|
|
2018 International Meeting
Meeting Begins: 7/30/2018
Meeting Ends: 8/3/2018
Call for Papers Opens: 10/18/2017
Call for Papers Closes: 2/14/2018
Requirements for Participation
|
|
Meeting Abstracts
Textual Interpretation, Metaphysical Power, and Pathologies of Recognition
Program Unit: Biblical Reception History and Authority in the Middle Ages and Beyond (EABS)
Heikki J. Koskinen, University of Helsinki
The religious form of life, for example within the Christian tradition, is to a large extent structured by acts of interpersonal recognition. Persons are granted access to religious communities by other people, who also initiate newcomers into their practices and ways of life. Moreover, religious groups and institutions incorporate various hierarchical power-relations, whose existence and normative statuses depend on the attitudes of the members of the relevant communities. In religious contexts, God then appears as the supreme ruler who acknowledges human persons, loves them, and even creates their very being. Because of the involvement of such deeply efficacious metaphysical assumptions, the normative statuses and consequent relations of power within religious communities also gain a heightened importance. Of special significance here is the issue of moral responsibility in wielding the internal metaphysical power of interpretation that religious communities grant to their own authorities. As a result of their normative statuses, religious authorities are in a position to formulate influential textual interpretations as well as to effect various normative decisions and social practices based on them. In this paper, I will argue that religious identities create and sustain social contexts that are susceptible to theodicist pathologies of mediated recognition. To back up the argument, I provide a conceptual analysis which specifies some problematic structural features of textual interpretation and mediated recognition in religious contexts. The articulated features can then help us to better understand the claimed susceptibility to pathologies, and therefore, also to better detect them and to try to prevent them from occurring.
|
The Emergence of Antitheodicism: On the Literary and Philosophical Reception of the Book of Job
Program Unit: Biblical Reception History and Authority in the Middle Ages and Beyond (EABS)
Sami Pihlström, University of Helsinki
The Book of Job has inspired not only Biblical scholarship but also literary and philosophical readings, rereadings, and rewritings. This paper discusses some selected literary and philosophical appropriations of the Book of Job in order to highlight the significance of this Biblical text as a central background of the philosophical position we may call antitheodicism.
As is well known, in the Book of Job, Job’s “friends” try to comfort him in his suffering by seeking to justify the fact that God allows such suffering to take place. In modern terms, they offer theodicies or “defenses” referring to God’s actual or potential reasons for allowing apparently innocent suffering to exist. However, Job himself does not accept such theodicist explanations. As Immanuel Kant emphasizes in his important essay, “On the Miscarriage of All Philosophical Trials in Theodicy”, 1791), Job’s key virtue is his sincerity, which in the Biblical story is contrasted with the friends’ dishonest attempt to flatter God.
The ways in which an allegedly overarching theodicy tends to crush the individual sufferer’s experience of their suffering have been criticized also in literary works examining individual suffering in its meaninglessness. Therefore, we may suggest that such key works of modern Western literature as Franz Kafka’s Der Prozess (1925) and George Orwell’s Nineteen Eighty-four (1949) can be seen as rewritings of the Book of Job.
Philosophically, the challenge of acknowledging the pointlessness and unjustifiability of another human being’s suffering has been emphasized in rather different traditions, ranging from Emmanuel Levinas’s ethics of otherness to D.Z. Phillips’s resistance to all theodicies. These examples show that the reception of the Book of Job in both literary and philosophical contexts is surprisingly widespread and varied. In short, all Kantian antitheodicies have to refer back to Job’s situation as the fundamentally human condition of meaningless suffering.
|
Distant Reading of the Gospel of Thomas
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
Zdenka Špiclová, Západoceská univerzita v Plzni
The paper applies selected methods of distant reading to the apocryphal text of the Gospel of Thomas. The applied methods are developed as a part of collaborative research project DiRECT: Distant Reading of Early Christian Texts: Explorations in Socio-Cognitive Interpretation (University of West Bohemia, Pilsen, Czech Republic) and include text network analysis and a version of topic modeling. Analyzing and visualizing the source text by using these methods, the paper offers a comparison of selected parables and Jesus' statements in the Gospel of Thomas with corresponding passages from Synoptic gospels. Because these methods allow a sophisticated and quantifiable comparison of the corpora of the early Christian movements, they thereby help to uncover and prove the differences in their theology.
|
The Context of the Edfu Manuscripts: Egypt at the Turn of the First Millennium
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Lloyd G Abercrombie, University of Oslo
This paper will explore the historical moment in which the Edfu manuscripts were produced. I will touch briefly on several issues: economics and trade, geography, religious demographics, and politics. I will lay out for the reader the geography of the area from which these manuscripts derive. I will present the religious demographics of the area, as far as it can be ascertained. I will also discuss the relationship between the Coptic community and the Muslim political authorities at the time. I will attempt to explain the materiality of these objects (paper and parchment) in the context of writing material in the larger Islamic world. All this will be done with the goal of illuminating why the texts in these manuscripts would have been of interest to readers of the period, and how they would have likely been interpreted.
|
Deuteronomy and the Pentateuch: Eckart Otto's Commentary on Deuteronomy vol. 4
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Law
Reinhard Achenbach, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
One of the remarkable scholarly achievements in Otto's Commentary on Deuteronomy is the verification of literary and hermeneutical links with deuteronomistic, priestly,and redactional texts in the Pentateuch, together with evidences for scribal disputes between Pentateuch and Prophets. The paper will reflect on consequences of these insights for further scholarly research.
|
Flood as Anti-war in Genesis
Program Unit: Pentateuch (Torah)
Bartosz Adamczewski, Cardinal Stefan Wyszynski University in Warsaw
The flood account in Genesis has mainly been studied in source-critical categories. The evident intertextual connections of this account to the Mesopotamian literature have also been analysed thoroughly. However, it has rarely been noted that the metaphor of the flood was widely used in military contexts, to describe an invasion of a powerful army into a given territory. This paper will explore the function of the flood account in Genesis against the background of the deuteronomic ideology of holy war. It will show that the flood account theologically subverts this military ideology into an anti-war idea. Such an understanding of the flood account has important consequences for the research on the origins, sources, and interpretation of the Book of Genesis.
|
Six Stone Jars in the Fourth Gospel
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Bartosz Adamczewski, Cardinal Stefan Wyszynski University in Warsaw
The number of the six stone jars in the Fourth Gospel is widely regarded as symbolic, in Jewish numerology evoking the idea of incompleteness and imperfection. However, the contextually related, likewise numerical remark concerning the capacity of the jars, as containing two or three measures each, undermines the hypothesis of symbolic significance of all these numbers. This paper, with the use of the tools of critical intertextual research, will offer a new understanding of the intended meaning of these quantitative remarks. Moreover, it will suggest a new interpretation of the symbolism of the whole Cana episode.
|
The Allusive Significance of the Character of Nicodemus
Program Unit: Allusions in the Gospels and Acts
Bartosz Adamczewski, Cardinal Stefan Wyszynski University in Warsaw
The character of Nicodemus in the Fourth Gospel is not known from the Synoptic Gospels. It has already been noted that this intriguing character has many traits of the synoptic character of Joseph of Arimathea. However, this intertextual link to the Synoptic Gospels does not fully explain the particular features of the character of Nicodemus. Therefore, this paper will explore other intertextual connections of the Johannine Nicodemus episodes, especially to the writings of Josephus and to the Acts of the Apostles. It will also offer a new understanding of the functions of the allusions contained in the Nicodemus episodes in the Fourth Gospel.
|
Re-linking 1 Sam 3 and 4
Program Unit: Septuagint of Historical Books (EABS)
Anneli Aejmelaeus, University of Helsinki
Early evidence of the textual history of 1 Samuel can be seen in some of the doublets of the Greek text that are present in practically all the manuscripts. In such cases the translation of part of the text – from one word to several sentences – is given twice: in the original translation and in a corrected form, which was presumably first added into the margin from where it later slipped into the text. In 1 Samuel, such doublets are relatively frequent. In some cases, the more original part of the doublet presupposes a Hebrew Vorlage different from the MT, thus preserving evidence for the editorial history of the Hebrew text. One of these cases is found at the end of chapter 3 where the Septuagint transmits a substantially longer text than the MT. A critical analysis of the text will show that the doublet in the Septuagint consists of two alternative forms of the redactional conclusion of the chapter and its connection with chapter 4.
|
A Lost Manual on Biblical History: Towards the Reconstruction
Program Unit: Slavonic Parabiblical Traditions (EABS)
Dmitry Afinogenov, Russian Academy of Sciences Institute of World History
The discovery of several fragments in Church Slavonic translation of George the Monk’s chronicle (Lětovnik) which supplement his entries on Biblical history from Seth to Moses’ childhood has permitted to establish a much clearer idea of the lost source that was used independently by George in 846/847 and by Symeon Magister in 960s. The editor who prepared the Greek original of Lětovnik must have worked between 847 and ca. 867. Now it is possible to partially reconstruct this lost work, which was of Jewish pre-Christian origin and dealt with the prediluvian as well as postdiluvian patriarchs, stressing especially various arts and occupations, of which each of them was the inventor. The manual also traced the origins of idolatry and of specific Hellenic deities (in euhemeristic fashion). Hagadic material, possibly rather abundant initially, survives mainly in the Slavonic fragments, which may point at deliberate exclusion by both chroniclers. Symeon also added information from the books of Jubilees and of Henoch. The somewhat strange initial phrase of George’s narrative: “The book of origin (Βίβλος γενέσεως) of men, in the day when God created Adam in his image and after his likeness,” may go back to the work in question. The reconstruction will be based on the following principles: 1). Interpolations surviving in Slavonic are accepted in their entirety. 2) If a passage has word-to-word correspondence in any other of the three sources, it is accepted. 3) All other passages may be accepted only hypothetically, on typological or stylistic grounds.
|
The Bogomil Apocrypha about the Archangel Michael: Translation from Slavonic into Greek?
Program Unit: Slavonic Parabiblical Traditions (EABS)
Afinogenova Olga, The Orthodox Encyclopedia
The study of the Greek manuscript Vatic. Gr. 1190a. 1542, containing the text of an apocryphal legend about the struggle between Archangel Michael and Satan (Stanael), has revealed an uncommon phenomenon of the existence of Slavonic (Bogomil) apocrypha in some Greek-speaking environment. The plot of the legend was quite widespread on Balkans, but all the published Slavonic versions of the apocrypha are shorter than the Greek text we have (eddited by A. Miltenova in 1981).
We can assume two possibilities of the origin of the Greek legend: 1. Translation into Greek of the so far unknown longest Slavic version 2. The story, initially written in Greek, was spread among the Greek-speaking population orally. Both assumptions, however, lead to the same conclusion: Bogomil apocrypha of this kind were probably more widespread than previously thought — not only in the Slavic environment. It is also possible that some features of the Bogomil worldview were inherent in the Greek folk tradition, reflected by this literary work.
|
Becoming a Subject: Mother-Daughter Relationships in the Acts of Thecla
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Vilja Alanko, University of Helsinki
The paper presents a reading of the Acts of Paul and Thecla, a classic text of feminist biblical scholarship, from the angle of maternal relations. On my reading, the fact that the story is framed by depictions of mother-daughter relationships is taken to be significant for the emerging of Thecla’s subjectivity. Namely, the maternal figures Theocleia and Tryphaena are present at the high-points of the narrative that portrays a protagonist with a growing sense of agency. This aspect has not been studied so far in the scholarship that has focused on Thecla’s character caught in the dichotomy of liberation and submission. Instead, I argue that it is the key for understanding Thecla and the influence her story has had while pointing to a particular trait in the gendered history of Christianity. Building on the argument of Luce Irigaray on the significance of feminine genealogies and especially maternal relations for feminine subjectivity, I suggest that the story of Thecla can be read as a process of becoming a subject and that this process takes place in the maternal relationships, being both challenged and supported by them. Furthermore, the element of gender ambivalence shows a movement in Thecla towards a subject position that nevertheless does not become overwhelmingly masculine. In addition to Irigaray, I build on earlier studies on hagiographic literature that points to the centrality of mother-daughter relationships in early Christian asceticism in contrast to contemporary culture (S. Ashbrook Harvey, ”Sacred Bonding”, 1996) and the transformative power of eros working in and through these texts (V. Burrus, The Sex Lives of Saints, 2004).
|
Embarrasing Inclusion: Samson and Jephthah in the Epistle to the Hebrews
Program Unit: Epistle to the Hebrews
David Allen, Queen's Foundation for Ecumenical Theological Education
The Beispielreihen of scriptural figures in Hebrews 11 famously includes a number of ambiguous characters, those whose commendable achievements are often equally matched by their apparent frailties and misjudgements. The list is a proverbial ‘mixed bag’. However, there are two individuals named within the discourse – Samson, and more notably, Jephthah – whose prior scriptural achievements seem particularly problematic, and whose presence within the cloud of witnesses seems questionable at least. This paper probes their inclusion within the Hebrews 11 retinue. It begins by engaging with the intra-Hebrews effect of such inclusion and the consequences for interpreting the text. The second part of the paper then turns to the ensuing reception of Hebrews, to explore how subsequent interpreters have engaged with the implied praise of such figures, and the ramifications of this for the text’s function.
|
And Now for Something Completely Different: A Reinterpretation of the Abraham Tradition is Ezekiel 33:24
Program Unit: Prophets
Eliza Justice, King's College - London
Ezekiel 33:24 represents the single reference to Abraham in the entire prophetic book and, compounding this distinction, its treatment of the patriarch constitutes a somewhat baffling polemic. The classical interpretation of this passage holds that Ezekiel 33:24 reflects awareness of patriarchal tradition which is coherent with the extant Genesis narrative, if not in full at least in part. While some variations on this interpretive theme exist, the idea that Ezekiel knows Abraham’s story, be it from the Priestly or non-Priestly source, dominates and directs our understanding of this passage.
This paper proposes an alternative way of reading Ezekiel 33:24 by suggesting that Ezekiel did not know the Abraham tradition of Genesis, or know Genesis as an authoritative text. This position rejects the practice of reading intentional parallels or dependence in cases where Ezekiel uses themes or figures appearing in other biblical passages. It contends that mention of Abraham in Ezekiel 33:24 is not itself conclusive evidence that Ezekiel was informed by the Genesis tradition. Moreover, viewing the prophetic reference as a consequence of the Genesis narrative, or the larger Pentateuchal text, only affords a partial understanding not just of that passage but of the broader context to which it belongs. Nonetheless, there is a preponderance to determine the reliance of Ezekiel 33:24 on Genesis without entertaining alternatives.
As part of my doctoral work, this paper briefly introduces what is a more complex argument, itself one of the three interpretive options I give for Ezekiel 33:24. My objective is to demonstrate how different ways of understanding the same material—through literary and theological methods as well as synchronic and diachronic readings—can generate a comprehensive appreciation of the text and contribute to a pluralistic exegetical approach.
|
“…Answer Me, and I Will Tell You by What Authority I Do These Things”: The Rhetorical Function of Question and Counter-Question in Mark 11:27–33
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Tobias Ålöw, Göteborgs Universitet
| In this paper I advocate an alternative understanding of Jesus’ response to the question “By what authority are you doing these things? Who gave you this authority to do them?” in Mark 11:27–33. Instead of reading Jesus’ counter-question “Did the baptism of John come from heaven, or was it of human origin?” as an implicit answer to the query posed by the religious authorities – as maintained by a large number of scholars, including e.g. Bultmann, Hooker and Schnabel – I argue that the commencing qualification “I will ask you one question; answer me, and I will tell you by what authority I do these things” (v.29), together with the concluding comment “Neither will I tell you by what authority I am doing these things” (v.33), show that Jesus’ counter-question is not intended, nor functions, as an answer. The same conclusion is further substantiated by examination of how counter-questions are used elsewhere in Mark’s gospel, as well as in Greco-Roman and rabbinic material. Form-critical analysis reveals that these alleged parallel traditions are substantially dissimilar from Mark 11:27–33, and should therefore not be adduced in support of the traditional interpretation. Finally, building on the insights of inter alia J. H. Neyrey, I contend, with reference to the function of questions in Greco-Roman rhetorical tradition, that the purpose of both question and counter-question in this context is neither the attainment nor the provision of information regarding the nature and origin of Jesus’ authority. Instead, for both the religious authorities and Jesus their respective questions are rather expressions of, and weapons in, the constant struggle to acquire honor and avoid shame that characterizes their culture. By responding with a counter-question that his interlocutors will not be able to answer, Jesus defends his own honor while simultaneously shaming his opponents
|
Polemics in the Story of Joseph
Program Unit: Pentateuch (Torah)
Yairah Amit, Tel Aviv University
Biblical literature is polemical in its essence. The polemics it includes reflect a variety of ideological struggles of its authors and editors. There were struggles with the cultural world that surrounded it, and among the different ideological streams and schools responsible for its creation. Naturally it includes different types of polemics. In my lecture I will present the prominent polemical types that characterize Joseph's story and their implications. Mainly I'll focus on the phenomenon of the hidden polemic, how to discover it and what it means. The interest in polemics connects with the dating of the story, because ideological struggles are not detached of historical background. The fact that Joseph's story, like the stories of Esther and Daniel, describes an exilic background, shows that the story is directly connected to the experience of exile. Moreover, following the hidden polemic may reveal who Joseph was, when and where he lived, and why this story was written.
|
The Lover's Body Is a Wonderland: Networks of Metaphors in the Song of Songs & ANE Love Songs
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible (EABS)
Jennifer Andruska, University of Cambridge
The large number of metaphors found in the Song of Songs cluster to form networks of metaphors with each other and with other metaphors found in ANE love songs more generally. These clusters reveal something about how they conceptualised reality, and specifically, the body of the lover. The metaphors in the Song of Songs reflect an underlying pattern also found in other ANE love song metaphors relating to the body of the lover. This paper will look at this network of metaphors in order to determine what underlies it cognitively, and what it reveals about how these poets conceptualised the lover’s body. I will utilise a cognitive linguistic approach to argue that the primary underlying conceptual metaphor – the ‘megametaphor’ or ‘extended metaphor’ – that underlies this network of micrometaphors in the Song and other ANE love songs, and unites them is: THE LOVER’S BODY IS A WONDERLAND. The metaphors in the Song and in other ANE love songs more generally share this conceptual metaphor, though the specific micrometaphors in the various texts conform to specific cultural and linguistic expressions, some shared and some novel. By ‘WONDERLAND,’ or perhaps better ‘WONDERWORLD,’ I do not mean landscape (though it includes this), but rather that, in the perception of the poet, each aspect of the lover’s body evokes an experience of wonder best correlated with and expressed by other experiences of wonder, in the land they live in and their world of reality. They are cognitively correlating their experience of the lover’s body with other cognitive experiences of wonder. For these poets, the enigma of the lover’s body is best expressed by other cognitive experiences of wonder and they use these metaphors to help us see this with a shock of new recognition.
|
Compounded Adjectives for Purple in the LXX
Program Unit: The Language of Colour in the Bible: From Word to Image (EABS)
Anna Angelini, University of Lausanne
Colors terms related to dye and textiles are of particular interest in the study of ancient colors lexemes. They attest of an essential feature of color terminology in antiquity : the fact that lexemes denoting color are contextualized, i.e. not dissociable from the material context of the objects defined by a specific chromatic referent. Among ancient dyes and textiles, purples represent a crucial item not only because of the variety of shades and nuances expressed by their hue, but also because of their high symbolic value. Such a relevance is reflected in the Greek Bible by a rich terminology referring to purples. The proposed paper will analyze the adjectives related to purple in the LXX against the background of the evidence coming from Hellenistic papyri, and will compare Hebrew and Greek lexicon for purples.
|
AnthroPOA: Writing the Anthropology of the Ancient Near East
Program Unit: Anthropology and the Bible (EABS)
Anna Angelini, University of Lausanne
Despite the significant impact of historical anthropology on the field of Classical studies and European historiography, this discipline remains underdeveloped in both ancient Near Eastern historiography and biblical studies. The project « AnthroPOA. Writing the Anthropology of the Ancient Near East » aims at filling this lacuna. AnthroPOA brings together scholars working in French, Italian and Swiss universities and centres of research. The proposed paper will present some of the major goals of the project, its methodology and the main issues at stake when trying to incorporate biblical studies within the anthropology of the ancient Near East. Three main lines of research have been selected so far as particularly relevant and worthy of examination: first, the necessity of replacing the classical topic of “cultural identity” with a model which prioritizes the concepts of cultural continuity and contiguity; second, a dialogue with the most recent areas of anthropological research (e.g. environment, materiality, “sensoriality”); third, and last, the processes which lead to the genesis of politics and the relationship between power and territory in antiquity.
|
(Don't) Show Me the Money: Economy, Corruption, and the Temple Scroll
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Giancarlo P. Angulo, Florida State University
This paper will explore the curious omission of economic regulations in the Temple Scroll’s rewriting of Deuteronomy. In 2002 Catherine Murphy astutely recognized that fourteen or fifteen of the eighteen legal passages from Deuteronomy left out of the Temple Scroll relate to rules regarding sacrificial and commercial economy. This paper hopes to read the exclusion of these specific legal materials as a reflection of the text’s perspective on the temple estate and its economic function. I maintain two significant methodological starting points: (1) the scroll’s portrait of an opulent temple estate represented an imaginary manifestation of the way the temple should operate in a contemporary worldly situation and (2) the laws promulgated in the Temple Scroll are tied to and reinforced by the authority of the new and pristine temple detailed in the scroll. Insofar as 11Q19 posits the correct temple establishment and legal stipulations, then, it introduced both a polemic against the concurrent Jerusalem Temple and a solution. In this light, I argue that the consistent excision of commerce laws constituted an intentional strategy meant to separate the temple from its economic role in Judean social and political life and to critique the temple’s place in fiscal oversight and financial responsibilities. Using a theoretical model proposed by Roland Boer, I suggest that this editorial practice stems from disappointment with the temple’s role in imperial systems of economic exploitation. It follows that this reading then lays the groundwork for an economic polemic against the Jerusalem Temple - one that rendered it irredeemably corrupted - that later emerged more pointedly in sectarian documents like CD (the nets of Belial) and the pesharim (the Wicked Priest).
|
Negative Theology in the Book of Isaiah: The Inaugural Vision
Program Unit: What a God is Not – The Early History of Negative Theology (EABS)
Stéphanie Anthonioz, UMR 8167
The inaugural vision in the book of Isaiah (Isa 6:1-13) takes place in a cultic context which is both historicized and atemporal. The text appears to be highly constructed and seems to question and debate significant religious issues concerning seeing or not the divinity in the Jerusalem sanctuary. This contribution will analyze the text in its literary and historical context. It will lay bare strategies of both non-prophecy and non-vision and at the same time contradict such negative theology through the description and function of the Seraphim.
|
Intellectual Illumination as a Visionary Experience
Program Unit: Vision and Envisionment in the Bible and its World (EABS)
Katri Antin, Helsingin Yliopisto - Helsingfors Universitet
The Thanksgiving Psalms (1QHa) discovered in Qumran cave 1 make use of traditional visionary language by referring to visions, God opening an ear, revelation of mysteries, and God’s counsel, for example. Previously, it has been argued the Thanksgiving Psalms do not refer to actual visual or aural experiences but revelation of divine knowledge is understood to be divinely inspired intellectual process. This paper argues further that one can identify two such intellectual processes in the Thanksgiving Psalms, revelation of divine wisdom and implicit exegesis. It is demonstrated that while the two intellectual processes are depicted also separately, they are related to one another in two Thanksgiving Psalms. In these psalms, God is depicted revealing his wisdom but the divine wisdom is in fact formulated by implicit exegesis of older traditions such as the Book of Jeremiah and Instruction. Finally, it is argued that similar ways of conceptualizing visionary experience can be found in other late Second Temple period literature such as the Book of Daniel, the pesharim, Sirach, and Instruction.
|
Implicit Exegesis as a Mean of Transmitting Divine Knowledge in the Thanksgiving Psalms
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Katri Antin, Helsingin Yliopisto - Helsingfors Universitet
This paper examines how allegedly divine knowledge is transmitted according to two Thanksgiving Psalms attributed to a wisdom teacher (1QHa 5:12–6:33 and 7:21–8:41). The psalms are approached from the theoretical framework of divination where transmission of divine knowledge is understood having four integral components: (1) God that sends a (2) message and a (3) human mediator that transmits the message to (4) other human beings. Divination can be divided into intuitive and inductive divination based on the mean of inquiring divine messages. It is argued that the two Thanksgiving Psalms depict a wisdom teacher receiving his knowledge from God and reciting it to his audience. It is also argued that the transmission process includes both intuitive and inductive elements. Even though the wisdom teacher is depicted receiving his knowledge through divine revelation, the disclosure of the divine knowledge requires also personal skills and material objects. The divine knowledge is in fact produced through implicit exegesis. 1QHa 5:12–6:33 interprets mostly Instruction (4Q417 1 i) while 1QHa 7:21–8:41 brings several passages into conversation, starting from Jeremiah 10:12. In both psalms, the divine message is a deterministic two-ways teaching. However, in 1QHa 5:12–6:33, the perspective is cosmic whereas 1QHa 7:21–8:41 focuses on the diverse paths of human beings. While especially the explicit exegesis of the pesharim has been examined as a divinatory practice, this paper brings implicit exegesis and its application in poetic compositions into this topical discussion.
|
Finnish Catholic Struggles with Paul and Justification: Thoughts on Scott Hahn's New Romans Commentary
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Emil Anton, University of Helsinki
The central theological discovery of Martin Luther's Reformation, whose quincentenary was commemorated ecumenically last year, was Paul's teaching about 'justification by faith'. Despite the 1999 Catholic-Lutheran Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification and its commitment to this doctrine as an ’indispensable criterion’, Roman Catholic theology continues to struggle to appropriate Paul’s teaching as expressed in the letter to the Romans. A recent example of this is professor Scott W. Hahn’s 2017 commentary on Romans, published by Baker Academic. While encouraging a rediscovery of the ’primacy of faith’ and offering some interesting new openings, the thrust of the book tends to minimize the relevance of ’justification by faith’ for Catholics.
The standard Catholic teaching, upheld by Hahn, is that initial justification takes place in baptism, after which it can grow thanks to good works, which are then taken into account in ’final justification’. The grace of justification can be lost due to a mortal sin and regained in the sacrament of penance. But where, in this system, does ’justification by faith’ fit in? Is it seen simply as an initial stage in preparation for baptism, or perhaps identified with it? Is it a mere ’necessary condition’, inefficient and insufficient unless supplemented by contrition, sacraments, love, or good works? If so, what happens to Romans 3-4?
As a Finnish Catholic, growing up and working in a majority Lutheran context, I have struggled with Paul’s teaching on justification for years. Taking Scott Hahn’s new book as my starting point, I will explore what I consider to be the main problems in Catholic readings of Paul and justification. I discuss apologetic strategies that lead to dead-ends, offering instead an ecumenical Catholic-Lutheran approach that does better justice both to the apostle and to the faith of the Church.
|
Heikki Räisänen: Helsinki's Most Controversial Bible Scholar
Program Unit: History of Biblical Scholarship in the Late Modern Period
Emil Anton, University of Helsinki
Heikki Räisänen (1941-2015), ordained pastor of the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland and professor of New Testament exegesis at the University of Helsinki, is probably the most famous Finnish Bible scholar. He became a very controversial figure in Finnish ecclesiastical and theological circles in the 1970s and 1980s (and remained such until his death), due to his popularization of historical-critical biblical scholarship and questioning of traditional Christian dogma.
On the international level, Räisänen is best known for his contributions to the study of the Qur'an (Das Koranische Jesusbild, 1971), the Apostle Paul (Paul and the Law, 1983; Jesus, Paul and Torah, 1992), the New Testament and early Christianity (Beyond New Testament Theology, 1990; The Rise of Christian Beliefs, 2010).
Based on Räisänen's Finnish-language autobiography and popular books, my paper outlines Räisänen's personal development from a Bible believer along the lines of the fifth Finnish revival, to an advocate of the salvation-historical view of the Bible, to a 'cultural Christian'. Attention is paid to some of the biblical arguments that shaped Räisänen's thinking as well as some of his central interpretive paradigms. Furthermore, essential background is provided for the intra-Finnish controversy that Timo Eskola's 2013 book Beyond Biblical Theology: Sacralized Culturalism in Heikki Räisänen's Hermeneutics (2013) has brought to the awareness of the international readership.
|
From One Pole to the Other: Reading 1Thess 4:4 across Discourse of Linguistic Selection and Combination
Program Unit: Bible Translation Workshop (EABS)
Paraskevi Arapoglou, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki
εἰδέναι ἕκαστον ὑμῶν τὸ ἑαυτοῦ σκεῦος κτᾶσθαι ἐν ἁγιασμῷ καὶ τιμῇ
Both translators and commentators have been debating for many years the meaning of the word σκεῦος and how this could be better understood in the broader context of Paul’s rationale and his use of metaphorical and ambiguous language. It is essential, therefore, for both the translator and the interpreter to dig deep to all the connotations that are at play and correlate with, while at the same time form, our understanding that eventually enters into the ways they read the text.
This paper proposes a reading of the verse based on the two poles along which language is developed, that of metaphor and metonymy. Based on theories of the aspects of language, conceptualization, and rhetoric an effort will be made to examine the verse trying to trace possible nuances that will help the reader better understand it. Focusing on the word σκεῦος, and on some of its other occurrences both in Pauline literature and its contemporary writings, the following issues will be addressed: i) under which category can the use of the word fall, metaphor or metonymy? ii) how would each of the two categories affect our understanding, and therefore translation? iii) and how does each of those rhetorical tropes function within the context of the Pauline text and the meaning perceived by the readers/audiences?
|
Were the Israelite Tribal Eponyms Real People?
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Rami Arav, University of Nebraska at Omaha
The Bible recounts that the children of Jacob were the eponyms of the Israelite tribes. Ostensibly there is no reason to doubt this attribution. On their trajectory to become a nation inheriting a land, according to the divine promise, the patriarch’s twelve sons became the eponyms of the twelve tribes.
However, despite its intrinsic logic, scholars reading critically the Bible cast doubt on this trajectory. First scholars challenged the biblical narratives of Exodus, then the conquest of the Promise Land and the settlement of the tribes as narrated in the Bible.
This presentation aims to take this lead further down and to claim that the names of the eponyms of the tribes are in fact regional names and not personal names. A few examples will be used here to illustrate this claim.
Ephraim, a central tribe situated in the hill country is explained in a Midrashic form in the Bible: “For God has made me fruitful in the land of my misfortunes.” However, P,R,H “fertile, fruitful”, is not the root of Ephraim, it is E,F,R which means meadow or pasture. The suffix AIM in Hebrew is locative and not a personal name, similar to Yerushalaim, Shomrain (Ezra 4:10), Mahanaim, and She’araim.
The root of Zebulun is Z,B,L means fertile. This is indeed the fertile plain in the north part of the country. The root of Naphtali is P,T,L means to meander and fits perfectly the topography of Galilee where the tribe of Naphtali was settled.
The Israelite tribal eponyms are in fact regional names and therefore do not indicate a tribal ancestry of the Israelites.
|
Ephrem’s 27th Hymn on the Nativity in the Quranic Landscape
Program Unit: Quran and Islamic Tradition in Comparative Perspective
George Archer, Iowa State University
Perhaps the central question of modern historical-critical Quranic studies is who is the text’s primary audience? How did they identify themselves? What did they already think and believe? This project is an attempt to reconstruct one small part of that answer.
The relationship between the Quranic proclamation and the Christian Syriac hymns has been well-attested in the literature. Here, I focus on just one of these hymns: Ephrem the Syrian’s 27th Hymn on the Nativity. There is no reason to suppose that this hymn was available in the Quranic milieu, either in the original Syriac or in some hypothetical Arabic translation. However, many of this particular hymn’s unusual arguments seem to be directly addressed by the Quran, even though the Quran is not addressing the hymn itself.
Of special note is the hymn’s explanation of the names Jesus (Yeshu’) and John (Yohanon). Using a Christian gematria, Ephrem says that these names (and others) are evidence of Jesus’ divine reality, and that he has elected John the Baptist as his forerunning herald. Centuries later, the Quran destabilizes this gematria. It presents Jesus’ name in an unusual way (‘Isa, not the common Christian Arabic Yasu’). And it claims that John’s name refers only to God, as it was created for John alone (Quran 19:7).
There is no evidence that the Quran is speaking directly to Ephrem’s arguments, or suggestion that some in the Quranic audience knew Ephrem’s text. I offer here a reconstruction of how Ephrem’s thoughts appeared in the Quranic milieu. Ephrem’s hymn passed into oral translation, was edited by Arabic-speaking Christians, and was assumed as part of the Christian Quranic audience’s shared culture in the early 7th century.
|
What Was Urdeuteronomium?
Program Unit: The Core of Deuteronomy and Its World (EABS)
Bill T. Arnold, Asbury Theological Seminary
The paper begins with three assumptions. First, Deuteronomy’s narrative and parenetic framing units (Deut 1-11 and 27-34) cannot be read without the legal core (Deut 12-26), but the core can be understood without the frames. Therefore, the core is older. Second, in agreement with E. Otto, B. Levinson, et al., the central focus of the legal core is updating (replacing?) an older Book of the Covenant (Exod 20:22–23:33). Third, Urdeuteronomium was not a linear book or original “source” but rather a collection of legal traditions preserved on separate textual objects (sepharim), probably papyrus sheets. The paper investigates portions of the legal core often ignored in the scholarship for further indications of dependence upon the Book of the Covenant (literary or cultural). In light of recent scholarship on the nature of biblical law itself, the question is also raised here: Precisely what was Urdeuteronomium?
|
Enoch and the Development of a Christian Tradition: The Reception and Appropriation of Enoch and Enochic Imagery in the Ethiopian Church
Program Unit: Enoch within and outside the Books of Enoch: Parabiblical Writings, Iconography and Oral Tradition (EABS)
Bruk Ayele Asale, Mekane Yesus Seminary
The text of 1 Enoch is preserved in its entirety only in the Ge’ez language. This fact owes much to the distinctive view of the scriptural canon and interpretive culture of the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahǝdo Church, which possesses a wider canon including biblical and para-biblical Jewish and Christian texts. Moreover, scholars have long noted that 1 Enoch has not only been uniquely retained in the Ethiopian tradition but that it has also influenced the development of Christian thought and praxis in this context. Thus far, however, an in-depth study of the reception and development of the figure of Enoch and Enochic motifs in Ethiopian literature, iconography and liturgy is yet to be conducted.
With this in view, this study seeks to demonstrate the significance of Enoch and Enochic imagery in the literature, art, architecture, music and popular spirituality of the Ethiopian church. I particularly look at the reception and appropriation of Enochic themes in the development of indigenous biblical commentary (the Andǝmta commentaries) and other significant texts in the Ethiopic Christian tradition – such as the Synaxarium and the Apocalypse of Mary. I also look at the depiction of Enochic motifs in art, architecture, music and popular spirituality to demonstrate the cultural, as well as theological influence of Enoch. This brief analysis serves not only to identify Enochic references but also the significance of 1 Enoch in the Ethiopian tradition, not only as a literary artefact but as a sacred text continually interpreted and utilized in the formation of theology and praxis.
|
Rewritten Masculinities in the Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs
Program Unit: Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha
Susanna Asikainen, University of Helsinki
The Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs narrate the final speeches of the twelve sons of Jacob. In these speeches, the twelve sons of Jacob reassess and reinterpret their lives, and at the same time rewrite the biblical narratives. Rewritten biblical narratives typically address the issues created by the biblical texts by filling in gaps and answering questions raised by the biblical text. Sometimes they enhance the portrayal of biblical heroes by omitting embarrassing details. In this paper, I study how the Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs rewrite and reinterpret the masculinities of the twelve sons of Jacob. I examine how the ideal behavior presented in the text is connected with the ancient ideals of masculinity, especially the ideal of self-controlled masculinity favored in Stoic philosophical writings. The speeches emphasize self-control with regard to sexuality, violent emotions, and aggression. Joseph emerges in the text as the ideal man, to whom the other brothers are compared and contrasted.
|
Heterosexuality in Joseph and Aseneth
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Susanna Asikainen, University of Helsinki
Joseph and Aseneth tells a story of how a man meets a woman and they get married. Despite, or possibly because, of the story’s universality, heterosexuality of the characters has often been ignored. Heterosexuality per se has been studied very little in the context of the ancient world. Heterosexuality is often constructed as a unified, stable, and fixed category. Influenced by the perspectives of queer theory, the study of heterosexuality seeks to question and problematize heterosexuality as an unquestioned norm. Heterosexuality is not limited to sexual activity, but includes everyday expectations and practices, relationships, and family structures. A related concept is heteronormativity, the assumption that all people are heterosexual. It is also important to notice that heterosexuality is not a monolith. There are several types of heterosexuality, some of which are valued more highly than others. In this paper, I study heterosexuality in Joseph and Aseneth and examine how the text constructs its characters as heterosexual. Since Joseph and Aseneth shares similar plot and motifs with the ancient Greek novels, I also compare it with the presentations of heterosexuality in the novels.
|
Philemon: A Conclusion to Paul’s Letters?
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
Stefan M. Attard, University of Malta
Within the context of the gradual formation of the New Testament canon, this paper seeks to highlight the import of the Letter to Philemon in terms of a synchronic analysis that takes the whole Pauline corpus into consideration. Because the Letter to the Hebrews is very generic and lacks a one-on-one style, Philemon can be considered the last significantly personal letter of Paul. The position of Philemon before Hebrews and the other non-Pauline letters hence lends credence to the maximalist view that all the epistles from Romans to Philemon were penned by the Apostle of the Gentiles, since it seems to function as a conclusion to the whole collection of both undisputed and disputed Pauline writings. Though Hebrews may have been considered of Pauline origin at the time the canon was put together, its different positions in various extant documents is a curious phenomenon. For this reason, the placing of Philemon and Hebrews in various codices and manuscripts is examined and the relation of Philemon to the preceding writings (all the way back to the Gospel of Luke and the Acts of the Apostles) are analysed, both with regards to structural and theological considerations. As for Philemon’s theological outlook, it is legitimate to ask whether this letter echoes some of the main teachings laid down in the previous letters and to what extent, if any, can it be said to fittingly bring to a close basic tenets of this entire corpus of writings. It will be argued that the reasons for its present position in the canon are not to be found primarily in its relative shortness, or in its being addressed to a somewhat unknown individual, but to more relevant concerns that make it a powerful conclusion to Paul’s thoughts.
|
Ai and Ebal in Greek Jesus
Program Unit: Editorial Techniques in the Hebrew Bible in Light of Empirical Evidence (EABS)
Graeme Auld, University of Edinburgh
The paragraphs in Greek Jesus that correspond to Josh 8 (MT) will be explored within the wider context of more recent studies of Joshua in Hebrew and Greek.
|
Synoptic Royal Narrative Reflected in Dt 12-26
Program Unit: The Core of Deuteronomy and Its World (EABS)
Graeme Auld, University of Edinburgh
Widening the discussion of Dt 12 presented to the Berlin meeting in summer 2017, this paper explores the role throughout Dt 12-26 of key terms in the synoptic royal narrative, identified as prominent either by frequency or significant pairing, and finds further grounds for dating the central chapters of Deuteronomy to the post-monarchic period.
|
Philo and the Valentinians
Program Unit: Judaica
Risto Auvinen, Helsingin Yliopisto - Helsingfors Universitet
This paper investigates philosophical and exegetical parallels in the writings of Philo of Alexandria and in the Valentinian sources. The closest parallels with Philo can be found in the Excerpts from Theodotus by Clement of Alexandria. In my dissertation (Philo and the Valentinians, University of Helsinki, 2017), I argued that the Valentinian theology in these sources cannot be properly understood without recourse to Philo’s inventions in the allegorical exegesis of the Book of Genesis. On the one hand, the Valentinians elaborated the allegories attested to in Philo’s writings in the light of the Gnostic myth of Sophia. On the other hand, the Valentinian theologians reformed the preceding Gnostic myth in the light of teachings that they found in Philo’s writings. Although the Gnostic writings contain apparent anti-Jewish tenets, the Valentinian teachers were working in the allegorical tradition in which many of Philo’s Hellenistic-Jewish exegetical interpretations were adopted and reformed. It is reasonable to suggest that there was a historical relationship between Philo and Valentinian teachers. This relation was restricted, however, to one group of Valentinians whose teachings go back to the school of Ptolemy in Alexandria and Rome. These Valentinian teachers belonged to the circle of Christian Platonists who saw Philo’s works as valuable and preserved them after the revolt in 115-117 CE, that is, before they became the property of the Alexandrian Catechetical School at the end of the second century.
|
Otherness, Belonging, and Gender: Comparative Study of the Five Megillot
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Orit Avnery, Shalem College and Shalom Hartman Institute
The purpose of this paper is to explore the literary and thematic connection between the works known as “the five Megillot”: the Song of Songs, Lamentations, Ecclesiastes, Ruth, and Esther.
While each of the five Megillot has been studied in depth by scholars and exegetes in general and by feminist Bible critics in particular, until now there has been no attempt at a comprehensive intertextual reading between them, especially focusing on issues of identity. Similarly, the symbolic meaning of women’s presence in these five works has not yet been explored.
Despite their stylistic differences, I believe that all five works have a common theme, a fundamental issue that lies at the heart of each work: the challenge of identity in the face of shifting reality. We can claim that all five texts discuss the issue of identity through the lens of gender, as four of the five have a central female character, while Ecclesiastes relates to women in a complex way and her absence from most of the text emphasizes her lack of presence. In my study, I will ask why the figure of the woman is immanent to the issue of identity.
|
The Holiness Contribution to the Hexateuch in Numbers 20–36 and Deuteronomy 32
Program Unit: Pentateuch (Torah)
Mark A. Awabdy, South Asia Institute of Advanced Christian Studies
Various interpreters have come to conclude that the Holiness scribes (H) who composed Leviticus 17-26 also contributed to the final redaction of the Pentateuch (I. Knohl, E. Otto, P. Tucker, et al.), or supplied the first post-P edition of the Pentateuch and later “logically extended its redactional activity to the entire Pentateuch” (Nihan, “Holiness Code,” 118). Yet others like J. Stackert are more skeptical: “Moreover, neither P nor H should be identified as a pentateuchal redactor” (“Composition,” 177). In this paper, I will argue that in a late edition of the Pentateuch, H contributed Num 20:1-13, 22-29; 27:1-13; 36:1-10; and Deut 32:48-52, all of which would soon be subordinated to the final Pentateuch redaction that honored Moses as Yhwh’s prophet par excellence, whose unrivaled faith, life and instruction (tôrâ) were sufficient without Joshua (for Deut 34:10-12 as PentR: Otto, Achenbach, Römer and Brettler). In Numbers 20-36 and Deuteronomy 32, H makes an important contribution not to the final edition of the Pentateuch, but to the epic of the Hexateuch. These stories are explicitly incomplete without the book of Joshua (contra Albertz, “Pentateuchal Redaction”). In particular, by the standard of Lev. 17-26, Moses fails to regard Yhwh as holy among the people and therefore is cursed with death outside the land, which will nonetheless not thwart Yhwh’s resolve to bring the new generation into the land. Also as a fulfillment of and expansion upon Lev. 17-26, the daughters of Zelophehad, whose father was not among the rebellious (Num 27:3), anticipate their newly promised share in the patrilineal inheritance of the land (Josh 17:3-4). This H layer is distinct from HexR (Deut 34:1*, 7-9; Josh. 24; et al.) and from Num 36:11-12, which I will argue, should be assigned to PentR.
|
“The Good, the Bad, and the Beautiful”: The Diffusion of a Mythologeme in Egyptian and Anatolian literature
Program Unit: Israel in the Ancient Near East (EABS)
Noga Ayali-Darshan, Bar-Ilan University
This paper examines a mythologeme revolving around three principal characters – the (good) Grain-god, the (bad) Sea, and the (beautiful) goddess – that circulated across Anatolia and Egypt during the second half of the second millennium BCE in works such as the Song of the Sea, the Songs of Hedammu and Ullikummi, the Astarte Papyrus and - in some ways - the Tale of the Two Brothers. The presence of features incommensurate with the local culture and setting in both the Egyptian and Anatolian texts indicates that the mythologeme originated elsewhere. Following an analysis of the text’s primary elements, I suggest its place of origin, exploring its diffusion to and reception in Egypt and Anatolia. In conclusion, I discuss the way in which it may have further developed during the first millennium along the Syrian coastline.
|
Reading the Parables as Semitic Meshalim: Reviewing and Applying Tarazi’s Approach to Parables in the Synoptic Gospels
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Daniel Ayuch, University of Balamand
Paul Nadim Tarazi has developed since 2003 a particular approach to Biblical narratives as “Edifying Stories”, which the scholar connects with the Hebrew term mashal. In his latest book The Rise of Scripture (2017), he speaks of mashal to present Biblical literature as a response to the Greek Iliad. This concept is strongly linked to his search for a function in the text, since it will allow Tarazi to move with greater ease and plasticity in the winding paths of historical reconstruction as it was imposed by historical-critical exegesis on the OT texts.
This article develops Tarazi’s concept and adapts it for reading the parables in the Synoptic Gospels. By these means, Jesus´ parables regain their original identity and their narratives can be read from a reader-response perspective and in a context of Semitic character. With this approach stories recuperate their function of educating new generations and are rescued from the emptiness of an obsessed objectivity for reconstructing “historical” sayings and recreating the literary transmission of texts.
|
The Institution of the Hasmonean Kingship and the Rise of the "Sons of Zadok" in the DSS
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Vasile Babota, Pontifical Gregorian University, Rome (Italy)
The appearance of the “sons of Zadok” in several DSS (CD; 1QS; 1QSa; 1QSb; 4Q163; 4Q174), has attracted the attention of many scholars. Scholarly attempt to identify the “sons of Zadok” has been made complicated by the appearance of the “sons of Aaron” (1QS; 1QSa), or simply “Aaron” (CD; 1QSb; 4QFlor), in all but one of the above mentioned scrolls. It has been noted that the "sons of Zadok" were inserted in texts where the "sons of Aaron" had already stood. This paper tries to answer why the sectarian authors chose this specific designation, why they inserted it in these specific scrolls, and when they did so. On the methodological level, however, this study does not limit itself to the relevant DSS only. It begins with the Book of Ezekiel (in its both Hebrew and OG [as attested in Pap 967] versions) both because of its several mentions of the “sons of Zadok” and because of its great influence on the ideology of many DSS. This analysis then moves beyond inner priestly relations of the “sons of Zadok” with the “sons of Aaron” as members of the same community (yahad), as most scholars have done heretofore. We propose to look at the “sons of Zadok” in the context of the broader socio-political and religious history of Judea and, in particular, in relation to the institution of the Hasmonean kingship, in particular under Alexander Janneus (103-76 BCE). The results of our analysis have important implications for our understanding of the history of the Commmunity behind these DSS, in particular, and that of the Hasmonean rule, in general. Not the least, this paper will shed some significant light on the history of the priesthood in the period under discussion.
|
The "Sons of Zadok" in the Book of Ezekiel: A Literary, Historical, and Theological Approach
Program Unit: Prophets
Vasile Babota, Pontifical Gregorian University
A number of exegetes of Ezekiel noted that the appellation “sons of Zadok” is a later addition in Ezek 40-48. Nevertheless, these scholars seldom asked themselves why someone would have decided to coin and insert this designation in this so-called Temple vision: four times in the MT and five times in the LXXEzek as attested especially in Pap 967. Furthermore, these scholars have shown only a limited interest in the more recent studies of the Pentateuch, in particular of its P material. Likewise, many specialists of the Pentateuch pay scarce attention to the latest developments in Ezekiel studies, especially with regard to its double literary tradition. As a result, there is no up-to-date discussion on the kind of relationship between the “sons of Zadok” and the “sons of Aaron” in the Pentateuch. Nor is there any recent specific study done on the significance encrypted in the two appellations or their date. On the methodological level this paper starts from an analysis of the ideologies contained in Ezekiel 40-48, namely, its attitude towards the issues of the temple, kingship, and priesthood. These ideologies are then checked against the P material. Consequently, we try to establish the relationship between the two appellations and their date. The results have some far reaching implications. They shed an important light on the shaping of the priestly traditions in the period following the destruction of the first Jerusalem temple. Also, they help us understand better the ongoing priestly debates which concerned some key institutions. Not the least, these results enable us to get a better perception of the formation of the last strata of Ezekiel with a view also on the formation of some P material born out of inner priestly disputes.
|
Demons and Demonized Enemies in Assyrian Royal Narrative Texts
Program Unit: Dispelling Demons: Interpretations of Evil and Exorcism in Ancient Near Eastern, Jewish and Biblical Contexts (EABS)
Johannes Bach, University of Helsinki
The talk takes a look at the occurrences of demons in Assyrian royal narrative texts, and tries to evaluate their role within this genre. Demons are relatively rare encounters in said corpora, and they usually occur only in cursing formulas. They take a more prominent role only in Middle- and Neo-Assyrian epical texts as well as in Sargonid royal inscriptions, culminating in the (in)famous equation of Babylonian citizens with the gallû demon under Sennacherib. While it seems quite probable that demons simply did not have a proper place in the plot structure of pre-Sargonid military reports, there might be some grounds to assume that they were assigned a slightly more important role under Assyria’s last dynasty. As the Sargonids partially broke with traditional textual identity of the Assyrian king and elevated this character onto a more mytho-heroic sphere, it stands to reason that some important enemies were elevated accordingly. Therefore, the talk will also discuss the possibility that the new stylization of the literary representation of the king as being located in a sphere between humans and gods sometimes demanded the enemies to be conquered to be located in a similar domain.
|
When Eschatology Tailors One’s Identity
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Melissa Bach, Københavns Universitet
The aim of this paper is to explore whether there is a shared worldview in The Rule of the Community/1QS, 1QHodayot, and 4QInstruction. More specifically, the paper seeks to examine whether instructions and rules regarding the community in 1QS, the hymns in 1QHodayot, and the hunt for wisdom in 4QInstruction may serve the same purpose. In relation to 1QS and 1QH, scholars have often identified ritual or liturgical elements, while 4QInstruction is usually associated with wisdom literature and regarded as a non-ritual text. However, in this paper, I argue that certain aspects of ritual theory may be fruitfully applied to all three texts. In a Qumran context reading and writing have a ritual aspect. With inspiration from Harvey Whitehouse’s Modes of Religiosity theory, among others, I intend to examine how the selected compositions achieve similar goals by applying different approaches. I will combine transdisciplinary methods of exegesis, ritual theory, and cognitive literary analysis. The results indicate that all three compositions strive to establish and maintain a tailored identity and sense of belonging in their readers. Conclusively, the findings in the present paper suggest that eschatology serves as the primary carrot and stick motivating continued remembrance and observance of directives.
|
Silent Victims in the Hebrew Bible: The Case of Ishmael and Dinah
Program Unit: Deconstructive Poetics (EABS)
Carol Bakhos, University of California-Los Angeles
This presentation will focus on the expulsion of Ishmael and the rape of Dinah in an effort to give voice to the ways in which silence contributes to violence. We will examine the literary parallels between the story of Ishmael and Dinah with an eye toward the notion of expulsion and how each story functions within a larger narrative that gives voice to power and oppression. The paper will largely concern itself with the biblical stories themselves and how they fit into the larger narrative arc of Genesis, but will also seek to problematize the role silence plays in the power dynamics between the biblical characters.
|
Iconography of Enoch: The Case of Ethiopian Tradition
Program Unit: Enoch within and outside the Books of Enoch: Parabiblical Writings, Iconography and Oral Tradition (EABS)
Ewa Balicka-Witakowska, Uppsala University
Taking in consideration the contribution of Ethiopian literary tradition in preservation of the Book of Enoch, recognised by the Ethiopian Church as a canonical script, it is not surprising that also in Ethiopian biblical imagery he occupied an important place. His figure appears in the murals, wood painting and on the pages of manuscripts. Enoch is depicted as a scribe, the “writer of justice,” but also as one of the prophets and a wise man who possessed the secrets of the past and the future. His cosmic journey stimulated the fantasy of the Ethiopian painters who represented him traveling to Heaven as well as visiting Paradise and Hell and witnessing eternal punishment of the sinners and salvation of the righteous.
|
Shear-Yashuv and the "Heads" of Aram and Ephraim: Unveiling Isaiah's Esoteric Symbol
Program Unit: Prophets and Prophecy (EABS)
Csaba Balogh, Protestant Theological Institute of Cluj-Napoca
According to Isa 8:18, the sons of the prophet Isaiah are supposed to function as "signs and portents" in some relation to "Israel" - whatever this latter would mean. The significance of the symbolic name of Isaiah's first mentioned ominous son, Shear-Yashuv, is thought to be fairly plain. The book of Isaiah itself, namely Isa 10:21, short-circuits the exegetical possibilities to a rather straightforward "a remnant will return", restricting the exegete's move with respect to the historical situation around 733 BC within the boundaries of an eventual positive, negative or ambiguous meaning (from a Judaean perspective). In this paper, I take another look at the symbolic name, Shear-Yashuv, placing it in the context of the other metaphors of the highly poetic Isa 7, in the context of Isaiah's other Samaria-related prophecies, and in the context of recent studies on the semiotics of Ancient Near Eastern (mostly Mesopotamian) omen-literature, arguing for the need to substantially revise the established interpretations of the original sense of the name "Shear-Yashuv".
|
The Polluting Enemy in the Sanctuary: An Early History of an Eschatological Motif
Program Unit: Early Christianity (EABS)
Rodrigo Galiza, Andrews University
Bodily purity and impurity as articulated in the Torah shaped the Israelite conception of the body, or self, and the holy community. These ritual categories were used in eschatological speculations in texts like Daniel 8 and 2 Thessalonians 2 in their portrayal of the evil other as the polluting agent of the sanctuary. Jewish groups, during and after the Second Temple period, understood sacred space and the pollution of it differently and, as a consequence, redefined the religious identity of the holy community and the outsider. This paper will show how selected texts from the so-called Old Testament Pseudepigrapha, of the Dead Sea Scrolls and Latin church fathers could have understood these eschatological texts in light of their definition of sacred space and of the polluting body.
|
A Bulla of a Priest from the Temple Mount
Program Unit: Northwest Semitic Epigraphy Related to the Biblical World (EABS)
Gabriel Barkay, Bar Ilan University
The paper will present a Hebrew seal impression on a bulla of a priest, from the Temple Mount excavations, found during our sifting project
|
From Physical Cultic Object to Goddess: Asherah in Canaanite and Israelite Religion
Program Unit: Israel in the Ancient Near East (EABS)
Amitai Baruchi Unna, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
The term asherah occurs, with some phonological variations, in several ancient Near Eastern cultures and languages. Though bearing some different meanings, it always functions in the realm of religion. This situation makes it tempting to find a basic original meaning, from which the other meanings may have derived, either directly or indirectly. It appears, nevertheless, that no satisfying solution for both equivalence and variety was suggested so far. Although most part of the relevant material is time and again collected and discussed, no suggested hypothesis seems to do justice both to the general ancient Near Eastern distribution of the term and to each of its manifestations. In general, it can be said, that most solutions seem to assume that, if the terms are indeed etymologically connected, whatever asherah in Israel might have been, it stemmed from the Canaanite Goddess Asherah. Alternatively, in my paper I will offer a reconstruction of a semantic, cultic, and conceptual development whose main course is from physical cultic object to goddess. As the distribution of the occurrences of asherah seems to suggest Levantine origins, my discussion focuses on the Ugaritic, Israelite, and Canaanite evidence, referring to the rest, i.e. Mesopotamian, Anatolian, Arabian, and possibly Syrian evidence, as various kinds of reflections of the Levantine one. Finally, in order to support the probability of the hypothetical development, I will present some known parallel developments to its reconstructed phases.
|
The Anargyroi (Physician Saints) in Early Christianity and Their Reflections on the Painting Programme of Byzantine Churches in Cappadocia
Program Unit: Medicine in Bible and Talmud (EABS)
Ferda Barut, Anadolu University
In Late Antiquity, healing stories were interwoven with the magic. During the rise of Christianity, a transition took place and numerous narratives and hagiographies of physicians known for their ethic and charity were appeared. Many of them were accepted as Christian saints of healing and called as Anargyroi which means without silver, because their service was free for the people in need of help. During their lives they served as physicians and after their death, the cult centers and hospitals were built in the name of them. They were performing both miraculous healing activities and a physician’s practice both. Most of them were from Anatolia. Besides many others; sisters Hermione and Eutychia, the founders of charitable hospitals in Caesarea Mazaca and in Ephesus; Zenais and Philonilla of Tarsus in Cilicia Pedias; Karpos the Bishop of Thyateira and Papylos the deacon; a team of doctors namely Kosmas, Damianos, Leontios, Anthimos, Eutropios; the most venerated Anargyroi brothers Kosmas and Damianos of Phereman near Kyrrhos; Orestes of Tyana; Stylianos of Paphlagonia, Zotikos the Orphanotrophos; Blasios the bishop; Kaisarios of Arianzos in Cappadocia are just a few of them. As an important center for the Christian communities from the beginning to the Late Byzantine period, Cappadocia churches still have the traces of Anargyroi. The aim of the present paper is to discuss their cult by the way of iconography of the Anargyroi in Byzantine Churches of Cappadocia.
|
Isaiah 53: Peace by Righteous Living, Vicarious Suffering, and Cultic Expiation
Program Unit: Prophets and Prophecy (EABS)
Joanna Bauer, NLA Høgskolen
Commonly, peace in Isaiah 53 is suggested to be achieved by the servant's message causing contrition or faith, or by his suffering being atoning. These suggestions are commonly based on interpreting the servant as a prophet, and on expressions which can be related to cultic expiation of sin, respectively.
Concerning identity, the servant is depicted both as in need of reconciliation, and as righteous, and thus not in need of reconciliation. This contradiction can be resolved by an ambiguous identity of the servant. Isaiah 53 depicts the servant both as the servant Israel, in need of reconciliation, and as a righteous servant, reconciling Israel.
A thorough word study suggests that likewise, achievement of peace is stated ambiguously, both by chastisement and insight, and by transfer of the burden of sin. Further, Isaiah 53 clearly alludes to various means of cultic expiation of sin.
Concerning chastisement and insight, the servant Israel's suffering in exile is "God's chastisement for our peace" (Is 53:5b), which fosters insight into the conduct required by God, and adhering to it. By adhering, the servant is righteous and proves himself righteous, as expressed by one meaning of Is 11a, "By his knowledge, the righteous one, my servant, will prove himself to be righteous to the many."
Concerning transfer of the burden of sin, Isaiah 53 states that the we-group's and the many's burden of sin, that is, the guilt incurred by sin and the punishment for this guilt, is transferred to the righteous servant. His suffering is "God's punishment for our peace" (Is 53:5b). By this transfer, the others are freed from their guilt and thus reconciled.
Concerning cultic expiation of sin, Isaiah 53 alludes to both the Day of Atonement and to guilt offering. However, the servant is not decisively depicted as scapegoat or offering.
|
Intratextual Exegesis in the Primeval History
Program Unit: Methodological Pluralism in the Study of Genesis
Michaela Bauks, Universität Koblenz - Landau
“The term ‚intratextual’ denotes interactions of various layers of Genesis with texts now standing within the same book. ... such fractured intratextuality in the book then becomes a frequent focus on early Jewish intertextual interaction with Genesis.” (D. Carr). Different figures as Adam, Cain, Noah, Enoch encounter in different contexts, which belong originally to different traditions and correspond to different layers (P; non-P) of the Primeval history. The paper examines how some figures become formally and in terms of content capstones of the whole composition with important extensions in the ancient reception history. In several cases the first Jewish interpretations give insight in the reconstruction of the formation of the Primeval history.
|
Was Ezra a Persian or a Yehudite Leader?
Program Unit: Concepts of Leadership in the Hebrew Bible (EABS)
Bob Becking, Universiteit Utrecht
In Ezra 7-10 and in Nehemiah 8, Ezra is cast in the role of a leader of the post-exilic community. His deeds and doings are presented as acts that consolidate the religious and social life of the community around the Jerusalem temple. These superficial observations, however, are not without problems. In my paper, I will discuss three topics: (1) What historical and/or literary connection is there between the figure of Ezra mentioned in Ezra 7-10 and the character of Ezra in Nehemiah 8. Are they one and the same person? Do we meet two different characters? Or something else? (2) How to classify the leadership of Ezra in Weberian categories? Charismatic, traditional, or judicial? (3) Applying the principal-agent theory for political and communal actions the question of Ezra’s loyalty will be explored. The answers to these questions are not prima facie clear.
|
The Difficult Ambiguity: Theology and Translation
Program Unit: Bible Translation Workshop (EABS)
Morten Beckmann, University of Agder
The so-called Colossian hymn (Col 1:15-20) uses several metaphorical depictions of Christ. The poetic quality of these verses often poses a challenge to modern commentators and Bible translators, who try to get hold of the meaning(s) of these poetic descriptions. This challenge is especially prominent in the translation of Col 1:15, which places Christ in an ambiguous relation to creation. Do modern translation theories allow for maintaining the uniqueness of the source text? In order to discuss this question, I will compare the rendering of Col 1:15 in two Bible translations based on two different translation theories and approaches: (1) The 1978-translation by the Norwegian Bible Society, based on the Dynamic Equivalence theory of Eugene Nida, and (2) Bibel 2011 (by the same publisher), based on a literary approach to Bible translation. How were these different theoretical approaches carried out in the actual translation, and how do they affect the poetic nature of the source text in this verse? The renderings of each translation will be evaluated and compared to the source text, and it will be argued that theological bias poses a challenge for the translation of this verse.
|
"Open Thine Eyes, O Lord, and See": A Possible Cultic Rite of Text Presentation
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Dan Belnap, Brigham Young University
According to Isaiah 37, during the Assyrian campaign against Judah, Hezekiah receives a letter from the Assyrian envoy. After receiving and reading it, Hezekiah is then described as going up to the temple whereupon he stretches out (pārash) the letter before God and proceeds to pray. In the prayer, Hezekiah petitions God to open his eyes and see and hear all the words that Sennacherib had sent.
While this brief narrative appears to be unique, the letter itself perhaps presented to God because of its overt criticism of YHWH, comparative evidence as well as at least two possible readings in the psalms suggests that the presentation of text within a cultic setting may have a recognized cultic practice. In Psalm 40:8, the speaker suggests that rather than bring animal sacrifice before the Lord, he will bring a scroll containing his account of his problem before God, while in Psalm 141:2, the petitioner’s prayer is described as being prepared or arranged before the Lord’s face like the daily incense.
This paper will seek to explore the intriguing possibility that a petitioner at the temple may also have presented his or her petition in textual form as well as in oral form, as well the parameters in which this particular form of petition presentation would take place over other forms.
|
Leadership in the World of Memories Evoked by Chronicles in the Context of the Late Persian/Early Hellenistic Period
Program Unit: Concepts of Leadership in the Hebrew Bible (EABS)
Ehud Ben Zvi, University of Alberta
Chronicles, on the surface, seems to be, mainly a book about Davidic kings of the past. In part, this is an expected outcome of strong tendencies in historiographic writing, and of grammars of identification of king and people. This said, close analysis of the book shows that reading Chronicles contributed much to an exploration and reconfiguration of the conceptual realm of leadership in Israel, which included a complex and sophisticated, even if for the most part implied, pragmatic reconceptualization of human monarchy, for the sake of imagining and construing a transtemporal Israel with whom the literati who read this book, within their own setting and their own world of knowledge and social mindscape, identified. This paper will explore through examples, mainly, some aspects of this reconfiguration of the conceptual realm of leadership and the role that memories of particular events and characters play in advancing it.
|
Othering the Alphabet: A New Proposal for the Social Context of the Proto-Sinaitic Writing System’s Invention
Program Unit: Ancient Near East
Nadia Ben-Marzouk, University of California-Los Angeles
Prior investigations into the icons selected for use in the Proto-Sinaitic script have focused largely on the correspondence between specific Egyptian hieroglyphs and the names of these objects in the West Semitic lexicon. More recent suggestions have argued that the images employed in the inscriptions may have reflected the importance of these objects to the Semitic-speaking producers. However, these previous interpretations fail to fully investigate the social context of the world into which the Proto-Sinaitic writing system was born, and thus how the script itself may have functioned for its creators.
This paper will further develop previous suggestions that the new writing system was an Egyptian invention, specifically intended to restrict access to the sacred knowledge of hieroglyphic writing. By combining archaeological, iconographic, and textual data with theories on situated learning and language ideology, it will be argued that some of the icons selected for the new Proto-Sinaitic script were part of a stock cultural repertoire Egyptians employed to depict Asiatics. By incorporating these culturally charged icons into the new writing system, it therefore reflected the Egyptian's purposeful attempt to mark the script as non-Egyptian in its use during the early second millennium BCE, essentially “othering” the alphabet.
|
The Beginning and the End of the Latter Prophets: Isaiah 1 and Malachi; Textual Contacts
Program Unit: Relationship between the "Major Prophets" and the "Scroll of the Minor Prophets": text, methodology, hermeneutics and Wirkungsgeschichte (EABS)
Guido Benzi, Pontifical Salesian University
The Jewish collection of the Latter Prophets presents, from a canonical point of view, multiple contacts between the individual texts. Above all, the relationship between the beginning of the Book of Isaiah (Is 1) and the Scroll of the Twelve Prophets is interesting. Isaiah 1 and Hosea 1-3 present many points of contact that have been studied, both in terms of incipit and words and images recurring. Also Isaiah 1 and Malachi (the beginning and the end of the Latter Prophets) have multiple points of contact. In particular, the image (and the lexicon) concerning the father (or mother) and children relationship that appears both in Isaiah 1 (Is 1,2) and at the beginning and at the end of the prophet Malachi (Ml 1,6; 3,17-24). The same image also appears in the final chapters of Isaiah (Is 63.8; 65.20; 66.8.20). This is evidently a structuring clue to the entire collection of Latter Prophets. Other contacts between Isaiah 1 and Malachi are the reference to the lexicon of worship (Is 1,10-15; Ml 1,6-14 and Ml 2,13); the reference to the lexicon of the devastation of the earth (Is 1,7; Mal 1,2); the image of the "fruits of the earth" (Is 1,19; Ml 3,11) and finally the reference to conversion (Is 1,25.26.27; Mal 1,4; 2,6; 3,7; 3,18; 3.24).
|
City and Hinterland: The Implicit City in Deuteronomy
Program Unit: The Core of Deuteronomy and Its World (EABS)
Kåre Berge, NLA University College
In the idea of “All Israel” in Deuteronomy, there is an implied city and the countryside. The issue of this paper is to understand the relationship between these two entities in this biblical book. Normally the one responsible for the unifying structure of a kingdom is the king. He is also responsible for the maintenance of the central temple. In Deuteronomy, there is a king, but kingship ideology, in terms of the king’s functions, is absent. The land is presented as a “paradeisos,” but it is not the paradeisos of the king. The central questions in this paper are: How did kingship ideology create an (elite) ideological unity of city and countryside in Mesopotamia? How does kingship ideology without a king contribute to the idea of a unified city-countryside entity called Israel?
The main point of interest is that subsistence production for the city affects not only logistics but also control of local customs and habits.
The text presents villages and towns as residential areas of the Israelites, and there are instructions related to these. It is also in these towns that one finds people who will lead the people astray, and they will be persecuted and killed there. However, the regulations are a unified system. The local practices are unified. Military actions are unified, so also the local judicial system, which is under control of the central authority. So, we get the impression that there is a concern for the towns and villages, but it is from the point of view of the city.
|
The Subversive Poetic Function of the "Fantastic" in the Exodus Narrative.
Program Unit: Deconstructive Poetics (EABS)
Kåre Berge, NLA University College
This paper explores the ‘subversive’ poetic function of ‘the fantastic’ in the Exodus narrative, to which also Laura Feldt refers in her seminal work (The Fantastic in Religious Narrative from Exodus to Elisha). However, instead of defining the function of the fantastic in narrative in part through the notion of cultural memory (Assmann), which tends to focus the formative and constructive work of narratives, this paper combines notions of ‘the uncanny’ in psychoanalytical poetics with a specific form of pedagogical theory, which argues that our subject-ness is always contested and interrupted.
Feldt contends that the narrator is the only speaker who is never disoriented. However, even at the level of narration, narrator and narratees, there are confusion and disorientation. The narrator does not explain how the ha-Elohim, Elohim, Mal’ak YHWH, and YHWH, relate in Ex 3:1-5. The ‘name-formula’ in v. 14 is left unexplained, and so is also YHWH’s sudden appearance as the violent killer-god in 4:24-26, etc. To my mind, this begs for an explanation different from Assmann’s ‘cultural memory’.
I agree that the purpose of the Exodus narrative is to express identity. However, while most models of identity-formation and education regard ‘identity’ as an external notion to be inculcated, the model I apply regards it as an internal phenomenon, closely connected with ‘subjectivation’, but also disruption and disturbance. Instead of seeing narrative of identity formation as something that creates norms (‘identity’), this study regards social structures and norms as pre-given ‘in’ the identifying ‘I/We’, in part as the unconscious and uncanny. The narrational attempt to create or explicate an ‘Israelite’ identity in Exodus redirects attention to these constitutive features by making them strange, unfamiliar and ‘new’. All this indicates that ‘identity-formation’ should be replaced by ‘the conditions of being subject’ as a perspective to explore the Exodus story.
|
How “Valentinian” Was Heracleon’s Reading of the Healing of the Son of a Royal Official?
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Carl Johan Berglund, Uppsala University
The interpretation of John 4:46–53 by the “Valentinian” disciple Heracleon (second century CE) is usually thought to reveal his sectarian belief in a lower creation god—the demiurge—and that human salvation is determined by their inherent nature as either spiritual (πνευματικοί), intellectual (ψυχικοί), or earthly (χοϊκοί). However, closer scrutiny of how this material is presented in the only available source, the Commentary on the Gospel of John by Origen of Alexandria (ca. 185–254 CE), reveals that references to such beliefs are not presented as actually written by Heracleon, but inferred by Origen on the basis of his reasoning. This paper will discern quotations and summaries from Origen’s interpretative paraphrases, and argues that Heracleon’s reflections on the healing of the son of a royal official discuss the historical referents of the narrative and the salvation of Jews and pagans—concerns that fit as well within a mainstream Christian community as within a sectarian one.
|
Food as Divine Reward
Program Unit: Anthropology and the Bible (EABS)
Claudia D. Bergmann, Universität Erfurt
In the Books of Isaiah and Ezekiel, the exile can be equated with the experience of hunger. Subsequently, the return from exile and the return to God can be equated with physical satisfaction and gustatory pleasures. This paper will explore the theme of God's ability to remove or withhold food for the demise (and sometimes the benefit) of humanity in connection with human personal and communal decision making in the Hebrew Bible. It will ask whether this divine trait, as it was understood by the authors of biblical texts, also had an impact on early Jewish ideas about the meal in the World to Come.
|
On How to Distinguish between Foreground/Mainline and Background/Offline in Biblical Hebrew Narrative Discourse
Program Unit: Intersections: A Forum for Research on Ancient Israel, Hebrew Bible, and Cognate Topics (EABS)
Ulf Bergström, Uppsala Universitet
One of the thorniest problems in the text-linguistic study of narratives in the Hebrew Bible is to decide which parts of the discourse constitute respectively “foreground” (alternatively “main line”, “backbone”, etc.) and “background” (or off-line, etc.) material.
Generally, the trend has been to associate foreground with wayyiqtol-clauses and background with all other types of clauses, including qatal-clauses, but opinions differ widely. Thus, whereas some scholars describe the aforementioned division of labour between the different clause-types more or less as a rule without exceptions, others hold that not only wayyiqtol-clauses but also some qatal-clauses belong to the foreground. Others still dismiss the correlation between wayyiqtol and foreground altogether. It has been rightly argued that this bewildering situation has arisen because the term “foreground” has come to designate quite distinct phenomena.
Eschewing, therefore, the term “foreground” in favour of “mainline”, this paper proposes that the mainline of narrative discourse consists of clauses that represent a particular type of course of events, here called “the episodic course of events”. According to the proposed analysis, the majority of the wayyiqtol-clauses of a narrative tend to belong to the mainline, but so do also various types of qatal-clauses and sometimes other clause-types as well.
The episodic analysis presented in this paper offers an alternative to the dominant theories in the field, according to which foreground/mainline is defined either by the criterion of thematic importance or temporal succession, or a combination of both.
|
Negative Theology in Pre-socratic Thought
Program Unit: What a God is Not – The Early History of Negative Theology (EABS)
Alberto Bernabé Pajares, Universidad Complutense Madrid
1. The aim of the paper is to review the main testimonies available to
sketch a history of the negative theology in the Pre-Socratic thought.
2. In a first stage philosophers reflect a negative theology in two ways: 1)
attributing to new philosophical principles adjectives that qualified the gods (f. i.
Anaximander qualifies the ἄπειρον as ἀθάνατος and ἀγέρως, adjectives that
characterized prototypically the gods in the epic), as if the new principles should
be considered divine with more legitimacy than the traditional gods; 2)
considering mere natural phenomena that were traditionally considered gods (f.
i. Hipp. Ref 1.7.8 = Anaximenes A 7 DK, on Iris).
3. Xenophanes of Colophon configures an explicit negative theology,
consisting of a critique of the Homeric view that gods behave like human beings
(B 11, 14 DK), by means of an anthropological argument (B 16 DK) and a
reductio ad absurdum (B 15 DK). A positive theology is also attributed to
Xenophanes, but it will be attempted to emphasize that, to a large extent, this is
still a negative theology.
4. The most explicit manifestation of negative theology among the
Presocratics is the commentary of the Derveni Papyrus, whose author interprets
an Orphic theogony as a philosophical cosmogony. He respects the poem and
considers it true because it is from Orpheus, but it transpires that he cannot
accept its literal meaning because it contradicts the fundamental principles of
his philosophical doctrines, especially the denial of γένεcιc. For him there is no
coming to be nor passing away of things nor of gods. According to commentator
(col. 22.1-3) Orpheus practices deliberately the mere designation (ὀνομαίνειν),
according to which Ouranos, Kronos, and Zeus are mere names of the same
god, intelligent air, Νοῦς-ἀήρ.
|
Late Redactional Alignments in the Book of Exodus
Program Unit: Developing Exegetical Methods (EABS)
Christoph Berner, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
The redaction history of the Book of Exodus has been decisively determined by the dynamic interplay between its priestly and non-priestly layers. In a complex process of revisions and counter-revisions, various editors have claimed their prerogative of interpretation by subjecting the earlier text to a new ideological agenda. Since supplementation was the dominant editorial technique, this editorial process has caused several doublets, tensions, and inconsistencies. Only at a very late stage in the literary development of the Book of Exodus, is there evidence of punctual editorial efforts to harmonize conflicting passages and enhance the coherence of the narrative. The paper will address these late redactional alignments by discussing examples from Exod 3-5 and the plague narrative.
|
The Testament of Abraham in a Juridical Manuscript of XVI Century
Program Unit: Slavonic Apocrypha (EABS)
Ivan Biliarsky, Bulgarian Academy of Sciences/Institute of History
There are two apocryphal texts in a miscellany of predominantly juridical and polemical anti-heretical content. The topic of my proposed paper is to explain their inclusion in such a code. I believe it should be sought in the comparison between divine mercy and the human justice.
|
The Exegetical Origins of Belial
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Josiah S Bisbee, Brown University
Lines 13–16 of section C in 4QMMT contain a reduced citation of Deut 30:1–3. In this context, the author of 4QMMT exhorts his readers to put away “the counsel of Belial” (section C, line 29), implying that such counsel would lead them astray from the proper interpretation and practice of the Deuteronomic covenant. This particular character, Belial, appears elsewhere as a prominent figure; so prominent that there is a yearly liturgical re-commitment to the Covenant, which includes multiple acts of cursing Belial and his horde (1QS 1:16–3:11). While the term בְּלִיַּעַל appears twenty-seven times in the Hebrew Bible, it is never presented as the name of an angelic being. The basic meaning of בְּלִיַּעַל is “worthlessness” or “wickedness.” Put simply, the character Belial represents wickedness personified. But what is the origin of בְּלִיַּעַל as a full blown character, who seeks to lead the faithful astray? This paper provides a theory, beginning first with examples of other angelic names in the DSS, as well as examples from Pseudepigraphic, Rabbinic, and Hekhalot literature, that appear to be derived exegetically from rare words in theophonic and netherworld contexts. Section two will argue that the proper name בְּלִיַּעַל was similarly derived from the rare phrase נַחֲלֵי בְלִיַּעַל (“rivers of Belial”), which appears only twice in the Hebrew Bible (Ps 18:5-6 and 2 Sam 22:5-6) and in contexts that also describe the netherworld. Section three will then compare and contrast the characteristics of Belial with Enochic angelology, demonstrating both the similarities, differences and possible influence of such traditions on the development of Belial as a character, ultimately proposing a path toward a diachronic theory that might explain the progressive development of Belial as a mythological being.
|
Ioudaioi Abroad: "Jewish" or "Judean" Migrants?
Program Unit: Construction of Identity in the Ancient World: Intersections and Reflections (EABS)
Josiah S. Bisbee, Brown University
Scholars debate the rendering of Ἰουδαῖος in Johannine literature, noting that some instances seem to require the translation “Judean,” such as John 7:1, where Jesus chooses to remain in Galilee, instead of going to Judea (Ἰουδαίᾳ), for “fear of the Ἰουδαῖοι.” And yet, some instances seem to necessitate something other than “Judean,” especially where ’Ιουδαῖοι are said to reside outside of Judea – the basic argument being that Judeans who do not live in Judea are not Judeans. But this now popular view fails to consider that Judeans may have simply migrated to Galilee and maintained an identity, as well as customs, indicative of their regional origin. By drawing attention to specific archeological data—namely, the manufacture and distribution of stew-pots, pans, stone vessels, and knife pared lamps—this paper will, first, present evidence for the existence of different regional customs in the first century CE. As will be demonstrated, the physical evidence — such as Judean pottery in Galilee, etc.— also indicates that Judeans migrated North. Afterward, both John 2.6 and Revelation 2.9 and 3.9 will be interpreted in light of this information, while drawing attention to other textual data, ultimately arguing that Ἰουδαῖος as “Judean” makes historical sense, even in contexts where Ἰουδαῖοι are described as residing abroad.
|
Drawing on Different Sources: Reexamining the Christian Arabic Translation of the Peshitta
Program Unit: Biblia Arabica: The Bible in Arabic among Jews, Christians, and Muslims
Aurélie Bischofberger, Université de Lausanne
As scholars have pointed out, the Christian Arabic translations considered to be based on the Peshitta present significant deviations from their Vorlage. However, the discussion on the origin of these variants did not reach a consensus. Three main explanations have been advanced: Georg Graf and some other scholars after him attribute the differences between this Arabic textual tradition and the Syriac text to the freedom of the translator, while others consider that the Arabic reflects an earlier stage in the transmission of the Peshitta, and still others (like Arthur Vööbus and especially Juan Pedro Monferrer Sala) suggest that it actually reflects the influence of at least one other textual and exegetical tradition.
As shown in a previous paper (Tel Aviv, 2017), while pointing to an explanation taking into account a combination of these three factors, my preliminary examination of the Christian Arabic manuscript material for Leviticus shows the relevance of this third explanative model. In particular, the comparison with the Septuagint, the Syro-Hexapla, the Masoretic Text, and the Targumim suggests that this translation is influenced by a broad range of influences that cannot be reduced to one tradition.
This paper will provide a preliminary assessment of the main textual influences that can be identified within this Arabic translation for the book of Leviticus and discuss their implications. In doing so, the paper will shed light on two key issues for current scholarship: 1) the strategies used by the Arabic translators; and 2) the broader context of shared textual and exegetical traditions between different communities in the Middle-Ages.
|
Jubilee Legislation in the Holiness Code in Light of the Hana Texts
Program Unit: Ancient Near East
Øyvind Bjøru, University of Texas at Austin
A vexing question in the discussion surrounding the biblical Jubilee legislation is the relation it bears to other Near Eastern practices that are somewhat similar in social or economic function, or are denoted by etymologically related terminology. Opinions are divided on whether the Mesopotamian andurārum/mīšarum and the Biblical yôḇel/šmîṭṭā are historically related phenomena, convergent distillations of socio-economic and religio-cultural concerns, or disconnected and quite disparate customs with only superficial and piebald semblance to each other.
Since the first substantial comparisons were made between the biblical Jubilee and fallow land practices ordained in the Hebrew Bible, and the proclamations or mentions of debt, slave, and land releases in Mesopotamia and Anatolia (Lemche 1979, Weinfeld 1995), new evidence has come to light. I will adduce evidence for andurārum practiced in the Middle Babylonian period in the kingdom of Ḫana, bridging the considerable gap between the Old Babylonian (early 2nd millennium BCE) and Neo-Assyrian (early 1st millennium) societies plaguing earlier attempts to compare practices.
The Ḫana texts will serve as a basis for a reassessment of how mechanisms for social justice and economic readjustment in Mesopotamia and its environs can be brought to bear on the biblical Jubilee legislation, specifically the relevant passages in the Holiness Code, i.e. Leviticus 25 and 27. I claim that despite some fundamental structural differences between the Mesopotamian proclamations and the biblical legislation, the same conceptual distinctions regarding property rights and claims are operative within both institutions suggesting significant confluence, if not influence, or even shared origins.
|
Public Suffering? Affect and the Complaint Psalms as a Form of Private-Political Depression
Program Unit: Emotions and the Biblical World (EABS)
Fiona C. Black, Mount Allison University
This essay takes up Ann Cvetkovich’s idea of depression (Depression: A Public Feeling) not as an interior, individual affliction, but as affect, a public, politically-produced register of feelings in response to various social and economic forces. Her work pursues a cultural analysis of depression “that can adequately represent [it] as a historical category.” The paper investigates whether or not the complaint psalms might be so viewed, particularly as a response to retrospective colonial impulses of the biblical tradition. As such, they obliquely represent themes such as the dissolving body, race (otherness), and violence, bringing these into conversation with the fabricated (?) subject of the individual in distress. What, politically, might these fabrications of feeling represent, and how do the themes mentioned contribute? At the same time, and as Cvetkovich’s work anticipates, there is still the matter of actual feeling and how it is represented in these texts. How might one distinguish between the personal—the subjective archive of feelings—in these works, and the public, socio-political response they might indicate? The essay will explore these ideas in conjunction with a few of the more distressing complaints, such as Pss. 22, 31, and 88.
|
A New Nation at the Hands of "Black Moses"? The Bible and the Bahamian Quest for Independence in the Words of Sir Lynden Pindling
Program Unit: Bible and Empire
Fiona C. Black, Mount Allison University
This paper looks to the reception and influence of the Bible in the emergent postcolonial nation of the Bahamas, under majority rule since 1967 and independent of Great Britain since 1973. Particularly, it is those transitional moments in which I am interested, especially those experienced under the stewardship of Sir Lynden Pindling, the first black Prime Minister of the Bahamas, referred to as “Black Moses.” In what is currently (or still) a very Christian and biblically literate nation, the comparison may not seem surprising. Moreover, perhaps again not unexpectedly, Pindling employs such texts as Ruth and Exodus to embellish his speeches, meant to spur on the nation to independence. And yet, I am curious about the juxtaposition of Moses and the loose liberation theology of Pindling with the nature of the nation that emerged, specifically as it negotiates its present identity as a context that regularly receives strangers (cf Ruth’s “alien”). The paper considers the reception of Pindling’s biblical ideas on Bahamian culture, evidenced in his political speeches, and the juxtaposition of these texts of liberation with tourism and its regulation in the country. The perceived crisis of identity of Bahamian citizens, post-independence, provides the backdrop for this conversation. Indeed, I am curious as to whether the Bible can provide the cure for the identity crisis as well as it was able to provide the texts of freedom from British rule.
|
Characterization of the Service of Injustice: An Exegetical and Theological Analysis of Micah 2:1-5
Program Unit: Prophets and Prophecy (EABS)
Blessing Onoriode Boloje, Ruhr-Universität Bochum, Baptist Theological Seminary, Eku-Nigeria
The struggle over land, power, loss and restoration ignites prophetic oracles represented in three different clusters of prophetic activities in the prophetic Books: eighth century, Babylonian exile, and the return from exile. Socio-economic perspectives regarding developments in the eighth century BCE are seen in the prophetic books of Amos, Hosea, Isaiah, and Micah. Reasonable claims to eighth century prophetic masterpieces imagine and refer to the economic structures and dynamics of their day influenced by Yahweh interpreted events of their era by looking back at crucial experiences of the past. Although it occupies sixth position in the Twelve (MT) and third in the LXX (after Hosea and Amos), Micah is the first in the book of the Twelve to direct criticism against Judah and Jerusalem. Micah 2:1-5 falls within the prophet’s wider judgement oracles addressed to the divided kingdoms of Israel and Judah (Mic. 1:2-3:12). The text appropriately spells out unethical activities and announces divine punishment against the wealthy social elites in Judah. The unethical activities of the addressees consist in coveting the houses and property of their neighbours and adopting oppressive economic policies in blatant violation of the requirement of the social scheme of Yahweh’s torah. Since injustice threatens economic sustainability and the survival of families in the covenant community, this paper shall analyze exegetically and theologically the various characterizations of the service of injustice in Micah 2:1-5 against the background of Yahweh’s torah (Exod 20:17; 34:24; Deut 5:21) and within Judah’s social, economic and theological categories. The various textual and exegetical analyses will provide stimulating insight into the socio-economic character of the oracle unit, in addition to a description of the impending lamentation of the people as a reaction to Yahweh’s judgement, which is obvious evidence of Yahweh’s interaction with a community experiencing his disciplinary pain.
|
Returning to Yahweh and Yahweh’s Return: Aspects of the Theme of Return in the Book of Malachi
Program Unit: Prophets
Blessing Boloje, Ruhr-Universität Bochum, Baptist Theological Seminary, Eku-Nigeria
The Book of Malachi has been acknowledged by scholars as possessing artistic brilliance and merit. Its style is simple and clear, direct and forceful, with little demand upon the imagination of the readers. Several discussions focus on its literary character and historical setting with its classification as a series of disputation. It is evident; however that Malachi’s theological message is highly robust and imaginative than its form-critical readers have proposed. In keeping with long-standing and older prophetic traditions, Malachi constructed a robust theology of the theme of return as an incontrovertible and unifying aspect of the Book of the Twelve. The purpose of this paper is to examine aspects of the theme of return in the Book of Malachi in light of the obvious complementary and inadequate pattern of Judah’s repentance and incomplete restoration. As a people whose history is characterized by covenant failure and refusal to repent, the Book of Malachi present a robust conglomeration of persistent noncompliance and rebellion of the postexilic Judahite community thus making her guilty of unfaithfulness and unworthy of Yahweh’s restoration. At the outset, the paper will examine aspects of the theme of return in the Book of the Twelve and then three seemingly connected aspects namely, return to the right cult, torah compliance and Yahweh’s return in the Book of Malachi. In line with the thematic thread in the Book of the Twelve, what emerges at the end of this paper is that Judah’s hope of spiritual revitalization and complete restoration is her faithful and wholehearted return to the right cult and to Yahweh’s torah.
|
Researching Cultural Objects and Manuscripts in a Small Country: The Finnish Experience of Raising Awareness of Provenance, Legality, and Responsible Stewardship
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Rick Bonnie, University of Helsinki
In late 2016, several researchers from Helsinki's Faculty of Theology and Faculty of Arts got together to set up a project focusing on the role of scholars and other professionals in researching (or not) potentially tainted cultural objects and manuscripts. The project became especially pertinent when the Society of Biblical Literature issued a new policy regarding the study, presentation, and publication of unprovenanced objects. The major aim of this cross-disciplinary project was to kick-start a national debate on this question within Finland and to develop policy recommendations for the study of cultural objects. This paper aims, first of all, to discuss in depth the reasons and importance for setting up this project within Finland. However, Finland is definitely not alone in dealing with the issues of researching unprovenanced objects and manuscripts and thus similar initiatives should be started elsewhere as well. The second aim of this paper is to critically evaluate the achievements of this project and to discuss the problems we are still facing.
|
"Levona" (Frankincense) in the Prophecy Literature
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Rachel Borovsky, Tel Aviv University
'Levona' (frankincense) is one of the oldest known spices in the ancient world. The etymology of the name is related to the white color of the resin or to the white smoke that the combustion produced. Frankincense was a very expensive material imported from the southern Arabian and the Ethiopian regions to the Egyptian and Mesopotamian trade centers along the 'Incense Route' starting from the 18th century BCE. Archaeological evidences of trade routes between southern Arabia and the kingdom of Judah appear in the eighth and seventh centuries BCE in Tel Be'er Sheva and Tel Arad. Evidence of sacrificing frankincense appears on a caption of a stone altar from 'Lachish' in the sixth century BCE and mentions the Aramaic word 'LVNT', i.e., frankincense. 'Lavona' is mentioned 21 times in the Bible, of which 9 times in the priestly literature, 6 times in the Prophecy literature, 3 times in Song of Songs, twice in Nehemiah and once in Chronicles. In most of the sources, 'Levona' is mentioned in ritual contexts. Despite its few appearances in the Bible, 'Lavona' was an important part of worship in ancient Israel. The lecture deals with the questions: What did the authors of the Prophecy literature knew about the use of 'Levona' in ritual and what use did they make with that knowledge? Are the ways of using frankincense in the prophetic literature reminiscent or similar to the way 'Lavona' was used in the priestly literature? What can we learn about the cult in prophetic literature, using the case study of the frankincense? An in-depth analysis of the practice of the use of 'Levona' in ritual in prophetic literature can serve as a window for further understanding of the cult in ancient Israel, its reference to different genres and its development under different historical circumstances.
|
Conflicting Roles of Leadership in the Temple Building Account of Ezr 1-6
Program Unit: Concepts of Leadership in the Hebrew Bible (EABS)
Anna Maria Bortz, Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz
A first glimpse at the opening chapters of the Book of Ezra already discloses the many different authorities that play a part in the restoration of the community and the construction of the Second Temple in Judah after the exile. There are Kyros and Sheshbazzar, Darius, Zerubbabel and Jeshua, the anonymous "Tirshata", the heads of the fathers' houses and the elders. In Ezr 1-6 leadership is tied to the rebuilding of the destroyed temple. Yet it is not really clear who actually is in charge of the temple (re)construction. Who is the builder? Who lays the temple foundations (Sheshbazzar: Ezr 5:16; Zerubbabel and Jeshua: Ezr 3:8; 5:2; or the anonymous building personnel: Ezr 3:9f)? Which role do the Persian kings Kyros and Darius play? Which role the triad of priests, Levites, and the people? And how does the alleged governor respectively the prince of Judah (Ezr 1:8) fit into this? At the same time, the lines between religious and political leadership seem to blur.
In Ezr 1-6 we are presented with an amalgamation of different voices borrowing from different biblical concepts and traditions such as Deutero-Isaiah and Hag-Zech. This paper attempts to shed some light on the nature and function of the multiple restoration traditions that have been integrated into this temple building account.
|
The List of Returnees in Ezr 2 and the Homeric Catalogue of Ships: The Importance of Lists for the Construction of Identity
Program Unit: Construction of Identity in the Ancient World: Intersections and Reflections (EABS)
Anna Maria Bortz, Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz
In literature, lists often seem as the roughest and most boring material and therefore have a tendency to be skipped over. Yet, they are crucial elements not only in the literature of the Old Testament but also in ancient heroic poetry like the Homeric epics.
Embedded into an epic or national myth they do not only serve as moments of retardation but they can function as important vehicles for the construction of identity, as can be shown by looking at the list of returnees in Ezr 2 and the Catalogue of Ships in Hom., Ill., II.
Ezra is a story about the return and restoration of the "true Israel" after the Exile. Those who appear among the returnees in Ezr 2 were part of the Second Exodus and in the course of the narrative form a holy temple community that distinguishes itself from all the other foreign people in and around Jerusalem and Judah. The list of returnees therefore serves as a marker of identity and legitimacy. Only those that had part in the return can be considered members of the "true Israel". Similarly in the Catalogue of Ships, only those areas whose ships were named among the ones beleaguering Troy can be considered part of the Panhellenic community.
Both lists incorporated into a narrative of national myth function as self-assertion for those that consider themselves affiliated with the listed groups. Although, both lists evolved out of a completely different context, it can be shown that they are essential parts of the narrative that help constituting collective identity. This paper aims at a comparison of the nature and function of these two lists embedded in their respective myth of "collective ancestry".
|
Being an Aramaean according to Deuteronomy 26:5: Considering Hybridity and Mimicry in Identity Construction in Yehud
Program Unit: Construction of Identity in the Ancient World: Intersections and Reflections (EABS)
Hendrik Bosman, Stellenbosch University
The first textual reference to Aramaeans is found in the Assyrian royal annals of Tiglat-Pileser I (11th century BCE) and it is possible that it also applied to migrants (hybrid communities) in Mesopotamia as early as the 17th century BCE. Amidst close cultural and political associations with ancient Israel, Aramaeans are presented ambiguously in the Hebrew Bible, oscillating between friendly (genealogical links with patriarchal families) and unfriendly (military conflict with the kings of Damascus). From the 7th century BCE Aramaic became the language of commerce, diplomacy and education during the late Assyrian and Neo-Babylonian empires – eventually it became the lingua franca of the Persian Empire and it provided Hebrew its alphabet. Although the reference of being ‘an Aramaean’ can be explained as ‘rooted in the memory of the roughly contemporaneous ethnogenesis and state formation of the Aramaeans and the Israelites (Knauf 2007), this paper will investigate the manner in which postexilic Jewish identity was possibly constructed by establishing Aramaean ancestry, whether ‘perishing’ or ‘wandering’, in manner that would make their future as part of the Persian Empire more bearable (Berlejung 2014). ‘Being Aramaean’ in Deuteronomy 26:5-11, can be interpreted as an example of how Jewish identity construction was influenced by both hybridity and mimicry, as part of strategies of resistance (or opportunism!?) to survive amidst the asymmetrical power relations prevalent in the Persian Empire.
|
The Symbolic Role of the Temple in Representing Yahweh in the First Davidic Psalter
Program Unit: Writings (including Psalms)
Phil J. Botha, University of Pretoria
The first Davidic Psalter (Pss 1-41) contains various references to the temple and to Yahweh’s presence in Zion. As is perhaps to be expected in a context of conflict and deprivation, the temple is often referred to in these psalms as the place from where Yahweh’s help and blessings originate. As earthly representation of Yahweh’s presence, it also serves to symbolize his omniscience and ability to judge wickedness as well as the desire of the worshiper to linger there. The paper will provide an overview of the symbolic role of the temple in these psalms and attempt to draw connecting lines between the symbolic value attached to the temple and the presumed date of composition of this part of the Psalter.
|
Marking Bodies: Ritual and Discipline in Early Christian Discourse
Program Unit: Bodies of Communication (EABS)
Pieter Botha, University of South Africa
Early Christian identity had its formative development in the urban households of the Mediterranean world. In this study of developing Christian values concerning the body — especially the meanings of pain — I look at this unfolding as an ambiguous, fissiparous process rather than a seamless cultural transformation. A scrutiny of domestic worship reveals not only hierarchical social structures, but also how meals, dress, and even greetings become ritualized behaviour, directing attention to control of bodies. These practices were essentially meaning-making behaviours, not only establishing insiders and “othering” non-participants, but establishing normalcy and gendering “meaningful” pain. The Petrine Epistles reveal some aspects of interaction with such domestic religiosity. In these Letters a trajectory of disciplining especially women’s bodies can readily be detected within the late first-century Jesus movement.
|
The Gospel of Mark, Orality Studies, and Performance Criticism: Opening a Window on Events within Early Christianity
Program Unit: Orality and Literacy in Early Christianity (EABS)
Pieter Botha, University of South Africa
More than any other New Testament text the Gospel of Mark has been the subject of orality studies, oral tradition criticism and more recently of performance criticism. Despite this considerable attention a number of significant connections (or intersections) between the various theories and methods concerning oral and textual transmission(s) of Jesus memories and the concomitant proposals of historical performances have yet to be explored. In this “state of the question” contribution, these “interconnected” issues are discussed. Some theoretical and methodological clarifications will be dealt with, as well as how we should deal with the historical data we have at our disposal. The final part of the presentation analyses some noteworthy divergences between various orality studies dealing with Mark, as for instance how certain dramatic devices in Mark's account (e.g. the references to screaming or other such acoustic intrusions), and implicit and explicit oral-textual cues are construed into different performative events and social memories. The possible pragmatic effects of these devices and cues will be contextualised with reference to the anonymity of ancient texts, the implications of ancient education and reading practices and some aspects of ancient performance entertainment.
|
Written in the Stars: Astral Symbolism in the IV Book of the Sibylline Oracles
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
Giorgia Bove, Università degli Studi di Padova
Even though it is not an apocalyptic text tout-court, but a propagandistic manifesto, the IV Book of the Sibylline Oracles threatens its readers with the promise of a catastrophic end by means of fire, as a retribution for the wickedness of mankind. The aim of the present paper is to propose an interpretation for the final warning of impending doom that will be displayed in the form of a sign “with a sword and a trumpet” (vv. 173 – 174). Through the lexical analysis of the text, in fact, it will be argued that this mysterious sign is indeed a double-tailed comet, a symbol whose meaning is intimately intertwined both with upper literature and popular mysticism and may provide with an insight into the library of the Sibyllinist, i.e. the whole set of bookish and non-bookish knowledge that the anonymous author mastered and, therefore, spread throughout the verses of his poetic effort.
|
Patterns (Tupoi) in Athanasius of Alexandria: Their Literary, Exegetical, and Ethical Functions
Program Unit: Biblical Interpretation in Early Christianity
David Brakke, Ohio State University
In his 39th Festal Letter (367) Athanasius of Alexandria (d. 373) introduces his historic lists of the Old and New Testaments with these words: "As I begin to mention these things, in order to commend my audacity, I will employ the pattern (tupos) of Luke the evangelist." In a remarkable display of intertextuality, Athanasius takes on Luke's voice and rewrites the preface to the Third Gospel to refer to his definition of the biblical canon against those who promote apocryphal books. Imitation of exemplars he called "the saints" features prominently in Athanasius's ethical exhortations, but he employs it also as a literary strategy. This paper examines both aspects of this theme and its exegetical implications, focusing on the Festal Letters but drawing also on other works, to explore the complex functions of "patterns" (tupoi) in Athanasian thought. The epistolary Athanasius, like many early Christians, imitates Paul, but, as we have seen, he also fashions himself after Luke in a moment of biblical "audacity." In turn, the bishop encourages his followers to seek virtue by imitating the "way of life" (politeia) of biblical saints and, above all, of Jesus. Christ, he says, provided "the pattern (tupos) of the heavenly politeia." Intriguingly, here Christ functions typologically, in a manner analogous to the events and rituals of the Old Testament, which Athanasius insists were merely "shadows" and "patterns" (tupoi) that should be transcended once the realities to which they refer are present. The historical narrative in which such patterns are embedded may be "marvelous," but it points beyond itself. Luke's and Christ's roles as tupoi suggest, however, the intertextual and multidirectional character of the literary, exegetical, and ethical imitation that Athanasius presents as hierarchical and linear.
|
Trauma on the Road to Emmaus
Program Unit: Psychological Hermeneutics of Biblical Themes and Texts
Susan Brasier, Princeton Theological Seminary
One of the odd post-resurrection accounts concerns the reaction of Cleopas and his companion upon encountering the risen Christ on their walk to Emmaus, as recounted in Luke 24. Despite the lengthy walk and conversation with Jesus, neither of these individuals was able to recognize Jesus. Not until Jesus sat down with them for dinner, “were their eyes opened and they recognized him.” Current research addressing the reaction of witnesses to violent crimes may offer some insight to this Biblical account. If Cleopas of Luke 24:18 is, in fact, the same man as Clopas mentioned in John 19:25 (as has been suggested by scholars), his unnamed companion was, in all likelihood, his wife, Mary. As recounted in John 19:25, “Mary the wife of Clopas” stayed with Mary the mother of Jesus witnessing Jesus’ execution. Studies have established that acute exposure to violence may cause psychological trauma that manifests in symptoms such as confusion and disorientation for up to three months after the incident. Furthermore, witnessing violence may be as traumatic as direct victimization – and this trauma also applies to first responders. Additionally, family members and friends of witnesses may also experience emotional trauma. This paper will pursue a reading of the account of the reactions of Cleopas and his companion in light of current work with witnesses to violence and will demonstrate that their reaction, including being unable to recognize Jesus, is within the parameters of emotional trauma caused by witnessing violence.
|
The Divine Indwelling: Literal and Metaphorical Concepts of God’s Indwelling Presence
Program Unit: Stylistics and the Hebrew Bible
G.G. Braun, post-doctorate fellow, before Northwest University
The divine indwelling emerges as one intertextual theme in the speaker’s doctoral dissertation on the connection between divine presence and human praise (2017). That study inspires the present paper arguing that narratives from both Testaments, which involve both above elements, witness to such connection. The correlation often occurs in the context of divine indwelling expressed through literal and metaphorical concepts. These concepts picture human-divine interaction at the initiation of a new divine dwelling, in the OT God’s new house and in the NT God’s new people: like God’s new house was filled with divine glory-presence prompting praise (1 Kgs 8:10-11; 2 Chr 5:13c-14; 7:1-2), God’s new people was filled with Holy Spirit-presence prompting praise (Acts 2:4; 4:31). The dynamic, tension filled analogy between these literal and non-literal concepts facilitates metaphorical interpretation.
Already the OT background reveals metaphors of divine ‘habitats’: Israel as growing landscape, building or city (Num 24:5-7; Isa 54:1-3; Zech 1:16; 2:1-5.10-13), or God’s presence as expanding eschatological glory (Num 14:21; Hab 2:14; Hag 2:9).
The NT introduces with Jesus’ temple logion (Matt 26:61; Mark 14:58; John 2:19) a metaphorical redefinition of the literal temple concept, which is continued in Acts without Luke using temple metaphors, but various metaphorical verbal concepts: ‘baptized with Holy Spirit’ (Acts 1:5), ‘Holy Spirit poured out’ (2:18.33; 10:45), ‘Holy Spirit falling’ (8:16; 11:15), ‘filled with Holy Spirit’ (2:4; 4:8.31; 9:17; 13:52), the latter suggesting divine indwelling. The ‘metaphorisation process’ peaks in the Pauline letters with building metaphors (1 Cor 3:6.16; 6:19; 2 Cor 5:1; 6:16; Eph 2:21f). Ultimately, the Lord’s presence is considered ‘the temple’ (Rev 21:10-11). Thus, narratives in both Testaments, supported by their background, portray the divine indwelling through literal and metaphorical concepts as glory-infilling and Spirit-infilling in praise context.
|
The Connection between God’s Praise and God’s Presence: A Canonical-Intertextual Study
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
G.G. Braun, postdoctoral fellow, before Northwest University
Is there a connection between God’s people’s praise and God’s presence? This question was addressed in the speaker’s doctoral dissertation (2017) with its key conclusions reflected in the present paper. The central argument of the study is that Scripture testifies to a correlation between divine presence and human praise, at times even reciprocal, yet always in the context of a divine-human covenant relationship. The argument was raised in view of contemporary, popular Christian worship and the corresponding need for further biblical investigation. This represents the background and rationale for this overview. The narratives chosen from both Testaments exemplify the dynamics of divine-human interaction at the beginning of a new period: divine glory-presence and human praise in God’s new house on the one hand, and divine Spirit-presence and human praise in God’s new people on the other. Hence, divine presence is perceived as God’s indwelling glory and God’s indwelling Holy Spirit. And human praise is understood as part of God’s people’s worship in terms of serving God. A canonical-intertextual approach facilitates finding an answer to the above question and meeting the following objectives:
First, to corroborate the hypothesis in texts from the Old Testament: God’s glory filling his new temple prompts his people’s praise (1 Kgs 8 and 2 Chr 5 – 7) and vice versa (2 Chr 5).
Second, to verify the argument in texts from the New Testament: God’s Holy Spirit filling his new people prompts their praise (Acts 2 and Acts 10/11). And also, God’s people’s praise initiates their refilling with Holy Spirit and/or other manifestations of divine presence (Acts 4 and Acts 16).
Third, to offer support for these findings from a biblical theology perspective, which identifies three intertextual themes: the correlation between divine presence and human praise, the divine indwelling, and the divine-human covenant relationship.
|
Animals in Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Law: Tort and Ethical Laws
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Law
Idan Breier, Bar-Ilan University
This paper examines the attitude towards animals in the Hebrew Bible and other ancient Near Eastern legal codes. In the first part of my paper I will compare the tort laws in each system, looking at such issues as stealing, responsibility, shepherds, renters, and stray animals. I will also investigate the various types of damages covered by these laws. In this discussion I will try to reveal the existence of close affinities between the biblical and ancient Near Eastern laws in the area of tort laws pertaining to animals, a clear trend towards deterrence and appropriate compensation for injuries exhibiting itself. In the second section I will analyze biblical ordinances regulating human-animal relations without any parallel in other ancient Near Eastern law codes—the sole exception being the fine imposed for killing outdoor dogs. This evinced a series of statutes belonging to the ethical realm known today as “humane” laws, intended to protect and promote animal welfare. Finally, I will address the question of the origin of the divergence between the two groups of legal codes, demonstrating that this derives from the variant fundamental principles upon which they are based. While the ancient Near Eastern injunctions are attributed to the kings, who are held responsible for their formulation rather than the gods, the biblical legal code is founded on the notion that its statutes were given to Moses by God, Moses then delivering them to the Israelites. The fact that they incorporate torts and ethical principles that encompass the animal as well as human world is a function of God’s status as a merciful and compassionate Creator who is concerned about and takes care of all His creatures. This cardinal principle later found expression in the legal and philosophical thought of the rabbinic Sages and early Christianity.
|
Interaction and Interplay: Methodological Remarks on the Composition and Redaction of the Psalter
Program Unit: Writings (including Psalms)
Johannes Bremer, Ruhr-Universität Bochum
Redaction-critical questions on the formation of the Psalter are based on deductive aspects of intertextuality. The paper first rises methodological questions to witness theological aspects regarding not only single Psalms but also the Psalter as a whole. In which way are questions of theology affected by intertextual text-exegesis? Second, the methodological questions are focused on five theological issues affecting the theology of the Psalter as they were first stated by Frank-Lothar Hossfeld and Erich Zenger: the shift from lament to praise, the difference between Davidic and divine kingship, the role of Zion, the history as it is reflected in the Psalms and the theology of the poor, which will serve as a concrete example. In so doing, the relationship between synchronic and diachronic exegesis is affected essentially. Third, the paper concludes again with questions on methodology. Theological issues, intertextuality, and questions on the redaction criticism do interact. And synchronic as well as diachronic questions do interplay.
|
Spatial Conceptions of "Land" in Gen 12-36
Program Unit: Place, Space, and Identity in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Johannes Bremer, Ruhr-Universität Bochum
The paper focusses on the spatial conception of "land" within the Patriarchs narrative Gen 12-36. What or which kind of spatial concept is reflected in the text? It is promised as oath on the one hand, but there are also pragmatic conceptions on the other hand: to possess land means to have a possibility to subsist. But is this the central aspect? Why are spatial questions so important for the Partriarchs? Why is it so important for Abraham to buy the field for Sarah's burial in Gen 23? What are the effects of the possesssion of land both, for Partiarch's daily life and religious thinking? The paper will further focus on selected texts. A conclusion will reveal the different spatial conceptions and understandings of "land" as they are reflected in Gen 12-36.
|
(In)Fertility and Birth Control in Biblical Literature, Revisited
Program Unit: Contextual Interpretation of the Bible (Hebrew Bible/Old Testament and New Testament)
Athalya Brenner-Idan, Universiteit van Amsterdam
Does the bible forbid birth control and abortion? Hard to say; it is not forbidden explicitly. Female fertility is a crucial yet sensitive issue in the bible, as witnessed by the several stories of woman figures allegedly desperate for sons (Sarah, Rachel, Hannah and Samson's nameless mother, for example). Infertility is seldom if at all assumed of males, and natural maternal feelings are attributed to females, even though their ambition is extended to having sons, not daughters. The bible pretends to contain no direct information about birth control or pregnancy termination, even though knowledge of those is available on the space (other ANE groups in neighboring lands) and time (during biblical times and beyond, also in Judaism itself) axes. A possible exception is a list of so-called Aromatics in Song of Songs 4. In this paper I shall return to this still culturally explosive topic, building upon what I've written about it in my book, The Intercourse of Knowledge, in order to re-examine the documented passages and to weigh on the question: Is proactive (birth control) and reactive (abortion) regulation of female fertility implicitly prohibited? If so, why? And finally, should the concerns embedded in the biblical stories still be considered valid for contemporary cultures?
|
Representing Representation: A Postmodern Reading of the Apocalypse of John
Program Unit: Deconstructive Poetics (EABS)
Clarissa Breu, Universität Wien
The Apocalypse of John can be described as a testimonial. Read from a deconstructive point of view, it appears as a testimonial that represents itself as a text instead of being presented by an exterior author. It represents itself as representing something, the testimony of Jesus, although the content of this representation is absent. This paper compares mechanisms of representation in the Apocalypse to mechanisms of representation in the painting of two pipes ("Les deux Mystères") by René Magritte. It aims at showing that both, text and painting, point to a representation within a representation, not to something outside text or painting. It thus problematizes the possibility to write about transcendent realities that remain ungraspable even if they are represented in a text.
|
Contextual Reading of Psalm 45:10 and the Question of Interfaith Marriages in Biblical Times and in the State of Israel
Program Unit: Contextual Interpretation of the Bible (Hebrew Bible/Old Testament and New Testament)
Ora Brison, Tel Aviv University
“Listen, O daughter, Consider and incline your ear;
Forget your own people also, and your father’s house” (Psalms 45:10)
In psalm 45:10-15, the Psalter advises the foreign royal bride marrying the King of Israel to forget her family and people and to adopt new loyalties. Although this directive does not exactly say that she is also expected to follow her husband’s faith— this is in the subtext. The seemingly soft command raises one of the significant religious-social biblical issues — the issue of interfaith marriages.
In this paper I would like to show that the phenomenon of religious separatism is characterized by opposition to marriages between in and out ethno-religious groups. This phenomenon is not restricted to ancient times, but still exists, currently, in Jewish Israeli society in the modern state of Israel and is a highly volatile subject. Thus demonstrating, that Israelite/Judean societies of the biblical era, as well as Jewish communities during the times that have passed since have been struggling with the question of exogamic marriages throughout the history of the Jewish people.
The examples presented in this paper express the diversity of viewpoints and dialectic attitudes concerning interfaith marriages from biblical times to the present-day Israel. These viewpoints varies from total opposition in (Deut 7:1-5; Ez 9); acceptance in (Ex 2:21; 2 Sam 3:3) and even blessing in (Ruth 4:11-12).These are compared to the complexities of modern day Israel (of the 21st century) where there is no distinct separation between state and religion.
|
Orality and the Emergent Nature of Human Discourse
Program Unit: Orality and Literacy in Early Christianity (EABS)
Edwin K. Broadhead, Berea College
I will argue that orality is not simply a utilitarian stage or alternative media in the development of the gospels. Orality is itself an emergent, generative competence, and it participates—as a component, catalyst, and canvas—within the emergent processes of human discourse that shape the use and the identity of early Christian traditions. In the paper I will address the following areas: a) orality as a functional component or an alternate mode of literary development, b) formalism and narrative dissonance, c) mouvance as a narrative trait and literary norm, d) the emergent quality of literature, e) Orality and the Phenomenology of Emergent Meaning, f) the emergent quality of human existence: gene and neuron, and finally g) The Gospel of Mark within the gravitational field of human discourse.
|
Courage, Betrayal, and the Roman State: Persons Enslaved to Christians in the Persecution at Lyons (177 CE)
Program Unit: Early Christianity (EABS)
Bernadette Brooten, Brandeis University
In this paper, I will argue that enslaved identity is central to the Letter of the Churches of Vienne and Lyons (Eusebios, Church History 5). The persecuted are either enslaved or free Christians, while their betrayers are enslaved to Christians, but maintain their own religious identities. I will further argue that the Roman governor is presented as abiding by Roman criminal procedure with respect to free persons, but as breaching it by accepting testimony from the enslaved non-Christians without their being interrogated under torture.
The Letter presents Blandina as subverting Roman slave-holding assumptions about persons with an enslaved identity, namely that they are weak in character and, as susceptible to torture, without honor. Far from representing Blandina as a victim, the authors of the Letter, imbue her prayers while hanging on a pole with Christological significance. They depict her as a kind of Christa-figure, as a woman in whom Christ crucified is made manifest to others. Accordingly, Blandina is an owner’s best possible enslaved laborer, one who shares her mistress’s religion and stands by it until the very end.
This contrasts sharply with the Christians’ enslaved betrayers. “Certain of our gentile slaves” enter the stage of the bloody drama as “also arrested.” Had they not betrayed their Christian owners, they may not have been mentioned at all. Terrified, they observe the tortures suffered by their Christian mistresses and masters, whom they betray even without being tortured. The Christians apparently expect that these enslaved gentiles should offer their own necks on behalf of their masters and mistresses, which aligns with what other slaveholders expected. The Roman officials believe them, even though they speak freely and not under torture. This reliance on testimony from these enslaved persons belonging to Christians constitutes a breach of Roman criminal procedure.
|
Between Joshua and Jamestown: Identity and Interpretation in King James England
Program Unit: Biblical Reception History and Authority in the Middle Ages and Beyond (EABS)
Ken Brown, Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz
The interpretation of the Bible, like the interpretation of all texts, cannot be separated from questions of perceived and projected (social) identity. How we read is fundamentally shaped by who we perceive “ourselves” to be, and how we distinguish between “us” and “them” (“others,” or “the Other”). To demonstrate this link between interpretation and identity, this paper will explore one particular example: the diverse interpretations of Joshua employed by early 17th-century English preachers defending the Jamestown settlement and the Virginia colony. It will be shown that these authors nearly always identify their own society with the ancient Israelites in their readings of Joshua, and often also identify the native “Virginians” with the Canaanites, yet this does not always lead to the conclusions one might expect. In fact, a range of mutually conflicting interpretations and identifications are evident in this literature, some of which construct an unbridgeable chasm between the English and the natives, but others of which seek instead to bridge the division between them. Interpretation and identity are in all cases deeply intertwined, but the relations between them are dynamic and variable.
|
In Search of the “Earliest Recoverable Text” of the Tabernacle Chapters: Retention of the Vorlage of the LXX in MT Exodus 25–40
Program Unit: Textual Criticism: Manuscripts & Methods
B. E. Bruning, University of Notre Dame
MT Exodus 35–40 frequently repeats verbatim from instructions for the Tabernacle in Exodus 25–31. Where parallel command and execution passages diverge in MT, excess details agree with otherwise shorter LXX: an ancient editor preserved even small details of the Hebrew underlying both the LXX translation and MT while drawing heavily from the more complete descriptions in the corresponding instructions of 25–31. This paper applies examples of the ancient editor’s retention of LXX Vorlage to the attempt to establish “the earliest recoverable form of the text” of Exodus for the new edition, The Hebrew Bible: A Critical Edition (HBCE).
|
The Law in the Flesh: Reading Rom 6-8 in Light of the Cradle Argument in Hellenistic Philosophy
Program Unit: Bodies of Communication (EABS)
Gitte Buch-Hansen, Københavns Universitet
In Cicero’s De finibus we are introduced to the Epicureans’ cradle-argument, by the aid of which they ‘naturalized’ their philosophy of pleasure with a reference to the newborn child’s reactions. In the cradle, it was possible to observe the most basic impulses guiding human behavior, the pursuit of pleasure and the shunning of pain. In his idiosyncratic, allegorical exegesis of the Fall in De opificio, Philo simultaneously manages to inscribe this tradition into the Bible and to explain the origin of the Epicurean pleasure drive. If impregnation were to be successful, pleasure had, according to ancient obstetrics, to be involved, and, in the act, so Philo explains, this pleasure was transposed to the fetus. Consequently, every person begotten in the ordinary way was from the very beginning abandoned to desire. The only way to get rid of this flesh-bound impulse was through death when the soul was separated from the body. Circumcision was, according to Philo, a symbolic reminder that the innate pursuit of pleasure had to be brought under control – or ‘cut off’. In this paper, I argue that Paul’s metaphorical play with death and life in his argument in Rom 6 represents his take on this phenomenon of concupiscentia, which a later generation coined ‘original sin’. According to Paul, neither circumcision nor the law offers the human being much help. Instead, the reception of Christ’s spirit in baptism anticipates the salvific moment of transition from death to eternal life. A process of recreation – Paul calls it new creation – which enables the vindication of the desirous, sinful will of the flesh now begins. Rom 7 is a midrashic prosopopoiia retelling the story about fallen humanity from Adam until the coming of Christ. Rom 8 unfolds the effects of the Christ-event on the pleasure-driven desire.
|
An Encounter That Changed the World: Jesus and the Syrophoenician Woman
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Gitte Buch-Hansen, Københavns Universitet
The call focuses on change in Mark and comes up with some inspiring examples, but without mentioning the most significant change in the Gospel. In his response to the Syrophoenician woman’s chain of reasoning, Jesus admits that his ignorance of the Gentiles until the Jews have had their fill was wrong. As the woman had argued: God’s Kingdom holds space for both groups. The significance of this change of attitude is often underestimated. Because of Jesus’ previous visit to the eastern lakeside and his healing of the (presumed) Gentile demoniac, most readings take for granted that Jesus’ involvement with Gentiles happened at his own initiative. However, this reading disturbs the plotline: why does Jesus, with reference to Jewish priority, refuse to heal the woman’s daughter, when the healing of the Gerasene demoniac caused him no trouble? Recent postcolonial readings have managed to solve the problem: with reference to Josephus’ description of the massacre on the Jewish population of Gerasa by Vesparian’s troops (JW 9.1), the Gentile identity of the demoniac is questioned. Consequently, it was the Syrophoenician woman who pushed Jesus back to the apparently ethnically mixed area of Decapolis to feed and heal Gentiles. The woman demonstrated to him that the mandate he once accepted differed from his first impression: because the Gentiles are invited into God’s Kingdom, the cultic separation of Jews from Gentiles is unacceptable. Therefore, the Jerusalem temple must disappear. Until this change, the Markan Jesus showed no interest in travelling to Jerusalem. But now he becomes aware that the goal of his mission may involve his suffering and death. Yet in the Gethsemane, he falter in front of the task. Thus, from a narrative point of view, the interlude between the Syrophoenician woman and Jesus constitutes the Gospel’s point of no return.
|
Advocating the Voices of Hope in the Deuteronomistic History
Program Unit: Postcolonial Studies
Wungtei Buchem, University of Sheffield
In the literature offering theological interpretations of the Deuteronomistic History (DH), one kind of redactional theme/viewpoint has developed a monopoly, which is, the interpretation that relates to doom, catastrophe, sin and monarchy. Such viewpoint is espoused by Martin Noth (1943) and Frank M. Cross (1973). However, such reading conceals the voices of the marginalized people within these texts. In turn, messages in the DH on the theme of hope are rendered lost to the marginalized readers of those texts. Therefore, there is a need to re-locate the voices of these marginalized people in the texts and use these voices as tools to counter-read the dominant viewpoints in the study of the DH. The voices in the text can be the framework by which a hermeneutical paradigm can be established. In doing so, I will incorporate a comparative reading of the texts considered by Gerhard von Rad (1975) and Hans Walter Wolff (2000). I will show how elements of hope are enclosed in the texts to argue that there can be multiple perspectives of reading DH and not only from the perspective established by the Nothian school. Hence, the reading will propose Deuteronomistic hope hypothesis as a framework to a post-colonial liberative reading. My arguments will attempt to respond to the questions that will challenge the dominantly held assumptions: If doom and catastrophe, sin and condemnation, and privileging Davidic hierarchy are the themes of the DH, will such themes/theology serve the marginalized readers? Is there a possibility of reading the DH texts from the perspective of hope and liberation for the marginalized? Wungtei Buchem (Mr) PhD Candidate University of Sheffield, UK.
|
“I’m a God,” “I Made the Nile”: The Pride of Tyre and Egypt in Ezekiel 28-32
Program Unit: Prophecy and Foreign Nations (EABS)
Micaël Bürki, Université de Lausanne
In the book of Ezekiel, the accusation of pride is targeted at the Prince of Tyre, Pharaoh and Egypt. The same accusation is pronounced against most of the kings and nations mentioned in the biblical Oracles Against the Nations, from Isaiah to Zechariah. This implies the same pattern was transmitted at least over four centuries, likely with an evolution in its meaning and formulation.
This paper aims firstly to situate the accusation of pride against the enemy in its Near Eastern context. Secondly, it compares the accusation pronounced against Tyre and Egypt in Ezekiel to the occurrences of the pride motif in other biblical prophetic books, highlighting the specificity of Ezekiel’s concept of pride.
|
Self-Begotten, Not Equal: The Pre-existence of Christ and the Elect in the Apocryphon of John
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Dylan M. Burns, Freie Universität Berlin
Although it is one of the best-known and certainly best-attested Gnostic texts, the Apocryphon of John remains an obscure and difficult work, not least with respect to its theology of the pre-existent Christ. This paper will therefore examine what evidence we have in the text regarding the Son or Christ-aeon. In all four extant versions of Ap. John, the Son is a majestic, terribly divine, pre-existent being. Yet the two scenes in which he appears both present numerous textual and interpretative difficulties, where scholars remain at loggerheads as to what on earth is happening in the text: first, the appearance of the revelator-savior as a sort of polymorphic hologram to John, in the frame narrative; second, the birth and chrism of the Son-Christ, in the text’s theogony. Moreover, we will consider the characterization of the Son as subordinate and begotten — like the elect — with respect not to 'Gnostic' theology, but Trinitarian speculations of the first centuries CE and their attendant development of metaphors of divine Sonhood, especially the Arian Controversy.
|
The Reception of Enochic Traditions in Gnostic Literature
Program Unit: Enoch within and outside the Books of Enoch: Parabiblical Writings, Iconography and Oral Tradition (EABS)
Dylan M. Burns, Freie Universität Berlin
Scholarship on the reception of the figure of Enoch and literary traditions associated with his name in early Christianity and late antiquity more widely have found this reception to be relatively muted in the case of Gnostic literature, particularly the corpus of Coptic works discovered near Nag Hammadi, Egypt, in late 1945. While it is true that the name Enoch surfaces only rarely, Enochic traditions play a much bigger role in Gnostic sources than is widely recognized. The present contribution will therefore discuss recent scholarship that highlights hitherto unnoticed or obscure echoes of Enochic traditions in our evidence concerning ancient Gnosticism, focusing particularly on the Nag Hammadi texts themselves—not only the relatively well-known cases of the Apocryphon of John or the Asclepius, but Zostrianos, the Hypostasis of the Archons, the Paraphrase of Shem, and others. The paper will conclude with a hypothesis regarding why some Enochic traditions proved more influential amongst the writers of Gnostic literature than did others.
|
“You Have Bestowed Your Glory upon the Heavens”: A Re-reading of Psalm 8:1b
Program Unit: Writings (including Psalms)
Marilyn Burton, University of Edinburgh
The opening verses of the eighth Psalm have long been recognised an exegetical puzzle. Textual issues regarding the explanation of the verb form תנה (1b) and questions concerning the relation of the “babes and infants” (2a) to the preceding and following clauses have defied consensus as to the verses’ meaning. In particular, the phrase אשׁר תנה הודך על־השׁמים has been translated in numerous ways, from “You have set your glory in/above the heavens” (NIV, ESV respectively) to “Thou whose glory above the heavens is chanted” (RSV).
This paper proposes an entirely new interpretation of verse 1b, taking into account linguistic evidence from both the Hebrew Bible and Ben Sira, as well as from the ancient versions. It is suggested that the phrase נתן הוד על is in fact idiomatic in Classical Hebrew, and concerns rather the transfer of authority to a chosen representative, which results in a novel perspective on the relation between God and the heavens in this verse. The second part of the paper will seek to support this reading theologically through discussion of the heavens’ role as God’s witness in the Hebrew Bible.
|
Recited History and Social Memory in the Ancient Mediterranean
Program Unit: Intersections: A Forum for Research on Ancient Israel, Hebrew Bible, and Cognate Topics (EABS)
Aubrey Buster, Emory University
The communal practice of reciting Israel’s history is an important component of public speech as represented throughout the Hebrew Bible. The “great histories” of ancient Israel (Pentateuch, DtrH,CHR), are masterful feats of history-writing, but likely would have been inaccessible to all but a select few. It is in the poetic summaries of these texts (e.g. Neh 9:6-37; Pss 78, 105, 106, 135, 136.) that we see the creation of a “functional” memory for the developing nation of Israel, a crucial piece in the dissemination and solidification of a basic level of cultural literacy. This phenomenon, of the creation of long textual histories existing alongside popular abbreviated versions also appears in the Athenian context. In this paper, I argue the case for the relevance of the comparative use of abbreviated histories in the ancient Mediterranean. In Classical Athens, the public funeral provided the occasion for an oral recitation of the city’s history from its beginning to the present. This was recited, year after year, by an appointed speaker, was highly formalized and typically repeated the same catalogue of deeds. The public recital of Athenian history also provided a communal event in which a shared image of the past was created and reinforced. So too, in these ceremonies we witness not only the creation of shared knowledge, but a mandated disposition towards this cultural knowledge. Therefore, the Athenian material offers an unexplored corollary to the Hebrew Bible. We witness in both contexts, the development of a minimal, shared historical vocabulary, which begins to be replicated in representations of oral speeches in both contexts. What this suggests is a significant role for the performance of historical schemas in creating shared historical knowledge, and the potential development of suggestive models for the interaction of oral and textual contexts for creating and sustaining social memory.
|
Narrative Identity and the Nehemiah Memoir: Nehemiah’s Resilient but Lonely Road
Program Unit: Writings (including Psalms)
Paul Byun, University of Sydney
With deep roots in psychology, yet vigorously researched in interdisciplinary studies, narrative identity theory postulates that individuals form an identity through the integration of an internalized and evolving life story. In more recent studies on narrative identity, many have paid a great deal of attention to the well-being of an individual through two distinct means: (1) the individual’s ability to adopt new viewpoints and (2) their level of interpersonal relationships. In the first-person stories within the book of Nehemiah (widely known as the Nehemiah Memoir), Nehemiah tells of his own actions and statements which are at best, to the reader, troubling. For example, statements such as, “I told no one what my God had put into my heart to do for Jerusalem” (Neh. 2:11), and “I contended with them and cursed them and beat some of them and pulled out their hair” (Neh. 13:25). Although troubling, they are indicators in the narrative identity theory of an individual’s well-being. In this paper, I adapt the narrative identity theory to cast a helpful light on what the Nehemiah Memoir was saying, but also what effect on the readers the memoir (through the protagonist) was trying to achieve. By first examining key passages which portray Nehemiah’s state of mind, followed by an evaluation of their effects, it can be seen that Nehemiah seeks to recount his own story of being simultaneously resilient and lonely in order to apprise his readers of the difficult task of faithfully doing God’s work.
|
The Imagery of Female Characters in Ben Sira
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israel and in ANE Wisdom Literature (EABS)
Nuria Calduch-Benages, Pontifical Gregorian University
The last years have seen a veritable explosion of interest in biblical poetic imagery. This interest has also been shared by Ben Sira scholars such as Antonino Minissale (the metaphor of “falling”), Jeremy Corley (zoological, botanical, astronomical and liturgical imagery) and myself (animal, garment, eating and drinking imagery). In this paper I intend to concentrate my attention on female body imagery. After a brief introduction on the use of body language throughout the book, I will study the most significant texts on wives, i.e. chapters 25 and 26; more specifically, Sir 25:17, 23 (on the bad wife), Sir 26:12 (on the adulterous woman) and 26:17-18 (on the good wife). The last text deserves special attention because of its innovative images. They establish a close relationship between women and liturgical sacred space, which refers back to the liturgical function of Lady Wisdom in chapter 24.
|
Visualising Revelation for Luther’s New Testament (1522–1546): Debt, Design and Development
Program Unit: Open Forum for New Testament and Early Christian Studies (EABS)
W. Gordon Campbell, Union Theological College (Northern Ireland)
With his associates in Wittenberg, Martin Luther was actively involved in publishing the New Testament, and in due course the complete Bible, for the last twenty-five years of his life (1522–1546). In successive editions of the New Testament, from the inaugural September-Testament onwards, Luther provided the text of Scripture in contemporary German, introducing it through explanatory prefaces which gave orientation to its various books or corpora; for the 1530 revised New Testament and subsequently, supplementary marginal notes were also included; and from the start the text of the Book of Revelation, uniquely, was punctuated by illustrations engraved successively by several graphic artists. The resulting combination of preface, text, marginal gloss and illustration was to characterise Revelation in Luther Bibles till the final edition of his lifetime (1545) and beyond: over this quarter-century, Luther’s rendering of Revelation was corrected, revised and annotated, a longer positive second preface substituted for his initial disapproving one and Cranach’s original set of twenty-one accompanying woodcut illustrations replaced several times and enlarged to twenty-six. In the present contribution I will critically evaluate this evolving interpretative achievement in visualising Revelation for users, with special emphasis on the way the Revelation illustrations help render exegetically explicit, for reader-viewers, Luther’s visualisation of the book. Mindful both of Luther’s rationale for the use of images and his convictions on translation, I will assess the extent to which the innovative and influential interpretative efforts of Luther and his collaborators may, retrospectively, reveal a debt to various precedents and predecessors, exemplify a process of design, from conception to production, and demonstrate significant development in their component parts.
|
Deuteronomy and the Means of Memory: A Study of Deuteronomy’s Frame
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
Stephen D. Campbell, University of Durham
The framing chapters of Deuteronomy (1–11 and 29–34), as is well-known, are interconnected across the core of the book in fascinating ways. Many studies have been conducted that have explored the linguistic, thematic, and theological connections between these chapters. This study seeks to add to this important and ongoing research through a discussion of the variant understandings of the epistemological requirements of the covenant as can be seen in 4:9–20 and 29:3 (Heb.). I begin with Deuteronomy’s closing frame and argue that Deut 29:3 establishes a strong separation between personal experience and understanding such that Israel’s personal experiences of YHWH’s acts in history does not guarantee a proper response of covenant faithfulness. In other words seeing is not always believing. I continue by addressing the different and implicit claim of Deut 4:9–20 that understanding the significance of the Horeb event is not dependent upon a personal experience of that event. In other words, not seeing is not not understanding. Together these two claims indicate that covenant fidelity is neither the guaranteed result of personal experience, nor is personal experience a prerequisite for faithfulness. With these two claims in place, I conclude by noting possible ways that a close reading of these texts in the outer frame of Deuteronomy may help the reader to comprehend the means by which the covenant may be understood by tradents to be perpetual, requiring obedience to Deuteronomy’s core stipulations in every generation.
|
The Reception(s) of a Fragmented Apostolic Father, Papias of Hierapolis
Program Unit: Apostolic Fathers and Related Early Christian Literature
Stephen C. Carlson, Australian Catholic University
Papias of Hierapolis is an early second-century Christian commentator whose five-volume work of Exposition of Dominical Oracles has unfortunately been almost completely lost, aside from quotations by later authors. Due to his antiquity and his apparent comments about the origins of the Gospels of Mark and Matthew, most of the scholarly attention has naturally focused on Papias’s relation to the New Testament. This paper, however, turns attention from Papias looking backwards to Papias looking forwards, building on my work on a new edition of the fragments of Papias for the Oxford Early Christian Texts series with the most complete set of testimonia to date (over seventy). More specifically, this paper looks at how Papias was received as an author in his own right by authors ranging from the second to the fifteenth century, focusing in particular on his reception as a chiliast, gospel commentator, student of John, and a teller of gruesome tales about Judas the traitor.
|
A Guide to Best Practices for Editing a Fragmented Work
Program Unit: Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha
Stephen C. Carlson, Australian Catholic University
Many works from antiquity—including so-called apocrypha and pseudepigrapha—have not survived intact but in fragments, in the form of quotations, allusions, and mentions of a lost work and its author. Editing the fragments of a lost work posts particular challenges to the researcher because the little material that has survived is mediated through a different author living in a different time in a different social context with different time. These challenges have especially come to fore in my own work on an edition for the Oxford Early Christian Text series of the fragments of Papias of Hierapolis, an early second-century commentator whose works fell out of favor due to his materialistic millennial views in continuity with 2 Baruch and related texts. In this work, I have surveyed the best practices of researchers working with fragmented authors, mainly in the classics and late antiquity, and formulated a methodology for dealing with fragments. In my paper for this session, I propose to summarize the best practices of editing fragments, building in particular on Guido Schepens’s notion of a cover-text. As explained by Schepens (and adopted by Ariane Magny in her work on the fragments of Porphyry and others) a cover-text is the text of a witness to a lost work that performs three related and interacting functions: it preserves the text in a stream of transmission unaffected by the loss of the original work; it encloses the quotation in a descriptive and interpretative matrix of the later author’s creation; and it conceals the meaning of the excerpt from later readers by altering the text or recontextualizing it. In this paper, examples from my own work on Papias are presented to illustrate specific issues.
|
Red as a Cow and Reddish as Esau? Reconsidering the Uses of אדם and אדמוני in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: The Language of Colour in the Bible: From Word to Image (EABS)
Carlos Santos Carretero, Israel Institute of Biblical Studies
The study of color terms allows us to make assumptions whether or not there is some correlation between psychological, social and symbolic elements of language itself. These words provide information and clarify other terms, while some of them are subordinated to others in the hierarchy of a semantic field. We will analyze the terms taking into account their discursive context. The meaning of a word in the sentence depends on its context, its extratextual context and other data. Once this is determined, it is necessary to take into account the extratextual context that will allow us to determine the real coloration of the object, or at least, approach it as much as possible. Considering the above, this presentation will focus on the use of both אָדֹם and אָדמוֹנִי in the Hebrew Bible. אָדֹם appears in the description of the skin of animals (a cow in Num 19: 2 and horses in Zech 1: 8), but also when describing the skin of the young man (Songs 5: 10). In a similar use, אָדמוֹנִי appears when describing the skin of both Esau (Gn 25: 25) and David (1 Sam 16: 12, 17:42). In these verses, both אָדֹם and אָדמוֹנִי are usually translated as "red", "reddish" or "ruddy". Analyzing the extratextual context of these verses (the structure of cattle sacrifice rituals or the ideal of young and strong men in Ancient Near East culture) is essential in order to obtain a more concrete meaning of the nuances these color terms represent in the biblical text.
|
"We lacked every good thing": The Self-Justification of the Queen of Heaven Worshippers in Jeremiah 44
Program Unit: Prophets
Claire E Carroll, Trinity College - Dublin
This paper begins with an analysis of the self-representation of the Queen of Heaven worshippers in Jeremiah 44. Particularly how they present the internal logic of their worship practices. This approach offers a way towards a reassessment of certain assumptions about the dominant theological outlook throughout the book of Jeremiah.
The investigation begins by identifying the coherent justifications the worshipping group ascribes to their activities. This serves to highlight the group’s own understanding of what they are doing and why, isolated from the influence of external prophetic condemnation. It will be shown that the worshippers understand the Queen of Heaven to have a nutritive and blessing function, agency to improve the circumstances of her adherents, bestowing upon them prosperity and abundance. Her worshippers articulate her as an effective and immanent deity; not an alien intrusion, but rather an indigenous element of life in Judah. Interpreters are then faced with the troubling question of why, in a text which is so often read as espousing a singular theological perspective, are this group of worshippers given the space and voice within which to so fully articulate the rectitude of their practice?
The account of the interaction between the prophet and the assembled group displays redactional and editorial traces which expose this episode as a site of conflict. The event recounted is an incidence of clashing perspectives. This paper explores the possibility that this episode is perhaps the clearest, yet by no means only, occasion where there is a discernible breakdown in the dominant theological perspective of Jeremiah. Such a study will foreground questions about what elements of the ancient Judean context the self-justification of the worshippers may represent. This analysis is performed in the hope of encouraging discussions and reappraisals of presumed Deuteronomistic elements and influences in the book of Jeremiah.
|
Profanation and Purim
Program Unit: Bible and Its Influence: History and Impact
Jo Carruthers, Lancaster University
Parody and lawbreaking at Purim are often characterised as joyful outbursts in celebration of redemption that are sometimes deemed to spill over into blasphemy. This paper approaches such Purim parodies as profanation, as formulated by Giorgio Agamben. Where the term blasphemy indicates being scared of or interested in offending the divine or the devout, the term profane is instead focused on what the ‘blasphemous’ or ‘profane’ act does to law and order. Profanation is interested in freedom of human participation in the world and in unconstrained creativity. This paper considers that which may be considered blasphemous at Purim – drunkenness, the parodying of biblical and liturgical texts – to consider these acts as set in a longstanding Jewish tradition of human participation. Such participation is constructed as a non-totalitarian version of divine sovereignty that I argue can be drawn on for understanding the importance of profanity to redemption and Purim.
|
Pre-monarchic Israel as a Somatic Society: Judges 19–21 and the Regulation of Bodies
Program Unit: Anthropology and the Bible (EABS)
M. L. Case, Elon University
The ancient Israelite pre-monarchic society depicted in the Hebrew Bible has frequently been described as kinship-based or tribal, but such an explanation reveals little about the details of the social order. I propose using sociologist Bryan Turner’s concept of a ‘somatic society’ as a valuable tool for biblical scholars to analyze this social organization. According to Turner, a ‘somatic society’ is one in which the main crises of a society—both political and personal—are problematized in the body and expressed through the body. Using Judg 19–21 as a test case, I argue that in a somatic pre-monarchic Israel, proper regulation of bodies helped perpetuate the order of society, while improper regulation of bodies led to social disorder. Through this lens, we can gain a greater understanding of the social order of the ancient Israelites depicted during the period of the judges.
|
Isaiah 40 in the Manuscript Tradition of the Gospels
Program Unit: Textual Criticism: Manuscripts & Methods
Jeff Cate, California Baptist University
The opening words of any great literary work set the tone, direction, and themes for the rest of the piece. This is true for the Gospel of Mark. The earliest manuscripts of Mk 1:2-3 cite Isaiah to introduce a combined quotation of Mal 3:1 (or Exod 23:20?) and Isa 40:3. This combined quote stands out noticeably in those opening lines because never again in the rest of the narrative are the Jewish scriptures cited in such a way. But how these two verses were understood and utilized diverges in our earliest sources, especially the lines from Isaiah 40. At times, scribes who copied these words in our extant manuscripts either lengthened the Isaiah quote or altered its attribution. For example, Greek Codex Washingtonius (032/W) and Vetus Latina Codex Colbertinus (VL 6, it-c) continue the quotation of Isa 40:3 to include the next five verses. And even earlier before that stage of activity, Matthew and Luke had already diverged from Mark in their own significant ways regarding this quote in their parallel passages. And additional variant readings with the Isaiah quotations arise in each of these Synoptic parallels. Still later in the Fourth Gospel, Isaiah 40:3 again appears early in the narrative associated with John [the Baptist] but unlike the Synoptics the quote now comes from his own mouth. And Codex Washingtonius has another singular reading with the quotation of Isaiah 40. These quotes of Isaiah and their variants are even more intriguing when observing how attributions to Isaiah fluctuate and vary in the manuscript tradition of OT citations in the Gospels. This paper will examine these interrelated text critical issues to address larger, broader issues of Old Testament citations in the Gospels and the history of the interpretation of those passages.
|
The Aspect of Consent
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Sylvie Chabert d'Hyères, Université de Lyon
“Behold, the servant of the Lord” (Luke 1.38) : By using those words, Mary could not ignore that she ranked herself among the “Servants of the Lord”, Moses, Joshua and David, the ones who received this title (Dt 34.5; Jos 24.29; Ps 36.1).
She was giving a response to the salutation “Adonai with you” since the preposition with requires reciprocity. The angel had not asked her explicitly, if she agreed to become the mother of the son of the Highest; he did not specifically request her consent. However, at her own initiative, she pronounced it ; it was a sign of confidence, an expression of her personal and spiritual maturity.
The dialogue of the Annunciation challenges the myths. Indeed, the begetting of a hero is based on violence, kidnapping, and rape ; sometimes, the god takes advantage of the woman in her sleep or by impersonating the husband. Only the satisfaction of the god spawner deserves to be considered ; intentions, will and motivations of the mother are neglected and her pleasure forbidden.
In contrast, if Mary testifies to the freedom of her soul through the consent she had been in a position to give, it is obvious that in the Gospel of Matthew as in the Rosary prayer of the Catholic Church, it is not even referred to; the very ancient prayer of the “Angelus” has turned her agreement into a mere ratification. If the theologian has accepted the freedom granted by the Lord to Mary, he has also granted her an eminently passive role. In the Koranic narrative the consent of the mother is clearly proscribed.
The Lukan text requires to be read with objectivity in the context of the twenty-first century.
|
Priestly Authority?
Program Unit: Authority and Influence in Ancient Times
Sylvie Chabert d'Hyères, Université de Lyon
The expressions “listen to me” and “my judgment is” in the speech of Actes XV testifies to the authority of James the Just within the assembly of Jerusalem. “It seemed good to us”, in the letter which he sent on behalf of the assembly to the communities of the Diaspora, is a clever turn to inform of a decision; it is nowhere else in the New Testament, except for Luke's preface, and both texts have a lot in common:
The speech and the preface give high importance to the written document and to the Scripture. Yet the leaders of the people were taking their authority from their adherence to the written prescriptions of the Torah read every Sabbath in the synagogues, as specified by James in his speech.
The speech of Acts is of liturgical concerns (David's tent, invocation of the Name, the prescriptions of ritual purity) whereas the Third Gospel is focused on prayer, liturgy, priesthood and Jerusalem.
No reference is made to God in the preface, but to the Holy Spirit in the letter sent to the communities of the diaspora in Acts. However, in both cases the writers did not give up their own authority to the benefit of the divine authority but they tended to paint themselves as partners.
The priestly class exercised spiritual, moral, political authority on the people ; the speech of James and the preface dedicated to Theophilus seem to be under this influence.
|
The Literary Tapestry of Amos 3:1-8
Program Unit: Judaica
Anthony Chapman, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
Inclusio, or envelope figure, is a well-known rhetorical device in which the beginning is repeated at the end, thus bringing structure and poetic beauty to the text. Amos 3:1-8 has been recognized by many Biblical scholars as an independent literary unit, due to the clearly identifiable inclusio in verses 1 and 8 (dibber yhwh || yhwh dibber). However, there has been very little agreement regarding its internal structure, especially regarding the relationship of vv. 1-2 to the rest of the passage. In addition, the significance of v. 3 has been the source of much disagreement. Through careful textual and poetical analysis, the literary tapestry of this passage will be brought to light, shown through the recognition of not only one but three inclusios, in conjunction with other rhetorical devices such as chiasmus, pivot, and keyword structures. This analysis will awaken an appreciation of the intended beauty, technical design, and artistic nuance present in Amos 3:1-8.
|
A History of Inclusio Study
Program Unit: Diachronic Poetology of the Hebrew Bible and Related Ancient Near Eastern and Ancient Jewish Literature (EABS)
Anthony Chapman, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
In this paper, research of the inclusio poetical figure will be traced from the early third century C.E. up through the seventeenth century, providing a diachronic perspective of inclusio research within the Hebrew Bible. Inclusio, or envelope figure, is a well-known rhetorical device in which the beginning is repeated at the end, thus bringing structure and poetic beauty to the text. Modern scholars have recognized inclusio structures throughout the Hebrew Bible, in both longer and shorter literary units, and in both poetic and prosaic genres. However, the study of inclusio did not begin with modern Biblical scholarship. As early as the third century, both Jewish and Christian sources began to call attention to poetical devices found within the Biblical text, and one of the devices they noted was inclusio, albeit by several different names. Amongst Jewish Rabbinical and Masoretic sources, inclusio was recognized as bringing poetic beauty, and also viewed as a mnemonic tool. Early Christian rhetors, on the other hand, were guided by attempts to analyze the Biblical text by way of secular classical rhetoric. As these studies are traced from the third century up through the Renaissance, a valuable perspective is attained which will inform and guide our understanding of inclusio within Biblical scholarship today.
|
Ezekiel Ben Buzi, the Raggedy-Ann Prophet
Program Unit: Deconstructive Poetics (EABS)
Simeon Chavel, University of Chicago
This presentation will analyze the character Ezekiel in the book Ezekiel as the equivalent of a raggedy-ann doll. It will survey how his voice, body, address, biography, and name are all agents of divine meaning, but he himself is robbed of all agency and control over them as Yahweh toys with every aspect of his being. Comparison with other prophetic works will show this work to cast Ezekiel’s condition as a case of prophecy or prophetic possession run amok. The analysis will argue that even the frame of the work, a first-person account long after the worst has occurred, presents a form of self-justification, a belated telling that explains his lack of protest, and thereby accentuates his inefficacy.
|
Expansion or Omission? An Inquiry into the Literary Development of MT 1 Kings 8:1–11 in Light of the Septuagint
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the New Testament, the Old Testament and the Qur’an (EABS)
Julian C. Chike, University of Notre Dame
The literary development of 1–2 Kings continues to occasion much debate, including the long story of Solomon’s Temple dedication (1 Kgs 8). The quest for clarity is complicated (or aided) by the textual witness of the Septuagint (LXX). Like LXX Joshua and LXX Jeremiah, LXX 3–4 Kingdoms reflects noticeable differences—both qualitative and quantitative—when compared to the Masoretic text (MT). Such differences may be observed in 1 Kgs 8. Of particular interest is 1 Kgs 8:1–11 where the LXX presents a noticeably shorter text than its Hebrew counterpart as reflected in the MT (vv. 1–5 contain the most noticeable differences). Interestingly, most of the material attested by the MT, but absent in the LXX, have been observed to bear the marks of Priestly editing. Does the Greek text reflect the earlier (pre-priestly edited) text form? Does the variation simply reflect the translator’s desire to compose a chronologically stylistically consistent text? Or does the variation between the texts evince the presence of two discrete literary editions? If the LXX bears witness to an earlier (shorter) text form, what exegetical, theological, or social concerns lead to the expanded MT? Additionally, what do these variations tell us about the literary development of 1 Kgs 8? Did the editing of 1 Kgs 8 continue into the second century BCE? These are the questions I will set out to answer in this paper through a close textual comparison of MT 1 Kgs 8:1–11 with LXX 3 Kgdms 8:1–11, along with the synoptic account in 2 Chr 5:2–14 and ancillary comparisons with 4QKgs(a).
|
Toward a Characterization of the Translation Technique of 3 Kingdoms 2:12–21:43: A Case Study
Program Unit: Septuagint of Historical Books (EABS)
Julian C. Chike, University of Notre Dame
Over the past few decades, several studies have emerged which treat text-critical questions posed concerning MT 1–2 Kings on account of the textual witness of the Septuagint (OG) 3–4 Kingdoms. Like the Greek text of Joshua, 3–4 Kingdoms reflects conspicuous differences—both qualitative and quantitative—when compared to the MT. While some scholars attribute the variations to the editorial initiatives of the OG translator, other scholars maintain the variations evince the presence of a Hebrew Vorlage which depicts a text form at an earlier stage of literary development. Underlying these propositions are the methodological presuppositions regarding the translation technique of 3–4 Kingdoms. Those who regard 3–4 Kingdoms as a rather free translation are reticent to posit a different Hebrew Vorlage; the differences likely arise from the translator. Conversely, those who regard 3–4 Kingdoms as a more literal rendition are more likely to view the variations as evidence for an underlying Hebrew Vorlage different from MT. Thus, the precise characterization of the translation technique of 3–4 Kingdoms figures prominently into the debate. However, few studies have been conducted which closely examine the grammatical/syntactical translation technique of 3–4 Kingdoms—especially the γγ section (3 Kgdms 2:12–21:43). In light of this lacuna, this paper serves as an entrée into further discussion of the translation technique of the γγ section by providing an analysis of three short pericopes (1 Kgs 3:16–28; 9:1–9; 17:8–24) to determine how the OG translator handled the grammar and syntax of his Hebrew Vorlage. The findings of this study will offer a contribution to the movement toward a characterization of the translation technique of 3 Kingdoms 2:12–21:43. Additionally, the findings will seek to further inform text-critical discussions.
|
John, Ethnicity, and the Concept of the Ancestral Land: Re-territorializing Jewish Identity in the Fourth Gospel
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Wally V. Cirafesi, University of Oslo
In 1974, W.D. Davies argued that, while the Fourth Gospel does not necessarily reject the ‘land of Israel,’ it simply does not care much about it to begin with. The spatial dimension that is most central to this Gospel is the “vertical” one, i.e., Jesus’s heavenly origin, not the “horizontal” one having to do with ‘real’ land. The Gospel’s take on the land serves only to advance the Johannine replacement motif. The other dominate approach to the topic has been from the perspective of ‘symbolic geography’ (e.g., Meeks 1966; Fortna 1974; Bassler 1981; Neyrey 2002). In this approach, Galilee and Judea, for example, are understood only to represent places of Jesus’s acceptance and rejection, while the possibility of both regions being Jesus’s patris (John 4:44) functions as a symbolic foil to the Johannine portrait of Jesus’s true origins “from above.”
The aim of the current paper, however, is to advance the discussion of John’s relation to the ‘land of Israel’ by approaching ‘land’ as a fundamentally ethnic category in antiquity (Satlow 2015), which functioned within a range of discursive constructions of Jewish identity. By surveying a variety of evidence from the Second Temple and rabbinic periods, I will suggest that many Jews, for whatever reason, were actively engaged in (re)interpreting their ancestral association with the land. The land as an ethnic component of Jewishness is not “replaced” or left behind in John, but rather provides the impetus for John’s strategy of reorienting, or even better, re-territorializing, the land toward a land “not of this world” (John 18:36) in light of its presentation of Jesus. Rather than being at odds with contemporary understandings of Jewishness, this re-territorializing strategy puts the Fourth Gospel firmly within the discursive trajectory of other ancient ‘diasporic’ expressions of Jewish ethnic identity.
|
Exploring the True Identity of Junia: An Exploration into Identifying Apostleship in Romans
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Constantina Ann Clark, Ubiquity University, Dean of Students
By studying similarities and circumstances within the New Testament scriptures, we find that it is possible to piece together the probable identities of those women who were of influence in the early Church. One such women who offers us a fascinating study is that of Junia, mentioned by St. Paul in Romans 16:7 as "outstanding among the apostles.” There are those biblical scholars, such as Richard Bauckham and Lynn Cohick who believe that Junia was better known to us than we may have previously thought and postulate that Junia was actually the Joanna of the gospels. Bauckham's thesis, is that Junia and the Joanna who is referred to in Luke 8:3 and 24:10, are one and the same. If the Joanna of the gospels is indeed the Junia of Romans, who simply romanized her name to a sound-equivalent early on in her life out of necessity, due to her association with Herod Antipas’s Roman palace in Tiberias, it would make Joanna/Junia an eyewitness to Jesus, having served with him in his earthly ministry as noted in Luke 8:3, and having proclaimed his resurrection, along with the other male apostles (Luke 24:10), making her uniquely qualified to serve as an apostle. Her social position as a former member of Herod’s court would have given her credibility in sharing the gospel in Rome and there is no doubt that the fact that she met the necessary criteria for apostleship would have not gone unnoticed by Paul. However, perhaps more relevant for modern day scholars, how did various aspects of Junia’s identity such as patronage impact her apostleship? These various concerns will be investigated and discussed in this presentation that takes an in depth look into the identity of Junia and her participation in the early church.
|
Early Feminist Christian Health-Care Activists: How Early Christian Women Defied Paterfamilias and Changed the Face of Women's Health Care in the Greco-Roman World
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Constantina Ann Clark, Ubiquity University, Dean of Students
To many modern day feminists, the women of the New Testament represented an adherence to a patriarchal systematic ideology that only served to disenfranchise women. This assessment represents a failure to recognize that women who became adherents of early Christian ideology promoted a radical departure from the authority of paterfamilias exercised in Greco-Roman culture, into which Christianity was birthed. This cultural phenomenon had a significant effect on how female converts cared for both their own health and the health of women in general, in the Greco-Roman world. These women acting as evangelists, missionaries, and simple female converts promoted a new way of female human consciousness, particularly as it applied to the care and authority over their own bodies. Females who were “followers of the way,” the early term for Christians, were women who acted as proponents of a feminist movement that was willing to defy paterfamilias in order to advance health care for the physical and psychological needs of women, in a fashion that had never before been experienced in the Greco-Roman world, a world where women lived in virtual subjugation to the authority of men over their bodies. This presentation will explore how early Christian women changed the face of women's health care in the ancient world, through the enculturation of Christ’s teachings, within a new feminist consciousness, positively effecting both the health and wellbeing of Greco-Roman women, both Christian and Pagan, alike. Lastly, this presentation will explore how female utilization of Christ’s teachings, during a period of evolving consciousness within a significant transition in psycho-spiritual change, demonstrated the efficacy of Christ’s philosophical, psychological and spiritual teachings, in ways that began to free women from paterfamilias and move them into a new and conscious exploration of authority over their own bodies and minds.
|
Pinning Sisera Down (Judg 4:17-22): Self-Construal in Light of the Indeterminate Other
Program Unit: Place, Space, and Identity in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Bruno J. Clifton, University of Cambridge
The puzzle of why Jael skewers Sisera's head with a tent peg (Judg 4:17-22) is solved if we recognize the dilemma she faces in determining who and where she is. I propose that it is Jael's family and its domestic space which shapes her identity and role with respect to Sisera. Such socio-spatial details direct social encounters and so in the same way, Jael's reaction to Sisera's approach would depend upon who he is in the social space she safeguards.
Jael's problem, however, is that Sisera's relationship to her is unclear in light of the battle described in Judg 4. In an apparent alliance with Jael's absent husband Heber, Sisera may be friend. But as defeated fugitive from a people related to Jael he may be foe. The biblical story plays on the struggle to mutually recognize identity: does Sisera belong to 'us' or is he the Other? Identity and space collide at a tent's threshold, thwarting Jael and Sisera's attempts to recognize loyalties and determine expected behaviour.
For this reason, the story is not only about why but whether: whether Jael ought to kill Sisera; whether she will. In the context of Judg 4, I think that it remains unclear whether Sisera should be welcome in Jael's tent and that her dilemma in this regard provides the tale's drama. Following Sisera's intrusion, Jael's identity and the space this informs are only settled when she strikes the final blow, a revelation made simultaneously to the tale's audience and to Jael herself. Resolving the dilemma both for her and for the reader is what makes Jael a hero as she pins Sisera down.
|
How Is This Dictionary Different from All Other Hebrew Dictionaries? The New Dictionary of Classical Hebrew Revised
Program Unit: Ancient Near East
David J.A. Clines, University of Sheffield
To mark the publication in mid-2018 of the first volume (Aleph) of the revised version of the Dictionary of Classical Hebrew, this paper will introduce some of the key new features in the revised edition (DCHR). The nine volumes will contain 100,000 improvements, including the addition of 2000 new Hebrew words (bringing the total to 5500 words not in BDB). 3500 byforms (words with the same meaning and similar form) have been identified for the first time, 660 verbal nouns appear in their alphabetical place, and 330 denominative verbs are labelled. There is a new section for each word, listing all synonyms (e.g. 53 for be strong, 41 for desire, 27 for trap, 20 for rejoice), and another identifying the semantic field to which each word belongs. DCHR contains 35,000 emendations of the biblical texts (8 times more than HALOT), and is 25% longer than DCH and 4 times the length of HALOT. At 5 million words, it is the equivalent of 50 standard-sized books.
|
Bible in a Multimodal Culture: Questions and Challenges
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical Studies, Early Jewish and Christian Studies (EABS)
Claire Clivaz, Swiss Institute of Bioinformatics
When celebrating the 500th birthday of the Reformation, the Federation of protestant churches has considered that Scriptures within the digital culture context have been emancipated from books (German), or were dissociated from them (French). By observing the Bible becoming increasingly digital on a daily basis, the nuanced difference between these stances highlight the diverse hopes and fears of Christian communities. This paper will raise three important points of evaluation with regards to these fears and hopes, furthermore it aims to map the challenges of the Bible in digital culture. First, the impact of two biblical applications will be examined: Youversion and Globible. Secondly, examples where the impact of oral digital culture is transforming our perceptions of the biblical text will be considered. Finally, we will examine the impact of manuscript- and textual- criticism cultures towards a multimodal Bible: new forms of editions and transmissions have to be imagined.
|
Deuteronomy's Motif of Life in Hebrews
Program Unit: Epistle to the Hebrews
Albert Coetsee, North-West University (South Africa)
The influence and effect of the book of Deuteronomy in the New Testament writings is widely accepted. One of the New Testament books that contains the most quotations, references and allusions to Deuteronomy, is the book of Hebrews. Several ground-breaking studies on the influence and effect of Deuteronomy in Hebrews have been done, including the following:
• Allen (2008), in his very informative PhD thesis (Deuteronomy and Exhortation in Hebrews: An Exercise in Narrative Re-Presentation), investigates the way in which the book of Deuteronomy operates within the paraenetic sections of Hebrews, and argues that Hebrews becomes a “new” Deuteronomy that challenges its predecessor’s contemporary hegemony.
• Steyn (2007:152-168; Deuteronomy in Hebrews) gives a synopsis of quotations, references and allusions attributed to Deuteronomy, as well as a brief discussion of certain motifs from Deuteronomy in Hebrews, namely covenant, Moses and priesthood.
This paper endeavours to contribute to the study of the influence and effect of Deuteronomy in Hebrews by investigating the influence of another possible Deuteronomic motif in Hebrews, namely the motif of “life”. References to “life” are found throughout Deuteronomy. Markl (2014:71; This Word is your life: the theology of ‘life’ in Deuteronomy), who outlines “life” (חיה) in Deuteronomy (the only study done on this subject in recent literature), calls it “one of the key theological concepts in the book”. With this paper I argue that traces of this motif are present in Hebrews, and I demonstrate how these traces function within the book.
The paper first defines the (multifaceted) concept of “life” in Deuteronomy. This is followed up by combing through the text of Hebrews to identify traces of this motif in the words and concepts that the writer employs, as well as the overall theme of the book. In conclusion, the findings are synthesized to give a panorama of this motif in Hebrews.
|
On the Trail of a Biblical Serial Killer: Sherlock Holmes and the Book of Tobit
Program Unit: The Biblical World and Its Reception (EABS)
Matthew A. Collins, University of Chester
In the apocryphal/deuterocanonical book of Tobit, Sarah, the daughter of Raguel, is tormented by the demon Asmodeus. She has been married seven times, but each time the demon kills her husband on her wedding night. In despair, she contemplates suicide and prays for deliverance. In the course of the narrative, Tobias, the son of Tobit, travels from Nineveh to Ecbatana and, with the help of the archangel Raphael, defeats the demon and marries Sarah.
Between 1939 and 1946, Basil Rathbone and Nigel Bruce starred together in "The New Adventures of Sherlock Holmes", a series of radio plays broadcast in the US. One episode, aired on 26th March 1945, was entitled “The Book of Tobit” and featured Holmes and Watson investigating the deaths of a woman’s previous three husbands, each of whom, prior to his death, had received a threatening letter signed “Asmodeus”. Though substantially different in both content and context, throughout the case numerous comparisons are made with its scriptural forebear.
This paper first explores the use of and engagement with Tobit in this wartime murder mystery before turning to re-examine the biblical text in the light of Holmes’ namesake investigation. By in effect transposing Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s celebrated detective to ancient Ecbatana, the inherently murderous nature of the biblical tale comes into sharper focus and the peculiarities of the narrative and its folkloric origins are both reassessed and illuminated from a perspective informed by crime fiction. Putting Sherlock Holmes on the case, a rather different interpretation of the text emerges – one in which there is a serial killer on the loose in the book of Tobit, and Sarah may not in fact be as innocent as she seems.
|
Unlocking Metaphorical Chains: New Horizons for Ancient Texts in the Modern World
Program Unit: Bible Translation Workshop (EABS)
Hans Combrink, Biblica, Inc.
This paper will explore the significance of recent theoretical developments in cognitive linguistics and translation theory, as well as a general move in translation circles towards more direct or stimulus-based translations. Reference will be made to an Afrikaans translation Die Bybel: ‘n Direkte Vertaling (BDV) [The Bible: A Direct Translation] as an example of this approach, since Ernst-August Gutt’s notion of a direct or stimulus-based translation embodies the skopos of this translation. This paper will also explore the concept of a translation brief which plays an important role in the functionalist model of Christiane Nord that can be seen as a helpful theoretical framework for identifying, negotiating and documenting all the variables to be taken into account when embarking on a translation project. I will further argue that an understanding of the cognitive mechanisms of metaphorical language and its cultural situatedness is crucial for determining an appropriate strategy when faced with the problem of translating ancient texts. I will try to show that the key to unlocking metaphorical language and retaining ambiguity lies in finding the relevant communicative clues of the ancient source language text and retaining those in the translation of ancient texts for the modern world.
|
A Gospel in the Margins? "To ioudaiïkon" in Manuscripts of Matthew
Program Unit: Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha
Jeremiah Coogan, University of Notre Dame
A number of minuscule manuscripts (Gregory-Aland nos. 4, 273, 566, 899, 1424) include material attributed to to ioudaiïkon, “the Jewish [gospel],” in the margins of Matthew. These marginalia problematize easy editorial distinctions between “text,” “variant,” and “paratext” and raise important questions. How should one edit marginalia? How should one edit texts with marginalia? More fundamentally, what do marginalia do to the texts they surround? Modern editions of the New Testament omit the to ioudaiïkon marginalia from apparatus critici as extraneous to Matthew “itself.” Instead, the marginalia have been printed as a separate “text,” a collection of non-canonical fragments (e.g. Klauck 2003; Evans 2007; Ehrman & Pleše 2011; Frey 2012). Yet this editorial approach is problematic in two ways. First, by separating the marginalia from their physical location and readerly context in the margins of Matthew, editors create a newly fragmentary “gospel” that may not have previously existed. Not only does the location of this material in Matthew’s margins enable its physical preservation, but the context and significance of the marginalia are generated in their juxtaposition with a running text. Second, this editorial practice obscures how marginalia supplement and even rewrite Matthew in these manuscripts. This is not unique; the remediation that occurs in modern print editions regularly omits the manuscript paratext in favor of a different, modern paratext. Yet, in the manuscripts, these marginalia create a particular “Matthew” to be read—even, in a certain sense, a new “text.” Modern editorial interventions reconfigure both marginalia and running text, but by deleting to ioudaiïkon from Matthew, something is lost on both sides. While such an editorial practice functions to reify a division between canonical text and noncanonical marginalia, this paper focuses on the complex interaction that occurs on the page and in the experience of the reader.
|
Matthew's Crowds in Recent Research
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Robert (J.R.C.) Cousland, University of British Columbia
Since the publication of my The Crowds in the Gospel of Matthew in 2002, scholarship addressing the Matthean crowds has continued to proliferate. In particular, Matthias Konradt's Israel, Church and the Gentiles in the Gospel of Matthew (2014) and Uta Poplutz's Erzählte Welt: Narratologische Studien zum Matthäusevangium (2008) and other works have advanced fresh perspectives on the question. This paper will offer an overview of this recent research, and a response to these findings.
|
Paul, Adiafora, and the Greco-Roman Context
Program Unit: Graeco-Roman Society and the New Testament (EABS)
Panayotis Coutsoumpos, Universidad de Montemorelos
In the Greco-Roman context, the term ἀδιάφορα was a common expression among the philosophers (Stoics) of the time, and it is probable that Paul was familiar with the term as well. Some scholars have argued that the apostle Paul used this term as part of his everyday language. For many years 1 Cor. 8-10 have posed difficulties for many interpreters, particularly, the issue of inconsistency. Was Paul or the Corinthians influenced by the Stoic philosophers? Whether or not Paul used this term is a manner of debate.
|
The Anthropological Study of Possession Phenomena: An Exercise in Cross-disciplinary Research
Program Unit: Anthropology and the Bible (EABS)
Pieter F Craffert, University of South Africa
Anthropology must certainly be the dominant discipline keeping itself busy with research on spirit possession. The resurgence of interest in spirit possession and possession phenomena in Biblical Studies will naturally result in cross-disciplinary research where these phenomena have been studied for decades. But neither anthropology as a discipline nor the anthropological study of spirit possession contains a single or unified approach. At least five prominent perspectives in anthropological research on spirit possession can be identified. A brief introduction of each perspective shows that depending on the research perspective, spirit possession take on completely different characteristics and features. In view of the different perspectives it is no longer possible to simply turn towards anthropology for the study of spirit possession. These perspectives point towards the challenges in cross-disciplinary research which should not only take the experiences seriously but also develop theoretical perspectives for making sense of such experiences. The implication is that the cross-disciplinary study of spirit possession faces is not only the challenged of the available data but also the available theoretical perspectives. Anthropological research on spirit possession cannot randomly be cited as if it deals with a single phenomenon from a unified perspective.
|
Diseased Leadership
Program Unit: Concepts of Leadership in the Hebrew Bible (EABS)
Isabel Cranz, University of Pennsylvania
My paper draws from the study of kingship ideology, medical humanities and disability studies to show how Deuteronomistic and Chronistic reports about sick kings call attention to core social and political issues of leadership in Judah and Israel. It is demonstrated how the motif of the sick king in the Deuteronomistic History serves to confirm the existence, continuation and survival of the Davidic Dynasty and Judah (Saul, David, Hezekiah). Alternatively, in the Elijah/Elisha-Cycles, the motif of the ailing king is used to anticipate the demise of the Omride Dynasty (Ahaziah) and the concomitant punishment of Israel (Ben Hadad). The Chronistic History, by contrast, merges the Deuteronomistic focus on the Davidic Dynasty with the anticipation of punishment and the destruction of the nation (Jehoram). Furthermore, after the Davidic Dynasty’s loss of power, the Chronicler shifts attention towards a more universalist interpretation of the sick king motif. To this end a didactic element and a critique of Judah’s political leadership is introduced. The motif of the sick king is now effectively used as a warning, announcing the dangers of both misguided self-reliance (Asa) and reckless arrogance (Uzziah, Hezekiah). It is, therefore, shown how the motif of the sick king functions both symbolically and pragmatically while being adapted to different ideological frameworks alternately reflecting the interests of the Deuteronomistic and Chronistic approaches to history and leadership.
|
The Greek Text and the Authorship of ll Peter
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
David Z Crookes, Independent writer
You happen to be called Lewis Carroll. Your friend Porphyre Églantine has written his own speech for a wedding. He requests that you polish its text for him. Well! You do your stylistic work without adding any factual material of your own. Is that a big deal? No! Like many other writers, Porphyre is unafraid to seek assistance. He is, and remains, the author of his own speech. Nonetheless, since he wants to acknowledge your assistance in a whimsical manner, Porphyre invites you to involve yourself cryptically in one or two words of the text. You therefore pounce on a dictum of Willard Quine with which Porphyre has begun his speech, and wickedly attribute it to ‘Carlos Willer’. Now, then. We often encounter in academe the kindergarten idea that II Peter must have been written either by Simon-Peter-Cephas working entirely on his own, or by another writer working entirely on his own. Will a careful study of the Greek text of II Peter reveal the fact of an assisted author? Will it also reveal the identities of his assistants? And were those assistants on the boat in John 21? Here are three fascinating questions which we shall address in Helsinki.
|
The Network of "Daughter Zion" Metaphor and Other Metaphors in the Book of Micah
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible (EABS)
Juan Cruz, University of Aberdeen
The ‘Daughter Zion’ metaphor is combined with several other metaphors in the book of Micah. It is introduced in 1:13, where Jerusalem is personified in the figure of a daughter, and linked with Lachish, where its sin originated. Two further metaphors for Jerusalem then appear in 1:16: the lamenting mother, who evokes our compassion as she mourns the banishment of her children, and the bald vulture, providing an alternative visual image of a woman who becomes unattractive after the loss of her hair. ‘Daughter Zion’ reappears in 4:8 with information concerning her restoration; she is elevated in grandeur like a tower as her kingdom is restored to her. However, in 4:10 she is compared to a woman in the pains of childbirth as she prepares for exile. Finally, in 4:11–13, ‘Daughter Zion’ is summoned to rise and gather her troops for war. She appears alongside the metaphor of threshing, a graphic image for how she plans to destroy the enemy nations.
Redaction critics in Micah scholarship were unable to identify the connections between these texts, or how the figure of ‘Daughter Zion’ expands throughout the book, because of their insistence upon the separation between the authentic sayings of the eighth century prophet in chapters 1–3, and the secondary materials in chapters 4–7. Using Benjamin Harshav’s theories of metaphor, which can integrate multiple and interrelated metaphors into meaningful relationships, this paper will first analyse the ‘Daughter Zion’ metaphor and its interaction with other metaphors in the texts where they appear, and then look at how these texts can be combined to determine their overall arguments in Micah. It will demonstrate that ‘Daughter Zion’, and the metaphors which appear alongside it, form a network of images that express the emotion, suffering, and hope of the Jewish people in history.
|
An Ethnography of Virtue in Luke’s Gospel
Program Unit: Virtue in Biblical Literature (EABS)
Kenneth Cukrowski, Abilene Christian University
How does one map the moral topography of virtue in a narrative? In one sense, the contours of virtue are evident in the commands, exemplars, and values reflected in the story. To give a full description of virtue, however, it is necessary to unearth the logic undergirding and connecting these moral claims. The question then becomes, “How does one gain access to this grammar of virtue?”
Inspired by W. Meeks’ metaphor of ethnography in his The Origins of Christian Morality, I propose to describe Luke’s concept of virtue in the following manner. I first attend to the diverse ways in which Luke makes moral claims in the narrative. For each moral claim, I then investigate the warrant for each norm. This analysis reveals that Luke employs a variety of warrants; in fact, Luke can even use different warrants for the same virtue. It is important to express these warrants, as much as possible, in emic terms, so that the resulting description of the moral terrain expresses Luke’s moral logic in Luke’s language. The end product of sorting through these claims is an ethnography of virtue for the Gospel of Luke, with which we are able to understand the construction of identity and community in what is the longest book of the New Testament.
|
The Grammar of Lukan Emotions
Program Unit: Emotions and the Biblical World (EABS)
Kenneth Cukrowski, Abilene Christian University
In Fitzmyer’s discussion of the literary composition of Luke, he claims, “the description of Jesus moved by human emotions in the Marcan Gospel is normally eliminated in the Lucan story, even if they are expressions of love, compassion, or tenderness.” Fitzmyer cites ten redactions to support his claim and then concludes that Luke’s removal of Jesus’ emotion “is an aspect of Luke’s concern for asphaleia, ‘assurance’” (95). I contend that his proposal does not give a sufficient account of how emotion functions in Luke (and Acts).
In contrast, I propose that for Luke, emotions are a constitutive part of his moral world, such that emotions play a foundational role in the shaping of Luke’s vision for Christian community and character. This paper articulates the moral vision embodied by Lukan emotions, explores the role that emotion plays in Luke’s ethical framework, examines the problematic redactions highlighted by Fitzmyer, and puzzles over the odd depictions of the disciples’ emotions in Luke 22:45 (“sleeping for sorrow”) and 24:41 (“disbelieved for joy”). Since Luke-Acts comprises the largest corpus by a single New Testament author, an exploration into the grammar of Lukan emotions offers a valuable understanding of early Christian views of emotion, ethics, and community formation.
|
Evolution as Learning: Early Christianity as a Test Case
Program Unit: The Biblical World and Cultural Evolution (EABS)
Istvan Czachesz, University of Tromsø
This paper applies the model of evolution as a learning process (Watson & Szathmary 2016) to the problem of the success of Early Christianity. The structure of social networks is identified as the most important factor, which, in turn, influenced the generation of memorable ideas and the use of religious elements as symbolic identity markers. In early Christianity, weak social ties enabled large-scale cooperation across geographically and sociologically distant groups and individuals. As a consequence, the social composition and structure of the movement favored the emergence of innovative theological ideas. Some of these ideas functioned as powerful symbolic identity markers, which further enhanced solidarity in cooperative associations of varying sizes between groups. Finally, both memorable ideas and social identity markers found their ways in great numbers into literary compositions.
|
Gandhi and the New Testament: What Do We Know? What Must We Ask?
Program Unit: The Biblical World and Its Reception (EABS)
Alex Damm, Wilfrid Laurier University
This paper summarizes scholarship on interpretation of the New Testament by India’s foremost nationalist leader, Mohandas K. Gandhi (1869-1948). To date, studies of Gandhi have started to outline his knowledge of and appeals to Christian literature. They have revealed some significant themes. These include Gandhi’s thoroughly religious intentions, namely to learn Truth (Wilson, 1981; cf. Gandhi, 1927); the influence of such intentions on his exegesis of texts (Räisänen, 1987); his interpretive concerns, such as judgement of a text’s value by its accord with reason and non-violence (Emilsen, 2000; Jordens, 1988); the often Christian sources of Gandhi’s concerns and methods (for instance, Brown, 2009); analysis of his most valued traditions, namely the Sermon on the Mount (Emilsen, 2000; Chatterjee, 1983); and some specific ends to which he applied biblical interpretation, including dialogue with the British Raj, with political opponents, and with Christians (for example, Räisänen, 1987).
Significantly, however, there is no study beyond the scope of an essay of Gandhi’s interpretation of the New Testament and Jesus. For one, there is less than thorough treatment of the aforementioned insights, several of which emerge in the course of more general study. For another, there is little scholarship that grounds study of Gandhi in the entire corpus of his writings. And third, there is scant consideration either of the influence of specific historical contexts on his interpretations, or of possible changes in his interpretation over the course of his long career.
This paper will propose a research agenda that addresses in particular the contexts and changes in contexts that shaped Gandhi’s New Testament commentaries. As such, it will constitute a foundation of original contributions to the fields of biblical interpretation and Gandhian studies.
|
Coming of Age: The Child Jesus in the Temple and Telemachus on a Journey
Program Unit: Allusions in the Gospels and Acts
Justin L. Daneshmand, University of Manchester
Insufficient scholarly attention has been given to the child Jesus’ transition into adulthood in Luke’s Child Jesus in the Temple pericope (Luke 2.41–52) in light of similar developments into maturity in the ancient literary world with which Luke and his audience were likely familiar. Where scholars cite parallel stories, emphasis tends to be on ages of children becoming adolescents or adults, considering the comment that Jesus was the age of twelve (v. 43), or on similar child sage motifs (vv. 46–7). In this literary-critical paper I argue that Luke’s story prominently expresses a coming of age theme or tradition of which, inter alia, these elements are components. Furthermore, I suggest via a comparative analysis that Telemachus’ development in the Telemacheia (books 1–4 and part of 15 of Homer’s Odyssey) provides a fitting comparison to Luke’s pericope with some significant narratological parallels and a shared coming of age theme which can illuminate our reading of the Lukan account. A crucial element to both stories is the active, independent, and elusive characterisations of the young figures in setting on and experiencing maturation journeys. Both youths: slip away without their mothers’ knowledge; are referred to as παῖς and τέκνον in contexts of journeying without parental awareness; listen to their elders and present witty responses resulting in amazement; are characterised by a concern for fatherly affairs and are portrayed as having a strong paternal association; pose corrective responses to their mothers whom marvel at their enigmatic behaviours and words; are depicted on a necessary journey; are reunited with their distressed mothers; return home; demonstrate experience developing into adulthood, all of which contribute to a coming of age theme. I consider whether apparent allusions or resonances could be accidental correspondences or deliberate emulations of the Homeric tradition.
|
A Digital Humanities Approach to Reconstructing the Arabic Text of The Gospels in the First Millenium: The Case of PAVONe project
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical Studies, Early Jewish and Christian Studies (EABS)
Elie Dannaoui, University of Balamand
This paper aims at presenting the role of PAVONe (Platform of the Arabic Versions of the New Testament), as a digital tool, in reconstructing the text of the Arabic translations of the Gospels in the first millenium.
It is well known that the oldest dated Arabic copy of the New Testament took place in Damascus in year 867; and it is the Arabic manuscript number 151, which was translated from the Syriac and conserved in St. Catherine monastery in Egypt. The manuscript comprises the Acts of the Apostles book, Paul’s epistles and the Catholic epistles. The oldest dated manuscript, which includes the Gospels in Arabic, is a lectionary based on the calendar of Jerusalem church. That lectionary dates to 897 and is conserved in the Arabic Sinaitic manuscript number 72. Conversely, there is a general agreement that the Arabic Vatican manuscript number 13 includes the oldest gospels text; and it dates to the 9th century.
But, what about the period before the dated manuscripts of the Gospels?
This contribution will focus on the the period from which no manuscripts of the Gospels in Arabic were obtained: Previous studies to PAVONe omitted the period from which no written texts were obtained, particularly the period before Islam until the mid of the 8th century. Consequently, the absence of manuscript copies was assumed to correspond to the absence of the translation of the Gospels. PAVONe dedicated special importance to this period and worked on collecting, identifying and transcribing all the Gospels verses cited in Christian and Muslim writings from the above-mentioned period. The results of this work offer new opportunities for researchers to understand various aspects of the Arabic translations of the Gospels and their receptions by Muslims.
|
God’s Changing Relationship with God’s House/Temple/Sanctuary and Their Overseers
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Paul Danove, Villanova University
This paper investigates the repetition of vocabulary and character referents in the Gospel of Mark to develop God’s changing relationship with God’s house (οἶκος), Temple (ἱερόν), and sanctuary (ναός) and those charged with their oversight. The introductory discussion establishes the continuity of reference among these edifices and situates God’s relationship with them in the past, present, and future of the story world of Mark. An examination of the contexts of their occurrence then clarifies God’s past positive and present negative relationship with the house and its chief priests (2:23-28; 11:15-19), God’s present negative relationship with the Temple and the chief priests, scribes, and elders, Pharisees and Herodians, and Sadducees exercising a teaching office within it (11:1-11, 15-19, 27-33; 12:18-27; 13:1-8; 14:48-52), and God’s present negative and coming positive relationship with the sanctuary and those charged with its oversight (14:55-59; 15:29-32, 37-39). The concluding discussion identifies the edifice and overseer with whom God chooses to be in a positive relationship.
|
Interpreting and Translating GINOMAI as a Verb of Process in the New Testament
Program Unit: The Greek of Jews and Christians Through the Pax Romana (EABS)
Paul Danove, Villanova University
The verb GINOMAI presents novel characteristics that pose significant difficulties for interpretation and translation into English. This paper develops these characteristics and then resolves the New Testament occurrences of the verb into ten distinct usages. The discussion of each usage specifies the licensing properties of the verb, proposes guidelines for interpretation, and offers illustrative examples of translations that clarify the implication that the verb consistently designates a process. The concluding discussion clarifies the conditions that accommodate polysemous occurrences that admit to interpretation and translation in more than one usage.
|
The Planting of the First Vineyard Following the Flood (Gen 9:20–27) in Light of Ancient Mediterranean Traditions
Program Unit: Ancient Near East
Guy Darshan, Tel Aviv University
As is well known, the accounts of the planting of the first vineyard and the discovery of wine following the Flood do not occur in any of the versions of the Mesopotamian flood story. While the fusion of these two motifs in Genesis 9 has thus traditionally been attributed to the biblical author, ancient Greek texts also combine the two themes. This paper discusses these Greek sources in the biblical context for the first time, exploring their origins and relation to other ancient Near Eastern Flood versions, and then evaluates their implications for the complexity of traditions and formation of the biblical narrative.
|
Some Tendencies in Luke’s Use of the Jewish Scriptures and Their Bearing on the Synoptic Problem
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Phillip Davis, Rheinische Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität Bonn
Study of the synoptic problem has paid surprisingly little attention to the use of the Jewish Scriptures by the evangelists. In 1993, David New published a rather limited monograph assessing synoptic quotations of the Jewish Scriptures and their bearing on the two-document and Griesbach hypotheses, and in 2011 Mark Goodacre published an article pleading for increased dialog between the study of intertextuality in the synoptic gospels and the study of the synoptic problem. While Goodacre regretted that New did not consider the Farrer hypothesis, with Alan Garrow’s postulation of Matthean posteriority (cf. M. Hengel) in his “Matthew Conflator Hypothesis”, it is worth taking a fresh examination of the evangelists’ use of Scripture in light of the full range of synoptic theories. This paper does precisely this by examining several cases not treated in the two earlier studies and asks in which direction(s) the synoptic traditions may have developed. In so doing, several particular tendencies become apparent. In particular, whereas it is well known that Matthew tends to expand scriptural citations, Luke tends to avoid double or expanded presentation of scriptural material. Luke does this in part by choosing different parts of the same allusion found in his predecessor(s). Yet what is most significant for the synoptic problem is that in several cases where Luke uniquely introduces or alters a scriptural reference, Matthew appears to have been the impetus.
|
"Thus He Has Distinguished Man from Man": Masculinity in The Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs
Program Unit: Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha
Tom de Bruin, Newbold College
This paper will examine the construction masculinity in the Early Christian text the Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs. This text contains discussions of gender and sexuality that have intrigued exegetes. As such it has been the topic of feminist and non-feminist readings for several decades, discussing the nature of women, femininity and (female) sexuality. While female sexuality is closely intertwined with the power of the opponent, it has become clear that the text has a more nuanced discussion of sexuality than appears at first sight. In particular, the construction of masculinity has not been sufficiently discussed. As a text that was produced by men for men, masculinity is not unimportant to the text.
This paper will examine masculinity as predominantly portrayed by the Testaments of Reuben, Judah, Issachar, Naphtali and Joseph; each of which show different aspects to this identity performance. While all five books focus on sexual desire for women as an obvious feature of masculinity, the way they suggest dealing with these desires and the way these desires manifest and influence men construct alternative forms of masculine sexuality. In Naphtali male sexuality is further described specifically as it relates to homosexuality and natural order. Judah and Issachar add other specific features to this construct, such as physical prowess, and spiritual and ethical simplicity. Joseph as the ‘good man’ fleshes out the construction of the perfect male, also introducing some traditionally effeminate characteristics.
The Testaments construct a variegated and nuanced masculinity to match their nuanced depiction of sexual desire and femininity. As such they bear witness to a form of early Christian masculinity that is less extremely hegemonic than that found in other ancient texts.
|
Exorcisms, Silencings, Healings and Apotropaism: The Variegated Portrayal of the Demonic in Mark
Program Unit: Dispelling Demons: Interpretations of Evil and Exorcism in Ancient Near Eastern, Jewish and Biblical Contexts (EABS)
Tom de Bruin, Newbold College
In this paper I will discuss the depiction of the demonic in the Gospel of Mark. Demons, Satan, and exorcisms have a distinct place in this gospel, and there have been numerous scholarly analyses of the precise role these evil beings play. Most recently, there has been some discussion of apotropaism, and to a lesser extent the relationship between healings and the demonic, but these facets are generally treated separately in scholarship. I argue that, for the ancient mind, they would have been a unified concept, and in this paper I will treat these components together, showing the various ways that the demonic was imagined and protected against.
Throughout Mark, Jesus deals with evil influences. Jesus’s career begins in a liminal place under the influence of a spirit: at the end of his baptism and then at the beginning of his testing. Following an implied defeat of the ruler of demons, Jesus’s career focusses on dealing with the demonic; be that the explicit demonic of possession, or the more implicit of physical sickness. Demons are exorcised, people are healed, and there are hints of apotropaic practices as well. All the while, the demons are privy to otherworldly secrets that they wish to share, which Jesus attempts to bring an end to. For Mark, Jesus and demons go hand-in-hand, and the demonic goes far beyond simply the exorcism narratives. Analysing all these influences together will give a fuller picture of the role and representation of demons in the Markan context.
In this complicated mesh of the demonic and Jesus’s anti-demonic ministry, Mark constructs a narrative where demons are dangerous, yet speak the truth; where liminality is created, emphasised, explored, but ultimately collapsed. In doing this Mark intertwines theology with satanology, demonology with Christology.
|
Predecessors of Hilma Granqvist: Women Exploring the Land(s) of the Bible before 1920
Program Unit: History of Biblical Scholarship in the Late Modern Period
Izaak J. de Hulster, Helsingin Yliopisto - Helsingfors Universitet
Hilma Granqvist conducted anthropological / ethnographical field studies in Palestine during the 1920s. She was not the first woman to do so. Many women were involved in exploring the Land(s) of the Bible, like Granqvist in ethnography but also, e.g., by composing travel reports (even when disdained as less scientific), contributing to other fields, such as botany, and through leading roles in fundraising, collecting (including, importantly, biblical manuscripts), and even by participating in excavations. Within Palestine, surprisingly many local women were active in larger archaeological projects (e.g., under Bliss at Tell el-Hesi or at the Harvard excavations of Samaria). Thus, this paper contributes an overview of women exploring the Land(s) of the Bible in the long 19th century, with consideration of historical background (in a variety of countries involved), in particular: society, images of women, politics, changes in technology and science, and developments in archaeology. Whereas Granqvist was initially interested "to find the Jewish ancestors of Scripture" (British Museum, biographical details), she ‘detached’ from this aim, researching contemporary Palestinians. In this paper, it also appears that a number of these women were not motivated by ‘the Bible’.
|
Hermeneutical Reflections on a Recently Excavated Cylinder Seal Fragment from Abel-beth-maacah
Program Unit: Iconography and Biblical Studies (EABS)
Izaak J. de Hulster, University of Helsinki
This paper presents a recently found fragment of a cylinder seal from Tel Abel Beth Maacah (Area B) and uses this as a case study for the interpretation of (cylinder) seals. Thus, this paper makes a historical, hermeneutical, and art historical contribution in general, and in particular also to the cultural history of Abel Beth Maacah.
|
The Variable Spellings of the Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical Studies, Early Jewish and Christian Studies (EABS)
Johan de Joode, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
In this contribution, I investigate the distribution of variant spellings in the Dead Sea Scrolls using principles and methods from data analysis and data visualisation. Current studies of orthography in Classical Hebrew focus primarily on the Hebrew Bible, either specifically on the diachronic evolution of spelling within the Hebrew Bible (Andersen and Forbes; Freedman et al.; Dershowitz et al.) or on the synchronic distribution of spelling re-occurrences in either block spellings or cases of rapid alternation (Barr). Despite much attention for the peculiarities of the orthography of the Dead Sea Scrolls, for instance in grammars of Qumran Hebrew, there is to date no large-scale quantitative study of orthographic variability in Scrolls research. This contribution fills that gap. Firstly, I measure the inner variability within the bounds of individual books. How much variation could one reasonably expect within a single book? I demonstrate a specific, computational method to extract spelling variation and visualise it. To do so, I present multiple aggregate models of spelling homogeneity or uniformity. Secondly, I systematically investigate the variability on the level of lexical items by constructing unique spelling profiles whose homogeneity can be compared. Are specific lexical items more prone to vary than others? Which parts of speech are most heterogeneous? This also leads to challenge of theoretically and practically distinguishing between orthographic and morphological variation. Thirdly and finally, I answer the following question: can the variable spellings be grouped in specific spelling traditions or schools? Are the spellings haphazard or do they tend to vary in more or less homogeneous groups that could possibly reflect spelling traditions (or rules?) within specific schools of scribal activity along the lines of propositions by Freedman and Mathews. In conclusion, I reflect on future avenues for research on orthography both within Scrolls research and within Digital Humanities at large.
|
Joshua's Strategy and the Strategies of Comparing Texts
Program Unit: Editorial Techniques in the Hebrew Bible in Light of Empirical Evidence (EABS)
Kristin De Troyer, Universität Salzburg
In my contribution I will survey the text critical data from a series of sources. I will focus on especially: 8:13, as this verse has been widely studied (eg. Van der Meer, Auld). The text of 8:13 can be found in the MT, but it is absent from the OG, 4QJosha, the Old Latin translation, and the reworked text of Josephus, albeit that the latter needs to be carefully considered. Whereas some scholars explain that the absence in 8:13 is due to the freedom of the translator who simply did not translate it, its absence in the other versions can not be explained as easily. In contrast to the scholars that claim that 8:13 is an omission from the Old Greek translator, I will argue that the textual evidence points to 8:13 being an addition of the MT. A series of hexaplaric manuscripts, as well as the Armenian and Ethiopic versions point to the addition of 8:13 as a plus. Moreover, in the hexaplaric tradition, 8:13 is marked sub asterisk in the Syrohexapla, and the reading is identified as a Theodotionic reading in the margins of the Syrohexapla. All these text critical data swing the pendulum in the direction of the OG representing the older Hebrew text and the MT being a later edited text.
|
"Open the Gates That the Righteous Nation May Enter": The Concept of the People of God in the Book of Isaiah
Program Unit: Prophets and Prophecy (EABS)
Jaap Dekker, Theologische Universiteit (Apeldoorn)
Synagogue buildings often display the words of Psalm 118,20 concerning the entrance of the righteous through the gate of the Lord. Some of them, for example the New Synagogue of Berlin, have chosen for the comparable words of Isaiah 26:2 welcoming the righteous nation. In the context of the Book of Isaiah, which begins with addressing Israel as ‘sinful nation, people laden with iniquity’ (Isa. 1:4) and complains about its ‘wild grapes’ (Isa. 5,4), it is not self-evident to identify ‘the righteous nation’ of Isaiah 26:2 as the people of Israel. This paper argues that the concept of the people of God is in fact redefined in the book of Isaiah. The Lord forms a nation for himself so that they might declare his praise (Isa. 43:21). He promises to the restored Zion that its people shall be all righteous (Isa. 60:21). The profile of these righteous becomes clear in the characterisation of the servants of the Lord (Isa. 65-66), the offspring of the righteous one (Isa. 53:11), among whom also foreigners are welcomed (Isa. 56:6). In the book of Isaiah righteousness seems to function as the key identity marker for the people of God. This causes the expulsion of the incorrigible wicked ones, but at the same time opens up perspectives for all peoples who want to enter and to participate. This paper will also discuss how the redefinition of the people of God in the book of Isaiah is to be related to the promise of an everlasting covenant with Israel (cf. Isa. 54:10; 55:3; 61:8).
|
"The Lord Loved Him": Solomon as Idealized Character and Paradigm for Character Ethics within the "Solomonic" Canon
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israel and in ANE Wisdom Literature (EABS)
Katharine Dell, University of Cambridge
This paper will argue that from the first mention of Solomon in 2 Sam 12:24 where we are told that "The Lord loved Him", he is portrayed in an idealized light, as somewhat of a cardboard cut-out of a character who can do no wrong. Despite a light critique of his actions towards the end of the 1 Kings account, the canon takes up this same idealization which is based on his role as the highest ethical paradigm - the embodiment of wisdom. In Proverbs, the characterization is reduced to authoritative voice, but in Ecclesiastes there is an interesting use of his ideal character as a paradigm not for emulation but for a test of the worth and/or worthlessness of wisdom. In the Song of Songs whilst he is also an authoritative voice, as in Proverbs, he also appears as a character evoking remembrance of his wealth and wisdom. The essential character of Solomon as wise king chosen and "loved" by God runs throughout his portrayal and provides an ethical paradigm for those seeking to become wise. Sirach provides a fitting summary of Solomon's 'fame': 'Your songs, proverbs, and parables, and the answers you gave astounded the nations' (Sir 47:14).
|
Sheger in the Balaam Inscription
Program Unit: Northwest Semitic Epigraphy Related to the Biblical World (EABS)
Aaron Demsky, Bar-Ilan University
This paper attempts to shed new light on the little known Canaanite goddess Sheger, who is mentioned in the Balaam inscription, one of the most important inscriptions found in Transjordan. She is mentioned as well in Ugarit and in the Phoenician onomasticon. In all likelihood, Sheger is the consort of ‘Ashtor, and should be recognized by her more common manifestation, i.e., ‘Ashtoret, the goddess of animal fertility. It is noteworthy that both feminine divine names are found in the demythologized biblical parallel shegar ’alefekha ve ‘ashtarot ẓonekha “the calving of your herd and the lambing of your flocks” (Deut 7:13,28,51; 28:4,18).
Sheger appears with ‘Ashtor in the Balaam inscription significantly in the context of a list of animals. It is ‘Ashtor’s function that has been an anomaly. In Ugarit, he plays a secondary role to the other male deities like Ba‘al, Mot and Yam, though he does take Ba‘al’s place in his absence. There may be more behind this relationship regarding the divine order and its geographic worldly boundaries.
‘Ashtor appears in the Transjordanian context in the Balaam inscription and particularly as ‘Ashtor-Kemosh, the patron deity of King Mesha, the great sheep herder. It would seem that that area, known for its pasture land, may indeed be his domain. In fact there might even be mythic symbolism distinguishing between the agricultural character of Cisjordan under Ba‘al’s rule as opposed to the animal rearing/herding domain of Transjordan under ‘Ashtor. This recognition of the natural ecology is strengthened by the place names Phahil “breeding ram”, Ashtorot and Karnaim, as well as the toponyms Botzrah, Lidvir, Naveh and Deir-`Alla
|
From Drowned World to Ecclesial Bestiary: Noah's Ark in the Beatus Apocalypses
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
Christopher Denny, Saint John's University
Beatus of Liébana's Commentary on the Apocalypse incorporates a commentary of Gregory of Elvira on Noah's Ark. Noah's Ark is for Gregory an allegorical prefiguration of the Church, and Gregory does not directly expound on the Genesis flood. Text accompanying the illustrations in Beatus's commentary differs from that in other early medieval manuscripts where Noah's Ark is painted.
In contrast to other late antique and early medieval illustrations of Noah's ark, arks in the early Beatus manuscripts are open-form structures without floodwaters, loosening the connection to Genesis and to patristic apocalyptic reinterpretations of the flood. Depictions of Noah's ark in the early Beatus manuscripts differ from the iconography of the ark in the "Cotton Genesis" tradition of Noah's Ark illustrations examined by Kurt Weitzmann and Herbert Kessler.
Following an article by Marianne Besseyre, I propose that these Beatus Noah's Ark illustrations be interpreted as a medieval bestiary, and one textual source for the Beatus bestiary is Gregory the Great's Moralia in Job. Understanding these images as bestiaries explains their unique depictions of the Noahide cycle. Beatus's illustrators needed to adapt the patristic trope of ark as church to portray a differentiated boat containing both orthodox believers and heresiarchs. Since Beatus was engaged in countering the adoptionist Christology of the archbishop Elipandus of Toledo, his later illustrators needed a way to depict a more differentiated boat whose cargo included both orthodox believers and heresiarchs such as Elipandus. Precedent for a division of the church into saints and sinners could already be found in the fourth-century African Donatist theologian Tyconius, whose commentary on the Book of Revelation was a major source for Beatus's own commentary. Visualizing Noah's ark as a bestiary allowed Beatus's illustrators to complement his differentiated understanding of the no-longer pure church.
|
Word Order in the Septuagint within Post-Classical Greek
Program Unit: Septuagint Studies
Marieke Dhont, University of Cambridge
This paper focuses on the question of word order in the Septuagint within the linguistic framework of Post-Classical Greek. The reflection of Hebrew word order is one of the constituent criteria for the characterization of any Septuagint book as a literal translation. Deviation from Hebrew word order, in this view, is seen as a sign of freedom on the part of the translator. What, however, may have motivated this freedom? How "free" could translators really be in their stylistic choices relating to word order? In this paper, I will compare three books with different translation characters and traditionally dated to different times — Genesis, Job, and Ecclesiastes — to show how insight into the development of the Greek language can help our understanding of the Septuagint's translators and their techniques.
|
The Intersection of Biblical Lament and Psychotherapy in the Healing of Trauma Memories
Program Unit: Psychological Hermeneutics of Biblical Themes and Texts
June Frances Dickie, University of KwaZulu-Natal
A study of biblical lament psalms can help present-day sufferers express their own pain to God. Lament is prayer that is born in the deepest secrets of abandonment and loss. It expresses passionate yearning for the presence of God Himself, and urges God to intervene (to speak and to act) in a situation that has become intolerable.
In this empirical study, Zulu “pain-bearers” first studied Psalms 3 and 13 and then wrote and performed their own laments. The biblical laments provide a model for their contemporary laments, with the inclusion of complaints (often in the form of rhetorical questions) and petitions (including for justice to be executed on their perpetrators). They also show a swing of mood, with a dialogue in tension between “the voice of experience” and “the voice of truth”. Their compositions and performances are considered in the light of cognitive psychological theories (e.g. those of Brewin and Holmes, and Van der Kolk and Van der Hart) as well as the theory of Judith Herman, including the three stages of post-trauma healing. Lament fits well into the second stage, and fits too into current research into ways to facilitate the healthy processing of trauma memories (using the research insights of Cozolino). The level of stress that is concomitant with being creative (as in learning something new, and composing and performing one’s own lament) can enable the sufferer to process the painful trauma memory (so that it no longer intrudes). Moreover, in line with dual replacement theory, the sufferer can replace negative pictures associated with the trauma with stronger positive metaphors in his/her poem. Thus it is posited that understanding biblical lament in the light of models of psychotherapy can result in the contemporary practice of lament which can contribute to the healing of trauma.
|
New Metaphors Create New Reality: Zulu Youth Find Fresh Meaning in Ancient Psalms
Program Unit: Bible Translation Workshop (EABS)
June Frances Dickie, University of KwaZulu-Natal
The Psalms make extensive use of metaphors to denote characteristics of YHWH as well as situations which the psalmist experiences. Some of the metaphors are not particularly meaningful to Zulu youth living in South Africa in the 21st century. Thus, when they were invited to compose and perform their own translations of some biblical praise-psalms, the young people introduced new metaphors which spoke to them in their Zulu culture and context.
However, the translations followed the literary-rhetorical approach of Ernst Wendland, and sought to be close to the original Hebrew text in using poetic devices which achieved the same functions as those in the Hebrew. Moreover, as the Zulu community prefers oral communication for important messages, the translations utilised principles of orality and performance, thereby maintaining some of the significant oral features in the Hebrew text.
Hawkes (1972) suggests that in predominantly-oral societies, rhythm and metaphor are essential, and that “Poetry nourishes the imagination by means of new combinations of thoughts”. The compositions of the Zulu youth show such new combinations as well as the use of literary rhythm to provide memorable and meaningful translations. Hawkes also notes that “Metaphor can … create new reality”, and this was found to be the case, when novel usage of imagery provided exegetical insights.
Further, the ambiguity apparent in many psalms “gives room for alternative reactions to the same piece of language” (Empson) and again this was found to be the case. As Hawkes notes, often the audience must “complete the meaning” from their own experience, and consequently the Zulu youth introduced new interpretations to some Hebrew expressions, which spoke into their situations. The results suggest that valuable insights can be obtained if community members are invited to use their indigenous oral art to translate biblical psalms.
|
Timo Veijolas Beitrag zur Erforschung der Samuelbücher
Program Unit: Editorial Techniques in the Hebrew Bible in Light of Empirical Evidence (EABS)
Walter Dietrich, Universität Bern - Université de Berne
This paper discusses Timo Veijola's contribution to the study of the Book of Samuel. The paper will be given in German. A paper with the English translation will be distributed.
|
A Re-examination of Homonymic and Polysemic Roots from the Book of Ben Sira
Program Unit: Judaica
Haim Dihi, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
In my lecture today, I will present additional results from the research that I began last year, the first findings of which were presented at the SBL conference that took place last year in Berlin. In this research, an attempt was made to re-examine roots from the book of Ben Sira that are classified as homonymous and polysemous and to examine the relations between them.
The re-examination will be carried out in light of the method suggested by Prof. Chaim Cohen in his article in the Shalom Paul Festschrift Birkat Shalom (2008) concerning homonymic and polysemic roots in the Bible. The examination of the roots in Ben Sira will include a comparison with Biblical evidence
Below, a few roots from the vocabulary of Ben Sira that are traditionally classified as homonymous. They were re-examined, and some of them will be presented in my lecture today.
I ʾmn = to believe, to be faithful; II ʾmn = to educate
I btsr = to pick grapes; II btsr = to prevent
I hgy = to ponder; II hgy = to remove
I hll = to praise; II hll = to lighten up
I zhr = to caution; II zhr = to lighten up
I chbr = joining; II chbr = to perform magic
I chrsh = to plow; II chrsh = to plot; III chrsh = to be silent
|
Imaging Christ in the Twenty-First Century Lectionary
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Culture
Amanda Dillon, Trinity College Dublin
One area of visual culture that is frequently overlooked when describing art that illustrates the Bible are those contemporary graphic designs that appear in liturgical books such as lectionaries, sacramentaries and missals, and the primary worship books found in the pews of different congregations. This paper shall present the graphic designs of the American artist Nicholas Markell, who was commissioned by Augsburg Fortress Press to create a corporate body of illustrations for a new series (Evangelical Lutheran Worship) of liturgical books including the Revised Common Lectionary, for the Evangelical Lutheran Church of America. These were published in 2006. A Social Semiotics of the Visual, an emerging methodology developed by Kress and van Leeuwen shall provide the theoretical framework for this exploration of the artistic interpretation, this reception in graphic design, of the biblical lections found in this iconic reception of the biblical text. Lectionaries offer a curated selection of biblical texts within the annual and cyclical structure of the liturgical seasons. These books bring the biblical text into the liturgical domain where they perform the semantic and iconic authority of the Bible. This makes these books themselves already a very particular and interesting site of the reception of Bible. The focus in this paper shall be on the design ‘Easter' as a visual reception of selected texts from the liturgical season of Easter.
|
Sign, Performance, Possession, Home: What Are Non-royal Phoenician Mortuary Stelae Doing?
Program Unit: Ancient Near East
Helen Dixon, Wofford College
Nearly 100 non-royal inscribed and/or carved stelae from known or suspected mortuary contexts have been catalogued from the Phoenician Levantine coast. This study reexamines the earliest iterations of the phenomenon, focusing on those that come from provenanced settings in the Iron Age II-Persian periods (ca. 1000 – 300 BCE). Beginning by reviewing the important contributions of Cross (2002), Sader (2005), Doak (2015), Hays (2015), and others to our understanding of this corpus, the paper then offers a reconstruction of the semantic constellation surrounding the appearance of these mortuary stelae in the Phoenician Levant in the Iron II period. The seeming interchangeability of image and inscription, the sparse grammatical markers in those bearing text, and the parallels with wall carvings in Phoenician contexts in Sicily and Sardinia bearing haunting human imagery (perhaps portraits of the deceased, perhaps images of divine or semi-divine beings) all offer an opportunity to read these inscribed objects not simply as markers of family or personal status and identity, but also as a performative element in the transition into ‘deadness’, or even as a new home for the deceased.
|
Amid Silence and Violence: Jeremiah 36 and the Emergence of Written Discourse in Ancient Israel and Judah
Program Unit: Deconstructive Poetics (EABS)
F.W.Dobbs-Allsopp, Princeton Theological Seminary
The hallmark of developed biblical prose narrative is an incipient kind of free indirect discourse that features the use of the third person without the assumption of a speaking subject. As R. Alter (1981) contends, the best analog to such a narrative style is modern “prose fiction.” I am broadly interested in probing the antecedents to this mature style in the vernacular alphabetic writings from the ancient Levant, including materials (narrative and nonnarrative alike) from the Bible. My intuition is that the prose style of the Bible did not arise in a single go and that the emergent forms of textuality that likely prevailed in a pre-Hellenistic Levant always thoroughly oral in orientation will have proscribed the kinds of fictionality then achievable. In this paper, I leverage Jeremiah 36 and its themes of silence and violence toward a sighting of several instances of such incipient fictionality that both anticipate and make possible the speaker-less narrator of this biblical story, a story which itself is played out amidst silence and violence.
|
Parenting like a Patriarch: Sacrificial Discourses Surrounding the Death of Children in Late Antiquity.
Program Unit: Families and Children in the Ancient World
Maria E Doerfler, Yale University
The Akedah, the binding of Isaac in Genesis 22, is without question one of the most prominent biblical motifs in late ancient exegesis. Patristic writers in particular cherished the typological valence of the passage: Abraham's willingness to sacrifice his only son at the behest of the deity could be said to foreshadow God's equally willing sacrifice of Christ in the Incarnation. Contemporary scholarship has traced these theological themes in considerable depth. By contrast, another strand of interpretation has received far less attention: the exemplar function of Abraham's "sacrifice" for late ancient families who had lost a child to death. Death in infancy or childhood was a common occurrence in late antiquity, as scholarship by Roger Bagnall, Bruce Frier, Tim Parkin, and others has amply demonstrated. Consolation literature -- or writings designed to encourage parents' acquiescence to a child's passing -- accordingly proliferated in late antiquity. From the third century onward and well into the Byzantine period, these writings, whether addressed to the individual bereaved or to a congregation in which many families had suffered a similar fate, frequently call on parents to emulate Abraham. Like the latter had willingly, even cheerfully, late ancient sources averred, sacrificed his son, so parents ought to regard their dead children as sacrifices demanded by and earmarked for God. Indeed, authors pointed out, unlike Abraham, Christian mothers and fathers did not have to go to the trouble of tying down and personally wielding the knife against their offspring; their pious assent to a child's death was all that was required for them to participate in and reap the merits alongside their patriarchal exemplar. This paper explores the developing discourse of sacrifice surrounding Genesis 22 as applied to parental bereavement in ancient Christian sources.
|
Imitating Sacrifice: Doubling Abraham in Biblical and Patristic Imagination
Program Unit: Biblical Interpretation in Early Christianity
Mari E Doerfler, Yale University
The call to imitation looms large in the ethical instructions of late ancient authors. Homilists, hymnodists, and correspondents could draw upon a cadre of heroes from the Hebrew Scriptures -- as well as not a few foils -- by whose examples to direct their audiences' moral, spiritual, and practical comportment. Different topical loci attracted different practices, as scholars like Marcia Colish and Blake Leyerle have demonstrated. This paper aims to elucidate a particular area of patristic engagement with mimesis: that of bereavement and consolation, particularly where these twin movements concerned the death of a child. Late ancient exegetes drew on a wide range of biblical characters to illumine to their interlocutors how to grieve -- or avoid grieving -- in such instances: the deaths of Job's and David's children, the murder of the so-called Holy Innocents, even the death of Abel at the hands of Cain could be deployed to inculcate biblically-endorsed responses in bereaved parents. One of the most popular examples for approaching the death of a child nevertheless was Abraham's response to the divinely-demanded sacrifice of Isaac; homilists across the Roman Empire commended Abraham's faith and faithfulness as worthy of imitation to Christians. Intriguingly, however, exponents recognized a discomfiting double for the Genesis 22 account in the Hebrew Scriptures as well: the sacrifice of Jephthah's daughter in Judges 11. For patristic writers, Jephthah's willingness to fulfil his gruesome disclosed the dark side of Abraham's responsiveness to the divine, and frequently troubled late ancient accounts of the Akedah as well. Interpreters and their audiences wrestled with the challenge of being like Abraham without being like Jephthah, in the process exploring the limits of mimesis. This paper examines the patristic challenge to discern the ethics of imitation amidst the hopes and horrors of these texts.
|
The Sage on Power: An Examination of Qoheleth’s Perspective on Socio-political and Religious Power
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Jerome Douglas, Valley Forge College
Relations with the king, considerations of the oppressed, and ruminations on order within the cosmos are among the socio-political and religious power dynamics that Qoheleth references in Ecclesiastes. Contemporary Biblical Criticism has often examined texts through the lens of social-political authority with consideration to topics such as the center and margins of power. Scholars wrestle with how these texts position themselves juxtaposed with these considerations. These power deliberations related to Ecclesiastes have not fully examined the impact of Qoheleth’s polemics, in the text, against apocalyptic thought and the corresponding impact upon the authors construct of social power. This paper gives attention to selected texts within Ecclesiastes that treat the power of royalty, the marginality of the oppressed, the established order with this life, and polemics against apocalyptic thought. The purpose of this investigation is to examine how Qoheleth uses the aforementioned concerns to communicate a message for the audience regarding these socio-political and religious dynamics.
|
Failure to Fit: Textual Strategies for Crafting Change
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Eric Douglass, Randolph-Macon College
This paper will explore how Markan stories are designed to change the worldview of readers. Authors write with their intended audience in mind, recognizing that they will apply their existing culture to the opening words, and so reproduce their existing culture from the text. If authors desire to change that worldview, they will need to disrupt this process, so that readers do not produce ‘sameness’ from the text.
Authors still begin with the public language of the intended audience and expect readers to construct ‘traditional’ meaning-bits from these words. The disruption occurs when readers attempt to fit these bits into their existing way of thinking, only to find that some resist incorporation. In short, authors instantiate whole systems in their texts, and when readers apply a different system, they create ‘parts’ that do not fit into their own system’s ‘whole.’ Instead of finding a repetition of culture, readers create disjunctive elements that require a creative reorganization of the pieces, where they must puzzle out new relations to account for these non-fitting elements.
In Mark, these creative shifts are often marked by various forms of commentary, which are designed to shape the ‘reorganizing’ process. In the first exorcism, the author has Jesus ordering an unclean spirit without the usual means (prayer, amulets, etc.). The author knew that such would confuse readers, as it violates their worldview (Malina’s “cosmic hierarchy”), and would likely engender surprise (1:27) and aberrant explanations (3:22). Hence, the author offers commentary via that spirit, where it recognizes Jesus’ higher authority, and even his power to ‘destroy’ demons. These meaning-bits require readers to creatively reorganize the text’s elements, resulting in a new system for the storyworld, and attendant shifts in the reader’s underlying worldview.
|
Bethel in the Wars of Ambush in Josh 7-8 and Judg 19-21
Program Unit: Editorial Techniques in the Hebrew Bible in Light of Empirical Evidence (EABS)
Thomas Dozeman, United Theological Seminary
Interpreters have long noted the similarity between the wars of ambush in Josh 7-8 and Judg 19-21, raising questions of literary dependence and inner-biblical composition. The stories share unique motifs, including the language of ambush itself (Josh 8:2, 12; Judg 20:29); the description of the advance for battle (Josh 8:11; Judg 20:34); the enemy’s lack of knowledge of the ambush (Josh 8:14; Judg 20:34); and the smoke that ascends to heaven as a signal (Josh 8:20; Judg 20:40). They also share the same general setting of Benjamin with an emphasis Bethel. In Judg 20-21 the tribes led by Judah repeatedly worship and receive oracles at Bethel; while in Josh 8 the citizens of Bethel join Ai in warring against Joshua. The paper will explore how Bethel acquired such a contrasting role in these parallel narratives and what the motive of the authors may have been.
|
“For the Whole Period of Your Faith Will Be of No Use Unless You Are Found Perfect in the Last Time” (Did. 16:2): Salvation by Works in the Didache and the Shepherd of Hermas?
Program Unit: Apostolic Fathers and Related Early Christian Literature
Jonathan Draper, University of KwaZulu-Natal
The Pauline understanding of salvation by grace alone appropriated by faith without works of the law has dominated Christian soteriology, particularly since Augustine. However, it is not the only or perhaps even the earliest understanding of the saving work of Jesus. This paper argues that an eschatological belief in the imminent coming of Jesus as the Messiah to inaugurate the new age, in the perspective of the Jewish Christian Didache and the Shepherd of Hermas, makes perfect fulfillment of Torah by Jews and at least observance of the ethical law derived from it by Gentiles even more urgent. Covenantal nomism provides the basis for initiation into the Christian community, as well as for their ongoing common life as believers, and their destiny in the final judgment when the Lord comes.
|
How al-Shayṭān Got His Name: The Arabic Recensions of the Narratives from the Syriac Cave of Treasures
Program Unit: Quran and Islamic Tradition in Comparative Perspective
Rachel Dryden, University of Cambridge
The importance of the Syriac Cave of Treasures for understanding the qur’ānic account of Iblīs’ refusal to worship Adam, has recently been confirmed by a number of scholars, who have shown how the Qur’ān engages with a number of texts in retelling this story. Material from the Cave of Treasures appears in various Arabic texts, such as the Kitāb al-majāll, the Apocalypse of Peter, and the Qalēmentōs traditions. Despite this, they do not appear to have been studied and no translation exists in any Western language, of the Arabic text, that appeared in Bezold’s Die Schatzhöhle (1888). A new critical edition of, and commentary on the Cave of Treasures, by John Reeves, expected to be published in the next few years, will correct this, by including the Arabic material. Although the Arabic texts are not simply translations of the Syriac, they use material from the Cave of Treasures and were clearly influenced by its style. They would thus appear to be important witnesses to the oral tradition that preserved these narratives and therefore invaluable in understanding the links between this cycle of stories and the qur’ānic text. This paper analyses the Arabic material that appears in the text published but not translated by Bezold and evaluate the relationships between the Syriac – Arabic – Qur’ānic recensions, focussing on the description of the fall of the Devil and his naming, as in the Cave of Treasures, III,6. The significant amount of scholarship the qur’ānic recension of this particular episode has recently attracted makes this a good choice of narrative for analysis. This paper not only sheds light on this one qur’ānic narrative but addresses the broader question of the interaction between biblical, extra-biblical and qur’ānic; textual and oral texts, and highlight the importance of Syriac and Syriac-related studies for qur’ānic research.
|
Bulgarian Parabiblical Tradition: When Modernity Meets Orthodoxy
Program Unit: Slavonic Parabiblical Traditions (EABS)
Ewelina Drzewiecka, Polish Academy of Sciences
The paper raises the question of how biblical tradition functions in modern culture from the perspective of the history of ideas and cultural transfer. It focuses on the case of Bulgarian culture and consists of two parts. The first part is devoted to the general context of actualizing and adapting biblical tradition in Bulgarian culture. I will present the main reference points and influences and aim to show the para-biblical nature of the phenomena under conditions of modernity. The second part gives a brief analysis of some literary texts that paraphrase biblical stories in order to reveal their hermeneutic potential as cultural para-phrases, and thus, testimonies of para-religious searching. It is suggested that Bulgarian parabiblical tradition in a modern sense is a witness to a meeting between modern ideas and Slavic Orthodoxy.
|
"... And Hannah Went home, without Samuel": Why Children's Bibles Matter to Contemporary Bible Interpretation; A Case Study
Program Unit: Contextual Interpretation of the Bible (Hebrew Bible/Old Testament and New Testament)
Jaqueline S. du Toit, University of the Free State (South Africa)
Children’s Bibles have a centuries’ long history of social reproduction in Judaeo-Christian religious communities. As stories intended for initiates - intended to interpret the Bible for those on religious establishments’ periphery (children, women as caregivers, newly converted adults) - children's Bibles express an agenda beyond simply making children interested in the Bible. As opposed to formal Bible commentaries, produced and consumed by the religious and scholarly elites, these books connect Bible-informed ideologies with the routines of everyday life in ways focused on the experience of an audience at or on the margins of the religion’s centre. This assumes the child as convert and the children’s Bible or Bible storybook as preferencing the introduction of contemporaneous social values over Bible content transmission. These Bibles could therefore always easily accommodate “straying narratives” (Ruth Bottigheimer) and excision of socially problematic thematic content (child abandonment in 1 Sam 1; fratricide in Gen 4; rape in Gen 34; child sacrifice in Judg 11; etc.) without raising questions about faithful adherence to the source text. This is well documented by Ruth Bottigheimer and Penny Gold. However, both historiographers predict the emergence of a “new generation of texts” representing “a return to canon” by the end of the twentieth century. This paper will use the “Author’s Note” in Ellen Frankel’s award winning 2009, "JPS Illustrated Children’s Bible", to describe how this new generation of biblical texts works and point to their predictive relevance to any understanding of 21st century religion and society.
|
“What Does God See in Him?” Seeing the Unseen in Samuel’s Anointing of David
Program Unit: Vision and Envisionment in the Bible and its World (EABS)
Tyler Duckworth, Universität Wien
Biblical scholarship has recognized the prominent presence of the motif of sight, vision, and appearance in Samuel’s anointing of David in 1 Samuel 16:1-13. This scholarly recognition comes broadly in two forms: 1) identifying terminology pertaining to sight in the pericope, and 2) discussing the textual theological anthropology that distinguishes between Samuel’s human sight and God’s divine sight that, respectively, see outer and inner character. While this visual gap in sight between Samuel and God is generally discussed in its theological context, this reading stops short of examining how sight is being used in the narrative to develop characterization.
In this paper, I analyze how the motif of vision in 1 Samuel 16:1-13 story ties into the introductory characterization of David. I examine both sensory terminology pertaining to sight and visual dramatic cues in how the narrative unfolds in 1 Samuel 16:1-13. I will argue that the narrator’s use of vision in the narrative aligns the audience’s visual information with Samuel’s. The contrast in sight that the narrator creates between Samuel and God draws the audience’s attention to what Samuel cannot see: i.e., David’s inner character. David’s inner qualities that make him God’s choice as Saul’s kingly successor remain unstated in the text and thereby become hidden from the audience’s own sight. I claim that the narrator uses visual information to obscure David’s inner character. The narrator uses vision to generate an unseen space for the audience to speculate what qualities God sees in David as his story unfolds in the Samuel-Kings narrative that follows.
|
Cultivating Rûaḥ in the Ethos of Proverbs
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israel and in ANE Wisdom Literature (EABS)
Tyler Duckworth, Universität Wien
This presentation stems from the research findings of my dissertation chapter investigating the meaning of rûaḥ in the book of Proverbs. Drawing upon cognitive linguistic approaches, I found that the word rûaḥ in Proverbs pertains primarily to human mentality and temperament. Within this subset of cognitive usage, however, I also observed an implicit apprehension about people governing their rûaḥ. Based upon my findings, I argue that the book of Proverbs regards human rûaḥ as a psychosomatic hazard that must be moderated and cultivated for the proper acquisition of wisdom. The ethical impetus for this concern in Proverbs is twofold: (1) rûaḥ acts as a psychosomatic “organ” that transmits and maintains vitality throughout the human person, thereby connecting their physical health and respiration with their psychological health and temperament; and (2) Proverbs depicts human rûaḥ as mutable in its ethical character (cf. 11:13; 16:18; 17:27), but also volatile to control (cf. 14:29; 16:32; 25:28; 29:11) and susceptible to breaking (cf. 15:4, 13; 17:22; 18:14). As a result of the psychosomatic nature of rûaḥ, any disequilibrium of rûaḥ presents a distinct threat to the well-being of the human person in their totality and, subsequently, the didactic character-building goals of Proverbs.
|
“The Oil of Gladness” and Priestly Investiture in the Epistle to the Hebrews
Program Unit: Epistle to the Hebrews
Justin Harrison Duff, University of St. Andrews
The anointment of Jesus with the “oil of gladness” (Heb 1:9) is broadly regarded as a royal investiture. Jesus’s anointment is associated with enthronement, the scepter, and the kingdom (Heb 1:8). The citation in Heb 1:8–9 is also drawn from Psalm 44 LXX, a hymn celebrating Israel’s king. The pronounced relationship between Jesus’s anointment and his kingship, however, may overshadow another function of the oil: high priestly consecration. Like Israel’s kings, Levitical priests were anointed with “holy oil” at their installment (Exodus 29–30, Leviticus 8, 11QT 15:3–16:4) and the high priest was called the “anointed priest” (Lev 4:3, 16:32). Moreover, Hebrews’ “main point” (8:1–2) is that Jesus became a high priest after Melchizedek’s order, a royal ruler and holy minister in the heavenly sanctuary.
Although some scholars have briefly considered a priestly anointment in Heb 1:9, the possibility has not been explored in depth and is rarely brought into conversation with the greater Septuagint and second temple tradition. In this paper, I engage these traditions and propose that the anointment in Hebrews appears to consecrate Jesus for two offices: high priest and king. When read against Jewish apocalyptic and early Christian texts in particular, divine anointment may further signal a bodily transformation that safeguards new priests for heavenly space. I therefore suggest that Jesus’s anointment may be connected to his inheritance of the “indestructible life” required by priests after Melchizedek’s order (7:16–17), a quality of life devoid of physical weakness that endures forever in the heavens (7:28).
|
The Idiom of "Wailing and Gnashing Teeth"
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
Rodney Duke, Appalachian State University
This paper examines the idiom of wailing and gnashing teeth that is found in Matthew and Luke. Given that this expression, as found in the mouth of Jesus, is formulaic, symbolic, involves eschatological projection, and is found within Matthew’s apocalyptic chapter (Ch. 24), one can identify it as apocalyptic in nature. After identifying some erroneous presuppositions that are often brought to the interpretation of eschatological, judgment texts in which the clause occurs, the paper turns to a fresh look at the idiom and, as a result, moves away from popular interpretations. The idiom occurs in an independent clause with set formulaic wording. The two actions of wailing and gnashing teeth must be examined not separately, but as a single idiom. The idiom should not be understood as action of those receiving judgment. Drawing on Ugaritic parallels, it is most likely that this was a funerary expression in the mouth of mourners. Therefore, this idiom does not support a conclusion that the recipients of judgment existed in a continued state of anguish.
|
A Critique of Substitutionary Atonement
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Rodney Duke, Appalachian State University
This paper is specifically a critique of Simon Gathercole’s book, Defending Substitution, but with the understanding that Gathercole’s arguments are fairly representative of those who understand Paul’s language of Jesus’ atonement to be substitutionary. That position contends that Jesus died ‘instead of sinners’, replacing them in his death. I primarily offer an exegetical critique based on an OT understanding of Paul’s language, in which I do not find a mechanism of substitution. In this paper I examine three main arguments for substitution. The first one draws on Paul’s atonement language of the scapegoat ritual as found in Leviticus 16. Another draws on the Suffering Servant language of Isaiah 53, to which Paul alludes in 1 Corinthians 15:3-4. The third argument draws on parallels from classical literature, in which one person dies vicariously for another person, and argues that Paul’s language in Roman 5:6-8 alludes to these classical examples. In the first two cases, I explain why a literal substitution is not the key mechanism found in the scapegoat ritual or the Suffering Servant of Isaiah 53. In the third case, I explain why the claim of parallel allusions does not work.
|
“What She Did Will Be Said”: Pleasure, Pain, and Words in Mark’s Gospel
Program Unit: Bodies of Communication (EABS)
Nicole Wilkinson Duran, First Presbyterian Church of Cape May
The reader’s attention in Mark’s gospel rarely leaves the human body. Broken and healed, hungry and fed, bleeding, leprous, bruising itself with stones or being beaten and executed by its enemies; the story of Jesus’ ministry and mission is written out with letters formed from the human body. Pain goes unspoken, as it must (Scarry). Yet the passion narrative—the story to which Mark’s gospel seems always to be headed-- begins not with suffering but with the anointing woman’s speechless act, intended to give Jesus physical pleasure. Like the gospel’s pain, this pleasure is unspoken, yet an integral part of the words of the gospel, as Jesus points out (Mark 14:9). This paper will examine the role of the woman’s gift of physical pleasure as a backdrop to the suffering that follows it in this gospel, with special attention to the relevance of gender, words, and wordlessness.
|
Canonical Framings of the Twelve
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
Oliver Dyma, Katholische Stiftungshochschule Benediktbeuern
The book of the Twelve constitutes a peculiarity with regard to canonical formation and framings. On a first level, there is this group of twelve writings intertwined by redactional means into one collection with its own opening and closing.
On a second level, there are strong intertextual links to the so called major prophets, especially Isaiah, e.g. by the motif of the pilgrimage of nations. Thus the Twelve have a closing force with in the latter prophets. On a third level, there is the frame around the former and latter prophets constituted by Jos 1-Mal 3 while Mal 3 also refers to the Pentateuch. A fourth level would comprise the different roles of the Twelve within various canonical configurations, i.e. the Tanakh, the LXX, and Christian Old Testament canons. Together with the other prophetic writings, the Twelve also play a major role within combined Old and New Testament canon(s) which constitutes a fifth level of analysis.
This paper explores these different levels of canonical framings focusing on the second and fourth level and their interplay. It takes into consideration the difference in sequence displayed by various codices and canon lists. It will then reflect upon the popular position in Christian canons at the end of the Old Testament and its connections to the New Testament writings, especially the beginnings and the ending of the New Testament.
|
Center and Periphery: Spatial Concepts in the Psalms
Program Unit: Centralization and Cult in Persian Period Israel: Biblical, Historical and Comparative Perspectives (EABS)
Oliver Dyma, KSFH Benediktbeuern
Psalms 120–134 are sometimes called Pilgrim Psalms (or Songs of Ascent), and K. Seybold has suggested that they should be understood as individual stages of an actual pilgrimage. Unfortunately, such historical conclusions are difficult to draw. It is more promising to evaluate the rich collection of religious imagery and traditions found in the psalms and—with regard to the topic of centralization—in particular their spatial concepts.
The Songs of Ascent feature a horizontal worldview with a stark opposition of center and periphery. This paper delineates their concept and compares it to the concepts of other psalms, especially to the Zion traditions in the Psalms. Subsequently, it relates it to the ones of several other theological approaches, namely the Priestly Code, Deuteronomy, and Chronicles, as well as some examples from the Ancient Near East. The dichotomy of center and periphery seems to be a fundamental part of the religious perception of the world and may well antedate religio-political attempts toward cult centralization.
On a methodological level, the examination of spatial (along with temporal) concepts is proven to be a valuable tool to compare and distinguish various texts and approaches.
|
Naming Emotions in Early Christian Monasticism
Program Unit: Emotions and the Biblical World (EABS)
Daniel Eastman, Yale University
The present paper explores the early Christian monastic discourse of emotions from the point of view of Monique Scheer’s category of emotion-naming as a discrete type of emotion practice. I argue that Christian monks in Egypt and the near east in late antiquity drew creatively on a variety of pre-existing anthropologies of emotion in order to shape a particularly monastic conception of emotions as embodied thoughts that could be trained by the ascetic practitioner. Specifically, the paper charts the development of the categories of pathē and ḥaše (typically translated as “passions”) in Greek and Syriac monastic writers of the fourth and fifth centuries, focusing in particular on Evagrius of Pontus, Isaiah of Scetis, and John of Apamea. These writers, drawing on earlier anthropological categories in Greek medical and philosophical literature, named certain emotions as irrational or rational, natural or unnatural, and as variously situated vis-à-vis the body and the soul. In so doing, they thereby helped to establish a monastic discourse that valued particular emotions over others, and that linked them to ascetic practices – such as fasting, psalmody, and prescribed social interactions – aimed at the mobilization or regulation of certain emotions.
|
On Writing a Commentary: Experiences and Perspectives on Research to Deuteronomy
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Law
Eckart Otto, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
The paper will respond to the lectures of D. Markl, T. Römer, R. Müller and R. Achenbach and line out perspectives on future research on the Pentateuch and Biblical Law.
|
Hab 3 and Its Relation to Hab 1-2
Program Unit: Intersections: A Forum for Research on Ancient Israel, Hebrew Bible, and Cognate Topics (EABS)
Franziska Ede, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
According to internal evidence (superscriptions), the book of Habakkuk breaks down into two major sections: An oracle in Hab 1f and a prayer in Hab 3. Already this superficial observation implies that Hab 3 constitutes a unit distinct from the preceding chapters. And, indeed, Hab 3 no longer continues the prophecies pertaining ‒ in one way or another ‒ to the Chaldeans, but describes a prophetic vision, in which Habakkuk sees Yhwh approach for universal judgment. The distinctions with regard to form and content have long been recognized and have led to the conclusion that Hab 3 may not represent an integral part of the book. This assumption is sometimes corroborated with reference to 1QpHab, the interpretation of which is restricted to Hab 1f. Following the afore-mentioned observations it has been suggested that the theophany in Hab 3:3‒15 relies on formerly independet material that was adopted by a redactor, who integrated the theophany into the extant book through the redactional verses Hab 3:2, 16. The redactional character of vv. 2, 16 is explained by the assumption that they ‒ unlike the remainder of Hab 3 ‒ share motifs and terminology with the preceding literary context. Contrary to this relative consensus our analysis will attempt to show that ‒ beyond Hab 3:2 ‒ the introduction of the theophany in Hab 3:3 relies on passages from Hab 1f and that the subsequent theophany unfolds ideas already extant in the preceding literary context. Specifically, this concerns the idea of divine judgment that can no longer involve human agents, but needs to be restricted to Yhwh. This narrowing of perspective already commences in Hab 2 and is continued in Hab 3 through the lenses of a certain theological angle. In Sum, Hab 3 expands upon the theocentric conception of judgment in Hab 2 and
|
Adapting Social Memory to Mold New Attitudes in the Present and Future: Examples from the Books of Deuteronomy, Judges, and Kings
Program Unit: Intersections: A Forum for Research on Ancient Israel, Hebrew Bible, and Cognate Topics (EABS)
Diana Edelman, University of Oslo
Within the Deuteronomistic History collection, some key ideas expressed
programmatically in the book of Deuteronomy are explored in more depth in succeeding books. Micah’s creation of an ’ephod and teraphim for use in his household shrine in Judges 17-18 and Saul’s consultation of the dead prophet Samuel in 1 Samuel 28 deal with the prohibition of consulting the dead found in Deut 18:10-11 and 26:14 and the need for aniconic representation of both YHWH and other deities found in Deut
4:10-19, 28, 35,39 and 5:7-9. Both narratives will be the focus of an
examination of how memory of the past has been adapted by the authors or subsequent redactors of Judges and Samuel in order to condemn what once were acceptable religious beliefs and practices. Inferentially, the authors or redactors wrote at a time when religious belief and praxis were in flux. Ideas that eventually became cornerstones of Judaism were advocated by the scribes who produced or modified
Deuteronomy, Judges, and Samuel but were contested within the larger community and targeted audience, requiring their programmatic reinforcement by presenting them as already unacceptable in Israel’s early history.
|
Exemplary Emotional Narratives in John Chrysostom’s Late Works
Program Unit: Biblical Interpretation in Early Christianity
Robert G. T. Edwards, University of Notre Dame
For John Chrysostom, biblical narratives function in an exemplary fashion, as healthy emotional narratives for his audience to imitate. Wendy Mayer has argued that much of Chrysostom’s work – and especially his later exilic treatises – was intended for such therapeutic ends: to heal the passions, to lead to the healthy emotional life. Mayer, however, has not appreciated the role of scripture in this project. On the other hand, in an influential essay, Frances Young argued that historia (the narrative thrust of scripture) was important for John because it was the basis of moral teaching. My goal is to bring the observations of these two scholars together, and to argue that, for Chrysostom, scripture provides narrative deep structures that are designed to be the foundation for a healthy emotional life; only by thus reigning in the passions can one live a virtuous moral life. This observation comes primarily from Chrysostom’s late, exilic treatises and letters (De providentia Dei, Quod nemo laeditur nisi a seipso, and Epistulae ad Olympiadem), in which he continually relates biblical narratives. Not only does he read these narratives as having common deep structures (hypotheseis), but he also does not hesitate to retell one narrative according to the structure of another: thus, for example, the Joseph cycle is read according to the Abraham cycle, as a story of promise and fulfilment. These biblical narrative structures form Chrysostom’s narration of his own emotions; in turn, the emotional deep structures are meant to be imitated by the readers of his letters and treatises. We thus find that the repetitious nature of Chrysostom’s works that many modern scholars find so tiresome is in fact a therapeutic device for instantiating these narratives in the life of the believer, that he or she might be led to emotional and spiritual health.
|
Of Burning Ovens, Half-Baked Cakes, and Helpless Birds: Exploring a Cluster of Metaphors in Hosea 7
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible (EABS)
Göran Eidevall, Uppsala Universitet
Already in the early 80s, Cheryl Exum called attention to a characteristic feature of biblical poetry, namely the juxtaposition of metaphors or similes that are linked to different source domains. In a pioneering study on extended similes in Isaiah 28–31, she demonstrated that metaphorical expressions appearing in close proximity may interact in a number of ways, ranging from mutual reinforcement to disambiguation. Drawing on more recent developments in cognitive metaphor theory and in the study of biblical metaphors, I intend to refine Exum’s approach. In this paper I shall explore a cluster of metaphors in the book of Hosea. The section 7:3–12 displays a bewildering array of images. Passions are likened to fire in an oven (vv. 4-7); the nation is depicted as poorly baked bread (v. 8), but also as a silly dove (v. 11); the punitive acts of YHWH are, finally, described in terms of catching birds with a net (v. 12). The analysis seeks to answer two overarching questions: 1) How do these metaphors and similes interact within the literary context? 2) How does each metaphor employed connect and contribute to themes or patterns permeating the book of Hosea? I will also discuss various implications for the interpretation of individual metaphorical expressions within Hos 7:3–12, as well as for the interpretation of the passage as a whole within its wider literary context.
|
Against A Stoic Mindset: The Function of Mark's Portrayal of Jesus' Emotions
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Thaddeus Ekuma, University of Oxford
The references to Jesus’ emotions in Mark’s Gospel may pose some difficulty to readers with a philosophical outlook, insofar as that outlook conditions them to prioritize rationality over emotion in their anthropology. Mark’s portrayal of Jesus may be particularly puzzling to Stoic philosophers perhaps because he makes strong claims to Jesus’ divinity (and I’ll return to consider to what extent this statement is true) while at the same time presenting him in terms that a Stoic would likely regard as irrational, hence not only far removed from divinity but also from an ideal human being. Jesus, in Mark’s Gospel, is shown as intimately connected with God (1:1; 1:11; 9:7; 15:39) while also being portrayed as having strong human emotions (1:41; 1:43; 3:5; 14:33). How then would the portrayal of Jesus’ emotion function for this set of readers of Mark’s Gospel?
Witney Shiner had assumed that Mark’s Gospel was created to provide emotional catharsis for its audience through their engagement with the story of Jesus. On the contrary, this study proposes that readers of Mark’s Gospel with a Stoic mindset would be shocked and surprised at his double portrayal of Jesus as both divine and expressing emotion. In a narrative which does not suppress but rather dramatizes the emotions of Jesus, Mark’s Gospel provides a counter mode of understanding the nature of divinity. He presents Jesus (and one might say also God) as infinitely unknown, even though perhaps infinitely knowable, and a good life on earth as entirely dependent on faith and trust in God. The favoured attitude to the divine life is not that of personal aspiration to self-sufficiency, but an openness to God as unknown.
|
Is the Amos Call Narrative a Factor of Unity for the Book of the Twelve and an Element of Contact between the Minor and Major Prophets?
Program Unit: Relationship between the "Major Prophets" and the "Scroll of the Minor Prophets": text, methodology, hermeneutics and Wirkungsgeschichte (EABS)
Di Pede Elena, Université de Lausanne
The booklet of Amos, in the Book of the Twelve, is the only one that contains a Call Narrative following the pattern of the "typical scene" that can be found in the cases of Moses, Isaiah, Jeremiah and Ezekiel. This peculiarity gives this Call Narrative a doubly specific role: Does Amos's Call Narrative concern only the booklet of Amos, and thus is meant to characterize only Amos, its protagonist? Or does it impact the whole Book of the Twelve, in which case it is part of the composite portrait of the prophet that emerges from the whole Book of the Twelve. The answer to these questions is not straightforward and should therefore be explored methodologically and exegetically, all the while keeping in mind that this particular narrative may well be a formal element connecting the Minor and the Major Prophets.
|
The Mysterious History of the Book of Mysteries
Program Unit: Medicine in Bible and Talmud (EABS)
Rivka Elitzur-Leiman, Tel Aviv University
In my paper, I will discuss "the Book of Mysteries" (Sefer Ha-Razim) – a Late Antique Jewish magical composition. I will explore some parallels to this work, as well as early attestations of the use of this influential composition. Finally, I will discuss the possible implications of these parallels on the study of Sefer Ha-Razim in particular and ancient Jewish magic in general.
|
The Strength of Hybridity: An Intercultural Case Study of an American and Maasai Analysis of Exod 20:4–6
Program Unit: Contextual Interpretation of the Bible (Hebrew Bible/Old Testament and New Testament)
Beth Elness-Hanson, Johannelunds Teologiska Högskola
In contrast to Enlightenment-influenced, epistemological-only approaches to biblical studies that are prevalent in Euro-American contexts, the author advocates for engaging the Majority World and the “epistemologies of the South” (de Sousa Santos 2015, Segovia 2015). This “multi-epistemological exegesis” merges the strengths of diverse ways of knowing for meaningful, hybridized results. This approach is an ethical path forward in light of today’s global realities.
In African knowledge systems, ontology is privileged. As a result, Western biblical scholarship is often “sterile” with regard to the questions asked in African contexts. Because the nature of the question determines the research methods, an expanded exegetical toolbox is utilized to develop hybridized theological knowledge. To evaluate the soundness of hybridized interpretations, the author proposes an adaptation of anthropologist Paul Hiebert’s centered set theory, where classical Western exegetical methods are understood in relationship to other epistemologies.
An intercultural case study on the “generational curse” within the Decalogue in Exod 20:4–6 demonstrates the value of hybridity. Through dialogue with “participatory inquiry,” the American author and Christian Maasai theologians of Tanzania, East Africa, developed a fusion of horizons regarding the covenant curse phrase, “visiting the iniquity of the fathers on the children to the third and the fourth generation” in the Decalogue. On one hand, phenomenological generational curses are prevalent within the Maasai worldview. On the other hand, the Enlightenment-influenced epistemology minimizes the attention of curses as a phenomenon.
Multi-epistemological exegesis demonstrates that insights develop for those who are willing to risk and dialogue with distinctively different ways of knowing and worldviews.
|
The Theophany at Mamre: Artistic Representations Reflecting Harmonistic Interpretations
Program Unit: Open Forum for New Testament and Early Christian Studies (EABS)
Yaffa Englard, Haifa University
The account of the theophany at Mamre and Abraham’s hospitality in Gen 18:1–13 poses various linguistic and stylistic difficulties. Since the fifth century CE, these scenes have been represented artistically in diverse ways, creating the impression that the painters portrayed them in accordance with their own particular understanding of the text. This paper explores the rabbinic and Christian traditions that may lie behind those visual interpretations, thus contributing perceptions and insights that add to the way art historians have traditionally “read” such tableaux.
|
Offices in the Communities of the Didache
Program Unit: Apostolic Fathers and Related Early Christian Literature
Wolfgang Ernst, Universität Wien
The Didache mentions several different offices in the communities of the Didache: bishops, deacons, prophets, apostles and teachers. The Didachist deals with this topic extensively in the chapters 11-13 and 15. In research of the Didache it is often noted (following Harnack and Weber), that the communities of the Didache are experiencing a conflict between different types of offices. Charismatic offices (apostle, teachers, and prophets) are still hold in higher regard (cf. Did 15:2) over locally bound offices (bishops and deacons). But simultaneously bishops and deacons are starting to gain influence in the communities.
My paper is using data provided by voluntary associations to challenge this idea. Voluntary associations show a great variety of types of offices. It is not unusual for an association to have several methods of appointing, electing and choosing officers. For example, the Herakliasts from (an eranos association) from Liopesi used four different methods of choosing and legitimizing their officers (election, appointing, lot and offices for life based on merit). Furthermore, I will show, that it is not unusual to have “charismatic offices” (e.g. priests, prophets, teachers) and “administrative offices” (e.g. epimeletes, tamias, grammateus) in voluntary associations.
My goal is not to label the group(s) addressed by the Didache as voluntary associations and neglect their Jewish heritage, or specific circumstances in the Didache itself. But the documents of associations provide helpful data to understand how offices in the Didache might be understood.
|
Reflections on the Sumerian Concept of God and Divine World in Light of Negative Theology
Program Unit: What a God is Not – The Early History of Negative Theology (EABS)
Peeter Espak, University of Tartu
In Sumerian sources, the deities and human beings are usually described and depicted in quite similar form and physical appearance. From the sources of visual depiction, the only difference seems to be the bigger size of the important deities and the horned crown. Since the divine forces can be called “immanent” in Sumerian contexts – not living in an outside unknown and supernatural reality but in the same geographical dimensions as all the other creatures – the divine world has no such characteristics as eternal, immortal, absolute, etc. in Sumerian religion and mythology. Gods live in the timely universe and can be destroyed and are not completely “immortal”; although more powerful in most aspects and having some divine attributes (such as me, he-gal, me-lam), they are still similar in nature and even in carrying out their everyday activities. However, we can still claim that god is not “human”. Deities are not formed or crafted using creation by handiwork, they are given birth by the “the universe” – they are part of the “original” divine rules and the “idea” of the cosmos. The god is not a craftwork or creation of a higher being; god has been born to the universe as its “natural” or “logical” inhabitant; and not crafted, such as mankind.
|
The Contextual Theology of the Earliest Congregationalist Missionaries in Kwazulu-Natal and Its Impact on Postcolonial Black Liberation Hermeneutics
Program Unit: The Bible in the Twenty-First Century: Politization of Bibles and Biblization of Politics (EABS)
Annette Evans, University of the Free State
In South Africa the current political clamor for de-colonization portrays the contribution of the missionaries as negative because there is a perception of collusion in the imperialist exploitation of the indigenous peoples of South Africa. However, John Langalibalele Dube, the first President of the black liberation movement inaugurated in 1912 publicly expressed thankfulness and appreciation of the missionary contribution. Although by the time of his death in 1946 his pacifist Christian values were no longer a dominant part of the ideals of the desperate African National Congress, it is significant that after the transition to democracy in 1994 Nelson Mandela himself acknowledged that the leaders of the ANC would not have been able to achieve freedom without the missionary impact. The diachronic development of imperialist motivations as a result of synchronic events such as the discovery of gold and diamonds in South Africa necessitates a nuanced denouement of the missionary contribution. Even amongst the missionaries the practical application of Bible interpretation was not without radical disagreement. The phenomenon that the biblical text can be applied in vastly differing cultural contexts makes it vulnerable to ideological interpretation and has resulted in a wide range of church affiliations. This paper attempts to assess the long-term impact of the introduction of the Bible to South Africa in the context of the seminal historical period of colonial land-grabbing and trampling on the traditional culture of the indigenous peoples. The deep-seated sense of loss of motherland is currently expressed in the postcolonial hermeneutic trend of black liberation theology to search the biblical text for a way to reduce the stark gap between the rich and the poor. This phenomenon is considered in terms of aspects of the views on biblical hermeneutics of Breuggemann, Rowland, Mosala, West, and Pope Francis.
|
The Gospel according to John—the Pastor
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Burton Everist, Wartburg Theological Seminary
Contrary to early church commentators John was not primarily evangelizing, not mainly polemicizing, not theologizing. John was portraying to fearful Christians a powerful Jesus. John urges, “These (things) are written that you may keep trusting that Jesus is the Messiah, the Son of God.” (20:21) Trust (pisteuō) occurs 98 times. Acts describes the churches facing expulsion from their families and synagogue community, with many fearing for their lives. John cares for one of these communities. John participates in the agony of the dispossessed and his language reveals his feelings about those oppressors with whom he shares ancestry, the Ioudaious (71 times.) Over half of his references are negative. It is not as often noted that Acts uses the term 79 times, and that nearly half of the references are also negative. All negative uses occur after Acts 9 that marks the beginning of Saul/Paul’s story. This may suggest that the persecution of the community Acts described of John and of Paul deeply marked them. It may also help move from judging John’s language to understand it as an outcry of agony from his sharing the dispossession and oppression of his readers. Three word clusters mark John’s call to live trusting Jesus. John calls the displaced to stay together in Jesus menō (40 times) for Jesus’ Father’s house has many monai (places to stay). He urges them to love each other with the love Jesus has for them: agapaō (37 times) agapē (7 times.) He reminds them they are sent as Jesus was sent, apostellō (26 times) and pempō (31 times).
|
The Historical Context of the Treatise on the Resurrection
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
René Falkenberg, Aarhus Universitet
In this short letter from the first of the Nag Hammadi Codices, an anonymous writer informs Rheginos about the nature of Christ, cosmos, humankind, and the post-mortal body. Almost all earlier studies consider the letter a second century Valentinian writing, but here another historical context is suggested: Egyptian monasticism, perhaps even the Origenist controversy from the last decade of the fourth century.
|
“Will You Fool Him as One Fools Men”: Can God Be Deceived according to Biblical Narrative?
Program Unit: Intersections: A Forum for Research on Ancient Israel, Hebrew Bible, and Cognate Topics (EABS)
Yoshi Fargeon, Bar-Ilan University
The biblical narrative contains several attempts to deceive God.
The first attempt to lie to God already appears in the first ‘documented’ sentence that man speaks to God. After Adam and the woman eat from the Tree of Knowledge, Adam attempts to lie to God by saying (Gen. 3:10): “I heard the sound of You in the Garden, and I was afraid because I was naked so I hid”, while the truth is that Adam was not at all afraid of his nakedness, but rather of the foretold punishment.
The second attempt to lie to God comes right after, when God asks Cain (Gen 4:9): “Where is your brother Abel?” and he responds with a bold-faced lie: “I do not know!” and then adds with sarcastic innocence: “Am I my brother’s keeper?”
One can find at least five more occurrences of this phenomenon elsewhere in biblical narrative.
Two questions arise: (1) What abilities God has according to the biblical narrative, (2) and what abilities were attributed to him by the characters in the story.
The answer to the last question depends on the scope of divine knowledge. In prophetic, poetic, and wisdom literature, God is presented as omniscient. On the other hand, in biblical narrative His representation is less one-sided, and depends largely on the assumptions of the reader.
In my lecture, I will review the attempts to deceive God in the biblical narrative, while comparing them to attempts to deceive 'ordinary' human being and prophets. I will explain why most attempts to deceive God appears in the stories of Genesis; And I will make a distinction between the theological position of the narrator and the position he attributes to his characters.
|
Peter’s and/or Jesus’ Leadership? An Exegetical Study of John 21:15-17 in the Light of the Notion of Leadership
Program Unit: Authority and Influence in Ancient Times
Maria Micheal Felix, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
Almost all the scholarly debates on Jesus’ command βόσκε/ποίμαινε τὰ πρόβατά μου in John 21:15-17 solely focus on Peter, interpreting the phrase either as the rehabilitation of Peter as one among the disciples for mission by undoing his denial (Bernard, 1928.2:691-692; Brant, 2011:283) or as Jesus’ authoritative commissioning specific to Peter to lead the community (Bultmann, 1971:713; Schnelle, 1998:318) or as both Peter’s rehabilitation and Jesus’ authoritative commissioning (Brown, 1966-70:1113; Bruner, 2011:1233) and not on Jesus’ own role and function. However, the purpose of the present paper is to redirect the focus from Peter’s to Jesus’ leadership and to investigate how Jesus’ dialogue with Peter and the transfer of leadership reflect Jesus’ own leadership function. This paper intends to study exegetically Jesus’ conversation with Peter in John 21:15-17 to explicate Jesus’ leadership. The phrase λέγει αὐτῷ in vv.15-17 indicates that it is Jesus who speaks and transfers his own leadership through the shepherd metaphor to Peter. The term ποίμαινε in its biblical perspective is a leadership term used to refer to leadership of people in various respects (e.g., Sheehan, 1964; Jeremias, 1968). Each time Jesus inquires of Peter’s love, he commands Peter to feed/tend his lambs or sheep which suggests that Jesus’ specific understanding of leadership is grounded in love (ἀγαπάω, φιλέω) and makes love for Jesus an indispensable prerequisite for leadership (Minear, 1983:94). Jesus’ authoritative commission to Peter after his denial demonstrates Jesus’ approach to lead others with integrity. Jesus’ interrogation and command ultimately aim at empowering Peter through his conversion and assertion of love. Thus, this paper intends to argue that Jesus’ interaction with Peter in John 21:15-17 envisages Jesus’ leadership in the first sense rather than Peter’s and illustrates the specific leadership style of Jesus. Jesus challenges, strengthens and transforms Peter to lead the community of disciples.
|
Cultural Change in Context: Jesus on Sexuality in the Discipleship Community: Ius Gentium?
Program Unit: The Biblical World and Cultural Evolution (EABS)
Nirmal Fernando, Ashram Community / Urban Theology Union Sheffield
Cultural shifts often occur both irreversibly and reversibly, with or without intentionality, among individuals within a group or society. Humans generally wish to live contentedly, and often there is information intake from the behaviour of others, resulting in intentional shifts that abandon previous conduct and sometimes lead to the substitution of new expressions that suit them better. However, perhaps equally, there also is resistance to information capable of affecting behaviour.
The ideal of relative individual and collective contentment is plausibly the axiom of the jurisprudential concept of ius naturale, which recognises the right of any micro-group to self-determine their ius gentium, ‘over and above’ macro-social ius civile.
It is clear from the various narratives about Jesus that he was questioned, particularly by those outside his discipleship community, about matters relating to marriage and divorce and was confronted as well with alleged situations of adultery. Not only did he respond to these, but he also advocated a pattern of sexuality to his disciples that was both prohibitory and mandatory.
Using the exegetical method, I will analyse relevant dialogues, instructions, and the practice of Jesus and his community in the context of the sexuality of their era.
The outcome will probably suggest that the sexual culture of the then ‘Jesus Community’ evolved by taking the mens rather than the actus as the axiom and by distinguishing between epithymesai and agapeseis. Was it a dialectical leap from Jewish sexuality of the times, transiting into an alternate ‘ius gentium’? While certain similarities with Stoic sexual culture in the first century CE are apparent, was there influence from socially transmitted information?
|
Entering and Leaving This World: Birth and Death in Mesopotamia
Program Unit: Ugarit and the Bible: Life and Death (EABS)
Sebastian Fink, University of Helsinki
Birth and death are inevitably bound together. Both mark a definite change in the status of a human being, and death can be interpreted as a reversal of birth. But how was this change conceptualized in Mesopotamia over time? What actually happened in the moment of an individual's birth or death? I seek to answer these questions on the basis of selected texts and I argue that the conceptualization of birth and death are closely related.
|
Visual Poetry in Sumerian Lamentations: A Diachronic View
Program Unit: Diachronic Poetology of the Hebrew Bible and Related Ancient Near Eastern and Ancient Jewish Literature (EABS)
Sebastian Fink, University of Helsinki
Due to our insufficient understanding of spoken Sumerian language our analysis of Sumerian poetry and therefore our understanding of Sumerian poetology does mainly rely on script, not on language. In this lecture I want to approach Sumerian poetry in a rather experimental way that focuses on the written text and tries to explore if these visual structures also had an impact on the diachronic development of Sumerian texts, namely to see if such visual structures were acknowledged by other scribes, namely the later copyists and editors, and contributed to the stability of texts.
|
Profane and Holy in Mishnah’s Cosmos: The Case of the Diaspora
Program Unit: Sociological and Anthropological Approaches to the Study of the Evidence of the Mishnah (EABS)
Simcha Fishbane, Touro College
Emile Durkheim notes that characteristic of all religions is the division between the holy and the profane. Furthermore, he understands that religious symbols and ideas are actually symbols for society, and the its moral order (Emile Durkheim, The Elementary Forms of Religious Life NY: The Free Press). In my proposed paper, I examine the way these ideas (and others) are expressed in the way the Mishnah understands the Land of Israel. The Land of Israel was a sacred universe in Mishnah’s “imagined collective”. The Jerusalem Temple was destroyed and there was no hope to return to or rebuild it through a military victory. Those remaining in the Land of Israe would continue to be bound to their universe by the ancient system of obligations, which their ancestors accepted as their covenant with God. This was manifested through the only remaining element, the holy Land of Israel. This reciprocity between Israel and God, the close parity between these two partners in the charge of restitution, is what Mishnah seeks to convey. The Land of Israel became the conduit for the rabbinic Jew to God. If the Land of Israel was sacred, then the land outside Israel was viewed and defined as profane. The sacred universe desacralized all other lands, placing that which resided in them within the category of “outsiders” and thus labelling them as a potential threat to the holy cosmos. The outsider could take the form of people or objects or land. For Mishnah’s redactors, the profane or outsider was of interest primarily when it served the needs of the “insider”, and specifically the rabbinic Jew. This essay will examine how the redactors of Mishnah viewed, used and drew the boundaries of the profane lands to serve the needs of Mishnah’s world and its members.
|
Formal Equivalence and Betrayal of Content? The Pitfalls of Metaphors and Their Translations
Program Unit: Bible Translation Workshop (EABS)
Hans Foerster, Universität Wien
Metaphors are widely used and an important part of almost any spoken communication. Especially narrative and poetic texts use metaphorical language. The use of metaphorical language enables the author to convey his/her message with very few words. Metaphors evoke images which are understood by both author and reader – if they share a common linguistic and cultural setting. Translation of metaphors is not easy. Metaphors function differently in different linguistic and cultural settings. “To be on the wrong track” must be rendered into German “auf dem Holzweg sein”. This is not a literal translation but the attempt to render the content of the metaphor. As to the metaphorical image, the closest English equivalent to the proposed German translation would be “to be up a blind alley”. A “Holzweg” is a way into the woods in order to take trees out of the woods. As a road it is a dead end. A dynamic equivalent translation disregards the exact wording in order to convey the content of the metaphor. A literal translation would not make sense in German.
It appears that some recently published Bible Translations—one could mention as examples the German revision of the Einheitsübersetzung and the English New American Bible Revised Edition—tend to favour formal equivalence over dynamic equivalence in translation. While a tendency to use formal equivalent translation might be indeed helpful for translating narrative passages as faithfully as possible – and a faithful translation is the aim of every Bible translation – it appears that the translation of metaphors poses a problem for such an approach. The paper will explore an example from Matthew’s Gospel (Matthew 23:33). The paper will argue that in this case the close adherence to the wording of the Greek text is in danger of imposing an interpretation onto the translated text.
|
The Limits of the Pentateuch as Narrative
Program Unit: Pentateuch (Torah)
Josef Forsling, Stockholm School of Theology
While the debates on the formation of the Pentateuch go on unabated, most scholars regardless of school or theory note that the Pentateuch is a narrative, albeit an uneven one. The idea of a story from creation to the (near) conquest may be understood to be a late innovation bringing together the different parts of the Pentateuch through the promises to the fathers or something found early on in all of its sources, but it is there. One of the main reasons for this contemporary narrative understanding of the Pentateuch arguably lies in the in-breaking of synchronic or narrative methods during the 1970’s and forward, which in turn reacted to what was understood as the fragmentary and hypothetical nature of the historical-critical methods. Consequently, David Clines lead the way in reading the Pentateuch as a narrative with a certain theme in his famous study of 1978, The Theme of the Pentateuch. Less known is perhaps that several similar studies have followed up to our days that develop or depart from Clines’ original arguments, such as Thomas Mann’s The Book of the Torah (1988), John Sailhamer’s The Pentateuch as Narrative (1992), Arie Leder’s Waiting for the Land (2010), and others that may be added to these. However, none of these studies feature to any large extent in the present debates on the formation of the Pentateuch despite the presupposition of its narrative character. This paper surveys several such narrative studies of the Pentateuch to unearth the contributions that can be gained from them, to point out some typical cul-de-sacs that show up, and to offer some critical suggestion on how to move research on the Pentateuch forward.
|
“For a Bird of the Heavens Will Carry the Sound”: Revealing the Secrets of Bird-Related Metaphors
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible (EABS)
Tova Forti, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
Ricoeur brings to light the processes by which linguistic imagination creates and recreates meaning through metaphor. The search for a metaphor's contextual-cultural setting is a prerequisite for arriving at its meaning that will enrich the reader’s perspective. This paper discusses two bird-related metaphors; the first deals with the image of trapped birds as a vehicle for concretizing the fate of the evildoer who is ensnared by the trap that he himself has set. This image is found in Prov 1:17-18 explicitly and in Ps 35:7-8 by implication. The second metaphor relates to birds as polar opposite points along a continuum from isolation and desolation (Prov 27:8; Ps 102:7-8) to intimacy and safety (Ps 84:4).
|
The Liturgical Fragments from Nag Hammadi Codex XI in Light of Recent Scholarship
Program Unit: Early Christianity (EABS)
Kimberly Fowler, CNRS/Aix-Marseille University
At the end of A Valentinian Exposition, a Valentinian Christian tractate from Nag Hammadi Codex XI dealing with cosmogony, anthropology, soteriology, and eschatology, we find five fragmentary liturgical texts, which have been read as supplements to the longer preceding text. Scholars have labelled them as follows: On the Anointing, On Baptism A, On Baptism B, On the Eucharist A, and On the Eucharist B. It has been thought that these liturgical texts were utilised catechistically to complement the detailed theological teaching that appears in the main tractate, possibly serving during Valentinian initiation rites. More recent Nag Hammadi scholarship has demonstrated that there is good reason to believe that the Codices were produced and utilised by Egyptian (probably Pachomian) monks. Much of the material within the so-called “Gnostic” Nag Hammadi texts can be shown to fit particularly well within such a context, but how would the monks have engaged with liturgical material such as the fragments from Codex XI? In this paper I will re-examine the fragments with this fourth-century monastic context in mind, and consider how apparent Valentinian initiatory material might have been interpreted by a Pachomian readership.
|
The Assyrian Stylized Tree: Propagation Not Pollination
Program Unit: Iconography and Biblical Studies (EABS)
Norma Franklin, University of Haifa
There are ca 180 wall reliefs depicting the Assyrian Stylized Tree decorating the walls of Ashurnasipal’s palace at Calah (Nimrud). The scene is usually thought to represent the pollination of a Date Palm, however it is the propagation of a female Date Palm that is depicted. A Date Palm replicates itself by producing basal offshoots that grow into a new identical palm, it literally clones itself. This paper will explore how the Date Palm came to represent immortality, at Calah and elsewhere in the ancient world.
|
Living in the Midst of the Land: Issues of Centralization in the Book of Numbers
Program Unit: Centralization and Cult in Persian Period Israel: Biblical, Historical and Comparative Perspectives (EABS)
Christian Frevel, Ruhr-University Bochum/University of Pretoria
In the Book of Numbers, the organization of space is a crucial issue. The sanctuary is described to be settled in the midst of the camp. Three of the twelve tribes each flank the four sides of the sanctuary during the wilderness journey and, thus, constitute it as a centre. The location of the sanctuary in the middle of Israel is furthermore emphasized at the beginning and at the end of the book (Num 2:17; 35:34). Read from the perspective of centralization, the book is full of aspects related to this subject: the centralization of cult, cult-personnel, ritual, purity/holiness, blessing, administration etc. Seen from this angle, the non-centralized issues or decentralizing tendencies in the Book of Numbers, e.g. the tent outside of the camp (Num 11:26), the relation between Transjordan (Num 32) and Cis-Jordan (Num 34), and the decentralized living space of the Levites (Num 35:2-7) become even more interesting – especially since the overall concept remains centralized (cf. e.g., the mention of the high priest in Num 35). This dynamic is not only remarkable in conceptual respect, but also in regard to its (religious) historical contexts, because most texts from the Book of Numbers are considered to be of rather late origin.
Against this background, the paper aims at answering the following questions by analyzing the selected texts conceptually and in diachronic respect: (1) What is the significance of centralization in the Book of Numbers? (2) How does it relate to other ideas of centralization in the Hebrew Bible? (3) How does it relate to the (religious) historical setting of the Persian period?
|
Local Elites vs. Imperial Elites in the Achaemenid Empire: The Temple as the Locus of Control
Program Unit: Judaeans in the Persian Empire (EABS)
Lisbeth S. Fried, University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
Throughout the Empire, the Achaemenids used local temples and temple officials to exert control over the local population. Demotic letters from Egypt (493 BCE) reveal that the satrap’s approval was required to confirm the office of a temple’s high priest, and that local Persian governors required bribes in order to approve appointees to lower temple offices (487 BCE).
An inscription dated to 365 BCE reads that the Achaemenid hyparch of Lydia donated a statue of a god to the temple of Zeus in Sardis. The conditions of the donation required that the temple priesthood avoid any participation in the mysteries of Sabazios, Angdistis, and Ma. These three gods, new to Lydia, were gods of Phrygia and Cappadocia, provinces then revolting from Persia during the Great Satrapal Revolt.
The Xanthus inscription, erected when the Persians extended Carian control over Lycia (338 BCE), describes the installation of a foreign Carian god and his foreign Carian priest into a Lycian temple formerly dedicated to Leto and her children. The installation of the foreign god into the Lycian temple was forced on the Lycians for the convenience of the Carian regiment installed there.
This paper considers the implications of this Achaemenid control over local temples for the Persian province of Yehud. Specifically, it will examine the events described in Nehemiah 13 in the context of this contentious background.
|
Resistance in Ezra-Nehemiah
Program Unit: Contextual Interpretation of the Bible (Hebrew Bible/Old Testament and New Testament)
Lisbeth S. Fried, University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
Nehemiah’s wall was built in the late Hellenistic period (Finkelstein 2008), suggesting a terminus post quem under the Hasmonians for the completion of Ezra-Nehemiah. It was likely not written at once, however, but over a long period of time, perhaps from the reign of Artaxerxes II to the late Hellenistic period.
If so, we may better understand the celebration of Sukkot in Nehemiah 8. As is widely recognized, the description of the festival in Nehemiah 8 differs from the holiday’s prescriptions in both Leviticus and Deuteronomy. Unlike Deuteronomy 16, Nehemiah instructs Judeans to collect branches to build booths on the roofs and courtyards of their homes “in all of their towns,” not just Jerusalem (Neh. 8:15-16). Unlike in Leviticus 23:40, the people are to use the branches they have collected not to carry them in procession with joy, but rather to use them to build booths. Besides differing from Pentateuchal passages, Sukkot in Nehemiah also contrasts with descriptions of Sukkot in second temple texts. In both Josephus and in the books of Maccabees, the people are described as processing joyfully around the temple, carrying leafy boughs and the fruit of the citron, while wearing wreaths upon their heads (Jub.16:30).
These descriptions of Sukkot described in second temple texts (except Nehemiah) remind one of Dionysian processions in celebration of that god of the grape harvest. Dionysus was the patron deity of the Ptolemies, and he was assimilated to the Ptolemaic lineage. The “Great Processional” in Ptolemaic Alexandria, dedicated to Dionysus, was the primary Ptolemaic religious observance. I suggest that before the Hasmonians, but in resistance to the Ptolemies and their linkage to Dionysus, that Nehemiah requires that the holiday of Sukkot be celebrated alone in the quiet of home.
|
Divine Visions in situ: The Temple of the Sebastoi at Ephesos and the Heavenly Throne of Revelation 4-5
Program Unit: Vision and Envisionment in the Bible and its World (EABS)
Steven J. Friesen, University of Texas at Austin
Jaś Elsner proposed that there were two standard modes of envisioning the divine in the ancient world—classical visuality and ritual-centered visuality. In this paper, I argue that these two modes do not do justice to the materiality of divine sightings. This comparative study looks at two late first-century religious phenomena from western Asia Minor—the provincial imperial cult temple established at Ephesos in 89/90 CE, and John’s vision report of the throne of Israel’s God as found in Revelation 4-5. The two phenomena took shape in very different socio-economic contexts and thus allow us to reflect on the difference that material conditions make in visualizations of the divine. For both phenomena, the paper focuses on financial resources, on material objects and the parameters for vision, and on language and narrative. I conclude that the materiality of the two divine sightings—at the temple and through the reading of the text in a specific place—requires us also to consider visualities of subordination and of subversion.
|
The Use of Proverbs from Didactic Wisdom Literature in the Book of Jeremiah
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Wisdom
Rachel Frish, Bar-Ilan University
Research has identified various sapiential elements in the book of Jeremiah. However, to date, scholars have barely attempted to identify quotations or variations of familiar proverbs from didactic Wisdom Literature that appear in Jeremiah. The primary proverb identified as corresponding to a proverb in the book of Proverbs is: “O LORD, I know that the way of man is not in himself: it is not in man that walketh to direct his steps” (Jeremiah 10:23).
In my lecture, I would like to reexamine this matter and present additional verses that may suggest the correlation between Jeremiah and didactic Wisdom Literature. I will explore four additional verses in Jeremiah in which a correlation to familiar proverbs is identifiable: Jeremiah 5:27 and 17:11 both compare wealth obtained through crooked means to birds, with the first verse presenting a situation that contrasts with the accepted doctrine of reward and punishment and the second verse providing a more traditional depiction of this same doctrine. These verses express a similar idea to the theme presented in Proverbs 23: 4-5 and in the Instruction of Amenemope (Chapter 7: 9, 10 – 14 , 5). Furthermore, Jeremiah 17:9-10 deals with man’s inability to know the thoughts within another man’s heart, in contrast with God’s unlimited knowledge, and this is similar to the idea and structure of the proverb in Proverbs 24:12. Finally, Jeremiah 50:34 presents the nation’s salvation from the hands of the Babylonians in terms identical to those used to describe the salvation of the weaker classes in society from the hands of their usurpers in Proverbs 23:11.
During my analysis, I will pay close attention to the significant correlation between the parallel phrases, presenting the differences between the verses and their meanings and offering an explanation of the manner in which these proverbs are integrated into Jeremiah’s prophecy.
|
Rituals of the 364-day Calendar in Qumran
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Ida Fröhlich, Pázmány Péter Katolikus Egyetem
The paper will examine the case of a ritual innovation in the tradition of the Qumran community, and disclose the inner logic of the new ritual system. 11Q5 27.4-10 gives a catalogue of the Davidic songs written for the festivals, shabbats, and weekdays of a 364-day schematic calendar. The list is added by four songs composed “for the stricken,” to be recited on four days of the year. The system of the daily, festival, and Shabbat spiritual liturgies is conform with the heortology of the Old Testament while the songs written for the four days (presumably identical with the turning days of the seasons) represent a new element in the liturgical calendar. The songs written for Shabbats and weekdays can be identified respectively with the Qumran compositions Songs of the Sabbath Sacrifice (4Q400-403, 4Q405), and Dibrē ha-Meorot „Words of the Luminaries” (4Q504-506). The four songs are identical with the four apotropaic and exorcistic compositions of 11Q11.
The first two texts are generally meant to originate outside and prior to the emergence of the Qumran community. They do not reflect sectarian vocabulary (however, the Shabbat prayers introduce a clearly new, mystical worldview). The copy of 11Q11 is from the Herodian era, and three of its four compositions reflect an acknowledgement with Enochic demonology.
The principle behind the ritual compositions lies in the authors’ conceptualization of space and time which are neither void nor homogenous. Adequate ways of communication between humans and the heavenly sphere in various periods differ among them. Prayers uttered on regular weekdays are forwarded by heavenly mediators, while Shabbat time gives an opportunity for the communion of humans with angels. The turning points of the year are liminal days when humans are especially exposed to demonic dangers that can be averted by the uttering of apotropaic songs.
|
The “Horned Demon” and Qumran Demonology
Program Unit: Dispelling Demons: Interpretations of Evil and Exorcism in Ancient Near Eastern, Jewish and Biblical Contexts (EABS)
Ida Fröhlich, Pázmány Péter Katolikus Egyetem
11Q11 is a set of four apotropaic and exorcistic compositions from Qumran, intended to be uttered on four days of a 364-day year. These days are most probably identical with the four annual liminal days, the equinoxes and solstices, when human communities were believed to be especially exposed to demonic attacks. Song 3, uttered at the spring equinox (identical with Passover in the 364-day calendar), was written against a horned demon. The demon is said to originate from heavenly and earthly beings, which seems to allude to the Enochic tradition of the Watchers, who were heavenly beings who had descended from heaven, mated with human women, and became the originators of impure evil spirits (1Enoch 6-11, 15).
The figure of the horned demon is akin with that of the Mesopotamian gallu that appears to humans and causes (sudden) death. The demon is described in the handbook of demonology, Utukkū Lemnūtu (“The evil utukku-demons”), a work that likely influenced the Enochic tradition.
The horned demon of 11Q11 seems to be related to the depersonalized figure of the “destroyer” (ha-mašḥīt), who entered the house and struck the firstborn on Passover night during the final plague of Egypt (Ex 12:23). The book of Jubilees, an authoritative work at Qumran, gives a systematic elaboration of the origin and working of evil demons in human history. Unclean demons originated from fallen angels (Jub 19:8-10) and led by Mastema, intervene in human history. The narrative ends with the Exodus from Egypt and the description of Passover, which is a ritualisation of an immanent divine law, a propos of a divine rescue from a demonic attack on the firstborn (Jub 49:2-3). The ritual is to be kept annually at Passover as a protection against demonic plagues. The exorcism of 11Q11 offers a practical example for it.
|
Jesus, Son of Mary: Lineage and Descent in the Bible and the Qur’an
Program Unit: Quran and Islamic Tradition in Comparative Perspective
Alyssa Gabbay, University of North Carolina at Greensboro
Though Mary’s centrality in Christianity has been well established for centuries, her role in Islam remains an understudied subject. Yet the Qur’an refers to the mother of Jesus in no fewer than seventy verses, and paints an exalted portrait of a woman who, if not divine, is extremely holy and whom God has “chosen … above the women of the worlds” (Q 3:42). In this paper I compare and contrast Biblical and Qur’anic accounts of Mary, including such events as the Annunciation, Mary’s encounters with her kinsmen Zachariah and Elizabeth, and the birth of Jesus. Working within a framework of gender studies, I then focus on questions of lineage, asking, “What is the significance of the fact that the Qur’an identifies Jesus as “‘Isa ibn Maryam” (“Jesus son of Mary”)? Although the most obvious answer is that this nomenclature establishes that Jesus is not the son of God, but rather the son of a mortal woman (and, indeed, the Qur’an makes this argument in many other places), applying a feminist lens to this terminology allows a more gender-positive interpretation to emerge, rather than a polemical one. By attributing the son to his mother, who herself belongs to an esteemed lineage, the Qur’an establishes a striking precedent for matrilineal descent, one that Shi‘i scholars were later to take up in their defense of the Imams as the descendants of the Prophet Muhammad through his daughter, Fatima. Interestingly, such a precedent is not found in the Biblical accounts; the Gospels of Matthew and Luke trace Jesus’ human lineage not through Mary but through Joseph to Abraham (in the case of Matthew) and to Adam (in the case of Luke). My paper notes these differences and speculates upon their significance for the development of gender roles in each religion.
|
The Qur’an: Authorship between Muḥammad and the Divine
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Abdulla Galadari, Khalifa Univesity / Al Maktoum College
The Jewish view of their canonical books is the various degrees of inspiration, where the Torah is dictated by God to Moses, while other prophets have various degrees of inspiration. Christianity typically holds the dual authorship concept, where the human author writes under the inspiration of a divine author. In Islam, there is no concept of a human author, but a sole divine author, who inspires the human prophet who, in turn, simply utters the very words of God without any amendments or agency, which is similar to the Jewish view of the Torah. When comparing itself with other scriptures, the Qur’an claims that some Biblical books were themselves of a similar nature.
Although the concept of a divine author is prominent amongst most Islamic schools, the Ismā‘īlī understanding of Qur’anic inspiration is different. Their concept is that the revelation comes down as spiritual light, and it is the task of the human prophet to translate these spiritual lights into the language of the people. As such, their notion of inspiration may seem similar to the Judeo-Christian. The difference, however, is that because the original revelation is spiritual light, then it requires a divinely appointed imām to interpret the human words back to its original spiritual truths, as the human words are merely symbols of these spiritual truths.
This paper looks into the Qur’anic concept of “kitāb,” which is typically understood as book, but not necessarily so, according to Daniel Madigan’s The Qur’an Self Image. Based on the root “ktb,” which means to arrange in order, this paper investigates the Qur’anic concept of revelation (tanzīl) and inspiration (waḥy) philologically, as the terms used in the Hebrew Bible correspond to flowing waters (nozelim) and to reveal or to instruct (ḥwy).
|
Matthew’s Own Ten Thousand Talents: Was the First Gospel Community Richer Than the Rest?
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Aaron M. Gale, West Virginia University
In this paper I will argue that the Matthean community, itself a conservative Jewish-Christian group possibly located in Galilee, was more prosperous than the gospel communities associated with Mark and Luke. In fact, when placed alongside the other Synoptic Gospels, Matthew alone clearly suggests a distinct and unique preference for money and wealth. First, I will provide a brief sketch of ancient Galilean economic activity. Second, and most relevant, I will examine and analyze Matthew’s views of: 1. coinage and money, and 2. the rich and the poor as it compares/contrasts with the other gospels. In particular, I will utilize two key pericopes (as well as others) within Matthew’s gospel: the parable of the unforgiving servant (18.23-35; cf Lk 7.41-43) and the story of the rich young man (19.16-30; cf Mk 10.17-30; Lk 18.18-30). Utilizing these two stories as well as other relevant textual evidence, I will focus on three important issues: Matthew’s usage of the terms “rich” and “poor,” or the lack thereof (as found in the story of the rich young man and elsewhere; see also Mt 11.5; 20.1, 29-34; 22.9; 27.57), the context and meaning of coinage and wealth contained in the Gospel (as seen in the parable of the unforgiving servant and the parable of the vineyard workers; see Mt 20.1-16), and Matthew’s understanding of wealth as it relates to the Torah, and subsequently to Mark and Luke (Deut 28.1-14; Prov 13.18; Mt 6.19-21; 19; 20.29-34; 27.57). The evidence provided in this paper will make it clear that the author(s) of Matthew’s Gospel understood wealth from within the context of a Jewish perspective, and that the Matthean community itself must have been far wealthier than the communities associated with either Mark or Luke’s Gospel.
|
What Does Colour Mean in the Bible? A Study from MT, LXX and Vulgate
Program Unit: The Language of Colour in the Bible: From Word to Image (EABS)
Lourdes García Ureña, Universidad CEU San Pablo
Since the discovery of Greek polychrome sculptures in the late 19th century, colour has become a subject of growing interest in a variety of scientific disciplines, from physics, anthropology and art history to psychology and philology. The concept of colour nowadays is very different from that contemplated in antiquity. Until now, although studies about colour terms in the Bible are being undertaken, no exhaustive research has been conducted on the presence and meaning of the term colour in the biblical corpus. Therefore, the present paper will analyze the respective Hebrew, Greek or Latin terms that used to designate ‘colour’ in the Masoretic Text, Septuagint and Vulgate, what function they play in the text, and which concept of colour emerges. Curiously, MT does not use the term colour, although recently it has been thought that עין ʿ ayin, has that value. LXX uses two terms to refer to the colour: χρῶμα and χρόα which are repeated seven times (Exod 4,7; 34,29-30; Esth 15,7; 2 Mac 3,16; Wis 13,14; 15,4). In contrast, the Vulgate only employs a lexeme: color, however, its frequency is much higher: 31 times (Gen 30,37.39; 31,10; Exod 39,3.5; Lev 13,2.3.4.10.21.26.32.36.39.42; 14,56; Num 11,7; Judg 5,30; 1 Chr 29,2; Esth 1,6; Job 28,16; Prov 23,31; Wis 13,14; 15,4; Sir 43,20; Lam 4,1; Ezek 23,14; 27,18; 2 Mac 3,16; 2 Esd 6,44; 14,39). At first glance the Vulgate presents a greater chromaticism than the previous versions of the Bible. The analysis of the contexts will allow us: a) to deduce what colour means in Masoretic Text, Septuagint and the Vulgate; b) to establish a comparison with the concept of colour in antiquity; c) to understand the reason as to why the Vulgate has a need to support itself with the lexeme colour to translate pericopes where χρῶμα or χρόα or
|
Imitation as Interpretation in the Vita Antonii
Program Unit: Biblical Interpretation in Early Christianity
Meron T Gebreananaye, University of Durham
The Vita Antonii [VA], generally believed to have been written by Athanasius of Alexandria (ca 356) is widely recognized for its influence as a template for the praxis and literature of subsequent Christian asceticism. In this short study I look at the development of imitation as a mechanism of interpreting scripture in the VA to argue that Athanasius not only promotes the life of the monk par excellence as a pattern for aspiring ascetics, but also develops the idea of imitation as an exegetical practice in aid of the (trans) formation of the ascetic. He achieves this by: 1) promoting biblical figures as archetypes and 2) through employing scripture as a sourcebook of literary style and motifs. In the first instance, the VA ascribes ascetic intent and practice to a wide range of biblical figures, both to supply legitimate models for aspiring ascetics as well as to affirm the scriptural basis and authority of the ascetic program it proclaims. Secondly, Athanasius appropriates elements of biblical narratives including —metaphors, settings, characters and plot — to describe, interpret and thus legitimize the experiences of Anthony. In the VA, imitation is thus seen to serve an essential function in the interaction between the text of biblical texts and their ascetic readers. Its deployment informs the quest of self-formation through physical and spiritual discipline as well as describing the new reality that is the telos of the ascetic agenda, in terms of the ‘world’ of the biblical narratives.
|
The Homily of John Chrysostom on How Archangel Michael Defeated Satanail: Between Apocryphal Literature and Oral Tradition
Program Unit: Slavonic Parabiblical Traditions (EABS)
Florentina Badalanova Geller, Freie Universität Berlin
The paper will discuss the apocryphal Homily of John Chrysostom on How Archangel Michael Defeated Satanail which is attested in Slavonic, Greek and Romanian redactions; folklore and iconographic traditions of the Byzantine Commonwealth are to be taken in consideration. Previously neglected data will be included in the analysis of the storyline, comparing and contrasting it to the narrative patterns of some other apocryphal compositions (e.g. The Sea of Tiberias).
|
“Enoch the Scribe”: God’s amanuensis or Satan’s agent
Program Unit: Enoch within and outside the Books of Enoch: Parabiblical Writings, Iconography and Oral Tradition (EABS)
Florentina Badalanova Geller, Freie Universität Berlin
The paper will focus on the image of "Enoch the Scribe" - portrayed either as God's amanuensis, or as a Satanic agent - in the intellectual landscape of the Byzantine Commonwealth. References to the "holy writings" of Enoch in some parabiblical sources (e.g. The Testaments of The Twelve Patriarchs, apocalyptic compositions, etc.) will be explored, along with folklore and iconographic data attested in Slavia Orthodoxa. These traditions will be compared and contrasted to some heretical texts (e.g. The Secret Book of the Bogomils), according to which Enoch is portrayed as a demonic figure and associate of God's adversary. The complex religious background of these two opposite templates will be the main topic of the discussion; hitherto neglected data from vernacular traditions of the three Abrahamic religious will be taken into consideration, thus aiming to create a much broader picture of the transmission and domestication of Enochic writings in medieval Europe and elsewhere.
|
A Recipe is a Recipe: Medicine in the Talmud
Program Unit: Medicine in Bible and Talmud (EABS)
Markham Geller, Freie Universität Berlin
Deciphering medical prescriptions in the Babylonian Talmud often turn out to be counter-intuitive, since modern translations and dictionaries usually accept Geonic definitions of rare terms and Rashi's understanding of passages as definitive and reliable. This often leads to finding exotic medical practices in the Talmud, such as snapping one's fingers 60 times over an abscess, with the inference that Talmudic medicine is unique and governed by 'irrational' approaches and not in line with other systems of medicine in late antiquity. This paper will propose that such translations usually represent a lack of understanding of Talmud medical recipes, which usually follow patterns similar to prescriptions from the same region, although the Talmud often reports abbreviated versions of prescriptions which must be interpreted in the light of comparative data.
|
Different Descriptions of God's Revelation in the Bible: What the God is NOT
Program Unit: What a God is Not – The Early History of Negative Theology (EABS)
Amos Geula, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
The definition of "what a God is not" begins of course already in theology of the Bible itself. On the other hand, the Bible describes God in many cases in a positive way. Naturally, these descriptions range from realism to metaphor.
In this lecture I would like to examine various descriptions of God in the Bible, all of which belong to God's revelation to man, and which use different forms of descriptions in dimensions of space. I intend to compare the descriptions of God's revelation in heaven, in earth, and between heaven and earth: through the Merkaba in heaven (Ezekiel 1; 10); On Mount Sinai (Exodus 19-20), in "Sulam Yaakov" (Genesis 28); In the Heichal (Isaiah 6) and on the altar (Amos 9). I would like to point out a unifying convention in all these descriptions. On the other hand, I would like to point out the fact that these descriptions are never the same - apparently deliberately. According to this convention I would like to explain some of these passages in a new way. In particular, I will present a thesis on this whole phenomenon, according to which the purpose of this changing description is to argue that these descriptions cannot be realistic but must be metaphorical. In other words, there is a sophisticated way to claim what the God is NOT.
|
“Clarifying the Divine Teachings for Thee”: Qur’an’s Self-Identified Role in Clarifying the Bible
Program Unit: Quran and Islamic Tradition in Comparative Perspective
Mohammad Ghandehari, University of Tehran
The textual relationship between the Bible and the Qur'an has been a controversial issue to which many scholars have contributed so far. The problem, however, has been hardly taken into account from the perspective of the scriptures’ self understanding. How the qur’an represent its relationship with the Bible? On the other hand, the scholarship on the Qur’an’s self-image is often concentrated on the Qur’an’s self-representation of its nature and identity. The way the Qur’an thinks of its purpose, its audience and its relation to other texts is yet neglected. In this research, we shall focus on the Qur’an’s self-image of its relation to the Bible. The Qur’an makes the claim of being a “clarification for the Book”, Clarifying (yubayyino) some parts of the Bible/Divine Teachings for the audience. In order to find the exact type of "clarification" Qur'an makes, it is required to study both the qur’anic verses which implies the clarifying status of the Qur’an with respect to the Bible and the qur'anic narratives of biblical stories. Here, we aim at addressing the former. By appealing to the Semitic rhetoric used in the flow of these texts, we have tried to focus on more than six Qur’anic phrases which have the implication that raison d'être of “qur’anic revelation” is to elucidate controversial parts of the old scriptures the. The analysis proposed here attempts to highlight one of the most important dimensions of the Qur’ān’s relationship to the biblical tradition, which may help Christians and Muslims to be able to read their scriptures together and will make room for further comparative studies of common narrative of both scriptures.
|
Of Light, Darkness, and Enjoyment in the Book of Qohelet: The Interaction of Metaphors
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible (EABS)
Agustinus Gianto, Pontificio Istituto Biblico
Following textual-empirical evidence rather than a specific theory of metaphor, this paper traces how notions of “light”, “darkness” and “enjoyment” interact with each other and finally become central metaphors in the Book of Qohelet. The discussion will first show that the book’s major theme of life and its absurdities hinges around the opposing notions of “light” and “darkness”. This way “light” serves as a metaphor for everything that is good, free of trouble, and meaningful, while “darkness” for bad things and its causes and consequences. Furthermore, this pair of metaphors interacts with another key idea of the book, namely that “enjoyment” is good. In fact, this idea builds on the previous pair above and becomes a strong metaphor in the Book of Qohelet. In a literary composition like this, metaphors interact with one another in constructing the main theme. A similar process is also observable in several other wisdom writings, both biblical and extrabiblical.
|
“Israel’s” Only Son? The Complexity of Benjaminite Identity between Judah and Joseph
Program Unit: Methodological Pluralism in the Study of Genesis
Benjamin D. Giffone, LCC International University
Several studies in recent years have sought to articulate the significance of the tribe of Benjamin for historical and literary study of the Hebrew Bible. This paper suggests that the received text of Genesis 35–50 both reflects and illumines the complexities of Israelite identity in the pre-exilic, Babylonian, and Persian periods. The fact that Benjamin is the only son born to “Israel” (other sons are born to “Jacob”) points to Israel’s origins in the land that came to be called “Benjaminite.” Between Josephites to the north and Judahites to the south, Benjaminites preserved a unique identity within the polities of Israel, Judah, Babylonian Yehud, and Persian Yehud. In Genesis 35 and 42–45 in particular, the silent character Benjamin finds himself in the middle of a tug-of-war between his brothers, particularly his full-brother Joseph and his half-brother Judah. The conciliatory message of the narrative of Genesis 35–50 for later communities comes into sharper focus when we see the compromise between tribal identities embedded in the text.
|
"The Nexus of Sacrifice-Eating and Ritual Sexuality" as Unifying Motif in 1 Corinthians 8-11
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Benjamin D. Giffone, LCC International University
The connection between the various sections between the third and fourth περὶ δὲ statements in 1 Corinthians (1 Cor 8:1-11:34) is not entirely clear, leading some scholars to suggest various divisions or rearrangements of the material. This paper suggests that the cultic practices of ancient Israel described (and idealized) in the Pentateuch, specifically with respect to ritual eating and sexuality, serve as a unifying motif for 1 Corinthians 8-11.
Eating and sexual intercourse are viewed as sacred acts in many cultures for their generative capacity and significance for communing with other beings (animals, humans, non-material beings). Thus, they are governed by rituals and taboos, and are often part of ceremonies that are considered “religious” in modern categories.
Ancient Israelite law provided many detailed requirements for eating as part of cultic activity, and also parameters for the sexual activity of priests. Yet ritual sexual activity was not part of “orthodox” Israelite worship, though clearly some ancient Israelites practiced sexual rites.
Against this backdrop of the generative and communicative function of ritual eating and intercourse, Paul applies his understanding of Israelite scripture to various practical issues faced by the Corinthian believers. The relationships between Jews and non-Jews, believers and non-believers, Israel’s deity and other spiritual entities, men and women, “clergy and laity,” and Christ and the church are linked in Paul’s discourse by the common thread of the generative and communicative power of food and sex.
|
A Genre in Decline? The Late Hittite Cuneiform Historiography
Program Unit: Israel in the Ancient Near East (EABS)
Amir Gilan, Tel Aviv University
The most popular genre of Hittite historical writing, attested, even if sporadically, from the very beginning of the Old Kingdom to the very end of the Empire Period is what the Hittites themselves named pešnatar ("Manly Deeds"). The "Manly Deeds" record, in varying degrees of detail, the settlement of political conflicts by the Hittite king, mostly in the form of successful military campaigns. The "Deeds" are often but not always arranged chronologically and depict, as their name suggests, the deeds of the reigning king - or in several famous cases, the deeds of his father and grandfather. The genre undoubtedly reached its peak with the 3 historical works attributed to king Muršili II - the "Ten Years Annals", the "Comprehensive Annals" and the "Manly Deeds of Šuppiluliama". These compositions, representing the pinnacle of Hittite historiographical writing, were also intensively copied by later scribes, perhaps in acknowledgment of their quality. Concurrently, and in contrast thereto, contemporary cuneiform historiography seems to have lost its appeal. Compositions belonging to the genre documenting the deeds of Muršilis successors are only poorly preserved. Consequently, they were relatively neglected in modern scholarship, certainly in comparison to other, better preserved forms of historical writing such as the "Autobiography" of Ḫattušili III or the monumental hieroglyphic inscriptions of Tudḫaliya IV and Šuppiluliyama II. My presentation will review some of these lesser-known texts and address some of the questions that originate from them.
|
Heavenly Secrets, Divine Action and Earthly Experience: The Spatial Dimension of the Book of Revelation
Program Unit: Vision and Envisionment in the Bible and its World (EABS)
Michael Gilbertson, Church House Chester
The paper will assess how the expansion of spatial horizons in the text serves to place the experience of the reader in a wider context of meaning. At the same time, the narrative of the text re-intensifies focus back to the earthly present and carries with it a moral and ethical challenge to the reader. Within the conventional understanding of the spatial relationship of heaven, earth and under the earth, movement upwards (the revelation of heavenly secrets) and downwards (the execution of divine action) take the narrative forward. The paper will argue that one of the key features of the overall narrative of the text is the construction of a spatial dissonance between the perfection of heaven and the ambiguity of earth, which is then resolved in the rest of the narrative, culminating in the descent of the New Jerusalem from heaven to earth. However, resolution in turn brings a re-intensification of dissonance as the reader is challenged to reconcile hope in the ultimate triumph God throughout the cosmos with the continuing demands and perplexity of life in the earthly present.
|
Chronicles, Matthew, and Evidence of Canon Binding between the Testaments
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
Andrew M. Gilhooley, University of Pretoria
Last year’s paper explored the Edict of Cyrus (2 Chr 36:22-23) situated at the end of Chronicles and its possible function as a canon-conscious and programmatic conclusion to both the book itself and the entire Old Testament. This year’s paper will expand this exploration by contending that similar elements of canon-consciousness are evident at the ending of the Old Testament (Chronicles) and the opening of the New Testament (Matthew)—possible elements which will potentially aid in formulating a canon theology. Both Chronicles and Matthew begin with detailed genealogies (1 Chr 1-9; Matt 1:1-17) and end with a commission (2 Chr 36:22-23; Matt 28:16-20)—the only two books in the entire Christian canon to follow such a pattern. The ending of Matthew, moreover, seems to be intentionally modelled on the ending of Chronicles, in which Jesus, like Cyrus, asserts his authority over all the earth, commands his disciples to “go”, and gives the promise that the divine presence will accompany them in their mission (cf. Beale: 2004, 176). It is my contention that Matthew understands Jesus’s commission for his disciplines to “go” and build the church as the fulfillment of Cyrus’s decree, in which also both the Old and New Testaments are bound together in a peculiar manner. Just as the Edict of Cyrus functioned as a programmatic conclusion to both Chronicles and the Old Testament, so does the Great Commission function as a programmatic introduction to the New Testament. The genealogies which open and the commissions which close both Chronicles and Matthew are arguably canon-conscious structural markers intended to bind the Christian canon together and subsequently reflect an early awareness of a two testament canon which was understood as authoritative for the church.
|
Paul and Pseudonymity in the Early Church: A Rhetotheological Approach
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Mark D. Given, Missouri State University
In 2013, Bart Ehrman published Forgery and Counterforgery: The Use of Literary Deceit in Early Christian Polemics. To judge from reviews and other responses, his research has convinced more scholars than ever before that there was no honorable practice of pseudonymous authorship in the ancient world, including the early church. For example, in the second edition of his Invitation to the New Testament (2017), conservative NT scholar, Ben Witherington, adds an appendix expressing his agreement with Ehrman while simultaneously arguing that this conclusion should increase our confidence that no pseudepigraphs were included in the NT! My paper, which follows the majority of critical scholars in concluding that there are pseudepigraphs in the NT, will argue that the phenomena can best be explained by a combination of rhetorical and theological perspectives. Ehrman is on the right track in suggesting that the justification for the deceptive practice of creating Christian forgeries is probably theological. In fact, the theological justification of deception was an aspect of my monograph, Paul’s True Rhetoric: Ambiguity, Cunning, and Deception in Greece and Rome (2001). In this paper, I will connect the dots, so to speak, demonstrating how the theology and worldview embodied in the authentic letters of Paul reflect the presence of a “rhetotheology” in the early church that attributes deceptive and manipulative persuasive strategies to God, and thereby justifies the use of such practices by believers. I further suggest that this rhetotheology helps explain why certain documents were defended by Christian leaders who very likely realized they were probably forgeries. Finally, I will also briefly address recent examples of lying for God in some forms of American Christianity and the ethical and theological issues these present.
|
Passio Charikleae et Theagenous: Comparing Book VIII of the Aethiopika to Martyrdom
Program Unit: Open Forum for New Testament and Early Christian Studies (EABS)
R. Gillian Glass, University of British Columbia
Scholars comparing Heliodorus’ 4th C CE opus to contemporary Christian fiction highlight how Christian authors were influenced by classical thought and paideia. They point to common themes such as virginal and suffering bodies and the defense of chastity as examples of common concerns in both genres. While fruitful, this approach fails to consider influences traveling in the opposite direction. In this paper, I argue that Heliodorus’ representation of the afflicted Theagenes and Chariklea stemmed from the same socio-cultural constructs of gender and class as the Christian authors of martyrologies. In this way, their heroically suffering bodies become the vehicles of their salvation. This paper analyses the incarceration of the protagonists in Book VIII of the Aethiopika, a section that exhibits Heliodorus’ views of both class and gender through sōphrosynē. This narrative is syncretic and integrates both Hellenic and Christian literary traditions: the attempted murder of Chariklea arguably reveals a debt to The Martyrdom of Polycarp. This comparison is justified by the wide spread knowledge of martyrologies by the 4th century generally, and the geographic locations of both stories specifically. Pagans would have heard of these Christian narratives, even if they had not read them. In Book VIII, both hero and heroine are tortured, and the heroine is nearly executed by fire. The torture of Theagenes and Chariklea is recast in salvific terms that show a considerable debt to martyrdom narratives, even if Heliodorus weaves the protagonists’ resistance into archaicizing aristocratic values. Sōphrosynē is simply represented as a hybrid virtue in this novel, incorporating aspects of both the classical Greek virtue and Christian ideal. This study reveals a more complex exchange of thought in Late Antiquity, and invites a revaluation of literature based on its intents and narrative, rather than the author’s religious self-identification.
|
1 Peter 2:13-17 and the Date of 1 Peter
Program Unit: Catholic Epistles
Edward Glenny, University of Northwestern – St. Paul (MN)
1 Peter 2:17 contains the only mention of the emperor in the letter (“Honor the emperor”). Some contend that this command fits best in an historical context in which the recipients of 1 Peter are experiencing some form of imperial persecution and in which they are to resist imperial demands. Others argue that this command would not have been included in 1 Peter if the imperial cult were widespread or if intense persecution of Christians had broken out. The purpose of this paper is to consider the Sitz im Leben of this command in light of the other references to suffering in 1 Peter and then to make some suggestions concerning the implications of that Sitz im Leben on our understanding of the date and authorship of 1 Peter.
|
Stylistic Features in LXX Amos
Program Unit: Septuagint Studies
Edward Glenny, University of Northwestern – St. Paul (MN)
This is a paper about translation technique in LXX Amos. The purpose of the paper is to demonstrate stylistic features in the Greek rendering of the Hebrew text of Amos and then to discuss the importance of those stylistic features for studying and evaluating this Greek translation. The study will focus on the language in the Greek rendering of the Oracles to the Nations in Amos 1:3–2:6, but it will also address the translation of other passages and point out stylistic features in them. In the conclusion of the paper I will attempt to point out the importance of the stylistic features in the Greek translation for reading the Greek text and for textual criticism.
|
Marriage in the Bible: An Inquiry Beginning with Genesis 6:2
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Alexandra Glynn, Bemidji State University
In Genesis 6:2 it says that "the sons of God saw the daughters of men that they were fair, and they took them wives of all which they chose." What does it mean to "take them wives"? What if it means "to know them"? It possibly could, as many have said over the yars. It seems to me that looking at this passage in Genesis 6:2 along with Luke 17:27, as well as passages such as Genesis 24:67, the end of Genesis 38, Deuteronomy 21:13, Judges 8:30, Ruth 1:12, 2 Samuel 13:15-16, Jeremiah 3:1, Matthew 5:31, John 4:18, and 1 Corinthians 6:16, it is possible to argue that knowing someone constituted a marriage in the biblical world. It also makes one wonder again if there is another possibility as to why Joseph was minded to put Mary away in the story about her conception of Jesus at the beginning of Matthew. Drawing on scholarship by Fuchs, Marshall, Rosner, Zaas, and others, this article seeks to deepen a conversation about what exactly marriage meant in various confusing places in the Hebrew Bible and the New Testament. The idea is to shed light on dictionary entries, and also to in a minor way interrogate feminist interpretations of the implications concerning prostitution in the sacred texts.
|
Survey Results on Ethics and Policies Regarding Unprovenanced Materials
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Matthew Goff, Florida State University
The chairs of the Unit, in cooperation with the steering committee and the Working with Cultural Objects and Manuscripts (WCOM) project, set up an online survey for Qumran and Dead Sea Scrolls scholars (to be implemented during spring 2018) to gather data in the field regarding the ethics and policies as related to the Dead Sea Scrolls. This is a brief summary of the survey results, in order to invite discussion in the session.
|
Primordial History Not according to Moses: The Creative Reformulation of Watchers Mythic Traditions in Nag Hammadi Texts
Program Unit: Enoch within and outside the Books of Enoch: Parabiblical Writings, Iconography and Oral Tradition (EABS)
Matthew Goff, Florida State University
In this paper I examine the exegetical mindset that shapes the iteration of the Enochic Watchers myth in the Nag Hammadi Apocryphon of John. It is reasonable to suspect that the text was produced with access to a Greek version of the Book of the Watchers. The creative and loose adaptation of how the Apocryphon reworks the watchers myth as found in that Enochic book accords with how this Nag Hammadi text reformulates the Book of Genesis. Key for understanding the composition’s exegetical perspective is the view that Watchers fills out the story of Genesis and that Genesis is itself a valid but imperfect account of how the cosmos came into being, thus requiring elaboration and reworking. I also speculate that the absence of attributing texts or revelation to Enoch in the Apocryphon of John and the Nag Hammadi library in general makes sense when his reception in late antique Egypt is understood. In that context he is more often associated with final judgment not the origins of the cosmos.
|
Metal and Stone as Symbols of Humanity and the Divine: A Study of Analogous Narratives
Program Unit: Literary Features – Fact or Fiction (EABS)
Naama Golan, Ariel University
Analogy between biblical narratives is an important and meaningful literary device. Uncovering analogies significantly contributes to a deeper understanding of the biblical narrative, and often sheds new light on each individual text.
There is a dual straightforward resemblance between the David and Goliath narrative (I Sam 17) and Nebuchadnezzar's Dream narrative (Daniel 2). David, who defeats Goliath, parallels Daniel, who is victorious over the wise men of Babylonia; and Goliath, who is defeated and falls, parallels the wise men of Babylonia, who fail in their attempts to decipher the dream. However, the analogy between the two narratives is much broader. Goliath, who falls to the ground in his metal shields, also parallels the statue in Nebuchadnezzar's dream, which is made entirely of metal. Despite the comprehensive analogy, which is supported by lexical, symbolic, and content similarities, the likeness of the two narratives has not received the attention it deserves in biblical scholarship.
The analogy is reinforced by the similar use of symbols in the two narratives: the enormous statue in Nebuchadnezzar's dream is made of metals and symbolize the 'Four Kingdoms' that will rise and fall one after the other, is similar to the giant Goliath who is wrapped in metal and copper. David's stone, which defeats Goliath, and the stone that shatters the statue in the dream, both represent God's sovereignty. The use of this symbol is also apparent in the Golden Calf narrative (Ex. 32): the stone tablets that are given to Moses on Sinai represent God, while the Golden Calf represents human handiwork.
In this lecture, I will outline the analogy between narratives, analyze its literary contribution, and elucidate the impact of the symbolic use of natural stone as a representation of God, and artificial metal as a symbol of man.
|
Lists, Location and Creation: Enuma Eliš’ List of Marduk’s Names and Biblical Lists
Program Unit: Israel in the Ancient Near East (EABS)
Shira Golani, Hebrew University of Jerusalem and Gordon Academic
The Babylonian creation myth Enuma Eliš culminates with a list of the fifty names of the god Marduk, as proclaimed by his fellow gods. The paper discusses this list’s place and function within Enuma Eliš, engaging with the scholarship of W.G. Lambert (esp., Babylonian Creation Myths, 2013) and A. Seri (“The Fifty Names of Marduk in Enuma eliš”, 2006), and complementing this discussion with a comparison of this case-study to examples from the Hebrew Bible, where the location of a list within its narrative context serves narrative functions. Thus, the paper sheds light on ancient Near Eastern scribal techniques in incorporating lists in narrative compositions.
|
Manuscripts of the Hebrew Bible: Their Typology and the Use in Biblical Textual Criticism
Program Unit: Textual Criticism: Manuscripts & Methods
Viktor Golinets, Hochschule für Jüdische Studien Heidelberg
Publications about textual criticism of the Hebrew Bible provide different numbers of Hebrew manuscripts. One of the figures given is 5000. This information is meaningless because the number is approximate and the reference to the manuscripts is unspecific. Neither the types of manuscripts are indicated, nor is it clear if singular pages which have survived from complete manuscripts are counted. Does this figure include Dead Sea scrolls as well as other “ancient” manuscripts, or does it cover only medieval manuscripts? Are the unvocalised Tora and Megillot scrolls comprised or not? What is the time limit for manuscripts assessed, and should the manuscripts written within the book print age be counted?
Another issue is the use of the manuscripts in the textual criticism, and with it is connected the lack of any accepted nomenclature of manuscripts utilised in editions and studies. Every author and every edition employs own systems. While this practice is not per se an impediment for the research, it is methodologically justifiable to ask if a uniform system comparable with that used in the New Testament textual studies should be established. If yes, how could it be organised, and what information should it feature?
Yet another topic is the question what textual information from Hebrew manuscripts should be featured in textual edition. Should every deviant trait of manuscript text be mentioned in an edition, or would it be better to treat manuscript variants in distinct studies, and then to cite in textual editions only “filtered” information provided in manuscript descriptions? In the latter case, extensive textual studies should be conducted before a textual edition of any type could be approached.
The paper discussed the questions mentioned above, establishes a typology of manuscripts, and seeks to put different aspects of Hebrew Bible manuscripts studies in relation to each other.
|
Blotting Out the Name: Scribal Practices Related to Correcting the Tetragrammaton in Medieval Hebrew Bible Manuscripts
Program Unit: Textual Criticism: Manuscripts & Methods
Nehemia Gordon, Makor Hebrew Foundation
As early as the Dead Sea Scrolls, the Tetragrammaton was given special treatment by Jewish scribes, sometimes being written in Paleo-Hebrew script or indicated by four dots (Tetrapuncta). An early rabbinic interpretation of Deuteronomy 12:4 deemed it prohibited to “blot out” the Tetragrammaton. This was taken to mean erasing even a single letter of God’s personal four-letter name (Sifre Deut. and parallels). This rule and its corollaries were codified in the tractate of Soferim (chapter 5), posing special problems for scribes when errors were made in writing the Tetragrammaton. This paper will illustrate how Jewish scribes implemented this prohibition with examples of scribal corrections surrounding the Tetragrammaton in medieval Hebrew Bible manuscripts.
Recent large-scale digitization projects have made it possible to examine hundreds of medieval Hebrew Bible manuscripts. It will be shown that the ideal codified in the Tractate of Soferim was usually followed, forcing scribes to use dots and other notations to “erase” spurious instances of the Tetragrammaton. Some unique phenomena will also be presented, such as the non-standard use of the Qere notation to indicate an ad hoc scribal correction of the Tetragrammaton. Exceptions to the rules codified in Soferim will also be considered. Despite the stringent prohibition, there were occasionally medieval Jewish scribes who “blotted out” the Tetragrammaton.
|
Disability Readings of the Lukan Banquet Parables in 14:7-24
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Louise Gosbell, Mary Andrews College
With the development of disability readings of the Bible, the parables of Luke 14:7-24 have been assessed anew with an attempt from scholars to cast off traditional ableist interpretations of these important Lukan references to disability. James Metzger (“God in the Parable of the Snubbed Host”), for example, has argued that the Lukan gospel in general reveals Jesus representing “ablebodied infantilization of the disabled” in his healings of the woman bent-over (13:15) and the man with swelling (14:5) which is “thus mirrored (in) the ableist householder in (the parable in) 14:15-24.” Likewise, Markus Schiefer Ferrari (“(Un)gestörte Lektüre von Lk 14, 12-14”), has also assessed these parables within the broader context of the Lukan portrayal of Jesus likewise arguing that a disability sensitive reading of these parables is important because of the long history of interpretations that have been propelled by, at worst, unconscious discrimination of people with disability, or, at best, limited sensitivity to the possible range of the bodily experiences of humanity. And yet, in contrast to Metzger and Schiefer Ferrari’s reflections on these parables, the recent Baylor University volume, The Bible and Disability: A Commentary edited by Sarah J. Melcher, Mikeal C. Parsons, and Amos Yong, overlooks the parables of Luke 14:7-24 altogether. Given this omission, this paper seeks to consider once more the implications of a disability reading of the Lukan parables of Luke 14:7-24. What, if anything, can a disability reading of these parables reveal to us about attitudes towards disability in the early Jesus movement? In what ways can interpretations of these parables seek to reinforce and promote the aims of disability readings of the biblical texts in defying categories of normalcy and homogeny?
|
Sensory Criticism and the Fourth Gospel
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Louise Gosbell, Mary Andrews College
In the last ten years, there has been an increase in scholarly interest in the role and representation of the body and the nature of the body in ancient texts including the biblical texts. This interest in the body in general has also included a growing interest in the role of the senses in ancient texts and what sensory language can tell us about ancient expectations of the body. Constance Classen, for example, suggests that sensory perception “is a cultural as well as a physical act” thus studying the role of the senses in ancient communities affords us the opportunity to the consider the senses as vehicles for the “transmission of cultural values.” Despite this, sensory studies are still at their inception with respect to the biblical texts. This paper seeks to survey briefly the use of sensory language in the Johannine gospel with the particular aim of bringing this sensory language into dialogue with the growing field of sensory criticism. It is clear from the outset of the Fourth Gospel that the text is replete with sensory language – the tasting of the newly turned water-to-wine, the touching of Jesus’ wounds by the so-called ‘doubting’ Thomas, the stench of Lazarus’ body following his death – thus what insights can be brought anew to the Johannine gospel through applying the methodology of sensory criticism? In what ways does the Johannine author represent and/or subvert the “transmission of cultural values” through his use of sensory language? In addition, this paper will respond to two recent publications on the senses and sense perception in the Fourth Gospel that of Rainer Hirsch-Luipold (Mohr Siebeck, 2017) and Sunny Kuan-Hui Wang (Mohr Siebeck, 2017) and consider ways that the insights of these investigations could be developed further through engaging with the growing field of sensory criticism.
|
Frame, Allegory, and the Parable of the Sower
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Thomas E. Goud, University of New Brunswick
Two questions have persisted concerning the parables of Jesus since the time of Adolf Jülicher’s landmark study and the subsequent work of Dodd and Jeremias: i) should the parables be cut from the frames in which we find them in the synoptic gospels? and ii) to what extent are allegorical interepretations appropriate? Of particular importance is the parable of the sower. It is one of only three narrative parables in all three of the synoptic gospels and appears in all three in a closely ordered block of pericopes. Furthermore, it comes complete with a general discussion of Jesus’s use of parables and a tutorial on the interpretation for his disciples. And that interpetation, which is allegorical, is prefaced in Mark’s account with the questions: “Do you not understand this parable? How then will you know all the parables?” In 4:2, Mark claims that Jesus “taught them many things in parables” and concludes the section once again emphasizing that Jesus taught “many such parables” (33). Mark sees this as so characteristic of Jesus’s teaching that he can even claim that Jesus did not teach anything without a parable and that he then regularly explained the parables to his disciples in private (34). Whatever one’s preferred solution to the relationship between the synoptic gospels, it is clear that all three evangelists chose to highlight the parable of the sower in the same complex frame and with the same allegorical interpretation. I propose a reconsideration of these two problems in the parable of the sower in light of recent works by Klyne Snodgrass (2008), Craig Blomberg (2012), John Dominic Crossan (2012), Amy Jill Levine (2014), Ruben Zimmermann (2015), Ernest van Eck (2016), Charles Hedrick (2016), and John P. Meier (2016).
|
“Hear the Metaphors That I Am Commanding You Today!” The Affective Dimension of Metaphor Clusters in Deuteronomy 4
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible (EABS)
Alison Gray, Westminster College (Cambridge)
Deuteronomy 4 has attracted attention from source critics and literary critics alike in recent decades. It sets a striking paraenetic tone to introduce the book’s warning against idolatry, and thus provides fruitful ground for an exploration of metaphor clusters that frame or underpin its message. This paper will explore the rhetorical function and impact of particular metaphor clusters in Deuteronomy 4, particularly as they relate to other clusters in chapters 1-3, 5-11 and the rest of the book. A close look at the metaphors in this chapter will shed a supporting light on arguments for the unity of the chapter and its integration within the wider literary context.
Deuteronomy, unlike other parts of the Hebrew Bible, is not kaleidoscopic in its array or density of metaphors, and yet its word patterns paint symbolic inner mindscapes and outer landscapes as the backdrop to Moses’ instructions to Israel. Metaphor clusters are often used in didactic texts because of their affective dimension, that is, they can trigger certain emotions, and influence the audience’s attitudes and values. In Deuteronomy 4 there are clusters of metaphors that picture Israel as ‘clinging’, ‘keeping’ and ‘guarding’, and a jealous, devouring God who speaks from the fire, yet is without form. All of these powerful word pictures are set against the background of God’s gift of land, and the cosmic context in which heaven and earth themselves are called as witnesses.
|
Identifying Goddesses: Rethinking a Silver Pendant from Tel Miqne-Ekron
Program Unit: Iconography and Biblical Studies (EABS)
Taylor Gray, University of St Andrews
Incised on a seventh-century silver pendant found by Gitin in the northeast acropolis at Tel Miqne-Ekron is a scene of a female astride a leashed-lion with a male worshipper standing opposite her. Since the time of its discovery, scholars have almost unanimously identified the female in question as Mesopotamian Ishtar, leading some to suggest that the pendant demonstrates the presence of Ishtar veneration in the area. Identifying the female as the goddess Ishtar is largely governed by an interpretive principle that assumes a high degree of overlap between the formal/morphological qualities of the scene and its 'meaning'/semantics in relation to analogous motifs from Mesopotamia. In other words, because the figure is depicted almost identically to Mesopotamian Ishtar, so the argument goes, the figure must be Ishtar, and because the Ekronite pendant ‘contains’ Isthar, Ekronite communities must have worshipped the goddess. But is Ishtar the best and only interpretation? Indeed, is identifying the female on the pendant as Ishtar even the correct interpretation? This paper proposes that there are defensible alternatives for the interpretation of the mysterious Ekronite woman that extend beyond Ishtar. It proceeds in two parts. First, the paper reviews the traditional Ishtar interpretation. Second, other evidence that is generally left out when identifying the female figure will be brought forth to bolster an alternative interpretation. By way of conclusion, the paper raises a number of questions regarding the method of iconographic interpretation in scholarly circles and asks whether or not the normative mode of interpreting iconographic material is as reliable as usually presumed.
|
"If the Sun Shone on Him" (Exodus 22:2): A Different Approach
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Law
Ed Greenstein, Bar-Ilan University
Laws concerning the theft of a farm animal in Exod 21:37 and 22:2b are interrupted by a case of homicide. A thief is caught in the act of breaking in or afterwards (22:1-2a). Two situations are described. In the first, the thief is killed by the householder in the act of breaking in; in the second, the thief is killed by the householder once “the sun has shone on him.” In the former, the slayer is free of bloodguilt; in the latter, he is not. The difference is usually attributed to the time of the break-in. The former takes place at night, the second by day. This interpretation is supported by comparative evidence. In the present paper, the usual understanding is challenged. The expression “the sun shone on him” is shown to have a particular meaning in biblical parlance that is not primarily as an indicator of time. The entire law of slaying a home-invader is explained according to a particular logic that is twice exemplified in the preceding laws.
|
The Enumeration of Divine Attributes and Their Parody in the Discourses of Job
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Wisdom
Ed Greenstein, Bar-Ilan University
One of the most widespread methods of imparting and cultivating theological knowledge is by way of liturgy. Prayers routinely incorporate references to the attributes of the deity. Numerous biblical psalms, conventionally classified as hymns or praise, include assertions about the powers and virtues of God—the creator, protector, healer, savior, etc. In the Hebrew Bible there is a well-known grammar of such attributes, describing the deity in the third person and employing participles and relative clauses in order to convey the pertinent qualities (see, e.g., Gunkel’s Introduction to the Psalms [trans. Nogalski; 1998], 31-32). Such elements are also characteristic of many so-called wisdom psalms. They are also characteristic, for example, of the Babylonian hymn to the sun-god Shamash, which has a distinct affinity to what is ordinarily understood as wisdom. In the book of Job the companions adopt the trope of enumerating divine attributes in order to remind Job of traditional theological norms as they seek to impress them upon him. Job, however, reacts by parodying the teachings of both the hymnal literature and its adaptations by his companions. The rhetorical means by which Job makes such theological protestations will be examined in this paper.
|
"Trauma Is Suffering That Remains": The Theoretical Contribution of a Psychology of Trauma to the Study and Interpretation of Prophetic Literature
Program Unit: Psychological Hermeneutics of Biblical Themes and Texts
Alphonso Groenewald, University of Pretoria
The phenomenon of trauma has always been part of the history of humankind. Although the psychological study of trauma spans a little more than a century, the literature within the field of psychology which focuses on trauma, is infinite. The application of a psychology of trauma has been common practice in several fields (e.g. anthropology, classics, comparative literature, history of medicine, sociology, etc). It, however, has only been since a couple of years that biblical scholars have used the concept of trauma as an important tool to interpret biblical texts. The aim of this paper is firstly to provide a very short overview of the history of psychological
trauma studies in order to understand its impact on theology and biblical studies. Secondly, it will describe the impact of trauma studies on theology and biblical studies. In the last section the focus will be on this new interdisciplinary conversation taking place between psychological trauma studies on the one hand, and the interpretation of prophetic literature on the other hand. Insights from the field of
trauma studies point to passages that anticipate disaster, as well as the solution they offer to survive disaster. Of particular interest are texts that emerged from experiences of collective devastation and exile. In the development of a theological hermeneutic for trauma the exegete cannot avoid dealing with both the victim and the perpetrator of violence. It is the latter that presents a special challenge to the
exegete, especially when God is described as the agent of this trauma.
|
The "Song of the Vineyard" (Isaiah 5:1-7) through the Lens of Trauma and Disaster Studies
Program Unit: Prophets and Prophecy (EABS)
Alphonso Groenewald, University of Pretoria
In this paper the field of trauma studies, a new interdisciplinary conversation, will be applied to the book of Isaiah. Insights from this field point to passages that anticipate disaster, as well as offer ways of surviving disaster. Of particular interest are texts that emerged from experiences of collective devastation and exile. The book of Isaiah draws its readers into the darkest valleys of destruction. The first part is full of oracles hammering its audience with images of corruption and warnings of imminent doom. The prophet’s oracles offered a reality check for the Isaianic interpretative community who reflected on the significance of his words for subsequent generations. The ‘Song of the Vineyard’ in Isaiah 5:1-7 is a masterpiece. The prophet sings about his friend’s failed attempts to grow good grapes in his vineyard. As the text progresses, the reader gets to know that the owner of the vineyard is YHWH and that the vineyard, with its sour grapes, is his people. As the interpretative community puts on the prophetic mantle it answers the questions about the causes of collapse. YHWH is the one who will allow his people to be trampled and Judah to be plundered. The ‘Song of the Vineyard’ is a text that describes God’s use of traumatizing penalties to enforce obedience. In the development of a theological hermeneutic for trauma the exegete cannot avoid dealing with both the victim and the perpetrator of violence. It is the latter that presents a special challenge to the exegete, precisely because God is often described as the agent of trauma. Maybe this Song that attributes suffering to God’s punishment can be understood as a representation of trauma that serves as a mechanism of survival, recovery and resilience.
|
Paul, Soteriology, and the Problem of Internal Evidence
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
William "Chip" Gruen, Muhlenberg College
Biblical scholarship is, to a large degree, hamstrung by a paucity of manuscript resources from the ancient period. With the exception of few papyrological fragments, we are left to rely on a manuscript tradition that emerges generations after the original composition of the texts in question. Aland and Aland's "Twelve Basic Rules for Text Criticism" include in part that "Criticism of the text must always begin from the evidence of the manuscript tradition" and "Internal criteria can never be the sole basis for a critical decision". However, abiding by these rules guarantees that changes made to the text before the emergence of the manuscript tradition are uncritically imagined as “original.” Building on the work of William Walker, this paper questions the necessity of this conservative approach by introducing a text case from the Pauline corpus. Rather than prioritizing the question of interpolations, however, the study starts with an examination of the use of the words “blood” and “sacrifice” in the earliest Pauline materials. By collating the uses of these terms with a newly available database of “conjectural emendations” from previous scholarship, I hope to show the plausibility of a method that values internal evidence as a basis of establishing ancient readings. Finally, having considered the possibility of interpolation, I will offer an interpretive framework for the findings that combines a comparative typology of sacrifice (using Eliade, Evans-Pritchard, and Smith) with a reconstruction of the historical circumstances of the emergence of a routinized mythical/ritual complex in the ancient Christian context.
|
Assuming Identity to Build Identity: The Imagined Other as Narrator and Recipient in the Letter of Aristeas and the Third Book of the Sibylline Oracles
Program Unit: Construction of Identity in the Ancient World: Intersections and Reflections (EABS)
Agata Grzybowska, Uniwersytet Warszawski
In this paper I will analyze the constructs of the Other as the narrator and as the recipient in the Letter of Aristeas and in the Third Book of the Sibylline Oracles, as well as compare them (as the two texts stem, arguably, from two different geographical and social contexts) to present their strategies of using the imagined outsider for the validation of the Jewish identity in the Diaspora. Conjuring up a figure of an outsider and having them speak about the Jews is a common practice in the Jewish literature of the Second Temple Period. This form of self-validation in the mouth of a non-Jew finds its fullest expression in two pseudepigraphical works from the Hellenistic Period: the Letter of Aristeas and the Third Book of the Sibylline Oracles. These two texts were not only written entirely from an outsider’s perspective, but were also made to appear as written for outsiders. In the Letter of Aristeas the narrator and the recipient are both distinguished Greek court officials, whereas in the Third Sibyl the narrator is a “pagan” prophetess who introduces herself as Noah’s niece (and therefore can be interpreted as a representative of the universal mankind), whose prophecies are addressed chiefly to Greeks. As numerous scholars agree, both of these works were actually written for a Jewish audience, which underscores their importance for the construction of a literary identity of the Jewish Diaspora in the Hellenistic Period. While the narrator and the recipient in the Letter of Aristeas are both distinctly Greek figures, who are ready to appropriate elements of Jewish heritage into their worldview, the Third Sibyl goes one step further by appropriating the well-known figure of the pagan prophetess, connecting her to the Jewish tradition and having her speak to the Greeks from a position of authority.
|
Times of Evil: Diverse Temporalities in the Apocryphal Psalms (11Q11)
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
Tupá Guerra, Universidade de Brasília
Apocryphal Psalms (11Q11) is one of the texts from the Dead Sea Scrolls that deals with evil beings. Temporal aspects are the element which defines the possibilities of actions of evil in the world, and it also mark which are the correct moments when humans can perform apotropaic actions against the threat of evil beings. This paper will explore the different temporalities described in the Apocryphal Psalms (11Q11), focusing on how magical and eschatological elements are informed by the many notions of time presented. “Time” will be understood as a broad concept, comprising periods of the day/night or eras and ages of human or world history.
|
The Reference to Moses in Neh 9:14b: Sources, Significance, and Function
Program Unit: Writings (including Psalms)
Hava Shalom Guy, David Yellin College, Jerusalem
The historical survey in the confessional prayer in Neh 9:6-37 differs from other biblical historical surveys. It does not open with the Israelites’ descent to Egypt, enslavement, and release from slavery (e.g., Judg 6:7-10; 1 Sam 12; Pss 78, 106), but with Abraham. It also differs in its treatment of Moses. The second unit of the survey (vv. 9-11), which describes the enslavement in Egypt and the Exodus, makes no mention of Moses, the protagonist of the pentateuchal Exodus tradition. Rather, through the use of second-person singular verbs, the description highlights divine mercy for Israel. Moses’s absence here is consistent with his “removal” from other biblical texts that narrate miraculous events, such as the crossing of the Reed Sea (Exod 15:1ff.; Josh 2:10, 4:23; Ps 78:13, 114:1-8, among others). This trend continues in rabbinic literature.
The sole mention of Moses in the survey is found in v. 14b: “and You ordained for them laws, commandments and Teaching, through Moses Your servant.” This refers not to Moses’s taking the Israelites out of Egypt and leading them in the wilderness, but only to the tradition of the giving of the Torah by Moses. This portrayal of Moses is related to the survey’s reference to the divine giving of the Torah (and the Sabbath; vv. 13-14a), which is not mentioned in other biblical surveys of Israelite history.
This lecture will attempt to show that this represents the stabilization of pentateuchal authority in Israelite life during the restoration period and the importance assumed by its public reading and study.
|
A Rabbinic Matryoshka: A Midrash within a Parable (Tsan 8:9); The Divine as Feminine and the World as House
Program Unit: Parables in Rabbinic Judaism and Early Christianity: Towards a New Comparative Approach (EABS)
Cecilia Haendler, Freie Universitaet Berlin
This paper focuses on a literary unit in tSan 8:9, presenting a case of the tannaitic use of feminine images as a figurative source domain from which a religious understanding is communicated. It is the last part of a section philosophical in nature, reflecting on Divine justice, humanity’s equality and diversity, and concluding with the question of why Adam was the last in the order of creation. The question-answer exegetical structure that ensues is used also in Christian exegesis, and indicates a controversy with opponents. Different answers are provided: for instance, that humanity came last to show the minim (heretics) that nobody assisted the Divine in creation, or so that the first human being (‘rabbinized’) could immediately perform a mitsvah (Shabbat observance). As a last answer, a parable is brought about a king (the Divine) who makes a banquet (the world) and invites a guest (humanity). This question, along with the parable, is also found in Philo’s OpMund and in Gregor of Nyssa’s OpHom. Philo and the Tosefta even share parallels in their wording. The rabbinic passage, however, presents an additional element, absent in the other two texts: a midrash encapsulated within the parable. This rhetoric strategy gives a new meaning to the parable, coloring it in the feminine and giving a rabbinic twist. Also the polemical context and the remark on the commandment’s performance make this contribution seem consciously perceived as their own. The Tosefta assembles different biblical texts in a story-image of the Divine creating the world as a woman who cares for her household, constructing it, preparing food. Wisdom is attributed to domestic work which, projected on the Divine, acquires value. The comparison of the Creator to an intelligent woman is an unexpected, shocking element that conveys rabbinic views on the feminine, the Divine, and the world.
|
The Angel of Satan in Corinth
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Lukas Hagel, Lunds Universitet
In the discussion regarding the phrase ”an angel of Satan” in 2 Cor 12:7, several possible
interpretations have been supplied throughout history. The suggestions are many, such as a demon,
migraine, blindness, or human opponents. Recent scholars have narrowed the discussion down to
either a disease, or Paul’s opponents. The purpose of my presentation is to argue that Paul was
aiming these harsh words towards the people who were undermining his authority in Corinth. I
explore this interpretation by using primarily two sociological theories that have not been used on
this text before, but have been used on other New Testament texts.
Using a modified Socio-Rhetorical method, I employ theories concerning group identity and
group formation and apply them to the wider context of 2 Cor 10–13. My thesis is that Paul creates
a sort of ”prototype” of himself and an ”anti-type” of his opponents, and in this way, he is showing
the community in Corinth what it is to be a true believer of Christ. By behaving in the proper way, a
person is considered being an ”insider”, while any deviations from this behaviour, makes you an
”outsider”.
I also apply Howard Garfinkel’s Status Degradation Theory on the text and trace Paul’s use
of different words to label his opponents—in effect showing the community in Corinth that these
people, Paul’s opponents, are not to be trusted. In fact, they belong not to Christ, but to Satan, and
are doing his bidding by being ”Satan’s angels”. Using these theories I propose that when Paul says
that he has an ”angel of Satan” beating him, he is referring to his opponents.
|
"Abjection, your Honour!": A Reading of Psalm 88 as a Work of Abject Art
Program Unit: Deconstructive Poetics (EABS)
Karin Hakalax , VID Specialized University
Psalm 88 has by commentators been felt to represent an enigma, if not an embarrassment in the Hebrew Bible, or as Brueggeman puts it: «an embarrassment to the conventional faith» (Message of the Psalms, 1984, p. 78.) The Psalm is saturated with pain and suffering, and is the biblical text with the richest use of images and metaphors of death and wrath of God. Compared to a standard biblical text of lament, Psalm 88 differs significantly, lacking any sign of hope, seemingly ending in utter darkness. This paper discusses the function of the Psalm in a postmodern, secular setting. This presentation focuses on a constructive approach to Psalm 88, and introduces avant-garde vocal artist Diamanda Galas’ groundbreaking reading of the Psalm. The paper explores Galas’ uncanny interpretation of the crying voice of the dying person in her vocal version of Psalm 88, «Free Among the Dead,» on the album «The Divine Punishment,» where she is making rich use of biblical texts. Galas works in the field of abject art, using "Schrei Opera" as a means of expressing her artistery. Another approach in this study is Julia Kristeva’s concept of abjection. The method is interdisciplinary, using rhetoric-critical and reader-response methods and a Kristevan psychoanalytical and literary theory approach, with the use of voice as a work metaphor. Galas’ use of Psalm 88 represents an interpretation of the Psalm as a work of liberating, therapeutic and cathartic art. The presentation will include a video / musical presentation of Diamanda Galas’ «Free Among the Dead.»
|
Interpreting the Gospel Stories in Their Social Context
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Sakari Häkkinen, Diocese of Kuopio, Finland
Academic research on the parables and other Gospel stories has been for centuries focused on the meaning of words in their literary context. When the analysis has been carefully done, the Sitz im Leben, the context or setting of the story or the entire gospel, has been defined in order to form a view of the community that used these stories, or in order to interpret the particular story from the point of view of the supposed community. This has led evidentially to the ¬¬- often unmentioned - view that the western academics are the best experts in understanding and interpreting the often quite strange parables and other words of Jesus. My book The Gospel of the Poor (Lambert Academics 2017) challenges this view. By telling the Gospel stories in African villages or in Palestinian towns showed me that people living in poverty or suffering from occupation do hear and understand the texts differently, at least if they have not been told beforehand the “right” meaning of the story. In my paper, I want to rise discussion about the usefulness of this kind of inter-contextual study to the study of Synoptic Gospels. Do people living in poverty and in a culture much closer to the NT times than most of the scholars understand the stories in such a way that needs to be heard also in academic studies? It would be useful for the participants to read the Gospel of the Poor before attending the session.
|
The First Heavenly Journey of Enoch (1Enoch 17) according to the Geneva Papyrus 187
Program Unit: Enoch within and outside the Books of Enoch: Parabiblical Writings, Iconography and Oral Tradition (EABS)
David Hamidovic, Université de Lausanne
The Geneva Papyrus 187 quotes a passage of The Book of the Watchers relating to the first heavenly journey of Enoch (1Enoch 17). The Greek text is different from the Akhmim fragments. Therefore the possibility of another Greek version of The Book of the Watchers should be raised.
|
New Materialism: A New Direction for Ecological Hermeneutics
Program Unit: The Bible and Ecology (EABS)
Robin Hamon, University of Sheffield
In this paper, I propose that the ontology of new materialism offers an innovative and original approach for analysing biblical texts from an ecological perspective. New materialism is perhaps best understood as an ontological model, but has been applied in a range of scientific, philosophical, political, and literary contexts since its emergence in the 1990s. In short, new materialism seeks to conceptualise the world, and indeed the wider universe, from a non-anthropocentric perspective by acknowledging the agency of both human and non-human entities, and the inherent interconnection and interdependence of all things. In these respects, then, new materialism appears to be compatible with the principles of ecology established in the last century. There is therefore potential to use new materialist ontology to examine biblical texts from an environmental perspective. I shall begin by discussing three principles that are central to new materialist thinking; (1) non-human agency, (2) interconnectedness, and (3) scale. I shall then show how these three principles are compatible with, but different to, the contemporary ecological theory upon which ecological hermeneutics has been founded. Finally, using the depiction of the physical world in Jonah 1:4 in exemplification I shall demonstrate how the ontology of new materialism might be applied to produce innovative interdisciplinary ecological readings of biblical texts.
|
The Influence of the Tergwāmē to Daniel on Daniel 11 in the Ge'ez Manuscript Tradition
Program Unit: Textual Criticism: Manuscripts & Methods
James R. Hamrick, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
Our earliest Ge'ez (classical Ethiopic) Daniel manuscripts contain a dramatically abbreviated version of Daniel chapter 11. Later scribes supplemented Daniel 11 in several different ways (extending Daniel 11 itself, appending a second, longer version at the end of Daniel or the end of the manuscript, etc.), drawing on at least two other distinct, Syro-Arabic sources. This was already noted by Oscar Löfgren (1927), who claimed that the extended versions of Daniel 11 were revisions based on Syro-Arabic Daniel witnesses. In the course of our preparation of a critical edition to the Tergwāmē (Ge'ez commentary) to Daniel, we have discovered that one of these extended versions has been taken from the lemma of this Tergwāmē, which offers us an independent translation of the entire book of Daniel (sans Susanna) based ultimately on the Peshitta. In addition to drawing on the lemma to supplement Daniel 11, some manuscripts also include marginal notes to Daniel 11 that may have been drawn from the commentary proper. We provide an overview of Daniel 11 in the Ge'ez tradition, offering a taxonomy of the different forms it takes. We then briefly introduce the Tergwāmē to Daniel, before exploring the influence of this text on Daniel chapter 11 in Ge'ez Daniel manuscripts. This case study can (1) enrich our understanding of the revisional activity that took place within the Ethiopian biblical manuscript tradition in the 14th century and beyond, showing us that biblical commentaries were one of the sources used to revise biblical texts, (2) provide us with an example of how versions of Daniel ultimately based on the LXX were influenced by semitic versions, and (3) contribute to the question of how lemma from commentary materials are used in the text-critical and text-historical study of biblical texts.
|
God’s Questions: Irony in God’s First Speech in the Book of Job (Job 38:1–39:30)
Program Unit: Writings (including Psalms)
Tobias Häner, University of Vienna
Paradoxically, God’s answers to Job in Job 38–41 consist – namely at the beginning – to a large extent of questions. In scholarship, these questions are unanimously recognized as ironic. But what is the aim of the irony in this part of the book? Attempts to identify the rhetorical effect and aims of the irony in God’s bipartite speech often lack theoretical foundations. Therefore, in my paper I will firstly compare theories on the function of irony in philosophical, linguistic and literary perspective and secondly propose a set of criteria in order to identify elements of irony in biblical texts and to evaluate their rhetoric function. Thirdly, I will examine Job 38:1–39:30 based on the proposed methodology and by this offer an interpretation of the rhetoric of irony in God’s first speech.
|
The Seams of Wisdom: The Beginnings and Ends of the Books of Job, Proverbs and Psalms in Intertextual Perspective
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
Tobias Häner, Universität Wien
In the Hebrew Bible, the books of Psalms, Proverbs and Job form a distinct group among the Writings. The connection between the three books is not just based on agreement in form (i.e. the poetic language) and content (e.g. the opposition of the just and the wicked). In my paper, I will particularly focus on the intertextual interplay at the beginnings and the ends of the three books, as e.g. the beginning of Job (איש היה) echoes the opening of the Psalter (אשרי האיש), while in contrast the book of Proverbs ends with the praise of the אשת חיל. The central questions of my study are: To what extent do the parallels at the beginnings and the ends of the three books encourage their contextual reading? How do the parallels and contrasts reciprocally influence the reading of each writing? In which sense do the “seams” of the books propose a reading order (e.g. Psalms before Job)?
|
The Ambiguous Use of “Nephesh” in Job 7:11-16
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israel and in ANE Wisdom Literature (EABS)
James E. Harding, University of Otago
In Job 7:11-16, it is made quite clear that the suffering of Job is not merely physical, but psychological and spiritual as well. His psychic torment is manifested here in the dreams and visions (7:14) that mock his fond hope that his bed would be a source of comfort (7:13), and this mental distress is compounded by his sense that the source of this violent attack on his inner life is God. In order to give expression to this conjunction of physical, psychological, and spiritual distress, the poet exploits the well-known polyvalence of the Hebrew noun nephesh. In 7:11, “mar naphshî” can be taken to mean “the bitterness of my soul,” an inner bitterness that forces Job to speak out in protest, and in 7:15 “naphshî” can be taken as the subject of “wativchar,” thus “my soul has chosen strangling,” or “I [myself] have chosen strangling.” Yet the fact that nephesh can sometimes mean “throat” and even “breath” suggests in the former case a wordplay with pî, “my mouth,” and in the latter case an ironic second meaning that “my throat has chosen strangling.” Thus by alluding to both physical and non-physical senses of nephesh, the poet is exploiting the richness of the language at his command to embody the conjunction of physical and psychological distress. This interpretation of Job 7:11-16 is set, in this paper, in the context of the ambiguous use of nephesh in the book of Job as a whole, in which Job’s attachment to his nephesh, that is, his “life,” is at stake (Job 2:4, 6). Brief suggestions will also be offered on how terms such as polyvalence, ambiguity, and indeterminacy can most accurately be used in the exegesis of the book of Job.
|
Methodological Approaches to the Synoptic Slave Parables
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
J. Albert Harrill, Ohio State University
Plots of the so-called Servant Parables follow a curious dramatic routine. That routine involves the master’s temporary absence and the subsequent slave drama of household chaos that ensues. My paper argues that this routine follows a stock theme familiar from Roman situation comedy known as absente ero (when the master’s away). Elements include monologues and actions of an elite slave reveling in gluttony, drunkenness, and the intoxicating authority of being left home alone with absolute power over the rest of the domestic staff. My goal is to explain why delayed eschatology essentially defines the very plot of the comedy––why the householder is described as already too late in coming back. While the presence of such comedy in the slave parables has been noted before, its importance for the study of the historical Jesus remains underexplored. Because the eschatological delay is essential to the comedic plot, it is difficult to argue that this particular set of parabolic material goes back to the teachings of the historical Jesus. My paper selects two parable types for detailed examination. First, I analyze the Overseer (Matt. 24:45-51; Luke 12:42-46), and second the Unmerciful Slave (Matt 18:23-28). Although previous scholarship has argued that these two parable-types work “against” each other to subvert reader expectations, I will show this hypothesis to be erroneous; the parables express the same comic routine. My third section then evaluates the best methodological approach to analyze this comic routine, known as absente ero, for research into the synoptic gospels and the historical Jesus.
|
“I Forgive You, Because God Has”: Assumptions about Forgiveness in Matthean and Lukan Parables
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
John Harrison, Oklahoma Christian University
No Gospel presents Jesus as providing a systematic, philosophical discourse on the topic of forgiveness. That God can and does grant forgiveness and that humans are to forgive under certain conditions are both presupposed by the Gospels. More specifically in the Synoptics, in addition to three narratives that recall Jesus’ controversial announcements that he can forgive some people’s sins without them showing any acts of repentance for those sins (e.g. Mark 2:5 [and parallels]; Luke 7:48; Luke 23:34), Jesus is remembered as teaching his disciples to forgive those who sin against them (Matt. 18:21-22; Luke 17:3) and that they ought to forgive others so that their Father in heaven may forgive their sins (Mark 11:25; Matt. 6:12, 14-15; 18:35; Luke 6:37; 11:4).
This paper, with the aid of several new social-scientific approachs to parables, will argue that Matthew’s parable of the unforgiving servant (Matt. 18:23-35), Luke’s parable of the two debtors (Luke 7:41-43) and the three parables collected in Luke 15:4-32 (the lost sheep, the lost coin, and the lost son) presuppose the divine-human connection assumed when people were described as forgiving others. Evidence from Second Temple Jewish literature and non-Jewish authors indicate that certain general assumptions about the conditions for announcing or offering forgiveness existed. The Matthean and Lucan parables investigated in this paper are more properly exegeted when recognizing these assumptions rather than imposing upon them anachronistic claims that they are evidence that Jesus offered a new paradigm about forgiveness wherein a person should forgive others regardless of whether God has.
|
Rethinking the Johannine Pentecost: An Investigation into UC Von Wahlde’s Counter Claim
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Stan Harstine, Friends University
Jesus’ appearance to his disciples in John 20:19-23 is frequently identified as the Johannine Pentecost. This association of Jesus’ command to his disciples to receive the Holy Spirit with the Acts 2 event seemed warranted in decades past when the dominant, nearly exclusive belief held that John’s gospel was best understood using a lens informed by the Synoptic gospels, or in this specific case the Book of Acts. UC von Wahlde challenges this perspective in his 2010 commentary when he associates this element in John 20 with the Nicodemus discussion in John 3 as part of his proposed second edition of the gospel. His conclusion that the bestowal of the Spirit upon Jesus’ disciples is the fulfillment of repeated promises in the Fourth Gospel and the “crowning moment of ‘salvation’” for the disciples is relatively rare. His claim that this event represents the “moment of ‘birth from the Spirit’” spoken about in John 3 deserves further investigation.
This paper utilizes literary criticism as an alternative methodology in order to determine whether any corroboration exists for von Wahlde’s claim. After investigating clues presented in the Fourth Gospel's narrative and categorizing them according to von Wahlde’s three editions, sufficient evidence should exist to substantiate or refute von Wahlde’s conclusion. Evidence derived from historical or source critical approaches will be introduced as it enlightens the passage under consideration. Two older works, Marinus de Jonge’s “The Son of God and the Children of God in the Fourth Gospel” in Saved by Hope, 1978, and Matthew Vellanickal's The Divine Sonship of Christians in the Johannine Writings, 1977, serve as counter sources for other studies on Johannine themes related to birth and sonship in the Fourth Gospel.
|
An Altruistic Alter Christus: Polycarp, Paul, and Imitating the Essential Norm of Christ’s Self-Donation
Program Unit: Biblical Interpretation in Early Christianity
Paul A. Hartog, Faith Baptist Theological Seminary
In a 2015 article, Shawn J. Wilhite compared and evaluated the views of Michael Holmes, Paul Hartog, and Candida Moss concerning the interrelationship between “imitation” and intertextuality within the Martyrdom of Polycarp. Wilhite sought to analyze and synthesize these scholarly perspectives from the last decade, by investigating the three themes of “in accordance with the Gospel,” twofold imitation, and the narratological Gospel mirroring, as found within the Martyrdom of Polycarp. He argued that the notion of “a martyrdom according to the Gospel” encompasses both narratological elements and ethical facets. The purpose of this paper is not only to distinguish but to hierarchize the thematic importance of emulating the normative essence of Christ’s self-donation and the secondary accoutrements of replicating the narrative details of Christ’s passion. In the Martyrdom, the latter are subservient to the former, and the Gospel tradition echoes are fundamentally framed by a Pauline quotation and an associated Pauline theology of imitatio Christi. This hierarchization relieves tensions in Wilhite’s paralleling of the twofold imitation model with particulars of the narratological mirroring. The narrative particulars may fortuitously highlight an imitatio Christi, but emulating the norm of Christ’s self-donation essentially constitutes a gospel-martyrdom. Beyond the examination of “imitation” culled by Wilhite, we will also analyze the parallel concepts of participation, discipleship, being taught by the gospel, and walking by “the word of Jesus Christ.” In addition, we will convey new insights into the interconnection of “a martyrdom according to the gospel,” the “cup of Christ,” saving the elect, and defeating the Evil One. In the final analysis, a “martyrdom according to the Gospel” emulates the character of Christ, the impetus of his offering, the purpose of his death, the manner of his suffering, and the result of his triumph—as particularly focused through the imitative prism of altruistic self-donation.
|
Community and Identity as a “Third Race” in Ad Diognetum and the Martyrdom of Polycarp
Program Unit: Apostolic Fathers and Related Early Christian Literature
Paul A. Hartog, Faith Baptist Theological Seminary
Several early Christian texts describe Christians as a “new race” or “third race.” As N.T. Wright declares, this concept of a “third race” has been “both canvassed and attacked,” bringing notions of identity “into sharp focus.” According to Wright, the concept of being a “third race” marked off early Christians as both rooted and redefined, through both continuity and discontinuity. This paper will apply relevant “social identity” theory to the Martyrdom of Polycarp and the Epistle to Diognetus. Our comparison will further develop—yet essentially diverge from—Charles Hill’s investigation of similarities in vocabulary and ethos between the Martyrdom and Diognetus (including the role of imitation, the “sojourning” nature of Christians, and the exemplary endurance of the executioner’s fire). In Diognetus, Christians were to be shaped by their “new message,” forming a third race “distinguished from the rest of humanity” by distinctive communal-moral characteristics. The Martyrdom is saturated with first-person plural language, uses Polycarp as a community exemplar, and emphasizes the elect and righteous status of the Christian “race.” The commemoration of Polycarp’s martyrdom as imitatio Christi, patterned after the Gospel, was intended to motivate secondary imitation among the “whole race of the righteous.” This “God-fearing race of the Christians” was to exemplify the “great difference between the unbelievers and the elect.” In constructing this Christian identity, however, the Martyrdom unrealistically merges the Smyrnaean Jews and pagans into an amalgamated “other.” Nevertheless, focusing upon a communal-ethical rather than an individual-biographical purpose for the Martyrdom of Polycarp allows us to rise above continuing debates concerning the work’s authorship, dating, and integrity (cf. Holmes, Hartog, Kozlowski, and Moss), even while disagreeing with Hill’s assessment of the authorship of Diognetus. Both texts, although differing in literary genre and style, do aim at a similar purpose: the protreptic formation of communal character.
|
Travel and Identity in Philostratus and the Acts of the Apostles
Program Unit: Graeco-Roman Society and the New Testament (EABS)
Pieter B. Hartog, Protestant Theological University
One of the key characteristics of the Roman world, emphasised in recent scholarship, is its interconnectedness. The roads and waterways that crossed the Roman Empire were catalysts for travel and intercultural interaction. As a result, inhabitants of the empire often constructed their cultural and religious identities in an ongoing dialogue with other cultures and traditions.
Travel narratives provide an excellent source to study these complex processes of identity-formation. In this paper I will explore how the authors of Philostratus’ Life of Apollonius of Tyana and the Acts of the Apostles construct multi-levelled identities for their protagonists and how these identities interact with the local traditions these protagonists encounter on their writings.
Combing the work of spatial theorists with concepts drawn from modern theories of globalisation, I intend to show that the identities of the protagonists in these works assume the shape of “global mélanges,” which incorporate and interact with a range of local traditions.
By so doing, I aim to challenge the Rome-centredness of much previous scholarship on these writings. Whereas these earlier studies have argued that Rome is of central importance for how the Life of Apollonius of Tyana and the Acts of the Apostles portray the identities of their protagonists, I will argue that Rome does not take centre stage in these processes of identity-formation, but serves as one out of many local traditions that contribute to the cultural/religious identities of the protagonists in these writings.
|
Making Meaning, Making Metaphor: The Rhetorical Function of the Phrases ‘His Hand’ and ‘His Right Hand’ in Psalm 139:5, 7 as a Subset of Embodiment Metaphor
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible (EABS)
Elizabeth R Hayes, Fuller Theological Seminary (Pasadena)
Literary features, including metaphor, often take human embodiment as a starting point. Literary features that make use of the body and characteristics of embodiment, including emotions, appearance, and physical capability, are widespread both in the Hebrew Bible and the New Testament. As such, this is likely one of the most prevalent networks to appear across the texts. Additionally, the use of human embodiment to express abstract concepts often includes co-occurring metonymy. This paper will use a cognitive approach to examine the issue.
Psalm 139 contains several examples of co-occurring metaphor and metonymy, specifically when the speaker addresses God directly, using phrases such as ‘your hand’ and ‘your right hand’ (Psalm 139:5, 7) and ‘your eyes’ (Psalm 139:139:16). Elsewhere in the Hebrew Bible these phrases are often paired with statements regarding God’s victory on behalf of his people or his role in their deliverance. However, in Psalm 139 the same phrases are used to create a sense of intimacy between the Psalmist and God. This paper will examine the role of the phrases ‘your hand’ and ‘your right hand’ using insights from cognitive linguistics to analyse and describe their rhetorical function within the psalm as a whole. It is suggested that the phrases are a prominent part of a larger schema that plays upon the language of embodiment, resulting in a poem that is both intimate and powerful.
|
Avoiding Embarrassing Meanings: Ambiguous Qur’anic Verses, Corrected Scribal Errors and Biblical/Apocryphal Intertexts
Program Unit: Quran and Islamic Tradition in Comparative Perspective
Ghilène Hazem, Paris-Nanterre
In its polemics against aspects of Jewish and Christian anthropomorphism (God’s omnipotence and moral perfection, divine filiation), the Qur'an strives to construct a negative theology of its own. Yet, some verses, when taken at face value, seem to contradict the new Islamic message.
Thus, when approached linguistically - and not theologically or through modern translations -, some segments in verses like Q 43:84 read “And it is He who in heaven is a god and in earth is a god”. We also learn in Q 33:57, that God curses “those who hurt God and his Prophet”, while another potentially embarrassing passage in Q 66:12 –“and We blew into it/him”–, might suggest that God breathed directly into Mary’s private parts. Such semantic possibilities were evidently discarded.
In examining this category of delicate verses, I will show that: 1) they are rare or unique in their formulation; 2) given their distinctiveness both in form and meaning, some early manuscripts exhibit corrected scribal errors associated with some of these unusual verses; 3) to avoid embarrassment in Q 66:12, the explanation provided by Muqātil ibn Sulaymān in his Tafsir contains an unnoticed Biblical element that can be traced back to the Protoevangelium of James.
I will also briefly consider the opposite phenomenon where semantic avoidance prevents the formation of specific themes (accusatory laments, God’s repentance) and motifs. As a case study, I will argue that the Prophet’s saying mentioning “the dog returning to his vomit” is reminiscent of Prov 26:11 and 2 Pet 2:22. It is to be found within the hadith genre only, for reasons analogous to those that motivated the pious rewriting of Jesus’ threat of vomiting the lukewarm in Codex Sinaiticus: to avoid inappropriate expressions of the divine.
|
Aspects of Coherence in Texts with a Literary History
Program Unit: Developing Exegetical Methods (EABS)
Raik Heckl, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
It is often mistakenly assumed that texts resulting from an editorial process, Fortschreibung or reformulation are incoherent. Since texts of this nature are formed by the intentions of their authors, they have a coherent structure. The paper explores the specific characteristics of the coherence that allows to reconstruct the literary history.
|
The Magnitude and Implications of the Rabbinic Interpretive Methods
Program Unit: Judaica
Paul Heger, University of Toronto
Much has been published about the rabbinic midrashic interpretive system, but I believe that we may still discover new aspects concerning the sophisticated philosophy behind the system. The rabbis converted the concrete principle behind many significant Torah rules into an abstract legal rationale. For example, they replaced the concrete injunctions of the Torah "to rest from work" on the Sabbath with various legal abstractions, such as whether one has created something on Sabbath or not. Digging a pit is forbidden because one has created a structure, but doing it in order to use the excavated earth for covering something is not deemed so. Similarly is the prohibition to “transfer from one domain to another” and the legal method of its circumvention. A host of consequential rabbinic halakhot of biological and genealogical aspects are founded on abstract considerations not on their concrete attributes. Complex legal fictions are the basis of ordinances, vital for the economic enterprises.
This sublimation offered them an effective system to interpret the Torah decrees both in more severe and more lenient manners, maintaining at the same time their theoretical formal adherence to the sacred immutable texts. In contrast to the modern attitude that permits to read into classic texts the reader’s response, without considering the author’s intent, the rabbis contended that their interpretation corresponds to the divine intent, even if the text did not mention it, or even bluntly contradicted it. Concurrently, the system stimulated the profound and constant study of the Torah to reveal its hidden intellectual and spiritual treasures.
|
A New Canon Begets New Birth: Beginning a Canon with Birth Narratives
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
Timothy P. Hein, University of Edinburgh
This paper explores the exegetical value of beginning the NT canon with a birth narrative (Matt 1-2; Lk 1-2). Why does Jesus have to be born to begin a canon of holy writ, twice? Matthew and Luke receive nearly immediate authoritative status, building an entire bios of Jesus life and teaching— Luke even includes John the Baptist’s birth. By contrast, the freestanding Protevangelium Jacobi (PJ) seems to receive a significant level of influence, though only reflecting on the origins of Jesus and clearly borrowing from Matthew and Luke. Another point of contrast, Tatian’s Diatessaron becomes the Gospel in the Syriac world (Crawford), wherein the Matthean and Lukan birth narratives are situated within John 1:1-18. This paper begins by (1) exploring the theological contributions of Matthew’s birth narrative, then Luke’s, to their respective gospels, then (2) as a point of contrast, juxtaposing these to PJ to explore theological distinctives that emerge from a freestanding birth narrative divorced from a complete bios. Finally, (3) in light of the above, reexamines the value of birth narratives to gospels as part of a settled canon. Historically, then, the first part of this paper will situate itself in the pre-canonical issues of the first three centuries (sections 1 & 2), then conclude with reflection on canon formation in the third and fourth centuries. Methodologically, this paper takes a reception history approach to explore this development of a canon that begins with birth narratives.
|
From A–Z: The Relegation of the A-List of Biblical History in the Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Charlotte Hempel, University of Birmingham
There is wide agreement that what we may call the A-List of biblical history as recounted in Samuel-Kings and then reframed or brought up to date in Chronicles and Ezra-Nehemiah is poorly represented in the Dead Sea Scrolls from Qumran. In fact, the role of David as the great king is arguably overshadowed by the powerful depiction of David as a luminous wise scribe and lyric composer in the Qumran Psalms Scroll (11QPsa). This paper will begin with a brief review of the evidence and previous explanations that have been offered for it. Most commonly the picture is explained by presupposing that the Qumran movement considered its own history as taking the place of the histories of Israel and Judah as well as Yehud as recounted in the Hebrew Bible. While there is certainly some truth in this, alternative explanations will be explored including some radical challenges to entrenched frameworks. In particular, the paper will walk us through a scenario suggesting that despite its formative place in the Bible that has reached us, the Deuteronomistic History and works such as Ezra-Nehemiah may not have been read and copied as widely as customarily assumed. This is not to say major events were not known. Many key players are certainly mentioned but we need not presuppose that the all too familiar comprehensive script of the larger narratives were inevitably read and copied widely. At the very least the Qumran evidence invites further critical reflection which I hope to stimulate with this paper.
|
Abram's Journeys as Nexus: Toward a Literary Philology
Program Unit: Methodological Pluralism in the Study of Genesis
Ronald Hendel, University of California-Berkeley
The complementarity of source and literary criticism can be illustrated by Abram's journeys in Gen 12-13, which have distinctive resonances and intertextual links in the J and P sources. Attention to these literary features clarifies the continuity of the documentary sources and allows for a richer understanding of their concepts of Abram within the larger discursive context from the primeval era to the life of Moses.
|
Jerusalem and Jerusalem Only? The Different Concepts of Cult Centralization in Kings, Chronicles and Ezra-Nehemiah
Program Unit: Centralization and Cult in Persian Period Israel: Biblical, Historical and Comparative Perspectives (EABS)
Benedikt Hensel, Universität Zürich
Where Deut 12 and related texts represent with the unnamed maqom a more open concept of cult centralization (which is why the Samaritans could read Deuteronomy and the Pentateuch as their basic authoritative document), and the Book of Kings represents an especially Judean but not necessarily Judah-exclusive perspective on cult centralization, Chronicles and Ezra-Nehemiah developed in last-Persian or Hellenistic times a distinctive Jerusalem-centered picture of the "Israelite cult". Jerusalem is understood as the exclusive representation of the one maqom mentioned in Deut 12. This means at the same time that the argumentative depictions of the cultic centre in Chronicles and Ezra-Nehemiah are directed against other possible Jahwistic sanctuaries, of which Mt. Gerizim the most well known and important one.
Chronicles and Ezra-Nehemiah differ however in the way they use the relevant texts and in itself ambivalent concepts of cult centralization from Deuteronomy, the Pentateuch (especially the priestly writings) and the Former Prophets. The different ways of accessing cult centralization will be addressed in this paper, with an emphasis on Chronicles` and Ezra-Nehemiah`s argumentation.
|
Women and the Truth that is Islam
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Keren Abbou Hershkovits, Center for the Study of Conversion and Interfaith, Ben-Gurion University
When considering women in early Islam the main images coming to mind are those of the extremes. It is either a strong woman such as Khadija, or the submissive, helpless and anonymous women in general. As in the way extremes, the truth lays somewhere in between. However, lack of sources and many other difficulties, prevent us from learning about early Islamic period and the status of women at that time, moreover, it is not clear that we have formulated the right questions.
In this paper I wish to look into women who acted as agents of conversion, using theological concepts and excerpts of the Quran as their justification for conversion (their own, or others). I will show that women who converted to Islam did so for many different reasons, or better say, were attributed various reasons. Understanding and conceptualizing the validity of Muhammad’s prophecy was among them. These women later on made a point of spreading that understanding to members of their family and even to strangers. I will also look into the reasons that encouraged authors to put such words in the mouths of women (rather than men). I will ask whether these women were presented as unique females, or maybe authors were making a different point. Such an inquiry might help us learn about women in early Islam, and maybe also about the still ambiguous process of conversion in the early period.
|
Dreams as Visionary Experience in the Joseph Story
Program Unit: Vision and Envisionment in the Bible and its World (EABS)
Eva Hiby, Bergische Universität Wuppertal
Dreams are a special form of visions in which the envisioned aspects are conveyed in longer narrational sequences. Within the sequences God delivers hints to the receiver’s behavior in the specific situation. This paper deals with the unique form of the the dreams which belong to the novel of Joseph and their narratological function. Two observations are striking concerning the function of the dream accounts within the novel of Joseph: 1. In Gen 37-50, Joseph is characterized on the one hand as a dreamer but on the other hand as a oneirocritic (dream reader) which means that he represents both functions in one person. In former investigations, the differentiation was used as argument for source criticism. But within the story the two characterizations geared to each other. Starting from narratological observations, this paper will line out the function of the dreams in comparison to other dream accounts of the Hebrew Bible and from other ANE sources to show the unique inner logic of the dream accounts within the novel. 2. The dreams of the novel of Joseph need to be interpreted. Therefore an oneirocretic is necessary. Within the Hebrew Bible this concept is rather unusual and one needs to ask the question if the reference to oneirocretic traditions in Egypt is used to evoke the local color of the novel or if it is a hint to the origins of the story in a Jewish community in Egypt as assumed in the latest diachronic analysis of the novel.
|
“They Saw No Man, Save Jesus Only”: Approaches to Scripture in Christian Arabic Psalm Commentaries
Program Unit: The Bible in Arabic in Judaism, Christianity, Islam (EABS)
Miriam L. Hjälm, Sankt Ignatios Theological Academy, Stockholm School of Theology
Scripture may be read in many ways. Scholars of Biblical Criticism read it as a historical document –as just another piece of literature– and deliberately remove what is sacred in “Sacred Scripture.” The early Church, on the other hand, strove to find exactly that: the sacred element in Scripture which turned this piece of Jewish literature into a Christian document. The basic Patristic approach is nourished by “the Road to Emmaus,” where Jesus appeared and “beginning with Moses and all the Prophets, he explained to them what was said in all the Scriptures concerning himself (Luke 24: 27 [13-35], cf 1 Cor. 15:3–4).” Thus, most of the early Christian interpreters approached biblical texts to search for prefigurations of the Christ.
Approaches to Scripture are based on social settings, intellectual environment, basic tenets, access to the biblical corpus, etc. If these contextual variables change, the approach to biblical texts might be affected. In this paper I aim to discuss selected portions (MT Ps 2, 22, 28, 110, 137) of the 11th-century deacon ʿAbd Allāh b. al-Faḍl al-Anṭākī’s translation-commentary of Psalms as well as that of the anonymous translator of Vat. Ar. 5, with an eye to Judaeo-Arabic and earlier Christian commentaries. The purpose is to establish tendencies in the Arabic recension of the Patristic heritage and by doing so, also build on the recent trend to re-examine various views of the Bible. In addition, we hope to add to the discussion of intellectual encounters between Jews and Christians in the Islamicate world.
|
The Palestine History and Heritage Project: A Presentation
Program Unit: Anthropology and the Bible (EABS)
Ingrid Hjelm, University of Copenhagen
The Palestine History and Heritage Project aims at producing balanced and critical historical texts and materials related to Palestine and each of its regions from prehistoric times to the present. Our historical perspective is inclusive of the variety of cultural, religious and ethnic traditions reflected in Palestine’s complex history; not least that this history might speak to a common heritage for all who live in Palestine. To do this successfully, we need to write a region-oriented “people’s history”, describing each region in its distinctive anthropological, social and cultural forms; we need to describe these smaller and larger regions’ everyday culture based on theories of “lieux de memoire” (memory and heritage sites), rather than letting history of empires and world religions take center stage. Pfoh and Thompson have in their introduction to the project outlined 14 such regions, e.g. Acco, Lachish, Shechem, Jerusalem, Pella, etc.
|
Jesus and the Virtues: The Biographical Presentation of Moral Qualities in the Gospel of Matthew
Program Unit: Virtue in Biblical Literature (EABS)
Daniel Hjort, Lund University
The analysis of the virtues of Jesus in the Gospels has not gained a lot of interest in New Testament studies. Some scholars hesitate to use the term “virtue” in reference to Jesus, emphasizing the difference between the NT and the Greek philosophical tradition. Other scholars suggest that the Gospels are not concerned with the character of Jesus, but with his identity as Messiah and Son of God. But the understanding of the Gospels as ancient biographies, which is almost a consensus among scholars, gives expectations of a presentation of the moral qualities of the protagonist. The present paper describes the focus on the moral qualities in characterization in the ancient biographies of authors like Xenophon, Plutarch, and Philo, and shows that this focus is also seen in the Gospel of Matthew. Though Matthew highlights the identity of Jesus, who he is, it also concerns his character, how he is. This biography of Jesus presents a protagonist with several virtues that conforms to the ideals in the Hellenistic philosophy, but also with moral qualities that differs from these standards and rather adheres to the ideals of the Old Testament thought world. The virtues of Jesus can thus not merely be understood from the Greek rhetorical traditions, as suggested by some scholars. Matthew’s biography gives a portrait of Jesus’ character that both affirms common Greek virtues and highlights some peculiarities. Some terms in the Greek moral philosophy are also used in Matthew, but with different connotations. While the identification of the virtues of Jesus in the Gospels is appropriate, and the Greek philosophy can be clarifying, scholarship needs to pay attention to the idiosyncratic moral ideals in early Christian literature.
|
Johannes Pedersen between the Wars
Program Unit: History of Biblical Scholarship in the Late Modern Period
Jesper Høgenhaven, Københavns Universitet
The present paper profiles the work of the Danish theologian and semitist Johannes Pedersen (1883-1977) in the context of his time. Pedersen published his highly influential work on ancient Israel in between the two World Wars (1920-1934). His book, Israel I-IV, and its reception mirrors its turbulent time. It is a product of the first post-war period, and in a way also a prelude to the Second World War. Israel I-IV, which was later translated into English, was hailed as an impressive achievement in the understanding and appreciation of the world-view of the Hebrew Bible texts. Biblical students and scholars found inspiration in Pedersen’s interpretation of the texts on their own terms. His presentation included a vivid and appealing combination of the exotic and the familiar in the biblical universe. Danish and Nordic Old Testament scholars in the period between WW1 and WW2 were deeply influenced by Pedersen’s work. The impact of Pedersen’s Israel should also be viewed against the general background of the culture and mood of the epoch. Cultural evolutionism and optimism on behalf of modern European culture were not highly regarded in the aftermath of the WW1. European culture was not necessarily the peak of evolution. Other more exotic cultures past and present were now perceived as relevant voices with a potentially important message for the day. Accordingly this paper maps the overwhelmingly positive reception of Pedersen in this perspective.
|
Abundance and Life Versus Abstinence and Death? Eating and Drinking in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Anthropology and the Bible (EABS)
Jesper Høgenhaven, Københavns Universitet
This paper is concerned with presentations of food consumption in the Old Testament, and the association of eating and drinking not only with life but also with death. The OT depicts mundane, immanent notions of divine blessing and happiness, so goes the modern reception. But is this necessarily and generally the case? Enjoying the fruits of the created world are regarded in many OT texts as direct expressions of Yahweh’s blessing. Eating and drinking are, accordingly, presented in a positive and unproblematic perspective. Scholars have contrasted this Old Testament view with the ascetic ideals of the Greek and Hellenistic cultures. However, since recent decades have seen a growing consensus that a significant portion of the OT literature may have been written in the Hellenistic period, there may be good reasons to reconsider the usefulness of emphasizing the contrast between Israelite/Jewish and Greek/Hellenistic ideas of food consumption and abstinence. When read in the light of common Mediterranean ideals of controlling the human body, several OT texts seem to convey nuanced views on the consumption of food and drink, and on the importance of moderation and abstinence in certain circumstances. This paper explores some of the relevant OT texts, and attempts to understand their implications in the light of OT notions of food consumption and human mortality. Eating and drinking are used as powerful metaphors in the OT, especially in prophetic texts. The use of eating and drinking as metaphors connoting life has been amply explored. Less attention has been given to the metaphorical association of eating and drinking with death.
|
With Apologies to Hazael: The Monumentality and Counter-monumentality of the Tel Dan Inscription
Program Unit: Ancient Near East
Timothy Hogue, University of California-Los Angeles
The Tel Dan inscription has come to be read as an apology of Hazael legitimating the extension of his domain into Dan. This is true of only the initial stage in the inscription’s ‘biography,’ however. The Tel Dan inscription also came to materialize the opposite of the surface meaning of its text at a later stage in its history. This reading can be borne out by a broader analysis of the text’s monumentality – the combined qualities of the inscription by which it afforded meaning to the community interacting with it. While the semantic content and rhetorical structure of the inscription are the most obvious meaning-making components to modern scholars, this was not necessarily the case for an ancient audience. Rather, the spatial integration of the inscribed object and its ritual manipulation would be more apparent sources of meaning in an ancient context. Because monumental inscriptions were socially embedded in these ways, their meanings were subject to change and must be studied in historical sequence. This paper proposes a two-stage history of the Tel Dan inscription’s monumentality. The text was initially produced and integrated at Dan to legitimate Hazael’s control there. When Israel recaptured Dan, however, the inscription was intentionally destroyed in an act of ritual deactivation. Furthermore, some of the pieces appear to have been reintegrated and displayed as a counter-monument at significant ritual zones at the site. This reversed the intended meaning of the text, instead materializing the defeat of Hazael’s kingdom and the resurgence of Israel.
|
The Divine in the Plaza: the Salutaris Procession at the Domitiansplatz of Ephesos
Program Unit: Place, Space, and Identity in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Sung Soo Hong, University of Texas at Austin
In accordance with the bequest of C. Vibius Salutaris in 104 CE, a procession was regularly held in Ephesos. The Artemision outside the city and the theatre inside marked pivotal points, for each of them displayed the Salutaris inscription on their walls, and the procession moved on a circular route between the two. Thirty-one statuettes and images representing Artemis, the Roman Empire, and the city of Ephesos were carried during the procession. This paper argues that the procession portrayed in the urban space the “ideal” relationships among Artemis, the Roman Empire, and the city of Ephesos; and suggests that such a “right” order of life was enacted through the experience of the participants of the procession—both the performers and the spectators—in the public space. This paper focuses on the moments when the procession passed through the Domitiansplatz, for, on the one hand, this plaza was the only wide open space on the route within the city, where the entire social strata of the people in the city were given access to the divine, whereas usually the access to the divine was controlled by rituals in temples; on the other hand, as F. K. Yegül puts it, the plaza was an “urban canyon” surrounded by high platforms and monumental buildings. These characteristics of the plaza call for investigation in connection to the procession. In order to elucidate the performance of the divine images and people’s experience of them in the plaza during the procession, this paper uses two theoretical sources, namely, Jaś Elsner’s work on visuality and Victor Turner’s two concepts, “liminal” and “liminoid.”
|
What Do You Mean the Letter of James is Paraenetic?
Program Unit: Catholic Epistles
Sun Soo Hong, University of Texas at Austin
Martin Dibelius’s view of the Letter of James as paraenesis has been rejected rightly yet only partially. While scholars now agree that the Letter has some structure and coherence, the label “paraenesis/paraenetic” continues being attached to the Letter (Holloway; Allison). This paper shows how unhelpful and unfitting the concept of paraenesis is for the study of the Letter. I suggest that it is time at least to carefully spell out what it means to say, if one chooses to say, the Letter is paraenetic.
The first part of this paper reviews critically the concept of paraenesis. I argue that, as the Lund account of paraenesis (2000) partially admits, paraenesis is an invention by biblical scholars that has been unduly reified. Problems abound. First, because the concept has evolved over decades it is unclear what the term means precisely when scholars use it. Second, despite the Oslo account (2001), there is no consensus in defining it. Third, there is some circular reasoning in scholars’ discussions of “paraenetic” writings. Fourth, some defining characteristics of paraenesis do not fit the so-called paraenetic writings or sections.
The second part discusses the Letter of James in relation to paraenesis, especially the view that paraenesis merely reminds the audience of what they already know. Some of James’s teaching, however, is unconventional and even striking. Three examples here: first, the sitting arrangement at the synagōgē (2:1-6); second, James 4:4 (parallel to the saying is not found anywhere); third, the idea that the elders can induce both healing and forgiveness of sins through their prayer for the sick (5:14-15; no parallel anywhere). Central to the rhetoric of James is the purpose to persuade the audience of the author’s unconventional assertions. At the end I will propose categories more promising than paraenesis for the study of the Letter.
|
J.B. Lightfoot as Interpreter of 1 Peter
Program Unit: Catholic Epistles
David G. Horrell, University of Exeter
The recent publication of previously unknown notes from Joseph Barber Lightfoot includes some 40 pages on 1 Peter, divided roughly equally between introductory materials and exegetical notes on chapters 1-3 of the letter. Despite being fragmentary and incomplete, these notes give us valuable insight into Lightfoot’s interests and judgments on the letter. It is particularly interesting to compare them with those of his contemporary and collaborator, Fenton John Anthony Hort, whose incomplete commentary remains among the standard points of reference for scholars of 1 Peter. It is also interesting to see how the judgments of Lightfoot and Hort appear in the light of more recent work, and to consider how much has changed, and why. The work of Lightfoot may be clearly seen to be a product of its time, and, as such, a significant window into the modern history of the letter’s interpretation.
|
The Reception and Contextualization of Qoheleth’s Wisdom in China
Program Unit: Contextual Interpretation of the Bible (Hebrew Bible/Old Testament and New Testament)
Wei Huang, Shanghai University
There is no doubt that “wisdom” has to do with human understanding, which is a particular form of human knowledge and behavior. Starting from the twentieth century, western scholars began to investigate the wisdom materials in the cultures which were neighbor to Israel. And it has been well discussed that the ancient Near Eastern wisdom was partly entered into Israelite wisdom. This paper will first outline the intellectual context of Qoheleth. The book is not a secondary edited collection, which presents an inner unity and stands firmly in wisdom tradition. The paper will then examine the Chinese translations of Qoheleth. Through the translations, attention will be given to the ways, in which the concept of wisdom in Qoheleth was accepted in China. It will be argued that Qoheleth’s “wisdom” in China has a twofold meaning referring to both knowledge and virtue.
|
"You Cannot Live with an Experience That Remains without a Story" (Max Frisch): How Mark's Gospel Narrates Experiences with Jesus (and What Follows from Them)
Program Unit: Orality and Literacy in Early Christianity (EABS)
Sandra Huebenthal, Universität Passau
The life-changing encounter with Jesus and what follows from it lies at the heart of every New Testament text. It connects such different characters as Paul, Peter and James with other and unknown of their contemporaries. They all have made an experience and it has changed their lives. The texts produced by the first generations of Jesus followers deal quite differently with this experience: While Paul in his letter can stick to the formula that Jesus is the Lord, has risen from the dead and appeared to him, narrative texts do not only have to unfold what these words mean but they also have to connect many different of these experience-loaded stories into a coherent whole. Building on social memory theory, this paper shows in how far Mark’s Gospel can be read as a text reflecting both the experience people have made in the present of their individual and social life with Jesus' Gospel and the traditions in which they try to make sense of what happened and how it changed them as individuals and as a group. It will become apparent that Mark’s Gospel does not merely collect and present memory accounts, but also narrates how those people behind the text understand Jesus – and themselves.
|
The Spirit of Barnabas: Pneumatology and the Construction of an Early Christian Identity
Program Unit: Apostolic Fathers and Related Early Christian Literature
Kyle R. Hughes, Whitefield Academy
This paper seeks to demonstrate the centrality of pneumatology to the construction of Christian identity in the Epistle of Barnabas, considering how the author of Barnabas utilizes the past, present, and future work of the Spirit to delineate a distinct identity in contrast to the epistle’s constructed Jewish identity. First, this paper analyzes three examples in which the epistle claims the great heroes of the Jewish faith for Christianity on account of their looking forward to Christ by means of the Spirit. Second, this paper examines the epistle’s understanding of the Spirit’s role in the present dispensation, focusing on how the Spirit not only foresaw those who would become followers of Christ but also continues to call them to obedience in light of the fact that the Spirit has been poured out upon them. This latter point, third, has implications for solving the puzzle of the epistle’s eschatology through careful attention to its pneumatology. At each step, this argument is concerned to show how a proper understanding of the work of the Spirit, past, present, and future, provides a unified and heretofore neglected means by which the epistle fashions a unique Christian identity.
|
Irenaeus and the 'Gnostic' Roots of 'Orthodox' Pneumatology
Program Unit: Early Christianity (EABS)
Kyle R. Hughes, Whitefield Academy
This paper considers the role of the Holy Spirit within Irenaeus of Lyons’ articulation of the divine economy through the lens of Irenaeus’ engagement with Gnosticism. While scholars are increasingly recognizing the importance of Irenaeus’ pneumatology, recent scholarship has tended to emphasize the impact of Judaism on Irenaeus’ view of the Spirit to the exclusion of other sources of influence such as Gnosticism. After a brief overview of Irenaeus’ conception of the Spirit’s role within the divine economy, this paper examines how Irenaeus’ presentation of the Spirit echoes and contests that of the Valentinians with respect to the Spirit’s origin and its function in revealing the Father. Irenaeus thus utilizes and adapts some of the Gnostics’ own pneumatological ideas even as he buttresses his own claims to religious authority against the Gnostics. This argument thus yields a more nuanced perspective on the development of Irenaeus’ pneumatology, highlighting the effects of even ‘heretical’ forms of Christianity on the development of ‘orthodox’ Christian belief.
|
The Unlikely Reveal in Mark 5:1-20 (Old Testament Parallels in Mark’s Account of the Demoniac)
Program Unit: Allusions in the Gospels and Acts
Daniel Huh, Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary
The story of the Gerasene demoniac (5:1–20) is indeed an interesting one in the Gospel of Mark. One of the more subtle yet significant themes that can be seen in this passage is that of the secrecy of Jesus’ identity. Although reasons for the Messianic Secrecy vary among scholars, it is clear from the eight specific counts of Jesus’ own words in Mark that secrecy is indeed an important motif. In the story of the Gerasene demoniac, however, the importance of secrecy is seemingly reversed, as Jesus specifically instructs the healed man to go and tell people of his demonic deliverance. Why does Jesus not follow suit as he does in the other eight instances of healing and deliverance? What is different in the characters or setting that could influence this difference? What is Mark trying to convey through this apparent break in the theme of secrecy? This paper will focus on the latter half of the pericope to address these questions, eventually addressing the theme of Mark’s Christology in this passage.
An argument will be made through an OT intertextual narrative analysis and comparison of the characters in this pericope, making connections between the exorcism/drowning in Mark 5 to the salvation/drowning account in Exodus 14. This will be done all the while delving into the historical background and literary context, examining the Greek grammar, analyzing the lexical and semantics nuances of certain terms, comparing the text with its synoptic parallels, and recognizing the social-cultural influences. Through these procedures, this paper will assert that Mark shows Jesus intentionally pausing his normal pattern of secrecy in order to relay the self-revelatory nature of YHWH in Exodus, which in this passage ultimately serves to imply the inclusion of the Gentiles in his plan of salvation.
|
The Siloam Inscription: New Insights
Program Unit: Northwest Semitic Epigraphy Related to the Biblical World (EABS)
Regine Hunziker-Rodewald, Université de Strasbourg
Early plaster casts which were taken from the so-called Siloam inscription when it was still at its original place in the tunnel of the same name allow a more precise drawing of the characters and the text’s layout than ever before. The (semi-)cursive style of the characters in the Siloam inscription has already been identified by Gerrit van der Kooij in 1999, but his observations have not been evaluated to determine paleographically the Judean writing tradition and the sociocultural background of the text. The Siloam inscription attests a highly skilled professional hand, but unfortunately it contains no name nor date. Recent comparisons with script on artifacts from archaeological excavations leave a trail to a possible royal workshop.
|
Characteristics of the Lucianic Reviser in 2 Samuel
Program Unit: Septuagint of Historical Books (EABS)
Paavo Huotari, Helsingin Yliopisto - Helsingfors Universitet
The understanding of the Lucianic characteristics is essential when reconstructing the oldest attainable text of the Old Greek, particularly in the Historical Books of the Septuagint. In the kaige-section (10:6-24:25) the Hebraising corrections at their best have influenced the majority of the Greek manuscripts. The Lucianic manuscripts, once in a while, as only witnesses have preserved the Old Greek. The search of revisional and Lucianic readings is therefore preferable to begin in the non-kaige-section (1:1-10:5), which is the object of this paper.
This paper shows some reviser´s characteristics such as syntactical, morphological and other stylistic features. They are observable in several part of speeches, which are added, omitted, rewritten or transposed. A characteristic is not constantly an individual part of speech itself but a text context where it is used.
To recognize a Lucianic reading requires special criteria, internal and external. A Lucianic reading is often stylistically and logically a better reading for the reviser aimed at improving the text. However, the question is whether the reviser accomplished this aim. In addition, if the Lucianic reading is secondary in relation to the Old Greek, the reading is not always Lucianic. The secondary reading might be attested in the Vorlage text of the reviser. The number of manuscripts that agree with the Lucianic manuscripts, may offer a clue of that. However, any external criteria, which lays importance only on a number of manuscripts and an individual manuscript, is insufficient. All readings need an evaluation case by case and by their own merits. This may reveal what happened to the text.
|
Liberationist Hermeneutics: Ruth and a Female Marriage Migrant in Contemporary Times
Program Unit: Political Biblical Criticism
Joomee Hur, Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz
In the Asia context, it is reported that many women from the Global South are migrating to the Global North through marriage brokerage or matchmaking industries. This new social phenomenon often reveals tragedies such as patriarchal, sexist and racial discrimination against migrant women and it draws concerns from artists, academics and activists, including pastors, missionaries and theologians in faith communities. This paper attempts to read the book of the Ruth, a story of the Moabite Ruth and her Jewish mother-in-law Naomi in the land of Judah with the experience of the marginalized as a female marriage migrant in the contemporary times. This experience of marginality will be extracted from a short film titled A Perm (2009), directed by Lee Ran Hee and awarded the Seoul Christianity-Film Festival in 2010 with its episode of a newlywed Vietnamese bride and her Korean mother-in-law at the hair salon on the fringes of the city. This hermeneutical dialogue will show the conflicts in biblical interpretation between the message, which the ancient text carries, and the meaning, which the contemporary context draws and it seeks further the liberationist interpretation of the book of Ruth corresponding to a present reality.
|
The Biblical and the Quranic Image of Moses and Jesus
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Sayed-Hassan Akhlaq, Boston University
For Muslims, the Quran is the holy book of God, but this is not the only holy book. The Quran names many other sacred books, including the Bible. Belief in these scriptures and their prophets clearly is mentioned as a necessary part of Islamic faith. Though there are some different implications for the term “prophet” in the Old Testament, New Testament, and the Quran, they have much in common as well.
This paper aims to (1) emphasize the figures of Moses, Jesus and Muhammad in the Quran, though Muhammad is mentioned fewer times than the others; (2) examine how Moses and Jesus are highlighted in the Quran, respectively as rational and irrational aspects of the faith. The former is related to the Covenant and the latter to the Word; (3) use several Biblical references to show the commonality between these three texts; (4) discuss how Muhammad is an outstanding example of harmony between Moses and Jesus in the Quran in order to avoid an anti-rational understanding of faith. It thus concludes with how these various aspects come together to present a comprehensive and dynamic image of faith, which encourages everybody to enjoy their share of it. Methodologically, I focus on the Quranic and Biblical texts themselves. However, I use the idea introduced by Ibn Arabi (1165-1240) and Sayed Haydar Amoli (1319-1385) about Moses, Jesus, and Muhammad. The conclusion, which is the big gap among these three religious traditions, does not emerge from the sacred texts, but the hermeneutics applied on them, which in turn, are impacted by an interpreter’s limits. A greater outcome is that the meaning of book and tahrif (distortion/alteration) as well as the scope of mutual cooperation to enhance Abrahamic spirituality will be promoted.
|
The Inspirational Aspect of the iIea of “Tahrif” for Inter-religious Dialogue
Program Unit: Quran and Islamic Tradition in Comparative Perspective
Sayed-Hassan Akhlaq, Boston University
All the different theological and legal schools of Islam look at the Quran as the main source of their understanding and of justification for their standpoints. This centrality plays a major role in terms of both understanding Islam and iman by itself, or in relation to non-Muslims. Given that, regarding the people of the book, the significant issue of tahrif (distortion of the Holy Book) arises.
The negative concept of tahrif was always dominant in Islam, discouraging Muslims from having a constructive dialogue with their Christian and Jewish fellows. This paper aims to reverse the path: it uses the same Quranic concept of tahrif to promote dialogue among religions. In order to implement this goal, three steps are taken. First, it examines the meaning of “Book” in the Quran to distinguish between current understanding and the Quranic use of it. It helps us to comprehend another aspect of tahrif: it is not something merely literal, but can be conceptual. Then I develop the conceptual distortion of the Holy Book which could include the Quran as well. Finally, discussing how Muslims can learn from the People of the Book to reduce misinterpreting religion. Thus, the concept of tahrif appears as a source of inspiration to bring religions to one table to learn from each other and improve the spirituality of the faithful. Methodologically, I apply interpreting the Quran by the Quran. As testimony, I will use Ibn Taymiyyah, from Sunni and Ma’rifat from Shia as a connection for the first part. Some Sufis will provide the testimony for the second part. Finally, I’ll use Jewish and Christian theology to develop the last part and reverse the concept of tahrif in its right positive and constructive path.
|
Multiple Perspectives on Research Method, Practical Theology, and Pedagogy with Black Queer Christian Men Seeking Refuge in the UK
Program Unit: Europe Contested: Contemporary Bible Readings Performed by "Ordinary" Readers in a European Context (EABS)
Omari Hutchinson, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam
This article presents and shares my fieldwork findings and contributes to practical theological conversations about the nature and practice of knowing the ‘other’, from the perspective of collecting, coding, discerning, observing, analysing, interpreting, and in, particular, discovering new concepts from the narrative or data emerging out of the experience of the participants’ and the researcher. I discuss a contemporary enquiry driven by desire for plausible and genuine reflection, deep into the everyday lived human and religious phenomenon. I discuss the perspectives in the men’s narratives and what that means. This includes different positions on seeking asylum and the process of renegotiating identity, which includes sexual violence. I explain how the analysis of the stories is carried out in conversation with scriptural material and, the extent to which this strategy it is supported by the available evidence and, how what the participant’s say possesses other theological virtues. The central ideas in these different contributions hinge on the question of how human stories and the story of/about God interact. It is through the narrative expressions (what the participants say) that I have observed stories that suggest their constant interpretation and analysis, which explains their desires for social change and deeper relationship with God. In this research, I distinguished between different layers of meaning, for example, the analysis of the text and the themes within that have evolved and, I employed a framework for epistemic appraisal between the epistemic statues of different shows of courage, strength and tremendous reliance; in the hope of contributing to a serious appraisal of the epistemic statues of some of the themes that run through Scripture, especially those that speak about transformation, wrestling, lament, desire, pleasure, multiplicity and multiple overwhelmings. KEY WORDS “structure, perspective, tone, role assignment, audience justification” Scripture, policy making
|
Cultural Gap: Translating Strange Thoughts
Program Unit: Nida Institute for Biblical Scholarship at the American Bible Society
Niko Huttunen, Finnish Bible Society
*
|
The Intertextuality between the Table of Nations and the Story about the Tower of Babel
Program Unit: Methodological Pluralism in the Study of Genesis
Juerg Hutzli, Université de Lausanne
The Table of Nations (Priestly composition, Gen 10*) and the story about the tower of Babel (Gen 11:1-9), which follows immediately, share certain commonalities. Common points include first the theme of humanity’s dispersal and its ethnic ramifications and second the expression šēm, which in Gen 10 is used as personal (and geographical) name and in Gen 11:4 as appellative (“renown, reputation”). Yet, in the Table of Nations šēm, Shem’s name, may also have this latter meaning (“great name, reputation”); this makes good sense insofar as Shem is considered to be the ancestor of five nations (regions) of great importance in the Levant during the first half of the first millennium BCE (see Gen 10:22). However, the two accounts also contradict one the other. The cause of humanity’s spreading over the world and of the inner differentiation in nations, tribes, and languages is different. According to Gen 10, this development seems neutral or positive. In Gen 11:1–9, however, it results from humans’ hubris, namely, the attempt to reach the divine realm, to “make themselves a name,” and from God’s countermeasure, confusing their language and scattering them over the whole world.
The linguistic and thematic commonalities between the two units are striking and may favor the idea that one composition depends on the other and react to it. What is the literary-historical relationship between the two compositions? The question is only rarely put forward in scholarship, because the two accounts are predominantly interpreted in their own respective contexts, J and P, whereupon the former is considered to be presupposed by the latter. But treating the texts individually allows us to reexamine the question of their relationship.
|
The Identity of the Messenger of Yahweh in Judges 13
Program Unit: Intersections: A Forum for Research on Ancient Israel, Hebrew Bible, and Cognate Topics (EABS)
Sunwoo Hwang, Chongshin University
Literally, the messenger of Yahweh in Judges 13 is understood as a messenger sent by Yahweh. If one contends that the messenger of Yahweh in Judges 13 is Yahweh, one should provide a strong proof that can deny the literal understanding of the messenger of Yahweh. Having investigated the arguments for identifying the messenger of Yahweh in Judges 13 as Yahweh, I conclude that it is most plausible to identify the messenger of Yahweh as it literally means. Every argument for identifying the messenger of Yahweh as Yahweh discloses its weakness. Manoah’s judgment concerning the identification of the messenger of Yahweh as God in Judges 13:22 is not warranted because the judgment is not the omniscient author’s but a limited character’s. Syntactically, though some view “Mal’ak Yahweh” as an appositional construct, this contention is to be dismissed. Normally, when a messenger appears with a divine name in ancient Near Eastern literature the relationship is to be viewed not as appositional but as subordinate. Even though some appeal to the passages where the messenger of Yahweh is Yahweh himself, there are still other passages of the Old Testament in which the messenger of Yahweh is distinguished from Yahweh. Most of all, if we identify the messenger of Yahweh as Yahweh, it is difficult to explain Judges 13:16, where the messenger of Yahweh distinguishes himself from Yahweh.
|
The Identity of the Servant in the Fourth Servant Song in the Book of Isaiah
Program Unit: Prophets and Prophecy (EABS)
Sunwoo Hwang, Chongshin University
Among the many issues surrounding the fourth servant song of Isaiah 52:13-53:12, the identity of the suffering servant is still a fundamental question to answer. To identify the servant of the fourth servant song, this paper examines the main arguments for the identification under two main headings: the collective views (Israel; a pious minority within Israel) and the individualistic views (a historical figure; the prophet himself; the Messiah). Seemingly, each view has its own weakness. The view that the servant is ‘Israel’ cannot explain the equation of sufferer and beneficiary. The idea that the servant represents a “pious minority” of Israel is unlikely when we consider that both impious majorities and pious minorities shared the suffering of the exilic situation. Equating the servant with a historical personage is difficult, because it is hard to pinpoint a historical figure whose identification can survive scrutiny based on the details of the servant song. That the prophet himself is the servant is hardly likely. When both ‘we’ and ‘he’ (the suffering servant) are mentioned together in prophetic speech, the prophet belongs to the group, ‘we’. With regard to the messianic view, the most serious obstacle is the conflict of the suffering servant’s image with that of the royal Davidic Messiah. Among the five views, I will sort out the messianic view as the most plausible option arguing for the complementary relationship between the royal and suffering images of the Messiah.
|
Response: Landforms in Matthew 5-7 and Mt 13:1-9; An Interdisciplinary Exploration for an Ecological-Economic Reading
Program Unit: The Bible and Ecology (EABS)
Ma. Marilou Ibita, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
Matthew 5-7 deals with 'earth' (5:13, 18, 35; 6:10, 19) and several other landforms. Some are explicitly named such as 'mountain'/'hill' (5:1, 13), 'rock' (7:24-25), and 'sand' (7:26) while others are implicitly considered such as the field where lilies and grass grow and where other agricultural products including grapes and figs as well as trees are cultivated (6:26, 28; 7:15-20). In Mt 13:1-9, the parable mentions different kinds of 'soil' and varied situations of lack or presence of seed growth. This paper posits that an interdisciplinary inquiry is needed in an ecological-economic reading of these biblical texts that recognizes these landforms not only as passive elements of the narrative setting but as active characters in the Matthean narrative. This reading will include an interdisciplinary approach in exploring the world behind the text (Roman Galilee's geography and archaeology, Roman economy), the world of the text (narrative-critical analysis of the landforms in the text), and the world before the text (earth science, ecological challenges, land/soil degradation). The insights gathered will shed light on the issue of land degradation and sustainable agriculture then and now and how biblical readers committed to eco-justice can respond to these challenges particularly in view of the United Nations Sustainable Goals.
|
The Old Church Slavonic Translations of the Book of the Prophet Daniel: How Many are They and how They Functioned?
Program Unit: Slavonic Apocrypha (EABS)
Ivan I. Iliev, Sofiyski universitet
It is well known that the Old Testament book of Daniel has been translated several times into Old Church Slavonic, but so far, there has not been a thorough investigation of the subject. The full text of Daniel is part of the Slavonic Catena in Prophetas and appears also in the so-called Judean Chronograph, while some quotes are used in the Slavonic Prophetologion. The book also served as the main core of Hippolytus of Rome’s Interpretation In Danielem. Finally, some passages have been included in De Antichristo. Some hypotheses have been expressed about the function of the different translations. After an examination of all Slavonic witnesses, I will argue that a revision of Ivan Evseev’s conclusions is needed.
|
The Unknown "Truth" of Nathan’s Character
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Virginia Ingram, Charles Sturt University
In their influential paper, The King Through Ironic Eyes: Biblical Narrative and the Literary Reading Process, Perry and Sternberg suggest there are many ‘gaps’ in the literature of the books of Samuel. The ‘gaps’ in this sense are missing knowledge in the text. Notably, Perry and Sternberg argue that there are gaps in knowledge in 2 Samuel 11. For instance, did Uriah know that David slept with Bathsheba or not? The text does not tell us. The different possibilities concerning Uriah’s knowledge of David’s sins are interesting. However, they do not impact the primary message of the narrative – that the king of Israel is corrupt (in my view). In this presentation I take Perry and Sternberg’s general proposition further. I discuss a gap of knowledge in I Kings I that could call into question the legitimacy of Solomon’s kingship. In this narrative Nathan directs Bathsheba to discuss with David a putative oath that David made concerning Solomon as his rightful successor. This ‘forgotten’ oath is problematic in the narrative since Adonijah, the rightful king by birthright, is concurrently making preparations to replace David as king and, crucially, doing so with David’s blessing. There are significant gaps in knowledge in this narrative. For instance, it is not known if David truly did make an oath concerning Solomon but forgot it, due to his aged state, or if Nathan and Bathsheba are tricking David by pretending that he made an oath and forgot it.
|
A Hermeneutic of Resonance in the Parables
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Glenna S. Jackson, Otterbein University
Who gets to tell the stories when they do not originate from one's own culture and context? New Testament parables have intriguing and unique contexts in Africa and the Middle East because they often resonate differently from the western world of which I am a part. On the one hand, I argue that experiences of the Good Samaritan, for example, that have been told to me in Africa and that I have also encountered in Israel-Palestine resonate much more authentically with Lukan authorial intent than my own cultural understanding. On the other hand, can I, as a white, female feminist Westerner and outsider to Africa and the Middle East, tell those stories without objectifying the story tellers; is it possible for me to be an effective ally?
|
Under the Guise of Modesty! Women’s Bodies, Cultural Purity, and the Politics of Dress in 1 Timothy 2:8-15; A Contextual, Feminist, and Postcolonial Reading
Program Unit: Europe Contested: Contemporary Bible Readings Performed by "Ordinary" Readers in a European Context (EABS)
Sharon Jacob, Pacific School of Religion
Women’s bodies dressed in traditional garb are fetishized into cultural symbols as their sexuality and character is directly connected to their clothing. The modesty of a woman determined through her clothing becomes a symbol of national and cultural purity to promote the superiority of a nation and/or community. Therefore, under the guise of protecting the cultural purity of a nation/community, women’s clothing is constantly policed and scrutinized. Thus, women dressing in “non-traditional” clothing are deemed sexually deviant and threaten to destroy the image of a culturally pure and homogenous nation or community. Policing women’s bodies by regulating their clothing are not unique to the contemporary context. This topic is dealt with in detail in 1 Timothy. 2:8-15.
Scholarly conversations on this passage, for the most part, have remained at the historical, cultural, and anthropological level. Although such interpretations are important, they fail to take into consideration the impact of such texts on the real life experiences of women. This paper reads 1 Timothy. 2:8-15 alongside a real incident in Bangalore, India on Dec 31, 2016. My paper proposes a contextual reading of this passage and argues that using the voices of real life women can lead to a more nuanced interpretation of this passage. Along with reading with ordinary readers, my paper also uses the lens of postcolonial, feminist criticism, and race studies to illustrate that politics of traditional dress and women’s modesty signifies connections to cultural purity, communal identity, and the larger issue of nation and nationalism.
|
Reading the Gospels in an Islamic Context: Dionysius Bar Ṣalībī’s Response to the Muslim Accusation of Scriptural Falsification
Program Unit: Bible and Syriac Studies in Context
Bert Jacobs, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
Scholarship on Syriac Christian responses to the challenge of Islam has so far mainly focused on the most obvious corpus, apologetic and polemic texts, leaving other literary genres where apologetic concerns may be more implicitly present largely unconsidered, such as Biblical
exegesis. This paper argues that the West Syrian scholarly bishop Dionysius Bar Ṣalībī (d. 1171), who authored both the most comprehensive Syriac biblical commentary as well as the most comprehensive Syriac disputation against Islam, provides a unique vantage point for exploring the dynamics of implicit and explicit apologetics vis-à-vis Islam. As a test case, we will study how Bar Ṣalībī in both contexts deals with Jesus’ words and deeds seemingly at odds with his divinity, i.e. his expressions of fear of death (Mt 26:39 par.), godforsakenness (Mt 27:46 par.), ignorance (Mt 24:36 par.), impotence (Mt 20:20-23 par.), and inferiority to the Father (Jn 14:28). For each of these five pericopes, we will compare Bar Ṣalībī’s interpretations in direct reponse to Muslim objections in the disputation with those in his Gospel commentaries, to assess the (dis)continuity of Bar Ṣalībī’s apologetic concerns in both genres. As a result, light will be shed on the impact of the Islamic context on the Syriac Christian reading of the Gospels.
|
The Possibility of God: Revealing His Form Man According to Rashbam’s Commentary on the Pentateuch
Program Unit: Judaica
Jonathan Jacobs, Bar-Ilan University
In his commentary on the Pentateuch, Rashbam offers a systematic and comprehensive discussion about the possibility of God revealing his form to man. In Rashbam’s opinion, it is possible for a person, at least theoretically, to see the God of Israel. However, One who does so is condemned to die. Passages which seem to describe God revealing himself to mortals without resulting in the death of the observer are explained by Rashbam using four exegetical strategies: exceptions which are related to establishing a covenant; the revelation of an angel and not God Himself; context-specific solutions; or a blurry, indirect vision of God. I suggest that besides exegetical considerations, Rashbam’s special efforts to interpret verses describing God’s revelation to man, are part of a polemical response to Christian interpretations which sought to downplay divine revelations to the Children of Israel, instead focusing on the descent of the Son to the world—Jesus.
|
Social and Legal Aspects of the Violation of the Widowed Mother's Rights in the Book of Proverbs and Ancient Near Eastern Legal Sources
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Law
Lea Jacobsen, Gordon College
Many verses in the Book of Proverbs discuss the behavior required from sons toward their parents. They are warned against inappropriate behaviors such as: cursing (20:20; 30:11), causing grief (10: 1; 17: 21, 25; 23: 25), stealing property (28: 24; 29:3), and contempt (15:20; 23:22; 30: 17). Most of the warnings of the author of Proverbs against offending parents concern father and mother living under the same roof, their validity in the case of a single parent living by himself being self-evident.
But in one verse - "he who torments his father and chases away his mother is a son who causes shame and brings disgrace" (Prov 19:26), the term "mother" should not be understood as completing the father to signify parents, but as a widow. Examination of the different behaviors of the son ("משדד" and "יבריח") and the time of their occurrence indicates that in this case, the son acts violently toward his father and mother in their lives, and after the father's death he harms his mother even more because of her new status as a widow and her property rights, so that she is forced to flee the house. This interpretation has not been discussed in previous studies and is based on a semantic linguistic analysis of the terms in the verse, and on ancient Near Eastern legal sources. The chasing away of the mother in Proverbs 19:26 and its motives are clarified in light of §172 in the Laws of Hammurabi, which deals with sons behaving in exactly the same way – chasing away their widowed mother from her home. The discussion is based on the assumption that the author warned against incidents firmly anchored in the social and legal reality of his own time and place.
|
Reconsidering 4QAstronomical Enoch A-B (4Q208–4Q209) in Relation to Late Babylonian Magical Hemerological Texts That Use the "Microzodiac"
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Helen R. Jacobus, University College London
In light of the existing research on the Aramaic calendars in the Dead Sea Scrolls, the development of 4QAstronomical Enocha-b (4Q208–209) is further explored in relation to Late Babylonian texts that use the ‘microzodiac.’ The calendar of 4Q208–209 has been reconstructed mathematically and it is argued that each day corresponds to a position in the zodiac within the context of an adapted schematic calendar of 12 ideal 30-day months, known from the third millennium in Mesopotamia until the Late Babylonian period. The scheme is compared to the Late Babylonian hemerological magical text BRM IV, 19 and related texts. It is shown that 4Q208–209 and BRM IV, 19 and related ‘microzodiac’ texts, are probably descended from a common astronomical-astrological source.
|
Voicing Violence: Women, Solidarity, and Estrangement in Biblical Poetry
Program Unit: Deconstructive Poetics (EABS)
Elaine James, Saint Catherine University
This paper is part of a panel, "Silence is Violence." Tarana Burke started the #metoo movement “to empower women through empathy,” and part of its power is in connecting women’s stories of harassment, assault, and violence in a communal narrative. This prominence of feminine solidarity is anticipated by historian Sharon Bloch's Rape and Sexual Power in Early America, which shows that in the patriarchal society of early America, one of the key ways sexual violence was reported and redressed was through networks of social connection among women. These examples, and their emphasis on homosociality and communal support among women as a key function of voicing violence perpetrated against individuals, frames a site of exploration for the voicing of violence in biblical texts. Many characters who are victims of violence are denied voice either by the narrator or by other characters (e.g., Dinah, Tamar). But for those who do speak, what are the circumstances that enable them to come to voice? Are there communal structures in evidence that play a role in naming perpetrated violence? Both Song of Songs and Lamentations strikingly feature the voice of an assaulted woman. This essay examines the emergence of speech after violence in both texts, exploring the social relationships that enable speech to emerge, as well as the patterns of silence that persist. It argues that sociality and communal identity (realized, or unrealized) are key components of the voice of an assaulted woman.
|
Regenerative Agriculture and Restoration of the Bond between Humanity and the Earth
Program Unit: The Bible and Ecology (EABS)
Jane Shey, Shey and Associates
The ancient Roman government’s push for productivity and intensive farming is reflected in modern society’s pursuit of this same type of agriculture at the expense of the land and the social structure that encompasses rural communities. Intensive farming has caused environmental damage. Today there is a need to restore soil health and biodiversity. Our society needs to heed the call of Pope Francis’ Encyclical Laudato Si to restore the connection and balance between all living creatures. In line with this thrust, from the perspective of urban climate governance and local food policy, this paper aims to dialogue with biblical scholars regarding the possibilities of restoring the land and recognizing our interconnectedness, our need for intergenerational solidarity through sustainable farming and the regenerative agriculture movement, and up to what extent religion and biblical insights can potentially influence this advocacy. Some of the questions that can be explored for interdisciplinary approach include: In what manner can regenerative agriculture rebuild the partnership between the land and people by following the cues provided by nature? What interaction between habitats which is found in sustainable farming result in the restoration of balance between humans and nature? With the greater awareness of ecosystem dynamics found in regenerative agriculture, how do we see farmers taking on the responsibility of being caretakers of the land for the next generation? In dialogue with biblical scholars, what biblical stories and insights can be influential for promoting this advocacy in and through the Christian religion?
|
Prophesying and Twisting: Exploring the Metaphorical Description of Prophesying Women in the Greek Text of Ezekiel 13:17–23
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible (EABS)
Patrik Jansson, Helsingin Yliopisto - Helsingfors Universitet
In this paper, I explore the significance of the metaphorical expressions that are used to characterize the actions of the prophesying women in the Septuagint text of Ezekiel 13:17–23. Ezekiel 13:17–23 is a section that has generated significant scholarly interest. The Masoretic text describes a group of women who seem to prophesy but also manufacture obscure instruments to trap people or souls. However, the Septuagint offers a reading that is considerably different since the references to trapping are replaced with verbs that refer to metaphorical perverting or twisting.
My primary argument is that the text uses metaphors to create a threatening image of the women who are able to lead people away from God. In the Greek text, the twisting and turning of the victims is used to conceptualize the actions and results of prophesying women. Metaphorical expressions of Ezekiel 13:17–23 cannot be interpreted in isolation since they follow each other, which enhances the image of the women as a threat. Furthermore, the conceptual metaphor “life is a journey” that is communicated more clearly in verse 13:22 seems to connect the metaphorical expressions of the section.
The paper argues that the relations of the metaphors need to be studied. This is essential for the assessment of the threat that the text seeks to communicate. Moreover, the paper suggests that in the case of Ezekiel 13:17–23 it is necessary to go beyond the Masoretic text and ask how metaphors and the nature of threat are presented in the LXX.
|
Reifying the Didache
Program Unit: Apostolic Fathers and Related Early Christian Literature
Clayton N. Jefford, Saint Meinrad School of Theology
A problem for scholars of the Didache is the need to assign provenance and dates for the text. This has led to a variety of options, from the contexts of Egypt, Palestine, and Syria to a range of years from the mid-first to fourth centuries. Unless one sees the Didache as a complete work originally written to be utilized from beginning to end as attested by the manuscript of Codex Hierosolymitanus 54, a quagmire of likely sources and hands likely have been at work in developing the tradition preserved there. Following the guidelines of Social Identity Theory, this essay proposes that the evolution of the Didache presents a uniquely complicated situation in that its various source elements probably were compiled within fluctuating contexts while the eventual collection of those elements was accomplished in another separate environment. To that end, one might expect individual portions of the work to reflect two separate lenses of interpretation: an earlier set of circumstances possessing the view of the originator of the materials in question and a later setting reflecting the orientation and emphasis of an editor who reassigned those earlier materials for a more relevant purpose. By way of illustration, the witness of the Apostolic Constitutions for the Didache tradition stands as an exemplar of this very theme: a reification of the work’s original purpose(s) derived from within one context but assigned to another. This essay seeks to suggest some general guidelines by which to identify the two differing viewpoints that may be at work within the text as now known from H54. While it is impossible to know the specifics either of the original settings or their eventual combination, the relevance of both lenses of interpretation are important as tools by which to understand the tradition’s evolving function in early Christian literature.
|
Two Editing problems in the Masoretic Text, the Septuagint and Kings: 2 Chr 36.8; 1 Sam 16,17
Program Unit: Editorial Techniques in the Hebrew Bible in Light of Empirical Evidence (EABS)
Patricia Jelbert, University of Gloucestershire
When comparing the citation formulae in biblical Chronicles in the Masoretic Text with the Septuagint, the last formulaic citation (2 Chronicles 36.8) presents a problem, where it may be seen that the Septuagint has substituted the standard Chronicles formula as found in the Masoretic text (“the Chronicles of the Kings of Judah”) with the one found only in Kings (the book of “the kings of Judah and Israel”). Furthermore, the burial site named only in Kings, and only in connection with Kings Amon and Manasseh, has been inserted into Chronicles from Kings in connection with King Jehoiakim, plus a few additiona details. Additionally, when looking at the unevenness between Chapters 1 Samuel 16 and 17 where David is called to sing and play the harp for Saul, and then in the next chapter where he kills Goliath, Saul asks to meet this hero who has saved Israel. It is as if Saul had never met David before. This points to two sources for the two narratives, but in the Septuagint 2 Samuel 17 the verses 12-32, wherein lie the discrepancies, are eliminated. Both instances point to a rationalising process, tidying up a problem area, which is not altered in the Masoretic Text. The old idea of “lectio brevior potior,” the shorter reading is to be preferred, has been challenged in recent scholarship. In my own research from a different angle, I have come to this same conclusion, realizing that “lectio difficilis potior” is more likely to be nearer to the original, at least in these instances. This has led to further enquiry into the Septuagint itself, which has resulted in several lines of enquiry and a whole lot of questions rather than reaching any definitive answers.
|
The Tripartite Structure of Biblical Chronicles: How the Citation Formulae Act as Editorial Markers
Program Unit: Intersections: A Forum for Research on Ancient Israel, Hebrew Bible, and Cognate Topics (EABS)
Patricia Jelbert, University of Gloucestershire
The citation formulae of Chronicles have been labelled as “tendentious”, “Literary adornments” and other such unflattering names. However when compared with similar formulae in the wider ancient Near Eastern chronography, we can see that they need to be taken seriously as functioning “colophonic” source citations that share features such as regnal dating, synchronic referencing, catchlines, burial formulae, and retribution and reward. Further, within the biblical book of Chronicles itself, these formulaic citations act as editorial markers, with their positioning within the biblical text revealing Chronicles’ tripartite structure: an origins section, a recapitulation section which is mostly selections from the book of Samuel, and the chronicling section which begins in Solomon’s reign once the Temple is built. As Chronicles, these records are maintained thereafter throughout the monarchical period. When Chronicles’ source citations are juxtaposed with those in the book of Kings, a complex referencing and cross-referencing system is revealed. For example, after the united monarchy is divided into two kingdoms, the book of Kings maintains bilateral cross-referencing between both the “chronicles of the Kings of Judah,” and “the chronicles of the Kings of Israel,” the latter which cease after the northern kingdom exile in 721/2 B.C. The references to the “chronicles of the Kings of Judah” continue, albeit increasingly erratically, until Judah’s exile in 587 B. C. The similarities and the variations in Kings and Chronicles' formulae show that each have distinctive formulaic patterning, with some mutual influences and interactions, which indicate scribal fluctuations over time between the two works. These formulaic citations then can be used for discerning the isagogic elements of genre, authorship, dating and editorial layers.
|
Ontology in the Genesis Myths of Origin
Program Unit: Methodological Pluralism in the Study of Genesis
Hans J. L. Jensen, Aarhus Universitet
The current anthropological discussion of ontology, inspired especially by Philippe Descola’s Beyond Nature and Culture (ET 2013), has so far had little impact on Biblical exegesis. In this paper I propose that Descola’s ontological categories may throw new light on Genesis and the rest of the Bible, including the relationship between Gen 1 and Gen 2-3.
|
"For I Handed on to You as of First Importance What I in Turn Had Received’ (1 Cor. 15:3): The Primitive Faith of the Earliest Believers in Jesus as Reflected in Paul’s Letters
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Joseph E. Jensen, Georgetown University
Before there was any written account of what Jesus taught and did there was Paul, and Paul wrote letters. Paul came to belief that Jesus is the messiah within five years after Jesus’ execution. Paul’s letters are the earliest extant writings, primary sources that reflect the faith and beliefs of believers prior to the written gospels. In 2 Cor 12:1-10 Paul describes a mystical experience that convinced him that he was mistaken in his zealous conviction that Jesus could not have been the Messiah. In the early years that followed believers in Damascus, Arabia, Jerusalem, and Antioch contributed from their oral traditions to guide Paul’s understanding of what Jesus had taught and done. Some of these believers had known Jesus before his death, and some were witnesses that God had raised Jesus from the dead (Rom 16:7; Gal 2:17-19; 2:1-14; 1 Cor 15:1-7). In this presentation, I discuss what can be known about the oral traditions that Paul was taught and how these contributed to Paul’s developing faith on the basis of Paul’s own words in the seven letters for which most scholars agree regarding Paul’s authorship. I will also discuss the teachings and faith of other believers who disagreed with Paul, but as such teachings and faith is reflected in these letters from Paul. Thus, the focus of my presentation is the faith of the Paul of history reflected in his own accounts, which deserve some priority over the portraits of Paul’s faith and teachings reflected in The Acts of the Apostles and in 2 Peter, both written long after Paul’s death.
|
The Levitical Struggle against the Priests and the Tent of Meeting in Chronicles
Program Unit: Writings (including Psalms)
Jaeyoung Jeon, Université de Lausanne
Recent socio-historical studies of the Persian Yehud have revealed that the Levites, the second-tier temple personnel, probably had their own social, economic, and religious interests distinguished from those of the priests.
Against this backdrop, this paper endeavors to look into the way the Chronicler, most likely a Levitical scribe, treats the pentateuchal tradition of the wilderness sanctuary, the priestly Tent of Meeting (Tabernacle). According to the recent Pentateuch discussions, the building of the Tent of Meeting is the ultimate goal of Pg as well as the conclusion of the source. In Pg, therefore, the Tent is the center of the cosmos where the creator is present permanently.
In Chronicles, however, the priestly Tent is treated ambivalently. On the one hand, the daily sacrifices are continuously made before the Tent (1 Chr 16.39-40), which is located in the high-place of Gibeon for a justification of Solomon's sacrifice there (2 Chr 1; 1 Kgs 3). On the other hand, the cultic significance of the priestly Tent is much reduced in Chronicles. An alternative tent built by David in Jerusalem holds the Ark, while the priestly Tent remains as a high-place sanctuary even without the Ark. The former’s cultic significance and continuity to the Solomonic Temple are emphasized, whereas the latter is eventually abandoned by David in favor of Ornan's threshing field (1 Chr 22.29). The Chronicler also reformulates the Davidic tent as a Levitical cultic place in a sharp contrast with the declining priestly Tent. Such an ambivalent treatment of the Tent of Meeting in Chronicles can be understood in a larger framework of the Levites’ social and ideological struggle against the dominant, Zadokite priestly group.
|
The Fate of the Beautiful and the Ugly in the Book of Judges
Program Unit: Bodies of Communication (EABS)
Dae Jun Jeong, Wycliffe College
As a general rule, the narrators of the Hebrew Bible do not mention characters’ outward appearance as ugly. In fact, “the idea of ugliness is virtually absent from the OT” except when describing animals’ exterior. The reason why the Hebrew Bible is void of this description is because all of God’s creatures are good (tob; beautiful/handsome) to Him. God sees His creatures in this manner, whether they are good or ugly. In general, the word ‘ugly’ is the last word a person would use to describe another. Nevertheless, I would like to use this word in a functional, rather than a derogatory sense. The biblical narrators depict beautiful characters in the narrative as ones without a blemish on their bodies (Dan 1:4; 2 Sam 14:25), as much taller than others (1 Sam 9:2) or as having a fatly healthy appearance (Dan 1:15). By categorizing these characters as beautiful, we can establish a control group against which, for the sake of convenience, to make a judgment of ugliness.
Characters live in the narrative world. If the narrator mentions the outward appearance of a character such as beauty, fatness, or lameness, the narrator means to convey intention to the reader. If the description served no purpose, the narrator would omit it. In this paper, I will examine the fate of so-called beautiful and ugly characters in the book of Judges. The result will help us understand that these expressions serve a special theological purpose of the narrator and are another way of exposing the coherence of the DtrH.
|
Torah and Li: Reading Psalm 1:1-2 in the Context of "Duke Zhao Twenty-Five Years" in Zuo Zhuan
Program Unit: Contextual Interpretation of the Bible (Hebrew Bible/Old Testament and New Testament)
Zhenshuai Jiang, Shandong University/Universität Zürich
The notion of the law (Torah) in the Hebrew Bible has developed into a system that, in some biblical texts originated in the Persian period, represents almost everything of religious and cosmological significance. The same can be said about the transformation of the tradition of “Li” in ancient Chinese culture. This transformation occurred around the 4th century BCE when the notion of “Li” gradually developed from a specific ritual behaviour to the all-inclusive collective concept. This presentation will read Ps 1:1-2 which in particular reflects the collective concept of “Torah” in the context of the notion of “Li” in “Duke Zhao Twenty-Five Years”. The presentation will discuss how the notion of “Torah” in Ps 1:1-2 and the notion of “Li” in “Duke Zhao Twenty-Five Years” provide insight into each other.
|
Esther’s Composite Identity in Susa: An Analysis of the Role of Gender in the Struggle for Ethnic/Religious Survival and Maintenance under the Persian Empire
Program Unit: Postcolonial Studies
Kristin Joachimsen, MF Norwegian School of Theology
The paper explores the role of gender in the struggle for ethnic/religious survival in the Book of Esther (MT). In this story, the character of Esther has been identified as a heroine, anti-heroine and trickster. She is characterized by various markers, like beautiful, woman, orphan, adopted daughter, virgin, refugee and as belonging to an ethnic minority, the Judeans in Susa. Moreover, she marries one from outside her ethnic/religious group, the Persian king, and so becomes part of the elite as the queen of the Persian Empire. Queen Esther uses this position to save her own people when threatened. To scrutinize the significance of gender related to ethnic/religious survival and maintenance in the Persian Empire, the role of Esther will be compared to that of Vashti and Mordechai. Also the eunuchs shed light on the role of gender in this story. The theoretical framework and methodical approach of the paper relate to postcolonial studies, which have proved to be fruitful in analyzing question of identity, gender and power. I shall apply the cultural critic Bhabha’s three concepts ambivalence, hybridity and mimicry on an analysis of identity, gender and power in the Book of Esther, in the interplay of Judean and imperial ideologies; in which the story of Judean Persian Queen might mirror adoption, adaption as well as altering within the culture of the Empire.
|
Jezebel as the “Ultimate Other”: Postcolonial and Intersectional Perspectives on a Foreign Woman, Loyal Baal-Worshipper, and Powerful Queen in 1 and 2 Kings
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Kristin Joachimsen, MF Norwegian School of Theology
In the “Deuteronomistic History”, there is a widespread dynamics between “us” and “them”, discerning between Israel and “the others”, that is, those who threaten Israel’s peculiar relationship to YHWH. These texts are also characterized by a language filled with stereotypes and clichés. This paper explores the role of gender in ethnic/religious encounters in 1 and 2 Kings, focusing on presentation of Jezebel. Characterized by various identities, Jezebel has been labeled “the ultimate other”: She is daughter of a Phoenician king, queen of the Israelite king Ahab and mother of the Israelite king Joram. She is a foreign woman, loyal Baal-worshiper, powerful wife and oppressor. Jezebel makes sure that YHWH’s prophets are killed and that some criminals make the vine-grower Nabot of Jisreel stoned to death (1 Kings 21:8-10). And like most in this story, also Jezebel is a victim of violence: she is killed and thrown to the dogs (2 King 9:7;10;32-37).
To scrutinize the significance of gender to ethnic/religious encounters, I will relate the role of Jezebel to that of Ahab (1 Kings 16:31), Elijah (1 Kings 18-19), Nabot (1 Kings 21) and Jehu (2 Kings 9). The theoretical focus relates to postcolonial and intersectional studies, which both have proven rewarding in analyzing questions of identity, gender and power, highlighting, for instance, the complexity of identity formations and the related topic of the construction of “the other”. I shall apply the cultural critic Homi Bhabha’s concept of hybridity, which is developed as a critique of constructed dichotomizations (including stereotypes and clichés). The analysis of the complex relationship between “us” and “them”, will be expanded with an intersectional perspective, which adds a sensitivity to the fact that there are different ways of being female- or gendered.
|
Contested Liberation from PTSD: Exorcisms in Luke in Psychological Perspective
Program Unit: Psychological Hermeneutics of Biblical Themes and Texts
Linda Joelsson, Ersta-Sköndal-Bräcke University
New Testament stories of Jesus involved in incidents of demonic possession and exorcism can be understood in new ways because of #metoo. A somewhat similar backlash, or negative reaction, to old stories now being told, is apparent in several pericopes. In Luke 11.14-26, some members of first-century Jewish society preferred to discuss whether it was wrong of Jesus to liberate the mute man from the demon, or not. No one appears to be particularly interested in what the man has to say, and the higher strata of society hijack the scene. Jesus is challenged by the accusation that his powers come from the devil, that is, they work toward strife and ruin. In Luke 8.26-39 (and its synoptic parallels), signs of traumatization are openly described. The possessed man lives among the graves. He calls himself ’legion’, the name of a military troop formation within the Roman army. The miracle Jesus performs involves a herd of pigs running away and throwing themselves into the sea as a vision of Rome leaving the region in an act of self-directed destruction. Similar to the 21th century phenomenon #metoo, in these pericopes not everyone is happy with traumatized people coming to their senses and telling their stories. The people around the formerly possessed man ask Jesus to leave before more ’damage’ is done. In such cases, psychology of trauma and family systems theory may shed light on the psychological reactions and the potential redistribution of power that follow self-revelations and healings, in the exorcisms in Luke 8.26-39 and 11.14-26.
|
Anatomy and Anthropology: The Interpretation of Flesh by Ordinary Readers
Program Unit: Europe Contested: Contemporary Bible Readings Performed by "Ordinary" Readers in a European Context (EABS)
Linda Joelsson, Ersta-Sköndal-Bräcke University
Eugene Nida and Charles Taber, two experts in biblical translation, suggest that the Greek term σάρξ is used only incidentally with reference to people in the New Testament. They maintain that ‘mass object’ is the primary sense of the concept. In their perspective, the “figurative usage can greatly complicate the analysis of certain phrases” (Nida & Taber 2003). This paper turn the tables and asks how ‘ordinary’ readers make sense of the translations of σάρξ in passages where ‘people’ is the primary sense of the concept. It appears that the Greek concept σάρξ belongs to the semantic domain of anthropology or cosmology, while the English concept ‘flesh’ (Ger. Fleisch; Swe. ‘kött’) belongs to anatomy. The association ‘mass object’ seems to be triggered by the well-established translation of the Greek term into English, rather than by the Greek text itself. According to George Lakoff and Elisabeth Wehling (2012), the human mind works in mental cascades. A concept or combination of concepts trigger a chain of associations which together form a mental construct in which the concepts are incorporated. The interpreter has generally difficulties in resisting the chain of associations once triggered, and to choose only a selected part of the mental construct which they together form. Without any doubt, this phenomenon constitutes a challenge in the task of translation when the translator tries to transfer the semantic structure of the source text by means of concepts and phrases that only partially cover the same semantic field or belong to different semantic domains. The passages that will be investigated include Luke 24, John 1, Romans 8 and Galatians 5. The readers are asked what the respective author was trying to convey by means of the passage, and about their own emotional reactions to the phrasing.
|
Visualizing Material Reconstructions in Three Dimensions: Some Insights on the Placement of 1QM Frgs. 3 and 9 from a Scrollable Digital Model
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Michael Brooks Johnson, McMaster University
Using a new method of digitally rolling reconstructions of Dead Sea scrolls, this paper will present a scrollable model of the War Scroll from Qumran Cave 1 (1QM) that sheds light on the placements of frgs. 3 and 9. Many reconstructions of Dead Sea scrolls rely on patterns of damage incurred by manuscripts while they were rolled in the caves at Qumran. The distance between these damages increase in regular increments toward the exterior layers of the scroll, and thus they can be used to guide reconstructions of fragmentary manuscripts. These reconstructions often rely on Hartmut Stegemann's method of reconstructing Dead Sea scrolls. One of the challenges of such reconstructions is that readers do not always perceive the patterns on which the scholar bases his or her reconstructive arguments because there has been no way of visualizing a scroll in its closed state in editions. This presentation will show how digitally rolling a reconstruction of 1QM in a three-dimensional environment can visualize how well corresponding points of damage align in the scroll's closed state, which can be used to adjudicate the placements of frgs. 3 and 9, each of which have multiple proposals. These two examples will demonstrate how a three-dimensional model of a rolled scroll can communicate arguments based on the closed state of scrolls to readers of editions in ways that conventional plates of unrolled scrolls cannot.
|
The Problem of Adamic Interpretations of Romans 7:8–10
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
David Johnston, University of St Andrews
A growing consensus in the study of Rom 7 is that an allusion to the fall in Genesis lies behind the event depicted in verses 8–10. However, the Adamic interpretation of this allusion has not proven sufficient to establish a resultant consensus concerning the identifications of either the event or the speaker in Rom 7:8–10, let alone the relationship of these verses to the remainder of the passage. We must therefore rethink the nature of the allusion.
The principal verbal correspondence between the Genesis text and Rom 7:8–10 is the verb exapataō in verse 10. The speaker of Rom 7 is said to be deceived in the event just as Adam and Eve were deceived in Eden. Scholars typically place the focus of the deception in Rom 7 on the one who is deceived, resulting in the speaker being identified as Adam or as one in the Adamic flesh. However, I shall argue that, although there is an allusion to Gen 3, the allusion does not function principally to identify the one who is deceived. Rather, the function of the allusion is to characterise the one who deceives.
In support of this reading I shall consider how Paul uses the verb exapataō throughout his letters, concluding that in every passage there is a shared context of false teaching. When there is also an echo of Eden, this allusion serves to draw a parallel between the serpent in the garden and the actions of the one teaching falsely in the present. The allusion is therefore not Adamic, but Edenic. Paul’s characterisation of the event of verses 8–10 in terms of deception presents the event as an occasion of false teaching, and, more specifically, functions to rhetorically denounce those teaching falsely in the present.
|
Three Blind Vices: Samson's Sight, Samson's Blindness
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Kirsty Jones, Georgetown University
This paper explores the associative link between vision and transgression in the Samson cycle, and the interpretative emphases on Samson's blindness. Incorporating sensory anthropology to investigate the role of vision in the text, and with close reading of the Hebrew text, I move from text to Talmud and Philo and through contemporary scholarship. I posit that the Ancient perception of vision as an active, embodied process which not only acquires knowledge but is understood as cognition and desire in and of itself sheds new light on Judges 13-16 and aids understandings of the text. I question why the Philistines, like so many contemporary works, link Samson's blindness to his weakness, ignoring the text's link between shaving and weakness. The complex interplay between ability-disability and strength-weakness makes the cycle a fascinating insight into Ancient conceptions of sensory disability and the reception of these ideas.
|
Holiness in Chronicles: Any Links with Pentateuchal Traditions on the Concept?
Program Unit: Writings (including Psalms)
Louis Jonker, University of Stellenbosch
It is quite interesting to see that the verb qds (to be/become holy) occurs most frequently in Chronicles (32X), Leviticus (31X) and Exodus (28X). What is reflected in the Chronicler's usage of this concept, and with which Pentateuchal traditions does he engage on the matter? And furthermore, what implications do the results of such an investigation hold for the Chronicler's relationship with the Pentateuch? These questions will be discussed in the paper.
|
Is There a Greek “History of Joseph”?
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Ljubica Jovanovic, American Public University
Dramatic retellings of the story of Joseph (Genesis 37, 39-47, 50) known to us in Syriac, Ethiopic, and Arabic all carry the title, History of Joseph. They include lengthy elaborations on Joseph’s use of the cup of divination in accessing supernatural and human secrets (Gen 44:5, 15) and belong to a Hellenistic Joseph tradition that saw his lecanomantic practice as a legitimate means of communication of a Hellenistic spiritual expert with the divine. So far the Greek version of this text has not been found. This paper will propose that the reason behind the missing Greek version could lie in the Septuagint’s translation of the Hebrew נַחֵשׁ יְנַחֵשׁ with οἰωνίζομαι (Gen 44:5, 15) for Joseph’s divinatory practices with his cup. Because οἰωνίζομαι means primarily divination from flight or cries of birds, a Greek reader would hardly have related Joseph’s divination with lecanomancy and a substantial part of the History of Joseph would have been lost on a Greek speaking audience.
|
A Biblical Tradition of Їѡсифь Прѣкрасни (Handsome Joseph) in Slavonic Manuscripts
Program Unit: Rethinking Biblical Written Tradition through Slavonic Interpretations
Ljubica Jovanovic, American Public University
The Slavonic name, Їѡсифь прѣкрасни, which is the translation of the Greek, Ο πάγκαλος Ιωσήφ, refers, in Slavic and Greek church traditions and texts, to the "Joseph of Genesis" or the "Patriarch Joseph." In English, it is rendered as either the “Handsome Joseph” or the “Most Beautiful Joseph.” Joseph was a beloved biblical character in medieval Slavic texts and numerous Hellenistic stories about him found a home in Slavonic manuscripts.
A number of these manuscripts are imaginative re-tellings of the so-called Joseph Story in Genesis (37-50). The embellishments and omissions in this biblical episode follow the earlier Hellenistic precedents, such as Joseph’s wail on his mother’s tomb, or the striking of his cup with the finger. A similar body of texts on Joseph has been preserved in Syriac, often with the same motifs. However, an excellent dramatic text, History of Joseph, which is known in Syriac, Ethiopic, and Arabic, did not find its way into the Slavic Joseph traditions. This presentation will argue that the omission of this text was due to its omission in the Greek Joseph tradition, which in turn has its cause in a particular Greek translation of the Septuagint of Gen 44:5 and 15.
|
"Truly in Deed " or "In Deed and in Truth"? The Meaning of the Expression ἐν ἔργῳ καὶ ἀληθείᾳ in 1 John 3:18 and Its Implications for the Interpretation of the Verses Following
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Chang-Wook Jung, Chongshin University
The prepositional phrase ‘ἐν ἔργῳ καὶ ἀληθείᾳ’ in the commandment in 1 John 3:18, ‘Dear Children, let’s love not in word and tongue but in action and truth’ has generated much discussion. Scholarly views are divided into two directions. Some insist that the locution denotes ‘truly in deed’ or ‘in real deed,’ In contrast, others postulate that it conveys the double meaning, i.e., both ‘truly in deed’ and ‘in deed and in Truth.’
Since the locution ‘of the truth’ occurs in the following verse, v. 19, the prepositional phrase in v.18, may be understood as ‘in deed and in Truth’ as well as ‘in real deed.’ Intriguingly, even scholars who argue for this view do not explain how it influences or functions for the interpretation of the following verses, vv. 19-24 and chapter, ch. 4; they do not explicate the passages by reflecting such understanding. What kind of different explanation for the following verses emerges with the interpretation that the locution means not only ‘truly in deed’ but also ‘in deed and in Truth’? I will try to demonstrate that the phrase ἐν ἔργῳ καὶ ἀληθείᾳ primarily denotes ‘in deed and in Truth’ rather than ‘truly in deed.’ The implications of this interpretation for the following verses, not only for vv.19-24, but also for ch.4 are explicated in detail.
|
Responding to Conflict: A Socio-Economic Approach to 1 Thessalonians 4:9-12
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Un Chan Jung, University of Durham
Love (φιλαδελφία), manual labour (ἐργάζομαι), a quiet life (ἡσυχάζω), decent behaviour toward outsiders (εὐσχημόνως) and self-sufficiency (μηδενὸς χρείαν ἔχητε) are, though seemingly different issues, squeezed into only two short sentences in 1 Thess 4:9-12. Scholars have puzzled over such a collection of various issues and their brevity, struggling also to clarify with confidence the contextual specificity of the text that Paul is addressing. Despite scholars’ nuanced exegeses, the precise meaning of the text still remains ambiguous.
An indispensable key for a more plausible interpretation of 1 Thess 4:9-12 is tracing the religious, social and economic context of Paul’s recipients based on clues both in the whole letter and in archaeological and historical sources which glimpse at historically invisible plebs’, in particular craftsmen’s, everyday lives in Thessalonica. Furthermore, another key is delving into the Thessalonians’ social behaviours and relationships through socio-economic and social psychological lens.
I suggest, on the basis of the above historical and social scientific exploration and reconstruction, that there was intractable conflict between believers and non-believers who had built camaraderie as fellow labourers in tabernae, social clubs, like voluntary associations, and households, and therefore that Paul had in mind responding to the conflict in 1 Thess 4:9-12 in three ways: mitigating harassment from outsiders, minimizing its detrimental social and economic effects on the believers, and thus sheltering solidarity and reciprocal relationships.
This is a case study in which the deep interrelations among theology, social behaviours or relationships, identity and socio-economic factors can be revealed. It is likely that Paul’s thought and the Thessalonians’ belief systems with regard to intergroup and intragroup ethics, such as reciprocity, are not unrelated to their socio-economic status and situations. I expect that this study may pave the way for further research on socio-economic factors influencing community ethics and social identity in Pauline letters.
|
Visual Representations of Black Samson
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Culture
Nyasha Junior, Temple University
In 1868, the celebrated political cartoonist Thomas Nast published an illustration titled “The Modern Samson” in the popular American magazine Harper’s Weekly. The cartoon criticized Southern Democratic opposition to suffrage for African American men. Nast depicted Samson as an African American whose hair represented his voting rights. Delilah, depicted as a White woman with the words “Southern Democracy” written on her gown, displays Samson’s shorn hair to a celebrating crowd of Southern Democratic politicians and members of the Ku Klux Klan. Beginning with this cartoon, our presentation traces visual representations of Samson as a Black man from the late eighteenth century to the present. First, we follow the development of the use of Samson imagery in political cartoons that address issues of racial injustice throughout the early twentieth century particularly in African-American newspapers. Second, we consider representations of Samson as a Black man in film, paintings, comic books, graphic novels, and television. This presentation is part of our larger book project studying racialized uses of Samson.
|
Stylizing the Bible for the Digital Age
Program Unit: Nida Institute for Biblical Scholarship at the American Bible Society
Tuomas Juntunen, Finnish Bible Society
The aim of my presentation is to show how the theoretical and methodological principles of the Digital New Testament project are put into practice. I wish to demonstrate how the word for word Finnish translation of the Greek source text is edited and stylized to meet the ideals formulated during the pilot project called DigiMarkus. I will concentrate on the questions of sentence structure as well as vocabulary. My primary example are verses 3–6 of the Colossians. In the word for word translation those verses form a single, very long and complex sentence. I will analyze how this sentence can be turned into five shorter and more readable sentences. I will also deal with the problem of antiquated words that are probably unintelligible from the point of view of our fictional model reader. For example, I have dispensed with the word armo, in English grace, because ₋ as I will argue ₋ this central Christian concept has become problematic in the Finnish context.
|
Transformational Kings
Program Unit: Political Biblical Criticism
David Justice, New Orleans Baptist Theological Seminary
The presentation of Jesus in the Gospels conforms to a pattern associated with kings and emperors: Jesus is God’s chosen agent who is authorized to bring about God’s kingdom by confronting the prevailing societal order with a vision for transformation into a new community. This pattern of a political figure who sets about transforming society and establishing a new social pattern hints at a similar pattern for lawgiver kings like Plutarch’s Lycurgus. Lycurgus, king of Sparta, consults Apollo at Delphi and receives an oracle that his laws would be the best and his commonwealth the most famous. He resolved to thoroughly reform Sparta and change the entire social system. Using insights from Michael Freeden’s morphological approach to ideological analysis, this presentation will examine how both the presentation of Lycurgus in Plutarch and the presentation of Jesus in the Synoptics employed the framework of kingship ideology, and how both their actions fit into this framework.
|
Textual History of Judg 6:7-10 and its Implications on Redactional History
Program Unit: Editorial Techniques in the Hebrew Bible in Light of Empirical Evidence (EABS)
Martin Kächele, Eberhard Karls Universität Tübingen
Since the very beginning of historical critical exegesis on Judg, the distinct character of Judg 6:7-10 within the Deuteronomistic introduction to the Gideon story has been noticed and highlighted. Although few scholars advocated the literary unity of Judg 6:1-10 (e.g. Martin Noth) the discovery of 4QJudg verified the others’ assumptions and provided evidence for the late insertion of the nameless prophet’s words. Going beyond this evidence, Judg 6:7-10 serves as a famous example of the methodologically close interdependence between literary criticism and textual criticism. In this case it becomes obvious that textual criticism does not only affect the so-called Endtext but also its previous stages. Going one step further, Judg 6:7-10 may also put the Former Prophets’ redactional history up for discussion. The striking and unique literary connections between Judg 6:7-10 and Josh 24 (i.e. Judg 6:10 and Josh 24:15, אלהי האמרי) raise questions which may challenge several explanations regarding Josh 24 and its function in the context of the Former Prophets. Is it possible to trace back both texts to the same tradition? If yes, this would result in a late dating of Josh 24, and any supposed pre-Deuteronomistic Hexateuch connections including this chapter would turn out to be obsolete. If not, it has at least to be explained which motives may have caused the interpolator of Judg 6:7-10 to exactly take up the formulas and ideas from Josh 24. In each case empirical evidence of textual history sheds new light on a key text of Former Prophets’ redactional history.
|
The Tree of Life
Program Unit: Slavonic Parabiblical Traditions (EABS)
Dolores Kamrada, Pázmány Péter Catholic University
The paper focuses on a certain type of icons entitled the ‘Fruit of Christ’s Passion’ that presents the crucifix as a blossoming tree. The investigation attempts to delineate the biblical background of this portrayal of the cross both in the Hebrew Bible and the New Testament. Special stress is laid on the interrelation between this presentation and the Adam and Eve traditions in Western and Eastern European iconography and folklore. Besides, Bonaventure’s book The Tree of Life (Lignum Vitae), which can be regarded as a parallel interpretation of the motif, is also treated in the paper.
|
Hebrew Poetry's Structure was Ancient!
Program Unit: Diachronic Poetology of the Hebrew Bible and Related Ancient Near Eastern and Ancient Jewish Literature (EABS)
Anne Kanno, Independent Scholar
In this paper I will show how ancient Hebrew poetry in the Bible (including Psalms, Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, the Song of the Sea) was constructed using ring composition dating back to Sumerian texts. This widely used structure, what I call the parable blueprint, is provable and is all about hidden comparisons for a wisdom purpose. It was used for genres other than just poetry. I will give examples of the structure in non biblical texts as well.
|
Ecclesiastes, Gospels, and Acts
Program Unit: Allusions in the Gospels and Acts
Anne Kanno, Independent Scholar
Ecclesiastes, the canonical gospels and Acts all share an identical underlying literary structure, which is about comparing hidden things for a wisdom purpose. The texts also seem to contain allusions to the structure itself. I will show the structure, what I call 'the parable blueprint" and the allusions that I see.
|
Struggling with the Concept of Kingship in Ezra/Nehemiah
Program Unit: Concepts of Leadership in the Hebrew Bible (EABS)
Christiane Karrer, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam
In post-exilic times the political structure of the sub-province Judah had to be reconstructed. Two conditions for concepts of leadership and political structure had to be met in this period: 1) Different from pre-exilic times, the king could not be a member of the Davidic dynasty (or another member of the Judean community) any longer. The most important element of pre-exilic political leadership was therefore missing. It was thus mandatory to find a concept that would make up for this gap of power and leadership. 2) Judah was a small part of the Achaemenid Empire. The Achaemenid king demanded loyalty and taxes. Any realistic concept of political leadership had to take this dependency on the foreign power into account. In my paper I will scrutinize the role of the concept of kingship in Ezra/Nehemiah. I presuppose that we can trace different ideas about political structure in the book on the account of the redaction history of the text. I will ask what happened to the concept of kingship within the different layers of the book. Had the pre-exilic concept been developed into a new one? If so, what traditions of kingship were used? Or was the concept of kingship refuted? If so, how did they conceptualize new forms of leadership? Who had to take over the functions of the ‘king’? How were the reconstructed forms of leadership related to the Achaemenid political structure?
|
Samaritan Inscriptions and the Development of a Centralized Cult in the Late Persian and Hellenistic Periods
Program Unit: Centralization and Cult in Persian Period Israel: Biblical, Historical and Comparative Perspectives (EABS)
Magnar Kartveit, VID Specialized University, Stavanger Campus, Norway
During the excavations on Mount Gerizim, more than 390 complete or fragmentary Samaritan inscriptions were discovered. They are dated 200-150 BCE and conform to a pattern for inscriptions from the same period found in several locations from Sinai to Turkey. However, some elements are unique to the Mount Gerizim inscriptions, notably the expression "in this place". This presentation will discuss the relation of these inscriptions to the centralization of cult as developed in other contexts.
|
Distant Reading of Early Christian Texts for Socio-cognitive Interpretation: Introducing the DiRECT Project
Program Unit: The Biblical World and Cultural Evolution (EABS)
Vojtech Kase, University of West Bohemia
From a bird's-eye view, what are the most central topics and concepts in early Christian texts in Greek from the first three centuries and how do these texts differ from other Greek texts from the same period? Is it possible to extract the topics and concepts from the texts by using semi-automatic computational tools? And when being successful in this, what would findings from this research reveal about cultural evolution of early Christianity and its distinctiveness in respect to religious cultural evolution in general? In a way of answering these questions, the paper introduces selected methods of distant reading currently developed by the DiRECT project. The distant reading here designates a palette of methods drawing on computer programming tools from the area of natural language processing and information retrieval. The important prerequisite for adopting this approach in given field is the fact that the input data are now available online in a machine readable form.
|
Representations of Violence in Functionalist Perspective: The Palace Reliefs of Ashurnasirpal II as a Test Case
Program Unit: Iconography and Biblical Studies (EABS)
Robert Kashow, Brown University
This paper investigates the social functions of representations of violence using select reliefs of Ashurnasirpal II as a test case, namely, the reliefs on the Balawat Gates and the Royal Lion Hunt relief. Previous scholarship on the anthropology of violence in functionalist perspective has generally focused on what physical forms of violence accomplish (i.e. what these anthropologists deem its function in society to be) in modern societies. This paper serves as an experimental attempt to push beyond such studies in an effort to begin consideration of (1) ancient societies and (2) the social functions of violence in representations of violence. Building on the work of Alfred Gell, who has made the case that things in the world can function as social actors, I explore how the aforementioned reliefs of Ashurnasirpal functioned as social actors that affected humans. I argue that like physical violence, the representation aids in legitimizing the status of the individual performing the physical act of violence and serves as a threat for further future violence; unlike physical violence, the representation of violence is more likely to eschew the possibility of social and political disassociation.
|
Editing the Septuagint of 2 Samuel
Program Unit: Septuagint of Historical Books (EABS)
Tuukka Kauhanen, University of Helsinki
The Greek 2 Samuel (2 Kingdoms) presents special problems for a critical editor. While the translation is fairly literal and the Hebrew Vorlage is not too different from the MT, the textual history of the Greek text is quite complex. The latter half of the book (probably from 10:6 onwards) has undergone the Hebraizing kaige revision and sporadic kaige-type readings can be found all over the book. The Lucianic (Antiochene) text has escaped many of the kaige readings but they evince heavy revision of a stylistic nature. Many manuscript traditions present a mixture of text-types. The complex text-historical situation requires the editor to set aside rules of thumb and apply a wide range of criteria in making the critical decisions. These include the nature of the witnesses, traits of the kaige revisers and the Lucianic reviser, and translation technique. This paper presents difficult cases esp. from 2 Sam 10–11 and 24 that have to be reckoned with when producing the critical edition of 2 Samuel for the Göttingen Septuagint.
|
Magic Embodied: Rethinking the Relationship between Script, Geometry, and Magical Ideas in the Kitab al-Diryaq (Book of Antidotes)
Program Unit: Medicine in Bible and Talmud (EABS)
Zahra Kazani, University of Victoria, Canada
The Kitab al-Diryaq (Book of Antidotes) of 595 A.H./1198-9 C.E. (Bibliothèque Nationale, Paris, arabe 2964) is a pseudo-Galen treatise delineating recipes for curing snakebites. The manuscript is written in Arabic and attributed to the region of northern Mesopotamia.
The calligraphic pages, having received less attention in scholarship than its figural counterparts, are meticulously executed and have a strong visual impact on the viewer. Not only does one notice a variety of calligraphic forms being utilized, the written recipes themselves are presented in the form of intricate patterns. Careful attention has been paid to visual rhythm and flow within these pages, many times compromising the content of the text. The discussion in this paper will attempt to highlight the calligraphic pages and patterns of the Kitab al-Diryaq with the aim of rethinking and re-evaluating the purely ‘scientific’ nature of such a manuscript.
Northern Mesopotamia (present-day north-western Iraq, north-eastern Syria and south-eastern Turkey), from the late eleventh to the early thirteenth centuries was governed by a series of minor Turkish dynasties. Islam was the religion of the governing bodies, but Christianity prevailed amongst the inhabitants. The period exhibits a revival (or survival) of Late Antique intellectual ideas and visual culture, most conspicuously seen in numismatics and architecture that deploy classical Greek and Roman iconography. The same period also witnesses an unprecedented surge in magical objects. The multilingual milieu of northern Mesopotamia, its proximity and exchanges with Byzantium and Latin Crusader cultures, the Late Antique surge of visuals, and the proliferation of magical objects, allow for a rethinking of the script patterns presented in the Kitab al-Diryaq. Acknowledging the multivalent nature of the visual and its interpretations, my research suggests that the Arabic script patterns employed in the Kitab al-Diryaq were perceived as prophylactic and magical.
|
Retribution and Repair of Norm Infringements in Qumran, Associations, and Pauline Congregations
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Thomas Kazen, Stockholm School of Theology
Similarities between the sectarian rule texts found in Qumran (D, S, and Sa) and Paul’s instructions to his groups of Christ-believers were noticed early after the discovery of the Dead Sea Scrolls. Research comparing the yahad with Greek and Roman voluntary associations began to be published in the 1960s. Since then, two major monographs have dealt with the latter relationship, those of Moshe Weinfeld in 1986 and Yonder Moynihan Gillihan in 2012, as well as a number of interesting articles. Much of the discussion has focused on questions of influence. During recent years, a wealth of inscriptions from voluntary associations has been published, and more is to come. In this paper I wish to revisit the issue by focusing specifically on how norm infringements are dealt with, or more precisely, analyse mechanisms of retribution and repair for trespasses. Comparing rule texts, association laws and Pauline reproaches, I will ask about possible effects and ultimate goals, given the diverse contexts these texts represent. The varying roles of hierarchy and honour in these contexts will be considered with the help of commitment (or costly) signalling theory, the valuable relationships hypothesis, and game theory (reputation).
|
Priests with a Disability: Examples from Israel and Greek-Roman Antiquity
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Edgar Kellenberger, Swiss Reformed Church
The cross-cultural idea that a priest has to be perfect is found in Israel, Greece and Rome. This perfection can be formulated in regards to the body, to the mind or the moral. Scholars proposed diverse explanations of this phenomenon. But several texts demonstrate a more complex and nuanced reality, resisting a simple systematization. This paper will present and discuss concrete examples from Israel, Qumran, Greek and Roman antiquity.
|
"Hesed and Emet Go before Your Face" (Ps 89:15): Faceless Impersonal Forces (Gerstenberger) or Concretisations of YHWH’s Own Activity?
Program Unit: Writings (including Psalms)
Edgar Kellenberger, Swiss Reformed Church
Ps 89:15 is one example of allegedly "abstract" nomina (also צדק ,דבר etc.) appearing like active persons. In 2016, Erhard Gerstenberger published a study by comparing such formulations to Sumerian texts. He understands these nomina as impersonal forces acting in some autonomous distance from YHWH. In a similar direction go earlier interpretations by exegetes speaking of a "genius" (e.g. Keel, Hossfeld/Zenger). In my paper, I will include examples with and without pronominal suffix (relating to YHWH), abstract nomina and concreter ones (anger, night, arm, mouth, etc.), in order to gain a more complete and nuanced understanding.
|
The Relenting of God in the Book of Jonah
Program Unit: Prophets
Marian Kelsey, University of St. Andrews
The book of Jonah uses inner-biblical allusion to present and explore the tension between the declaration of a relenting God and multiple biblical accounts in which God did not relent. In doing so, the book emphasises the freedom of God to relent or not, bound by neither human understanding of his character nor past behaviour. Without ever mentioning Jerusalem, various hints in the text suggest that the fate of this city is what motivated the book’s exploration of divine freedom and its implications, for good and ill. While Jonah alone addresses the fate of Jerusalem only obliquely, once the book is embedded among the Twelve, the issue is more pronounced. The near-juxtaposition of Jonah and Nahum encourages an understanding of ‘relenting’ as deferral, rather than rescission, of punishment. Other texts among the Twelve seem to intimate an analogy between Nineveh and Jerusalem. Thus, it is suggested that the destruction of one city should have served as a warning to the other that deferred punishment will eventually be enacted. Finally, Jonah’s integration into the Twelve places the book within a broader historical scheme. In the presentation of the Twelve, Nineveh is spared but then destroyed utterly, alongside an account of the deferral of punishment, later destruction then ultimate restoration of Jerusalem. This brings into explicit statement the hope for Jerusalem that is only subtly implied in Jonah.
|
Interpreting “Thorn in The Flesh, Angel of Satan” in 2 Cor 12:7 through an Original Exegetical Analysis Of Its Context
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Jack Khalil, University of Balamand
This verse has been the subject of many heated exegetical debates aimed at shedding light on its elusive meaning. This study does not intend to offer a new interpretation of the meaning of “thorn in the flesh, angel of Satan”; it rather focuses on the text itself, by examining exegetically the various ideas and words communicated in it, paying special attention to grammatical forms, linguistic remarks, syntactic analysis (including the punctuation of some sentences), and textual criticism. It also assumes that the interpretation of 2Cor 12:7 has to occur within the context of St. Paul’s thought sequence, especially when it reaches its apex in the last verses of this unit, where the key words found throughout the entire context are used extensively (weakness, strength, boasting). The study provides original and persuasive arguments in favor of the old interpretation, the one adopted by St John Chrysostom, who considered the “pseudo-apostle” opponents of St Paul as the concrete referent in the metaphor “thorn in the flesh”.
|
New Arguments in Favor of the Similar Understanding of Ἀρχή and Λόγος in 1 John 1:1 and in the Prologue of the Gospel according to John
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Jack Khalil, University of Balamand
The expression ἀπ ̓ ἀρχῆς appears in the first epistle of John with two temporal meanings: the first connotes eternity, corresponding to the meaning of ἀρχή in the prologue of the Gospel according to John, while the second points to the beginning of the Incarnate- Logos’ activity. In regards to 1Jn 1:1, the decision becomes much more challenging. The ambivalence is more pronounced due to the divergence of positions in the commentaries; some scholars support the first interpretation, others argue for the second, let alone the greater differentiation within the second interpretation that places the ἀρχή within a time frame.
The same ambivalence shadows the syntagm Λόγος τῆς ζωής, “Word of life”. How are we to interpret the Logos here? Is it a personal Logos referring to the Son of God as in the prologue of the Gospel (John 1:1), or does it refer to the message of Jesus Christ and the proclamation of the Gospel?
This study examines the prologue of 1john, and provides fresh arguments, based on a chiastic structure of the sentences and some grammatical remarks, in favor of a similar understanding of the expressions ἀρχή and Λὀγος, both in the First Epistle of John and the prologue of the Gospel according to John.
|
Land Issues in Isaiah and Micah: A Tribal Perspective
Program Unit: Prophets and Prophecy (EABS)
K. Lallawmzuala, Aizawl Theological College
This paper is an attempt to illuminate further Isaiah 5:8-10 & Micah 2:1-3 from a tribal perspective. It is generally recognized that the issue of land was of fundamental concern to the eighth-century prophets. However, an adequate explanation has never been given of the values and ethos of the prophets as reflected in their critique of the process of accumulation of land in the hands of a few rich people. Traditional interpretation of the texts has been dominated by questions relating to land tenure, land rights or land ownership patterns. Scholars usually connect the issue of land during the eighth century BCE with the economic issue of the widening gap between the rich and the poor. The commitment of the prophets to fight against land grabbing and the growth of large estates is also largely believed to have been motivated by their concern for the protection of the increasingly impoverished peasants. Though we cannot deny that the economic issue is profoundly associated with the issue of land the concerns of the prophets appear to be much more than economic. In light of the experiences of the tribal people in India, whose socio-cultural values, traditions and customs have been and are being destroyed in the context of alienation and displacement from their lands, some fundamental questions concerning issues encountered by the victims of land acquisition in the eighth century Judah have been raised. A new light has been thrown to reveal that land issues during the time of Isaiah and Micah can be connected not only with economic issue, but also with social, cultural and religious issues of the alienated people. The prophets could also largely be seen as the defenders of the traditional communitarian ethos and values which were being eroded during this time.
|
Foretold Ministry in First Clement
Program Unit: Apostolic Fathers and Related Early Christian Literature
Taras Khomych, Liverpool Hope University
The aim of this presentation is to explain an ambiguity embedded in key passages dealing with ministry in an early Christian epistle known as First Clement. This first century letter bears witness to the origins of Christian reflection on Church offices. Although this writing does not offer any systematic exposition of this topic, it presents ministry in an original manner, combining imagery and phraseology of the Septuagint with early Christian traditions and other ancient Greek and Roman sources. The author elaborates his ideas in the context of his reflections on the communal life, emphasizing the importance of harmony and order. Interpretation of the relevant passages dealing with ministry, however, is often hampered by ambiguities of the Greek text. This contribution seeks to explain one of the ambiguities in light of the letter’s internal evidence, which has not been sufficiently considered before. It will be argued that First Clement sets up concrete principles for the building of a viable Christian community, emphasising the continuity between Israel and ekklesia as the people of God and community of salvation.
|
Scriptural Interpretation in the Syriac Apocalypse of Baruch
Program Unit: Bible and Syriac Studies in Context
Daewoong Kim, Chongshin Theological Seminary
In my presentation I will investigate scriptural interpretation in 2 Baruch. I will show that 2 Baruch draws on the biblical sapiential tradition (Job and Qoheleth) and integrates it with the Jewish apocalyptical ideas (Daniel). I will explore linguistic components in 2 Baruch that find their home in biblical wisdom and in Daniel, as well as the ideological kinship. Both Baruch and Job are deeply involved with the human quest for wisdom. Like Job, Baruch has a series of conversations with God. Baruch is modeled after Job in that they share a formidable problem in preserving the reliance on the traditional wisdom. Particularly, Job’s theological skepticism of the familiar wisdom doctrine throbs beneath the text of Baruch’s disputation about divine justice in 2 Baruch 14. Like Job claiming his suffering to be innocent, Baruch is unwilling to accept the principle of God’s retribution about the Babylonian sacking of Zion. If Job resists it on a personal level, Baruch resists it on a social level. 2 Baruch describes God as quite different from the deity whom Job and Qoheleth envision. God offers Baruch a way out of Baruch’s theological impasse. Most fascinatingly, the resurrection scene in 2 Baruch 49-51 seems to forge an apocalyptic response to Qoheleth’s thought of death. While Qoheleth says that the righteous people’s “work,” “knowledge,” and “wisdom” are all forgotten (Qoh 9:10), Baruch’s God opposed view of them (2 Bar. 50:4, 51:7). Two different kinds of “many” in terms of the Torah in Daniel 11:33-34 is interpreted in 2 Bar. 14 and 41, where they either withdraw from or cling to the Torah. The portrayal of the two-stage glorification of the righteous group in 2 Baruch appears to be a revisionary exegesis of the eschatological bliss of maskilim in Daniel 12.
|
The Satirical Portraiture of Imperialism in Daniel 4 and Its Nachleben in Early Judaism
Program Unit: Bible and Empire
Daewoong Kim, Chongshin Theological Seminary
My presentation deals with the afterlife of Daniel 4, focusing on how the satirical portraiture of imperialism as animalizing human society in Daniel 4 shapes its exegetical stream in Pseudo-Philo (135 B.C.E. – 70 A.D.) and 3 Baruch. Both Daniel 4 and its literary reflexes conceptualize in common the hierarchical imperial Babel as the great social evil that degrades humankind. The authors of Daniel 4 and Pseudo-Philo envision God as hostile to the imperial social system that defies the sovereignty of God, regarding the theriomorphic metamorphosis as God’s judgment on rebels (pace H. Jacobson, A Commentary on Pseudo-Philo’s Liber Antiquitatum Biblicarum, 1996). The dehumanized form of the imperial society in Daniel 4 finds a closer analogy in 3 Baruch (1st to 2nd centuries A.D.). Transferring the context of Daniel 1 and 9 to the fabric of 3 Baruch, Baruch’s heavenly journey alludes to the motif of bestial transformation in Daniel 4. In Daniel 4 the subordinates of Nebuchadnezzar are depicted as the birds and the wild beasts in the monarch’s dream vision. Nebuchadnezzar, the head of their society, turns out to be a monstrous animal-hybrid more detestable than the natural animal-forms of the subordinates. Similarly, the animalized congregation of the first heaven in 3 Baruch refers to the subjugated workers (“the faces of oxen,” “the horns of stags,” “the feet of goats,” and “the haunches of lamb” [3 Bar. 2:3]) under the rule of their political leaders at Babel (“dogs” and “stags” [3 Bar. 3:3]). They are not simply the “result of an editorial elaboration” (pace A. Kulik, 3 Baruch, 2010) but also two separate groups that are divided into governing class and exploited class. Unlike the lower group in the first heaven, the upper group in the second heaven is identified as planners and controllers of the tower construction.
|
The Nachleben of Daniel 4 in Pseudo-Philo and the Greek Apocalypse of Baruch
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
Daewoong Kim, Chongshin Theological Seminary
My essay deals with the afterlife of Daniel 4, focusing on how the satirical portrayal of imperialism as animalizing human society in Daniel 4 shapes its exegetical stream in Pseudo-Philo (135 B.C.E. – 70 A.D.) and 3 Baruch. Both Daniel 4 and its literary reflexes conceptualize in common the hierarchical imperial Babel as the great social evil that degrades humankind. The authors of Daniel 4 and Pseudo-Philo envision God as hostile to the imperial social system that defies the sovereignty of God, regarding the theriomorphic metamorphosis as God’s judgment on rebels (pace H. Jacobson, A Commentary on Pseudo-Philo’s Liber Antiquitatum Biblicarum, 1996). The dehumanized form of the imperial society in Daniel 4 finds a closer analogy in 3 Baruch (1st to 2nd centuries A.D.). Transferring the context of Daniel 1 and 9 to the fabric of 3 Baruch, Baruch’s heavenly journey alludes to the motif of bestial transformation in Daniel 4. In Daniel 4 the subordinates of Nebuchadnezzar are depicted as the birds and the wild beasts in the monarch’s dream vision. Nebuchadnezzar, the head of their society, turns out to be a monstrous animal-hybrid more detestable than the natural animal-forms of the subordinates. Similarly, the animalized congregation of the first heaven in 3 Baruch refers to the subjugated workers (“the faces of oxen,” “the horns of stags,” “the feet of goats,” and “the haunches of lamb” [3 Bar. 2:3]) under the rule of their political leaders at Babel (“dogs” and “stags” [3 Bar. 3:3]). They are not simply the “result of an editorial elaboration” (pace A. Kulik, 3 Baruch, 2010) but also two separate groups that are divided into governing class and exploited class. Unlike the lower group in the first heaven, the upper group in the second heaven is identified as planners and controllers of the tower construction.
|
The "Way" Motif in the Gospel of John: The Reception and Transformation of the Jewish Wisdom Traditions
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Moon Geoung, KIM, Presbyterian Univ. and Theological Seminary(Seoul)
"I am the way(ἐγώ εἰμι ἡ ὁδὸς Jn. 14:6a)" is the one of the proclamations that Jesus reveals himself to his disciples and to the world(6:35,41,48,51; 8:12; 10:7,9; 11:11,14; 11:25; 15:1,5 etc.). The 'way' motif seems to be derived from the Old Testament, especially from Jewish wisdom literature (ὁδὸς τῆς ζωῆς καὶ ὁδὸς τοῦ θανάτου Jer. 21:8; ὁδὸς δικαίων καὶ ὁδὸς ἀσεβῶν Ps. 1:6; ὁδοὶ δικαιοσύνης ὁδοὶ δὲ μνησικάκων Prov. 12:28; δύο τρίβοι Sir. 2:12; 3:13 etc.). In the Qumran document and the Sermon on the Mount in the Synoptic Gospels etc., appears the 'way' motif in a relatively fixed, stereotyped form.(δύο τρίβοι, ὁ ὁδὸς κυρίου Matt. 3:3 parallels etc.) Basically, this motif can be related to the doctrine of retribution, the conception of the fixed connection between action and consequence and the ontological dualistic (or paired) popular philosophy. On the contrary, the self-revelation, "I am the way” in the John 14:4-6 is unique (cf. Joh. 1:23 ὁ ὁδὸς κυρίου). In this short paper, I will examine the reception - and the transformation process of the 'Way' motif.
|
Queering Jesus in the Gospel of John
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Moona Kinnunen, University of Helsinki
In my dissertation I will study the gender of Jesus in the Gospel of John. I do this from a queer theoretical point of view. Queer theory pursues to deconstruct the norms about sex, gender, and sexuality. It resists all fixed categories, including the identity categories that are attached to Jesus. Queer studies take a step forward from gender theoretical biblical studies, yet focusing on the important question about Jesus’ persona. Queer studies challenge previous Jesus studies by including the questions about sex, gender, and sexuality – but without stating anything fixed or certain. // Jesus’ persona still fascinates people, and as an answer, queer studies offer new theoretical tools and new perspectives. For example, Jesus’ masculinity and femininity, sexuality and relationships, are feasible research topics. The Gospel of John is intriguing source material for queer interpretations because it includes unique figures (such as Lazarus and beloved disciple), and unique textual forms (the prologue). Yet my main focus is on Jesus’ gender. By approaching the Gospel of John from queer theoretical perspective, I argue that the godliness of Jesus, and his relationship with God, has great effect on his persona, most of all, to his gender. Jesus is a man, but he is also a God – how can a human/God hybrid be a male per se? // Queer theory has no established methodology, thus, every scholar has to find out their own ways of using queer theoretical approaches in theology. My own approach is based on critical close reading and hermeneutical analysis. I will combine Jesus and queer theoretical perspectives in a new and re-imaginative way to produce new theological research, and to show in which ways Jesus could be queered in the Gospel of John. My queer theological research will produce multidimensional interpretations, where intersectional dimensions are tied together.
|
Solomon and Qitovras Redux: Regarding the Sources of Palea Interpretata
Program Unit: Slavonic Parabiblical Traditions (EABS)
Reuven Kiperwasser, FU Berlin
This paper aims to discuss the reception of a famous narrative concerning Solomon and Ashmedai, from bGittin 68b, in one of the significant early medieval works of Slavonic literature: Palea Interpretata, where it is entitled, “Solomon and Qitovras”. I wish to show that the story was brought to the Slavonic realm by transmitters acquainted with the language and figures from the Babylonian Talmud. Some elements of a post-talmudic understanding of the narrative from bGittin 68b are incorporated into the Palea’s version. This study proposes a comparative reading of the parallel stories and evokes discussion regarding the nature of the early reception of rabbinic aggadic plots into Slavonic literature.
|
The Vow to Kill Elisha: Function and Meaning in 2 Kgs 6:31-33
Program Unit: Israel in the Ancient Near East (EABS)
Itamar Kislev, University of Haifa
The siege of Samaria, which constitutes the longest story involving the Prophet Elisha (2 Kgs 6:24-7:20), has commanded a great deal of scholarly interest. The presentation concentrates on the king’s surprising threat to the life of Elisha son of Shaphat and the ensuing narrative developments (2 Kgs 6:31-33). In this episode, there is unparalleled tension between Elisha and the king of Israel. The function and meaning of this passage will be examined through the prism of other Elisha stories in the Book of Kings and their place in the book.
|
The Four Empires, the Laws of History, and Israel according to the Midrash
Program Unit: Bible and Empire
Menahem Kister, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
According to midrashic interpretations to Jacob's dream in Leviticus Rabbah and Pesiqta de-Rav Kahana, the “ascending and descending angels” in Jacob's dream (Gen 28:12) are the angels of the four empires of Daniel (as interpreted by the rabbis). Jacob's dream becomes an opportunity for the rabbis of the second century CE to deal with the rules of history, with the deterministic sequence of the rising and falling of empires, with the empire of Israel expected in the eschatological future and with the ups-and-downs of people of Israel in the present. On the one hand, I will interpret these sources in light of biblical passages, and will consider them in light of Jewish sources of the Second Temple period. On the other hand I will try to demonstrate that these rabbinic texts are linked to non-Jewish Greek texts concerning the sequence of empires and the fate of Israel. These midrashim, as well as parallel passages in the midrashic corpus, express various attitudes towards the unique situation of the Jewish people, and reflect struggles between quietist and activist reaction to the subjugation of the people of Israel by the Gentiles.
|
Two Sides to the Story: Royal Inscriptions from Late Antique Yemen and Ethiopia
Program Unit: Ancient Near East
Sigrid K. Kjaer, University of Texas at Austin
This presentation will discuss the epigraphs erected by the two sides in the military clashes that took place in Yemen circa 525 CE. In doing so, it will explore the impetus behind the texts and analyze their polemicizing content as a reflection of their cultural and religious context. Furthermore, I argue that their material circumstances were an attempt to mirror their social context and—in some cases—attempt to shape the outcome of the war as it progressed.
The generals of the Jewish king, known in later sources as Joseph dhu Nuwas, left several vast inscriptions incised on rock describing their victories over and destruction of the Christian inhabitants in the area of Najran. These texts are polemical in nature and have an air of expediency since they were created on the road towards the next military encounter and recorded events which had just transpired. And with good reason as the Yemenis a year later lost the war, and their territory was annexed by the Ethiopians. The Yemeni inscriptions describe a mid-point in the war in which their authors thought they were winning. Their advances were quickly quashed by the Ethiopians, and the great epigraphs are a testament to the initial optimism on the Yemeni side. The inscriptions were found in situ in the 20th century. The Ethiopian king Kaleb had a long elaborate inscription written describing the ultimate victory over the fearsome heathens across the sea. It employs biblical phrases and terminology, casting the war, and victory, in a distinctly religious light. This epigraph is currently in the treasury of the church of our lady Mary of Zion in Aksum, Ethiopia, but exactly how it ended up there is somewhat unclear.
|
Christian Dead Sea Scrolls? The Post-2002 Fragments as Modern Protestant Relics
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Ludvik A. Kjeldsberg, University i Agder
The use of the Post-2002 Dead Sea Scrolls-like fragments for evangelistic purposes is an essential, but often neglected part of their story. Mainly on the basis of Stuart Hall’s social constructionist theory of representation, I will investigate how these fragments were utilized in exhibitions organized by Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary, Azusa Pacific University, Lanier Theological Library, and the Museum of the Bible.
|
Imitating the Sower: Figurative Appropriation of Jesus’s Parable of the Sower in the Infancy Gospel of Thomas and the Recognitions of Pseudo-Clement
Program Unit: Biblical Interpretation in Early Christianity
Jarrett Knight, Emory University
Abstract: The Infancy Gospel of Thomas 12:1-4 and the Recognitions of Pseudo-Clement 3:1-14 both present complex figural interpretations of the parable of the sower. Unlike many texts often considered in biblical reception history, however, these writings provide at most minimal explicit interpretations of their biblical intertexts, instead relying on implicit narrative cues in the form of their diction, settings, dialogue, and plot structure to establish intertextual connections. Careful attention to these cues shows that both of these texts offer rich interpretations of the parable of the sower that also function implicitly as exhortations to their hearers. Specifically, the Infancy Gospel of Thomas connects the fruit-bearing seed in the Lukan parable of the sower to almsgiving through its diction and plot structure and by establishing an intertextual link between the parable and Jesus’s feeding of the five thousand in Luke 9. In doing so, it implicitly exhorts readers to an imitatio Christi by feeding the poor and reconfigures the context in which readers will hear the parable in Luke 8. The Recognitions of Pseudo-Clement, on the other hand, uses an alternation between private and public settings and corresponding contrasts between Peter’s private and public speech along with the content of Peter’s speech (which explicitly cites the parable of the sower) as a paradigm for preachers, showing them the different ways they are to behave towards different kinds of hearers of the word in different settings, and supplying them with a reason why: the needs of the different types of souls who will hear the word. The complexity present in such narrative texts, which superficially appear simplistic, suggests an abundance of little-considered patristic interpretation waiting to be probed.
|
Intertwining Law and Narrative: Structural Observations in the Covenant Code and Their Legal Relevance
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Law
Amrei Koch, Martin Luther University Halle-Wittenberg
The Covenant Code in Ex 22,20–23,33 is presented as a part of Israel’s foundational narrative. Regarding this contextualization, several literary strategies serve to integrate the legal material of the Covenant Code into the Pentateuchal narrative. Here in particular narratological devices function as connecting elements between the Covenant Code and the narrative world of the Pentateuch. Moreover, the same word inventory and similar semantic fields are applied to the legal and the narrative passages, rising altogether an intratextual or, seen historically, even an intertextual relationship between the two genres. The linkages between the laws of the Covenant Code, its frameworks, and the closer and wider narrative context not only intertwine the legal and the narrative texts, but also influence the authority of the given laws, creating a link between “Nomos and Narrative”, the interaction of which was famously described by Robert M. Cover (1983): Revealing the narrative dimension of law enables us to see the law’s guiding principles inasmuch as the laws acquire a specified or even new meaning within their relation to other texts. Therefore, the intertwinement of law and narrative is also relevant from a legal perspective and allows comprehending the narrative as an ideological framework into which the law is set and by which it receives authority and normativity. My paper aims at a detailed description of the interfaces and intertwinements between the Covenant Code and its Pentateuchal narrative context and focuses to figure out the value of these connections for the normative character of the laws.
|
Intangible Imagery: Conceptualizing Fictive Inscribed Artifacts in Ancient Near Eastern Literatures and in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible (EABS)
Sarah Koehler, Friedrich-Schiller-Universität Jena
In context of Ancient Near Eastern literatures, there are a few instances of narrated inscribed artifacts intended for eternal preservation. These artifacts are to a greater or lesser extent of fictive character, frequently created by gods. The aim of the present talk is to investigate how these artifacts along with their inscriptions are conceptualized in different cultural environments, based primarily on Sumerian, Akkadian as well as Hebrew texts. In literate cultures, when fictive scriptures are thematized as part of a narrative, the description of their materiality and production draws on real models comparable to the fictive artifact. However, in case eternal accessibility or divine creation should find expression, the description tends to apply metaphoric language. Beyond the artifacts also tools used for their production might obtain inconceivable or unrealistic material properties. The scope of the imagery these texts make use of diverge according to the significant differences in document production perceptible in the Ancient Near East. Furthermore, the concepts of these adapted metaphors are culture-specific and thus only restrictedly transferable. Beyond presenting the evidence from the literary inheritance of different eras, similarities and differences of culture-specific conceptualization of this imagery will be discussed. Furthermore, a historical development of conceptual mapping of the presented network of metaphors within the Ancient Near Eastern culture area will be addressed. The analysis of some passages from Sumerian hymnic compositions, the Akkadian Gilgamesh epic as well as Jer 17:1 and Job 19:23-23 will serve as starting point for the investigation.
|
Downfall Description: Doomed Edom in Ezekiel’s Speech
Program Unit: Prophecy and Foreign Nations (EABS)
Sarah Koehler, Friedrich-Schiller-Universität Jena
The oracles concerning foreign nations are a constitutive element of Old Testament prophetic literature. In the book of Ezekiel, they can be found in the chapters 25-32. The first four oracles in chapter 25 are against the Ammonites, Moab, Edom and the Philistines.
The aim of this case study is to investigate how the oracles in Ezek 25:12-14 and in Ezek 35:1-14 are related to each other as well as the character of the language, which is used to described Edom’s coming destruction.
Furthermore, the function of Ezek 25:12-14 as one of the opening oracles in the complex of 25-32 just as Ezek 35 as introduction for Israel’s salvations shall be analyzed. Beyond presenting the connections between these two texts, the topic of Edom’s downfall will be compared with the oracle in Jer 49:7-22 MT. Focusing on similarities and differences in the language, which is used to predict Edom’s destruction, conclusions about their particular contextual functions will be drawn.
|
Déjà Vu: Shirley Kaufman’s Biblical Poetry
Program Unit: Intersections: A Forum for Research on Ancient Israel, Hebrew Bible, and Cognate Topics (EABS)
Anat Koplowitz-Breier, Bar-Ilan University
In her article “Roots in the Air,” American-Israeli poet Shirley Kaufman (1923–2016)
observes:" I think in a sense all art is a coming to terms with the past. The literary
imagination feeds on many sources. … What do we do with the Bible as literature?"
Reading Kaufman’s poetry reveals that in “coming to terms with the past” she frequently
means “coming to terms with the Bible.” Marge Piercy notes that "Midrash is the
entrance into the canon through the back door. In the patriarchal world of the texts,
we miss the voices and ideas of women. So we put them back in." However, while the
early midrashists regard Scripture as a sacred text and its interpretation a form of
divine revelation, modern poets use the biblical texts as a springboard for their own
ideas. Kaufman’s reading of biblical texts can be viewed as belonging to the midrashic-
poetry tradition being established by Jewish-American women as part of the Jewish
feminist wave.
Following what Adrienne Rich named "re-visioning" and Alicia Ostriker's called an
act of "invading past tradition in order to change it," Kaufman rewrite biblical women
empowering them by making use of her/their own words. In this paper I would like to
explore Kaufman’s approach to reading the Bible as an elaboration (on) its feminine
characters via three devices: a) dramatic monologues, in which the woman speaks for
herself b) description of a specific circumstance that gives us a glimpse into the
character’s thoughts and feelings; and c) interweaving the biblical context with
contemporary reality. By analyzing Kaufman’s biblical poetry, I will illustrate how she
adds psychological and political interpretation to the biblical women. Hence, her
reading of the Bible from a contemporary point of view, brings the biblical women
into the present world, giving them a fresh new meaning.
|
The Linguistic Analysis of the Names and Toponyms in the Slavic Apocalypse of Abraham
Program Unit: Slavonic Apocrypha (EABS)
Milan Kostresevic, Universität Bern - Université de Berne
The linguistic analysis of the text of the Slavic Apocalypse of Abraham, which this paper will discuss, is intended to show that an original Aramaic-colored Hebrew text can not be dismissed as the basis for all translations of ApcAbr. Both in the assumption of proper names and toponyms as well as in the reproduction of various syntactic and semantic constructions, the initial hypothesis of a Hebrew or Aramaic original text can, therefore, be regarded as confirmed. Based on a new comprehensive text edition, many new insights into ApcAbr may well be gained - not only concerning their genesis and tradition but also in terms of their theological-philosophical intention, their author milieu, and their „Sitz im Leben“. The linguistic analysis of the Slavic Apocalypse of Abraham will focus primarily on the personal names (Terah, Nahor), names of Gods and Angels (Marumath, Nachon) as well as the Toponyms (Fandana).
|
The Understanding of the Eucharist in the Acta Johannis. (ActJoh 85.109)
Program Unit: Early Christianity (EABS)
Milan Kostresevic, Universität Bern - Université de Berne
This paper will discuss the Understanding of the Eucharist in the Acta Johannis. In the Acta Johannis is a clear talk of a Eucharistic celebration in two places and twice the question arises as to whether we are dealing with Eucharistic allusions. Once this is the case with a banquet, another time with a series dance. We can compare the Eucharistic material in the Acta Johannis with the findings of the Didache and Justinus Apologia, but we have only to perceive them as examples of practice in the second century and not as a line of development. The clear ambiguity of the Eucharistic understanding in Acta Johannis has come to the fore with two questions. On the one hand, the relationship between doxology and anamnesis: when and how was the celebration of Jesus' bestowal dedication to death joined with the now generally accepted, initially eschatological focus of the celebration? On the other hand, has it come to the connection between bread and wine: while the wine was originally interpreted as an indication of the completed Kingdom of God? Finally, we will try to answer the following questions: What purpose and meaning does a Eucharistic Mark have in both Acta Johannis and how do these passages help to understand the whole philosophical and spiritual context of this church?
|
In-Group and Out-Group in Daniel 1: An Investigation into Food and Identity
Program Unit: Place, Space, and Identity in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Manitza Kotzé, North-West University (South Africa)
Food as a marker of identity is often used within the religious sphere. Throughout the Hebrew Bible, this distinction between Us and Them is emphasised, based on the presumed superiority of the Israelite religion. A shift can then also be found between food as a marker of identity from the Hebrew Bible, where the dietary laws and regulations marked identity in terms of that which we don’t eat, to marking identity, and again, perceived superiority by what we do eat, over and against those who remain trapped by what is seen to be legalistic systems and superstition in the early Christian Church. Dietary practices can institute powerful symbolic separations where populations are religiously intertwined, such as in the final pre-Christian centuries, where religious identity and its effects were issues Judean writers grappled with. This contribution will especially look at the figure of Daniel, who actively maintained the distinction established by God between Israel and the nations, even as he reached the uppermost status of gentile society. How food is used to establish identity in Daniel 1 as a marker of division within Israelite identity will be investigated; the argument could be made that the refusal of Daniel and his friends to eat of the royal table was not only because of the Jewish food laws. There is no indication that the others, who did eat the King’s foodstuff, were breaking dietary laws, so perhaps an in-group and out-group dynamic is rather at play. This contribution will investigate how the use of food to establish identity in Daniel 1 is done as a way setting apart Our identity against Their identity, and from there make some ethical and theological conclusions.
|
Neo-Assyrian Visual and Written Sources and Impalement Imagery in Lamentations 5:12
Program Unit: Iconography and Biblical Studies (EABS)
Gideon Kotzé, North-West University (South Africa)
In Classical Hebrew literature, the verb TLH signifies different modes of suspension in cases where humans are the objects that are “hanged”. It can refer to strangulation by hanging, impalement, and crucifixion. The use of the verb in Lamentations 5:12, where officials are said to have been “hanged by their hands” (BYDM NTLW), is interesting and scholars have debated its meaning in the passage without arriving at a consensus view. The renderings in ancient Greek, Syriac, and Aramaic translations seem to denote crucifixion, but scholars have been reluctant to follow this interpretation of the colon. Many regard the expression as a reference to either the strangulation of the officials, or a way of humiliating and torturing them. Iconography has even been enlisted to support the latter interpretation. Other scholars suggest that Lamentations 5:12 has the public exposure of officials’ corpses on stakes in view and, in this regard, they mention Neo-Assyrian sources that describe or depict the impalement of dead or living enemies. This line of interpretation of the Hebrew passage that interacts with a combination of Neo-Assyrian written and visual sources merits closer consideration. Accordingly, this paper examines a passage from the inscriptions of Sennacherib that documents the “hanging” of Ekron’s elite during the Assyrian king’s expedition to the Levant, as well as the visual representation of the impalement of three figures in the Lachish reliefs. The discussion of these sources suggests that “hanging” functioned as an image of impalement in the larger cultural environment in which Lamentations was penned. The phrase SRYM BYDM NTLW in Lamentations 5:12 can be taken as a Hebrew instance of such impalement imagery that expresses ideas that are comparable to those conveyed by the images in the Assyrian sources.
|
Images of Human and Divine Persecution in LXX Lamentations 3:52-66
Program Unit: Septuagint Studies
Gideon R Kotzé, North-West University (South Africa)
One of the striking motifs in ancient disaster literature is the responsibility of deities for catastrophes and the gods’ relationship to human enemies, who also play prominent roles in these calamities. Images of persecution are an important part of this motif in Lamentations 3:52-66. The speaker recounts how his enemies had persecuted him to a point from where it was not humanly possible to escape. He recalls how he implored YHWH not to ignore his cry for help and that the deity promptly arrived to save him. Having been saved from his seemingly hopeless plight, the speaker goes on to demand divine justice in the shape of retribution on his opponents. They should experience persecution and complete destruction by a righteously indignant YHWH. For an examination of persecution as a literary theme in early Jewish literature, it is imperative not only to investigate how it finds expression in the extant Hebrew version of Lamentations 3:52-66, but also in the Greek translation, which dates to the Second Temple period as well. Indeed, an analysis of how LXX Lamentations presents the content of 3:52-66 is a desideratum in research on the translation unit and the theme of persecution in early Jewish literature. In general, the Greek wording of LXX Lamentations 3:52-66 can be understood along similar lines as the Hebrew version. Nevertheless, the content of the verses, as represented by the Greek translation, does not match its representation in the Masoretic text in all details. This paper provides a closer look at the wording of LXX Lamentations 3:52-66. It presents analyses of variants and difficult readings in the Hebrew and Greek textual representatives with the aim of gaining a better understanding of how LXX Lamentations presents the passage’s theme of human and divine persecution.
|
The Earliest Printed Portions of the Greek New Testament
Program Unit: Textual Criticism: Manuscripts & Methods
Jan Krans, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam
To most, the printed Greek New Testament starts with the Complutensian Polyglot (1514-1520) and Erasmus' Novum Instrumentum (1516). However small portions of the Greek New Testament had been printed earlier. After a brief overview of these, the paper will focus on the most surprising specimen: an almost random part of the Gospels (John 1-6) found in Aldus Manutius' 1504 edition of Gregory Nazianzen's Carmina. The technical device Aldus developed will be explained, and placed within the intellectual history of the time.
|
Paul the Apostle: A Jew, a Roman, a Greek or … an Egyptian? An Inquiry in the Light of a Hypertextual Reading of The Letter to the Romans and of the Book of Wisdom
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Mateusz Krawczyk, Cardinal Stefan Wyszynski University in Warsaw
In my paper, I will present the hypothesis and preliminary conclusions of my research concerning hypertextual reworking of the Book of Wisdom in the Letter to the Romans. I will reflect on the cultural melting accomplished in the latter writing by Paul - a person coming from a Jewish milieu and writing in Greek in the Hellenistic world.
By analysing selected verses from the Letter to the Romans and their possibly hypotexts in the Book of Wisdom, I will argue that although Jew by blood and Greek by language, Paul was in various ways also an Egyptian in his thought.
This will lead me to conclusions concerning the Letter to the Romans as a place of early Christian cultural melting.
|
Can We Understand Romans without Wisdom? Reproaching for Transgressions of the Law and Boasting in God; The Wisdom of Hypertextuality
Program Unit: Comparative Methodology (EABS)
Mateusz Krawczyk, Cardinal Stefan Wyszynski University in Warsaw
The relation between the Book of Wisdom and the Letter to the Romans has been a subject of academic interest since the 18th c. In my paper, I will discuss the possibility of, what can be called 'a hypertextual reworking' of the Book of Wisdom in Rom 2.
In the first part of my paper, I will focus on the depiction of the method I am using in my research project concerning the hypertextuality between Wisdom and Romans (a grant from NCN Poland, 2017-2019). I will reflect on the question whether the comparison of the texts is justified and, if it is, on what basis.
Then, I will focus on the juxtaposition of the texts from the Letter to the Romans (esp. Rom 2:12.17.21-23) with two statements from the Book of Wisdom (Wis 2:12.16). I will discuss the similarities of the texts - both on the lexical and the ideological level.
I will reflect on the subjects to which the authors of both Wisdom and Romans refer. Who is reproaching whom for the transgressions of the law? Who is boasting that God is his Father in the Book of Wisdom? Are the subjects in Romans and Wisdom similar or do they differ greatly?
Is it a coincidence of motifs or do Paul employs the ideas from the Book of Wisdom on purpose? Does he follow blindly Pseud-Solomon's, Wisdom's author, thought or is he reworking it? And if it the allusion is intended, what are his reasons to include Wisdom thoughts in his writing?
Finally, I shall attempt to answer the question how the hypertextuality Wisdom-Romans may help the reader to understand Pauline thought. In what way does a comparative reading changes the reception of the Letter to the Romans? And, lastly, can we really understand Romans without Wisdom?
|
Rashi and His Interpretation on Isaiah 40ff
Program Unit: Biblical Reception History and Authority in the Middle Ages and Beyond (EABS)
Carola Krieg, Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz
Rashi and his interpretation on Isaiah 40ff. Solomon b. Isaac (1040-1105, northern France) known by his acronym 'Rashi' is the most widely Jewish Bible commentator and he also wrote commentaries to the Babylonian Talmud. Despite the fact that his comprehensive commentaries on the Bible are often taught side by side with the Tanach, they are not all translated in languages of our century. In the context of the Jewish-Christian Dialogue it is a necessary means of communication to learn from the different interpretations of the Bible according to the Jewish or Christian background. The Biblical commentaries of Rashi go back to the Middle Ages and the period of the Crusaders where Solomon b. Isaac suffered from the massacre of friends in 1096. It is the focus of my paper according to Rashi's commentary on Isaiah 40ff to find out his contemporary interpretation of the Bible. I will keep an eye on the question of his authority during his time and beyond. His own perspectives of Isaiah 40ff – he is the first one to declare that with Isaiah 40 starts a new section in the book of Isaiah, which is not connected to the subject of the previous chapters – are to be underlined besides pshat and drash. In his commentary on Isaiah 40ff French terms are being used, trying to explain the Hebrew expression to the French-speaking audience. Therefore according to his clarity of style the question may be raised concerning the interest of Rashi's commentaries of the Bible.
|
Regimes and Regime Changes in Samuel
Program Unit: Authority and Influence in Ancient Times
Paul Krueger, North-West University (South Africa)
This paper explores patterns of authority and leadership in the literary unit comprising the books of Samuel and the first two chapters of 1 Kings. This literary unit is usually outlined according to successive centres of power: Eli, Samuel, Saul, Dawid and Solomon.
Apart from each of these leaders being divinely appointed and installed according to the text, each of these leaders display a distinctive leadership style vertically, i.e. towards their subordinates. Most of them are also depicted first as subordinates themselves, using distinctive language and behaviour that suits their position relative to their superiors.
Even more interesting is the horizontal line of succession, i.e. the transition of power from one leader to the next. The biblical text gives evidence of a variety of power transitions. On a macro level the literary unit establishes a climactic pattern: From the smooth transition of power between Eli and Samuel, through the loyal resistence of David against Saul, to the open revolt in the Succession Narrative that culminates in the dramatic seizure of power by Solomon.
|
Paul, Gladiators, and Marginal Groups: A Response to Ekaterini Tsalampouni
Program Unit: Graeco-Roman Society and the New Testament (EABS)
Jennifer Krumm, Kirchliche Hochschule Wuppertal/Bethel
This paper is a response to Ekaterini Tsalampouni: “'We have become a spectacle to the world': Gladiators and Other Entertainers as Marginal Groups in the Graeco-Roman Cities".
|
David in Psalm 89: Individual or Collective?
Program Unit: Writings (including Psalms)
Marcel Krusche, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
The paper deals with a thesis which came up in biblical scholarship already in the 19th century and has been revived in the last decades by several scholars. They suggest that when Psalm 89 talks about David and the anointed one, it does not have in mind the individual Davidic king but the whole people of Israel as the heir of the dynastic promise to David. This thesis with its arguments is critically discussed. In Ps 89, there is in fact a close connection and a community of destiny between the Davidic king and the people, but there is no clear evidence within the psalm that suggests identifying the anointed one with the people. Rather, the psalm clearly distinguishes between the two. Therefore, Ps 89 can justifiably be interpreted as a royal psalm, lamenting the fate of the Davidic dynasty. The second part of the paper focuses on the textual and reception history of Ps 89. In three instances (vv. 4, 20, 51), there is a textual diversity regarding the grammatical number of the referenced character. Thus, in textual history, an individual and a collective interpretation of these verses exist in parallel. The reception of the psalm in Isa 55,3, in the Septuagint, in 4QPsx, and in the Targum of Psalms demonstrates the obvious tendency in reception history toward a collective interpretation or at least an amplification of the collective and national dimension of the psalm. Consequently, although the thesis of the collectivization of the Davidic promise in Ps 89 has no strong basis within the psalm, it is appropriate in so far as the collectivization is an observable phenomenon of reception.
|
Deleuze and Suspension-till-Death in Mark’s Gospel
Program Unit: Deconstructive Poetics (EABS)
Joel Kuhlin, Lunds Universitet
The Gospel of Mark has in the recent past been the object of influential studies “experimenting” with poststructural concept and theories. Arguably, the second gospel has proven particularly receptive to these sorts of approaches. In this paper, I will work within this ongoing “tradition” by exploring the Markan death of Jesus (with special focus on Mk. 15.1-47) and the Deleuzian notion of event as becoming and paradoxical element (mainly theorized in the Logic of Sense from 1969.)
There is something paradoxical and obscure about Jesus’ Markan death, and the cross/crucifixion (σταυροῦν/σταυρος́) constitute the main elements of this paradox. The happening of the crucifixion and the symbol of the cross (σταυροῦν/σταυρος́) should perhaps, as recent scholarship by G. Samuelsson suggests, be translated with “suspension till death.” According to ancient sources, Samuelsson argues, little can be said about the meaning of σταυροῦν other than an agonizing death by suspension, with the aid of some sort of pole. This is not a mere linguistic issue, seeing as the crucifixion works as suspension/suspense on many levels. The entire gospel can rightly be approached as rhetorically relating the figure of Jesus to this event of execution by suspension. σταυροῦν/σταυρος́ bleed into the narrative’s rhetorical structure and create obscurity and wound the narrative, which in a sense allows the death-event “to run through” Mk. without much hindrance.
Following Mark’s aforementioned track record with thinkers similar to Deleuze, as well a Deleuzian approach to the potentiality of other’s texts through what he calls “immaculate conception,” the coupling of the concept event and Jesus’ death is monstrous, in so far as it means experimenting with the Markan textual corpus in order to see what the body can do (as Spinoza would put it) and what new aspects of Jesus’ death are waiting to be actualized.
|
Job or Isaiah? What Does Paul Quote in Rom 11:35?
Program Unit: Septuagint Studies
Katja Kujanpää, University of Helsinki
In Rom 11:35 Paul presents a quotation the origin of which is unclear. The apparently unanimous scholarly view is that in some way or another it derives from Job 41:3. Yet the wording of Paul's quotation considerably differs from the reading of the Septuagint. Scholars have referred to targumim or to Hebraizing revision of the Greek text in order to explain the origin of Paul's wording. In this paper, I will examine the explanations provided and demonstrate that they are unsatisfactory. I will then offer a completely new solution to the textual problem. I will argue that it is probable that the quotation has nothing to do with Job 41:3 at all. Instead, Paul may be quoting a verse from Isaiah that differs from Ziegler's critical text but is included in numerous important and ancient manuscripts. The case is most interesting from the perspective of textual transmission: do Paul and the textual variants within Septuagint attest a verse in Isaiah that has been lost in the Masoretic text?
|
The Politics of Friendship: A Comparative Study of the Johannine Literature with the Graeco-Roman World
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Mark Kulikovsky, Macquarie University
In his works, Aristotle conceives of a friendship in three main ways – a friendship based on virtue, which he considers the highest form of friendship; a friendship based on utility and usefulness which he describes as a kind of political relationship; and a friendship based on pleasure. All of these normally take place between equals, for as Plato argued, friendship cannot occur between unequals; but Aristotle was more of a realist and acknowledges that most friendships are actually between unequals, with the basis of such friendships being a political agreement where each party gains something from the other in proportion to their worth and according to an agreement between them. Writers of literature in the first century world frequently made use of this type of friendship since they often needed patron support to live while writing and to then get their works heard and published.
In the Johannine literature one might expect the relationship between Jesus and his disciples, and between the Johannine author and his recipients, to be relationships between unequals and thus political friendships based on utility and usefulness, but in John’s Gospel Jesus described his disciples as his friends and the author of the Johannine Epistles describes his recipients as his children, his beloved, and his brothers. In light of the fact that other writers of literature in the first century depended heavily on political friendships, how are we to understand the relationship of the Johannine author to his readers? Is the Johannine author expressing a politics of friendship which is more egalitarian than that of the Graeco-Roman world? This paper examines these questions and argues that Christianity redefined the ‘politics of friendship’ and the relationships between unequals, allowing the Johannine author to speak frankly with the expectation that his words would be heard and accepted.
|
Two Horns like Those of a Lamb: Mimetic Rivalry in the Revelation of John
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
Mateusz Kusio, University of Oxford
In my paper, I would like to attempt to apply René Girard’s concept of mimetic rivalry to the way eschatological opponents–the dragon, the beasts and the great prostitute–are portrayed in the Revelation of John. My claim will be that John portrays all of these evil figures as mimicking the good ones, especially the Lamb. The dragon casts down a third of the stars with his tail (12:4b); this is exactly what has happened upon the blowing of the fourth trumpet in 8:12b. The beast of the land with “two horns like those of a lamb” (13:11) imitates the seven-horned Christological Lamb (5:7). The three tripartite descriptions of the great prostitute (17:8 bis, 11) the self-revelatory statements of God and Christ (1:8; 21:6; 22:13). Such points of contact and contrast have been noted in isolation by many commentators, spoken of in more detail by Rissi (1966) and Beasley-Murray (1974), and cogently surveyed by Lunceford (2009).
My aim will be to study these resemblances through the lens of Girard’s mimetic theory. It is fruitful to understand the apocalyptic confrontation as a competition for the divine status. In this framework, the evil actors in Revelation would try to usurp it for themselves and consequently mimic–always incompletely and thus unsuccessfully–the divine agents of the end-time conflict. The mimesis leads ultimately to the eschatological war.
My presentation would also point to the applicability of Girard’s theoretical insights to apocalyptic and patristic literature more generally. Imitation of the divine realm by the daemonic and the satanic is to be seen in texts such as 2 Thessalonians 2:3-12, Coptic Apocalypse of Elijah 3:3-15, Sibylline Oracles 3.63-74, and De Antichristo by Hippolytus of Rome. These texts show the eschatological antagonist as taking on the semblance of the Messiah, and as such can be illuminated by my Girardian reading of Revelation.
|
Social Background of the Chronicles' Translator
Program Unit: Hellenistic Greek Language and Linguistics
Un Sung Kwak, University of Oxford
Purpose:
This paper aims to examine the social background of the Chronicles’ translator. In the circumstance that direct and empirical evidence is very selective and fragmentary, the study of vocabulary would be one of the proper ways to disclose his social background. In addition, because there were many influential factors for the translator’s lexical choice, it seems very hard to find a certain vocabulary clarifying his social background. Nevertheless, this paper attempts to offer three linguistic clues – καταλοχισμός, ἐπιγονή, and συλλοχισμός –representing the social background of the Chronicles’ translator.
Methodology:
One helpful approach for studying the LXX vocabulary may be to understand the semantic value of the Greek word in the context of Greek culture and thought. In this regard, by examining Zenon, Fayum, Oxyrhynchus and Tebtunis papyri, which were found in Egypt and were assumed to be written from the third century BCE to the second century CE, the semantic value of the three Greek words are investigated.
|
Job’s Body Parts, Sensibility, and Mind
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israel and in ANE Wisdom Literature (EABS)
JiSeong Kwon, Universität Zürich
In Job’s speeches, metaphors to expose the status of his mind and emotion are recurrently connected to his physical body parts that are significant instruments in expressing his unimaginable mental anguish (7:15a; 9:27-31; 14:21; 16:15). His broken body parts signify the foremost reason of his suffering, namely the fact that God’s enmity against Job is destroying human body (6:4, 9; 16:7; 30:19, 21; 7:12; 10:8-13, 16-17; 16:14; 9-11, 13). Because of this, Job’s sensibility malfunctions, and God’s presence is hidden from Job’s sight (9:11; 23:8-9; 16:20; 10:4; 19:25-27). Moreover, Job’s body metaphors are sometimes used for vindicating his innocence and are suggested as faithful witnesses in a court (9:17, 20; 16:8, 17-18; 19:20-24; 23:11; 27:4, 6; 31:35-36). This paper, therefore, will show how Job’s body parts and sensibility denote his cognitive dissonance and mental turmoil and will indicate that irrelevant to the physical suffering from the Adversary (2:7), Job is experiencing a sort of “somatic symptom disorder” (SSD) which means that persons focus on physical symptoms such as fatigue, fragility, and pain according to their particular cognitive schematic in terms of property loss, extreme anxiety, and the absence of God that lead them to chief anguish and agony in their daily lives. The inter-relationship between body and mind/spirit of Job plays a central role in resisting the retribution principle of Job’s friends and in doubting the justice of God.
|
The Book of Isaiah and Ezra
Program Unit: Prophets and Prophecy (EABS)
Antti Laato, Abo Akademi University
The aim of my paper is to discuss the ways in which some Isaianic texts have influenced the formation of the Book of Ezra (and Nehemiah) and what conclusions this evidence may give about the formation of the Books of Isaiah and Ezra-Nehemiah.
The Isainic texts which are discussed are related to expressions in Ezra 7-10:
1) Quakers (Isa 66:2,5) and Mourners (Isa 57:18, 61:2-3, 66:10).
2) Holy Seed (Isa 6:13 and passim).
3) Tent-Peg and Stone Wall (Isa 33:20, 54:2-3, 58:12).
4) Foundation of the procession (Isa 40:3, 62:10).
In order to avoid quite a naïve methodology, where reference is made to only some common words between both books, I have chosen to analyze only peculiar, even extraordinary expressions and metaphors which fulfill the criteria of Jeffrey Leonhard (JBL 127; 2008, 241-265): They share language which is rare or distinctive. In addition, taken together they signify accumulation of shared language between both books and often in similar literary and thematic contexts.
|
Grouping Manuscripts between Text and Context: The Coherence-Based Genealogical Method Facing to Elliott’s Application of Thoroughgoing Principles
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the New Testament, the Old Testament and the Qur’an (EABS)
Didier Lafleur, Institut de recherche et d’histoire des textes
For centuries, and especially since the mid 1970s with computer-aided textual criticism, biblical scholars have been plagued with issues about relating manuscripts one to each other. With that aim, analysis of textual features and variant readings have led critics to develop different methods for understanding the history of the texts of the Greek New Testament. Some recent developments, such as the Coherence-Based Genealogical Method, reveal new approaches in the way to solve the contamination phenomena which remains a main issue to whom wants to relate Greek New Testament manuscripts and publish a critical edition.
Amongst used terms in developing the aforementionned methods were « nations », « families », « text-types », and more recently « clusters » or « streams of transmission ». Taking support of the latest publications of the field, especially some new approaches to textual criticism, we will focus on the newly developed Coherence-Based Genealogical Method facing to Elliott’s Application of Thoroughgoing Principles (SupNT 137, 2010). On the basis of these different views, we will explore how textual criteria could be defined for the so-called « families » 1 and 13 and how the notion of « core-member » may be significant according to their text and context, chronological and historical.
|
What God Should Not Be, but Still Somehow Is? Cognitive Perspectives on "Theological Incorrectness"
Program Unit: What a God is Not – The Early History of Negative Theology (EABS)
Lauri Laine, Helsingin Yliopisto - Helsingfors Universitet
According to the Hebrew Bible (Ex. 20: 4-6; Deut. 5: 8-10) YHWH, the God of Israel, should be considered a non-anthropomorphic and aniconic divine character. However, there are a number of attestations of God that are clearly contrary to this theological presupposition. Indeed, God is very often described using clearly anthropomorphic imagery. Furthermore, the descriptions of the ancient Israelites in the Deuteronomistic History report continuous violations against these theological principals of aniconism (e.g. 1. Kings 16: 30-33). According to historical-critical research, these stories tell more about the time in which they were actually written (namely, at some point in the Second Temple period) than about the times wherein their narratives occur. Regardless, even if many of the details of these stories are not based on actual historical events, we may still infer from them information concerning Israelite religious practices outside the official Yahwistic cult. Thus, we can ask why it had been so difficult for ancient Israelites to consider divinity in the entirely non-anthropomorphic and aniconic way that the official Judaism of the Second Temple period wanted.
Cognitive Science of Religion approaches this question through an understanding of human cognition. Humans tend to conceptualize their own religious thinking in many ways that do not fit into any official or imperial theologies, leading to the many anomalies that appear in the religious practices of different times and cultures. Still, some of these anomalies have become so popular that they appear incorporated into the official theology.
|
Paul’s Reimagining of Living and Dying Well in the First Century CE: A Comparative Analysis Between Philippians and Egyptian Sources
Program Unit: Comparative Methodology (EABS)
Gregory E. Lamb, Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary
How does Paul present the concepts of living and dying well throughout Philippians? Does Paul’s presentation comport with or contradict other ancient conceptions, which Paul may have been familiar with as a Roman (Tarsian) citizen and former Pharisee? This essay compares/contrasts conceptions in Philippians with those of ancient Egyptian sources up to the first century CE—focusing primarily on the concept of ma‘at/Maat in The Book of the Dead (ca. 4266 BCE) and the Papyri Graecae Magicae originating in Egypt as early as the second century BCE.
I contend that Paul reimagines competing pagan conceptions in terms of Christian unity: unity with other believers who are “in Christ,” and unity with Christ in life and death (Phil 1:23, 27). In this sense, the physical death of a Christian is not something to be feared or eschewed, but rather is seen by Paul as kerdos (Phil 1:21b), the gain/fulfillment of being with Christ, which, for Paul, is certainly better than physical life. Thus, the process of dying is not bifurcated from human flourishing, but is the conduit through which Paul will be eternally with Christ.
Such an exploration fills at least two lacunae in Pauline scholarship. First, numerous studies have focused on analyses between Paul, Greco-Roman, and Jewish literature, but few (if any) have explored Paul through a primarily Egyptian lens. Second, no studies known to this author explore Paul’s conception of flourishing through Philippians specifically.
This essay consists of two main sections: (1) a brief discussion of the history of comparative methodology and a description of the methodology employed in this essay; and (2) the comparative analyses between the three texts. Additionally, this essay shall address questions regarding the viability of comparative analysis in biblical studies, the benefits of comparative analysis, and my criteria for the selection of sources.
|
Is Harmonization Natural and Inevitable? The Case of Mordecai’s Refusal to Kneel
Program Unit: Developing Exegetical Methods (EABS)
David A. Lambert, The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
It is certainly a commonplace among those interested in the growth, rewriting, and interpretation of the biblical text that the catalyst for such editorial practices often lies with discrepancies and literary tensions within the text itself. The complex compositional history of the Bible’s various corpora, the passage of time, and, of course, the potential for incoherence and ambiguity inherent in any writing practice leaves biblical texts are seen as demanding interpretation. Bestowing coherence comes to be seen as an essential component of textual transmission itself.
Such a scholarly perspective differs significantly from the sensibility evinced in historical-critical investigations, which privilege what is original, even if it must be reconstructed, over later layers of textual development. Nevertheless, in one respect, both parties agree. They share as a starting point what are perceived to be a common set of problems that are seen as intrinsic to the text itself.
I would like to suggest that the very identification of a text as a problem, not just its resolution, whether by means of harmonization or reconstruction, must be seen as the product of particular, historically-situated reading practices. In other words, attending to various sorts of gaps, ambiguities, and contradictions is not natural, inevitable, or universal but the product of certain cultures of reading. As an example, I will consider, with special attention to Addition C of LXX Esther, a famous interpretive crux: why Mordecai refuses to kneel before Haman in the book of Esther (3:1-6). I will show how the passage need not be seen as unclear but that the Septuagintal plus must mark it as such, before proposing an elucidation, on account of its particular, culturally-specific ethical platform.
|
Biblical Interpretation and the Linear Model of Emotional Processes
Program Unit: Emotions and the Biblical World (EABS)
David A. Lambert, The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
In a recent article, Monique Sheer has synthesized scholarship from various disciplines to emphasize the embodied, social, and historically-situated nature of emotions. She is especially aware of the particularity of Western views of emotion with their dichotomy between “inner” and “outer.” My concern is that the redefinition of “emotion” along these lines is that it remains overly wed to the particular historical discourses within which it was first conceptualized even as we strive for a universal, scientific basis for its definition.
In this respect, a renewed practice of philology may provide us with an additional opportunity for reconceptualization. Such a philological practice would begin by identifying the dominant hermeneutical frameworks at work in our textual interpretation. How does “emotion” as a category impact, for instance, the reading of the Hebrew Bible? It would then turn to a tradition of close, contextual reading to determine if alternatives to the dominant paradigm are possible. Do terms commonly identified as “emotions” in biblical Hebrew actually fit into this category, whether in its conventional sense or scientifically-modified sense? Finally, it could shed light on the origins of “emotion” as a dominant category. How does the history of biblical interpretation help reveal the nature and effect of the introduction of “emotion” as an interpretive framework?
In this paper, I will consider these questions by examining a common phenomenon in biblical interpretation, namely, the imposition of a linear model of emotional processes within, especially but not exclusively, biblical narrative, whereby a subject’s actions come to be analyzed according to a sequence of impetus, emotional reaction, and behavioral expression. In this context, even Sheer’s concept of “emotional practice” may not arrive at the full range of social, relational, and transactional dimensions present in terms such as “love,” “hate,” and “fear” in the biblical text.
|
The Semantic Representation of the Motion Verb (jrd) in Biblical Hebrew
Program Unit: Literary Features – Fact or Fiction (EABS)
Adriaan Lamprecht, North West University, South Africa
This paper focuses on the semantic representational format of the motion verb √dry (jrd) in Biblical Hebrew. In all existing lexicons, the semantic representation of √dry (jrd) does not provide a peculiar nuanced distinction between literal and non-literal spatial properties such as abstract concepts. The majority of lexicons reduces the semantic potential of the word (jrd) to a verbal indication within a topographical context. This traditional dictionary (literal) view becomes problematic when one takes cognizance of recent findings in cognitive linguistics which indicate that knowledge types are conceptual in nature and appear to constitute a vast structured body of relational information. Methodologically, this paper proposes a cognitive semantic perspective and argues that the verb √dry (jrd) does not represent a neatly packaged bundle of meaning, but serves as ‘point of access’ to vast repositories of knowledge relating to a particular concept or conceptual domain. An analysis of the 360 occurrences of (jrd) in the Hebrew Bible supports this argument by indicating that the domain of (jrd) appears to be protean in nature and too complex to assign the meaning only within a literal understanding of the word. The following representational format confirms this: (1) At least six meaningful basic-level conceptual categories are apparent, namely: Horizontal space, Vertical space, Structural space, Bodily space, Container space and Navigational space; (2)(jrd) may be further classified into change of location, change of position, change of posture and configuration; (3) The radial category of (jrd) is structured with respect to a prototype (movement and down-path), and the various category members are related to the prototype by convention.; (4) The organization in prototypical categories allows new senses for the linguistic unit (jrd) to be created; and (5) abstract concepts are systematically structured in terms of conceptual domains deriving from their experience.
|
Refreshing Rains or Devouring Lion? Towards a Methodology for Conceptual Coherence among Prophetic Metaphors
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible (EABS)
Mason Lancaster, Wheaton College (Illinois)
How do individual metaphors relate to one another within a network of metaphors? The question is especially pertinent when metaphors seem at best paradoxical, if not contradictory, to one another. Is there a way to discern a coherent network among metaphors that seem so different-even mutually exclusive? Might the contemporary identification of contradictory metaphors be the result of importing modern conceptions of coherence that are foreign to ancient texts?
This paper concerns a methodology for identifying conceptual coherence among potentially conflicting metaphors. The first half of this paper will put modern metaphor theory into conversation with the ancient aspective approach and various models of conceptual coherence.
The aspective approach has been identified in ancient Near Eastern contexts from Egyptian art, to Mesopotamian literary depictions of deities, legal corpora and medicinal texts, to Israelite wisdom literature. The aspective approach focuses on richly explaining the parts with less concern for how they fit together as a whole. This is the opposite of the perspectival approach (characteristic of most Western thought), in which the parts are subsumed to a coherent sense of the whole. Often the aspective approach can so emphasize the adequate presentation of the parts that it can strike modern readers as scattered and incoherent. An awareness of the aspective approach makes sense of the variety of metaphors in Hosea by reading the text according to its own methodological agenda, then identifying an inherent sense of coherence.
The second half of this paper applies this methodology to the metaphors presented in Hosea 5:8-6:6. This paper hopes to show that the metaphors presented in this pericope are not random or contradictory, but rather can be understood coherently according to ancient literary and conceptual conventions.
|
Studying the Ambrosian Gothic Palimpsests with the Help of Digital Technology
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
David Landau, Tampere University of Technology
The premises upon which this presentation is based is that studying palimpsests with one own eyes and with the help of a magnifying glass is the best way for deciphering the text. As the palimpsests included in this study are available for scholars for direct inspection, digital technology can a play a significant role in assisting with the preparation for examining the text. From my own experience of observing the parchments themselves I suggest that present digital photography does not capture all the details needed for the deciphering process. In this respect, the most important feature of digital technology is the ability to enlarge the text and in this way to imitate the role of a magnifying lens. Other tools are creating fonts, cutting lines of various photos taken in different wavelengths and placing them one beside the others, the use of layers, the possibility of marking letters with colors, the easiness of preparing a draft with markedup photos with indication of spots to be thoroughly examined, etc. By the time I observed the palimpsests at Milan, I already had a printout of a draft I prepared earlier where I could mark the new observations I made through examining the palimpsests with my own eyes. From earlier studies I have concluded that, as a rule of thumb, digital filters are too crude for this kind of study and therefore useless here.
|
Metaphorical Clusters in Isaiah
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible (EABS)
Francis Landy, University of Alberta
In Isaiah metaphors (I include simile as a subset of metaphor) characteristically come in chains, in which each member modifies, reverses, and shifts the ground of the previous one. Moreover, similes and metaphors are frequently doubled, so that the same simile is repeated, but with a subtly different meaning. A shift from metaphor to simile, in other words of tropological register, may insert an intimation of doubt, a slight displacement of the original identification. One wonders, for instance, why Ariel in 29.1 becomes “like Ariel” in 29.2. Moreover, chains of similes and metaphors link up with other chains of similes and metaphors throughout the book and beyond, to create the fabric that constitutes its poetic unity. Metaphors and similes operate at different linguistic levels. For instance, there are innumerable phonological equivalences and transformations. Sound and sense collaborate or contradict. Every metaphor, consequently, is at the centre of interminable intertextual relations, and cannot be interpreted through a simple mapping of domains, as in the cognitive model. In Isaiah, the difficulty is compounded by the transfer from divine to human speech, and by the command not to understand in the commissioning scene. Language, and poetry, translates the ineffable initial vision, and risks transgressing the divine command. At the same time, we are obliged to read, interpret, and be good critics. In this paper I will be examining some complex and intertextually rich metaphors and similes in Isaiah 32-33. In particular, I will be looking at the chain of similes in 32.2, the cluster of alliterative permutations in 32.14-15 and 19, and the elaborate description of Jerusalem in 33.20-24.
|
Remarkable Proportions in the Disposition of the Gospel of Matthew
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Friedrich G. Lang, Retired minister of the Lutheran Church of Wuerttemberg, Germany
In his commentary U. Luz has observed that the six antitheses of the Sermon on the Mount in Mt 5:21–48 are divided into two parts of the same length. The measure he applied was the number of letters and of words. In ancient Greek literature, however, the measure was a standard line of 15 syllables, the so-called stichos. Here in a first step it will be demonstrated how the stichos was used by the authors in disposing prose texts. Then by analysing the Gospel of Matthew in terms of stichoi, many remarkable proportions will be discovered, not only in the Sermon on the Mount, but also between Matthew’s five great sermons and in the disposition of the whole book. According to the stichometrical analysis, for instance, the size of the middle main part (9:35–18:35) is exactly a third of the Gospel of Matthew. The author apparently wanted to dispose the Good News in a good shape.
|
Observations on the Disposition of the Gospel of John
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Friedrich G. Lang, Retired minister of the Lutheran Church of Wuerttemberg, Germany
It has been discovered since long that the chapters John 1–6 and 7–12 (without 7:53–8:11, of course) are of about the same size. It seems that the author was aware of this and wanted to dispose his book in good proportions. In order to demonstrate this thesis the Gospel of John will be analysed by way of the stichometrical approach. First the stichos will be introduced, the ancient standard line of 15 syllables for measuring Greek prose, then it will be applied to John’s gospel, and finally the results will be interpreted. Some remarkable proportions lead to the conclusion that a single author elaborated the consistent disposition of the whole book.
|
The Vindication of YHWH in Ezekiel’s Oracles against the Nations.
Program Unit: Prophecy and Foreign Nations (EABS)
Andrew Langley, University of Oxford
This paper examines the theological purpose of the oracles against the nations in the book of Ezekiel and contends that the recognition formula, ‘they shall know that I am YHWH, is the vehicle for this theological purpose since it is fundamentally a statement of the vindication of YHWH. The paper offers an interpretation of the relationship between judgement on the nations and the restoration of Israel that sheds light on the position of the oracles in the book.
|
Keeping Jude Company: The Epistle of Jude and Its Shifting Relationships in the Early Reformation
Program Unit: Catholic Epistles
Beth Langstaff, Institut zur Erforschung des Urchristentums
The Epistle of Jude, in the sixteenth century, did not usually appear on its own; commentators, then as now, most often considered Jude in company: together with James, II Peter, or both Petrine Epistles; as one of the Catholic or Canonical Epistles; as part of a group of disputed or doubtful NT books; and in troubling association with apocryphal texts or traditions. The close parallels between Jude and II Peter led Erasmus, for one, to treat Jude together with the Petrine Epistles. The assumed dependence of Jude on II Peter was evaluated in various ways: as something close to plagiarism (Luther); as evidence of the Spirit’s inspiration (Esmer); and as use of the same material to make different points (Calvin). Jude’s Epistle was also linked with that of James, on two disparate grounds. If the identification of Jude as the “brother of James” were accepted, then Jude and James were bound together as blood relations. By contrast, James and Jude could be bracketed together by those (Luther, Tyndale) who called their apostolic authorship into question. During the Reformation, Jude generally kept its traditional place as one of the seven Catholic or Canonical Epistles, listed last after James, I & II Peter, and the three Johannine Epistles—although this traditional order was upset on more than one occasion (Council of Trent, Bullinger, Calvin). Some reformers, however, reassigned the Epistle of Jude to a third order of books (Karlstadt) or to a group of disputed or more doubtful books within the NT canon (Luther, Brenz, Oecolampadius). Finally, the Epistle of Jude came under fire for keeping company with extra-biblical or apocryphal texts and/or traditions (Jude 9 & 14-15). These shifting relationships help explain why the Epistle of Jude became the subject of debate and dispute in the early Reformation and beyond.
|
Luke-Acts and the LXX Version of Esther: A Study in Common Narrative Patterns
Program Unit: Allusions in the Gospels and Acts
Daniel Lanzinger, Rheinische Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität Bonn
As Richard Pervo notes in his “Profit with Delight”, the Greek version of Esther was “almost certainly known to the author of Acts” (119). There is, however, so far no exhaustive collocation of the parallels between these two texts. This paper seeks to fill this gap by examing the most important commonalities. These are: (1) the humiliation of the mighty and the exaltation of the humble, which serves as a leitmotif in both texts; (2) the fact that God’s activities are predominantly expressed by the characters rather than by the narrator; (3) the foreshadowing of events by a divine revelation; (4) the use of dramatic irony; and (5) the idea that the protagonists’ opponents are used as a device of providence against their will.
In conclusion, it is argued that although there is not sufficient evidence for allu-sions to specific passages in Esther, the similiarity in narrative patterns makes it probable that the book of Esther inspired Luke’s style of narrating.
|
Pablo de Santa María's Marginalia on the Apocalypse
Program Unit: The Bible in the Iberian World: Fundaments of a Religious Melting Pot (EABS)
Anthony John Lappin, Maynooth University
In this paper I will discuss Pablo de Santa Maria's commentary on the apocalypse, with a focus upon the characterization of Muhammad as a figure of the Antichrist that he had received from Nicholas of Lyra's commentary; rather than being a disagreement over Lyra's admittedly fragmentary interpretation, Santa María's discussion turned on a radically new understanding of Islam within a theology of history. I'll further explore the context for these views, as well as the shifting political situation that saw the publication of his annotations at the end of the fifteenth century accompanied by a highly-antisemitic "refutation". Finally, I will consider the re-evaluation of Pablo de Santa María's views at the beginning of the seventeenth century in the work of the Jesuit Benedictus Pererius, who attempted to undo the Lutheran understanding of the apocalypse in part by attacking – with Santa María's help — one of their sources.
|
1 Cor 14:33b without vv34-5: Internal Evidence and Its Six Possibilities
Program Unit: Textual Criticism: Manuscripts & Methods
Alesja Lavrinovica, -
The background of this topic is my in-depth research on 1 Cor 14:33b-34 with a focus on v 33b and its place in the oldest Greek and Latin manuscripts. In my study presented at the SBL International Meeting in Vienna in 2014, and in my article published in the NTS ("1 Cor 14.34–5 without 'in All the Churches of the Saints': External Evidence," New Testament Studies Volume 63 Issue 3, Cambridge University Press, 2017) I displayed external evidence for a separation of 1 Cor 14: 33b from vv 34-35. Following the study on external evidence, this presentation aims to continue the discussion on a place of v 33b and its syntactic function now focusing on internal evidence. The main question is: if v33b is not to introduce Mulieres Taceant, how are we to read and reconcile it with the context? In the first part of the presentation I will outline (at least) 6 different exegetical reading possibilities of v 33b that are found in the scholarly literature (i.a. Westcott and Hort, von Harnack), as well as argumentation from the Greek syntax for each of them. In the second part of the presentation I will discuss the following issues of syntax and semantics: Is v 33b a prepositional phrase or a subordinate clause assuming that the verb is elliptic? What are the two things hōs compares to each other? How common is it for Paul to introduce a new sentence with hōs and how Paul uses hōs in a verbless clause elsewhere in 1 Cor? The goal of this presentation is to advance scholarly discussion on the role of v 33b in the context of 1 Cor 14.
|
Tongues as sēmeion in 1 Cor 14:22: Madness, Mystery or Miracle?
Program Unit: Bible Translation Workshop (EABS)
Alesja Lavrinovica, -
This paper aims to strive for balance in exegesis of 1 Cor 14 by claiming that the context speaks about the valuable benefit of both gifts – tongues and prophecy, albeit different for each of the participants.
The focus of the presentation is not so much a translation of sēmeion, but the meaning of „sign” in 1 Cor 14:22. I would like to propose that sēmeion here can be better understood to mean a mystery or a miracle. In that case 1 Cor 14:22 could be understood as follows: “Tongues, then, is a mystery not for believers but for unbelievers; prophecy, however, is not [a mystery] for unbelievers but for believers.”
The meaning of ‘sign’ as a mystery would better reconcile v. 22 with v. 21. 1 Cor 14:21 makes an allusion to Is 28:11, 12 saying that the people will not listen, hear or obey, when God speaks through the foreign nation and foreign language. This paper suggests the reason behind not listening or hearing - people struggle to understand. Understanding and clarity seems to be the main thread in 1 Cor 14:2, 5-9, 11, 13-14, 16, 19 et al. Thus, in the discourse of 1 Cor 14, unbelievers do not understand tongues and might think they are madness (v. 23); believers who speak to God do not [need to] understand tongues, but they use the Charisma for their own benefit (v. 2, 4, 14, 18); unbelievers do understand the prophetic message and acknowledge God’s presence (v. 24-25), but believers do not [need to] understand the prophetic message when it reveals particular secrets of the hearts of the newcomers (v. 25).
|
The Biblical God and the Divine Opponents in the Translation of the Scripture in Northeast Asia
Program Unit: Contextual Interpretation of the Bible (Hebrew Bible/Old Testament and New Testament)
Archie C. C. Lee, Shandong University
This is a post-colonial critical study of the translation of the divine names (Elohim, and YHWH) and the divine enemies (Rahav, Leviathan and Tannin, Yam, etc.) in the Hebrew Bible in the context of Northeastern Asia. The Bible translation project during the colonial times fashions the site of contestation and negotiation between the negative image of the pagan cultures held by the missionaries and the aspiration of the indigenous Christian converts who intend to shape their religio-cultural identity that is inevitably hybridized. How the biblical God is to be rendered into the local cultural peculiarities and in what way the opponents of the divine in the Hebrew Bible are to be perceived and translated into the local language are the issues that had to be addressed by Bible translators in China, Japan and Korea. These countries have been under the cultural impact of Confucianism and share a great deal of linguistic affinities. The history of translation of the Bible in these regions also shows certain degree of interdependence and influence among them. A few passages will be selected from the Book of Isaiah (27:1 and 51:9-10) and the Psalms (74:12-14 and 148:7) for focused investigation in this presentation.
|
The Redemption of the Lord in the Parables of Enoch: Formulaic and Thematic Allusions in 1 Enoch 48 and 50
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
Joseph Hyung S. Lee, University of Aberdeen
In a thoroughly-researched work on messianism in the Similitudes of Enoch, J. Waddell has rightly pointed out that salvation and judgment are the key functions of the messiah figure in the second parable of the Similitudes (Messiah, 2011, p. 87). In 1 Enoch 48:1-3, there is an account where the son of man was named in the presence of the Lord of Spirits. Such scene of 1 En. 48:1-3 confirms that there is a close relationship between the son of man figure and the Lord of Spirit in the Similitudes. However, it is also true that the salvation is found in the name of the Lord of Spirits rather than in the name of the son of man in 1 En. 48:7 (cf. 50:4). Such a close relationship, as well as a bifurcation, between the divine agent and the deity for the redemption, resembles the relationship between the servant figure and the God of Israel depicted in Isaiah 45–49. Thus, 1 En. 48:4-7 alludes particularly to the passages in Isa 45, 47 and 49 to emphasise the eschatological function of the son of man, as well as to draw out the unique role of the Lord of Spirits and his name for redemption/salvation. Additionally, in the same vein of a redemption theme, 1 En. 50:1-4 alludes to Zech 14 thematically in order to emphasise the uniqueness of the Lord of Spirit, but this time, apart from the son of man figure. Thus, this paper will analyse the texts of 1 En. 48 and 50 and their allusions to Isaiah and Zechariah, respectively, in order to draw out the significance of the relationship between the son of man and the Lord of Spirits for redemption/salvation in the Similitudes.
|
The Tyrian Ruler in MT and LXX Ezekiel 28:11-19
Program Unit: Prophecy and Foreign Nations (EABS)
Lydia Lee, North-West University (South Africa)
The Tyrian ruler in MT and LXX Ezekiel 28:11-19 has garnered much scholarly attention. While the MT identifies him as the cherub, the LXX distingushes him from the cherub. Both the MT and the LXX seem to connect his garment with the Israelite high priestly pectoral in varying degrees (cf. Exodus 28:17-20; 39:10-13). Do such textual variants show the mechanical errors committed during the manual transmissions? Should they be attributed to the existence of different Hebrew Vorlagen? Or do they reflect the ideological or historical concerns of the editors/translators? Taking the questions and other relevant manuscript traditions into consideration, this paper attempts to trace the literary growth of the Tyrian ruler in Ezekiel's prophecies.
|
Thorleif Boman and the Twentieth-Century Quest for the Hebrew Mind
Program Unit: History of Biblical Scholarship in the Late Modern Period
Michael Legaspi, Pennsylvania State University
In 1952, Norwegian biblical scholar Thorleif Boman published a study of Hebrew thought, Das Hebräische Denken im Vergleich mit dem Griechischen (Hebrew Thought Compared with Greek). The work became widely influential, as it was translated into English and Japanese and appeared in five German editions, the last in 1968. Boman's book was in many ways the climax of a forgotten sub-genre in biblical studies, one characterized by the attempt to isolate, on textual and linguistic grounds, the distinctive mentality of the Hebrews. As Boman's title suggests, it was not merely a study of ancient Israel but an effort to recover a mode of Hebrew thought in opposition, specifically, to Greek thought. In this paper, I will examine the antecedents of Boman's work, connecting it to broader intellectual currents in the inter-war period, and, more specifically, to attempts by scholars to revisit and reinterpret the ancient foundations of civilization at a time when the future of "the West" (as Oswald Spengler denoted it) seemed to hang in the balance. How and why Hebrew thought became significant for this cultural moment - and why the quest for a distinctive, non-Greek, Hebrew mentality was soon abandoned - are questions central to this paper.
|
Arma Virumque Cano: A Hidden Oral–Aural Agenda in the Karatepe Inscriptions?
Program Unit: Israel in the Ancient Near East (EABS)
Reinhard G. Lehmann, Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz
Instead of blaming scribes for something we do not yet fully understand, it will be shown that the Phoenician version of the Karatepe inscription bears a layer of low-level suprasegmental aural score. Its existence allows us to catch a glimpse of the oral process (orality) and the audibility (aurality) of tales as they might have been performed in ancient times.
|
Textual Healing: Magico-medical Practices in Rabbinic Texts Reconsidered
Program Unit: Medicine in Bible and Talmud (EABS)
Lennart Lehmhaus, Freie Universität Berlin
Earlier scholarship on the history of medicine and science as well as on ancient Jewish history and Talmud tended to draw sharp distinction between rationale knowledge and magic or superstitious approaches to medicine and the body. Accordingly, many Talmudic passages with rather obscure recipes and therapeutic instructions have been interpreted as belonging to the latter category.
However, more recent studies into late ancient medicine, apotropaic texts and practices (e.g. , Aramaic and Syriac incantation bowls, papyri, amulets etc.) or into so-called miraculous healing in the Gospels and early Christian culture have pointed to the problematic nature of such a dichotomous approach. Projecting modern analytical distinctions between magic and medicine/science onto late ancient cultures, one risks to overlook the fluent boundaries and astonishing overlap between such ‘disciplines’ and their respective experts, even within the writings of Graeco-Roman medical authors.
Moreover, Talmudic scholarship saw the rabbis in most cases as disapproving of magic and as being solicitous about clear boundaries between legit religious practices and non-Jewish approaches that smacked of ‘magic’. This paper interrogates some Talmudic passages with therapies and recipes that were seen as drawing heavily on ‘popular’ or ‘folk’ healing rather than on medical knowledge proper. However, reading them in light of recent scholarship, I will question usual assumptions about the seclusiveness of the spheres of medical, religious and ritual knowledge and its related practices in rabbinic cultures of Late Antiquity for which ‘magic’ might be too narrow a category.
|
A Visual Culture of Violence at the North Palace of Ashurbanipal in Nineveh
Program Unit: Iconography and Biblical Studies (EABS)
Joel M. LeMon, Emory University
Most studies of visual culture are oriented to contemporary contexts. Yet recent works of Zainab Bahrani, Valentin Groebner (the late Middle Ages), and Lela Graybill (post-revolutionary France) have focused attention on ages past, how representations of violence from various media construct and legitimate power, and how the images of violence have stabilizing or destabilizing effects on their viewers. Ryan Bonfiglio has also brought the concept of “visual culture” into conversation with the Fribourg School of iconographic analysis, drawing out particularly important implications for biblical scholars. This paper explores the visual culture of late Neo-Assyria, through an analysis of Ashurbanipal’s North Palace at Nineveh. By all accounts, the iconographic program of Ashurbanipal’s reliefs represents the apogee of the Neo-Assyrian artistic tradition. To be sure, the reliefs in the Northern Palace do not all share the same high level of execution. In fact, Ashurbanipal may have repurposed some from earlier structures, especially Sennacherib’s Southwest palace. Nevertheless, given the size of the palace and the maturity of the iconographic traditions represented in its reliefs, the North Palace provides an excellent subject for exploring the visual culture of violence in the late Neo-Assyrian Empire.
|
Dehumanization and Mass Killing in the War Scroll, Ḥērem Texts, and Neo-Assyrian Sources Compared
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
T M Lemos, Huron University College, Univ of Western Ontario
This paper compares the imaginary of mass killing and dehumanization in sources that are rarely examined together—Neo-Assyrian royal inscriptions, Levantine texts speaking of ḥērem, and the War Scroll from Qumran—in order to theorize about the development of eschatological conceptions of large-scale slaughter to the point of anthropocide. While neo-Assyrian sources and many Israelite texts from the first half of the first millennium BCE and other eras regularly use animalizing language of victims and describe victims being subjected to clearly animalizing violence such as flaying and dismemberment, ḥērem texts such as the book of Joshua and Deuteronomy 7 and 20 that call for the elimination of whole groups strikingly do not use this animalizing rhetoric. Nor does the War Scroll from Qumran. This paper will argue that there is a common reason for this absence—one rooted in ancient peoples’ experiences with the natural world and, more specifically, with different animal species. Because the elimination of whole species was not a part of the experience of the ancients, they did not use animalizing language in texts envisioning complete elimination of groups but—perhaps rather paradoxically to modern readers—only in contexts of violence with a more limited target group. This limit in conceptualization then led to other modes of justifying calls for totalistic violence, modes centered less in dehumanization and more in demonization of opponents.
|
"Learn from My Example": The Reception of Ludlul Bel Nemeqi
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Wisdom
Alan Lenzi, University of the Pacific
Although often classified as "speculative wisdom," I have argued in the past that Ludlul Bel Nemeqi has some practical purposes. It is doxological in that it exalts Marduk's sovereignty; it is ideological in that it protects the institution of exorcism from charges of ritual failure; and it is pedagogical in that the poem challenges readers to learn from the paradigmatic suffering and recovery of the poem's protagonist, Shubshi-meshre-shakkan. In this paper, I consider how the reception of Ludlul in various texts served as a pedagogical resource. The paper will begin with a review and discussion of the purpose of several previously identified allusions to the poem. Why is the poem invoked? How does this invocation serve the texts’ rhetorical purposes? And how does this invocation reflect the pedagogical purpose of Ludlul? The paper will then turn to focus more extensive discussion on a royal inscription of Ashurbanipal. This latter text, I will argue, alludes to Ludlul in order to create an analogy between the sufferer in the poem and the king, whose piety has not yet, apparently, paid off. In sum, my paper attempts to look at the reception of Ludlul Bel Nemeqi in these several texts with a view to determine how Shubshi-meshre-shakkan’s charge “to learn from my example” (Tablet IV, Section C, line p, in Oshima’s new edition [ORA 14, 2014]) was actually carried out in them.
|
Multimodality and Cultural Transmission in Ancient Near Eastern Treaty Traditions
Program Unit: Ancient Near East
Mark Lester, Yale University
Comparative work on ancient Near Eastern treaty traditions has largely focused on textual philology, deciphering inscriptions of ancient treaties and studying them for historical backgrounds and literary genealogies. But at their core, treaties are not repositories of information, but vigorous attempts to impact the material world by regulating attitudes and behaviors. This paper argues that multimodality is present already within ancient Near Eastern treaties, and that multimodality works toward the cultural transmission of each treaty—in other words, to achieve the treaty’s desired impact on its audiences. How does the language each treaty uses about its contents attempt to change attitudes or behavior on the part of its audiences? How does it seek to ensure the reproduction of this text (and attendant obedience to this text) over time? This paper examines the language that the Aramaic Sefire treaty, Esarhaddon’s Succession Treaties (EST), and Deuteronomy use to categorize their contents. Each text refers in turn to (1) intangible cultural forms (e.g., ʿd, adê, torah), (2) the linguistic elements (e.g., ml, abutu, dabar) that communicate those forms, and (3) their material manifestation in inscribed objects (e.g., spr, nṣb, ṭuppi-adê, sēper). I argue first that the use of all three types of reference indicates that an awareness of multimodality was present within ancient Near Eastern treaty traditions. Second, I argue that in each treaty text considered, multimodality is tied to strategies for securing transmission. Drawing on recent work in linguistic anthropology, this paper considers treaties’ internal criteria for successful cultural transmission in each mode—the abstract, the linguistic, and the material. Through these insights we can better understand how ancient Near Eastern treaty traditions worked to achieve a material impact on the worlds they inhabited by shaping their social, political, and ritual environments.
|
The institutional Context of Biblical Scribal Tradition According to Timo Veijola
Program Unit: Editorial Techniques in the Hebrew Bible in Light of Empirical Evidence (EABS)
Christoph Levin, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
This paper discusses Timo Veijola's conception of the Deuteronomists as the forerunners of later Biblical scribes (especially Die Deuteronomisten als Vorläufer der Schriftgelehrten) and its influence and impact in recent research.
|
Judges, Elders, and Officers in Chronicles
Program Unit: Concepts of Leadership in the Hebrew Bible (EABS)
Yigal Levin, Bar-Ilan University
Within the Book of Chronicles, Shophtim (“judges”) are mentioned 7 times, Zeqenim (“elders”) 9 times, and Shoterim (“officers”) 6 times. This paper wishes to compare their use in Chronicles to the way they are used in the Chronicler’s “pre-exilic sources” (the Pentateuchal sources and the Deuteronomistic History) and to examine the way in which these office-holders are envisioned in Chronicles: their relationship to the monarchy, to the priesthood, to the Temple and to the tribal institutions. Is the Chronicler’s vision of these office-holders fundamentally different from that of the earlier sources? If so, does this different vision reflect the reality of Persian-Period Yehud, or is it a utopian vision, more reflective of the Chronicler’s ideology than of any historical reality?
|
Development Units in Ruth
Program Unit: Stylistics and the Hebrew Bible
Stephen H. Levinsohn, SIL International
Apparently redundant references to participants in a Hebrew narrative occur not only at the beginning of a new episode or to highlight the action or speech concerned, but also at the beginning of “development units” (DUs: new bursts of closely related actions—Heimerdinger 1999). This paper contrasts the overt references to the participants in Ruth 2 with their absence in chapter 3. Much of chapter 2 is organised around a series of initiatives by Boaz, though the long reference to “the servant in charge of the reapers” (JPS) in 2:6 highlights what he has to say about Ruth's good character. The ensuing conversation between Ruth and Naomi is also presented as a series of DUs (2:19-22) but, after 3:1, the only overt reference to an active participant in the narrative (‘the man’) is at the beginning of an episode in 3:8. Chapter 3 is presented as a single DU because Naomi’s speech of 3:1-4 sets out the strategy that Ruth is to follow and ends with the statement, “And he will tell you what you are to do”. The rest of the chapter is basically an outworking of Naomi’s instructions, so is not treated as a new development in the story (which in turn suggests that Ruth did not deviate in any significant way from Naomi's instructions). Furthermore, Naomi’s strategy fails because of the existence of a closer kinship-redeemer so, in that sense, following her instructions does not represent a new development, either, as far as the purpose of the story is concerned. It is only as Boaz starts to interact with the other potential kinship-redeemer in chapter 4 that further significant DUs occur.
|
Magic and Rational Medicine in the Twelfth-Century Manuscripts of the Book of Medicines of Asaf the Physician
Program Unit: Medicine in Bible and Talmud (EABS)
Emunah Levy, Bar Ilan University
The Book of Medicines of Asaf the Physician is the first known medical book to have been written in Hebrew. The book was compiled perhaps as early as the seventh century and no later than the beginning of the tenth century. It was probably written somewhere in the wide expanse of the Byzantine empire, as Syriac and Persian influences on the text have been determined.
I would like to speak of the magic copied alongside The Book of Medicines in the twelfth century in the two main manuscript witnesses of the text, one being Italian and the other, German. The book itself is not known for its magic, but rather for its Hippocratic mindset. Hence the magic recipes copied alongside it in these two manuscripts appear to be at complete odds with it. These recipes seem to stem from several sources of influence: Some have possible connections to Syriac astrological texts; some that were written in Aramaic are reminiscent of the Babylonian practice of using incantation bowels; one recipe also found in the Cairo geniza; and several recipes demand the reciting of a Biblical verse, in direct transgression of the Talmudic prohibition. Alongside these is also evidence of surrounding influences, with Latin magic texts translated or transcribed into Hebrew letters.
The marked difference between The Book of Medicines and the texts which surround it in these two witnesses of its text allow perhaps to argue for its being an attempt to make a corpus of Hebrew rational medicine which stands in opposition to the popular Babylonian magical tradition. These two manuscripts present the failure of this attempt, as magic and Hippocratic medicine co-exist in them, perhaps even transmitted together from the onset, as their sources suggest they were perhaps geographically, politically and historically formed not so far apart.
|
To Run but Not to Race: Revisiting the Metaphor of Phil 3:12-14 within Its Context
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible (EABS)
Soeng Yu Li, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
In Philippians 3 Paul urges the Philippians to imitate Christ by presenting himself as an example or model. In this light, the common scholarly understanding of the metaphor in Phil 3:12-14 as an athletic and more specifically an agonistic metaphor (e.g., Pfitzner, Poplutz) is strange. How can Paul urge the Philippians to imitate him by presenting their calling as a Wettkampf (agōn)? Does this mean that the “citizens of heaven” (cf. 3:20) are competitors of each other? The metaphor in Phil 3:12-14 presents a tension that does not fit within the understanding of a community that is called by God. We believe that the metaphor in Phil 3:12-14 needs to be understood in light of the metaphor “citizens of heaven” or to borrow a term of the Gospels, the Kingdom of God. This means that the metaphor and the agonistic terms such as “goal, prize” are not to be understood in terms of this present age/world but in terms of the world that can be expected in the future. Paul is thus re-describing the present world by means of the future world. As Paul is not using the metaphor of the runner in a situation that is characterized by competition, we think that Paul is focusing on a runner (exemplified by himself) who is running with all his strength and mind towards the goal. By means of this runner, Paul is describing a certain attitude that needs to characterize the life of a Christ believer/follower. And this attitude reflects an attitude that characterizes the future, therefore, it needs to be imitated in the present life of the believer. In light of the broader context, we will demonstrate that Phil 3:12-14 contains the conceptual metaphor CHRISTIAN CALLING/LIFE IS TO RUN WITH ALL YOUR STRENGTH AND MIND TOWARDS THE GOAL.
|
Social Cohesion among the Early Rabbis, Part III: Evidence of the Talmuds Compared with Mishnah's
Program Unit: Sociological and Anthropological Approaches to the Study of the Evidence of the Mishnah (EABS)
Jack Lightstone, Brock University
In two antecedent papers, the pervasive literary-rhetorical conventions of, first, the Mishnah and, second, the Tosefta were analyzed in the attempt to draw from these conventions conclusions about the nature of reader-engagement and of requisite skills expected of members of the early rabbinic group, for whom study of Mishnah and its associated texts comprised the central inner-group activity of early rabbinic masters and their novices. The literary-rhetorical traits of Tosefta, it was argued, both confirmed the shared foundational skills expected of the members of the rabbinic movement in the course of Mishnah-study and modulated those shared skills. The current paper, the third in the series, argues that pervasive literary-rhetorical traits of the Jerusalem and Babylonian Talmuds modulate these core shared skills still further.
|
“The Fellowship of Christ’s Sufferings” (Phil 3:10): Politics, Sufferings, and Social Identity Formation in Philippians
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Kar Yong Lim, Seminari Theoloji Malaysia
Both the political discourse and the notion of suffering in Paul’s letter to the Philippians have been widely acknowledged. However, how these two themes intersect in this letter has yet to be fully explored. In this paper, I would like to suggest that both the political discourse and the theme of suffering are closely related to social identity formation of the early Christ-movement in the city of Philippi. By briefly examining a series of passages related to these two themes, this paper also attempts to further the current discussion on social identity formation of early Pauline communities by highlighting the uniqueness of identity formation in Philippi as compared to other communities.
|
Performing the Bible in Postcolonial Context
Program Unit: Political Biblical Criticism
Sung Uk Lim, Yonsei University
The present study explores the political nature of performing the Bible as a sacred text in the context of Korean Christianity. Among others, I investigate the scriptural performance of singing and dramatizing the Bible in the postcolonial era. The political context of South Korea leads to the performed transformation of the semantic range of the long-standing Christian tradition. It is my contention therefore that the adaptation of Christianity to Korean soil renders the performative dimension of the Bible all the more political than Western Christianity may imagine. In other words, the Korean ways of performing the Bible are under the influence of the endless political turmoil and crisis that lingered in Korea. In the long term, Korean Christianity turns out to be such a subversively performative religion in its widely differing range of semantics.
|
Abraham as an Identity Sign in Paul and the Qur’an
Program Unit: Quran and Islamic Tradition in Comparative Perspective
Ilkka Lindstedt, University of Helsinki
Our paper compares identity building in the New Testament and the Qur’an by utilizing the social identity approach and focusing on the character of Abraham as a positive identity signal. The processes through which the Christian and Muslim group identities eventually emerged as distinct are still underway in the NT and Qur’an. This explains the texts’ great interest in creating positive distinctiveness for the emergent groups – and in the negative stereotyping of those cropped outside.
Both the apostle Paul and Qur’an depict their respective ingroups as the true heirs of Abrahamic legacy, revealing the value of this particular figure for these related, monotheistic, traditions. In Galatians 3–4 Paul devotes considerable space to arguing for Abrahamic ancestry for Gentile Christ-believers. Instead of remembering their past as one of idol worship, the believers are invited to rewrite their collective history by tapping into an honorable Jewish history. In Paul’s construction, the Gentile Christ-believers already belong to the Abrahamic lineage through belief in Christ, which leaves out those who rely on the Mosaic Law.
While Paul endeavors to appropriate Abraham from the Jews, the Qur’an rhetorically seizes him from both Jews and Christians in order to make him a prototype for the Believers’ movement. Qur’an 3:65–67 states that the People of the Book do not understand the true nature of Abraham because he came before the Torah and Gospel, which only contain a distorted image of him. Abraham was not Jewish nor Christian, but a hanif muslim, probably meaning in its original context “a Gentile, submitting [to God].” Qur’an 3:68 asserts that closest to Abraham are Muhammad and his group.
In Paul’s letters and the Qur’an, Abraham is evoked to signal positive social identity. At stake is not only group belonging in the present but also the possession of sacred history.
|
The Reception of Pistis Sophia: Exploring the Relation between Theologians and Esoteric Groups in Eighteenth–Ninteenth-Century Europe
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Paul Linjamaa, Lunds Universitet
The ancient text Pistis Sophia was found in the end of the eighteenth century and was quickly received with great enthusiasm among some of Europe’s most famous theologians, such as Karl Reinhold von Köstlin and Adolf von Harnack. Simultaneously, the text was hailed as a treasure of immense wisdom among many of Europe’s leading esoteric figures, such as Helena Blavatsky and Gérard Encausse. This paper presents the content of a newly established project aimed at exploring the reception of Pistis Sophia in these two milieus. It will be argued that studying the reception of this text, and the way it was thought to represent ancient Gnosticism, allows us to view nineteenth and early twentieth century theological and esoteric milieus in new light and, what is more, explore the contact between these two milieus and their dependence on and interest for each other.
|
Rolling Stones and Biblical Literature: Theory and Method of Ancient Media in the Southern Levant
Program Unit: Iconography and Biblical Studies (EABS)
Florian Lippke, Université de Fribourg - Universität Freiburg
Sequence analysis can be considered as one of the most important methodological steps when dealing with iconographic content of cylinder seals. It is comparable to (a) structure analysis of texts defining "beginning" and "end" of a certain pericope and also tracing the interior structure of a given text. Similar questions arise when focussing on basic questions in details. Anaphoric and cataphoric elements as well as stabilizing and dividing factors can be traced. When categorizing the different features a clear set of equivalents between textual and iconographic elements can be observed. Taken these hints for granted another similarity of texts and iconographic sources is to be identified in the broader realm of a history of Pre-Hellenistic media.
|
Holy and Catholic Church: A Study of Paul’s Purity Language
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Chiaen Liu, McMaster Divinity College
The concept of purification is a complicated issue since there are different types of purity rites in the book of Leviticus, but Christians do not follow most of them because Christ has fulfilled the salvation. In Acts 21, however, Paul practiced the rite of purification with four men. It may be inappropriate to assume that Paul’s action is related to atonement, and therefore, we need more information to explain Paul’s action. Many scholars have attempted to tease out the reason for his action, but there seems to be no consensus. Nevertheless, no direct clue indicates that Paul’s action is associated with the Old Testament regulation, and no evidence shows that the purification in Acts 21 is related to Paul’s returning from the area of the Gentile. In addition, the text says nothing about corpse contamination, and most scholars have dealt with this problem without considering the context in Acts 21, but focusing on the Old Testament regulations instead. Therefore, one needs to probe into what was in Paul’s mind in the event in Acts 21. This paper, therefore, will start from Paul’s language of purity in his letters. The semantic meanings of purity denote that there is a strong connection between holiness and wholeness. Paul’s purity language concerns the community of God, focusing on the relationship between the individual and the group. Paul connects the concept of purity and union because real purity and true unity result from the death and resurrection of Christ. This understanding argues that for Paul, the purification rite is for the purpose of restoring union between the Gentile and Jewish believers. Therefore, the church is built as “One” and “Holy,” meaning as a group of people who are untied and pure.
|
The Appropriation of Isaiah of Isa 6:9-10 and the Parable of the Sower: A Synoptic Study of Citational Patterns
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Jonathan Lo, Hong Kong Baptist Theological Seminary
Although there are minor variations to the “Parable of the Sower” between the synoptic gospels, the vocabulary, content, and arrangement of all three versions have many similarities. When Jesus's disciples inquire about the parable’s meaning, he responds by quoting from an enigmatic passage in Isa 6:9-10 about a people who “see, but do not perceive” and “listen, but do not understand” (Matt 13:13 / Mark 4:12 / Luke 8:10). An interesting aspect of this particular demonstration of dependence on the Jewish Scriptures is the fact that the quotation of Isaiah in each gospel is different from both the LXX and MT versions of the Isaianic text. Isaiah 6:9-10 is appropriated in creative ways in the synoptic gospels due to stylistic tendencies that also reveal each evangelist’s understanding of the Isaianic passage in light of what they see as the function of the Parable of the Sower. Mark’s quotation is a condensed version of Isa 6:9-10 and modifies the phrase from “be healed” to “be forgiven,” emphasising the special role of the forgiveness within Jesus’ ministry. Matthew’s quotation includes the name of the prophet, Isaiah, and includes a fuller and more exact recitation of the passage, demonstrating a familiarity of the quotation’s scriptural context. Luke’s quotation of Isa 6:9-10 is a truncated version of Mark’s, omitting even the reference to “turning” and “being forgiven.” This paper will use the synoptic appropriation of Isa 6:9-10 as a test case to see whether an evangelist’s distinctive style of citation and idiosyncratic use of the Jewish Scriptures can be reliably ascertained. If such intertextual phenomena can be revealed to be consistent, they can be used to inform and further discussions about the relationship between the synoptic gospels and their writing styles and concerns.
|
Pauline Authority in the Letter to Philemon: Identifying the Theological Underpinnings of Paul’s Persuasive Discourse
Program Unit: Authority and Influence in Ancient Times
Jonathan Lo, Hong Kong Baptist Theological Seminary
Philemon is an ideal text for exploring the nature of Paul’s authority and leadership because in it we observe Paul at work to persuade someone to see things from his point of view and to act accordingly. In this stirring and skilfully composed text, Paul broaches the subject of how to deal with a runaway slave who also has now also become a believer. Paul believes the best course of action is to send the slave home to his master and employs a range of rhetorical strategies to facilitate their reconciliation. An important element of Paul’s persuasive discourse that has not received much attention is the fact that Paul is relying on Philemon’s commitment to the Christian gospel when making his appeal for Onesimus—Paul does not make his appeal on the basis of his apostolic authority or social pressure, but rather on their shared religious convictions, which Paul frequently mentions in this brief letter. First, the relationship between “faith” and “love” for the Christian is given new insight when Paul inverts the order of this pair and expands on the meaning faith. Second, the frequent mentions of “Christ,” “Christ Jesus,” and “gospel” in different contexts place Paul’s request in the category of exhortation rather than command. Third, the language of “obedience” is theological and suggests that perhaps Paul is not only referring narrowly to compliance to his apostolic command, but to the broader trajectory of “obedience of faith” mentioned in his other letters. This study will identify the theological underpinnings of Paul’s plea for Onesimus, discuss how they add weight to Paul’s persuasive discourse, and reveal how Paul’s leadership style and authority are ultimately shaped by his theological convictions.
|
James and Jude as Bookends to the Catholic Epistles Collection
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
Darian Lockett, Biola University
With Eusebius’s comment that “James” is “said to be the first of the Epistles called Catholic” (Hist. eccl. 2.23.24–25) we have the first unambiguous reference to the Catholic Epistles as a collection. Interestingly, in the same passage Eusebius numbers Jude as one (and perhaps last?) of Catholic Epistles. John Painter argues that, implicitly, Eusebius describes James and Jude as the first and last (the bookends) of the Catholic Epistles collection. Recently, however, Bemmerl and Grünstäudl have concluded that: “Paradoxerwise trägt der Umstand, das die in Jak 1,1 und Jud 1 Benannte fiktiven Briefautoren in einem nahen Verwaandtschaftsverhältnis stehen, wenig bis nichts zur Bestimmung des literarischen Verhältnisses der beiden Texte aus…” (p. 21). The degree of literary sharing between the texts will not be considered, but the canonical relationship suggested, in part, by the letter prescripts will prove more important than Bemmerl and Grünstäudl assert. This paper offers evidence to support the function of James and Jude as bookends bracketing the Catholic Epistles as a canonical collection. First, the paper argues for thematic and lexical connections between the letter openings of the two texts especially highlighting the familial and literary connection brokered by the phrase “brother of James” (Jude 1), contra Bemmerl and Grünstäudl. Then the paper offers a sustained argument that both letters draw the conclusion, in their respective endings (Jas 5:19–20 and Jude 22–23), that mercy must triumph over judgment or that rescuing/offering mercy to the wayward covers a multitude of sin. Using a canonical approach, the paper concludes that the connection between the opening (James) and closing (Jude) elements of the Catholic Epistles is indicative of a canonical consciousness and that James and Jude hold this discrete sub-unit of the New Testament canon together as a coherent collection.
|
Methodical Analysis Meets Pragmatism: Rhoads’ Practical Narrative Approach of "Mark as Story" through the Cognitive Turn Lens of Finnern’s Narratological Analysis
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Igor Lorencin, Theologische Hochschule Friedensau
In this paper, I am exploring how Rhoads’ pragmatic approach to the Gospel of Mark, coming from theater and performance, can benefit from Finnern’s analytical approach, based on linguistic theories. Are there some points of conjunction between the two narratological approaches? They both have similar five working steps for their investigations: 1) Points of view; 2) characters; 3) plots; 4) settings; 5) reception/effects. They have their common ground in linguistics, but Finnern uses latest cognitive turn research and bases his methodology on clearly described theoretical considerations. On the other hand, Culpepper claims that Rhoads has “introduced narrative criticism of Mark to non-specialist,” putting more emphasis on praxis than theory.
What is cognitive turn that Finnern follows? The main question is, how are verbal meanings represented in human brain? More specifically, what foreknowledge, or what scripts and frames are influencing readers thinking? What cognitive schemata can an author count on by his recipients as he writes his work? By cognitive schemata, scripts describe general processual knowledge, while frames describe semantic content knowledge. It is about methodologically tangible and concrete concepts that can be defined and researched in the five working steps of narratological investigation.
What is the result of Finnern’s application of the cognitive turn? His approach calls for studying original situation of the writing by accessing mental processes that were going on in the minds of authors and recipients, and thus defining their scripts and frames. It is finally about the text reception and effects of that reception on the recipients. In this paper, I want to focus on the fifth working step (reception/effects), and analyze what additional value does Finnern’s methodological approach to the text reception and its effect on the audience bring to the narratology of the gospel of Mark. What are prospects and limits of his methodology?
|
Profile-Based Classification of Composite Text Forms in the Gospel of Mark
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the New Testament, the Old Testament and the Qur’an (EABS)
Peter E. Lorenz, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
Profile-based classification — in which manuscripts are related by common profiles of distinctive readings — supplies a practical approach to grouping manuscripts that avoids the most obvious pitfalls of classification by text types. Classification based on shared profiles is particularly suitable in cases, such as Families 1 and 13, where core members consistently attest the same readings. But how do we classify a manuscript such as Codex Bezae, in which we find in Mark (according to the Hauptliste, TuT 4.1.2, 438-41), one group of readings that agrees distinctively with 03 and relatives and, at the same time, another that agrees distinctively with 038 and 565, yet considered as a whole the manuscript appears as isolated within the tradition, with no closely-related witnesses (according to the Gruppierung table, TuT 4.1.1, §2.6)? It is clear that, in such cases, a profiling approach that only considers the whole text as a unit is inadequate to identify potential relationships. In this paper, I suggest a more flexible approach to profile-based classification that allows us to address composite profiles by splitting the total profile into smaller sub-profiles, each with a specific alignment within the tradition and hence different relationships. When considered individually, these sub-profiles reveal relationships that are not captured when all readings are considered simultaneously in a single profile. Pointing to the example of Codex Bezae’s composite text form, I argue that such an approach can reveal much about its development and place in the larger tradition that is not possible with a less granular approach.
|
Imitating Paul in His Many Contests: Life, Death, and the Ambiguous Metaphors of 2 Tim 4:6-8
Program Unit: Biblical Interpretation in Early Christianity
Cory B. Louie, University of Notre Dame
In 2 Tim 4:6-8, the pseudonymous Pauline author claims that he, having completed his athletic contest, is now being poured out as a sacrificial offering as he anticipates his just reward in heaven. While this complex of sacrificial and athletic metaphors initially appears to predict Paul's imminent death, the ambiguity surrounding these metaphors has led to diverging scholarly opinions as to whether these metaphors refer to Paul's death or to some other aspect of Paul's life and ministry. Early Christian interpreters, however, cast little doubt as to whether Paul's martyrdom was in view. Yet when this verse became used in an exhortatory setting to encourage Christians to imitate Paul in his contest, the ambiguity of these metaphors exposed this passage to a multiplicity of interpretations that allowed Paul's "contest" to be understood in different ways. This paper explores various receptions of this passage from the 2nd through 6th centuries that show how Paul could be taken as an exemplar to imitate in different "types" of contests, from the contest of ministry (e.g., Ambrose, Off. 1.15.58), to the contest of martyrdom (e.g., Cyprian, Ep. 10.4.3), to the contest of the ascetic life (e.g., John Cassian, Inst. 5.17). Taking these examples and others into consideration, I argue that the ambiguity inherent within these metaphors allowed 2 Tim 4 to be applicable in various settings as it exhorted individuals to imitate Paul in completing his contest. Moreover, because this contest was ill-defined, it became subject to a fluidity of interpretation that consequently blurred the lines between life and death, as imitating Paul's contest sometimes referred to living life well, sometimes to dying well, and other times to dying well through living well.
|
A Jewish-Christian Exegesis in the Slavonic Text on the Perdition of the Higher Intellect
Program Unit: Slavonic Apocrypha (EABS)
Basil Lourié, Scrinium. Review of the Patrology, Critical Hagiography
"On the Perdition of the Higher Intellect and on the Image of Light" is the title given to a work preserved (only partially and without the title) in Slavonic by its recent researchers, Maria Korogodina (who provided the critical edition) and Basil Lourié (who identified it as an Origenistic treatise translated into Slavonic from Greek but written, most probably, in Syriac). Regardless of its own theological purpose, the text is interesting due to the archaic exegetical tradition it refers to. The sequence of the periods marked by (1) Abel and Cain, (2) Enoch, (3) Noah and the Flood, (4) the Tour of Babel, (5) Abraham, and (6) Isaac and Melchizedek has precedents in the Second Temple Jewish apocalyptic and/or calendrical traditions (including 2 Enoch) and has some parallels in James of Sarug.
|
Paul Beyond Piety: A Reading of Paul’s Injunction to Prayer (1 Timothy 2:1-7)
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Kwang Meng Low, National University of Singapore
This paper is set to discuss the phenomenon of prayer as more than a pious act. Prayer has become an interested topic for philosophy with its “theological turn.” Prominent philosophers who engaged in discussion on prayer are contemporary French thinkers Jacques Derrida, Emanuel Levinas, and Jean-Louis Chrétien. Hence, “prayer” is no longer the sole domain of theology and biblical studies; philosophy and other “-logy” are weighting in on the question of “prayer.” It is within this flow that this paper seeks to discuss “prayer’ beyond piety, and to situate prayer within performance and performative, and understanding it as both a corporeal and oral performance using J.L. Austin’s theory of performatives, and performance theory by Jeffrey C. Alexander and Jon McKenzie.
Paul’s injunction to pray is more than an expression of Christian piety. Instead, Paul’s use of prayer is more subversive as an instrument of civil disobedience. In this paper I will first discuss prayer in relation to Austin’s theory and argue that we might need to look beyond prayer as an oral performance with its questionable effectiveness. I suggest that Jeffrey and McKenzie’s theories help us see the effectiveness and potential of prayer as subversion in Paul’s political discourse.
|
Are There Traces of Ugaritic or Egypto-Semitic Phrases in the Tafsir?
Program Unit: Northwest Semitic Epigraphy Related to the Biblical World (EABS)
Meir Lubetski, City University of New York
The blessing bestowed by Jacob upon his favorite son, Joseph, opens with the famous phrase, ben porat yoseph, and then repeats ben porat, again in the next stich. Commentators, as well as translators, uncertain of the meaning of the expression, grappled with the reason for the repetition, and struggled to understand the metaphoric implications of the tri-part verse (Genesis 49:22). In sum, there was no unanimity in providing a meaningful explanation of the verse.
This paper attempts to present an explanation of the whole verse based on the ingenious translation/interpretation of the Tafsir composed by Saadiah Gaon (882-942).
|
The Role of the Sabbath in the Construction of Exilic Identity Construction in the Book of Ezekiel
Program Unit: Construction of Identity in the Ancient World: Intersections and Reflections (EABS)
Ottilia Lukacs, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
This paper scrutinizes the Sabbath as identity marker for the exiled covenantal community as attested by the Sabbath references in Ezekiel. I agree with the consensus that the Sabbath institution as the seventh day of the week was not attested before the Babylonian exile, that the emergence of the Sabbath (particularly the development of Sabbath law) needs to be situated against the ideological and theological background of the exilic and post-exilic periods, and that the Sabbath functioned as the Judean/Israelite identity marker in exile. Despite the agreement, they prompt us to ask further: What are the characteristic features of that identity which is marked by the Sabbath commandment? How do we envisage the community or communities that used the Sabbath as identity marker? How did they use the Sabbath to express the community's self-definition and self-understanding? I will analyse how the striking references on the Sabbath in Ezekiel 20:12,13,20,21, 22:8,26, 23:38 and 22:26 form part of this ideological and theological tendency to interpret the notion of exile. I argue that they underline the identity-formation of the exiled Judeans in their new context (socio-political-cultural-economic) after their deportation and Babylonian settlement. In the evoked history (like Ezekiel 20), the Sabbath is highlighted in the covenant-making process in the wilderness (i.e., exilic environment). The covenant itself is not explicitly mentioned in the recalled history but the Sabbath is accentuated as the sign of relationship between God and Israel. The profanation of the Sabbath, together with the idolatry and rejection of the statutes and ordinances, brought about the exiled situation. Therefore, I suggest that the Sabbath contributes to the identity marker formation of the exiled covenantal community (Judean exilic community) in Ezekiel, which is considered to be the direct continuation of the covenantal community at Sinai vis-à-vis the community left in Jerusalem.
|
The Transmission of Apocrypha in Egyptian Monasteries
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Hugo Lundhaug, Universitetet i Oslo
Taking recent studies that have confirmed the overwhelming likelihood of a monastic provenance of the Nag Hammadi Codices as its point of departure, this paper places the apocryphal texts of these codices within a broader tradition of textual production in Egyptian monasteries. Drawing on evidence from other monastic manuscript collections from Egypt deriving from the fourth to the twelfth centuries, including the Monastery of Apollo at Bala’izah, the Monastery of the Archangel Michael at Phantoou, the Monastery of Mercurius at Edfu, and the White Monastery near Atripe, the paper argues that the production and use of apocrypha was not a marginal phenomenon in Egyptian monasticism, and discusses some salient features of their transmission in the context of monastic manuscript culture.
|
From Micro to Macro Level Evolutionary Analysis
Program Unit: The Biblical World and Cultural Evolution (EABS)
Petri Luomanen, University of Helsinki
The paper address the relation of micro and macro level analysis in cultural evolutionary studies, in particular how these levels are to be combined in the project Early Christianity in Cultural Evolution (https://www.helsinki.fi/en/researchgroups/early-christianity-in-cultural-evolution). The project consists of micro-level case studies that focus on the possible selective advantage of early Christian groups and texts in their Greco-Roman cultural context. What are the prerequisites for proceeding from these case studies to a broader cultural evolutionary narrative of the expansion of early Christian culture and communities before the Constantinian turn? What are the questions to be addressed in the case studies if they are to serve a broader cultural evolutionary analysis? What is the significance of the cultural evolutionary paradigm for the macro level analysis? Does it only impose a Darwinian framework on the data that could be as well—or even better?—illustrated by more conventional methodologies? Or does the cultural evolutionary analysis reveal something in the history of early Christianity that would otherwise remain undetected?
|
Use of Desire and Aversion in the Moral Discourse in the Book of Proverbs and Its Effect on Character Formation
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Wisdom
Sun Myung Lyu, Baekseok University
Hebrew wisdom tradition recognizes human character, namely the total makeup and disposition of a person, as the link between human actions and their consequences (Boström’s “act-character-consequence nexus”), and fostering novel character stands tall among the goals of moral education proffered in the book of Proverbs. An interesting feature of the moral discourse of Proverbs is the frequent use of emotional appeals to influence its readers and shape their characters according to its ideals. This has been often explained as a rhetorical and pedagogical strategy as the target audience of the wisdom discourse in Proverbs is the impressionable youth who can be swayed between moral choices. There is, however, more fundamental basis for linking human emotion and character formation than rhetorical and pedagogical effectiveness. Desire is crucial in human decision-making process, thus psychotherapy has long recognized the importance of fostering desire for “desirable” state in patients to treat psychological malaise. Thus presenting relevant data vividly, therapists expect the patient to build desire for change (image training in weight control, for example), or aversion to calamity (like photo show of damaged lung in anti-smoking campaign). In a similar vein, Proverbs paints its ideal life (wise and righteous) as a desirable object (happy and loved), whereas its anti-ideal life (foolish and wicked) as undesirable object (unhappy and hated). Examples abound: the righteous person is loved by God (Prov 15:9); wicked person is the object of hatred (Prov 29:27); the righteous life is solid while the wicked one is fear-driven (Prov 28:1). Employing psychological and therapeutic insights, this paper elucidates how the moral discourse of Proverbs solicits behavioral responses from the inexperienced pupil (peti) and carrying him toward formation of the ideal character titled as wise (hakham) and righteous (tsaddiq).
|
Blood and Justice: Lactantius and Porphyry on Sacrifice, Persecution, and the Pious Citizen
Program Unit: Citizens and Aliens in Greco-Roman Antiquity (EABS)
Kirsten H. Mackerras, University of Oxford
During the Diocletian persecution, Christian abstention from sacrifice was judged a violation of their obligations as Roman citizens. Porphyry of Tyre accused Christians of impiety, lawlessness, and failure to treat their fellow-citizens and the Roman gods justly. Yet Porphyry himself modified the traditional account of the pious citizen's duties when he rejected blood sacrifices for being unjust. This paper explores how Lactantius' Divine Institutes use the theme of blood, a motif not considered in previous scholarship, to respond to these charges. Firstly, the paper compares how Lactantius and Porphyry describe the relationship between blood and justice. Both authors criticise blood sacrifices, and attribute them to society's fall from a primeval golden age. Both authors must then defend the piety of their rejection of the traditional cult, yet these defences led them to opposite sides of the persecution. The paper then explores how Lactantius uses the motif of bloodshed to argue for the justice of Christianity and the illegitimacy of the persecution. Lactantius believes that bloodshed destroys virtue and true religion, and reflects the immorality of the Graeco-Roman gods. For Lactantius, pagan readiness to shed the blood of animals in worship, and the blood of Christians in the persecution, shows that pagan conceptions of justice, piety and law are fundamentally mistaken. Finally, the paper considers whether Lactantius' use of the bloodshed motif is a deliberate riposte to the vegetarianism of Porphyry and his fellow philosophers, situated within the broader discussion of whether Porphyry is Lactantius' unnamed philosopher. Ultimately, Lactantius argues that the presence of wrongly-spilled blood shows that pagans have failed to treat both God and their fellow-citizens justly. The motif of blood allows Lactantius to turn the charges of the persecutors back upon themselves.
|
Jesus vs. John the Baptist: The Intention and Effect of John 10:40-42
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Yutaka MAEKAWA, Kwansei Gakuin University
In John 10:40-42, it is noted that Jesus left Jerusalem and went to “the place where John had been baptizing earlier.” In this paper, the intention and effect of this phrase is examined.
Previous studies on John 10:40-42 have not been paid sufficient attention to the place in this passage. The scene described in this passage can only be found in the Gospel of John. Without 10:40-42, the story would still flow; however, as these verses had a certain meaning for the readers of the Gospel of John, namely, the Johannie community, the author included them.
John the Baptist plays a prominent role in John’s Gospel. In the synoptic Gospels, John the Baptist sometimes doubts the authenticity of Jesus; however, in the Gospel of John, he always affirms Jesus’ authority. Chapter 10 is the last occasion that the name of John the Baptist is mentioned. At that very time, Jesus went back to the place that concerned John the Baptist. One may ask what the implications of this description are.
In the Gospel of John, the death of John the Baptist is not reported. This reveals that the author of this Gospel had more interest in his spiritual heritage, that is, his disciples rather than the historical events about him. This can be inferred from the activities of his disciples. In other words, the Johannine community and John the Baptist competed with one other. This is the background of the phrase that is being scrutinized. Jesus went back to that place and many people believed in him rather than John the Baptist; this was the triumph of the Johannine community.
Therefore, the place in John 10:40-42 was an important one for the Johannine community because it informs the reader that they defeated the disciples of John the Baptist.
|
Positive Emotions in the Book of Jubilees: The Insertion of Happiness and Joy into the Stories of Genesis and Exodus
Program Unit: Emotions and the Biblical World (EABS)
Daniel Maier, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
The aspect of positive emotions inside the narrative of Jubilees has played a minor or nonexistent role in commentaries and articles since the beginning of research on this interesting piece of Second Temple literature. This only changed relatively recently with the publication of articles by Betsy Halpern-Amaru (2005), on festive joy in Jubilees, and Anke Dormann (2017), on the happiness of Abraham in the passages retelling his life story. These were the first scholars to describe the drastic changes concerning emotional elements in the final version of Jubilees as compared to the narrative Vorlage in Genesis and Exodus. While the whole book of Genesis and the first twelve chapters of Exodus each only have one verse respectively which mention joy in the form of the Hebrew word שמח, the Gəʿəz equivalent ፈሥሐ for happiness/joy appears more than forty times in Jubilees. In my paper, it shall be argued that this major insertion of positive emotions by the author of Jubilees was undertaken in order to establish his ideals of a certain form of happiness. He mainly does this in two ways: (1) by describing the happy lives of the patriarchs, who achieved their happiness primarily through their gratitude towards God, and (2) through depicting the celebrations of joyful festivals by these patriarchs and their descendants. Via the latter, the author demands that his readers likewise properly celebrate the holidays of the Jewish year as a non-material sacrifice to God. The comparison of both aspects of positive emotions in Jubilees allows for a deeper understanding of the author’s thoughts on the universal question: “What is a good life?”
|
Jonah and Mark's Jesus
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Elizabeth Struthers Malbon, Retired, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University
This paper offers an overall look at narrative parallels between Jonah and Mark’s Jesus, focusing on interactions of characters and the movement of the plot, and a closer look at verbal parallels, or allusions to Jonah in Mark at the level of vocabulary when comparing the two Greek texts. Narratively, both Jonah and Mark include a storm on the sea during which the main character is asleep on the boat and is awakened by fearful passengers who ask him to do something so that they may not perish. Linguistically, a number of significant terms occur in both narratives: boat, sea, sleep, perish, subside, waves, fear, and pray. But the differences between Jonah and Jesus are equally meaningful. The Book of Jonah tells the story of a reluctant prophet of a God merciful to Gentiles. When Jonah tries to run away from God’s purpose, for himself and for Gentiles, God provides for Jonah a second chance. Jonah cannot hinder God’s mercy, and God works patiently to coax Jonah into extending it. The Gospel of Mark tells a story not only about Jesus but about the disciples, so the pattern of Jonah is both reversed and extended, not simply paralleled. Jesus is a willing prophet of a God merciful to Gentiles. Jesus’ disciples are reluctant (or struggling) to be followers of such a prophet of such a God. Jesus provides for the disciples a second round of guided instruction to encourage and enable them to do so. Jesus and his disciples continue Jesus’ initial success as a prophet of a God merciful to Gentiles, although the disciples continue to struggle with the implications of such discipleship to the end. Thus, Jesus acts in a godly way in teaching and guiding his disciples, as God tries to teach and guide Jonah.
|
Virtue in the Letter to Titus
Program Unit: Virtue in Biblical Literature (EABS)
Dogara Ishaya Manomi, Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz
This paper asks and attempts answering, “What concept of virtue is in the letter to Titus? How and why does the author use Greek philosophical ethical vocabularies like παιδεύουσα, σωφρόνως, δικαίως, and εὐσεβῶς (2:11-12) without using ἀρετή throughout? With what distinctive motifs does the author modify the concept of virtue?” The paper approaches these questions by considering the virtue-ethical functions of the linguistic elements, theological motifs, and ethical norms in the text, especially in 2:11-12.
This paper argues that at the linguistic level, the author frequently and carefully uses the various forms of εἶναι “to be” not only as linguistic elements, but more importantly to construct an ethic of character which focuses more on moral “being” than “doing.” Similarly, he presents the ethical norms in adjectival and adverbial forms more than noun forms in order to describe qualities of moral persons than moral actions. Moreover, he uses the verb ζήσωμεν, which has an ingressive nuance, to show that the Christ-event imparts virtue through a radical moral transformation and to express the virtue concept of moral progress towards a moral telos.
At the theological level, the author moralizes the early Christian theological concept of “χάρις” as an ethical representation of the Christ-event. At the ethical level, he integrates the moral significance of the Christ-event with the Greek philosophical παιδειά to introduce divine moral agency and moral progress towards a telos. Moreover, in order not to overshadow the distinctive motifs he introduces to the concept of virtue, the author avoids using the umbrella term ἀρετή.
The thesis of this paper, therefore, is that the ethical perspective of Titus is a virtue perspective, but with “Christian” distintictives. Titus, therefore, provides an insight into how some early Christian authors engaged, modified, and appropriated the Greek philosophical concept of virtue without necessarily using ἀρετή.
|
Aliens and Moral Anarchy from Aristotle Point of View
Program Unit: Citizens and Aliens in Greco-Roman Antiquity (EABS)
María José Martin Velasco, University of Santiago de Compostela
In the fourth century B.C. the democratic political system of Athens went through a crisis: its focus on the "polis" no longer fitted the new circumstances of the individual. Athenian citizens developed a more critical attitude towards the democratic assumptions of the preceding period. The lack of interest in actual political life, compared to the characteristic activism of the previous century, is reflected at several levels. To begin with, New Comedy confronts the social criticism of Aristophanes with plots focusing on the private life of citizens. A second aspect is the gradual acceptance of universality, of equality between all men, and the elimination of differences between Greeks and barbarians, which culminates in the policies of Alexander the Great. A third element can be found in Demosthenes' continuous complaints about the indolence of citizens and their abandonment of duties. Finally there is the fact that the democratic constitution acquires greater complexity, leading to the demise of the archetype of the personal, political citizen and to the progressive evolution of what we now refer to as the professional politician. Like Plato, Aristotle establishes a link between two alarming phenomena of his time: the instability of Greek political life and moral anarchy. I am going to examine his political and moral theory from this point of view. I am going to start with the theoretical and general proposal that questions the possibility of living together, and will then analyse the concept of law. I will finish with the influence of education on citizens.
|
The Relationship between the Micro-Asiatic Sitz im Leben and John's Gospel
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Sara Marino, University of Milan
The paper aims to examine the absolute centrality of the Eucharistic practice meant as the effective occurrence of Jesus’ sacrifice for redactors of John’s gospel. The references to "living water"(Jn7:38, 4:14) and to "bread of life"(6:35,6:48,6:51,6:58)are on-going pre-figuration of Jesus’ sacrifice(Jn19,34). Moreover, the liturgical use of water is attested in the Eucharistic practice in the quartodeciman context(Martyrium Pionii). Thus it is clear that, according to the Johannine tradition, the references to the water and bread of life are to be read in close connection to the paschal apocalyptic eschatological context as Rev21,22:12 demonstrates. The Eucharistic practice which for Johannine community expressed in a mysterion a full match on Jesus’ sacrifice mirrored the full effectiveness of Christ’s immolation. It reshaped the Exodus climax in according with John’s timetable frame (14 Nisan). The faithful would then acquire the spirit by virtue of the Eucharistic supper there by becoming a citizen of the eschatological kingdom. From this perspective a Christianity emerges that is other than Pauline’s, which continuous the Jewish apocalyptic tradition. For this Christianity baptism represents a purification practice preliminary and preparatory to the eschatological supper. As evidence of this primitive aspect Acts 2:38 witness the function of baptism in the early Christian pre-Pauline kerygma. The first meaningful point is the separation of the baptism of purification from the obtention of the Spirit. The second one is the finalization of baptism to the remission of sins so perfectly matching the predication of Baptist. The baptism of Spirit would be a later interpretation of John’s baptism. Thus the Ephesians community of Acts 19 would attest this early Christianity traits, which Paul contested and which was already removed in the synoptic tradition. In conclusion John’s gospel present a Jewish paschal theology.
|
“Infants Who Spoke” Topos in the Hadith Literature
Program Unit: The Bible in Arabic in Judaism, Christianity, Islam (EABS)
Joonas Maristo, Helsingin Yliopisto - Helsingfors Universitet
The below passage is from Ibn Ḥanbal’s hadith (Beirut: 309-310):
He [Saʿīd b. Jubayr] said: Ibn ʿAbbās said: Four infants (ṣiġār) spoke: ʿĪsā ibn Maryam, may peace be upon him, companion of Jurayj (ṣāḥib jurayj), witness of Joseph (šāhid yūsif), and the son of the hairdresser of Pharaoh’s daughter (wa-bn māšiṭat ibnat firʿawn).
This is an example of the “Infants who spoke” topos in the hadith literature. It is mentioned numerous times in the hadith literature and the content varies greatly. For instance, the number of the infants varies between two and six. It is not always fixed to four as it is above. Altogether there are scores of hadiths in which the infants who spoke are mentioned.
Interestingly, the infants mentioned seem to be of shared Jewish, Christian and Islamic tradition (isrā͗iliyyāt). These include Jesus, the witness of Joseph, John the Baptist, the Christian monk Jurayj and Pharaoh’s daughter’s hairdresser’s son. The latter is presented in a story which has striking parallels with story of the mother and her seven sons in the book of the Maccabees.
In this paper I will discuss the content and implications of these hadiths within the Islamic tradition. The topos is found in different contexts and conveys different meanings. Regardless of this, I will also argue, that the “infants who spoke” topos forms a motif that can be analyzed separately.
|
Transforming Aliens to Members of the Urban Community: Immigrants and New Citizens in Religious Communities of Ancient Ostia
Program Unit: Citizens and Aliens in Greco-Roman Antiquity (EABS)
Marja-Leena Hänninen, University of Tampere
Ostia, the harbour city of the ancient Rome, was characterized by its cosmopolitan population. A large proportion of the inhabitants was born outside Ostia or outside Italy and many of them were freedmen. Furthermore, Ostia was a city filled with numerous cults and cult sites brought or favoured by immigrants and new citizens, freedmen. In this paper, I’m discussing the social profile of the cult of Magna Mater, Attis and Bellona as well as Mithras. I’m specifically interested in worshippers with immigrant or unfree background. As for the cult of Magna Mater, Attis and Bellona, I’ll argue that despite of the non-elite status it was not a question of a secret sect outside or at the utmost margin of the urban society. On the contrary, participation of the non-elite inhabitants of Ostia in these cults seems to have been a sign of the willingness to belong to the urban community. The cult of Mithras is a different case, since the membership of the cult communities was more exclusive and the communities were basically secret. However, even if the cult of Mithras was less visible than other oriental cults in Ostia and the membership of the communities was more reduced, the Ostian Mithraea and Mithraic communities were practically situated in middle of the urban life, not in distant margins. I’m discussing and comparing the oriental cults of Ostia in context of urban space and society. The paper is based on epigraphic evidence as well as the topography of Ostia. The majority of the evidence dates from the second and early third century AD and, thus, my evidence on the oriental cults in Ostia offers interesting points of comparison with the early Christianity.
|
The Decalogue and Deuteronomistic Deuteronomy
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Law
Dominik Markl, Pontifical Biblical Insitute
Deuteronomy 5-11 appears like a parenetic propylon for the laws in Deuteronomy 12-26. One of its intriguing features is the double reference to Horeb – the Decalogue revelation in Deuteronomy 5 and the Golden Calf story in Deut 9:1-10:11 – and how these passages relate to the parenesis of Deuteronomy 6-8; 10:12-11:32. Moreover, Deuteronomy 5 is a key chapter for the legal hermeneutics of Deuteronomy as Moses explains the origin of his teaching of laws in the divine revelation at Horeb (5:31). This paper will discuss Eckart Otto’s diachronic and synchronic interpretation of Deuteronomy 5-11 in the second volume of his commentary on Deuteronomy.
|
The Rhetoric of Power in Esarhaddon’s Succession Treaties and in Deuteronomy
Program Unit: Authority and Influence in Ancient Times
Dominik Markl, Pontifical Biblical Insitute
Previous studies (esp. by Hans Ulrich Steymans, Eckart Otto and Bernard Levinson) have shown the close similarities between Esarhaddon’s Succession Treaties (EST, 672 BCE) and some texts in Deuteronomy (especially Deuteronomy 13 and the curses of Deuteronomy 28). The discovery of an almost intact copy of EST at Tell Tayinat in 2009 (edited by Jacob Lauinger) has strengthened the historical plausibility of the exposition of a copy of EST in Jerusalem and its direct influence on an early version of Deuteronomy. The present paper will compare the use of rhetoric of power in EST and in Deuteronomy, focusing on four areas. First, the general address of a public audience by an authoritative voice in second person and the exceptional appearance of a voice in first person plural in commissive speech acts; second, metatextual references to and authorizations of the written document (the adê and the “book of the torah” respectively); third, instructions concerning the transgenerational transmittance of the document’s normative content; and fourth, the role of deities in the rhetoric of power. In all four areas, the analysis will show both structural analogies and differences. While EST is a document of immediate written rhetoric of power used as a means of imperial politics, Deuteronomy’s employment of similar techniques is transformed to a higher level of complexity through its embedding into a larger literary complex.
|
Aural Structuring Elements in the Prologue of Mark’s Gospel
Program Unit: Orality and Literacy in Early Christianity (EABS)
Priscille Marschall, Université de Lausanne
The prologue of Mark’s Gospel (Mk 1:1–13) exhibits many patterns which can be called “aural”: that is, patterns that are characteristic of texts intended to be performed. Some of them serve as structuring devices which assist the reader in the process of delivery by indicating the places where breaks are needed – in other words, some aural patterns play a role similar to our modern punctuation marks. The aim of this paper is to highlight the main aural structural elements present in Mk 1:1–13. Regarding method, I will proceed with a colometric analysis, i.e., an attempt to recover the original micro-structure of the passage in terms of côla and periods. This will be done in light of the definitions and examples exposed in ancient rhetorical treatises (Aristotle, Rhetoric; Demetrius, On Style; Rhetoric for Herennius; Cicero, On the Orator and The Orator; Dionysius of Halicarnassus, On Stylistic Composition; Quintilian, Institutes of Oratory; Hermogenes, On Types of Style). The process of colometric analysis will notably show that the prologue of Mark’s Gospel makes frequent use of paromoiosis (parallelism of sounds between côla) and parisosis (similar length between côla), two figures of speech traditionally used by ancient authors to make explicit the structure of their “aural texts.” Finally, I will also address the issue of how the passage should be punctuated – with the use of modern punctuation marks – to preserve as best as possible the original structure.
|
The Old Greek Witness in the Revision of Jacob of Edessa’s Book of Daniel
Program Unit: Septuagint Studies
Bradley J. Marsh, Jr., University of Oxford
Around the year 704-05 CE, the Syriac Orthodox polymath Jacob of Edessa (d. 708 CE) finished editing his own recension of the Book of Daniel-Bel-Dragon-Susanna. He accomplished this by combining the traditional Syriac Peshitta with the various Greek Danielic traditions, resulting in a wholly singular and unique version of one of the Bible’s most enigmatic books. While the principal Greek source Jacob used was indeed the so-called ‘Theodotion’ version, particularly in its Lucianic recension, he also employed the other major Greek form of Daniel, namely the Septuagint or Old Greek. This paper seeks to provide a survey of Jacob’s use of OG-Dan in the construction of his own version, outlining some of its major occurrences as well as sketching out some of the reasons why Jacob may have thought to use the OG, reported by Jerome approximately 300 years beforehand to have been rarely used (or known). The paper will reveal that Jacob clearly had access to more than one witness of OG-Dan, including a MS which transmitted a chronological presentation of the book similar to, but not identical with, the celebrated 3rd century witness pap. 967. For this and other reasons, the forthcoming critical edition of Jacob’s Book of Daniel will present future scholarship with an important witness to the Greek versions of Daniel, particularly with respect to the OG form of the book.
|
Timo Veijola's Finnish Publications and their Influence
Program Unit: Editorial Techniques in the Hebrew Bible in Light of Empirical Evidence (EABS)
Marko Marttila, University of Eastern Finland, Joensuu
In this presentation, Timo Veijola's Finnish contributions will be introduced and evaluated. The intention of these Finnish works often differs from his international studies. Veijola was not only an exegete, but he was also a theologian who was well acquainted with systematic theology. Thus theological and hermeneutical discourse is conspicuous in many of his Finnish essays. Furthermore, Veijola favored to popularise his field of research and thought of a wider audience than just professional scholars.
|
What Now of Reverend Mother? (African) Biblical Hermeneutics in the Context of “Imposed” Barrenness and “Normative” Motherhood
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Madipoane Masenya (Ngwan'a Mphahlele), University of South Africa
In his book, “Reverend Mother”, Henry presents the story which foregrounds some of the practical challenges faced by single women in ordained ministry. The challenges are linked with women’s struggle to navigate an alienating biblical hermeneutic. Reverend Mother’s entry into ordained ministry did not quench her maternal instincts to experience the fruit of her own body. Her craving was thus not for a man as a husband, but for a baby, the fruit of her own womb. As a result of her unconventional choice to fulfil her desire through artificial insemination, the church “…stripped her of her authority, position, and title.” (Henry, 2010). In many a family-orientated, communal hetero-patriarchal (African) Christian settings, contexts in which many a woman, persuaded by a specific biblical hermeneutic, finds herself trapped between “imposed” barrenness and a keen desire to engage in normative motherhood, what kind of hermeneutic may emerge if the Christian Bible is read side by side with the preceding narrative about Reverend Mother? The present paper is an attempt to critically engage the preceding pertinent question in our day.
|
The Art of Reigning in the Book of Chronicles
Program Unit: Concepts of Leadership in the Hebrew Bible (EABS)
Lars Maskow, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
The paper investigates the concept of leadership in the Book of Chronicles.
It is to be shown that the foundation of the chronistic concepts is restricted by the authority of the Torah, which is adopted in two ways. On the one hand, Chronicles explicitly refers to the lexeme Torah in order to evaluate periods of government, on the other hand it implements the discourses of leadership into the narrated story itself by reformulating it accordingly to the Torah.
In particular, the Chronistic discourse of leadership provides evidence for the thesis that the concept of a kingdom of priests, which is developed in the latest priestly strata of the Pentateuch, is enforced and simultaneously continued (fortgeschrieben) in Chronicles under the signs of Judean monarchy that can only be narrated. The hegemony of the Zadokites in Chronicles thereby unfolds the latent hermeneutic potential of the Torah, according to which the Levite-Zadokite-line connects with the Judean line in Exod. 6,14-25.
On the basis of some key texts it will be shown that Chronicles, insofar as it is directly linked to the so called Theocratic Editions of the Pentateuch, is a Fortschreibung of the priestly discourse of the Torah. In addition, there are indications that for the first time in Chronicles a complete enforcement of the Royal Law (Deut. 17,14-20) is to be expected. In this respect, the prehistory of the late priestly strata of the Torah is a condition for the development of the concept of leadership in Chronicles. However, the indirect elaboration with the implicit pragmatics of rewritten scripture, gives the Book of Chronicle less the character of a charter of law than an artful compromise document.
|
Unholy Bodies Navigating Sacred Places: Embodied Space and Communal Identity in the Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Place, Space, and Identity in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Joshua M. Matson, Florida State University
The intersection of the human body and physical space occupies a prominent position in the milieu of ancient Judaism. Scholarly discussions on this prominence, however, have primarily focused on communal purity law as preserved in the Hebrew Bible and its relation to the preservation of the clearly marked sacred spaces of the tabernacle and Jerusalem temple. These conclusions have influenced our current understanding about the human body in the Dead Sea Scrolls. While these studies have proved instructive in understanding a view of sacred space in ancient Judaism, they have largely overlooked the symbiotic relationship between the materiality of space and the role of the human body in producing, perceiving, and influencing the construction of place. Separated from these traditional approaches, the Dead Sea Scrolls can shed additional light on Second Temple Jewish presentations of the human body as it relates to the production and perception of space. Employing the three-fold anthropological model of space as proposed by Setha M. Low upon references to the human body in the Dead Sea Scrolls, this paper argues that the body plays an integral part in producing ideas of sacred places and identity among the Dead Sea Scrolls community. The implications in this study include a new form of spatiality in ancient Judaism that is centered on the individual and their movement throughout their respective communities. By adjusting our focus on how the individual moves through space on their own trajectory, while at the same time acknowledging the underlying importance of the political and social production and reproduction of pathways created by such movement, we are challenged to look at the body in spaces and places that evolve the identity of the community itself.
|
Lesbian Resistance in the Heart of the Beast
Program Unit: Europe Contested: Contemporary Bible Readings Performed by "Ordinary" Readers in a European Context (EABS)
Kathleen McCallie, Phillips Theological Seminary
Oklahoma is one of the most conservative geopolitical regions in the United States. Lack of education, poverty, and fundamentalist biblical teaching intersect in a culture of hostility to feminist and queer liberationist ideas. Biblical texts are frequently used to bully and shun LGBTQ persons, and lesbians as a specific group are often non-believers for good reasons. I theorize from my experience reading texts like Romans 1:24-28 with non-believers who are lesbians. These women are seeking narratives to disrupt local oppression rooted in homophobia and gynophobia powered by Christendom. Oppressive readings of biblical texts perpetuate Eurocentric traditions of sexism and heterosexism. In contrast, our hermeneutic of suspicion makes room for alternative, collaborative readings and empower lesbians through exploration of essential questions regarding textual authority, revelation, and imperialistic, colonial institutions. As an ordained pastor working in the LGBTQ community for more than two decades, I continue to deepen my research reading these texts with non-believers in ways that can be literally save lives. Suicide, addiction, and self-destructive behavior within the LGBTQ population in this region of the United States continue due to frequent rejection by families of origin. Fundamentalist reading of biblical texts primarily causes this condemnation and rejection. Lesbian activists in Oklahoma are working to change discriminatory policies regarding employment, housing, and child custody. Learning to utilize liberatory reading of biblical texts and correct erroneous readings is crucial even for non-believers. A hermeneutic of mutual respect requires that I am not interested in persuading others to become believers. Conversion is not the goal of dialogue with non-believers. My hermeneutic of suspicion requires self-examination regarding my own motives and theological positions. Lesbians who are believers and those who are non-believers share the goal of mitigating harm inflicted through literalist readings of biblical texts.
|
The Ancient Synagogue at Horvat Kur, Galilee: Excavations 2010-2018
Program Unit: Archaeological Fieldwork in the Hellenistic-Roman Mediterranean (EABS)
Raimo Hakola, University of Helsinki
Seven (7) seasons of excavation at Horvat Kur in the Lower Galilee (New Israeli Grid 25050-60/ 75450-60) have exposed the remains of a broad-house basilical synagogue from the Late Roman and Early Byzantine period. The excavations are sponsored by Leiden University (Netherlands), University of Bern (Switzerland), University of Helsinki (Finland), and Florida Atlantic University (USA). This paper will present the architecture and stratigraphy of the synagogue, including notable finds such as a "seat of Moses," a stone table, and a mosaic floor featuring a menorah and an Aramaic inscription. The architecture and stratigraphy of adjacent houses will also be described.
|
The Gift of Teaching Theology Through Music (Rom 12:7)
Program Unit: Early Christianity (EABS)
Teresa Lee McCaskill, University of Edinburgh
Music has been intertwined with the worship of deity in western culture since the time of antiquity. Considered by pagans as a divine gift, music became a significant tool for teaching worshipers both how to approach the gods and how to understand their character. Music thus became an important medium for teaching theology in the ancient world. This tradition of musical instruction helped shape the religious education of pagan worshipers who became early Christ-followers.
My PhD thesis investigates the transition gentile believers faced as they emerged as monotheistic worshipers in first-century Rome. Abandoning myriad cultic practices, they must now find religious activities that are appropriate for their new belief system. Paul’s epistle affirms their new faith, and re-orients their formerly polytheistic worship expressions by recognizing their uniquely gentile liturgical dilemma. I posit that he accordingly presents seven gifts in Rom 12:6-8 that function as replacements for previous cultic practices. As practical expressions of "reasonable worship" (12:1-2), these gifts, already familiar to Roman gentiles from their pagan past, are re-purposed to help them progress in their new faith.
My paper will focus on didaskalia, the gift of teaching. Surveying the Greco-Roman literature that refers to religious instruction, I have found that pagans in the ancient world used music to teach about the gods. A professional teacher of music was in fact called a didaskalos. Considering the importance that music had played in the pagan worship practices of Paul’s gentile audience, I submit that the gift of didaskalia may reflect his assessment that music would continue to be of value for theological instruction in the new faith system he envisioned for these early adherents.
|
The Liminal Spirit: Ritual Initiatory Praxis in the Early Christian Sect
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
David McCollough, Durham University
This paper employs discourse analysis, narratology and literary analysis to outline the ritual dimension of Luke’s ecclesiology. Through his didactic narrative, Luke prescribes a ritual initiation structure that is coherent and internally consistent, with an allowance for variation which comports well with ‘real world’ ritual behaviour. Luke presents Christian initiation as a liminal process consisting of belief in the kerygma, repentance, immersion in water, prayer by the initiate for the Spirit, prayer with handlaying by particularly powerful ritual elders to transmit the Spirit, and, climactically, dissociative tongues speaking combined with an intelligible element, which, in its gestalt, is consistent with the traditional tongues speaking practices of the community and which is conceptualised as the experience of Spirit reception. Luke’s initiation praxis is then analysed in terms of the anthropology of religion: Mary Douglas, grid and group; Victor Turner, liminality and communitas; Maurice Bloch/Douglas Davies, rebounding conquest/rebounding vitality; Marcel Mauss/Maurice Godelier, the fourth obligation; Clifford Geertz, models of and for.
|
Moabites, Edomites, Canaanites, Hittites, Hivites, Perizzites, Girgashites, Amorites, and Jebusites: Are They All Bad? Or Do They Represent Convenient ‘Whipping Boys?”
Program Unit: Psychological Hermeneutics of Biblical Themes and Texts
Heather A. McKay, Edge Hill University, UK
Reading through the texts in the Bible where these tribal names are listed—as often as not—accompanied by some negative connotation, the alert reader wonders about what exactly can be the purpose/s of such blanket excoriation/s.
Some psychological understandings become useful at this point. The Israelites lived in a relatively fertile land which was positioned between two much richer superpowers, and they often encountered the negative effects of their position—between ‘the king of the north’ and the king of the south” (KJV notations).
In particular, understandings of the psychological strategies of regression, rationalisation and sublimation can give some explanations and answers. Through the device of regression, the writers may position themselves as the dependent and needy children of a powerful God and father figure, while through rationalisation they can excuse their desperate desire to curse or eliminate those threatening their livelihood or survival as proper responses to that threat. And, through sublimation, they can tell themselves that these violent changes are what their loving and powerful God want for them; they are merely his helpers in carrying out his divine plans.
Various texts will be explored with these issues in mind.
|
Social Evolution of the Central Highlands of Israel in the Iron Age I: A Neo-evolutionary Perspective on the Current Polarity of Israelite State Development
Program Unit: The Biblical World and Cultural Evolution (EABS)
James Mclellan, Bar-Ilan University
This talk re-examines the contention surrounding Israel’s central highland polity formation in the Iron Age I from a neo-evolutionary perspective. Studies on the development of the ‘Israelite state’ in the 21st century have largely failed to incorporate anthropological theory alongside biblical and archaeological data and often the true value of cross-cultural analogues are misunderstood and devalued. This is in opposition to the original monographs of the 20th century on the settlement-statehood process and to the methodology particular to social-cultural evolutionary theory. Recently, Faust argued that Israelite Iron Age state formation resulted from phases of destruction and abandonment, due to external incursions, encouraging the crystallization of a central highland identity that ‘pushed’ the occupants into remaining regional centers thereby forming the basis of the monarchy (2003, 2006b, 2007, 2015). Essentially, an application of Carneiro’s ‘circumscription’ theory documented in the biblical and archaeological record. Finkelstein objects to Faust’s methodology (Finkelstein 2005) and in his latest monograph (2013), he identifies continuity from the LB into the Iron I-II, which largely rejecting the biblical narrative. The current polarity illuminates the problematic nature of tracing the Israelite state. Despite a general modern objectivity and more archaeological data being presently available now than in previous decades, the methodology of the subject lacks much consensus and there is a need for growth in the understanding of the process. While many have sought to identify conspicuous architectural features and other material correlates between the early highland settlements and Israel’s Iron Age state(s), abstract ideas are just as susceptible to cultural transmission. The concepts of power and authority, which this study views as a primary driver of societal change and the cause of complex social organizations, are emphasized in this talk and examined in an attempt to showcase the evolutionary nature of Israel’s Iron Age settlement-statehood trajectory.
|
The Bare Life of a Gerasene (Luke 8:26-39)
Program Unit: Postcolonial Studies
Luis Menéndez-Antuña, Graduate Theological Union (Berkeley)
Theory-based approaches (i.e. Postcolonial and Empire Studies) interpret the Gerasene (Luke 8:26-39) as a colonized subject, the demons—not coincidentally named Legion—as a metaphor for Roman occupation, and the exorcism as an emancipatory process whereby Jesus restitutes his dignity back. In such studies, the focus is on Jesus’ actions and on the exorcism itself. In this paper I argue that these interpretations swiftly skip over the political and ethical singularity (Spivak) of the Gerasene: homeless, naked, living among the dead, shackled, isolated, the demon-possessed is an exceptional character. My argument focuses on one feature of such exceptionality: his (a)political status (he is located outside the basic political units: oikos and polis) understood as “bare life” (Agamben).
|
A Contextual Observation of the Biblical Depiction of Persia
Program Unit: Contextual Interpretation of the Bible (Hebrew Bible/Old Testament and New Testament)
MENG Zhenhua, Nanjing University
Scholars have shown great interest in the issue of the relations between Israelites and the ancient foreign countries they actively or passively dealt with, with special focus on the situation of the Restoration period. When Yehud became a relatively unimportant part of the Persian regime, the Achaemenids shaped and formulated their policy on Yehud for the empire’s own interest and showed no more mercy than their predecessors. However, the biblical authors, many of whom were favored and supported by the Persians, endeavored to venerate the foreign rulers in their work and depicted Cyrus as a generous and benevolent savior of the Israelites. The typical brutal, evil and wicked character of foreign monarch does not apply to Persian kings. This presentation will analyze the biblical texts about and attitude toward Persia in the context of modern Asia, in which a number of people also expressed their praise to the Japanese invaders and rulers and even identified themselves as real Japanese. There are more complicated reasons for their ideas and behaviors and a cross-textual reading of the two stories will shed light on each other and help understand the complexity of this phenomenon.
|
The Ritual of Yom Kippur Interpreted in the Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Sarianna Metso, University of Toronto
The text of Leviticus 16 describing the rituals of atonement on Yom Kippur is preserved in only two fragmentary scriptural texts found at Qumran, but echoes of its wordings are detectable in several non-scriptural texts. Much scholarly attention has been paid to apocalyptic texts and the figure of Azazel-first mentioned in Lev 16: 8, 10 and 26-to whom the sin-carrying goat is sent in the wilderness. A connection between Lev 16:21 and the formulaic language of penitential prayers has also been established. The main focus of this paper, however, will be on rule texts, and various sections of the Community Rule in particular. The paper aims at demonstrating a broad textual link in the Scrolls between the ritual of atonement and the wilderness landscape, and examines the notion of the yaḥad withdrawing into the wilderness to atone for its members, for the whole Israel, and for the land.
|
Moses the Martyr: A Martyrological Reading of Hebrews 11
Program Unit: Epistle to the Hebrews
Paul Middleton, University of Chester
While the roll call of the heroes of faith in Hebrews 11 contains explicit references to martyrs (11.34–38), they are usually interpreted as comprising a subset of exemplars of Faith alongside other significant Hebrew Bible figures who demonstrated that Faith in different ways. This paper, instead, argues there are strong martyrological elements planted throughout chapter 11, such that those mentioned at the end become the climax of a list of heroes who have in some way undergone (albeit metaphorical) martyrdom. While I will illustrate this claim using a number of figures from the chapter, the paper will focus on the way in which the character of Moses has been refracted through a martyrological lens (11.23–29), such that he proleptically conforms to the model of Christ’s suffering (11.26). Moreover, chapter 11 is situated between two sections of the letter which, I will argue, deal with potential martyrdom (10.26–39; 12.3–7). Therefore, the rhetorical force of the chapter highlights not merely examples of faith, but faith potentially leading to martyrdom. Among these examples is Moses, who imitated the same sufferings of Christ which the Hebrews are in turn called to emulate (13.13).
|
Why Did Paul Ask Men Not to Cover Their Heads and Women to Cover Their Heads? Interpretation of the Passage in 1 Cor. 11:2–16.
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Anne Mikkola, University of Helsinki
This paper suggests a specific type of conflict in Corinth that allows us to make sense of Paul’s contradictory sounding argument from the beginning to the end – along with its exegetically contradictory details. Paul’s argumentation is assumed to be logical and consistent with his theology elsewhere. The interpretation combines results from previous research.
The key new insight comes from the realization that a) the Corinthian class and status conflict would likely exist among women as well as among men, rather than between genders only, b) hairdo and head-coverings in worship reflected one’s social status and c) punctuation marks in the Greek text were added much later, so they can be ignored. Combining a) and b) means that the conflict on head-coverings was plausibly related to a conflict amongst women and amongst men of different social classes. While Paul addresses the whole congregation, he does not want to point his finger directly at any one specific group. The pieces of the puzzle fit together once we allow for the possibility that Paul is simultaneously addressing less respected women of mystery cult background who let their hair loose, and those God-fearers or Jewish women who prefer to cover their heads as an indication of their status. Similarly, the upper-class men demonstrate their status by covering their heads while praying and prophesying. Paul addresses the various parties by choosing words with multiple meanings and connotations that function to connect everyday issues to heavenly reality (like “head”, “glory”, “uncover”, “power or authority”). All the parties are challenged towards culturally acceptable behavior as they focus on the theological truths they can agree on.
|
Metaphoric Dynamics in Proverb Translation: Insights from Paremiology and Cognitive Linguistics
Program Unit: Bible Translation Workshop (EABS)
Suzanna Millar, University of Leeds
The concise sayings in Proverbs 10-29 are very difficult to translate. Many contain terse grammar, metaphors, or linguistic ambiguities, and they do not have a clear literary context to elucidate them. This is not an incidental feature of the sayings, but is at the heart of what a proverb is. Paremiologists (those who study the proverb genre) have stressed that the textual meaning of a proverb can never be its total meaning: a proverb requires application to a situation to be fully meaningful. It must be ‘translated’ into its new setting, and it picks up particular nuances along the way. Recent paremiologists have begun to use Fauconnier and Turner’s Blend Theory to describe these dynamics. The process is metaphoric: the ‘source’ proverb is blended imaginatively with the ever-new ‘target’ situation.
This paper uses insights from paremiology and cognitive linguistics (especially Blend Theory) to explore the interplay between source proverb and target situation; along with source language and target language (as two comparable ‘translation’ processes). It asks how the open-endedness of a proverb text might be retained in translation. Yet it also reflects that the open-endedness is there so that the proverb might acquire fresh meanings in different situations. Perhaps then, the fresh meanings acquired through translation are part of the inherent joy of the genre, and are not its nemesis.
|
Dining on Destruction: The Pedagogical Power of a Metaphorical World in Proverbs
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible (EABS)
Suzanna Millar, University of Leeds
From Lady Wisdom’s feast (Prov 9:1-6) to King Lemuel’s “strong drink” (31:4-7), imagery of food abounds in the book of Proverbs. Often it is used metaphorically – scholars have particularly highlighted how it depicts the wisdom and edifying words the disciple must ingest. This paper examines a converse manifestation of the metaphor. Over the course of the book, a network of mutually-interpretive proverbs develops, in which the “food” is not wisdom, but wickedness. This metaphor has a double thrust. An individual “eats” evil as a foodstuff. This evil empowers their activity, energising their wicked deeds. And yet it also proves a poison – they have been dining on their own destruction. This network of metaphors is didactically significant. It develops into a world where one’s “act” (internalising wickedness) intrinsically corresponds to “consequence” (being poisoned), and thus it becomes a powerful disincentive from wickedness. By chewing over this imagery – in individual proverbs and across the book as a whole – this paper highlights the pedagogical power of the emerging metaphorical world.
|
Creating History: Comparing Book Divisions and Book Orders of the Former Prophets and the Historical Book of the LXX
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
Matthias Millard, Kirchliche Hochschule Wuppertal/Bethel
This paper will focus on the differences between the Hebrew Bible and the LXX by the different position of the book of Rut and the different divisions within Samuel and Kings. In the context of the question of the canon group of this year we can regard how different framing texts create new contexts with different theological emphases.
|
Is the Biblical City Sustainable?
Program Unit: The Bible and Ecology (EABS)
Mary Mills, Liverpool Hope University
This paper aims to explore the presentation of city life in terms of potential crossovers between verdicts of biblical texts on the life/death of narrated cities and modern environmental critique of sustainable cities. It examines the dual perspectives of city as ultimate secure site and as danger to survival, drawing out both historical and symbolic portrayals of biblical cities, before addressing the scope of the term apocalypse as a form of language common to ancient texts and modern environmentalism. The paper concludes that although there are many differences between ancient approaches to walled
Enclaves and modern urban anxiety, not least the reversal of nature as threat to built environment to the unbearable pressure the built environment places on the resources of planet earth, it is viable to work towards a biblical urban ecology.
|
Biblical Written Tradition and its Transformation in the Slavonic Oracles of Leo the Wise
Program Unit: Rethinking Biblical Written Tradition through Slavonic Interpretations
Anissava Miltenova, Institute for Literature Bulgarian Academy of Sciences
The specific semantic and historical framework of the content of the so-called Oracles (Χρησµοί) of the Byzantine Emperor Leo VI the Wise (886–912) allow their constant updating, or reinterpretation, over the centuries and particularly their re-functionalising in the Post-Byzantine period. The Middle Bulgarian translation of the Χρησµοί is supposed to date from the 12th century. It spread in Serbian, Russian and South Russian manuscripts and was used as a source for compiling new works. The quotations from the Scripture are in the key position in the texts and their identification and comparison with other sources is an important part of the research. The center of South Slavonic texts features a motif about 'redeemer ruler', woven with traits of real historical personalities The circulation of the Slavic translation of the Oracles of Leo the Wise among Serbians and Bulgarians and its resonance in other texts with similar contents is a significant part of the development of the apocalyptic and historical literature in the Balkans, as it shows the transformation of the translated works in accord with the historical reality.
|
South Slavonic Apocryphal Collections
Program Unit: Slavonic Apocrypha (EABS)
Anissava Miltenova, Institute for Literature Bulgarian Academy of Sciences
Research on ‘miscellanies of mixed content’ is needed both in the field of contemporary palaeoslavic studies and the history of Byzantine-Slavonic literary contacts. No less important are the relations between Eastern Slavonic (Russian, Ukrainian and Carpathian) and Romanian literature. There are also resonances of Judaic, Early Christian and Middle Eastern tradition. I have made a survey of the essence and scope of the concept of ‘mixed-content miscellany’ as a type of edifying and instructive book, its audience and specific features. My objectives are twofold: to extract complete archaeographic and content data from almost 50 manuscripts and to make a typology of the miscellanies. A few are not mentioned in reference books, and others lack analytical descriptions. Every miscellany includes 35-40 texts (self-dependent or in a series) that are coherent and interwoven throughout the larger collection. It is very important to view the transmission of the texts and their filiation during the development of the literature in the 13th–17th centuries. A typology of manuscripts is supported by plectograms produced in the project, “Repertorium of Old Bulgarian Literature and Letters” (http://repertorium.obdurodon.org/).
|
The Liar Paradox in Titus 1:12
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Richard K. Min, University of Texas at Dallas
The text in Titus 1:12 presents a prophet who is a Cretan and thus a member of the larger group of Cretans to whom he is referring in his prophecy of self-negation. That is, the Cretan prophet is referring to himself, creating a circular reference by referring to the Cretan community of which he is a member. The paradoxical question and problem in Titus 1:12 is whether the prophet himself is also a liar as he declares that every Cretan is always a liar. A similar passage is found in Romans 3:4 where Paul declares that all men are liars, citing the passage in Psalm 116:11. The difficulty in the Liar paradox is the presence of a self-negation in the circular relationship. In this paradox, even though not explicitly stated, a negative implication is clearly present. Negation in circular reasoning not only presents a challenge, but also complicates the matter with respect to its meaning and validity. Circular rhetoric (e.g., idem per idem) has been one of the most misunderstood or controversial areas in contemporary biblical scholarship for the latter half of the 20th century. Recently there has been a renewed interest due to a new approach by Richard Min with many groundbreaking results in biblical exegesis and hermeneutics. The author identifies and explores circular rhetoric and paradox in Titus 1:12, and its implication in exegesis and hermeneutics, to provide a viable alternative, to defend the validity of 1 Titus 1:12. Further the author explores and presents a new paradigm in exegesis and interpretive framework to understand and analyze circular rhetoric and its exegetical challenges.
|
Born Again: Circular Rhetoric and Paradox in John 3
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Richard K. Min, The University of Texas at Dallas
Circular rhetoric is frequently found in the Bible. A literary cycle is formed to reference oneself in self-reference or in circular relationship (e.g., idem per idem). To name a few, some of the well-known circular expressions in John include: the testimony of John the Baptist about the coming Christ in John 1:15, 30, "grace for grace" in John 1:16, the "I am" saying of Jesus in John 8:11–20, or the mutual-indwelling "be in" relationship of the Father and the Son in John 10:38. In contrast to the frequent use, circular rhetoric has been one of the most ignored, confused, misunderstood, or controversial areas in contemporary biblical scholarship for the latter half of the twentieth century. The author explored various cases of circular rhetoric and the associated problems of paradox in the Bible, and proposed a novel approach and solutions to the problems with a new exegetical method with many groundbreaking results. In the paper, the author investigates and explores circular rhetoric in John 3, especially dealing with the expression of being "born again" (John 3:3, 7) and the paradox expressed by Nicodemus (John 3:4). The passages about the Kingdom of God in John 3 are further examined in the framework of Salvation History (Heilsgeschichte) dealing with the two-stage coming of the Kingdom of God as a temporal-modal paradox of "already" and "not yet" in tension.
|
The Son of God in Psalm 110 in the Light of the New Testament
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Richard K. Min, The University of Texas at Dallas
As warned by the author of Hebrews, two passages in Psalm 110 generate the enormous controversies and difficulties in New Testament study and exegesis. The first controversy and paradox about the Son of God is the problem of the lordship of Christ. He is the son of David. Yet he is being addressed by David as "my lord" (Psalm 110:1). The paradox deals with the extended human "father-son" relationship in the law, with the divine-human relationship (of lord-servant). This divine lordship of the Son of God is professed by David who is the very author of this psalm and the father of the son of David. All synoptic gospels deal with the passage (Psalm 110:1) as having great significance (Matthew 22:41–46; Mark 12:35–37; Luke 20:41–44). The second controversy and paradox of the Son of God in Psalm 110:4 is the problem of the priesthood of the Son of God who is from the tribe of Judah (Hebrews 7:14–15). According to the law, to have a priest outside of the tribe of Levi and according to the order of Aaronic lineage is impossible. The legal question is how it could be possible for Christ, the son of David, to be a priest of God. This controversy has never been dealt with or resolved in any part of the New Testament except in Hebrews. The paper presents and extends this new perspective and paradigm of circular rhetoric and paradox in the Bible.
|
The Function of Enoch and Elijah in the Eschatological Scenario of the Apocalypse of Elijah
Program Unit: Enoch within and outside the Books of Enoch: Parabiblical Writings, Iconography and Oral Tradition (EABS)
Ivan Miroshnikov, University of Helsinki
The Apocalypse of Elijah, at least in its present form, is an early Christian text which by recycling earlier eschatological traditions (e.g., the notion of the two witnesses in the Book of Revelation and that of the transformation of the body in the eschatological resurrection in 1 Corinthians 15) offers an idiosyncratic account of the victory over the Antichrist and the end of the world.
In this eschatological scenario, Enoch and Elijah—the two righteous persons taken to heavens alive—play a unique role. First, they descend onto the earth to rebuke the Antichrist and die. Second, God raises them from the dead and then they (apparently) ascend to heavens. Third, as the final stage of the last judgment, they descend once again to transform their “flesh of the world” into “flesh of the spirit,” which appears to be a prerequisite for killing the Antichrist and imprisoning the sinners in hell. This presentation will seek the origins and logic of this eschatological scenario.
|
Deed and Danger in Proverbs and Ben Sira
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Wisdom
Jesse Mirotznik, Harvard University
The Book of Proverbs, as has long been noted, assumes a 'deed-consequence nexus,' in which ethical behavior will be consistently rewarded with a positive outcome, even if after a slight delay. As a result of this optimistic worldview, Proverbs is often willing to countenance cautious engagement with dangerous individuals (such as kings, enemies, fools and sinners) in the belief that proper behavior will guard against the risks inherently posed by interaction with such threatening characters. "A king's wrath is a messenger of death," states Proverbs, "but a wise man may appease it." Despite his terrifying might, a clever courtier may find a way to mollify the monarch. The Wisdom of Ben Sira, in its explicit discussions of ethics and justice, tends to closely reproduce the confidence in the deed-consequence nexus which Proverbs declares. Yet the compilation's actual, concrete advice, rather than encouraging the cautious engagement with danger found in Proverbs, exhorts the addressee to total avoidance of threatening agents. Despite explicitly towing the party line of Proverb's deed-consequence nexus, then, Ben Sira's direct recommendations imply a much more pessimistic state of mind-- an operative worldview in which proper behavior may not provide protection against the lurking dangers of the world. " Do not lift a weight too heavy for you," Ben Sira instructs, "or associate with one mightier and richer than you. How can the clay pot associate with the iron kettle? The pot will strike against it and be smashed." This paper will seek to demonstrate the ways in which Sirach, while paying explicit lip service to the worldview presented in the book of Proverbs--and thus demonstrating a certain attitude of deference to it--nonetheless consistently undermines that worldview in the practical advice which it offers to its readers.
|
Importance of Intertextuality in Medieval Slavonic Literature: Apocalypse of Pseudo-Methodius in the Legend of Twelve Fridays as a Case
Program Unit: Rethinking Biblical Written Tradition through Slavonic Interpretations
Keiko Mitani, University of Tokyo
Intertextuality is of particular importance when studying medieval Slavonic texts, not only because it uncovers the textual relationship but also because it could be suggestive of the formation process of a particular text. This presentation treats the special textual relationship between the Slavonic translation of Apocalypse of Pseudo-Methodius and the Eleutherius recension of the Legend of Twelve Fridays, focusing on a parallelism found in these texts. The impact of Apocalypse of Pseudo-Methodius-one of the most influential texts of the eschatological theme in the medieval literature-on the development of medieval Slavonic literature has been observed in various genres of texts. A notable example of this may be some reminiscences of the Apocalypse in the Russian Primary Chronicle, which indicate the early encounter of Slavs with this eschatological literature. Another less known, though no less significant, example concerning the textual influence of Apocalypse in Slavonic writings is the Eleutherius recension of the Legend of Twelve Fridays, an apocryphon of unclear provenance circulated broadly in the medieval Slavic world. Although the intertextual relationship of these two texts has long been noted, there is still an interesting parallelism between them that has remained scarcely noticed until today. Drawing attention to this phenomenon, this presentation argues that the involvement of Apocalypse in the formation of the Legend of Twelve Fridays could be much more significant than has been considered to be so far. It also points out the possibility that there existed a variant of Slavonic Apocalypse that was different from the two, identified by V. Istrin as of old Bulgarian provenance.
|
David and Darics: Reconsidering an Anachronism in 1 Chronicles 29
Program Unit: Concepts of Leadership in the Hebrew Bible (EABS)
Christine Mitchell, St. Andrew's College, University of Saskatchewan
In 1 Chr 29:7, the people give gold, silver, and other precious items for the construction of the Jerusalem temple. The term “daric” is used to identify the form of some of the gold. The daric coin, possibly although not necessarily named after Darius the Great, was a well-known coin of the Achaemenid period, having an archer on the obverse and an incised rectangle on the reverse. It is an obvious anachronism, and the reference in 1 Chr 29:7 is the only use in Hebrew/Aramaic biblical texts not set in a Persian context. While it is possible to argue that the author of Chronicles did not know the origin or meaning of “daric,” in this paper I will engage in a thought-experiment that assumes that the author did know the origin of the term. The iconography of coins had high symbolic and ideological value – so what was David doing collecting darics from the people of Jerusalem? The answers to this question lead to a comparison of David and Darius.
|
Hunting, Illicit Sex, and Pollution: Metaphor Clusters in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible (EABS)
Abir Mitra, Université Catholique de Louvain/KU Leuven
In keeping with this year's set topic, i.e. "networks of metaphors in the Bible", this paper focuses on specific type(s) of metaphor clusters in the Hebrew Bible. Several genres in the Hebrew Bible - narrative texts, prophecy, and poetry - contain metaphor clusters in which the domains of hunting and illicit sexual relations co-occur as source domains (e.g., Judg. 8:27; Psa. 106:36-39; Hos. 5:1-3). A vast majority of these metaphors are found in anti-idolatry polemics that conceptualize idolatry in terms of hunting and illicit sex in which the conceptual domain of pollution often plays a crucial role acting as an additional source domain. In other texts, particularly in Proverbs, the domains of hunting and illicit sex co-occur in slightly different argumentative contexts involving practical hazards of illicit sexual liaisons from which the domain of pollution is usually absent (e.g., Prov. 6:26; 7:22-23). In this study, focusing on select metaphor clusters from a wide variety of biblical genres, I shall explore the raison d'être of these co-occurring domains in metaphor clusters and their implications based on the similarities and differences they display across diverse literary and theological contexts.
|
The Use of Digital Tools in Studies of Biblical Intertextuality in Early Christian Authors: The Case of Shenoute and Besa, Coptic Abbots in the 4-5th Centuries
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
So Miyagawa, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
Two current projects at the Göttingen Academy of Sciences and Humanities and the University of Göttingen are dedicated to digital research in the Coptic Bible and Coptic literature: the long-term project of a “Digital Edition of the Coptic Old Testament” and the project “Scriptural Interpretation and Educational Tradition in Coptic-speaking Egyptian Christianity of Late Antiquity: Shenoute, Canon 6” project, in the framework of the Collaborative Research Centre 1136 “Education and Religion”.
The former project involves the development of digital manuscript editions, a critical edition and translations of the (Sahidic-)Coptic Old Testament in cooperation with the Coptic New Testament edition in Münster, while the latter has, as one of its goals, a digital online edition of the manuscripts transmitting Canon 6 of Shenoute († 465) and the works of his successor Besa.
This paper examines how, on the basis of manuscripts digitized by these projects, Biblical intertextuality can be studied using the TRACER text reuse detection tool, which was created by the eTRAP research group (Institute of Computer Science, University of Göttingen). For this purpose, we developed an OCR tool to extract digital Unicode texts from existing Coptic printed editions. We then created the base text of Shenoute, Canon 6 and Besa’s works and adjusted this base text by collating photos of all available manuscript pages. We subsequently employed corpus linguistics tools, including the lemmatizer, tokenizer, morphological and syntactical parsers of Coptic SCRIPTORIUM, to generate linguistically annotated XML corpora. Finally, we ran TRACER on the digital texts of Shenoute Canon 6, Besa and the Bible, as far as available. We compared the results of the TRACER with text reuses previously identified by scholars and evaluated the effectiveness of TRACER within the intertextuality studies on early Christian texts.
|
Healing a Holy Traumatized City: Transformation of the City of Jerusalem in the Book of Isaiah
Program Unit: Prophets and Prophecy (EABS)
Zafer Mohammad, Tel Aviv University
To manifest Yahweh’s gracious attitude towards Jerusalem, the chapters of the book of Isaiah develop theological and literary mechanisms to envisage Jerusalem’s transformation by which her former times of miseries and anguish are eliminated and answered by new proclamations of hopes, promises, and consolations in the book. As a result, Jerusalem’s theological prominence, glory, peace, and centrality are greatly celebrated and experienced. In her most dismal times, Jerusalem has been called a “whore” (1:21), the vulnerable and besieged city (1:8), the ruined city (3:26), and the city of chaos (24:10). Moreover, Jerusalem had devoted herself in vain to her collections of idols (57:13). Corruption was prevalent in the milieu of the holy city (1:22-23). To judge her, Yahweh had besieged and distressed her (29-1-3). Her people had made covenant with death (28:15), and the holy city had stumbled (3:8). To respond to all that gloominess and darkness which overshadow the plight of Jerusalem in her dire past, the book of Isaiah also contains another cluster of promising portrayals which are related to the restoration of Jerusalem and her transformation. These hopeful depictions exhibit promising circumstances that will be prevalent in the restored Jerusalem. In her promising times, the pilgrims of nations and Israel shall be streaming to Zion (2:3), and they shall be bringing gifts (18:7). The holy city’s re-building and restoration are announced and promised (44:28). In addition to that, Jerusalem’s wilderness will be made by Yahweh like the Garden of Eden (51:3). Eyes will see Jerusalem as a quiet and peaceful habitation (33:20), and Yahweh shall arrange a universal banquet at Mount Zion and Yahweh restores his holy presence at the city (25:6). Quite obviously, these promising references present redemptive theological perspectives about the forthcoming destiny of Jerusalem in which the traumatized holy city is consoled and delivered.
|
A Study of the References to Jerusalem in Her Promising Times in the Judaeo-Arabic Versions of the Book of Isaiah
Program Unit: The Bible in Arabic in Judaism, Christianity, Islam (EABS)
Zafer Mohammad, Biblia Arabica Research Project
The presentation primarily focuses on the translations of the references to Jerusalem in her promising/new times in the Judaeo-Arabic versions of the book of Isaiah, especially Saadiah Gaon's recension and Yefet ben Eli's commentary on Isaiah. The primary focus is to analyze these references in order to reveal how Jerusalem’s promising times have been articulated and expressed in these translations. Various issues pertaining to syntax, style, grammar, and vocabulary will be examined. Moreover, and a comparison with other ancient versions such as the Targum, Vulgate, Qumran, Septuagint, and the Masoretic text will be made in order to provide a broader spectrum of the exegetical meanings of these translations. The influences of Quranic and Islamic terminology and themes will be also examined. The presentation deals with four major interconnected questions. First, what are the theological, social, cultural, and political perspectives which have influenced these Arabic translations as far as the status of Jerusalem in her new times is concerned? Second, how has Jerusalem’s transformation and her deliverance been conveyed in these translations? Third, what did these translations have in common and on what points did they disagree on the status of Jerusalem in her new times? Last, can the reader discern any signs of theological conflict between Jews and Muslims on the definition and articulation of the legitimate authority over Jerusalem after her deliverance and transformation?
|
Repeated Death-Notices: Redactional and/or Literary Technique
Program Unit: Intersections: A Forum for Research on Ancient Israel, Hebrew Bible, and Cognate Topics (EABS)
Paola Mollo, Pontifical Biblical Institute (Rome)
The repeated death-notice of Joshua (Josh 24:28-31; Judg 1:1 and 2:6-10) deserves special attention. Because of its location at both the end of the book of Joshua and the beginning of the book of Judges, it is considered relevant for the redactional history of these two books. It has been compared with the repeated death-notice of Moses (Dt 34:5-9; Josh 1:1-2), which is also situated at an important narrative "connection" between the end of Deuteronomy and the beginning of Joshua, and with that of Joseph (Gen 50:26; Exod 1:6), which closes the patriarchal age in Genesis and introduces the history of the people of Israel in Exodus.
In addition to being situated at significant narrative and redactional points, these repeated death-notices are associated with crucial figures in biblical history. Because of this latter point, scholars no longer consider them to be simply "resumptive repetitions".
This paper aims to investigate this phenomenon from a narrative and literary point of view, with a view to exploring their postulated redactional function, by analyzing, in particular, the conceptual patterns, wording and narrative logic involved.
|
Luke's Jesus and Pliny's Trajan: The Virtue of "Pietas" in the Wake of a Roman Succession Crisis
Program Unit: Virtue in Biblical Literature (EABS)
Mina Monier, King's College London
After the assassination of Domitian and Nerva's transitional seizure of power, the question of constructing a new legitimate system of succession became a problem that necessitated an ideological programme to justify Trajan's rule. This could be understood from the writings of the major biographers and historians of that period. However, it is Pliny the Younger's Panegyricus that gives a detailed explanation of what image Trajan needed to acquire and how he could become a legitimate successor. According to the biographers of that age and the Panegyricus, the major contrast between the dark age of the Flavians and the "new happy age" was the restoration of Augustan pietas (piety). This movement resonates in contemporaneous Christian texts of that period. In this paper, I will argue that the three fundamental elements of the revived pietas could be found particularly in Luke-Acts as part of its apologia for a pious Lord who accomplishes pietas in the life of his community. This appears in the expressions and materials that biblical exegetes consider as characteristically Lukan, and therefore I suggest that the rhetoric of Luke's double work was directed particularly to address this new imperial ideological movement.
|
Reading James and 1 Peter Together: James's and Peter's Use of the Old Testament
Program Unit: Catholic Epistles
Nelson R. Morales, Central American Theological Seminary (SETECA)
This paper applies a Relevance Theory approach, following Chistoph Unger's concept of global coherence and the expectation of relevance and complex stimuli. In the corpus of the General Epistles, the book of James appears first and 1 Peter after it. There are many thematic parallels between James and 1 Peter. These parallels have at least three OT quotations in common (Isa 40:6-8; Prov 3:34; and Prov 10:12). When reading James and 1 Peter canonically, a theme appears first in James. That is recalled to memory as intertextual background information when reading 1 Peter. It is not necessary to assume any literary dependence between both letters. In this way, the theme in James could create more specific expectations of relevance, or guide toward cognitive effects; or reduce processing effort in an interpretation of 1 Peter. This paper analyses each of these cases of the OT citations and demonstrates the way James uses the OT guides our reading, and derivation of both explicatures and implicatures in 1 Peter.
Using Relevance Theory as a framework of intertextuality, this article answers the question: What happens with the search for relevance in the case of multiple authors and works in a corpus? The question is important, because Relevance Theory is built upon the communication and comprehension process between a communicator and the audience. The paper proposes that in a canonical reading, at least an implicit meta author (the Holy Spirit), or even an implicit editor/compiler/anthologist could be assumed in the interpretive process and in the search for relevance. The paper will illustrate ways that the intertextuality produced in a canonical reading is equivalent to a reading of a longer piece of work, in this case, James-1 Peter.
|
"An Aid that Fits": Genesis 2 and the Anthropological Machinery of Sex Robots
Program Unit: The Biblical World and Its Reception (EABS)
Jon Morgan, University of Exeter
Since the conception of the term, the robot has consistently functioned in fiction as a site of reception, rehearsal, and reinterpretation of the Edenic myth. Robot fiction has long used dynamics constructed between a (usually male) scientist-creator and their creations, as well as those between the creations themselves, to explore questions of identity, ontology, epistemology, and relationality. More specifically, many works of robot fiction have employed such dynamics to probe the nature and limits of sexual expression. This theme has, however, taken on a new emphasis in both speculative and science fiction and scholarly and popular discourse alike as recent technological advancements have begun to bring into sharper focus the practical, ethical, and philosophical implications of humanoid robots designed and made to give sexual pleasure.
This paper offers a set of reflections on the relational dynamics in Genesis 2 and 3 read through a lens shaped by the contemporary phenomenon of humanoid sex robots and their treatment in both scholarship and recent screen fiction. In bringing insights from a range of other texts into conversation with the biblical material, the paper highlights a set of intertextual anxieties concerned with (and by) masculinity, sexuality, and reproduction. It focuses in particular on YHWH Elohim and the man’s joint attempts first to find then make an ezer k’negdo for the man as acute manifestations of these anxieties. Following the lead of ancient interpreters, the paper thinks in and with the gaps in the section of the narrative that connects the recognition that man on his own is ‘not good’ (2.18) to his ejaculation ‘at last!’ (2.23). It indicates how an interpretative emphasis on the woman as a product of male design and manufacture reframes connections between text and the urgent discussions about politics of gender and sex currently taking place in public discourse.
|
Some Aspects of Mourning according to Sumero-Akkadian Texts
Program Unit: Ugarit and the Bible: Life and Death (EABS)
Virginie Muller, University of Lyon
This paper introduces and analyzes in detail the various rites of mourning described by the Sumero-Akkadian texts, especially for the 2nd-1st millennium BC.
Rites of mourning are mentioned in numerous practical documents (letters, economic and legal documents, rituals, etc.), as well as in literary and mythological material. Thus, these extensive and practical sources introduce concrete cases. Moreover, these texts provide information about the rites performed for elites and for private individuals, as well as the impacts of these rites on the daily life of the bereaved persons.
This contribution will first deal with the terminology, by means of a lexical study of the words used in the texts to depict mourning and its constituent parts (sipittam šakānum, bakûm, etc.). It will also describe and analyze the various grieving demonstrations, which are performed most often in a public and effusive way. Examples of these performances are crying, lamentations, specific clothing, physical modifications as “having dirty hair (mesûm)”, and specific behaviors. This work will also deal with the duration of the mourning, which fluctuated according to the personality of the deceased, and finally with the actions that symbolize the end of the mourning period and the return to normal life.
Focusing on Sumero-Akkadian texts, this paper intends to serve as a starting point for reflections and to provide data for comparative surveys with Ugaritic and Biblical literature. Furthermore, this paper will be an opportunity to examine common motives and differences related to the traditions in the Ancient Near East regarding aspects of life and death, and, more particularly, of mourning and its effects on the living.
|
Was Jesus Transcending or Transforming the Judaism of His Day? Representations of the Jesus Figure in Biblical Scholarship in Denmark 1840-1939
Program Unit: History of Biblical Scholarship in the Late Modern Period
Mogens Müller, Københavns Universitet
The relation between the Jesus of history and his religious background has always been an important question in scholarship. The extremes encompass on the one hand that Jesus fully transcended the Judaism of his day, on the other hand that he did not represented anything really new, Christianity owing its existence to later, creative disciples such at Paul. In this lecture, I will draw attention to five different solutions to this question set forth by Danish scholars from 1840 to 1938. Framed by two textbooks on New Testament hermeneutic by H.N. Clausen (1840) and Frederik Torm (1938), I have selected the account on Messianic promises by the Old Testament scholar, Frants Buhl (1894), and two examples of life-of-Jesus-books by religious historian Ditlef Nielsen (1924) and the historian of literature, Georg Brandes (1925). These five authors present us for understandings ranging from a historical Jesus being transcending the religion of the Old Testament and Judaism, stressing the discontinuity, and to a Jesus transforming the very same religion, emphasizing the moment of continuity. The presupposition for all five is that Judaism and Christianity represents two from the very beginning fundamentally different religions.
|
Luke as a Rewriter of Matthean Parables
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Mogens Müller, Københavns Universitet
With the exemption of Mk 4.26-29, all of the parables in Mark find their parallels in Matthew and Luke. However, six of the parables new in Matthew turn out to have counterparts in Luke (Mt 7.24-27≠ Lk 6.47-49, Mt 11.16-19 ≠ Lk 7.31-33, Mt 13.33 ≠ Lk 13.20-21, Mt 18.12-14 ≠ Lk 15.3-7, Mt 22.1-14 ≠ Lk 14.15-24, Mt 25.14-30 ≠ 19.11-27). Of course, some of the parallels can be discussed. However, if you accept, that the author of Luke, besides Mark, has known and used Matthew, it invites, instead of presuming a common source besides Mark, to consider this writer’s interpretive rewriting Matthew to see if and, given the answer is positive, how it is influenced by his special theology.
|
Eckart Otto’s Models of "Urdeuteronomium" and Deuteronomistic Deuteronomy
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Law
Reinhard Müller, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
The paper addresses Eckart Otto’s monumental contribution to reconstructing and contextualizing the original core of Deuteronomy ("Urdeuteronomium") in the history of Israelite religion. In addition, it highlights how Otto’s evaluation of this core is related to his model of a Deuteronomistic edition of Deuteronomy ("deuteronomistisches Deuteronomium"). Both models are critically discussed.
|
Timo Veijola’s Commentary on Deuteronomy
Program Unit: Editorial Techniques in the Hebrew Bible in Light of Empirical Evidence (EABS)
Reinhard Müller, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
The paper addresses Timo Veijola’s groundbreaking commentary on Deuteronomy Das fünfte Buch Mose: Deuteronomium, Kapitel 1,1-16,17 (ATD 8.1; Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 2004). It highlights Veijola‘s redaction critical method of investigating and reconstructing Deuteronomy’s literary history, and it discusses exemplarily the most important results.
|
When Meal-Time Doubles as Feet-Time: Exploring Gender(ed) Ambiguity in the Narrative of John 13:1-17
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Nina Müller van Velden, Stellenbosch University
The Johannine Gospel continues to be of interest for biblical scholars attuned to the manner in which gender is constructed and performed by means of characterization in its narratives, interpreted from a vast range of social locations. Whereas the process of interpretation and meaning-making for some leads down the road of gender equality and gender-transgressive behaviour, others deem the Fourth Gospel narratives to merely reinforce the all too familiar patriarchal social structures and hegemonic masculine ideals. Central to interpretative judgements on the gendered dimension of the Fourth Gospel narratives, is the manner in which Jesus is characterized, and the manner in which his character relates to those in his presence.
In this paper I argue that the narrative of John 13:1-17 – when read with a gender-critical lens against the background of the first century cultural script of honour and shame – resists simplistic categorization of being either a liberating or a restrictive gendered narrative. Rather, by taking into consideration the complex intersections of honour, shame, gender, and class, a gender ambiguous picture emerges; a picture that, by means of its characterization, both affirms and transgresses ancient gendered ideals.
This unresolved gendered tension depicted in the narrative, and rightly noted by the character of Peter in the narrative itself, opens up possibilities for contemporary theological discourses on gender and sexuality. Instead of feeding into simplistic discourses which promote essentialist, binary gender categorization, the ambiguity of this narrative could potentially create spaces for theologically engaging gender and sexuality in a more informed and complex manner – a hermeneutic that can rest in the discomfort of constructivism, variation, and unresolved open-endedness, and thereby extend an invitation of life for all.
|
Islamic Elements in Yefet ben ʿEli’s Commentary on the Book of Malachi
Program Unit: The Bible in Arabic in Judaism, Christianity, Islam (EABS)
Meirav Nadler-Akirav, Bar-Ilan University
This paper focuses on the Islamic, and more in particular Muʿtazilite elements found in the commentary on the Book of Malachi by the Karaite Yefet ben ʿEli (10th century CE). The Jews of the Middle Ages who lived in a Muslim environment quickly became acquainted with Islamic culture and philosophy. Both Judaism and Islam are monotheistic religions, both preoccupied with issues such as the oneness and uniqueness of God, reward and punishment, etc. It is not surprising, therefore, that Jews, Rabbanite and Karaite alike, were familiar with the various ideas of Islamic rational theology (kalam). In his commentary on the Book of Malachi, Yefet ben ʿEli deals with two distinct issues that are found in the doctrine of the Muʿtazila. One is reward and punishment, and the other, the "middle position," meaning the question of whether there is a difference between an infidel and a person who deviates from the straight path; who are those two groups and what will be their punishment. Yefet discusses these issues in his commentary on Malachi 3, where he distinguishes between the terms zedīm, ʿōṡei rishʿa and reshaʿīm. He presents a number of possibilities for understanding these expressions, and one may find a great deal of similarity to the ideas of the Muʿtazila.
|
The Existential Value of an Incompetent God: A Critical Evaluation of the παντοκράτωρ Concept in Revelation
Program Unit: What a God is Not – The Early History of Negative Theology (EABS)
Peter Nagel, Stellenbosch University
There are eight references made to παντοκράτωρ in the whole of the New Testament, seven of which is found in the book of Revelation. The concept has become a generally accepted epithet for the Christian deity, rendering such a deity ‘competent’ and ‘all-powerful,’ even though the concept is not widely used by New Testament scribes. The aim is to answer the question whether there is any existential value in acknowledging that a deity is incompetent. To answer this question, a brief overview of the παντοκράτωρ idea will be given, by investigating its origin and history. This will be followed by a critical evaluation of its use and function in Revelation.
|
What Has Väinämöinen Got to Do with Moses? Mapping the Influence of Finnish Folklore Scholarship on Biblical Studies and Suggesting Future Directions
Program Unit: History of Biblical Scholarship in the Late Modern Period
Aulikki Nahkola, Newbold College
The ‘discovery’ of genre as a critical tool in Old Testament studies is generally accredited to Hermann Gunkel’s work on the narratives of Genesis (Genesis, 1901) and in his designation of these narratives as Sage the concepts of oral composition and transmission also first entered biblical studies. Gunkel’s indebtedness to pioneering German folklore scholarship (Grimm brothers) has been well-recognised, but much less is known of the seminal influence some early Finnish scholars (Julius and Kaarle Krohn, Antti Aarne) had on the development of the evolutionary transmission model (historical-geographical school) that came to dominate the understanding of oral composition/transmission for almost a century and which was perpetuated in biblical studies not only by Gunkel, but e.g. John Van Seters and Klaus Koch. During the 20th century Finnish folklore scholarship established itself universally as a major force in the study of oral/orally derived genres, from epic to riddle, now often with particular focus on the performance event (e.g. Lauri Honko). While biblical scholarship has continued to utilise these insights, this has generally happened somewhat sporadically. The purpose of this paper is to form a more comprehensive picture of the impact Finnish folklore scholarship has had on biblical studies, particularly in its understanding of oral/orally derived genres, their composition and transmission, and how a more consistent and up-to-date application of folklore methodology could function as a corrective to what has sometimes been criticised as a selective or dated use of this methodology. Secondly, in folklore scholarship the underlining hermeneutical assumptions about genre, composition and transmission, are often more readily articulated (e.g. as (d)evolutionary models) than they are in biblical studies, where, nevertheless, the same assumptions are in force. Thus the purpose here is also to make consciousness some of the fundamental assumptions about genre that undergird humanities in general, but are seldom articulated.
|
The Advantages of Teaching Biblical Hebrew as a Living Language
Program Unit: Intersections: A Forum for Research on Ancient Israel, Hebrew Bible, and Cognate Topics (EABS)
Eyal Nahum, Polis Institute, Jerusalem
Biblical Hebrew has been for centuries an object of study and research, yet it is not until recent years that modern methods of language teaching have been implemented for this language. In this lecture I will present the principles of the 'full immersion' method for teaching (any) language, which employs all four basic language skills (listening, speaking, reading, writing), and show the ways in which I implemented these principles on BH. These include inter alia some state-of-the-art methods of language teaching, such as TPR, Storytelling, pair and group works, that will be introduced and briefly exemplified.I will also present parts of my BH textbook for beginners (to be published soon) and show the fundamental way in which it differs from other textbooks of the 'teach yourself' kind.By doing so I hope to present a convincing argument for the advantages of the living method over the classical one, encouraging students to experience the language and be deeply immersed in it, a process which directly and naturally leads to the ultimate goal of anyone who wishes to learn an ancient language, namely to become a fluent reader of it. I will argue that it is through full-immersion that such a goal is
best achieved.
To end my lecture I will discuss some challenges unique to the teaching of ancient languages as living ones (as opposed to modern ones). These in turn raise some questions of a more
theoretical nature. As I will try to show, these questions touch up
on the very core problem of resurrecting a language from the dead and
may contribute to any discussion on the subject.
|
The Dirge Over Kirta? KTU 1.16 i-ii Reconsidered
Program Unit: Ugarit and the Bible: Life and Death (EABS)
Shirly Natan-Yulzary, Gordeon Academic Colleges, Israel
In the Kirta Epic, after the hero falls ill, three feasts are held in which Ḥuraya asks the honored guests to weep on behalf of her husband Kirta (1.15 iv-vi). Later his children Ilḥa'u and Thitmanitu deliver a speech, which is repeated three times (1.16 i-ii) with variations.
An examination of the text’s structure and literary motifs confirms the classification of the speeches about Kirta as belonging to the genre of dirges. But examples from the Bible and the Ancient Near East reveal that a dirge is recited after a person’s death (e.g. Gilgamesh’s dirge over Enkidu; David’s dirge over Saul and Jonathan; David’s dirge over Abner son of Ner). What then can be the meaning of a dirge over Kirta before he is dead? Can their speeches still be defined as dirges if their father is still living?
My lecture will address not only the identification of the literary genre, but also the different attitude Kirta exhibits toward Ilḥa'u’s mourning and his speech, and toward Tatmanat’s raising of her voice and her speech. I will also discuss the central issue of Kirta’s relationship to his patron God. Is Kirta, who is designated a ‘A scion of El, Son of the Gentle and Holy One’ (bnm.il.špḥ/lṭpn.wqdš; KTU 1.16 i 10-11), perceived by his progeny as mortal or immortal? Finally, I will propose an explanation for the dirge’s appearance while Kirta is still alive and of its meaning.
|
Asherah, Lady of the Sea: A New Look at KTU 1.4 ii
Program Unit: Israel in the Ancient Near East (EABS)
Shirly Natan-Yulzary, Gordon Academic Colleges, Israel
The goddess Asherah is designated as ‘Lady of the Sea’ several times in the Baal Cycle. In this lecture I will focus on the description of Asherah in KTU 1.4, ii, and propose a new reading for a few of its passages. Until now scholars have assumed, based on the reading of column ii, that Asherah is a goddess who represents women and women’s domestic labor, since according to this passage, she is described as weaving, laundering, cooking, and serving food to El, her consort. These scholars have not explained the connection between this description and Asherah’s epic epithet as ‘Lady of the Sea’. Similarly unexplained is the connection between the description of Asherah engaging in domestic chores and the following passage, which deals with fishing and with Ashera’s fisherman Qudshu-wa-Amruru.
Closer examination of the Ugaritic word npnyh along with an alternate verse division of the text raise the possibility that Asherah is described here as weaving a fishing net, which also serves her as a garment. In light of this passage and other textual references (including the Kirta Epic), as well as archeological findings from Ugarit (a drawing on a drinking mug and a figurine of a goddess), one can argue that in the city of Ugarit, which is located on the seaside, Asherah was also considered a goddess of fishing, alongside her other attributes. She is described as a lady and as the consort of El, the head of the pantheon, as well as the goddess responsible for feeding the inhabitants of Ugarit.
|
Lemuel’s Mother (Prov 31:1–9) and the Wise Women in the Biblical Wisdom and Narrative Literature
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Wisdom
Nitsa Nave, Haifa University
This lecture examines the linguistic and conceptual affinities between Prov 31:1–9 and the descriptions of the other wise women in the Hebrew Bible. It addresses questions such as why Lemuel’s mother is regarded as a wise woman, the traits she shares with personified Lady Wisdom, the links between her wisdom and that of the “woman of valour” and other wise women, such as the Queen of Sheba, Abigail, the wise woman from Tekoa, and the wise woman from Abel-beth-maachah, and the features and characteristics common to the biblical wise women—advisor to the king, rhetorical speech, involvement in social life, etc. It also discusses the image of the matriarch as the source of her authority in the relevant texts and the tradition that lies behind the passages dealing with Lemuel’s mother and the wise women in Proverbs and biblical narrative.
|
Obscure Places in 2 Enoch: What Can They Tell Us about the Provenance of the Text?
Program Unit: Rethinking Biblical Written Tradition through Slavonic Interpretations
Liudmila Navtanovich, Autonomous University of Barcelona
The paper deals with 2 Enoch, one of the Old Testament Pseudepigrapha that notwithstanding the fact that it has been under research for more than 150 years remains an ‘enigma’ in many respects.
From the middle of the 19th century (when the first Slavic fragments were published) up to the present, there has been a protracted debate about the provenance of the text in question. ‘One of the most remarkable token of continued puzzlement over this work is the failure of scholars to decide whether it came from Jewish or Christian circles’ . This ‘contradictory’ nature makes this text one of particular interest and importance, and it probably has to do with its long history of transmission through different times, different lands, different cultures and different languages.
One of the peculiarities of 2 Enoch is that, being relatively short one, it has quite a lot of examples of what the Slavists call “темные места” (obscure places). In the paper I will be commenting on some of them and demonstrating that they can really provide us with certain data concerning the provenance of the Pseudepigraphon.
|
A King’s Ransom: The Inversion of Authority and Power in Matthew 20:20-28
Program Unit: Authority and Influence in Ancient Times
Marius J. Nel, Universiteit van Stellenbosch - University of Stellenbosch
The paper investigates the nature of the language used in Matthew 20:20-28 to articulate the Matthean Jesus’ radical inversion of the status (servant instead of master), nature (suffering instead of adulation) and destiny (death instead of glory) of leaders within the kingdom of heaven. It focusses on the various acts, symbols, expressions, rhetoric and language used to create both inner (8:2; 18:1-4; 23:8-12; 27:38; 26:27-28, 39; 28:9) and intertextual echoes (e.g. Dan 7:13-14; Pss 16:5; 23:5; 75:8; 116:13; Jer 18:36; 25:15-29; Isa 51:17-23; Ezek 23:31-34; Lam 4:21) that delineate Matthew’s understanding of leadership and authority. The relationship between the Matthean epigrammatic explanation of Jesus’ death (20:28), regal language (13:41; 16:27-28; 19:28) and the contest for power amongst Jesus-followers (20:20-24) will also be explored within the respective contexts of the ministry of Jesus and that of the Matthean community.
|
Visions and the Spatial Conception of Acts
Program Unit: Vision and Envisionment in the Bible and its World (EABS)
Nils Neumann, Leibniz Universität Hannover
It has long been noticed that in the beginning of Acts the risen Jesus commands the apostles to be witnesses from Jerusalem to Judea, Samaria, and to the ends of the world (Acts 1:8); and this is precisely what happens in the subsequent narration. By giving special attention to spatial movement and directions in the visionary scenes of Acts the present paper explores the way in which the narrator depicts the spreading of the „Way“ as being directed immediately by Jesus from the heavenly sphere. Nightly visions as well as Angelophanies, the heavenly voice of Jesus, and the work of the spirit have a heavy influence on the apostles and their traveling in the earthly realm. The visions in Acts thus not only form a means of communication between heaven and earth but also initiate a chain of action that originates in heaven and drives the earthly protagonists to accomplish their mission.
|
Taking the Pain Away: Paul, Circumcision, and the Success of the Gentile Mission
Program Unit: Bodies of Communication (EABS)
Karin Neutel, University of Oslo
The dominant popular perception of Paul is that he was the person who abolished circumcision and thereby broke Christianity away from its Jewish roots. More specifically, the success of Paul's Christian mission is attributed to the fact that the requirement of circumcision was dropped. The assumption behind this is that non-Jewish men feared the pain associated with circumcision and were much more likely to convert to a circumcision-free Christianity. This paper will analyse this reception of Paul in contemporary culture, particularly in sources that discuss male circumcision. It will show how portraying Paul as ‘tactical’, ‘resourceful’ or even ‘a genius’ for abolishing such a 'painful procedure', is used to support competing positions on circumcision today.
|
Moses (De)constructed in the Persian Period
Program Unit: Concepts of Leadership in the Hebrew Bible (EABS)
Lukasz Niesiolowski-Spano, University of Warsaw
In the scholarly debate about the history of Biblical texts the figure of Moses plays a key role. On the one hand, the discussion about the historicity of the exodus is less vivid in recent years. On the other hand, the question about the origin of Moses as law-giver is still open. The paper aims at discussing the possible connotation of Moses as the source of authority of the written law in the Persian Period. The paper will try to open up new directions in seeing Moses as literary figure created in the Persian Period, but based on older traditions.
The creation of the new law-system in the province of Yehud and the possible activity of Nehemiah as the law-giver (law-codifier) may offer the best background for the shifting of the figure of Moses from the religious leader into the aesymnetes-figure. In some way the literary figure of Ezra, the propagator of the Torah, is also parallel to the figure of Moses. One may here, however, ask which literary portrait was original. By now, it is not given that Moses as the law-giver must predate Ezra.
The discussion on the role of Moses, and the tradition of Moses as law-giver in particular, may shed new light on concepts of leadership and law-authorisation in the Persian Period, especially in the 5th century BCE in Yehud.
|
Koinōnia and Koinōnos in 1 Corinthians 10:16 in Light of Documentary Evidence
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Markus Nikkanen, University of Aberdeen
Recent discussion on the meaning of koinōn- cognates in 1 Corinthians 10:14–22 has associated Paul's discourse on eating sacrificial food with the fellowship meals of the Graeco-Roman world in general and translated the crucial phrase, koinōnia tou haimatos kai sōmatos tou Christou in 1 Corinthians 10:16 as "fellowship in regard to the blood and body of Christ" (e.g. Norbert Baumert and Harm Hollander) whereas earlier scholarship preferred the translation "joint participation in the blood and body of Christ" (e.g. John Campbell and Heinrich Seesemann).
Recently, Julien Ogereau has proposed that scholars have not paid enough attention to documentary evidence and contextual meanings in their discussions of koinōn- cognates. Ogereau also suggests in passing that the meaning of koinōnia in 1 Corinthians 10:16 could be clarified through a study of documentary evidence that refers to κοινωνία in the sacrifices.
This paper builds on Ogereau's suggestion and argues based on relevant documentary evidence that in the cultic context of 1 Corinthians 10:14–22 koinōnia should be understood as "joint participation in the blood and body of Christ" which creates and maintains sacred human-divine and human-human bonds. Consequently, Paul's use of koinōn- cognates explains his underlying logic: becoming a koinōnos in the demons' tables is impossible because of the exclusive covenantal relationship with God that has been created and is maintained through the believer's koinōnia in Christ's blood and body. This shows that Paul is not merely using Graeco-Roman sacrificial concepts but reinterpreting them through Jewish covenantal ideas.
|
Magic, Miracles, and the Cultural Evolution of Pauline Christianity
Program Unit: The Biblical World and Cultural Evolution (EABS)
Nina Nikki, University of Helsinki
The paper discusses the role of magical enrichment in the success of Pauline Christianity in the first two centuries CE.
The presentation begins with a brief discussion of the concept of magic (and miracle) from the perspective of the cognitive science of religion, which suggests that magical beliefs are a universal character of the human mind. It is argued that magic and miracle are cognitively appealing to the human mind, because they include elements such as counterintuitivity and emotionally arousing content, which enhance memorability. Memorability in turn is directly related to cultural evolution, which discusses the transmission and success of various cultural representations.
The theoretical discussion will be applied to selected examples from early Christian literary material relating to the character of Paul. In order to establish the magical enrichment with time, examples will be drawn from the authentic letters of Paul, through the Canonical Acts, to the apocryphal Acts of Paul and Thecla. The paper suggests that the increased number of magical and miracle stories had a positive impact on the survival and spread of Pauline Christianity in the first centuries. It is less certain, however, whether Pauline Christianity had any real selective advantage in this respect with regard to other strands of Early Christianity, or if magical enrichment was more a matter of accommodating to the expectations in the surrounding environment. In fact, a process of blending between the various strands becomes more and more evident as time goes on. Interestingly, Pauline Christianity seems to take two distinct forms that develop in different directions. The first one is the narrative mode where magical enrichment, among other elements, flourishes. The second one develops around the epistolary material and is notably scarce in magical elements, centering more on community control.
|
The Cultural Evolution of the Word ‘Love’ in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: The Biblical World and Cultural Evolution (EABS)
Ronit Nikolsky, Rijksuniversiteit Groningen
In this lecture I will study the concept ‘love’ in the Bible (OT) from an evolutionary perspective.
Based on Merlin Donald’s theory of three stages of human cognitive evolution, I will show how the concept ‘love’ appears in a different manner in each of the stages he describes - mimetic, mythic and theoretic.
I will study the use of the word ‘love’ in biblical texts that represent the three cognitive strategies: mimetic cognition in the Song of Songs poems, mythic cognition in biblical narratives, and theoretic cognition in legal texts.
Except for Donald’s theory of cognitive development, I rely on Lisa Feldman Barrett's theory of emotions, and other theories of Culture and Cognition.
|
Emotional Translation of Rabbinic Culture in the Tanhuma
Program Unit: Emotions and the Biblical World (EABS)
Ronit Nikolsky, Rijksuniversiteit Groningen
The Tanhuma-Yelammedenu corpus should not be classified as ‘late midrash’ as it is not engaged in adapting biblical material to rabbinic culture like the classical role of rabbinic midrash. Rather, Tanhuma is engaged in adapting rabbinic beit-midrash culture to its own intended audience, apparently the synagogue-goer of the Byzantine period.
The shift away from the beit-midrash entails emotional translation, since the emotionality of the rabbinic halakhic elite does not suit a wider public constructed not only of learners.
In my lecture I will look at a few cases where the emotional translation takes place by studying how Tanhumaic narratives suggest emotionality to its audience. There are three instances where a narrative suggests emotionality: 1) in emotional concepts found in the discourse; 2) in the incentive for action in the plot, i.e. what moves the protagonist to act; and 3) in the clues the teller or the implied author gives to the audience as to how the story and its people should be valued.
I am regarding the topic from a cognitive-narrative approach based on culture and cognition theories (van Heusden, Donald, and others) as well as cutting edge neuroscientific studies of emotions (Feldman, Barrett) to follow the emotional community established in the Tanhuma corpus.
|
Punishing God’s Messenger in the Book of Isaiah
Program Unit: Prophets and Prophecy (EABS)
Yochi Nissani, Bar-Ilan University
This presentation deals with the question of the punishment of the Assyrian and Babylonian Empires in the book of Isaiah; two empires whom the prophet perceives as God’s emissaries or executioners of His plan. This issue arises in two places in the book: in chapter 10:5-19, ascribed to Isaiah son of Amotz; and in chapter 47, recognized as Second Isaiah’s oracle. These two prophecies present a common idea: God, furious with His sinful people, punishes them through a powerful nation who conquers and destroys the land. This enemy, too, is punished in turn; its sentence is overtly or covertly followed by a pronouncement of Israel’s impending redemption. Using this common pattern as a basis for comparison, we will discuss the reason why each enemy was punished even though their acts served to fulfill God’s plan.
In research, we see that most scholars ascribe their punishment to two reasons: pride, and excessive cruelty. Some hold that both crimes are equal in weight, while others emphasize one of the two; in either case, no distinction is drawn between chapter 10:5-19 and chapter 47 in this regard.
The purpose in this presentation is to show that through analysis and close reading of the two prophecies, it emerges that each passage presents a different reason for the enemy’s punishment. The explanation I propose for this difference is related to the historical context of each prophecy.
|
Why Prophets Are (Not) Shamans
Program Unit: Anthropology and the Bible (EABS)
Martti Nissinen, University of Helsinki
While prophecy and shamanism are to be regarded as different phenomena, they also share many phenomenological features, such as the communication between the human and superhuman worlds, the altered state of consciousness, performances that are best described as magical acts, and, occasionally the ambiguous gender role. The purpose of this paper is mapping the interface between shamanism and prophecy, paying attention especially to the agency of the shaman vis-à-vis the prophet. It will be argued that, while these agencies typically do not overlap, they fulfill partially similar socio-religious functions.
|
A Consideration of the City-States of the Late Bronze Age Southern Levant
Program Unit: Ancient Near East
Andres Nõmmik, Tartu Ülikool
The Late Bronze Age (1550-1200 BC) in the Southern Levant was characterized by the establishment of the Egyptian political influence and control of this region. At its height, the Egyptian Empire controlled the regions in the Levant to as north as Ugarit.
This paper looks into the question of how many city-states there were in the Southern Levant at this time. To solve this problem, the nature of a city-state or a small-state in the Southern Levant is analyzed. These states were under Egyptian control and there are problems that need to be clarified pertaining to the balance between local power and the Egyptian influence. Different polities of the Southern Levant varied in their autonomy, but even the ones with considerable imperial control had some autonomy. There were also some centers of direct Egyptian influence, which worked side by side with the local centers of authority.
The region analyzed in the paper is limited to the area south of Megiddo, thus excluding such states like Qadesh, Ugarit and Amurru, which Egypt lost to the Hittite Empire during the Late Bronze Age. The paper uses mainly the Amarna letters and some other written sources, but the archaeology of the region is also taken into account. By analyzing these sources an outline of the city-state system will be established and the balance between the Egyptian control and the control of local rulers will be clarified.
|
Changes in Form and Genre: Five Research Questions
Program Unit: Diachronic Poetology of the Hebrew Bible and Related Ancient Near Eastern and Ancient Jewish Literature (EABS)
Urmas Nõmmik, University of Tartu, University of Helsinki
Every human phenomenon inevitably manifests change. So does ancient Hebrew poetry and its context, its composers, writers and subjects. The paper will offer a wide perspective on the complex questions and aspects related to the dynamic character of poetry. Five programmatic questions will be discussed. Firstly, the peculiar impression that "classic" genres seem to disappear or melt together in the Second temple period needs elaboration. Secondly, the relation between oral poetry and written texts has an impact on the form of texts. But how to assess traces of orality in texts? Thirdly, the change of scribal material and scribal practices must have provoked changes in form; concepts of tablets, inscriptions and scrolls should be thoroughly examined. Fourthly, the scribal institution has not been static through the monarchic and post-monarchic eras, but how do forms and genres reflect institutional changes? And fifthly, the concept of word, particularly of divine word has not been always the same. What happens, if a single word or phrase gains the upper hand over genre and form? The latter observation explains wide-spread redactional practices and many younger forms of texts.
|
The Wife as Stranger in the Family
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Lilly Nortje-Meyer, University of Johannesburg
The phenomenon of stranger reveals that spatial relations are only the condition, on the one hand, and the symbol, on the other, of human relations. The stranger is thus being discussed here, not in the sense often touched upon in the past, as the wanderer who comes today and goes tomorrow, but rather as the person who comes today and stays tomorrow. She is, so to speak, the potential wanderer: although she has not moved on, she has not overcome the freedom of coming and going. She is fixed within a particular spatial group, or within a group whose boundaries are similar to spatial boundaries. But her position in this group, namely the family is determined, essentially, by the fact that she has not belonged to it from the beginning, that she imports qualities into it, which do not and cannot stem from the group itself. The unity of nearness and remoteness involved in every human relation is organized, in the phenomenon of the stranger, in a way which may be most briefly formulated by saying that in the relationships to her, distance means that she, who is close by, is far, and strangeness means that she, who also is far, is actually near. In this paper the specific form of interaction of the wife (woman) as stranger in the context of the biblical family will be discussed.
|
Biblical Figures in Islamic Visual Culture: The Case of Al Khidr, "The Green One" and "Servant of Moses"
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Culture
Martin O'Kane, Prifysgol Cymru, Y Drindod Dewi Sant - University of Wales, Trinity Saint David
This proposal argues for a more sustained commitment to the inclusion of Islamic visual culture within what has become a predictable repertoire of ‘biblical art’, employed by those who document the Bible’s cultural influence and impact. While much work has been done on the scriptural and textual traditions that Islam, Judaism and Christianity share, this has not been the case with visual culture where the selection of artworks that commentators draw on is generally limited to those from well-known artistic periods, such as the Italian Renaissance or the Dutch Golden Age. However, biblical subjects have often proved to be creative and imaginative meeting places for Islamic, Jewish and Christian artistic traditions and there is much evidence for the borrowing and sharing of a rich iconography between the three faiths - frequently very similar, but also at times quite unique and distinctive.
By way of illustration, the presentation will begin with some introductory comments outlining the importance of Rashid al-Din’s fourteenth-century historical composition Jami ‘ al-Tawarikh (Compendium of Chronicles), generally thought to be the first major Islamic work in which illustrations from the Hebrew Bible and the New Testament appeared. For this work, Rashid al-Din established the first Persian school of painting, recruiting the most promising painters from Tabriz. The presentation will then focus specifically on the character of Al Khidr (The Green One), a hugely important and ubiquitous figure in every age throughout the Islamic world where he is identified in various ways: as the servant of Moses, as the prophet Elijah and, in the Eastern Churches as St. George. The presentation concludes with a few brief examples of the biblical Solomon where Jewish and Islamic illustrators and calligraphers appear to share similar iconographical processes, but which are absent in Christian tradition.
|
Metaphors and Symbols in Jonah
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible (EABS)
Constantin Oancea, Lucian Blaga University of Sibiu
The Book of Jonah tells more than a simple story of a prophet. Beside the narrative level itself, there is a hidden level suggesting a deeper understanding of the story, where symbols and metaphors have a consolidating function.
The metaphor of the way is widely used in the Old Testament to express human attitude toward God. Distance, directions and movement in Jonah 1 describe acts with religious connotation.
A complex imagery of death is present in the Psalm of Jonah by expressions like ‟the belly of Sheol” (2,3), or ‟the closing bars of the earth” (2,7). Water is synonymous with death in the psalm, be it the sea and the floods, the waves (2,4) or the primordial waters (2,6), associated with chaos and considered a permanent threat for life in the Ancient Orient.
The use of metaphors and symbols does not replace the literal message of the Jonah narrative; it simply augments the concepts and themes discussed in the book.
|
Triplets in Mark’s Gospel as Backbone of Structure and Story
Program Unit: Orality and Literacy in Early Christianity (EABS)
Christine Oefele, Universität Basel
The starting point of this paper is the fact that one important feature of oral literature of every period and geographic origin is the striking frequency of repetition. Repetitions create structure, emphasize important statements and are means to develop themes throughout a story. They form patterns which differ not only depending on period, language, and region, but constitute the individual audible design of a certain text.
The overall structure of Mark’s Gospel is characterised by triplets of repeated episodes. Each of the five main parts is structured by one episode which is told with variations three times. Many words, the setting or other aspects remain the same in the first and second repetition of one of these stories. But at the same time, there is something new in each version. A theme is established the first time a story is told. In the first and second version, it is resumed by repeated material and developed by new elements. These new elements differ from main part to main part: the crowd invades the calling stories in 1,16-3,35, the disciples’ incomprehension increases from one boat trip to another in 4,35-8,21, the announcements of death and resurrection in 8,27-10,45 are accompanied by a geographical progression, Jesus’ visits in the temple in 11,1-13,3 get longer and longer, and each consultation of the chief priests with other members of the council in 14,1-15,39 brings Jesus one step nearer to the cross.
The analysis of the ‘triple episodes’ shows that these are not only crucial for the Gospel’s structure, but also contribute to the development of the two major Markan themes Christology and discipleship.
|
Good News for Outsiders: The “Logos” of the Syrophoenician Woman (Mk 7,24-31a) in its Markan Context
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Christine Oefele, Universität Basel
In Mark’s Gospel the issue of insiders and outsiders with respect to the “mystery of the Kingdom of God” is established by the provoking divide between οἱ περὶ αὐτόν and οἱ ἔξω in Mk 4,10-12. In the following chapters, this distinction is blurred and finally turned upside down in the last boat trip (8,14-21). There Jesus’ reaction to the disciples’ concern about having no bread (8,17-18) is strongly reminiscent of the ‘stubbornness motif‘ from Is 6,9-10 which he applied in 4,10-12 to the outsiders. In this context, the Syrophoenician woman plays a crucial role. On the surface, she is portrayed as an outsider but what she says reveals that she, in contrast to the disciples, “understands about the loaves” (see Mk 6,52; 8,18-21).
I analyse the issue of insiders and outsiders in Mk 4,10-8,21 with a focus on the echoes which are created by repetition, in particular of keywords of the semantic fields “to eat” and “to understand”. These keywords are used throughout these chapters and generate an intratextual interpretative space in which the story of the Syrophoenician woman resonates not only with other healing stories, but also with the feeding miracles (6,30-44; 8,1-9), and the second and third boat trip (6,45-53; 8,14-21).
Interpreting the results of this analysis from a pragmatic perspective, I propose to understand the “logos” of the Syrophoenician woman – “Lord, yet the dogs under the table eat of the children’s crumbs” (Mk 7,28) – as “good news” for Mark’s listeners who consider themselves to be outsiders and unable to understand the mystery of the kingdom of God: They are invited to change their minds and to understand that the little “bits” of the Gospel which they can grasp in their – probably difficult – situation are enough to live on.
|
Yahweh of Bashan
Program Unit: Writings (including Psalms)
Florian Oepping, University of Zurich
Psalm 68 is known as the "Mont Blanc de l'exégèse" (Caquot) and indeed, the work on this psalm can be very challenging. Nowadays, scholars see the psalm neither as a "Catalogue of Early Hebrew Lyric Poems" (Albright) nor as an entity (Mowinckel), but as a text with a complicated process of growth. It is obvious that the psalm went through a Jerusalem revision. Especially, this revision is triggering hermeneutic issues.
The aim of this paper is to analyse this Jerusalem revision and to try to break through the hermeneutic spiral which is caused by it. What is part of the revision process for sure? And what does the reader and exegete think is only part of it? Where is she or he taken in by the revision?
The paper will present the different steps of this analysis as well as the result: A text in which Yahweh is moving into his new territory, the mountain of Bashan.
|
(Initiation) Visions through the Lense of Cognitive Philology
Program Unit: Vision and Envisionment in the Bible and its World (EABS)
Nicole Oesterreich, Universität Leipzig
In Jewish, Greek and Roman Antiquity, Altered States of Consciousness (ASC) were a typical mode to encounter a deity. Against former notions of ASC or “ecstatic prophecy” as relics of archaic religions particularly by German biblical scholars, I will argue that narrations of ASC are an essential pattern throughout the bible. Previous definitions of ASC often based only on psychological or ethnological categories, and thus did not recognize cultural elements of ASC. Therefore, in my paper I will employ a new definition including neuroscientific, philosophical, and cultural aspects. This definition is based on the assumption that ASC are states in which the background mechanisms of the brain tend to produce misrepresentational contents. These background mechanisms of consciousness (e.g. neurotransmitter systems, osmotic equilibrium, pH) can be influenced by inductions like fasting, sensory and sleep deprivation, constant prayer etc. Misrepresentations are incorrectly processed perceptions like a perception of something that does not exist (hallucinations), a different representation (e.g. illusion) or missing representations something that does exist (like the complete loss of a sense for the vicinity in very intensive ASC). Narrative depictions of misrepresentations in antique texts often indicate them as deviation from everyday experience, as surprise or miracle. Together with references to inductions, such narrations activated a cognitive scheme in the brains of antique readers, which they generated from other texts containing ASC or their everyday religious environment (e.g., public ecstatic prophecy, initiations to mystery cults, frenzy priests at processions of those religions like the cult of Cybele etc.). The textual basis of my argument are initiation visions like Ez 1:1–3:15; Mc 9:2–9; Acts 26:12–18; 2En 1 and De virtutibus herbarum 23–26.
|
Ritualized Actions Stirring Eschatological Hope
Program Unit: Early Christianity (EABS)
Bernhard Oestreich, Theologische Hochschule Friedensau
Earliest Christian documents witness the expectation of Christ’s imminent glorious parousia (1Thess 4:15; 1Cor 15:51). It is commonly held that this expectation declined as decades elapsed and church members passed away. The emphasis shifted from future to realized eschatology or Christian hope was re-interpreted in an individualistic sense. However, as Erlemann (1993) has shown, there is no clear development towards disappointment and abandoning the expectation. Late documents like Revelation, 2Peter, or Didache do not give up this early conviction of the soon coming parousia despite permanent disappointment. How was this possible?
The paper explores the possibility that some ritualized actions of early Christians did not only express eschatological hope but also continuously stirred this hope. One of the features of ritualized actions is the recourse to tradition—especially by actions that seem to stick to traditional forms—that lets historical event and present time fall together in the participants’ experience. Performing rituals of Christian hope would thus make the first generation of Jesus’ followers and later Christians contemporaneous and help the latter ones to be filled with the expectations of earlier generations.
The study investigates eschatological elements in Christian rituals, especially the Lord’s supper, in New Testament texts and the Didache. It also entertains the idea that the letter to the Hebrews with its interpretation of Israel’s cult and its contested eschatology could be a theoretical reflection of Christian hope as an afterthought based on the ritual performance of hope.
|
“Ask the Animals and They will Teach You”: An Investigation into Various Didactic Settings for Israelite Wisdom Teachings
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Wisdom
Funlola Olojede, University of Stellenbosch
The didactic slant of ancient Israelite wisdom literature is foregrounded visibly in the book of Proverbs (in particular the Instruction genre) which forms the envelope to the book. In ancient Israel and the ANE (cf. also African oral contexts), wisdom instruction was performed orally. There were different “classrooms” (didactic settings) including the home front, the school setting and the royal/court setting among others. The teachings, especially in the public settings of the school and the royal court, were geared among others at the moral formation of the recipients who were mainly young men.
Apart from their regular business of conveying (wisdom) lessons from the experiences gained through the years though, the sages appear to have believed that wise teachings could also be derived or learned from nature or aspects thereof. To use present-day jargon, could it be that the sages were ecologically conscious? It is therefore not a surprise that the sluggard could be exhorted to “learn” the wise ways of the nemala (Prov. 6:6-8) while in Job’s poem, the animals, the birds, the earth and the fish can serve as teachers to humankind (Job 12:7-11). The important question raised in this paper is the motive behind the sages’ conviction that didactics was not only a human effort, it could be performed by nature as well.
|
What of the Night? Conceptions and Theology of Night in Isaiah and Micah
Program Unit: Prophets and Prophecy (EABS)
Funlola O. Olojede , Universiteit van Stellenbosch - University of Stellenbosch
“…Watchman, what of the night? ...The morning cometh, and also the night: If ye will inquire, inquire ye…” (Isa 21:11-12)
ABSTRACT
Even though a number of studies have probed the concept of time in the Hebrew Bible, very little has been said about night as a unit of time. This paper investigates the conceptions and theology of night in the books of Isaiah and of Micah. Whereas strong existential correspondence between day and night is found throughout Isaiah which describes certain negative and positive activities that occur in the night, Micah records only one night time activity—having a vision. It is argued that the conceptions of night as depicted through the night-time activities and actors (which include God, prophets, watchers, the people of Israel, etc.) have implications for the theology and the worldviews expressed in the two prophetic books.
|
Changing Perspectives on the Death of Jesus
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Heike Omerzu, Copenhagen University
A significant aspect of the rhetorical strategies employed in the Gospel of Mark is signaled by literary techniques of inverting reading expectations. This is particularly relevant with reference to the way in which Jesus’ death is portrayed in the course of the narrative. This paper explores how the perception of Jesus’ death in the Gospel of Mark seemingly changes in the course of the narrative. While Jesus’ cruel death is anticipated from early on in the Gospel, both from the perspective of the narrator (e.g. 3.6) as well as by Jesus himself, who fully seems to accept his destiny in the passion predictions in chapters 8-10, the prayer in the garden in 14.32-42 marks a turning point in this respect. It is here where Jesus laments in tears and asks his father that “if it were possible, the hour might pass from him.” (14.35) Even though Jesus at the end of this scene occurs to accept his fate by acknowledging that “the hour has come; the Son of Man is betrayed into the hands of sinners” and the passion events unsettle, Jesus’ final words on the cross again recall the reluctance uttered in Gethsemane, “God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" (15.34) This paper analyzes how this seeming change of attitude towards Jesus’ death can be understood as being part of Mark’s theology of the cross. Against the background of ancient noble death traditions (and recent scholarship reading early Christian interpretations of Jesus’ death in that context and intertext), this paper argues that the Markan Jesus is required to show human, “unnoble” fear of death and doubt while the reader knows that he will eventually be vindicated by the resurrection by God (even though this is not narrated in Mark).
|
Maryrdom in Judaism, Christianity, and Islam
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Heike Omerzu, Copenhagen University
The recent history of religious conflict and violence in Europe and beyond generated, amongst others, a renewed interest in ways in which Christian identity is informed by depictions of Jesus's death. This opens a door to interreligious dialogue with contemporary traditions like Judaism and Islam where images of death and martyrdom play an important role in the formation of religious identity and action. Against this background, this paper will explore different characters that suffered martyrdom according to the three traditions (viz the death of the woman and her seven sons in 2 Maccabees; the death of Jesus in the Gospel of Mark; Sumayyah, the first martyr in Islam). It will be elucidated which world views the construction of the respective characters represent and how they operated as a means of identity formation.
|
Roman Religion as a Source of Identity in the Early Roman Empire
Program Unit: Construction of Identity in the Ancient World: Intersections and Reflections (EABS)
Eric Orlin, University of Puget Sound
Drawing the relationship between memory and the built environment, this paper explores how residents of Italy during the Early Principate, especially in Cisalpine Gaul, both integrated themselves into the Roman community and maintained a sense of local identity. At its heart are questions of how to understand Roman identity outside Rome during the first fifty years of imperial rule. On the one hand archaeological evidence attests to the beginnings of what scholars can identify as imperial cult activity, including dedications and sanctuaries connected to the imperial family, but on the other hand this activity manifested itself in different ways that often reveals unique local behavior, different both from Rome and also from other parts of the Roman West. Inscriptional evidence also reveals that “traditional” cult activity continued unabated as temples were constructed and reconstructed for Jupiter, Diana and other deities usually identified as Roman, but at the same time attests to a wide array of divinities, including deities of local importance. The cultic activity and new structures could serve to erase or replace Republican and Civil War memories and allow for new memories to emerge, or to strengthen local identities in the face of an increased Roman presence. This reshaping of space allows us to trace the reshaping of relationships and of the boundaries between various social groups. The insights into how residents of Italy viewed themselves and their relationship to Rome in the wake of the Roman civil wars thus provides an instructive model for the shaping of Roman identity throughout the Roman Empire prior to the impact of Christianity.
|
Testamentum Iobi as a Source for the Instruction of Vladimir Monomakh
Program Unit: Slavonic Parabiblical Traditions (EABS)
Lyubov Osinkina, University of Oxford
Vladimir Monomakh, Great Prince of Kiev (1053-1125) is one of the most interesting and remarkable figures of the Kievan Rus’. Amongst other things he is known to us through his instruction-Pouchenie. The text of Pouchenie which survives in the Lavrentievsky Chronicle of 1377 was published a number of times. Scholars wrote about various sources for Monomakh’s Instruction: Psalms, Homilies on the Hexaemeron by Basil the Great, Octavius of Marcus Minucius Felix and the apocryphal Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs which includes the Testament of Judah. To this list I may add another apocryph, The Testament of Job. The earliest known version of the Testament of Job is the Coptic papyrus of the IV century AD. There are four Greek manuscripts of the XI-XVI centuries and several South Slavonic copies of the XV-XVI centuries. The comparison of this text with Vladimir Monomakh’s Instruction has never been explored by scholars. My current paper aims to fill this gap by discussing the range of reading at the court of Vladimir Monomakh, and the representation of literary motifs in the visual arts (in connection with the apocryphal image of Job).
|
Diachrony and Synchrony in the Book of Deuteronomy: How to Relate Them
Program Unit: Developing Exegetical Methods (EABS)
Eckart Otto, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
The paper delivers some aspects of how to reconcile these two approaches in
biblical scholarship. Like hardly any other book, Deuteronomy allows
conclusions to be drawn on its literary history, because the later
authors and editors consciously set some literary critical breaches. For
example, the change of the numerus (Numeruswechsel) seems to be a means
of the theological structure of the text, which serves the hermeneutics
of the book.
|
The Functions of Extensive Psalms and Prayers in Narrative Contexts
Program Unit: Developing Exegetical Methods (EABS)
Mika Pajunen, University of Helsinki
The paper deals with the basic question why are there extensive psalms and prayers that disrupt the flow of the narrative in most narrative works among the texts now in the Hebrew Bible, Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha, and the Dead Sea Scrolls. Thus far very little has been written on this overall topic and all of these studies deal with only small portions of the available evidence. Most of the prior studies have seen these psalms and prayers as secondary insertions into the narrative contexts and of little or no worth for understanding the overall compositions they are parts of. This paper is based on a larger comprehensive study of this literary phenomenon but it will concentrate on the empirical evidence for this practice as well as give illustrative examples of the main reasons for the incorporation of this material into the narratives. According to the empirical evidence from the versions and the Dead Sea Scrolls, a few of the psalms and prayers are indeed purely secondary insertions with little overall importance but most have probably been composed or modified directly for the literary setting by the authors of the work or later editors. Moreover, they are far from secondary for understanding the aims of these authors and editors. On the contrary these psalms and prayers offered the chance for these writers to direct the ideological and theological message of the narrative towards their own interpretation of the events, presented an excellent way to tie the overall narrative to a larger framework of traditions, and to promote some novel contemporary ritual practices as ancient customs.
|
Metaphors as Instrument of Diplomacy: Networks of Metaphors in the Hittite Diplomatic Texts
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible (EABS)
Marta Pallavidini, Freie Universität Berlin
From the Middle-Hittite Period onward, and in particular from the reign of Šuppiluliuma I until the end of the Hittite Empire, the Hittite kings made large use of several diplomatic instruments to build and define their relations with the other rulers of the Near East. In particular, diplomacy was based on the issuing of three textual categories: treaties, international decrees and verdicts, and international correspondence. In all these textual categories, several topics related to the political discourse are expressed by metaphors. In particular: phases of political life, relations between kings, the concepts of alliance and enmity, characteristics of the Hittite king, and finally politically relevant events. These topics are closely related to one another from what can be called patterns or networks of metaphors. Metaphor is not here intended traditionally as figure of speech but, according to the so-called Conceptual Metaphor Theory developed by G. Lakoff and M. Johnson (see Metaphors we live by, 1980), as the result of a cognitive process. Metaphor is thus “pervasive in everyday life, not just in language but in thought and action” (Lakoff – Johnson 1980, 3). In this paper, in particular, I intend to discuss the metaphors employed in the three textual categories of treaties, international decrees and verdicts, and international correspondence in the aforementioned topics in order to answer the following research questions: (1) can networks of metaphors be found in a single category and/or in all of them?, (2) what is the function of these networks for the specific textual category and, more in general, for Hittite diplomacy?, and (3) do these networks show changes depending on the dating of the text or on the language (Hittite vs Akkadian)? The answer to these questions intend to underline the complexity of the Hittite diplomatic apparatus on the textual and on the conceptual level.
|
The Relevance (or Not) of Using Josephus to Study Social Realities of Women in the Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Carmen Palmer, Toronto School of Theology
When studying women within early Judaism, finding sources to confirm social realities can be difficult. When considering historical realities among the Dead Sea Scrolls, including the status and inclusion of women within the sectarian groups affiliated with the scrolls, scholarship often looks to the work of Josephus for historical confirmation. The works of Josephus that discuss the Essenes are usually correlated to the Qumran movement, whether those members are affiliated with the site of Qumran or elsewhere. It has been debated whether it is possible to mine the literary works of Josephus for factual historical information, acknowledging that he wrote with a certain apologetic. Steve Mason has argued that such attempts will not work as hoped, and furthermore, that the group that Josephus defines as the Essenes may not be that group or those groups affilated with the site of Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls. These considerations raise the methodological question whether it is appropriate to use Josephus as a comparative source when considering social realities for women within the Qumran movement. This paper will explore this question by performing a case study that analyzes two topics in which women are discussed within the Damascus Document and related 4QD material, namely slavery (e.g. CD XII, 10-11; CD XI, 12) and marriage (e.g. CD XIII, 16-17; 4Q271 Frag. 3, 12-15). The paper will contrast the material from within this rule text among the Dead Sea Scrolls, along with any corroborating archaeological data (if available), against material from Josephus (Ant. 18.21; J.W. 2.120-121, 160-161). Using the careful lens of Mason as a guide, we shall see that those individuals described by Josephus may not relate historically to regulations found in the Damascus Document in which women are identified as both slaves and spouses.
|
Translating Metaphors of Sex into a Culture Where Sex is a Taboo Subject
Program Unit: Bible Translation Workshop (EABS)
Ma'afu Palu, United Bible Societies
In this paper, I wish to explore the semantic and pragmatic range of metaphors of sex in the Bible with special reference to the way in which they were translated in the current versions of the Tongan Bible. We have two versions of the Tongan Bible, both of which were translated in the nineteenth century by missionaries. While the Tongan culture has exhibited strong evidence of modernism, the subject of sex, and its derivative notions (eg. sexual immorality, prostitution, homosexuality) remain a culturally taboo subject. As a result, the terminologies that are current in reference to sex and sexually related subjects are freight with pejorative and well-nigh-rude terms which cannot be used widely in public forums or Bible translation. So, how best can we translate sex and sexually related metaphors in cultures such as the Tongan culture, where this is an embarrassing subject to be brought up in an open and public discussion let alone, in the Bible, which is widely supposed to be the sacred word of God?
|
Jewish Identity and Everyday Life in Early Byzantium
Program Unit: Construction of Identity in the Ancient World: Intersections and Reflections (EABS)
Alexander Panayotov, Centre for Advanced Study Sofia
My paper will present an overview of the epigraphic, archaeological and literary sources concerning Jewish life in the Balkans and the Aegean between the fourth and the first half of the seventh century. I aim to establish the place the Jews occupied in the stratigraphy of Byzantine society and how the social and political changes in this society influenced their communal life and identity. I will analyse information from inscriptions, archaeological data from excavated synagogues, cemeteries and moveable artefacts, literary sources and documentary materials including Roman and Byzantine legislation. I will focus my analysis on the communal organisation and leadership of the Jewish community, the social status, professions and cultural concerns of its members including religious feasts and burial practices. This will allow me to further suggest the possible ways Jews approached the new political and religious realities in early Byzantium – from the traditional Roman policy of protection of Jewish privileges to the reaction against Judaism and Jewish religious influence among Christians under Justinian I (527‐565) and the forcible baptism of Jews under Heraclius (610‐644).
|
The Grouping of Pauline Catena Manuscripts: A Crash Test
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the New Testament, the Old Testament and the Qur’an (EABS)
Theodora Panella, University of Münster
Scholars in the field of New Testament textual criticism are familiar with theories about types of text, families and groups identified by earlier scholars according to the content of manuscripts, even if some of these are considered today as out-dated. The text of the New Testament is not only found in a standalone form in a biblical codex, but also as a guide for the creation of commentaries and, later on, for compilations from multiple sources in the form known as the ‘catena’. Despite previous attempts to group New Testament catena manuscripts over the last century and a half, by scholars such as Cramer, Caro & Lietzmann, von Soden and Staab, this will show that there are gaps and misunderstandings regarding the proposed groups of the Pauline catena manuscripts and propose a new, more descriptive, way of identifying similarities between different witnesses.
|
The Parable of the Rich Man and Lazarus (Lk 16.19-31) and Luke’s Strategy for the Salvation of the Rich
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
James Panthalanickel, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
Early studies on the story of the Rich Man and Lazarus focus on its unity, extra-biblical parallels and its authenticity (Jülicher, Die Gleichnisreden Jesu, 1886 and 1899; Gressmann, Vom reichen Mann und armen Lazarus, 1918; Hock, “Lazarus and Micyllus,” JBL 106/3, 1987; Bauckham, “The Rich Man and Lazarus,” NTS 37/1, 1991). In the last decade, Outi Lehtipuu has demonstrated great interest in the afterlife imagery depicted in the parable (The Afterlife Imagery in Luke’s Story of the Rich Man and Lazarus, 2007). Recent research into the themes of possessions and poverty in Luke-Acts and early Christianity has examined Lk 16.19-31 as one of the significant texts and expounded the motifs of charity and renunciation of wealth as demands of discipleship (Seccombe, Possessions and the Poor in Luke-Acts, 1982; Metzger, Consumption and Wealth in Luke’s Travel Narrative, 2007; Hays, Luke’s Wealth Ethics, 2010). However, these explorations pay little or no attention to the motif of the salvation of the rich implied in the parable and in other related Lukan passages. Through a critical analysis of Lk 16.19-31 employing an “integrative and open model” of parable analysis (Zimmermann, Puzzling the Parables of Jesus, 2015), we will highlight Luke’s caricature of the rich man and identify the command to care for the poor as prescribed in the Law and the Prophets as a crucial and decisive element in the quest of a rich man for salvation.
|
The “Yoke of the Lord” and the Identity of the Community/ies of the Didache
Program Unit: Apostolic Fathers and Related Early Christian Literature
Nancy Pardee, Univ Chicago Greenberg Center for Jewish Studies
At the conclusion of the Two Ways in the H54 witness to the Didache, the text reads,
εἰ μὲν γὰρ δύνασαι βαστάσαι ὅλον τὸν ζυγὸν τοῦ κυρίου, τέλειος ἔσῃ· εἰ δ᾿ οὐ δύνασαι, ὃ δύνῃ, τοῦτο ποίει.
Clearly a correct interpretation of ὅλον τὸν ζυγὸν τοῦ κυρίου is crucial for understanding the (self-)identity of the communities associated with the Didache. In the last 15 years scholars increasingly have accepted it as a reference to the Law of Moses and as indicating that the community/ies of the Didache, at least at some point in their history, advocated for Torah practice, as far as possible, by gentile converts (Van de Sandt/Flusser, Draper, Slee; earlier Stuiber, Wengst). Rarely discussed—indeed almost summarily dismissed by Wengst—is what seems to be the surface meaning of the text, namely that the “yoke of the Lord” refers back to the Two Ways tradition, serving as an equivalent to ταύτης τῆς ὁδοῦ τῆς διδαχῆς in 6.1. This interpretation is warranted by the presence of the conjunction γάρ and is attested by the parallels in Barnabas, Doctrina, and the Apostolic Constitutions, all of which, despite variations, support this understanding of the text. Only in Did. 6.3 is the issue of Torah observance raised, here regarding food laws and specifically meat sacrificed to idols. It is significant that this is also where a disruption in the text occurs with the sudden appearance of the new topic marker περὶ δὲ, otherwise only seen outside the Two Ways teaching in Did. 7.1, 9.1, 3 and 11.3. This paper will seek to show that the Didache originally held gentiles simply to the Torah-based moral instruction of the Two Ways, that only subsequently was a rule on avoiding idol meat added, and that this was a position perhaps found with Paul as well.
|
Valence and Polyvalence: The Function of Magical Discourse in the Acts of Peter
Program Unit: Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha
Shaily Shashikant Patel, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University
In an essay on magic in the apocryphal acts, Bovon claimed that these acts might be treated as a whole by invoking the same episteme. For Bovon, the apocryphal acts presupposed, “an identical conception of eternal life that goes beyond doctrinal and ethical divergences.” Thus, all the narratives of magic in the apocryphal acts express the conviction that beyond the tangible world was a divine realm, one deserving priority. The supernatural deeds recounted in the Christian apocrypha do suggest the existence of such a divine realm, but their function is not limited to describing and prioritizing it. This paper examines the discourse of magic found in one of the apocryphal acts, the Acts of Peter, in order to justify the use of magic as a category for excavating the broader theological purposes of a text. My secondary aim is to highlight how attending to the unique nature of one text allows scholars to foreground differences that have been elided by our propensity to analyze these acts as a collection.
In short, in the Acta Petri, the discourse of magic is polysemous, with each valence carrying specific purpose. Scholars have noted that supernatural wonders are invariably followed by Peter’s audience converting to Christianity. Magical discourse is thus a vehicle for inculcating and stabilizing faith. But other functions obtain as well. For example, by demonstrating the exclusive efficacy of magic in inculcating faith, the Acts of Peter provides a corrective to the ways such practices are narrated and interpreted not only in the canonical acts but also in some traditions that would later comprise other apocryphal acts. Not only should this text be read individually, then, it should be read against the grain of other apocryphal acts, at least with respect to the magical activities narrated therein.
|
Marginal or Mainstream? Magic in the Acts of the Apostles
Program Unit: Graeco-Roman Society and the New Testament (EABS)
Shaily Shashikant Patel, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University
Émile Durkheim famously declared that there is no church of magic, meaning that magic’s purview lay outside that of institutionalized religions. It thus becomes a maligned, marginalized obverse of “proper” religion. Yet magical objects like the curse tablets excavated from Athens or the grimoires of the Theban Magical Library suggest that the practice of magic, institutionalized or not, was not nearly as marginal as Durkheimian conceptions might suggest. The pervasive nature of this “magical material” implies that the world occupied by the earliest Christians was teeming with magicians and their wares. On the one hand, magic may have been constructed as a marginal practice; yet, on the other hand, it enjoyed widespread popularity. This paper seeks to demonstrate how these dual aspects of ancient magic, held in tandem, might deepen our understanding of early Christianity. I aim to broaden modern notions of Christian magical ideation and participation by attending to the magical discourses in the canonical Acts of the Apostles. Scholarly treatments of Luke’s magical worldview claim that the Third Evangelist demonizes magical practices of outsiders in order to establish Christianity’s legitimacy. But considering the ubiquity of magic in ancient culture, one must also contend with the fact that Luke accommodates Christian participation in magic as well. The distinction between magical outsider and non-magical Christian is not as clear as we might expect. Magical differentiation in Luke lies not along the indices of insider/outsider, but rather, via the effects of the magical deeds themselves. Christian magic seeks to foster a unity within the fledgling community, to establish a hierarchy among group leaders, and yes, to distinguish Christians from outsiders. By highlighting the multiple, nuanced ways in which magic pervades the ancient world, I hope to complicate modern analyses of magic which are based on Durkheimian sociological frameworks.
|
The Parable of the Vomiting Son (Sifre Deut 43) In or Out of Context
Program Unit: Parables in Rabbinic Judaism and Early Christianity: Towards a New Comparative Approach (EABS)
Jonathan Pater, Tilburg University
Parables in rabbinic literature are always found in a specific literary context. Most parables are found in the context of midrash. Apparent tensions between the narrative of the parable (mashal), the application (nimshal), and the literary context (midrash) suggest that the parables had a literary prehistory and were redacted to fit in their present context. In some cases parallel versions of the parable can indeed be found in the context of another midrash. The redaction- critical approach of the parables in midrash, suggested for example by Catherine Hezser, is obviously legitimate. However, it is an interesting suggestion that such tensions can be deliberate and are part of the working of the parable in its complex interaction with the midrashic context and the biblical text. In this paper the parable of the vomiting son in Sifre Deuteronomy Pisqa 43 will be discussed to evaluate both approaches to the parables.
|
Forginess in the Book of Jeremiah
Program Unit: Prophets
Eric Peels, Theologische Universiteit (Apeldoorn)
The theme of forgiveness is at the heart of Jewish and Christian faith: credo remissionem peccatorum. Forgiveness is part and parcel of the image of JHWH in the Old Testament, as the ‘confession’ of Ex. 34:6-7 is reverberated many times throughout the OT literature. Now the book of Jeremiah is notorious for its fierce judgment oracles, leaving no or scarcely any room for hope for the future. It is quite striking, however, that precisely in this book so full of wrath and doom, the notion of forgiveness has got a particular place. Even most attestations in the prophetic literature of the root salach, the technical term for ‘forgiveness’, are found in the book of Jeremiah. Surprisingly so, since the last decades of the kingdom of Judah, the time of Jeremiah’s ministry, were overshadowed by the verdict ‘YHWH was not willing to forgive’ (2 Kgs 24:4). Hence, the place and function of the theme of forgiveness in Jeremiah are worthwhile to investigate in depth, as integrating part of the theology of this controversial prophetic book.
|
Joshua and Elijah as a Second Moses: A Literary Approach
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Yitzhak Peleg, Gordon College
The stories of Moses dominate four of the Torah's books, beginning with the Exodus from Egypt and ending with the leader’s death just before the entrance of the people to the Promised Land. Later biblical characters are formed in the image of Moses: stories about Joshua, Gideon, Elijah, and Elisha reflect stories about Moses. Even Jesus can be seen as a second Moses. In this paper I focus on two such biblical characters - Joshua and Elijah. One may say, as did the Sages, "like father like son."
In this paper I claim that Joshua, Moses' successor, is fashioned in the image of his master.. God said to Joshua: “My servant Moses is dead. Prepare to cross the Jordan […] As I was with Moses, so I will be with you" (Joshua 1:1-5). The word Moses itself serves as a leitwort (guiding or leading word). Indeed, the word Moses appears eleven times as a leading word in the first chapter of the Book of Joshua. I shall show that not all the resemblances between Moses and Joshua add a positive dimension to Joshua. Such is the case when Joshua Ch, 2:4 parallels Moses (Ex. 2:2) by sending spies to Canaan. The verb 'hidden' appears only twice in the Bible (Jos. 2:4; Ex. 2:2) and it functions as, "a rare guiding word" (this literary device). What can we learn from these analogies?
The story of Elijah in Horeb (I Ki. 19) is built on motifs borrowed from the Moses Cycle. But Elijah's arena is the land of Israel. If he suddenly makes his way to Horeb, what is the meaning of this unexpected journey? Defamiliarization (hazarah) is common in biblical literature. In this case we are encouraged by the presence of this literary device to seek for an answer regarding the linkage between Moses and Elijah. We must admit that a comparison between the two does not flatter Elijah.
|
The Narration of Our Father Agapius: The Slavonic Arrangement of the Greek Original
Program Unit: Rethinking Biblical Written Tradition through Slavonic Interpretations
Daria Penskaya, Independent scholar
The first part of the paper briefly introduces the unfinished and unpublished work of prof. Richard Pope, the scholar who in the year 1984 prepared the first edition of the Greek text of the Narration. The edition was based on the only manuscript known at the time in Greek: the one from Athens (ms. E.B.E. 2634, National Library of Athens). A decade later working in Russian archives Pope studied more than 120 Slavonic manuscripts of the Narration and prepared the book in which he treats the Slavonic tradition as a whole. This edition is accompanied by the Greek text that in some cases takes into account the evidence from the second existing manuscript, the one from St. Petersburg (RAIK 160, Library of the Russian Academy of Sciences). Pope left the work unfinished and bequeathed its completion to the next generation of scholars. It is now being prepared for publication by Daria Penskaya.
The second part discusses the Greek original of the Narration (following the critical edition prepared by D. Penskaya) with its Slavonic translation. The focus is on the text from the Uspensky Sbornik but other evidence from South and East Slavonic tradition is also taken into account. The translation has eliminated quite a few important traces of the Greek text, such as an intimate first-person narration and a striking detail when the main character himself tells about his death. The adjusted symbolic structure of the Narration that reveals the transformation of the character from myst to mystagogue seems to be eliminated in Slavonic tradition. Moreover, the main idea of the Greek text: the asсesis predominates over the koinobion - is scarcely readable. In fact, the text in the Slavonic tradition started resembling a fairytale.
|
Writing about Books within Scrolls: Portrayals of Scribal Craft and Written Tradition in the Aramaic Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Andrew Perrin, Trinity Western University
Motifs of writing, reading, and transmitting tradition are found across the Aramaic Dead Sea Scrolls. Inscribed content features regularly in settings of revelatory disclosure, portrayals of the transmission of tradition along approved genealogical channels, episodes accentuating the scribal profile of figures from the recent or remote past, and in outlooks undergirded by apocalyptic historiography. Using case studies of the permutations of this motif in texts such as Aramaic Levi Document, Visions of Amram, Genesis Apocryphon, Pseudo-Daniel, and 1 Enoch, the present paper works towards a comprehensive explanation of the rhetoric and function of scribalism across the Aramaic corpus. At an ideological-literary level, tracking consistencies and contrasts in this theme will add to our understanding of the unity/diversity of the Aramaic texts as a group. At a socio-historical level, the outcomes of this study point the way ahead for articulating the potential scribal qualities and social location of the group(s) behind this literature.
|
Unity and Authorship in the Vulgate of the Pauline Epistles: A New Methodology for the Analysis of the Latin New Testament
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the New Testament, the Old Testament and the Qur’an (EABS)
Anna Persig, University of Birmingham
The Vulgate revision of the Pauline Epistles is traditionally attributed to Saint Jerome although it is probably the work of an anonymous author whom some scholars have identified as Rufinus the Syrian. To date the language and the style of these texts have not been thoroughly studied and many uncertainties still remain regarding the authorship, the unity and the model of the Vulgate. My paper aims to describe an innovative approach that can be highly effective in addressing these issues. This methodology is combined with the use of new digital tools which make it possible to carry out a more extensive and accurate analysis than those previously undertaken. The method focuses on both internal and external criteria, and combines quantitative analysis with qualitative examination of particularly interesting features. It consists of four stages: a) the collection of data and creation of spreadsheets containing the lexical and syntactical renderings that differ in the Vetus Latina and the Vulgate of each Epistle and cannot be attributed to variant readings present in Greek tradition; b) the analysis of the reason for these variations; c) an internal examination in order to clarify the relationships between the Vetus Latina and the Vulgate within each epistle; d) an external comparison among the letters to understand if they constitute a unitary translation or are independent from each other. The results are then illustrated and their significance explained. Finally my contribution will give the opportunity to discuss the benefits and drawbacks of grouping the direct tradition and patristic citations into text types and to reflect more generally on the textual tradition of the Epistles in Latin.
|
"Μετὰ τὴν ἔγερσιν αὐτοῦ": Philological Evidences of an Interpolation in Matthew 27:53
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Anna Pessina, Catholic University of Sacred Hearth, Milano
Matt 27:51b-53 are some of the most discussed verses in the exegesis of the New Testament. Only in the Matthean redaction the moment of Jesus’ death is underlined by some apocalyptic signs. In Matt 27:53, the short addition «μετὰ τὴν ἔγερσιν αὐτοῦ» has been defined as «the most difficult phrase in Matt 27:51-53» (Brown 1994). It breaks the chronological sequence of the events and the rhythmic cadence of the text by postponing the rising of the saints or, at least, their appearance in Jerusalem to a different moment from that of the Passion.
After considering the main scholars’ positions about the nature and origin of the addition (either as Matthean [Schenk 1974, Wehnam 1981, Hill 1985, Maisch 1986, Wright 2003, Waters 2003, Quarles 2015] or as a later correction [Klostermann 1909, Riebl 1978, Schnachenburg 1987, Troxel 2002, Davies & Allison 2004, Luz 2005, Luiser 2008]), I will demonstrate how philological evidences could support the interpolation theory, through a deep rethinking of the early history of the text. This paper aims at a critical restitution of the early text of Matt 27:53, in which the addition was probably absent. In particular, this research will explain how the indirect tradition could have been a more notable witness of the original text of Mt 27:53 than the direct one, and how this peculiar situation could urge a deep reconsideration of the New Testament transmission history as a primary critical issue.
Finally, in this new proposal both the presence or the absence of «μετὰ τὴν ἔγερσιν αὐτοῦ» in Matt 27:53 imply theological consequences which must be taken into consideration.
|
The Beginning of the βγ Section in 2 Samuel
Program Unit: Septuagint of Historical Books (EABS)
Leonardo Pessoa, Pontificio Istituto Biblico
The beginning of the βγ section in 2 Samuel is still a matter of debate among Septuagint scholars. 2 Sam 10 is at times considered part of the βγ section, at times part of the ββ section. This divergence is found in recent publications and even in translations of LXX into modern languages; Septuaginta-Deutsch includes 2 Sam 10 in the βγ section, whereas for NETS the beginning of that section is found in 2 Sam 11. The difference is relevant because the beginning of the βγ section marks the beginning of the καίγε section in 2 Samuel, and the definition of its limits has implications for the study of the textual character of Codex Vaticanus, the relationship between the Greek textual witnesses, the role played by the Lucianic or Antiochene text in the reconstruction of the Old Greek, the relationship between the Greek manuscripts and other versions such as the Old Latin, the study of translation technique, and so on. This paper intends to explore the reasons that lead scholars like Thackeray, Barthélemy, Shenkel and Wirth to accept or reject 2 Sam 10 as part of the καίγε section, and to offer an evaluation of the current status of the research on the subject. In order to find the starting point of the βγ section, attention will be paid to the presence or absence of linguistic traits typical of καίγε through 2 Sam 10.
|
The Synoptic Problem, Ancient Historiography, and Luke’s Preface
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Josh Peters, Regent University
In view of the current consensus that Luke wrote as an ancient historian, scholarship on the Synoptic Problem has paid insufficient attention to the distinction within ancient historiography between accounts written about events contemporary with the author (e.g., by Thucydides, Xenophon, Polybius) and accounts written about non-contemporary events (e.g., by Diodorus, Dionysius, Plutarch, Arrian). Richard Bauckham recently commented on the subject recognizing “that the gospels are some sort of historiography" and that "the earlier ones are contemporary history, written within living memory of the events, the sort of history people expected to be closely based on eyewitness testimony.”1 While classicists (e.g., John Marincola, Guido Schepens, Luke Pitcher, et al) widely recognize that ancient authors of contemporary histories represented the sources for their accounts in terms of autopsy and eyewitness testimony, very few scholars of the Gospels have recognized that Luke’s preface largely corresponds with this ancient historiographical practice.
In view of the fact that Luke represented his two-volume account as a contemporary history, the paper argues that analogies with ancient historians and his use of “attempted” (Luke 1.1; Acts 9.29; 19.13) indicate that Luke represented as the sources for his account not the “many” prior narratives referenced in Luke 1.1, which he implies were somehow inadequate, but the “eyewitnesses” and “servants of the word.” The conventions and epistemological hierarchy of historiographical practice deriving from Herodotus and Thucydides, indicate that the last thing historians of contemporary events wanted was for audiences to believe that their accounts were based on the writings of other authors. These conclusions pose direct problems for the major theories of the Synoptic Problem which assume that the prior accounts Luke references functioned as his written sources.
1. Richard Bauckham, “Gospels before Normativization" JSNT 37, no. 2 (December 2014): 198.
|
Inside an Apocalyptic Gallery? Visionary Re-adaptations of Biblical Traditions in the Hellenistic Era and Later On
Program Unit: Slavonic Parabiblical Traditions (EABS)
Julian Petkov, Heidelberg University
The Hellenistic period of Jewish history is commonly referred to as the natal hour of apocalyptic literature within and beyond the Bible. It is well known for the emergence of both the genre of otherworldly journeys (Henoch) and historical eschatology – the latter dealing with the profound cataclysms that took place in the Near East from the 3th century BC on (Daniel).
In my paper, however, I will discuss the textual evidence for the revelatory re-framing of key Biblical episodes in this period and later on. In particular, I will focus on the visionary portraits of Abraham and Jacob found in some later Slavonic texts initially originating from the timespan in question (Apocalypses and Testaments of both patriarchs). In my view, these apocalyptic sketches most probably reflect the transmission of Henochic traits to a broader group of biblical characters.
Furthermore, the striking similarities between some of the texts (Apocalypse of Abraham and Ladder of Jacob) suggest that they should not be regarded as disconnected writings but rather as pieces of the same ‘puzzle’. Taken together, they disclose the use of an ‘apocalyptic prism’ directed towards the long-known tales of the patriarchs as a means of interpretation and re-actualization. In my brief review I will attempt to summarise some of its peculiarities.
The existence of such an apocalyptic tool for exegesis necessarily raises a bundle of further questions. Amongst other things, it is pertinent to ask to what extent the evidence presented might relate to an ongoing process of intense re-reading of the Torah in the light of mystical speculation.
|
The Need for a Comprehensive Sociology of Knowledge of Biblical and Archaeological Studies of the Southern Levant
Program Unit: Nationalism, Religion, and Archaeology (EABS)
Emanuel Pfoh, CONICET / National University of La Plata
During the last thirty years in the field of biblical and archaeological studies of the Southern Levant (a.k.a. “ancient Israel”, a.k.a. “ancient Palestine”), a considerable amount of criticism has been produced from within the field itself towards (1) the ways the history of “ancient Israel” is re/constructed considering alternative histories of ancient Palestine, (2) the historical value of the Hebrew Bible/Old Testament as a primary or secondary source for such a history, and (3) the political implications of such re/constructions of the past, both the traditional and the alternative. While these developments represent—in spite of some academic unpleasantries—a healthy symptom of epistemological reflexivity in Old Testament scholarship and Syro-Palestinian archaeology, much more work should be pursued, beyond limited topics and transcending episodic discussions. This paper calls, therefore, for establishing a serious and comprehensive study of the conditions in which institutional knowledge on the Old Testament and about the history of Israel/Palestine is produced and reproduced as an international discourse (through academic meetings, research projects, media and popular culture, etc.), touching upon issues of national memories and identities and past and current politics in Israel/Palestine.
|
Ethnography, Allochronism and the Problem of the Modern Discovery of the ‘Biblical World’
Program Unit: Anthropology and the Bible (EABS)
Emanuel Pfoh, CONICET / National University of La Plata
This paper seeks to explore the temporal and cultural displacements that nineteenth-century Western travel accounts in the southern Levant produced through different streams of scientific exploration, in particular after insights into the ethnography of Levantine societies as reflecting directly the most ancient ‘biblical world’. By analyzing samples from these textual sources from critical ethnographical and historical perspectives, we can dissect the construction and workings of a Western discourse dealing with the biblical past (i.e., building upon the continental research in biblical studies, but also upon the developments in biblical archaeology and cartography). A critical reflection on these modernist epistemologies sheds light on how much of them have survived in current historical and sociological reconstructions of the ‘biblical world’.
|
"Just Is" After Atrocity: Lady Justice, Lex Talionis, and the Artwork of Samuel Bak
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Culture
Gary Phillips, Wabash College
In a stunning series of paintings and drawings entitled "Just Is 2016," Holocaust survivor/artist Samuel Bak interrogates and reanimates the iconic image of Lady Justice and the biblical principle of retributive justice expressed in the Lex Talionis. Bak refracts conventional representations of western and biblical justice through the lens of his experience as a child survivor of the Vilna ghetto liquidation and the murder of his family in the Ponari forest. He draws upon palette and vision to question the very possibility of justice lived after such atrocity. On Bak’s canvasses moral universe gives way to atrocity universe where Justice is refigured as Just Is, evoking in the title a necessary mixture of resignation and responsibility that falls to him as artist.
Theodor Adorno famously asserted that the work of writing poetry after Auschwitz is barbaric, and yet, paradoxically, art cannot not attempt to express the suffering. By that aesthetic and moral standard, Bak’s artwork is at once disturbingly barbaric and beautiful; he embraces the responsibility imposed upon him as artist to give voice to the suffering. Through his engagement with western biblical and juridical traditions, Bak invites his viewers to take up the demanding interpretive work of reimagining justice for their day. In our present age of atrocity, what shape does Lady Justice and the biblical Lex Talionis take? How might we reimagine the rule of law and the biblical demand for justice in an era where the unspeakable has become normative? Bak’s midrashic brush and unblinking eye show us one way to face up to, not turn away from, these necessary questions. His artwork both challenges and inspires confidence that the work of Just Is remains just possible. (https://www.puckergallery.com/artists/#/samuel-bak/).
|
After The Postmodern Bible: Theory, Silence, and Other Barbarisms
Program Unit: Deconstructive Poetics (EABS)
Gary A. Phillips, Wabash College
The double aim of The Postmodern Bible (PMB) was to report on a transformed biblical scholarship and to engage in transforming a modern biblical scholarship viewed as insufficiently critical and theoretical about the cultural conditions that produced, sustained, and validated the dominant historical approaches to biblical study. The hope was that the volume, both by its content and form of production, could help bring biblical scholarship into a meaningful engagement with current political, cultural, and epistemological critiques afoot in fruitful forms of literary and cultural criticism. Yet, despite all best intentions, to what extent was this volume and its collective authorship sufficiently critical of its committed political and ethical efforts in a postmodern age marked not just by theory but by atrocity? Did the PMB ironically aid in obscuring the role of the Bible and biblical scholarship not only after Auschwitz but also during the ethnic cleansing in Bosnia as the book was being written? Why was the PMB virtually silent about atrocity and violence?
This paper raises these and other questions with the aid of Theodor Adorno’s critique of committed art. “After Auschwitz to write poetry is barbaric,” Adorno writes. Is barbaric an apt judgment about any writing about theory and critique, modern or postmodern, that remains silent in the face of the profound suffering of others? Now 23 years after publication, this original member of the Bible and Culture Collective asks whether the PMB was transforming politically and ethically in ways that matter most.
|
Digital Bibles and Manuscripts: Exploring Breadth, Durability and Materiality
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical Studies, Early Jewish and Christian Studies (EABS)
Peter M. Phillips, University of Durham
The digitisation of manuscripts is a major academic industry, which in turn is leading to an important increase in first class research in what those manuscripts reveal. Providing access to first class resources feeds research. The complexity and breadth of provision is remarkable. The first section of this paper will look at some key examples and discuss where we go next with digitisation and the increasing use of computer reading but also of the problems of durability and longevity for these academic projects. What happens when the tech changes?
The second section will look at Digital bible provision, which is remarkably conservative, limited to a few sources and tending to provide access to the Protestant canon. In what ways could Bible provision be expanded - perhaps to include possibilities of new canons and revised readings of texts. What are the thoughts of the key players in this industry on expanding into alternative texts? How accessible are alternative sources for Second Temple Judaism and early Christianity?
Finally, the paper will explore the importance of the increasing dissemination of facsimile copies of manuscripts, looking especially at the advantages and disadvantages of a facsimile copy of the so-called Cuthbert Bible held by Durham Cathedral.
The paper will conclude with some considerations of the benefits of digitisation programmes and the potential enhancement of such programmes through provision of high quality physical replicas of manuscripts and bibles.
|
Anthropology among Fellahs and Diplomats: Hilma Granqvist in Palestine 1925-1931
Program Unit: History of Biblical Scholarship in the Late Modern Period
Kira Pihlflyckt, University of Helsinki
Hilma Granqvist (1890-1972), one of the foremost Finnish anthropologists, conducted fieldwork in the Palestinian village of Artas in 1925-1931. Focusing on the meaning of religious practice in modern societal life and life cycle rituals, Granqvist produced material known for its extraordinary systematic completeness and its valuable descriptions of local traditions and dialects.
Granqvist's diaries from 1930-1931 describe this fieldwork experience. The rituals of everyday life in Artas with its village gossip and intrigue are interjected with notes from Jerusalem "the melting pot", where religious diplomacy and world politics take centre stage. This contrast of village life with its Fellahs celebrating weddings and mourning its dead, and the city life with its religious conflicts and European gossip is striking and fascinating, producing an insightful picture of life in Palestine in the 1930s.
These travel diaries, along with Granqvist's fieldnotes, photographs and published books, are currently being digitalised and partly translated into English as part of a project to make Granqvist's scattered archives available to scholars and readers everywhere. The extent and preciseness of the material makes it a seminal body of research material for anyone interested.
|
Confession, Trust, Lordship, and Resurrection: A Negotiation of the Salvific Purpose, Consequences, and Effect of the Resurrection of Jesus as Articulated in Romans 10:9
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Edward Pillar, Northern Baptist College
In Romans 10:9 the Apostle Paul appears to give us a clear indication of the means of salvation, ‘Because if you confess with your lips that Jesus is Lord and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved.’ Wright describes this statement as ‘what precisely Christian faith consists of.’ (Wright, ‘Romans.’ NIC. p.664). However, is salvation just so straightforward and can we concur that this statement precludes other means of salvation? Why and how is salvation dependent upon confession of the Lordship of Jesus and the belief in his resurrection? It is the particular aim of this paper while briefly considering the importance of the Lordship confession, to focus our discussion on the link between the resurrection of Jesus and salvation. In order to do this we shall make a brief overview of salvation within the Pauline corpus, before exploring what can be understood as the salvific purpose, consequences and effect of the resurrection of Jesus. We shall take Wright, Campbell and Kirk as our interlocutors, and consider how each of these scholars engages with Romans 10:9, with a particular consideration of the stress on resurrection.
|
“From ‘What a God is Not’ to ‘There are No Gods’”: Negative Theology and Its Interpretation as an Atheistic Attitude
Program Unit: What a God is Not – The Early History of Negative Theology (EABS)
Pablo Pinel Martínez, Universidad Complutense de Madrid
The paper which I propose primarily deals with the connection between Xenophanes’ description of what the One God is and the Sisyphus fragment, usually attributed to Critias (Critias, B25 DK). The similarity between the description of
Xenophanes’ divinity and the one which the character speaking in Critias’ fragment describes as invented by a cunning legislator has previously been pointed out, but there has been little explanation to what such coincidence means.
To account for this, I will try to prove that, since the Sisyphus fragment can be read as a heterogeneous mixture of doctrines that were regarded as atheistic at the time, negative theology and even rational theology might have been thought to that kind of belief. Other sources that will be of use to illustrate this will be the caricatures of atheism depicted by Athenian comedy (especially Aristophanes), and Xenophon’s and Plato’s Apologies, which also contribute to our knowledge of what was considered as atheistic then. Finally, I will also try to briefly explain what relationship negative theology has to other attitudes that were thought to be impious, and also describe how speaking about what a god is not may have been reinterpreted as saying that there are no gods. Therefore, my paper contributes to our knowledge of the relationship between presocratic philosophy and sophistics, and also adds to our insight of what Athenians thought atheism was and how it was related to certain philosophical doctrines that (at least from our point of view), not only are not necessarily atheistic, but even demand the existence of the Divine.
|
David’s Dirge of 2 Samuel 1: A Multidisciplinary Approach
Program Unit: Septuagint of Historical Books (EABS)
Andres Piquer-Otero, Universidad Complutense de Madrid
David’s dirge for Saul and Jonathan is quite an uncanny piece in the corpus of biblical poetry for exhibiting both important parallels with pre-biblical NWS literature (e.g. verse 21 and the Ugaritic Epic of Aqhat) and an interesting textual history in the framework of the textual plurality of Samuel-Kings. This paper tries to reconsider both the Ancient Near Eastern context and possible intertextuality and the reconstruction of the Hebrew Vorlage underlying the Old Greek text from a holistic discourse-analysis perspective, which hopes to shed some light on the history of redaction and transmission of the text while reflecting on the limits of intertextual and source analysis models.
|
Deuteronomy 26:1-11 and Community Solidarity
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Pekka Pitkänen, University of Gloucestershire
Dt 26:1-11 has drawn considerable attention in the past. Von Rad famously considered that vv. 5-9 contained a small historical creed (kleines geschichtliches Credo). This paper proposes to first briefly review scholarship on the portrayed ritual and then look at the ritual from the perspective of community solidarity. It will in particular make a comparison and interact with Ronal Grimes’s work on the contemporary Santa Fe Fiesta (esp. Ronald Grimes, The Craft of Ritual Studies, Oxford: OUP, 2014). In the Santa Fe Fiesta, the rituals employed transform but also in a number of ways distort historical experiences so as to achieve the function of the fiesta in promoting peace and community cohesion. The possession of the Americans of the land is a theme that underlies the Santa Fe Fiesta as is the case with the biblical text of Dt 26:1-11, accordingly, it should be possible to make some fruitful comparisons between the Santa Fe Fiesta and the biblical text. The paper will also consider the timing of the ritual in Dt 26:1-11 that appears somewhat unique and separate from the three annual pilgrimage festivals. With the issue of community solidarity in the foreground, the paper will then reflect on how this ritual might relate to the overall Israelite festivals as portrayed in Deuteronomy.
|
Drinking with a Lion: A Symposium Motif
Program Unit: Iconography and Biblical Studies (EABS)
Lukasz P. Popko, École biblique & archéologique française Jérusalem
Lion-headed cups occur sparingly but regularly among archaeological finds beginning from MB Anatolia up to LB Ugarit and Iron age Philistine sites and NA period. They have not been found in the Samaritan or Judean highlands, but there too the lion motif was associated with wine as is suggested by the Tell Dothan krater, which is decorated with lions. Since the meaning and function of these objects remain disputed, it is desirable to seek a better documented context. The palace of Sargon II in Khorsabad gives us a relative abundance of iconography and written sources. The most probable setting for the lion-headed cups is a non-cultic banquet: there the hierarchy among the drinking men is both confirmed and challenged. Sargon was regularly presented as a lion-slayer and it is not by accident that on the same reliefs lion heads decorate the swords and beakers. His officials while drinking alcohol and speaking were thus constantly reminded that they were literally facing a lion-king. A similar social and metaphoric setting sheds some light on the Philistine drinking parties with another lion-slaying participant: Samson. His riddle in Judg 14:14 and the Philistine riddle-like question in v. 18 fit the context of a symposium challenge. Yet, their importance within the story goes beyond the immediate intent of their authors because the riddles remain meaningful for the whole of Samson’s story. In fact, they incite and express the reader’s main puzzlement in identifying the strongest one: is it Samson, his women, the Philistines, or the riddle itself? Indeed, since Samson has always remained God’s instrument, Samson’s riddle is also the riddle of God. Sweeter than honey and stronger than a lion, He is to be declared the hidden winner.
|
Thirty-Five Arad Payment Orders
Program Unit: Northwest Semitic Epigraphy Related to the Biblical World (EABS)
Bezalel Porten, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
Of the eighty some Aramaic ostraca from Arad, the largest group consists of thirty-five payment orders, all from the same locus and square. One of them (Arad 12 = ISAP 2112) uses the word mdyntʾ, (“province”), and thereby confirms the designation of Diodorus that Edom was an “eparchy” (XIX , 95.2). As the northern province Yehud (yhwd) was designated mdyntʾ, so was its southern neighbor, Edom. Moreover, the same ostracon refers to the dgl (“detachment”) of Abdnanai. This term is well known from the military colony at Elephantine and indicates that a similar organization was stationed in or around Arad. On the basis of the names on the payment orders, we conclude that it was a mixed unit of Jews and non-Jews. At least a third of the ostraca record animals—horses, colts, donkeys and camels, over forty in all. The grains to be distributed were wheat, barley, and crushed/sifted grain. We discuss who got what and how much. Each text has a day date (between 2 and 9), a signatory (Yaddu), and a sealing sign (archaic alef). The orders were issued outside Arad and the supplies provided there. Once paid out, the orders were kept there for further reference
|
“And He Placed the Plant of Life in Their Nostrils…”: Metaphorical Allusions to Life-Giving Plants in Neo-Assyrian Texts and Images
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible (EABS)
Ludovico Portuese, Freie Universität Berlin
In the royal correspondence of late Assyrian kings (8th-7th century BCE), a few letters refer to the so-called “plant of life” (Akk. šammu balāṭi) being placed by the king in the mouth or nostrils of his subjects. Textual evidence seemingly bestows symbolic meanings to this plant that suggest it is a metaphor of the king’s mercy to save and sustain the life of his subordinates. Moreover, far from being a common attitude, letters make explicit that only loyal vassals and trustworthy court members deserved such a treatment. Thus, textual evidence points to a metaphorical use of the “plant of life”.
At the same time, in the royal iconography that goes from Tiglath-pileser III onward (8th century BCE), sculptures and wall paintings often show the ruler holding a plant or flower either in his lowered left hand, or in his upraised right hand placing the plant/flower close to his nose. In images, the king exhibits sometimes the plant/flower in ‘audience scenes’ when he receives foreign vassals and court members.
Despite studies on a variety of aspects of life-giving plants in Mesopotamian literature and iconography, there appear to be few or even no specific studies on the ‘plant of life’ in Neo-Assyrian texts and images. This paper fills part of this gap by analysing the portraits of the kings in the light of textual evidence in order to identify the function of the ‘plant of life’. A link between texts and images will be proposed, thereby suggesting that the plant was used primarily by the king to express his mercy and metaphorically to indicate himself as a ‘life-giving’ ruler.
|
Negative Theology in the Levant? A View from Divine Epithets
Program Unit: What a God is Not – The Early History of Negative Theology (EABS)
Fabio Porzia, Université de Toulouse - Jean Jaurès
On October 2017 a group of post-docs led by Corinne Bonnet started the ERC Project 741182 called “Mapping Ancient Polytheisms” which is hosted at the University of Toulouse – Jean Jaurès (France). The MAP project seeks to challenge our understanding of ancient religions by focusing on a heretofore neglected aspect: divine epithets, that is to say, all information usually added to the divine name, understood as the interface between divine systems and human contexts. Proceeding with a systematic scrutiny of epigraphic and literary sources, the project will examine both polytheistic religions (Greek world, Phoenician, and Aramaic) and a monotheistic religion (biblical Judaism) to compare their strategies of naming, organising, and calling upon the gods. Concentrating on these aspects does not preclude the possibility of isolating some tendencies that could be related to “negative theology.” From this perspective, the corpus of Levantine epithets dating to the Iron Age and the Persian period, including a selection of those from the Hebrew Bible (such as the book of Psalms) will be examined. Despite the modern willingness to write systematic theologies, these documents, the Hebrew Bible included, seem to prefer scattered and partial references to gods. In particular, the fragmentation of a god or, to quote J.-P. Vernant, “divine power,” into a broad spectrum of epithets, each connected to a particular aspect or competence, and the consequent multiplication of divine epithets can be interpreted as a strategy to underline the gods’ ineffability and the impossibility of fully grasping the divine.
|
God’s Knowledge of Creation in Scholastic Theology: Biblical and Philosophical Perspectives
Program Unit: Biblical Reception History and Authority in the Middle Ages and Beyond (EABS)
Mikko Posti, University of Helsinki
The central aim of medieval scholastic theology was to reconcile biblical teaching, as interpreted by the Catholic Church, with Aristotelian and Neoplatonic philosophy. In some cases, the doctrines put forth by the philosophers were in clear contradiction with the Christian theological ideas. The doctrine of divine omniscience provides one such example. Aristotle had defined the unmoved mover as eternal, perfect, unchanging, and most importantly, as pure self-thought. In other words, Aristotle’s unmoved mover is an idea that consists of simply thinking of itself and without knowledge of anything distinct from itself. The philosophical formulations of God put forth by the Islamic philosophers Avicenna and Averroes emphasized the perfection of God’s knowledge. They argued that God knew and had care for the created beings only on the level of species, but ultimately remained indifferent towards the particular beings residing in the lower world. The perfection of God’s knowledge required the perfection of the objects of this knowledge. Limiting God’s knowledge to the general features of the species of beings had the conceptual task of safeguarding divine perfection.
In this presentation, I will show how the Christian scholastic theologians opposed such a view of God’s knowledge largely on Scriptural grounds. All the scholastic theologians affirmed that God had both knowledge of and care for the particular created beings. In addition to strictly Biblical arguments, they argued that being omniscient required knowing the contingent features of particular beings in addition to knowing the general features of species of beings. I will focus especially on theories and arguments put forth by Dominican Thomas Aquinas (1225–1275) and Franciscan Peter Auriol (c. 1280–1322).
|
A Spatial Rhetoric? Spatial Metaphors as a Means of Persuasion in Rom 5:12–21
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Annette Potgieter, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin - Humboldt University of Berlin
George Lakoff and Mark Johnson’s seminal book “Metaphors we live by” (1980) has given rise to the realisation that a metaphor is not just a linguistic phenomenon, but also conceptual, socio-historical, neural and bodily phenomenon establishing mental models. Rom 5:12–21 is saturated with rich imagery. The rhetorical impetus of pericope is often highlighted. Nonetheless, the imagery of persuasion is often overlooked. Especially, the value spatial metaphors add to Paul’s argument as spatial metaphors also have a rhetorical function. This paper investigates persuasion in Rom 5:12–21 drawing on spatial metaphors.
|
Defining Diaspora in the Joseph Story (Gen 37–50)
Program Unit: Political Biblical Criticism
Frederik Poulsen, University of Copenhagen
At first glance, Genesis 37–50 offers a strikingly optimistic vision of Jewish life in a foreign land: Joseph, banished by his brothers and sold into slavery in Egypt, soon rises to become co-regent with the Pharaoh. Receiving a local name and marrying into an important Egyptian family, he assimilates thoroughly into the culture of the host country. Egypt is presented as a land full of opportunities for immigrants. A closer look at the story as a whole, however, reveals different views concerning life among foreigners. While some scholars attribute these differences to discrete redactional layers (e.g. J. Wöhrle), this paper argues that such seemingly contrasting views testify to the ambivalence of Jewish life in the Diaspora. To shed light on this issue, the paper will draw from insights and methodology from the emerging field of diaspora studies. Kim D. Butler, in the article “Defining Diaspora” (2001), outlines five dimensions to detect and compare variant aspects of diasporic existence: 1. the conditions of the relocation (forced or voluntary), 2. relationship with the homeland (political, religious, imagined), 3. relationship with the hostland (assimilation, cultural retention), 4. interrelationships within the diasporic communities (dependency, rivalry), and 5. comparative studies of different diasporas. By applying Butler’s approach, the paper seeks to identity, isolate, and compare distinctive aspects of life in the Diaspora as envisioned in the Joseph Story.
|
Old Testament Theology According to Johannes Jacobsen
Program Unit: History of Biblical Scholarship in the Late Modern Period
Frederik Poulsen, Københavns Universitet
Johannes Jacobsen, a contemporary of Frants Buhl, was Professor of Theology at the University of Copenhagen from 1891 to 1929. The paper first offers a brief introduction to his life and work. Then, the paper reviews Jacobsen’s contribution to the field of Old Testament theology in his small monograph “Om ‘Den gammeltestamentlige Theologi’ som theologisk Disciplin” from 1912. Key issues in the review will be Jacobsen’s reflections on the history and purpose of the discipline, his assessment of the scholarship of his own time (e.g. J. Wellhausen), and his concluding vision for future studies.
|
"Warmth Fled Away and Coldness Ruled His Body": Ishoʿdad of Merv's Commentary on 1 Kings 1
Program Unit: Bible and Syriac Studies in Context
Marion Pragt, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
At the end of his life King David became so cold that no blankets could keep him warm, until eventually a young woman was brought to stay with him (1 Kings 1). This paper focuses on the portrayal of David's coldness in Syriac biblical interpretation with particular emphasis on Ishoʿdad of Merv, the ninth century bishop and biblical interpreter. The paper will situate Ishoʿdad's interpretation in the context of late antique and early medieval exegetical traditions and compare it to the views of some of his predecessors (Ephrem, Daniel of Salah, Theodore bar Koni). Ishoʿdad discusses and rejects several different explanations of the causes of David's cold body. He insists that the single correct understanding is that of 'the schools' - referring to the East Syrian school tradition - upon which he then expands. Ishoʿdad states that covering a cold person is not effective by itself, in the same way that throwing a blanket over a stone would not have any effect on its temperature. It will be shown how Ishoʿdad uses the oppositions between warm and cold, and dry and wet to explain why only young women - who are associated with moisture - could warm David, who had become cold and dry. Moreover, it is argued that Ishoʿdad's interpretation may be explained with reference to the concept of vital or innate heat as used by Aristotle and Galen. Finally, the paper discusses how Ishoʿdad's interpretation fits his overall portrayal of David. In this way, the paper aims to show how two strands of intellectual tradition - biblical interpretation on the one hand, and Greek philosophy and medicine on the other - are brought together in Ishoʿdad's commentary on 1 Kings.
|
Gathered from the Lands: Reading Psalm 107 as a Spatial Journey from Exile to Restoration
Program Unit: Place, Space, and Identity in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Gert Prinsloo, University of Pretoria
In many ways, Psalm 107 is a remarkable text eliciting both consensus and controversy. On the one hand, remarkable consensus exists regarding the structure of the poem. The poem is introduced (vv. 1-3) by a call for thanksgiving based upon YHWH’s covenantal love directed towards the redeemed whom he has gathered from lands located at the ends of the earth. The call to thanksgiving is followed by four examples of groups of people who were in dire straits, called upon YHWH in their distress, and were saved by him (vv. 4-32). On the other hand, equally remarkable controversy characterizes the scholarly discussion on the unity, date, literary and social function of the poem. Doubts about the unity of the text have often been expressed. On form-critical and redaction-critical grounds, different origins and Sitzen im Leben have been proposed for the different structural building blocks of the poem. Psalm 107 clearly illustrates that consensus regarding structure and content does not translate into consensus regarding function, setting and date. In this study an alternative reading of Psalm 107 will be proposed, one that neither focuses upon form-critical and redaction-critical issues, nor upon purely literary insights. The study departs from two general observations: first, that Psalm 107 is literally obsessed with notions of space and spatiality; second, that Psalm 107 appears at a very conspicuous place as the introductory poem to Book V of the Psalter. By utilizing insights from the field of critical spatiality, I propose that a spatial reading of the poem will elucidate its content and function as an introduction to a spatial journey from exile to restoration and from collective despair to the universal adoration of YHWH, the Creator-King.
|
Christians on the Western Black Sea Coast according to the Epigraphic Evidence from Moesia Secunda and Haemimontus
Program Unit: Graeco-Roman Society and the New Testament (EABS)
Maya Prodanova, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin - Humboldt University of Berlin
The emergence of organised Christian communities in the province of Thracia and the late antique Thracian dioecesis can be described as a very uneven process. Although two of the prominent Graeco-Roman settlements in the coastal region, the Greek city of Anchialos and the Roman colony of Deultum are reported in Eusebius’ Ecclesiastical History (Eus. Hist. Eccl. V 19,3) to have been among the very first Thracian cities to be reached by Christianity, the archaeological evidence has failed to deliver a decisive proof of that claim. However, the study of inscriptions originating from the Black Sea Coast, the late antique provinces of Haemimontus and Moesia Secunda in particular, can shed some important light on the life and origin of the first Christians in this part of the Balkan Peninsula.
As part of a dissertation on the rise of Thracian Christianity, this paper focuses on the Christian epigraphic evidence from the Black Sea Coast of modern-day Bulgaria. It aims to present and discuss a selection of the available sources (4th-6th century), which alongside with archaeological evidence from this period allow to draw some conclusions about the profile of the Christian believers in selected coastal cities (Odessos, Sozopolis, Mesembria), as well as to address questions concerning the formation of Christian identity in a culturally diversified society.
|
Child-Sacrifice, Power and Identity in the New Testament: Links and Problems
Program Unit: Families and Children in the Ancient World
Jeremy Punt, Stellenbosch University
Sacrifice is a central biblical metaphor that informs the discursive frameworks of New Testament documents. At the same time, in the world contemporary to the NT, sacrifice was also a pervasive phenomenon. Far from merely being a ritual currying religious favour, sacrifice in the NT times had everything to do with social location, identity and power as well – which form the nexus for making sense of child sacrifice. The study of child sacrifice in the NT often, rightly, invokes its Jewish setting and frame, but it is a move that sometimes passes over the contemporary ancient Mediterranean world too glibly. This paper traces the links between sacrifice, power and identity, and how these links related to child sacrifice in the ancient world and selected NT texts in particular.
|
The Postmodern Bible and Reception History
Program Unit: Deconstructive Poetics (EABS)
Hugh S. Pyper, University of Sheffield
As with any other text, the Postmodern Bible has now accumulated its own history of reception. The book itself, however, contains explicit predictions and speculations on the future of biblical interpretation. Interestingly, reception history does not appear as one of the seven major approaches that the volume seeks to cover, reflecting the fact that the last twenty years have seen a new turn to reception and its problems as a focus for research. In this paper, the predictions in The Postmodern Bible are examined in light of the evidence that the programme book of the International Meeting provides as to the state of biblical studies at present. The question to be asked is whether the Postmodern Bible provides underused resources for reflection on the history of reception that have a new pertinence in the present state of the discipline.
|
Coherence within "Chaos": Techniques to Increase or Evoke Coherence in the Book of Numbers
Program Unit: Developing Exegetical Methods (EABS)
Katharina Pyschny, University of Lausanne
Since the farewell of the documentary hypothesis in the 20th century, the Book of Numbers became somehow the sleeping beauty of Pentateuchal research. Its structure and content often characterized as non-systematic, amply obscure or chaotic (e.g., M. Noth), for many scholars the Book of Numbers turned out to be a “parking area” or a reservoir for rather late material that could not find a place within the Sinai-pericope (anymore). Thus, the redactional processes within the Book of Numbers were thought to be predominantly about the preservation of traditions rather than evoking or increasing coherence. The tables turned significantly in the last two decades thanks to scholars who emphasized the book’s Janus face or narrative bridging function keeping in mind the importance of Sinai on the one hand and the (promised) land on the other (e.g., Achenbach, Römer, Frevel).
Against this background, the paper analyzes techniques and strategies to evoke or increase coherence within the Book of Numbers in a Pentateuchal or Hexateuchal perspective. By focusing on Num 16–17(18) in particular, it will be argued that the rather late redactional processes visible in the Book of Numbers have a clear interest in evoking coherence on several levels and in many ways (e.g., in regard to concepts, topics, plot, theology). These processes specifically include moments of innovation, which are by no means contradictory to a coherent reading or understanding of the book but are rather grounded in the texts themselves and thus often constitute a form of innerbiblical exegesis.
|
Centralization in Deuteronomy against the Background of the Historical Context of the Persian Period
Program Unit: Centralization and Cult in Persian Period Israel: Biblical, Historical and Comparative Perspectives (EABS)
Katharina Pyschny, University of Lausanne
There can be no doubt that (cult) centralization is a widespread concept within Deuteronomy – and especially Proto-Deuteronomy –, which received plenty scholarly attention in previous and recent times. But the scholarly debate on centralization in Deuteronomy is still somehow limited: First, former research almost exclusively focused on cultic issues (e.g., bloody sacrifices). Second, centralization was rather analyzed within a Neo-Assyrian context and was regarded as a concept with a specific anti-Assyrian focus.
The paper offers a new approach to Deuteronomy's concept of centralization by breaking free from both limitations: It will be shown that the Deuteronomic texts attest to centralization as a complex process involving aspects of politics, administration, economics, leadership, cult, rituals, theology, ideology etc. In this context, the following four points will be highlighted: (1) Cultic or sacrificial aspects of centralization are by no means as dominant as previously and currently assumed in the scholarly debate. The same holds true for the argumentation pattern “Israel vs. the nations”. (2) Cult centralization and Yhwh's exclusivity are not explicitly linked to each other (or rather seldom), but they are combined in compositional and structural respect within Deuteronomy. (3) In Deuteronomy, it is possible to detect different aspects and dimensions of cult centralization as well as specific focal points (not every aspect of centralization has to be mentioned in every text). As a whole, the concept seems quite coherent, even though not necessarily in literary-historical respect. (4) Cult centralization is not “unquestioned” within Deuteronomy: There are texts or traditions with decentralizing tendencies, but centralization remains the dominant ideology.
Against this background, Deuteronomy's concept of centralization will be linked to the specific religious-historical situation of the Persian Period, which is considered here not necessarily as the time of its origin, but as a time of significant revision etc.
|
Bodies That Speak: Body Adornment in Ancient Jewish Narrative
Program Unit: Bodies of Communication (EABS)
Laura Quick, Princeton University
The use of cosmetics and body adornment in order to decorate and beautify oneself is an almost universal part of the human experience. This was also true of the ancient Palestinian culture that gave rise to the Hebrew Bible and early Jewish literature. Cosmetic use in the Hebrew Bible is routinely condemned, and yet the heroines of the books of Esther, Ruth, Judith, and the story of Susanna from the Additions to Daniel all adorn their bodies with cosmetic oils and receive no censure for their actions. By utilizing a sociological approach to the function of cosmetics and body adornment alongside archaeological and textual evidence from ancient Palestine, in this paper I will consider the use of cosmetics akin to a speech act, able to convey the social status and sexual intentions of the wearer to those around them. Key to this is an understanding of the body as a site of social, cultural, and sexual communication. The body is the visual center in which complex ideologies of identity, gender, sexuality, ethnicity and social status are articulated, and the way in which we adorn and dress our bodies is a non-verbal way of communicating these ideologies. This perspective provides a new access to understanding the characterizations of these women, showing that their intention in utilizing cosmetic oils fundamentally differs in the narratives. This has implications for understanding some of the narrative elements within the tales, as well as their reception at the hands of later interpreters.
|
The Semantics of Melas in the Greek Bible
Program Unit: The Language of Colour in the Bible: From Word to Image (EABS)
Anna Rambiert-Kwasniewska, Pontifical Faculty of Theology
It is well known fact for every careful biblical scholar, that every Greek and Hebrew term, and especially the biblical one, is ambiguous. A perfect example of this ambiguity is Greek color term melas, which is translated primarily as “black”. Even a superficial confrontation of this translation with the biblical text shows that “black” is simply not enough and the color palette hidden under this term is much wider. In the Greek texts of the Bible (including LXX) melas designates equine coat color (Zec 6,2; 6,6; Rev 6,5). It also indicates the hue of human hair on the head (Sol 5,11; Mat 5,36) and on the body suffering from tinea (Lev 13,37). Melas is also the adjective describing human skin (Sol 1,5) color of the sackcloth (Rev 6,12) and finally color of ink (2 Cor 3,3; 2 John 1,12; 3 John 1,13). As we see, melas can not be understood as “black” but rather as a “dark color”. Examination of the semantics of biblical color terms requires a consultation with the other ancient Greek (literal, papyrological) and archeological sources. Just a glance combined with a comparative study is enough to conclude that many modern translations of the Bible should be revised. In my presentation I would like to present a short examination of melas – starting from dictionaries, through the examples from the Greek literature, LXX, to the New Testament - and a precise description of its semantics.
|
Negotiating the Masculine Ideal: Gender Stereotypes in Ancient Religious Discourse
Program Unit: Construction of Identity in the Ancient World: Intersections and Reflections (EABS)
Marika Rauhala, University of Helsinki
Religion was an integral part of identity formation in the ancient world. Religious rites, cultic communities and ritual inclusion shaped individuals’ identification with their family, community, society, and culture at large. Furthermore, religion was part of the articulation of one’s age, social standing and gender. Even though women had an indispensable role as religious agents both in domestic and public cults, religious discourse was dominated by male voices. Consequently, religion became one of the arenas where masculine identities and norms were created and contested. Both in Greece and in Rome manliness was not a fixed category but rather a social construction which required constant assertion and substantiation. A man’s appearance and actions determined his standing on the sliding scale between masculinity and femininity, and I will argue that religious conduct was among the defining criteria. In my paper, I will discuss various literary depictions of unacceptable religious conduct and their association with gender expectations building mainly on material from philosophical and rhetorical writings of the classical and Hellenistic period. Thus, I aim at investigating the intersection between religious and masculine gender identities in Greco-Roman thinking.
|
Cosmic Clouds and Divine Encounters in Paraphrase of Shem (NHC VII,1) and Related Traditions
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Pamela Reaves, Colorado College
This paper explores the particular prominence of cloud (ⲕⲗⲟⲟⲗⲉ) imagery in the cosmology of Paraphrase of Shem (NHC VII,1), with attention to how the employment of clouds intersects with other elements of the text, specifically: [i] Paraph. Shem’s related incorporation of Jewish scriptural traditions, including the narrative of Noah; [ii] its understanding of the relationship between clouds and water (as well as other cosmic elements, such as fire); [iii] its reflections on clouds as a mediating space between the supreme God and humans seeking awareness; and [iv] how clouds operate in Paraph. Shem's apocalyptic scheme. A consideration of related depictions of clouds in other Nag Hammadi traditions, including the Apocryphon of John (NHC II,1; III,1; IV,1; BG8502,2) and the Revelation of Adam (NHC V,5), will further illuminate Paraph. Shem’s visions of clouds.
|
Sexuality, Stoning, and Supersessionism in Post War Biblical Epics
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Culture
Adele Reinhartz, Université d'Ottawa - University of Ottawa
The Golden Age of the epic film included many films based on biblical stories that feature strong female characters. Several of these films depart significantly from their biblical sources by inserting a narrative thread involving the stoning or threat of stoning of their female protagonists. This essay examines this non-biblical insertion in three films: David and Bathsheba(Henry King, 1950), Solomon and Sheba (King Vidor, 1959), and The Story of Ruth (Henry Koster, 1960). I argue that the motif of stoning can be traced to the New Testament story of the woman caught in adultery (John 7:53-8:11), or, more specifically, to the role this story plays in the subtle denigration of Judaism in popular postwar American Christianity in which these films participate.
|
Standardization and Centralization in the Festal Calendar of Leviticus 23
Program Unit: Centralization and Cult in Persian Period Israel: Biblical, Historical and Comparative Perspectives (EABS)
Julia Rhyder, Université de Lausanne
This paper examines the centralizing logic of the festal calendar of Lev 23. Although this chapter of the Holiness legislation has received little attention in the scholarly discussion of cult centralization, certain studies have suggested that H’s distinctive interest in the festal activities that take place בכל מושׁבתיכם “in all your settlements” (Lev 23:3, 14, 17, 21, 31) might reveal H’s expectation that the Israelites will offer festal sacrifices at multiple sanctuaries in the land (e.g., K. Weyde). This paper argues, to the contrary, that H’s interest in the settlements reveals its concern to ensure collective conformity with a centralized means of time reckoning. The expression בכל מושׁבתיכם, the paper shows, is never used by H to refer to local sacrificial activities, but only when commanding that certain domestic rites (e.g., food prohibitions or work bans) be observed by the Israelites in their local context. By assigning to the settlements domestic activities that can be performed without requiring a shrine, H negotiates new ritual means by which the entire community, irrespective of geographical location, can participate in a shared calendrical scheme. Meanwhile, H’s setting of immovable dates for the festivals (מועדי יהוה “the fixed times of Yhwh”) ensures that the Israelites celebrate the rites at the same time each year, and thus standardize their festal celebration in accordance with a fixed calendar. The paper concludes that Lev 23 throws valuable light on the importance of shared temporal schemes for ensuring the compliance with central authority that the centralized cult required. It illustrates also the broader significance of ritual standardization for negotiating cult centralization in ancient Israel and for discouraging the variation that is inherent to de-centralized cultic practice. The implication of these findings for the study of centralization and the Priestly traditions of the Pentateuch will also be briefly discussed.
|
What Does Mary Know That Joseph Doesn’t? Uncovering Mary’s Mysteries in the Book of the Nativity of the Savior
Program Unit: Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha
Bradley Rice, McGill University
The Book of the Nativity of the Savior (= Nat. Sav.) is a poorly known infancy gospel that first came to light when M. R. James published his Latin Infancy Gospels in 1927. It has not been preserved in its entirety and is still in the process of being reconstructed from the medieval infancy gospel compilations into which it has been incorporated, compilations which combine it with the Protevangelium of James and Gospel of Pseudo-Matthew. The Book of the Nativity of the Savior has, however, many intriguing features which clearly set it apart from these more familiar narratives, most notably a description of the nativity in which Jesus is born as a concentration of light from above, as a child luminous and weightless, with lightning in his eyes and a smile on his face. While this peculiar description of Jesus’ birth has understandably attracted the most attention from scholars, also important in Nat. Sav. is its distinctive portrait of Joseph and Mary. We find that Joseph is a rather talkative fellow in this text, frequently speaking with his son Symeon and having long, lively conversations with the shepherds as well as the Magi. Mary, on the other hand, remains silent. Yet she does speak quietly “within herself,” as Joseph and others observe, and it is here, I suggest, that Mary’s silence becomes a pregnant one: It is only she who is privy to the “mystery” of the arrival of the luminous savior from above and the silence of all creation at Jesus’ birth. As I will show in my paper, in the Book of the Nativity of the Savior we discover a Mary who is esteemed less for her chastity and purity, and more for her special knowledge of celestial mysteries and eager anticipation of the heavenly savior.
|
Aspects of Anthropology in the Different Versions of the Apocryphon of John
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Christina Risch, Universität Koblenz - Landau
My paper analyses the different versions of the Apocryphon of John with special regard to its anthropology. My thesis is that the anthropology of the Apocryphon of John is inconsistent in several ways. The shorter version (NHC III,1 and BG 2) describes the creation of Adam in several phases beginning with his psychic body. In this part of the narration, the longer version includes a detailed list of demons responsible for each part of the body (NHC II p. 15-19). At first sight, this passage appears more “materialistic” than the surrounding text and not connected to the creation of the psychic body. This point is a significant difference of the anthropology of the shorter and the longer version. Moreover, the insertion seems to be inconsistent in itself. First demons build every single part of the physical body (NHC II p.15-18), later four leading demons create the emotions (NHC II p. 18-19) – at least this part fits in with the topic soul. By exploring the religious and philosophical background of these ideas, I will try to get a clearer picture of the anthropological concepts of the different versions of the Apocryphon of John including discrepancies as well as uniting elements.
|
Pain in the Apocryphon of John
Program Unit: Bodies of Communication (EABS)
Christina Risch, Universität Koblenz - Landau
The Apocryphon of John is a noncanonical gospel preserved in a shorter (NHC II,1; BG 2) and a longer version (NHC II,1 and NHC IV,1) and composed probably in the second century. It is an important example of an early Christian reception of the biblical creation stories in a gnostic context. Therefore, anthropology is a central topic of the text. The paper has a special focus on the phenomenon of "pain": The so called "longer version" of the Apocryphon of John adds a detailed list of demons to the account of the creation of Adam’s psychic body (NHC II p. 15-19). At last four leading demons create the emotions – one of these emotions is "pain". A very remarkable point of this passage is the fact that pain seems to be an emotional rather than a physical sensation. Thus, this passage of the longer version of the Apocryphon of John describes the phenomenon of pain in its entirety. This idea of soul, which is one with the physical body is based upon hellenistic conceptions of soul. Here the text probably uses Greek philosophical concepts of the soul. The paper will explore the importance of “pain” in this context and its relation to other parts of the writing.
|
Comparison and the "Semiotics of Epiphany": Isaiah 6 and the Homeric Hymn to Demeter
Program Unit: Comparative Methodology (EABS)
John Ritzema, King's College - London
The classicist Verity Platt's 2011 monograph Facing the Gods on epiphany in Greco-Roman art, literature, and religion includes a discussion of 'the semiotics of epiphany'. She argues that in Greek epiphany deities are manifested in their particular forms (εἴδεα), and thereby distinguished from one another, by a complex system of signs (σήματα) drawn from a received body of Greek poetry and art. This paper will suggest that reading epiphanic texts in semiotic terms is a helpful comparative method. A semiotically informed reading of two texts allows comparison on a typological/phenomenological level (to paraphrase Meir Malul's terminology), without requiring immediate engagement with issues of their relationship, influence, genealogy, etc. Concentration on the semiotics of texts reinforces the imperative that we compare sources, rather than reconstructed realities. Finally, the explicit use of semiotics allows for a clearer articulation of intertextual theory: our sources are fragmentary not only in the usual archaeological and literary senses, but also in terms of being composed of the semiotic fragments of social texts (Kristeva) or sociolects (Riffaterre) which would have eluded the total grasp of their authors, let alone us moderns. The paper will offer a brief case study of semiotically informed comparison, reading one of Platt's examples (the Homeric Hymn to Demeter) alongside a Hebrew Bible epiphany text (Isaiah 6).
|
Status Inconsistency of Judean Communities in the Persian and Hellenistic Periods
Program Unit: Intersections: A Forum for Research on Ancient Israel, Hebrew Bible, and Cognate Topics (EABS)
Johannes Unsok Ro, International Christian University
In most recent discussions related to Persian and Hellenistic Judah, the concept of status inconsistency has been ignored and the socioeconomic strata have been regarded as consistent throughout the hierarchy of Judean society. Therefore, it is frequently presupposed that from the beginning, throughout the multiple class systems within Persian Judah, the members of the golah community enjoyed consistent hegemony over the descendants of those who had not been exiled. However, the socioeconomic position of the golah could have been much more ambivalent, at least at the initial stage. It is no coincidence that we find a desire and a passion for a radically new, ideal society in the Deuteronomic Code (DC) and the Holiness Code (HC). DC and HC have such a revolutionary character because they were shaped and formed by returnees experiencing status inconsistency. Furthermore, the status inconsistency of the lower-ranking priests could offer a helpful clue for understanding the Piety of the Poor reflected in some postexilic Psalms.
|
Jews and Samaritans in the Textual History of 2 Kings 17
Program Unit: Septuagint of Historical Books (EABS)
Jonathan M. Robker, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
That Jews and Samaritans, even the precursors to these groups, did not always maintain congenial relationships is well known. Their attitudes toward one another were variegated and changed over time (cf. Knoppers 2013). A factor that has not been adequately addressed, however, is to what degree changes in these attitudes appear in the textual history of the Bible. This paper will address some text-historical issues in 2 Kings 17 that indicate later scribal editing reflecting changes in the relationship between Jews and Samaritans. Of particular focus are the Septuagint, the Antiochene text (Lucianic Recension) with recourse to the Vetus Latina, and their relationship to the (proto-)Masoretic version.
|
The Source of Herod's Eagle on the Facade of the Temple: Eastern-Hellenistic or Roman?
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Samuele Rocca, Ariel University Center of Samaria
The well-known eagle, which decorated the façade of the Temple in the days of Herod, had no Roman source of inspiration whatsoever, but it was of easterner origin. Once we shall examine in detail the account given by Josephus, comparing the two versions of the episode, War and Antiquities, it is clear that the two passages, although similar present important differences.
Moreover, the eagle on the façade of Temple ought to be associated to the eagle depicted on one of the coins minted by Herod, a half prutah, minted by Herod in Jerusalem, which depicts on the reverse an eagle with cropped wings. Indeed, the depiction of the eagle, in fact the only animal, which appears on Herod’s coin, is possibly our main source to understand how the eagle set on the façade of Temple looked like. The eagle depicted on the Herodian coin is identical to that depicted on the reverse of the Tyrian shekel, an issue, which was used in the Temple. This iconography, which appears in the East in the early Hellenistic period, traced its source of inspiration to the earlier depiction of the eagle with cropped wings on Ptolemaic coins. Although unlikely, possibly King Herod looked to earlier Jewish art as his source of inspiration. In fact, the depiction of animals, such as eagles, although not common, appears in the Achaemenid and the early Hellenistic period. On the other hand, a close analysis of contemporary issues, makes clear that there is no evidence whatsoever that King Herod, though the depiction of an eagle, wished to emphasize his allegiance to Rome. Therefore, the main source of inspiration for the eagle set on the façade of the Temple stemmed in contemporary iconography, still widespread in the Hellenistic East.
|
Narrative Exemplars in the Catholic Epistles: A Terminological Suggestion
Program Unit: Catholic Epistles
Kelsie G Rodenbiker, Durham University
While Hays’ language of citation, allusion, and echo has become common when referring to intertextual references, terminology used to describe the New Testament use of narrative exemplars (e.g., typological, figural, paraenetic, etc.) has been systematized in no such way, and narrative exemplars are often not treated within these categories. Furthermore, studies on narrative and characterization tend to focus on the gospels and Hebrews rather than other New Testament letters.
When it comes to narrative exemplars, Paul prefers τύπος language (Rom 5:14, 1 Cor 10:6, Phil 3:17, Tit 2:7, etc.), the majority of his references to characters from Old Testament narrative texts come from the Pentateuch, primarily Genesis (e.g., Adam, Abraham, Sarah, Isaac, Jacob, Moses), and his use of narrative exemplars is typically illustrative or part of a scriptural citation. Despite the diversity of authorship and provenance represented by the Catholic Epistles (CE), this collection makes substantial use of a surprising number of narrative exemplars – at least 18 by my count (e.g., Rahab, Job, Elijah, the sinful angels, Balaam), in contrast to around 14 textual citations, and the range of vocabulary surrounding narrative exemplars is more diverse (ὑπόδειγμα, δεῖγμα, αντίτυπον, and ὑπογραμμόν), as is the range of representative exemplars, which are found throughout the Old Testament and branch into parabiblical literature.
This paper discusses the unique usage of narrative exemplars throughout the CE and suggests two characteristics of the collection’s use of narrative exemplars, namely ‘recollective’ and ‘constructive’ elements: for example, James’ audience is expected to have “heard of the endurance of Job” (Jas 5:11) and Jude’s reference to Michael the archangel appears to be a composite of Zechariah 3 and the Assumption of Moses (Jd 8–9) and includes interpretive commentary by the author.
|
The Sanctuary Motif in the Day of YHWH's passages of Isaiah: A Canonical Reading
Program Unit: Prophets and Prophecy (EABS)
Alvaro F. Rodriguez, Universidad Peruana Unión
The common understanding of the day of the Lord in the OT prophets suggests that that day is a time of judgment and destruction (cf. Isa 2:4, 7-16; 3:14; 26:8-9; Joel 2:11; Amos 5; et al). However, there are some cases where the opposite picture is drawn, where the righteous, God’s people, and/or the remnant is saved or restored (cf. Isa 2:2; 25:9; Mic 4:1; Zeph 3:13; et al). In that picture, there are some passages in the book of Isaiah where the day of YHWH is connected to some mentions of the temple/sanctuary and some cultic motifs.
Isaiah 2:1-22 refers to the establishment of the house of YHWH. In Isaiah 3:1:4-6, Mount Zion is established and the filth is washed away. Isaiah 10:5-12:6 declares that there is no harm in the holy mountain and the idols have been destroyed as well. At the same time, Isaiah 19:1-25 depicts a universal worship that used to take place in the temple/sanctuary. Moving ahead in Isaiah, atonement for sin is also depicted (Isa 27:9), and worship will take place in the holy mountain or Mount Zion, which will be established as the center of God’s kingdom (cf. 24:23; 25:10; 27:13). Isa 30:19-26 depicts the righteous dwelling in Zion with no more idolatry among them. Finally, YHWH defends Mount Zion and idols are thrown away (Isa 31:1-9).
The paper takes the final form of the book of Isaiah, doing a canonical reading of the material in order to describe what the role of the temple/sanctuary motif and the cultic motifs are in the understanding of the day of YHWH events.
|
Coins Not Calories: An Economic Analysis of Behaviors and Possessions in Luke's Parables
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Sam Rogers, University of Manchester
Abstract: Bruce Longenecker’s economic scales have enabled scholars to describe the socio-economic realities of the first-century. Longenecker’s scales are based on caloric intake—a first-century person fits on the scales according to their access to a necessary number of calories. His model, however, sees limitations once applied to NT passages. We do not find much evidence of daily caloric intake in the NT texts, and levels of surplus are impossible to assess in this way. To derive exegetical benefit from an economic analysis, we must move towards what Peter Oakes describes as a ‘behaviorally based’ poverty scale. Doing so will yield the following benefits: (1) we will improve our conception of economic scaling for the first-century; (2) we will correct Lukan scholars’ reliance on word studies of ‘rich’ and ‘poor’ for economic analysis and (3) move toward the more complicated picture of economic in Luke’s which better reflect first-century life.
To illustrate this method’s viability, we will analyze the behaviors and possessions in the parables of the Good Samaritan and the Clever Steward. Luke provides detailed markers describing the economic status of the main characters. When analyzing these markers, scholars make two misguided conclusions: (1) the Samaritan pays the innkeeper for the injured man’s future accommodation, (2) the debtors to the steward’s masters are tenant farmers who must pay their loans off through their yield of crops. Both conclusions assume that the average person in the first-century was impoverished which drives prices for food, accommodation, and labor down to remain affordable. With these assumptions, Oakman and Jeremias miscalculate the value of commodities and the buying power of the denarius. Using the economic method detailed above, we illustrate (1) the Samaritan is a middling class character, and (2) the debtors in the parable of the clever steward are wealthy merchants.
|
(Mis)Calculating Economic Markers of Luke’s Parables: The Examples of the Good Samaritan and the Clever Steward
Program Unit: Open Forum for New Testament and Early Christian Studies (EABS)
Samuel Rogers, University of Manchester
The parables of the Good Samaritan and Clever Steward illustrate first-century economic transactions and can describe economic situations in the first-century. However, scholars have miscalculated the value of commodities and the denarius to reach two misguided conclusions: (1) the Samaritan pays for the injured man’s future costs, (2) the debtors are tenant farmers who pay their loans through their crops. I seek to demonstrate the need for renewed calculations of commodities and cost through the following conclusions: (1) the buying power of the denarius is lower than previous scholars assume which suggests the Samaritan pays for one night’s stay; (2) debt was routinely paid with crops; (3) the amount of debt suggests the debtors are wealthy merchants rather than tenant farmers. The Samaritan pays for two people for at least one night in an inn and guarantees money for future expenses. Relying on late Mishnaic material, Jeremias states the Samaritan’s two denarii covered about two weeks’ accommodation and food. Douglas Oakman arrives at similar numbers though he argues from grain prices found in papyri. First, their calculations only consider food at wholesale cost. Prices of grain do not convey prices of sold goods. Second, neither scholar account for the cost of accommodation. We find that two denarii covers the cost of food and accommodation for one night. Rather than a generous overpayment, the Samaritan pays only what he has in his pockets. Douglas Oakman and others argue that the debtors are tenant farmers who pay their loans off through their crops. Yet crops were often used as payment for official debts. More likely, the debtors have some means because (1) the steward, who is status-conscious, seeks hospitality in their homes (οἶκοι); (2) the debtors put up significant collateral; (3) the loaned items were likely “cashed in” for money.
|
Inverse Strategies of Creating Coherence in the Story of Aaron Being Anointed to Be Priest (Lev 8)
Program Unit: Developing Exegetical Methods (EABS)
Meike J. Röhrig, Ruhr-Universität Bochum
An important insight of modern historical-critical exegesis is the idea that many texts in the Old Testament can be understood as results of Innerbiblical Exegesis or “text-oriented text-production”: The authors or producers of texts were also attentive readers of already existing texts. Redactional activities and Fortschreibungen can thus in many cases be described as the product of foregoing text-reception. Lev 8 provides a good example of such processes: the story of how the Aaronides were anointed to be priests is a redactional application of the prescriptive text of Ex 29 that is transformed into a compliance report in Lev 8. But Lev 8 does not just reproduce the ceremonies prescribed in Ex 29: the authors rather changed small details like for example the distribution of tasks in the sacrificial ceremonies, attributing larger parts of the procedure to the Aaronides, who seem to be more active in Lev 8 than in Ex 29. It can be shown that these changes are meant to increase the congruency of Lev 8 with regular cultic activities as they are described in the sacrificial Tora Lev 1-7. An ongoing interest in evoking coherence with the help of changing small details can further be observed in the translation into Greek: The Septuagint version of Lev 8 seems to be concerned with creating a stronger congruency of Lev 8 with Ex 29 and therefore re-changes the distribution of tasks in the sacrificial process systematically in order to make Moses the main actor again. As a case study, the close reading of Lev 8 can help to develop exegetical methods by 1) giving an example of the sometimes close interwoveness of text-critical and redaction-critical observations and by 2) illustrating how changing historical circumstances will lead to different strategies of evoking coherence in the redactional process respectively translation.
|
Deuteronomy and Deuteronomism: Eckart Otto's commentary on Deuteronomy (Vol. 1)
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Law
Thomas Römer, Collège de France - University of Lausanne
This paper will evaluate Eckart Otto's contribution to the study of Deuteronomy and the so-called Deuteronomistic History by focussing on volume 1 of his commentary to the book of Deuteronnomy.
|
Scribal Revisions and Oral Traditions in Genesis 39
Program Unit: Methodological Pluralism in the Study of Genesis
Thomas Römer, Collège de France - University of Lausanne
This paper will exmaine the possible oral origin of Genesis 39 in comparing the narrative to the Egyptian tale of the two brothers. It will then argue that this chapter was added to the Joseph narrative in order to change the theological perspective of the narrative. A second revision introduced the divine name Yhwh into the Joseph narrative which was not used in the original narrative.
|
Judgement of God and Jesus according to John
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Jan Roskovec, Univerzita Karlova v Praze
The final judgement by God is an important theme of Jewish and Christian apocalyptic. Among the canonical Gospels, it is the fourth of them where it receives a special attention, as indicated already by the relatively high frequency of the terms krino/krisis. At the same time, certain ambiguity, or even contradiction emerges, when the utterances of the Johannine Jesus regarding judgement are taken together. The tension may be expressed in the juxtaposition of the sayings John 3:17 (“God sent his Son into the world not to judge the world, but so that through him the world might be saved”) and John 5:22 (“the Father judges no one; he has entrusted all judgement to the Son”). The paper will explore this tension as part of the narrative strategy of the fourth evangelist and will attempt to show, how it is resolved in his original reinterpretation of Christology, as the deep basis for his eschatology.
|
Hermeneutics of Manumission and Hermeneutics of Editing: Jer 34,8-22MT and Deut 15,1-18 between Textual Criticism and Redaction History
Program Unit: The Core of Deuteronomy and Its World (EABS)
Benedetta Rossi, Pontifical Urbaniana University
The use of Deut 15,1.12 in Jer 34,14 has been extensively investigated from different perspectives and with different outcomes. A shared viewpoint among the various interpretive efforts seems to be that Jer refers back to Deut as an authoritative source. This reference would have two primary aims: 1) to elucidate the account of Zedekiah's manumission of slaves
and 2) to provide reasons for the judgement against Jerusalem. Those adopting this understanding have seen the reference to Deut to highlight Jeremiah's role as preacher of the Torah.
Jer 34,8-22MT has been the starting point for further investigation; when discrepancies between the MT and LXX have been taken into account, they usually have been discussed as single textual variants. As a result, the impact of divergences between Jer 34,8-22MT and 41,8-22LXX on the redactional history of the unit, and consequently, on interpreting references in it to Deut, have been marginal to the debate.
Against this background, I will reconsider the relationship between Jer 34,8-22MT and Deut 15,1-18, tackling the issue from the differences between Jer 34,8-22MT and 41,8-22LXX. Jer 34,8-22MT shows a remarkable number of divergences from Jer 41,8-22LXX that point toward a deliberate redaction of the MT. Recognition of this situation allows a more nuanced understanding of how Jer 34,8-22MT and 41,8-22LXX each refer back to their authoritative "sources" and the development that has taken place over time in how Jer refers back to Deut. While, for instance, Jer 34,8-22MT hints at debt remission and manumission, Jer 41,8-22LXX does not seem to show any reference to the former. Moreover, Jer 34,8-22MT seems to edit a former edition of this passage by referring to Lev 25,36f. This process, however, does not appear to reinforce the authority of Deut laws (Deut 15,1-18),. Rather, it highlights a discrepancy between two Torah statements.
|
A Visual-Narrative Reading of Space in Revelation
Program Unit: Vision and Envisionment in the Bible and its World (EABS)
Joel Rothman, University of Divinity
A reading of the Book of Revelation is a vicarious revelatory experience, visually creating a space or cosmos for the hearer. What the seeing-hearer sees may be discerned through a visual-narrative reading strategy, involving consideration of narrative logic and cinematic perspective. Narrative logic can show why and how a character moves through the set, and therefore the positioning of subsequent elements within the set as the character moves toward or acts upon them. The cinematic perspective is the “camera angle” from the viewing position of the seeing-hearer, and can be essential for perceiving the relative positioning of characters and locations. Cinematic perspective is indicated in part by narrative logic, though it is more clearly discerned by paying attention to “see” verbs and the visual nature of the narration. In the Book of Revelation, a visual-narrative reading strategy leads to a picture of a four-layered cosmos; hyper-heaven, sky-heaven, the flat earth, and the under-earth regions. At each moment the viewer is in a specific location within this four-layered cosmos, which influences how they view beings and events. And in turn, everything that is seen (or heard) is seen in (or heard from) a specific layer or location within this cosmos.
|
A Visual-Narrative Reading of Apocalyptic Cosmology
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
Joel Rothman, University of Divinity
Structural and functional cosmology hold great importance in apocalyptic literature, though some apocalypses are more explicit than others. Where it is less explicit cosmology may nevertheless be discerned through a visual-narrative reading strategy, involving consideration of narrative logic and cinematic perspective. Narrative logic can show why and how a character moves through the set, and therefore the positioning of subsequent elements within the set as the character moves toward or acts upon them. The cinematic perspective is the “camera angle” that is the viewing position of the seeing-hearer, and can be essential for perceiving the relative positioning of characters and locations. Cinematic perspective is indicated in part by narrative logic, though it is more clearly discerned by paying attention to “see” verbs, or the visual nature of the narration.
An apocalypse creates a cosmos for the reader, and reading this way we discern what the seeing-hearer sees in their vicarious revelatory experience. Applied to the New Testament book of Revelation, a visual-narrative reading strategy leads to a picture of a four-layered cosmos; hyper-heaven, sky-heaven, the flat earth, and the under-earth regions. These cosmic regions do not correspond to contemporary concepts such as natural and supernatural, or heaven and sky. The different cosmic regions operate and relate in different ways, creating a new cosmic context that is brutally realistic yet hopeful, unmovable yet dynamic. It becomes a new context in which to understand the realities of life and the possibility of change.
|
Μέλας in the Epistle of Barnabas
Program Unit: The Language of Colour in the Bible: From Word to Image (EABS)
Clare K. Rothschild, Lewis University
Μέλας occurs in Homer with a wide range of meanings including dark red, dark blue, and dark grey. It is the color of hair in youth, skin burned by the sun, and animal hide. It may suggest the sinister, mournful, frightening, dispirited, or inauspicious. In Greek texts, it may also have a cultic role (indicating chthonic deities or harmful demons) or magical power (suggesting an unfavorable omen or apotropaic effect). In contrast, ancient Israelite and NT/ECL texts very rarely feature black in discussions of the cult. In ECL, it occurs, as in Plato, with reference to the color of sepia (product of cuttle-fish) or soot-produced ink (2 Cor 3:3, 2 John 12, 3 John 13), but is otherwise scarce. Even in early Christian apocalyptic contexts, it occurs only rarely, for example, with reference to the color of one of the four horses (Rev 6:5, 12; cf. Zech 6:2, 6). In the Shepherd of Hermas, μέλας occurs with reference to a beast, a hill, unserviceable stones, and garments of morning, but only in the Epistle of Barnabas (4:9; 20:1) does it occur substantively (i.e., ὁ μέλας), describing the eschatological opponent of the "children of God" (i.e., addressees). This essay explores the meaning and function of the color black in Barnabas, arguing that an Egyptian context may best explain this usage.
|
Sheol Engulfing (the Trees of) Eden: Ezekiel 31:16-18
Program Unit: Stylistics and the Hebrew Bible
Anna Rozonoer, Hellenic College
The ultimate conceptual antithesis “down in the Hebrew Bible” is found in Ezek 31. :Now you shall be brought down with the trees of Eden to the world below” (Ezek 31:18) – is Ezekiel’s exhortation to Pharaoh, last in a series of oracles. A metaphor for the fall of the great empires, confederates to the Assyrians, this political dynamic is at the heart of the oracle and an object of reflections by leading Ezekilian scholars. The “Descent into Sheol” motif is not unique to this passage in Ezekiel or to Ezekiel altogether. Unique in the late biblical tradition is the collation of Eden and Sheol, the trees standing for Eden as synecdoche. The magnetic attraction of the two antithetical concepts is intriguing, whereas the juxtaposition of these two quasi-geographical locations raises a series of issues ranging from their topography to toponomy. A lead is given by the frequent arboreal epithet “well watered” and the verbal proximity of “the deep,” bringing us to an etymological survey of the toponym Eden. An etymology suggested by the Arabic root ʿdn in its noun form had the meaning of “source, borehole” and spotlights a significant aspect of the Ezekilian Eden. In addition to this Semitic root, a Sumer word idim designates “freshwater source.” The development of this research brings us to the notion of Eden’s toponymic and topographic origin from a freshwater subterranean resource from which, according to Genesis, the four rivers originated and which brings the trees of Eden to their singular, allegedly oxymoronic descent to Sheol in Ezekiel. The paper will explore the antinomy and the connection of Sheol with its notional antipode, Eden, using the etymological methodology. The results of the research will contribute to highlighting the paradoxical nature of Sheol.
|
Jewish Haggadah as a Context for Understanding of Syriac Prayers: Examples of Unity and God’s Mercy
Program Unit: Bible and Syriac Studies in Context
Miroslaw Rucki, Opole University (Uniwersytet Opolski), Theological Faculty
All Biblical references to the Last Supper unequivocally indicate on Jewish Passover celebration as a context of the most important liturgical event of Christianity, which is the Eucharist. Despite the fact that the Passover Seder (order of prayers and rituals) was canonized much later, in Gaonim era (7th-9th centuries A.D.), some of its passages are of ancient origin. Moreover, since it was finally compiled by the Gaonim in Sura and Pumbedita, in Syriac-speaking region, the mutual Christian-Jewish influence was inevitable.
The paper is dedicated to the comparative study between the Haggadah contemporary text and Syriac liturgical book, especially focused on words and phrases connected with God’s mercy in different contexts, as well as the unity of people and between God and humans. Statistically, most often (10 times) God was called 'Harachaman,' i.e. ‘Merciful’ in Haggadah, but when His Mercy was recalled, the word 'chesed' was preferred (41 times). Interestingly, none of Aramaic passages of the Haggadah mentioned God’s mercy.
Since it is obvious that the Last Supper was not celebrated exactly according today’s Haggadah text, it should be spoken of a common source for both Hebrew Jewish and Syriac Christian contemporary prayer, which is easily traceable. Some similarities can be ascribed just to the related languages, but the others can be proved to belong to the same prayer tradition. The study lays open some new elements of a solid foundation for dialogue and cooperation between the Christianity and Judaism.
|
Hebrew Bible and History according to Slavomil C. Daněk (1885-1946)
Program Unit: History of Biblical Scholarship in the Late Modern Period
Jan Rückl, Protestant Theological Faculty, Charles University of Prague
Slavomil Ctibor Daněk (1885-1946) was the first professor of the Old Testament at the Faculty of Protestant Theology founded in Prague in 1919. The paper focuses on Daněk’s understanding of the relation between history and the Hebrew Bible, which may be seen as a driving force of his theses that in several respects are close to those embraced by the so-called Myth and Ritual and Scandinavian schools. In the first part, the paper will treat Daněk’s conception of history as the context in which the Biblical traditions came into existence and were handed down. Daněk sharply separated profane and religious history, and this brought him to stern rejection of the Wellhausenian documentary hypothesis which he, not unlike some Nordic scholars, replaced with the notion of slowly evolving tradition. The second part of the paper will deal with history as a theme in the Biblical texts. The peculiarity of Daněk’s approach consists in his belief that a “religious” (that is mythical or cultic) base may be discovered behind every motif in the text. At some point of its development, the tradition chose to veil the “religious” motifs through historicizing. On the other hand, it is because of the “religious” message connected to these motifs that the text has been handed down at all, and, what is more, the tradition, while suppressing the concrete religious meanings of the individual motifs, nevertheless strived to somehow conserve them, and now and then even to allude to their presence, shaping the text into a kind of anagram. Here again, the discovery and valorization of the text’s mythical and cultic aspects, comparable to views of some Nordic scholars, results from Daněk’s specific difficulty with history, and it leads him to unusually radical conclusions.
|
God Backstage: Story World and Vision Accounts in Mark’s Gospel
Program Unit: Vision and Envisionment in the Bible and its World (EABS)
Jan Rüggemeier, Universität Bern - Université de Berne
“Mark’s narrative is thoroughly theocentric and permeated with God language”, as Eugene Boring has already noted some twenty years ago (Boring 1999: 451). However, in terms of a narrative theory of character the Markan “God” has to be conceived as a backstage character. Nowhere in the whole Gospel does he enter the stage. Only in few scenes, mainly vision accounts, God (implicitly) participates as a character, or at least as a voice (1:9–11; 9:2–13) or hidden actor (15:38; 16:1–8). Nevertheless, beyond the immediate surroundings of actual events and the various locations shown by the narrator, God’s backstage world captures the attention of the ‘intended recipient’ (on this term, see Finnern/Rüggemeier 2016: 129–131).
Today’s postclassical narratology has compensated the theoretical neglect of space. On the basis of Marie Laure Ryan’s narrative theory of space (Ryan 1991; 2003; 2014) my paper will examine Mark’s ‘story world’, as “completed by the reader’s imagination on the basis of cultural knowledge and real world experience” (Ryan 2014: 9). This cognitive re-reading will enrich our understanding of the meaning and function of Markan vision accounts. How does the spatial extension of the text help the reader to understand the story’s diverse conflicts? How do these accounts contribute to the revealing of Jesus’ identity? In what respect do these accounts differ from Mark’s general spatial concept?
|
"From the End of the Earth": Space and Time in Psalm 61
Program Unit: Place, Space, and Identity in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Karoline Rumpler, University of Vienna
Psalm language uses spatial terminology to describe different dimensions of suffering and trust in God. Some approaches focus on the suffering of the praying person; others concentrate on the metaphorical use of spatial terms to describe a special image of God, i.e. “God as a tent” or “God as a rock”. Several studies dealing with these expressions of trust refer to different metaphor-theories. This paper shows how spatial and temporal dimensions are closely interwoven and explains this on a few examples in Psalm 61. On basis of my dissertation-project, which combines cultural, literary and linguistic theories of space and elaborates how space is constructed in and by the text, the presentation focuses on spatial terminology associated with temporal categories like be’åhālkā ‘ôlāmîm – “in your tent forever” (Ps 61,5). Furthermore, it examines the possibility of superimposing temporal and spatial representations to express a profoundly existential experience.
|
From Dagan to Kronos: Hesiod's Theogony and Syrian Geo-politics
Program Unit: Israel in the Ancient Near East (EABS)
Ian Rutherford, University of Reading
Since the 1990s it has become apparent that the "Kingship in Heaven" myth, known from Hurrian-Hittite texts found at Hattusa and from early Greek poetry, can be traced back to North Syria in the early 2nd millennium BC or earlier. It seems to have focused on the storm-god Hadad of Aleppo and his relations to Dagan, an important deity at Mari and elsewhere, who corresponds to Hittite-Hurrian Kumarbi and Greek Kronos. In this paper I want to ask whether the striking contrast between these two deities - the powerful young storm god and the passive older deity whose role is as much mother as father - reflects the political relations between Aleppo and the rest of Syria at this time.
|
Cross-Cultural Applications of the Concept of Shamanism: A Critical Assessment
Program Unit: Anthropology and the Bible (EABS)
Håkan Rydving, University of Bergen
Against the background of a brief history of the concept of shamanism, the first part of the paper exemplifies some of the definitions and cross-cultural applications of the concept. A special focus is put on its origin and on two radical changes in the process of conceptualisation during the 20th century: one after the publication of Mircea Eliade’s Le chamanisme in 1951, the other when Eliade’s understanding during the 1980s was abandoned by most researchers, the only exceptions being some archaeologists and the so-called shamanthropologists. The second part presents a critical assessment of the current use of the concept, distinguishes between different narrower and wider understandings and discusses four different ways of regarding shamanism: (1) as a worldwide phenomenon defined in different ways; (2) as a regional (Evenki, Siberian, Northern Eurasian, or Circumpolar) phenomenon defined in different ways; (3) as an analytical concept defined in different ways; or (4) as neither a phenomenon nor a useful analytical concept.
|
A Re-examination of the Common Hypothesis about the Messianic Figures in Medieval Islamic and Byzantine Apocalyptic Literature
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
Hadi Taqavi, Hadi Sabouhi, Ehsan Roohi, University of California-Irvine
The apocalyptic literature of the 7th and 8th centuries AD, both in Christian and Muslim contexts, is characterized by a strong tendency to expect a divinely-guided monarch, one who would restore faith in God and bring justice and prosperity to the world.
In the 7th century, the notion of the Last Roman Emperor was introduced in the Revelation of Pseudo-Methodius, an apocalyptic work composed by a pseudonymous author, presumed to be a monk living in the region of Sinjār in northern Mesopotamia. This apocalyptic text has had a profound impact on medieval literature—particularly in the Byzantine Empire—and since gained widespread popularity. This is apparent from the wide distribution of the text, its translation into other languages such as Greek, Latin, and Slavonic, as well as its influence on later prophetic literature.
Additionally, during that same period, the doctrine of the Mahdīsm was formed and expanded in Islamic ḥadīth collections. Islamic traditions of crises (fitan) often contain similar apocalyptic materials concerning a descendant of the Prophet Muḥammad who will rise at the end of time and bring justice and equity to the world. The second half of the 9th century seems to have been the climax of such eschatological sentiments. As believed by Shī’ī Muslims, the Twelfth Imām, or the Expected Savior of the world was born in this period, i.e. 869 AD. It has been suggested that the Last Roman Emperor topos was developed within Byzantine apocalyptic traditions in order to polemicize the notion of Mahdī.
The present study is to discuss, perhaps as the first, that the Shī’ī portrayal of Mahdī cannot be explained away as mere polemic against Byzantine apocalyptic texts, but further, that there exist remarkable thematic parallels between Muslim and Christian apocalypses that have remained unaccounted for by previous studies.
|
Identifying Davidic Beloved King And The Bride of His: Textual Criticism of Psalm 45
Program Unit: Textual Criticism: Manuscripts & Methods
Hadi Sabouhi, University of California-Irvine
The characteristics of Psalm 45 make it unique; as it commemorates a specific Royal Wedding. It remarks a divinely blessed King; whose might, justice and grace are such enormous that make Him superior to mankind, and the Princess who must abandon her country and dwelling house for the King’s sake. Despite this importance, the figures of these two, due to the complexity of the text, shrouded in ambiguity.
Of the most significant uncertainties are: grammatical difficulties, syntactical problems and lexical obscurities. These obscurities are partially based on the fact that a number of phrases are unique in OT and have no parallels in Biblical literature; but to a greater degree, these problems are deeply rooted in the historical transmission of the Bible.
Textual criticism is an effective method to resolve some of the mentioned problems. A text critic attempts to reverse the hands of time to rethink and improve the concepts without damaging the original. The critical text of the Ps 45 is the earliest inferable reading, on the basis of the available evidence and the editors' acumen and arguments.
Jan Mulder’s work on Psalm 45 can facilitate researchers’ studies in this field, as he initiated the first steps towards constructing a critical edition, through finding “The Literary Background” or “Parallels” of Psalm 45 in the ancient Egyptian, Akkadian cultures and Biblical literature. His efforts exclude “Variation-scope” of the old major versions and comparison of parallel passages to reach the less erroneous Vorlage.
The purpose of this paper, which represents research conducted chiefly by Hadi Taqavi with the assistance of Hadi Sabouhi, is to reflect on some of the principles and procedures of textual criticism of the Hebrew Bible, using an important partially-obscure passage of Psalms, to illustrate the wider methodological considerations with which it is directly concerned.
|
What is the Genealogy of Job and Where is the Land of Oz? Possible Answers According to Early Christian-Arabic and Judeo-Arabic Bible Translations and Commentaries on the Book of Job
Program Unit: The Bible in Arabic in Judaism, Christianity, Islam (EABS)
Arik Sadan, Shalem College
According to the first verse in the book of Job, אִישׁ הָיָה בְאֶרֶץ עוּץ אִיּוֹב שְׁמוֹ וְהָיָה הָאִישׁ הַהוּא תָּם וְיָשָׁר וִירֵא אֱלֹהִים וְסָר מֵרָע “there was once a man in the land of Uz whose name was Job. That man was blameless and upright, one who feared God and turned away from evil” (translation taken from NRSVB). This verse, which serves as an introduction to the book of Job, raises several questions as to the genealogy of Job and the geographic location of the land of Oz, especially as hardly anything is explicitly said on both. The proposed paper shows several answers according to some early Christian-Arabic and Judeo-Arabic bible translations and commentaries on the book of Job, highlighting similarities and differences among them. The sources to be used are not only texts of scientific critical editions of such translations and commentaries, but also manuscripts of unedited works of these genres. Attempt will be made to compare Christian-Arabic and Judeo-Arabic bible translations and commentaries produced in the same period, around the 10th century AD.
|
Mustafa Sabri Efendi’s Views on the Resurrection of Jesus
Program Unit: Quran and Islamic Tradition in Comparative Perspective
Jusuf Salih, University of Dayton
Mustafa Sabri (1869-1954), was one of the last supreme religious leaders (Shaikh al-Islām) of the Ottoman Empire. He was an Ottoman thinker who with his intellectual and academic works on one hand and social activism on the other hand had an important place in the late period of the Empire’s history.
Among many issues he wrote about was also the debate on Jesus and his resurrection. This is an important topic that brings together but also divides Muslim and Christian religious scholars. In the Qur’ān, Jesus is mentioned frequently and his mother, Maryam, is the only female name mentioned in the Qur’ān. The debate of the Muslim scholars about Jesus includes his death, his rising up, and his resurrection. Some Muslim scholars argue that his rising up (rafa‘ah), was just spiritual, and some argues that it was both spiritual and physical. The majority of Qur’ānic exegetes maintain the idea that the rise of Jesus was both spiritual and physical. A well-known Qur’ānic exegete, al-Ṭabarī claimed that there is a consensus among Qur’ānic commentators supporting this position.
Mustafa Sabri, maintaining the mainstream opinion, interpreted the Qur’ānic verses by saying that the rise of Jesus was spiritual and physical. He argued that people were trying to kill Jesus and that since death is physical and spiritual, the rising of Jesus should also contain both. This paper will elaborate various Qur’ānic verses on the topic and explain Sabri’s interpretation of these verses.
The paper will also review few Arabic words and their usage in Arabic language which Sabri skillfully uses in supporting his ideas.
|
The Assyro-Babylonian Medical Texts and the Theory of the Conceptual Metaphor
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible (EABS)
Silvia Salin, Università degli Studi di Verona
Pain is a very subjective and complicated experience; feeling it personally is quite different from observing it in another. Indeed, the distance between us and the other is enormous, and it is impossible to share our suffering with someone else. Thus, the only way to communicate our own suffering and make it understandable to those around us is through the use of metaphor. The anthropologist G. Pizza defines it as a “social action”, as it uses everyday language – inadequate to express the suffering body – to place the sick person in his/her social context. Moreover, according to the theory of linguists G. Lakoff and M. Johnson metaphors are part of everyone’s daily life, in language, thoughts and actions. In their opinion, “most of our ordinary conceptual system is metaphorical in nature”, and conceptual metaphors might refer to different ideas.
This conceptual system has been developed by every culture, past and present, including that of Mesopotamia. Among the most interesting conceptual metaphors of the Assyro-Babylonian language are those relating to illnesses and the pain experienced by the patient, that belong to the technical language of the medical professionals, asû and āšipu.
This paper aims to offer a general overview of some of the most remarkable metaphors of the Assyro-Babylonian culture used to describe the individual suffering, considering the “mutual tension” among them, and the whole network they belonged to. Particular consideration is given to medical texts – but also to literary texts, letters, omina, incantations and prayers – dating back to the late second and first half of the first millennium BCE, in order to try to better understand the social context in which these metaphors and their network were used.
|
Ezekiel 35: Tradition-Historical and Redaction-Critical Aspects
Program Unit: Prophecy and Foreign Nations (EABS)
Reettakaisa Sofia Salo, University of Münster
The oracle against the mountains of Seir in Ezek 35 announces the desolation of this region through Yahweh but connects this message also with some positive aspects: By learning of their fate, these foreign mountains recognize the power of Israel’s God. The paper discusses the parallels of Ezek 35 with the oracles concerning Israel in Ezek 6 and 36 and demonstrates how later additions connected it with other texts. Of utmost importance is the comparison with Ezek 25, but the Edom topic is also related to the Book of Obadiah. In addition, empirical evidence provided by the Septuagint and MasEzek sheds light on the growth and formation of this intriguing text.
|
The Growth of Ezekiel 6 in Light of the Masoretic Text and the Septuagint
Program Unit: Editorial Techniques in the Hebrew Bible in Light of Empirical Evidence (EABS)
Reettakaisa Sofia Salo, University of Münster
The Book of Ezekiel is of utmost importance for methodological discussions dealing with the growth of biblical texts: The Masoretic text is often longer than the Septuagint, which in many cases indicates that intensive editing took place at very late stages in the formation of the Hebrew Bible. The paper discusses Ezek 6 as a case study. In a methodological perspective, the divergences between the MT and LXX versions contained in this chapter are particularly illuminating since they show that short glosses were the most typical way of editing and that many of the late additions could also be found by means of the classic criteria of literary criticism. In addition, it can be seen that small additions sometimes caused a substantial revision of the theological meaning.
|
In the Deep: A Psychological Analysis of Surviving the Waters of Chaos (Gen. 6-8, Mark 4)
Program Unit: Psychological Hermeneutics of Biblical Themes and Texts
Belinda É. Samari, University College London
The ancient Near East is saturated with symbolic representations of the Deep, in the traditions of Egypt, Mesopotamia, Israel and even Greece. Whatever its name – Tiamat, Tehom, Chaos, Abyss – it always symbolizes the ever-looming terror of non-existence, the threat of extinction and certain death. Chaos appears not only in literature but also in rich and multi-faceted iconography and imagery, most commonly as the waters of the deep of the underworld. We also encounter this symbol in the psychoanalytic tradition (both as water and e.g. the dragon/serpent) in which it plays a crucial role in the process of what Jung calls ‘individuation’, the process by which one becomes an integrated whole.
Taking an interdisciplinary approach drawing primarily (but not exclusively) on Jungian psychoanalysis and ancient Near Eastern imagery, I will examine the parallels between two stories that symbolize the importance of the waters of Chaos in the process of individuation: the Flood (Gen. 6-8) and the storm on the Sea of Galilee (Mark 4:35-41). More specifically, I will consider Noah and Jesus/the disciples, and concepts such as the unconscious, fear, fragmentation, displacement, archetypes of water, Chaos, etc. In short, I will analyze the indispensable role Chaos plays in our process of ‘becoming’, and what we are able to do as humans when we face the waters of Chaos in our lives.
|
Body, Soul or Neither? Reconsidering Terminology and the Biblical Conceptualization of the Human
Program Unit: Pentateuch (Torah)
Belinda É. Samari, University College London
The central tenet of my paper will be to examine the biblical conceptualization of the human (largely articulated in the Torah) and the challenges presented when attempting to refer to, or discuss the biblical human using terminology that is in fact alien to that conceptualization. For example, the terms and concepts of ‘body’ and ‘soul’ as are commonly used, generally implicitly assume Plato’s or Aristotle’s ‘human’, not that of the biblical worldview (incidentally also not that of the Ancient Near East at large).
While there are terms that we encounter in ancient Greek (soma, psyche, daimon), Hebrew (nefesh) and Akkadian (pagru, zumru), these terms are insufficient in fully articulating the conceptualization of the human within these respective systems of thought. Just as psyche cannot describe the concept of the Platonic human but is rather just an aspect of the concept of ‘human’ within that system, so nefesh or lev are unable to describe the biblical human. The question is: what can? If the dualist terms ‘body’ and ‘soul’ are foreign to the biblical worldview - and are hence unable to accurately refer to or describe the biblical human - what does accurately describe the biblical human?
Can we legitimately transplant terminology from one worldview to another when discussing the human being? If the ancient Babylonian concept of the human differs from the ancient Israelite ‘human’ that, in turn, differs from the ancient Greek ‘human’, then it follows that our language should reflect these conceptual nuances. And as it does, possibly open up new doors of exploration and research through the link between language and thought.
The key question is whether it might be necessary to rethink our terminology when discussing the conceptualizations of the human being in different ancient worldviews, in an attempt to align terminology with its underlying concepts.
|
Ancient but Not Oral: Towards a Literary History of Genesis without Undocumented Assumptions
Program Unit: Methodological Pluralism in the Study of Genesis
Seth Sanders, University of California-Davis
Since the work of Gunkel and Rendtorff there has been a strong tendency in biblical studies to assume that orality and antiquity are necessarily related: to be old, biblical poetry must be oral, and if it is oral, it is old. Driven by a refuted European elite ideology which stereotypes whole societies by means of their media ("oral cultures") as primitive but artistic, this has led to a situation in which poorly-supported evolutionary assumptions about genre take the place of data about the history of ancient Hebrew literature. In this line of thinking, (authentic) linguistic archaism, poetic genre, and the oral-traditional mode (in which the event of composition is identical with the event of performance) are assumed to naturally go together with small oral sub-units. While the “small oral sub-units” assumption has been effectively critiqued by scholars from Nicholson to Baden, there is also a larger issue, because the concept of the oral and its relationship to the archaic has been recently illuminated in new ways. Taking a cue from recent work of Richard Bauman and Charles Briggs in linguistic anthropology as well as the forthcoming work of Jacqueline Vayntrub on biblical Hebrew poetics, this paper rethinks the relationship between the oral and the archaic in the literary history of Genesis without the typical, and equally unjustified, opposing assumption that there are no relevant aspects of oral literature in the Hebrew Bible. Using several difficult poems in Genesis as case studies it argues for the productivity of integrating the more reliable and relevant aspects of historical linguistics, especially verbal syntax, with a historical approach founded in both comparative Semitics and literary reading.
|
Virtue Ethics, Natural Law, and Wisdom: Reconsidering Proverbs 8:22-31
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israel and in ANE Wisdom Literature (EABS)
Timothy J. Sandoval, Brite Divinity School (TCU)
Aristotle and Aquinas are key figures both for traditions of virtue ethics and for natural law thinking. Yet virtue ethics and natural law are often thought to stand in significant tension with each other. The “nature vs. convention” debate highlights this conflict: virtue ethic’s emphasis on a virtuous agent’s practical wisdom applied to particular situations is opposed to natural law’s universalizing moral demands. Although the moral discourses of Aristotle and Thomas are obviously complex enough to be accommodated to both poles of this debate, Aristotle is usually regarded as falling on the virtue ethics or particularistic side while Thomas is regarded as a stronger proponent of natural law.
Proverbs 8:22-31 is regularly understood to suggest that the divine created the cosmos by Wisdom. Therefore, the cosmos is so ordered that wise humans can derive particular moral claims—the moral vision of Proverbs itself—through their observations or perceptions of the world. The text is thought to demonstrate that for Proverbs a natural moral order is embedded, and discoverable, in creation. Proverbs may thus fall into a natural law tradition most associated with Aquinas and any evidence of a virtue oriented moral outlook in the book perhaps should be subordinated to the text’s fundamental natural law perspective.
By contrast I will argue that Wisdom in Prov. 8 is an already existing element abiding ‘where’ (or in the midst of the space upon which) God creates the physical universe. Thus for Prov. 8 all that is created participates in Wisdom or is created with its own wisdom—a wisdom that is, in the Aristotelian idiom, appropriate to its kind. With the evidence for a virtue ethics perspective elsewhere in the book, 8:22-31 thus indicates Proverbs is more a text of virtue ethics than of natural law, closer to Aristotle than Thomas.
|
A New Methodology in Reconstructing the Roles of Satan and Demons in Luke’s Gospel
Program Unit: Developing Exegetical Methods (EABS)
Chakrita M. Saulina, University of Cambridge
This paper introduces a new comprehensive approach to evaluate Luke’s portrayal of evil spirits, which (i) includes the two modes of a character’s existence as important principles in examining characters, (ii) is designated for evaluating non-human characters, (iii) intends not only to reconstruct the overall portrayal of the character (characterization) but also to find the function of the character in the overall narrative.
The methodology of this study consists of two main steps: microanalysis and macroanalysis. These two steps correspond to Alex Woloch’s character-space and characters system. The microanalysis is the assessment of each passage or pericope where Luke portrays Satan and demons or where it is relevant to Luke’s notion of evil spirits. The microanalysis is the evaluation of Luke’s overall presentation of evil spirits (their appearance and disappearance) and their relations with other characters and other elements in the whole Gospel. Drawing on Cornelis Bennema’s approach, the microanalysis will be divided further into two subsections: (i) characters in text and context; (ii) character analysis. Meanwhile, the macroanalysis will focus on character significance and evaluation.
In the character analysis, this paper will evaluate the self-revelations and symbolic meanings of Satan and demons as non-human characters. Therefore, adapting Baruch Hochman’s continuum of literalness and symbolism will be a helpful tool in incorporating and assessing the unique features of these divine beings into our character reconstruction. Then in the macroanalysis, one of the main aspects of evaluation is the characters’ significance to the plot and narrative threads. In this stage, the authorial intention plays a key role in evaluating the significance of the characters. The term ‘narrative thread’ is used in addition to the plot as the one that ‘unifies’ all components and bring significance to the message of the Gospel, as it is suggested by Luke’s incipit.
|
Isaac and Rebecca: Scenes from a Marriage
Program Unit: Families and Children in the Ancient World
George Savran, Schechter Institute for Jewish Studies, Jerusalem
Biblical narrative is not very expansive about the dynamics of husband-wife relations beyond the obvious patriarchal concerns of marriage and childbirth. There is a tendency to focus on conflict within the marriage rather than on positive interaction between man and wife. Rarely do we see one party helping the other to deal with a difficult situation (the book of Ruth is a noteworthy exception). There are relatively few examples of displays of affection or flirtation between men and women in biblical narrative. However, the narratives about Isaac and Rebecca reflect more of these positive aspects than any other depiction of marriage. There is an important thematic connection between them as providers of water: In Gen. 24 Rebecca fetches water for Abraham’s servant and his camels, while in Gen. 26 Jacob is engaged in digging wells and locating water. More important is the love and mutuality between the two. Their first meeting in Gen. 24:61-67 is described in surprisingly romantic terms for the Bible. Gen. 26:8 describes what seems to be sexual intimacy between the husband and wife, a rarity in biblical narrative. And when Rebecca’s barrenness becomes clear Isaac actually prays on her behalf – the only husband in the Bible to do so for his wife. While Rebecca's deception of Isaac in Gen. 27 would seem to undercut this affinity for one another, even here we can see traces of mutuality. The absence of confrontation in the closing part of the episode testifies to the balance between the two and to their unusual compatibility. The larger issue to be addressed concerns the implications of this relationship for their sons Jacob and Esau, and for the portrayal of family life in Genesis in general.
|
The Jacob Cycle and Fluidity of Boundaries: Identity Confusion and its Resolution
Program Unit: Construction of Identity in the Ancient World: Intersections and Reflections (EABS)
George Savran, Schechter Institute for Jewish Studies, Jerusalem
The biblical account of Jacob in Gen. 25-35 is noteworthy in its attempt to define both personal and national boundaries as a developing process. As is well known the book of Genesis uses the story of Jacob’s personal development to mirror the emergence of Israel, as reflected most famously in his name change from Jacob to Israel. This is encapsulated in a single moment in Gen. 32, but the process itself is described with great subtlety in the chapters which precede the name change, and carried further in the chapters which follow it. What I wish to describe here is the initial fluidity of the boundaries of Jacob’s personal identity in chapters 25-30 which allow for this development, followed by the emergent sense of that identity in Jacob’s struggle with Laban in 30-31, and concluded by the emphasis on national and religious boundaries for Jacob/Israel in chapters 31-25. The very fluidity of identity which marks the first part of Jacob’s narrative is succeeded by a concomitant hardening of those boundaries as Jacob “becomes” Israel. This fluidity is refocused in the overlapping boundaries of the personal and the national in this part of the narrative. Identity formation is portrayed as a complex process of developing personal identity in the face of Jacob’s brother Esau, his wives Rachel and Leah and his father-in-law Laban.
|
Communicating with the Divine: Yahweh and His People in Light of Ancient Egyptian Divination
Program Unit: Ancient Near East
Elisabeth Sawerthal, King's College - London
This paper will explore how a study of ancient Egyptian divination can illuminate our understanding of the relationship between the God of the Hebrew Bible and his people. Divination, the practice of divine-human communication, can be found in cultures across the world, past and present. The phenomenon appears in a great variety of forms, including the consultation of oracles, prophecies, astrology or the interpretation of divine signs from sacrificial animal entrails. The study of such practices provides valuable insights into the relationships between people and their gods.
Traditionally, divination in the Hebrew Bible, if studied within the context of the ancient world, is examined in relation to Near Eastern and Mesopotamian sources and, to a lesser extent, Greece. These comparative studies have provided new insights on divination and the role of the diviner and have been applied to facilitate and inform our biblical exegesis.
Egypt has, for the most part, been excluded from this field of research. However, just like its ancient Near Eastern and Mediterranean neighbours, Egypt was also a divining society.
This paper will examine divination and the role of the diviner in ancient Egypt through a variety of sources from the ancient culture's written and archaeological record. It will, in particular, focus on and highlight the social role of the diviner in this society and the empowering effect of divination in light of sociological works on divination. In light of this discussion and based on passages from the biblical texts, this paper will seek to draw attention to how the connection between divination and power reflects on the complex relationship between people and the gods they worship.
|
From the Word-Vision of the Prophet to the Prophetic Book
Program Unit: Relationship between the "Major Prophets" and the "Scroll of the Minor Prophets": text, methodology, hermeneutics and Wirkungsgeschichte (EABS)
Donatella Scaiola, Pontifical Urbanian University
The biblical prophet speaks in the name of God and often also has visions. In some books, however, there is a shift from the word-vision of the prophet to a book, written or to be written: Jer. 36; 45:1-4; 51:59-64; Ezek. 2:8-3,4; Na. 1:1; Hab. 2:2; Zech. 5:1-4. How should we interpret this phenomenon? What consequences can be drawn from it, in order to better understand the prophetic event? After an exegetical analysis of selected texts, I will try to answer these questions from a theological point of view.
|
Divine Metaphors in the Book of the Twelve
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible (EABS)
Donatella Scaiola, Pontifical Urbanian University
This paper seeks to contribute to the Research Unit “Metaphor in the Bible” by focusing on the Book of the Twelve. The theme of the divine metaphors in the Book of the Twelve is interesting because, to our knowledge at least, there are studies dedicated to individual scrolls, but not to the whole book. From a methodological point of view, it is first of all necessary to clarify some premises, for example, to clarify the concept of metaphor here adopted, and to distinguish between metaphor and simile. After this necessary methodological clarification, it is noteworthy that in Hosea many divine metaphors and similes are found, while other books do not contain them at all, for example Obadiah, Jonah, Nahum, Zefaniah, Haggai and Malachi. Second, some divine metaphors will be dealt with, in order to verify the following hypothesis: the abundance of divine metaphors present in Hosea confirms the privileged role that this scroll occupies in the Book of the Twelve, and also the relationships that it establishes with the major prophets (for example, Isaiah 5:29: God as a lion; Isaiah 18:4, 26:19: God as Dew).
|
The Construction and Demarcation of Sacred Space in Hasmonean and Herodian Galilee
Program Unit: Place, Space, and Identity in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Joseph Scales, University of Birmingham
The question of sacred space has been addressed more fully in recent decades in the study of religion in dialogue with spatial theorists such as Henri Lefebvre and Edward Soja. The insights about how we structure and maintain the experienced and imagined space around us aids our understanding of religious experience. This paper applies some of the considerations of spatial theory to ancient, Jewish artefacts and settlement dynamics in Galilee during the Hasmonean and Herodian periods (c. 100 BCE – CE 50). During this period Galilee came under the dominion of the Hasmonean kingdom and the inhabitants developed a material culture similar to Judea. Many of the particular artefacts used by these ancient people speak specifically to uniquely Jewish religious concerns. Artefacts which will be presented include: stone (chalk) vessels; stepped plastered pools (miqva’ot); secondary ossuary burial within loculi tombs; oil lamps; Hasmonean coins; locally produced ceramic ware. Most of these artefacts had religious functions, but all were used by non-elites, and often outside of strictly religious contexts. The perception of the space of Galilee, and more broadly the “promised land,” was reflected upon by both the producers and users of these artefacts. The connection between many of these artefacts and everyday life reflects the perception of lived, experienced space for ancient Jewish Galileans.
|
Fishing for Jonah’s Sitz im Leben: What Has Changed from Trible to Today, and Why?
Program Unit: Prophets
Jo-Marí Schäder, University of Pretoria
In 1963 Phyllis L. Trible completed her doctoral thesis titled Studies in the Book of Jonah in which she proposed possible Sitze im Leben for the book of Jonah. She would also re-iterate them in her contribution on the book of Jonah in The New Interpreter’s Bible Volume VII (1996). She proposed that the book of Jonah (1) could have had a function within the cult, (2) is wisdom literature, and / or (3) that its hokmic character indicated its setting in the sodh of post-exilic Israel. To a greater or lesser degree her proposals as to the book of Jonah’s use in an original setting is still visible in recent Jonah scholarship. However, each of Trible’s proposals is also subject to critique which has been dealt with in a variety of ways – or not at all – by Jonah scholars. In this paper a short overview will be provided of Trible’s arguments in support of her proposals. This will then be followed by a critical discussion on them, and a comparison with what recent scholars have (not) written on the topic. The aim is then to answer the following question: What are the more recent perceptions or proposals as to the book of Jonah’s Sitz im Leben, how have they changed from those proposed by Trible, and why?
|
Reflecting on the Concept of Gratitude in the Bible from a Positive Psychological Perspective
Program Unit: Psychological Hermeneutics of Biblical Themes and Texts
Eben Scheffler, UNISA
Although gratitude is widely viewed as a positive value on a popular level, scientific investigation into it is scarce. In its endeavor for a non-medical preventative approach to human health and well-being, positive psychology considers gratitude as a positive value promoting human health. In this contribution some biblical texts (e.g. the psalms, Jesus in the gospels, Pauline letters) are scrutinized from the perspective of positive psychology. The aim is to probe whether gratitude should be positively pursued and how it can be increased (without creating a false consciousness) in individuals and society for the sake of the latter’s happiness, well-being and health.
|
Traces of Negative Theology in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: What a God is Not – The Early History of Negative Theology (EABS)
Annette Schellenberg, University of Vienna
Negative theology is usually explained as having originated with Plato. Occasionally, however, theologians and others also trace it back to the Hebrew Bible and some of its traditions (thus, for example, Andreas Benk in his recent book “Gott ist nicht gut und Gott ist nicht gerecht”). This paper seeks (a) to provide an overview on all texts/traditions from the Hebrew Bible that have been or might be considered expressions of (something like) negative theology, and (b) for each of them to ask whether or to what extent they indeed could/should be understood as expressions of negative theology. More concretely, the paper will address the prohibition of images, YHWH’s “explanation” of his name in Exod 3:14, the negation of common notions of theophany in 1 Kings 19, statements about God’s incomparability (Isa 40:18, etc.), the juxtaposition of most diverse metaphors about God, statements about humans’ inability to comprehend God (Eccl 3:11, etc.), and other texts like Isa 55:8 (“my thoughts are not your thoughts, nor are your ways my ways”) and Isa 28:21 (“alien is his work”). The paper will conclude that (beside many others that are positive about positive statements about God) the Hebrew Bible indeed includes some traditions/texts that are in line with the concern of negative theology, but that only a few of them express this concern with negating positive statements about God. Whether or not they still should be labeled “negative theology” is primarily a question of definition.
|
Reading and Seeing Dan 7: The Vision as Image and as Text
Program Unit: Vision and Envisionment in the Bible and its World (EABS)
Uta Schmidt , Paedagogische Hochschule Heidelberg
This presentation explores some of the chances and limits of reading vision reports within a theoretical framework of a theory of images (cf. Hans Belting, Gottfried Boehm). Dan 7 serves as an example and a starting point to show how apocalyptic visions like the one about the beasts and horns in Dan 7 can be understood as „speaking images“ (Ruediger Lux) and also be seen and read within the context of ancient iconography.
Seen as images they combine representational and referential functions: They represent the reality they present. For apocalyptic visions, this is a reality which is revealed only to some but is not obvious in the experienced present time. But even though the images seem fantastic, their effect hinges on the fact that the individual elements refer to a collective reservoir of images which can be traced to ancient iconographic evidence as well. Much of the effect of visionary images like the beasts and horns in Daniel 7 can be analysed because of their image-like quality. But still Dan 7 is a vision report, thus, a text, not a painting or similar. Instead of visual simultaneity it offers the sequentiality of language. Where images have to be static, texts can tell about dynamics. By exploring also the limits of an analysis of vision reports and their contents as images, their characteristics and effects can be scrutinised even further.
|
The Origins of the Quartodecimans: A Possible Solution
Program Unit: Early Christianity (EABS)
Brian Schmisek, Loyola University of Chicago
In the ante-Nicene era the Quartodecimans (the “fourteeners”) preserved a tradition that was said to go back to “John.” They commemorated not Easter, but 14 Nisan. For decades now scholars have addressed the ‘Quartodeciman question,’ defined in various ways but essentially, “What did the Quartodeciman observance of 14 Nisan mean? What did it commemorate?” This brief paper proposes a solution to the question in claiming that the Quartodecimans were descended from the community of the beloved disciple. They preserved a tradition from that community, which commemorated Jesus’ death as the paschal lamb, which was a simultaneous glorification. The paper proceeds in three parts (1) evidence and summary of the Quartodeciman practice and the controversy it created (2) review of Johannine theology of paschal lamb and glorification as it related to the day of crucifixion (3) proposal and testing of the hypothetical solution.
|
Sequencing Cylinder Seal Roll-offs: To Lateral Surfaces and Beyond
Program Unit: Iconography and Biblical Studies (EABS)
Daniel Schmitz, Bergische Universität Wuppertal
The way of looking at cylinder seals content in the last centuries in databases and illustrated books always was defined as looking at a photograph of a c.s.´s roll-off. But therein lies a problem. Every c.s. is depicted as a 360°degree scenery. Therefore the whole lateral surface is depicted. We are facing the problem that the definition of the starting point is highly relevant for the depicted scene. But the question about the precise starting point never is asked. Within the paper I will demonstrate three different kinds of sequencing by which cylinder seals can be categorized. Examples of correct and incorrect roll-offs in various publications will be shown. Starting from my observations I will ask for form-critical aspects concerning sequence dividing elements and their meaning for the use of c.s. In the final step I will present a way to define the sequence of depicted scenes.
|
A Bit of Rome in the Galilee: Tabernae, Phallic Amulets, and and the Nile
Program Unit: Archaeological Fieldwork in the Hellenistic-Roman Mediterranean (EABS)
Dan Schowalter, Carthage College
This talk considers the work of the Omrit Settlement Excavation Project at a Roman temple site in the northern Galilee. For five years we have excavated the domestic/commercial area to the north of the temple and discovered a shifting socio-economic reality in the 1st to 4th centuries CE. Evidence shows that contact with Roman architecture, art and gender identity is juxtaposed with local traditions in some very creative ways.
|
Remember Abraham – or not? Abraham in the Book of Isaiah
Program Unit: Methodological Pluralism in the Study of Genesis
Andreas Schuele, University of Leipzig
The call to remember Abraham is a common motif in texts that are oftentimes assigned to post-exilic literature, inside and outside the Pentateuch. Interestingly, in the Pentateuch, this call extends to both Israel and God. While Israel is expected to remember Abraham as an example of faith (Deut 9:27), God is supposed to remember his promises to Abraham in situations when Israel least deserves to be regarded as Abraham’s descendants (Exod 32:13). Either way, there seems to be agreement among these relatively late texts about Abraham as Israel’s primal ancestor. The same is true when Abraham is referenced in the book of Isaiah (Isa 29:22; 41:8; 51:2). Here, too, he is presented as a figure that marks a fresh start in the relationship between God and Israel. However, there is a notable exception: in Isa 63:16, the call to remember Abraham is rejected because not he but God alone is Israel’s true father. This paper will examine Isaiah’s theological discourse about Abraham vis-à-vis the Pentateuch and thus delineate the changing perceptions of ‘tradition’ that one finds here.
|
A "Grammar of (Davidic) Messianism"? God's Emissary in 1 Enoch
Program Unit: Bible and Empire
Joshua Scott, University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
In his 2017 The Grammar of Messianism, Matthew Novenson performs a cultural-linguistic study on Second Temple texts relating to messiah. He suggests that following the legend of David, "all subsequent messiah language inherits the twin ideological poles of ancestry and merit, rightful succession and divine inspiration. All early Jewish and Christian messiah texts, therefore have to navigate both these poles, and in practice do so in creative ways that suit its own rhetorical ends." However, the messiah of 1 Enoch does not rise to a position of power based on merit or family lineage, but serves as a divine emissary at God's bequest. While messianic texts are linked by a unique sociological grammar, Novenson downplays the central issue - how messiah figures are employed to mediate power. To downplay this power relationship within the imperial context of the Second Temple period overlooks what individual messiahs 'do' in texts. Utilizing studies on imperialism and theologies of resistance from Anathea Portier-Young and Richard Horsley, this paper proposes that these apocalyptic texts borrowed Greco-Roman cultural cues to shape the presentation of messiah figures. By analyzing the sequential and structural elements of the narrative surrounding the theme of divine judgment in the Parables of Enoch (1 En. 37-71), this paper shows that the central issue in the Parables is the deliverance of the marginalized from the oppressive elites. The Chosen One or God's Emissary is a variant of a charismatic leader motif, a character who represents active or imagined resistance against imperial occupation. And yet the messiah is a literary tool of war and domination. Against Novenson and others, this historical study of messianism complicates the role of the messiah as both a tool of imperialism and anti-imperialism.
|
"For He Had Told Them …": Mordechai the Jew and Jonah the Hebrew; Conflict and Identity
Program Unit: Writings (including Psalms)
Ayelet Seidler, Bar-Ilan University
Many scholars have pointed out that the Book of Esther deals with questions of Jewish identity in exile. The Book of Jonah portraits a Hebrew prophet confronting gentiles and in doing so deals with questions of his identity. In an article to be published at VT, I pointed at an analogy between Jonah Chapter 3 and Esther Chapter 4. In this paper I would like to expand this analogy and present connections between Jonah Chapter 1 and Esther Chapter 3. The analogy focuses on questions of identity raised in the narratives. In both narratives a fateful confrontation takes place between the hero of the story (Mordechai, Jonah) and a group of gentiles (the king's servants, the crew of the ship). In both cases, the heroes refer explicitly to their identity. At the end of the confrontation, the hero's fate is sealed to death. Yet, the two protagonists succeed to extricate themselves from imminent death. Some of the information revealed in the confrontations is exposed by way of retrospect, using an expression that occurs only in these two stories " כי הגיד להם" ("for he had told them …" Esther 3:1; Jonah 1:10). Only few scholars tried to find out the reason for the use of retrospective narration in these stories. I intend to show that the use of retrospect information in each of the stories contributes to the emphasis on the conflict between the hero's worldview and that of the gentiles facing him. Ironically it seems that the gentiles express the narrator's position in the identity conflict taking place in the narrative. By pointing out the analogy between the stories a deeper understanding of the question of identity discussed in both stories is being established.
|
Rabbi Joseph Carlebach: His Exegesis and His Approach to Higher Biblical Criticism
Program Unit: The Biblical World and Its Reception (EABS)
Meir Seidler, Ariel University
Rabbi Joseph Tsvi Carlebach (1883-1942) was the last orthodox Rabbi in Nazi Germany, subsequently in Lübeck, Altona and Hamburg. After his deportation "to the east" in December 1941, he was murdered by the Germans in Riga in April 1942 together with his wife and three of his children as well as a great part of his community. His extraordinary personality, his moral stature as well as his charisma were acknowledged by many of his pupils (among them the former head of the Israeli Supreme Court Chaim Cohen, the illustrious Rabbi Issachar Jacobssohn and others). Carlebach was also a prolific writer. However, he had no time to formulate his coherent Jewish outlook in an appropriate magnum opus. Besides communal, philosophical, historical and halakhic matters many of his writings deal with Biblical exegesis. His book on "The Three Great Prophets: Isaiah, Jeremiah and Ezekiel" (meanwhile translated into Hebrew, English and French) was much lauded by Shmuel Hugo Bergmann. He published also many exegetical articles: on the Psalms, the Song of Songs, Ecclesiastes, the Book of Ruth and some other more. These are still only available in the German original. His exegesis is harmonistic. In most of these articles as well as in some other separate writings he also addresses the challenge of Biblical higher criticism. An analysis of his approach as a Bible interpreter as well as the way he addresses the challenge of Biblical higher criticism was not undertaken yet. My paper will present the main traits of his Biblical exegesis and his unique approach towards Biblical higher criticism.
|
Rocking the Cradle: Mothers as Transmitters of Authority in Genesis and Beyond
Program Unit: Methodological Pluralism in the Study of Genesis
Sarah Shectman, San Francisco, CA
In Genesis, mothers perform a variety of roles, from naming their offspring to ensuring favored sons inherit. Frequently the actions of these mothers are interpreted by scholars to contravene social norms and exercise power usually reserved for men. Such interpretations, however, assume that maternal authority is subversive in that it deviates from an expectation of male-centric authority. The proposed paper draws out and interrogates the various assumptions that shape interpretations of maternal agency in Genesis. Do such assumptions emerge from their presentation in the narrative or are they the result of inherited models of domestic power? This paper will outline the various models upon which mother-son relationships are constructed in the ancestral narratives and will compare these models to ideas of mother-son transmission in royal contexts. Parallels from other biblical material, including genealogies outside Genesis, texts like Prov 31:1¬–9, and extrabiblical inscriptions, suggest that in fact mothers were frequent transmitters of authority, in a variety of settings, and that the biblical authors drew on these traditions in composing their narrative.
|
A Living Soul: On the Complex Status of Animals in the Bible
Program Unit: Contextual Interpretation of the Bible (Hebrew Bible/Old Testament and New Testament)
Yael Shemesh, Bar-Ilan University
As a vegan animal activist on the one hand and a Jewish religious Bible scholar on the other, the subject of this lecture is not only an academic matter for me but rather the basis of my being ¬– a source of frustration but also one of comfort and action.
The lecture considers the Bible’s complex attitude towards animals. On the one hand, the Bible reports that God granted humans permission to harm animals for their own needs and as part of religious ritual. After the Flood God explicitly permitted the consumption of meat (Gen. 9:3); following the Exodus the Israelites were commanded to offer animal sacrifices. As a result, many see the Bible as the source of Western culture’s utilitarian treatment of animals. On the other hand, Bible law sets many limits on how animals may be exploited. morever, in most biblical genres we find manifestations of a positive and even compassionate attitude towards animals, by human beings and especially by God. Various biblical texts refer to animals as members of the community. In addition, from the Creation story it seems that God’s original intention was for human beings to subsist on a vegetarian diet; The relations between humans and animals seem to have been ruined as a result of the first transgression (Genesis 3). This is similar to the breakdown in the relationship between man and woman and man’s domination of woman as a result of the same transgression (3:16). In the idyllic future world envisioned by Isaiah, relations of peace and harmony among all creatures will be restored, including between Eve’s descendants and the serpent’s: “A babe shall play over a viper’s hole, and an infant pass his hand over an adder’s den (Isa. 11:8).
|
The Blasphemous Bible of Léo Taxil
Program Unit: Bible and Its Influence: History and Impact
Yvonne Sherwood, University of Kent at Canterbury
In this paper I will look at some of the 401 (!) Bible cartoons in Léo Taxil’s La Bible Amusante (published in 1882 by the Libraire Anticléricale in Paris). Some of the cartoons were copied in George Foote’s penny magazine The Freethinker, for which he was sentenced to a year’s imprisonment with hard labour. I will look at how the images are often situated between the biblical texts (read over-literally) and contemporary events in Paris: for example, the recent exhibition of the telephone; the first performance of Offenbach’s Tales of Hoffmann in 1881; and the scandal of the spirit photograph hoax known as the ‘procès de spirites’.
|
Vertical and Horizontal: The Matrix and Message of the Book of Jonah
Program Unit: Stylistics and the Hebrew Bible
Zvi Shimon, Bar-Ilan University
The role of the root ירד (descend) in the opening verses of the book is common knowledge to all readers of Jonah. However the verb yarad does not stand alone in the book but is rather part of a larger directional matrix underlying the whole narrative. There is an interplay between the vertical axis contrasting rising (קום) and yarad as well as a less recognized horizontal axis contrasting the movements of Jonah throughout the narrative. The presentation will not only trace the different axes in the book but claim that the interplay and tension between the axes reveal the underlying message behind the book.
|
The Connection between the Opening and Closing Chapters of the Pentateuch
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
Zvi Shimon, Bar-Ilan University
We are accustomed to approaching some of the books comprising the Pentateuch as literary constructs with clear openings and endings (Genesis and Deuteronomy). This is less the case (although there are of course, quite a few exceptions) in relation to the Pentateuch at large. Can the Pentateuch be viewed as an "Enateuch"? The presentation will claim that there are strong literary connections between the first and last three chapters in the Pentateuch (Gen. 1-3 and Deut. 32-34). These connections include parallel wording, use of leitwords, and similar motifs. These parallels, however, do not only connect between end and beginning, but also point to progress and a transformation that takes place across the pentateuchal text. The proposal, while not negating diachronic analysis of the Pentateuch, strengthens the claim for conscious literary artistry in the formation of the Pentateuch and the case for viewing the Pentateuch (in contrast to suggestions for a tetra or hexateuch) as an extended literary work.
|
"Cliff Shelters":Caves Cut into Cliff Tops in the Galilee during the Jewish Revolt against the Romans and Their Historical Significance
Program Unit: Archaeological Fieldwork in the Hellenistic-Roman Mediterranean (EABS)
Yinon Shivtiel, Zefat Academic College
In two works, "The Jewish War" and "The Life", Josephus described his intention to fortify 18 named settlements, which have all been identified archaeologically. The methods that he claimed to have used have never been tested in the field. My research has shown that in the vicinity of each settlement a steep mountain exists full of natural caves. Research has been conducted and a method of defense called "Cliff shelters" was discovered.
Our search for defense methods has resulted in the discovery of a central defense method, which characterizes ten of the settlements surveyed. We have found that five settlements mentioned by Josephus among those he had fortified are located in close vicinity to precipitous cliffs, inside which Karstic caves were formed. Reaching most of these caves was only possible by descending inside them with ropes. According to finds in these caves such as walls, arrowhead, shards of pottery, coins, rims of vessels, loops for tying ropes, ritual bathes, and more helped us to reach the conclusion that the majority of these artifacts belong to the Roman periods.
The findings in all these cliffs shelters indicate beyond doubt intense activities in the area during the period which preceded the Great Revolt ( 66 – 70 A.D.). They also teach us that the fortifications Josephus ascribes to himself were not erected thanks to his personal efforts but were a technique known in the Galilee well before his arrival.
Nevertheless, it is plausible that the fortifications described by him in his two works were carried out with his inspiration and encouragement.
In my paper, I will discuss the spread of the "cliff shelter" in the Galilee and the findings inside them
|
Is Descendant-Leaving Success the Function of Religion
Program Unit: The Biblical World and Cultural Evolution (EABS)
Paul Shrell-Fox, Schechter Institute
The descendant-leaving strategy explanation of religion hypothesizes that religious behavior is a human universal because natural selection favored ancestors who transmitted religious traditions encouraging many generations of descendants to be willing to sacrifice for the ancestors’ other descendants. Thus, ancestors who transmitted such religious traditions had greater long-term descendant-leaving success than those ancestors who did not transmit religious traditions. After describing this descendant-leaving strategy explanation, this paper summarizes the previously published evidence of religious traditions encouraging of altruism toward co-descendants that might eventually have had the effect of increasing long-term descendant-leaving success, and the more recent application of religious traditions to encouraging altruism toward fictive co-descendants. Although explicit recognition of long-term descendant-leaving success as a goal of religion is not necessarily a prediction generated by the explanation, explicitly stating that goal might be expected as one of the means of reaching it. Thus, this paper uses the traditional religion of Judaism to help answer the question: To what extent is the descendant-leaving success proposed to be the function of religion an explicitly stated goal of religion?
|
Speaking to One’s Heart/Soul in Wisdom Literature
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israel and in ANE Wisdom Literature (EABS)
Nili Shupak, University of Haifa
Speculative Egyptian wisdom, which developed in the wake of the crisis into which Egypt was plunged during the First Intermediate Period (around the second millennium BCE), contains a literary pattern known as speaking to one’s heart (ib) or soul (ba). While addressing one’s heart is frequent in Egyptian literature (cf. The Prophecies of Neferti and Complaints of Khakheperre-Sonb), only one composition—The Dialogue Between a Man and His Ba—relates to a man’s conversation with his soul.
A complex, complicated work, numerous ways of understanding this text have been proposed. I shall approach its content and message from a different perspective, analyzing it as a unique example and seeking to understand why the author chose the soul as the protagonist’s interlocutor rather than his heart.
After surveying the role played by the heart and ba in Egyptian sources in general and wisdom literature in particular, I shall compare this text with other works of speculative wisdom and draw some conclusions from the findings. The paradigm of a man addressing his heart also occurs in the biblical texts, being a particular favourite of Qohelet’s. I shall thus also relate to these parallels.
|
“Agite Ergo Et Vos”: The Patristic Evidence on the Text of Jos 8:1–29 (The Battle of Ai)
Program Unit: Editorial Techniques in the Hebrew Bible in Light of Empirical Evidence (EABS)
Marcus Sigismund, Protestant University Wuppertal
The biblical narrative of so called ‘second battle of Ai‘ (Jos 8) is a challenge that faces textual criticism and redaction criticism alike. The varying lengths and some smaller differences between the versions and even between text-forms within particular versions lead to the fact, that there was some kind of editorial change in this account. But up to now, despite of many extensive analyses, it is uncertain whether the Hebrew Masoretic or the Greek LXX tradition represent the oldest attainable text of this passage.
Trying to add further empirical evidence on ‘The battle of Ai’, this paper will survey a group of sources, which in this context has been mostly disregarded so far: the patristic evidence. Although dependent on the LXX and the Latin tradition in the first instance, their testimony might indirectly shed light on the comprehensive editorial history.
|
Paul’s Baptismal Teaching: Jewish or Stoic?
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Samuli Siikavirta, Luther Foundation Finland
The apostle’s thinking fits as part of the development that brought the notions of ritual and moral purity closer and placed more weight on the latter. Although the roots of the moral application of purity language can already be seen in the OT, this development begins to unfold more in the Diaspora context, Qumran, John and Jesus. For Paul, the ritual fulfilments of Jewish purity laws were not important in the new Gentile Christian context, although his baptismal teaching does include a ritual aspect, but it is one that is wholly redefined and transformed. Paul talks about baptism as a death by drowning and a reinvigorating newness of life in a way that could have brought to a Jewish mind the descent down the stairs of a miqweh into the full immersion of its cleansing waters and the ascent into a state of ritual purity.
Paul’s Letter to the Romans contains a strongly cognitive element in its ethical teaching that in many ways resembles Stoic sources (e.g. Epictetus and Seneca). Paul makes use of popularised Stoic models that were familiar to the recipients of his letter, although he does so in a distinctly Christ-centred way. A key reason for this seems to be for Paul to want his addressees to find motivation for their morally upright living from reckoning who they were as baptised into Christ, and whose they were as his slaves (Ron. 6:11).
This paper, inspired by my Cambridge PhD published in 2015, addresses the question by summarising Jewish and Stoic sources and comparing them with Paul’s baptismal teaching and its ethical application in Rom. 6–8.
|
Dirty Underpants and the Voice of God: Jer 13 in the Context of the Israelite Domestic Economy
Program Unit: Prophets
Edward Silver, Wellesley College
Discussion of the symbolic action scene of Jer 13 has situated it in the context of ancient Near Eastern oracular practices, or in relation to inner-biblical interpretive strategies. Indeed, the entire suggestion of a “symbolic action report” as a narrative genre suggests a coherent formal context within which the practice of eliciting significance from material objects was grounded. As such, narrative accounts of these actions are frequently treated—implicitly or explicitly—as precursors to the sorts of text-focused interpretive practices that characterize early Judaism. How, by contrast, might we situate mundane, even contemptible oracular signifiers like broken pottery or rotten undergarments within a literary corpus (the Book of Jeremiah) that favors imagery rooted in the agrarian, patriarchal household? How do mantic practices like these diverge from and even critique elite, institutionally favored modes of divination and oracle consultation? Might we locate in these narratives an implicit critique of official power, one that could productively contribute to a larger discussion within post-colonial literature of the kinds of covert theoretical and critical discourse developed by politically subaltern populations? This essay seeks to understand the ‘ēzôr pištîm of Jer 13 as a coherent symbolic focus rooted in a non-elite domestic context, the interpretation of which models for a late-monarchic audience how to develop an autonomous, indigenous, critical discourse on power.
|
Imperium as Context for Defining "Elite": Persians and Yahwistic Socio-economic Structure
Program Unit: Judaeans in the Persian Empire (EABS)
Jason M. Silverman, University of Helsinki
The use of the term "elite" in discussions of Near Eastern empires is often quite vague, and the Persian Empire is no exception. This paper will first try to unpack the usefulness of the term "elite." Then, the paper will discuss how the various different known contexts for Judaeans in the empire impact our understanding of the social and economic structure in each location, and the implications on the greater imperial systems for each one. With these in mind, it will be possible to broach the question of interactions with the broader imperial "koine."
|
Identity and the Theophoric Element: Evaluating the Role of Onomastic Evidence in the Construction of Religious Identity in Syro-Mesopotamia
Program Unit: Construction of Identity in the Ancient World: Intersections and Reflections (EABS)
Brandon Simonson, Boston University
Onomastic evidence is often used to make claims about the religious identity of individuals and families throughout the Levant and Mesopotamia in the first millennium BCE. Conclusions about personal piety and family religion rely heavily upon theophoric elements in personal names, which denote reverence for the named deity. Using data from my ongoing research project ‘An Aramaic Onomasticon of Syro-Mesopotamian Texts and Inscriptions’, this paper re-evaluates the role of the theophoric element in the construction of religious identity, arguing that it is one of a combination of linguistic and conceptual features within the personal name that can inform our perception of personal piety and family religion. Ultimately, the theophoric element is only one part of the greater body of onomastic evidence that plays an essential role in the construction of religious identity during this era. Included in this presentation are geographic representations of cultural contact as evidenced by the presence of specific theophoric elements in Aramaic names.
|
Cultural Hybridity Revisited: Genesis in Islamic Religious Art during the Mongols
Program Unit: Quran and Islamic Tradition in Comparative Perspective
Ka Kwan Almond Sin, Vanderbilt University
This essay examines how ancient Chinese motifs help elevate the royalty and sacredness of biblical figures in Islamic traditions under the Mongols. I focus on visual materials shared by Christian and Islamic traditions. In religious visual culture, David Morgan maintains that belief is shaped through a medium, how human beings engage with objects. In this regard, religious visual culture can be viewed as a powerful device to connect human and the spiritual realm within a particular context. The formation of the Mongol Empire in the thirteenth century marked a pristine phase in the development of Islamic art. Trans-Eurasian exchange of knowledge, commodities, and traditions contribute to an enthralling artistic and religious interaction under the auspices of a single political authority. Drawing elements from various cultures and traditions, Islamic religious art during the Mongol period turned into an extremely sophisticated and colorful synthesis. Ancient Chinese royal features such as clouds, dragon, phoenix, peony, chrysanthemum, and horses, were combined with elements drawn from eastern religions such as Buddhism and Daoism, which makes the adaption of early Chinese themes in Islamic religious paintings one of the most distinctive features in Islamic religious art during the medieval period. By comparing the visual and textual materials in the Genesis account of these two religious traditions, in particular the creation narratives and the predominant biblical figures of Adam and Eve, Abraham, and Noah, this essay discusses how the use of Chinese features in Iranian/Persian art pieces helps enhance the sacredness of the forefathers in the Islamic tradition, and how visual arts display theological differences in the views of creation and the depiction of these characters in the Christian and Islamic religious traditions.
|
Prophecy at Mari: Examining the Interplay Between Prophets, Court Specialists, Temple Personnel, and Members of the Elite
Program Unit: Ancient Near East
Jennifer Elizabeth Singletary, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
Recent scholars have noted that evidence from royal correspondence discovered in archival contexts demonstrates that prophets in Old Babylonian Mari worked in concert with several types of scholarly and religious professionals, as well as members of the elite. Literate intermediaries recorded prophetic messages and conveyed them to the king; court specialists verified the validity of the information through various types of divination. Furthermore, many prophecies appear to have originated in the context of temples, where prophets operated alongside various temple personnel. This paper investigates the available textual evidence and argues that the interactions between these groups benefitted all of the parties involved, regardless of the participants’ relative status, authority, or erudition. A close examination of the letters pertaining to prophecy reveals a complex system of interplay between prophets, temple personnel, educated members of the elite, and other types of diviners (such as haruspices), and provides valuable insight into the interdependent and synergistic nature of the cooperative efforts required to convey prophetic messages to the king.
|
Bible for Smartphones: Theoretical Considerations
Program Unit: Nida Institute for Biblical Scholarship at the American Bible Society
Seppo Sipilä, Finnish Bible Society
There is a growing need for making the Bible accessible for people who use smartphones. As the Bible has been translated into many languages, the answer to this need may look like a straightforward one: just turn the existing versions into a suitable form, and the work relating to the content is done. However, this may not be the ideal solution to the need, because the smartphone is a different publishing platform than a printed book. This paper discusses some theoretical issues relating to an ongoing translation project in Finland that aims in composing a version of the New Testament designed to be used exclusively in smartphones.
|
The Male Gender of Virtue: The Allegorical Interpretation of Pharaoh’s Decree in Exodus 1
Program Unit: Virtue in Biblical Literature (EABS)
Agnethe Siquans, University of Vienna
In Exodus 1:16, 22 the Egyptian Pharaoh decrees that the male Hebrew newborns shall be killed while the female ones may live. Philo and, following him, Origen interpret the gender of the newborns in allegorical terms: The “male” represents the virtues which Pharaoh wants to repress, while the “female” represents the vices which are promoted by him. Origen’s interpretation is much more elaborated in this respect and goes as far as to maintain that the Hebrew midwives killed the female babies. Later Christian authors follow Origen and present virtue as male, e.g. Cyrill of Alexandria and Gregory of Nyssa. They pick up this motif in different manner and pass it down to the later exegetical catenae. Christian virtue is portrayed as male, whereas vices are represented as female. The way to Christian perfection, therefore, is to become male and eliminate anything female from one’s spirit. This paper asks for the hermeneutical presuppositions and especially the consequences of this gendered view of virtue.
|
The Use of Doxa in Disputed Pauline literature
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Mikko Sivonen, University of Helsinki
With this paper, I explore the use of doxa language in Pauline disputed letters. There has been an increasing interest in recent Pauline studies in relation to the doxa motif. Given the number of occurrences of doxa-related words (24) in Paul’s disputed letters, however, it is surprising that this motif has not received sufficient attention in these letters. Building on my dissertation where I explore the doxa motif in Paul’s undisputed letters (University of Helsinki, forthcoming 2018), this paper seeks to make a scholarly contribution to this field by examining Paul’s glory motif from the biblical redemptive narrative method. More specifically, this work considers the use of doxa in the Jewish Scriptures in order to analyze and discover how Pauline disputed literature uses, develops and redefines the doxa motif in light of the Christ-event. Finally, I will examine similarities and difference compared to the undisputed letters.
|
Piping Hot Lyres: Instrumental Instruction in the Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
David A. Skelton, Pepperdine University
The references to musical instruments in the Dead Sea Scrolls remains an understudied topic. In this paper I examine the role of the lyre and pipe in the scrolls. In this corpus the pipe and the lyre occur often together but this combination is rare in the Hebrew Bible. This paper will utilize music archaeology and comparative evidence from the Hellenistic world in order to explain the sudden emergence of this combination in the Second Temple period. I will suggest that the lyre-pipe combination occurs quite frequently in a pedagogical context and is part of a broader construction of the sage as singing teacher. The construction conflates imagery from the Levitical tradition with Greco-Roman pedagogical practices. The former depicts the Levites as sages and lyrical singers and the latter depicts training in the lyre as in essential marker of educated status. Whereas scholars tend to understand descriptions of musical performance in the scrolls as metaphorical, I will contend that one should take more seriously the pedagogical use of musical performance in the scrolls and suggest that musical instruments are a valuable lens through which one can examine both scribal and sectarian identity in the Second Temple period.
|
The Transformation of Emotions: A Look at Love in Ruth
Program Unit: Psychological Hermeneutics of Biblical Themes and Texts
Cecilie Skupinska-Løvset, Jevnaker Municipality Psychiatric Clinic
Love encompasses a variety of different emotional and mental states ranging from the deepest interpersonal affection to the simplest pleasure . It’s many transitions can function as a type of mature defense mechanism. An example of this range of meanings is that the love of a mother differs from the love of a spouse differs from the love of money. Commonly though love refers to a feeling of strong attraction and emotional attachment. In Ruth’s story we see many different types of love. Some in which socially unacceptable idealizations are unconsciously transformed into socially acceptable actions or behavior, resulting in a long-term conversion of the initial impulse. In this paper I wish to address the transformation of love in Ruth. The story shows both familial love, friendly love, romantic love and divine love, all four forms of love identified by Ancient Greek philosophers. But does love explain Ruth’s actions?
|
Pleasure and Pain: Jesus' Body and Topping from the Bottom in Mark's Passion Narrative
Program Unit: Bodies of Communication (EABS)
Peter-Ben Smit, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam
Jesus´ body is in the passion narrative of the Gospel of Mark a site of both pain and pleasure. Pain is inflicted upon this body by Jesus´ `adversaries´, or at least: they attempt to do so, "pleasure" is derived from the fact that all of this suffering in fact serves to further God's aims, which are also Jesus' aims. Using insights from the study of sadomasochism, in which the apparent "bottom" frequently determines the course of the "play", this paper shows how the presentation of Jesus' bodily suffering as an intentional suffering, pleasing (even pleasurable) as it is part of Jesus' dedication to God, serves to undermine the apparent power of his adversaries.
|
Broken and Outpoured: On Symbolism in the "Words of Institution"
Program Unit: Food as Concept / Symbol / Metaphor
Peter-Ben Smit, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam
Substantial discussion exists concering the question whether or not the fact that Jesus' "words of institution" (a misnomer) intend to underline the brokenness of the bread in relation to the brokenness of Jesus' body and the outpouring of the wine (or cup) in relation to the shedding of Jesus' blood at the cross. While some doubt is certainly justified, this paper argued on the basis of syntactical, narrative and intertextual observations on the one hand and on the basis of a consideration of the symbolic use of foodstuffs in the synoptic and Pauline tradition on the other that one ought indeed to attach significance to the brokenness of the bread and the outpouring of the wine beyond a simple and practical reference to their mode of distribution. This sheds also light on the use and understanding of these texts in early Christian (liturgical) contexts.
|
“Do You Understand What You Are Reading?” The Nascent Church as Arbiter of Biblical Interpretation in Luke-Acts
Program Unit: Allusions in the Gospels and Acts
Joshua Paul Smith, University of Denver
This paper compares the literary elements of the post-resurrection appearance of Jesus on the road to Emmaus in Luke 24:13-35 with the story of Philip and the Ethiopian eunuch in Acts 8:26-40. Among other parallels, the two stories both feature perplexed readers/interpreters of the Jewish tradition who need someone to help explain the meaning of Israel’s scripture for them, requiring “new eyes” with which to read the text. At the core of each narrative is the striking theological claim that “it was necessary” that the Messiah must suffer and die before entering “into his glory” (Luke 24:26), a concept that, strictly speaking, is nowhere to be found in the Old Testament. The fruit of this literary comparison, I argue, is the conclusion that the author of Luke intends to portray the church and its budding Christian mission as the inheritor of Jesus’s peculiar exegesis, a reconfiguring of the biblical tradition that allows readers to see Christ at work in the very foundation of Israel’s scripture, “beginning with Moses and all the prophets.”
|
What is a Monumental Inscription? Reflections on Space, Time, and Materiality
Program Unit: Ancient Near East
Jeremy D. Smoak, University of California-Los Angeles
Most studies of the monumental inscriptions from the southern Levant take a rather narrow approach to their function as sites of political and cultural performance. The tendency is to locate the significance of such inscriptions within narratives of political and linguistic development. Such tendencies prioritize the linguistic dimensions of the inscriptions to the neglect of their materiality, artistic design, and display features. The present paper applies recent theory on materiality in order to develop a more robust approach to Iron Age monumental inscriptions. The paper attempts to initiate discussion of the following questions: What is a monumental inscription? What does the label monumental imply about the design and function of such inscriptions? What did the non-linguistic features of these texts communicate to audiences? Writing biographies of inscriptions as cultural artifacts paves the way for a more sophisticated approach to the diverse modes of communication (shape, graphic design, materiality, etc.). Thinking more broadly about the lives of monumental inscriptions also draws attention to their agency and the multiple ways in which they spoke and acted as objects.
|
Teshuvah in the Jewish Literature of the Second Temple Period
Program Unit: Judaica
Yuri Snisarenko, Saint Petersburg State University
In an attempt to comprehend the processes taking place in the modern world, politicians, thinkers, and a broader audience are increasingly turning to exploring biblical constants, looking for possible answers to the most challenging questions of the today’s society. Despite the rapid development of the modern world, often referred to as the world of postmodernism, the Biblical texts and Jewish texts of the Second Temple period become the focus of many researchers. We can say that the modern Bible studies are at a new peak of interest among scholars, opening a new perspective on the importance of these texts for a modern person. One of the major concepts of the Tanakh, which had a particular influence on the development of religious beliefs of the Jewish people of the Second Temple period, and later gained new momentum and was reflected in Talmudic Judaism and Christianity, is Teshuvah (תְּשׁוּבַת). In the Second Temple period the subject of Teshuvah, tracing back to the fragment of the book of Devarim, 30: 1-10, gained particular importance for the authors of the texts available to modern scholars. In the context of the ‘continued captivity’, the awareness of the need for Teshuvah would continue to have a significant impact on religious ideas of the Jewish people. In allegorical terms, the concept of Teshuvah appears as a cornerstone underlying the framework of the further development of religious Jewish and Christian beliefs. By the example of the development of Teshuvah concept in a number of the Jewish texts of the Second Temple period, we will attempt to understand the reflection of a ‘Bible Person’ of the Second Temple period on the earlier Bible texts having civilizational importance.
|
Contingent Discourse and the Question of “Paul's Theology”
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Julia Snyder, Universität Regensburg
How invested was Paul in the ideas he articulates while arguing for something else? Which would one want to include in a "Theology of Paul"? How does the possible contingency of his statements impact the way we think with his letters about “Christianness”? I focus on two ethical issues, post-baptismal circumcision (Galatians) and eating in idol temples (1 Corinthians 8-10), and the persuasive strategies Paul uses to discourage his addressees from engaging in those behaviors. I argue that one can do justice to Paul’s letters without assuming that he was equally invested in all of his “theologizing” statements. This absolves us of the need to accuse Paul of “inconsistency” when he employs variable supporting arguments, and cautions us not to assume that he would have considered all of the “theological” ideas in his letters essential to “being Christian.”
|
Rahab and the Raid of Jericho Beyond Denial
Program Unit: Psychological Hermeneutics of Biblical Themes and Texts
Flavia Soldano-Deheza, Universidad de Tres de Febrero
Elsa Tames claims that it is necessary to turn to other disciplines to pose liberating hermeneutics that would question established readings. We think that psychoanalysis can contribute to a different approach. Paul Ricoeur mentions Freud as one the thinkers of the suspicion, the ones that have read reality searching to unmask a hegemonic and lineal reading. And it is from this locus of suspecting that we propose a different reading of the story of Rahab, and the raid of Jericho, such as it appears in Joshua 2:1-24; 6:22-27.
Violence addresses and unsettles us; but denial, as a defense mechanism against this uncertainty, erases the singularity where the otherness is constructed. From our perspective some of the Latin American liberation analysis of this story tarnish the violence of the text and seek cover within the favor of Yahweh as justification. Misunderstand this violence might be an unconscious attempt at justification that avoids discontent with the contradictions that the Old testament poses.
We will also present a practical case of inmigrant “sex workers” who are confronted with this biblical narrative as a trigger in a reflection group. We propose their reading as a controversial hermeneutic that goes beyond violence denial as a defense mechanism.
|
Gen 16 and Gen 21: A Lacanian Perspective
Program Unit: Deconstructive Poetics (EABS)
Flavia Soldano-Deheza, Universidad de Tres de Febrero
What is the function of Gen 16 and Gen 21 in the Promise texts?
We will approach both stories from a Lacanian psychoanalytical perspective, keeping in mind that the narrative of Hagar and Ishmael´s expulsion is not linear but rather interlaced by discursive articulations.
The deconstruction of the apparent binary form of the text will allow us to read it as a disruptive fabric that finds its anchorage in the trauma (injure) as an incessant place, as a boundary constituted by that same exclusion. As such, the expulsion weaves itself together as a gap operation that produces an abject wandering exterior, but, at the same time, it is part of the same injury. This boundary does not demarcate a bi-spatiality (inside/outside) but rather establishes the exterior as founded by the rejection.
We will focus on this new surface, where two opposite terms can unite, presuming it is the necessary separation and subjective operation so as to constitute the social bound that makes up a community.
|
Woman and Devotion: The Use of the Bible and Other Devotional Objects in the Religious Formation of Joanna I of Castile and Katherine of Aragon
Program Unit: Biblical Reception History and Authority in the Middle Ages and Beyond (EABS)
Melania Soler Moratón, University of Murcia
The transition from the Middle Ages to the Renaissance involved the creation of a new Christian ideology. The teachings of the movement called Devotio Moderna, based on the intimate relationship between the faithful and the deity through prayer and a more human aspect of Christ, implied a reinterpretation of the Holy Scriptures and the way of teaching them. This new interpretation had its own personality in the Iberian Peninsula: the coexistence of the three cultures and religions - Christian, Jewish and Muslim - gave rise to different values of the Bible and its teachings.
The objective of this proposal is to show the means, forms and iconographies used and developed in the Iberia and, specifically, its relationship with the education of feminine power elites. For it, this study will focus on the figures of the Infantas of Castile and Aragon - Joanna I of Castile and Katherine of Aragon - as two complementary means of accepting or denying the religious teachings that were inculcated through the Bible. The inclusión of the Infantas in the religious world in childhood, at the hands of his preceptors and their mother Queen Elizabeth, was based on biblical teachings and other religious texts. These texts emphasized those episodes related to typically feminine values, with the aim of modelling the infants into perfect wives for a foreign king.
The study of their inventories and the chronicles about their lives will allow us to raise the biblical female models and, in turn, the repercussion that they had in their religious lives.
|
Nordic Horizons in Feminist New Testament Scholarship
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Anna Rebecca Solevåg, VID Specialized University
The Nordic Countries are often hailed as model societies for gender equality. Although the situation in these countries is more complex than such headlines account for, the context for feminist biblical exegesis in the Nordic Countries has been social democracies with a strong component of gender equality. Our paper will present these Nordic Horizons for feminist biblical scholarship, looking back as well as ahead. First, we briefly trace the history of feminist scholarship, presenting and contextualizing scholars such as Lone Fatum, Turid Karlsen Seim and Halvor Moxnes. In a second part, we discuss the contemporary situation and try to point forward. What are the challenges and possibilities that lie ahead?
|
How to Write a Syntax of the Septuagint?
Program Unit: Septuagint Studies
Raija Sollamo, Helsingin Yliopisto - Helsingfors Universitet
It has been one target of the International Organization for the Study of the Septuagint to produce a syntax as a useful tool for the research of the Septuagint. This target was expressed as early as in the congress at Uppsala in 1971. It also was the dream of my teacher Professor Ilmari Soisalon-Soininen. The target has seemed to be very far away in the future. But now we are one step closer to the final goal. There are two reasons for that. One is the syntax by Takamitsu Muraoka that appeared in 2016. The second consists of a number of special translation-technical studies of the LXX syntax published since Soisalon-Soininen’s Die Infinitive in der Septuaginta (1965). On the one hand, the task is to collect and utilize the available data. On the other hand, the challenge is to compile the data in a way that a syntax of a translation can be written on the basis of translation technique. As is generally known, the LXX syntax shows interference from the syntax of the source language. The new syntax should show where and how the Septuagint Greek differs from the contemporary Koine. It should also display how the different books of the Septuagint differ from one another without overlooking the internal variation within the books. The main aim is to describe, to understand and explain the characteristics of the LXX syntax. In this paper, the content of the syntax and the method of presenting it are dealt with
|
“Physicians” in LXX Ps 87:11 and Isa 26:14 as an Example of the Septuagint Polemic against the Hellenistic Cultural-Religious Environment
Program Unit: Septuagint Studies
Alexey Somov, Institute for Bible Translation, Russia/CIS
In the LXX version of Ps 87:11 (MT 88:11) and Isa 26:14a, the Hebrew rǝphāʾim (“the spirits of the dead”) is translated as iatroi (“physisians”), while yāqûmû (“will rise up”) as anastēsousin/anastēsōsin (“will raise up”). It appears that for the translators of the LXX the direct connection of rǝphāʾim with the otherworld was lost, since they never translate it as such. In the context of Ps 87:11 and Isa 26:14, they understood it to be pointed as rōphǝʾim (healers), and rendered the verb qûm as a transitive verb. Was that the only reason for this rendering? It breaks the parallelism “the dead will not live//the spirits of the dead will not rise” and leaves “raise up” without an object. I propose that the reason for this rendering was only partially due to the fact that the meaning of rǝphāʾim as “the spirits of the dead” was in all likelihood lost. This is also because the biblical text was interpreted by the translators in the context of their polemic against the Hellenistic cult of Asclepius, who was revered not only in Alexandria, where the LXX was created, but also throughout the Greco-Roman world, and also against those Hellenistic medical practices that were associated with Asclepius. Indeed, controversy with Hellenistic gods is a feature of some LXX texts, especially of Isaiah. Asclepius, a Greek mythological hero and the god of healing, was sometimes called iatros (“physician”) and was believed to be able to resuscitate the dead (anistēmi). The LXX translators may have rendered the discussed parts of Ps 87:11/Isa 26:14 as affirming that pagan gods and their followers cannot raise the dead.
|
Cognitive Metaphor Studies and Eschatological Meal Imagery: Some Methodological Observations
Program Unit: Food as Concept / Symbol / Metaphor
Alexey Somov, Institute for Bible Translation, Russia/CIS
In cognitive linguistics, metaphor is defined as a phenomenon in which one conceptual domain is systematically structured in terms of another, e.g., the more abstract concept of the heavenly or supernatural world is structured and represented in terms of a “lower level” concept of the physical world. Such an approach to metaphor is appropriate for study of apocalyptic language (special language tools and symbolic imagery, e.g., similes, metaphors) as used in Jewish and Early Christian descriptions of the otherworld and eschatological matters. My presentation focuses on the advantages of using this method when investigating the Messianic or eschatological meal. While the functions and genesis of meal imagery in the eschatological imagination are usually investigated in linguistic terms (grammar, semantics) and literary terms (motifs, ideas, symbols), the cognitive approach tries to explain the way of portraying the mythological otherworld as based on “recurrent patterns of human embodiment” (Tappenden 2016, 34). I utilize several examples from the Bible (Zech 3:1-5; Sir 12:12; Luke 12:35-38;13:28-30; 14:16-26; Mat 22:1-14, 1 Cor 11:23-26) in order to demonstrate how the concepts of honor, the reversal of fates, and the gift of eternal life in the Kingdom of God are depicted by the imagery of the Messianic or eschatological banquet. This imagery involves elementary pre-concepts from embodied experience (UP–DOWN, INSIDE–OUTSIDE, CENTER–PERIPHERY, NEAR–FAR, CONTAINER, WHOLE–PART, LEFT–RIGHT, FRONT–BACK, FIRST–LAST), on which the concepts of selectivity, exclusivity, unity, and identity are based. It also includes the cultural-social issues of banquet invitations, arranging places at the banquet, proper clothes, reclining, and master-slave relations. The interpretation of these concepts helps us to understand how meal discourses define the multilevel worldview and describe the exaltation, transformation, and resurrection of the righteous, as well as their union with the divine.
|
The Interplay of Metaphor and Metonymy in Song of Songs
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible (EABS)
Jean-Pierre Sonnet, Pontificia Università Gregoriana
Next to the metaphoric dynamics, a second impulse underlies the flow and clustering of images in biblical poetry: the metonymical drive. In a 1956 article, Roman Jakobson has associated the two Freudian concepts of Verdichtung (“condensation”) and Verschiebung (“displacement”) to the tropes and axes of metaphor (substitution) and metonymy (contiguity). In a further step, Jacques Lacan has provided the metaphor/metonymy distinction with its most sustained elaboration in “The Instance of the Letter in the Unconscious” (1957): the two rhetorical figures represent the main tropes of the language of desire. The paper will investigate the interconnected dynamics of metaphor and metonymy in Song of Songs in the light of the linguistic and psychoanalytic categories just mentioned. In its poetic, oneiric and erotic dimensions, Song of Songs is apparently a sanctuary – and a grammar – of “polytropic” imaginative creativity.
|
Philip: Human Bridge between the Prologue and the Fourth Gospel
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Gilbert Soo Hoo, Singapore Bible College
Although a minor character, Philip assumes a significant role as a bridge between the Prologue of the Fourth Gospel and the rest of the narrative and, at the same time, reveals traits commonly associated with character. This study seeks to address both issues using two templates—the Johannine literary device of misunderstanding with the Prologue as the point of reference and Cornelis Bennema’s comprehensive theory of character. The outcome would be a better appreciation that disciples can fulfill their mission for the cause of Christ as humans with noteworthy character and not merely as a plot device.
|
“Utterly Perishing” or Simply “Dying to God"? Tracing the History and Assessing the Contextual Plausibility of a Crucial Variation Unit in the Shepherd of Hermas 72.4 [Sim. 8.6.4]
Program Unit: Textual Criticism: Manuscripts & Methods
Jonathan E. Soyars, Louisville Seminary
Manuscript witnesses to the second-century Shepherd of Hermas are notoriously limited. This unfortunate situation extends to the text of Similitude 8.6.4 [72.4], where the Roman author imagines an appropriate fate for those persecuted persons whom he labels “deserters and betrayers of the church.” Sinaiticus lacks this particular portion of the Shepherd, but extant witnesses agree that Hermas’s rhetorical targets committed blasphemy, were ashamed of their Lord’s name, and did not repent. Critical editions are conflicted regarding whether Hermas described them as thereafter “utterly perishing to God” (apolōnto tō theō; trans. Holmes) or merely “dying to God” (apethanon tō theō). The Vulgate and Palatine Latin and the Ethiopic translations support reading apethanon, but following Lampros’s 1888 collation of the medieval Mount Athos codex, editors consistently adopted its reading of apolōnto until Bonner published the third-century Michigan codex, which reads apethanon, in 1934. Since then, the overwhelming majority of scholars have adopted this reading, although without explaining why. Against that strong consensus and the agreement of the versions, I argue that the Athos codex’s reading of apolōnto tō theō at Sim. 8.6.4 [72.4] is probably original for three reasons. First, it is harder to explain apōlonto as a copyist or translator’s change than apethanon. Second, the verb apollymi, being stronger in connotation than apothnēskō, is more contextually appropriate. Finally, a phrase conceptually similar to apethanon tō theō appears at Sim. 10.2.4 [112.4], where only the Latin survives, indicating that my preferred reading is not an anomaly within Hermas’s thought. Recognizing the authenticity of Codex Athos’s reading at Sim. 8.6.4 [72.4] reveals Hermas’s creative extension of the biblical dyad “living and dying to God” within his argument against abandoning the faith under persecution, as well as the very early date at which it was corrupted in the manuscript tradition.
|
Unearthing the Pagan Temple in Popular Culture
Program Unit: The Biblical World and Its Reception (EABS)
Petter Spjut, Uppsala Universitet
This presentation examines a recurring theme in contemporary horror movies: the forgotten pagan temple. Buried beneath a church, or concealed in a jungle or a desert, the temple functions as a plot twist and an explanatory device: a sinister presence haunts a seemingly peaceful location. The haunting remains a mystery until the discovery of an ancient pagan temple, which not only heightens the tension but also provides a cause for the menacing activity.
But why are their sanctuaries so frightening, and what ideologies are at play in the construal of other peoples’ gods as monstrous? Attempting to answer this question, I analyze how three contemporary movies engage with ancient history and biblical traditions in their presentation of pagan temples: The Exorcist: The Beginning (2004), The Borderlands (2013), and The Pyramid (2014). In these movies, knowledge of the past serves as an interpretative key. As the narrative progresses, the viewer learns more about the sixth-century conquests of Justinian, or the triumph of Christianity in medieval England, and is gradually able to unravel the mystery of the rediscovered pagan temple.
Since the frequent allusions to the past invite to intertextual readings, I analyze the cinematic narratives together with fourth- to fifth-century CE materials on temple cleansings and demonic deities. This comparative perspective reveals how ancient ideologically loaded narratives have been adapted to new contexts in contemporary cinema. Such an historical contextualization also invites a closer look at rivalling narratives that have not been included in those films, and the implications of those ostensible omissions.
|
The Prophecy of Nahum and the Positive Aspects of Revenge
Program Unit: Psychological Hermeneutics of Biblical Themes and Texts
Klaas Spronk, Protestantse Theologische Universiteit
In the field of psychological hermeneutics much attention and sympathy is given to prophets like Jeremiah helping to cope with the traumatic experience of the Babylonian exile. The prophetic vision of Nahum in the comparable situation of the Judeans suffering under Assyrian tyranny is less popular and often condemned for the way it pictures YHWH as a violent god and which even seems to approve and therefore also incites to sexual abuse of women. In this paper I hope to demonstrate that the trust in YHWH as both a good god and an avenger of the evil deeds of the Assyrians functions as a prerogative to restore the faith of the traumatized Judeans. The way in which YHWH’s revenge is presented has an important function within this framework. Modern interpreters should be reluctant in criticizing it, because in the specific situation of the traumatized it can have a healing function.
|
Reconsidering the Cult of the Dead in Ugarit
Program Unit: Ugarit and the Bible: Life and Death (EABS)
Klaas Spronk, Protestantse Theologische Universiteit
In his monograph "Death in the Iron Age II and in First Isaiah" published in 2011 Christopher B. Hays presented an overview of the history of research on the Ugaritic cult of the dead around what he called "the Spronk synthesis", taking my dissertation of 1986 ("Beatific Afterlife in Ancient Israel and in the Ancient Near East") as a marking point representing "the most ambitious attempt to argue for widespread cults of the dead". It would also have marked a turning point. Whereas I could build on the work of Schaeffer, De Moor, and Pope, my "synthesis" was firmly criticized by later scholars. Hays takes a middle position.
More than thirty years after my dissertation I would like to take up this issue: does the history of recent research lead to important new insights? Are there relevant new facts and better methods?
|
Continuations of 'Anat in the First Millennium
Program Unit: Israel in the Ancient Near East (EABS)
Adrianne Spunaugle, University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
The deity 'Anat is well known from various myth and ritual texts of Ugarit and to some extent from Egypt. However, the goddess was also a key figure for the kings of Suhu, who claimed descent from Hammurapi of Babylon, himself. This paper explores the continued role of the West Semitic deity of 'Anat in the first millennium along the Middle Euphrates, the significance of the inclusion of the Suhu kings in the Babylonian Kinglist, and suggests new insights into the West Semitic / Aramaean connections of the Neo-Babylonian kings.
|
Jerusalem of Stones as a Witness of God`s Love: The Vantage Point of Salvation Through the Eyes of Righteous Simeon (Luke 2:22-40)
Program Unit: Place, Space, and Identity in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Dimitrije Stanojevic, Trinity International University, Deerfield, IL
Place is what shapes the identity of persons, families and nations. It affects making the crucial decisions in life that bring people to God or away from him. Jerusalem has always been the center of God`s revelation, the witness of generous loving acts, and the place par excellence which shapes the lives of all. Since the beginning of the world until today, Jerusalem carries the mystery of the city “knit together” (Ps 122:3) and deserves to be called Axis Mundi - the center of the world. In fact, in the city of Jerusalem, Righteous Simeon and Anna testified the extraordinary event of presenting Jesus in the Temple by Joseph and Mary and seeing the universal “salvation” (Luke 2:29) of the world.
In this paper, I argue that the vantage point of salvation through the eyes of Righteous Simeon did, indeed, assume the revelation of God through the acts of loving kindness. It was inseparable from the city of many stones itself. Hence, this point in space impacted human identity, ideology, as well as orientation because Jerusalem is not merely the city of its characteristic white lime-stones by which it is naturally surrounded. It is the city of the Stone of Foundation (Even HaShetiyah), and of the stone of faith (religions), but above all it is the keystone of salvation. Perceiving Incarnated Word spatially, Simeon observed the purpose of the Creation: become “new Creation” (2 Cor 5:17), and be in communion with God. Consequently, by meeting Christ, one gains life everlasting and elevates the Holy City of Resurrected Christ to New Jerusalem, and transfigures the stones of Jerusalem into “the living stones” (1Peter 2:5), “bringing unity to all things in heaven and on earth under Christ” (Eph 1:10). Finally, Jerusalem is the place where spatial becomes eternal through the glorious resurrection.
|
Dispelling the Evil at Ugarit: The Incantation KTU 1.82 as a Case Study
Program Unit: Dispelling Demons: Interpretations of Evil and Exorcism in Ancient Near Eastern, Jewish and Biblical Contexts (EABS)
Clemens Steinberger, University of Innsbruck
Dispelling all sorts of evil was a major concern at the city of Ugarit: Demons and evil gods were supposed to cause diseases and sufferings, which is why incantations were performed to cure afflicted persons and to dispel the evil from the patients’ surroundings. One of these incantation texts is KTU 1.82, including several spells and ritual instructions to ward off malevolent snakes: Rašpu, god of the underworld and plague, was responsible for snake attacks against various men and women. An authoritative god is invoked to cure the patients’ suffering by the cry of an intermediate agent. This god can then heal the patients by means of magical practices.
My lecture addresses a new interpretation of KTU 1.82 in respect of its local Ugaritic as well as its wider Ancient Near Eastern setting. Firstly I will discuss the plot and the structure of KTU 1.82. In this regard I will focus on the characterization of the text’s protagonists, e.g. the evil, the patients, the gods of release, special agents, and their dependencies among each other. Secondly I will discuss KTU 1.82 in the light of the corpus of Ugaritic incantations: Several texts seem to follow a standardized form, which is also expressed in KTU 1.82. Thereby I want to bring into focus recurring protagonists and particular mythological backgrounds of the Ugaritic incantations. Lastly I will put KTU 1.82 and the Ugaritic incantations in the context of Mesopotamian incantations and text traditions, that were obviously picked up and adapted at Ugarit. Therefore, I will compare concepts and ideas from Ugaritic and Mesopotamian incantations. The interpretation of KTU 1.82 in the light of Ancient Near Eastern traditions as well as Ugaritic innovations should cast new light on Ugaritic magical practices to dispel the evil.
|
Before the "Alexandrian Text": Origen, P46, and the Search for the Earliest Greek New Testament
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the New Testament, the Old Testament and the Qur’an (EABS)
Matthew R. Steinfeld, LCC International University
Papyrus 46 is typically dated no later than the second half of the 3rd century AD. Origen of Alexandria, a contemporary of this important manuscript, who lived from (AD 184-254), sometimes demonstrates agreement with its text where there is no other external support. Considering that many papyrus readings are unsupported by later manuscript traditions, units of variation where Origen provides external support for P46 are likely to reveal not just Origen’s authorial citations but evidence that the text of P46 could have been a more normative text-form than extant New Testament evidence suggests today. However, Origen normally does not usually support P46’s readings of Romans. In fact, sometimes Origen’s works do not agree with his own citations from his other works. His conflicting citations of Romans demonstrate the fluid nature of his citations and the effects of later scribes or readers on the text of his works (and ultimately the Greek New Testament). This paper explores two independent sources that could contain the earliest possible form of the Greek New Testament in Egypt. When compared to each other in relation to, perhaps, the most influential epistle of the New Testament, it provides an opportunity to validate the readings of P46 that might have been previously considered singular while at the same time gauging the readings of Origen’s citations of Romans in regard to his whole corpus in the second half of the epistle. The implications of this paper could reveal a previously unknown connection between the most influential theologian and one of the more important New Testament manuscripts of the early church, while at the same time providing insight into the textual nature of the earliest Greek New Testament.
|
Philo of Alexandria’s Life of Moses: An Introduction to the Exposition of the Law
Program Unit: Judaica
Gregory Sterling, Yale Divinity School
The placement of Philo’s Life of Moses within his corpus is problematic. Is it an independent biography, an introduction to the writings of Moses, an introduction to Philo’s three commentary series, or an introduction to the Exposition of the Law. This paper will argue that it serves as an introduction to the Exposition. We will consider three major lines of evidence: the plans for the Exposition (Mos. 2.45-27; Abr. 2-5; Praem. 1-3), the use of secondary prefaces in the treatises of the Exposition (Abr. 1-6; Ios. 1; Decal. 1; Spec. 1.1; 2.1; 3.7; 4.1, 132-235 [for Virt.]; Praem. 1-3 ), and the internal cross-references to the Life of Moses within the Exposition (Virt. 52 and Praem. 53).
|
Treasure Hunt or Biblical Archaeology? Valter Juvelius in Jerusalem 1909–1911
Program Unit: History of Biblical Scholarship in the Late Modern Period
Timo R. Stewart, University of Helsinki
One of the less known Finnish “Holy Land explorers” is the poet Valter H. Juvelius (1865-1922), who initiated and participated in one of the early large scale excavations in Jerusalem. Known best as the Parker Expedition after its leader, the excavations proceeded in 1909-1911 under a shroud of mystery on the Hill of Ophel, immediately south of the Temple Mount. Secrecy soon gave way to wild public speculation in the spring of 1911, when European and American papers reported that the leaders of the expedition had caused a riot and had to flee the city. Perhaps, scores of papers reported, escaping with untold ancient treasures and even the Ark of the Covenant. The scholarly community at the time was rather critical or dismissive of the expedition and it received a mixed reception in the press in the months following the initial scandal of the riot in Jerusalem. Many dismissed it as essentially a treasure hunt, as opposed to a truly scientific archaeological expedition. Yet it had far more in common with other archaeological expeditions of the early 20th century than has been generally recognised. This paper will examine the aims and the conduct of the Juvelius project and analyse them in relationship to the criticism levelled by scholars and the press. Although the notoriety of the expedition limited its impact on Biblical scholarship, some of the themes central to Juvelius – an inerrantist approach to the Bible and a desire to use archaeology as verification for the Bible – were also to become closely associated with the Biblical archaeology of the Mandate era. Examining the differences between the Parker Expedition’s approach and the scholarly criticism of it will afford an interesting insight into the early 20th century debate on the relationship between Holy Land exploration and science.
|
The Death of the Prophet? A Comparative Study of Prophetic Sign-Reports in Ancient (Mari) Syria (ARM 26/1.206) and Israel (Jeremiah 19:1–13)
Program Unit: Prophets
William R. Stewart, Alphacrucis College
This paper is a contribution to the debate concerning the relationship between pre- and post-exilic Israelite prophecy, with particular reference to what has been called “mantic exegesis,” defined by Schorch (2000) as “The art of interpreting signs considered to be a medium of revelation.” A relationship between “prophets” and “signs” is axiomatic in the literature of ancient Israel. Paronomastic puns constitute the exegetical key to several prophetic sign-reports in the Hebrew Bible. The presence of “mantic exegesis” in biblical prophetic texts (the Neviʾim of the Hebrew Bible canon) has acquired particular importance in recent scholarly theorising about their composition. Joachim Schaper (2006) has concluded that the Babylonian exile (586–538 BCE) represented the first stage in “the death of the prophet.” Schaper’s phrase offers a convenient shorthand designation for the view that biblical prophetic texts attributed to the pre-exilic period are in fact the “constructs” of post-exilic (Persian and Hellenistic period) scribal activity. Scholars associated with this view represent a recent trend in scholarly research identified by Ben-Dov (2008) which “centers on the relation between the mantic arts, prophecy, and the scribal culture.” My contribution is a comparative study of the coherence of a biblical sign-report with a reliable extra-biblical prophetic text, both of which feature “mantic exegesis” in the form of paronomastic puns. The biblical report of a sign attributed to the prophet Jeremiah (Jer 19:1–13) in Jerusalem, in the southern Israelite kingdom of Judah, ca. 609–597 BCE, is compared with the earliest extant extra-biblical prophetic sign-report (ARM 26/1.206) recorded in Mari, Syria, ca. 1776–1761 BCE, a millennium before any of the prophecies reported in the biblical Neviʾim. Is Jer 19:1–13 credible as a pre-exilic prophecy enacted and exegeted by a historical prophet? Is the prophet dead?
|
ΣΗΜΕΙΑ ΚΑΙ ΤΈΡΑΤΑ: The Cosmopolitan Language of Prophets and Signs in the Judean War and Antiquities of Flavius Josephus
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
William R. Stewart, Alphacrucis College
The relationship between the Israelite/Judean historian Josephus and his Hellenistic-Roman cultural milieu has been a focus of modern Josephus scholarship. His major works, Judean War and Antiquities, report several would-be Judean prophētai of the mid-first century CE whom, Josephus says, promised to display sēmeia kai terata (War 2.259; 6.285; 7.438; Ant. 20.168). Josephus also uses sēmeia-terminology with reference to phenomena he claims foretold the destruction of the Jerusalem Temple (War 6.288–315), and even for genuine sēmeia among the Gentiles, notably the omina imperii of emperor Vespasian’s accession (War 1.23; 3.404; 4.623). The Roman historian Tacitus (early-second century CE), relates several of the Temple-destruction sēmeia as prodigia (Hist. 5.13.1). Moreover, in Josephus “signs authenticate the words of prophets in much the same way that other omens signal divine approval or disapproval” (Miller). My heuristic axiom is that the existing Greek sēmeia (kai terata)-terminology (corresponding to signa et portenta/prodigia in Latin) constitutes the key to Josephus’s understanding of the phenomena and their theological significance in his major works. Josephus did not need to deliberately “Hellenize” signs/omens. Sēmeia-terminology had been available at least since the LXX Pentateuch to Judeans necessarily involved in “a negotiation between cultures” (Rajak). My thesis is that as “cosmopolitan language” sēmeia-terminology enabled Josephus (and other Hellenistic-Roman era Judean authors) to narrate sēmeia with an intentional “double-sidedness” (Kelley) intelligible to both his Greek-reading Roman and Judean audiences. Writing in Greek to Greek-readers, he naturally uses Greek sēmeia-terminology to describe the signs/omens of the Judean prophētai. However, neither Josephus’s use of Greek terminology for a Greek-reading Roman primary audience nor his (hostile) apologetic motives obscure the fundamental features of the sēmeia of his first-century prophētai as they would have been known by his secondary Judean audience—as a “distinctively Israelite phenomenon” (Horsley).
|
Building a Fence around the Vineyard: Shepherd of Hermas’ ‘Parable of the Fasting’ in Light of Comparative Parable Research
Program Unit: Parables in Rabbinic Judaism and Early Christianity: Towards a New Comparative Approach (EABS)
Martijn Stoutjesdijk, Tilburg School of Catholic Theology
In the field of parable research the parables of the Shepherd of Hermas have not received much scholarly attention in the past, since they have often been denounced as ‘visions’ (cf. Blomberg 1990, 48) or ‘not real parables’ (cf. Barton 1909, 308). However, as I will show in my paper the fifth parable of the early christian text Shepherd of Hermas (‘Parable of the fasting’, chapter 55) offers us a unique insight in the development of the parable-genre and the relation between redactional frameworks and the parable as a literary unit, since Hermas offers three different and competing levels of interpretation of the parable, a phenomenon that is called ‘allegorical polysemy’ by Philippe Henne (1992, 181). In my paper I situate the ‘Parable of the Fasting’ in the context of early Christian and early Rabbinic parable telling and discuss its ancient social-historical background. After analyzing its different interpretation layers, I argue that the christological interpretation of the parable is a later development, while its plot and characters are firmly rooted in early christian and early rabbinic imagery.
|
Aesop, Shimon bar Kappara, and Jesus: The Literary Personality of the Historical Fable Teller
Program Unit: Parables in Rabbinic Judaism and Early Christianity: Towards a New Comparative Approach (EABS)
Justin David Strong, University of Notre Dame
For more than a century, scholars who have worked on Jewish folklore in the rabbinic period have noted many overlaps between Aesopic fables and numerous rabbinic meshalim. While it has seldom occurred since the days of Jülicher, a few intrepid New Testament scholars have also sought to demonstrate a certain continuity or affinity between the Aesopic fables and parables of Jesus found in early Christian gospels. Far more common have been attempts to establish continuities between the parabolai of Jesus and the meshalim/ot found in rabbinic literature that would justify bridging the centuries-long gap between them. This paper offers a new avenue for comparing and establishing continuity between the rabbinic and early Christian parables: the literary persona the authors impart to the parable speaker. This paper argues that the persona of the fable speaker, Aesop, known through the narratives accompanying his fables in the first-century CE author Phaedrus and the Aesop Romance served as a paradigm for Jewish and Christian authors in their portrayal of parable speakers: Jesus and Shimon bar Kappara (fl. 180-220 CE). The commonalities established, what these depictions of Aesop, Jesus, and Bar Kappara communicate about these figures as authors of fables will be examined in light of Foucault’s “Qu'est-ce qu'un auteur?” The results invite further comparisons between the Aesop materials and other rabbis in the Talmud and early Christian portrayals of Jesus, from the depictions of their personae to the contents of their parables.
|
Parables and Paratexts: Promythium and Epimythium as a Guide and a Crutch to Interpretation
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Justin David Strong, University of Notre Dame
This paper advances a new approach to the parables in the Synoptic Tradition, seeking to understand material that surrounds numerous parables in light of ancient paratextual features known as the promythium and the epimythium. These paratextual features are common to the ancient fable, a genre near the parable. From the style and function of these features in the first-century CE fables literature it will be argued that the Gospel authors, in imitation of the closest Greek literary genre to the parable, found it natural to use the technology appropriate to the fable in their own texts. These links established, we shall then examines how the verses surrounding the parables have been misused by modern interpreters who have not recognized the ways in which these paratextual additions historically related to the enclosed parable. An overview of how the pro- and epimythium came into being and how they were used in the first century CE will be offered, followed by the implications for how scholars can use these paratexts productively to generate new insights into the parables.
|
The Metaphor of the ‘Bee’ in the Hebrew and Greek Traditions of the OT and Its Influence on Post-biblical Literature and Thought
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible (EABS)
Barbara Strzalkowska, University of Cardinal Stefan Wyszynski, Warsaw
In European culture a bee is often considered a hardworking and diligent creature, similar to the ant. Such imagery has its roots in either biblical or classical ancient tradition. The biblical metaphor of a bee is at least twofold: in the Hebrew tradition bees are usually presented as dangerous (for example an attacking bee swarm; to a lesser extent as ‘honey-producers’, without any admiration for their assiduity), whilst only in the Greek tradition are they described as hardworking creatures (for example in LXX-Prov 6:8, where the description of the bee follows upon that of the ant). The biblical imagery of the ‘labour of bees’ might therefore have resulted from the relationship between the Hebrew community and the Hellenistic world (where this metaphor of a bee existed together with the one of an ant; see Aristotle). The paper will present the metaphor of ‘diligent bees’ in this wider Biblical and ancient context, both Hebrew and Greek. This consideration is important also because the post-biblical image of a bee enriched the theological tradition of the early Church (for example, the “Exsultet” has two references to bees, not to mention later bestiaria or iconography).
|
"Coat of Many Colors": Evidence for the Use of Plant Dyes in Textiles Dating to Kings David and Solomon's Era
Program Unit: The Language of Colour in the Bible: From Word to Image (EABS)
Naama Sukenik, Israel Antiquities Authority
This paper is co-authored by Erez Ben-Yosef, Vanessa Workman, and Orit Shamir. In this talk we present a unique collection of dyed textiles dated to the early Iron Age (11th-10th centuries BCE), focusing on the analysis of the organic dyestuff used for red and blue. These textiles were uncovered in the copper smelting camps of Timna as part of the ongoing excavations of the Central Timna Valley Project, which aims at better understanding the society operating the mines at the turn of the 1st millennium BCE (early Edom). Analysis by HPLC-DAD identified two organic dyestuffs, Rubia tinctorum L. and indigotin from a plant source (probably Isatis tinctoria L.), which are among the earliest documented dyeing materials. Currently, our results constitute the earliest evidence for the use of these dyestuffs in the Levant; they also shed new light on the favorable colors (and clothing fashion) of elite in the era of David and Solomon (10th c. BCE), and on technological achievements in the dyeing industry. It seems that our study provide first physical evidence for the biblical "Coat of many colors" (“kəṯōneṯ passim” in Hebrew), which was an important garment at the time (Gen, 37: 3; Sam 2, 13:18).
|
Dominant Schemata in the Pentateuch: A Cognitive Overview
Program Unit: Stylistics and the Hebrew Bible
Talia Sutskover, Tel Aviv University
This paper suggests that each Pentateuchal book consists of one or several dominant schemata. The term ʽschemaʼ is roughly synonymous to ʽframesʼ and ʽscenariosʼ, all which are theoretically discussed and practically applied in the areas of cognitive linguistics, discourse analysis, literature, philosophy and psychology. In this paper the term ʽschemaʼ refers to a net of words relating to a particular type of object, situation or event (Elena Semino; Guy Cook). For instance, the mental schema of an event of sacrificing includes words referring to a sacrifice, an offerer, a priest, a sacred place, and a deity to which the sacrifice is brought. It is enough for certain linguistic elements to occur in a text, in order that the entire schema be activated in the mind of the reader (Fillmore). Once a schema is activated, it is used to have a better understanding of the discourse.
Hence, it will be argued that the book of Genesis foregrounds the schema of ʽsightʼ (Sutskover, Sight and Insight in Genesis), whereas, Deuteronomy, highlights ʽoral communicationʼ, and seems to prefer the latter schema over the former (Stephen Geller). The sense of touch and the body (of both animals and humans) are foregrounded in Leviticus, perhaps as a result of an intensive occupation with the topics of purity and impurity. Exodus and Numbers include dominant schemata of their own, as will be suggested in the paper. This preliminary mapping of schemata, and the way they are depicted throughout the Pentateuch, elucidates some of the main concerns of ancient Israel.
|
Representations of an Ideal Citizen and Justifications of Exclusion from Community in Classical Athenian Law and Literature
Program Unit: Citizens and Aliens in Greco-Roman Antiquity (EABS)
Suvi Kuokkanen, University of Oulu
In 451/0 BCE, the Athenians articulated legal criteria of Athenian citizenship. While this verbalization of the standards of citizenship, initially proposed by Pericles, was the first emergence of legal definition of Athenian-ness, numerous political and religious institutions already existed which entailed exclusion from the citizen body. This suggests that the Athenians already had shared ideals of a good citizen. In my presentation, I discuss these ideals and criteria. I analyse the explicit and implicit representations of an ideal citizen in Athenian laws, institutions, and literature. At the same time, I discuss the justifications of exclusion from the citizen community in Athenian law and literature.
I approach the subject from two perspectives. Firstly, I analyse certain legal, political, and religious institutions which entailed exclusion from the Athenian citizen community. These included legal and political institutions such as banishment and disenfranchisement, on the one hand, and religious practices such as the scapegoat ritual, on the other hand. Secondly, I locate these institutions in broader cultural context by reflecting their developments against the altering idea of a good citizen as represented in classical Athenian literature – for example, in comedy plays, philosophical writings, and law-court speeches. In this connection, I examine also implicit representations of an ideal citizen in drawings and texts inscribed on a selection of ostraka, i.e. on potsherds used as voting ballots when voting on ostrakismos (ten-year exile). It will be argued that the political and religious institutions reflected the shared idea of an ideal Athenian.
|
“As Yet There Was No Spirit…” (John 7:39): Pneumatology and the Making of the Fourth Gospel
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Kari Syreeni, Abo Akademi University
It is not without reason that Clement of Alexandria called John “the spiritual Gospel.” Oddly, however, the pneumatology of that Gospel shows perplexing contradictions. John the Baptist witnessed that Jesus would baptize with the Holy Spirit (1:33). The Gospel narrates that Jesus baptized many people (3:26; 4:1). But why is it emphasized that Jesus himself did not baptize (4:2)? Water and Spirit belong together, as John 3:5 shows. But what should we make of John 7:37-39? On the great day of the festival of booths, Jesus is standing and crying: “Come to me and drink…” What could Jesus offer if “there was no spirit” at that time? Or could he really have given the Samaritan woman living water (cf. 4:10)? The present paper argues that the tensions in Johannine pneumatology cannot be understood apart from the complex making of the Gospel.
|
“May the Dew Fall upon Them”: Jewish Epitaphic Poetry from the Late 19th – Early 20th Centuries in Bialystok and Bible Reception
Program Unit: The Biblical World and Its Reception (EABS)
Heidi M. Szpek, Central Washington University
Biblical texts have long been recognized as a component of the Jewish epitaph. Men are frequently described as “perfect and upright,” in keeping with the character of the biblical Job (1:8). Women are often remembered as “women of valor” (Prov. 31:10). Nearly every epitaph aligns the deceased with all who preceded them in death in its final blessing: “May his/her soul be bound in the bond of everlasting life” (I Samuel 25:29). In more traditional Jewish epitaphs, individual poetic lines as well as extensive acrostic poems are also incorporated to characterize the deceased, to express family or community’s response to a person’s passing and/or to offer commentary on death due to trauma.
The last Jewish cemetery in Bialystok, (current day) Poland, preserves approximately 3000 of its once 35,000 epitaphs, many of which incorporate individual lines of poetry and nearly 70 record acrostic poems. Dating to the late 19th – early 20th centuries, these poems are replete with biblical references, drawn especially from the books of Job, Psalms, Proverbs, Lamentations, Genesis and Isaiah. Scholarship, in general, views these compositions as derived from the medieval piyyutim, but degenerative in quality. While not ignoring the complex history of epitaphic poetry, the biblical texts, which are used in this corpus, are significant for considering the reception history of the bible both in the epitaphic tradition as well as in this period in history. Ultimately, the crafting of biblical texts in these epitaphs reflects a diachronic connection with the greater epitaphic tradition, the value and adaptation, at times, of these texts for this community, and the struggle of modernity in the traditional (mithnagdic) Jewish world in Bialystok (and Eastern Europe, in general) at the turn of the 20th century.
|
The Hittite Word šaklai-: Between Ritual and Law
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Ada Taggar-Cohen, Doshisha University
"In ancient Near Eastern cultures, the gods are guardians of justice who authorize kings by establishing them and conferring upon them the principles of justice and the wisdom essential to their rule, but the laws of the land are produced by the kings and are known by their names", thus indicates Christine Hayes in her book titled What's Divine about Divine Law (Princeton-Oxford: Princeton University Press, 2015 p. 2). However, when we speak about rituals, which in the Hebrew Bible as well as in the Hittite case are regarded "laws", we find them being similarly declared as "laws of the land" but coming from the gods directly, (even if some are mediated by humans). This presentation will explore in what way the ritual texts in Hittite culture are indeed divine law, and its exploration will encounter the difficulty posed by rituals being remodified and changed through time, while divine law is expected to be "static and coercive."
|
From Shamhat in Gilgamesh to Gomer and the Prostitution Metaphor in Hosea
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Nancy Tan, Chinese University of Hong Kong
Following Daniel Bodi’s essay on “The Encounter with the Courtesan in the Gilgamesh Epic and with Rahab in Joshua 2,” (2013) that draws the link between Šamḫat and Rahab and how they function metaphorically as acculturation to Enkidu and the spies of Israel, this paper attempts to explore the possible extension of the story in the another depiction of a prostitute mentioned in the Hebrew Bible, Gomer. This paper examines the story of Šamḫat and Enkidu and considers the probable inspiration of the biblical prophet/author for the portrayal of Gomer and the personification of Israel and Judah into a prostitute metaphor.
|
Rediscovering Phroneō: The Missing Link in Understanding Paul's Perspective on Humiliation and Exaltation in Philippians and the Interpretation of the Carmen Christi
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Rachael Tan, Taiwan Baptist Theological Seminary
The verb φρονέω (phroneō) is a significant word carefully chosen by Paul to highlight the importance of cultivating a Christ-centered thinking in his urgent call for unity in his letter to the Philippians. It is remarkable in both frequency and significance. Despite its importance in the letter, φρονέω is not given enough attention. This paper proposes that a close examination of the wide array of meanings attached to the verb and a closer look at the mind of Christ--humility and selfless attitude--will help us understand Paul's perspective on humiliation and exaltation and interpret the hymn more appropriately.
Philippians 2:5-11 is one of the key passages in the letter. A proper interpretation of this important Carmen Christi (Hymn of Christ) will unpack the kind of attitude that Jesus adopts. It is common to pit the two main streams of interpretation (kerygmatic and ethical) against each other. I argue that this is a false dichotomy since a doctrinal exposition does not cancel out its ethical implications, and Pauline ethics is often grounded in theological foundations. Paul integrates both theology and ethics in the letter. The only possible way for believers to live in harmony with each other in the Lord is to have the mind of Christ in dogma and praxis. Jesus Christ is the ultimate pattern to which we are being conformed in the way we think, feel, decide, and act (cf. Phil 3:10).
|
The Motif of Joy in the Prophecies of Isaiah 40-66
Program Unit: Judaica
Hagit Taragan, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
The prophecies of Deutero-Isaiah (Isa. 40-66) are launched with the exclamation: "Comfort, O comfort my people says your God" (40:1). Prophecies that hold a call for solace are expected to exhibit an attendant spirit of joy and encouragement, which manifests itself in words and verbs as derived from dedicated semantic fields.
Joy is an integral element of the prophecies of the consoling prophet who comes up with a variety of ways to convey it and to intertwine it with each of their respective central themes. Throughout these prophecies the expressions of joy are shared by all creatures of the universe, human and nature, Jerusalem and the cities of Judea, the People of Israel and remote islands, and they are surpassed by the joy of the Lord as expressed over the renewed creation and the return of the exiles to Zion.
The prophecies of Deutero-Isaiah abound with words associated with joy or joyful sounds, such as: gilah; simḥah; śaśon; ṣwaḥah; ṣahala; rinnah. Other demonstrations of joy may be inferred from the script, even if terms of joy are not explicitly used; rather, they follow from the context of elements of the script.
In this lecture I will demonstrate:
a) How the prophet conveys to his audience, by use of 'sound-related words' associated with the generation of voices and sounds, the sensations of exhilaration and joy that accompany the deeds of God and his salvation.
b) How the notion of joy that attends solace constitutes a link that connects the prophecies.
c) The terminology that is peculiar to the prophet, marking his portrayal of scenes of "joy of nature" as well as scenes of wedding and bridal joy which recur in the prophecies of Isaiah 40-66.
d) Modes of style as applied by the prophet in renderings of joy.
|
The Conflict in Colossians in the Context of "Jewish-Christian“ Discourses of Identity
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Andrea Taschl-Erber, University of Graz
Studies on the concrete identification of the opponents in Colossians have led to a big amount of diverse proposals. Since many keywords in Col. 2 hint to classic Jewish identity markers such as circumcision, dietary laws, or Sabbath observance (which are similarly discussed in e.g. Justin’s Dialogue with Trypho), I suggest to view the conflict reflected in Colossians in the context of debates (re)defining boundary markers of identity. In this situation, the author of the epistle speaks with the borrowed (and at the same time fortified) authority of Paul as apostle by the will of God (1:1) and rewrites Pauline tradition, as the intertextual references to Galatians (“the elemental powers of the cosmos”) and Romans (see e.g. “eating and drinking” in 14:17) show, concerning the relevance of Torah practices for non-Jewish followers of Jesus. Searching for categories of identity that transcend ethnicity and classic borderlines between “circumcised and uncircumcised” (Col. 3:11), the author draws on and updates Pauline “body” language to establish “corporate” identity “in Christ” in a universal perspective. In the complex situation of interrelations and intersections of “Jews” and “Christians”, without definitive “parting of the ways” in the first century, the dissenting voices of a “philosophy” (2:8) with a competitive claim (devalued as “human tradition”, cf. Mark 7:8) in defining exclusive boundary markers do not refer primarily to “external” opponents (such as non-Christian Jewish synagogues). Rather, the rhetorical strategies in Colossians indicate “internal” disputes about the criteria for “sharing in the inheritance of the saints” (1:12). In this view, apocalyptic circles like that of Revelation, for example, which stresses strict observance of food laws (Rev. 2:14, 20) – and focuses on angels and visions of the divine throne (see Col. 2:18) –, could be seen as the other side of the coin regarding discourses of demarcation and identity.
|
Old Testament Parallels in the Literary Typology of the Ruler (Based on Examples from Medieval Slavonic Literatures)
Program Unit: Slavonic Parabiblical Traditions (EABS)
Iliana Chekova, Sofia University
The paper will be dealing with specific implementations of Biblical templates in depicting the image of the ruler in medieval Slavonic writings. The comparisons between the verbal portrayals of members of Slavonic royal families and some Old Testament characters will be analysed, with reference to narratives associated with Bulgarian, Russian and Serbian dynastic lineages. As a rule, the construction of the literary portrait of the statesman is based on his legitimation through association with Biblical forefathers, patriarchs, prophets and kings. Various literary sources will be taken into consideration (e.g. chronicles, hagiographic data, eulogies, church services, legendary narratives). With respect to male rulers (depicted either as positive, or negative characters), parallels are made with Adam, Cain and Abel, Abraham, Jacob, Moses, David and Solomon, Joseph, Samson, etc.; in the case of female members of the ruling dynasties, biblical templates employed include the images of Sarah, the Queen of Sheba, and others. Included in the discussion will be indigenous cults of some local rulers, along with the universal tendency of the sacralization of the ruler’s personality, along with the image of the “ideal ruler”. All these processes create a system of poetic symbols and literary topoi shaping the intellectual landscape of Slavia Orthodoxa.
|
The Materiality of the Iron Age Desert Cults and the Yahwistic Southern Home and Exodus/Patriarchal Traditions
Program Unit: Archaeological Fieldwork in the Bronze and Iron Age Levant (EABS)
Juan Manuel Tebes, Ruhr-Universität Bochum
Recent archaeological excavations in the arid southern regions south of Palestine and new interpretations of old epigraphic and iconographic evidence are rapidly changing the biblically based paradigm of the interactions between desert cults and Levantine religions in the Iron Age. In this paper I will explore and identify the configuration of the varied desert cultic practices in the Negev, southern Transjordan, and the Sinai during the Late Bronze and early Iron Ages. I will seek to understand how they might have contributed to the emergence of the Yahwistic cult and to the development of the Exodus and patriarchal narratives. I will analyze big historical questions concerning desert religions in the Late Bronze and Iron Ages. Was there something unique in the desert cults? How were religious experiences shaped by interactions between local rituals and sanctuary cults that penetrated from agricultural lands? More widely, what role did trade and cultural interconnections play in the diffusion of religious ideas? I will particularly explore how these data relate to those religious practices attested in Judah and Israel of the later Iron Age and beyond.
|
Re-appropriating Scripture for Cultural Transformation: Comparing the Allegorical Practices of Philo and Paul
Program Unit: Comparative Methodology (EABS)
Samuel Tedder, Finnish School of Theology (Suomen Teologinen Opisto)
I argue that a comparison between Philo and Paul enables a sharper analysis as to what is distinctive in each author’s allegorical practice, and what possibly accounts for it. Comparison also provides the analysis with new insights and avenues to explore that would otherwise be missed.
In my comparative analysis of the allegorical programmes of Philo and Paul, I begin by investigating what drives their allegorical practice and for what purpose it is done. I argue that in both cases the allegorical re-appropriation of scripture is predicated on a transformative understanding of divine revelation that stems from their own revelatory experience. Both Philo and Paul utilise allegory then for cultural transformation. Philo’s aim is to demonstrate that Hellenism is actually Jewish in order to guide his fellow (Hellenized) Jews towards a faithful practice of Judaism and prove to the Gentiles the intelligibility of the Jewish faith. Paul utilises allegory in Gal 4:21-5:1 to affirm that the Gentile believers in Christ are true heirs to the promises of Abraham, and to challenge conventional Jewish readings of the Abraham narrative to make room for Gentile inclusion without the requirement of them adopting a Jewish identity.
After observing how both manage the divergences and transformations of meaning from the literal to the allegorical, I conclude that Philo’s interpretation runs into a system that is more heterogeneous with the world of thought in the scriptures, whereas Paul’s is more homogeneous. Also, Philo’s allegoresis builds mainly on the details of the text, whereas Paul’s is interested in the overall context and content of the text. However, the main difference between Philo and Paul is in the role that intertextuality plays in their allegorical practice. It is essential for Paul’s allegoresis in Gal 4:21-5:1, whereas it is only corollary for Philo.
|
Reading 1 Samuel 28 and Odyssey 11 through the Lens of Shamanism
Program Unit: Anthropology and the Bible (EABS)
Hanna Tervanotko, McMaster University
In recent scholarship various divinatory practices of the ancient Israelites have been revised. Earlier it was assumed that the chief diviners were the prophets. Now a growing number of scholars see their function as a literary construct (e.g., Nissinen, “Prophecy as Construct, Ancient and Modern”). Consequently, what we actually know about various divinatory practices and the people involved in them including shamans are being questioned.
In this paper I will address necromancy as method that shamans practiced and analyze how the ancient Jewish literature attests to it. Necromancy is typically prohibited in the ancient Jewish literature (e.g., Deut 18:11; 2 Kgs 23:22, and the CD 12:1-5). Nonetheless, some passages suggest it was practiced despite the ban (Isa 29:4;1 Sam 28:8; Jannes and Jambres). After a diachronic reading of the Jewish texts I will turn to Odyssey 11, which contains a description of Odysseus’s descent to the netherworld. A female figure, Circe advices Odysseus to visit the underworld, where he meets Tiresias, a blind seer. My comparative reading of 1 Sam 28 and Od. 11 will provide new information on how necromancy and shamanism are depicted in ancient Jewish and Greek literature. Furthermore, I will ask whether gender of the necromancer (i.e., a shaman) plays any particular role in the narratives of 1 Sam 28 and Od. 11.
|
Towards an Annotated Edition of the Parables in the Tannaitic Midrashim: Relevance and New Insights
Program Unit: Parables in Rabbinic Judaism and Early Christianity: Towards a New Comparative Approach (EABS)
Lieve Teugels, Protestant Theological University Amsterdam
In this paper I will set out the rationale behind, and methodology applied, in my upcoming edition of the meshalim (parables) in the two tannaitic Midrashim to Exodus, the Mekhiltot. This edition intends to be the first in a series of editions of parables in all the tannaitic Midrashim (Sifre Numbers and Sifre Zuta; Sifra; Sifre Deuteronomy and the Mekhilta to Deuteronomy). Since these editions cover only sections of midrashic works, a full critical edition of only these section would not be meaningful. I have nevertheless looked for a way to present the relevant textual witnesses in a critical way and provide them with the necessary remarks and commentary. In the paper I will demonstrate the way these witnesses are presented, on the basis of some examples. I will also discuss some difficulties and the way these were overcome. Further I will put the project of these editions in the larger context of the Dutch research project “Parables and the Partings of the Ways” in which it is embedded, and set out its relevance for this project.
|
Is There a Unified Sense of Virtuous Character and Action in the Book of Haggai?
Program Unit: Virtue in Biblical Literature (EABS)
Jonathan Thambyrajah, University of Sydney
In the book of Haggai, there are various competing notions of virtue. Right action appears to be measured against two different standards. On the one hand, as prophecy, there is the sense of right action that derives from God’s intervention in natural events. God’s word through the prophet Haggai is taken to show the correct way in which to act in the given situation. On the other hand, at several points in the book, characters are told to determine what is right using their own mental faculties: the refrain ‘consider how you have fared’ and the directions to seek the priests’ judgment seem to imply that the audience is supposed to be able to determine the right course of action without God’s intervention. It is also difficult to get a sense of what character traits are considered virtuous, as different parties are singled out as either praiseworthy or blameworthy: however, the criteria on which these distinctions are made does not always appear to be moral categories. We are then left with the question: can we establish a unified sense of virtue from a text like Haggai?
|
See Trinity through the Fourth Gospel
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Florensia Theograsia, University of Newcastle, Australia
Living in a modern era, an era of empiric state of mind, sometimes it can be tricky to explain the meaning of Trinity to people who do not share the same faith and knowledge as practicing Christians. It is not easy either to explain the concept of Trinity to most Christians adequately. This is a faith-life challenge that needs to be faced and solved, as Trinity is a centre of Christian doctrines. In my enlightenment, it would work in a scholarly manner. Scholars can offer a new way in defining the concept of Trinity, not only theologically (or even sometimes spiritually) but also in a biblical way.
Scholarly, the Fourth Gospel is judged as a more Christocentric gospel, comparing to the Synoptics. In my judgement, it is then should be a clear tool to describe one of the three entities of Trinity. If the Father and the Son and the Spirit were one, we need a source, which clearly describes, at least, one of them in an adequate way. I found the Fourth Gospel as a record full of references to the concept of Trinity. The description of the three figures are not historical as in the Synoptics. The figures are more personified than in Synoptics. This is an advantage for a biblical study in defining the concept of Trinity. This paper is to show how the Fourth Gospel can be used to define the concept of Trinity in a scholarly manner.
|
Illicit Antiquities and Cultural Objects: Issues, Challenges, and Regulation
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Suzie Thomas, University of Helsinki
Illicit Antiquities and Cultural Objects: Issues, Challenges, and Regulation
Suzie Thomas, University of Helsinki
Cultural objects, particularly those considered “high status”, rare, or financially valuable, have forever been vulnerable to theft and illegal trade. These objects, including manuscripts, become particularly vulnerable in times of conflict or civil unrest, or in situations where there is economic pressure on societies to find alternative ways of generating more cash. We know that looters are often living in poverty, and are willing to sell objects that they can illegally excavate or steal from sites in order to survive. Yet at the same time the other end of the spectrum, where wealthy collectors and prestigious institutions admire, own and otherwise utilise the same cultural material, still seldom considers the dubious origins of many of their most prized pieces. In this presentation, I outline some of the key issues known about the illicit trade in cultural objects, the intellectual consequences of this trade, and the role that scholars can have either in facilitating or preventing such activity. Finally I discuss some of the measures in place to try to control the loss of cultural heritage in this manner, and why we still have some way to go.
|
Methods and Themes for the Palestine History and Heritage Project
Program Unit: Anthropology and the Bible (EABS)
Thomas Thompson, Københavns Universitet
This presentation will take up examples of methods and themes which illustrate narrative coherence and continuity of our history. Among the themes emphasized are 1) the importance of Palestine’s sub-regions to the development of a continuous historical narrative; 4) the relationship between Palestine’s Mediterranean economy and the millennia-long development and function of its enduring polity of patronage: 3) change and discontinuity of ethnic identities throughout Palestine’s history.
|
Parable or Prophecy?
Program Unit: Parables in Rabbinic Judaism and Early Christianity: Towards a New Comparative Approach (EABS)
Lauri Thurén, University of Eastern Finland
In the redactional reworking of the parables of Jesus, two major phases can be distinguished. Originally, a parable functions as a part of argumentation in a specific context. Irrespective of the authority of the speaker, the parable describes a plausible story or principle. It illustrates a general principle, which the audience in turn ought to apply to the issue discussed. Thus, for example, the parable told by the Sadducees in Luke 20:29–32 is a persuasive piece of argumentation, irrespective of its origin. At the first redactional stage, the type of function is preserved, even if the parable may be utilized in a new context, designed by the evangelist. Thus, Luke and Matthew may tell the same parable in their own contexts, but both still use it in the way described above. At the second redactional stage, however, the authority of the speaker becomes more important. The parable no longer functions as a narrative, illustrating a general principle. Instead, it becomes authoritative proclamation, which conveys religious ideas by using cover names. A shepherd taking care of his sheep directly describes God and his people. The credibility of this type of proclamation, traditionally called allegory, depends most of all on the credibility of the speaker. Thereby it functions as a prophecy. While a genuine parable appeals to emotions and reason only, a prophecy appeals to (divine) authority. The redactional process of the parables of Jesus shows a development from stage 1 (the evangelists) to stage 2 (the Early Fathers). I will argue that this is connected to the increasing divinity and authority of Jesus in the Christian communities. Accordingly, the parable of the Sadducees seldom if ever reached stage 2. The theory can be further used when analyzing the process of redacting and interpreting the parables.
|
Again about Adam’s Contract with Satan: The Romanian Manuscript Tradition of The Lamentation of Adam
Program Unit: Slavonic Parabiblical Traditions (EABS)
Emanuela Timotin, Institute of Linguistics of the Romanian Academy
The Slavonic and Romanian traditions of The Life of Adam and Eve narrate that after being cast away from paradise, Adam is prevented by Satan from working the land. Moreover, he is tricked into signing a contract through which he submits his offspring to Satan. This contract, a cheirograph, is hidden under a rock in the river Jordan, under demonic scrutiny. It will remain there until Christ breaks it, during his baptism. The theme can also be found in the iconography of medieval monasteries of northern Moldavia.
I could also identify it in numerous Romanian manuscripts of The Lamentation of Adam. This text, which gives a thorough description of Adam’s sorrow outside the lost paradise, is known in three recensions, two of which mention the episode when Adam signs the contract with Satan.
The present paper presents this manuscript tradition and analyses the variation of the theme of the cheirograph of Adam in respect both to the apocryphal Life of Adam and Eve, and to liturgy.
|
The Narative about Melchisedek in the Romanian Liturgical Tradition: Printed Books and Manuscripts
Program Unit: Rethinking Biblical Written Tradition through Slavonic Interpretations
Emanuela Timotin, Institute of Linguistics of the Romanian Academy
In his seminal book about Melchisedek (Geschichte Melchisedeks, 2010, p. 28), Christfried Böttrich discussed the existence of Romanian liturgical books printed between 1812 and 1863, which comprise a narrative about Melchisedek that was supposed to be read in a specific day of the Lent. This paper focuses on several contemporary manuscripts which comprise a similar narrative and which have never been analysed so far. It describes the relation between the printed and the manuscript traditions, it establishes the source of the narrative and its connection with other narratives about Melchisedek which were transmitted in Romanian (Palaea historica, the Pseudo-Athanasian Narrative), and it inquires whether the liturgical role of this narrative contributed to its transmission.
|
Moses and His Leprosy: Hebrew Bible, Rabbinic Texts and the Qur'an
Program Unit: Quran and Islamic Tradition in Comparative Perspective
Kate Tinson, Cardiff University
In the Hebrew Bible, Leprosy is often seen as the disease of God. Leprosy is associated with many scenes of sin and punishment; from Miriam to Uzziah. However, the leprosy that is most confusing is that of Moses in Exodus 4:6-7. This case is so small that it could go unnoticed. No explicit meaning for it is given in the Hebrew Bible which leaves Rabbinic commentators and others (Josephus, Philo, the LXX) space to interpret as they see fit in Haggadic and Halackic Midrash, Mishnah, translations and other works. What brings this scene again to our focus is the radically different portrayal it receives in the Qur’an. It is recounted more than once for the reader (in Q7, 20, 26 and 27) and in two separate scenes; one in its Hebrew Bible setting of the Burning Bush narrative and another of a meeting between Moses and Pharaoh and his Magicians (Exodus 7). Yet, the wording has been changed as to move the readers’ imagination from the idea of disease to one of light. In this presentation, I shall examine leprosy in the Hebrew Bible and in this specific case. Then I shall consider Rabbinic interpretations of this scene and that of Exodus 34 which considers a similar theme and finally the Qur’anic interpretation which can be tied to other concepts involving light in Islamic tradition.
|
Arabic and Islamic Elements in the Sa‘adia’s Biblical Translation and Commentary
Program Unit: The Bible in Arabic in Judaism, Christianity, Islam (EABS)
Yosef Yuval Tobi, University of Haifa
Sa‘adia Gaon contributed more than any other Jewish Sage to open the gates of Jewish culture to the Arabic culture, including his Biblical translation and commentary. Apart from using the high level of the classical Arabic language and its syntax and style, in contrast to the Biblical translations that preceded him, he was influenced also by principles of the tafsīr on the Qur’an. Moreover, he integrated in his commentary parallels from Arabic culture. Of particular interest is the alleged use of Islamic terms to translate words in the Bible, like imām for cohen (priest). However, based on the Biblical translations created before Sa‘adia’s, it should be concluded that Sa‘adia continued a translational tradition that was popular among the Arabic-speaking Jewish communities, a tradition that was absorbed – like many other Jewish traditions originating in these communities – as well in early Islam.
|
Contextualizing the Wisdom of Sirach in Slavia Orthodoxa
Program Unit: Slavonic Parabiblical Traditions (EABS)
Svetlina Nikolova, Cyrillo-Methodian Research Centre
The oldest Slavonic translation of the Book of Ben Sirach was accomplished along with the full translation of the Bible by one of the creators of the Slavonic alphabet, St. Methodius (and his disciples), between the years 882 and 884. Although the oldest Slavonic translation of the Bible has been repeatedly studied and published since the 19th century, only the texts of the New Testament and the Psalter have mainly been analyzed. The translations of other Old Testament books remain poorly studied, including the Book of Ben Sirach, part of the canonical biblical corpus of Slavia Orthodoxa, which is well preserved in Slavonic manuscript tradition – both in full texts and fragments, the earliest of which date from the 11th century. I have prepared an editio princeps of the full text of Methodius’ translation known to Orthodox Slavs. This short presentation analyzes the texts which are extant in the Slavonic medieval copies of the translation, from the period until the 15th century and their development after the initial translation. A comparison will be made between the full translation of Ben Sirach and the Septuagint text on which it is based, paying attention to some similarities in structure with the Hebrew text that has reached us in part. The oldest Slavonic translation, preserved in a Bulgarian manuscript from the 14th century, is similar to the so-called oldest Greek version G I, and is therefore useful for the study of the original text of the Book of Ben Sirach. An overview will be presented of the changes observed in Slavonic manuscript tradition of the translation before the 15th century. So far, this translation is unknown to biblical scholars not working in the field of Church Slavonic, and it should be included in the mainstream of research on early translations of the Old Testament.
|
Virtue in Abundance: Solomon as an Anti-hedonist Exemplar in Gregory of Nyssa’s Homilies on Ecclesiastes
Program Unit: Virtue in Biblical Literature (EABS)
Siiri Toiviainen, University of Helsinki
Of the wide array of biblical figures, King Solomon may not strike one as the obvious candidate to illustrate a virtuous attitude towards sensual pleasure. While in early Jewish and Christian texts Solomon is frequently depicted as an exemplary sage, accounts of his immense wealth and marriages to foreign women have also cast doubts on his moral qualities. However, in his Homilies on Ecclesiastes, Gregory of Nyssa, a fourth-century Christian author, makes a somewhat surprising choice to present Solomon as a paragon of anti-hedonism. Like many ancient interpreters, Gregory reads the homilies as Solomon’s retrospective account of his own life. But whereas most interpreters portray Solomon as something of a repentant sinner, for Gregory the Solomon of the Book of Ecclesiastes is a virtuous man who carries out a carefully designed experiment: by making use of his immense wealth and his characteristic virtue of wisdom, Solomon has a disciplined encounter with pleasure to prove first-hand its shortcomings as the final good. To undertake this challenge, Solomon hardens himself with a rigorous training programme. Thus, although the king’s authority is created by his unique social location, exceptional wisdom, and unusual first-hand experience, he is also presented as an example for all Christians to emulate. While Solomon’s exemplary role in the Homilies on Ecclesiastes has been previously noted in passing, little has been said about its specific emphases. In this paper, my aim is to analyse Gregory’s use of Solomon as an example of a deliberate and disciplined attitude towards pleasure and of the rigorous training it entails. I will argue, furthermore, that Gregory’s use of Solomon as an example should be read in the context of a fundamental juxtaposition between pleasure and virtue that underpins his whole corpus.
|
Pleasure Isn’t Always about Sex: Gregory of Nyssa on Genesis 3 as a Hedonist Error
Program Unit: Bodies of Communication (EABS)
Siiri Toiviainen, University of Helsinki
Numerous recent accounts of early Christian and Jewish receptions of the story of Genesis 3 have focussed, in particular, on matters of gender and sexuality. Often, the conclusion has been that for ancient interpreters the crux of the story is a breakdown of sexual integrity instigated by the woman who is overcome by her sensual drives. While this is undoubtedly often the case, in this paper I suggest that the widespread interest in matters of gender and sexuality may leave unattended interpretations of famously “gendered” passages – such as the biblical account of the fall – that do not centre on these issues.
I will take as my example Gregory of Nyssa’s reading of Genesis 3 in De hominis opificio. The same work also contains an interpretation of the creation of Adam and Eve, which has received plenty of scholarly attention. It has been argued, for example, that Gregory “waxes eloquent” about prelapsarian celibacy to defend his agenda of virginity. From this perspective, it would seem likely that the subsequent interpretation of the fall would correspondingly entail a breakdown of sexual discipline. However, we find nothing of the sort. This is particularly surprising since Gregory conceptualises Genesis 3 in terms of a hedonist error. But while Eve is driven by pleasure, Gregory makes no suggestion of the specifically sexual or gendered nature of her transgression. For him, at the heart of the story lies the enticing fruit which gives a false impression of being good by tricking Eve’s senses of sight and taste.
I will go on to suggest that throughout Gregory’s corpus the problem of pleasure is a broad aesthetic problem that is more akin to materialism and idolatry than sexual debauchery. For him, sexual pleasure is simply one of the many manifestations of sensual pleasure and rarely its paradigmatic form.
|
The Characterization of the Royal Official in the Fourth Gospel
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
D. Francois Tolmie, University of the Free State
This paper begins with a detailed overview of studies on the characterization of the royal official in John 4:43-54. This overview shows that the text does not provide readers with enough clues to obtain a precise picture of the official, and that the choices that they have to make have a decisive impact on the picture of the official that emerges as they read along, a picture depending just as much on what the text explicitly states as on what they assume. Accordingly, the five most important decisions that readers have to take are outlined with all the possible options identified. These are: the specific approach to be followed, the meaning and relevance of vv. 43–45 for the characterisation of the official, the dominant trait(s) to be associated with the concept basilikos, making sense of Jesus’s response in v. 48 and making sense of the twofold reference to the faith of the official in the narrative. Finally, an own interpretation of the royal official is offered that is closely linked to death/life contrast in the narrative.
|
Beyond Reason? The "Manliness" of the Mother in 4 Maccabees
Program Unit: Virtue in Biblical Literature (EABS)
Anna-Liisa Tolonen, University of Helsinki
One of the central virtues examined in 4 Maccabees is courage. First, an aged priest, then seven brothers from the eldest to the youngest, and, finally, the boys’ mother demonstrate the mastery of diverse pains and fears by courage and thereby the supremacy of pious reasoning – reasoning in accordance with law and philosophy. As the mother is ”proven more powerful than a man” (4 Macc 16:14), and as the Greek word ”courage” (andreia) is semantically linked to the word ”man” (aneer), it has been claimed that the mother crosses the boundaries of her gender, becoming the manliest example of them all and, ultimately, a ”truer” man than men. I argue, however, that the mother’s abundant sacrifices do not include her gendered being; in contrast, she gives the most striking demonstration of courage precisely by not being, nor becoming, a man. Her performance of courage transcends manliness, while she does not break from her woman- and motherhood. A parallel story of the mother and her seven sons in the late antique rabbinic commentary, Lamentations Rabbah, which I read as a response to the story and the ideals told in 4 Maccabees, supports the argument: in it, too, the ideal of courage, as well as the notion of rationality, are negotiable when the mother’s subjectivity and authority are fully displayed.
|
High Priest of the Temple in Jerusalem and the Mosaic Identity of Hellenistic Jews
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Sladana Mirkovic, University of South Florida
In this paper I attempt to show how the Moses and the Plagues narrative in Greek language (Exodus 7-11) become the foundational story of the Temple of Jerusalem. I should argue that during early Greek period (with the beginning ca.200 BCE on), the High Priest of the Temple in Jerusalem intentionally selected the Plagues on the Egyptians tradition and related it the Moses tradition in order to mediate identity to His community. Subsequently the priests developed the Mosaic discourse in the Greek language as it is found in excerpts such as Ezekiel, Artapanos, Demetrios, and Eupolmos. As a matter of fact this type of Mosaic literature should be called the priestly exercise in the Greek language. This priestly exercise resulted in the production of the Septuagint account on the Moses and the Plagues on the Egyptian. The trajectory of formation and transformation of Temple Mosaic discourse will be suggested.
|
Slavic Studies and Wissenschaftliche Approach to the Bible
Program Unit: Rethinking Biblical Written Tradition through Slavonic Interpretations
Sladana Mirkovic, University of South Florida
This paper is a selected survey of the research methods in the History of Religion/s Schools (Religiongeschichtliche Schule) as it pertains to biblical criticism since the late 18th up to the last quarter of 20th century. The methodology of its most influential representatives in biblical scholarship: Hermann Gunkel (1862-1932) and Sigmund Mowinckel (1884-1965) will be examined. I will discuss the influence of the exegetical principles of the Religionsgeschichtliche Schule, such as radical historical approach, comparative examination, sociological analysis, and psychological investigation, on the Slavic Studies. This influence will be demonstrated on the interpretation of the early Slavic narrative and visual cultural heritage.
|
Focus Up! Focus Structure as a Literary Feature
Program Unit: Literary Features – Fact or Fiction (EABS)
Diana Tomingas, Tartu Ülikool
Focusing is a literary feature that has gathered surprisingly little attention. This is often due to its positioning in the well-researched realm of Biblical Hebrew Syntax and the wide array of meaning it has obtained.
However, when combining the information structure model, specifically constituent focus, and the strict nature of Biblical Hebrew word-order which allows all deviations from unmarked word-order to stand out, it becomes possible to analyse and re-assess the purposes and literary functions of some of these deviations. My paper proposes to do this by looking at focusing - a feature that for a long time was cast aside from further necessary research as the sole purpose of the feature was considered to be “emphasizing” - a verdict much too superficial while also regretfully lacking in precise meaning. Luckily several noteworthy monographs have alleviated the situation in the recent years (Heimerdinger, Shimasaki, Lunn, Moshavi). Although these scholars have finally brought focus structures to the table, marked constituent preposing has not been discussed as a literary feature in its own right. Armed with Adina Moshavi’s typology (developed using Biblical prose examples of constituent focus in her brilliant book pub. in 2010 “Word order in Biblical Hebrew Finite Clause”) I will delve into both prose and poetic text (the books of Job and Ben Sira in particular) and aim to establish a modified system appropriate for assessing the types of constituent focus found in biblical poetry, compare it to the existing information Moshavi has provided on focusing in biblical prose texts and establish an overview of the literary functions of this feature. The purpose of this paper is to expand on the effect focusing has on, respectively prose and poetic, text and the change in meaning it holds for the reader when compared to unmarked word order.
|
Illuminating Syntactic Seams
Program Unit: Diachronic Poetology of the Hebrew Bible and Related Ancient Near Eastern and Ancient Jewish Literature (EABS)
Diana Tomingas, Tartu Ülikool
Poetic texts in the Old Testament are known for the complexity of their features - stylistically, literally, and syntactically. No stranger to this is the elusive book of Job, where an additional layer of complexity is added by the sheer amount of redactional layers identified throughout the text. Several birds can be killed with one stone, though, when the challenges posed by a multitude of editorial inputs and the reassessment of certain syntactic features are combined. A syntactic feature that has not been investigated for this purpose yet seems intriguingly appropriate for the task at hand is constituent focus. The term, which came into wider linguistic attention as “argument focus” in the 1990s with K. Lambrecht’s revolutionizing book, Information Structure and Sentence Form has received prominent attention and a greatly clarifying taxonomy by Adina Moshavi (in her 2010 book, Word Order in Biblical Hebrew Clause) that has allowed a new approach to what can be achieved when this function is analyzed in the context of different redactional layers. The aim of my paper is to analyze the constituent focus structures of the book of Job t to discover new datapoints to illuminate the seams of particular redactional layers.
|
Fables, Parables, Allegories: Ancient Border-Crossing Stories
Program Unit: Parables in Rabbinic Judaism and Early Christianity: Towards a New Comparative Approach (EABS)
Peter J. Tomson, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
‘Folk themes, figures of speech, and entire proverbs migrate across geographical and cultural boundaries by routes which are often impossible to trace or document.’
(J.M. Lindenberger, ‘Ahiqar’, in Charlesworth, OTP 2: 486)
1. Fables and Parables in the Ancient Near East and Greece.
Multiple links between the Aramaic Story of Ahikar, Jewish Wisdom Writings, the Greek fables of Aesop, and ancient Jewish parables.
2. The Evolution of Rabbinic Judaism.
Rabbinic Judaism, originated after the Jewish Revolt, came to fill the void left by the destruction of the Temple. New forms of prayer and liturgy were introduced, Tora study became the central socio-religious value. The process of change was triggered by the Jewish-Roman war of 66-70 CE and strongly accelerated after the one of 132-136.
3. The formal separation of Christianity from Judaism.
Tacitus on Christians after the fire of Rome, Pliny the Younger on Christians in Asia Minor, Tosefta Hullin on forbidden links with Christians, Gospel of John on excommunication of Christians: formal separation, early second century CE.
4. Beyond the Separation: Parallel Developments among Jews and Christians.
Example 1: the exposition of the Song of Songs in Judaism and Christianity.
Example 2: the evolvement of the Lord’s Prayer and the Eighteen Benedictions.
5. Parables in Judaism and Christianity.
Comparison of selected examples of parable clusters (‘families’) as used by rabbis and church fathers: parables in midrash and of parables as allegories.
|
"A Stop to That Rageing Spirit of Atheism" or "Je Suis Thomas"? Thomas Aikenhead’s Bible and the Formation of a Secular Hero
Program Unit: Bible and Its Influence: History and Impact
Samuel Tongue, University of Glasgow
Thomas Aikenhead was executed on 8th January 1697, the last person in Britain to be sentenced to death for blasphemy. His accusers claimed that, among other blasphemous utterances, he had condemned the scriptures as “so stuffed with maddness, nonsense, and contradictions, that [he] admired the stupidity of the world in being soe long deluded by them” and that he had “lykwayes in discourse preferred Mahomet to the blessed Jesus” and “hoped to see Christianity greatly weakened.” This paper analyses Aikenhead’s trial as a test case for the media performance of blasphemy and what this might mean for formations of ‘the modern’ (Asad, 2008) at two different socio-political junctures: (1) the ‘Great Noise’ that this case of ‘articulate irreligion’ (Hunter, 1992) made in Scottish and London newspapers at the time and (2) the afterlife of Aikenhead’s ‘atheism’ in two recent novels – Doubting Thomas (2017) and Unspeakable (2017) – and a play – ‘I am Thomas: A Brutal Comedy with Songs’ (2016). By studying the reportage and performance of Aikenhead’s blasphemy, particularly around the question of criticising the Bible and (Presbyterian) religion, in both the 17th and 21st centuries, I will demonstrate how his resurrection in contemporary literature continues to deploy and reassert ideas of the self-owning liberal subject as a free-speech martyr, executed in the name of tolerance and acceptance. I shall trace how Aikenhead is co-opted along the lines of Talal Asad’s ‘secular hero’ to the extent that the phrase ‘Je Suis Thomas’ becomes a constant refrain to buttress the secular against the irruption of inarticulate religion.
|
The Return of the King: An Eschatological Challenge to the Empire
Program Unit: Bible and Empire
Sydney Elise Tooth, University of Edinburgh
Among the Pauline letters, 1 and 2 Thessalonians are the most eschatologically focused. In fact, the main purpose of both epistles is to address eschatological issues within the Thessalonian community. This paper argues that the eschatologies presented in both epistles inherently challenge the dominate political powers. Both accounts make ample use of terms and images with imperial connotations, such as “parousia” and “apantesis”, as well as the slogan “peace and security” in 1 Thessalonians 4 and 5 and the depiction of the “apostasia” and “the man of lawlessness” in 2 Thessalonians 2. The use of these evocative terms and images within the eschatological framework of the letters will be explored. This paper argues that both eschatologies indicate those loyal to the Empire rather than to the true Lord, Jesus, will be destroyed on the day of the Lord, when the true king returns. Furthermore, this paper argues that the eschatologies of the two letters encourage faithfulness and perseverance, rather than active resistance to the ruling powers, urging the Thessalonians to trust God’s word that justice will be served in the end.
|
2 Sam 15:34-37: Two Different Texts and Two Different Stories
Program Unit: Septuagint of Historical Books (EABS)
Pablo A. Torijano, Universidad Complutense de Madrid
The text of LXXBL has in v. 34 a “plus” regarding MT: διεληλύθασιν οἱ ἀδελφοί σου καὶ ὁ βασιλεὺς κατόπισθέν μου διελήλυθεν ὁ πατήρ σου καὶ νῦν. ("Your brothers have passed through, and the king your father (LXXL) has passed through behind me, and now"). The Antiochean text has in v. 35 a “plus” regarding MT and LXXB (kaige) where the same text of v. 34 is reproduced (without καὶ νῦν).
In v. 34 MT continues with the text עַבְדְּךָ אֲנִי הַמֶּלֶךְ אֶהְיֶה עֶבֶד אָבִיךָ וַאֲנִי מֵאָז וְעַתָּה וַאֲנִי עַבְדֶּךָ ("I will be your servant, O king; as I have been your father's servant in time past, so I will now be your servant"). Instead of this Masoretic text, LXXBL have the text παῖς σού εἰμι βασιλεῦ ἔασόν με ζῆσαι παῖς τοῦ πατρός σου ἤμην τότε καὶ ἀρτίως καὶ νῦν ἐγὼ δοῦλος σός ("I am your servant , O King, permit me to live; I was a servant of your father in the past and recently, and now I am a servant of yours'.").
This paper proposes to analyze the variants of each text (including those of Jacob of Edessa) and study the textual filiation of each one, with the aim of identifying the kaige text and the pre-Lucianic / OG text. Finally, the Hebrew Vorlage of LXX and the MT will be compared. Further examination discovers two different narrative threads in chaps15-17.
|
The Ambiguity and Liminality of the Mediterranean Sea in Ancient Semitic Mythology
Program Unit: Ugarit and the Bible: Life and Death (EABS)
Joanna Töyräänvuori, Helsingin Yliopisto - Helsingfors Universitet
The god of the Sea in Ugaritic texts is Yamm, adversary of the Storm god Baal, infamous as the antagonist in the Ugaritic Baal Cycle. Like the sea itself, its god displayed an inherent ambivalence: he was a source of life and death, the provider of bounty and the cause of wreckage, the master of monsters and the protector of domesticated beasts, especially horses that are connected to the god of the sea in multiple ways. Depicted in Syrian iconography as a winged deity, Yamm was capable of traversing the distance between his two watery realms: the sea surrounding the earth and the sea on top of the dome of the sky. Yamm had a dichotomous character, borne in part out of the element of the sea itself. For all its ambiguity, Yamm as a symbol of the Mediterranean sea was immensely important to the coastal kingdoms.
|
“We Have Become a Spectacle to the World": Gladiators and Other Entertainers as Marginal Groups in the Graeco-Roman Cities
Program Unit: Graeco-Roman Society and the New Testament (EABS)
Ekaterini Tsalampouni, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki
In 1 Cor 4:9 Paul describes his situation as an apostle with a strong metaphorical language inspired by the world of public spectacle in the Graeco-Roman world (either the gladiatorial contests or even the procession of a Roman triumph). The images he uses stress the marginality of his apostolic existence and the ambivalence of his status. In order to fully appreciate his rhetorical strategy in this passage it is necessary to look into the world of gladiators and other kinds of entertainers in the Graeco-Roman cities and explore the ambiguities of their lives. Material evidence, like inscriptions and iconography, will provide the necessary data in this research. In the first part of the paper the methodological presuppositions of a survey of ancient marginality on the basis of our material will be discussed. In the second part the concrete evidence regarding these particular social groups will be presented. Finally, in the last part connections will be made between the social and historical circumstances of these groups and Paul's metaphorical discourse in 1 Cor 4.
|
"Buen Vivir" and Its Possible Ecological Relevance: A Biblical Approach
Program Unit: The Bible and Ecology (EABS)
Ekaterini Tsalampouni, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki
This paper dialogues with the concept of Buen Vivir (Sumak kawsay) and its relevance in the global, interdisciplinary approach to respond to ecological concerns. In particular, this paper will explore the points of possible intersections as well as limitations of Buen Vivir from a biblical perspective.
|
What is the Text, Work, and Composition of Serekh ha-Yaḥad?
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
James M. Tucker, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
In his The Untold Story of Qumran, James Trever recounts the earliest events of the Dead Sea Scrolls discovery. In the process of his narrative, two important observations can be made. The first observation is that 1Q28 (which Trever initially called Jerusalem Scroll #1) was brought to him in two pieces, and he later joined these two pieces to make the eleven columns of 1Q28 (1QS). This explains why Trever never photographed 1Q28a or 1Q28b. The second observation is that, by implication, Trever never saw 1Q28a or 1Q28b physically attached to 1Q28, and he even posits that they were separated in antiquity, by Second Temple Jewish scribes. What evidence can be found to demonstrate that these three scrolls (viz., the modern categorized 1Q28, 1Q28a, and 1Q28b) did indeed exist as one scroll? If they did exist as one scroll, who separated them? Were they separated by Second Temple Jewish scribes/tradents, or were they separated sometime after their 1947 discovery? What is more, how does this evidence—what makes the text of this scroll—change and influence our modern ideas about the literary notion of the work or composition of Serekh ha-Yaḥad? In the history of scholarship pertaining to Serekh ha-Yaḥad, these questions have not been thoroughly addressed. In this paper, I provide analyze and provide an answer to these questions.
|
Continuity and Change: A Historical Perspective on the Assessment of Septuagint Jeremiah as a Textual Witness
Program Unit: Septuagint Studies
Miika Tucker, University of Helsinki
Text critical assessments of Septuagint Jeremiah (Jer LXX) have been made as early as the time of Origen (184–254 CE), and have at times been very contradictory in comparison to one another. A crucial lynchpin in such assessments is the understanding of the character of the translation. It is only natural to discuss the translational and text critical character of Jer LXX together, but oftentimes, especially in early assessments, the two are not clearly distinguished from each other. A pivotal threshold in this regard was the incorporation of the Dead Sea Scroll evidence, which shifted the text critical discussion more desicively toward the Vorlage of Jer LXX and solidified the determination of the translation character as a valuable pursuit in it own right. This paper surveys assessments of Jer LXX, ranging from the 19th century to the present, with the aim of highlighting the continuity and change that can be seen resulting from the availability of the Dead Sea Scroll evidence.
|
Verse Metrics: Analyzing Manuscript Families Using String Comparison Techniques with a Test Case in the Arabic Gospels
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the New Testament, the Old Testament and the Qur’an (EABS)
Robert Turnbull, Ridley College Melbourne
Grouping manuscripts into families is an important initial step towards the study of their texts. As the numbers of manuscripts and families grow, it becomes increasingly difficult for the researcher to compare the text of each manuscript with every other one under consideration. This situation is further complicated when some manuscripts show evidence of mixing between families. This paper presents a method for storing verse transcriptions into a database which can then be compared between manuscripts using string metric algorithms to quantitatively express the similarity between them. This paper explores how this method can be used to distinguish different families of texts and as well as the variation within families in order to explore transmission history and the generation of stemmata. As a test case, the various families of the Arabic Gospels as surveyed by Hikmat Kashouh are used to probe the method with both its limitations and benefits.
|
Arabic Gospel Lectionaries at Jerusalem
Program Unit: The Bible in Arabic in Judaism, Christianity, Islam (EABS)
Robert Turnbull, Ridley College Melbourne
The majority of extant Arabic Gospel lectionary manuscripts in the Melkite tradition are at St. Catherine’s at Sinai and the Orthodox Patriarchal library in Jerusalem. Recently the Arabic Gospel lectionaries in St. Catherine’s at Sinai were grouped into twelve distinct families. This present paper extends this survey to include the manuscripts at Jerusalem. The dates of the lectionaries in the Sinai collection range from 10th to the 17th centuries, with the majority in the 13th century, whereas those in the Jerusalem collection range from the 11th to the 19th centuries with the mean in the 16th century. The lectionaries at Jerusalem, therefore, make a complementary contribution to those at Sinai, giving witness to later stages in the history of how the Bible in Arabic was experienced in Christian worship down the centuries. Some of the lectionaries at Jerusalem are of the same families as what was found at St. Catherine’s, including two manuscripts which include texts derived from the earliest translations of the Gospels from Greek into Arabic. Other lectionaries at Jerusalem have no parallels with those in the Sinai collection and are grouped into new distinct families.
|
The Textual Transmission of Law and Narrative in Exodus: A Statistical Comparison
Program Unit: Editorial Techniques in the Hebrew Bible in Light of Empirical Evidence (EABS)
Megan Turton, University of Sydney
Scribal editorial processes and techniques have long been detected and conjectured within the received form of the Hebrew Bible -predominantly the Masoretic Text- and the biblical laws are no exception. Studies abound on how discrete law collections are the products of complicated redactional processes whereby core laws are edited, revised, elaborated upon, and sometimes drastically reorganised. Furthermore, an ongoing trend in scholarship maintains that a law collection may also be largely created through the revision of older legal traditions. These studies indicate that substantial scribal intervention and reformulation was characteristic of the ancient Israelite legal traditions as they were passed on through time. However, although they certainly exist, fewer studies substantiate these claims by reference to the evidence provided by the scribal transmission of the biblical laws extant in the various textual witnesses of the late Second Temple period. This is despite the increasing recognition that a hard distinction between the scribal production of the biblical books and their subsequent transmission cannot be maintained. Conversely, in the field of textual criticism, some scholars maintain that the laws in transmission are more stable than narrative texts, and that their variants are more tightly constrained because of the binding nature of the biblical laws. Thus, this paper seeks to provide a statistical comparison between the amount of textual variation that occurs in select legal and narrative portions of the book of Exodus. Such a study illuminates both the degree and quality of variants that occur in these narrative and legal texts, and paves the way for further study on the extent and nature of biblical law editorial processes.
|
Raz and Riqma: Changing the Community Rules
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Shani Tzoref, Universität Potsdam
This paper explores the communal structures and values within Qumran Studies that have led us to enable and ignore the large-scale unprofessional and criminal conduct that is coming to light with respect to the post-2002 "Fishy Fragments." Presuming the innocence of the majority of scholars in our discipline, this paper posits that our longstanding non-responsiveness to the fraud was not the result of an absence or abandonment of values. Rather, it is suggested that our passivity was in fact due to a surfeit of values-- of a sort that proved unequal to the task at hand. Using Moral Foundations Theory as a framework for analyzing our communal failure, it is argued that-- until recently-- the In-Group values of Loyalty and Authority have been privileged by Qumran scholars over the more universalistic-type values of Care/Harm and Fairness/Cheating. It is further argued that our discipline is particularly vulnerable to misuse of Haidt's and Graham's fifth category, Sanctity. With particular reference to the academia.edu discussions that paved the way for public revelation, this paper demonstrates how the privileging of "privacy" (raz/secrecy) over Transparency, and excessive "humility" (riqma/deference to hierarchy) has prevented us from fulfilling our obligations as critical thinkers, educators, and curators of the past and its artefacts. A prescriptive position is taken in support of increasing the relative weight given to the values of care and fairness in our Community ethos.
|
Socio-historical Clues of Editorial Revision in Variant Literary Editions
Program Unit: Developing Exegetical Methods (EABS)
Eugene Ulrich, University of Notre Dame
The Dead Sea Scrolls have brought to light variant literary editions of many biblical books. Do the various manuscripts - the Scrolls, the MT, the SP, the LXX, or others - offer clues to the creative scribes or specific groups who produced the new forms? This paper explores whether there are clues in the revised editions that might help in understanding which of the various religious groups produced them and what the motivations (if any) for revision were - literary, pedantic, theological, or sectarian?
|
Apparel Metaphor in the Book of Revelation
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible (EABS)
Beata Urbanek, Uniwersytet Slaski w Katowicach
The authors of the Bible are rarely interested in people’s appearance. There is only occasional, detailed information about someone’s apparel. Clothes in general are mentioned quite often, and sometimes, what one wears has a symbolic meaning, as in the book of Revelation, in which the imagery connected to garments creates a whole chain of metaphors. Because of that, the numerous places depicting clothing should not be analyzed as individual cases but as interwoven metaphors. Applying a cognitive linguistic approach, I will argue that the conceptual metaphor underlying this network of metaphors is IDENTITY IS APPAREL. The paper will explore the mapping between the source and the target domains and then investigate how the clothing metaphors conceptualize the characters of the book of Revelation.
|
Ritual, Ecology and Biblical Traditions
Program Unit: The Biblical World and Cultural Evolution (EABS)
Risto Uro, University of Helsinki
The aim of this paper is to take first steps toward developing a cultural evolution approach which draws on ritual theory and builds a bridge between two related areas, ecological anthropology and more recent developments in the evolutionary and cognitive study of religion. The key question in ecological ritual studies is to ask, how rituals can function as mechanisms (“technologies”, if you like) by means of which human cultures adapt to and interact with their natural environment. This issue was raised fifty years ago by Roy Rappaport in his seminal Pigs for the Ancestors (1968) and is relevant in the context of more recent theorizing on the evolutionary and cognitive roots of ritual using findings, for example, in embodied cognition, cooperation studies, and niche construction theory. The paper offers a very tentative model of ritual and ecology for discussion.
How to apply an ecologically-informed ritual approach to biblical traditions? The paper argues that at least three general criteria have to be met: Biblical scholars must be ready 1) to adopt population thinking and not focus merely on particular texts and historical contexts; 2) to realize that “societies evolve in response to changes in their natural and social environments” (G. Lensky, italics added), in other words, they must be willing to abandon their one-sided focus on socio-cultural factors; and 3) to recognize and define the role of ritual in the evolution of human societies and religions, including biblical religions and societies, as part of the larger nature – culture co-evolution.
|
Is There ‘Virtue’ in Semitic texts? An Analysis of the Testament of Qahat
Program Unit: Virtue in Biblical Literature (EABS)
Elisa Uusimäki, Helsingin Yliopisto - Helsingfors Universitet
Can the category of ‘virtue’ be associated with the Testament of Qahat (4Q542), although the text is written in a Semitic language that lacks a separate term for it? This paper addresses both problems and benefits that pertain to discussing the selected Aramaic writing in the context of virtue. Concentrating on the intersection between the transmission of biblical tradition and the display of ancestral virtue, it argues that morally valuable conduct is attributed to characters of the Israelite narrative in 4Q542. The author employs biblical figures of the past in general and the figure of Qahat in particular as he exhorts the intended audience to pursue good behaviour. As such, the Testament of Qahat witnesses to the variety of discourses concerning good life in the Mediterranean antiquity.
|
Frozen Canaanite Letters as Symbols in the Hebrew Script of the First Temple Period
Program Unit: Northwest Semitic Epigraphy Related to the Biblical World (EABS)
Daniel Vainstub, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
The Hebrew script in use in the kingdoms of Israel and Judah has two supplementary sets of signs. The first one is the well-known set of frozen hieratic numerals. The second is a relatively rich group of signs prominently present mainly in ostraca like those found in Arad, Kuntillet Ajrud, etc., but also engraved in ceramic vessels. The only sign in this group whose meaning is unanimously accepted is the shekel symbol. Tentative interpretations of other signs offered by Y. Aharoni were never proved, and the origin of the signs remained unknown, as their proposed borrowing from the hieratic script seems very inconclusive.
In my opinion some of these signs –including the shekel symbol– developed from Canaanite letters and were used acrophonically for measuring units of volume, weight, length, quality, etc. These frozen letters continued to serve as supplementary signs in the Hebrew script, even though at times some of them did not have anymore Hebrew counterparts because of the reduction of the Canaanean alphabet to 22 letters.
|
Mesopotamian Parallels and Eleventh Chapter of the Book of Daniel
Program Unit: Comparative Methodology (EABS)
Kaisa Vaittinen, Helsingin Yliopisto - Helsingfors Universitet
Mesopotamian cuneiform text form an important source of parallels for Old Testament texts. The nature of these parallels and the significance of these texts to Biblical studies has been discussed from different viewpoints from Bibel-Babel controversy to parallelomania. The 11th chapter in the Book of Daniel is one of the texts in Old Testament that has been often discussed in the context of parallels and the usage of parallels. There is a group of Mesopotamian texts that does resemble the Old Testament text in many ways. The question with these texts is that do they bring any more understanding to the text in the Book of Daniel and what is the real relationship with these texts?
There are several viable proposals for this relationship of the Mesopotamian texts and that of the Book of Daniel but the thing that has been rather sparsely discussed is the meaning of the connection and the formal criteria for proposing one between different texts from different eras. The main aim in this presentation is to discuss on the possible formal criteria for the connection between the texts and especially the possible meanings of these connections or relationships.
|
Colours and Precious Stones in the Greek Bible: ὁ λίθος ὁ πράσινος in Gen 2:12
Program Unit: The Language of Colour in the Bible: From Word to Image (EABS)
Emanuela Valeriani, Université de Genève
Expressions and terms used in the Bible to describe colours do not exactly correspond to the nomenclature of modern tables. Biblical writers used to give the idea of colour through the context or comparing less-known objects with well-known ones. In detail ,the appearance of substances and / or common elements such as blood, snow, fire or precious stones were used as a reference to describe a certain colour. Several studies have been dedicated to the presence of precious stones in the Bible, to their respective colours and to the possible symbolic meanings of the text, but little attention has been given to the greek version of Genesis 2:12 that describes the riches of the land of Havilah among which there are gold and precious stones. Not all the translations and commentaries of the book of Genesis identify the expression ὁ λίθος ὁ πράσινος with the same type of stone, since the interpretation of the colour tone of πράσινοςi s uncertain. This adjective in classical Greek is used - generally - to indicate a precise shade of green, but in the greek Bible the range of "green" is repeatedly attested through the adjective χλωρός and its lexical family or through the reference to the emerald (σμάραγδος / σμαραγδίτης).
Therefore, starting from the consideration that in the LXX and in the New Testament the names of many precious stones are widely used, while Gn 2,12 is the only passage in which the adjective πράσινος appears referred to the chromatic tonality of a precious stone of which - instead - the name isn’t specified, I’ll analyse the chromatic value of this adjective in order to identify what kind of stone the greek translator refers to and why πράσινος is used to translate the hebrew term “שׁהם”.
|
The Resurrection of the Dead in the First Apocryphal Apocalypse of John
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
Emanuela Valeriani, Université de Genève
The eleventh chapter of the so-called First apocryphal Apocalypse of John presents a peculiar doctrine of resurrection according to which all the resurrected will have the age of thirty and, with the exception of the righteous, they will not be able to recognize themselves among brothers, friends, fathers and sons since their appearance will be like that of bees that has no traits that make it possible to distinguish them. In fact, according to the author of this apocalypse, men will be resurrected without the material body. The present contribution will compare this text, both with the twenty-second chapter of the Quaestiones ad Antiochum Ducem where it is said that souls will rise without bodies and are compared to doves and bees, both with the text of another Apocalypse always attributed to John the Theologian and consisting of a series of questions and answers, between the apostle and Abraham, on the theme of resurrection. This is an unpublished text of which, at the moment, only one Greek manuscript is known and whose doctrinal position is very similar to that of the First apocryphal Apocalypse of John because it is stated that men will rise without the body, all of them will be thirty years old and, like the bees, they will all look the same. Although the uncertain origin and dating of these works does not make it possible to establish whether there is effectively a contact between them, I’ll try to determine whether the theme of the incorporeal resurrection in the First apocryphal Apocalypse of John is a reference to a theological controversy related to the current situation or whether it is a restatement of a Byzantine Theologumenon in order to find out an internal element of the text that can be taken into account for its dating.
|
Aapeli Saarisalo and Biblical Archaeology
Program Unit: History of Biblical Scholarship in the Late Modern Period
Kirsi Valkama, Helsingin Yliopisto - Helsingfors Universitet
Aapeli Saarisalo (1896–1986) was a Doctor of Theology and professor of Oriental Languages at the University of Helsinki. He conducted a survey in Galilee in the 1920s. He wrote his dissertation The boundary between Issachar and Naphtali: an archaeological and literary study of Israel's settlement in Canaan (1927) based on the survey material, discussing the topographic names of the area. In this paper, I will discuss his archaeological interests in the Near East. He participated in several excavations in the Near East and supervised an excavation at Kafr Qama. Saarisalo was a devout conservative Christian and his orientation to archaeology followed the traditional form of biblical archaeology. His conservative interpretation of the Bible caused dispute in the Faculty of Theology and he oriented towards linguistics. He was well appreciated among the members of the Finnish Lutheran Church and published dozens of books and newspaper articles aimed at the general public about biblical history and his own excavation experiences. As a prolific writer he made the field well-known to the wider public in Finland.
|
The Book of Malachi and the Transformation of Deuteronomic Concepts of Righteousness/Virtue
Program Unit: Virtue in Biblical Literature (EABS)
Lotta Valve, Abo Akademi
The Book of Malachi (ca 470 BCE) has often been, especially in early scholarly literature, characterized as a book with a catechetical or paraenetic features. The larger part of the book is indeed comprised of disputation speeches, where God or the prophet accuses the priests and the laity for violation of covenant laws, and this discourse has sometimes been seen as a development of announcements of curses in earlier prophetic literature.
However, the disputation speeches in Malachi can also be viewed as reflections of the attitudes and behavior, which the author sees as exemplary and wants his audience to follow. In his example list, he mostly applies Deuteronomic (but also Priestly) concepts and vocabulary concerning righteous behavior and good deeds; or conversely, sinful behavior and bad deeds. Being earlier in time than most Greek literature on virtue, Malachi’s listing thus provides interesting material for comparison. Moreover, especially the eulogy on Levi (Mal 2:4–7) had an impact on discourses concerning moral behavior in intertestamental reception history of the Hebrew Bible (e.g. the Book of Jubilees and literature of the testament genre). The moral discussion in Malachi has thus also formed a component in Jewish and Christian heritage transmitted for example in the Greek and Latin languages.
|
Elijah, Elisha, and Other "Prophets" in Hebrews 11:33–38
Program Unit: Epistle to the Hebrews
Lotta Valve, Abo Akademi
The list of exemplary biblical figures of faith in Hebrews 11 turns, in the end of the chapter, into a list of actions of unnamed figures, who in v. 32 are called “prophets.” The rapid listing of their sufferings but also righteous deeds of faith in a stylistically persuasive way is an interesting example of the rhetoric of the author/s. However, it is quite remarkable that the author nevertheless lets these persons go unnamed. Why this procedure? In my paper, I analyze which figures of biblical and intertestamental literature are referred to in this list, and whether there are other than rhetorical reasons for leaving out their names. According to my hypothesis, the relative importance of especially Elijah and Elisha as types for Christ in early Christianity has made it possible for the author to refer to them only vaguely, while simultaneously acknowledging their significance.
|
A Corpus Linguistic Approach to the Prosodic Function of the Masoretic Accents
Program Unit: Judaica
David Van Acker, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
This contribution presents a corpus linguistic analysis of the Masoretic accent sequences found in the prose sections of the Hebrew Bible. Firstly, we quantitatively describe accent sequences by aligning and comparing consecutive sequences of accents using n-grams, skip-n-grams, and Markov chains. The aim of this first step is to investigate the distribution of accents by not just focusing on individual accents, but on accents in relation to the other accents found in their immediate vicinity. Secondly, we test the correlation between specific accent sequences and the respective clause types they occur in (using the ETCBC database). The correlation between interrogative clauses and accent sequences is investigated in detail to evaluate whether accent sequences can disambiguate cases where it is unclear whether a clause is interrogative. Thirdly and most importantly, we build on the above insights to theoretically describe the relationship between accent sequences and prosody. Scholarly research has accepted the prosodic nature of the Masoretic accents since the 1990’s. The implications of this view, however, have yet to be explored to the fullest. Traditionally the disjunctive accents and especially the ‘stronger’ accents such as Silluq, Atnach, Zaqeph, Segolta and Revia have received greater attention than other accents. The former highlight the boundaries of units of speech. However, much of the accents are overlooked. This is unfortunate given that the study of prosody cannot limit itself to the detection of boundaries. For that reason we evaluate whether accent sequences can be mapped to prosodic sequences in the Hebrew Bible. In summary, we explore new ways of interpreting the Masoretic accents by approaching the accentual system as a whole. Our methods allow for a comprehensive analysis and present a new perspective on the debate.
|
Early Christian Spirituality Embedded in 1 John Where the Author Refers to His ‘Writing’ Concerning the Son of God
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Dirk van der Merwe, University of South Africa
Authors make use of various figures of style or different rhetorical mechanisms to influence or to convince their readers. These figures of style and rhetorical mechanisms can also create different spiritualities (lived experiences) in the reader. In 1 John the author refers several times to himself (also once in the plural, 1:4) writing certain things with the purposes that: ‘our joy may be complete’ (1:4); ‘you may not sin’ (2:1); ‘you may know that you have eternal life’ (5:13). This essay investigates the rhetorical use of the author’s three references to his ‘writing’ and the possible spiritualities embedded in these explicit references with special attention of 1 John 5:5-13.
|
Virtues in the Aramaic Dead Sea Scrolls in a Hellenistic context
Program Unit: Virtue in Biblical Literature (EABS)
Hanneke van der Schoor, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
Previous scholarship dealing with ethics in the Dead Sea Scrolls focuses on the dualistic and predeterministic worldview of the community, on information from polemic descriptions of opponents and on purity regulations. In the majority of cases these analyses are based on the Hebrew scrolls, mainly on the so-called sectarian scrolls (e.g. Tso and Kampen). In this paper I focus on the Aramaic Dead Sea Scrolls, particularly on the Testament of Qahat (4Q542). This text displays a clear view of what kind of virtues belong to the moral vocabularies of priests: truth, justice, uprightness, perfection, purity, holiness and the priesthood. The first part of the paper surveys the use of the foregoing virtues in the Jewish Aramaic literature of the Second Temple Period. By evaluating the usage of virtues in Jewish Aramaic literature the relation between those seven virtues can be explained. It has been suggested that qushta, often translated as 'truth', came to be interpreted as a fundamental power and an ultimate goal in the world (Koch). It will be argued that the connection between qushta and other virtues in the Testament of Qahat can be interpreted in the same way. The second part of the paper will be devoted to assessing the relationship between aletheia and related virtues in Jewish Hellenistic texts. In this manner it will be possible to evaluate the variety in discourses about morally laudable behaviour in the Aramaic Dead Sea Scrolls.
|
Peace Is More than Swords Being Turned into Plowshares: The Development of Peace in the Books of Isaiah and Micah
Program Unit: Prophets and Prophecy (EABS)
Chris van der Walt, North-West University (South Africa)
An aspect in both the books of Isaiah and Micah which received a considerable amount of attention is the notion of “Swords being beaten into plowshares” (Isa 2:4 & Mic 4:3). This notion is often perceived as “peace” as can be seen from the title of the published proceedings of a colloquium on Isaiah 2:1-5 and Mic 4:3 namely “Isaiah’s vision of peace in Biblical and modern international relations”. Strictly speaking, however, “swords being beaten into plowshares” does not speak of peace, but only about the absence of war. In this paper it will be argued that שָׁלוֹם / peace in the context of the book of Isaiah has a more extensive meaning than only the absence of war. In light of the fact that peace as a theme is used more extensively in the book of Isaiah than in the book of Micah, the development of the concept in Isaiah can be used to shed light on the theological use of peace in the book of Micah. Rather than interpreting “swords being beaten into plowshares” in a political manner, the phrase should be interpreted in terms of relationships. Moreover, since there is a lot of discussion about the correct interpretation of וְהָיָה זֶה שָׁלוֹם in Micah 5.4(5), it will be argued that the development of the concept of peace in Isaiah can shed light on how it could be interpreted theologically in Micah.
|
Scanning the Body-Image of Job Psychoanalytically
Program Unit: Psychological Hermeneutics of Biblical Themes and Texts
Pieter van der Zwan, University of Pretoria
In the approximately 546 times that the body is explicitly referred to in the book of Job, around 68 body-parts are mentioned, making it amongst the top “body-referents” in the Hebrew Bible, alongside the Psalms, the Song of Songs and Leviticus. These references are spread over the main human character, other human beings, God and animals, but are all in the mind of the author whose unconscious body-image is projected onto them. Although there is a strong emphasis on the face, Job’s final challenge confronts him on his skin, his body’s boundary. This makes him reflect on the temporal boundaries of his life-span, his birth and death, which he both equates with his mother’s womb, a body-part not belonging to and perhaps dissociated by him. Summarising the bodily map of the protagonist can add to insight in his experiences and struggles, especially when a psychoanalytic lens is added to it.
|
Genesis 4,8: Hebrew Text and the Septuagint Translation Technique
Program Unit: Septuagint Studies
Jacob van Dorp, Netherlands Bible Society
It has long been observed that the Masoretic text (MT) of Genesis 4,8 omits what Cain could have said to his brother Abel just before he killed him. Almost all ancient versions and modern translations fill in the apparent lacuna with a direct object like Let us go to the field. I would like to put forward some data concerning the translation of Genesis 4,8 in the Septuagint (LXX).
My first observation regards the hypothesis that there is a lack of words in Genesis 4,8a. The explicit presentation of a direct speech is rightly expected after the verb ’amar in biblical Hebrew. Nevertheless, omitting direct speech after a verbum dicendi is found more than twenty times in biblical Hebrew and Aramaic.
My second observation refers to the way the phenomenon of omitting speech has been treated by the Old Greek translators.
1) They frequently apply a very literal type of translation.
2) It happens that the Hebrew construction of two successive narrative verb forms is transformed in a more natural Greek syntax: the Hebrew consecutive imperfect of the execution of a command can be reformulated in a Greek infinitive.
3) The omitted Hebrew report of how an order is executed, can completely be transformed in a direct speech in Greek as the content of the preceding instruction.
In my paper I will discuss the observations just mentioned in view of the LXX version of Genesis 4:8.
|
Peculiar Language in the Pastoral Epistles? A Reassessment of Register Variation as an Explanatory Model
Program Unit: Hellenistic Greek Language and Linguistics
Jermo van Nes, Evangelische Theologische Faculteit
For over two centuries, the language of the so-called Pastoral Epistles (PE) has been subject to controversial debates. A majority of New Testament (NT) scholars has found the vocabulary and syntax of the PE to differ from other Pauline letters, giving rise to all sorts of explanatory models. Traditionally, scholars have attributed the PE’s peculiar language to a pseudonymous author (or authors), a secretary, or a combination of these. Others have attributed linguistic variation inter alia to Paul’s old age, the PE’s different subject matter, and/or their individual addressees. More recently, however, NT linguists have introduced the notion of register in the discussion, arguing that the PE’s peculiar language is due to register variation. While this might be a viable explanatory model, so far it has not been tested whether the quantifiable features of register in the PE significantly differ from those in other Pauline letters. The aim of the present study is to do so by means of linear regression analysis.
|
The Impact of the Orality/Literacy Debate on the Gospel of Mark: Doing Exegesis with More Questions Than Answers
Program Unit: Orality and Literacy in Early Christianity (EABS)
Geert Van Oyen, Université catholique de Louvain
Ever since the emergence of critical exegesis the orality/literacy issue has always played a role in the discussions on the origin, the composition, the interpretation and the influence of the gospel according to Mark. These discussions received a facelift with the rise of recent approaches based on the theories of performance and social and cultural memory. This paper is an essay to evaluate the impact of these new approaches on the study of the Gospel of Mark. A double hypothesis will be explored. On the one hand, taking seriously into account the influence of orality in the process of the making of the gospel and in its afterlife makes exegesis more complex and leaves scholars with more questions and uncertainties than answers: To what degree was oral tradition fixed or flexible before and after the gospel of Mark was written? Does not the “oral tradition” hypothesis become a master key to solve all “unsolvable” issues in the synoptic problem? If each oral performance of the gospel is a unique event, what is the function of written commentaries on the written gospel? On the other hand, new approaches have in common an openness towards the communicative and pragmatic aspects of the gospel's story. They open new dimensions that could lead to a more integrated methodology in which historical, socio-cultural, narratological and practical readings contribute to a renewed appreciation of the vividness of the story.
|
Patterns of Metaphors in Psalm 51
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible (EABS)
Ellen van Wolde, Radboud Universiteit Nijmegen
It is quite common to distinguish in Ps 51 various metaphors of sin: “sin is a stain to be washed out” or “sin is an impurity to be purified”. However, seldom mentioned is the way these metaphors build into a metaphorical pattern of sin. Yet, still another metaphorical pattern pervades the psalm, namely that of kingship. These two patterns and their interaction is the topic of this paper.
|
An Infamous Trinity: Herod Antipas, Herodias, and Salome in Josephus and Gustave Flaubert
Program Unit: Bible and Its Influence: History and Impact
Caroline Vander Stichele, Universiteit van Amsterdam
The story about the death of John the Baptist in Mark 6:14-29 and Matthew 14:1-12 has a long history of interpretation. However, very little is said in that story about its main protagonists: Herod Antipas, Herodias and her daughter. Later interpreters therefore turned to Josephus as a major source of information, but also inspiration. They identified Herodias’ anonymous daughter in the Gospel stories with the one called Salome in Josephus. In this paper I focus on the representation of Herod Antipas, Herodias and Salome in Josephus’ work on the one hand and in a short story, entitled Hérodias, from the French novelist Gustave Flaubert (1821-1880), published in 1877, on the other. In the first part of my paper, I analyze where and how these characters appear in Jewish War and Jewish Antiquities. In the second part of my paper I focus on how these representations informed their portrayal by Flaubert.
|
Polemics and Identity in the Pseudo-Clementine Basic Writing
Program Unit: Construction of Identity in the Ancient World: Intersections and Reflections (EABS)
Antti Vanhoja, University of Helsinki
This paper examines the polemical discourse in the Pseudo-Clementine Basic Writing and its importance in constructing an in-group identity. It argues that the author of the Basic Writing is using hostile language, sometimes subtly, in order to strengthen the borders of his in-group and set it apart from others.
The Pseudo-Clementine Basic Writing is a 3rd-century Jewish Christian text, a reconstructed source behind the preserved Pseudo-Clementine literature which consists of 4th-century CE writings usually called Recognitions and Homilies, as well as three short texts attached to the Homilies.
The Basic Writing, written in the form of an ancient novel, contains polemics against “pagan” beliefs (e.g. magic and astrology) but also against other Christians like Paul and Marcion. The literary attacks in the Basic Writing follow the conventions of ancient polemical rhetoric, such as accusing opponents of hypocrisy and sorcery, although the critique is often veiled and tightly bound to the narrative form of the text.
As is often pointed out, polemical discourse is most of all used for the benefit of the in-group; it is a way of identifying the out-groupers and keeping them apart from “us”. This notion connects polemics to the concept of social identity. From its perspective, the hostile language can be seen as a tool for creating a positive in-group identity and isolating unwanted beliefs from the group.
In the Basic Writing, the author thus indicates what is appropriate and what is not by identifying “false” beliefs and attacking them as well as their supporters. Whether this is done to protect the boundaries of the in-group or to create them in the first place, is up to debate. In either case, the use of hostile rhetoric paints a picture of an author coping with his social surroundings in the multiform thought-world of the early Christianity.
|
Apocalyptic Vision or Ritual Instructions? The Qumran War Texts as Apocalyptic Literature
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
Hanna Vanonen, University of Helsinki
The Qumran War Text manuscripts form in many ways an intriguing ensemble of texts. The group includes both large and well-preserved leather scrolls and very damaged papyri. The content of the texts extends from detailed war instructions to visionary images of the apocalyptic battle – and from brief blessings and curses to a large poetic survey of history. The battle between the Sons of Light and the Sons of Darkness described in the War Scroll (1QM) and other War Texts is one of the classic examples of apocalypticism in Qumran scrolls. On the other hand, the terms “Sons of Light” and/or “Sons of Darkness” are only represented in one fourth of the War Text manuscripts and in 1QM, for instance, they are featured only in the chosen few columns. By analyzing this contradiction, I discuss to what extent the War Texts of Qumran can be categorized as belonging to the apocalyptic literature. The paper is based on my recent dissertation on Qumran War Texts.
|
Exodus 3:14 as an Explanation of the Tetragrammaton: What if the Septuagint Rendering Had No Platonic Nuances?
Program Unit: Septuagint Studies
Pavlos D. Vasileiadis, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Greece
It is commonly maintained that the LXX rendering of the phrasal theonym ´ehyè ´ášer ´ehyè (if considered as such) found in Exodus 3:14 comprised a theological shift in the biblical understanding of God. This divine declaration (only once addressed to Moses) was taken by some exegetes as an explanation of the sacred Tetragrammaton yhwh (found more than six thousand times in the Hebrew text) and even as the real, one and only divine name—especially when the Greek rendering of the Tetragrammaton started conveying the notions of lordship and supremacy. As early as Philo, it was accepted by Hellenistic Jews that the Platonic understanding of the Deity was fully compatible with the Jewish scriptures. In fact, the choices made by the Alexandrian translators allowed and even promoted a Platonic reading of the sacred text in Greek. A reaction to this development had been the renderings in Bible versions made by Jewish and Jewish Christian translators during the early centuries CE that Origen opted to include in his Hexapla. Despite the total dominance of the LXX in the Christian world, this reverse theological tendency—aiming to attain a more faithful adherence to the Hebrew text—has been present in a number of Greek Bible translations until today. Such noteworthy cases include the late medieval translations of Graecus Venetus (late 14th/early 15th cent.) and the Constantinople Pentateuch (1547). This paper will attempt to trace such translation traditions and investigate alternative Greek renderings of the original Hebrew terms (both the Tetragrammaton and the phrasal theonym) that might not pose a direct threat to core biblical ideas about God. Towards this end, the tension between “being” and “becoming” within theological and philosophical frameworks will also be sketched.
|
The Emergence of Intention in Early Interpretations of Biblical Law
Program Unit: Septuagint Studies
Jelle Verburg, University of Oxford
This paper traces the development of intention in ancient interpretations of the laws of the Torah. I will argue that the introduction of intention in the civil and criminal laws of the Mishnah was not a novel invention of the rabbis, but rather a continuation of an established pattern of biblical interpretation. It has been argued that the rabbis of the Mishnah first introduced the concept of intention in their interpretation of the civil and criminal laws of the Torah (see for example Neusner, Judaism: The Evidence of the Mishnah and Eilberg-Schwartz, The Human Will in Judaism). However, a similar tendency of interpretation—which emphasises the distinction between intentional and unintentional transgressions—also occurs in sources predating the Mishnah. Much like the Tannaitic rabbis, the translators of the Septuagint, Philo of Alexandria, and the community of the Dead Sea Scrolls supported the idea that crimes committed intentionally should be punished more severely than those committed unintentionally, and that sacrifices offered without the right intention were not valid. It could be maintained that these sources evince a more developed sense of interiority due to the influence of Greek philosophy, but in this paper I will argue that all the ingredients for the emergence of intention in early interpretations of biblical law and Jewish law can be found already in the Torah itself.
|
"Kai Eis Panta ta Ethne Proton dei Kerychthenai to Eyaggelion" (Mk 13,10): An Inclusion in the Most Ancient Christian Apocalypse?
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Martina Vercesi, Università degli studi di Milano
The aim of this paper is to analyze a Jesus’ saying contained in the so-called Little Apocalypse (Mk 13:9-11). In particular, I intend to formulate a hypothesis of a late inclusion of v.13:10 in which it seems to identify a delaying clause.
First, I will consider the philological aspect of the verse which is very interesting because the oldest direct witnesses that preserve Mk 13:10 are dated in the IV century. Secondly, I will study the meaning of the verse and the implications it determines through its inclusion in the literary context, inside which it can actually be read.
Subsequently, the paper will focus on the synoptic criticism; in the redactions of the other two Gospels, in fact, Mk 13:10 has been omitted. Special emphasis will be given to the context and reworkings of the Jesus’ saying present in the Gospel of Mark made by Matthew and Luke in order to investigate the reasons for the omission. Furthermore, the implications that Mk 13:9-11 and parallels have brought in the communities will also be examined.
All these elements will contribute to develop a hypothesis of inclusion of Mk 13:10 after the marcan redaction and the reconstruction of the possible genesis and redactional history of the verse.
|
Friendship and Character Formation in Job
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israel and in ANE Wisdom Literature (EABS)
Patricia Vesely, Union Presbyterian Seminary
The book of Job centers around an eminently virtuous individual, yet rather than extolling the merits of good character, the book highlights virtue’s incapacity to secure an individual’s well-being. How can the book of Job, in keeping with “wisdom’s project,” contribute to the aim of character formation if, indeed, the book only accentuates the notion that good character results in extreme suffering? In this paper, I argue that friendship is elevated as a moral category in Job as a response to the problem of unjust suffering. This component of the ethical life is shaped not through traditional didactic methods, such as deliberation, careful observation of creation’s orders, and discipline, but, more fundamentally, through encounter. Through encounter, certain dispositions, perceptions, motivations, and desires are generated that are essential to friendship, according to Job: the perception of others as Subjects rather than Objects, compassion and awe before the anomaly of inexplicable suffering, and ḥesed, or a commitment to remain bound to another throughout life’s disruptions and fractures. Job’s “friends” fail to face him in genuine encounter, choosing, instead, to treat him as a proposition in their ordered understandings of retributive justice. The failure of Job’s friends to respond to Job rightly, plus the dialogic nature of the poetic portions of the book, draw readers into this ethical drama and prepare them to respond as would-be friends of Job.
|
Ignatius of Antioch’s Bishop is the Cognitively Natural One
Program Unit: The Biblical World and Cultural Evolution (EABS)
Jarkko Vikman, Helsingin Yliopisto - Helsingfors Universitet
My presentation views Ignatius of Antioch’s understanding on episcopacy from a cognitive perspective. This view may affect to the way, in which the evolution of religious expertise in Late Antiquity can be understood. According to cultural evolutionary view of Ullucci, pagan religious experts represented cognitively optimal religion. They were challenged by Christian bishops with their cognitively costly ideas. I am contesting this cognitively costly view on Ignatian episcopacy: Ignatius could have been simply propagating something universally easy for human mind to hold true.
I am using Shamanism – the oldest known form of religious authority – as a comparison to Ignatius’ texts. Shamanism has been studied cognitively and interpreted to wake certain cognitive mechanisms. It increases intentional interpretations of surrounding environment: human mind seeks intentional causes for events even when there are no visible agents available. This intentional stance towards the environment favours magical thinking as a heuristic device. Magical thinking is part of cognitively optimal processing. Though it has often been labelled psychopathological because of its anti-empirical reasoning, it has also increased adaptability and life quality.
The following categories of magical thinking can be seen in the majority of the Ignatius’ arguments considering episcopacy: Transmutation (a shaman does not represent supernatural, but becomes one), Similarity (effect is more likely to happen, if cause resembles it), Thought-Action Fusion (certain thoughts lead to certain events), Illusion of Control (likelihood of the wanted outcome as higher than probable outcome) and Tempting Fate (carefree attitude leads to negative outcomes).
The Ignatius’ emphasis on uniting Christians under the rule of a bishop is also a universal social mechanism rising from intentional stance. The illusion of control felt by a shaman increases the feeling of control and security in a human group around him. Similarly, uniting under the protection of supernaturally empowered bishop increases benevolence from God.
|
To Obey the Teachers of the Law and Pharisees, but Not to Do What They Do: An Intra-textual Reading of Matt. 23:3
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Francois Viljoen, North-West University (South Africa)
Jesus’s instruction to the crowds in Matt. 23:3 to obey and do everything the teachers of the law and the Pharisees tell them, is the only case in Matthew where the teachings and conduct of the Jewish leaders are seemingly portrayed in a positive light. If this portrayal indeed is positive, it is clearly in tension with how Matthew construes these leaders and their teachings in the rest of the gospel (e.g. Matt. 5:20; 15:3–6, 15:14; 16:11–12). Jesus’ positive remark furthermore stands in contrast with Matt. 28:20, where Jesus claims all authority to himself and instructs his disciples to teach all the nations to obey everything he has commanded them. The question therefore arises as to how this seemingly positive reference of Jesus, which apparently stands in contrast with Jesus’ criticism in the rest of the gospel, should be interpreted. In answering this question, an intra-textual approach is followed. This intra-textual investigation demonstrates how this pronouncement is embedded in a narrative where Jesus is involved in constant and intensifying confrontation with the Jewish religious leaders. It is argued that the Matthean Jesus with this instruction uses irony to sternly expose the hypocrisy of the Jewish religious leaders.
|
Greek Usage in Genesis Rabbah 2:4
Program Unit: Hellenistic Greek Language and Linguistics
Burton L. Visotzky, Jewish Theological Seminary of America
I assay to translate and explicate a complex passage from Midrash Bereishit Rabbah, a fifth-century, Galilean, rabbinic commentary on the book of Genesis. Each textual explanation refers to contemporary Greek literature to unpack the text. In Roman Galilee, Koine Greek was ubiquitous in the rabbinic Jewish community, even so far as to be used in synagogues for both inscriptional and liturgical purposes.
The passage to be discussed is: Genesis Rabbah 2:4b (ed. J. Theodor, pp. 17-18):
Once, Shimeon ben Zoma was standing confounded. Rabbi Yehoshua passed by and asked after him once, and again, yet he did not reply. At the third attempt, he replied in confusion. He [Yehoshua] said to him, “What’s this Ben Zoma? Where from and where to?” He replied, “Nothing from nothing, Rabbi.” He said, “I call heaven and earth to witness that I shall not move from here until you tell me where your feet are coming from!”
He said to him, “I was speculating on the Works of Creation, and between the Upper Waters and the Lower Waters there is no more than two to three fingers-breadth. Further, it does not say `The spirit of God blew,’ but rather `hovered’ (Gen. 1:2), like a bird that is fluttering, flapping its wings, and its wings touch, yet do not touch.”
Rabbi Yehoshua turned away and said to his disciples, “Ben Zoma has gone.”
The Greek sources include: Lucian of Samosata (following Plato) in his , “In Praise of Demosthenes,” and Athenaeus, Deipnosohistae.
|
Rewriting Methods in the Palaea Historica and in the Slavic Cycle of Abraham
Program Unit: Slavonic Apocrypha (EABS)
Maria Vitkovskaya, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin - Humboldt University of Berlin
In 1961, Geza Vermes coined the term "rewritten Bible," which originally was meant as a designation for antique and medieval Jewish legends about the patriarch Abraham in different ways transforming the text of chapters 11 to 25 of Genesis. Later this term was assigned to a broader circle of Jewish texts and more recently it is often in use in scholarly works on Early Christian literature, including the New Testament writings. At the same time, there is no doubt that the legends about Abraham are still one of the best examples of the rewriting method. This is true especially for Abrahamic texts which were in use since 9th century in Byzance and among Southern (partly also Eastern) Slavic peoples. The paper deals with rewriting methods used in the Palaea Historica (including its Slavonic translations) and in the texts of Abraham’s cycle contained in many Slavic miscellanies (sborniki), which probably also had Greek origins.
|
The Psychology of ‘Mountain Top Experiences’ and the Psalms of Ascents (Ps 120-134)
Program Unit: Psychological Hermeneutics of Biblical Themes and Texts
Hendrik Viviers, University of Johannesburg
Mountains are not only appreciated for their natural beauty but notably also for their inspirational and elevating effect on the mind, ‘mountain top experiences.’ To illuminate the last-mentioned, insights from Attention Restoration Theory (ART; developed by environmental psychologists Stephen and Rachel Kaplan) will be utilised, as well as insights from Dark Green Religion (DGR; Bron Taylor). It is especially the ART human:nature relational properties of ‘fascination’ (awe) and ‘extent’ (order, mystery), complemented by the DGR notions of ‘interconnectedness’ and ‘sacredness’ (intrinsic worth), that explain the cultural constructs of mountains as the centre (s) of the world, sources of life, sites of identity, symbols of power, seats for deities and places of inspiration/transformation/renewal. The Psalms of Ascents collection (šîrê hamma‘ălôt; Ps 120-134) provides an exemplary (ancient) expression of a ‘mountain top experience’ for a group of post-exilic Israelites in search of their identity. Apart from a few explicit references to mountains in the collection, the overall focus is on an ‘ascent’ to Jerusalem, to Mount Zion and the temple where Yahweh chose to reside. This is the centre of the (then Israelite) world, where earth and heaven meet. The rather insipid Mount Zion becomes larger than life, where pilgrims find security, solace, blessing, unity and a transcending to 'a greater reality' in the presence of their deity.
|
Biblical Prophecy between Ritual and Liturgy
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Giancarlo Voellmy, Seminar für Biblische Theologie Beatenberg
The concepts of ritual and liturgy are closely related and yet clearly distinct. In biblical prophecy of the exilic period, effective divine ritual and performed liturgy appear in close parallel. Habakkuk’s collage of dialogue, dirge and psalm (Hab 1-3) may serve as an obvious example. We ask, if the elements of liturgy do also pertain to Ezekiel’s texture of prophetic speech, acting and vision in chs. 4-11, and if the concept of a „prophetic liturgy“ can be generally established.
The study is done with particular interest in (1) the legitimation the prophet attains by narrating his participation in performed liturgy, and (2) how the effective and formative dimension of liturgy can be evidenced by the means of Ritual Studies. In addition to prophetic exegesis and ritual theory, the study aims at a dialogue with recent thought in practical theology.
|
Usage-Based Translation Syntax of the Septuagint
Program Unit: Septuagint Studies
Anssi Voitila, University of Eastern Finland
In my paper, I will examine what one should take into consideration when writing a Septuagint syntax. My presentation is based on the principles presented by Ilmari Soisalon-Soininen. I will discuss what it should consist of and deliberate the principles the authors should follow in creating their contributions to the work. As an example of what I mean, I will present a sample paragraph treating usage of tenses.
In a syntax of translated language, the reader must be able to see which linguistic phenomena reflect the usages and style of the target language (here the Greek language contemporary to the translation) and which originated from the syntax of the source language. The syntax should provide information concerning the differences between the various translators as well. In this way, the syntax would be useful not only to the biblical scholars studying Septuagint in order to reconstruct the original reading of the Hebrew Bible but also to those interested in the texts of the Hellenistic Judaism and the New Testament as well as the Greek linguists investigating Septuagint, the most important collection of prose texts from the Hellenistic era. Therefore, I will justify, in my presentation, why I would recommend a syntax that will present the Septuagint language as it is, a language produced by translating: applying a sort of usage-based approach (describing all the linguistic phenomena relevant to a Greek syntax of a corpus, not so much emphasizing the level of sophistication of the language used) accompanied by careful analysis of the syntactical features generated by its being translated from a Hebrew text, the new Septuagint syntax differs from the one written by Takamitsu Muraoka.
|
Rhetorical Children in Galatians: Metaphor, Affect, and Persuasion
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible (EABS)
Robert H. von Thaden, Jr., Mercyhurst University
Paul’s argument in Galatians deploys various metaphors related to legitimate children (e.g., adoption, inheritance, contrast with slaves, etc.) to convince the Galatians of their freedom from the Law. This presentation will explore Paul’s metaphorical argumentation and analyze the rhetorical force generated by such imagistic language. While the multiple conceptual metaphoric blends Paul creates might not necessarily cohere in a strictly logical sense, such imagistic language harnesses cognitive resources that work affectively on the intended audience. The affective responses prompted by Paul’s rhetoric can help account for its persuasive power.
|
Claiming Superiority through "Virtue" as a Configuration of Empowering Bodily Strategies in 4 Maccabees
Program Unit: Virtue in Biblical Literature (EABS)
Johannes Vorster, University of South Africa
In his publication, "Permanence and Change"," Kenneth Burke resists the exclusive absorption of piety as religious disposition arguing for its relocation within a wider systemic configuration. Defining piety as “the sense of what properly goes with what,” while at the same recognizing its system constructing capacities, it is a disposition that inclines more towards what can be called gregarious obedience or compulsion. From the perspective of a rhetoric of the body, deploying inter alia the Bourdieuan notion of "habitus" and integrating Burke’s views on piety, I argue that “virtue” in its variety of expressions be seen as a configuration of empowering bodily strategies in 4 Maccabees. Embedded within the socio-political hierarchies of the Roman Empire “virtue discourse,” performs less to cultivate and demonstrate adherence to the law, less to reflect a particular mentality, than to effect what can be called hybridized, gregarious bodies, produced by a collective of normativities that simultaneously entrenches and produces their habituation. However, always echoing their habituation, “virtue” is modified contingent to the contexts in which it performs. I argue that in the agonistic context of 4 Maccabees, “virtue” performs as an empowering bodily strategy that summons identification with a superior Jewish male body who also strategically incorporates the virtuous female body. Several strategies within the rhetoric of “virtue discourse” will be highlighted and also related to some of the early Christian martyr narratives. For citation see: Kenneth Burke, Permanence and Change: An Anatomy of Purpose. 3rd ed. With Afterword (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1984), 74.
|
Rhetoric on the Intersection of HIV/AIDS and Biblical Discourse
Program Unit: Political Biblical Criticism
Johannes Vorster, University of South Africa
Various studies from the perspective of critical rhetoric have emerged to lay bare how medical discourse as a catalystic terministic screen that filters, selects,and conducts, also prevents and censures other discourses concerned with the HIV/AIDS pandemic. This often happens via the parading of prior classificatory categories borrowed from spheres of violence within the body politic that then function as scientific knowledge in its newly acquired medical environment. However, this type of uncritical terminological appropriation may have the effect of forcing persons with HIV/AIDS to assume its logic in order to become knowable, thereby perpetuating its violent qualities. It has in addition been demonstrated how such a catalystic terministic screen, not subjected to self-critique allows for the privileging of institutional power differentials. Although an explosion of literature on the internexus of religious discourse and HIV/AIDS can be reported, few have paid attention to the rhetoric at work in this encounter. In this paper I identify some of the strategies at work in the engagement of religious discursive practices and HIV/AIDS in a variety of contexts, but specifically also in Africa. Furthermore I problematise the non-self-reflective inclination towards emancipatory theologies and biblical appropriations where the complex interaction of “belief” and “body” is neglected, and affectivity is sacrificed for bureaucratic institutional benefit. Operating from a rhetoric of the body, I propose instead that human vulnerability be taken as point of departure in the encounter of religious discourse and persons with HIV/AIDS.
|
Sheba as a Net of Metaphors across the OT
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible (EABS)
Stefan Wälchli, Universität Bern - Université de Berne
Well known is the story of the visit of the Queen of Sheba to King Solomon. In this story, the Queen of Sheba represents the wealth and the wisdom of a foreign land, quite in terms of a fairy tale. But additionally, there are around 10 other instances in the OT, where the land or the people of Sheba are mentioned and used as metaphor, especially in the Prophets and in the Psalms. The paper presents the different use of the metaphor "Sheba" in these texts and retraces the connections of these different use of the same metaphor. On the whole, it depicts a network of the same metaphor across the OT and different OT-Textcorpora. Dependent on the context, the same image of a wealthy land can be used as a representation of a marvelous future and also as an image of Israelite domination in past or future. Both uses of the same metaphor are interdependent.
|
Elite Shifts in Babylonia under Xerxes
Program Unit: Judaeans in the Persian Empire (EABS)
Caroline Waerzeggers, Leiden University
The question how violently Xerxes responded to the revolts in Babylonia of 484 BCE is much debated, but scholars generally agree that his reprisals involved at the very least an "elite shift": after the revolts, pro-insurgency groups were dismissed from their positions of influence and replaced with new ones favored by the Persian Empire. Evidence from Uruk suggests that the Empire tracked down social networks even beyond the area of unrest, in what seems to be a targeted punitive program. The selective reprisals have earned Xerxes the benevolent title of "architect of a stable empire" among ancient historians, while Assyriologists insist on the disruptive nature of this social intervention. In this paper I will reflect on the concept of "elite shift" and its application to post-insurgency Babylonia. In particular, I will argue that this de-personalized notion tends to mask the repercussions of state intervention in the lives of "real" people. The paper will identify specific victims of this abstract policy and trace their fate.
|
Visionary Experience as Test Case for the Interrelation of Cylinder Seals and Textual Evidence
Program Unit: Iconography and Biblical Studies (EABS)
Thomas Wagner, Bergische Universität Wuppertal
The interrelation of image and text has been investigated in various contributions during the last two decades. Within all approaches concerning the text-image- or image-text-relationship, the material property of the image is not used to gain insight into either aspect of interdependence.
In this paper I will deal with images of visionary experiences and their value for text interpretation, based on form-critical aspects of material evidence and their impact on the recipient. I will start with basic insights concerning the form and content of cylinder seals, their use in the ancient world, and finally ask about the animation of images in biblical texts containing visionary experiences.
|
On Sphere and Space: The Development of ANE Cosmology and Its Effect on Visionary Experiences
Program Unit: Vision and Envisionment in the Bible and its World (EABS)
Thomas Wagner, Bergische Universität Wuppertal
Biblical texts and ANE sources contain various images of the divine world. These images are based on cosmological ideas and are reflected in the location of temple, palace, and gates in the layout of settlements. In general, the texts differentiate between a divine and a human sphere or the atmosphere and the heavens. Prophetic visions are described as envisionings of the divine sphere but often are attached to the idea that the divine sphere is located in the heavens.
Firstly, I will deal with a development in ANE and biblical literature from the idea of a spheric cosmology towards the image of God(s) dwelling / living in heavens. Secondly, I will point to the existence of visionary prophecy in pre-exilic times but to the end of visionary experiences of prophets due to the installation of a Second Temple theology.
|
The Poetics of Magic: Depicting and Dispelling Demons in the Jewish Babylonian Aramaic Incantation Bowls
Program Unit: Dispelling Demons: Interpretations of Evil and Exorcism in Ancient Near Eastern, Jewish and Biblical Contexts (EABS)
Daniel James Waller, Rijksuniversiteit Groningen
Because the primary "readers" of the Aramaic incantation bowls are the demons invoked in these texts, the bowls leave us primarily with an author-oriented situation in which we are obliged to investigate their implied supernatural readers as they are envisioned by the practitioners behind the bowls. The rhetoric of the bowl texts is designed primarily to exorcise demons and frustrate their hostile designs, but the bowls do not just seek to communicate with the supernatural for these ends; they also employ various literary techniques in order to directly depict this supernatural reality. This paper analyses these representations of the demonic in the Jewish Babylonian Aramaic (JBA) incantation bowls, as well as the role these representations play in the broader rhetorical repertoire developed by the authors of the bowls to fight malevolent supernatural forces. Focussing on a select corpus of JBA bowls, it examines how the bowl practitioners used poetic structures to construct their representation of the demonic realm, and asks (1) how these demons are designated with subjectivity and the 'needs' that motivate their malevolence; (2) what expressive features these demons are granted; (3) how these features are crafted using narrative and figurative language; and (4) what the rhetorical warrant of such practices was. It argues that these narrative and figurative techniques have everything to do with the argument of the bowls, and that their rhetorical strategy was plainly felt to be that much stronger for their use. It suggests that the practitioners behind the bowls were responsible not just for crafting a material and textual response to the demons that plagued their clients, but that their creative systematisation and conceptualisation of the demonic also played a significant role in defining the broader community's sense of the demonic.
|
On the Use of the Term "Elite" in Research on the Ancient Near Eastern Empires
Program Unit: Judaeans in the Persian Empire (EABS)
Caroline Wallis, University of Helsinki
Reflecting on the term of "elite" in research on the ancient Near East, I will present a history of the use of this term in European and North-American academic literature while taking care to situate this historical overview in a history of political ideas. I will reflect on the effects caused by the semantic "halo" of this term in research in the field of social sciences. In what way can the term, “elite” help us apprehend the social reality of ancient Near Eastern societies, and what are the possible distortions resulting from its use? What social representations do we import in our research when we use this term to describe the distribution of power in ancient Near Eastern societies? I will subsequently move on to an examination of the particular historical period of interest to us here, i.e. the advent of the Persian Acahemenid Empire and the consequences of the political shift for the local Babylonian social structure. What were the terms used at the time to describe individuals and groups holding power, and was this typology impacted by successive changes of regime?
|
Quoted Text and Interpretation; Is There Always a Correspondence? Jer. 31:15 (LXX 38:15) in Matt. 2:18
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Georg A. Walser, Independent Scholar
When working with quotations from the Old Testament in the New, the correspondence between a quoted text and its interpretation can in some cases be very hard to comprehend. Mostly, this difficulty is due to the fact that we, of course, cannot know what was in the mind of the interpreter.
However, in a few cases the quoted text is extant in various forms, and occasionally one of the variant readings seems to fit the interpretation better than the one found in the actual quotation. The question arises, if perhaps the interpreter had a different version of the text in mind from the one quoted, when he made his interpretation.
In Qumran there are some well-known examples, where this might be the case. This is also true for some interpretations in the Midrashim and in the early Church Fathers. But what about the Gospels?
Are there any such examples in the Gospels, where the quoted text might not be the text in the mind of the interpreter, i.e., the author of the New Testament text? And what could possibly be the reason for quoting one version of a text and presenting an interpretation of a different one?
For one quotation in Matthew there exist several different versions, namely Jer. 31:15 (LXX 38:15) in Matt. 2:18. This paper will discuss the possibility that the author of Matthew might have had another version in mind from the one present in the standard editions.
|
What Did Jacob Do at Gen. 47:31b?
Program Unit: Pentateuch (Torah)
Georg A. Walser, Independent scholar
This paper will focus on a short text from Genesis, which exists in two distinctly different versions based on different vocalizations of the Hebrew consonantal text. One version has been preserved in the Masoretic text, the other one in the Septuagint and in subsequent literature. At first glance the text might seem quite uncomplicated and the difference between the versions appears to be only a matter of different vocalization of the same Hebrew consonantal text. However, a look into the commentaries shows that the text has quite a complicated history, and its interpretation is anything but simple.
Claus Westermann comments in his Genesis commentary (Genesis 37–50: a commentary) on the Masoretic text and concludes that we “no longer know the meaning of the phrase”, and Nahum Sarna, also commenting on the Hebrew text in his commentary on Genesis (The JPS Torah commentary: Genesis), points out that it “is not clear whether it is a token of gratitude to Joseph or an expression of thanks and praise to God”. The last comment is especially interesting, since it shows that interpretations based on both versions have been preserved and are referred to in a commentary on the Hebrew text, although the version found in the Septuagint is usually considered to be a mistake by the translator.
Apparently, this rather obscure text is preserved in several versions, with various interpretations, and it can be found in a number of different contexts. Is it at all possible to retrieve an original meaning of this text? And if, what could that have been?
|
The Greek of the Jews and Christians
Program Unit: The Greek of Jews and Christians Through the Pax Romana (EABS)
Georg A. Walser, Independent scholar
This paper discusses the existence and nature of a peculiar variety of the Greek language which was used by Jews and Christians. It is argued that this variety arose from the Greek translation of the Pentateuch made during the Hellenistic period.
The use of a number of frequent linguistic phenomena—participles, conjunctions, particles—in the Pentateuch are discussed and compared to the use of these in a corpus of other texts. The conclusion is that a group of texts that were written by Jews and Christians are quite similar to the Pentateuch and to each other, but differ significantly from the texts having no reference to the Jewish and Christian context. Both the Hebrew original and the translation technique of the Pentateuch influenced this contrast, which can mainly be recognized in the word order.
The investigation assumes that Greek texts produced by Jews and Christians, as well as other Greek texts of the period, reflected a common sociolinguistic situation of writing in distinctive ways according to the genre or occasion at hand. The peculiar variety of Greek found in the Pentateuch emerges as yet another variety used for a particular genre, intended for a certain audience, and dealing with a similar subject. This variety of Greek recurs mainly in texts from the Septuagint, pseudepigrapha and the New Testament.
|
When Is a Ligature Not a Ligature? Scribal Traits and Errors
Program Unit: Textual Criticism: Manuscripts & Methods
Bill Warren, New Orleans Baptist Theological Seminary
The use of ligatures especially in Greek minuscule manuscripts of the New Testament is well known and documented. These ligatures often present problems for transcribers working on those manuscripts today, at times with rather strange and even comical results. What is often not recognized and even less often noted is that sometimes the scribes themselves misread the ligatures and introduced erroneous readings into their manuscripts. This paper will present some examples of these scribal phenomena and draw some conclusions related to transcribing practices that might be helpful to follow so that ligatures that are wrongly interpreted by scribes are not overlooked.
|
The Impurity of the Impure Spirits in the Gospels
Program Unit: Dispelling Demons: Interpretations of Evil and Exorcism in Ancient Near Eastern, Jewish and Biblical Contexts (EABS)
Cecilia Wassén, Uppsala Universitet
In their descriptions of Jesus’ work as an exorcist, the authors of the synoptic gospels frequently call the evil spirits “impure.” As I will argue, it is likely that the expression goes back to the historical Jesus. This raises questions about what Jesus may have meant by the term: was it just an expression, or did he view the evil spirits as literally impure? If he did, in what way would they have been impure? I will discuss the possible meanings of the alleged impure nature of the spirits by examining the use of the expression in the gospels and the Jewish sources, including the Pseudepigrapha and the Dead Sea Scrolls. I will address the questions also by taking the conceptual links between disease, sin, and impurity into regard. I will argue that the impurity of the spirits are linked both to their evil actions and to their inherent, impure nature.
|
Pauline Gifting and Marxist Criticism
Program Unit: Political Biblical Criticism
Taylor Weaver, University of Kent
Despite works by New Consensus authors, it seems likely that there were few to no elite practitioners in early Christian assemblies. Instead, early Christian communities likely consisted of those who either existed in exploited classes, or were a part of what de. Ste. Croix called ‘intermediate classes'. If there is class tension, then surely Christian assemblies are affected. In a moment of resurgence of Marxist criticism in biblical studies it would do well to attend to the place of early Christians within the material social realities of the first century. In this essay, I attempt to do so by paying particular attention to the practice of gifting in early Christianity. In particular, in this essay I will note how this social practice created indebtedness while sustaining society; gifting is a form of debt that exists to sustain social structures. Gifting, then, helps sustain class division. I will put forth a tentative reading of the social situation of early Christians that points to the possibility of the creation of intra-communal structures that destabilised normal gifting relations, particularly within the Pauline corpus. This is class struggle precisely because it destabilises normal relations. These relations Paul experiments with are an attempt at breaking down class divisions, taking away power from landowners and those whose honour and material reality depend on the subjugation of non-elite. This is, however, less about an emergence of Christian ‘identity’ than it may appear at first. Instead, I show that class struggle occurs in the early Christian context through augmentations of social functions, or social agitation, which can be seen in other minor groups. Nonetheless, despite reading this as a strategic employment of class struggle, I attempt to point out major flaws that such movements engender in spite of desires to read them as 'subversive'.
|
Compositional and Redactional Coherence: Micah 1-3 as a Test Case
Program Unit: Developing Exegetical Methods (EABS)
Kristin Weingart, Eberhard Karls Universität Tübingen
In recent years, the redaction history of Mi 1-3 has become an object of extensive scholarly debate. While some scholars find a largely unified composition within these chapters (though disagreeing on its starting point: Mi 1:5; 1:10, or 2,1?) others assume a high degree of redactional activity. Both groups focus on more or less the same textual phenomena. Some of the phenomena which play an important role in the discussion are doubtlessly aimed at strengthening textual coherence, e.g. the Wiederaufnahme of significant elements of 1:6 in 3:12 or the phrase בכל זאת in 1,5. The latter connects v. 5 to the preceding theophany in vv. 3-4 or to the following announcement of doom for Samaria and Jerusalem in vv. 6-9 – depending on how one sees its deixis.
The question is whether textual features like these stem from the work of authors or the work of editors and how to distinguish between the two possibilities.Therefore, the paper will survey how they are evaluated in a number of recent analyses of Mi 1-3 and discuss the reasons and the methodological presuppostions which lead to percieving them as either compositional or redactional. Eventually, some more general propositions on the evaluation of textual features which generate coherence in Mi 1-3 and beyond will be put up for discussion.
|
Citizen and Christian: An Oxymoron?
Program Unit: Citizens and Aliens in Greco-Roman Antiquity (EABS)
Alexander Weiss, Goethe-Universität Frankfurt am Main
In this paper I will examine what it meant to be a ‚citizen‘ at all in the Greek East of the Roman Empire, given that there were different forms of citizenship. One could hold citizenship in one of the old Greek poleis that mostly were civitates liberae under Roman law or hold citizenship in one of the newly founded Roman coloniae. As a citizen of a colonia, one automatically also possessed Roman citizenship. I will then discuss how, as several examples demonstrate, on the one hand, early Christians were ‚normal‘ citizens of their respective cities and understood themselves as such. These included Christians with Roman names who very likely held Roman citizenship; Christians who showed a strong sense of belonging to the cities in which they were citizens; individual Christians like the famous Aberkios who in the 2nd cent. was a Roman citizen *and* showed a strong sense of belonging to his hometown of Hieropolis; and Christians who even were local magistrates, especially in Phrygia in the 3rd century. On the other hand, there was a strong strand of thought in early Christianity dubbed ‚heavenly citizenship‘ that sometimes has been understood to have undermined the loyalty of Christians to their earthly home-towns. In the final section of my paper, I will explore if the concept of ‚heavenly citizenship‘ really contradicted or undermined the loyalty of early Christians to their respective cities and how this concept would have been perceived by those who were ‚normal‘ citizens in their respective cities or even possessed Roman citizenship.
|
Spittle in Biblical Texts and "Popular" and Rational Medicine
Program Unit: Medicine in Bible and Talmud (EABS)
Annette Weissenrieder, Martin-Luther University Halle-Wittenberg
The use of spittle in the Septuagint (e.g. Job 7:19), healings in the Gospel of Mark (7:32-37 and 8:22-26) and John (9:1-11), and possibly Tacitus’ and Suetonius’ account of Vespasian’s healing, or the Talmud (Baba Bathra 126b) demonstrate that views of spittle’s healing use were influenced by the view of spitting as a contemptuous or contaminating action. In secondary literature the use of spittle is often evaluated as a “magical element,” “folk medicine,” or as “healing with an agent.” In this paper I intend to present Greco-Roman literature in which a range of ailments and conditions respond to spitting or spittle, although the ways that spit is used as a remedy vary. The uses of spit for healing in ancient texts can be divided into the ceremonial, which focus on spitting as an action (Pliny), and the pharmaceutical (e.g. Aristotle’s History of Animals; Galen), which focus on spittle as a substance.
|
The 2017-2018 Excavations at Huqoq in Israel's Galilee
Program Unit: Archaeological Fieldwork in the Hellenistic-Roman Mediterranean (EABS)
Martin Wells, Austin College, on behalf of the Huqoq excavation team directed by Jodi Magness
Since 2011, Jodi Magness of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill has directed excavations in the ancient village of Huqoq in Eastern Lower Galilee, assisted by Shua Kisilevitz of the Israel Antiquities Authority. The excavations have brought to light parts of the Jewish village of the fifth-sixth centuries and the Ottoman period Muslim village of Yakuk. In this paper, we report on the results of the 2017-2018 excavation seasons, which focused on a monumental, Late Roman (early fifth century) synagogue paved with extraordinary mosaics depicting an unparalleled series of biblical scenes. The synagogue was expanded and reused as a public building in the Middle Ages (twelfth-thirteenth centuries), when the stylobates and pedestals were lifted one meter, and the aisles were paved with mosaics. This paper provides an overview of these recent discoveries, which shed new light on Galilean Jews and Judaism against the background of the rise and spread of Christianity.
|
"A Land Flowing with Milk and Honey": Yahweh’s Promised Provision of Food
Program Unit: Anthropology and the Bible (EABS)
Rebekah Welton, University of Exeter
Using anthropological and archaeological insights to discuss the roles of milk and honey in ancient Israelite and Judahite diets, this paper will explore what was implied by the biblical expression ‘a land flowing with milk and honey’. Previous scholarship which has attended to this phrase has not typically addressed the socio-religious roles of milk and honey, and the impact they had on social relations and commensality between consumers. I will argue that Yahweh’s provision of a land ‘flowing’ with these food items promised not only physical nourishment but also socio-religious nourishment.
|
Interactive Isaac: Empowerment and Empathy in Video Gaming’s Aqedah
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Culture
Rebekah Welton, University of Exeter
Edmund McMillen’s independent video game ‘The Binding of Isaac’ was released for PC in 2011 but has since expanded onto multiple gaming platforms including, Xbox One, Playstation 4, iOS, and Nintendo Switch. The game has thus become extremely popular, known notoriously for its difficulty and dark thematic content. Players of the game play as Isaac and attempt to escape from his would-be sacrificing parent. Throughout the video game Isaac must battle a variety of monstrous enemies, and become monstrous himself, as he collects power-enhancing items which modify and distort his body. Using insights from gaming studies this paper will explore the effect that ‘becoming’ Isaac has on one’s interpretation and critique of the biblical Aqedah. In shifting the perspective of the story onto Isaac, the passivity and silence of the biblical Isaac is put into stark contrast. Controlling Isaac in response to visual stimuli on screen is driven by the player’s motor action creating a first person perspective. Such a perspective elicits an emotional and perhaps cathartic identification with Isaac. Due to this ‘becoming’ of Isaac through play, I will argue that game players may be forced into reflecting on the biblical text and reassessing both the value they placed on that text, and the text’s own ideological preferences.
|
When Closure Opens a Door: On Various Canonical Functions of Deuteronomy 31-34
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
Heiko Wenzel, Freie Theologische Hochschule Gießen
The paper reflects on the dynamic relationship of various functions of Deuteronomy 31-34 for closing the Torah and for connecting it to other parts of the Hebrew Bible.
Several scholars have noted various aspects of Deuteronomy 33-34’s relationship to other parts of the Torah, for example the framing aspects with the beginning of the Torah, the parallels to Genesis 49-50, the framing aspects with the beginning of Exodus or the framing function with the opening chapters of Deuteronomy. Others have pointed to the opening character of these chapters for connecting Deuteronomy and the Torah to other parts of the Hebrew Bible, for example, by drawing attention to the people’s disobedience and to the resulting exile (Deuteronomy 31-32) or to divine faithfulness (Deuteronomy 32-33). The relationship of these various functions establishes a noteworthy dynamic between the connections within the Torah and to texts outside the Torah, between closing and the opening, between the death of Moses and the beginning of a new era for the people. The paper particularly reflects on the theological and hermeneutical implications of this dynamic in light of Deuteronomy’s fabula concerning the succession of Moses.
|
Enoch as Ritual Specialist
Program Unit: Enoch within and outside the Books of Enoch: Parabiblical Writings, Iconography and Oral Tradition (EABS)
Rodney A. Werline, Barton College
Obviously, much of the scholarship on Enoch has focused on the antediluvian figure as a visionary and the recipient of revelations about the structures of the cosmos and future events. Enoch becomes the guardian of this knowledge, which he faithfully transmits to future generations. As more recent scholarship has chipped away at the old categorical distinctions between apocalypticism and wisdom, Enoch has emerged as a sage, which invites comparisons between him and other figures such as ben Sira’. Since traditions in 1 Enoch also label him as a scribe (e.g., 1En. 12:3-4; 15:1), scholars interested in scribal culture have probed the text for hints about the social location and roles of scribes in Second Temple Judaism. To help fill out the figure’s character in 1 Enoch, though, more attention could be given to the significant liturgical and ritual features of the text. Traditions in 1 Enoch show that ritual and liturgical knowledge is key in receiving revelations, in responding to revelations, in acting properly when transported into a visionary scene, and function as performatives through which Enoch engages and includes his “future” audience. Ritual and liturgy draw the audience into the text and provide a way to experience the text and participate in the world envisioned in 1 Enoch. Drawing on several modern anthropological theorists [e.g., Rappaport and Geertz], this paper argues that traditions in 1 Enoch unite the audience with the world of the text, in part, through the presentation of Enoch as a ritual specialist.
|
Critical Spatial Theory and the Place of the Atonement in Hebrews
Program Unit: Epistle to the Hebrews
Cynthia Long Westfall, McMaster Divinity College
David Moffitt’s observation in Atonement and the Logic of Resurrection in the Epistle to the Hebrews that heaven is the place in which the author of Hebrews depicts the atonement leads him to deduce that the culmination of the atonement was after the resurrection and ascension. Negative responses to Moffitt’s work have reflected an overriding theological concern with the time in which he concludes the final act of the atonement took place.
Place and time are linked without question. As Hermann Minkowski who was Einstein’s teacher said, “Nobody ever noticed a place except at a time or a time except at a place.” However, interpreters of Hebrews often ascribe metaphorical, symbolic or otherwise abstract significance to the references to place, treating them as if they were references to time (e.g. most often in eschatological/apocalyptic future) or assigning them to a theological category or idea (e.g. exaltation). Studies on the role of place say that the preference for mapping reality on time is an anachronistic bias of the characteristically modern domination of space by time, and speak of recovering a sense of place on which meaning is mapped which was characteristic of ancient thought.
Critical spatial theory provides definitions and categories for place and space that are helpful, and allow us to explore the meaning of place as its own category in the Book of Hebrews. My thesis is that the interpretation of the Hebrews author of the heavenly tabernacle and its use (priesthood and sacrifices) in the LXX is based on the meaning of place in the continuity and contrast between the past Mosaic tabernacle and what is true in the present of the heavenly tabernacle in the light of Jesus’s sacrificial death.
|
“So They Sat Down in Groups, by Hundreds and by Fifties” (Mark 6:40): New Considerations on Two Cryptic Numbers from an Anthropological Perspective
Program Unit: Open Forum for New Testament and Early Christian Studies (EABS)
Christian Wetz, Carl von Ossietzky Universität Oldenburg
The traditional interpretation of the group sizes in Mark 6:40 as an allusion to the arrangement of the Israelite camp (“Lagerordnung”) according to Exod. 18:25 (and certain other biblical and Qumran passages) seems to be present throughout the entire research history of the feeding of the 5000. Nevertheless, it remains quite unsatisfying. E.g., Mark 6:40 offers only two of the four numbers of Exod. 18:25 etc. and the Markan context is unlike the supposed pretexts not a military one. This paper focuses on the studies of the anthropologist and psychologist Robin Dunbar who managed to demonstrate that the ability of humans to survey the members of a group is limited to groups not bigger than 148 (“Dunbar’s number”). This ability depends on the specific size of the human neocortex. Groups exceeding Dunbar’s number are no longer calculable for the neocortex. If there is in fact a historic core behind the feeding of the multitude, as recent studies of scholars suppose (Theißen, Dunn, Meier), one can assume that the two numbers played a formative role in relation to the “miracle”: The multitude was divided into amounts of people that were calculable for the human neocortex. An individual, possibly carrying some food remnants in his bag (to pick up only one of many controversial historic reconstructions), which he thought would never be enough for all, was no longer surrounded by an inconceivable mass of people, but rather by other individuals. The manageable amount the individual was now a part of made him believe that these remnants were enough – and he started sharing them with the other members of his group so that in the end “they all ate and were satisfied.” The relevance of the two numbers soon became incomprehensible, as their absence in Matthew and John reveals.
|
Traditio-historical Method in the Research of Magne Sæbø
Program Unit: History of Biblical Scholarship in the Late Modern Period
Karl William Weyde, MF Norwegian School of Theology
In research on the Hebrew Bible in the 20th century, the Norwegian scholar Magne Sæbø gave 'tradition history' a broad meaning. He applied it not only to the transmission and composition of the tradition material (M. Noth), or to the theological content and significance of the traditions (G. von Rad), but also to the textual history. He argued that both the oral and the written transmissions of the text were productive processes, but that they also reflect the stability and the reliability of the Masoretic text including its prehistory, which permits us to search for its "Urtext". In this approach, there are influences from both Scandinavian and German scholars, but Sæbø made 'tradition history' an all-embracing phrase.
Following the paradigm shift in biblical exegesis from the 1970s onwards, Sæbø slightly modified his view by focusing on the redaction history of the texts, when a gradual unification of the multiple traditions took place, in which, he argues, the driving force was the moulding power of the monotheistic YHWH theology of ancient Israel. The attempt to uncover this process is the scarlet thread in Sæbø's scholarly works, from his monograph on Zechariah 9-14 (WMANT 1969) to his commentary on Proverbs (ATD 2012).
Sæbø's definition of tradition history also sheds light on how he understands the relationship between the HB/OT in its canonical form and its pre-history. He argues that there was no clear-cut border between Holy Scripture and its interpretation, but rather a gradual transition from Scriptures to their various interpretations. Thus the OT is in itself open to scrutiny of its own 'history of interpretation', since it in various ways involves interpretations of traditions and, to some extent, constitutes the outcome of a variegated inner-biblical exegesis.
|
Collecting Thecla: Supplement, Paraphrase, and the Dynamics of Textual Reception
Program Unit: Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha
Paul D. Wheatley, University of Notre Dame
How do texts mean what we understand them to mean? The passage of time can change the reception of a text and its perceived meaning as new readers bring new interpretive contexts to bear. Between the author, and the reader, and the passage of time, what other dynamics affect the meaning of a text? This paper interrogates the influence of scribes and editors in the dynamics of textual reception, focusing on the act of placing a text in a collection with other texts. As a point of entry, this paper focuses specifically on the story of Thecla as it appears in collections throughout its manuscript tradition.
The story of the martyr-saint Thecla appears, in the earliest recoverable data, to be tied up with the complexities of its textual tradition. Tertullian indicates that not only the story but the very inscribing of the story is problematic, saying in De Baptismo 17,
“If certain Acts of Paul... claim the example of Thecla for allowing women to teach and to baptize, let men know that in Asia the presbyter who compiled that document, thinking to add of his own to Paul’s reputation, was found out, and... was deposed from his position.”
Through Jacques Derrida's theory of the supplement, this paper surveys different strategies scribes and book producers employ in the transmission of this popular, yet problematic text, showing how collecting Thecla with other texts functions as a hermeneutical strategy.
After a brief theoretical introduction, this paper investigates the story of Thecla within the collected Acts and Martyrdom of Paul, the 5th century CE Life and Miracles of Thecla, the 6th century CE Syriac Book of Women, and an 18th century CE Arabic manuscript that includes a preface and postscript to the Acts of Thecla within a collection of miracle and martyr tales.
|
“You Must Love Those Who Hate You”: The Use of Social Identity Theory, the Identity of Persecution, and Social Oppression in the Didache’s Two Ways
Program Unit: Apostolic Fathers and Related Early Christian Literature
Shawn J. Wilhite, California Baptist University
Social Identity Theory (SIT), as a social scientific discipline, in recent years have been making an influence in the study of the Hebrew Bible and New Testament. Jonathan Draper and Stephen Finlan are among the few Didache scholars who have utilized SIT and its application to the Didache. Given that SIT is relatively nascent in Didache studies, as a whole, I will consider how SIT has been explored in biblical and early Christian studies, in addition to Didache studies, and I will apply such social theory to the Didache. The question of inquiry will be: how does the Didachist employ Two Ways material and Jesus tradition to portray the implied reader and historical community as a persecuted oppressed identity? In answering this question, I will explore how Didache scholars have mentioned or offered clarity on the role of persecution, and how SIT may help provide clarity to these topics. Additionally, I will offer exclusive attention to Did. 1 and the use of Jesus tradition, and to Did. 5 and the use of social oppression language. The Didachist reframes Jesus Matthean τελειος language and the lex talionis to reorient the self-identity of the Didache’s community (Did. 1). And, the Didachist writes as an “insider” to describe the “outsider” as a persecuting group, thereby suggesting the Didachist has more rhetorical language than actual historical language (Did. 5).
|
Framing the "Ecological Crisis" Now and Then: A Call for Historical Approach for a Green Reading of Paul
Program Unit: The Bible and Ecology (EABS)
David Wiljebrand, Umea University
In ecological readings of the Bible, it is commonly implied or even emphasized that today’s questions must set the agenda for an ecological reading of the Bible, since the issue – it is assumed – could not have been addressed or conceived in biblical times. Therefore, in the search for answers to our ecological problems and questions, not least from Pauline letters, not much is harvested. However, in the interdisciplinary field of Environmental Humanities, various scholars emphasizes the need of critical deconstruction of the standard modern framings and narratives in which “environmental crisis” and related concepts are embedded. I suggest that an ecological hermeneutics needs the insight that modern ways of describing the predicaments are based on modern world-views and ideas, and that this makes us blind to however an ancient person (including Paul) would describe the issue. Consequently, I propose that this leads us to the ancient context and the need to draw more attention to NT historical background, using knowledge from Environmental History. Here, it is clear that many of today’s problems, such as salinization, overgrazing and resource depletion, have antecedents in antiquity. Moreover, that ancient people had awareness of large-scale human-caused effects on nature and often observed them as negative, and that human (non-)actions towards nature were motivated by different attitudes based on (non-modern!) philosophic/religious/theological frames and narratives. In this presentation, I will give tentative examples of how the understanding of “ecological” problems/predicaments in 1st century ANE supports a green reading of Pauline letters.
|
A Teleological Fallacy in Psalms Studies? Decentralizing the Masoretic Psalms Sequence in Discussions of the Formation of the "Book" of Psalms
Program Unit: Writings (including Psalms)
David Willgren, Academy of Leadership and Theology
It is well known that the issue of the formation of the "Book" of Psalms has been intensely discussed in the last few decades. In this discussion (as with most studies of the Hebrew Bible) the final shape of the collection has provided the foundation on which observations are made and indications as to the prehistory of the collection have been found. Proceeding from the sequence of psalms found in Codex Leningradensis in particular, scholars have identified earlier stages of growth by means of vocabulary, superscriptions, thematic overlaps and more. Although the Dead Sea psalms scrolls have been part of the discussion for a long time, they have not affected this fundamental presupposition. However, since the Dead Sea psalms scrolls reveal quite a significant variance as to both order and selection of psalms, and since they provide the earliest attestation of collections of psalms, the issue needs to be revisited. Overviewing all known manuscripts of the ”Book” of Psalms prior to the first pandects, both Hebrew and Greek, this paper will argue that studies proceeding primarily from the Masoretic sequence of psalms and tracing its growth backwards so that each successive stage of formation builds on the former runs the risk of a teleological fallacy. If taken into fuller consideration, the manuscript evidence reveals that such linear models of growth are not entirely convincing, and the prominent place given to the Masoretic sequence somewhat questioned. Rather, a more complex and multilinear model of growth is suggested, guided by insights from the new philology and exemplified by the way Psalm 106 is found in various contexts.
|
“I Have Seen the Lord”: Jesus in Contemporary Art
Program Unit: Deconstructive Poetics (EABS)
Andrew P. Wilson, Mount Allison University
Despite its centrality to Christian belief and practice, the resurrected body of Jesus has always occupied an ambiguous space. In the text of John 20: 18, for example, Mary’s experience of not being able to touch or recognize Jesus belies her decisive announcement that she has seen the Lord. The depiction of an encounter with the post-resurrected Jesus, thus, has always in some way had to deal with both the impenetrability of this moment and the incompleteness of Jesus’ transformative journey. This tension between insight and incomprehension is manifest, and also continues unresolved, in the Western history of art. Possibly, it provides an explanation for the continued proliferation of contemporary images of Jesus, which often addresses themes and issues far removed from the 1st century context. This paper explores the space between insight and incomprehension over Jesus’ body, by beginning with the confusion of John 20, and following it into a variety of representations of Jesus’ body in art. The latter see Jesus pushed from his traditional artistic formulations into those, such as Wallinger’s Ecce Homo (1999), Cavallaro’s Sweet Jesus (2005) and Kendall Geers Jesusfuckingchrist (2006), which communicate his detachment from the Christian tradition, and cement his role as secular cultural icon. The association of Jesus with non-traditional reference points in contemporary art is revealing both theologically and culturally. By plotting the connections between traditional Christian iconography and contemporary manifestations of Jesus images, it is possible to see an unexpected and unorthodox reinvestment that breaks down boundaries of sacred/secular and invites one to “see” with new eyes.
|
Lydia: Was She the Only Rich Woman in Philippi?
Program Unit: Allusions in the Gospels and Acts
Daria Winiarczyk, Cardinal Stefan Wyszynski University in Warsaw
During the second missionary journey, having crossed the border between Asia Minor and Europe, Paul met an extraordinary woman: Lydia from Thyatira. This “God-fearer” became the first person converted to Christianity in Europe. Therefore, she is traditionally called the "godmother of Europe". The author of the Acts of Apostles presented the figure of the first European Christian in a very interesting way. He showed her as an independent, rich, resourceful businesswoman. Such a portrayal stands in contrast with the traditional ancient image of women. Is it possible that Luke used one of Paul’s letters as a model to make such a portrayal of Lydia? Do we know other women in Philippi who had a similarly high social status? It is worth looking at the Lukan story of Lydia in Acts 16 and compare it with Paul’s Letter to the Philippians to discover interesting allusive relationships.
|
Daughters in the Bible: Fathers Doing "Right in Their Own Eyes"
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Karen Strand Winslow, Azusa Pacific University
The biblical stories that feature daughters and fathers are cryptic, tension-filled, and disquieting, like the biblical son-father stories. While neither set of stories provides models of healthy parent-child interactions, in the biblical daughter stories, the high profile fathers are abusive, indifferent, neglectful, or inadequate in their treatment of their daughters. On the other hand, when daughters are not presented as silent or despairing victims, they outstrip their father or father-in-law in righteousness, wits and/or courage. I propose here that even though male writers wrote daughter-father stories during patriarchal times, they deployed them to either overtly or subtly reproach Israel’s leaders—patriarchs, champions, and royalty. Daughter stories show how doing right in one’s own eyes endangers the family, tribe, and nation, leading to dismemberment, destabilization, and dissolution of the people of God.
Whereas ancient interpreters defended fathers and blamed daughters for the ill that befell them, later interpreters have ignored or marginalized them. Feminist biblical interpreters, however, have underscored the patriarchal values of the producers and interpreters of these texts, which still exist today in many cultures and focus on the daughters and the problems for cultures that accept these texts as Scripture. Most biblical scholars fail to allow for the narrators’ explicit or implicit censure of the fathers. In this paper, I will examine some biblical daughter stories, interact with feminist interpretations of them, and show how the context indicates criticism of the patriarch, champion, or king who utterly failed his daughter. Although the ancient cultural valuation may have been different from that of readers today, and we may not know what these stories accomplished for early audiences, I argue that biblical daughter stories supply counter testimony to patriarchal aspects of the Hebrew Bible. At least, they must do so today.
|
Literary Criticism and Conservative Orthodoxy: Critics of the Q-Hypothesis in Twenty-First Century Denmark and Russia
Program Unit: Rethinking Biblical Written Tradition through Slavonic Interpretations
Vadim Wittkowsky, Humboldt University Berlin
For the joint session: One of the oldest Christian books – the Saying Source called “Q” – is standing somewhere between apocalyptic and wisdom writings, between canonical and non-canonical texts and also between Jewish and Christian literatures. The main problem with this book is, however, its hypothetical status: it is far from clear whether “Q” ever existed, notwithstanding the mainstream opinion of the 20th century. The most serious doubts about the existence of a “lost source” were raised in the last decades, mostly in the United Kingdom and the USA. Since 2010 there are new voices against “Q” from two countries, which were hardly of much significance for the New Testament scholarship in the before time: Denmark and Russia. The reasons on which the “Q” hypothesis is criticized in these countries differ heavily as also do suggestions about the rise of the canonical Gospels. The paper deals with the achievements of the Copenhagen school led by Professor Mogens Müller and the discussion in the Seventh Symposium of Eastern and Western NT scholars in Moscow (2016). The author of the paper participated himself in both main international conferences organized by M. Müller and his group (Roskilde 2014 and 2015) and in the NT symposium mentioned above; he published several articles about the “Q” problem in German, English and Russian.
|
“The Seventh from Adam” and “the Seventh from Joseph” in the Lucan Genealogy of Jesus
Program Unit: Enoch within and outside the Books of Enoch: Parabiblical Writings, Iconography and Oral Tradition (EABS)
Vadim Wittkowsky, Humboldt University Berlin
Henoch is mentioned in the Gospel of Luke (3,37) as one of the ancestors of Joseph, the (step)father of Jesus. Another place in the New Testament – Jude 14 – explicitly claims Henoch to be “the seventh from Adam”. The Lucan genealogy, where Henoch occupies the same seventh place before Adam, is based on “hebdomades” containing 77 names (7x11). The last name in a part of these “hebdomades” belongs to an especially significant Old Testament figure (Abraham in 3,34, David in 3,31). Henoch is the last of them, being the closest to God (3,38). But what about such Lucan “hebdomades”, where the last name is as obscure as the rest of the names? The paper deals with the name at the end of the first Seven, which is “Joseph, the son of Mattathias” (3,24-25). Is it not a cryptogram for the Jewish name of the historian Flavius Josephus? How do these both figures - Joseph and Henoch - at the end of the first and the last of the eleven “hebdomades” function in the Lucan text?
|
The Persecution of Virtue in Greco-Judaean Texts
Program Unit: Virtue in Biblical Literature (EABS)
Jed Wyrick, California State University, Chico
Jewish culture in a Greek or Hellenistic context tends either to praise the virtue of adherence to the law, perhaps in an instinctive or natural way, or extol a more universal virtue that would be recognizable and admirable in both a Jewish and non-Jewish context. Works such as Jubilees seem to focus on the “virtue” of the patriarchs in the sense that they are portrayed as living by the commandments even before their revelation. This approach almost demands a Jewish audience, since it is unclear whether a Gentile reader would appreciate “virtue” being implicitly defined in this manner.
By contrast, works in a Greek cultural context tend to focus on virtues with a more universal appeal, with a special focus on chastity. The figure of Joseph becomes a particular exemplar in Greco-Judaean texts, serving as a typological model whose characteristics can be assumed by other characters. Women like the Esther of the additions to the Septuagint and Judith, while similarly exemplifying blamelessness or chastity, are required to demonstrate a willingness to go to the edge of what their inherent virtue can tolerate. The Septuagint Mordechai and the young men of the Prayer of Azariah are depicted as exceptionally humble, obedient to God, and resolute in the face of adversity. In each case, adversity defines virtue.
Ultimately, a discussion of virtue cannot be separated from the persecution that it begets, whether on the part of Pharaoh, Nebuchadnezzar, or the other villains of these works; for example, Artapanus states that Moses was persecuted by Pharaoh on account of jealousy of Moses’ virtue (aretê). Recognition of the connection between the two concepts requires us to examine the extent to which virtue is conceptualized as the tyrant’s trigger and deployed as a way of explaining anti-Judaean persecution.
|
Deterioration of Judas’ Image in Light of Comparison between Allusion to Psalm 40:10(LXX) in Mark 14:18 and Its Parallel Citation in John 13:18
Program Unit: Allusions in the Gospels and Acts
David Ganlin XIE, The Chinese University of Hong Kong
This paper analyses different functions of using Psalm 40:10(LXX) as Jesus’s saying in the Gospel of Mark and John. Although Mark 14:18 and John 13:18 refer to the same text, different uses of it highlight its different understandings of the referred text as well as the nature of betrayal. I will examine the theme and structure of Psalm 40:10 suggesting various understandings of this Psalm partly due to the problem of its classification. Then the story context in John and Mark will be analysed. It illustrates that Psalm 40:10 serves as the proof of prophecy of betrayal and manifestation of omniscience of Jesus in John. On the contrary in Mark, one would find that Jesus in Mark has borrowed psalmist’s voice as his own voice by echoing the theme of suffering righteous one, crying that being betrayed by dearest friend was the deepest distress he suffered. Their different concerns also shape the image of Judas. John demonstrates the foreknowledge of Jesus so that Judas is directly pointed as the demonic betrayer and subjected to the command of Jesus. Retrospectively, while Mark focuses on the fact of Jesus being handed over by associate rather than the one who acted it, Judas isn’t distinctly singled out to be blamed.
|
The Comparison of the Love in the Gospel of Matthew and the Pauline Letters
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Xu Jun, Chinese University of Hong Kong
Love is the important concept in the Gospel of Matthew and the Pauline Letters. In Matthew22:34-40, “love your God” is the greatest commandment, the entire law and all the demands of the prophets are based on the love commandments. Paul thought that love was the fulfillment of the law(Rom13:10), the entire law was fulfilled in one statement: Love your neighbor as yourself(Gal5:4). Paul and Matthew both held that love was related to the law, and the law was fulfilled in love. This paper analyzes the similarities and differences of love between Paul and Matthew, and the relationship of love and the law in the Gospel of Matthew and Pauline Letters.
|
Lexical Contacts between Anatolian and Hebrew: Historical and Sociolinguistic Interpretation
Program Unit: Israel in the Ancient Near East (EABS)
Ilya Yakubovich, University of Marburg
There are a significant number of Hebrew lexemes displaying close parallels in the Anatolian Indo-European languages, primarily in Hittite and Luwian (Rabin 1963), Despite the temptation to attribute the transfer of Anatolian lexical stock to Hebrew to the mediation of Biblical “inland Hittites” (ha-ḥittî; bēnê Ḥēt), there is hardly any independent confirmation for the presence “inland Hittites” in Canaan (Singer 2006). Therefore, the more current trend is attributing the same transfer, at least in part, to the mediation of the Philistines (Niesiołowski-Spanò 2016: 221-236). The necessary logical step before postulating a transfer from A to B is excluding the hypothesis of a common borrowing from the third source C (Simon 2013). In my presentation I intend to examine the Hittite and Luwian lexemes, suspect of being borrowed into Hebrew, in order to check whether their Indo-European origin can indeed be proven. I will then use the assuredly inherited Anatolian forms as an input for further sociolinguistic conclusions. Niesiołowski-Spanò, Łukasz. 2016. Philistines and Hebrews in Biblical Times. Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz. Rabin, Chaim. 1963. “Hittite Words in Hebrew”. Orientalia 32: 113-139. Singer, Itamar. 2006. “The Hittites and the Bible Revisited”. I Will Speak the Riddle of Ancient Times (Fs. Mazar), ed. A.M. Meier and P. de Miroschedji. Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns, pp. 723-756. Simon, Zsolt. 2013. “Die angenommenen hethitisch-biblischen kulturellen Patallelen: Das Problem der Vermittlung”. Themen und Traditionen hethitischer Kultur in biblischer Überlieferung, ed. M. Hutter (Biblische Notizen 156). Freiburg: Herder, pp. 17-37.
|
Divine Embodiment of Territorial Boundaries of the Hittite Kingdom
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Hajime Yamamoto, Kyoto daigaku
This paper presents the concept of the territories and the national boundaries of the Hittite kingdom in the Late Bronze Age Anatolia by looking at the usages of two Hittite words within ritual texts. The usages of the Hittite verb maniyaḫḫ-, meaning, “to govern; to entrust,” illustrate that the idea of the land of Ḫatti was the divine possession of the state gods, entrusted to the king under his direct administration on earth. Conceptually those lands might have extended from most of the regions in central Anatolia to a part of northern Syria in the east. The sanctity of the territories might be surmised by the metaphor of territorial boundaries (Sumerogram ZAG; irḫa/arḫa in the Hittite language), representing the knees of the Storm-god in a ritual text (KUB 17.29). That ritual indicates that the national boundaries were seen as body parts of the state god and thereby sacred and inviolable. Accordingly, “territories” surrounded by the boundaries might have been seen as divine bodies.
|
Comparison of Hezekiah’s Healing (Isaiah 38)
Program Unit: Medicine in Bible and Talmud (EABS)
Mihi Yang, Claremont School of Theology
The Hebrew Bible shows YHWH’s various healing episodes including His clear self-declaration, “יהוה רפאך” (I am your healer, Ex 15:26). YHWH’s healing is one of the most important of His consistent works through the Old and New Testaments. His healing usually begins with compassion for patients and is performed by prayers, hymns (liturgy), medicine, and miracles. These healing methods have many similarities and differences with old Syriac and Mesopotamian texts. However, prohibition of the latter’s divination or necromancy in the Hebrew Bible may mask the context of healing in the Bible and limit understanding of biblical healing. For example, King Hezekiah’s healing, which appears in three different texts, 2 Chr. 32:24, 2 Kgs 20:1-11, and Isa. 38, includes the above four methods. Therefore, I compare Hezekiah’s healing to ancient Syriac, Mesopotamian, and Qumran healing texts, such as the Kirta epic, the Gula Hymn of Bulluṭsa-rabi, Lamaštu incantation, 11QPsApa, etc. Most ancient peoples thought that sins or disobedience to gods caused diseases. Therefore, exorcism, amulets against Lamaštu or Lilitu, etc., seem to be popular. The Qumran community’s prayers, e.g. 11QPsApa, also show they depend on exorcising power, calling on David’s or Solon’s names. Single or mixed medicinal plants were used for antidotes for kišpū (black spells) or real therapy. Figs for Hezekiah and milk thistle (šcr klb) for drunken Ilu still show their efficacy. Liturgical and medicinal experts were available for patients (ašipútu and asû, respectively). The Apocrypha also notes, “Honor physicians for their services, for the Lord created them” (Sirach 38:1). Compared to the passive Ugaritic King Kirta, the Judean King, Hezekiah, moved YHWH by his prayer, “(God turned) bitterness to peace” (Isa 38:17). Therefore, Judean (biblical) healing shows some cultural or regional similarities, despite religious differences with other ancient peoples.
|
Did the Translator Have a Crib Sheet?
Program Unit: Septuagint of Historical Books (EABS)
Sarah Yardney, University of Chicago
The Septuagint translator of Samuel displays a perplexing inconsistency in his knowledge of Hebrew lexemes. He renders a large number of technical terms accurately, often using equivalents established in the Pentateuch, and yet apparently fails to recognize a similarly large number of much more common Hebrew words. No theory has yet been offered to account for this inconsistency. This paper will propose that the data can be explained if we imagine that the translator had access to a limited Greek-Hebrew glossary of Pentateuchal technical terms. Analogous tools from the ancient Near East and the Greco-Roman world will be adduced to support the plausibility of such a document. The paper will argue that this proposal can bridge a divide in Septuagint scholarship regarding whether later translators used the Pentateuch as a lexicon. The conclusions of this study reframe our understanding of the Septuagint translators’ tools, competencies, and working methods, and suggest new possibilities for the history of the production of the Septuagint.
|
Codex Vaticanus and Bentley's Proposed New Testament Edition: A Preliminary Report
Program Unit: Textual Criticism: Manuscripts & Methods
An-Ting Yi, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam
In 1720, the renowned classical scholar Richard Bentley (1662-1742) published a pamphlet on his proposed NT edition. By using as many ancient manuscripts as possible and by analysing ancient versions and patristic citations, Bentley believed that a fourth-century text could be achieved and thus the Textus Receptus would be replaced. Such a proposal was pioneering in the early eighteenth century when NT textual criticism was still in its formation period. At that time Bentley was well-prepared to undertake this ambitious project, given his roles as Regius Professor of Divinity at Cambridge and King's Library Keeper, his experience of editing classical literature, and numerous collations he had. Notably in the following years Bentley was able to obtain two collations of Codex Vaticanus (B03) from Rome. Regretfully, this proposed edition has never been realised.
Why did Bentley give up the project? Many scholars suggest that his knowledge about B03 could be the main reason because its readings differ significantly from his emerging text. Epp even calls this manuscript as the "death knell" for the edition. But the hypothesis is based on the contemporary scholarly consensus of the prominence of B03. In Bentley's time, however, the manuscript was almost neglected and its value was underestimated. Furthermore, the characteristics of the collations Bentley requests should be taken into account. They are not precise and comprehensive enough according to present-day criteria, and in particular the second collation focuses on later corrections in the manuscript. As a preliminary report, this paper aims to reopen the discussion of the influence of B03 on Bentley's edition from a historical perspective. It will introduce the reception of B03 before the eighteenth century, contextualise Bentley's proposed edition, and summarise his collations on the manuscript. The analysis will also give nuances to our understanding of the history of the field.
|
Philo’s Reincarnational Anthropology: A Comparison with Clement
Program Unit: Judaica
Sami Yli-Karjanmaa, University of Helsinki
The dualism of body and soul manifest in the writings of Philo of Alexandria has been described as even more extreme than that of its model, the anthropology of Plato. In Philo, the body is the foreign land in which the incorporeal soul only temporarily dwells. Licentious life turns the body into a prison or a grave to which the soul returns life after life until it becomes purified through reorientation. Once the mind achieves ability to direct its life towards and in accordance with the things that are “akin to itself”—the divine realities—, it is well on the way to being granted salvation by God.
Philo is clear that although human beings in their earthly life are combinations of body and soul, this is not their proper condition. The body is ultimately not part of the human being. The same holds for the lower, irrational part of the soul: even though it is incorporeal and invisible, it too is mortal, although not in exactly the same sense as the body. For Philo, the soul within the soul and the real human being is the rational mind (nous).
The situation is less clear with Clement. Although he too was a Platonist in his basic philosophical orientation and shares much with Philo, his works include discussions of various things that do not fit into a pure dichotomy of sense-perceptible vs. noetic, such as bodies that are unlike those in this world, corporeal souls, or spiritual blood. As part of a project aimed at finding out Clement’s stance on reincarnation, this paper looks at his anthropology by asking if it is more amenable to positing a special relationship between the soul and one particular body (a key notion in resurrection beliefs) or if it can be reconciled with repeated embodiments.
|
"To Know One Is to Love One": Verbal Connotations of Care in the Amarna Letters and the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Ancient Near East
Tyler R. Yoder, Culver Academies
Scholars have long known that the verbal root ידע in Classical Hebrew, as well as its cognates, such as Akkadian edû, can signal connotations that transcend mere cognition. Presumably ensuing from an intensive relationship with an object, this verbal root can, in both languages, take on the meaning "to take care of" or "to show concern." But it is not the only Semitic root whose semantic range extends in this direction. For example, even a high-frequency Hebrew word that often means "punish" (i.e., Heb. פקד) can, at times, refer to intimate care (e.g., Ps. 8:5). Semantic shifts analogous to these examples occur in even greater frequency in Amarna Akkadian; in fact, at least eight different verbal roots found among the Amarna Letters exhibit secondary meanings related to care. For example, an Amurru scribe employs the verb wabālu ("to carry") to convey "looking after" someone. A similar phenomenon occurs with malāku ("to discuss") at least twenty-five times, just as it does with an anomalous use of lamādu ("to stand"). This study scours the extent and function of such verbs in Amarna Akkadian that rarely and idiosyncratically inherit a connotation of care. Drawing on Vita's 2015 paleographical study, this research sheds new light on Canaanite scribal education during the Late Bronze Age, demonstrating how scribes, operating as diplomats in a contentious political context, creatively and skillfully crafted letters designed both to capture their overlord's attention and elicit a helpful response. This work, in turn, affords an opportunity to observe afresh the ways in which certain Hebrew verbs make similar semantic shifts.
|
Different Types of Pivot Pattern
Program Unit: Judaica
Shamir Yona, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
The pivot pattern, concerning which I myself co-published two papers with Daniel Sivan, has yet to be properly investigated. Yet, the pivot pattern is one of the most important stylistic-syntactical phenomena in biblical parallelism and in Ugaritic parallelism. In fact, we may distinguish within the category of the pivot pattern two principle sub-categories. The first category involves repeating at the beginning of the second half of a verse, a word or phrase that already appeared at the end of the first verse. For example:
Psalm 98:5: Sing praise to the LORD with a lyre//
with a lyre and melodious song
In this category the repetition does not add information. This pivot pattern is a form of concatenation, in which one can always remove the repeated item without in any way changing the meaning of the text.
The second form of pivot pattern, which I wish to discuss, involves a word or phrase which concludes the first half of a verse, while serving at the same time also, as part of the second half of the verse. In this kind the pivot element can serve any given syntactical function. However, it should be noted that when the pivot element is a verb, it is possible that this verb will not correspond in gender and number to the subject of the second clause. The reader is required to recreate the grammatical correspondence as required by the context. I shall discuss a few examples, most of them not presented in previous research. Obviously, in consideration of the time allotted to me, I shall not include every example that I have found.
|
The YHWH Cult at the Time of the Religious Reforms (2 Kings 18–23) in Light of the Urukian Cult Reform in the Eighth Century B.C.E.
Program Unit: Centralization and Cult in Persian Period Israel: Biblical, Historical and Comparative Perspectives (EABS)
Yuan Wenxuan, University of Notre Dame
This paper is a study of the YHWH worship in Judah and Israel during the reigns of Hezekiah, Manasseh and Josiah in light of the cult reform in Uruk in the eighth century B.C.E. Both cases reveal the tension between the “national cult” and local cults.
The first part of my research will be a survey of the Urukian cult reform according to Babylonian records, standing on the latest research by Paul-Alain Beaulieu. Based on Beaulieu’s study of the historical events and their later reception, I will point out three important notions about gods and cults in the context of centralization: 1) the importance of local cults, 2) the “marriage” of gods as means of centralization, and 3) the breaking of vassal treaty as transgression against gods. Due to the frequent interaction between Mesopotamia and Canaan, these notions should not be alien to the biblical world; therefore, in the second part of my paper, I propose to use the Mesopotamian ideology about cult to shed light upon that in Judah and Israel during the religious reforms. I will focus on three biblical passages for case study: the YHWH worship among the settlers in Samaria, Rabshakeh’s Speech during the siege of Jerusalem, and Manasseh’s introduction of Asherah into the temple. As I will demonstrate, all three passages betray the popularity of certain religious beliefs which stand against that of the DtrH. Since the DtrH did not spell out the whole situation in detail, I will use the three Mesopotamian notions revealed in the case of the Urukian reform to shed light upon a more complex understanding of gods, cults and centralization hidden between these lines.
|
Proverbs 26:1-28: Admonition against the Antisocial Types and Its Network of Metaphors
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible (EABS)
Bálint Károly Zabán, Hungarian Reformed Church
Proverbs 26:1-28 offers probably the most extensive admonition against antisocial types in this book. This is composed through reoccurring sequences of similes. It may also be viewed as a characterization and/or caricature of antisocial types. This admonition, characterization and/or caricature, remains uninterrupted for the length of several stichoi. This uninterruptedness offers a fitting context for displaying an array of metaphors, which constitute the warp and woof of this admonition.
Proverbs 26:1-12 is concerned with the fool (כְסִיל/ἄφρων). Apart from 26:12, all the other verses retain the same structure. The first hemistichs display poignant negative vehicles from the order of creation as images (Waltke) and as metaphors of the fool in the social order. These metaphors are predominantly introduced in the text as similes, which may also retain the function of metaphors (c.f. Ricoeur, The Rule of Metaphor). Specifically, in 26:1 the simile of unexpected snow in summer or rain in harvest functions as a metaphor for the unseemly bestowal of honour upon a fool. Verse 2 employs a metaphor from the realm of birds, verse 3 a metaphor from the realm of tools used for guiding domesticated animals, verse 6 a metaphor of self-mutilation, with hyperbolic elements, and the metaphor of drinking violence concerning the occasion when the fool is entrusted with a message etc.
The same remarks apply to 26:13-16, preoccupied with the sluggard (עָצֵל/ὀκνηρός), 26:17-19, incorporating two metaphors concerning the self-inflicting character of the tatlletale, 26:20-22 regarding the slanderer and 26:23-28 in connection with the misanthrope.
It is suggested that in 26:1-28 an unparalleled sequence of similes function as a network of metaphors for various antisocial types. This sequence presents negative vehicles from the order of creation as images and as metaphors of and for the antisocial type to illustrate his disorderliness in the social order of creation.
|
House, Storehouses, and Wealth as a Ransom: A Comparison of a Possible Connection between the Instruction of Supe-Ameli and Proverbs
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Wisdom
Bálint Károly Zabán, Hungarian Reformed Church
The Instruction of Supe-Ameli (also known as The Wisdom of Supe-Ameli; Sima Milka) received considerable attention in recent years. V. A. Hurowitz in an article published in 2007, offers a preliminary presentation of this didactic or reflective composition. More recently, Y. Cohen (2013) provides a translation and an insightful commentary of this composition as it is found in the Akkadian version of it from the Hattusa tablet, the Emmar and Ugarit manuscripts and Hittite parallel texts. Both authors mention possible connections and parallels between this didactic or reflective composition and biblical wisdom texts, such as Proverbs. Still, it is suggested that some additional comparisons may be performed. In lines II. 133’-139’ in The Instruction of Supe-Ameli the son lists the accumulated wealth of the father, exemplified by the building of houses, storehouses etc. and by the acquisition of bribes and taxes. Nonetheless, the son continues the vanity theme, which he introduced earlier on, declaring that all this wealth is of no avail when faced with ephemerality. Conversely, in Prov 13:8a, accumulated wealth seems to feature as a ransom, bribe for a man’s life, which pithy statement puzzled commentators for quite a while. This connection may also be extended to the extensive house imagery used in Proverbs, in relation to Lady Wisdom (house, storehouse) and Folly in Prov 1-9, and the building of human houses in chapters 10 – 31.
It is suggested that while according to The Instruction of Supe-Ameli wealth does not ransom an affluent person when tormented by the arrival of the final moment, in Prov 13:8 the wealth of a prosperous person may serve as a ransom when motivated to respond to moral censure. Since a normal person would offer all he/she has in exchange of his/her life (Job 2:4), assuming that the offended will receive it.
|
“My Brothers Were Plotting Evil”: Family Violence in the Ancient Near East
Program Unit: Families and Children in the Ancient World
Shana Zaia, University of Helsinki
Fratricide has been called “the first crime” by J. Bremmer since it is the first crime committed after the expulsion of humans from the Garden of Eden, featured in the story of Cain and Abel in Genesis 4: 8-10. Stories not only of fratricide but also of other forms of violence against one’s own family members appear in the Bible and ancient Near Eastern texts. As family violence represents profound forms of betrayal and a rupture of familial relationships, the way these events were depicted in ancient Near Eastern texts differ significantly from other forms of death and killing. For instance, in Mesopotamian literature such as "Erra and Išum" and in omen reports, fratricide, parricide, and filicide are symbols of extreme chaos and the breakdown of the natural order. Of particular consequence is violence within the royal family, as this was often the manifestation of rivalries for the throne and had serious implications for the continuing government of the kingdom or empire. The death of a reigning king, for example, was an important event made all the more dramatic if his demise was orchestrated by family members, as one can see by the reaction to the murder of the Assyrian king Sennacherib (705-681 BCE), which was included in the royal inscriptions of his successor as well as in 2 Kings 35-37, though in quite different ways. This paper takes up the question: how was such family violence depicted and discussed in the ancient Near East? Combining royal corpora, literature, and legal texts from the ancient Near East with biblical material, this paper sheds light on how murder within a family was conceptualized to demonstrate the various ways in which societies grappled with this particular form of violence.
|
Before the Polyglots: The Journey of a Text of the Arabic Pauline Epistles
Program Unit: The Bible in Arabic in Judaism, Christianity, Islam (EABS)
Vevian Zaki, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
The text of the Arabic Pauline Epistles in the Paris (1629-1645 CE), and then London Polyglots (1657 CE) was for a long time overlooked. The scant attention it received was limited to identifying its Greek Vorlage. However, this text had a long history in the Greek Orthodox Church before it was utilized to prepare the Arabic text of the Polyglots. In this paper, I revisit the history of this text starting from its early manuscripts and its transmission throughout the centuries. I also demonstrate that it was widely accepted and used in lectionaries and commentaries in the same church, thus posing the question: What are the features of a particular biblical text that grant it a high status in a community?
|
Reception of the Character of David in Judah Halevi’s Book of Kuzari
Program Unit: The Bible in Arabic in Judaism, Christianity, Islam (EABS)
Marzena Zawanowska, University of Warsaw & Jewish Historical Institute
One of the most complex, rich and ambivalent characters in the Hebrew Bible is King David. Despite the fact that Scripture overtly criticizes him for some morally reprehensible deeds and sinful behavior, with time, he became one of the most central figures in all monotheistic traditions which significantly reinterpreted him and his life story. In addition, all these traditions turned him into the pious author of the entire book of Psalms, although the Bible does not make such claims.
In this paper, I would like to focus on reception of the biblical David in one of the most important and influential works of medieval Jewish philosophy and beyond, namely Judah Halevi’s Kitab al-radd wa al-dalil fi al-din al-dhalil, or Kitab al-hujja wa al-dalil fi nasr al-din al-dhalil [The Book of Refutation and Proof on Behalf of the Despised Religion]. It is a treatise of comparative religion, written in Judeo-Arabic in twelfth-century Spain, better known under its shorter Hebrew title Sefer ha-Kuzari [The Book of Kuzari], in which David is among the most often mentioned of all biblical heroes. The purpose of my analysis will be to see what was Halevi’s outlook at this character, what use did he make of him, and why, as well as how far did he go from the scriptural depiction of this figure.
A preliminary scrutiny of all the instances when David is mentioned in Kuzari demonstrates that the author turns this biblical hero of flesh and blood into an abstract, flat and idealized figure of a pious scholar and prophet, detached from any narrative or historical context. He then uses the thus reinterpreted David to support his philosophical and theological conceptions, as well as for polemical purposes.
|
The Lord's Field and Elisha's Spring: Reconstructing P. Egerton 2, 2v
Program Unit: Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha
Lorne R. Zelyck, St. Joseph's College - University of Alberta
I previously reconstructed Jesus’ ‘Miracle on the Jordan River’ (P. Egerton 2, 2v.6-14) based on the apparent parallels with Elisha’s miracles in 2 Kings and Josephus, War 4.460-464. In this paper, I will offer my reconstruction of the conclusion of this miracle (lines 15-16), as well as Jesus’ ‘strange question’ (lines 1-5), based on parallels with pilgrim accounts that connect traditions about the Lord’s Field (Inf. Gos. Thomas 11/12) and Elisha’s Spring (2 Kings 2:19-22).
|
Beyond the National Gods
Program Unit: Israel in the Ancient Near East (EABS)
Anna Elise Zernecke, Universität Bern - Université de Berne
The corpus of Northwestsemitic inscriptions of the 1st millennium BCE gives witness to the national gods and religious concepts of the various states in the Levant in the Iron Age. Due to their genre, concepts of the world at large are only rarely mentioned. The paper examines the very few attestations of „international“ deities in the light of Ugaritic and Biblical texts to reconstruct an outline of a concept of the divine world beyond the small states.
|
Observations on the “Special Introductions” in Maimonides’ Guide of the Perplexed
Program Unit: Judaica
Ying Zhang, East China Normal University
This paper attempts to explore “the Special Introductions” and their function in Maimonides’ Guide of the Perplexed. By “Special Introduction,” we mean those independent passages in the main text of the Guide, to which Maimonides draws readers’ attention with “preface” (tauṭi’a), “introduction” (muqaddima), and “attention” (tanbīh) or “consideration” (i‘tibār). These terms are usually located either before or after the corresponding passages. In other words, the focus of this paper is not on those “formal introductions,” such as the ones proceed the three Parts of the Guide. The proposed paper tries to argue that certain passages, such as the “Introduction” in the Guide II 2, 9 and III 41, and “Attention” in I 73 and III 51, and so on, are the hints given by Maimonides for his addressee or the intended reader to achieve a better understanding of a crucial issue or to trace his true view on different subject matters in a book full of deliberate self-contradictory statements. Among the passages mentioned above, the paper limits itself in dealing with the three in the Guide I 73, II 2, and 9, all of them are related to the subject of creation.
|
| |
|
|