such that when the body was envisioned as a vessel or container, the divine spirit was seen as entering into it or filling it in ways that had implications for the understanding of the very nature of the self (Gen 41:38; Exod 31:3; Ezek 36:27; Job 32:8; Dan 5:11, 14)? And when the body was construed as a simple entity, was the divine spirit envisioned as interacting with it as an external agent, “seizing, cloaking, resting upon” or otherwise affecting it from outside (Num 11:17; Judg 3:10; 6:34; Ezek 11:5; Joel 3:1; etc.)? Why might these engagements with the divine spirit be construed in such different fashion? Our efforts to understand are, of course, limited by the nature of our sources. But even posing the questions and arranging the fragmentary evidence in provisional categories may assist us in framing hypotheses about the anthropology of ancient Israel.
|
Tamar: Levirate Widow; The Story from the Inside
Program Unit: Genesis
Rosalie Ní Mhaoldomhnaigh, University of Cambridge
The primary theme of Genesis 38:1-26, originally an independent story, is that of levirate marriage. As the story evolves it becomes clear that Tamar is the only character totally committed to the realization of a levirate union but the narrative reveals little about Tamar’s motivation and feelings. She is conspicuous by her silence and passivity. In tracing Tamar’s situation from the initial arrangement of her marriage to Er to her final success in becoming pregnant by means of an unorthodox levir, this paper explores the story from Tamar’s perspective. It does so by drawing on the information supplied in the text and in other parts of the bible, on our knowledge of ANE culture, and on our understanding of human nature, which in many respects has changed very little in the last three thousand years. Accompanying Tamar through Genesis 38:1-26 offers a unique perspective on the events of the story. It becomes clear how limited her choices were but it also illuminates some of the motivations which drove her. In this way Tamar emerges from the shadows where her largely mute and apparently passive role has placed her. This mute passivity makes all the more extraordinary her seduction of Judah and especially the subtle revenge which she exacts in a clever parody of the halitza ceremony. A focus on Tamar also casts new light on the role of the male participants in a levirate marriage - in this instance on Onan, Shelah and Judah - and reveals the unexpected complexities involved, if Tamar were to attempt to apply the rubrics of Deuteronomy 25:5-10 to her own situation.
|
Contested Spaces and the Colonized: A Senegalese Reading of Galatians 3:27–28
Program Unit: Polis and Ekklesia: Investigations of Urban Christianity
Aliou Cissé Niang, Union Theological Seminary in the City of New York
Colonial settlers often build cities where they introduce their civilization as normative for the colonized--a practice traceable from Greeks and Romans to French colonists in Senegal, West Africa. The Apostle Paul lived and preached in urban tenement house-churches to audiences variably affected by Roman imperial policies. This paper will explore two main questions. First, might Galatians 3:27-28 offer new insights into contested colonial spaces and identities? Put differently, might Roman imperial demands have forced some of the Pauline converts to choose margins as a site for negotiating life and create an identity shaped by their hopes? Second, might the French colonial missionaries’ preaching of Gal 3:27-28, from 1887-1960, in Senegal, West, Africa have had similar effects on the dwellers of cities founded by French colonists--urban centers called Les Quatres Communes du Sénégal “The Four Communes of Senegal”?
|
Water into Beer! Transformations of Biblical Miracles in Late Antique and Early Medieval Traditions
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Tobias Nicklas, Universität Regensburg
The idea that extra-canonical miracle stories are usually much more fanciful and full of absurd and fantastic details than the stories in the New Testament can still be found in handbooks on early Christian literature. The paper wants to show that this is not the case. Instead, the range of miracle stories in a certain writing has to do with the contexts, functions and intended audiences of the text. In some cases even the usual boundaries of genres - like Gospel literature and hagiographical literature which in some cases can both be understood as foundation narratives - can be of lesser relevance. The paper will offer a spectrum of examples from both late antique and early medieval literature, including a set of miracles by Saint Brigid from Ireland who turns water into beer - certainly a good idea in a country where grapes tend to remain sour.
|
Reception of Revelation in Video Games: The Case of Post-Apocalyptic First/Third Person Shooter Games
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Valérie Nicolet, Institut protestant de théologie, Paris
First/third person shooter video games (such as Fallout 4, Gears of War, Darksiders) have been analyzed for their theological implications, their rendering of the good versus evil battle and their apocalyptic settings. Scholars also explore how avatars create a God-perspective for the player involved in the game, especially when the player can control and organize the chaotic world he/she faces. In this paper, we are choosing to focus particularly on the hack and slash video game Darksiders. Its first edition was released in 2010, followed by a second instalment in 2012. The player is War, one of the four horsemen of the Apocalypse. Darksiders III is scheduled to be released in 2018 and introduces another horse[wo]man, Fury. The innovation in adding Fury to the cast of the four horsemen already highlights one of the aspects our paper aims to analyze, namely the way apocalyptic lore is used and expanded to construct the storyline of a game with direct references to the Apocalypse.
We will explore how the apocalyptic universe influences the game (for example the rules of play, the gamespace, the gameplay, the visual art of the game) and reflect on the understanding of apocalyptic drawn by the game, as well as on the appeal of apocalyptic scenario for games that combine hack and slash and survival. Darksider provides its own interpretation of apocalyptic material broadly elaborated from canonical and non-canonical literature (for example the importance of angels and fallen angels in Darksider, drawn from enochic literature), creating a mash up that calls for untangling and interpretation.
An implication of the paper is to reflect on the interactions that the video game provides to the player, who gets to be in the game and actively takes part in the story. This direct involvement might shed light on some of the effects of apocalyptic texts. Is part of the appeal of the video game the possibility to move in a universe where good and evil are clearly delineated? Apocalyptic literature is about interpreting present reality for its addressees and giving them clear behavioral guidelines which will make them active participants in the war between good and evil. Perhaps the apocalyptic storylines supporting games like Darksider can shed additional light on the possible ways in which apocalyptic texts (such as Revelation, but also 1 Enoch) could have functioned in ancient times, allowing their readers the space to fantasize their own participation in the end-time battles.
|
Man's Creation in the Image of God: A Rising Notion in Rabbinic Literature
Program Unit: Early Exegesis of Genesis 1–3
Maren Niehoff, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
The paper traces the development of the Biblical motif from the Mishna through the Tosefta to Genesis Rabbah, pointing to a remarkable lack of interest in the topic in the Mishna. The Tosefta addresses for the first time fundamental questions about human nature as well as heretical interpretations of the Biblical motif. These tendencies are fully developed in Genesis Rabbah, where Gen. 1.26 receives a complete section full of theological and philosophical queries. Moreover, the so-called heretical interpretations mentioned in Genesis Rabbah can be identified with Christian positions. The paper raises questions about the connection between the different rabbinic collections and their engagement with contemporary Christian exegesis.
|
Books and Religious Specialists in Kings
Program Unit: Book History and Biblical Literatures
Flemming A. J. Nielsen, Ilisimatusarfik (University of Greenland)
The story of king Josiah’s eighteenth regnal year (2 Kgs 22:3–23:27) is a story about the sudden appearance of the Book of the Law and a portrayal of the king in his capacity of being the ideal reader of the book. Not much is said about the origin of the book, only that it was “found” by Hilkiah the high priest. Designations such as the Book of the Covenant (23:2, 21) and the Law of Moses (23:25) as well as the book’s cache in Yahweh’s temple connect the finding with Deuteronomy’s story that Moses wrote such a book and that this book should be kept close to the ark of the covenant (Dtr 31:24-25). However, the origin of the book is not important to the implied author of Kings. Rather, he tells us how the ideal recipient of Hilkiah’s book should deal with it: He should study it carefully, believe in it and have it interpreted by a religious specialist (2 Kgs 22:8, 10-12). However, most of Josiah’s actual religious reforms are carried through without reference to the book (23:4-20). Only when Passover is introduced, reference is made to “this Book of the Covenant” (23:21). This is in line with most of the preaching and descriptions of religious reforms in Kings: Even though reference may be made to Moses and Yahweh’s commandments to Moses (2 Kgs 18:6), references to scripture are rare (1 Kgs 2:3). Most of the things that Yahweh demands from the king and his people are imparted orally by religious instructors such as prophets and Jehoiada the priest (2 Kgs 12:3). When a book is finally referred to, its contents must be verified by a prophet. I intend to reflect on this complicated relationship between books and religious specialists in Kings in their capacity as religious authorities.
|
Johannine Rituals
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Jesper Tang Nielsen, University of Copenhagen
It used to be an intense discussion whether or not the Fourth Gospel includes references to the ritual praxis in the early communities. Or rather, it was claimed that the unambiguous references to baptism and eucharist were not genuine Johaninne but derived from a later ecclesial redactor. For a number of reasons this position is completely obsolete and not defended by anyone. There is no reason for reviving it. But the basic model of explanation, namely that the Johannine references to rituals in the gospel relate actual praxis in the community, has not yet been tested in Johannine studies.
Especially concerning baptism and eucharist this is a relevant question. On the one hand, the Fourth Gospel undeniably refers to these specific rituals from the earliest community praxis. On the other hand, it presents them quite differently from other New Testament writings. This paper takes on the challenge to present the specific Johannine understanding of baptism and eucharist as it is presented in the Fourth Gospel; and to question the possible relation to rituals practiced in early Christian communities.
The paper consists of three parts. First, an exegetical interpretation of baptism and eucharist in the Fourth Gospel. New readings of the philosophical background for the Johannine concept of pneuma will form the basis for an interpretation of references to baptism and eucharist. In both cases the pneuma has the central role as the one that gives life. It happens in a rebirth through spirit and water (3:3.5) and through Jesus' flesh and blood (6:63).
In a second part of the paper this understanding of the rituals will be related to the Johannine understanding of worship in general. It will be shown how the concept of pneuma establishes a worship that is congruent with its object (4:22f). In the Fourth Gospel true worship takes place in the pneuma. Baptism incorporates the community members into that pneuma and the eucharist confirms their pneumatic identity. This enables them to participate in the worship in spirit and truth.
In the final part the question is raised whether this Johannine understanding of rituals has a counterpart in actual praxis in the earliest communities. From a comparison with the First Epistle of John and Pauline ritual texts it will be demonstrated that the Johannine understanding of rituals on the one hand relates to praxis in the earliest communities; on the other hand interprets this praxis in a specific philosophical way that does not match other New Testament writings. In the end, possible reminiscences of the Johannine understanding of rituals in later texts (e.g. Gospel of Philip) and in parts of ancient liturgies (e.g. the epiclesis of the Traditio apostolica) will be presented.
The paper contributes to the understanding of the diversity of rituals in Early Christianity and to the discussion of the relation between actual rituals and literary texts.
|
Pneumata in the Fourth Gospel
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Jesper Tang Nielsen, University of Copenhagen
For a few decades there has been very little talk of redactions, layers and sources in Johannine studies. This is with good reason. All too often, source and redaction criticism resulted in an incoherent and fragmented gospel that was incomprehensible in its present form. In order to counter these readings, narrative criticism and other contemporary approaches have been successful in understanding the Fourth Gospel as one narrative text and detecting its plot structures. Today, interpreters rarely question the coherence of the text. However, without returning to source criticism of old, it is worth asking if the focus on the unity of the Fourth Gospel has made exegetes neglect the tensions in the gospel that may derive from different sources of inspiration.
This paper will focus on the concept pneuma in the Johannine writings. It will show that the Fourth Gospel includes three different concepts of pneuma that have different functions in the narrative structure of the gospel. It will furthermore point to specific backgrounds for the three pneumata: The first one is Jesus’ possession of the pneuma from the incarnation to his death on the cross. It derives from the synoptic tradition, or more probably directly from the Gospel of Mark. The second one does not have parallels in the synoptic gospels. It concerns the role of the pneuma for the believers. All instances of this idea are connected with ritual praxis in the community and have remarkable relations to Paul. The third conception includes the Paraclete-sayings and is probably a genuine Johannine invention. It presents the pneuma-paraclete as an active figure that takes the place of the absent Jesus. In many ways it authorizes the gospel writing.
In sum, the corpus of the Fourth Gospel incorporates these three separate understandings of pneuma that cannot be reduced to one single concept. On the contrary, the different backgrounds of the Johannine pneumata create tensions in the gospel.
The paper is not classical source criticism. It does not only describe the tensions in the gospel and ascribe the different concepts to different sources. It explains why the evangelist did not find it problematic to include all three concepts in his gospel. Drawing on new readings of the philosophical context of the Fourth Gospel, the paper argues that the logos of the prologue must be understood in specific Stoic terms. According to the Stoic understanding, the logos is the cognitive side of the material pneuma. This concept is able to comprise all aspects of the Johannine pneuma-paraclete. Therefore, the evangelist was able to include the different ideas in his gospel. Consequently, the prologue should be understood as a philosophical introduction that makes the reader incorporate all three Johannine pneumata into one conception despite the tensions that appears.
|
Shed in Egypt and West-Semitic Deities: A Reexamination
Program Unit: Egyptology and Ancient Israel
Christophe Nihan, Université de Lausanne
This paper is part of a larger interdisciplinary project, comparing and contrasting the evidence for the god Shed in Egypt with possible parallels in the West-Semitic world. The origins of the god Shed in Egypt, and his possible connections with Western Asian deities, remains a disputed issue among Egyptologists. Various proposals have been made to connect the Egyptian Shed with a deity ŠD or ŠDY in the West-Semitic world (among recent proposals, see, e.g., Matoian 2015 for Ugarit, and Neumann 2016 for Israel), all of which raise however significant methodological problems. Based on a comprehensive reexamination of all the available evidence for Egypt (G. Lenzo) and the West-Semitic world (C. Nihan), the paper will make the following points: (1) representations of the god Shed in New Kingdom steles (when that god is first attested) evince clear Western Asian influence, especially as concerns his representation as “master of the animals”; (2) in the West-Semitic world, ŠD / ŠDY are originally two variant forms of the same divine name, which is already attested in Ugarit in the Late Bronze; despite some general parallels (such as the association with the hunt and the steppe), there is no evidence for a direct connection with, or derivation from, the god Shed in Egypt; (3) the divine name Shadday in the Hebrew Bible is a form of the same West-Semitic deity ŠD / ŠDY; the evidence for a derivation from Egyptian Shed is problematic and unsubstantiated.
|
How Literary Investigations Can or Cannot Integrate Archaeological Perspectives
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Christophe Nihan, Université de Lausanne
(no abstract)
|
“I Would Become Weak Like Anyone Else”: Reading Judges 16 as Sexual Violence
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Audrey M. Nissly, The University of Texas at Austin
Samson has long been viewed as a hypermasculine hero—he woos women, is prone to violent outbursts, and uses his superhuman strength to wreak havoc upon his enemies. Samson’s hair is the literary source of his masculinity and also functions as a visible phallic symbol within the narrative. He is, however, immediately feminized as a result of his game of sexual tug-of-war with Delilah. Her cutting of Samson’s hair voids his strength, sexual subjectivity, and masculine status, all of which he regains in a final act of brute strength after his hair grows back. Should the cutting of Samson’s hair be read as an act of sexual violence? Is it a story of rape or, at the very least, one of metaphorical castration? Sexual violence against males is an uncommon event in the Hebrew Bible, which leaves a noticeable lacuna of interpretive resources. A reading that privileges the performance of masculinity and femininity by both Samson and Delilah helps uncover textual cues that identify this story as one of sexual violence. While Samson and Delilah have been considered at length in previous scholarship, they are frequently analyzed individually in terms of their gendered performances. Highlighting the negotiation of their gendered experiences in relation to one another marks this narrative as one of sexual violence and provides a biblical resource for sexual violence enacted against males by females.
|
The Philistine–Egyptian relationships: Some Considerations
Program Unit: Egyptology and Ancient Israel
Andres Nõmmik, Helsingin Yliopisto - Helsingfors Universitet
In the beginning of the 12th century several polities in the Eastern Mediterranean collapsed. Egyptians blamed this collapse and the associated destruction on different groups of people, known by modern researchers as the “Sea Peoples”, of whom the Peleset are the most prominent. The well-known depiction of the Egyptian narrative is displayed on the walls of the Medinet Habu temple indicate that there were two battles during the 8th year of Ramses III. The Egyptians seemed to have won these battles and utterly defeated the enemies. However, the Peleset is connected to the Philistines who during the 12th century did settle in the region of the Palestine, which was up to that point controlled by Egypt.
The settlement of the Philistines considerably changed the political situation in the Southern Levant. Although it is likely that the Egyptians did actually encounter the Philistines, the results of these battles with the Sea Peoples are not as clear. Although Egyptians showed it as a complete victory, the Philistines took over the cities, several of which show signs of destruction and the appearance of new foreign culture. This may indicate a rather modest victory for the Egyptians or even a small defeat, since they lost a strategically important location. On the other hand, Ramses III is claimed to have settled the Philistine with his strongholds, which may mean that the resettlement of Philistines into Philistia was a deliberate act.
Although Egypt’s influence over Palestine decreased, it still controlled several important points in the Southern Levant till the middle of the 12th century. These include the northern parts of the Southern Levant, the Jordan valley and the parts south of Philistia, essentially surrounding the Philistine territory. Still at some point Egypt chose to withdraw or was forced to pull out its forces from the Southern Levant. Any or all of three reasons may have contributed to this process: firstly, the situation in Egypt became increasingly difficult, because of the strikes and unstable rule. Secondly, there may have been attacks on Egyptian strongholds by the groups residing in the Southern Levant, including the Philistines. Thirdly, the region may have lost its economic importance as a trade route.
This paper reconsiders different ways the Egyptians and the Philistines could have interacted, and what can be said about their relations based on archaeology and the written sources. The paper also helps to clarify the political situation of the Southern Levant as a result of these interactions.
|
Conflict Management in Royal Lore: Biblical Narratives and the Sumerian Story of Bilgames and Akka
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Urmas Nõmmik, Tartu Ülikool
Five Hebrew biblical texts potentially attest to the same narrative type that can be designated as a (royal) conflict management narrative. They are: a double episode of the conflict between Isaac and Abimelech the king of Gerar in Genesis 26*, a story about Laban’s covenant with Jacob in Genesis 31:2-32:2*, an episode with Abner defecting to David in 2Samuel 3*, a narrative about the conflict management by Elisha in 2Kings 6*, and a story about the trickery of the Gibeonites in Joshua 9* that is likely younger and literarily dependent on previous stories. In all these cases, a thorough literary and redaction critical work reveals basic narrative layers which contain a chain of similar motifs, such as a conflict between two main characters (or groups), the protagonist and the antagonist of the story, a cunning, negotiations, a feast meal and a peace agreement, and a leaving in peace at the end. Several additional features in the first four narratives point to the royal context. An unexpected parallel to the narrative type in the Hebrew Bible occurs in the considerably older Sumerian story of Bilgames and Akka in Uruk where the basic plot is similar and a number of additional features underline an analogical context. The Sumerian story is a royal narrative par excellence, and together with biblical narratives, it suggests a common narrative type in the royal lore of the Ancient Near East that deals with the ideal of peace and agreement whatever it takes. Needless to say that in the backdrop of these particular literary representatives of the narrative type, a respective (rather international) oral tradition must have been massive. This is the only explanation why a remote Sumerian story can have counterparts in biblical narratives.
|
The Hebrew Book of Job as Part of the Job Literature: A Tribute to Otto Kaiser
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Urmas Nõmmik, Tartu Ülikool
On 14 December 2017, Otto Kaiser died. The paper pays a tribute to the fruitful trace he left in the research on the Book of Job. Mostly, this trace materialized in many doctoral dissertations of his students inspired by his great spirit and constant scholarly challenge. Firstly, a brief summary of the status of the redaction critical model of the book initiated by Kaiser and his students since the end of the 1980s will be given. Secondly, consequences for the further study of the book will be sketched. The most important among them is a wider perspective on the Book of Job as part of a broader phenomenon of the Job literature. The oldest layers in the book are related to the problem of the righteous sufferer in the Ancient Near Eastern literature. Younger layers attest to tensions in the social, political and theological landscape of the second temple period, having particular connections to the younger psalms, the Qumran literature, the Book of Ben Sira as well as in certain cases to the New Testament. Thirdly, completely in line with Kaiser’s approach would also be a critical assessment of the Old Greek translation of the Hebrew Book of Job and its aftermath in the form of the Testament of Job as part of the overall development of the literature of Job, hence, also having impact on our understanding of the emergence of the Hebrew Book of Job.
|
Loanwords and the Dating Game noch einmal: Can Loanwords Be Used to Date Biblical Texts, and If So, How?
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Benjamin J. Noonan, Columbia International University
The question of whether or not biblical texts can be dated chronologically remains a lively topic of debate. One important part of this conversation is the possible significance of loanwords for dating biblical texts. The traditional diachronic approach argues that loanwords can be used to date biblical texts as early or late, whereas the synchronic approach contends that they cannot. Unfortunately, the debate thus far has largely ignored more general scholarship on lexical borrowing. As a result, scholars in both camps have made uncritical assumptions about when lexical borrowing can and cannot occur, and they have confused the kinds of information that can and cannot be obtained from philological investigation of loanwords. The proposed paper will address this gap by reconsidering the Hebrew Bible’s loanwords within a linguistic and philological framework for lexical borrowing. In light of this approach, the proposed paper argues that (1) that there is no one-to-one correspondence between a loanword of any type and the date of a biblical text’s composition, and (2) that loanwords nevertheless are useful for dating biblical texts when they appear in high percentages or exhibit features dating to a particular stage of their donor language. Representative examples and case studies will be presented along the way. First, there is no inherent correspondence between loanwords of any type and the date of composition of biblical texts. Various sociolinguistic factors—such as the need to borrow, linguistic conservatism, and a community’s relationship to a linguistically-influential people group—determine whether or not foreign terminology is adopted, not the date of a text’s composition. As such, the ancient Israelites were never obligated to adopt or reject words from any language at any time. This is evident from the Hebrew Bible’s distribution of loanwords, which does not support a uniform distinction between Standard Biblical Hebrew and Late Biblical Hebrew. Thus, simply asking whether loanwords of a given type are present or absent cannot be used as a sole criterion to fix the date of a biblical text. Second, despite this limitation, loanwords can be valuable for establishing the date of a biblical text. At least two circumstances in which they remain useful emerge from consideration of principles from historical linguistics: (1) when the biblical text contains a high relative percentage of loanwords of a given type, which can plausibly correspond with a specific historical situation leading to language contact; or (2) when the biblical text contains a loanword exhibiting features characteristic of a particular stage of its donor language, which can fix the date of borrowing into Hebrew. In both cases, it can safely be assumed that the time of borrowing establishes a terminus ante quem for when the loanword was incorporated into the biblical text. This is because—questions of textual fluidity aside—it is unlikely that scribes would add significant quantities of loanwords from a past era or would insert loanwords with archaic features, even if they are aware of them.
|
High-Handed Sin and the Promised Land: The Rhetorical Relationship between Law and Narrative in Numbers 15
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Benjamin J. Noonan, Columbia Biblical Seminary
High-Handed Sin and the Promised Land: The Rhetorical Relationship between Law and Narrative in Numbers 15
|
What Light Can Be Shed on the Feuding Christian Women of Philippians 4:2?
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
John G. Nordling, Concordia Theological Seminary - Fort Wayne
A number of explanations have been proposed regarding the conflict that possibly divided Euodia and Syntyche in Phil 4:2 (e.g., Dahl 1995,7; Fee 1995, 397; Bockmuehl 1998, 239; Hansen 2009, 283). Mere names reveal little in themselves; on the other hand, the Pauline encouragement is one of several passages suggesting that Macedonian “ladies of birth and rank” (so Lightfoot 1913, 55) were particularly well-disposed to the gospel and helpful to the apostle in his ministry (Acts 16:14-15, 40; 17:4, 12). The first name was descriptive of slaves (P.Dubl. 12.10-12), freedwomen (IG V 277.1-6), or someone whose status cannot now be determined (IG 4811.2-5; IG 6668.1). Similar ambiguity attends the name Syntyche. The KJV treats the first as a man’s name: “I beseech Euodias…” However, neither putative “Euodias” nor “Syntyches” appear in the ancient evidence, and the New Testament names should be feminine because accompanying pronouns in 4:3 require feminine antecedents. The two could have been among those women to whom Paul spoke at the house of prayer outside Philippi during the early days (Acts 16:13).
|
Not All Flesh Is Alike but There Is One Flesh: Bodies, Colorblindness, and Resurrection
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Kristopher Norris, Wesley Theological Seminary
In his first letter to the Corinthians, Paul reminds his Gentile readers that God gave each person a body according to God’s own choosing. God created a rich tapestry of diverse bodies, a multichromatic creation of humankind. Yet, through the incarnation and resurrection of Jesus Christ, these various distinctive fleshes also constitute one flesh: “Not all flesh is alike but there is one flesh for human beings” (1 Cor. 15:39). This paper proposes reading Paul’s discourses in 1 Corinthians 12 and 15, concerning the church as Body of Christ and the resurrection of the body, in light of contemporary racial discourses of “colorblindness.” I argue that Paul’s exhortations on bodies and resurrection illuminate new ways of challenging a colorblind white supremacy that renders black and brown bodies invisible.
The paper will begin by briefly evaluating current discourses of colorblindness. This pretension to “not see color” in inter-personal and structural relationships fails to recognize systemic racial privilege and oppression, and shields white people from seeing our own “color”—the ways our flesh empowers this privilege of ignorance. After examining this contemporary context, the paper will then proceed by analyzing three aspects of Paul’s exhortations in order to provide clarity and specificity to the (white) church’s mission and offer a challenge to colorblind white supremacy. 1) By placing the particularity and universality of human flesh in dialectical tension, Paul provides scriptural resources to understand the complexity of race as social formation. When interpreted through the contemporary work of black and womanist theologians, Paul’s exhortations reveal that there is indeed one race (or flesh)—human being; yet race, as it has been socially constructed according to different flesh tones, perpetuates real, concrete consequences in this world. Reading Paul through the insights of M. Shawn Copeland, I argue for the importance of a fleshly ecclesiology that challenges the Docetic tendencies in much of white theology and takes seriously the role of bodies in the church’s identity and mission. 2) Paul’s imagery of the church as the “Body of Christ” in its unity (one body) and diversity (many members) then gives specificity to the church’s mission: solidarity with the oppressed. Reading this imagery through James Cone’s argument for the “Black Christ” and J. Kameron Carter’s emphasis on the particularly Jewish flesh of Jesus illuminates the ways multiple fleshes constitute the one Body of Christ and continue the bodily work of Jesus Christ by becoming “black” in solidarity with the oppressed. 3) Paul’s discussion of bodily resurrection reveals a tension between the transformation of the resurrected body and its continuity with the mortal body, reflecting the resurrected body of Jesus that still bore the scars of his earthly suffering. Drawing on Augustine and womanist biblical scholars, this clarifies the image of the church as the wounded Body of Christ that suffers in solidarity with the oppressed. This clarified image of the Body of Christ challenges aspirations to colorblindness and signals the need for greater attention to embodied solidarity as resistance to white supremacy.
|
New Directions in Interpreting the Book of Ruth
Program Unit: African-American Biblical Hermeneutics
Yolanda Norton, San Francisco Theological Seminary
This paper considers the question of cultural assimilation in the relationship between Ruth and Naomi
|
Has Bethsaida-Julias Finally Been Found?
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
R. Steven Notley, Nyack College
Since 1987 excavators at et-Tell have attempted to identify the site with Bethsaida-Julias. Their efforts are best summarized by Magness. "While the Iron Age remains at Bethsaida are monumental and impressive, the Roman period remains are poor, and therefore the site does not look like an urban center.” In other words, et-Tell lacks the central feature in Josephus’ description of Bethsaida-Julias (Ant. 18:28); namely, Philip’s urbanization of a village into a polis, like Tiberias and Sepphoris. In light of this failure, the El-Araj Excavation Project began in 2016 at an alternative site already suggested by Gottlieb Schumacher and others as a possible candidate for Bethsaida-Julias. Several strata were identified during the first season. In the upper stratum, excavators found a crusader (12th century) sugar factory, which incorporated walls from an earlier Byzantine monastery-church. The church is further attested by gilded-glass tesserae that typically belong to wall mosaics in richly ornate churches, and fragments of marble and roof tiles. The church may be that visited by Willibald, a Bavarian bishop (725 CE), which he reports was built over the house of Peter and Andrew. During the second season (2017) two probes were dug almost 2 meters below the Byzantine floors, to the Roman level and found typical 1st-3rd century pottery and a silver denarius of Nero dated to 66 CE. Of greater significance, the remains of a Roman-period bathhouse with portions of white and black mosaic floor are the first evidence of urbanization in the region, indicating that el-Araj should now be considered the leading candidate for Bethsaida-Julias. This paper will consider the ongoing excavations at el-Araj and their consequence for the site identification of Bethsaida-Julias.
|
Into the Hand of a Woman: Deborah and Jael in Judges 4–5
Program Unit: Joshua-Judges
Pamela J. W. Nourse, Claremont School of Theology
Among the themes in the Book of Judges are marginalization and anxiety regarding the stability of Israel’s covenant and the nature of Israel’s leadership. These themes are at play in the unexpected gender roles highlighted in Judges 4 and 5. Whereas most women in the Hebrew Bible are defined by their identities as wives, mothers, or daughters, both Deborah and Jael are shown acting as leaders and heroes of both the prose narrative in chapter 4 and the poetic song in chapter 5. Although both women are presented in a positive light, however, their depictions are quite different from one another. The verbs which describe Deborah’s actions are rare, and sometimes unique, when applied to women; the verbs which describe Jael’s actions are those which are expected of women, yet they produce shockingly unexpected results. This paper will analyze the language used in the text to show that, while Deborah is acting in a manner which appears to transcend the gender norm, Jael’s actions are expressed in verbs appropriate to women’s traditional gender identities, but which are nonetheless subverted and perverted in a manner that produces an unanticipated narrative result.
|
The Legalism of the Apostle Paul
Program Unit: Paul within Judaism
Matthew Novenson, University of Edinburgh
If we did not know—as one of the assured results of modern criticism—that the apostle Paul was the father of theological anti-legalism, we could be forgiven for thinking that he was in fact an extreme halakhic rigorist, or, to use an unfashionable term, a legalist. “It is not hearers of the law who are right with God, but doers of the law.” “Everyone who undergoes circumcision is obligated to do the whole law.” “[My opponents] do not themselves guard the law.” “In respect of the law, I am a Pharisee; in respect of righteousness in the law, blameless.” And so on. This paper undertakes to make sense of these sayings not as rhetorical feints or as theological impossibilities but as the actual views of the person who wrote them.
|
With Liberty and Justice for All, or: The Moral Life of the Resurrected Dead in Romans 6
Program Unit: Pauline Theology
Matthew Novenson, University of Edinburgh
Liberty (eleutheria) and justice (dikaiosune), although best known to Americans from the final clause of Francis Bellamy’s fin de siècle pledge of allegiance to the flag of the United States, are both characteristic Pauline terms for the moral life of the resurrected dead. Both terms feature prominently in Paul’s Letters to the Galatians and the Romans, but together they pile up, alongside resurrection (anastasis), in the dense argument of Romans 6. This paper examines why and how Paul reckons that liberty and justice are effected for all in the resurrection.
|
Between Family and Community: Jewish Epitaphs from Rome
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Megan Nutzman, Old Dominion University
Epitaphs have long served as a medium for exploring identity and social relationships in the Roman world. Over the last twenty-five years, several important studies have examined the vast corpus of Roman funeral inscriptions and advanced a framework for quantifying elements included on them. This work has focused on several pieces of information frequently articulated on the epitaphs, such as the age of the deceased, the relationship between the deceased and the dedicator, and the use of epithets to describe the deceased. This paper utilizes a similar technique to investigate the epitaphs attributed to the Jewish community of Rome. By comparing the results to previously published samples from republican and imperial contexts, ways in which the Jewish inscriptions diverged from the earlier corpus and anticipated trends found in later Christian inscriptions becomes apparent. I argue that a shift in epigraphic habits is apparent not only through the inclusion of Jewish symbols and synagogue titles, but also in the use of epithets and the inclusion of details about the deceased’s age and family relationships, ultimately revealing that the Jewish inscriptions placed greater importance the religious identity of the deceased, at the expense of commemorating the family relationships that pervaded the broader corpus of Roman inscriptions.
|
The Character Spotlight Pattern in 1 Samuel 13-15
Program Unit: Book of Samuel: Narrative, Theology, and Interpretation
Meredith F Nyberg, University of Gloucestershire
Using a literary approach, I consider 1 Samuel 13–15 as an interesting aspect of a pattern of characterization I have discerned in 1 Samuel. This five-fold ‘character spotlight pattern’ consists of 1) building anticipation; 2) the introduction of a na’ar; 3) comparison and contrast; 4) choosing and challenge; and 5) rise, rule, and replacement. I observe that the three major characters of 1 Samuel—Samuel, Saul, and David—are each developed according to this pattern. I propose that chapters 13–15 represent an area of overlap between these three major character spotlights and involve yet another important character, Saul’s son Jonathan. Thus these chapters contribute to the characterization of the prophet Samuel, the first king Saul, his son Jonathan, and also serve as a pre-introduction of David. I propose that while chapters 13 and 15 present a double rejection of Saul by YHWH and Samuel, sandwiched between these rejections is a subtle suggestion of David as the armor-bearing na‘ar who climbs up to attack the Philistines with Jonathan in chapter 14. Together, these chapters build anticipation toward the introduction of David as the anointed ‘replacement king’ in 1 Samuel 16.
My paper will explain the character spotlight pattern that I have proposed, a pattern occurring primarily in 1 Samuel but covering the whole of David’s spotlight to 1 Kings 2. The main focus of the paper will be 1 Samuel 13–15 and how these chapters serve to prepare the way for the introduction of David as YHWH’s chosen king. The paper will also include a discussion of the word na‘ar and the nuances of its use in 1 Samuel, perhaps leading to a better understanding of its overall use in the Hebrew Bible. This paper arises from my recently defended thesis on the character spotlight pattern in 1 Samuel.
|
Among Jews and Gentiles in the Holy Land: Reconsidering Readings of Romans in the Context of Dialogue
Program Unit: Paul within Judaism
Jennifer Nyström, Lund University
Commemorating the important work of Krister Stendahl, this paper aims at exploring contextual readings of Romans in the framework of Jewish-Christian relations in the Israel today. Whereas Romans 9-11 has been much used to legitimize the dialogue from an official (church) level, I intend to challenge the usefulness of this text for creating a mutual understanding of each other. This will be done by taking a grass-root perspective on the understanding of the text as the main arguments in this presentation will be taken from fieldwork and reading interviews conducted among Jewish and Christian leaders in Israel and the West Bank who are engaged in interfaith relations. Thus, I engage in what I call biblical ethnography as a way to shape and create the field of “the social life of scripture.” I hope to demonstrate the importance of reconfiguring both biblical studies and Jewish-Cristian relations into a more empirical science as it offers both new questions and answers. Therefore, this paper presents and analyses contextualized readings of the most important text for dialogue. Jewish-Christian dialogue in Israel is complicated and much different from “mainstream” dialogue in the US giving the reversed power-relations between Jews and Christian in the Holy Land on the one hand, and on the other hand given the sociocultural situation with the Israeli-Palestinian conflict as well as with Christians on both the Israeli and Palestinian side of the wall. Apart from picturing the landscape of dialogue, hermeneutical approaches towards the text of Romans 11 will be presented, alongside more narrow text studies that will primarily focus both on issues of chosenness/rejection and eschatological expectations/mission. These themes are much present in Romans 11 and of immense importance for Jewish-Christian dialogue – and even more so in an Israeli context. Furthermore, I aim to demonstrate how these, many times challenging, readings might, for good or for bad, influence the dialogue and the ways Jews and Christians interact with each other on both a theological and a social level in the Holy Land – continuing the legacy of Krister Stendahl.
|
The (After-)Lives of Functionally-Anonymous Prophets
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Julia M. O'Brien, Lancaster Theological Seminary
While none of the Twelve offers extensive literary characterization of the named prophet, the books of Obadiah and Malachi are especially devoid of biographical markers. In functionally-anonymous books such as these, what function does the prophet’s name play? This paper explores (1) the literary effect on each book of its identification with an individual; (2) the possible legitimation function of superscriptions, akin to scribal practices in Mari and Nineveh; (3) the ways in which the inclusion of prophetic names advances the larger discourse about prophecy in the Hebrew Bible; and (4) the role that later interpretation (premodern and modern) has played in transforming the content of Obadiah and Malachi into biography.
|
Prophetic Authority and Formulaic Diction in al-Musabbiḥāt
Program Unit: The Qur’an: Surah Studies (IQSA)
Andrew J. O'Connor, University of Notre Dame
The five musabbiḥāt generally share a similar prophetological profile, featuring assertions of the Prophet’s authority in the context of conflicts with the ahl al-kitāb and frequent exhortations to believe “in God and His Messenger (bi-llāhi wa-rasūlihi)”. Indeed in his recent monograph, Nicolai Sinai highlights the distinctive prophetic paradigms between the Meccan and Medinan corpora, noting that the elevated prophetic authority associated with the Prophet in Medinan surahs is often tied to the need for militancy and the occurrence of the formulaic linking of “God and His Messenger” (Sinai, The Qur’an, 2017, chs.7 and 8). He further remarks that a possible candidate for the first surah to declare a “militant manifesto” is Sūrat al-Ṣaff (Q 61), and the first to employ the linking of God and the Messenger is Sūrat al-Taghābun (Q 64), both belonging to the musabbiḥāt. Intriguingly, both were also flagged by Andrew Bannister as the two surahs with the highest formulaic density in the entirety of the Qurʾān (Bannister, An Oral-Formulaic Study, 2014, ch.6). Q 64, however, particularly stands apart from the rest of this collection. It exhibits a comparatively low Mean Verse Length of 89.28 transcription letters, whereas the other four surahs have values greater than 100. Likewise, as is also noted by Sinai (2017, p.207)—and pace its placement by Nöldeke and Schwally—this surah exhibits many features that are generally more comparable to Meccan material than Medinan. Unlike the other musabbiḥāt, Q 64 features no explicit critique of other monotheistic communities or allusions to the struggles of the Prophet and his community. Instead it emphasizes eschatological themes and notes that the Messenger’s only duty is al-balāghu l-mubīn (v.12). Might Q 64 more likely be a Meccan rather than a Medinan surah, or otherwise have an entirely different provenance than the rest of the musabbiḥāt? And how do we account for the pervasive presence of formulaic diction in Q 64 and Q 61?
In this paper I examine the prophetologies of al-musabbiḥāt and discuss their position within the prophetological spectrum of the Qurʾān as a whole. I then highlight the anomalous position of Q 64 (including its high formulaic density), arguing that Q 64 is either (following Sinai) early and marks a new development in the text’s prophetic paradigms—and subsequently served as a sort of model of formulaic diction for later surahs—or, alternatively, Q 64 may be a composite construction which drew upon material from across the qur’anic corpus. In this I draw upon the works of Bannister, Klar, Paret, Sinai, and others.
|
Resurrection Past and Future: Temporal Aspects of Social Identity in 1 Corinthians 15
Program Unit: Pauline Theology
Matt O'Reilly, St Mark Church, Mobile, AL
This paper explores the role of Paul’s attitude toward bodily resurrection in 1 Corinthians 15 in relation to the formation of group identity among the recipients. In particular, I consider how Paul’s portrayal of past and future function to form and maintain the recipients’ present social identity. Identity theorist Marco Cinnirella has argued for the category of “future possible social identity,” which is an individual’s unrealized expectation of future group membership. Individuals tend to behave in a way to attain such hoped-for identities. They are drawn toward positive portrayals of the identity and avoid negative portrayals. Further, individuals tend to desire temporally coherent identities. Thus, they often construe the past in a way that aligns with their desired future identity. Drawing on Cinnirella, I argue that Paul understands resurrection primarily in social terms, and that Paul’s discussion of resurrection in 1 Corinthians 15 functions to persuade the Corinthian factions to embrace his vision of future bodily resurrection as an essential feature of their “in Christ” identity. To make the case, I first argue that future bodily resurrection constitutes for Paul a future possible social identity. Second, Paul’s portrayal of Jesus’ resurrection in the past functions as what Cinnirella calls a “life story” and thus establishes a narrative that coheres with his vision of the future (15:1-11). Third, Paul provides a negative evaluation of the denial of future bodily resurrection (15:12-19) before, fourth, engaging in an extended positive evaluation of future bodily resurrection (15:21-58). Additionally, I point to ways that this analysis provides a framework for interpreting Paul’s behavioral expectations in 1 Corinthians 15 and elsewhere in the letter.
|
People of the Day: Temporal Aspects of Social Identity in 1 Thessalonians
Program Unit: Writing Social-Scientific Commentaries of the New Testament
Matt O'Reilly, St Mark Church, Mobile, AL
Questions about the future feature largely in Paul’s first letter to the Thessalonians. Whether the fate of the dead, future bodily resurrection, the Parousia, or questions about judgment and destruction, Paul has plenty to say about what is to come in what is one of his earliest letters. This paper takes up Paul’s attitude toward the future in 1 Thessalonians to consider its role in the formation and maintenance of the recipients’ social identity. What social categories govern Paul’s vision of the future? How does he portray those categories? How does his portrayal of the past (including past social categorizations) relate to his vision of the future? How does his portrayal of past and future relate to the behavioral expectations set forth in the letter? Drawing on models from the field of Social Identity Theory, I argue that Paul defines the community in relation to “the day” (1 Thess 4:8) of Christ’s anticipated return and all that it entails. He portrays the past, both in terms of the Christ-story and the conversion of the Thessalonians, to cohere with that anticipated future. This coherent representation frames and strengthens the ethical expectations Paul articulates in the letter.
|
The translationCore Bible Translation Checking Tool
Program Unit: Global Education and Research Technology
Perry Oakes, Distant Shores Media
As the church has grown and reached more places on the globe, the desire for the Bible in the heart language has also been increasing. At the same time, the ability of Western missionary linguists to deliver those Bible translations has been diminishing. A particularly acute problem that has been widely recognized is the shortage of Bible translation consultants who can check those translations for accuracy. On top of this, church networks in many parts of the world are increasingly uncomfortable with Westerners coming and doing things for them. We at Distant Shores Media, in conjunction with the unfoldingWord project, are working toward a possible solution to these problems through the creation of the translationCore Bible translation checking tool (tC). Through tC we seek to put into the hands of speakers of the target language much of the knowledge that a consultant brings to a checking session in a format that is easily accessible. TranslationCore gives the user access to the original language texts as well as various Gateway Language (GL) translations to compare with the target translation.
One of the components in tC is the alignment tool, which allows the user to match up the words and phrases of a GL text with those of the biblical language. Through this tool the user can see where the GL translation may have deviated from the original, and tC uses the alignment information to track and highlight the parts of the original and GL texts that correspond to each other. There are currently two other checking components in tC: the translationWords component that contains definitions of the biblical key terms, and the translationNotes component that contains checks of the different types of figurative language, grammatical difficulties, and other issues. These checks are modular in format and can be expanded according to the needs of the user. Each of these items to be checked are aggregated by type and presented by book in the order of appearance and in the scriptural context. An explanation of each type of problem is given along with the problem itself so that the user knows why each thing must be checked, with context-specific help as to the meaning of the word or figure of speech, etc. that is under scrutiny. TranslationCore keeps track of what has been checked and provides an indication of progress for the user or any supervisor. If the user needs more help, he or she can flag a check and/or leave a note in the comment field. The translation team can then discuss these notes together, or a translation consultant can use these to quickly see the problem areas and offer solutions. In this way, we hope that tC provides a robust and extensive checking method that can greatly increase the abilities of a translation team independently of a translation consultant, or allow them to greatly reduce the workload of a consultant if they have one working with them. This will be a presentation of the strategy, technology, and resources of tC.
|
Did Paul Write for Asterix? The Extent of Celtic Ethnicity in Galatia and the Audience of Galatians
Program Unit: Polis and Ekklesia: Investigations of Urban Christianity
Peter Oakes, University of Manchester
The ethnicity of the population of Galatia and of the audience of Galatians has played a range of roles in scholarship: from relationship with modern French nationalism to picturing of political resistance to the Roman Empire. This paper uses epigraphic evidence from sites in the Roman province of Galatia to discuss the extent of Celtic ethnicity in the province at the time of the letter. That will then provide a way into discussion of how scholars can most reasonably and usefully construct the expected audience of Paul’s letter.
|
Repeated Performance of Oral or Written Christian Texts in Light of Ritual Analysis
Program Unit: Performance Criticism of the Bible and Other Ancient Texts
Bernhard Oestreich, Friedensau Adventist University
The local and temporal arena of performances of Christian traditions and texts was the gathering of the community of the believers. Historical evidence indicates that these gatherings were Hellenistic meals that have high social significance and follow a pattern that is rooted in social tradition. These features of the community meals suggest that they may be studied with the aid of ritual analysis. This paper explores the oral performances of oral and written compositions in the Christian gatherings in light of the ritualized actions in which the performances are imbedded. This analysis will shed light on the custom that certain texts are repeatedly performed because ritualized activity refers to tradition (is in a sense a re-doing of previous actions) and at the same time (through the perceived formal stability) aims to future actions that can be recognized as a re-doing of the ritual.
|
Deuteronomy 17:14-20 and the (Il)legitimacy of African Rulers
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Gilbert Okuro Ojwang, Oakwood University
As is widely recognized, in ancient Israel and the Neat East, royal ideology played a key role in lending legitimacy to the king. Deuteronomic legislation, especially Deut 17:14-20, formed a major part of the traditional basis of legitimation for Israelite/Judean statecraft (at least retrospectively if Deuteronomy is dated to the exilic period). One thing is certain, the Deuteronomic historical books of Samuel and Kings assess kings and rulers on the basis of their fidelity, or the lack of it, to this constitution. This paper examines how the themes in this biblical tradition can inform a conversation around African autocratic rulers, and the deficit of legitimacy that often bedevils their reigns. The paper pays attention to political theory and historical sociology in analyzing the debilitating effects of illegitimate rules of many an African president, with Kenya as a test case, from the perspective of biblical studies.
|
You Have Become Children of Sarah: Reading 1 Peter 3:1-6 through the Intersectional Lens of Asian Immigrant Wives, Honorary Whiteness, and the Oriental Feminine Mystique
Program Unit: Asian and Asian-American Hermeneutics
Janette H. Ok, Azusa Pacific University
This paper reexamines the exhortation to Christian wives in 1 Peter 3:1-6 through the intersectionality of gender, ethnicity, and culture discussed through two lenses: the experiences of the first-century women in mixed marriages addressed in the Petrine household code and that of recent Asian immigrant women in interracial marriages. It suggests that this text can be productively read in such a way that can speak to the particular identity challenges of Asian immigrant women who are married to white American men. Such Asian American women often experience the homogenization of their identities, despite having immigrated to the U.S. from distinct cultures, and the exoticization of their identities, despite being ethnicized as honorary whites. This sometimes leads them to construct their own idealized identities in contrast to white American women and the cultural stereotypes the dominant culture has of them. This paper questions the tendency among white feminist interpretations of 1 Peter 3:1-6 to see the injunctions as a backlash of social conservatism by the author or among male leaders to alleviate the conflict between Christian wives and their pagan husbands. It argues that the Petrine household code may instead be a form of challenging the essentializing of the differences between Christian and non-Christian women by exhorting wives to be more chaste, virtuous, and family-oriented than their Greco-Roman counterparts and behave as “children of Sarah” (3:6). As the experiences of some Asian immigrant women suggest, idealizing and ethnicizing certain behaviors as a way to refute stereotypes may ironically lead to the essentializing of gender and idealization of whiteness and patriarchy.
|
The Textual Criticism of the Text of Daniel in the Hebrew Scroll of Hodayot
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Daniel Olariu, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
The aim of this paper is to discuss the quotations and allusions to the Hebrew-Aramaic Text of Daniel in the Hebrew scrolls of Hodayot found at Qumran. It equally attempts to evaluate the relevancy of these quotations and allusions for the textual criticism of the Hebrew Bible.
|
The Mechanics of Recensional Process: The Treatment of the First-Found Equivalents
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Daniel Olariu, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
One of the ongoing debates in the textual studies in the Book of Daniel relates to the proper characterization in relation to each other of the two Greek versions of this book, i.e. Old Greek (LXX-Dan) and Theodotion (Th-Dan). Do these texts stand in a translation-revision relationship or are they better assessed as two independent translations? The standard method which tests the quality of a text as a revision comprises two criteria: (1) the confirmation of a common basis shared between the two texts based on significant lexical choices and (2) the attestation of revising tendencies aiming to represent the Semitic source text more faithfully. The goal of this paper is to substantiate the quality of Th-Dan as a recension by discussing extensively the reviser’s treatment of the first-found equivalents in LXX-Dan for the Semitic words. Not only that this feature has never been noticed in the previous recensional studies but also it convincingly demonstrates both the reviser’s dependence on LXX-Dan in selecting his equivalents and his agenda to stereotypically employ them further once they were adopted.
|
How Does the Author Know? ’Az yiqtol as Evidential Strategy in Classical Biblical Hebrew
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Vladimir Olivero, University of Oxford
The goal of my paper is to make a case for evidentiality in Classical Biblical Hebrew. The argument rests on the conviction that yiqtol is used as an evidential strategy to express information source when preceded by the particle ’az. Nineteen such cases are witnessed in the Hebrew Bible, which have so far eluded a neat and satisfactory explanation. After briefly outlining the grammatical category of evidentiality in order to offer a typological set of data to which to compare the Hebrew construction, I will proceed to explain the nineteen occurrences of ’az yiqtol in the framework of Joosten’s theory of the Hebrew verbal system, which sees in the yiqtol a future/modal form. As I will try to show, the yiqtol is employed so as to tie the world of the narration to the reality of the author, who put together the passages in question and tried to place events and facts known to him and to his public in the broader context of the narration. Finally, I will also seek to illustrate how this linguistic explanation tallies with the results obtained through a text-critical analysis of the passages, yielding a coherent picture of the phenomenon: as many scholars have observed, ’az yiqtol serves to insert an external source into the text. Furthermore, since the construction is attested only in Classical Biblical Hebrew, it may shed light on the early, i.e. pre-exilic, nature of editorial activity on the passages where it occurs. Not surprisingly, an evidential strategy is employed where clear editing marks show up. Hopefully, my investigation will produce harmonic results obtained through a linguistic and a text-critical analysis.
|
“My God, My God, Why…?” A Reading of Lament Psalms in the Context of Abused Female Bodies
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Funlola O. Olojede , Universiteit van Stellenbosch - University of Stellenbosch
This paper shows that certain Psalms of Lament make use of a variety of body imagery which when read contextually and theologically in the light of the agonies of physically abused women could open up fresh interpretive insights into the use of such Psalms in an African space.
|
The One Who Sees Me: Finding Hagar through Literary Hermeneutics and Religious Interpretive Agency
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Oluwatomisin Oredein, Memphis Theological Seminary
The figure of Hagar is a critical example of a marginalized woman of color whose actions and relationship to God models the course of theological liberation for the oppressed; but her story must first be her own. Examining the under-explored details of Hagar’s story and voice renders them (scripturally and diasporically) significant to broadly understanding the marginalized lives of women of color. Placing the Hagaritic findings and interpretive moves of Delores Williams in dialogue with Arabic, African, and African-descended literature and religious scholarship allows for a broader understanding of Hagar’s experience to inform the lives of those who draw connection to her story.
|
Identifying the Deer in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Animal Studies and the Bible
Dag Oredsson, Lunds Universitet
Findings of bone and depictions show that red deer, Persian fallow-deer and roe deer were spread all over the Ancient Near East in Biblical times. Still only two words in the Bible are considered to refer to these species, ’ayyal and yachmur. When scholars and translators have discussed the species these words may refer to, it is always the fallow deer and roe deer that are considered. The red deer is left out of the discussion. Considering that the roe deer is more absent in the findings, than the red deer, this may appear peculiar.
There are several possibilities to explain this. The roe deer may have been less popular as a game animal, and therefore ignored in the texts. It may also have been included into the category of gazelles (tsvi). Another possibility is that ’ayyal includes both red deer and fallow deer, as they were of a similar size. In that case yachmur may refer to roe deer.
By looking at the statements concerning these animals in the Biblical text, early translations, cognates in other Semitic languages, etymology, archaeozoological evidence and studies on the species’ behaviour and habitat; all the evidence are weighed together to consider several possibilities to understand the Hebrew words, and evaluate their plausibilities.
The Bible refers to the ’ayyal as being at home in the mountains, jumping, longing for water and in an Ugaritic text we are told that the does (female deer) form herds together. These statements seem to support an understanding of ’ayyal as red deer, which is contradicted by the common understanding of its Akkadian cognate. In Akkadian it supposedly refers to the Persian fallow deer.
If we choose an inclusive understanding of the word, i.e. that it refers to both the big deer, then yachmur may be understood as roe deer. This is supported by the use of the Arabic cognate during the last two centuries. A recent suggestion that yachmur should refer to the extinct bubal hartebeest is dismissed, mainly by understanding yachmur as a derivative of hmr, suggesting that the animal should be reddish. That description does not go well with this particular species of hartebeest.
|
Paul's Gospel According to Deutero-Isaiah in Romans 1–2
Program Unit: Scripture and Paul
B. J. Oropeza, Azusa Pacific University
Paul's Gospel According to Deutero-Isaiah in Romans 1-2
|
A Decade of Research at Tel Gezer: The Transformation of a Border City
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Steven Ortiz and Samuel Wolff, Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary
This paper is part of a session on the results of the Tandy excavations at Tel Gezer. This paper will discuss the history of the ancient city, major Egyptian and Assyrian campaigns to the site, as well as the shifting urbanization of the site. Major results to date include 1) verification of the extension of the MB glacis on the eastern slope of the western hill; 2) Late Bronze Age Patrician house destroyed by Merneptah 3) an Iron Age I city wall with a complex of several structures built up against the wall (11-10th c. BCE); 4) excavation of an Iron Age II Palace or Administrative Central Courtyard Building Complex; 5) several 9th century domestic units built up against the reused casemate city; 6) an 8th century administrative quarter that includes three large administrative and industrial public buildings; 7) a large four-room house (elite), 8) and additional units of a Hellenistic building complex that extends the Hellenistic exposure previously excavated by HUC.
|
Tandy Gezer Excavations: Research Design and Strategy
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Steven Ortiz, Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary
This paper is part of a session on the results of the Tandy excavations at Tel Gezer. Tel Gezer has a long history of excavations from Macalister to the Hebrew Union College excavations under the direction of W. Dever and J. Seger. Gezer was an important city in the second millennium BCE as well as infamous as one of the three cities Solomon fortified (1 Kings 9:15). The Tel Gezer Excavation Project is directed by Steve Ortiz of the Tandy Institute for Archaeology and Sam Wolff, formerly of the Israel Antiquities Authority. The project is sponsored by the Tandy Institute for Archaeology at Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary. This paper will introduce the project, and address the research design and methodology of the project. In addition, a discussion of the development of the field strategy over 10 seasons of excavations.
|
The Genesis of a Martyr Complex: Martyrs Mirror and the Self-Perception of Assimilated Mennonites
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
Jennifer Otto, University of Lethbridge
This paper employs the concept of “hegemonic anxieties” to explore the role of Martyrs Mirror, a seventeenth-century compendium of martyr acts, in shaping the self-perception of Mennonite Christians assimilated into majority-Christian societies. Drawing a straight line through the biblical accounts of the deaths of Jesus, John the Baptist, and Stephen the ur-martyr to the tortures and executions of sixteenth-century non-conformist Anabaptists in Europe, Martyrs Mirror constructs a singular narrative of Christian faithfulness as the ready willingness to die rather than to accept infant baptism or military conscription on the pain of persecution at the hands of governments—or of other Christians.
Yet Martyrs Mirror was composed not during a period of intense violence, but in the tolerant circumstances of the Dutch Golden Age, more than a century after peak of anti-Anabaptist violence in Europe. The anthology’s compiler, Thieleman van Braght, was the well-educated and well-off son of a successful cloth merchant. His aim in compiling the Martyrs Mirror, according to Julia Spicher Kasdorf, was to “remind Mennonites of their martyr heritage, even as they were busy buying and selling opulent homes and gardens, wearing fashionable clothing sewn from expensive imported cloth, and hosting lavish banquets.” It is not without some irony that the Martyrs Mirror rose to prominence among seventeenth-century Mennonites as a luxury consumer good and status symbol. When Van Braght’s 1660 edition met with modest commercial success, its printing rights were purchased by a consortium of businessmen. Sensing the opportunity to turn a profit, they re-published the text in 1685 in both a standard edition and in a “deluxe” format, printed on higher quality paper and featuring 104 illustrations contributed by the prominent artist Jan Luyken, costing 13 guilders (approximately the weekly salary of an average Dutch tradesman at the time).
In the four centuries since its initial publication, Martyrs Mirror has seen numerous reprints and translations, often coinciding with moments of crisis in assimilated Mennonite communities, brought on by pressure to conform to the practices of the majority. In this paper, I argue that Martyrs Mirror has functioned to reinforce in otherwise well-assimilated Mennonites a perception of the self as belonging to an historically persecuted minority group rather than to a larger Christian hegemony. This self-perception has been successful in shoring up pacifist conviction and practice among Mennonites in the face of military conscription. Yet it has also served to obscure the ways that Mennonites have been complicit in, and profited from, violence undertaken against marginalized peoples. Only in recent years have Mennonites begun the critical task of accounting for their roles in the displacement of indigenous peoples, the silencing of victims of sexual abuse, and violence against Jews during the Second World War. Constructing an image of themselves in the reflection of the Martyrs Mirror, Mennonites have traditionally self-identified as victims, and yet they have also been beneficiaries of violence prompted by hegemonic anxieties.
|
Paul’s Multi-layered Use of Scripture: Taking Intertextuality One Step Further
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Konrad Otto, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
For the past decades, research on intertextuality in Paul has been locked in a stalemate between the proponents of minimalist and maximalist readings. While adherents to a maximalist approach tend to identify even the slightest semantic or conceptual overlap as a biblical echo that nuances Paul’s meaning, others hold to a minimalist view, admitting only clearly marked citations to contribute to the thrust of Paul’s argument. After all, we can assume Paul to have been well versed in Scripture, whereas the majority of his addressees are commonly portrayed as converts, mostly unfamiliar with Israel’s traditions. Thus, depending on their perspective, scholars have reached vastly different assessments of Paul’s use of Scripture.
This paper tries to chart a course out of this deadlock. In order to bridge the gap between both approaches, it combines the notion of intertextuality with argumentation analysis. A survey of Paul’s use of Scripture in the hotly debated passage of 2 Cor 2:14-4:6 serves as a test case. Based on a reconstruction of the text’s train of thought and pragmatics (author-oriented perspective), the paper demonstrates how several of its scriptural references can be contextualized before the backdrop of a) a Greco-Roman/Hellenistic background with only elementary knowledge of Israel’s Scripture and theological concepts; b) a Jewish-Hellenistic background with a solid knowledge of biblical themes and stories; and c) a Jewish-Hellenistic scribal background, familiar with the very texts Paul might allude to (reader-oriented perspective, drawing on the work of Christopher Stanley). Strikingly, all three groups of potential readers would have been able to follow the main thrust of Paul’s argument, their different levels of scriptural competency notwithstanding. This holds true for unmarked allusions (2 Cor 3:2-3.6) as well as for clearly marked citations and their processing along the lines of Jewish exegetical patterns (2 Cor 3:7-11.12-18). Although different readers would have conceptualized Paul’s allusions differently, they probably would have arrived at the same conclusions concerning his prime concern. The more the reader is rooted in Israel’s Scripture, the more compelling Paul’s argument grows, yet the neophyte is not left out of it. On the contrary: He, too, will be able to follow Paul’s thought, yet he will notice some jarring notes in his understanding of Paul’s words that guide him into a process of intra-communal discussion and teaching.
These findings shed new light on Paul’s use of Scripture and the question of its intentionality. They portray Paul as a thinker and preacher who is himself deeply embedded in Scripture, yet sensitive to his readers’ cultural background(s). Thus, the paper essentially argues that Paul deliberately crafted (some of) his texts in a way that they appeal to readers with different levels of scriptural competency. Taking the notion of ‘intertextuality’ one step further by reconstructing and including the reaction of different readers to Paul’s writing and matching them with the text’s pragmatics might help to recover this multi-layered use of Scripture.
|
The Royal Feast and Female Vulnerability in 2 Samuel
Program Unit: Meals in the HB/OT and Its World
Leann Pace, Wake Forest University
In the book of 2 Samuel, women play pivotal roles in two very different meal events within royal contexts. In 2 Samuel 25, Abigail serves a very unconventional royal meal to David and his men in the wilderness after her husband denied them proper hospitality. Her actions saved the entire household from the revenge of David and his army. In the days that follow, her husband is struck dead and David takes her as one of his wives. Her serving as hostess at an unconventional royal feast radically altered the trajectory of her life.
In 2 Samuel 13, Tamar serves an intimate meal to her half-brother, Amnon, who is feigning illness in order to gain her attention and access to her. Once she has prepared the meal and they are alone, Amnon rapes Tamar and she remains in deep grief through the remainder of the chapter (and likely her life although we are not privy to the remainder of her story). Two years later, Absalom exacts revenge on behalf of his sister by killing Amnon at a royal feast.
These two stories from 2 Samuel highlight the vulnerability of women during the act of cooking and serving. In both cases, providing food within a royal context proves to be a time when a woman’s marital and/or sexual status can be radically altered.
This paper seeks to evaluate these stories through the lens of the women’s experiences, examining why food preparation, feasting, and serving within royal settings creates spaces of vulnerability for women, in which their sexual and marital statuses may be redefined with or without their consent. This paper will conclude with a consideration of how these stories may inform our understanding of the experiences of unnamed and/or unacknowledged women who prepared and served food within royal contexts in the world of the Hebrew Bible and how we might shed some light on their contributions and experiences through textual and archaeological investigation.
|
How John of Patmos' Readers Made Him into a Christian
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
Elaine Pagels, Princeton University
In his Apocalypse, John of Patmos excoriates "those who say they are Jews, and are not, but are lying" as "a synagogue of Satan" (Rev. 2:9, 3:9). John warns that when Jesus comes as judge, he'll harshly rebuke and humiliate such people. But whom does he have in mind? For over a millennium and a half, countless readers who've found John's book in the the New Testament have declared that John has in mind Jews hostile to Christians--Jews he sees as "not worthy of the name," since, of course, he understands Christians like himself as the "true Israel."
After David Frankfurter and I independently challenged the consensus, we both suggested a different answer. Noting that John never mentions the term Christian, much less applies the term to himself, I suggest instead that he was castigating Gentile converts among his contemporaries (like Ignatius of Antioch, c. 90-117 C.E.), who called themselves "Christians, not Jews," claiming to be the new--and better--Israel.
This brief talk sets forth recent and contemporary reception history, first showing how the traditional interpretation requires exegetes to invert completely the meaning of prophetic passages to which John alludes (from, for example, Isaiah 60), this brief talk sets forth recent and contemporary reception history. Second, we see how even some of today's most respected scholars of the Apocalypse are insisting that John intentionally says the opposite of what he means. Some insist that John is writing this phrase against Jews with bitter irony, even going so far as to invoke "the sarcastic Christ" to castigate Jews who reject Jesus.
We conclude with a far simpler suggestion: that John is saying exactly what he means, since he sees himself not as a Christian, but as a Jew who has found Israel's Messiah.
|
New Resources for Pauline Reception History: Is the Gospel of Truth Paul's Secret Wisdom Teaching?
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Elaine Pagels, Princeton University
As is well known, Paul opens his first letter scolding believers in Corinth for their spiritual immaturity, saying that since they were only "babies in Christ," he could only give them baby food--"milk, not meat." But, he adds immediately, that's not because its all he knows; the contrary, he himself received secret "wisdom of God...hidden in a mystery" (1 Cor. 2:7) from the holy spirit directly (2:13); but, he writes, he can only reveal it to the teleioi, and he clearly tells them "you're not that."
The anonymous author of the Gospel of Truth, a follower of Valentinus, a teacher who claimed to have received Paul's secret teaching orally from a disciple named Theudas, here reveals, in language dense with Pauline allusions, what he calls "the true gospel"--thus staking a major claim among second century Christians battling over the disputed territory of Paul's legacy. This short talk sets forth the moving and powerful story he tells, shows (in a handout) its striking correlation in language and sequence with 1 Corinthians, and opens new awareness of the power of Paul's poetic and mythical images.
|
The Use of Chronicles, Ezra, and Nehemiah in the Hodayot
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Mika Pajunen, University of Helsinki
The Hodayot psalms of the Qumran movement provide an intriguing test case for the use of sources in poetic texts. As is well known, poetic texts rarely use quotations and even allusions are typically adapted to the poetic form and style of these works. This presents a methodological challenge for uncovering and classifying the different sources employed by authors of such poetic works as the Hodayot. This paper focuses on the use of Chronicles, Ezra, and Nehemiah in the Hodayot. There are several possible allusions to each of these works in the Hodayot, and it will be investigated whether these potential allusions hold any significance for the textual criticism of these three compositions. Moreover, in view of the scant manuscript evidence for Chronicles, Ezra, and Nehemiah at Qumran it is of interest whether these possible allusions can be termed certain enough to demonstrate that these compositions were in fact known and used by the authors of the Hodayot.
|
Was the Early Transmission of the Hebrew Bible Essentially Oral or Textual?
Program Unit: Transmission of Traditions in the Second Temple Period
Juha Pakkala, University of Helsinki
Since early biblical criticism it has been assumed that the early transmission of the Hebrew Bible was essentially textual. The evaluation of variant readings in textual criticism and attempts to reconstruct the history of the text in historical criticism imply that the changes can be understood textual in nature, and thus our focus should be to understand how texts were changed.
The essentially textual nature of the transmission has been challenged in the recent decades. Some studies have argued that oral transmission played a larger role than conventionally assumed in biblical criticism (thus e.g., Niditch, Carr). Some scholars, such as Ray Person, have taken a further step and argued that the early transmission of the Hebrew Bible was essentially oral and that textual witnesses were primarily performances for various occasions. Texts or manuscripts would thus be arbitrary glimpses of the broader tradition that was transmitted in the community’s collective memory. Consequently, the evaluation of variant readings in manuscripts and attempts to reconstruct the history of textual transmission would not be fruitful.
In this paper I will discuss challenges to the conventional assumptions and will argue that the transmission was essentially textual. I maintain that the primary evidence for understanding how the Hebrew Bible was transmitted are documented changes that can be seen in variant editions, while analogies from other literature, which are partly essential to some of the challenges, should only be used with caution. Without neglecting the oral aspect, many features in the transmission of the Hebrew Bible imply that the history of the texts remains key to biblical studies.
|
My Sister, Bride, and Lady Wisdom? On the Imagery of the “Sister” in Song of Songs 4
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Carmen Palmer, Toronto School of Theology
As with “sister” terminology elsewhere in the Hebrew Bible, the term “sister” can represent a female spouse or companion in biblical Hebrew poetry. Such is the case in Song of Songs 4 and 5, in the repeating phrase “my sister, bride.” However, when various manuscript evidence within proto-Masoretic tradition is compared against the Masoretic Text (MT), it may be possible to see even other less common representations of the sister present in the mind of scribes of ancient Judaism. In particular, in 4Q107 Frag. 2, II, 11 (matching Song 4:10), the term “bride” in the repeated poetic phrase “my sister, bride” has been replaced with a different word, subsequently scratched out. Beside the word is a parenthesis sign possibly indicating words belonging elsewhere (e.g. Tov, “Three Manuscripts”). The present paper will propose a variant hypothetical reading for the scratched out word, namely an archaic form of the second feminine singular independent personal pronoun “you.” In this way, the scribe may have been conflating another passage from Hebrew poetry, namely Prov 7:4, in which “wisdom” is identified as a sister. The paper will proceed by means of a comparison between Song 4:9-11 as attested in 4Q107 and the MT. Special attention by the scribe of 4Q107 to include the parallel term “sister” alongside the “bride” of Song 4:11 (missing in the MT) highlights that these terms are understood to belong together in this poetic passage, making the scribal alteration all the more intriguing. After arguing for an allusion to Prov 7:4 and the 2.f.s. pronoun “you” contrasted against other possibilities (such as another descriptor from Song 5:2), the paper will conclude by questioning the underlying motivation for a scribe to use the imagery of a sister as “wisdom” in addition to “bride” in biblical Hebrew poetry.
|
An Analysis of Female Gentile Conversion to Judaism through Marriage in the Temple Scroll
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Carmen Palmer, Toronto School of Theology
Temple Scroll (TS) LXIII, 10-15 retells the narrative of the beautiful captive woman. The sequencing of the the content in the passage mirrors its predecessor from biblical law (Deut 21:10-14) fairly closely when recounting that the female captive undergoes a month of mourning, after which she becomes the captor’s wife. At this point, however, the Temple Scroll passage diverges and articulates that after a period of seven years has passed, the woman may touch the purities and eat of the peace sacrifices. Scholarship has already noted this passage’s similarity to the description of graduated entry into the Yahad, described in the Community Rule (1QS VI, 16-21). The fact that this captive woman can also eat of pure food after a certain time has passed suggests that she, too, has become a full member of the group. The present paper investigates whether this passage in the Temple Scroll describes a Gentile woman’s initial conversion to Judaism through marriage. The question is open to investigation because it is uncertain whether this rewritten biblical law indicates that marriage may actually serve as a conversion mechanism for female converts, in this period prior to the introduction of immersion as a conversion requirement. Another passage within the Laws of the King in the Temple Scroll (TS LVII, 15-17) expressly forbids marriage to “the daughters of the nations,” leading one to question whether TS LXIII is indeed permitting it. The paper’s method will consist of comparing TS LXIII both innertextually and intertextually. First, the paper will compare TS LXIII against its scriptural and other legislative parallels, namely Deut 21:10-14 and 1QS VI, 16-21. Second, TS LXIII will be compared innertextually against TS LVII, 15-17 in addition to that passage’s predecessor from biblical law (Lev 21:14). And third, the paper will draw comparisons to other early Jewish writings of Philo and Josephus, in particular to passages which may describe the conversion of Gentile women to Judaism through the act of marriage. This last area for comparison involves non-legal texts, although their contents may comment upon Jewish law. The purpose of the study is not to focus on intermarriage or its prohibitions in general in the Dead Sea Scrolls, but rather to assess a unique piece of rewritten biblical law that may indicate that the result of the marriage described is considered to be a “conversion” in this time period and for this text. Among other findings, the paper will suggest that despite the non-prescriptive nature of the Temple Scroll (and even that of its predecessors in biblical law), a combined approach of assessing changes between legal texts alongside other non-legal texts from ancient Judaism may reveal certain social realities.
|
The High Priest in Glorious Array: Embodying the Meeting of Human and Divine
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Christine Palmer, Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary
The High Priest in Glorious Array: Embodying the Meeting of Human and Divine
|
Do Galatians Feel Comfortable in between the Lines of the Catena Manuscripts?
Program Unit: Novum Testamentum Graecum: Editio Critica Maior
Theodora Panella, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
Scholars in the field of New Testament textual criticism are familiar with theories about text types, families and groups identified by earlier scholars on the basis of the content of manuscripts, even if some of these are considered today as out-dated. The text of the New Testament is found not only in a standalone form in a biblical codex, but also acts as a guide for the creation of commentaries and, later on, for compilations of exegetical comments from multiple sources in the form of the so-called catenae. Several attempts to group New Testament catena manuscripts over the last century and a half, were made by scholars such as Cramer, Caro & Lietzmann, von Soden and Staab, most of the times on the basis of their catena text. This paper will examine the case of the catena on Galatians . More specifically, it will attempt to extract useful information from it regarding the flow of the biblical text in the history of its transmission as well as of its relationship to the text of the catena.
|
"Builder for God": Representations of Nehemiah in Contemporary Children’s Bibles
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Angela Parchen Rasmussen, Georgetown University
The title of one children’s book asks the reader, “Why Did Nehemiah Work So Hard?;” another suggests he is a model of prayer; still another presents him as “Wall Warrior.” This paper analyzes the representations of Nehemiah in contemporary children’s Bibles in the U.S. in light of practices that scholars have observed in the translation of children’s literature: cultural context adaptation, ideological manipulation, and illustration. In terms of cultural context adaptation, how do children’s Bibles convey cultural matters with which children may be unfamiliar, such as proper names [e.g. Levites], laws and customs [e.g. taxation], political terminology [e.g. the role of cupbearer], etc? Ideological manipulation changes elements deemed inappropriate for children by the target culture. How do children’s Bibles deal with topics such as alcohol or the prohibition of intermarriage, and which cultural values are passed on to children through the figure of Nehemiah? Finally, illustrations convey a great deal, and in children’s Bibles they interpret many aspects of the biblical text. How do the illustrations depict Nehemiah and other characters? Do they provide additional historical context and/or convey plot details unstated in the text? What are the characters’ skin tones? To answer these questions, I examine a selection of Bible adaptations published or re-published in the past 35 years, intended for children ages 4-12 of various religious backgrounds and social identities. An overarching issue is the differences in representations of Nehemiah in Christian and Jewish children’s Bibles, and how often he is included in each. Nehemiah is an interesting point of comparison as he is usually at or near the end of Jewish children’s Bibles and at the transition between testaments in Christian Bibles, which tend to overlook the second temple period or give a christological reading to these later texts.
|
Trans-textual Scribes: The Memories Beyond the Manuscript
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Cambry G. Pardee, Pepperdine University
Memory was an asset for the ancient scribe, who typically read a few words or lines, committed them to memory, and reproduced them on a new sheet. The stronger and more acute the scribe’s memory, the faster and more accurately the scribe could copy. In some cases, however, memory was a liability. This paper explores anew the long-recognized scribal phenomenon of harmonization in the Synoptic Gospels and demonstrates that when scribes copied these texts they often moved beyond the manuscript exemplar and into the realm of memory. Harmonization in the earliest centuries was not only a textual phenomenon, but a trans-textual one.
The first part of this paper discusses the general phenomenon of harmonization in relation to memory on the basis of a comprehensive analysis of every manuscript of the Synoptic Gospels from the 2nd–4th century. Harmonization is regularly discussed with other scribal “habits,” but in actuality this practice is less a habit than a reflex activated by familiar material. For example, when the scribe of Codex Guelferbytanus (Q) read the phrase “blessed are the poor” in his exemplar of Luke 6:20, the passage itself automatically and reflexively activated the scribe’s memory of the longer statement “blessed are the poor in spirit” from Matthew 5:3. In this case, the scribe’s “cognitive exemplar,” constituted by the Matthean form, stood in competition with his physical exemplar and exerted the stronger influence. This and other examples explored in this paper indicate that harmonization is a textual phenomenon that reflects trans-textual realities.
Individual manuscripts exhibit the influence of memory differently, as can be seen in the pattern of their variants and especially in their singular readings. The second part of this paper treats several individual manuscripts (e.g. P45, P75, 0171, ℵ, B) and describes the role of memory in their creation. For instance, the third-century scribe of the Chester Beatty Codex of the Gospels and Acts (P45) does not exhibit a uniform practice of harmonization throughout his manuscript, but rather harmonizes in “bursts” as particular pericopae activate his memory of parallel material. By contrast, individual scribes copying in the Alexandrian tradition (P4, P75, B) show themselves to be remarkably resistant to external sources of competing material, even material residing in their memory.
Although the practice of harmonization was recognized already in the time of Origen of Alexandria, analysis of the practice through the centuries has continued to yield new ways of understanding how the gospels were read and understood alone and together. Harmonization especially testifies to the dynamic role of memory in the transmission of Gospel material.
|
Johannine Idea of Incarnation in Ahn Byung-Mu’s Theology
Program Unit: Korean Biblical Colloquium
Chan Sok Park, College of Wooster
While Ahn Byung Mu’s study of ochlos in the Gospel of Mark is commonly referenced whenever his theology is discussed, it is lesser known that he considered the Johannine proclamation of incarnation in John 1:14 as the core of this Gospel’s theology and took it as a basis of his understanding of Jesus. This paper will examine how Ahn interpreted “Logos Christology” in the Fourth Gospel in light of his own “theology of embodiment.” For Ahn, Johannine idea of incarnation is not a factual statement explaining a miraculous event of transforming a diving being into a human being, but a theological remark presenting the notion of “embodiment of logos.” This is a significant shift of the perspective from Christ Kerygma to historical Jesus in Ahn’s overall theological project.
|
Language of Debt Easement in the Synoptic Traditions: Beyond Wishful Thinking into Dreaming an Alternative Reality
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
Eugene Eung-Chun Park, San Francisco Theological Seminary
Burden of debts was one of the most serious social problems in the advanced agrarian society from the Iron Age in the Mediterranean word and in the ancient Levant. It was through debts that the majority of peasants became landless tenants, share croppers, or debt-slaves. There are multiple attestations to decrees for canceling or decreasing debts issued by rulers and legislators in the Greco-Roman antiquities and in the ancient Mesopotamia. Most of them were only temporary measures. There were exceptions to this. That is, the legislations by Solon in the 6th century BCE in pre-classical Athens and the Jubilee laws in ancient Israel. Solon’s legislative reform had two foci. One was the debt cancelation, which was called “seisachtheia (shaking-off of burden)”, and the other was the manumission of debt-slaves. These laws were not meant to be temporary but long-lasting for the duration of up to one hundred years. The Jubilee law, which was most probably codified during the post-exilic period, seems to reflect a political agenda of the priestly aristocrats who returned to the land of Judah from Babylon, and scholars have doubt about its actual implementation on a long-term basis.
This paper will examine The Athenian Constitution by Aristotle and the Life of Solon by Plutarch, which document the laws introduced by Solon to see why Solon did what he was credited to have done and whether the laws were successfully enacted or not, and if they were, to what results. Then it will discuss similar debt easement measures issued by Roman rulers during the early days of the Roman Empire to see how they were different from Solon’s laws. Finally, it will survey scholarly opinions about the Jubilee Law and how it was most probably not implemented, particularly during the Second Temple period. Then it will find evidence in Josephus that the lack of serious debt easement measures in the society from within and the added burden of taxes imposed by the colonizers of the Roman Empire created a miserable condition for ordinary peasants, which eventually caused a political revolt largely supported by peasants with heavy burden of debts.
Against this background, the language of debt easement in various forms of the synoptic traditions, at least in their earlier, pre-synoptic stages, would have reflected a deep sense of despair caused by the burden of debts. This paper will survey a few paradigmatic passages of debts easement in the synoptic gospels and see how the original sayings of Jesus might have intended to covertly reveal the anger of injustice and the feeling of defeat on the part of the indebted peasants and their fanciful wishes that it would have been otherwise. Then it will propose that by way of inviting them to imagine what it would be like if God ruled, these sayings of Jesus are part of the resistance discourse of the oppressed to transform their wishful thinking into dreaming an alternative reality, in which the burden of debts will actually “be shaken off.”
|
The Kingdom of God: Not by a King Nor by a Father, but by the Children of God
Program Unit: Q
Inhee Park, Ewha Womans University
Recently scholarly discussions of Q’ Kingdom of God have broadened beyond the scope of debate about theological genealogies such as apocalyptic or wisdom tradition. Viewing its socio-political aspect brings a possibility for more diverse conversations with other fields and cultures. Since the concept of the kingdom of God generated from political context in Israelite history, it inevitably retains socio-political connotation from its environment. Q’s Kingdom of God, however, manifests far different social ideal from Jewish culture and from ancient Greco-Rome world. Q’s kingdom discourses illustrate the fact that Q pursuits a community based on one’s awareness as children of merciful God which ultimately enables Q community to build a society where its members have an equal obligation of mutual help for one another, and, Q even suggests totally radical social rule of love for enemy which breaks ancient criterion of love and justice. Considering its back ground of destitute socio-economic condition of the first century Galilean villages, Q attempts to strive for an alternative community of reciprocity based on compassion and mercy.
To some extent, Q’s socio-political vision has a similarity with that of Confucianism. In terms of the matter of how one can cultivate and transform oneself in the direction of pure goodness eventually becomes the matter of how one is able to build a good society. In this regard, considering the inter-religious discourse of the earliest Korean Christians in 18th century can shed a new light on Q study. As political philosophers of Neo-Confucianism, they recognized the strength of Christianity as a political ideal of social equality in the meaning of the children of God. They had voluntarily become Christians and developed a religious discourse of Christianity into socio-political conversations that incorporated both Confucian and Christian teaching. This contributed to create a political idea of a more democratic society even in 18th century Asia.
However, their opponents, mostly Confucian elite of ruling class severely accused their concept of children of God. For them, it deluded subjects to believe in the personified God and to prioritize the authority of this invisible father to those of kings and fathers of household, which threat their ideological support of filial piety from Confucianism as well as social system. The more serious problem was this heresy misleading people to believe in immortal soul and not to fear death, and accordingly there was no final solution to eliminate this new socio-political paradigm in spite of death penalty. This historical event is reminiscent of Q’s controversial sayings of Q 12:4 pertained to immortal soul and punishment in Gehenna, which enables us to reconsider Q’s apocalyptic sayings under a view of socio-political resistance. This paper will explore socio-political dimensions of Q especially with insights from the earliest Korean Christian philosophers in order to demonstrate Q’s Kingdom of God as a remarkable political vision for the ancient world and still for today.
|
Meaning One Thing, Saying Another: The Challenge and Advantage of Teaching Biblical Hebrew in English to Students Whose Primary Language is Not
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Seon Young Park, Trinity Evangelical Divinity School
Learning biblical Hebrew is a daunting task for most students. Learning biblical Hebrew in a language other than one’s native language introduces an additional, sometimes formidable, dimension to acquiring a working language of the language. Teaching biblical Hebrew effectively in English to students whose primary language is not English requires an understanding of the multi-language matrix. This paper will identify and examine some of the challenges of Hebrew instruction for third language students. The paper will propose that learning a foreign language (Hebrew) in a foreign language (English) can be inherently advantageous, which, if recognized, can facilitate the learning experience for the third language student. The paper (1) will explore the dynamic of teaching and learning biblical Hebrew through the prism of a non-native language, (2) will evaluate English language Hebrew grammars (or types of grammars) that either facilitate or complicate the learning process, (3) will examine methodologies and approaches most conducive to linguistic comprehension and retention when a third language is the vehicle of instruction, and (4) will propose strategies for effective and successful teaching and learning of biblical Hebrew utilizing English grammars and resources for students whose native language is not English. This co-presented paper emanates from both research and first-hand experience of teaching and learning biblical Hebrew in English when a third language is in the linguistic mix.
|
Unveiling Identity: A Womanist/Feminist Dialogue on the Women of Revelation
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Angela Parker, The Seattle School of Theology & Psychology
This paper is a co-authored piece committed to developing an feminist/womanist dialogical methodology around interrogating identity for contemporary biblical interpretation. Applying this dialogical framework to the women of Revelation, we argue that a conversation between womanist and feminist biblical interpretation opens new perspectives on constructed identity both within the biblical text and within contemporary society. We seek to nuance the author’s imagery by highlighting the particularities of the women in the Revelation context. This paper will bring Revelation into dialogue with the tension that exists between particular identity and collective solidarity when working for social transformation around contemporary race and gender issues. This paper provides a dialogue between feminist and womanist biblical studies that opens up a space for the creation of a critical, yet constructive contextual hermeneutic for social transformation.
|
“Don’t Want to Live like a Refugee": Ishmael as a Poignant and Powerful Precedent
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Julie Faith Parker, General Theological Seminary
Although Ishmael is the first child born in Israel’s historical memory, he is largely overlooked in Jewish and Christian traditions. This paper argues that Ishmael, the foundational ancestor of Islam, sets the example to be followed by Moses and Jesus through his role as an outcast child. I will review narratives about young Ishmael, Moses, and Jesus through a lens that focuses on refugee children. After briefly outlining the oft-cited similarities between Moses and Jesus as endangered children (Exod 1:15-2:10; Matt 2), I will introduce parallels from Ishmael’s story as a boy forced to leave his home (Gen 21:1-21). The paper will include attention to issues of translation and appreciation of characters in roles of accompaniment and advocacy. Ultimately, this paper points to ironies in both text and tradition. The text introduces Ishmael, Moses, and Jesus as child characters who are forced out of their homes and thereby embody vulnerability. Yet these displaced children grow to become the most venerated figures in their religious traditions. The tradition is subverted as Ishmael is the forbearer of the Islam, the latest of the Abrahamic traditions, yet he sets the precedent for Moses and Jesus. In this way, the last becomes first.
|
The Quest for the Rhetorical Jesus: The Innovation of the Q Gender Pairs
Program Unit: Q
Sara Parks, University of Nottingham
This paper demonstrates that the gendered parable pairs of Jesus as found in Q are unprecedented in ancient Mediterranean literature. Their uniqueness is illustrated both through a comparative examination of prior Hellenistic and Jewish literature, and also in relation to the later first-century Christian texts in which the pairs can be said to have an afterlife. With the help of some of the criteria for authenticity in historical Jesus research, the early Christian use of gendered parallels helps to establish them as a rhetorical innovation, and as such, as important evidence for role of women in the earliest Jesus movement.
|
Garments of Glory: An Investigation of Yahweh's Act of Investiture of Clothing in Ezekiel 16:1–14
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Shannon Parrott, Regent College
The subject of dress in the Hebrew Bible yet remains a cursory topic. Often listed as a brief comment, Ezekiel 16:1-14 remains no exception to this in many commentaries. To help remedy this, this paper examines Yahweh’s first act of investiture of dress upon lady Jerusalem. It will look at the meaning and significance of Yahweh’s act of clothing in relation to the affective (emotional) dimensions of this act and the dress itself. Specific attention is given to the crown/wreath of ornamentation and the affections associated with the ‘splendor’ that perfects Jerusalem’s beauty.
|
The Textg of Isaiah in the Hodayot
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Donald Parry, Brigham Young University
The goal of the paper is to compare the Isaianic quotations and allusions in the Hodayot (Thanksgiving Hymns: 1QHa, 1Q35, 4Q427–432) with the Masoretic Text of Isaiah, Qumran Isaiah scrolls, and versions (where appropriate), and to draw conclusions regarding the text critical value of the Hodayot for understanding Isaiah.
|
Colossians and Resurrection: A Pseudepigraphal Remembrance of Paul
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Kyle R.L. Parsons, Charles University in Prague
Concepts of resurrection are diverse within the Pauline tradition. Past approaches have tended to divide the diversity into authentic and inauthentic Pauline traditions. This paper attempts to show how social memory theory helps us to better understand the generational shifts of competing voices. As a case study, resurrection in the pseudepigraphal letter of the Colossians is compared to that of Romans with the aim of showing how the past of Paul and the present of Pseudo-Paul interrelate. Whereas Romans describes resurrection as an imminent eschatological phenomenon (Romans 6), Colossians describes it as a realized eschatological phenomenon (Colossians 2). By viewing Colossians as a memory text, written in a generation after Paul, we can better understand the process of change from one concept of resurrection to another.
|
Textual Criticism and Lukan Studies: The (Dis)connection between the Two
Program Unit: Gospel of Luke
Mikeal Parsons, Baylor University
This paper proposes that scholarship on Luke’s Gospel and the pursuits of textual criticism are mutually beneficial to one another, and thus each would benefit from greater attention to the other. We demonstrate this proposal through three areas of inquiry: (1) the disconnection of recent developments and discussions in textual criticism on the text of Luke from many interpreters and exegetes of Luke; (2) the way in which select commentators of Luke have handled text-critical issues and their relationship to the standard critical edition of their era of scholarship; and (3) the promise of attention to individual early manuscripts and witnesses to the early text of Luke for addressing exegetical and theological issues.
First, this paper asks the extent to which textual scholarship (particularly developments by K. Clarke, B. Ehrman, D. C. Parker, and the IGNTP on Luke) impacts the scholarship in commentaries on Luke. Using case studies (especially Luke 3:22; 19:25; 22:43-44), we consider how textual criticism shapes exegesis as well as how exegesis shapes textual criticism. Second, this paper tests the thesis that commentaries are primarily influenced by the critical text that they use, but not as often the most recent scholarly developments in textual criticism. This is traced as far back as the relationship between Westcott & Hort’s text (1881) and Plummer’s commentary (1st ed. 1896), but can be seen since then with the publication of successive editions of NA and UBSGNT. At what point do commentaries diverge from the critical text and on what grounds? Finally, this paper asks what benefit it would be for Lukan scholars, particularly exegetes and writers of commentaries, to look at the individual manuscript witnesses of Luke themselves. For example, looking at P75 when commenting on Luke (rather than only at the critical text) may hint at the first reception of the text, particularly regarding the origin of the NS ΙΗ and the use of “18” in Luke 13:16. Moreover, further interpretative possibilities and theological considerations could be opened by considering early manuscripts and witnesses as early “reception history” of Luke, which could enrich the task of the history of interpretation of Luke.
|
Healing Paralysis and Divinity: A Background Study to Mark 2:1–12
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Beniamin Pascut, McKeen Study Center, Bowdoin College
Why does Mk 2:1-12 attach undisputed uniqueness to Jesus’ healing of paralysis with the words, “We never saw anything like this!” (v. 12b)? Critical discussion on the ancient view of paralysis is a common lacuna among commentators of this gospel episode (e.g. Weiss and Weiss, 1892; Gould, 1896, Swete, 1898; Wohlenberg, 1910; Lagrange, 1910; Klostermann, 1926; Hargreaves, 1965; Moule, 1965; Nineham, 1969; Lane, 1974l; Mann, 1986; Guelich, 1989; Marcus, 2000; Witherington, 2001; Moloney, 2002; Collins, 2007; Stein, 2008). The present paper fills this research lacuna in three stages, arguing that the elements Mark chooses to include in the story, which reflect the character of similar healings in the Asclepian cult, highlight Jesus’ divine authority and identity. It brings forth evidence from textual, epigraphic and archaeological sources to support Justin Martyr’s claim in his Apology that “when we say that he healed the lame, the paralytic, and those born blind, and raised the dead, we appear to say things similar to those said to have been done by Asclepius.”
|
Precincts and Praxis: Interactions in a Jerusalem without Temple
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
Paul M. Pasquesi, Marquette University
This paper offers a proposal for interpreting passages detailing specific locations and actions in Jerusalem that have traditionally been taken to prove either the pre-70 origins of a source or, conversely, its anachronism and unsuitability as historical data. The suggestion here is that several sources can be used to reconstruct the period between the two Judean Revolts based precisely on the narrative encounters described. These encounters will focus on depictions of Jesus or James interacting with others in specific locations in Jerusalem in the Gospel of John, P. Oxy 840, and Hegesippus (apud Eusebius). Rather than using these as sources for understanding the historical Jesus or James, it will be argued that these sources reflect and thus can be used to understand elements of the interactions of varieties of Judaisms in Jerusalem, in this case Christian Judaism with Levitical priestly Judaisms in the period between the two revolts.
|
Magical Acts: Magical Discourses and Identity Formation in the Acts of the Apostles
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Shaily Shashikant Patel, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University
F. C. Baur argued that Acts (among other texts) represented an effort to present Christianity as a unified tradition free from factional strife. This paper supports Baur’s classic claim by attending to the discourses of magic found in the Book of Acts, specifically those discourses attendant to Paul, and by extension, to Peter. Luke crafts the magical tradition of his two Christian heroes from extant Graeco-Roman discourse of magic. In short, both Peter and Paul perform activities that would have been recognized as having a magical valence by ancient audiences. Despite this, Luke is able to mobilize these discourses towards distinctively Christian ends, at times flouting his own disparaging attitude towards magic. Peter and Paul’s magical repertoire is remarkably similar. In crafting these parallel “discourses of magic,” Luke elevates Paul to the level of Peter, making him an equal partner in the Jesus movement, a co-leader of the nascent church. Moreover, in ossifying a cohesive Christian magical tradition, Luke is able to delineate insiders from outsiders based on how they utilize their magic. Christian agents display proper agency, legitimacy, and orthodoxy when demonstrating magical prowess. It is the ambiguity inherent in Graeco-Roman magic that allows for Luke’s simultaneous execution of these two seemingly contradictory ends – the use of magical discourse to effect cohesion between Peter and Paul, and the use of magical discourse to distinguish insiders from outsiders. This paper foregrounds the ambiguity of magical discourse, first in Graeco-Roman traditions more broadly, then in Acts specifically. I hope to demonstrate how the fluidity of magic as a concept makes it a particularly compelling theological expedient with which Luke carries out his greater program of rapprochement between Petrine and Pauline factions of Christianity.
|
Magic and Polysemy: The Case of the Pseudo-Clementines
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Shaily Shashikant Patel, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University
In the Clementine Recognitions, the Christian hero Peter is described as having done many “signs and miracles divinely performed amongst men.” Despite this blanket assertion of Peter’s magical prowess, any fuller descriptions of his wonderworking ability are slighted in favor of foregrounding philosophical discussions of doctrine. On the other hand, Simon Magus, the antagonist, retains all of the magical abilities ascribed to him in earlier traditions such as the canonical Acts and the Acts of Peter. Simon’s characterization as a magical menace is the focus of this paper. I hope to demonstrate that Simon’s correlation with magic is not simply an adoption of earlier traditions; rather, Simon’s magic is a literary expedient designed to legitimate a particular theological agenda. My paper builds upon the work of scholars who have argued convincingly that Simon is a composite, a literary representation for Paul of Tarsus and other figures incompatible with the Jewish-Christian elements of the Pseudo-Clementines. I hope to offer support to this position by demonstrating that Simon’s magic is also constitutive of this polysemy and functions to intensify not only the associations between magic and heresy, but also between “non-magic” and orthodoxy. In the Pseudo-Clementines, then, magic (as embodied in the figure of Simon) functions as a foil for acceptable belief.
|
The Rebirth and Co-regency of Saul in 1 Samuel 13:1
Program Unit: Book of Samuel: Narrative, Theology, and Interpretation
James Patrick, University of Oxford
1Samuel 13:1 is considered one of the most problematic verses in the Book of Samuel, from the perspective of both textual and narrative criticism. The verse introduces Saul's age at accession and length of reign, yet the numbers in the Hebrew text are usually thought to be the remains of textual corruption. Some English translations leave blanks in this verse, while others remove it completely and place it in a footnote. This paper will summarise past scholarship and argue that both numbers are grammatically acceptable, chronologically accurate, and theologically informed. The accession age of one year is calculated from Saul's 'rebirth' by the Spirit of God following his anointing, and carries connotations of a perfect sacrifice. On the other hand, the two-year length of reign refers to his sole rule after the death of Samuel, under whom he had ruled only as co-regent.
|
An Ever-Rolling Stream: How Time Subverts “Translating for” into “Journeying with”: Half a Century of Bible Translation in Urak Lawoi
Program Unit: Nida Institute
Stephen Pattemore, Bible Society New Zealand
Bible translation in Urak Lawoi’ began with linguistic work in the late 1960s. The Gospel of Mark was published in 1984 and the New Testament in 1998. The Old Testament, though almost complete, is still in the checking phase in 2018. Those raw data reveal time to be one of the primary players in the drama. Time has impacted the agency of translation and its purpose, its cultural context and even its medium. But contrary to contemporary efficiency-based presuppositions and product-oriented drive, the result is not all bad! In the process the task has become rather a journey where the companionship is as important as the goal. This paper will reflect on the exigencies of time and cultural shift over a half a century of Bible translation in Urak Lawoi.
|
Towards an Ecological Guide to Translating the Bible
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Stephen Pattemore, United Bible Societies
Biblical scholars (and some scientists) have long grappled with the often troubled relationship between sacred texts and the current ecological crisis. But the evangelical Christian world has been slow to follow. Despite a groundswell of evangelical authors writing for academic and popular audiences on care of the earth, and the positive impact of essentially evangelical organisations like A Rocha, the fact remains that in these circles, the biblical text itself is sacrosanct and authorititave and often interpreted “as literaly as possible.” Alternative reading strategies, like “reading against” the text, are simply not an option.
Despite well intentioned efforts (such as the Green Bible, and the Earth Bible), the urgency of the ecological crisis has come too late for us in the West to significantly change the language of our Bible translations and traditions. The Green Bible used an existing text (NRSV.) We can and must interpret and re-interpret, obey and argue and resist. Yet in many places of critical importance to conservation there are first Bible translations being made – usually by owners of the land and language. These communities are often in “ecological hotspots” – places with both high biodiversity and high current rates of commercial exploitation of mineral, plant and animal resources for burgeoning populations. While working with indigenous Bible translation teams in Papua New Guinea over the past 17 years, I have often been confronted with the painful dilemma of competing interests between the need to preserve unique natural ecosystems and the right and natural desires of local human communities for better education, food, water, sanitation – and smart phones! The causes are complex and many-sided.
In an earlier paper (2010) I argued for the production of minority language Bibles which are “green to the core” - Bibles which take the contemporary context of ecological crisis as a crucial feature of the context into which the Bible is being translated. They would choose the vocabulary of translation carefully, seeking to amplify the voice of the earth and the priority of its care. They would provide paratextual materials such as notes, break-outs, and introductions, which help the intended audience understand texts that impact the earth and its community (whether helpfully or harmfully) both in their first context and in the contemporary world of the language community. They would seek to demonstrate that care of the earth is part of the “normal Christian life.”
This paper will examine passages from the book of Revelation, not only from the “usual suspects” – passages of ecological devastation (Rev 15) and of new creation (Rev 21-22) – but also from the more mundane (Rev. 1). I will examine assumptions behind the text to help frame them for the translator and suggest some relevant translation choices and places where notes might prove necessary and helpful to the reader. The aim is to provide a model of what might become an “Ecological Guide to Translating the Bible.”
|
“I Will Make Her Male”: Mary Meets Plato in the Gospel of Thomas
Program Unit: Westar Institute
Stephen Patterson, Willamette University
*
|
The Critique of Slavery in Ezekiel and the Book of Revelation
Program Unit: Bible and Ethics
Ian Paul, Fuller Theological Seminary (Pasadena)
Although the Book of Revelation is often considered (in both popular and academic readings) to be 'otherworldly', it includes specific and detailed comment on particular features in its social, material and cultural world. This is introduced in the messages to the assemblies (ekklesiai) in chapters 2 and 3, but is evident throughout the book. Revelation's depiction of humanity is unique in the New Testament in making evident the wide socio-economic range of human life, and emphasises this through its use of OT imagery and its use of merisms ('free and slave, great and small').
Particular attention has been drawn to the economic critique of Rome in chapter 18. The 28 cargoes are at once:
a. structured using one form of Revelation's numerology
b. connected with the material culture of the wealthy Roman elite, and
c. adapted from the critique of Tyre in Ezekiel 27.
The particular language of slaves as 'bodies' and 'human souls' combines the language of the slave market with the terminology of Ezekiel, which in turn draws on the creation narratives of humanity as 'living beings' made in the image of God.
This adoption of biblical tradition in the Book of Revelation contributes significantly to the implicit critique of slavery based on the parity of all humanity made in the image of God found at other points in the New Testament. It has a direct bearing on contemporary Christian ethics, for example contributing explicitly to the Church of England's policy on investment in the extractives industries which often take a serious toll on human life and livelihood.
|
Improving the CBGM: Recent Interactions
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Gregory Paulson, Institut für Neutestamentliche Textforschung
The Coherence-Based Genealogical Method (CBGM) has received a lot of attention lately due to the continued publication of the Editio Critica Maior and the NA28/UBS5. While previously only those who utilize the CBGM method at the INTF in Muenster have published about its background and its application, there have been several extensive interactions with the method in recent years outside of Muenster. Some of these have been positive and some negative, though some elicit fundamental misunderstandings about the method itself. Each of these assessments, however, has proffered ideas for improving the results and usability of the CBGM. In this presentation, I would like to address these ideas and explore both their merits and feasibility.
I will survey four primary responses to the method and highlight their proposals for improving the CBGM. In Don Wilkins’ chapter on the CBGM in The Text of the New Testament (2017), he suggests that a textual commentary be provided, similar to Metzger’s Textual Commentary for the UBS Greek New Testament, and that an interactive program be made available for the users to understand the decision making process. Tommy Wasserman and Peter Gurry, in A New Approach to Textual Criticism (2017), suggest that the CBGM include a way to divide agreements among witnesses into different levels and that corrections in witnesses should count as a separate witness. They also desire that the CBGM include various types of witnesses (i.e. lectionaries, patristic sources, and versions), less regularization of variants, and that a fully customizable version of the CBGM be made available for the public. Gurry in his dissertation, A Critical Examination of the Coherence-Based Genealogical Method in New Testament Textual Criticism (2017), adds that coincidental agreement should be removed from pre-genealogical coherence and that the data behind the textual flow diagrams should be presented along with the diagrams themselves. He also adds that the reconstruction of lost hyperarchetypes should be able to be carried out and that coherence should be able to be utilized from multiple variation units (across multiple books) at once. While Bengt Alexanderson, in Problems in the New Testament (2014), exhibits an unfortunate misunderstanding of the CBGM, he nevertheless offers one way for improvement: the addition of patristic evidence in genealogical coherence.
While engaging with these proposals for improving the CBGM, I will describe which ideas might be desirable and realistic. I will explain the steps currently being taken by the INTF to make certain suggestions a reality and highlight why other proposals are incompatible with the method. It is hoped that explaining which tools are already available for users and what changes will be carried out in the future will bring more clarity about the method itself as well as its tremendous potential to elucidate the development of the textual tradition of the Greek New Testament.
|
Verbal Irony in Translation: The Septuagint Prophets
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Matthew Pawlak, University of Cambridge
In comparison to questions of history and theology, the subjects pertaining to the field of humour research have received relatively little attention in biblical studies generally. Fortunately, recent scholarship on the Hebrew Bible has begun to pay greater attention to humour as an area of study in its own right, recognizing the importance of comic elements in understanding the Old Testament (Garrison, 1960; Kruger, 2014; Radday, Yehuda T and Brenner, 1990). Alongside this growing interest in humour, researchers have also turned a degree of focused attention to the subject of irony (see Domeris, 2016; Good, 1981; Luciani, 2009; Sharp, 2009; Williams, 1977), though such studies do not always differentiate between irony's various forms. Furthermore, past studies on humour and irony have generally focused on the Hebrew version of the Old Testament. While this is a valuable enterprise, it leaves the interesting subject of how these humorous and ironic passages are brought across from Hebrew to Greek in translation untouched. To address this gap in the field, this paper seeks to assess, on a linguistic level, the way that the translators of the LXX convey verbal irony. While the theoretical discussions are complex, verbal irony may be distinguished from more literary forms of irony-such as situational and dramatic irony-insofar as it consists of statements that communicate an oppositional evaluation to the evaluation implied by the normal use of the words themselves (Bailin, 2015; Haiman, 1998: 20). For reasons of scope, we shall use the Septuagint Prophets as our test case, as the prevalence of satire and polemic in these texts makes them fertile ground for ironic reversal and sarcastic remarks. The nature of the LXX as a corpus makes it an excellent case study for observing how implicit speech is conveyed in translation. Attending to the similarities and differences between the Hebrew and Greek versions of the Prophets will enable inquiry into the extent to which the translators of the LXX have understood the ironic nature of the original texts, and how they have carried these readings into Greek. Such observations have the potential to nuance considerably our understanding of the linguistic means speakers of ancient Hebrew and Greek had at their disposal for conveying irony.
|
Ancient Democratic Discourse and Paul's Use of Eleutheria in 2 Cor 3:12–18
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
Steven T. Payne, Fordham University
Scholars have variously interpreted the Apostle Paul’s use of “eleutheria.” One of the commonest valences of this term, however, has received little consideration. As Mogens Herman Hansen has argued, eleutheria was principally male citizens’ equal prerogative to govern in a democratic polis. Yet the traditional narrative asserts that Paul could not have had this meaning in mind since Greek democracy had long disappeared by the Roman period. Both historians of the Greek city and some New Testament scholars have begun to unsettle this presupposition. Such scholarship contends that democracy remained lively in many municipalities until at least the middle of the third century. Still, does this shed any light on Paul’s employment of eleutheria? More regularly, Paul either contrasts eleutheria with slavery or lends the word a philosophical sense. In 2 Cor 3:12–18, however, Paul curiously contrasts the “veil” that Moses wore at the time of the Sinai covenant (cf. Ex 34:35) with the eleutheria brought about by Christ’s pneuma. Paul’s peculiar use of eleutheria here has received some illumination with reference to Stoic or Cynic moralizing discourse. Nevertheless, building off the recent work of Anna C. Miller, in this paper I will propose that we can further understand 2 Cor.’s utilization of eleutheria in relation to ancient democratic discourse.
The first part of this paper shall read Paul’s presentation of Moses and the Israelite congregation in Exodus in conjunction with Josephus’s near-contemporary retelling of these scriptural motifs in Ant. 4. This shall allow us to perceive the ways in which the two similarly frame the Exodus account in terms of ancient democratic discourse, though to different ends. While Josephus construes Moses and the Israelites as paragons of democracy, Paul depicts both in antithesis to democracy and does so precisely through his midrash on Moses’s “veil,” which he implicitly marks as a sign of subservience. Paul, his companions, and the Christ Assembly at Corinth, in contrast, manifest particularly democratic virtues. This is because those “in Christ” all alike have Christ’s pneuma, and “where the pneuma of the Lord is, there is eleutheria” (2 Cor 3:17). The second part of this paper shall make sense of this compounding of “pneuma” and “eleutheria” with the aid of recent scholarship on the first of these terms. As such studies have argued, for Paul, Christ’s pneuma not only incorporates those who have been baptized into a new lineage, but also at some level transforms such ones into men. In this passage, therefore, those “in Christ” would enjoy eleutheria and would be empowered to shed their — literal, metaphorical? — veils because Christ’s pneuma has imparted the genealogical and sexed requirements for full inclusion in the messianic Assembly. I shall finally explore the grounds this reading provides for reconstructing the further development of Paul’s conflict with the women prophets in the Christ Assembly at Corinth. Paul might indeed cede to arguments made against women’s veiling by his opponents. Yet he does so by reinscribing the male-centric notion of citizenship that typically prevailed in ancient democratic discourse.
|
Rules of Engagement: God's Permission of Evil in Selected Cases of Scripture
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
John Peckham, Andrews University
Rules of Engagement: God's Permission of Evil in Selected Cases of Scripture
|
Church of Worshipers of the Present-and-Coming King: The Time and Place of Worship in the Epistle to the Hebrews
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Amy Peeler, Wheaton College (Illinois)
Church of Worshipers of the Present-and-Coming King: The Time and Place of Worship in the Epistle to the Hebrews
|
Isaiah in Codex Sinaiticus
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Ken Penner, Saint Francis Xavier University
In this time slot I will present a portion of commentary on the book of Isaiah for the Brill Commentary on the Septuagint series.
|
Church as the Community Gathered before the King
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Jonathan Pennington, Southern Baptist Theological Seminary
Church as the Community Gathered before the King
|
Arms and the Unman: The Role of Masculinity in Tertullian's Arguments against Military Service
Program Unit: Inventing Christianity: Apostolic Fathers, Apologists, and Martyrs
Alexander D. Perkins, Fordham University
Scholars who wish to argue that the attitude of early Christians toward the Roman army was contentious, if not antagonistic, often turn to Tertullian as their primary source. Some scholars have claimed that the North African’s apparent distaste for Christians serving in the military stemmed from theological concerns over idolatrous practice among the ranks (Helgeland 1974, Osborn 1997). More recently, a strong argument has emerged for viewing Tertullian as staunchly anti-war and against Rome’s imperial project on moral grounds (Kalantzis 2012). However, Tertullian’s arguments against Roman military service also have a gendered dimension that has yet to be explored. In this paper, I perform a close reading of Tertullian’s comments on the military with special attention to the role of masculinity in the apologist’s polemic.
In the Republican period, the Roman elite considered the soldier to be an archetype of masculinity. It was no coincidence that Roman leaders preferred elite enlistees within their ranks. The leaders considered these men capable of the modestia and disciplina purportedly required for the smooth operation of the military (Phang 2008). The second-century saw changes in military demographics that ignited what Kuefler calls a “crisis of manliness” among the Roman elite (Kuefler 2001). As military enrollment among the lower classes surged, the common soldier became a man of questionable motives in the eyes of the elite. Veterans detested these new recruits for what they felt was an unrefined and brutish nature. For upper-class individuals like Cassius Dio, the concern was that, since the new soldiers were “uneducated men of low degree,” they were incapable of the discipline that assured the Roman soldier’s manliness (Dio, Hist. 68.7.5). In their view, this left the defense of Rome’s borders in the hands of a powerful yet insufficiently manly mob. As a result, in literary and rhetorical productions, the body of the soldier, once the paragon of manliness, became a site for contesting masculinity.
For Tertullian, an elite provincial whose community already suffered at the hands of Roman soldiers, this cultural moment provided an opportunity to reframe the social position of the Christian man. I argue that Tertullian’s attacks on the military and its idolatrous practices in his Apologeticum follow this second-century pattern of calling the masculinity of the Roman soldier into question. Tertullian’s invective is not directed at idolatry or the military per se; rather, the apologist portrays the idolatrous practices of Roman soldiers as throwing the masculinity of the military into disarray and thus threatening the social and moral security of Rome. The faults of the Roman military, he seems to claim, stem not from the refusal of its Christian members to participate in its polytheistic traditions. On the contrary, it is the Christian who is the truly masculine soldier who can fight the physical and spiritual threats Rome faces and who alone can guarantee its well-being.
|
Plague Terms and Plague Descriptions in Greek Exodus: Strategies Used by the Translator to enhance the Narrative.
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Larry Perkins, Northwest Baptist Seminary/ACTS, Langley, B.C.
Exodus 7-12 narrates Yahweh’s ten, increasingly punitive actions to persuade Pharaoh to send Israel into the desert to worship him. The variations in the length of the accounts and the terminology employed in the Hebrew text is mirrored in the Greek translation. However, the translator also in some contexts seems to dramatize the action beyond what the MT reads. Whether these transformations were already present in the translator’s Hebrew text or were alterations made by himself is much discussed. In this paper I seek to identify a variety of ways in which the Greek text differs from the MT and in some cases presents the plague(s) stories in a narrative form more appealing to a Greek-speaking audience. In so doing the translator shows how Yahweh delivers Israel “by a raised arm and great judgment” (6:6) and “with great vengeance” (7:4; 12:12). If this can be demonstrated from the text-linguistic data of LXX Exodus, then this would be another indication that this translator has a larger vision for his work than just producing a Greek crib for the corresponding Hebrew text.
|
The Scribal Architecture of Ancient Jewish Aramaic Literature: Case Studies in Textual Variants among the Qumran Aramaic Corpus
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Andrew Perrin, Trinity Western University
The Aramaic Dead Sea Scrolls corpus includes previously unknown mid-Second Temple period writings, original language versions of Jewish literature received in other works, and the earliest witnesses to the limited heritage of Aramaic writings received as scripture in various canons of Judaism and Christianity. In many ways, the compositional development and scribal cultures behind these ancient texts are yet to be fully explored. One area of particular importance regards the collation and evaluation of the overlaps between those fragmentary Aramaic texts attested in multiple manuscripts across the Qumran library (e.g., 1 Enoch, Tobit, Aramaic Levi Document, Visions of Amram, Four Kingdoms, and New Jerusalem). In this paper, I will present a cross-section of examples from a larger study on the textual variants that exist among copies of these compositions. These variant readings hold the potential to illumine the earliest shape, content, transmission, and linguistic variation of Aramaic literature emerging in scribal settings of ancient Judaism.
|
An Apocalyptic Movement that Wrote Apocalypses? Reconsidering the Interface of Danielic Traditions and Qumran Identity
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Andrew Perrin, Trinity Western University
Daniel’s influence on Qumran origins and outlooks has been explored at intervals. However, most discussions on this topic equate Daniel with the canonical work of his namesake and isolate the Qumranites as a solo sectarian group awaiting the eschaton off the saline beaches of the Dead Sea. The present study, however, reframes the question by taking the following dual premise as its departure point: the library of the Dead Sea Scrolls both attests to a broader set of Danielic traditions in antiquity and evidences that the Qumranites were likely but one expression of an Essene or Essene-like movement. Using the Aramaic Pseudo-Daniel (4Q243-4Q245) materials as a case study, the paper will reconsider several key aspects of the fragments that may suggest they originated in a scribal or communal setting reflective of this broader socio-religious diversity. These include: scribal features (e.g., use of paleo-Hebrew for penning divine epithets), approaches to scriptures (e.g., shared exegetical traditions with the Damascus Document), and conceptual categories or motifs of mutual interest (e.g., priestly lines, resurrection, spiritual blindness). While Pseudo-Daniel is not a “sectarian” text it may provide a space for rethinking the way complex textual traditions informed the shaping of the larger movement.
|
The Editorial Aside of Mark 13:14 ("Let the Reader Understand") and Its Implications for the Gospel’s Earliest Performances
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Nicholas Perrin, Wheaton College Graduate School
Over the past several decades, the study of the Gospel of Mark has demonstrated not only an increasing appreciation of the gospel’s aural design, but also growing interest in exploring what implications this insight might have for interpretation (Rhoads, Dewey, Robbins, etc.). Yet if the Gospel of Mark was more properly “performed” than “read,” the social and/or liturgical conditions under which this performance was first executed remain obscure. In this paper, following a review of recent scholarship surrounding the meaning of the phrase “Let the reader understand” (Mark 13:14), I will maintain that this enigmatic phrase was inserted in order to tip off the gospel’s enlisted performers to certain intertextual allusions at play in the text. On this basis, it is further argued that the first rehearsals of Mark’s gospel were not performances simpliciter, but scripted recitations supplemented as necessary by explanatory comments from duly authorized readers.
|
“Do Not Harm the Trees!” Ecology, Empire, and Translation in the Book of Revelation
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Peter S. Perry, Fuller Theological Seminary (Arizona)
The Book of Revelation shows an unexpected interest in trees, and not only for their symbolic or anthropocentric value. Relevance Theory helps compare various interpretive options an audience might consider. An audience’s understanding of the warning to “not harm the trees” will be affected by their awareness of the effects of storms, locust plagues, imperial deforestation, siege tactics, and prophetic use of these topics to expose the effects of human sin on creation. Paratextual aids in translations of these passages will help modern audiences become more aware of these cognitive effects. Using different words to translate the Greek terms δένδρον (used to refer to earthly trees that other creatures are dependent on) and ξύλον (used for the symbolic “Tree” of Life) will further emphasize the earthly and ecological concern of the Seer’s visions.
|
The Paradox of Lying Historians and Jesus Research
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
John J. Peters, Regent University
An explosion of research on historiography has followed in the wake of the decline and fall of the form critical consensus in New Testament scholarship. While this is a welcome development, a largely unrecognized obstacle to modern research on the ancient world continues to be the prevalent amount of accusations against ancient historians concerning their proclivity to lie and retail false information. Although it is common for modern historians to accuse ancient historians of lying, few have engaged the data on ancient critics who did the same to near contemporaries, and even fewer have considered the implications and problems that lying presents to modern research. As it has become the dominant view that the gospels represent some sort of historiography, probably biographies in the Greco-Roman sense, the subject is germane to historical research on Jesus.
T. P. Wiseman’s 1993 essay “Lying Historians: Seven Types of Mendacity” remains perhaps the fullest discussion of the topic to date. Although widely referenced, no one has endeavored to advance beyond Wiseman’s analysis, despite his comment that “the paradox of lying historians needs a wider enquiry.” The current paper takes up Wiseman’s invitation and endeavors to contribute to a wider inquiry on the subject of lying ancient historians giving particular attention to its implications for research on Jesus.
The ancient data lead broadly to the following overlapping conclusions: either (1) a prominent problem of lying existed among ancient historians; or (2) a prominent problem of accusing historians of lying existed, accusations which themselves may have been lies; or (3) a mixture of (1) and (2) existed which entails, among other things, that a noteworthy problem of lying existed both among historians and the writers who attacked them. These data present a very complex problem which, among other things, raise the epistemic question: how can modern historians’ statements about the ancient past be true and reliable if the sources for their statements, the texts, are sprinkled with lies which modern historians are unable to detect or discern? Another aspect of the paradox is expressed in the following question: how is it that so many accusations of lying were made against writers in a genre supposedly characterized by telling the truth? The dramatically contrasting portraits of historians suggest that ancient expectations for the genre were much more variegated than modern scholars generally recognize. Although no single definition of lying existed, all authors stood resolutely against the practice of lying by historians in principle.
The paper concludes by comparing Detlev Fehling’s treatment of the “fictive character” of Herodotus with Arthur Droge’s treatment of the “deliberate literary deceit” of Luke and concludes that Fehling’s and Droge’s disbelief in the methodological claims of their respective authors results in historical portraits that necessarily characterize them as clever liars. The paper does not resolve the problem of lying historians, but endeavors, among other things, to make scholars aware that writing about the ancient past necessarily involves making evaluative judgements about the character of ancient authors.
|
Isaiah’s Theophany and the Opening Petitions of the Lord’s Prayer
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Jeffrey Peterson, Austin Graduate School of Theology
Scholarly interpretation of the Lord’s Prayer (Matt 6:9–12; Luke 11:2–4; cf. Didache 8:2) tends to focus on how its individual petitions should be construed. With respect to the prayer as a whole, the question most often considered is whether its orientation is eschatological or quotidian; even that issue, while informed by debates about whether the historical Jesus was more sage or apocalyptic seer, often turns largely on the interpretation of the rare adjective epiousios in the petition for bread (Matt 6:11; Luke 11:3). Easily lost in such discussions, however, is a sense of the prayer’s internal coherence. This paper’s contribution to recovery of this sense is the recognition that, especially in Matthew and the Didache, the prayer’s first three petitions evoke the theophany in which Isaiah was called to bear witness to God’s coming intervention in the life of his people (Isaiah, chap. 6).
The prayer’s allusions to Isaiah 6 have largely escaped the notice of scholars. Yet in his call vision, Isaiah sees YHWH enthroned as “king” over the earth (Isa 6:1, 3, 5), attended by seraphim who declare his name “holy” (Isa 6:2–3), and preparing to execute his will, in the form of judgment on the kingdoms of Israel and Judah (Isa 6:8–13). Isaiah’s theophany plausibly informs the Matthaean petitions that, as in heaven so on earth, God’s name be hallowed, his kingdom come, and his will be done (Matt 6:9–10). In Luke’s version of the prayer, possible echoes of Isaiah’s theophany are limited to God’s (coming) “kingdom” and his “hallowed” name (Luke 11:2); these are more explicit in the Isaianic intertext than the more diffusely expressed idea of the divine “will” yet to be accomplished. This difference between the two Synoptic versions of the prayer can be accounted for either by the evangelists’ use of divergent oral or written sources, or by Matthaean or Lucan redaction.
The echoes of Isaiah’s theophany invite the reader/hearer/user of the prayer to enter in imagination into God’s presence and stand among the celestial chorus before the heavenly throne to plead for the divine advent (Matt 6:9–10) and for those things that are needful while awaiting its arrival (Matt 6:11–13). In both Matthew and Luke-Acts, the evocation of Isaiah’s call vision in the Lord’s Prayer coheres with the use of Isa 6:9–10 (first attested in Mark 4:12) as a prophetic template for the ministry of Jesus (Matt 13:14–15; cf. Luke 8:10) or of the church (Acts 28:26–27). Matthew’s quotations from Isaiah chaps. 7–9 (Matt 1:23; 4:15–16) and Luke’s allusions (cf. Luke 1:31, 32, 79; 2:34; 8:10; 20:18) attest that the prophetic text beginning with Isaiah’s theophany supplied the evangelists a rich quarry from which they drew freely in constructing their literary portraits of Jesus’ ministry. Recognition of the prayer’s Isaianic echoes promises a greater appreciation of its significance in the texts and communities that transmitted it, as well as a clearer context for the interpretation of its individual petitions.
|
Qoheleth and Epicurus on the Harm of Death
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Jesse Peterson, University of Durham
Many scholars have attempted to relate the message of the Hebrew sage Qoheleth to that of the Hellenistic philosopher Epicurus, and parallels have often been identified in Qoheleth’s prominent carpe diem theme. Typically, the effort has been made to demonstrate literary dependence on the assumption that the Jewish sage is gleaning from his Greek contemporary.
But this paper is less interested in the question of dependence and more interested in a philosophical comparison between the two thinkers. In particular, given their undeniably shared emphasis on the enjoyment of life, how do the two writers respectively conceive of death’s harm—whether and why a person’s death may constitute a harm against that person? The question is both ancient and contemporary. Epicurus’ well-known argument for death’s benignity is still widely discussed in contemporary philosophy of death, providing a kind of roadblock through which any intuitive suggestion of death’s harmfulness must pass. His argument, and the more contemporary debates it has fed, will be articulated in our presentation. Qoheleth, on the other hand, for all his apparently Epicurean tendencies when discussing the good things in life, takes a decidedly anti-Epicurean position concerning death’s harm: death is not only a harm for its victims, but the greatest harm perpetrated against humanity. What exactly constitutes death’s harm for Qoheleth, and how his rationale differs from Epicurus’ as well as contemporary philosophers’ notions, will be discussed in the paper. An analysis of key passages in the book will find five distinct senses in which death directly harms its victim.
By simulating this ancient conversation our project contributes to several wider scholarly issues: the use of contemporary philosophy in studying ancient Jewish texts in general and Qoheleth in particular; the relationship between Qoheleth and Hellenistic philosophy; and the study of death and the afterlife in ancient Jewish literature.
|
“Open Your Mouth, Judge Rightly”: Wise Speech and Wise Restraint in Proverbs
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Catherine Petrany, Saint Vincent College
In Proverbs 31:8-9, the queen mother exhorts her royal son Lemuel to “open your mouth” (פתח־פיךָ) on behalf of another, namely those who cannot themselves speak, the poor, and the needy. The queen mother’s exhortation is placed in the final chapter of a book that both prizes and warns against the power of words as such. The sages aim to offer the “words of discernment” (Prov 1:2) that give life (e.g. Prov 10:11, 20; 15:4), and yet remain acutely attentive to the easy distortion of words by the foolish, and the danger that words pose for those commencing the path to wisdom (e.g. Prov 2:12-13, 16). In the sayings, wise speech is often restrained speech and even silence (e.g. Prov 10:19; 11:12-13). Moreover, the role of the addressee, the son to whom the father gives his instructions in Proverbs 1-9, lies primarily in hearing (e.g. Prov 1:8; 2:2; 4:1, 10, 20; 5:1; 7:1), that is, in remaining wordless himself. So too does Woman Wisdom appeal to the listening ears of her audience (Prov 1:33; 8:6, 32-34) rather than their voices. A kind of active receptivity characterizes the path to wisdom: listening, observing, reflecting, and restricting speech.
Within this context, the queen mother’s call to her son affirms the culminating moment of wise entrance into explicit verbal agency on the part of the addressee/son identified throughout the book. This entrance into words on the part of the son, into the art of becoming a wise speaker, finds precedent in the father’s instructions, which point toward a verbal future for the son (Prov 2:3). The particular shape of this wise speech in Proverbs 31:8-9 influences the broader appeal to wise verbal restraint throughout the book and vice versa. The focus on justice for the vulnerable in the queen mother’s appeal undercuts the negative impact of communicative restraint in the face of injustice, the tyranny of silence in the midst of suffering that scholars such as Walter Brueggemann have so well illuminated in relation to the biblical lament tradition. On the other hand, this final exhortation for Lemuel to speak the words of advocacy is contextualized by the broader ethic of wise verbal restraint that characterizes the book of Proverbs as a whole. In this way, wise silence and wise restraint provide the framework for appropriate speech – speech at the appropriate time, speech on behalf of another, speech that calls forth justice.
|
The Ideology of Kingship from Saul to Frank Underwood
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Christina Petterson, Australian National University
This paper constitutes the first steps of a reception history of the ideology of kingship. Considering representations of kingship from Saul, through Machiavelli/Shakespeare, and European absolute monarchy, this paper seeks to understand exactly how sovereignty is conceptualised in engagement with biblical kingship. Then, taking Foucault’s statement about how political theory still has not cut off the head of the king, I look at how this understanding of sovereignty is replicated in the two versions of House of Cards, and their depiction of power.
|
The Superman? Symbol and Mythopoeic Worlds
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Jeff Pettis, Fordham University
This study examines the childhood experience of symbol as part of mythopoeic culture including early Christianity. At the focus of this discussion is a young man in Central Park who finds subjective meaning in the letter “S” as part of his superman shirt. The shirt as symbol gives him a sense of flight and movement. Like the ancient Egyptian bird Horus given birth by his mother Isis, the boy in Central Park in his fantasy ‘soars into the sky.’ Most likely this young man is well versed in the Western mythology of Superman. In some ineffable way the "S" symbol provides everything Superman represents for this child: super-human ability, as well as human vulnerability. At the same time, learning ‘to fly’ involves experiencing failure. While bounding forward the child looks back and fixates on his mother to secure her attention. In doing so his movement is arrested by a vertical obstacle in the road. Had he not become fixated upon his mother, he would not have fallen. Rather, the task of the young man as one moved by the symbol “S” is learning to be part of the spiritual world into which he bounds, as well as the relational world of the mother from which he comes. Such co-relation constitutes the very nature of symbol itself. Jungian Jolande Jocabi writes that a symbol is that "third thing” made through and mediating the tensive relationship between spirit and matter, the masculine-soaring and the feminine-earth. Interestingly, the actual serpentine shape of the letter “S” is representative of such bivalence. At its source the serpent occurs as a fundamental archetype in the ancient world and specifically early Christianity and its texts. Is this symbol inherent to the unconscious at the collective level? The late first century Gospel of John 3.12-13 says Christ as Son of Man will be raised as Moses raised a bronze serpent in the wilderness. Compare the ancient Asclepius cult, newly adopted by Rome in the time of Jesus, which relies on the serpent’s bite to restore health. It would seem that the human psyche has an inextricable relation with symbol as transformative medium. It may be that both on an individual and collective level one is especially prone to and available to the power of symbol in early life. At the same time, as with the young man, early Christian authors caught up in the mythopoeic and transformative power of symbol will also have to negotiate polarities, with a focus ultimately on Jesus both human and divine. Questions follow. Are those at a stage of early development such as the young man in the park and early Christian communities especially prone toward the transformative experience of symbol? Are there obstacles in early Christian writings which result in an arrest of movement and the loss of life-force come through various symbols? In what ways do early Christian authors fixate on one aspect at the expense of the opposite bivalent aspect of symbol?
|
Fiery Twins: James, John, and the Sons of Zeus
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Jeff Pettis, Fordham University
In Luke 9.54 the brothers James and John claim the ability to exact fire/lightening in order to destroy the Samaritans. Jesus seems to understand and take seriously this power of his twin disciples. He turns and rebukes them, disallowing their request and thus the perceived potency of their heavenly fire. The brothers, who are given no distinctions to separate them one from the other, have parallels with the Dioscuri, Castor and Pollux the “sons of Zeus.” They also have the power of fire from heaven as “glorious…deliverers of humans” (Homeric Hymn 33). In a storm they manifest round the mast of a ship—also known as St. Elmo’s Fire. In Acts 28.11 Paul speaks of traveling to Rome on a ship “with the Twin Brothers as figurehead” (parasemo Dioskourois). The images probably appeared on either side of the ship’s prow to assure safe journey. Given the association of Jesus’ twin disciples with the celestial twins of Zeus, the question follows, in what way(s) does the early church respond to and negotiate Greek and Roman mythology as potent religio-spiritual material? To what extent do authors bring such content into relationship within and as part of early Christian narrative? It would seem that New Testament texts point to definitive contrast of the the twin disciples and their association with the heavenly twins over and against Jesus himself. He is one whose own powers clearly establish him as a figure of authority. James and John are portrayed reverently seeking the power (se poieses) of Jesus, specifically to sit with him en doxe sou, “in your glory” (Mark 10.35-37). As if to establish a distinction of greater status, Jesus makes it clear that they have no knowing (oidate) nor the ability/power (dunasthe) to acquire such glory (Mark 15.38). In Mark 3.17 the twin disciples are given directly the surname “Boanerges,” “sons of Thunder/Zeus” by Jesus, but Jesus alone receives the apocalyptic title Son of Man (Mark 2.10, 28; 8.31, 38; 9.9, 12; 10.33, 45; etc.). For the early church such authority is rooted in sacrifice and inseparable from the rituals of “drinking the cup I drink and being baptized with the same baptism” (Mark 10.38). These texts are telling therefore, of a rhetoric of degrees of divinity perceived and apportioned by early Christian writers. The twins James and John have heavenly identification as well as inner access to Jesus their teacher. However, neither they nor, it follows, the heavenly twins, are presented as being on a level equal to Jesus. Ultimately, it will be Jesus alone, transfigured, who will stand before the twin disciples (and Peter) on the mountain, his clothing, as the author Luke notes, “white as lightening” (Luke 9.29). Even Moses and the fiery prophet Elijah on the mountain with Jesus are unequal to Jesus: “And suddenly looking around they [the disciples] no longer saw any one with them but Jesus only” (Mark. 9.8).
|
Longing for Flowing Streams: Water as Metaphor and Mediator in Psalm 42
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
David Pettit, Iliff School of Theology and University of Denver
I argue in this paper that water is a metaphor in Psalm 42. The Psalmist invokes water, and the thirst for it, to evoke something of his/her yearning for God. But water, as experienced in the natural landscape, is also a sign of the divine that mediates God's presence and intervention. In this way, water both evokes yearning metaphorically and is the object of that same yearning.
Psalm 42 draws from the natural world in order to express something about the inner longing and anxiety the psalmist feels over separation and absence of God, and the consequent threats to the psalmist's well-being. In this sense, water functions as a metaphor in Psalm 42; a way of expressing what is hard to say "straightforwardly" about longing for the divine, the life giving, and the life-preserving. Psalm 42 opens with two lines set in parallel and connected with the preposition, k, "like," or "as," creating a set of correspondences. The deer corresponds to the Psalmist's nepeš, the deer's thirst corresponds to the nepeš longing, and flowing streams of water to God. This correspondence between water and God leads Holt to argue for the metaphorization of God as water. She draws from ancient iconography to assert the association between the divine and water, both fresh life-giving water, and salt/chaos waters. But even as God is metaphorized as water in Psalm 42, drawing from the natural world to say something about the divine which the psalmist yearns for, this is more than a conceptual metaphor-God as life-giving water. We have both idea and object. And while the turn to cognitive linguistics has been helpful in drawing attention to the ways conceptual metaphors help us think about, talk about, and express ideas and experiences, we sometimes lose focus on the object itself. In this case, we lose sight of the connection between the psalmist and water in the natural world. Water is also one mode by which the divine is experienced to be present. Like Baal bringing the rain, or the showdown in I Kings 18, water signifies divine presence and intervention. In Psalm 68 water is implied when the earth yields its increase as a sign of God's blessing. I suggest, therefore, that water in Psalm 42 functions both as metaphor for the divine and as mediator of the divine. These two functions are entwined. Water does not merely say something about the divine or signify some internal experience of the divine (as Holt suggests) but represents externally an experience of the divine as well. To have one's nepeš satiated, is to experience divine help. The imagery of water, moreso, directs the listener towards a deeper experience of the landscape through which they have experienced divine presence and absence: both life-giving water and life-threatening water (raging waters of 42:8 MT). As Elaine James states, landscape is not, "a neutral backdrop against which a literary event takes place; rather, it is already a conceptualization of the relationship between humans and their environs."
|
Masorah figurata as Visualised Parshanut
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Kay Joe Petzold, Heidelberg University
The Masorah forms a constituent part of the Masoretic Text of the Hebrew Bible and comprises the linear annotations of mediaeval Bible Codices. Especially in the Western European tradition, the Naqdanim started to shape the Masorah magna as figurative micrography. Those micrographic illustrations consist of various material (numerical Masorah and Okhla-we-Okhla lists), but behind the figurative micrography there was a program of exegetical narratives which relate to the content of the actual folio and which correlates masoretic annotation with exegetical interpretations.
The paper will discuss the appearance and material character of masoretic list material as part of the Masorah figurata in Ms Vat. ebr. 14, and elucidate the hermeneutical implications of the visualized Parshanut.
|
The St Cuthbert Bible: Exploring a Text in Material, Digital, and Replica Form
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Peter M Phillips, University of Durham
The St Cuthbert Gospel (formerly known as the Stonyhurst Bible) is the oldest intact European book, dating from the early 8th century CE. The original Gospel is part of the British Library's collection, having been purchased from the Jesuit Mission in Britain in 2012 for £9million. The British Library has digitised the manuscript and the digital format can be reviewed at http://www.bl.uk/manuscripts/Viewer.aspx?ref=add_ms_89000_fs001r. Replicas of the Gospel are now readily available both in gift shops in Durham Cathedral and the British Museum and also online. The book contains the text of the Gospel of John.
This paper explores the three instantiations of the Gospel and compares the opportunities, benefits and limitations of each version, as well as looking at the technological affordances of each instantiation. Of particular interest will be the differences between digital and material instantiations and also between the two material instantiations - is the replica a good research tool. Moreover comments will be made about the potential benefits of using material replicas for academic research over against digitised originals.
The digitisation of manuscripts is a major academic industry, which has led to an important increase in first class research in what those manuscripts reveal. However, there is an increasing conversation about where we go next with digitisation and of the potential limitations in terms of durability and longevity for these academic projects. This paper will explore whether material replicas, either printed on traditional tech or through 3D printing, might provide a more durable research tool for academics.
The paper will include a visual exploration of St Cuthbert's Bible, as well as an opportunity to handle a contemporary material replica of the book.
|
Human Identity and Violence against Supposed Nonhumans in the Bible, Bladerunner 2049, and Contemporary Society
Program Unit: Bible and Film
Peter M Phillips, University of Durham
Bladerunner 2049 (Denis Villeneuve, 2017) is the sequel to cult science fiction film Bladerunner (Ridley Scott, 1982). Both films present a dystopian future in which andriods are used by security forces to track down other androids who have sought to hide among the human population. Both films purposefully play on the ambiguity between human and android identity. In the first film, however, there is little exploration of the topic in the script itself. In the follow up, much more of the film's script focuses on the ambiguities between human and android identity and, on occasion biblical allusions are made both to reinforce or seek to clarify the ambiguity, especially in scenes including Niander Wallace (Jared Leto).
This paper explores the tensions between the picture of human identity offered in Bladerunner 2049 and intimations of human identity within the Bible text, focussing particularly on two scenes from Bladrunner 2049, the unveiling of a new android update called Eve and the introduction of the new version of Rachel. Both scenes depict extreme violence against women. The purpose of the paper is to reflect on the use of the Bible in these scenes and on the lips of the perpetrator of violence to give authorisation to violence against women. The paper will also explore the historic use of the Bible in such terms and query the charactisation of Wallace in the films.
In what way does the treatment of androids in contemporary cinematography, compare Ex Machina (Alex Garland, 2014) and Altered Carbon (Laeta Kalogridis for Netflix, 2018) for example, show how quickly power resorts to violence when it sees objects as falling (just) below markers of human identity, reflecting historical patterns of others seen as falling (just) below those same markers - including women, children and non-majority cultures?
|
“Your Brother’s Blood Drips from Your Hand”: The Punishment of Cain in Rabbinic and Syriac Christian Interpretation
Program Unit: History and Literature of Early Rabbinic Judaism
Daniel Picus, Brown University
As the child of the first man and the first woman, Cain would likely have loomed large in the interpretive imaginations of ancient Jews and Christians on his own merits. As the man responsible for the first murder, however, his story took on a life of its own in late antique literature. The account of Genesis 4 leaves several details unresolved: the reason for Cain’s murder of Abel and his later encounters with his parents among them. Various late antique exegetes reflect on his crime, its punishment, and the effect of both on the ensuing history of humanity. Among Syriac Christian interpreters, Cain is the prototypical rebel, who, in sinning, abandons human reason and becomes bestial and brutish. Among these, Jacob of Serugh (active during the late fifth and early sixth century) reflects on the murder of Abel and the punishment of Cain in a series of four homilies. In the third (Memra 149), Cain falls into such despair at his crime that he sees no hope for repentance. His despair hardens into anger, rage into pride, until he begins to shake and tremble violently. For Jacob, this is Cain’s curse: to suffer forever the physiological and psychological effects of rage. For the rabbis, on the other hand, Cain is the archetypical penitent. They continually repeat a tradition in which Cain repents for his action and is ultimately forgiven after his punishment and teshuvah, a fact that leaves Adam dumbstruck, and underscores repentance’s awesome power. This tradition appears in Palestinian (Genesis Rabbah 22:13, Leviticus Rabbah 10:5) and Babylonian rabbinic literature (bSanhedrin 37b), suggesting that it tapped into a wider set of notions about repentance and the first murder.
These two papers compare the interpretation of Cain’s curse and questions about his repentance in two communities within relatively close cultural and linguistic proximity. These interpretations are generally contained in the homiletic and literary expansions of Genesis 4:10 and 4:16: God’s rebuke of Cain, and Cain’s wandering and eventual settlement in the land of Nod. Repentance is a crucial component of both rabbinic and Christian interpretations, but it figures differently. For the rabbis, Cain’s repentance is successful. This is intelligible within the context of a religion that emphasizes repentance and forgiveness within a yearly liturgical cycle. For Jacob, on the other hand, relief comes not to Cain but to his parents, when a new son, Seth, is born. Jacob’s exegesis points toward Christological concerns: Cain in his obstinacy cannot repent, redemption must come through another. Behind Jacob’s homily, too, is the necessity of the crime, for without it, Seth cannot be a new beginning and a consolation. While it is hard to say if proponents of these differing interpretations were in direct competition with each other, they can both be read as using Cain’s repentance and redemption to think about those perceived as having committed grave sins against the community.
|
Complexifying Ambrose’s Reception of Basil’s Homiliae in Hexaemeron: The Legacy of Origen
Program Unit: Early Exegesis of Genesis 1–3
Alexander H. Pierce, University of Notre Dame
Since Jerome made a passing comment about Basil of Caesarea’s influence on Ambrose of Milan’s Homiliae in Hexameron (ca. 387), there has been general acceptance of the view that Ambrose makes use of Basil’s own Homiliae in Hexaemeron (ca. 378). Many modern scholars have shown interest in Ambrose’s reception of Basil’s hexaemeral homilies. The most common approach has been to make a general historical or textual case for the affirmation or denial of whether Ambrose used Basil’s homilies. For example, Louis Swift, in his 1981 article, “Basil and Ambrose on the Six Days of Creation,” offers a textual analysis in which he compares and contrasts the hexaemeral homilies of Basil and Ambrose in the order that they unfold. While Swift observes some interesting continuities and discontinuities between the homilies, the analysis is limited by his focus on pastoral and polemical preoccupations as the interpretive grid for understanding differences in Ambrose’s “organizational pattern” (319). The issue of Ambrose’s reception of Basil is more complex and subtle than Swift and others have shown. For example, to study Ambrose’s reception of Basil is complicated by Ambrose’s reception of other early Christian thinkers, as is evident in the major interpretive issue of whether Genesis 1 narrates the origin of spiritual creation. Although Basil and Ambrose agree that it does not, their individual explanations can be clarified and differentiated by understanding where they agree or disagree with Origen, who argued long before that Gen. 1:1-5 pertains to spiritual creation. To observe the differences in their readings is no difficult task, but to explain them requires paying careful attention to their respective interpretive decisions. In the following essay, then, I consider how the continuities and discontinuities across Origen, Basil, and Ambrose help us to contextualize Ambrose’s configuration of the origin and relation of spiritual and material creation. In other words, the goal of this inquiry is an increased awareness of Ambrose and his sources, including points of continuity and discontinuity with Basil considered in the light of the continuing influence of Origen, an influence that I will trace by reference to Origen’s Homilies on Genesis, De Principiis, and fragments of his Commentary on Genesis (while recognizing the presence of related discussions in Contra Celsum as well as in various homilies and commentaries). Conducting this study will have numerous benefits, including, for example, to increase our understanding of Ambrose’s reception of Basil, both theologians’ reception of Origen, the literary form of hexaemeral homilies, and the contours of each theologian’s visions for the origin and relation of spiritual and material creation.
|
Ṣabr: An Activist Turn in Qurʾānic Hermeneutics
Program Unit: Qur’anic Studies: Methodology and Hermeneutics (IQSA)
Johanna Pink, Albert-Ludwigs-Universität Freiburg
The term ṣabr occurs frequently in the Qurʾān in a variety of contexts. The general meaning is patience or perseverance in the face of adversity. The semantic field it covers thus has passivist and activist potential: It can refer either to patient endurance, resignation and submission to the fate that God has decreed or to perseverance and a steadfast refusal to give up; thus, continued action. The Qurʾānic usage and context of the term sometimes suggest an activist meaning, such as in Q. 3:142 where the believers are instructed to continue their struggle and not to lose hope after defeat in battle; at other times, they suggest a passivist meaning, such as in Q. 12:18 where Yaʿqūb's sons tell their father about Yūsuf's death and he asks God for patience; and sometimes ṣabr could be read both ways as in Q. 103: "Man is in loss, except for those who believe, do good deeds, urge one another to the truth, and urge one another to ṣabr." The ambiguity of ṣabr, a concept that is clearly promoted in the Qurʾān as a virtue, becomes apparent when examining exegetical perspectives on what, exactly, it entails. In Sūrat al-ʿaṣr (Q. 103), for example, ṣabr was frequently interpreted as referring to persistence in obeying God's commands, such as ritual prayer, and refraining from sins. This might require some amount of action, but a very limited degree of human agency. A marked change occurred at the beginning of the 20th century when Muḥammad ʿAbduh, who wrote no less than two commentaries on Sūrat al-ʿaṣr, understood ṣabr in the sense of perseverance with respect to the reform of Muslim societies through education, travel and social activism. This reading invests humans with a high amount of agency but also places equally high demands on them. It also attacks all passivist readings of ṣabr as fatalist und responsible for the decay of Muslim societies. Muḥammad ʿAbduh and many adherents of his interpretation, far beyond the modernist circles he is usually associated with, understood ṣabr as a call to change, rather than quiet endurance. I propose to take the interpretation of the term ṣabr as a starting point for an exploration of passivist and activist readings of the Qurʾān and their shift in the early 20th century, a phenomenon that was closely related to the emergence of reformist movements such as the Muslim Brotherhood. I will examine selected occurrences of the term ṣabr in the Qurʾān, their context and the potential they offer for activist and passivist readings. I will then delineate the development of interpretive approaches until the middle of the 20th century, examining the exegetes' engagement with the term and the interpretive effort they invested into explaining it. My focus will be on the notions of activism and passivism, continuity and change, and human agency. I aim to contextualize my findings within a broader perspective on how Qurʾānic exegesis is inextricably linked with an exegete's notion of man, society and history.
|
New David Means New Temple: Matthew’s Full Narrative among Second Temple Jewish Expectations
Program Unit: Matthew
Nicholas G. Piotrowski, Indianapolis Theological Seminary
While several studies have been produced focusing on the temple in specific parts of Matthew (e.g. Gurtner 2007 on the veil, Welch 2009 on the Sermon on the Mount, Barber 2013 on Peter’s confession), this paper attempts to draw together a global perspective of the first gospel’s understanding of Israel’s largest theological symbol. As early as chapters 1–2 questions swirl around the current temple: there is a strong Son of David emphasis, evoking 2 Samuel 7 among other intertexts, and the use of Micah 5 draws with it the prophet’s eschatological expectations of the “the mountain of the house of the LORD” receiving Gentile pilgrims. This, mixed with cultural expectations of David’s role to purge Jerusalem (Pss. Sol. 17), creates literary anticipation; the reader is prepared for the ensuing narrative to envelop a vision of the eschatological temple’s construction. Jesus’ teachings through the narrative—particularly the beginning and end of the Sermon on the Mount, the zenith at 16:13–20, and the transfiguration (all at structurally significant moments)—hint toward a temple theology but are ultimately elusive at their current points in the narrative. From chapter 21 on the narrative concentrates unflinchingly on the temple for the remainder of the story, which in turn draws Jesus’ previous statements into focus. Linguistic elision throughout chapters 24–28, finally, produces a conceptual alignment of Jesus’ death and the temple’s destruction: through their similar descriptions they are coordinated on the same theological axis. They are, of course, temporally quite separate, but in Matthew’s narrative world they are telescoped into the same theological “moment.” This is matched by Jesus’ resurrection and the re-gathering of the disciples, marking the expected construction of the eschatological temple. In sum, the disciples and those they teach (28:20) comprise the post-resurrection Son-of-David-built temple that imbibes the nations, closing off the narrative’s earlier narratological expectations. This is a literary analysis of Matthew that hopes to further the growing scholarly awareness of the rhetorical effects of Matthew as a coherent speech-act in its original historical location (cf. e.g. Piotrowski 2016) regardless of, though not oblivious to, compositional issues leading up to its final form. It also furthers our understanding of Matthew’s Davidic theology (cf. e.g. Zacharias 2016), as well as Matthew’s teaching on the relationship between the temple and the church (cf. e.g. Konradt 2007/2014).
|
The Burning End Times: Gender and Trauma in Darren Aronofsky’s Mother!
Program Unit: Bible and Film
Tina Pippin, Agnes Scott College
The Apocalypse of John is connected to fire, or rather the potentiality of fire. This apocalyptic tale is bound up in fire, generating more fury with every reading and each appearance (in politics, economics, art, war, and more). Genesis eventually turns into Apocalypse, and flood into inferno.
In Darren Aronofksy’s 2017 film, Mother!, fire provides the framework for his allegorical retelling of the Bible, with apocalyptic themes at the center. The psychological and physical horror adds layers to the plot. Aronofsky has said little to explain the film, except to admit that it is an allegorical reading of the Bible and also an environmentalist tale. This film is an expression of Aronofsky’s anger about environmental destruction, which he also visualized in his film, Noah. He reads the Bible as a horror tale that circles back from creation to chaos and back again. Using the work of philosopher Gaston Bachelard (The Psychoanalysis of Fire, Beacon, 1964, one of his four-part works on the elements), along with readings of the function of fire in literature (Northrop Frye, John Berger, and others), and trauma studies, I will analyze the ways the wild dreams of this film offer a reading of the Apocalypse of John.
One prominent layer of the film is its portrayal of gender and marriage. Like the women in the Apocalypse of John, Mother is expendable in an endless cycle of creation and destruction. The house, symbolic for Aronofsky of the earth, is also expendable. The symbiotic relationship between Mother and the bleeding, crippled house provides the film’s centerpiece. An Eve character tells Mother, commenting on her marriage to the narcissistic poet Him, “You give and you give and you give. It’s just never enough.” Like other (apocalyptic) women before her, Mother gives her body as a burnt offering, providing the elements for the horror story to begin all over again. Is Him’s desire to consume young, fertile females also embedded in Him’s creation plan? Is this the experience of women exegetes? Are we playing Mother to an apocalyptic Him?
The allegory of apocalyptic fire in the film exposes the terrifying narrative structure of the Bible. The allegory also provides a critique of recent positivistic, ecotheological readings of the Apocalypse of John. The fire in Mother! is generative, but the eerie apocalyptic cycle makes creation violent, brutal, and ultimately undesirable. Fire serves as warning in the film and in the biblical text. What is at stake is the fate of the Earth, of creation, of women, and what costs are embedded in of the dream of the New Jerusalem.
|
Greek Text Types and Hebrew Editions: The Case of the Beginning of 2 Kings
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Historical Books
Andrés Piquer Otero, Universidad Complutense de Madrid
Our knowledge of the Hebrew text of Kings is decidedly one-sided when approached from the Hebrew sources only. Even though, after research of biblical texts from Qumran, a situation of textual plurality in the centuries around the change of era is generally accepted among scholars, MT remains the sole Hebrew text of a significant extension. Therefore it falls to work on the versions, especially LXX, to detect traces of this plurality by attempting to reconstruct the Hebrew Vorlage of the Old Greek text. Evidently, this effort is challenged by the different revisions of the Greek in accordance with a proto-MT text-type. In this paper I will try to present some methodological proposals which take into considerations that, beyond a simple opposition between Old Greek and philo-MT, the different Greek text-types, with the assistance of their versions, especially the Old Latin, may also bear witness to a slower and less monologic process in which the oft-named (proto-)Masoretic Hebrew text-type also had a modicum of plurality and development in time; and that an adequate survey of the Greek translations (together with other versions of the Hebrew, such as Targum, Peshitta, and Vulgate) may at times shed light on that dynamic process. I will take the beginning of the book of 2 Kings as a macro-structure where differences between Greek tex-types and the particular readings of MT in regnal formulae ( especially 2 Kgs 1:17-18 and 2 Kgs 3:1-3) are of high interest to illustrate a rich and complex landscape.
|
An Intonation-Based Prosodic Model for Tiberian Hebrew
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Sophia L. Pitcher, University of the Free State
The system of vocalization encoded in the Masoretic accents represents one of the most prominent expressions of the oral nature of the Hebrew Bible, yet the value of investigating extant cantillation traditions has been largely dismissed in non-liturgical scholarship. In this presentation I analyze an extant Ashkenazi cantillation tradition using modern prosodic theory and the musical concept of conjunct and disjunct melodic motion to demonstrate that the accents have a highly structured intonational basis that organizes the system and conforms substantially to cross-linguistic prosodic norms. I investigate the prosodic nature of the Masoretic accents by describing, classifying, and cataloging the types of melodic patterns and intervals that conjunctive and disjunctive accents are able to form. I then determine the organizational prosodic structure of the accents and compare it to the cross-linguistic prosodic model developed by Selkirk (2009; 2011). Finally, I test how well this intonation-based model for Tiberian Hebrew identifies and locates cross-linguistic prosodic structures for restrictive and non-restrictive relative clauses. The biblical corpus used to test this model is comprised of all the overtly headed relative clauses in the twenty-one books of the Hebrew Bible. My analysis indicates that Tiberian Hebrew distinguishes three prosodic classes of relatives, a finding that accords with and refines cross-linguistic prosodic norms for these syntactic constructions.
|
Paul's Linguistic Competence and the Pseudonymity Debate
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
AW Pitts IV, Arizona Christian University
Much recent discussion of the so-called Q document depends in large part upon the assumption of Luke's literary incompetence. Once Gospel scholars like Michael Goulder, Mark Goodacre, Nicholas Perrin, and others, began to entertain the possibility that Luke might not be all that incompetent as an author after all, the Q-thesis suddenly began to look less impressive, at least to many. In this paper, we shall argue that a similar phenomenon obtains for the apostle Paul with respect to the authorship of many of the letters in the New Testament that claim to have him as their author. We know far more about Paul, his upbringing, and especially his linguistic abilities than we do about the historical Luke (i.e. the author of Luke-Acts). We shall argue that Paul's educational background, in particular, provides important background information for the pseudonymity debate. Assuming at least a moderate level of education for the apostle allows us to argue that the apostle's training likely motivated rather than deterred language diversity in his letter-writing, especially when we consider his potential instruction in the progymnasmata and mastery of the Greek Scriptures. After all, Paul's Greek education, especially mimetic theory, likely taught him that language diversity is a hallmark of good Greek writing. Was Paul a linguist or literary specialist? Probably not. But was he a literary or linguistic ιδιώτης? We seriously doubt it. We argue, therefore, for a linguistically and literarily competent Paul, as evidenced by his education and especially his letters. Paul, then, was likely an author easily capable of the kind of language diversity we find in a 13-Letter Pauline canon. Or, so we shall argue.
|
"And Still He Won't Leave Me Alone" (Acts Thom. 43.11): A Toxic Masculine Demon in the Acts of Thomas
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Catherine Playoust, University of Divinity
Ideals of masculinity vary across and within cultures, but in the Acts of Thomas a woman makes a critique of male behaviour that sounds very familiar today. She complains that a demon has been sexually abusing her for five years. While the demon proclaims his love for her, this is a desire that privileges his wishes over hers; he has forced himself into her life and her body, clearly exhibiting what has recently been called "toxic masculinity." Yet there are some complications in the demon's portrayal. Unlike in the modern stereotype, his voice is weak and his manner troubled, which may be signs of unmanliness if Greco-Roman gender symbolism applies here. Furthermore, he is polymorphic, which the woman views suspiciously, but granted how much both Jesus and Thomas shift form in this text is more likely to be a sign of his super-human demonic powers. And beyond that, he is ugly despite his polymorphic abilities, yet this (fortunately) would surely say little about his nature or character when Jesus had previously also appeared in what is termed an ugly form. Lastly, in a discussion of masculinity and gender relations, it should not go unsaid that the Acts of Thomas promotes a type of Christianity in which sexual continence is required even of the married. Thomas's exorcism of the demon leaves this woman free to refrain from sexual intercourse and to keep postponing the marriage for which she had been betrothed. This short episode in the text prepares the reader for the more nuanced portrayal later of Mygdonia and Karish, a married couple pulled apart by Thomas's preaching; there, the husband's behaviour toward his wife because of her conversion definitely has toxic elements but his genuine concern for her wellbeing may evoke some sympathy too.
|
"The Lord Is Our Mirror" (Odes Sol. 13.1): Christological-Anthropological Ritual Connections in the Odes of Solomon
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Catherine Playoust, University of Divinity
As is well known, the Odes of Solomon use the first person singular in complex ways. In several of the odes, "I" seems clearly to be Christ, but in several others, "I" is clearly the singer. Moreover, even within an ode the apparent speaker can shift between these without warning. (This is our evidence from the ode texts themselves, it should be noted; our sources lack extra-textual features such as rubrics or indicators of who the speaker is.) On occasion this feature of the texts has been explained in terms of either prophetic inspiration or mystical union. We may also gain some ground through a performative approach, considering the effect on the gathered community as it is presented with a Christ resembling the singer and a singer representing Christ, so that its repertoire of narratives and images is broadened for each. Furthermore, since there is no evidence that the so-called Odist is some kind of exceptional case, set apart from the community, this figure is probably better considered as a representative member of the believing community, and possibly not the same person on each occasion. Thus we have an assembled community whose engagement in hymnic ritual has the effect of blurring the distinction between their Christology and their Christian anthropology. In view of recent research by Orlov and Stang on the prevalence of the "divine double" concept in Mediterranean-Levantine antiquity, it is worth looking in more detail at these early Syrian Christians who may not merely be engaging in imitation when they stand in a cruciform posture (Ode 35) and who consider the Lord as their mirror (Ode 13).
|
Paraphony and Leitwort at Work in the Samuel Narrative (1 Sam 3–24)
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Bezalel Porten, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
The paraphonous pair yra-rah (fright and sight) courses through some eight different tales: (1) demise of the house of Eli; (2) departure of Samuel; (3) Saul-Jonathan confrontation; (4) rejection of Saul and election of David; (5) David vs Goliath; (6) Saul vs David; (7) Ahimelech, Achish, Doeg, Abiathar; (8) Jonathan and Saul acquiesce in David’s succession; and their imprint is felt in each tale. Along the way they link up with similar sounding words – or and arur (light and cursed) in 1 Sam 14 and the roots ra, raa, raah (bad), ria (shout), raah (shepherd, feed); and attract the polar pair glh (reveal) and glh (exile) in 1 Sam 3:7, 4:21-22. Alongside this pair is the leitwort lxm. It has the double meaning of “bread” and “fight.” David comes from the House of Bread, brings bread to his brothers and takes holy bread from a priest (1 Sam 17:17, 21:4-7); though but a lad, he defeats the Philistine “man of war” and is put in charge of the Israelite “men of war” (1 Sam 17:33, 18:5). Though Saul is “taller” (wygbh) than all the people (1 Sam 10:23), he and they fear (wyraw) the “tall” (gbhw) Goliath (1 Sam 17:4, 11). Moreover, since Saul also ‘fears” (yraty), God “sees to” (rayty) David as king (1 Sam 15:24, 16:1).
|
Second Millennium Amorrites from an Archaeological Perspective
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Anne Porter, University of Toronto
Who were the Amorrites, how broad was their reach, and how did they come to power in the first centuries of the second millennium BCE? If decades of textual analyses have failed to reach a broad consensus on these issues, can archaeology point the way? This paper will argue that it can. But we need to go far beyond consideration of form in the singular categories studied to date, such as pot types and settlement patterns. We need to engage a systematic comparison of multiple material cultural attributes, such as mortuary practices, religious practices, foodways and commensality, with consideration of what kinds of ways of life, socially, economically and politically, those attributes are embedded in. And all this must be combined with rigorous chronological control across all the regions involved – Mesopotamia, Northern Syria, and both the Northern and Southern Levant.
|
Assessing Background Socio-historical Narratives, Social Memory and Social Identity Construction in the Gospels - Not a saga with SAGA.
Program Unit: Writing Social-Scientific Commentaries of the New Testament
Christopher A. Porter, Ridley Melbourne
Within a socio-cognitive approach, assessing the historical situation and social history of texts often proves to be a major challenge. Subsequently a lack of socio-historical anchoring for the identity formative argument within a given text may produce a plethora of socio-cognitive readings for the same text. To address this methodological challenge several proposals have been made to assess the plausibility and probability of the interaction between textual argument and a given background social model. Among these proposals, two stand out as particularly pertinent to social identity analysis of the ancient world. The first of these is the Structured Analysis of Group Arguments (SAGA) model from Stephen Reicher and Fabio Sani (1998; also Reicher et al., 2006). While the second-effectively a means of assessing the social memory of a group--stems from the proposal of 'Shared Schematic Narratives' from Martha Auguostinos and Mark Rapley (2002, also Auguostinos, 2002). This paper proposes a hybrid model utilising the insights from both approaches, allowing for a richer socio-historical background to be assessed. This hybrid model allows for prospective use: to assess the outcome of social-arguments given a certain schematic narrative; and retrospective use: assessing the plausibility of a schematic narrative given the social-argument deployed. After outlining the hybrid model, this paper will then seek to apply the model to the schematic narratives and arguments deployed in three gospels: Matthew, Mark and John. Through this application the paper will firstly show how this approach may be used to differentiate and assess schematic narratives to see the range of outcomes. Secondly, it will investigate the plausibility of reconstructed social histories given the normative and comparative fit outcomes. Thirdly, it will look at the links between social memory and social identity in the form of shared schematic narratives. Finally, it will look at how textual authors can leverage social memory in a shared schematic narrative format for social-category identity construction in contested environments. This paper hopes to shed light on, and generate clarity for, the various shared schematic narratives and social-histories that lie behind much of the social-identity construction in social-category interaction.
|
Reflections from the Co-editor of "Pillars in the History of Biblical Interpretation," Vols 1 and 2
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Stanley Porter, McMaster Divinity College
Reflections from the Co-editor of "Pillars in the History of Biblical Interpretation," Vols 1 and 2 (Eugene, OR: Wipf & Stock, 2016)
|
Text as Participant in Ritual Assemblage: A Material Approach
Program Unit: Society for Ancient Mediterranean Religions
Scott Possiel, Boston University
This paper applies a material approach to papyri from the Late Antique Mediterranean in order to re-evaluate the role of text in ritual. By examining the physical and visual features of three groups of sub-literary papyri (horoscopes, sortes, and magical formularies), this paper explores how these manuscripts actively participate in ritual activity.
Looking closely at the materiality of these “ritual texts” introduces new possibilities for the study of religious practice and ritual in the Late Antique Mediterranean. While recent studies of ritual expertise by scholars such as Wendt (2016) and Gordon (2015) have paid some attention to these manuscripts, their analysis focuses on the persons responsible for their creation. This preference for human agents has resulted in a lack of attention paid to the mechanics of manuscripts as ritual instruments. Unlike other types of manuscripts, ritual texts are not meant to merely be read and understood. Instead, they cooperate with human practitioners and clients as equal contributors. By offering directions, foretelling the future, and embodying the power of divinities, ritual texts serve as vital members of an assemblage of actors that enables ritual to occur. This agency of ritual texts is further revealed when these papyri are analyzed as material objects. Through their formatting, design, layout, and punctuation, ritual texts empower and govern ritual performance. This paper outlines these special characteristics of ritual texts by pairing close readings with in-depth paleographical and material analysis of three groups of Christian and non-Christian manuscripts dating from the 2nd to 5th centuries CE.
This paper first considers the interactions between practitioner and manuscript found in the corpus of Late Antique horoscopes. The sparse wording of many of these horoscopes is supplemented by a distinctive tabular format that facilitates astrological calculation. Several horoscopes also appeal to divine powers in hopes of improving the fortunes of a client. Second, this paper examines Greek and Coptic sortes and divination manuals that take on their own voice or that of a deity as they provide access to hidden wisdom. These ritual texts have been carefully presented in order to accommodate a complex process of numerical randomization. Finally, this paper turns to the recipes and incantations found in Graeco-Egyptian magical formularies. The images and symbols found in these ritual texts leads to a creative use of space that displays the special efficacy of these figures.
After looking at the features of these three groups of papyri, this paper considers the implications of a new model of ritual that includes a greater appreciation of textual agency. Understanding texts as equal participants in ritual, as evidence by a material approach, raises a new opportunity for thinking about the involvement manuscripts in the practice of religion in the Late Antique Mediterranean among the members of any tradition.
|
Ritual Texts and Ritual Performance: Re-categorizing Marginalized Manuscripts
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Scott Possiel, Boston University
This paper explores the world of early Christianity by investigating the way that papyri from the Late Antique Mediterranean participate in and enable ritual performance. It brings together three groups of sub-literary papyri (horoscopes, sortes, and magical formularies) to establish the new category of the ritual text.
Looking closely at this category of papyri provides valuable insights into the use of manuscripts in the practice of religion during this period and fills a gap in scholarship of ritual in the Late Antique Mediterranean. As is customary with papyri marginalized under the vague term “sub-literary,” ritual texts are typically not considered for comparative study. Even when scholars of ritual expertise such as Heidi Wendt (2016) and Richard Gordon (2015) cite these manuscripts as data, they focus on the persons responsible for their creation. This preference for human actors in ritual studies neglects the distinctive features or ritual texts and the mechanics of how papyri themselves functioned as ritual instruments. Unlike other types of manuscripts, ritual texts are not meant merely to be read and understood. Instead, they cooperate with human practitioners and clients by offering instructions, granting access to divine wisdom, and even acting as manifestations of the power of gods. This key aspect of ritual texts affects their very design and layout as well. In order to more easily facilitate ritual performance, ritual texts employ unconventional layouts, erratic columniation, and uncommonly frequent punctuation. This paper investigates these special characteristics of ritual texts by pairing close readings with in-depth paleographical and codicological analysis of three groups of Christian and non-Christian manuscripts dating from the 2nd to 5th centuries CE.
This paper first takes up Greek and Coptic sortes and divination manuals containing divine oracles that must be unlocked through a process of randomization involving casting dice, lots, or bones. Indicating their interactive nature, sortes manuscripts often forego justification of text or uniform margins in order to restrict each oracle to one page or line. Second, it considers the way in which Late Antique horoscopes embody the foreknowledge of heavenly bodies and act as reference sheets for the astrologer. The sparse wording of many of these horoscopes, most containing only two words per line, is supplemented by a tabular format that aids their use in astrological prognostication. Finally, it turns to Graeco-Egyptian magical formularies that promise marvelous results through the precise completion of their recipes, procedures, and incantations. The regular appearance of special symbols and complex images on these papyri leads to a creative use of space and columns to emphasize the efficacy of these figures.
After placing these three groups of papyri in one shared category, this paper observes that ritual texts may also inform scholars about those manuscripts that fall outside of this category. Through their interactions with human practitioners, ritual texts raise a new possibility for thinking about the involvement of any manuscript in the practice of religion in the Late Antique Mediterranean, both among Christians and non-Christians alike.
|
Rewriting the Synoptic Problem? On the Uses of Rewritten Scripture for Understanding the Composition of the Gospels
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Jonathan M. Potter, Emory University
[1] A prominent component in recent challenges to the Two-Document Hypothesis (2DH) has been an appeal to the group of texts commonly referred to as "Rewritten Bible" or "Rewritten Scripture." This has been especially true of the work of a group of scholars out of Copenhagen, led by Mogens Müller, and demonstrated in the recent conference volume "Luke's Literary Creativity" (edited by Müller and Jesper Tang Nielsen). The idea is that if we take into account the compositional practices evident in works like Jubilees, the Genesis Apocryphon, and the Liber Antiquitatum Biblicarum, the need to posit Q, a hypothetical source used independently by both Matthew and Luke, disappears. Scholars from this perspective claim that Rewritten Scripture demonstrates the widespread existence of the kinds of creative rewriting techniques that Luke would have applied to both Mark and Matthew under the Farrer Hypothesis (a.k.a. Marcan Priority without Q).
[2] In this paper, I ask whether the category Rewritten Scripture can bear the weight of proof being placed upon it. I begin with a review of this interpretive trajectory, which in some ways is a revival of the "gospels as midrash" view promulgated by Michael Goulder, John Drury, and others in the 70's and 80's. This can be profitably contrasted with the emergence of several studies defending the 2DH by appeal to Greek and Roman compositional practices, beginning with F. Gerald Downing and continuing in recent years in, among other works, the dissertations of two of John Kloppenborg's students, Robert Derrenbacker and Alex Damm. It is striking that proponents of the 2DH have looked primarily to non-Jewish Greek and Roman writers (Josephus being the primary exception; he is of course also writing in Greek) for evidence of compositional practices, while supporters of Farrer have drawn their comparanda from Jewish texts mostly written in Hebrew and Aramaic.
[3] On the hand, it makes sense to give priority to comparative texts written in the same language (Greek) and broadly in the same formal genres (history, biography, etc.), although of course genre is always a vexed question. Yet the arguably Jewish character of Matthew and Luke(-Acts) in general and their clear familiarity with Jewish exegetical traditions in particular suggests that Rewritten Scripture should not be too hastily set aside in reconstructing plausible compositional scenarios. What has so far been lacking from Synoptic studies utilizing Rewritten Scripture is a careful analysis of the texts themselves and in comparison with Matthew and Luke, rather than simply evoking a general notion of "midrash" or "literary creativity." My own research, from which I draw a few key examples, suggests that while such comparative work can be highly profitable for understanding the composition of the gospels, it is unlikely to solve the Synoptic problem one way or another. Rewritten Scripture can, however, suggest one of the possible compositional models Matthew and Luke strove to emulate as they endeavored to interpret and retell the story of Jesus.
|
Figs, Pigs, and Imperial Rome: Jesus and the Barren Fig Tree in Mark 11
Program Unit: Westar Institute
Stephen Potthoff, Wilmington College
*
|
Zayd, Zaynab, and Muhammad: Revisited
Program Unit: The Qur’an and Late Antiquity (IQSA)
David S. Powers, Cornell University
The earliest Muslim and Christian sources preserve strikingly different versions of the notorious episode in which Muhammad falls in love with, and eventually marries, Zaynab bt. Jahsh, the former wife of his adopted son Zayd. In the earliest Muslim source to mention the episode—the Tafsir of Muqatil b. Sulayman (d. 150/767), Muhammad falls in love with his daughter-in-law Zaynab after catching a glimpse of her in a state of dishabille; the marriage was legitimized by the revelation of Q 33:37, which stipulates that it is permissible for a believer to marry the former wife of an adoptive son, on the condition that the latter is “finished with her.” In the earliest Christian source to mention the episode—The Fount of Knowledge of John of Damascus, composed ca. 730 CE—Muḥammad tells his “co-worker” Zeid that God had commanded him to divorce his (unnamed) wife so that he (the Prophet) could marry the woman. Zeid complied, and the Prophet then had intercourse with the woman, thereby, according to John, committing adultery. In this instance, the marriage was legitimized by the Prophet’s introduction of the “law” that would become Q 2:230 (on tahlil marriage). In my presentation, I propose to explore the relationship between the Muslim and Christian versions of this episode in an effort to account for the differences and to determine which is the earlier version.
|
Reflections from the Co-author of "The Genesis Liberation: Biblical Interpretation in the Antebellum Narratives of the Enslaved"
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Emerson Powery, Messiah College
Reflections from the Co-author of "The Genesis Liberation: Biblical Interpretation in the Antebellum Narratives of the Enslaved" (Louisville, KY: WJKP, 2016).
|
Context: Methodology and Taxonomy
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Stephen O. Presley, Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary
Context: Methodology and Taxonomy
|
Earthly Portraits and Heavenly Tombs: Evolving Materialities of Cultic Patronage in the Acts of John
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Travis Proctor, Northland College
According to the Acts of John, the apostle John’s Christian mission heralded the “twilight” of Greco-Roman religion in the city of Ephesus. John destroyed the famous Temple of Artemis, critiqued its priests and practitioners for their moral laxity, and converted many Ephesians to Christian devotion. I would like to draw attention, however, to another, lesser-noticed attack on Greco-Roman modes of religiosity: namely, John’s antipathy for the exchange of material goods for cultic services. This is seen especially in the Acts’ emphasis on Jesus as the “physician who heals without charge” (AJ 108). The practice of public euergetism by important patrons was foundational to Greco-Roman civic cults, and so this critical appraisal strikes at the heart of traditional Ephesian cultic systems. What is more, John elsewhere attacks a common method of honoring benefactors by criticizing his follower Lykomedes for commissioning and displaying a portrait of the apostle (AJ 27). Lykomedes justifies this practice through an appeal to traditional cultic sensibilities, suggesting that “it is right and proper that, next to God, our earthly benefactors be acknowledged as gods” (27). John rejects this rationale, positing that such portraits are mere “physical” images, “childish and inadequate,” and ultimately distractions from “spiritual” concerns (27). The Acts of John presents the interchange between Lykomedes and John as representative of a fundamental discontinuity between the two cultic systems of Ephesus – the traditional Greco-Roman “materialist” modes of cultic exchange as opposed to the new “spiritual” virtues of the Christian faith. I would suggest, however, that careful attention to the textual afterlives of the Acts of John – that is, its own “material” copying and dissemination as part of Christian reading practices – complicates this neat dichotomy. In this regard it is notable that narratives of John’s activities in Ephesus – for which the Acts of John served as an important vorlage – became a central part of Ephesian material cultures. Legends regarding John’s burial site in Ephesus, for example, informed early Christian pilgrimage to and veneration at the tomb of John, which eventually resulted in the imperially-sponsored construction of the Basilica of St. John during the reign of Justinian (r. 527-565). What is more, archaeological evidence attests to the use of pilgrimage flasks to collect manna from the tomb, some of which were decorated with images of the apostle. The longer history of the Acts of John and the city of Ephesus, then, attests that in two important respects – cultic benefaction and representational imagery – the material cultures of early Christianity share broader lines of continuity with late antique Greco-Roman cultic practices than the Acts of John would have its readers believe. Thus, the case of the Acts of John pushes us to reconsider Christianity’s complicated relationship with Greco-Roman cultures while also demonstrating that the contextualization of textual traditions within broader material economies can be a fruitful avenue for tracing more complex configurations of cultic life in the religious world of late antiquity.
|
The Celestial Mnemonic Structure of Ancient Narrative and Its Implications for Intertextuality in Biblical Literature
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Evan Proudfoot, University of Oxford
Recent decades have seen a growing interest in studies of orality and memory as they relate to biblical texts. It has long been noted that compositions such as the Gospel according to Mark exhibit markers of orality and an indebtedness to earlier oral tradition, and at the same time that they seem to participate in a rich intertextuality not only with earlier Jewish texts, but with Greek novels, drama, and epic. How far these resemblances are a result of deliberate borrowing and allusion versus common compositional practices or the subconscious residue of a diffuse cultural koine has been debated. Similarly, the question of what tacit assumptions informed the ways ancient authors and exegetes decided to interpret or repurpose earlier material for their own ends has been of immense interest. Memory has been proposed to play a key role in possibly explaining these questions, but up until now, it has remained unclear how ancient authors memorised compositional material.
This paper suggests a way forward to resolve some of these questions, namely it proposes that, in common with many other ancient narratives, some biblical texts participated in the use of celestial memory palaces. The celestial art of memory was used not only as an aide-mémoire in reading or reciting compositions, but as a means to structure and furnish them with imagery. In this respect, the memory palaces were not what the story was “about” per se (although they could be used in a self-aware manner); they were a poetic device that allowed for the creation of well-ordered, memorable narratives with complex internal harmonies and rich intertextual allusions. They were a product of a culture at the interface between orality and literature, and they were, by all indications, used in the creation (and/or performance) of drama, epic, and the Greek novels, historical works and rhetorical speeches.
|
Memory and Judgment, Replacement and Forgetting: Phenomenology of the Threshold in the Apocalypse of John and the Parables of Enoch
Program Unit: Cognitive Science Approaches to the Biblical World
Jolyon Pruszinski, Princeton Theological Seminary
Following Christopher Rowland, who famously observed that apocalypses are not inherently oriented toward the eschatological or temporal, and Michel Foucault, who argued that historical analyses have generally diverted attention away from crucial spatial realities, this paper examines the Apocalypse of John and the Parables of Enoch using a spatial hermeneutic to consider the significance of differences in the ways that each apocalypse addresses and reproduces space. This paper considers spaces that appear in both apocalypses but which appear with significantly different descriptive language, with particular attention to doorways or gates.
In a 2011 paper which appeared in The Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology (64) entitled "Walking Through Doorways Causes Forgetting: Further Explorations," the authors Gabriel A. Radvansky, Sabine A Krawietz, and Andrea K. Tamplin determined that passing through a doorway has a measurable cognitive effect on the traveler, inducing forgetfulness of what one was contemplating prior to passing through said doorway. The authors suggest that this cognitive phenomenon is related to the expectation of new stimuli and results from a de-prioritization of the stimuli that occurred before the threshold. In the Apocalypse of John, the author employs door and gateway language repeatedly, while the author of the Parables of Enoch does not employ it at all. This discrepancy is particularly surprising since the two authors are relating visions of the same place, that is, heaven.
What may be suggested by the respective spatial emphases of the authors of the Apocalypse and the Parables is that their modes of engagement with a traumatized material world appear to diverge dramatically. References by the author of the Parables to oppressive landowners and transformative goals for the heavens and earth suggest a meaningful and critical political engagement with the material world. The lack of similar specific language in the Apocalypse may suggest an orientation toward the existing world that is less engaged and more escapist. The author of the Apocalypse combines polemic against all "those who dwell upon the earth," an emphasis on the disappearance of the old order and its replacement with a new one, and the use of compensatory cultic language to orient the reader away from the existing material world. And the frequent use by the author of the Apocalypse of doorway language further suggests a governing psychology of separation and forgetfulness. This analysis highlights the value of spatial hermeneutics employed in concert with findings from cognitive science for identifying key differences between texts and the contexts out of which they arise.
|
Revelation, Economics, and Sex: Contextual Biblical Interpretation and Sex-Work in South Africa
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Jeremy Punt, Universiteit van Stellenbosch - University of Stellenbosch
The legalising of sex-work in South Africa is an ongoing debate which received renewed attention when the ANC as ruling party passed a resolution in 2017 to decriminalise sex-work. In the Global South in particular, the entanglements between gender, sexuality and economics are nowhere more prevalent than in sex-work. In a context where desperate socio-economic inequalities, questionable gender patterns, and questioned sexualities are interrelated and interspersed with explicit and subtle appeals to the Bible, Revelation with its rich, sexualised imagery is involved in debates pertaining to the decriminalisation of sex-work in the country. Given the prevalence of Christianity in South Africa, both in faith communities and in cultural impact, and political and societal leaders’ reliance on biblical texts in different formats, the discursive presence of Revelation in and with regard to the sex-work is understandable, revealing, and worrying, all at the same time.
|
Comparing the Imagery of Submission in ANE Art and Psalm 2
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Richard Purcell, Emory University
Psalm 2 presents a constellation of literary imagery that features the submission of foreign kings to Yahweh and his king. Some scholars have characterized such imagery as overzealous and unrealistic, regulating the psalm to a late, idealistic context. Others point to the ‘Davidic empire’ as the sole appropriate context for understanding the imagery and claims of Psalm 2. However, attention to ANE royal art demonstrates that the ‘submission of the nations’ imagery displayed in Psalm 2 is a standard aspect of royal rhetoric. The images of submission and subjugation in Psalm 2 line up with motifs that occur in ANE royal art in depictions of foreign kings and nations. Psalm 2’s theme of subjugation has been acknowledged by multiple scholars, but ANE art has rarely been considered as a line of evidence for understanding the imagery of this theme. Drawing on ANE artistic evidence not only helps to fill out this theme in Psalm 2, this line of evidence might also shed light on verse 12a, the interpretive crux of the psalm. A multitude of readings have been proposed for vv. 11b and 12a of Psalm 2, from complete reorderings and repointings of the MT to different proposals for the root words based on comparative philological evidence. Yet, scholars generally agree that the line is concerned with the submission of foreign leaders to either Yahweh or Yahweh’s chosen king. Iconographic depictions of the submission of foreign peoples and their leaders may serve as a productive source for narrowing down the sensible choices for this text critical issue. Textual evidence, both the text-critical and the comparative, has been explored in attempts to propose a sensible reading of vv. 11b–12a, but this paper will turn to iconographic evidence to determine which reading(s) are most congruent with the textual imagery of Psalm 2.
|
The Archaeology of Sanctuaries in Ancient Israel and Judah and the Concept of Cult Centralization
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Katharina Pyschny, University of Lausanne
(no abstract)
|
Literary Criticism in Numbers 32: Methodological Basics, Problems, and Challenges
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Katharina Pyschny, University of Lausanne
(no abstract)
|
A Rabbi, a Priest, and the Bible Walk into a Sitcom: The Quest for a Divine Comedy in the Popular Television Culture of "Living Biblically"
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Phil Quanbeck II, Augsburg University
In the CBS Television sitcom, “Living Biblically” a newspaper movie reviewer named Chip experiences a two-fold personal crisis brought about by the death of a close friend and his wife’s announcement of her pregnancy. He responds to these crises by resolving to live a life that follows the Bible 100%.
In this paper we will argue that the quest for jokes in this sitcom, provides window into the understanding of biblical interpretation in popular culture and addressing life crises. As Ted Cohen noted in “Jokes: Philosophical Thoughts on Joking Matters” jokes are conditional. Conditional in the sense that the joke depend on the degree to which the audience supplies meaning in order to get the joke. The knowledge which the audience requires can vary from the general to the arcane.
In “Living Biblically” the Bible is presented as presenting commandments, challenges, situations which need to be resolved. And jokes are the way in which the hermeneutical problems are engaged. This characters in this sitcom provide instruction and examples for interpretation. Chip, the central character is representative of the quest for meaning. The Priest and the Rabbi provide explanations and expertise and help set and break boundaries. Chips wife, work colleagues and friends provide a range of understanding or misunderstanding responses and stand in for the television audience.
This paper will argue that “Living Biblically” doesn’t simply deal with biblical humor in religious themes or tropes, but deals deal with the particularity of biblical texts or popular understandings of those texts. Further, it will be argued that this sitcom approaches biblical interpretation through what is in fact the complex nature of jokes.
|
Gender Discord in Biblical Hebrew
Program Unit: Philology in Hebrew Studies
Laura Quick, Princeton University
Gender discord describes a phenomenon in Biblical Hebrew in which a masculine pronoun may stand in for a feminine noun. Typically, scholarship has approached instances of this either as grammatical error, or as a feature of “Late Biblical Hebrew,” arguing that there was a weakening in the distinction of gender in the Second Temple Period and hence the feminine plural suffix became subsumed under its masculine counterpart. On the other hand, Assyriologists have noted a similar grammatical strategy in which high-ranking Assyrian women are referred to, reverently, with male titles, called bēlu, “lord” (masc.), despite their female sex. Influential women of the court in a society where institutional authority was most often a masculine property come to be seen as “honorary males” in this patriarchal social system. Beyond the grammatical explanation, in this paper I will consider the literary effect of gender discord in biblical narrative.
|
The Down Payment of Righteousness: An Economy of Suffering in Polycarp’s Letter to the Philippians
Program Unit: Inventing Christianity: Apostolic Fathers, Apologists, and Martyrs
Jennifer Quigley, Harvard University
This paper takes up the financial themes in Polycarp’s Letter to the Philippians to consider one direction of the intersections of theology and economics, or theo-economics, in early Christian literature. I focus especially on Polycarp’s introduction of the idea that Christ through his death forms the “down-payment (tōn arrabōn) for our righteousness” (2.1). What are the implications of taking seriously the ways in which this text commodifies Christ and suffering? Reading this language alongside documentary and epigraphic materials, including sale contracts, I consider the broader role of down-payments in appeals for legal judgment. I also read this text alongside a proto-rescript, in which an appeal to divine imperial judgment is dependent upon having the proper financing on hand. The language of arrabōn in Polycarp signals theo-economic ties between this letter’s focus on martyrdom, the use and misuse of money, Pauline exegesis, concerns over false teaching, and emphasis on God’s judgment and salvation. Polycarp places both the use of money and following proper teaching within a juridical theo-economic context in which Christ has spent blood in suffering as a down-payment for humanity’s future judgment, and he argues that both right belief and right action are required in order to avoid being held liable for that down-payment. The commodification has here been turned to marshal polemical ends. I conclude that this letter offers one data point for an emerging divine-human economy of suffering in early Christianity, especially in texts which address martyrdom. I conclude that the deployment of theo-economic rhetoric in early Christian literature, especially as it relates to suffering, contributes to a system where divine-human brokers attempt to set the theological and practical standards for access to God.
|
Where Shall Anthropology be Found, in Wisdom?
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Benjamin Quinn, Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary
Where Shall Anthropology be Found, in Wisdom?
|
Island Identity in the Malagasy Bible Translation
Program Unit: Nida Institute
Brigitte Rabarijaona, United Bible Societies
One of the peculiarities of the Bible translation is that it must take into account the two cultures: that of the Source Text and that of the target audience. This is not always an easy task and is even more difficult when it comes to an island. Because of its geographical isolation, its remoteness, its size etc, it has also a particular identity. In the islands, there is a multiculturalism, a certain endemicity, and a different worldview compared to continental countries. This peculiarity is also reflected in the temperament of people, their language, their relationships to each other and their relationship to the divine. This observation came to me while working for some translation projects in the islands of the Indian Ocean. In this paper, I am going to talk mainly about Madagascar: the island identity in the Malagasy Translation of the Bible. Through a socio-linguistic analysis, I will try to understand how the insularity of Madagascar is reflected in the Malagasy translation of the Bible which is the first full Bible translated entirely into a local language in Africa in 1835.
|
The Hermeneutics of Christian Social Justice
Program Unit: Bible and Ethics
Volker Rabens, Friedrich-Schiller-Universität Jena
The potential relevance of the Bible for (social) ethics today is a contested issue. What is the significance of individual ethical texts of Scripture, and how – if at all – can they be dialogue partners for social justice discourses of the 21st century? This paper suggests and discusses different interpretative parameters for a fruitful dialogue between biblical texts and contemporary concerns of ethics and politics. After some introductory remarks on the use of the Bible in a Christian context, the paper submits four parameters of practical hermeneutics, inviting discussion of the potential interplay of 1. Cultural particulars and cultural analogies, 2. Cultural limitations and countercultural inclinations, 3. Canonical diversity and canonical consistency, and 4. Canonical diversity and canonical centrality.
|
The Value of Attention to Land and Place in Biblical Interpretation
Program Unit: Jewish Interpretation of the Bible
Jason Radine, Moravian College
Interpretive interests concerning the Bible that have often been more central to Jewish interpreters than non-Jewish, such as the particularities of land and peoplehood, can be of significant historical value in understanding what biblical texts were written or assembled to communicate in their ancient contexts. A territorial-focused approach was taken by a passage in the Midrash, Bereishit Rabbah (followed by Rashi), which drew on Ps 111:6 to make the case that the reason why the Torah begins with the creation of the world, rather than the creation of the Hebrew people or the giving of the commandments, is that the Torah is indicating that God, as sole creator of land, has the authority to displace the Canaanites and place the Israelites in Canaan. Reading the Enuma Elish, available to the modern scholar, reveals that the culminating achievement of Marduk’s creation of the world is the foundation of Babylon. It may be that at least in some cases, the purpose of ancient cosmogonies is to tell of the founding of a people’s territorial homeland. Thus, the Midrash’s land-based understanding of the creation narratives may in fact be a historically valuable insight regarding the structure of two of the Torah’s sources. The modern Jewish experience, so heavily affected by the presence of a Jewish State, can prompt scholars to have a greater appreciation for the role of land and something like nationalism in the ideologies of ancient biblical writers and editors. Standing apart from earlier universalizing interpretations of biblical ideologies or repudiations of land-based understandings of biblical literature as “narrow nationalism,” a modern critic can experiment with reading biblical literature with a somewhat nationalist lens (about ancient Israel, not modern Israel) to see if the results provide better explanations of previously unclear passages. Such readings would not be “Zionist” in the sense of modern political realities, but based rather on taking seriously the role of land-nationalism amongst biblical writers’ ideologies. Reading biblical books often read universally, such as Amos, Micah, and Zephaniah, with a more particularist territorial lens can bring explanatory benefits for understanding the political contexts and purposes of the early strata of these books.
|
I'm Mad about You, God, You're Mad about Me: The Erotic to Agapic Transfiguration of Our "Bootylicious" Body
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Jyoti Raghu, University of Oxford
I work on subjectivity, embodiment, and affectivity. Through French phenomenology I rethink (Christian) redemption of the body on affective grounds. In my presentation I look at how French phenomenologist Michel Henry is influenced by Neoplatonism in his characterization of salvation and the body’s redemption. This stems primarily from both Meister Eckhart’s influence on Henry, and from a twentieth century revival of Neoplatonism in France. I argue that this redemption entails the return of the body-self to its origin and source in God, through the phenomenological self-manifestation of a Primal Affect, God, also known as Life, Love, Truth. Thus our erotic, sensible, passionate body is not transcended through rational soteriological knowledge but transfigured through return to God and held in Christ as our true affective flesh. This Primal Affect moreover redeems the world through its overflow in our body, animating and expressing in it the love of God through works of mercy.
|
Wathint’ umfazi, wathint’ imbokodo (You Strike a Woman, You Strike a Rock): Dinah and Tamar as Rape Protestors; The Unsung Heroines in the Rape Stories
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Hulisani Ramantswana, University of South Africa
It has been five years since she was raped as she walked from a church in Tembisa township. Her rapist was not caught and the thought of him still out there is terrifying. She has overcome, but the scars remain. Every year on that day, she calls and says: It was on this day that it happened.
This paper reflects on two rape stories in the Old Testament, the rape of Dinah and the rape of Tamar. In the two rape stories, the male figures are portrayed as heroes—the defenders of the rape victims. However, this paper rationalises that the women in the rape stories are not passive objects rather they are the unsung heroines in the stories. The stories are reflected on using the IsiZulu saying “wathint’umfazi, wathint’ imbokodo” to foreground the role of the rape victims as the unsung heroines in the stories. Thus, the paper presents Dinah and Tamar as heroines who represents the demand for justice in the face of the violation of female bodies in society. It is “her” voice of protest that should be heard in each of the rape story crying out, “my life matters.”
|
Speech in the “Dialogue of Adamantius” and the Dialogues of Origen
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Ilaria L.E. Ramelli, Angelicum; Catholic University; Erfurt MWK; Oxford University
I would like to propose this paper for the session on Speech in Ancient Narratives, or another session you may prefer. It will analyse the structure of the Dialogue of Adamantius and will offer a comparison with other dialogues of Origen of Alexandria and with Plato’s dialogues as well as other early Christian dialogues (Methodius, Gregory of Nyssa, etc.). This paper will explore the dialectic and "zetetic" role of the use of dialogues in this document (of which I am preparing an Oxford critical edition and a commentary), and the role of the judge as impartial “logos”. A reassessment will be proposed of the relationship between the extant Greek text of this dialogue and the Latin translation of Rufinus; their divergences will be explained, and a hypothesis will be offered about the composition of this dialogue.
|
Dialogue on the Role of Practical Theology on Reading the Bible
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Johnny Ramirez-Johnson, Fuller Theological Seminary (Pasadena)
This short presentation will begin a dialogue in our business meeting as we plan future sessions.
|
Reproving Words: Disabilities of Speech Itself in the Book of Job
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Rebecca Raphael, Texas State University
In The Senses of Scripture (2011), Yael Avrahami included a short section on speech as a sense. This paper will both build upon and interrogate that insight by exploring the representation of speech as something that can, apart from its speaker, have semi-embodied qualities, in particular, exceptional ability or disability. Focusing primarily on the Book of Job, I analyze the image of exceptional speech and contrast it with disabled speech. We see this contested among Job and his interlocutors, with each accusing the other of a kind of speech to which the attacker imputes disabled qualities. Both Job and the interlocutors also suggest a contrasting type of speech, although their constructions of that differ; Job’s contrast is an honest but powerless speech, while the interlocutors’ is speech that conforms to discursive norms. While scholarship on Wisdom literature treats speech as a locus of an individual’s virtue or vice, this study will test the extent to which the textual representation of speech treats speech almost like an independent entity that can have its own abilities and disabilities. Relative to biblical sensory criticism, I find that speech in the Book of Job is treated as an epistemic sense, and as such, can reflect its speaker’s ability or disability; yet to the extent that speech is independent of its speaker, the representation of disability has special features that attach distinctly to it as a semi-autonomous being.
|
Demons and Health in the Biblical World: Good, Bad, and ….
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Ilona Rashkow, Stony Brook University
Our medieval/modern presumption is that a demon is an intrinsically evil supernatural being and an angel is an intrinsically good supernatural being, but the Ancient Near East did not view demons in the same way. In the ancient world, there was a widespread belief in supernatural powers or beings that existed in addition to the well-known gods and goddesses. Demons were not viewed as necessarily evil, although some might be. It was accepted generally that demons could take control of nature and cause natural calamities. On a more personal level, demons could cause physical disease (including specific problems such as deafness or blindness) as well as mental illness.
On the other hand, some demons were apotropaic; others could heal; and some caused fertility. Although they are classified often as either evil or good, for the most part they were largely amoral – their harmful or beneficial effects could be manipulated: they could be appeased with offerings and incantations, and even directed against each other by a skilled practitioner of magic. Demons are far more complicated, and more interesting, than one side in a simple opposition between good and evil.
This paper examines the role of demons in the Hebrew Bible through the spectrum of other Ancient Near Eastern demons and their role in health and disability.
|
Garden of the Gods: Why, What, When, Why, and Where?
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Ilona Rashkow, Stony Brook University
There are three basic types of gardens in Ancient Near Eastern literature: (1) royal parks, (2) cultic/temple gardens, and (3) forests at divine/human borders. All of these gardens have several similar classifying features, such as lush and exotic foliage, abundant waters, and limited access. The most well-known garden in the Hebrew Bible is the Garden of Eden. A garden discussed less frequently is גַ֥ן הָאֱלֹהִֽים (lit. the “garden of the gods”) which Ezekiel describes as a place of great luxury: “…every precious stone …: carnelian, chrysolite, and amethyst; beryl, lapis lazuli, and jasper; sapphire, turquoise, and emerald; and gold beautifully wrought…” (Ezek 28:13). Similarly, the “Jewel Forest” described in Gilgamesh contains trees with precious gemstones bearing fruit: “… fruit of carnelian…lapis lazuli leaves… hematite and rare stones, agate, and pearls from out of the sea” (ANET, Epic of Gilgamesh, Old Assyrian Version. Tablet IX ll.169–94).
While some scholars view the garden of the gods as a parallel to the garden of Eden in Gen 2–3, I disagree. Some of the main features of Ancient Near Eastern “gardens of the gods” is the presence of deities, lavish jewels, a monstrous-looking guard, and a lack of humankind. Thus, while the Garden of Eden includes the biblical deity, the issuing of divine decrees, the source of the subterranean life-giving waters which supply the earth, abundant fertility, trees of supernatural qualities and great beauty, people are there but jewels and guards are not. This paper examines the similarities and differences between the biblical garden of the gods and the “Jewel Forest” described in Gilgamesh. What interests me is: who has access to the garden of the gods; who are the guards; where is it; and why all of the jewelry….?
|
Material Memory and Phenomenology in Greece: Accumulated Votives as Group-Made Monuments
Program Unit: Society for Ancient Mediterranean Religions
K.A. Rask, Duquesne University
Greek devotional activity included the accumulation and clustering of common votive types, many of which featured similar motifs and repetitive designs. Frequently deposited around focal points such as cult statues, altars, and meaningful topographic locations, the placement generally allowed closeness to sacred presence. This paper explores these constructed assemblages by focusing on the use of objects featuring visual ‘sameness,’ drawing examples from the horse-and-rider figurines and likna from Corinth, votary statuettes from Cyprus, and pinakes from Attica. While the appearance of ubiquitous votive imagery may have been dictated by tradition and manufacturing realities, the creation of cluttered and repetitive displays had phenomenological significance: the physical experience of holding objects, witnessing others dedicating similar objects, the visual contemplation of endless displays of artifacts in their limited types and motifs, and the encoding and recollection of comparable moments in the past.
Building on the work of D. Morgan and J. Gonzalez, this paper theorizes Greek votive accumulations as larger conglomerations that impact religious experience through the artifacts’ very number and ubiquity. The repetition and the pervasiveness of certain votive types and iconography, made familiar through an individual’s personal biography, ensured that the objects became particularly resonant. Such familiarity has been shown to reassure during difficult or emotionally-charged moments in a person’s life, precisely when the gods are approached.
Amassed votives inevitably functioned as markers for other devotees who also came to the god for similar reasons. The clustered items participated in an ‘aesthetics of accumulation,’ visually and physically linking individuals to a network of other worshippers. The accrued numbers testified to shared experiences and reconstituted the mutual relationship that humans had with deities but also one another.
By forming assemblages of figurines, worshippers likewise created larger, dynamic monuments out of individual items. These testaments and spectacles were constructed by numerous makers, built up over time, and incorporated space and topography. Their phenomenological impact in a religious setting serves to complicate interpretations that stress artistic or ritualistic aspects of recurring votive imagery.
|
Calendrical Lexicography in the Bible and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Qumran
Eshbal Ratzon, University of Haifa
Time is a social structure, which affects many fundamental aspects of life, including politics, religion, and economics. Therefore, it is not surprising that calendrical discussions were the cornerstone of sectarian disputes of Second Temple Judaism. This paper will not deal with the basic astronomical structure of the calendars, but rather with their language and content. While various Second Temple groups based their calendars on the Hebrew Bible, different interpretations and oral traditions created distinct practices. The proposed presentation will analyze calendrical lexicography in the Hebrew Bible, Dead Sea Scrolls, and Tannaitic sources, in order to demonstrate differences in vocabulary that may be attributed to social and religious background on the one hand, and continuity of concepts and terms throughout the sources and periods on the other.
|
The Archipelogics of Africana Biblical Hermeneutics: Africana, Orality, and Transtextual Biblical Interpretation in the Twenty-First Century
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
A. Paige Rawson, Drew University
In the late nineties, Édóuard Glissant asserted that “the entire world is becoming an archipelago.” Africa, however, particularly since the mid-seventeenth century, is already archipelago, and while African biblical hermeneutics are unarguably rooted in the continent and context of Africa, its cultures and peoples, they are undeniably archipelogical—a neologism, which emerged for me as I engaged Glissant’s theorizing of archipelagic thinking and oraliture in conversation with Dorothy Akoto-Abutiate’s monograph Proverbs and The African Tree of Life. As Akoto-Abutiate illuminates, Wisdom is represented by a tree in Ewe and Akan as well as Hebrew Proverbs, and is not only rooted in one (particular) region but (perpetually) in relation and, therefore, always already outside the constraints of demarcation (as colonized territory). Accordingly, I propose an Africana interpretation of Wisdom as the rhizomatic Tree of Life through hermeneutics as archipelogics, where I read the Bible and the interpretive process as archipelagic assemblage. In my experience of Africana, and through my exegetical encounters with and explorations of the Tree of Life as rhizome of poetic Relation rather than Root tree, I have come to recognize that African biblical hermeneutics are as much about interpretation in the cultural context and social location—the historical space and geographical place—of Africa as they are about displacing Eurocentric episteme and methodologies in favor of Non-Western, and distinctively Africana, ways of knowing and being (what I consider the archipelogics of bibliorality). In this paper, then, I advance this decolonizing project, furthering my ruminations on Wisdom in Proverbs and/in Africana studies and biblical interpretation, I deploy queer, affect and orality theories in an archipelogical alliance in order to challenge the very Western European hermeneutic hegemony under which students of the Bible are trained to read Wisdom as convention and orthodoxy juxtaposed against the wayward, the strange, the alien—where the virtuous woman is Wisdom and Folly is otherwise. Such transtextual, transcultural, transdisciplinary affiliations are the future of the academy and/as thought activism, if we hope to have any relevance in our world becoming archipelago. These previously disparate discourses and texts are the bodies that like the islands create the very potentialities for new hermeneutical horizons and intertextual exegetical entanglements, and it is precisely those avant-garde archiepelagic assemblages I explore in this paper. Therefore, drawing from the African biblical scholarship of Akoto-Abutiate, Madipoane Masenya, Kenneth Ngwa, and Robert Wafula, which disrupt traditional Western European exegetical analyses, and calling forth the relational poetics of Édóuard Glissant (and his deployment of the Deleuzoguattarian rhizome), I interpret Wisdom as the Tree of Life in Proverbs, the Wo/man who resists Western convention through bibliorality, enlisting and enacting the archipelagic (fluid and connective) thinking that characterizes oraliturary, Africana epistemologies. Jettisoning the sort of conventional “continental thinking” (i.e., insular, auto-referential, static) that has dominated Western academia, Wisdom, then, serves as the very variegated vehicle, the archipelogical mode and always a bit alien medium, through which we may read the Bible Other-Wise.
|
Scribal Performance and the Wild Papyri of the Homeric Epics: Comparative and Interdisciplinary Perspectives
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Jonathan L. Ready, Indiana University
Dating from the fourth to the first centuries BCE, papyri containing snippets of the Iliad and the Odyssey reveal texts that differ from the texts found in the medieval manuscripts of the epics. Compared with the medieval textual tradition, the papyri offer variations within lines, plus verses (verses not in the medieval manuscripts), and minus verses (verses not in the papyri but found in the medieval manuscripts). These so-called wild papyri testify to a manner of textual reproduction of the Homeric poems that can best be labeled scribal performance. The scribes who produced the texts in the papyri performed in the act of copying. They sought to entextualize, to provide a complete and affecting presentation, to traditionalize, and to negotiate an intertextual gap. This presentation builds on the work of scholars of other chirographic traditions—including Israelite, early Christian, and Anglo-Saxon traditions—and on linguistic anthropologists’ investigations of performance. It thereby illuminates the history of the written transmission of the Homeric epics before the emergence of standardized written texts.
|
Susanna's #MeToo Moment: Redefining Biblical Masculinities
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Leah Rediger Schulte, Doane University
This paper will demonstrate that the interactions between Daniel and the elders represent a reversal in the social construction of ideal (hegemonic) and subordinate biblical masculinities. Reviewing studies on the apocryphal narrative of Susanna in the Greek additions to Daniel uncovers some feminist approaches, but an absence of masculinity frameworks. Feminist scholars such as Jennifer Glancy, Toni Craven, and Ilse von Loewenclau have previously identified Susanna as the heroine, a subject whose words and actions exemplify loyalty to God and the Torah. Building on this perspective, this paper will consider Susanna the feminine object around which ideal biblical masculinity is redefined. There are two elements at play with Daniel and the elders. First, this paper will demonstrate how ideal biblical masculinity privileges age over youth, equating an advanced age with God’s favor and fear of the Lord (Lev 19:32; Prov 16:31, 17:6). Yet Daniel is identified as a young boy in whom God “stirred up the holy spirit” as God’s answer to Susanna’s cry for justice (Sus 45). Second, ideal biblical masculinity presumes righteous intent of male leaders who hold political and social power as kings, judges, prophets, and elders. The elders in the story are expected to represent the embodiment of justice and social order; instead, they act as perpetrators. Finally, this paper suggests that the arc of Susanna’s narrative parallels women in the #MeToo movement, as men who hold other men accountable have been the impetus for positive change in social constructions of (hyper)masculinity and male power.
|
Handing Down the Sword of Yahweh: The Mesopotamian Background of Ezek 30:20-26
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
William Reed, Johns Hopkins University
Submitted for open sessions.
Ezekiel's oracles against Egypt (Ezek 29-32) contain a dramatic prediction for the Pharaoh that Yahweh himself will break the king's arms and give his own divine sword into the hands of the Babylonian king. Many scholars connect this passage, the so-called "Breaking of Pharaoh's Arms" (Ezek 30:20-26), with the Egyptian sword of victory bestowal scene. This motif goes back to the very beginning of the New Kingdom. The sword bestowal scene is an iconographic and literary motif often associated with triumphal traditions in which a god presents the king with a sword of victory. While this trope is well represented in the New Kingdom, it is much less frequently attested afterwards. Appropriate weight, however, has not been given to a still productive Mesopotamian motif, especially considering the book's setting in Babylonia. The bestowal of a divine weapon was a part of royal self-conception and the legitimation of violence: the weapon was simultaneously a symbol of divine support, validation of the king's actions, and the means by which to vanquish enemies. The motif had a long history in the traditions of Mesopotamia from Sargon of Akkad to Neo-Babylonian empire, including Ezekiel's captor Nebuchadnezzar II. Despite the ubiquity of the motif among Israel's neighbors, the occurrences of the weapon bestowal motif are few among the texts of the Hebrew Bible. Outside the book of Ezekiel, one other example remains in the parallel text of 2 Samuel 22 || Psalm 18, which draws on Neo-Assyrian royal ideology.
In recent years, there has been a flood of scholarship demonstrating various Babylonian influences upon the book of Ezekiel. These connections take the form of Akkadian loan words, literary references, and important cultural concepts. In light of this, I argue that Ezekiel's Mesopotamian mileu forms the backdrop for his oracle. To begin, I will briefly sketch how the motif is employed in Sargonid royal inscriptions, before examining its presentation in Neo-Babylonian inscriptions and hymns. I will then compare Mesopotamian examples with Ezekiel's usage, noting the similar focus upon the king's hands and arms (idu, rittu, qātu) as part of the bestowal (tamāḫu, malû, šutlumu) of the weapon. Significantly, in Mesopotamian sources, when the motif involves a foreign god, the bestowal of the divine weapon signifies the right to conquest over that god's land and people. Yahweh's bestowal of his sword upon Nebuchadnezzar II should be a signal of the Babylonian king's right to conquer Judah.
Ezekiel's version of the motif affirms the outward structure of the imperial narrative, while at the same time changing what the narrative signifies. The prophetic usage reframes the imperial rhetoric to remove the king's efficacious agency. In Ezekiel 30, even though the Babylonian king received Yahweh's sword, his role in Egypt's punishment was superfluous. Removing the agency from the king undermines the usual intent of the weapon bestowal motif to glorify the king. The fact that the king's role is so perfunctory serves as a reminder that Yahweh could fill this role with anyone.
|
Tears in a Time of War: Weeping with the Daughters of Jerusalem
Program Unit: Bible and Emotion
Caryn A. Reeder, Westmont College
In Luke 23:28, Jesus redirects the tears of the “daughters of Jerusalem” away from himself; war is coming, and their lamentation should therefore be on behalf of themselves and their children. Jesus’s words are most commonly understood as an expression of his compassion for the women of the to-be-besieged city or as a pathetic depiction of the helpless, innocent victims of war. In this paper, I argue that the tears of the daughters of Jerusalem have greater significance than in these (unhelpfully gendered) suggestions. Following the insights of classicists John Keegan and Lawrence Tritle, this paper explores the traditional association of women’s tears with defeat in war in the Bible and in Greco-Roman historiography and epic. Women’s lamentation provides a necessary emotional response to trauma for the participants in war, both the conquerors and their victims, and for the audiences of the stories. The tears of the daughters of Jerusalem in Luke 23:28 identify them as active agents who give voice to the experience of victory and defeat.
|
Psalms Commentary in an Age of Multiple Originals, #MeToo, and Color-Blind Racism
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Stephen Breck Reid, George W. Truett Theological Seminary
James Luther Mays’ Psalms commentary in the Interpretation series appeared in 1994. Mays at that time eschewed the emerging fields of a hermeneutics of suspicion and ideological criticism. The intervening years higher education in North America in general and the Society of Biblical Literature brought at least three shifts that might have an impact on a Psalms commentary for the 21st century. The paper will rehearse the editorial impulse of the Interpretation Bible commentary series over the years. One shift is the new textual criticism that posits multiple originals. A second shift examines how construals of gender of the #MeToo social movement challenges Psalms commentary process and structure. Finally, the guilds response to matters of race and ethnicity have shifted as well. These urges can profitably express themselves in a Psalms commentary of the 21st century.
|
Elijah Levita’s Masoret Ha-Masoret, C. D. Ginsburg, and Theological Issues
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Fred N. Reiner, Wesley Theological Seminary
Elijah Levita (1468-1549; also known as: Elias Levita; Eliyahu ben Asher ha-Levi Ashkenazi; Bachur) was a Jewish grammarian and Masoretic pioneer. Notably he served as editor of the Rabbinic Bible published by Daniel Bomberg’s press in Venice, beginning in 1527, succeeding Jacob Ben Chayim. Levita also taught Hebrew to leading Christian clergy, published Hebrew grammars and dictionaries, and, significantly, wrote and published Massoret Ha-Masoret (1538), an early explanation and guide to the Masorah, complete with a preface and three introductions.
Christian David Ginsburg (1821-1914) edited and translated Masoret Ha-Masoret and published the work in 1867, along with extensive notes and a biography of Elijah Levita. Notably, Levita’s background and work gave rise to several controversies:
1. Levita claimed that the vowels and accent marks in the biblical text did not originate with Moses nor with Ezra, but were post-talmudic, and thus of a different age and revelatory status from the Bible.
2. His extensive work in teaching Hebrew to Christian clergy caused him to be attacked by members of the Jewish community.
3. Ginsburg emphasizes the number of Jews who converted to Christianity who surrounded Levita and the Bomberg publishing house. Since Levita had fled from anti-Semitism in Germany, Padua, and Rome, the issues of Jewish-Christian relations were central to his life and work.
This paper will explore the background, controversies, and work of Levita and Ginsburg’s commentary on it.
|
Gospel and Groupness: Reflecting on J.L. Martyn’s “Johannine Community”
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Adele Reinhartz, Université d'Ottawa - University of Ottawa
Abstract: The idea that the Gospel of John was written for a group of Jewish Christ-confessors that had experienced a traumatic expulsion from the Jewish community has become nearly axiomatic for Johannine studies since the publication of Martyn’s masterful History and Theology in the Fourth Gospel. Fundamental to this hypothesis is the assumption that the Gospel was written for a “Johannine community” that already existed as a distinct group in the mid-to-late first century prior to the Gospel’s final redaction. In this paper, I will examine and challenge this hypothesis. I will draw on Brian Stock’s concept of textual communities to suggest that instead of reading the Gospel as a response to the experience of a prior community, we might hypothesize a community that was formed as a response to the Gospel.
|
A quo tandem abest iste vitio? Libelous Lists in Pauline Invective
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Joshua M. Reno, University of Minnesota-Twin Cities
Vice lists have been the subject of a not inconsiderable amount of scholarly attention. By 1931, Burton Scott Easton, delivering the Presidential Address at the annual meeting of the Society of Biblical Literature, was able to declare definitively, "It is now generally recognized that the catalogs of virtues and vices in the New Testament are derived ultimately from the ethical teaching of the Stoa" (1). While research has provided greater nuance over questions of origin and form, no scholar has questioned the function of New Testament Lasterkatalogen. Conzelmann (1975), Aune (1985), and Malherbe (1986) all stress their paraenetic and protreptic function. No consideration has been given to their use in invective.
The rhetorical handbook Ad Herrenium describes frequentatio as a strategy for strengthening conjectural cases: "when insinuations, which spoken separately were minor and weak, once gathered in one place seem to make the subject clear, not suspect." As an example of frequentatio, the author offers a vice list: "What vice, finally, does your man lack? … He is a traitor to his own pudicitia, a mugger to another; lecherous, intemperate, wanton, arrogant … in short, intolerable to everyone" (4.52). The polemical tone is clear. Accusations are gathered that mutually reinforce each other. Cicero employs a polemical list in his Second Catilinarian: "For our faction, then, fights pudor, for theirs wantonness, ours pudicitia, theirs stuprum, ours loyalty, theirs deception, ours duty, theirs villainy, ours constancy, theirs madness, ours honesty, theirs shamelessness, ours continence, theirs lechery…" (Cat. 2.25).
Vice catalogs serve an important function, therefore, for invective. Their deployment may mark a sophisticated rhetorical strategy, especially in a polemical ethopoeia. Rebecca Langlands (2006) maintains that the vices cataloged in such lists are formulaic and expected, even if they are tailored for the orator's needs. Sexual charges were standard part of socio-political rivalry and often constitute the foundation of political invective (Krenkel, 2006; Tatum, 2011). Both examples above commence with sexual allegations. Skinner (1997) has remarked, sexual ideology was regularly the medium through which other power issues were addressed.
First Corinthians 6:9-10 culminates with an extensive vice catalog notable for its sexual vocabulary. Paul writes, "Or, do you not know that the unjust (adikoi) will not inherit the reign of God? Do not delude yourselves!" Injustice was thought to manifest in innumerable instantiations, and so, the succeeding vice list is not a series of individuated evils but "different symptoms of the same disease" (Ivarsson, 2007). The conceit of Paul's assertion, however, comes in 6:7-8, where Paul has just accused the Corinthians of acting unjustly (adikeite). The threat of 6:9-10, therefore, is not general but startlingly specific. Those wronging their siblings in Roman courts are unjust. Moreover, these persons are, Paul insinuates, the pornoi, moichoi, malakoi, arsenokoitai, whom Paul moves to exclude from divine inheritance. Paul's vice catalog, then, once situated among other exempla of sexual invective, offers new avenues by which to understand Paul's rhetorical purpose in his deployment of some of the most contentious terminology in the Pauline corpus.
|
Synonymous Readings in Ben Sira's Hebrew Variations
Program Unit: Philology in Hebrew Studies
Jean-Sébastien Rey, Université de Lorraine
The Hebrew manuscripts of Ben Sira from Qumran, Masada, and the Cairo Guenizah contain numerous variants between them. This is true whether comparing the different Hebrew witnesses or the marginal readings of manuscript B. One of the crucial and reoccurring features of these variants is that most of them represent so-called "synonymous readings." In this paper, we propose to closely examine this phenomenon through comparing the different textual Hebrew witnesses of Ben Sira and focusing on three main points: (1) In which ways can the synonymous variants be apprehended in an historical-linguistic point of view; (2) How can this typical feature inform our understanding of scribal practices from antiquity through the medieval period; (3) If we compare this phenomenon with similar features found in the Hebrew Bible and the Dead Sea Scrolls (cf. Talmon, “Synonymous reading”), could these textual variations serve as a paradigm to help illuminate textual transmission in antiquity?
|
Lexical Innovations in the Wisdom of Ben Sira
Program Unit: Qumran
Eric Reymond, Yale University
The Wisdom of Ben Sira was written in Hebrew in around 180 BCE, though it is mostly preserved in manuscripts from the middle ages. The book attests numerous innovations in the lexicon of classical Hebrew. However, the complex textual history of Ben Sira prevents us from easily assuming that the lexical innovations it attests reflect usage of the second century BCE or even the usage that predates the Medieval period. The present paper discusses only a few lexical innovations from the Wisdom of Ben Sira in order to demonstrate the complexities involved in analyzing its vocabulary.
|
Jewish Apocalyptic Tradition’s Shaping of New Testament Thought
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Benjamin Reynolds, Tyndale University College (Toronto)
Within much scholarly writing the term ‘apocalyptic’ is used synonymously with the adjective ‘eschatological’. Using the term in this way recognizes the significance of end-of-the-world scenarios in some Jewish apocalypses. What this perspective on ‘apocalyptic’ fails to note, however, is that Jewish apocalypses appear to be primarily concerned, not with eschatology, but with the revelation of heavenly mysteries. The content of what is revealed in those mysteries suggests that a broader understanding of ‘apocalyptic’ is needed within biblical studies (see Rowland, Stone, etc.). The volume Jewish Apocalyptic Tradition and the Shaping of New Testament Thought (Fortress, 2017) was an attempt to argue for just such an understanding of Jewish apocalyptic tradition. The essays in the volume address the revelation of cosmology, wisdom, and the consummation of time in the New Testament documents. These essays argue that the New Testament is indebted to Jewish apocalyptic tradition for its understanding of revelation, and not merely its understanding of eschatology. Having argued that revealed cosmology, revealed wisdom, and revealed consummation of time in the New Testament have been shaped by Jewish apocalyptic tradition, it may be helpful to consider what interpretive possibilities and further areas of exploration lie before us after having made the ‘initial foray’. I will briefly highlight some of these ways forward and introduce the discussion that will follow in the session.
|
Quotations and Allusions to the Text of Genesis in the Hodayot
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Bennie H. Reynolds, Medical University of South Carolina
This paper investigates quotations of and allusions to the Hebrew text of the Book of Genesis found in the various manuscripts of the Hodayot (Thanksgiving Hymns: 1QHa, 1Q35, 4Q427–432) discovered at Qumran. The paper focusses on the use of quotations and allusions for textual criticism of the Book of Genesis but also attempts to determine if the writers of the Hodayot demonstrate a preference for a specific text-type of Genesis.
|
The Problem of Qurʾanic Insertions
Program Unit: Qur’anic Studies: Methodology and Hermeneutics (IQSA)
Gabriel Said Reynolds, University of Notre Dame
In a 2011 paper (“Le problème de la chronologie du Coran”) I highlight a number of problems with the common method of interpreting the Qurʾān through the categories of “Meccan” and “Medinan”. I argue therein that the chronological labels given to Qurʾānic passages are often based on akhbār from the biography of the Prophet while these akhbār often prove to be based on those passages (what Blachère calls “un cercle vicieux”). Since the publication of that article Nicolai Sinai has published a number of studies (“The Unknown Known,” MUSJ; “Inner-Qurʾanic Chronology,” Oxford Handbook; The Qurʾan: A Historical Critical Introduction, esp. ch. 5) which develop a chronological model without reliance on akhbār/asbāb al-nuzūl . In my 2018 IQSA paper I will not take up the larger question of the coherence of this model (which is based in part on data including verse length and formulaic density). Instead I would like to address only the question of whether vocabulary might form a basis for vindicating the chronological (or diachronic) model of reading the Qurʾan, a notion, found already with Nöldeke and R. Bell and later with N. Robinson, T. Nagel, A. Neuwirth, and others. As these scholars recognized, many key terms or turns of phrase which are thought to mark a Meccan or Medinan Sura – including for example asāṭīr al-awwalīn, dīn, ḥanīf, munāfiqūn, alladhīna hādū, jāhada bi-, kun fa-yakun, and nabī – in fact appear also in Suras of the other type. The classic solution to this problem (indeed one found already with the mufassirūn, as I will show with reference to Zarkashī [d. 794/1392] and Suyūṭī [d. 911/1505]) is to identify certain appearances of these terms as insertions: thus the appearance of asāṭīr al-awwalīn in 8:31 is explained as a Meccan insertion and the appearances of jāhada bi- in 16:110 or 25:52 are explained as Medinan insertions. To Sinai such cases are related to a phenomenon of “inner-Qurʾanic interpretation” (see already his work Fortschreibung and more recently “Two Types of Inner-Qurʾanic Interpretation”). I agree with Sinai that the notion of a simple insertion of one static text into another static text does not fully explain this phenomenon. In this paper I will argue further (with reference to the work not only of Sinai but also D. Stewart and K.-F. Pohlmann) that the distribution of this vocabulary is better understood to reflect a dynamic process of written redaction where various texts were joined – and edited in the process -- to form the Qurʾanic text as we know it. I will make this case with particular attention to Suras al-Naḥl (16) and al-‘Ankabūt (29).
|
Frames and Exegesis
Program Unit: Cognitive Linguistics in Biblical Interpretation
Richard A. Rhodes, University of California-Berkeley
Little of the discussion of cognitive approaches to Scripture address the basic insight of cognitive semantics that meaning is essentially encyclopedic. Say chair and speakers not only activate the mental image of a prototype chair, but understand that chairs are for sitting, where chairs are found, what things people do seated, and so on. The complex cognitive structure that stores this information is called a frame. A frame is a gestalt of cultural knowledge — an aggregation of entities, concepts, and actions that cannot be fully understand individually, independent of the other parts of the gestalt (Fillmore 1982).
When we read Scripture, whether in English or in the original language, we are accessing the frames of our native language. We learned in Greek 101 that kaqedra means ‘chair’ but that only got us to add kaqedra to the list of terms associated with our native frame for chairs. However the frames for kaqedra and chair are very different. The prototypical chair is simple wood with four legs, a back, and for most of us, no arms. It is used at a table for eating or at a desk for working. Our homes have lots of them, generally more than there are people living in the home. Most homes have, in addition, one or more less prototypical ones like easy chairs. Chairs are not symbols of wealth or power.
A New Testament kaqedra, on the other hand, was prototypically backless of various constructions, some we would call stools. Nobody sat in a chair to eat. They reclined. (Mk. 14:3, Lk 5:29) Ordinary houses might not even have a thing we might call a chair. Chairs were a sign of power. Men of influence sat in a kaqedra when carrying out certain aspects of their business. (Lk. 14:28, Lk. 14:31, Lk. 16:6, ) Even without chairs, people sat to work (Mat. 13:48). Teachers sat to teach (Mk. 9:35, Lk. 5:3, Jn. 8:2, Act 16:13). If the power was governmental, the specific kind of kaqedra was a bema (Jn. 19:13, Act12:21, Acts 25:6).
An understanding of the fact that the NT frame of kaqedrai were so strongly associated with power or authority allows us to understand that the usual literal translation for Matt. 23:3 is misleading.
Epi ths Mwusews kaqedras ekaqisan oi grammateis kai oi farasaioi.
“The teachers of the law and the Pharisees sit in Moses’ seat.” (NIV)
Authority was not being implied, it was being asserted. The scribes and Pharisees bear the authority of Moses.
This paper will go on to discuss the frame of house and household, oikos drawing heavily on Howe (forthcoming) and, if time permits, beds and bedding, klinh/ krabattos.
We will conclude with an argument for the importance of understanding frames for exegesis, and drawing on more complex frames where no single word captures the whole, for example the commercial transaction frame (Rhodes, 2013). We will emphasize the importance of frame analysis for understanding metonymic reference like that in Lk 7:37, I Cor. 8:10, referenced above.
|
Lev 17 and Deut 12 in the Study of Centralization
Program Unit: Book of Deuteronomy
Julia Rhyder, Université de Lausanne
In scholarly discussions of the influence of Deuteronomy on the Priestly traditions and their attitude towards centralization, the relationship between two texts, Lev 17 and Deut 12, has long been a key issue. In view of thematic parallels and a series of verbal overlaps between the two texts, especially in Lev 17:11, 14 and Deut 12:23, the majority of scholars have interpreted Lev 17 as a response to Deut 12. Lev 17, it has been argued, accepts D’s call to a centralized cult but rejects its concession of local butchery. However, recent developments in the study of Deut 12 have raised a challenge to this interpretation, by suggesting that the verses, Deut 12:20-28, that share by far the strongest verbal overlaps with Lev 17 constitute a late addition to Deut 12 which post-dates and responds to H’s ban on local butchery (Römer; Rüterswörden; Otto; cf. Rofé). The implications of this interpretation for the study of centralization in Lev 17 have not yet been fully explored. This paper argues that if Deut 12:20-28 post-date H, there is insufficient evidence to support the view that Lev 17 depends on Deut 12; and the assumption that H assumes D’s centralizing logic becomes unsustainable. The paper does not conclude, however, that we should assume from this that Lev 17 lacks any centralizing impulse. On the contrary, this paper argues that Lev 17 advances its own call for the centralization of slaughter and sacrifice on the basis of the potency of the ritual disposal of blood. In particular, Lev 17 illustrates the capacity of Priestly texts to articulate distinctive concepts of cult centralization, ones which do not necessarily look to D but rather promote centralization through mandating ritual practices which oblige the Israelite community to defer to central authorities.
|
Affecting Foucault’s Ancient Mediterranean Man of Desire: Revisiting Sexual Emotions in the Testaments of the XII Patriarchs
Program Unit: Bible and Emotion
Luiz Felipe Ribeiro, University of Toronto
According to Michel Foucault, the Christian intervention on Greco-Roman models of interiority of sex accomplished the stark transition, from concerns about gender role intercourse protocols, of who yielded power and could thus be penetrated, to sexual anxieties in the solitary dialectic of oneself to one’s desires. Some scholars suggest we should look for the birth of this “desiring man” some centuries before Christianity, in Hellenistic Jewish models of psychology such as that of the Testament of Reuben. For instance, it has been noted how in T. Jud., Reu. and Jos., the passions of sexual epithymía and hēdonē, not the sexual taboos typical of the Holiness Code, are causes of ethical disquiet. This turn toward the libidinal is also present in Reuben’s treatment of the antediluvian Watchers, who “fall” over a purely mentalist erotic impulse without so much as acting on the forbidden sexual encounter between angels and women. My contention is that Foucaulteans who speak about the birth of this “desiring subject” have looked at its passions as mere Hellenistic moral psychology loan-words. How would the “emotion-affective turn” address the Testaments’ man of desire? A new approach would entail we look at sexual desire beyond notions of impulsion stationed in ancient Selves. According to burgeoning social theories on emotions, affects do not just reside intra-personally in psyches. They rather circulate between emotion-actors, bodies and socialities, serving as currency in ideological interchanges. Emotionalities are activities that accomplish things politically and because they are bound to how power forms people as subjects and how power is resisted, they have been the focus of relations of guidance and strategies of political domination since Hellenistic Antiquity. This paper looks at how Hellenistic Judaism and nascent Christianity inaugurated certain ideological employments of forms of doing and performing sexual desire so as to enact docile and obedient bodies and subjectivities and how these are paraded in the Testaments of the XII Patriarchs.
|
Pederast Playthings and Androgynous Souls: Philo Judaeus’ Polemic against Socratic Pedagogic Pederasty in the Symposium (Vit. Cont. 57–64)
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Luiz Felipe Ribeiro, University of Toronto
A work from Philo’s maturity received some attention in last years as to the Jewish exegete’s ethnic affiliations. For instance, Maren R. Niehoff argued that De Vita Contemplativa and its long tirade against Greek drinking parties should be read in the context of Philo’s enlisting of the Jews with the ranks of Roman culture. Accordingly, Philo’s “us vs. the Greeks” diatribe belongs to claims of the intelligentsia of his Roman contemporaries, wherein the heritage of Old Greece as enlightenment agent to Barbarians had passed on to the Empire. What is more, this Roman ethos had more gravitas, more self-restraint, and frugality than the old Greeks. Philo’s description of the encratite symposium of his Jewish contemplatives is understood in this context of cultural war.
It is within this polemic that we read Philo’s boutade against Plato’s Symposium (Vit. Cont. 57-64). From a critique of Greek drinking parties, Philo shifts to an assault on the philosophical symposia of Plato and Xenophon. These, he assures, are not models for posterity’s merry banquets. Philo’s attack focuses on the otherwise celebrated Socratic pedagogic pederasty. Following other Roman Middle-Platonists skeptical of a Socratic chaste philosopher uninterested in boy “tail-chasing” (paidiká/erōtōn thēra), — e.g. Cicero suspects all “seizing of Ganymede” erōs are mere excuse for “desiring of mundane kind!” (Tusc. IV.71) — Philo launches an attack on pedagogic pederasty and on Plato’s philosophical erōs. This paper maps out De Vita Contemplativa’s participation in the counterculture gaining momentum in the 1st c. CE which expressed disapproval of homoerotic ars amatoria, arguing love between a man and a woman was more spiritual than love between a man and a boy and describes how the Jewish philosopher derides of the idea that the contemplative man may fall in love — an ideal expounded by Platonists and Stoics alike. The paper further makes observations about how cultural war wants to make claims over sexual object-choice protocols.
|
The Suspension of Time in the Book of the Nativity of the Savior
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Bradley Rice, McGill University
The Protevangelium of James contains a well-known yet very peculiar episode recounting how time stood still at the moment Jesus was born. We are told that Joseph, who has just gone out to seek a midwife to assist in Mary’s delivery, suddenly saw himself suspended in motion and the vault of heaven standing still, the birds of the sky suspended in midair. Like figures in a wax museum, Joseph saw sheep, goats, and certain people going about their business and yet wholly frozen in time, with “all of their faces looking up” (Prot. Jas. 18.3–11). There have been several good studies of this curious episode in the Protevangelium of James, including an influential article by François Bovon entitled “The Suspension of Time in Chapter 18 of the Protevangelium Jacobi.” It is less known, however, that this episode also exists in a rather different form in the Book of the Nativity of the Savior (= Nat. Sav.), a poorly known infancy narrative that first came to light when M. R. James published his Latin Infancy Gospels nearly a century ago. This is partly because the Nat. Sav. is still in the process of being reconstructed from the medieval Latin and Irish infancy compilations into which it was incorporated, compilations which combine it with the Protevangelium of James and, in the case of the Latin compilations, with the Gospel of Pseudo-Matthew; it is also because Prot. Jas. has often been assumed to be the source of the material that Nat. Sav. shares with it. However, Jean-Kaestli has offered good reason for thinking that Nat. Sav. is actually independent of Prot. Jas. in many of these instances, and perhaps even prior. Following upon Kaestli’s work, in my paper I will explore the possibility that Nat. Sav. preserves both an earlier form of the “suspension of time” episode as well as its original context—one that is both intriguingly different from that of Prot. Jas. and also explains some its peculiarities. As we shall see, in Nat. Sav. the suspension of time is told not from Joseph’s perspective, but from the perspective of an otherwise unnamed midwife—and according to her account, it was only Mary who was “looking up,” and it was only she who anticipated the stillness of all creation. We will discover that the suspension of time episode plays a pivotal role in the larger story of the Book of the Nativity of the Savior, one which is intricately woven together with its dramatic depiction of a luminous savior born from above.
|
Gene Tucker: Wooly Wisdom, Guilds, and Commitments
Program Unit:
Kent H. Richards, StrategyPoints
My reflections about Gene go back to the early 1960s when he was at the University of Southern California and I was a graduate student in Claremont. “Wooly wisdom” comes from the name of a wet fishing fly, wooly bugger, of which it is said that it should probably be banned given its extraordinary ability to catch so many kinds of fresh and salt water fish. “Guilds” refers not only to my associations with Gene in the Society of Biblical Literature, but his many contributions to far more than SBL. “Commitments” is a way of talking about Gene’s values. He did not just contribute to many people, guilds, and causes, he committed himself to them.
|
Message on a Bottle: The Siran Inscription Revisited
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
Matthieu Richelle, Faculte de theologie evangélique
Since its discovery on the University of Jordan campus in 1972, the inscribed bottle from Tall Siran (Jordan) has mesmerized scholars, both epigraphists and philologists. In the first two decades (1972-1992) following the publication of the editio princeps by H. O. Zayadine and F. Zayadine, most scholars regarded the inscription as a sort of dedicatory text, centered on a list of works by the king Amminadab II (e.g. F. M. Cross, K. Jackson, W. E. Aufrecht, M. Baldacci, G. W. Ahlström). From 1973, a new approach gained some momentum: that the genre of the inscription was that of a poem attributed to the Ammonite king (e.g. C. Krahmalkov, W. H. Shea J. Emerton, O. Loretz). Other studies have focused on the comparison with Qoheleth 2:4-6 (Müller) or philological issues (K. Beyer, J. Azize); translations in anthologies (e.g. ANET and COS) have also appeared. In a word, forty-six years after the initial discovery, no consensus regarding the interpretation of this inscription has emerged from the profusion of articles dedicated to it. Yet not all of the philological proposals made during the last decades are of equal plausibility, to say the least. As the present author prepares a new philological edition of the Transjordanian inscriptions (together with André Lemaire), it is time for a new look at this fascinating text.
|
A New Aramaic Incantation from Zincirli
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
M. Richey, University of Chicago
In August 2017, a complete, eight-line incantation on a stone cosmetic palette was excavated at Zincirli, Turkey (ancient Sam’al) by the Neubauer Expedition of the University of Chicago. The text can be dated on palaeographic grounds to the second half of the ninth century B.C.E., i.e. ca. 850-800. It is written in an Aramaic dialect but shows a number of ‘developed’ or ‘late’ features in both consonantal orthography and verbal morphology. Such features both complicate accepted dialectal divisions and expand our knowledge of Old Aramaic beyond conservative monumental idioms.
The text is attributed to one ‘RḤM son of ŠDNN’ and describes the seizure of a threatening creature, the ‘devourer’, whose blood is then employed as either a healing or apotropaic material for the benefit of an afflicted person. Accompanying the text are illustrations of various creatures, including what appears to be a centipede, a scorpion, and a fish, on both the obverse and reverse of the palette. Alongside the Aramaic-inscribed Pazuzu statuette in the Ashmolean Museum and the Phoenician-language Arslan Tash amulets, this new text is one of only a few epigraphic witnesses to magico-medical praxis in the Iron Age Northwest Semitic languages. It therefore opens considerable new vistas on everything from incantatory formulae and terminology to the range of materia magica employed by professional sorcerors in assisting their clients.
|
The Ethiopic Version of Hebrews: A New Witness and Its Value for Text Criticism
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Dominique Rideout, Abilene Christian University
The discovery of the oldest Ge'ez manuscript of the Pauline Epistles (including Hebrews), Sinai New Finds Ethiopic 2, gives us a second valuable witness to the earliest attested text of the book of Hebrews. In his critical edition of the Ethiopic version of Hebrews, Tedros Abraha presents a diplomatic text of the 14th century Ambrosian manuscript. With the addition of the Sinai manuscript to this critical edition, we can more easily reconstruct the earliest Ethiopic text. In addition to its place as a valuable witness to the Ethiopic, the Sinai manuscript also provides insight to the relationship between the Ethiopic and Greek texts. As a result, for example, Hoskier’s work proclaiming a close correlation between the Ethiopic tradition and p46 no longer stands. This paper will survey the significance of the Sinai manuscript for the study of Hebrews in Ethiopic. First, it will analyze selected variations between the Sinai and Ambrosian manuscripts that are significant for the construction of the earliest text. In this section, it will identify places where the Sinai manuscript preserves an earlier tradition as well as those where comparison between the two manuscripts provides a window into an earlier reading not preserved by either. Second, it will evaluate the relationship of this earliest text to the Greek witnesses. Here, it will compare the earliest Greek texts with the earliest Ethiopic text to determine where a relationship between the two sets of witnesses can be found.
|
Bearing the Interest of Elites: Deuteronomy 23:20–21 in Light of Neo-Assyrian Debt Notes from the Western Provinces
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Guy Ridge, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion
Deuteronomy 23:20–21 continues to pose interpretive problems for biblical scholars. The text appears to completely ban the practice of lending at interest between native Israelites, while allowing the practice to continue between Israelites and foreigners. Attempts to understand its content raise the question of historical context: What was the historical situation in which the text was written? Given the amount of support generated by modern scholars for a seventh-century BCE composition date for the core legal texts of the book of Deuteronomy, the late Neo-Assyrian period is a logical starting point for investigation. This paper proposes that an argument for a seventh-century date of composition for Deut 23:20–21 is supported by a close-reading of Neo-Assyrian legal documents from the same period. Debt notes from the western provinces of the Neo-Assyrian Empire written in Akkadian and Aramaic provide a unique window into the lending practices of West Semitic elites in the seventh century BCE. These local elites took advantage of their elevated social positions under Neo-Assyrian hegemony, in part by lending at high rates of interest to their West Semitic kinsmen. This behavior by the elites in the western provinces of the Neo-Assyrian Empire raises the possibility that the author(s) of Deut 23:20–21 sought to subvert similar efforts by indigenous elites in Judah to exploit their own Hebrew kinsmen. Further support for this comparison can be found in non-legal biblical texts highlighting local elite exploitation in Israel and Judah in the eighth and seventh centuries. The aggregate evidence derived from this study suggests that Deut 23:20–21 was written in the hopes of eliminating the types of predatory lending that contributed to this indigenous elite exploitation of native Judahites under Neo-Assyrian hegemony.
|
God Sees You: Jeremiah 23:9–40 through the Lens of Foucault’s Surveiller et punir
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
Guy Ridge, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion
According to the Hebrew Bible, the prophet Jeremiah son of Hilkiah was no stranger to political debate. He seems to have inserted himself into the most pressing domestic and foreign policy deliberations facing the royal apparatus of decision-makers in Judah in the late seventh and early sixth centuries BCE. His unpopular positions afforded him a great deal of hostility from his contemporaries, including other prophets. In Jer 23:9–40, Jeremiah confronts his prophetic and priestly opponents directly, delivering a scathing set of oracles against them in the name of YHWH. Jeremiah 23:21–32 stands at the heart of this rebuke, warning the false prophets that YHWH can see and hear everything they think and say, and no one can escape his surveilling eye. Jeremiah’s depiction of YHWH’s omniscience resembles Michel Foucault’s presentation of panopticism in Surveiller et punir (1975), based on his analysis of Bentham’s Panopticon. Foucault interprets the Panopticon as a new type of political technology that allows those in authority to exercise the full extent of their power with the least amount of effort and the lowest amount of risk of revolt among the powerless. As some biblical scholars have already noted, YHWH’s ability to perfectly observe his subjects without being observable himself makes him akin to the warden in Bentham’s center tower, watching the inmates while they can never return his gaze. Jeremiah’s use of this rhetoric reflects an effort to establish himself as a prophet with special access to YHWH at the exclusion of his opponents, vying for a position of authority over the other prophets. Such a strategy is not unique to Jeremiah in the Hebrew Bible or the ancient Near East. In biblical laws, crimes that are not observable by other humans are said to be punished by YHWH personally. Similarly, treaty texts from throughout the ancient Near East used witness lists of deities called upon to hold each party accountable for the kinds of transgressions they could easily conceal from one another. The effect of this panoptic omniscience as a political tool of power is to create a group of subjects who self-police through the anticipation of punishment, without requiring the authorities to expend significant resources to enforce their sovereignty. Jeremiah employs the trope of YHWH’s ever watchful gaze in an effort to undermine the confidence of his interlocutors and reduce their standing before the ruling authorities in Judah, hoping to enhance his own position.
|
The Legal Loophole of Gen 2:17: “You Shall Die” but You Shall Not Not Live
Program Unit: Genesis
Jason A. Riley, Fuller Theological Seminary (Pasadena)
The delay of the death sentence in Genesis 2-3 has been a source of consternation for readers of the Bible as early as the second century B.C. (e.g., the book of Jubilees might provide the earliest interpretation of the death sentence; see Jub 4:29-30). Over the past two-thousand years, scholars have attempted to explain the apparent contradiction between the explicit death sentence in Gen 2:17 and the fact that Adam and Eve do not die on the day in which they ate the fruit of the tree of good and evil. Explanations range widely, e.g., (1) Yhwh meant that Adam and Eve would become mortal, (2) the punishment only seemed delayed but was ultimately carried out because of the meaning of the infinitive absolute (Hamilton, Speiser) or because a day to God is like a thousand years and Adam only lived 930 years (Jubilees), (3) the death that Yhwh referred to was spiritual death (Augustine), (4) Yhwh demonstrated mercy by not killing Adam and Eve, (5) withdrawing the possibility of rejuvenation by the tree of life (Sarna) by (6) expulsion from the garden was more catastrophic than death (Sarna, Wenham), or that (7) God simply changed his mind (Skinner). Many explanations for the apparent contradiction in the text are often influenced by the interpreters' theological presuppositions and rarely incorporate incorporate comparative data from the ancient Near East. This paper will argue that there is a simple literary explanation for the fact that the death sentence is not immediately carried out, and that this literary reason is made possible by the legal language used by Yhwh in Gen 2:17. The legal phrase "you shall die" is understood by comparison with legal terminology used throughout the ancient Near East and in the Hebrew Bible, first employed in the Laws of Eshnunna.
|
Moral Blindness: The Levite’s Concubine, Judges, and Samuel
Program Unit: Intertextuality and the Hebrew Bible
Jonathon Riley, Book of Mormon Central
Many commentators have noticed the similarities between the Levite’s concubine narrative in Judges and the description of Sodom and Gomorrah’s destruction in Genesis, as well as the similarities between the Levite’s concubine narrative and the description of Saul’s rise to power. However, because the Levite’s concubine narrative may have been a later insertion, commentators rarely note what implications these inner-biblical connections might have for understanding Judges and Samuel as a whole. Yet, when the narrative about the Levite’s concubine in Judges is read in light of the narrative concerning the rise of Saul as well as Lot’s experience in Sodom and Gomorrah in Genesis, the Levite’s concubine narrative can be seen as a comment on the moral state of Israel under the judges, demonstrated through imagery of blindness and sight. When Yaira Amit’s criterion for discerning “hidden polemic” in the Hebrew Bible is applied to the Levite’s concubine narrative, the omission of any references to blindness in the Levite’s concubine narrative (a prominent element in the Sodom and Gomorrah narrative) suggests that allusions to blindness and sight should be sought within Judges and Samuel, in the material surrounding the Levite’s concubine narrative and its aftermath. Because the stories of two deviant Levites, found in Judges 17-21, are framed by the phrase “in those days there was no king in Israel, each man did what was right in his own eyes,” one can see these chapters as a demonstration of the disaster that ensues when the morally blind Israelites do what is right in their own eyes. These chapters become the hinge around which much of Judges and early Samuel turns. As one examines the Samson narrative, one sees his descent from light and sight to darkness and blindness. The text repeatedly emphasizes “sight” and “light,” including sun imagery, until Samson is finally blinded. On the other side of the Levite’s concubine narrative, Samuel and Saul restore sight to Israel. Samuel the “seer,” one who sees, restores light and sight to Israel, as does King Saul, who rescues Jabesh, preventing the people of that city from being blinded by Nahash the Ammonite. Saul symbolically undoes many of the problems created by the judgeship. He saves Jabesh, which had been destroyed during the Judges. He cuts up an animal to encourage the people to come save a city of Israel, while the Levite cut up his concubine to encourage people to come destroy a city of Israel. The Saul narrative shows that, symbolically, the chaos and blindness of the period of the judges has been replaced by the sight and order of kingship. Regardless of the dating of the sources of these narratives, the narratives may have been seen this way by part of the early audience of the Deuteronomistic History and seeing it this way can give insights to modern readers that might otherwise be overlooked.
|
Deafening Silence: Sexual Violence in the Ammonihah Narrative When Read in Light of the Lot Narrative and the Levite’s Concubine Narrative
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
Jonathon Riley, Book of Mormon Central
Many commentators have noticed the similarities between the Levite’s concubine narrative in Judges and the description of Sodom and Gomorrah’s destruction in Genesis. These two narratives paint a disturbing picture of sexual violence and the violation of the laws of hospitality in the Hebrew Bible and are used to show the depravity of both Israel under the judges as well as Sodom. These narratives are also alluded to in the Book of Mormon, with the references to sexual violence removed. However, when one applies Yaira Amit’s methodology for finding hidden polemic in the Hebrew Bible to the Book of Mormon, it is possible that sexual violence is implied in the Ammonihah narrative (Alma 8-16) although it is not explicitly mentioned. The significant parallels between the Lot narrative and the Levite’s concubine narrative appear to have been noticed by the author of the Book of Mormon, who weaves together allusions to both stories in crafting the Ammonihah narrative. The Ammonihah narrative draws extensively on the two narratives, using textual “red flags,” including paranomasia, to alert the reader to the fact that it is alluding to these narratives. This missing references to sexual violence, when read in light of theories derived from biblical narrative, suggest that the author is implicitly condemning the sexual violence of these biblical narratives. He is doing this by alluding to all the material surrounding the sexual assault scenes in the biblical narratives, while not mentioning anything about sexual violence itself, creating a sort of “deafening silence” that implicitly condemns the violence. This idea is strengthened by the fact that there are other recurring, if oblique, condemnations of sexual violence in both Mosiah and Alma, which suggests that this condemnation may be present in the Ammonihah narrative as well. The allusions to the Levite’s concubine narrative and the Lot narrative in the Ammonihah narrative are manifold. Considering Ammonihah’s track record with women and children (burning a number of women and children alive simply because they were believers) the city may certainly have had a problem with sexual violence, so the lack of any reference to sexual violence may be surprising at first. However, by alluding to these narratives without directly mentioning them, the Book of Mormon can condemn sexual violence without directly referencing it, depending on the reader to pick up the allusions and infer what the author seems to have wanted the reader to infer: sexual violence like that seen in the Lot narrative and the Levite’s concubine narrative is the worst kind of heinous sin, the kind of sin that warrants complete destruction by God if the perpetrators are not repentant.
|
Tertium Genus or Dyadic Unity? Ecclessiology as Soteriology in Ephesians
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Andrew Remington Rillera, Duke University
Scholars are nearly unanimous in reading Ephesians 2:11–22 as promoting a tertium genus (“third race”) ecclesiology that entails the beliefs (1) that the Torah has been abolished and (2) that Torah-observance (such as circumcising sons) is rendered problematic for baptized Jews. Contrary to this, this paper argues that Ephesians 2:11–22 renders the dissolution of Torah-observant Jews within the church soteriologically problematic. This essay claims that Christians should rethink tertium genus ecclesiologies as a result of the soteriological consequences of the exegesis of Ephesians. It also argues that according to Ephesians the covenantal distinction between Jews and gentiles, circumcised and uncircumcised, not only remains valid within the church, but soteriologically essential for the church (even though their relationship with each other has been reordered under the peaceable rule of Christ to mean mutual hospitality rather than mutual hostility). The paper also argues that the church, the locus of participation in Christ’s salvation, should be understood as a dyadic unity (a non-homogenous socio-political reality) that renders a tertium genus reading soteriologically problematic. This is based upon the claims within Ephesians 2–3 that depict Jesus’s saving death as establishing the citizenship of gentiles qua gentile within the commonwealth of Israel. Tertium genus ecclesiology amounts to the dissolution of the commonwealth of Israel within the church and thereby disrupts the socio-political reality Jesus established (since baptized Jews are discouraged from remaining Torah-observant and therefore become gentile in practice). This state of affairs, then, is problematic soteriologically and exegetically because it leaves gentile believers in an ecclessial socio-political reality in which there is no genuine ongoing association in “all generations” (3:21) with the Torah-observant “circumcision” thereby leaving them in the ironic state of being “estranged from the commonwealth of Israel” (2:12), which is the very condition the text claims Jesus overcomes by his blood (2:13).
|
Providence and Polemics: The Second Temple in Tobit and Isaiah
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Joseph Riordan, University of Notre Dame
The Book of Tobit is a novella from the Hellenistic period that relates the story of a faithful Israelite who goes into exile with the northern tribes in the 8th century. At the end of the tale, after Tobit miraculously recovers his sight and fortune and missing son, he breaks out in a psalm of praise that correlates his own restoration with that of Jerusalem (Tobit 13), channeling imagery and motifs from Isaiah 60. To be sure, Tobit registers some criticisms of the Second Temple (“it will not be like the first one,” at least initially, as he predicts in Tob 14:5), though he accepts its basic legitimacy and deems it providentially willed, even though it does not exhaust the glorious promises that are attached to Zion. This stands in contrast to one strand within Isaiah scholarship that traces Isaiah 60 back to a “visionary” faction that became bitterly alienated and disillusioned with the Second Temple and its clerical guardians, and consequently sought to retreat from the nightmare of history into the cosmic realm of myth. This paper will argue that Tobit’s more irenic reading of the oracle captures its inner dynamics with sharper nuance than this prominent approach.
|
Cult and Community: Commentary on a Second Chronicles Commentary
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Ken Ristau, MacEwan University
no abstract
|
Paul as Sacrificial Expert
Program Unit: The Historical Paul
James Rives, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
In a much-studied series of passages, Paul addresses concerns raised by his correspondents about two issues that, although distinct, both focus on matters of commensality: whether Christ-followers may eat food sacrificed to idols (1 Cor. 8-10), and how they are to conduct themselves at their own communal meals (1 Cor. 11:17-34). In doing so, he presents himself as an expert in the wider significance of sacrificial ritual. Paul was not the only religious expert of the early empire to address this issue, although we lack the sort of direct evidence for the thinking of other figures that we have for Paul. It is nevertheless clear that the early empire saw the development of a new theology of sacrificial practice that we can see in the works of such later figures as Celsus, Porphyry, and Iamblichus. As I have argued elsewhere (Rives 2011), there is some reason to associate this development with Neopythagoreans such as Apollonius of Tyana. Although the historical Apollonius is beyond our reach, enough evidence survives from varied authors (Philostratus, Porphyry, and Eusebius, as well as the letters attributed to Apollonius himself) to allow us to reconstruct some of the general views that were at least ascribed to him by later tradition. Two aspects provide intriguing comparanda with Paul’s own views. First, Apollonius and Paul both advocate alternative ritual forms as substitutes for animal sacrifice, albeit in very different ways. Apollonius rejects animal sacrifice as an appropriate form of offering to the gods, and instead emphasizes such inanimate offerings as incense. By contrast, there is no evidence that Paul rejected the practice of animal sacrifice. Nevertheless, it was not an option for his addressees, the gentile Christ-followers of Corinth, and he in effect presents the Lord’s Supper of bread and wine as an alternative ritual locus of commensality. Secondly, and more importantly, both Apollonius and Paul locate the meaning of animal sacrifice in an understanding of the superhuman world that is at odds with, or at least significantly distinct from, that implied by traditional Greek sacrificial practice: Apollonius in a hierarchy of increasingly remote superhuman entities, with which he correlates a hierarchy of sacrificial practices, and Paul in a cosmic duality of God and demons. They thus both present themselves as authoritative guides to appropriate ritual practice, based on their privileged knowledge about the true nature of the cosmos. (Rives 2011: ‘The Theology of Animal Sacrifice in the Ancient Greek World: Origins and Developments’, in J. W. Knust and Z. Várhelyi, eds., Ancient Mediterranean Sacrifice. Oxford: Oxford University Press [2011], 187-202.)
|
Status Inconsistency in the Biblical Laws and the Psalms of the Poor
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
Johannes Unsok Ro, International Christian University
Status inconsistency refers to a social phenomenon that emerges when an individual’s resources within various social class systems become inconsistent. In our view, status inconsistency played a crucial role in certain facets of the religion of Judean communities in the Persian and Hellenistic periods. Judean communities in the Persian and Hellenistic eras should be scrutinized on the microlevel as a citizen-temple community with the particular attribute of status inconsistency. The unique features of the citizen-temple community distorted and twisted the distributive systems of the respective Judean societies. They contributed to increase status inconsistency of social strata within the communities in Yehud and thus to the origins of the unparalleled radicalism of certain biblical law codes in the Pentateuch. Furthermore, the phenomenon of status inconsistency provides an insightful clue to the question of why the theology of the poor was generated by a select group of people who cannot be located in the lower stratum of postexilic Judean society.
|
Cosmic Texture in Early Christian Writings
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Vernon K. Robbins, Emory University
This paper will explore presuppositions about the shape, structure, and nature of the cosmos in New Testament writings in relation to three Jewish apocalypses now presupposed to be written during the first century CE: 2 Baruch, the Apocalypse of Abraham, and the Parables of Enoch (1 Enoch 37–71). What is the relation of the perception of the shape, structure, and nature of the cosmos in these three first century Jewish writings to views of the cosmos in writings in the New Testament? Is it possible to describe a limited range of alternative perceptions of the shape, structure, and nature of the cosmos in first century CE Jewish apocalyptic writings? If so, what is the relation of this range of perceptions to writings in the New Testament? Toward the end of the paper, it will be proposed that emergent storylines of precreation Jesus as the agent of the heaven-earth cosmos during the last half of the first century CE in New Testament writings inaugurated some significant innovations in perceptions of the apocalyptic cosmos, and some of those innovations appear to be related to some Greek philosophical thinking about the nature of the cosmos.
|
Teaching the Bible across the Church
Program Unit: Anglican Association of Biblical Scholars
C. K. Robertson, General Theological Seminary
(No abstract at this point.)
|
The Greek Syntax Package: Bringing Open Linguistic Data into Documents
Program Unit: Global Education and Research Technology
Jonathan Robie, SIL International
Researchers, teachers, and students of biblical languages often write texts that invoke linguistic examples or corpus statistics. Sometimes these are found using commercial software, sometimes they are prepared manually, sometimes they are produced by querying datasets using programs or databases.
The Jupyter Notebook is an open-source web application that allows researchers to create and share documents that contain live code and visualizations so that written texts can contain the queries that produce their examples and the data analysis behind their claims. It is widely used in scientific fields to make it easier for researchers to collaborate, replicate results, and build on each other’s work.
Together with open datasets, notebooks are an important tool for doing open science, but they require software that can interpret the data and return it in formats Jupyter Notebooks can use. Scientists in a given field often have software packages specific to their field. Recently, the Jupyter Notebook has become central to Hebrew research at the the Eep Talstra Centre for Bible and Computer (ETCBC), which has developed a package called Text Fabric for their data. The Greek Syntax package is designed to allow queries on open datasets for New Testament Greek, including Greek morphological, syntactical, and discourse analyses, contextualized glosses, and lexicons. This talk demonstrates a large notebook that explores biblical Greek syntax for asking and answering questions. Each section contains text and a query based on a corpus.
|
Popup Greek
Program Unit: Global Education and Research Technology
Jonathan Robie, SIL International
Teachers increasingly recognize the importance of teaching biblical Greek using the same kind of modern, effective techniques used to teach modern languages in schools and universities. These techniques focus on carefully designed learning activities that require the student to think in the target language in order to respond appropriately. There are now several university level courses that take this approach to teaching Greek, but we believe that there is a real need for a course that (1) can be taught by anyone with a solid reading knowledge of Greek (using the teacher’s notes and recordings to prepare), (2) concentrates on texts drawn from the New Testament, and (3) is freely available. For those who do not have access to a teacher, we believe that it is also important to be able to learn online. This course works through New Testament texts using pictures, TPR, and asking and answering questions in Greek. Each lesson has (1) a content objective focused on the text and (2) a language objective like those found in a traditional Greek textbook. Linguistic terms are taught after students have experienced the construct they describe. Before introducing a term like “1st person singular,” we expose students to the word ἐγώ and verb forms that correspond to it. Before introducing terms like nominative, genitive, dative, accusative, we teach how to ask and answer questions using questions with the corresponding forms τίς, τίνος, τίνι, τίνα. Before introducing terms like circumstantial participle, we act out scenarios that illustrate the relationship between two verbs. In keeping with the philosophy of this course, this presentation will focus on presenting sample teaching activities live rather than talking about them, followed by discussion of the specific content or language objective and why we teach it the way we do.
|
“This Great House…and Also This Laundry”: Religion and Work at the White Monastery
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Dana Robinson, Creighton University
In a sermon commemorating his monumental 5th century church, Shenoute proudly lists his building projects: “this great house, and these other places that we have built with it, and also this laundry” – a frankly amusing juxtaposition of the monumental with the mundane. (1) Though of course, the church stood at the heart of a complex multi-functional site, recent work at the White Monastery complex by the Yale-sponsored Monastic Archaeology Project has uncovered large areas of food and craft production and even water treatment installations. From one viewpoint, this built environment simply reflects the twin pillars of monastic life: work and prayer.
However, a close spatial association between religion and work in everyday life is not unique to monastic compounds. Many Roman neighborhoods would have included both small and large cult sites, from monumental temples, to the small crossroad shrines of the Lares Compitales, to small lararia in workshops and taverns. These cult sites and their support systems are integrated into the experiential landscape of daily work. The Temple of Fortuna Augusta in Pompeii, for example, juts out into a busy street corner while its small residential compound, at the back, lacks its own water supply and must share the nearby neighborhood well. According to Ulrike Egelhaaf-Gaiser, this site shows “a functional merging of sacred cult space and secular urban space” that “participates fully in the daily life of the city.” (2) So I propose that the spatial and conceptual juxtaposition of a monumental cult site with work areas at the White Monastery complicates the traditional narrative of monastic labor by making it more, rather than less, like “worldly” labor. Furthermore, I argue that the monastery – as a highly-theorized microcosm of daily life – can be used to reverse-engineer a glimpse of the working world outside its walls.
As has already been shown in other work, Shenoute’s claims to monastic uniqueness mask a deep structural dependence on the systems and values of the Roman social world. Ariel López has shown how much Shenoute’s monastery was economically integrated into the community via the patronage system, despite his assertions to the contrary. Rebecca Krawiec approached Shenoute’s construction of work from the household perspective, showing how he draws on Roman family values, divisions of labor, and gender roles to impose hierarchy despite his ideological commitment to ascetic equality. So I think it is also likely that his view of monastic labor reflects, in inverted or exaggerated form, some common views on work and religion in non-monastic settings. But beyond the prescriptive ideological vision, the comparison of spatial environments where religion meets daily work will also, I hope, reveal some experiential affinities of religion and work in the lives of monks and other ordinary Romans.
(1) Shenoute, This Great House, Canons 7 XL 273-274; Stephen Emmel, Shenoute’s Literary Corpus (Leuven: Peeters 2004), 583.
(2) Ulrike Egelhaaf-Gaiser, “Roman Cult Sites: A Pragmatic Approach,” in Jörg Rüpke, A Companion to Roman Religion (Malden, MA: Blackwell, 2007), 218-221.
|
Childbearing, Liminal States, and Mark 13
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Laura Robinson, Duke University
While traditionally scholars have taken Mark 13 as an ex eventu prophecy depicting the destruction of the Temple in 70 CE, in recent decades more scholars have challenged the idea that this is the case. The depiction of the Temple’s destruction in Mark 13 is not necessarily prophecy ex eventu, given its highly stereotyped nature (Marcus 870-71) and frankly, its inaccuracy (869). In her commentary, A. Y. Collins ventures the possibility that Mark 13 is actually , but a look ahead to a future unfulfilled desecration of the Temple inspired by the memory of Caligula’s attempt to put his likeness in the sanctuary. Mark assumes following the book of Daniel that during the Messianic Woes, Rome will attempt to do something similarly blasphemous. The construction of the idol will cause extreme profanation of the sanctuary, prompting God to respond by swiftly destroying the pace in an act mirroring the flood and Sodom and Gomorrah.
The argument of this paper is that Collins is basically right, and that her argument is bolstered by a long-neglected piece of data in the text -- Jesus’ prediction of particular harm for pregnant and nursing mothers. Generally, this line is explained as an instance of Jesus’ compassion for the vulnerable. But if this is all that inspires the quote, it is difficult to explain why Jesus is particularly concerned about pregnant and recently-postpartum mothers, and not the sick, elderly, and handicapped who would have arguably had an even harder time fleeing in a hurry. My argument is that this verse deserves more critical attention than it receives in most commentaries, and is best explained by fears of impurity. In a wide range of ancient Greco-Roman texts, we see evidence that pregnant and nursing mothers were commonly assumed to be particularly vulnerable to ritual pollution. Their nearness to the occasion of birth put them in a liminal state, and in such circumstances ordinary pollutants could be made especially potent. Pregnant and recently postpartum mothers were strongly encouraged to avoid polluting agents on the grounds that such agents were understood to cause miscarriage or death. It is possible that the pollution that Mark is concerned about is the pollution of dead bodies, which would place this passage after the siege of Jerusalem. However, if this is the case, the command to flee is deeply counterintuitive, since a woman fleeing the city would be fleeing directly towards the Roman army. What is most likely is that MArk is envisioning a catastrophic reaction to an imagined future impurity in the Temple, and is advising all people to get away from the Temple before such a desecration causes destruction. Given their particular vulnerability to a desecrated space, pregnant and nursing mothers are warned to be especially vigilant. This would place Mark before 70 CE in an area experiencing heightened expectations of the end, and imminent eschatological woes.
|
The Scepter from Judah (Gen 49:10): A Diachronic Evaluation
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Jonathan M. Robker, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
In many modern translations of Gen 49:10, one reads of a scepter never turning aside or departing from Judah. But to what should this refer? The common interpretation has been messianic in some capacity. By considering other usages of the term scepter (שׁבט) and its reflection in ancient translations, this paper will discuss whether this modern understanding is appropriate. Further, by considering the interrelationship between Gen 49:10 (including its text-critical variants) and other biblical texts, this paper will address whether this term even appeared in the oldest reconstructable version of Gen 49:10. Finally, I will reflect on when this term made its way into Genesis 49 and its related texts, particularly those in the Torah.
|
What's in a Frame? The Utility of Trajector-Landmark Frame Diagrams for Biblical Hebrew
Program Unit: Cognitive Linguistics in Biblical Interpretation
Daniel Rodriguez, Stellenbosch University
Trajector (=TR)/landmark (=LM) frame diagrams have now been used by cognitive semanticists to describe the relationships symbolized by prepositions for almost four decades. Brugman (1981) and Lakoff (1987) started by using these image schemas to describe the polysemies of the English preposition "over". Since then others have built a great deal of cognitive semantic theory based on this method, namely in Tyler and Evans (2003) and Evans (2010) criticism of that prior work. More recently, Hebraists have applied this method to biblical Hebrew (=BH) prepositions (Mena 2012, Rodriguez 2011, 2016, etc.). In fact, the language of TR/LM is used in the newly revised second edition of Biblical Hebrew Reference Grammar (Van der Merwe-Naudé 2017) (=BHRG) in the preposition section of the grammar.
However, the method is not without criticism. Riemer (2010) has criticized the ability of TR/LM diagrams to be precise. Lyle (2011) applied this criticism to the work of Rodriguez (2011), and, while still using the language of TR/LM to describe prepositional relationships, BHRG does not use the frame diagrams themselves. This paper asks whether or not TR/LM frame diagrams are still useful for BH semantic description. It will be shown that while the limitations of such a tool must be acknowledged, it can still serve as a tested methodological useful tool in many expected situations and as a heuristic tool in some unexpected situations.
|
"Strengthened in Faith, Giving Glory to God": Resurrection and the Forge of Abrahamic Memory in Paul
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Rafael Rodriguez, Johnson University
In Paul's remembering of Abraham we see the dynamics of collective memory at work. On the one hand, it is nearly axiomatic among Pauline students that Paul recasts Abraham according to his own interests. The apostle found in the patriarch fertile ground for pursuing his rhetorical and theological aims. Abraham's plasticity in Pauline memory is obvious enough; in Romans 4, Paul goes so far as to portray Abraham's faith in God in terms of his confidence in the resurrection! On the other hand, the emphasis on the malleability of Abraham in Pauline memory has produced a number of interpretive problems. These problems include claims that Paul redefines descent from Abraham to marginalize Torah and circumcision, and that he-in contrast to most of his contemporaries-imagines an open and universal Abrahamic family. The firmer we press claims such as these, the less recognizable becomes Paul's Abrahamic memory as memory of Abraham. Social memory research offers a better perspective from which to see Paul's Abrahamic memory as simultaneously innovative and traditional, in which Paul is constrained by established commemorative patterns even as he creatively engages those patterns in his proclamation of his gospel to gentiles. Paul's Abrahamic memory was fundamentally shaped by his understanding and interpretation of Jesus' resurrection and its significance for Jesus' followers. We should not, however, overlook the dramatic consequences of Abrahamic traditions on Paul's own resurrection faith, which consequences rendered Paul's presentation of Abraham recognizable and consonant with Jewish discourse of the Second Temple period.
|
The Judean Wilderness Meets the American Frontier
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
Wil Rogan, Fuller Theological Seminary
This paper compares the treatment of the wilderness in the Gospel of Matthew and in the work of the American historian Frederick Jackson Turner, in order to illuminate and critique some of the religious architecture of early twentieth-century American self-consciousness. In the Gospel of Matthew, the wilderness is conceptualized as a place of purification (as the setting of John’s Isaianic ministry of baptism and preaching), revelation (as the location where the heavens were opened and divine word spoken at the baptism of Jesus), and testing (as the place the Spirit directed Jesus to be tested by the devil). The wilderness in Matthew is thus an imaginative construct that imbues desolate land with theological intensity; the wilderness is the place of God’s mercy and judgment. The wilderness as a conceptual construct has also been significant in imagining America, because of Frederick Jackson Turner’s “Frontier Thesis,” which was first introduced in his seminal essay “The Significance of the Frontier in American History” (1894). Turner argued that to understand America one must understand the American frontier, which was "the line of most rapid and effective Americanization.” For Turner, the frontier was, at its most basic level, the meeting point between the European colonist and the American wilderness. The wilderness first “masters the colonist,” by stripping away the customs and sensibilities of Europe, and then that wilderness is developed by the colonist into a distinctively new thing, namely, America. In Matthew, the wilderness as purification is a break with the past, insofar as the forgiveness of sins is offered there. In Turner, the frontier as purification is a break with the past, insofar as its ruggedness strips away European customs. In Matthew, the wilderness as revelation is a divine word identifying Jesus as Son of God. In Turner, the frontier as revelation is the theory that identifies America in its distinctiveness and exceptionalism. In Matthew, the wilderness as testing means the salvation of a people through Jesus. In Turner, the frontier as testing means the "perennial rebirth" of America through adaptation and conflict. Turner’s Frontier Thesis, which has been contested on historical grounds and is now philosophically outdated, must also come under theological critique: its religious architecture replaces Jesus with America, and God’s salvation of humanity with American promise.
|
Commentary on the Sacrifices of Cain and Abel
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Justin Rogers, Freed-Hardeman University
Forthcoming
|
Perception Risk in the Sermon on the Mount
Program Unit: Cognitive Science Approaches to the Biblical World
Rikard Roitto, Stockholm School of Theology
The paper considers how the Sermon convinces its readers to accept its risky ethics by means of insights from risk research. The human estimate of risk is largely based on emotions associated with reward, dread, moral appreciation, trust and other factors, and the Sermon’s rhetoric skillfully guides the listeners emotional appreciation of the dangers and rewards involved in abiding by its ethics. The dangers involved in an ethics that makes one vulnerable is countered by dread-invoking images of the final judgment and promises that God will make sure that the righteous will not lack basic material resources. The ethics is also portrayed as both prototypical for those who belong to the Kingdom of Heaven (the Matthean community) and morally superior to ordinary ethics, which would have led its readers to a positive emotional evaluation of it. This, in turn, would have repressed negative emotions of danger, since humans tend to strive for uniform emotional responses. The potential social effects of the risky ethics of the Sermon is discussed, suggesting that it had the potential to encourage the Matthean community to remain in socially risky interaction with other Jewish groups.
|
"Revelation as History" in Pannenberg and Liberation Theology: Remarks on Avery Dulles' Proposal
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
David Roldan, Instituto Teologico FIET, Buenos Aires, Argentina
Dulles proposition that Liberation Theology has to be interpreted as fitting in the “awareness” model of Revelation is partially correct. Whereas Juan Luis Segundo can be clearly included in the “awareness” model—since he constructed his concept of revelation through the evolutionary scheme of Teilhard de Chardin—theologians like Gustavo Gutiérrez, Rubem Alves, Porfirio Miranda and Míguez Bonino fit much better within the historical model. Given the fact that W. Pannenberg is the “preeminent defender” of the Revelation as history model, it is needed to be conceded that Liberation Theologians share many elements in this model. Nevertheless, Liberation Theologians represent an attempt to draw theological conclusions from this starting point in a much more concrete, and allegedly more effective way, than Pannenberg. While Pannenberg remains in the realm of a mere symbolic relationship between Church and Kingdom of God, Liberation Theologians emphasized the eschatological significance of historical actions for the new aivw,n . The Liberation Theology model of revelation is missed by Dulles because he misses the concept “to know God is to love the neighbor”, which has a central role in Latin American theology. This emphasis is easier to be included in “historical model” than “new-awareness” model in many of the cases.
|
Contemporary Readings on Paul’s Theology: The Latin American Contribution
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
David A. Roldan, FIET Theological Institute
No wonder that the theology of Paul has a central role in Western Culture. Passing through theological reflection in “long term theology” (St. Augustine, Luther, Wesley, Barth) to exegetical contextual appropriation (Rudolf Bultmann, Ernst Kässemann, Elsa Tamez), the case is that Western philosophy was deeply interested in St. Paul legacy also (for example, the concept of “Geist” in Hegel, through Lutheran translation of “Pneuma”). With the central role that atheist Marxism took in Twentieth Century (with the climax in Jean-Paul Sartre’s pilgrim to Marxism, for example), philosophical readings of St. Paul came to a “Thermidor”. The main hypothesis of this article is that with the fall of East Socialism, postmodern readings of St. Paul (and religion in general) were welcome again. But some philosophical readings do not match with postmodern mood ―that of Slavoj Žižek, Jacob Taubes, Alain Badiou and Enrique Dussel. Certainly we can find very interesting approaches in Giorgio Agamben and Daniel Boyarin, in another tradition, representing a contribution to a postmodern reading of Pauline theology. The Pauline Greek syntagma “hos mè” (1 Cor. 7.29) is a particular case, in the interpretations of Martin Heidegger and Gianni Vattimo —as postmodern receptions too. My thesis is that Latin American theology can make a contribution to the discussion on Paul and Politics in these specific domains: a) the relationship between “Paul and Freud”, as Jacob Taubes stated, can be found also in Juan Luis Segundo; b) the relationship between “Paul and Hegel”, in Žižek, can be found also in Juan Luis Segundo; c) the “political implications” of Paul’s theology can be found in Míguez Bonino, Rubem Alves and Juan Luis Segundo, in the “Latin American golden age” (1970-1990). Enrique Dussel developed, recently, a new approach to St. Paul’s theology that matches with Liberation theology legacy.
|
The Yeshayah[u] Bulla and Reasonable Doubt: A Sober Analysis of the Evidence
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Chris Rollston, George Washington University
This presentation will focus on the evidence that would need to be present to make a good, cogent case for this inscription as hailing from a seal of Isaiah the Prophet. The concluding components of this presentation will focus on best practices for the publication of an artifact, especially those with putative sensational content or great importance.
|
The DNI Bible project (Dictionary of Nature Imagery of the Bible): An Introduction
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Dalit Rom-Shiloni, Tel Aviv University
What do biblical scholars need to know in their exegetical work when addressing a plant (e.g. 'eshel "tamarisk"), an animal (e.g., hasidah "stork"), a watercourse (e.g., 'afiq "stream"?), a climate phenomenon (e.g., ruah qadim "the east wind"), or a landscape characteristic (to give a more complexed example, carmel as "border of the desert")? DNI Bible is a new comprehensive academic online encyclopedia of all references to nature and nature imagery in the Bible in five fields: Fauna, Flora, Landscape characteristics, Climate systems, and Water sources (dni.tau.ac.il). The project is aimed at deciphering nature images in terms of their biblical occurrences, their history of identifications, their biological / life sciences background, material culture findings, and reception history. It is designed to expand the exegetical toolbox by becoming a recognized device that Bible scholars can turn to when addressing aspects of nature that together comprise the natural scope in which the Bible was written and to which the texts relate. The point of departure for this project is the recognition that knowledge of diverse aspects of the biology and ecology of the biblical world is essential for exegesis. The DNI Bible sets a rigorous multi-disciplinary study that adjoins expert contributions of leading life and natural studies scientists and archaeologists, that could provide biblical scholars with the needed tools to allow deeper understandings of biblical texts in general, and poetic nature images in particular. The introductory remarks will present the methodology and the six layers structure of each item in the DNI Bible, leading to this session's multi-disciplinary case study.
|
Bird Metaphors of Nesting and Parenthood: Contents and Functions
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible and Cognate Literature
Dalit Rom-Shiloni, Tel Aviv University
This paper looks at the ornithological sphere of nesting and parenthood with two major goals: First, to describe the overall biblical data concerning the different ways poets and prophets use these metaphors and similes as they refer to specific species or generalize their images on behavioral qualities of birds. Mapping the metaphors reveals the contents and functions that images of nesting and parenthood serve in; e.g., metaphors that illustrate divine protection of his people and city (Deut 32:11; Isa 31:5), or those that portray divine judgment of one of the foreign surrounding nations, Edom (Jer 49:15–16; Obadia 1–4). Second, the study focuses on the phenomenon of nesting upon the ground. This less familiar imagery serves as the ornithological background behind two wisdom sayings (Jer 17:11; Job 39:13–18) and one prophetic passage (Isa 13:13–14). I will decipher each of these nature images, and address the functions of each imagery in its context. The co-operation of biblical studies and ornithology formed by the DNI Bible module leads to new understandings of each of these texts.
|
Intertextual Reverberations in the New Testament through the Phrase τοῖς ἀγαπῶσιν αὐτον from Deuteronomy 7:9 and Literature of the Second Temple Period
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
James Romano, Fuller Theological Seminary
In the New Testament, there are three uses of the precise phrase, "for those who love him" (τοῖς ἀγαπῶσιν αὐτον, 1 Cor 2:9; Jas 1:12; 2:5). This exact wording is also found in the LXX in Deut 7:9 and Esd B 11:5 (Neh 1:5 MT). Additionally, the Greek phrase occurs in Sirach 1:10; and Psalms of Solomon 6:6; 14:1. This paper explores the phrase as a sensible unit of speech evoking an additional motif through application of an intertextual method. Beyond the potential for "parallelomania" in over selecting incidental verbal connections, this analysis will demonstrate other significant thematic echoes. First, there are other indications of an additional consistent layer echoing in each of these texts regarding covenant between God and people, which supports a good case for metalepsis. Second, there is also a strong additional intertextual echo between the immediate context of 1 Cor 2:9 and Sir 1:1-10 in the theme of God's wisdom as a gift "for those who love him." It will be argued there is an additional theological trope for those who are in a covenant relationship with God, which is signaled by the phrase under examination along with its uses in each place. The brevity of the phrase is limiting but taken together with the other uses and also the potential for a theological trope that was understood by the originally intended audience, it is possible to see connections that are not easily dismissed. This provides a case of a brief allusion evoking a broader, significant echo as it points to a principle important to what it means to be counted among the faithful covenant people of God. This additional echo relates to Paul's notion of faithfulness between God and the people of God.
|
The Origin and Development of the So-Called Ark Narrative
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Thomas Römer, Collège de France - University of Lausanne
This paper will argue that the original Ark narrative ended in 1 Sam 7:1 with the transfer of the Ark to Kiriath Jearim. This narrative was apparently a Northern work, composed possibly under Jeroboam II, who wanted to legitimate the site of Kiriath Jearim as one of his "border sanctuaries". 2 Sam 6 was composed much later when Josiah took over the territory of Benjamin and transferred the Ark to his capital.
|
Jeroboam II’s Israel: Literary and Archaeological Perspectives
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Thomas Römer, Collège de France - University of Lausanne
(no abstract)
|
It’s a Beautiful Day in the (Mostly Empty) Neighborhood: Settlement Patterns at Mt. Gerizim and Early Second Temple Jerusalem
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Kirstin Rose-Bean, Baylor University
In the tradition of Gary Knoppers’s investigation into cultural indicators of the communities of Samaria and Yehud in the Persian period (Jews and Samaritans: The Origins and History of Their Early Relations), my paper presents an analysis of both archaeological and textual evidence of settlement patterns around the temple sites of the two groups, at Jerusalem and Mt. Gerizim. Knoppers argues that the similarities between the communities of Yehud and Samaria are strong enough that a common origin cannot explain their continued parallel development if the two groups identified as separate communities. Rather, Samaria and Yehud must have had “substantial and persistent” contact with one another to explain this development (Knoppers, 133). Knoppers reaches this conclusion through comparisons of cultural indicators like language, cultic paraphernalia (or lack thereof), names, sacrificial animals, and religious stigmas.
My investigation into settlement patterns adds yet another cultural indicator to Knoppers’s list of similar practices. In both Jerusalem and Mt. Gerizim, the site of the temple was sparsely populated in the Persian period and became more heavily settled only in the Hellenistic period. At Mt. Gerizim, residential space in the Persian period is limited to a few rooms for the priests and some courtyard space for visiting worshippers. In Jerusalem in the Persian period, the archaeological evidence is limited, but provides no evidence of occupation at the Temple Mount. The earlier materials of the book of Nehemiah do provide some evidence of limited occupation in the temple itself (Neh 13:4-9) and some priestly occupation near the temple mount (Neh 3). Even assuming these texts accurately reflect Persian period Jerusalem, this limited occupation is a good parallel to the few residential spaces at Mt. Gerizim. It appears likely that the priestly communities of both Samaria and Yehud followed some sort of priestly rotation, like that mentioned in Ezra 6:18. The bulk of the priestly communities likely lived in nearby towns, Shechem for the Samarian priests and the City of David for the Yehudite priests. This examination of settlement patterns therefore adds another piece of evidence that although the communities of Samaria and Yehud may have identified as separate and maintained some minor distinctions, their similarities on many issues indicate communication and shared development of practice during the Persian period.
|
Expulsion and Binding: Canonical Perspectives on the Sons of Abraham
Program Unit: Genesis
Eliza Rosenberg, Utah State University
The binding of Isaac (Gen. 22) has a long history as a key but troubling text for Jewish and Christian interpreters alike. God's demand that Abraham kill his own son, and Abraham's willingness to comply without question, raise seemingly endless questions about sacrifice, theodicy, righteousness, trust, ethics, and a host of other issues. Jewish tradition links the binding of Isaac to atonement and to the end of sacrifice, while Christian theology has tended toward typological interpretation, sometimes veering into supercessionism. Historical and textual critics have taken a full range of positions on the pericope.
I aim to offer another perspective on the text, one that reads it in canonical context. Here, the binding of Isaac follows the expulsion of Hagar and Ishmael, which led to Hagar's theophany and Ishmael's near-death. I argue that God's demand of Isaac as a sacrifice, and Abraham's mute assent, mirror Sarah's demand that Abraham destroy his other son, to which Abraham and God appear to acquiesce. In this reading, Sarah is nearly forced to lose her son in the same way that she nearly forced Hagar to lose hers. In both cases, Abraham is the immediate agent and God the last-minute intervener. The binding puts Isaac on an equal footing with Ishmael before both God and their father. The permanent damage the the Abraham-Sarah-Isaac family is implied to suffer thereafter serves as a commentary on and a consequence for the treatment of Hagar and Ishmael.
|
The Early Rabbinic Conversion Process as a Transition from Impurity to Purity
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
Michael Rosenberg, Hebrew College
Scholars have long debated whether early Rabbinic texts assumed some sort of impurity inherent to gentiles. One key site of this debate has been the Rabbinic conversion process. Was immersion always a component of Rabbinic conversion? And if so, what does this requirement mean for Rabbinic conceptions of gentiles, boundaries, and the permeability of those boundaries?
In this paper, I will first demonstrate briefly that immersion appears as an assumed component of conversion from the earliest Rabbinic texts (and that debate about this point results from an undue focus on the Mishnah specifically). In light of this, I will then turn to consider the meaning(s) of immersion and the significance of this act for conceptualizing early Rabbinic conversion. Although at some later point—certainly by the latest strata of the Babylonian Talmud—immersion evinced a range of meanings with relevance to discourses of ritual impurity, identity, and prohibition, in the earliest extant Rabbinic texts (i.e. those of the early third century C.E.), immersion was always associated with matters of ritual impurity. Though a few examples, such as the immersion of a mourner, seem to counter this claim, careful attention to the meanings of immersion in those cases, without recourse to later interpretations, makes clear that they too reflect concern about impurity. Thus, conversion, with its requirement of ritual immersion, was for these early Rabbinic authors, at least in part, likewise a matter of transitioning from a state of impurity to one of purity. To become a Jew, in early Rabbinic texts, to some extent meant to achieve ritual purity.
|
Jewish, Gentile, and Divine Prisons: Rabbinic Use of Incarceration Imagery as Divine Punishment
Program Unit: Social History of Formative Christianity and Judaism
Michael Rosenberg, Hebrew College
The deathbed scene of the mythological founder of Rabbinic Judaism, Rabban Yohanan ben Zakkai (henceforth RYbZ), has been the focus of as much scholarship as perhaps any other in the Rabbinic canon, largely for its perceived relevance to (and potential contrast with) Pauline theology. Less attention has been payed, however, to the reference in RYbZ’s parting words to two kinds of prison. One, which would be fearful enough, RYbZ says, is the prison which is not everlasting, i.e. human-made, earthly prisons. The other, the specter of which haunts RYbZ’s final moments, is an eternal prison, constructed and enforced by the divine sovereign.
What does this use of prison-imagery tell us about the cultural assumptions of the authors who composed this scene? How does the use of this incarceration-discourse affect the late antique audience’s understanding of God as portrayed by RYbZ? In this paper, I argue that though Rabbinic authors discuss both gentile and Jewish modes of incarceration, they consistently use different language to describe them. The more common phrase bet ha’assurim and other variants based on the shared root ’-s-r generally refer to gentile prisons, both when describing narratives and when invoked as metaphors (as for example in the expression that “one cannot free oneself from prison [i.e. bet ha’assurim]). By contrast, the Rabbinic place of confinement is called a kippah, and when verbs are applied to Rabbinic/Jewish acts of incarceration, the verb is generally h-v-sh (which, to be clear, also appears in the context of gentile incarcerations), as opposed to the root ’a-s-r.
It is thus significant that RYbZ, when comparing and contrasting earthly and divine incarceration, uses the expression unique to gentile imprisonment (“if he will imprison me [yo’serani], his imprisonment [’issuro] will be…”). Divine incarceration is likened to the form of confinement known from the dominant Roman context, rather than the (constructed or not) Rabbinic mode of incarceration. This paper will consider the ramifications of this rhetoric for our understanding both of Rabbinic views toward gentile imprisonment and of their depiction of divine punishment.
|
The Priority of Being Known by God in Galatians 4:8-9 and the History of Redemption
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Brian S. Rosner, Ridley College
The Priority of Being Known by God in Galatians 4:8-9 and the History of Redemption
|
Skeuos of the Septuaginta: Statistical and Semantic Reflections from the Making of a Reader's Edition
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
William A. Ross, University of Cambridge
This paper presents findings from a multi-year project editing a reader's edition of the Greek Old Testament (or Septuagint), which involved working closely with the text of 1,175 chapters and crafting over 125,000 individual vocabulary glosses. Three areas of research emerging out of this project will be of interest to Septuagint specialists and students Hellenistic Greek. (1) Quantifying the attributes of the Koine represented by each book/translator(s), with implications for further study on translation strategy. (2) Reflecting on the interaction of morphology and semantics, including the complexities of the middle. (3) Glossing the un-glossable, and how semantic development shapes the way we read this body of literature.
|
Woe, Horror, Disaster, or Lament? Revisiting Translations of ouai in Revelation
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Barbara Rossing, Lutheran School of Theology at Chicago
The difficulty of translating the Greek word ouai used in three numbered "woe's" of Revelation and in the exclamations of Babylon's merchants and rulers poses a challenge for ecological hermeneutics. The most common English translation, "woe," can imply God's curse against the earth. "Alas" is the translation used in RSV and NRSV for the three-fold laments in Revelation 18, but not for the earlier references to ouai in regard to Earth or the inhabitants of Earth. The Common English Bible translates "Horror, horror, oh!" (Rev 8:13). The New Jerusalem Bible uses “disaster” in Rev 8:13 and 12:12, but "mourn, mourn" in chapter 18. Micah Kiel notes a thirteenth century Latin manuscript, the Trinity Apocalypse, that portrays the eagle’s announcement in 8:13 as “Alas, alas, alas.” I will argue that it is important to find a consistent translation such as “Alas” for all references to ouai that can convey God's lament over the earth as well as God’s horror at ecological catastrophe.
|
Marcion’s Gospel and the Textual History of Luke
Program Unit: Gospel of Luke
Dieter Roth, Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz
After a period of time in which there was a slight lull in the study of Marcion and Marcion’s Gospel, the new millennium has witnessed a resurgence in scholarly work on this important second century figure and the Gospel he utilized. Several new reconstructions of Marcion’s Gospel have been published in the past few years (e.g., BeDuhn, Klinghardt, Roth) and a variety of monographs related to Marcion have devoted extensive discussion to his Gospel text (e.g., Lieu, Moll, Tyson, Vinzent). Despite widely divergent scholarly opinion on precisely how Marcion’s Gospel and Luke are related, that they are related has been nearly universally recognized in the history of research on Marcion's Gospel. For this reason, one should remain cognizant of the fact that a better understanding of the text of Marcion’s Gospel may provide important insight into the textual history of Luke. At the same time, however, all of these issues are related to the thorny questions surrounding the reconstruction of Marcion’s Gospel. Thus, in this paper the requisite methodological precision for reconstructing Marcion’s Gospel is considered through critical interaction with recent reconstructions of his text in order to then offer a series of preliminary conclusions concerning the place of Marcion’s Gospel when studying the textual history of and creating a textual apparatus for Luke.
|
Where Does the Deity Reside? The Divine Presence in the Temple Scroll
Program Unit: Qumran
David Rothstein, Ariel University Center of Samaria
In contrast to depictions of the divine presence attested in the Hebrew Bible, relatively little attention has been accorded to the Temple Scroll’s (TS) formulation of the divine presence. An influential contribution to this field of inquiry was, however, made by the late Aharon Shemesh. In his study Shemesh posited, inter alia, that the scroll’s author maintained that the nature of the divine presence in the Jerusalem temple differed from that obtaining outside the temple. Specifically, Shemesh argued that the “šēm” and “kābōd” – but not the deity itself – were present in the (spatially defined) temple; by contrast, the scroll’s use of the formulation “I (= the deity) dwell in the people of Israel’s midst” indicates that this the divine (temple) presence was not viewed as emanating outward from the central sanctuary throughout Israel’s land but, rather, was viewed as a distinct abstract presence that resides among the people of Israel, with no regard to their location. Shemesh concluded his investigation by positing that this perception of the extra-temple presence of the deity would have been heartily endorsed by the inhabitants of Qumran, who viewed their community (sic) as a substitute for the defiled Jerusalem temple, i.e., as one wherein the deity resided. The impact of Shemesh’s essay on other investigations of TS notwithstanding, his central thesis is, in point of fact, beset by several substantive flaws; these include forced readings of several passages in TS, as well as a lack of attention to non-pentateuchal sources – most importantly, the book of Ezekiel – that have informed TS’s formulations. The present paper demonstrates that attention to two passages in Ezekiel, along with a proper understanding of deuteronomic and priestly (H) formulations, leads to the ineluctable conclusion that TS’s author did not distinguish between the nature of the divine presence in the central sanctuary and that obtaining beyond the sanctuary's confines. The paper concludes by noting some of the far-reaching implications of this datum for the scroll’s positions on impurity laws.
|
New and Neglected Readings from De sacrificiis and Other Works of Philo
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
James Royse, Claremont, CA
Various sources for the text of Philo have been either inadequately edited or overlooked more or less completely. This paper will report on some discoveries found in various manuscripts. First, the Coptos Papyrus of Philo, which contains De sacrificiis and Quis heres, contains many superior readings that were not reported in the 1893 edition by Scheil and thus are also not found in the Cohn-Wendland edition; some of these will be presented here. Second, there are some fragments from an otherwise unknown work that are found in the Oxyrhynchus Papyrus of Philo; these have been edited, but have been (it seems) almost entirely neglected. Third, from a known work a further reading that seems to be original is also found in the Oxyrhynchus Papyrus, which was erroneously edited at that place. Fourth, a few Greek fragments from De providentia 1, otherwise completely unknown in Greek (even to Eusebius), will be discussed.
|
The Nine Portraits of Patriarch, God, and Sin in Genesis 12, 20, and 26 "Trilogy"
Program Unit: Genesis
Anna Rozonoer, Hellenic College
This paper focuses on the nature of the protagonist in the famous “trilogy, ” the wife-sister stories in Genesis 12, 20, and 26. Whereas the narrative is dealing with variant readings of the same trickster motif – passing off the wife as a sister, -- each story’s nuances draw a picture with its unique theological emphasis and a very different kind of protagonist in every chapter. The Abraham of Genesis 12 is a classical poor trickster; naturally connected to this motif are landing in a strange land, getting rich, disclosure, and the expulsion of the deceiver. Chapter 20 and 26 use the motif, at the meantime radically changing the focus and the plot. There, Abraham and Isaac are heroes of a different type. Abraham of Genesis 20 is the mediator between God and people, able to intercede for Abimelech, as he intercedes for Sodom at a prior occasion. The hero of the third story, Isaac, is a sacred creature who cannot be touched. Abimelech tells the entire nation: “Whoever touches this man or his wife shall be put to death.” (26:11).
Here the prohibition of “touching” is extended to Isaac himself and has a wider meaning. Isaac is the sacred person, a person of taboo. Even to touch him is dangerous! The other main protagonist who is depicted differently in each of the three stories is God. In the first story God “automatically” sends plague on the Egyptians, because the pharaoh in his ignorance had violated the sexual taboo. God is aloof, embodying impersonal law. In the second story, God is involved in personal relationships with people, independent on their ethnic identity; he is caring and just. In the third story, it is the God of Israel Who mostly protects his chosen ones. The third kind of portraiture that is so versatile in this plotline belongs to the notion of sin and is expressed both through the subtleties of fabula and the lexic usage in Hebrew. Sin in the first story is the violation of sexual taboo, and it automatically attracts punishment. In the second story, sin is rated in the moral sense. In the third story, sin again means violating taboo, but the forefather himself is the object of the taboo as a sacred person. This paper attempts to show the diverse and picturesque tapestry of narrative art and theological meanings in the wife-sister “trilogy” of Genesis 12, 20, and 26.
|
Re-keying Shebna and Eliakim: Unlocking the Offense in Isaiah 22:15–25
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Timothy Rucker, The Catholic University of America
Towards the end of Isaiah's "Oracles Against the Nations," YHWH unexpectedly sends Isaiah to deliver a pronouncement of judgment against an individual: Shebna (22:15). YHWH demotes Shebna and promotes Eliakim, but the specifics of Shebna's occupation and offense have proved elusive. Shebna is often understood as being second-in-command to the king, and scholars frequently propose that Shebna controlled access to the king. Similarly, they regard "the key of the house of David" to refer to Shebna's authority to discern who could enter the king's presence. Despite two recent exceptions (Ganzel 2015 and Barber 2013), interpreters rarely recognize-or bother to explicate-the temple echoes that reverberate throughout 22:15-25 and its ancient versions. When these echoes are heard alongside an intertextual reading of Shebna's lack of Isaianic social justice, a new door can be opened for the occasion of this oracle: Shebna failed to enact social justice and to enable the priests to care for the temple.
The lexical parallels between 22:16 and 33:16 provide the cylinder lock plug for recalibrating Shebna's trespass along the grooves of social justice. In 22:16, the singular "on high" and "rock" correspond to the plural "heights" and "rocks" of 33:16; additionally, the nominal form "dwelling" is matched by its verbal form "to dwell" in 33:16. Shebna's has not enacted social justice, but the person of 33:16 has embodied it (33:15). Thus Shebna provides the ideal foil for this righteous person. This person will behold the king in his beauty and see "an expansive land" (33:17), as opposed to Shebna dying in "a land of outstretched hands" (22:18). The eyes of this person will behold the lasting "pegs" of Zion (33:20) instead of the "peg" that will fall (22:22, 25). This person is not reckoned with those who "counted" (22:10; 33:18), and the people's "iniquity" will be forgiven (33:24) instead of the "iniquity being left unatoned (22:14).
Furthermore, the clothing (22:21) and the key (22:22) indicate that Shebna has neglected his duties at the temple. Only priests wear the combination of "sash" and "tunic," and the thrice-utilized root ṣnp (22:18) cleverly evokes the priestly turban (Lev 16:4). In reference to "the key of the house of David" (22:22), Targum Jonathan expounds, "the key of the house of holiness and the dominion of the house of David." This explanatory gloss is fitting within a context that presupposes an inextricable interconnection between the house of YHWH and the house of David (2 Sam 7; 2 Chr 29-31). However, while the twin temple sermons of Jeremiah (Jer 7 and Jer 26) recognize this presupposition, they also elucidate the vanity of temple maintenance without social justice. Isaiah 22:15-25 rightly emphasizes both.
Shebna's crime was this: he failed to utilize his elevated position for the rehabilitation of the temple and the rescuing of the poor. Instead, Shebna legislated his own dwelling of death-effectively locking his keys in the car. Shebna does not belong in presence of YHWH or the king, and he will receive his due recompense.
|
Who Killed Jesus, and Why? The Jewish Nature of Matthew’s Anti-imperial Polemics
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
Anders Runesson, University of Oslo
The death of Jesus has been at the center of Christian anti-Jewish polemics from the Church Fathers onwards, with Matt 27:25 and the fall of Jerusalem employed as strategic theological building blocks. As a result, Rome’s political and military role both in the crucifixion and the sequence of events leading up to it—indeed, the entire Jesus event—has been minimized as history has been theologized and guilt assigned by church authorities. Rome’s representative, Pilate, has even achieved sainthood in some Christian traditions, taking this interpretive trajectory to its extreme. Modern scholarship has noted the problematic nature of such theologies and interpreted the Gospels’ backgrounding of Rome and portrayal of Pilate as a way for Christ-followers to protect themselves against imperial persecution. This, however, creates further problems, not least in light of the idealization of suffering in almost all of the texts authored by members of the movement in its early history. Focusing on the First Gospel, the aim of this paper is to show that reading Matthew as a Jewish text solves the narrative inconsistencies created by traditional Christian readings, as well as undermines the idea that the portrayal of Pilate’s innocence is a strategic Matthean choice to avoid suffering. It will be argued that what seems to be, from a (non-Jewish) Christian triumphalist perspective, God’s vindication of his ‘church’ as the Jewish people is punished for the death of the Christ, is really an expression of an inner-Jewish conflict caused by and responding to the political and socio-economic pressures following from both direct and indirect Roman imperial presence in the land. Far from being an attempt at reducing the risk of suffering for Mattheans at the hands of the empire, this Gospel builds on the theo-ritual realities of second-temple Judaism to construe both Rome and the Jerusalem chief priests as unwitting tools in the hands of the God of Israel as he aims to save the Jewish people from destruction in a drama where another Jewish group, the Pharisees, is identified as the cause behind the unfolding catastrophe.
|
Mismatched Construals of the Holy Spirit: What Are We Missing?
Program Unit: Cognitive Linguistics in Biblical Interpretation
Steven E. Runge, Logos Bible Software
Greek prepositions are one of the many areas of translation where the preferred construal of the NT writer does not match well modern English sensibilities. The preferred method of resolving such mismatches is to posit an alternate sense of the preposition that more closely aligns with the preferred modern English construal. This has resulted in the multiplication of senses in lexica and the blurring of what would seem to be meaningful metaphorical distinctions writers have made based on the selection of one preposition over another. Conference papers presented in 2015 and 2017 applying the spatial model of Vandeloise (2006) traced the extensional use of the container metaphor associated with the Greek prepositions EIS and EN. One interesting mismatch was the preference in Greek to treat supernatural beings as containers, whereby their power to achieve change is construed as a location, domain, or dominion within or through which one worked or from which one drew rather than as a means by which change is achieved (e.g., path or accompaniment as agent). This paper focuses on the metaphorical representation of the Holy Spirit within the New Testament with particular attention given to mismatches in preferred construal. The most common and perhaps most interesting is use of an accompaniment (‘with’) or proximity (‘by’) construal, which construes the being as an agency or means, for what in Greek is construed as containment by (EN) or path through (DIA) the being. Representative examples will be analyzed to demonstrate the exegetical consequences of conflating the Greek construals with preferred English counterparts.
|
Writing Commentaries on Philo’s Allegorical Treatises
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
David Runia, University of Melbourne
In my paper I will reflect on my experiences preparing commentaries for the
Philo of Alexandria series (PACS) on two of Philo’s allegorical treatises, De
agricultura and De plantatione, in each case in collaboration with Dr Albert
Geljon. Writing commentaries is always contextual, so I shall begin with the
purpose of commentaries in PACS. Next I shall look at the particular
requirements for expounding an allegorical treatise. Structure is key, and it is
generally supplied by the citation of the biblical text. I will explain how the
consequences the follow from the determination of the treatise’s structure.
Three further topics will be: (1) how does one determine the purpose of a
particular treatise? (2) where does one stop in explaining details of the text and
argument, including the treatment of parallels from Philo’s own works and other
texts in the Greco-Roman and Jewish traditions? (3) what are the particular
issues relating to the writing of a commentary based on an English translation?
|
Carceral Terror: Slave Catechisms and Their Apocalyptic Precursors
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Erin Runions, Pomona College
tba
|
Daughters in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: African-American Biblical Hermeneutics
Kimberly Dawn Russaw, Claflin University
This paper offers a new analysis of the role of daughters in the narratives of the Hebrew Bible.
|
Preaching the Parables: Results from a National Study
Program Unit: Homiletics and Biblical Studies
Patrick J. Russell, Sacred Heart Seminary and School of Theology
Modern biblical scholarship has stressed that parables are, by their very nature, provocative invitations for the hearer to wrestle with multiple strategies for constructing meaning from open-ended similes, perplexing metaphors, and pithy stories. Unfortunately, quantitative and qualitative data from a recent national study, entitled the Parables Project, indicates that parishioners and homilists tend to reduce each parable to a limited range of connotations or even a single interpretative lesson. This is unfortunate since encountering the multivalent meanings of Jesus’ parables assists in forming an analogical imagination, which is essential for developing an authentic Christian faith that can navigate an increasingly pluralistic world (see David Tracy’s seminal work, The Analogical Imagination: Christian Theology and the Culture of Pluralism, New York: Crossroads, 1981). The analogical imagination involves encountering and embracing the continuity (analogy) and discontinuity (dialectic) between human experience and the divine reality. As C.H. Dodd noted in his classic definition, a parable is “a metaphor or simile drawn from nature or common life, arresting the hearer by its vividness or strangeness, and leaving the mind in sufficient doubt about its precise application to tease it into active thought” (The Parables of the Kingdom , New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1961, p. 5). Parables are thus particularly potent vehicles for engaging the analogical imagination: they are simultaneously commonplace yet surprising, elastic but familiar, comforting and challenging.
Focusing on the parables in the Gospel of Luke, this paper will share the results from the Parables Project, a national study on the preaching strategies employed by preachers that effectively lead congregants to profound encounters with the gospel parables. The Parables Project – funded by a grant jointly awarded in July 2017 by the Confraternity of Christian Doctrine of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, and the Catholic Biblical Association – is a mixed-method study that consists of three parts: a) a comprehensive review of current parable research in order to construct a “taxonomy of meanings” for the parables appearing in the Gospel of Luke, b) a quantitative and qualitative study on the range of meanings employed in the preaching of the Lucan parables, and c) a quantitative and qualitative analysis of the formational impact of preaching on parishioner understanding of the Lucan parables and the development of an analogical imagination. The study’s results are based on a demographically representative and statistically valid sample of Roman Catholic parishioners and clergy throughout the United States. By dissecting how parishioners initially hear the parables and how homilists explain them, the study provides insight on the preaching approaches and particular methods that most productively unpack the parables’ surplus of meanings in a manner that draws out and deepens their relevance to the faith journeys of believers.
|
The Aims of Jesus in Light of Current Research on Early Synagogues
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Jordan J. Ryan, University of Dubuque Theological Seminary
The synagogue was a vital and integral part of Jewish life in the Land of Israel during the late Second-Temple period. So too was it a vital and integral part of the life and mission of Jesus of Nazareth. Synagogues play an important role in the evangelists’ accounts of the ministry of Jesus. In fact, all four of the canonical Gospels identify the synagogue as the primary locus of Jesus’ teaching and proclamation activities during his Galilean ministry (Mark 1:39; Matt 4:23; Luke 4:14-15; John 18:20). This data leads to a crucial historical question: what role did the synagogue play in the aims of Jesus?
In order to answer this question, it is essential to understand early synagogues of the Land in light of recent scholarship and extant evidence, both literary and archaeological. The Gospel narratives strongly indicate that the synagogues that Jesus interacted with were what current scholarship calls public synagogues. Archaeological and textual evidence show that public synagogues were local-official public institutions, comparable to town halls with both religious and political functions. They were the primary gatherings and gathering places for a given town, where decisions were made for the town as a whole. This paper suggests that the public synagogue as an institution was intrinsic rather than incidental to Jesus’ aims during the Galilean ministry, and will seek to explore the question of the role of the synagogue in Jesus’ ministry in conversation with synagogue data and scholarship.
|
Large Predators in Israel: A Material Culture Perspective
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Sanna Saari, University of Helsinki
This paper introduces the large predators of the thickets of the Jordan and the Israeli 'forest', as reflected in the material culture, especially focusing on the iconography of lions, leopards, and bears. It focuses on answering questions like 'were any of those predators known in these regions?' so that we might partially overlap with the previous papers in our session and add a perspective from material culture. Through the use of iconographic sources from Israel within its larger (esp. Levantine) context, we extend our paper and discuss how these predators appear and to what extent these representations show reference to their habitat. The paper addresses the identification of these large predators in iconography and their possible overlap in appearance and interchangeability in representation amongst each other, as well as with other animals, such as dogs. Finally, we make initial steps in exploring the consequences that this information has for broader discussions of exegesis.
|
Do Not Take Baths Outside in the Garden: Alias Grace, the Male Gaze, and Susanna and the Elders
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Peter J. Sabo, University of Alberta
A recurring theme in Margaret Atwood’s literature is the power and omnipresence (but also potential frailty) of the male gaze. For instance, the secret police of Gilead in The Handmaid’s Tale, tellingly named “The Eyes of God,” is made up exclusively of men. It is a great irony, of course, that in a society in which handmaids are to be understood purely as reproductive, not sexualized, objects—and thus supposedly free from the lecherous male gaze—they are still continually “under his eye.” A similarly complex interaction with the male gaze occurs in Alias Grace, the focus of this paper. A painting of Susanna and the Elders that hangs in Thomas Kinnear’s house fascinates Grace, his maid. After hearing the story that lies behind the painting, Grace concludes that its moral is “not [to] take baths outside in the garden,” to which Mr. Kinnear laughs in response. The biblical story (and Mr. Kinnear’s reaction) reveals the broader theme of how Grace cannot escape the male gaze. Indeed, this is paralleled in the reception history of the story of Susanna itself, as in the exclusive focus of paintings to depict the elders’ voyeurism of Susanna bathing. In analyzing the way that Susanna and the Elders and Alias Grace reflect and refract each other, I will pay particular attention to Artemisia Gentileschi’s painting of the biblical story, as well as the restoration of its underpainting by Kathleen Gilje. In its final form, Gentileschi’s work displays a passive Susanna, submissive to the voyeurism of the elders; beneath the surface, lurks a violent Susanna, wielding a knife and ready to strike her attackers. Gilje’s restoration piece, therefore, is a thought-provoking intertext on both Susanna’s and Grace’s role as victim and (potential) avenger, and on the subversive power of female agency in the male gaze.
|
Lot's Daughters and Moabite Women
Program Unit: Genesis
Peter Sabo, University of Alberta
This paper will look at the story of Lot’s daughters as archetypal and paradigmatic Moabite women. David Jobling and Rachel Havrelock (among others) have observed how the Transjordan is coded in female terms (in comparison to the male Cisjordan), and how Moabites are categorized as deviants. Accordingly, it is Moabite women—specifically daughters (who are both foreign and available objects of desire)—who play the most central part in this configuration. In the inverted world of the Transjordan, Moabite daughters play active and powerful roles, while men are passive and vulnerable. I will examine how this occurs not only in the story of Lot and his daughters, but also with the Moabite women in Numbers 25, the daughters of Zelophehad, Jephthah’s daughter, and Ruth. These stories reveal the combination of Israel’s worry over proper claim to (certain) Transjordanian land and its conflicted stance in relation to its close neighbors/others. In examining these stories, moreover, I will pay particular attention to how these anxieties are displayed in the twin tropes of incest and miscegenation.
|
New Testament Exegetes of Alexandrian Tradition over the Interpretation of John 19:34
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Stefano Salemi, Oxford-Centre for Hebrew-Jewish Studies/KCL London
The paper investigates the interpretations of the scene of blood and water flowing from the wounded side of Christ at his Death (John 19:34) in the Gospel of John, within the specific frame of selected early Christian writings of Alexandrian tradition, “canonical” or non-, and how this may have influenced the perception of the soteriological “ground” of the fourth Gospel.
It has sensed to delimit this research to a theological period closer to New Testament composition, as to try to understand the earliest interpretation of John 19:34. I will consider only authors, as early New Testament exegetes, during the first four centuries CE, before the Christological positions of the Council of Nicaea (325) and the Christianization of the Roman Empire. For this case study, the Alexandrian tradition has offered a soteriological interpretation of blood and water in four important texts, extant in two ecclesiastical writers, Clement and Origen, a gnostic Gospel, Pistis Sophia, and the later writings (V cent.) of the Armenian historian Elishe, perfect for a comparison on the perception of Jesus’ death in early “Christian” theology. These testimonies are actually the main soteriological reflections on John 19:34 (seemingly the only ones available) about blood and water imagery in the mentioned period of time and tradition.
The episode, reported only by John, has been generally considered by early writers as well as by modern NT scholars, rich of intentionally “mysterious” meaning and a very emblematic and representative episode of the Death of Christ in John’s Passion narrative. John presents this event in a unique way, stating as the first inner interpretation that of its true purpose is the fulfilment of Scriptures. The Death of Christ is surely a subject which has always been of a great interest, but the scene found in John 19:34 has been often collocated into a marginal position respect to the wider theological understanding of the book. On the opposite, the ancient proof-texting methodology made of allegory, figural reading and a rich engaging of Scriptural references, offers a deep and diversified reflection which places the scene of the pierced side of Jesus into a central theological-Christological position in the Gospel of John.
Analysing the abundant findings, and the numerous theological approaches to John 19:34, one after the other, I would not have done justice to the theological emphasis of each witness. Therefore, I have decided to concentrate my attention only on a specific theological area in a set period of Christian history since I believe, for the sake of clarity, that the chosen cases may be perfect examples (though not exhaustive) of how the early Christian exegesis as well as the non-canonical reflections, could join on a commune ground of hermeneutical methodology, and perhaps sources (to be rediscovered)
|
“Moses Made Arrangements for the Sacrifices That Were Utterly Different from Those of Other Races…” Hecataeus of Abdera’s Portrayal of the Jewish Priesthood in Ptolemaic Egypt
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
Jared W. Saltz, Florida College
Writing ca. 300 BCE in Ptolemaic Egypt, Hecataeus of Abdera is earliest known Greek author to write about the Jews. In his short ethnographic sketch, he describes (in some depth) the bios of the Jews and focused on those “origins and customs” most interesting to a Greek audience whose horizons were rapidly expanding. As K. Trundinger notes, unusual customs such as burial or marriage rites were common in such works, but so were religious laws, the conception of the deity, types of sacrifices, and the requirements for the priesthood (Trudinger, Studien). In fact, two other contemporary idyllic ethnographic-utopian works—Euhemerus of Messene’s Sacred History and Iambulus’ Island of the Sun—include similar themes and foci: Euhemerus describes the human origins of the gods and their priests; Iambulus praises a sun cult; and Hecataeus talks about the Jewish priests of an aniconic deity. But all seek to critique the current political situation and opine their own cult’s role therein. By using these three political critiques of current Greek religion at the beginning of the Hellenistic era and the inception of the ruler cult, we can gain insight into connections between state and cult as seen through the eyes of early (if still elite) resistance literature, and see how the Jewish politeia was marshalled by at least one Greek who wished to censure his own developing religious customs.
|
“He Compelled Those Dwelling in the Land to Rear Their Children”: Hecataeus Abdera and the Context of Ekthesis
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Jared W Saltz, Florida College
In the ancient world where subsistence farming was the norm, children were often considered a liability: a child was one more mouth to feed; worse, it was a mouth to feed whose body could not produce; they even took a worker out of the field to raise them. Because of the harsh realities of ancient agrarian society, children were often exposed and left to die in the elements (ekthesis). In some cultures, such as Sparta, ekthesis was practiced on those children considered inferior. And yet, behind all of this pragmatism, there was a yearning for something more; something better. When Hecataeus, writing at the turn of the 3rd century BCE, wrote the earliest description of the Jews by a Greek, he lauded “the commandment of Moses” which prohibited ekthesis, and saw this legal precedent as the reason that their land was flourishing. By choosing to include this information in an otherwise idyllic portrayal of the Jewish polity, he intoned to his own audience that—maybe, just maybe—if they treated their children as resources rather than liabilities they might themselves flourish as did the Jews (or the Egyptians). In this paper, I will explore various perceptions of and reactions to the raising of children in the Greek and Roman Age, and compare how Hecataeus’ description of the Jews fits into that larger narrative while paying special attention to the effect that Hecataeus wished to achieve by his critique.
|
Linguistic Dating of the Book of Qohelet: A New Direction
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Nili Samet, Bar-Ilan University
The problem of Qohelet’s (Ecclesiastes’) language and date has been treated at length during the last two centuries. Numerous studies of almost every aspect of Qohelet’s language have yielded the following firmly-based conclusions: 1. Qohelet’s language is late; 2. consequently, the book should be dated to post-exilic times; 3. the book’s author spoke Aramaic. This historical framing enables either a Persian or a Hellenistic dating for the book. The difference between these two possibilities is crucial. Each of these periods suggests a totally different cultural and social context, which in turn bears on our understanding of the book as a whole and on the interpretation of specific passages. However, scholars consider it methodologically impossible to use linguistic tools for distinguishing between Persian and Hellenistic dating. Accordingly, there is currently no scholarly consensus regarding this highly important exegetical problem. The current paper seeks to suggest a new direction which may shed light on this problem from a linguistic angle. My paper will attempt to trace the specific Aramaic dialect spoken by the book’s author. I shall examine four test-cases of Aramaic calques found in the book, attempting to identify the specific Aramaic dialect which gave rise to them, and accordingly to locate Qohelet within a more specific historical framework.
|
Mapping the Musabbiḥāt: Genre Boundaries and Sūra Structure
Program Unit: The Qur’an: Surah Studies (IQSA)
Karim Samji, Gettysburg College
On the surface, the praise formulae that open the musabbiḥāt might reasonably be thought to provide a final and definitive judgment as to their genre classification in the Qurʾān. On the one hand, the presence of liturgical elements leaves no doubt that this cluster of sūras preserves multiple hymnic pericopae (Q. 57:1–6; Q. 59:1, 22–24; Q. 59:2–4; Q. 62:1–4; Q. 64:1–4, 13), not to mention a doxology (Q. 61:1). Take, for instance, the complex structure of Sūrat al-Ḥashr. The formula of liturgical praise (sabbaḥa li-) in verse 1 begins a hymn to God. Assuming, for the moment, that sūras as extended compositions are not without rhyme or reason, the hymn evidently resumes in verses 22–24 (Bell 1991). Whereas the cohesion of this hymnic fragment is structural, that of the intervening verse pair is patterned on end-rhyme (-āC). In this hymn to victory (vv. 2–4), the liturgical formula (huwa lladhī: ‘He, who…’) features relative predication. On the other hand, the liturgy genre alone cannot account for the sūra structure of Q. 59 in its entirety, let alone the musabbiḥāt as a whole. Put simply, there are as many genres in the group as there are sūras. For example, Q. 59:18–21 (-ūC) closes the sūra with a sermon, belonging to the wisdom genre. Accordingly, the vocative formula reads: yā-ayyuhā lladhīna āmanū (‘O you who believe!’). In fact, the exact same formula also concludes Sūrat al-Ḥadīd (Q. 57:28–29), Sūrat aṣ-Ṣaff (Q. 61:14), Sūrat al-Jumuʿa (Q. 62:9–11), and Sūrat at-Taghābun (Q. 64:14–18). In the first three sūras (Q. 57, 59, 61), this formula introduces the simple sermon form, while in the remaining units (Q. 62, 64), it doubles as a proclamation formula introducing regulatory forms. Moreover, Q. 64:14–18 represents a complex sermon, which overlaps with and incorporates multiple genres, including that of proclamation. The same might even hold true for Q. 62:9–11. Based on this premise, form criticism offers a first glimpse into the framework of the musabbiḥāt. Although the structural similarities seem to end here, the historian of religion is tempted to see in this traditional group of sūras ‘a live transcript’ of a typical communal service (cf. Sinai and Neuwirth 2011), which opens on a liturgical note and closes with words of wisdom.
|
Shifts in the Usage of the Hebrew Verbal Stems
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Harald Samuel, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
At the 1999 SBL Annual Meeting, E. Jenni (“Aktionsarten und Stammformen im Althebräischen”) presented his refined understanding of the piʽel stem. Based on Z. Vendler’s four classes of situation aspect, he was able to describe subtle semantic differences in the seemingly equal usages of different stems of the same root. What is missing in his treatment, however, is a diachronic perspective on possible shifts in the verbal system. At the same meeting, S. Fassberg (“The Movement from Qal to Piʽʽel in Hebrew”) presented a synopsis of examples from different stages of the Hebrew language—inter alia Qumran, the Samaritan reading tradition, and Amoraic Hebrew—that had been used to argue for a relatively widespread shift from the qal to the piʽel stem. Fassberg related this shift to the disappearance of the qal internal passive and also proposed a general time frame for it. From a different perspective—i.e., the morphological distinction between active and middle voice still productive in a few verbs—J. Joosten (“Actif et moyen en sémitique”) offered a more general perspective on shifts between the Hebrew verbal stems in terms of historical linguistics, whereas F.W. Dobbs-Allsopp (“Biblical Hebrew Statives and Situation Aspect”) demonstrated the permeability between the classes of situation aspect and thus highlighted the necessity of considering the semantic shifts of individual verbs. Discussing further examples that may be hidden behind the Tiberian vocalization of the Hebrew Bible, my paper calls for a more comprehensive catalogue of roots possibly affected by the aforementioned shift(s). If, however, traces of such shifts are detectable already in the consonantal text of the Hebrew Bible, several methodological problems arise. It is therefore necessary to combine the respective strengths of the different named approaches and to include comparative Semitics to reach a more holistic, even if inevitably fuzzy, picture of the phenomenon.
|
The Beginning of the End of Jewish Christianity
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
J. Gunnar Samuelsson, University of Gothenburg
Ancient Christianity rests upon a bed of uncertainty. There are significant gaps in the historical narrative of how the Jewish sect transformed into a global religion. From the first thirty years, there are pieces of information from Luke and Paul, but many questions are left without comprehensive answers. One of these is the religion’s transformation from its Jewish cradle to its anti-Jewish dress during the age of Constantine. Anti-Jewish sentiments could be seen already in the decades following the fall of Jerusalem, which are assumed to be connected to one another. This catastrophic event combined with Jewish prosecution of the first Christians, described in Acts, and harsh New Testament texts, such as Matt. 27.25 and 1 Thess. 2:14ff, could be seen as the sparks that kindled a destructive fire. In this paper, I will argue for an additional cause which is connected the elusive brother of Jesus, James the Just. The beginning of the end of the Jewish primacy of the Christian faith might have occurred before the destruction of Jerusalem, or in an event that Eusebius implies being connected to it (2 Euseb. 23.20), the lynching of James. Could the silence in the New Testament regarding the fall of Jerusalem and the death of and James, as well as the subsequent deaths of Peter and Paul, reflect a process that became the causa mortis of Jewish Christianity as well as being the means by which the anti-Jewish stance of the later church got its momentum? I will suggest an answer to the question how and why the church turned against its own roots and managed to use the biblical texts throughout its history against the very people the biblical texts are all about – the Jews.
|
Daniel: Against Biblical Interpretation
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Seth Sanders, University of California-Davis
*
|
Cognition of Time in Process-Based Worldview and Aspect Theory of Hebrew Language
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Jun Sato, University of Toronto
What is time? Since the beginning of modern times, time has often been considered according to a linear conception, in which narratives of progress and evolution (e.g., past, present, and future) are a priori supposed to exist. However, this concept of linear time is a product of the Western Enlightenment and philosophy; it does not necessarily follow that all human beings have such a linear concept of time. In fact, the reconsideration of time has been suggested from various perspectives in the past century, including philosophy, anthropology, history, psychology, cognitive science, and theoretical physics. In short, time can be interpreted not only linearly, but also cyclically or spirally, and not only temporally, but also as embodied and spatial cognition. Furthermore, time is not absolute, objective, concrete, and real, but rather relative, subjective, abstract, and refined. Some biblical scholars have also reexamined the concept of time as it applies to ancient Israelite religion and Judaism. An important, but forgotten work is Stern’s Time and Process in Ancient Judaism (2003). Based on an anthropological approach, he concludes that ancient Judaism had a process-based worldview without the concrete concept of time. In light of these discussions, this paper reexamines the concept of time in the ancient Hebrew language, contributing to an issue that has been debated in Hebrew studies since the nineteenth century. Biblical Hebrew (BH) has long been considered a tense-prominent language, whose verbs mainly express past, present, and future. This tradition could be at least traced to Gesenius in 1813 and still serves as a standard grammars for BH. Against the traditional view, aspect theories have been sporadically introduced, from Ewald in 1870 and Driver in 1892 to Cook in 2012. This paper assesses their theoretical understandings of time respectively and argues 1) the traditional tense-prominent approaches often uncritically adopt the concept of linear time as an a priori premise in their theories and 2) the aspect theories (e.g., Cook 2012) better fit with the ancient process-based worldview. As a trial cut, some biblical and Qumran passages (e.g., Isaiah 8:23–9:6, 11Q19 29:2–10) are further discussed with close attention to speakers’/narrators’ cognition of time.
|
A Paragon of Faith? The Use of Abraham in Hebrews
Program Unit: Hebrews
Katrina Schaafsma, Duke University Divinity School
This paper considers the manner and rhetorical ends of the portrayal of Abraham in Hebrews. The investigation emerges from two observations regarding how the work’s depiction contrasts with the casting of Abraham in Pauline literature and in examples of rewritten bible.
For the New Testament writers, Genesis 15:6 is a natural place to turn when considering Abraham’s faith: “He trusted the LORD, and he reckoned (λογίζομαι/חשׁב) it to him as righteousness.” However, the grammar of the phrase is ambiguous in both Hebrew MT and Greek LXX; it is unclear precisely who is reckoning on whom. Paul is unequivocal when he deploys λογίζομαι in both Romans 4:3 and Galatians 3:6 in pursuit of his argument that, since God reckoned Abraham righteous because of faith, God will also reckon future believers righteous on the basis of faith. Yet when Hebrews 11:19 draws on the same verb, it exploits the grammatical ambiguity in the opposite direction. Here Abraham, not God, does the reckoning. Abraham considers God and comes to the conclusion that God is reliable (as Sarah similarly concludes, v. 11). In a chapter that is often interpreted as an exhortation to pursue faithfulness like Abraham’s, Hebrews counterintuitively places the accent on the trustworthiness of God.
Similarly, while it may seem obvious that Hebrews depicts Abraham as a paragon of faith, his eulogization in Hebrews appears rather thin when compared with his portrayal in so-called rewritten bible. Philo and Josephus, for example, develop and enhance Genesis material to present Abraham as a model of virtue. But if Abraham is meant to function similarly in Hebrews, the homilist is most unresourceful, missing key opportunities to lift up Abraham’s virtue and consistently sidelining this lead character in his own stories. Instead of recounting Genesis 22 in heightened, agonizing detail, Hebrews 6:13-20 mobilizes an account others treat as Abraham’s crowning moment to make a point that is not even about him. The eclipsing of Abraham in his own story is even starker in Hebrews 7:1-10, where the minor character Melchizedek becomes the major focus instead of Abraham (the true hero of the story, according to the renderings of Genesis 14, Philo, and Josephus).
Hebrews resists the tendency, prominent in other canonical and extra-canonical portrayals, to cast Abraham as a paragon of faith. Instead, it depicts Abraham primarily as the paradigmatic recipient of God’s promises, a designation that the audience of Hebrews now shares. With this established, I show how the Abraham narratives are used to shape realistic expectations regarding the lives of those who, like Abraham, receive the promises. I conclude with the homily’s invitation for its audience to ‘consider’ something greater than the reliability of any model of human faith: the reliability of the God who made the promises.
|
Leviticus 17 in Relation to Genesis 9 and Deuteronomy 12: Ritual, Texts, Theologies
Program Unit: Book of Deuteronomy
Joachim Schaper, University of Aberdeen
The relationship between Lev. 17:10-12, Gen. 9:4-7 and Deut. 12:20-25 is at the centre of the investigation. The present paper explores that relationship with a view to the concepts of nefeš expressed in the respective texts. In doing so, it attempts to throw new light on the theologies implied in the texts and the significance of the ritual aspect of Leviticus 17:10-12. Interesting aspects of the literary history of the Pentateuch which are often overlooked will thus come to the fore. This will in turn raise questions with regard to some of the assumptions in Pentateuchal theory.
|
The Deuteronomistic Corpus: Increasing Evidence and Open Questions
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Aaron Schart, Universität Duisburg-Essen
James Nogalski was the first scholar who proposed, in his ground-breaking two-volumes dissertation from 1993, the hypothesis of a "Deuteronomistic Corpus", comprising former versions of Hosea, Amos, Micah, and Zephanaiah as parts of one book, written on a single scroll.
25 years later, this reconstructed precursor to the Book of the Twelve Prophets is the best accepted part of his view of the redaction history of the Twelve. The strongest argument for the existence of the "Deuteronomistic Corpus" is the consistent system of the superscriptions (Hosea 1:1, Amos 1:1, Micah 1:1, and Zephaniah 1:1) that unites the four writings Hosea, Amos, Micah, and Zephaniah into one book. The goal of this book was to demonstrate to later readers that YHWH rightly allowed the Assyrians destroy the Northern kingdom and, in a second move, the Babylonians to conquer Jerusalem, because Israel, Judah, and Jerusalem have sinned in multiple ways against YHWH. Although this hypothesis is profoundly and widely accepted, its details are still disputed (e.g. Schart, Wöhrle, Levin).
The paper seeks to address some of the questions that are still under discussion: What is the precise extent of the text of the Deuteronomistic Corpus? What is its exact position within the sequence of redactional layers of the Twelve? How is the message of the Deuteronomistic Corpus altered when it is perceived within the framework of the canonical version of the Book of the Twelve. Each question is addressed by analyzing a short key passage.
|
The Space-Time-Torah Continuum: Boundaries of Natural and Biblical Law in Leviticus Rabbah
Program Unit: Midrash
Nicholas J. Schaser, Macalester College
Leviticus 26 begins with a series of blessings for the Israelites, provided that they “walk in [God’s] statutes” and fulfill the commands of the Torah (Lev 26:3). Leviticus Rabbah juxtaposes the statutes of the Mosaic covenant with the covenant(s) that God makes with time and space. Specifically, the rabbis equate the “statutes” of Lev 26:3 with “the statutes by which [God] established heaven and earth” (Lev. R. 35:4), and they cite Jeremiah to show that the latter covenant is both temporal and spatial: “If I have not established my covenant with day and night; if I have not appointed the statues of heaven and earth” (Jer 33:25). The midrash goes on to specify aspects of the natural order and associate them with biblical Law: the fact that God established a covenant with the “sun and the moon” (Jer 31:35) and “set the sand as the boundary of the sea” (Jer 5:22) shows that the Sinaitic statutes are just as eternal and unchanging as nature. In fact, the midrash claims, the statutes that God gave at Sinai are the very statutes ordained at creation, “when [God] set the statute for the sea” (Prov 8:29). On the one hand, this collapsing of biblical and natural law nuances Christine Hayes’s conclusion that “the rabbis do not attempt to square Mosaic Law with… natural law… [or] depict Mosaic Law in natural terms” (2015: 328). In the case of Lev. R. 35:4, the Mosaic Law is divine insofar as it “expresses the profound structures of a permanent natural order” (Brague: 2007, 18). On the other hand, the rabbinic intertexts that present Mosaic Law in natural terms come from biblical contexts that either predict or recall Israel’s failure to uphold the Torah (cf. Lev 26:14-39; Jer 5:23; 31:32). Thus the divinely inviolable covenants with nature intermingle with a Mosaic covenant that Israel is able to violate, so that God’s ability to uphold the laws of nature ensures the continuation of the Torah—regardless of Israel’s occasional inability to fulfill it. Moreover, because each of the intertexts belongs to promises about the prosperity and restoration of the Land of Israel (cf. Lev 26:3-5; Jer 31:23; 33:11-13), the rabbis argue implicitly that God’s enduring contract with the natural order guarantees the ongoing wellbeing of the Land—even a Land without a Temple and under Gentile control in Late Antiquity. Through midrashic exposition of natural law vis-à-vis biblical Law, Leviticus Rabbah presents the Land as—to use Jonathan Z. Smith’s formulation— “an ideal construction, unconstrained by the pragmatics of architecture or the accidentalities of history” (1987: 49). By explicating the spatial, temporal, and geographical boundaries that God establishes in nature, the rabbis show that the borders of the Land remain secure—theologically, if not politically. Therefore, the midrash provides a covenantal framework within which the rabbis can locate late antique Jews as the commandment-keeping people of God. According to Leviticus Rabbah, Israel lives within a space-time-Torah continuum that defines and sustains Jewish identity.
|
Catholic Identity in a Hostile Vandal Context: Insights from the Notitia Provinciarum
Program Unit: Contextualizing North African Christianity
Christoph Scheerer, University of Vienna
As a register of dioceses and bishops in Vandal Africa, the Notitia Provinciarum is, at first glance, not a source of information regarding African identities. But in the light of its specific historical context, as it can be reconstructed from Victor of Vitas Historia Persecutionum, it is possible to draw some conclusions. Different views and decisions of the African Catholic Church in regard to Vandal rule as well as to its relationship to Catholic ecumenical Christianity become evident. In spite of its common confession of faith as documented in the Liber Fidei Catholicae, this reveals a plurality of self-conceptions in the African Catholic Church. It can be assumed that this plurality is caused by different experiences under Vandal rule, varying especially between the province of Proconsularis and the other provinces.
|
Positive Psychology, Children, and Luke's Gospel
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Eben Scheffler, UNISA
Positive psychology emphasizes concepts like hope, acceptance, development, prevention and promotion(cf e g Roberts et al) which are very relevant for children, their growth and their positive experience of life. Luke's Gospel has a unique focus on children and the paper explores (1) how positive psychology can contribute to a better understanding of Luke's emphasis on children and (2) and how Luke's emphasis on children can contribute to a better understanding of positive psychology.
|
The (Tree of) Knowledge of Good and Evil - is it Good or Evil? Tracing the Motif through its Early Reception History
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Annette Schellenberg, Universität Wien
In Gen 2-3, the tree of knowledge of good and evil plays a crucial role, bringing about the transition from the primeval beginnings to the reality “out of Eden.” Scholars do not agree how the motif is to be interpreted within Genesis 2-3: some argue that humans’ ability to discern between good and evil is seen negatively in the Paradise story, others counter that it is seen positively. Similarly, in the text’s early reception history, the motif is interpreted differently. This paper aims at presenting an overview on the most important texts of this early reception history (Sirach, 1Enoch, Jubilee, 3 Bar, sapiential texts from Qumran, etc.) and how they utilize the motif within their own argumentations.
|
Paul and Other Autarchic Prisoners
Program Unit: The Historical Paul
Ryan S. Schellenberg, Methodist Theological School in Ohio
At least since Bultmann, Paul’s claim in Phil 4:11 that he has learned to be autarkēs whatever his circumstances has been understood in light of philosophical discourses of autarkeia—specifically, the notion of the wise man as sufficient unto himself and thus independent of external circumstances. But a survey of usage of the term contemporary with Paul casts doubt on this interpretive paradigm. Although they certainly emphasize the sage’s independence from his circumstances, those moral philosophers with whom Paul is most frequently compared (Epictetus, Musonius Rufus, also Dio Chrysostom) do not employ the terms autarkēs or autarkeia to do so. In fact, they do not use these terms at all. When Roman-era Stoics do speak of autarkeia, it denotes just what it means also in non-technical usage—namely, satisfaction with whatever is at hand. In this paper, I seek to understand Paul’s claim by broadening the comparative scope: first, by locating autarkeia within a complex of moral values that were widely shared throughout the Greek and Roman world; and, second, by comparing Paul’s claim to be autarkēs with similar claims by modern prisoners who likewise assert their indifference to external circumstances. Exploring the various attractions a posture of satisfaction holds for other prisoners will, I suggest, help us articulate what it does for Paul.
|
Textual Traditions of the Book of Deuteronomy in the Hodayot
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Lawrence Schiffman, New York University
This paper will analyze allusions to passages and expressions drawn from the book of Deuteronomy to determine the nature of the text or texts of Deuteronomy used by the authors of the various Hodayot (Thanksgiving Hymns). Careful methods will be used to separate adaptations and/or egegeses of Scriptural material from quotations or usages that allow reconstruction of the author’s Vorlage. Further, the study will be basd on all of the Hodayot manuscripts. The Deuteronomic material culled from the Hodayot will be carefully compared with extant textual witnesses, including ancient biblical manuscripts and translations as well as other Dead Sea Scrolls non-biblical texts that are dependent on Deuteronomy. Conclusions will be drawn regarding the contribution of the Hodayot to the textual criticism of Deuteronomy.
|
Scrolls, Testament, and Talmud: Issues of Anti-Semitism in the Study of Ancient Judaism
Program Unit:
Lawrence Schiffman, New York University
The study of ancient Judaism raises numerous issues regarding anti-Semitism such as: Greco-Roman anti-Semitism, early Jewish Christian relations, antagonism to the Jews in Babylonia, and early anti-Semitic literature. What has been lacking in research is a meta-analysis that seeks to show how anti-Semitism has affected study and research on ancient Jewish religion and history as a whole. Aspects of this problem include the effects of anti-Semitism on descriptive terms for Judaism in antiquity and late antiquity; approaches to periodization within the larger ancient framework; construal of Jews and Judaism in light of New Testament images and later anti-Jewish material in the church fathers; effects of the Reformation and Protestantism on views of the Jews and Judaism; and more recently, the questioning of the basic geographical and historical facts of ancient Jewish history as a result of modern Middle Eastern issues. This paper will attempt to address this problem in its various often subtle manifestations. Finally, we will propose approaches for correcting for these biases in teaching, research and publication.
|
“Fear the Lord and the King!” Prov 16:10-15 and Achaemenid Royal Ideology
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Bernd U. Schipper, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin - Humboldt University of Berlin
The reference to a king in the Book of Proverbs has often been taken as an argument for dating the so-called “Solomonic Wisdom” to the pre-exilic period of Ancient Israel. Scholars have argued that references to a king imply that a kingdom existed in Ancient Israel and Judah during the text’s composition.
This paper presents a new approach to the passages on the king in Prov 10:1–22:16 with special focus on Prov 16. In light of Achaemenid texts such as the Bisitun-inscription and other royal inscriptions of Darius I, it will be demonstrated that passages such as Prov 14:35; 19:12 and 16:10–15 derive from Persian Period royal ideology. The text can be compared to some passages from the wisdom of Ahiqar, which was used for the education of scribes at Elephantine, along with the Aramaic version of the Bisitun-inscription found in Egypt with the text of Ahiqar.
|
James D. Nogalski and the Elusive “Zurich School”
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Konrad Schmid, University of Zurich
This paper considers James D. Nogalski's work on the Book of the Twelve during the late 1980s and early 1990s, which he conducted in Zurich in connection with the redaction-critical scholarship of his Doktorvater Odil Hannes Steck. On the one hand, Nogalski was influenced by Steck but, on the other, Steck was also influenced by Nogalski as Steck continued to research the Prophetic books. There never was a "Zurich school" in studies of the prophets. Rather, mutual influences between different scholars in Zurich helped create a comprehensive presentation of the Prophetic corpus's literary origins.
|
Nadav Na’aman and Albrecht Alt: A Comparison
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Konrad Schmid, Universität Zürich
Nadav Na'aman's collected essays were published as three volumes in 2005. Fifty-two years earlier, Albrecht Alt's essays were also published as three volumes. Each of these scholars changed the field of the history of ancient Israel, both masterfully using interdisciplinary approaches and furthering the scholarly discussion through the genre of the article. This talk will investigate how and why both Alt and Na'aman altered their academic field when they did.
|
Embodying Wisdom: Ben Sira's Praise of Simon the High Priest (Sir 50:1-24)
Program Unit: Deuterocanonical and Cognate Literature
A. Jordan Schmidt, Catholic University of America
As several scholars have noted, Ben Sira's praise of the high priest Simon (Sir 50:1-24), which concludes the section of his book known as the “Praise of the Ancestors” (Sirach 44—50), draws from several previous contexts in his book of instruction, including “the Hymn to Creation” (42:15-43:33), the praise of Aaron (45:6-22), and the self-praise of Lady Wisdom (24:1-33). Though many have commented on the way in which Ben Sira’s praise of Simon focuses on his beauty and the visual experience of God’s glory in the cultic liturgy, less attention has been given to the sapiential claims that Ben Sira makes regarding Simon’s cultic action. This paper will examine the manner in which Ben Sira combines the vocabulary of God’s “glory” (e.g., kabôd, hedar, tipêret, hôd) as it is found in “the Hymn to Creation” and his praise of Aaron with arboreal imagery that is found in the self-praise of Lady Wisdom. This study will illumine how Ben Sira combines language from these various contexts not only in order to underscore Simon’s magnificent appearance in the cultic liturgy but also for the purpose of presenting Simon as a perfect embodiment of wisdom, despite the fact that Ben Sira does not present Simon as having studied or acquired a facility with written wisdom.
|
The Testimonium Flavianum in Light of Jewish and Greco-Roman Reports about Jesus
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
T.C. Schmidt, Yale University
This paper examines the common objections made to the authenticity of Josephus’s ‘Testimonium Flavianum’ (TF) in light of other statements about Jesus from Jewish and Greco-Roman sources. Such objections frequently point out that Josephus suspiciously attributes miraculous deeds to Jesus, that he calls him the “Christ,” and that he describes Jesus as being resurrected, all of which are believed to be unlikely for a non-Christian to say. This paper argues however that similar claims about Jesus are frequently made by other Jewish and Greco-Roman sources, many of which are quite willing to admit that Jesus performed miraculous deeds (Celsus and his ‘Jew,’ Porphyry, the Tosefta, Hierocles, etc.). Many also have no qualms with giving Jesus the name “Christ,” though they do not actually believe that he was the Christ (Suetonius, Pliny, Tacitus, and Porphyry). Though no other non-Christian source states that Jesus was resurrected, the paper introduces new linguistic evidence that helps us to reinterpret Josephus’s apparent affirmation of Jesus’s resurrection as a report, not a statement of fact. Based on these and other arguments this paper suggests that scholars should not be overly skeptical about the TF, but should rather interpret it as an ambiguous or neutral statement about Jesus. The paper concludes by highlighting how such a neutral or ambiguous reading of the TF helps to explain why early Christian writers (Eusebius, Jerome and perhaps Origen) do not seize on the supposedly incredible claims of the TF — for they likely did not understand the TF as a confessional statement about Jesus, but rather as a report about him in line with what other non-Christian were saying at the time.
|
Negotiating the Boundaries of "Identity": Benjamin at the Yahweh Festival of Shiloh
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Jonathan Schmidt-Swartz, New York University
This paper seeks to analyze the second Benjamin wife-provision account, found in Judges 21:15–24, which introduces a connection between Benjamin and Shiloh, as a window onto the complex and sometimes contradictory Benjaminite "identity" dynamics at play in the finished biblical text. In this text, Benjamin may have at once entangled its own ancestral "identity" with Yahweh's sacred center at Shiloh while it upheld its difference as an independent 'ereṣ ("land") separate from Shiloh. More than any other biblical text, this one would genealogically link all Benjaminites to the Shiloh region — every Benjaminite would have been envisioned as having a Shiloh-regional ancestry on the basis of this text. Because the text stages Benjamin's ancestral link to Shiloh at the annual Yahweh festival, it likewise may imagine Yahweh at the center of the kinship ties between the Shilonites or festival-goers and the Benjaminites. Whereas the Israelites call the Benjaminites their "brothers" in chapter 20 (as examined in Dustin Nash's 2015 Cornell dissertation), the Shiloh episode at the end of chapter 21 represents a different conceptual means to relate Benjamin to worshippers of Yahweh. Namely, it frames the relationship between Benjamin and Shiloh in kinship terms with the word šēbeṭ ("tribe") — socially and genealogically linking the distinct peoples — making an association with Yahweh a potential commonality. Unity between the distinct people of Benjamin and the sacred site of Shiloh is asserted through providing Yahweh-worshipping wives for the Benjaminites. Thus, the Shiloh wife-provision narrative at the end of chapter 21 transitions Benjamin from its status as a politically-allied foreign "Other," as depicted in the war narrative, to a distinct group that is socially linked to Shiloh through its kinship-based connection to Yahweh-worshippers. This analysis leads in turn to the potential historical settings reflected in Judges 20 and 21 and their implications for other attestations of Benjaminite "identity" in the broader biblical tradition. The present paper intends to problematize "identity" as a heuristic category in ancient history and biblical studies (Brubaker and Cooper, "Beyond Identity," 2000) and to offer new perspectives on the potential socio-historical settings that underlie and inform the composition, redaction, and reception of this material while addressing the methodological and theoretical problems inherent in any scholarly work that intersects the Bible and history. This paper treats Judges 21:15–24 as a case study for applying an "histoire croisée" theoretical approach (Zimmerman and Werner, "Beyond Comparison," 2006) to scholarly intercrossings of the Bible and history as a means at once to problematize and to strengthen the complex integration between Bible and history.
|
Bathsheba and a Theology of Suffering
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
Mary K. Schmitt, Trevecca Nazarene University
Although many readings of 2 Samuel 11-12 focus on David, shifting attention to Bathsheba sheds light on how victims of sexual assault and sexual misconduct can contribute to a theology of suffering. Bathsheba is often deemed a silent pawn in the stories of men who manipulate her (e.g. David, Nathan, and Solomon; see Sakenfeld for analysis and critique). However, focusing on Bathsheba’s story reveals interesting parallels between her role as sufferer and Jesus in the Passion narratives. For example, Bathsheba wails for her dead husband Uriah (2 Sam 11:26), which parallels Jesus’ s sorrow in the garden (e.g. Matt 26:38/par). She is sent for and taken to a political leader who decides her fate, much as Jesus was. In both instances, the question of rightful kingship lies in the background. Bathsheba bore a son (2 Sam 11:26); Jesus bore his cross (John 19:17, but not in the Synoptic Gospels). Not only does Bathsheba suffer because of someone else’s sin, but her son dies because of David’s sin (2 Sam 12:14). Moreover, after that death, she brings forth a new life – Solomon, whom God calls Jedidah because he is a sign of the restoration of God’s love (2 Sam 12:24-25). Above all, her silence throughout the narrative is comparable to Jesus’ silence during the events of the Passion. All of these points resonate with elements of the Passion narratives in the Gospels. The comparison of Bathsheba’s story to Jesus’ Passion highlights certain aspects of the Passion narrative that are often downplayed or explained away. For example, Jesus’ sorrow is often treated as something needing to be explained. Since he chooses to suffer, how can he really be sorrowful? The sorrow often becomes nothing more than a spectacle; it is assumed that Jesus cannot really be sorrowful. However, Bathsheba’s story causes us to reconsider the place of sorrow in a theology of suffering. Or, Jesus not bearing the cross in the Synoptic Gospels must be contrasted with the stories of Bathsheba and other sexual assault victims who have no option but to bear the effects of what has been done to them (in her case, she bears a son [2 Sam 11:26]). Her story raises questions about the purported element of “choice” in a theology of suffering. Thus, it is not only that a theology of suffering that begins with Jesus’ Passion can shed light on Bathsheba’s story, but also that Bathsheba’s story sheds light on the Passion narratives themselves. Moreover, Bathsheba’s story represents the story of many women and men who have endured sexual assault and abuse. She represents countless others who have experienced sorrow, who have born the effects of others’ sexual sins, and who have been silenced by those in power. Her story, now told by interpreters (see Exum), invites us to consider their stories and what those who have experienced sexual violence can teach us about suffering.
|
Judiths Prayers (Jdt 13:7.9) in the Greek and Latin Version
Program Unit: Deuterocanonical and Cognate Literature
Barbara Schmitz, Julius-Maximilians-Universität Würzburg
In the Book of Judith, speeches and prayers are of great importance. Beside the six long speeches and prayers in the chapter 2, 5, 8, 9, 11, and 16, there are also other short prayers. Two of them are placed at the most crucial situation, the killing scene of Holofernes (Jdt 13). Judith prays twice (Jdt 13:7.9) before cutting off Holofernes’ neck with his own sword.
The paper will explore the placement, content, and function of these two prayers within the storyline of the LXX-version of the Book of Judith. Then, they will be compared to the same prayers in the very different Vulgate-Version of the Book of Judith in order to ask for the content and the function of the two prayers within the Latin Version.
The differences will not only shed light on the text history of the Judith-narrative, but will also point out the different theological concepts of both versions.
|
Exodus Rabbah and the Aggadic Response to Biblical Law: The Ten Commandments and the Covenant Code
Program Unit: Midrash
Jonathan Schofer, University of Texas at Austin
This paper responds to and extends the call that we analyze more fully the historical changes in the forms of expression of midrashic literature over time. Rachel Anisfeld has emphasized the need for “a literary history of rabbinic literature or of rabbinic midrash” to undo a “generalized notion of rabbinic midrash” and to address “temporal differentiation” as well as geographic. Anisfeld’s study of Pesikta deRav Kahana addresses homiletic midrash in the Amoraic period. Anisfeld draws attention to the development in Amoraic rabbinic materials of the “petihta or proem,” and she has argued that midrashic anthologies from the Amoraic period and onward reveal a life-setting and context that is in part the intensive knowledge of the disciple-circle and school, and in part practical ritual knowledge as well as a focus on preaching and a ritual calendar (Anisfeld 2009; also the more recent study, Weiss 2017). This paper examines a much later stage in midrashic literature in the late Exodus Rabbah and its presentation of the importance of the Ten Commandments (Exodus 20 and Deuteronomy 5) and the Covenant Code (Exodus 21-23). The paper makes three arguments. First, the homiletic midrash of Exodus Rabbah presents compilations that educate readers in difficult parts of the Bible that address relevant themes of legal cases and divine commands. Homiletic midrash in general shows that any given themes at hand are addressed throughout the rabbis’ scripture, but also in concrete ways, the late Exodus Rabbah shows that a concern with law and society runs through the Psalms and Prophets, and leadership from Moses to Daniel and Esther. The audience listening to or reading an exposition of known verses in the Pentateuch learns of relevant material in the Aramaic of the Book of Daniel, or in variants on the accounts of David told in the Books of Chronicles and not only the Deuteronomic History. Second, Exodus Rabbah reinforces the importance of prayer and liturgy by highlighting David as the writer of Psalms, and also links between the Ten Commandments and the Shema. Exodus Rabbah does not discuss the synagogue specifically but rather draws the audience’s attention to a triad of scripture, law, and liturgy, which sets out a cultural connection for enduring time without sovereignty and in larger empires. Third, for this specific topic, Exodus Rabbah strongly links condemnations of idolatry and heresy, on one hand, with the call that Israel observe both the specifics of decisions for legal cases named in the Covenant Code, and the direct commandments of the Decalogue. Exodus Rabbah juxtaposes accounts of God’s destruction of idolatrous empires, and God’s call for Israel to observe laws and decisions in legal cases, to emphasize Israel’s self-definition as accepting upon itself those laws and decisions. Israel is separated from the heretics and the idolatrous peoples, and favored by God rather than condemned, because of observance of law in its specificity.
|
Sodom and Gomorrah in the Art of Yehuda Levy-Aldema
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Susanne Scholz, Southern Methodist University
The Israeli artist, Yehuda Levy-Aldema (b. 1957), created a series of modern sculpture art on Genesis 14-19. The more than thirty pieces, produced since 2015 and still growing in numbers, are based on a close reading of the biblical text in conversation with traditional Jewish sources, such as Bereishit Rabbah and Rashi, and on conversations with people gathered in what Levy-Aldema calls “visual beth midrashim.” This paper introduces the artist, offers some background information on his work and its stated goals, and analyzes one piece of the series, entitled “Teku.” The piece focuses on Gen. 19:32 and its visual interpretation encourages intriguing (feminist) exegetical insights into the biblical text. Levy-Aldema’s work offers artistically innovative and exegetically provocative visual ways of reading the tales about Sodom and Gomorrah together with his sculpture art that recognizes the Bible as relevant in the “here and now.”
|
Hermeneutic of Reproduction: Sociological Tools for Understanding Biblical Infertility
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
David A. Schones, Southern Methodist University
Biblical scholarship on the “annunciation” type-scene rarely engages sociological approaches to infertility. My essay proposes that an interdisciplinary method which incorporates this sociological research, which I term a “hermeneutic of reproduction,” produces a more complex description of the concept of infertility in biblical texts in three interrelated ways. First, it incorporates methods used by sociological, psychological, anthropological, and social scientific scholars to complexify the social construction of involuntary childlessness in biblical literature. Second, these sociological tools also elaborate on the social, economic, and theological stigmatization surrounding this reproductive disability. Finally, the interaction between disability and feminist scholars in the social sciences on this topic reflect the need for interdisciplinary work among disability and gender scholars in biblical studies.
This essay incorporates the feminist and disability sociological scholarship on involuntary childlessness to a biblical hermeneutic of reproduction. First, I outline the scholarly interpretation history of infertility studies in the humanities. This section suggests that the formation of an interdisciplinary feminist-disability framework in the social sciences can inform biblical scholarship on this topic. Second, the essay explores how the felt/enacted stigmatization model advocated by disability scholars complexifies the presentation of infertility in biblical texts and contexts. This tool identifies multiple variations of the stigmatization surrounding involuntary childlessness and stresses that class and social status alter how infertility is perceived as a disability. Finally, I highlight the recent work of feminist-disability scholars who incorporate the social-location of infertile women in their analyses of female reproduction. Their work complicates a purely negative assessment of motherhood and encourages collaboration between feminist and disability scholars on the subject of involuntary childlessness.
The interdisciplinary hermeneutic of reproduction demonstrates that sociological research on involuntary childlessness can foster a closer relationship between feminist, gender studies, and disability scholars in the field of biblical studies. This method elaborates on the variations in the social construction of infertility as a disability. Finally, this approach enables biblical exegesis to better address the contextual issues surrounding fertility and involuntary childlessness.
|
The First Altar in the Promissed Land According to the Textual History of the Book of Joshua
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Stefan Schorch, Martin-Luther-Universität Halle-Wittenberg
According to the Masoretic text of Jos 8:30–35, referring to Deut 27–28, Joshua built an altar on Mount Ebal, inscribed a copy of Mose’s teachings on stones, and renewed the covenant. As opposed to the Masoretic text, however, the Septuagint and 4QJosa contain the altar account in other contexts – the former after Jos 9:2, the latter before Jos 5:2. This diverse and difficult textual evidence has been the subject of several important studies, but a consens in regard to the textual history which would explain the different contexts in which this passage appears in the textual witnesses does not seem to have been emerged so far: While Eugen Ulrich came to the conclusion that 4QJosa preserves the oldest version, Emanuel Tov demonstrated that the textual embedding of the altar account in 4QJosa contains secondary exegetical features, Kristin de Troyer attributed primacy to the Old Greek, and Michael van der Meer to the MT.
Building on observations made by these scholars and an own fresh analysis of the evidence, the present study demonstrates first of all that the micro textual history of this altar passage is not entirely coherent with the general textual history leading to the emergence of the different textual witnesses, but is at least partly the result of an independent development, pertaining only to this passage. In the framework of this micro textual history of the altar passage, a linear literary dependancy is visible between the main textual witnesses, with 4QJosa being dependant on the Vorlage of the LXX, and the latter dependent on proto-MT.
|
“Rabbouni,” Which Means Lord: Narrative Variants in John 20:16
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Elizabeth Schrader, Duke University
This paper is a close examination of several fascinating textual variants found in the oldest manuscripts of John 20:16. Although modern Bibles state that Mary Magdalene recognized Jesus as her “teacher”, in some crucial ancient witnesses, Mary’s Aramaic word “Rabbouni” is alternatively translated as “Lord” (or sometimes as both “teacher” and “Lord”). Furthermore, in many manuscripts Mary additionally runs to touch Jesus – a widely-attested reading, which some ancient commentators interpreted to mean that Mary Magdalene touched the risen Jesus in John’s Gospel. These “narrative variants” in John 20:16 reveal a rich history of textual interpretation, as well as fascinating attempts by editors and scribes to solve debates and questions about this important passage in their day. After a survey of manuscript evidence, Aramaic scholarship, and the verse's Johannine context, this paper makes the text-critical argument that in the initial text of John 20:16 "Rabbouni" was correctly translated into Greek as kyrie ("Lord"). However, at an early stage of the text transmission this word kyrie was deliberately replaced by the word didaskale ("teacher"), brought over from the parallel passage at John 1:38. This substitution would explain the node of textual instability we find in the earliest manuscripts of this verse. Citations from Augustine and Jerome also demonstrate that prominent church fathers knew both textual variants, but favored the "teacher" reading when making rhetorical arguments that Mary Magdalene was weak in both faith and understanding, especially when compared to the male apostles. This paper thus suggests that an editorial substitution of didaskale for kyrie at John 20:16 took place at a very early stage of the text transmission, and that the reading "'Rabbouni', which means Lord" should be considered as retaining the initial text of John 20:16b.
|
Monastic Manipulations
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
Caroline Schroeder, University of the Pacific
This paper will examine case studies of early Christian male monastic leaders who seek to assert authority over women monks in their communities, and will explore how they use emotional rhetoric to manage potential threats to their authority and reputation from these women. This authority they seek to wield takes a couple of different forms: power and social control over the women in a particular physical place (the monastery), or an attempt to influence the woman’s ascetic discipline and reputation to meet the man’s ideation regarding ideal ascetic womanhood. In each case, an accusation of physical abuse has been made against the male monastic leader. In each case, the male authority figure uses emotional rhetoric to manipulate and shame, to preserve his position of authority. The case studies involve Jerome and his student/patron Paula and the Egyptian monastic leaders Shenoute and Besa along with the women of the White Monastery (including a named Egyptian monk identified as Aphthonia). In the case of Besa and Jerome, gender means that Aphthonia, Paula, and Paula’s daughters hold a lower social status than the two men. The economic privilege of the women, however, means that Aphthonia and Paula hold leverage over the men and may even pose a threat to them. The intersectionality of gender and economic class destabilizes the gender hierarchies, which these male leaders attempt to reassert by emotionally manipulating and shaming the women.
|
The Labor of Children in Early Egyptian Monasteries
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Caroline Schroeder, University of the Pacific
This paper will examine the experiences of children as laborers within early Christian monasteries in late antique Egypt as well as the representation of the labor of caring for children in these communities. Through the lens of labor, we can understand the liminal status of children in early Egyptian monasticism. Children themselves labored in the monastery. In some cases, rules governed their physical labor in order to protect them from exploitation or assigned a specific ritual task especially for them. In others, children were perceived to be a laborious burden to the adult monastics tasked with their care. They required food, education, supervision, discipline, and attention. Such labor was framed as an impediment to the ascetic discipline of the adult monk, and in at least one community (the Pachomian monastic federation), was assigned only to monks particularly advanced in asceticism. The fruits of this labor could be great, however; some monastic texts promoted the view that monks who began their journey as children were destined to be the greatest monks. Children in monasteries were both protected and exploited, a treasure and a burden, a source of manual labor and a cause for undesired labor. This paper will examine child labor and labor for children in the late antique monastic federations of Pachomius and Shenoute, as well as the monastery of Phoibammon in Thebes.
|
Reflections from the Translator and Editor of "The Bible in the Medieval Tradition" and Author of "Deborah's Daughters"
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Joy Schroeder, Trinity Lutheran Seminary and Capitol University
Reflections from the Translator and Editor of "The Bible in the Medieval Tradition: The Book of Genesis" and ""The Bible in the Medieval Tradition: The Book of Jeremiah" (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 2015, 2017); Author of "Deborah's Daughters: Gender Politics and Biblical Interpretation" (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014).
|
The Assertiveness of Achsah: Gender and Intertextuality in the Reception History of Caleb's Daughter
Program Unit: Joshua-Judges
Joy A. Schroeder, Capital University
Through the centuries, numerous Jewish and Christian biblical interpreters engaged in something akin to what we now call “intertextuality.” This paper explores the preoccupations of selected ancient, medieval, early modern, and nineteenth-century commentators who interpreted the story of Caleb’s daughter Achsah, who was given in marriage to her kinsman Othniel to reward a military victory (Joshua 15:13-19, Judges 1:11-15). Late antique and medieval interpreters debated the ethics of the consanguineous marriage, and they used Jephthah’s vow (Judges 11:29-40) as a lens through which to explore the morality of honoring a questionable pre-battle promise. Variant readings allowed for differing assessments of Achsah’s initiative in making a direct request to her father, asking for springs of water (or, in some interpretations, watered land), in addition to the arid field Caleb had already granted. In the Masoretic text, Achsah took the initiative, asking her husband to request a field from Caleb and then taking it upon herself to ask her father for access to springs. The Septuagint and Vulgate say her husband prompted her to make the request. Interpreters using these Greek and Latin translations generally approved of her obedience to her husband, while many who followed the Hebrew text criticized her initiative as self-serving. Numerous Christian interpreters spiritualized Achsah’s assertiveness, making her a model of the soul at prayer, rewarded by a Heavenly Father, just like the child who confidently asks and receives good things from a loving parent (Matthew 7:11). Achsah was also viewed through the lens of the Samaritan woman at the well, receiving springs of spiritual “living water.” Beginning in the seventeenth century, some interpreters read Achsah’s story with reference to the daughters of Zelophehad (Numbers 27:1-11), exploring issues of women’s property rights, with implications for women of their own day. In an 1851 Bible story book, Thomas Gaspey testily employed Achsah’s example to censure greedy, acquisitive daughters of his day. Four decades later, in Part II of The Woman’s Bible (1898), suffragist Elizabeth Cady Stanton, referencing Zelophehad’s daughters, used Achsah as a positive model for women of her own day to demand social, civil, and political rights: “How are men to know what we want unless we tell them?” Clara Neyman, another contributor to The Woman’s Bible, praised Achsah’s initiative as a trait found in sensible women who must provide for their families, since her husband, like most heroic warriors who “generally lack the practical virtues,” would have been satisfied with the arid southern field. Thus, in reception history, we see a range of perspectives regarding the assertiveness of Achsah, most of them reinforcing gender norms by downplaying, criticizing, or spiritualizing her initiative, while a handful of early feminist authors regarded Achsah’s example as worthy of emulation by the women of their day.
|
The Canon of the New Testament: Some Observations concerning Its Origin and Meaning
Program Unit: Development of Early Christian Theology
Jens Schroeter, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin - Humboldt University of Berlin
Against the background of recent discussion about the origin of the New Testament in this paper it will be asked which evidence we have for the accessibility and usage of certain writings in early Christ groups. In particular, it will be looked at the distinction between writings which later became "canonical" and those which were rejected and regarded as "apocryphal". Since such a clear-cut distinction appears not before the 4th century, it is important to ask what early Christians read and whether they already thought in the categories of "authoritative" and "rejected" writings. In particular, this paper will look at the early Gospel tradition asking for the relationship between the "Four Gospels" and the many other gospels circulating in early Christian communities.
|
Reaping the Fruits of Torah: 4 Ezra’s Alternative to Violence Against Rome
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Lucas L. Schulte, University of Nebraska - Lincoln
This paper proposes that the book of 4 Ezra advocates for hope in Torah’s fruition in the world to come as an alternative to placing hopes in insurrection against Rome. Previous studies have observed that 4 Ezra encourages political quietism for its audience while they hope in the world to come. Complementing this perspective, this paper argues that the book’s paradigm shift from an understanding of Torah in conflict with the tragic experiences of this world to hope in Torah’s fruition in the world to come likewise promotes a perspective of consolation, patience, and commemoration instead of revolt. First, this paper will examine how 4 Ezra promotes the perspective that individuals—not nations—are judged as righteous or wicked, thereby dissuading hopes in a national reconstitution of Israel against Rome. Second, this paper will demonstrate how the book purports that Torah’s efficacy will be in the world to come, not in this present world; the audience must wait for the eschaton to reap the fruits of righteousness. Finally, this paper suggests that the choice of the character of Ezra as the protagonist of such a message hearkens to the biblical Ezra as an example for how to interact with a foreign occupying empire.
|
Not a Dead End: The Isaianic “Highway” Theme in Diachronic and Synchronic Perspectives
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Richard Schultz, Wheaton College (Illinois)
The “eschatological highway” texts (e.g., 11:16; 19:23; 35:8; 40:3; 42:16; 43:19; 49:11; 57:14; 62:10) within the book of Isaiah offer a helpful case study for the relationship between diachronic and synchronic approaches. On the one hand, their placement suggests compositional/redactional design. Accordingly, Steck (Bereitete Heimkehr) claimed that some of them were late additions to the book that served to link its major subsections. Zimmerli and others argued further that in Third Isaiah the highway imagery has been drained of its vividness or spiritualized, unlike its occurrences in Second Isaiah. On the other hand, their strategic placement at the beginning, mid-point, or end of subsections serves to emphasize the theme’s importance. Accordingly, the detailed description of the “Holy Way” in Isa 35:8–10 anticipates the repeated references to the highway in the remainder of the book, even though Isa 35 is usually considered to be later than these chapters. (For example, in the verbal parallel between 35:10 and 51:11, the former is viewed as dependent on the latter.) Initially focusing on the function of the highway theme in Isa 35, this paper will illustrate how diachronic approaches serve to highlight the diverse uses of the highway motif in Isaiah to denote both physical and spiritual returns with both divergent points of origin and destinations. It will conclude, however, by demonstrating that holistic/structural approaches highlight the anticipated divine involvement in the journey—and the resultant requirements of those who will travel these highways—and indicate that the “way” motif is more pervasive in the book of Isaiah than usually noted.
|
“They Will Not Hurt or Destroy on All My Holy Mountain” (Isaiah 11:9 and 65:25): Problematic Utopian Promises in the Vision of the Future Jerusalem in Isaiah 65:17–25?
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Richard Schultz, Wheaton College (Illinois)
Isaiah 65:17–25, although offering what is arguably the best-known description of future hope in the book of Isaiah, if not within the entire prophetic corpus, resists a facile ascription of the “utopian” label. Set within the context of the coming creation of a new heaven and a new earth, it nevertheless focuses on the situation of “my people” in a newly-created Jerusalem (vv. 18–19) and highlights features of the city both mundane (houses, vineyards, childbirths, vv. 21–23) and imperfect (sin and the curse of death, v. 20; cf. the dust-eating serpent, v 25). Theologically, this text displays a unique combination of a return to paradisiacal conditions and the effects of the termination of the covenant curses (cf. its intertextual connections to Gen 1–3, Lev 26, and Deut 28). Nevertheless, this is not a utopia for all, since those who “forget [God’s] holy mountain…will fall in the slaughter” (Isa 65:11–12); the promises apply only to God’s “servants” who are contrasted repeatedly with the evil-doing “you” (plural; vv 12–15). Nor does this utopian vision serves as the “happy ending” of the book of Isaiah, which concludes instead with an excursion to view “the dead bodies of those who rebelled” against God (Isa 66:24). Also intriguing is its intratextual link to the more expansive description of “animal harmony” in Isaiah 11:6–9, which directly follows the depiction of the reign of the future Davidic ruler (vv. 1–5; cf. v. 10). This raises the question of whether the prophetic author of Isaiah 65 is offering an alternative vision of eschatological hope in which a Davidic ruler no longer plays a role. This paper will discuss and assess several options for understanding the vision of the future in Isaiah 65:17–25 in light of its placement and function within the book of Isaiah and will conclude by briefly tracing its reception history as a utopian text.
|
How to Draft a "Hybrid Document"? The Aramaic Legal Tradition at Elephantine (5th Century BC) Reconsidered
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Alexander Schütze, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
The Judean military colony at Elephantine is well documented by hundreds of Aramaic papyri and ostraca as well as the archeological record of a part of its quarter. For more than a century, research has been focusing on the religious life of this colony although most of the papyri belong to the legal sphere being contracts on a variety of transactions like sales, loans, donations and so on. A closer look on these legal documents indicates that Aramaic scribes, drafting legal documents for members of the Judean settlement at Elephantine, heavily adopted clauses from an Egyptian legal tradition. They thus provide indirect evidence for a supposed compilation of Egyptian laws under Dareios I including a translation into Aramaic: This compilation probably comprised model forms for every legal transaction, which may have been taken over by Aramaic scribes at Elephantine. The Aramaic legal documents, however, were not mere copies of Egyptian contracts but combined legal formulae of both Aramaic and Egyptian legal traditions. In this paper, I will discuss to what extend the scribes of Elephantine adopted Egyptian legal formulae by comparing different types of legal transactions. I shall also highlight the legal background within the multicultural society of Persian Period Egypt in order to understand the reasons for the production of these ‘hybrid documents’.
|
“Flee Porneia”: Rethinking Paul’s Sexual Politics in the Age of #BlackLivesMatter and #MeToo
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
Tyler M. Schwaller, Wesleyan College (Macon, GA)
As Jennifer Glancy has incisively observed, the sexual politics elaborated in 1 Corinthians 5–7 were a problem for slaves, who could be and frequently were exploited sexually by their masters, including forced prostitution. This paper addresses the tension between inclusion of slaves in the body of Christ and exclusion of any sexual relations outside marriage by considering how the enslaved may have responded to Paul’s teaching. In the midst of fevered rhetoric condemning prostitution and elevating individual sexual(ized) behavior to a matter of communal concern, Paul inquires rhetorically whether he should “take the members of Christ and make them members of a prostitute,” ultimately admonishing readers to “shun fornication (porneia)” (1 Cor 6:15, 18, NRSV). What of the slave pimped out by the master? Is s/he always already shunned from the Christian body? Alternatively, might someone who was enslaved have recognized sexual exploitation as a form of abuse from which s/he could rightly flee? This paper reads Paul’s injunction to shun, or more literally from the Greek, to flee porneia alongside evidence of slaves actually fleeing circumstances of extreme abuse. Interpreting the text in light of such enslaved resistance contributes to constructing an alternative interpretive history, one that resists the legacies of slavery and misogyny with which Pauline sexual politics have been entangled from the beginning. This is made ever more urgent by contemporary movements that variously call out and address racialized and sexualized forms of violence, such as #BlackLivesMatter and #MeToo. Hence, this paper underscores repetitive sexualized logics that leave certain bodies vulnerable, while also taking seriously capacities, both ancient and modern, to condemn and resist sexual exploitation and abuse.
|
Geography, Location, and the Redaction of the Pentateuch
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Baruch J. Schwartz, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
The plot lines of the Pentateuchal sources, while similar enough to be woven together on a chronological continuum, do not always dovetail precisely with one another. One area in which they often differ is that of location: one of the narrative threads situates the characters at a specific place at the same moment in the story that one of the other threads situates the same characters elsewhere. The compiler of the Torah employed a variety of strategies for dealing with these editorial conundrums. Often, he simply allowed the discrepancies to stand, adhering to his overall policy of preserving the documents unaltered. In at least some of these cases, he may have been intimating that no contradiction is present and that a single locale is designated by two different toponyms; in others, the exact manner of splicing together geographically incompatible narratives succeeded in obscuring the problem from view. Occasionally, he found it possible to make minor, virtually imperceptible adjustments of a harmonistic nature in order to obliterate the geographical difficulty. In a few instances, he even found it necessary to re-arrange the sequence of events in one of the documents in order for the progression of the characters from one location to the next to be consistent with that described in the others. These techniques, and the reasons for their use, have for the most part been ignored by critics. The examination of a number of examples may bring into sharper focus the Pentateuchal compiler’s well-known conservatism in the preservation of the sources against the background of some of the circumstances in which he was willing, or compelled, to diverge from it.
|
Mosaic Reverberations and Mosaic Reversals in Isaiah 1–12
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Ethan Schwartz, Harvard University
In its present form, Isaiah 1-12 is widely recognized as a distinct literary unit, giving way in chapter 13 to a demonstrably new section consisting of pronouncements against the nations. In this paper, I explore this unit’s significant thematic, lexical, and structural affinities with four key Mosaic texts: Moses’ first prophetic commission (Exod. 3-4), the Song at the Sea (Exod. 15), the Sinaitic revelation (Exod. 19-20), and the Song of Moses (Deut. 32). These texts span Moses’ prophetic career; they represent, respectively, its inception, two of its climactic moments, and its conclusion. Isaiah 1-12 preserves the basic arc of Moses’ career, but inverts it: Isaiah opens with his own song (Is. 1) and closes with a new Song at the Sea (Is. 12), with a combined commission/revelation standing in the middle. The inversion clearly plays into the explicit presentation of the ingathering as a new exodus (Is. 11:11). However, I argue that it is yet more subtle and consequential than that, for the inversion also activates both Mosaic songs’ eschatological potential––explicitly recognized at Qumran and in later Jewish literature but detected and mobilized here as well. By beginning, rather than ending, with the “time to come [literally, ‘end of days’]” (Deut. 31:29) when everything has gone so terribly wrong, the exodus is transformed from the high point of an ideal past to the eschatological culmination of an ideal future. The song by which Israel joyously recognizes that “Yah (the LORD) is my strength and might, and He has been my deliverance” (Exod. 15:2; Is. 12:2) becomes the last word of Israel’s history. Moreover, the cosmic overtones of the Song at the Sea, stretching back to the older West Semitic combat myths, are brought to the fore. The new exodus is not just a time when Israel will be free of an oppressive yoke but when wolves will dwell with lambs (Is. 11:6). I bring the literary and theological effects of this reversal into conversation with redaction-critical approaches to Isaiah 1-12, exploring the possibility that these chapters have been shaped in light of the pronounced exodus typology in Deutero-Isaiah. In this way, I present Isaiah’s first twelve chapters as a potentially fruitful site for coordination of synchronic and diachronic approaches to the book.
|
Horses, Worms, and Ants: The Power of Solomon in the Qur’an and Biblical Literatures
Program Unit: The Qur’an and Late Antiquity (IQSA)
Sarah L. Schwarz, Princeton University
An understanding of Solomon the wise and powerful king is shared among readers of the Hebrew Bible, New Testament, and Qur’an, and his legend grew in myriad complex ways over the centuries. In the Islamic material we see evidence of a web of influence and intertextuality. Early scholarly interpreters of this thread of tradition tended to explain what they found with a unidirectional arrow drawn from earliest Israelite traditions through to rabbinic Judaism, a line branching off toward what becomes Christianity, and Islam as the last part of the timeline. More recent scholarship has shown that there never was an arrow, and that even though Islam might be the latest religion of the three to develop historically, authoritative interpretation often originated with Muslim communities and was transmitted into Jewish and Christian ones. Even when interpretive threads predate Islam, far from a unidirectional arrow, we instead see interlaced webs of conversation. It is particularly interesting and challenging to trace these webs, however, since often these echoed conversations leave a flavor or a suggestion of contact, rather than a smoking gun. Seemingly small details like an association of Solomon with horses might yield a vast series of horse and rider amulets in one context (as, for example, in the vast corpora published by Bonner), and a difficult textual tradition about Solomon possibly killing horses in another (Q 38:30). Even a worm might be more than just a worm, as the Babylonian Talmud tells us of a worm used by Solomon to miraculously cut stones for the Temple, and Q 34:14 tells us that the jinn recognized Solomon’s death when a worm gnawed his staff. Finally, in extracanonical stories such as the Testament of Solomon, we read of Solomon engaging in the sacrifice or crushing of insects—locusts—a very different story with perhaps similar themes to Surah 27, in which ants are particularly cautioned to take shelter, lest Solomon and his armies crush them. Following Shari Lowin, I argue that “Islam and Judaism purposely and purposefully manipulated and adjusted the texts of the other in order to emphasize their own unique religious values. In so doing, the traditions provided their adherents with material for religious self-perception and for defining themselves as entities distinct and separate from one another, despite their almost identical biological and spiritual heritage.” Using comparative material from biblical and qur’anic traditions and from related “magical” materials such as amulets and spell collections, this paper will examine the ways the biblical and qur’anic interpreters told stories of Solomon’s power and how they transformed it in conversation with each other.
|
Bell and Bourdieu in Corinth
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Jonathan Schwiebert, Lenoir-Rhyne University
Ritual is often treated as a uniquely religious phenomenon. One of the advantages of Catherine Bell’s perspective is that her work challenges this reduction in the scope of what ritual analysis can explore. In this paper I will test out Bell’s concept of ‘ritual practice’ in Paul’s Corinthian correspondence (especially 1 Corinthians 1-4), focusing almost exclusively on non-‘religious’ materials there. To broaden Bell’s perspective, and to offer some critiques, I will also bring into the discussion Pierre Bourdieu’s theory of practice, a major source for Bell’s own thinking on practice. Using both theorists, I hope to illuminate some of the less obvious ritual dimensions of Paul’s interactions with the Corinthians, and their interactions with one another.
|
In the Beginning is the End: A Comparison of the Jesus Seminar and John Meier’s Marginal Jew
Program Unit:
Bernard Brandon Scott, Phillips Theological Seminary
In this lecture, Bernard Brandon Scott will ask how it is possible to end up with two very different views of the historical Jesus. He will compare Meier’s methods and starting point to those of the Jesus Seminar and offer insights into the outcomes.
John Meier conducted his own version of the Jesus Seminar. Scott notes that Meier started with Jesus as an apocalyptic prophet and ended with the parables, which he then had largely to dismiss. In Meier’s view, only a small number of parables turned out to be authentic. In contrast, the Jesus Seminar started with the parables—a distinctive difference in methodology—and found most of them to be authentic. The Seminar ended with a non-apocalyptic Jesus. Investigating these differences reveals the influence of methodology, the testing of assumptions, and the judgements of critical historical study.
|
Building Re-usable Tools for Digital Humanities Research: Lessons from Developing the Grammateus Editor
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
Ian W. Scott, Tyndale University College and Seminary (Ontario)
The great promise of digital texts is often frustrated by two closely related obstacles: a) the high degree of technical facility needed to produce and use such texts, and b) the high cost of developing software tools to edit and manipulate them. That first obstacle to involvement can only be overcome by software that simplifies the user’s experience. The obstacle of development cost can be reduced by a healthy ecosystem of open source components. Although many tools already exist, most are difficult to integrate into new projects. Some are only installable or usable by those who already have significant technical facility. Others are tightly coupled to a large framework which, as a whole, may not meet the needs of many projects. Still others are only usable for a short time because they go unmaintained. Earlier versions of the Grammateus Editor suffered from these common shortcomings. With version 3.0, being built for use in the *Online Critical Pseudepigrapha*, we aim to offer a set of components which are standards-compliant, modular, maintainable, easily deployable, and readily usable by content specialists who are not necessarily computer specialists. We hope that individual components will be re-used in other projects. Even more valuable, though, are the APIs we are developing in consultation with others working on similar tools. These are the publicly documented "connectors" through which various software components can communicate, even when they have been developed by different teams. We hope that these APIs might be adoptable by a broad base of digital humanists, moving us toward a set of standard APIs analogous to the TEI standards for markup.
|
Puns in the Enochic Dream Visions in Their Ancient Near Eastern Context
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
James M. Scott, Trinity Western University
The dream visions of 1 Enoch contain a number of puns (also known as “paronomasia” or “wordplay”), that is, words that sound alike but have different derivations. No systematic study of the puns of 1 Enoch has previously been undertaken. Instead, they are usually treated in isolation as instances of rhetorical flourish or amusing ornamentation. However, recent work on dream visions in the ancient Near East paints a very different picture of the nature and purpose of puns, which are often deployed in the context of mantic wisdom. My paper aims to show that attention to punning in this broader ancient Near Eastern context opens up important new insights into the interpretation of the apocalyptic dream visions of 1 Enoch. The paper will focus on the Animal Apocalypse as a salient case in point.
|
Sensations of War: A Rhetorical Reading of 1QM
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Joshua Scott, University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
The victory of Sons of Light over the Sons of Darkness described in the War Scroll (1QM) has captured the attention of researchers. Column I introduces the seven-stage battle and its participants, columns II-IX describe in great detail inscriptions on banners and trumpets, and military movements, and columns X-XIV contain a collection of liturgical material. In his now classic treatment, Jean Duhaime suggests these desperate parts of the manuscript are united in theme and procedure akin to a Roman military manual, while parallel texts from Cave 4 represent a different recession. More recently, Brian Schultz proposes that the columns i and ii represent two stages of the same war, and the remaining portion of the manuscript supports this division. These respective approaches to 1QM emphasize the eschatological battle over the liturgical portion of the manuscript, and so either dismiss the liturgical portion in its entirety or fail to sufficiently place it in relation with the other portions. If the manuscripts from Cave 1 are as prized to the community as Devorah Dimant suggests, then it is unlikely that 1QM was half-hazardly redacted and we have not fully appreciated how the portions of the text function together.
This paper proposes that the varied sections of the War Scroll are united through their aesthetic character by immersing the reader in the sensing of war. The text rhetorically invites participants to see and experience victory by describing in stark detail God's power. For instance, "when there is war in your land against the enemy who oppresses you, you shall blow the trumpets and you shall be remembered before your God, and you shall be saved from your enemies" (X, 7; cf. Num 10:9). Faith is recalled and strengthened through real or imagined sound. Through the mutual touch of God's hand and the hand of 'David, your servant,' the readers of the text can feel triumph. God's warrior, then, is military leader and audible, tangible prophetic pronouncement of victory. This reading suggests that this eschatological vision was not simply hoped for, but actively experienced through senses of the participants.
|
"Can You Hear Me Now?...Good!" A Deaf Adder and the Threat to the Righteous in Psalm 58:5–6
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Kevin Scott, Baylor University
Since the 2004 creation of the “Biblical Scholarship and Disabilities” unit by the Society of Biblical Literature, scholars have begun to read biblical texts with questions concerning disability in mind. Despite the increase in studies on literary images of disability in the Hebrew Bible since 2004, there remains a distinct lack of studies on disability in the Psalter. Most of these studies focus on the depiction of disability in Pss 38; 94; and 115, though many clear references to disability occur elsewhere throughout the Psalter. This presentation aims to supplement previous discussion with an examination of disability in Ps 58.
In this presentation, I will examine the role disability plays in Ps 58, which utilizes images associated with deafness to describe those who oppose the psalmist’s community. The text compares the venom of wicked people with “the deaf adder that causes its ear to shut, so that it does not hear the voice of the charmers or the wise spell casters” (Ps 58:5–6). I will demonstrate that the text’s use of deaf imagery is unique in two ways. First, the text describes an adder who disables itself, which contrasts with other literary images of disability, where Yahweh or another figure does the disabling. In addition, the adder’s disability is associated with strength, which contrasts with most depictions of disability as a weakness that must be healed. The psalmist utilizes this literary image of disability to describe a powerful threat to the community.
Within the presentation, I will first define the model and approach to disability I will use throughout the analysis of Ps 58. Next, I will examine literary depictions of deafness in the Hebrew Bible, with a focus on how disability is presented elsewhere in the Psalter. Then I will provide an analysis of the disability imagery present in Ps 58 and some concluding thoughts.
|
The Schubert Ogden Notebooks Project
Program Unit: Westar Institute
Andrew D. Scrimgeour, Drew University
*
|
Josephus’s Retelling of the Patriarchs’ Polygyny in a Greco-Roman Context
Program Unit: Jewish Interpretation of the Bible
Joshua M Sears, Brigham Young University
Several studies have analyzed Josephus’s retellings of biblical stories in Jewish Antiquities to determine how and for what purpose Josephus changes different aspects of those stories. One area that has not received adequate attention is how Josephus responds to the polygynous marriages of the patriarchs Abraham and Jacob. Josephus adds to, deletes, and modifies various parts of Genesis’s presentation of patriarchal polygyny, and his changes reveal discernable patterns. I argue that Josephus has modified the biblical portrayal in three ways that make the patriarchs’ families more understandable and acceptable to Greek and Roman audiences.
First, Greco-Roman law only recognized monogamous marriages and their societies considered plural marriages barbaric; in contrast, in the ancient Near East polygynous marriages were accepted both legally and socially. While maintaining the essential plot points from Genesis, Josephus downplays the extent of the patriarchs’ polygyny by dropping all references to Hagar, Keturah, Bilhah, and Zilpah as “wives” and by clarifying (just in case) that Abraham did not marry Keturah until after Sarah’s death. Josephus also makes the polygynous relationships more palatable by skipping uncomfortable details, making the plural families more harmonious and loving, and claiming that God himself approved of the patriarchs’ unique relationships.
Second, Greco-Roman norms accepted, without social stigma or legal penalty, that a free man could engage in extra-marital sexual relations with his female slaves; however, because slaves could not be legally married, a man would not be able to take a slave as a wife. In contrast, ancient Near Eastern custom generally allowed slaves to be married, and Genesis presents Hagar, Bilhah, and Zilpah simultaneously as slaves to their mistresses and wives to their husbands. Josephus turns these Semitic plural wives into acceptable Greco-Roman sex partners: he downplays their marital status by deleting all references to them as “wives” and emphasizes their slave status in relation to their mistresses.
Third, Greco-Roman law held that the children born to female slaves are illegitimate and inherit the slave status of their mothers, in contrast to the ancient Near East where it was widely assumed that children born to a free man could be his heirs even if their mother was a slave. Josephus vacillates with respect to the children of Bilhah and Zilpah (perhaps because they are among Israel’s tribal ancestors) but he acknowledges Greco-Roman standards by admitting that they are not as legitimate as Jacob’s children through his free wives Rachel and Leah.
|
The Poetics of Defending Sacred Space: Cultivating Empathy in Flavian Rome
Program Unit: Josephus
Chris Seeman, Walsh University
While it is increasingly recognized that Josephus crafted the Judean War to appeal to the values and sensibilities of his Roman audience, not enough attention has been devoted to how Romans themselves reacted to the desecration of sacred space and what narrative and rhetorical strategies they employed to mobilize defense of it. An examination of these strategies will facilitate a comparison with Josephus’ narratives about the defense of the Jerusalem temple in War. Livy’s accounts of defense of the Capitoline (1.12; 3.17; 5.49-54) offer especially fruitful candidates for this comparison—not only because the temple of Jupiter Optimus Maximus architecturally represented Roman perceptions of divine favor and imperial destiny, but also because Josephus composed and performed War in the wake of the Capitol’s conflagration, making it an exposed nerve in the Roman psyche. Likewise, the fact that Vespasian made a priority of rebuilding the Capitoline sanctuary meant that it would have been a prominent fixture of the new urban landscape. Josephus need not have read Livy to grasp the emotive force that the ideal of defending of sacred space held for Romans. In light of this, I argue that a Roman audience steeped in Livian poetics would have responded empathetically to Josephus’ portraits of Judean piety with respect to the Jerusalem sanctuary. Whether War succeeded in stemming the tide of anti-Judean sentiment in Rome, Josephus’ audience would certainly have comprehended the sentiments Josephus enshrined in it as analogous to their own.
|
Sefer Okhla we-Okhla: A New Approach
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Sebastian Seemann, Hochschule für Jüdische Studien Heidelberg/Germany
Sefer Okhla we-Okhla is a medieval Masoretic work consisting of various lists of rare words and other linguistic peculiarities present in the text of the Hebrew Bible. The author of this work is unknown, but the book was already mentioned by name in the 10th century by Ibn Jannah. A case can be made that it was composed in the 8th or 9th century. Only two recensions of Sefer Okhla we-Okhla are extant: MS Paris Hébreu 148 and MS Halle Yb 10. 4Q. They were written in France (Tsarfat) and Germany (Ashkenaz), respectively, and while they do not contain colophons, they can be dated somewhere between the 12th and 14th centuries. There is also another source for the material contained in Sefer Okhla we-Okhla, such as old Masoretic bibles in which many similar lists can be found among their Masorah Magna. This paper presents a new approach to the study of Sefer Okhla we-Okhla, namely, from the side of the Ashkenazi tradition of readings and variants.
|
Monsters, Beasts, and Animals: The Taxonomy of Fierce Creatureliness in the Biblical Text and Beyond.
Program Unit: Animal Studies and the Bible
Robert Seesengood, Albright College
What makes an animal a “beast?” Or a “monster?” We might answer that the beast or monster have some degree of unique ferocity or is somehow transcendent of Nature. It is tempting to suggest that “beasts” or fabulous monsters were something populating the world of pre-scientific modernity. The Beast, from our safe distance of (post)modernity, was a savage but misunderstood animal. Indeed, the modern, sophisticate, armed with sturdy Zoology and Taxonomy textbooks, seems hard pressed to find any sort of Beasts or Monsters anymore (one wonders: to our impoverishment?).
Certainly, one could point to cases of the modern domesticated-Beast-become-ordinary-animal in antiquity, or even biblical literature. Are, for example, Job’s Behemoth and Leviathan ordinary crocodiles or whales? The translators of the King James Bible (following rabbi Abraham bin Ezra) decided lilit of Isa 34:14 was screech owl, not demon. But, one must also note: both Hebrew and Greek language differentiate between the “beast,” “monsters” and common animals.
In his late lectures, Jacques Derrida argued that the Beast was a creature who transcends law and rule, eluding domestication, beyond restraint (The Beast and the Sovereign). Beasts, Derrida argued, shared this status with kings and sovereigns. Above the Law (because they made the law), sovereigns could become equally savage, unpredictable and unstable. In biblical studies, much has been made of this insight and its elucidation of conflicts between God (the sovereign) and the Beast(s) of John’s Revelation (particularly by Stephen Moore), and in other apocalyptic texts, such as Daniel, whose focus is humiliation of foreign kings (Koosed and Seesengood). Yet is this equation stable, or complete? While Derrida has articulated the difference between Beast and Domesticated Animal, and noted the relationship between Beasts and Kings, what is the difference between Beast and the Human? In what ways are both Beast and Human distinct from Animal?
This paper will explore the possibility that Human and Animal share an affinity in being, each, transcendent over the rudimentary “Animal.” Yet, Human and Beast remain separate in terms of ferocity and wildness (the Beast) in contrast to reason and restraint (the Human). Beasts (and Monsters) parallel Humans (and Divine) in ascendency over Animals via the ascription of volition. To have a Will (whether a wild or a reasoned one), not necessarily awareness or intelligence, was the determinate for transcendence from animality. Finally, this paper will briefly consider this equation in light of modern discoveries about animal cognition and sentience (particularly, once “monstrous” or beastly animals).
|
“To Be His Own Special People”: Christology and Exegesis in 1 Clement
Program Unit: Development of Early Christian Theology
John Sehorn, Augustine Institute
Scholarship has typically highlighted 1 Clement’s emphasis on Christ’s role as teacher and moral exemplar (Torrance [1959]; Bumpus [1972]; Henne [1992]). The content of his teaching, in turn, is largely communicated through the quotations of the Old Testament, which take up approximately one-fourth of the entire letter. While Jesus may be a uniquely effective teacher and exemplar, the OT is fundamentally made up of “timeless oracles of God” (Hagner [1973]), which are used paraenetically to address the ecclesiological situation at Corinth. This paper argues for a closer connection between Christology and exegesis in 1 Clement than has generally been recognized. It is of course true that Clement uses the scriptures of Israel as a resource for addressing the Corinthian schism. But Clement does not restrict himself to moral exhortation that might be viewed as universally applicable. He also relies on passages that are quite specific to the covenantal history of Israel. Chief among these is Deuteronomy 32 (see 1 Clem. 3.1; 29.2), along with other assertions of Israel’s elect status. Clement’s logic in chaps. 40-47, which constitute the heart of his prescriptive intervention, is vexed. But it is at least clear that his exhortation hinges, not merely on “timeless oracles,” but in part on the relevance of specific characteristics of Israel’s polity to the Corinthian circumstance. Clement’s warrant for assuming that relevance is precisely Christological. Despite Clement’s famous forays into a sort of natural theology, he frequently emphasizes Jesus’s mediation of the Corinthians’ relationship to God. More specifically, it is “through Christ” that the largely Gentile Corinthian community has come to be chosen, like Israel, as God’s “special people” (1 Clem. 64.1). This Christologically mediated election provides the justification for Clement’s scriptural paraenesis. In this, Clement draws on Paul, particularly in 1 Corinthians (though possibly with some important differences; see Simonetti [1994/1981]), a letter to which he explicitly refers (1 Clem. 47.1-3). Furthermore, Christ is not simply an inert passport for Gentiles to travel to the OT. Clement not only finds Christ “preached” by OT figures (1 Clem. 17-18), he also hears Christ’s voice itself speaking in the Psalms (1 Clem. 16.15-16; 22.1-8). The character of Christ’s “presence” in the OT, as well as Clement’s explicit language (e.g., 1 Clem. 7.4; 36.1; 49.6), suggests a more pivotal role for Christ’s death and resurrection in this work of mediation than many have allowed for. While Clement does not develop anything resembling a full-fledged “Christology,” Christ’s mysterious presence in the OT also opens questions about his ontological status. Here I cautiously suggest that C. Kavin Rowe’s concept of “kyriotic overlap” in Luke might provide a useful tool for considering Clement’s view of Christ.
|
Philo and Origen on Moses as Prophet
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
John Sehorn, Augustine Institute
A quarter-century ago, David T. Runia noted a “lack of a solid foundation for the study of Philo’s influence on Origen.” In 2000, Annewies van den Hoek supplied just such a foundation by publishing a truly impressive catalogue of passages where Origen may be dependent on or inspired by Philo. Since that time appreciation for Origen’s estimation of Philo as an exegetical model has only deepened (e.g., Ramelli [2012]). This paper further explores Philo’s influence on Origen, not only on particular exegetical points or hermeneutical procedures, but at a more foundational level of hermeneutical principle: the concepts of prophets and prophecy. Significant scholarly attention has been given to the views of prophecy to be found both in Philo (e.g., Burkhardt [1988], Winston [1989], Levison [1995]) and in Origen (e.g., Nardoni [1984], Hauck [1989], Sfameni Gasparro [1995]), and while some preliminary attention has been given to comparing the two thinkers on the matter, much remains to be done. Focusing on the paradigmatic case of Moses, “the greatest and most perfect of men” (Philo, Mos. 1.1) and “the greatest of the prophets” (Origen, Hom. Ex. 3.1), I argue that Philo is an important influence on Origen’s understanding of prophecy. (While we know that Clement read Philo’s Vita Mosis [see Strom. 1.153], I will argue briefly against viewing Clement as an intermediary between Philo and Origen on this point.) Origen does not take over Philo’s view wholesale; the two Alexandrians diverge most notably on the complex question of the prophet’s condition during divine inspiration. Rather, Origen selects particular elements of Philo’s presentation of Moses, modifying, adapting, and synthesizing them into his own Christian view of prophecy as participation in the Logos. Specifically, Origen builds on Philo’s insistence on the interpretative value of the prophet’s bios — knowledge of “the man himself as he really was” (Mos. 1.1) — with its attendant emphasis on the indispensability of virtue and friendship with God for true prophecy. Origen will reconfigure this emphasis by making its core criterion the kenotic philanthropia of Christ, but, strikingly, seeds of this view are also discernible in Philo’s profile of Moses. Finally, I argue that the significance of Philo’s contribution is fully appreciated only when it is recognized that Origen’s concept of prophecy is centrally constitutive of his case for the unity of the two testaments of the Christian Bible.
|
Achan's Blasphemous Utopia: Or How to Get Yourself Killed in Ancient Israel
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Zach Selby, Chicago Theological Seminary
Though blasphemy is most frequently connected with acts of speech, what might it mean to commit an economic blasphemy? What might economic blasphemy mean in the biblical literature? The narration of Achan's transgression and execution in the Book of Joshua communicates a sense of blasphemous action on the part of this individual, which produces disastrous consequences for the Israelite community and which can only be rectified by a reversal of the herem upon the blaspheming element.
At the root of many of the narratives of the exilic and post-exilic literature of the Hebrew Bible stands a concern to legitimize a distinct political organization characterized by ethnic, religious, and economic concerns. As numerous readers and commentators have demonstrated, these concerns significantly inform the literary articulation of the Book of Joshua's conquest narratives—both in its emblematic successes and paradigmatic failures. The brutality of the total war against the Canaanites in Joshua is only surpassed by surprise at the quickness with which it turns against members of the Israelite community, epitomized by the narrative of Achan in Joshua 7.
In this paper, I will perform a close reading of Achan's narrative highlighting the literary resonance of his blasphemous actions with an emphasis on the residual traces of Utopia contained within Achan's violation of the “ban.” Achan's treachery serves as both the continuing sign of the legitimacy of the not yet realized post-exilic ideal and that post-exilic community's inability to constitute itself as such without a recurrent and internal blasphemous element which must always be expropriated from society. Informed by Fredric Jameson's interpretive theory outlined in The Political Unconscious and elsewhere, I will demonstrate the inability of the Deuteronomistic narrative to firmly cement and contain its category of the herem and, through this inability to complete itself, point toward possibilities for detecting within such narratives a Utopian resistance to the idea that the eradication of blasphemy or blasphemous patterns of behavior functions as the condition for the production of an ideal social formation.
|
The Mysterious Numbers of the Hebrew Kings and the Arithmetic of the Ancient Scribes
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Mikhail Seleznev, National Research University Higher School of Economics, Moscow, Russia
The book of Kings contains a lot of chronological data, including regnal years of the Judean and Israelite kings and accession synchronisms. However, as is well-known, these data contradict each other as well as the Near Eastern chronology. Some scholars believe that these contradictions are due to textual corruption and try to reconstruct the original text (e.g., Shenkel’s attempt to reconstruct the original chronology of the kings of Judah and Israel with the help of the Lucianic recension of the Septuagint). Other scholars (e.g., Thiele) try to explain the chronological data in Kings through elaborate hypotheses on how reigns were counted in ancient Israel and Judah (different calendars in Israel and Judah, antedating vs. postdating systems of counting king’s years, coregencies). Often the two approaches are combined (e.g., Tadmor, Galil).
Despite abundant literature on “mysterious numbers of the Hebrew kings”, one more factor that may have contributed to the inconsistencies in the chronological data has missed the attention of scholars, namely the peculiar character of rules of addition and subtraction as used by ancient scribes for counting units of time.
A good example of how ancient Hebrew scribes added units of time is provided by 2 Kings 18:9-10: “In the fourth year of King Hezekiah, which was the seventh year of King Hoshea son of Elah of Israel, King Shalmaneser of Assyria came up against Samaria, besieged it, and at the end of three years, took it. In the sixth year of Hezekiah, which was the ninth year of King Hoshea of Israel, Samaria was taken”. In other words, 4+3=6, 7+3=9. This is quite logical: the first year of the siege was the fourth year of Hezekiah, the second year of the siege was the fifth year of Hezekiah, the third year of the siege was the sixth year of Hezekiah. This way of counting time is evidenced many times in the Bible corpus. Adding units of time was a routine task and the relevant techniques must have been taught at scribal schools.
However, a different arithmetic is used in the Bible while subtracting units of time. A good example is 1 Kings 6:37-38: “In the month Ziv of the fourth year of Solomon's reign the foundation was laid for the LORD's temple. In the eleventh year the temple was completed ... It took seven years to build”. In other words, 11-4=7. This way of subtracting units of time is witnessed many times in the Bible. It is correct arithmetically, but it is incompatible with the above mentioned way of adding units of time. Systematic errors arising from this incompatibility can explain a large part of the contradictions in the chronology of Kings.
To evaluate our thesis, we will turn to parallel problems in Mesopotamian texts and historiography.
|
Female Bodies, Male Asceticism: Why the Jovinian Controversy Hinges on Female Virginity
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Jeannie Sellick, University of Virginia
Recent years have seen an increased interest in the controversy over the teachings of the monk Jovinian, which played out in Rome and its environs during the closing decades of the fourth century. Jovinian had scandalized many in the ranks of the Italian clergy by arguing that there was no difference in merit between married, widowed, and virgin Christian women. His most aggressive detractor was the pugnacious presbyter Jerome, whose two-volume treatise Against Jovinian is our most extensive source of information about Jovinian’s teaching. In this work, Jerome argued forcefully for a distinction in merit between different ranks of Christians—echoing the positions of Ambrose, bishop of Milan, and Siricius, bishop of Rome—but Against Jovinian itself almost immediately became a source of controversy among many Christians who felt that Jerome was actively disparaging marriage. Thanks to the work of David Hunter, Jovinian, his “anti-ascetic” propositions, and Jerome’s Against Jovinian have earned their place in conversations about early Christian heresy, ecclesial authority, and asceticism. Most notably, Hunter persuasively argued that rather than simply codify a pre-existing status quo, the anti-Jovinianist writings of Jerome and others led to the successful promotion of a hierarchy of merit based on ascetic practice, where previously the majority of Christians in the Western Empire had been ambivalent, if not hostile, to sexual renunciation. This paper will attempt to examine the so-called Jovinianist controversy from a perspective that has not been significantly emphasized in recent scholarship – that of gender. While much ink has been spilled discussing Jerome’s aversion to Jovinian’s anti-ascetic teachings, little has been made of one significant point. In both Jovinian’s mind and Jerome’s response, the issue of whether or not virginity was better than marriage rested squarely on female shoulders (or rather, female genitalia). In an age in which both female and male virginity was seen as a superior state, why did these two men place women’s bodies at the center of their debate? This paper will serve as a preliminary exploration of why the issue female marital status loomed so large in the minds of Jovinian, Jerome, and other 4th century men. The question I attempt to answer then, is why specifically female sexuality lay at the center of the debate between Jovinian and Jerome. Furthermore, this paper will attempt to scratch the surface of why women and their bodies are consistently at the center of early Christian debates.
|
Christian Identities and Judaizing Praxis in Roman Asia Minor in the Second Century CE: A Look upon the Letters of Ignatius of Antioch
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Monica Selvatici, Londrina State University
Among the seven epistles that are considered genuinely written by the bishop Ignatius of Antioch (most of which addressed to Christian communities in Asia Minor in the first decades of the 2nd century), in two of them he shows concern about Judaizing practices among the disciples: the epistles to the Magnesians and the Philadelphians. Both Christian communities were located in the Roman province of Asia. By addressing the letters of Ignatius, the purpose of the present paper is to analyze the relationship between Christian identities and Judaizing praxis in Christian communities of Western Asia Minor in the 2nd century CE, especially those of Roman province of Asia.
As the paper focuses on the process of Christian identity formation/construction, it is necessary to understand ‘identity’ as a multilayer phenomenon: on the one hand, Christian identity can be construed normatively by the discourse of a Church authority (in this case, the ‘apostolic father’ Ignatius), on the other hand, it also encompasses the level of popular piety and popular praxis, which, by its very nature, escapes the realm of normative discourse control. Early Christians and Jews – if those labels applied in the 2nd century CE – interacted with one another and this interaction contributed to the development of many forms of manifesting and practicing the faith in Jesus Christ.
In terms of theoretical framework, the concept of ethnicity, as defined by archaeologist Siân Jones (1997), is employed in the study for it focuses on how social and cultural processes intersect with one another in the matter of group identification. Jones adopts the subjectivist understanding of ethnic identity as postulated by Norwegian anthropologist Fredrik Barth in his seminal work Ethnic groups and boundaries (1969), and, in order to bring empirical or objectivist criteria to her own definition of ethnicity, she adds the Theory of Practice as developed by French sociologist Pierre Bourdieu (1977) to it. This new understanding of ethnicity focuses on the construction of identities and does not take them for granted, as essential elements, but, rather, as relational ones.
The role played by Rome is an important element for a long time neglected by scholarship in the study of early Christianity. Roman rule and values were, nonetheless, intrinsically related to the way Christian faith took shape within the Empire. In order to analyze, according to the concept of ethnicity, the social and cultural processes that intersect with one another in the question of identity for Christians in the Roman province of Asia in the 2nd century CE, the paper examines Western Asia Minor social and cultural background and the larger situation of Christians in the Roman Empire at this period.
References:
BARTH, Fredrik. Ethnic Groups and Boundaries. Boston, MA: Little Brown, 1969.
BOURDIEU, Pierre. Outline of a Theory of Practice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1977.
JONES, Siân. The Archaeology of Ethnicity: constructing identities in the past and present. London & New York: Routledge, 1997.
|
From Source Criticism to Theology, and Not the Opposite: Models of Divine Anger and its Appeasement in Numbers 25
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Ariel Seri-Levi, Hebrew University of Jerusalem and The David Yellin Academic College of Education
Numbers 25 describes the turning of the Israelites to idolatry that involved sexual transgressions, Yhwh’s harsh response to their deeds, and the actions the Israelites were required to perform in order to appease the divine wrath. It is thus an important text for understanding the mechanism of divine wrath, the circumstances by which it is aroused and the methods for its appeasement. However, as scholars have long discerned, the reading of this story gives rise to difficulties leading to the conclusion that it does not represent a single uniform narrative.
For more than a century there has been broad consensus regarding the need to distinguish between the first part of the chapter, verses 1–5, which discusses the daughters of Moab and Baal-peor, and the second part of the chapter, verse 6 and onward, which describes Phinehas’s act; and, until recently, it was also agreed that the story of Phinehas was part of the priestly literature.
In recent decades, however, alternative suggestions for analyzing the chapter were proposed though they too added to those problematic points that were already controversial. The debate revolved around almost every issue of the chapter’s analysis: the composition of verses 1–5 and the nature of the connection between elements in this section to other writings in the Pentateuch and out of it; about the degree of uniformity of verses 6–18; on the question of whether the different elements in the chapter are dependent upon one another or independent; whether the story of Phinehas is part of the “priestly source,” if such a source exists at all, or might it be part of the “priestly redaction,” if such a redaction exists at all; or perhaps, it is connected to the “redaction of the Book of Numbers,” if Numbers is indeed a “book” that was redacted separately from the rest of the Pentateuch; and, so on.
In my paper, I would attempt to show that Numbers 25 is comprised of three fully independent stories, no more no less. This conclusion was already drawn by classical Pentateuch research and it remains the most convincing and economical explanation of the chapter’s structure. First and foremost, it emerges from the chapter itself, but it receives reinforcement and confirmation from the study of other biblical texts. I will point to several implications of this analysis as a test case for some of the most important questions on the agenda of contemporary Pentateuch scholarship.
|
From the Field to Facebook: Why Context Matters in "Biblical Archaeology"
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Cynthia Shafer-Elliott, William Jessup University
In the social media age, news about the latest discovery related to “Biblical Archaeology” races around the world in an instant. As a result, an expanding audience of both scholars and lay people alike have access to and are making use of these discoveries - indeed these are exciting times. Although the intentions are good, these discoveries are often not placed within and shared in their context, thus often doing more harm than good. In this paper I will briefly address why context matters both on the excavation field and how that could possibly translate into the social media age.
|
Women’s Work: The Ancient Israelite Matriarch in Domestic Context
Program Unit: Economics in the Biblical World
Cynthia Shafer-Elliott, William Jessup University
Subsistence economies rarely have the luxury of gender roles, which can be defined as the socially constructed roles, behaviors, activities, and attributes that a given society considers appropriate for men and women. The daily concern of most ancient people was survival, and ancient Israel was no different. Each member of the ancient Israelite household was expected to participate in their survival, regardless of sex, age, or other differentials. While subsistence economies may not have had so-called gender roles, certain household members had more specific roles to perform: in particular, the role of the patriarch and matriarch, who possessed the most power and authority within the household. This view of co-power and authority within the household is not the traditional view, but one that has been put forward within the last few decades by many feminist biblical scholars and archaeologists. In particular, Carol Meyers, the Mary Grace Wilson Professor Emerita of Religious Studies at Duke University, has written extensively on the roles and power of ancient Israelite women. This paper will examine Meyer’s contribution to the study of women’s economic roles within the household and will focus primarily on that role as manager of the household foodways.
|
“Now to One Who Works…” (Rom 4:4): Working Debtors and Grace-Filled Profits as a Neolibral Capitalist Framework for Romans 4
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
Katherine A. Shaner, Wake Forest University
This project proposes analyzing the acquiescence of biblical interpretation with neoliberal capitalist structures of debt, particularly in the interpretation of Romans 4. In Romans 4, Paul writes about the mechanisms by which God accounted for (λογίζομαι) Abraham’s righteousness (δικαιοσύνη). In the world of neoliberal capitalism, “financial literacy” demands create the conceptions of good debt and bad debt. These taxonomies are valued along class lines—wealthy, professional-class debt and profitable business debt is valued as a sign of healthy entrepreneurship while impoverished, working-class, daily-living debt is valued as irresponsible, decadent, and dead-beat behavior. In many interpretations of Romans 4, the accounting for faith is kept in terms of grace (κατὰ χάριν) whereas the accounting for works is kept in terms of debt (κατὰ ὀφείλημα) (Rom 4:4). In this paper, I argue that this equation of bad debt with working and good debt with faith, draws on these slippery contemporary rhetorical framings of good debt and bad debt. On the one hand, debt incurred in the process of building wealth is celebrated as a leap of faith. On the other hand, debt incurred because wages are low, consumer costs are high, or for attempts to break social status barriers is considered a reckless attempt at living above one’s means. Ultimately this paper argues that intersectional rhetorical critical lenses offer new, and more liberative possibilities for understanding communal theo-economic (Quigley 2018) security in ancient and modern contexts.
|
To Each His Own Blessing: The Twelve Tribes in Genesis Rabbah
Program Unit: Midrash
Avram R. Shannon, Brigham Young University
Bere**** Rabbah 98:6 states, “A man does not say, I am a Reubenite or I am a Simeonite, but I am a Judahite.” This statement establishes the Sages’ position that being an Israelite and being a Jew were synonymous propositions regardless of any putative tribal affiliation. Indeed, the biblical twelve tribe system was largely a casualty of history. From a halakhic perspective, the only tribal affiliation that differedwas Levi, and even that was connected to a Jewish identity. In spite of this, Bere**** Rabbah contains a lengthy interpretive section on Genesis 49, which contains the blessings of the various sons of Jacob. This interpretation provides insight into how the Sages were thinking about Israelite identity, even though the halakhic question had already largely been settled.
Each of the tribes receives interpretation in turn, but the interpretations do not apply the same hermeneutical tools to every tribe. Comparison between the individual tribes’ interpretations gives insight both into how the Sages were reading and understanding the biblical world and how they were constructing their own identity and the world around them. Sometimes an interpretive strand emphasizes a biblical or historiographical point. This may be seen in the interpretation of Dan’s blessing in Genesis 49:16, which is interpreted almost exclusively in terms of Samson, the most famous Danite. Other times, the Sages use the biblical verse in order to make a statement about the character of the tribe in general. This is the case with the interpretation of Issachar’s blessing, where the biblical praise of hard work is rabbinized into hard work studying the Torah, presenting the men of Issachar as Torah scholars.
This paper looks at the traditions about the Twelve Tribes in Bere**** Rabbah 98 in order to explore the various conclusions that the Sages bring to bear in their exploration and interpretation of the Bible. The midrashic process is never simply about somehow discovering some kind of original biblical intent. The Sages were embedded in a broader world of discourse, but the Bible represented a privileged place for discussion of identity and boundary maintenance. While the halakhah proceeded from the principle that Israel=Judah, the ancient system of the Twelve Tribes gave the Sages interpretive space for looking at the broader category of Israel, and to use that to praise behaviors and ideas that they found beneficial and worth promulgating.
This paper specifically examines the interpretations of the blessings of Reuben and Issachar in Bere**** 98. These two blessings show the wide interpretive net cast by the Sages, including the desire to rehabilitate biblical figures such as Reuben. The interpretation of these two blessings also illustrates the important role that intertextuality plays in this midrashic interpretation of the Twelve Tribes. The whole of the Bible is brought to bear to explain the often cryptic sayings from Genesis 49. All of this then points to the role that the midrashic enterprise has in the rabbinic construction of their world, at the confluence of biblical ideology and their own lived experiences.
|
It’s All in How You Look at It: The Eyes and Morality in Matt 6:22-23
Program Unit: Cognitive Science Approaches to the Biblical World
Colleen Shantz, Toronto School of Theology
The oddness of Matt 6:22-23 resists easy interpretation by several means. On its own, the extended aphorism about the eye as the lamp of the body presents an odd image, buttressed by an illogical parallelism, directed toward a vague moral injunction. What makes it possible to imagine the eye as the site of bodily infection with evil? This paper explores the interplay of two key aspects of cognitive theory: cultural embeddedness, and embodiment. Notions of the evil eye and its function in societies of limited good explain some of the peculiar language. But while culture provides context for the values in the saying, it does not explain how the eye came to express the focus of the concern. This paper explores the significance of the character of vision, eye contact, and gaze as key factors in the character of identity and construction of conscious knowledge. These embodied factors of cognition fill out the picture of what might otherwise remain merely peculiar and help to highlight how such a saying could motivate morally informed action.
|
A Timely Word in Lament: Psalm 90 and the Homiletical Wisdom of Gardner Taylor
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Carolyn Sharp, Yale Divinity School
Invited paper.
|
New Fragments in the Bodmer Library and What They Can Tell Us about the Story of the Bodmer Papyri
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Daniel B. Sharp, Brigham Young University Hawaii Campus
The purpose of this presentation is twofold: First, at the 2017 annual meeting in Boston, I reported on the identification of some Coptic fragments in the Bodmer and the placement of one of these pieces. The identification of those pieces was only a side note at the 2017 meeting, and the first purpose of this presentation is to provide more detailed information about the number, identification and specifics of these Coptic fragments from the 3rd and 4th letter of Horsiesios.
The second purpose is to explore the connection between these newly identified Coptic fragments housed in the Martin Bodmer Foundation, with Chester Beatty Library Ac. 1494 & 1495, and a fragment at Duke identified as P.Duk.Inv.799. I will demonstrate that both the Bodmer fragments and P.Duk.Inv.799 have a shared provenance and are fragments from Chester Beatty Library Ac. 1494 & 1495 and explore the implications that this has on the provenance of the larger “Bodmer Papyri.”
During my 2017 presentation I noted that these Coptic fragments had the potential to either validate or undermine James M. Robinson’s thesis that the “Bodmer Papyri” come from a Pachomian library and articulated the need for further research on this topic. This paper will present my findings over the past year as I have researched this question. Having personally reevaluated many of the relevant personal notes, letters and papers of James Robinson, Michel Testuz, Rodolphe Kasser, William H. Willis, Odile Bongard, A.F. Shore and others, I will attempt to recreate the Story of the Bodmer Papyri and present the evidence that these fragments from the Pachomian corpus are from the same archeological discovery as the other Bodmer papyri.
|
Use of the Biblical (LXX) Onomastica among Early Christian Commentators
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Frank Shaw, Independent Scholar
Biblical onomastica are the world's first Bible commentaries. They are thoroughly based on the LXX and expound in Greek the meanings of Hebrew and Aramaic proper names, both personal and place, along with a number of “technical” Hebrew words, all transliterated into Greek. Eusebius did a revision of their place names, and Jerome, who records that “they had filled the libraries of the world” by his day, did another on personal names. During the Patristic Period they were translated from Greek into Latin, Syriac, Arabic, Armenian, Ethiopic, and Slavonic. Evidently none are specifically known in Coptic, but there is some evidence that they perhaps existed.
Deriving from mysterious origins in Second Temple Period Judaism, like so many other writings of the time, they have only been preserved directly via (reworked) ecclesiastical copies dating from late antiquity and the medieval age, save earlier quotations by Aristobulus, Philo, NT writers, perhaps Josephus, and especially patristic authors. No substantial research on them has taken place since Franz Wutz's Onomastic Sacra of 1914-15, although one important papyrus onomastic fragment (P.Oxy. 2745) was published in 1968-70. Wutz attempted to record their usage from Origen forward in time but failed in his endeavor. He made no effort to document their employment in earlier patristic writers and he missed references to the onomastica in Origen and later authors. I have traced citations/quotations from the onomastica among early Christian authors, from the New Testament composers to Origen’s mentor, Clement of Alexandria. One revealing, evidently previously unnoticed, usage of the onomastica has come to light in the process, as have certain other finds. Another surprising one is the fact that, unlike Philo, until the third century early patristic usage was not by any means always in an allegorical context. Difficulties in finding such early Christian commentary that utilizes these LXX name lists are reviewed. Interestingly, no use of them has so far been discovered among the Apostolic Fathers or in the NT Apocrypha. Some possible reasons for this are offered, and naturally input is solicited from colleagues.
|
Philosophy and Religion in Later Platonism: Who Were the Bacchoi?
Program Unit: Religion and Philosophy in Antiquity
Greg Shaw, Stonehill College
Philosophy and religion were not opposed for later Platonists as they are for us. They were deeply integrated in their mystagogy, which this paper aims to explore. For these Platonists, philosophy was not conceived as a purely cerebral discipline; it was an integral part of a way of life aimed to transform us into gods. That this may seem foreign or even preposterous to us reveals how distant we now are from sharing the vision of the later Platonic schools. In their mystagogic practice, the intellectual disciplines of philosophy and the rituals of theurgy were deeply integrated and were designed to transform souls into Bacchoi, embodied gods. That this may strike us as bizarre, misguided, or perhaps even disappointing simply reflects how little we have been able to move out of our cultural context and enter the otherness of a tradition that, ironically, lies at the very root of our own philosophic traditions.
|
The Priestly Language of Gender
Program Unit: Philology in Hebrew Studies
Sarah Shectman, Independent Scholar
The Priestly author in the Pentateuch uses terms connected to sex and gender, both gender-specific terms like ish, ishah, zakhar, and nekevah and gender-neutral terms such as adam and nefesh, as technical terminology. P’s precise usage reflects a carefully structured view of the world and of the cult that is aimed at safeguarding the people’s purity. In addition, P seems to recognize the difference between biological sex and gender related to personhood, something more akin to what we might term socially constructed gender.
|
The Death of John the Baptist and the Sociology of Beheading in the Ancient World
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Nathan Shedd, Saint Mary's University College (Twickenham)
This paper offers a sociological analysis of beheading in the ancient world. Two observations prompt this analysis. First, interpreters have considerably neglected bringing the social context of beheading to bear on interpreting John the Baptist’s decapitation (Mark 6:14–29, etc.). Second, historians frequently assert that beheading in the Greco-Roman world represented an honorable method of death. Accordingly, the paper breaks into two parts. The first section briefly sets forth a sample of the recounted beheadings in Jewish and Greco-Roman literature. This sample suggests that those who lived in the first century were familiar with the social “script” of beheading. The second section then details the nature of this script by offering several points of modification to the assertion that beheading comprised an honorable death among the Romans. I argue that beheading, in the general context of John the Baptist, could represent an honorable form of death, but could also represent a degrading form of bodily mutilation that intended to impact the status of the individual in life in the hereafter as well.
|
What’s "Targumic" about the Genesis Apocryphon? Further Reflections on 1Q20 as an Aramaic Version
Program Unit: Qumran
David Shepherd, Trinity College - Dublin
Originally christened 'The Book (or Apocalypse) of Lamech', 1Q20 has of course become well known as the 'Genesis Apocryphon', the title bestowed upon it by Avigad and Yadin. While references to the Apocryphon as a ‘midrash’ would eventually become commonplace, the initial analysis of Avigad and Yadin, especially in relation to the final columns, seemed to invite the text’s association not with midrash, but with the targum—an invitation subsequently taken up by Matthew Black in his 'Scrolls and Christian Origins' in which he further credits his own interest to a conversation he had with Paul Kahle in Oxford. While there is little suggestion today that the Apocryphon as a whole bears much resemblance to any known targum, suggestions do persist in the scholarly literature (e.g. Fitzmyer 2004; Machiela 2009) that in cols xxi and xxii, we find the Apocryphon at its most targumic. This paper offers a reassessment of the ways in which these columns are and are not ‘targumic’ in light of recent advances in targum studies which have led to a fuller understanding of what is characteristic of a ‘targumic’ approach to translation and how this approach relates to that found in Aramaic versions from Qumran like 11Q10 (11QarJob).
|
Haggai and Zechariah in Greek Psalm Superscriptions
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Michael B. Shepherd, Cedarville University
The multiplication of psalm superscriptions in the Greek Psalter vis-à-vis the Masoretic Text raises a question about whether such additions were prompted by the Hebrew or by the Greek text. The present article attempts to answer this question specifically regarding the addition of the names of the prophets Haggai and Zechariah in LXX Pss 110; 111; 137; 138; 145–150 (= MT 111; 112; 138; 139; 146–150). While the evidence strongly suggests that these names were added secondarily and exclusively within Greek tradition, there is reason to believe that the decision to do so in each case had its basis in the Hebrew text behind the Greek translation. Thus, the superscriptions are not only part of the history of interpretation of the Greek Psalter but also part of the history of interpretation of the Hebrew text behind it.
|
From Fat Bibles to Thin Bibles: The Development of the Ethics/Etiquette for Taking/Devouring Land
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Yvonne Sherwood, University of Kent
The history of colonisation, and its critique, is full of images of greedy empires (and their gods) gorging themselves on land. One famous example is Gillray’s cartoon The plum pudding in danger, or state epicures taking un petit souper (1805): Napoleon Bonaparte and William Pitt at the dinner table carving up a steaming ‘plum-pudding’ globe. Another is that most Bullish of Bulls: the world-gorging Papal Bull of Alexander VI of 1493, supported by the quite spectacular ‘Requirement’ or Requerimiento of 1513. Propped up by obsequious biblical texts such as ‘The earth is the Lord’s and all the fullness thereof’ (Ps. 24.1) or the proclamation that ‘At the name of Jesus every knee should bow’ (Phil. 2.8-10), the Bull gave the Pope, and his God, absolute authority to slice up the globe. The Requerimiento turned the book of Joshua and Deuteronomy 20 into texts to be performed, as legal-ritual scripts.
In this paper, I begin with a brief close reading of these biblical mandates and point out some surprising facts about them. For example, even the Spanish empire was already modifying the severity of Deuteronomy 20, and the Requerimiento was also a biblicisation of an Islamic ritual, hence not as pure as it wanted to claim. I then go on to look at how, even at the time of the Spanish empire, the Bible became a far more effective ally of colonisation as it made a great show of slimming down its claims. In particular, I look at the work of Francisco de Vitoria (c. 1492-1546), Chair of Theology at the University of Salamanca, who, I argue was a predecessor for John Locke. Vitoria’s work is a work of ‘theological bulimia’ (cf Heschel) or biblical dieting. In fact, his key lecture on the topic of land claims in ‘New Spain’ was called ‘On Dietary Laws and Self-Restraint’ (1538). In Vitoria’s lectures, the biblical justification gets slimmer and slimmer. For example, the Canaan mandate is taken away on the grounds that God’s gift of Canaan was an exceptional, singular, case. What remains are the parts of the Bible that talk about opening ports, keeping borders open, and supporting the truly universal law of travel and the friend. The Bible no longer turns up with a gun, sword or knife and fork at the ready, so to speak. It enters softly, with much improved manners/etiquette/ethics. Violence only follows—and only now by accident-- if the inhabitants fail to welcome and support the ius peregrinandi (the right to travel) and the right to trade.
The transition from fat Bibles to thin Bibles, and the development of a whole ethic of justice as ‘eating well’ (cf. Derrida), was, I argue, essential to the violence of colonisation. The transition from the divine command to ‘hand over the land’ to the invitation to share/eat together became essential to the process of actualizing land claims as facts on the ground.
|
Cartoons of Muhammad in the Context of "Blasphemous" Bible Cartoons
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Yvonne Sherwood, University of Kent at Canterbury
In this paper I look at the recent, now infamous, cartoons of Muhammad published by Jyllands-Posten and Charlie Hebdo, alongside ‘blasphemous’ Bible cartoons from the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Specifically I shall be looking at cartoons published in The Freethinker in the 1880s, and what I believe to be the first (accidentally) ‘blasphemous’ cartoon of Muhammad (and Adam) published in Europe, printed in the newspaper The Star in 1925. The 1925 cartoon was by David Low—one of the most famous cartoonists of the twentieth century—whose cartoon ‘Rendezvous’ (Hitler meets Stalin) was recently mimicked in a satirical cartoon, also called ‘Rendezvous’ of Trump meeting Kim Jong-Un. In this comparative study I will be treating issues of racism, colonialism and representation on two levels: the representation (or its prohibition) of divinities and sacred figures; and the representation of religions, and the asymmetrical relations between Christian, Muslim and Jew.
|
A “Polyphonic Hero” David from the Perspective of an “Internally Dialogized Word” in the Book of Samuel
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
SuJung Shin, New Brunswick Theological Seminary
This paper deals with the questions related to the complexity of David in the book of Samuel from the perspective of an “internally dialogized word.” Focusing specifically on the figure of David in 2 Samuel, this paper’s approach to the topic of the complexity of David especially in terms of his complex interrelationships with other characters (including YHWH) in the book of Samuel invites a rereading from the perspective of an internally persuasive word, and thus provides a dialogic way of understanding the interrelations of character, speaker, and audience. This paper investigates how, as a character represented with a “plurality of independent and unmerged voices,” David remains undecidable and unstable in the Samuel narrative, and how both the author’s and the audience’s judgments of David are constantly being deferred in terms of the dialogic nature of the text of Samuel. This paper examines how and why the character of David can be represented as the kind of hero who is not determined from the point of view of either the author/speaker or the reader/audience, and thus cannot be finalized by “monologic” authoritative conclusion in the book of Samuel. In so doing, I attempt to make the stylistic (and ideological) distinction between “authoritative word” and “internally persuasive word” from the perspective of the theories of “dialogue.” In the authoritative word, one would encounter a single and unitary language containing a monologic ideological thought. In internally persuasive discourse, on the other hand, one discovers various available ideological points of view and values that become contestable in each of the new contexts that dialogize the discourse. From narrative-critical and post-narrative critical perspectives, this paper ultimately attempts to reveal how the Samuel text can be reread as dialogic, rather than straightforwardly monologic, when it speaks specifically to the questions of David (and the Davidic monarchy) in the Samuel narrative. Influenced by a new perspective in literary studies, this paper challenges certain traditional values and presuppositions in regard to the text, such as the univocality of meaning, the privileging of the author’s intention, and the passive role of the audience in receiving and comprehending the semantic content of the author’s utterance. This paper eventually aims to provide an opportunity for recognizing a dialogic, rather than monologic, understanding of the biblical text in the context of the twenty-first century, where hierarchical dominance and the authority of the logocentrism have been continuously questioned by and in dialogue with ordinary readers.
|
Internarrativity and Ecce Homo: A Masterplot Underlying Zech 6:9–15 and 1 Sam 9:1–11:15 and Its Function in John 19:1–8
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
W. Gil Shin, Fuller Theological Seminary (Pasadena)
Scholars have differed in their basic methodological assumptions about how reliably one can hear the NT text’s evocation of Israel’s Scripture. When addressing a text that has multiple allusive possibilities, a strict view has often focused on determining a “correct” precursor text. The ecce homo scene in John’s Gospel is a good place to test whether the current discussion of methodological grids is precise enough or whether it may have left an area undeveloped. This paper demonstrates that diverse allusions may be considered at a more fundamental level as a conduit for a common underlying signification system. I probe whether the allusions in the ecce homo scene evoke a basic story form, which can be tapped from Israel’s scriptural traditions. This approach is methodologically based on a specification of Ben-Porat’s theory of allusion and the concept of masterplot. Narrative theory employs masterplot to explain how to recognize myriad forms of narratives as the same story (e.g., the Cinderella masterplot). For this reason, I call this approach a search of internarrativity as a specific form of intertextual relations.
I point to one candidate masterplot underlying the allusive interactions of the ecce homo scene: God as a warrior-king conquers (foreign) enemies who dishonor his subjects and subsequently builds a sanctuary-like dwelling place where his kingship is established (shown most succinctly in Exod 15). I exercise a literary analysis of two allusive possibilities that have often been proposed in the ecce homo scene: Zech 6:12 and 1 Sam 9:17. This will show that both passages, despite the difference in the degree of phraseological conformity and their genres, have a congruent literary significance for the ecce homo passage when read in light of the same masterplot.
First, both the Zechariah and the 1 Samuel passages—vis-à-vis the ecce homo scene—have a recognizable analogy of the settings around the “Behold (the) man” statement. Second, the two OT passages themselves are analyzed in terms of the masterplot. The sign-acts in Zech 6:9–15 are semantically structured around a symbolic object, “crown” (6:11), which involves a simple narrative sequence of the reversal of fortune (from dishonor to honor) of the exiled Israel and the Davidic Branch’s subsequent building of the temple. Regarding the 1 Samuel passage, the entire unit of 1 Sam 9:1–11:15 portrays how Saul is established as the first king of Israel in a three-part process of designation, battle, and confirmation. The actantial analysis of its basic storyline shows that underlying the narrative of the establishment of Saul’s kingship is God’s own war and the subsequent creating of his sanctuary-like indwelling.
These allusive interactions can be considered together via the same masterplot, and they help tease out the intriguing nature of the ecce homo scene. First, the internarrative allusions shed light on the carnivalesque distortion of interchange between honor (conquest) and dishonor (defeat) around the crown. Second, this reading provides a solution for the narrative crisis that the humiliated “king of the Jews” generates.
|
Social Identity and Mind Sciences in Philemon
Program Unit: Writing Social-Scientific Commentaries of the New Testament
Elizabeth Shively, University of St. Andrews
Paul’s letter to Philemon is wrapped up with concerns about the formation of identity, relationship and community. I contend, that is, that Paul wrote not only to correspond with Philemon and his community, but also to shape their identities. In this paper, I employ a triangulation of social identity theory, sciences of mind, and textual analysis in order to develop a methodology for addressing how Paul sought to shape the identity of this audience by means of letter-writing. I begin with the work of Judith Lieu who looks at the textual construction of early Christian identity through which Christians created a particular world for themselves and their audiences. I tie this work to cognitive genre theory and research in mind sciences that support the idea of a mind-body-world relationship. Also, I employ social identity theory’s concern with how individuals identify themselves according to groups according to prototypicality, and bring precision to this concern through mind science’s use of prototypes. Finally, through a textual analysis, I look at how the letter, through the process of reading/hearing, may function as a resource for metacognition (thinking about thinking) for Philemon, early Christian audiences, and today’s readers and thereby shape individual and group identity.
|
Strengthening the University Bible Class with Bible Odyssey
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Elizabeth Shively, University of St. Andrews
The aim of this presentation is to look at how Bible Odyssey can enhance teaching and learning in biblical studies courses and, conversely, how student feedback can drive and enhance the creation of content on Bible Odyssey. My use of Bible Odyssey in my course “Jesus and the Gospels” serves as the key case study. In addition, I look at feedback from other instructors who have used Bible Odyssey in their teaching over the last two years. I suggest ways that faculty can integrate this online technology with a variety of other classroom techniques (lectures, small tutorials, private study) in order to improve the content and delivery of Bible courses that attract a range of students from across the university.
|
Recognizing Mark and Matthew: How to Extend Burridge’s Contribution to the Gospels’ Genre with a Cognitive Model
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Elizabeth Shively, University of St. Andrews
Looking specifically at Mark and Matthew, the aim of this paper is to review the methodology of Burridge’s What are the Gospels? in light of developments in genre theory over the past 25 years. In his book, Burridge employs a family resemblance theory, superior to the neo-Aristotelian model of fixed forms, to explain how people may recognize similarities among texts that do not share every feature (similar to the way we recognize siblings in a family). He concludes that an ancient audience would have recognized the Gospels as a sub-genre of Greco-Roman biography because they share key features with other members of that genre. Family resemblance theory has come under fire by literary theorists, however, who have turned to to cognitive sciences to address its shortcomings (e.g., John M. Swales, John Frow, Michael Sinding; cf. Giles Fauconnier, Mark Turner). Yet Burridge’s methodology and conclusions remain unexamined in light of these developments. In this paper, I seek to review and then sharpen Burridge’s work by suggesting ways that a cognitive lens may be employed to examine the genres of Matthew and Mark. Certain cognitive theories – such as prototype theory and conceptual blending theory – hold promise for the study of the genres of Mark and Matthew because they account not only for the communicative process of author, text, audience, and contexts, but also for the differences between the Gospels, their outlying features, and the merging of diverse genres into hybrid texts.
|
Anastasius of Sinai's Witness to Earliest Islam: Some New Evidence
Program Unit: The Qur’an and Late Antiquity (IQSA)
Stephen J Shoemaker, University of Oregon
The Edifying Tales of Anastasius of Sinai is an extremely informative, yet almost entirely overlooked, source for understanding the beginnings of Islam. In part, this is because the second part of his collection, which is the most important for this purpose, has been published only in a French dissertation from 2001 that is very rare and difficult to obtain. Anastasius made this collection, it would seem, sometime before 690 at the latest, and its stories have much to tell about relations between the Christians of the Near East and their new “Arab” (for so Anastasius names here them, seemingly for the first time) sovereigns. Like John Moschus before him, Anastasius gathered these stories during his travels among the Christians of the eastern Mediterranean, and they relate various anecdotes from the period between approximately 650 and 690. In them, the Muslims appear mostly as wicked and blasphemous oppressors of the Christians, in contrast, perhaps, to certain other contemporary sources that seem to describe more harmonious relations. Among other things, Anastasius reports that he himself witnessed “Islamic” construction on the Temple Mount as early as 660 (and in fact, possibly even earlier). He also reports what is alleged to be an eyewitness report from certain Christians who observed the Believers performing sacrifices at their shrine. And Anastasius also includes the first account (to my knowledge) of a Christian who was martyred by the Islamic authorities for his faith, George the Black, who was put to death in Damascus sometime before Anastasius made his collection. Anastasius’ stories thus provide valuable insight into many aspects of day-to-day Christian-Muslim relations in the first half-century after the Muslim conquests, and their reports raise some fundamental questions about the nature of Islam during its earliest history.
|
Asceticism and/as Capital: The Case of Jerome
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Karl Shuve, University of Virginia
The writings of Pierre Bourdieu have left an indelible imprint on a generation of scholarship on the religions of the ancient Mediterranean world. Even those who do not engage directly with his work still reproduce many of his basic claims. His definition of a “field” as a social space in which there is struggle over the accumulation of capital has provided scholars of religion with an invaluable tool for analyzing and understanding the myriad competitive practices evident in extant sources. Indeed, practices that would have previously been described as “devotional” or “private” can now also be described in terms of social relations, with “expertise” functioning as a kind of capital being sought by practitioners. But given Bourdieu’s ubiquitous and subterranean influence, his concepts can easily be adopted without precision or consideration of their potential limits and pitfalls.
In this paper, I wish to consider what it would mean to describe ascetic expertise as a form of capital, on the terms set out by Bourdieu in his essay, “The Forms of Capital.” Ascetic practice is clearly competitive in nature, even as late ancient Christians themselves envisioned it: the ascetic practitioner was engaged in competition with demonic powers, a theme that recurs with particular frequency in Egyptian sources; Athanasius refers often to Antony’s askesis, a term that recalls the athlete’s training and the martyr’s preparation. Moreover, ascetic practitioners were frequently competing against one another, for patronage or for disciples, and their authority would often be invoked in the course of other controversies. But what are the specific implications of referring to ascetic expertise as capital in a Bourdieusian sense?
An answer to this question will require a fine-grained analysis of how Bourdieu envisions the nature of and relationship between the different forms of capital—cultural, social, and economic—and how these forms may need to be re-described. Will it suffice to see both cultural and social capital as essentially dependent on the economic? If we define ascetic expertise as cultural capital (as surely we must, given its “embodied” character), can we agree that it is “external wealth converted into an integral part of the person”? In what institutional forms would ascetic expertise be objectified, given the lack of any ancient parallel even moderately resembling a modern academic qualification? Capital is also "field" specific, creating further issues. Given the relatively amorphous nature of ancient “religion,” can we speak coherently of a “religious field”? If there is such a field, how can ascetic expertise function as capital within it when it was often looked on with suspicion? What of the growing importance of ascetic expertise in the “political field”?
I will attempt to answer these questions through a consideration of the case of Jerome—an upper-class monk who expanded the definition of asceticism to include scholarly practice, who traveled around the empire founding circles of wealthy disciples based on his ascetic credentials, and who kept up correspondence with some of the leading politicians of his day, even converting some to the monastic life.
|
Hildegard of Bingen as Feminist Biblical Interpreter?
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Karl Shuve, University of Virginia
The origins of female biblical scholarship can be traced to at least the fourth century CE. In the closing decades of that century, a group of female ascetics in Rome began to study scriptural texts—not only in Greek, but also in Hebrew (a rarity at that time)—under the direction of the scholar and translator Jerome, even producing their own commentarial work. Sadly, none of their scholarship survives, and we know about it only through Jerome’s letters. If we wish to encounter a female scholar whose work survives in significant quantity, we must jump over seven centuries to the German Benedictine Hildegard of Bingen (1098-1179).
Hildegard is an unusually well-known medieval figure, due in large part to the resurgent popularity of her liturgical music and to the wide range of her extant writings, which deal not only with theology, but also with the natural sciences. She is, however, most often classified as a “mystic” or a “prophet,” and rarely as a biblical scholar. The reason for this is fairly obvious: she presents herself as an unlearned conduit of the divine voice, and she claims that all of her theological and interpretive writings are entirely the products of divine revelation, sent to her vividly in visions. Her writings do not, moreover, generally take the form of commentaries (with the exception of a collection of homilies on the Gospels delivered on a series of preaching tours along the Rhine), but weave quotations and explanations of scripture into her descriptions of elaborate visions, which are themselves heavy with biblical allusions. As for reading pre-modern works as feminist—the problems with this approach have been frequently addressed. Saba Mahmood has recently delivered a withering critique in her "Politics of Piety" of attempts to impute contemporary Western notions of agency and liberation to women from other times and places; it would seem unreasonable, if not irresponsible, to impute such ideals to Hildegard, in the twelfth century, who openly lamented that she, a "feeble woman," had been called by God to take a leadership role in such weak and “womanish times.”
My argument in this paper is not that Hildegard would recognize herself either as a scholar or a feminist, but that her voice is essential to any project of recovering the long, fragmented history of women’s contribution to biblical scholarship and understanding how this scholarship relates to the history of modern feminism. My focus will be on her earliest “published” text, Scivias, a work of exceptional creativity in which she displays not only an encyclopedic knowledge of scripture, but also of earlier Latin-speaking interpreters. Moreover, she inscribed her biblical interpretation not only in writing, but also in visual representation, overseeing the production of 35 illustrations for a manuscript known as the Rupertsburg-Scivias. I will demonstrate how she engages with and subverts tropes of femininity from biblical texts (esp. Genesis and the Paulines) and earlier Christian theology, imaginatively finding within them sources of encouragement for her mission as well as those of her female protégés.
|
Jesus and Sympotic Desire
Program Unit: Westar Institute
David Sick, Rhodes College
*
|
Exegete with Authority: Hildegard of Bingen on Paul
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Catherine Sider Hamilton, Wycliffe College, University of Toronto
Hildegard of Bingen is known chiefly as visionary and theologian, and chiefly in her great theological trilogy, Scivias, Book of Life’s Merits, and Book of Divine Works. She is also, however—and unusually for her time—an exegete whose reading of the scriptures was treated as authoritative. Her explicitly exegetical works, Homilies on the Gospels and Solutiones, are often passed over in discussions of her work. The 2001 Penguin introduction to Hildegard’s works, for instance, treats Homilies only briefly and does not include Solutiones (cf. Flanagan 1996; Acevedo Butcher 2007). As an exegete, however, Hildegard is particularly interesting: “We know of no other twelfth-century woman,” Beverly Mayne Kienzle notes, “and perhaps no other medieval woman, who wrote in standard genres of exegesis—homilies and solutiones—and whose interpretations of Scripture were sought by male audiences” (Hildegard of Bingen: Solutions to Thirty-Eight Questions, 2014, p. 1). This paper explores Hildegard the exegete through her reading of Paul in a selection of her works, with special attention to the little-treated Solutiones.
|
Joel, a Literary and Didactic Anchor for the Book of the Twelve
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Anna Sieges Beal, Gardner-Webb University
Twenty five years ago James Nogalski first wrote about the redactional processes in the Book of the Twelve and focused his attention on the catchword-rich verses of Joel. Eighteen years ago he showed that Joel is the “literary anchor” of the Twelve. Today scholars can ask what more there is to be gleaned from Joel. Aaron Schart has pointed to even more parallels between Joel and writings in the Book of the Twelve. Jakob Wöhrle has suggested a rolling Joel-corpus. And while scholarship may continue to puzzle over whether the book of Joel began as a composition, created for its place in the Book of the Twelve (Nogalski), a rolling corpus into which the growing ideologies of the twelve writings were inscribed (Wöhrle), or as a separate writing, later added to the collection (Jeremias), all can agree that Joel is a touchstone for the Twelve. A question that remains to be answered concerns the scribal motivations for adding this writing to the growing collection of the Twelve. This paper turns to Joel 1:2-2:17* as a starting point for answering the question of scribal motivation. Building on the claim that Joel is schriftprophetie (S. Bergler), created for its place in the Book of the Twelve (Nogalski), this paper will explore the possibilities for identifying the scribal circles responsible for Joel’s creation and preservation. The paper claims that this scribal circle intended Joel, not only as a literary anchor but also a didactic anchor for the Twelve. This didactic anchor provides a road map for Day of YHWH situations such as locust plagues, drought, and invading armies. David Carr’s work on scribalism in the Hebrew Bible suggests that many biblical texts were preserved among interest groups as curriculum. Such curriculum perpetuated the cultural endowment of the interest group in the midst of foreign rule. Joel 1:2-2:17* bears the marks of didactic literature (Jeremias) which instructs hearers with a rhetorical call and response (1:2-3) as well as an injunction to “tell it to your children” (1:4). In view of Joel’s complicated relationship to the cult, one must ask, which interest group is in view here? Are the elders the primary keepers of this tradition (1:2, 14), the priests (1:13), the farmers (1:11), or all who live in the land (1:14)? The interest group responsible for the creation and maintenance of Joel has vast implications for the Book of the Twelve as a whole. Joel, as the literary anchor and didactic anchor may hold the key to understanding the scribal circle who preserved and continued to form the Book of the Twelve in the Persian Period.
|
Persian Imperialism as Context for Defining Judaean "Elites": The Persians and Yahwistic Socio-economic Structures
Program Unit: Literature and History of the Persian Period
Jason M. Silverman, University of Helsinki
The use of the term "elite" in discussions of Near Eastern empires is often quite vague, and the Persian Empire is no exception. This paper will first try to unpack the usefulness of the term "elite." Then, the paper will discuss how the various different known contexts for Judaeans in the empire impact our understanding of the social and economic structure in each location, and the implications on the greater imperial systems for each one. With these in mind, it will be possible to broach the question of how Persian Imperialism impacted both the sociology and economics of being a "Yahwistic" "elite". The goal is to work towards a more dynamic and differential model of local-imperial interactions than is sometimes employed.
|
From Abraham to Daniel, and Back Again: Exploring the Rabbinic Practice of Embedding New Tales into Old Scriptures
Program Unit: Midrash
Malka Z. Simkovich, Catholic Theological Union
Many midrashic legends which expand on the lives of early biblical heroes share narrative parallels with legends that were recorded in the Second Temple period about diasporan Jews who lived and thrived under Persian rule. Daniel in particular stands at the center of numerous Jewish legends whose themes were eventually transferred and embedded into midrashic stories about earlier, more foundational figures in Israelite history. This paper will argue that stories which originate in the Danielic corpus, such as the accounts of Daniel establishing three set times to pray every day (Daniel 6:10), Daniel miraculously surviving in a den of lions (Daniel 6:16-24), Daniel being touched on the mouth by the angel Gabriel (Daniel 9:21), and Daniel defeating and destroying foreign idols (Bel and the Dragon 1-40) all become superimposed by later rabbinic writers onto stories about early biblical heroes, particularly Abraham and Moses (Genesis Rabbah 38:11; b. Berakhot 26b; Exodus Rabbah 1.26; Genesis Rabbah 38:13).
Narrative transferences from heroes who lived in the recent legendary past to heroes who lived in the distant biblical past may reflect a broader trend regarding how the rabbis developed midrashic traditions in the centuries following the Second Temple period. By adopting existing legends about Daniel and other heroes who lived in relatively recent times, and applying them to much older stories, rabbinic writers were able to embed their newer legends into the fabric of Israel's earliest history. In doing so, these writers were able to work within their tradition to add theological dimensions to Israelite history that are missing from the biblical scriptures. These dimensions include themes of divine intervention, divine concern particularly for the Abrahamic family, and the early establishment of a normative system of worship on the part of the biblical patriarchs. The construction of parallels between the biblical patriarchs and later Jewish heroes such as Daniel also enable rabbinic writers to concretize a cohesive narrative of Jewish history that marries early biblical tradition with late biblical history. This paper concludes that scholars should consider whether this hermeneutical method might explain how certain midrashic legends about early Israelite history developed over time.
|
Multiculturalism at Elephantine: Evidence of Intersectionality in Persian Period Egypt
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Brandon Simonson, Boston University
The Aramaic and Demotic documents from Persian Egypt depict everyday life in multicultural communities, as onomastic and other evidence establish that parties interacting in some legal transactions came from different cultural and socio-economic backgrounds. Documents from communities such as Elephantine illustrate a melting pot of cultures as native and foreign populations operated together under a Persian imperial presence. Few studies of the Elephantine legal documents have explored the intersections between social categories of class, gender, ethnic, and religious identity. The intersectionality model established in the disciplines of Biblical Studies and Religious Studies can be applied to the Elephantine community and the Aramaic and Demotic legal material from Persian Egypt, revealing new perspectives on identity in this ancient milieu. This paper contributes to the discussion on the intersectional construction of identity in Persian Egypt by using models of intersectionality to study the interpersonal relationships between representatives of the various cultural and ethnic entities present in extant legal texts. This is accomplished by analyzing class, gender, and religious identity as intersecting social categories as they appear in textual and onomastic evidence. Ultimately, reading the Aramaic and Demotic material through this intersectional lens provides a framework which reveals social stratifications in society and identifies how local and foreign populations living in multicultural communities struggled with one another under Persian hegemony in Egypt.
|
Psalm 49: Enigma of Life and Death in Poetic Performances
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Ka Kwan Almond Sin, Vanderbilt University
This paper explores poetic elements and performative features of Psalm 49. How these elements have contributed to the thematic development of this psalm in order to articulate the enigma of life and death. Psalm 49 is a highly structured poem and its poetic features are skillfully interwoven with one another. Distinctive poetic elements such as the exquisite use of repetition, sound play, interlocking semantic fields and lexical choices indicate that their presence is not accidental, but crafted by a skilful and creative poet. From an aesthetic perspective, this poem is a work of art that is self-sufficient and autonomous, it offers to the readers a pleasure that derives from an appreciation of the poetry per se. While most of the studies focus on the psalm’s possible meanings, some also discuss its significance as a riddle. This poetic genre associated with metaphors and paradox that lead to multivalent interpretations. Paul R. Raabe proposed that some verses in Psalm 49 exhibit deliberate ambiguity on the lexical, phonetic and grammatical levels. Despite his and others important contributions in this direction, this psalm is still largely underappreciated as poetry, and most poetic analyses continue to focus primarily on a matter of structure and putative intricate meanings. This paper will first discuss the riddle genre in poetry; then it will propose a poetic structure of this psalm, followed by an analysis of the performative features in each stanza. I argue that unpredictable rhythmic patterns; asymmetrical poetic structure and multivalent interpretations are all part of this psalm and the aesthetic features in riddle genre.
|
Incomparable or Prototypical? Prototype Theory and the Category of God in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Jennifer Elizabeth Singletary, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
Certain texts in the Hebrew Bible that mention divine beings associated with YHWH are frequently interpreted as expressing a categorical distinction between this God and other divine beings. Further, whether this God is posited as the sole member of the category of GOD in certain texts is also heavily debated, especially in recent discussions of monotheism in the Hebrew Bible. This paper begins to explore the shifting construction of the category of GOD in a selection of biblical texts, using advances from the fields of cognitive science and linguistics. Specifically, my analysis uses prototype theory to re-examine some of the biblical texts that have spurred debate about biblical conceptions concerning the inhabitants of the divine or unseen world, and which have caused difficulties for translators and interpreters. The prototype theory of categorization, developed by the psychologist Eleanor Rosch in the 1970s, builds on Wittgenstein’s notion that categories are not clearly bounded or defined by one set of necessary and sufficient attributes, but instead are flexible and blurry, tending to exhibit a family resemblance structure. Additionally, this theory asserts that category members are perceived as having varying degrees of typicality, while sharing in some, but not all, of the features considered characteristic of the category. In short, according to the theory of prototypical categories, some members are perceived as more prototypical exemplars of a category than others, particularly when they clearly display the greatest quantity of characteristics considered to be important attributes of a category and a minimum number of attributes characteristic of contrasting categories. Prototype theory can provide insight into the nature of the category of GOD and what beings were considered to be members of the category, as may have been perceived or constructed by the biblical writers and their audiences. This paper argues that various biblical texts attempt to impart ideas concerning divine beings’ degrees of representativeness within the category of GOD; some texts go so far as to begin to try to push certain divine beings to the periphery of this category, or even to attempt to eliminate them from the category altogether. After a brief discussion of some of the most salient points from research in cognitive science and linguistics, these insights will be used to elucidate difficult biblical texts, such as Exodus 15:11, Psalm 89:6–19, Psalm 82, Isa 40:25–26, Isa 45:5–6. A close reading of passages with prototype theory in mind, as well as attention to the use and significance of polysemy, reveals some of the key features that different groups considered to be the most indicative of representativeness for the category of GOD within their cultural contexts: in other words, the qualities that serve to most clearly represent what members of the category have in common, paired with the minimization of qualities indicative of contrasting categories.
|
Collaboration between Prophets and Other Religious Specialists in the Mari Letters and the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
Jennifer Elizabeth Singletary, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
Evidence from royal correspondence discovered in archival contexts demonstrates that prophets in Old Babylonian Mari worked in concert with several types of scholarly and religious professionals, as well as members of the elite. At Mari, literate intermediaries recorded prophetic messages and conveyed them to the king; court specialists verified the validity of the information through alternative methods of divination. Furthermore, prophecies frequently appear to have originated in the context of temples, where prophets operated alongside temple personnel. Though the biblical writers often denigrate religious specialists who compete against approved prophets, excluding them from the ranks of professionals considered legitimate, a significant number of texts from the Hebrew Bible also describe more inclusive, cooperative, collaborative, or group efforts among prophets and other religious professionals and elite individuals. This paper investigates the textual evidence for collaborative interactions between prophets and various religious specialists in the Mari letters and biblical texts, analyzing the complex systems of interplay between prophets, temple personnel, and other types of diviners, as well as educated members of the elite. A comparative reading of these texts reveals glimpses of the working cultures of these specialists among their peers in different contexts in the ancient Near East.
|
Exilic Methodologies: Fernando Segovia's Critical Contribution Beyond Disciplinary Disciplines
Program Unit: La Comunidad of Hispanic Scholars of Religion
Santiago Slabodsky, Hofstra University
Exilic Methodologies: Fernando Segovia's Critical Contribution Beyond Disciplinary Disciplines
|
From "Thirdspace" to "For Space": Reading Philippi in Acts 16 with Doreen Massey for Interpretive Advances with and beyond Edward Soja
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Matthew Sleeman, Oak Hill College, London
Many readers of ancient space, myself included, have made use of the notion of ‘thirdspace’, as developed by Edward Soja, Thirdspace: Journeys to Los Angeles and Other Real-and-Imagined Places, (Oxford: Blackwell, 1996). Fewer scholars in our field have drawn on the work of Doreen Massey, a feminist geographer, who has also written extensively on revitalising how we imagine space, at greatest length in her book, For Space (Los Angeles: Sage, 2005). Although Massey made sharp criticisms of Soja’s work, her project focused predominantly on her own distinctive and constructive spatial imaginary. It is here where the center of gravity of this paper is located.
In this paper, I outline briefly several criticisms of Soja’s formulation of space, criticisms raised by biblical scholars as well as by Massey and other geographers. I then summarise Massey’s project as expressed in For Space, highlighting where it offers positive advantages for reading ancient texts, artefacts, environments and spatial practices. These include: its richer integration of space within an understanding of time; the overcoming of space/place dichotomies; the notion of throwntogetherness; and the inherent and dynamic relational and political negotiations of time-space.
This outlining of Massey’s vision also raises particular needs and gaps within her project which appear when it is applied to sacred spaces. These limitations suggest avenues for further development within biblical studies. Rather than limiting her contribution, I propose that recognizing these implications will help enliven it. For instance, they point towards suggestive historical equivalences which can parallel recent considerations of current-day infra-secular spaces, made by Veronica della Dora, ‘Infrasecular Geographies: Making, Unmaking and Remaking Sacred Space,’ Progress in Human Geography 42(1) (2018): 44-71.
These observations concerning spatial theory are illustrated and applied through a reading of the account in Acts 16 recounting Paul’s visit in Philippi. This aspect of my paper both draws upon, and partially re-positions, recent research in this area, such as Alexandra Gruca-Macaulay, Lydia as a Rhetorical Construct in Acts (Atlanta, GA: SBL, 2017). It also models how – and the extent to which – Soja and Massey can be employed together to illumine ancient spaces and spatialities. As a whole, the paper points to Massey’s work as a fruitful and generative lens for further applications more widely in our area of scholarship.
|
How Do We Test Social Network Theory Hypotheses? Digital Humanities Approaches
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Edward Slingerland, The University of British Columbia
The question of what makes some religious groups successful while the vast majority of new sects and movements die out has been of central interest in the academic study of religion. Social Network Theory (SNT) has proposed a variety of mechanisms that might explain the differential survival of specific religious groups in times of great religious competition. When applied to contemporary, or near-contemporary, religions, a wealth of demographic and survey data is available that allows one to quantitatively evaluate the explanatory power of any given SNT hypothesis.
When it comes to ancient (or even early-modern) religions, however, we do not have the luxury of zipcode-linked census data or detailed poll responses. Scholarly information about ancient religions tends to be scattered throughout monographs, journal articles and book chapters, and to be primarily qualitative in nature. In this talk, I will discuss how new, digital humanities tools can help us to respond to this challenge. Large-scale text analysis allows us to discern significant patterns in enormous, digitized text corpora, including patterns too subtle to be noticed by an individual reader. Online quantitative-qualitative databases bring together into a central clearinghouse scholarly opinion on ancient religious history. Focusing in particular on the Database of Religious History (DRH; www.religiondatabase.org) project, I will explain how these tools are beginning to be used to allow quantitative assessments of hypotheses about ancient religion, as well as their exciting potential to be used as platforms for future SNT research.
|
Israel, Jesus, and Christians in the Desert: The Scriptural Wilderness as a Christian Theological Resource
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
Daniel Lynwood Smith, Saint Louis University
Many a biblical narrative is set in the wilderness (midbar/eremos), from Hagar’s twin wilderness sojourns in Gen 16 and 21, to a pair of mysterious women in the wilderness in Rev 12 and 17. Joseph is thrown into a pit in the wilderness (Gen 37:22), the Israelites leave Egypt for the wilderness (Exod 13-14), David takes refuge in the wilderness (1 Sam 23), and Jesus is tested in the wilderness (Mark 1:12-13 and parallels). While scholars have attempted to define the meaning of wilderness as a “motif” or “concept” (Funk 1959; Talmon 1966; Najman 2006), I follow Schofield (2008) in expanding my purview to include both wilderness as a space and wilderness as reference to a historical time, namely the Israelite wilderness sojourn narrated in Exodus, Numbers, and Deuteronomy, as well as references in Psalms and prophetic literature.
I propose here a threefold consideration of the roles wilderness has played in Christian theology. First, I will highlight the New Testament writings’ use of wilderness language that clearly hearkens back to the Israelite wilderness period, from the wilderness testing of Jesus in the Synoptic Gospels, to the reflections of Paul on “our ancestors” (1 Cor 10), to the interpretive application of Psalm 95 (94 LXX) in Heb 3-4. Second, I will take up post-NT reflection on the wilderness as the site of early Christian asceticism, treating works like Athanasius’s Life of Antony and Origen’s Homily on Num 33. Finally, I will begin to articulate the theological implications for twenty-first-century Christian reflection on the role of wilderness in earlier traditions. Although the ancient Christian traditions moved in different directions, each can claim firm scriptural footing, offering a versatile array of options for contemporary Christian theologians to consider.
|
With Ears to Hear: Intertextuality in GIFs and the New Testament
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
David Smith, Johnson University
This paper is an exploration of ancient and modern uses of intertextual “images.” In it I examine the similarities and differences of the use of these “images” between ancients and moderns. Questions such as How, why, and from where are images chosen? What do those images indicate about the author and recipient? What is to be interpreted in light of an intertextual image? From whose perspective is it to be interpreted? These, or at least some of these, questions address traditional impasses of contemporary New Testament scholarship on intertextuality. I suggest that modern media can offer a way forward through these questions.
|
Using Hypothes.is for Communal Annotation and Close Reading
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Eric C. Smith, Iliff School of Theology
Over the past few years, I have experimented with several different methods for how to do group close readings of biblical texts in hybrid and online environments. After trying and abandoning several previous methods, including using regular discussion forums, Google Docs, and Quip, and after exploring many other options, I have recently settled on Hypothes.is. In an ongoing, weekly exercise I call Marginalia, I have my students communally annotate a selection of the week's primary text material, commenting on whatever aspects of the text catch their eyes. Hypothes.is provides a means to annotate and respond to annotations at the level of single words, phrases, sentences, or paragraphs. It also offers private group options, which helps to protect student privacy and insulate them from unwanted attention from their annotations. By using Hypothes.is, I have been able to foster vigorous discussions of primary texts in an asynchronous way, but in a way that we are all viewing the text together and sharing our insights on it. Hypothes.is's recent integration with at least one LMS platform has made this task easier. In their evaluations, student report a great deal of satisfaction, enjoyment, and insight gained from our Marginalia exercises on Hypothes.is. In this short presentation, I would orient users to the Hypothes.is platform, demonstrate my Marginalia exercises, and provide suggestions for using this technology in all pedagogical environments, but especially hybrid and online settings.
|
Purple Gospels and Imperial Book Patronage
Program Unit: Student Advisory Board
Eric C. Smith, Iliff School of Theology
We are often reminded that correlation does not imply causation, but here I propose that we consider a correlation and follow its implications through, just in case. The correlation is this, in rough timeline form: early Christianity's greatest library received an important imperial commission, became a center of book production, and began focusing on and specializing in vellum. Not long after, richly produced and decorated gospel books began to appear, several at once, with no extant previous exemplar, sharing common textual features and eccentric material forms. If correlation did imply causation, we might ask whether the exemplar of these strange books, or even the books themselves, came from the library and scriptorium in Caesarea. A second causative implication follows, more speculative still: the scriptorium in Caesarea might have been the place where manuscript illumination entered the mainstream of Christian book production.
A unique class of "purple" dyed vellum manuscripts-often illustrated, written in exotic inks, and featuring the Eusebian Canon Tables-sprang up in the sixth century, seemingly out of nowhere. Codex Rossanensis, Codex Sinopensis, Codex Beratinus, Codex Purpureus Petropolitanus, and Uncial 080 all date to the sixth century. They are all written on red-dyed vellum, using silver or gold ink, or sometimes both. Three of the five are illuminated-extremely unusual for the period-and the other two are too fragmentary to know with certainty whether illustrations had been included. At least three of them included the Eusebian Canon Tables, and by the inexact art of text-type analysis, all can be grouped plausibly into the same category of "Caesarean."
A few generations before these manuscripts appeared, Jerome reports that the library founded by Origen and the scriptorium originated by Eusebius had begun the process of copying the library's papyrus holdings onto vellum. A generation or two before that, Constantine had commissioned Eusebius (and presumably his scriptorium) to produce fifty copies of scriptures. The scribal work in Eusebius's workshop in Caesarea, in other words, was prominent, skilled, sought-after, and linked to imperial book production in the centuries leading up to the emergence of these "purple" gospels, and those "purple" books entered the world just when the scriptorium of Caesarea was at the height of its powers. Scholars over the years have asked in various ways whether and how textual traditions were shaped and propagated from the pens of Origen and Eusebius, but the question of whether Christian book illustration might have taken hold in Caesarea has been much less frequently raised. As the library and scriptorium basked in the new light of imperial patronage, and as the newly ascendant Christian emperors sought to fuse imperial trappings with Christian material culture and coalescing orthodoxy, the conditions were exactly right for the emergence of opulent, conspicuously Christian, and unique imperial Christian books-books just like the purple gospels of the sixth century. There is no clear causation here, but there is certainly a lot of intriguing correlation.
|
What Kind of Problems Do Demons Solve in Late Antiquity?
Program Unit: Religion and Philosophy in Antiquity
Gregory Smith, Central Michigan University
This paper attempts to argue for both sides of the categories question. Using late ancient demonology as a case study, it suggests first that “philosophy” and “religion” work but poorly as independent frameworks for analysis. Even if we try to use definitions explicitly advanced by ancient authors—definitions that can be found in the wild, not just among modern scholars with etic axes to grind—conclusions that rely on one category to the exclusion or minimizing of the other will be as misleading as they are difficult to reach. On the other hand, taking account of the categories, their history, and especially how they have been deployed in different ways through time and space can yield insights that are unlikely to have emerged at all in the absence of the categories. In short, category-talk invites anachronism at every turn, signaling crucial areas of difference and change over time that might otherwise be missed altogether. Intellectual and cultural historians should welcome this: anachronism is our friend.
|
From the Altar to the Abattoir: The Evolving Figure of the Bovine in Jewish Text and Art
Program Unit: Animal Studies and the Bible
Joshua Paul Smith, University of Denver
In the last decade, the subject of animality has gained increasing traction among theorists and scholars of religion. Aaron Gross in particular has been responsible for advancing conversations about animal ethics, animal theory, and Judaism. Following this line of inquiry, in this paper I will trace the development of the specific image of the bovine as it has been presented historically in Jewish text and art. To follow this trajectory, I have divided the discussion into three parts, roughly correlative to chronological epochs: Part One examines the bovine-as-symbol in ancient Near Eastern, Israelite, and Greco-Roman pagan sacrificial rites. Part Two focuses on the shifting signification of the bovine during the Mishnaic period, immediately following the fall of the Jerusalem temple in the first century of the Common Era. Finally, in Part Three I examine three modern examples of people—two artists, one theorist—whose work has reflected serious engagement with Judaism and the question of the animal, and collectively precipitated yet another major shift in how cows are understood in relation to human subjects. I conclude that the overall trajectory of the evolving image of the bovine in Jewish scripture and art has been marked by a shift from signifying virility, strength, and wildness in the Hebrew Bible toward an understanding of the bovine as a symbol of victimhood in more recent text and image.
|
Hermeneutical Roundtable: Active Learning with Biblical Lit
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Joul Layne Smith, University of Texas at Arlington
When I taught The Bible as Literature at a large research university, most of my students were engineering, business, or medical professional majors. They were not interested in the typical kinds of contemplative analysis that biblical literature requires. They did, however, like conferencing with one another to solve problems, so I introduced the hermeneutical round-table with every class, an activity that required every student to be ready with a real world application of the textual material. In game-show style, each student was permitted ten seconds to offer an application of the text's meaning, and if he or she couldn't, another student would be able to steal their turn. Each application resulted in a point, and the points added up to a final score for the semester. There was also a prize at the end of the term. Some texts were obviously more difficult for others, but for my demonstration, I will use the room of scholars, and after going over the rules, have them conduct the activity with Matthew chapter 5.
|
The Prophet's Enthymeme: King, Prophets, Kenneth Burke, and the Hermeneutic of Identification
Program Unit: Bible and Cultural Studies
Joul Layne Smith, University of Texas at Arlington
The most influential rhetorical theories during the decades 1940-1960 were those of Kenneth Burke, whose notions of “identification” became the driving force for communicative techniques throughout the twentieth century. Burke insisted on the importance of sociocultural phenomenon when considering the best way to communicate with an audience, which established a heuristic that enables a communicator to assume an identity that an audience identifies with and as. Using Burke’s heuristic, known as dramatism, I argue that Dr. King employed a hermeneutic of “identification” by invoking his own personhood within the scope Old Testament prophets’ callings to justice and freedom. King’s interpretative framework required him to dismiss the typical Old Testament imagery of the beleaguered people groups in favor of the righteous statesman who stakes his claim upon a sense of belonging. I will focus my attention on King’s use of these images in his Letter from Birmingham Jail. In that text, King aligns his identity with “eighth-century prophets,” which serves as the evidence that he belongs, like Amos and the other pre-exilic prophets, wherever there is injustice. The complexity of his identification with Old Testament prophets translates into a cognitive realignment for his readers, eight clergymen, who must reckon King’s identity with his suppressed, though palpable, premise about his important place as a prophetic voice.
|
Hope and Endurance in Romans: Agrarian Virtues for Citizenship in the Heavenly Commonwealth
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Julien C. H. Smith, Valparaiso University
This paper proposes a reading of Romans, focusing on 8:18-25, that will serve as a resource to the contemporary church in forming local communities that live in healthy interdependence with the land. Using the methodology of the Exeter Project (Horrell et. al., Greening Paul, Baylor 2010), this paper develops a hermeneutical lens for reading Romans in conversation with both ancient political philosophy and contemporary agrarian discourse. The investigation is guided by two interrelated questions: What virtues are required and enabled by citizenship within a heavenly commonwealth (Phil 3:20) whose telos is the eschatological transformation of creation (Rom 8:19-25)? And what practices will nurture such virtues both in the church and in the world? The first part of the paper locates Paul's argument within a wide stream of ancient political philosophy that correlated the formation of virtue with the reign of the good king. As attested by Augustan court poets such as Virgil (Fourth Eclogue), the reign of the virtuous king was believed to usher in a golden age marked by virtue and agricultural fecundity. Yet by claiming the return of Saturn's reign as a fait accompli, such propaganda implied no causal relationship between human virtue and just, healthy agricultural practices. Indeed, Roman practices such as the distribution of grain (Annona) in the face of declining Italian agriculture divorced the fruits of farming from the agrarian virtues that sustain land health. Ironically, the economic practices used to prop up the fiction of Rome's golden age not only failed to inculcate and sustain agrarian virtues, but instead contributed to widespread ecological degradation. Paul's argument in Romans, beginning with the announcement of the reign of Israel's Messiah Jesus (Rom 1:3-4, 16) and proceeding towards a description of the virtues of the church, the body of the Messiah (Rom 12), echoes key elements of the audience's cultural repertoire concerning the inculcation of virtue and the reign of the good king. Yet crucially, Paul looks not backwards with nostalgia, but forwards with hopeful endurance. The virtues of hope and endurance, largely absent from the classical canon, are essential to Paul's vision of the Messiah's reign and its telos, the liberation of creation through the revealing of the Messiah's people in glory (Rom 5:2-5; 8:24-25; 12:12; 15:4-5). The second part of the paper engages in the constructive task of applying the Pauline virtues of hope and endurance to the present ecological crisis. Beginning with Hauerwas's notion of the church as virtue-forming community and MacIntyre's concept of practices that both require and form virtues, we ask: What are the practices that anticipate the eschatological transformation of creation, and how might such practices inculcate the virtues of hope and endurance within the church? It is argued that farming is one such vital practice, and that local congregations, functioning as the "hermeneutic of the gospel", should seek ways to participate in local farming communities and economies. In so doing, churches cultivate the virtues of hope and endurance, essential to the process of God's people growing in glory.
|
Unity in Christ: Virtue and the Reign of the Good King in Colossians and Ephesians
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Julien C. H. Smith, Valparaiso University
The author of Ephesians and Colossians (referred to below as Paul) makes an appeal to unity in the church that resonates with the achievement of unity predicated upon the reign of the good king within Hellenistic political ideology. This pronounced echo is hardly accidental, but rather can be attributed to a broader strategy within these two letters to present Jesus the Christ as a type of ancient ideal king. We can best understand Paul's argument with respect to unity in the church if we grasp the relationship between two important functions attributed to the ideal king in Mediterranean antiquity, the establishment of unity and the inculcation of virtue. Unity within the polis cannot be achieved unless virtue is first inculcated within the citizenry, and both of these achievements are the consequence of the good king's reign. The belief that virtue was a necessary condition for unity, and that both were the prerogative of the ideal king sheds light on the relationship between the unity that Christ has established, and the moral effort required by the church in order to realize unity within itself. As a consequence of Christ's resurrection and enthronement as king (Eph 1:20-23; Col 1:13-20), the hostility between Jew and gentile has been abolished and a new humanity has been created in its wake (Eph 2:14-16; Col 3:11). Yet it is only as the church puts on the character of Christ and learns virtues (Eph 4:17-5:20; Col 3:5-17) that the implications of this new humanity, namely unity in the midst of diversity, can be realized in the church and household (Eph 4:1-6; 5:21-6:9; 3:18-4:1). Thus, for Paul, unity in the church is a direct consequence of the gospel, the proclamation of Jesus's reign as cosmic king (Eph 1:10, 13; Col 1:13, 23). Does Paul imagine that Jesus's reign, as it effects unity in the church, will have an effect on the wider society outside the church? Although the focus of these two letters is decidedly upon the church, the outside world is not excluded from view (Col 4:5-6; cf. Eph 5:16). Indeed, the telos of Jesus's reign is that God is reconciling, or summing up all things (Eph 1:10; Col 1:20). Consequently, it will be argued, Paul envisions the church as "the hermeneutic of the gospel", that is, the community that embodies the life of an alternative polis in which the wider world is able to see and understand the reign of the resurrected Christ. In formulating a political theology that embodies the gospel announcement of Jesus's cosmic reign, and working out its implications for human society, Paul calls the church to anticipate the eschatological recovery of the divine vocation to be a royal priesthood (Gen 1:26-28).
|
Exodus 32:10: Mere Rhetoric or an Intent to Consume?
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Katherine Smith, Trinity College - Bristol
Exodus 32–34 has a complex redaction history that has preserved at the beginning of the pericope at least the dynamic of Israel’s actions at the foot of the mountain (32:1-6) and YHWH’s response at the top of the mountain (32:7-14). At the centre of this dynamic is Moses’ presence with YHWH at the top of Mt Sinai as God first assesses Israel’s actions and then conveys his intent to let his anger consume the people and make Moses into a great nation. However, before announcing this intent, YHWH issues a command in v10a for Moses to leave his presence. The Hebrew focus clause in v10a emphasises the urgency by which YHWH desires Moses to withdraw and to go back down the mountain. From a literary perspective, the verbal sequence is significant suggesting that Moses’ obedience to YHWH’s directive would be the trigger for the rest of the sequence to occur. If Moses departed, he would allow God's anger to burn freely and so consume the people. The directive and subsequent verbal sequence also leaves another possibility, which is Moses not accepting YHWH's directive by staying and so risking his own life. Past scholarship though has struggled with this understanding of Exodus 32:7-10 and have mostly understood YHWH’s command in v10a to be a rhetorical invitation for Moses to intercede before YHWH rather than a directive to Moses that conveys danger for Israel. Using insights from redaction criticism and rhetorical analysis, this paper explores this issue of YHWH’s intent at the top of Mt Sinai in 32:10 in response to Israel’s actions at the foot of the mountain in 32:1-6.
|
Theophany and Parousia: Thirty Years On, and Twenty Years Back
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Murray J. Smith, Macquarie University, Sydney
In an influential article in New Testament Studies published 30 years ago, T.F. Glasson argued that the origins of the early Christian expectation for Jesus’ return are to be found in the early church’s application to Jesus of Israel’s expectation that “the Lord will come” (Glasson 1988). The same thesis has been recently repeated by N.T. Wright, who argues that Paul – in the Thessalonian correspondence – was the first to apply Israel’s “coming of God” tradition to Jesus’ ultimate future, and thus produce the expectation of Jesus’ return (Wright 2013). The thesis of the present paper is that Glasson and Wright are correct to identify Israel’s theophany tradition as a major source of early Christian parousia expectation, but that Jesus himself was the first to apply this tradition to his own future. In terms of method, the paper follows T. Holmén’s “continuum approach,” and so locates Jesus’ expectation within the continuum of Jewish and early Christian eschatologies (Holmén 2007, 2014). In addition, with a growing number of scholars, the paper eschews the attempt to get back “behind” the Gospels to Jesus’ vision (Keith and LeDonne 2012). Instead, the paper applies D.C. Allison’s criterion of “recurrent attestation” to build a composite picture of the kinds of things Jesus most likely said (Allison 2010). The argument proceeds in two stages. First, the paper highlights that on both sides of Jesus, chronologically speaking, the Scriptures of Israel and later Jewish texts, and the early Christian texts, both envisage a great and final theophany, with the significant development that the early Christian texts place Jesus at the centre of this event. Second, the paper catalogues thirty-one Gospel texts, spread across all four Gospels, which provide testimony that Jesus applied Israel’s theophany tradition to his own ultimate future. The paper shows that in these texts the Gospels variously have Jesus speak of own future in terms of the major features of Israel’s “coming of God” tradition, namely : i. “the coming of the Lord”; ii. the “day of the Lord”; iii. cosmic convulsions or transformation; iv. an angelic retinue; v. “power”; vi. “glory”; vii. “lightening”; viii. “fire”; ix. trumpet sound; x. resurrection and/or the gathering of the elect; xi. eschatological judgment; xii. eschatological warfare; xiii. fear or shame or mourning, and; xiv. eschatological feasting. In all of these ways, the Gospels repeatedly have Jesus speak of his own final advent in terms which evoke the "coming of God” tradition of Israel’s Scriptures. The paper reasons, following Allison’s logic of “recurrent attestation”, that this theme is so characteristic of Jesus’ teaching in the Gospels that it almost certainly reflects the “gist” of a significant element in his eschatological vision. The paper concludes that thirty years on from Glasson’s thesis, we need to move twenty years back: the origins of early Christian parousia expectation do indeed lie with the application of Israel’s theophany tradition to Jesus’ future; the first to make this connection, however, was not Paul, but Jesus himself.
|
"Everyone Who Sins is a Slave to Sin” (Jn 8.34): Sin in the Johannine Literature
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Murray J. Smith, Macquarie University, Sydney
At least since the influential studies of C.H. Dodd (1953) and R. Bultmann (1964), it has often been assumed that the Johannine literature contributes little to a Christian harmartiology beyond the understanding of sin as “unbelief”. Major commentaries on John, and monographs on Johannine theology, across confessional lines, rarely provide any discrete discussion of sin, and routinely omit “sin” in their catalogues of the major emphases in Johannine theology (Martyn 1968; Brown 1974; Haenchen 1984; Carson 1991; Moody Smith 1999; Moloney 2005; Köstenberger 2009; Bauckham 2015; Thompson 2015). Indeed, there does not yet appear to have been any major scholarly study of Johannine harmartiology. This is surprising, since the Gospel and letters of John explicitly frame their Christology and soteriology in terms of sin (John 1:29; 1 John 3:7-10), and include statements that might be taken as definitions of sin (John 8:34; 1 John 3:4). Addressing this lacuna in the scholarship, the present paper constructs a theology of sin in the Johannine literature (the Gospel and letters). In terms of methodology, the paper surveys the Johannine terminology for sin (ἁμαρτία; πονηρός; ἀδικία; ἀνομία), and sets John’s use of this language within wider Johannine teaching about “the world”, “the flesh”, “the devil”, and “death”, and the distinctively Johannine themes of “darkness”, “blindness”, “ignorance”, and “unbelief”. On this basis, the paper advances the thesis that while unbelief is at the core of John’s teaching on sin, his understanding of unbelief is multifaceted, mirroring his multifaceted understanding of faith. In particular, the paper presents a sixfold anatomy of sin in the Johannine literature. Sin is: i. powerful (involving enslavement to the power of sin); ii. propositional (involving the denial of truth about God and Christ); iii. personal (involving personal rejection of God in Christ); iv. practical (involving actual moral lawlessness); v. public (involving disowning God’s revelation in Christ before others), and; vi. persevering (involving continuing in one’s rejection of God in Christ). The paper concludes that the Johannine literature presents a rich and multi-dimensional harmartiology, and suggests that further attention to this theme promises to shed new light on other related aspects of Johannine theology (anthropology, Christology, soteriology, eschatology).
|
Intertextuality and the Direction of Dependence: Toward a Comprehensive List of Criteria
Program Unit: Intertextuality and the Hebrew Bible
Cooper Smith, Wheaton College (Illinois)
Despite some thoughtful criticism of such a scheme (Barton 2013; Meek 2014), the basic division between diachronic and synchronic approaches to intertextual analyses has proven useful and persistent (Dell and Kynes 2013; Kynes 2012). Miller, espousing such a bipartite division, describes recent trends of both approaches while outlining their methodological interests and obstacles (2011). One prevailing methodological problem in the diachronic analysis of biblical texts is the need to formulate an agreed-upon set of criteria for determining the direction of dependence once a literary relationship between two biblical texts is reasonably established (Schultz, 2015). Such a gap negatively affects interpretation since, in many cases, determining the direction of dependence can contribute significantly to the meaning of a given passage. Currently, most determinations for a direction of dependence are made on an ad hoc basis. The direction of borrowing is usually argued from the case at hand without any articulation of which criteria were considered or what criteria are even available for arguing the direction of borrowing. What is needed is a comprehensive set of criteria that can be used to argue for directionality in cases of borrowing, while understanding the persuasive power and limits of each argument. This study addresses this lacuna by identifying and cataloguing nine arguments used in recent scholarship to assert a direction of dependence between Isaiah and other books in the Hebrew Bible. Deductive attempts at a comprehensive list do not account for each of these nine arguments, which demonstrates the need for this inductive approach (Kynes 2012, Lyons 2009, Leonard 2008). This analysis focuses on four frequently-cited monographs that give focused attention to Isaianic parallels to other biblical texts: Tull Willey (1997), Sommer (1998), Schultz (1999), and Nurmela (2006). Each argument will be explained, illustrated from one of these works, and evaluated with regard to its logical soundness, the clarity of the textual example, and its implicit assumptions. This study takes a first step toward the goal of compiling a broadly acceptable and comprehensive list of arguments scholars can use in analyzing allusions throughout the Hebrew Bible. This list promotes methodological clarity and scholarly creativity—clarity by providing increased precision for the operative criteria in cases of dependence and creativity by suggesting additional avenues for arguing the direction of borrowing in future studies of inner-biblical dependence.
|
Liminal Spaces: Foreign Women as the Creators and Killers of Culture in Ezra 9, 10 and Nehemiah 13
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Terry Ann Smith, New Brunswick Theological Seminary
Ezra-Nehemiah is concerned with issues of identity where the holy seed serves as a major marker of identity. The portrait of mingling the holy seed with presumably unclean foreign women exposes the fear that the community has regarding the power these women possess to erase Judahite culture. Thus, the juxtaposition of zera haqodes with niddah presents an opportunity to examine the liminal space that foreign women inhabit as creators and killers of culture. Niddah can be understood as getting rid of the blood or separating the menstruant from the community or both. Curiously, blood, in particular menstrual blood, as it appears in the Levitical material occupies a liminal space because it is both a source of life and death and, therefore, perceived as a dangerous fluid. In Ezra-Nehemiah, foreign women occupy this liminal space as they represent life through the marriage and birth of children while simultaneously perceived as the killers of Judahite culture and, therefore, dangerous and must be expelled from the community. The emphasis on the holy seed is possibly meant to minimize the significance of foreign women in Ezra-Nehemiah. However, the opposite occurs as the writers’ attempt to erase these women draws attention to the power they possess as liminal figures, thus elevating rather than minimizing their appearance in the text. Finally, we ask whether these texts can aid contemporary conversations about the liminal spaces women hold in society including cultural perceptions in which blood and purity remain dangerous companions when describing women’s agency and power.
|
Monologically and Dialogically Sustained Discrepant Awareness in Joseph and Aseneth and the Greek Novel
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Tyler Smith, Université d'Ottawa - University of Ottawa
Thought representations in the Greek novels, as manifested both in dialogue and interior monologues, provide a narratological mechanism for creating and sustaining distinctions between illusion and reality, between "how things appear" and "how things are," so that later these distinctions may be resolved in the climax of a given narrative. Readers usually have access both to appearance and reality in the novels of Chariton and Xenophon, although Heliodorus and Achilles Tatius are more sophisticated in creating situations that involve discrepant awareness between their external narrators and their readers, as well as between characters in the narrative. This paper will assemble and catalogue the narrative techniques by which the Greek novels create discrepant awareness in monologue and dialogue, then compare the findings with the monologues and dialogues of the Hellenistic Jewish text Joseph and Aseneth, in order to gain a more textured appreciation of how the latter plays with the conventions of its novelistic genre with respect to the manufacture and resolution of discrepant awareness.
|
Oedipus, Jesus, and John 9's Man Born Blind: Recognitions and Reversals
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Tyler Smith, Université d'Ottawa - University of Ottawa
In the Poetics, Aristotle writes that the best tragedies involve complex plots, marked by both recognition (anagnorisis) and a reversal of one's fortunes (peripeteia), with Sophocles' Oedipus tyrannus offered as an ideal example (1452a31-33). While Johannine scholars have long observed parallels between Sophocles's Oedipus and the blind man in John 9 (e.g., Larsen 2008), the nature of the peripeteiai attendant on their respective recognitions have not been fully probed. This paper explores similarities and differences between the two representations of recognition. While the peripeteia attendant on Oedipus's anagnorisis casts his character into a tragic state of mind, the man born blind's moment of anagnorisis alters his situation from tragic to the good. His acquisition of the ability to see is the external sign of a reversal that has taken place on the cognitive plane of the narrative, making his character's anagnorisis a representative model for character recognition of Jesus as Messiah in the Fourth Gospel. Whether or not John 9 reflects the two-level social drama described by Martyn, an investigation of that chapter's literary and cognitive poetics reveals in the characterization of its central figure a drama-inspired blueprint for effecting peripeteiai away from psychic blindness and towards the Gospel's desideratum: a clear-eyed recognition of Jesus as God's Messiah.
|
Moving Forward on the Pastoral Epistles ECM
Program Unit: Novum Testamentum Graecum: Editio Critica Maior
W. Andrew Smith, Shepherds Theological Seminary
Work on the Editio Critica Maior edition of the Pastoral Epistles is underway. In the spring of 2015, our student volunteers at over a dozen institutions began producing transcriptions of the minuscule manuscripts of 1 Timothy. Three years later we have gathered transcriptions for a total of 292 Greek manuscripts of 1 Timothy and have made significant initial progress on transcriptions of 2 Timothy and Titus. In July of 2018, the editorial work began on 1 Timothy, which represents the first phase of the editorial process; phase two involves processing the data for 2 Timothy and Titus. This paper presents an overview of the work flow, a progress report, and the challenges of this project.
|
History as Heuristic: Acts, Apostle, and Intertext
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Zachary G Smith, Yale University
Scholars who propose the foundational nature of Acts for Christianity as a religion are also forced to admit its irrelevance as such for actual early Christian readers. Representative of the scholarly attempt to have one’s cake and it eat it too is C. K. Barrett’s oft-quoted dictum: “The fact is that the church of the next two or three generations after its composition did not know what to do with Acts” (C. K. Barrett, A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Acts of the Apostles [2 vols; Edinburgh: T & T Clark, 1994, 1998], 2:lxix-lxx). Barrett’s pithy remark simultaneously guarantees and erases Acts from its place in history, elevating Acts to such a lofty role that the early Christians simply were incapable of recognizing its place. Meanwhile, those who understand the true spirit of Christianity find in Acts the initial evidence of the Christian historical worldview, lying dormant in the NT until its full manifestation in the fourth century, the Protestant Reformation, or even perhaps the Enlightenment.
Yet by ignoring the manner in which Acts functioned for its earliest readers, scholars have fashioned early Christians into modern historicists avant la lettre, who fall short of historicity in practice but not in aspiration. This paper will correct the portrait of the early reception of Acts by highlighting the actual interpretive practices of its second and third century readers. Such interpreters did, in fact, read and cite Acts with some frequency, and in various ways they assigned to Acts a crucial role in their own theological projects.
In this paper, I consider treatments of Acts by Irenaeus, Tertullian, Origen, and others that rely on the narrative of Acts for a biography of Paul, an apologetic against “heretical” opponents who used Paul, or a formal commentary on the Pauline corpus. While not surprising that readers would have connected the Lukan and epistolary Paul, I highlight the degree to which this correlation was textual rather than historical. In particular, readers capitalized on and exploited divergence between the Lukan and epistolary Paul in order not to defend the former so much as to explain the latter. The status of Acts follows its intertextual function, and its ability to explain or constrain the Pauline epistles—essentially a literary or intertextual appeal—was a primary component of its authoritative pull.
Put simply, in its earliest surviving readings, we are faced not with the remnants of a lost debate where Acts had already attained some authoritative status. Rather, we see the actual construction of the authority of Acts by means of textual imbrication, or what Jonathan Z. Smith termed “sacred persistence.” I endeavor to show that early readers utilized Acts as a supplement, crucial not for its intrinsic value but its interstitial ability to add, enhance, and transform the Pauline corpus. Further, this supplementary function was integral rather than incidental to its reception among early readers, who were concerned not so much with the theological meaning of history but more pressing projects of scriptural authority and interpretation.
|
A Hermeneutical Approach Against Whiteness: Barth’s Dialectical Interpretation of Romans 2
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
Shannon Smythe, Seattle Pacific University
Theologian Willie James Jennings has defined whiteness as a deformed formation toward maturity created at the sight of Christian missions and argues that Christianity must begin to form places that offer a different building project toward maturity. Indeed, Jennings is hopeful that “a Christianity born of the colonialist wound” might “speak to itself” in ways that reckon “with the ramifications of colonialism for Christianity identity” (The Christian Imagination: Theology and the Origins of Race, 291).
This paper provides a constructive reading of Barth’s interpretation of Romans 2 in the second edition of his Romans commentary in conversation with his treatment in CD IV/3.2 of the sinful human attempt to construct a worldview (Weltanschauung) in opposition to the saving activity of Jesus. I argue that Barth, as a dialectical theologian, provides western Christianity with a hermeneutical approach against whiteness grounded in a Reformational theology of justification by faith alone. Understanding Barth’s theology as dialectical allows us to connect his focus on the event of justification in the freedom of God’s grace with his concomitant refutation of the colonialist logic of the Christian missionary enterprise. In this way, Barth’s dialectical approach to theological interpretation of Scripture is a resource for constructing Christian identity free of whiteness.
First, Barth’s reading of Romans 2 centers on the utter strangeness and freedom of God who can and does make Godself known as the Judge of all people. In contrast, whiteness attempts to replace God as the Judge of all people by establishing human-based standards and classifications for all people. According to Barth, when humanity wants to resist the Word of grace as the Word of God, humanity grasps after the possibility of a worldview, of which whiteness is a supreme, if not the supreme example. A worldview allows us to view and make images of the world and its people according to our own chosen metrics. Second, against a worldview of whiteness and following Romans 2, Barth centers the hope of all people on the complete abandonment of all human or worldly attempts at righteousness. In opposition to this, whiteness deforms righteousness by God alone by offering an idolatrous vision of maturity that entails an abandonment of the hope of God’s disruptive action in the world to save. Here, Barth aptly notes the power of a worldview lies in its ability to relativize and blunt the edge of the absolute claim of God’s Word of grace on all people. Third, in listening to the witness of Paul, Barth locates Jesus Christ as the place of judgment of all people by God so as to affirm that only the new human person created by God for God is righteous before God. Whiteness creates humanity in its own image, thereby denying a righteousness that comes from God alone.
|
Parallelomania and the Origin of Baptism
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Benjamin J. Snyder, Asbury Theological Seminary
This essay exposes the ideological biases characterizing recent research into the origin of Christian baptism as scholars variously root its origin in their preferred religion (Greco-Roman, Jewish, or Christian). This is made possible in part through the invented categories of various types of “baptisms” and a preference for Christian baptism, which controls comparison. To remedy the distortion of sources, I propose that a robust implementation of the comparative method is necessary, including clarification on what, why, and how we compare.
|
Bed, Bath, and Burial along the Via Latina: The Archaeological Context for the Flavia Sophe Inscription
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Greg Snyder, Davidson College
The presentation will discuss the immediate environment of the Flavia Sophe inscription, and look at a few other structures in the neighborhood where baths and burial sites are closely associated.
|
Children in Famine Biblical Narratives: A Psychoanalytic Approach
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Flavia Soldano-Deheza, Asociación Bíblica Argentina ABA
In order to tackle the concept of childhood in Biblical texts we will theorize from the psychoanalytic perspective that considers culture as the discourse of the Other: the symbolic dimension of the social where the psychic life is woven. According to this theoretical frame, childhood is defined as the locus occupied by children within the mentioned social articulation.
An observable constant for this approach is the infans’ reliance on the significations that adults grant them for his/her subsistence, a concept in which no historical period is excepted. In all cases, the different constructions of childhood are postulated in the symbolic and imaginary modes pertaining to every time and place.
From this point of view, we are interested in approaching some narratives that would allow us to inquire into social assumptions that imply childhood. We will examine cases of famine and cannibalism in 2 Kngs 6:24-31 and Josephus B. J.6:199-219, challenging the concept of instinct and love as an articulator in the mother /offspring relationship. We will analyze the direct discourse of these women in Hebrew and in Greek, emphasizing reiteration and difference in linguistic uses.
|
The Abraham Narratives and Their Message of Hope in Genesis Rabbah and John Chrysostom’s Homilies on Genesis
Program Unit: Theology of the Hebrew Scriptures
Kris Sonek, University of Divinity
Can we read the Abraham narratives in Gen 12-25 as literature that offers hope and sustains individuals through periods of dejection and despair? I ask this question in the context of the recent proliferation of reception studies of Genesis. While authors such as Soloveitchik (2008), Levenson (2012), or Grypeou and Spurling (2013) analyse the dense fabric of theological themes of the Abraham cycle through the prism of Jewish and/or Christian history of reception with great sensitivity, it seems that relatively little attention has been given to the concept of hope present in and communicated by the stories of Abraham and his family.
This paper is part of a future project exploring the theme of hope in Gen 12-25 from various methodological angles. It begins by briefly identifying the characteristics of expectation, anticipation and confidence that emerge from the text interpreted in its exilic and early post-exilic contexts. Second, I present and examine the reception of the Abraham narratives in two works representative respectively of Jewish and Christian interpretation in late antiquity: Genesis Rabbah and John Chrysostom’s Homilies on Genesis. It is hardly possible to find two more divergent ways to interpret the Abraham cycle. The divergence of interpretation of these two texts in relation to the concept of hope as the central governing idea yields interesting insights into the dialectical relationship between rabbinic and patristic interpreters. There are numerous Jewish and Christian texts illustrating that intense relationship between exegetical traditions, but few are of more importance than commentaries on Gen 12-25, which give witness to the growth and diversification of Abrahamic traditions in both religions.
The paper argues that the concept of hope provides an important lens through which ancient Jewish and Christian theologians interpreted Gen 12-25. The way they understand, explicate, and apply the message of hope communicated by the text helps understand their respective theological positions. It also sheds light on the hotly debated question of the relationship between Jewish and Christian interpretative communities in late antiquity: are they well-defined groups fighting in terms of well-defined views (T. Herford, A. Segal), or are Christian theologians to be viewed as an entity within and enemy internal to Judaism (D. Boyarin), or is the tension between rabbinic Judaism and patristic Christianity based on political and socio-historical factors rather than theological ones (A. Schremer), or based on something entirely different?
|
The Book of Mormon's Use of Isaiah 53
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Joseph M. Spencer, Brigham Young University
Drastically underrepresented in the literature of biblical reception history is the use and interpretation of biblical texts in Mormonism’s unique sacred texts—the Book of Mormon. Not only does the Book of Mormon use (King James) biblical language as a way of presenting its story and message, it not infrequently quotes both short and long passages from the Bible and offers commentary on them. Unquestionably, the biblical voice to which the Book of Mormon gives the most sustained attention is that of (the Book of) Isaiah. This paper finds a foothold for a reception historical approach to the role played by the Bible in early Mormonism by looking at how the Book of Mormon outlines a unique interpretation of key verses in Second Isaiah’s famed song of the suffering servant.
Despite the persistent popularity of Isaiah 53 within the mainline Christian interpretive tradition, the Book of Mormon tends to privilege other Isaianic texts, which it appropriates in apocalyptic anticipation of a gathering of scattered Israel. In the one narrative it does dedicate to expositing the meaning of Isaiah 53, one finds extremely traditional elements but also remarkably nontraditional elements. On the one hand, it offers an interpretation of the Isaianic question, “Who shall declare his [the servant’s] generation?” (Isaiah 53:8) along patristic lines, understanding it to refer to the mystery of Jesus Christ’s incarnation. In the context of the Book of Mormon’s antebellum appearance, this interpretation was traditional, but arguably so traditional as to appear quaint to most readers. For those who first encountered the Book of Mormon, its approach to Isaiah would on this account at first appear startlingly conservative. On the other hand, it offers an interpretation of the Isaianic claim that “he [the servant] shall see his seed” (Isaiah 53:10) along entirely heterodox lines, understanding it to refer to a pre-Christian church of anticipation, a group of believers before Christ’s advent who receive the promise of rising with him at his resurrection. In the context of the Book of Mormon’s publication, this interpretation ran directly against the lines of traditional interpretation, questioning the longstanding distinction between obscure messianic anticipation in the Old Testament and clear typological retrospection in the New Testament.
The Book of Mormon’s approach to Isaiah 53 thus articulates a simultaneously traditional (i.e., Christological) and radical (i.e., revisionary) approach to the text that opens onto a larger contestation of the basic Christian understanding of the relationship between the two testaments. It also helps to lay a foundation for understanding how the Book of Mormon addresses other Isaianic texts—always with an eye to apocalyptic anticipation. Especially, though, it clarifies the basic hermeneutic stakes for Mormon approaches to biblical texts, consistently revisionary because never far enough from the interpretive mainstream to be dismissed as incomprehensible.
|
The Apocalypse in the Context of Early Mormonism
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Joseph M. Spencer, Brigham Young University
Given the popularity of John’s apocalypse on the fringes of American Christianity, it isn’t surprising to find early Mormonism in the 1820s and 1830s invested in sorting out its meaning and relevance. The uses early Mormon sacred texts made of Revelation are, however, extraordinary and worthy of notice. Rather than taking the text as sacred and inviolable, calling for the difficult work of interpretation (as in the Millerite movement a few years later), early Mormon texts assert that what’s most crucial about John’s apocalypse is how it records an experience all human beings are expected to seek and then to have. This paper explores two Mormon texts recorded respectively in 1829 and 1832 that trace the development of one peculiar modern cultural context for the use (rather than just the interpretation) of the Book of Revelation.
In 1829, Joseph Smith dictated the Book of Mormon to scribes, a text that intersperses its complex narrative with a few key claims about John’s Apocalypse. At the outset of the volume, a Jerusalem-born prophet figure from the sixth century before Christ has John’s visionary experience, according to the text, although he is required not to record most of the experience in his account of it. This requirement is apparently motivated by the fact that this prophet’s “plain” style of discourse would make problematically clear what has been obscured by the European Christian tradition about the basic meaning and import of John’s biblical apocalypse. Then, a thousand years later and at the close of the Book of Mormon, another prophet describes another such experience (as having been had by another prophet). He does in fact write up an account of the experience, but he’s then divinely instructed to seal it up, explaining to readers that it isn’t to be made available until they—especially those hailing from the European Christian tradition—have themselves had John’s apocalyptic experience themselves. Only at that point is the Book of Revelation to be “unfolded” in the eyes of all people.
Three years after the dictation of the Book of Mormon, Joseph Smith and an associate (Sidney Rigdon) claimed to experience an apocalyptic vision themselves, which they were then commanded to describe in a text that drastically revised much of early Mormon theology. Now canonized as Section 76 of the Doctrine and Covenants, this text arguably presents itself as Joseph Smith’s (and his companion’s) experiential confirmation of the promise within the Book of Mormon. Smith’s written account of the vision repeatedly borrows language from John’s apocalypse in its attempt to describe the experience, indicating the way it serves to work as another “edition” of the Book of Revelation. Together with the Book of Mormon, this visionary text outlines a non-textual-because-experiential hermeneutic of the Book of Revelation. Rather than a text to be interpreted, it is a record of an experience to be had.
Early Mormonism’s redirection of Revelation’s meaning from interpretable text to producible experience marks a unique and interesting moment in the book’s reception history.
|
The City that Does Not End: On Migration and Immutability in Hebrews
Program Unit: Islands, Islanders, and Scriptures
Althea Spencer Miller, Drew University
In Hebrews 13:8, Jesus Christ is tantalizingly described as being the same in the past, the present, and the future – a trans-temporal existent. Perceived in ontological terms such a claim can be interpreted as representative of a high Christology of Jesus’ divinity. This would be appropriate for Hebrews as the treatise avers Christ’s eternal existence from creation. Yet there are other insinuations throughout the treatise that interplay issues of unbounded temporalities with an existential nomadic consciousness and a multi-faceted Jesus. Jesus morphs as priest, God, and human, assonant with subtle temporal switches dispersed throughout the treatise. A theological chart and an atemporal chronology are borne in Hebrews by theological tropes of Jewish histories and temporal switches. There is an intensification of those switches in chapters 11 and 12 with implications for the averral of Jesus’ trans-temporal immutability. Arguably, Jesus’ trans-temporal constancy can be re-defined by those switches. It would be simple to regard those switches as simple contradictions or confusions in the author’s thought world. This paper argues, to the contrary, that Jesus’ trans-temporality is about complexities of time warps that are mediated in a conceptual frame of a time-bending ancestry conveyed through historical tropes and the litany of way markers in chapters 11 and 12.
Ancestry is therefore another conceptual frame for thinking about the work of the past in Hebrews. Time-bending ancestry functions to help ground the communities addressed by Hebrews. It also has implications for understanding Jesus’ immutability. But another concept is the treatise’s sense that this world is a temporary experience. There is a futuristic impulse that calls toward a “heavenly country” from a history of being strangers in an alien land. I prioritize this migrant subjectivity as a point of contact with postcolonial migratory experiences of instability and strategies of relocation and adaptation. These dynamics elucidate, not Jesus’ divine ontological immutability, but the importance of his trans-temporal function in generating cohesiveness and reassurance for a community caught in the crosswinds of migratory temporariness and the heritage of a changing past. In such a case, Jesus’ immutability is less about immutability but points to the migrant ancestral oriented subjectivity of the author’s thought world and methods of community definition and guidance.
|
Animals’ Economic Role in the Temple and Market as Reflected in Zooarchaeology and the Bible
Program Unit: Animal Studies and the Bible
Abra Spiciarich, Tel Aviv University
Subsistence strategies of the first millennium primarily focus on the use and exploitation of domesticated livestock (i.e., sheep, goat, cattle, and donkey) for secondary products, meat, agricultural labor, and depending on site as sacrifices. Jerusalem, a major cultic site in the Hebrew Bible, was no exception. The use of animals within Jerusalem’s differed between its neighborhoods, as well as, differed greatly from its neighboring rural countryside. Animals, as a form of wealth, were used as sacrifices and food. Their use in cultic sacrifices lends them to be a major source of revenue for the Temple. Additionally, the draw of people into Jerusalem, for the pilgrimage festivals (i.e., Sukkot, Shavuot, and Pesach) allowed for the local markets to prosper. Archaeofaunal remains along with the laws and antidotes found in the Hebrew Bible are the two main sources that can be utilized in order to understand the role of animals during the first millennium. This paper aims to explore the reality of animal use in the temple and market of a cultic capital through the lens of Zooarchaeology and biblical scholarship.
|
The Acts of John 87–105 (Vienna hist. Gr. 63 fol. 51v-55v): Is It a “Fragment”?
Program Unit: Book History and Biblical Literatures
Janet Spittler, University of Virginia
The Acts of John 87-105 (Vienna hist. Gr. 63 fol. 51v-55v): Is it a “fragment”?
|
The Minor Acts of Thomas and John 20:24–29
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Janet Spittler, University of Virginia
In the Minor Acts Thomas (or, more descriptively, the Acts of Thomas and his Wonderworking Skin), the apostle, while being flayed by leather cutters, prays to Jesus, harking back to their exchange in John 20:24-29. The apostle then explains and excuses his words with reference to Jesus’ own words in Mark 13:6 (and/or par.) This little-known apocryphal text, then, offers an interesting example of a narrative reinterpretation of canonical texts—in this case both the defense of a sometimes maligned character and the harmonization of johannine and synoptic Gospel accounts. This paper will present a brief introduction to the Acts Thom. Skin followed by an interpretation of its reception of John 20:24-29.
|
"Aramaeans" in the First Millennium BCE: The Multivalence of a Term
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
Adrianne Spunaugle, University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
The intersection of historicism and anthropological theory affords new insights into the social world of the ancient Near East. This is especially true when applied to first millennium BCE cuneiform texts. Identifying the place of "Aramaeans" in society at large has suffered in the past because of a desire for a single term to maintain consistent usage over the course of a millennium. Instead, when the term is allowed to evolve according to the historicism of the specific author(s), we discover that the term Aramaean is most likely an etic descriptor which has no meaning to those it supposedly describes. This paper illustrates the importance of utilizing methods developed by other disciplines in our attempt to piece together the social world of ancient Israel and her neighbors at home and in exile.
|
The “God of Israel” and the Politics of Divinity in Ancient Israel
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Michael J. Stahl, New York University
Since the discovery of the Ugaritic texts, there has developed a growing consensus in biblical studies that Israel’s original god was not Yahweh, but El, the old head of the West Semitic pantheon. However, El’s identification as Israel’s first god leaves important historical and religious questions unanswered. For instance, how did El function as Israel’s god in earlier periods? And when did Yahweh formally come to appropriate El’s identity as the “God of Israel,” and under what political conditions? This paper explores these questions through a fresh analysis of Genesis 33:18–20 and Judges 5:2–11 + 12–22, both of which appear to derive from authentic Israelite tradition, yet reflect different political and religious realities. In the light of ARM XXVI 24:10–13 and EA 74:29–31, I argue that Genesis 33:20 situates El’s role as “God of Israel” in the context of Israel’s robust collective political tradition as maintained at Shechem. By contrast, Judges 5:2–11 offers a programmatic assertion of Yahweh’s identity as the “God of Israel” in the service of a royal centralizing program, comparable to what appears in the Mesha Stele and other ninth-century West Semitic royal inscriptions. I therefore propose that Yahweh especially came to assume El’s role as “God of Israel” under royal auspices, as the Omrides sought to forge a new kind of Israelite identity in the ninth century, one grounded in the mutual interdependence of god, king, and people.
|
Finding the “God of Israel” in the Kingdom of Judah: 1 Kings 8:14–21*
Program Unit: Israelite Religion in Its Ancient Context
Michael J. Stahl, New York University
Although the Hebrew Bible ultimately is a product of Judah, its pages repeatedly identify the deity by the divine title “God of Israel.” Yet, in its very formulation, the “God of Israel” epithet explicitly identifies the deity as the god of a particular political community distinct from Judah, namely Israel. Judah’s cultural appropriation of Israel’s god thus raises important historical and religious questions. When did the formal title “God of Israel” first enter into Judah’s religious discourse, and through what channels? What political interests did the “God of Israel” appellation come to serve in its new Judahite political context? As part of a larger systematic analysis of the “God of Israel” title — a longstanding lacuna in biblical scholarship — I argue that the “God of Israel” name likely only entered into Judah’s religious life after the fall of the kingdom of Israel. Moreover, I contend that Judah’s appropriation of the “God of Israel” title especially served Judahite royal interests during the late monarchy. In particular, I locate the core of 1 Kings 8:14–21* — which programmatically identifies the Jerusalem temple as the location of Yahweh’s “name” as “God of Israel” — in late monarchic royal circles. Whereas other late monarchic biblical texts indicate that Yahweh was worshiped at the Jerusalem temple as “Yahweh of Hosts,” 1 Kings 8:14–21* reaches back to the time of Israel’s great King Solomon to assert a new political and religious reality, one in which the “God of Israel” dwells in Jerusalem alongside David’s royal house. By attaching the “God of Israel” epithet to one of Judah’s most central political and religious institutions — even as the first Jerusalem temple’s cult does not appear to have venerated Yahweh as “God of Israel” — 1 Kings 8:14–21* functions as royal propaganda, reinforcing the claim of Judah’s monarchy on Israel’s name.
|
Paul, the Apocalyptic Seer in Philippians 3
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Angela Standhartinger, Philipps-Universität Marburg
Beside few comments to “the day of Christ” (Phil 1:6.10; 2:16) and the eschatology of Phil 1:20-23 or Phil 4:5 the discussion on Paul as an apocalyptic thinker has never centered on Philippians. Yet, when one considers apocalyptic thought as revelation, Philippians 3 become the most intriguing part of the letter. My paper comments on my recent article in the book that read Phil 3:18-21 in the light of Jewish apocalyptic texts. Paul takes on the part of an apocalyptic prophet and predicts in tears the fate of the God’s enemies as well as the future of Gods people. What present afflictions might obscure, is actual reality if one reflects reality from a heavenly perspective.
|
Member of Abraham’s Family? Hagar’s Gender, Status, Ethnos, and Religion in Gal 4:21–31
Program Unit: Polis and Ekklesia: Investigations of Urban Christianity
Angela Standhartinger, Philipps-Universität Marburg
Hagar, the Egyptian slave of Sarah, mother of a patriarch’s son and blessed by divine epiphanies, can described both as multiply oppressed and multiply privileged. This paper undertakes an intersectional analysis of Gal 4:21-31 in the light of its biblical archetype and some of its Early Jewish retellings. By analyzing constructions of Hagar’s gender, status, ethnos, and religion in Jewish retellings of the biblical story Paul’s allegory appears in a new light.
|
From Varro to Damasus: Symbolic Reimagining and the Cult of the Martyrs
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Patrick Stange, University of Toronto
“It is true, Varro. For we were wandering and straying like foreigners in our own city and it was as if your books led us back home so we could recognize at last who and where we were.” (Cicero, Acad. 1.3.9)
In this famous quotation from the City of God (6.2), Augustine nods to the acumen of his Roman intellectual predecessors, specifically Varro’s ability in linguistic and cultic excavation to, “discover” what it meant to be Roman through the urban landscape of the city itself. Varro looms large as a worthy opponent in Book 6 of the City of God and, while Augustine does not respect his conclusions, he recognizes the power of Varro’s primary tools: the city of Rome and the Latin language. Augustine likely recognizes the rhetorical power of these tools as he has seen their efficacy a generation earlier in the work of Damasus I, who repurposed the cult of the martyrs using the palimpsestic quality of Rome so celebrated by late Republican intellectuals. In De Lingua Latina, Varro acts a tour guide to show Romans how to interpret the signs by which they already lived; it is only through philological inquiry can the city be made intelligible (Spencer 2014, 75). Unlike Varro, Damasus did not engage in a purely literary reimagining of the city but enacted very real topographical changes to make the Roman cult of martyrs accessible and the grammar of Christian Rome legible.
This paper argues that Damasus’ project to establish the cult of martyrs functioned in the same tradition of meaning making as Varro’s work noted by Augustine. I focus specifically on the verse epitaphs of Damasus, which serve as points of interest to situate the reader in the present through an exegesis of the past, much like the etymological excavation undertaken in De Lingua Latina. In the epitaphs, Damasus often interjects himself as the tour guide, reminding his audience that it was he who mapped Rome for proper veneration. His poetic style and tone differs greatly from the Republican religious project as well. Instead of the obscure etymologies and wandering exegesis seen in Varro’s work, the epitaphs pack a simple yet sharp hexametric punch, echoing the style of classical authors like Virgil and Ovid. The reader is often addressed directly, exhorting them to take part in the now publicly sponsored cult of martyrs (cognoscite [ED 7]; quaeris si [ED 62]; cognoscere debes [ED20]).
At a time when bishops often relocated the remains of martyrs to urban centres (translationes), Damasus’ project respects the early Christian history of the city by his insistence on in situ veneration, subsequently turning martyr veneration into a public affair (Sághy 2010, 25). It is this respect for the past through the veneration of the present that most strongly links his work with the Republican project of symbolic excavation. As these spaces were being becoming physically accessible through Damasus’ architectural interventions, these epitaphs make the ideology of the space accessible through a connection to both Roman and Christian history.
|
Dutch Contributions to Modern Exegesis: The Case of the Remonstrants
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Keith D. Stanglin, Austin Graduate School Of Theology
In addition to their well-known rejection of Reformed orthodoxy, the Dutch Remonstrants (or Arminians) also reflect the shift that was taking place in approaches to Scripture. This paper will summarize the views of the three most prominent Remonstrant theologians of the seventeenth century—Simon Episcopius, Étienne de Courcelles, and Philip van Limborch—on topics such as the inspiration and historical reliability of Scripture. Notably, their emphasis on the use of “right reason” in biblical interpretation, controversial at the time, would become standard fare by the end of the seventeenth century.
|
Myth and/as Ideology: Josephus Reads Daniel in Rome
Program Unit: Bible, Myth, and Myth Theory
Sheldon Steen, Florida State University
Josephus’s retelling of Daniel has inspired significant scholarly attention, particularly his adjustment of the four-kingdoms schema in Daniel 2 to make room for the emergence of the Roman Empire. He also offers tantalizingly brief mention of the stone that, in Daniel, destroys the fourth kingdom and ushers in the divine, unending kingdom. Scholarly opinions of Josephus’s adaptation of the schema and the oblique reference to the stone has largely relied, even if not explicitly, on the work of James C. Scott on hidden and public transcripts, suggesting that it might betray a counter-imperial hidden transcript. In effect, most scholars see Josephus’s adaptation as yet another example of his ability to shrewdly communicate to two audiences at once, and a negotiation of what are assumed to be his contested allegiances. Building from the work of theorists such as Bruce Lincoln and Jean-François Bayart. I argue instead that Josephus’s adaptation of the schema ought not to be understood not as a mere negotiation of competing identities/allegiances, but is helpful in the study of the reshaping of myths according to the ideological concerns of interested actors, and how those discursive moves are then naturalized by interested actors. By reading Josephus’s reshaping of Daniel through Lincoln’s work on “myth as ideology” and Bayart’s on “operational acts of identification,” I argue that we can then make better sense of what Josephus is up to in actively constructing an identity that can make two seemingly competing claims at once.
|
A Material History of the Tura Papyri
Program Unit: Book History and Biblical Literatures
Blossom Stefaniw, German Research Council
A Material History of the Tura Papyri
|
Social Gender and the Hebrew Personal Nouns ’iššah and ’iš
Program Unit: Philology in Hebrew Studies
David E. S. Stein, Stellenbosch University
To understand the social-gender constructions depicted by the Hebrew Bible, scholars first need a reliable understanding of the wording used to describe persons. One of the Bible’s featured designators for human beings is the pair of terms _’iššah_ and _’iš_. Scholars tend to think of these nouns as denoting their referents mainly in terms of gender, by classifying them as “women” or “men,” respectively. This paper contends, however, that what these noun labels actually tell us about social gender may well be different than the conventional wisdom suggests. To illustrate, we will examine two types of linguistic usage. The first is the construction that combines _’iššah_ with a substantive in apposition, such as _’iššah zonah_ (e.g., Josh 6:22; usually rendered “harlot”). The second usage of interest combines the definite form _ha-’iš_ with a proper noun in apposition, such as _ha-’iš Mošeh_ (e.g., Exod 11:3; referencing Moses). In both types of expression, what meaning does our noun contribute? (After all, at first glance, its presence seems superfluous; wouldn’t the apposed term alone suffice? And if _’iššah_ is not disclosing the referent’s gender, then what is it telling us?) For both of these usages, I will posit meanings that index representation: “head of household” (who acts on behalf of the household) and “agent” (who acts on behalf of another party). Such relational meanings have strong arguments in their favor. The last part of this paper will examine the lexicographic method historically applied to our nouns. Two developments that stand out will be reviewed in turn. First, the place of social gender in the presentation of _’iš_ has shifted over time. The earliest biblical dictionaries in Hebrew (starting with Ibn Saruq, more than a thousand years ago) begin their entry by calling attention to our noun’s gender-inclusiveness. In contrast, the entry in many modern dictionaries—whether composed in Hebrew or in other languages—start with our noun’s semantic opposition to _’iššah_, which emphasizes its gendered aspect. I will offer a possible reason for that shift in focus. Meanwhile, in a related development spanning more than seven centuries, the semantic contribution of our two nouns has been quietly debated. I will outline that debate—and situate it within scholarly commitments to opposing lexicological approaches. The latter have been called “maximalism” versus “minimalism” when attributing meaning to words. Recounting that debate will underscore how difficult it is to ascertain what words mean in an ancient language.
|
How to Do Things with Prophecy: Reading Prophetic Actions in the Light of J.L. Austin
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Elizabeth Stell, Oxford University
The Hebrew Bible depicts prophets punctuating their lives and their spoken oracles with scenes of particular behaviour which the text marks out as significant and meaningful. From smashing a pot (Jeremiah 19:1-13), to tearing a new coat (1 Kings 11:29-31), or even engaging in a marriage (Hosea 1:2-9), the actions may be extensive or momentary, complex or as simple as abstaining from action (Ezekiel 24:15-24; Jeremiah 16:1-9), and they may be performed by the prophet or at prophetic instruction (2 Kings 13:14-19; Jeremiah 51:59-64). Disparate as they are, the performances are unified by the prophetic role and their functions within the narrative which are not as clear as acts of healing.
Scholars have categorised them using labels such as ‘prophetic symbolic actions’ and have examined them as adaptations of a magical form, as non-verbal communication, as instances of street theatre and as events comparable to cultic dramas. Numerous explanations attempt to access the function of the actions and, to some extent, the efficacy which the texts claim for them. However, the breadth of the actions in question complicates such attempts to analyse or even to define the category itself.
This paper attempts to show a framework for treating the prophetic performances which asks the question of efficacy without presupposing that the answer will be precisely the same for each action. That framework comes from J.L. Austin’s Speech Act Theory. Austin’s work ostensibly focuses on the potential for language to operate outside the realm of truth and falsehood, to achieve something by ‘(conventional) force’ as part of a broader situation. Austin’s work allows us to think in an analogous way about prophetic actions. Some prophetic performances are literally speech acts (such as naming in Isaiah 8:1-4; Hosea 1:4-9) but all are presented as meaningful and often communicative, like speech. Austin’s work allows broad discussion of the performative dimension and to think about what it is that the prophets ‘do’ in these scenes. Taking Austin’s theory as a guiding framework, the approach to prophetic action and performance can be deepened and nuanced.
I shall demonstrate two major dimensions through this method. First, as I have begun to suggest, prophetic actions cannot be confined as a category but participate in spheres beyond the traditionally ‘prophetic’. Not only can they be communicative, but they engage in the ritual, the divinatory, and the magically efficacious. Second, I move into an attempt to bring a more particular insight into the prophetic from the very variety of the actions performed by prophetic figures and the way they are entwined with each other as well as with prophetic life (see particularly Isaiah 8). These imply a range in the prophetic role on the one hand but also a deep interaction creates prophetic life and prophetic effect. In Isaiah 20, for example, the prophet who walks naked creates for an audience a shocking depiction of captivity but brings that into his own life, engaging in the world of sign creation and understanding which is seen in divination.
|
Fear Appeals, Maladaptive Responses, and the Apocalypse of John
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Alexander E. Stewart, Tyndale Theological Seminary
This presentation will utilize social scientific research on maladaptive responses to fear appeals to heuristically examine how John’s Apocalypse alternatively exacerbates the danger of maladaptive responses while guiding hearers towards the author’s intended response. It will conclude with reflection on how John’s threats would have likely been received by the various Christian factions he addresses throughout his Apocalypse.
The Extended Parallel Process Model (EPPM) has proved foundational for social scientific study of fear appeals over the past three decades. Among other things, it attempts to explain why fear appeals fail. Fear appeals often backfire because the emotion of fear is double edged. On the one hand, fear is important to jump-start the threat assessment evaluation process and it motivates individuals to find solutions to alleviate the fear (danger control processes). If there is too much fear, however, and if response and self-efficacy is not high enough to inspire confidence and hope the fear will lead to maladaptive defensive responses.
Studies demonstrate that, in general, higher fear leads to more effective persuasion. There is a limit, however, and, at some point, depicted fear leads to diminishing returns. Overloading an individual with fear appeals won’t automatically lead to a negative response to the message but can cause a numbing effect. In addition to simple message rejection, individuals may engage in maladaptive responses such as self-exemption, normalizing the harm, or counter arguments which often involve an attempt to discredit the message or source credibility.
Defensive reactions can be alternatively categorized as avoidance (ignoring fearful beliefs or information), denial (refusing to accept the truthfulness of fearful beliefs), cognitive reappraisal (fearful beliefs are accepted as true but additional beliefs are brought in to decrease the threatening nature of the beliefs), and suppression (suppressing or inhibiting fearful thoughts from conscious awareness). When the weight of evidence makes avoidance and denial impossible, individuals often still employ cognitive reappraisal to minimize fearful emotions.
Maladaptive defensive reactions, however, are not just triggered by excessive fear of danger; health-promoting information can trigger defensive reactions by challenging an individual’s assessment of themselves as adaptively and morally adequate. Fear-inducing threatening health information may not trigger defensive reactions because an individual is afraid of the consequences, per se, but because the individual does not want to deal with the implications of somehow falling short or not being good enough and the emotions of shame and guilt which result from negative self-evaluation.
John freely employs fear appeals in his apocalyptic message to various Christian groups at the end of the first century.
This presentation will use social scientific research on maladaptive responses to fear appeals as a heuristic tool to probe how various Christian hearers would have responded to John’s message.
|
Pathos in the Cosmos of Amos: How Creation Rhetoric Shapes the Emotions of Ethical Character in the Old Testament
Program Unit: Bible and Emotion
Alexander Coe Stewart, McMaster Divinity College
(1) In Western modernism, there is a prevalent tendency to pit affective “emotions” against intellectual “reason” and to think that emotions are nothing more than irrational, private, and passive feelings that have little role in grounding morality/ethics. However, in the prophetic books of the Old Testament, for example, there is quite the contrast: Although the emotional terms and categories in Hebrew never overlap precisely with ours, emotions in these texts are neither private nor passive, nor are they devoid of ethical importance. They are rather active, bodily, relational stances that are arguably at the heart of ethical (and unethical) responses in the public sphere. There is a reciprocal relationship in the texts between physical bodies of the created world and emotional dispositions that shape moral character of human communities. Cosmos and pathos shape each other in mutual ways, for better or worse.
(2) The book of Amos is an excellent example of how depictions of the physical world (“cosmos”) and embodied emotions (“pathos”) rhetorically shaped the character of the ancient Hebrew audience. Amos depicts withering vegetation and penitential humans alike as dressing for “mourning” (Amos 1:2; 5:16–17; 8:3, 8, 10; 9:5), which bodily expresses sorrow and evokes empathy, regret, and other public emotions designed to lead to further action. Throughout the book of Amos there are metaphorical and literal references to lions, earthquakes, fires, floods, and droughts that all evoke reverence, awe, and humility, ethical dispositions in light of divine judgment. Other nature metaphors leverage the embodied emotion of “disgust” at foul smells (Amos 4:10; 5:21), poisonous plants (Amos 5:7; 6:12), or defiled land (Amos 7:17), all to condemn Israel’s moral failures. Some agricultural and animal metaphors of could elicit horror, moral outrage, or a sense of poetic justice and moral wisdom, respectively. The creation rhetoric of the doxologies in the book (Amos 4:13; 5:8–9; 9:5–6) also elicit awe and an embodied disposition toward “justice” in its positive and negative senses as Yahweh both destroys and creates earthly life. Social justice is measured as lacking based on ecological justice, especially in Amos 5:8. Indulgent luxury is criticized through the sensuous language of feasting without emotional concern for the country’s ruin (Amos 4:1–3; 6:1–7), and divine emotion is evident at a few key places in the book.
(3) This presentation will explore the creation rhetoric of Amos to show how the embodied realities of the created order were assumed to evoke affective dispositions that could lead to ethical or unethical practices. Ecology and social justice are linked through embodied emotions. For my ethical methodology, I will use the categories of “character ethics” from William P. Brown and M. Daniel Carroll R., combined with an emphasis on embodied dispositions and practices found in the work of James K. A. Smith and in recent studies of emotions in the Bible. The resulting findings make contributions to the fields of Old Testament ethics, emotions and embodiment studies, and ecological discussions.
|
Threats of Divine Punishment in the Apocalypse of John: The Character and Intentions of the One Threatening
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Alex Stewart, Tyndale Theological Seminary (Amsterdam)
Threats of Divine Punishment in the Apocalypse of John: The Character and Intentions of the One Threatening
|
The Role of Fear and Hope in Drawing and Transcending Boundaries in the Apocalypse of John
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Alexander E. Stewart, Tyndale Theological Seminary (Amsterdam)
Revelation is a fearful book and John seeks to rhetorically utilize fear to shape the identity of his hearers by creating and maintaining boundaries between the communities within his influence and their broader cultural and religious environments. Fear is not the only emotion utilized by John in his rhetorical strategy and visions of salvation throughout the book also produce a strong sense of confidence and hope for those who were overcoming. Surprisingly, these hopeful visions describe the transcendence of the ethnic, social, linguistic, and economic boundaries which stratified the first century Roman world. These hopeful visions combined with a fearful attitude toward syncretism and moral laxity function rhetorically to motivate hearers of Revelation to transcend the traditional boundaries which divided society while maintaining high behavioral and theological boundaries for overcomes, the insiders who alone would be saved.
|
Is the Notion of "Sexuality" Inherent to Biblical Law?
Program Unit: LGBTI/Queer Hermeneutics
David Tabb Stewart, California State University - Long Beach
Does biblical law have a system of sexuality—such as the binary opposition of homo- and heterosexuality? Boyarin argues that the Hebrew Bible confirms Foucault’s thesis about the “history of sexuality”: The ancient world does not “divide off sexual practices” as identities separate from “the general categories of forbidden and permitted.” However, if sexuality is a “socially produced invention” does biblical law exhibit indigenous notions of sexuality? For if we set aside contemporary notions of homo-, hetero-, bi-, and asexuality and examine what sexual behaviors are made problems or celebrated in ancient Israel, a different sexual landscape emerges. The Bible does identify different objects of sexual desire from those commonly thought of in contemporary Western society: divine beings and animals. As to the former, (a) the relations of the “sons of God” (bene Elohim) with human daughters, (b) the attempted rape of angelic visitors to Sodom, (c) the molekh practices mentioned in Leviticus, (d) “whoring after” ghosts and familiar spirits, and (e) the same sexual metaphor applied to worshipping other gods, are seen both as “sexual” and as an identity—“idolater”—though we might name it ‘hierogamist’. Likewise, (a) “The Adam” (ha-adam) finding no mate among the animals, (b) the phallic snake approaching Eve, and (c) the commands against penetrating, approaching, and allowing the sexual approach of animals, reveal a similar pattern of interspecies relations. In these sexual behaviors the Bible contemplates desire as two-sided. It can flow in either direction—up and down the hierarchical chain of being—from the divine, to the human, and then to the beasts, or the reverse. This paper will argue that the Holiness Code (Lev 17-26) particularly, and biblical law diffusely, gesture toward a hierarchical system of sexualities—hierogamy, human sexuality, and bestiality—that evokes the realm of ancient Eastern Mediterranean mythologies.
|
Jesus and Other Priests: On the Masculinity of Ritual Efficacy of Priests in the Second Temple Period
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
Eric Stewart, Augustana College (IL)
Masculinity in the civilizations of the ancient Mediterranean world has often been read in terms of power, including the ability to dominate one’s inferiors. The more power a man is able to exercise, the more masculine he is. Gods, however, possess more power than human men. For that reason, one element of the cardinal virtue of justice is piety. The cases of Jesus in Hebrews, Simon in Sirach, and Jaddus in Josephus’ Antiquities, show three priests who provide mediation between the people and the God of Israel that saves the people. In each case, these priests are compared to other, lesser men. Each priest is able to offer an efficacious ritual action in order to deliver the people from threatening circumstances due, in part, to ineffective ritual action. Simon’s action as the exemplar of one who fears God is praised for “saving” the people of Israel through his efforts to fortify the temple (Sir 50:1-11) and to offer sacrifice (Sir 50:12-21). Hebrews presents Jesus as a more effective high priest than any other high priest in part because he does not exhibit “weakness” as do the other high priests. Jaddus/Jaddua is a priest singled out for efforts that resulted in “saving” the people is in his intervention of Alexander the Great’s conquest of Judah (Josephus, Antiquities 11.313-345). Obedient submission to a higher authority, for each of these priests, delivers efficacious ritual action that results in the salvation of the people.
|
Weaponizing Scripture: The Use of the Samaritan Pentateuch in the Catholic-Protestant Debates
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Joseph Kyle Stewart, Gulf Coast State College
A century before the arrival of any manuscripts of the Samaritan Pentateuch to Western Europe, the Reformation was being fueled by a zealous endeavor for biblical research and originality of the written word. At the heart of this tension was the debate concerning which manuscript tradition was ultimately profitable for Christian teaching and practice in Christendom. On one side of the debate were Roman Catholic scholars who believed that the Greek manuscripts of the Septuagint were the only inspired and approved translation of the Hebrew Scripture available for Church doctrine. On the other side, were the newly emerged Protestant thinkers who believed that the original Hebrew manuscripts of the Jewish community were more accurate than their Christian counterparts and that they were closer to the scriptures that were used and read by Jesus and the Apostles. And as a natural outcome of these debates, the necessity for an intimate knowledge of the biblical languages and the subsequent collection of ancient biblical manuscripts became paramount for scholars as the two sides fought each other for supremacy in Christendom. It is in this context that the re-discovery and the following arrival of the Samaritan Pentateuch to Europe thrust these documents into the fray.
This paper seeks to trace the early history of the Samaritan Pentateuch in the context of the Reformation in Western Europe and demonstrate how these manuscripts were used by early scholars, on both side of the debate, to further supplement their rooted view of scripture. Throughout this paper, I will extrapolate how early attempts at textual criticism was employed upon these texts to not only to validate a particular side of the debate but to show how these efforts spurred a renewed interest by Christian academics to study not only the Samaritan Pentateuch but the Samaritans and their traditions themselves that had been lost to the West for a thousand years. I will conclude my discussion by summarizing the scholarship of Wilhelm Gesenius concerning the Samaritan Pentateuch and how his suppositions proved detrimental for the study of the Samaritan Pentateuch in biblical criticism for decades to come. It would take until the discovery and ensuing study of the Dead Sea Scrolls to re-vitalize the field once again for the Samaritan Pentateuch in biblical scholarship.
|
The Origin of Evil and Subordinate Creators: Philo’s Exegesis of Gen 1:26 in Context
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Tyler A. Stewart, Lincoln Christian University
Philo’s view of evil was profoundly influenced by Greek philosophers. Like his contemporaries, Philo followed the Platonic axiom that God, by definition, cannot be the cause of evil (esp. Opif. 75; Fug. 63; Mut. 32; Abr. 143; QG 1.55, 100; QE 1.23). Yet Philo’s strong monotheism (esp. Leg. 2.2) appears to give the Alexandrian hesitation about identifying a superhuman cause of evil. Famously, in his exegesis of Gen 1:26–27 Philo draws on the creation myth of the Timaeus to identify the source of human capacity for moral evil with the activity of subordinate creators (Opif. 72–75; Conf. 168–183; Fug. 68–72; Mut. 30–31). The primary function of Philo’s interpretation is to argue that God cannot be the source of evil. But these co-creators remain a mystery. Can the subordinates be further identified? What exactly are they responsible for creating? To answer these questions Philo’s exegesis of Gen 1:26 (Opif. 72–75; Conf. 168–183; Fug. 68–72; Mut. 30–31) is compared with contemporary views of angels and daimons/souls causing evil. The comparison focuses on the Book of Jubilees and Plutarch. The goal of this analysis is to reveal how Philo’s exegesis compares to contemporary interpreters, one of Plato (esp. Plutarch, De an. Procr. 1014d–1015) and one of Moses (esp. Jub. 10:7–14) to see if the comparison produces insight into Philo's view of the subordinate creators.
|
Apollo in Hellenistic Judaism and Early Christianity
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Olivia Stewart Lester, Oxford University
This paper considers Jewish and Christian ambivalence toward traditions about the god Apollo in texts and material culture during the first four centuries CE. Many Jewish and Christian texts from this period, including Philo’s Legatio ad Gaium and De decalogo, the Fourth and Fifth Sibylline Oracles, Revelation, the Acts of the Apostles, and Clement’s Protrepticus, subvert traditions about Apollo, particularly as he is considered a source of prophecy. Several of these texts target Apollo’s shrine at Delphi in particular, and participate in larger economic and sexualizing polemics against Apollo’s prophecy, also found in Greek and Roman texts such as the Life of Aesop and Lucan’s Bellum Civile. Jewish and Christian literary resistance to the prophecy of Apollo becomes more significant when we consider it alongside narratives about prophecy’s decline in Judaism and Christianity, and narratives about the decline of prophecy at Apollo’s shrine at Delphi (such as those found in Plutarch). The texts under consideration in this paper argue for the persistence of prophecy as a literary strategy in Hellenistic Judaism and early Christianity, and the ongoing cultural significance of prophetic rivalry in the ancient Mediterranean. Recent scholarship on material culture, however, complicates the picture of Jewish and Christian interactions with Apollo in this period. Sun imagery, of the kind often associated with Apollo, appears in numerous Jewish synagogue mosaic floors, including those from Sepphoris and Hamat, and it also occurs in the Mausoleum of the Julii under St. Peter’s basilica. This paper reassesses the relationship between Jewish and Christian literary resistance to Apollo as a prophet or a source of prophecy and the more hospitable adoption and reworking of sun imagery of Apollo in Jewish and Christian mosaics. The ambivalence with which Jewish and Christian texts and material culture adopt some features of Apollo traditions and reject others speaks to the complex and ongoing negotiations of Hellenistic Jews and early Christians with rival claims to divine revelation, even after the so-called “decline of prophecy.”
|
Prophecy, Pseudepigraphy, and Collection: The Making of the Sibylline Oracles
Program Unit: Book History and Biblical Literatures
Olivia Stewart Lester, Loyola University Chicago
This paper considers the production and collection over time of the pseudepigraphic Jewish-Christian Sibylline Oracles alongside legends about the destruction and re-collection of the Roman sibylline books. Traditions about the Roman sibylline books, found in the works of Dionysius of Halicarnassus and Suetonius, include three instances of book burning in the life of the collection. The first act of burning was done by an old woman, rebutted by the Roman king Tarquinius in her attempts to sell him her oracles. In response, she burned portions of the book until he finally realized their worth. These legendary lost oracles were never recovered. In 90 BCE, the temple of Jupiter Capitolinus that housed the collection was burned down, and the oracles were destroyed. So the Romans collected new oracles from locations throughout Italy and Asia, although some of them were deemed to be spurious. During the reign of Augustus, Suetonius relates that he collected and burned books of Greek and Latin prophecy. Augustus destroyed portions of the Sibylline books, and preserved other portions. The legendary history of Roman sibylline prophecy, then, is characterized three times by destruction through burning. In one instance, after the burning of the temple of Jupiter, new oracles were gathered in their place.
The Jewish-Christian Sibylline Oracles demonstrate some knowledge of their own identity as books and of these larger Roman sibylline traditions. This paper suggests that the repeated destruction, and less frequent reconstitution, of the Roman sibylline books may have encouraged the pseudepigraphic production of Jewish and Christian books over time, prophetic works which I take to be engaging in a calculating prophetic subterfuge of the Roman sibylline books through mimicry.
The modern history of the Sibylline Oracles includes their relatively early detection as fake by early humanists such as Isaac Casaubon, as Anthony Grafton has shown. They were never taken to be scripture, but they lost something further of their sacred character as inspired prophecy, once modern scholars determined their inauthenticity. And yet the Sibylline Oracles are their own kind of canon, despite being marked as spurious and marginal from the early humanists onward. They became an authoritative inspired collection over time, and they engage in endlessly varied and creative inspired scriptural interpretation. Relocating the collection within the larger ancient narrative of prophetic destruction and reassembly suggests yet another reason, in addition to the significance of role-play in Roman and Hellenistic educational practices and the popularity of pseudepigraphic prophecy in Second Temple Jewish literature, why Jewish and Christian writers may have produced and collected Sibylline Oracles.
|
Pecunia olet: What Stood behind the Roman Siege of Masada?
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Guy D. Stiebel, Tel-Aviv University
The Roman siege of Masada is seemingly one the most celebrated sieges of the ancient world. Much ink has been spilt over varied aspects of the siege; discussing its physical remains, the course of battle, its duration and above all the act of collective self-killing and the reliability of the historical narration by Flavius Josephus. Nonetheless, at the end of the day the siege was a result of a Roman decision and it is rather surprising to learn how little has been devoted to date as to the motivation to lay siege on such a remote and isolated site. Examining this decision from a Roman point of view, one is compelled to elucidate it, three years following the conquest and subsequently destruction of Jerusalem and two years following the triumph in Rome, which marked the official ending of the war.
The present paper wishes to offer a new context and a wider framework to this famous episode, indicating that the economic factor played a major role in the Roman decision then had been recognized before. The geographical location of Masada in close proximity to the site of En Gedi appears to be the key stone in the presented argument; one that lays weight to its flourishing perfume industry. The settlement and its balsam plantations, which in the year AD 70 had been the only location in the entire Roman empire, where this perfume – "second to none" – had been cultivated. The site that became a territorium of the Roman fiscus, one of two such sites in Judaea, apparently bore a significant importance not overlooked by both rivaling sides. A new reading of an ancient historical text, that joins the testimony of Flavius Josephus, appear to shed new light not only on the Roman motivation to besiege the remote site but also on the occurrences that took place at Masada at the very end of the siege.
|
Food on the Journey: The Rhetorical Use of Food Language in the Psalms of Ascents (Pss 120-134)
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Michelle A. Stinson, Simpson University
While Psalms 120-134 display a wide range of literary types, scholars have identified a variety of shared features among these fifteen psalms bearing the heading, ‘A Song of Ascents.’ These psalms are for the most part short compositions (contra Ps 132), making them easy to commit to memory. The subject matter of the psalms reflects concerns and interests of every day life, often drawing on agricultural realities (cf. Loren Crow). Building on Crow’s agrarian observations, this paper widens the study to explore the Collection’s use not just of images of food production, but food consumption as well. For in these Pilgrimage Psalms, food language pervades this Collection (Pss 124, 126, 127, 128, 129, 131, 132). In this paper, I will consider the rhetorical function of food language as a means to encourage a company of pilgrim as they journey to Jerusalem.
|
The Perfect Male: Priestly Bodies as Examples of Nonsubservient Masculinity
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
Jonathan Stökl, King's College London
In this paper I will start from the observation that priestly bodies in biblical and other ancient Near Eastern priestly texts are described as flawless and even as god-like (e.g., Leviticus 21, Consecration of a Priest of Enlil). This observation is contrasted with another masculinity: royal (warrior) masculinity, which is usually described as hegemonic. Both masculinities have a strong focus on physical attributes and physical performance. While royal masculinity is indeed described well with the term hegemonic and demands other subservient models of masculinity it leaves rhetorical space for a perfect priestly masculinity—which does not try to emulate royal masculinity. Instead these two masculinities operate side by side indicating that ancient Near Eastern constructions of gender are complex and diverse.
|
Song of Moses, Song of Deuteronomy
Program Unit: Book of Deuteronomy
Keith A. Stone, Center for Hellenic Studies, Harvard University
Models of the formation of the book of Deuteronomy abound, and in these conceptions, the Song of Moses (32:1–43) is usually considered to be a late addition, tacked on as if by chance to the end of the book. However, several of this poem’s distinctive themes and locutions are strikingly and organically reflected among what are usually considered to be the earliest parts of Deuteronomy. For example—the morally pivotal moment of satiety (32:15; see 6:11–12, 8:10, 12–14), the use of hypothetical speech (often to be avoided; 32:27; see 9:4, 28), or the phrase “[whom] they knew not,” which is riffed on in various syntactical ways (32:17; see 8:3, 11:2, 28, 13:3). There are others. Through an analysis of these reflections (which also count among the relatively unique features of the book of Deuteronomy), I argue that, even if the text of the Song was formally added to Deuteronomy only at a late time, the book as a whole was influenced by the Song from the beginnings of its development. Working within one model of the formation of Deuteronomy, Jon D. Levenson has written that “the exilic frame to [the Deuteronomic Corpus] is the sermon for which the Song of Moses is the text.” I propose that this characterization can be convincingly extended to the central sections of the book.
|
Requesting a Dividend of Hegemonic Masculinity: Esther’s Prayer in LXX Esther
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Meredith J. Stone, Hardin-Simmons University
In LXX Esther, a contest for power, glory, and hegemonic masculinity is waged between the kingdom of Artaxerxes and the kingdom of God, and the character of Esther is the primary site upon which the contest is waged. After briefly describing how Esther functions as the location of the challenge between God and Artaxerxes, this paper will argue that in her prayer (14:1-19), Esther requests a dividend of God’s masculinity in the form of courage (14:12), eloquent speech (14:12), and freedom from fear (14:19), and she disparages the dividends of Artaxerxes’ power and masculinity which she possesses and in which she participates. In doing so, Esther aligns herself with God in the contest and chooses to become God’s representative by performing disguised negotiation of Artaxerxes’ power on God’s behalf. Esther becomes liminal as a double object of both God and Artaxerxes, and gender liminal as she performs both femininity (e.g. 15:1-19) and masculinity. Like other characters who function liminally in LXX Esther (eunuchs, Vashti, and Mordecai) Esther’s liminality becomes the means of her subversive opportunity.
|
Ritual Objects and Proto-Idolatry: Productive Forgetting in Exodus 34:10–17
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Jenna Stover-Kemp, University of California-Berkeley
The theoretical underpinning of this paper will center the productive nature of forgetting in the maintenance of textual tradition, examining Exod 34:10-17 as a late text. This paper will focus on the use of and reference to various banned ritual objects, each of which reflects a remembering of a previously existing legal code. However, in order to remember these codes in this single textual addition, the author of Exod 34:10-17 must forget the individual functioning of each of the banned objects in their previous contexts. The impulse to collect ritual objects and ban them in one single text is a step toward the theological concept of idolatry, a category which requires the forgetting of object distinctions as the biblical text begins to be remembered as a whole.
|
Refugees: The Missing Element in Discussions of the Galilean Economy in the Roman Period
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
James R. Strange, Samford University
This paper asks if we are ready to propose a model to explain evidence of exchange at the villages and cities of Roman period Galilee. The debate turns on what provides the correct information on which to build the model: social models or archaeological data. This paper will argue that archaeology supplies the data, and that if they are properly constructed or adjusted, appropriate social modes can help us understand those data. Accordingly, we are not yet ready to propose a model, for some realities of Roman Galilee that are critical to our understanding have not received enough attention: namely, evidence of war refugee populations in 70 and 135 CE migrating from Judea following the First Jewish and Bar Kokhba revolts. In this paper, I argue that evidence of lamp production and distribution at the Roman period village of Shikhin in the Lower Galilee might supply evidence of these migrations, and that models derived from twentieth-century refugee and other migrant populations, properly adjusted, can help us understand the data.
|
Ephrem the Syrian’s Acrostic Theology
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Cody Strecker, Baylor University
One of the most distinctive formal features of Ephrem the Syrian’s madrashe, or teaching hymns, is the acrostic. The sheer number of acrostics within Ephrem’s corpus (one-fourth of his extant Syriac hymns) renders it a topic worthy of greater attention than it has yet received—as does the diversity and complexity of acrostics he employs: onomastics, monogrammatics, and even reverse alphabetics. To date, only one scholar, Andrew Palmer, has investigated at length the significance of acrostics within Ephrem’s poetry. Palmer's attempts to distinguish genuine stanzas from later accretions by means of repetitions within acrostic poems are a significant start, as are his identification of theological meaning within broken acrostics. However, his studies are restricted to Ephrem’s "Hymns on Faith" and "Hymns on Paradise." Furthermore, his arguments are based on the hypothesis that Ephrem consistently adheres to the rule of one stanza per letter. This paper argues that Palmer’s hypothesis does not hold across the rest of Ephrem’s madrasha cycles, but is instead on occasion subverted to theological effect.
In the course of its argument, the paper expands on Palmer’s work in three respects. First, it tests the applicability of his hypotheses on a further cycle, "Carmina Nisibena" 1-34. Since these hymns are peculiar within Ephrem’s corpus in addressing events within the imperial and ecclesial histories of Nisibis and Edessa, examining them will reveal how Ephrem’s formal choices intersect with drastically different content. Second, the paper contextualizes Ephrem’s acrostics among other Near-Eastern examples, specifically the biblical acrostics found in Psalms and Lamentations, and Manichaean works such as the "Hymn to the Father" and "Living Gospel." Ephrem saw himself as a spiritual inheritor of King David’s psalmnody and Mani was one of the three primary heresiarchs against whom Ephrem wrote his polemical hymns. Thus, each of these provides a necessary point of reference as the place of acrostics within Ephrem’s poetics is discerned. Finally, this paper interprets Ephrem’s onomastic acrostics—including one heretofore unrecognized by scholars—as an aspect of Ephrem’s theology of divine names. By testing and extending research into Ephrem’s acrostic hymns, the paper argues that Ephrem’s acrostic theology works as a principal vehicle within his project of poetic encounter with divine revelation.
|
Salomania: Veils, Vampires, and the Evolution of Salome in Modern Popular Culture
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Gail P Streete, Rhodes College
Mention the name, “Salome,” to practically anyone, and their reaction will be, “Dance of the Seven Veils?” This dance became closely associated with the girl who danced before Herod, at her mother’s prompting, resulting in a rash vow by a drunken king that leads to the beheading of John the Baptist. Unnamed in the gospels of Matthew and Mark, the only places in the Bible where she appears, she perhaps never danced at all, let alone the Dance of the Seven Veils. Nonetheless, it was this brief stage direction, “She dances the Dance of the Seven Veils,” in Oscar Wilde’s 1891 play, “Salome,” that fixed the association of a nubile femme fatale with an “Oriental” erotic dance. Wilde never described the dance, although Richard Strauss, who based his 1906 opera on Wilde’s play, did describe it in an appendix, written in 1920, but he omitted three of the veils. Did the playwright and the composer assume everyone knew what the dance was, as exotic “Oriental” dances were already appearing on the American vaudeville and Parisian cabaret stages? Or did dancers freely adapt Wilde’s and Strauss’ suggestions to what was emerging as “the Salome dance” or “the Jewish dance” on popular stages, to such an extent that its frequent appearance and popularity was characterized as “Salomania”?
The best-known performer of the “Salome dance” was the Canadian Maud Allan, although the American Loïe Fuller performed her own two versions of it, one that depicted Salome as an innocent girl (a flop) in 1895 and one that bowed to popular appetites and portrayed her as a femme fatale (1907). Allan went more in the direction of the latter, and was wildly popular, especially in England, until a strange and abrupt end came to her career, through a libel trial in which not only she but Salome was accused of lesbianism and vampirism. This accusation, from a British M.P., Noel Pemberton-Billing, backed up by the bizarre medical opinion of a physician, was perhaps influenced by a novel by Joseph Sheridan Le Fanu (1871), featuring the first female vampire, Carmilla, who preyed primarily on women. Salome and her dance re-emerged in film in the early 20th-century, played by an actress known as “the Vamp,” Theda Bara (1918). A vampirish Salome (portrayed as promiscuous but heterosexual)Salome Agrippa, re-emerges in the popular TV series of the early 21st century, “True Blood.” This paper attempts to show how core assumptions about Salome and her “deviant sexuality,” which emerged from literature, opera, and theatre, were transformed in popular culture into the figure of the “vamp,” the figurative and later the literal blood-sucking female vampire.
|
False Prophets, Sons of Belial, and Sins unto Death: First John’s Reading of Deuteronomy 13 as Eschatological Halakha
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Daniel R. Streett, Durham University
Because 1 John never directly quotes the Old Testament, it is often asserted that letter offers no real insight into the way that early followers of Jesus read their Scriptures. More recently, however, scholars (e.g. J. Lieu) have questioned this consensus by pointing to the extensive use of OT concepts, images, and symbols. In this paper, I supplement this challenge by proposing Deuteronomy 13 as the key subtext for the letter’s treatment of community opponents. Deuteronomy 13 describes “sons of belial” who go out to deceive their fellow Israelites by enticing them to transgress the covenant through idolatry. The text commands that such false prophets be put to death without mercy. I argue that 1 John 2:18–24 and 4:1–6—the key “opponent passages”—apply this OT text halakhically and eschatologically in order to shape the community’s own response to the secessionist crisis. Special attention is paid to a) elements in the text of Deut 13 which may have suggested an eschatological understanding of the text, b) other early Jewish uses of Deut 13, c) the relationship between the Deuteronomic subtext and the puzzling and abrupt injunction against idolatry which concludes the epistle (1 John 5:21), and d) how the Deut 13 subtext may inform our understanding of a classic exegetical crux, namely the “sin unto death” (1 John 5:16–17).
|
Back Where You Came From: Reading Genesis and Making Art with People Seeking Sanctuary in Sheffield
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
C. A. Strine, University of Sheffield
This paper arises from the Back Where You Came From project I co-directed with artist/art therapist Emilie Taylor. Together with six people seeking sanctuary in the United Kingdom, we read stories about migration in the Book of Genesis and these sanctuary seekers made a range of monoprints and ceramic vessels as a response. More than just aesthetically pleasing, these images hold the embodied knowledge of involuntary migration from all manner of horrifying experiences. They opened a new window into a phenomenon that permeates Genesis and enabled me to interpret its stories in a new and innovative fashion. In this paper, I shall use the Jacob narrative in Gen 25–33 and a selection of our artists images to highlight our work and results.
|
Seeking a Comforter: The Megilloth and the Diversity of Thought in Second Temple Literature
Program Unit: Megilloth
Megan Fullerton Strollo, Union Presbyterian Seminary
In recent years, scholarship has shifted from the understanding that the Megilloth is organized strictly for liturgical purposes to consider potential literary and thematic connections among the five books. Such work has provided a new lens through which to view the theological dimensions of these oft-overlooked biblical books. When viewed together, these books share some remarkable characteristics that in turn reflect a diversity of thought in the literature of the Persian and early-Hellensitic periods. This paper will focus on one thematic connection found within the Megilloth: comfort (Heb. naḥam). The theme of “comfort” which permeates throughout the five books highlights the multiplicity of theological perspectives in Second Temple literature. This paper therefore will examine “comfort” in the Megilloth on two levels: how comfort is understood by the various books within the collection and, in particular, who offers that comfort; and secondly, how their collective understanding relates to other Second Temple literature.
The first half of this paper will explore the theme of comfort in each book and make connections among the five books. Throughout biblical literature, comfort is offered to those who are grieving or in distress, often with the intention or desire to influence (often by the cessation of aforementioned distress or grief) the aggrieved individual or party (TDOT, 342). In the Megilloth, the theme of comfort is linked specifically to the tension between the prominence—and promotion—of human agency and the reality of a distant or even absent Deity. God is frequently perceived as distant, absent, or even hostile within the Megilloth; in the light of this reality, human characters are encouraged to be agents of kindness, goodness, love, generosity, and justice. The Megilloth together present the perspective that human beings must act to comfort those in mourning or distress when God perhaps fails to do so.
After examining the collection specifically, this paper will broaden the scope and consider how the treatment of comfort in the Megilloth relates to other Second Temple literature. In general, there appears to be a marked contrast between the Megilloth and other literature from these periods. For example, Second Isaiah presents a strong counterpoint to the Megilloth by affirming repeatedly that God is the one who acts to comfort (e.g., 51:3, 12, 19). This perspective is consistent in other Second Temple literature, particularly in other prophetic works and the Psalms.
Finally, the exploration of comfort as a theme in the Megilloth and other Second Temple literature makes perceivable the diversity of theological thought during the period. By recognizing the Megilloth as a collection of literature with shared thematic and theological perspectives, their theological perspectives are fortified and they become more than mere exceptions to the rule (i.e., the theological perspectives of prophetic and priestly sources).
|
Parables in Q or Parables in L?
Program Unit: Q
Justin David Strong, University of Notre Dame
A perennial question in Q studies is what, if any of the Lukan and Matthean Sondergut the authors drew from Q rather than from other sources or composed themselves. As this question relates to the parables tradition, Q scholars appear to be especially eager to claim several uniquely Lukan parables for Q, including The Friend at Midnight (Luke 11:5-10), the Rich Fool (Luke 12:13-21), and The Lost Coin (Luke 15:8-10). Arguments in favor of Q as the source of these Lukan parables involve establishing ties between them and other Q material on the basis of style, form, and their context (assuming Q follows Lukan order). Generally left aside, however, are the counter-arguments that would indicate that these parables are closely linked to other L material, especially the many other L parables. This paper seeks to establish that the aforementioned L parables were not part of Q by demonstrating that they form a cohesive whole with the other L material, sharing a common form, style and origin all their own.
|
Negotiating Identity in Civic Space: Acts 18:1–17 and the Salutaris Foundation Inscription
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Christopher Stroup, Boston College
Christ-followers negotiated their various places in the ancient city within and around material, civic topography, like other inhabitants of the city. The gods moved through cities in numerous ways as well—in processions, at sacrifices, during festivals and assemblies, and on coins. The regular and regulating movements of gods and their worshippers through space had the power to both perpetuate and alter civic identity.
This presentation compares the ways that the Salutaris Foundation inscription (IEph27) uses the movement of Artemis and her agents through the civic topography of Ephesus to perpetuate and alter Ephesian identity with the ways that the author of Acts uses the narrative movement of the God of Israel and his agent, Paul, to perpetuate and alter the identity of the Christ-following community in Corinth (Acts 18:1-17). Thus it explores how the Salutaris Foundation inscription and Acts us gods and their agents to legitimate identity change through narrative performance in geographical space.
Both the Salutaris Foundation and Acts share a focus on geographical movement and deploy movement through space to represent and remap religious and ethnic categories. Imagined geography thus provides both those responsible for the inscription and for Acts with a way to enact and legitimate identity changes, which are made to appear ancient and ancestral rather than innovative.
As Guy Rogers has persuasively argued, the Salutaris Foundation changed the way that Ephesians interacted with Artemis and their city by processing her image past the imperial temples first, by including images of the imperial family in her procession, and by excluding the ancestral protectors of Artemis, the Kouretes, from the festivities. This paper argues that in a similar way to the Salutaris Foundation, Acts changes the way that Christ-following non-Jews could imagine their place in the city through their interaction with the God of Israel and his Messiah by leveraging Paul’s movement from the Jewish synagogue to the home of Titius Justus (18:7), the benefaction of Crispus (18:8), the vision of the Lord to Paul (18:9-10), and the ruling of Gallio (18:12-17).
|
On the Way to NA29 and UBS 6: An Insight into the Work of the Editorial Committee
Program Unit:
Holger Strutwolf, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
A few years ago a new editorial committee for the further development of the Novum Testamentum Graece (“Nestle-Aland”) and the UBS Greek New Testament has been established. Since then the committee met several times and the changes which will be introduced in NA 29 und UBS 6 begin to take shape. This paper will allow attendees to gain an insight in the committee’s work.
Holger Strutwolf is Professor of Patristics and NT Textual Research at the University of Münster, Germany. In connection with this Dr. Strutwolf also is the director of the Institute for NT Textual Research in which the NA, UBSGNT and the Editio Critica Maior are edited. He is also a member of the new Editorial Committee of NA and UBS.
|
Reading the New Testament as Jewish Apocalyptic Tradition: Challenges and Prospects
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Loren Stuckenbruck, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
This paper shall do two things: (1) outline reasons why one might think that interpreting New Testament texts does not fit neatly into any paradigm of Jewish apocalyptic tradition and then, more constructively, (2) make the case for doing so. Within the framework of the latter, it will be argued that the notion of mediated revelation, whether it relates to time or wisdom, is embedded within not only the thought structures of many writings of the New Testament but also - and variously - the christological convictions they convey. The paper will conclude with an indicative list of research projects that could be followed in the coming years.
|
The Destroyed City as Grazing Space: Interpretive Possibilities in Isaiah 5:17, 17:2, 27:10, and 32:14
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Daniel J. Stulac, Duke University
A familiar topos used to portray ruin in biblical prophecy is that of the destroyed city becoming grazing space for domestic livestock. Modern scholars typically insist that such language, as it appears in the book of Isaiah (5.17, 17.2, 27.10, and 32.14) and when it is understood in its proper historical context, conveys a straightforward, negative image of destruction. By contrast, this essay argues that the grazing-space topos reflects a concrete phenomenon whereby ancient cities experienced an explosion of lush revegetation in the aftermath of their demolition, which in turn attracted a high density of grazing herds. City destruction therefore set in motion an agro-ecological phenomenon through which historical witnesses of such destruction might have begun to imagine the renewal of their lost livelihoods. Once entextualized, this phenomenon served Isaiah's author-redactors as a 'pivot point' by which to express their theological hope for renewal and restoration. Thus, a historically-responsible interpretation of the grazing-space topos as it appears in the book of Isaiah should respect its capacity for both negative and positive interpretive possibilities.
|
The White Robe: Angels, Appearances, and Resurrection Speech in Gospel Narrative
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Maria Sturesson, Lunds Universitet
The angelic figures taking place in the empty tomb of New testament gospel stories are characters with a somewhat ambiguous role in a textual tradition of gospel writing. As an angelus interpres of a synoptic tradition, the messengers announce the news of the resurrection to their intradiegetic audience, the women. In the Gospel of John, the angels do not proclaim the news of the resurrection, but are nevertheless there, and directs the vision of Mary Magdalene to the missing body of the risen one. Outside the boundaries of canon the Gospel of Peter and Gospel of Nicodemus are narratives that also portray the events that closes in on the messengers and their resurrection speech.
This paper examines the interrelation between the narrated visual elements of the scene – where the messengers’ visual appearance is a feature of all these stories – and the speech in turn given by these angelic personae. However, the perspective, or narrative point of view, differs in between these gospel stories. And thus, these narratives appeal in different ways to perception, to vision and hearing, to eyes and ears within these stories. This an element inside the narrative as well as a literary and rhetorical device to an audience in front of the story, an audience that is in different ways guided towards an authoritative voice proclaiming news of the resurrection.
|
Targum Onqelos and the Biblical Aramaic Reading Tradition
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Benjamin Suchard, Leiden University
The language of Targum Onqelos continues to defy classification. Isoglosses typical for Western Aramaic occur besides typical Eastern Aramaic features. A majority of scholars attribute this mixture to the text’s supposed transmission history, positing that it was written in Palestine and edited in Babylonia, but this remains uncertain. This talk will consider the question starting from a similarly unclassified dialect of Aramaic, which has largely escaped attention by hiding in plain sight: that of the Biblical Aramaic reading tradition, which reflects a different dialect than the Biblical Aramaic consonantal text. This dialect does not match any known form of Aramaic; a number of characteristic isoglosses show that it is close to the language of Targum Onqelos, yet not identical to it. The closest match is found with a small number of texts attributed to leading Pharisaic and Rabbinic figures from first-century CE Palestine, a setting that is also plausible on dialectological grounds. Given the linguistic similarities between the dialects of the Biblical Aramaic reading tradition and Targum Onqelos, this supports the Palestinian origin of the latter and provides us with new insights into the origin of both texts in the transformational period in Jewish history surrounding the destruction of the Second Temple.
|
Say What? Some New Hebrew Sound Laws and the Seemingly Irregular Forms of ʾāmar
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Benjamin Suchard, Leiden University
The lexeme ʾāmar ‘to say’ is the most frequent verb in the Hebrew Bible. Cross-linguistically, frequent words tend to be more irregular, and ʾāmar is no exception to this tendency. Especially the stem alternations in the prefix conjugation make ʾāmar unlike any other Hebrew verb. In this talk, I will present a number of new Hebrew sound laws that bear on the morphology of ʾāmar. Specifically, I will describe the regular dissimilation of unstressed *u to *i next to bilabial consonants, as in PNWS *rummān-, BH rimmōn ‘pomegranate’, and a set of stress shifts leading from the original situation of automatic penultimate stress to the phonemic stress system of Biblical Hebrew, elaborating on the model presented in Joshua Blau’s Grammar of Biblical Hebrew (1976; Wiesbaden: Harassowitz). These sound laws were formulated to explain other phenomena, but as we will see, taking them into account makes the historical derivation of the various prefix conjugation forms of ʾāmar completely regular.
|
The Ethiopic Version of Stephen the Theban’s Sermo asceticus
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Alin Suciu, Göttingen Academy
Stephen the Theban was a fourth- or early fifth-century Egyptian ascetic author who penned several texts meant to serve as rules for solitary monks. The longest and most significant of his writings is a Sermo asceticus, which is preserved in Arabic, Coptic (Sahidic), Ethiopic (Gǝʿǝz), Georgian, and Greek. The text is relevant not only because it is one of the earliest ascetic writings extant, but also because it can be argued with good evidence that it was originally composed in Coptic, and that the Greek is a translation from this language. The present paper focuses on the Gǝʿǝz version, which has recently been identified.
|
The Isaianic New Exodus Wisdom Polemic in Romans 9–11
Program Unit: Scripture and Paul
Steve Sullivan,
The Isaianic New Exodus Wisdom Polemic in Romans 9–11
|
"We Are Obliged to Give Thanks": Aspects of Grace in 2 Thessalonians
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Jerry Sumney, Lexington Theological Seminary
This paper will explore the ways the author of 2 Thessalonians understands grace through the lens of the aspects of grace that John Barclay identifies. It will investigate which aspects it "perfects," if any. It will compare the view of grace in this letter with what Barclay finds in Galatians, Romans, and other Jewish literature.
|
Historiography after F. C. Baur: Intertwining Methods in Gospels and Acts Research
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Ben Sutton, Diocese of Quincy (ACNA)
Historiography after F. C. Baur: Intertwining Methods in Gospels and Acts Research
|
The Homiletic Value of War Imagery in the Lament Psalms, from the Perspective of the Imprecatory Psalms
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Lodewyk Sutton, University of the Free State
Invited paper.
|
A Towering Presence, Bent Like Grass: Krister Stendahl’s Call and Conversion
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Jesper Svartvik, Lund University
A Towering Presence, Bent Like Grass: Krister Stendahl’s Call and Conversion
|
Bible Pipelines: Scripting the Land for Profit
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Diana M. Swancutt, The Poverty Consortium
Grounded in the Papal bulls of 1455 (Romanus Pontifex) and 1493 (Inter Caetera), the Doctrine of Discovery sought to place the entire world under Papal rule. Any un-Christianized land was to be possessed at God’s behest. As George Tinker, Roxanne Dunbar-Ortiz, and Steven Newcomb have described well, the Discovery Doctrine was wed to biblical notions (“be fruitful and multiply”, the Great Commission) and placed in service of “Manifest Destiny,” a.k.a., the US government’s expansionist mistreatment of indigenous ‘American’ tribes and their lands and its legalization of same (Johnson v. M’Intosh, 1832). As late as 2005, Supreme Court Justice Ruth B. Ginsburg relied on the Discovery Doctrine to reject land-claims of the Oneidas, one of the Haudenosaunee nations. As Robert Miller, Native American scholar of law, said: “The deed to almost all real estate in the United States originates from an Indian title that was acquired by the United States via Discovery principles” (Paul Kivel). While several US churches (e.g., Episcopal, UCC, Quaker) have explicitly rejected the Discovery Doctrine embodied in events like the pipeline incursion at Standing Rock, US colonial abuse of native People’s sacred freedoms and land rights continues today. This presentation analyzes church documents condemning the Doctrine, highlights techniques of resistance tribes have used in response to the Doctrine, and explores in detail the ideological intermingling of economic, political, biblical and religious scripts at work in current governmental and corporate land grabs in North America.
|
The Bible as Mammon
Program Unit: Poverty in the Biblical World
Diana M. Swancutt, The Poverty Consortium
In his 1967 speech, "Where Do We Go From Here?," Martin Luther King Jr. rightly asserted that "there is something wrong with capitalism" because it sustains and produces poverty and profound ethnic and racial inequities. Yet, capitalism orders Biblical Studies. Claiming that Biblical Studies is a capitalist formation and its products and practitioners, commodities, should not be news. But the practices and self-descriptions of the biblical fields as fields suggest that this knowledge has not impacted us as profoundly as it should. "The educator has the duty of not being neutral," Paulo Friere said, because "dehumanization...is not a given destiny but the result of an unjust order." This paper seeks to articulate some of the "misrecognized" roles of capitalism and its attending social dislocations in Biblical Studies and interpretation, roles and dislocations that too often make them dehumanizing economic formations. To cast this situation into relief, I examine essays by public scholars who use the Bible and the power of 'the academy' as currency to sway public opinion in the current immigration debate. The paper's goal is to illuminate the capitalist ideological assumptions and tools of power-brokering deployed quietly, sometimes unwittingly, in the interstices of their--and our--arguments.
|
This Is My Body: Repetition and Remembrance
Program Unit: Performance Criticism of the Bible and Other Ancient Texts
Richard W Swanson, Augustana University
“This is my Body,” says a pale, earnest young man, dressed in a flowing white gown. Before him, sitting in solemn anticipation, are rose-scented septuagenarians, wearing their Sunday best.
“This is my Body,” says another earnest man, somewhat older, again wearing a white gown that ripples in the breeze. Before him, some of the same men, this time wearing olive drab, preparing for a parachute jump.
This paper begins in reflections on stories my father told me. He, a paratrooper in the Second War, wondered at the effect of the repetition of the ritual around the words, “This is my Body,” as he experienced it in his youth and later, in his home and in France in the midst of the war. Drawing on Richard Schechner’s notions of “restored behavior” and on the work of Marvin Carlson (especially The Haunted Stage: The Theatre as Memory Machine), this paper will explore the ways this phrase (“This is my body”) is haunted by its many repetitions. Particular attention will be paid to the impact this repetition has on the simple physical embodiment of those that enact this performance.
|
Theogenesis and Ethnogenesis: The Role of Qaus in the Formation of Edomite Identity
Program Unit: Israelite Religion in Its Ancient Context
Kipp Swinney, Baylor University
The Hebrew Bible obscures the religious practices of Israel’s near neighbor, Edom. Numerous theories about the reason for this obscuring have appeared. Known primarily through Assyrian sources and a handful of epigraphic findings in Edom, the central deity of Edom was the enigmatic Qaus. In this study, I argue that a shift towards Qaus as the central deity of Edom mirrored and facilitated the shift away from Judahite hegemony in the region. Sparse data assists in reconstructing the history of the region of Edom in the ninth century BCE; however, evidence from the Hebrew Bible and archaeology suggests that Judah controlled the region at some point. Evidence from Kuntillet Ajrud, Egyptian epigraphic texts at Soleb, and the Hebrew Bible suggest that a cult dedicated to Yahweh existed in some form in Edom, possibly alongside a cult dedicated to Qaus. The Calah Annals (c.a. 735) of Tiglath-Pileser III identify Qosmalak (Akk. Qaušmalaka) as a king of Edom. Other subsequent Edomite monarchs also bear names containing Qaus theophoric elements, indicating that Qaus was the central deity of Edomite kings in the late eighth century BCE. I argue that an increase in the prominence of Qaus in Edom at the expense of Yahweh beginning in the ninth century BCE helped to differentiate nascent Edom from their previous Judean oppressors, who worshipped Yahweh. While both Edomite identity and Qaus worshiped likely began before the rebellion of Edom against Judah, the eighth century provides a point of reference where both have reached a level of maturity, indicating significant communities tied to these two phenomena began developing earnestly in the ninth century. The cult of Yahweh either persisted or left a mark on Edomite religion, as Qaus appears to assume some of the qualities of Yahweh.
The presence of the Yahweh cult in Edom and the similarities between Qaus and Yahweh makes condemnations of Edomite religious practices difficult for Yahwistic authors. The nominal difference, however, makes endorsing Edomite religion impossible. Thus, the Hebrew Bible remains nearly silent on the issue of Qaus and Edomite religious practices
|
Significant Features of Qur'an Produced in Subcontinent: A Comparative Study of Bihari and Kashmiri Qur'an
Program Unit: The Qur’an: Manuscripts and Textual Criticism (IQSA)
Saima Syed, Taxila Institute of Asian Civilization, QAU
The purpose of this study is to highlight the techniques of illumination incorporate with elements of design of selected sample related to Bihari and Kashmiri Qur’an. Data (primary) source is Ganjbakhsh library Islamabad. This comparative study discusses the differences and common patterns of illuminated Qur’an like calligraphy, paper quality, page layout, colours, signs and main heading of sura/chapter. Kashmir is very vital for producing of art objects and manuscripts during the Sultan Zain al Abdain’s time (1417- 1467). Northern India became the centre of manuscript production under the patronage of Sultan of Delhi in 1206-1555. Many scholars associated Bihari Qur’an to the region of Bihar (in India) and other called Bahar (A Persian word meaning spring) due to its calligraphic presentation. Though it originated in Indian land but have some similarities to Maghribi script as well. Foliage design and multi-coloured appearance of manuscripts attracts the viewer ‘s attention in a positive way. Subcontinent is a multi-cultural land. It also bears invaders and religious reforms through-out the centuries. The study is conducted under the frame work of codicology. Results are generated after finding out the historical evidences and physical analysis. Key words: Qur’an, Kashmiri, Bihari, Illumination, Manuscript, GBL.
|
Judah's Rewriting of Israel's Tradition: The Composition of Genesis 37-50 and the Concept of Election
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Josef Sykora, Northeastern Seminary at Roberts Wesleyan College
Judah's Rewriting of Israel's Tradition: The Composition of Genesis 37-50 and the Concept of Election
|
David's Shadow in Saul's Rejection: A Hermeneutical Thought-Experiment in 1 Samuel 13-15
Program Unit: Theology of the Hebrew Scriptures
Josef Sykora, Northeastern Seminary at Roberts Wesleyan College
God’s rejection of Saul in 1 Samuel chapters 13 and 15 presents one of the chief difficulties encountered in the Old Testament for a reader trying to align this seemingly unfair incident with the image of a benevolent God described in other portions of Scripture and cherished in both the Jewish and Christian tradition. In the first instance, in chapter 13, Saul—having been previously chosen both by God and the people as Israel’s king—is rejected by Samuel because he had overstepped the commandment of YHWH, presumably by not waiting for the prophet and offering the sacrifice himself. Yet the text makes it clear that Saul did wait seven days, the time appointed by Samuel, and was still rejected by the deity. In chapter 15 Saul is rejected because he failed to fulfill another command, this time to annihilate another nation, Amalek. Saul had compassion on—that is, spared—the Amalekite king and the best of the spoils of the battle. God’s rejection of Saul thus naturally troubles the reader of this episode.
The narrative of chapters 13–15 is at the same time also a portion of Scripture containing major textual difficulties. One way of dealing with these difficulties has been to point out the possible editorial work in the account of Saul’s first rejection (in 1 Sam 13:7b–15a). There are two primary reasons for regarding this first incident at Gilgal as something intrusive or awkward in the narrative. First, the narrative of Saul’s rejection in chapter 13 unnaturally relocates Saul from the region of Michmash-Gibeah to Gilgal. Second, there is both a narratival and temporal gap between the initial command to Saul to wait for seven days in 1 Sam 10:8, and its fulfillment in 1 Sam 13:8.
Although a case could be made in which Saul’s detour to Gilgal would be seen as not completely unnatural, and the connection with the original instruction to wait seven days for Samuel as tighter than it has often been argued, the redactional-critical claim is supported by its usefulness—namely, that without Saul’s first rejection the text reads more smoothly than what the canonical version of the story offers.
In my paper, I make use of historical-critical findings that view 1 Samuel 13:7b–15a as a possible later insertion, but reorient them for theological purposes in order to assess the contours of chosenness depicted here. I present two readings of Saul’s reign in these chapters—first without, and then with this intrusive section—in order to see what difference this passage makes for the overall story and for the question of Saul’s rejection. It is my conviction that this approach brings out the depth dimension of the text, raises fresh questions regarding the identity of Saul’s successor (who could it be before David comes to the picture?), and brings deeper insights into the theological concept of God’s choice.
|
“Don’t Let the Dragon Bite You!” The Use of Apocalyptic Texts and Imagery in the Passio Sanctarum Perpetuae et Felicitatis and Other North African Martyr Acts
Program Unit: Contextualizing North African Christianity
William Tabbernee, University of Oklahoma
This paper examines the way the authors and/or editors of early Christian “Acts of the Martyrs” written in North Africa during the third and fourth centuries C.E. utilized apocalyptic literature in their own literary productions. The best-known and most significant of these works are the passio and, subsequent, acta of Saints Perpetua, Felicitas, and their co-martyrs who died in the amphitheater in Carthage in 203 C.E. Most of this paper will be devoted to the use of apocalyptic texts in the accounts of these famous Carthaginian martyrs. Attention will also be given to the way apocalyptic material is utilized by the composers of other North African acta martyrum, such as those of the Scillitan Martyrs, Cyprian, Montanus and Lucian, Maximilian. Marcellus, and Crispina.
This paper demonstrates how and why the authors/editors of North African Martyr Acts utilized direct quotations, indirect references and allusions, as well as imagery, themes, and concepts drawn from apocalyptic texts to provide an eschatological framework for their acta martyrum.
|
Ritual Performance and Hittite Royal Ideology in Dialogue with Catherine Bell's "Power of Ritualization"
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Ada Taggar-Cohen, Doshisha University
Mesopotamian and Hittite royal ideology has been treated in recent two decades separately as well as in comparative perspective. There have been publications which convincingly showed the influence of Mesopotamian royal presentation as well as royal titles on Hittite kingship. However, while Mesopotamian kings boosted in their royal iconography their worship of gods and used a large number of images to present themselves in ritual scenes, Hittite kings did not leave us much of that. But in contrast they left us a large number of texts where their prescribed ritual activities were drawn in detail.
In her seminal and highly influential book "Ritual Theory Ritual Practice," Catherine Bell dedicated the last third of the volume to the topic of Ritual and Power where she discusses the ways ritualization enables empowerment within "highly structured societies, closed and hierarchical." One of the questions that arose in this discussion relates to the symbolism used in such rituals.
This paper will present an analysis of a Hittite royal ritual taking place during the great festival of the spring named in Hittite AN.TAH.SUM-festival. The ritual is conducted on the 16th day of the festival that lasts more than a month. The performance of the ritual, which is prescribed, projects on the status of the royals and their relations to the deity, in the social context of the royal family, and high courtiers. This ritual is not seen by the large public, but still is heavily symbolic.
|
Teaching Hebrew to Students in Japan using English Textbook?
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Ada Taggar-Cohen, Doshisha University
Studying Biblical Hebrew grammar using English textbook was my - Hebrew native speaker - own experience at an Israeli university. This seems a natural way of study for an academic learning ancient languages. I learned Akkadian with a German textbook and Ancient Egyptian with an English textbook. That was the state of publications in those days. But today with new technologies teaching through a third language should not be the case - but in many countries it is still the case.
Teaching Hebrew - Biblical or Modern - using English to students of English native speakers has its own challenges, but the students interpret the new language directly to their mother tongue. Doing it through a third language causes in most cases a barrier or is an obstacle. For most Japanese students teaching through English is as hard as learning the English language itself, which has a very limited success in Japanese schools and in the general society.
I have taught a decade Hebrew (Biblical and Modern) to English native speakers and have been teaching Modern Hebrew more than fifteen years to Japanese speaking students. After a year of using English textbook in Japan, I have realized that there is only one way to teach Hebrew and that should be by creating a Hebrew- Japanese textbook.
Beside the fact that English demands extra use of a dictionary for the average Japanese student, the most important point was the accuracy of the transfer of meaning of words and phrases, that once translated into English are not always transferred into Japanese accurately, and it leaves the students wondering or even frustrated.
The proposed paper will touch the following points:
1) Which textbook in English? Biblical Hebrew and Modern Hebrew.
2) Focusing on Modern Hebrew - what does a textbook in Japanese achieve?
3) Tools created by me in Japanese and Hebrew to assist students in different levels of their study. One of the tools includes a website that uses mostly voice, but some videos as well.
4) The difficulties of the teacher using three languages in teaching a new one. How much translation is to be used during class of Modern Hebrew especially?
|
Experiencing the Divine in the Book of Visions of the Shepherd of Hermas
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Aldo Tagliabue, University of Notre Dame
The Shepherd of Hermas (2nd century CE) recounts a series of revelations made to the ex-slave Hermas, in which Hermas and other members of the Church are called to repent. Despite its non-canonical status, this text was often used for private education among the members of the early Christian communities. The presence within the Shepherd of visions, intermediaries, heavenly books and mention of eschatological events makes this text a representative of the apocalyptic genre. My analysis will focus on the first four visions received by Hermas, the so-called Book of Visions (BV), which originally constituted an independent section of The Shepherd (the whole text contains another vision and two other sections dedicated to commandments and parables). In the BV, Hermas sees two personified allegories of the Church, an elderly lady (addressed henceforth as Lady Church) and a tower, and, finally, an enormous beast that due to his faith he is able to overcome.
In previous readings of the BV most scholars have offered theological interpretations that identify as the text’s core either the call to conversion or the portrayal of the Church. Following Hellholm, Lipsett and Maier, I undertake a narratological analysis of this text which emphasises its invitation to the readers to achieve an experience of the Church through narrative form.
Since the Church is both a divine and human entity, I will argue that the BV is able to provide readers with an experience of both its human and divine nature.
After a brief introduction on my approach to experience, in Part 1 of my paper I will show that the BV overtly reflects on the nature of the Church in the form of didactic statements, and introduces the manifested and the spiritual Church, which are characterised both by human and divine time. My narratological analysis will follow: in Part 2 I will argue that the BV is a text that turns the depiction of the manifested Church into the narrative of Hermas’ lifelong conversion, and through its immersive quality readers are invited to experience the complex temporality of the manifested Church. In Part 3 I will show that within the same narrative, the downplaying of temporal development and the creation of a cycle invite readers to experience the timelessness of the spiritual Church. In my conclusion, I will draw a comparison between the different techniques through which the BV makes the divine experiential, and I will take the downplaying of temporal development – which I will call non-sequential form – as the proof of this text’s ability to provide experience of the divine.
|
The Torah on Trump: American Rabbinic Biblical Interpretation after the 2016 Election
Program Unit: Jewish Interpretation of the Bible
Caryn Tamber-Rosenau, University of Houston
Many Americans on both sides of the political aisle appealed to religious scriptures in arguing about Donald Trump’s election and what it meant about and for America. This paper explores how American rabbis used the Torah to speak to their congregations about Trump’s election. Jews voted more heavily for Trump’s opponent Hillary Clinton than almost any other religious group, so many rabbis and their congregants were dismayed at the outcome of the race. To assess how the rabbis interpreted the Torah for their congregations in light of the election, I gathered divrei Torah—sermons focused on the biblical reading of the week, often attempting to connect it to current events—from congregations in 20 cities for the weeks following Trump’s victory and the week of his inauguration. Because Jews follow a common calendar of readings from the Torah, all congregations read the same text, or parashah, in each week. If a sermon is given, it is frequently related to the parashah. This fact presents a unique opportunity for the scholar to compare apples to apples, examining how rabbis across the country and from many different strains of Judaism used the same parashah. By analyzing more than 85 divrei Torah provided to me, I endeavor to understand how rabbis collectively interpreted these specific biblical passages to speak about Trump, answering questions such as: which part(s) of the Torah portion garnered the most attention from rabbis? Are there similarities in textual focus and interpretation among rabbis of the major American Jewish movements? Did rabbis use the biblical material to draw direct parallels to the modern political situation? In this paper, an excerpt of a larger project, I will focus on one parashah, Shemot (Ex 1-6:1). This parashah was read the weekend of Trump’s inauguration and presented fascinating opportunities for rabbinic biblical interpretation in light of American politics, such as “a new king” arising over Egypt, the struggle for justice, and the prominence of women in helping to lift the Hebrews out of Egyptian slavery. This paper offers an inside look at how Jewish religious leaders used a defined set of biblical texts to address the game-changing 2016 election with their congregations.
|
Re-membering Life after Death: Constructing, Receiving, and Contesting the Pauline Body
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Frederick S. Tappenden, St. Stephen's College, University of Alberta
This paper explores the many ways that Paul’s body is remembered in the Pauline tradition of the first and second centuries, particularly around themes of death and coming back to life. My analysis proceeds in two parts. The first half of my paper is devoted to the theme of Paul’s body in the undisputed letters (esp. Philippians 3; and Galatians 2). Here I give attention to the ways death and life are dynamically mapped to the apostle’s body, and the resulting visions of death and life that emerge within Paul’s somatic self-presentation. Attention is given specifically to locating Paul’s resurrection ideals within the broader tapestry of Judean resurrection ideals in the Second Temple period. The second half of the paper examines the many ways Paul’s “body” is remembered within the late-first and second centuries (esp. Colossians 1; Acts 9, 14, and 19; and Acts of Thecla 3). Here I examine ways in which the memory of Paul’s body—his presence, his absence, his reputation, and his (living) voice—both reflect and ground certain kinds of early Christian discourses about death and coming back to life.
|
Dressing Jesus (and Why This Matters): Some Further Considerations
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Joan E. Taylor, King's College - London
This paper will summarise the main results of the presenter’s book What did Jesus look like? (Bloomsbury T&T Clark, 2018) and discuss various topics that have arisen since publication. It is argued that appearance matters because the body is essentially a project on which we inscribe meanings about our identity. Garments are signifiers of social status, ideology and gender, inter alia. In the small clues we have about Jesus’ clothing, it seems that the way Jesus presented himself illuminated key aspects of his message. This paper will also consider how clothing was made in village culture and review some of the ancient textiles found around the Dead Sea.
|
Writing a Commentary on De Vita Contemplativa
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Joan Taylor, King's College - London
Writing a Commentary on De Vita Contemplativa
|
Sarah Hale, the Cult of Domesticity, and the Apostle Paul
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Marion Ann Taylor, Wycliffe College
Sarah Hale (1788-1879) is fondly remembered as the author of the nursery rhyme, “Mary had a little lamb,” and as a campaigner to make Thanksgiving a national American holiday. More recently scholars have begun to recognize her wider influence on literary, political, and religious culture through her work as editor of the Ladies’ Magazine (1828–1836), Godey’s Lady’s Book (1837–1877), and numerous gift books as well as her own works of poetry, prose, and drama. In this paper, I will present Hale’s reading of the 1 Corinthians 11 that she embeds in the General Preface to her very popular book that focuses on the lives of women, The Woman’s Record (1853). There she writes concerning 1 Corinthians 11: “This chapter has never, in my opinion been rightly understood.” She sets out to remedy this situation, “trust[ing] those who make the Bible their study, wise theologians and learned commentators, will pardon my attempt to show the true interpretation.” Hale’s true interpretation is distinctive, as she reads Paul through the lens of her idealized view of women’s moral superiority: “her soul was to ‘help’ [man] where he was deficient, namely, in his spiritual nature” (Hale, Woman’s Record, xxxvii).
|
Reflections from the Editor of "Handbook of Women Biblical Interpreters," and Co-Editor of "Women of War, Women of Woe" and "Women in the Story of Jesus"
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Marion Ann Taylor, Wycliffe College
Reflections from the Editor of "Handbook of Women Biblical Interpreters" (Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Books, 2012), and Co-Editor of "Women of War, Women of Woe: Joshua and Judges through the Eyes of Nineteenth-Century Female Biblical Interpreters" and "Women in the Story of Jesus: The Gospels through the Eyes of Nineteenth-Century Female Biblical Interpreters" (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 2016).
|
Hypocrites and the Pure in Heart: Religion as an Evolved Strategy for In-Group Formation
Program Unit: Cognitive Science Approaches to the Biblical World
John Teehan, Hofstra University
The cognitive science of religion allows us to engage in a new sort of hermeneutics, a cognitive-critical approach to Scripture. Just as the historical-critical approach seeks to uncover the influences of historical context on the construction of Scripture, the cognitive-critical method seeks to read through texts to uncover the influence of various cognitive processes. These cognitive processes are the means through which humans apprehend their experiences and environment. We do not think with these processes but rather think through these processes. That is, these processes construct the basic categories that constitute human cognition. Operating outside of conscious awareness (indeed they structure conscious awareness), their influence goes unnoticed unless we are led to reflect on the structures of these mental categories. Here, we consider the Sermon on the Mount as a case study in this cognitive-critical approach, focusing on the cognitive processes underlying identity-formation, with its consequent effect on the construction of moral frameworks. It will be argued that this key Biblical moral teaching is structured by and taps into humanity’s evolved moral psychology, and that this a source of its moral power.
|
The Trauma of Autopsy and the Transgression of History in Josephus’ Jewish War
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Sarah Christine Teets, University of Virginia
This paper explores how the psychology of trauma elucidates a crisis of historiographical composition presented by Josephus in the proem of the Jewish War, occasioned by his attempt to give an account of his traumatic experience of Roman violence from within the confines of the classical Greek war monograph. In staking his claim to historiographical authority in his direct experience of the events of the war (autopsy) in the proem, and attempting to compose within the conventions of the classical Greek war monologue, Josephus presents himself as facing a remarkable dilemma: what is a historian to do if, as he has argued, it is his experience of autopsy which generates his historiographical authority and veracity, yet that very experience was in fact traumatic and has engendered tremendous suffering in the author within a genre to which expression of such personal emotion is not appropriate? He claims that his emotions of grief are manifest in the very writing of War itself, and will be perceptible to the reader (War 1.9, 11). Josephus further proclaims this intrusion of his own emotion into the work to be “contrary to the custom of history” (παρὰ τὸν τῆς ἱστορίας νόμον at 1.11). The lament of War 5.19-20 certainly bears a closer resemblance to the lamentations of the Hebrew Bible than to anything found in Greek historians. The fact that he has presented his work at the opening of the Jewish War in terms of its conformity to the conventions of Greek historiography necessitates that he frame his intrusive expressions of feeling as a surplus that cannot be contained within the conventions of the genre. It is paradoxically his attempts at conformity with the genre’s conventions that forces him to break from them in the opening of Jewish War. While the fact that Josephus has chosen a classical Greek model for his account of the war cannot be separated from the Hellenistic imperial-colonial encounter in Judea, it is the experience of Roman violence that he has chosen to represent by means of the classical Greek war monograph, with the transgressive addition of lamentation. When we consider that talking about an experience of trauma and its attendant feelings puts the speaker in a position of vulnerability, and the hearers in a position of discomfort, and that accordingly, people tend to remain silent about their own sufferings, and to render others’ suffering unspeakable, we must raise the question of why Josephus should choose to present his emotions within his history and actually acknowledge that the choice is transgressive. Work on the role of epic and tragedy in the Greek tradition as a communal means of processing trauma by Jonathan Shay and Bryan Doerries prompts me to argue that Judith Herman’s work on the importance of reconstructing an account of traumatic events that is both detailed and emotional for the alleviation of suffering sheds light on the quandary presented in the opening of Jewish War as Josephus’ response to Roman violence.
|
Sustained Scarcity and Moral Creativity: Theological Reflections
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Theodros Assefa Teklu, Ethiopian Graduate School of Theology
Current theological trends tend to privilege a normative vision of divine plenitude over that of scarcity; consequently, the role the concept of scarcity once played in moral reflection is undermined. Granted, such approaches that accentuate the necessity of enacting theological virtues – God’s gifts mediated through the Church’s sacraments – are vital for Christian social engagement; I contend that the notion of sin (which is significant to understand the dark side of life characterised by scarcity) is passed over in silence, and I find this silence problematic. Drawing on the works of Radical Orthodoxy thinkers such as Stephen Long and the John Milbank-Adrian Pabst duo, I wish to inquire what it might mean to speak of sustained (constructed) scarcity created by sin while considering the scope available within the theological discourse of moral creativity.
|
Enhancing the Depiction of a Prophet: The Repercussions of Textual Criticism to the Study of the Elisha Cycle
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Timo Tekoniemi, Helsingin Yliopisto - University of Helsinki
In this paper it will be argued that the Masoretic Text reflects a textual form that has at least in six different instances (2 Kgs 2:14, 3:14, 4:41, 5:18, 8:11, and 13:14–21) gone through a slight but notable revision, interested in a theologically more orthodox depiction of prophet Elisha. This revisional layer is lacking from the Old Greek (OG) edition (in the kaige sections often found with the help of the Antiochian/Lucianic text and/or the Old Latin translation), which should be taken as reflecting a more original textual tradition in the given passages. This is particularly noteworthy since not very often are the readings of Septuagint taken into account when assessing the redactional or especially (composition) historical questions concerning the Elijah-Elisha traditions, or the books of Kings as a whole. Indeed, the more original readings of OG may have some further repercussions to the understanding of the Elisha cycle as a whole. The OG edition seems to indicate that, unlike now in the Masoretic version, the original Elisha narrative was closer to a tragedy rather than to a story of insuperable prophetic prowess.
|
Continue to Sing, Miriam! The Song of Miriam in 4QPentateuch (4Q365)
Program Unit: Book History and Biblical Literatures
Hanna Tervanotko, McMaster University
Continue to sing, Miriam! The Song of Miriam in 4QPentateuch (4Q365)
|
Q 23:93–103 and 4 Ezra 7
Program Unit: The Qur’an and Late Antiquity (IQSA)
Tommaso Tesei, Van Leer Jerusalem Institute
Intertextual resonances between the Qur’an and biblical and extra-biblical texts have attracted significant scholarly attention since the very beginning of modern Qur’anic Studies. The question has recently obtained renewed investigation within the more general trend of research that aims to re-situate early Islam in its late antique context. Intertextualities offer scholars a valuable means to explore the allusiveness that characterizes qur’anic narratives. Moreover, the study of intertexts helps us to determine to what degree biblical traditions were spread in the Qur’an’s environment. In this paper I will address the case of Q 23:93-103. As I will argue, this qur’anic passage presents number of intertextual connections with different sections of 4 Ezra 7.
|
Two Competing Visions of Restoration: Matthew 28:18-20 and 2 Chronicles 36:23
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Gregory S. Thellman, Evangelical Theological Seminary in Osijek, Croatia
Two Competing Visions of Restoration: Matthew 28:18-20 and 2 Chronicles 36:23
|
Bromance in Bible: How Male-Male Friendships in Biblical Literature Can Teach Students about the Use and Misuse of Women and Women’s Bodies
Program Unit: LGBTI/Queer Hermeneutics
Barbara Thiede, University of North Carolina at Charlotte
Teachers employing biblical literature to teach sexuality frequently devote time to pedagogical necessities: demonstrating that homosexuality, as modern society defines it, isn’t found in Hebrew Bible and that sexual violence is. One issue that is salient for comprehensive sex education has yet to be explored: the ways in which male bonding and friendship serve as channels for the misuse of women.
In Hebrew Bible, male friendship can function as a literary interlocutor for homosocial and possibly homoerotic relationships that rely on the use and abuse of female sexuality to direct male energies. This project considers three pivotal narratives in Hebrew Bible from that vantage point: Genesis 38, 2 Samuel 13, and Judges 19. Exploring these texts can teach students about the range of sexual expression found in male-male relationships, demonstrate in what ways those relationships impact women, and show how power intersects with sexuality in subtle and dangerous forms.
|
The Sublime and Subliminal in Romans 2–3
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Jonathan Thiessen, Université de Strasbourg
The anonymous author of the first-century treatise On the Sublime attributed to Longinus recommends a subliminal element when seeking to persuade with the sublime (17.2): the listener must be carried away by the strength of the rhetoric without having time to understand how (32.3). Agreement is produced more through powerful experience than through logical persuasion. Several of the features “Longinus” describes (question and answer, for example, emotion or momentum) can be seen in Rom. 2-3, where Paul's exchange with a “Jew” raises questions for his audience: who is the “Jew” he is addressing? What exactly are the advantages of the Jews? The solution to these questions remains ambiguous. Parallels between Paul's rhetoric with the theory of the sublime lead us to question whether this ambiguity may be intentional. Does Paul's apostrophe of an unidentified “Jew” lead his Jewish readers to question their behaviour? Does his rapid series of questions and answers which avoids stating what the “Jews’” advantages really are lead them to wonder for themselves whether they have lost their privileged position? Paul's prudence leads us to suspect that he is in fact treading carefully in a conflict between Jewish and non-Jewish groups in Rome, seeking to communicate an unpleasant message in a way that will not encourage discrimination. The momentum sustained throughout the passage enables Paul to elicit agreement without giving his audience time to realize his arguments may be insufficient. Thus, the argumentative texture of the passage weaves syllogistic reasoning with emotional appeal suggested subliminally.
|
Introducing Interpretive Principles through Art & Popular Culture
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Matthew A. Thomas, Fuller Theological Seminary
Rather than attempting to tailor our learning to each students' preferred 'learning style' (a 'myth' not supported by research), using a variety of activities in the classroom—whether physical or virtual—produces better outcomes for the vast majority of students. One way that I have enlivened my Biblical Studies courses is through the inclusion of art, advertising, song lyrics, and other media that can lead to issues of interpretation relevant to the study of the Bible.
I will present examples from an activity I use in an introduction to biblical exegesis course (BI500: Interpretive Practices at Fuller Theological Seminary). The activity involves students reflecting on aspects of interpretation in response to paintings such as Picasso's Weeping Woman, song lyrics such as Kendrick Lamar's 'Alright', or poems like Billy Collins' 'Introduction to Poetry'. Members will be asked to reflect on the art pieces with the aid of interpretive questions. Typical responses will be shared and connected to interpretive issues in biblical studies. Further, I will outline how the activity can be adapted to the online environment through the use of a combination of wiki and non-wiki pages.
|
Voiceless Idols, Speaking People: 1 Corinthians 12-14 and the Accessibility of Divine Presence
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Ambrose Thomson, McMaster Divinity College
Voiceless Idols, Speaking People: 1 Corinthians 12-14 and the Accessibility of Divine Presence
|
Freedom for Telling the Truth: On Martin Luther King, Jr., Mark’s Gospel, and Riots as the Language of the Unheard
Program Unit: Bible and Cultural Studies
Marsha A. Thrall, Chicago Theological Seminary
In his March 14, 1968 address titled “The Other America”, the Reverend Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. professed to the Grosse Point Human Relations Council that “a riot is the language of the unheard.” King boldly asserted this claim and justification of the practice of rioting while speaking to this middle-America crowd on the premise of having a polite conversation about the race problem, prevalent within United States political and social structures. Though King politely prefaces this statement with an assertion of his belief in “militant, non-violent resistance”, within this same address, King provides an afterthought regarding his stance on non-violent resistance, directly implying that the tool of non-violent resistance, when utilized within the arsenal of the battle for civil rights, was employed merely to appease whiteness. In delivering “The Other America”, King asserts that “militant, powerful, massive non-violence as the most potent weapon in grappling with the problem (race) from a direct action point of view”, while asserting that rioting “intensifies the fear of the white community while relieving the guilt.” In other words, to paraphrase King, non-violent resistance was a translation of the dialect of the oppressed into a language to help oppressors understand the condition of marginalization; however, the only language that social oppressors could hear, with meaning, was the language screamed within the act of civil rebellion manifest as rioting. In comparing King’s speech to the New Testament Gospel narratives that tell the story of Jesus’ ministry, as it worked within the marginalizing and oppressive imperial social structures of first century Palestine, it would seem a similar form of appeasement was at play within Jesus’ ministry, as a means of subverting order within a culture both structured and intent upon exploiting the humanity of the most vulnerable. The most simplistic, yet meaningful example of both non-violent resistance, and ultimately the pained scream of rioting can be found in the first healing “campaign” found within Mark 1:21-3:35, and subsequently within Jesus’ “cleansing of the temple” as told in Mark 11:15-18. Through the lens of King’s “The Other America” and Mark 1:21-3:35, as well as Mark 11:15-18, this paper will work to explore how “white fear” and “white guilt” (as termed by King), act as a social contaminant that infects the ability of the socially oppressed and marginalized to be heard in meaningful, non-violent ways, while at the same time exploring how rioting, when acknowledged as the “language of the oppressed”, ultimately leads to the act of state-sanctioned murder of rioting’s translators; for example, Jesus and Martin Luther King, Jr.
|
Bede’s Portrait of Nehemiah: A Portrait Made of Proof-Texts and Selection
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Lena-Sofia Tiemeyer, University of Aberdeen
This paper looks at the portrayal of Nehemiah in the commentary on Nehemiah by the English monk Venerable Bede (d. 735). In particular, it will address two points. First, it will investigate the exegetical significance of the use of proof-texts in this commentary. What proof-texts does this commentator use? In what manner does he employ them? How do they transform the portrayal of Nehemiah? Second, it will explore the selection of material and discuss to what extent the choice of verses on which Bede comments influences the portrayal of Nehemiah. At times, other retellings will be referred to in order to offer pertinent comparisons. For example, Bede comments on neither Neh 5:19 nor 13:14, 22, 31, i.e. the two passages where Nehemiah lauds his own good behaviour. In the final words of his own commentary, however, he makes Nehemiah’s words ‘Remember me with favour, oh my God’ his own. Both the silence in this commentary and his adoption of Nehemiah’s words indicate that Bede saw Nehemiah as a person to emulate and that he did not see Nehemiah’s self-praise as a character fault. Rabbinic interpretations of Neh 5:19 and 13:14, 22, 31 offer an intriguing contrast to Bede’s views. B.san. 5:19, for example, uses of Ps 106:4 as a proof-text of Neh 5:19, that accomplishes to compare Nehemiah negatively with David and thus serves as a hidden critique of the former.
|
Haggai-Zechariah 1–8 in the Book of the Twelve: A Dialogue with James Nogalski
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Lena-Sofia Tiemeyer, University of Aberdeen
This paper explores the composition history of the Haggai-Zechariah corpus and its place within the Book of the Twelve in dialogue with James Nogalski’s redaction-critical theory pertaining to the formation of the Twelve, as well as with his more recent exegetical commentary of the same text. It begins by assessing the common theory of an early Haggai-Zechariah 1–8 textual corpus. Are we speaking about two distinct bodies of texts that at one point were combined, or rather about two sets of texts that share a common and overlapping trajectory of growth? The paper then turns to the issue of the incorporation of the Haggai-Zechariah corpus into the growing collection that subsequently came to form the Book of the Twelve. In doing so, it will look at the date of its incorporation, as well as its relationship with the surrounding material in Zechariah 9–14 and Malachi. In particular, it will re-evaluate the relationship between Zechariah 1–8 and Zechariah 9–14. In short, to what extent is Zech 9–14 an example of prophetic Fortschreibung of Zechariah 1–8 and to what extent is it a distinct textual unit with few connections to the immediately preceding material?
|
Disciplinary Mechanisms in Basil of Caesarea's Great Asketikon?
Program Unit: Student Advisory Board
Nathan Tilley, Duke University
Though Basil of Caesarea's ascetic works hold great importance for later communal monasticism, scholars disagree on the extent to which his own context involved a formal, monastic institution. Studies of Basil of Caesarea's ascetic corpus from the last two decades largely argue that his rules do not involve or necessitate monastic institutions but rather offer principles of life applicable to all Christians. This work importantly corrects earlier scholars who anachronistically read the Asketikon as intended for formal institutions as developed as those of later periods. Nevertheless, recent scholarship has insufficiently noted how principles of the Asketikon do not merely relate to interior Christian transformation but often involve communal mechanisms of discipline. This paper uses a Foucauldian analysis of disciplinary power to make visible some disciplinary principles found in Basil's Asketikon which suggest more institutional structure. Specifically, Basil's rules employ three broadly-Foucauldian strategies of disseminated discipline: surveillance, normalizing judgment, and psychological examination. Foucault's analysis of biopower demonstrates how the soft power of surveillance and examination does not merely restrict bodies, but also produces dispositions in those bodies to act in specific ways. Basil's Asketikon offers a similar "micro-physics" of power that disciplines individual bodies to be disposed towards particular embodiments of love. Although the limitations of textual and material evidence preclude definitive conclusions about Basil's historical community, I argue that these textual traces of institutional discipline suggest an original institutional context for the Asketikon. By connecting Basil's ascetic principles to biopower, this project offers new understandings of Basil's monastic setting as well as lines of connection between Basil's Asketikon and its role in later, institutional monasticism.
|
The Lives of Joseph and of His Garment
Program Unit: The Qur’an and the Biblical Tradition (IQSA)
Sarra Tlili, University of Florida
Although the motifs of Joseph’s beauty and garment are common to the biblical and qur’anic versions of the Joseph story, their employment varies considerably. Study of these variations not only leads to better appreciation of the literary quality of each version, but also provides important insights into the worldview in which each version is embedded. Joseph’s beauty is an important plot morpheme in the biblical narrative, providing necessary motivation for Potiphar’s wife. Thus, the biblical narrator appropriately introduces this motif for the first time upon the transition to the building block involving the love story. Of course, Joseph’s beauty is not a new development in the actual sequence of events; however, to bring it to the audience’s attention prior to this point would have served no purpose. In fact, placement of the motif at this juncture enhances the characterization of Joseph’s brothers in subtle though important ways. Lack of reference to Joseph’s beauty in the first section appropriately indicates that this trait has not been in his brothers’ minds, or even that the brothers have sought, perhaps subconsciously, to suppress any awareness of Joseph’s distinction out of jealousy. The beauty motif poses a challenge to the Qur’an. On one hand, certain aspects of the narrative depend on it, on the other, if this motif is not handled carefully it can create a theological problem. Verbal description of Yūsuf as handsome, if articulated straightforwardly by the Qur’an’s divine narrator, could be construed as a divine endorsement of a set of features as constituting an objective aesthetic model. Such position would be problematic not only because of its racial undertones, but also because it is inconsistent with the ḥadīth stating that “God does not look at your bodies or your images, but rather looks at your hearts.” The Qur’an solves this theological conundrum by avoiding verbal commentary on Yūsuf’s looks and allowing us to learn about his beauty by describing its impact on a group of women. This approach also enhances the style, as the Qur’an shows--rather than tells--how handsome Yūsuf is. Joseph’s garment is not only an effective structural device in the biblical narrative, linking seemingly disparate parts of the plot, but it also draws attention to the importance of clothing as a mark of social status. Indeed, several biblical scholars have noted that the garment appears at transitional moments in the narrative to signal Joseph’s rise to prominence or fall from favor, depending on whether he receives or is stripped of a garment. The Bible also illustrates how clothing can be adduced as misleading evidence when Joseph’s garments are used to prove his alleged death and alleged betrayal of his master, respectively. Clothing as a symbol of social status is not reflected in the qur’anic narrative, which indicates that to the qur’anic narrator clothing does not hold the same meaning as to the biblical one. Moreover, although the Qur’an seems to agree with the Bible that clothes can be adduced asmisleading evidence, such attempts are condemned to failure.
|
Empires, Power, and Politics across the Twelve: YHWH, National Identity, and Destiny
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Daniel Timmer, Puritan Reformed Theological Seminary
Empires, Power, and Politics across the Twelve: YHWH, National Identity, and Destiny
|
Cohesion, Coherence, and the Nations: Beyond the Synchronic-Diachronic Polarity in the Book of Isaiah
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Daniel C. Timmer, Puritan Reformed Seminary, FTE-Montreal
Recognizing the unnecessary opposition of synchronic and diachronic approaches but also their frustratingly varied definitions and uses in biblical studies, this paper attempts to move beyond this methodological impasse by drawing increased attention to the linguistic concepts of cohesion and coherence. Building upon an investigation focused on the Book of the Twelve that correlates these concepts with the compositional-holistic continuum (Daniel C. Timmer, The Non-Israelite Nations in the Book of the Twelve: Thematic Coherence and the Diachronic-Synchronic Relationship in the Minor Prophets, BINS 135 [Leiden: Brill, 2015]), this paper uses them to trace the dis/continuity of the theme of the non-Israelite nations in the Book of Isaiah in an attempt to better understand a theme that has received extremely diverse interpretations over the last several decades (contrast John Oswalt, “The Nations in Isaiah: Friend or Foe; Servant or Partner,” BBR 16 [2006]: 41-51; Lother Ruppert, “Das Heil der Völker (Heilsuniversalismus) in Deutero- und ‘Trito’-Jesaja,” MTZ 45 [1994]: 137-59).
In contemporary linguistics, cohesion and coherence are distinct but ultimately inseparable features that describe, respectively, textually (and usually lexically) inscribed connectedness and semantic-pragmatic unity. One important feature of their relationship involves the primacy of coherence, since it captures the conceptually-focused elements that drive the formation of the text. Because cohesion and coherence can be helpfully correlated with the synchronic-diachronic spectrum, increased attention to the text’s linguistic features will potentially guard against assigning too dominant or too monolithic a role to historical processes (or their absence) in understanding the text’s composition. This shift in emphasis is desirable for several reasons. In addition to Benjamin Sommer’s caution against pseudo-historicism in interpretation, the very different dates that interpreters propose for various features or pericopae and recent critiques of commonly-accepted theories of redaction and textual growth (cf. Raymond F. Person and Robert Rezetko [eds.], Empirical Models Challenging Biblical Criticism, AIL [Atlanta: SBL, 2016]) suggest that compositional mechanisms and features are often more difficult to discern than is commonly thought. A perspective that puts linguistic features on par with historical ones should therefore also help interpreters critically evaluate and refine the criteria by means of which they identify compositional features so that they better reflect how literary texts come into being and transmit meaning. This is particularly desirable in light of the varying degrees of cohesion and coherence that different texts exhibit. Despite arguments to the contrary, there are good grounds on which to assume that ancient Near Eastern texts were coherent on their own terms, and that these terms are in essential continuity with many, but not all, of the criteria used to ascertain the compositional history of BI, i.e., differences in style or vocabulary, conceptual complexity, etc.
This paper thus argues that increased attention to the text’s cohesion and coherence alongside its more overt historical contours has the potential to correct a variety of methodological weaknesses and to advance our understanding of one of the most diverse and intriguing themes in BI.
|
The Translation of Rituals in the Bible: A Cultural Ecological Perspective
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Samy I. Tioyé, United Bible Societies
In my work with translators dealing with the books of Exodus, Numbers, Deuteronomy and Leviticus, I observed a growing interest from the translators to discuss more about rituals. In those books, some rituals are fully described while some are not. Many of them noted similarities between the rituals in the Bible and theirs. When trying to explain their translation of some terms related to those rituals, the translators will always go further to mention the interactions between the community and their environment. These interactions seem to be reflected in their rituals. This observation led me investigate the context of rituals in the Bible, especially in the book of Leviticus to see if the same thing can be said to the Israelite community. In the context of translation, this investigation will help us understand the cultural dynamic of rituals as embedding aspects of ecology.
This paper aims to shed light on the interactions between rituals in the Bible and ecology by studying the rituals in the book of Leviticus for translation purpose. Elements of cultural ecology are used to explore the interactions between the people of the Bible and their environments by analyzing some of their rituals.
This work is articulated around three parts. The first part explains the context of rituals in the Bible, specifically in the book of Leviticus. The second part describes cultural ecology and how it applies to the study of rituals in the Bible. Four rituals subjected to our study have been identified. They are sacrifices, blood disposal, clean and unclean animals, and celebrations of feasts. The implication of this study for translation will be the third part. The expected results of this work are to raise awareness among the African translators that there is more to look into translation when it comes to rituals in the Bible.
|
Bible Translation and Ethnicity Revindication: A Case Study of the Lobi People in Burkina Faso West Africa
Program Unit: Nida Institute
Samy Tioyé, United Bible Societies
The missionary activities started in the Lobi community in Burkina Faso (Upper Volta back then) around 1920. The work grew fast to the point that several churches were planted and two bible schools were opened to train believers for the ministry. Two New Testaments were produced and a new translation came as a result of the adjustment to the new orthography of the language in 1985. The local church born from the missionary work came to a crossroads around 1990s when the younger generation started proposing the use of local dances and Christian songs based on local rhythms. It is as if the local church was woken up to a new sense of ethnicity as a way of expressing their faith. Today more and more actions are done toward this affirmation of as a claim. We believe Bible Translation was the catalyst to this great awareness.
This paper seeks to study the link between Bible Translation and ethnic assertiveness by looking at the missionary activities in the Lobi country in Burkina Faso area as well as the translation activities and its impact on the Christian community and the larger community.
|
African Identities in Vandal-Era Poetry
Program Unit: Contextualizing North African Christianity
Mark Tizzoni, Angelo State University
This paper examines the ways in which the Christian poets of Vandal North Africa engaged with their African identities. The poets of the Vandal kingdom conducted their art at the highest levels of Vandal society and played a very active role in the creation of the shared culture at its heart. Mostly coming from the Romano-African aristocracy they embrace, and celebrate, their African Romanitas in the context not only of the Vandal kingdom, but also of the city of Carthage. Thus we see author and subject identified as Tyrians, as Africans, as Romans, and, indeed, as Vandals, and all of these identities together. As such, Africa, and African identities, stand at the forefront of the Vandal cultural product. Key to this discussion are the works of Dracontius, who operated in the late fifth century and the poems of the sixth-century Anthologia Latina.
|
The Full Land: Writing Biblical History amidst Contestations
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Andrew Tobolowsky, College of William and Mary
As the familiar biblical vision of the history of ancient Israel continued to take shape in the Persian period, we are now fully aware that its shapers were not the only ones pursuing this type of project. The discrediting of the “Myth of the Empty Land” reveals a multiplicity, both in Persian period Yehud and across the first true diaspora. It now seems increasingly likely, for example, that the Samaritans, or perhaps the Samarian ancestors of the Samaritans, long dismissed as the descendants of foreigners brought in by the Assyrians in the 8th century B.C.E., were likely instead Israelites whose ancestors had not been deported, and that the temple on Mt. Gerizim was not constructed in the Hellenistic period but in the fifth century B.C.E. This paper explores what it means for how we tell the history of biblical history that the narrative likely appeared in its familiar dimensions only in competition with other interpretations of the same past. I will argue that typical models of its development presume a representativeness for its constituent traditions over time that recent evidence countermands, and that we must begin to write new kinds of histories of narrative development in response.
|
Classics and Biblical Studies Have a Lot of the Same Problems, The Paper
Program Unit: Student Advisory Board
Andrew Tobolowsky, College of William and Mary
In Biblical Studies and Classical Studies, scholars often make similar kinds of arguments but rarely entertain what the solutions in one might mean for the other. So, for example, scholars in biblical studies have often suggested that the presence of ancient realia in the David story, such as the role of Gath, which was destroyed fairly early, indicates its reliability – but people make the same argument about the Iliad, which employs a Bronze Age geography rather than an Iron Age one. In that case, everyone acknowledges that the fact that the story might be old doesn’t mean it’s true -there may have been something like a Trojan War but that doesn’t mean the son of a water goddess actually held a labor strike until the death of his best friend. Classicists often think the mythic account of the “Return of the Herakleidae” contains memories of a “Dorian Invasion” as poorly evidenced as the Exodus, but few people have asked what the fact that Herakles obviously never existed, therefore never had children, means for the historicity of the exodus. This paper attempts to deal with these issues, and then kind of throws its hands in the air.
|
Jewish Consumption Practices and Identity during the Second Temple Period
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Alan Todd, Coastal Carolina University
A renewed theoretical interest in material culture within cultural anthropology has shown focusing on the processes of consumption is a particularly promising way to understand how indigenous peoples assert and maintain distinctive identities during colonial encounters, as well as the impact that these acts of agency can have on broader socio-political networks and economic conditions. I will draw on these insights to show what consumption practices reveal about Jewish identity formation and maintenance during the latter half of the Second Temple Period. I review discussions of the material remains recovered from in and around Jerusalem and that date from the onset of Seleucid rule (ca. 200 BCE) through the heyday of the Hasmonean state (ca. 75 BCE). Analyses of these remains show a significant shift in Jewish consumption patterns: the material evidence, particularly as it relates to household items, reveals that Jews living in Jerusalem and its environs adopted and only slightly adapted Greek cultural practices prior to the Hasmonean revolt, whereas afterward Jews living with the burgeoning Maccabean kingdom all but turned their backs on acquiring gentile-made imported wares and wine from the Greek world. This new consumption pattern, as I will argue, is evidence for an increased desire for goods that could help Jews create a new material reality, one that could help them re-assert a distinctive identity in the wake the traumatic events that led to the Hasmonena revolt.
I will go further, however. I will conclude my paper by explaining what I believe to be the immediate and longer-term impact the consumption practices that emerged after the Hasmonean revolt had on other aspects of Judean, and eventually Galilean, life. I will argue that it was the Hasmoneans who, if they did not create, certainly facilitated the new consumption habits. In doing so, they helped to create a Judean-based economy, which transformed not only the regions’ trade patterns, but also established and entangled a number of individuals and groups within a new economic reality. These new conditions, I will argue, facilitated a growing class-consciousness that had a significant impact on the Jewish population for the rest of the duration of the Second Temple period.
|
"When Did We See You Naked?" Re-reading the Stripping of Jesus in the Context of #MeToo
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
David Tombs, University of Otago
The #MeToo campaign created by Tarana Burke in 2007 and popularized by Alyssa Milano in October 2017 has confirmed what feminists have long argued on the prevalence of sexual assault, sexual harassment and sexually abusive behaviour. It has also prompted a more public debate on dynamics of victim blaming and victim shaming which contribute to the silences which typically benefit perpetrators and add a further burden to survivors. As such, the #MeToo movement raises important questions for Christian faith and practical theology. Gustavus Adolphus Lutheran Church New York offered a creative response in a sign which adapted Jesus' words 'You did this to me' (Mt 25.40) to read 'You did this to #MeToo'.
This presentation will review a current initiative, titled 'When Did We See You Naked?', which brings together practical theology and biblical studies to explore the identification of Jesus with sexual abuse. It focusses on the biblical accounts of stripping and forced exposure of Jesus and explores whether this experience should be acknowledged and labelled more explicitly under the specific term of 'sexual abuse', or the more general term 'abuse', or some other label. The stripping and exposure is often passed over without detailed comment in biblical commentaries or wider literature. It is rare for its significance to be discussed with sustained attention to gender-based violence, or as a form of sexual abuse or sexual assault.
To promote discussion of these questions, the initiative uses a photo of Michelangelo's crucifix, in Santo Spirito Church, Florence, along with the passage Mark 15.16-24 as focal points. The passage references Jesus being stripped three times in just nine verses (vv 17, 20, 24), and the Michelangelo crucifix shows a fully naked Christ on the cross. Discussions so far have suggested the combination of the image and detailed attention to the text typically help those involved in the discussion to see the text in new ways. After a careful reading, most readers report being more aware of the stripping, and are also more likely to label it as a form of abuse than they were previously. Furthermore, many participants see it as sexual abuse, whereas some participants argue against this.
The paper will outline the approach taken to promote this discussion and the responses which it typically provokes. It will describe some of the reasons offered for naming Jesus as a victim of abuse but not sexual abuse, and examine the issues linked to this. These include concerns over cultural and historical anachronism in attitudes to nudity, and arguments that the stripping is not intended to be sexual. It will then present a case for naming the stripping as sexual abuse and will conclude that recognition of Jesus as a victim of sexual abuse can support positive new approaches in practical theology. These approaches can strengthen church responses to sexual harassment, sexual assault and sexual abuse. In particular, they can help challenge tendencies within the churches, as well as in wider society, to collude with victim blaming or shaming.
|
Using Classroom Memes to Generate Class Discussions
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Carl N. Toney, Hope International University
Teachers are continually looking for relevant tools to contextually engage students in classroom discussions and to spread ideas beyond the classroom. One tool is the “image macro,” which is a popular form of “internet memes” and is composed of words superimposed upon a digital image. The assignment begins when students are tasked with creating a “classroom meme” in response to their weekly reading. Through this act of creation students engage at a higher level of Bloom’s taxonomy of learning rather than traditional forms of assessing student’s reading comprehension, such as class notes or quizzes that measure acquired knowledge. Further, in light of the mantra “form equals function,” classroom memes help generate good discussions because, by nature, memes spread cultural ideas, symbols, or practices from person to person. When students share their classroom memes, they transfer their online habits into the classroom because they are fluent with internet memes, which are interactive by nature, encourage communication between others, and elicit feedback, comments, opinions, etc. Classroom memes also help students to take greater ownership of their learning because students are generating classroom instructional content. Further, ideas continue to flourish outside of the classroom as students and instructors share their memes with others on the internet.
|
Women’s Bodies Don’t Make a Difference: Circumcision as Jewish-Christian Borderline
Program Unit: Construction of Christian Identities
M. Adryael Tong, Fordham University
From the second-century apologist Justin Martyr, who argued that circumcision was “given as a sign” to differentiate Jews from Christians (Dialogue 16.3) to “A Short World History of Christianity” (Mullin 2015), which designates circumcision as “the old dividing line” (16) between Christians and Jews, circumcision has been envisioned as a primary borderline between Judaism and Christianity. This paper, however, interrogates the effects of using of circumcision as a theoretical category for determining Jewish-Christian difference. In particular, I argue that the continued usage of circumcision as a differentiating mechanism results in the exclusion of women’s bodies qua women’s bodies as bearers of religious difference. In other words, women’s bodies––as long as they are marked by femininity––cannot be determinants of Jewish or Christian identity. On the contrary, women’s bodies can only be truly marked as differentiating by application of a symbolic analog––and thus always secondary, derivative, and potentially counterfeit––to circumcision, an exclusively masculine and masculinist signifier. Put simply, women’s bodies can only signify Jewish-Christian difference inasmuch as they are circumcised––that is, inasmuch as they are rendered legible within a masculine form of difference-making. My paper examines the way late antique Jewish and Christian texts both designate circumcision as an exclusively masculine signifier––in fact, as a guarantor of masculinity. The Mishnah and Tosefta designate circumcision as a fundamental determiner in sexual difference––to be circumcised is to be male and vice versa. Justin and Cyprian, however, take the Jewish equation of circumcision and maleness as evidence of its inferiority and present spiritual circumcision as its gender-neutral alternative. However, divorcing circumcision––even in its spiritual form––from its inherent masculinity was far more difficult than Justin or Cyprian could have expected. As a result, Jews and Christians were faced with this question: if circumcision is what men and only men do, and if it is the determinant par excellence of Jewish-Christian difference, how can women ever be truly Jewish or Christian? I examine two answers to this question, one from the Babylonian Talmud and one from the fourth-century Christian Bishop Zeno of Verona. Both the Talmud and Zeno present the same argument: in order for women to signify a Jewish or a Christian identity, they have to “count” as circumcised. I finish my exploration of this topic with a question: how should we interpret this? Is this an example, as Irigaray might suggest, of the current impossibility of (and desperate need for) an ethics of sexual difference? Can women only be truly Jewish or Christian inasmuch as they participate in a masculinist and masculinizing signification? Or, is this an example of a necessary queerness of Jewish and Christian women––a shared queerness that is often occluded through an overemphasis on a difference structured and necessitated through patriarchy?
|
Some Thoughts on awtad and What's a(t) Stake
Program Unit: Linguistic, Literary, and Thematic Perspectives on the Qur’anic Corpus (IQSA)
Shawkat M. Toorawa, Yale University
For centuries the term awtad in the expression dhi l-awtad, used in the Qur'an to describe Fir‘awn, has been understood to mean “tent-pegs” or “stakes,” (possibly) used by Pharaoh to torture his subjects. Classical commentators, and most modern scholars following them, have accepted this interpretation. A small number of modern readers (among them translators, lay exegetes, scholars) have proposed “pyramids” as a better translation. I will briefly review the classical view, survey the (minority) plea for “pyramids” and the (good) reasons for it, and then consider why “pyramids” might also be… wrong.
|
Living Interpretation, Living Faith: How Apostolic Pentecostals in Managua Use the Bible
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Laura Jean Torgerson, Graduate Theological Union
Observers of religion in Latin America have quipped, “the Catholic church opted for the poor, but the poor opted for Pentecostalism.” Pentecostalism is a major factor in the shift since the 1970s from the near-monopoly of the Roman Catholic church across the region to religiously pluralistic societies. Nicaragua is one of the countries in which this recent shift has been the most dramatic. A 2014 survey found that only 49% of Nicaraguans identified as Catholic. Nearly three-quarters of Nicaraguan Protestants are Pentecostal. Nicaragua is also the poorest country in Central America, and the second poorest in the Western hemisphere, as measured by GDP (gross domestic product) per capita.
This paper is based on an ethnographic study of biblical interpretation in a Nicaraguan Apostolic Pentecostal congregation in a “barrio popular” (a poor neighborhood) in Managua, the capital city. This study examines the practices of interpretation as they are lived in the congregation: through singing, ritual reading of the Bible, preaching, teaching, and daily life. Aspects that affect interpretation include: which verses or passages are most often repeated in worship and other communal activities, how biblical text is invoked, which translation of the Bible is used, which verses are committed to memory, who is regarded as an authoritative interpreter, and others. Taken together, these practices express and construct communal norms of interpretation.
The denomination to which this congregation belongs is part of the Apostolic branch of Pentecostalism, which, early in the history of the Pentecostal movement, was persuaded by a reading of the Bible that rejects traditional formulations of the Trinity. These Unitarian (Oneness) Pentecostals require baptism by immersion with the liturgical formula “in the name of Jesus,” and re-baptize those who have been baptized with the Trinitarian formula. They have been in Nicaragua for a century and are one of the largest Pentecostal denominations in the country. They remain in a minority status, however, because most Pentecostals are Trinitarian.
Based on participant observation in this congregation and interviews with key congregational leaders, this paper will focus on Pentecostal Bible reading and interpretation in this particular context, especially as the Bible is used to construct Apostolic Pentecostal identity. Drawing on approaches from the ethnography of reading and discourse analysis, this paper offers an example of methods that can be used to study how the Bible is used in a variety of contexts.
|
The Göttingen Edition of III-IV Kingdoms: The Recension Criticism Approach
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Pablo Torijano, Universidad Complutense de Madrid
The critical edition of LXX Kings poses a immense challenge for the textual critic. The OG of Kings underwent a heavy recensional process that reached till Origen recension and that affected in different degrees the text. To solve that conundrum and establish the critical text of LXX Kings we have used what we called Recensional criticism. In this method, it is necessary to distinguish between readings of a pre-Hexaplaric recension and the readings of the OG itself. The ways to approach this original text include a careful assesment of the Antiochene Greek text (19-82-93-108-127 and partially in 700, 460) in its “pre-Lucianic” readings, as well as the preserved remains of the Old Latin version and reading in the oldest, pre-Hexaplaric stratum of the Armenian versions. In this paper we will present several examples of such method that show our understanding of the history of the text and the impact it has on the critical edition of these books.
|
1 Kgs 11:1–10: Problems and Solutions
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Historical Books
Pablo Torijano, Universidad Complutense de Madrid
The literary unit of 1 Kgs 11:1-10, framed as such by petuhot, is characterized by the different order of the text in MT and LXX, as well by the absence of several MT elements in LXX. This passage is a good example to show the different behaviour of the groups of Greek manuscripts, to remake the process of recension of the OG text and to acknowledge the formation of the Hebrew text from the fusion of two different textual traditions. However, this unit constitutes a challenge for the textual critic and shows the problems and limits of a critical edition in LXX Kings since the usual approaches do not allow to reflect adequately the process of edition and textual transmission of this passage. In the present paper we will present a solution proposal for the problems of the Hebrew and Greek text of this passage and a preliminary edition of the Greek text. The proposed solution modifies in some aspects the one advanced by Joosten in his sample edition of the Hebrew text of 1 Kgs 11:1-8.
|
The Special Character of the Masoretic Text of Samuel
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Historical Books
Emanuel Tov, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
This lecture is the key note lecture of this year´s Sam-Kings Text Criticism Program Unit
|
Outcast in the Deserts of Hopelessness
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Emilie M. Townes, Vanderbilt University
It was not until Delores Williams’ Sisters in the Wilderness that Black women’s experiences and modes of survival were given theological voice as a companion and/or corrective to the dominant mode of liberation found in Black Theology. This womanist response helped provide a thicker description of Black religious thought and modes of being—female and male. I explore what this expanded discourse has been used in womanist social ethics and ongoing battle that Black folk wage for our humanity.
|
An Illiterate Farm Boy?: Joseph Smith’s Use of the Bible from 1828-1830
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
Colby Townsend, Utah State University
Many researchers of early Mormon history have assumed that due to his lack of formal education Joseph Smith, Jr. was not directly familiar with the Bible through his own reading and engagement with the book. Based on the idea that Smith was an illiterate or uneducated farm boy who rarely read, some have argued that it was virtually impossible that Smith was capable of composing his own literature. Consequently, Smith’s texts are only explicable in terms of the supernatural and they defy authorial examination as literature using the same methods to determine the compositional nature of other sacred historical texts, like the separate books of the Bible itself for example.
Most of the assumptions used in the previous literature on this topic are problematic. It is my contention that these assumptions need to be reevaluated in scholarship on the origins of the Book of Mormon primarily because they do not fit the material record left by Smith and his scribes. More critical, exploratory, and detailed analyses of the historical evidence are necessary for further studies on this important aspect of Smith’s early religious career. Smith was exposed to biblical phraseology at religious revivals, through standard education and homeschooling typical of early nineteenth century America, during family devotionals, and by reading the Bible directly. A reevaluation of previous assumptions is in order.
This paper suggests a new direction for research on the production of early Mormonism’s religious texts. I apply historical-critical methods from biblical studies including text, source, and a blend of inner-biblical exegesis and intertextual criticism to describe the depth of Joseph Smith’s familiarity with the Bible between 1828–1830. I also detail how he utilized biblical narratives to construct his new religious literature at that time. Specifically, I will examine the influence of King James Bible language on the composition of the early revelations Smith received that are now designated Doctrine and Covenants sections 3–23. Highlighting several distinct phrases and language, I will compile a list of the most influential biblical texts that catalyzed Smith’s compositional work.
Smith’s knowledge of the Bible directly affected not only his daily ministry within early Mormonism but also informed the narratives of the Book of Mormon, his Bible revision, and his revelations that were published later in the Book of Commandments (1833) and Doctrine and Covenants (1835). More specific knowledge about the extent of Smith’s familiarity of the Bible during 1828–1830 illuminates Mormon beginnings. This can help turn scholars toward more sound methods of collecting data and help to place Mormon scripture within the established field of the reception history of the Bible.
|
Echoes in Ephesus: "From the beginning" in the Johannine Letters and in Ephesian Foundation Myths
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Paul Trebilco, University of Otago
In 1 and 2 John, the phrase ‘from the beginning’ is used a total of ten times – a surprising number, given their short length. In each case, the stress is on ‘antiquity’ or on ‘foundations’. This emphasis resonates with the foundation stories of the cult of Artemis and other stories in the city of Ephesus; the sense of ‘looking back’ to antiquity was a vital part of what it was to be an Ephesian. In this context, it was entirely understandable for John as an author to speak of ‘what was from the beginning’, which for him referred to the one true ‘foundation story’, the one they had heard ‘from the beginning’, concerning the person, life, death and resurrection of Jesus.
|
Should I Pray for the Peace or Destruction of Babylon? The Intersection of Enemy Love and Imprecatory Psalms in the Old Testament
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Charlie Trimm, Talbot School of Theology (Biola University)
Should I Pray for the Peace or Destruction of Babylon? The Intersection of Enemy Love and Imprecatory Psalms in the Old Testament
|
The End of Islands: Drawing Insight from Revelation to Respond to Prisoner Radicalization and Apocalyptically-Oriented Terrorism
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Eric M. Trinka, Catholic University of America
John’s Apocalypse possesses a distinctly islanded nature. Additionally, John’s revelatory experience contains multiple carceral images. Thus, through the intersecting conceptual frameworks of insularity (islandedness) and incarceration, this paper engages apocalyptic religious texts in relation to the problems of prisoner radicalization and apocalyptically-oriented terrorism. Islands, prisons, prisoners and terrorism share a robust set of real and metaphorical relationships. This paper places findings from the fields of biblical and religious studies in conversation with the disciplines of geography, criminology, and terrorism studies to elucidate the place of apocalyptic literature in modern terrorism and the impact of carceral spaces on individual’s readings of apocalyptic texts. Reading the insular and carceral elements of Revelation in tandem with research on the pressing issues of apocalyptically-oriented religious terrorism and prisoner radicalization is instructive for cultivating alternatives to destructive readings and actualizations of religious literature like Revelation. This paper argues that the islanded nature of John’s experience can point readers toward constructive interpretations of such texts in physically and ideologically insular environments because the liminality of John’s experience provides a valuable point of access for readers who find themselves in similarly marginalized social locations that are fertile sites for violently anti-social behavior. Finally, this paper explores how John’s vision culminates in the end of islands (Rev 21:1) and concludes that through its depiction of the end of insularity, Revelation provides a rich symbolic framework to engage ideologically insular and destructively radical ways of being.
|
Listening to Paul: Letter Collections as a Narrative Genre
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
David Trobisch, Museum of the Bible
Having looked at over 200 letter collections published in antiquity, the observation that the genre tries to tell a story, emerged as the single most important insight. Recurring characters, places, and conflicts move the plot forward. Telling stories through a set of letters is like telling them through a series of still images, each one capturing a single moment. The paper will demonstrate a literary appreciation of the 14-Letters-of-Paul Book following the implied reading instructions of the genre. Special attention will be given to the crucial role of the Pastorals and the Letter to Hebrews in the context of the editorial narrative of the collection.
|
Poll the Classroom: A Tool for Active Learning
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Troy M. Troftgruben, Wartburg Theological Seminary
(10-minute teaching tip for biblical studies)
For teaching classrooms with many students, especially hybrid classrooms, soliciting feedback and responses from learners is tricky: time is precious, accessibility is not 100% equal, and often only the most talkative voices speak up. This poses a real challenge to teaching biblical interpretation in a way that models collaborative dialogue (vs. monologue).
A tool I have found helpful for soliciting and sharing learner feedback quickly is online polling (“Poll the Classroom”), used at set times and made accessible via a course site or texting. The poll is multiple choice, simple in design, easy to use, and enjoyable to learners—and free to use, depending on the program (multiple ones are available). Using a strategic poll, a class can enter into a biblical text using the prod of a specific question, followed by a relatively quick snapshot of the class’s responses. The question is not an end in itself, but a springboard to deepening the conversation by reflecting the class’s initial thoughts, whether diverse or lopsided. Armed with this awareness, the instructor can work more deliberately to challenge a majority opinion or to encourage more constructive dialogue in the ensuing time. The tool works especially well for hybrid classroom settings, with both synchronous and asynchronous students, since it gives all students equal access to voicing their feedback. It also models active learning in a way that values the input of all types of learners.
|
Jacob’s Vision in Bethel (Gen. 28:10–22)
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Jason Tron, Claremont School of Theology
Gen. 28:10-22 breaks the Jacob cycle in to two minor cycles. The narrative stands between the Jacob – Esau stories and the Jacob- Laban stories. The narrative in Gen. 28:10- 22 is not necessary for the development of the plot. Jacob is running away from his brother to Padan Aram, why tell a story about a dream he had one night, when he was on his journey to Aram? This story was inserted in the middle of the Jacob cycle for theological reasons: Israel’s right to the land is divine.Understanding the dreams in the book of Genesis as prophetic dreams points to the history of Israel, but does not necessarily point to the Judean monarchy.
Genesis 28 describes Jacob’s dream about a ladder that is based in the ground with its top in the sky. This vision resembles prophetic call narratives, such as Samuel. In 1Samuel 3, God reveals himself at night to the young Samuel at the northern sanctuary Shiloh. In a similar way Jacob’s revelation is portrayed as a dream.
The proof of the Gen. 28 vision being E-source can be found through theological and historical analyses, including: (1) the theological differences between Bethel as a divine location in Gen. 28 and as a place of sin in later Deuteronomistic sources, such as Kings; (2) Northern elements of divine-mortal relationships, such as the use of visions and dreams, compared to other interactions from differing sources; (3) analysis of the appearance and role of the sulam ( ladder), compared to historical architecture such as the ramp at the temple at Dan and the ramp at the ziggurat at Babylon.
First, differences around the role of Bethel include the use of different divine names, the sacredness of the Bethel location, and the importance of Bethel as a key sanctuary of the Northern Kingdom. Second, the E source is characterized by a physically distant relationship between God and human beings: God is represented by angels, burning bushes, dreams, or visions. In comparison, the J source shows direct contact between God and mortals, such as seen in Genesis 2-3. Following this logic, elements of Jacob’s vision of God at Bethel (Genesis 28) point to the E source. Third, term sulam can mean a ramp, such as seen in the temple at Dan, and might have been at the temple of Bethel. Jacob’s ladder might be a direct image of Northern temples. Exploring these three elements (name and role of Bethel, divine-mortal relationships, and the sulam) can show the thread of an original E-source that was later redacted by pro-Judean J-source.
|
The Prophet Joel, on Paper
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Ronald L. Troxel, University of Wisconsin-Madison
Recognition that the book of Joel is scribal prophecy voids speculating about Joel's social location or seeing a specific occasion for his speech. Instead, it spurs consideration of the role of the prophetic figure as part of the book's literary structure. Seen in that light, it is possible to distinguish between the Joel who summons the elders and inhabitants of the land to hear of an unprecedented event and the prophetic voice who speaks within that recounted event. Distinguishing these voices makes use of Jerome's early recognition that the book is a narrative whose prophet plays a pivotal role.
|
Christian Epigraphic Travelogues: Religious Topography and Identity
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Ekaterini Tsalampouni, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki
Τhe paper discusses a small number of Christian inscriptions that contain travel narratives of ancient Christians. Apart from the famous Abercius inscription some more inscriptions of the same period describe the adventures of Christians. They are certainly not an exclusively Christian phenomenon since some non-Christian examples of similar itineraries have come to light. In the first part of the paper, the circumstances that led to the production of such texts and their social and historical context will be briefly discussed. The Christian epigraphic travelogues will also be compared to similar texts of a non-Christian milieu of the same period in order to trace down similar or different strategies in constructing sacred geographic spaces. Special emphasis will be laid on the political and religious importance of such sacred geographies. Finally, the language of these Christian texts, its symbolic content and its allusion to biblical texts will be examined in order to determine how it contributes to the construction and public display of Christian identities.
|
Thessalonians Read 1 Thessalonians: A Preliminary Report of the Byzantine Project
Program Unit: Novum Testamentum Graecum: Editio Critica Maior
Ekaterini Tsalampouni, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki
This is a preliminary report of the Byzantine Project run by the Department for the Study of Manuscript Tradition of the Volos Academy of Theological Studies. In its first phase, this project aims at producing a critical edition of the Byzantine text of the 1 & 2 Thessalonians and the ultimate prospect is to provide useful data for a searchable New Testament manuscript database where various base texts will be included. The group of Thessaloniki has been working on the transcription of the text of 1 Thessalonians in the Byzantine manuscripts for two years. In this report, the philosophy, the aims and the structure of the project will be presented as well as one or two examples of the data gathered in the previous years.
|
Testament of the Lord: Its Countenance in the Ethiopic Eucharistic Prayers
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Fanos W. Tsegaye, University of St. Andrews
In most scholarly endeavour the Syriac influence in the Ethiopic Christianity is treated as 'secondary' in contrast to the attention given to the Coptic and the Jewish origins. This ignores the broad historical relation of the two traditions in Christian history, monastic traditions and liturgy unlike the conjuncture of these liturgical tradition which until recently obtained inadequate attention. This study therefore attempts to draw attention to the influence of Syriac Christianity in the Ethiopic liturgy.
The Syriac heritage of the Ethiopic liturgy is exemplified in the Liturgy of the Lord, a derivate of the Syrian anaphora of the Testament of the Lord. The anaphora treasured in both traditions as the last word of Our Lord Jesus Christ given to the Apostles 'after his resurrection and before his ascension' concerning 'the things pertaining to the Kingdom of God' (Acts 1:3). Its prominence in the Ethiopic tradition manifest in different prayer patterns adopted in the liturgy and other prayer books among them are: 'Concerning Holy Things' - [በእንተ ቅድሳት - bä'ǝnǝtä ḳǝdǝsatǝ], 'the admonition'- [በሰማይ የሀሉ ልብክሙ - bäsämayǝ yähälu lǝbǝkǝmu] and Holy, Holy, Holy, Ineffable Trinity" [ቅዱስ ቅዱስ ቅዱስ ሥሉስ ዘኢይትነገር - ḳeduśe, ḳeduśe, ḳeduśe, Śəlus Zä-iyətənägärə]. This paper particularly explores the influence of the prayer 'Pilot of the Soul' [ሐዳፌ ነፍስ - Haddafe Näfəs], which is appropriated in all Ethiopic anaphoras. The study engages in a historical -theological analysis of the Syriac Testament of the Lord and the Ethiopic anaphora to identify 1) the theological meaning of the prayer and its significance of the prayer in Syriac liturgical context, 2) its usage and theological meaning in the Ethiopic liturgical context and 3) its theological significance in the whole liturgical structure of the Ethiopic Liturgy.
This paper will first provide a brief introduction of the study to describe its contribution to the historical-theological study of these early Christian liturgical tradition. Second, it will analyse the historical and theological origin of the Syriac text of the Testament of the Lord with special attention to the of Pilot of the soul. Third, it will analyse the usage of the prayer in the anaphoras of the current Ethiopic liturgy. Fourth, it will discuss the theological meaning attached and its significance within the whole structure of the Ethiopic liturgy. Finally, a conclusion will be made on historical theological influence of the Anaphora of The Testament of the Lord to illustrate the continuities between these ancient liturgical traditions.
|
Ben Sira’s Praise of the Fathers: A Narrative of Unmatched Perfection
Program Unit: Deuterocanonical and Cognate Literature
Pete Tsimikalis , University of Oxford
The Praise of the Fathers within the book of Ben Sira has grasped my attention for three reasons: (1) the inclusion of particularized sentiments in what, until that time, was a “genre” completely dominated by universal principles, was innovative; (2) the object of this praise was not God, but people, which was a novelty; (3) the inclusion and placement of the protagonists within the Praise is curious.
Scholars have been trying to identify its function for some time, but the ambiguous nature of the pursuit has led to very little consensus. The unit has been understood in a multitude of ways, ranging from an encomium, to a parenetic apologetic, to a lengthy proverb regarding the consequences of action.
Although there is little consensus regarding its specific function, there is widespread agreement in its exemplary purpose. However, as Annette Reed notes, “In the modern West, the assumption of the exemplarity of the biblical past has perhaps become so naturalized that it is almost inevitable. It is often taken for granted…” Thinking with Reed, amongst others such as Hindy Najman, I would like to use the framework of perfectionist ethics to provide an alternative to the aforementioned exemplary understanding.
I argue that the Praise, although seemingly a list comprised of exemplary figures intended to be imitated and/or emulated, is actually a nuanced deviation of this understanding. The protagonists of the Praise are not exemplars, but rather examples of the perfect Israelite leader at a given time. Ben Sira glosses perfect historical leaders as a way to assert that the current leader of the time, Simeon II, was indeed the rightful leader of the Israelites. When viewed in this regard, the Praise operates as a pedagogic performance, with the function of describing the figures within the Praise as perfect examples of leadership, rather than perfect exemplars of wisdom.
I use three main pieces of evidence to arrive at this thesis: (1) Ben Sira characterizes the figures of the Praise as being part of a select group which receives a special wisdom as a gift (what I call “chkmt lv”), and not through human achievement; (2) Ben Sira is clear throughout his book that his audience is first and foremost future sages/wise men/scribes, yet he purposefully omits referencing such figures within his Praise that could actually serve in an exemplary capacity (such as Ezra or Baruch); (3) the negatively depicted figures in the Praise cannot be exemplary, as being an exemplar implies a perfect model. I will demonstrate that these three pieces of evidence, amongst others, make it incongruous to understand the figures in the Praise as exemplary.
These assertions lead to a secondary thesis. The only exemplar included within the book is the one who is also carefully differentiated from all others: the character of Ben Sira himself. This ideal exemplar manages to function on two levels within the Praise: by operating as the conscious authorial voice and by operating within the text itself.
|
The Translation Character of Septuagint Jeremiah
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Miika Tucker, University of Helsinki
The Septuagint book of Jeremiah (Jer LXX) has been described as one of the more complex books in the Septuagint. Reasons for this revolve around the textual history of the book, with regard to both its Greek text and Hebrew Vorlage. The translation equivalents in the Greek text vary to a significant degree between the two halves of the translation, and the Hebrew text of Jeremiah (Jer MT) contains ca. 3000 words that are not represented in the Greek text. These features have raised important questions regarding the unity and the text critical value of the translation. A crucial step in explaining these features is to understand the translation character of the Greek text. A characterization of the translation can identify possible differences within the translation character of the book and is a necessary prerequisite to determining the text critical value of the translation.
This presentation is an introduction and summary of my soon to be finished dissertation project on Septuagint Jeremiah. My dissertation consists of a translation technical analysis of both lexical and syntactic equivalents in the Greek text of Jeremiah with the aim of contributing to the discussion on the text critical issues mentioned above. Several features of the translation character of Jer LXX have already been identified in previous research. My dissertation will advance the characterization of the translation with the hope that it will serve further research into the text critical questions of the book.
|
Closing the Loop: The Challenge of Writing a Psalms Commentary in an Era of Biblical Illiteracy
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
W. Dennis Tucker, Baylor University
Invited paper.
|
Peshitta Ruth: Insights from Translating the Mosul Text for the Antioch Bible
Program Unit: International Syriac Language Project
Eric J. Tully, Trinity Evangelical Divinity School
Insights gleaned from translating the Mosul Text of Peshitta Ruth for the Antioch Bible Set by Gorgias Press will be presented. These include a description of the relationship between MT and P-Ruth, distinctive readings and their exegetical implications, and insights for the Peshitta as a witness for Old Testament textual criticism.
|
Listening to the Griever: Preaching from Lamentations
Program Unit: Homiletics and Biblical Studies
Adam Tune, Cumberland University
An often forgotten notion about the texts within the Bible is that they were written from and in response to real life. This is especially true in the cases of the Laments. Times of grief and pain are not only opportunities to help comfort those who need words from the Divine, but they provide a homiletical occasion to listen to the wailing prayers of others who once needed the same.
The five chapters of Lamentations are among the saddest in scripture. The preacher will do well to both listen to its cries, and to notice the structure by which those cries are organized. There is a story to be told within its pages that has the rare ability to quench the spiritual thirst of an audience in pain. Like those of us who mourn in real life, the composer of Lamentations wants the audience to think that the grief is only temporary and that even though sadness looms, it does not possess the soul. But what the reader discovers in this national lament is that grief cannot be ignored, it cannot be tamed, and it cannot be buried. No amount of organization and professionalism will prevent the sadness from overcoming the writer. And when homilies utilize not only the words of Lamentations, but the author’s own emotions, the hearers of the word can find assurance that they were not the only ones who find themselves in danger of losing hope.
|
Paul and the Politics of Translation
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
Ekaputra Tupamahu, Vanderbilt University
The appearance of the noun ἑρμηνεία (12:10) and verb διερμηνεύω (12:30; 14:5,13,27; and the noun διερμηνευτής in 14:28) is one of the greatest challenges for those who hold the view that tongue(s) in 1 Cor 14 is an unintelligible ecstatic experience because translation, especially from one language to another, generally assumes and requires some degree of intelligibility on both the source and the target languages. Translation is an act of making the intelligible source language understandable to the target language.
In this paper, I will read Paul's use of these terms, i.e., ἑρμηνεία and διερμηνεύω, in light of the way Philo uses them. The discussion on διερμηνεύω (or διερμηνευτής) is critical because it demonstrates the political force of Paul's demand from tongue(s) speakers, i.e., minority language speakers. When Paul states in 14:5 that he wants everyone to prophesy instead of speaking in foreign languages, he further adds this statement "unless [the speaker] translates it thoroughly [διερμηνεύῃ]." Here Paul does not just require a translation, he wants it to be a "thorough" translation. Minority language speakers have to subject themselves thoroughly to the force of language of the dominant group. As Eric Cheyfitz has argued, translation is an integral part of the imperial expansionist enterprise. In this paper, I will argue that the demand for thorough translation is a political project intended to subjugate all knowledge and culture under the superior rule of the dominant group.
It is important to note, however, that translation never exactly represents the intention of the original text and writer. There is always an inexactness or impreciseness in every translation because linguistic representation is partial. As Hans-Georg Gadamer puts it: "the translation of a text, however much the translator may have dwelt with and empathized with his author, cannot be simply a re-awakening of the original process in the writer's mind; rather, it is necessarily a re-creation of the text guided by the way the translator understands what it says." Thus, even when a translation is provided it will produce an expansive locus of inaccuracy. This linguistic inaccuracy or impreciseness is the space of linguistic resistance and disruption against the dominating language.
|
Eboni Marshall Turman Reads Delores Williams' Sisters in the Wilderness
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Eboni Marshall Turman, Yale University
*
|
D-Codex: Software for Digital Manuscript Transcription, Analysis, and Publication
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
Robert Turnbull, Ridley College Melbourne
D-Codex is a software platform for digitally editing families of manuscripts. This presentation outlines the major features of the software and illustrates them through a test-case in editing what Hikmat Kashouh designated Family A of the Arabic Gospel manuscript corpus. Family A is a version of the Gospels translated from Greek into Arabic and was in use by the Palestinian Greek Orthodox (Melkite) community from the eighth century and contains many non-Byzantine readings. Test passages from each of the witnesses of this family are transcribed using the D-Codex web-interface and this is used to create a stemma for the transmission history of this family. This stemma is used to reconstruct the Ausgangstext for this version which can be displayed on the web via D-Codex together with a critical apparatus. It is hoped that this program will be useful to others working with biblical manuscripts by streamlining their workflow and providing analytic tools to investigate relationships between texts.
|
Ritual and Contemplative Techniques of Ascension and Mystical Union with the Divine in Gnostic and Related Literature
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
John D. Turner, University of Nebraska - Lincoln
A comparison of selected Sethian, Valentinian, and Hermetic treatises reveal a general line of development in which the objective acts of earthly ritual become displaced by the verbal performances of a heavenly liturgy in which the participant is elevated to angelic status and thenceforward to increasingly silent acts of visionary imagination, culminating in techniques of self-reflexive cognition that result in assimilation to the divine reality itself.
|
Primeval Desire (Genesis 3) and Its Paradigmatic Role for Reading Biblical Hebrew Narrative Texts of Perilous Passion
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Cephas Tushima, Jos ECWA Theological Seminary (JETS)
The biblical Hebrew texts of sexual politics (often involving sordid sexual violence, especially against women) have been studied in the last forty years with ideological bent, employing contemporary literary analysis. This essay is an attempt to allow the biblical text to furnish strategies for reading its troubling narratives rather imposing external ideologies over it. An ethical narrative close reading of the text of primeval desire (Gen 3) led me to the discovery of five themes (desire—particularly its derivative, sexual passion; power-play; alterity; peril; and the characterization of God, in divine response to human deviant behavior) as heuristic tools for reading these texts of desire.
|
Undoing Paul: Imagining Apostolic Insecurity
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Jay Twomey, University of Cincinnati
Despite the fact that any careful reader of the New Testament can see the Apostle Paul’s complexities, the vast majority of interpreters have always also been remarkably tempted to discover in Paul a culturally-foundational consistency of one stripe or another by means of a figure who embodies, and often heroically, a fantasy of achievement, completion. But a number of New Testament scholars (e.g., Elisabeth Schussler Fiorenza, Elizabeth Castelli, Joseph Marchal, Laura Nasrallah, Shelly Matthews, and others) have been complicating the Pauline picture considerably, often by re-describing the epistles from the perspective(s) of the disempowered and marginalized, including those whom Paul chastises or overlooks in his letters, or those harmed by histories of sexist, homophobic, and racist Pauline interpretation. My book, Undoing Paul: Imagining Apostolic Insecurity, inspired by such scholarship, explores recent cultural texts produced over the last half century and more that approach Paul and the Pauline story in terms of surprise, distraction, confusion, disappointment and other affective modalities of failure (v. achievement) or in-completion. A common trend in gospel retellings over the same general period has been to humanize the character of Jesus, often thereby to rescue Jesus from unappealing or restrictive theological contexts. By contrast, some of the most intriguing treatments of Paul frequently take aim at Paul himself, as though the best way to reimagine Paul were to think him, creatively, out of existence. Undoing Paul begins with an introduction discussing the key terms in my title: undoing and insecurity. Thereafter I set my primary texts into tense conversation with an authoritative Paul of a key cultural moment (the Civil Rights Movement, the Cold War, 9/11) or problem (neoliberalism, the return of authoritarianism, white supremacy). And throughout I discuss the work of well-known figures like Martin Luther King, Jr., Pier Paolo Pasolini, Flannery O’Connor, and Gore Vidal alongside the lesser-known, like the graphic novelist Steve Ross, evangelical hip-hop artist Lecrae, experimental playwright Sarah Kane, and others. On the panel I’d like to present undoing as a metaphor for reception. I’ll take into consideration the ways in which recent important statements – Aichele, Miscall, & Walsh (2009); Beal (2011); England & Lyons (2015) – about or informing reception work seek to undo broad disciplinary tendencies. I’ll also point to the occasional if not always fully thematized aim of “undoing” within particular reception projects. Simply put, the central impulse here is to present, as a valuable way of doing reception study, Judith Butler’s double charge from Undoing Gender that “one must enter into a collective work in which one’s own status as a subject must, for democratic reasons, become disoriented, exposed to what it does not know” (36).
|
Textuality and Identity in the Qumran Pesharim on Isaiah
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Shani Tzoref, Universität Potsdam
This paper re-visits my published research on the reception of the book of Isaiah in the Qumran Isaiah pesharim, with the aim of bringing my analyses of textuality and identity into the session’s broader conversation about Isaiah in Second Temple literature, through the lens of Fortschreibung. I examine formal and rhetorical aspects of the Isaiah pesharim that illuminate their use of Isaiah as an authoritative text, addressing: textual fluidity and variance, the commentary form, and scribal practice. I further discuss how the pesherists’ often-creative adaptations of the text and its meanings reflect the self-understanding of the communities associated with these works within their socio-religious historical context. In particular, I examine the use of Isaiah as a source for polemic epithets in the pesharim to Isaiah, in a manner that exhibits similarity and difference to the use of epithets in other “sectarian” Qumran texts. This points to the pesherists’ extension of an earlier Isaianic identity-marking technique with dualistic overtones. It is part of a general tendency in the pesharim to pick up on, and to further concentrate, the concepts of Election, Judgment, and Eschatology that are so prominent in portions of the book of Isaiah and in the book’s reception history.
|
Becoming an Intentional Neighbor to Challenge Capitalism and Colonial Embedded Hermeneutics of the Gospels’ Memories
Program Unit: Poverty in the Biblical World
Paulo Ueti, Anglican Alliance/Anglican Communion Office
The reception of Leviticus 19:18 in the Jesus movement is challenged, and in some ways could be jeopardized, by the ideo-theological struggles that occurred during the process of canonization of the Second Testament. The imperial (and currently, the capitalist) eyes and hands managing memory choices, writings, and interpretations can prevent us from understanding the most important question, following Jesus’ path, which is not ‘Who is my neighbor?’ but ‘To whom do I intentionally place myself in relationship as neighbor?.' I would like to use some biblical texts and hermeneutical examples to picture the political intentionality of some interpretations and images of Jesus and his movement in order to address the conversation on the current power of religious discourses supporting xenophobia and exclusivity of belonging. Also, I would like to tackle the image of Jesus (as differently portrayed – as a dispute – in the NT) regarding his messianic identity: individual messiah – man, powerful, alone who is solving/saving all and fix everything--or collective, communitarian, allied, in need of collaboration?
|
Technology and Pedagogy in a Seminar on Intercultural Hermeneutics
Program Unit: Global Education and Research Technology
Daniel W. Ulrich, Bethany Theological Seminary
This paper reports on an experiment in the use of technology for global education. In January 2018 seventeen students and two professors gathered in two technologically-equipped classrooms for an intensive, post-graduate seminar titled, “Global Perspectives on Scripture: 1 Corinthians.” One classroom was in Jos, Plateau State, Nigeria, and the other in Richmond, Indiana, USA. Each was equipped with sensitive microphones, video cameras, and large-screen computer monitors, and high-speed internet connections. Video conferencing via Zoom allowed participants in the two classrooms to interact with one another in real time. The seminar was offered as a pilot project by Bethany Theological Seminary in partnership with Ekklesiyar Yan’uwa a Nigeria. Professors Pandang Yamsat from Nigeria and Daniel Ulrich from North America team-taught the seminar from their respective locations.
The seminar was designed to help students meet the following objectives: (1) describe and practice intercultural hermeneutics as a means for deepening readers’ understanding of, and engagement with, scripture; (2) interpret passages in 1 Corinthians with careful attention to their literary and historical contexts; (3) explain how Paul’s instructions for the Corinthians remain relevant in situations of communal conflict, cultural diversity, gender diversity and equality, economic inequality, or ethical uncertainty; (4) seek out and learn from the perspectives of interpreters from various social and geographical locations, including interpreters who are currently marginalized; (5) identify ways in which scripture challenges or affirms one’s own cultural presuppositions; and (6) communicate one’s own understandings of scripture clearly, confidently, and with openness to further insight.
By facilitating real-time interaction between participants in quite different cultural contexts, the technology employed was closely aligned with the seminar’s instructional design and objectives. The co-instructors repeatedly modeled intercultural hermeneutics through collaborative interpretations and discussions. Students practiced intercultural hermeneutics, first in groups that interpreted an assigned passage and then individually with opportunities for intercultural consultation about a passage of the student’s choice. Students experienced that 1 Corinthians can be heard differently in diverse cultural contexts while remaining highly relevant in each location.
Like the seminar itself, this paper will be a collaborative effort. Prof. Ulrich will speak face-to-face with attendees in Denver. Prof. Yamsat plans to speak from Jos, Nigeria, demonstrating the technology employed in the course. An educational technologist will be available to answer questions about the technology, speaking from the classroom in Richmond, Indiana. In addition to describing the alignment that was achieved between pedagogy and technology, the presenters will offer samples of intercultural interpretations of 1 Corinthians that emerged from the seminar. The presenters will also reflect on ways in which future editions of the course might improve.
|
Redeeming the Vestal Virgins: Afterlife and Reception in Hagiography and Medieval Literature
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Sissel Undheim, Universitetet i Bergen
As one of the most famous priesthoods of ancient Rome, the Vestal virgins lingered in collective memory and imagination long after the priestesses were gone from the temple of Vesta at Forum Romanum. Christian writers had in various ways evoked them as foils in texts written to recruit more consecrated virgins for the Church, and although the Vestals played no major part in the vast fourth century “virgin literature”, these implicit and explicit comparisons between “their virgins” and “ours” were elaborated on and found new expressions from the fifth century onwards.
As a starting point for investigating the late antique and medieval afterlife of the Vestals, I will focus on references to the so called crimen incesti, the crime that Vestals were accused of when they were no longer believed to be virgins. Despite relatively few documented historical prosecutions of this crime, this religious offense became a significant, although not the only, focus in the reception history of the Vestal virgins. Knowledge of this “crime”, of how it was punished, and of the stories that were spun around priestesses who were said to have proven their innocence when they had been wrongly accused, influence not only later representations of individual Vestals and the priesthood as such, but also representations of Christian virgins, thorough the entangled web of comparisons that we first encountered in the writings of Christian authors.
I will argue that late antique Christian writers’ comparisons between Vestal virgins and consecrated Christian virgins set the stage for some interesting roles to be played by Vestal virgins in Christian hagiography and later medieval literature. I will conclude with a brief discussion of how these late antique and medieval representations of Vestal virgins also came to influence modern studies of the priesthood.
|
“The Philosopher is Heard When He is Seen”: The Poetics of Clothing and the Philosopher’s Wardrobe in Second Sophistic and Early Christian Texts
Program Unit: Inventing Christianity: Apostolic Fathers, Apologists, and Martyrs
Arthur Urbano, Providence College (Rhode Island)
Efforts to conceptualize the engagement of Early Christian authors with Greek philosophical systems have frequently resulted in binary models that propose either an oppositional or syncretistic relationship: Christians either rejected philosophy; or they borrowed from it. Recent scholarship has explored the more complex dynamics of ancient education, intellectual culture, and social formation, including the participation of Christians (and eventual Christian converts) in Greek and Roman intellectual culture and educational structures as both students and teachers. As participants, Christians were both shaped by and played a role in shaping the intellectual landscape of Late Antiquity from within. This pertains not only to abstract intellectual systems, but also to practices and manners of self-representation.
In this paper I examine the discourse related to the “philosopher’s look” in several sources dated from the late first through third centuries C.E.: Dio Chrysostom’s Or. 72 (“On Appearance”), Epictetus’ Disc. 4 (on the true Cynic), Justin Martyr’s Dialogue with Trypho, and Tertullian’s On the Pallium (the Latin name for the philosopher’s robe). The “philosopher’s look” was an identifiable fashion of clothing, accessories, and hairstyles. It was a mode of personal appearance cultivated by knowledge-producers who laid claim to intellectual, pedagogical, and moral authority, especially in those schools of thought that traced a Socratic lineage. My analysis will focus on what Roland Barthes called the “poetics of clothing,” a fusion of material with language that shifted clothing from the functional to the spectacle, connected forms of dress to social, cultural, and economic matrices, and, in the process, afforded garments cultural capital and sublimity. Such discourse also built a homology between the materiality of dress and the metaphysical state of the soul. To Barthes framework I propose some additional categories: “tailoring rhetoric” whereby ancient intellectuals deployed fashion commentary either to ascribe or deny “authenticity” either to themselves or others; and “proper custody,” the conditions under which one would be recognized to have legitimately adopted the philosopher’s look.
The aim of this analysis is to demonstrate how second- and third-century Christian intellectuals participated in these customary discursive and sartorial practices in order to stake a claim in the larger intellectual field, to delimit the boundaries of Christian philosophy in relation to other competing schools, and to define the identity of the Christian philosopher. Rather than setting up “Christianity” and “philosophy” as an oppositional binary, such an analysis highlights the relationship between competitive rhetoric and identity formation and suggests that Christian rhetoric, rather than borrowing, contributed to the evolution of the idea of the “philosopher” in Late Antiquity.
|
In Search of Good Character: Ancestral Virtue in the Testament of Qahat
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Elisa Uusimäki, Helsingin Yliopisto - Helsingfors Universitet
This paper explores ethical instruction in the testamentary literature of the Dead Sea Scrolls, focusing on the so-called Testament of Qahat (4Q542), an Aramaic text originating from the late Second Temple period and discovered at Qumran. Can the category of ‘virtue’—i.e. human activity regarded as good and morally valuable—be associated with 4Q542, although the text is written in a Semitic language that lacks a separate term for it? This paper addresses both problems and benefits that pertain to discussing the selected writing in the context of virtue. Concentrating on the intersection between the transmission of the biblical tradition and the display of ancestral exemplarity, it argues that virtue is indeed attributed to characters of the Israelite narrative in 4Q542: the author employs biblical figures of the past in general and the figure of Qahat in particular as he exhorts the intended audience to pursue good behaviour. However, the portrayal of virtue in 4Q542 challenges the modern idea of virtue as a characteristic of an autonomous individual, as well as spelling out the significance of one’s relation to the divine in character formation. In so doing, 4Q542 demonstrates the need to choose an inclusive, open-ended approach rooted in descriptive/comparative ethics. In the light of such an approach, the Testament of Qahat, for one, appears as a distinctive witness to the variety of discourses concerning good life in the Mediterranean antiquity. The text invites scholars to rethink the study and scholarly narrative of the ancient ethical tradition, hitherto dominated by the perspectives of Greek philosophers and later Christian thinkers, by integrating Jewish sources into the enterprise.
|
Interrogating Diaspora: Engaging the Bible on a Hyphen
Program Unit: Islands, Islanders, and Scriptures
Nasili Vaka'uta, Trinity Methodist Theological College
This paper will interrogate the idea of diaspora from an Oceanic standpoint by engaging the ways in which the concept is theorised in diaspora studies alongside the lived experiences of islanders in so-called diaspora communities. I will argue that one cannot speak of diaspora without a notion of home (actual or imaginary). Between the two lies a hyphenated space from which a 'diasporic' person views the world and makes meaning. Out of such a space emerged the narratives we find in the Bible, and those narratives should, therefore, be read likewise, on the hyphen, where there are tensions amongst opposing notions of home.
|
Metaphysical Christians: Reading Spirits and Demons across Church Lines
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Katy E. Valentine, Creative Christian Spirituality
Few contextual biblical readings exist that embrace Christians across denominational lines and racial-ethnic groups. I propose a contextual biblical interpretation with a group I call “metaphysical Christians,” whose common identity is as highly intuitive or sensitive people who interact with the spirit world on a regular basis. These Christians experience ghosts, negative spirits/energy, and demons as physical realities, but they keep them secret from their churches. My paper will present a contemporary contextual interpretation of select biblical passages dealing with spirits and demons with this group of Christians. Participants will be drawn from members of a Facebook group that I administer called The Metaphysical Christian.
In general, the geographical context of the members of The Metaphysical Christian is North American and rich in racial-ethnic diversity. Members are “everyday” Christians who come from a variety of ecclesial backgrounds, including Pentecostal, Catholic, mainline Protestant, and Evangelical. While an intense interest in demons and spirits is discouraged by progressive Christianity but embraced widely among charismatic and evangelical Christianity, group members transgress these lines. The uniting factor for the group is an interest in metaphysical practices that extend beyond the traditional church box. At least half of the group members consider themselves to be intuitive, psychic, or gifted to interact with the spirit world. Group members bring up demons, dark entities, ghosts, and spirits (good or neutral) with regularity. Interpretations of spirits and demons differ based on church background and personal theology, and the conversations are lively. When I began this Facebook group in 2017, the claims of group members about their interactions with the spiritual world in fact surprised me. Nevertheless, for the group members, their experiences are real.
Despite the interest of the group in a wide variety of metaphysical practices, group members also express concern about their abilities. Many are troubled that they can sense spirits or demons, worried that their abilities may be sinful. The Bible Study that I propose will allow members to explore particular biblical passages in light of their own belief system and within a supportive group. Within the confines of the Bible Study, group members can articulate their own belief system and metaphysical experiences without fear of being laughed at (a common reality) or excommunicated from their churches (another common reality). Employing the methods of the Contextual Bible Study (West), group members will explore 1 Sam 28:3-25, Mark 9:1-9, and Acts 16:16-18, plus additional self-selected passages. These selections have cropped up multiple times in the Facebook group, both troubling and complicating self-perceptions of the members. My role in the Bible Study will be to facilitate and provide ancient context but not to convince the participants of any one reality. Many group members see their own metaphysical realities confirmed in such biblical passages.
In sum, I propose a contextual reading of demons and spirits in light of among “everyday” metaphysical Christians living in North America. These Christians are highly intuitive and gifted people for whom the spirit world, especially negative energy, ghosts, and demons, are very present.
|
The Conjunctive Accents in Relative Clauses
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Van Acker, David, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
This contribution studies the use of conjunctive accents within relative clauses. It hypothesises that relative clauses – generally speaking – are a secondary expansion of the main clause and therefore less emphasised. This implies that relative clauses would be characterised by conjunctive accents, for conjunctive accents add the accentuated word to the following word while disjunctive accents add a pause after a word thus emphasising it. Therefore clauses with relatively more conjunctive accents have less emphasis, but they also feature a higher rate of speech as there are less pauses. This would be especially obvious when two or more consecutive words are conjunctively accentuated. As both emphasis and rate of speech are manifestations of prosody, a correlation between relative clauses and a higher concentration of conjunctive accents would clearly illustrate the prosodic nature of the Masoretic accents. Furthermore it will allow scholars to identify other clauses with less (or more) emphasis by measuring their concentration of conjunctive accents.
A survey of the conditional accents in all 71877 non-relative clauses in the prose sections of the Hebrew Bible shows that 74.93% of all clauses have at least one conjunctive accent. Whereas conjunctive accents are found in 88.11% of all relative clauses. This already significant tendency is shown even clearer when one looks at the sequences of consecutive conjunctive accents. 6,78% of all non-relative clauses feature two or more consecutive conjunctive accents, compared to 14.84% of all relative clauses. This study will dig deeper in this tendency. An in depth comparison of relative clauses with their respective main clause will be performed and additional factors will be explored such as the length of the clause, the tense of the verbal predicate, or the syntactic function of the relative clause within the sentence.
|
Diaspora Studies, Hybridizing Movements, and Comparative Religion: Redescribing and Reframing the Study of the Historical Paul
Program Unit: The Historical Paul
Gerhard van den Heever, University of South Africa
While the history of the study of the apostle Paul since the Reformation has been predominantly theological in character, recent 'turns' in the study of Paul have inflected the 'standard Paul' with questions of ethnicity ('Paul within Judaism'; the 'New Perspective on Paul'; the 'radical perspective') as key to interpreting Paul's missionary programme. This paper does not offer a comprehensive programmatic frame with which to theorize the entrepreneurial cult foundation work of Paul. Rather, a modest proposal is offered: in keeping with the emphasis on classification and comparison in recent theorizing of religious discourses as part of a broader programme of redescription, this paper intends a twofold theoretical gesture. First, a comparative move is made to frame Paul in a setting of cult foundations in diaspora contexts in comparison with similar hybridizing movements in Africa typically characterized by translocal cult foundations, retraditionalization, and reimagined socio-cultic identities. Second, drawing on comparative work and re-classification a suggestion is made to reframe the issues described in the New Perspective and Radical Perspective so as to redescribe typical Pauline themes such as the Law/Gospel or the Jew/Gentile contrasts as social discourse in settings of identity ambiguities as quite normal phenomena in diaspora settings impacted by problematic interactions with homeland contacts.
|
Becoming Jews at Elephantine
Program Unit: Literature and History of the Persian Period
Karel van der Toorn, Universiteit van Amsterdam
Becoming Jews at Elephantine: The History of a Diaspora Community in Persian Egypt in Light of Papyrus Amherst 63.
The origins of the Jewish community at Elephantine Island have long been shrouded in mystery. It was neither clear exactly when they came to Egypt nor from where. Papyrus Amherst 63 sheds new light on both matters. The Aramaic text in Demotic characters shows that the ancestors of the Elephantine Jews came from Samaria. After the fall of Samaria they found shelter in the Aramaic-speaking city of Palmyra. Some hundred years later, around 600 BCE, they migrated to Egypt. These migrants to Egypt did not claim a Jewish identity when they came. Under the double impact of their diaspora in Egypt and the Persian politics of ethnic diversity they became the Elephantine Jews. For them the diaspora experience was not about preserving a Jewish identity but about developing one.
|
Job’s Emotional Struggle with the Womb: Some Psychoanalytic Interpretations
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Pieter van der Zwan, Universities of Vienna and Pretoria
Around 68 body-parts are mentioned in the book of Job, including all four words for the womb used in the Hebrew Bible. Twice he even alludes to God as having a womb, and another time probably refers to that of the Leviathan. Apart from equating his nameless mother with her womb and so reducing her to it, he curses that very base and origin of his existence when life makes no sense to him anymore, making him to regards the womb as a grave. Coupled with that is the relative absence of women in a book of 42 chapters, when these hints and a few mentions are considered exceptions. This conspicuous silence and such a complex attitude to the womb in a biblical book calls for some psychoanalytic interpretations.
|
The Linguistic Similarity between Qumran’s Core Texts: A Computational Stylistic Approach
Program Unit: Qumran
Pierre Van Hecke, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
It is commonly accepted that the non-biblical Dead Sea Scrolls can be divided in sectarian and non-sectarian compositions. Arguments for this distinction are on the one hand the particular content and ideology of the sectarian Scrolls, and the typical “sectarian” vocabulary found in them. On the other hand, it is argued that most of the sectarian Scrolls (as well as several biblical manuscripts) share common linguistic (orthographical and morphological) and scribal features (Tov 2004). Valuable though these features may be, the criteria by which they are extracted from the text and the way in which their relative importance for the classification of the Scrolls is weighed are mostly left implicit.
In this contribution, this lacuna is filled by applying recent developments in computational stylistics to the study of the Scrolls. This methodology allows for the automatic extraction and selection of linguistic features from the Scrolls and for state-of-the-art computation of the pairwise distances between each document on the basis of a large number of these features. It will be shown that this approach provides robust quantitative arguments for the existence of a core group of major Dead Sea Scrolls sharing a statistically relevant high number of linguistic characteristics. Subsequently, it will be analyzed whether these features provide sufficient evidence to distinguish a sectarian from a non-sectarian group of texts in the corpus.
The proposed stylometric approach has proven its robustness in verifying and challenging the authorship of texts in many different corpora (see e.g. Kestemont, Moens & Deploige 2015). Recently, the feasibility and the challenges of this approach for the study of Classical Hebrew texts have been studied in detail (Van Hecke 2018; Van Hecke & de Joode forthcoming). This exploratory research constitutes the necessary background to reassess the clustering of the Dead Sea Scrolls in the present contribution.
|
“For the Welfare of My Children and Grandchildren”
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Jan W. van Henten, Universiteit van Amsterdam
The formula “for the welfare of my children and grandchildren” is part of a donor inscription from an anonymous Jewish mother praying for the welfare (sotèria) of her children and grandchildren. The inscription (IGLSyr 4 1335) is transmitted on a mosaic floor, parts of which are currently preserved in Brussels and Amsterdam. The mosaic floor, discovered in 1930, was made in 392 CE and part of a synagogue in Apamea (Syria), which was transformed in a church. This paper aims at (1) contextualizing the inscription by linking it to the history of the Jews in Apamea, (2) discussing the meaning and function of the formula, which was popular at Apamea, and (3) assessing its relevance for related New Testament phrases.
|
The Beloved Pupil at the Last Symposium: The Self-Authentication of John’s Gospel and Plato’s Symposium
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
George van Kooten, University of Cambridge
This paper looks at the way the author of John’s Gospel authenticates himself by embedding his own person in the Gospel’s narrative, and particularly by situating himself at the last Symposium. Rather strikingly, Plato’s Symposium is authenticated in a rather similar way, as the key informant, from whom the whole report of the symposium “of Agathon, Socrates and Alcibiades” (172a-b) eventually derives, is similarly located at the Symposium: Aristodemus of Cydathenaeum (173b-174e), “one of the chief among Socrates’ lovers at that time” (173b, cf. 218a-b), is the eyewitness at the symposium and informant of Apollodorus (173a-b), who mediates his story to the readers. The description of Apollodorus’s exchange with his companions makes up Plato’s Symposium. In this paper, a full comparison will be drawn between the self-authentication of John’s Gospel and Plato’s Symposium, exploring whether our insight in the authentication of the latter provides some heuristic insights in the modus operandi of the author of John’s Gospel.
|
The Absence of Syriac Borrowings in the Qurʾān
Program Unit: Linguistic, Literary, and Thematic Perspectives on the Qur’anic Corpus (IQSA)
Marijn van Putten, Leiden University
It is a widely held belief that the Quran contains many Syriac Aramaic loanwords, as exemplified by such statements such as “[Syriac] is undoubtedly the most copious source of Qurʾānic borrowings” (Jeffery 2007: 19). However, Aramaic borrowings in the Quran consistently lack two defining isoglosses of Syriac, namely the lenition of the begadkephat letters, and the loss of short vowels in open syllables. This can be exemplified by the Quranic word malakūt ‘kingdom (of heaven)’. Had this word been borrowed from the Syriac malḵūṯā ‘id.’, it would have been borrowed into Arabic as **malḫūṯ, rather than the much more archaic form actually attested. This means that Jeffery’s “copious source of Qurʾānic borrowings”, while certainly Aramaic, could not have been of the Syriac variety. Instead, the Aramaic variety that influenced Arabic bears striking similarities to the Aramaic that has influenced Classical Ethiopic and Late Ancient South Arabian. For example, the Classical Ethiopic word malakōt ‘kingdom (of heaven)’ resembles the Quranic word much more than the Syriac equivalent. This seems to suggest that Quranic Arabic was not oriented northward when it comes to its Aramaic religious vocabulary, but rather faced south. In this paper, I will present the evidence for the non-Syriac source of the Aramaic loanwords in the Quran, and I will explore its historical implications. References: Jeffery, A. (2007) The Foreign Vocabulary of the Qurʾān. Leiden & Boston: Brill.
|
Orthographic Idiosyncrasies and the Written Quranic Prototype
Program Unit: The Qur’an: Manuscripts and Textual Criticism (IQSA)
Marijn van Putten, Leiden University
Studies of early Quranic documents often discuss their orthographic features on a case-by-case basis, rather than comparing similarities across early documents. When different documents are compared, however, we find remarkable consistency between the different documents. We consistently find the same idiosyncratic spellings in the same position, time and time again, across many different early Quranic manuscripts. This consistency of the place where orthographic idiosyncrasies occur can only be explained by assuming that all documents go back to a single written Quranic prototype, whose specific orthographic variants have been accurately reproduced throughout the centuries. While many of such shared orthographic idiosyncrasies ultimately come to be described in technical manuals such as Al-Sijistānī’s Kitāb al-Maṣāḥif and Al-Dānī’s Muqniʿ fī Rasm Maṣāḥif al-ʾAmṣār, there are many others that are not mentioned in these medieval works, which are nevertheless so consistently attested across early Quranic documents that they must go back to a shared prototype. In this presentation, I will examine several of these early shared idiosyncrasies, and I will examine what the implications of such idiosyncrasies are for the history of the Quranic prototype, the development of Quranic reading traditions and the language of the Quran.
|
Intertextual Layering as a Method for Reading Matthew with 19:10–12 as a Test Case
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
R. Jarrett Van Tine, University of St. Andrews
While attention has been given to the nature and significance of intertexuality in Matthew’s Gospel, little work has been done on his use of intratexuality as a rhetorical method. (I am using these terms in a generally structuralist sense focusing on the relationships formed between specific literary texts [cf. Genette, Riffaterre, et al]. Intratexuality is sometimes conflated with narrative criticism, although the two are markedly different—Allison 2005 being a notable exception.) For example, intratextuality is not even mentioned as a viable methodology for interpreting the First Gospel in Mark Alan Powell’s Methods for Matthew (2009). Furthermore, I am aware of no study that examines how these two relate to one another and the consequent interpretative import. My paper fills this gap by demonstrating that Matthew employs the same mechanisms in his use of both inter and intra-texuality. That is, Matthew creates verbal, structural, and thematic linkages between texts across his Gospel to indicate that they are to be read in light of one another—and he does so in the same manner that he forges interpretive links (i.e. allusions) to texts outside of his Gospel (cf. Ben-Porat 1976). This observation culminates in a critical insight vis-à-vis Matthew’s exegetical method, which I label intertextual layering. By this I mean that Matthew interweaves texts from his own Gospel as well as from outside of his Gospel to create a hierarchical layering effect in certain pericopes. In each case, the resultant passage constitutes a pastiche, with the intertexts combining to enrich the significance of the new text. (Methodological analogues include: Ezek. 38–39; 1 En. 14:8–25; 11QT 59:2–13a [Tooman 2011]; and L.A.B. [Fisk 2001].) These intertexts, moreover, do not operate on the same plane, but work together hierarchically to generate levels of meaning, with each intertext building upon the layer(s) below it.
As a test case, I examine the intertextual layering of Matthew’s eunuch pericope (19:10–12). This passage interweaves three levels of texts. The foundational layer is an intratextual allusion to Jesus’s call to self-dismemberment from 5:29-32. That is, Jesus here calls illegitimately divorced men considering remarriage to “cut off” (cf. 5:29–30) that which would cause them to stumble (that is, their male organ), by remaining spouseless (i.e. eunuchs) so as not to incur the charge of adultery (aitia; 19:10; cf. 5:31–32) by marrying another (cf. 19:9; cf. 5:32). The second layer sets this interpretation within Matthew’s extended Parable of the Sower/Soils motif (13:1–23). Specifically, 19:10–12 is connected to 19:16–26 (the rich young man), such that together these passages illustrate “the concerns of this age” and “the deceitfulness of wealth” respectively from the thorny soil (13:22). Lastly, the top layer—Isaiah’s prophecy about eunuchs (56:1-5)—provides the eschatological framework for the passage as a whole, and counterbalances the severity of the paraenesis with the hope of glorious eternal reward in the restored temple. The cumulative effect of such textual density is a rich and textured reading.
|
Faithfulness or a Flamethrower? The Judgment and Redemption of Salome in the Protevangelium of James
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Eric Vanden Eykel, Ferrum College
In the second-century Protevangelium of James, a woman named Salome performs a postpartum gynecological examination of Jesus’s mother Mary. The examination is clearly unwelcome, evidenced by the fact that Salome’s hand bursts into flames as soon as she touches Mary’s body. She is healed from her affliction when at the direction of an angel she picks up the infant Jesus. Scholars who have examined this scene have generally focused on its literary connection with the so-called Doubting Thomas pericope from the Gospel of John. As such, Salome’s test of the Virgin becomes indicative of her doubt, while her willingness to be healed by Jesus becomes indicative of her belief. In this paper I should like to build on this interpretation of the Salome episode in the Protevangelium by examining a number of intertexts dealing with fire as something that would consume those who are unwelcome. In doing so, I shall suggest that Salome’s examination of the Virgin might be understood not only as a test of faith, but as a sojourn into forbidden territory.
|
Gendering Rembrandt: Paintings and Prints with Scenes from the Gospels
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Caroline Vander Stichele, Universiteit van Amsterdam
In light of the exhibit at the Denver Art Museum this Fall on “Rembrandt: Painter as Printmaker” (September 16, 2018 – January 6, 2019), this paper discusses both paintings and prints related to stories from the gospels, focusing on issues of gender. After introducing Rembrandt and his oeuvre on the Bible, scenes in his work that are related to gospel stories are analyzed. Attention will be paid to the characters that are included (or not) and the way they are represented in terms of gender. The paper takes the form of a dialogue with Mieke Bal’s work, "Reading Rembrandt: Beyond the Word-Image Opposition" (1991, republished in 2006), which discusses gender issues related to stories from the Hebrew Bible. In my paper I explore the possibilities that her approach offers for the interpretation of scenes from the New Testament.
|
Job Gets a Job: How an Unemployed Bible Verse Found Work in Masorah and Midrash
Program Unit: Midrash
Robert Vanhoff, TorahResource Institute
Some Bible passages were neglected by the ancient rabbis. Like kids who never got picked for playground sports, these verses did not make the cut for inclusion in the classic corpus of Mishnah, Talmud, and Midrash. If we think of the rabbinic world-builders and meaning-makers as experts in putting Scripture to work, we can say that such Bible verses were left unemployed.
Though ignored in late antiquity, some such verses get attention in the medieval period, if only because of the commentators’ growing appreciation for and appropriation of masoretic tradition. Masorah lists contained numerous labor-ready textual oddities, any number of which a creative parshan could exploit to demonstrate his midrashic ingenuity and seeming mastery of arcane knowledge. Job 8:8 was among those finally put to work. This paper traces its spotty employment history in commentaries roughly spanning the masoretic adoption of the codex (10th c.) to the printing of the Rabbinic Bible (16th), highlighting older midrashic undercurrents that made this verse attractive.
|
Can’t a Scribe Take a Hint? How Ben-Jacob “Fixed” an Ambiguous Ben-Asher Tradition but Missed Its Meaning
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Robert Vanhoff, TorahResource Institute
Samuel ben Jacob was the unmistakably brilliant and gifted scribe who copied, pointed, and provided masoretic notes for what is now our oldest complete Hebrew Bible. Though not a Masorete himself, ben Jacob ascribed authority to and relied upon the older Tiberian Ben Asher tradition when producing this famous manuscript (known popularly as the Leningrad Codex, or “L”) in early 11th century Egypt.
It has been observed that L’s scribe had at times added detail to received tradition (Yeivin, Introduction to the Tiberian Masorah). But did ben Jacob ever misread a ben Asher note? This paper compares a curious masorah tradition found in the Aleppo Codex with its “fixed” version in L. In his zeal to correct a note about the “Alefbeta Rabba” (aka Psalm 119), it did not occur to ben Jacob that the “helpful” clarification he added may have been intentionally omitted by the Masoretes.
|
Bearer of Heresies: Simon Magus in the Pseudo-Clementine Basic Writing from the Perspective of Identity Construction
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
Antti Vanhoja, University of Helsinki
This paper deals with the figure of Simon Magus in the Pseudo-Clementine Basic Writing from the perspective of social identity. It focuses on the debate between Simon and Peter as well as the preceding account of Simon by two of his former disciples. The main question is, what role the figure of Simon plays in the author’s process of identity construction.
Simon Magus is a biblical figure who often features as a prominent heretic in the early Christian writings of the second and third centuries CE. In the Pseudo-Clementine Basic Writing, Simon is a false preacher and the main adversary of Peter the Apostle. Description of him is mostly based on earlier tradition but interestingly his beliefs reflect those of later “heretics”, including Marcion and Apelles. It has been noted that the author of the Basic Writing likely attributed to Simon certain beliefs he opposed.
From the perspective of social identity, linking unwanted views with a widely recognized heretic, an obvious out-grouper, is a way to dismiss them and reduce the authority of those who support them, thus strengthening the cohesion of the author’s in-group.
|
Transformative Concepts and Troublesome Knowledge: Toward a Consensus of Threshold Concepts in Biblical Studies
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
John VanMaaren, McMaster University
This paper proposes a preliminary set of threshold concepts (TCs) for the discipline of biblical studies at an undergraduate liberal arts institution. In contrast to core concepts, which build upon the learning foundations that students already possess, TCs are “conceptual gateways, or ‘portals’ that students must pass through to arrive at important new understandings” (Meyer, Land & Smith, 2008). TCs are (1) transformative, in that they occasion a shift in the perception of the subject; (2) probably irreversible, in that the perception shift may be unlearned only with considerable effort; (3) integrative, as far as they expose the previously hidden interrelatedness of something; and (4) potentially troublesome, causing an uncomfortable shift in identity (Meyer & Land, 2006). The potential contribution of TCs is especially promising for the biblical studies classroom that is made up of diverse students whose identities (religious, racial, cultural, sexual, political, etc.) are closely tied to specific, and sometimes conflicting, readings of the biblical texts, and who may experience discomfort in a liberal arts atmosphere of intellectual openness to inquiry and new discovery (Blaich, et al., 2004). A discipline-specific set of TCs will enable teachers to structure course content, allocate classroom time, design strategic assignments, and provide constructive feedback in order to encourage deep reflection on concepts that are both essential for progress, and potentially disturbing to student identity.
To date, most of the work identifying TCs has been done in STEM disciplines (e.g., Medicine, Mathematics, Engineering). This is partly because identifying TCs is easier in disciplines with a more clearly-defined body of content knowledge. Within the social sciences and humanities, “ways of thinking and practicing” may also function as TCs, and important work has been done especially in Economics (e.g., Davies & Mangan, 2005). Individual TCs have been identified in disciplines related to biblical studies. For example, apophatic knowledge may be a TC for spiritual formation (Mudge, 2014). However, while the need for TCs in biblical studies has been noted (O’Connell Killen, 2011), and a single study identifies the Exodus event as a TC for the biblical writers (Gilmour, 2016), no study addresses TCs for “ways of thinking and practicing” in biblical studies.
This paper begins the process of identifying TCs for the biblical studies classroom in an undergraduate, liberal arts institution. First, it first explains threshold concepts and their potential contribution to student learning with examples from mathematics and economics. It then proposes a preliminary set of TCs for the biblical studies classroom and provides a rationale for each concept in terms of the above four TC characteristics. This set represents a first step toward a consensus of TCs in biblical studies. The set will then be revised through a “transactional curriculum inquiry” process involving feedback from teachers, students, and educational developers (Barradell, 2013).
|
No Early Parting of the Ways: The Gospel of Mark within the Boundaries of Jewishness
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
John VanMaaren, McMaster University
No Early Parting of the Ways: The Gospel of Mark within the Boundaries of Jewishness
|
Bodies and Souls: The Case for Reading Revelation 18:13 as a Critique of the Slave Trade
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Murray Vasser, Asbury Theological Seminary
Bodies and Souls: The Case for Reading Revelation 18:13 as a Critique of the Slave Trade
|
Composition through Character: Solomon’s Narrative Biography and the Excess of Speech
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Jacqueline Vayntrub, Yale Divinity School
How should we understand the naming of legendary figures like Solomon in biblical and early Jewish texts? Scholarship has classically viewed these titles with respect to (often untenable) claims to authorship. More recently, studies of Second Temple Jewish texts have have problematized conventional reading practices that confine attribution to canon and authorship (Najman 2003; Reed 2009; Mroczek 2016), focusing on how ancient practices of attribution intersect with the attributed figure’s narrative biography. Following this growing body of scholarship, attribution is more productively viewed as a set of relationships between a composition’s formal and thematic characteristics and aspects of the character of figures from ancient Israel’s narrative history. For example, Solomon’s character shapes certain types of instruction speech, David is related to certain types of song, while Enoch is related to certain modes of visionary speech. This view of early Jewish literary compositional practices, developed over the past decade in scholarship, can be productively brought back to the phenomenon of biblical anthology—Proverbs and Psalms, for example—both in their titles as well as in their subsequent reception in antiquity. In this paper, I will use this framework to outline formative elements of Solomon’s legendary character and narrative biography that shape a particular notion of anthology.
|
Theological Method and Theological Anthropology
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Mary Veeneman, North Park University
Theological Method and Theological Anthropology
|
A Phenomenological Spatial Reflection of Agency in the Book of Ruth
Program Unit: Student Advisory Board
Jordan Venditelli, Appalachian State University
Much work has been done on the question of whether the biblical book of Ruth can be read as a feminist tale. As I explore in my attached paper, Danna Nolan Fewell's 2015 JSOT article advances this conversation by considering each character's potential for moral agency as conditioned by the tale's social construction of space. For this panel, I experiment with how the work of feminist philosopher Sara Ahmed might contribute to the questions Fewell and others have considered. In particular, I want to ask how Ahmed's reflections on the common notion of a "snapping point" might be relevant to our understanding of moral agency in general and to use the book of Ruth as a space to think with these questions. A “snapping point” is the point in which one can no longer bear the weight of one's oppressive circumstances, and then "snaps" or breaks under the pressure. One consequence of this is a disruption in the agent's surrounding social environment. Ahmed thinks that we should consider such moments as expressions of authentic moral agency. Fewell demonstrates the extent to which Ruth, as a foreign immigrant, a woman, and a childless widow, must use what Michel de Certeau terms “tactics” in order to shore herself up and secure financial safety and bodily protection for herself and her mother-in-law, Naomi. Naomi is an Israelite, and so presumably has more capacity for agency than she appears to express when she withdraws from the story after re-entering her homeland. However, just before she recedes to the background, at the end of chapter 1, Naomi "snaps," telling the townswomen not to call her “Naomi” but to call her “Mara,” meaning “bitter.” Naomi snaps out of frustration, grief, and anger. She snaps not only at the townswomen but also at God. What if we were to view this "snapping" as an expression of Naomi's moral agency rather than the shrill outburst of a grieving mother? Is her movement to the outskirts of the story a product of her snapping? What would it look like for Ruth to snap? Would it even be possible for this foreign woman to express the agency that could cause social disruption and shape the space of her story? How does Naomi's privilege as a member of her society afford her the space to snap, as opposed to Ruth who might not be afforded that privilege? Finally, how has the history of interpretation dealt with such "snapping points"? I suspect that we have probably ignored the moral dignity of such moments when expressed by female as opposed to male characters, such as Job. Accordingly, I propose developing from my paper’s engagement with Ruth as an opportunity to critically explore feminist agency with others attending the panel.
|
“You Have Girded Me with Strength for the Fight” (Ps 18:40): Building Resilience through the Words of the First Book of the Psalter
Program Unit: Biblical Literature and the Hermeneutics of Trauma
Danilo Verde, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
Over the last few decades, several studies in the field of psychology have argued that religiousness plays a crucial role in response to life stressors and traumatic events, such as death, illness, war, injustice, oppression, existential crises, etc. According to Pargament and Cummings (2010), religiousness constitutes “a resilience factor,” insofar as it helps many people withstand the most threatening human experiences by (1) fostering the search for meaning, (2) providing emotional comfort, (3) creating social interconnectedness, and (4) establishing and reinforcing the relationship with the sacred. In this view, prayer is one of the many ways through which religious people build their resilience. In this paper, I will inquire into the Book of Psalms as Ancient Israel’s “equipment for hardiness,” namely as Ancient Israel’s spiritual heritage that helps “to buffer exposure to extreme stress” (Bonanno 2004: 25). More precisely, I will focus on the First Book of the Psalter looking for its peculiar pathways to resilience. I will argue that the First Book of the Psalter contributes to building individual and community resilience on different and intertwined levels. On the cognitive linguistic level, it provides the supplicant with words (and thoughts) through which a reassuring worldview and metanarrative can be created. On the emotional level, it provides the supplicant with words to express the most disquieting emotions, creating a profound and solid sense of trust. On the relational level, it provides the supplicant with words to address a reliable “Thou” (i.e. God) to whom s/he can tell his/her own story. At the same time, it provides the supplicant with words that bind him/her to the community from which the supplicant receives the Psalter, and to which s/he is joined in the common prayer and common process of coping. I will first present the theoretical model on the relationship between religiousness and resilience to which I refer (Pargament and Cummings 2010; Pargament 2007, 1997) in order to establish a productive lens for understanding how the appropriation of the Psalter may have contributed to building its former readers’ resilience, as well as how the appropriation of the Psalter may still function as a pathway to resilience for its modern readers. I will then give textual examples on how the powerful words of the First Book of the Psalter build individual and community resilience on the cognitive linguistic level, the emotional level, and the relational level.
|
Trading Gender for Redemption: A Look into the Suppression of the Valentinian Feminist
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Eunice Villaneda, Claremont School of Theology
The misclassification of the Valentinians as a gnostic sect led to the perception of their interchangeability with other ancient Christian sects. This resulted in erroneous assumptions about most ancient Christian sects, especially the Valentinians. Among these assumptions is the notion that women were empowered because of their inclusion in the rituals of Valentinians. Indeed, women were included and were urged to take part an active role in the Valentinian community but the notion that they were empowered by this inclusion is wrong.
Elaine Pagels argued that feminism thrived throughout Gnostic Christianity. She argues that while the church fathers expressed negative views of women in gnostic sects, women in fact, were held to the same standard as men. While this theory resonates among the Valentinian sect, one must argue whether women's inclusion in rituals, liberates them from the gender constraints of that time or if it, in fact, restricts them. Taking a look at the trifold nature of Valentinian bodies and gender/feminist theory we will be able to deconstruct gender in the Valentinian sect and find that Valentinians were forced to disregard 'material' bodies altogether forcing both men and women to disregard their material bodies as well as the gender ascribed to them. The findings of this investigation show that while Valentinianism gave women their places alongside men during rituals, it inducted them into a tradition in which gender was suppressed for redemption.
|
Shedding Light on the Shadows: Cyril of Alexandria’s Interpretation of Genesis 1–3
Program Unit: Early Exegesis of Genesis 1–3
Barbara Villani, Berlin-Brandenburgische Akademie der Wissenschafte
Although Cyril did not compose systematic commentaries on Pentateuch, in his treatises De adoratione and Glaphyra he interpreted selected passages of the books of Moses. In these two works beginning with the literal interpretation of various biblical episodes he then moves to their allegorical sense in order to show that the mystery of Christ was already present in the Old Testament. The opening chapters of Genesis are analyzed in the first book of Glaphyra, where Cyril, more than on cosmogony, focuses on the creation of man: he discusses the reasons of his existence, his original state and his fall. By comparing the interpretations of Glaphyra with those proposed in other works, this paper will explore Cyril’s understanding of the creation account, with special attention on his allegorical reading of Adam’s origin.
|
Between Qur’an and Psalmody: How Medieval Muslim Piety Integrated Two Notions of Scripture
Program Unit: The Qur’an and the Biblical Tradition (IQSA)
David Vishanoff, University of Oklahoma
David Vishanoff, University of Oklahoma. As Angelika Neuwirth has shown, the Qur’an bears a particular affinity to the Biblical Psalms. Both texts reflect and shape shared Near Eastern traditions of wisdom, narrative, liturgy and piety. In the imagination of some medieval Muslim advocates of scrupulous piety (waraʿ), both texts had the same form, the same function, the same style, and even some of the same content. At some point between the ninth and eleventh centuries an unknown collector of wisdom (ḥikma) and exhortations (waʿẓ) decided to cast his material in the form of a prophetic revelation, which he called the Psalms of David (Zabūr Dāwūd). The Biblical king and Qur’anic prophet David made an ideal addressee for his compilation of divine admonitions about repentance, nighttime devotions, and otherworldly piety. Several redactors independently expanded and improved this new scripture, resulting in what I have described elsewhere as the Koranic, Orthodox, Sufi, and Pious recensions. This paper shows how each redactor reconciled the traditional image of David’s psalmody with a Qur’anic conception of scripture. Only in psalm 1 was the Biblical text preserved. Psalm 2 was modified to preempt Christian interpretations that made it a proclamation of Jesus’ divine sonship, and the beginning of Psalm 3, retained only in the Sufi recension, had to be marked as “the words of David” because the rest of the text is framed as God’s speech, not the psalmist’s. From that point on the Biblical text disappears, but the Qur’an is often quoted or paraphrased, and the coming of Muhammad is duly announced. The Koranic recension ends each psalm with a Qur’anic–sounding phrase such as “I am Mighty and Wise.” Some manuscripts label each psalm a sūra, and lay out the text as in a muṣḥaf. Yet the Biblical Psalms are not forgotten. Amid snippets of wisdom, exhortations to prepare for the afterlife, and admonitions about a variety of sins, there appear hymns of praise, human calls for divine assistance, and echoes of the penitential Psalms. David laments his transgressions quite explicitly in some versions, though in others he is shielded from grave sin. In form, style, and content these rewritten psalms are more Qur’anic than Biblical, yet their ethos of piety, penitence, and praise have much in common with the scripture they purport to replace. Indeed, they were not intended as a challenge to the supposedly corrupted Psalms of Jews and Christians. Rather than interreligious polemic, appropriation, or forgery (as Ignaz Goldziher called them), these psalms constitute an intrareligious polemic against worldly fellow Muslims, constructed from a repertoire of motifs, aphorisms, characters, and imagined books that, in the minds of their Muslim authors, were the common property of all scrupulously pious believers.
|
Hearing Jesus in the Garden of Gethsemane
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
James W. Voelz, Concordia Seminary
If the Gospels were received orally not via silent reading, what does this mean for the understanding of the Gospel texts? In this presentation, the scene of Jesus and three disciples in the Garden of Gethsemane in Mark 14 will be performed for those in attendance. The performance will seek to embody specific linguistic insights relative to this text, but, because of the characteristics of oral performance, it will also, in turn, suggest additional linguistic insights that may well elude the silent reader.
|
“We Will All Be Changed”: Apocalyptic Transformation of Christ Believing Bodies
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Robert H. von Thaden, Jr., Mercyhurst College
The inbreaking of God’s apocalyptic reality, in texts produced by early Christ believing communities, has not only cosmic implications, but somatic ones as well. Christ believing bodies will not only undergo transformation at the time of the eschaton, but are already undergoing a transformation in this age. Such transformation (future and ongoing) has implications for how bodies are conceived, how bodies act, and how communities understand themselves—not only in the biblical texts, but in later communities shaped by them.
|
’wṭ as a Greek Loanword in 4QInstruction
Program Unit: Qumran
Daniel Vos, Boston College
The etymology and meaning of the word ’wṭ in 4QInstruction remains a significant interpretive crux. Translations of the word tend to fall into two categories: either representing property or some kind of personal secret or inner disposition (Novick 2008; Kampen 2011). Although Greek loanwords are rare in the Dead Sea Scrolls (Heijmans 2013), I propose that ’wṭ derives from the Greek autos and is used in 4QInstruction with the sense of “one’s self” or “one’s own.” autos is common in Greek language property documents found in the Judaean Desert and ’wṭqrṭwr (autokrator) occurs as an imperial title in the date formula of 5/6Ḥev7. This reading of ’wṭ as a derivative of autos bridges the divide between previous translations, since both inner disposition and property can be described as one’s own, and more satisfactorily explains the varied contexts in which ’wṭ is employed in 4QInstruction.
|
Discerning God in 1 Kings 3: Wisdom in High Places and Pentecostal Praxis
Program Unit:
Rick Wadholm, Jr., Trinity Bible College
In this paper I will be discussing the literary textures of 1 Kings 3 in light of ambiguity and discernment for readers engaging the characters of Yahweh and Solomon in their own ambiguities and calls for discernment. The ambiguities and discernment of the text finds resonance within Pentecostal praxis as the pneumatic prophetic community moves toward discerning what God is doing and saying within their midst as interplay of Word and Spirit. This movement functions both descriptively and prescriptively for Pentecostal praxis in the experience of wisdom as Word and Spirit.
|
Binding the Strong Man in Africa: The Strong Men Phenomenon in the Context of Global Politics
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Robert Wafawanaka, Virginia Union University
This paper seeks to analyze African strong men phenomenon in the context of global politics and offer illuminating biblical responses to the problem. A few select African leaders are used to illustrate the extent of the problem in Africa. The paper argues that many post independent African leaders have ruled by strong man tactics, much to their detriment. The paper will also examine other strong man leaders in the global context and offer a comparative analysis of what motivates them and how they fare in different social contexts. Finally, I will offer some biblical responses to the strong man syndrome in Africa. I seek to argue that such leadership approaches are doomed to failure. The rise of the protest movements and global freedom movements are veritable threats to the strong man phenomenon wherever it exists. These movements provide the necessary checks and balances to the strong man phenomenon in any social context.
|
The Neighbor Then and Now: Is There Anything New under the Sun?
Program Unit: Poverty in the Biblical World
Robert Wafawanaka, Virginia Union University
This paper seeks to explore the concept of neighbor in both ancient and modern contexts with attention to whether anything has changed in this historical continuum. Arguing that the ancient concept of neighbor was based on the exclusion of the other, the Jesus movement sought to counter this understanding by expanding it. A brief examination of ancient Near Eastern and biblical texts demonstrates the construction of neighbor on ethnic identity. Though existing in the same geographical locale, ancient biblical texts primarily view the non-Israelite as the different other, the one to be excluded. I will seek to demonstrate that in the teachings of the Jesus Movement, a new understanding of neighbor is advanced. The paper argues that this new understanding of the neighbor requires us to re-orient our perspectives and transgress some boundaries—ethnic, historical, social, and religious. In the context of systemic poverty, the new identity of the neighbor is a challenging mandate to reassess and reconstruct the concept of the neighbor.
|
The Way of the Lord and the Way of This People: The Book of Isaiah and Communal Identity at Qumran
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
J. Ross Wagner, Duke University
The Way of the Lord and the Way of This People: The Book of Isaiah and Communal Identity at Qumran
|
Due to a Lack of Knowledge: Pragmatism as Ethical Principle in the Book of Qohelet
Program Unit: Bible and Ethics
Thomas Wagner, Bergische Universität Wuppertal
The Book of Qohelet represents a critical (also described as sceptic) perspective on human life. Beside a cosmological foundation of human existence Qohelet formulates several insights in ethical problems which occur in the course of life. Even if Qohelet does not present a cohesive position on ethic he gives several hints within his book how to interact in social affairs.
This paper will deal with both, the cosmological foundation of Qohelet's teaching and the ethical implications of his insights. The reference to older sapiential rules and the new interpretation under changing insights in human existence will be the main focus of this paper.
|
Humanizing God: Job and the Limits of the Legal Metaphor
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Cassie Waits, Emory University
Can language adequately describe the relationship between divine and human? What modes of language best capture this relationship? What are the risks of such language?
The relationship between divine and human is portrayed metaphorically in the Hebrew Bible as a political relationship and a marriage relationship. In the poetic portion of the Book of Job, this relationship takes on the trappings of a legal arrangement. While Job is well-known as a text that wrestles with questions of theodicy, Job’s theodicy problem presupposes a particular cognitive framework that orders the divine/human relationship. Lurking behind serious questions of theodicy are metaphorical constructs that ground Job's understanding of how he relates to God.
The nature of Job’s metaphorical constructs matters. To what extent do these metaphors remain generative sources of meaning? In “Metaphorical Theology" (1982), Sallie McFague investigates divine metaphors and finds that, when religious language ceases to be understood as metaphorical, the language itself becomes idolatrous. Unfortunately, this risk of idolatry is not constrained to divine metaphors. George Lakoff and Mark Johnson’s “Metaphors We Live By” (1980) demonstrates that every metaphor gives rise to sub-metaphors and is, therefore, situated within a system of meaning. If divine metaphors are at risk of becoming idolatrous, then the relational metaphors that flow from those divine metaphors are also at risk.
Job repeatedly returns to the forensic metaphor as a description of the divine/human relationship throughout the poetic dialogue. With each iteration, Job embraces the metaphor more firmly and moves God more concretely into a human-sized role. Though Job initially recognizes the openness of the metaphor, by chapter 31 this metaphor has become part of Job’s cognitive framework and fundamental to his identity in relation to God. In the process, Job has slowly, but consistently, narrowed the distance between human and divine.
This paper will trace the progress of Job’s humanizing of God over the course of the poetic sections of Job. Of particular interest will be Job’s use of the forensic metaphor in chapters 9, 13, 16, 19, 23 and 31. Has this metaphor become idolatrous? Does Job yield yet another data point in support of McFague’s dire warnings? The cognitive power of this metaphor and its potential for idolatry will be assessed as Job grows more certain in his belief that the forensic metaphor is a proper and effective description of his relationship with God.
|
The Wisdom of Jepthah's Daughter
Program Unit: History and Literature of Early Rabbinic Judaism
Miriam-Simma Walfish, Harvard University
The account of the “sacrifice” of Jepthah’s daughter (Bat-Yiftah) in Judges 11 has long preoccupied interpreters from both Jewish and Christian traditions. Yiftah’s vow to sacrifice blindly the first living being to approach him upon his victorious return from battle, and his apparent killing of his only child, spurred controversy and competing exegetical efforts within and between the interpretive communities. Our papers will explore the differing approaches Christian and rabbinic exegetes take to understanding the import of Bat-Yiftah’s death and its significance for their respective religious communities.
Rabbinic texts see the death of Bat-Yiftah as an avoidable tragedy, a child sacrifice undesired by God. Numerous texts (e.g. B. Taanit 4a and GenR 60:3) blame this tragedy on Yiftah’s lack of expertise in rabbinic laws of vow annulment. Midrash Tanhuma dramatically develops this interpretive strand, depicting Bat-Yiftah deploying fine rabbinic logic in a futile attempt to convince her father that his vow was improper and thus could be annulled. In this midrash, Bat-Yiftah emerges as a wise woman whose knowledge of Torah cannot save her from the fate that her overly stubborn non-rabbinic father brought upon her.
Christian exegetes, like their rabbinic counterparts, reacted with visceral judgment against Yiftah’s actions. Their response, however, was complicated by the latter’s appearance in the Epistle to the Hebrews, which celebrated Yiftah as an example of faith (Hebrews 11:32-35). Thus commended by the biblical text, Yiftah could not be wholly dismissed -- and yet interpreters labored over how and whether to wring edification and inspiration from the text.
To recover Yiftah’s “sacrifice” as exemplary, some Christian exegetes celebrated Bat-Yiftah as a model of virginity, a feminine parallel to Isaac, and indeed as a typological forerunner for Christ. An example of this approach can be found in a Syriac verse-homily attributed to one Isaac. Isaac was a fifth- or sixth-century lyrical poet who celebrated Bat-Yiftah in terms that are surprisingly analogous to Midrash Tanhuma: Amidst a gathering of confounded men, including her father and the elders of the city, she is the sole source of sound reasoning and insight into the divine will. And yet, the reasoning that Bat-Yiftah expounds in this sogita differs dramatically from the rabbinic version of this story: she welcomes her own impending sacrifice and rejects the efforts of all to save her from becoming the virginal “handmaid” of the divine. This sogita aligns with a general trend among Christian exegetes among whom Bat-Yiftah’s unmarried death becomes a source of celebration and turns her into a model for late ancient virgins.
Our papers will highlight not only the clear differences in approach taken by rabbinic and early Christian authors, but also moments of surprising similarity. Where do rabbinic authors draw our attention to Bat-Yiftah's virginity? When do Christian authors resist the common trend of viewing Bat-Yiftah as a holy exemplar? Attention to this shared conversation will sharpen our understanding of how Bat-Yiftah fits into broader Christian and rabbinic interpretive discourses.
|
“Almsgiving Delivers from Death”: John Chrysostom’s Connection of the Narratives of Tobit and Tabitha
Program Unit: Biblical Exegesis from Eastern Orthodox Perspectives
Becky Walker, Saint Louis University
David J. Downs, in his recent book, Alms: Charity, Reward, and Atonement in Early Christianity, discusses the impact of the Septuagintal book of Tobit and the narratives of Tabitha and Cornelius in Acts 9:36–10:48 on the doctrine of atoning almsgiving. Although Downs discusses these texts in their original historical contexts, my paper will discuss the interpretation and connection of these passages by John Chrysostom. Chrysostom links the phrase, “Almsgiving delivers from death” in Tob. 12:9a with the raising of Tabitha in Acts 9 and the salvation of Cornelius in Acts 10. Corresponding to these connections, Chrysostom, in line with both Cyprian and rabbinic interpretations of “righteousness (tsedaqa)" delivers from death” in Prov. 10:2 and 11:4, interprets “death” in Tob. 12:9 as both physical and spiritual. (The term tsedaqa in Jewish thought had gradually become equated with almsgiving by the Amoraic period, roughly 200-500 CE). Chrysostom is also in agreement with rabbinic sources regarding the redemptive value of almsgiving, although neither Jewish nor Christian sources assert that almsgiving is the only way to deal with sin and its consequences.
There are, however, two differences in emphasis between Chrysostom and the rabbinic commentators regarding their exegesis of the phrase, “tsedaqa/almsgiving delivers from death.” First, while rabbinic sources emphasize salvation from a literal death, Chrysostom tends to emphasize salvation from a spiritual death. Second, while both Talmuds maintain that tsedaqa cancels doom or saves from Gehenna or from an eternal death, none of them says that it cancels or saves from sin. Chrysostom, by contrast, claims that almsgiving “purges,” “cleanses,” and “frees” from sin, itself. This difference in emphasis can be explained, in part, by the fact that Chrysostom is referring to the phrase from its context in Tobit, which specifically mentions that almsgiving cleanses sin. The rabbinic commentators are only referring to the phrase in Proverbs as they chose not to include Tobit in their canon. However, the frequency and intensity with which Chrysostom and other Christian authors discuss almsgiving in connection with sin suggests that this difference is due to more than simply the canonical status of Tobit. It appears that rabbinic sources stress almsgiving’s ability to rescue one from the judgment due to sin while early Christian sources emphasize almsgiving’s power to free one from sin itself.
My discussion will focus on Chrysostom’s Homilies on Acts 22.3 and Homilies on Genesis 55.4; y. Peah 1:1, 15b; b. Shabbath 156b; and b. Baba Bathra 10a–b.
|
The Poetics of Violence in Lamentations and Ashurbanipal’s Palace Reliefs: Reconsidering Keel's "Phenomenological" Approach
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Justin Walker, Emory University
Forty-five years ago, Keel’s SBW introduced ancient Near Eastern iconography within biblical scholarship as a primary means of seeing “through the eyes of the ancient Near East” (8). Iconography, for Keel, permitted the artist and viewer “to participate” in the represented events” (10) and, with respect to the biblical material, to render accessible “identical, similar, or even diametrically opposed apprehensions of the same phenomenon” (12-13). Following in the tradition of Keel’s pioneering phenomenological approach, this paper explores the poetics of violence in Lamentations with recourse to some of the most violent images within the ANE repertoire: Ashurbanipal’s palace reliefs. Rather than appealing to Neo-Assyrian iconography as a means of clarifying the (historical) content of the biblical poem, the paper will instead consider how the phenomenon of violence figures within compositions like the Battle of Til-Tuba in the Southwest Palace at Nineveh or the lion hunt reliefs in the North Palace as a means of illuminating how the Lamentations poet presents and arranges violent images. The paper is thus a circumscribed exercise in “seeing through" ancient Near Eastern iconography and thereby ascertaining a glimpse into the power of violent imagery in biblical poetry.
|
Palaces of Ivory or Teeth (Ps 45:9): Carol Adam’s Absent Referent and Ecological Translation of the Psalms
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Art Walker-Jones, University of Winnipeg
In The Sexual Politics of Meat, Carol Adams develops a feminist-vegetarian theory of the “absent referent.” She argues that cultural imagery and semantics function to make moral consideration of the animal absent from the act of eating meat. For instance, the use of the word “meat” for non-human animals and “flesh” for humans helps humans deny that “meat” is the flesh of another sentient being that can suffer like humans and wants to live. Adams also shows that the cultural imagery that makes animals absent referents overlaps with imagery that makes women and Earth absent from moral consideration and open to exploitation. Similarly, when translators of the Hebrew Bible use “ivory” for Hebrew shen in Psalm 45:9 (ET 8) rather than “teeth,” this makes the elephants who provided their tusks the absent referent and makes exploitation that a royal economy is built on less visible and the human identification with the suffering of elephants less likely. The situation is more complex with the Hebrew word basar. Hebrew has only this one word for flesh and meat so might resist the absent referent and encourage identification between humans and other species. On the one hand, the fact that readers come to the text with a cultural distinction between human “flesh” and animal “meat,” may mean that they understand the translation of basar as “flesh” referring only to humans instead of all creatures. This is evident when the NJPS translates basar as “mankind” in Psalm 65:3 (ET 2), even though an argument can be made from the Psalm that women and all creatures are in view. Thus NJPS’s translation of basar as “all creatures” in Psalm 145:21 is better. On the other hand, translators commonly translate basar as “flesh” in Psalm 50:13 and this could encourage human identification with other species. This paper argues, therefore, that translators need to understand absent referents in English in order to translate the Book of Psalms adequately and ecologically.
|
Malachi as Hosea’s Wise Reader
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Nathan Wall, Wycliffe College at the University of Toronto
Prophetic books “are prophetic exegesis of the prophets,” wrote Odil Steck, referring to the redactional processes which produced Hebrew prophetic literature. While this is true of all prophetic books, it is true in different ways for different books. This paper focuses on the final book in the Twelve, Malachi. In what what ways does Malachi represent “prophetic exegesis of the prophets”? And how does Malachi’s exegetical character shed light both on its own composition and on its role in the formation of the Twelve? Three decades ago Michael Fishbane highlighted the “exegetical” character of Malachi by focusing on the book’s ironic invocation of the Priestly Blessing from Numbers 6.23-27. Using Fishbane’s taxonomy of mantological exegesis (reworking, reapplication, reinterpretation, and mantic anthology), I analyse Malachi’s use of texts and traditions from other books in the Twelve, focusing especially onHosea, and particularly on the ריב (riv) against the priests in Hosea 4. More than providing a thematic bookend to the Twelve, Malachi gives an exegetical answer to a challenge. I argue that the book of Malachi responds to what Raymond Van Leeuwen has called “the wisdom admonition” attached to the end of Hosea (14.9-10): “those who are wise understand these things.”
|
How to edit New Testament Paratexts
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Martin Wallraff, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
This paper finds its origins in a large-scale research project entitled “Paratexts of the Bible: Analysis and Edition of the Greek Textual Transmission”, which is funded by an ERC Advanced Grant. The project approaches the edition of paratexts from the Greek New Testament in a way that is both comprehensive and systematic. It consists of two phases; the first phase saw the collection of data from a large number of New Testament manuscripts, while the second phase concentrates on editing selected paratexts. In this present phase, we are dealing with a large amount of evidence that remains either unpublished or is not easily accessible. This paper looks at some of the different methodological questions, strategies and challenges that have arisen in the publication of the results of the project. One of our primary intentions is to establish a clear set of criteria to help guide and shape the edition process. In this context, three questions need to be addressed.
1) Which texts? During the Byzantine millennium the New Testament accumulated a sizable mass of paratextual material: from standard features like chapter titles or canon tables to specific information like colophons or dedications, from theological treatises like prologues to graphic features like portraits of the evangelists etc. Given the wide range of content that one could rightly consider paratextual, it is important to establish a) what a paratext is, b) what selection can be edited within the framework of the present project.
2) Which philological method? The very broad spectrum of different forms of manuscript attestation presents a significant challenge: from several hundreds of witnesses (table of contents of the gospels) to a single manuscript (colophons). In almost all cases a classical “stemmatization” will not work, mostly because the texts are too short. An additional problem arises in cases of “liquid transmission”: variants are not only the result of scribal errors or, more generally speaking, a deterioration of the text, but sometimes reflect textual growth or adaptation to new circumstances. All this requires careful methodological reflection.
3) What technology? For some of these questions, there may be good answers in electronic forms of editions. At the same time, the stability and the clarity of criteria in the world of “conventional” (= printed) editions should not be abandoned. Moreover, the challenge with these (largely) short paratexts is not only to provide a reliable and readable text, but also to ensure that interested readers will know where to find the relevant evidence (not every potential reader will have a clear idea of where to look for the answer to his question). The interaction between a clavis of New Testament paratexts (database) and the edition(s) is therefore of vital importance.
By raising these types of questions, the paper seeks to increase awareness for the issues at stake in this project and to open a dialogue with New Testament scholars at the SBL conference.
|
The Silent Wisdom of Creation in Job
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Carey Walsh, Villanova University
TBD
|
Vanishing Women, Lingering Voices: Wrestling with Representations of Gendered Speech in Greek and Syriac Poetry
Program Unit: Religious World of Late Antiquity
Erin Galgay Walsh, Duke University
(Open Call) Greek and Syriac-speaking Christians in late antiquity experienced authoritative texts through a variety of literary genres and visual media. Liturgical poetry is an under-explored source for understanding the religious and moral instruction that Christians of all social locations and stages of spiritual advancement received. The plethora of female figures within this literature renders it a tantalizing treasury for feminist scholars of religion. These representations of women’s bodies, moral deliberations, and voices confront us with questions and limitations similar to representations of women in genres such as hagiography and martyrdom accounts.
My dissertation examines the development of Greek and Syriac poetic rhetoric in the fifth and sixth centuries through studying poetic re-narrations of biblical pericopes featuring unnamed women, specifically the Sinful woman, the Canaanite woman, the Hemorrhaging woman, and the Samaritan woman. I focus on the poetry of Narsai, Jacob of Serugh, and Romanos Melodos in light of the shared legacy of Ephrem the Syrian. In the course of writing my dissertation I have struggled to refine my theoretical and methdological approaches. While these texts do not illuminate the lived experience of women in a straight forward manner, can they shed light on the ideological matrix in which religious and social views of gender were constructed? How does gender amplify polemical and doctrinal claims? First narrated by male biblical authors, these female characters are transformed by male poets into moral exempla for men and women alike to emulate. Furthermore, these memre, or narrative poems, were recited by a single male voice, a distinction from the madrashe that were performed by female choirs. Scholars of Ephrem’s poetry have employed the insights of performance theory for exposing the gender dynamics of early Syriac poetry. Without embodied female voices vivifying the extended imagined speeches of these women, I am forced to pivot my own theoretical stance to better accommodate the features of this later poetry.
In this paper I focus on the imagined speeches attributed to the biblical women that lie at the heart of my study. Unlike the Nachleben of these figures in iconography and homilies, the poetic renderings depicted them as figures of boldness and religious zeal. The virtue of humility and its attendant personality traits are absent, and poets craft portraits of assertive women who overcome the marginality that their bodies and “ethnic” identities impose. Saba Mahmood’s Politics of Piety has been a formative influence on my work, especially her nuanced approach to female agency within patriarchal contexts. In practice, I have identified places where the self-assertion and agency of female characters is scripted in ways that apply pressure to social expectations, often in comparison with how male voices and actions are narrated. Avoiding the Scylla and Charybdis of either mistaking these voices for real women or dispensing with this literature as representative of purely “patriarchal” construction, I seek out the conceptual seams and moments of ideological break that these narratives of boundary-crossing women allowed.
|
Teaching the Effect of Narrative Pacing in Gen 22
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Lora Walsh, University of Arkansas
This teaching method enables students to recognize the literary technique of narrative pacing in the story of Abraham and the binding of Isaac (Gen 22), using a simply-designed worksheet in pairs or small groups. Students often have difficulty discerning the literary qualities of Biblical texts, but this exercise asks students to examine one Biblical story as a narrative that, as Erich Auerbach famously put it, is “permeated with the most unrelieved suspense.” For each verse and phrase of the narrative, students must estimate the amount of time that it would take for the described events to elapse—in days, hours, minutes, or seconds. Students are usually surprised to notice that the journey to the mountain in Moriah takes a full three days but is described in few words, whereas many phrases are used to describe each precise gesture of Abraham assembling an altar and preparing to kill Isaac. Students discover how Biblical narrative pacing can produce effects similar to slow-motion film, and how the narrative creates dramatic tension as Abraham appears to defer the moment of sacrifice. The presentation of this teaching method includes making connections to pacing in other Biblical genres, such as the Psalms, and to designing written assignments that challenge students to test the effects of literary style in transmitting other Biblical narratives.
|
In a Common Lot with the Angels of the Presence: Angelic Fellowship and Sectarian Identity at Qumran
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Matthew L Walsh, Acadia Divinity College
The claims of liturgical communion with the angels as a present reality of community life are well-known features of the Qumran sectarian texts. But often overlooked is the fact that it is angelic priests with whom the sectarians claim fellowship. In order to gain a fuller appreciation of sectarian angelic fellowship, this paper will highlight the key role played by priestly angels – especially those considered the foremost among them – in the religious imagination of ancient Judaism by comparing relevant non-sectarian Dead Sea Scrolls with sectarian compositions. While non-sectarian texts such as 1 Enoch, Aramaic Levi, Visions of Amram, 4QInstruction, and Jubilees point to the belief in an archetypal angelic priesthood whose actions and revelations were arguably for the benefit of many/most Jews and, in some cases, even Gentiles, the same cannot be said about the stance of the sectarian texts. Though the Hodayot, the Community Rule, and the Songs of the Sabbath Sacrifice presuppose and develop many of the themes of the non-sectarian texts, the Qumran movement considered its members the sole beneficiaries of the ministry of the celestial priesthood. Moreover, in light of the related sectarian conviction that they alone were true Israel and the nation’s valid priests, there likely would not have been a more powerful way to assert themselves as such than to make lofty boasts of fellowship with the ranking priests of the model sanctuary in heaven.
|
"Holy Ones" as a Christian Self-Designation: A Comparison of Religious Identity in the Pauline Corpus and in the Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Matthew L. Walsh, Acadia Divinity College
In his 2012 monograph, Self-Designations and Group Identity in the New Testament, P. Trebilco investigates οἱ ἅγιοι (literally, “the holy ones”), which is employed 60x in the NT to refer to Christians, with over half of these occurrences found in the Pauline corpus. While Trebilco convincingly argues that eschatological references to humans as “holy ones” in Second Temple Period Jewish texts (e.g., 1 En. 43:4; 100:5) were attractive to early Christianity due to its inaugurated eschatology, a main contention of this paper is that fuller recourse to the angelic associations of the term “holy ones” brings its NT usage into sharper focus. To be sure, Trebilco posits that the Church’s appropriation of οἱ ἅγιοι is indebted to Jesus’ self-referential use of the “one like a son of man” (Dan 7:13), and that subsequent reflection upon Dan 7 led the earliest Christians to refer to themselves as the Danielic “holy ones” (cf. Dan 7:18-20, 22, 27), which indicates the usurpation of an angelic appellation. But as this paper will endeavor to show, the benefits Trebilco suggests are conveyed by the Christian co-opting of “holy ones” – namely, privilege, holiness, and unity – are only enhanced by a more robust comparison with the angelic uses of the term in the late Second Temple Period. Thus, after interacting with key insights
from C. Newsom’s 2004 anthropological and social-psychological study, The Self as Symbolic Space: Constructing Identity and Community at Qumran, this paper will compare some of the eschatological outlooks of the sectarian texts of the Dead Sea Scrolls with those of the Pauline corpus. It will then be argued that “holy ones”– not least because of its angelic associations – was an ideal self-designation by which Paul sought to articulate and to fashion the identity of his Gentile congregations, especially as it pertained to their relationships with Jewish Christians.
|
Speculating (on) the Bible: Biblical Transformations in Atwood’s Dystopic Fiction
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Richard Walsh, Methodist University
Labeling The Handmaid’s Tale and the MaddAddam trilogy science fiction causes Margaret Atwood to bristle. She contends instead that they are “speculative fiction,” pushing present (social, political, scientific) trends to their logical (absurd?) conclusions. Parts of the Bible, particularly Genesis—read à la Aronofsky in an “apocalyptic” mode—play major roles in these stories. What one should notice, however, is that Atwood is speculating (on) the Bible, thrusting present “Bibles” toward their (absurd) consequences. The result provides lessons in biblical semiotics. The most obvious of these new Bibles are radically “literal” and calculatingly “lived.” The Gilead Bible in The Handmaid’s Tale is horrible, tyrannical, repressive. The “eco-freak” Bible (as the character Zeb terms it) in the MaddAddam trilogy borders on the suicidal (and the terrorist) in the face of the imperial power of mega-corporations. As various characters try to live “by the(se) book(s),” different, but predictable lifestyles emerge: true believers; hypocrites, those of little faith; and even rebels. The characterizations “realize” the respective Bibles but also raise provocative questions about trying to live life according to a/the book (cf. Don Quixote; Borges’ Ficciones). Significantly, the dominant Bibles in each story face challenges from other, differently empowered, readings. In The Handmaid’s Tale, Offred both explains and challenges the tyrannical, patriarchal Bible through various resistance strategies and through her own memory of and recreation of another Bible (God). In the MaddAddam trilogy, the Bible of the Church of PetrOleum supports the corporations’ rape of the planet and even the targeted assassinations of eco-freaks (and the end of their rival reading). While it may be less obvious, in the MaddAddam trilogy, Atwood also imagines the creation of a new Bible/myth/gods (after the death of God/Bible[s]), out of the vestiges of ruined myths, for and by the Crakers (and their human prophets). This rather Borgesian Bible reflects a dominant motif in Atwood’s fiction imagining “the word” itself as mysterium tremendum et fascinans. As the narrator of Blind Assassin opines, “Anyone intending to meddle with words needs such blessing, such warning.” One trembles at this word (cf. Isa 66:2). Intriguingly, this new Bible is strikingly vital in a way that the historical readings of the Twelfth Symposium on Gileadean Studies that concludes The Handmaid’s Tale are not. Hauntingly, these scholarly readings are the closest simulacrum in the dystopias to the readings that dominate academic biblical studies.
|
Jesus in Berlin: Normativity in Classics and the Skewing of Early Christian Literature
Program Unit: Redescribing Christian Origins
Robyn Faith Walsh, University of Miami
In order to understand the intellectual ethos that contributed to scholarly imagination about gospel writers and the early Christians, one must first understand the institutional and political contexts that characterized historical inquiry into antiquity within Germany during the Romantic era. The formal study of the New Testament/early Christianity emerged during this period, at a time when ideas of what constitutes a "Classic" and classical aesthetics inculcated numerous forms of normativity and exclusion within scholarship and disciplines. Ancient texts about Jesus, for example, were not treated as yet another piece of comparanda for understanding the era of Flavian literature; the means and methods used to evaluate them centered on nationalistic interests in reclaiming myth and a proto-Marxist desire to uncover the language of premodern/illiterate peoples. Such approaches were further troubled by the Protestant leanings of many of these scholars who, among other things, imagined Christians to be a unique collection of humble, itinerant underdogs resisting the elitism and indulgences of Rome. The continuing bifurcation of Classics and Religious Studies as stand-alone fields within the academy has reinforced these inherited, false dichotomies to the detriment of both disciplines.
This paper will explore some of central themes of Romanticism and nationalism that have adversely affected our approaches to early Christian literature. I will focus on three common presumptions or missteps pervasive in the field: (1) that the gospels represent communal, oral traditions; (2) that New Testament literature actively resists the corrupting influence of imperial 'Rome'; (3) that the language of the New Testament reinforces certain philological truisms about "Indo-European" or "Aryan" history. Integral to this discussion is the broader question of "What is a Classic" and how do our inherited assumptions about this category continue to circumscribe approaches to early Christian literature that are dominated by theology.
|
The Digital Syriac Corpus: A New Digital Resource for the Study of Syriac Literature
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
James E. Walters, Rochester College
The Digital Syriac Corpus is a new open-access digital repository of Syriac texts. The texts, which have been transcribed from both print editions and manuscripts, are encoded in the markup language of the Text Encoding Initiative (TEI) and displayed in a standardized format that is fully searchable. Furthermore, the Corpus has advanced searching options which will allow for new ways of searching for lexemes and relationships between words across the Corpus. Additionally, the Corpus interacts with other Digital Humanities projects in several ways, which highlights the unique opportunities that digital resources provide for the future of research. In this presentation, I will briefly introduce the Corpus and its features, and I will provide examples of ways that scholars can benefit from and contribute to the Corpus.
|
The (Syriac) Exhortation of Peter: A New Addition to the Petrine Apocryphal Tradition
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
James E. Walters, Rochester College
The "Exhortation of Peter" is a Syriac text attested in a single manuscript (Berlin 201 / Sachau 165 held in the Staatsbibliothek zu Berlin). Heretofore unedited and untranslated (forthcoming translation in Burke/Landau, More Christian Apocrypha, Vol. 2), this text narrates a public speech by the apostle Peter in which he exhorts a crowd regarding the need for preparation and perseverance in the Christian life. This text bears no apparent relationship to any other apocryphal literature featuring the apostle Peter. Furthermore, given the style of the content, the text is unlikely to have originated from the Apocryphal Acts tradition and instead appears to be a self-contained text that circulated independently. In this presentation, I will provide a brief introduction to the contents of this text and attempt to locate its genre and literary style more specifically by comparison with late-ancient hagiographic and monastic literature.
|
The Eternal Reign of Christ in Early Christian Interpretation
Program Unit: Development of Early Christian Theology
James Ware, University of Evansville
Despite continuing debate regarding the precise nature of his teaching, it is widely agreed that Marcellus of Ancyra in the fourth century taught that the reign of Christ would have an end. Our evidence is also clear that Marcellus’ central textual basis for his teaching was 1 Corinthians 15:24-28 (cf. Cyril, Cat. 15.29-30). Writing in opposition to Marcellus, fourth century authors such as Eusebius of Caesarea, Cyril of Jerusalem, Gregory of Nyssa, and John Chrysostom reject his interpretation of 1 Cor 15:24-28 as a novelty, but themselves interpret the passage in a variety of ways. Why should this be so? The history of interpretation in the first three centuries may provide an answer. In pre-Christian Jewish thought, the reign of the messianic king is everlasting (2 Sam 7:13; 7:16; Ps 61:7-8; 72:5-7; 72:17; 89:5 [Eng 4]; 89:30 [Eng 29]; 89:37-38 [Eng 36-37]; 132:12; Isa 9:6; Jer 33:17; Ez 37:24-25; Ps Sol 17:4; Jn 12:34), and the kingdom of the Son of Man of Daniel is eternal (Dan 7:14; cf. LXX Dan 7:27). The conception, Jewish in its origins, that the reign of Jesus as the Christ and the Son of Man is everlasting, is present in a number of New Testament texts (Luke 1:33; 22:30; Eph 1:21-22; 5:5; Heb 1:8-13; 2 Pet 1:11; Rev 11:15; 22:3), and is continued in early patristic sources. Justin, Irenaeus, Aristides, and Tertullian, and Hippolytus understand the kingdom of Christ as without end, and this understanding is regularly connected with key Old Testament passages affirming the everlasting reign of the Davidic king or of the Son of Man of Daniel (the three passages most frequently invoked being Isa 9:6 [LXX 9:7], Dan 7:14, 27, and Psalm 72:11). In these early authors, 1 Cor 15:24-28 is rarely cited, and plays no role whatsoever in discussion of the duration of Jesus’ reign. In the third century, Origen’s work Peri Archon marks a shift in approach. Origen in this work shows no interest in the messianic texts which were the focus of earlier authors, but gives sustained attention to 1 Cor 15:24-28, where he discovers a termination point for the reign of Christ. Origen’s thesis of a temporary reign of Christ finds no parallel until the work of Marcellus in the following century. The evidence taken together suggests the following. 1) The eternal duration of the kingship of Christ was widely held in the first two centuries. 2) An exegetical tradition involving core Septuagintal texts regarding the everlasting reign of the messianic king undergirded this understanding. 3) No widespread tradition of interpretation existed as to how 1 Cor 15:24-28 fit with this claim. This helps to explain a situation in which fourth century authors affirm the everlasting character of Christ’s kingship, reject Marcellus’ (and Origen’s) discovery of a temporary reign of Christ in 1 Cor 15:24-28 as without precedent, and yet themselves interpret this passage in a great diversity of ways.
|
A Good, Strong Story: Genesis as Resilience Literature
Program Unit: Biblical Literature and the Hermeneutics of Trauma
Megan Warner, University of Exeter
This paper proposes reading Genesis as ‘resilience literature’. It adopts gerontologist William L. Randall’s concept of ‘the good, strong story’ and Whitehead and Whitehead’s proposed resilience factors, ‘reframing’,‘recruiting’ and ‘resolve’, as frameworks within which to assess the capacity of Genesis to assist in the building of resilience, both in its context of its own time and in the context of our time. Beginning with a discussion of method and definition, the paper moves on to explore Genesis 1 in particular and Genesis as a whole more generally. The paper addresses the distinctive challenges or opportunities of considering, in the context of resilience, literature that does not directly address the traumatic events, or narrate the episodes of violence, to which it responds.
|
"The LORD was with Joseph": Thinking Diachronically about Divine Presence and Absence in Genesis 37–50
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Megan Warner, University of Exeter
Genesis 37-50 has long been considered the place where source-critical approaches encounter particular difficulty. Methods that have been fruitful elsewhere in Genesis and in the Pentateuch more generally seem to come unstuck in these chapters, so that synchronic approaches to interpretation are often preferred. While this paper does not attempt to resolve the larger conundrum of the transmission history of Genesis 37-50, it addresses a theological problem - the significance of YHWH’s presence with Joseph in Genesis 39 in the light of divine absence elsewhere in Genesis 37-50 - through the posing of diachronic questions. Does the limitation of YHWH’s presence with Joseph to Genesis 39 have theological implications for interpretation (does Joseph’s behaviour cause him to lose the favour of YHWH, for example), or do the multiple references to YHWH in Genesis 39 reflect diachronic development in the chapter that should not be considered significant for theological interpretation of the saga as a whole? If the latter, then which elements of Genesis 39 might be considered to indicate diachronic development and why, and what impact, if any, does the distinctive literary character of Genesis 37-50 have upon this assessment? Finally, if these elements do suggest development of a diachronic nature, what significance might this conclusion have for interpretation of Genesis 39, for Genesis 37-50, or for Genesis more widely?
|
A Question of Method: Senses, Bodies, and Religious Experience in Antiquity
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Meredith J. C. Warren, University of Sheffield
In the study of ancient religions, we as researchers often strive to make connections between the sometimes obscure remnants of the texts that happened to survive and lived human experiences. As humans ourselves, we know what it is like to live in bodies, to translate the world through our senses, and to feel powerful and transformative emotions. The gap, however, between our bodies and ancient bodies is immense, held apart by time, geography, culture, and language. The way we experience the world today is likely completely alien to the way Paul or Perpetua did, for example; the gap between their experienced reality and their textual legacy only complicates matters. This paper will examine the methodological questions at the foundation of any examination of ancient religious experience: how do we get from text to lived experience? How do we understand the role of ritual or performance, both in historical reality and in the imaginary world of the text? How do the senses impact how religious experiences take place and how they are communicated? Using Perpetua and Felicitas as an example text, I aim to highlight how an embodied approach to religious experience illuminates important aspects of ancient religions and their human practitioners.
|
Negotiating Cross-Cultural Identity: The Case of Egypto-Persian Kingship Display in the Achaemenid Empire
Program Unit: Literature and History of the Persian Period
Melanie Wasmuth, University of Helsinki
The conquest of Egypt by the Persian Great Kings of the Achaemenid dynasty created a representational dilemma, which is often not adequately taken into consideration: The two roles of Persian Great King and Egyptian Pharaoh were conceptually incompatible. Both kingship concepts stylized the king as absolute ruler of the whole world. More specifically, as pharaoh the Persian king had to fulfil and be displayed fulfilling the task of smiting the peoples in the southern, western and eastern realms, i.e. also the Persians. Consequently, when accepting the challenge of becoming not only conquerors, but also legitimate local rulers of Egypt from Cambyses onwards, new representational designs had to be composed, if the double role was to be expressed. One of these designs, and possibly the most intriguing one, is the monumental statue of Darius I, which was made for an Egyptian place of erection, but finally showed up in the gate context of Darius’s palace at Susa. Based on a reconsideration of the phraseology of its cuneiform inscription, the prevalent reconstruction of the statue with Persian-style head will be challenged. Instead, I will present four different reconstructions and discuss their potential reception by a cross-cultural audience.
|
Philosophical Polemics, the Worship of Creation, and Idolatry in the Wisdom of Solomon
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Emma Wasserman, Rutgers University
This paper explores the way that Pseudo-Solomon adapts inter-school philosophical critiques to its polemics about idolatry. A particular focus will be in Wis 13, which recycles philosophical arguments about providence and intelligent design to argue that idolators worship the created order, or some part thereof.
|
Scribal Alterations and the Reception of Jesus in Early Manuscripts of Luke
Program Unit: Gospel of Luke
Tommy Wasserman, Orebro School of Theology
The fact that theological difficulties at times caused scribes to alter the biblical text seems to be accepted by most scholars today. However, opinions diverge considerably as to the extent to which this happened. In the evaluation of individual passages, the lectio difficilior is a useful criterion, as long as it is not used in a mechanical fashion and it is important to note that scribal alterations do not necessarily reflect an alternative theological reception of Jesus – in particular additions may be theologically aligned with the text they expand. In order to understand how ancient scribes might have struggled with the text, it is further crucial to pay attention to the wider history of interpretation of a passage, not least in patristic writings. This paper looks at some selected textual variants in early witnesses to the Gospel of Luke and discuss the significance of these alternative readings (deviations from NA28) in relation to the portrayal and reception of Jesus. In these examples we can be certain that a scribal change took place in the early period of transmission because the textual variation is attested in at least one early papyrus witness or discussed by an early church father.
|
"Even the Doe Forsakes Her Fawn": The Earth Responds to Drought in Jeremiah
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Jaime L. Waters, DePaul University
Jeremiah 14:2-9 describes the impact of drought on the land of Judah. Drought plagues the land because of human disobedience. Judah broke its covenant with Yahweh by not obeying laws, worshiping other gods, and committing various iniquities (Jer 11:6-13). As a result of the unfaithful behavior, Yahweh sends a disastrous drought. The drought hurts the human transgressors, but it also damages the land itself and its animals. This paper will examine the non-human characters who lament the drought, i.e. the land, the doe, and donkeys, as well as the non-humans who are said to be absent from the land, i.e. water and grass (Jer 14:4-6). It will use the ecological hermeneutic of suspicion, identification, and retrieval as a framework to analyze these characters. The divine response to human cries for relief will also be considered. When Yahweh hears human pleas, the response is to further condemn the human transgressors. Yahweh threatens to send four destroyers: the sword to kill, dogs to drag, birds of the air and wild animals of the earth to devour and destroy (Jer 15:3). In an ironic twist, non-humans who suffer because of human behavior are called upon to be a destructive force. This paper will consider the implications of animals as trauma victims and agents of trauma.
|
The Creation of Sociorhetorical Commentary on 1 Peter
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Duane F. Watson, Malone University
This paper focuses on the writing of a commentary on 1 Peter for the Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity Commentary Series being published by SBL Press. This series structures the commentary by first identifying the rhetography of a text, that is, the series of pictures that the text is creating in the mind. This is followed by a discussion of the textures of the text, including inner texture, intertexture, social and cultural texture, ideological texture, and sacred texture. These textures are discussed in the order that best explains the text and is followed by the rhetorical force of the text as emergent Christian discourse. A sample of the commentary from 1 Peter 2:4–10 will be used to illustrate the sociorhetorical approach.
|
"Inasmuch as Many Have Attempted...": The Apocryphon of James and the Problem of Gospel Plurality
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Francis Watson, University of Durham
The ostensibly harmonious co-existence of four gospels in the canonical collection masks the fact that early gospels and gospel-like texts competed with each other for influence and impact. Thus Luke claims greater fidelity to the authentic apostolic tradition than his predecessors, while other evangelists seek a competitive advantage by communicating unique insights ascribed to individual apostolic figure such as John, Thomas, Mary, or Judas. This intertextual rivalry is dramatized in a scene near the opening of the Apocryphon of James (NHC I, 2), where all twelve disciples are depicted as writing the private or public teachings of Jesus in their gospel books, only to have their work disparaged and superseded as higher revelations are bestowed on James and Peter alone. For this author all other gospels are fundamentally unreliable, since the apostolic evangelists misunderstood and distorted the truth about Jesus – for example, his relation to prophecy and his parables. Definitive truth is contained only in this apocryphon or epistle of James, which relativizes even an earlier apocryphon written by James himself. Precisely in this heightened form, the Apocryphon of James highlights the competitive dynamic running through all early gospel literature.
|
Paul and Scripture: Theologian, Historian, or Something Else?
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Rikk Watts, Alphacrucis College, Regent College
Rom 9-11 unquestionably constitutes the densest, most complex, and most extensive use of Israel’s Scriptures in the NT. As such it offers an unparalleled opportunity to observe the mind of Paul at work. This paper will begin by offering some brief comments on the problematics of the terms “theologian” and “historian” (with an eye to the current NT debate). Then, using Rom 9-11 as a test case, it will argue, first, that Paul’s stance is fundamentally historical (but along the lines of Vico, Croce, Collingwood, and McMurray with the emphasis on agency, the inside of history, and re-enactment). And second, that his operative hermeneutic in engaging with Scripture is the principle of Yahweh’s consistent character: as Yahweh had acted in the past so he would act again (so also the rabbis). After a survey of how this principle informs Rom 9-11, the paper will conclude by suggesting that the number one problem besetting NT scholars in this field is their basic lack of familiarity with Israel’s Scriptures, and proposing some ways forward.
|
Flooded: Deluge Mythology in Declassified American Intelligence Analyses of Iran, 1946-1953
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
Chase L. Way, Claremont Graduate University
This paper surveys recently declassified intelligence analyses produced in the lead-up to the 1953, US-supported Iranian coup. In doing so, it demonstrates how these documents disturb the categories that scholars have historically conceived of as “religious” and “secular,” particularly as they describe the written production of the US intelligence apparatus. By extension, this piece argues that government analysts incrementally co-constructed a modern-day deluge myth narrative. Specifically, it shows how this political “flood” mythology – inspired by, although not identical to, traditional religious ideas – was an important causal factor in the US’ securitization of non-Western peoples: the 1953 coup is but one example of this. It likewise complicates characterizations of Cold War discourse as “apocalyptic,” by highlighting the prevalence of dystopian, post-apocalyptic scenarios of Soviet control. Finally, it suggests that the emergence of the deluge myth trope may be traced to the collective trauma experienced by the US during WWI and WWII.
|
Towards a Descriptive Hermeneutic for Early Mormonism
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
Thom Wayment, Brigham Young University
Beginning in 1828, Joseph Smith began making public his efforts to create new scriptural texts, including the Book of Mormon, followed by his Bible revision or translation, and continuing through the production of the beginning part of the Book of Abraham in 1835. Those efforts to revise sacred texts exist in a linear, historical sequence, and span a roughly seven-year period where texts were created, revised, and published. Fortuitously, many passages of scripture were revised or re-envisioned multiple times in this process, so that the Book of Mormon adopted and transformed New Testament and Old Testament language, which was then subsequently revised again in Smith's Bible translation and Book of Moses, which was then revised a third time in the Doctrine and Covenants. This production of scripture has never been fully analyzed with respect to its consequences for defining Mormon hermeneutics. I propose to provide an outline of Smith's use of scripture in the period from 1828 to 1835 to offer evidence of a developing LDS hermeneutic that forms the foundation of early Mormon theology. I will argue that the period of 1828-1833 was a period of defining prophetic control over canonical texts that included the reshaping of biblical texts in the period between 1833 and 1835. This process of re-imagining the relationship of prophet and sacred texts continued on until the "revelations" contained in the Doctrine and Covenants ceased in the 1840s.
|
Addressing Diversity through Transformative Learning
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Jane S. Webster, Barton College
The students coming into our Liberal Arts classrooms have changed. They no longer need access to our elite knowledge—now readily available in the palm of their hand—but they do need to learn how to find, evaluate, and use information to understand themselves and the larger world they live in. According to Walvoord (2008) and Parks (2005), they often take our Religious Studies courses to make sense of their identity, purpose, and meaning; those who “cultivate the spirit” (Astin, et al 2011) reap the benefit of greater success throughout college. These students are not looking for content, but relevance and meaning, especially when they are encountering diversity for the first time.
This paper will describe two “learner-centered” (Weimer 2013) experimental courses that use biblical content to address issues of diversity that are both personal and relevant to contemporary students. In conversation with the Old Testament, students explore identity formation, and with the New Testament, they explore power relations. After briefly reviewing the pedagogical foundations of the approach, I will describe the course design, report on the results, and reflect on the implications of such a move. The end-goal of both these courses is to promote transformative learning (Cranton 2016).
|
Developing a Radiocarbon-Based Chronology at Tel Gezer
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Lyndelle Webster, Institut für Orientalische und Europäische Archäologie (OREA)
Gezer is one of the major tell sites in the southern Levant for the Bronze and Iron Ages. The ancient city is well attested in Egyptian and biblical texts, and archaeological work has shown it to have a long occupation history, punctuated by destructions but with few substantial gaps. Thus the development of a radiocarbon-based chronology for Tel Gezer has great potential to contribute to our reconstructions of the region’s history, and the synchronization of southern Levantine strata with Egypt. Until now almost no radiocarbon data has been available from Tel Gezer.
In 2016 the Tandy Tel Gezer excavation team radiocarbon-dated an initial set of short-lived material, representing many of the Iron Age strata they have targeted over the past decade of fieldwork. Shortly after this, a collaboration was formed with Lyndelle Webster, whose radiocarbon research focuses on southern Levantine Late Bronze Age chronology. We then proceeded to date the recently excavated strata in Field West spanning the Late Bronze to Iron Age transition. This sequence includes strata characterized by Philistine pottery, and a final Late Bronze Age destruction that the excavators attribute to Pharaoh Merneptah. The Tandy radiocarbon sequence is complemented by new material sampled from the exposed baulks of the earlier Hebrew Union College (HUC) excavations. This material primarily concerns the Late Bronze to early Iron Ages, but includes some data from Middle Bronze strata.
This paper will present the first substantial radiocarbon dataset from the occupation levels of Tel Gezer, including the material from the Tandy excavation and newly sampled short-lived material from the HUC baulks. An evaluation of the data will be given, including Bayesian chronological models. Discussion of the results will focus on points where the data is sufficiently robust to help clarify key chronological issues pertaining to the history of the site and the wider region.
|
The Abrahamic Narratives and Their Interpretive Background in Hebrews 11:8-19
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Leonard Wee, Trinity Theological College-Singapore
Many studies of the use of the Old Testament in the Letter to the Hebrews analysed the Writer’s interpretation of the OT on the basis of the scriptural texts themselves, but few have articulated exactly how the traditional interpretation of these texts would have played a significant role in the Writer’s use of Scripture. This paper proposes that the traditional interpretation of these texts serves as the framework for the Writer’s use of the OT narratives, and that certain departure from the framework at the micro-level can be explained by the rhetorical purpose of the Writer.
|
Novatian’s Use of Philippians 2:6-7
Program Unit: Development of Early Christian Theology
Mark Weedman, Johnson University
Placing Novatian within the overall trajectory of early Latin Christology has proved difficult. It is surely too much, as a recent scholar has tried to argue, to claim that Novatian almost entirely anticipates the catholic Christological formulas of the fifth century. But it is also true that Novatian does demonstrate a movement away from the logos-sarx Christologies of his Latin contemporaries and predecessors. As Grillmeier notes, Novatian’s Christology is a “remarkable mixture” of the old models with his formulations (133)--formulations that may well prefigure much later doctrinal solutions.
As a number of scholars have noted, Novatian’s primary innovation is twofold. The first concerns his application of the notion of “community of substance” to both Trinitarian and Christological questions. For Novatian, the phrase “communion of substance” is an extension of the traditional Latin Logos theology. Novatian insists that concept “Word” must be recognized as the “substance of power” that extends from the Father, and it is this divine power that is extended in the Son (and returned to the Father) through the communion of the substance. Though Novatian initially develops this idea to describe the relationship between the Father and the Son, he will also use it to account for the relationship between the divinity and humanity in the incarnation. Novatian’s second innovation is his use of Philippians 2.6-7 and the notion of “emptying” to explain how the Son could be fully God and fully human. Though exegesis of the passage will become central to Trinitarian and Christological debates in the fourth and fifth centuries, Novatian is among the first to use it directly this way, especially in the Latin West.
In this paper, I will argue that Novatian’s development of “community of substance,” in both its Trinitarian and Christological contexts, derives from his exegesis of Philippians 2.6-7. This exegesis, especially his exploration of the “emptying,” accomplishes three things for Novatian: It was the emptying of the Son that also helps us understand how the Son could be human and divine at the same time, which is how this passage will show up in later controveries. But for Novatian, the emptying of the Son also helps us understand how the Son could share the Father’s nature and so be one with the Father. And it was the emptying that also helps us understand how the Son’s divinity and humanity correlate in the person of Jesus.
Accordingly, Novatian’s significance may lie less in his specific doctrinal formula than as an example of how early theologians used the exegesis of specific passages of Scripture to articulate a new theological grammar; once Novatian articulated his exegesis of "the emptying," he was able to deploy that "grammar" to a number of questions. And so, Novatian’s use of Philippians 2 illustrates the kind of exegesis, even more than the specific results of that exegesis, that will become the centerpiece of later controversies.
|
God in the Biblical Imagination: Nature Imagery
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible and Cognate Literature
Andrea Weiss, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion (New York Branch)
This paper will examine the many biblical metaphors for God rooted in the realm of nature, like metaphors of God as dew, a rock, the wilderness, and a spring of water. Applying insights from corpus linguistics, this paper will analyze the diverse divine metaphors drawn the biology and ecology of the biblical world. Attention will be paid to the mechanics of these metaphor—how they manifest themselves linguistically—and the theology of these metaphors—what they reveal about biblical perceptions of God.
|
Samuel and Saul at Gilgal: A New Interpretation of the Elephant Mosaic Panel at the Late Antique Synagogue of Huqoq, Israel
Program Unit: Jewish Interpretation of the Bible
Zeev Weiss, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
A figurative mosaic panel on the floor of a 5th-c. CE synagogue at Huqoq has recently been identified by the excavation team as a depiction of the Seleucid king Antiochus VII with the Hasmonean king John Hyrcanus I, or alternatively, of Alexander the Great meeting the Jewish high priest Jaddus. We argue that the panel shows the prophet Samuel’s fateful encounter with King Saul at Gilgal, as told in 1 Samuel 15. Narratively, this is where Saul learns that God has rejected him as king, paving the way for the rise to the throne of David. In the lower register we see the aftermath of Saul’s battle with Amalek, where he spurned the divine command to fully exterminate the Amalekites. In the middle register we have a formal portrait of an enthroned Samuel and his prophetic disciples, here styled as holy warriors, inhabiting an arcade. In the upper register we see an emboldened Samuel reporting the news of God’s rejection to Saul upon his return from war with a looted bull for sacrifice in tow. The panel is a work of artistic and narrative embellishment—a kind of visual midrash—that still hews closely to the biblical story. Samuel appears here as spiritual victor over Saul, despite the king’s formidable machinery of war and his stylization as glorified warrior-emperor of the East. The depiction draws on late antique religious and imperial iconography to illustrate the scene, which appears also in a few illuminated Bibles. We argue that a biblical scene is far more suitable to this social and architectural context than the extra-biblical tales proposed thus far.
|
"Belonging to Christ" at Corinth: Challenging the Assumption of Exclusive Allegiance
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Laurence L. Welborn, Fordham University
This paper explores Paul’s Corinthian correspondence and the Acts of the Apostles regarding the boundaries and commitments of the identities of Christ believers, individually and as a group. Evidence of continuing connections to the synagogue and participation in Greek and Roman cults will be reassessed in light of the evidence of inscriptions and dedications from Roman Corinth.
|
Where's the Beef?
Program Unit: Meals in the HB/OT and Its World
Eric L. Welch , University of Kansas
Where’s the Beef? The Conspicuous Absence of Royal Feasting in Chronicles
The foundation of scholarly inquiry surrounding Chronicles is comprised of the analysis of the historiographical techniques, theological motives, and topical fascinations of the book’s idiosyncratic author. Among the well documented facets of the Chronicler’s style are his affinity for public ceremony and the use of lists. Given these preoccupations, it would seem that royal feasting would easily lend itself to becoming a topic of focus for the Chronicler. Perhaps surprisingly then, depictions of royal feasting are absent in the Chronicler’s account of Israel’s history, with the only feasting taking place in the context of the primary religious festivals. Taking into account the theological motives of the Chronicler as well as contemporary viewpoints surrounding royal feasting, this paper will explore why the author most likely to engage in detailed depictions of royal feasting probably avoided depicting Israelite kings engaging in the practice.
|
Seeing John 11:47–57 as the Jewish Trial of Jesus according to John
Program Unit: Biblical Law
John W. Welch, Brigham Young University
After reviewing the events leading up to the raising of Lazarus in John 11, this paper proposes that John 11:47-57 should be understood as a legal proceeding before the Sanhedrin presided over by Caiaphas, resulting in a verdict that Jesus should be put to death (John 11:53). Most treatments of the trial and death of Jesus in the Gospel of John begin with his arrest in John 18:1-13. But that event cannot be understood without backing up a few days earlier in Bethany, just over the hill to the east of Jerusalem, when reports went out, both positive and negative, about the apparent raising of Lazarus from the dead at the home of Martha and Mary. As a result, important legal steps were set in motion. The chief priests and Pharisees convened a court (synedrion). They wondered and debated what they should do. Some argued that Jesus’s “many signs” (polla sēmeia) constituted wonders or miracles that were leading people for which the wonderworker should “be put to death” (Deuteronomy 13:2, 5; John 11:53). Several of the terms in this account are juridical: As they discussed this case, some argued if they left Jesus alone (aphōmen), also meaning if we exonerate him or condone his conduct, the Romans will take away “the place” (ton topon), the temple or their place of political authority (11:48). Caiphas, however, rejected these arguments out of hand. He reasoned (logizesthe) or ruled—based on a long-standing principle of Jewish law—that it would be advantageous or helpful for one man to die on behalf of the people (11:50). In saying this, Caiphas acted officially as the High Priest (11:51). This verdict has a ring of legal finality to it, and from that point forward the Jewish leaders, Sadducees and Pharisees, were legally resolved together (ebouleusanto) to kill Jesus. A final decision on the culpability of Jesus had been reached. The only remaining questions were how shall he be apprehended, sentenced, and executed. The paper concludes with legal evaluations of such things as how (1) this understanding affects one’s reading of the account of the raising of Lazarus, (2) explains the order to arrest not only Jesus but also Lazarus (11:57; 12:10), (3) makes sense of Jesus’s popularity at his entry into Jerusalem the Sunday before his crucifixion, (4) accounts for the lack of a trial at the home of Annas (18:24), and (5) the legal representation to Pilate that Jesus had been accused of being (18:29) and found to be (18:30) a worker of evil (kakon poiōn) or an illegal wonderworker (kakopoios). According to John, by openly raising Lazarus from the dead, Jesus was effectively signing his own death warrant.
|
The Eye as Metaphorical Agent in Deuteronomic Law
Program Unit: Biblical Law
A. Rahel (Schafer) Wells, Andrews University
Laws found in Exodus and Leviticus reference the eye as a specific body part, such as Exod 21:26, where damage to the eye of a slave results in freedom for the slave. However, Deuteronomic law shifts from this literal reference to a more metaphorical usage of the eye. In multiple passages and various laws, the eye is used in a metaphorical sense. For instance, bribes are said to blind the eyes of the wise in Deut 16:19, but receiving money in order to insure a certain action or decision does not lead to actual physical blindness. Here, the text indicates a metaphorical use of the eye to represent a part of the brain that judges correctly and fairly. Most of the remaining examples involve just retribution or punishment where the law specifies that the eye should not pity the one being punished (cf. Deut 13:8; 19:13, 21; 25:12). These passages indicate a metaphorical use of the eye to represent the emotions (or the heart), a part of the brain that is affected and moved by those who are suffering or punished. None of these laws in Deuteronomy discuss actual physical eyes or eyesight, but use the body part which normally is associated with physical eyesight to refer to mental and emotional thought-processes. Physical eyesight may certainly be involved in provoking these thought-processes, but the metaphor carries the meaning of the law into categories that would not require physical eyesight. For example, a blind person could still be bribed, described as the blinding of the eyes of their mind. A blind person could also still pity the one being punished for sin, described as the eyes of their emotions pitying the guilty. This paper will further explore the reasons for this metaphorical usage of the eye in Deuteronomy, as well as ramifications for metaphors found in legal material. Additional intertextual linkages with other metaphorical usages of the eye in the Hebrew Bible will also be noted.
|
The Purpose of the Covenant and Deuteronomic Codes and the Insights of Eckart Otto
Program Unit: Book of Deuteronomy
Bruce Wells, University of Texas
This paper will consider current scholarly views on the nature of the so-called law codes of the ancient Near East. There are multiple ways to categories these views, but they seem to fall into three basic groups: the legal, the scientific, and the textual. The legal view holds that the codes formed the basis for the operative law in their respective societies. The scientific view sees the codes as scribal academic endeavors that more or less described but did not prescribe the law in practice. The textual view recognizes the codes simply as texts or documents and is generally agnostic about any relation they might have had to practiced law. This paper will go on to argue that any attempt to identify the purpose of the codes must distinguish between the stage when the individual provisions were composed and the stage when provisions were compiled for display on a monument (e.g., Hammurabi) or within a narrative text (e.g., the Covenant and Deuteronomic Codes). Different purposes may well have obtained at each stage. The work of Eckart Otto has shown that the biblical authors were intentional about the religious and ethical dimensions of the codes, and these dimensions become significant at the stage of display. Much previous scholarship has focused principally on the stage of composition, and it is Otto’s insights that have, in part, helped to push scholarly analysis to consider the more ambitious goals of those who incorporated the Covenant and Deuteronomic Codes into the biblical texts as we now have them.
|
The Liberation of the Body of Creation: Towards a Pauline Environmental Ethic
Program Unit: Pauline Theology
Kyle B. Wells, Westmont College, Santa Barbara
To many Paul’s radical notions of sin and death (Gal 3:22; Rom 3:9, 5:12–21; Rom 6:6, 7:24), along with his singular focus on “New Creation” (Gal 6:14–15), imply a theological framework that has little interest in or hope for the natural world. Others, inside and outside Pauline studies, look to Romans 8:19–22 as providing clear support for an environmental agenda. Such differing readings of Paul depend, in part, on the highly ambiguous and contested meaning of ktisis in Rom 8:21, and in what way this ktisis participates in the freedom of the glory of the children of God. While various answers have been given to these difficult questions, and while most studies recognize that Paul closely relates the liberation ktisis (v 21) to the resurrection of the body (v 23), Paul’s distinct theology of the body and of its resurrection has been largely overlooked by scholars answering these questions. This paper traces the ways in which Paul’s statement about the liberation of κτίσις in Rom 8:21 echos Paul discourse on the resurrection of the body in 1 Cor 15:42, as well his description of the liberation of the Christian in Rom 6:6–7, 17–22. By setting these observations within the context of Paul’s larger theology of the connectedness of the body, and by paying particular attention the place of the the body in the Christian’s liberation from sin and death (6:6; 12–13; 8:23), this paper offers an alternative explanation to the relationship between the liberation of ktisis and resurrection in Paul’s thought, one that accounts for ktisis appearing to be both distinct from and a part of the children of God. Moreover, by comparing the relationship Paul sees between the liberation of ktisis and the liberation of the body, we are able to explore new avenues for a distinctly Pauline environmental ethic, one that is rooted in his apocalyptic framework.
|
Biblical Texts and Video Games: "The Binding of Isaac" as Case Study
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Rebekah Welton, University of Exeter
This paper discusses Edmund McMillen’s independent video game ‘The Binding of Isaac’ which riffs on the biblical Aqedah, radically transforming its portrayal and message. As a form of media typically considered to be ‘low’, video gaming is not usually paid much attention within biblical studies. The ubiquity of video gaming across large segments and intersections of modern society attests to the need to view video gaming as an influential cultural phenomenon. Due to the exposure video game content receives, biblically themed games impact wide and diverse audiences. What is particularly fascinating about ‘The Binding of Isaac’ is its stance; the game does not view the biblical text as sacred and thus makes dramatic transpositions and transvaluations to the text, rendering it foreign to those familiar with the narrative in Genesis 22. For example, Isaac’s sacrificing parent is his mother rather than Abraham, Isaac is portrayed as a baby, the game is set in the modern day and the game utilises imagery from Catholicism, Satanism, and, fantasy and horror genres. Due to the interactive nature of video games, players have a physical and psychological role in the making of meaning and also experience the story from a first person perspective. This paper argues that the reception of biblical texts in the new, digital media of video games needs to be taken seriously by academia as impactful and culturally meaningful expressions of biblical stories.
|
Underwriting Authority: Religious "Experts" of the Second Century and the Texts that Made Them
Program Unit: Religious World of Late Antiquity
Heidi Wendt, McGill University
Underwriting Authority: Religious "Experts" of the Second Century and the Texts that Made Them
|
The Kingdom of God and Human Rights: Insides, Outsides, and Points of Entry
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Karen Wenell, University of Birmingham
Despite the dominance of Gustaf Dalman’s ‘rule not realm’ definition of the Kingdom of God in biblical studies, the Kingdom presents as a significant spatial resource in biblical interpretation. The spatial contours of the Kingdom include a clear delineation of inside and outside (e.g. ‘for those outside, everything comes in parables’), and a point of entry (e.g. the difficulty of entering for those with wealth), yet there is also a sense of ‘striving’ for the Kingdom and a degree of uncertainty about belonging, conveyed through parabolic and judgement scenarios. The paper takes this degree of uncertainty as a starting point for consideration of the ethics of the Kingdom, working with the principle that all sacred spaces entail ethics for belonging and relation to ‘the other’. In order to try and understand how both particular and universal aspects of the Kingdom might be used to engage with human rights which transcend borders, and contrasting categories like refugee/citizen, the paper will interact with the thought of Hannah Arendt, whose work sets up the notion of a general history of oppression in order to understand nation states and the creation of refugees and oppression. Resources like the Kingdom may be both universalising and differentiating at different moments, indicating that everyone must have the right to belong, yet the claim to belong is dislocated from any specific community. The idea in Matthew of the wheat and tares growing together, and other images (that often end in judgement) of the Kingdom suggest a sense of uncertainty that might be connected to Arendt’s notion of cohabitation. The moment when one is certain they belong to the inside may be the moment they prove themselves to be outside. One cannot absolve the ethics of their behaviour because they think they are ‘inside’ as the outsider and seeming enemy might be the one who justifies themselves by their ‘good’ actions as in the famous parable of the Samaritan. The group boundary is present, but cannot serve as protection. Ultimately, one’s status as belonging is characterised by a level of uncertainty. Such an approach to the Kingdom might also avoid some of the pitfalls of supersessionist interpretations of the Kingdom as universal in relation to more particular spatialities, recognising that resources from different religious traditions are necessary in order to address pressing needs for belonging to a human community (and protecting attendant rights) and issues of plurality and differentiation.
|
Ritual Action and Epiphany in 1 Enoch
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Rodney A. Werline, Barton College
After Enoch’s pronouncement of judgment upon the watchers, the watchers plead with the seer to seek mercy for them from God. Enoch responds to their request by writing a letter of memorandum, which he then recites by the head waters of the Dan (1 En 13:4-7). This ritualized action results in an epiphany in which Enoch sees the heavenly throne and is commissioned to tell the watchers that their petition has been rejected. Further, one might even understand the epiphany as extending through his cosmic journeys (chs. 17-36). While the ritual occupies only a few verses, it reflects a rather complex cultural phenomenon. First, the activity of writing a memorandum is the work of a scribe; the action requires writing a text. Second, as Nickelsburg has argued, Enoch’s intercessory activity resembles the roles of the archangels in chs. 6-12, and in this case resembles the function of priests. Third, the text is read or recited. Repetition in both the ancient and modern worlds can induce trance states (Merkur). Further, the effect of this embodied activity is enhanced or intensified because it occurs by running water (Idel), which can be hypnotic. Finally, the action takes place in a potent geographical location, for Mt. Hermon was considered sacred ground for many years by the time of the production of the text (Nickelsburg). In describing this phenomenon in 1 Enoch, I will employ Rappaport’s principle that while rituals may appear across several cultures, they remain specific to the cultural setting in which they are performed. This paper will also explore the oddity that Enoch performs a ritual action that will lead to a revelation of the heavenly throne even though the request in the memorandum is rejected and is actually wrong-headed. Finally, the paper explores the way in which Enoch’s ritual activity in the end does not simply benefit the visionary and move the narrative along, it also engages the text’s audience, making its members recipients of the revelation through its reporting.
|
Reconsidering the Literary Links between Hosea and Joel
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Nicholas R. Werse, Baylor University
Book of the Twelve scholars widely recognize the importance of the composition of Joel for the formation of the Book of the Twelve as a whole. Joel echoes language and passages from across the Twelve and redaction critics identify Joel-like language and ideology in later redactions across the Twelve. Although Joel contains strong links with the following prophetic texts in the Twelve, the nature of its relationship with Hosea remains a point of debate. Hosea lacks the focus on the nations that links Joel with many of the following texts in the Twelve. Hosea and Joel share thematic concerns with the land and repentance (as argued by Nogalski, Bosshard, and Schart), but some scholars object that these thematic similarities do not necessitate a redactional linking of these two texts (e.g., Ben Zvi and Wöhrle). Such parallels often depend on the identification of a common theme or word that appears elsewhere in the prophets, calling into question the intentionality of the parallel for integrating Joel into its place in the Twelve. Furthermore, Joel’s compositional style as scribal prophecy indicates that one would expect literary parallels from preexisting prophetic texts without necessitating a scribal awareness of placement next to these texts in a collection. I propose a paper that reexamines the case for redactional links between Hosea and Joel, by building a case for Joel’s editorial connection to Hosea upon the structural placement of literary parallels between these texts. This paper argues that Joel’s parallels with Hosea follow the same editorial patterns as Joel’s parallels with Amos, suggesting that they position Joel in relation to these two texts in the same way. This paper begins by examining the structural significance of Joel’s parallels with Amos, building upon the established arguments of Nogalski, Schart, and Wöhrle. Scholarship widely recognizes the importance of Joel 4:16 and Amos 1:2 for positioning Joel before Amos. This paper argues that this widely recognized parallel occurs as part of a scribal agenda that ends Joel with parallels of the beginning (Joel 4:16//Amos 1:2) and end of Amos (Joel 4:18//Amos 9:13aβb). The first parallel with Amos (Joel 4:16) quotes the Amos text (Amos 1:2), while the second parallel (Joel 4:18) requires the editors to update the end of Amos (9:13 aβb). This paper then argues that the parallels with Hosea follow the same structural pattern at the beginning of Joel. Joel similarly opens with strategic parallels to the beginning (Joel 1:1//Hosea 1:1) and end of Hosea (Joel 1:5-7, 9-12//Hos 14:2-8). Whereas the first parallel (Joel 1:1) quotes the preexisting beginning of Hosea (1:1), the second parallel (Joel 1:5-7, 9-12) requires the editors to update the end of Hosea (14:2-8). These structural similarities indicate that Joel connects to Hosea in the same way as it connects to Amos. This conclusion supports the proposal that Joel was shaped for its placement between Hosea and Amos in the MT order of the Twelve (as argued by Schneider, Nogalski, Bosshard, and Schart).
|
Texts and Social Contexts: Sets of Possibilities for Pauline Texts Concerning Gender
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Cynthia Long Westfall, McMaster Divinity College
|
The Rule of Faith as Hermeneutic: Irenaeus' Interpretation of Psalms in the Demonstration of the Apostolic Preaching
Program Unit: Development of Early Christian Theology
Paul Wheatley, University of Notre Dame
In Irenaeus's writings against Gnosticism, one of his main points of contention was the hermeneutical method of those who, "endeavor to adapt…to their own peculiar assertions the parables of the Lord, the sayings of the prophets, and the words of the apostles, in order that their scheme may not seem altogether without support" (Against Heresies, 1.8.1). Yet, Irenaeus did not take issue with the Gnostics' rearranging of scripture per se; Irenaeus himself also undertook a flexible synthesis of scripture from both the Old Testament, the Gospels, and the apostolic letters in his Demonstration of the Apostolic Preaching. Rather, he castigated the Gnostic heretics because their synthesis was artificial, and their hypothesis was false. But how might one arrive at a faithful hypothesis?
In Irenaeus's Demonstration, he describes the Rule of Faith not primarily as a plot or metanarrative, but as a hermeneutical tool based on the divine characters within the metanarrative, namely, the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. In the Demonstration, Irenaeus defines the persons of the Trinity by their action in the different οἰκονομία, and presents the work of the triune God first within the baptism of Jesus and then throughout salvation history. This paper will examine Irenaeus' interpretation of Ps 2:7, 45:6-7, and Ps 110, demonstrating how Irenaeus uses the Rule of Faith as a hermeneutical tool which not only functions to interpret the Old Testament scriptures Christologically, with Jesus Christ present in the work of God, but also functions as a Trinitarian hermeneutic within which Father, Son, and Spirit are at work in the presence of God in the Old Testament.
|
Pre-Islamic Camel Sacrifice in the Qur'an
Program Unit: The Qur’an and Late Antiquity (IQSA)
Brannon Wheeler, United States Naval Academy
Various passages in the Qur’an (e.g., 6:143-146) refer to a number of pre-Islamic practices associated in early Muslim exegesis with the sanctuary of Mecca and the nearby areas of Muzdalifah, Mina, and Arafat. Exegetes explain that pilgrims visiting the Ka’bah in Mecca used to offer “first-fruits” sacrifices linked to seasonal festivals during the month of Rajab and fertility rites linked to the date harvests and annual fairs in Ukaz and at the sanctuary of Wajj in Ta’if. Other rituals associated with hunting and warfare center on the cult of Quzah or Qaws (described as a storm-god not unlike Hadad and Ba’al in Northwest Semitic contexts) in Arafat and Mina at both ends of Muzdalifah. This has led some scholars, such as Snouck Hurgronje and Arent Jan Wensinck, to propose that the Islamic Hajj was modeled after the rituals performed one time by the prophet Muhammad just before his death that combined what were, in pre-Islamic times, rituals performed at two separate cultic sites (i.e., ‘umrah to Mecca, hajj to Muzdalifah). This paper focuses on how the final camel sacrifice of the prophet Muhammad, performed at Mina at the conclusion of his joint pilgrimage to Meccan and Muzdalifah, is interpreted by Muslim scholars as representing a break with the pre-existing sacrifices and ritual hunts of the pre-Islamic period. Part one studies the pre-Islamic fertility and hunting rites described by Muslim exegesis in the wider context of other sources. Part two examines the pre-Islamic roots of the rituals linked to the acquisition of the sacrificial victim (marking, garlanding, driving of animals) as described in hadith and Islamic law. Part three investigates how various parts of the pre-Islamic cult(s) were appropriated to biblical precedents, primarily through connecting fertility and hunting rites with biblical exegesis of the Abraham stories.
|
(Re)reading Regulating Sex in the Roman Empire One Year Later
Program Unit: Westar Institute
David Wheeler-Reed, Yale University and Albertus Magnus College
(Re)reading Regulating Sex in the Roman Empire One Year Later
|
"Like a Lion Roaring": Exploring the Beastly Rhetoric of Revelation 10–13
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Robyn Whitaker, University of Divinity
This paper seeks to refine sociorhetorical interpretation of Revelation by exploring the various textures (innertexture, intertexture, social-cultural texture, and ideological texture) associated with the personified agents. Using the two beasts of Revelation 13 and the mighty angel of Revelation 10 as examples, I will argue that the narrative sets up competing beastly images to rhetorically undermine imperial power and reinforce heavenly power. Comparison will be made with personified beastly agents in other ancient apocalypses.
|
Paul within Judaism: Notes from the Second Century
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Benjamin White, Clemson University
As Isaac Oliver (2013, 2016) has now strongly reminded us, the Paul of canonical Acts continues to position himself within Judaism in significant ways even after his encounter with the risen Christ. He has Timothy circumcised (Acts 16.3), celebrates Pentecost (Acts 20.16), takes a Nazarite vow (Acts 21.26), speaks in a “Hebrew dialect” (Acts 21.40), calls himself a Pharisee (Acts 23.6), and refers to his fellow Jews as “my people” (Acts 24.17; 28.19). Paul’s modus operandi in Acts is “to the Jew first, but also to the Greek” (Rom 1.16; 2.9-10) as he enters into cities of the Diaspora and proclaims the risen Messiah in their synagogues. These are just some of the highlights. This paper raises the question of what the early reception of Paul can tell us about the historical Paul’s ongoing relationship to Judaism. If his own letters have remained “hard to understand” and easy to “twist” (2 Peter 3.16), what can early memorializations of the Apostle tell us about the matter?
Canonical Acts is not alone in portraying Paul as a practicing Jew who saw his fellow Jews being within close orbit of his ministry. The Martyrdom of Paul portrays the Apostle, in the final breaths before his execution, facing east and praying in Hebrew to “the fathers” (Acts of Paul 10.5). Papyrus 46, the earliest preserved collection of Paul’s letters, contains Hebrews in second position after Romans. Clearly its scribe and likely the scribe of its Vorlage viewed Paul’s calling to “all the nations” (Rom 1.5) as naturally including those of Jewish birth (Hebrews 1.1: “our fathers”). The Muratorian Fragment says that Paul took Luke around with him as one “zealous for the Law” (l. 5). This line has been variously amended and interpreted by scholars, but perhaps it is best to leave it as is and take it at face value. The Muratorian Fragment remembers Paul’s close associate as Torah-observant (whether as a Jew or a Gentile the text does not disclose).
These kinds of texts help to balance out the sometimes lazy characterization of a disappearing Jewish Paul in the second century – a disappearance indebted to Marcion and the Ebionites, as well as the rising anti-Judaism of various forms of early Christ-faith. Moreover, since their various portrayals of Paul within Judaism are independently attested and cut against the rising anti-Judaism of early Christianity, it is more likely than not that this element of their mnemonic bricolage retains a strong lineage back to the historical Paul. Canonical Acts, the Martyrdom of Paul, Papyrus 46, and the Muratorian Fragment provide early readings of Paul that correspond in many ways with the burgeoning “Paul within Judaism” movement in contemporary scholarship. They suggest that Paul remained a Torah-observant Jew long after his association with the Christ-cult, that he included in his inner-circle other Torah observant associates, and that he saw his field of apostleship as including his fellow Jews.
|
Timothy as Collaborator: Rolling Delta and Its Utility in Multi-authored Pauline Epistles
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
Benjamin White, Clemson University
The measurement of Paul’s stylome – the supposedly fixed, quantitative representation of his literary style – has been a task most often engaged in for the sake of authorship attribution. The foundation of Pauline Studies as a discipline rests in the criticism of the canonical assumption that there are 13 or 14 authentically Pauline Epistles. Naysayers of what is now called computational stylistics have sometimes pointed to the short length of the Pauline Epistles or the evolution of a person’s stylome through time as factors so complicating of the enterprise that the entire endeavor should be mistrusted. More often, defenders of the canonical tradition have pointed to Paul’s co-authors or amanuenses as complicating access to a Pauline stylome. Studies in ancient letter-writing by Otto Roller (1933) and E. Randolph Richards (1991, 2004) have made this point explicitly, concluding that it is likely that co-authors and amanuenses played a larger role in the wording of the Pauline Epistles than most of us have imagined.
Scholars of early Christianity have historically found it difficult to evaluate this claim. A recently developed tool can help. The Computational Stylistics Group (https://sites.google.com/site/computationalstylistics/) has developed a feature called “Rolling Delta” in its Stylo computer package that is being used to help solve longstanding questions of collaborative authorship. “Rolling Delta” works as follows. First, for any multi-authored text one needs a training set of texts from each of the collaborators and a feature (usually some vector of most frequent words or character n-grams) that easily distinguishes between them with standard distance measures like Delta. Second, the co-authored text is then sliced into successive overlapping samples of, say, 2,000 words. Rolling Delta measures each new slice of the text for the prescribed set of features, marks the places in the text where the style significantly shifts, and then assigns sections of the collaborative piece to one or the other of the authors. Maciej Eder (2016), Jan Rybicki (2014), and Mike Kestemont (2013) have used the tool convincingly on English and Latin texts.
This paper builds on the training that I did with the Computational Stylistics Group in Krakow, Poland in 2017 and discerns the utility of Rolling Delta for marking authorial hands in the Pauline Epistles. The contributions of an amanuensis are nearly impossible to discern given the paucity of evidence. There is sufficient material, however, to set out a test to discern Timothy’s participation as co-author. If Philippians and Philemon are taken together as representative of a Paul and Timothy stylome while Galatians and Romans are taken together as characteristic of a singly Pauline stylome, then we can evaluate 2 Corinthians using the Rolling Delta tool and discern whether there are shifts in the text that can clearly be assigned to Paul/Timothy vs. singly Paul. This paper describes the results of this test and its implications for authorship attribution in the Pauline Epistles.
|
Evagrius of Pontus on Exodus 30:34–37 and the Virtues of the Soul
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Devin L. White, Australian Catholic University
This paper examines Evagrius of Pontus’s interpretation of Exod 30:34-37 in On Prayer 1 and its relevance for his theory of virtue. Attention to Evagrius’s literal, allegorical, and text-critical reading practices yields an unexpected, functionally Peripatetic, theory of virtue. Correspondingly, the paper critically appraises previous scholarship on Evagrian virtue theory, particularly the claims that it was (1) Stoic and (2) learned from Gregory of Nazianzus. Evagrius’s argument highlights the problem of the relationship between individual virtues and unified virtue, ultimately depicting the virtues as parts of a natural whole from which the removal of any one part would diminish the whole without disfiguring the other parts.
|
Changing Patterns of Communal Dining in the Ostia Synagogue
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
L. Michael White, University of Texas at Austin
Recent work by the UT•OSMAP excavations on the Ostia Synagogue have significantly revised previous assumptions regarding the building history and chronology of this important Diaspora Synagogue. The main complex can now be securely dated but is no earlier than the early 3rd cent. CE; it was almost certainly not a Synagogue (or any kind of Jewish edifice) in its initial stages. Two subsequent stages of renovation — one in the mid 4th cent. CE and another at the very end of the 5th cent. — saw the complex first transformed into a Synagogue and then subsequently made over in the opulent “basilical” fashion of the day. Ceramic evidence suggests, moreover, that this building continued in active usage at least through the 6th cent., and thus represents the experience of a large and affluent Jewish community at a crucial moment of transition in the political and social environment of Rome at the end of Late Antiquity. It is this final edifice that is preserved in the excavated remains, including the addition of a monumental Torah Shrine (measuring 2.80 m in width and over 5.50 m in height) with polychrome marble decoration. Beyond the importance of the areas for worship and assembly, each of the final phases of the Synagogue complex contained specific and rather elaborate provisions for dining and other social and commercial activities. Interestingly, the renovation of the building in the final phase included transforming the earlier dining room into a bakery and the addition of a new dining area, with attendant cooking rooms, more than twice the size of the earlier one. Following an archaeological summary of the building’s history and chronology, this paper will focus on the spatial configuration of the dining areas in these two major phases of Jewish usage, with special attention to how the architectural changes reflect different patterns of access and usage within the life of the Synagogue community.
|
“Treasuring Up”: Mary as a Resilient System in Luke-Acts
Program Unit: Biblical Literature and the Hermeneutics of Trauma
Nathan H. White, Institute for Faith and Resilience
Mary, the mother of Jesus, stood as a pillar of the early church (Acts 1:14), and a living testament to nearly the entirety of Jesus’ tumultuous earthly life. She experienced the joy of her son’s birth as well as the despair of his death—a constant, though not always visible, witness in Luke-Acts. How could this woman endure the execution of her son and remain steadfast in its aftermath? The answer may lie in what could be termed her ‘resilience.’
Resilience holds great promise for understanding potential human responses to adversity. Already being used across a wide spectrum of disciplines, the construct has been helpfully applied as a hermeneutical framework in biblical studies (e.g. Carr, 2014; Schreiter 2016). Additional reflection is needed, however, for the construct to achieve maximum utility in this context. Drawing on extant resilience research (e.g. Masten, 2014), I suggest that a resilience hermeneutic based upon von Bertalanffy’s seminal ‘general systems theory’ (1968) can helpfully progress dialogue in two primary ways. First, such a hermeneutic views biblical texts themselves as resilient systems that have withstood varied pressures to form the canon. Thus, Luke-Acts could be understood canonically as a resilient system (or systems)—the product of various editorial and authorial forces, as has been argued regarding the canon as a whole (Carr, 2014). Furthermore, a ‘systems’ resilience hermeneutic allows biblical characters to be understood as complex systems who themselves seek to withstand trauma—that which significantly disrupts
the stability of a system and/or the ability of the system to recover from disruption—utilizing a variety of resources. Mary, particularly in Luke 2, concretely displays the promise of a ‘systems’ resilience hermeneutic for biblical studies.
Stylistically, the narratival force of portraying Mary in Luke 2 using several key phrases is instructive. Twice variations of the refrain “Mary treasured up all these things” (v.19,51) occur following the description of extraordinary events in Jesus’ childhood. The poignant warning of Simeon’s prophecy to Mary, “and a sword will pierce your own soul also” (v.35), notably occurs between, and seemingly offsets, the refrains. Viewed through systems theory, Mary herself may be understood as a sort of ‘system’—a human being—attempting to maintain equilibrium amidst the tempestuousness of life. This comes into focus in Luke 2, where, through the conscious act of “treasuring up,” Mary strengthens herself for the trauma that is to come by harnessing resources that support the system’s functioning (hope). Narratively, this inference is indicated to the reader by ‘bookending’ phrases denoting the building up of the system (“treasuring up”) around the incisive prophecy that intimates the disruptive climax of Jesus’ earthly life. In short, Luke 2 alludes to the coming traumatic narratival climax of Luke-Acts while displaying how one central figure in that narrative prepared to face the trauma. Subsequently, in Acts, Mary stands resilient, having “treasured up” resources to maintain health despite trauma. She and this text serve as examples of the promise of resilience as a hermeneutic strategy for interpreting and
appropriating biblical texts.
|
Humor in the Infancy Gospel of Thomas
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Michael Whitenton, Baylor University
Readers of the Paidika (Infancy Gospel of Thomas) have long puzzled over the jolting portrait of Jesus as an irascible divine child. Recent scholarship has primarily developed questions regarding whether Jesus should be viewed as an idealized child or a more true-to-life child? Yet attention to the plausible emotional impact of this enfant terriblé on ancient auditors has received far less attention. Recently, Reidar Aasgaard has argued that Paidika would evoke feelings of catharsis among children who felt helpless in day-to-day life. While I wish to resist Aasgaard's specificity, I am keenly interested in the emotions Paidika evokes among audience members. More specifically, I explore the rhetorical dimensions of the destructive behavior of Paidika's boy Jesus, with specially attention to its potential for humor. In his seminal volume, Greek Laughter: A Study of Cultural Psychology from Home to Early Christianity (Cambridge University Press [2008]), Stephen Halliwell argues that early Christianities largely disapproved of laughter, largely because of its associations with the surrounding pagan culture. Paidika is exceptional, Halliwell notes, in its portrayal of the boy Jesus as laughing. Still, Halliwell leaves unexplored (1) the potential for early Christian writing to evoke laughter from auditors and (2) the rhetorical functions of any baited laughter. Halliwell is not alone in this omission; audience laughter is typically ignored within studies of canonical and non-canonical early Christian writings. This trend makes sense, but how are we to assess the laughter of audiences long since gone?
In what follows, I propose the cognitive sciences as a viable means of ferreting out potential humor in ancient texts. My argument unfolds in four stages. First, I briefly anticipate objections to the use of contemporary cognitive sciences for understanding ancient texts. Second, I summarize ancient and modern explanations of humor, following especially the work of Cicero, Quintilian, Salvatore Attardo, and Victor Raskin. Despite their distance in time, their theories converge on humor as a result of some combination of feelings of incongruity, superiority, and relief. Third, in light of this "General Theory of Verbal Humor," I explore the most salient examples of potential humor from the Gs recension of the Paidika, all of which revolve around the boy Jesus's interactions with (and at the expense of) others. Finally, I turn my attention to plausible functions of humor in the Paidika. Briefly stated, I argue that Paidika was likely meant to be funny and that audience laughter provided a number of prosocial benefits, including group cohesion, feelings of catharsis, and superiority over against outsiders. In the end, the resistance to humor in the Paidika, I suggest, reflects the anti-humor presuppositions of its interpreters more than the lack of humor in the stories themselves.
|
Subversive (E)masculation: A Medical Perspective on Paul’s Baldness in Acts of Thecla
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Michael Whitenton, Baylor University
This paper problematizes unequivocally positive readings of Paul's appearance in Acts of Thecla by exploring ancient medical explanations of baldness. Contemporary discussions of Paul's appearance in the Acts of the Thecla tend to revolve around different construals of physiognomic expectations, and Paul has fared quite well: He has been a general in God's army (Grant 1982), a hero fashioned after Augustus (Malherbe 1986; Hartsock 2008), even an "ideal male" (Malina & Neyrey 1996). However, these readings underappreciate the negative connotations often associated with baldness. While some men wore their baldness with pride, others, such as Julius Caesar, Seneca, and Domitian, were regularly embarrassed by-and mocked for-their baldness (Suetonius, The Deified Julius 45.2; Dom. 18; Seneca, On Firmness 16.4). Ancient medical perspectives on baldness provide an effective way for understanding the characterization of Paul in Acts of Thecla.
My argument develops in two primary steps. I survey medical explanations for baldness contemporary to Acts of Thecla, focusing primarily on Galen's Art of Medicine and Method of Medicine. Galen believed that baldness was often intertwined with sexual function. Hot and dry krasia in the testes (and thus sperm) led to increased fertility and a stronger desire for sex. In times of health, semen acted as a cooling and moistening agent in the head. However, as such a person has more and more sex, levels of semen are depleted leading to an excessively dry and hot head (compound dyskrasia). When the head overly dries and heats up-whether through excessive loss, misuse, or general lack-one's hair falls out. Baldness thus carried connotations of aberrant masculinity brought about by low levels of semen: such a man probably had either too much sex or not enough.
Second, I offer a medically sensitive reading of Paul's baldness in Acts of Thecla. Paul's baldness indicates an excessive depletion of semen or naturally low levels of it, thus suggesting behavior that deviated from gender ideals, such as licentiousness, madness, and/or impiety (Pliny the Elder, Natural History 6.94.231; Aelian, Historical Miscellany 11.4-5). In other words, Paul's appearance supports the accusations that he was leading many men, women, and virgins astray (Acts of Thecla 11). More specifically, his baldness disrupts dominant narratives of Roman masculinity by suggesting a lack of self-control and immoderation in sex. Ancient sympathetic audiences, however, would likely conclude that Paul's baldness resulted not from excessive emptying of semen, but naturally low levels of it. In the words of Acts of Thecla 6, sometimes (to the townspeople) Paul appears to be a (licentious) man, while at other times he appears (as chaste) as an angel.
|
The Invention of Atheism and the Invention of Religion
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Tim Whitmarsh, University of Cambridge
Like religion itself, atheism takes many forms in many cultures; it may therefore seem incautious to speak of ’the invention’ of either at one particular time and in one particular place. Nevertheless, given the pivotal importance of late fifth-century Athens in post-enlightenment accounts of the development of atheism, we may be justified in asking whether there were particular historical factors that explain the emergence in that era of the atheoi (who can be justly identified as the first at least to be specifically named ‘atheists’). This paper argues that atheism emerges first as a broadly legal category, as a result of the so-called Diopeithes Decree of ca. 432 BCE (for the historicity of which there is little reason for scepticism); in other words, that it was the mechanisms of the Athenian state that cleared the space for atheism (much as, on one reading, it was the legal devising of the Clinton White House that cleared the space for Al Qaida). In fact, I argue, Diopeithes also gave Athens for the first time a coherent category of ‘religion’ (with due allowances for the problems of that modern term), which had been hitherto very weakly conceptualised.
|
Show Me the Funny: Using Humorous Pictures to Teach Biblical Studies
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
James R. Wicker, Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary
Humor is an effective teaching tool. Research shows it has a number of benefits in education. This 10- minute presentation will use a PowerPoint slide show to demonstrate how humorous pictures can help one teach the Bible in four areas: (1) interesting introductions, (2) memorable word associations, (3) teaching an important hermeneutical principle about words, and (4) inspiring creativity in biblical studies and teaching. To prove one can employ humorous pictures in teaching any part of the Bible, this presentation will focus on Judges 3-5, which includes two gruesome assassinations in a spiritually dark age for Israel.
|
Trans* Historiography and the Problem of Anachronism
Program Unit: LGBTI/Queer Hermeneutics
Rebecca Wiegel, University of Notre Dame
This methodological paper explores the question of how (if at all) one can do trans* historiography when studying pre-modern societies. It will open with a brief descriptive survey of trans* theory with respect to historiography, and then it will present a concise argument for a set of criteria by which the historian can identify trans* persons in the past. In particular, this paper will join with Prosser's (and Elliot's) critique of scholarship that over-identifies trans* as queer — as critique or as disruption — as an object of identity politics. Instead, the paper argues, we ought to view trans* persons as subjects: subjects of received cultural narratives, subjects of their particular embodiment, and subjects with agency who must creatively dialogue with these given conditions. The body provides a necessary limit and point of dialogue for telling our individual stories, but the stories and means of telling them derive from our received culture — from our body’s located-ness in space and in time. These intelligible roles, though, vary from culture to culture and, accordingly, we must expect that what a trans* person looks like in each culture will likewise differ; we cannot expect to find trans* persons in the historical record in any way that is straightforwardly imitative of our modern categories. Ultimately, this paper will therefore argue that a trans* person is someone who seeks or desires to transition from one category of sexed or gendered intelligibility (telling an intelligible story with their body) to another category of sexed or gendered intelligibility, or someone who seeks or desires to transition from intelligibility to unintelligibility because of the inadequacy of their culture’s categories for them. In its conclusion, this paper will apply the argued-for criteria to Matt 19:1–14’s opposition between men and non-men (women, eunuchs, and children) to ask if those who “have made themselves eunuchs for the kingdom of heaven” ought, on any level, to be considered as trans*.
|
The Oracles of Balaam in View of Ancient Near Eastern Oracular Reporting
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Benjamin Wiggershaus, Asbury Theological Seminary
The Oracles of Balaam in View of Ancient Near Eastern Oracular Reporting
|
Isaiah as Kingmaker: Reading Isaiah 45:1 in Light of Persian Temple Restoration in Conquered Lands
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
Christian Wilder, Grand Canyon University
In Ezra 1:1-4, the author records a decree from Cyrus that sends the Jews to their land with the purpose of restoring their temple. In the seemingly unconnected text of Isaiah 45:1, the author (referenced as Isaiah in this study for the sake of simplicity) declares Cyrus as his “anointed one.” However, study of Persian involvement in the rebuilding of temples in Ur (The Moon temple of Sin Nannar, according to a fragmentary cylinder), Babylon (Cyrus Cylinder), Akkad (Cyrus cylinder, lines 25-34), and two temples in Egypt identifies a pattern. The pattern begins with a Persian political need in the geographic area of the temple. Second, a method to legitimize the Persian king must exist in the cultic community. Third, A quid pro quo and status quo ante agreement exist. Fourth, there existed a mixture of central authority and local autonomy. Fifth, often, an intermediary between king and temple exists who is connected to the Persian empire and perhaps, even acts a kingmaker (Udjahorresnet in Egypt, for example). Applying this pattern to the historical return of the Golah, the paper concludes that Isaiah’s identification of Cyrus as Messiah becomes the conclusion to the quid pro quo whereby a Persian king allowed for restoration of a local temple and in return, the local official provided him with the highest office available in the temple community. The writer of Isaiah 45:1 is now a political strategist and kingmaker; he recognizes Cyrus as the official king of Yehud and by doing so, guarantees the ongoing rebuilding program of the temple.
|
Mountains, Myth, and Authority: Examining Whether Jewish Authors Created or Borrowed Authority through the Omphalos Myth in Apocalyptic Material
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Christian Wilder, Grand Canyon University
This paper examines how Second Temple apocalyptic authors used the omphalos myth—the idea that a mountain is the navel of the earth connected to heaven as though with an umbilical cord—as authority for their messages. It begins by reviewing how authors combined what Edward Soja called the Firstspace (the mountain, in this study) and Secondspace (the Omphalic myth) into a Thirdspace (a new understanding combining the first two spaces) from which they gained authority for their writing in 1 En. 26:1-2 and Jub. 8:19-20; but was this authority created or borrowed? The main body of the paper answers this question by identifying several occurrences of mountains tied to the omphalos myth. These occurrences are examined using a comparative analysis that explores points of verbal contact concerning authority. Such verbal contacts include the use of similar words, cognates, or synonyms; a similar word picture in both passages; or similar contexts in which the omphalos myth appears. Analysis begins with Judg 9:37 and Ezek 38:12 (scholars such as Samuel Terrien, Walther Zimmerli, Daniel Block, and others inform this part of the study). Following that is an examination of the omphalos myth in Ugaritic, Hittite, Egyptian, and Hellenistic literature. This study concludes that apocalyptic authors created authority for their writings by uniquely using the omphalos myth. They created a Thirdspace in which the navel of the earth (Mount Zion or Sinai) became spatial representations of God’s authority. The authors then wrote pseudepigraphically as righteous men (Enoch and Noah) who entered this authoritative space to receive the message intended for the reader. As such, the pseudepigraphic author’s message carries the authority from the mountain space where it was received.
|
Reading Jesus as YHWH in the Old Testament: From Mark’s Gospel to Justin Martyr
Program Unit: Development of Early Christian Theology
David E. Wilhite, Baylor University
Whereas most Christian readers of the Bible today (both devotional and academic) assume that the primary persona found in the Old Testament is God the Father, a significant strand of early Christian thinking differed drastically from this assumption. Instead, many early Christians assumed that the person encountered in the Old Testament God, YHWH, was the person of the Son, or the Logos – i.e., the pre-incarnate Jesus. Without making reductionistic or anachronistic claims about the New Testament authors (who should be read with full awareness of their diverse views), we contend that this practice of reading the Old Testament God as the pre-incarnate Jesus was in fact a practice shared by some New Testament authors. In short, early Christians confessed “Jesus is Lord” in the sense that he was the same “Lord (Kurios)” found in the Septuagint. Our case studies will be a comparison of Mark, Ep.Barn., and Justin Martyr’s Dial., and some points of contact will also be addressed, such as Paul’s (occasional) and John’s (frequent) YHWH-Christology. Furthermore, these cases will be contrasted with New Testament sources that do not employ this exegetical approach, such as Matthew given its arguably low Christology and Hebrews even with its remarkably high Christology. Our reading relies on work done in Second Temple Judaism by Daniel Boyarin and others, which will be briefly summarized. Our argument also follows certain claims of the so-called “Early High Christology Club” (Hengel, Bauckham, Hurtado, Hayes, etc.), but we will note significant differences and criticisms of this group’s approach. Namely, instead of interpretations in which Jesus is identified “with” YHWH, we contend that some of the earliest Christian sources describe Jesus as YHWH. Other recent studies supplement the early high Christology approach with prosopological exegesis in order to read Jesus was seen as “fully” divine in New Testament sources (e.g., Bates) and thereby strictly avoid the so-called subordinationist mistakes of later centuries. We, however, find that YHWH-Christology of early texts like Mark and Justin could have in fact led to a subordinating of the immanent YHWH to the transcendent Father. In sum, one exegetical approach found in many, but not all, early Christian texts entailed reading Israel’s scriptures with the assumption that Jesus is the LORD acting therein, and this approach then resulted in various later Christological trajectories.
|
A Canonical Taming of Suffering: On the Effect of Paratextual Activity in the Book of Psalms
Program Unit: Prayer in Antiquity
David Willgren, Academy for Leadership and Theology
It is often claimed that the adding of biographical superscriptions to psalms opened them up for new uses, so that David became a blueprint of piety for others to follow (so esp. Childs). However, the function of paratexts is rather the opposite: to limit interpretive options and propose specific ways in which a text ought to be read (Genette). Proceeding from such an observation, the current paper will inquire into the effect paratextual activities such as the collection of psalms into canonical collection and the providing of Davidic, biographical superscriptions have had on the way the complaint psalms in particular have been interpreted. By comparing the way complaint psalms from the first “book” in the “Book” of psalms are presented in the manuscripts from the Dead Sea with how they are paratextually framed in early Septuagint manuscripts and the East Syriac tradition, new light will be shed on the way varying canonical context effect the understanding of the suffering portrayed in these psalms, and, as a consequence, also the way these prayers are meant to be used.
|
Why the Masoretic Sequence of Psalms Should Not Be at the Center of Scholarly Reconstructions of the Formation of the "Book" of Psalms
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
David Willgren, Academy for Leadership and Theology
Reconstructions of the formation of biblical literature in general and the ‘Book’ of Psalms in particular have regularly been teleological—and quite understandably so. The history of transmission has been traced backwards from a certain point in time, and the material has been arranged to meet the needs of the questions asked. But in this process, much of the nature of the material culture and manuscript evidence itself has been side-stepped. In the search for Ursammlungen, scholars have often established a text that all material is structured by, and invested in it an unwarranted hegemony. In providing a fixed starting point, interpretive strategies and implicit values are transferred back to a time when they are not necessarily appropriate, while other, ongoing interpretive activities are missed. As an example, the term “Davidic Psalter,” if not properly defined, runs the risk of creating an illusion, enabling scholars to imagine proto-Psalters or proto-collections to be similar to what is found in modern, printed versions of Codex Leningradensis. The aim of the current paper is to show why such an approach creates more problems than it solves, and by looking at the earliest manuscripts of the ‘Book’ of Psalms I will argue that the Masoretic sequences should not be at the center of scholarly reconstructions. More specifically, I will look at the way Ps 104 is laid out, and explore how a reassessment of the manuscript evidence enables fresh conclusions to be drawn as to issues of textual stability, authority, and canonicity.
|
Barrenness, Conception, and Bearing Sons: Manoah's Wife and the Health of Pregnant Women
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Jennifer J. Williams, Linfield College
Using Judges 13 as the primary focus, this paper will explore the barren woman type scene and will consider the Hebrew terms for barren, conceive and bear.
In many cases, barrenness in the biblical text does not reflect an issue innate to a woman, but is related to divine power and points to a mysterious quality of pregnancy. Thus, this paper will consider Turner and Van Gennep’s use of liminality, liminal states and rites of passages, as many cultures recognize pregnancy and other stages in the female reproductive system as liminal periods. The transitional time of pregnancy often marks a woman as dangerous or impure because she is in a physiologically and socially abnormal condition. While this categorization of liminality frequently leads to the examination of how female bodies become regulated in this socially “dangerous” state, pregnancy viewed as a liminal stage in the human experience might also help pinpoint how ancient people understood and cared for the health of women.
Using the story of Manoah’s wife, I will explore how “barrenness” might primarily point to a problem with bearing a child (carrying a child full term) and not with conceiving a child (being able to get pregnant). English translations often fail to reflect the nuances of the Hebrew, especially related to these terms for conceiving and bearing. For example, is Manoah’s wife already pregnant at the moment the messenger comes to her, or will she conceive in the near future? Also, ambiguity exists in the reason for why she must refrain from drinking wine. Does the prohibition against drinking wine relate primarily to her ability to conceive or to her ability to have a successful pregnancy and bear a healthy child? And could these prohibitions reflect ancient fertility practices and precautions for having a successful birth? Or, do the prohibitions have little to do with the mother’s health, but instead primarily relate to the Nazirite son? Furthermore, the messenger indicates that the razor should not touch the head of the child because of his Nazarite status. Why, then, does the woman omit the razor phrase entirely and make the food and wine prohibition the indication of the child’s Nazirite status? The paper will also explore 1 Samuel 1 and Hannah’s barren woman type scene as it similarly incorporates a restriction of razors and reference to wine.
Because Judges 13 raises questions about the specific quality of “barrenness” and what a woman might need to do in order to have a successful pregnancy, this discussion shifts our understanding of fertility issues in the biblical text. Miscarriage, false pregnancy, pre-mature births and other issues related to the gestation period (rather than conception) become the focus. How might we begin to understand the biblical corpus and the ancient world anew? And if these type scenes suggest a whole range of infertility issues, including miscarriage and the inability to carry a child to full term, how might that impact contemporary interpretations, especially in light of contemporary interests in fertility, infertility, miscarriage, etc.?
|
The Mother’s Womb: An Unhomely Collision of Politics and the Home
Program Unit: Joshua-Judges
Jennifer J. Williams, Linfield College
Focusing on the characterization of the gendered pair in Judges 13, this paper deploys contemporary reading strategies from feminist, anthropological and postcolonial thought. Although Manoah is the named character in the scene, he is not as integral to the scene as his wife. He receives less information than she does and is not given an initial invitation from the divine messenger. The barren woman is only known by way of the men in her life, either as Samson’s mother or Manoah’s wife, and she follows other biblical mothers who receive an announcement that they will miraculously bear a son.
The paper will explore how this liminal woman omits, adds to and changes the divine message when she relays the announcement to her husband. The implications of these changes will also be considered. For example, the messenger indicates that the razor should not touch the head of the child because of his Nazirite status. So, why does the woman omit the razor phrase entirely and make the food and wine prohibition the indication of the child’s Nazirite status? The paper will also examine other barren woman type scenes, focusing especially on Hannah’s narrative in 1 Samuel 1 as it similarly incorporates a restriction of razors and wine.
The narrator of Judges 13 utilizes the unique elements of this type scene to reemphasize a theme that runs throughout the Judges narratives: the complicated portrayal of women and the way in which women operate in domestic and extra domestic functions. A concern with how women contribute to political endeavors and the realization of the ideal group identity becomes apparent. Judges 13 specifically points to the reality that women bear, raise, and educate military leaders.
The news from the messenger means that the woman is an essential but compelled participant of public life and politics invading her family and more accurately, her body. She also becomes an accomplice in military efforts as she bears the deliverer of her people. This element resonates with Rebekah’s experience in Genesis 25:23. In both stories, these once barren women find out that not only do politics enter the home and family, but also that which is political invades a woman’s actual womb. The women’s bodies hold the political leaders of entire peoples.
By the end of the Samson narrative, it is clear that in the ways that the woman’s testimony differs from the messenger’s dispatch, her report to Manoah is judicious and even more accurate than the messenger’s original message. Thus, the woman’s digressions from the messenger’s announcement are not insignificant. This pregnant woman seems to possess an understanding that exceeds not only her husband’s but also the expectations of the divine messenger and the reader.
|
Utopian Priests and Foreign Levites: Ezek 44 as "Counterstory" to a Broken Priesthood
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
Lindy Williams, University of Manchester
Explorations of the priesthood often seek to solve the dilemma of Ezekiel 44 and the hierarchy detailed there. In the future temple of Ezekiel's vision the "sons of Zadok" hold the highest priestly office while it appears the Levites are punished for their interaction with foreigners. These verses encourage scholars to pursue a historical referent for both the "sons of Zadok" and the source of Levitical transgression, neither of which are entirely clear.
The methodology of this paper allows a different look at these "sons of Zadok." Accepting that Ezekiel plays with narratives allows the "sons of Zadok" to be rhetorical rather than historical. This use of rhetoric opens up the possibility that the restorative vision of chapters 40-48 functions as a "cournterstory" to the historical reality of the temple and its personnel prior to the exile. This rhetorical reality would explain why a search into the history of the priesthood yields few satisfactory theories.
In support of MacDonald's conclusions in Priestly Rule, this paper seeks to find support for his direction of influence (Ezek 44 drawing upon Num 18 and Isa 56) in Ezekiel's use of narrative. Relating the Levites to the foreigners allows Ezek 44 to highlight the problems with the historical priesthood in Ezekiel's day. Then relating the foreign Levites to the rhetorical "sons of Zadok" is the beginning of a future hope for a less corruptible priesthood. Utilizing the stabilizing function of hierarchy consistent with a Num portrayal of the cult, and combining that hierarchy with the hope for the foreigner found in Isa 56, Ezekiel offers a "counterstory" consistent with his overall rhetorical scheme. As is normal for the author(s) of the book, this recasting of the priesthood in Ezek 44 focuses on the complicity of Ezekiel's audience and the enduring faithfulness and character of YHWH.
|
Making the Sign of the Cross: To Do and to Undo
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Ritva H. Williams, St. Stephen's Lutheran Church
This paper will draw on the Catherine Bell's theory of ritualization to illuminate the early Christian practice of making the sign of the cross. What did this ritual action do for those who engaged in it? What did this ritual action undo in the world around them? Answers to these questions will be emerge from an examination of excerpts from the writings of Tertullian, Cyrian, Origen and Lactantius read in light of the ritual contexts in which early Christians lived and interacted with others.
|
Delivering the Oracles of God: The Nature of Christian Communication in 1 Peter 4:11
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Travis B. Williams, Tusculum College
Commentary Series: International Critical Commentary.
In 1 Peter 4:11, commentators are presented with a number of interpretive difficulties. Not least of these is the nature of spoken communication within the gathering of Christian communities. Those who speak are instructed to carry out their task "like (one speaking) the oracles of God" (ὡς λόγια θεοῦ). This, of course, raises an important question: when Christians rendered service to the community through various forms of verbal communication, was there a real correspondence between the words of the speaker and divine oracles, so that members were actually dispensing the words of God, or was this comparison made on a hypothetical level so that speakers were encouraged to approach their communicative duties as if they were delivering a message which derived from the mouth of God? Of course, one cannot ignore the fact that these instructions are part of a direct comparison. By way of simile (ὡς), the Petrine author explains how he expects the task of speaking in the congregation to be carried out. But contrary to what some have assumed, this literary diagnosis alone is not sufficient to answer the question of whether the author envisions all congregational speakers as divine mouthpieces, for the basis of this comparison is left unstated. The author may have drawn on this image because it vividly illustrated the proper approach toward speaking within a local congregation. On the other hand, it is possible that the reason why speakers are urged to understand their communicative duties in this way is because the author believed there to be a direct correspondence between the speaker's words and the oracles of God. Both interpretations represent plausible bases from which to draw the current comparison. In this paper, we will seek to bring resolution to the question by considering what was involved in the process of communicating divine oracles, and by exploring how the Petrine author understood the transmission of divine revelation through human agents.
|
Sharing God's Gift in Christ: Paul and His Philippian Co-workers
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Wendell Willis, Abilene Christian University
This paper will explore Paul's letter to the Philippians in conversation with
J.M.G. Barclay's anthropological insights on gift giving and reciprocity in the Greco-Roman world.
|
Judith 9: A Prayer and More Than a Prayer
Program Unit: Prayer in Antiquity
Lawrence Wills, Brown University
It has been noted that the prayers and speeches in Judith give voice to themes of the book. In particular, her prayer in chap. 9 brings many motifs and themes of the book into play. It is even argued, with good reason, that 9:9c-10 is the theological center of the text. Yet it is not clear that the prayer is an earnest statement of the author’s theology so much as speech-in-character, or even the ironic engagement of a transgressive trickster. Indeed, there could be some truth to both perspectives. In opera, the libretto, or words sung, often present a one-dimensional statement of events or emotions, while the emotional tone of the music and the actions of the characters may ironically operate at levels counter to the libretto. An irony of interpretative levels is achieved. Here Judith’s prayer will be analyzed as the interplay between her words (libretto) and her actions (music).
|
The Aroma of Prayer: Smell, Space, and Sacrificial Praxis in Luke-Acts
Program Unit: Senses, Cultures, and Biblical Worlds
Brittany E. Wilson, Duke University
As one of the so-called lesser senses in Western understandings of the sensorium, smell has typically not received much attention in recent scholarship on sensory experience in biblical texts. This is especially the case in New Testament scholarship because, except for Paul’s statement that Christians are the “aroma” of Christ (2 Cor 2:14-16) and passing references to odor (both fragrant and foul) in the Gospel of John (John 11:39; 12:3), smell does not figure prominently in the New Testament. When we turn to the two-volume work known as Luke-Acts, however, we find that the narrator (or “Luke”) uses scent imagery—specifically incense imagery—to describe prayer on two key occasions. First, Luke begins his Gospel with a threefold emphasis on the priest Zechariah’s incense offering in the Jerusalem temple (Luke 1:9-11)—an offering that arguably functions as a prayer on behalf of the Jewish people gathered outside the temple. Second, Luke begins his account in the book of Acts of the first Gentile convert Cornelius by mentioning that Cornelius’s prayers have “ascended as a memorial to God” (Acts 10:4), recalling the heavenward wafting scent of burning incense and animal offerings, especially the “memorial portions” of the Jewish sacrificial system. Luke’s portrayal of prayer as incense is not unique, for the description of prayer in these terms became a prominent trend in early Christianity starting in the late second century, as Susan Ashbrook Harvey details in her landmark book _Scenting Salvation_. Like these later Christians, I will argue, Luke very likely describes prayer in this manner because he is wrestling with how to understand Christian practices (such as prayer) within the context of olfactory sacrificial practices in the wider Greco-Roman world. On the one hand, Luke criticizes both Jewish and Greco-Roman sacrificial practices more broadly. Luke is at times critical of the Jerusalem temple and its sacrificial system (Luke 19:45-46; Acts 7:48-49), and he is also critical of the Greco-Roman system, as when he prohibits gentiles from sacrificial meat offered to idols (Acts 15:20, 29; 21:25) and when Paul and Barnabas reject the Lystrans’ attempts to offer them sacrifice (Acts 14:13-15). But on the other hand, Luke incorporates the language of incense offering, not only as a way to suggest that Christians do not perform “actual” sacrifices, but to relocate practices that once occurred within the temple to practices that now occur within the context of gathered Christians. Given that Luke-Acts was written in the wake of the temple’s destruction, we find that, in this instance, the destruction of space elicits new ways of “scenting” practices that now occur in different, though less easily defined, spaces.
|
Gezer in the Iron IIA: Solomonic and Ninth Century Remains
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Charissa Wilson, Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary
The recent completion of fieldwork for the Tandy Institute of Archaeology's excavations at Tel Gezer marks the end of the third major project to work at the site. Field E of the Tandy's excavations ended the final season with a wide exposure of architecture belonging to Stratum 8, the Solomonic phase of the city, located adjacent to the site's well-known six-chambered gate. The first part of this paper will present an overview of this phase, informed by the findings of previous excavations, but focusing primarily on the newly revealed data. The Tandy project has uncovered in its entirety the large administrative building partially excavated previously by the Hebrew Union College excavations and labeled "Palace 10,000" by that project. This structure is significantly larger than previously known, and can now be recognized as a bit hilani-type structure, although that descriptor has been reevaluated recently. The administrative structure was connected to the city gate by a large stone-paved plaza that extended to approximately twenty meters west of the gate entrance. These newly revealed features combine with the city gate, casemate wall, and other previously known Stratum 8 features to provide a more thorough understanding of the character of Solomonic Gezer.
The second part of the paper will report on the Gezer Stratum 7 city plan with a focus on a complete domestic structure. Stratum 7 is tentatively dated to the 9th century and has a destruction contemporary with other nearby destructions (e.g. Tel Gath) which has also been associated with Hazael. The Tandy excavations have defined 5 units built directly on top of the 10th century administrative building of Stratum 8 which is west of the Iron Age gate complex. Included in this paper will be a discussion of the change in city plan between Stratum 8 and Stratum 7, a proposal of the origin of the Stratum 7 complete domestic structure, an overview of the distribution of the finds in relation to the domestic structure, and a brief summary of the 9th century ceramics by Sam Wolff.
|
An Elite Iron Age IIB Four-Room House at Gezer
Program Unit: Archaeology of the Biblical World
Charles Wilson, University of Chicago
This presentation shares an overview of the architecture and associated finds of an elite Iron Age IIB four-room house from Tel Gezer, Israel, including updates from the 2017 season. Many of the ground-floor artifacts were discovered in situ, the result of Tiglath-Pileser’s destruction of Gezer in 734/733 BCE. From the distribution of artifacts within the house, several activity areas are identified, mostly domestic in nature: storage space, a kitchen, weaving areas, and a stable. While the house shares many characteristics of typical four-room houses, there are also several characteristics that set it apart: it is a large intra muros house (124 m2 ground floor plan in its final phase); it is aloof from the other known four-room houses at Gezer, avoiding shared walls; it is near to public buildings; and it is east facing. Some of the finds from the house are also elite in nature, including two bullae, a cosmetic palette, an incense burner, and several imported jars. Viewed together, the architecture and artifacts reflect an elite household, probably that of a multigenerational family.
|
Remembering the Future: Prophetic Literature’s Representations of Exile and Judah’s Social Memory
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
Ian D. Wilson, University of Alberta - Augustana Campus
The multivocality of many ancient Judean texts, on the one hand, speaks to their long compositional history—there is no doubt that, say, the book of Isaiah came together over an extended period and reflects different authorial voices and their times. On the other hand, the fact that various voices were preserved in individual texts, and that these voices were collated with certain and sometimes diverse narrative aims, also says something about the mindset of those that received the texts in antiquity (cf. David Jobling’s thoughts on 1 Samuel). Focusing on this latter aspect of Judean literature’s multivocality, my paper will examine concepts of exile in prophetic literature, with the goal of illuminating ancient Judean processes of social remembering as they would relate to Judah’s literary culture. The prophetic book, as a genre, appears to have been something like a literary archive, an organized collection of speeches and visions associated with a particular personage from the past, that served to remember the future. In other words, prophetic books provided means to access past imaginings of possible futures. As such, this literature would play a key role in Judean readers’ negotiation of dissonance in their remembering of exile (and exoduses from lands of exile). By complicating the imagining of exile and its outcomes in a community’s past, the reading of prophetic texts would enable ongoing debate about the significance of such concepts for the community going forward.
|
I Threw It on the Ground! An Analysis of the Noncultic Blood Rite in Deut 12:16, 24, and 15:23
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Jim Wilson, Asbury Theological Seminary
I Threw It on the Ground! An Analysis of the Non-Cultic Blood Rite in Deut 12:16, 24, and 15:23
|
“Whenever You Desire” Does Not Mean What You Think It Means: Limitations on the Scope and Timing of Noncultic Meat Consumption in Deuteronomy 12
Program Unit: Book of Deuteronomy
Jim Wilson, Asbury Theological Seminary
The phrases “whenever you desire” and “whatever you desire” in Deuteronomy 12:15 and 20 have often been interpreted as open-ended concessions which permitted Israelites to slaughter any clean animals for meat consumption (whatever animals they desired) and on their own whims at any time of year (whenever they desired). However, consideration of zooarchaeological data suggests that non-cultic animal slaughter was actually more restricted in scope (types of animals slaughtered) and in timing (when the animals were slaughtered). The present paper will utilize this information to present a more realistic understanding of non-cultic slaughter in Deuteronomy, with additional attention given to how non-cultic slaughter practice compared to cultic slaughter in scope and timing, and to the deliberately hopeful, albeit unrealistic use of ‘avah (desire) in Deuteronomy.
|
Reading the Proverbs 31 Woman from a Postcolonial Perspective
Program Unit: Postcolonial Studies and Biblical Studies
Lindsay Wilson, Ridley College, Melbourne
Feminist scholars have expressed mixed feelings over the woman portrayed in Prov 31:10-31. Some have pointed to her initiative in a wide range of activities, despite the strongly patriarchal setting in which she lives. On this reading she can be a vital model for women in the contemporary world. Yet other feminist readers have objected to the heavy weight of expectation loaded on this woman, while the one who gets the social credit is her husband (vv.12, 23). On this reading she appears to be a tool used by powerful men to impose even greater burdens on women for their own patriarchal benefit.
Could not a similar ambivalence be seen in analyzing this portrayal from a postcolonial vantage point? Many women in the majority world long for opportunities and possibilities often denied them by their former colonial rulers as well as (often) their own patriarchal societies. The role exercised by this woman could provide a paradigm for majority world women to explore bold new pathways. However, when other majority world scholars (male and female) analyze this text, they notice that she is in a position of privilege and power—a setting denied to most women in the majority world. At best she would be a model of replacing one tyranny by another.
This paper will propose that a more useful postcolonial reading involves peeling away both the patriarchal patterns of past colonial rulers as well as the more recent ‘colonial’ values of Western individualism and materialism. A closer reading of the text will take more seriously its role within the book of Proverbs, and understanding it in the social context of a community-based, honor/shame culture. It is argued that such a reading will result in understanding the Proverbs 31 woman able to be applied in the majority world in a way that is different from the patriarchalism of previous centuries or the rampant, Western-centered individualism of our current century.
|
Reconsidering Theological Readings of Proverbs
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Lindsay Wilson, Ridley College, Melbourne
While the theological interpretation of scripture is a relatively new scholarly track, there have been a number of theological commentaries on the book of Proverbs. This paper evaluates the varying approaches taken by Daniel Treier (Brazos Theological Commentary on the Bible, 2011), Amy Plantinga Pauw (Belief Theological Commentary on the Bible, 2015) and Ernest Lucas (Two Horizons OT Commentary). It is argued that theological interpretation should not be restricted to the writings of systematic theologians, but that it is most fruitful when it allows the structure and thought categories of the text to determine the theological ideas drawn out. Thus, biblical theologians are a crucial part of the Theological Interpretation of Scripture movement, as reflected in A Manifesto for Theological Interpretation (eds. Craig Bartholomew & Heath Thomas, 2016). In relation to Proverbs, the theological undergirding of the book is provided by chapters 1-9, which affects the way the entire book should be read. In addition, the theological kernel (identified by Norman Whybray) in the concentration of Yahweh sayings in chapters 15-16—at the seam of the two halves (chapters 10-15 & 16-22) of the major Solomonic collection—should be seen as giving a theological flavouring to the sentence sayings in the second part of the book. It is argued that this approach does more justice to the ecology of the text than does Treier’s analysis of the sentence literature using the categories of the classical virtues.
|
Odegology and the Will of God: Is the Book of Acts "Normative" for Divine Guidance?
Program Unit:
Mark Wilson, Asia Minor Research Center
This paper uses the neologism “odegology” to encompass theological discussion concerning divine guidance, a significant issue for spiritual formation in the modern church. Jesus’ promise of power and his commission to be witnesses in Acts 1:8 sets the theme for the book. Acts is replete with examples of guidance for completing that mission, particularly in the ministries of Peter, Philip, and Paul. Can Paul’s experiences with guidance, whether natural or supernatural, be normative for Christians today? Paul’s missionary journeys in Acts will serve as a heuristic model for decision making. The paper will present several case studies from Paul’s ministry travels as it discusses odegology and discipleship today, particularly in Pentecostal and charismatic circles.
|
Displacement as a Cradle of Creative Creole Liminality: Exporting Identity to the Diaspora through Bible Translation
Program Unit: Islands, Islanders, and Scriptures
Marlon Winedt, United Bible Societies
The role of Scripture among the Papiamentu speaking diaspora and their descendants in the Netherlands functions is a case study for how a community of islanders have dealt with displacement. Nestled in front of the South American continent, in the southern part of the Caribbean basin, the ABC islands of the so-called Dutch Caribbean, have a moving history, between having been colonized first by the Spanish (1499) and subsequently conquered by the Dutch (1634). Thus, the relationship with the Dutch has a more than 300 year history which on the island of Curacao resulted in the voluntary selective migration of Sephardic Jews looking for asylum in the first part of the 17th century, after the Portuguese conquered Dutch-Brazil. Subsequently around 1665 the more massive forced African slave migration started with the island of Curaçao functioning as a key slavetransition harbor.
After the WWII a mass migration to “mama Ulanda” (mother Holland, from the now autonomous Netherlands Antilles gradually resulted in a diaspora community of about 150.000 at present. Even the second generation still focuses on its Caribbean roots in terms of music, culinary expression, celebration of typical cultural feasts and Scripture consumption. This use of Scripture in the Creole through music, multimedia messages and Bible translation has only increased in the past 10 years.
There is a tension between forging a separate identity within the Dutch multicultural reality and the island mentality of the Caribbean. A tension which among a minority has resulted in family breakdown, gang and ghetto-formation while another segment is losing its identity due to total assimilation to the European culture. However a more substantial part are protagonists in a positive re-creolization in the new reality. The latter re-invention of the Creole identity in its liminality between the North Sea and the Caribbean basin, partially frames the continual use and re-discovery of the language and culture through Bible translation in the tongue of the islands. The same can be said about the role of Bible translation in Jamaican Creole, Creole Haitian other Creole languages in diaspora. In this context, the slavery of the People of God in Sacred Hebrew History (Exodus 3) and the liminal reality they constructed as a community in exile in Babylon (Jeremiah 29) are all paradigmatic texts for the diaspora church which in part harkens back to the Caribbean realities. To a greater degree the identity expands its liminal existence, between different worlds, resulting in one dynamic evolving Creole identity where resilience, survival, an Anansi- the-spider-astuteness combined with faith in God is celebrated.
Thus, Scripture performance through drama, singing, preaching and teaching, and communal reading, in the land of migration and now (re-)birth, becomes an expression of cultural identity through religious identity, beyond victimhood, where a community aspires to attain a Glissant-like “tous le-monde” reality where creolization is not seen as bastardization or miscegenation, but as part of the new mixed people of God, consisting of that great multitude from every tongue, tribe and nation before God (Rev 7:9).
|
Abraham, the Iconoclast, in the Gospel of Barnabas: New Insights into a “Jewish-Christian-Muslim Hotchpotch”
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
Franz Winter, Universität Graz
The so-called “Gospel of Barnabas” (henceforth: GB) is an ideal object for any case study into transcultural dynamics of religions and the close entanglement of Jewish, Christian, and Muslim traditions. Since its first academic edition in 1907 the text has been the object of a highly controversial perception with Christians and Muslims arguing over its authenticity. The GB presents itself as a „Gospel harmony“ with the „true“ version of the story of Jesus by rewriting and amending the Biblical material and introducing Jesus as presaging the coming of a future (and final) prophet, namely Mohammed.
There are many unsolved issues with this strange text, that is only preserved in a rather odd looking Italian manuscript with Arabic sidenotes and a major fragment of a (later) Spanish version. The most popular current academic answer to the riddle posed by the GB is given by some (mainly) Spanish scholars who point to an origin of the text in the context of the so-called moriscos, i.e. forcefully converted Ex-Muslims on the Iberian insula after the defeat of al-Andalus.
This is highly probable, but by no means definite as any deeper look into the text soon suggests. As my paper wants to show, a detailed historical analysis of selected passages of the GB gives new insight regarding the questions of its origin and transmission. This focus is extremely important, as little detailed textual research has been done on the GB with the exception of a few studies so far. My paper is concerned with one specific episode in the GB (in chapters 26–27) which deals with the story of the prophet Abraham who already at a very young age became convinced of the reality of monotheism, and consequently began to fight against his polytheistic father who is making a living by producing idols in a workshop.
This story as preserved in the GB makes up part of Jewish traditions and plays an important role in Islam where the Quran and the later so-called Qiṣaṣ al-anbiyāʾ („Stories of the Prophets“)-genre provide a plethora of material on exactly this episode with many variations. My in-depth study of this specific passage in the GB will focus on the interdependence with Jewish and Islamic traditions, that give the impression of being used here in a very concrete and sophisticated way. An important reference point will be the material by the Andalusian scholar Ibn Muṭarrif aṭ-Ṭarafī (997–1062), who wrote a major Qiṣaṣ al-anbiyā’-collection that shows many similarities but also differences with the GB-version. In addition, I want to show which function particularly this story in the GB might have, as it is located in a rather crucial part of the text where major variations between the Italian and the Spanish version are evident. This leads to further questions (and hopefully solutions) regarding the origin of this most fascinating text.
|
Hebrew Bible-Driven Immersion in Bible OL
Program Unit: Global Education and Research Technology
Nicolai Winther-Nielsen, Global Learning Initiative
Biblical Hebrew Immersion can be practiced in many ways. It usually means that students without knowledge of Ivrith learn to read and speak conversational Ivrith for use in Biblical Hebrew. For Ivrith speaking students immersion may mean to unlearn some conversational habits in order to dive into the language system of the Hebrew Bible. But in practice, for me personally and for many other students, immersion has meant to learn basic Biblical Hebrew outside Israel and attain mastery of Biblical Hebrew through Ulpan and academic studies in Israel.
In this paper I will argue that Bible Online Leaner (https://bibleol.3bmoodle.dk/) can effectively help most students to practice immersion driven by the Hebrew text. This technology uses a corpus of the Hebrew Bible (the ETCBC database) for task-based language learning, serving as a persuasive tutor, trainer and tracker of inquiry and practice. It can optimize the early stages of the learning processes and gradually take learners deeper into the text and prepare for conversation in class and communication in Israel.
The paper will share results from the development of My Biblical Hebrew (http://mbh.bibleol.3bmoodle.dk/). Informed by 10 years of research and development, in the Fall of 2018 15 students will participate in a flipped classroom designed for peer-based blended and online learning in Copenhagen, Tanzania, Cambodia and elsewhere. After some 500 hours of learning some of these students will go to Israel to practice cultural immersion, reading and interpretation in a live setting in January 2019.
The new approach will test an integration of Bible OL with Paradigms Master Pro https://paradigmsmasterpro.com/. The basics of Biblical Hebrew is learned through thousands of small discrete tasks for practice, created by the text for interactive training and supported by paradigm practice. Bible OL gives instant feedback on accuracy and speed and plots their progress. Facilitators can compare their performance with other learners and gently guide and encourage learners into more effective learning.
This presentation will also discuss the use of Moodle, video, auto-correct exercises, and the attempt to stimulate a living-language style classroom through chapter 1 of the Book of Jonah. Examples will cover data on effective reading, vocabulary acquisition and learning of the Hebrew verb. The development of this new course will be informed by the cultural immersion approach of Paul Overland. Reading will be enhanced by the use of a proficiency corpus using vocabulary occurring 50 times in the Hebrew Bible.
|
Act in Accordance with All (Josh 1:8)
Program Unit: Bible and Ethics
Nicolai Winther-Nielsen, Global Bible Initiative
The Divine encouragement by God in the opening speech of the Book of Joshua explicitly refers to following the Law, and it demands careful obedience to the written standard. On closer inspection it even recapitulates the speech of Moses in Deuteronomy 31 to Joshua. This is a canonical invitation to test written ethical intertextuality in a very specific case. What does it mean to act according to all that is written: verbatim, or different, and how can we tell? What is the model for the reception of Deuteronomy in Joshua?
This paper will test prior work to establish a three-level functional reception of the Law. In the Pentateuch, it is possible to analyze the internal reception in terms of a foundational level with creation, sin and redemption, to which the cultic holiness is a fundamental reception and it defines the nature of God. Above this we find a personal level with an ethical application of what it means for the individual to live by what is written, and this level focuses on responsible care and concern in an ethical expression of holiness. The uppermost level is the broadest and most general application to society and justice and human existence on the national level.
This paper will trace the prototypical cases of the latter two levels through the book of Joshua in order to define how exactly the personal and national ethics is applied in Joshua from Deuteronomy. It will be argued that concrete cases can help us understand the implication of “act in accordance to all.”
|
Describing the Structure of Greek: What Inflectional Paradigms Tell Us About Syntax
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Ryder A. Wishart, McMaster Divinity College
Hellenistic Greek syntax constitutes a challenging and stimulating domain, in terms of both theoretical modeling and practical analysis. A major source of this challenge can be traced to the many obvious differences between Greek and the major world languages for which syntactic models are usually developed. However, I will show that it is not merely the surface idiosyncrasies of Greek that pose a challenge for syntactic modeling, but even more fundamentally the abstract categories of the language. These abstract categories structure all areas of the Greek language, including lexis and morphology, syntax, and semantics. I will argue that a model of Greek syntax must be paradigmatic in orientation. By paradigmatic, I am referring first of all to the notion of contrasting linguistic choices as modeled in systems, which is the defining characteristic of Systemic Functional Grammar. However, I am also referring to an equally abstract but more specific kind of paradigm, namely the inflectional paradigm. Greek is a synthetic language, which means that it expresses morphosyntactic categories through patterns of change on the level of the word (i.e. through the addition of affixes of various sorts, and also through stem changes). I will argue that the systemic theory I chiefly rely on here, Cardiff Grammar, does not have the theoretical machinery either to analyze inflectional variation or to accord inflectional paradigms and the morphosyntactic properties they realize their proper significance in regard to syntax-Fawcett's claims to the contrary notwithstanding. Nevertheless, the Cardiff Grammar model provides a promising platform from which language-specific alterations can be made, ultimately facilitating a fully systemic and probabilistic model of Greek syntax.
My argument will proceed in the following stages: First, I will introduce the Cardiff Grammar framework, noting what I perceive to be its key contributions or shortcomings for analysis of Greek. I will specifically explore the challenges posed by a richly morphological language like Greek. Secondly, I will introduce Gregory Stump's paradigm-linkage hypothesis and give several minor examples of its application to Greek. Thirdly, I will make the case that Stump's hypothesis clarifies the Cardiff Grammar's notion of realization statements, and that furthermore this clarity is instrumental in the task of syntactic theorizing for synthetic languages like Greek. Finally, I will suggest some of the implications of this argument for the specification of syntactic categories in Greek. I will ultimately seek to demonstrate that Greek's semantic and syntactic paradigms are, like its inflectional paradigms, shaped in critical ways by morphosyntactic property sets.
|
The Epistemologies of 4QInstruction and the Wisdom of Solomon
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Benjamin Wold, Trinity College - Dublin
Within wisdom literature a number of different epistemologies may be observed (e.g., wisdom may be found by reason, experience, it may be identified with Torah, and it may be revealed). The Wisdom of Solomon expresses a negative view of humanity's intelligence, stating that "the reasoning of mortals is worthless" (9:14) and that no one learns wisdom unless God gives it by his holy spirit "from on high" (9:17). 4QInstruction's epistemology includes the raz nihyeh, which is seen by some interpreters as given only to the elect. If this is the case, then it stands in contrast to other wisdom tradition where the created order is apparent to everyone. The deterministic nature of 4QInstruction and the raz nihyeh, I argue, is misguided. Instead, it relates to the created order, is universal, and operates within a merit based system. This change of perspective opens up new ways of assessing how 4QInstruction relates to other early Jewish wisdom traditions. In this paper I assess continuities and discontinuities in the epistemologies of 4QInstruction and the Wisdom of Solomon.
|
African Onomastics and Famine Names in Ruth
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Lisa M. Wolfe, Oklahoma City University
The Book of Ruth opens with meaning-laden character names, the dire setting of a famine, and—within five verses—widowhood three times over. Like many interpreters, my social location overshadowed my initial reading of Ruth chapter 1, such that the names “Mahlon,” or “disease” and “Chilion,” or “disaster” (v. 2) seemed fitting only to the literary context of the story. In other words, I took the name meanings to be literary foreshadowing for the inevitable demise of these characters in 1:5 by comparing them to the European fairy tales with which I am familiar. Thus, of course a man named “Disease” died, just like “Cinderella” cleaned cinders out of the fireplace, and “Prince Charming” saved the day. A memoir by William Kamkwamba (with Bryan Mealer, HarperPerennial, 2009) entitled "The Boy Who Harnessed the Wind" opened my eyes to a new way of understanding Mahlon and Chilion’s names. In this book, Kamkwamba details the horrific famine he and his family survived in Malawi in 2001. Amid his description, he explains how in his culture infants born during famines were often given names that articulated their likely fate. From “Phelantuni, Kill Me Quick" to "Mdzimange," which means 'Suicide'" (Kamkwamba and Mealer, 101), these famine names have much in common with those of Elimelech and Naomi’s sons in Ruth 1:2. The field of onomastics, or the study of names and naming practices has helpful research to lend to Kamkwamba’s story. Studies of famine names in such places as Bunyoro (Western Uganda), and among Amharic speakers in Ethiopia provide notable cross-cultural and cross-historical insight for readers of the book of Ruth. While “Mahlon” and “Chilion” still may serve a literary function in the book of Ruth, through the lens of African famine naming practices, these names additionally lend a sense of seriousness to the setting of famine, one that would be lost on many European and American readers of Ruth. In this paper, I will present my research on onomastics in African famine situations, and describe how these naming practices provide bridges across cultural and historical gaps, offering new ways of understanding the Book of Ruth.
|
The Book That Changed: Narratives of Ezran Authorship as Late Antique Biblical Criticism
Program Unit:
Rebecca Wollenberg, University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
This essay in critical historiography proposes that the divide between modern biblical criticism and ancient Jewish and Christian perceptions of the biblical text may not always have been as great as we have imagined. In support of this position, this essay analyzes a selection of late antique Jewish and Christian materials that describe the text of the Hebrew Bible as an imperfect document ravaged by history, cut off from the divine, and reworked (perhaps even composed anew) by human hands. This brief exploration of the topic focuses particularly on early Jewish and Christian critical traditions that revolve around Ezra the Scribe. This focus was selected on the grounds that several premodern traditions about Ezra in Muslim and Greco-Roman works have already been recognized as a form of premodern critical consciousness that foreshadowed modern biblical criticism. This essay is conceived as a contribution to biblical studies not only as a reflection on the field’s methodological presuppositions but also on the grounds that the portrait that we paint of the earliest reception history of the biblical text cannot help but influence our scholarly interpretation of scriptural literatures themselves. In addition to a broad topical focus on the role assigned to the Hebrew Bible in the late antique imaginaire, this essay examines more detailed exegesis of Hebrew Bible books such as Ezra and Daniel.
|
Synchrony vs. Diachrony: Reader- vs. Author-Centered; Shall the Twain Ever Meet?
Program Unit: Intertextuality and the Hebrew Bible
Gregory T.K. Wong, Evangel Seminary (Hong Kong)
Of the many approaches to exploring textual relationships, an author-focused, diachronic approach such as inner-biblical allusion poses some of the greatest challenges in execution. These include proving that links between texts are author/redactor-intended and, especially regarding the Hebrew Bible/Old Testament, establishing plausible direction of dependence. These challenges notwithstanding, such an approach has tremendous potential of offering significant insight into a variety of issues of historical interest, such as an author/redactor’s perspective on the events being recounted, how sources are used, and the process through which the text arrives at its final form. Using as an example what I will argue are author/redactor-established links between the narrative of the sacrifice of Jephthah’s daughter in Judg 11 and the narrative of finding wives for the Benjaminites in Judg 21, I will explore some of the historical issues such an approach has the potential of addressing and clarifying.
|
The Umbrella Movement and the Bible
Program Unit: Minoritized Criticism and Biblical Interpretation
Sonia Wong, Chinese University of Hong Kong
The Umbrella Movement and the Bible
|
Prayers in the Greek Daniel
Program Unit: Deuterocanonical and Cognate Literature
R. Glenn Wooden, Acadia Divinity College
This contribution focuses on the Prayers in the Greek texts of Daniel.
|
2 Cor 13:1 and the Early Jewish-Christian Applications of the Law of Witnesses
Program Unit: Second Corinthians: Pauline Theology in the Making
J. David Woodington, University of Notre Dame
In 2 Cor 13:1, Paul directly cites Deut 19:15: “Let every charge be established by the testimony of two or three witnesses.” Typically, the three witnesses are understood to metaphorically represent Paul’s three visits to Corinth, but detractors maintain that Paul could not have utilized this law in a way that differs so dramatically from its original function in Deuteronomy. This paper defends the figurative understanding of 2 Cor 13:1 by comparing what we find in Paul with other examples of Deut 19:15 being employed by Jewish and Christian authors. 2 Corinthians 13:1 shares many similarities with other applications of the law of witnesses in early Jewish-Christian literature, including some often-overlooked correspondences in the New Testament itself. An analysis of these texts demonstrates that Paul’s use of Deut 19:15 is not nearly as idiosyncratic as has often been argued, even by those who favor the metaphorical interpretation.
The first section of the paper examines the relevant passages from early Judaism and the New Testament. Three main groups of texts prove especially significant, all of which depart radically from the intentions of the original Deuteronomic law. First, several rabbinic works cite Deut 19:15 as part of a process for forewarning someone suspected of wrongdoing about the possibility of being punished for their misdeeds. Second, regulations found at Qumran and in Matt 18:16 connect the law of witnesses with the reproof of sinful members in the community. The former group offers some semblance of protection to the accused by making it more difficult to prosecute them for a crime, whereas the latter is far more hostile and has witnesses serve in a process that assertively calls out immorality before the entire community. Lastly, the law of witnesses is referenced on several other occasions in the New Testament (John 8:17–18; 1 Tim 5:19; Heb 10:28–29; 1 John 5:7–8).
The second portion of the paper uses these parallels to interpret 2 Cor 13:1. As it turns out, they strongly mirror what Paul does in this verse. He warns the Corinthians to correct their sinful behaviors before his arrival, lest he be forced to discipline them. Having pointed out their sins and forewarned them of their consequences twice before, his subsequent visit will act as the third and final witness against their wrongdoing and grant him the legal authority to administer punishment against them. Technically speaking, Paul employs the law of witnesses in a new way, but no aspect of his application of this well-known principle is without precedent. Texts outside of the writings of Paul can be found validating testimony of a single witness on three occasions (cf. CD 9:16–22), calling oneself as a witness (cf. John 8:17–18), and even taking a metaphorical approach to the identity of the witnesses (cf. 1 John 5:7–8). What at first glance appears to be an entirely novel application of Deut 19:15 turns out to be only one of many comparable examples of this law being adapted by later authors.
|
Travels with Texts: Mapping Exegesis in Early Medieval Europe
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
Clare Woods, Duke University
Carolingian scholars expended a great deal of energy and ink on explicating the Bible, perhaps more so than on any other literary or theological endeavor. Like the Fathers before them, they composed biblical commentaries at the request of students, fellow religious, lay men and women. Networks of intellectual friendship emerge from the dedicatory letters that frequently accompany these commentaries, but beyond these initial exchanges, patterns of circulation are difficult to discern. We know, for example that Hrabanus, abbot of Fulda, composed a commentary on Genesis for Freculf, bishop of Lisieux. Many manuscripts survive of this commentary, including early fragments from Fulda, but none can be connected with Lisieux, nor does any trace remain of the copy Freculf made. Although surviving correspondence constructs a relationship, manuscript evidence for the commentary itself tells a different story.
Hrabanus was not alone in commenting on Genesis. In fact, of all biblical books, Genesis, Matthew, and the Pauline Epistles attracted the most exegetical attention from Carolingian scholars. Surviving manuscript witnesses, many dating to the ninth century, attest a similar pattern of interest. For those studying early medieval networks, this is a rich seam to mine, and yet, despite the wealth of physical evidence, scholars rarely introduce manuscripts into their analyses or discussions.
Early medieval manuscripts present challenges, of course: critical information about them is usually rather "fuzzy". Precisely dated/datable manuscripts are very rare, dates typically being offered within parameters: e.g. "first quarter of the ninth century", or "second half of the tenth". While paleographers have made huge advances in "placing" Carolingian manuscripts, for too many we have nothing more granular than a suggested script region, e.g. "N.E. France" or "Bavaria". Despite these challenges, I argue that we must find ways to mobilize as much of our manuscript data as possible if we are to explore transmission patterns in a holistic way. Fortunately, newer digital tools such as NodeGoat -- a data management, analysis, and visualization tool -- allow us to use "fuzzy", pre-modern data in more sensitive ways.
By mapping with timelines all surviving ninth-century manuscripts of Carolingian commentaries on Genesis, Matthew, and the Epistles, and layering this data with other known networks, especially road and river systems, this paper demonstrates ways in which we can more fully understand the distribution patterns of Carolingian exegetical texts. Tracing the transmission from author to dedicatee is only a tiny part of the pattern. When a copy of Hrabanus's commentary on Genesis crossed the vast expanse of Frankish Europe from Fulda on the eastern border to Lisieux near its western shore, the journey would have taken over a month. As the courier - a Fulda monk? -stopped en route, perhaps showing the book to hosts and friends, what impact did that have on the further dissemination of Hrabanus's text? Ultimately, textual communities cannot be understood properly unless we also appreciate and explore their materiality - unless, in other words, we follow in the footsteps of the courier-monk and his burden of books.
|
Mapping a Discourse of Difference: Reading JZ Smith through Derrida
Program Unit: Redescribing Christian Origins
Bruce Worthington, Wycliffe College
Christian Origins scholarship can be configured in two trajectories—an older one which owes its heritage to Hegel (see Baur, Strauss, Harnack), and the other which can be traced to the monumental work of Jonathan Z Smith. There is currently no way to reproduce the work of Hegel on Christian Origins without repeating the Protestant theological assumption of Christian superiority: its moment is gone. The movement generated from Smith is a gesture beyond the language of Christian metaphysics that is consistent with post-structuralist configurations of “difference.” While the Smith trajectory claims a neutral comparative anthropology to the study of religion, closer observation reveals its affiliation with deconstruction, and the philosophical project of Derrida. For those engaged in method and theory in the study of religion, an assumption has been made that precludes a singular point of origin in the development of early Christianity, echoing the sentiment of Derrida, namely, that “every concept is necessarily and essentially inscribed in a chain or a system”, and thus “there is no single moment, single cause, single concept, or single unique figure that accounts for the explosion of speculative tale-telling about Jesus.” (See Arnal and McCutcheon). For Derrida, difference should not be configured in terms of neutrality—difference is active and “plays a role in language”, they are “effects” themselves, and may determine a system of taxonomy or classification in a manner that is often political (see Derrida, Differance). Most of Smith’s work, especially in Drudgery Divine, is exactly this: to chart the effects of difference in Christian Origins, and chronicle how difference has determined our current taxonomies in the study of Early Christianity. In this paper, I suggest it is impossible to understand Smith on the topic of difference without situating him within a broader discourse of “difference” in contemporary structuralism and post-structuralism of the late 20th century. Strengthening the connection between Derrida and Smith challenges the assumption that comparative approaches to the study of religion lack philosophical rigor, and adds greater methodological clarity to the configuration of difference in the study of early Christianity.
|
The Early Israelite Settlement through the Lens of Joshua
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Lissa Wray Beal, Providence Theological Seminary
The Early Israelite Settlement through the Lens of Joshua
|
Combating Beliar in Esoteric Traditions of Late Antique Judaism
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Archie Wright, Regent University
The primary figure of evil in early Jewish apocalyptic literature is not the Satan figure, but Beliar/Belial (secondarily Mastema – particularly in Jubilees). Beliar appears to be the leading representation of evil in late antique Judaism and features significantly in the Dead Sea Scrolls and the Pseudepigrapha, in particular the Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs, as an instigator and a leader of a group of evil spirits under his authority whose task was to afflict humanity and draw them away from sanctioned religious views or practices. This paper examines how Beliar, as representative of the primary figure of evil in these apocalyptic texts, is understood as attempting to influence individuals in late antique Judaism and, despite pressures, how persons endeavored to protect themselves. With regard to esoteric traditions, these texts revealed to the select strategies to combat perceived evil otherworldly beings. Many of these traditions suggest that certain individuals possessed or could obtain specific/secret knowledge through carefully worded prayers or specific methods of protection that could be used to combat evil, while assisting efforts to maintain a righteous life.
|
Leadership and Authority in the Qumran Sapiential Texts and Ben Sira
Program Unit: Qumran
Benjamin Wright, Lehigh University
Sapiential literature often takes the form of a teacher addressing a student in which the teacher might adopt a variety of rhetorical strategies to construct an authoritative relationship with the student. So, for example, a teacher might adopt the role of the students' father and thereby claim the same level of obedience as that due to a parent. In another important strategy the teacher becomes an ideal to be emulated. In this paper I will examine some of the strategies that teachers in the Qumran wisdom texts and in the Wisdom of Ben Sira employ to set themselves up as authorities and leaders in an effort to ensure that their students not only listen to them but eventually accept and internalize their teaching.
|
Scribal-Cultural Continuity from the Covenant Code to Deuteronomy
Program Unit: Book of Deuteronomy
David Wright, Brandeis University
My contribution argues that Deuteronomy continued the Covenant Code's scribal model and technique of hermeneutical transformation to create a number of its laws. In particular D imitated CC’s technique of recasting Mesopotamian texts related to law and administration as divine law. D also maintained and developed themes that were influential in CC or in its accompanying narrative, including the sacrificial cult, festivals, ethical obligations to the poor, homicide asylum, the judiciary, and even covenant (e.g., Gen 15; Exod 24:3–8). The relationship of D to CC demonstrates that CC and its narrative may be characterized as proto-Deuteronomic (or D as “post-CC”). Relative dating places CC and its narrative before D, with D only a generation or two later. Absolute dating is most likely within the Neo-Assyrian period, in the 7th century BCE.
|
Fictionalization in Ancient Biographies: Implications for Gospel Studies
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Edward T. Wright, Asbury Theological Seminary
Fictionalization in Ancient Biographies: Implications for Gospel Studies
|
Doctors of the Soul: Therapeutic Expertise in Late Antiquity
Program Unit: Religious World of Late Antiquity
Jessica Wright, University of Southern California
Doctors of the Soul: Therapeutic Expertise in Late Antiquity
|
“Out with the Christians, . . . Out with the Epicureans!” Atheism and Constructing the Other in Antiquity
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Richard A. Wright, Abilene Christian University
In his recent book on atheism in antiquity, Tim Whitmarsh observes, “The history of atheism cannot be just that of those who profess not to believe in gods; it must also account for those social forces . . . that construct it as the other, the inverse of true belief” (Battling the Gods: Atheism in the Ancient World, 116). Although one can point to individuals in antiquity who did not believe that the gods existed, far more frequently the term “atheist” was pulled from a portfolio of labels that intellectuals (frequently philosophers) could use against those whose ideas or behavior seemed dangerous or threatening.
Writing in the second century CE, Lucian (from whom the quotation in the title of the proposal derives) could place Christians and Epicureans in the category of atheists (Lucian, Alex. 38). This move invites an exploration of the degree to which these two groups might help us understand the ancient use of this category. By the time that Lucian writes, Epicurus and his followers had long been labeled as atheists. For example, both Cicero and Plutarch (but also others) attacked Epicurean theology as atheistic. This, in spite of the fact that Epicurus explicitly argued that the gods exist. One gains insight into at least one reason why such might be the case in Plutarch’s Adversus Colotem. In this treatise, Plutarch argues, among other things, that proper thinking about the gods establishes the foundations of society; Epicurean theology destroys these foundations (see especially, 1125E-F). For Plutarch, the atheism of the Epicureans threatens the very stability of civilization.
Christians in the second century faced a broader spectrum of labels used against them. While it is true that the earliest polytheistic writers to explicitly call attention Christians label them as “superstitious” (Pliny [Ep. 10.96.8], Tacitus [Ann. 15.44.3], and Suetonius [Nero16.2] all use this term), by the second half of the second century, the apologists (Justin [1 Apol. 24] and Athenagoras [Leg. 13.1], to name two), were defending themselves against the charge of atheism. One discerns a concern similar to that seen with the Epicureans at work in the labeling of Christians as both “superstitious” and “atheists.” This concern can be seen most clearly in Celsus’ critique of the Christians: they risk the gods’ anger by not paying them proper respect (Cels. 8.55); they and their god put the empire at risk by not fighting in its defense (Cels. 89.69, 73). From Celsus’ perspective, the Christians threaten the order and safety of the empire.
This paper, by examining the literature in which Epicureans and Christians are labeled as atheists and the language they themselves use to defend themselves, shows that one of the primary purposes of the use of the term “atheist” by intellectuals during the Roman period was to mark as “other” groups whose ideas and practices were perceived as a threat to the social order.
|
Women Interpreting Women: Hildegard of Bingen, Birgitta of Sweden, and Teresa of Avila Interpreting Mary and Martha of Bethany
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Jennifer S. Wyant, Emory University
The story of Mary and Martha and their encounter with Jesus in Luke 10:38-42 became a particularly popular one during the Middle Ages and beyond. The two sisters were heavily featured in art, sermons, liturgy, biographies, and even limericks. Drawing upon patristic interpretations, medieval writers argued that the siblings represent the dual lives of contemplation and action, with Mary being the ideal monastic figure and Martha being the picture of a life of service. While much has been written about the function of this allegorical reading in monastic communities, little attention has been paid to the ways in which mystical women read and interpreted the story.
This presentation, therefore, seeks to examine three such women and their interpretations of Luke 10:38-42. How do they read this story differently than their male counterparts? By examining the writings of Hildegard of Bingen, Birgitta of Sweden and Teresa of Avila on Luke 10:38-42, I will show how these women in their own way both align with the standard narrative of action and contemplation, but also expand and adapt that narrative to make their own exegetical conclusions about the story. They draw upon familiar imagery and ideas about the two sisters in order make their own claims using Luke 10:38-42. This examination will show the ways in which these three women were creative and careful exegetes, despite claims that they were not biblical interpreters.
|
The Best of the Best(iary): LXX-Job's Use of Greek Zoology Texts
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
James Wykes, Marquette University
It is well-known that the LXX translator of the book of Job shows the influence of Greek literature on his translation. The terminology and turns of phrase are clear indications of his erudition and literary skill. Less well-known, however, are the ways in which he inserted material from certain Greek writers (such as Aristotle) in expanding or embellishing his descriptions of the animals. The moments that he chooses to expand show us his keen theological mind and allows us to begin to compile the texts he may have read.
|
Bible Odyssey as Textbook
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Jackie Wyse-Rhodes, Bluffton University
I teach at a small university with a religiously-diverse student body numbering approximately 850. Each student is required to take two Religion courses as a part of our General Education curriculum. The first of those two courses, REL100, is essentially a Bible survey class, though when teaching it, I do not aspire to “cover” the entire Bible. Rather, the course objective is focused on teaching the skills of interpretation: “Successful students will be able to produce interpretations of biblical texts informed by the texts’ literary and historical contexts and the students’ own social locations.” In order to foster this learning goal, I opt for short, in-class writing assignments rather than out-of-class essays, and I eschew traditional textbooks, instead using Bible Odyssey alongside an NRSV study Bible. In this essay, I will explore several advantages of using Bible Odyssey as an alternative to a traditional textbook. First, when students read a series of short articles from Bible Odyssey in preparation for an upcoming class session, they are exposed to differing (and sometimes competing) scholarly perspectives. Gone is the one overarching interpretive lens which governs most traditional textbooks. Second, Bible Odyssey is amenable to syllabi that prefer “deep dives” to “coverage.” When using Bible Odyssey, the professor is essentially given the freedom to construct her own textbook, congruent with her own course goals, without any pressure to "get through" a traditional textbook in the course of the semester. Third, as a free and accessible resource with scholarly integrity, Bible Odyssey functions pedagogically as a showcase for excellent digital scholarship. By interacting with articles, videos, and other resources on Bible Odyssey, students begin to learn how to sort internet gold from cyber dross. In this presentation, I will also highlight some articles, videos, and images from Bible Odyssey that have been well-received by my students. I will share a few other online resources I use for teaching, including Ancient History Encyclopedia and floodofnoah.com, and place their strengths and weaknesses in conversation with those of Bible Odyssey. Finally, I will reflect on how my use of Bible Odyssey has changed since I began using it as a teaching resource in 2015.
|
Imperialism in the Achaemenid Age: A Central Asian Perspective
Program Unit: Literature and History of the Persian Period
Wu Xin, Fudan University
The two-hundred years of Achaemenid domination in Central Asia did not seem to have left much in the way of material remains in the regions. This has led many archaeologists to conclude that the Achaemenids had little socio-economic impact on the life of local inhabitants.
This paper explores the manifestation of the Achaemenid Empire in Central Asia through the lens of cities and urbanization. Drawing on recent survey and excavation of the Achaemenid period sites in Central Asia, the paper argues that the domination of the Achaemenid Empire fundamentally changed the socio-political life of the region. Following a brief survey of the main urban settlements, the paper examines the location, internal organization, and spatial distribution of these sites and offers an explanation of their functions within the region and their significance within the Achaemenid imperial network.
|
Mood and Ideology in Galatians 1–2
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Xiaxia Xue, China Graduate School of Theology
*
|
The Nature of Biblical Paratext: How the Bible Means More Than Its Words
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
William Yarchin, Azusa Pacific University
I am writing a book describing non-textual dimensions of the Bible specifically in their cultural role of creating and conveying targeted engagements with the Bible as a material artifact. The working title is The Nature of Biblical Paratext: How the Bible Means More than Its Words.
The subject is the Bible as a paratextual phenomenon. I employ categories of book production introduced in the 1980’s by Gérard Genette and elements of philological theory introduced by book historians in the 1990’s. This research perspective, sometimes known “material philology,” holds promise for a more fully-orbed understanding of the use and impact of the Bible.
I describe how a range of paratexts have shaped the presentation of biblical texts toward affective and cognitive signals keyed to reception at particular social-religious nexuses within multiple cultural horizons. My account demonstrates how specific non-textual elements participate in the perception, creation, and transmission of textual meaning. Recognition of that wordless (but not silent!) influence can help us take greater accountability for our own roles as producers and readers of the Bible directing its impact and influence.
My book spans the entire 2,000-year history of the Bible. Of particular relevance to the Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible SBL program unit session are chapters:
• describing how the biblical paratext that came into prominence as translation has become the exclusive portal for access to the Bible in the West, with lasting linguistic effects normalizing hermeneutical assumptions about how the Bible means;
• describing biblical paratexts that came into prominence when printing technology—as an industrialized commercial publishing enterprise—drafted previously established biblical paratexts into the service of market development wedded to zeal for religious instruction, helping transform experience of the Bible across a range of very different social locations;
• describing the biblical paratexts that came into prominence when computer technology digitized Bible production, transferring the pre-modern interior locus of personal scriptural memory to externally-housed searchable databases in multiple languages available for virtually any purpose.
Here is the argument my book presents. The literary works that eventually became canonized as scripture were early on subjected to ongoing re-composition by textual moves (adjusting the words). But in the 21st century the discernment of meaning, preservation of meaning, and guidance toward meaning are now accomplished almost entirely via paratexts (adjusting presentation of the words). Whenever it is received and handed on, the Bible shares with all other literatures the same destiny: the voice of the text will be heard through its paratext. Indeed, it is the Bible’s paratexts that have always determined how it will speak, to whom it will speak, and what it will say. Biblical paratext is the influencing elephant in the room.
|
The Divine Name as an Apophaticism in Bibles Hebrew and Otherwise
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
William Yarchin, Azusa Pacific University
In this paper I employ categories of paratext introduced in the 1980’s by Gérard Genette and elements of material philological theory introduced by book historians in the 1990’s. I describe a range of non-verbal messages offered through a specific paratextual practice of divine name-substitution in ancient, medieval, and modern Bible publications. I conclude that this pre-modern qere perpetuum has found new life in modern Jewish and Christian Bible production.
Ancient Greek, Syriac, and Latin translations of the Old Testament avoided direct representation of the divine name. In this they anticipated the MT’s qere perpetuum of the scribally-crafted substitute for the divine name. As a result, the divine name is both present and absent: it is absent from Scripture's text but present through a substitute for the divine name conveyed in Scripture's paratext. So God is textually unnamed in the Hebrew Bible/Old Testament yet God is nonetheless named paratextually, albeit with a non-name. Thanks to the ubiquity of divine name-replacement, substitute became reality: the non-name for God—“the Lord”—became God's name.
In the 2000-year course of biblical reception, specific paratextual ways of representing God's name in the Bible were standardized. This had an effect on uses of the common noun “lord” as a proper noun in European languages both graphically and in speech. In my presentation I describe how carefully executed printing conventions in early modern Bibles reflected the efforts of scholars to express specific philological (Jacques Lefèvre d'Étaples), doctrinal (Martin Luther), and theological (William Tyndale) denotations by their addition of targeted paratextual adornments to the biblical text in translation. In the twentieth and twenty-first centuries, late modern Christian and Jewish Bible translations have continued this paratextual tradition but with an interesting twist. In some cases (most modern vernacular versions) the current form of the ancient qere perpetuum yields the opposite effect of the Masoretic device, because the substitute truly does replace the reality. Yet in in other cases (JPS) printing decisions are fully aligned with the original intent to preserve, through paratext, the divine name—albeit apophatically, evoking God’s name while leaving the name itself unspoken.
|
A Preliminary Report from the Critical Editions for Digital Analysis and Research (CEDAR) Project
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
Sarah Yardney, University of Chicago
This paper provides a preliminary report from the Critical Editions for Digital Analysis and Research project (CEDAR), which makes use of database technology to encode textual data in unprecedented ways. In contrast to a critical apparatus, which can include only a limited number of variants, CEDAR enables researchers to generate instant detailed comparisons of an unlimited number of full manuscripts. It further allows for powerful philologic and epigraphic searches within and across manuscripts. This functionality is made possible by a high-performance XML database originally designed to handle archaeological data, the Online Cultural and Historical Research Environment (OCHRE), located at the University of Chicago. Using our current research on the book of Genesis as a case study, this paper will describe CEDAR’s innovative data model, describe the improvements it offers over currently available computational tools, and demonstrate its extensive capabilities for text-critical research in the context of biblical studies.
|
Are the Gospels Multiple Traditions or Multiple Performances? Revisiting Albert Lord and the Synoptics with John Miles Foley
Program Unit: Performance Criticism of the Bible and Other Ancient Texts
Danny Yencich, University of Denver
In this paper I argue that the Synoptic Gospels represent three scribal performances of the one, shared Jesus tradition rather than three independent traditions. To do so I facilitate a conversation between Albert Lord and John Miles Foley on the relationships and traditionality of the Synoptic Gospels. Lord argued that the Synoptics represented three independent oral traditions (cf. Albert Lord, “The Gospels as Oral Traditional Literature,” pp. 33-91 in William O. Walker, Jr. [ed], The Relationships Among the Gospels: An Interdisciplinary Dialogue [1978]). Foley, Lord’s inheritor and refiner, might rather frame the Synoptics as three scribal performances of the one, circumambient Jesus tradition. Working with Foley’s theory presents a challenge, however, in that he never argued a thesis about the Gospels comparable to Lord’s. Culling from Immanent Art, The Singer of Tales in Performance, and multiple of Foley’s essays intersecting with Gospels studies and performance, I will argue that Foley’s theorization of the relationship between performance and tradition (“tradition is the enabling referent; performance is the enabling event”) offers a way forward, beyond Lord’s problematic proposal that the Gospels represented totally independent oral traditions. Leaving aside the question of oral performance and revisiting Lord’s assertion of independence, the paper frames the Synoptics as interdependent scribal performances drawing upon a shared pool of tradition. The paper will begin by (briefly) comparing the the theories of Lord and Foley on the question of the Gospels and their production. Next the paper will take up the baptism of Jesus (Matt 3:1-12; Mk 1:2-8; Lk 3:1-17), which Lord characterizes as competing traditions, and offer up a Foleyan reading of the story as three particular scribal instances/performances of the one, shared Jesus tradition tradition. The paper will conclude by problematizing the assumption in Gospels studies, inherited from B. H. Streeter, that the Gospel composers were necessarily competing with one another in the production of these Jesus stories. Joining a growing chorus (e.g., Rafael Rodriguez, J. Andrew Doole, James Barker), I suggest that the Synoptic Gospels might be better understood as complementary rather than competitive: as a scribally performed tradition -- that is, as repeated, particular, and at times divergent performances of the shared body of Jesus tradition.
|
The Gendering of Az: A Comparative Study of Sexuality, Gender, and Etiology in Manichaeism, Mazdaeanism, and Christianity
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Felege-Selam Yirga, Ohio State University
To date, no scholars have attempted to reconcile a glaring contradiction in the study of gender and sexuality in the Manichaean religion, which thrived from the third to fourteenth centuries, its practitioners ranging from Roman North Africans to the Hephthalites of Tokharistan. On the one hand, the faith’s social and ritual prescriptions have little if any interest in the gender of practitioners, and unlike many of its late antique competitors, offered no explicitly misogynistic texts. Yet its theological and cosmogonic discourse, as preserved in a range of fragmentary and widely dispersed texts, conflates femininity with sexuality, which was perceived as unambiguously harmful. The aim of the paper is to explain this apparent contradiction by answering the following question: What is the significance and purpose of the gendering of the goddess Az, who was originally an androgynous lower deity, assimilated by the highly syncretic Manichaeans from the Mazdean pantheon?
The paper demonstrates that the gendering of Az was meant to provoke reactions and ideological shifts from two distinct textual communities simultaneously, that of the Mazdaeans and that of the Jews and Christians of the Sasanian empire. In the former group it would encourage a rigidly encratic view of sexuality, by describing coition as the result of demonic action. Meanwhile, it would have raised heavily conflated notions of femininity, sexuality, and spiritual danger familiar to the latter.
This is done by using a three-stage comparative approach. The first stage is an overview of Manichaean sexuality and the role that Az plays in the cosmogonic narrative of the religion. Here I will demonstrate that rigid encratism characterized Manichaean attitudes towards sexuality, and Az’s role as its progenitor in Manichaean cosmology. The second stage examines the Sassanid Mazdaism from which Az was drawn, focusing on her role in the cosmogony, as well as the gentler attitudes towards sexuality in Mazdaean texts more broadly. The third stage will be an examination of the Judeo-Christian literary and mythological milieu into which the early Manichaean authors ejected Az, as well as its explicit conflation of moral danger, sexuality, and the feminine.
The paper concludes by using this analysis to better understand the relationship between text and practice in Manichaeism. The syncretism inherent in the religion allowed Manichaean missionaries not only to adopt gods and stories from the religious communities they encountered, but the discursive tools of these groups as well. This strongly suggests that the essential function of Manichaean texts was as intellectual support for an on-going soteriological project centered in ritual. Malleable theological texts justified and encouraged the enforcement of behavioral norms as part of a preparatory process for the correct execution of ritual.
|
Moving the Mountain of God: Redactional Activity and the Conflation of Sinai and Horeb
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Philip Yoo, University of Texas at Austin
In Ben Sira’s praise of Elijah, the prophet “heard rebuke at Sinai, and judgements of vengeance at Horeb” (48:7 NRSV). The account in 1 Kings never mentions “Sinai” and so it has been suggested that Ben Sira equated Sinai to Horeb, and as a single mountain. Ben Sira’s praise of Elijah reflects a reading of the Pentateuch, as Pentateuchal texts refer to the mountain of Israel’s deity as both Sinai (Num 10:33) and Horeb (Exod 3:1). Some critics contest the identification of Sinai and Horeb as two separate mountains, yet the multiple, and oftentimes contradictory, topographical depictions of this mountain remain. For instance, the Pentateuchal texts appear to locate Sinai and/or Horeb to a location in the southern Sinai Peninsula or somewhere in the Arabian Peninsula. The confusion increases when Pentateuchal texts contain incompatible claims of what exactly happened at this mountain. This paper proposes that the identification of Sinai and Horeb as “the mountain of God” preserves different, and at times irreconcilable, geographical understandings and historiographical interests of multiple hands. In the process of identifying the multiple portrayals of “the mountain of God,” this paper will also consider the extent by which a redactor intervenes as they collect their received materials and reshape them as the Pentateuch reaches its (near) final form. As Sinai and Horeb emerge as a single mountain, this redactional activity results in the loss of precision in the different understandings of “the mountain of God.”
|
Unfamiliar Horns in Old Greek Daniel 7 and 8
Program Unit: Book of Daniel
Ian Young, University of Sydney
The motif of “horns” plays a central role in both Daniel chapters 7 and 8, the word occurring ten times in Masoretic Text Dan 7 and nine times in Dan 8. For those readers most familiar with the Masoretic Text of these chapters, however, some of the readings in manuscripts of the Old Greek translation can be quite a surprise. Among the most interesting variants, in various manuscripts one finds: A ram with ten horns, rather than just two (Dan 8:3); a goat whose horn is not “prominent” (Dan 8:5, cf., 8:8); a strong horn, not a small one in Dan 8:9; and indeed, the absence of any small horn at all with its absence also from Dan 7:8. This paper will discuss what we know about the origin of these readings and their relationship to the more familiar readings of the Masoretic Text. It will also ask the important question of how readers of these variant manuscripts might have understood the text of Daniel that they knew. This attempt at “comparative commentary” will allow readers of both the Masoretic Text and the Old Greek to see more clearly the ways in which each text constructs its message.
|
“Let’s Take the Text on Its Own Terms”: New Testament Studies as a Safe Space for Protectionism
Program Unit: Redescribing Christian Origins
Stephen Young, Appalachian State University
In some corners of Religious Studies, protectionism refers to collapsing explanation into description such that legitimate analysis of a text is circumscribed by its own claims. In other words, a protectionist approach disallows any interrogation, redescription, or explanation that transgresses or fails to reinscribe a source’s own understandings; a source’s own partitioning of reality. Classic protectionism insist, for example, on ‘taking the informant seriously’ or ‘on its own terms’ such that if it claims uniqueness, then the scholar’s methods must reflect its incomparability. Few observers would quibble with the idea that overtly confessional or apologetic scholars of earliest Christianity are protectionist. Indeed, the ways they theorize their scholarship often mandate it (e.g., insisting that valid interpretations always uphold biblical truthfulness). But protectionism also characterizes the discourses of mainstream New Testament studies. This paper briefly analyzes several influential arenas of New Testament studies: (I) the common recourse to claims about religious experience or ‘the Christ event’ for historical explanation, (II) standard discussions of comparison between New Testament/Early Christian writings and Hellenistic philosophy, and (III) contestation over whether to situate New Testament sources within Greco-Roman ethnic rhetorics. I exploit these case studies to elucidate how protectionism structures the spaces of New Testament studies at the level of methodological common sense in the field. Across mainstream academic venues, scholars routinely construct their work around protectionist logic in ways that promote basic confusions in historical and social analysis. They furthermore often manifest little concern to defend such approaches; or when they do, they reproduce additional protectionist arguments. Protectionism is a plausible, or even preferred, form of analysis because it aligns with inherited conventions and key genealogies of New Testament studies. It informs the doxa of the field and thus masks its own consequences while at the same time rendering New Testament studies something of a safe space where protectionism can flourish.
|
The Katumuwa and Ördekburnu Steles: Some Reflections on Two Grabdenkmäler
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
K. Lawson Younger, Jr., Trinity International University
The recent discovery of the Katumuwa Stele and the new edition of the Ördekburnu Stele have invigorated the study of ancient Yādiya/Samʾal, in particular the study of its Grabdenkmäler. This paper will investigate some of the ways in which the two are mutually informing of one another. It will address some of the important interpretive difficulties in these monuments, especially as they bear on religion in that ancient polity.
|
Eucharist and Seder: What Should the Simple Scholar Say?
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Peter Zaas, Siena College
Proposal/Abstract
Eucharist and Seder. What Should the Simple Scholar Say?
This essay aims to examine the the origins of the Christian eucharist alongside those of the Pesach seder, with an aim to describing with greater precision how this comparison contributes (or detracts from) contemporary Jewish-Christian dialogue.
?חָכָם מָה הוּא אוֹמֵר The experienced scholar (it is rare to find the wise one ) knows that the connections between these two foundational liturgical moments are complex, and that getting to them bottom of them means maneuvering through a number of both exegetical and historical issues.
?רָשָׁע מָה הוּא אוֹמֵר The agenda-driven scholar (not really רָשָׁע, just motivated by a need to fit the text into a larger narrative) makes claims for the connections between eucharist and passover that match his or agenda, to make Christianity Judaism, say, or Judaism Christianity.
?תָּם מָה הוּא אוֹמֵר The scholar who is strictly concerned with the plain meaning of the words in the text, and the specific connections between parallel passages can draw conclusions about the formation of the text, but where does she go from there?
ושֶׁאֵינוֹ יוֹדֵעַ לִשְׁאוֹל For the scholar who has trouble formulating a specific approach to material which is as difficult as it is vital, the solution is to sit with other scholars of good will, to find the right questions: How is this liturgical moment different from all other liturgical moments? How is it the same?
|
Erasing the Distinction between “Biblical Redactions” and “Variant Literary Editions”
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Molly Zahn, University of Kansas
In recent years, ongoing analysis of early Jewish literature in light of the Qumran discoveries has increasingly made clear the points of continuity between, on the one hand, the composition and development of books of the Hebrew Bible prior to our earliest manuscript evidence and, on the other, the development and transmission of those books as attested in extant manuscripts and versions. Yet scholarly language describing textual development does not yet fully reflect these continuities. This paper will use examples from across the biblical and Qumran corpora to argue that redactional developments in biblical books, as reconstructed based on the literary evidence of the MT, cannot be distinguished as a group from the developments witnessed by extant manuscripts. In other words, there is no meaningful difference between “biblical redactions” and “variant literary editions,” except that the former label is typically used for textual strata detected by means of traditional literary (redaction) criticism, and the latter for strata attested in the manuscript record. The categories are ultimately distinguished only by the contingencies of manuscript preservation, and thus can impede an accurate understanding of the composition and development of the books of the Bible. I propose that we might more profitably focus on distinguishing various types or degrees of revision/textual development (e.g., major or minor expansion; rearrangement; revisions that coordinate parallel passages; “theological” updating; etc.), without regard for whether they are detected via redaction criticism or via comparison of manuscripts. This type of approach, as I will demonstrate, cuts across the artificial conceptual boundary represented by the MT, and thus helps us formulate models of textual development that more fully correspond to the realities of early Jewish scribal culture.
|
Women in Text Criticism: The Time is Ripe for Change
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Molly M. Zahn, University of Kansas - Lawrence
What is it that causes some subfields within biblical studies (including text criticism) to have larger gender disparities than others? Is there something about text criticism, the types of questions it has traditionally asked, or the scholarly discourses in which it has been most prominent that has discouraged women’s participation? Besides reflecting on my own experiences in the field, I will explore possible answers to these elusive questions. It seems to me that the current paradigm shift in our understanding of the scribal production and transmission of texts has provided new opportunities to ask different kinds of questions than text critics traditionally have asked. This paradigm shift, it is to be hoped, might facilitate the inclusion of a broader range of voices.
|
“May The King Not Forsake His Servants!” Cultic Personnel in Minor and Peripheral Mesopotamian Cities
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
Shana Zaia, University of Helsinki
Many studies have discussed the cultic personnel of 1st millennium Mesopotamia, particularly in the Assyrian and Babylonian Empires. The availability of temple archives, royal correspondence, and administrative or economic documents means that the status and lives of cultic personnel in major cities such as Assur or Babylon are quite well understood. The temples in these cities received significant royal patronage, controlled considerable wealth, and were even featured in imperial ideology. Much less visible are the cultic officiants in cities that were not the large religious or political centers in their respective empires, such as Arbela, Kilizi, or Nemed-Laguda, or in cities that were geographically peripheral. This paper will explore cultic life on the fringes of empire, illuminating what is known about officiants in these cities and how their lives differed from their counterparts in the larger or more central urban centers. In doing so, this paper seeks to make these data accessible to those scholars working on cultic personnel in the broader ancient Near East or in the Bible. Using priestly and official corpora from the Assyrian and Babylonian Empires, this study will touch on themes of power and privilege, disenfranchisement, marginality, and elite status to give voice to those at the edges of the imperial cultic network.
|
Philo’s Double Paraphrase of the Parting of the Red Sea in Mos. 1.175–79 and 2.250–55
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Richard A Zaleski, University of Chicago
In his Life of Moses, Philo of Alexandria retells the biblical events of Moses’ life. Although his retelling is sometimes said to have paraphrastic qualities, there has not been a thorough scholarly attempt to compare it with examples of Greco-Roman paraphrase. This paper sets out to analyze Philo’s retelling of the biblical text in Mos. in light of the cultural production of such texts. By analyzing paraphrase both in its theoretical setting in rhetorical handbooks (e.g., Aelius Theon’s Progymnasmata, Quintilian’s Institutiones, and Aphthonius’ Progymnasmata) and in actual literary works, we may arrive at a typology of its essential characteristics, typical compositional techniques, and its common effects. Significantly, such an investigation reveals that Mos. has much in common with ancient paraphrases. By analyzing Mos. in light of ancient paraphrase, not only do we understand the text in a new way, but we also reveal more about Philo’s place in the wider literary culture.
His reworking of the Exod 14 account of the parting of the Red Sea provides an excellent place to see Philo’s paraphrastic techniques at work. Exod 14 contains a narrative of the parting of the sea that has proved exegetically problematic for interpreters throughout the centuries. In particular, the plot sequence appears convoluted and several ambiguities present themselves to the reader. By surveying the reception history of the passage, three issues stand out prominently. First, the narrative purpose and function of Moses’ staff is unclear. Second, the sequence of events—particularly in how Moses’ staff and the wind work together—that leads to the splitting of the sea is confusing and somewhat illogical. Third, the manner in which the sea closes again could provide some potential problems.
Like other exegetes, Philo is confronted with these same issues. Unlike other exegetes, however, by employing the methods of paraphrase, Philo deals with them not in an explicit manner but in an implicit way through crafting a new narrative. He does this in three ways. First, in his retelling of the event, he crafts a new narrative that resolves potential ambiguities and problems in the exemplar. Second, he improves the narrative coherence by rearranging the plot sequence. This also creates a more logical, plausible account. Third, he provides a narrative that contributes to his literary aim.
Significantly, because he narrates the parting of the Red Sea twice in Mos., the episode provides a unique opportunity to see how Philo employs paraphrastic techniques. Both versions are contained in larger sections of the text that highlight certain features of Moses’ character. In his first telling, Philo aims to portray Moses as the ideal leader. In his second version, he aims to depict Moses as a prophet. As a result of these literary aims, as he resolves various issues in the biblical exemplar, he does so in such a way that he also contributes to his literary aims of depicting Moses as leader or prophet.
|
Practical Biblical Activities on Spiritual Formation
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Juan Marcelo Zanga Céspedes, Universidad Peruana Unión
Every model of spiritual formation, from a biblical point of view, must take the Christian practical life into account. The model based on Romans 8:1, 4 and development by Paul is his letter to the Ephesians considers Christian orthopraxis described in Ephesians 6:11 to 18 and points out in it some practical activities in order to live in the Spirit.
Considering that the Scriptures indicate various practical activities for spiritual formation and that among these are the practice of studying the word of God (Jn 5:39, Acts 17:11), prayer (Mt 14:23; ; Luke 6:12; 9:28; 1 Thess 5:17), meditation (Ps 104: 34; Ps 119: 97) and fasting (2 Sam 12:16; Isa 58: 5, 6)., A model of spiritual formation was developed through the practice of these disciplines.
This model of spiritual formation was tested on a group of 43 young students of a university in Lima, Peru. The results indicate that they experienced significant changes in their form of communion, Bible knowledge, discipleship, and commitment to the mission.
|
The Role of Government in Promoting Social Justice
Program Unit: Bible and Ethics
Markus Zehnder, Ansgar Teologiske Høgskole
According to a widespread view, an important element of (social) justice is the alleviation, if not eradication, of social inequalities through government action, especially in the form of the redistribution of the wealth of the upper classes of society. This paper aims at investigating in what ways, if at all, this view is found in the concepts of social justice represented in the Hebrew Bible.
|
Paul ἐν τοῖς δεσμοίς: Rethinking John Knox on Acts, Prisons, and the Apostle’s Letters
Program Unit: Redescribing Christian Origins
Christopher B. Zeichmann, Emmanuel College, University of Toronto
The specifics of Paul’s life are nearly as controverted as the details of the historical Jesus’ life. The present paper is an effort to methodologically clarify the role of Acts in Pauline biography, taking as its point of departure the work of John Knox and using as Paul’s ‘prison letters’ as its example. It will be suggested that there is little evidence that Paul wrote while in prison, and that his references to chains need not refer to the prisons that feature prominently in Acts' narrative. Scholarly assumption that he wrote Philippians and Philemon while in a detention facility are largely propelled by the interpretive inertia of Acts upon the epistles. This paper will address the sociology-of-knowledge issue regarding the scholarly doxa (following Bourdieu) knowledge that is taken for granted in Pauline biography, despite any number of methodological reasons one might think otherwise.
|
Hermeneutics of the Spectacular in Biblical Scholarship since 9/11
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Christopher B. Zeichmann, Emmanuel College, University of Toronto
Since 9/11, there has been a surge in interest among New Testament scholars in the topic of violence. This article suggests that such works operate with a “hermeneutics of the spectacular” that functions to legitimate the liberal status quo by concentrating its focus upon the most visibly heinous forms of state violence under the aegis of "resistance." This paper argues that the emphasis on "discourse" as the premier site of resistance among ancient Jews and Christians is ultimately a self-serving move for biblical scholars - reflecting their own investment in the careful study of (written) word and the apparent decline of value in such study in the public perception. If biblical scholarship is to be something other than an self-preserving ideological repository for late capitalism and state violence, it is necessary to reconsider the issue.
|
Heavenly Scriptures, the Interjections of the šayāṭīn, and the Protection of the Prophets from Late Antiquity to Early Islam
Program Unit: The Qur’an and the Biblical Tradition (IQSA)
Holger Zellentin, University of Cambridge
Qurʾān Q22 Sūrat al-Ḥağğ 52 teaches that “We did not send before you any apostle or prophet but that when he desired (ʾillā ʾiḏā tamannā), Satan interjected in his desire (ʾalqa š-šaiṭānu fī ʾumniyyatihī). Thereat God abrogates whatever Satan has interjected (fa-yansaḫu llāhu mā yulqi š-šaiṭānu) [and] then God confirms His verses (or: signs, ʾāyātihī), and God is knowing, wise.” The issue of satanic interjections has troubled Islamic theologians henceforth. Beginning with a brief consideration of Ibn Taymiyyah’s position on the matter, to which Shahab Ahmed has recently drawn our attention, this paper will probe the Late Antique discourse about the satans’ interpolations into Scripture, and will consider the ways in which the Qurʾān responds to it, with a special focus on two intertwined doctrines: the Heavenly Scriptures and the sinlessness of the of the prophets.
|
Sir Harold Idris Bell’s Papyrus Syndicate (1920–1935)
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Lorne R. Zelyck, Saint Joseph's College - University of Alberta
Recent publications about the Green Collection, the Gospel of Jesus’ Wife, and the SBL Policy on Scholarly Presentation and Publication of Ancient Artifacts, have revealed the importance of knowing the provenance of a single papyrus and entire papyri collection. Yet little is known about the provenance of historic papyri collections in American and European institutions. I will address this narrative lacuna by discussing the role of Sir Harold Idris Bell as principal leader of the Papyrus Syndicate, based on archival letters from the British Library, National Library of Wales, and Bentley Historical Library. Bell was responsible for the acquisition, identification, description, and dispersal of papyri to the British Museum, and American and European universities. The Syndicate reduced price-raising competition among its members, but more importantly, it prevented antiquities dealers from dividing papyri collections and selling these fragments to private collectors. However, the presence of sister-manuscripts (fragments of the same manuscript) in multiple institutions indicates that the Syndicate was not entirely successful. Previous attempts to join separated fragments have focused on identifiable texts, without first examining the acquisition history of individual papyri collections. Identifying the manuscripts that were acquired by the Syndicate and examining their provenance (location; antiquities dealer; date of acquisition), could help to locate separated sister-manuscripts, particularly fragments of previously unidentified texts. In this paper I will focus on the provenance of two manuscripts that Bell acquired in 1934: the Egerton Gospel (Papyrus Egerton 2 + P.Köln. VI 255 [inv. 608]) and a supposed “Gospel Commentary” (Papyrus Egerton 3 + PSI inv. 2101).
|
Contradictions and Coherence in Targum Pseudo-Jonathan: Apparent Conflicts between Numerals
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Iosif Zhakevich, Master's College and Seminary
This presentation analyzes three apparent contradictions in Targum Pseudo-Jonathan (Ps-J), all of which relate to numerals—the time of Abraham’s death, before or after the birth of Jacob and Esau to Isaac (Gen 25:8 vs. 25:29); the number of plagues against Egypt, ten or two hundred and fifty (Ex 14:21 vs. Gen 15:14); and the number of days the Israelites ate Manna after Moses’ death, forty or thirty-seven (Ex 16:35 vs. Deut 34:8). At first blush, these contradictions seem to suggest that the Targum is internally incoherent and that the targumist was careless. However, analysis of the targumist’s exegetical method and the study of the Jewish traditions underlying the targumic expansions reveal that the passages that appear to be mutually exclusive are in fact coherent and complementary.
The implication of Ps-J’s actual coherence amidst its apparent contradictions is twofold. First, a necessary inference is that, though the targumist permitted literary tension within the surface text of Ps-J, the targumist was indeed committed to logical consistency and was scrupulous in his production of the Aramaic narrative even to the point of minute detail. Second, due to the presence of literary tension within the surface text, the Ps-J narrative seems to require its audience to interact closely with its text and to be familiar with the implied Jewish traditions, in order for the audience to discern the meaning and the coherence of the complex narrative.
In the end, this analysis suggests that Ps-J is a carefully crafted Targum that was produced in the context of a learned Jewish community—by a scholar-targumist(s) for an informed audience.
|
A Preliminary Study on Maimonides’ Conception of Nature and Zhu Xi’s Doctrine of Li (Principle) and Qi (Material force)
Program Unit: Theology of the Hebrew Scriptures
Ying Zhang, East China Normal University
In his Guide of the Perplexed, Maimonides discusses “the meaning of nature” and relates nature on the one hand to the four elements – fire, air, water and earth, thus to the material world, and on the other hand, to the notion of governance, and therewith to the generation and preservation of living beings (Guide II 10). While the same passage seems to imply a deified nature by saying that nature is “wise” and “similar to a craftsman,” the author of the passage may as well suggest a naturalized deity in the same work (cf. Guide III 32, 525). Maimonides’ blurring the boundary between the natural and the divine raises serious questions. Among them is the one as how to understand his identifying divine science with the Account of the Chariot and natural science with the Account of the Beginning.
As a preliminary study on comparing Maimonides’ conception of nature with the naturalistic doctrine of li (pattern or principle) and qi (material force or vital energy) in Zhu Xi, Maimonides’ Chinese contemporary and counterpart, this paper will limit itself in a tentative reading of Maimonides’ interpretation of the Account of the Chariot (Guide III 1-7) in the light of Zhu Xi’s discussion of the dynamic transformations among taiji (supreme ultimate), qi (material force) and wuxing (the Five Phases, i.e., metal, wood, earth, water, fire).
|
Assyria, Isaiah, and the Odyssey: The Expansion of the Neo-Assyrian Empire and Its Cultural Koine
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Marcus Ziemann, Ohio State University
Especially since Peter Machinist’s “The Image of Assyria in First Isaiah,” scholars have recognized influence from Assyrian literature on First Isaiah. Recently, scholars have emphasized that Isaiah was not only influenced by Assyrian literature and propaganda, but also knowingly appropriated it and used it to delegitimize Assyrian power (see in particular Shawn Zelig Aster’s new book Reflections of Empire in Isaiah 1-39). It will be the argument of my paper that similar concerns underlay the influence of the Assyrian Empire on the contemporaneous emergence of Greek literature in the 8th-7th centuries.
This contention cannot be proven definitively with a single paper, but a case-study from the Odyssey will point in this direction. During his descent to the Underworld, Odysseus digs a pit, pours milk and wine into it, and mixes in the blood from a goat in order to call forth the spirits of the dead. Traditionally, scholars have seen this ritual as borrowed from Hittite/Hurrian necromantic pit-rituals. However, as Beate Pongratz-Leisten has recently pointed out, Assyrian culture was a syncretic combination of Hurrian and Babylonian elements. Moreover, the Neo-Assyrian emperors performed a similar pit-ritual to expel ghosts and confirm the authority of the emperor. Odysseus performs this ritual while attempting to regain his identity and authority as the king of Ithaca. It is therefore far more likely that the Odyssey is responding to the contemporary Assyrian ritual rather than the Hittite ritual attested only centuries before the Odyssey was composed.
Furthermore, First Isaiah has been shown to respond to this same ritual. Christopher Hayes recently argued that Helel ben Shahar (traditionally rendered as Lucifer/the Morning Star) in Isaiah 14 is to be identified with the Mesopotamian god Enlil. Specifically, he argues that the fall of Helel/Enlil in Isaiah 14 is to be connected with the overthrow of Enlil by Marduk in the Assyrian cultic explanatory text that interpreted the symbolism of the pit-ritual mentioned above. Isaiah 14 therefore subverts the legitimacy of the Assyrian emperor using Assyria’s own semiotic system and also demonstrates that the Assyrian pit-ritual was a literary topos that could be exploited by an international audience.
Along with the spread of Assyrian military power came Assyrian soft power in the form of an international cultural koine that reached the Aegean during the Orientalizing Revolution (8th-7th centuries BCE). While this pit-ritual was originally used to bolster the power of the Assyrian kings, it was adopted and adapted in various ways by the peoples in Assyria’s shadow. Isaiah could tap into this international koine to attempt to delegitimize Assyrian power while the Greeks could use the koine to assert their position within this prestigious international system.
|
The Placement of Nebuchadnezzar’s Encyclica (MT: Dan 3:31–33) in Papyrus 967 as Clue for the Relationship of the Main Versions of the Book of Daniel
Program Unit: Book of Daniel
Benjamin Ziemer, Martin-Luther-Universität Halle-Wittenberg
The LXX version of Daniel is known for two peculiarities in comparison with the Masoretic text
(MT): On the one hand, it contains additional material (the hymns in Chapter 3, BelDr, Sus) as
does "Theodotion"; on the other hand, it differs from the MT (and "Theodotion") in chapters 4–6 in
a much higher degree than in the rest of the book. Papyrus 967, in turn, is highly important among
the Greek witnesses of Daniel for two reasons: Aside from some tiny fragments and citations, it is
the only non-hexaplaric witness known so far for the text of LXX-Daniel, and it shows a discrete
order of the book not attested in any other Greek manuscript. In this paper, I propose to combine
these peculiarities into a theory about the relationship of the main Daniel versions.
It is likely that Papyrus 967 shows the original order of LXX-Daniel, since the order of the hexaplaric
version (88–Syh) is easily explained as a result of the alignment with the MT (resp.
"Theodotion"), as it is the case for, e.g., the book of Jeremiah.
At the same time, the placement of Daniel 5–6 between Daniel 8 and 9 as witnessed by Papyrus
967 improves the chronological order of events regarding the succession of kings. This fits well
for a Greek translation while the MT sequence (supported by the Qumran fragments and
"Theodotion"), with Dan 2:4b–7:28 as one continuous Aramaic section within a Hebrew frame,
seems more likely to represent the required Hebrew-Aramaic original.
In contrast, it remained widely unnoticed that Daniel 4 too is placed differently in Papyrus 967
compared with the other Greek witnesses. Whereas "Theodotion" agrees with MT in giving Nebuchadnezzar’s
madness report (Dan 4) after his encyclica to all nations (Dan 3:98–100 resp. 3:31–
33) and before Belshazzar’s meal (Dan 5), Pap. 967 has the madness report after the elevation of
Sedrach, Misach and Abdenago by Nebuchadnezzar (Dan 3:97LXX ≈ Dan 3:30MT) and before his
encyclica (Dan 4:34cLXX ≈ Dan 3:31–33MT). The hexaplaric tradition (88–Syh) solved this problem
by doubling the encyclica, supplying "Theodotion"’s translation (with asteriscs) at the beginning of
chapter 4 while retaining LXX’ formulation at the end of chapter 4.
So, the order and the content of Dan 1–3; 7–12MT (and "Theodotion") are confirmed by the LXX
version while the content and the placement of Dan 4, 5 and 6 differ fundamentally between Papyrus
967 and the MT.
This is most easily explained with the assumption that the common ancestor of both versions
agreed with MT in order and content while the LXX version combined a more or less faithful translation
of Dan 1–3 and 7–12 (including all visions of Daniel relating to the reign of Antiochus
Epiphanes) with the insertion of free renderings (perhaps made by memory?) of the legendary
texts of Dan 4–6 at places suitable by reason of chronology.
|
"The Day That Thou Eatest…" as a Day of Thousand Years in the Earliest Interpretation of Genesis
Program Unit: Early Exegesis of Genesis 1–3
Benjamin Ziemer, Martin-Luther-Universität Halle-Wittenberg
How Adam and Eve were able to live and to procreate descendants since it was said to the human being (Gen 2:17, KJV) »for in the day that thou eatest (i.e., of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil) thou shalt surely die«? This question kept occupied the interpreters of the book of Genesis rightly from the beginning. So, according to Genesis Rabbah 22,1, Rabbi Yehoshua, son of Nehemya, answered it in combination of two psalm verses. That way, he is able to call the verdict of Gen 2:17 an example of God’s mercies which »had been ever of old« (Ps 25:6) by posing the rhetorical question »hadst thou not given him one day of thine, which is a thousand years (cf. Ps 90:4), how could he have applied himself to begetting posterity?« The reception history of the identification of a »day« in Gen 1–3 with a »day« of thousand years, known both in Judaism and Christianity (cp. Justin’s Dialogue, 81:3), can hardly be overestimated. But Rabbi Yehoshua is not the first who made such an equation. On the contrary, I like to show that such reasoning, used already in the book of Jubilees for explaining the longevity of Adam (Jub 4:30), most likely goes back to the time of the formation of the biblical text itself.
|
Women's Voices on Early Christian Epitaphs from Lycaonia: Fiction and Reality
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Christiane Zimmermann, Christian-Albrechts-Universität zu Kiel
In Acts 13-14 Paul is said to have come to Lycaonia on his first missionary journey. More than 1000 Christian grave-inscriptions from the region help us to gain an initial insight into the development of Christianity in the first Christian centuries. Albeit grave-inscriptions usually follow specific forms and tend to idealise the dead and the family left behind, features concerning the real life can be extracted through careful analysis. The lecture will focus on Christian women as dedicators of grave-inscriptions, and aspects of fiction and reality in the self-representation of these women.
|
Assyria and Egypt in the Book of Hosea
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Yisca Zimran, Bar-Ilan University
Assyria and Egypt are mentioned five times in Hosea as a parallel pair [7:11; 9:3; 11:5, 11; 12:2] and one additional time in the Septuagint version [8:13]. The prominent number of appearances in varied contexts indicate that this is a significant phenomenon. The fact that the historical Egypt and Assyria have never cooperated, but were rather alternate allies to Israel, reinforces the impression that the joint mention is significant; not merely a representation of the historical kingdoms, but of the ideology the prophet wishes to deliver. Assyria and Egypt also appear separately throughout the book [three and eight times in correlation]. The separate references strengthen the presence of the kingdoms in the book, reinforce the impression of the parallel appearances, and support the need to clarify the significance of the phenomenon and its contribution to understanding the essential principles of the Book of Hosea.
Examining the appearances of Assyria and Egypt in light of each other contributes to a better understanding of the units that mention the two kingdoms. Uncovering the meaning of the units is also based on the unique poetics of the Book of Hosea, and grapples with its unique language. A study of the entirety of paired appearances in the book, from a synchronic perspective, enables discussion of the current structure of the book, and an outline of the process the nation will undergo according to the Book. An analysis of the entirety of paired appearances will also elucidate questions such as, what is the core of the sin according to the Book of Hosea? Will Israel exile to Egypt and Assyria, and if so why? What will lead to their return to the land? How is God perceived in the book? What is the perception of the covenant in the book, and the relationship between God and the nation derived accordingly?
The lecture will discuss the literary-theological significance of the phenomenon described above, while addressing the core questions uncovered through this phenomenon as presented above. This contradicts studies such as that presented by Barstad, who primarily emphasizes the historical side of the paired references of Assyria and Egypt in the book.
This lecture will prove and demonstrate that the paired mention of Assyria and Egypt in the various units and throughout the book represents personal and exclusive relations between Israel and their God, in contradiction with the universal perception of the divine. These relations are apparent from additional literary phenomena in Hosea such as the use of the lion simile, as demonstrated in my article [VT 68, pp. 149-167[, the repetition of the root זנ"י in the book, and the husband-wife, father-son metaphors, which have been broadly addressed. These relations affect the prophet's definition of the essence of the sin, as well as methods of punishment and redemption.
|
The Sulky and Abusive Nature of the Gods: Permutations of Erra and Išum in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Ilona Zsolnay, University of Chicago
In my article "The Inadequacies of Yahweh: A Re-examination of Jerusalem’s Portrayal in Ezekiel 16," I contend that Ezekiel's Yahweh brutally attacks his city-wife Jerusalem in order to force the city to cling to him as an abused spouse will cling to their abuser. I argue that Yahweh does this out of a gross sense of insecurity. In the conclusion of the piece, I muse that Yahweh's hot temper seems more in line with those of the great Greek gods Zeus and Hera or the Mesopotamian gods of war Ištar and Erra than those of a deity of an exiled people. Here I will consider my observation that Ezekiel's Yahweh (at least in this chapter) is not unlike Ištar or Erra. He is defensive, abusive, and very much a martial deity. Like Ištar and her actions against the mountain Ebih when it did not bow down to her awesomeness, the response of Ezekiel's Yahweh to Jerusalem's perceived disrespectfulness is to devastate. Erra, a deity of peace (through war) responds with similar violence on an unsuspecting (and seemingly impertinent) Babylon. The focus of this talk will be the transmission of the ancient Near Eastern themes of enslaved humanity, city devastation, and cultic upheaval as depicted in Sumerian texts, their reinterpretation in the late Babylonian epic Erra and Išum, and the resonances of this poem's Deity of Peace in the Hebrew Bible.
|
Putting the King in His Place: Orchestrating Ritual Space in Cuneiform Texts
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
Ilona Zsolnay, University of Chicago
Mesopotamian priests, such as the šangû (sağğa), are by and large keepers of a home. As any good caretaker, they tend to their charge's needs alongside other cultic personnel such as bakers, courtyard sweepers, and singers; and, while this home may be the domicile of a great god, it is a space-delineated activity. Mesopotamian rulers, such as the šarru (lugal), also exist to serve the gods; however, their purview is both interior and exterior. Within the walls of palace and city, Mesopotamian rulers participate in cultic ritual and mete out urban justice from their thrones; outside of these walls, they mete out territorial righteousness through campaign. This paper will consider these differing relationships to physical space and, as each office examined is held by a male figure, will define the constructs of masculinity represented and interrogate points at which they come in contact.
|
Moving Boundaries or Encroaching upon Territory? Translating Deuteronomy 19:14
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Shlomo Zuckier, Yale University
Among the more famous ethical commands in the Hebrew Bible is that of Deuteronomy 19:14, prohibiting the unlawful extension into one’s fellow’s land: “lo tassig gevul re’akha asher gavelu rishonim.” This has commonly be translated as “Do not move back your fellow’s boundary marker, which was set by the early ones” or similarly.
This paper will argue for a reassessment of that translation, drawing upon lexicological considerations pertaining to both the word “tassig” and the word “gevul.” It will argue that, generally speaking, the word “gevul” is better translated as “territory” than as “boundary marker” within the Bible, using several examples to demonstrate this. It will further argue that there is reason to consider taking “tassig” as the hiph’il of n.s.g rather than of s.u.g, notwithstanding the fact that the word generally is represented with a “samekh” rather than a “sin.” The translation yielded by this alternative approach would be “do not encroach upon your fellow’s territory, which was set by the early ones.”
This alternative translation, which to my knowledge has not been previously proposed, has several advantages: First of all, as noted, it takes a more straightforward use of the word “gevul.” Second, the parallelism in Proverbs 23:10 (which utilizes the same verb clause) works much more smoothly under this translation. Finally, a central leg that the standard translation stands on, namely the focus on the “samekh” rather than “sin” in the word “tassig,” is a weak one indeed, as the MT of Job 24:2 features the text “gevulot yassigu” with a “samekh,” and as many early representation of these verses spells them with a “samekh”!
Given the number of early interpreters (in both the Dead Sea Scrolls and rabbinic literature) who take this verse to be about moving back boundary markers, it is necessary to account for how such readings originated. I will argue that they stem from a semantic shift in the word “gevul” in post-Biblical Hebrew where the meaning of “territory” recedes and that of “boundary marker” becomes prevalent. I will use examples to demonstrate this, as well.
Throughout the paper I note the rampant bleeding into one another of the two meanings of “tassig.” I conclude with a question as to whether there may be cause to see the two roots whose hiph’il is “tassig,” namely n.s.g and s.u.g, as related to one another in some form.
|
Destroying Oneself for the Community: Competitive Gift-Giving in the Roman East
Program Unit: Polis and Ekklesia: Investigations of Urban Christianity
Arjan Zuiderhoek, Ghent University
What was the socio-political or economic reality (if any) behind the notion of the benefactor who ruined himself through his generosity, which we encounter as a topos in both pagan literary, epigraphic and legal sources as well as in early Christian texts? In this paper, I shall try to explore some of the longer-term societal dynamics in the cities of the Roman east (particularly Greece and Asia Minor) which might serve to explain such remarkable behaviour, and at the same time suggest why the idea of excessive munificence came to exercise such a powerful hold over the imagination of both elite authors and ordinary inhabitants of eastern provincial cities, both pagan and Christian.
|
The Eschatological Judgement of the Impious in the Wisdom of Solomon: Apocalyptic or Hellenistic Commonplace (or Both)?
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Jason M. Zurawski, Rijksuniversiteit Groningen
Ever since scholars began investigating the relationship between wisdom and apocalyptic literature, the Wisdom of Solomon has been a perennial example of a wisdom text which incorporates apocalyptic elements. Such elements typically pointed at are the mysteria (of God) in 2:22 and 6:22, the veiled reference to Enoch in 4:10-14, and, especially, the eschatological judgement of the impious in 4:20ff. Some have argued that this evidence points to a “direct rapprochement” between the biblical wisdom tradition and apocalyptic literature, while others have gone so far as to suggest that these elements signal a decisive break from the sapiential tradition. Such conclusions, however, largely derive from an approach to the text (though not only this text) narrowly focused on the categories created to help understand ancient Jewish literature, without equally considering other influences. In this paper, I will look at the eschatological judgement scene in order to complicate the common binary of wisdom and/or apocalyptic. The post-mortem judgement of souls was a motif common in ancient Greco-Roman literature, ubiquitous even beyond the boundaries of traditional poetry and myth. Philosophers like Plato or Plutarch could utilize such “eschatological” scenes often to make larger philosophical or rhetorical points. The author of the Wisdom of Solomon was well versed both in Hellenistic philosophy and contemporary literary devices, and his use of source materials, whether Greek or Jewish, was free and highly inventive. Therefore, with these two points in mind, the obvious question becomes: is the judgement scene in the Wisdom of Solomon actually derived or influenced by Jewish apocalyptic traditions, or does it instead spring from the intellectual milieu of the author’s city of Alexandria? If the latter, does this mean, then, that it is not apocalyptic? How does this effect the way we understand the passage—e.g. are we to read the account literally as expressing a sincere belief, or do we find the author attempting a bit rhetorical dexterity, using the vivid depiction to make a more profound point? These are the types of questions which will be explored. Definitive answers may not be found, but the investigation will hopefully serve to highlight the necessity of reading these texts more broadly and pushing scholarly abstractions and typologies in new directions.
|
The Louw-Nida Lexicon as an Extendable Source of Metaphors
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
Joost Zwarts, Utrecht University
The Louw-Nida lexicon of New Testament Greek (Louw and Nida 1988) organizes word meanings into semantic domains, like 8B for "Body parts" or 87C for "High status". An ambiguous word like 'kephale' (head) belongs to both of these semantic domains, reflecting the conceptual metaphor LEADER IS HEAD. Examples like this raise the question how we could use the information in the Louw-Nida lexicon to collect metaphorical mappings in that lexicon and how representative this is of metaphors in the New Testament more generally.
The idea for extracting and visualizing cross-domain mappings was first presented at the EABS/SBL meeting in Berlin in 2017. The present paper demonstrates how this plan is now worked out into an interactive circular visualization which gives access to all the cross-domain mappings in the Louw-Nida lexicon. Starting with a circle of the 93 top domains, the user can highlight the connections that a domain has to other domains and then click on a domain to explore those connections in more detail, down to the lexical items that instantiate these mappings. In this way one can explore, for instance, the domain of body parts as a source domain or the domain of high status as a target domain. This reveals how 'cheir (hand), 'daktylos' (finger), 'dexia' (right hand), 'keras' (horn) map to the domain 76 of Power and it shows the role of vertical position, 81B and 83I, in providing words for status like 'hypsoo' (exalt is lift up), 'hypsos' (high rank is height), 'hyperano', 'epano' (superior is above).
The paper addresses the "recall" of this method for finding metaphors, that is, how many of the metaphors in the New Testament are actually part of the Louw-Nida resource and what would need to be added. There is no exhaustive and authorative list of NT metaphors that could serve as a "gold standard" for comparison. However, Williams (1999) offers a fairly detailed overview of the metaphors in the Pauline part of the NT, organized according to source domains (e.g., Veil and Mirror, under Providing for Physical Needs), which makes a comparison possible. This comparison shows that less than half of the Pauline metaphors recorded in Williams is represented in the lexical entries of the Louw-Nida lexicon. An example is 'kalymma' (veil), which only has the semantic code 6Q (Cloth), but not 32E (Lack of capacity for understanding).
The paper then demonstrates how the existing lexical information could be enriched by the addition of such metaphorical senses. In this way we can make a step forward to an accessible and representative map of the metaphors of New Testament Greek (like Mapping Metaphor 2015 for English), using the richness of information embedded in existing resources.
Louw, J. P., and Nida, E. A. (1988). Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament: Based on Semantic Domains. New York, NY: United Bible Societies.
Mapping Metaphor with the Historical Thesaurus (2015). Metaphor Map of English. Glasgow: University of Chicago. http://mappingmetaphor.arts.gla.ac.uk
Williams, D. J. (1999). Paul?s metaphors: their context and character. Peabody, Mass.: Hendrickson.
|
Gold in the Old Testament
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Wolfgang Zwicekl, Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz
In ancient (Biblical) Hebrew exist several words which can be translated as gold: zāhāb, ḥārūṣ, kätäm, paz and bäzär. What are the differences between these words? The paper will present a methodological approach how to translate these different lexemes correctly. A careful study of the Biblical and extra-Biblical texts from the 1st millennium BC allows a more concrete understanding of the specific use of each lexeme. The etymology with comparisons in Egyptian, Akkadian or other Semitic languages helps sometimes to understand the meaning much better. Dating the age of the texts is important to understand if one lexeme replaced an older one. Old translations (Septuagint, Vulgate) add sometimes new information to understand the meaning of a Hebrew word; anyhow we are not always sure if ancient translators really understood and translated all Hebrew words correctly. The use of different types of gold in Greek or Latin texts describing the manufacture of gold more explicitly can be very helpful. And finally archaeological finds from the Southern Levant may demonstrate how gold was used in ancient times. All these multi-disciplinary approaches must get together for a successful interpretation of any ancient lexeme.
|
| |
|
|