|
|
2014 Annual Meeting
Meeting Begins: 11/22/2014
Meeting Ends: 11/25/2014
Call for Papers Opens: 12/20/2013
Call for Papers Closes: 3/4/2014
Requirements for Participation
|
|
Meeting Abstracts
Isaiah 65 and the Purposes of Preaching
Program Unit: Homiletics and Biblical Studies
Charles L. Aaron, First United Methodist Church
The protoapocalyptic theology of Isaiah 65:17ff. helps define the purpose of preaching itself as offering hope beyond what the hearers can ascertain by looking at events in the world. This theology critiques both evangelical preaching and social justice preaching by acknowledging that human effort may not accomplish the goals either of evangelization or social justice. Because Isaiah 65 is not full apocalyptic, however, it encourages preaching that looks for divine activity in the current creation as well as God's redemption of the creation.
|
Translation of the Colors of the Horses in Zech 1:8; 6:2–3; and 6:6 Based on Textual and Material Evidence
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Diana Abernethy, Duke University
The first and final visions of Zechariah include the Hebrew Bible’s only descriptions of horses in terms of their color. Six color and pattern words occur in Zechariah 1:8; 6:2-3; and 6:6. These color terms have long sparked debate about whether or not these horses have realistic or imaginative colors, whether ‘technical’ or ‘ordinary’ color terms are most appropriate for translating them today, and the significance of these colors for the interpretation of Zechariah’s visions. Recent genetic studies of the coat color of ancient horses prompt a new consideration of these horse coat color terms in Zechariah. This paper combines Athalya Brenner’s textual analysis of the color terms in the Hebrew Bible, Colour Terms in the Old Testament, with a list of genetically probable horse coat colors in Iron Age Israel in order to produce working translations of these terms for American audiences familiar and unfamiliar with horses. This list of genetically probable horse coat colors results from the integration of David Anthony’s 2007 magisterial study of the initial domestication of horses and the subsequent spread of domesticated horses throughout Eurasia, The Horse, The Wheel, and Language, with Arne Ludwig et al’s 2011 genetic study of horse coat color in the ancient world, “Coat Color Variation at the Beginning of Horse Domestication.” Evaluating current genetic analyses of ancient horse coat colors in light of the broader use of color terms in the Hebrew Bible produces translations of these color terms that are as precise as possible given current genetic evidence, sensitive to the contours of the source and target languages, and best suited for modern target audiences. Because modern experience with and vocabulary for horses varies, this paper suggests translations aimed at two contemporary target audiences, Americans familiar with horses and Americans unfamiliar with horses. This study also reveals that the horses in Zechariah most likely possessed realistic colors and that these colors contribute to meaning of the imagery in Zechariah’s visions.
|
Symmetry and Asymmetry in the Qur'an
Program Unit: Linguistic, Literary, and Thematic Perspectives on the Qur’anic Corpus (IQSA)
Dalia Abo-Haggar, Harvard University
This paper examines repetition as a literary technique which yields additional meaning in the Qur'an. Research in the field of Semitic Rhetoric has shown that repetition in classical Semitic texts follows particular symmetrical patterns (parallelism, chiasmus, and circle composition), which are closely connected to the theme. The works of Michel Cuypers, Carl Ernst, and Raymon Farrin have each shown that certain suras are indeed composed in circular or parallel patterns, typical of Semitic Rhetoric. The present paper will investigate one further pattern: asymmetry, whereby deviation from symmetrical patterns invites the addressee to play an active role in extracting new meanings. Asymmetry, as Jerome T. Walsh explains, is deviation from a symmetrical pattern, concentric or parallel. He identifies three varieties of asymmetry; the first is the "unmatched subunit," which occurs when a subunit in one sequence does not have a corresponding subunit in the other. The second variety is "non-correspondence." It is achieved when subunits with corresponding positions in a pattern carry variations of repeated elements common in the pattern. The third category classified by Walsh is "asymmetry of transposition," where the order of corresponding subunits in one sequence does not match that of the other. Asymmetry, unlike concentric and parallel symmetry, according to Walsh, does not provide a "characteristic interpretive dynamic"; however, they invite the listener/reader to revisit , compare and contrast verses or passages in order to account for differences. It is a process that helps reveal more layers of meanings. I will try to demonstrate through examples how these patterns work in the Qur'an. Through some examples selected from sura 83 (al-Mu?affifin) and sura 7 (al-A?raf), I will show that these three types are present in the Qur'an, and that they generate layers of meaning which cannot be detected from linear readings.
|
Studying Women’s Religion in Ancient Israel: Some Methodological Considerations
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Susan Ackerman, Dartmouth College
The Bible, almost everyone admits, is an essential yet a problematic source when it comes to understanding the history of ancient Israel. Its problems multiply, moreover, the further one moves from the context the biblical writers represent: the culture of male scribal, priestly, and prophetic elites who are primarily denizens of urban locales, most predominantly the Southern Kingdom’s capital city of Jerusalem. For those interested in the religious history of ancient Israel, in all its diversity, the Bible’s almost exclusive focus on Jerusalem, and its temple-centered environment, complicates matters even more. How, then, to write a description of women’s religious lives and experiences in ancient Israel? This paper examines various strategies scholars have used, both in reading the biblical text and in going beyond it, in order to overcome the Bible’s deficiencies.
|
The Wisdom Psalms in African Context
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
David Tuesday Adamo, Kogi State University
The study of the Psalter has been dominated by Western scholars. However, African biblical and none biblical scholars have started to do some serious studies of the book of Psalms. This paper attempts to discuss not only the Eurocentric and Africentric approaches to the book of Psalms that are classified as wisdom psalms, but also some of the differences, similarities and the need for cross-fertilization. Despite the fact that the Africentric approach may seem “strange” and even seem “magical” to non-African scholars it is a reality, it is existential and relevant to everyday life of African people. Evidence from biblical archaeology seem to support the fact that ancient Israelites used the book of Psalm for protection, healing and success in life according to the ancient Near Eastern Culture. This supports the Africentric use of the wisdom Psalms.
|
Scribal Status and Authority in Ben Sira and “Dissident” Texts
Program Unit: Economics in the Biblical World
Samuel L. Adams, Union Presbyterian Seminary
The question of the social standing for scribes in the late Second Temple period continues to generate much interest. Who were these individuals, and how much leverage did they have in the society? To what institutional structures (e.g., the priestly establishment) were scribes bound, and what do extant sources reveal about their financial possibilities? This paper will address such questions, with special attention to Ben Sira. Such passages as Sir 8:8-9; 33:19; 39:1-5; and 51:23 merit attention in this regard. Our discussion will explore the implications of Ben Sira’s claims about the scribe’s possibilities for social advancement in light of the socioeconomic context of Judea under the Ptolemies and Seleucids.
This paper will seek to demonstrate that Ben Sira operated as an independent scribal figure whose work involved honoring the priestly class and any wealthy benefactors, while also demonstrating faithfulness to the social justice aspects of the Torah. Since many scribes plied their trade on a freelance basis, their reputation involved a delicate balancing act of interacting with elite persons while acknowledging the ethical demands of their tradition. This paper will argue that Ben Sira’s trenchant critique of financial improprieties is an earnest, daring move for a scribe of his station that deserves more attention in terms of understanding his social position.
In considering this question of social status for the scribe, the paper will also address the background for other notable texts from this larger period, particularly Daniel and portions of the Enochic corpus. The assumption that these are the products of “dissident” scribes whose vision led them to withdraw in certain respects from establishment circles demands reevaluation in light of recent scholarship.
|
Composite Citations of Homer and Their Importance for Understanding the Citation Practices of New Testament Authors
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Sean Adams, University of Edinburgh
Composite Citations of Homer and Their Importance for Understanding the Citation Practices of New Testament Authors
|
The Position of the Fragmentary Manuscript 845 in the Textual History of the Septuagint of 1 Samuel
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Historical Books
Anneli Aejmelaeus, University of Helsinki
This is a fragmentary 4th century manuscript, parts of which are divided between various libraries in Europe. It is one of the earliest manuscripts containing parts of 1 Samuel. Nevertheless, it shows some corrections and additions according to the Hebrew text, which has puzzled the scholars who have dealt with this manuscript before. Although just a fragment, 845 is an important witness throwing light on the early textual history of the Septuagint.
|
The Qur'anic Terminology of the Biblical Tradition
Program Unit: The Qur’an and the Biblical Tradition (IQSA)
Mohammad Hasan Ahmadi, University of Tehran
In both Muslim and Christian Theology to a certain degree historical-critical methods are employed to interpret the Holy Scriptures (Quran; Bible). But the rebuilding of the Q&B interaction is necessary before adopting any method to interpret or compare. In this presentation we try to offer a new approach towards this dealing from the Quran's perspective. The main Question is: Do the terms Tawrat (Torah) and Injil (Gospel) in the Qur'an exactly cover the Biblical tradition? We respond to this question in two parts: 1. What is important for the nature of the Biblical tradition in the Qur'an is the question, to what extant the historical reality and the text of these books nowadays equal these books' definition in Qur'an. For example the message and history of Jesus is written down in the four gospels of Mark (around 70 CE), Matthew, Luke and John (between 70 and 100 CE). From the comparison of the texts it is clear that Matthew and Luke knew and used the gospel of Mark. Beyond Mark, there must have been a second written source common to Matthew and Luke, which is called "Q" in modern Christian exegesis. Finally it is clear that the Bible (New and Old testaments) has been formed and fixed in its writing nature before the period of the rise of Islam (621 CE). From the Qur'an's perspective it is not easy to prove the writing natures for the Torah & Injil. Then it can be concluded that the Torah or Injil is not regarded by the Qur'an as a written and fixed text. 2. The concept of the Biblical tradition changes in the Qur'an such that Muslim researchers believe that the Tawrat (or Torah) and Injil (or Gospel) undoubtedly have been changed. On the other hand, the term "tahrif" has been seriously applied by the Qur'an in numerous occasions. These holy verses beside the other Islamic traditions have led to establishing a common theory among Muslim Scholars. According to this theory the term "Tahrif" is used by Muslims for the Biblical manuscripts alteration which means that Jews and Christians have made change to these manuscripts. Including some internal contradictions, there could be another meaning for this alternation which has been claimed by some scholars. A new theory comes out by deeply studying the Qur'anic verses and Islamic traditions. It is possible to claim that the concept of Distortion is not apparently in perfect coordination with the Qur'anic terminology. This lack of conformity is justifiable through studying the narrations and interpretations of the related verses.
|
Priestly Depiction of Sacrifice in the Mishnah: The Case of Tractate Tamid
Program Unit: Social History of Formative Christianity and Judaism
Mika Ahuvia, University of Washington, Seattle
Scholars of Rabbinic literature have long noted the unusual character of one particular tractate in the foundational Jewish legal code of the Mishnah, called tractate Tamid, which differs linguistically, topically, and structurally from the rest of the Mishnah. I would like to posit that its differences ought to be traced to its origins in priestly circles.
What is missing from present scholarship and the lacuna I hope to fill, is a study of Tamid as a priestly document. Drawing on Jonathan Klawans’s and Mary Douglas’s scholarship on priests and purity, I intend to reconstruct the thinking that framed the sacrificial practices of the priests in the Temple from their own perspective rather than through polemical views presented elsewhere in Rabbinic literature. I argue that tractate Tamid sheds light on the priestly theory of sacrifice, on the temple, on the priests’ own self-conception, on Jewish ideals in the late Second Temple period, and finally on the project of the creation of the Mishnah. In short, I will demonstrate that the vision of sacrifice in Tamid invokes imitatio dei and imitation of Abraham.
My analysis contributes to larger questions about Jewish society and leadership after the temple’s destruction. Contemporary scholars privilege models of conflict, competition or replacement in explaining the rise of the Rabbinic movement: although the Mishnah faithfully documents the cult in the ancient Temple, its very redaction under Judah haNasi demonstrates that the Rabbis have superseded the priests after the destruction of the temple and will now lead Jewish life in Palestine. My reading of the evidence suggests that a different paradigm is possible, one which reconciles and upholds both the significance of the social hierarchies the Torah imparts and the merits of Rabbinic Torah learning.
|
Rabbis, Authority, and the Angels
Program Unit: Midrash
Mika Ahuvia, University of Washington, Seattle
Traditions in rabbinic literature suggest tension between angels and Israel, and assert Israel’s superior status in creation, in liturgy, and in Torah. Interestingly, no source before the rabbis claimed that humans were better than the angels. Scholars have explained this anti-angelic tendency as a response to a so-called gnostic threat or as part of the monotheistic impulse of the rabbis, or as part of the rabbinic emphasis on Israel’s choseness (election theology). My argument is that there is evidence that the rabbis were reacting to other Jews, who themselves upheld angels as an alternative source of authority in Late Antiquity. I argue that in rabbinic literature, we see the rabbis reacting to these other Jewish beliefs by demoting the angels. In my presentation will show that the idea of commingling with angels and aspiring to angelic status was present in the lives of ancient Jews, and moreover that it was actually the more common belief in ancient Judaism, already present in the second temple period and popular throughout late antiquity. Although the rabbinic view (for a number of ancient and modern reasons) prevails today, the rabbis may have actually been the minority voice and the dominance of their positions today obscure the relative marginality of their views in antiquity. When we decenter Rabbinic texts, and bring the liturgical, mystical, and magical evidence into the foreground, we encounter a very different picture of angelic human relations, with Jews aspiring to pray with the angels, to invoke the power of angels, and even to become angels.
|
Inscriptions and Septuagint Lexicography
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
James K. Aitken, University of Cambridge
Inscriptions have played second fiddle to papyri in the study of Septuagint vocabulary. Undoubtedly the papyri have provided a rich field, and one that still requires further exploration, and remain the closest in terms of register to the Septuagint. Nevertheless, the inscriptions remain important, as Deissmann had himself recognized but was prevented by time from devoting effort to their exploration. This paper will examine the contribution inscriptions can make, especially as they offer a far larger database of words, a broader geographical scope and different registers from papyri. It will trace the use of inscriptions in Septuagint lexicography and illustrate with examples the sorts of insights that can be made through the incorporation of epigraphic data.
|
Genesis 3:5 in the Ethiopic Tradition
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Alemayehu Gabreil, Saint Vladimir's Orthodox Theological Seminary
This paper examines the influence of Patristic, and Jewish Literature on the Ethiopic Commentary on Genesis 3:5
|
Rhetorical Texture and Pattern in Philo of Alexandria's De Decalogo
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Manuel Alexandre Jr., Universidade de Lisboa, Portugal
ABSTRACT
Philo of Alexandria didn’t use lofty words and impressive thoughts to comment De Decalogo. But, as Nikiprowetzky asserts, philosophy and rhetoric can be remotely felt in its background. Philosophy shapes the thoughts that give his commentaries substance, and rhetoric shapes the harmony and power of their expression. For him, Philo’s style was often admirable. And it wasn’t just a question of eloquence or style.
As I will show in this paper, Philo creatively used forms of argumentation as practiced in the progymnasmata and fixed in the Greek textbooks of prose composition and rhetoric, namely those related with thematic elaboration. Exploring the argumentative texture of De Decalogo in its multiple kinds of logical and qualitative reasoning, I found rhetorical coherence and effectiveness in the discourse as a whole and in the particular units that compose it. My critical analysis brought to the surface types of argumentative topics and structures which sustain my conviction that the essence of true rhetoric is pervasive in Philo; a learned process of argumentation that is more than a taxonomy of linguistic devices and persuasive strategies.
|
How Did the Jewish Sabbath Become the Christian Sunday?
Program Unit: Sabbath in Text and Tradition
Edward Allen, Union College
The process whereby Christians came to worship on Sunday appears to have begun in the first century of Christianity. This process has been the topic of scholarly study for at least four hundred years. Theories range from the contention that Jesus informed his disciples of the change between his resurrection and his ascension to the idea that anti-Judaism was the principle reason for the change. Recently, the work of Samuele Bacchiocchi has provoked considerable interest in this topic. His book, From Sabbath to Sunday (1977), along with his self-promotion of the book provoked a response from D. A. Carson with the volume From Sabbath to Lord’s Day (1982). Since the publication of these two volumes discussion has continued, though there appears to be less scholarly interest in the topic in the last fifteen years. I propose to review differing theories of the origin of Sunday worship in the first century of the Christian era. I will consider theories developed between the time of the Protestant Reformation and the present. In conclusion, I will review reactions to Bacchiocchi’s and Carson’s volumes and attempt to bring the discussion up to date.
|
Rewriting Zechariah's Horse Visions in Antiquity
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Garrick V. Allen, University of St. Andrews
It is widely acknowledged by modern commentators that Zechariah's horse visions (Zech 1.8; 6.1-5) are incohesive in terms of number and colours of horses. Scholars (esp. Meyers and Meyers) often turn to textual emendation to make sense of the rutted texture of Zechariah’s visionary discourse. This perceived inconsistency was also acutely noted by ancient readers and afforded ample exegetical attention. This perception is preserved in the various ways that the scribes who produced Zechariah's ancient versions (OG/LXX and Targum Jonathan) created greater lexical and numerical consistency between these passages. This co-referential reading of logically similar visions is also preserved in an early Christian visionary text—Revelation 6.1-8—wherein the author greatly expands the purview of Zechariah’s visions but retains evidence of a careful reading of Zech 1.8; 6.1-5. The purpose of this essay is to examine the exegetical procedures by which these ancient scribes/authors created greater coherence between Zechariah's horse visions and the underlying strategy of reading that motivated the impulse to rework these passages. This goal is accomplished by analysing the extant textual evidence witnessed in the OG/LXX, Targumim, and the book of Revelation and, secondarily, by describing the exegetical processes by which these scribes/authors reworked the text of Zech 1.8; 6.1-5.
|
Religious Persecution: A Lens for Contemporary Biblical Hermeneutics in Northern Nigeria (with Romans 12 as a Test Case)
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Isaiah Allen, Asbury Theological Seminary
Persecution has shaped the way Nigerian Christians interpret scripture. Africans who interpret the Bible through the lens of present-day issues employ a type of reader-response criticism that has been called an “inculturation hermeneutic.” After I argue the validity of such an approach, I present an original exegesis of Romans 12, sensitized to the issue of religious persecution. I aim to demonstrate that this reading strategy, when integrated with other critical methods, may yield fresh, practical, historically sound, and compelling insights into New Testament texts.
|
Jesus the Pharisee: Expectation and Conflict Pertaining to Table-Fellowship as Indicators of Jesus Socio-religious Identity
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Tobias Ålöw, University of Gothenburg
In a number of studies J. Neusner has demonstrated how the key distinguishing feature of the Pharisees was their exclusive table-fellowship. In order to uphold the laws of what was originally Levitical purity in relation to food in everyday-life, the sectarians organized societies so that their members could share their meals at an uncontaminated table and thus maintain their ritual purity. In Neusner’s words, a Pharisee, “…ate only with other Pharisees…” While this depiction has been generally acknowledged, its perhaps most interesting implication does not appear to have been realized: If the Pharisees ate only with other Pharisees, then how come the Gospel of Luke tell of them inviting Jesus to share their table-fellowship on three occasions (Luke 7:36–50; 11:37–54; 14:1–24)? Was Jesus perhaps also a Pharisee, or are these traditions more the result of Luke’s fascination with meals combined with his positive predisposal towards the Pharisees? This paper explores these issues and argues with reference to non-Lukan traditions in which Jesus is expected to follow Pharisaic legislation (Mark 2:13-17; 7:1-23, par.) that the most natural conclusion to draw is that Jesus was indeed considered a Pharisee. This adds a much needed praxis-oriented dimension to the long noted theological similarities between Jesus and the “first philosophy”, and thus goes some way in establishing a factional affiliation on behalf of Jesus.
|
On the Road: Judean Royal Merchants in Babylonia
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Tero Alstola, Leiden University
As a consequence of the deportations to Babylonia, people of Judean origin start to appear in the Babylonian cuneiform sources in the sixth and fifth centuries BCE. Most of the available documents originated in an agricultural context in the Nippur region, but some Judeans were living in cities such as Babylon and Sippar. The socio-economic status of the immigrants varied a lot, but the Babylonian and Persian societies did not discourage the economic activity of the Judean newcomers.
A family of Judean royal merchants appears in five cuneiform documents from the mid-sixth century BCE. They were living in Sippar in Northern Babylonia, where state investments had triggered an economic boom both in trade and agriculture. As royal merchants, the Judeans were working for the palace, and their business activities involved trade in luxury products imported to Babylonia. The paper discusses the socio-economic status of the merchants and their integration into the Sipparean trading community. It has been suggested that immigrants had an important role in the Babylonian long-distance trade, and the present case study further corroborates this view. In the end of the paper, the question of the merchants’ role as an intermediary between Judah and the Judean exiles is raised.
|
Famine and Food Shortage: The Literary Motif and Its Political Implications
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Peter Altmann, University of Zurich
This paper investigates the nature of famine and food shortage in the Hebrew Bible and ancient Near Eastern texts. For, while Peter Garnsey addressed the problematic of food shortage for classical antiquity some 25 years ago, little comparable work on the ancient Near East or the Hebrew Bible exists. This study seeks to address the desideratum, discussing the depictions of the causes and experiences of food shortage in biblical texts and the surrounding cultures. Significantly, numerous Mesopotamian, Egyptian, and West Semitic sources link agricultural abundance with political success. Accordingly, this paper considers the extent to which biblical and extra-biblical sources depict shortage and famine in terms of political failure.
|
Mixed Motives: Justifications of War in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Warfare in Ancient Israel
Frank Ritchel Ames, Rocky Vista University College of Osteopathic Medicine
Nations declare war for ideological and economic reasons, but motivations behind violent conflict are always mixed and are often unrecognized or unacknowledged. This paper identifies and categorizes explicit and implicit justifications of war presented in Hebrew Bible narratives and compares and contrasts idealogical rhetoric to socioeconomic factors in ancient Israelite communities. The approach is interdisciplinary, with attention given to the design and provenance of biblical texts and to current socioeconomic explanations for the pursuit and avoidance of organized violence by social groups, both ancient and modern.
|
The Fool, the Wicked, and the Idol Worshipper: The Transformation of a Sapiential Scheme in Wisdom 12–15
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Sonja Ammann, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin
The opposition of stereotypical figures like the fool and the wise, the wicked and the righteous is a well-known scheme to approach human behaviour in wisdom literature. The opposition between the wicked and the righteous also permeates the first chapters of the Wisdom of Solomon. In this paper, I will show that the characteristics that mark off the wicked against the righteous in Wisdom 1-5 appear again in the description of the worshippers of idols in chapters 12-15. Thus, the idol worshippers are modelled on the wicked. The contrast of the wicked and the righteous in the Wisdom of Solomon is based on the antithetical description of human types as found in the book of Proverbs. In later wisdom, the wicked coincides with the fool, as can be seen in the Septuagint of Proverbs. The description of the idol worshippers in the Wisdom of Solomon presupposes that foolishness and impiety have become related, and applies the scheme of the wicked/fool as opposed to the righteous/wise to idol worshippers. Drawing on results of my discourse analytical study on idol polemics, I will show that this development stands in a line which can be traced back to the Letter of Aristeas, Jeremiah 10 and Second Isaiah. This exploration will reveal that the antithetical sapiential scheme proves highly adaptable to issues which were not traditionally dealt with in wisdom literature. Wisdom 12-15 transforms it into a powerful tool to turn all of humankind – except for the worshippers of the biblical god – into wicked fools.
|
A New Leading Family 1 MS: Codex 2193 and Family 1 in Mark
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Amy S. Anderson, North Central University
Recent years have witnessed a number of scholars giving new attention to the MSS that belong to Family 1 in the Gospels. While Codices 1 and 1582 have been shown to be nearly identical and outstanding representatives of the archetype in all four Gospels, another MS deserves attention. Codex 2193 was shown to have a Byzantine text by Anderson’s work in Matthew, but in Welsby’s work in John it was demonstrated to combine with two others to provide a core Family 1 witness independent of 1 and 1582. Current work in Mark will demonstrate that 2193 stands with 1 and 1582 as a third independent core witness.
The presentation will demonstrate how these conclusions were reached, as well as raise questions about relationship to several lesser Family 1 MSS. The energetic corrections applied to this MS will also be discussed.
|
Situating Obadiah: Textual and Visual Perspectives on the Context of a (Very) Minor Prophet
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Bradford A. Anderson, Mater Dei Institute, Dublin City University
When exploring the reception of Obadiah, the question of the historical setting and context of the prophet is one of the more striking issues that one encounters. While contemporary scholarship, with almost complete unanimity, places the book in the exilic or post-exilic periods, this has not been the assumed setting for readers and hearers throughout history. Indeed, pre-modern readers often understood the book to be pre-exilic in setting, either because of canonical resonances with the Obadiah found in 1 Kings, or because of the book’s placement in the early part of the Book of the Twelve. Not surprisingly, it was with the Reformation and the rise of more historically-interested readings of the Bible that the shift toward an exilic reading became commonplace, a reading strategy that has held sway down to the present day. Meanwhile, the visual representations of the prophet and the book also demonstrate the complexity of situating Obadiah, at times following a strikingly similar trajectory to that found in written exegesis. This paper will thus look to Obadiah’s reception history, outlining some of the significant developments in the attempt to situate Obadiah in particular settings and contexts, and, using a variety of images, tracing how the visual depiction of the prophet can be seen to both cohere and diverge from written exegesis on this shortest of prophetic texts.
|
The Voyage Back to the Vineyard: Allusion in Mark 12:1–12
Program Unit: Markan Literary Sources
Craig Evan Anderson, Azusa Pacific University
In Mark 12:1-12, Jesus tells a parable to the temple authorities in response to their provocative questioning of the basis of Jesus’ authority. The parable that Jesus tells alludes to Isaiah 5:1-7. However, this allusion features numerous significant modifications from the Isaiah source text: First, the term of evaluation in Isaiah 5 is only temporal – the time of the harvest; Mark adds to the temporal harvest element a spatial element – the vineyard owner’s departure to a different country. Second, Isaiah links the descriptor, “beloved” to God, the vineyard owner; Mark changes the descriptor, “beloved,” to refer to the vineyard owner’s son. Third, the focus of judgment that God destroys in Isaiah 5 is the vineyard itself due to the wild grapes that it grew; Mark shifts the focus of judgment to the tenants who have occupied the vineyard in the landowner’s absence, asserting that the landowner will eventually destroy them.
This parable in Mark 12:1-12 taps into the traditional authority of Isa 5:1-7 as a biblical text of prophetic judgment, yet it modifies it in order to conform to the narrative framework that the Odyssey provides. First, by adding a spatial orientation, Mark emphasizes the notion of geographic distance separating the family estate from Odysseus, the rightful claimant of that estate. Second, by applying the descriptor, “beloved,” to the returning son, Mark places attention on the son (Odysseus) in the context of his homecoming. Third, by directing the landowner’s destruction toward the tenants, Mark highlights Odysseus’ slaughtering of Penelope’s suitors who have ungratefully occupied Odysseus’ land amidst his absence.
Therefore, Mark reframes Isa 5:1-7 around the narrative of the Odyssey in order to demonstrate that the true heir of God’s city, Jerusalem, is his son, Jesus (Odysseus), not the current temple authorities, who are merely unwelcomed tenants (Penelope’s suitors). In order to solidify the motif of the homecoming of the rightful heir, Mark 12:10 then cites Ps 118:22, which comes from a psalm precisely about this topic – celebrating God destroying foes on behalf of the rightful king.
|
From Enoch to Jesus: Similarities between the Enochic Worldview and Q
Program Unit: Construction of Christian Identities
Olegs Andrejevs, Lewis University
The history of one of the earliest Judeo-Christian communities, the one behind the Synoptic Source Q, has long been a subject of scholarly inquiry. That there was some form of a communal experience, a Q group, appears in little doubt: the reconstructed document’s compositional stages feature both an optimistic vision of a missionary outreach and a bitter reaction to the hostility and ridicule with which these missionaries were met. But while the Q studies have largely focused on the group’s travails, little attention has been paid to the possible origin of these early followers of Jesus.
This paper will highlight and examine a number of theological parallels between the Q group’s beliefs and worldview and those of the followers of Enoch, especially as these views are reflected in the Book of Parables and in Jubilees. It will show that the branch of early Judeo-Christianity represented by the Synoptic Source appears to have been strongly influenced by some of the Enochic ideas. It will argue that this influence proved to be particularly instrumental in the formation of the Q group’s christology, demonology, and self-identity as an apocalyptic community of elect. Based on this evidence, it will finally propose that at least at one of its formative stages the Q group is likely to have actively interacted with the Enochic movement.
|
Violating Women in the Name of God
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
Rosie Ratcliffe, King's College - London
The critical and commercial success of violent films and computer games and of sexualized super-women (think Lara Croft), testify to the fact that sexuality and violence fascinate and captivate. The visual effects that are available today were not available in antiquity. Nevertheless, authors of martyrdoms produced visual effect through narrative. In this respect the systematic cruelty and violence that martyrs endured was remembered and recounted in particularly graphic ways. Although martyrdoms were stories about transformation, mastery of the self and, God’s victory over earthly powers, female martyrdom accounts often depicted the violence women endured more as sado-erotic display. Such accounts told of women who were exposed and sexualized in gladiatorial type contests with cheering spectators: a captivating extravaganza enticing the male gaze. Christians too participated in this spectacle.
This erotic, violent performance, of course, had serious, religious dimensions to it but, were ancient narrators of martyrdoms gender neutral in their recounting of a saints death? In looking at the rhetorical effect of martyrdoms what we find is a notion of gender that endorses the sado-erotic treatment of women. By utilising contemporary feminist theorising about violence and pornography I will show that, despite modern technology and its use in producing very graphic sexual violence, modern conceptions of pornographic violence correspond well with certain scenes depicted in martyrdoms. Within this paper I will explore how the genre contributes to the formation of an ancient discursive field of gender and sexuality and reflects and inscribes a certain “normativity” vis-à-vis gender construction. Do these texts leave room for us to nuance patriarchal men writing women and, considering how women’s piety developed in later years (Holy Anorexia recounts the flamboyant suffering of female saints), do such representations of pornographic violence ultimately invite legacies that promote and perpetuate the violence done to women?
|
Systematic Theology’s Use or Misuse of the Book of Job
Program Unit: Theology of the Hebrew Scriptures
Jennifer Andruska, University of Cambridge
This paper seeks to address the way in which Systematic Theologians engage the Book of Job when constructing their doctrines, particularly concerning innocent suffering, God’s justice, retributive theology, and disinterested righteousness. In order to assess the relationship, twelve more recent systematic theology volumes were cataloged in three ways. The scripture indexes of the various volumes were consulted in order to see which chapters of Job were being referenced heavily and which were not. The scripture indexes were next consulted to see which characters were most often quoted in support of the theologian’s theology. Finally, each scripture index reference was looked up within the volume, in order to ascertain what topic the reference was being used to address, which doctrine it was used to support, and if it had any relevance to the reference’s contextual meaning in the book of Job. Several surprising observations emerged from this study. A disproportionately large number of references came from the introduction and conclusion of the book rather than the middle, and addressed a number of topics that have little to do with the focus of the book. The references to the middle of the book also often did not address the same topics as the texts within which they were found. Many of these citations were made without any recognition of their surrounding context, as many of them actually belonged to arguments that contradicted the way in which they were used by the Systematic Theologian, or were found within an argument that the book of Job later declared false. The paper concludes by discussing four major theological topics that do emerge from a careful study of the book of Job and asks why they have not been allowed to inform the doctrines of Systematic Theology.
|
Functions and Provenance of Deuteronomy 32: A Comparison between the Greek and Hebrew Text
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Anna Angelini, Lausanne University
The so-called “Moses farewell song” has received much attention scholarly attention due to its strategic function within the construction of the book of Deuteronomy, its poetic features, and the text-critical problems it raises. The main issues concerning its dating and provenance, while debated at length, remain far from solved, with some recent scholars suggesting an early date of composition (Sanders 1996, Thiessen 2004; contra Meyers 1961, Boston 1966, von Rad 1966). Crucially, throughout the poem one finds key references to the representation of the heavenly court in Ancient Israel and the relationship of Yhwh with others divine entities. It is well known that the Greek versions and Qumran fragments constitute testimonies of primary importance for verses referring to the “sons of God/sons of Israel” (8 ff. and 43), probably reflecting an earlier stage of composition than MT. I will argue that a systematic comparison between the Hebrew and Greek versions of Dt 32 can help in clarifying the redaction process underpinning the composition of the poem, as well as the distance between the Hebrew text and its Greek reception. The Persian or Early Hellenistic periods will be considered as possible contexts for the final composition of Dt 32. Focusing on the different forms and representations of divine agencies in the Hebrew text and in its Greek translation (the sons of God, the new gods shedîm/daimonia, the helpers of Yhwh Reshep and Qeteb) as key passages, I will combine text-critical and historic-religious approaches in offering my own contribution to the discussion concerning the historical provenance of the poem. A reassessment of these questions surrounding Moses’ farewell song can provide useful tools for further studies concerning fundamental aspects of the development of Israelite religion: the polemic against idols, the relationship between Yhwh and “foreign” gods, and the persistence of the imaginaire of the heavenly court surrounding Yhwh.
|
Job, Liminality, and the Powers of the Weak
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Christopher Ansberry, Oak Hill College
The conception of human life as a series of status incumbencies acquired through various limina of passage has served as a theoretical framework within which to view the socio–symbolic dimensions of the biblical materials in general and Israel’s wisdom literature in particular. While various studies focus on the liminal phase within rites de passage in order to illuminate the Sitz im Leben or Weltanschauung of the sapiential materials, few have explored the powers attributed to individuals within this transitional state. In view of this lacuna, this paper explores the degree to which Victor Turner’s discussion of power vested in liminal individuals may serve as a heuristic guide for understanding the social and ritual dynamics of the Joban dialogue. The study will consist of three parts. The first will summarize Turner’s conception of the powers of the weak; the second will give particular attention to Job’s liminal status, while the third will consider the way in which the powers of the weak are employed in Job’s discourses. In so doing, this study attempts to enhance the ritual dimensions of the Joban dialogue as well as the conceptual world of the individual parties in the debate.
|
Collaborative Hermeneutical Reading of 1 Tim 3:1–7 in the Ghanaian Context
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Eric Bortey Anum, University of Cape Coast
Most Churches in Ghana use 1Timothy : 3:1-7 as blue print in either formulating titles in or to screen eligible people for short-listing and appointment into leadership positions in their Churches.
It is however not very clear why almost all Churches quote this text and use it in the selection and composition of leaders even though there are other equally good biblical texts.
To address the leadership issues in Ghana and the conflicts we have to resolve in Ghana concerning leadership one cannot overlook an institution like the Church in Ghana which is massive and have the capacity to nurture leadership for their respective contexts or even show case leadership for other sectors of the society to learn from as the Church is listened to and has a strong voice in national affairs.
Put together, Christians in Ghana constitute over seventy percent of the population. Leadership and its constituent elements are vital concepts for the development of any society and so leadership in churches for the Ghanaian society. The crux of all church activity is spirituality, with the Bible providing guiding principles. At the heart of this spiritual leadership is the desire to create the space for the adherents to replicate in their respective communities leadership models in churches in Ghana which is Bible based, exemplary and iconic. The youth has been complaining that there seem to be some challenges in applying this text in their respective Churches. This therefore calls for a closer reading of the text with them since they will be taking the mantle of leadership in their respective Churches later.
This paper explores this familiar text (1 Timothy 3: 1-7) which most Churches in Ghana employ in establishing and maintaining their leadership structures in their set ups. This is to find out how the text will be interpreted and utilized by youth who are aspiring leaders in their Churches and para-church organizations.
Indeed we have so many powerful charismatic and flamboyant preachers but we do not have many who can boldly say that their leadership models should be followed. The situation has become so urgent these days as we noticed young people are now assuming leadership positions as Chief Executive Officers after their twentieth birthday in their secular lives. The Church is the arena for moulding eligible people for leadership positions in the society at large.
The question therefore is what is the mechanism for cultivating and appointing leaders for the Church?
This work uses the collaborative hermeneutical reading method with selected youth in the Cape Coast Metropolis in Southern Ghana. This method gives room for different classes, and levels of education and understandings to read the text together to find meaning through a discursive method which gives privilege to all the readers to contribute towards the reading process. The method is a contextual approach to the Bible that employs interaction between stakeholders of the Bible together to create meaning, with the scholarly reader acting as a midwife to bring forth meaning.
|
Engaging the Bible in the Late Medieval Peninsula: Ta’yid al-Milla and the Mudejar Polemics with the Jews
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
Monica Colominas Aparicio, University of Amsterdam
Ta’yīd al-milla [The Fortification of the Faith] is an Arabic polemic against the Jews written in 1361 by an Aragonese Mudejar. This work was later adapted into aljamiado and was read until the 17th century by the Iberian Muslims converted to Christianity. One central element of Ta’yīd is the author’s approach to the Bible: its authenticity is not debated but he rather pleads for an alternative reading that prefigures and affirms Islam. Here I will suggest that the uses of the Bible in this work are a novelty in the context of anti-Jewish Muslim polemics in the Iberian Peninsula and the Maghreb but that, nevertheless, these are consistent with attitudes found in other Muslim authors alongside the Mediterranean. My analysis points toward an oriental origin of the sources of Ta’yīd and calls attention towards the importance of the Bible when constructing and defending the Muslim identity in the middle Ages.
|
Strangers in a Strange Land: Creating a Heart-Centered Praxis
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Deborah A. Appler, Moravian College & Theological Seminary
The Hebrew Bible recounts stories of people journeying from one place to another for many reasons—to search for food or a better way of life or to join in a new marriage. Some may find themselves on the run in an attempt to flee injustice and others are forcefully displaced from their lands by conquering powers. Regardless of their reasons for leaving home, these sojourners come into contact with the unfamiliar or with those who are alien to them, This takes them out of their comfort zones to places of vulnerability and fear that, when misdirected, often leads to brokenness in relationships. Many contemporary conflicts operate in the same manner. As co-instructors of a course dedicated to offering tools for empowering students to build genuine relationships among people from all aspects of the “beloved community,” we aspire to assist students to see that vulnerability and fear are not weaknesses. They are stair steps for exploring one’s own multiple identities and paths to opening up to others. The tools that we draw upon come from the fields of critical consciousness theory, Social Justice education and biblical studies.
This paper will demonstrate how biblical texts, specifically Ezekiel 1:1-28, can elicit honest discussions about identity and close encounters. Ezekiel and his community are forcefully exiled and replanted in Babylon to live, work and worship among those who are strangers. As he and his community dwell by the river Chebar in Babylon, Ezekiel has a strange vision that illustrates the fear and vulnerability he and his community experience among these new people. The terrain is stormy (v.4), the images of people he encounters are frightening (vs. 5-14), eyes peer out of wheels and track his every move (vs. 15-21). Does this encounter mirror the reality of being out of his comfort zone? Yet in the midst of Ezekiel’s curiosity and willingness to engage with the strangers in the vision in spite of his fear, he and the community encounter the divine (vs. 22-28). Our goal as we move through our discussion of Ezekiel 1 is to apply critical consciousness theory and social justice education as a means for self-reflection, identity awareness, and dialogue in the hope that students grow a heart for hospitality and for co-creating the “beloved community.”
|
Why the Biblical Civic Center Is at the City Gate and Not in Its Physical Center?
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Rami Arav, University of Nebraska at Omaha
When biblical cities civic centers are compared with the Greco Roman cities, an important difference singles out. While the civic center, whether it is the Greek Agora or the Roman forum, was always in the physical center of the city, the biblical civic center is located at the gate, the edge of the city, far removed from its physical center. What would be the reason for this? Why would people do their businesses at the liminal portion of the city and not in the midst of it?
Moreover, when researching the origin of the Iron Age city gates in the Levant, it becomes apparent that they did not evolve from the Middle Bronze predecessors. The Iron Age city gates looked totally different and had different functions.
Furthermore, when analyzing the attitude of ancient sources to the city we discover an interesting compliance. The Hebrew Bible is by and large negative to the city. Cities were founded in sin. The founder of the first city was none other but Cain the forefather of all criminals. Most prophets condemn the city dwellers and accuse them with corruption. Isaiah calls to leave the city go back to the desert and start all over again. Jeremiah wished to be lodging in the desert “For they are all adulterers, a band of traitors”. (Jeremiah 9: 1-2 [NRSV]). Amos condemns the city dwellers of Samaria: “you cows of Bashan who are on Mount Samaria, who oppress the poor, who crush the needy, who say to their husbands, “Bring something to drink!” (Amos 4:1 [NRSV]).
The NT is no different. Jesus refrained from entering any city except for Jerusalem. But on the other hand, the LXX written in a city and aimed to city dwellers conveys a different attitude to the city and so were the Greek philosophers who maintained that they could not function outside the city.
So what was there in the Biblical city that was so negative? This paper attempts to answer this question by looking at the physical remains of the city and by applying cognitive archaeology to the finds.
Archaeological surveys indicate a situation similar to the textual evidence. Most Israelites did not dwell in cities. It seems therefore that the cities with their formidable fortifications were viewed as a threat. Most people wished to avoid the city centers and to carry out their businesses at the gates of the cities rather than the core of the city. This was not the first time in the history of the Southern Levant that animosity and fear of city dwellers is encountered. The population of the majestic cities of the Middle Bronze Age, dwindled during the Late Bronze Age as a growing number of dissidents left the cities to live in the country. This disposition was ubiquitous all over the Ancient Near East and is known as the phenomenon of Habiru and Apiru.
|
An Intellectual and Theological Coming of Age: Messianic Judaism at the Turn of the 21st Century
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Yaakov Ariel, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
In the 2000s-2010s, a new generation of Messianic Jewish intellectuals has further developed the theological independence of the movement and its scholarly enterprises. Introduction to Messianic Judaism serves as a declaration of the movement’s scholarly coming of age. Merely a few years earlier, such a literary endeavor would not have been possible. The volume gives voice to the intellectual interests and self-perceptions of the group. While the book draws a connection between the contemporary and early Jewish believers in Jesus it also promotes the importance of dialogue between Messianic Jews and other groups of Christians and Jews.
|
Euripides and Ephesians: Peripeteia and Deus Ex Machina in Eph 2:1–10
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Elizabeth Arnold, Gardner-Webb University
Ephesians 2:1-10 is replete with dramatic language. Given the oral nature of letter sending and receiving in the ancient world, the audience or congregation would have deftly employed visualizing techniques borrowed from the theatre. Greek theatre was the single most effective conduit of culture, philosophy, and religion in the Hellenized world. Therefore, an audience familiar with receiving education through drama would have heard the terms and descriptions in the Letter to the Ephesians and visualized contemporary “special effects” seen, heard, and discussed in regard to the theatre. The most influential and innovative playwright of the Greek world being Euripides, it is a reasonable assumption that the author of Ephesians would have been educated in the literary and dramatic plot devices used in Euripidean plays.
Upon establishing the importance in the Greco-Roman world of theatre in general and Euripides in particular, this paper will evaluate the general dramatic technique of peripeteia and the more specific device of deus ex machina used in Euripides plays Medea and Alcestis, then demonstrating how the same devices function in the drama of Ephesians 2:1-10.
In general, the writer of Ephesians employs the Greek literary device peripeteia, which implies a sudden reversal of fortune for the hero of the narrative. Specifically, the writer utilizes the theatrical device deus ex machina, which would conjure the image of a god descending by use of a crane/pulley into the drama, performing a divine intervention in the progression of the narrative. This demonstrates the writer of Ephesians’ intentional use of culture and literature in order to convey weighty theological concepts to the recipients.
|
Embodiment, Spirituality, and Decolonization: Toward an Integral Feminist Pedagogy
Program Unit: Bible and Cultural Studies
Alka Arora, California Institute of Integral Studies
This paper is focused on a pedagogical model that I term "integral feminist pedagogy" and its relationship to embodiment, spirituality, and decolonization. I argue that a synthesis of the intellectual traditions of feminist pedagogy and integral pedagogy can provide a powerful framework for addressing power, identity, embodiment, and religious/spiritual experience. I share specific examples of how I employ integral feminist pedagogy in my courses, both online and residentially. Further, I offer reflections on the challenges of instructor embodiment in the integral feminst classroom, particularly when the instructor is a woman of color. Specifically, I examine students' increased expectations for nurturance by women of color faculty, and how we can address this through our own embodied practices of boundary setting.
|
The Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahedo Church (EOTC) Canon of Scripture: Neither Open nor Closed
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Bruk A. Asale, University of KwaZulu-Natal
Traditionally, the EOTC holds that its canon of Scripture comprises eighty-one books of the Old and New Testament. However, which books comprise this list remains obscure and the very little research executed so far on the topic is both insufficient and misleading. This paper critically investigates if there has ever been a closed canon in the EOTC. It further critically engages with the notion and concept of the term “canon” and Scripture. The study focuses on the history of reception, collection, translation, and transmission of Scriptures in the Ethiopian church. Methodologically, this study applies both library readings and fieldwork and the main tool employed in collecting data is qualitative interviews. In addition, insights from Ethiopian literature are used. Finally, the study tries to prove that not only the canon of the EOTC, but also its concept in this church is very loose; and it is possible to conclude that the canon of the EOTC is neither open nor closed.
|
Associations and the Social Dynamics in the Christ Group at Philippi
Program Unit: Polis and Ekklesia: Investigations of Urban Christianity
Richard Ascough, Queen's University
Although the archaeological evidence for associations at Philippi tends to post-date the formation of the Christ group in that city, it can still be instructive for understanding the group dynamics reflected in the Pauline letter addressed to the Philippians, particularly when set within the broader associative practices in the Roman period. For example, Craig de Vos has argued that the conflict experienced by Philippian Christ adherents arose when outsiders attempted to persuade them to (re)join an association. My own work in this area has delineated how the Christ group both shares organizational features with an array of associations, yet is urged to stand in contrast to typical association practices when it comes to honor display and banqueting. This paper will extend the investigation by examining how Philippians intersects with association texts from Philippi and its environs as well as nearby Thrace and the northern Aegean islands of Thasos and Samothrace. We will give particular attention to membership recruitment and the public display of financial support, evidence for which appears both in the epigraphic record and the Pauline letter to Philippi.
|
Apples to Apples: Reframing the Discussion of Models for Pauline Christ Groups
Program Unit: Paul within Judaism
Richard Ascough, Queen's University
|
The Armor of God (Eph 6:10–18) in the World View of Ndorobo
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Shelley Ashdown, Graduate Institute of Applied Linguistics
What would a Kenyan ethnic group known for a peace-orientation, confrontation avoidance, hunting/gathering way of life, and a fondness for bee keeping do with Ephesians 6:10-18 and the 2,000 yr. old battle dress of a Western soldier? Traditionally, Ndorobo male youth serve as murrani or warriors with the duties of protecting livestock and the shamba or homestead. Even with this mandate, Ndorobo warriors have no elaborate attire as the ancient Roman soldier did in preparing for battle. It is a rare occasion indeed for a Ndorobo to fight outright. What can an audience-centered approach championed in African biblical hermeneutics reveal about Ndorobo understanding of spiritual warfare consequently lived out in every day Ndorobo life? It is necessary to answer these questions by looking at the Ndorobo context, a contextualized Ephesians text, and the Ndorobo reader. Behind the tangible articles of swords and shields lies a depth of African wisdom connecting the physical with the non-physical.
|
Missiles, Demagogues, and the Devil: The Rhetoric of Slander in Eph 6:16
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Jeff Asher, Georgetown College
Although the translation of Eph 6:16 is fairly straightforward, its interpretation is not. It has been a common practice among New Testament scholars to read this verse in light of parallels with the Old Testament and Qumran on the one hand or of parallels with Hellenistic moral philosophy on the other. In contrast, this paper presents an alternative way of reading Eph 6:16 by examining the verse in the context of ancient rhetorical invective and of the ancient social values that informed that invective. It aims to show that what is important is not what the missiles represent, but the fact that a worthless scoundrel (a p??????) uses missile weapons (ß???). As evidence of my thesis, I will make five points: (1) the author draws on the conventions of slander in the Greco-Roman world in his description of the Devil as a p?????? who uses missile weapons; (2) the title of the adversary as a p?????? is derived from a demagogic topos and carries negative social, personal, and moral connotations; (3) missile weapons were believed to be shameful because of their ineffectiveness, their conflict with close-order battle, and their association with women and barbarians; (4) the “burning” condition of the missiles metaphorically connects the p?????? label and the missiles to the Devil; and (5) the author uses this invective language to diminish the stature of the Devil and to position him appropriately in his cosmic hierarchy.
|
Carbon Dating and the Gospel of Judas
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Christian Askeland, Protestant University Wuppertal
In the 2007 National Geographic publication of the Tchacos codex, Herbert Krosney argued through radiometric evidence that the famous codex had a date of 280 CE (±40 years). Krosney’s date would place this codex before the era of Constantine and the rise of official imperial Christianity, and would indeed establish this codex as the earliest securely-datable Christian literary manuscript. The present discussion will review Krosney’s use of 14C evidence, and consider what limitations this method offers to scholars of ancient manuscripts in general and the certainty with which the National Geographic date can be held for Codex Tchacos.
|
Rewriting “Canonical” Luke in the Period before Marcion and Valentinus
Program Unit: Gospel of Luke
J. D. Atkins, Marquette University
This paper examines an important text not discussed in Andrew Gregory's influential monograph, The Reception of Luke and Acts in the Period before Irenaeus. In Haer. 1.30, Irenaeus summarizes the mythological system of an early gnostic sect—unnamed by Irenaeus but later known as Sethians or Ophites. Their account begins with a rewritten version of the primeval history of Gen 1-11 that has been adapted to gnostic mythology. Then, after briefly summarizing the rest of the OT, it presents a gnosticized version of the birth, life, death, and resurrection of Jesus. For each of these phases of the gospel narrative, the gnostic account uses material that is either drawn from Lukan redaction or otherwise unique to Luke’s Gospel. This account, which Irenaeus attributes to a pre-Valentinian source, therefore constitutes one of the earliest instances of the reception of Luke.
This conclusion has implications for both the state of Luke’s text and the status of Luke’s Gospel and in the early second century. The use of material from Luke 1-2 debunks modern proposals that these chapters were added to the Third Gospel in response to either Gnosticism or Marcion. Moreover, the genre of the account is best characterized as “rewritten Bible.” Rather than rejecting the OT or Luke, the gnostic account retells and reinterprets the stories according to gnostic mythology. The rewritten narrative moves seamlessly from the OT to Luke as if the gospel events were simply part of the OT story. This is a strong indication that these early second-century gnostics presupposed Luke's Gospel to have same authoritative status as that of the OT books. Indeed, they find support for some key gnostic doctrines in the details of Luke’s text.
|
Josephus’s Portrayals of Geography as Sacred Space and Hasmonean Territorial Expansion in the War and Antiquities
Program Unit: Josephus
Kenneth Atkinson, University of Northern Iowa
The War and Antiquities of Josephus are the largest extant sources for the Hasmonean period. Josephus’s historical chronology and accounts of events sometimes conflicts with books such as 1-2 Maccabees that document the Hasmonean period. This is particularly true regarding the land, which almost becomes a character in Josephus’s narratives. He uses the biblical descriptions of the Davidic kingdom to create an imaginary history of Hasmonean land conquests and a fictitious Jewish past. His accounts are not only shaped by the biblical stories of the expansion of the Davidic kingdom, but also by the history of the geographical enlargement of the Roman Republic. This paper explores the role that space plays in Josephus’s accounts of the Hasmonean dynasty and how Scripture and Roman history shaped his narratives regarding the geographical expansion of their realm. It will also suggest that traditions found in several Dead Sea Scrolls regarding space, particularly 4QTestimonia, 4QApocryphon of Joshuab, and 4QApocryphon of Jeremiah Ce, shaped his narratives of Hasmonean territorial expansion. These texts, moreover, suggest that Josephus was likely influenced by Jewish exegetical traditions and apocalyptic beliefs regarding the duration and geographical extent of the Hasmonean kingdom, which he used to shape his narratives of the size and nature of the land occupied by each Hasmonean. For Josephus, geography essentially becomes sacred space as each Hasmonean ruler is judged by the amount of land he or she added to the country. This presentation is based on a forthcoming monograph on Josephus’s portrayals of the Hasmonean state.
|
Why Compare Plutarch and the New Testament? Some Possibilities and Problems
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
David E. Aune, University of Notre Dame
This essay surveys some of the major issues involved in using texts from the corpus of Plutarch’s works to shed light on the New Testament and other early Christian literature. Despite the fact that a central preoccupation of scholars concerned with the historical, social, cultural, and linguistic contexts of the New Testament is to search for relevant parallels in ancient literature, the theory and method involved in making such comparisons requires careful discussion and clarification. One major advantage for investigating Plutarch’s corpus is the fact that the author lived from ca. 50-120 CE, the period when nearly all the books of the New Testament were written. Some of the more obvious problems involved in making such comparisons include: (1) the relative unity of Plutarch’s writings compared with diversity, multiple authorship, and geographical spread of early Christian literature; (2) Plutarch as a member of the literary culture of the upper class writes in a high linguistic register (Hochliteratur), compared with the generally lower class origins of most early Christian authors who wrote in a correspondingly lower linguistic register (Kleinliteratur); (3) the tendency among some New Testament scholars to cherry pick parallels between Plutarch and early Christian literature, disregarding the contextual integrity and structure of Plutarch’s thought; and (4) the even more widespread tendency for readers who use such collections of parallels with little knowledge of Plutarch’s works to study such collections of parallels only in excerpt form. Another important issue is the format chosen for presenting literary parallels, i.e., they can be listed in the order in which they occur in the New Testament with little or no comment or explanation (as in the enormous collections of parallels assembled by J. J. Wettstein, Paul Billerbeck), and the Neuer Wettstein), making it easier to misuse them or they can be presented and interpreted in a more explanatory and discursive form providing more guidance in how they should be understood.
|
The Challenge of Reading with Ordinary Readers: Two Case Studies and a Methodological Exploration
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Esa Autero, University of Helsinki
In this presentation we will explore and reflect on various aspects of empirical hermeneutics by comparing the approaches we used in two separate studies. This addresses issues surrounding contextual interpretative methodologies and practices with a special focus on dialogical hermeneutics or a “reading with” approach. Esa Autero, a Finnish Pentecostal Scholar, met with two Pentecostal church groups in the city of Santa Cruz, Bolivia in 2011-2012, to study five passages in Luke’s gospel on the topic of wealth and poverty. His research project was conducted in a different culture and language than his own and involved two socio-economically distinct groups. Jim Grimshaw, a United States, Liberal Protestant Scholar and caregiver, met with four groups in Wisconsin (two Presbyterian congregations, a senior living facility, and a college) in the fall of 2013 to study two passages in Mark’s gospel on the topic of chronic illness. These studies took place in Grimshaw's home culture among a sprawling suburban area with middle class, educated groups. Though both studies used distinct approaches both have been influenced by previous works by Carlos Mesters, Ernst Conradie, Louis Jonker, Hans de Wit, Gerald West, John Riches, Musa Dube, and others.
After a brief summary of the dialogical hermeneutics approach and how it fits into the larger field of empirical hermeneutics, we will explore and discuss our research protocols, including: (1) choosing and setting up the groups, (2) procedures for running the groups, (3) data gathering and analysis of results, (4) our assumptions and presuppositions, and (5) field research ethics. We will also analyze the strengths and weaknesses of our approaches and dialogical hermeneutics in general. Through this comparison, we aim to encourage scholars to pay more attention to the manifold ways that the Bible is used by the ordinary readers as well as encourage methodological reflection on the implications and challenges that reading with non-scholarly readers entail.
|
How Healing People Can Sicken Environments: Health Care, Economics, and Ecology in the Ancient Near East
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Hector Avalos, Iowa State University
The relationship between economics, health care, and ecology has received little attention in explanations for the vitality or demise of ancient Near Eastern civilizations. By applying theories derived from medical anthropology, which views health care as a system of options and resources for maintaining or restoring health in any community, this paper will provide some examples of how health care impacts both ecology and economics in ancient Near Eastern societies. In particular, it will focus on data from lists of animals, plants, and minerals needed to conduct certain magical healing rituals in Hittite Mesopotamian, Ugaritic, and ancient Hebrew texts. Some of those rituals may have impacted the availability of food resources because they re-directed those food resources to health care needs and to temples. Other rituals may have stressed the environment by requiring the killing of animals for components in healing rituals. An analogy today is the hunting of bears for their gall bladders which are believed to have healing properties. Such killings, when done on larger scales, may have upset ecological balances. We explore the methodological problems such questions raise, and also the possible future directions for detecting links among health care, economics, and ecology.
|
Academic Freedom and Creationism in Public Universities
Program Unit: Metacriticism of Biblical Scholarship
Hector Avalos, Iowa State University
Much of the discussion around academic freedom has centered on institutions with religious affiliations. However, the last decade has brought some important cases where creationists have complained about violations of academic freedom. One case, in particular, is that of Dr. Guillermo Gonzalez, an astronomer who was denied tenure at Iowa State University in 2007. He is a proponent of Intelligent Design Creationism. His supporters argue that prejudice against Intelligent Design motivate his tenure denial, while others argue that Intelligent Design had little or nothing to do with that denial. Regardless of the merits of the decision, the case raises broader issues about differences between academic freedom in public universities as compared to institutions with religious affiliations. This paper explores those differences, and argues that faculty who make claims about the scientific validity of religious claims are justifiably evaluated on how well those claims withstand scientific scrutiny.
|
The Egyptian Sojourn and Deliverance from Slavery in the Framing and Shaping of the Mosaic Law
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Richard E. Averbeck, Trinity Evangelical Divinity School
The Egyptian sojourn and the Lord’s deliverance out of slavery plays a significant part in the framing and shaping of the Law as it is laid out in the Pentateuch. Historical critical issues abound and will be addressed but, as the text stands, this point is essential to our understanding of the nature of the Law. As is well-known, the most inclusive frame extends from Exodus 19 through Deuteronomy 26, from the beginning at Sinai to the end of the Law as expounded in Moab (cf. Exod 19:4 with Deut 26:5-10, the “credo”; and also segullah “treasured possession” and “holy nation [gôy]/people [?am]” in Exod 19:5-6 with Deut 26:18, 19; as well as “just as he spoke [to you]” in Deut 26:18, 19, referring back to Exodus 19:5-6). Similarly, the “ten words” begin with “I am the Lord your God who brought you out of the land of Egypt” (Exod 20:2) and, unlike any other ANE law collection, after the cultic introduction (Exod 20:22-26), the regulations in the Book of the Covenant begin with Hebrew debt slave law (Exod 21:2-11).
What is not so well-recognized is that, first, the same theme frames the second major unit of the Book of the Covenant with resident alien protections (since they were resident aliens in Egypt; cf. Exod 22:20 with 23:9, and note the MT break between 22:19 and 20), after which comes the sabbatical year and cultic conclusion in Exodus 23:10-19. Second, the Egyptian sojourn and slavery comes to the forefront in the conclusion to the Law as it is given at Sinai overall. There are other units of law spread through Numbers, of course, but Leviticus 26 closes off the main presentation of the Law at Sinai with the blessings and curses, followed by the colophon at the very end: “These are the decrees and the judgments and the instructions which the Lord established between himself and the Israelites at Sinai by the hand of Moses” (Lev 26:46; cf. 27:34). In this regard, Leviticus 25 concludes the Sinai laws, and it does so at the very end with an emphasis on Hebrew debt slave law (Lev 25:39-43, 47-54) comparable to that at the beginning of the Book of the Covenant (see above). The final verse reads, “the Israelites belong to me as servants. They are my servants, whom I brought out of Egypt. I am the LORD your God” (Lev 25:55).
|
The Geographical Information in Josephus' Retelling of the Books of Samuel
Program Unit: Josephus
Michael Avioz, Bar-Ilan University
"Places in the narrative are not merely geographical facts, but are to be regarded as literary elements in which fundamental significance is embodied". Thus wrote the late Shimon Bar-Efrat. In Josephus's writings there are numerous significant geographical materials, such as the borders of the land of Israel and identification of various sites with contemporary sites. This paper will examine the geographical materials in the sixth and seventh books of Antiquities, in which the Books of Samuel were rewritten. We shall deal with the following questions: What significance does Josephus see in the biblical sites mentioned in Samuel? What were his sources? What are the differences between Antiquities and his other works with regard to the use of geography?
|
Ruth and Esther: Two Women, Two Works, Two Worlds, One Challenge
Program Unit: Megilloth
Orit Avnery, Shalem College and Shalom Hartman Institute
I shall suggest that the central theme that intertwines the narratives is the tension between otherness and belonging, and this is the observation tower from whose window the narrative horizon can be defined. The motif of otherness features in different facets, but is most salient through the figure of the main protagonist in each work. Ruth and Esther are described as utterly foreign figures within the environments in which the narrative situates them. This is so from both an ethnic perspective – the woman arrives from a different culture, and she must do her best to integrate into local society—and from the perspective of gender – the woman must navigate through a masculine world and deal with the difficulties that hinder her and her abilities to influence and take action. Both works, then, describe one woman’s journey to overcome the many definitions of otherness that enclose and surround her. Ruth must deal with ethnic, gender and social otherness, and, in a different way, Esther too must deal with ethnic, gender and social otherness.
There is one important difference, which is the Jewish people’s position in relation to the motif of “otherness.” From the perspective of the Jewish people, the challenge presented in each work is diametrically opposed to the other. In the book of Ruth, the Jewish people is the majority, dwelling in its homeland, as Ruth the Moabite stands on the outside and seeks entry; while in the book of Esther, the Jewish people is a minority, dwelling within a vast foreign culture, far from its homeland and fighting for its existence and identity, so that Esther is a symbol of the Jewish people in their feminine otherness. The challenge in the book of Ruth, then, is whether to accept and accommodate the foreign woman, wherein this question relates directly to the issue of constructing and conserving national identity; and the challenge in the book of Esther is how a nation can preserve and retain a separate identity when it has become the minority, without endangering its very existence. Through the otherness of these women, the question of identity emerges in full force and is weighed from both the inside and the outside – to the point that it can be argued that Ruth and Esther are no longer the main protagonists of their stories. A new character materializes from the intermeshed narratives, and it is the identity of the Jewish people—how it is constructed, how it is threatened, and how it is preserved.
Thus the two narratives complement each other, for they describe two alternate realities. Reading the two works together allows for extensive discussion about the issue of identity, from both sides of the coin. Both alternate states of existence were relevant, accurate representations of the Jewish nation’s bifurcated reality at the time of their writing, and have continued to reflect their dichotomous existence over the generations, thus constituting two alternate explorations of how a nation maintains its existence.
|
To See or Not to Be: The Hidden Disability of King Saul
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Yael Avrahami, ORANIM: Academic College of Education
In the outset of the Saul cycle, Saul is presented as "a handsome young man", that "stood head and shoulders above everyone else" (1 Sam 9:2, NRSV), a description of seeming ability and perfection. This description creates a promise that would be breached with the appearance of David, and even more so with Saul's death and the readers acquaintance with his disabled inheritor Mephibosheth. This paper aims to demonstrate that the fate of Saul and his descendant is foreshadowed by literary motives that implicitly ascribe blindness to Saul.
In the paper I will analyze the characterization of Saul vis-à-vis another character in five episodes: Samuel in the first meeting (Ch. 9); Jonathan during the war at Michmash (Ch. 14); David during his flee (Ch. 24 and 26); and The witch of Endor (Ch. 28). I will demonstrate that the biblical author consistently used Leitworts from the semantic filed of sight that enhance the opposition between Saul and the other character. Samuel, Jonathan, David and the witch are all presented as the ones who can see clearly, thus inevitably Saul in characterized as blind.
As demonstrated in the past by both Fishbane (1979) and Alter (1981), the repetition of Leitworts within narrative cycles creates thematic development in an unconscious way which influences the way biblical characters are read. In Saul's example, the use of Leitworts from the semantic filed of sight together with the negation between Saul and other characters forms the reader's impression of Saul as blind in an unconscious way. Furthermore, the antonym sight-blindness embedded in the narrative evokes elsewhere in the Hebrew Bible antonyms such as wisdom and folly, life and death, and divine acceptance and divine punishment. Thus, Saul's implicit blindness is both metaphoric to his fate, and a literal clue to the disability of his descendant.
|
The Mythologem of the Creation of Mount ?aphon Echoed in Job 26 and Psalm 89
Program Unit: Bible, Myth, and Myth Theory
Noga Ayali-Darshan, Bar-Ilan University
Through a comparison with various biblical and ancient Near Eastern texts, from Hatti, Ugarit, and Mesopotamia – some have just recently been published – the paper argues that the extant text of Job 26:7-13 represents an inverted order of a cosmogonic myth, identical to Proverbs 8:27-29, Psalms 89:10-13 and 74:13-14. Not having been recognized as such, Job 26 has rarely been discussed in reviews of Israelite cosmogony or adduced as proof that no link between theomachy and cosmogony existed in ancient Israelite traditions. The proposed original order not only explains the text’s composition but also reveals the existence of a unique and previously unrecognized element of the Israelite cosmogony: the motif of the creation of Mount ?aphon. Naming ?aphon rather than Zion or another Israelite sacred site, suggests that this cosmogonic mythologem – although not attested in Ugarit – was common in Canaan prior to the establishment of the Israelite kingdoms. According to this cosmogony, the culmination of the local ancient story of combat between the Storm-god and the Sea was not only the erection of the storm-god’s abode, but also the creation of its site, Mount ?aphon.
|
What Is the Dating of the P Strata in Joshua?
Program Unit: Joshua-Judges
William Babcock, Duke University
The existence of a significant stratum of P material in the Book of Joshua has long been recognized within Old Testament scholarship; however, the relationship of this material to the D elements in Joshua, the dating of this stratum, the extant extent of this tradition’s presence in Joshua, as well as the significance of this material for our understanding of this book’s redaction history, remains uncertain. Even a superficial reading of the Book of Joshua would suggest that a Priestly tradition of some kind is not an insignificant linguistic and thematic component of this narrative, especially in chs. 1-12.
Connected with this issue is the significance of the above observation. In other words, what does the preponderance of P or P-like language in a certain half of the book potentially tell us about the composition history of this book? Most of the scholarly treatments of this subject assume a late, post-Exilic date for this material, a model which would make the P elements very late redactions to a pre-existing text. This view is not incontrovertible, and is subject to significant challenge, especially in terms of contrasting the unbalanced treatments of D/DH and P elements in Joshua. In this paper, I review the existing literature, and then seek to problemitize the dating of the P strata in Joshua for chs. 1-12, demonstrating in the relevant passages how a pre-Exilic dating of this material, following the work of scholars like Wienfeld, Milgrom, and Knohl, is just as likely as the standard, Graff-Wellhausian, post-Exilic viewpoint. Such a reevaluation is especially appropriate when the P evidence is treated in the same fashion as the D/DH material. I hope the results of this study will stimulate reconsideration of the overall importance of P material for Joshua, as well as the redaction history of this text.
|
Authority and Authorization in Literary Reference
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Joel S. Baden, Yale University
How much authority does a dependent text vest in its precursor by the simple act of reference, allusion, or citation? Many scholars, including this one, have long observed the literary dependence of Deuteronomy on the non-Priestly narrative in Exodus-Numbers; less frequently examined, however, is the question of what sort of knowledge of the preexisting narrative the author(s) of Deuteronomy imagine, or require. How familiar with these texts is the imagined audience - or, methodologically speaking, how familiar must we assume an audience be when evaluating such references?
|
The Occasion of 1 Clement Reconsidered
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Jeremiah Bailey, Baylor University
It has frequently been asserted, on the basis of a straightforward reading of 1 Cl 3:3, that the conflict which spurred the writing of 1 Clement was a matter of the young men in the community rejecting the leadership of their elders. This paper proposes that such a reading fails to appreciate the rhetorical and polemical function of "the young" in 1 Cl 3:3. Instead, the comments in 3:1-2 about the "enlargement" of some and the resultant jealousy should be taken as a starting point. Paying careful attention to the development of the argument in Clement one finds the intersection of important concepts like jealousy/envy, concord, and order with economic issues. The paper ultimately proposes that the conflict in Corinth which lead to the writing of 1 Clement was about poor Christians refusing to accept wealthy leaders.
|
Book Discussion of the T&T Clark Handbook to Social Identity in the New Testament
Program Unit: Construction of Christian Identities
Coleman A. Baker, Brite Divinity School at TCU
Book Discussion of the T&T Clark Handbook to Social Identity in the New Testament
|
Mares, Myrrh, and Metaphor: An Integrated Reading of Song 1:9–14
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Sarah Lynn Baker, The University of Texas at Austin
The opening words of Song of Songs 1:9–14 compare the beloved woman “to a mare among Pharaoh’s chariotry.” Understanding the nature of horses and their role in ancient Near Eastern society and imagination is therefore essential for appreciating the full sense of this metaphor. In this presentation, I will begin by giving a general overview of how this text has been approached in the major translations and commentaries, whose word choices and division of this passage into separate units have overlooked the cohesion created by the equine metaphor. I will then provide some background on the nature of horses and their history in the ancient Near East, demonstrating how a more detailed knowledge of equine nature and equipment can illuminate the visual and olfactory metaphors employed in Song 1:9–14.
Though the adornments praised in vv. 10–11 have traditionally been translated with reference to a woman’s fine neckwear, a closer look at evidence from the ancient Near East suggests that this vocabulary in fact refers primarily to specific elements of the bridle and other trappings. Verses 12–14 focus on the olfactory sense, which was known in the ancient world to be significantly more compelling for horses than humans. The equine metaphor functions on multiple levels, ascribing to the woman the exquisite splendor of a royal horse in full regalia and underscoring the powerful appeal of her lover’s scent.
Recognition of Song of Songs 1:9–14 as a single cohesive unit thus enables us to see in this pericope a more integrated visual and olfactory exposition of the lovers’ mutual attraction and possession of one another. The multivalence of the imagery at work in these verses gives us a deeper appreciation for how the writer(s) can layer meaning in Song of Songs and calls us to be attentive to how other extended metaphors in biblical poetry could also provide cohesion in ways not previously recognized.
|
Dabber Immanu Yehudit: Biblical Dialogues in the Pedagogical Toolbox
Program Unit: Applied Linguistics for Biblical Languages
Sarah Lynn Baker, University of Texas at Austin
As discussed in previous meetings of this group, the ability to hear a language is critical for fluent reading. If our students cannot process Hebrew aurally as they read, they will not be able to store enough in their working memory to absorb a written text in natural chunks. As language teachers, our task is to provide our students with the aural input necessary for developing fluent reading skills. How then can we best infuse our classrooms with grammatically authentic Biblical Hebrew (BH) speech, and what sort of conversational activities are appropriate in the context of a language classroom thousands of years removed from the biblical text? These questions arise out of our experience teaching the “Intensive Biblical Hebrew” course (6 class hrs/wk) at the University of Texas, which we are modeling after our department’s highly successful modern Arabic program. In this system, grammar is presented and reinforced with written and online exercises at home, and class time is devoted to activation of the language through spoken engagement with instructors, classmates, and authentic texts. Our search for authentic sources of spoken BH has led us to the dialogue sections of the biblical text as ideal places for both students and instructors to begin developing oral proficiency. Practical conversation is easier to interact with than narrative prose. It is a natural starting-point for language learning, and there is plenty of authentic biblical material from which to draw in taking such an approach. Simple conversational tasks for building spoken proficiency can draw on specific biblical texts as model dialogues for students to imitate, enacting situations such as meeting a stranger on a journey (Judg 19.17–20), finding out where someone lives (2 Sam 16.3), or finding someone/something in a city (1 Sam 9.13). Since much of the modern world cannot be authentically discussed in BH, re-enacting ancient scenarios such as “coming before the king with a request” (1 Kgs 2.20–24; 2 Sam 14.4ff) gives students the chance not only to role-play in dialogue, but also to explore the linguistic peculiarities of such a meeting in BH. In short, the situational contexts of specific dialogues in the biblical text dictate the setting for conversational activities conducted in class. Immersion in direct speech and dialogue at the beginning stages of a BH course provides students with critical aural input and, just as significantly, gives them the confidence to produce the language themselves. This in turn paves the way for in-Hebrew discussion of narrative BH texts, a conversational activity which is a key tool for strengthening active comprehension. Such conversations enable students to develop a much deeper understanding of the texts and equip them more completely to dive into the biblical material on their own.
|
Re-examining the Maskil: The Ideal Figure of the Sage in Serekh ha-Yahad and Musar le-Mevin
Program Unit: Qumran
Arjen Bakker, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
Scholars have often interpreted the term maskil as referring to an office in the community (Newsom; Hempel; Lange). This view is mainly based on 1QS IX 12-21, which ascribes a number of tasks to a maskil. However, a significant amount of material related to the maskil does not seem to apply to a leading official. It is hard to make a synthesis of all occurrences of maskil in the DSS and a hypothetic division in sectarian and non-sectarian occurrences does not help bring any clarity neither. Nevertheless, for many scholars it is clear that the term maskil is of central importance in the DSS.
In this contribution, I will demonstrate that the term maskil has a wider significance than is often assumed. First, it refers to those members of the community who belong to its intellectual and spiritual elite. And second, it transcends the organizational reality since it refers to the ideal figure of the sage. The maskil exemplifies central values of the community: He is of humble character; constantly praises God for his gracious acts; has insight into divine mysteries; separates himself from corrupt society; examines possible pupils and sets them apart; instructs them in hidden teachings; and safeguards his secret knowledge from the outside world. Interestingly, a very similar depiction of the ideal sage arises from Musar le-Mevin, although the term maskil is not central in this text.
An investigation of the ideal figure of the sage in the Serekh and Musar will lead both to a better understanding of what the term maskil signifies, and to a reconsideration of the relations between the two texts. The latter has important ramifications on more general questions concerning the classification of the DSS.
|
Narratives of Empowerment: The Emergence of the Grand Synagogue in Antiquity
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Victoria Ballmes, University of California-Santa Barbara
With the Christianization of the Roman Empire, the shift in social and political power led to a change in power relations between Christians and Jews in Late Antiquity, with increasing instances of violence against Jews particularly through the destruction and appropriation of religious buildings. Despite imperial law that forbade the building of new synagogues and even specified that they would be automatically transformed into Christian churches, Jews continued to build synagogues in Late Antiquity, some of which remained in use for centuries. Not only that, but they built even larger and more elaborate synagogues than ever before. I argue that the emergence of monumental synagogue buildings in Late Antiquity in both Israel and the Diaspora was a form of non-written narrative of empowerment used to reinforce communal identity in the face of increasing aggression and violence and the loss of communal autonomy.
|
Denying the Divide: Narrative and Rhetoric in the Defense of Religious Boundaries
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Victoria J. Ballmes, University of California-Santa Barbara
Although the ‘Parting of the Ways’ between Christianity and Judaism is often seen as something that happened both early and decisively, there is evidence that many people in antiquity actually fell somewhere between these two poles. As most of this evidence survives in the sermons and literary works of the elites, it is difficult to get a sense of the everyday people who transgressed boundaries between Christianity and Judaism. However, by examining narratives directed at these people and analyzing the authors’ use of rhetoric to critique and manipulate their constituents, we can begin to get a sense of both what they were doing and why it was seen as dangerous to community leaders.
John Chrysostom, a late fourth century church leader in Syrian Antioch, gave a series of sermons to his congregation aimed specifically at those who were straddling the line between Christianity and Judaism by attending both church and Synagogue. He criticized Christians who not only participated in Jewish festivals, but also made pilgrimages to Jewish holy places and even underwent circumcision. In an interesting parallel, the Toledot Yeshu, a Jewish anti-gospel probably written in the late fourth or early fifth century in Syria/Palestine, appears to be addressing the same people – those who defy boundaries set between the religions by acting as though they are members of both. While Chrysostom is inclusive of those liminal figures, trying to convince them to stay on the Christian side and give up their Jewish activities, the Toledot Yeshu excludes them and tries to separate them from the “good” Jews. Though they stand on different sides of the religious divide, both are addressing “those dangerous ones in between” in an attempt to strengthen their own religious boundaries and enforce an idea of what it means to be a Christian or a Jew.
|
Wine, Wisdom, and the Everflow: The Visual Interpretation of the Kabbalat Shabbat Liturgy and Traditions
Program Unit: Sabbath in Text and Tradition
Debra Band, Honeybee in the Garden, LLC
The Jewish tradition of Kabbalat Shabbat, literally, “receiving Shabbat”, incorporates the special Friday sundown synagogue liturgy and festive home meal customs developed by the Kabbalists of sixteenth century Safed. These traditions infuse the beginning of the sacred day with celestial imagery and vivid human experiences of love and companionship among family and friends at the festive dinner table. The liturgy of psalms and special piyyutim (liturgical poems) immerses worshippers in mystical imagery of divine energy and wisdom in the human world, while the combination of liturgy and dinner-table customs, reminds celebrants that they both re-enact and honor the Creator’s seventh day rest as they greet the Sabbath. Indeed, the Kabbalistic tradition holds that human Sabbath observance actually affects the dynamics within the godhead. The unity of the godhead, and the unity of humankind with the divine comprise central themes in the Kabbalat Shabbat liturgies and the kabbalistic thought from which they spring. These unities are often symbolized by the image of man and wife united in love. Today, however, in the era that has seen the dating of the Big Bang, that has developed a physical understanding of the unity of all matter, the current cosmological model presents an expanded vision of the unity of all matter and creative force. This paper and its accompanying slide presentation will explore the process and problems in developing an original illuminated manuscript interpreting the Kabbalat Shabbat liturgy and traditions according to both the classical Safed Kabbalistic metaphors and the current physical understanding of the unity of all matter.
|
Hebrew Bible in the Perseus Digital Library
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Barry Bandstra, Hope College
For the third theme section: "Teaching the Bible in an Open World: Open Resources for Teaching and Learning with the Bible"
This is a description and progress report of the Global Education and Research Technology (GERT) project to add the Hebrew Bible and ancillary resources to the open Perseus Digital Library. The Hebrew text added to the Perseus Project is based on the Westminster Leningrad Codex digital edition of the Masoretic text, along with a digital version of the Brown-Driver-Briggs Hebrew lexicon.
|
Retelling the Tale: A Computerized Oral-Formulaic Analysis of the Qur’an
Program Unit: Linguistic, Literary, and Thematic Perspectives on the Qur’anic Corpus (IQSA)
Andrew G. Bannister, Melbourne School of Theology
Is the Qur’an an oral document, not merely transmitted orally but generated orally? The classic work exploring oral composition was that of Parry and Lord, who demonstrated that formulaic diction is one key indicator of creation-in-performance. Their theories have been applied to hundreds of traditions and in 2003, folklorist Alan Dundes argued that their model of oral-formulaic composition applies to the Qur’an, which is replete with formulaic phraseology. His work was much criticised, chiefly because he worked from an English concordance.
But was Dundes’ work dismissed too quickly? Historically, the Qur’an is certainly located in an oral strata. Immediately before, much of pre-Islamic poetry appears to have been composed in performance. Whilst after the Qur’an, oral preachers, the qu??as, played a formative role in shaping the Islamic tradition.
So what about the Qur’an itself? This paper explores how computerized analysis of the Qur’an, made possible by deploying a morphologically tagged database of qur’anic Arabic, enables us to conduct a systematic analysis of the Qur’an for the first time. Computerized analysis demonstrates the Qur’an’s formulaic density to lie between 23% and 53%, depending on the length of formulaic phrase that we search for. We also highlight some further fascinating features that computerized formulaic analysis can reveal, such as the fact that those surahs traditionally considered ‘Medinan’ are considerably more formulaic than those considered ‘Meccan’. We will also demonstrate how computerized analysis can detect not just repetitions, but entire ‘formulaic systems’ throughout the Qur’an, an even greater indicator of oral generation.
Recognizing the Qur’an as being (at least partially) orally composed relocates it back in the strata from which it is often removed, the oral milieu that both preceded and succeeded the composition of the Qur’an—whilst also demonstrating the potential of computerized linguistic analysis of the Qur’an.
|
Cultic Theosis in Paul and Second Temple Judaism: A Fresh Reading of the Corinthian Correspondence
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Michael Patrick Barber, John Paul the Great Catholic University
Since the rise of the Käsemann school the centrality of apocalyptic eschatology in Paul has been widely maintained across the spectrum of contemporary Pauline scholarship, ranging from such diverse scholars as Stuhlmacher and Campbell. In addition to this, there has been the more recent emergence of the place of theosis for comprehending Pauline soteriology, as initially suggested by Hays and later demonstrated by Gorman, Blackwell, and Litwa (e.g., 2 Cor 3:18; 5:21; Col 2:9–10). In this paper we will suggest that these two strands are directly linked by means of second temple Jewish hopes for an eschatological temple and cult, and actualized in Paul. As is becoming increasingly clear (e.g., Tuschling), apocalyptic eschatology was inextricably tied to cultic worship (e.g., 1QHa 19:10-13, 1Q28b 3:25–26). Indeed, building on the work of Deismann, Aune has suggested that apocalyptic eschatology was understood to be realized within the cult in early Christianity (e.g., John 4:23). We will suggest that Paul is no exception. In order to demonstrate this, we shall turn our attention to the Corinthian correspondence, where these themes serve as a leitmotif in Paul’s discussion. Beginning in 1 Corinthians 2:6, Paul speaks of this age passing away yet this gives way to the discussion of a new temple in chapter 3. Paul then elucidates the life of this new temple in the following ways: keeping the feast in chapter 5, linking becoming one spirit with Christ and temple imagery in ch. 6, and, finally, the cultic explanation of participation in Christ in terms of the eucharist in chs. 10-11 and baptism in ch. 12. These cultic emphases continue in 2 Corinthians with the explicit temple language in ch. 6 and almsgiving as liturgical offering in ch. 9.
|
Apocalyptic Investments: First Corinthians 7 and Pauline Ethics
Program Unit:
John Barclay, University of Durham
*
|
Interpretation, Not Repetition: Bultmann on Paul
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
John M. G. Barclay, Durham University
Bultmann is clear that his task is to interpret Paul, not simply repeat him. But what does this mean? This paper will analyse the ways in which Bultmann selects and prioritizes Pauline themes and identifies what Paul "wanted to say." I will comment on the strengths and weaknesses of this procedure, in reflecting on what it means to do theological interpretation of the New Testament.
|
Classification of Early Christian Manuscript Styles
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Don Barker, Macquarie University
W. Johnson in his investigation of literary book roll production in Oxyrhynchus devised three categories of quality in order to distinguish grades of book production quality. His three categories are: (1) formal, semi formal, or pretentious, (2) informal and unexceptional (for the most part probably professional), (3) substandard or cursive. In using these categories Johnson is more concerned with the type of book that the scribe thinks he is writing and so does not, for example, use the term ‘formal’ in the strict palaeographical sense as used by Turner (1987) 20-22. Something like Johnson’s categories is necessary to be able to distinguish the quality of book production of early Christian literature. For the purposes of the inquiry his categories are too broad and vague and a different system of categorization is needed. This paper will outline that system of categorization and give an explanation of how each category is determined. The concern is with the quality of the manuscript that the copyist has produced for his/her client and the ability of the scribe. Having categorized the manuscripts a tentative proposal will be made as what conclusions we can draw from them as to their use and the socio-ecomonic standing of the early Christians.
|
Ecclesial Authority from Matthew to John
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
James W. Barker, Rhodes College
According to Matthew, Jesus authorizes Peter (16:19) and the disciples (18:18) to bind and loose. According to John (20:23), Jesus authorizes the disciples to forgive and retain sins. Given that a single Aramaic term can mean both “loose” and “forgive,” C. H. Dodd concluded that these logia independently attest one orally transmitted saying. Revealing the weakness of Dodd’s semantic argument, this paper nonetheless strengthens the connection between the Matthean and Johannine traditions: John actually knows the “binding and loosing” saying from its redacted context in Matthew 18. Although these sayings do not meet the criterion of multiple attestation, they similarly remember Jesus’ institutionalization of the church as an historical event. Moreover, Matthew and John share a distinctive vision of ecclesial authority: whereas Mark (6:34; 14:27) and Luke (15:1–7) depict Jesus alone as a shepherd, Matthew and John delegate Jesus’ pastoral role to the disciples and Peter respectively (Matt 18:12–14; John 21:15–17). Finally, the paper contextualizes the adaptation of Matthean material and the exercise of ecclesial authority within the Johannine situation, particularly as pastors perform baptisms (John 4:2) and forgive post-baptismal sins (John 20:23).
|
Ancient Compositional Practices and the Gospels: A Reassessment
Program Unit:
James W. Barker, Rhodes College
*
|
The Shema in James
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Lori Baron, Duke University
The author of James uses the language of divine unity (2:19; cf. 4:16) as the centerpiece of his argument on the importance of works alongside faith. For James, it is not enough to believe that God is one (Deut 6:4) without accompanying actions demonstrating one’s piety. This paper argues that James’s use of the Shema (Deut 6:4) is derived from and in reaction to Paul (Rom 3:21-31; cf. Gal 3:20) and that it demonstrates with biting sarcasm the author’s strong disagreement with Paul’s assertion that a person is justified by faith alone. James’s use of the Shema is thus filtered through Paul’s use and is masterfully deployed to reverse Paul’s conclusion.
The author’s positive view of the Law (1:29; 2:9-12) makes it likely that he is Torah-observant and that his addressees may be as well; he shows concern that they may be influenced by Pauline teaching. His view of the Law comports with an understanding of the Shema that would have been at home among other Jewish communities: to love God requires more than believing that God is one, it means keeping the Mosaic commandments.
|
"Your Will Be Done, on Earth as It Is in Heaven": Covenant Renewal and Economic Justice in the Sermon on the Mount
Program Unit: Poverty in the Biblical World
Michael Barram, Saint Mary's College of California
Contemporary faith communities read the Sermon on the Mount in a radically different economic context than the one in which Matthew’s earliest readers found themselves in the late first century. What kinds of economic dynamics would the Matthean community have heard in the Sermon? What kinds of communal responsibility and economic conduct would they have found it seeking to engender? What might such values and practices provide for those who read Matthew 5–7 today, in the context of widespread individualism and neoliberal economic empire? Building on the insights of Richard Horsley (Covenant Economics, 2009) and others, this paper explores how early readers of Matthew’s Gospel may have understood the Sermon on the Mount—and themselves as those commissioned to embody its message—with regard to economic justice. Matthew 5–7 indicates that Jesus expected more from his followers than what was explicitly articulated in the law (e.g., 5:21-48); nevertheless, he assured his listeners that his teaching had to be understood as in continuity with—indeed, as fulfillment of—both the law and the prophets (5:17-20). Framed by Matthew as Jesus’ “covenant renewal speech” given to his followers, the Sermon surely presupposes at least the broad outlines of the Israelite covenant tradition of communal economic justice (such as gleaning laws; condemnations against mistreatment of widows, orphans, and aliens; and prohibitions against charging interest on loans to fellow Israelites). The “covenant renewal” character of the Sermon on the Mount is critically important. Matthew 5–7 serves to (re)form community values and economic conduct. Neither Jesus nor Matthew understood the Israelite covenantal legal tradition as mere exhortation to ideals. As “covenant speech,” Matthew surely assumes that Jesus’ words are to be concretely embodied in the community to which he writes: A faithful reading will have concrete implications for the community’s values and actions (see, e.g., 5:14-16, 17-20; 7:24-27). This paper considers some of those implications, both ancient and contemporary.
|
Kierkegaard, the Cross, and Kenosis
Program Unit: Søren Kierkegaard Society
Lee Barrett, Lancaster Theological Seminary
Kierkegaard’s use of the concept “atonement” has puzzled readers of Kierkegaard. At times his language seems reflect theories of satisfaction and penal substitution, while at other times he seems to be suspicious of any seemingly “theoretic” approach to grasping the significance of the passion of Christ. An examination of his use of New Testament passages, and the rhetorical purposes to which he put such passages, suggest that he was willing to employ a variety of different images of the death of Christ, depending upon his particular edifying goal. Sometimes he sounds Anselmic, sometimes he sounds Abelardian, and sometimes he sounds “classical.” Most often, however, he develops the theme that human society is so allergic to self-giving love that it would inevitably attempt to eliminate any example of such love. Consequently, the crucifixion represents God’s willingness to accept such a cost in order to love human beings in an utterly self-giving way. His various forms of atonement discourse are usually deployed to elaborate this theme.
|
Moving and Giving: The Conceptual Substructure of the Marital Metaphor in Hosea 2
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible and Cognate Literature
Rob Barrett, The Colossian Forum
The standard analyses of Hosea 2 rightly devote considerable attention to the marital metaphor that is as undoubtedly present in the conflict as are the roles of husband and wife. However, an overreliance on this one metaphor places an unsustainable burden upon it. This overburdening becomes evident in interpreters’ attempts to explain difficult historical and logical elements of the narrative by means of the marital metaphor alone. In terms of history, the extreme images of the husband’s reprisals in forcibly confining, stripping, and killing the wife send interpreters off on a relatively fruitless search for historical evidence of such practices within marital conventions of the author’s social context. In terms of logic, the wife’s confusion between husband and lovers over the source of her material support so contorts the marital metaphor that many interpreters recognize its breakdown at this point. By identifying two common conceptual metaphors that have not previously been identified in this passage--INTIMACY IS CLOSENESS and WELL-BEING IS HAVING POSSESSIONS--these problems are substantially alleviated. These two metaphors form the conceptual substructure for the narrative and explain the aforementioned extreme elements as poetic uses of these conceptual metaphors within the marital domain rather than reflections of historical practice. The marital metaphor’s contribution can then be more precisely and narrowly understood as contributing important emotional and ethical elements to the story rather than operating as the single, controlling metaphor. This one in-depth example illustrates a more general approach to identifying metaphors based on recognition of overburdened and complementary metaphors.
|
Jesus’ Breath: A Physiological Analysis of Pneuma within Paul’s Letter to the Galatians
Program Unit: Development of Early Christian Theology
Jeremy W. Barrier, Heritage Christian University
This presentation is based upon my research as an Alexander von Humboldt Research Fellow in Regensburg, Germany. This presentation outlines ancient concepts of physiology, specifically related to the role of breath within the human body, while also relating these concepts to Paul’s language in the book of Galatians. I am arguing that Paul’s ideas on the ‘Spirit’ in Galatians are much more intelligible with a better understanding of Greco-Roman physiology.
|
Paul’s Unacknowledged Opponents
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
S. Scott Bartchy, University of California-Los Angeles
Many sentences in the Synoptic Gospels call the reader’s attention to the serious strain on traditional family/kinship relationships provoked by Jesus’ call to follow him. Jesus is widely remembered to have challenged the authority of fathers and of loyalty to family ties, including his own. The various synoptic contexts suggest that Jesus’ critique of conventional purity rules, including blood-solidarity, resulted in many of his followers experiencing heavy pressure from their families of origin to “come to their senses,” abandon their fascination with this new prophet, and resume their honored places among their families. While many scholars have commented on these passages and Jesus’ creation of alternative kinship relationships, none have approached Paul’s letters and the analysis of his various opponents from the perspective of the serious tension between these Christ-followers’ new social world and relationships and their previous consanguineal family responsibilities and loyalties.
At one point, Paul’s converts in Corinth had granted him greater authority over their lives than they had previously given to their parents, extended family, friends, patrons (if any), and perhaps employers, whom they had naturally grown up imitating. For them, religion was embedded in family life. So many, if not most, of these people must have repeatedly warned these Christ-followers to “come to their senses” and return to blood-family solidarity and the practice of traditional and honorable cultural values and social codes. They must have exerted pressure on Paul’s converts to give up Paul’s culturally suspect views and their new “in-Christ” identity and to come back to the “real world” in which they had been raised. In this paper, I explore the ways in which Paul implicitly rejects parental authority over his converts (e.g., regarding marriage) and explicitly challenges that authority by his creation in the Spirit of alternative kinship relationships and by his call to imitate his own behavior rather than follow the values and codes of their consanguineal families—whom we should include among Paul’s opponents.
|
Sabbath Innovation in Ezekiel 20
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
Penelope Barter, University of St Andrews
Ezekiel 20 has long been recognised as dependent on numerous Torah texts and traditions, in spite of the apparent contradictions. This paper examines how this relationship is in fact reversed in the case of Exodus 31:12-17*, the development of which has been influenced by the innovative understanding of Sabbath in Ezekiel 20. We will first briefly explore the compositional history of Exodus 31:12-17, concluding, with the majority of contemporary mainstream scholarship, that the received text is secondary to its context (Baentsch, von Rad, Noth, Blum), and the product of more than one compositional layer (Stackert, Olyan). Upon turning to the shared locutions and contextual overlap between Exodus 31:12-17 and Ezekiel 20, it becomes evident that the later layer of Exodus 31:12-17 is dependent on the description of Sabbath in Ezekiel 20:12-13, 16, 20-21, 24, leading us to argue that Exodus 31:12-17* was developed in light of this text. The second half of the paper will be devoted to investigating how and why the author of Ezekiel 20 used the language of the Holiness Code to further develop this theology of Sabbath, particularly as a sign related to sanctification of a people, which was further developed in Exodus 31.
|
Was Paul an Allegorist? The Wrong Question
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
Matthew W. Bates, Quincy University
Both ancient and modern combatants have staked out territory and dug trenches, fighting a feverishly-pitched battle over a simple question: Was Paul an allegorist? Within antiquity, Origen and those congenial to his allegorical method felt that the answer was simple: Of course Paul was an allegorist! Meanwhile Theodore of Mopsuestia and others objected—although Paul uses the term ?????????µe?a in his recounting of the Sarah-Hagar narrative in Galatians 4:21-31, he in fact respects the basic narrative sequence of Genesis while gazing upon it from a higher vantage point. Since Paul’s interpretative practices are felt by many to supply a precedent sufficient to establish a norm for all Christians, contemporary theologians and biblical scholars have continued this polarized debate, frequently pitting so-called “typology” against allegory. Yet, drawing on ancient rhetorical and compositional theory, I will argue that the question, “Was Paul an allegorist?” is the wrong question because it obscures Paul’s larger concern with mimesis. It falsely assumes that Paul’s “allegory” is primarily about exegetical generation when it is really an ornamental description of narrative imitation.
|
The Spirit as Distinct Person: Prosopological Exegesis and Divine Differentiation
Program Unit: Development of Early Christian Theology
Matthew W. Bates, Quincy University
Although not yet widely appreciated by biblical scholarship, prosopological exegesis was an ancient reading strategy that sought to explain an inspired text by assigning a dramatic character as the speaker or addressee, even when that dramatic character was not identified as the speaker or addressee within the text itself. Evidence from early reception history will be marshalled to show that it is probable that the author of Hebrews used prosopological exegesis to assign the Holy Spirit as the speaker of two Septuagintal citations in Hebrews 1:8-12. The import here is that the Spirit is not being construed simply as the inspiring agent, but the Spirit is felt to be speaking in the Spirit’s own unique prosopon. In fact, in Hebrews 1:8-9 three divine persons are construed as distinct actors, anticipating in vital ways the much later Niceno-Constantinopolitan creedal synthesis.
|
Fish for Thought in the Early Church
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Alicia Batten, Conrad Grebel University College
The study of fish consumption in antiquity is complex, as there is ongoing debate as to a) the degree to which ancients actually ate fish; and b) understanding the extensive “fishy” ideologies (Beer, 2010) that existed, which in turn, could involve the avoidance of fish altogether, eating certain kinds, sizes or portions of fish, or raising the creatures on private fish farms. Although “fishermen” were low on the social scale, eating fish was considered a luxury, and sometimes associated with effeminacy. This paper offers a survey of these issues; then addresses specific biblical and early Christian texts that refer to fish and fish consumption in light of such questions.
|
Interpreting away the Qur'an: Hermeneutical Strategies for Reconciling Text and Values
Program Unit: Qur’anic Studies: Methodology and Hermeneutics (IQSA)
Karen Bauer, The Institute of Ismaili Studies
Scholars of religion are well aware of the hermeneutical difficulty posed when a holy text says something that its interpreters do not want it to say. The text of the Qur’an often seems to clash with interpreters’ beliefs and values on gender issues. Examples are found in verses such as Q. 2:282, which specifies that two women should testify in place of one man because of one woman’s error, and Q. 4:34, which gives an overview of the hierarchical nature of the marital relationship specifies a three-stage punishment for recalcitrant wives: admonishing, abandoning in the beds, and beating. Medieval interpreters had trouble with the phrase ‘abandon them in the beds’, because a wife’s recalcitrance usually entailed her refusal to have sex with her husband, and abandoning a wife in bed would seem to give her exactly what she wanted, while depriving her husband of his marital right. Modern interpreters question the command to beat them, since wife beating goes against common ideas of fairness and justice. In such difficult cases, it seems that interpreters have three choices: deny the plain sense reading, acknowledge the plain sense reading and explain why it is fair and just, or acknowledge the plain sense reading and explain why it can be reinterpreted. But this argument presumes that there is a plain sense meaning, whereas the multiplicity of exegetes’ interpretations, and their interpretative strategies, call into question the relationship between text and interpretation. Is there really a plain sense meaning to the text, and does it matter to its interpreters? In the words of Amina Wadud, ‘the text is silent. It needs interpretation… We make it speak for us by asking of it’ (Inside the Gender Jihad, 2006, p.197). In this paper, I examine the specific strategies used by medieval and modern ‘ulama’ to reject or justify elements of the text that clash with their values. I focus on the question of whether there is indeed a plain sense meaning to the text, and, if so, whether that meaning influences its own interpretation. Drawing on textual analysis and interviews of ‘ulama’ in Iran, I query whether the ‘ulama’ would agree with Wadud’s assertion about the silence of the text, and describe how they explain the multiplicity of interpretation, and the influence of culture on interpretation, in a way that still grants the Qur?an a meaning and a voice.
|
Film and Holy Mystery: Two Recent Passion Films
Program Unit: Bible and Film
Lloyd Baugh SJ, Pontificia Università Gregoriana
The earliest Gospel films are passions, brief, mute, linear in structure and static in photography, that depict the final hours and death of Jesus. Most are based not on the Gospel but on the Christian devotional practice of the “stations of the cross,” of which only 8 of 14 scenes are attested to in the Gospel. In recent years, several film makers return to the beginnings of the tradition, but now producing often elaborate, and quite dynamic passion films, some of which use complex sound tracks and special photographic and digital effects.
This paper will study two of those films, Mel Gibson’s "The Passion of the Christ" (USA 2004) and Giovanni Columbu’s "Su Re" ("The King") (Italy 2013). Radically different in both style and content, the two film texts raise many questions about how the Seventh Art represents this particular part of the Gospel; further they compel a reflection on, and evaluation of the relationship between these films and the Gospel.
After a description of each film, particularly important for the recent but narrowly-distributed "Su Re," the paper develops a comparative analysis of diverse aspects of the films, indicating how these exercise a determining effect on the meaning of these texts. Of prime importance is the source material of their narratives–biblical, Christian-devotional, fictional or a mix of these–and the attitude of the directors towards that material. No less significant is the basic concept or understanding the director has of Jesus: his physical attributes, his speech, his psychological state, his way of relating to the disciples and others in these crucial final hours of his life and mission.
Then various extradiegetical elements of the films are considered: settings, scenography, cinematography, camera movements, direction and blocking, lighting, the use of digital effects, and sound/music tracks. Further, and regarding intradiegetical elements, the paper considers how the films portray the secondary characters and how they depict and justify–by biblical or other means–the violence, both physical and psychological, visited on Jesus.
Finally it considers and evaluates the radically-different ways the Resurrection is represented–in one case, quite directly and in the other, indirectly, through largely-symbolic means–as the key to determining how, and the extent to which, the films succeed in respecting the element of Holy Mystery in the passion, death, and Resurrection of Jesus. Supplementing the paper, printed stills from the films will be provided at the beginning of the presentation and a short series of video clips will be screened at the end.
|
Sacred Trees in Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and Their Impact for the Interpretation of Genesis 2–4
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Michaela Bauks, Universität Koblenz - Landau
A tradition-historical approach to the motif of trees in ancient Near Eastern iconography reveals their multivalent quality. On the one hand, they can be described as “’time-transcending’ motifs of ancient Near Eastern pictorial art” (A. Moortgat). As cross-temporal motifs, they are regularly associated with life-giving and blessing. On the other hand, they are not only connected with fertility and goddess devotion but also with the power and the divine sanction given to kings and other representative people, and further with the potency of sacred space, on which humans and the divine come together. These general patterns in combination with selected iconographic evidences reflect certain assumptions connected with fertility or cults of the king or sacred space. They provide a better interpretation of the symbolism of trees in Gen 2-4 presenting a notion of divinity influenced by an intended aniconism in a traditional metaphorical way.
|
Genealogy’s Role in Identity Negotiation: A Comparison of Ezra and Leviticus
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Richard Bautch, St. Edward's University
In recent years the study of biblical historiography has turned increasingly to issues of identity negotiation. A prime example is the book of Ezra; one of the most salient features of this text is the negotiation of group identity through language. Scholarship of late has emphasized how the figure Ezra calls for separation from the people of the land so that his community might become a “holy seed” (Ezra 9:1-2, 11-12). In this instance genealogy provides the basis for Ezra’s rhetoric, and a similar situation prevails in Ezra 2:59-63 where certain parties are barred from the golah community because their “seed” and lineage (kinship through the father’s house) are in question. This study provides additional perspective on the historiographical issue of identity negotiation by comparing Ezra’s rhetoric of genealogy with that found in Leviticus. Ezra 9 has several lexical counterparts in Lev 20:22-26, an admonition to separate from other groups on purity grounds and to reject all their customs. Rhetorically, there are also telling differences between the two texts; the passage in Leviticus presents a community whose identity is negotiated differently than that of Ezra’s group. A comparison and contrast of Ezra and Leviticus sheds new light on both texts and leads to the conclusion that in the case of Ezra the biblical writing did not simply reflect the dynamics of identity negotiation in Persian-period Yehud but likely influenced and affected these dynamics as well.
|
Q, Divine “Kingdom,” and the Political Theology of Bureaucrats
Program Unit: Q
Giovanni Bazzana, Harvard University
The basileia of God plays a very peculiar role in the Sayings Gospel Q. While Q does not present any instance of the traditional Jewish acclamation of God as “king”, the abstract basileia becomes personalized in a way that is at the very least unusual. The basileia appears almost appears to acquire an agentive character, so that it might seem that is bringing about on its own the eschatological reward and relief that constitutes one of the central theological themes of Q. How to explain this peculiarity? Is it in any way linked to the specific socio-cultural profile of the village scribes behind Q and to their theological-political ideology?
The present paper tackles this question by arguing that the emergence of the notion of an abstract divine basileia should be understood against the backdrop provided by the changes in the discourse on sovereignty that impacted several eastern Mediterranean intellectuals elites at the moment when Greco-Roman imperialism brought about the disappearance of native monarchies. Confronted with such momentous developments, local elites (and sub-elites, as in the case of Q) tried to cope with the new situation and to protect their social prestige by detaching the ideal notion of “sovereignty” (basileia) from the concrete human figures of their contingent rulers. As several texts present the abstract “sovereignty” acting in the form of a political agent, likewise – in a theological-political perspective – the abstract divine basileia performs the salvific activities that one would have expected from God and opens up the space for the bureaucrats to play a significant role in the divine governmental ordering of the cosmos.
|
The Economics of Basileia in Luke-Acts according to Halvor Moxnes
Program Unit: Gender, Sexuality, and the Bible
Giovanni Bazzana, Harvard University
More than three decades ago, Halvor Moxnes published one of the most influential treatments of socio-economic relations in the Gospel of Luke (The Economy of the Kingdom). Since then, Moxnes has been incessantly coming back to the crucial issues that he had raised in that book by opening several innovative and insightful methodological directions of research. The present talk aims to reexamine Moxnes’s Economy of the Kingdom by tapping into some of the perspectives sketched by the Norwegian scholar throughout his long and fruitful career. In particular, the paper will focus on the category of “space” that has been brought to the forefront of New Testament studies mainly thanks to Moxnes’s creative use of it in his landmark Putting Jesus in His Place. There the “space” of Galilee is read as an ideological construal, so that a critical analysis may interrogate it as the means to uncover power relationships and material structures that shape the text of Luke. Moreover, Moxnes has been a proponent of a more decidedly intersectional approach to the study of early Christian writings. Such methodological shift can also take advantage of other points of view (such as gender, ethnicity, or status alongside class) in order to render more complex and nuanced our reading of the Lukan texts.
|
A Generous Dialogic: Feminism in Islam as a Locus for Interfaith I-Thou Engagement
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
Matthew S. Beal, Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary
This paper utilizes Martin Buber’s concept of the ‘I-Thou’ relationship as an approach to interreligious dialogue. This approach honors the humanity of adherents of diverse faith systems and minimizes the dehumanizing effects of ‘I-it’ approaches, allowing for mutual benefit and critique between religious perspectives. Beginning with an overview of Buber’s I-Thou concept, this paper offers suggestions for its application to interreligious dialogue and the critical evaluation of Islamic texts. It then models this approach in surveying the textual foundation of women’s place within Islam, identifying the challenges to women’s equality and overviewing feminist approaches to such texts. It argues that despite passages which can serve sexist and oppressively patriarchal agendas, Islam is capable of nurturing feminist sentiments and the promotion of women’s rights. It concludes by suggesting practical steps by which feminist approaches to challenging Christian texts and doctrinal traditions may be placed in ‘I-Thou’ dialogical conversation with Islamic feminism.
|
The Background of Paul's Use of Ekklesia Revisited
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Greg Beale, Westminster Theological Seminary
This paper reviews and evaluates a part of a recent debate about the background and origins for Paul’s use of the word ekklesia. Paul Trebilco argues that the word ekklesia is to be understood mainly from its Septuagint background, where it refers to Israel in its congregated form. G. H. Van Kooten has responded to Trebilco by contending that the word is better understood, not against an LXX background, but primarily from the Greco-Roman background, where it refers to gathered public assemblies of a political nature. This paper is an attempt to present further evidence that there, indeed, is a clear Septuagint background for Paul’s use, especially his multiple uses of “church of God” (ekklesia tou theou). These uses in Paul appear to be derived from Neh. 13:1, which quotes Deut. 23:4-5 (3-4 in Eng. versions) and renders Deuteronomy’s ekklesia tou kuriou by ekklesia tou theou. Neh. 13:1 is the only place in the LXX where ekklesia tou theou occurs. Significant parallels occur in Philo, where he also repeatedly translates ekklesia tou kuriou (“assembly of the Lord”) in Deut. 23:2-4 by ekklesia tou theou likely under the influence of Neh. 13:1. This is, at the least, a precedent for Paul’s use. This does not mean that there is not also a Greco-Roman background, though the limits of the paper cannot explore this further. [special note: I could not show the eta in ekklesia as a long vowel in the above transliteration nor could I put the transliteration into italics].
|
Roundtable Analysis of Contemporary Liturgical Practices Based on Ancient Texts, Narratives, and Oral Traditions about the Marys
Program Unit: Maria, Mariamne, Miriam: Rediscovering the Marys
Mary Ann Beavis, University of Saskatchewan
Roundtable will include priests, ministers, and a rabbi who have incorporated Mary Magdalene, Mary the mother, Miriam the sister of Moses, and/or other Marys into their services and liturgy. Panelists are Rev. Darryl Kistler,
Senior Minister, Kensington Community Church, UCC; Rabbi Lenore Bohm,Executive Director, Waters of Eden Mikvah and Education Center; Father Eugene Grushetsky Archpriest,
John of Kronstadt Russian Orthodox Church;Dr. Jane Via,
Pastor; Mary Magdalene Apostle Catholic Community.
|
Show Me Your Palace: The Late Bronze Age Administrative Palace at Hazor
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Shlomit Bechar, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
Tel Hazor was the largest Canaanite city in the southern Levant during the second millennium BCE, when it covered an area of approximately 200 acres. During this time, both the Upper and Lower Cities were occupied. The Upper City consisted of monumental public buildings while the Lower City included public and cultic structures, as well as residential buildings.
The Renewed Excavations at the site began in 1990, and have uncovered large amounts of information regarding Bronze Age Hazor. In the past two seasons, new finds provided more information on the administrative and royal complexes of Late Bronze Age Hazor. These include the identification of the administrative palace of Hazor, which is situated at the connection between the Lower City and the Upper City, on the northern slopes of the tel.
This palace is the focus of the presentation. Its architectural remains will be presented here, together with the material assemblages that were found in this context. These include the ceramic assemblages as well as parts of two stone statutes which were found in the last phase of use of the palace. The implications of these finds will also be presented and discussed in their relation to other finds from the same period as well as Carbon 14 dates.
|
Like Talking to Yourself in the Rain: Job and Apocalyptic Film
Program Unit: Bible and Film
Meghan Alexander Beddingfield, Princeton Theological Seminary
In the film Cool Hand Luke, the prisoners hurry to escape a thunderstorm while Luke stands in the rain. “Get in here. Ain’t ya scared? Ain’t ya scared of dyin’?” fellow inmate Dragline asks. Luke replies, “Dyin’? Boy, He can have this little life any time he wants to.” He looks up at the sky. “Do ya hear that? Are ya hearin’ it? Come on. You’re welcome to it, Ol’ Timer. Let me know you’re up there. Come on. Love me, hate me, kill me, anything. Just let me know it.” He looks around. “I’m just standin’ in the rain, talkin’ to myself.”
Dostoevsky identified a theme in the Book of Job that disturbed him, namely that Job/everyman can be righteous and suffer. This understanding was later adopted by some interpreters, including Elie Wiesel, following WWII, in response to the suffering and terror of the atomic bomb and the Holocaust. Some interpreted these events being implemented by an evil God, but others saw it as proof of God’s absence. It is from the latter tradition that one sees the interpretation of Job shift in reception to apocalyptic themes that emphasize God’s abandonment – designated as a direct action by God, not a passive absence– of humanity and the ensuing destitution of humanity.
This paper analyzes four films directly related to Job and the genre of modern apocalypticism; A Serious Man, Life of Pi, God on Trial, and The Road. I suggest that in this format expectation in the apocalyptic genre has shifted from emphasizing the faith, hope, and righteousness of the community, to God’s failure to intervene.
|
The Servant and the Conclusions of Acts and Isaiah
Program Unit: Formation of Luke and Acts
Holly Beers, Westmont College
My thesis is two-fold. First, the author of Luke-Acts builds aspects of his portrayal both of Jesus and his disciples in Luke-Acts on the servant, who is the human agent of the Isaianic restoration in Isaiah 40-66. According to scholars such as Brueggemann and Hanson, in Isaiah the servant’s mission being embodied is, to a great extent, how the renewal comes to fruition. Second, Luke is sensitive to the Isaianic co-text of the servant’s mission in chapters 40-66, often called the New Exodus, and he demonstrates his awareness at least partly by concluding Acts with the same notes of triumph and tragedy that end Isaiah.
The servant figure from Isaiah has attracted great interest in modern critical scholarship, and a recent trend in Isaiah studies is to see the servant’s role as integral to its co-text(s) and to take seriously the book’s own identification of Israel as the servant as various points. In Second Temple Judaism the servant was interpreted corporately in some texts, and individualistically in others, though an Israel-as-servant identity in Isaiah allows for such fluidity.
Many Lukan scholars see Luke identifying Jesus with the servant in Luke 4:18-19 (quoting Isaiah 61:1-2; 58:6); 22:37 (using Isaiah 53:12); Acts 3:13-15 (cf. Isaiah 52:13; 53:6, 11-12); and 8:32-33 (quoting Isaiah 53:7-8). My claim is that Luke also portrays the disciples embodying various aspects of the servant identity, and I will argue this specifically in Acts 1:8 (through the use of the phrase “to the end of the earth (??? ?s??t?? t?? ???) , lifted from the servant’s commission in Isaiah 49:6 LXX); 13:46-47 (where Paul and Barnabas quote Isaiah 49:6 in reference to their own mission and identity); and 28:17-31. In this final passage, Paul is blanketed with servant language such as pa?ad?d?µ? and d?aµa?t???µa?, and he quotes from Isaiah 6:9-10 when the Jews who are present refuse him and his message. This pre-New Exodus passage and its judgment is thus the result of such rejection. Significantly, the book of Isaiah ends with hope and judgment, and my claim is that Luke models his ending in Acts, with its own such emphases, after the ending of Isaiah.
|
Object Marking in Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Peter Bekins, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion
It is has been observed that the so-called “prose particles”—the definite article haC-, the relative pronoun ?asher, and the object marker ?et—are used relatively infrequently within poetic texts (see Andersen and Forbes 1983; GKC § 117a). The prose particle count has become one of many factors used to determine whether a text is properly categorized as poetry, but the precise relationship between the frequency of prose particles and the poetic genre remains unexplained. This paper will investigate the distribution of the object marker ?et within biblical poetry in light of the functional-typological literature on Differential Object Marking (DOM). Object marking is conditioned by a complex set of semantic and pragmatic features. The underlying principle is that the more prominent the referent of the object phrase, the more likely it is to be marked. As a DOM system develops, marking may also be conditioned by semantic features associated with topicality such as definiteness and animacy, which are typically represented as scalars. Rather than simply count the occurrences of ?et per total number of words, therefore, it is more precise to analyze the frequency of marking in relation to topicality, definiteness, and animacy. The infrequent use of object marking in poetry can be explained in relation both to the diachronic development of the DOM system within Biblical Hebrew and the more essential role of participant reference within narrative than in poetry.
|
Dreams, Trees, and Empires in Apocalyptic Literature
Program Unit: Prophetic Texts and Their Ancient Contexts
Jonathan Ben-Dov, University of Haifa
The Aramaic apocalyptic texts preserve numerous variations on one basic theme: a prophetic dream which depicts a tree or trees – sometimes a cedar – and their destruction: by cutting down, by flooding or by other means. The dreams often depict a confrontation between the imposing cedar and a feebler tree, a grapevine or date palm. The dream accounts go into considerable iconographic detail. In Daniel 4, the most famous exemplar of such a dream, the tree iconography carries with it an anti-imperialistic message, which has often been connected with the Assyrian ‘Tree of Life’. Accounts in the Book of Giants and in the Genesis Apocryphon shed light on earlier formulations of the motif, preceding Daniel. Some of these also connect the trees to the motif of the Watchers, i.e. the Fallen Angels which indulge with the trees. Later on similar iconography comes to fore in the dream of 2 Baruch 36, and in addition, outside a dram account, in the Hodayot (1QHa XVI). Much of this imagery was collected in a useful article by E. Eshel. In this paper I aim to examine: 1) what added value is gained in the apocalyptic narrative by presenting these visions as dreams, 2) the iconographical sources for this motif, and 3) the link of the tree motif with the imperial or anti-imperial message.
|
Rewriting Eve as an Act of Resistance: 15th–17th Century Women’s Interpretations of Eve
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Amanda W. Benckhuysen, Calvin Theological Seminary
“Do you not know that you are (each) an Eve?” Tertullian’s notorious comment associating all women with Eve captures well the significant influence of Eve on the construction of gender identity and norms in the West. As Eve was woman, women were Eve, her characteristics, behaviors, and impulses defining what it is to be female. Through much of Christian history, Eve was depicted as a secondary and inferior creation whose delinquent behavior plunged the world into sin and strife. This interpretation fostered negative cultural stereotypes and norms, devaluing women and limiting their rights and freedoms. By way of response, 15th-17th century women interpreters offered their own readings of Eve, resisting their devaluation and challenging the limitations imposed on women. This paper will explore three strategies that women interpreters employed in this effort: 1. Reinterpreting the biblical text to portray a more noble and liberating Eve; 2. De-essentializing women’s identity and thereby reducing Eve’s importance for gender construction; and 3. Reappropriating the narrative of Eve in ways that support and advocate for greater rights and freedoms for women.
|
Lexical Repetition in Noah's Discourse in the Qur'an
Program Unit: Linguistic, Literary, and Thematic Perspectives on the Qur’anic Corpus (IQSA)
AbdelMadjid Benhabib, University of Tlemcen - Algeria
This paper will illustrate the application of textual analysis to the Qur'an by uncovering some aspects of Lexical Cohesion that are contained in the Qur'anic comments connected to the discourses of Noah and the Leaders of his people in their verbal exchanges. Noah's discourse focuses on worshiping Allah alone (Q. 7:59; 11:26; 23:23; 71:3) and encouraging his people to make the shift from polytheism (71:23) - that being the current worldview of his community - to monotheism, the new worldview championed by Noah as a messenger. In order to accomplish this, Noah's approach concentrates on changing the disparity between two social classes: that of the leaders who are mandated to support polytheism and to speak on behalf the community against Noah's discourse; and that of the rest of the people who are ordered by their leaders to resist (23:24) and then to rebel (23:25) against Noah, thus taking into account the aim of the leaders. This disparity is founded on a vertical relationship, as the verb "to follow" shows by its connectedness in Noah's discourse "[they] (.) followed those whose riches and children only increase their ruin" (71:21). Here, Noah, being from outside the worldview of his people, judges what happens inside the worldview of his community. The same verb is used by the leaders but through pointing out the relationship between Noah and those who moved from polytheism to monotheism. An illustration of this kind of connectedness may be seen in "the worst (.) followed you" (11:27; 26:111). Here the leaders are still inside their worldview and judge what happens outside, referring to Noah's worldview. Consequently this lexical repetition is used, from each character, differently towards the two referents. Another aspects is seen when Noah names those who accept his call "those who have believed" (11:29), "the believers" (26:114; 26:118; 71:28) and "a believer (71:28). This lexical repetition shows its cohesion, in terms of opposition, with the previous discourse of the leaders toward the same referent, and in terms of similarity with the Qur'anic comment about also the same referent (11:36; 11:40). How can we understand what is at stake in the verbal exchange between the characters cited? And how does the discourse of each of these aspects progress and make its ultimate point about the move from polytheism to monotheism? Through my work I will try to answer these practical issues with which I am presently concerned with the Qur'an.
|
Moving beyond Mesha: Narrating Social Life in Iron Age Jordan
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Benjamin W. Porter, University of California, Berkeley
Any attempt to narrate Jordan’s Iron Age history faces two challenges. First, the documentary corpus, although seemingly abundant in sources, consists of problematic texts that are often brief, unprovenienced, and/or present significant interpretive challenges. Even the Mesha Stele, the 34-line inscription detailing the king’s ninth-century campaigns to establish the Moabite polity, must be read critically as hegemonic discourse rather than historical annals. The second problem is that deposits containing Iron Age archaeological data are limited due to later Classical, Islamic, and Modern Era building activities that destroyed earlier evidence. Where data are available, excavation projects have regularly forgone systematic recovery and documentation methods of deposits for expediency’s sake. Furthermore, excavated evidence is unpublished or under-published, preventing scholars from using it as complementary source material. Given these two problems, and the likelihood that the situation will not change in the coming decades, this paper argues that the desire to write panoramic ‘histories’ of Iron Age Jordan should be replaced by efforts to compose thick descriptions of Levantine societies as it was constituted at local levels. Writing such narratives requires the rigorous recovery and analysis of several different kinds of archaeological evidence. Evidence from the author’s recent research on the Early Iron Age agro-pastoralist communities along the Wadi al-Mujib as well as the more substantial Moabite and Edomite settlements of Dhiban and Busayra will illustrate this approach. Rather than rush to historicize the evidence in predetermined and occasionally awkward historical frameworks of kings and polities, the evidence is assembled in an evidence-based narrative of social life within Jordan’s cultural and environmental contingencies. The paper concludes with a reflection on the broader implications of this approach for historiographical research on Iron Age Levantine societies where written documentation is limited, problematic, or absent.
|
The Scope and Limitations of Using a Uniform Approach to Character in the Gospel of John
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Cornelis Bennema, Wales Evangelical School of Theology
Character in the New Testament has been the subject of focused literary-critical study since the 1970s, but there has never been consensus on how character should be understood either in contemporary literary theory or in biblical studies. This paper will evaluate a range of approaches, from Forster’s elementary classification of characters as “flat” and “round” in 1927 to more complex and nuanced approaches developed in the last five years. It gives specific attention to the scope and limitations of Cornelis Bennema’s approach to character in the Gospel of John, which is outlined in A Theory of Character in New Testament Narrative (Minneapolis: Fortress, 2014) and applied in Encountering Jesus: Character Studies in the Gospel of John (2nd edn; Minneapolis: Fortress, 2014). The main question of this paper is whether Bennema's uniform approach to character study has advantages over an open-ended approach, which has been adopted in the most extensive contribution on the subject—Character Studies in the Fourth Gospel: Narrative Approaches to Seventy Figures in John, ed. Steven A. Hunt, D. Francois Tolmie, and Ruben Zimmermann (WUNT 314; Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2013).
|
War and Disaster in Ecclesiastes
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Stephen J. Bennett, Nyack College
The Book of Ecclesiastes is often placed in it's precise historical context due to a perceived lack of social upheaval evident in the book. It is considered to have been written in a time of peace (e.g. Whybray). Yet words for “war” are used four times in the book (Eccl. 3:8; 8:8; 9:11; 9:18). There is also a concern for the lack of control due to some unknown disaster which may occur in the land (e.g. Eccl 11:3). As well as these specific mentions of war and disaster, the poems in Eccl. 3:1-8 and 12:1-8 also juxtapose war and peace (Eccl. 3:1-8) and describe the conditions of a city under seige or ravaged by war (Eccl. 12:1-8).
Rashbam is one of the few interpreters to see the theme of war in the entire poem of Eccl. 3:1-8, although he only deals with this briefly. The switch from verbs throughout the poem to nouns in the last couplet signals the topic of the poem: war and peace. Interpreters have occasionally seen allusions to war in various elements of the poem, e.g. casting stones (to ruin a field), or refraining from embrace (Greidanus). However, more than just a few of the images relate to war and peace. This can be demonstrated with a closer look at the infinitives which provide the driving action of the body of the poem. The poem is really a poem on war, rather than a poem on time.
The poem of Eccl. 12:1-8 is usually seen as an allegory for old age (in older works), or an eschatological poem (in more recent works). Some scholars recognize the descriptions of a ruined city and elements of city lament (Barbour). This approach should be taken literally and seen as one of the contingencies of war or disaster which make life uncertain, according to Qoheleth.
This paper will show how war and disaster pervade the thinking of Qoheleth and provide a major reason for Qoheleth's advice to enjoy life in the present. A disaster such as war could easily change the possibility of such enjoyment.
|
The Reforms of Jeroboam I: Religious Heresy or Theopolitical Orthodoxy?
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Brendon C. Benz, William Jewell College
1 Kings 12 records a significant transition in the political life of Israel. Echoing the process of David’s rise to power in 2 Samuel 5, the elders of Israel gathered at Shechem to ratify Rehoboam’s authority. Several scholars have noted that this narrative illustrates a critical aspect of Israel’s early political structure that is reflected in the Amarna letters and the much later “Israelite” portions of the Bible. Corresponding to the strategies used to limit the exercise of exclusionary power outlined by Richard Blanton and others, the collective decision-making body of Israel reserved the right to accept or reject a king’s bid for the throne. In the case of Rehoboam, the elders appear to have concluded that the Jerusalem-centered House of David had attained a level of centralization through the processes of linearization and promotion articulated by Kent Flannery that threatened the corporate ideals upon which Israel was founded. The rejection of Rehoboam set in motion several reforms enacted by Jeroboam, including the establishment of a new capital at the site where Israel’s collective decision-making body convened and the installation of two bovine representations of Yahweh in Dan and Bethel. Scholars generally regard the latter act as an example of religious heresy, an interpretation supported by the later Deuteronomistic condemnation of Jeroboam and his calves. However, a reevaluation of this decision in light of the larger political concerns involved suggests that it was motivated by political orthodoxy, and therefore represented a return to an earlier vision of Israel’s religion.
|
Reuse of Deut 24:1–4 in Jer 3:1–10: A Reexamination
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Kenneth Bergland, Andrews University
The purpose of the following paper is to evaluate the textual basis for claiming that Jer 3:1–10 reuses and depends upon the prohibition against a husband remarrying his formerly divorced wife in Deut 24:1–4 and to demonstrate how the latter is incorporated into the line of thought of the former. While the majority of scholars today see Jer 3:1–10 as dependent upon Deut 24:1–4, the textual support provided for this claim is often weak. In the present study, I will apply William Tooman’s methodology for determining inner-biblical reuse and the direction of dependence, which facilitates more precise and solid analysis, to a reexamination of the relationship between Jer 3:1-10 and Deut 24:1-4. In this way, I will identify the strongest arguments and point out some factors in these passages that interpreters have missed (see below).
Firstly, I discuss the relative strength of arguments for reuse, based upon unique or distinct expressions that appear in Jer 3:1–10 and Deut 24:1–4, and examine a possible case of conflation of clauses in Jer 3:1. I also point out how MT and LXX Jer 3:1–10 provide independent evidence that strengthens the case for reuse of Deut 24:1–4 in Jer 3:1-10.
Secondly, I proceed to the question of direction of dependence. Here I focus especially on a strange sequence of verbs in Jer 3:8 (s?illah?ti^ha¯ wa¯?ette¯n ?et-se¯per k?ri^tute^ha¯ ?e¯le^ha¯), what appears to be a word-play in Jer 3:2 (ka??ra¯b_i^ bammidba¯r) upon Deut 24:1 (?erwat da¯ba¯r), and the metaphorical language of Jer 3:1–10.
Thirdly, I investigate how Jeremiah adapts the law in Deut 24:1–4 regulating sexual conduct into his own logical trajectory regarding the relationship between YHWH and Judah.
|
Ezekiel, H, and "Z": The Relationship of Ezekiel to the Holiness Code and "Zion Theology"
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
John S. Bergsma, Franciscan University of Steubenville
In recent years, close lexical studies of Ezekiel and H have been executed (e.g. Lyons and Levitt Kohn), suggesting that Ezekiel is (with nuances) dependent on H. Using an analysis of the *conceptual* relationship of Ezek 46:16-18 and Lev 25:8-55 (jubilee laws) as a test case, this paper argues that Ezekiel 40-48 appears to combine Holiness concepts with some elements of the "Zion theology" so prevalent in the psalms, some prophets, and other biblical sources. The implications of this finding for evaluating the literary relationship of H and Ezekiel is discussed.
|
Healing a Broken Relationship: The Meaning of ??? in Hosea, Isaiah, and Jeremiah
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Abraham Berkovitz, Princeton University
The paper explores the impact of Neo-Assyrian royal idiom on Hosea, Isaiah and Jeremiah. It is in conversation with the work of (inter alia) Peter Machinst and Shawn Aster, both who focus mostly on Isaiah. It argues that Hosea, based on the Neo-Assyrian Royal ideological use of the Akkadian Bullutu, innovates a new Hebrew meaning of the ???, which denotes God's remitting of punishment for a disloyal Israel. It traces this new usage through Isaiah and Jeremiah. This paper is part of an ongoing project to sketch the earliest interactions of Prophetic literature with Assyrian domination and idiom and their long term effects on Biblical literature and thought.
|
The Kadesh Inscriptions of Ramesses II and the Song of the Sea
Program Unit: Egyptology and Ancient Israel
Joshua Berman, Bar-Ilan University
The Song of the Sea (Exod 15:1-21) has long been examined against the backdrop of West Semitic mythopoeic compositions such as the Baal Cycle. This paper claims that the Sea account of Exodus 14-15 must be examined in light of Egyptian context as well. In particular, I claim that this account bears striking similarities with the Kadesh Inscriptions of Ramesses II, and specifically with the composition known as the Kadesh Poem. A common plot emerges: the protagonist army is attacked while on the march by an enemy chariot force. A plea is made for divine help, and victory is promised. Single-handedly, the king (Ramesses and YHWH respectively) engages the enemy, without assistance from his troops. The enemy charioteers are met with divine fire, and recognize the divine force that overpowers them. Many meet their death by drowning. Most significantly, in each composition the king's troops (Ramasses' and YHWH's respectively) return to the battlefield following the victory of the king over the enemy charioteers. There, they survey the corpses, are awestruck by the king, and offer a hymn of praise to him. The paper demonstrates that the Song of the Sea is replete with stock terms found in New Kingdom military inscriptions, and with terms found only in the Kadesh Poem. The paper concludes by surveying the role of the Kadesh Poem in the Egyptian literary tradition and offering conjecture as to when and why Israelite scribes would have composed the Sea account with the Kadesh poem in mind.
|
The Legal Blend in the Narrative of Gideon's Obliteration of His Father's Cultic Site (Judg 6:25–31)
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Joshua Berman, Bar-Ilan University
Michael Fishbane has proposed that in the books of Ezra-Nehemiah and Chronicles we find what he terms "legal blends": narrative passages outlining the performance of a law, whereby the narrative has "blended" the prescriptions of a given law from several different pentateuchal law corpora. The classic example is the blending of prescriptions concerning the paschal sacrifice in 2 Chr 35:13. Expositors have classically understood that this was a post-exilic phenomenon and demonstrated the need to unite Israel's differing legal customs in post-exilic Yehud. This paper rejects this narrative. It claims that the phenomenon of the legal blend is widespread within Israel's narrative tradition. I will take as my primary example the narrative of Judges 6 in which Gideon is instructed to obliterate his father's cultic site. I will demonstrate that the narrator of Judges 6 deliberately wove together the seemingly disparate and mutually exclusive prescriptions concerning the asherah found in Exod 34:13, Deut 7:5 and Deut 12:3. This exercise, in turn, allows us to consider the larger and more central question: how did biblical writers apprehend the relationship between the law-corpora? Why would the author of Judges 6 access all three prescriptions, rather than display affinity for one of them? I claim that this narrative is proof positive of a need to apprehend biblical law corpora as complimentary rather than as mutually exclusive.
|
The Gibeonite Deception: Reflections on the Interplay between Law and Narrative in Joshua 9
Program Unit: Joshua-Judges
Christoph Berner, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
“We have come from a far country …” (Josh 9:6). It is with these deceitful words that the Gibeonites introduce themselves to the unsuspecting Israelites and talk them into making a covenant. What necessitates their deception, is Israel’s war legislation which prescribes that all inhabitants of the land must be annihilated (cf. Deut 20:17). According to Josh 9, the Gibeonites were well aware of these stipulations and eluded them by pretending that they had come from a place far off. In this way, the chapter offers an explanation for why they were spared by the Israelites. Now, the obviously artificial character of the text strongly suggests that its author reacts to a problem he has already encountered in an earlier version of the narrative. In my paper, I try to demonstrate that it is in fact possible to reconstruct an early version of Josh 9 which did not yet contain the motif of the Gibeonites’ deceit. Rather, the text briefly told that the Gibeonites made peace with the Israelites, and thus prepared for the ensuing battle account in Josh 10. At this stage of development, an influence of the Deuteronomic Law is not yet discernible. Only later, Israel’s transgression of the divine commandment to utterly annihilate all inhabitants of the land was sensed as problematic which then triggered an extensive reworking of Josh 9. As a soultion, the editor now introduced the idea that the Gibeonites tricked the Israelites into making a covenant which, once established, had to be respected. Interestingly, the prohibition to make covenants (Exod 23:32; 34:12, 15; Deut 7:2; Judg 2:2) does not yet seem to be in view. Quite to the contrary, it is reasonable to assume that this peculiar law was only conceived in the light of Josh 9, as a means to close a potential legal loophole. By discussing these literary developments, I wish to illuminate the complex and fascinating interplay between law and narrative. Based on the results of the exegesis, I will then draw some general conclusions concerning the relationship between the Deuteronomic Law and the so-called Deuteronomistic History in the final section of my paper.
[This proposal is intended for session 3.]
|
Aposynagogos and the Aims of John
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Jonathan Bernier, McMaster University
The argument of this paper is two-fold. First, that if properly defined John’s aims in general and particularly in the aposynagogos passages (9:22, 12:42, 16:2) exclude the two-level reading typical of redaction-critical work on the Gospel. Second, that the relevant data warrants the judgment that these passages plausibly describe events that occurred during (in the case of 9:22 and 12:42) and potentially short after (in the case of 16:2) the ministry of Jesus.
|
Between Temple Scroll and Damascus Document: The Forms of the "Minor" Legal Texts from Qumran
Program Unit: Qumran
Moshe J. Bernstein, Yeshiva University
Because of their substantial size and virtual completeness alone, the Damascus Document (CD) and the Temple Scroll (11QT) have dominated most broad discussions of legal material at Qumran. Whether the matter under discussion is the content of the laws or the exegetical derivation of the laws or the arrangement of the laws, the focus is almost always one or the other or both of those two documents. Especially when it comes to consideration of the literary forms in which the laws are presented, it has become a virtual given in the field that there are two forms of legal documents at Qumran, the CD-type and the 11QT-type. The former is said to be analogous to the mishnaic form, while the latter stays close to the style of the Hebrew Bible.
On the other hand, it is due primarily to their fragmentary and incomplete nature that the “minor” (i.e., other than CD and 11QT) legal texts from Qumran have not been brought into play in consideration of the forms of Qumran legal interpretation. Texts that do not match up neatly with either CD or 11QT, such as 4Q159 (so-called Ordinances-a), 4Q251 (Halakha A), and a variety of others such as the Tohorot material, have thus had little impact on the theoretical discussion. This paper will examine a number of the “minor” legal texts among the Dead Sea Scrolls in order to demonstrate that the forms of Qumran legal texts actually lie along a spectrum which might be said to run from 11QT to CD in terms of their adherence to “biblical” or “mishnaic” styles, respectively. The standard view is thus seen to be useful only as a broad paradigm, and attempts to force the legal texts into binary pigeonholes should therefore be abandoned.
|
The Place of Wisdom across the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Jon L. Berquist, Disciples Seminary Foundation
In Hebrew Bible studies, there are three dominant theories about the spatial locus of wisdom: the household, the school, the scribal desk. I would want to argue for the household as primary, and I do not see an organized school system throughout most of Israel's system. Thus, wisdom begins in the household. (Most of Proverbs, the narrative frame of Job, etc. reflect this sociolect.) Because writing was taught within the households of scribes (who teach it to their children in an apprentice model), the scribal setting is also a household -- although a more urbanized household. Eventually, the scribes formed more of a guild than a household, but with many of the same characteristics as extended family. Thus, there are traces of family and household in the center of Job, the frame of Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, and later wisdom literature. What we see over the history of wisdom literature is not so much a move from household to school, but a move from rural household to urban households.
|
Isaiah 63:1–6: Otherness as Literary Strategy
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Willem Beuken, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
This paper explores the literary use of otherness in Isaiah 63:1–6—a unit that presents an encounter between the prophet and the bewildering figure in garments stained crimson, coming from Edom. The passage abounds with images and metaphors, including the image of this commanding and yet strange figure treading grapes. The rhetorical development of the passage relies on extensive use of otherness as a literary device. As has long been noted, this unit is strongly related, first of all, to Isa ch. 59, and next to chs. 60–62, while remotely to ch. 34.
The paper will mainly discuss two aspects of the unit: first, how the prophet perceives and describes this strange figure—otherness as deviance of image from reality—using the references to other related passages in Isaiah (mentioned above); second, how this imposing figure himself explains his identity, objectives, activity, and inner urgency—he thereby does not dissolve his otherness, on the contrary, he enhances it in a conspicuous way to the extent he defines himself with new otherness.
From all this, it will be shown that otherness affects both the prophet and the inscrutable figure. The two forms of otherness are not fixed images/metaphors but develop through interaction. As will be shown, the references of 63:1–6 to the immediately preceding chs. 59–62 and the far-off oracle against Edom (ch. 34) are not meant to dissolve the cloud of otherness that encloses the two actors. Rather, they help readers entering that cloud to become engaged in what takes place within it.
|
Loving Animals: A Queer Zoological Reading of Song of Songs
Program Unit: Gender, Sexuality, and the Bible
Jared Beverly, Chicago Theological Seminary
Through the lens of a queer zoological reading of Song of Songs, I will explore previously unnoticed examples of what might be animal attraction in the characters. For instance, the woman and her body is metaphorically represented by a number of animals: a mare (1:9), goats (4:1; 6:5), sheep (4:2; 6:6), and gazelle fawns (4:5; 7:3). Likewise, the man is characterized by gazelles and deer (2:8–9, 17; 8:14) and a raven (5:11). Behind these descriptions can be read an attraction to the animals themselves. If the man can call the woman sexually appealing by portraying her as a mare, then it is highly possible that a mare itself might also be sexually appealing. Interpreters of the Song regularly point out that the animal imagery in the text is representative of sexuality, but no one as of yet has gone as far as to argue that the animals themselves might be sexualized. In addition, I aim to show how the animal imagery can destabilize the boundary between humans and animals and thereby challenge racist and sexist discourses. A queer zoological interpretation such as this can reveal new dimensions of attraction in the Song.
|
Once Again: First Samuel 1 and the Deuteronomistic History
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Hannes Bezzel, Friedrich-Schiller-Universität Jena
In the course of the discussion about the original beginning of a first narrative of Israel’s history that may be labelled “deuteronomistic”, the spotlight of scholarly interest has been turned on 1 Sam 1. Martin Noth identified Dtn 1 as the opening chapter of his Deuteronomistic History not least out of necessity, because Josh 1 could not serve this purpose due to its transitory character (cf. Noth 31967, 12 f.). A reassessment of the redactional status of Dtn in the context of the story about the exodus and the conquest of the land led Reinhard Kratz – among other arguments – to the affirmation of an idea that had been tentatively suggested by Ernst Würthwein (1994) and Konrad Schmid (1999): 1 Sam 1 once opened a (first) deuteronomistic narrative about the history of Israel’s monarchy from its beginnings to its end (cf. Provan 1988, 164 f. with the concept of a pre-exilic DtrH from 1 Sam 1 to Hezekiah).
This thesis has been challenged by Christoph Levin in 2011. He refers to the similar openings in Judg 13:2; 17:1; 1 Sam 1:1; 9:1, and comes to the conclusion “[that a]t no time was there [...] a Deutero¬nomistic History composed only of the books of Samuel and Kings” (Levin 2011, 152 f.). In this regard, Levin is followed by Reinhard Müller, who recently emphasized this position and instead opts for “a pre-Deuteronomistic collection of stories that also [scil. together with 1 Sam 1, H.B.] included the narrative about Saul’s anointment in 1 Sam 9–10*, as well as the cycles about Samson in Judg 13–16* and about Micah and the Danite sanctuary in Judg 17–18*” (Müller 2013, 219). Without denying the thesis of a literary connection between the four references in question, the paper will argue that this connection rather should be explained diachronically. On this understanding, the case of the character(s) of 1 Sam 1 as well as of the oldest beginning of a Deuteronomistic History is reopened again.
|
Ideological Constraints and "Literal" Translation of the Bible
Program Unit: Metacriticism of Biblical Scholarship
Bryan Bibb, Furman University
Biblical translators produce Bible versions using critical methods, but they often work as agents of particular religious communities that expect "their" Bible to conform to a particular theological system. Thus, even textual criticism and translation theory are theologically implicated. All translation is interpretation, but many Christians consider one Bible version to be "the word of God" literally rendered into the English language, while they reject other translations as inadequate or dangerous interpretations of the "original." Thus, religious expectations can control not only translation decisions but also the very approach that is taken. To illustrate the theological agenda of this "literal translation" rhetoric, the paper will examine ways in which translators obscure the historical context of passages for theological reasons. The most important example of this translating against the text is the rendering of "Christological" passages in the Hebrew Bible, but others include the handling of historical inaccuracies, mythological imagery, and gender-related difficulties. Proponents of literal versions claim that they essentially translate the Hebrew and Greek words without interpreting them, but these translations are constrained by prior theological commitments and external pressures. "Liberal" protestant translations such as the CEB face similar constraints for different reasons. The fact that all mainstream biblical translations have been produced for a Christian market raises an important meta-question. What would a Bible translation look like if it faced no constraints from a religious community? The paper concludes with a preliminary sketch of an academic Bible produced by critical scholars exclusively for peers and students.
|
Women, Water, and Walkways: An Example from Tel Jezreel
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Julye Bidmead, Chapman University
In the Hebrew Bible young women were assigned the task of drawing water from wells to supply the family household. At the wells these women frequently acquired more than water; they often gained blessings and husbands (Gen. 21:14-20; 24:10-27; 29:1-11; Ex. 2:15-19). Yet, the meeting at the well was more than a biblical betrothal type-scene. Rather, water gathering was a gender-specific and time consuming task that was essential to the household and community. Cross cultural ethnographic data from nineteenth and early twentieth century Levant also depict women were the water barriers. Using the results of the 2014 Jezreel Expedition field season, with a focus on the ancient path that led from Tel Jezreel down to the spring (‘Ein Jezreel) below, this paper will discuss the length and gradient of the path while investigating the mechanics of water bearing. As women were drawing water from ‘Ein Jezreel for usage in settlement on the tel, various questions to reconstruct the social situation must be explored. This paper will examine the amount of daily time devoted to water carrying, methods of conveyance, and types of vessel employed.
|
“Truth-Telling” and the Hermeneutics of Trauma in Psalm 137
Program Unit: Biblical Literature and the Hermeneutics of Trauma
Miriam J. Bier, London School of Theology
Scholars of biblical lament literature often contend that this genre of prayer urgently needs to be re-embraced by the church, and, moreover, that it can be helpful in the world at large. The theory is that giving voice to past trauma, or “truth-telling,” akin to the biblical lament psalm tradition, can have therapeutic benefit for those who have suffered trauma.
However, recent studies of Rwandan witnesses of genocide by Karen Brounéus (2008; 2010) and Ulrike Funkeson et al. (2011) have found that in fact, those who talked about their experiences were significantly worse off, psychologically, than those who did not. Is it necessarily the case, then, that “truth-telling” is of therapeutic benefit to the teller?
This paper works at the collocation of Psalm 137, truth-telling, and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). It draws on clinical studies of religious framing by individuals with PTSD by Julia Juola Exline et al. (2005) to suggest that truth-telling in and of itself may be insufficient. It suggests that a key factor in the therapeutic benefit of biblical lament-style “truth-telling” is the assumed audience of the deity.
|
The dikaiosynê of God and the dikaiosynê of the Corinthians (2 Cor 9:9–10)
Program Unit: Second Corinthians: Pauline Theology in the Making
Reimund Bieringer, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
While dikaiosynê only occurs once in 1 Corinthians (see 1:30 where it is used with reference to Christ), this word is found seven times in the canonical 2 Corinthians. The noun dikaiosynê is present in the first apology 2:14-7:4 (namely in 3:9; 5:21; 6:7 and 6:14 which belongs to the disputed passage 6:14-7:1), in a collection chapter (9:9-10) as well as in the second apology 10:1-13:10 (namely in 11:15). In this paper we shall examine the meaning of “his dikaiosynê” in 2 Cor 9:9 and of “your dikaiosynê” in 9:10. In 9:9 Paul quotes Ps 111:9 LXX. Here the interpreters are divided as to whether Paul intends the subject of the statements to be the human person as in the original context of the psalm or rather God. Consequently the question is whether “his dikaiosynê” refers to God’s righteousness or to human righteousness/uprightness, possibly in the sense of benevolence or generosity. In 9:10 “your dikaiosynê” clearly refers to the “dikaiosynê” of the Corinthians/Achaians as the addressees of the letter. But what is the precise nuance of meaning of dikaiosynê in 9:9-10 in light of the occurrences of this vocabulary in 2:14-7:4 and in 10:1-13:10? In particular we shall investigate what the expressions “hê diakonia tês dikaiosynês” in 3:9 and “dikaiosynê theou” in 5:21 can contribute to our understanding of dikaiosynê in 9:9-10. We shall argue for a genuinely theological understanding of dikaiosynê in 9:9-10 reading these verses in line with 3:9 and 5:21. We shall investigate whether 9:(9-)10 and 3:9 can be understood as practical reflections of the theoretical theological statement of 5:21. In this way we shall examine whether 9:(9-)10 can be viewed as evidence of Paul’s dikaiosynê theology “in the making” or rather “in evolution.” Potential implications for the discussion of the unity of the letter will also be addressed.
|
Against Historicism: The Rule of Faith, Scripture, and Baptismal Historiography in Second-Century Lyons
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
D. Jeffrey Bingham, Wheaton College (Illinois)
Against Historicism: The Rule of Faith, Scripture, and Baptismal Historiography in Second-Century Lyons
|
The Ethiopian Alexander: Tracing the Roots of Ethiopic Traditions about Alexander the Great in the Zena Ayhud
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Yonatan Binyam, Florida State University
This paper accomplishes two tasks. First, it provides an introduction to the textual history of the works which inform the medieval Ethiopic text of Joseph Ben Gurion, which is also known as the Zena Ayhud. Secondly, it traces the story of Alexander’s visit to Jerusalem from its Hellenistic origins in works like Josephus to its appearance in the Ethiopic texts of the medieval period. The Zena Ayhud depends on an Arabic translation of the tenth-century Hebrew text commonly referred to as Yosippon. Yosippon itself builds upon various earlier traditions, including a Latin recension of Josephus known as Hegesippus, or Pseudo-Hegesippus. Yosippon also incorporates material from the Latin translation of Pseudo-Callisthenes, which is a Hellenistic account of stories about Alexander. This long and varied trajectory that connects the Hellenistic world to medieval Ethiopia affects the stories transmitted between the two points in an interesting way. Having provided an introduction to the various textual traditions involved in the transmission process, this paper analyzes some of the changes which can been seen between Josephus’s account of Alexander’s visit to Jerusalem and the Ethiopic version of that same story as it appears in the Zena Ayhud.
|
The Son of God and the Roman Imperial Cult: Engaging Some Recent Studies
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Michael F. Bird, Ridley Melbourne
The Son of God and the Roman Imperial Cult: Engaging Some Recent Studies
|
Why the Lost Gospels Lost Out
Program Unit: Texts and Traditions in the Second Century
Michael Bird, Ridley Melbourne
The omission of “other” Gospels from the canon of the orthodox church has often been attributed to the theological narrowness of its leader. Whereas some think that a top-down approach imposed “orthodoxy” on a diverse and pluralistic when it came to sacred literature, this study examines other reasons for the omission of “other” Gospels from ancient canon lists including their failure to convert the imaginations of persons in the proto-orthodox churches and their inability to provide a coherent narrative about God, Israel, Jesus, and salvation.
|
Desiring the Manuscript: Reading the Flesh-and-Book Song of Songs
Program Unit: Senses, Cultures, and Biblical Worlds
Fiona C. Black, Mount Allison University
This paper considers the multi-sensorial, affective experience of reading various historical manuscripts of the Song of Songs. Following the work of Michael Camille and others, the paper seeks to think through the medieval practice of experiencing texts (via smell, hearing, touch and taste, for instance), investigating whether the contemporary experience of reading—especially of the medieval illuminated manuscript—resonates with such practices. It challenges the notion that “modern” readers are limited to a flat, singular-sensed, and uni-directional relationship to texts, and also in this way wonders whether, and how, such “other-sensed” experiences of the text might impact traditional readings. The Song of Songs is a particularly apt text for such an inquiry, with its highly figurative, synaesthetic depiction of the world of the lovers. Building off previous work about the amatory relationship that readers have with the Song of Songs, here I pose questions about what it means to be an embodied reader and lover of the physical book. I also wonder what happens when the physical book, with its sounds, smells and touch, refuses to form a seamless relation with its own thematic contents.
|
“Ain’t Nobody Goin’ Take It from Me!” Dancing with David and the Shulamite as Frames for Junkanoo and Bahamian Identity
Program Unit: Islands, Islanders, and Scriptures
Fiona C. Black, Mount Allison University
Dance, in both its historical formulations during the slave trade and its contemporary manifestations in carnival celebrations, has enormous significance for numerous Caribbean cultures. Using some biblical texts to think with (2 Sam. 6: 14; Song 6:13), this paper explores the historical and contemporary event of Junkanoo as a reflection of Bahamian culture and its interaction with colonialism and contemporary tourism. Junkanoo is not explicitly biblical or religious, though it does show the marks and tussles of colonization and hence Christianization. The stories and themes of the Bible, impacting Caribbean history and culture as they have, are an apt resource. Indeed, Caribbean writers have often used the Bible to explore dynamics of colonialism and resistance, as for example in the poetry of Luis Pales-Matos. Two significant instances of biblical dance are explored here: the first is practiced by King David in celebration of the Ark’s return to Jerusalem, and is the subject of Michal’s censure (2 Sam. 6:16, 20-23); the second is the mysterious dance of the Mahanaim, performed by the Shulammite in Song 6:13, and the subject of her admirers’ gaze and potentially, a tool of her defiance. These biblical moments of movement and resistance frame dance in various and interesting ways—as the vehicle for emotional expression, as liberation, as licensed revolt, as the tool of empire—allowing for exploration of dance as a multi-valent, political act, as much as a powerful reflection of affect.
|
Irenaeus on the Deification of Believers and the Divinity of the Spirit
Program Unit: Development of Early Christian Theology
Ben C. Blackwell, Houston Baptist University
Within recent debates over the nature of early Jewish and Christian understandings of monotheism, the focus has been on the relationship of the Son to the Father and the issue of binitarianism. Within those discussions Irenaeus stands as an important marker in the development of early Christian Christology with his direct affirmation about the Son as God. At the same time, Irenaeus describes the Spirit and the Son as the two hands of God, and he sets the Spirit and Son alongside the Father in his discussion of the rule of truth. In light of these and other points of evidence, Anthony Briggman has recently argued strongly for a clear Trinitarian, not merely binitarian, theology in Irenaeus’ writings. A lens for situating the nature of the deity of the Spirit which has yet to be explored is Irenaeus’ use of deification language, as he calls believers “gods” in light of Psalm 82. Irenaeus’ effort to distinguish between believers as gods and the Son as g/God shows that he uses the language metaphorically for believers. (Or, as I have explained elsewhere, he argues for a form of “attributive deification” for believers rather than “essential deification.”) However, in his deification passages Irenaeus does not merely situate believers in relation to the Son; rather, Irenaeus repeatedly employs several Pauline texts to explain deification through the agency of the Spirit (i.e., Romans 8, Galatians 4, and 1 Corinthians 15). Thus, Irenaeus’ use of gods language and his qualification of its meaning provides a helpful lens to situate the nature of the deity of the Son and the Spirit. Irenaeus argues, explicitly for the Son and implicitly for the Spirit, that they must be divine by nature to deify believers, an argument that becomes central to later, fourth century debates about the nature of the deity of the Son and Spirit. Accordingly, while Irenaeus does not explicitly affirm that the Spirit is God, his exegesis of biblical texts in support of his doctrine of deification makes the deity of the Spirit clear in a way that others have not considered.
|
De caelo patrocinium: The Economy of Divine Patronage in Apuleius' Metamorphoses
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Thomas R. Blanton, Luther College
Analogies to the economy of the offering are typical of Greco-Roman religions—one need only point to the ubiquity of sacrifices and votive offerings dedicated at temples. However, when comparing Greco-Roman economies of the offering to that of modern French Catholicism, one must reckon with culturally specific modes of exchange. The aim of the present study is to delineate the economic and social functions of the “economy of the offering” as presented in the Metamorphoses, in its specific form shaped not least by the ideology and practice of Roman patronage. As a corollary, the study hopes to demonstrate that sociological models such as that developed by Pierre Bourdieu can serve useful heuristic functions for the study of antique religions, provided those models are appropriately nuanced and adapted to the ancient cultural contexts to which they are applied.
|
The Bitter Weight of Wisdom: Sensory Experience and Social Status in the Aramaic Book of Ahiqar
Program Unit: Senses, Cultures, and Biblical Worlds
Seth A. Bledsoe, Florida State University
This paper explores the sensory metaphors in the Aramaic Book of Ahiqar (5th c. BCE). Like many other wisdom collections (e.g., Proverbs), Ahiqar draws on imagery related to the senses in order to convey meaning. In this paper I will argue that the Book of Ahiqar uses language related to proprioception and taste in order to respond to a particular socio-economic circumstance. Attention to these senses reveals a worldview associated with “lower” levels of the social order. While social and economic concerns are common to wisdom collections, Ahiqar is prominent in having a perspective that is in sympathy with the poor or the foreigner. For example, whereas Proverbs mentions poverty as a warning for laziness or, at best, a circumstance of the “other” which is to be pitied, Ahiqar, on the other hand, speaks of a familiarity with the “bitterness” of poverty. One’s experience with poverty is metaphorically internalized for the audience by means of a representative act associated with such a social condition, namely the eating of bitter herbs — a real and regular taste of the poor person's palate. This paper will begin with a brief survey of social and economic issues as they relate to Ahiqar and the wisdom tradition. Then, I will look closely at a few sayings of Ahiqar which draw on proprioceptive and gustatory language in order to demonstrate how and why Ahiqar is unique in its use of the senses. Brief comparisons with similar sayings in the biblical books of Proverbs and Ben Sira will provide a helpful contrast.
|
The Power of a Shared Boast: Paul’s Use of Kauchema in Philippians as a Motivation for Ethical Conduct
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Isaac Blois, University of St. Andrews
This paper seeks to investigate the nature of Paul’s use of “boasting” language in Philippians 1:26 and 2:16, where the Apostle uses this terminology in discussing the ministry he has among his converts in Philippi. The study attempts to situate Paul’s language within the milieu of two important Greco-Roman topoi: friendship (building on the work of Stowers, Fitzgerald, Reumann, etc.) and political/military rhetoric (following Krentz, Geoffrion, Johan Vos). The thesis of the paper is that the idea of multiple individuals boasting in each other was not foreign to the culture of ancient Philippi, but rather was familiar, and was able to be used as a motivating factor for ethical behavior. The framework gleaned from such a background will then be applied to the epistle of Philippians as a whole, showing how Paul develops the concept of sharing with the Philippians in a mutual boast as a key motivating factor to promote their obedience to his exhortations given within the letter.
|
Didymus the Blind as Biblical Commentator: Didymus’ Exegesis of Pss 26:10–29:1
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Lincoln H. Blumell, Brigham Young University
As part of a current project at Brigham Young University to publish twenty-two signatures of Didymus the Blind’s commentary on the Psalms, this paper seeks to elucidate the content of this material. Specifically, this paper will seek to describe, analyze, and provide explanation of Didymus the Blind’s Commentary of Psalms 26:10–29:1. As this material has been in possession of Brigham Young University for almost 30 years and has remained unpublished the content of this material is surely welcome and will shed additional light on Didymus’ biblical exegesis.
|
An Earth Bible Reading of Margaret Atwood’s The Year of the Flood
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Elizabeth Boase, Flinders University
In her dystopian MaddAddam trilogy, Canadian novelist Margaret Atwood constructs a frighteningly plausible future world in which climate change, environmental degradation, genetic engineering, consumerism, materialism and the greed of multinational corporations have led to the development of a deeply divided and dysfunctional social landscape. In this fictional world, Atwood engages with the complex questions which dominate the rhetoric of late twentieth/early twenty-first century “western” society.
The second book of the trilogy The Year of the Flood centres on the figures of Toby and Ren, members of an eco-religious cult called God’s Gardeners. The novel is shaped around the stories and hymns told and sung by the Gardeners on their feast days. Spoken by Adam One, the founder and leader of the group, the stories/sermons weave together familiar threads from Genesis, Job and the Psalms, elements of evolutionary science, a devotion to vegetarianism, pacifism and harsh warnings about the evils of modern technology. The novel explores the dynamics of religious belief and its place in a world dominated by science and technology.
This paper seeks to explore the way in which Atwood brings the biblical text into conversation with evolutionary science in order to critique fundamentalist beliefs in both the religious and secular spheres. It will be argued that the stories and hymns of God’s Gardeners arguably reflect the eco-justice principles which form the hermeneutical framework of the Earth Bible Project. Atwood’s fictional eco-theology is one example of the way science and biblical faith might, and perhaps even does, find expression in a world in which science and faith are so often seen as oppositional rather than complementary.
|
Jerusalem and Zion in Exile: Dual Identity in Diasporic Perspective
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
Mark Boda, McMaster Divinity College
Zion and Jerusalem are well known as feminine figures within the prophetic books of the Hebrew Bible. In most cases these feminine figures relate to the physical city and/or its inhabitants in the land of Judah. However, in a few cases Zion and Jerusalem are actually identified with the exilic experience (e.g., Isa 49:21; 52:2; Jer 30:17; Zech 2:11[7]; cf. Lam 4:22). This paper investigates the use of Zion and Jerusalem as key bridge figures between homeland and diaspora, part of a rhetorical strategy to ensure diasporic adherence to homeland values and encourage a return to the homeland.
|
The Prophet Ezekiel as the Guardian of the Love Relationship between YHWH and His Wife Jerusalem
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
Daniel Bodi, Université Paris 8 Vincennes à Saint-Denis - University of Paris 8
The paper will start from the metaphor of the marital relationship between Yhwh and the city of Jerusalem presented as his wife in Ezekiel 16. As pointed out by André Neher, the matrimonial metaphor employed in Ezek. 16, implies the continuity of the nation through progeny. By denouncing corrupted love the prophet fights for the protection and restoration of true love and faithfulness. He also speaks about and hopes for a change of human heart (Ezek. 11:19). He is Yhwh’s ally in the ge?ullâ “redemption” of his compatriots. The prophet's role will be compared to similar figures in ancient Near Eastern literature with comparable roles: 1) Ištar as the guardian of human love par excellence in Iddin-Dagan’s Hymn and in the Atra?asis Epic I 299-304, insuring that marriage be fruitful with progeny. 2) Išum the guardian of both divine love (Erra and Mami) and human love relationships (young men and women) in the Poem of Erra I 21-22. He is also invoked in a profilactic incantation protecting people from destructive demonic influences that “tear the wife away from her husband.” This paper is part of my continued work on Babylonian influences on the themes and motives in the Book of Ezekiel.
|
Promoting a Cult Site without Bodily Relics: Material Substances and Imagined Topography in the Syriac Life of Symeon the Stylite
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Dina Boero, University of Southern California
Following the death of Symeon the Stylite the Elder in 459, Symeon’s body was transported from his cult site in Telneshe, Syria, to the Great Church in Antioch. The Syriac Life of Symeon, written by two of Symeon’s devotees in Telneshe only fourteen years after his death, speaks with great reverence of the interment of Symeon’s body in Antioch. However, the removal of Symeon’s body must have posed a challenge to the success of the cult site. A cult site’s authority and prestige depended in part on the possession and control of a saint’s remains. This paper investigates the Syriac Life of Symeon‘s attempt to promote a cult site that lacked bodily relics. In place of contact with Symeon’s body, the Syriac Life of Symeon describes the ritualized distribution of dust, water, oil, and ?nana (a paste mixture of oil, dust, and water) as an alternate method of accessing the saint’s intercessory power. These substances were holy not only because of their contact with Symeon but also due to their association with the sacred space of cult site. In addition to offering healing and protection, they functioned to delineate new spaces in the landscape marked by Symeon’s sanctity. In the imagined topography of the text, the distribution of these substances constructed a center and periphery for cultic devotion and created ritually-constituted territorial links between the cult site at Telneshe and satellite sites. This approach maximized the importance of the cult site at Telneshe while minimizing conflicts with neighboring centers of cultic devotion, particularly Antioch. It differentiated Telneshe’s cult community, while also integrating devotion to Symeon across an expansive landscape.
|
Strategic Essentialism as a Tactical Approach to an Ecofeminist Epistemology
Program Unit:
Cynthia Bond, Claremont Graduate University
*
|
Visualizing Literacy: Images, Media, and the Language of Minor Art in Ancient Israel
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Ryan P. Bonfiglio, Emory University
An increasing number of Hebrew Bible scholars suggest that literacy rates were quite low in the ancient world, thus raising questions about the role and importance of textual media in Israelite culture. In this perspective, orality is often seen as an alternative (or additional) mechanism of biblical transmission and interpretation. While this conclusion rightly recognizes that large threads of Israelite culture were oral, it does little to challenge the overarching assumption that words, whether written or spoken, are the sine qua non of communication. Rather than call into question the importance of orality, this paper expands the discussion about the Bible and ancient media by considering how images, especially in the form of the minor arts (i.e., seals, coins, amulets, and ivories), functioned as a type of language. In fact, due to their miniature size and ease of production, the minor arts served as a form of ancient "mass media" that was capable of disseminating religious beliefs and other forms of cultural knowledge across vast territories and throughout diverse segments of society. As such, I argue that the iconographic data on the minor arts constitutes a widely utilized vehicle of communication—perhaps even a lingua franca in the ancient world. This conclusion has two important implications for Hebrew Bible research. First, I contend that in order to understand the issue of biblical transmission more fully, we must attend to the notion of "visual literacy"—i.e., how ideas are expressed and received through images. This is especially needed when it comes to interpreting the conceptual background of figurative imagery in the Hebrew Bible. Second, understanding images as a type of language raises crucial but often unasked questions about the types of interactions that occur between visual and textual media, including the relative importance of word and image on mixed-media artifacts.
|
Israelite Religion and the Myth of Aniconism
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Ryan P. Bonfiglio, Emory University
In The Power of Images, art historian David Freedberg claims that the idea of there being cultures or religions completely without images—that is, purely aniconic—is "a deep and persistent historiographic myth." Much of the same can be said about ancient Israel. As such, some biblical scholars offer a narrower definition of ancient Israel's aniconic tradition. For instance, in his highly influential study (No Graven Image? 1995) Tryggve N. D. Mettinger draws on Charles Sanders Peirce's semiotic theory to suggest that only iconic signs—i.e., images that aim to resemble the deity's appearance in a naturalistic or anthropomorphic fashion—were prohibited. While Mettinger's use of Peircian semiotics makes an important contribution to the study of Israelite aniconism, his definition tends to assume that what makes a religion aniconic or iconic is primarily determined by what its images look like or how they signify. However, an equally important, and perhaps more relevant, issue to consider has to do with how certain images were utilized, relied upon, and responded to by their users regardless of whether those images are classified as iconic or non-iconic signs. Drawing on evidence from ancient Near Eastern art and religion, this paper makes two observations about the correlation between iconographic preferences and visual practices. First, the absence of iconic representations of the deity in a given media (such as glyptic art) does not necessarily indicate that a given culture's worship practices were aniconic. Second, there is ample evidence that non-iconic divine images (such as symbols, emblems, and metonymic or "empty-space" representations) were often described and responded to in much the same way as anthropomorphic cult statues or other iconic signs. In light of these observations, this paper revises Mettinger's definition of aniconism and, more broadly, suggests that Israel's so-called "aniconic tradition" shared far more in common with other ANE visual practices than is often assumed.
|
Early Qur'anic Manuscripts from the Muslim West: A Typological Survey
Program Unit: The Qur’an: Manuscripts and Textual Criticism (IQSA)
Umberto Bongianino, University of Oxford
My paper aims to bring into focus the rich but often overlooked production of fine Qur'anic material in the Maghrib al-Aqsa (modern Morocco) and al-Andalus (Muslim Spain) between the 5th/11th and the 6th/12th centuries. From a palaeographic perspective, this period witnessed the crucial transition from local Kufic scripts to Maghribi cursive scripts, already employed during the previous century in non-Qur'anic and Mozarab manuscripts. Despite this dramatic change, paralleled in the Muslim East by the so-called 'revolution of Ibn al-Bawwab', numerous features of western Kufic Qur'ans were preserved, and constituted for the following centuries the distinctive trademarks of the Maghribi school of calligraphy and illumination: chapter headings in knotted Kufic, different colours and shapes in notation and orthoepic signs, enduring predilection for parchment, etc. Several variants of Maghribi Qur'anic scripts were also devised - from monumental to miniature - and begun to influence the style of non-Qur'anic religious texts, such as Hadith collections and the fundamental works of Maliki doctrine. The possibility of linking these calligraphic traditions to precise sub-regions of the medieval Maghrib (such as Western or Eastern Andalus, Northern or southern Morocco) will be discussed, trying to dispel some widespread misconceptions. The last part of the paper deals with the format and function of the earliest surviving Wester n Qur'ans, from the horizontal multi-volume codices still produced in the 5th/11th century, to the single-volume, square 'pocket' Qur'ans dominating the 6th/12th century, epitomised by the work of the Ibn Ghattus family (Valencia). The question will be tackled as to whether the miniaturisation of Western Qur'ans in the 1100s is a historical phenomenon prompted by political and cultural changes, or rather a false modern impression generated by problems of survival.
|
Were Ancient Libraries Anything Like a Canon?
Program Unit: Book History and Biblical Literatures
Francis Borchardt, Lutheran Theological Seminary, Hong Kong
Though libraries and canons can both be collections of texts, the terms are not synonymous. The precise definition and characteristics of each entity are necessarily distinguished. Further, the use of these terms are tied to specific contexts. This paper will survey several libraries and library-like entities particularly relevant for the ancient Judean context (e.g. the “temple libraries” of Judas Maccabeus and Nehemiah, the “library at Qumran”, the library of Alexandria, and gymnasium libraries) highlighting their function and the nature of their collections, so far as we know them. The paper will then proceed to discuss these findings in comparison to the qualities associated with the term ‘canon’ as it is used when discussing scripture. The aim of this paper will contribute to the ongoing discussion attempting to clarify the definitions and necessary conditions for both ‘library’ and ‘canon'.
|
From the Horse’s Mouth: Second Maccabees 2:19–32; 15:38–39 and Textual Adaptation
Program Unit: Transmission of Traditions in the Second Temple Period
Francis Borchardt, Lutheran Theological Seminary, Hong Kong
In studying how and why texts are changed in antiquity, the empirical comparison of ancient textual witnesses is undoubtedly valuable. It shows for us what changes were possible and to what types of text they were made. However, this type of evidence does not provide the whole story. It cannot tell us why particular changes were made or versions selected over and against others. It further cannot give us much of a clue about the reception of such changes. There is evidence from the ancient Judean context that may help provide some insight: the testimony of ancient scribes who make such changes. 2Maccabees provides just such an example. The scribe claims to have abbreviated a five volume work by Jason of Cyrene, producing his one volume work. The scribe goes on to explain how and why such an abbreviation is being published. This paper will reflect on the testimony offered by this scribe particularly as it relates to 1) the reasons scribes might change texts, 2) the impact such changes may have had on the newly produced text, and 3) the reception of texts known to have been changed. Comparisons to other texts from the ancient world will be brought into the discussion.
|
Addressing the Spiritual Dimension of the Secular: Encouraging Spiritual Awareness in a Freshman Biblical Studies Honors Course
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Jason Borders, Huntingdon College
In the Fall 2013 Semester, I was given charge to develop and teach all of our honors sections of a new course entitled "Interpreting the Bible" at Huntingdon College. This was the debut of this course for our college, required for all incoming freshmen. Since I was responsible for pedagogical design and implementation, I combined the 3 sections as one "think tank" through a class website using wikis, blogs, photos, etc. Students began working on a project to determine the most dominant symbols of society (in our case, the American South) that expressed who they were as persons, individually and collectively. They were to interpret these symbols and begin to work together to explain how these shaped who they were as individuals and as a group. We took these symbols and used the biblical text to consider possible connections or disconnections between them. The class encouraged a large group of students to consider the spiritual dimensions of their secular context, assisting them as we explored questions of meaning and purpose within a broader context of knowledge as a social construct.
Based on results from my first attempt, the second iteration of the course will improve upon the above strategy by specifically exploring the sacred dimensions of the classroom space. Particular attention will be given to the challenge, offered in Cultivating the Spirit: How College Can Enhance Students’ Inner Lives, that “there’s little opportunity [on campus] to talk specifically about spiritual matters.” In my previous attempt to teach this course, I was surprised to find that my students perceived “education” and “college” and the “classroom” as sacred spaces. By sacred, I mean that students have been formed to think and act in certain ways when occupying the classroom space. Students were unaware of this learned sacredness until it came into conflict with their attempts to add their own voices to the learning process. In our case, students’ preconceptions of this sacred space actually discouraged self-reflection and expression. The learned sacredness of the classroom space was exposed as a spiritually oppressive symbol. As I modify the course for the Fall 2014 Semester, I am wondering how attention to the space of the classroom itself may open up for students new possibilities for exploring the spiritual dimensions of society at large.
|
Moving to the Kingdom of God: The Intention of Q in Light of the Semantics of Room, Space, and Characters
Program Unit: Q
Arne Bork, Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz
In recent research, Q has often been understood as a literarily as well as theologically coherent text. Nevertheless, skepticism concerning the ability to reconstruct the precise text of Q persists and, at least in some cases, may even cast doubt upon the significance of Q-research in principle. In order to avoid this difficulty, I have chosen to pursue an intertextual approach to Q in order to demonstrate the theological and literary interest(s) of this text, not on the basis of a precise reconstruction, but rather by means of the semantics of room and space as well as characters and movement.
For this purpose, I bring into contact New Testament research and literary theory which provides concrete illustrations on the specific intention of the Q-document. By means of the theories of space semantics of Jurij Lotman as well as George Lakoff and Mark Johnson, I point out first, that spatial oppositions in Q correspond to semantic oppositions, and second, that concepts of movement such as the coming of the Kingdom of God as a top down movement enlighten the metaphorical language of Q which refers to a certain social reality. Regarding the characters of Q, we have to admit that most of them can only obtain a very rudimentary characterization. Hence, I have chosen to analyze certain characters of Q by means of their relation to the narrated space. An important role is assigned not only to the movement of characters, but also to the function of significant characters and character groups within the reality of Q. A specific inventory of roles for the plot arises out of this analysis, an inventory which can then be organized and presented through the character analysis model of Jens Eder.
The analysis of Room, Space and Characters finally leads to the perception that Q constructs the identity of a religious community literarily. This literary arrangement essentially results from an important change of scenery performed by the entry into the Kingdom of God, which is described in Q as a household and thus as the central room in Q. Altogether, this intertextual and literary criticism approach to Q provides an innovative access to the narration of Q which confirms and complements previous Q-research.
|
Reading the Prophetic Books as Propaganda: Haggai and Zephaniah as Test Cases
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
James M. Bos, University of Mississippi
Propaganda is a persistent messaging technique (or series of techniques) employed by the elite that has for its goal, whether intentional or not, obtaining or maintaining the legitimacy of these elite and the consequent imbalance of resources provided them by means of this legitimacy. In ancient Judah, one available propaganda technique was via the writing of literature, including the prophetic books. This paper will examine how propaganda theory may shed light on the prophetic books as one aspect of the propaganda messaging system employed by the elite in early Persian-period Judah by analyzing the books of Haggai and Zephaniah. In the case of Haggai, the tradents promoting and distributing its message very overtly support or even require the redistribution of resources to the temple. In the case of Zephaniah, the propaganda is more subtle, but the tradents responsible for this book thoroughly delegitimize the worldview and religious practices that were in competition with their own, the net result being that should the book’s message be accepted, the religious functionaries serving Yahweh would benefit.
|
Weeping in Hebrew and Akkadian Prayers
Program Unit: Bible and Emotion
David A. Bosworth, Catholic University of America
Tears reflect strong emotions in those who shed them and in those who witness them. Researchers (e.g., Judith Kay Nelson and Ad Vingerhoets) understand weeping as an attachment behavior, or a behavior directed toward another person that seeks to reinforce relationship and elicit caregiving. This understanding of weeping coheres with decades of research in attachment theory (initiated by John Bowlby) and more recent work in the social sharing of emotions (by Bernard Rimé et al.). Crying is not a solitary behavior that discharges emotion, but a social behavior that builds relationship and facilitates the co-regulation of emotion. This modern theory of weeping illuminates ancient literary texts that employ weeping as a motif for diverse purposes. The present paper will focus on weeping in ancient prayer texts. It is a corpus-based study that examines the motif of weeping in large collections of Hebrew and Akkadian prayers in order to discern both specific functions of weeping in prayers and larger patterns in the distribution of the motif. The textual evidence of ancient prayers tends to confirm findings in the psychology of religion that persons at prayer engage in an attempt to regulate their emotions through relationship with a deity that closely resembles how people regulate emotions in relationships with other humans. In prayer texts, the speaker may verbalize non-verbal weeping behavior in order to draw on the power of tears to elicit caregiving and connect to the deity.
|
“On Their Way to Nowhere”? Exploring Body, Identity, and Place in the Jesus Movement
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Pieter J.J. Botha, University of South Africa
There are links between adopting an itinerant life style and distinct expositions of divinity and moral issues. Given that places are the clear supports of identity, and that no one has a natural, inborn inclination to become itinerant, the various implications of the spatial and communal identities developed by the itinerant early Christian “teachers” require investigation. The constitutive other of communal identity is neither an ontological nor a psychical geography but an epistemological entity, integrated with and defined by distinct somatological metaphors. The focus will be on selected traditions from the early Roman empire to explore possible relationships between religious and moral views and aspects of the social construction of the human body. The Jesus movement will be approached as situated in this context. Being ostensibly ‘on their way to nowhere’ expresses ways of thinking about the role of religion and moral behaviour that contrasts not only in terms socio-economic realities but also how human bodies should and can be constructed. The alternative somatological sensibility — ascetical and uprooted — that emerged may have been more about not liking what it saw in elite body construction than about really imagining an alternative vision.
|
In the Beginning God Spoke...to Jesus: Script and Dramatic Enactment in Mark's Prologue (1:1–15)
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Max A. Botner, University of St. Andrews
In this paper I aim to demonstrate that the composite citation at the opening of Mark (1:2-3) is the key to unlocking the narrative grammar of the prologue (1:1-15). While it is universally recognized that the citation functions to introduce John the Baptist (1:4-8), and on some level, Jesus (1:9-11f), what I take as a central function of the citation is rarely mentioned. That is, the gospel of Jesus begins with God speaking directly to Jesus (1:2). By making this rhetorical move, the narrator is able to show the audience that this Jesus-story is indeed gospel (1:1) precisely because God has elected to make Jesus the protagonist of his (God’s) story. For heuristic purposes, I read the composite citation (1:2-3) as the prologue’s performative script and the remainder as its dramatic enactment (1:4-15). By calling the script “performative,” I intend to highlight God’s role as the central actor of the prologue, and especially, to emphasize the foundational speech-act of the entire gospel—the pre-narrative “moment” when the divine “I” directly addresses “you” (1:2). Through a narrative reading, I go on to explore how the dramatis personae respond to their scripted roles, even and especially, when they appear to have broken with the script.
|
The Recalcitrant Prophet: Jonah between the Qur’an and the Hebrew Bible Traditions
Program Unit: The Qur’an and the Biblical Tradition (IQSA)
Emad Botros, McMaster Divinity College
It is interesting to note that none of the major or minor biblical prophets other than Jonah appears in the Qur’an. This paper examines the interplay between the Qur’an and the Hebrew Bible traditions of Jonah as a prophet. One of the main methodological questions this paper will address is how the interplay between both traditions can be best described and how these traditions are used in their respective contexts.
This paper will suggest that the Qur’an uses Jonah as an example, or illustration, to warn its audience. If we assume that the Qur’an is interested in Jonah’s narrative with this particular purpose in mind, focusing on the dynamics of repentance and divine mercy, then one can argue that the Qur’an tells the story in such a way that serves this purpose, and is not concerned at all, as some scholars suggest, with establishing a basic sequence of the events. This paper, thus, raises the question of whether we need the biblical subtext of Jonah’s narrative in order to fully understand and solve some interpretive problems of the Qur’anic narrative.
This paper will be divided into three major sections. The first section will briefly review different approaches to the interplay between the Qur’an and Hebrew Bible traditions, with particular interest in Jonah. The second section will attempt to identify differing functions and emphases of the two accounts of Jonah in their respective contexts to show how the function of the narrative in the Qur’an affects the choice of materials included and the treatment given to it. The third section will reflect on the interplay between the Qur’an and the Hebrew Bible traditions of Jonah suggesting that both Muslims and non-Muslims are encouraged to appreciate both traditions in their respective contexts.
|
Abraham’s “Dead” Body in Rom 4:19 and Heb 11:12: By Age or Association?
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Nicholas Bott, Stanford University and Palo Alto University
The descriptions of Abraham’s body in Rom 4:19 and Heb 11:12 have historically been cited as evidence of his infecundity, and by extension, of the divine procreative power both he and Sarah received for the fulfillment of the promised heir. And while current scholarly consensus upholds the divine procreative power argument to account for Abraham’s children with Keturah, this solution is admittedly forced (Dunn). In contrast, the interpretations of Augustine and Abelard argue against Abraham’s infecundity on the grounds that Abraham produced more children with Keturah later in life. Rejecting the argument that Abraham’s divine procreative power persisted even after Sarah’s death, Augustine advances the argument that Keturah’s youth and fertility in combination with Abraham’s diminished fertility, and in contrast to Sarah’s post-menopausal state, better accounts for Abraham’s subsequent children. Abelard also rejects the persistence of divine procreative power to explain Abraham’s subsequent children, arguing that Abraham’s “dead” body is grammatically connected with Sarah’s “dead” womb, thereby suggesting a joint powerlessness. In light of these alternative proposals, this paper argues for an interpretation of Abraham’s infecundity by means of his association with Sarah through marriage, demonstrating the contextual presence of Sarah in these texts, validating both the grammatical and biological interpretations of Abelard and Augustine respectively, and offering additional exegetical support for Abraham’s marital relationship with Sarah as the theological grounds for his infecundity. This paper is particularly distinctive in that it establishes the literary coherence of Abraham’s faith, age, and childless status as mediated by his marital relationship to Sarah. With this reading, Abraham’s infecundity and subsequent fertility can no longer be understood in isolation from his relationship with his wife, Sarah, and the faith for which Abraham is lauded in Rom 4:19 and Heb 11:11-12 exhibits remarkable sensitivity to the underlying scriptural narrative to which it alludes.
|
Review of James Davila, Hekhalot Literature in Translation
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Ra'anan Boustan, University of California-Los Angeles
Review of James Davila, Hekhalot Literature in Translation
|
Missing Books and Their Ancient Libraries
Program Unit: Book History and Biblical Literatures
James Bowley, Millsaps College
Getting beyond what Robert Kraft called the ‘tyranny of canon’ is crucial, if we are to understand the world of ancient Israelite and Jewish textual culture. Such a task requires both the eschewing of any understanding this literature that derives from the idea of canon, the re-imagining of textual and scribal possibilities, and the exploring of old and new data in a variety of ways that are now open because we have removed the anachronistic barriers of canonization and codexification.
In line with this view of ancient Israelite literature, this paper explores data of preserved texts of the Dead Sea Scrolls and medieval manuscripts of Hebrew Bible to discover ways to gain insight into the existence of texts that are now “missing” from collections of ancient Israelite literature and ways to understand better the ancient collecting, or library-making, of texts. Looking for clues of scrolls now lost expands the possibilities of literary influence and broadens the comparative context of all Israelite literature. Searching for possible collections of texts might help us better imagine and understand values and ideologies of collectors prior to the invention of ‘Bible’. We will explore known evidence (e.g. Jer. 36 of Jerusalem; 1 Macc. 12.9 of Jerusalem, Luke 4.17 of Nazareth, 2 Tim. 4.13 of Troas) and other evidence in an effort to expand our vision of ancient text making and collecting.
|
The Temple Setting of the Sermon on the Mount in the Book of Mormon: A Hermeneutical Key?
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
Robert M. Bowman Jr., Institute for Religious Research
The Book of Mormon reports Jesus preaching to the Nephites the Sermon on the Mount almost exactly as it appears in the Gospel of Matthew (3 Nephi 12-14, cf. Matt. 5:3-7:27). John Welch has proposed that the temple setting of the Nephite sermon provides a hermeneutical key to the biblical Sermon on the Mount as a temple text. In this paper, Welch’s temple-text model for interpreting the Sermon will be compared with an alternative interpretive framework, the Messianic-kingdom model. The paper defends the following six conclusions. (1) Although temple motifs do appear in the Sermon on the Mount, its dominant theme is the Messianic kingdom that Jesus came to inaugurate. (2) The problem with moralistic interpretations of the Sermon is not that they are exoteric but that they are superficial misinterpretations that ignore the kingdom context of Jesus’ sayings. (3) Jesus’ authority in the Sermon derives not from the temple but from Jesus’ own status as the royal and divine Son of God. (4) The Sermon’s structure is not a temple-oriented ritual ascent through ever-higher stages of spiritual development, but that of a Jewish didactic literary composition. (5) The genre of the Sermon was not that of an ascent or ritual text but an anthology of Jesus’ teachings on the Messianic kingdom, composed around the core of Jesus’ historical sermon in Galilee. (6) Jesus’ agenda in reference to the temple was not its renewal or restoration but the revelation that the temple’s typological purpose was being fulfilled in his coming. Thus, in all six aspects of the Sermon—its themes, interpretation, authority, structure, genre, and agenda—a Messianic-kingdom model proves superior to a temple-centered model for understanding the Sermon as a whole. Therefore, the temple theme is not a long-lost hermeneutical key to the Sermon on the Mount.
|
Pedagogies of the Talmud: Boyarin Contra Levinas on Labor and Migration in the Talmud
Program Unit: Bible and Cultural Studies
Daniel Boyarin, University of California-Berkeley
This presentation will focus particularly on issues of pedagogy when engaging labor, migration, and biblical studies.
|
A Tale of Two Eunuchs: Towards an SBLCS Commentary on Esther A.12–17 and 2:19–23
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Cameron Boyd-Taylor, Trinity Western University
Esther A.12-17 (plot1) and 2:19-23 (plot2) comprise a doublet within Greek Esther. In both pericopes Mardochaios learns of a plot against the king by two eunuchs, reports the matter, and is honored accordingly. While plot1 has no direct counterpart in MT (it does occur in the ancient Greek version referred to as AT, but neither in the Old Latin nor Josephus), plot2 is evidently the translation of a source similar to MT 2:19-23 (for which AT lacks a parallel). The tradition history of the doublet remains highly controversial, and there is no consensus regarding the relationship of plot1 to the activity of the Hebrew-Greek translator responsible for plot2. This uncertainty raises serious problems for a genetic historical-critical commentary such as the SBLCS, focused as it is on the text as produced (see the Preamble to the Guidelines). Without losing sight of these problems, I hope to show through detailed commentary that the thematic mirroring of the two episodes in Greek Esther is intentional and not a mere bi-product of redaction. Whatever its tradition history, plot1 is an integral part of the text as it comes down to us. Motifs peculiar to it are echoed both in the translated material paralleled by MT as well as in material found in the so-called Additions. I shall suggest, therefore, that in this particular instance synchronic literary analysis of the extant text is not inconsistent with the aims of genetic commentary.
|
The Gospel of Judas, “Gnostics,” and “Sethians”: An Emendation to My Argument in The Gnostics
Program Unit: Westar Institute
David Brakke, Ohio State University
*
|
Textual Relationships: The Bible and Other Ancient Literature
Program Unit: Global Education and Research Technology
Rick Brannan, Logos Bible Software
The Bible is rich with textual relationships. The textual relations within the Biblical text are frequently studied, but the relationships between the Biblical text and other ancient literature do not play as large a role, probably due to the difficulty in tracking them down.
Logos Bible Software is developing data that classifies relations between the Biblical text and literature such as Talmuds, sectarian Dead Sea Scrolls, Pseudepigrapha, and other corpora. These sorts of textual relationships matter because they shed light on how the Biblical text was used and understood in antiquity. They also provide greater insight to ancient cultures. With this sort of data available, when studying a Bible passage it will be easier to examine possible relations between the current passage and a wealth of ancient literature.
The references have been classified as intertextually related (citation, quotation, allusion, echo), topically related (topical, historical), or lexically related (phrase, word). Further, because these references are abstracted to their structure and the relationships use a limited vocabulary, the reference and relationship can be localized to languages other than English when located and displayed within Logos Bible Software, making this valuable data available to those working with primary languages other than English.
|
Another Look at the Principalities and Powers in Paul
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Jeff Brannon, Belhaven University
The elusive “principalities and powers” of the Pauline corpus have been the subject of much intrigue and debate within New Testament studies. These terms appear in the undisputed Pauline letters of Romans and 1 Corinthians but are most prevalent in the disputed letters of Colossians and Ephesians. Among interpreters, there has been little agreement on the nature, background, function, and identity of these powers. As to their nature, which will not be discussed at length, I contend that the principalities and powers (and other related terms which appear in the Pauline corpus) are personal, evil, and spiritual powers. In this paper, I will explore some overlooked aspects of the principalities and powers in Paul and attempt to shed light on the topics of the background, function, and identity of these spiritual powers. In reference to background, I will argue that the Old Testament and Jewish thought are the proper background for Paul’s view of the principalities and powers; however, since Paul’s usage of the terminology predates the usage in apocalyptic and since there is a divergence between Pauline and apocalyptic usage of the terminology under consideration, I will argue that the Old Testament and Jewish background for Paul’s understanding is conceptual rather than from terminology. This background is important for the second topic I will explore, namely Paul’s view of how the principalities and powers function and operate. Specifically, I will highlight two significant aspects which have generally been overlooked in discussions of the function of the principalities and powers in the Pauline corpus. First, Paul conceives of the principalities and powers as evil powers which lead the nations astray from God. Second, Paul subtly highlights that the principalities and powers join Satan in an accusing role against God’s people. I will investigate these ideas in the Old Testament and Second Temple Jewish thought and will also demonstrate how Paul emphasizes that these functions of the principalities have been broken in Christ. Finally, in relation to the identity of the powers, I will explore the question of whether these powers should be identified with or distinguished from other terms for evil powers in Paul and in the larger New Testament.
|
Toward a Theory of the Social: An Assessment of the Work of Theodore Schatzki
Program Unit: Redescribing Christian Origins
Willi Braun, University of Alberta
Since the turn to the social in the study of religion in the late twentieth century it is a cliché to announce that religion cannot be disarticulated from other dimensions of the social. Rarely, however, is this cliché analytically influential. Taking it seriously means to consider “the social,” not “religion,” as the preeminent theoretical challenge. A consideration of the work of Theodore Schatzki is offered here as an attempt to question the perverse distinction between religion and the social.
|
Generate Research Questions through Turabian and Digital Collaboration
Program Unit: Wabash Center for Teaching and Learning in Theology and Religion
Mara Brecht, St. Norbert College
This teaching tactic employs Kate Turabian's Manual for Writers of Research Papers, Theses, and Dissertations and Google Docs to help students begin the research process by collaboratively following a systematic guide for identifying a research question. The strategy enables students to view the research process as inquiry-based and to see themselves as participants in a scholarly conversation.
|
Daniel as Interpreted by Oppressor and Oppressed
Program Unit: Book of Daniel
Brennan Breed, Columbia Theological Seminary
In the Persian period the figure of Daniel offered hope to disaporic Jews living under foreign rule, and in the Hellenistic period Daniel encouraged Jews living under the oppression of Antiochus IV. It is unsurprising, then, that Daniel functioned in similar ways for various disaporic, minority and oppressed communities throughout history, who often read Daniel as a statement about their political situations. Some saw the text as an example of quietism or subtle resistance, while others understood it as a call to armed rebellion. But Daniel also functioned as scripture for many dominant groups that had attained temporal power, and these groups continued to read and interpret the book of Daniel as somehow instructive for their political consolidation of power. This paper will explore the markedly different dynamics of interpreting Daniel in oppressive and oppressed communities. It will introduce a variety of ways that those in power have interpreted the book of Daniel to legitimate their authority and offer hope for their eternal dominance--and offer a glimpse of those rare instances in which the reception of Daniel prompted internal critique among the powerful. This paper will also analyze the types of oppression that cultivated interpretation of particular texts in Daniel within minority groups, and the specific hopes that the different stories and visions of Daniel tended to offer to these groups. Particular attention will be given to the four-kingdom schema in Daniel 2 and 7.
|
First-Century Philippi: The Social and Political Background of Paul’s Visit
Program Unit: Polis and Ekklesia: Investigations of Urban Christianity
Cedric Brelaz, Universite de Strasbourg
Philippi is with Pisidian Antioch and Corinth, the two other colonies visited by Paul, by far the most well-known Roman colony in the Greek-speaking East. Hundreds of inscriptions on stone such as honorific texts, dedications and epitaphs have been found, and are still being found nowadays, on the site of ancient Philippi and in the surrounding region. As everywhere in the Graeco-Roman world, these monuments were primarily used by local elites to stage themselves in front of the civic community. The systematic study of inscriptions allows us to look at the social, ethnic and linguistic features of Roman Philippi as well as at the civic and religious life of the colony. In particular, the social and political background of Paul’s visit can be inferred from such evidence. This paper will aim at putting Paul’s visit in its local context. Apart from the Jews, which were the ethnic communities Paul might have met in Philippi with a view to proclaiming his message ? What were the most spoken languages in the colony and what was the proportion of people able to understand Paul’s preaching in Greek ? What were the main cults in Philippi at that time and how were organized the pagan religious associations Paul had to deal with ? What were the social milieu and the ethics of the local magistrates responsible for the arrest of Paul and his fellows ? How did the political and legal institutions in Philippi allow the jailing of Paul, a Roman citizen, without trial ? On the other hand, attention will be paid to the fact that the narrative of the Acts of the Apostles on Paul’s stay at Philippi, brief though it is, provides a lot of informations on the colony which would otherwise have remained unknown to us. This paper will argue that society in first-century Philippi can only be fully understood through the combined investigation of epigraphic and New Testament evidence.
|
Plutarch’s Monotheism and the New Testament
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Frederick E. Brenk, Pontifical Biblical Institute, Rome
Perhaps, a more natural comparison would be between Plutarch’s monotheism and that of the Old Testament/Hebrew Bible, rather than that of the New Testament. Presumably, many of those attracted to Judaism, Theosebeis, would have been coming from religious Platonism, especially in a monotheistic form. On a number of points, however, Plutarch’s monotheism fits with the New Testament concept, even granting certain essential differences. These are the beliefs: 1. belief in a Middle Platonic God who alone has the fullness of being and good (thus equated with the Platonic Form of the Good and Beautiful) and living in instantaneous eternity; 2. belief in the literal interpretation of creation in the Timaios and in God’s providential oversight over the world; 3. the possibility of divine filiation; 4. that certain gods of popular religion vaguely reflect the supreme Middle Platonic God, such as Apollo (The E at Delphi) and less explicitly, Osiris (On Isis and Osiris); 5. belief in a god who undergoes suffering and death, is resuscitated, and ascends to reign in heaven as in the case of Osiris.
|
The "Historical Psalms" and Their Sources
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Marc Zvi Brettler, Brandeis University
The Psalter contains a dozen or so psalms that refer to events or traditions also mentioned in the Pentateuch. Much ink has been spilled on determining if particular psalms knew particular biblical texts. This paper will examine the "historical psalms" in books four and five of the Psalter with the aim of developing criteria for determining whether or not particular psalms are alluding to texts that are now extant in the Pentateuch and the Deuteronomistic History.
|
Religion and Contemporary Art: The Emmanuel Paintings of Alfonse Borysewicz
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Christopher R. Brewer, University of St. Andrews
Alfonse Borysewicz (b. 1957) is a Brooklyn-based, American artist who, after receiving a B.A. and an M.A. from St. John’s Provincial Seminary (Detroit, MI), decided against the priesthood, moved to Boston and enrolled in the Studio School of the Museum of Fine Arts. Early success led to a string of exhibitions in Boston, New York and Tokyo, as well as two Pollock-Krasner Foundation Fellowships, and a John Simon Guggenheim Painting Fellowship. Nevertheless, Borysewicz has confessed that he was reserved about his Catholic beliefs in these early exhibitions. That said, in the mid-nineties Borysewicz began to explore the biblical images which fed his imagination. This resulted in increasingly explicit religious imagery, and culminated in 2005 with four Emmanuel Paintings: Emmanuel I – Bethlehem (2005), Emmanuel II – Jordan River/Galilee (2005), Emmanuel III – Jerusalem (2005), and Emmanuel IV – Alpha and Omega (2003). In this paper, I will present a visual theology of Borysewicz’s Emmanuel Paintings, and argue that they are, indeed, the culmination of his early work, as well as a beautiful transition of art and artist from Art World to Church. More generally, I will argue that Borysewicz’s work challenges James Elkins’ taxonomy of religion and contemporary art (Elkins, 2004), and in so doing might serve as a successful example of contemporary religious art.
|
The Necessity of Narrative: Comparing the Parable of the Lost Sheep in Matthew, Luke, and Thomas
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Todd Brewer, University of Durham
Since the rise of form criticism, particularly in the work of Rudolf Bultmann and his successors, much of historical Jesus studies has operated under the assumption that Jesus’ teachings can be extracted from the narrative frameworks offered by the synoptic gospels to arrive at a compilation of authentic sayings of Jesus. Within this enterprise, the Gospel of Thomas often assumes a privileged status, providing the very de-contextualized kernel of Jesus’ sayings it seeks to unearth. Yet this quest has operated according to its various methods without critically examining whether its near exclusive preference for sayings and devaluation of narrative frameworks is suitable for the goal of historical enquiry.
This paper seeks to evaluate some of the methodological assumptions of historical Jesus study through an examination of the parable of the lost sheep in the gospels of Matthew, Luke, and Thomas. The narratives of Matthew and Luke seek to embed the parable within plausible historical sequences, and therefore mediate the meaning of the parable through its past occurrence. But far from providing unmediated access to the historical Jesus, the dislocation of the parable of the lost sheep from a plausible historical setting – as analogously represented by the Gospel of Thomas – may ironically betray a de-historicizing tendency of such an approach. The Gospel of Thomas does not characterize itself as a repository of the historical Jesus, but teachings of the Living Jesus to be understood by the interpreter in the present. Therefore, in the name of historical criticism the narrative frameworks of the synoptic gospels cannot be uncritically discarded as secondary, inauthentic, renderings of the Jesus tradition. However much the historian may wish to object to the verisimilitudes of Matthew or Luke, these prove to be essential for a historical understanding of the parable.
|
The Counseling Queen Mother and the Reflection of Her Influence in 1 and 2 Kings
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Ginny Brewer-Boydston, Baylor University
The narrator(s) of 1-2 Kings makes no apologies in laying the blame for Judah’s exile at the feet of the Judean kings through their regnal formulas located in 1 and 2 Kings. One of the astonishing factors of these formulas is that the mother of the king is named in each formula with two exceptions. If the narrator uses the formulas to make a theological statement regarding the reason for Judah’s exile, is this naming also a theological statement upon the king’s mother as she is almost always included in the formulas? To answer this question, this paper will first look at the regnal formulas where the queen mother figures prominently. Then the paper will demonstrate how the king’s mother can be seen as an archetypal advisor to her son through Proverbs 31:1-9. Next, the paper will investigate the three Judean queen mothers (Maacah in 1 Kgs 15:11-14; Athaliah in 2 Kgs 11:1-15; and Nehushta in 2 Kgs 24:8) who appear in the narrative, revealing that these women acted as advisors to the king or demonstrated a considerable cultic influence upon him and/or the court. Their naming in the regnal formulas appears to be a testament to this influence upon the monarchy. By naming the mothers of seventeen kings in the regnal formulas, the narrator seems to be laying the blame for the exile at the feet of the queen mother as well as the king.
|
Going the Extra Mile: Reading Matt 5:41 Literally and Metaphorically
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Laurie Brink, Catholic Theological Union
Owing to Matthew’s use of the verb ???a?e??, the Roman practice known as ???a?e?a is exclusively cited as the backdrop against which to read Jesus’ imperative to go the extra mile (Matt 5:41). However, a review of the inscriptional and literary evidence on ???a?e?a demonstrates that the official practice concerned the transportation of goods and not the wanton impressing of individuals into labor. Freed from a strictly imperial context, Matt 5:41 might more accurately be interpreted as an example of extortion—compelling the services of another. The Matthean Jesus advises that those disciples who are compelled to go a mile must actually go further. Set within the antitheses of the Sermon on the Mount, this verse serves as a metaphorical example of fulfilling the Law (Matt 5:17) by exceeding it. Read in this light, the extra mile logion stands in opposition to the scribes and Pharisees whom Jesus accuses of compelling others to carry the Law that they themselves neglect (Matt 23:4).
|
An Abolitionist's Cut Bible: Icon, Myth, and Metaphor
Program Unit: Society for Comparative Research on Iconic and Performative Texts
Edwin K. Broadhead, Berea College
I will explore the history and the iconic use of a "cut Bible" that belonged to John G. Fee, one of the founders of Berea College. This Bible, which has some 46 passages removed, has, for many years, played a ceremonial role in the opening procession and in the graduation ceremonies of Berea College, located in Berea, Kentucky. The myth surrounding this Bible, which was printed in Philadelphia in the early 19th century, is that the staunch abolitionist John G. Fee removed, supposedly in anger, all of the slave passages from his Bible. After exploring the iconic status and use of this Bible, I will deconstruct its mythical dimensions and offer a critical assessment of its history and use. In doing so, I will place it alongside two other Bibles with similar histories. Finally, I will explore the more recent use of the Fee Bible at Berea College, which is more historical, but also more metaphorical in its representation of the values of the founders.
|
Sacred Killing, Sacred Dying: Religion and War in Comparative Perspective
Program Unit: Society for Ancient Mediterranean Religions
Jeffrey Brodd, California State University - Sacramento
*
|
Magic or Not? Ritual Speech Acts and the Ways of the Gods
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Marian Broida, Georgia State University
This paper uses speech act theory to examine certain ancient Near Eastern ritual utterances intended to transform reality. Hittite, Akkadian, and biblical Hebrew commonly use third-person modal verb forms in these contexts. Akkadian made frequent use of the precative or vetitive in incantations. Hittite oral rites typically ended with a third-person imperative. Biblical Hebrew often used the jussive in blessings and curses (“May YHWH bless you and keep you”). All of these modals share an important attribute: all have significantly different senses depending on the relationship between speaker and addressee in ordinary human discourse. Uttered to a social inferior, they typically serve as indirect commands (“Let the prisoner be brought forward”), yet uttered to a social superior they function as petitions, requests, or pleas (“May my lord not consider me guilty!”) Significantly, some ancient Near Eastern deities are quoted as issuing supernatural directives with such forms (“Let there be light!”). The question arises: when humans use these forms in ritual speech, are they petitioning the deity or are they imitating divine speech? This paper makes the argument that such ambiguity is no accident and may underlie the popularity of these forms in ancient Near Eastern ritual discourse
|
“Many Members, One Body”: The Stoic Body Metaphor and Conceptual Blending in Paul
Program Unit: Cognitive Linguistics in Biblical Interpretation
Timothy A. Brookins, Houston Baptist University
In response to the constantly shifting demands of the contexts in which he found himself, Paul carefully selected material from the available discourses of his day, adapting them as needed for speaking intelligibly and persuasively to each of his audiences. Just as he reshaped this material to new ends, however, so also did the discourses from which he drew help to shape his theology. Drawing from a number of linguistic theories (Olbrechts and Tyaca’s “New Rhetoric,” Lakoff and Johnson’s metaphor theory, and Fauconnier and Turner’s theory of conceptual blending), the present essay focuses on the conceptual dynamics of Paul’s thought by tracing the development of his use of the Stoic “body” metaphor, beginning with his discovery of its usefulness for dealing with the Stoic-influenced church in Corinth, and following its development from the Corinthian correspondence into Romans and the “Deutero-Paulines.” The metaphor, it is argued, is not just a matter of illustration; rather, it supplied Paul with a new discursive framework from within which to conceptualize the idea of unity, and thus served as a vital “input” in the development of the ecclesiology and cosmology evident in his most mature letters, and continued to give off its "original" Stoic resonances in the very act of expression. This leads to two hermeneutical observations, proposed in conclusion. First, insofar as metaphors not only serve as vehicles for new forms of thought, but also generate new conceptual content, the source domains of Paul’s metaphors continued to resonate even after those metaphors were blended with other input sources. Second, metaphorical usages in particular instances must be considered in relation to the “total” structural dynamics of Paul’s body of thought, particularly with respect to the relation between “controlling” structural metaphors and the various Jewish and Greco-Roman sub-narratives or sub-structures that fed into those more controlling frameworks.
|
Historicizing the Concept of Religion: A Prerequisite to Critical Research, or an Intrinsically Interesting Subject?
Program Unit: Religious World of Late Antiquity
James Broucek, Iowa State University
Brent Nongbri’s Before Religion drives home a point that is hopefully becoming uncontroversial. Religion is not a universal feature of human cultures, but a heuristic device, developed by modern European intellectuals, in their efforts to classify and control the behaviors of others. Now that this point is conceded in a growing body of literature, however, researchers run the risk of treating the history of “religion” as an intrinsically interesting subject. Nongbri makes his history of “religion” interesting by arguing that it demonstrates why “ancient religion” should be classified as a “redescriptive” concept. By endorsing descriptive narratives of ancient religion, however, Nongbri undercuts this normative conclusion. Indeed, Nongbri’s distinction between descriptive and redescriptive narratives calls for a classification of “religion” that fails justify itself as a response to pressing questions in the student of religion’s field. Instead, this classification serves the end of securing certain markers of professionalization.
|
The Devil and Disease in the Biblical Tradition
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Derek Brown, Logos Bible Software
Among the many malevolent activities charged to the figure of the devil (or Satan) in ancient Judaism and early Christianity was the giving of various diseases, illnesses, and physical ailments to people (e.g., Job 2:5; Luke 13:16; 2 Cor 12:7). At times the devil figure causes people to suffer using agents such as evil spirits or demons and at other times no agency is involved. This paper will consider this motif in ancient Judaism and early Christianity. In particular we will be concerned with the following questions: how did the devil come to be associated with the giving of sicknesses and diseases in Judaism? Is this role reflected in other ancient traditions? What kinds of diseases or maladies were given by the devil and to whom did he give them? What are theological implications for the belief that the devil causes illnesses (e.g., theodicy)? How is this tradition preserved in, or absent from, the writings of the New Testament? The paper will conclude by offering remarks on the significance of this tradition for understanding the relationship between the human body, powers of evil, and sin in the biblical tradition.
|
Not “When?”, but “Where?” The ßas??e?a in Q, Thomas, and the Roman Empire
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
Ian Brown, University of Toronto
My paper focuses on the ways in which “the kingdom” is imagined spatially in Q, the Gospel of Thomas, as well as in Roman imperial proclamations, inscriptions, and other imperial documents. A great deal of scholarship has already been devoted to reading “the kingdom” in light of the Roman Empire, much of which assumes that “kingdom” is deployed by Jesus traditions as a direct challenge to the Roman Empire. In these instances the kingdom is often imagined as a future utopia presented in contrast to the current Roman world. I will complicate this reading by looking at the different ways in which the space of the kingdom is imagined in Q and Thomas. I argue that, while “the kingdom” in Q and Thomas certainly borrow the language of “the kingdom” from the Roman Empire, all three imagine different spaces with their use of the term. In spite of recent attention to constructions of space in early Christian texts, spatial theorizing has yet to focus specifically on kingdom sayings, or the relationship between the kingdom in Thomas and Q and the kingdom in Roman Imperial rhetoric. Combining spatial and postcolonial theory, my paper examines the ways in which Q, Thomas, and the Roman Empire imagine the space of ßas??e?a.
|
Epistemology and the Production of History: “History” as a Discipline and Object in the Study of Early Jesus People
Program Unit: North American Association for the Study of Religion
Ian Brown, University of Toronto
History as a mode of inquiry and history as an object of inquiry are both, in many ways, constructions of the present and constructions in the present. Modern historical critics have argued that the reality of the past, historical narratives, and even historical objects themselves are largely, or even exclusively, the constructions of the historian. Critiques of history argue that constraints of the historian’s own historical situatedness prevent the historian from doing much more than retrojecting his or her own interests, concerns, and questions onto his or her historical object of inquiry. This paper takes these criticisms seriously, but refuses to give up history as an object of study. I present as my example first and second century texts relating to Jesus. These texts are particularly interesting as they have been subject to centuries of historical inquiry, and a large number of these inquires are clearly coloured by the present concerns of the historian. And while it is not my position that our histories of these texts are getting better and better, I do argue that it is possible for the discipline of history produce new knowledge concerning those objects. This knowledge is very much a product of the present, but it does not preclude us from making arguments about the past.
|
Welcome and Difference in Interdisciplinary Conversation
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Jeannine Brown, Bethel Seminary (San Diego, CA)
Recent forays into interdisciplinary exploration between theology and psychology have sometimes been mired in methodological considerations of disciplinary priority or even hierarchy. For example, the issue of theology’s priority as queen of the sciences remains a standing question (e.g., Wolters, 2007; Porter, 2010). In response to and in conversation with these discussions, we will suggest an interdisciplinary model of relational integration that thematizes the embodied and culturally located nature of interdisciplinary integration. These values in interdisciplinary pursuits are important to highlight, since abstract disciplines themselves do not “do integration.” Rather, it is the disciplinarians themselves, such as psychologists and theologians, who are involved in the practices of interdisciplinarity and pursue integration. Most particularly, we will explore the intercultural nature of relational integration, namely the importance of differentiation of self in the midst of conversations where differences in methods, assumptions, and conclusions can often appear to preclude productive interdisciplinary understanding. To highlight the tension of difference and connection that is important to maintain in interdisciplinary dialogue, we will bring to the conversation Paul’s admonitions to the ‘weak’ and the ‘strong’ in Romans 14:1-15:13. In this text, a balance emerges that values relationship through welcoming the Other, while allowing differences to remain and to be mutually influential and formative.
|
The Dual Textual History of the Prayer of Jonah in the Ethiopic Manuscript Tradition
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Jeremy R. Brown, George Fox University
Jonah 2:3-10 was not only transmitted in Minor Prophets manuscripts in the Ethiopic manuscript tradition. This passage also was copied as the Seventh Biblical Canticle within the Ethiopic Psalter. The goal of this study is to compare the textual histories of the Prayer of Jonah in these two types of manuscripts. We gathered and transcribed manuscripts that represented the full chronological sweep of both manuscript types, thirty manuscripts of the text from Psalters and fifty manuscripts of the text from Minor Prophet manuscripts (as part of the Textual History of the Ethiopic Old Testament Project). For both types of manuscripts we identified families and their date ranges and generated lists of characteristics readings for each family.
In this presentation we will provide answers to the following questions. Does the text preserved in Psalter manuscripts undergo revision across the centuries? How does the development of the canticle text compare to the development of the text in the Minor Prophet manuscripts (the text of the canticle appeared quite static in comparison to the text in the Minor Prophets manuscripts)? Does the textual history of the one appear to affect the textual history of the other? What characteristic differences exist between the text in the Psalter and that in the Minor Prophet manuscripts? We will answer these questions as we examine the dual textual history of the Ethiopic Prayer of Jonah.
|
The Sabbath and Festivals in the Gospel of John: Against the Replacement Paradigm
Program Unit: Sabbath in Text and Tradition
Ken Brown, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
The Sabbath plays a prominent role in John’s gospel. It is the first holy day addressed in the Festival Cycle (John 5-10), recurs in John 9 and is even invoked at the crucifixion, which is set on the eve of “a great Sabbath” (John 19:31). Yet the Sabbath’s role in John is often interpreted differently than the other festivals. Several recent studies on the temple and festivals in John skip over the Sabbath (e.g. Hoskins, Fulfillment of the Temple; Coloe, God Dwells with Us) or explicitly treat it differently (e.g. Kerr, Temple Theme). According to Kerr, the Sabbath is “transformed” while the temple and festivals are “replaced” by Jesus (266-67, 374-75). This distinction is problematic, as is the larger replacement paradigm on which it is based (on the latter, cf. esp. Lieu, “Temple and Synagogue”; Fuglseth, Johannine Sectarianism; Spaulding, Commemorative Identities, none of whom focuses on the Sabbath). This paper will argue that Jesus’ actions on the Sabbath in John 5 and 9 provide the paradigm for John’s treatment of all the temple festivals. Jesus’ healing activity on the Sabbath is not, for John, an indication of its abolition, but rather a sign that Jesus’ stands in the same basic relation to the Sabbath as God himself does (John 5:16-18). I will argue that this sets the tone for John’s entire temple festival theme. Throughout, John invokes the traditions and symbolism of these festivals not to signal their “replacement,” but to emphasize Jesus’ divine prerogatives and identity.
|
The Firstborn of Death: Myth and Monotheism in Job
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Ken Brown, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
One of the many intriguing features of the book of Job is how often it describes figures who act between humanity and God without clearly identifying them. "The Satan," assuming that is a title rather than a name, is the most famous, but other examples include Job’s “mediator” (9:33), “witness in heaven” (16:19) and “redeemer” (19:25). Two of the most enigmatic, however, appear in Bildad’s second speech: “the firstborn of death” and “the king of terrors” (18:13-14). Though generally recognized to allude to some kind of mythological conception of the underworld and its denizens, there has been no consensus on the identification of these figures. For instance, Wyatt, “Mythological Background,” points to the Ugaritic texts concerning Mot, the god of death, even though there is no evidence that Mot ever had any children in Ugaritic mythology. Meanwhile Burns, “Namtaru and Nergal,” emphasizes Mesopotamian parallels, but his reconstruction draws too freely from widely scattered traditions. In this paper I argue that the most likely background to Bildad’s image is the figure of Resheph, a popular West Semitic warrior deity who is associated with death elsewhere in the Hebrew Bible and appears in a similar context in Job 5:2-7. I argue that the relation between Resheph and God (by various names) is problematized in Job, as Eliphaz and Bildad depict him as one who carries out judgment on those who reject God, while Job depicts God’s own unjust attacks against him with similar imagery (e.g. 6:4; 16:12-13). This suggests that the still common dichotomy between "myth" and "monotheism" is deeply problematic, even in texts so late as Job.
|
What’s in an Ending? John 21 and the Performative Force and an Epilogue
Program Unit: Performance Criticism of the Bible and Other Ancient Texts
Sherri Brown, Niagara University
Biblical scholars often ponder the intent—and even the existence—of chapter 21 of John’s Gospel given the profound concluding notes of 20:30-31. Nonetheless no ancient manuscript exists without the scenes of this chapter as the final act of the Gospel. Many of these same scholars also agree that the Gospel was likely composed in stages over a period of time. This final chapter could have been added late in the composition history of the Gospel to respond to the changing needs and circumstances of the Johannine community. John 21 therefore can be understood as an epilogue insofar as it brings the Gospel story beyond its conclusion into the time of its early audience and clarifies the form and mission of the community it engenders.
This paper explores the performance features embedded in this text as a storyteller crosses the dramatic axis into the theatrical axis when John 21 is performed as an epilogue. A Gospel telling that has beautifully faded to black is then picked up again; and a performance critical approach to this text helps to explain the very existence of this chapter as well as how it was intended to be received by the audience.An epilogue, as an “afterword,” carries forward some aspect of the narrative by describing the consequences resulting from its climax, its solution or outcome. Broadly speaking, the relationship made possible by Jesus in John 1–20 leaves its community with two commands: to love and to believe. However completely these truths are revealed, living through them as a community can become problematic over time when members differ on who and what exactly to love and to believe. Therefore, the storyteller actualizes the new covenant commands into the lived experience of the audience through the performance of this epilogue written for them.
|
Hypocrisy and the Neural-Cognitive Bases of Action
Program Unit: Ethics and Biblical Interpretation
Warren S. Brown, Fuller Theological Seminary
Hypocrisy presents a dilemma in that it is constituted by discrepancies between what we say about ourselves and our motivations, what we believe we desire to do, and what we actually do. While it has been proposed that this is due to conflicts created by brain modularity (different modules presumed to create different action programs), there are other perspectives from cognitive neuroscience to take into account.
This paper will consider hypocrisy in human action from the alternative point-of-view that understands human neurocognitive processes as complex dynamical systems that self-organize to meet specific environmental (physical, social, cultural) contexts. Specifically, hypocrisy will be discussed in light of: (1) behavioral automaticity versus conscious choice; (2) dynamic organization of behavior with respect to specific social contexts; (3) environment-based neural reorganization, and (4) contextual affordances.
Finally, hypocrisy will be considered in light of recent theory and research on the psychological and neurophysiological nature of exemplary virtue from the Habitvs Project. What brain systems are involved in decisions to rescue others in distress? What individual social schemas and situational contexts come together to elicit exemplary acts of care and compassion?
|
Creation as Cosmic Temple, Part I
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
William P. Brown, Columbia Theological Seminary
As the first of a two-part presentation (the second given by Stanley Saunders), this paper explores the literary and theological connections between creation and temple in the Hebrew Bible with an eye toward their ecological implications. Particular attention is devoted to the opening chapters of Genesis, the building account of the Tabernacle in Exodus, Temple architecture and theology in 1 Kings and Ezekiel, and the Temple controversy profiled in Isaiah 66. In light of these various traditions, I argue that creation made in the image of the Temple provides a promising theological framework for ecological reflection and practice.
|
Reading Psalms Sapientially: An Exercise in Differentiation
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
William P. Brown, Columbia Theological Seminary
This preliminary study attempts to move beyond labored discussions of what constitutes a “wisdom psalm” or how one recognizes sapiential editing in the Psalter. Taking a reader-centered approach, I ask, What is it like to read the Psalms in the light of Proverbs? Specifically, this paper will explore how certain shared motifs, including common metaphors, figures, and moral constructs, are profiled in Psalms and Proverbs. The resulting picture is that of two complex corpora sharing certain points of contact but moving in strikingly different directions didactically and theologically.
|
Manuscript and Tradition: Exploring Scribal Alterations in Early Qur'ans in View of the Qira'at and Masahif Literature
Program Unit: The Qur’an: Manuscripts and Textual Criticism (IQSA)
Daniel Brubaker, Rice University
Many scribal changes involving the consonantal text exist in early Qur'ans. Types of change include insertion, erasure, erasure overwritten, overwriting without apparent erasure, covering, and covering overwritten. Usually these changes result in a consonantal skeletal text (CST) that is in conformity with that of the standard King Fahd Qur'an based upon the 1924 Cairo edition. In some cases, these scribal changes are found at points that are dealt with in the qira'at literature and other early Islamic traditions. At these points the manuscripts may serve to corroborate the secondary literature that acknowledges certain textual concerns that were being dealt with by the early Muslim community. However, in others cases the secondary literature is completely silent about a verse at which some change has been made in the earliest manuscripts. Acknowledging the fact that some scribal change was conducted near the time of original production and in order to correct obvious slips of the pen or other sources of human error, there are yet some cases in which a manuscript change does not appear attributable to such causes. What is the meaning of these for scholars of the early history of Islam and of the Qur'an in its written form? This presentation will show and discuss some instances of scribal change that do coincide with and/or reflect the concerns that emerge in the early qira'at or tafsir literature, as well as some examples of changes that do not.
|
Silence Broken from "Elsewhere"
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Walter Brueggemann, Columbia Theological Seminary
Silence is the hallmark of every totalizing ideology, ancient or contemporary. Prophetic voice consists in the originary capacity to break that imposed silence, to bear witness to bodily existence that is known to be occupied with holy intentionality.
|
Sexual Assault Recovery in the Aftermath of the Liberian Civil War: Forging a Sisterhood between Feminist Psychology and Feminist Theology
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Thema Bryant-Davis, Pepperdine University
Cross border feminist collaborations enhance efforts to combat violence against women, including sexual violence. Sexual assault was a pervasive human rights violation perpetrated against many Liberian women during the over decade long Civil War. Based on a review of the mental health literature focusing on the realities of this crime against humanity in the lives of Liberian women, thirteen interviews were conducted with Liberian Church leaders. The participants and the first and second authors are collaborators on faith-based initiatives aimed at serving and empowering Liberian women and girls through the African Methodist Episcopal Church. Interviewees highlight the effects, dynamics, needs, and solutions for Liberian women attempting to recover from these atrocities. This article utilizes feminist theology and feminist psychology as a frame for understanding the experiences of Liberian sexual assault survivors and feminist cross-border collaborations in West Africa.
|
Compromesso Storico in Rossellini’s TV-Version of Atti degli Apostoli
Program Unit: Bible and Film
Gitte Buch-Hansen, Københavns Universitet
"See, here is water! What is to prevent my being baptized?" The eunuch’s question is followed by a very touching scene in which he divests himself of his turban, purple cloak and jewellery, the symbols of his economic and royal status. In his huge corpus, the eunuch stands socially and psychologically naked in front of Philip’s skinny figure, who bows down to fetch a handful of water. Did the eunuch leave his jewellery with Philip as he returned to the queen’s court? The Italian director Roberto Rossellini cuts off the answer and scene before Philip is snatched away by the Spirit. Miracles are spare in Rossellini’s screen version of Atti degli Apostoli which was shown five Sundays in prime-time during the summer 1969 on RAI (Radiotelevisione Italiana).
In the beginning of the 60ties, the director who inaugurated the neorealistic wave in European film had renounced on making film for the silver screen. Filmmaking had become an industry which only allowed movies that “infantilized” their audience and kept it in “squalid escapism”. Instead, Rossellini turned his attention toward the new, public medium: television. From the mid-60ties to his death (1977), Rossellini’s company Orizzonte 2000 produced several series about history and science for television, among them Atti degli Apostoli. Rossellini saw his television work as a revival of the 18-century encyclopedists’ enlightenment project, but in a new, more didactic and more dialogical medium. According to Rossellini, our experiences are maintained in images, which precede the conceptualization of writing. Neorealistic films enriched the audience by inviting them to make their own experiences. Consequently, TV became the natural medium for Rossellini’s neorealistic project.
In Atti degli Apostoli, the camera dwells by the daily work needed to sustain the earliest Christian community. The kneading of bread, the pottery and the movement of the weaver’s shuttle are documented in real time. The processes of work frame the famous speeches of Peter and Paul. The prologue to the series, which replaces the ascension, is a composed speech from Rossellini’s hand, but spoken by a Greek slave working for the imperial administration in Jerusalem. The slave introduces a Roman guest to the city and demonstrates to him the foreign working habits of the Hebrews. According to Rossellini, the Hebrew ethics, which “thanks to Christianity” were spread throughout the Roman Empire, changed man’s relationship with nature: as God’s gift, man had to use it to distinguish himself from animals.
Atti degli Apostoli is a political film, which reveals Rossellini as an atheistic Christian and a liberal Marxist. The film is Rossellini’s secular gospel to his own time. Paul’s travel from Jerusalem to Rome can be seen as a reminder of a forgotten heritage. Paul becomes Rossellini’s alter ego and a spokesman for the Historic Compromise in Italian politics between the Communists and Democrazia Christiana.
The paper reflects on Rossellini’s interpretation of Acts, his neorealism, his use of the TV-medium and the historical situation and argues that the message of Atti degli Apostoli should have a say today as well.
|
Thoughts on the Influence of the Pentateuch on Later Translational Praxis
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Dirk Büchner, Trinity Western University
Brock, Barr and others have pointed out that, having no precedent, the Pentateuch translators proceeded in what could be termed ad-hoc fashion, varying their strategies from moment to moment, now being freer, now being more literal. Sadly, this spontaneity became abandoned by later LXX translators as it became more and more normative to view, and therefore render sacred writings as “law” rather than as “literature” (Brock). And so, many translational precedents set in the Pentateuch became replaced or “rectified” by works that either were more literal at the outset or became revised towards a Hebrew text. Examining some of these “corrections” towards a Hebrew understanding, makes for fruitful reflection on the residual persistence of a Hebrew tradition, in spite of the widespread use of the Septuagint as Scripture.
|
How Spiritualism and Theosophy Haunt Early Christian Studies: The Case of Gnosticism
Program Unit: Westar Institute
Denise K. Buell, Williams College
*
|
For Cause or Kin? Religious Fusion, Not Religious Belief, Underlies Self-Sacrifice
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
Michael Buhrmester, University of Oxford
There is significant debate concerning the impact of ‘religion’ on self-sacrifice and outgroup violence. We argue in this paper that just as the cognitive science of religion has advanced our understanding of the construct ‘religion’ by fractionating it into its component parts , so too will the field advance by fractionating the notions of ‘cohesion’ and ‘ingroup commitment’. We will present evidence from a series of studies with American Christians showing that ‘fusion’ with one’s religion, more so than one’s degree of fundamentalism, group identification, sacred values, religious orientation, or conservatism, predicts one’s willingness to sacrifice one’s life for Christianity and one’s fellow Christians. Further, these studies show that fusion’s power is mediated by its ability to trigger perceptions of kinship among co-religionists and that the altruism produced is limited to members of one’s religion, regardless of the content of one’s Christian beliefs.
|
Monkey Business: Magical Vowels and Cosmic Levels in the Discourse of the Eighth and the Ninth (NHC VI,6)
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Christian H. Bull, Universitetet i Bergen
The visionary ascent in the Hermetic text The Discourse of the Eighth and the Ninth (NHC VI,6), is both preceded and followed by a hymn containing magical vowels as well as nomina sacra. The seven vowels, it has long been recognized, were associated with the seven planets, and it has been argued that the omegas in this text also symbolize the Ogdoad. However, through a comparison with Zosimus of Panopolis’ Treatise on the Letter Omega and the Leiden magical papyrus (PGM XIII), it will be argued that the letter omega has a double function in the Hermetic hymns, representing both the sphere of Saturn and the sphere of the thirty-six decans, which separates the immaterial Ogdoad from the material cosmos below. Furthermore, the Leiden magical papyrus indicates how the vowels should be uttered ritually, and explicitly identifies the vowels with the mysterious language of baboons, a concept familiar from ancient Egyptian religious texts. Baboons were seen as heralds of the sun god, since they were often heard screaming during sunrise, and indeed the Egyptian Hermes, Thoth, was often portrayed as a baboon. Just as the soul of the deceased in Egyptian funerary literature was often considered to join the choir of baboons on the sun-boat in the beyond, so the ascending soul in the Hermetic texts is also considered to join the choir of daemons and blessed souls in the Ogdoad, singing hymns to the Ennead. It is therefore likely that the hymn of magical vowels in the Discourse of the Eighth and the Ninth reflects the Egyptian notion of a heavenly choir of baboons singing hymns to the sun god.
|
“Maybe We’ve Caught the Virus of Prophecy”: The Motif of the Prophet in “Angels in America” and “Don’t Ever Wipe Tears without Gloves”
Program Unit: Bible and Film
Mette Bundvad, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
Tony Kushner’s “Angels in America: a Gay Fantasia on National Themes” and Jonas Gardell’s “Don’t Ever Wipe Tears without Gloves” both make extensive use of biblical motifs in their exploration of the AIDS-crisis in the 1980s and its effect upon the gay male community in New York and Stockholm, respectively. This paper explores the use of eschatological prophecy and prophetic identity in the screen adaptations of the two works (“Angels” by Mike Nichols and “Don’t Ever Wipe Tears” by Simon Kaijser, with screenplays by the original authors).
Both works use the figure of the prophet to articulate the gay community’s experience of trauma and to investigate the identity crisis brought on by the AIDS-epidemic. Particularly interesting are the ambiguities inherent in the presentation of prophecy, which comes to symbolize both threat and solution in the two works. In “Angels”, eschatological and prophetic language is used to emphasize the severity of the threat to the gay community. However, as the protagonist, Prior Walter, reluctantly takes on the role of a prophet, the community is simultaneously given prophetic voice and agency. In “Don’t Ever Wipe Tears” the references to biblical prophecy appear in particular in relation to the main characters’ experience of societal, religious, and individual attempts to erase their identity. While offering for the most part a negative view of the potential of prophecy, “Don’t Ever Wipe Tears” also shows how prophetic identity can be appropriated as a strategy for retaining control of one’s own life-story. This is most clearly apparent in a climactic reenactment of Isaiah’s eschatological vision (Is. 11) which reinterprets the wish for a new world into a quest for maintaining one’s own identity.
The paper focuses in particular on the two works’ use of prophetic call visions (especially Isaiah 6 and Jonah 1) and visions of eschatological salvation (Isaiah 11 and Revelation 21). Discussing the ambiguities of prophecy in “Angels” and “Don’t Ever Wipe Tears” may also offer new perspectives on biblical depictions of prophecy – and the dual role of the prophet as a messenger of doom and a voice of hope.
|
Hearing Jeremiah in African Context: An Intercultural Interpretation
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Katho Bungishabaku, Shalom University of Bunia (DR Congo)
The well-known criticism that the African church is growing very fast in quantity but lacks quality to sustain and transform the continent might be explained by the fact that most of the practices and thinking in the African churches are inspired by Western categories. By pressing upon us that there is more than one way of reading the biblical text, contemporary biblical criticism opens the possibility of interpreting the Bible differently from the currently dominant western scholarship. Therefore, this paper argues that there are other theological possibilities of thinking about God in Africa without neglecting important matters like the literary shape of a text and its historical context. This will be demonstrated through the book of Jeremiah. My reading of Jeremiah is shaped by several factors that have real impacts on our daily life and therefore on the way we think of God in Africa: a culture of war, destruction and “exile”; a context of poverty which has terrible impact on our Christian faith; a culture of daily struggle for land; a culture of ethnic strife; the abuse of power/authority; the inescapability of suffering; the possibility of renaissance and renewal, etc.
|
Figural Reading in the Cave of Treasures: Recovering an Interpretive Tradition
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Brian W. Bunnell, Southern Baptist Theological Seminary
The purpose of this essay is to recover the interpretive tradition of figural reading depicted in the Syriac Book of the Cave of Treasures with the hope that this method of interpretation might serve as an avenue of investigation for modern day biblical scholars. Throughout his extended fifty four chapter narrative that recounts the story of biblical history from creation to Pentecost, the author uses the interpretive method of figural reading as a means to unite the biblical story and provide cohesion. Although present day readers may question any number of the unique interpretations presented in this pre-critical document, it is not the intention of this essay to evaluate the legitimacy or illegitimacy of the various figural readings as such. Rather, the goal of this essay is to recover the various types of interpretive moves that the author himself makes with a view towards proposing these figural readings as interpretive possibilities for contemporary scholars. This essay will be divided into two sections. First, I will discuss the content, literary character, and theological message of The Cave of Treasures (CT). Second, I will present a taxonomy representative of the author’s figural interpretations under five headings: 1) Adam-Christ Readings; 2) Soteriological Readings; 3) Christological Readings; 4) Ecclesiological Readings; and, 5) Cessation-Replacement Readings. By recovering the interpretive tradition of one of the most influential documents in Syriac Christianity contemporary scholars are afforded a rich store house of interpretive data that may serve as gateways for further investigation.
|
The Function of Martyrs and Tyrants in 4 Maccabees and Epictetus
Program Unit: Function of Apocryphal and Pseudepigraphal Writings in Early Judaism and Early Christianity
Justin Buol, University of Notre Dame
This paper analyzes the function of martyrs and tyrants in two more or less contemporary texts from the Roman era, Epictetus’s Discourses and an anonymous Jewish work, 4 Maccabees. After preliminary statements regarding the date of the two works, as well as the appropriateness of "martyr" terminology, discussion moves to the purposes of these two texts in utilizing martyrs. The paper first argues that both texts make use of martyrs, in Stoic fashion, as concrete exempla to augment their arguments; moreover, both authors are particularly interested in using martyrs to model behavior that the reader ought to follow. The paper then turns to consider the tyrants who opposed the martyrs. It argues that tyranny is a special concern for both authors, who each use martyrs in order to expose the illegitimacy of tyrants and enthrone reason and virtue in their place.
|
The Unity of Law and Love in Psalm 119: A Christian Reading
Program Unit: Bible and Ethics
Rebecca Burgess, University of Otago
This paper aims to demonstrate how a Christian Trinitarian reading of Ps 119 illustrates the unity of law and love.
Firstly I will offer a description of the law as the expression of God’s love and faithfulness in Psalm 119. I will show how this psalm identifies the law very closely with God, being life-giving and eternal and identified with the word of God. It will also be seen that the law is described as the way of true life and wholeness, the supreme expression of God’s love and faithfulness. The law is never presented as the possession of the observer but always belongs to God and God’s communication. The psalmist also expects that the observer will be graciously enabled by God to obey.
I will then identify a Christian reading as specifically Trinitarian in terms of God’s economy of salvation. This will involve a co-identification of revelation and reconciliation and the argument that revelation occurs in participation in Christ.
I will argue that participation with God in Christ is the telos for which all humanity was created and that this divine fellowship is the expression of God’s love. The role of God’s commanding and forbidding is central to participation in Christ since participation involves reconciliation and transformation. In this role the Law has its true purpose as humanity is shaped into the likeness of God’s beloved Son by the power of the Holy Spirit.
The law understood in terms of the Trinity is not only God’s command to us as we participate in Christ, but involves his salvific action on our behalf as we are made into the likeness of Christ by the power of the Holy Spirit. Here law and love find complete unity in the reconciling work of the Father, through the Son, in the Holy Spirit.
|
"So Shall Your Seed Be": Paul’s Use of Gen 15:5 in Rom 4:18 in Light of Early Jewish Deification Traditions
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
David A. Burnett, Criswell College
In Romans 4:18 Paul cites verbatim the “promise” to Abraham in the LXX of Genesis 15:5 “so shall your seed be” in relation to what it means to “become the father of many nations (Genesis 17:5).” It is widely recognized that Paul reads the promise to Abraham of becoming “the father of many nations” synonymously with Genesis 15:5 as his seed becoming as the stars of heaven. Modern scholars have traditionally understood the relationship between these two texts quantitatively, both promising a vast multitude of descendants. Conversely, early Jewish interpreters of Genesis 15:5 such as Philo, Ben Sira, and the author(s) of the Apocalypse of Abraham understood the promise qualitatively, to be transformed into the likeness of the stars of heaven. This paper will argue that this early Jewish interpretation could provide a better explanation of the relationship Paul sees between these two texts. This would place Paul in context of already well-established deification (or angelomorphic) traditions in early Judaism that see the destiny of the seed of Abraham as replacing the stars as the gods (or angels) of the nations. This will be demonstrated first by considering the promise of becoming as the stars as it is repeated to Abraham and Isaac in Genesis 22:17 and 26:4 in the broader framework of the Hebrew Bible in its cosmological context. Secondly, it will be demonstrated that this particular interpretation of the promise as seen in early Jewish literature contemporary with Paul should be understood in terms of early Jewish deification (or angelomorphic) traditions. Thirdly, it will be demonstrated that this interpretation applied to Paul’s use of Genesis 15:5 could make clear the relationship between a nexus of complexly related concepts in Romans 4 such as what it means that the “promise” to Abraham was to “inherit the kosmos,” “become the father of many nations,” and his seed to be as the stars of heaven.
|
Self-Identity through Competition: The Development of African Ecclesiology
Program Unit: Inventing Christianity: Apostolic Fathers, Apologists, and Martyrs
Patout Burns, Vanderbilt University
In attempting to respond to the failure of so many Christians in Africa during the first systematic testing of the church under Decius, Cyprian described himself and his episcopal colleagues struggling to discern an appropriate procedure for restoring the fallen to the communion of the church and hope for salvation. Neither the scriptures nor preceding church practice provided a solution: they had to innovate (ep. 54.3.3, 55.6.1). In this, they continued a process that began no later than Paul’s responses to the questions posed by the Corinthians. Christians constantly developed and adopted new practices though which they attempted to remain faithful to Christ.
This paper will focus on the decisions made in Africa by Christian leaders dealing with the effects of Decius’ attempt to revive the empire by requiring all to sacrifice to the immortal gods guiding its fortunes. In play were developing practices of avoiding persecution, using the martyrs as agents of forgiveness, and differentiating types of church membership.
The central argument of this proposal is that the African church debated and rejected the view, earlier argued by Tertullian and then championed by Novatian, that salvation could be attained by penitents outside the church’s eucharistic communion. After a struggle, the Africans rejected the permanent exclusion of lapsed Christians. They developed and institutionalized two divergent practices for reintegrating the sinners into the communion. The competition between the two parties focused attention on their shared belief that participation in the eucharistic ritual was a necessary condition for salvation. This commitment led, in turn, to a conflict with the Roman church over sacramental efficacy.
In their innovative response to failure in the Decian persecution, the Africans shaped a peculiar identity that would influence the future of Latin Christianity.
|
Collecting and Using the Prophet’s Hair in Early Islamic Texts
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Adam Bursi, Cornell University
Eighth- and ninth-century biographical texts about the Prophet Mu?ammad present the Prophet’s followers collecting his bodily products with a competitive fervor. In a widely reported tradition, a purported eyewitness narrates what he saw when visiting the Prophet: “By God, Mu?ammad does not spit out phlegm without it falling into the palm of one of his Companions, who then rubs his face and skin with it … when he performs ablution, they nearly come to blows over the water he had used.” Reminiscent of a trope in several late ancient Christian saints’ biographies in which individuals fight over the bodies of recently deceased holy men as they rush to acquire saintly relics, this story illustrates a similar desire to acquire remnants of the Prophet’s body. In several narratives, the Prophet’s hair is presented as a particularly cherished object: according to another eyewitness report, the Prophet’s Companions circle him as he is shaved, “not allowing any of his hair to fall but into a man’s hands.” Further indicating the significance of these Prophetic relics, a set of traditions appears in which the Prophet explicitly encourages those around him to take strands of his hair and to distribute them amongst the people.
Indeed traditions about the Prophet’s hair suggest that early Muslims saw a distinct power residing in these relics of the Prophet’s body. The Prophet’s hair was able to perform such feats as grant its possessor victory in battle, heal individuals of illness, and even to intercede with God on behalf of an individual after his or her death. Early Islamic texts thus exhibit a set of ideas and practices associated with the Prophet’s hair comparable to those associated with the relics of saints and other holy figures in late ancient Christian texts. This paper will argue that these traditions suggest that the veneration of relics of the Prophet Mu?ammad was a component of Islamic religiosity from an early date in Islamic history and that possession of the Prophet’s hair functioned as a distinct sign of Islamic identity. In particular it will examine the tension exhibited in these texts between private possession of the Prophet’s hairs and shared communal usage of their power: reflections perhaps of conflicting notions of access to such potent markers of Islamic identity, and thus of the nature of formative Islamic identity itself.
|
Mark 8:31ff as an Adaptation of Galatians 1–2
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Austin Busch, The College at Brockport: State University of New York
This paper tests the increasingly influential theory that Mark knew Paul’s epistles by examining Mark 8:31-9:1 as a potential adaptation of Paul’s representation of Peter in Galatians 1-2. Consideration of points of contact between these texts supports the hypothesis and allows for a fairly precise accounting of the literary relationship it proposes.
For example, (1) Galatians presents Peter’s resistance to table-fellowship with Gentiles as a rejection of the implications of Jesus’ death and resurrection (2:19-21). Mark 8:31-9:1 represents Peter as resisting Jesus’ death and resurrection, with Jesus proceeding to clarify their implications for his followers. (2) Galatians associates Peter’s resistance with the cursed demonic opposition to God that Paul’s opponents in Galatia display (cf. 1:8), claiming both Peter and they pervert the gospel: the latter want to metastrepsai it (1:7); Peter and his party do not orthopodousin according to its truth (2:14a). Mark too characterizes Peter’s resistance as demonic and signals its perversity with a metaphor analogous to Paul’s: “line up behind me, Satan” (hypage opisô mou, Satana, 8:33a; cf. opisô mou akolouthein, 8:34). (3) Galatians accuses Peter of being more attentive to human concerns than to God’s commandments (2:12-13), as Jesus accuses Peter in Mark (8:33b). (4) Paul claims it is he who has been crucified with Christ and accordingly participates in Christ’s new life (Gal 2:19-20), thereby presenting himself as a positive example against the implicit failure of Peter to do the same thing with respect to his relationship to the Law. In Mark, Peter’s rebuke of Jesus for prophesying his death prompts Jesus to call on all who would follow him to take up their cross. Mark underscores Peter’s literal failure to do this, not only by having Peter vow he will die with Jesus before denying him (14:31) immediately before representing him deny Jesus thrice out of shame and fear (14:66-72, anticipated in 8:38), but also by reporting that Peter’s namesake, Simon of Cyrene, manages to take up the cross of Jesus that Peter shuns (15:21).
Incidentally, understanding Mark 8:31-9:1 as a revision of Paul allows for an persuasive account of Matthew 16:13-20, which is often viewed as a source of independent traditions about Peter whose occasional convergences with Galatians 1-2 may point to direct reliance on Galatians (Sim, JSNT 31 [2009]: 401-22). In fact, Matthew merely redacts the Markan passage by systematically eliminating and reversing the troubling representation of Peter Mark adapts from Paul’s polemical portrayal.
The parallels between Paul and Mark involve similarities of language and ideas (e.g., Gal 2:19-20; Mark 8:34-35), and of characters and context. They are sufficiently extensive to make plausible the hypothesis that Mark 8:37-9:1 adapts Galatians 1-2. Mark’s employment of Paul’s letters, however, involves not merely the adoption of discrete Pauline ideas or theological perspectives, but also the adaptation of Pauline polemic and theological argument into narrative form. My analysis points to an unexpected structural dimension in this literary relationship that complicates, even as it supports, the hypothesis that Mark employs Paul’s epistles as a literary source.
|
Memory and Agent Formation in the Psalms
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Aubrey E. Buster, Emory University
A wide variety of explanations have been given for the lament psalms’ almost universal shift from petition to praise. The shift has been viewed as a result of an external oracle of salvation, a psychological move from sorrow to hope, or rhetoric designed to motivate God to act on the behalf of the psalmist. In contrast, I present a way to view the lament psalms as morally formative texts, designed to compel the one who prays them to become the ideal pray-er, as envisioned in the psalms. This is accomplished in part through the empowering and training of the one who prays to make this move, from sorrow, to hope and praise. I argue, using categories drawn from sociologists Mustafa Emirbayer and Anne Mische, that the psalms participate in the transformation of agents through a three stage process of selective attention, recognition of types, and categorical location. These three stages empower individuals to transform their present experience of suffering in light of the past actions of the deity. Psalm 77 provides a case study for this model, using the movement of the psalmist’s memory to rhetorically “re-typify” and “re-categorize” suffering and to turn the one who prays toward the deity. This reading suggests that the model I present can beneficially be applied to the psalms in order to understand their role in forming both the practice of prayer more broadly.
|
A Perfect Pedagogy, Another Look at the Greek parakeienh/Perfect
Program Unit: Applied Linguistics for Biblical Languages
Randall Buth, Biblical Language Center, Israel
To teach a language, it helps to know the language. Last year we heard how Greek professors disagreed about the meaning of the Greek perfect. Did it represent a simple aspect, whether stative or imperfective, or was it a more complex aspect, a resultative? Morphology was considered irrelevant to the discussion. However, the Greek perfect is etymologically and structurally different from the imperfective system (AKA ‘present’), from the aorist system, and from the future system. Verbs in the imperfective system, the aorist system, and the future system have one marker for their respective stems. However, the perfect active has two markers. Another asymmetry occurs only in the perfect between the active and middle where the perfect does not use the same stem—the middle stem does not have a kappa. The perfect is the only aspectual system to have different stems for the active and middle.
Semantically, within Indo-European linguistics there has been a hypothesis that the perfect possibly developed from an archaic middle voice into a stative, and finally into a resultative. This has left traces and layers in the morphology. The oldest perfect marker appears to have been a vowel shift. Reduplication added a later stage as a stative. This has remained in the language as a perfect middle where verbs are typically stative and the reduplication iconically fits such open-endedness. The last stage of the perfect morphology has added a kappa to the reduplication. The kappa iconically brings along a previously complete action to create a resultative semantic.
There are several kinds of idiosyncratic verbs that are used differently in the perfect, if they use the perfect at all. Other verbs are almost restricted to the perfect. The question for pedagogy is to ask how the young Greeks would have learned to use these verbs that seem to resist the generalized currents in the language. What can help us maximize this for students and teachers today?
|
Egyptian Imperialism and the Geography of Gesture
Program Unit: Egyptology and Ancient Israel
David Calabro, University of Chicago
This paper applies understandings developed in studies of modern gestures by Desmond Morris and Adam Kendon to ancient gestures known from the Hebrew Bible, Egyptian texts, and iconography from Egypt and the Levant. Previous studies of biblical gestures have often sought to draw parallels with the Mesopotamian world, ignoring closer parallels with gestures found in Egyptian sources. For example, the biblical gesture of raising the hand heavenward to take an oath, although absent from Mesopotamian sources, has close parallels in Egyptian texts of the New Kingdom and the Ptolemaic period, a fact that has been overlooked in studies of the biblical gesture. I catalogue attested cases of cross-cultural distribution of ancient Near Eastern gestures and, using the work of Morris and Kendon as a model, discuss how this evidence points to various modes of contact between Egypt, the Levant, and Mesopotamia. Many of the instances of cross-cultural distribution are likely related to Egyptian military and economic dominance in the Levant, especially Egypt’s imperial presence in the region during the New Kingdom. Overall, the evidence urges greater attention to the influence exerted on ancient Israel’s nonverbal communication patterns by its southern neighbor.
|
Humorous Invective as a Component of Persuasion in Early Christianity
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Callie Callon, University of Toronto
In view of the predominant role that humorous invective played in discourses of persuasion in the ancient world, it is striking that the similar utilization of this form of rhetoric by early Christian authors has not received the scholarly attention that it warrants. The goal of invective in the ancient world was to publicly denigrate an individual as deviant from shared social and ethical preconceptions, with the aim of isolating him or her from the community. Humor highlights insiders and outsiders (who is "in" on a joke and who is the outsider "subject" of the joke), forging and enforcing group boundaries, and in antiquity the form humor took was often an aggressive form of personal derision. While to a modern audience such ad hominem invective is rightly deemed a logical fallacy, to an audience in the ancient world such aggressive humor yielded real powers of persuasion. In antiquity personal attacks were efficacious even if they had seemingly little relevance to the details of the argument - it was sufficient to discredit the opponent him or herself. In addition to the persuasive power this form of discourse held, it had the additional benefit of simultaneously conveying to an audience the speaker or writer's own intelligence and rhetorical polish. As Valentina Arena suggests, "the effect of humorous invective is thus twofold: it denigrates the opponent while simultaneously asserting the speaker's authority." In light of this I argue that the vitriolic insults employed by some early Christians against other Christians were done so with cognition of this two-fold purpose. Rather than merely inflammatory expressions of disdain, I argue that some early Christians utilized these hostile assertions much like their contemporaries trained in the use of rhetorical strategy did. I suggest that in addition to rational argumentation this method of persuasion was also utilized by some early Christians in works that were composed and circulated to help negotiate insider and outsider group boundaries, and to demonstrate their perceived superiority over opponents, in particular so-called heretics.
|
Paul's Apocalyptic Epistemology
Program Unit:
Douglas Campbell, Duke University
*
|
The Sabbath and the Taiping Rebellion
Program Unit: Sabbath in Text and Tradition
Michael W. Campbell, Adventist International Institute of Adventist Studies
The massive civil war in south China known as the Taiping Rebellion (1851-1864) was largely inspired through the millenarian hopes of Hong Xiuquan, a self-baptized Christian who believed that he had God-given mission to rid China of all demons. His message was a fundamental rejection of the deeply entrenched Confucianism but neither was his message Christian. It represented more of a syncretism that at its core included a renewal of the Ten Commandments. A major tenant of belief and outward marker was Sabbath observance, which occurred initially on the European Saturday. Feng Yunshan, a key leader of the Taiping rebellion, developed a calendar that observed a weekly Sabbath. Thus Sabbatarianism played a significant role in one of the greatest military conflicts in world history, with a loss of an estimated 20 million people. This paper describes the theology and nature of Sabbath observance in the Taiping movement. Taiping Sabbatarianism furthermore illuminates the confluence of religion and culture as Protestant and indigenous religion synthesized into one. Such interactions highlight the ideological force and lasting value of the Sabbath.
|
Retrospective and Prospective on Social Identity in Paul 25 Years On
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
William S. Campbell, Prifysgol Cymru, Y Drindod Dewi Sant - University of Wales, Trinity Saint David
Retrospective and Prospective on Social Identity in Paul 25 Years On
|
Paul’s Judaism and the Jesus Movement
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
William Sanger Campbell, The College of St. Scholastica
Using Paul’s undisputed letters, especially Romans, 1 Corinthians, and Galatians, this paper will demonstrate that Paul’s change of viewpoint with regard to Jewish orthodoxy and orthopraxy when he joined the Jesus movement was, in his judgment and in reality, neither radical nor without precedent. It was, in fact, well within first-century Jewish self-understanding. The paper will argue that the Jewish community of Paul’s era consisted of a variety of groups and expressions all coexisting within first-century Judaism. The diversity of Jewish beliefs and practices at the time involved what many consider to be first-century Judaism’s core concepts, viz., circumcision, temple worship and its corresponding purity requirements, and messianic expectations. As a first-century Jew, therefore, Paul, both before and after becoming part of the Jesus movement, would have been aware and at least tolerant of Jewish individuals and parties espousing positions that conflicted with his own. The opposition of certain ethnic Jewish members of the new Jewish party galled Paul not primarily because his disputants disagreed with specific doctrines or practices, quarrels that were common among first-century Jews, but because they insisted on a strict constructionist understanding of Torah obedience for Gentiles wishing to join the Jesus movement (and so the Jewish covenant community) that was not demanded of ethnic Jews.
|
Mark and the Movies: Making Sense of the Bible
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
William Sanger Campbell, The College of St. Scholastica
Students who are not majoring in biblical studies often find the Bible’s concepts, contexts, and linguistic and literary styles alien and off-putting and, therefore, experience biblical writings as tedious to read and difficult to understand. In addition, students today are much more attuned to visual media (internet, television, movies, and the like) and less interested in reading in general. In order to address and, hopefully, overcome these potential problems, I propose that students in NT and Bible courses do a comparative analysis of the Gospel of Mark and the screenplay, It’s a Wonderful Life. By utilizing a medium with which students are more comfortable to familiarize them with the Gospel and to introduce them to critical methodologies for reading ancient narratives, this analysis, in Jonathan Culler’s words, “reduces [the Bible’s] strangeness so that it speaks . . . in an idiom [they] can understand.” Students begin to think “outside the box” about Mark’s literary creation and the NT more broadly They learn to appreciate the artistry of Mark as they liken the Gospel to the product of a screenwriter who adapts the work of another medium into a dramatic interpretation of the original subject, and discover that the keys to understanding Mark’s narrative are similar to those required when viewing a motion picture, viz., (1) taking seriously its story world, (2) being attentive to generic tools, (3) and actively engaging the material.
|
Swapping Sex for Drugs: Mandrake Mythology and Fertility Drugs in Gen 30:14–24
Program Unit: Bible, Myth, and Myth Theory
Robert R. Cargill, University of Iowa
Rachel’s agreement in Genesis 30:14-24 with Leah to exchange sex with Jacob for mandrakes discovered by Leah’s son, Reuben, constitutes an exchange of sex for fertility drugs. The story is rooted in an ancient fertility myth in which mandrakes are understood to possess physical and chemical properties that enhance fertility. This article examines the exchange of sex for drugs in Genesis 30:14-24, the origin of the fertility myth, and examines the myth’s reception history, including apologetic devices employed by biblical and extra-biblical authors to disguise the fertility myth, its efficacy, and the willingness of the biblical characters to participate in it.
|
Papias on the Gospel of Mark
Program Unit: Texts and Traditions in the Second Century
Stephen C. Carlson, Australian Catholic University
Out of all that has survived of the writings of Papias, his statement on the Gospel according to Mark attracts the most attention. It is not only the earliest surviving statement of any kind on the origins of the Gospels, but it is also the most detailed before the fourth century. Unfortunately, Papias’s statement does not come down to us intact and in context. Papias’s work is lost and all we really have of it a lengthy quotation by the fourth-century church historian, Eusebius of Caesarea.
Indeed, the length and detail of Eusebius’s quotation makes it almost irresistible for critics to bypass the layers of embedded discourse and treat this comment about Mark as if it were a self-contained block of a tradition. It is not that simple. To be sure, Papias quotes a presbyter, but the presbyter’s comment about Mark was presumably uttered not out of the blue but within some larger discourse context, now lost to us. Indeed, what the presbyter said is extracted, edited, and embedded by Papias in a different context of his own creation. Even this does not come down to us intact, but only as preserved by Eusebius, who also extracted, edited, and embedded this statement into a context of his own and in furtherance of his own agenda. As a result, the most famous statement in antiquity about etiology of Mark is a joint production of three different people living at three different times with three different purposes: the presbyter, Papias, and Eusebius. All of them have contributed to surviving shape of the passage, and all of them had different purposes for discussing Mark.
To understand this statement on the Gospel of Mark, then, it is important to understand as best we can each of these tradents who passed the tradition down to us. Concerning Eusebius, it is vital to contextualize the church historian’s use of this passage in terms of his overall views on the gospel of Mark, particularly on its authorship and canonicity. It is also important to take into account Eusebius’s attitude toward his earlier sources: what did he think of his work and its value for Eusebius’s history. After understanding the function of Papias’s remarks in Eusebius, then one ought to look at Papias’s interests and concerns. They are not the same as Eusebius’s. Only after understanding the function of Papias’s remarks, as best as we can in light of the fragmentary preservation, can we dare to draw some responsible conclusions on this famous fragment.
|
Holy Resilience: How the Bible Grew from and Speaks to Trauma
Program Unit: Biblical Literature and the Hermeneutics of Trauma
David M. Carr, Union Theological Seminary in the City of New York
The author will discuss his book with an emphasis on methodological issues pertaining to understanding trauma for biblical interpretation.
|
Diaspora Acts: Contextualizing a Metanarrative SyntActs
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
A. Francis Carter, Jr., Vanderbilt University
Narrative presentations of the past, understood here as history, are key components in the production of ideas and meaning. Comprised of contextual recollections, memories, traditions, omissions, and valuations, history is, by nature, perspectival. History is a freestanding discourse. Yet, these narratives of the past also function as hermeneutic intertexts. As intertexts, histories are organizing structures, providing syntactic frameworks that interpreters use to give meaning to the past, present, and future, and to decipher and interpret other texts. The contextual critique of this latter function of history is this paper’s principle objective. Foregrounded by contextual readings of Black Atlantic authors, I offer a critical theory of diaspora that challenges prevalent (re)constructions of Acts’ ancient context. This paper is a contextual exegesis of Acts’ historical setting. Illuminating protean, polyvocal contexts where authors negotiate multiple identities and allegiances, diaspora can help (re)construct the logics, ideologies, and metanarrative substructures behind Acts. Rejecting univocal notions of diaspora as traumatized existence in perpetual exile, or a root/diaspora binary, diaspora, as conceived here, is a dynamic trans-spatial relationship in perpetual negotiation of relatedness and particularity. In the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries modern critics constructed, through their contextual lenses, world histories that, as evidenced in Hegel’s Philosophy of History, depicted Africa and its descendants as ahistorical, infantile, and outside of human civilization. While scholarship has ceased using such language, the marginalizing effect of these histories’ logic and metanarrative continue to inform scholarship. Black Atlantic writers have challenged these constructs by rooting similar discursive practices in different metanarratives, often censuring both dominant culture, and segments of their diaspora communities. Thus, the crafting of history—as an intertextual metanarrative—with diaspora discourse can subverts binaries and enhance a text’s polyvocality by engaging, affirming, and critiquing multiple aspects of a subject’s being. Hegel, similarly informed nineteenth century biblical critics’ pursuit of the objective history of Christian origins. With varied articulations, these scholars consistently invoked the Jesus movement’s metamorphosis from a sectarian group of Jews into a formal institution of gentiles as the agonistic metanarrative that governs Acts. Employing similar logic and metanarrative, twenty-first century critics most often focus on Acts’ discursive dimensions (themes; citations; story and narrative), while reinscribing rigid binaries such as Peter/Paul, Jew/Gentile, Jewish/Christian, and church/synagogue. Flattening the narrative through a focus on difference instead of ambiguity or relatedness, the resultant consensus views Acts’ author as a gentile, Christian apologist. Diaspora, as a concept, becomes a simplistic geospatial designation for “not Palestine,” or a Jewish gradient ranging from authentic to apostate. My framework, alternatively, uses early Principate Jewish writers such as Philo, Josephus, and the authors of 3 and 4 Maccabees as intertexts juxtaposed to the Black Atlantic, who help me reconstruct Acts’ ancient setting. After identifying places in Acts that convey a relatedness-amidst-particularity, I present Acts’ narrative as a series of diaspora acts, where the concept of diaspora acts in, and through the narrative, as both an organizing structure and logic.
|
Imperial-Critical Work on Jesus-Traditions and the Gospels: Reflections and Assessment
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
Warren Carter, Brite Divinity School (TCU)
This paper critically reviews a decade or so of imperial critical work on the Gospels and Jesus Traditions. It offers some critiques and suggestions for further work.
|
Ship Happens: Acts 27 as an Aquatic Display of Navigating the Stormy Roman Imperial World
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Warren Carter, Brite Divinity School (TCU)
I read this sixty-verse scene as a depiction of a literal sea storm and ship wreck which also carries symbolic (not allegorical) significance. In imperial-critical perspective, I argue that the scene constitutes an “aquatic display” that provides for its audience of Christ-followers a spectacle of navigating the stormy imperial world. I place the Acts account in intertextual relation with Pliny’s Panegyricus, a text that employs five aquatic displays to construct a very positive image of the emperor Trajan. With complex self-positioning, Pliny eulogizes Trajan, constructing him as the bringer of calm seas after the Domitianic storms in which now emperor and senate can enjoy partnership in governing and freedom of speech. I argue that Acts 27 foregrounds the stormy sea as a third space, a contested site in which the sovereignties of God and Rome cooperate and compete, and which Christ-believers must navigate in powerful powerlessness – like Paul - by various means including cooperation, self-assertion, alliance, opposition, imitation, and caution.
|
James as Origin of Paul's Doctrine of Justification
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Brendan Case, Duke University
How does the justification material in the Epistle of James relate to justification in Paul’s epistles? This is one of the great puzzles of New Testament studies, but at least since the Reformers placed justification at the center of Pauline interpretation, the vast majority of commentators have offered variations on a single solution to it, taking Jas as derivative from and somehow responsive to Paul. This paper entertains the possibility that this strategy is fundamentally mistaken, and that, far from being dependent on Paul, Jas might represent the earliest extant installment of justification discourse, which was relayed to Paul by “the Teachers,” a group of Jewish-Christian missionaries closely linked with James and Jerusalem, who adapted James’s discourse for a Law-observant mission to the Gentiles, thus provoking a dramatic rejoinder from Paul in the Letter to the Galatians.
|
Cunning Linguists: Oral Sex in the Song of Songs
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
M. L. Case, The University of Texas at Austin
With its coy poetic style, the Song of Songs typically describes sexual activities obliquely, without any explicit references. As a result, while many interpreters recognize the physical aspect of human love depicted in the Song, they often hesitate to define the specific practices portrayed in a given verse. For example, both Song 2:16 and 6:3 describe the male lover as “he who grazes among the lotuses.” Many scholars read these verses as a vague reference to love-making. In this paper, I strive for specificity by suggesting that Song 2:16 and 6:3 depict the act of cunnilingus. I make my argument on the basis of comparisons to both Egyptian and Sumerian love poetry, as well as contextual analysis of these verses in the Song. With my reading, Song 2:16 and 6:3 focus mainly on the woman’s sexual pleasure, relegating the man’s sexual pleasure to a secondary position. By doing so, the Song not only subverts gender norms for sexual activity, but with its disregard for strictly procreative sex, depicts the woman as a fully sexual being, not merely as a means for reproduction. Thus, the Song gives us a rare glimpse into a particular sexual practice in ancient Israel.
|
Allegory and Myth in Origen’s Contra Celsum
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
John C. Cavadini, University of Notre Dame
Celsus, the late second century philosophical critic of Christianity, and Origen, who responded to his critique in the middle of the third century, are both aware of philosophical allegories of Greek myths, as well as the myths of other ancient cultures such as those of the Egyptians. But Celsus regards the biblical stories as “trash,” not even susceptible to allegorical interpretation. They are not “philosophical” enough to have the capacity to bear any deep, hidden truths. Origen is quick to defend the biblical narratives as containing hidden depths that are, indeed, made available by allegorical exegesis, and yet at the same time, resist reduction to myth. This paper examines the way in which Origen argues for the unique status of biblical narrative as neither merely history nor simply myth, but something in between, which we could appropriately, following Origen’s lead, call “mystery.”
|
Understanding the Structure of the Book of Joel in Light of Deut 30:1–10
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Moonkwon Chae, Baylor University
Since the middle of the 20th century, scholars have greatly emphasized the unity of the book of Joel on the authorial, redactional, or theological level (Wolff, Bergler, and Prinsloo). The short book of Joel, however, includes two or three different days of YWHW. Joel 1-2 describes the imminent day of YHWH that is coming upon Jerusalem and Joel 3-4 describes an eschatological day of YHWH that will come upon the nations in the distant future. Moreover, Joel 3 is often regarded as a different day of YHWH from the one in Joel 4 (Rentorff). Why did the redactor of the book of Joel put the three different days of YHWH together? How were these three days of YHWH put together?
The comparison between Deuteronomy 28-30, specifically Deuteronomy 30:1-10, and Joel 1-4 sheds light on the understanding of the structure of Joel 1-4. While the similarities between Deuteronomy 28-30 and Joel 1-2 were proposed by Bergler, Stuart, and Nogalski, the comparison between Deuteronomy 28-30 and the second half of Joel have not yet been explored. The literary sequence of the series of events in Joel 1-4 follows the Deuteronomic schema of the Israelite history in Deuteronomy 28-30, in particular 30:1-10. By the comparison between Deuteronomy 28-30 and the entire book of Joel, I will argue that the redactor of Joel, anchoring on prophetic traditions and languages, expands the Deuteronomic schema of the Israelite history by connecting it with the day of YHWH traditions and by coloring it with eschatological language.
|
Psalter in First Clement
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Lung Pun Common Chan, Chinese University of Hong Kong
In 1 Clement the second most frequent cited biblical texts are the Book of Psalms (or Psalter). In spite of such an impression, scholarship lacks detailed investigation (cf. Hagner 1973). The overarching purpose of the paper is to examine how 1 Clement received the Psalter in the history of interpretation. The results are illustrated in a threefold outline. First, 1 Clement exemplifies a thematic exegesis of the Psalter. Unlike Ignatius, Clement of Rome rarely opted for a single biblical passage as his interpretational basis. Instead his fragmentary but composite quotations, which perhaps originated from a Jewish anthology, form coherent, extensive arguments (contra the Letter of Barnabas). In addition, he quoted extensively from all five Books of the Psalter. Thus, 1Clement weaves (or intensifies) not only an intertextuality between the Psalter and other biblical writings, but also between individual psalms. Second, 1Clement emphasizes a moralistic reading of the Psalter (cf. Lindemann 1992). Unlike Hebrews (and other NT books), Christological reading of Psalms play an insignificant role in 1Clement. Though Clement adopted a High Priest Christology just like that of Hebrews (cf. Mees 1978), he did not reflect similar interpretation of "messianic" psalms. He mentioned neither soteriological nor eschatological ideas. His numerous choices of psalms focus chiefly on anthropic verses. Consequently the Jewish ethos of Psalms was inherited by previously unrelated recipients, namely Christians (1Clem. 48:2-4). Third, 1Clement emancipates the individual psalms from liturgical setting. In a non-liturgical epistle (contra Drews 1906), Clement reproduced the LXX dictions more or less verbatim and cited mostly with a quotation formula (Pratscher 2010). The popularity of 1Clement catalyzed the canonization of the Psalms in Early Christianity (Ehrman 1983; Metzger 1987 cf. Lona 1998).On top of the spread of Frühkatholizismus, (Beyschlag 1966; Fuellenbach 1980; Moriarty 2012), 1Clement also popularizes Psalms-dictions as daily language in Christian life.
|
Fides et Ratio: Apocalyptic Experience of "I" in Light of McNamara's Neurocognitive Mechanisms of Decentering
Program Unit: Cognitive Science Approaches to the Biblical World
Lung Pun Common Chan, Chinese University of Hong Kong
The overarching purpose of the paper is to apply McNamara's Neuroscience of Religious Experience (2009) to ancient apocalyptic texts, especially the Apocalypse of John. They are treated as reports of subjective religious experiences seriously (14). Special attention is paid to the neurocognitive "decentering" mechanism in them. Decentering is an "offline" process of construction of "a centralized executive Self by reducing the discrepancy between an ideal Self and the current Self" (44). In a religious sense, the Self enters a liminal state. Cognitive-architecturally the decentering mechanism involves four stages of implementation (as shown in Figure 3.2.): (i) "offline" of agency/volition (Rev. 1:9-10); (ii) Self-concept placed in "Possible World" Box (PWB) (Rev. 4:1); (iii) search for optimal Self (Rev. 5:10); and (iv) binding (Rev. 22:8; cf. 22:18). Thus, John's work is investigated for any remaining clues about the decentering stages. The grammatically emphatic "ego" (Greek word: "I") in Christian Apocalypse(s) become(s) surprisingly the entry point of research. "Ego" appears 97 occurrences in the Apocalypse of John. This paper attempts to analyze these apocalyptic "ego" as locale of John's neurocognitive self-construction. McNamara's and other related neuroscientific research results of religious experience are adopted to help explaining these ''ego"-construction. In surface level, John mentions his own "ego" as if simply a spectator in a heavenly throne-room and spiritual journey. However his cognition of self-construction is far more complicated. "Ego" is rather used by other characters too. Plausibly, Christ the Lamb's "ego" is his ideal Self. Earthly human beings' "ego" reflects his own current Self whereas heavenly worshippers' "ego" echoes his new possible Self. If McNamara's neurology of the self would have not been applied in the biblical studies, neurocognitive self-construction in the Apocalypse of John might still be kept unexplored in its Forschungsgeschichte. On and on limitations of McNamara's neuroscience would be kept noticed.
|
“Fate Can’t Be Fled”: The Jerusalem Temple in Josephus’s War and the Capitoline Temple in Tacitus’s Histories
Program Unit: Josephus
Honora Howell Chapman, California State University - Fresno
In War 6.267, Josephus directly compares the fate of living creatures with that of the destroyed Temple and its objects (ergois) and the place where they once stood (topois). This paper will examine the extraordinary narrative space devoted to the Temple in War in contrast to the relatively sparse Tacitean description of the Capitoline Temple, another temple destroyed in a Flavian war (Histories 3.71). Rhiannon Ash (2007) has analyzed Tacitus’s “personification of the suicidal Capitoline Temple,” which provides counterpoint to Josephus’s statements about God sentencing the Temple to death by fire. Both Tacitus and Josephus provide ‘obituaries’ for their respective temples; whereas Tacitus has the opportunity to report the Capitol’s rebirth, Josephus’s ekphrasis in Book 5 also allows for a future for the Jerusalem Temple, even if simply literary in nature. Ultimately, both buildings stand in these texts as symbols of their nations, and both authors in these descriptions question—and answer—whether their nations deserve respect.
|
Rethinking Rhetorical and Literary Criticism: Methodology Panel Proposal
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Davida Charney, University of Texas at Austin
It is now over forty-five years since James Muilenberg proposed rhetorical criticism as a method for "understanding the nature of Hebrew literary compositions." At the time, his goal was to distinguish rhetorical criticism from both form criticism and stylistics. In contrast to form critics, Muilenberg proposed focusing on establishing the boundaries of a literary unit, identifying its internal structure, and describing devices, such as repetition and parallelism, that operated within and across the structural elements. In contrast to the style analysts of the day, Muilenberg emphasized the goal of discerning how the structure and devices contribute to a unique whole, reflecting the writer/speaker's setting, thoughts, and intentions. The first part of Muilenberg's program has clearly been a success. The internal composition of scores of psalms is much better understood. The nature of devices in the psalms—particularly repetition and parallelism—has been the subject of much productive debate. The second part of the program, the coherence of the text as a whole, has received less attention. In part, this neglect is due to the fact that Muilenberg singled out only a few elements of rhetorical theory, which at the time was undergoing a dramatic revival. A focus on structure and devices also overlapped with some concerns of literary theory, which has also developed in important ways over the past four decades. As a result, the terms "rhetorical criticism" and "literary criticism" are now used interchangeably within psalms scholarship, while full power of each approach has gone untapped. In this talk, I will lay out the similarities as well as the distinct concerns of rhetorical and literary analysis. Both methods rely on the techniques of close reading. Both aim to produce plausible and coherent readings that account for as many textual features as possible; neither method claims that its readings are exhaustive or definitive. What most distinguishes the two is their degree of attention to author and audience. The hallmark of rhetorical analysis is viewing the text as persuasive, crafted by the author in an attempt to move hearers or readers to change their attitudes, beliefs, or actions. In contrast, literary analysis may take up any of a wide array of critical paradigms, including some that dispense with the text's historical context and the putative author's intentions. As such, its methods are more conducive to exploring intertextual relationships, such as the placement of individual texts within a collection. The talk will conclude with a sketch of the questions each approach raises that psalms scholars may wish to pursue.
|
Self-Persuasion through Enargeia in Psalm 77
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Davida Charney, University of Texas at Austin
Since ancient times, rhetorical theorists have recognized that the most powerful forms of persuasion are appeals to pathos (or emotion). Changing someone's mood or disposition goes a long way toward changing their willingness to entertain new ideas and opinions. The most powerful emotional appeals make use of enargeia, vivid description and imagery that evokes in hearers/readers the physical sensations and emotions of real-world experience. Imagining and visualizing are so powerful in part because, as neuro-psychologists have found, they activate areas of the brain associated with perceptual organs and motor activities. The psalms, particularly the first-person laments, are filled with evocative description and imagery. Yet the persuasive function of these passages often goes unrecognized. They are treated as expressive, as a release or articulation of feeling, rather than as persuasive, a move to change the disposition of others whose attitudes, beliefs, or actions the speaker wishes to influence. A particularly interesting example of the persuasive use of enargeia comes in Psalm 77. Psalm 77 has resisted easy classification. As in many laments, the speaker vividly describes physical distress and distance from God but fails to call on God to respond and or to make a vow of public praise. Rather, the psalm takes on the quality of a hymn with a lengthy historical narrative of the exodus from Egypt and revelation at Sinai. In this talk, I will suggest that the speaker is recounting, enacting, and prescribing an active form of self-persuasion. Rather than asking God to intervene to relieve his distress, the speaker calls to mind images that change his own disposition. In this way, the speaker uses both first-hand experience and imaginative recreations of such experiences as a way to build moral character, as a form of self-discipline or habitus.
|
How Much Shame Can One Text Take? Examining Gideon via Shame Psychology
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Amy J. Chase, Drew University
Gideon has been judged either a hero or a disappointment according to how well he is believed to fulfill Yahweh’s intention for him to serve as his "mighty warrior." But either judgment assumes the narrator’s unreserved loyalty toward Yahweh. Biblical criticisms that employ a hermeneutic of suspicion have cleared some space to instead examine Yahweh as a character himself, one whose motives, actions, attitudes and beliefs can be critically engaged to assess his value and virtue as a character in the text. Into this space I propose setting psychological theories of shame as a tool to understand the Gideon saga of Judges 6-8.
Psychological theories of shame, such as those promoted by Donald L. Nathanson or Thomas J. Scheff and Suzanne M. Retzinger, can supply insight into the goals and agency of key characters by illuminating the shame they likely experience and how this shame influences their actions. In the Gideon saga, two figures in particular interact with Gideon in response to their own shame and in doing so pass shame onto Gideon. These figures are Yahweh and Joash, who each claim possession of Gideon. This paper argues that the shame resulting from their tug of war accumulates until Gideon is finally transformed from powerless representative of Yahweh to enraged advocate for his own identity, an identity aligned with his family and its affiliation with Baal.
|
The Poetry of the Deliverance at the Sea in the Book of Psalms
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Kevin Chau, University of the Free State - Universiteit van die Vrystaat
The traditions of the deliverance at the Red Sea and the theomacy during creation have been well noted in many of the individual psalms; however far less attention has been directed toward how these traditions have been expressed through the poetry of the Psalms. This paper explores how poetic macrostructure, parallelism, metaphor, and other poetic devices shape how these traditions were understood and utilized. It will focus primarily on Psalms 74, 77-78, 89, and 106. Psalm 74 will be analyzed according to how the two aforementioned traditions are intertwined through the poetry; Psalms 77-78 according to the theophanic imagery and the relationship between the shepherding metaphors and the tradition of the deliverance at the Red Sea; Psalm 89 according to the relationship between the theomachy tradition and God’s anointed one; and Psalm 106 according to the personification of the sea.
|
The Rise of Localism within Empire Governance: Second Temple Judea and Postcolonial Hong Kong (HKSAR)
Program Unit: Asian and Asian-American Hermeneutics
Philip P. Chia, Chinese University of Hong Kong
This paper examines the relations between the Local and the Central in the Judean state under the Imperial Persian Empire and later the Seleucid rule, and makes some comparisons with (post)colonial Hong Kong (Special Administrative Region) under the British Empire and later the Communist China rule, in terms of localism and nationalism, demography and immigration policy, labor and social capital, democracy and empire governance, illuminating the tensions created due to cultural differences. The study also examines analogies between ancient and modern imperial governance, and identifies warning signals within the current fragile situation in the tiny Hong Kong colony.
The preservation of an empire as one unity depends largely on the system of imperial governance. The form of power-sharing between the Local and the Central is crucial if the empire is to remain unified. The granting of a certain degree of autonomy to Yehud, whether under the imperial Persian Empire and later Seleucid rule, or to Hongkongers under the British Empire and later Communist China’s rules, throws up significant questions for how to understand the relationship between the Local to the Central. The tensions arising can easily make or break an empire.
What kind of local priestly power was evident within Yehud? Was there a specific provision for local autonomy under Persian and Seleucid rules? Was there some kind of locally constituted power, or was power rested only in the hand of the Persian and Seleucid rulers and their appointees? What provoked social upheaval in Judea under Seleucid rule?
A postcolonial predicament has arisen from tensions between the Local and Central in HKSAR, which is tearing the fabric of Hongkongers’ society. What might be learned from second Temple biblical texts that could inform the current debates on national unity and imperial governance in the communist-ruled HKSAR? Is a kind of Maccabean resistance possible? And how does this discussion bear on the challenges faced by other polities (ethnic, religious, political) within China?
|
The Platform of Mark’s Gospel, Its Aramaic Sources, and Mark’s Achievement
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
Bruce Chilton, Bard College
The earliest written Gospel did not spring from the pen of a single writer. “Mark” is composed from materials that had been used before, some emerging first in Aramaic, and then in Greek, while others began life in Greek. Because he composed his work for hearers already familiar with the sources involved, the composition of the Gospel represented a communal interaction between composer and audience in a principally oral environment of communication.
Any knowledge of Mark’s informants comes by way of inference, by assessing the material they handed on to be incorporated within the Gospel. Sometimes, we are aided in this evaluation by the existence of Aramaisms in the text, which might indicate when an Aramaic tradition has been taken up by Mark, whenever it was initially translated. But other criteria are at least equally important: instances where possible tradents (such as Peter) are named or their identities alluded to, the alignment of interests signaled in the New Testament with those of a known tradent, and signal changes of scene or style as passage flows after passage.
|
The Theological Meaning of the Literary Shape of the Book of Job
Program Unit: Theology of the Hebrew Scriptures
Paul Kang-Kul Cho, Wesley Theological Seminary
In a forthcoming article (“The Integrity of Job 1 and 42:11-17,” CBQ [April 2014]), I argue that Job 1 and 42:11-17 constitute an originally independent literary unity that a later author split and expanded (Job 2 and 42:7-10) in order to incorporate the poetic dialogue (Job 3:1–42:6). (I do not consider the complex literary history of the poetic dialogue in the article.) In this presentation, I will explore the theological implication of this literary history. I will argue (1) that the theology of Job 1 and 42:11-17 is theocentric in contrast to the human-focused theology of Job 2:1–42:10 and (2) that the literary shape of the Book of Job privileges the divine perspective of Job 1 and 42:11-17 at the same time it makes room for and embraces the human perspectives of the inner core. The proposed theological interpretation differs from the generalizing interpretation of M. Fox (“Job the Pious,” ZAW 117 [2005] 351-66) and C. Newsom’s (The Book of Job: A Contest of Moral Imaginations [Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2003]) Bakhtinian interpretation.
|
Reexamining the Marriage Metaphor in Hosea 2
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible and Cognate Literature
Paul Kang-Kul Cho, Wesley Theological Seminary
In this presentation, I will reexamine the marriage metaphor in Hosea 2 through the lens of R. Jakobson’s analysis of a speech event (“Linguistics and Poetics,” in Style in Language [ed. Sebeok; New York: Wiley, 1960] 350-77), replacing “message” with “metaphor.” In so doing, I will (1) rearticulate one feminist critique of male and historical-critical interpretations of the marriage metaphor using Jakobson’s terms and concepts, (2) rearticulate one feminist interpretation of the marriage metaphor, and (3) attempt to move beyond the impasse by providing a fresh reading of the metaphor within Jakobson’s analysis of a speech event that underlines the inadequacies of both historical-critical interpretations and feminist interpretations. While affirming feminist critique of Hosea’s portrayal of sexual violence, I will attempt to show that the metaphor functioned to criticize the male audience and to motivate them to be less like the abusive God portrayed in the metaphor.
|
Country Mouse Goes to the City: Situating Q 7:1–10 in Galilee
Program Unit: Q
Agnes Choi, Pacific Lutheran University
A perennial question in the study of Christian origins has concerned the transition of the ministry of Jesus in the rural domain to the ministry of the early Jesus movement in the urban domain. While the construction of space within Q itself has been studied, less attention has been given to the redaction of Q in the real, or actual, space of Galilee.
The transition of the early Jesus movement from the rural to the urban domain almost certainly occurred gradually, moving from smaller villages, to larger villages, before arriving in the city proper. Nevertheless, a typology of Galilee’s space has not yet been introduced into the conversation about the redaction of Q.
Many have argued that Q 7:1-10 was absent from Q1 and added to Q2. This paper will consider Q 7:1-10 within the redactional history of Q, with a focus on what might be revealed by the introduction of this pericope into Q about Galilee’s space and the movement of the early Jesus followers within that space.
|
Toward an Anthropology of Money in the Gospels
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Michelle Christian, University of Toronto
What is at stake in any reference to money in the gospels? What 'work' does money perform in the various contexts in which it appears? This paper, intended for the second project, addresses these questions from an anthropological perspective, focusing in particular on money's role in constructing value. It then analyzes Mt 10.29-31//Lk 12.6-7, a curious aphorism that estimates human worth according to the price of sparrows, reckoned in assaria. I suggest that the saying's explicit reference to money and price is remarkable in that, quite unlike other sayings with similar themes (e.g. Mt 6.26//Lk 12.24; Mt 12.12), it quantifies and calculates value. It is, therefore, a good test case for demonstrating the insights to be gained from an anthropological approach to money in the gospels.
|
Paul and the Rhetoric of Insinuatio: How Paul Raises the Dead in First Corinthians
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Timothy J. Christian, Asbury Theological Seminary
"Defunctos excitare" is one way, says the Latin rhetorician Quintilian, to end a speech with a bang. This exciting of the defunct, or “raising of the dead” if you will, was one tactic that ancient rhetors could use at the end of speeches to bring home their final points throwing down the gauntlet and pulling out all of the stops. It is no coincidence then that Quintilian mentions this right before discussing a pertinent approach for constructing a speech, an approach that saves the major bone of contention for the end of the oration, namely, insinuatio – “the Subtle Approach.” Now it has long been held about 1 Corinthians that 1 Cor 15 functions as the climactic ending to the epistle, though some have purported that it simply addresses one topic among a laundry list of topics having no climactic piquancy. Concurring with the former view in asserting that 1 Cor 15 is the climax of 1 Corinthians, I am offering an explanation – something that is all but missing with this assertion among the scholarly debate – as to how it functions in this way from the method of rhetorical criticism, namely, that Paul uses the rhetorical device of "insinuatio" to bring this epistle to a climax in 1 Cor 15. In other words, I am proposing that Paul's main contention with the Corinthians is that some are denying the doctrine of the resurrection of the dead, and rather than addressing this using the direct approach, Paul tactfully opts to hint at resurrection indirectly throughout the letter (1 Cor 1-14) and then towards the end addresses it head-on (1 Cor 15) which is precisely how ancient rhetoricians would address either topics that their audience thought were dubious or court cases that were scandalous. Since the Jewish notion of resurrection was such an inconceivable idea for Greco-Roman peoples, Paul uses "insinuatio" to save his discussion of resurrection for the end so that (1) his argument is convincing, and (2) so that his audience is not turned off to everything else that he must address to this church. I therefore will argue in this paper that this best demonstrates how 1 Cor 15 functions as the climax of 1 Corinthians; that Paul uses "insinuatio" to build the entire epistle to its climax of convincing the Corinthians of an otherwise incredulous idea in their minds, namely, resurrection.
|
Leadership and Followers
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
Frank Clancy, Independent Scholar
In Baltimore, Jacob Wright stepped in at the last moment and presented a paper on leaders and the qualities of leadership and the relationship with Yahweh. However, he did not discuss the relationship of the leader and those that he or she led. The nature and functions of leadership should be seen in relationship to those who are led. Is there a difference in the leadership qualities and functions of David and Solomon? How about Saul? Do we see a difference in the authority of Moses at different times? Or Joshua? Is there a difference between leading "all Israel" and the "tribes or families of Israel? It is important to see who were led, where the authority resided, as we examine the concept and functions of leadership in the Biblical Texts.
|
Brubeck’s Bible: The Use of Biblical Texts in Sacred Jazz
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Dan W. Clanton, Jr., Doane College
While religious concerns and theological reflection have not been absent in Jazz, engagement with biblical texts has been much less common. One notable and consistent contributor to this engagement was the pianist and composer Dave Brubeck. Brubeck was one of the most popular Jazz artists in history, becoming only the second Jazz musician to appear on the cover of Time magazine in 1954 and scoring a huge crossover hit with his 1959 album Time Out. His own religious background was eclectic, and he composed numerous religious works in his career that incorporated a variety of musical styles and textual components, including biblical texts. This presentation will examine Brubeck’s use of the Bible in his compositions, focusing especially on The Real Ambassadors (1962), The Gates of Justice (1969), and The Commandments (2005). Only the latter’s text is adapted wholly from the biblical library; the other two include texts from a wide range of sources, including Hillel and Martin Luther King, Jr. Even so, all of these pieces employ biblical texts to address what Brubeck saw as serious societal ills (racism, war, and more generally the fracturing of society) and to reinforce his fervent belief in the oneness of humanity. The time seems ripe for an examination of this kind for three reasons: Brubeck died recently in 2012; there is a decided dearth of scholarly engagement with the religious aspects of Jazz; and Jazz is now more of an umbrella genre than at any point in its history, incorporating more diverse sounds, approaches, and influences than ever before. As such, examining the biblical influences on Brubeck’s work will allow us to discuss the impact of Bible on one of Jazz’s most celebrated figures at a key moment in the development of Jazz, what Brubeck called “the purest form of music.”
|
Ecclesiastes 7:16–17: Moderation Concerning Assimilation
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Bruce Clark, Church of the Good Shepherd, Durham, North Carolina
The imperatives of Eccles. 7.16-17 have long intrigued readers (e.g., Christianson 2007: 193).
Concerning these intriguing imperatives, I will argue that, whereas...
- Perry sees them as “contradictory proverbs” (1993: 128);
- Ogden places them in the mouths other than Qoheleth’s (1997: 249);
- Salyer sees “incongruous admonitions” that “advocate a utilitarian ethic” [2001: 240];
- Bartholomew, 2006, (following Seow) sees them as arguing for moderation;
it is prefer to see these imperatives as...
- coming from Qoheleth himself (vs. a third party) and, therefore, complementary;
- aiming to guide the reader between the extremes of radical adoption and radical rejection of dominant/foreign behavioral and intellectual norms.
Why? The key lies in rightly interpreting the two key sets of antonyms, which are regularly translated ‘righteous’ / ‘wicked’ and ‘wise’ / foolish’:
As a lexical-semantic analysis will bear out, both sets of antonyms are very generic, such that a usage’s immediate context must provide the precise standard of conformity / nonconformity (for ts-d-q and r-sh-‘, respectively) and of wisdom / folly (for chakmah and saqal, respectively). The immediate context (v. 15) indicates not a conformity to a standards of Torah (contra, e.g., Odgen and Zogbo [1997, 247]) but to the standards of a daily life that is deeply informed by a dominant/foreign culture, as Qohelet himself experienced it (cf. Salyer 2001: 339). Similarly, the immediate context suggests that the standard of wisdom / folly is not the ‘fear of YHWH’ a la Proverbs) but again that of a dominant/foreign culture. While Fox et al. are right to speak of Qohelet’s limits to wisdom, my proposed explanation more easily accounts for these otherwise perplexing imperatives, esp. v. 17, in which Qohelet (purportedly) says, “Do not be overly wicked.”
|
Toward a Pastoral Reading of 2 Corinthians as a Memoir of PTSD and Healing
Program Unit: Biblical Literature and the Hermeneutics of Trauma
Peter Yuichi Clark, UCSF Medical Center & American Baptist Seminary of the West (GTU)
In recent years pastoral theologians such as Donald Capps and Kathleen Greider, to name two prominent exemplars, have sought to illuminate the spiritual dimensions of the lives of people who are coping with mental illness through an examination of first-person published narratives. This approach of exploring the intersection of spirituality and mental health enables soul-sufferers (Greider’s term) to speak in their own voices, with the theologian functioning as companion to the memoirists and as guide to the readers. This paper aims to apply a similar methodology to the Pauline epistolary corpus. Inspired by a minister’s blog post that asserts that the apostle suffered from posttraumatic stress disorder, this essay will test that contention by concentrating on Paul’s second letter to the Corinthian church. The goal is to employ a pastoral-theological lens that reads and interprets the letter as a memoir of the apostle’s mental struggles and healing process. While sensitive to the scholarly debate about whether 2 Corinthians is a unified letter or contains sections of multiple letters, this paper nevertheless presumes that in several pericopes Paul either alludes to or explicitly describes his personal experience—viz., 2 Cor 1:3–10; 4:7–12 and 16; 5:1–8; 6:4–10; 7:5; 11:21–33; and 12:7–10. The paper will argue that, irrespective of Paul’s rhetorical purposes, the incidents he recounts are consistent with the symptomatology of PTSD as understood through a modern medical theoretical framework. The author will draw upon psychiatric and psychotherapeutic literature to provide a commentarial counterpoint to the biblical text. This pastoral reading will interpret the text as illustrating the apostle’s journey through illness, with an emerging awareness of his own vulnerability and a reliance on the sustaining power of divine grace to lead him toward a sense of healing and wholeness.
|
Dear Theophilus: A Lucan Practical Theology of Jesus among the Marginalized
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Ron Clark, George Fox Evangelical Seminary
The Gospel attributed to Luke claimed to have been written to a second generation Christian community whom had heard the story of Jesus but somehow had neglected to embrace or hear the stories of his encounter with marginalized people. Luke’s narrative of the Messiah is an attempt to intentionally insert stories, teachings, and encounters with the poor, marginalized, and outcasts in Jesus’ world. This seems to be an intentional challenge for the community to address either a neglected area of their ministry and teaching. The Lucan call to free the captives who were marginalized socially, rather than geographically (Luke 4:16-19) is one that needs to be practiced again, as it was in the days of the Theophilus community. As a minister who planted and preaches for a church in inner city Portland and teaches at a seminary, the task of moving students, Christ followers, and our audience to engage those on the margins of Portland has heavily depended upon Luke’s Gospel. As we continue to partner with our community abuse providers, law enforcement, and services to those in prostitution and provide a welcoming environment to them, the need for merging biblical interpretation and homiletics continues to be a challenge, but one that is working.
|
Zechariah: Repeated Cycles and Apocalyptic Images Addressing Shame in Post-exilic and Colonized Yehud
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Ron Clark, George Fox Evangelical Seminary
The book of Zechariah discusses prophecies and dialogue with the Jewish community post exile and under colonization. Assuming the recipients to be a colonized community the issues of shame, oppression, and hopelessness become important qualities of the community. The canonical form of the book displays repeated stories/symbols of forgiveness, restoration, and celebration. Power, in this book, is unique in that it contrasts the power to punish, found in other prophetic texts, with the power to forgive suggesting that Yahweh’s might is one of love and faithfulness. Yahweh, unlike the Persian emperor, rebuilds the soul of the community rather than the structures of the city. However, Yahweh’s prophet repeatedly tells stories of forgiveness and new life, as an attempt to develop a shamed community and address their guilt from both exile and their traumatic journey home. This also offers a similar reminder to addressing those in counseling and therapy struggling with shame, trauma, and guilt as a reminder that the text speaks even to them.
|
Moses Typology and the Sending Motif in Matthew and John
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Carsten Claussen, Elstal Theological Seminary
The expectation of a prophet like Moses, based on Deut 18:15-18, was very much in the air in first century ancient Judaism. Thus it is not surprising that both the Gospels of Matthew and John show considerable influence of Moses typology and especially the sending motif (cf. Exod 3:10-15). In Matthew Jesus presents himself as being sent by God (Matt 10:40) and sends out his disciples (Matt 10:16; 28:16-20). In the Fourth Gospel the sending formula is the key to Jesus’ self-understanding: The Son is sent by God, the Father, and Jesus sends the disciples into the world (17:18). “As the Father has sent me, so I send you” (20:21). This paper will explore the history and reception of the sending motif in light of Moses typology in both Matthew and John.
|
The Future of the Dictionary of Classical Hebrew Project
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
David J. A. Clines, University of Sheffield
The Dictionary of Classical Hebrew is complete, in 8 volumes, published between 1993 and 2011. But the project is ongoing. At present we are engaged in a though revision of all the volumes. Volume 1 (Aleph) was most in need of revision, since it does not have a Bibliography, and it lacks reference to the many Qumran texts that have been published since 1993. For other older volumes we need to retrieve and incorporate the more recent scholarly literature. Our plan is to publish an English–Hebrew Index to Volumes 1–8 in 2014, and revised versions of all the 8 volumes beginning two to three years after that. Already we have 4000 new bibliographical items, and 800 ‘new words’ (not in BDB) to add, as well as some thousands of minor corrections and improvements, and there will be many more additions by the time the revised Volume 1 Aleph begins the publication of the new series of DCH in 2016 or 2017. Then The Concise Dictionary of Classical Hebrew (2009) will be due to be brought into line with the Dictionary of Classical Hebrew, Revised. The joint paper will describe our current method of working.
|
NT Manuscripts as "Beyond Categories" Objects: Thinking about the Death of Jesus as Object of Reprobation
Program Unit: Gospel of Luke
Claire Clivaz, Université de Lausanne
In a 2012 article, François Bovon noticed not without surprise that he devoted almost no time to study New Testament manuscripts, whereas he was all his life so fascinated by some new manuscript of a Christian apocryphal text. To pay attention to the «materiality» of the New Testament, to consider it first through its documents and concrete historical traces, leads clearly the researcher to revise his/her perceptions of ancient Christian texts categories, whatever one call them «useful for the soul», «apocryphal», «canonical». This general affirmation will be study on a specific test-case, the notion of «reproach», or «reprobation» (oneidizo), applied to the death of Christ in a famous variant in Mk 15.34, but also in Rm 15.3, Mt 27.44, or He 11.26, or to qualify for example a not usual pregnancy in Lk 1.25, or for persecutions as in Lk 6.22. The variant of Mk 15.34 will be questionned from this NT background, but also from the «other» Christian texts perspective. According Bovon’s terminology, this variant was at the evidence «useful for the souls» at least for certain ancient Christians, even if it remains difficult to specify them clearly. In a probably clearer way, it challenges our present perception of categories of «texts», leading us to map early Christianity also with the more flexible notion of «traditions».
|
Biblical Studies and Foodways, Ancient and Modern
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Margaret Cohen, Lycoming College
In a February 2014 speech on American manufacturing, President Obama suggested that an Art History degree would not necessarily result in strong job prospects. Indeed, encouraging students to work in the humanities frequently requires something other than a post-graduation job offer. It is crucial that those engaged in fields like biblical studies work to remind the larger academic and non-academic communities that what we offer in the classroom remains important, relevant and meaningful in the modern world. Certainly there are myriad ways of providing this kind of reminder, and I wish to offer one such example in which biblical texts and criticism are brought to bear on the very timely issue of foodways, including modern food movements. For a number of years I have been teaching (both alone and team-taught) a course which investigates ancient Israelite, early Jewish, and modern Jewish foodways, addressing approaches to land and agriculture, regulations and practices for food production, preparation, and eating, and thought concerning food distribution and food justice. Such an exploration is strongly rooted in an agrarian reading of the biblical texts, following, for example, the work of Ellen Davis. Though my primary focus in the modern arena has been on current Jewish food movements, I am informed by work in Christian circles, such as that highlighted in Jennifer Ayres’ recent Good Food, and will make mention of the use of both.
The constellation of topics surrounding food and foodways within the framework of biblical Israel has proven to be a wonderful entrée both for students who have limited experience with the biblical text, and for students who, because of their own religious backgrounds, enter a religion course thinking that they already know the material. Because the concept of an agrarian reading of the Bible is almost always new, students from both of these categories start from a level playing field and are able to consume the material with fresh perspective, thus mitigating one common challenge of biblical studies teaching. Another opportunity afforded by this curriculum is the appeal to students who have not previously considered taking a biblical studies course. Because modern foodways, especially, are so multifaceted, this topic has the opportunity to engage students from a wide array of disciplines including, but certainly not limited to, religious studies, ethics, agricultural and food science studies, economics, political science, environmental studies, biology, anthropology and peace and conflict studies. In addition to discussing the content and organization of this program, I will also address the use of diverse resources, especially electronic resources, used to teach this course and the benefits to students with regard to increased internet research competency and critical use of non-scholarly, “real world” sources. Finally, my anecdotal evidence suggests that these themes naturally encourage people to become involved in their communities either at the moment of study or in future endeavors, which contributes to one of the great goals of the liberal arts—to create responsible, informed and competent citizens of the world.
|
The Complex Nature of the Hebrew Verbal Tense System
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Ohad Cohen, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
The linguistic debate between the supporters of the tense approach and the supporters of the aspect/mode approach concerning the Biblical Hebrew verbal tense system can be seen as two generalizations, on the basis of which each school endeavors to bend the entire system to a single perspective. Since the verb is a “predicative complex,” a comprehensive description of the verbal system must take into account the fact that there is more than one perspective with which to describe the system. We propose that the biblical verbal system’s two central axes are the modal axis, which is underpinned by the indicative-modal contrast, and the reference-time axis, wherein every form is defined according to the chronological relation that it maintains with the deictic center R-time. Not only do these two axes not contradict one another, they may be viewed as complementary.
|
The Deposition of Athaliah as a "Democratic Coup d'Etat": A Political and Gender Reading of 2 Kings 11 and 2 Chronicles 23
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
Stuart Cohen, Ashkelon Academic College
The term "democratic coup d"etat" was coined in Ozan Varol's 2012 article of that name (Harvard International Law Journal, 53: 292-356). Disputing the conventional view that coups – even when not carried out by the military (as most are) – affront stability and legitimacy, Varol demonstrated that they occasionally enhance constitutionalism and restore governmental norms.
Utilizing that insight, the present paper employs contemporary theories regarding coups d'etat in order to analyze the deposition of Queen Athaliah of Judah, as depicted in II Kings 11 and II Chron. 23.
Both accounts emphasize this coup's distinctiveness.
(1) It caused considerably less bloodshed than many others, and especially that only recently instigated by Jehu in the northern kingdom. Accomplished in just one day, the episode resulted in the death (“state execution” in modern circumlocution) of just two persons: Athaliah and Matan the priest of Ba’al.
(2) The coup against Athaliah was not the work of a military junta. Rather, from start to finish it was orchestrated by Jehoiadah "the [high?]priest."
(3) Even so, Athaliah's deposition was not a hole in the corner affair. On the contrary, her replacement by the boy-king Joash received public sanction during a stage-managed pageant of covenant-making in the Temple compound.
(4) Finally, Joash's accession did not ignite civil strife between supporters and opponents of the new regime. The texts are explicit that, once the coup was over, “the city was at peace”.
The present paper places that narrative in a political science setting and also presents a gender-based interpretation of the deposition of Judah's only female monarch. To the best of our knowledge, it is the first attempt to read the relevant texts through those lenses. Although several studies do depict Athaliah’s deposition as a “classic” coup d’etat, none have hitherto utilized political theory in order to elucidate the term. Likewise, whereas the queen's gender is conventionally noted, nowhere are its possible influences on the vulnerability of her regime explored.
Seeking to repair both deficiencies, this paper will:
1. Identify the nature of the regime change which the overthrow of Athaliah entailed, defining as rigorously as possible the coup as a mechanism for the attainment of political power.
2. Discuss the conditions that modern political science literature considers conducive to coups d’etat and the criteria thought necessary for their success.
3. Assess the possible impact of Athaliah's gender on her status as an "outsider" in Judean political society and hence prone to isolation.
|
Birthing the Virtues: Endurance, Romans 8, and the Acts of Paul and Thecla
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Lynn Cohick, Wheaton College (Illinois)
In the Acts of Paul and Thecla, the proto-martyr Thecla endures torture in light of her hope in bodily resurrection. The virtue of endurance took on new meaning among Second Temple Jews who held to the resurrection of the body, and became a key virtue for Christians. Endurance was a second order virtue for the Roman philosophers, who saw it as appropriate for women, but not for men. Endurance was often typified by the image of a woman in childbirth. Christian appeals for endurance, linked with images of childbirth and with bodily resurrection, challenge the gender-constructed virtues of the wider Roman world.
|
Jesus and the Empire of God in Jas 2:1–13: Using Jesus Traditions as Nativist Rhetoric
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
K. Jason Coker, Albertus Magnus College
James begins the body of his letter using certain Jesus traditions to legitimize and authorize his stance against common Roman social customs regarding wealth and poverty. James 2:1-7 adopts “kingdom” or “empire” language from the Jesus tradition to argue against partiality to the wealthy that is typified in the patronage system. To counter the patronage system, James argues that within his anti-imperial “empire,” God chooses the poor rather than the wealthy (2:5), which utterly contradicts the Roman patronage system. In the second half of this passage (2:8-13), James is more explicit in his use of the Jesus tradition when he explains the “law of the empire.” The way James appropriates Leviticus 19:18 evidences his debt to the Jesus tradition. The heavenly “law of the empire” or “imperial law” defines what it means to follow God’s command to “love your neighbor as yourself” (2:8). James uses the authority of the Jesus tradition to create his antithesis between the heavenly “law of the empire” and the cultural “laws” that determine appropriate behavior regarding the wealthy and poor. As he explicates the heavenly “law of the empire,” James emphasizes the “whole law” (2:10) and uses the Decalogue as an example (2:11). In this process of explication, many scholars recognize the “voice of Jesus” behind James’ argumentation. James’ use of the Jesus tradition, then, gives his nativist rhetoric the authority and legitimacy he needs to make his emphatic statements against the patronage system.
|
The Corporation of God: Globalization Studies and God’s Basileia
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
K. Jason Coker, Albertus Magnus College
In his important work Empire and Apocalypse, Stephen Moore persuasively argues for translating Basileia as empire specifically in the Gospel of Mark and the Revelation. By translating Basileia as empire rather than the traditional kingdom, Moore highlights the anti-Roman sentiments in these two New Testament writings. In this anti-imperial mode of discourse, however, the author of Mark and Revelation offer a Basileia of God that is none other than the Roman Empire reversed and expanded to heavenly proportions.
I will explore the intersection of Moore’s analysis of the Basileia of God with Globalization Studies specifically related to the issue of translation. In the aggressive rise of multinational corporations over the past several decades and their challenge to the autonomy of sovereign nations, how does the ancient concept of the Basileia of God challenge, coopt or comply with these powerful entities if one translates Basileia as corporation or specifically as multinational corporation? Can the Basileia of God be used as a moral critique against multinational corporations and argue for modern economic justice? In other words, how would/could Basileia function if it is translated as the Multinational Corporation of God? I will examine these translational questions with the critical lens of Globalization Studies.
|
Allegory and the Nature of Biblical Referentiality: Proverbs 8:22–31 as ‘Other Speaking’
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
Don Collett, Trinity Episcopal School for Ministry
To speak of ‘allegory’ in the context of biblical exegesis raises numerous difficulties for modern readers of Scripture, not the least of which stem from the many different ways in which the term may be understood. Allegory may be variously understood as a genre category, a non-historical way of reading that ‘spiritualizes’ Scripture, the literary device of personification, or the practice of fusing the NT’s semantic level with that of the OT in order to ‘Christianize’ Israel’s scriptures. All these usages have found expression in the church’s exegetical tradition, thus making it difficult to define allegory in a monolithic sense, or even to speak of a ‘traditional’ or received sense for the term.
The present paper suggests that the grammar of allegory in the church’s exegetical tradition is best understood as a way of capturing Scripture’s referential sense, that is, a mode of ‘other speaking’ grounded in the church’s traditional conviction that Scripture is a book about God. Viewed in this light, allegorical exegesis does not arise in the first instance as an ad hoc or retrospective maneuver that seeks to guarantee the OT’s Christological sense, but as that which properly belongs to the peculiar nature of biblical referentiality and Scripture’s literal sense. Stated differently, the church’s continuing need to wrestle exegetically with Scripture’s allegorical sense is ultimately made necessary by the Bible’s theological subject matter. Thus the church’s traditional grammar of allegory is a function of—indeed, a hermeneutical extension from—Scripture’s ontological frame of reference. The paper further suggests that modern exegetical disagreements over the referential sense of Proverbs 8:22-31 offer an instructive test case for assessing the usefulness of ‘allegorical exegesis’ in biblical interpretation.
|
The Mysticism of Paul
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Adela Collins, Yale University
The mysticism of Paul
|
Angels, Giants, and Culture Heroes in the Development and Reception of the Book of the Watchers
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Jack Collins, University of Virginia
The ?Asa?el or instruction narrative in the Book of the Watchers (roughly, 1 Enoch 7:1; 8:1–3; 9:6, 8; 10:4–8) presents distinct interpretive and historical challenges in its decidedly negative reappropriation of a usually positive ancient literary motif, viz., that of supernatural culture heroes who provide humanity with essential knowledge or technology. This motif of angelic instruction figures prominently in the later reception of the BW narrative, but many of these interpretations seem to retain vestiges of more positive culture-hero traditions associated giants and with the flood.
Through a diachronic survey of several key texts, this paper will demonstrate the influence of other, more positive culture-hero traditions, rooted in Gen 6:1–4, which were not derived from the negative portrayal of angelic instruction found in the Book of the Watchers. By proposing set of criteria for determining the presence of these parallel traditions, I will argue that two additional, independent complexes of tradition played a key part in Jewish and Christian interpretations of the fallen-angel myth, and contributed to some of the less negative portrayals of angelic instruction found therein.
In the first of these traditions, Noah and members of his family are depicted as giants, or as the offspring of angels, and are said to be responsible for the transmission of secret, antediluvian knowledge. John C. Reeves (1993) already identified traces of these traditions in ancient birth-narratives of Noah and in the pseudo-Eupolemus fragments, but they are also evident in later traditions attributing the origins of alchemy to Ham. The other complex concerns the fallen angels’ failed divine commission as the keepers of the cosmic order. This narrative (attested in Jubilees and the “Animal Apocalypse” [1 En. 85–90]) differs from the Book of the Watchers in depicting a two-stage fall, in which the angels’ presence on earth leads them to sin, thus shifting the vector of corruption. Connected with this strand in particular are traditions associating the fallen angels with the celestial spheres (not simply the interpretation thereof), and those treating the fallen angels or the spirits of the giants as objects of human worship.
The presence of parallel fallen-angel traditions has several important implications to the study of Enochic literature. First, it would solve the long-standing question of why the culture-hero stratum was inserted into the Book of the Watchers at all, by demonstrating that the motifs of culture heroes, the flood, and giants were readily associated in the contemporary cultural lexicon. Instead of an intrusion, the ?Asa?el narrative becomes an organic extension of the themes of the book. Moreover, parallel fallen-angel traditions would also explain why motifs not attested in the Book of the Watchers appear independently in later interpretations of the Watchers myth. As certain themes and motifs became entangled in the traditions derived from 1 Enoch, the interpretive “canon” expanded beyond the text itself to include certain implicit connections drawn from outside traditions.
|
"Degraded from Their Heavenly Vigour": Fallen Angels, the Testament of Solomon, and the Demonology of the Early African Church
Program Unit: Function of Apocryphal and Pseudepigraphal Writings in Early Judaism and Early Christianity
Jack Collins, University of Virginia
The works of the third century Latin fathers Tertullian (Apology), Minucius Felix (Octavius), Cyprian (On the Vanity of Idols), and Lactantius (Divine Institutes) contain strikingly similar (often verbatim) accounts of the origin and nature of demons. Direct dependence between some of the sources is possible, but the overall trajectory of any influence is obscure—particularly given the uncertain dates of Felix—and to date, no scholars have undertaken to clarify the relationship.
The demonology presented by these African sources draws heavily on Justin Martyr, and upon especially Athenagoras, with whom they agree in distinguishing fallen angels from demons, the latter being the spirits of the children born to fallen angels and human women. This paper will trace this concept of demons from its origins in 1 Enoch 15–16 and Jubilees 10, through Justin and Athenagoras, and then compare it to the demonology evident in the Testament of Solomon. This will firmly locate T. Sol. within the context of third-century Christian thought, reflecting a specific sub-stratum of the Enochic fallen-angel complex in which the giants—rather than the angels themselves—were seen as the primary tradents in forbidden heavenly knowledge.
Finally, a synopsis of the relevant passages will demonstrate that the commonalities and divergences of the African authors are better explained by a shared, external Latin source than by any direct dependence between them, or by the shared influence of the Greek text of Athenagoras. This study will enrich our understanding of the vital role that demonological concerns played in the worldview of the early fathers, and how these concerns shaped—and were shaped by—pseudepigraphal works.
|
Torah as Wisdom in the Second Temple Period
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
John J. Collins, Yale University
The wisdom tradition, from Proverbs to Qoheleth, is distinguished by its lack of attention to the Torah. This suggests that there was a scribal tradition in Jerusalem that did not regard the Torah as part of its curriculum. At some point in the Second Temple period, however, the Torah too came to be viewed as a source of wisdom. This paper will consider this phenomenon as it finds expression in the later Psalms and in the Book of Ben Sira, and consider the sapiential view of Torah as distinct from the halakhic view that becomes dominant in the Dead Sea Scrolls.
|
Judah, Ephraim, and Conceptual Identity in the Qumran Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Qumran
Matthew A. Collins, University of Chester
The labels, sobriquets, and typological language utilised within the sectarian Qumran scrolls have, ever since their discovery, generated widespread speculation and countless theories as to the precise nature of their significance and, of course, the identities of their historical referents. While debate has raged over the identities of such figures as “the Teacher of Righteousness” and “the Wicked Priest”, there has, in most quarters, been an uncommon degree of consensus (or at least, tacit acceptance) that use of the scriptural terms “Judah”, “Ephraim”, and “Manasseh” in the pesharim should be understood as typological labels for the Community and its opponents – according to most constellations, the Essenes, Pharisees, and Sadducees respectively. This paper will first highlight some ambiguities in the use of “Judah” and “Ephraim” (and to a lesser extent, “Manasseh”) in the sectarian texts, problematizing a straightforward reading of these labels in relation to distinct groups. It will then focus in on the use of “Ephraim”, proposing that the explicit association of this patriarchal label with “the Seekers of Smooth Things” and the community of “the Man of the Lie” in the pesharim can be straightforwardly derived from implicit scriptural allusions present in the Damascus Document.
|
Abraham, Isaac, and Polar Bears: Reading Genesis 22 through the Lens of “Lost”
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Matthew A. Collins, University of Chester
The popular U.S. television series Lost (2004–2010, ABC) is saturated with biblical allusion. This paper takes as its focus the Season 3 episode “Catch-22”, which contains a number of explicit allusions to the Aqedah of Genesis 22. These would appear to provide a lens through which to understand the episode as a whole, one in which the theme of sacrifice is especially prominent. Viewed in the light of the biblical text, the focal character of the episode seems to grapple with the same personal and ethical dilemma faced by Abraham. Setting “Catch-22” and Genesis 22 alongside one another, however, it becomes clear that this is only part of a larger mutually-informative process. Accordingly, this paper not only demonstrates how the Lost episode can be read and interpreted in the light of Genesis, but also returns to the biblical text in order to re-read Genesis 22 through the lens of Lost. In doing so, it is argued that the episode is not merely the passive recipient or product of biblical influence and allusion, but actively functions as a surreptitious commentary on the Aqedah event itself – one which should make us return to the biblical text with fresh eyes.
|
To Tread on Serpents: Jewish-Christian Violence and Memory-Making in Severus of Minorca’s Letter on the Conversion of the Jews
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
Jennifer Collins-Elliott, Florida State University
In 418 CE Severus, the bishop of Minorca, wrote an account of the conversion of all of Minorca’s Jews. The arrival of Stephen’s relics to the island made this miraculous conversion possible according to the letter’s author. These relics reminded the Christian community at Minorca of their suffering at the hands of the island’s Jews, and at the hands of Jews in the past, which is reenacted through a public stoning that parallels Stephen’s own martyrdom. Peaceful relationships between Jews and Christians soon disintegrated, and Stephen’s relics galvanized Minorca’s Christians into action against the Jewish community on the island. According to Severus’ narrative, the Jews, under the influence of Christian reasoning and divine intervention, began to convert, and thus the Christians were no longer subject to their persecution. With this success, Christians had yet again proven themselves to be a community of victorious sufferers who had triumphed over their powerful, historical persecutors, the Jews.
While Severus’ account is not purely “historical” and the author employs many pious embellishments in order to tell this story, it is precisely these pious embellishments that reveal the normative narrative beyond the “facts” of the situation. Thus in this paper, rather than focusing on questions of the historicity of the events recounted in this text, I employ Maurice Hablwachs’ theory of collective memory and Elizabeth Castelli’s work on Christian martyrdom and collective memory in order to engage with this letter as a piece of Christian memory-making inspired by a continuing sense of persecution and violence inflicted on Christians. In order to craft such an argument, I build on Castelli’s thesis in her book Martyrdom and Memory so as to demonstrate that through this letter the Christians on Minorca are creating a collective memory that serves to define not only themselves but also the Jews in their community. More specifically, I will argue that Severus, through the presence of Stephen’s relics and the acts of violence that accompany them, creates and propagates this collective memory in which Christians are the righteous sufferers and Jews their persecutors. The bishop suggests in his writing that Minorca’s Christians had failed to recognize their own suffering and that it was only brought to light when Stephen’s relics were brought to light. Stephen served not only as a reminder of their shared heritage of suffering but he also served as validation for Christians who felt embattled and persecuted. In this way, Stephen’s relics reminded Christians that they were a suffering people and thus through his presence, as well as the act of writing and circulating this letter, this facet of Christian identity was further entrenched and justified.
|
Dreaming Christian: Tertullian’s Epiphanies and the Construction of Pagan/Christian Identity
Program Unit: Inventing Christianity: Apostolic Fathers, Apologists, and Martyrs
Jason Robert Combs, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
Tertullian’s writings were once understood within the fixed categories of orthodoxy and Montanism, and his particular interest in dreams was considered evidence of the latter. Now, scholars operate with a more dynamic understanding of early Christianity, one in which ancient authors struggled continuously to produce and negotiate identities. Yet, the role of dreams within this new framework has not yet been considered. My paper addresses this gap by examining Tertullian’s discourse on dreams — especially epiphanies, or dreams and visions of the divine — as a discourse on identity. Rather than locate Tertullian in relation to Montanism, I show how Tertullian’s narrativizations and theorizations of epiphanies were implicated in the construction of a Christian identity as distinct from pagan identity. Building on the work of Patricia Cox Miller, I situate Tertullian’s theories about dreams (e.g., De Anima 42–57) and his narratives of epiphanies (especially in De Spectaculis, De Idololatria, and De Virginibus Velandis) within their broader Greco-Roman context. I show that, in Tertullian’s time, discourses surrounding epiphanies could shape and sustain “religious” identities because these phenomena were integrated into the cultural practices and societal relations of daily life. Through dreams and visions, the gods revealed the future, offered protection, commanded particular actions or honors, punished, and performed miraculous healings. Tertullian’s theories and narratives of these phenomena share much with contemporary pagan accounts, but they are employed in a way that crafts a normative Christian identity. By redefining how and when dreams should be interpreted, acted upon, or dismissed, Tertullian prescriptively establishes the Christian as distinct from the pagan. For instance, when he associates legitimate visions only with Christian liturgical contexts and ecclesial authorities (e.g., De Anima 9), he buttresses his community against outside influence. When he defines the dreams of pagan images as demonic, he constructs a Christian who is immune to the common dream of pagan gods (e.g., De Anima 46) — unlike pagans, this Christian cannot be deceived into offering sacrifice. In conclusion, by closely examining how Tertullian crafts the dreaming Christian, this paper sheds new light on Tertullian’s construction of pagan/Christian identities.
|
Islands in the Corrupting Sea: Mapping Second-Century Christianity
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Cavan Concannon, Duke University
Modern historians map the diversity of early Christianity in a variety of ways, from declines into heresy to competition among “varieties” of early Christianities. In this paper, I argue that we might better map the remains of second-century Christianity by focusing on networks of people, ideas, and letters that moved along broader patterns of trade and communication in the eastern Mediterranean. Focusing on the costs, velocities, and viscosities of movement and commerce, I examine two early Christian networks associated with Dionysios of Corinth and Ignatius of Antioch, respectively. In each case, I show how non-human actants such as geography, economic activity, and trade routes shape the interactions among the various nodes in each network, allowing us to map second-century Christianity as a series of emergent networks that form, coalesce, and dissolve in the flow of movement and connectivity that characterized the Roman Mediterranean.
This proposal is for project three.
|
“Come Up Here!” The Throne Room of Revelation as Reflected in Orthodox Liturgical Experience
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Eugenia Constantinou, University of San Diego
Although Revelation is recognized as part of the canon of Scripture by Orthodox Christians, for all practical purposes it remains non-canonical in the Eastern Orthodox Church since it is entirely omitted from the lectionary. Yet its influence in the popular imagination of the East is readily apparent in the Divine Liturgy and other liturgical services in a wide variety of ways, from the reference to God and the altar as “throne,” to depictions of angels whose invisible presence is directly expressed in the hymnology as well as iconography on the walls of churches and on liturgical objects. The Orthodox Divine Liturgy is a consciously theological representation of the Kingdom of Heaven in realized eschatology. Familiar Orthodox liturgical practices, including prostrations, incense, angels and saints, and thrice-holy hymnic praises exclaimed before a throne appear to mimic the throne room scene of Revelation 4. Furthermore, Revelation’s artistic influence and inspiration is evident in the Orthodox Church in many iconographic symbols, titles for Christ, quotations from Revelation on icons, and various depictions of Jesus, such as Christ as the white-haired Ancient of Days.
|
Holy of Holies! The Amazing and Impossible Life of Mary as Told in the Apocrypha of the Christian East
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Eugenia Constantinou, University of San Diego
Popular piety in the ancient Christian East eagerly embraced early oral traditions about the life of the Virgin Mary and expanded to create fanciful apocryphal stories. Some of these apocrypha were ultimately embraced as acceptable for “historical” content while simultaneously rejected from the canon of Scripture and decried as historically false by some early Church fathers. The Orthodox Church is characteristically conservative, refusing to engage in speculative theology and hesitating to venture beyond unspoken but implicit boundaries of theological expression and scripture interpretation. But the apocrypha remain an area for a certain freedom of expression in popular devotions and theology. To this day, the piety of the faithful maintains a delighted and lively fascination with the more remarkable, fanciful and downright impossible details of the stories about the Virgin Mary with no apparent concern for what is historically accurate, possible or even reasonable. Treated as almost quasi-canon in the Orthodox Church, these apocryphal books, which themselves were the fruit of theological interpretation, in turn gave rise to feasts, hymns and iconography which remain very vibrant in the Eastern Christian tradition. Interpretation of Old Testament prophecies led to poetic statements about Mary which were historicized in the apocrypha, and by turn inspiring centuries old hymnology and iconography. Orthodox iconography not only depicts apocryphal stories about Mary but, more importantly, this iconography also conveys theological meaning. Furthermore, even though both the Catholic and Orthodox traditions apparently accept as historically accurate certain details which are found in the apocrypha, specific features in Orthodox iconography reveal theological disagreements with Catholic doctrine about the Virgin Mary, her parents and even the person of Joseph. The interpretive interplay between piety, theology, scripture, apocrypha, iconography and hymnology in the Christian East has resulted in an amazing - and even impossible - “life” of the Virgin Mary.
|
Riding Feminist Waves: Jael in the 20th and 21st Century
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Colleen Conway, Seton Hall University
The paper will examine the use and influence of the figure of Jael from Judges 4-5 in first, second and third wave feminism as expressed through the literary arts. The focus will be on the treatment of Jael’s violent act. In second wave feminist fiction, the appropriation of Jael’s violence takes a distinctive turn. Unlike earlier depictions of Jael, fiction writers in the 1970s and 1980s situate the violence of Jael in the context of violence done to her, an element that is absent in first wave feminist appropriations. In novels by Johanna Russ (The Female Man) and Aritha van Herk (The Tent Peg), Jael responds to the threat of rape. In Sara Maitland's work (Daughter of Jerusalem), there is an implied history of violence against Jael and women in general that drives Jael to an act of vengeance. Compared to earlier mixed assessments of Jael by first wave feminists, these second wave feminists all find something to admire in the biblical figure. All three authors find in Jael a woman who can be put to work for the cause of women’s liberation. In third wave feminist readings of Jael, gender identity rather than violence becomes the primary focus. The figure is again seen as a resource, but now one that represents gender instability. Third wave feminists view Jael as a transitional subject, one points the way toward a queer understanding of bodies and desire.
|
An Evaluation of Ehud as Revealed by the Narrative Appraisal Method
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Mary Conway, McMaster Divinity College
An Evaluation of Ehud as Revealed by the Narrative Appraisal Method
|
Punk Rock Paul: The Cross as a ‘Dumb’ Symbol in Comics and Paul’s Epistles
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Elizabeth Rae Coody, University of Denver and Iliff School of Theology
When choosing their look and style, punks in 1970s Britain made sure to chose ironically self-abasing and sordid objects to decorate themselves: swear words, lavatory chains, bin-liners, tampons, cheap fabrics, ‘nasty’ colors, sexual fetish-wear, and even swastikas. The point of these symbols, even the ones with already established social and political meanings, was to elicit revulsion, hatred, and shock rather than to refer to their accepted value. In his study of punk subculture, Dick Hebdige insists, “the symbol was as ‘dumb’ as the rage it provoked” (Subculture, 1979, 117). The viewers saw both meaning and emotion in these objects, but what I call a “punk sensibility” wished only to evoke emotion.
I argue that hearing a cross—symbol of Roman occupation and cruelty—used to represent the whole of the Jesus-kerygma might be imagined to have provoked something of this rage and revulsion in Paul’s contemporary hearers, but traditional exegesis blunts the irony of the symbol. Comics with a punk sensibility can provide insight into the ways Paul’s use of crosses provokes his addressees; the art and text form of comics is particularly suited to reveal irony in symbols.
In this paper, I will use contemporary comics that use crosses in provocative ways to illustrate the emotional impact crosses can elicit when their meaning is in flux. Last year, webcomic Rob DenBlyker of *Cyanide and Happiness* (2013), earned a facebook lockout for mild cross-related humor. The public reaction to his strip reveals sensitivity to ironic uses of crosses. Garth Ennis uses crosses laden with horrifying violence in his *Crossed* (Avatar 2010) and *Preacher* (Vertigo, 1995-2000) comics with notably little reaction from the church. Ted McKeever’s *Miniature Jesus* (Image, 2013) uses a crucifix to offer silent and ambiguous help to a recovering alcoholic in a violence and demon-filled psychological drama. My paper will juxtapose these comics and their ironic use of crosses with Paul’s use of the Cross in Galatians and 1 Corinthians and assess the role of the biblical text in these pop culture interpretations.
|
The Biblical Hebrew Verbal System in Action: First Samuel 1–2
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
John A. Cook, Asbury Theological Seminary
The tense-aspect-mood system of Biblical Hebrew continues to attract scholarly attention. In this paper I present a case for discrete general meanings for each of the verbal grams and illustrate how specific meanings in the context of 1 Samuel 1–2 are derivable from the respective general meanings based on a strong compositional approach that distinguishes the contribution of the verbal grams from other contextual contributions to the meaning of the passages. Attention is given specifically to the philological reasoning from a the semantic theory to specific instances and the role of the verbal grams in the temporal structure of the passages under discussion.
|
Verbal Valency in Biblical Hebrew and the Case of ML'
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
John A. Cook, Asbury Theological Seminary
Analysis of verbal valency in Biblical Hebrew holds the potential to contribute to a number of aspects of our knowledge of of the ancient language. An approach to valency patterns that appreciates the role of implicit complements provides a means of relating a variety of valency patterns to one another, thereby refining our understanding of the syntax and semantics of the lexeme. This refined understanding may in turn shed light on philological difficulties and questions of language variation in the Hebrew Bible. In this paper I introduce an approach to analyzing verbal valency that takes into account the notion of implicit complements and is illustrated with the case of ML'.
|
The Man on the Patibulum in the Arieti Tomb
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
John Granger Cook, LaGrange College
In 1875 a tomb was discovered in Rome that contained five frescoes. One of them depicts a man attached to a horizontal bar. Interpretive hypotheses of the image have identified the man as: an element of a pompa funebris (funeral procession); an element of a voyage to the Underworld; a telamon; or part of a triumphal procession. Some have identified the tortured man as the crucified Regulus. The horizontal bar to which he is bound by a fetter is best described as a patibulum. This is confirmed by the ancient usage of the term including its occurrence in the lex Puteolana, a law regulating crucifixion during the Augustan era. Comparisons of the image with Andromeda exposed on a patibulum (an Etruscan cista), the crucified individual in taberna 5 of Puteoli (Alkimilla), the Palatine graffito, and the Pereire gem are relevant to the interpretation of the Arieti fresco. The research has implications for the understanding of John 19:17.
|
Will the Real "Faithful Priest" Please Stand Up: Priesthoods in the Deuteronomistic History
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Stephen L. Cook, Virginia Theological Seminary
God's challenge to Eli that he will replace him with a "faithful priest" immediately raises the problem of differing priesthoods within the Deuteronomistic History. The History itself suggests differing interpretations of the faithful priest's identity. If Levites had a central role in the History's composition, would they really have understood Zadok, the founder of a rival priesthood, as the figure in question? Answering such questions begins to clarify the place of Levites, Aaronides, and Zadokites in the DTR historical work.
|
Babylonian and Judean Philology and Epistemology
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Jeffrey L. Cooley, Boston College
Historically, epistemology in the Hebrew Bible has received the most attention from biblical scholars focusing on the wisdom tradition, or from theologians and philosophers. These perspectives, to be sure, possess their own individual merits. Nonetheless, they have rarely concentrated on the topic of epistemology from the viewpoint of the sociology of knowledge of scholarly cultures. This latter outlook has long been employed by science historians, e.g., Thomas Kuhn (The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, 1962). Within that vein more recently, scholars such as Karin Knorr Cetina (Epistemic Cultures, 1999) have highlighted how specific scholarly cultures have specific epistemologies.
Such an approach, I maintain, provides a powerful heuristic for understanding how the professional scribal circles in both ancient Judah and Mesopotamia functioned. We know a great deal, of course, about the practices and conventions (both mental and instrumental) that defined Babylonian scribal culture, and thus the sociological models developed to understand epistemology in modern learned cultures has already begun to be applied to Babylonian scribalism. To be sure, we know less about the specifics of Judean scribal culture, but we do know that the Hebrew Bible itself is a product of it.
In this paper, then, I will discuss how the problem of epistemology within the biblical text reflects the distinctive knowledge culture of Judean scribes. In both Mesopotamian and Judean scribal circles, knowledge could be revealed by the gods and handed down with the authority of previous generations of scribes. But it could also be uncovered by learned means of textual exegesis. Thus, written language served as a particular medium through which acceptable knowledge was not only received and distributed, but also discovered and created.
|
"Land Shall Not Be Sold beyond Reclaim": Collective Responsibility and Usufruct in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Poverty in the Biblical World
Matthew J.M. Coomber, Saint Ambrose University
This paper offers an exploration of how the Hebrew Bible's collectivist and inalienable approaches to land management—as addressed in Torah, the Deuteronomistic History, and the Prophets—offered a viable approach to a community’s well-being, while also mitigating the risks of social stratification and people falling into perpetual poverty. The focus will then contrast these ideals with the United States' individualistic culture and biblical interpretations to develop new understandings of how the Bible might address poverty through communal action.
|
The Sons of Moses in Critical and Traditional Jewish Commentary
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Alan Cooper, Jewish Theological Seminary of America
There are three narrative fragments in Exodus that mention Moses’ marriage and offspring: 2:21-22; 4:20, 24-25; and 18:1-7, respectively. The disparate fragments pose critical problems of chronology, consistency and coherence that must be addressed. In addition to raising critical issues of composition, they engender provocative questions including: How could Moses marry a Midianite woman—daughter of a priest, no less? Why did he fail to circumcise his son prior to his departure from Midian? And, how is it that Zipporah embarks for Egypt with Moses in chapter 4 but turns up in Midian in chapter 18? Traditional Jewish commentary harmonizes and fills gaps as necessary, supplying the coherence that the biblical texts lack, and typically offering apologetic answers to difficult questions. For example, Zipporah converted prior to marriage; Moses failed to circumcise his son because the operation might endanger an infant embarking on an arduous journey. Alongside that approach, however, there is a provocative alternative, based on a brief passage in the Mekhilta that finds more elaborate expression in Spanish commentary of the 14th-16th centuries. In this alternative account, not only did Zipporah remain non-Jewish, but because of an agreement between Moses and Jethro, she intended to raise a non-Jewish (and hence uncircumcised) son. The goals of this paper are to describe the development of this alternative line of interpretation, to explore its social context(s), and assess its value in relation to critical commentary.
|
Levantine El and the Question of God Mergers: El and Milkom in the Ammonite Onomasticon
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
Collin Cornell, Emory University
LBA Syrian evidence from Ugarit has played a decisive role in scholarly reconstructions of the IA Levantine god El. Mainstream accounts of Israelite religion rely on the Syrian profile of El to posit the merger of El with Yahweh; research on Ammonite religion sometimes proposes a comparable merger of El with Milkom. However, because of temporal and cultural remove, this paper recuses the Ugaritic evidence and reopens the question of the identity of IA Levantine El. I argue that the Ammonite onomasticon provides the most reliable index available to this god’s IA profile. After criticizing the existing onomastic taxonomies of Kent Jackson and Jeanene Fowler, I draw on prototype theory to produce a new and more precise classification. The body of the paper then makes a systematic survey of the Ammonite El onomasticon and finds that nothing more specific can be claimed about El than that he was a Levantine god: with benevolent, exalted, and destructive aspects, as well as astral associations. This paper also surveys the Ammonite Milkom onomasticon to compare against the profile of El. In the end, Milkom names show only that Milkom shared benevolent and astral properties with other Levantine gods. I consequently conclude that common scholarly claims about IA mergers of El with other gods such Milkom or Yahweh exceed evidential warrant – and should be abandoned.
|
Magic, Necromancy, and Theurgy in the Pseudo-Clementines
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Dominique Cote, Université d'Ottawa - University of Ottawa
It is generally accepted that the Pseudo-Clementines should be read as a Jewish-Christian text. They certainly have a word to say on the issue of defining Jewish-Christianity in Late Antiquity, but the literary form adopted by the authors, the Greek novel, the contents of many discussions between Peter and Simon, and the Pseudo-Clementines main plot (the conversion of the “pagan” Clement), tell us that the greatest threat the authors had to face concerning religious identity was not Judaism but Hellenism. In terms of the narrative, the main opponent of the Apostle Peter is Simon Magus, who represents, in a way and amongst other things, Greek culture. In the Pseudo-Clementines, Simon Magus is not only the Samaritan magician known since Irenaeus as the Father of all heresies, he is also described, exactly like Peter, as some sort of a Greek philosopher endowed with supernatural power. Unlike Peter’s ability to perform miracles, Simon’s power to accomplish prodigies has nothing divine as it comes from the practice of necromancy. The magician is said to have murdered a child and separated the child’s soul from his body in order to use this soul as his assistant for any exhibition of power (Hom. 2, 26).
In this paper I shall suggest that the necromancy’s episode in the Pseudo-Clementines should be understood in the light of another similar episode of necromancy and murdering of children reported by Gregory of Nazianzus about the Emperor Julian (Or. IV, 92; V, 31). Since the accusation made by Gregory is probably a way of attacking the theurgic rites performed among Neoplatonists like Julian, I shall also suggest that Simon Magus’ necromancy in the Pseudo-Clementines might be a manner of dealing with Neoplatonists and theurgy as well, in a context (4th century AD) where magic and theurgy are getting increasingly repressed after the imperial administration became Christian.
|
First and Second Timothy and Titus: Culture Clash and Troubling Transition from Private to Public "Ecclesia"
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Wendy Cotter, Loyola University of Chicago
The three main issues that control 1 and 2 Timothy and Titus, heresies, organizational structure and ideals of conduct, appear in a scattered manner, suggesting repeated thoughts of concern for these necessary areas of control. These counsels give evidence of a shift occuring in the community/ies from that of a more informal social gathering with easy interchange appropriate and natural in the private venues in which Christians were obliged to meet, to a far more structured organization, much more in keeping with the formal dignified collegia known in the city. The specific directions concerning conduct suggest that the expectations of propriety typical of the Hellenistic East are trying to replace the easy familiarity of Roman culture, where heterosexual conversations and social interchange were quite proper and indeed expected in a friendly family style meeting fostered by the private venue of a family home. 1 and 2 Timothy and Titus, indicate that authority was needed for this transition, the authority of Paul himself, to demand these formal structures and ideals of behavior appropriate to the character of an 'ecclesia' , a public and political meeting of the citizens of heaven, albeit. in a private venue.
|
Retrospective Patterning in Isaiah 1–33
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Blake Couey, Gustavus Adolphus College
According to the literary critic Barbara Herrnstein Smith, readers or hearers continually form new impressions of a poem’s meaning as they experience its performance. These impressions give rise to certain expectations for how the poem will develop. When their initial hunches are frustrated or contradicted by the unfolding poem, the readers or hearers must both adjust their subsequent expectations and reinterpret earlier lines of the poem accordingly. Smith calls this ongoing process “retrospective patterning” (Smith, Poetic Closure: A Study of How Poems End [Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1968], 10–14). In this paper, I discuss several examples of this phenomenon in Isaiah 1–33, including Isa 1:9–10; 5:29; 29:4–5; and others. Poems in these chapters frequently prompt retrospective patterning, which often entails the nearly total reversal of earlier expectations, especially in contexts of judgment and deliverance. These rhetorical effects are achieved through a number of different literary strategies, such as syntactic and morphological parallelism, paronomasia, semantic ambiguity, or novel uses of familiar language. The frequency of retrospective patterning in Isaiah 1–33 has a number of important poetic effects. Minimally, it increases the audience’s interest in a poem and thus sustains their attention throughout its performance. At the same time, however, it destabilizes their confidence in their own understanding of the poem and the world the poem depicts; indeed, it threatens to destabilize the possibility of meaning itself. Finally, it mimics and reinforces one of the central theological claims of these chapters—namely, that YHWH has a divine plan for the kingdoms of the ancient Near East that is shocking, unpredictable, and unopposable.
|
Born to Be Wild? Jesus in the Infancy Gospel of Thomas
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
J.R.C. Cousland, University of British Columbia
Recent examinations of the Infancy Gospel of Thomas (IGT) have focused at length on the need for the gospel to be interpreted in light of contemporary accounts of children. Reidar Aasgaard, Tony Burke, and Chris Frilingos among others have all emphasized the need for social-historical contexts to make sense of the narrative, particularly of Jesus’ violent and petulant behavior. While not disputing the importance of such contextualizing, I will argue that Jesus’ arrogance is better explained as a literary construct that is reliant on the Homeric Hymns (especially that of Hermes). The Greco-Roman gods were often portrayed as infantile in their pettiness and narcissism(!), and quick to punish any acts of outrage (hubris) against their persons with divine retribution (nemesis). The infant Jesus manifests these very bsame traits. Paradoxically, however, he also displays some of the divine attributes that characterize Jesus in the Gospel of John (such as pre-existence), and it is the fusion of these two literary models (John and the Homeric Hymn to Hermes) that results in the divine being that is the infant Jesus in the IGT. Of course, Jesus is portrayed as a human infant as well—hence the ongoing need for contextualizing studies—but the fundamental emphasis of the Infancy gospel is on Jesus as a divine figure.
|
Scripture Speaks: The Personification of Scripture as Interpretive Authority in Paul and the School of Rabbi Ishmael
Program Unit: Paul within Judaism
Michael Cover, Valparaiso University
In his important study of the exegetical method of the School of Rabbi Ishmael, Scripture as Logos (2004), Azzan Yadin pinpoints a previously underappreciated characteristic of this school of tannaitic midrash: the notion that the personified Scripture (ha-katuv)—in contradistinction to the personified Torah (ha-torah)—interprets itself. In short, “Scripture speaks” (maggid ha-katuv, ha-katuv medabber). This exegetical phenomenon, Yadin argues, finds an important counterpart in the scriptural exegesis of 4QMMT and Clement of Alexandria—particularly in the latter’s hypostasized Logos. While such connections are plausible, Yadin leaves largely unexplored a more intuitive lexical and exegetical parallel in the New Testament: the personification of grafe as an interpretive authority in the letters of Paul. Using Yadin’s discussion as a springboard, this paper will study the personifications of grafe and nomos in the Pauline corpus, focusing particularly on the formula legei he grafe in Galatians, Romans, and 1 Timothy. While Paul’s use of the personified Scripture in Galatians and Romans does not map exactly onto the Ishmaelian paradigm, Scripture functions similarly as an exegete in both corpora. This suggests not only that Paul stands as an important predecessor to the Ishmaelian practice, but also that studying the Rabbi Ishmael midrashim offers a new window into Pauline biblical exegesis and Paul’s construction of interpretive authority.
|
Rhetoric, Theology, and Antiochene Exegesis in the Armenian Version of Lamentations
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Peter Cowe, University of California-Los Angeles
This paper seeks to examine the Armenian version of this book within the tradition of reading and interpreting scripture in the eastern Mediterranean world of Late Antiquity in terms of the historical, literary, and theological context out of which it emerged. These issues are of particular moment for an understanding of the book of Lamentations since the genre it represents, that of the city lament, is already attested in Sumerian culture from the third millennium BCE, while the dramatic setting it sketches of the city lamenting its demise as a widow mourning the loss of her children becomes standard within the later Armenian tradition from the history of Movses Xorenac‘i who initiates the trope of invoking Jeremiah’s assistance in implementing his task.
Similarly, it is important to underscore the literary creativity of the translator as linguist, stylist, and interpreter. Clearly, the latter was not operating in a vacuum, but possessed a training not only in the grammar of the base and target languages but also in rhetoric and theology that informed his undertaking. Moreover, the translation process took place in an era of unprecedented interchange between the Roman and Persian spheres due to the rapport of Yazdgard I and Theodosius 1, which facilitated various political and religious cross-border contacts. Consequently, several factors indicate the initial Armenian translators’ intellectual genealogy derives from the School of Antioch of the 4th-5th centuries. Thus, with regard to the early stratum of the Armenian version of Lamentations, I would like to propose that the parallels to many of its literary and theological proclivities found in Theodoret’s commentary on the first four chapters of the work are to be interpreted in terms of joint dependence on earlier Antiochene traditions represented first in the Armenian version and some years later in Theodoret’s opus. The paper will present each of these tendencies in order and illustrate them with specific textual examples.
|
The Text of Old Greek Job: A History of Its Transmission
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Claude Cox, McMaster Divinity College
This paper traces the transmission of the text of OG Job from the time of its translation, through early corruptions, its earliest textual witnesses, revisions toward the Hebrew; the recensions of Origen and Lucian; the subversions, with particular attention to the Armenian; the great uncial manuscripts and medieval miniscule witnesses; then printed editions, down to Ziegler's eclectic text (1982).
|
Being Seen: Toward a Phenomenology of Parable
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Kendall Cox, University of Virginia
My proposal is for your second call, concerning “New Philosophical Perspectives,” or “the potential and impact of new developments in philosophical thought and critical theory on biblical studies and biblical texts.”
In my paper I, first, develop a “phenomenology of parable” that gathers together and clarifies some of the central claims of contemporary parable and metaphor theory in the context of New Testament scholarship. What I am interested in, here, is the way parabolic language can enact, through indirection and disorientation, a reorientation of vision on behalf of its readers. Much twentieth century biblical parable scholarship bears vestiges (often unwittingly) of a vocabulary that derives from the philosopher Edmund Husserl—as well as Martin Heidegger, Maurice Merleau-Ponty, Paul Ricoeur, and Jean-Luc Marion after him. Retracing this path, I suggest the phenomenological language of epoche and reduction helps us account for the way the parabolic form functions.
Second, my paper includes a close phenomenological reading of the Parable of the Prodigal Son that uncovers an overlooked interpretive trajectory of the parable, giving special attention to the way it deconstructs ordinary power relations between fathers and sons (as well as imagined power relations between God and humans). My reading runs counter to prevailing “two sons” interpretations by highlighting a different focal actuality: the embracing watchfulness of the father as contrasted with the servile self-perception of both sons. In an emblematic way, this parable brackets the logic of the everyday, inverts ordinary intentionality, and leads the reader back to an experience not only of seeing but of being seen otherwise.
While phenomenological reading is a nascent field, and much phenomenology can appear immune to socio-political concerns, it is a valuable resource for ideological criticism because it offers us certain techniques for recognizing, evaluating, and “purging” the constructed gaze through which we see the world.
|
Being Found Fighting against God: Luke's Gamaliel and Josephus on Human Responses to Divine Providence
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Kylie Crabbe, University of Oxford
This paper deals with two passages in which characters caution listeners against fighting God, the Jewish War (JW) 5.362-419 and Acts 5:12-42, in order to explore what these passages reveal about the writers’ understandings of divine and human action in history. In the first passage, Josephus stands as a character in his own narrative and, in light of his revelation that the war represents God’s punishment by means of the Romans, passionately exhorts his fellow people to repent – to God and to Rome. In the second, following the arrest of the apostles Gamaliel advises the Sanhedrin against action, reasoning that movements that do not enjoy divine support die out naturally, while those that do cannot be stopped.
As a speech attributed to the implied author’s own character, the rhetorical frame of Josephus’s speech can be dealt with more quickly, however interpretation of Gamaliel’s voice in Acts has proven more contentious. I argue that the use of irony reveals that the implied author shares Gamaliel’s views in relation to God’s providence, while simultaneously exposing Gamaliel’s response as inadequate. Thus, both the JW and Acts affirm divine providence as an unstoppable force, but in other ways make allowances for human action. Significantly, I argue, the writers present the human choice to align oneself with, or to oppose, divine providence as having eschatological consequences. Indeed, although they place stress differently on divine judgement and invitation, both the JW and Acts present divine and human action in history in ways which reveal their understandings of the telos of that history.
Therefore, after outlining some relevant considerations of literary convention in Hellenistic historiography, I will discuss the passages from the JW and Acts in turn, with a particular focus on the rhetorical function of Gamaliel’s statement in the narrative of Acts. Finally, I will comment on the implications for eschatology in Josephus and Luke/Acts.
|
Of Women, Vessels, and Journeys: Zech 5:5–11 as Elimination Ritual
Program Unit: Israelite Religion in Its Ancient Context
Isabel Cranz, University of Pennsylvania
Zechariah 5:5-11 consists of a curious scenario: a woman in a measuring container is identified as wickedness and dispatched to the land of Shinar where she will be placed on a pedestal. In the past, scholars have often treated this vision as a form of visualized ritual by comparing it to the dispatch of the scapegoat in Leviticus 16 and the Hittite Myth of Telepinu. This paper will further explore the ritual elements of the vision by using Assyro-Babylonian exorcisms as comparative material. Of particular interest are rituals protecting against ghosts and demons in which a figurine is placed in a vessel and sent to the underworld by burial (CT 23.19-21; BAM 323; W 23287). The comparison will illustrate how ritual elements are adapted to fit the scope of the vision which inevitably alters the internal relations between participants, recipients, actors and audiences. On a larger scale, these observations suggest that the operational mode of rituals is modified by the framework in which they appear.
|
The Diatessaron, Canonical, or Non-canonical? Rereading the Dura Fragment
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Matthew R. Crawford, University of Durham
Among those texts which vied for a position as authoritative Scripture, but were eventually rejected by ecclesiastical authorities, was the so-called Diatessaron of Tatian. Having been compiled from the four canonical gospels, Tatian’s work occupies a liminal position between the categories of “canonical” and “apocryphal,” since the majority of its content was common to users of the fourfold gospel, though this content existed in a radically altered form and was tainted by association with a known heretic. In this paper I intend to give a close reading of the only surviving Greek witness to this work, a fragment of parchment found in excavations at Dura-Europos. Dura’s very location as a borderland between Rome and Persia corresponds with the fact that in this outpost garrison city Christians were using a gospel text that would have appeared markedly strange to those in the mainstream of the Christian tradition. Here I want to highlight how the text that can be recovered from the Dura fragment shows Tatian creatively and intelligently combining the text of the four gospels to produce a new narrative of the life of Jesus, choosing to leave out certain elements and to highlight others. Moreover, comparison with the early medieval Arabic gospel harmony and with the Latin Codex Fuldensis illustrates well how later users of Tatian’s work engaged in their own editing of this text in varied attempts to improve it and to bring it into line with the authoritative gospel versions with which they were most familiar. The Dura fragment, therefore, as our oldest extant witness to Tatian’s work, provides a window into the rewriting of canonical Scripture in the second century, and how this attempt was further received by later generations of Christians.
|
The Nature and Literary Situation of the “Untitled Text” of the Bruce Codex
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Eric Crégehur, Université Laval
Preserved in a papyrus manuscript generally dated of the fourth century, the Coptic Gnostic treatise known as “Untitled Text” of the Bruce Codex (Bodleian Library MS Bruce 96) consists of a series of hymns addressed to a metaphysical Primordial Principle. The “Untitled Text” is usually considered a late witness of the so-called “Platonizing Sethian Gnostic” treatises, a modern category which is represented in the Nag Hammadi library by four tractates, Allogenes (XI,3), Zostrianos (VIII,1), the Three Steles of Seth (VII,5) and Marsanes (X,1). Research on the relationship between Gnosticism and Neoplatonism has seen tremendous progress in the last twenty years, demonstrating the need for scholars interested in Neoplatonic traditions to consider the Gnostic sources. Although it is a significant piece of the “gnosis and philosophy” puzzle, the “Untitled Text” of the Bruce Codex was and is still largely ignored by modern scholarship on the subject. By analyzing the nature and literary situation of this neglected treatise, this paper will attempt the better understand its place within the “Platonizing Sethian” category.
|
The Temple of Joel 4:18-21 (MT): From Suffer to Life-Giver
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Lacy K. Crocker, Baylor University
Central to the book of Joel is the place of the temple, as seen by the cultic activity of lamenting, fasting, and prayer. The temple suffers as the people suffer, experiencing a deprivation of offerings and a loss of joy. The temple, however, transforms desolation into fertility and it establishes justice for the people of Judah in Joel 4:18-21 (MT). This essay will utilize a comparative methodology focusing on temple ideology found in the Gudea Cylinders and the Baal Cycle, which will demonstrate that fertility and protection motifs are linked as provisions from the temple in the ANE and in Joel’s conclusion. The close association of the temple with fertility and protection motifs will set the stage for a detailed examination of the cultic references in Joel that will highlight the reversal from judgment to blessing (from Judah’s perspective) in Joel’s conclusion, while also showing the centrality of the temple and the unity of the conclusion with the rest of Joel, especially Joel 1-2. I will argue that Joel 4:18-21 (MT) serves to communicate the eschatological reversal that will take place in Judah with the restoration of an ideal temple that provides Edenic abundance, perfect security, and joy for the people of the LORD.
|
"What Have You Done for Me Lately?" Patronage and Conversion in the Ancient Mediterranean
Program Unit: Society for Ancient Mediterranean Religions
Zeba Crook, Carleton University
"'What Have You Done For Me Lately?': Patronage and Conversion in the Ancient Mediterranean."
|
Enhancing Undergraduate Students’ Understanding and Appreciation for Primary Texts
Program Unit: Wabash Center for Teaching and Learning in Theology and Religion
Lynne Cropper, University of Iowa
Often times the primary texts used in Religious Studies research are difficult to understand or comprehend. This practical teaching tactic facilitates student engagement with, and appreciation of primary texts before they begin to analyze them. It also helps the students internalize the implicit and explicit messages of the texts studied.
|
History and Myth in Pullman’s Jesus/Christ Novel
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
James Crossley, University of Sheffield
Philip Pullman’s novel The Good Man Jesus and the Scoundrel Christ (2010) does not in any way attempt to construe a historical figure. In spite of this the book raises the issue of the relationship between history and myth, here in the guise of a fictional story of Jesus and his twin brother Christ. The relationship between history and myth has also been one of the major themes in the quest for the historical Jesus. From this angle Pullman’s novel is analyzed both in relation to wider cultural trends and to historical Jesus scholarship.
|
Forced Migration in the Deuteronomistic History and Comparative Empire Theory
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
Brad Crowell, Drake University
The forced migration of major portions of the ancient Israelite and Judean populations by the empires of the Iron Age are a significant theme within the Deuteronomistic History. The debates about these forced migrations, often called exiles, revolve around archaeological findings and demographic realities of the time. This paper will use comparative empire data along with related anthropological theory to explore the role of empires in the forced demographic shifts in Iron Age Israel and Judah.
|
When Bhabha Meets Solomon: Postcolonial Theory and the Historiography of Ancient Israel and Judah
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Brad Crowell, Drake University
Postcolonial analysis has been a part of biblical studies for nearly twenty years, but it has yet to significantly impact the study of the history of ancient Israel and Judah. Postcolonial theory is now being employed in several other historical disciplines, especially in contexts that were significantly impacted by expansive empires. When Bhabha meets Solomon will use the postcolonial theories of mimicry and the construction of a pre-imperial golden age to analyze the Deuteronomistic presentation of Solomon’s empire and explore how the colonized context of the writers influenced their presentation of the United Kingdom.
|
Respondent: Religious Experience in Qumran
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Thomas Csordas, University of California, San Diego
Dr. Csordas, an anthropologist noted for his early, enduring, and influential work on embodiment and religion, will respond to the five papers presented by the panel.
|
The Learned Scribes of Proverbs and Their Relations to Power and 'the Poor'
Program Unit: Economics in the Biblical World
Elizabeth Currier, University of Wisconsin-Madison
The learned scribes responsible for the book of Proverbs include numerous sayings about economic issues in their collections. Sayings that revolve around diligence/sloth, gift giving, surety arrangements, governmental and judicial functions/functionaries and relatedly, justice/injustice, and of course, wealth/poverty and the rich/the poor all touch on economic states and relations. I discuss the interactions between mentions of items associated with wealth (a large vocabulary), the state of poverty (N of yrš, ma?sor, rêyš), individuals described as rich (‘ašîyr), and individuals described as poor (’ebyown, dal, ‘anaw/‘anîy, raš) in this paper. I also explore interests apparent in these statements and how the social-economic position of its scribal producers may have affected what they say about wealth/poverty and the rich/the poor. The scribes who produced Proverbs were scholarly retainers with opportunities to prosper socially and economically to some degree. Their pedagogical interest is to guide human behavior toward wisdom, righteousness, diligence, restraint, and success/prosperity, and at the same time, away from the antitheses of these. They also surely had interests bound up with the obligations of their profession (to transmit cultural traditions) and with the political-economic-religious relations that profession entailed. We must use a disciplined imagination to conceive their relation to power and to “the poor” on the basis of what they say about kings and other officials in addition to what they say about the rich and the poor. We must also be clear about differences between sayings that mention wealth/poverty and those that mention the rich/the poor, while taking pains continuously to relate them to one another. The producers of Proverbs often speak of inanimate objects and states of being associated with wealth and poverty within very different frames of reference than those within which they portray the rich and the poor, animate (if didactically and stereotypically constructed) individuals. As didactic constructions, the relations between these “individuals” constitute social-economic worlds the producers of Proverbs want to promote and to critique. I offer in this paper a description of these social-economic worlds, and I attempt to situate the scribes responsible for Proverbs within them on the basis of their statements about economic issues and the interests apparent in what they say about wealth/poverty and the rich/the poor.
|
Tours of Heaven in Light of the Neuroscientific Study of Religious Experience
Program Unit: Cognitive Science Approaches to the Biblical World
Istvan Czachesz, University of Heidelberg
In this paper I will interact with two central chapters of Patrick McNamara’s “The Neuroscience of Religious Experience”, that is, chapters five and six that deal with the neurology and neurochemistry of religiosity. Drawing on McNamara's conclusions in these chapters, I will turn to early Christian apocalyptic texts that describe tours of heaven and ask the question of how far the available neuroscientific evidence and models can help us make sense of these reports. A perennial question in the research of such literature is whether there is any actual religious experience behind the accounts. I will argue that the best approach is one that combines knowledge about the neurological bases of religious experience, the role of tradition and beliefs shaping experience at subconscious and conscious levels, and the different ways in which memory and textual transmission influence the preserved forms of the seer’s story.
|
Cognitive Science and Network Theory in the Study of Early Christian Origins
Program Unit: Redescribing Christian Origins
Istvan Czachesz, Ruprecht-Karls-Universität Heidelberg
In this paper I will argue that network theory can complement cognitive science approaches to create models that explain data about early Christianity. In recent years, network theory has grown into a multidisciplinary research area and produced groundbreaking insights about social structures, ecosystems, the internet, physical processes, and textual data, among others. In showing how network models explain the spread of early Christianity, I will focus on the emergence of cognitively optimal and otherwise successful ideas and behaviors and their dynamical interaction with social network structures that both facilitate the formation of such beliefs and are shaped by them.
|
Interpreting Psalm 121 from the Perspective of Yoruba Understanding of Metaphysical Evil
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Adekunle O. Dada, University of Ibadan
Psalm 121 is one of the popular Psalms in contemporary Africa where physical and metaphysical insecurities are ever-present threats. It has been differently interpreted and used. In its original setting, the Psalm is classified as one of the pilgrim Psalms. It was subsequently used in the history of its interpretation to enhance physical security. However, in my own interpretation of the text I will like to contextually ground it in the Yoruba (African) cultural and metaphysical realities. For example, vs. 6 “the sun will not harm you by day, nor the moon by night” when read from the Yoruba metaphysical realities most probably indicates that the enemies that the Psalmist was dealing with were not just physical in character they could also be metaphysical or malevolent diabolical forces. Approaching the text from solely Western epistemological perspectives may not make the meaning of the text relevant in the African context. This is because from the Western perspective, reality is basically limited to things that can be subjected to objective parameters of verifiability. This paper therefore will establish the position that the enemies the Psalmist encountered in this text, when read from the Yoruba context are not only physical entities but mystical and unseen diabolical forces which are said to be responsible for much of the calamities and crises in the world. The Yoruba are one of the largest homogeneous ethnic groups and found mainly in Southwestern Nigeria and pockets of them are found in North Central Nigeria, Benin Republic, Togo, Cuba and Brazil.
|
An Eco-hermeneutical Reading of the Fourth Gospel: Problems and Possibilities
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Margaret Daly-Denton, Trinity College Dublin
An eco-hermeneutical reading of the Fourth Gospel must confront certain problems: the pervasive dualism showing through in flesh/spirit, above/below, heavenly/earthly antitheses; the “otherworldliness” of the Johannine Jesus; his apparent disengagement with ethical issues like justice, care for the poor, detachment from greed, which an ecological reading might extend beyond human concerns to those affecting the wider Earth community. There are great possibilities, however: in the Evangelist’s claim that in Jesus God’s creative “Word” has become flesh with all its implications of materiality and interconnectedness with other life on Earth; in the revelatory role the author assigns to natural phenomena such as water and light; in the entwining of the story’s chronology around the daily and seasonal rhythms of nature; in the Johannine teaching that the “life of the aeon” (zoe aionios), the flourishing God intends for all creation, that was expected when a new age would dawn, is not actually some future other-worldly existence, but a new way of living on Earth here and now, in harmony with the energy sustaining the creation now embodied in Jesus (1:14).
A reading from an ecological perspective is done in the reader’s situation: in this case, in the one-third world that indulges in the most voracious life style the Earth has ever been expected to provide for. Our awareness of our planet’s predicament becomes a “hermeneutical lens” enabling us to see things in the text that we never noticed before. We look out for the impact of socio-economic realities on nature in the world of the narrative and in the author’s and the intended audience’s world. Alert for parallels with current environmental concerns, we purposefully allow the ecology of our own world to affect our reading. We focus on features of the natural world that figure in the gospel, foregrounding them, instead of regarding them as mere “props” or “husks” that can be discarded once their Christological import has been grasped. Thus we try to change our anthropocentric reading habits into more Earth-conscious approaches, showing Earth the regard that we are trying to develop in our everyday lives.
A grain of wheat must first die if it is to bear fruit (12:24). Perhaps this Johannine principle, based on Jesus’ own observation of nature, might inspire his disciples to be pastoral people, carers who are prepared to do some “dying” for the sake of the flourishing of creation, rather than predatory thieves who only exploit and destroy.
|
Deciphering Religious Dress in Roman North Africa: Tertullian on the Clothing of Christians and Rival Cults
Program Unit: Inventing Christianity: Apostolic Fathers, Apologists, and Martyrs
Carly Daniel-Hughes, Concordia University - Université Concordia
Dress was a signature part of religious life in the Roman world. Historians have begun to consider how dressing as well as undressing figured in initiation ceremonies across religious communities in antiquity. But dress could also serve as an indicator of religious affiliation in a variety of cults. Adherents would be put such religious costumes on display in civic processions as well as memorialize them in portraiture and images, all in a effort to establish their place in civic life. Did Christians likewise utilize dress to make themselves visible and recognizable in this context? This paper considers the writings of Tertullian of Carthage as evidence for how, in Roman North Africa, Christians might have utilized their dress (both discursively and performatively) in this way. While scholars have examined Tertullian’s vestimentary advice with regard to gender and sexuality, philosophical virtue, and to a lesser degree, ethnicity, we have paid less attention to his comments in light of the garb of rival religious communities in Carthage and its vicinity. A consideration of cultic clothing associated with Asclepius, Ceres, and Mithras (which feature in Tertullian’s writings) illuminate the complexity of constructing a distinguishable Christian look. In fact, Tertullian’s advice on dress could find his Christian audience in garb that might also identify them with these groups. This paper will consider what we know about the clothing of these communities, as well as their presence in Roman North Africa. It will consider Tertullian’s rhetoric about particular garments (such as laurel crowns, pallia, and white tunics) as attempts to lay claim to certain looks and garments as authentically Christian, and then to promote them to his Christian audience. His goal, it suggests, was to construct recognizable Christian dress that would situate this group advantageously in the civic space of Roman Carthage.
|
"As a Seal upon My Heart": Evaluating Seals as Evidence for Personal Religious Ritual in the Ancient Near East
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Erin Darby, University of Tennessee, Knoxville
Studies of personal religious ritual in the ancient world are impacted by a variety of theoretical positions. One concern is the socio-economic status to which the data belong. Another is the way focusing on personal religion may cloud the ways individuals were constituted by their broader social nexus. Yet a further methodological difficulty is the lack of chronological specificity attributed to personal rituals, which are often assumed to be consistent over large spans of time. Finally, personal religious experience may inadvertently privilege the hypothesized interior sentiments of the practitioner, giving rise to a host of issues, like the extent to which ancient data actually attest to the internal states of the participants, or the possibility that ritual agents act without fully understanding themselves.
In order to demonstrate the way these theoretical concepts impact reconstructions based upon epigraphic and archaeological data, this paper will examine one source often associated with personal religious ritual – seals. Within the study of ancient Near Eastern religion, a host of assumptions have been brought to bear on reconstructions of personal religion based upon seals. These often overlook archaeological context (or lack thereof), socio-economic status, the existence of seal-cutting industries, the ritual functions of seals, and the various parties who might have commissioned seals. In fact, these factors complicate to what extent seals actually provide information about the individuals with whose names they are inscribed and the degree to which seals attest to a separate realm of personal religious experience. After reviewing contemporary theorizing relevant to ancient personal religious ritual, the paper summarizes Iron Age seals from ancient Israel, evaluates prominent interpretations that share a complicated relationship with the aforementioned theoretical challenges, and poses a more theoretically-informed approach to seals that might be applied across a variety of time periods in the Mediterranean and ancient Near East.
|
What Does It Mean to Be ‘Saved’? An African Reading of Ephesians 2
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Daniel K. Darko, Gordon College
The paper examines the soteriology and sociocultural framework of Ephesians 2. It observes conceptual parallels with African conventions to elucidate the multifaceted aspects of the salvific vision usually minimized or overlooked in scholarship. The method of analysis is not ideological (i.e. post-colonial) but social-scientific study grounded in the milieu of the early readership/hearers and exegetical analysis while simultaneously showing the contributions that an African reader brings to our understanding of the concept of salvation in the letter. For example, parallel notions of ethnic stereotyping, kinship, worldview and community in the concept of salvation will unveil some perspectival blinders accompanied by some Western existential and individualistic approach to the text.
|
Everything Old Is New Again: The Parable of Garments and Wineskins (5:36–39) in Luke’s Narrative Discourse on Time
Program Unit: Gospel of Luke
John A. Darr, Boston College
Literary critics have long observed that parables can function as synopses, prolepses, and programmatic passages in gospel narratives. Notably, Mary Ann Tolbert argued persuasively that the brief and highly mnemonic parables of the Sower and the Tenants summarize Mark’s wider narrative and serve continually both to orient his audience and to guide their interpretive efforts (Sowing the Gospel: Mark’s World in Literary-Historical Perspective [Minneapolis: Fortress, 1989]). After a brief survey and evaluation of scholarly contributions in this vein, I argue that Luke uses the parable of Garments and Wineskins to crystallize lessons in the narrower context of the episode of Levi’s call (Luke 5:27-39) and to prepare his audience properly to unpack his upcoming, complex discourse concerning continuity and discontinuity in the unfolding plan of God. Timing is everything when it comes to discerning the times. Yes, “the old is good” (Luke 5:39), but so is the new; and, if mixed, both are distorted.
|
The Origins of the Foundation Stories Genre in the Hebrew Bible and Ancient Eastern Mediterranean
Program Unit:
Guy Darshan, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
This paper examines two types of foundation narrative prevalent in the biblical literature in light of as-yet-undiscussed parallels from ancient Greek and Mediterranean texts. The first type, embodied in the Genesis narratives and Greek genealogical traditions, portrays the founders as leaving a distant land to settle peacefully in a new land. The second is exemplified by the central Hexateuchal theme of the Israelites’ migration to Canaan by dispossessing the native population as well as the Dorian migration traditions. Several factors indicate that the foundation-story genre also became central and foundational in other small kingdoms around the Mediterranean—as indicated, for example, by the Phoenician-Luwian inscriptions referring to bt Mpš/Mopsus and related classical sources. The popularity of the genre in ancient Mediterranean is striking in light of the fact that, while experiencing tribal migrations and wanderings, the great Mesopotamian and Egyptian kingdoms never represented themselves as “immigrants.” It is suggested that this genre may have emerged with the rise of the new, small-scale kingdoms in the Mediterranean basin towards the end of the second millennium B.C.E. The Phoenician and Greek colonization enterprises of the first third of the first millennium B.C.E in particular increased awareness of the Mediterranean states and focused attention on ethnic identity.
|
Episcopal Burials in North African Christianity
Program Unit: Contextualizing North African Christianity
Bradley Daugherty, Vanderbilt University
Episcopal Burials in North African Christianity
|
Even Better Than the Real Thing: The KJV as Icon for British Israelism
Program Unit: Society for Comparative Research on Iconic and Performative Texts
David Dault, Chicago, Illinois
Christianity has always been plagued by a supersessionist impulse. The question of who constitutes the "true Israel" has formed a background not only for Christian-Jewish relations, but for intra-Christian relations in the wake of the Protestant Reformation.
While such disputes have tended to emphasize the theological aspects of the supersessionist question, we can also find a distinct and troubling racialist undercurrent that weaves its way through the history.
One of the most pronounced examples of this racialist impulse is the "British Israel" movement, which claims a direct lineage from the current British royal family to the line of King David. Those making arguments in favor of British Israelism often turn to the existence of the King James Version of the Bible as "proof" of the racial, intellectual, and theological superiority of English-speaking caucasian Europeans. The claim is made that, in this English version, the text actually surpasses the quality and veracity of the Greek and Hebrew predecessors, and offers the most accurate version of God's Word in existence.
This paper will argue that such a claim, which defies not only the accepted tenets of historical criticism, but perhaps reason itself, is evidence that the KJV functions for the adherents of British Israelism as a very distinct type of object. Using the analytic tools developed in the disciplines of Iconic Books and material Scripture, this paper will examine the mechanism by which the King James Version of the Bible subtends this counter-rationalist, hyper-racialized identity politics.
|
Geographies of Otherness: Alterity in Territorial Organization in the Oracles against the Nations
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Steed Vernyl Davidson, Pacific Lutheran Theological Seminary
Proposals to identify a geographical scheme in the oracles against the nations have relied upon territorial organizations that imitate schemes utilized in Egyptian execration texts and other ideas. Most often these proposals offer inadequate explanations both for the ordering of the nations in the respective collections as well as an insufficient answer to the inclusion/exclusion of nations. This paper examines the issue of geography in the oracles against the nations from the perspective of the imagined world that these collections construct. Utilizing the notions of alterity and their applications to geographies, this paper examines the construction of the world outside of the center created for the reader. This construction renders the outside world dangerous, sinful, marked by corruptions, and instances of violence, thereby deploying geography as a tool to construct otherness. By characterizing spaces outside of the center as other, the oracles construct and fill out characteristics about the various nations as well as its people (re)producing traits tied to certain places and by extension people. This paper pays attention to the oracles against the nations as one of the last layers of the Latter Prophets that demonstrate a preoccupation with space. The preoccupation with space requires (re)imagining the world in different ways precisely because of the alterations in the world of the reader. Although the binary constructions of outside/inside or self/other appear simple, the operations of the binaries in the reading of the oracles and their place within the final form of the prophetic books are more complex. The paper considers the implications of (re)imagined geography for articulations of national self-identity and theological negotiations in a changed context.
|
Prophecy in Interfaith Context: Christianity and Islam
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Ellen F. Davis, The Divinity School, Duke University
Two theological themes—the prophets and their relationship with God, and repentance and salvation—provide fruitful ground for exploring points of both commonality and difference between Christianity and Islam. Yet even in their differences, both traditions show strong connections with different strands of the prophetic traditions of the Bible, in both Testaments.
|
Virgin Mary Co-Priest or Not: The Continuing Trend of Redaction and Revision
Program Unit: Maria, Mariamne, Miriam: Rediscovering the Marys
Judith M. Davis, Goshen College
Not until the Georgian Life of the Virgin attributed to the seventh-century Maximus the Confessor do we see Mary depicted as a close companion of Jesus during his ministry. Two hundred years after Maximus, George of Nicomedia and John the Geometrician produced versions that redacted passages that demonstrated Mary’s leadership. The tenth-century edition fashioned by Simeon the Metaphrast eliminated almost everything related to Mary’s active work and that of other women in the early church.
In the twenty-first century, the tradition of redaction and reduction appears to continue with Stephen J. Shoemaker’s recent translation (Yale University Press, 2012). Although Shoemaker consulted Michel Van Esbroeck’s 1986 French translation, he did not use van Esbroeck’s eleventh-century manuscript, the oldest available; instead, he relied upon others, including Jerusalem 108, which van Esbroeck himself said was censored in key scenes. This omission is most poignant at the beginning of the Last Supper scene in a passage that van Esbroeck translated as “she sacrificed herself as the priest and she was sacrificed, she offered and she was offered.” Afterwards, Jesus then sacrificed himself. Later editions of this scene, which van Esbroeck called “censored,” eliminated Mary’s participation by adding masculine indices. Shoemaker’s translation follows these later editions. The trajectory of redaction of the markers of Mary’s priestly authority in early Christian literature is most recently illustrated by Ally Kateusz in her Fall 2013 JFSR article, for which she received the First Prize Elisabeth Schüssler Fiorenza NSA award.
In this paper I contrast additional aspects of Shoemaker’s translation versus van Esbroeck’s. This comparison is made in light of the long tradition of translators who on one hand emphasized Mary’s privilege as Theotókos but on the other hand minimized the depictions of Christian priesthood associated with her.
|
4QJeremiah-a (4Q70): From Anthology to Scripture in the Oldest Known Copy of Jeremiah
Program Unit: Transmission of Traditions in the Second Temple Period
Kipp Davis, Universitetet i Agder
4QJeremiah-a (4Q70) consists of 50 fragments that appear to preserve material from Jer 7:1 to perhaps Jer 26:10, although the extant remains are more clearly confined to Jer 7:28–22:16. This ms. is one of the oldest witnesses to any text from the Hebrew Bible ever discovered, and has been palaeographically dated to the late-third cent. b.c.e. Emanuel Tov edited and published 4QJer-a in DJD 15 (1997), and characterised the text as a "proto-Masoretic" witness to the dynamic textual history of Jeremiah. His reconstructions throughout almost unfailingly follow the MT, but there are several instances in which this appears to be in error, and in which the text seems closer to the LXX. Furthermore, the unique feature in this scroll of an enormous secondary insertion consisting of six full additional lines of the text in the margins distinguishes this copy as an intriguing subject for further study in the textual history of Jeremiah. This paper shall examine in some greater detail one section of this scroll, preserving Jer 9:11–15, which contains a variety of textual variants that do not appear in Tov's edition. Following the presentation of a new reconstruction, an attempt is made to account for the textual variations in these verses, and how they might reflect the scribal character of this text. The implications for the rest of the fragmentary remains of this scroll are significant, especially if it can be demonstrated that 4QJer-a is not necessarily "proto-Masoretic", but rather a considerably more independent or "freeform" witness to the development of the Jeremiah scriptures and their malleability even as late as the second cent. b.c.e.
|
Wrong Word: The Limits of Patriarchy in Post-exilic Israel
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Stacy Davis, Saint Mary's College (Notre Dame)
In her 2013 presidential address, Carol Meyers questioned the application of “patriarchy” to ancient Israel. Knowledge of the biblical world remains limited in a number of areas; however, prophetic texts at least offer a glimpse into the ways in which certain segments of the Israelite population viewed their world. The book of Haggai may be a useful text for an examination of Meyers’ question. As Rosemary Radford Ruether notes, patriarchy means the rule of men, specifically free, adult men, over all other people (women, children, and slaves). Because Meyers has published a significant work on Haggai, placing that earlier work in conversation with her presidential address and feminist theory will challenge Meyers’ challenge of “patriarchy.” Elisabeth Schüssler Fiorenza argues that “kyriarchy,” which expands patriarchy to include the diverse ways in which certain men do (or do not) rule over other women (and men), may be a more appropriate description of the biblical world. Kyriarchy also takes into account the intersectionalities of gender, ethnicity, and social class, and intersectionality remains an indispensable part of feminist theory. Examining Haggai within a feminist theoretical framework will reveal that the word “patriarchy” should be questioned as a descriptor of ancient Israel, not because it perpetuates a myth or “a misplaced preoccupation with biblical androcentrism” (Meyers 1988: 45). The word should be questioned because it may be not be strong enough to describe accurately the gendered hierarchy embedded in post-exilic prophetic language and life.
|
The Covenant Renewal Ceremony of 2 Esd 19–20, Atonement, and the Exclusion of Christian Gentiles
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Kathy Barrett Dawson, Independent Scholar
As demonstrated by Holmgren, Duggan, and Williamson, the covenant renewal ceremony in 2 Esd 19-20 (MT Neh 9-10) conflates the Abrahamic and Mosaic covenants and addresses a postexilic controversy concerning the identity of Abraham’s seed and the exclusion of all others from the temple cult. I will argue that 2 Esdras’ understanding of the covenant, along with the text’s depiction of the people’s voluntary submission to the authority of the “curse of the law” as the proper means of atonement and reconciliation with God, plays an important role in the controversy over the identity of Abraham’s seed as it is recorded in Paul’s Letter to the Galatians and is representational of the growing conflict that resulted in the parting of the ways between Jews and Christians. By alluding to statements in 2 Esd 19-20, Paul shapes his argument in Gal 3-4 to combat the confluence of the Abrahamic and Mosaic covenants and to counter the threatened exclusion (Gal 4:17) of the law-free Galatians. Although Paul quotes Gen 15:6, which indicates that Abraham was considered rectified solely on the basis that he believed God’s word before he was circumcised (Gen 17) or was tested (Gen 22), I contend that Paul’s reference to “the faithful Abraham” (Gal 3:9) is an allusion to the theological reinterpretation of Gen 12 and Gen 15:6 presented in 2 Esd 19:7-8. Additionally, Paul’s discussion of the “curse of the law” is shaped to combat his opponents’ insistence that, just as 2 Esdras 19-20 describes, the law-free Galatians must voluntarily submit to the “curse of the law” in order to be truly reconciled with God. However, by declaring that Christ is the sole seed of Abraham (Gal 3:16) and that the Galatians are in Christ and, therefore, the seed of Abraham (3:28-29), Paul can uphold the covenant with Abraham while insisting that the covenant at Sinai is a separate covenant that enslaves (Gal 4:24). Although the covenant with Abraham obviously included circumcision (Gen 17), Paul can claim that circumcision is unnecessary for the Galatians since they are in Christ, who was born under the law and, therefore, circumcised. While 2 Esd 19:14 claims the Spirit was given to instruct the people in the Mosaic covenant, Paul claims that the Spirit is now the authority for ethical behavior and the proof that the Galatians are reconciled with God without submission to the “curse of the law.”
|
Paratext: Software for Bible Translators—Staying Close to the Cutting Edge
Program Unit: Global Education and Research Technology
Reinier de Blois, United Bible Societies
Since 1997 thousands of Bible translators worldwide have been working with Paratext, a suite of programs, created by the United Bible Societies for Bible Translation staff. In 2011 UBS and the Summer Institute of Linguistics decided to merge Paratext with SIL’s Translation Editor (TE) and continue developing the resulting tool together under the name ParaTExt. Other tools of the suite are Publishing Assistant, Concordance Builder and Names Index Builder, the Digital Bible Library, and the Global Bible Catalogue. Together these programs offer Bible translators, publishers, and archivists a set of tools that cover almost all phases of the Bible Translation lifecycle.
This paper will give a brief history of the development of this tool, followed by the description of the entire suite and the place of each individual tool within the Bible Translation lifecycle. We will also focus on a number of advanced features of the software, such as ParaTExt’s glossing technology, including a number of new features that are currently in development, such as the Master Bible and an online Scripture review tool called ScriptureForge.
|
Apocalyptic as Eschatological Activity
Program Unit:
M. C. de Boer, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam - VU University Amsterdam
*
|
Righteousness/Justice in Paul: A Comparison of Galatians with Romans
Program Unit: Pauline Theology
Martin de Boer, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam - VU University Amsterdam
A discussion of this critical word group, theme, and theological motif in Paul, with particular reference to the often neglected data in Galatians. This will be brought into conversation with the well known data found in Romans.
|
The Economy of Excellence: A Thematic Study of Fadl in the Qur'an
Program Unit: Linguistic, Literary, and Thematic Perspectives on the Qur’anic Corpus (IQSA)
Vanessa De Gifis, Wayne State University
Moral excellence (fadl) is a critical paradigm for early Muslim conceptions of legitimate leadership. The qualities and signs of moral excellence are complex and contested, as Afsaruddin shows in Excellence and Precedence (2002). Examination of the term fadl in the Qur'an can help elucidate early Muslim understandings of the concept and the theological underpinnings of its usage in Muslim socio-political discourse. I undertake a co-textual reading of fadl and its cognates (faddal and tafaddal) in the Qur'an, informed by Izutsu's influential semantic analysis of The Ethico-Religious Concepts in the Qur'an (rev. 2002), in which fadl figures only briefly in a discussion of "God's bounty" (218-9). Operating on the theory that the Qur'an has a harmonious internal logic, I collate verses involving fadl in order to understand them in light of each other. Comparative analysis of relevant verses throughout the Qur'anic corpus reveals a coherent, if multivalent, concept of fadl that correlates divine grace, moral excellence, and social order. Fadl in the Qur'an usually signifies God's bounty or "grace," which He bestows gratuitously upon whom He wills (e.g. 3:73) as revelation (e.g. 2:105), worldly wealth (e.g. 24:22, with fadl meaning economic "surplus"), kingship and wisdom (e.g. 2:251), and life itself (e.g. 2:243). His grace establishes hierarchal degrees of "excellence" in the social order (e.g. 17:21): to check people by means of each other (2:251), and to test their gratitude (e.g. 2:243, 89:15-16). God exhorts recipients of His fadl to show gratitude through acts of socio-economic charity (e.g. 16:72, 24:22), and He gives preference (faddal) to those who expend their wealth and lives for Him (e.g. 4:95). Correlations between divine grace, moral excellence, and social order in the Qur'anic field of fadl suggest similar correlations in the use of the term in debates over legitimate leadership. God bestows virtues befitting leadership upon whomever He wills. The gratuitous nature of His bounty makes its recipient incur a sacred debt and duty to expend his wealth (material, intellectual, etc.) in the service of others. Thus leadership itself becomes an act of charity to which one well endowed is exhorted as a moral duty. The social order thus implicates a blessed leader duty-bound as an agent of God's grace and will on earth, and a community of subjects duty-bound to obedience as a sign of gratitude for the blessing of excellent (afdal) leadership.
|
Images along the Sacred Bridge: The Northern Influence on Iron Age Glyptics in Israel
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Izaak J. de Hulster, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
The Southern Levant is known as the "Sacred Bridge," which underscores the exchange that took place in this region with a number of other locales across various millennia. This paper focuses on Northern Israel, in particular the northern Jordan valley, and limits itself to the Iron Age. With this focus, the paper discusses possible influences on the glyptic repertoire of northern Israelite cities such as Hazor. This influence stems from places like Anatolia and Syria, but a special focus will be on scrutinizing traces that might be related to the Aramaeans. The endeavor is complicated by the way glyptic material spread in miniature art, and by the fact that a single artifact may show several distinct kinds of influence.
|
The Scholarly 'Construction of the Qumran Sect'
Program Unit: Metacriticism of Biblical Scholarship
Gwynned de Looijer, University of Durham
In the course of Qumran Scholarship, scholars have moulded and remoulded early theories of Qumran that, on the basis of a limited amount of texts, constructed a sectarian entity behind these texts. In this paper, I attempt to demonstrate that, at least part of these texts, do not fit this 'Qumran Paradigm', but that scholarly investments prevent the Paradigm to be reconsidered at its foundations.
The Qumran Paradigm connects the archaeological site of Khirbet Qumran to, on the one hand, the manuscripts from the eleven caves in its vicinity and, on the other hand, the descriptions of the Essenes by Philo, Josephus and Pliny the Elder. Thus, the Qumran Paradigm hypothesises that the Qumran manuscripts reflect the ‘sectarian’ library of a radical minority group (or ‘sect’), which was closely connected to the Essenes and resided at Khirbet Qumran. Part of this group’s ideology is thought to be their self-identification as ‘the chosen righteous ones’, awaiting the eschaton. Their exclusivist self-understanding is perceived to be demonstrated by modes of separatism and dualistic thinking in the manuscripts of the group’s ‘library’.
Several of the hypotheses that have formed the foundations of this prevalent Qumran Paradigm can be named: the idea of a ‘sectarian library’; literary and socio-historical models of textual classification; the use and accurateness of certain terminology to describe particular textual peculiarities (such as ‘dualism’), and finally, the implications of conclusions drawn from the perception of ideological coherence in the Qumran texts.
This paper wants to address the latter aspect in the construction of the Qumran Sect, and focuses on the construction of social reality through the perception of ideological coherence, particularly with regard to the concept of ‘dualism’. We evaluate the expansion of its definition into ten types of ‘Qumran’-specific dualism. Subsequently, the concept of ‘dualism’ is discussed with regard to the Treatise of the Two Spirits (1QS iii 13 – iv 26), as its dualistically perceived ideas are analysed and compared to similar ideas in other texts.
This paper wants to critically evaluate those elements in the foundations of the Qumran Paradigm that prevent scholarship from theorising about possible social realities beyond the scholarly construct of the Qumran 'library' and 'sect'. Hence, it wishes to advocate a more revisionist approach that more fundamentally questions the foundations of the Paradigm, specifically for those texts that do not seem to ‘fit’ within the Qumran Paradigm and that allow us to consider whether the texts found at Qumran represent a wider range of social backgrounds and a fuller engagement with the diverse forms of Second Temple Judaism than is normally envisaged.
|
Towards a New Model of Actualizing Interpretation in LXX Isaiah
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Rodrigo Franklin de Sousa, Universidade Presbiteriana Mackenzie
The notion that actualizing interpretation is a fundamental trait of LXX Isaiah has received significant attention in the field. Van Der Kooij’s account of actualizing interpretation of prophecy has been challenged recently in the works of Troxel (2008) de Sousa (2010) and Wagner (2013).
In this paper, while questioning Van der Kooij’s account of actualizing interpretation of prophecy, I also challenge aspects of the positions of Troxel and Wagner, both of which seem to imply that actualizing interpretation involves a high degree of conscious, even mischievous, manipulation of the text.
The main goal of the paper is to offer an alternative model of how the phenomenon described as “actualizing interpretation” functions. I develop the model in dialogue with examples of interpretation taken from the LXX corpus and other works of the same period, current LXX research, and recent developments in discourse and anthropological theories. This model challenges the patent excesses in contemporary accounts of theological exegesis of LXX Isaiah, incorporates the criticisms of Troxel and Wagner, and still seeks to acknowledge the mechanisms by which scriptural motifs, theological notions and ideological trends informed the peculiarities of LXX Isaiah.
|
The Wonderful Marginal Notes of MS 344 and the History of the Biblical Text
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Historical Books
Kristin De Troyer, University of St. Andrews
There are many marginal notes in ms 344. Most notes are straightforward, but some are not. Moreover, the author of these notes seems not always consistent. The notes however are very interesting as they are offering comments on variants and on the use of hexaplaric signs. The variants are important for a better understanding of the variants offered by the early jewish revisors. The remarks about the signs offer us insights into the manuscripts or their textual tradition used by the maker of the notes. In this paper, i will demonstrate the variety of the notes and their importance for the history of the biblical text. All examples will be taken from the Book of Joshua. This presenter is especially interested in discussing similar notes used in other manuscripts esp Sam or Kings mss.
|
Smuggling the Law through the Back Door? The Law and Love in the Ethics, Ethos, and Identity of the Galatian Community
Program Unit: Bible and Ethics
Pieter G.R. de Villiers, University of the Free State - Universiteit van die Vrystaat
In the reception history of Paul's letter to the Galatians, a passage like Galatians 2:15-16 was used to argue that justification by faith is its key theme. The letter is then read as a consistent rejection of observation of works of the law (Gal.2:12; 6:12).
Attention has been drawn, however, to the tension of such polemics with Paul’s interpretation of love as an enslavement and law (cf. Gal. 5:9, 14; also M. De Boer: Galatians. A Commentary on Galatians, 332ff and J.D.G. Dunn, The theology of Paul the Apostle, 115-118). This raises the important question of the role of love in the letter and its relationship with the law.
This paper aims to investigate this tension by analyzing Paul’s presentation of love in Galatians. This aim will be attained in a first part of the paper by briefly pointing out how contemporary research tend to overlook the theme of love in Galatians and, through a linguistic analysis, by illuminating its methodology. Then, through a close literary reading, the paper will demonstrate the important place and meaning of love in Galatians (Gal. 2:20; 5:6, 13, 14 and 22). It will argue that Paul regards love as having an originary character, linked with God as Initiator of an intimate relationship with humanity despite the human condition and lack of merit (Gal. 2:20-21). A special focus will be on the way in which Paul sees divine love as as a self-gift (Gal.2:20; 1:4) and as comprising an intimate, even mystical relationship with humanity. It will be shown how Paul moves from a discussion of justification without works in Gal.2:15-19 to a deeper level by grounding it in the divine love.
The paper will then show how this explains Paul’s view of love in the second half or the letter. It will evaluate how Paul sees love as more than an ethical obligation. Love is for him characteristic of believers’ identity and ethos as a gift of the Divine in the Spirit (Gal.4:6; Gal.5-6). An analysis will be given of Paul’s profound remark that love is the face of faith (Gal.5:6b) that love should characterize relations between community members (Gal.5:14), that believers are enslaved to each other in love (Gal.5:14), that love is the sum of the law (Gal.5:14) and that love is the very first of the fruit of the Spirit (Gal. 5:22).
In a final section the paper will bring together the two perspectives on love: Love permeates the identity and life of the faith community as mirror image of the identity and actions of the divine. Paul’s ethical pronouncements and his description of the community’s identity and ethos are the consequences of God’s love and actions. The loving relationship of the divine with humanity inspires and compels believers to be and act likewise. Even more so: Faith that gives up self-promotion through works is paired with love that empties itself as it seeks to be with and serve others. Such love is so compelling that it becomes a law unto itself.
|
Protecting the State against the Church: The Reception of John’s Revelation in the First Greek Commentary on Revelation
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Pieter G.R. de Villiers, University of the Free State - Universiteit van die Vrystaat
This paper aims at explaining the reception of the Revelation of John in the First Extant Greek Commentary written by Oecumenius in the sixth century C.E. It will focus on the history of this commentary by analyzing the ideological assumptions that underpin its contents and by evaluating its subsequent religious, cultural and political influence.
The paper will firstly analyze the influential commentary of Oecumenius within its cultural context in the Byzantine Empire when the church was a powerful institution in society with Emperors as its members and its supporters. It will spell out how the Emperors are depicted as pious rulers who are benefactors of the church. It further portrays the Byzantine Empire as a global institution with a peaceful and inclusive character that forms a perfect partnership with the church. It will point out how the commentary reconciles this presentation with the very different situation and message of Revelation in the first century that portray the readers as minority which was felt themselves persecuted in a violent manner by extremely hostile political opponents and that felt themselves under severe cultural attack and sought to escape state and political violence.
It will then investigate the irony that the commentary of Oecumenius is driven by the desire to secure and stabilize the state against violent opposition of apocalyptic groups that used the Book of Revelation to promote insurrection against the state. In this way the commentary seek to protect the state against religious violence and opposition. The paper will point out how the apocalyptic fervor of those times was countered by important passages in the commentary that read Revelation as a product of times long past when emperors erred in their persecution of the state or as a book with a mystical meaning that cannot be taken literally. It further contrasted those times with later actions that changed the violent policies of the state and that brought about a time of peace, prosperity and well-being of an all-embracing and global partnership between state and church.
In a last part of this paper, attention will also be paid to the underlying ideological considerations that motivated Oecumenius to write in the form of a commentary. It will focus on the question how he relates to previous commentaries on Revelation and how he impacted on subsequent commentaries. Finally the significant contribution of his commentary to the acceptance of Revelation in the East will be spelled out.
|
Breaking Bodies and Building Theologies: The Discourse of the Suffering Slave in Early Christianity
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Chris de Wet, University of South Africa
This paper examines the role of the discourse of the suffering and broken slave body in early Christianity up to the end of the fourth century CE. It argues that this discourse functions as the hermeneutical key for the production of Christian subjectivity. This discourse had three consequences that are interrelated: firstly, it encourages real, institutional slaves to be submissive and obedient to their masters, and especially to embrace unjust suffering. Secondly, embracing this type of suffering becomes a form of Christomorphism, as Christ is also depicted as the suffering slave par excellence. Finally, Christian suffering becomes equivalent to doulological suffering, they become suffering slaves of God, who should also find joy in their unjust suffering, whether it is in martyrdom or in living the ascetic life. It aims to illustrate that the boundaries between institutional and metaphorical slavery were very transparent, and to indicate that the oppressive practice of slavery, and the subjectivity of the slave body, were central to early Christian operations of subjectivation.
|
John Chrysostom on Nurses and Pedagogues
Program Unit: Slavery, Resistance, and Freedom
Chris L. de Wet, University of South Africa
Nurses and pedagogues were in many cases either slaves or freedpersons, and of all the slaves involved in the education of a child, they were the most influential. They were, on the one hand, important role-players in the formation of late ancient Roman masculinity, but on the other, they also destabilized traditional patriarchal and kyriarchal frameworks. In light of these tensions, the purpose of this study is to investigate John Chrysostom’s remarks on the role of the nurse and the pedagogue in the education of a child. It will examine Chrysostom’s advice regarding tasks related to birth, nursing, and early childhood education, especially in terms of discipline and punishment of adolescent males, and guarding the chastity of young females. The study will also examine his description of what the character of the nurse and pedagogue should be, and finally, also comment on the use and function of the nurse and pedagogue as metaphor in Chrysostom’s works.
|
Octosyllabism in Biblical Hebrew Poetry: Toward a Tetrametrical Analysis
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Vincent DeCaen, University of Toronto
DeCaen (2009) outlines a research programme in the metrical analysis of Biblical Hebrew poetry. In that study, the known prosodic principles of Tiberian Hebrew phonology are brought to bear, demonstrating sufficient prosodic regularity to establish the presumption of metrical regularity, in principle refuting the claim of Vance (2001) that Hebrew poetry necessarily cannot have a poetic meter.
It has been well understood since at least Culley (1970) that Hebrew poems have distinctive statistical profiles, generating an unambiguous typology on that basis. DeCaen (2009) identifies the octosyllabic type (mean, median and mode of eight syllables per line) as the most regular among these types, and proposes metrical principles governing the structure of these octosyllabic lines.
In the present paper, I identify a corpus of octosyllabic poems. I show that predictions made in DeCaen (2009) are fulfilled, and can be extended to this corpus generally. In the second half of the paper, I move to the more interesting question: what modifications of Tiberian phonology must be made to fully regularize these poems as accentual-syllabic tetrameters? In the event, there appear to be very few. The conclusion outlines the next steps in this research programme.
|
On the Syntax and Semantics of the Biblical Hebrew Infinitive Absolute
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Vincent DeCaen, University of Toronto
Biblical Hebrew possesses two infinitives: the straightforward infinitive or “infinitive construct”, and the so-called “infinitive absolute”. Typically the latter appears paronomastically with intensifying force, though it often functions adverbially.
The syntax and semantics of the infinitive absolute remain problematic. This is despite the monograph by Kim (2009), and generative treatments by Harbour (1999) and Pereltsvaig (2002).
I argue that difficulties arise because of the morphosyntactic misanalysis of the infinitive (syntactic head versus phrase), and because of the application of the conventional analysis of Biblical Hebrew syntax (VSO or verb-initial). I pursue the idea that a unified analysis of the various uses and several syntactic configurations of the infinitive absolute can be obtained by adopting my particular verb-second (V2) analysis, set forth in DeCaen (1995, 1999) and Cowper & DeCaen (2014).
In this model, there is a double movement: some constituent is necessarily topicalized (and this may be the null pronoun); and the finite verb may raise to realize phonologically features of the complementizer. I also argue that the infinitive is a bare verb phrase (VP)---crucially, not a head---originating as an adverb or VP adjunct. In this light, there are four possible scenarios: the verb may or may not move, and the bare VP may or may not be topicalized. The syntax and semantics of the infinitive absolute fall out naturally from this analysis.
|
Women's Voices in the Enthronement Psalms
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Nancy deClaisse-Walford, Mercer University
This paper will explore the question, "Can we hear the voices of women in the Enthronement Psalms?"
|
The Care of the Self and Gnostic Initiation
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
April D. DeConick, Rice University
Patrick McNamara defines religion as a form of therapy that promises to heal the “divided self” through ritual (McNamara 2009, 26). The centralization of the self into a “new executive form of the Self” has cultural benefits, he says, including enhanced autonomy, attentional control, and cooperativeness. It also makes possible a dissociative process that allows individuals to gain access to “unusual abilities of healing and aggression” (McNamara 2009, 166).
While McNamara’s understanding of religion may reflect many contemporary forms of religion, ancient religions in the Mediterranean largely were not focused on therapy or the construction of the self. Their focus was on overcoming the natural propensity of chaos, and then the maintenance of social order through the strong external control of the moral self by the laws of kings and priests. The person was considered a servant or slave of the god whose purpose was to labor on behalf of the god who desired leisure and gifts.
This understanding of the human is drawn from the everyday experience of lives of people ruled by terrifying kings and capricious oligarchies in slaveholding societies. The daily experiences of forced labor, oppressive governments, patriarchal families, and the avaricious wealthy was their reality, and this extended to their conceptualization of the sacred and the transcendent. Once these patterns of subservience toward the sacred were embedded within the myths, symbols and rituals of the ancient religions, the religions became powerful instruments that maintained society’s patterns of dominance and servitude. Religions, then, became powerful advertisements of the human’s place in the world and society as obedient and humble slaves to entities superior to them, whether they were the gods or the men who represented them.
So where does McNamara’s understanding of religion as therapy of the self originate? Is it a completely modern concept? I do not think so. At the beginning of the first millennium a new form of spirituality arose and began to interrogate the status quo. Gnostic spirituality provided an alternative model of reality, one in which the human is not a servant to the gods, but is liberated from them. The first Gnostics flipped the old forms of spirituality upside down as they became aware of another reality altogether, and began to initiate people into this. This form of spirituality understood the real self to be divine. This divine self existed within the human as a seed that needed to mature. The movements associated with Gnostic spirituality created elaborate rituals in order to mature and then integrate the real self with a transcendent god who was ineffable. The main purpose of these ancient Gnostic rites was self-therapy, the construction of a powerful divine self through ritual that could overcome the cosmic gods (and their men), bring healing to broken bodies, and foster autonomy to brave an unsympathetic chaotic world.
|
The Ethiopic Form of Deuterocanonical Writings
Program Unit:
Stephen Delamarter, George Fox University
The so-called “deutercanonical” books of the Ethiopic Old Testament are, of course, fully canonical to the Ethiopian Orthodox tradition. But, so little critical work has been done on these books that a full and complete picture of their textual histories is still some years away. Nevertheless, several recent developments have put us in a position to know more than ever before: 1) many previously un-imaged manuscripts have been digitized; 2) images in digital form have created new avenues of access for researchers; 3) methods and workflows have been developed so that distributed teams of scholars have been able to collaborate on the work; 4) the Textual History of the Ethiopic Old Testament (THEOT) project has executed its goal on at least a dozen of the books of the Old Testament shared in common with the Hebrew Bible, that goal being “to transcribe and study select shared variants in at least 30 manuscripts of every book of the Ethiopic Old Testament in order to identify the families of manuscripts, characterize the agendas behind each edition, and thereby tell the story of the textual history of the book;” and finally; 5) several other scholars have made significant progress on Ethiopic works like Jubilees and Enoch. The early findings of THEOT have created a framework in which to execute some soundings in the textual history of Ethiopic books like Judith, Tobit, the Letter of Jeremiah, 1 and 3 Esdras, and Psalm 151. From these we will sketch an overview of the general story of the Ethiopic form of the deuterocanonical writings.
|
The Singular, Dual, and Triple Textual Histories of Ethiopic Old Testament Texts
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Steve Delamarter, George Fox University
The work of the Textual History of the Ethiopic Old Testament (THEOT) Project has identified three types of case studies related to the textual history of the Ethiopic Old Testament. The first, and most common, is the case of the singular textual history which results from the transmission of biblical books solely in one manuscript type, namely those defined narrowly as biblical manuscripts. The second case is the dual textual history resulting from the transmission of Old Testament Biblical Canticles in two types of manuscripts: biblical manuscripts and in Ethiopic Psalters. The third case has to do with the triple textual history of the Ethiopic book of the Song of Songs, known to us from Psalter manuscripts (in two very different text types!), from biblical manuscripts (narrowly defined), and from lectionary manuscripts for Holy Week known as Gabra Hamamat manuscripts. The investigation of texts with singular, dual, and triple textual histories each requires a particular mode of investigation, and each analysis produces very interesting insights about the nature of the transmission and reception histories of biblical texts in the Ethiopic tradition.
THEOT scholars have completed the work on nine books of the Ethiopic Old Testament with singular textual histories: six books from the Minor Prophets (Hosea, Amos, Obadiah, Jonah, Micah, and Habakkuk), two books from the Ethiopic Octateuch (Deuteronomy and Judges) and the Psalms. Each study involved the transcription and analysis of shared variant readings in at least thirty manuscripts and up to a maximum of fifty manuscripts. We can now begin to describe the general trends in the textual history of the Ethiopic Old Testament for these books which were passed down in a singular transmission history.
We have also studied the dual textual history of three of the twelve Old Testament Biblical Canticles: The Song of Hanna (1Sa 2:1–10), The Song of Jonah (Jonah 2:2–9) and The Song of Habakkuk (Hab 3:2–18). For this work we transcribed and analyzed the shared variant readings in texts from at least thirty biblical manuscripts and thirty Psalter manuscripts. We will describe the character of each textual history and the relationship between them. Quite interestingly, the textual history for the one is not identical to the textual history of the other.
Finally, we have studied the special case of the triple textual history of the Ethiopic Song of Songs. We did this by transcribing and analyzing key sections of the text from all three types of manuscripts in which the Song is transmitted. Of particular interest is a form of the text, called the Hebraic edition, which was transmitted in some Psalter manuscripts.
|
John's Baptist in Luke's Gospel
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
John DelHousaye, Phoenix Seminary
Some believe John was written independently of the Synoptic Gospels, and others see dependence on one or more. Most attention has been given to parallels in Mark or the Johannine Thunderbolt in Matthew. However, the extensive overlap between John and Luke is often overlooked. Although the source-critical assumption might be Luke influencing John, F. Lamar Cribbs (1971) suggested the opposite. His theory was developed by Mark Matson (2001), who focused on the Passion. This paper offers further evidence from Luke's presentation of the Baptist. For example, Luke adopts John's opening synkrisis between Jesus and the Baptist and his presentation of some believing the latter was the Messiah.
|
What Was Job's Malady?
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Katharine Dell, University of Cambridge
This paper revisits the issue of Job’s illness with the fresh lens of disability studies. Whereas studies of the past focused on what Job’s precise medical condition might have been, this fresh approach assesses both the mental aspect of his condition and the socio-cultural aspects in reference to his feelings of social ostracization. Whilst it is interesting to reconsider the nature of his skin disease, the focus of the paper is on the wider elements that lead to his disability in mind and body and socialization, following studies in disability such as that of J. Schipper on Disability and Isaiah’s Suffering Servant (2011). The dialogue section of Job will prove to be the most fertile part of the book for studying these sentiments, which bear close comparison to psalmic laments. The theological question is raised whether his illness is indeed punishment for sin, at least in Job’s eyes, or whether in fact it is of a different nature to his other calamities. The surprising fact of the non-statement of the restoration of his health in the epilogue is also considered afresh.
|
The Rhetoric of Divine Revelation: The Other as Cosmic Creator and World Ruler in Isa 40:12–41:7
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Carol Dempsey, University of Portland
Through a series of rhetorical questions and a plethora of images, the poet of Isaiah 40:12—41:7 describes the Holy One as one who is totally Other and beyond the scope and comprehension of humankind and the human domain. Through choice rhetoric, the poet implies that this Holy One is, metaphorically, the Cosmic Creator and World Ruler of all. For ancient Israel and those who read Isaiah today, the poet’s poem is a reminder that the Divine is incomparable and that trust in one’s own power, prestige, and status is an exercise in folly. This paper explores Isaiah 40:12—41:7 from a literary perspective to show how the biblical poet uses rhetoric and implied metaphors to highlight the uniqueness of God and the transcendent sphere that are so very different and separate from the human sphere, past and present. Consideration will also be given to (a) how the conception of the Other may have shaped the self-understanding of the biblical poet and ancient Israel as reflected in the use of the implied metaphors, and (b) how the use of the implied metaphors helped to shaped an Isaianic understanding of the Other.
|
Love: The Fulfillment of the Law and the Prophets
Program Unit: Bible and Ethics
Carol Dempsey, University of Portland
Israel's prophets offer a transformative vision of law that goes beyond the legalities of commandments and ordinances. This vision is rooted in an understanding of divine love and right relationship. This paper explores such texts as Jer 31:31-34, Hos 6:1-6, 11:1-9, and Matt 22:34-40 to show how love is the fulfillment of the law and the prophets.
|
Rethinking "I Cannot Be Other Than What I Am": The Evidence for Religious Self-Identification from Early Christian Inscriptions
Program Unit: Society for Ancient Mediterranean Religions
Nicola Denzey, Brown University
Rethinking "I Cannot Be Other Than What I Am": The Evidence for Religious Self-Identification from Early Christian Inscriptions
|
MS R38 from Kairouan, Tunisia, and Its Umayyad Context
Program Unit: The Qur’an: Manuscripts and Textual Criticism (IQSA)
François Déroche, Ecole Pratique des Hautes Etudes
In the collection of the Great mosque in Kairouan, MS R 38 has been known for a long time, although its date and its connections with Umayyad art remained unnoticed. Thanks to a recent survey of the collection, it has been possible to collect evidence about the connection existing with other Qur'anic manuscripts from the same period and to offer a new glimpse into Umayyad calligraphy and illumination.
|
Ancient Literacy, Ancient Literary Dependence, Ancient Media, and the Triple Tradition
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Robert Derrenbacker, Thorneloe University
This paper will bring the studies of ancient media, ancient literacy and ancient literary dependence into a dialogue, with particular focus on the question of Matthew’s and Luke’s use of Mark in Synoptic theories that posit Markan priority.
|
How Has the Scholars Version Translation of the Authentic Letters of Paul Changed the Traditional Picture of Paul and Its Significance for Future Theology?
Program Unit: Westar Institute
Arthur J. Dewey, Xavier University
*
|
Who Are King Yareb and Shalman? A Fresh Look at Two Enigmatic Figures in the Book of Hosea
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Heath D. Dewrell, Princeton Theological Seminary
This paper examines two figures who appear in the book of Hosea, King Yareb of Assyria (5:13, 10:6) and Shalman, who devastated Beth-Arbel (10:14). Previous commentators have almost universally understood the former as a misreading of malk(î) rab “great king,” a title for the Assyrian king Tiglath-Pileser III, and the latter as referring to an otherwise obscure king Salaman(u) of Moab. Despite this scholarly consensus, these identifications are problematic on both linguistic and historical grounds. Additionally, a much more obvious solution exists—that Yareb is an abbreviated form of Sennacherib and that Shalman is an abbreviated form of Shalmaneser V. The reason that this possibility has not been considered in previous scholarly work on the book is that it has been assumed that its contents can be securely dated to the fairly narrow window of ca. 755-725 BCE. Sennacherib did not take the throne in Assyria until some twenty years later, so it would be impossible for him to appear in Hosea’s oracles. There are several reasons to question this narrow window, however, and to date at least some of its contents to as late as ca. 700. After presenting evidence for this slightly later date, the paper will explore some of the implications for our understanding of Hosea’s historical context and message.
|
Changing Features in Translation: Chiasmus versus Symmetry in the Book of Job
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Marieke Dhont, Université Catholique de Louvain
The dialogues of the book of Job are the example of Biblical Hebrew poetry par excellence. Literary features are abundantly present. Its Old Greek translation, in turn, which is infamous for its 'translational freedom', has been characterized as highly stylized as well. In the translation process, features of the source text can be maintained in the target text. They can, however, also go lost in translation, or be altered. Specifically in the book of Job it occurs regularly that one feature of the Hebrew text is eliminated and replaced by another feature in the Greek text. The question can rightfully be asked what consequences these differences bring about, especially on the level of information structure. In this paper, I want to examine those instances in which the Greek, due to a change in word-order, exchanges symmetry in the Hebrew text for a chiasmus in the translation and vice versa, in order to gain insight in the different ways the same information can be structured and what effect these differences have.
|
The Place of Nature in Job 38–42: A Vision for Ecology, Issues for Theology
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Robert A. Di Vito, Loyola University of Chicago
While the divine speeches in Job 38-42 are not typically the texts one thinks of in assessing the bible’s contribution to ecological awareness, the potential of its unsentimental and unvarnished naturalistic description of the animal kingdom to subvert the anthropocentric bias of the dominant biblical tradition deserves attention. The dislocation of the human from the center to the periphery occurs spatially, psychologically, and spiritually. Spatial dislocation occurs in terms of the architecture of the cosmos as God’s temple, the marginalization of humankind in God’s catalogue of creation, and the hierarchy of the created order. Psychological dislodgment takes place in the undermining of the human subject as a knower. Finally, spiritual dislocation occurs in terms of what the speech “from the storm” reveals about God and God’s relation to the human even as the theophanic experience of Job comes through the tour of the natural, mostly nonhuman world. This paper will confront traditional biblically based religion with the challenge of forgoing anthropocentric particularism in favor of a realistic view of nature and the vast nonhuman world as the locus for God’s manifestation of God’s self.
|
Abraham’s Uncircumcised Children: The Enochic Precedent for Paul’s Program of Gentile Reclamation qua Gentiles
Program Unit: Paul within Judaism
Genevive Dibley, University of California-Berkeley
It is clear that Paul considered the circumcision of gentile converts a first-order threat to the messianic age. No other subject, not even the Corinthians’ denial of the bodily resurrection, provoked a rebuttal in the tenor or on the scale of Paul’s letter to the Galatians. His warning could not have been more dire – should the converts submit to being circumcised the work of Christ to free [them] from the present evil age would be negated (Gal 1:4, 2:18-21, 4:11, 5:1-10).
Why Paul considered the prospect of the converts’ circumcision a catastrophic threat has been historically unclear. The metonymic significance of circumcision virtually ensured the rabbi’s interpretation of Paul’s argument as a wholesale repudiation of Judaism. For their part, Christians, rationalizing the severity of Paul’s alarm, came to read circumcision in his discourse as a cipher for the entirety of Jewish Law.
The Book of Dreams, however, contends that the healing of the world would be completed through the redemption of “gentileness” as a category of being. If Paul was of this eschatological school then his distress over the Galatians’ desire to become circumcised, i.e. the Galatians’ desire to become Jewish, would be greatly clarified. The circumcision of the converts would have eradicated the remaining point of theological distinction thereby threatening the very goal of the messianic age:the creation of a contingent of righteous gentiles as the eschatological complement to righteous Jewry. The panicked imperative of Galatians forbidding the rite of circumcision to the converts was aimed, then, not at negating Judaism but rather at preserving the otherness of the gentiles.
Amidst the ever increasing numbers of New Perspective studies asserting that Paul did not conceive of the Epistles as a challenge to Judaism, I offer this one; a reading of the Book of Dreams which offers a precursor to Paul’s argument concerning the reclamation of gentiles qua gentiles predating the composition of the Epistles by two centuries.
|
Washing Away Sin: Metaphor and Inner-Biblical Allusion in Psalm 51
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Lesley DiFransico, Catholic University of America
Commentators have often noted the numerous prophetic allusions contained in Psalm 51. Identifying and evaluating the nature of such inner-biblical allusions, however, is not without difficulty. The psalmist’s petition to “create in me a clean heart” (Ps 51:12) echoes God’s promise to bestow a “new heart and new spirit” in his people in Ezek 36:26 (cf. Jer 24:7). The repudiation of sacrifice in Ps 51:18 parallels similar prophetic declarations (Isa 1:11; etc). In addition to such allusions, Psalm 51 employs a distinctive metaphor: the penitent individual petitions God to “wash” him of his sins (Ps 51:4, 9). Elsewhere in the Hebrew Bible, the concept of washing away sin as a metaphor for redemption is found only in Isa 1:16; 4:4; Jer 2:22; 4:14. This paper will evaluate the connection between Psalm 51 and these prophetic passages vis-à-vis a study of the washing metaphor and other relevant imagery and lexical data. Specifically, the paper will explore the use of a novel metaphor as a criterion for identifying inner-biblical allusion. This paper will argue that the analysis of a metaphor that is rare or unusual within the Hebrew Bible has the potential to inform the identification and exploration of inner-biblical connections.
|
Elijah the Hero: A Comparison of Depictions of Elijah in Classical Rabbinic Texts and Philostratus' Heroikos
Program Unit: History and Literature of Early Rabbinic Judaism
Thomas W. Dilbeck, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion
Perhaps even more surprising than Elijah's exit from the biblical narrative of 2 Kings 2, is his ubiquitous appearances in classical rabbinic texts. Unexpectedly, Elijah is quite a different figure in the literature of the rabbis when compared to his role in the Hebrew Bible. Elijah reveals information to human beings apart from their canonical, authoritative texts and traditions. He has the ability to change shape, heal, and even to harm. In her recent monograph on the subject Elijah and the Rabbis, Kristen H. Lindbeck agrees with previous scholars as seeing Elijah's role as being comparable to the Greek emissary to the gods, Hermes.
In this paper, I argue that while Lindbeck's comparison is valid, perhaps there are other comparisons to be made as well. I refer specifically to Philostratus' work On Heroes.In this text, Philostratus depicts the heroes of the Iliad and Odyssey as being still alive in his day instructing people as to what "really" happened thus clarifying and even correcting the Homeric text. In Philostratus' work, the heroes can do other things as well such as heal people, change their appearance, hunt, and even have sex.
While I do not think these similarities are to be interpreted as a direct borrowing, I do argue that they reflect a similar cultural milieu. In sum, if my analysis is correct, the rabbis conceived of Elijah as a "hero" like those in the Heroikos.
|
Entering Eternity through Images of the Past: Eranos Religionism, Gnostic Rituals, and the Nag Hammadi Library in Laurence Caruana’s “The Hidden Passion”
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Matthew Dillon, Rice University
Published in 2007, Laurence Caruana’s The Hidden Passion: A Novel of the Gnostic Christ Based on the Nag Hammadi Texts is a piece of historical fiction that reimagines the life of Jesus of Nazareth using only antique Gnostic works as source-texts. In this paper, I analyze the novel as an example of how the Nag Hammadi Library has been received by some neo-Gnostics through the interpretive grille that Wouter Hanegraaff has labeled “Eranos religionism.” For Caruana, figures such a Jung, Eliade and Joseph Campbell recovered a forgotten ability to “think through images" that better accesses the sacred and eternal than logic alone. Through a close reading of his re-imaginging of the Sethian-Gnostic rite of the “Five Seals,” I show how Caruana attempts to turn the novel itself into a ritual of interpretation that releases the sensitive reader from mere logical thinking into the sacred epistemology of image thinking.
|
No Male and Female...in Virtue? Paul on Women's Moral Development
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Laura Dingeldein, Brown University
In this paper I integrate studies of Paul’s “ethics,” Paul’s gender ideology, and the role of women in early Christian assemblies by reconstructing and historically contextualizing Paul’s program of moral development for female Christ followers. Paul envisions Christ followers as undergoing a gradual process of moral development that involves, among other things, the strengthening of one’s mind, the control and eradication of corrupt emotions and desires, and assimilation to Christ. In ancient Mediterranean culture, however, women were generally viewed as possessing weak constitutions and proclivities toward corrupt emotion and desire that would have inhibited such moral progress. Given that Paul wrote to groups of Christ followers that included women, then, what does Paul have to say about women’s ability to progress in virtue? And do Paul’s statements about women’s moral progress reflect ancient Mediterranean gender ideologies?
I seek to answer these questions by comparing Paul’s thoughts about women’s ability to progress in virtue with the thoughts of two contemporary Hellenistic philosophers – Philo of Alexandria and Seneca the Younger – on the matter. Certainly, Paul, Philo, and Seneca all consider some particular, historical women to have achieved great virtue, but does Paul agree with Philo and Seneca that women's gender generally puts them at a disadvantage to men when it comes to progress in virtue? Due to the nature of our evidence, Paul’s thoughts on the subject are much more difficult to reconstruct than the views of Philo and Seneca. Yet I argue that Paul, on the whole, is less willing to differentiate between men and women with regard to propensity toward progress in virtue than are Philo and Seneca. I attribute this in part to Paul’s ideas about the role of the pneuma in Christ followers’ moral development and Paul’s emphasis on the role of ethnicity in determining humans’ base moral condition.
|
"The Suffering Self" in Mark and 1 Peter
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Michal Beth Dinkler, Yale Divinity School
In her classic study, The Suffering Self: Pain and Narrative in the Early Christian Era, Judith Perkins argues that the early Christians’ foregrounding of their own suffering provided a unique self-definition for the nascent Christian movement; as such, the concept of the “suffering self” ultimately enabled the rise of Christianity as an institution.
A classicist, Perkins shies away from using New Testament texts, inviting her readers “to make the often obvious connections between the subjectivity constructed in the Christian discourses [she] examine[s] and that offered in the New Testament” (13). This paper accepts Perkins’ invitation in a modified form. Specifically, I compare the two New Testament texts that are most often privileged in discussions of suffering in the New Testament – the Gospel of Mark and The First Epistle to Peter.
Many discussions of “suffering” in early Christian literature conflate diverse types of suffering, implying that early Christian depictions of suffering all function in the same way, and that early Christians agreed about the reasons for and appropriate responses to suffering. Still, close readings of the relevant passages in Mark and 1 Peter demonstrate the opposite. This paper is structured around the following three questions regarding the nature of suffering in Mark’s Gospel and in 1 Peter:
1) To what does “suffering” refer in this text?; 2) What reason(s) does the text give for suffering?; 3) What response(s) does the text recommend in the face of suffering?
Taking up these questions allows us to move toward a more nuanced understanding of the rhetorical functions that suffering plays in Mark and in 1 Peter, respectively.
|
"The Thoughts of Many Hearts Shall Be Revealed": Listening in on Lucan Interior Monologues
Program Unit: Gospel of Luke
Michal Beth Dinkler, Yale Divinity School
Upon the occasion of his retirement in 2009, François Bovon delivered the Ingersoll Lecture at Harvard Divinity School, titled, “The Soul's Comeback: Immortality and Resurrection in Early Christianity.” In that address, Professor Bovon implored scholars of early Christianity to recover the concept of the “soul” (yuchv), which – he argued – was eclipsed by the “rediscovery of the body” in twentieth-century academic discourse. Ultimately, Bovon asks us to avoid letting the pendulum swing too far to either side of the psyche/soma divide, lest we miss the immortal, interior dimension of the self that also was prominent in early Christian understanding.
In his lecture, Bovon surveyed a wide range of early Christian authors, beginning with several writers from late antiquity, and ending with a Jesus saying from Matthew (10.28). Perhaps surprisingly, however, he did not draw from a text to which he devoted much of his scholarly career – the Gospel of Luke. Here, I wish to expand upon Bovon’s observations regarding the soul and interiority in early Christianity, with specific attention to the Gospel of Luke.
In this paper, I consider several Lukan references to what one says to one’s soul, particularly as portrayed through internal monologues. In doing so, my goal is subversive; like Bovon, I wish to challenge a current consensus in which the scholarly pendulum has again swung too far toward an unhelpful extreme: in this case, not between the poles of “soul” and “body,” but between the poles of supposedly “introspective” individualist and “anti-introspective” collectivist societies.
|
Ezekiel 23: A Marital Metaphor or Martial Parable? An Iconographic Consideration
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Brian Charles DiPalma, Emory University
Previous research on Ezekiel 23 suggests two primary settings in life from which the violent sexual imagery may have emerged: 1) Practices associated with adultery in a marital context or 2) Practices associated with warfare in a martial context. Despite these different proposals, scholars typically turn to the same type of evidence: textual, whether biblical or other texts from the ancient Near East. This paper, however, revisits the question about the social setting of the textual imagery in Ezekiel 23 by turning to visual media from the ancient Near East in light of advances in the practice of iconographic research. On the basis of numerous points of congruence between Ezekiel 23 and ancient visual representations of warfare, I argue that the violent textual imagery draws primarily from a martial rather than marital social setting and that it is primarily male bodies that are envisioned as the recipients of the martial violence in the passage. In the process, martial violence is gendered and sexualized while gender and sexuality are militarized, which adds additional layers of complexity to why this passage is problematic.
|
Reconstructing Neo-Babylonian Policy in the Phoenician Levant
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Helen Dixon, North Carolina State University
Discussions of Phoenicia in the Neo-Babylonian period tend to focus on the changing role of Tyre in the wake of Nebuchadnezzar II’s siege (or rather, blockade) of that city, ending in the late 570s BCE. While this event did indeed have dramatic implications for Carthage and the balance of trade in the Mediterranean, other aspects of Phoenician administration and commerce under Neo-Babylonian rule have gone un- or under-explored. This paper will go beyond Josephus’ account of Tyrian royal affairs to survey other types of archaeological and inscriptional evidence that bear on the history of Phoenician sites in this period. What changes would Arwad, Byblos, Beirut, Sidon, and cities further south have experienced? How might the status of Phoenician colonies abroad reflect these “homeland” changes?
A brief reconstruction of Phoenicia’s political structure and economic role under Neo-Babylonian rule will be offered, moving site-by-site through its territory to illustrate the available evidence. Diachronic change at each site will be discussed where possible. Although this is difficult to detect in a period lasting just sixty-five years, data from the early Achaemenid period in Phoenicia may in some cases shed light on the status that certain sites carried over from Neo-Babylonian arrangements. Finally, Phoenicia’s value to the Babylonians will be assessed given the implications of this new reconstruction.
|
Breaking the Backbone of Oppressive Power: King, the State, and the Wrath of God
Program Unit: African-American Biblical Hermeneutics
Thomas P. Dixon, Princeton Theological Seminary
During the United States civil rights movement, Martin Luther King, Jr., repeatedly brought the Hebrew scriptures into the public square to oppose oppression, inspire resistance and motivate social and political change. Many know King’s use of Amos 5 in his call to fight “until justice runs down like water, and righteousness like a mighty stream,” but fewer recall his use of Psalm 46 as a warning from God to unjust leaders to “be still and know that I am God, that if you don’t obey me I will break the backbone of your power and slap you out of the orbits of your international and national relationships.” Even King’s use of Amos 5 at times signified not merely the hope of justice rolling down but also the threat of judgment rolling down. King believed God’s justice to include God’s judgment, some of which should be carried out by the state.
This paper will explore how Dr. King inhabits the world of Hebrew prophetic scripture in speeches and writings to contend that the just state was called to enact God’s judgment by punishing oppressive rulers who opposed divine justice. On a statewide or communal scale, however, both punishment of and protest against injustice were to have a common goal of reform and reconciliation. Not only does Scripture enjoin the state’s just punishment of oppression, but for King it also declares that such measures must lead not to mere retaliation but to a “beloved community” that anticipates the coming kingdom of God.
|
Eidete or Idete? Reading 1 John 2:29a from NA27, NA28, and the Editio Critica Maior
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Toan Do, Australian Catholic University
Background: For 1 John 2:29a, the eighth-revised-1998 Nestle-Aland27 lists no variants while the 2012 Nestle-Aland28 cites eleven MSS for idete (aorist subjunctive) in place of eidete (perfect subjunctive). While NA28 is a much more improved critical edition than NA27, the number of MSS cited are rather incomplete. The 2003 Novum Testamentum Graecum Editio Critica Maior (ECM) provides seventy-nine MSS, plus lacunae, for idete (compared to fifty-four MSS for eidete). Besides, several witnesses read oidate (perfect indicative) instead of eidete or idete. Moreover, the presence of ean and de-kai occurs in some MSS but not in others. Since the difference between these subjunctives occurs in the protasis (here the ean-clause), the meaning of each variant depends little on the tense (factual time) of the verb, but rather on the aspect. Each variant has the potential to affect and nuance interpretive implications: it questions the scribal intention of the text(s); it alters the aspectual types of action in the conditional clause. These variants obviously call for various interpretations of the entire verse 2:29, in that the grammatical and theological distinctions between eidete, idete, and oidate can only be fully appreciated through a careful examination of the apodosis. These distinctions, while subtle, lend significant insight to the Aktionsarten perceived through the aspect of the perfect and aorist subjunctives.
Methods: Applying the criteria in the so-called reasoned eclecticism, this paper evaluates the different readings of 1 John 2:29a in the textual tradition to see whether eidete, idete, or oidate (with or without ean) is most likely the initial text.
Conclusions: A text-critical analysis, backed by the ECM and CBGM, suggests that idete is the better reading in accordance with the textual tradition for 1 John 2:29a. Thus, the variant eidete (in ? B rell) is mostly likely due to scribal intention.
|
A Making Out of Words: Philology and Biblical Poetry
Program Unit: Philology in Hebrew Studies
Chip Dobbs-Allsopp, Princeton Theological Seminary
I use Paul Valéry’s insistence that poems, at bottom, are made out of words—historical artifacts all!—to argue the indispensability of philology (the literal “love of words”), our principal disciplinary means for fixing and thus accessing poems through their words and worlds, to the reading of biblical poetry. In so doing, I advocate a return to one of the founding methods of modern biblical scholarship, albeit in a Nietzschean mode with an enlarged horizon of interest. For Nietzsche (ever the philologist), philology was the ultimate method of close and slow reading: “it teaches to read well, ... to read slowly, deeply, looking cautiously before and aft, with reservations, with doors left open, with delicate eyes and fingers” (1984).
|
Some Initial Reflections on XML Markup for an Image-Based Electronic Edition of the Brooklyn Museum Aramaic Papyri
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
F. W. Dobbs-Allsopp, Princeton Theological Seminary
A collaborative project of the Brooklyn Museum and a number of allied institutions, including Princeton Theological Seminary and West Semitic Research, the Digital Brooklyn Museum Aramaic Papyri (DBMAP) is to be both an image-based electronic facsimile edition of the important collection of Aramaic papyri from Elephantine housed at the Brooklyn Museum and an archival resource to support ongoing research on these papyri and the public dissemination of knowledge about them. In the process of building out a (partial) prototype of the edition, to serve as a proof of concept, we have discovered little field-specific discussion that might guide our markup decisions. Consequently, here our chief ambition is to initiate such a conversation. After a brief overview of DBMAP and a demo of our prototype edition, we offer some initial reflection and assessment of XML markup schemes specifically for Semitic texts from the ancient Near East that comply with TEI, CSE, and MEP guidelines. We take as our example BMAP 3 (=TAD B3.4) and we focus on markup as pertains to the editorial transcription of this documentary text and to the linguistic analysis of the text’s language.
|
Universalism and Particularism in the Book of Wisdom, the Gospel of Matthew, and the Epistle of Barnabas
Program Unit: Texts and Traditions in the Second Century
Joseph Dodson, Ouachita Baptist University
This paper will place the Epistle of Barnabas in dialogue with the Book of Wisdom and the Gospel of Matthew regarding the salvation and judgment of gentiles and Jews. More specifically, it will focus on how these authors employ scripture and the history of Israel to support their respective arguments. The paper will aim to show how the author of Wisdom uses Israel’s story to underscore Jewish particularism on the one hand and the damnation of the gentiles on the other. In contrast, Matthew draws from scripture to lambaste the Jewish leaders for their faithlessness and to hold out the hope of salvation to the gentiles. As if in a trajectory, Barnabas cites Hebrew prophets and rehearses tragic moments in Israel’s history to denounce the salvation of the Jews in order to affirm the election of the gentile Christians. The paper will (1) first examine the relevant passages in their own right before (2) delineating points of convergence and divergence within the works. It will conclude by (3) demonstrating how the comparison enhances our understanding of these works, especially the Epistle of Barnabas.
|
Medium and the Mixed Message of Rabbinic Oral Law
Program Unit: Orality, Textuality, and the Formation of the Hebrew Bible
Natalie B. Dohrmann, University of Pennsylvania
A great deal of ink has been spilled on the question of early rabbinic literary culture and the rabbinic dedication to the development of an explicitly oral legal tradition. In this essay I will argue that given that the manifest content of early rabbinic discourse is law, it is productive to look to the very public practices of communication inscribed, literally and figuratively, in the Roman legal culture of the east. Within this context, the rabbinic legal project makes sense as a form of provincial shadowing of a dominant Roman legal culture. This paper will explore the paradoxical rabbinic deployment of the most public of Roman genres, law, in a manner explicitly coded as private. How does one make sense of the public aspirations of rabbinic law with its choice to remain unwritten and therefore largely invisible in the imperial landscape of the rabbinic city?
|
Rejecting "Patriarchy": On Clarifying the Objectives of Feminist Biblical Scholarship
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Shawna Dolansky, Carleton University
This paper seeks to answer the question, raised by Carol Meyers, of why biblical studies lags behind classics and other disciplines in rejecting “patriarchy” as a category for biblical Israel. Through an exploration of the origins and development of feminist biblical criticism, the paper discusses the differences between two historically feminist approaches to the Bible. One is historical-literary criticism, working to reconstruct the social and religious histories of ancient Israel; and the other is literary-theological-hermeneutical feminist criticism based (either implicitly or explicitly) in the need to inform the interaction of living (and frequently faith-based) communities with the biblical text. Those operating in the latter category often either attempt to redeem the biblical text in ways that affirm feminist faith commitments, or polemicize about the Bible as patriarchal and oppressive to women; this approach does not contribute to our understanding of the society that produced the Bible.
These two categories of feminist criticism and their disparate objectives tend not to be differentiated in the literature, in congresses, and often by scholars themselves. The conflation of both types of “feminist biblical criticism” results in (and from) the uncritical labeling of ancient Israel as “patriarchal.” The application of this category of post-industrial capitalist societies to ancient Israel serves the interests of feminist theology (or anti-theology) in the guise of literary criticism, but obscures the biblical historian’s ability to properly reconstruct the social and religious realities of the ancient world. Perhaps, in rejecting the term "patriarchy" for ancient Israel, we also have to reconsider the use of the term "feminist biblical scholarship" to more clearly differentiate between the application of feminist historical criticism to the Bible as a method to better understanding ancient Israel, on the one hand, and the approaches of feminist literary criticism, feminist hermeneutics, and feminist theology on the other.
|
Women's Voices in Books II–III of the Psalter
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Denise Dombkowski Hopkins, Wesley Theological Seminary
This paper will examine if a female voice can be discerned in books II–III of the Psalter
|
Approaching the Qur'an's Contradictory Statements on ahl al-kitab
Program Unit: Qur’anic Studies: Methodology and Hermeneutics (IQSA)
Fred M. Donner, University of Chicago
It is well known that the Qur'an contains contradictory statements on the "Scripture People" (ahl al-kitab), meaning mainly Christians and Jews. After reviewing some of the salient features of this contradictory material, the paper will offer some thoughts on different sets of assumptions scholars sometimes make in trying to explain these contradictions, which then dictate their particular approach. The paper will then discuss the implications of these assumptions or approaches for one's unde rstanding the character of the Qur'an text and its early evolution.
|
A Preliminary Report on the Families of Manuscripts for the Ethiopic Book of Micah
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Anke Dorman, Universität Zürich
As part of the Textual History of the Ethiopic Old Testament Project, this paper presents some preliminary results of the research into the textual history of Ethiopic Micah. The collation of eleven select readings in about 30 manuscripts enables a classification of various families of manuscripts in Ethiopic Micah. This paper describes the process of collating and presents the manuscripts families that could be identified for Ethiopic Micah.
|
Working with the Masorah Parva of BHS
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Christopher Dost, Alliance Theological Seminary
This is the first section of the workshop on the Masorah Parva. It will concentrate on the mechanics and editorial principles of the Masorah of BHS.
|
Why Was Jesus Understood and Proclaimed in the Language and Imagery of Woman Wisdom? An Exploration of the Role of Experience in the Ignition of Wisdom Christology and Wisdom Soteriology in the Early
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Sally Douglas, Melbourne College of Divinity
In Second Testament and early church texts it is proclaimed that Jesus was due, with God, the devotion, proclamation and obedience usually reserved for God alone by utilising the language and imagery of Woman Wisdom (e.g. Colossians, 1 Corinthians, Hebrews, John’s prologue, Matthew, 1 Clement and Justin Martyr’s Dialogue).
While Woman Wisdom’s origins in Hebrew tradition continue to be disputed, insufficient attention has been given to the reasons why various early Jesus communities would identify Jesus with Woman Wisdom as they proclaimed understandings of Jesus in relation to God.
As early Jesus communities sought to proclaim that a person who had been executed in a state sanctioned murder was actually worthy of devotion, they, presumably, would have utilised only those arguments that were most compelling. Why, then, did various Second Testament and early church authors image Jesus like, and as, the female divine? The view that language and imagery of Woman Wisdom were adopted to bolster convictions about the divinity of Jesus rest on assumptions that christology evolved through a process of rational, linear accretion. This assumption is unconvincing in light of the very early expressions of much Wisdom christology and the “problematic” nature of Jesus’ gender when compared with the gender of Woman Wisdom.
This paper will demonstrate that collective experiences within early Jesus communities ignited the proclamation of Wisdom christology in Second Testament and early Christian texts. Furthermore these texts reveal the conviction of early Jesus communities that these experiences were bearing collective ontological transformation: transformation that finds expression in the celebration of a “realised” Wisdom soteriology.
The key ignition points of this early, experientially fueled identification of Jesus with Woman Wisdom in Second Testament and early Church texts will be discussed and the “realised” Wisdom soteriology that is proclaimed in these early Christian texts will be excavated and explored.
|
Hearing the Voice of Earth in the Lukan Parable of the Pounds
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Elizabeth Dowling, Australian Catholic University
In the traditional reading of the Parable of the Pounds in the Gospel of Luke (19:11-27), the third slave is criticized for his inaction and is contrasted negatively with the first two slaves who act according to their master’s expectations. This paper will bring an ecological perspective to a reading of the parable. It will engage a hermeneutic of suspicion, identification and retrieval in order to bring to the surface the pain of the Earth community represented in the text, and to allow the voice of Earth to be heard.
The master engages in practices which exploit the Earth community: he travels afar to take a basileia for himself (19:12); he reaps where he has not sown and takes up what he does not deposit (19:21). Particular attention will be given in this paper to the role of the third slave who provides a voice for certain Earth elements in the text. By not following the master’s instructions, the third slave chooses to break the cycle of exploitation of the poor, both human and other than human. He protects what he has been given rather than damage his relationship with the Earth community. It is the third slave who is the hero of the parable, risking corporal punishment, and acting according to the example of the Lukan Jesus.
|
Dying They Live: Suicide Protesting as Automartyrdom
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
Jack Downey, La Salle University
This paper will provide an opportunity for reflection on the modern phenomenon of suicide protesting, with particular attention to autocremation and self-starvation. Since the 1960s – although certainly with precedent – self-mortification has evolved into its own genus of dissent, which has been labeled “communicative suffering.” By focusing on IRA hungerstrikers and Tibetan self-immolators as primary case studies, this paper will compare Buddhist and Christian understandings of suicide, the body, asceticism and martyrdom as a performative act that paradoxically forms a subject through the destruction of its physical form. It will also critically assess how these phenomena may be contingent upon technologies of globalization, and how they may alternately undermine and bolster neocolonial visions of oppressed communities.
|
Christ’s Victory over Death: Wall Paintings in the Early Basilica at Stobi
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Caroline Downing, State University of New York at Potsdam
One of the most well preserved Early Christian basilicas has been uncovered at the site of Stobi, in the former Yugoslav republic of Macedonia. The basilica dates to the end of the fourth or early fifth century, and was preserved because it was deliberately buried in order to create a terrace for a larger basilica. Excavation has revealed an unprecedented amount of painted decoration, including painted walls in situ; large areas of fallen ceiling painting; and mosaic floors, including inscriptions that shed light on the meaning of the entire program.
Because of its exceptional state of preservation, the Early Basilica has produced a nearly complete decorative program, allowing unprecedented opportunity to study the meaning of the imagery, and even to determine the dedication of the structure. Around the ceiling of the aisles ran a decorative wreath, very similar to those found in Early Christian tombs around the Mediterranean, and likely signifying the deceased’s participation in Christi’s victory over death. The remainder of the ceiling consisted of a grid of decorative panels surrounded by stars, also a common motif in ceiling decoration in the early church. More wreath imagery appears above the aisle walls and above the nave colonnade. At the east end of the church stood the lower portion of an image of Christ as the Good Shepherd, surrounded by chi rho symbols. Most of the surviving walls contain painted imitations of opus sectile. A spur wall at the west end of the church contains the most intriguing image, a painted panel of mice surrounded by vines. Toward the east end of the north aisle, a painted fish, also surrounded by vines, flanks a mysterious opening in the north wall.
Among the designs in the mosaic floor, some of them recalling motifs in the ceiling, is an ichthus acrostic, and a Greek inscription as follows: Prayers and charity and fasting and the repentance of pure hearts deliver us from death. The specific reference to deliverance from death adds support to the theory that the entire decorative program of the Early Basilica at Stobi refers to the power of Christ to save the faithful from death. It is likely, then, that the church was dedicated to Christ, as was common in the fourth century; an example is Ambrose’s church in Milan dedicated to the victory of Christ. The Early Basilica at Stobi now provides evidence of an iconographic program that was created to visually express the theme of Christ’s Victory over Death.
|
The Pauline Concept of Union with Christ in Ignatius of Antioch
Program Unit: Texts and Traditions in the Second Century
David Downs, Fuller Theological Seminary (Pasadena)
This paper will explore the Pauline concept of union with Christ in the writings of Ignatius of Antioch. First, after presenting a brief sketch of the theme of union with Christ in Paul’s letters, the paper will ask how the concept of union with Christ in Ignatius’s epistles compares with that found in the Pauline epistles. Second, the paper will ask if the motif of union with Christ in Ignatius can plausibly be traced to Pauline influence.
|
Sacred Sites, Paralyzed Bodies: The Account of Peter’s Daughter in the Coptic Act of Peter
Program Unit: Function of Apocryphal and Pseudepigraphal Writings in Early Judaism and Early Christianity
Luke Drake, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
The healing and un-healing of Peter's daughter in the Coptic "Act of Peter" is, to say the least, a provocative and problematic account, and one that has received relatively little scholarly attention. In this brief paper, I will examine the narrative’s depiction of the half-paralyzed female body, as well as work to demonstrate how the text’s particular use of this motif might shed additional light on the world in which this narrative was recorded and received. More specifically, I will seek to answer a question particular to the interests of this SBL session: what, if any, is the relationship between this apocryphal account of Peter’s daughter and the Jewish literary productions of 2 and 3 Maccabees? This paper works to demonstrate a shared lineage between these discreet literary traditions, in spite of their obvious differences in rhetorical, political, and theological agendas.
|
Unique L.D.S. Understandings of the Apocalypse of John the Apostle
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
Richard D. Draper, Brigham Young University
Joseph Smith stated that “the Book of Revelation is one of the plainest books God ever caused to be written” (History of the Church, 5:342), but, as some have quipped, “He saw the movie.” Whether or not that is the case, the revelations received as part of the Restoration have given Latter-day Saints a unique interpretation of some aspects of this master work and its authorship. This paper explores some of these and their place in LDS doctrine and theology.
Latter-day Saints take the position that the book can be understood. They feel that those who live in the day when prophets of God walk the earth, who have access through the prophets to eternal truths and thus to the gift of prophecy, the central message of the book is clear. Elder Bruce R. McConkie stated: “The common notion that it deals with beasts and plagues and mysterious symbolisms that cannot be understood is just not true. . . . [It] is clear and plain and should be understood by the Lord's people” (Ensign [September, 1975]: 87).
For Latter-day Saints, the authorship of the book, debated for centuries, is settled by scripture. The Book of Mormon makes it clear that the Apostle John was foreordained to “write concerning the end of the world” and explains why God did not order his visions, unlike so many others, sealed up (1 Ne. 14:18–27).
Among the various schools of thought concerning the book, the Latter-day Saints fall into none precisely. Joseph Smith made it plain that “the things which John saw had no allusion to the scenes of the days of Adam, Enoch, Abraham or Jesus, only so far as is plainly represented by John, . . . [he]saw that only which was lying in futurity and which was shortly to come to pass” (History of the Church, 5:341–42). He came to this understanding through a revelation that specifically addressed issues in Apocalypse (Doctrine and Covenants 77). This revelation went counter to scholarly thinking in Joseph Smith’s day most of which placed the events in chapters 7–9 and 11in the past. The revelation clearly placed them in the future and, thus, broke a long standing point of view.
The paper will comment on areas addressed by other scholars such as the timing of the Second Coming (19:11), the work of the angel “flying through the midst of heaven” (14:6), the nature and purpose of the “white stone” (2:17), the work and ministry of the 144,000 (7:4), and the work and ministry of the “two witnesses” (11:3). It will also examine some uniquely LDS subjects, such as the fullness of the priesthood (1:6) and the plurality of the Gods (1:6). Finally, it will assess how Joseph Smith’s work has helped make the book “plain,” noting areas he has clarified but also paying attention to some his insights have complicated.
|
How and Why the Temple of Jerusalem Changed? “Historiography” of Religious Architecture
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Peter Dubovsky, Pontifical Biblical Institute
Writings from all historical periods, ANE included, dedicate a lot of space to building accounts. Both the changes introduced by kings or clergymen and the motives that led them to rebuild their temples and palaces found their way into literary works. Therefore, in the first part of my paper I will offer a few examples of the “historiography” of religious architecture. Then I will apply this interpretative model to the temple of Jerusalem as described in the Bible. To this aim, I will summarize the descriptions of architectural changes that had an impact upon the temple of Jerusalem and answer the questions how and why the first temple changed according to the biblical writers.
|
Second Corinthians 9: The Earliest of the Letters Contained in Canonical 2 Corinthians?
Program Unit: Second Corinthians: Pauline Theology in the Making
Paul B. Duff, George Washington University
The role that 2 Corinthians 8 and 9 play in the Corinthian correspondence has long been questioned. In the eighteenth century, Johann Semler wondered why Paul repeats in chapter 9 the same argument that he had just made in chapter 8. A century later, H. Hagge argued that chapter 8 must have been an independent letter since the gar of 9:1 clearly connects to 7:16 and chapter 8 disrupts that connection. Early in the twentieth century, Johannes Weiss followed up with the suggestion that, because Paul’s praise for the Corinthians in chapter 8 is effusive, it must have been composed prior to virtually everything else in 2 Corinthians.
Hans Windisch, in his 1924 commentary, proposed that neither chapters 8 or 9 fit into their canonical context. Rather, both represent fragments of separate letters focused on the collection. Chapter 8 is the earlier of the two letters although chapter 9 was probably composed not long after. Noting that Paul refers to Achaia in 9:2, Windisch suggested that chapter 9 had originally been sent to the churches in that province rather than to Corinth. Later on, Günther Bornkamm agreed that chapter 9 was a circular letter to the province. Furthermore, Bornkamm proposed that this circular letter and chapter 8 (possibly an independent letter or perhaps the conclusion to 1:1-2:13; 7:5-16) represent the concluding chapter of the Corinthian story. In his 1985 commentary, Hans Dieter Betz agreed with Bornkamm that chapters 8 and 9 represent late writings. Betz compared each of the two chapters to various other ancient administrative letters and concluded that each chapter represents a single letter composed after the conflict between Paul and the Corinthians had been resolved; chapter 8 was sent to Corinth and chapter 9 to the other cities of Achaia.
In the early years of the 21st century, Margaret Mitchell revived Weiss’s idea that 2 Corinthians 8 represents the earliest of the letters found in 2 Corinthians. Particularly noteworthy in Mitchell’s argument is her recognition of the difference between Paul’s instructions for the collection in 1 Cor 16:1-4 and in 2 Cor 8:18-19. In my paper I build on the findings of Weiss and Mitchell (i. e., that chapter 8 represents an early letter in the correspondence). However, I further suggest that chapter 9 represents an even earlier letter than chapter 8. I base my argument primarily on two things. First, I contend that the suggestion that chapter 9 represents a circular letter to all of the churches of Achaia except Corinth is not viable. Second, I argue that information given about the collection in Macedonia in both 2 Corinthians 8 and 9 strongly indicates that the Macedonian effort was incomplete when chapter 9 was written but it had been completed when chapter 8 was penned, This information thereby suggests that chapter 8 was composed after chapter 9.
|
“Justa” and the Borders of Piety in the Pseudo-Clementine “Homilies”
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
Patricia Duncan, University of Chicago
Embedded in the second book of the fourth-century Greek novel known as the Pseudo-Clementine Homilies is a gem of a story, barely twenty lines long, about a minor female character named Justa. Although the pious woman who is the subject of this cameo will never appear as an actor on the main timeline of the narrative, the brief account of her life describes events that, in hindsight, will turn out to have facilitated some important connections in the two overarching plot lines of the novel, those of the battle between the Apostle Peter and Simon Magus and of the reunification of the natal family of Clement. But before the family romance can unfold, Justa herself must undergo a conversion and become “Jewish,” for in the Homilies alone (i.e., not in the Pseudo-Clementine Recognitions), she is identified with another woman, whom the informed reader cannot help but recognize as the anonymous Gentile suppliant who petitions Jesus for the exorcism of a demon from her daughter in Mark 7:24-30 and Matthew 15:21-28. The story about Justa, as (re)told by the Apostle Peter in the Homilies, is also a multi-faceted exploration of religious boundaries, revealed in an account of their crossing. What territories and customs lie on either side of the border that sets Peter and his cohort apart in a complex religious landscape can begin to be made out in the miniature narrative about this woman who “changed what she was” (Hom. 2.19.3). In this paper, I will argue that Justa’s story represents a remarkably creative and highly contentious reading of the canonical gospels that is thoroughly marked by the peculiar, dualistic ideology of the Homilies.
|
Augustine's Use of the Pauline Portrayal of Peter in Galatians 2
Program Unit: Contextualizing North African Christianity
Geoffrey D. Dunn, Australian Catholic University
In Galatians 2:11-14 Paul records how he took Peter to task over the incident at Antioch after Peter had withdrawn from table fellowship with Christians of a Gentile origin due to some pressure. There is a great deal of disagreement among contemporary scholars as to just what happened at Antioch and what significance it holds, and we can see that same level of disagreement in early Christian interpretations of the event. In the correspondence between Jerome and Augustine of Hippo the question of how to interpret Galatians 2 was one of the key topics that sparked the rancour that was to exist between the two men for many years. It features also in his Expositio epistulae ad Galatas. One of the more recently discovered Dolbeau sermons is also dedicated to this question of the interpretation of Galatians 2. The other place where reference to this scriptural text occurs is in seven places in De baptismo contra Donatistas. In this paper I suggest that perhaps one of the reasons why Augustine was so opposed to Jerome’s reading of Galatains 2, in which the disagreement between Peter and Paul was more apparent than real, was because without the reality of the conflict between the two apostles, he could not redeem Cyprian of Carthage from the clutches of the Donatists without having Cyprian, like Peter, being wrong and capable of being rebuked and willing to be corrected. While Matthew Gaumer has explored Augustine’s appeal to Cyprian he has not considered this particular aspect of the importance of Galatians 2 in shaping Augustine’s argument, which will be explored here.
|
Disputed Christian Identities in North Africa: A View of the Current Landscape
Program Unit: Inventing Christianity: Apostolic Fathers, Apologists, and Martyrs
Geoffrey D. Dunn, Australian Catholic University
Abstract to come later.
|
Paul, Bodily Difference, and the Politics of the Universal: Reading Romans 7 with and against Contemporary Philosophers
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
Ben Dunning, Fordham University
This paper critically engages representative readings of Romans 7 in Continental philosophy as they function to support articulations of universalism that attempt to eschew identity politics. I begin with an analysis of Jacques Lacan’s psychoanalytic interpretation of Romans 7 and then turn to Slavoj Žižek’s appropriation of Lacan’s reading. For Žižek, Romans 7 can be read in terms of what he calls the problem of perversion: the law by its act of prohibition necessarily gives rise to the desire for its own infringement. In unplugging from this cycle, Žižek sees the possibility for a new politics of the universal and a new order of theopolitical solidarity. But in the process—and as part of his polemic against “identity politics”—the distinctives (and attendant dilemmas) of embodied difference recede from view. By way of critique, then, the paper goes on to offer a counter-reading of Romans 7, one that builds on several different trajectories of biblical scholarship: the significance of the Adam-Christ typology, Paul’s use of prosôpopoiia, and the intriguing insight that the narrator echoes not Adam’s language, but Eve’s. I suggest that the chapter’s much-debated first-person pronoun may be treated as an anthropologically significant moment of textual undecidability. The ambiguity of this figure—invoking Eve’s words in the primal scene, yet resolving the conflict with resort to the Pauline two-anthrôpos paradigm—points suggestively toward the interplay of Eve’s presence and absence, a gendered shadow haunting the androcentric self-assurance of the Pauline text. In this way, the anthropological complexities of Romans cannot be fully neutered, as Žižek would have it. Rather, the never-totally-excluded trace of bodily difference troubles the stability of the Pauline typological frame. As such, it calls into question nothing less than the anthropological coherence of the system as a whole—and by extension that system’s pretensions to represent adequately and fully a theological space in which to situate a “universal” human subject.
|
Religio without Religion: Reflections on Recent Debates in Roman Religion and Religious Studies
Program Unit: Religious World of Late Antiquity
Andrew Durdin, University of Chicago
In his recent work on the emergence of the distinctly modern category of religion, Brent Nongbri argues against supposed “premature births” of religion in antiquity. Although Nongbri rightly emphasizes the discontinuity of these moments with the modern birth of religion, the question still remains: if these moments were not forerunners to the modern category of religion then how should we understand their importance within the modern study of religion? By way of answering, this paper examines the case of ancient Rome and argues that although the intellectual proliferation in the “age of Cicero” cannot be considered a historical antecedent to religion, a constellation of concepts nonetheless emerged from a distinct discursive formation during this time. Building on recent research in the field of Roman religion I explore how these might provide a useful set of comparanda for analyzing the modern discursive formation from which the category of religion emerged.
|
"Not like Cain": Marking Moral Boundaries through Vilification of the Other in I Jn 3:1–18
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Jim Dvorak, Oklahoma Christian University
This paper explains why M. Bakhtin's notions of language are important to linguistic theorizing, and specifically to Hallidayan Systemic-Functional Linguistics (SFL). The bedrock tenet of the SFL paradigm is its characterization of language as a social semiotic, with ongoing attention to three semantic functions (ideational, interpersonal, textual). The emerging framework can be used to analyze the treatment of "The Other" in the First Epistle of John, specifically in 3:1-18.
|
Participles and Syntactic Variation in Biblical Hebrew
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Janet Dyk, Eep Talstra Centre, VU University Amsterdam
Having in their morphology both verbal and nominal aspects, participles can function governed by a head of a nominal or prepositional phrase (phrase level), as a head of a clause constituent (clause level), or as a main verb alongside other verbal forms in a text (text-hierarchical level). By means of the Eep Talstra Centre for Bible and Computer database, the distribution of all participle constructions in the Hebrew Bible will be charted as to their functioning at the aforementioned syntactic levels. A single set of linguistic rules accounts for the behavior of the participle in all contexts. This set can be used to gauge the relative frequency of the various syntactic functions of the participle throughout the Hebrew Bible. Only after quantifying the presence and frequencies of a broad set of structures evidencing variation in Biblical Hebrew is it permissible to hypothesize as to the reasons for the differences. Once inventoried, the data can be searched for clustering of characteristics which could point to a specific explanation for the differing proportions in which the syntactic possibilities are used.
|
Women of Genesis on a Pedestal: Hannah King’s Mormon Exegesis
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Amy Easton-Flake, Brigham Young University
When Hannah Tapfield King published her pamphlet Women of the Scriptures (1878) and dedicated it to “the Young Ladies of Utah . . . [from] their affectionate elder sister,” her work became part of the growing body of women’s biblical exegesis. King’s social and religious background first as a wealthy, devout Anglican living in Cambridge and later as a financially challenged, faithful Mormon living in Utah makes her a particularly intriguing exegete as her sketches reflects both faith traditions. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (most commonly known as the “Mormon Church” in the nineteenth century) was founded in western New York in 1830. Although its prophet and founder, Joseph Smith, introduced a new book of scripture called the Book of Mormon, the Bible remained the primary religious text for Mormons in the nineteenth century. Distinct Mormon theology did, however, influence men and women’s interpretations of the Bible, particularly in regards to polygamy, the Fall, gospel knowledge and keys possessed by the patriarchs, and the role of women. Though King was not avant-garde in either her exegetical approach or the place she offered women, she did expand women’s agency and help them recognize the latent power that came as they strove to live up to an ideal within their familial roles and relationship with God. Particularly interesting is her re-writing of Eve’s story solely in terms of motherhood, but a motherhood that places her next to God, and her exegesis on Hagar as solely a mother (as opposed to a slave or plural wife), but a mother who is an active agent calling down heavenly help to save her and her child. Through her work we see how Mormon women negotiated what they saw as their divinely appointed familial roles with their desire for agency and self-definition as well as how their unique Mormon theology influenced not only their understanding of the Bible but also how they interpreted their daily actions.
|
Making a Case for the Origin of the First Edition of Deuteronomy in the Persian Period
Program Unit: Book of Deuteronomy
Diana Edelman, Independent Scholar
The ancient scroll of Deuteronomy was conceived by a single author, who created it as a long speech by Moses to Israel on the eve of entry into the Promised Land. It recapitulates the people’s covenantal experience of their God at Mt. Horeb and during the wilderness wandering, before setting out the divine teaching that is to apply when the people are in the Promised Land, framing this in terms of a loyalty oath or treaty, where the teachings constitute the stipulations. The subsequent changes to the original work are not likely to constitute more than 10% of the current scroll, so most of it reflects the intentions of its implied author.
Three main considerations point to the creation of this work in the Persian period. First is the emphasis on the covenant between the people directly and its god, which constitutes it as a holy nation rather than a political polity. This suggests a historical situation when the monarchy no longer exists and a native king no longer can function as the intermediary between god and people. The almost total absence of any reference to a king indicates his dispensability in the religiously conceived people of Israel, and when he is mentioned, once, in what is often argued to be a later addition (17:17–19), he becomes a pious reader of Torah, not its ultimate enforcer. This makes explicit what already was implicit about the absence of a functioning native king. Torah enforcement has devolved upon Levitical priests and an appointed head judge (17:8–10; 19:17; 21:5).
Second is the conception of the divine consistently as YHWH Elohim, never as YHWH Sebaot, the former deity of the kingdom of Judah. This new deity has a single place it will choose in the Promised Land for its name to dwell, and the people will visit the sanctuary three times a year to participate in pilgrimage festivals. The deity is made manifest in its Torah kept inside the Ark, which is in the charge of the Levites. In the monarchic period, there were Yahwistic shrines and temples throughout Judah, and it is likely YHWH Sebaot and his Asherah were made manifest by massebot and in some instances, divine statues. The creation of a centralized temple was a feature of Yehud and Samaria in the Persian period.
Thirdly, the acceptance and application of this book within Samarian circles is likely to have resulted from the participation of their literati with those in Yehud in framing a new, common sense of religious identity for the people of Israel, whose membership included descendants of 12 sibling tribes. Such a situation presupposes the early Persian period and is not easily placed during the monarchic period.
|
Neo-Babylonian Policy in Judah
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Diana Edelman, Center for Advanced Study, Oslo
Two views of Neo-Babylonian imperial policy in the region of Judah after its conquest remain current: one is that they did virtually nothing and imposed at most, minimal administrative presence; they considered this a no-man’s land and deliberately left it a frontier area on the border of Egypt. Its most recent proponent has been Avi Faust (The Archaeology of Destruction), who has characterized it as a post-collapse society. The other is that the Neo-Babylonians set up the region as a province, whose seat was located at Mizpah, and that they extracted taxes from the local inhabitants, as they did everywhere. These different views are attempts to interpret the same data: reduced settlement in Judah and Benjamin after 586 BCE; the failure of the Neo-Babylonian court to resettle the area by forced immigration; the relative lack of archaeological evidence for the introduction of a new infrastructure in the region; the concurrent destruction of Philistia and its lack of resettlement; and the biblical description of the area as an “empty land.”
To break what seems to be an impasse, developments elsewhere in the Empire need to be taken into consideration. Philistia and Judah, who had entered into an anti-Babylonian alliance with Egypt, were treated harshly to set an example of the fate of disobedient vassals; mass deportations supplied a needed labor force to build Nebuchadnezzar’s new palace complex along the outskirts of Babylon and to undertake building projects in Borsippa. The unexpected thirteen-year siege of Tyre (186-573 BCE), which required extended manpower and resources, could account for a delay in immediate forced resettlement. A possible unsuccessful invasion of Egypt in 568 BCE when civil war broke out there indicates an early imperial plan to conquer Egypt, but a needed campaign against insurgents in Cilicia under Neriglissar shifted imperial focus, and under Nabonidus, after quashing two more uprisings in Cilicia, interest seems to have shifted away from Egypt to Arabia. The implications for policy in the hill-country of Judah will be presented.
|
Northern Trends Regarding the Composition and Transmission of Deuteronomy: An Overview
Program Unit: Book of Deuteronomy
Cynthia Edenburg, Open University of Israel
The presentation reviews and evaluates the major trends in research regarding a northern, Samarian context for the composition and transmission of Deuteronomy.
|
Joshua 7–8 and Pentateuchal Law: Paradigm, Illustrative Narrative, or Legal Midrash?
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Cynthia Edenburg, Open University of Israel
This paper deals with both methodological and literary aspects in investigating the relationship between law and narrative. Firstly, Biblical narratives might reflect legal practices that are not presumed by the Biblical law corpora. Secondly, narrative may employ a literary motif found in a law without actually evoking the law itself. Parallels in circumstances, rulings and wording do not necessary establish literary relationship, since both the narrative and the Biblical law may presume the same common legal practice. Thus, strict criteria are necessary to establish that a literary relationship does exist between a Biblical narrative and Biblical law. Even then, the nature of the relationship must still be explained. A narrative may be designed as a paradigmatic situation that gave birth to a law; or the narrative might be drafted in order to illustrate the law’s application. Finally, a narrative might employ elements of a law in an exegetical or haggadic fashion. In this paper I shall employ the three categories of legal paradigm, illustrative narrative and legal midrash in examining the relationship between the complex narrative in Josh 7:1-8:29 and different Pentateuchal laws, such as Deut 7:25-26, 13:16-18, 17:2-5, 20:10-18, 21:22-23; Lev 26:40; Num 5:6-7.
|
The Christian Interpretation of the Qur'an in Syriac Literature
Program Unit: The Qur’an and the Biblical Tradition (IQSA)
Salah Mahgoub Edris, Cairo University
Arameans and Syrian Christians were always well connected to Arab culture and life. Prior to the rise of Islam Syrians stood in close relationship to the Arab tribes, for instance the Ghassanid and Mundhir tribes, especially since the Ghassanids were followers of the Syriac “Jacobite” Church. Some Syriac historical documents offer important information about the history of the Ghassanid and Mundhir Emirates, The Days/Wars of the Arabs before Islam. The relevant Syriac documents for that period are Eusebius of Caesarea’s Church History, the History of Joshua the Stylite, the Church History of John the Asian and others. Some Syriac authors may well have been familiar with specific genres of Arabic literature, for instance that of maqamat, traditional rhymed prose literature, yet whether or not they knew Arabic proverbs and literary prose from the period prior to Islam is not clear.
The current research project focuses on the circumstances or the context of Christian Syriac writing and Christian writers who quoted verses of the Qur’an from the rise of Islam until the present days. It examines especially the norms of Qur’anic citation in Syriac and in Christian Arabic writings.
|
Murderous Wife and Tragic Hero: An Early Female Interpretation of Eve’s Fall
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Robert G. T. Edwards, Wycliffe College
This paper will investigate Eudocia’s early fifth century interpretation of Eve’s temptation and Fall, a section of one of the earliest remaining female biblical interpretations. Aelia Eudocia Augusta, the classically educated wife of Emperor Theodosius II, retold the biblical account of the creation and fall of humanity (among other biblical events) by rearranging lines and half-lines from Homer’s Iliad and Odyssey; this type of work is referred to as a cento – that is, a “stitching together.” This retelling of the biblical narrative is in fact a biblical interpretation, in that Eudocia makes interpretive choices by selecting lines from the Homeric corpus in order to shed light on what she considers to be central to the biblical text itself. By taking such a view of Eudocia’s Homeric cento, I am seeking to correct the balance of scholarship, which sees Eudocia primarily as a student of Homer, often at the expense of her interest in, and knowledge of, the Bible. Instead, it will be shown that Eudocia is an able biblical interpreter, often using the well-known events and characters in Homer’s epics to illuminate aspects of the biblical narrative. In this passage, her interpretive choices reveal more precisely what the serpent’s offer to Eve was, who was at fault for the Fall, and what it effected. As the title of the paper indicates, Eudocia interprets the passage in such a way that Eve is representative of, or at least stands in line with, the Greek epic tradition of the weak, wicked, and conniving woman, wreaking havoc upon the race of men.
|
Targumim - Translation and Interpretation
Program Unit:
Beate Ego, Ruhr-Universtität Bochum
This paper first gives an overview of the different types of translation that we encounter in Targum literature. Following this, the interpretative character of these translations is pointed out. The first part of this paper gives a general overview of current research while the second part addresses further questions of Targum research that are based on these results. The main focus will lie on the relation between Targumim and Rabbinical literature in a narrower sense. It needs to be examined as to whether Targumim have an own profile of motifs that distinguishes them from the interpretations of Talmud and Midrash.
|
"To Those Who Are Sanctified in Christ" (1 Cor 1:2): A Contribution to the "in Christ" Debate
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Kathy Ehrensperger, Prifysgol Cymru, Y Drindod Dewi Sant - University of Wales, Trinity Saint David
Schweitzer’s insights on the importance of ‘participation in Christ’ in Paul’s letters rather than settling a debate has triggered a stream of new questions, not least of all Sanders’ recognition that Schweitzer did not come to clear conclusions what it ‘really means’, and Stanley Stowers has commented ‘that apocalyptic did not explain (that is, provide a context for) the central idea of participation.’ Although a link has been proposed by Käsemann with the notion that ‘in Christ’ denotes the sphere of power of Christ’s lordship, this also did not settle the question of ‘what it really means’. One presupposition, which seems to dominate many approaches, is that ‘?? ???st?’ refers to a ‘reality’ which implies the same for all Christ-followers. But the question is whether there is one such central or uniform idea of ‘participation in Christ’ in the Pauline letters at all. This is not to deny that what is expressed with ‘?? ???st?’ is central, but only to question whether a universal meaning is implied. The multifaceted aspects, which Paul expresses, seem to resist any uniformity of perception. What it ‘really means’ may be multifaceted and multidimensional. With these caveats in mind I will focus here on one aspect of ‘in Christ’ language, which catches the eye in the very opening of 1 Corinthians where Paul labels those addressed as ‘sanctified in Christ Jesus’ (1 Cor 1.2).
|
Citizens of Heaven and Residents of Philippi, but No Ekklesia?
Program Unit: Polis and Ekklesia: Investigations of Urban Christianity
Kathy Ehrensperger, Prifysgol Cymru, Y Drindod Dewi Sant - University of Wales, Trinity Saint David
It is remarkable that nowhere in this letter does Paul refer to the addressees as ekklesia nor does he refer to himself as apostle. In the passage often taken as using ekklesia for the addressees, Phil. 4.15, this term does not refer to the latter but to other ekklesiai, the addressees being referred to as ?µe?? F???pp?s???. The question thus arising is, who are those ‘saints in Christ Jesus who are in Philippi’ (1.1)? And who is Paul for them ? The only other letter where Paul does not refer to the addressees as ekklesia is Romans. It is evident that Paul did not found Christ-following groups in Rome, and this might explain his reluctance to use the term ekklesia in this letter; he nevertheless claims the title of apostle in relation to the Christ-followers from the nations there thus legitimating his writing to them. The absence of both the term ekklesia for the addressees, and the title apostle in the letter to the Philippians is thus a bit of an enigma. According Acts 16.14-15 Paul did establish a Christ-following community in Philippi, hence one would expect that he would refer to himself as their apostle and to them as ? ?????s?a ?? F???pp??? or similar. The friendly tone of the letter has lead to the proposal of a number of paradigms to capture what appears to be a special relationship between Paul and the Philippians, such as friendship or patronage.The absence of terms ekklesia and apostle is often neglected or attributed to mere chance. In this paper I will explore whether the absence of both terms is interlinked, and indicates a more complicated relation between Paul and the Philippians than the friendly tone might lead us assume. It might be an indication that something contextual is involved having to do with the consolidation of Roman domination in the colony of Philippi at the time, which would preclude the use of these terms.
|
What Is a Cherub?
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Raanan Eichler, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
The cherub is a type of creature mentioned some 90 times in the Hebrew Bible, where it is portrayed as being closely associated with the God of Israel and serving as the predominant motif in Israelite iconography. What is it? Many hypotheses have been put forth, but the prevailing view in modern scholarship is that the cherub is a winged sphinx, i.e. a winged human-headed lion. In this paper, analysis of the relevant biblical texts and investigation of ancient Near Eastern visual art lead to the conclusion that the cherub cannot be a winged sphinx and is probably a winged human.
|
A Farewell to the Anti-cultic Prophet: Attitudes towards the Cult in the Book of Amos
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Göran Eidevall, Uppsala Universitet
The first part of this paper offers a very short survey of scholarship on Amos and the cult. Many earlier studies pursued “the quest for the historical Amos.” This (hypothetical) person has been portrayed either as a cultic functionary or, more often, as decidedly anti-cultic. However, in the light of extant sources on prophecy in the Ancient Near East the very concept of an anti-cultic prophet looks suspiciously anachronistic. A shift of emphasis is called for: from the prophet to the book. In this study of the attitudes toward priests and cult that are expressed by the book of Amos I shall therefore refrain from biographical speculations. In the second part, a number of passages in Amos containing cultic references are analyzed from a rhetorical and contextual perspective. As regards the “cult-critical” passages (4:4-5; 5:4-5; 5:21-24), it is shown that they are compatible with a basically positive attitude toward sacrifices. It is, moreover, argued that it is of vital importance to take geographical and chronological aspects into account, in order to make sense of the differing attitudes to cultic matters that are juxtaposed in this prophetic book. In the third and final part, an attempt is made to relate the results of the analysis to some overarching themes and concerns in the Book of the Twelve.
|
The Distinction between the ’almanâ and the ’iššâ-’almanâ in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Cody Eklov, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion
Scholars have long discussed the distinguishing characteristic(s) and social status of the ’almanâ ("widow") in the Hebrew Bible. However, an important usage of this word has gone yet unnoticed in scholarship, namely its appearance following the common noun ’iššâ (“wife, woman”). Translators inevitably render this construction as “widow woman” or simply “widow,” overlooking the distinction that the pairing indicates. This article argues that the construction ’iššâ-’almanâ represents a particular usage that designates a widow who has one or more living sons, as opposed to simply ’almanâ, which is a general term that refers to a widow who may or may not have living male offspring. In the biblical corpus, the construction ’iššâ-’almanâ occurs five times in four different passages, and each contains explicit reference to living male offspring. Although the evidence is limited to only four passages and there is no comparable construction in any other Semitic language, the word-pairing seems to be a particular designation for the biblical author(s).
|
The Christian and Jewish Context of the Qur’an’s Enemies
Program Unit: The Qur’an and the Biblical Tradition (IQSA)
Emran El-Badawi, University of Houston
This paper investigates the identity of those whom the Qur’an explicitly condemns and against whom it warns. In this vein, the Qur’an’s enemies include rebels (kuffar), associators (mushrikun), hypocrites (munafiqun), those gone astray (dallun), and others. I argue, principally through the rhetoric of these condemnations and warnings, that these “enemies” are none other than the salient Christians and Jews of late antiquity (ca. 2nd-7th century CE). More specifically, in conflict with the Qur’an’s strict revision of monotheistic doctrine (tawhid) are the institutions of the Eastern Churches and Rabbinic Judaism.
I support my argument further by adducing late antique Biblical and post-biblical evidence, especially the Hebrew Bible and Syriac Christian writings, including Narsai, Jacob of Serugh, John of Ephesus and Babai the Great. I make sparing use of early Islamic exegesis where original insights support my argument, especially the works attributed to Ibn ‘Abbas, Mujahid b. Jabr, and those known to originate from Muqatil, Ibn Qutaybah and Tabari.
This paper will naturally build upon the work of modern scholarly research as well. These include, Gabriel Reynolds, Fred Donner, Gerald Hawting and John Wansbrough. It also expands upon the research of my earlier article on “Condemnation in the Qur’an and the Syriac Gospel of Matthew” in New Perspectives on the Qur’an: The Qur’an in Its Historical Context 2. Ed. G.S. Reynolds. London; New York: Routledge, 2011.
|
1QSamuel—A Variant Literary Edition of 2 Samuel
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Historical Books
Torleif Elgvin, NLA Høgskolen
The fragments of 1QSamuel, found in Cave 1 by de Vaux in 1949, were published in DJD 1 (1955). With one small exception the fragments derive from the end of the scroll and preserve parts of chs. 20, 21, and 23. Barthelemy noted that the scroll did not contain 2 Sam 24, and suggested that the scribe could have attached this chapter to a scroll of Kings.
A material analysis of the fragments shows that this scroll departed even more from the later masoretic recension. Barthelemy’s assertion of a scroll with forty lines should be revised. Only five of the eight appendices to 2 Samuel in chs. 21–24 were present in this recension, and the sequence of the appendices is different from the later canonical order. This scroll, copied in the early Herodian period, did not contain the psalm of ch. 22 (=Ps 18), the story of the census in ch. 24, and the story of the killing of Saul’s relatives (21:1-14). Thus, 1QSamuel shows a stage in the literary growth of Samuel before the book had reached its final form. Two of the minuses are stories about transgresssion and expiation that may be explained as belonging to one late literary layer.
The recension of 1QSamuel represents a documentary confirmation and refinement of Karl Budde’s (1903) outlining of the editorial process behind 2 Samuel. It shows light on the development of the varied textual tradition of the books of Samuel in Hebrew and Greek. A tentative outline of some of the editorial processes behind 1–2 Samuel will be suggested.
|
Mother Abraham: Ancient Christian and Jewish Mothers Valiantly Sacrificing Their Children
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Kathleen Gallagher Elkins, Rutgers University
The trope of a mother heroically sacrificing her child/ren appears in a number of ancient Jewish and Christian texts, from the books of the Maccabees (2 Maccabees 7 and 4 Maccabees 8-18), to Josephus’s Jewish War (see the narrative about Mary cannibalizing her infant son in 6.201-213), to later martyrdom narratives (for example, the Martyrdom of Marian and James and the Martyrdom of Montanus and Lucius). While the details of the narratives vary, there is a common emphasis on the suffering of the about-to-be-sacrificed child or children, on the one hand, and the bravery (and sometimes joy) of the mother, on the other hand. These narratives often involve some emphasis on corporeality: the suffering maternal body and the physical pain of her child are highlighted to heighten the pathos of the moment. In this paper, I will reflect on the theme of matrilineage as it relates to these sacrificed children: why is the maternal body such a focus in these texts? Why a mother and not a father (that is, why matrilineage and not patrilineage)? Why is the suffering of the child (and sometimes the mother) presented as necessary or inevitable, like the pain of childbirth? The pain of childbirth itself produces a new life or, rather, produces two new identities from one (a singular woman becomes a mother and her child). Likewise, these narratives about bravely suffering mothers and their sacrificed children are from historical moments that can be broadly characterized as times of loss, change (sometimes violent change), and communal rupture. The use of mothers and children in this context is not accidental or incidental, but indicates the need for a community to reflect on productive pain and the creation of new identities in the midst of traumatic change, vulnerability, and loss.
|
The Psalms as a Book of Theology in Part of the Reformed Tradition
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Mark W. Elliott, University of St. Andrews
The emphasis on the Psalms as a collection of diverse voices and theologies in recent times has been if anything reinforced by the acceptance that a ‘wisdom-Torah’ redaction shaped the early Psalms (so, Zenger.) Even apparent attempts to sketch uniform themes flatter to deceive: H.-J. Kraus’s Theology of the Psalms (1979/ET 1986) regards the Psalter as a window on to the religious, worshipping life of Ancient Israel at various times and places. For this reason it is not easy to regard the texts as speaking theology to the reader, let alone be able to discern common threads. Of course the theme of Messiah, or rather, the voice of the promised king (p. 176) is, for Kraus, the ‘cantus firmus ’ of the Psalms, which the New Testament reception of them confirms by its echo. It seems for Kraus as though it is only with the NT that one can get a theology of the Psalms, when at last they are no longer tied to Ancient Israel’s history. Hence with the ‘today’ of Psalm 2:7 one moves into the eternal ‘now’: the relevant Psalms are understood a-temporally: this with a debt to Augustine. The Psalms as prayers have ben fulfilled in Christ, for example Ps 69:9 ‘zeal for thy house’ and 118:22-24 (the stone the builders rejected) reinforce the theme of Christ’s suffering and uniqueness. Kraus’s work here is useful, but it does not consider enough just what the OT Psalms themselves bring to the conversation between the Testaments. It might ssem predictable to propose that pre-moderns in the Reformed tradition provide the answer. Calvin’s theocentrism combined with an interest in spirituality of salvation makes his Psalms commentary as ‘a pastoral variation of the Institutes’. (H.J. Selderhuis, Calvin’s Theology of the Psalms, p. 284) Yet for all his insights, Calvin’s weakness is one of ‘the other extreme’: reading the Psalter is about seeing a timeless God reflected in the experience of the reader. In early modern Reformed controversies, Moses Amyraut insisted that a Church that read the Psalms together, stayed together. The Psalter was common to many forms of Christian religious cult. But just as the synagogue before it, the Reformed Church could not simply allow the Psalms to have a liturgical purpose without using them as a resource for theology. The paper will focus on an alternative Reformed tradition, from A. Alesius (d.1565), W. Musculus (d.1563) and R. Rollock (d.1597).
|
Rewriting Evil: The Epistle of James and the Jobraham Narratives
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Nicholas J. Ellis, University of Oxford
In this paper I argue that the author of James engages in a long-established reading of the trials of Abraham and Job wherein the author assimilates the two trials to mitigate divine agency and to highlight human patience.
The Epistle of James opens with a mitigation of divine responsibility for testing or temptation (Jas 1:13–14). As the Epistle unfolds, however, the author engages in a close reading of well-known biblical testing narratives: the Binding of Isaac (Jas 2:21–24) and the suffering of Job (Jas 5:9–11). Is this juxtaposition between open theological apologetic and the use of potentially conflicting biblical narrative intentional or unintentional? Is it a demonstration of the author’s theological incoherence or rhetorical and hermeneutical acumen?
When we examine the history of reception of Abraham and Job, we find that these two figures are frequently read in unison. Many ancient texts show unease with certain implications of both the Job and Abraham narratives. While Abraham’s exemplary patience under trial is characterised especially by his refusal to ‘speak words’ against God, the canonical account of Abraham’s test at the Aqedah allows for a potentially compromising role of God as Tester (Gen 22:1). In contrast to the Abraham narrative, the Job story provides a famously robust cosmic drama with clearly defined roles and responsibilities. However, Job narrative also portrays its human protagonist as potentially self-righteous and a ‘speaker of words’ against God’s integrity. To solve these problems, a number of intra-canonical readings of these two narratives was developed within ancient Judaism. Authors saw within these two narratives an exegetical solution that could solve a compromised cosmology on the one hand and a compromised anthropology on the other. In literature such as Jubilees, 4Q225, the Testament of Abraham and Genesis Rabbah retellings of Abraham’s trials interweave language and imagery from Job’s cosmic vision to mitigate the implications of a God who tests. In these and other ancient texts exemplary anthropological features drawn from traditional Abraham legends suppress Job’s less salutary characteristics. In this manner, these two figures become inter-canonical interpretive solutions capable of solving a variety of theological and hermeneutical problems.
In light of these Jewish readings of Job and Abraham, I propose that this ‘Jobraham’ solution is likewise operative in James’ hermeneutic. Within a discourse heavily dependent on the language and theology of probation, the author’s appeal to both Tested Abraham and Patient Job is neither unrelated nor accidental. Rather, the author’s desire to construct for his readers an example of the perfect, tested person and the perfect righteous God leads him to interweave material from both biblical narratives. The author’s reworking of Job’s character in conformity with Abraham’s patience under trial results in the Patient Job of Jas 5. The author’s engagement with the Aqedah in Jas 2 in light of his apologetic statements in Jas 1:13–15 is possible due to an assimilation of Job’s cosmology into Abraham’s trial.
|
Joined in Life and Death: The Sarcophagus of Catervius and Severina
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Mark D. Ellison, Vanderbilt University
While some strands of early Christian tradition expected the dissolution of this world’s familial structures in the next, other evidence points to a different perspective in which the married relationship, seen as divinely sanctioned, continues in some way to be a part of Christian identity in the hereafter. One example is the sarcophagus of Catervius and Severina in Tolentino, Italy. Commissioned by Severina upon death of her husband in the 380s CE, this funerary monument is intriguing for its potential insight on the perspectives of a Christian woman, but the few existing publications have not undertaken much interpretation of its overall iconographic program or its social and religious functions, let alone Severina’s distinctive voice. An analysis of the sarcophagus’s iconography and inscriptions (some of which have never been published in English), seen in concert with comparable artifacts and texts, clarifies Severina’s visual presentation of being “joined” to Catervius in life and in death, and allows us to locate Severina among Christians who held a range of beliefs in heavenly reunion and continuing marital identity. The artifacts and texts brought into the comparative analysis include key texts of the New Testament (e.g., Mt. 19:4-6; 22:30 and parallels; 2 Tim. 4:8; 1 Pet. 3:7); the sarcophagus of Bassa, the Velletri plaque, gold-glass couple portraits, Proba’s Cento De Laudibus Christi, Jerome’s letter 57 to Theodora, and Tertullian’s On Monogamy.
|
Body or Body Politic: Constructions of Pain in Individual Lament Psalms
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible and Cognate Literature
Barat Ellman, Fordham University and Jewish Theological Seminary
Pain is a notoriously difficult sensation to represent verbally in all languages and cultures. While producers of pain (e.g. burns, lashings, wounds) may be identified objectively and the phenomenology of pain scientifically defined as a sensation generated by nociceptors, the perception and the experience of pain itself is subjective. It can neither be verified nor shared.Nevertheless, the construction of pain in literature, including biblical literature, may be a function of larger cultural factors, or to use Talal Assad’s terminology, “the dominant discourse.” By examining expressions of pain (and/or suffering) in 8-10 individual lament psalms, this paper will demonstrate the relationship between a national discourse of Israel’s experiences and the terms and lexical units employed by the psalmist. I hope to demonstrate that the psalmist’s representation of his pain and suffering is conditioned by the national experience of famine, drought and conquest by enemies and that, ultimately, it cannot denote actual perception but a cultural idea of what is perceived.
|
Uses of the Exodus Tradition in the Past and Present: A Response
Program Unit: Jewish-Christian Dialogue and Sacred Texts
Barat Ellman, Fordham University and Jewish Theological Seminary
This paper will respond to the others presented, with a special focus on the ways in which the exodus theme is put to polemical use, historically and/or in contemporary debate.
|
Rembrandt: A Biblical Interpreter?
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
David Emanuel, Nyack College
Genesis 22:10-12 succinctly captures a moment in biblical literary history in which an angel of God prevents Israel’s most revered patriarch, Abraham, from taking the life of his only son and heir, Isaac. Even after a cursory reading of the text, however, numerous interpretational challenges arise—such as the mysterious change in divine voice, and Isaac’s willingness to comply with the attempted sacrifice. Rembrandt’s painting, Abraham’s Sacrifice, vividly brings these few verses to life, enabling a reader of the biblical text to visualize the literary-historical drama as it unfolds. In addition to visualizing this event, however, Rembrandt’s painting opens a dialogue with the biblical text by filling in literary gaps in the passage, and addressing difficult questions raised by the biblical writer. The present paper explores aspects of this dialogue between the written text and visual implementation. It first briefly outlines some of the interpretive challenges presented in Genesis 22:10-12, and then continues by elaborating on ways in which Rembrandt relates to the problems via his artwork. Moreover, Rembrandt’s answers to questions raised by the text are additionally compared with the work of later biblical exegetes. Ultimately, the present paper arrives at the conclusion that Rembrandt’s painting, Abraham’s Sacrifice, is not just a stunning visualization of a biblical text, but an impressive work of biblical interpretation.
|
Retaining Sinai and Yahweh: The Contours of Engaging with God’s Presence in Three Parts: Babel-Sinai-Pentecost
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Brad Embry, Northwest University (Washington)
Retaining Sinai and Yahweh: The Contours of Engaging with God’s Presence in Three Parts: Babel-Sinai-Pentecost
|
My Beloved Is a Bass Line: “De-colonial,” Pop Musical Interventions in the Politics of Love as a Cultural Practice
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Heidi Epstein, University of Saskatchewan
What meanings might be produced from the Song of Song’s amatory and horticultural language if it is read with a sense of love as irreducibly “de-colonial”? For Chela Sandoval (and other postcolonial theorists), ‘true love’ materialises in the “double consciousness”, interstitial agency and “tactical sign-reading”--the “semiotic technology of the oppressed”--with which colonized subjects deconstruct “Euro-American artifacts” such as “love …work…soul…knowledge” so as to redefine them in de-colonial terms (Sandoval, 2000: 138-46). Such “revolutionary love” in turn generates “social erotics”—coalition-building across disparate oppositional groups and academic disciplinary boundaries (Sandoval 2002: 23ff.). Womanists and U.S. third-world feminists forged an indispensable lexicon with which to build this new “eccentric” model of love-as-political hermeneutic, imaginative space, and anti-colonial activism (ibid.).
1. I shall construct a womanist intertextual matrix for the Song to illustrate the pertinence of such a hermeneutic shift. In Alice Walker’s search for African American “mothers’ gardens,” gardens and songs compose an ambivalent metonymic economy. They correlate lost possibility and defiant creativity, slave labour and indigenous freedom. For Walker, songs as gardens and gardens as songs trigger haunted longing as much as sensual delight: they are goads to inter-generational remembrance, social rebellion and public grieving. Toni Morrison’s ‘commentary’ on the Song (Beloved) circulates similar socio-political energies both within the text and among those who read it.
2. Such intertexts chasten the whiteness of, not only earlier ‘eccentric’ readings of the Song that contested its historical role in the sexist, heteronormative politics of love as a cultural practice (Boer, Exum, Moore, Moore and Burrus), but also 1) Roland Boer’s “economic” reading of the Song’s land, crops and animals as an “inexplicably self-producing, work-free realm” (2009:11-14); and 2) Fiona Black’s construal of the Shulammite’s “darkness” as a non-racialised opacity that affords romantic agency (2006: 172-74; 177f.). The de-colonial intertexts I assemble beg a re-signification of the Song’s musicality (i.e., the Song as song), its garden imagery, its female protagonist’s blackness and her vineyard migrations in terms that critically intervene in the racial and economic politics of love as a cultural practice.
3. The final section of the paper offers one such critical intervention. Given that music figures centrally in Walker’s, Morrisons’s and Sandoval’s genealogies of love, a de-colonial reading of the Song mandates the construction of a counter-hegemonic musical archive within religious discourses of sacred eroticism: if the Shulammite’s erotic longing and seeking are re-read as “nomadic” and “trickster”-esque, she begets a subaltern musical family tree that pointedly shifts the thematic content (and political uses) of the sacred erotic. Such a musico-biblical lineage is evoked for me today by the bass playing and protest singing of black and comely, bisexual Meshell Ndegeocello who beats back new watchmen-gone-global with her axe. I shall conclude with a few “shulammitic” tastes of Ndegeocello’s gardens and songs.
|
Transforming the Sacrificial Act into Images (and Texts)
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Dorothea Erbele-Küster, Faculte Universitaire de Theologie Protestante
I shall consider iconographic material from the ANE that is related to sacrifice, asking what implicit view of sacrifice it represents. Figurines portraying the bringing of an animal to be sacrificed and images with offering persons on seals shall be analyzed. The Mesopotamian scene as such is known as Einführungsszene vor einer Gottheit (Introduction to a deity). It may have had a protective function or as well as their impressions – indicating the owner‘s justification before the deity. The paper offers another understanding of it: a picture of someone offering a gift functions as the gift itself. The artifacts are evidence of a transformation of the very notion of sacrifice. The purpose of this paper is to understand this transformative process of the (idea of) sacrifice.
In a second step this may help to understand how the offeringtorot in Lev 1-7 functions beyond the First and Second Temple Period, i.e. in times where sacrifice at the Temple has been impossible.
|
Jubilees (Matshafa Kufale) in the Ethiopian Manuscript Tradition
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Ted Erho, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
Although fragments found among the Dead Sea Scrolls confirmed both the antiquity of the text and its Jewish origin, when studied as a whole in the modern era, Jubilees also needs to be understood as a product of a lengthy and often convoluted Christian transmissional process in Ethiopia, where it is known instead as Matshafa Kufale (the Book of Divisions). Indeed, the fourteen Hebrew copies from Qumran generally contain only a few fragmentary verses apiece, whereas the Ethiopic version is now found complete in approximately fifty known manuscripts, nearly twice the number available to VanderKam for his 1989 edition; many undiscovered others are doubtlessly also extant. Closer examination of the Ethiopic evidence in its native context reveals several interesting features, most notably a degree of regionality within the various text-types and an increasingly distinctive link between VanderKam’s group 1 of manuscripts (considered to be most akin to the ancient versions) and the area around Aksum, the ancient capital of the Ethiopian Empire. Other aspects are more peculiar, such as the lack of the same thoroughgoing textual revision ca. 1600 found in the other books of the Ethiopian Old Testament, including Enoch, but this suggests the likely antiquity of at least one strain of witnesses. Lastly, while debate over the scriptural status of Jubilees has simmered for centuries in Ethiopia, a survey of its placement within manuscripts and alongside other works supplies a prima facie case for its longstanding canonicity within ecclesiastical circles there.
|
Ex Eventu Prophetic Historiography in Babylonia and the Book of Daniel
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Ted Erho, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
Although a broadly-recognized component of the so-called Jewish “historical apocalypses”, their lengthy appeals to past history are often reduced in modern scholarship to identification of the alluded to figures and events. This approach ignores an important underlying matter, namely the purpose and function of not only these reviews, but the compositions in full. With few exceptions, such scholarship has also broadly neglected one of the most resemblant corpora of antecedent material, namely the ex eventu prophetic historiographical texts from ancient Babylonia. As with the Jewish texts, these documents contain substantial reviews of past events – mostly negative – followed by sudden reversals of fortune towards their ends, all cast as future predictions. Yet, whereas the Jewish texts are almost exclusively interpreted as products of the end of an era of great evil prior to a glorious future age, the Akkadian ones instead locate the reader as having just passed into the second period. Almost certainly composed by political elites during times of political uncertainty and upheaval, these go on to promise those who side with the author(s) abundant prosperity. In these cases, the historical reviews largely serve to disparage the political opposition of the present by linking it to events and leaders (especially foreign ones) deemed to have had a negative impact on the community, thereby further implicitly advocating a particular political choice. Leveraging the Uruk and Dynastic Prophecies as representative models, this paper will explore Daniel 7 and 8 in light of this comparative background both with respect to a) the use and selection of past events and b) the narrative point in time of the author.
|
Jeremiah 16: The Withdrawal of the Prophet’s Body and Its Representation of Israel
Program Unit: Writing/Reading Jeremiah
Johanna Erzberger, Institut Catholique de Paris
Jer. 16 formulates the denial of the body. Not only does Jeremiah have no sexual relations. Jeremiah is forbidden even those mourning rituals which symbolically harm the mourner’s body. While in other prophetic sign acts the prophet’s body represents the people in being harmed (cf. Isa 20:2-6; Ez 5:1-4), the prophet’s body is explicitly denied any basic function of representation. Most prophetic sign acts function by the disturbing impression of their performance of the prophet’s bodily representation of Israel’s future. In Jr. 16 the prophet’s body is withdrawn. While other sign acts are followed by an explanation, the audience becomes aware of the act and of its meaning only by means of Jeremiah’s word. The withdrawal and absence of the prophet’s body and the presence of his word stand in a tense but meaningful relation.
|
The Qur'an on Black and White: Exploring Possible Traces of Race and Racism in Tafsir
Program Unit: Qur’anic Studies: Methodology and Hermeneutics (IQSA)
Farid Esack, University of Johannesburg
Colours are interpreted in various ways and the words used to denote them can range from the exotic, particular when used for humans, to the outrageous. There are several colours mentioned in the Qur’an such as white, black, yellow and blue. White and black in some verses of the Qur’an are mentioned side-by-side and in other verses they are mentioned separately. The Arabic language as a Semitic-Levantine language - has a unique way in the description of colours, particularly white. For example, there are different descriptions of the degree of white/ness in the Arabic language: abya?, yaqaq, lahq, wadih, nasi’, hijan, khali?.
This paper examines the subject of colour in the light of the Qur’an and how some of the classical mufassirun of the Qur’an comment on the verses of the Qur’an in which some colours are mentioned. The focus of this paper is on the distinctive nature of two colours in the Qur’an: black and white. It examines how these may be or not be read with a view to examining the question of pigmentation and the related question of race and racism. More specifically, this paper considers whether the privileging of whiteness or blackness may have any implication for anti-Black racism.
|
Ideology and Bible Translation: How Can Performance Criticism Help?
Program Unit: Bible Translation
Nathan Esala, Lutheran Bible Translators
As a young idealistic Lutheran pastor and linguist coming from North America, living in a small village in Northern Ghana plunged me into contact with a space where ideologies that I had consciously or unconsciously lived with could not operate in the same way. From challenges of proclaiming the theology of the cross while socio-economically my life spoke a theology of glory, to the difficulty of just what constitutes a language among an acephalous multilingual group of clans, the ideological underpinnings of my North American takes on theology, socio-linguistics, and translation looked different, sometimes in challenging ways. My journey into the ideologies of Bible translation made me become a point of contact negotiating between different semiotic and ideological systems, between international, national, and local levels. I discovered Bible translation in Africa involves ideological communication exchange which takes place between multiple asymmetric systems of cultural power, which operate on two distinct levels: the international – national and the local, and most of the time, the two have different priorities. In any exchange where there is power disparity between cultural participants, local voices are reticent to freely express their agency. However, by prioritizing the oral medium, biblical performance criticism attempts to shift the balance of power in the communication exchange, empowering local voices to negotiate the exchange more freely at least within their own cultural system. I will explore some of the ideological benefits and detriments Biblical performance criticism creates as a tool to be used in communicating between and within cultural systems. I will especially focus on opportunities for local agency and opportunities for integration of cultural identity, by performing one’s self and one’s culture in the biblical stories.
|
Halvor Moxnes and the Social-Scientific Interpretation of the New Testament: An Appreciation
Program Unit: Gender, Sexuality, and the Bible
Philip Esler, University of Gloucestershire
Among Halvor Moxnes' contributions to scholarship on the New Testament are a number of significant contributions to its social-scientific interpretation. These include the monograph The Economy of the Kingdom: Social Conflict and Economic Relations in Luke's Gospel (Fortress, 1988), the edited work Constructing Early Christian Families: Family as Social Reality and Metaphor (Routledge, 1997), and many seminal essays on topics such as social relations, economic issues, patron-client relations, landscape and spatiality, gender, and identity. This paper will discuss these contributions and the important role they have played in New Testament interpretation in the last twenty-five years.
|
The oikos of Christ and the Church at Corinth: Understanding oikonomos and oikonomia in Paul's First Epistle to the Corinthians
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Mitchell Alexander Esswein, Princeton Theological Seminary
The cosmology of the Greco-Roman world was defined by structure and hierarchy in every realm of life. Each institution was a microcosm of the grander universe, and everything was stratified where each person had their proper place. In this article, I show that Paul intentionally framed his appeal for unity in Corinth upon these ideas of cosmic hierarchy and proper order through the image of household management. By asserting that he is an oikonomos in 4:1, Paul establishes himself as the steward of the community. He is the estate manager charged to regulate the home and ensure that stability persists. Later in v. 15 he calls himself the community's father. These seemingly paradoxical titles are best understood within the social context of Greco-Roman society, where slavery and household management were linked.
Concerning the image of the household, I focus on Xenophon's Oeconomicus. Although it is unlikely Paul read this text, or any others referenced in this paper, one can perceive potential parallels with Paul's epistle so as to gain a better understanding of his argument. The influence of Greco-Roman culture was so pervasive in the Mediterranean world that it is nearly impossible to point to a particular idea or thought and definitively establish it as Jewish, Greek, Roman, etc. Since Paul was a product of his time, his arguments are largely contingent on many social constructs of his day. For Xenophon, everyone in the household has a role to play and each was dependent on others to fulfill their duties. So it is in the Corinthian body. Paul, the oikonomos, needs his fellow brothers in Christ, and they too need him and one another. Paul desired greatly to foster solidarity amongst difference in the community. By orchestrating his argument in the realm of a household, he rhetorically builds a case for them to coexist in harmony.
This analysis begins with a brief survey of Greco-Roman conceptualization of the household (oikonomia) and slavery (oikonomos). 1 Cor 4:1 and 9:17 exemplify how these aspects influenced Paul's writing of the epistle since they pertain to oikonomia. Many scholars appeal to John Reumann as an authority on oikonomia in the New Testament, but his thesis on the subject is unsatisfactory, for the term has greater significance than just relating to God's plan for salvation. I conclude that Paul established this community to resemble a household that would have been found within the first century Greco-Roman world. He constructed this model to impart on the community the importance of hierarchy in the Church by appealing to his status as the oikonomos, which harkens back to the notion of proper household management.
|
Philo's Sabbath: A Study in Philo's Jewish Law
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Yedidya Etzion, University of California-Berkeley
Philo’s exposition of Jewish Law covers many areas, such as cultic laws, festivals, marital laws, and civil laws. The laws of the Sabbath provide an opportunity to touch upon matters with implications on broad issues such as Jewish identity, universalism vs. particularism, etc. and gain insights into Philo’s intellectual world as well as an understanding of his legal system.
Even with the initial mention of the Sabbath in the Bible, the laws pertaining to it combine purely technical aspects such as the injunction against lighting fire, as well as “positive” requirements that have a mental or even psycho-physic aspect such as the requirement to “rest” or to “delight” on the Sabbath. The mental aspects of the Sabbath practice allow us to examine Philo’s view on the question of body and soul in the context of Second-Temple Judaism. In addition, we find that while Philo does not seem to reflect the consensus in rabbinic sources (if such a consensus exists), his views are not alien to the Rabbis' world, either. Our study reveals both a textual basis, similar to midrash, as well as a theoretical foundation of Philo's Sabbath.
|
Demeter as Focal Point: Eleusis as Mirror
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Nancy Evans, Wheaton College (Massachusetts)
Theorizing about mythology in 1999 Bruce Lincoln wrote, ‘If myth is ideology in narrative form, then scholarship is myth with footnotes.’ This paper will argue that the traditions of explication for the cult of Demeter at Eleusis provide contemporary critics a clear example of the power inherent in Lincoln’s proposed narrative ideology. Explanations of the mysteries at Eleusis – both the sanctuary site itself and the initiatory rites that took place there – can be understood as mirrors for the values and concerns of the scholars who promote their theories. A review of some of the more influential post-war scholarship (from Mylonas and Travlos, to Richardson, Burkert, Clinton, Foley, Parker, Sourvinou-Inwood, and Nightingale), will bring forward an array of modern perspectives and beliefs about the forces that animated Greek ritual practice. Critical approaches to interpreting Eleusis have (implicitly) embraced nationalism, feminism, Christianity, humanism, Platonism, imperialism, and democracy. There can be little doubt that some powerful set of motivations moved many generations of Athenians to dedicate significant public and private resources to the sanctuary at Eleusis, as well as its companion site on the slopes of the Athenian Acropolis, the city Eleusinion. But given the state of the evidence for the mystery rites themselves, what footnoted, post-Christian scholarly method can actually get us closer to an understanding of these traditional, fundamentally agricultural rituals? J.Z.Smith intuited this in his first chapter of Drudgery Divine. For comparanda the argument will then turn to select ancient authors and traditions (e.g. Plato, the Hippocratic corpus, and early Christian texts), and suggest that a controlled comparison of Eleusinian metaphors from antiquity can be read against other ancient evidence to help fill out our understanding of the mystic rites of Demeter.
|
Critiquing the Supposed “Oral Mindset”of the Chronicler and Its Implications for Assessing the Chronicler’s Method
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Paul S. Evans, McMaster Divinity College
In his book, The Deuteronomic History and the Book of Chronicles, Raymond Person has argued that since the Chronicler lived in a primarily oral society he wrote with an “oral mindset.” According to Person, this “oral mindset” explains the Chronicler’s divergences from Sam-Kgs since he did not slavishly copy his Vorlage but simply preserved its meaning for the on-going life of his community. Thus, scholarly attempts to understand the Chronicler’s divergences from Sam-Kgs as intentional ideological changes are ill conceived due to the fact that an “oral mindset” would not have viewed such divergences as changes at all. This paper critiques Person’s approach and argues that positing an “oral mindset” (like past attempts to posit a ‘primitive’ or ‘Hebrew’ mindset) to ancient scribes is too speculative and difficulties in assessing the validity of such a model too great. Second, through discussion of several texts I will show how Chronicles consciously diverges from his Vorlage, regardless of whether an “oral mindset” would have considered these divergences as such or not. Thus, the issue concerns modern and ancient understandings of what constitutes a “change.” Therefore, the task of understanding the Chroniclers’ method remains even if he had an “oral mindset.”
|
The Illiterate Scribe: Assessing the Thought Processes of the Chronicler in Light of Modern Fieldwork with Illiterate and Literate Subjects
Program Unit: Orality, Textuality, and the Formation of the Hebrew Bible
Paul S. Evans, McMaster Divinity College
Several important studies have underscored the importance of orality studies for a proper understanding of the texts of the Hebrew Bible in terms of their origins, their preservation, and their function in ancient communities. Further, given that the context for the writing of biblical texts was a primarily oral society, it has been suggested that the scribes who wrote and preserved the biblical texts, though literate, would not have the same mindset as literates in a modern print culture as the oral context of the ancient world would have affected their mindset in important ways. This paper explores the issue of how literacy and illiteracy would have affected thought processes and proposes a model for how we might understand the mindset of a scribe in Persian Yehud by drawing on modern fieldwork with illiterate and slightly literate subjects. This research suggests that significant differences are seen in terms of abstract thinking, categorization, logic, defining terms, and articulating self-analysis. Finally, taking the book of Chronicles as test case, this paper will look for evidence of this mindset in the Chronicler (especially in comparison with the so-called Deuteronomic History).
|
A Greek-English Lexicon of the Zenon Archive: Aims, Methods, Significance
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Trevor Evans, Macquarie University
The documentary papyri preserve a mass of evidence of the greatest importance for Greek lexicography in general and for biblical lexicography in particular, as scholars such as Deissmann and Moulton long ago recognised. These fragile textual artefacts, recovered mostly from the rubbish tips and mummy-wrappings of ancient Egypt, offer us a vast and growing hoard of new Greek words and new senses of previously known words. No reliable lexical analysis of any of this material is currently available. Earlier treatments are now seriously dated, and many inaccuracies lurk in the standard works on which contemporary scholars are forced to rely. To address the urgent desideratum of replacing these works and filling the increasingly yawning gap in our knowledge-base is a daunting challenge. This paper introduces the aims, methods, and significance of a project seeking to address the problem by providing a lexicon for a key subset of the corpus. The project is based at Macquarie University in Sydney and is producing a Greek-English lexicon of the Zenon Archive. The Zenon Archive includes roughly 40 per cent of all third-century BCE documentary papyri. Its vocabulary amounts to some 4,558 words, excluding proper names. This may be compared with the vocabulary of the Greek Pentateuch, approximately 3,453 items, and that of the New Testament, approximately 4,861 items. The vocabulary of the Archive thus represents a very large body of material in its own right and the lexicon will provide a model for the lexicography of the Greek papyri as a whole.
|
Angels in Targum Pseudo Jonathan and Post-Talmudic Midrash
Program Unit: Midrash
David L. Everson, Xavier University
Among the Pentateuch Targumim, Targum Pseudo-Jonathan (TPsJ) contains the greatest variety of angelological traditions. These traditions are paralleled in Second Temple literature, pre-Talmudic rabbinic literature, Talmudic literature, and post-Talmudic literature. Unlike the other targumim, only TPsJ contains angeglological traditions which are most closely or exclusively paralleled in post-Talmudic sources. For example, Gabriel is the specific angel who helps Joseph find his brothers (Gen 37:15), God is accompanied by a seemingly incalculable number of angels (Exod 12:12; Deut 33:2), the Angel of Death is the specific angel responsible for the destruction of the Egyptian firstborn (Exod 12:13), Gabriel brings the brick containing the miscarried fetus to heaven (Exod 24:10), angels provide the Israelites with the miraculous central bar of the Tabernacle (Exod 26:28), and Satan possesses and animates the Golden Calf (Exod 32:19). There are many other examples that could be cited. In this paper, I will make the case that the number and quality of these parallels to post-Talmudic sources suggest a late date for TPsJ. Accordingly, the angelology of TPsJ represents a later stage of rabbinic angelology. This corroborates the findings of E. M. Cook, M. Ohana, A. Shinan, D. M. Splansky, and J. A. Foster (among others).
|
The Golden Calf Possessed: A Targumic Rendering
Program Unit: Jewish-Christian Dialogue and Sacred Texts
David L. Everson, Xavier University
Within the history of interpretation, the rabbis and church fathers alike offer a variety of attempts to mitigate the cruces presented by the episode of the golden calf. Namely, how could the people make such a request at that moment and how could Aaron be complicit in the production of the idol? Among the targms, Targum Pseudo-Jonathan (TPsJ) goes to great lengths in vindicating not only Aaron but the people as well (this requires the murder of Hur and the satanic possession of the calf). The targum's sensational rendering of this pivotal text provides an excellent opportunity for examining its position within the history of interpretation. In this paper, I shall provide an analysis of the various rabbinic and patristic interpretations of this passage and, more importantly, make the case that TPsJ is drawing upon or contributing to remarkably late traditions (in addition to earlier ones). These traditions may shed light upon the contested date of this particular targum.
|
Fakaeve: An Island Reading of 1 Kgs 17:7–24
Program Unit: Islands, Islanders, and Scriptures
Ikani Fakasiieiki, Graduate Theological Union
Fakaeve literally means “to collect together the small pieces or to gather (gather up) together the left over.” Fakaeveeve as a subject refers to “flat cakes,” or as a verb also refers to the collection of leftovers or very small pieces of something, including food. Also, fakaeve is a metaphorical label given to those (outsider, marginalizer) who are asking for and begging for food or leftovers from someone’s table. As a subject it refers to food that is made up by mixing left over ingredients. This presentation has two facets. First, I will use the concept of fakaeve as a hermeneutic lens to study 1 Kings 17:7 – 24. For example, Elijah, in the time of famine, was instructed to go and fakaeve in a foreign/neighboring land. Arriving there, the woman is fakaeveeve for firewood in order to cook her last meal with her son. In this presentation, we are encouraged to use the leftovers, or the momo “crumbs” that have fallen from the table or are about to be thrown out. Second, I will use the concept of Fakaeve as an Island way of responding to the world where knowledge is controlled and dominated by some certain ideology and system of belief. We only get things through the fakaeve’s way. On the other hand, the only thing a fakaeve gets are the leftovers and the things that are about to be throw out. Ironically in the Fakaeve or Fakaeveeve perspective, everything is valuable, especially the leftovers, the unwanted and the insignificant or the things that are about to be throw out.
|
Liturgical Progression and the Experience of Transformation in Prayers from Qumran
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Daniel K. Falk, University of Oregon
A striking feature of some of the prayers found at Qumran is a structured liturgical progression over the course of a sequence of prayers. In the morning and evening blessings of 4Q503 Daily Prayers, the community tracks the movements of the kingdom of light with the angels over the course of the month, and marks the sabbath rest. Throughout the weekday prayers of the Words of the Luminaries, they relive the history of Israel’s relationship with God progressively from the failings of Adam and Eve on Sunday through to the contemporary time on Friday. In the Songs of the Sabbath Sacrifice, over the course of three months they progress in visionary scenes through the heavenly realm including different classes of angelic priests, temples and animated furnishings, culminating in a vision of the divine throne in the seventh week, and again at the end of the cycle, just after the Feast of Pentecost. In the Festival Prayers as well are seeming indications of progression through the story of Israel, but the scrolls are far too broken to reconstruct the sequence. This feature, in which there are different prayers throughout the sequence, is one of the most significant ways that the prayers in the Scrolls differ from prayers in the synagogue liturgy.
Angela Kim Harkins has shown that there is a profound sense of movement in many of the Hodayot. In terms of place, the speaker moves from wilderness to the garden, from the underworld to the heavens, from darkness to light, from danger to safety, from prison to freedom, from a tight place to a wide open plain, from being alone and outcast to having place in community. This is accompanied by language of movement of the body (stumbling, buckling knees, collapsing on the ground, to standing tall and walking erect) and transformation of emotion (from fear, anxiety, and shame to joy, exaltation, and confidence). Drawing on insights from various fields such as neurosciences and theater studies, she has emphasized the experiential dimension of imitation in ritual, and its role in religious formation.
Building on such insights, this paper will examine elements of liturgical progression throughout the entire corpus of prayer texts as means of guided experience and formation.
|
Prophecy and the Practice of Poetry in Alan of Lille’s Anticlaudianus
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Claire Fanger, Rice University
This paper will explore the understanding of prophecy as it relates to the role of the poet in Alan of Lille’s long narrative poem Anticlaudianus. Alan of Lille was an influential twelfth century poet whose allegorical fantasy narratives are playful, witty, and strongly embedded in fashionable neo-Platonic cosmology. The Anticlaudianus is explicitly intended to be entertaining to those in search of diversion, but to transmit wisdom to those in search of wisdom – in short, it (playfully) claims for itself an esoteric initiatic function. In order to illuminate the link between prophecy and the practice of poetry, the paper will set out some background from other twelfth century works before examining the relations between prophecy and the depiction of language in this part of the poem to show how its initiatic structure is developed.
|
Elazar the Priest: The Torah's Final Character
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
Zev I. Farber, Project TABS
Elazer is the son of Aaron and his successor. He is appointed by Moses to be Joshua’s partner during the conquest and to share in the responsibility of dividing the land. In the later sections of P, Elazar is a pervasive character. (Out of 50 appearances of his name in the Hexateuch, 31 occur in the latter half of Numbers.) In this paper I propose that Elazar is not only a uniquely P character, but that he was added in a later revision of P. This, I will demonstrate by looking at texts where the addition of Elazar subverts the meaning of the older layer of text. In addition to this redaction critical approach, the paper will suggest a number of tradition historical motives for the creation of this character and the magnification of his importance. Elazar creates a familial bridge between two important biblical characters, Aaron and Phineas, each of whom were ancestor figures to a particular group of priests. Additionally, Elazar becomes a partner, even a senior partner, to Joshua, reflecting a Second Temple period ideology, where a high priest (Elazar) may have been seen as more significant than a proto-monarch (Joshua), even when imagining the leadership of ancient Israel. In short, the paper will explore the possibility that the character of Elazar is an artificial creation whose function in the text serves the worldview of the Second Temple Jerusalem priesthood. In some instances, he is inserted into early P redactionally, but he appears as an integral character only in late P.
|
Job and Jewish Philosophy after the Holocaust
Program Unit: Jewish-Christian Dialogue and Sacred Texts
Noah Zvi Farkas, Valley Beth Shalom (Encino, California)
This paper will explore Job and Jewish Philosophy after the Holocaust.
|
The Scribal Habits of P127
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Alan Taylor Farnes, Duke University
James R. Royse has built upon previous scholarship by Ernest Colwell and F. J. A. Hort by examining singular readings in the papyri in order to determine scribal habits. With respect to six early New Testament papyri (P45, P46, P47, P66, P72, and P75), Royse has shown that these early New Testament scribes tended to omit more than they added. His findings have disproven, at least with respect to these six early papyri, the long held text critical maxim lectio brevior potior. Royse has replaced this maxim with lectio longior potior while emphasizing the ceteris paribus clause. He calls upon New Testament papyrologists and text critics to continue to analyze papyri using this method saying, “Ideally, of course, all the major witnesses to the text of the New Testament…would be studied in detail in order to provide this same kind of information concerning scribal habits…. One’s assertions could then be based on empirical evidence about the witness” (Royse, Scribal Habits in Early Greek New Testament Papyri, 13).
In response to Royse’s entreaty to study New Testament witnesses I have begun to analyze P127: a fifth century papyrus containing portions of Acts 10–12, 15–17. My analysis confirms Royse’s findings that the scribe of P127 does indeed omit more than s/he adds. However, although the scribe omits more than s/he adds, the scribe’s habits are strikingly different than Royse’s scribes. Royse also wonders if scribal conventions may have changed, becoming more constant in post-Constantine Christianity. Such a question would require an investigation of many later (fourth century and later) manuscripts. However, P127 does not represent a fixed, more stable text. Rather, the opposite is true—P127 displays a high degree of textual variance. More studies of this type are needed to determine if P127 is indicative of the fifth century or if other fifth century witnesses do exhibit textual fixity. This current study will only analyze P127 and will leave broader issues of general chronological trends unanswered.
|
Ring Structure in Sura 9: Repentance Emphasized
Program Unit: Linguistic, Literary, and Thematic Perspectives on the Qur’anic Corpus (IQSA)
Raymond Farrin, American University of Kuwait
This paper builds on the work by contemporary scholars such as Michel Cuypers and Carl Ernst, who highlight the incidence of ring composition in whole Qur’anic suras. As they point out, ring structure serves as guide to meaning, calling attention to especially significant messages in the center. This paper examines Sura 9 (Repentance), one of the very last to be revealed to the Prophet (dating to 9 AH/631 CE) and concerning military confrontation with non-Muslims. The first part of the paper examines the structure of Sura 9. Our analysis shows that it consists of five sections: A – B – C – B’ – A’. Section A (vv. 1-37) calls on the believers to slay those disbelievers who have violated treaties. However, it also leaves open the possibility of repentance. Should they ask for asylum, they are to be granted it so that they may hear God’s Word. Section B (38-57) then reprimands those in Medina who were reluctant to go forth on the Tabuk expedition. True believers, the text points out, do not ask to be excused from striving in God’s cause. In the middle (C, 58-80), the Prophet is commanded to strive against the disbelievers and hypocrites. Yet it is stated likewise that should they repent, then that would be best. Section B’ (81-99) adverts again to the laggards: blame falls not on the weak, ill, or poor who stayed back, but on the rich; their abode will be Hell. Section A’ (100-129) rounds out the sura, urging the believers once more to confront disbelievers and hypocrites, while also mentioning the opportunity of repentance. The paper’s second part concerns implications. Specifically, it contrasts conclusions from chronological and literary approaches to the Qur’an. Sayyid Qutb (d. 1966), who takes a chronological approach to this sura, contends that it articulates the relationship between the Islamic state and outsiders in its final form. He finds the Qur’an here urging confrontation, including against People of the Book. On the other hand, the structure of the sura, while calling on believers to fight, also emphasizes the possibility of repentance. Furthermore, we see that this sura is not central. Indeed, within a scheme of Suras 2 – 49 (perhaps part of a larger ring scheme of the whole Qur’an), Sura 9 may well bear a meaningful relationship to Sura 40, The Forgiver. Thus a literary approach—taking into account the Book’s complete form—opens to a more tolerant reading.
|
Between Israel and Judah: Politics, Economy, and Identity
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Avraham Faust, Bar-Ilan University
Until a few years ago, all scholars treated the Israelites and Israelite identity in a way that embraced both Israel and Judah. Gradually, however, this consensus is questioned, and more and more doubts are cast over this overarching identification. Did Israel and Judah had more in common than other ancient peoples? Did they really share a common identity? Or is it a later perspective, supplied by the authors and editors of significant portions of the biblical texts, which strived to legitimate later territorial and political claims by Judahite or Jewish rulers and authors by claiming an "Israelite" identity for themselves? It is the aim of the paper to reexamine the question of an "all Israelite" identity on the basis of the available archaeological evidence. The paper will examine the political and economic organization in both kingdoms on the one hand, and the distribution of "sensitive" archaeological traits on the other hand, in an attempt to identify differences, commonalities, and mainly patterns of separation and\or inclusion as far the populations of the two kingdoms is concerned.
|
Jeremiah’s Mediated Body in Jer 18:18–23
Program Unit: Writing/Reading Jeremiah
April Favara, University of Denver
This paper will articulate the ways in which Jeremiah embodies his role as a mediator between God and the people. His experiences of bodily trauma attributed to the deity and the people to whom he relates shape a particular agency that is both culturally scripted and resisted by the prophet himself. In this particular passage, one of Jeremiah’s Confessions, where the agency of the prophet and his bodily experience is highlighted to its greatest degree, we find reference to the maiming of his “tongue,” as well as to various threats against his life. The deity “hears” as Jeremiah calls repeatedly for the violent demise of those pursuing him. Though Jeremiah himself notes that he had called once on their behalf, Jeremiah, as a mediated body, “shapes” a way of being in the world that is characterized by his vicious experiences of mediation. This allows Jeremiah to proceed to follow a cultural script that produces violence and trauma. His conception of this agency unfolds from his experience as a mediated body that often experiences the persecution of the other, in the form of the people around him, various enemies, and sometimes, the deity.
|
What Flooded? A Post-Finkel/Crowe Analysis
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Peter Feinman, Institute of History, Archaeology, and Education
2014 has been a banner for the flood in both Mesopotamia and the Bible. It may one day rank with George Smith in 1872 and Sir Leonard Woolley in 1924 as key dates in flood historiography. All this attention invites a reappraisal of the flood stories in and of themselves and in relation to each other. This analysis is part of a larger study of “Who Wrote J?” from a political perspective. The flood tradition within Mesopotamia itself appears in different versions with different goals and does not speak with a single voice. Even if a biblical writer was familiar with a Mesopotamian flood story, there still would be the issue of which one or ones and in what context. The study here will show that the biblical flood story did not originate as a global flood but grew to become one based on Mesopotamian motifs. This change was reflective of the development of the idea that the temple at Jerusalem was the cosmic center supplanting Mesopotamian cities. I will suggest that the author of the global flood story also was responsible for Gen. 2:10-14 and Gen. 10:8-10 as part of this transformation which supplemented an existing narrative and which generated written opposition.
|
Isaiah 52 and the Subtext of Luke's Triumphal Entry
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Tucker S. Ferda, Pittsburgh Theological Seminary
One of the most poignant scenes in Luke is without parallel in the other Gospels: Jesus interrupts the triumphal entry to weep over Jerusalem, prophesy its destruction, and speak of the city’s missed “time of visitation” (19:41-44). Ever since an important essay by C.H. Dodd in the 1940s, study of the use of Scripture in this passage has focused on the background of the destruction imagery in vv. 43-44 and what the episode may imply about Luke’s knowledge of and perspective on 70 CE. But, as a consequence, one key aspect of this text has been overlooked: Jesus assumes that Jerusalem should have expected “this day” to come (v. 41). Where does the expectation for “the time of your visitation” (v. 44) come from? What does the disappointment presuppose?
This paper attempts to answer this question and to contribute to the study of Luke’s use of Israel’s Scripture by suggesting that the Third Evangelist has shaped the triumphal entry to evoke and subvert a famous oracle of Jerusalem’s restoration, Isaiah 52. The upshot is a striking reversal of expectations: the long awaited euangelizomenos on the Mount of Olives with his message of peace here weeps and prophesies the destruction of the city on account of its failure to recognize “the time of visitation.” The nature of the intertextuality, then, approximates what Richard Hays has called “dialectical imitation”: a process of juxtaposing two literary worlds so that the tensions between the worlds generate meaning. The argument finds support in (a) the narrative function of Isaiah in the larger context of Luke-Acts, where particular prophecies from Deutero-Isaiah find not only their fulfillment but also their disappointment in narrative action; (b) otherwise clear interpretive strategies and assumptions in the immediate context; (c) clear lexical and thematic connections to Isa 52; (d) the important role of Isa 52 in Jewish hopes for the end-time restoration of Zion; and (e) some rather striking corroboration in the history of interpretation that modern commentaries no longer mention.
|
Non-English ICT Computer Language Support
Program Unit: Global Education and Research Technology
Stephen Fierbaugh, The Seed Company
Android, Apple OS X and iOS, Linux (including Balsa and Wasta), and Microsoft Windows 7 and 8, all provide excellent support for reading documents in languages other than English. Most provide good support for creating documents in major languages. Support for languages of wider communication (LWC) is mixed. Support for minority languages is best provided through Keyman ($23.99 for Windows) or Multiling Omni Keyboard (free for Android). Apple iOS should be avoided for non-major languages. Documents should be stored in UTF-8 Unicode, the default of most modern systems. Additionally, a language-appropriate virtual keyboard and language-specific font are required. Arial Unicode MS and Droid Sans are both safe fonts for any language; Gentium Plus is a good font for Latin-based alphabets. The appendix includes simple flowcharts for five common Use Cases involving documents in non-English.
|
Emerging ICT Trends Affecting Progressive Publication of Newly Translated Scripture
Program Unit: Global Education and Research Technology
Stephen Fierbaugh, The Seed Company
Progressive publication is the practice of distributing portions of Scripture in a language as soon as it is translated, rather than waiting until there is a complete New Testament before publication. A brief introduction to progressive publication is provided. Information and Communication Technology (ICT) such as mobile phones and village radios, which affect progressive publication are examined. Macro-trends are documented, and then how the trends play out at the local level are explored. The capabilities of the average phone are explained in detail. Some challenges to progressive publication are identified. An appendix for American readers explains how mobile phones work in the developing world.
|
Paul and the Synagogue: Archaeological and Literary Perspectives
Program Unit: Paul within Judaism
Steven Fine, Yeshiva University
|
Samaritan and Jewish Meals in Late Antiquity: Between Archaeology and Literature
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
Steven Fine, Yeshiva University
Recent scholarship has shown considerable interest in the history of Jewish dining habits as discussed by the rabbis in late antique Palestine. These have resulted in significant monographs in both English and Hebrew. This talk will widen this conversation in three ways: by exploring archaeological evidence for Jewish practice in Israel, in diaspora communities, and among Samaritans. I will focus upon drawing lconnections between material culture and rabbinic and Samaritan literary sources from late antiquity.
|
The Rebuilding of the Jerusalem Temple in Emperor Julian's Program
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Ari Finkelstein, University of Cincinnati
The Christianization of Jerusalem began with the founding of the Church of the Holy Sepulcher by Constantine the Great in 335 CE. Within a generation Constantine’s nephew, Emperor Julian, attempted to rebuild the Jewish Temple and thereby reverse the Christianization process. This is how many scholars understand Julian’s plan to rebuild the Jerusalem temple. Still others suggest that this endeavor ought to be seen in light of Julian’s efforts to rebuild temples across the empire.
But in light of recent scholarship which explains Julian’s program as an attempt to obtain the beneficence of the gods by fostering a correct understanding of the cosmos and correct worship, I re-read Julian’s Letter to the Community of the Jews, his Against the Galileans and his Letter to Theodorus and argue that this rebuilding effort was first and foremost designed to fix the Jewish God firmly within Julian’s cosmological order. Similarly the Jewish people, reformulated as Judeans - an ethnic group subject to the laws of their God - were fixed to a specific geographic region. Only a correct worship of the Judean God could guarantee the success of the empire and Julian’s impending campaign in Persia.
No doubt this strategy also helped Julian deal with Christianity. He calls Christians “Galileans” throughout his works, grounding them in the Galilee. The rebuilding of the temple would have returned Jerusalem to the Judeans and presumably would have been accompanied by a renaming of that province to Judea.
The rebuilding project also interrupted Christian space and thus undermined its identity. Eusebius described how Christians exiting the Church of the Holy Sepulcher could see the garbage heap that was the temple mount reminding them that they had replaced Jews as “Israel”. A Jerusalem in which the Jewish temple was restored, would interrupt that landscape. Now Christians would see a renewed Judean ethnicity with a vibrant cult undermining Eusebius’s defunct image of the Jew and openly questioning Christian replacement theology.
|
Shabbat Violation in Qur’anic Discourse
Program Unit: The Qur’an and the Biblical Tradition (IQSA)
Reuven Firestone, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion (California Branch)
The Qur’an mentions seven times that God created the heavens and the earth in six days. This seems to confirm the most famous creation account of the Hebrew Bible, in which God created the heavens and the earth in six days (Gen.1:1-31). Following the sixth day of biblical creation, God finished or completed (k.l.w.) the work (mela’khah) and then “ceased” – s.b.t. (sometimes “rested”) – from all work (Gen.2:1-2). “And God blessed the seventh day and declared it holy because on it God ceased/rested from all the work of creation that he had done” (Gen.2:3). Later, in Exodus 20:8-11, the Israelites are charged to withhold from doing all manner of work “because the Lord… rested (n.w.?.) on the seventh day” (Ex.20:11). The Genesis story does not insist that God “rested” because the verb s.b.t. generally means “to cease.” However, the Exodus passage places s.b.t. in parallel with n.w.?, which means in all cases to rest. S.b.t., then, is associated with rest as well as cessation from labor. Because God rested on the seventh day, Israelites are commanded to rest on the seventh day.
This association creates a problem if one accepts the omnipotence of God. If God is indeed all powerful, why should God need to rest? In the retelling of the Exodus story that occurs later in Deuteronomy 5:12-15, the command to observe the Sabbath is couched differently, based there on the experience of slavery in Egypt (Deut.5:15).
The Qur’an also questions the need for an omnipotent God to rest after creation, and states the impossibility outright in Q.5:38, “We most certainly created the heavens and the earth and what is between them in six days, but weariness did not touch Us.” This would rebut the biblical – and Jewish – claim that God rested on the Sabbath day, for which Jews must rest on the Sabbath day. God had no need to rest after creation. Therefore, perhaps, God’s creatures need not rest on the Sabbath day. Nowhere does the Qur’an associate Sabbath observance with creation or Israelite slavery. It does, however, mention that God spoke to the People of the Book (ahlu al-kitab) at the mountain (al-?ur): “and We told them, ‘Do not transgress the Sabbath,’ and We made with them a firm covenant” (4:154).
The Israelites (or Jews), however, failed to observe this requirement and are depicted repeatedly as breaking the law of Sabbath observance (Q.2:65, 4:47, and 7:163). Those who transgressed are transformed into “despised apes” (Q.2:65, 7:166). Yet despite parallels with other biblical commandments, neither the Qu’ran nor post-qur’anic Tradition requires Sabbath restrictions, notwithstanding the fact that the Arabic sabata, like the Hebrew sabat, can mean “to rest” or “keep the Sabbath.” This presentation will parse out the seemingly ambivalent perspectives regarding Sabbath observance and violation in reference to Jews and Muslims in the Qur’an, and in relation to pre-qur’anic texts and Muslim interpretation in order to suggest an explanation for the tension.
|
Charting the Celestial Sanctuaries: Making Sense of the Spaces of the Songs of the Sabbath Sacrifice
Program Unit: Qumran
Amy Marie Fisher, University of Toronto
The French sociologist Henri Lefebvre noted, “that spaces made (produced) to be read are the most deceptive and tricked-up imaginable.” Lefebvre was remarking on the nature of monumental architecture in particular and the way this architectural style contains multiple narratives at once. While Lefebvre was speaking of real built space such as the temple in Jerusalem, his remarks carry resonance for the study of written spaces that can only exist if literally read. This is particularly true with respect to the confusing cartographic sections of the Songs of the Sabbath Sacrifice (Shirot) that simultaneously obfuscate and offer thick descriptions of the nature of the heavens. In this paper, I explore the complicated and contradictory spaces of the celestial temple in Shirot nine, ten, eleven, twelve and thirteen using aspects of Lefebvre’s critical spatial theory, recent work on the practice of ekphrasis of temples in antiquity, as well as the work of Philip Ethington on the spatiality of the past, particularly his notion that places are more “events” than “things”. This paper argues that the spatial descriptions of the Shirot are as confusing as they are because they are attempts to aggrandize the visual rhetoric of the earthly temple in Jerusalem and thus describe its greater heavenly counterpart. This aggrandizing of the already myriad narratives of the earthly temple created an even more confusing set of narratives for the celestial temple. Here I further suggest that the performance of these narratives at Qumran allowed the group there to create the space of the heavenly temple by recreating the “events” of the celestial temple. This performance of the events of the celestial temple created the place of the celestial temple, pure and in proper order at Qumran, a physical place quite other from the earthly temple in Jerusalem.
|
The Ark in I Kings 8, Redacted and Remembered
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Daniel Fisher, University of California-Berkeley
In what ways might the redaction of biblical historical writings represent memory work, shaping biblical societies by forming and reforming their shared past? How have redacted biblical historical writings served as sites for the negotiation of counter-memories, and are there limits to the extent that they may do so? I Kings 8 describes the dedication of Solomon’s Temple, a turning point in Israel’s religious history that culminates with the installation of the Ark (1-13) and a prayer from Solomon, who presides over the ceremony (14-66). Literary features in the text suggest that it is a complex, extensively redacted work, creatively shaped and reshaped by biblical writers both before and after the destruction of the Temple. The description of the Ark’s installation in the received text of I Kings 8 mobilizes at least two independently developed and, I argue, mutually exclusive, pentateuchal memories of the Ark—one from Deuteronomy (10:1-5) and one from the Priestly stratum of Exodus (25 and 37). Employing the narrative of the installation of the Ark in I Kings 8 as a case study, this paper considers the relationship between redaction and memory. How do the two pentateuchal memories of the Ark move across history, through the ongoing redaction I Kings 8—and critically, why? Why did the writers of I Kings 8 concern themselves with the Ark, contesting its meaning and significance? Further, how do the different strata of Solomon’s prayer refocus the narrative, leading to different understandings of the preceding installation of the Ark? This paper explores the ways in which the different writers of I Kings 8 form different visions of the Temple and God’s relationship to Israel through the Ark. I argue that I Kings 8 provides a forum for the contestation of the memory of the Ark, where through redaction biblical writers negotiate competing visions of Israel’s past in a contest over Israel’s future. In this redactional contest, biblical writers remember the Ark by rewriting the story of its installation. Though the combination of the two memories of the Ark in the received text of I Kings 8 ultimately resolves their incompatibility, it also exposes the tensions between them—raising important questions about the limits of redaction as a technology of memory.
|
The Power of Music and Rhythm in the Performance of Revelation
Program Unit: Bible Translation
Dan Fizgerald, The Seed Company
This paper, as part of the Bible Translation and Nida Institute session on Translating for Performance and Performing for Translation, will address issues relating to the performance of select passages of the Book of Revelation through the use of rhythm and music, both from a theoretical as well as from a practical perspective.
|
“Where” Is the Second “If”? A Reanalysis of the Ugaritic Particle “’im”
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
S. A. Fix, Catholic University of America
In the past few decades of Ugaritic scholarship the particles written "’im" and "hm" have been understood to be virtually synonymous conditional particles meaning "if." Yet the scant evidence for "’im" meaning "if" suggests it may be some other particle. This paper argues that "’im" should be reanalyzed as an interrogative locative particle meaning “where?” Such a reanalysis also clarifies readings in the few Ugaritic texts in which the particle “’im” is found.
|
Allusions in Lamentations to Deuteronomy 4; 28–32; and Leviticus 26
Program Unit: Megilloth
Denise Flanders, Fuller Theological Seminary (Pasadena)
Scholars have long noted the presence of a handful of significant lexical parallels between Lamentations and Deuteronomy 28. In 1963, Bertil Albrektson identified ten “points of correspondence,” both lexical and content-oriented, between Lamentations and the list of covenant curses in Deuteronomy 28:15-68. Albrektson suggested that these parallels were too significant to be “dismissed as pure coincidences.” He proposed that the author of Lamentations consciously alluded to Deuteronomy 28, and in doing so, offered a theological interpretation of the destruction of Jerusalem.
Since Albrektson’s work, commentators such as Adele Berlin, Robin Parry and Leslie Allen have continued to recognize connections between Lamentations and the curses in Deuteronomy 28. This work has been fruitful, as Berlin has shed light on additional instances of shared language between the texts and both Berlin and Allen have suggested possible reasons for the author’s use of this text. However, the current state of investigation might be expanded in at least three ways. First, while scholars have confined their attention to allusions to Deuteronomy 28, I suggest a focus on the covenant curses more broadly found in Deuteronomy 4; 28-32 and Leviticus 26. Second, current investigation focuses almost exclusively on distinct verbal parallels, while overlooking a multitude of other content-oriented parallels. Finally, scholars often remain tentative or silent when it comes to the significance of such parallels. More emphasis is needed on how the allusions work in the text and the purpose for which the author employs them.
The present paper seeks to address these issues. First, it endeavors to show the presence of extensive curse imagery from Deuteronomy 4; 28-32 and Leviticus 26 in Lamentations, especially where allusions have gone unnoticed because they lack distinct similarities in vocabulary. Second, it seeks to demonstrate least two ways in which the allusions function in the text – first, to depict the fulfillment of the curses, and second, to indicate to God that the events of 586 BCE have actually gone beyond what God forewarned.
The downfall of Judah represented a worse fate than what was promised in the covenant curses; Judah was not simply a proverb among the nations (Deut 28:37); she had become their mocking song (Lam 3:14, 63). God had said he would not allow the enemy to boast that the downfall of his people was their doing (Deut 32:27), but they in fact believe they have swallowed her (Lam 2:16b). While God had warned that Israel’s overthrow would be like that of the cities of the plain (Deut 29:22[23]), it was far worse (Lam 4:6). And finally, although God had promised not to utterly reject his people (Lev 26:44), that appeared to be exactly what he was doing (Lam 5:22). By alluding to the covenant curses in this way, the author of Lamentations directs God’s own words back to him, appealing to him to respond.
|
Chemosh's Wrath… in Mesha's Point of View: An Analysis of Genre and Point of View in 2 Kgs 3:4–27
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Denise Flanders, Fuller Theological Seminary (Pasadena)
Chemosh's Wrath… in Mesha's Point of View: An Analysis of Genre and Point of View in 2 Kings 3:4-27
|
Christian Apocalyptic Eschatology in Q and the Origin of the Gospel Genre
Program Unit: Q
Harry Fleddermann, Alverno College
To grasp the eschatology of Q we need to understand three distinctions: (1) The distinction between prophetic eschatology and apocalyptic eschatology; (2) The distinction between Jewish apocalyptic eschatology and Christian apocalyptic eschatology; and (3) The distinction between the first phase of Christian apocalyptic eschatology that looked to an imminent parousia and the second phase of Christian apoclayptic eschatology that recognized that the parousia had been delayed. This paper will explore all three distinctions to set the eschatology of Q in its proper context, and it will show how Q's Christian apocalyptic eschatology gave rise to the gospel genre.
|
Benjamin: A Biblical Vehicle for Reconsidering the History of Israel and Judah
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Daniel Fleming, New York University
In discussion of history as it relates to the kingdoms of Israel, Judah, and the peoples related to them, the Bible often falls into easily stereotyped roles. Its stories beg to be proven right or wrong, even as its narrative frames much historical reconstruction, whether for the first millennium BCE or before. Written sources contemporary with Israel and Judah are limited in number and content. Ideally, the Bible could offer distinct and indispensable perspectives, if it could be allowed the methodological space to contribute based on the critical caution its particular composition and transmission warrant. The historical questions underlying such investigation would be defined by the evolving existence of the peoples who occupied the southern Levant through the early and mid-first millennium, not by the biblical narrative or its categories. With the freedom thus invested in the Bible’s voices, these can be considered for what they say directly or indirectly about the periods and peoples in view.
For historical research on Israel and Judah, the people of Benjamin offer a unique vehicle by which the Bible can challenge and change long-held assumptions. In strict terms, there is no study of Iron Age Benjamin apart from the Bible. The name derives from the Bible and does not appear in Iron Age inscriptions, alphabetic or cuneiform. Excavations and survey may be carried out in the region north of Jerusalem under this name, but such work can only be applied to Benjamin by treating the tribal territory defined in Joshua 18 as a settled historical reality. In fact, the Bible’s Benjamin cuts across the dominant political categories of Israel and Judah. Careful reevaluation allows this biblical evidence to undercut the very narrative commonly attributed to the Bible and contribute to historical reconstruction in larger terms.
|
Tying the Knot: Marriage, Economy, and Survival in Early Christianity
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Michael Flexsenhar III, The University of Texas at Austin
This paper investigates marriages between freeborn women and former slaves in ancient Ostia, Italy, and the implications of this practice for understanding the ancient economy and early Christian communities. It is generally assumed that slaves and freedmen rarely, if at all, could marry outside of their particular status group. This study explains the socio-economic factors that prompted or constrained this apparent cross over, and the economic strategies for survival, viability, or mobility, which depended on these marital connections. Through several case studies I analyze epitaphs, survey onomastic data, and chart out prosopographies. I then set this material in a socio-economic framework of immigration, social networks, and the local economy. In each instance the marriages represent an investment in social and economic resources for the respective families. These examples raise questions about “class” and economy in antiquity, and also about the socio-economic positions of the first Christians, the role of benefactresses, and the impetuses and consequences of marriages in early Christian communities.
|
Wine at the Wedding at Cana and in the Papyri: Some Observations on Wine-Consumption in Antiquity
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Hans Foerster, Universität Wien
The interpretation of the first sign in the Fourth Gospel is dependent on the perception of the amount of water changed into wine which is mentioned there. The paper will start with the vessels in John 2:6 and discuss their capacity. The analysis will use the metric numbers to be deduced from the text to compare the amount mentioned in the Fourth Gospel to papyrological evidence. The possible lack of metric definition for some of the containers for wine mentioned in Greek papyri will also be taken into consideration. To this comparison also literary and archaeological evidence will be added. This comparison of the text from the Fourth Gospel with Greek papyri will then raise the question as to how the amount has to be perceived. The paper will conclude with a discussion of the consequences of this analysis for the interpretation of this passage which marks the beginning of the signs in the Fourth Gospel.
|
Discourse Deixis in Biblical Hebrew
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
A. Dean Forbes, University of the Free State - Universiteit van die Vrystaat
The terms deictic or discourse deictic are “used for words which refer backwards or forwards in discourse (anaphora and cataphora respectively)” [Crystal (2008)]. In this paper, I consider the discourse-deictic uses of the 1,175 tokens of kh, kkh, and kn types attested in the Kethiv-text of the Hebrew Bible.
Following a brief review of the approaches to these entities found in traditional lexica and grammars, I suggest a discourse-deictic analysis. I then introduce and discuss the anaphoric and cataphoric incidences for each type, report instances of exophoric reference, and present discourses that require multidominance for their proper representation. Finally, I examine the usefulness of Polanyi’s right-frontier constraint when assigning anaphors in discourse.
|
The Jewish High Priest: Mediator of the Divine
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Deborah Forger, University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
Scholars have long emphasized a crucial difference between Jews and other the religious ethnicities scattered across the ancient Mediterranean world. While the monotheistic stance of Jews compelled them to worship the one God of Israel alone, the polytheistic outlook of others allowed them to worship the Roman emperor as though he were divine. However, in On Dreams 2.189, the Jewish philosopher Philo of Alexandria suggests that the Jewish high priest was also divine. Here, in an exegetical remark on Leviticus 16:17, Philo describes how on the most sacred day of the Jewish year, when the high priest enters the holy of holies to atone for the sins of the people, the high priest becomes "no longer a human," but is not quite God either. Rather, he becomes a sort of intermediary, touching "both extremities" of divinity and humanity simultaneously, "as if he touched both the feet and the head." Accordingly, for Philo the Jewish high priest stands at the boundaries between the created and uncreated realms in order to function as the instrument whose quasi-divine status enables humans to connect with God. By placing Philo’s comments within the context of other pagan, Jewish, and Christian literature that discusses the high priest—such as Hecataeus of Abdera, Sirach, and Josephus—I argue that the so-called monotheistic stance of Jews became compromised by their veneration of the high priest. In particular, as the high priest’s jurisdiction expanded beyond traditional cultic roles to include civic governance, many Jews—like their pagan counterparts with respect to the emperor—began to view, and worship, the high priest as though he were God.
|
Transmission as Interpretation: A Case Study on Jacob of Sarug’s Homily on the Blasphemer
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Philip Michael Forness, Princeton Theological Seminary
The homilies of Jacob of Sarug continue to be seen as remote from the controversies of his time. The earliest manuscripts of his works in the sixth century reflect this. They gather his homilies ordered according to the order of biblical canon, seemingly as a commentary, not a polemical tool. But this does not reflect the later manuscript tradition.
This presentation examines the transmission of one homily as a means of exploring the value of the manuscript tradition for our interpretation of Jacob’s homilies and, more broadly, any text with varied transmission. Despite its seemingly polemical title, Jacob’s Homily on the Blasphemer offers an exegesis of Leviticus 24:10–15, retaining, it seems, distance from the controversies of his time. The two manuscript witnesses to this homily offer competing interpretations. British Library, Add. 14,604, from the seventh-century, locates it within in a collection of works with a polemical orientation against dyophysite Christologies. Vatican, Syr. 117, from the twelfth century, places the homily within a large collection of texts at a time when the Syriac Orthodox Church was attempting to transmit its tradition by collecting the writings of important authors from the early church.
The juxtaposition of these two manuscripts poses an important question: What value does the interpretation of texts, shown through their transmission in manuscripts, have for how we approach and interpret the texts contained within? This presentation will outline several criteria for how we can begin to address this complicated question. I will argue that the transmission of texts can suggest their potential to serve roles that otherwise remain hidden from view.
|
Inner-dialogue on Women between Qohelet 7:26, 28; 9:9; Proverbs 2; 5; 6; 7; 18:22; LXX-Prov 18:22a and Sira through Metaphors of "Search" and "Hunting"
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Tova Forti, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
Reading Ben-Sira's lectures on various types of women sheds light on the sparse and elliptic references to women in Qohelet (7:26, 28 and 9:9), and supplies a preliminary manifest on the behavior and decorum of women seen as positive and negative in social contexts.
Confrontation between the adulterous woman and the wife of one's youth is already developed in Proverbs (2, 5, 6, and 7). Despite efforts made in research to explain the “strange woman” in Proverbs in other ways—as a metaphor, symbol or allegory for abstract dangers – this paper assumes the "strange woman" refers to a woman belonging to another man, namely a woman who is not yours.
This paper examines the recurrent use of the verb of ?-?-? "to seek/search" in Qoh 7:24, 26-29 in relation to other wisdom texts (Prov 18:22, LXX-Prov 18:22a; Sir 51:16) as referring to both eagerness for Sophia and seeking the ideal wife.
Against the sophia idiomatic use of search [[?-?-? for searching the right woman, Qohelet employs the hunting metaphor as a concretizing devise in his paideia against getting involved with dangerous women (Qoh 7:26; Prov 6:26; 7:22-23; Sir 9:3).
|
Afterthoughts on Proverbs: A Critical Edition and Text-Critical Commentary
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Michael V. Fox, University of Wisconsin-Madison
Discussion of text-critical issues in preparing Proverbs for publication (The Hebrew Bible: A Critical Edition, 2014).
|
The Qeré in the Context of the Masorah Parva
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Michael V. Fox, University of Wisconsin-Madison
The Qeré in the Context of the Masorah Parva
The ketiv is simply the written text in any Masoretic manuscript, though the term is usually used only of words paired with a qeré. It is more difficult to determine the nature of the qerayin. While the qeré is always studied in conjunction with the ketiv (as it must be), little attention has been paid to its form and function in the Mp. For a trial probe into this issue, I took a limited data base: the Mp of Proverbs, Job, and Psalms. I compared three manuscripts: the Aleppo Codex (early tenth century C.E.), the Leningradensis (1008-1009 C.E.), and a Yemenite codex, Cambridge University, Add. Ms. 1753 (1577 C.E).
Though the three witnesses usually agree on identifying the phenomena, they often describe them differently. The qerayin and functionally equivalent phenomena appear in different formats:
1. The standard or full format.
2. Apocopations.
3. Orthographic annotations, including (a) orthographic descriptions and counts; (b) explicit writing instructions; and (c) notation of superfluous letters.
There are also numerous nul entries, where one ms lacks a note to a word which is annotated in other manuscripts.
Certain conclusions can be proposed for the data in the trial cut (without asserting their validity for the entire biblical corpus):
(1) The qeré collection was not intended as a record of textual variants, though some may derive from knowledge of variant texts.
(2) The qerayin are not essentially a record of an oral tradition, though they certainly derive from oral and interpretive practices.
(3) There is a typological development leading from minimal notations into full qerayin.
(4) In the context of the Mp, the qerayin are primarily a prompt to the copyist to preserve the precise written form even though it “is read” (pronounced) as specified by the qeré-note.
|
Form, Content, and Tendenz in the Temple Scroll
Program Unit: Qumran
Steven D. Fraade, Yale University
Determining the "genre" under which the Temple Scroll might be located is difficult in part due to it its sui generis combination of form and content. Is it more like exemplars of "reworked Pentateuch" or of "rewritten Bible," or like neither? An alternative way of asking the question is to look within the text itself for the possible ways in which its textual form, topical contents, and ideological tendenz are mutually serving. This line of inquiry will be advanced through reference to two comparative exercises.
|
Encoding Apocalypse and Empire: Online Editions of Rev 17:1–18:24 and 21:1–22:7 and the Display of Intertextual Allusions
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
C. Thomas Fraatz, Boston College
Uniquely among the books of the New Testament, Revelation never cites Scripture directly and uses no citation formulae to indicate allusions. Yet John the Seer’s vision of God’s heavenly empire, casting the New Jerusalem as a heavenly metropolis and Babylon-Rome as a defeated enemy, repeatedly borrows words and imagery from Scripture. Indeed, Revelation contains more allusions to Scripture than any other early Christian text or the contemporary Jewish and Christian apocalypses. Despite this saturation of allusions, the idiosyncratic characteristics of Revelation complicate an intertextual analysis of John’s apocalypse. John seemingly diverges from the Septuagint and other ancient Greek translations, typically reflecting the recension preserved in the Masoretic Text. Furthermore, John combines multiple texts to generate a single image, entangling the readers in a web of prophetic allusions. The crush of marginalia in scholarly editions point toward this multifaceted intertextuality, but printed editions constrained by the spatial limitations of the page cannot graphically display the overwhelming density of Revelation’s allusions. Online editions, however, circumvent these physical restrictions.
Using Rev 17:1-18:24 and 21:1-22:7 as case studies, this paper demonstrates the potential of online annotated editions to represent visually John’s reapplication of Scripture. Free from the spatial constraints of printed texts, online editions can provide fuller, dynamic references. Allusions in the body text can be color-coded, and the marginal references can be hyperlinked to source texts in the MT and LXX. Online editions also provide flexibility, as users can toggle citations of individual texts, selecting the source texts and text-forms they prefer. Expanding beyond case studies to whole books will provide enhanced visual tools, such as heat maps to indicate clusters of citations or recurring imagery. Though digitally annotated editions will not solve the riddles of Revelation’s intertextual allusions, they will expand our tools for interpreting John’s immersive vision of God’s heavenly empire.
|
Wasted Seed and Sins of Intent: Sexual Ethics in Spec. 3.34–36 in the Case of Infertile Marriage
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Michael Francis, University of Notre Dame
De specialibus legibus 3.34-36 is one of the more intriguing passages in which Philo deals, in one way or another, with sex. Here in the Exposition of the Law, Philo considers the phenomenon of infertile marriage. More specifically, he addresses two different cases of infertile marriage, and offers contrasting assessments of each. The passage is of particular interest for two reasons. First, unlike the surrounding material, Philo has no scriptural basis for his interpretation in this section. Second, in one of the two cases addressed, Philo offers what seems to be qualified approval of the childless marriage as a going concern but does not specify sexual abstinence for partners who, on the face of it, cannot engage in procreative intercourse. This silence appears particularly pointed when viewed against the immediately preceding section and in light of Philo's perspective on sex more generally. In Spec. 3.32-33, Philo unambiguously prohibits sexual activity for the duration of another situation not conducive to procreation, the time of a woman's monthly period. More generally, Philo's perspective on sex is notoriously demanding. In a wide range of passages across the Philonic corpus, Philo presents a strict procreationist perspective that, it would seem, finds no legitimate place for nonprocreative (marital) sex.
This paper has three goals. First, it locates and considers Spec. 3.34-36 alongside other sections of Philo's treatment of the Sixth [/Seventh] Commandment, sections with which it shares a conspicuous characteristic: the rationalization of the biblical legislation in the conceptualization of illicit sexual activity as a condemnable wasting of seed. Second, it explores the phenomenon of the inclusion of this passage in Philo's presentation of biblical law. Why does Philo include this material? Third, it addresses the particular puzzle identified above. What should we make of Philo's failure to specify sexual abstinence in Spec. 3.35? If, implicitly, Philo does allow for ongoing sexual activity within some marriages long since proved infertile, why or on what basis might he do this? In response to this question, the paper interacts with the reading of Spec. 3.34-36 proposed by Maren Niehoff (in her influential study, Philo on Jewish Identity and Culture), who finds in this passage support for her contention that Philo's procreative concern is directed towards the wider context or general framework within which sex occurs, rather than sexual activity per se. In response, this paper argues that if Philo sanctions ongoing sexual activity in the case of certain infertile marriages, and that without fatally compromising his procreationist convictions, the outstanding candidate for satisfaction of the procreative requirement is the procreative intention of the husband. The paper concludes with some brief reflections on the challenge of framing Philo's perspective on marriage and sexual conduct, and, correspondingly, of accounting for certain details in Philo's treatment of marriage and sexual conduct that seemingly jar with his central convictions.
|
“John Did No Sign”: The Synoptic Evidence Reconsidered
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Daniel Frayer-Griggs, Duquesne University
It is often assumed that while Jesus performed healings and exorcisms, John the Baptist did nothing of the sort. The Fourth Evangelist’s claim that “John did no sign” (John 10:41) would appear to confirm this. Challenging this assumption, this paper demonstrates that several synoptic traditions assume the belief that John, like Jesus, was a reputed exorcist. Texts to be examined include Mark 6:14 (and parallels), where the people and Herod identify Jesus as “John the Baptist raised from the dead” on account of the “deeds of power” at work in Jesus, and the charge that John “has a demon” (Matt 11:18; cf. Luke 7:33), which is strongly reminiscent of the charge leveled against Jesus—“he has Beelzebul” (Mark 3:22)—on account of his success as an exorcist.
|
By What Authority Do You Do These Things? The Origin of Jesus' Reputation as Healer
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Daniel Frayer-Griggs, Duquesne University
Recent studies have identified Jesus as a folk healer whose success as an exorcist and healer was contingent upon his reputation and people's faith in his powers. This raises the question: how does one first attain a reputation as a successful healer? Jesus' inability to heal in his hometown of Nazareth (Mark 6:5) suggests that early in his life he enjoyed no such reputation. This paper will argue that it was through his association with John the Baptist that Jesus first gained authority as a healer. The case will be made that John too was regarded as a healer (cf. Mark 6:14) and that the association of Jesus' baptism by John with his reception of the spirit (through which he subsequently healed) offers a critical clue to the origin of Jesus’ reputation as a healer and exorcist.
|
It’s the End of the World as We Know It: Apocalyptic Eschatology, the Gentile Mission, and the Mysticism of Schweitzer’s Paul
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Paula Fredriksen, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
It’s The End of the World As We Know It: Apocalyptic Eschatology, The Gentile Mission, and the Mysticism of Schweitzer’s Paul
|
Revising in Response to the Competition: On a More Dynamic Relationship between P and Non-P
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Aron Freidenreich, Union Theological Seminary in the City of New York
Perhaps the most important and enduring contribution of critical Pentateuchal scholarship over the past two centuries has been the clear-cut distinction of Priestly materials from other, non-Priestly traditions within the Pentateuchal corpus. However, the same unmistakable distinctiveness of the Priestly material that allowed for such relative consensus in distinguishing between P and non-P texts has also led to some erroneous theories over the years regarding P’s chronological and literary relationships with its non-Priestly counterpart. So, for example, Pentateuchal scholars originally attempted to match P’s literary uniqueness with a historical separateness, such that the sharp differences in P could be said to be caused by, and reflective of, its distance in time and place from non-P. But whereas P was originally conceived of as the earliest “Grundlage” (foundational basis) and was later considered the last contribution to the Pentateuchal corpus, scholars have increasingly attributed non-Priestly texts to both pre-P and post-P origins, thereby desegregating P from its strict historical separateness from non-P. Similarly, the more recent approaches viewing P as a redactional layer or as a “Komposition” have offered less rigid alternatives to the strict separation of Priestly and non-Priestly sources envisioned by the Documentary Hypothesis. However, I believe that there is a somewhat middle position that can still accept the correctness of the “Quellenschrift” (source document) model without retreating to the opposite extreme of contending P’s and non-P’s mutual unawareness, as advocated by Neo-Documentarians. In this paper, I will argue for the possibility of a more dynamic relationship between the Priestly and non-Priestly literary traditions even as the two remained independent, self-standing corpora. Moreover, I will explore specific examples of passages within both sets of material that seem to show evidence of revisions within these separate corpora in response to the competition.
|
Understanding alla, ei/ean me, and plen: The Importance of Differentiating Their Discourse-Pragmatic Functions
Program Unit:
Chris Fresch, University of Cambridge
Greek writers had several options available for restricting statements, including use of particles such as alla, ei/ean me, and plen. Descriptions in traditional grammars and lexica sometimes create the impression that there is significant overlap between these particles, making it tempting to conflate their distinctive functions. This presentation introduces participants to a cognitive-based framework that describes the discourse function of particles regardless of how they might end up being translated. Each particle is understood to contribute a different cognitive constraint, allowing for greater differentiation between their respective functions and thereby aiding in our exegesis. After describing the unique constraints of alla, ei/ean me, and plen, attendees will have an opportunity to collaboratively apply these descriptions to passages from the New Testament. The session will conclude with a general discussion of the passages.
|
Limiting "all' e": An Investigation into Its Use in the Septuagint in Light of Contemporary Papyri
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Chris Fresch, University of Cambridge
Any reader of the Septuagint will, at some point or another, come across the collocation of the particles alla and e (commonly written as all' e). Out of about 550 occurrences of alla in the Septuagint, almost 140 of them co-occur with the particle e. Despite representing twenty-five percent of the uses of alla in the Septuagint, all' e has received very little treatment in lexicons, grammars, and scholarship on Septuagintal translation technique. At worst, the collocation is ignored altogether; at best, it is assumed to be functionally equivalent to alla.
The purpose of this paper is to investigate the use of all' e in the Septuagint and what a translator may be communicating about his understanding of his source text by choosing this collocation, rather than alla alone or ean me, to render various Hebrew particles. Instead of ignoring all' e or simply equating it with alla, a functional description will be offered that takes into account the discourse context and the relevance constraints of the collocation. In addition, evidence from contemporary papyri will aid the discussion, helping to delimit the function of all' e and clarify its use in comparison with alla. As will be seen, all' e serves a slightly different function than alla. While the two are related, all' e is frequently used as a limiting construction, both actual and metaphorical. The use of this collocation by the Septuagint translators is significant, especially in the many instances in which it is not lexically motivated by the underlying Hebrew. Understanding its function and paying attention to its use may provide further insight into the translators and how they read their Vorlagen.
|
On Murders and Methodology: Reading the David Story as Propaganda
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Daniel A. Frese, Franklin & Marshall College
The stories of David’s rise from obscurity to kingship over the united tribes of Israel continues to engage both popular and scholarly imagination. Books about the historicity of the narratives in Samuel and 1 Kings have been produced at a steady pace for the last three decades, with many varied re-creations of the “true” historical David. An approach shared by several recent authors, however, is the assertion that many of the stories about David’s rise to the throne should be understood as propaganda. In this paper, I will review and critique some of the divergent results that this approach has produced, including the date of the text’s composition, and evaluate the legitimacy and usefulness of labeling these narratives as propaganda.
|
An Early Persian Pottery Assemblage of Yehud Jars from Ramat Rahel
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Liora Freud, Tel Aviv University
The Ramat Rahel excavations have yielded the greatest number of Persian Period stamp impressions ever found in one site. Renewed excavations identified for the first time the type of jar which bore them, never before found with stamps; in marked contrast to the well-known late Iron Age Judahite ovoid four handle jars bearing lmlk or rosette stamp impressions.
The rich pottery assemblage excavated from one sealed pit includes these new jar types, which were impressed with "lion," Yehud, and "private" stamps on their handles or shoulders.
Typological study of this assemblage shows that the former late Iron Age tradition is still present in most vessel types such as bowls, cooking pots and the jars. Despite a difference in raw material and a drastic decrease in the manufacturing quality, one can clearly see that the ancient potters continued to produce the same morphological features.
In this paper I will present this new pottery assemblage and its position in the chronological sequence between the late Iron Age and the early Persian period. The consequent implications of this typology for stamp impression studies will also be discussed.
|
Heavenly Abodes, the Parusia, and the Hope for the Final Communion with Christ in John
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Jörg Frey, Universität Zürich
TBA
|
Intermarriage and Exile: The Threat of Foreign Influences
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
Lisbeth Fried, University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
The intermarriage crisis portrayed in Ezra 9-10 (and Nehemiah 13) are literary texts whose sitz im leben demands to be discovered. Is the mass divorce historic, or, is it rather a manifestation of later fears and apprehensions retrojected onto an earlier period? If historic, is it an external matter, imposed on unwilling Judeans as a result of Persian imperial policy (as the mass divorce from foreigners imposed on the people of contemporary Athens was a matter of Athenian imperial policy)? Or, was it an internal matter, a search for a strong Judean ethnic identity as a result of the disastrous and recent effects of exile?
If not historic, does the text actually reflect the concerns of the period in which these books were finalized, at the end of the fourth century? That is, was it rather a general fear of the Hellenistic influences prevailing in the region of Palestine after the Macedonian conquest that sparked these texts?
While definitively answering these questions may not be possible, outlining the strengths and weaknesses of the various alternatives may enable progress toward the solution of these problems.
|
The Levites in Egypt
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
Richard Elliott Friedman, University of Georgia
There were western Asiatic people in Egypt, and there was an exodus of some of them from Egypt. Not all of Israel was there. There is no evidence of such a huge exodus population, and there are few signs of Egyptian material cultural influence in early Israel. But there are signs of such cultural influence among the Levites: Egyptian names, architecture, design of shrines, practices. And the huge numbers (which are not mentioned in the earliest biblical sources) are not necessary if it was just the Levites. Their arrival and merger in Israel resulted in the doctrine that the God El and their God YHWH were one and the same. And it resulted in their acquiring the priesthood, the tithe, and the role of teachers, which in turn resulted in their teaching all of Israel to accept the doctrine of having been slaves in Egypt.
|
Getting Samuel Sober: A Plus in LXX 1 Sam 1:11 and Its Ethical Afterlife
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Courtney Friesen, University of Oxford
The Old Greek of 1 Sam 1:11 includes a component of Hannah’s vow lacking in the MT: “wine and liquor [Samuel] shall not drink.” The status of this phrase in the translator’s Vorlage is ultimately inconclusive: on the one hand, it is plausible that the translator inserted it under the influence of Hannah’s later assertion of her own sobriety (1:15) or in conformity to the Nazirite vow (e.g., Num 6:2-5); on the other, its probable attestation in 4QSam provides this phrase with an early Hebrew witness. This paper explores the implications of this ‘plus’ as it relates to the moral and religious entailments of alcohol in ancient Judaism. Here, Philo’s interpretation of 1 Sam 1 is particularly striking. In De ebrietate, a treatise devoted to the exegesis of biblical texts relating to wine and drunkenness, he takes Hannah’s oath as a starting point for his exposition of Samuel’s spiritual virtue (Ebr. 143-53). In Philo’s reading of this passage, the prophet’s abstinence is not ultimately taken literally, but rather occasions reflections on “sober inebriation,” the condition whereby the truly pious ascend to a divine vision. I argue that Philo’s appropriation of this biblical text functions on at least two fronts. First, he engages with contemporary philosophical debates (esp. among Stoics) regarding the sage and intoxication (Plant. 140-47), and aims to demonstrate that scriptural prohibitions against alcohol were exceptional not normative and were to be understood as spiritual metaphors. Second, in view of Samuel’s prominence in the history of Israelite prophecy, the question of the role of alcohol in oracular inspiration is implicit. This was also a concern of several contemporaries, including Greeks and Romans (e.g., Plutarch and Livy) and Christians; for the latter, I argue, it underlies the narratives of John the Baptist’s abstinence and the apostles’ alleged drunkenness at Pentecost.
|
(En-)Acting Tragedy: Philo on Emperor Gaius’ Theatrical Pretensions
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Courtney Friesen, University of Oxford
In the late Republic and early Empire, theatrical spectacle was a prominent feature of Roman society. Dramatic performance functioned among other things as a mean for elites to exhibit their wealth and power. Myths were frequently staged with a view to contemporary politics, as depicting the achievements of elite Romans or contestations of power. Within this wider metatheatrical context, the personal interest in the stage taken by some Roman emperors is striking. This paper explores several ways in which Philo brings Roman conceptions of the theater to bear on his criticisms of the emperor in the Legatio ad Gaium. First, Gaius associated with professional actors, a connection that Philo, in keeping with contemporary senatorial sentiment, regarded as morally reprehensible. Moreover, Philo observes that Gaius would dress up in the theater as various gods and demigods in an odious blending of the theatrical with his own aspirations for divine honors. Philo argues, however, that in his administration Gaius failed adequately to embody the divine figures whom he imitated on stage; rather, his government enacted tragic plots in the theater of empire. Philo’s evocation of the interplay between tragedy and contemporary conflict is particularly evident in his narrative of the events ensuing from Gaius’ threat to erect a statue of himself in the Jerusalem temple (40 CE). Attempting to preserve the temple’s sanctity, the Jewish delegation to the Syrian governor offered to sacrifice themselves and their own family members, asserting that “tragic misfortunes” (tragikai symphorai) require “tragic terminology” (tragika onomata) (Legat. 234). Proceeding with an expression of pathos, they evoke a central feature of Greek tragedy—kin-murder performed as ritual sacrifice—in order to characterize the consequences of Gaius’ policies. In this rhetorical move, Philo deploys a literary trope that blurs distinctions between tragedy, history, and politics.
|
Unpairing and Repairing: Mary and Joseph in Ancient Christian Infancy Accounts
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Chris Frilingos, Michigan State University
This paper will focus on the depiction of Mary and Joseph in two distinct moments of early Christian storytelling. The first moment involves the Synoptic Gospels of Matthew and Luke, which introduce Mary and Joseph as a couple engaged to be wed. Both accounts fasten the messianic credentials of Mary's baby to Joseph's ancestry while raising questions about paternity. Matthew refers to conception by the Holy Spirit (1:18). Luke begins the genealogy with an obscure aside: "He was the son, as was thought (hos enomizeto), of Joseph son of Heli" (3:23). The second moment belongs to the Protevangelium Jacobi, a pseudonymous, second-century account of the childhood and teenage years of Mary. In it Mary and Joseph do not marry, and the nature of the relationship remains somewhat vague. Yet together they brave doubt, scandal, and a potentially lethal ordeal. The Protevangelium Jacobi thus illustrates more clearly than the Synoptic Gospels the strength of the bond between the unmarried pair.
The paper has three parts. Part one will discuss the depiction of Mary and Joseph in the Synoptic infancy stories. Turning to the Protevangelium Jacobi, part two will highlight instances of amplification—moments that intensify and perhaps distort the Synoptic tradition. Part three will discuss what these two moments of storytelling can tell us about the complicated process by which later Christian texts both pay tribute to and contest earlier narratives.
|
Disembowelment as Disempowerment: A Reexamination of Violent Death in 2 Maccabees 14
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
Alexandria Frisch, Ursinus College
This paper theorizes the body as a site for power dynamics in Second Maccabees. Specifically, it focuses on an account of self-disembowelment in 2 Maccabees 14 in which a Jew, confronted by Greek persecution, publicly tears out his own entrails and hurls them at imperial soldiers. Following theorists Wolfgang Kayser and Mikhail Bahktin, I view disembowelment as not only violent, but grotesque; the abnormal (the intestines spilling forth) interrupts the normal (the unadulterated body) as one’s insides are now outside. Thus, grotesque elements within a story call the normative world into question and, in the case of a text written about foreign domination, unsettle expectations about power.
This paper begins with an analysis of biblical texts such as Judges 3 and 2 Samuel 20 in order to demonstrate how disembowelment, as a literary motif, resolves issues of power within stories of early Israel. The paper then explores the use of the same motif within 2 Maccabees. While scholars have noted how the tortured body functions in martyrdom legends to defy the ruling power (i.e., the victim ultimately retains control by embracing death), they have ignored this story’s grotesqueness. Throwing intestines at soldiers transforms the intestines into weaponry, turning the story’s imperial world upside down—the empire’s victim becomes the empire’s attacker. Moreover, the Jew asks God to return his intestines through resurrection. Only God’s power can make the man whole again, resolving the grotesque situation necessitated by the violent imperial setting.
Viewed in this way, the concept of resurrection is a direct response to empire. More broadly, then, this paper highlights an intrinsic connection in post-biblical literature between depictions of the body and issues of power. This paper, thus, lays the groundwork for a reexamination of the varied and new somatic beliefs in the Second Temple period (among Jews and Early Christians alike), suggesting that they are more of a response to imperial power than has previously been considered.
|
An Interpersonal Metafunction Analysis of the Dialogue between Joseph and the Egyptians in Gen 47:13–26
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
David J. Fuller, McMaster Divinity College
Joseph’s enslavement of the Egyptians in Gen 47:13–26 has been interpreted as being culturally benevolent as well as oppressive. Some scholars have disputed the role of the narrator; was he trying to subtly imply Joseph was a tyrant, or was he proudly showing an example of administrative wisdom? More broadly, quite a few different explanations have been given for its function, or “main point” in the Joseph novella as a whole. Regardless of its centrality or marginality to the author’s intention, one interpretive topic that has piqued the curiosity of all types of scholars is the relationship between Joseph and the Egyptians as depicted in the narrative, and how the social hierarchy between the two parties is negotiated. While many scholars have ventured forth opinions on this topic, it has usually been on grounds of general intuition and not within a system that utilizes grammatically substantiated criteria for discerning the dynamics of interaction. The interpersonal metafunction of Halliday is an ideal resource with which to address this question. It provides categories of speech roles into which one can classify each clause of a given speech utterance. Each speech role has an expected response and a discretionary alternative, and by tracking how closely a respondent follows the expected responses, one can discern the social heirarchy assumed on the part of that participant. Additionally, by tracking the exchange of the subject and finite verb throughout a discourse, one can discern which participants take the initiative in setting and modulating the topic. It is the intention of this study to demonstrate that clarity can be brought to the dispute over the nature of the interaction between Joseph and the Egyptians in Gen 47:13–26 by applying the analytical tools of the Interpersonal Metafunction from the Systemic Functional Linguistics of M.A.K. Halliday.
|
Quotations of and Allusions to the Book of the Twelve and the Book of Ezekiel in the Damascus Document and Their Use in the Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Russell E. Fuller, University of San Diego
There are at least twenty-six suggested quotations or allusions to the Twelve Minor Prophets in the various manuscripts of the Damascus Document and at least ten suggested quotations or allusions to the Book of Ezekiel. This paper will first determine which of the suggested quotations and allusions are valid and seek to address the following questions regarding them. (1) How does the Damascus Document handle the quoted or alluded texts? (2) From which textual types are the quoted or alluded texts drawn (proto/semi-MT, Vorlage LXX, non-aligned)? (3) Are these quotations and allusions to biblical texts of any text critical value and if so, what methodological questions are raised in their use fro the textual criticism of the Hebrew Bible? All extant manuscript evidence for the text of the Damascus Document will be referenced in this paper including the manuscripts from the Cairo Geniza and fragments of CD from Caves 4 and 6 at Qumran.
|
The THB - Online Interface
Program Unit:
Russell Fuller, University of San Diego
The Textual History of the Bible will provide an invaluable and unique resource for both specialists in the study of the text of the Bible as well as for generalists. Online access to this resource will make the THB of even more use to scholars. This paper will present ideas for the interface and search functions of the online version of the THB. We are very interested in having feedback from eventual end-users before the interface for the THB is finalized.
|
The Changing Status of the Netînîm in Second Temple Period
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
Deirdre N. Fulton, Baylor University
The literature of the postexilic period demonstrates the importance biblical writers placed on establishing boundaries. Several texts delineate the people and/or groups who were part of the Temple community in Jerusalem and those who were not. In the postexilic texts of Ezra, Nehemiah, and 1 Chronicles, the Netînîm are occasionally mentioned as part of the Jerusalem Temple community along with the Priests and Levites. In later Qumran and Rabbinic traditions, however, the Netînîm are no longer considered part of the elite religious community. Scholars such as B. Levine and J. Weinberg have examined the Netînîm, specifically focusing on textual traditions and the personal names of certain Netînîm in order to understand their function and status within the Jerusalem Temple community. These two scholars, however, differ concerning the level of inclusion of the Netînîm within the Jerusalem Temple community. This paper will explore the role of the Netînîm within the postexilic traditions of Ezra and Nehemiah and their demotion in later traditions. Borrowing upon anthropological studies of ethnicity and identity, such as the Us-Them phenomenon (T. Erickson 1993), I will explore motivations for the changing status of the Netînîm from the background of their full inclusion in Ezra-Nehemiah to their lesser role in the era of Qumran.
|
Moral Reading as Mystical Ascent: A Nyssan Critique of Richard Hays
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
Timothy J. Furry, Cranbrook Kingswood Upper School
Theological interpretation of Scripture has enjoyed prominence in many circles over the past two decades in biblical and theological studies—and rightly so. While acknowledging the specific contributions of Richard Hays to the rise of theological reading and the fruit it has produced, this paper will argue that Hays’ narrative-ethical reading of Paul and the New Testament does not go far enough and remains circumscribed by modern historical and philosophical assumptions insofar as Hays’ theological focus remains on ethical formation within the community of faith and not on mystical union with Christ. Using Gregory of Nyssa, I will show that Hays’ use of Scripture is unable to address and articulate, with the same theological profundity as St. Paul and Gregory of Nyssa, the proper telos of humanity in God as evidenced in Scripture. In other words, I will show how Hays risks reading moral formation as an end in itself for Christianity, while Paul and Gregory of Nyssa understand morality as a means to the end of union with God. The paper will engage specific exegetical arguments from Scripture in Hays and Nyssa, but will focus on the use of Scripture and how it’s (re)presented by both exegetes.
|
Reading Luke-Acts Using Contextual Bible Study among Pentecostal Women in Botswana
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Rose Gabaitse, University of Botswana
Biblical Interpretation in Botswana has always been dominated by men within the churches and the academy. The result of this is that women’s voices remain largely unheard and this is the cry of African women scholars including me. In an effort to make women’s voices heard especially on how they negotiate and struggle with patriarchy both in the church and in Biblical texts, I engaged them in a contextual reading of selected texts from Luke-Acts using the Contextual Bible Study method popularised by Gerald West of the University of Kwa-Zulu Natal. Luke-Acts is important to Pentecostals because Pentecostal identity revolves around the work of the Holy Spirit and it is the basis for the major Pentecostal beliefs and doctrines. While the focus on the Holy Spirit should make the Pentecostal space an egalitarian space, the reality is the Pentecostal church is ambivalent towards women. CBS then offered a safe space to the Pentecostal women who are on the margins to read and interpret the Bible. I used it in an effort to hear, listen, engage with, and partner with Pentecostal women in reading Luke-Acts within patriarchal spaces. In this paper I discuss CBS as a method of data collection and as a safe space for marginalised people to read and interpret the Bible for their empowerment. The second part of this paper will focus on how through their reading of Luke-Acts, Pentecostal women offered a critique of patriarchy within Pentecostal spaces and Pentecostal biblical interpretation.
|
Separated by Grace?! Heb 2:9 and the Mutual Interdependence of Christological Debates and Textual Transmission
Program Unit: Hebrews
Georg Gäbel, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
The textual variation in Heb 2:9b is a window both onto the history of the textual transmission and on the early use and interpretation of the Epistle to the Hebrews. In this paper, I will concentrate on citations and interpretations of Heb 2:9 in works of Christian authors, beginning roughly with the time of the council of Nicaea and ending roughly with the aftermath of the council of Chalcedon and of the Nestorian controversy. Christological debates and doctrinal decisions were influenced by contemporaneous exegesis and vice versa. I will pursue the development of the interpretive strategies applied to Heb 2:9 in the context of contemporaneous Christological debates. I will ask which role textual variation did (or did not) play in this process, and how notions of orthodoxy or heterodoxy did (or did not) influence it. Finally, I will suggest that the importance of Christological debates of the 4th-6th centuries for our understanding of the textual history of the NT may be greater than is sometimes assumed.
|
It’s All about Presentation: Methodological Reflections on the Use of Greek Manuscript, Versional, and Patristic Material in Critical Editions: The Example of Acts 1:2
Program Unit: Novum Testamentum Graecum: Editio Critica Maior
Georg Gäbel, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
In this paper I will discuss some of the questions which arise in our work on the Editio Critica Maior (ECM) of Acts. I will take as my starting point one variation unit in Acts 1:2. Some of the variants in this verse are certainly important for those interested in the so-called “Western” textual tradition and in the so-called Western non-interpolations. However, the focus of my contribution will be mainly on editorial procedures and decisions, and not so much on textual history/criticism as such. I will mention some of the decisions made by other editors before, and the (putative) reasoning behind them. I will briefly discuss some of the versional and Greek manuscript evidence available at this point. On this basis, I will then address the questions of the presentation of evidence in the ECM – particularly, but not only, versional and patristic evidence.
|
Populace-Ravaging Warfare in Deut 20:10–14 and Beyond
Program Unit: Warfare in Ancient Israel
Kathy L. Gaca, Vanderbilt University
In ancient war discourse, two ideological tropes discourage the investigation of the ways in which populace-ravaging martial forces attack targeted people: The portrayal of ravaging overlords as superman agents, such as “David slew every male in Edom” (1 Kings 11:15), and the romantic legend that such deeds are manly.
Sobering discoveries emerge, however, when we study historical evidence that discloses populace-ravaging methods and aims. There is not, as commonly assumed, a single generic method, the one that includes killing fighting-age males, known in Greek as “andrapodi¬zing.” A second method includes the slaughter of males of all ages at an overlord’s command. For example, Israelite forces in Deut 20:10-14 and elsewhere in the Hebrew Bible must “put all the males to the sword” in distant cities whose inhabitants fight back rather than surrender. This command is significantly different from the andra-podizing policy of killing only fighting-age men, despite scholarly consensus to the contrary. These ravaging methods are differentiated in this way by the Greek geographer-historians Strabo and Pausanias and the Christian Platonist Synesius. The killing of all males is further recognized as a broader Indo-European practice from Homeric epic to Synesius.
Populace-ravaging by either method has a corresponding female-targeting aspect of aggression. Based on ancient accounts, armed forces kill mature women (Num 31:1-47, Judg 21:1-15), mainly through lethal gang rape (Hdt. 8.33, Isocr. epist. Archid. 9.10, Paus. 10.22.2-4), so as to abduct girls and young women alive. The young female captives are then subjected to survivable rape, compulsory procreation, and coerced labor. Thus, by looking behind the usual tropes of populace-ravaging warfare, we see what the devastating effects of this martial aggression against the attacked people overall, females and males, young and mature.
|
Economy, Society, and Land Ownership: Jerusalem, Ramat Rahel, and the Rural Hinterland during the Iron and Persian Periods
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Yuval Gadot, Tel Aviv University
Scholars have often emphasized the contribution of analyzing rural land exploitation for reconstructing the economic, political and social history of Judah and its capital city Jerusalem. In this paper the settlement pattern around Jerusalem during the late Iron Age and the Persian period will be presented and discussed.
Numerous excavations and surveys conducted mainly by the Israel Antiquity Authority have contributed for the creation of a large corpus of over 150 settlement sites that were settled between the 8th and 3rd centuries BCE. Close examination of the material culture shows that most of these sites were first settled during the 7th century and after a crisis some have re sprung during the 5th and 4th centuries BCE.
The paper will examine the significance of these dates: why was there a settlement peak after the 8th century BCE? How deep was the 6th century 'crisis'? And finally - what brought about the revival of rural activities in the 5th and 4th centuries BCE?
|
Keep Justice! (Isa 56:1): The Programmatic Opening of Trito-Isaiah (Isa 56–66) and Its Redactional Function for the Entire Book of Isaiah
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Judith Gaertner, Universität Osnabrück
The opening of Trito-Isaiah unfolds a concept of sedaqa which in its universal orientation is unique for the Old Testament. It is unique, because it unfolds the meaning of a universal understanding of sedaqa without hesitation and with full consequences. This perspective is explored in view of the individual at its limits. The perspective of belonging to the nation of God is exemplarily for all humankind opened up for foreigners and Eunuchs, the ones at the boundaries of the community. Central condition is a life lived in accordance to sedaqa. The text shows a reciprocal approach to this condition. Foreigners and Eunuchs who practice sedaqa by keeping the Sabbath and holding fast the covenant are thereby ritually integrated into the nation of God. The outcome of this is that the house of YHWH is called a house of prayer for all people (Is 56:7).
On this background the paper will focus on two questions. First, a central aspect of the paper will focus on the question of the understanding of sedaqa, which is a main topic in the whole of the Book of Isaiah. Here, it will be of main interest which concepts of Proto-Isaiah and Deutero-Isaiah are received, continued and modified. Second, the significance of the redaction history of Is 56:1-8 as the opening of Trito-Isaiah will be analyzed. What is the intention of a text which shows such an exposed understanding of sedaqa regarding the composition of the whole Book? In order to answer this question it will be necessary to take into consideration not only questions of redaction criticism regarding Trito-Isaiah but also regarding the whole of the Book of Isaiah.
|
The Camel Passing through the Eye of the Needle: A Comparison between the Qur’an, the Greek Gospels, and Tatian’s Syriac Diatessaron
Program Unit: The Qur’an and the Biblical Tradition (IQSA)
Abdulla Galadari, Masdar Institute
The metaphor of a camel passing through the eye of a needle is found in the story of the rich man in the Synoptic Gospels and also found in the Qur’an, but from an apparently different context [Qur’an 7:40]. Those who argue for the Aramaic primacy use this metaphor as a proof that the rendition is more accurate for camel (gml), as it also means a rope. They argue that it is supposed to be understood it is a rope and not a camel that goes through the eye of a needle, which logically would make more sense. However, in Greek, the difference between the words for camel (kamelos) and rope (kamilos) are morphological, which Cyril of Alexandria had even suggested. Nonetheless, the Gospels seem to suggest that it is easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle than a rich person to enter the Kingdom of God. The Qur’an, on the other hand, puts it in the context of disbelievers who are arrogant (istakbaru). From the outset, it would seem that the contexts of the Gospels and the Qur’an are different. However, through a closer analysis of the keywords, there are textual parallels that can be extracted between the Gospels and the Qur’an. The term for rich used in Greek is “plousios.” The verses preceding state that the person had great (polys) possessions. The Arabic term for arrogant is rooted in “kbr,” which also means great. In Aramaic, the term “kbyr” means both large and also rich. If we suggest that the Qur’an is quoting or alluding to the Gospels using this metaphor, then the term (istakbaru) may not only mean arrogant ones, but also rich ones, or people with abundant (kbr / polys) wealth. Perhaps it is also that the Gospels’ use of the term “polys” could be translated as “kbyr” for both rich and arrogant. Although the rendition of the Arabic Qur’an seems to be closer to the Greek than the Aramaic, there is a lot of parallelism between chronological events of the Qur’anic context of the camel passing through the eye of the needle with Tatian’s Syriac Diatessaron.
|
The Antilegomena in Rufinus of Aquileia
Program Unit: Function of Apocryphal and Pseudepigraphal Writings in Early Judaism and Early Christianity
Ed Gallagher, Heritage Christian University
Rufinus of Aquileia had a great deal to say about the biblical canon. In his Commentary on the Apostle’s Creed, he found occasion to include a list of the canonical books in his explanation of the doctrine of the Holy Spirit. Besides this, he also translated a number of Greek works that contain important statements on the canon, especially the Ecclesiastical History by Eusebius. Yet, scholars have not devoted significant attention to Rufinus’ views. This is unfortunate, for he presents an interesting study in several ways. The period of his life—at the end of the fourth century and the first decade of the fifth—saw the hardening of the boundaries of the biblical canon, even as debates continued especially in regard to the deuterocanonical literature and certain New Testament documents, such as some of the Catholic Epistles. His translations testify to his effort to adapt to his later time several earlier Christian writings with their statements on scriptural books that are often less clear than what Rufinus’ audience knew. Rufinus himself, while very learned, was not a great theologian or scholar, like Augustine or Jerome; he wanted to transmit tradition, thus making him a value witness to the doctrine he thought would be generally recognized as orthodox in his day. This paper will show that Rufinus advocated a "traditional" approach to canonical issues even as he recognized that the situation in his day differed at times significantly from what prevailed only a few decades earlier. By focusing on his treatment of the books on the fringe of the canon, the antilegomena of the OT and NT, this paper highlights the varying fortunes of these books throughout the fourth century.
|
Augustine on the Greek and Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Ed Gallagher, Heritage Christian University
This paper will explore Augustine’s developing theory about the place of the Septuagint in the divine economy and the relationship of the translation to its Hebrew Vorlage. Augustine’s ardent support for the Septuagint as the true Old Testament for the Church never waned, but his understanding of the relationship between the Hebrew Bible and the Septuagint did develop over his career. His earliest statements on the issue assume that the Seventy translators faithfully rendered the Hebrew text, and any discrepancy among Greek translations of that Hebrew text simply results from the inherent ambiguity of the source text. His correspondence with Jerome convinced him that there was more to it than that, that there were genuine differences, beyond just translational difficulties, between the Septuagint and its Vorlage. As a theologian for the Church, he was unwilling to abandon the Bible sanctioned by the Church, as Jerome had done. Instead, he developed a theory whereby both the Hebrew text and its Greek translation could be correct, guiding the reader to spiritual insight, even if they said different things. In this respect the two texts resemble the multiple voices of the Fourfold Gospel, or the various Prophets enshrined in scripture, each speaking the Word of God differently. Whereas earlier Christians (and Jews) who had trumpeted the authority of the Septuagint had dismissed the Hebrew text as irrelevant because of the accuracy and authority of its Greek rendering, Augustine’s mature views attribute to the Hebrew Bible a still significant place within the Church.
|
Contending with Postmodern Hermeneutics and Biblical Criticism: Thinking Philosophical Theology with the Jesus Seminar
Program Unit: Westar Institute
David Galston, Brock University and Westar Institute
*
|
The Megilloth and the Horizontal Dimension of the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Megilloth
Garrett Galvin, Franciscan School of Theology
Recent scholarship has called attention to the importance of the Megilloth within the third part of the Hebrew canon. All five books offer a horizontal theology in which human experience comes before dogma often associated with a more vertical theology. Ecclesiastes questions the certainties of dogma. Song of Songs is a celebration of love that challenges rigid boundaries. Rather than the proscriptions against intermarriage based on Moses in Neh 10:30-31 and 13:25, Ruth and Esther highlight a more pragmatic approach to human experience. The lived reality of these two characters (Ruth and Esther) stands in tension with much of the Torah and especially the Deuteronomistic History. Lamentations represents a love for even the seemingly disastrous kings that the ideology of DH or Jeremiah does not seem to allow (Lam 4:20). The Megilloth seems to show openness to boundary-breaking love that is shared in the Joseph Story.
|
Storm Theophany and the Portrait of YHWH as King in Psalm 99
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Violet C. Gandiya, Independent Scholar
The scope of this paper is concerned with the proclamation of YHWH's kingship in imagery relating to his storm theophany. Undoubtedly, there are technical terms and militaristic imagery associated with YHWH's manifestation in Ps 99. Other symbolic features representing different modes of YHWH's presence in the midst of his people are highlighted in an overview of this psalm in relation to storm theophanic imagery in Deut 33:2, 26 and relevant passages from 1 Samuel. Although the connection of the first part of the psalm (vv. 1-5) and the latter (vv. 6-9) is not immediately apparent, the link is forged by use of different symbols representing YHWH's presence, as the king and judge in Israel's Heilsgeschichte. This is marked by the cherubim (v. 1), Zion (v. 2) and the footstool (= ark, v. 5; cf. Ps 132:7), all traditionally associated with the Zion tradition. The idea of YHWH seated on the cherubim alludes to the ark. Yet, also, in consequence, the idea of nations trembling and the earth shaking in awe of the presence of YHWH, seated on his cherubim, points to the effects of his storm theophany. Then, there is also the idea of YHWH's revelation mediated through the intercessory role of Moses, Aaron and Samuel, as presented in the latter part of the psalm. In relating to the priestly/ prophetic narratives on Moses, Aaron and Samuel and the tradition on YHWH's presence in the "pillar of cloud," this psalm indicates that YHWH's appearance is effected in much more than the "pillar of cloud". Moses (along with Aaron) and Samuel as advocates of the covenantal relationship, called on YHWH and he appeared in storm phenomena (Exod 19:16-18; 20:18, 20 & 1 Sam 12:14-18, respectively). Therefore, in light of these related traditions, and in view of the idea of storm theophany supported by the terminology common to theophany traditions in Ps 99:1, this storm theophanic mode of self- disclosure is involved in this psalm in declaration of YHWH as the sovereign king.
|
Title of Article: Isaiah's Critique of Shebna's Trespass: A Reconsideration of Isa 22:15–25
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Tova Ganzel, Bar-Ilan University
Scholarly treatments of Isa 22:15-25 have addressed the action by Shebna that led to his harsh punishment, the scope of the oracle, and the related question of the nature of the affinity between vv. 15-19 and 20-25. I will examine the terminology used in the oracle and then compare it with Ezek 43:6-9, a passage that condemns the kings of Judah for placing their tombs so close to the temple. A consideration of the realia of keys and their holders, which emphasizes ancient descriptions of how doors were locked, indicates it was the bolt-pin that was inserted into and fixed the lock. This in turn allows the proposal that Shebna's transgression was an encroachment on Davidic and divine authority by undertaking the hewing of his tomb in close proximity to the Temple. I will examine Shebna’s position as second to the king, his transgression and punishment, the portrayal of the transfer of authority from Shebna to Eliakim, and the role of the image of the bolt-pin in this oracle. I will end with a consideration of what we can learn from this case-study about ancient biblical historiographical technique.
|
Response to D. Rudolph and J. Willitts, eds., Introduction to Messianic Judaism (Zondervan 2013)
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Zev Garber, Los Angeles Valley College
My remarks will engage aspects of Messianic Jewish beliefs and practices and related issues involving Jewish rabbinic tradition and Christian Gentiles,
|
From “Little Horn” (Dan 7:8) to Hollywood: The Transformation of an Ancient Image into Contemporary Horror
Program Unit: Book of Daniel
Anne E. Gardner, Monash University-Victoria Australia
In recent research, the “Little Horn” of Dan 7:8 was shown to be benign, but that changes in the interpretation of the vision in Dan 7:20-22; 24-25 where arrogance is its defining characteristic. By Daniel 8, the “Little Horn” attempts to rival God. Subsequent ancient works highlight different aspects of the “Little Horn”, either good or bad, but in the Book of Revelation, the two extremes that appear in Daniel 7 and 8 are combined and further developed. It is these images, often with a contemporary twist, that have been adopted by Hollywood in its tales of “apocalyptic” horror.
|
Communal Responsibility for the Poor in Early Rabbinic Judaism
Program Unit: Poverty in the Biblical World
Gregg Gardner, University of British Columbia
Care for the poor is one of the most significant concepts in the biblical tradition. Charity, in particular, is a central commandment in late-antique rabbinic literature and the rabbis instruct that almsgiving is best performed in a communal and collective way. “Just as in a coat of mail every small scale joins with the others to form one piece of armor,” the Babylonian Talmud (Bava Batra 9b) posits, “so every little sum given to charity combines with the rest to form a large sum.” Given these ideals, how did the rabbis envision that communal charity would work? In this paper, I will examine the earliest rabbinic discussions of collective almsgiving, particularly texts from the Mishnah and Tosefta – legal compilations from third-century Roman Palestine that form the foundations of the Talmud and all subsequent Jewish law. As I will show, the rabbis lay out a system in which everyone in a community either contributes to – or is eligible to receive alms from – local charitable institutions. While the rabbinic instructions draw upon certain biblical ideals, the institutions that they discuss constitute marked innovations in poverty relief. I find that these institutions are shaped by Greco-Roman political culture, as the rabbis envision them as standing alongside other institutions in the landscape of the Roman city. They provided alternatives to individual and direct almsgiving, as bringing an end to begging would serve the common good – benefitting the rich and poor alike. It is this vision of organized charity that would be carried forward by the Talmud, where it would become a hallmark of Jewish approaches to poverty relief, charity and, more broadly, Jewish life and thought.
|
Experts, Relics, and Competition
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Gregg Gardner, University of British Columbia
A response paper highlighting the interconnections between the Religious Competition sessions for 2014.
|
The Kellis Coptic Papyri and Christianity in Fourth Century Egypt
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Iain Gardner, University of Sydney
This year 2014 see the publication of Coptic Documentary Texts from Kellis 2 (= P. Kellis VII, ed. I. Gardner, A. Alcock, W.-P. Funk, Oxbow Press 2014), a volume that completes the editing of the major archive of Coptic papyri found at Ismant el-Kharab by archaeological excavations in the Dakhleh Oasis during the early 1990s. It also marks the 20-year anniversary of the first paper to the SBL (Chicago 1994) where this discovery was announced to a North American audience. The occasion is suitable for an evaluation of the entire archive, now finally edited in full and available to scholars. In this paper I will outline the principal themes and discoveries as regards the changing nature and varieties of Christian belief and practice in a fourth-century Egyptian village. Although it should not be suggested that the world revealed by the Coptic texts from ancient Kellis stands as a paradigm for all of Egypt or indeed Christianity during the fourth-century, this material has cast light on a number of vital and remarkable features such as literacy and bilingualism, the role of women, travel and trade, and of course alternative churches such as Manichaeism in the fabric of domestic life during this transformative period.
|
Art and Ritual Practice in the Coptic Magical Handbooks of Antiquity
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Iain Gardner, University of Sydney
The study of magical papyri from antiquity has tended towards a focus on the correct reading of the text, with expertise in philology very much to the forefront in the editing of source-material. This paper forms part of a major international research project that seeks to redress this imbalance by taking seriously the role of images and design elements in the construction of such artefacts. These include drawings of spiritual powers such as angels or demons, as well as illustration of the necessary ingredients and the actions to be undertaken by the participants. In particular, I will discuss a set of Coptic magical handbooks now preserved in Heidelberg (P. Heid. Inv. 684-686), together with similar material from late antiquity (e.g. P. Macq. 1, recently published by M. Choat and I. Gardner, A Coptic Handbook of Ritual Power, Brepols 2013), to determine their actual ritual function in practice. Especial attention will be given to the design of these artefacts, and particularly the use of images and practical instructions as preserved within them and utilised by the ritual practitioner for material effect.
|
Difficult Reputations
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Gary Fine, Northwestern University
This paper will outline sociological research on difficult reputations.
|
Romans 9–11: An Apocalyptic Reading
Program Unit:
Beverly Gaventa, Baylor University
*
|
Righteousness/Justice in Paul: The View from Romans
Program Unit: Pauline Theology
Beverly Roberts Gaventa, Baylor University
A discussion of this critical word group, theme, and theological motif in Paul, with particular reference to the data in Romans.
|
Review of Jared Calaway, The Sabbath and the Sanctuary
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Gabriella Gelardini, Universität Basel
Review of Jared Calaway, The Sabbath and the Sanctuary
|
Colophons in the Syro-Hexapla and the Early History of the Hexapla
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Peter J. Gentry, Southern Baptist Theological Seminary
This paper follows up on a presentation made in Munnich, August 2013 and seeks to analyse afresh the contribution made by the colophons in the Syro-Hexapla to the early history of Origen's Hexapla. This is an area of the evidence largely unexplored.
|
Finding the Self in the Garden of Eden: The Cosmic and Psychological Dimensions of the Knowledge of Good and Evil
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Arthur George, Independent Scholar
Adam and Eve’s acquisition of the knowledge of good and evil in the garden of Eden was, among other things, an elevation of ego consciousness such that humans could recognize and understand pairs of opposites. This paper, based on one theme in my new book, The Mythology of Eden (May 2014), which analyzes the Eden story from the standpoint of mythological studies (and hence ultimately psychology), offers new insights into this question by drawing from the creation myths of the ancient Near East and examining the psychic nature and consequences of the acquisition of this faculty. Specifically, the author of the Eden story embraced the prevailing ancient Near Eastern mythic view that the cosmos was created from chaos, that elements of chaos still inhere in the created cosmos (in particular the human psyche) and that a never-ending tension exists between them, that the opposites of good and evil are one manifestation and subset of this tension, and that these opposites are integral components of the human psyche. The paper argues that obtaining the knowledge of good and evil in the Eden story meant attaining a godlike understanding and perspective on this underlying dynamic at both the cosmic and human levels, which are by nature interrelated. In the biblical author’s view, this knowledge in turn should enable people to understand and follow Yahweh’s Law, itself a form of order (good) that, when observed, helps control the chaotic (evil) aspects of human nature. The biblical author’s view that chaos/evil is inherent in human nature (which view later developed into the rabbinical doctrine of the yezer hara), is functionally equivalent to the modern psychological view of the (chaotic) unconscious and the “shadow” part of the psyche. Having the knowledge of good and evil, in modern psychological terms, offers a godlike perspective that is really that of the Self at the center, from which one can address the shadow, further individuate to attain wholeness, and hence also deal with the issue of evil at its source, with less reliance on the biblical author’s approach of using prophylactic laws, which only address the symptoms.
|
Prophetic Otherness and the Technology of Authority
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Mark George, Iliff School of Theology
Prophetic representations of otherness are not restricted to discursive statements. Identifying and knowing an Other—such as by gender, spatial practices, ethnicity, or ritual practices—assumes and enacts the authority of a particular social role, including that of prophet. Whether Moses or Jeremiah, prophets are recognized experts with the authority to define both what is other to Israel and the truth about Israel’s own subjectivity. This role is the result of a larger network of social relations. Using Moses as its focus, this paper analyzes how Moses’ expertise is produced in Deuteronomy. Authority is an important concern in Deuteronomy, and Moses’ status as expert is produced by a particular technology of authority. Like other prophets of ancient Judah and Israel, Moses speaks for YHWH, articulating the divine Torah in both speech and text. Having spoken with YHWH face to face, he repeats the divine speech to the people. In Deut 34:10, he also is designated a prophet without equal in Israel, whether past, present, or future. Laid to rest in an umarked grave, his authority and expertise live through the text of Deuteronomy. Yet the technology of authority that produces Moses in Deuteronomy is itself part of a larger apparatus of suzerainty. Israel and Moses are the subjugated Other to the suzerain, YHWH. Moses’ authority to define the truth about Israel and the other is itself produced within the context of being other. Recognition of the interplay between these regimes of power forces a reconsideration of Moses’ expertise. Given that many other prophets in the Hebrew Bible work within the context of suzerain relationships, the analysis of Moses’ authority is suggestive for the interpretation of those texts and how otherness is represented in them.
|
The Boundless Speech of the Exile: Paul as a Civic Virtuoso in Acts 21–22
Program Unit: Speech and Talk in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Allan T. Georgia, Fordham University
We do not ordinarily think of Paul as an exile, but exilic themes surround Paul in Acts. Among them, Paul visits and appeals for friendship in unfamiliar cities, he is denounced by crowds, shipwrecked, and tried in front of Roman authorities. The experience of exile was widely discussed in the Roman imperial world, especially among Sophists like Dio Chrysostom, Plutarch, and Favorinus, who developed a discourse on exile that was predicated upon the notion that exile constituted a kind of philosophically-liberated citizenship of the world that blessed the right-minded exile with freedom to belong anywhere. ¶ Drawing on Pierre Bourdieu’s notion of the “virtuoso” who operates as a native member of a cultural field, I contend that Paul, in Acts 22 and 23, counter-intuitively taps into this exilic discourse in order to carry himself as a virtuoso of the imperial urban landscape who can legitimately operate as a Jew, a Greek, and a Roman. Remarkably, he demonstrates this by speaking in ways that flout the contradicting implications of his diverse citizenship(s) –– and by extension the implied boundaries of civic identity –– as only an exile could. Paul addresses Roman soldiers in Greek while claiming citizenship of a prominent Greek city; he speaks in Hebrew to the crowd in Jerusalem (adopting a Greek rhetorical form, no less); he confounds a Roman tribune when he explains that, while the tribune spent a fortune to gain Roman citizenship, Paul was born a citizen of Rome. I contend that these seemingly incommensurable allegiances play with the implications of Socrates as a ??sµ??? (which Plutarch explicitly employs) by having Paul speak in diverse dialects to audiences who cannot make sense of “a man like this” (t?? t????t??, 22:22)! In Acts, Paul undermines the conventions of citizenship and the fixed strictures of identity by embodying a virtuosic ability to belong.
|
A Philosophical Perspective on Theological “Why?" Questions in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Philosophy
Jaco Gericke, North-West University (South Africa)
One perennial philosophical concern through the ages has involved asking the question “Why?” with reference to some or other aspect of reality. In the Hebrew Bible "Why?"-questions (WQ's) of the philosophical sort are also attested in some contexts. One context is of the theological type and involves, inter alia, perplexity as to why Yhwh/God acts in certain ways. In this paper a philosophical clarification of some of these theological WQ's is ventured from a descriptive metaphysical perspective invoking the so-called Principle of Sufficient Reason. Based on the pros and cons of such a reading it suggested that some very sophisticated albeit covert philosophical theologies are implicit in the Hebrew Bible's WQ's. The evidence for this claim is provided by looking at what several examples of theological WQ's in the Hebrew Bible assumed with reference to divine motivation, the divine attributes, divine relations and concerning the nature of reality itself.
|
Thus Saith the Scribe: Textual Divination in the Mari Letters and the Book of Jeremiah
Program Unit: Transmission of Traditions in the Second Temple Period
Justus T. Ghormley, University of Notre Dame
This paper examines the variant manuscripts of the book of Jeremiah in light of the practice of scribes from Mari who were responsible for transcribing prophetic oracles. These scribes from Mari actively participated in the process of divination, that is in the discernment of the deity’s will. Through techniques of “scribal prophecy,” or better, “textual divination”—i.e. a textually focused and textually expressed mode of divination—scribes shaped and expanded the meaning of prophetic oracles. These techniques of textual divination illuminate the practice of the Jewish scribes who utilized similar divinatory methods in their interpretation, adaptation, and expansion of Jeremiah. Furthermore, this paper provides insight into the nature and formation of religious revelatory texts—texts which both record the will of the deity and yet require further interpretation and extrapolation to continue being sources of revelation.
|
The Akedah and the Temple in Ancient Jewish Art
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Gary Gilbert, Claremont McKenna College
Artistic depictions of biblical scenes appear rarely in synagogues built and used during the Roman and Byzantines periods. It is, therefore, remarkable that depictions of the akedah (the story of the binding of Isaac told in Genesis 22) can be found in three extant synagogues from Late Antiquity. (Dura, Sepphoris, Beth Alpha). In each instance the depiction of the akedah occupies a central area of the synagogue’s interior. Many scholars have suggested possible interpretations of this image, but without general agreement. Most studies, however, have failed to notice or take seriously the fact that all three representations appear in conjunction with depictions of Temple objects (e.g., menorah, ark). This study begins with the understanding that the association between the biblical story and the cult center is not accidental, and that there exists a direct connection between the Temple objects and the akedah. After reviewing possible interpretations, this study argues that the visual presence of the akedah in combination with the Temple objects seeks to evoke at least two major associations: God’s persistence presence with and promise to Israel; and Israel’s perduring attachment to the city of Jerusalem, the site, according to contemporary Jewish tradition, of the akedah. This study then concludes that these images should be viewed together as part of a competitive exchange between Jews and Christians, in which both sides seek recognition for their respective, but contested, understandings of the Temple and the city of Jerusalem.
|
Why God Is Not a Vegan: Divine-Human Commensality in Aaronid Texts
Program Unit: Meals in the HB/OT and Its World
William K. Gilders, Emory University
Aaronid priestly texts in the Hebrew Bible configure sacrifice as the production and presentation of meals to God, most explicitly by applying the designation “food” (lehem) to sacrificial offerings (see, e.g., Lev 3:11, 16; 21:6, 8; Num 28:1; Ezek 44:7). Central to this sacrificial “cuisine” (to use the language of M. Detienne and J.-P. Vernant) is animal flesh and blood. Yet, the Aaronid creation story that stands at the beginning of Genesis portrays God as creating a world in which a plant (vegan) diet obtained for all creatures, including humankind (Gen 1:29-30); only after the Flood was meat-eating conceded to humankind (Gen 9:2-3). As the Aaronid narratives unfold, the Israelite sacrificial cult is established, in which animal flesh is offered to God (Lev 1-10), in tandem with legislation of restrictions on the living creatures Israelites may eat (Lev 11). In Aaronid texts, God’s reception of sacrificial animal flesh (and blood) functions as an indexical sign of a distinctive relationship with a meat-eating human community. Aaronid sacrificial laws work out the principles and procedures of this divine-human commensality both to emphasize the intimacy of the relationship it indexes and to clearly distinguish the participants in that relationship.
|
Who Captured Jerusalem? A Study in Historiography and Collective Memory in 2 Samuel 5
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Rachelle Gilmour, University of Sydney
The purpose of this paper is to use the theoretical frameworks of historiography and collective memory to help us read the text of Samuel better as an historical source, according to its own conventions of literary invention and representation. Comparison between the accounts of the capture of Jerusalem in 2 Samuel 5 and 1 Chronicles 11 suggests that the Samuel version deliberately omitted Joab’s involvement in the victory. Although scholarship is not unanimous, this paper will briefly review text- and literary-critical evidence pointing to this conclusion. Whilst the two versions do not contradict each other directly, this major omission of information points to a conception of historical representation very different from the modern day. By employing the theoretical frameworks of historiography and collective memory, this paper will investigate what this omission can tell us about the text’s function and characteristics as an historical representation. From the point of view of historiography, the omission points to the type of selectivity exercised in retelling the past, and some of the specific ways that language creates a bias. From the point of view of collective memory, we suggest that the omission helps to cast the story in a familiar narrative template and so it contributes to shaping the ideology of the audience. When we examine the story in conjunction with Joab at Rabbah in 2 Samuel 12, which possibly references his involvement in capturing Jerusalem, it points to the presence of competing memories within a single text.
In conclusion, this paper will reflect on the utility of both historiography and collective memory for understanding the dynamics of the text, in particular its ideology and function in its ancient context. The relationship between these two terms will also be examined, suggesting they are complementary, and that there is a place for examining the text of Samuel according to both theoretical frameworks.
|
In the Service of the King: Chinese Court Tales, the Book of Daniel, and Presumption of Resistance
Program Unit: Asian and Asian-American Hermeneutics
Andrew Giorgetti, Fuller Theological Seminary (Pasadena)
In recent years the “Court Tales” of Daniel 1-6 have been understood according to their socio-cultural milieu of exile/diaspora. Consequently, similar court tales exist in legends of Chinese advisors in the court of the Mongolian conquerors. In the Chinese advisor stories, the advisor heroes to the Khans interpret omens and give prophecy foretelling the demise of the Mongol empire. This tradition of advisors/diviners, particularly the ones that relate the demise of the conquerors, recalls the dreams and omen interpretation in the Daniel stories. The stories of Chinese advisors to the Khans during the Yuan dynasty (c. 1200-1368) are later perpetuated and “embellished” in the following Ming dynasty (and subsequent Qing dynasty) by both official historiographers and the populous. Far from being understood as quislings who serve the agenda of the foreign rulers for their own self-interests, the traditions that develop portray the advisors’ actions as undermining the authority of the Mongol rulers and their regime. These stories bear some important similarities to the stories of Daniel and his companions, particularly in relation to elements of resistance. This paper will utilize comparative analysis in a twofold manner: 1) a postcolonial reading will be brought to the interpretation of legends involving Chinese advisors to the Mongols (Yuan Dynasty) and then 2) a postcolonial reading of Daniel 2 will be undertaken, employing the insights gleaned from the Chinese traditions. The final analysis will center on the proposal that Daniel 1-6 should be read with a presumption of resistance.
|
“Begotten with Imperishable Seed”: Ethnicity and Procreative Imagery in 1 Peter 1
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Katie Girsch, University of Durham
This paper argues that the imagery of procreation in 1 Peter 1 is a necessary and complementary step in Peter’s construction of a new ethnic identity for believers in 1 Peter 2. It is precisely through being begotten with the imperishable seed of the word of God that believers can become the chosen race, royal priesthood and holy nation of 1 Pet 2:9. First, this paper will briefly define “ethnicity” and outline several significant features of ethnicity for group identity, such as the perception of descent from a common ancestor. Second, this paper will focus on how divine begetting relates to this central ethnic category. By engaging in this language, 1 Peter is participating in a small, but identifiable Jewish tradition which described the God of Israel as one who begets or gives birth. This language is admittedly rare in the Scriptures, though was becoming more common in Second Temple Literature, such as Philo, Pseudo-Philo and Josephus. This paper will argue that the language of begetting and seed in 1 Peter is part of this Jewish tradition of ethnic, genealogical reasoning. In 1 Peter, this language is used to establish a spiritual family tree as the genealogical foundation for Peter’s construction of a new, Christian ethnicity. Specifically, regeneration in 1 Peter is connected with two things: the resurrection of Christ from the dead and the preaching of the word of God. Both of these things, the resurrection and the preaching of the word, relate in different ways to spiritual begetting, but both incorporate believers into the spiritual family of God.
|
The Politics of Election: A Burdened Pauline Legacy with Hope for Peace
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
Tommy Givens, Fuller Theological Seminary (Pasadena)
In *The Rites of Assent: Transformations in the Symbolic Construction of America,* Sacvan Bercovitch documents and analyzes the powerful use of a Protestant doctrine of election in the colonialist production of "America." Pauline language, inflected by Puritan rhetoric, was called upon to mythologize the colonialist/missionary conquest of the continent and consolidate divergent forces and populations as an identifiable "people," chosen before the foundation of the world and elected by God to rule among the nations. As Anthony Smith has shown in *Chosen Peoples: Sacred Sources of National Identity,* the political project of "America" was not unique in this regard. The Pauline legacy of election is thus a burdened one, ensconced in a modern history of strategic domination and rivalry, atrocious violence, and massive exploitation in obedience to a theopolitical ideology whose geopolitical ramifications continue to the present day. Most of those concerned to resist this Pauline legacy would just assume be done with talk of election. But, following Jewish philosopher Jacob Taubes in *The Political Theology of Paul* and drawing on my research of the last several years (in a forthcoming monograph), I propose to show why Paul's letters must be revisited precisely on the question of election, for the sake of both better understanding Paul's writings in their particular Jewish-Roman context and addressing his burdened political legacy.
After outlining the burdened Pauline legacy of election, my proposed paper will focus on Rom. 9-11, what Taubes calls "the most significant Jewish as well as Christian political theology" in a 1979 letter to the Christian Nazi Carl Schmitt (who himself coined the term "political theology" decades earlier). My explication of the Pauline politics of election according to Rom. 9-11 will dialogue critically with Giorgio Agamben's recent readings of Paul and appropriations of both Taubes and Schmitt (e.g., his "commentary" on Romans *The Time That Remains,* the monograph *State of Exception*) and articulate the pressure that Rom. 9-11 should exert on the interpretation of Paul's other letters. I will argue that, according to Paul, God's election of Israel and of Jesus entails a politics of refusing to disown those whom God has gathered as part of "the people" and who are perceived to burden "the people." My argument has some sympathies with Agamben's readings of "the messianic" in Paul in answer to the identity politics of modern social orders in the West (including his sound worries about the concept of "ethnicity" or “ethnic Israel”), while it criticizes his tendency to abstract "the messianic" from the messy life of Israel as Paul presents it. My summary reading of Rom. 9-11 will also contend that N. T. Wright's version of Paul's theology (i.e., the church as Israel) misunderstands the force of Rom. 9-11 (working against it in fact) as well as key features of the Jewish-Roman political drama that gave shape to Paul's letters.
|
The Colonialist Bible and the Political Rhetoric of Purity
Program Unit: Postcolonial Studies and Biblical Studies
Tommy Givens, Fuller Theological Seminary (Pasadena)
Étienne Balibar has traced the fictive ethnicity of modern (Christian and post-Christian) nationalism to the theological anti-Judaism of the Christian tradition (*Race, Nation, Class: Ambiguous Identities,* Verso, 1991). In relation to the foil of the Jews, Euro-American Christian powers constructed pure, national identities by which populations were policed and consolidated into discrete, national "peoples." Those not counted among the empowered populations of reference (i.e., among the White "people") were thus (further) politicized as not belonging to "the people," that is, as variously suspect, exploitable, alien, impure, etc., even if in some cases they have been granted a formal status of citizenship. This colonialist force of politicization was at once a matter of Christian piety and biblical interpretation and coincided with the rise of biblical higher criticism. In *The Enlightenment BIble: Translation, Scholarship, Culture,* Jonathan Sheehan shows how the Bible of this period became a book of culture, with scholarship that sought to unearth the pure origins of its authority and a popularization that made its content the cultural inheritance of the dominant, Euro-American population (thereby eclipsing biblical narrative, according to Hans Frei, according to the distinction between the text and die Sache of the text). My paper brings Balibar's and Sheehan's accounts together to highlight two hermeneutical tendencies that characterized the colonialist Bible outlined above: 1) a separatist and purifying usurpation of the narrative of Israel and 2) a totalized frame of reference policed by the conquering "culture." Together these two tendencies have constituted a powerful rhetoric of purity, operative at both elitist and populist registers, one that has functioned both politically and culturally to sustain White privilege and enfranchise others only at the price of conformity and subordination. My paper closes with some gestures of hermeneutical reform made possible by articulating the two highlighted tendencies of the colonialist Bible.
|
The Face of God: An Exploration in Lucan Christology
Program Unit: Gospel of Luke
William Glass, Duke University
The question of Lucan Christology has been discussed at great length in recent years. One influential position holds that Luke has a "low" Christology, holding Jesus instead to be a prophetic agent acting on behalf of Israel's God. Among those who argue for a higher Christology, Kavin Rowe has argued that Lucan Christology is best discovered as Luke's favorite title for Jesus, i.e. kyrios, comes to be defined within the frame of his narrative itself. Rowe concludes that the narrative deployment of the title kyrios eventually makes it impossible to speak of Israel's God without speaking of Jesus, and vice versa. Rowe's narratological analysis, he thinks, sidesteps objections, like that of Oscar Cullmann, that ambiguity in the deployment of such titles in mundane contexts prevents their successful use in theological work. Within the narrative, however, Rowe thinks that Luke's use of kyrios is rather more controlled. His thesis is troubled, however, by the fact that kyrios, even within Luke's narrative, has several mundane ascriptions as well, which mirror the semantic range of kyrios in the world outside Luke's narrative. Thus, Cullmann's objection can apply, in a transposed way, to the narrative itself. This paper, then, will aim to show how Luke's deployment of Scripture actually may avoid Cullmann's objection. Malachi 3:1 speaks of Israel's God sending out messengers before the divine face. Quoted with reference to John the Baptist in all three synoptic gospels, it is referenced at least two other times in Luke's gospel, stretching out across the narrative as a significant motif. As references to Malachi recur, it becomes increasingly evident that Luke is using Scripture to refer not to the face of God but to the face of Jesus, before whom messengers are sent on the way to Jerusalem. This gradual modulation of Malachi 3:1 to refer to Jesus in God's place bears none of the ambiguity that is present in the use of the title "lord" throughout the gospel. The fact that in Luke God's self-reference becomes a reference to Jesus confirms Rowe's initial thesis without the confusion caused by other mundane uses of God's self-indication (since there are no such uses). The paper will conclude by suggesting that, within the frame of Luke's narrative, the use of Malachi 3:1 is important not only so that we come to know whose face is seen in that of Jesus, but also whose face is marred in the lengths to which Jesus goes in his effort to preach the good news to the poor.
|
Competing Gustatory Regimes in the Book of Proverbs
Program Unit: Senses, Cultures, and Biblical Worlds
Greg Schmidt Goering, University of Virginia
In this paper I argue that the sages of Proverbs construct competing gustatory regimes based on the dichotomy sweet/bitter. Onto their opponents the sages project a regime which promotes the consumption of bitter foods; such an eating pattern leads a person to become foolish, and he becomes marked as such by the foods he eats. Counter to this regime, the sages promote a regime in which the naïve young man eats the sweet food of wisdom in order to become wise. In Prov 24.13-14, for example, the sages prescribe the consumption of honey—the paradigmatic sweet food in Proverbs—and compare the effects of consuming wisdom on the young man’s appetite (nephesh). Once wise, a person must continue to consume sweet foods, both to maintain his wisdom and to mark himself as wise. In the paper, I illustrate the sages’ construction of competing gustatory regimes through an analysis of passages that counterpose Woman Wisdom/One's Own Wife with the Foolish Woman/Strange Woman. I show that eating and drinking the fare of Woman Wisdom/One's Own Wife serves as an antidote to the poisonous fare offered by the Foolish Woman/Strange Woman. In devising these competing regimes, the sages develop their own system of gastrosemantics, i.e., the use of food to symbolize and transmit cultural meaning. This research points to the significance in Proverbs of the mouth as a gateway between the body's interior and exterior. In the metaphorical world constructed by the sages, the mouth functions both as a portal through which a person consumes wisdom and incorporates it into his body and as a gate which governs whether previously ingested words are retained in the body or released to the outside. At this key breach in the boundary of the self sits the sense of taste. As arbiter of sweet and bitter, wise and foolish, the sense of taste serves a crucial evaluative role. As an organ of judgment, the tongue determines what enters and exits the body, controlling the flux across the boundary of the body and thereby playing a central role in determining what kind of self the person becomes. My investigation of the way sages inculcate wisdom through educating the sense of taste, therefore, points to the embodied, not merely cognitive, nature of wisdom in Proverbs.
|
Teachers in 4QInstruction, Ben Sira, and the Hodayot
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Matthew Goff, Florida State University
4QInstruction, Ben Sira and the Hodayot all include the persona of a speaker who is a teacher giving instruction to students. But they do not present these teacher-figures in the same way. Ben Sira extols his own knowledge, and stresses that a student could learn much from him. 4QInstruction by contrast, places much less focus on a teacher-figure. The focus is not on the wisdom dispensed by a teacher but rather what the student should learn. The presumed teacher of 4QInstruction never boasts of his own wisdom in the manner of Ben Sira. Comparison with the Hodayot is valuable since in some hymns (esp. cols. 14-16) the first person speaker, like Ben Sira, stresses the importance of the knowledge he transmits to his students. But he does so by drawing on Garden of Eden traditions that have more in common with 4QInstruction than Ben Sira. 4QInstruction, Ben Sira and the Hodayot drew on common exegetical and sapietial traditions, transmitted and presented in different ways, in part because they were composed in different pedagogical contexts by different teachers, who had their own distinct personalities.
|
The Body of Christ as the Evental Site of Parts Beyond a Part: An Intercorporeal Reading of 1 Cor 12:27
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Menghun Goh, Vanderbilt University
Biblical scholars do not pay much attention to “?a? µ??? ?? µ?????” in 1 Cor. 12:27 (?µe?? d? ?ste s?µa ???st?? ?a? µ??? ?? µ?????). Most translations render it as believers individually or each person constitutes the body of Christ. Joseph Fitzmyer even finds the Vulgate “strangely reads the second clause as: et membra de membro.” While Anthony Thiselton finds the “syntax of the verse fittingly combines singular and plural,” he does not elaborate further. Most recently, in arguing for an “organic part-whole connective ethic” in Paul’s political-soteriological notion of t? s?µf????, Kei Eun Chang does not address this clause either. This paper makes three arguments. First, ?a? is more than a conjunction. It explains the “body of Christ” in terms of µ??? ?? µ?????. Secondly, as the preposition ?? can signify a “beyond,” an “outside,” a “de-parting,” a “means,” or a “spacing,” it highlights the connection and separation in the touching and spacing of the body parts. It thus averts a fixed source of the origin and a totality, as it reveals and conceals simultaneously the interface of µ??? and µ?????. This dynamic relation between one and many is evident in 1 Cor. 12-14 as Paul stresses how singularity and plurality implicate one another. Thirdly, µ??? ?? µ????? shows that a body member is more than a member. It has many parts. It is a member precisely because it is also a member in touch with other members. So a hand is a hand-foot-eye-ear-etc. This is why the members are of and beyond a member. The hyphens are indispensable. They signify a connecting and a separating at the limit. The body of Christ cannot be objectified into any system. In the language of Jean-Luc Nancy, Alain Badiou, and Giorgio Agamben, it is always already a dynamic and strange “division of division.”
|
History by Lists: Some Observations on the Use of Lists in the Deuteronomistic History
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Shira Golani, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
The Deuteronomistic History is abundant with lists. These are used not only as mere sources of information, but many times lists occur in pivotal points with an editorial and/or ideological purpose. Two better known examples are the list of defeated kings in Josh 12, separating the two parts of the book, and the twice-occurring list of David’s cabinet in 2 Sam 8:16-18 and 20:23-26, framing the literary cycle between them. These examples and others will be discussed in this paper, which will explore how lists are used within the Deuteronomistic History to express Deuteronomistic ideas such as periodization, the importance of Deuteronomy as an ideological source, and YHWH’s involvement in the history of Israel.
|
Translating Common Words
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
John Goldingay, Fuller Theological Seminary (Pasadena)
The introduction to the Dictionary included the announcement that it was more interested in common words than in unusual and difficult ones. In writing a commentary on Isaiah 40—55 I found it especially useful in this connection, and I remember emailing David Clines after the first volume or two had come out to say so – which I suspect is why I was asked to give this paper. In the course of writing the commentary and using the Dictionary, especially in connection with common words, I came to the conclusion that translations evidence a kind of myopia and lethargy in translating words such as hesed, ’aheb, sane’, yare’, darash, biqqesh, nasa’, mishpat, and tsedaqah (many common words are also difficult words). At the same time, ironically, recent translations have moved away from word-for-word translation towards dynamic equivalence, and thus obscured the significances of way recurrences of individual common words in a book are significant. The paper will consider examples.
|
A Tale of Two Texts: Syriac Aesop's Fables and Its Jewish Recension
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Binyamin Y. Goldstein, Yeshiva University
The oldest manuscripts of the Syriac recension of Aesop’s Fables date to the early 15th c. However, there is a Jewish-script recension of the Syriac dating to before the 11th c., which has received almost no attention, save for a monograph and subsequent review in 1859 and 1860. I propose that the Jewish redactor not only could read Syriac well enough to transliterate the text, but was fairly fluent, if not a native speaker. The Jewish recension is important both as another witness to the Syriac recension (in which capacity it is ignored in Lefevre’s 1940 critical text of the Syriac), and also as one of the few surviving examples of Syriac literature that permeated into Jewish spheres. This aspect of the text has been completely overlooked. As such, it sheds much light on several fields, such as Jewish-Christian interaction in the early medieval period, and how Jewish scribes converted Christian texts into Jewish ones.
|
Mary and Jesus in the Garden: Ban and Blessing
Program Unit: Maria, Mariamne, Miriam: Rediscovering the Marys
Deirdre Good, General Theological Seminary
In this essay I describe two contrasting strands of interpretation in text, art and music in order to ask how the encounter between Mary and Jesus in the garden generates and sustains both readings of ban (in the command “Do Not Touch Me”) and blessing (in a meeting between a woman and the beloved she sought beyond death).
|
The Magdalene Effect: Misreading the Composite Mary in Early Christian Works
Program Unit: Maria, Mariamne, Miriam: Rediscovering the Marys
Mark Goodacre, Duke University
The restoration of Mary Magdalene’s reputation has been a major achievement in recent scholarship on early Christianity, but scholarly fascination with the figure has led to a misreading of the character named Mary in early Christian works. Mary is a composite character who incorporates features from both Mary Magdalene and Mary of Bethany. She adores Jesus' feet, she listens to Jesus' words, she weeps, she loves Jesus and she has a sister named Martha.
The difficulty arises in part from the pedagogically important stress on avoiding harmonization, an academic concern not shared by Christians in the second to fourth centuries, who routinely harmonized different characters. The “Magdalene effect”, whereby one Mary becomes ever more prominent, has prevented scholars from fully appreciating the characterization of Mary in early Christian works, but a re-examination of this composite character leads to a fresh appreciation of how Mary functions in these works, and how their authors read Luke and John.
|
Psalms of Solomon and Pauline Studies
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Matthew E. Gordley, Regent University School of Divinity
A number of surface features of the Psalms of Solomon suggest their potentially high value for understanding the world of thought from which Paul emerged and with which he engaged: they are among the few documents known to have been written, edited and translated in or around Jerusalem less than a century before the time of Paul; they offer rich theological reflection on several ideas that were central to the Judaism with which Paul engaged (deuteronomic theology; the covenant; divine justice; sin; messianic renewal); and, though not necessarily a Pharisaic composition, they are about "as close as we are likely to come to a specifically Pharisaic text" (Wright, Paul and the Faithfulness of God, 127). In spite of this confluence of important Pauline touch-points, the Pss Sol have received limited treatment within Pauline studies since the now almost two-decades-old study by Michael Winninge (Sinners and the Righteous). This state of affairs is all the more surprising given the renewed interest in viewing Paul as someone who saw himself remaining closely connected to his Jewish heritage (as recent book titles like "Paul and Judaism Revisited" suggest). This paper briefly reviews the treatment of Pss Sol in several recent major monographs (including those of N. T. Wright and Douglas Campbell), for an indication of how the Pss Sol are being employed in Pauline scholarship today. Noting the limited ways in which these psalms have been utilized, this paper points to an additional area in which further study of Pss Sol could illuminate Pauline studies: namely, in the recognition of the extent to which Pss Sol provides a unique instance of a kind of scribal resistance to the Roman imperial messianic narratives that were being embraced and promoted by Herod the Great (cf. Horsley; Schalit). Reading Pss Sol within the historical context of Herodian propaganda that associates the fulfillment of the covenant promises with the rise of Augustus allows for a greater appreciation of the subtlety and complexity of Jewish resistance to imperial ideology in the form of the otherwise seemingly innocuous genre of biblically-styled psalmody. Attention to this dynamic within Pss Sol allows a new dimension of Paul's implicit anti-imperial narrative to come into view, particularly in a passage like Phil 2:5-11 with its complex web of biblical allusions. Though Paul writes in the context of a different set of imperial pressures, nevertheless, by comparing the method and the mode of resistance in Paul and Pss Sol we gain a greater understanding of the message of Paul, as well as a path to considering other ways that the Pss Sol might be employed to illuminate Paul's writings.
|
On the Sanctity of Mixtures and Branches: Two Halakhic Sayings in Romans 11
Program Unit: Paul within Judaism
Benjamin D. Gordon, Duke University
Paul opens the olive tree allegory of Rom 11:17–24 with two halakhic sayings on the principle of extended sanctity. The first (11:16a) appears to involve the sanctification of non-sacred food once it is added to a batch of heave-offering set aside for a priest. The second, on a root sanctifying the branch (11:16b), has hardly been recognized as halakhic in nature, much less related to a body of highly relevant Tannaitic discourse on sacrilege law.
In m. Me?ilah 3:6, R. Judah denies the transference of sanctity from root to branch and removes sacrilege protections from agricultural derivatives growing after the point of dedication. R. Simeon, on the other hand, affirms their sanctity if they are self-generating. This discussion is anticipated by the saying Paul quotes. His choice in Rom 11 to draw on halakhic parlance may have been a conscious attempt to signal yet again the extent of his own Jewish pedigree. He also happens to be preserving for us a very early instance of a rabbinic (or proto-rabbinic) position on the matter of agricultural dedications. Moreover, the statement in 11:16b is rhetorically linked to the allegory that follows, suggesting that Paul is envisioning the grafting of non-sacred branches onto an olive tree dedicated to God. Agricultural dedications such as these were common in the ancient world and Judea appears to have been no exception.
While Paul chose this image to convey a deeper message about the transferability of sanctity to new members of the church, a saying by a Palestinian Amora turns Paul’s metaphor on its head when it compares the grafting of olive branches to intermarriage in Jewish families (p. Kil?ayim 27b).
|
Adjusting the Prophet’s Numbers: Scribal Intervention and the Sacred Economy in MT Ezekiel’s Temple Vision
Program Unit: Economics in the Biblical World
Benjamin D. Gordon, Duke University
Among the details on the temple’s everyday operations in the closing utopian vision of the book of Ezekiel (chs. 40–48) are rates for what the book presents as the standard temple tax and calls terumah (“offering,” 45:13–15). While the Masoretic Text (MT) gives relatively low rates for the tax—at 1.6% for grains, 1% for oil, and 0.5% for animals of the flock—the earliest Greek witness (Papyrus 967) indicates the much higher rate of 16.7% for grains and 10% for oil and animals. I argue that, contrary to prevailing opinion, the Greek reflects the more contextually sensible and thus more original version. The numbers given in MT, on the other hand, are probably the result of Judean scribal intervention in the late Second Temple period. By then terumah had become one in a broad range of sacred and secular taxes paid to the local authorities in Judea; early rabbinic tradition has it collected on staple products at a voluntary rate of 1.6–2.5% (m. Terumot 4:3), quite similar to that given in MT. The Judean scribes behind the change proposed here may have been concerned that the prophet’s vision was being used by members of the priesthood to claim higher collection rates for terumah. Since the scribes’ intervention works to the priesthood’s disadvantage and would seem to support the status quo, a political alignment with the royal aristocracy or even Pharisaic sages seems likely. Other potentially problematic features of the temple vision that scribal activity resolved through deft textual adjustments include a sacred pasture around the temple (45:4) and discrete cities consisting entirely of Levites (45:5), neither of which were present in Judea’s sacred economy in the late Second Temple period. These scribal changes in MT anticipate exegetical solutions by the rabbis to other issues presented by the prophet’s vision.
|
The Apocalyptic New Covenant and the Shape of Life in the Spirit
Program Unit:
Michael Gorman, Saint Mary's Seminary and University
*
|
Disability, Inclusion, and Exclusion in the Gospel of John: An Exegetical Study of Jn 5:1–18 and Jn 9:1–41
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Louise Gosbell, Macquarie University
While the gospel of John possesses only a small number of healing narratives, the gospel does include two significant healing accounts featuring people with physical and sensory disability: the healing of the man at the pool of Bethesda and the healing of the man born blind. While the healing narratives described in the synoptic gospels generally feature only a physical cure, these two accounts recall not only the healing proper, but also the healed person’s response to it. These two accounts also feature a significant parallelism: both accounts portray men with long-term, non-urgent impairments and both are revealed to be recipients of Jesus’ healing ministry on the Sabbath, at the instigation of Jesus himself. In many respects, it appears Craig Keener’s assessment of these healing accounts is correct in stating that together they demonstrate both a positive and negative paradigm of initial discipleship. And yet, the writer of the Fourth Gospel does more than this. In keeping with the imagery of dualism represented throughout the Fourth Gospel (e.g. light/dark, flesh/spirit, above/below, etc), the gospel writer uses these two accounts to represent an additional contrast: what it means to be included/excluded. While the gospel writer depicts the two men as socially marginalised as a result of their impairments, he also highlights that marginalisation does not result only from a physical/sensory deficit but can also occur as a result of one’s response to the gospel. While the healed man in John 5 is depicted as being restored to the temple and its cultic community, the formerly blind man, in contrast, is shown to be not only excluded but indeed ‘excommunicated’ from the synagogue and its community. In this respect, these two healing accounts offer an additional representation of dualism in the Fourth Gospel that has previously gone unnoticed. Assessing these accounts in terms of the dichotomy of included/excluded rather than disabled/able-bodied assists with liberating these stories from the traditional view that spiritual wholeness (holiness?) is the natural bi-product of physical wholeness in the canonical gospels.
|
A Tale of Two Targums: Similarities and Differences in the Targums of Psalms and Chronicles
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Leeor Gottlieb, Bar-Ilan University
Targum Psalms is frequently paired in scholarly discussions together with Targum Job due to similarities in language, form and style. While grouping these two Targums together is certainly justified, ties between either of the two and other Targums tend, to a certain degree, to be ignored. In this paper I wish to point to some striking similarities between Targum Psalms and Targum Chronicles. Upon establishing the existence of commonalities in these two Targums, I shall attempt to determine if these shared features indicate that one Targumist was directly influenced by the other. A particular point of interest in this respect would be the comparison of both Aramaic translations to the hymn in 1 Chronicles 16 and sections of Psalms 96; 105-106. Defining the precise relationship between Targum Psalms and Targum Chronicles may contribute to a better understanding of each Targum on its own, as well as a clearer notion regarding the origins of several of the Hagiographa Targums.
|
The Passion Narratives in Kierkegaard’s For Self-Examination and Judge for Yourself!
Program Unit: Søren Kierkegaard Society
David J. Gouwens, Brite Divinity School
In For Self-Examination (1851) and the posthumously published Judge for Yourself!, Kierkegaard employs the passion narratives in often unexpected ways to illuminate his understanding of a hermeneutics aimed at “inward deepening.” Beginning For Self-Examination with the famous account of reading Scripture “with true blessing” as a mirror and a love letter, Kierkegaard then moves to the narratives of Ascension Day and Pentecost in Acts 1 and 2. Ironically, however, Kierkegaard approaches each of these two New Testament narratives by relating them inter-textually to the passion narratives. In the discourse on the Ascension Day in Acts 1, Kierkegaard offers an apparent digression: a presentation of the passion narrative under the title “Christ Is the Way.” But Kierkegaard thereby shows how, contrary to the reader’s expectation, it is the passion narrative of Good Friday that answers doubts about the Ascension. So too the passion narrative shapes Kierkegaard’s next discourse on Pentecost in Acts 2, where the Spirit’s life-giving gifts of faith, hope, and love may only be appropriated in relation to the follower’s “dying to.” Looking back to the book’s opening theme of Scripture as mirror and love letter, it becomes clear that it is only as the passion narratives illuminate the Ascension and Pentecost texts that the latter may indeed function as both mirror and love letter.
Similar patterns appear in Judge for Yourself!, where the passion narrative is again strategically recounted in detail, now under the theme of “Christ as Prototype,” with the cross as the culmination of Christ’s fulfillment of his own teaching that “no one can serve two masters.” It is this ideality of Christ’s work as Prototype that sets the standard for judging Christendom. Yet grace sounds too in Judge for Yourself!, reminding the reader that it is Christ the Redeemer, who has made satisfaction for everyone, who raises up the striver.
In both books, the passion narratives profoundly shape Kierkegaard’s hermeneutics, his understanding of Christ as Prototype for imitation, and his increasingly stringent social critique of Christian triumphalism. But as with his other presentations of the passion narratives, Kierkegaard in these books too is careful to place this striving of imitation within the context of the follower’s continual return to the forgiveness and atonement given by Christ as Redeemer and by a reliance on the Spirit’s gifts.
Merely describing a hermeneutics of discipleship does not exhaust Kierkegaard’s interest in the passion narratives. Neither is he content with inter-textual readings of New Testament narratives for their own sake. He aims rather to present exemplary readings that foster “inward deepening.” Kierkegaard uses the passion narratives as a central vehicle to elicit the capacities essential to discipleship: seeing oneself as imitator on “the narrow way,” but also as recipient of the Redeemer’s forgiveness and the Spirit’s life-giving gifts, enabling a discipleship grounded in gift, jest, and “a striving born of gratitude.”
|
“The Belated Return of the ‘Son’”: Thomas Hart Benton’s Prodigal Son
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
David B. Gowler, Emory University
Thomas Hart Benton’s Regionalism emphasized that art should represent life as it is actually lived in a specific time and place: “penetrating to the meaning and forms of life . . . as known and felt by ordinary Americans” (Benton 1951: 9). Religion did not play a dominant role in Benton’s work—Benton himself had little use for religion—but his art portrays the religious experiences of numerous people; his lithographs include, for example, African-Americans headed to their country church in southern Arkansas (Sunday Morning, 1939), a pastor preaching to his small white congregation in the mountains of West Virginia (The Meeting, 1941), and people headed to an evening prayer meeting in a church “anywhere south of the Mason-Dixon line” (Prayer Meeting or Wednesday Evening, 1949). Other works illustrate additional dynamics of religious life, such as revival meetings, hymn sings, Ozark baptisms, and Salvation Army street testimonials, including the paintings, The Lord is My Shepherd (1926), Holy Roller Camp Meeting (1926), Lord Heal the Child (1934), and the provocative Susanna and the Elders (1938).
Benton’s lithograph, Prodigal Son (1939)—which was a study for his later painting of the same name—could be interpreted as connecting aspects of labor and migration in the context of the Great Depression and the Dust Bowl. Benton, in fact, created this lithograph around the same time that he was employed to create a series of drawings of the characters of John Steinbeck’s The Grapes of Wrath for the 1940 Twentieth-Century Fox film.
The black and white lithograph presents an idiosyncratic and haunting view of a prodigal son who has waited far too long to return home. The house stands as only a ramshackle shell of its former self—with no father to greet the prodigal, no servants to attend to him, and no elder brother to complain about him. The evocative sun-bleached bones of a cow are all that’s left of what could once have been a fatted calf. Although other interpretations are possible, this lithograph can speak about the utter despair of those people in the rural areas of the United States who were not able to survive on their desolate farms.
|
Fire and the Body of YHWH
Program Unit: Theology of the Hebrew Scriptures
Deena Grant, Barry University
According to modern studies of the psychology of anthropomorphism, anthropomorphisms tend to highlight both a deity's likenesses to, and also its differences from that which is not divine. In this way, the deity remains relatable to the devotee but is also elevated as markedly other and worthy of reverence. Biblical descriptions of Yhwh's body tend to accord with this research. While some passages speak of or imply Yhwh's anthropoid form, these same verses portray Yhwh's body as mysterious and transcendent. One of the elements of this transcendence is Yhwh’s substance of embodiment, particularly his corporeal manifestation in fire. In this paper, we consider how fire functions as a material representation of a typically non-corporealized deity. Specifically, we observe the ways in which Yhwh's corporeality in fire is both like and unlike human physicality. On the one hand, a number of poetic passages associate Yhwh's body – particularly his breath, mouth and tongue – with fire (e.g. Lev 9:24; Deut 32:22; 2 Sam 22:10; 1 Kgs 18:38; Isa 30:27). Similarly, though not as explicitly anthropomorphic, a number of passages from a diversity of narrative texts portray Yhwh using fire to execute tasks that humans perform with their bodies; these include breathing, eating, carrying, traveling and seeing (Exodus 19; Deuteronomy 4-5; Judg 6:21-22; 13:20-21). On the other hand, the human body is composed of flesh and blood and is comprised of many of parts, each which has a distinct function. By contrast, Yhwh's physicality is manifest as radiant fire which serves a variety of functions – fire functions as Yhwh’s eyes, lips and limbs. Thus, while Yhwh's "body" is like the human one in that it affords him the capacity to interact with corporeal elements, it is also unlike the human one in its radiant multi-functionality.
|
Bible Translation and the Web: A Twenty-First Century Rearrangement
Program Unit: Global Education and Research Technology
Gilles Gravelle, The Seed Company
Internet penetration is accelerating globalization. In this sense, globalization means connectedness. It also means access to information. Research confirms Clay Shirkey’s assertion that the internet and web technology (i.e web 2.0 and new media) is allowing whole communities to do things they always wanted to, but never could. That is, greater collaboration. Web-based Bible translation is disrupting the process of translation, too. It is not so much about abandoning all we’ve learned about what it takes to do good quality translation. Rather, these changes are producing a rearrangement of the parts to create more involvement, more ownership, and rapid diffusion of the message.
|
Where Is Clytemnestra When You Need Her? The Womb, the Masculine Economy of Prophecy, and the Problematics of Otherness
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Rhiannon Graybill, Rhodes College
In the Hebrew prophetic literature, masculinity is largely negotiated between men (including, at points, a male God). And yet within this masculine economy of prophecy, traces of the female body persist. Metaphors of childbirth and of the womb recur across the prophets, reaching a particular intensity in Second Isaiah. This maternal and bodily imagery is sometimes taken as a sign of a feminine voice, presence, or counternarrative in Isaiah or in the Prophets more generally. I will argue, however, that the womb and uterine imagery is central to the negotiation of prophetic masculinity, and for masculinity’s entanglement with forms of otherness. The womb haunts the masculine economy of prophecy, but without resolving into a feminine counternarrative or rival presence. Bringing together masculinity, alterity, and gendered bodyspaces, I will map the consequences of the womb (as metaphor, event, and space) for prophetic embodiment, the performance of masculinity, and the articulation of otherness.
|
Expanding Boundaries: An Investigation of the Northern Tribal Allotment according to Josh 19:10–39 on the Interface of Textual Criticism, Translation, and Commentary
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Leonard Greenspoon, Creighton University
A distinctive feature of the book of Joshua is the inclusion (in chapters 12-21) of extensive lists of place names, or toponyms, many of which are obscure. It is often difficult to know how the Old Greek translator represented these names, given the wide variations as evidenced in the manuscripts. Thus, there are many factors, some unique to these passages, that must be taken into consideration when analyzing their translation and transmission. In this presentation, previous research will be summarized, and new proposals, both specific and of larger methodological significance, will be offered.
|
Metaphors of Illness and Wellness in Job
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible and Cognate Literature
Edward L. Greenstein, Bar-Ilan University
In this presentation I shall examine metaphors representing illness and wellness in the Book of Job, using a method informed by cognitive linguistics. Wellness in Job is often related to wholeness, and illness to deterioration. The conceptualization of illness as the deterioration or diminution of the whole is not peculiar to Job. However, in Job we find a parallel decimation of Job’s family and estate, which gives special poignancy to the imagery of illness. Even more poignant is the contrast in the book between Job’s experiences of affliction, represented as the degradation of a whole, and his absolute commitment to integrity (tummah—wholeness).
|
The šelamîm in the Hebrew Bible and Archaeology: Meaning, Evidence, and Power
Program Unit: Meals in the HB/OT and Its World
Jonathan S. Greer, Grand Rapids Theological Seminary
In Israelite religion, the šelamîm served as the nexus between sacrifice and feasting. In these events, worshipers communed with God and with each other while sustaining the sacrificial economy and its officiants. As such, these events provided a context ripe for manipulation in the hands of Israelite monarchs. This paper surveys biblical and extrabiblical sources describing the šelamîm sacrifices and then evidence from Tel Dan arguing that these events not only took place there, but that change in practice over time suggests ways in which these events were used to create and maintain power structures.
|
Useful for the Soul? In Dialogue with François Bovon on the Early Reception of Luke
Program Unit: Gospel of Luke
Andrew Gregory, University of Oxford
This paper engages with two aspects of François Bovon's many contributions to our understanding of early Christianity and the way in which early Christian texts were used: (1) his concept of books that were considered 'useful' for the soul, and (2) the way in which different authors, whose writings were later regarded variously as orthodox or apocryphal, made use of the Gospel according to Luke. In so doing it follows Bovon's lead in problematising the way in which distinctions are often drawn between canonical and non-canonical texts and between orthodox and non-orthodox Christian voices.
|
Isaiah 14 (LXX) as Narrative Template for Antiocohus IV in 2 Maccabees
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Bradley C. Gregory, University of Scranton
In cryptic, poetic imagery, Isaiah 14 describes an arrogant tyrant who aspires to ascend to heaven and is subsequently cast down to Sheol. While virtually all scholars have recognized that there are allusions to Isaiah 14 (LXX) in the account of the death of Antiochus IV in 2 Maccabees 9, I argue that the influence of Isaiah 14 is more pervasive. The common denominator underlying these allusions is that in each case the given element from Isaiah 14 is also thoroughly integrated into the rest of the story in chapters 5-9. The divine striking of Antiochus with disease in his bowels, his fall from the chariot and subsequent pain in his limbs, and his death in the mountains are all styled to show a “measure for measure” punishment for his actions in chapters 5-7. This level of narrative integration suggests that the tyrant in Isaiah 14 forms the epitomator's most basic understanding of Antiochus' historical significance. Yet, in a few places he subtly diverges from Isa 14 for literary and theological reasons. Therefore, it is clear that the author of 2 Maccabees does not simply collapse the referentiality of the prophetic oracle into the circumstances of the second century, but allows the two to resonate with each other. He both conforms his historical memory to the prophetic paradigm and yet also adapts it for the particularities of his Hellenistic culture.
|
Genesis 34 as Open Narrative
Program Unit: Genesis
David Griifin, University of Virginia
In the past three decades, Genesis 34 has frequently served as a test-case for literary methods applied to the Hebrew Bible. The story of Dinah and Shechem is fraught with ambiguity: who is the villain and who are the heroes? Does the story have a moral message? This paper proposes a different method for reading Genesis 34. By attending to the representation of time, or what Gary Saul Morson calls tempics, we will find that this narrative is written in “open time,” such that the narrative never achieves closure and questions remain unanswered. To borrow Morson’s terminology, most of Genesis unfolds in closed time. A narrative arc rarely begins that is not later closed off so that the next arc can begin anew, all within the broader sweep of the Priestly framework that assures Genesis will resolve into the rest of Israel’s historical self-representation. By contrast, the story of Dinah and Shechem operates with an open sense of time. It highlights the contingency of the “events” narrated, suggesting that the sack of Shechem might not have been a foregone conclusion. Likewise, no future event in Genesis – not even Jacob’s blessings in Gen. 49:5-7 – completely determines the significance of what transpires between Dinah, Shechem, and their respective clans. In other words, Genesis 34 resists typological readings (e.g., the story is “really about” the city of Shechem’s becoming an Israelite cult center) due to its open-ended narration. I will therefore explain Morson’s theory in greater detail to show how it can be fruitfully applied to biblical narrative and open up the much worked-over text of Genesis 34 to new readings. This study will then close by briefly comparing my own reading inspired by Morson’s work with other literary approaches to Genesis 34, especially those of Meir Sternberg, Danna Fewell and David Gunn.
|
Breathing New Life into Ancient Texts for Tech-Savvy Students Today
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Tyler J. Griffin, Brigham Young University
Students today are digital natives. Most have spent significant time immersed in video games, smart phones, tablets, and countless computer technologies. These students are inherently comfortable and capable of navigating complex visual and spatial environments while processing vast amounts of information. Most academic teaching today, however, relies heavily (and at times, exclusively) on textual and logical argument to engage the learners. This can lead to an inordinate focus on what we are teaching while disregarding who we are teaching. Much more could be done to bridge this technological gap between academic teaching styles and current learning preferences.
Immersive technologies can be used in academic settings to increase a “sense of time and space” for the students. These tools make it easier for the students to visualize what they are reading about. For instance, we could show students a 2D map of ancient Jerusalem with arrows proposing a route that Jesus followed during his final 24 hours or we could show them a virtual fly-over of the various sites in a 3D immersive environment. We could show them a diagram of Herod’s Second Temple or let them walk through it much like they would navigate a video game. As another example, we could show students maps of significant travels like Paul’s missionary journeys or the Exodus of Moses, or we could let the students navigate the route using an interactive map that allows for zooming and panning. If a teacher today wants to engage learners at a deeper level in ancient stories, these immersive technologies become an inviting portal for them.
This presentation will “practice what it preaches” by showing many examples of how various forms of interactive tools and apps can be used to enhance the teaching of a variety of pericopes in the New and Old Testaments. While some of the tools demonstrated are available for sharing, others are available for purchase as an app, and others are not yet accessible for distribution. This will also be an opportunity to find other academics who have the interest and means to help contribute in designing and developing similar teaching tools to be shared.
The goal of the presentation is not to minimize non-visual teaching practices that have proven effective. The presentation will (1) demonstrate a vision of how new immersive technologies can be used to engage our learners at deeper levels with ancient texts, (2) show how these tools can be used for teaching a variety of passages from any number of theological or academic contexts, (3) help highly verbal teachers learn how to better connect with more visual students in their classes without having to become a computer expert, (4) show where many of these helpful resources can be found, and (5) find others who are willing and able to contribute in efforts to develop and effectively use such teaching tools to increase our effectiveness in bridging the many gaps that exist between our students and the ancient world they read about in the pages of the Bible.
|
The Suhuf of Abraham and Moses
Program Unit: The Qur’an and the Biblical Tradition (IQSA)
Sidney Griffith, Catholic University of America
Recalling a passage in Narsai of Nisibis’ (d. 503 CE) Syriac Mêmrâ, ‘On the Revelations to Abraham’ alongside a verse in surah 87 al-A?la 18-19, in this presentation the purpose is to call attention to and to explore the significance of the parallels to be seen between the Qur’an’s typology for God’s messengers and prophets, and the typological prophetology of Late Antique Syriac, popular biblical commentary.
|
The 'End' of Divine Punishment: 4 Maccabees' Reading of 2 Maccabees through the Lens of Deuteronomy 32
Program Unit: Function of Apocryphal and Pseudepigraphal Writings in Early Judaism and Early Christianity
Robbie Griggs, University of Durham
The precise relationship between 2 Maccabees and 4 Maccabees has long been a topic of debate. Some argue for direct dependence and others suggest that 4 Maccabees is dependent on the work of Jason of Cyrene, the purported source of 2 Maccabees (2 Macc 2:23). In this paper I argue that 4 Maccabees is an expansion and interpretation of 2 Maccabees 3 – 7, read through an historical logic sourced from Deuteronomy 32. The author of 4 Maccabees, noting the characterization of the impending military victories of Judas Maccabeus as God’s dike (2 Macc 8.11, 13), fills the interpretive space between 2 Maccabees 7 and 8 by reading the martyrs’ deaths through the lens of divine dike described at the end of the Song of Moses (Deut 32:41, 43; cf. Lev 26:25). This reading is applied first to the Hellenizing attack on the Temple service, which incites God’s dike in the form of Antiochus (4 Macc 4.13, 21). Then it is applied to the deaths of the martyrs themselves, which ends dike for the nation (4 Macc 6:28; 18:22). On this view of the catastrophe, the dissolution of the Temple service both incites God’s justice/punishment and leaves the nation without a cultic mechanism for turning it away, a situation which can only be remedied by the paradoxical, life-giving deaths of the righteous martyrs. In addition to illustrating how an ancient reader received 2 Maccabees in ‘Deuteronomic’ terms, this analysis suggests the surprising result that, far from an individualizing or spiritualizing approach (van Henten), 4 Maccabees represents a firm hope in the diaspora near the end of the first century C.E. for national and political renewal ending in the restoration of the Temple. For effective obedience does not replace the Temple in 2 Maccabees but rather leads to its restoration.
|
"You Will Forget Your Ancient Shame": The Innocence of Susanna and the Vindication of Israel
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
Jennie Grillo, Duke University
This paper considers the figure of Susanna in the Greek version of Daniel in relation to prophetic pictures of Israel/Judah/Jerusalem as a disgraced woman. As the later tale responds to the ‘ancient shame’ of the Babylonian Exile, it provides a focus for methodological questions about the use of female figures in conceptualizing Exile, about metaphor and sight, and about scriptural interpretation in early Jewish and Christian communities.
|
Reading Susanna Allegorically
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
Jennie Grillo, Duke University
This paper will reflect on the tale of Susanna, found in the Greek versions of the book of Daniel, tracing the different construals of that story in the writings and artworks of a number of allegorical readers. Susanna herself has been cast as Christ, as the church, as Eve, as Mary, and as the individual believer in baptism: I will explore the relationships and discontinuities between these various frames in the works of Hippolytus, Origen, Pseudo-Chrysostom and others, and consider whether modern readers can make constructive use of any of these allegorical proposals for interpretation, examining how engagement with biblical theology and with Jewish interpretation might guide a principled appropriation of allegory for exegesis.
|
A Theology of Glory: Paul’s Use of Doxa-Terminology in Romans
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Sigurd Grindheim, Fjellhaug International University College
According to a common interpretation, Paul’s reference to the lack of God’s glory in Rom 3:23 alludes to the story of Adam and his loss of God’s image. This identification is problematic, however, as most of the evidence that can be cited in its favor is later than Paul.
To arrive at a better interpretation, this paper pays close attention to the development of doxa-terminology in Romans as well as to Paul’s use of Israel’s Scriptures. In the Septuagint, doxa refers to the tangible presence of God, a usage that also is able to explain Paul’s terminology very well. The 16 occurrences of doxa in Romans are rich in Septuagintal undertones, both in the form of Septuagintal terminology and in the form of more or less clear allusions to the Scriptures of Israel. Against this background, I argue that there is an underlying story that inspires Paul’s use of doxa-language in Romans. That is the story of the revelatory presence of God in Israel, a presence that was rejected, but is renewed in Jesus Christ.
|
As Easy as 1-2-3? Seeing Jerusalem through the Eyes of Josephus
Program Unit: Josephus
Davina Grojnowski, King's College London
This paper will use the spatial categories as identified by the French philosopher Henri Lefebvre as a lense to review Josephus's perceptions of the city of Jerusalem in his Jewish War 1. By looking at the text through the categories of perceived, conceived, and lived space, the paper will discuss to what extent Josephus distinguishes between his narratives of Jerusalem, and how they relate to each other. In doing so, it will become evident that Josephus's narratives of Jerusalem are the narratives of three different cities: Jerusalem is a seat of power, both divine and earthly (conceived space); Jerusalem was built as a magnificent city (perceived space); Jerusalem suffered from the human events that took place in the city (lived space). Thus this paper will argue that by distinguishing between the different narratives and through using a tri-partite perception of the city, Josephus does not allow the lived space, the actual experiences of Jerusalem's inhabitants, to reflect on to the Jerusalem as he perceives and conceives of it. This reading highlights how using spatial categories allows us to reconsider Josephus's view of Jerusalem. Ultimately, it will argue that through the text we see distinct presentations of the city as a transcendent and powerful entity, abstracted from the material and temporal conditions that caused its physical destruction.
|
Genesis 23 and the Zwiegesprächsurkunden Reconsidered
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Andrew D. Gross, The Catholic University of America
In 1965, Herbert Petschow published his classic study of the Neo-Babylonian dialogue document (aka Zwiegesprächsurkunden). While he acknowledged the parallels between this document format and Abraham's land-sale negotiations in Genesis 23, he published his study in part to reject the suggestion that these parallels were due to the dialogue document having been brought to Babylonia by Judean exiles. He, in fact, suggested that the direction of influence likely had run the other direction. Since the publication of Petschow's study, our knowledge of West Semitic legal tradition has been enhanced by the greater availability of various legal corpora including many more Aramaic texts as well as the materials from Emar. This study will thus reconsider the question raised by Petschow about what the Zwiegesprächsurkunden can tell us about the direction of influence of ancient Near Eastern legal traditions.
|
Intertextuality in Esther: Evidence of a Hidden Plot, Political Program, and Polemic
Program Unit: Megilloth
Eric W. Grossman, Frankel Jewish Academy
The intertextuality between the book of Esther and narratives found in Genesis and Samuel was already recognized in antiquity. Ancient midrashic and medieval Jewish commentaries noted echoes of language and theme between Esther and both the Joseph story and the tales of Saul found in the books of Samuel. These allusions have been both noted and expanded upon in contemporary commentaries on Esther, mostly to draw attention to the richness and depth of text. This paper will argue that intertextuality in Esther is not merely a literary tool, but a sophisticated device used by its author to transmit ideas sub rosa to the community of exiles at whom the text was directed. Intertextuality is utilized in Esther as covert methodology to present a unified theology of exile and redemption, and a political program for restoration that favors a return of the Saulide dynasty. This theology and program, moreover, runs counter to the pro-Davidic stance that dominates the Hebrew Bible and is featured predominantly in two of the other Megilloth—Ruth and Lamentations. The precarious nature of the community in Persian exile coupled with the author’s unorthodox notion of Israelite monarchy (past and future) necessitated a literary style that mimics a roman-a-clef. The original meaning and message of Esther has been further obscured and lost as a result of the canonization of both the Hebrew Bible and the New Testament, as well as through the grouping of the Five Scrolls, which extends canonical ideology to the books of Ecclesiastes and Canticles.
|
Religious Experience and the Discipline of Imagination: Tanya Luhrmann Meets the Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Maxine Grossman, University of Maryland - College Park
In books like Persuasions of the Witch's Craft (1989) and When God Talks Back (2012), psychological anthropologist Tanya Luhrmann explores the cultivation of a religious mindset through disciplines of imagination and imaginative practice. Meditation, prayer, directed visualizations, and other forms of mental cultivation contribute to a state of mind in which practitioners actually see and hear—in physical, material ways—images and sounds that are not available to others around them. In the Dead Sea Scrolls we find evidence for mental cultivation practices including song, prayer, “searching” the scriptures, and night-time study sessions. To what extent do the sectarian rule scrolls provide evidence for intensive disciplinary practices such as those that Luhrmann documents? Do the evidence of the liturgical and wisdom texts provide additional information? In what way, if at all, does Luhrmann’s approach provide tools for considering notions of prophecy, revealed knowledge, or the presence of angels in the texts from Qumran?
|
A Male Speaker's Obsession with the Feminine: The Strange Case of Lamentations 3
Program Unit: Megilloth
Mayer Gruber, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
Meir Bar-Ilan (1998), argued that "I am the man. . ." (Lam. 3:1) alludes to the fact while Lam 1 and 2 are spoken by women, Lam. 3 is spoken by a male. Indeed, geber can mean simply 'person' (Prov. 20:24). NRSV translates Lam. 3:1, "I am the one who." The author of Lamentations 3 anticipates NRSV's discomfort with masculine gender-specific language, and he compensates by employing specifically feminine language in Lam. 3:25, 37, and 51. "Good is the LORD to those who pray to Him" in Lam. 3:25 reminds one of Ps. 145:9, "Good is the LORD to all," and Ps. 145:18, "Near is the LORD to all who call upon Him, to all who call upon Him with sincerity." We shall note with Gruber, Rashi's Commentary on Psalms 2004, p. 281 that the root qwy often means 'pray' rather than 'hope', and we shall note that the verb darash means 'pray' in Ps. 34:5 and Ps. 77:3 and appears in parallelism with the verb qara 'call' in Isa. 55:6. Distinguishing between the noun nephesh 'the female person' in Lam. 3:25 and other usages of the lexeme nephesh in Lam. 3 (periphrasis for the personal pronoun in vv. 17, 20, 24, 58 and the meaning 'neck' in v. 51a) and nephesh meaning 'person' of any gender in P and H, we shall unpack the almost unique instance in all of biblical poetry of common plural//feminine singular parallelism in the Qere at Lam. 3:25 [another kind of gender-matched parallelism according to the Kethib]. Ps. 33:9 states, "For He spoke, and he (the cosmos) was//He commanded and he (the cosmos) stood." Lam. 3:37 parodies Ps. 33:9 when it asks, "Who is it that ordered that she should be thus?" Here 'she' designates the destroyed City of Jerusalem (cf. Lam. 1-2 and 5:2). In Lam. 3:51 as in Ruth 1:19-20 the women of the city are seen as tantamount to the people of the city collectively. In short, the self-conscious male author of the third chapter of the biblical book of Lamentations goes out of his way to compensate for this author's performing the quintessentially women's work of composing and singing lamentations (Jer. 9) by deliberately and unexpectedly employing female language in vv. 25, 37, and 51. This author anticipates the modern politically correct use of female language and gender-neutral language where older Bible translations had gone overboard in employing male-specific language to refer to people in general and to the activities of people in general. Our ancient author once again illustrates the principal that Hebrew Scripture tells us about women in the world of the Hebrew Bible what our father's never told us and our mothers never knew.
|
A Rite of Affliction: A Reexamination of the Law of Jealousy in Num 5:11–31
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Erin Villareal, Johns Hopkins University
The various interpretations and analyses of the ritual prescribed in Numbers 5.11-31 have most often focused on the issues surrounding the treatment of adultery and purity in the Hebrew Bible, as well as the classification of this ritual as an “ordeal” within a broader Ancient Near Eastern context. Primary concern in past scholarship has dealt with the function and potency of various ritual components, such as the “waters of bitterness” and the purgatory-oath. However, this paper will seek to evaluate the ritual from a different perspective, emphasizing not the curse or the oath, but the role of jealousy within the ritual and how it serves to frame the passage. This paper will argue that this procedure functions as a rite of affliction in which the “spirit of jealousy” troubles the husband, who has no other recourse but to seek divine mediation. By applying S.J. Tambiah’s performative theory to magical ritual and analyzing the semantic and pragmatic frames of the ritual, the function of the “spirit of jealousy” and the “jealousy offering” will be addressed.
|
“Junia … Prominent among the Apostles” (Rom 16:7), Paul, “the Least of the Apostles” (1 Cor 15:9): Equality or Hierarchy of Jewish Christian Apostles?
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
Judith Gundry, Yale Divinity School
Apostles had the highest position of authority in early Jewish Christianity. Luke refers to the Twelve as apostles. Paul however uses the term “apostle” more broadly for those who had seen the risen Lord. But were all apostles equal in Paul’s book? He refers to himself as “the least of the apostles” in view of the fact that he was “unfit to be called an apostle, for I persecuted the church of God” (1 Cor. 15:8-9), and acknowledges those who were “apostles before me” (Gal. 1;17). Similarly, in Rom. 16:7, he refers to two other Jewish Christian apostles, Junia (Iounian, a woman) and Andronicus (a man), perhaps a married couple, as “those who came to be in Christ before me” and are “prominent among the apostles.” Is Paul implying that Junia and Andronicus have a higher status as apostles than Paul does, and if so, is it simply on the basis of chronological priority, or something else? In this paper I will suggest that ?p?s?µ?? (“prominent”) can connote leadership and that Junia and Andronicus were leading Jewish Christian apostles. I will also explore the relation of their prominence as apostles to their having been “prisoners” (for Christ’s sake). Paul’s lower apostolic status made him dependent on alliances with other, higher-ranking apostles such as Junia and Andronicus (cf. also Gal 2:6-9).
Scholarship on Rom 16:7 has thus far been occupied with the question of whether Iounian is a male or female name, and whether episemoi en tois apostolois means “prominent among the apostles” or “notable to the apostles." Thus the question of Junia’s and Andronicus’s relation to other apostles has not received due attention. My paper aims to fill this lacuna and show that gender was not a criterion for status relative to other apostles in Jewish Christianity.
|
Faith That Works: Pistis at the Intersection of Law and Love in 1 Thessalonians
Program Unit: Bible and Ethics
Nijay K Gupta, George Fox Evangelical Seminary
This paper, in keeping with the 2014 Biblical Ethics subject matter, will examine the themes of “law” and “love” in 1 Thessalonians with special attention to the leitmotif of pistis in this early Pauline epistle. Too often the meaning of pistis is assumed by modern readers, rather than examined. More problematically, there is a trend in some strands of scholarship to refer to Pauline pistis as a “passive” concept. However, this paper will argue that pistis is a polyvalent term for Paul and one distinct use (especially common in 1 Thessalonians) approximates Jewish language used of covenantal loyalty. If one looks at Paul’s “faith/faithfulness” language in this light, pistis has the capacity to situate obedience and love within a relational framework. It will be argued, therefore, that Paul’s pistis language drives his moral vision for this afflicted church and promotes steadfast endurance and holy obedience in the battle against sin and darkness.
|
Irenaeus on Gal 4:4–7
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Tyson Guthrie, Coram Deo Academy
As the title of his 1990 essay “Irenaeus’ Use of Paul in His Polemic Against the
Gnostics” implies, Richard Norris positions Irenaeus’ reading of Paul in the context of his larger
intention of demonstrating and refuting the heretics’ misreading of Paul. Given this wider
perspective, Norris claims it is Galatians 4:4-7 and not Romans 5 that provides Irenaeus with “a
central and thematic” picture.(Norris 1990, 89-90.) “Recapitulation” occurs at the “fullness of
time” through the “adoption of sons.” However, Norris' treatment of Galatians 4:4-7 is limited
by the broad scope of his article. The present article will develop Norris' thesis by demonstrating
the theological assumptions and textual cues which drive Irenaeus' use of this passage. I will
claim that the Virgin Birth is the key to both continuity and discontinuity. In the Virgin Birth
Christ partakes of the “ancient formation” (vetus plasmatio) of humanity, but inaugurates a “new
generation” (novus generatio). The adoption of sons is participation in the "new generation"
inaugurated at the Virgin Birth. To that end, this article will survey the textual cues which
occasion Irenaeus' use of this passage. These include canonical and chronological concerns
showing continuity between the message of the OT prophets and that of the NT, and
anthropological concerns showing continuity between the humanity of Adam and that assumed
by Christ in the Incarnation. Then I will survey the Pauline terms, which take on polemical
meaning for Irenaeus. These terms include "at the fullness of time," "made of a woman," and
"adoption of sons." I will then examine the theological terms in which Irenaeus understands
these concepts. These include "formation," "re-formation," and "generation."
|
Wasting Apocalyptic Time: Queer Temporality as Resistance in 1 Corinthians
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Lindsey Guy, Drew University
In 1 Corinthians, Paul frames his relationship to the community in generational language: father and children, his maturity versus their immaturity. This rhetoric not only concretizes and naturalizes the power dynamic; it furthermore associates maturity with an apocalyptic temporality, as Paul’s communal ethics are oriented toward the “present crisis” (7:26). Childishness obstructs the fulfillment of time; thus Paul urges the Corinthians to “put away childish things” in preparation of the end times (13:11).
In this paper I argue that a hermeneutic of queer resistance to Paul’s rhetoric may instead interpret the Corinthians’ immaturity as a virtue and a counter-cultural performance in defiance of re/productive ethics (a term I use to gesture to the relation of familial reproduction to economic production). Queer time defuses the apocalypse – and furthermore, it defuses the compulsory timeline of re/production and maturity as teleological success. In this frame, the Corinthian failure is a queer failure of normative intelligibility: from speaking in tongues to Paul’s reprimands that they should ‘just grow up already.’ These gestures, when read resistantly, may be interpreted as a necessary component of queer utopia as process: a reversed dialectic of constructive disruption of the status quo, producing a paradoxical present-future of imaginative alternatives. Using the queer theory of Judith Halberstam, Lee Edelman, and José Esteban Muñoz, I will explore how a queerly resistant reading deconstructs Paul’s “straight time” apocalyptic logic, instead suggesting a utopian and non-teleological relation of time to ethics.
|
An Ecological Reading of the Divine Speech in the Book of Job: Wild Animals as a Critique of and an Alternative to Human Civilization
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
SungAe Ha, Graduate Theological Union
Nowhere else in the bible is found such a vivid description of animals than in the divine speeches in the book of Job, in which a close observation and attention is given to their characteristic activities deemed valuable for themselves with no purpose to serve human interest. In particular, it is striking that the animals are presented in the divine speech in ways that challenge the traditional perception of enmity toward wild animals dwelling in the desert considered as a hostile and dangerous place and a symbol of disorder and chaos beyond the boundaries of ordered and civilized society.
In the paper, I will closely examine the divine rhetorical questions about the wild animals to explore how the divine speech transforms the image of wilderness from its negative connotations into positive ones: from barrenness, ruins, chaotic and dangerous place, and expulsion to strength, multiplication, blessing, freedom and liberation. In particular, I will examine the metaphorical images of the wild animals portrayed to be freed from any human control and exploitation, represented by the ass freed from the city as an emblem of civilization and oppression (39:7), and enjoying their autonomy in the harsh life of the wilderness.
The divine speech reveals God who has no control over and intervention in the autonomy of creatures, although autonomy of life with no intervention risks destruction and death, as shown in the case of the ostrich’s eggs laid on the ground in order to be warmed but risking being crushed (39:14-15). The new vision of life in the wilderness opts for risk over control, and opts for freedom over security.
The theme of freedom beyond security continues with the flight of the hawk to the south (39:26) that perhaps alludes to the annual migration of hundreds of thousands of raptors from Eastern Europe to their wintering territory in Africa. The image of migrating birds points to life with no fixed home and the fluidity and instability of life close to what is radically Other. Life of migration is tough and risky: the vulture makes its nest on high, a risky place; it lives on the rock and makes its home in the fastness of the rocky crag (39:27-28). Though tough and risky, life with autonomy, beyond control and confinement provides a higher point from which to see, wisdom different than human convention.
The image of the ostrich laughing at horse and its rider when pursued by them has a significance in terms of the opposition between culture and nature, as reflected in the motif of the royal hunt in ancient Near East, where the king’s hunting of a variety of animals, including ostriches, was a symbolic act to defend his order against the chaotic represented by wild animals.
Through the divine speech that celebrates wild life controlled or domesticated by neither humanity nor deity, human civilization based on the exploitation of humans and nature is criticized, and the hierarchical order assumed in the relation between human and nature is subverted.
|
Paul's Large Letters in the Context of Hellenistic Primary Education
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Tobias Hagerland, Lund University
The question why Paul emphasizes his use of "large letters" at the conclusion of his epistle to the Galatians (Gal 6:11) has been answered in divergent ways, some of which are more fanciful than others. Reviewing earlier proposals, I will argue in this paper that Paul's remark has nothing to do either with his physical limitations nor with a wish to verify the authenticity of the letter. Rather, as argued by Chris Keith in an important article (2008), the remark should be interpreted within the context of Hellenistic primary educational practices.
Unlike Keith, who sees in the remark a reference to Paul's own grapho-literacy, I will suggest that Paul here assumes the persona of a teacher who chides his addressees for their lack of progress in learning by alluding to the didactic practice of _praescriptum_, known to us from various ancient literary and documentary sources. This understanding fits Paul's argument in Galatians well. Furthermore, I propose that it may throw light on another debated passage in Galatians, that is, Gal 3:1. Here as well, an allusion to the _praescriptum_ can be detected.
The results, beside offering a reading of the passages that is coherent with the overall argument of Galatians, have implications for our understanding of the social location of the implied addressees of the letter.
|
Towards an Epistemology of the Alley: Negotiating Muslimness in the Everyday
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Chad Haines, Arizona State University
Drawing upon my original research in diverse urban settings in the Muslim world, in this paper I reflect on shifting focus away from the iconic spaces of Islam to the back alleys; the spaces of disruption from the normative where Muslims perform and negotiate everyday encounters, dialogues, and practices. In the alley Muslim material culture, everyday ethics, and modern aspirations are lived practices. Islam in the alley is not about normative texts or encoded orthopraxy. Rather, we discover texts and practices as negotiations, dialogues, and at times even open debates. We observe iconic symbols as taking on multiple meanings, moving away from any fixed notion of being Muslim. In the alley, Islam is a processual, dialogical, “din” (Bowen 1993) – both in its English (cacophony) and Arabic (religion) senses.
|
The New School: Communicating Ancient Greek via Modern Technologies
Program Unit: Global Education and Research Technology
Michael Halcomb, Conversational Koine Institute
One of the implications of globalization is that it has the ability to destabilize organizational hierarchies and powers. Oftentimes as this occurs new openings are forged, new ideas formed, and new paths and approaches taken. As globalization penetrates the realm of education, teachers must not only be ready to take on old subjects in new ways but also prepared to engage the twenty-first century student—whose realities and goals differ from previous generations of students—in meaningful and innovative ways. This is especially true of educators within the realm of biblical studies and theology, that is, those who believe that the subjects they’re teaching are of eternal worth. In this paper, I investigate the significance of teaching Koine Greek communicatively in a real-time online setting with students from across the globe and what such a course might suggest about where education is heading and what scholars and institutions alike might do to stand at the forefront of educational and technological advances. I will consider the question—as posited in the first portion of this paper’s title—of whether or not a “new school” or new type of school is on the horizon. If so, might this “new school” resemble something close to or analogous with the Conversational Koine class previously mentioned? In addition, several implications of this for education, ministry, and missions in the educational landscapes of the 21st century and beyond will be explored.
|
Setting Students Up to Fail Biblical Languages: An Assessment of Assessment
Program Unit: Applied Linguistics for Biblical Languages
T. Michael W. Halcomb, Conversational Koine Institute
It is quite common to hear students two or three years out of seminary say that they have “lost” the languages or language skills they sought to acquire in their biblical language courses. Why is this? And why has this complaint persisted for so long? Has the academy simply ignored it? In this paper I argue that the time has come for teachers of biblical languages to face this reality directly and address one of the underlying causes of long-term student failure: biblical language courses driven by the traditional model of assessment. In this paper I will underscore the numerous problems inherent within this model and offer an alternative approach.
|
Paul's Collection and the Body Politics of Empire
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
Crystal L. Hall, Union Theological Seminary in the City of New York
The purpose of the Gentile Mission, animated by Paul’s call as an “apostle to the nations” (Lopez), is to create solidarity among Jews and other nations together “in Christ.” Through this “unity in difference,” in which both Jews and other nations are made equally righteous before God through their trust in Jesus Christ, a collective body is (in)corporated—namely, the body of Christ. This “body politic” (Ando), in which Jews and other nations join in solidarity and mutuality with one another “from below,” stands in stark contrast to the body politic of the Roman empire. Within the imperial collective body Jews and other nations are divided from, and forced to compete with, one another as the conquered—and yet are united by their common enslavement as nations to Rome (Lavan).
This paper will argue that Paul’s collection, the bodily practice of gathering money for the “poor among the saints” in Jerusalem, is one concrete application—with theological, political and economic dimensions—of the Gentile Mission. The flow of money as “grace” toward Jerusalem is a circulatory system that animates the Body of Christ; it is the embodiment of a theological program that has significant political implications within the Roman imperial context in which it operates (Kahl). The collection will be framed as counter to, and resistant of, the money that circulates ultimately toward Rome. The transfer of money through exploitative economic relations, including taxation and indebtedness, functions as a circulatory system for the imperial body politic. The collection will be explored as an anti-poverty program in response to an imperial political economy that impoverishes and oppresses. It will be demonstrated that Paul’s method of incorporating the collective body of Christ mimics, yet deconstructs and transforms, the incorporation of the imperial body politic.
|
Teaching the Bible with Google Earth and Other Visualization Tools
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Taylor Halverson, Brigham Young University
Humans are visual learners. Texts alone cannot provide the full context for engaging the Bible. Therefore, emerging visualization tools, particularly geographical tools offer promising opportunities to engage our students more significantly in reading and understanding Biblical texts. The purpose of this presentation is to provide several examples of how meaning, understanding, and interpretation of the Bible may be enhanced when it is read in its geographical context. I will introduce several free geographical study tools such as Google Earth, the Google Earth Bible (scriptures.byu.edu/mapscrip) and the VirtualWorldProject.org. Then I will model teaching and studying practices that employ these tools to help learners develop their Biblical interpretation skills. Case examples to serve as models of teaching the Bible visually and geographically will include Caesarea Philippi in Matthew 16, the Temple Mount in John 8, Tel Dan in Genesis 14, Beth She’an in 1 Samuel 31, Timna in 1 Kings 7, Lachish in 2 Kings 14.
|
Language Speculation in the Thunder: Perfect Mind
Program Unit: Speech and Talk in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Tilde Bak Halvgaard, University of Copenhagen
The presentation will focus on the use and function of language related terminology in the Thunder: Perfect Mind from the Nag Hammadi collection. In especially three passages, the female revealer of this text presents herself in a language related vocabulary: she is silence, thought, sound, voice, word etc. I argue that this specific vocabulary has roots in a language philosophical discussion appearing in Platonic and Stoic dialectics, and that the linguistic passages in the Thunder: Perfect Mind are fruitfully understood against this background.
So when the female revealer in the Thunder reveals herself in linguistic terms beginning in silence and ending in word (logos) I will interpret this as reflecting the manner in which the Stoics described a verbal expression – an utterance. Likewise, I will argue that the Platonic discussion on the correctness of names, found in the Cratylus, and the Stoic notion of “sound words” clarify the pondering upon the name of the female revealer who proclaims to be the utterance, knowledge and voice of her own name. Finally, to approach the difficult saying: “It is I who am …the manifestation of the division”, found towards the end of the Thunder, I call attention to the Platonic notion of “definition by division” (diairesis) as an illustration of the entire manifestation of the female revealer, and as an explanation of her paradoxical self-presentations.
Understood against the background of ancient philosophy of language I argue that the three linguistic passages occupy key positions to the overall interpretation of the Thunder: Perfect Mind.
The outcome of such an interpretation is a renewed focus on the fundamental interest formulated in Platonic and Stoic dialectics: the relation between language and reality. This interest, I argue, lies at the core of the Thunder: Perfect Mind. It makes its readers reflect upon language.
|
Filling the “Empty Frame”: A Plausible Empirical Model for Royal Ritual in the Psalms
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Joel Hamme, Fuller Theological Seminary (Pasadena)
This paper explores a plausible empirical model for the reconstruction of royal ritual in the Psalms by exploring the incorporation of the DINGIR.ŠA.DIB.BA prayer collection and short maqlû ritual into house 6 of bît rimki. It begins by surveying earlier scholarship on the royal ritual in the Psalter that relies on the Akitu as an empirical model and deconstructs it. It has two basic weaknesses: 1) The parts of the ritual reconstructed with the Akitu use supposed features of that festival that are not actually witnessed to in the preserved texts (the mock battle and ritual humiliation of the king), 2) The reconstruction is too subjective in that it is used as an “empty frame,” using A. R. Petersen’s apt description, in which to pour any number of psalms. Although these criticisms are valid, the king is an important figure in ANE cult, including in Jerusalem, and so it would be surprising if no royal ritual was preserved in the Psalter. When the incorporation of independently existing rituals into bît rimki is examined, two things are discovered: 1) The rituals are used secondarily in bît rimki, and 2) they occur in the independent rituals and bît rimki ritual tablets in the same sequence that the texts of the individual incantations are transmitted separately. When used as an empirical model with which to view the incorporation of ritual into the Psalter, it is plausible that psalms in a royal ritual that may be preserved in the Psalter would occur in the same sequence as they did in the ritual. This is a step forward in removing the subjective nature involved in reconstructing royal ritual in Psalms studies. The paper then briefly discusses why Pss 15-18, 20-21 is plausibly read as such a royal ritual.
|
Hypocrisy and Moral Agency in Qohelet
Program Unit: Ethics and Biblical Interpretation
Davis Hankins, Appalachian State University
While hypocrisy is usually associated with ancient Greek theater, Jesus in the NT, and modern politicians, this paper examines the concept with attention to the HB and Qohelet in particular. Carol Newsom’s current research on moral agency in the Hebrew Bible, outlined in her 2011 SBL presidential address, offers a starting point. Drawing on cross-cultural anthropological studies, Newsom presents two vectors that map different constructions of human agency: the vector of control indicates the extent to which the self is conceived as “in control” or “under the control” of someone or something else, and the vector of location indicates the extent to which the substance of one’s moral capacities are conceptualized as internal or external to the self. Hypocrisy is an ancient concept with dynamic and contested meanings and evaluations. Yet it supplies an enlightening frame for investigating constructions of moral agency because, across hypocrisy’s variations, it always involves moral judgments about a human subject that is both internally divided and externally conditioned. Hypocrisy is not a matter of what one does, but rather of how one’s actions relate to one’s convictions and expressed intentions, and of what motivates the acting. Moral agency in Qohelet is deeply intertwined with dynamics typically associated with hypocrisy. For Qohelet there is something essentially crooked, divided, and conflicted about human beings (7:29), and this conviction seems the basis of various teachings about human behaviors typically associated with hypocrisy. Human action is not seen as an arena for self-actualization, but rather stems from far more ignominious motives, such as one person’s envy of another (4:4-6). He condemns the wise who claim to know what cannot be known (8:16-17). Yet some of his own teachings seem susceptible to charges of hypocrisy if not outright prescriptions for a minimally hypocritical life, as in his counsel that one should not be too righteous or too wicked but should instead grasp both (7:16-17).
|
Augustine’s Use of Paul in Confessions XI
Program Unit: Contextualizing North African Christianity
Sean Hannan, University of Chicago
It is well known that Augustine’s exploration of time’s mysteries in Book XI of the Confessions relies on the creation account in Genesis for its Scriptural grounding. What scholarship has attended to less, thus far, is his use of Paul in the same book. For Augustine, time is indeed a cosmological issue, but not exclusively so. There is also an experiential dimension, which concerns our lived experience of time and the sense of disorientation we might feel within it, caught up as we are between future and past. It is this dimension of temporality that Augustine found alive and well in the letters of Paul. Philippians 3, specifically, with its rhetoric of stretching out between the past and the future, gave Augustine a vocabulary for expressing his sense that his soul was torn apart by temporality. Not just Genesis, then, but also the letters of Paul lie at the heart of Augustine’s account of time as distentio animi.
By properly contextualizing both Phil. 3 and Augustine’s use of that text in Conf. XI (especially Chapter 29), this paper will flesh out Augustine’s constructive adoption of Paul’s rhetoric of forgetting the past and stretching out towards the future. Doing so will allow us to find a place for Paul’s letters as a Scriptural source for Augustine’s account of time, while also clarifying how Augustine received and reshaped those letters in service of his account. Pursuing these two goals should get us somewhat closer to the prize of glimpsing the North African reception of Paul as found in Book XI of Augustine’s Confessions.
|
The Integration of Spectral and Reflectance Transformation Imaging Technologies
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
Todd R. Hanneken, St. Mary's University, San Antonio
This presentation reports on the phase of the Jubilees Palimpsest Project dedicated to the integration of spectral imaging technology and reflectance transformation imaging technology (RTI). In 2013–2014 the National Endowment for the Humanities, Office of Digital Humanities funded a collaboration of scientists and scholars of early Jewish literature to develop a method for integrating two previously successful technologies. The combination is greater than the sum of the sum of the parts because the data is fully registered, meaning each pixel represents the same location on the object across the data set. As the data set grows the possibilities for processing grow exponentially. The two technologies integrated capitalize on two features of erased manuscripts (palimpsests) that offer hope for recovery of textual information. First, the erasure of ink is typically not complete. The difficulty is more often in distinguishing the erased ink from the similar shades of brown surrounding it. Spectral imaging uses nine or more discrete wavelengths of light, both outside and more precisely within the color resolution of the human eye. This significant quantity of data can be processed and mapped to false-colors within the human range of color perception. The second area of hope for recovery of textual information from erased manuscripts results from the effect of acidic ink on the texture of parchment. Even if the ink has been entirely washed away it may be nevertheless be possible to distinguish where ink had been because of the rougher texture. RTI uses light reflected from many angles to identify the orientation of any one pixel, such that the texture of an imaged object can be visualized and enhanced in an interactive viewer. The integration of these technologies means that a scholar can see both the chrominance and texture features of an object at the same time.
|
Becoming Paul: Oral Performance and the "Center" of Paul's Thought
Program Unit: Performance Criticism of the Bible and Other Ancient Texts
James Hanson, Saint Olaf College
This paper utilizes a performance-critical approach to the undisputed letters of Paul to shed new light on a much-disputed interpretive question: Is there a “center” to Paul’s thought? If so, of what does it consist? The Augustinian-Lutheran theological tradition that placed “justification by faith” at the center has, of course, been challenged in modern Pauline interpretation, with suggestions ranging from “Christ mysticism” (Schweitzer), to apocalyptic (J.C. Beker), to the assertion that Paul’s thought is fundamentally incoherent (Räisänen). A performance-critical approach allows for a reframing of the question and for fresh insights into Paul’s life and thought to emerge. First, the quest for the center of Paul shifts from the attempt to ground his life and thought in a central idea from which all others emanate to the question of what constitutes his fundamental goal as a human character, and the means he chooses to achieve that goal. Second, realizing the Apostle’s letters in oral performance – as they were designed to be experienced – fundamentally reshapes the interpreter’s relationship to the “script,” such that he or she must embody Paul’s message rather than simply explicate it; Paul’s thought becomes an expression of Paul’s character as the performer has brought it to. Finally, the recipients of the performance (the audience) experience Paul’s ideas in an embodied and relational form, rather than as static words on a page, and thus have a fundamentally different – i.e., richer and fuller – basis on which to judge the central thrust of the man and his message. The fruitfulness of the approach will be illustrated through performance of selected texts from Romans, Galatians, and 1 Corinthians.
|
The Multiple Origins of Scriptural Commentary
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
James E. Harding, University of Otago
Scriptural commentary is, in essence, the practice of explaining the authoritative scriptural text in light of something other than itself, something putatively more familiar to some intended readership. In the process, the authority of the commentated text is reinforced, by virtue of being rendered newly applicable. This seems obvious in the case of modern commentaries, including marginal notes in study bibles, which seem intended either to make an opaque text accessible, or to create the false impression that the text is less opaque than it really is. Where this involves the claim that Scripture is sui ipsius interpres, the additional irony is that external commentary is required in order to show that Scripture is, in fact, its own interpreter. But how, in ancient Judaism, did scriptural commentary get started? While we now work with a single category of “commentary,” the origins of this genre are multiple, and depend on different negotiations of group identity in relation to an emerging authoritative text within the various milieux in which Jewish communities found themselves in the late Second Temple period. In this period, the pluriform biblical text evolved — in Hebrew, Aramaic, and Greek — alongside various parabiblical genres, including rewritten Bible, and other genres parasitic upon a pre-existing authoritative text, such as the various forms of pesher at Qumran. This paper illustrates, with reference to the Qumran pesharim and three works of Philo (Alleg. Interp.; QE; QG), how different forms of scriptural commentary emerged independently within different socio-cultural frameworks, with rather different assumptions about the text whose nature and authority they each helped to create and reinforce. In the process, not only is serious doubt cast on the viability of the term “commentary” as a useful descriptor, but the very notion of “scripture” as a unitary phenomenon is also called into question.
|
On Language Variation and Grammatical Change in Ancient Hebrew: There and 'Back' Again
Program Unit: Philology in Hebrew Studies
Humphrey Hardy, Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary
This paper investigates language variation in ancient Hebrew as a window into understanding the dynamic nature of grammar and its philological value for studying diachrony. As a heuristic illustration, the morphemes ?a?ar, ?a?are, and ?a?ore—each originating from a body part noun meaning 'back'—are outlined according to their morphosyntax and semantics. The differences of meaning and form are demonstrated to suggest discrete pathways of grammatical change through the acquisition of novel functions. Employing methods of historical linguistics and diachronic typology, this functional evolution is evaluated according to the general changes inherent in diachronic grammar—grammaticalization, recategorization, reanalysis, semantic loss, and innovation.
The resulting model of change of these morphemes evidences a logical order of the grammatical expansion which suggests a diachronic relationship among the usages. These trajectories will be assessed further with regard to the different linguistic strata of ancient Hebrew from, in particular, the Hebrew Bible, the Dead Sea Scrolls, and the Mishnah. The goal, then, is to evaluate the degree to which the conclusions based on internal and comparative language study reflect actual changes realized in time and the implications for the investigation of diachrony in Hebrew.
|
New Apostles: The Lasting Effects of Paul’s Reception among British Missionaries
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
Christina Harker, Yale University
My paper analyzes Paul’s reception among British missionaries during the imperial period in relation to three main discourses: Christianity vs. heathenism, Christian paternalism, and missionaries’ identification of themselves as heirs to Paul and his mission. These discourses are (briefly) compared with similar discourses at work in the wider imperial context. During Britain’s imperial age, intellectual forces in British society identified Britain as heir to Rome, facing down barbarism abroad in the colonies and at home in Ireland, and spreading “civilization” to benighted peoples as a benevolent empire. The missionaries’ Christianized echoes of these discourses frequently turn on their understanding of Paul as a masthead for Christian mission. Just as scholars in Classics have interrogated their field’s uncritical reception of inherited colonial values in evaluations of the Roman Empire and the “civilization” it spread, this paper joins the chorus calling for similar self-reflection among biblical scholars. Its goal is to highlight the effect of discourses we may have uncritically absorbed from the imperial past and now take forward into a neo-colonial future. This paper ultimately questions whether Paul’s role among the missionaries has vestiges in his new incarnation as a postcolonial hero. This branch of postcolonial biblical interpretation is viewed as a new form of apologetic: one co-opting a political mode of dissent to re-instate and re-enshrine a neo-colonial icon as a “good” for all the world, as set forth by the Western academy.
|
The Memory of the Teacher in the Admonition Section of the CD and the Formation of a Collective Consciousness
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Angela Kim Harkins, Marie Curie Fellow, University of Birmingham
In the Damascus Document, references to the Teacher of Righteousness appear in the section known as the Admonition (see CD 1:11, 6:11; 20:1 and 20:32, possibly also CD 19:35 and 20:28). This paper will analyze how the Admonition section of the Damascus Document and references to the memory of the Teacher of Righteousness found there can function in the generation of group emotions. Emotions intensify experiences, and their role in the re-invigoration and re-constitution of memories has long been recognized by psychologists, although their role in the study of religion has been largely overlooked until recently. This study will analyze the rhetoric of the Admonition section with special attention to how the memory of the Teacher is used to arouse guilt, longing, and polarization. The proposal is that the arousal of emotion in the Admonition section is instrumental in generating entitivity among the community, well preparing them for an optimal reception of the laws that follow.
|
Thinking about the Neuroscience of Religious Experience: Daniel’s Interpretation of Scripture
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Angela Kim Harkins, Marie Curie Fellow, University of Birmingham
This study takes as its focus Patrick McNamara’s chapter, “Self-Transformation as a Key Function of Performance of Religious Practices” in his book, The Neuroscience of Religious Experience. According to McNamara, a crucial part of the religious experience is the decentering process which is a loss of agency that ultimately can result in the transformation of the religious practitioner toward some ‘ideal self’ (153-54). The general cognitive processes related to decentering and transformation resemble “the experience of problem solving and sudden insight and creativity concerning the solution to the problem after a period of impasse” (18); the individual begins with intense concentration, with no results, discouraged, the individual abandons the project. From this sensation of defeat (loss of agency), the individual experiences a surge of creativity and resolves the problem (18).
This paper will explore the way in which practices of mourning found in penitential prayers play a key role in the cognitive and affective processes associated with transformation that ultimately produce a more complex Executive Self who, in this case, is capable of scripture interpretation. This study will examine how the ritual acts of mourning (fasting, wearing sackcloth and ashes) performed by Daniel in the penitential prayer found in Dan 9 can generate vivid sensations of grief that can then be understood to play an instrumental role in Daniel’s experience of scripture interpretation. Some studies of grief and the post-traumatic growth that sometimes follows grief have noted the role of rumination in grieving individuals, noting that there is a correlation between this process of rumination and the experience of transformation (Bray 2013). The cognitive process of ruminating can have both an intrusive and intentional frequency. According to Martin and Tesser (1996), rumination “refers to several varieties of recurrent [event related] thinking, including making sense, problem solving, reminiscence, and anticipation.” In Dan 9:2, Daniel studies Jeremiah’s prophecy that the exile will go on for seventy years, then he performs mourning practices and prays a penitential prayer in which he confesses sins and guilt (9:4-19)—these are the acts that create a loss of agency in Daniel. After doing this, Daniel gains access to a new interpretation of Jeremiah’s prophecy. This paper proposes that the rites of mourning and confession of sins are instrumental in generating the experience of grieving which, in turn, initiates a loss of agency; these cognitive and religious experiences of transformation that follow may be what allows Daniel to access a new understanding of Jeremiah’s prophecy of seventy years. The dynamic process of prayer and scripture interpretation in Daniel 9 can be said to fit the cognitive processes of decentering and transformation that is proposed by McNamara.
|
At "the Place of the Skull": Pilgrimage to Golgotha in Late Antiquity and the Development of Crucifixion Iconography
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Felicity Harley-McGowan, Yale Divinity School
The Gospels record that Jesus of Nazareth was crucified at a site known as Golgotha, or “the place of the skull”, located just outside the walls of Jerusalem. When the first pilgrim narratives begin to appear, in the middle decades of the fourth century (such as the Itinerarium Burdigalense, written c. 330), there is emphasis on the area in and around Jerusalem, and specifically those places or loca sancta associated with the birth, death and resurrection of Christ.
When the first images of the holy sites begin to appear, produced from the 5th to the 6th century on portable objects manufactured in Jerusalem for pilgrims, the emphasis on place is further articulated through the replication of topographical or architectural features. This paper will examine the development of Crucifixion iconography in this context; and with reference to the medieval fresco of the subject preserved in the church of Santa Maria Antiqua in the Roman forum, will consider the broader consequences of the circulation of this site-specific imagery not only for the representation of the Crucifixion on Golgotha across
the medieval period, but for the putative functions of that imagery.
|
“Taking a Different View of the Translation”: The Illumination of Alternative Meanings in the Bible Translations of Joseph Smith and Meister Eckhart
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
Tod R. Harris, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints
Though less well known than his work on the Book of Mormon, particularly outside Latter-day Saint circles, Joseph Smith spent significant time and effort on another unique translation project—a revision of the King James Version of the Bible. While some may not consider this a translation in the truest sense, his alterations of more than 3000 Bible verses reveal another aspect of Smith’s highly original, speculative, and creative theological work. And though it is unique in many ways, there is a fascinating historical analogue for Smith’s Bible translation. The 14th century German Dominican preacher Meister Eckhart is also known for original, speculative, and creative work, chiefly through the large body of sermons he composed in his native Middle High German. In each of these vernacular sermons, Eckhart quotes at least one verse from the Bible, in many cases stating that he is translating from the Latin into German. Much of the originality and creativity of his ideas can be traced to the way Eckhart translates almost 1000 of these verses, often rendering the same verse differently from sermon to sermon. Despite their remove in time and space, a careful comparison of the way Joseph Smith and Meister Eckhart translate Bible verses reveals striking parallels between the American prophet and the German mystic. The purpose of this paper is to briefly examine Smith’s and Eckhart’s apparent translation methods, the way each uses translation to extract meaning from the Bible text, and what these processes and products reveal about their respective hermeneutics. Such a study not only serves to illuminate another aspect of Joseph Smith’s originality and how it sets him apart from his contemporaries, it also reveals an alternative mode of understanding some of his most important doctrinal themes.
|
The Nations Rising and Roaring: New Insights into the Origins of a Central Motif of the Zion Traditions
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Friedhelm Hartenstein, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
One important motif of the cultic traditions of Jerusalem is the concept of (all) the nations coming from afar in order to attack or besiege the city and its inhabitants. Mostly the nations are imagined in the colours of chaotic enemies with cosmic dimensions (the primeval waters). The motif occurs in texts dating from pre-exilic to late post-exilic times, beginning with the elder strata of the book of Isaiah (e.g. Isa 17; 29) and the Zion Psalms (Psalms 46; 48; 76), and ending with late Prophetic texts such as Zech 12 and 14. There are two ways the motif is elaborated: a) YHWH acts against the rebellious nations and terrifies them before they even reach Zion; b) YHWH himself is the main actor of the attack against his city as the driving force of history behind the enemies. Being of the same significance as a concept of cosmic order and of announcements of judgement, most scholars believed that the origins of the motif dated from Bronze age traditions of Jerusalem. A closer look at comparative material from Neo-Assyrian sources however shows that it is more probable that the motif of the nations is part of the Judaean engagement with Assyrian propaganda in the 8th and 7th century BCE. The paper evaluates important examples from Isaiah, the Book of the Twelve and the Psalter against the background of Assyrian texts and pictures leading to the conclusion that the idea took shape from Assyrian times onwards.
|
Animalizing Others in 1 Corinthians 5: Gender, Sexuality, and Racial-Ethnic Terms in Paul's Logic of Exclusion
Program Unit: Gender, Sexuality, and the Bible
Midori E. Hartman, Drew University
This paper explores how 1 Corinthians 5 utilizes an animalized logic to minoritize others through gender, sexuality, and racial-ethnic means in order to define the identity of the ekklesia over and against the kosmos. I first bring Christ's sacrifice as paschal lamb in 5:7b into conversation with Jacques Derrida's neologism carnophallogocentricism (1989), arguing that Paul's use of the metaphor of Christ as sacrificial animal produces a particular type of subjectivity that remains always under threat of erasure. If Christ's sacrifice gifts the ekklesia with a “humanity” born out of divine animalization, then it is a benefit that can be removed from any who disorder the ekklesia or support such people. I then elaborate on how Paul uses the ekklesia's obligation to honor Christ's sacrifice as a means to promote a normative ethic based in exclusion. If we accept that the construct of the human-animal divide intersects with various forms of discrimination to establish “insider-outsider” boundaries, then 1 Corinthians 5 uses this logic to determine what is and is not porneia concerning gender and sexuality, as well as who is and is not among the ethne in racial-ethnic terms. Through this lens, I am asserting that one can read Paul as arguing that the Corinthian ekklesia must be more “human” than both their Greco-Roman context (the ethne) and their own interpretations of the Pauline message (what is and is not porneia). At its core, this theoretical and exegetical approach opens up the question to what extent do biblical texts facilitate the construction of normative subjectivity based in a logic of championing the human over and against the animalized other, a point which has profound implications for relations today.
|
The Creation of Person in Ancient Narrative and the Gospel of Mark
Program Unit: Markan Literary Sources
Matthew R. Hauge, Azusa Pacific University
The creation of person in ancient narrative was shaped and bound by Greco-Roman education, which was a remarkably consistent private enterprise throughout antiquity. Given the static nature of ancient education, any author who composed in Greek during this period was trained and influenced by this ubiquitous curriculum, including the author of the Gospel of Mark. With regards to characterization in ancient narrative, for example, the first-century Alexandrian rhetor Aelius Theon lists ‘person [p??s?p??]’ as one of the six elements that comprise narrative and identifies several properties involved in the creation of person, including ‘origin, nature, training, disposition, age, fortune, morality, action, speech, death, and what followed death’ (Prog. 78 [Kennedy]). This essay will examine ancient education and literary mimesis as the foundation for recognizing and appreciating an example of the mimetic texture of person in Mark 11:1-11.
|
Sacred Bites: Krishna's Butter, Michelangelo's Fruit, Maui's Fire
Program Unit: Islands, Islanders, and Scriptures
Jione Havea, Charles Sturt University
I propose a contrapuntal reading of Hindu stories about the young mischievous Lord Krishna stealing milk and butter from the neighbors, with one of Michelangelo’s fresco at the Sistine chapel (based on Gen 3) in which Adam picks from the fruits of the tree and Eve picks from Adam’s fruit, and the Polynesian legend of Maui tricking his ancestors in order to bring fire (for cooking) from Pulotu to earth. These texts circle around food, but they come from different regions (Asia, Mediterranean, Pasifika) and canons (Hindu scriptures, Hebrew Bible via ceiling of the Sistine chapel, Pasifika legends). This presentation will cross cultural and religious boundaries as well as scripturalize non-traditional canons (artwork, folktale). The juxtaposition of these texts will interweave food and eating with mouth (Gen 3), sex (Michelangelo) and deception (Krishna, Maui). “Sacred bites” is when such interweaving takes place.
|
No Commentary Is an Island, No Island Lacks Commentary: Numbers 12
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Jione Havea, Charles Sturt University
This presentation will (1) challenge the assumption that commentaries are free of their contexts, (2) engage with romanticizing and colonialist views that islands are simplistic and isolated, disconnected, from the rest of the world, and (3) lay out some of the marks of island commentary. The latter includes attention to the orality of cultures, the reciprocity in familial and social relations, the fluidity of space and borders, and the fluctuating state of belonging. I will define and develop island commentary through island-reading the story of Miriam in Num 12. This presentation will add an island-commentary to the already rich mixture of commentaries on Num 12.
|
Feasting at Mt. Ebal: Secular or Sacred?
Program Unit: Sacrifice, Cult, and Atonement
Ralph K. Hawkins, Averett University
Throughout the Middle and Late Bronze Ages, food was prepared and sacred meals were consumed in the vicinity of sanctuaries and their associated altars. The faunal remains from the Iron Age I site on Mt. Ebal, which represent one of the largest samples ever studied in Israel, suggest that a narrow range of activities took place at this site. These activities clearly included the consumption of both food and water. This paper will examine the faunal remains from the Ebal site and explore the question of whether they should be associated with meals, sacrifice, or both.
|
The Iron Age I Structure on Mt. Ebal
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Ralph K. Hawkins, Averett University
This paper will review and assess the various interpretations of the Iron Age I structure excavated on Mt. Ebal by A. Zertal from 1982 to 1989, which the excavator identified as a cultic site. No scholarly congress or colloquium has ever been held regarding the Mt. Ebal excavations, though some archaeologists have argued that the site should be understood as a watchtower, a barbecue site, a farmstead, or as a center of commerce – rather than as a cultic site. As a benchmark site for the survey of Manasseh, however, the Mount Ebal site may shed important light on our understanding of the emergence of ancient Israel, regardless of how its nature is ultimately understood. This paper will review the excavation on Mt. Ebal and its results, give an overview of alternative explanations of the site, and will seek to draw conclusions about how the site can be understood and what contributions it might have to make to our understanding of the emergence of Israel.
|
Metaphor Coherence and Competition in the Joban Discourse: “Proverbs of Ashes” in Its Conceptual Context
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible and Cognate Literature
Lance Hawley, University of Wisconsin-Madison
Within the literary construct of the book of Job, the speeches between Job and his companions respond to one another at least in the sense that they take turns speaking. However, whether or not they advance their own arguments by countering the opponent’s point of view is not obvious. This paper seeks to propose a way forward for understanding the nature of the Joban discourse by assessing the interlocutors’ use of metaphor. When speakers express and hearers interpret metaphor, they demonstrate a level of shared knowledge and belief about the way the world functions. The acts of metaphor production and interpretation are fundamentally grounded in interlocutors sharing common human experience; however, in the book of Job, Job’s new experience of unjust suffering causes cognitive dissonance and sparks disagreement between Job and his companions. The interlocutors’ use of metaphor potentially highlights the key areas of agreement and disagreement throughout the discourse.
This paper seeks to lay the theoretical groundwork for assessing the expansive discourse of Job through a conceptual model of metaphor by discussing a particular lexical expression, Job 13:12a (zikronêkem mišlê ?eper “your reminders are proverbs of ashes”), in its discourse context. The context of Job 13:12a goes far beyond the parallel line in 13:12b or even the immediate speech that Job is giving. The hearer/reader must also consider broader levels of discourse, including the other speeches of Job, the character of the friends’ speeches, and the narrative setting for the dialogue (“among the ashes” Job 2:8). These contextual factors influence the selection and employment of particular metaphors within discourse. After briefly defining important terms and explaining the systems of the conceptual theory of metaphor, I comment on the study of metaphor in discourse in general and propose a few criteria for perceiving coherent or competing metaphors in the book of Job. These criteria take into account the conceptual levels (generic, basic, and specific) at which multiple metaphors demonstrate commonality, the textual space between metaphorical expressions, and the conventionality of the various metaphors.
|
“To See a World…” *in a Banana: An Exploration of No Self, Interbeing, and Interrelationship with the Earth in a Buddhist Context
Program Unit: Wabash Center for Teaching and Learning in Theology and Religion
Yusef Hayes, North Shore Community College
This teaching tactic engages the ideas of no self, interbeing, and interrelationship with the earth as taught by Thich Nhat Hanh. Through a participatory group activity, lecture, and class discussion, these ideas are introduced and explored.
|
Divine Extortion and Polysemic Pivots: The Strategy of Complaint in Joel 2:12–17
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Rebecca Whitten Poe Hays, Baylor University
The natural human response to announcement of imminent disaster is to attempt to alleviate or avert the calamity. In Joel 2:12–17, the priests use in their complaint the polysemic possibilities of mashal as part of a two-tiered strategy to ensure YHWH’s intercession. This poetic unit unfolds an argument for why YHWH should have pity on Judah that begins with repentance but then reinforces this incentive by combining the description of YHWH’s character in the call to repentance with the imagined derision of that character by the nations. In an ancient Near Eastern context that often correlated deities’ power with the welfare of their worshippers, the key that enhances the complaint’s persuasive force resides in a pivot device playing upon the two mashal roots (mashal I “to be like”; mashal II “to rule”). The threat to God is not merely that Judah will become the object of mockery; it is that the nations will understand Judah’s situation to be analogous to YHWH’s status and character. This polysemic verb has the capacity to communicate complex, shame-related notions of defeat and humiliation. Ultimately, the complaint song of Joel 2:12–17 utilizes a strategy of extortion wherein the priests present YHWH with a threat to the divine character, which the polysemic use of mashal enhances, as a means of incentivizing YHWH to reverse Judah’s fortunes.
|
The Erasure of Israel in Bultmann's Theology of Paul
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Richard B. Hays, The Divinity School, Duke University
Rudolf Bultmann systematically downplayed the significance of the Old Testament for Christian faith. This essay will examine what role the OT actually plays in Bultmann's exposition of Pauline theology, while at the same time exploring how Bultmann's account truncates and distorts Paul's thought by eliding Paul's emphasis on Israel's Scripture as witness to the gospel.
|
The Metaphysics of Creation in Genesis 1
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Philosophy
Yoram Hazony, The Herzl Institute
The creation account in Genesis 1 appears to describe two things that existed prior to the creation of heaven and earth: the primeval waters and ruah elohim--a spirit or wind of God. The paper examines the possibility that this duality of water and wind may have been understood as providing a metaphysical basis for the rest of creation, with Gods wind imposing a tendency and form on the chaotic waters. Parallel texts in Genesis, Psalms and elsewhere are explored to flesh out this conjecture.
|
A Flood of Noahs: Aronofsky’s “Noah” in the Noah Film Tradition
Program Unit: Genesis
Christopher Heard, Pepperdine University
Since 1909’s “Tale of the Ark” (dir. Arthur Melbourne Cooper), Noah has appeared in about a dozen films, most recently Darren Aronofsky’s “Noah.” The family of Noah films includes theatrical, television, and direct-to-video releases; animated adaptations, live-action adaptations, and documentaries; feature films, series episodes, and shorts; comedies and dramas. Aronofsky’s “Noah” bears certain family resemblances to other Noah films, not entirely attributable to common source material. But it also departs in very noticeable ways from the Noah film tradition, setting itself apart as something more than “just another flood film.”
|
The Inverted Nun: Flipping the Biblical Hebrew Classroom
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Christopher Heard, Pepperdine University
Over the last few years, the “inverted” (Lage, Platt, and Treglia, 2000) or “flipped” (Bergmann and Sams, 2012) classroom model has gained considerable popularity and attention. In a flipped classroom, relatively passive information-transfer activities (particularly lectures) take place outside of class, making room for more active learning experiences inside of class. A Faculty Innovation in Teaching and Learning grant from Pepperdine University enabled me to incorporate elements of the flipped classroom model into my two-semester Elementary Biblical Hebrew course. In this presentation, I will demonstrate and reflect upon both online and in-class components of the model, with assessment of the difference that flipping the Hebrew classroom has made for student learning.
|
The Contribution of the Syriac Version to the Critical Text of the Apocalypse
Program Unit: Novum Testamentum Graecum: Editio Critica Maior
Martin Heide, Philipps-Universität Marburg
The Syriac version of the Apocalypse is divided into two subversions, the Philoxenian and the Harklean. Of the latter version, some ten manuscripts are extant. A new critical edition based on these manuscripts provides many insights in the form of the Greek text of the Apocalypse current in Late Antiquity and the Early Middle Ages, not only through the text itself, but also via their variant readings and their marginal notes.
|
A Meal in the Background of John 6:51–58?
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
Jan Heilmann, Technische Universität Dresden
The new paradigm that the SBL Seminar “Meals in the Greco-Roman World” presented among other results challenges the exegesis of John. Both the question of “eucharistic overtones” of selected passages in the Gospel of John as well as the assumption of a cultic meal on the level of the community has become disput-able. In my paper, I will argue that the bread of life discourse is to be analyzed as a textual phenomenon that makes use of an imagery of eating and drinking, but does not refer to a specific meal practice on the ritual level. For heuristic reasons one should argue, that the conceptual metaphor EATING/DRINKING IS ADOPTING TEACHING – widely used in the ancient world – is the conceptual basis on which the complex metaphor network in the bread of life discourse is formed. The sources show hat the drastic intensification of the metaphoric language of adopting teaching in the sense of eating flesh or similar like in John 6:53–58 is has several parallels in antiquity. Moreover, the drastic metaphoric language in John 6:53–58 is part of a conscious provocation of the recipients at the level of the narrated world, and part of a typical Johannine misunderstanding scene. In the narrative strategy of John 6, the crucial moment of using the drastic metaphors is their function in the narratively enacted separation of the believing from the unbelieving disciples. However, the motif of drinking the blood of Jesus in John 6:53–58 is not a metonymic description of drinking wine. Analyzing the reception of this motif of drinking the blood of Jesus in the Ancient Church, it becomes evident that this motif first infiltrated the discourse on meals. Only in a second step, the motif of drinking the blood of Jesus became part of ritual semantics itself. This observation corresponds to the highly dynamic and complex historical development on the ritual level, which M. Klinghardt, A. McGowan, and M. Wallraff amongst others have described. In sum: In its reception, the text of the Gospel of John influenced the development of ritual, but not did the ritual influenced the text.
|
Common Exegetical Fallacies in the Interpretation of Biblical Proverbs and Interpretive Strategies for Their Eradication
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Knut M. Heim, Trinity College Bristol
Drawing on representative examples from the Book of Proverbs, this paper will highlight four common exegetical fallacies: (1) references to other (similar) verses to settle ambiguities; (2) the use of parallelism to discern the precise meaning of obscure words (lexicography); (3) the use of parallelism to prompt and justify textual emendations and conjectures (textual criticism); (4) the use of the notion of "better parallelism" to justify exegetical decisions. We will then consider insights, values, virtues, skills, and techniques that help to overcome common challenges to the interpretation of biblical poetry. These include new insights into the nature of poetry, leading to the employ of diligence, imagination, courage, flexibility, and wisdom in interpretive processes.
|
Common Exegetical Fallacies in the Interpretation of Biblical Psalms and Interpretive Strategies for Their Eradication
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Knut M. Heim, Trinity College Bristol
Drawing on representative examples from the psalms, this paper will highlight four common exegetical fallacies: (1) references to other (similar) verses to settle ambiguities; (2) the use of parallelism to discern the precise meaning of obscure words (lexicography); (3) the use of parallelism to prompt and justify textual emendations and conjectures (textual criticism); (4) the use of the notion of "better parallelism" to justify exegetical decisions. We will then consider insights, values, virtues, skills, and techniques that help to overcome common challenges to the interpretation of biblical poetry. These include new insights into the nature of poetry, leading to the employ of diligence, imagination, courage, flexibility, and wisdom in interpretive processes.
|
Sacrifice and Divine Goodness in Porphyry and Origen: A Debate with Popular Religion or with Other Cultural Producers?
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Ky Heinze, The Catholic University of America
Dale Martin (2004) claims that philosophy and popular religion were in conflict over questions of divine goodness from Plato into the imperial period. According to Fritz Graf (2011), this was the source of differing philosophical and popular ideas about sacrifice. Indeed, it is hard to deny that many philosophers objected to ideas about sacrifice because they seemed to conflict with the philosophical principle of divine goodness. But this perspective must be nuanced by the claim that popular religion, as well as philosophy, held the gods to be good. The conflict was not over the claim that the gods were good but over the definition of goodness, which led to differing expectations concerning how the gods interact with humans in sacrifice. But was this a conflict between philosophy and popular religion? Daniel Ullucci (2012) presents the objecting philosophers as cultural producers competing with each other for the right to interpret sacrifice in keeping with their own worldviews. The purpose of this paper is to resolve these two perspectives – to determine who was arguing with whom in the debate over sacrifice and the goodness of the gods. Were cultural producers sparing with each other or were they united in their attempt to discredit or reinterpret the flawed views of popular religion? To answer the question, this paper examines passages from Porphyry of Tyre and Origen of Alexandria. The texts under consideration by these authors address other elite cultural producers, not the masses. And yet they perceive some of these cultural producers (whose texts largely have not survived) to be capitulating to popular misconceptions about divine goodness and sacrifice. Thus, Marin and Graf are correct in that these philosophers perceive themselves to be attacking popular views, but Ullucci is correct in that they attack these views as they appear in other cultural producers.
|
Canticles and Christology
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Desta Heliso, Ethiopian Graduate School of Theology
This study seeks to broadly identify exegetical methods adopted and theological themes developed in the Ethiopic Canticles and then explores whether there are identifiable contributions that the Canticles made to the development of Christological ideas in Ethiopia.
|
The Triumph of Love over Legalism: An Interpretation of Biblical Morality
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Philosophy
Jeff Helmreich, University of California—Irvine
A popular way of viewing morality, roughly following Aristotle and Kant, focuses on acts of the will: morality, on this rough gloss, is a guide or directive or set of principles or evaluating, and thereby choosing, among acts of will. Even so-called consequentialist" ethics is of a piece with this tradition, as it aims primarily at delineating which action choices would count as morally optimal, and thereby as manifesting the best in ethical behavior. A feature of this tradition is the primacy of rights and duties in the evaluation of action - roughly, what types of actions should others enable or allow us to do, and what types of actions ought we to try to do. Call this focus on rights and duties (specially interpreted) "legalistic." In contrast, a different view can be imagined, and in fact gleaned from lessons and examples in the Hebrew Bible, crystalized in rabbinic literature. On this view, the primary focus of ethics is the particular, localized and case-specific interests and needs of particular (other) people, in particular cases, regardless of desert, status or any of their characteristics (such as "shared" humanity and rational agency). Mercy, compassion, love and responsibility for consequences are, on this model, prized over justice, fairness and other applications of principle. To the extent it shares anything with contemporary ethical theory, this approach has affinities with the particularism of Jonathan Dancy and the Other-based focus of Emmanuel Levinas. An examination of the tales of Abraham, Moses and Job will provide the primary model for analysis. The paper neither endorses nor rejects this approach, but hopes instead to bring it into sharp relief, as an original contribution to normative ethics.
|
Shared Bodily Pleasure as a Treatment for Trauma: Modern Body Therapies and Ecclesiastes’ Injunction to Enjoyment
Program Unit: Biblical Literature and the Hermeneutics of Trauma
Philip Browning Helsel, Princeton Theological Seminary
Trauma theorists working in “somatic experiencing” such as Babette Rothschild and Peter Levine argue that processing trauma is not possible in treatment until people are capable of enjoyable experience in their bodies. Before memories of trauma are addressed, the capacity for pleasurable experience is built up through mindfulness, breathing, and relaxation in order to increase clients’ capacity for self-regulation during the return of traumatic memories. The book of Ecclesiastes (Qoheleth) ponders questions of intractable meaninglessness, of life not adding up, but, as Eunny Lee suggests, Qoheleth maintains that experiences of shared pleasure help orient human life and are thus a gift from God. According to Qoheleth the gift of enjoyment consists of shared activities such as eating and drinking that take shape through shared ritualized activity and thus orient the body of the participant. In this way, Qoheleth recommends a process of restoring meaning through pleasurable engagement in communities. Qoheleth’s injunctions to pleasure should not be interpreted as a “diversion” but rather as a way of orienting the “heart” and “eyes,” thus connecting desire and pleasure in life’s broader meaning. The fact that Semitic languages conceptualize cognitive faculties in bodily terms lends credence to the notion that bodily experience can be a distinctive source of meaning-making in the face of trauma. Additionally, this treatment will address the role of misogyny in Qoheleth’s discussion of women, particularly the expectation in the “royal” monologue of the use of others for one’s pleasure. Following Lee, it will argue that the primary emphasis in Qoheleth is on shared meaning-making through ritual experiences of pleasure, which are similar to body-oriented trauma therapies that begin by addressing the capacity for ordinary pleasure before returning to address traumatic memory.
|
Rhizomatic Encounters: Translation Resources and New Media Epistemologies
Program Unit: Global Education and Research Technology
Michael Hemenway, Iliff School of Theology
In August of 2012, several bible translation agencies gathered together to consider the possibility of creating a new training manual for bible translation. As we considered the role of new media and emerging technologies in both the translation and the training processes, the push for another printed translation manual transformed into the beginnings of an ecosystem we call MAP. MAP is a collection of technologies and learning communities that take seriously the role of media and emerging technologies in support of the ongoing training efforts for bible translation around the world. The cartographic characteristics of rhizomes suggested and practiced by Deleuze and Guattari in A Thousand Plateaus, provide a helpful and challenging way of looking at the dynamic evolution of MAP, the values operative in the current state of the MAP ecosystem, and imaginations for MAP's future in bible translation.
|
Biblical Inerrancy and Textual Criticism: A Curious History
Program Unit: Metacriticism of Biblical Scholarship
Ron Hendel, University of California-Berkeley
The modern doctrine of biblical inerrancy that emerged in the late 16th and 17th centuries was, in part, a response to text-critical controversies. The problem of textual variants in the MT, the LXX, and the Samaritan Pentateuch became incendiary in Protestant-Catholic controversy, particularly after the Council of Trent elevated the status of the Vulgate. The orthodox Protestant position on textual variants crystallized into the doctrine of inerrancy in creeds of the late 17th century. This little-known chapter of textual-theological dispute has implications for contemporary biblical scholarship.
|
Constructing the Digital Edition of the Hebrew Bible: A Critical Edition
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Ronald Hendel, University of California-Berkeley
General Editor of The Hebrew Bible: A Critical Edition to discuss the digital version (http://ohb.berkeley.edu/iPad.jpg).
|
Refining Topos: “Finding” “Places” for Embodied Persuasion in Early Christian Rhetoric
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Ian H. Henderson, McGill University
The notion that persuasive transformative arguments are available for “finding” or “discovery” (heuresis; inventio) in conceptual-verbal-social “places” (topos; loci) must surely rank among the most productive and fateful analogies ever articulated. It is all the more intriguing that the concept “place” and the heuristic method that arose with/inspired it have never required a fully coherent definition in order to function in rhetorical practice. The essential point is that Greek and Latin speakers and their audiences found it helpful to imagine persuasion happening in social spaces demarcated by words. I am not sure –and I don’t think that users need to decide-- how far “topos” is a metaphor and how far it corresponds with some real relationship between social cognitive perception of persuasion and cognition of space, location and movement. In the present essay I will be interested rather in the local-rhetorical sense both as a crossing between antiquity and modernity and as an ambiguous frontier zone of decision, of intentional fence-building within any discourse. For this purpose I will continue to represent topoi as marked pairs of contrasting value-terms (less-more; new-old; etc.). An essential project for topos-research in biblical studies would thus be the systematic identification of such marked value-pairs and their modulations in discourse inside or discourse about the Bible. Thus, in the SBL setting, Bruce Malina and the Context Group have been massively influential in their claim that understanding the topos of “honour-shame” in all its ambiguities is vital for an appreciation of Greco-Roman and early Christian thought worlds. Among scholars, however, the explanatory power of the “honour-shame” topos depends in turn on topoi of “antiquity-modernity” or, even more problematically, of “Mediterranean-Northern.” In particular, topoi, thought of this way as locations of social knowledge, have an especially close relationship with patterns of embodied knowledge including “embodiments of forward-backward, high-low, curved-straight, back-front, in-our, right- and left-handedness, pleasure, pain, pride, shame, guilt, and many more.” (Gabriel Ignatow, “Theories of Embodied Knowledge: New Directions for Cultural and Cognitive Sociology?” Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour 37 2007) 115-135, 129) The more seriously we take the analogy between argumentation and “place-finding,” the more topos-analysis can help us think about the relationship between social and individual cognition and the embodied persuasive affect of the gospel.
|
Metaphorical, Punitive, and Pedagogical Blindness in Hell
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Meghan R. Henning, Emory University
What is the role of the blind body in hell? Does it gesture to broader cultural conceptions of physical impairment? Can the blind be healed in places of eternal punishment? Does this "healing" function similarly to the understandings of blindness available in contemporaneous medical texts?
This paper will examine the depictions of the blind in the extra canonical apocalypses that describe hell. We will begin with a discussion of the ancient medical texts that describe blindness, comparing those descriptions with the depictions of the blind in the apocalyptic tours of hell. Next, we will consider the way in which blindness is used to depict both eternal punishment and spiritual enlightenment. Finally, we will use our analysis to draw conclusions about the role of sight and blindness within apocalyptic theology . We will also consider the impact of that these understandings of the disabled body have upon the readers of apocalyptic texts when placed alongside other impaired and disfigured bodies in hell.
|
Christ as Savior in the Otherworld: The Harrowing of Hell in the Second Century
Program Unit: Texts and Traditions in the Second Century
Meghan Henning, University of Dayton
This paper will examine the history of interpretation of the traditions of post-mortem salvation that read 1Peter 3 (albeit incorrectly) as a salvific event in which Christ "harrows hell." We will begin with the text of 1Peter 3 itself, and its circulation in Asia Minor, as a late first century text that inspires the readings of the second century. Next, this paper will survey the patristic readings of this text in the second century, demonstrating that there were diverse reading practices at play surrounding the theological conception of Christ as Savior in the Netherworld. Finally we will compare the patristic readings of that text with the apocalyptic tradition of the Apocalypse of Peter. Our analysis will be attentive to the distinctive readings, counter-readings, and re-readings of the incipient "descent of the redeemer" tradition, and to the soteriological claims that are at stake in each interpretation of the tradition.
|
Second Kings 6:24–7:7: A Case of Unintentional Eliminatory Killing
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Kristine Henriksen Garroway, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion
Second Kings 6: 24-6:33 presents an astonishing narrative wherein two Israelite mothers agree to eat their children. Granted, the city of Samaria is under siege and food is scarce, but this hardly lessens the shock and horror the reader experiences when reading that Israelite mothers have resorted to cannibalism. Previous scholarship understands this text as describing a world where everything has gone awry, where cannibalism and the violence against children becomes a call for social change. However, it has failed to connect the mothers’ act to the events immediately following their actions: the king has a revelatory moment and and Elisha announces the siege will end. This last part of the narrative, 7:1-7, provides the key to understanding the text and a new way of reading the text. The women have saved the city by unintentionally offering a sacrifice and in doing so stop the siege and restore order and harmony. The efficacy of the sacrifice then becomes a veiled polemic against child sacrifice and the religious depravity running rampant in the Northern Kingdom.
The first part of the paper examines 2 Samuel 6:24-7:7 through the lens of religious anthropology. It first presents the circumstances under which eliminatory killings are carried out and shows that all the elements needed for an eliminatory killing are in play in 2 Kings. Then the paper explores the purpose of children as sacrificial victims and the rhetoric of child sacrifice in the biblical text broadly. What we will see is that Second Kings 6 echoes the language used to describe child sacrifice as a regular religious practice thus linking 2 Kings 6 to child sacrifices not only from an anthropological viewpoint, but from a linguistic stance as well. As I will demonstrate, the phrase ??? ?????? in particular corresponds to the way in which the biblical text describes a parent offering their son or daughter to mlk or Baal.
With the link between 2 Kings 6 and eliminatory sacrifice firmly established, the paper considers why the Deuteronomistic Histories would choose to include this narrative. Ostensibly it is a direct result of the people breaking the covenant with God (Deut. 28:53-58). One may therefore ask what part of the covenant the Northern Kingdom has broken for it had no lack of sins to choose from. I suggest that the author hints at a sin so dark that he must veil it —the Northern Kingdom was practicing child sacrifice. Sacrifices were meant to get the attention of a deity and spur the deity to action. By presenting a narrative where child sacrifice was effective, the Deuteronomistic Historian puts an ironic twist on the narrative; the sacrifice got the attention of the king, not God and God responds to people who properly seek Him. Thus, the text becomes a polemic against the religious depravity including child sacrifice happening in the Northern Kingdom.
|
The Goals, Content, and Means of Achieving a Working Knowledge of Biblical Hebrew
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Jared A. Henson, University of the Free State - Universiteit van die Vrystaat
Teaching biblical Hebrew to congregational leaders can be challenging to instructors because of the amount of material that must be covered to bring students to an adequate level of proficiency in the language. Teachers must often decide what and how much material to present to achieve a working knowledge of the language. This paper will explore the goal(s) of our instruction under such restraints, the content that should be considered essential to achieve a working knowledge, and the means of achieving and maintaining a working knowledge for ministry purposes.
|
An Experiment in Almsgiving as Pedagogical Practice
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Seth Heringer, Fuller Theological Seminary (Pasadena)
One of the most surprising findings of the study collated in the book Cultivating the Spirit: How College Can Enhance Students' Inner Lives is summed up in the following statement: “We found that philanthropic giving (‘giving money to charity’), another altruistic act, enhances each and every spiritual quality. It also shows positive effects on virtually every traditional measure of academic performance, including GPA, Psychological Well-Being, Leadership abilities, Satisfaction with college, commitment to promoting racial understanding, and self-rated ability to get along with people of other races and cultures.” In short, the study shows that one of the most powerful tools for enhancing the spiritual, religious, and educational outcomes is what the authors call “Charitable Involvement.”
Due to this unexpected result, I will implement a Charitable Giving requirement in my Fall 2014 section of Theology and the Christian Life at Azusa Pacific University. This particular class already has a history of incorporating spiritual practices such as prayer, meditation, and fasting, thus pivoting to include this new strategy will not be difficult and will fit well into the larger class outcomes. A few complications arise when considering how to implement philanthropic giving into a classroom. First, it is not appropriate for teachers to demand of their students that they give away money. Not only are there legal and moral implications of such a requirement, but such coercion seems contrary to the spirit of giving itself. Thus, I will offer two options for meeting the requirement correlating to the two factors of Charitable Giving identified with strongest student outcomes. I will allow for my students to either give a certain dollar figure to a charity or will allow them to give a proportionate amount of their time in service-learning.
The evaluation of this experiment will take the form of a self-assessment survey given at the completion of the Charitable Giving assignment. It will consist of various questions that will identify the helpfulness of Charitable Giving as a course requirement. In particular, I will design questions to gauge changes in spiritual engagement, ability to get along with other races and cultures, and equanimity. In short, the questionnaire will be designed to see if any progress was made on encouraging “other-directed” thinking in students.
My current expectations are that the results of this experiment will be varied. Some students will embrace the idea, particularly those who already have religious commitments and those who are providing their own support through college. I anticipate that students who have no philanthropic interest or have no stake in their own financial support will see this assignment merely as trading money/time for class points.
|
Playing with Maps: Using Interactive Maps to Teach Biblical Geography
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Seth Heringer, Fuller Theological Seminary (Pasadena)
Map tests are an integral part of introductory courses to the Christian Bible. Although learning the geography of Israel during different eras is a valuable learning outcome, the means to do so need to undergo creative rethinking. Although map tests force surface learning through memorization, such memorization is not “sticky.” This paper will argue that using interactive maps better promotes deep learning. It will do so by applying the criteria in Teaching that Sticks by Chip and Dan Heath to a map of Israel created with RPG Maker VX Ace.
Chip and Dan Heath identify six components to sticky learning: simple, unexpected, concrete, credible, emotion, and story. I will argue that an interactive map is better at promoting deep learning according to these six criteria than a paper map. By “interactive map” I mean a map like those in classic RPG games such as Final Fantasy, The Secret of Mana, or The Legend of Zelda. These maps allow for the representation of a large piece of land on an “overworld” map in addition to submaps that could correspond to cities or smaller areas of land. Characters with dialogue, scripted events triggered by an action, and enemies to battle can be added to these maps if desired.
The challenges of using an interactive map in this manner are quite significant. First are the technical challenges. RPG Maker VX Ace is not a free program, it is challenging to learn, and it exports maps to an .exe file that will only run on Microsoft Windows. Second, there is the social factor of students being unwilling to participate in a teaching medium that is associated with “geeks” or “nerds.” Although this social stigma is lessening, it still could have negative effects on students’ willingness to participate. The third challenge is creating a map with enough content to engage students while not being a time sink. Many students work jobs and participate in extracurricular activities, causing them to be unwilling to spend the time to run the program, create a character, and explore the map. They will instead prefer to have the familiar paper map and learn the material through rote memorization. Fourth is the challenge of the teacher’s time investment. Learning the program, designing a map, creating the proper stories, and writing the syllabus section will time intensive. This problem could be alleviated by sharing maps among departments or schools; however, there will still have to be a willingness to spend time above handing out paper maps.
Despite these challenges, I am arguing that interactive maps serve as better learning tools for students willing to engage with them. A well-designed map that walks students through important locations by setting up an interesting story can be a powerful teaching tool.
|
Assigning ‘Prophetic’ Labels: The Interpretive Template and Authoritative Claims of pneumatikos in Early Jewish and Christian Texts
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Ronald Herms, Fresno Pacific University
Assigning ‘Prophetic’ Labels: The Interpretive Template and Authoritative Claims of pneumatikos in Early Jewish and Christian Texts
|
Nestle-Aland 28 and the Revision of the Apocalypse’s Textual History
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Juan Hernandez, Bethel University (Minnesota)
By all accounts, the only part of the Greek text that has changed in NA28 is the Catholic Epistles—the product of Münster’s ongoing work on the Editio Critica Maior. It would be a mistake, however, to overlook changes to the apparatus that equally appear to signal a new day for the NT’s textual history. One such change pertains to the identification of Codex Sinaiticus’s correctors. The revisions that have been proposed have direct implications for our understanding the Apocalypse’s textual history. Corrections once understood as belonging to the fourth-century are now placed circa the seventh. Unbeknownst to many, however, part of the evidence for the existence of a fourth-century Andreas text-type (an important aspect of the current understanding of the Apocalypse's textual history) hinges upon the fourth-century corrections of the manuscript. That is now in question. Further, in the history of textual research, Codex Sinaiticus’s corrections have been tied claims of “recensional” activity in the Apocalypse, as well as to the manuscript’s status as a “mixed text.” This paper will therefore explore the implications of the recent changes for the Apocalypse’s textual history. The paper will further disclose textual variants in Codex Sinaiticus that have been left out of the apparatus (either because they have been considered spelling errors or insignificant) and argue for their inclusion as witnesses to Sinaiticus’s “mixed” text in the Apocalypse.
|
Imagery Relating to Ill-Gotten Gain in the Book of Job and the “Instruction of Amenemope”
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Dominick S. Hernández, Bar-Ilan University
The similarities between the ancient Egyptian composition The Instruction of Amenemope and the biblical book of Proverbs, particularly Proverbs 22:17-24:22, have been noted for years. However, what has not been widely observed is that Amenemope features themes and imagery that are shared with the Book of Job. In particular, Amenemope illustrates the fate of the wicked who perpetually desire to obtain ill-gotten gain by exploitation of the weak. In Amenemope, illicitly obtained goods are ephemeral, as the corrupt are forced to surrender them. Various texts in Job similarly illustrate, in accordance with traditional wisdom, that ill-gotten gain results in a loss of possession. In fact, Zophar in Job 20 seems to be using the same imagery as noted in Amenemope in identifying the wicked.
In Job 20, Zophar depicts the cycle of the wicked obtaining ill-gotten gain by means of exploitation and striving to maintain possession of their goods. Yet, by use of the imagery of regurgitation, Zophar claims that evil-doers are forced to surrender control of their goods. Zophar asserts that all of the consequences brought upon vile people are caused by God. God’s justice does not permit evil-doers to maintain their possessions.
In the Instruction of Amenemope, poverty is not necessarily considered misfortune and is preferable to obtaining ill-gotten gain. However, Amenemope still displays aspects of the doctrine of retribution; hence, one would expect there to be similarities between this composition and the dialogues in Job. In Amenemope, there are corresponding themes to Job relating to admonitions against exploiting the weak for material gain and the ephemerality of unlawful possessions. In addition to this, swallowing imagery is shared between the two compositions to depict the inability of the wicked to retain their ill-gotten gain.
Observing these similarities in imagery, it is clear that, although Job is an exceptional composition, it must be understood, though not exclusively, as a part of a larger corpus of ancient Near Eastern literature. This presentation compares and contrasts the imagery depicted in Job 20 and Amenemope that represents the consequences of the wicked person’s attempt to obtain and retain ill-gotten gain. This comparison will explore what each composition conveys regarding the consequences of exploitation of the weak, the ephemerality of possessions, and the imagery of swallowing. After reviewing the related imagery, I will suggest how one might read Job 20 anew in light of the unmistakable similarities between word pictures in Job and Amenemope. The presentation concludes by suggesting that the poet of Job was familiar with well-known Egyptian imagery as employed in Amenemope and customized this language to convey two main theological points: 1) Zophar’s claim that Job corruptly obtained his former possessions, as well as 2) portraying Zophar’s ardent belief in the theology of just retribution.
|
Retelling the Story of Exile: The Figure of Jeremiah in Fourth Baruch
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Jens Herzer, Universität Leipzig
Among the Jewish literature that emerged after the destruction of the Second Temple in 70 CE, 4Baruch develops a surprising vision of the future of the people by retelling the story of the Babylonian exile. Jeremiah as the prophet of doom does not end up in Egypt as in the book of Jeremiah, but he accompanies his people to Babylon and after the exile back to Jerusalem. 4Baruch thus highlights Jeremiah’s priestly function. In this new story the author also connects certain theological features from different sources, merging the hopes for the people as a whole with individual expectations of salvation. In the paper I will contextualize this visionary concept as a substantial contribution to the contemporary debate about the identity and the future of the Jewish people without the Temple as well as about the relation between Jerusalem and the Diaspora.
|
The Transformation of Pauline Theology in the First Epistle to Timothy
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Jens Herzer, Universität Leipzig
The relation of the Pastoral Epistles to the larger Pauline and non-Pauline tradition is one of the most vexing problems in the research on these letters. Astonishingly, from a pseudonymous perspective the obvious quotations of formed traditions particularly in 1Tim are not quotations from Pauline letters, as one might expect, but fragments from so-called “Gemeindetraditionen” (ecclesial traditions). Some have tried to put these fragments together, supposing an “ordination form” used for the installation of officers (E. Käsemann), some even called those texts “traditions already worn out” (G. Strecker). In the paper I will show that none of these characteristics is appropriate. In fact, the author of 1Tim uses an already formed Christological confession in three parts in order to develop a new ecclesiastical vision of the congregation as a fortress of the truth, based on the generally recognized hymn. In developing his new vision, the author allows insights into his way of transforming Pauline theology within a wider framework of Christian traditions.
|
Eve, Abraham, and the Ethics of (Dis)Obedience
Program Unit: Genesis
Todd Hibbard, University of Detroit Mercy
This paper offers a synchronic reading of the Garden of Eden story (Gen 3:1-24) and the Binding of Isaac story (Gen 22:1-19) which compares and contrasts the figures of Eve (and to a lesser extent Adam) and Abraham in these texts and highlights ethical and theological considerations in their portrayals. The warrant for such a reading is found in the literary and thematic similarities that exist between these texts. For example, both characters receive or are aware of divine commands/instructions and both are tested by outside figures (the serpent, God) in some way. Beyond that, both texts develop the themes of life and death, acquisition and use of ethical knowledge, and obedience and disobedience. Several other less important literary and thematic similarities and contrasts are also noted as well. This leads to a conclusion in which each figure’s ethical knowledge and behavior is contrasted with each one’s role as a type or anti-type for faithful behavior in Genesis. On the one hand, Eve pursues the knowledge of good and evil (i.e., ethical knowledge) and is upbraided for doing so. Abraham, on the other hand, arguably displays a lack of ethical knowledge, but is, remarkably, commended. The reading of these two texts offered in this paper is one in which a theological tension is highlighted between, on the one hand, unquestioning obedience to the divine and, on the other, independently acquired human ethical knowledge and judgment.
These texts are traditionally regarded as originating in different sources (J and E, respectively), so some attention is devoted in the paper to assessing the literary critical issues raised by assigning them to different sources. However, their combined presence in the Book of Genesis creates the opportunity to ask questions about each one’s meaning in the canonical form of Genesis, both individually and collectively. Though innumerable studies have taken up each of these texts in isolation, I know of no detailed analysis of the two that examines them comparatively.
|
Genesis and Gentiles: The Greek Bible in the Hands of Paul and Aseneth
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Jill Hicks-Keeton, Duke University
The apostle Paul refers to his gentiles-in-Christ as “sons of the living God” (Rom 9:25-26). This re-appropriation of Hosea’s language to claim eschatological sonship for gentiles is typically interpreted by Pauline scholars as novel, surprising, or even potentially scandalous to Jewish ears. Yet, another ancient Jewish text uses identical rhetoric: that of Joseph and Aseneth, whose author is, like Paul, steeped in the Greek translation of Israel’s scriptures. Aseneth is conceived as a “city of refuge” in which the “sons of the living God” (future converts to Judaism) will dwell (Jos. Asen. 19:8). I suggest that this similarity is grounds for exploring another commonality: their rewriting of characters from Genesis to authorize gentile access to Israel’s God. I argue that Joseph and Aseneth participates in a similar discursive project to that which Caroline Johnson Hodge has attributed to Paul: the construction of a “myth of origins” for gentile inclusion in Israel. Both Paul and Joseph and Aseneth wrest a character from Genesis LXX to write Israel’s story in such a way as to make room for gentiles. While Paul employs Abraham to justify gentiles’ access to God’s promises, Joseph and Aseneth uses Aseneth to authorize gentile access to the Jewish community. The latter narrative accomplishes this goal in part by drawing on yet another motif from the Greek Bible: Isaiah’s portrayal of renewed Zion. I argue that Aseneth’s position as “mother-city” (Jos. Asen. 16:16; cf. Isa 1:26) is intimately tied to the role of Zion in Isaiah, a mother(-city) who is said to provide comfort, refuge, and mercy to those who worship God, a group which – significantly – includes gentiles.
|
Placing Deuteronomy in Its Historical Context: A Study of the Monarchic and Temple-Centered Layers in Deuteronomy
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
Andrew W. Higginbotham, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion
The book of Deuteronomy, as it appears in the canonical form, clearly reflects upon, if not outright adapts, prior cultural thinking and traditions. While its composite nature is not widely debated, the exact breakdown of sections and units is not settled among most commentators. This paper proposes a historical placement of subunits of text, seeking to discern how the ideology and legal structure of Deuteronomy was developed over its history of reception and transmission. The Sitz im Leben of the core of Deuteronomy require a stronger and more centralized monarchy than is existent in the times of the later Judean monarchy. So this paper will explore how the strong monarchial tone of certain sections has been adapted by the later scribes of the period of a weak monarchy, which was guided by the cultic center and its priesthood. The interplay between the power centers of palace and temple will be explored, with attention to how economics and cultic practices are conceptualized in the verses of the canonical form. Though Deuteronomy is the result of various redactions, its core however relies on a centralizing principle which narrates both cultic and secular practices. Such a strong hand cannot occur during the decline of the Israelite state, as the traditional dating assumes. Thus, as the layers of textual composition are discerned, the conclusion of an earlier core is supported by what evidence remains in the final product found in Scripture.
|
Textual Division in Early Christian Gospel Manuscripts: An Unexplored Correspondence between P75 and B
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Charles E. Hill, Reformed Theological Seminary
Early Christian manuscripts of the Gospels show an evolution in the ways in which scribes divided the text, no doubt reflecting and in turn influencing exegesis. The practice of introducing textual division to mark chapter, paragraph, or “verse,” though perhaps surprisingly common in Gospel manuscripts, is irregular and inconsistent. There is diversity both in the principles behind the divisions and in the scribal procedures for marking them (namely: spacing, punctuation, ekthesis, paragraphos, letter-enlargement, marginal chapter numberings, the Eusebian canons).
Besides having a system for marking paragraphs, Codex Vaticanus uses a system for numbering chapters that is unique up to that time and has only been observed elsewhere in Codex Zacynthius Rescriptus (6th century), and minuscule 579 (13th c), and Zacynthius contains only Luke 1-11. This paper will demonstrate an unexplored correspondence between the chapter numbering system in B and the textual divisions in P75, from about 150 years earlier, in the Gospel of John. The correspondence has been obscured by the fact that the scribes used different procedures for signifying textual division. While it is well known that the texts of P75 and B are extremely close, we can now observe a system of textual division that connects the two as well, at least for a major portion of John (though not Luke). This paper will lay out the details of this correspondence and make comparisons with other manuscripts. Finally, it will explore possible implications suggested by this correspondence for the proposed common ancestor of P75-B, and for the origins of visual sectioning techniques in Christian manuscripts.
|
Experiencing the Dao in the Introductory World Religions Class
Program Unit: Wabash Center for Teaching and Learning in Theology and Religion
Susan E. Hill, University of Northern Iowa
Student outcomes assessment data from our religion program suggests that religion majors have a very difficult time understanding East Asian sacred traditions. This teaching tactic uses Tai Chi to help students experience concepts related to Dao, yin and yang, and chi, ideas central to understanding the religious traditions found in East Asia.
|
Cult, Hope, and Love in 1 John 3
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Julian V. Hills, Marquette University
In 1 John 3:3 the author writes that “every one who thus hopes in him purifies himself as he is pure” (RSV). Scholarly opinion is surely right to take “him” and “he” as references to Jesus, and is more or less uniform that the word “purifies” transfers cultic language to the moral sphere. Hence the goal of this “purification” is ethical uprightness. Just as “in him there is no sin” (3:5), so “no one who abides in him sins” (3:6).
But despite a recent near consensus (Smalley, Strecker, Von Wahlde, et al.), it may be asked if this reading gives sufficient force to hagnizein, a term that had a long association with cultic activity both Jewish and pagan; and especially to its appearance with the reflexive pronoun as direct object: “purifies himself.” Some translations, and remarks drawn from various commentaries, suggest that translators and commentators can be rather nervous at the prospect of the Christian believer engaging in self-purification of any sort other than the avoidance of sin. A reduction of the concept to the moral plane is therefore seemingly welcome — so that it is routinely asserted that the only other occurrence of the verb in the Johannine writings, in John 11:55 and again with the reflexive pronoun, bears a quite different sense: the Jews “purifying themselves” for Passover.
With reference to Jewish, pagan, and later Christian writers I wish argue that for the Johannine writer hagnizein has not been emptied of its connection with cultic performance, and is not an isolated metaphor. It is instead a clue to a wider conceptual framework — theological, but also liturgical — in light of which the Johannine soteriological and communal vision may be more fully understood.
|
Open Educational Resources and Empirical Studies on Cost, Access, and Quality
Program Unit: Global Education and Research Technology
John Hilton III, Brigham Young University
Proponents of Open Educational Resources (OER) have articulated that OER can broaden learners’ access to educational materials. The promise of OER is that access can be increased while driving down costs for learners without compromising quality. The purpose of this presentation is to provide empirical data that support these claims drawn from a wide variety of studies and to illustrate implications that these findings have for fields related to biblical studies.
For example, studies regarding MIT’s OpenCourseWare have showed large numbers of international learners accessing materials that were previously available only to students physically present in Cambridge, MA, thus establishing increased access. I have recently been involved in an initiative across eight community colleges to utilize OER in a variety of courses. These efforts have resulted in students saving several million dollars in textbook costs, illustrating the significant cost savings that can take place as a result of OER.
Ultimately the key question is the extent to which OER can be considered to be of the same quality as proprietary learning materials. I will synthesize research studies done by myself and others that indicate that the vast majority of both professors and students who have utilized OER perceive them to be of the same quality as traditional resources. Moreover, a series of studies have found that students enrolled in courses that utilize OER achieve the same learning outcomes as those utilizing more costly learning materials.
I will also connect this research with the possibilities and promises of religious studies fields more fully utilizing OER. For example, much of the most complete teacher and student OER currently available are for very high-enrolling courses, such as “College Algebra” or “Introduction to Psychology.” I will discuss currently-available OER in fields related to biblical studies and also describe processes that could take place in order to create more complete OER in frequently-taught religious studies courses, such as “World Religions.”
|
Plutarch and the New Testament: History, Challenges, and Perspectives
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Rainer Hirsch-Luipold, Universität Bern - Université de Berne
Since the groundbreaking project on "Plutarch’s Writings and Early Christian Literature" initiated by H.D. Betz 40 years ago, the discussion on the use of "parallels" to the New Testament has changed considerably. While efforts to bridge the "Hellenism-Judaism" divide have been made, studies on Hellenistic and early imperial philosophy led to renewed reflection on the validity of the "religion-philosophy" divide. Since the publication of Athanassiadi and Frede’s volume of collected essays in 1999, a fervent dispute about the existence of a "Pagan monotheism" has emerged. Plutarch, the Platonist philosopher and priest of Apollo at Delphi, is a central figure in all these discussions. He seems to be particularly close to the more philosophical writings of the New Testament in many respects (genre, ethics, figurative language, theology, views on women, love, marriage etc.). Already his enormous reception history within Christianity signals that this author was thought to be more than a mere parallel – he appeared at times as a kind of a pagan Greek "Church father," similar to Seneca in the Latin West. Since the 1970s, the study of Plutarch’s voluminous works has boomed with major developments in the analysis of his literary and philosophical technique as well as of his hermeneutics of religious traditions and the importance of theological reflections for Plutarch's philosophical mind-set. After a short retrospect, this paper will point to some challenging methodological issues when reading Plutarch in the context of New Testament studies. Further, it will present Plutarch as a deeply religious philosopher and identify areas of special promise for comparison with the New Testament and conclude with some reflections on ways ahead.
|
The Transforming Leader: The Characterization of Jesus as Leader in Matthew’s Call Narratives and Its Implications for Pastoral Leadership Today
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Daniel Hjort, Lund University
The first part of this paper discusses how Jesus is presented as a leader in the call narratives in the Gospel of Matthew (4.18–22). By making use of a biographical-narrative reading of Matthew, which takes the biographical genre seriously and pays attention to the narrative development of the story, and modern understanding of leadership, mainly by making use of transformational leadership theories, it is possible to shed light on the presentation of Jesus as a good leader in this passage. The calling narratives clearly emphasize the leadership role of Jesus. Contrary to the view of many scholars these narratives do not emphasize the authority of Jesus, but his attraction as leader. Jesus is unmistakably presented as a role model for his followers, who are to imitate him. The author also portrays Jesus as an empowering leader who develops his followers into leaders.
In the second part of the paper the relevance of the findings from the Gospel of Matthew for pastoral leadership today is outlined. The portrait of Jesus in the Gospel of Matthew as the good leader and the model for his disciples also encourages us to see Jesus as a model for leadership. The calling narratives in Matthew thus help pastors today to see essential characteristics in pastoral leadership. Today’s pastors are surrounded by a multitude of opinions about how they should lead and what it means to be a Christian leader. Matthew’s portrait of Jesus suggests that two aspects are central in pastoral leadership. The pastor is supposed to lead the people by being a model and thus showing with his life how a Christian life is to be lived. Pastoral leadership also needs to be empowering leadership and the leader has to focus on developing followers to become leaders themselves.
|
Home-Building in Christian Worship: A Discourse Analysis of 1 Cor 14:20–25 in Light of the Domestic Cultic Practice in Roman Corinth
Program Unit: Speech and Talk in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Sin-pan Daniel Ho, Lutheran Theological Seminary, Hong Kong
1 Corinthians 14:21 is a well-known interpretation crux, for the changed cited scripture and Paul’s own interpretation in 14:21-22 seem to be contradictory to the ensuing evaluation of tongues and prophecy in 14:23-25. Some scholars interpret the term “sign” in 14:22 negatively as “judgment sign” and translate “mad” in 14:23 positively as “inspired” in order to make Paul’s discourse more consistent between 14:21-22 and 14:23-25. Yet, the inconsistency is still retained.
In this paper, it is argued that the key for understanding Paul’s rhetoric lies in the domestic cultic practice of Roman Corinthians. Paul’s intended change of the quoted Law and the echoes of the former domestic idol worship of the first audience point to the same direction: public speech in Christian worship should create a space being open and welcoming to outsiders, just like the participation of guests in your domestic worship ritual. By applying rhetorical and social identity theory regarding norm-breaking discourse, it is argued that Paul’s mutated Jesus Shema in 1 Cor. 8:6 and modified cited scripture in 14:22 serve similar purpose of differentiating and defining Christian worship space from Jewish and pagan domestic religious practice. 14:26-33 further applies the principles stated in 14:20-25 to concrete church order. Under this new interpretation, Paul’s opposing evaluations of tongues / strange languages and prophesy in Christian worship ritual in 14:22-25 will be explored. As a result, the logic of Paul becomes more apparent.
|
Joy in Suffering: 1 Peter and Emotional Possibility
Program Unit: Bible and Emotion
Katherine Hockey, University of Durham
This paper takes as its starting point the work of scholars such as James Averill and Catherine Lutz who assert that emotions are socially constructed and culturally defined. Their position has to call into question any assumption that modern western readers will immediately understand the emotions present in ancient texts in the same way that the first audience did. Yet, this seems to be so often the approach concerning emotion: an approach which ignores the historical, cultural and social context out of which these emotion terms and their related conceptual fields have come. This paper will seek to address this problem with regard to the emotion of joy in 1 Peter. With help from both contemporary Greco-Roman philosophical discussion, particularly Stoicism, and from Jewish ideas revealed in the LXX, it will situate words such as chara, chairo and agalliao in the emotional landscape of the time in order to discover their particular nuances and the range of emotional experience they can cover. In doing so, specific qualities of these emotion terms will be highlighted, such as their common objects, assumed temporal qualities, inherent value judgements and associated psychological states. These findings will help to add to the debate about detailed grammatical ambiguities in 1 Peter and will also shed light on larger scale issues such as cosmic ordering and the making of meaning. This will finally enable us to approach the difficult paradox found in 1 Peter of how, in light of the Christ event, an author can advocate or even expect joy in suffering, something that would have been impossible for his Stoic contemporaries; and whether a modern western audience, because of its own cultural understanding of emotion, has misread this expectation. A more culturally sensitive reading will show how this emotional paradox can be an emotional possibility.
|
Delivering the Qur’an: Metaphors of Qur’anic Maternality and Natality
Program Unit: Linguistic, Literary, and Thematic Perspectives on the Qur’anic Corpus (IQSA)
Thomas Hoffmann, Københavns Universitet
Studies on the self-referentiality of the Qur’an have proliferated in the past decade (inter alia Boisliveau 2014; Hoffmann 2006; Madigan 2006, Wild 2006). This paper pursues this trend by focusing on the prominent self-referential metaphor on ‘mother of the book’, ummu al-kitab (3:7; 13:39; 43:4) and the genesis of Qur’anic revelations. Given the patriarchal origins and discourse of the Qur’an it is noteworthy that this crucial metaphor draws on such a feminine and maternal lexeme. Furthermore, the maternal metaphor seems to be associated with natality and birth pangs, a topic already disseminated in near-eastern and Biblical texts (Bergmann 2008). These observations open for an approach that combines philology with metaphor theory (esp. conceptual metaphor theory á la Lakoff & co. 1980, 1989) and streaks of embodiment-theory and feminist reading and (cf. Gibbs 2006; DuBois 1988; Lybarger 2000).
The hypothesis is thus that the Qur’anic notions of self-referentiality and revelation are beholden to a maternal-natal stratum. Subsequently, it will be argued that this maternal-natal stratum provides a felicitous means to articulate otherwise highly abstract notions of revelatory pre-existence and divine omniscience (Hoffmann 2014). This hypothesis could also be interpreted as a deconstruction of the Qur’anic patriarchal – in the vein of some contemporary emancipatory Muslim feminist readers – and as a queering of the Qur’an’s gendered discourse and its predominant masculine God-metaphors. Despite the promising theological perspectives these trajectories bode for feminist tafsir, this paper will argue that the metaphors of Qur’anic maternality/ natality must ultimately be construed as metaphors that were framed and mastered by a patriarchal textual voice.
Selected bibliography
Bergmann, Claudia. Childbirth as a Metaphor for Crisis. Evidence from the Ancient Near East, the Hebrew Bible, and 1QH XI, 1-18. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter, 2008.
Boisliveau, Anne-Sylvie. Le Coran par lui-même. Vocabulaire et argumentation du discours coranique autoréférentiel. Leiden: Brill, 2014.
DuBois, Page. Sowing the Body. Psychoanalysis and Ancient Representations of Women. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1988.
Gibbs, Raymond W. Embodiment and Cognitive Science. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006.
1Hoffmann, Thomas. “”Den finds i Skriftens Moder her hos os.” Om Koranen og præeksistensens alma mater”, Kristian Mejrup et al. (eds.), Præeksistens. Forum for Bibelsk Eksegese 18. København: Museum Tusculanum Press, 2014, 95-114.
2Hoffmann, Thomas. “Agonistic Poetics in the Qur’ân: Self-referentialities, Refutations, and the Development of a Qur’ânic Self”, Stefan Wild (ed.), Self-Referentiality in the Qur’ân. Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz Verlag, 2006.
Lakoff, George & Mark Johnson. Metaphors We live By. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1980.
Lakoff, George & Mark Turner. More than Cool Reason. A Field Guide to Poetic Metaphor. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1989.
Lybarger, Loren D. “Gender and Prophetic Authority in the Qur’ânic Story of Maryam: A Literary Approach”, The Journal of Religion, Vol. 80, No. 2, 2000, pp. 240-270.
Madigan, Daniel A. The Qur’ân’s Self-Image. Writing and Authority in Islam’s Scripture. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2001.
Wild, Stefan (ed.). Self-Referentiality in the Qur’ân. Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz Verlag, 2006.
|
Would Philo Have Recognized Qumran Musar as Paideia?
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Karina Martin Hogan, Fordham University
Nearly every occurrence of musar in Proverbs is translated with paideia or an etymologically related term in the Septuagint. At least for the Septuagint translator of Proverbs, therefore, the two terms were functionally equivalent. The first section of this paper examines the concept of musar in Proverbs and paideia in LXX Proverbs to interrogate this equivalency. The second section looks at the handful of occurrences of musar in Qumran wisdom texts to determine how close their usage of the term is to that of Proverbs. Finally, the paper turns to Philo’s understanding of paideia, especially in De Congressu Eruditionis Gratia, to determine whether it has anything in common with the understanding of musar at Qumran. It concludes with some reflections on the relative importance of Proverbs to the authors of the Qumran wisdom texts and to Philo.
|
Great Is the Mystery of Piety: Contesting Discourses on Piety in Plutarch, Philo, and 1 Timothy
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
T. Christopher Hoklotubbe, Harvard Divinity School
What did it mean for early Christians to claim to be “pious,” let alone to describe their piety as a “mystery”? 1 Timothy 3:16 makes such claims, and in doing so, seeks to differentiate itself within a marketplace of competing notions about the true nature of the divine. While commentators have suggested that 1 Timothy’s use of piety was influenced by contemporaneous Hellenistic Jewish literature as Fourth Maccabees, I contend that this text is better illuminated when read alongside of a broader philosophical discourse on piety that framed claims to knowledge about the divine with mystery terminology. Within this predominately elite discourse, philosophers marshaled the language of piety and mystery in order legitimate and differentiate their claims about the nature of the divine from competing religious experts and the superstitious masses. As representative case studies of this philosophical discourse on piety, we will examine the works of both Plutarch and Philo of Alexandria. While the author of 1 Timothy might not be sociologically categorized among such elite or wealthy intellectuals, this does not preclude the author from participating within this elite, philosophical discourse nor from re-describing “piety” and “mystery” toward his own social and political ends. 1 Timothy thus represents a re-appropriation of an elite discourse used to distinguish its conception of the divine from the non-elite by a non-elite. As a helpful conceptual tool for describing 1 Timothy’s conscription of such Hellenistic terminology, along with its possible rhetorical effects within its socio-political sphere, I employ Pierre Bourdieu’s concept of “symbolic capital.” I argue that 1 Timothy trades upon the positive cultural value ascribed to the virtue of piety and mystery terminology in its own attempt to both legitimate its authority over against competing religious experts and provide an apologetic appeal to the surrounding society.
|
Buyers and Borrowers: Rural Demand for Goods and Services in Roman Italy
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
David Hollander, Iowa State University
Roman farmers in late Republican and early Imperial Italy needed many goods and services that they either could not make for themselves or could produce only with great difficulty. This paper examines these necessities which are divided into three categories: ‘start-up’ supplies (i.e., materials and expertise necessary to establish a farm such as building supplies, iron tools, and processing equipment), seasonal supplies (e.g., storage containers and additional labor), and maintenance supplies (e.g., the services of a blacksmith or doctor). While farmers would have to resort to markets for many of these goods and services, they could acquire some of them through loans, in kind exchanges, and partnerships.
|
RPC 1651 and the Provenance of Philippians
Program Unit: Polis and Ekklesia: Investigations of Urban Christianity
Paul Holloway, Sewanee: The University of the South
This study will ask whether the re-dating of the small bronze coin RPC (= Roman Provincial Coinage [London and Paris, 1998]) 1651 (front: VIC AUG; back COHOR PRAE PHIL) to the reign of Claudius or Nero has any implications for the provenance of Philippians.
|
Vindication or Conversion? The Meaning and Implications of “Glorify God on the Day of Visitation” in 1 Pet 2:12
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Douglas Holm, Trinity College/University of Bristol
Over the last twenty years, a renewed topic of scholarly attention in 1 Peter has been the transformative influence of the community’s good deeds and conduct upon those living around them. As a “hinge” between the Christians’ responsibility to declare God’s “mighty acts” and the ensuing paraenesis, 1 Peter 2:11-12 is key for understanding this critical function of the readers’ behavior and lifestyle. One of the interpretive debates surrounding 1 Peter 2:11-12 revolves around whether “glorify God on the day of visitation” by the Christians’ accusers signifies the vindication of the believers at a time of judgment or the conversion of their accusers. Contrary to those who argue that this phrase only refers to the vindication of the readers (e.g., Balch), this paper argues that “glorify God on the day of visitation” refers to the conversion of Gentile accusers as a result of observing the Christians’ good works and conduct. To support the thesis, this study will address a lacuna in the literature by presenting the findings of a comprehensive survey of “glorify God” and related terms in the LXX and Second Temple Jewish writings that might inform the usage in 1 Peter. Overwhelmingly, Gentiles who “glorify God” are either already aligned with God and his people or they are in the process of converting. Similar usage in New Testament writings (Gospels, Pauline Epistles, Revelation) further confirms this interpretation. An important implication of these findings is that 1 Peter 2:11-12 serves as an interpretive lens for appraising other instances of the prominent motif of good works for the purpose of witness (e.g., 1 Pet 3:1-2, 15-16).
|
The Yahwistic Psalms in Papyrus Amherst 63
Program Unit: Israelite Religion in Its Ancient Context
Tawny Holm, Pennsylvania State University
The unique Papyrus Amherst 63 from Upper Egypt contains three Yahwistic psalms in columns xii-xiii. The papyrus as a whole was written in Aramaic but using a Demotic script that paleographically dates to the Early Hellenistic period. These Yahwistic psalms were placed at a pivotal point in the liturgical portion of the 23-column text. However, only one of them has received much attention (xii 11-19), because it closely resembles the biblical Psalm 20. P. Amherst 63 is likely the product of a single, yet quite diverse, Aramean or Aramaic-speaking community that included a number of Judeans and Samaritans, amongst other groups who came to Egypt from the Syro-Mesopotamian region and farther east. Thus, these three Yahwistic psalms will be studied within the religious and social context of the production of P. Amherst 63. This paper stems from the author's work on a forthcoming volume on Early Aramaic Literature for the SBL series "Writings from the Ancient World."
|
(Religious) Language and the Decentering Process: McNamara and De Sublimitate on the Ecstatic Effect of Language
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Christopher T. Holmes, Emory University
This paper outlines how the perspective of De Sublimitate concerning the effect of great literature resembles ancient and modern notions of religious experience. To demonstrate this similarity, the paper draws on McNamara's concept of the decentering process in religious experience. This concept of the decentering process serves as a framework for understanding how an encounter with writing that the author deems to be hupsos ("sublime" or "elevated") has similar decentering effects. The paper engages, but also moves slightly beyond, McNamara's understanding of the role of language in the decentering process. The first part of the paper provides an overview of McNamara's concept of decentering. In particular, it highlights four aspects of the decentering process: (1) the loss of agency; (2) the experience of ecstasy; (3) the role of the emotions; (4) and the cognitive changes that occur during and after the process. The second part of the paper demonstrates the presence of similar ideas in De Sublimitate's discussion of the effects of encountering literature that is characterized as hupsos. The concluding section considers how this reading of De Sublimitate aids in an understanding of the relationship between religious texts and religious experience, drawing a connection with Celia Deutsch's concept of "text work" as religious experience.
|
‘Canonical’ Gospels in the Second Century?
Program Unit: Texts and Traditions in the Second Century
Michael Holmes, Bethel University (Minnesota)
Discussions of the formation of the four-gospel canon (irrespective of how they define “canon”) virtually always approach the topic teleologically, in terms of how the process concluded in the 4th/5th centuries (i.e., looking back at the process in light of its outcome). Approaching the matter protologically, however—from the 1st century forward—and in light of the concurrent debate about the canon of the LXX suggests that the 2nd century argument about “which gospel(s)?” was an aspect of a larger debate about authority and hermeneutics, a debate whose outcome was, at the end of the 2nd century, by no means certain or predictable.
|
Trauma and Traumatization in Individual and Collective Dimensions: Insights from Biblical Studies and Beyond
Program Unit: Biblical Literature and the Hermeneutics of Trauma
Else Holt, Aarhus Universitet
The papers collected in this volume were presented at a conference on trauma studies and biblical literature that took place in Denmark at Aarhus University in June, 2012. Two of the editors of the volume will discuss methodological issues taken up in the volume.
|
Orality, Textuality, and Mesopotamian Law
Program Unit: Orality, Textuality, and the Formation of the Hebrew Bible
Shalom E. Holtz, Yeshiva University
Mesopotamian law provides a rich fund of data for analyzing questions of orality, textuality, power and authority. One can draw not only on the well-known law collections, such as Hammurabi's "Code," but also on the myriads of cuneiform documents of legal practice from throughout the Fertile Crescent. Both types of texts, even when viewed on their own, rather than as a basis for comparison with the Hebrew Bible, shed important light on the questions at hand. The law collections stand precisely at the intersection between writing, royal authority and scribal tradition. Documents of practice attest to the immediate interplay between scribal writing conventions and legal actions that were probably carried out orally.
Biblical legal traditions find important analogues to the Assyriological material at almost every turn. The identification of legal performative utterances in Hebrew, often embedded in ostensibly non-legal written genres, can rely on similar Akkadian utterances in overtly legal contexts. The incorporation of legal materials in prayers and prophecies suggests an interesting interplay between law and literature, written or oral. The attestation of Akkadian formulations in post-biblical Aramaic documents raises interesting questions of transmission. Similarly, and more generally, situating biblical law within the broader Near Eastern legal continuum requires addressing how this very continuum came to be. Orality and textuality are central to understanding this core topic.
|
Contextualizing Ritual Contamination: Donatist and Transmarine Communities on the Validity of Heretical Rites
Program Unit: Contextualizing North African Christianity
Jesse Hoover, Baylor University
For Augustine of Hippo, the ecclesiology of his Donatist opponents was absurd. The heretical movement (in Augustine’s portrayal) claimed that the true church was defined by its pure observance of the divine commandments rather than its worldwide communion, that congregations could be dragged into ecclesiastical impurity merely by maintaining ties with traditor bishops, that anyone who came out of such deficient communions and joined the true church needed to be “rebaptized” – Trinitarian or not, their original sacrament was invalid.
It has long been demonstrated that the bishop of Hippo overstates his case by a considerable margin. In spite of himself, Augustine has done modern researchers a favor by transmitting snippets of Donatist writings that tell a different story, an ecclesiology more nuanced than Augustine would like to admit. We know, for instance, that Donatists did not simplistically view congregational contamination as a mechanistic corollary of a fallen hierarchy: when Petilian angrily accuses Augustine of omitting the word “knowingly” from the Donatist leader’s phrase “He who has knowingly received faith from the faithless receives not faith, but guilt” (C. Litt. Petil. 3.22.26), he is not being pedantic.
In this presentation, I would like to extend the existing conversation by contextualizing Donatist perceptions of ritual contamination within the broader ecclesiastical milieu in which they are set. I will argue that in many ways, Donatist ecclesiology represents more an intensification of existing ecclesial presuppositions than a rejection of them. Augustine is certainly not alone in his doctrine of the church – but his is not the only theology in play. Donatist beliefs about the essential nature of the church, the possibility of ritual contamination, and, perhaps unexpectedly, even the necessity of rebaptism are mirrored to a certain extent within the transmarine provinces the dissident communion allegedly defied.
|
The Song of Songs: A Hebrew “Counterweight” to Hellenistic Drama?
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Matthias Hopf, Augustana-Hochschule
The Song of Songs is a drama! At least that was what famous exegetes like Delitzsch, Ewald and Ginsburg were convinced of in the 19th century. Yet, since the middle of the 20th century the Song has commonly been held not to be dramatic at all. However, as the concept of “drama” in literary studies has evolved in the past decades, it is questionable if this verdict of “undramatic” can be upheld. So, it seems worthwhile to take a new look at the “drama theory”, taking into account these new literary insights.
One has to bear in mind that the issue whether the Song of Songs can be called a drama or not is not a mere question of definition. For, as this book in its canonical form is increasingly being dated to Hellenistic times, we can ask if the book gained its importance precisely out of this confrontation with Hellenism. It actually stands to reason that the canonization of the Song of Songs might be the result of a process of Jewish identity building. This process seems to stand in opposition to and at the same time in a high affinity with the predominant Hellenistic, Alexandrian culture.
But at the bottom of all this lies the question: Does the Song resemble a drama-text at all? Or even more elementary: Which ingredients are necessary to identify a text with a basic drama- or at least performance-orientated impetus? To answer this, criteria taken from contemporary literary studies will be presented and applied to the Song of Songs. This will lead to a differentiated look on the “drama theory” and to the basic conclusion that the Song matches all the necessary criteria of a drama-text. Therefore, it should be viewed as a very early example of Jewish interaction with Hellenistic theater.
|
Deuteronomistic History and the Latter-day Saints
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
Shon D. Hopkin, Brigham Young University
Since the inception of their religion in 1830 under Joseph Smith, Latter-day Saints have had a unique approach to the critical study of the Bible. The Book of Mormon proclaimed that the Bible had been affected by the hands of editors, and Smith consistently echoed this view, declaring in the church’s Eight Article of Faith that “We believe the Bible to be the word of God as far as it is translated [i.e. transmitted] correctly.” With this foundational view of the Bible, LDS have not been beholden to the viewpoints of biblical inerrancy that have impacted many strands of conservative Christianity. They openly regard the possibility of numerous textual emendations and the types of changes caused by a Deuteronomistic editing. LDS have often used this view of the Bible in a positivist manner to pursue strands of thought that are hinted at in the Bible as supporting their own unique Christian theology. This includes evidence that at one point Israelite religion may have included a view of deity with multiple divine figures, a grand council or pantheon in heaven, a female deity, and a father and son figure, all of which were carefully removed or altered by the Deuteronomist. Some LDS have delighted in books by such biblical scholars as Margaret Barker and William Dever.
This strand of thought is balanced by a conservative strand of LDS biblical thought. Although Joseph Smith believed the Bible had been altered by many hands over the centuries, he also believed that the basic presentation of the Bible message – Genesis through Revelation – was correct. The Book of Mormon and his Joseph Smith Translation of the Bible worked to restore the lost message of a divine council, of an early understanding of a father and son deity, but also saw God as working consistently throughout time to proclaim the gospel message in all ages. Thus the antediluvian prophets were seen as real figures who knew more about a future Messiah than the Bible portrays, who spoke with God, who wrote their messages in books likely recorded during their own lifetimes (such as Moses’s recording of Genesis) and who at least in some form experienced such things as a fall, a flood, and an exodus.
This paper will analyze these two foundational strands of LDS thought to show how Mormons have interacted over time with the view of a Deutereronomistic history, and will propose that this tension in LDS thought creates a fertile ground for both religious faith and intellectual discovery. Thought by church leaders and biblical scholars such as Joseph Fielding Smith, Bruce R. McConkie, and Robert J. Matthews (tending to the conservative side) will be presented, as will thought by John Widtsoe, J. Reuben Clark, B. H. Roberts, Philip Barlow, and Jeffrey Bradshaw who take into account such biblical scholarship as the Deuteronomistic History. Barlow’s scholarship on Mormons and the Bible will serve as a foundation for this paper.
|
Christian Apocrypha in Georgian on Jesus and Mary: Questions of Canonicity, Liturgical Usage, and Social Settings
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Cornelia Horn, Catholic University of America
This paper argues that the study of Christian apocryphal texts that are composed or transmitted in Georgian offers a formidable stage for exploring the intersections of questions of the relative canonicity, liturgical usage, and social settings of Christian writings on Jesus and Mary in the Caucasus. It contributes to the systematic study of Georgian apocrypha through revisiting the transmission and reception histories of the Georgian versions of the Infancy Gospel of Pseudo-Thomas and of the Protoevangelium of James. On the basis of a careful examination of one, heretofore neglected Georgian Monophysite apocryphal gospel in conjunction with other Georgian apocryphal texts, a more nuanced picture emerges of how the apocryphal lives of Mary and Jesus received their distinctive profiles in the Christian literature of the Caucasus. Significant factors that contributed to the shape of these profiles consisted in the reception of apocryphal writings in the ascetic milieu, the relative permeability of liturgical boundaries for apocryphal writings, as well as the rather prominent roles available to women in Christian Georgia.
|
Parallel Structures, Polemical Interpretations: An Intertextual Approach to Jesus’ Miracles in Jewish, Christian, and Islamic Normative and Interpretive Texts
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Cornelia B. Horn, Catholic University of America
The recognition and detailed exploration of parallel structures between thematically shared subsets of Jewish, Christian, and Islamic texts continues to be a promising and productive area of scholarship on interactions between the three monotheistic religions in late antique Arabia and Syria. This paper contributes to the study of the polemical and competitive dimensions of interactions between these religious traditions with one another. These are revealed through a comparative approach to variant interpretations of lists of Jesus’ miracles in the religious literatures on sacred texts in the late antique Aramaic-, Syriac-, and Arabic-speaking Near East. To achieve this goal, the paper pursues two dimensions. It studies closely the level of density with which thematic and structural parallels in accounts of Jesus’ miracles across religious borders speak to the likelihood of shared narrative traditions circulating in oral or written forms in and out of these three respective communities. On the other hand, the paper argues that the recognition of parallel structures that do not bespeak full identity is a powerful tool for discovering and appreciating the distinct differences in the interpretation, appropriation, and self-representation which the Jewish, Christian, and Islamic traditions reveal in their respective approaches to Jesus’ miracles.
|
Modern Hebrew and Biblical Hebrew: Reflections on Their Integration
Program Unit: Applied Linguistics for Biblical Languages
Aaron Hornkohl, University of Cambridge
Following a brief summary of personal experiences learning and teaching Hebrew (Classical and Modern), the speaker will outline, against the background of the history of Hebrew Language instruction at the University of Cambridge (UK), an explanation for the motivation behind the recent initiative within the University’s Faculty of Asian and Middle Eastern Studies to integrate more closely the teaching of Classical and Modern Hebrew. The focus will then shift to significant differences and affinities between the Standard (i.e., Classical) Biblical Hebrew verbal system and that of Modern Israeli Hebrew—including such differences as the disappearance from Modern Hebrew of the conversive tenses, the short and lengthened yiqtol forms, and the past imperfective yiqtol, and such similarities as the encoding of the actual and gnomic/habitual present, the prospective past, performatives, affirmative and negative volitionals, conditionals, and circumstantials/adverbials, not to mention the notion of semantic predictability within the verbal stem (binyan) system and pragmatic effects of shifts in constituent order.
The principal aim of the lecture is to persuade those Biblical Hebrew instructors apprehensive concerning the potentially negative effects of a Modern Hebrew education on students of Biblical Hebrew that, given the thoughtful and judicious integration of the two, the benefits of such an education far outweigh any possible harm. Not only does the living, vibrant, and ever-evolving Semitic tongue known as Modern Israeli Hebrew serve as something of a corrective to artificial and forced accounts of ancient grammar and facilitate access to medieval commentaries and modern Israeli scholarship, but the communicative-immersion approach typically adopted in Modern Hebrew instruction coupled with the innumerable affinities shared by Biblical and Modern Hebrew—especially in terms of the writing system, morphology, and lexicon, but also in the realm of syntax—make Modern Hebrew an excellent support for achieving fluency in Biblical Hebrew.
|
Performance and Identity in the Ancient World
Program Unit: Bible Translation
Richard Horsley, University of Massachusetts Boston
This paper, as part of the joint Bible Translation and Nida Institute session on Performance, Translation and Identity, will introduce the topic of Performance Criticism as a hermeneutical lens in Biblical studies, while touching on issues regarding identity of people groups in the ancient world. Performance of texts and the writing of texts for performance by the community and for the community clearly contributes to identity issues like authorship, community hermeneutics, pseudo-epigraphy, the presence of multiple traditions, and other matters relating to the collective identity, as well as the role of writing and the seminal role of orality in the forging of the identity of the larger illiterate people groups and the position of the literate elite.
|
Konstan, Griswold, and the Economy of Forgiveness
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Fred Horton, Wake Forest University
David Konstan in Before Forgiveness follows Charles Griswold in Forgiveness by defining what he terms a "paradigm of forgiveness," an emotional activity by which the victim of an offense seeks to diminish or eradicate the resentment and rage she has directed toward the offender because of the injury. Konstan correctly labels this paradigm "a clearly recognizable sense of in modern society"; and the thesis of Konstan's book is that classical antiquity lacked such a paradigm within its moral philosophy. Both Konstan and Griswold reject the forgiveness of debts as part of the paradigm of forgiveness and so stumble badly when encountering the biblical term nasi' and its Greek translation afiemi. Since remission of debts lacks essential elements of the paradigm, both Konstan and Griswold find it ambiguous and deficient to express forgiveness.
I hold that remission of debts in scripture is not metaphorical and in its New Testament form reflects Jewish apocalyptic ideas about the coming age as the tenth and last jubilee. Further, the idea that followers of Jesus should always forgive is not a matter of moral perfectionism but of eschatological expectation.
|
The Unity of the Twelve after Twenty-Five Years: Retrospect and Prospect
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Paul House, Samford University
The Unity of the Twelve After Twenty-five Years: Retrospect and Prospect
|
"To Share Your Bread with the Hungry": Justice or Charity?
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
Walter J. Houston, University of Manchester
Giving to the poor is often described both in modern advocacy and by preachers of the early church as justice, rather than charity. Arguably, this harks back to a biblical tradition that is older than that dominant since the Exile, in which sedaqah simply means ‘alms’ (eleemosune), and hesed ‘compassion’ (eleos). No text likely to be earlier than the 6th cent BCE urges the relief of hunger (etc.) as a duty; they rather reprove the active exploitation of the poor. Alongside this goes a tradition of state action to protect the poor (mishpat usedaqah). But the relief of hunger is urged or praised in post-587 works; and in post-canonical works becomes the main or exclusive expression of sedaqah: hence its change of meaning. (Several passages speak of people ‘eating at the table’ of a ruler or powerful person, i.e. subsisting at their expense. These official ‘meals’ are not examples of justice or even charity, but of patronage.) The change may be explained by the loss of state and community structures resulting from the invasions and the incorporation of Israel and Judah into world empires. Has justice thus been reduced to charity, or is charity actually justice? It is justice, but it is not all that justice requires. For its full implementation political structures are needed. Injustices accumulating in their absence can only be ameliorated by the personal exercise of justice/charity, sharing one’s bread with the hungry.
|
Boogie with the Bible: Movement as an Interpretive Lens for Mark 6:14–29 and Beyond
Program Unit: Islands, Islanders, and Scriptures
Melanie A. Howard, Princeton Theological Seminary
In studying the dance of the daughter of Herodias, F. Scott Spencer has asked, is it “a tap dance or lap dance? Shirley Temple or Charo?” (Dancing Girls, Loose Ladies, and Women of the Cloth: The Women in Jesus’ Life [New York: Continuum, 2004], 56). This paper answers Spencer’s question by considering the role of dance in first-century banquets in which viewing a dance for entertainment was not uncommon (e.g., Athenaeus, Deip. 4.129d, 4.130a; Lucian, Dial. Meret. 15). The study of this context serves as a backdrop for the role of the dance in Mark 6:14-29. My thesis is that the girl’s dance functions not simply as entertainment, but as a means of persuasion. The daughter of Herodias communicates not only through the use of verbal rhetorical devices (6:24-25), but also through the use of her body (6:22).
The paper closes with autobiographical reflections on the use of dance in interpreting not only Mark 6:14-29, but also other passages in Mark where discipleship itself develops “on the way” (8:27; 9:33; 10:32; 10:52) and in other biblical texts where the movement of bodies figures centrally. I consider the use of movement and dance as pedagogical tools for teaching biblical studies, aiding students in the translation of texts into modern contexts. The paper concludes by suggesting that just as the speech of Herodias’s daughter supplemented her dance, the enterprise of biblical criticism can also be complemented by the bodily translation of texts.
|
“I Read the Chapter, but I Didn’t Understand It”: Biblical Studies and Reading for Comprehension
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
David B. Howell, Ferrum College
Reading is the primary means for understanding for college students, and yet one recent study found that just less than half of high school graduates have the reading skills that college-level work requires (Kuh, Kinzie, Shuh, 2005). How often have we heard from students that “I read the assignment, but I didn’t understand it”? Such a statement reflects a conceptualization of the reading process which separates reading from comprehension and understanding. In this paper, I will explore strategies in teaching that encourage/require students to engage the content of their reading assignments. I will briefly review research on the difference attitudes between good and low performing readers (capable college readers see reading as an interactive process for comprehending the message of the author vs. poor readers who are more passive and focus on vocabulary rather than concepts). Moreover, as disciplinary experts we have organizational skills and perspectives to structure what we read in ways that novice learners do not. Research about the way readers organize knowledge can thus also contribute to constructing assignments that help students read and understand. Even if they are not experts, students come to the reading assignments with prior knowledge which can help or hinder the learning process. Thinking about ways that appropriate background or prior knowledge can be activated may also be helpful in constructing assignments. Applications of these known principles of learning are then presented in assignments drawn from a variety of my biblical classes that ask students to engage the reading. Participants in the session will be invited to apply these strategies in designing assignments for their courses as well at the end of the presentation.
|
Prophetic Speech and Divine Response
Program Unit: Homiletics and Biblical Studies
J. Dwayne Howell, Campbellsville University
The role of the prophet in the Old Testament is often seen as a spokesperson for God to the people. The Hebrew, nabi, finds its in meaning in "one who calls." A modern day image of the prophet as prognosticator is inappropriate for the prophets of the Old Testament. While the prophetic word can be seen as important for today, it must first be understood in its historical context. The prophet is an observer of the culture and seeks to bring a word from God for the given situation. It is then better to say that the prophets spoke a timely message with a timeless meaning.
While the prophets speak a message from God, they also speak directly to God. A cursory review of the Old Testament provides several examples: The questioning of one’s call; voicing laments; and offering intercession. These interchanges between the prophets and God provide the listener/reader with an example of dialogue. Dialogue occurs when at least two carry on a conversation. Most notable of the dialogues in scriptures are those found in the book of Job between God and Hasatan, Job and his friends, and Job and God As the Book of Job teaches us, conversations may open the path to understanding but they do not guarantee understanding. Seeking the divine will is often the reason for the dialogues between the prophets and God. The purpose of the paper is to provide an overview of these prophetic/divine dialogues and their implications for preaching today. Moses is used as the paradigm prophet, but other prophets are included in the discussion.
|
Lucian's Hermotimus: A Fictive Dialogue with Marcus Aurelius
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Justin Howell, University of Chicago
In the Hermotimus, Lucian’s fictive dialogue with Marcus about how to present himself as a ruler suggests that Lucian is neither an enemy nor a sycophant of the emperor, but rather a person who attempts through satire to offer indirect yet constructive criticism for the benefit of the Empire. Scholars purporting that Lucian was antagonistic toward Rome and those suggesting he sought an audience with the emperors merely to flatter them must take into account that his longest dialogue is a subtle yet forceful charge, which displays his stance as a member of the Empire invested in its governing capacities.
|
A Day in the Life of an Ancient Farm Worker
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Llewellyn Howes, University of Johannesburg
As part of the first project of this program unit, the current paper investigates the daily life of ancient farm workers in the Greco-Roman world. The purpose is to plot the position of these farm workers on the socio-economic hierarchy of the ancient world. In the process, farm workers are distinguished from peasants, on the one hand, and slaves, on the other. Attention is specifically paid to aspects that influence socio-economic status, such as job security, typical duties, duration of "employment", forms of sustenance, patron-client relations, and methods of "remuneration". Care is taken to distinguish within the class of farm workers between day-labourers and more permanent workers.
|
Advice for Farm Workers: A Radical Rereading of the So-Called Mission Discourse
Program Unit: Q
Llewellyn Howes, University of Johannesburg
Ever since the “discovery” of the Sayings Gospel Q, the mission discourse has been read as a piece of instruction for missionaries. This tradition is so well-established that the various titles of the passage in Q 10:2-16 have all included the word “mission”. Theissen’s popular theory that the first followers of Jesus were itinerant radicals functioned to cement this text as a mission charge. The passage continues to be read as an instruction for missionaries even though it is generally accepted that the introductions (in Matthew 10:5-6 and Luke 10:1) were added by the evangelists, and even though the Critical Edition of Q reconstructs this text without those introductions. The words “mission” and “missionary” do not even appear in the Q text as it has been reconstructed by the International Q Project. It seems obvious that all past and present interpretations of Q 10:2-16 have been influenced by the meaning of this text in Matthew and Luke. This paper argues that the so-called mission discourse is not an instruction for missionaries at all, but rather a piece of wisdom that dispenses advice for farm workers. This is done by analysing each verse of Q 10:2-16 in turn, indicating, on the one hand, that it cannot be aimed at missionaries, and exposing, on the other, the sapiential advice it had for farm workers.
|
Writing the Qur'an in Stone: Use of the Muslim Scripture in Early Arabic Inscriptions
Program Unit: The Qur’an: Manuscripts and Textual Criticism (IQSA)
Robert Hoyland, Oriental Institute, Oxford
Arabic inscriptions from the early Islamic period draw upon or allude to the Qur'an in a number of different ways. This is most obvious in their choice of vocabulary; for example, the most common wishes of these texts are to ask for forgiveness (ghfr), seek compassion (rhm), to make a declaration of faith ('mn), to bear witness (shhd), to enter paradise (jnn) and to be spared punishment ('dhb), each of these a prominent theme a nd root in the Qur'an. From the 70s AH onwards the use of the Qur'an in inscriptions becomes more inventive, beginning with the famous Dome of the Rock text (72/691), which subtly adapts the Qur'anic text. Much has been made of these adaptations of / deviations from the standard wording of the Qur'an, often regarded as confirmation that the latter had not yet stabilized. But though it cannot be excluded that that it reflects the fact that different versions of the Qur'an circulated in early times, there are many other possible, and arguably more plausible, explanations for such divergences, such as a need for clarification and slight lapses / intrusions from other forms of Arabic (such as the spoken, the administrative, the literary, etc) by those who were working from memory. As regards graffiti, where we often find a collage of phrases assembled from different verses of the Qur'an, it is evident that creative citation and handling of the Qur'an was acceptable. This paper will explore and elucidate this point and will also pay attention to the question of what purposes were served by citing the Qur'an in inscriptions (statement of identity/allegiance, public demonstration of status and piety, etc.), especially in the case of graffiti, which sometimes consisted of nothing more than a verse of the Qur'an and the name of the writer or commissioner of the text.
|
John's Apocalypse and Queer Contextual Interpretation
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Lynn Huber, Elon University
John’s Apocalypse is a text whose identity has historically been interrogated and challenged. In this way, the book that sits at the edge of the Christian canon has a contested and, arguably, queer existence. As early as the fourth century, interpreters debated whether it could be described as a “revelation,” since it seemed covered by a veil of obscurity (Eusebius, Hist. eccl. 3.25). Today, interpreters within mainline Christian communities in the US seemingly find Revelation, especially given its popular revisions in evangelical pulp novels, unpalatable and strange. Some modern biblical scholars and theologians, including Tina Pippin and J. Michael Clark who co-authored the entry on Revelation in the Queer Bible Commentary (ed. Deryn Guest, et. al.; SCM Press, 2006), characterize the text as unredeemable on account of its penchant for violence and dualistic thinking, along with its apparent valorization of celibacy. Yet for other scholars, such as Stephen D. Moore and Christopher A. Frilingos, the Apocalypse has proven to be a rich site for engaging queer questions, especially related to the gendering of the Divine. Moreover, many of the text’s rhetorical textures, including its interest in unveiling that which is hidden, its deployment of imagery that evokes the critique of camp and drag performance and its rejection of traditional and productive temporalities, might ring familiar to those with an ear for queer discourses. In fact, the text has inspired queer artists, including Keith Haring and David Lachepelle, who redeploy Revelation’s images of destruction and its warnings against commodification in their work. In light of this and in conversation with queer theorists such as Elizabeth Freeman and Lee Edelmen, this paper outlines some of the ways that John’s Apocalypse invites or, perhaps, tempts queer interpreters to engage and even appropriate its imagery and patterns of thought. How and why has the Apocalypse been a productive source for the queer imaginary? Despite the fact that queer artists have been inspired by John's Apocalypse, and despite the turn to issues of temporality and futurity in recent queer theory texts, biblical texts are still absent from most queer theory discourses. Thus, attention to the ways in which Revelation intersects with and contributes to queer discourses might illuminate aspects of these theoretical conversations as well. Finally, by attending to the cautions of those who highlight Revelation’s history of oppressive reiterations and potentially destructive discourses, Pippin and Clark as well as Catherine Keller, an important distinction between LGBT liberation readings of the text and specifically queer contextual interpretation is drawn.
|
Remembering the Betulah: Judges 11:29–40 and Israelite Funerary Practices
Program Unit: Joshua-Judges
Henry M. Huberty, Emory University
The oft-discussed story of the Israelite judge Jephthah, recounted in Judges 11, ends by mentioning a practice carried out every year by the young women of Israel in remembrance of Jephthah’s daughter, sacrificed by her father in fulfillment of his vow to Yahweh. The text does not otherwise elaborate on the nature of the practice, which has led to considerable speculation among scholars as to what the practice constituted; suggestions have included lamentation rites, coming-of-age or life cycle rituals, or ceremonies to prepare young girls for marriage. This essay proposes an alternative interpretation: that the practice described in Judges 11 is a funerary rite carried out for Jephthah’s daughter. Guided by Hanan Brichto’s synthesis of the practices of Israelite burials and the ideologies of family continuity reflected in the biblical text, I examine biblical and archaeological evidence for ancient Israelite offerings to the dead, especially food and drink offerings made by family members to ancestors. I further argue that the text of Judges 11:29–40 uses the term _betulah_ to emphasize the childlessness of Jephthah’s daughter, rather than, as is commonly argued, her virginity _per se_. Taking all of this into account, Judges 11:40 can be understood as referring to a funerary rite in which the Israelite women remember and make offerings for Jephthah’s daughter--functioning, in effect, in the place of the children she was never able to have.
This paper is intended for session (1), the “open session.” Please note that although this is not my first SBL paper presentation, the essay is complete, and I am happy to forward it to the selection committee at their request.
|
Was the Author a Literary Polymath? Egyptian and Neo-Assyrian Imagery in First Isaiah
Program Unit: Egyptology and Ancient Israel
John Huddlestun, College of Charleston
The earlier chapters of the book of Isaiah have received renewed attention over the past three decades from biblical and scholars and Assyriologists interested in the writer’s portrayal of the Neo-Assyrian empire, and especially the king, from the point of view of an outsider. At issue is the biblical author’s knowledge of all things Assyrian, how he might have obtained that knowledge, and the ways in which he makes use of it, for example, in his depiction of the Assyrian king in oracles where that figure speaks. Assyriological studies of First Isaiah have identified a variety of images that appear to draw on Neo-Assyrian royal idiom, where the biblical writer selects, adapts, alters or inverts Neo-Assyrian literary motifs to his advantage as part of his larger critique of the Neo-Assyrian empire. While not on the same scale as above with Neo-Assyria and Isaiah, where the evidence is much more plentiful, biblical scholars and Egyptologists have also in recent decades focused more attention on First Isaiah (mainly the oracles against Egypt in chapters 18-20, but also 30-31). Given the now sizable number of persuasive studies of Neo-Assyrian influence, one is justified in asking what type of influence might be detected in Isaiah’s oracles relating to Egypt? Is it of the same type or scale? Did the biblical author employ the same procedure in descriptions of Egypt and its king? Was the author conversant with both Egyptian and Assyrian literary traditions? Unlike the case with Assyrians in Judah in the latter half of the eight century, we possess very few Egyptian texts relating to action in the Levant. Nevertheless, a number of scholars have argued for Egyptian influence, assuming some (and at times, a great deal of) knowledge of Egyptian texts and religious practices. To that end, a brief consideration of a handful of studies – dealing with different genres of Egyptian material – provides some comparative perspective vis-à-vis proposed Neo-Assyrian influence. By way of conclusion, I suggest that, while the biblical author(s) did possess some knowledge of Egypt, when compared with that demonstrated in studies of Neo-Assyrian dependence, that knowledge is often more general in nature and less easily linked to a specific Egyptian literary tradition.
|
Sabbath and Punishment in P
Program Unit: Sabbath in Text and Tradition
Charles Huff, University of Chicago
In the Priestly History, Sabbath is punished by the death penalty. This paper will explore the symbolism and meaning of punishment in P, tying it to the maintenance of divine repose. It will treat punishment in Priestly narratives like the flood, Nadab and Abihu, and the punishment of Moses and Aaron and will compare the logic of these punishments with that of the sacrificial system, particularly the ???? and ??? sacrifices. Other instances of the death penalty in the Priestly law code, all relating to the tabernacle and its accoutrements, will serve as the final piece of P’s construction of punishment. In the end, it will be seen that the Priestly literature attempts to define divine time along the lines of divine space; for P, the Sabbath is a sanctum like the tabernacle, in constant need of protection to avoid disrupting the divine repose—and the divine wrath that accompanies such disruption.
|
The CBGM Applied to Variants from Acts
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Annette Hüffmeier, Institut für Neutestamentliche Textforschung
This presentation will show the Coherence-Based Genealogical Method (CBGM) as developing and weighing external evidence in a new way. The CBGM tries to control the subjective moment of applying external criteria (e.g. “best quality witnesses”) by taking into account how all included witnesses are related to each other in terms of coherence. Consequently, each variant is assessed impartially, regardless of its appearance in a certain group of manuscripts, or its apparent importance. As a rule, this approach assumes, a scribe did his best to produce a fair copy of an exemplar. He did not distinguish between more or less interesting variants, and often we can only speculate about the reason why a variant arose. Nevertheless, rewarding examples from editorial work with Acts show the important insights that are generated when the results of coherence analyses are balanced with everything else known about the textual transmission of the New Testament, especially on the basis of the internal criteria of Transcriptional Probability.
|
Revolutionary Sacred Architecture: Akhenaten's Sun Temples and Israel's Tent
Program Unit: Egyptology and Ancient Israel
Herbert B. Huffmon, Drew University
With revolutionary theology one anticipates revolutionary concepts of sacred space. This expectation is realized in the sun temples built under Akhenaten (ca. 1348-1331 BCE) and in the concept and design of early Israel's portable shrine, the tent/tabernacle, supposedly dating back to the 13th century. The basic concepts for these constructions are quite different, and the contrast with the standard sacred architecture of the latter part of the Second Millennium BCE is quite striking. What is similar is the attempt to give architectural expression to the revolutionary theologies in question. For the architecture of Akhenaten, there is considerable archaeological evidence, but for the Israelite tent/tabernacle there is only chronologically and conceptually elusive information in the Biblical tradition, with but a few textual parallels. A key statement is Nathan's response to David (2 Sam 7:5-7), "Thus says the Lord: 'Is it you who would build a house for me as my residence? I have not resided in a house since the time I brought up the Bene-Yisrael from Egypt until the present. I have been going about in a tent and a tabernacle.'" God adds a comment about never having requested of any of those to whom he had entrusted the shepherding of his people, Israel, "Why have you all not built me a cedar house?" And the "Short Hymn to the Aten," as an example, affirms of the Aten, "Your rays light up all faces, your bright hue gives life to hearts, when you fill the Two Lands with your love . . . When you dawn their eyes observe you, As your rays light the whole earth; Every heart acclaims your sight."
Israel's tent/tabernacle and Akhenaten's temples in Akhet-Aten reflect these respective theologies, departing from contemporary standards for religious architecture. With changes in theology, Akhenaten's temples soon emptied and Israel's tent became a "cedar house."
|
Q Never Goes Away, It Just Changes Shape
Program Unit: Q
Ronald V. Huggins, Midwestern Baptist Theological Seminary
All attempts at dispensing with Q by the mere re-sequencing of the synoptic order ultimately fail. Although such solutions may succeed in dispensing with Q defined as Matthew's and Luke’s shared non-Marcan material, they do so only at the expense of having to presuppose an assortment of new and different kinds of Qs. So, for example, when I tried to dispense with Q by postulating Matthean Posteriority + Matthew’s dependence on Luke for his double tradition material, the process resulted (among other things) in the materials traditionally defined as L and Q simply flowing together to become a new kind of Q consisting of both. Similarly, when the defenders of the Farrer/Goulder/Goodacre hypothesis try to dispense with Q by postulating Lukan Posteriority + Luke’s dependence on Matthew for his double tradition material, M and Q similarly flow together to become a new kind of Q, again, consisting of both. The same kind of thing is true to a greater and lesser extent of all such attempts to dispense with Q by re-sequencing the synoptic order. Anyone claiming therefore that their particular Q-dispensing hypothesis serves the demands of Occam’s Razor better than the dominant two-source theory should be given pause lest they speak prematurely, lest, that is to say, their solutions necessarily presuppose the existence of “lost” sources they are not adequately cognizant of. In this paper I will discuss the ways in which this process develops in relation to four different solutions to the Synoptic Problem, each of which is often regarded as not requiring appeals to additional “lost” source documents: (1) the Augustinian hypothesis, (2) the Owen-Greisbach (Two Gospel) hypothesis, (3) the Farrer (Goulder/Goodacre) Lukan Posteriority hypothesis, and (4) my own Matthean Posteriority hypothesis.
|
The Spirit Speaks: Prosopological Exegesis and the Johannine Testimony Motif
Program Unit: Development of Early Christian Theology
Kyle R. Hughes, University of Virginia
This paper considers the role of the Spirit within early Christian writers’ use of prosopological exegesis, which seeks to identify various persons (prosopa) as the “true” speakers or addressees of a Scriptural text in which they are otherwise not in view. While scholars are increasingly recognizing that, for some early Christian writers, the Spirit could himself be a speaking agent, there remains no systematic analysis of the texts in which the Spirit speaks from his own prosopon. After making just such an analysis, focusing on key texts in the writings of Tertullian and Justin Martyr, this paper concludes that the need for divine testimony concerning both the Father and the Son was the central motivating factor for assigning OT quotations to the prosopon of the Spirit. In particular, this paper argues that this emphasis on the Spirit’s role as one who testifies is a direct outgrowth of the portrayal of the Spirit in the Johannine corpus. By making this connection, we have a new window by which to glimpse the theological dynamics at work in the pre-Nicene period that would contribute to the development of a distinctively Trinitarian, and not merely binitarian, view of God.
|
Honest to God: Truth, Theodicy, and the Heavenly Law Court in 3 Enoch
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Tom Hull, Monash University-Victoria Australia
3 Enoch (or Sefer Hekhalot) has a complicated intertextual relationship with the rest of the Hekhalot literature, and with the rabbinic corpus. Its complex and often overlapping or contradictory angelological hierarchies, not to mention the rise and fall of Metatron, contain a wealth of intertextual allusions, dependencies and appropriations.
A common thread throughout is a double bind posed by 1) an apparent attraction to the potent imagery and ‘activist praxis’ behind merkavah speculation, and 2) a rejection of the dualistic heresy implied by such speculation.
While 3 Enoch’s status as a compilation of originally independent sources is beyond doubt, the literary and theological logic of the final redactor (or, the redactor of its longest macroform: §§1-80) is of interest for this paper.
This paper will look at two sections of 3 Enoch: 1) the heavenly law court passages (§§44-50), and 2) §§8-9 and §§68-70, which this paper suggests can be read together as an ‘apophatic framing narrative’ of divine withdrawal and weakness.
The ‘framing narrative’ presents a weakened, hidden God whose Shekhinah and right hand are withdrawn from earth due to the sins of Israel and the destruction of the Temple. It functions as a powerful theodicy, but it comes at a price: God is diminished. This representation of God accords with heavenly law court passages such as §44 which declares that God does nothing without consulting the Watchers and Holy Ones. §48 states that Truth (emet) stands facing (k’neged) God during the tribunal, which appears to tweak an earlier Rabbinic notion that truth had been expelled from heaven for protesting the creation of man. It also draws on messianic traditions that feature a throne opposite God. The status of Truth (a hypostasis?) and its function (to correct God?) seems to reinforce the notion that God ‘needs help’.
This double-edged theodicy helps to explain the proliferation of angels in 3 Enoch, and the extensive delegation required to keep things running. It will be demonstrated that the question of successful intercession with God binds all these various passages of 3 Enoch together. Furthermore, the inclusion of these passages in late versions of 3 Enoch helped to turn the text upon earlier manifestations of itself and amounts to a rejection of the original praxis of intercession that gave rise to the merkavah tradition.
|
The Sound of His Voice: Jesus' Voice as Theological Problem
Program Unit: Speech and Talk in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Jeremy F. Hultin, Murdoch University
How should the Son of God sound? In what ways ought the voice and speech of an incarnate deity set him apart from mere mortals?
Already in the second century, the critic Celsus pointed out that if a divine spirit lodged in a human body, it would sound quite unlike normal people. Some early Christian texts reflect this very assumption, and claim that Christ sometimes spoke with "a different kind of sound than our physical mouth produces." Yet Christians also wrestled with the occasional scriptural clue that suggested Jesus' speech had been as unprepossessing as his appearance ("his voice was not heard in the street" [Matt 12:19; Isa 42:2]).
This paper explores early Christian reflection on the sound of Jesus' voice and the nature of his speech. Special attention will be given to Origen's remarkable claim that Jesus' voice had a quasi-magical charm that cast a sort of spell on those who heard it--indeed, a quality so captivating that even women, despite their "feminine weakness and the dictates of outward propriety," were drawn to follow him into the wilderness.
|
Apocalypse as Theoria in Paul: A New Perspective on Apocalyptic as Mother of Theology
Program Unit:
Edith Humphrey, Pittsburgh Theological Seminary
*
|
Ecce homo or Hic vir? Translation and Allusion in Jn 19:5
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Laura J. Hunt, Prifysgol Cymru, Y Drindod Dewi Sant - University of Wales, Trinity Saint David
In some Latin versions of John, and certainly in the Latin Vulgate, after Jesus comes out wearing the crown of thorns and the purple robe, Pilate presents him to the crowd with the words ecce homo, a word-for-word translation of the Greek, idou o anthropos. What do these words mean on the lips of Pilate, and what might John mean by reporting this event? This paper will provide an analysis that begins with the use of the Latin language in the army, the law, and commerce, in Palestine, Alexandria, Antioch and Ephesus, locations linked to the composition of John’s Gospel. It will then examine praetorium as a loan-word or possibly a code-switch that brings the Latin encyclopedia to salience in the Johannine trial scene. Finally, since Vergil’s Aeneid had become popular by the second century C.E. not only in Latin but also in Greek translation, this paper will ultimately argue for the possibility of Aeneid 6.791, the presentation of Augustus, as the literary allusion made in John 19:5. It will further suggest that this allusion functions in the passage to clarify for auditors familiar with a Roman encyclopedia that Jesus, as basileus, was imperator, not rex.
|
Character Studies in the Fourth Gospel: Methods, Trends, Results
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Steven A. Hunt, Gordon College
As the editors of the volume Character Studies in the Fourth Gospel, we committed early on to a narratological approach to the roughly seventy major and minor characters and group characters in John. We also decided, for a number of reasons, to leave its implementation open, thereby giving our forty-one fellow contributors as much methodological flexibility as possible. This paper illustrates the benefits of such an approach. Given such open-endedness, then, what lessons can be drawn from the way that the contributors wrote their essays? The paper will further survey the various methodologies employed by the authors, while highlighting several of the remarkable readings that followed from their application. Do current scholarly trends emerge in light of such a survey? And what specific results followed from those studies in the volume of the so-called minor characters, characters normally glossed over in other studies of characters in John?
|
Mirror or Metaphor? The Mirrored Bridal Chamber in the Gospel of Philip
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Jennifer R. Hunter, Northern Arizona University
Even though many scholars have embraced the bridal chamber in the Gospel of Philip as a reference to a type of ritual, there has been little research regarding the material nature or physicality of this ritual. Nevertheless, although a discussion of materiality has largely been absent from scholarship regarding the bridal chamber ritual, the question of materiality is not entirely out of our reach. On the contrary, the text’s reference to a “mirrored” bridal chamber suggests that a mirror or mirrors played a role in the bridal chamber ritual. Previous scholarship has treated the author’s usage of the term mirrored as a simple metaphorical description of the bridal chamber. However, the question regarding the realness of the mirror in the mirrored bridal chamber has never been legitimately explored as a historical possibility, and the research presented in this presentation attempts to rectify that situation. By comparing the textual context and purpose of the mirrored bridal chamber in the Gospel of Philip with other rituals in Greco-Roman society which utilized the mirror as a power-filled ritual tool, including its use in marriage ceremonies, we discover that there is historical precedence to suggest that the mirror was used as a powerful ritual tool in the mirrored bridal chamber. The findings of my research suggest that the community of the Gospel of Philip would likely have been drawn to the mirror due to the mirror’s ability to act as a gateway to the gods, affect transformation, evoke light, dispel evil spirits, and enable a process of unification between God and initiate, or in the case of the Gospel of Philip, between husband and wife.
|
The Dictionary of Classical Hebrew in the Classroom: Dealing with Patterns of Meaning
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Regine Hunziker-Rodewald, Université de Strasbourg
One of the requirements for a dictionary of Ancient Hebrew, when used for teaching exegesis of the Old Testament at university level in the classroom, is to refer to the communicative function of the language. The users of a dictionary are supposed to understand how the usage of Hebrew can express the use(s) of Hebrew. The present paper serves two purposes: 1) to summarize the experience of working with the Dictionary of Classical Hebrew in an exegesis course on Bachelor level, for example by a study of the entry 'yrš' and 2) to provide guide lines for teachers how to get students to deal with the data presented in DCH.
|
P.Oxy. 10.1228 (P22): A Fresh Autopsy Analysis
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Larry W. Hurtado, University of Edinburgh
P.Oxy. 10.1228 (Gregory-Aland P22; van Haelst 459) is a papyrus fragment, apparently a portion of a roll, a lines of the Gospel of John written on the vertical-fibre side, the horizontal-fibre side blank, the manuscript dated palaeographically 3rd century CE. It is one of only a few instances of a NT text written on a portion of a roll. Skeat (Birth of the Codex, 39-40) described it as "an eccentric production," and Kurt Aland (Studien zur Ueberlieferung des NT) proposed that the copyist re-used a roll, attaching extra sheets at the end, thus explaining the blank "recto". Based on my own autopsy inspection of the item (to my knowledge the first in many decades), I will make a fresh attempt to answer questions about the nature and likely original use of this noteworthy copy of GJohn.
|
The Morphological Development of the 3.m.sg. Suffix on Plural Nouns in Hebrew
Program Unit: Philology in Hebrew Studies
Jeremy M. Hutton, University of Wisconsin-Madison
The 3.m.sg. pronominal suffix on plural nouns is realized in several allomorphs in Epigraphic Hebrew and Biblical Hebrew [BH]. The suffix appears as {-W} and perhaps as {-YH} in Hebrew inscriptions (although evidence of the latter form is tenuous). In BH, the suffix may appear as {-W} as well, usually in instances where the kethiv is corrected by a Masoretic qere, but the far more common realization of the suffix is {-YW}; {-YHW} is also found in some poetic texts. This paper seeks to combine philological and linguistic (specifically, phonological) observations in an effort towards understanding the variegated development(s) of the suffix from a single underlying morpheme. We first survey various explanations for the suffix’s morphology, siding with more traditional analyses positing an underlying phonological value of the grapheme {-Y} (over against those viewing it as a purely graphic marker of the plural). We then seek to explain the presence of {-Y-} in BH through recourse to theoretical concepts provided by generative linguistics. We argue (in agreement with most philologists) that the {-W} form of, e.g., Byblian Phoenician and the Gezer Calendar is the result of diphthong contraction and h-deletion, with the resultant syllabic reconfiguration in which /u/ was realized as the featurally-identical phone [w]. This process is identical to that reflected in Epigraphic Hebrew and exemplars from other Semitic languages. Further, we suggest that the {-Y-} of BH {-YW} arose through the operation of glide insertion in a manner analogous to that suggested by Huehnergard (Maarav 7) for the non-Byblian Phoenician 3.m.sg. {-Y} on genitive singular nouns. Finally, we argue that the Tiberian vocalization—specifically, the a:-vowel—of BH {-YW} as /-a:(y)w/ is the result of a divergent phonological development of the suffix in Galilee (where the Tiberian vocalization originated).
|
Presumed Theological Changes in the Main Witnesses of 1–2 Samuel: Specific Tendencies Found in MT, 4QSama, and LXX
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Historical Books
Juerg Hutzli, Université de Lausanne
Recent studies in the text history of 1-2 Samuel show evidence that all three main witnesses (Massoretic Text; 4QSama, LXX) have been revised for theological reasons. In each witness certain tendencies can be observed.
The proposed paper will discuss exemplary examples for the three texts. In 4QSama and LXX (Hebrew Vorlage) the reckoned changes consist in the harmonization with specific Pentateuchal prescriptions and their language. In the MT several presumed corrections concern the concept of YHWH and his cult on the one hand and the image of King David on the other.
The presentation of these cases is followed by a consideration on the genetic relationship between the three texts MT, 4QSama and the Hebrew Vorlage of the Septuagint.
|
Storytelling and Spiritual Formation according to Apostle Paul
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Jin Hwang, Fuller Theological Seminary (Pasadena)
Storytelling is one of the favorite means Apostle Paul has frequently employed in his letters to enrich spiritual formation of his converts. This can be demonstrated well from Philippians. In this letter we encounter various stories that contribute to character formation, social and religious identity formation, ministry formation, and/or leadership formation. Paul not just presents stories of his own personal experiences—whether in the past or present (1:12-16; 3:5-16; 4:10-13). But he also talks about Christ Jesus (2:6-11), about his coworkers (Timothy and Epaphroditus) (2:19-24; 2:25-30), about the Philippian brothers and sisters (1:3-5; 4:2-3; 4:14-16), and about the false teachers (3:1-2; 3:18-19). The story of Christ in particular provides a theological foundation for all kinds of formation experiences taking place in the individual, ecclesial, and societal contexts. In this paper, I will attempt to demonstrate how Paul interweaves this metastory with other stories in order to help the Philippians continue in their Christian journey and service for Christ and his people both at the personal and communal levels and suggest the implications for pastoral ministry today.
|
Thecla’s Silence and Speech in the Acts of Paul and Thecla
Program Unit: Speech and Talk in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Susan E. Hylen, Emory University
This paper interprets Thecla’s silence and speech in the Acts of Paul and Thecla (ATh) against the background of social conventions for women’s speech and silence in the Greco-Roman period. I argue that both Thecla’s silence and speech before the governors of Iconium and Antioch embody the virtue sophrosune, modesty or self-control. Because women’s modesty is often associated with silence, I address the complexity of sophrosune as a virtue, especially as it relates to the speech of women. Against this background, I argue that the author of the ATh uses both Thecla’s silence and speech to characterize Thecla as sophrosune.
|
Proposing an Ecological-Economic Hermeneutics in View of Matt 6:19–34
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Ma. Marilou S. Ibita, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
While other branches of theology like ethics have long addressed the ecological concern (e.g., McFague, 2000) following White’s publication (1967), biblical studies seems to be a latecomer to this field (Wainwright, 2012). To date, a wide spectrum of ecological approaches tries to respond to the issue. The Earth Bible Project uses six eco-justice principles along with critique-retrieval-identification with Earth (Habel, et. al., from 2000 onwards). The Exeter Project (Horrell, Hunt and Southgate, 2008; Horrell, 2010) brings together historical studies and informed exegesis, contemporary science, and dogmatic lenses earlier pointed out by Conradie (2004). Wainwright (2012) advances ‘ecological thinking’ while Marlow (2009) adapts Wright’s (2004) ‘creation triangle’ into an ‘ecological’ triangle (God, humans and non-human creation). My paper will first explain how Wright’s initial insight on including the significant influence of economics in the ‘triangle of redemption’ (God, Israel and land) seems to unnecessarily fade as ecology becomes the focus of biblical interpretation. In Wright’s earlier ‘triangle of redemption’, attentiveness to how humans treat the land in connection with economics is like a “covenantal thermometer” measuring how the people’s relationship with each other and with God is going (2004). Next, I will underscore the need for biblical studies to fill the gap and begin reading the Bible with the double lens of ecology and economics. This combination is already underway in ecological ethics as ‘ecological economics’ (McFague, 2002, 2008) but the updated, unique contribution of biblical scholars is still lacking. Finally, I will focus on Mt 6:19-34, a text addressed to a border-crossing motley crowd following Jesus in Galilee. It contains clues that can be explored using ecological-economic hermeneutics and yields insights for biblical readers who face ecological and economic challenges today compared to an interpretation that is only focused on the ecological aspect.
|
Technical Possibilities versus Legal Limitations
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
David Instone-Brewer, Tyndale House (Cambridge)
The main restrictions in Biblical Studies research at present lies in limited access to ancient texts. Although virtually all Greek, Hebrew and Latin texts can be read online, these texts cannot be downloaded en-mass to be analysed as a corpus. In contrast, the scientific community regards free access to data as normal, and this has resulted in huge strides forward. The legality of such restrictions have yet to be tested, but in the mean time there are ways to move forward.
This paper will reveal results of an experimental site at www.RabbinicTraditions.com which stretches of the law of Fair Use to overcome legal restrictions. The Nov.2013 court ruling for Google now makes this legally safer. This opens up numerous novel ways to interrogate large corpuses of material to serve up enhanced results from existing datasets. These results could be much more useful than the thousands of hits from word searches.
|
Fascinax Strikes Again: Rosicrucianism and European Dime Novels, 1909–1949
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Massimo Introvigne, Center for Studies on New Religions (Turin)
Although subsequently obscured by comics, dime novels had a large circulation between the end of the 19th century and World War II both in the U.S. and Europe. The eccentric French Rosicrucian leader Joséphin Péladan (1858-1918,) often seen in Paris dressed in bizarre Oriental garbs, became the model for a French dime novel character of 1909, the Sâr Dubnotal, a Rosicrucian who solved a number of mysteries (including the Jack the Ripper case) through meditation and hypnotism. Dubnotal was followed by a later and more influential French and international dime novel hero created in the 1920s, Fascinax, an esoteric Rosicrucian who battled criminals and black magicians. Dime novels thus became a vehicle through which some general ideas about Rosicrucianism, secret societies, initiation and magic were disseminated. They played in the early 20th century the same role that comics and TV series assumed in disseminating certain esoteric ideas after the 1950s.
|
Remembrance of the Aeons Past: Apostasy and Reintegration in the Tripartite Tractate (NHC I,5)
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Eduard Iricinschi, The Van Leer Jerusalem Institute
This paper will explore the attempts of the author of the Tripartite Tractate to deal with apostasy in a community that had modified its initial Valentinian myth under the pressure of heresiological critics. It will first advance the hypothesis according to which the community to which the author of the Tripartite Tractate belonged altered its religious discourse, by incorporating some of the heresiological critics similar to those raised by Irenaeus and Tertullian, and by eliminating those Valentinian ideas and concepts difficult to hold in the late third century. As a result of this drastic change, rifts occurred within the community behind the Tripartite Tractate. The paper will next proposed that prayer, baptismal practices, and confirmation represent some of the strategies suggested by the author of the Tripartite Tractate to convince this community to commit itself, through the practice of remembrance, to an ideal of “unity,” “harmony,” and “joyous willingness.” Redemption is the purpose of this ideal, materialized through the knowledge of how to regain the initial unity of Pleroma. This paper will finally suggest to regard the Tripartite Tractate as an attempt to keep its community together with the help of the Origenian conception of restoration, through rituals of reintegration.
|
Edom, the Proximate 'Other': Persisting Category and Permeable Boundary a Social Identity Reading of Isa 63:1–6
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Dominic Sundararaj Irudayaraj, Jesuit School of Theology at Berkeley
Against the larger textual witness of Israel’s close kinship with Edomites, the prophetic portrayal of Edom as the place from which the blood-soaked divine warrior returns (Isa 63:1) sounds odd. Can this unrelenting animosity argue for ‘Edom’ as prophetic category for Israel’s immediate ‘other’?
A Social Identity reading of Isaiah 63:1–6 can underscore how the category of Israel’s proximate ‘other’ gets constructed. And, once constructed, the proximate ‘other’ takes on a life of its own. So, even if its original referent ceases to exist, the constructed notion continues to hold sway by pointing to new referents.
With textual and archeological evidences pointing to the continued presence of Edomites in Judean inlands, the prophetic attempt to portray the obliteration of a nation may be just that – a portrayal! Nonetheless the persisting category of Israel’s proximate ‘other’ can underscore prophetic otherness in post-exilic Isaian context.
Reading against the backdrop of Isa 34 where Edom is singled out as the recipient of divine wrath, the coming of divine warrior after trampling the enemies in Isa 63 appears to complete the prophetic vision. But other evidences (text and archeology) complicate such an Isaian vision of completed action. Why does a nation that exists but in memory should be singled out? Why such an unrelenting animosity towards one’s nearest neighbor? A Social Identity approach helps to locate the category called ‘Edom’ as the proximate ‘other’ on an inter-personal and inter-group continuum. Discursive depiction of relationship with one’s proximate ‘other’ is often characterized by ambivalence and ambiguity which serve the rhetorical need of constructing a category that persists and a boundary that is permeable! The paper ends with a note on contemporary significance of the proposed reading together with an illustration.
|
Rahab’s Visitors: Spies, Spokesmen, or Stooges?
Program Unit: Joshua-Judges
Melissa Jackson, Baptist Theological Seminary at Richmond
Argued elsewhere by Mark Biddle, Joshua is portrayed as a mirroring character to Moses, with much of the conquest narrative having a parallel in the exodus narrative. Similarly, the narrative of Rahab and her two Israelite “visitors” (Josh 2) contains numerous allusions to the exodus events, as well as reference to deuteronomic theology.
Rahab’s “visitors” hold varying roles in a developing tradition. Joshua 6.17 describes the men as “messengers”, a tradition reflective of the stipulations of Deuteronomy 20, in which a city is to be offered peace before any attack is mounted. Joshua 2 portrays the men as being sent to “explore secretly”, an assignment for spies. Joshua 6.25 knows both traditions, conflating the two roles of “messenger” and “spy”. Focusing on Joshua 2, another role emerges for the two men – stooge – as Rahab takes control of events, and the two spies recede, important only insofar as they aid Rahab’s cause.
Joshua 2 contains numerous allusions (and one direct reference, v. 10) to the book of Exodus. These allusions connect the saving of Rahab to the saving of the firstborn and the figure of Rahab to the figure of Miriam. First, Joshua 2 recalls images of the final plague and passover (Exod 12-13) through use of the number three (v. 16), a red thread to mark the spared household (vv. 18, 21), instruction not to go outside the house (v. 19), and reference to blood (v. 19). Second, Joshua 2 contains allusions to Moses’ infancy (Exod 2) and the song of Exodus 15, including the motifs of “hiding” and an outsmarted king, proclamation of enemies’ “melting” in “terror” (vv. 9, 24), and enemies’ being “pursued” and “overtaken” (v. 5).
These allusions taken together connect Joshua 2 to Exodus and cast Rahab as a subversive Miriam-esque figure, who saves herself.
|
R. Tuvia ben Eli'ezer ("Leka'h Tov") and the Judeo-Christian Polemic
Program Unit: Midrash
Jonathan Jacobs, Bar-Ilan University
R. Tuvia ben Eli'ezer ("Leka'h Tov") was active during the second half of the 11th century in Greece. His exegesis has not been widely researched, and to date no scholarship at all has been devoted to his commentary on Song of Songs, which presents a systematic commentary on every verse of the text, mostly based on rabbinic midrashic teachings. However, his commentary is not a random collection of midrashic material, but rather a composition constructed in a manner unprecedented in the rabbinic tradition of his time or of earlier periods. In the lecture I shall examine its contribution to the Judeo-Christian polemic, in comparison with Rashi's exegesis. I will show that He focuses on one main theme throughout his allegorical commentary: most of his teachings deal with the situation of the Jewish People in exile, the memory of the past, and anticipation of the future. we may say that although R. Tuvia and Rashi lived in different geographical regions and in different cultural environments, there is considerable similarity in the way in which each of them addresses the events of their time.
|
Gendered Identity as Vehicle for Cultural Expectations
Program Unit: Megilloth
Mignon R. Jacobs, Fuller Theological Seminary (Pasadena)
The narratives in the Megilloth depict gendered identity that both challenges and reinforces patterns and expectations of cultural systems. Identity and social location are intertwined in each society and culture such that narratives typically exhibit signals to their presence in the world inside the text particularly regarding the characters’ roles and choices. This paper proposes a reading of the narratives looking at depicted behaviors as indicators of efforts to maintain the cultural systems. It is proposed that gendered identity is a necessary vehicle for preserving the cultural systems depicted in the text. First, this paper looks at the books of Ruth and Esther in light of their depiction of gender roles and identity. In particular the paper examines the expectations associated with female gender roles. Second, the paper examines ways that the narratives filter the ‘otherness’ of these gendered roles through individual and corporate identity and expected behaviors.
|
Women as Readers of the Psalms
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Diane Jacobson, Luther Seminary
This paper will explore what it means to think of women as readers of the psalms, especially as this pertains to issues of translation.
|
Dualing (Read: Dueling) Psalmos
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Karl Jacobson, Augsburg College
My paper explores the fluid nature or function of persona (voice), audience, Sitz-im-Leben, and genre in the so called dual-psalms. Hossfeld and Zenger (Psalms 2, 186) characterize this fluidity in terms of the “biblical double traditions,” that is, poetic material that has been preserved in two different streams, and which is evidence of redaction history in the Psalter. Broadly speaking, the basic approach to the question of the dual-psalms has been to focus on such ideas as two variants of an ur-psalm (which can be reconstructed through comparative deconstruction), faulty scribal transmission (which can be assessed to reveal the genuine original of the psalm), and deliberate alteration (which is due to a re-appropriation of the poetic material for a new setting). My goal is to provide a comprehensive analysis of the psalms via side-by-side reading. Each pair of psalm-voices will be heard together, comparatively, with an eye not for finding the “original” poem, but to evaluating the fluid nature (and function) of persona (voice), audience, Sitz-im-Leben, and genre in these dueling psalms.
I will focus on each of the pairings in the Psalter, Pss 14 and 50; 40:14-18 and 70; 57:8-12/60:7-14 and 108; as well as the composite psalm found in 1 Chr 16:8-37, which is made up of Pss 105:1-15, 96:1-13, and 106 1, 47-48.
|
Noah as “Action Hero,” Godzilla as “Leviathan”
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Karl Jacobson, Augsburg College
Our paper will explore the interpretive dynamics and cultural connotations at work in the reimaging of a biblical epic through the lens of action-flick (Noah [March, 2014]), and the classical monster movie figure Godzilla (May, 2014) through the lens of the sporting/laughter-inducing of Leviathan (Ps 104:26).
The goal of the paper is to examine closely the nature of the interplay of the textual tradition and the current, new “Sitz-im-Leben” of the text in American popular culture; How do text and new context shape the interpretive exercise, both in films themselves, and in conversation of text and film, reader and viewer?
|
Two Aramaic Zodiac Calendars: Why 4Q318 Is Related to the Synchronistic Calendar of 4Q208–4Q209
Program Unit: Qumran
Helen R. Jacobus, University College London
This paper will argue that both the zodiacal calendar element of 4Q318 (the unit, 4QZodiac Calendar) and the Synchronistic Calendar of 4Q208-4Q209 (4QAstronomical Enoch a-b) are part of similar astronomical schemes. Both are zodiac calendars but the latter has been misunderstood in recent scholarship.
It will be proposed that there has been confusion in this subject area as a result of the work of Otto Neugebauer in the 1960s to the early 1980s who wrongly argued that the “gates” in Ethiopic Astronomical Book of Enoch did not refer to the zodiac signs, as had been --- correctly--- understood by Laurence and the 19th century scholars after him such as Hoffman, Dillman and Martin through to Charles in the early 20th century.
Neugebauer said, rightly, that the “gates” of the sun in 1 Enoch 72 represent arcs on the horizon where the sun rises and sets throughout the year. But, as shall be shown, this does not contradict the theory that the “gates” also represent the signs of the zodiac. Furthermore the zones on the horizon cannot be used to determine the rising and setting places of the moon. Neugebauer’s misleading theory has been inappropriately applied to the Aramaic Synchronistic Calendar of 4Q208-4Q209 with the result that since Milik’s critical edition on the Aramaic fragments of the Book of Enoch, this text has not been accurately analysed in Qumran scholarship. Furthermore, modern scholars have incorrectly isolated 4Q318, which I shall argue, is part of the same corpus as the Synchronistic Calendar of 4Q208-4Q209.
|
The Violent Gift: Trauma’s Subversion of the Deuteronomistic History’s Narrative
Program Unit: Biblical Literature and the Hermeneutics of Trauma
David Janzen, North Central College
The author will discuss methodological issues especially pertaining to his application of literary trauma theory in his book.
|
Spectacle and Stage-Craft in Philo's Flaccus
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Jeff Jay, Wabash College
In spite of Philo's frequent critiques of the theater and other Roman spectacles he is well-versed in their dialogical dynamics and knows how to appropriate, critique, and subvert the semantics normally governing the shows in order to push back against the injustices of Roman overlords.
This is evident in Philo's Flaccus, where Philo responds to the violence against Jews during the pogrom of 38, which culminates in the theater during the festivals celebrating Gaius's birthday, when Flaccus marches Jewish elders into the theater and has them stripped and whipped so severely that some die, while others remain long incapacitated. Philo understands that this spectacle, with its penal dimension, functions both to humiliate the elders and satisfy the Alexandrians' felt need for retribution.
Philo himself then pursues the very strategy employed by his opponents. He interprets the demise and sufferings of Flaccus as penalties for his injustices against the Jews exacted by the retributive work of personified "Justice." Like the Jews Flaccus earlier marched into the theater, Flaccus's punishment takes a theatrical turn, when he who has staged spectacles becomes a spectacle himself, for Philo transforms Flaccus's deportation to exile on the Aegean island of Andros into a "spectacle" and thus creates textually a spectacle to counter those that recently have victimized the Jews. He thereby shows himself as inventive in spectacle-creation as the Alexandrian audiences and Flaccus are, even if Philo's primary medium is literary ekphrasis rather than live participation. But even as Philo issues his combative textual spectacle in the Flaccus, he shares and accepts the same rationale for theatricalizing punishment as his opponents. Namely, punitive spectacle discharges the just punishment of offenders and offers redress to victims, whose retributive satisfaction is maximized by the very dimension of exhibition.
Evoking spectacle and other theatrical elements thus provides for Philo a means by which he can create textually (via ekphrasis) a spectacle that both deters Roman overlords from treating Jews as Flaccus has and offers retributive redress for Jewish victims. Philo thus exemplifies how it is possible to participate in the life and culture of the theater and spectacles in a way that offers considerable leverage to speak back to and compete with leading power holders and culture brokers.
|
The Dual Textual History of the Song of Hannah in Ethiopic Manuscript Tradition
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Brian Jeanseau, George Fox Evangelical Seminary
In Ethiopia, the Song of Hannah was transmitted both in biblical manuscripts (1Samuel 2:1-10) and in Psalters (the fourth biblical canticle). The goal of this research is to compare the textual histories of this song within these two types of manuscripts. To complete this study, we gathered manuscripts representing the full chronological sweep of each tradition. We then transcribed at least 30 manuscripts of each type. After transcription, we identified the families of manuscripts and their date ranges and then generated lists of characteristics readings for each family.
In this presentation we will provide answers to the following questions: Do the same rules of transmission apply to both types of manuscripts? How does the development of the text in the canticle compare to the development of the text in the biblical manuscript (the text of the canticle appears quite static in comparison to the text in the biblical manuscripts)? What characteristic differences exist between the two types of manuscripts? This research is part of the Textual History of the Ethiopic Old Testament Project (THEOT).
|
Gospel Traditions in the Epistle to Diognetus
Program Unit: Texts and Traditions in the Second Century
Clayton Jefford, Saint Meinrad School of Theology
Though uniformly acknowledged as a product of the late second century, the Epistle to Diognetus offers a curious mix of biblical references, focused largely on materials drawn from the letters of Paul and Johannine tradition. At the same time, limited attention is given to teachings from Matthew, albeit in a seemingly unsystematic way. This paper gives focus to the work’s use of gospel traditions, keying on evidence both of Matthean teaching and Johannine tradition. It is postulated here that Diognetus as scholars now know it represents the juncture of two different developing traditions: an earlier work that employed but did not focus on Matthean trajectories, and a later editorial layer predominantly influenced by Johannine teachings (if not necessarily by the text of the Fourth Gospel itself). The paper will seek to analyze how these divergent approaches to different gospel traditions may help scholars to distinguish between the perspective of the original author and that of the later editor.
|
Iron Age Silos and the Story of Gideon
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Mark A. Jenkins, Evangel University
The story of Gideon preserves a memory of grain concealment in a "gat"—a type of installation typically identified by translators as a wine press. Although it is a legitimate gloss, this translation decision may in fact be too specific for the type of installation the author had in mind. A careful study of the usage of "gt" within the Ugaritic corpus, and its apparent Akkadian equivalent "dimtu," reveals that the word was applied far more widely, often in reference to farming installations. With this generic agricultural usage in mind, this paper will offer an archaeological explanation for Gideon’s "gat," specifically the pit silo of the Iron I hill country.
The actions of Gideon display the general insecurity of the people of Israel as they were attempting to gain a permanent foothold in the land Canaan. At the beginning of the Iron Age, one of the defining characteristics of settlements in the Central Hill Country was the proliferation of pitting activity. As a settlement indicator they are so common that they are literally found “from Dan to Beersheba.” While it seems apparent that these pits were used for storage of grain, the practice appears to have ceased in favor of more efficient grain storage options during Iron Age II. If gat, as used in Judges 6, describes a general farming installation such as a silo, then the story of Gideon may preserve an authentic memory of the Iron I pitting activity as a means to conceal grain. Ultimately, this reading links the story of Gideon with one of the hallmarks of Iron I material culture and offers new insights on the Iron Age pitting phenomenon.
|
Depictions of Dining in Early Christian Art
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
Robin M. Jensen, Vanderbilt University
Depictions of banqueters seated at semi-circular tables are common to both Christian and Greco-Roman art. These are sometimes found in domestic contexts but most frequently in funerary settings. Although most scholars interpret these scenes as alluding to the funerary banquets held in honor of the deceased or perhaps referring to post-death picnics in a paradisiacal setting, the suggestion that they depict actual sacred ritual meals lingers (e.g., a Christian eucharist or agape meal). This paper will explore the components of these images in some detail. It will examine surviving scenes of dining from secular or non-funerary contexts, noting the visual representations of certain dining customs that appear to be most emphasized thereon. It will then compare the Christian with non-Christian parallels, particularly in funerary art, and explore the ways that Christians may have reinterpreted a conventional Greco-Roman funerary motif as pointing to explicitly Christian expectations for the afterlife. As context for these images, this paper will consider related material evidence, particularly decorated funerary tables (mensae) from both pagan and Christian settings, either those often attached to stele or elaborated with mosaic designs that were found, mainly, in cemetery churches. In some instances these objects depict the particular foods or types of dishes employed for these banquets. Others present iconography or epigraphic indications of the significance of the meal in Christian as well as non-Christian funerary rituals.
|
Exodus 18: A Post-Priestly Literary Invention?
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Jaeyoung Jeon, Université de Lausanne
While there had been a consensus among classical source critics that the story of Jethro’s visit at the Mountain of God (Exodus 18) belongs to E, given its affinity to some parts of Exodus 3 (deemed E) and the use of Elohim over YHWH, an increasing number of European scholars assign either the whole (Blum, Otto, K. Schmid) or majority (Berner) of the text to a post-Priestly Pentateuchal redaction executed in the Persian period. By contrast, most North American scholars regard the chapter as a pre-Priestly composition carried out under the influence of the Deuteronomistic literature (Van Seters, Carr, Dozeman). An earlier date for the text is claimed by those who maintain the Elohist hypothesis (Schwartz, Baden, Graupner) or who advocate yet alternative models (Albertz, Crüsemann). It is clear, then, that the discussions concern broader formation models; a common phenomenon in recent Pentateuch scholarship.
The late dating of Exodus 18 is argued mainly as a logical consequence of the post-P dating of another pivotal text in current Pentateuch discussion, the commissioning of Moses (Exodus 3-4), which is presupposed by the present text. However, this literary-stratigraphical claim provokes many new problems, since many features of Exodus 18 are incompatible with P and other post-P texts. Indeed, a post-priestly date of composition for Exodus 18 raises significant thematic issues concerning the presentation of the character of Moses, since the description of Moses as an unwise person seems to jar with a growing tendency in the Persian period and onwards to present him as an exalted figure, as is visible in Ezra-Nehemiah, prophetic books, and later Second temple period literature. Moreover, there appears to be a contradiction between the very positive description of a Midianite (Jethro) and the unusual hostility toward the Midianites evident in other post-P texts (Numbers 25, 31), as well as the sharp contrast between Exodus 18 and Num. 25 about the issue of intermarriage with Midianite women (Zipporah and Cozbi).
In the proposed paper, I will critically review the grounds for and problems surrounding the post-P dating and suggest my own redaction critical analysis of Exodus 18, including the possibility that the second half of the chapter is a later addition. This analysis will present indications of a pre-P origin of the text, in close associations with my earlier work on Exodus 3-4 (The Call of Moses and the Exodus Story, Mohr Siebeck, 2013) and the recent thesis of Thomas Römer that earlier biblical traditions remembered the wilderness period only positively and the negative description of it is later invention—Exodus 18 describes the wilderness wondering only positively.
To be sure, it should not be ruled out that diverse scribal groups participated in the completion of the Pentateuch in the Persian period, so that contradictory ideas may have been merged into the present form of the text. This possibility will be discussed in light of the present text in the paper’s conclusion.
|
Toward a Poetics of the Biblical Mind: The Personhood of the Biblical God
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Job Y. Jindo, The Tikvah Center for Law and Jewish Civilization, New York University
In this paper, I wish to develop a heuristic approach that enables us to better explore the phenomenology of biblical religion in general, and the personhood of the biblical deity in particular. In modern scholarship, monotheism, like any other religion, is regarded, more often than not, as a symbolic system, through which biblical writers conceived and expressed the operation and meaning of the world and the self, a cultural matrix through which they sought to communicate with members of their community. This approach—with all its profundity and appealing sophistication—seems inadequate if one seeks to understand this religion from within. For this approach reduces the biblical God into (just) one such symbol or an idea, while the lived experience as reflected in biblical literature is clearly premised on the realness of this deity—not as a static concept or symbol, but rather as a real living person with a will and character that interacts with humans in all his fullness. I will use works of such scholars as Franz Rosenzweig, Abraham Heschel, and Yochanan Muffs to develop an alternative approach to the phenomenology of biblical religion.
|
Memories of Exile in the Book of Ezra
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Kristin Joachimsen, The Arctic University of Norway
Based on memory studies, which deals with the relationship between memory, identity, and history, the paper examines how memories of the Exile are used in the Book of Ezra. By a close reading of Ezra 2, 4:1-5, 6:21, and 9-10, that is, episodes where boundaries of the community are challenged, it will be shown how members become incorporated in a mnemonic community by being made to know the group’s stories of the past. In this inclusion, also a process of “othering” is taking place, related to “our” self-understanding, where “we” define “others” and simultaneously themselves. Also in biblical scholarship, the Exile works as an identity marker, as well as a marker in a periodization of a before and an after. This becomes apparent in the way the Book of Ezra has been used as a primary source of what we can know about the situation in Yehud in the Achaemenid period. The analysis relates further to studies by the cultural critic Bhabha, who draws attention towards cultural hybridity, in which the trope of exile might help to define better theories of culture and how they work. As will be shown, the trope of exile challenges related tropes of identity, home, diaspora, displacement, and repatriation.
|
"As for You, Do Not Pray on Behalf of This People”: Intercession, Deception, and Shalom in the Book of Jeremiah
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Mari Joerstad, Duke University
A unique feature of the Book of Jeremiah is God’s thrice repeated ban on intercession (7:16, 11:14 and 14:11). These commands can seem purposeless and vindictive, the divine version of covering one’s ears while singing loudly. In this paper, I will explore how the ban on intercession connects with the Jeremian themes of falsehood (???) and shalom (?????), and Jeremiah’s role as God’s prophet. In the first section of the paper, I will look closely at the passages in which God commands Jeremiah not to pray. In the second section I investigate what makes intercession problematic in the Book of Jeremiah by considering verses 4:7 and 29:7-12.
I will argue that what is at stake in Jeremiah’s intercession is the prophet’s ability to distinguish between truth and falsehood, that is, the prophet’s ability to correctly interpret God’s actions in the fall of Jerusalem. Though Jeremiah clearly empathizes with the suffering of the people, it is imperative that he does not empathize too closely with their understanding of why they suffer. To pray for the welfare of the people is problematic, because it clings to the notion that perhaps the destruction of Jerusalem can be avoided. But the welfare of the people cannot be restored until the people learn the source of their welfare and discontinue religious and social practices contrary to God’s will. Thus praying for welfare independently of a radical change in the people fundamentally misunderstands the origin and shape of ????? as it relates to God’s covenant with the people.
Verse 4:7 makes clear that Jeremiah’s understanding of the siege and fall of Jerusalem is in question in the book. In this verse, Jeremiah accuses God of deceiving the people. Jeremiah’s complaint raises the possibility that God, rather than the people itself, is the source of deceit. This possibility is emphatically rejected, and when the people (note: not Jeremiah!) are finally command to pray for Babylon in 27:9, the call to intercession serves as a practical lesson. In Babylon, the people must learn to distinguish between the false words of the prophets and the good that God promises in exile, and to pray accordingly. While intercession in the mouth of Jeremiah threatens to undo his vision of God’s purpose behind the destruction of Jerusalem, intercession in the mouth of the exiles teaches them what they did not previously understand, that the Lord, and no other gods, is the source of their welfare, their future and their hope.
In conclusion, God’s ban on intercession, however harsh, forms a necessary part of Jeremiah’s prophetic office. As God’s mouth, Jeremiah must understand God’s point of view, and must commit to God’s interpretation of events over against that of people.
|
Ecclesiology, Election, and Holiness: A Missional Reading of the Thessalonian Correspondence
Program Unit: GOCN Forum on Missional Hermeneutics
Andy Johnson, Nazarene Theological Seminary
As I complete a commentary on 1 and 2 Thessalonians in which I attempt to offer a missional reading of the letters, the interaction between the way I have read these texts and the particular sort of missional understanding of the Trinitarian God that informs these readings has come into sharper focus. This sharper focus has come from grappling with two systematic proposals that have important implications for missional hermeneutics and the theology emerging from it: John Flett, The Witness of God and Suzanne McDonald, Re-Imaging Election.
I will begin the paper with a brief summary of Flett’s (Barthian) attempt to provide missio Dei theology with a sufficient Trinitarian basis and McDonald’s re-conceptualized missional understanding of election. I will include a discussion of the way that the doctrine of God in each of these systematic proposals informs their author’s understanding of the nature of the church’s participation in God’s mission.
In the main part of the paper, I will engage portions of the Thessalonian correspondence in critical dialogue with Flett and McDonald. I will attempt to show that these texts are illuminated by Flett’s articulation of the correspondence between the act/being of God and the act/being of the church as well as by McDonald’s re-conceptualized understanding of election. However, the paper will also show that the particular shape of the church’s participation in this God’s mission that flows from their articulation of the doctrine of God/election needs to be reconceived in light of such Pauline texts. The nature of participation implied by these texts flows from a particular missional understanding of God that ought, in turn, to inform our doctrine of God in a way that would correspondingly sharpen our thinking about the (missional) nature of the church, its elect status, and the holiness it is called to embody in its particular context.
|
What Are We to Do with the Hebrew Bible’s Resistance to Metaphysics?
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Philosophy
Dru Johnson, The King's College (New York City)
Philosophical theology has been accused of moving down a slippery slope to nothing more than onto-theology in recent decades. It is claimed that reducing biblical complexities to well-argued “primitive” propositions can end narrowly in a discussion of the ontological nature and status of God himself. However, this claim might distract from the problem directly confronting readers of the Hebrew Bible: these ancient texts contain diverse stories where biblical authors certainly presume metaphysical relations yet leave them entirely unexplored. What, then, is the role of metaphysics in understanding these stories in the Hebrew Bible itself? The reader is begged to imagine ontological relationships directly beneath the logic of the story that than allow the story itself to make sense (e.g., the passing of blessing by the laying on of hands, the movement of sin from the High Priest to the goat on Yom Kippur, and even the presence of YHWH himself in discrete spatial locations). If the relations go unexplained in the text and are indiscernible when analyzed in their aggregate, do all metaphysical claims (e.g., sin as substance) ultimately resolve to metaphysical mysterionism in the bible? In this paper, I would like to explore two paradigms where metaphysical presumptions—movement and presence—figure into the logic of biblical narratives. I then consider what method can parse such a reticence to fill in the metaphysical gaps without falling back into etic notions of perfection theology concerning the divine being of the Hebrew Bible?
|
The Prophetic Witness of James
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Luke Timothy Johnson, Emory University
The Letter of James is usually categorized as a form of wisdom, and it rewards being read that way. But its distinctive challenge to readers to live in friendship with God rather than in friendship with the world, and the ways in which it insists that believers live by "the implanted word" rather than by the distorted values of the world, show it to be a powerful prophetic voice within the New Testament.
|
The Great Mirror: Historical Fictions at Court, from Hellenistic Egypt to Heian Japan
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Sara R. Johnson, University of Connecticut
Greek and Roman novels flourished in the world of ancient popular literature, along with a host of other less easily classifiable fictions. Recent research has increasingly suggested that ancient fictions arose partially in response to the impact of imperial rule (Swain 1996, Whitmarsh 2001, Goldhill 2001), and not only that of the Roman empire, but the Persian Empire and Hellenistic kingdoms before it (e.g. Tatum 1989, Wills 1995, Berlin 2001).
Outside the ancient Mediterranean context, a fully developed pre-modern novel also appeared in Japan, the Tale of Genji (Genji Monogatari). In Japan as in the Mediterranean world, the novel appeared at a time when historical fictions of various kinds flourished. In this paper, I will offer a very preliminary sketch of a few similarities between the production of fictions in the eastern Mediterranean in the Hellenistic period, and the production of fictions at the imperial court in Heian era Japan (794-1185 CE).
Some of the similarities are striking enough to be remarkable. Drawing on only one Japanese example, the Great Mirror (Ookagami, ca. 1100 CE), a quasi-fictional account of the Fujiwara ministers at the Heian court, we find apparently deliberate chronological distortions left both as a signal to the reader of “fictionality” and at the same time as an ideological support for the writer’s own claims (parallels abound in the books of Esther and Judith); solemn truth-claims and appeals to written evidence (in a text widely acknowledged since its inception as more fictional than historical) which precisely mirror the language used by the author of the Letter of Aristeas; and tales of elite maneuvering at court (cp. Josephus’ Tales of the Tobiads) that suggest that members of marginal elites faced much the same challenges in different cultures, even when the moral of the tale is rooted in a very different set of social mores.
I tentatively suggest that female literati at the Heian court occupied a position not unlike that of the Greek-educated Jewish elite under Hellenistic rule – a precarious balance of marginal elite status, language polarities, and relations with the loci of power at the imperial center (cf. Adolphson 2007).
|
Urban Spaces and Christian Beginnings: Cultivating a Critical Spatial Imagination
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Melanie Johnson-DeBaufre, Drew University
A common approach to situating the earliest Christ assemblies into the built environment of the ancient city is typological: identifying social categories and their spaces and analyzing the points of contact or divergence with Pauline texts. However, spatial meaning and practice are shaped by several spaces (Pile; Massey). Typology privileges ideological meanings rather than the use and misuse of urban space, especially by non-elites (De Certeau; Cresswell). And space is produced but also productive, shaping identity as much as being shaped by it (Lefebvre; Massey). This paper uses 1 Thessalonians to explicate these theoretical problems. I argue that the dominance of the “house-church” (whether villa or tenement) and the workshop/association over determine the spatial stories that could be told and privilege Paul’s chorography over his city-dwelling audience. I make proposals for cultivating a critical spatial imagination of urban Christian beginnings that can do justice to dynamic and contested space.
|
Mobility, Transgression, and Deviance: Samson in the Post-exilic Context
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
Amy Beth Jones, Drew University
Samson is a liminal and transgressive figure in the book of Judges. A highly mobile character, Samson (an Israelite) spends most of his narrative life among the Philistines. He is endowed with super-human capacities, but has the impulsiveness of an animal. The hyper-masculine hero is duped by a woman. Samson straddles, crosses, and transgresses geographic, social, and bodily boundaries.
This paper will perform a social and spatial analysis of Samson’s character with particular attention to the way in which Samson’s many and varied border crossings construct, ridicule, and challenge the identity and leadership of post-exilic Israel. I will engage the work of sociologist Tim Cresswell, particularly his definition of transgression as “out-of-place phenomena” that leads people to question what they otherwise assume to be appropriate and “normal,” or “common sense” for a particular setting. Mobility, therefore, is a form of “super-deviance” because movement disrupts the ability to predictably organize spaces, in turn threatening the order of society. Narrative places, spaces, and personalities become tools for producing and reproducing dominant ideology(ies) that determine (a) which spaces are inhabitable and by whom; (b) which behaviors and interactions are acceptable, justified, and “normal”; and (c) which gendered personalities are best capable of shaping cultural, ethnic, and political identity in a narrative world.
If mobility is a form of “super-deviance,” then Samson is particularly aberrant. Samson’s movement between Israel and Philistia is part of the pulse of the narrative. As he travels between Dan in the Shephelah region and Philistia in the coastal plains, Samson crosses not only topographic boundaries, but also economic, cultural, and ethnic boundaries. With each move, Samson’s animalistic tendencies are increasingly unwelcome in civilized society. He is pushed to the fringes of society until his hyper-masculine body is permanently mutilated and feminized so that his “wild-man” qualities are satisfactorily tamed (or are they?).
Placed in a post-exilic context, Samson’s character is a thinly veiled reference to those upper class returnees (such as priests, political leaders, and temple staff) whose power and authority depended on the support of Persian officials. Samson descends from the Danites (the tribe known for migrating from the southern part of Israel to the far north) who are analogous to the returning exilic community. The Philistines, both a foreign imperial threat and a highly mobile military people, are a cipher for other colonizing forces (the Persians, perhaps) whose sheer power and mobility threaten the established order of Israelite space. The geographic and social transgressions of Samson’s character spoof the leadership of the returning exilic community. His (failed) nazirite status is a way of comically exaggerating the role of the priest. His love-hate relationship with the Philistines is a carnivalesque rendering of the dance between the colonizer and the leadership of the colonized. Read in this way, Samson’s geographic, social, and bodily transgressions challenge the communal identity and leadership provided by exilic returnees, and demonstrates the dangers of (literally) sleeping with the colonizer.
|
Presenting Ancient Spaces Using Google Earth
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Christopher M. Jones, Beloit College
Biblical literature is filled with vividly imagined spaces. Its histories unfold in the realistic spaces of ancient Israel and Judah; its prophetic poetry invokes the symbolic value of real places; its apocalypses imagine transcendent heavenly worlds that nevertheless mirror the world of human experience. These texts depend on the lived experience of their early readers for their rhetorical power. We appreciate them only insofar as we know the material worlds that they presuppose.
Most of our students, however, have little access to these worlds. In the classroom, I have taken to using spatial theory, in tandem with the free version of Google Earth, to help my students bridge the gap. In my presentation, I will provide three resources for teachers of biblical literature. First, I will briefly survey some theoretical readings on space, place, and lived experience, assessing each in terms of its topic, its relative accessibility to undergraduate and graduate readers, and my own experiences teaching it. Second, I will demonstrate the technical side of using Google Earth. I will show everyone how to locate ancient places precisely, how to enter precise coordinates into Google Earth to generate placemarks, and how to embed artifact images and presentation slides alongside of placemarks. The result is a seamlessly integrated presentation tool—a moveable, interactive map that includes lecture content, discussion questions, visual stimuli, and relevant geographical features that can be used in the classroom or made available to students to explore on their own. Finally, I will present an interactive lesson to demonstrate how I use Google Earth in the classroom.
I will provide an annotated bibliography along with my presentation. It will include 1) my list of theoretical readings, 2) a list of web resources for locating biblical places, and 3) a list of web resources for using Google Earth.
|
From Jesus to Lord and Other Contributions of the Early Aramaic-Speaking Congregation in Jerusalem
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
F. Stanley Jones, California State University - Long Beach
Beginning with an exposition of how the early congregation came to designate Jesus as Lord, a search ensues for other early Aramaic terminology of the primitive Aramaic-speaking congregation in Jerusalem. Central rituals and institutions of this congregation will be used as guides for the exploration.
|
Judges 19 and the Foundations of Rape Culture
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Laura Jones-Armstrong, Independent Scholar
This paper explores the theoretical underpinnings of rape culture by reading the rape of the Levite’s secondary wife in Judg 19 as a foundational story for the interpretation of rape culture, here understood as the socio-sexual contract whereby women’s bodies come to stand in for men’s bodies as objects suitable for rape and violation. In my analysis of the story I identify three basic characteristics of rape culture: 1) in rape culture male homosocial bonding and cooperation is established around the image of the violable female body, 2) because this image is foundational to rape culture, there can be no recourse offered for rape except the continuation and reproduction of rape, and 3) the violable female body provides an imperfect resolution to male anxiety around violation, such that the image comes to represent the fractures of the civic body as well as the bonds of homosocial cooperation. I conclude by suggesting ways in which the examination of rape culture through the lens of Judg 19 might prove useful in interpreting the Steubenville rape case, a recent, highly publicized incidence of rape in which the representation of the rape in social media played a significant role.
|
On the Nature and Limitations of the Coherence Based Genealogical Method
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Dirk Jongkind, Tyndale House (Cambridge)
Over the past years some big claims have been made regarding the benefits of the newly developed CBGM. However, now that the honeymoon is over, it is time to start talking about the limitations of the method. As a discipline we should start asking questions like, What does the CBGM actually tell us? Within the method, is ‘genealogical coherence’ more than just an abstraction with little to say about actual history or is ‘genealogical coherence’, in terms of textual history, a ‘real’ concept? Is the method perhaps unnecessary complicated? Could the same be achieved with simpler, more accessible and more flexible methods?
In this paper it will be argued that so far, the CBGM has only been used to provide materials for a visual analysis of the distribution of the evidence. Besides, the contribution of the CBGM as an analytical tool has not been distinguished sufficiently from the particular way of doing textual criticism by the editorial team in Münster. On the other hand, the CBGM is raising an important issue within our discipline, namely by questioning the value of ‘earlier is more important’. But is the method correct in suggesting that the actual age of a document may be of much less importance than often assumed?
|
Syriac Evidence for Primitive Aramaic Gospel Terminology
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
Jan Joosten, Université de Strasbourg
The Old Syriac and Peshitta Gospels, as well as some other early writings such as the Acts of Thomas, transmit a number of terms and expressions that appear to go back to a West Aramaic tradition. In all likelihood, the Greek Gospels were preceded in Mesopotamia by an oral tradition telling the story of Jesus and his deeds in Aramaic. The present paper will take a global look at the evidence and focus on two christological titles (behira "the chosen", memra "the word") of particular theological importance. .
|
The Dictionary of Classical Hebrew— A Philological Appraisal
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Jan Joosten, Université de Strasbourg
The DCH is a monument to the ability of David Clines and his team to get things done. It will be used by linguists and exegetes for years to come. But of course, it is not the last word. The completion of the Dictionary is a good moment to revisit its guiding principles and to evaluate the way they affect the information it offers. In the present paper, this will be done from a philological point of view, taking into account in particular two fundamental decisions, namely: a) to eschew etymological data ; b) to approach "Classical Hebrew" as if it were a synchronic whole.
|
The Reception of the Martyr Texts in 2 Maccabees 6 and 7 in a Multicultural South African Environment
Program Unit: Function of Apocryphal and Pseudepigraphal Writings in Early Judaism and Early Christianity
Pierre Johan Jordaan, North-West University (South Africa)
During the SBL meeting in 2011 Loren Johns made the remark that the Anabaptists used the text 2 Maccabees 6 and 7 as performance hymn during their times of persecution in the Reformation. This provided the impetus to use the martyr texts of 2 Maccabees 6 and 7 as possible texts of encouragement and compassion to contemporary believers in South Africa living in challenging circumstances. These believers are confronted by rampant crime, corruption within government circles and a general sense of being at the end of the food chain. The problem with 2 Maccabees is that it is not accepted as part of the canon for proclamation within this mainly Protestant country. We nevertheless ventured forward making our intention clear within two Protestant denominations to preach from 2 Maccabees. The one was an orthodox group of congregations, the other a group of more liberal congregations. The orthodox Protestant group was not willing to entertain the idea of preaching from the 2 Maccabees. All of them cited articles 4-6 from the Belgic confession, stating that it was forbidden to preach from these books. We were even reprimanded for what we were trying to do. The other group was willing to take a chance and accept the idea of preaching from 2 Maccabees. A scientific questionnaire was compiled to evaluate the reception of this sermon in these congregations. The results of preaching from 2 Maccabees surpassed all our expectations. The applicability and general acceptance of 2 Maccabees was overwhelming. In our research we also encountered certain unforeseen insights into the South African environment. At the same time interesting conclusions about the forming and openness of the canon emerged.
|
The Textual History of Ethiopic Obadiah: Identification and Analysis of Families of Texts in Obadiah within the Context of the Book of the Twelve
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Garry Jost, Marylhurst University
My research is part of the Textual History of the Ethiopic Old Testament Project (THEOT), whose work has included a study on the Ethiopic book of Obadiah. Based on a study of 33 manuscripts of Obadiah, we have identified and analyzed the following families: Oldest Attested Text (traditionally referred to as “Old Ethiopic,” but this title is problematic), Transitional Texts, Standardized Texts, The Modern Textus Receptus Text, and Non-Indigenous Text.
This presentation expands this analysis by comparing the families identified for Obadiah to those identified for other books of The Book of the Twelve, such as Habakkuk and Jonah. For the study of individual books, procedures were developed by the THEOT team, and I wrote computer scripts to 1) calculate percentages of agreement between each manuscript and each other manuscript, 2) color code ranges of percentages, 3) generate a dendrogram (a statistical tool based on hierarchical clustering) to identify the families, 4) determine which readings are best able to identify a manuscript’s family, 5) determine the “family profile” for each manuscript, and 6) identify which manuscript best represents each family.
For the comparison of families within Obadiah to those within other books of The Book of the Twelve, the methodology was adapted and expanded to include analysis between books. Then, additional computer scripts were written to perform these analyses. This presentation will explain the statistical and linguistic characteristics of the families in Obadiah, compared and contrasted to those of the other books of the Book of the Twelve. This study moves us in the direction of a more general understanding of the larger textual history of the Ethiopic Book of the Twelve.
|
Review of the Books Presented
Program Unit: Biblical Literature and the Hermeneutics of Trauma
Paul Joyce, King's College - London
In discussing each of three books presented, the reviewer will focus on methodological issues involved in employing the concept of trauma in biblical interpretation.
|
Sloppy Sowers and Peasant Power: Exploring Some Parabolic Pictures
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Christine E. Joynes, University of Oxford
Although the storytelling techniques of gospel parables have been widely discussed, little work has been done on visual depictions of the parables in art. Picking up on the theme of ‘labour and migration’, this paper will explore artistic representations of labour as found in the parables in Mark’s gospel. Focusing primarily on the parable of the sower, I will examine why this parable was frequently depicted in art, in contrast to other parable narratives that are ignored. On the other hand, I will suggest (developing here the work of Paolo Berdini) that despite superficial appearances, the sower is frequently shown as incompetent, indicating that the images are not intended to show the actual practice of sowing. This is in contrast to the suggestion that, in portraying the sower, artists ‘attempted to elevate peasant work to the level of a symbol, signifying eternal glorification of human work on earth’ (Jure Mikuž). From coins to canvas, stained glass windows to sacred book illuminations, images of 'The Sower' have served a variety of functions. I will bring the well-known images of Van Gogh (1888) and Millais (1864) into dialogue with other less frequently discussed representations, such as Oscar Roty’s 'The Sower' (1887), before concluding with some reflections on the impact of reading the Markan text through the visual images.
|
Anti-Judaic Tendencies among Early Christian Scribes: The Case of Luke 23:17
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Frank F. Judd, Brigham Young University
Anti-Judaism is well-documented within early Christianity. Following Jesus’ death, some early Christian writers emphasized in various ways Jewish responsibility and Roman innocence for the events associated with the crucifixion.
My paper explores this phenomenon through a study of Luke 23:17. The Passion narratives in all four Gospels mention that Pilate released Barabbas instead of Jesus to the Jewish crowds. The Gospels of Matthew, Mark, and John refer to a tradition that a prisoner was released at Passover. There has been less certainty whether or not the Gospel of Luke included a reference to this tradition. The disputed verse is Luke 23:17: “For it was necessary that he release someone unto them at the feast.” Since this verse is absent from a number of Greek manuscripts and different versions, modern critical editions place it in the apparatus and most modern translations relegate it to a footnote.
In my paper, I reevaluate the evidence and argue that Luke 23:17 is, in fact, original. First, I briefly review the manuscript tradition, noting the most important witnesses for and against inclusion of the verse. The crux of my paper is the presentation and evaluation of new evidence for a patristic reference to Luke 23:17 in a catena on Luke attributed to Origen of Alexandria. I then consider the internal evidence, discussing both the intrinsic probability and transcriptional probability for the shorter and longer readings. I conclude that an early Christian scribe excised Luke 23:17, with the result that the later edited narrative exculpates Pilate and inculpates Jews to a greater extent than even the original author of the account intended.
The significance of this study is that it supplies another piece of evidence that anti-Judaism in early Christian thought not only influenced early Christian writers and apologists. It also affected early Christian scribes.
|
'Abd al-Hamid al-Katib's Use of the Qur'an in His Legal, Theological, and Historical Letters
Program Unit: The Qur’an: Manuscripts and Textual Criticism (IQSA)
Wadad Kadi, Oriental Institute, Chicago
In an earlier study, I established that the "founder of Arabic literary prose," 'Abd al-Hamid al-Katib (d. 132/750) used the Qur'an extensively in his letters and explored in detail the various techniques he used in his borrowing from the Qur'an. In this study I wish to study how 'Abd al-Hamid used Qur'anic materials specifically in his theological, legal, and historical letters, addressing such issues as how selective he was in this use; how he mixed it with administrative terminology; how he accommodated alongside it the materials representing the Prophet Muhammad's authority, namely his mission and statements; and how he rephrased the Qur'an to highlight his political and ideological commitments.
|
The Death of Josiah at Megiddo
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Dan'el Kahn, University of Haifa
Josiah's death is described in 2 Kgs and 2 Chr. While the version in Kgs is vague, for historiographical reasons, the versions in 2 Chron and in later traditions blame the righteous Josiah for disobeying the word of God, which led to his punishment by being killed in battle. However, when reconstructing the historical reality on the basis of extra-biblical sources, it is possible to reject the claim that a war between Necho II and Josiah led to the latter's death. I will propose an alternate reason for why a meeting between both Kings took place at Megiddo and will suggest, based on Egyptian parallels, that Josiah's death should be regarded as capital punishment for his behavior. Finally, a possible mode of execution will be advanced, based on Egyptian judicial practices.
|
The Incurable Wound and the Perfectible Body in Jeremiah
Program Unit: Writing/Reading Jeremiah
Amy Kalmanofsky, Jewish Theological Seminary of America
The image of the incurable wound, found throughout the Bible’s prophetic books, is prominent in the book of Jeremiah (Jer 8:22; 14:17; 15:18; 30:12-15; 46:11; 51:8-9). Often viewed as a convention of ancient Near Eastern curses, this paper argues that the incurable wound is a vital part of prophetic corporeal discourse, which articulates a dynamic inherent in the divine-human relationship, and reveals a distinction in the biblical depiction of male and female bodies. I begin by considering the image of the wound within the context of ancient Near Eastern ideas of disease and healing. I then present a close reading of several passages in Jeremiah that depict the wound, addressing questions of rhetorical purpose, and identifying common features that characterize the image. Finally, I consider the image within in the context of the idea of the perfectible body as considered by Kenneth R. Dutton. For Dutton, the perfectible body is an ideal body that depicts the body not as it is, but as it “could or should be.” In Greek art and culture, the perfectible body is exemplified by the image of the athlete. In contemporary culture, it is the image of the body builder or the physically enhanced celebrity. In the Bible, I argue, the perfectible body is the circumcised body—the male body rendered ideal through a genital wound. In contrast, the wounded body, as portrayed by Jeremiah, is an imperfect body. It is a source of impurity, which often is gendered female.
|
Did Job's Friends Get It All Wrong? Recovering a Nuanced Understanding of Biblical Retribution
Program Unit: Jewish-Christian Dialogue and Sacred Texts
Joel S. Kaminsky, Smith College
Contemporary readings of Job often see Job as not only winning the argument but also as demonstrating the falseness of the widespread biblical view that God rewards the righteous and punishes the wicked. In this paper I ask whether such readings not only simplify the view of divine recompense found in other biblical books but also impede our ability to read Job in a fully nuanced fashion.
|
Juxtaposition of Psalms 110 and 111
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Dae I. Kang, Golden Gate Baptist Theological Seminary (Mill Valley)
This paper argues that Psalms 110 and 111 are intentionally juxtaposed from analyzing the lexical, genre/structural, and thematic connections and from the editor’s strategy using the juxtaposition of the royal and wisdom psalms as in Psalms 1 and 2.
It has been generally considered that Psalms 110 and 111 belong to the different blocks; Psalms 107-110, and Psalms 111-118. However, from the connection between Psalms 110 and 111, the fact that Psalms 110 and 111 are purposefully arranged will be observed and the meaning of their juxtaposition will be discussed.
|
Continuity in Discontinuity: ‘Light’ as a Thematic Link between Deutero-Isaiah and Trito-Isaiah
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Niranjan Kanmury, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
In the last three decades, there has been an ever growing interest among Biblical scholars for a holistic reading of the book of Isaiah, thus leading to the rediscovery of its unity. A majority of scholars, instead of highlighting discontinuity, now pay special attention to the interconnections among the three parts. Scholars have taken different approaches in arguing for the unity of the book. Some have done so on the basis of common themes and intertextualities, while others have applied Redactional analysis (Steck, Rendtorff) and Literary approaches (Muilenburg, Conrad, Miscall). Even though the final part of the book (56-66) apparently presents a new theological perspective in a different historical context, there are numerous quotations, restatements of or allusions to ideas found in earlier chapters. Scholars have highlighted various recurring themes like salvation, Zion/ Jerusalem, servant(s), way, righteousness, destiny of nation, etc.
In the scholarly literature not enough attention has been paid, however, to the rich light terminology found in this book (except for a brief article by R.E. Clements), even though terms for light occur remarkably often in it. This paper will, therefore, focus on the light imagery in Isa 40-66. On the one hand, a closer examination of the light theme in this corpus will illustrate how the theme of light - an important metaphor of salvation - is gradually and progressively developed in the final part of the book. On the other hand, it will be argued that light metaphors constitute a unifying factor in the book of Isaiah. Taking a diachronic approach, I analyze how TI consciously and purposefully builds upon the previous core of oral/written texts of Isaiah, particularly 40-55. It will be shown that the nations being drawn towards the splendour of Jerusalem’s salvation (60:1-3, 62:1-2) can be seen as a Fortschreibung of Deutero-Isaiah’s mission to be ‘a light to the nations’ (42:6, 49:6).
|
A Biblical Approach to Politics: Differentiation, Organic Morality, and Embrace of the Future
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
Kalman J. Kaplan, University of Illinois at Chicago
Our paper is about a Biblical approach to politics. For the Bible, government is a means to improve human life, to give a maximum of opportunity for people to grow and develop in faith, individuality and creativity. We contrast the Biblical view with ancient Graeco-Roman views, and we will draw implications for modern political life and society regarding three areas of important contrast: 1) differentiation/individuation versus uniformity/ conformity, 2) organic morality versus abstract equilibrium, and 3) hope versus fear regarding the future.
First, Plato elevates being over becoming in the sense of preferring the abstract Idea of something rather than the real, singular thing in itself. Individual differences themselves are suspect, despite pretensions to the opposite. The ideal form for Plato provides the glue that holds life together. Thus, the idea of humankind is superior to the real person. The biblical view, in contrast, views each separate person as created uniquely in God’s image rather than demanding uniformity and conformity. Indeed the book of Genesis can serve as a political primer allowing differentiations: day from night; earth from water from sky; mammals from birds from fish; man from woman; the six days of the week from the Sabbath.
Second, the biblical view of society and politics emphasizes an organic sense of morality rather than fixate on an abstract philosophical equilibrium. For Aeschylus, the land is almost an animate force demanding its due. The murder of Agamemnon has caused pollution in the land, and chthonic deities as well as the spirit of the slain cry for vengeance in the blood of the murderer. Without this the land cannot avoid the curses of its pollution. The Biblical view is very different. A person is not an abstract unit but a living being but a precious creation made in the image of God (Genesis 1:26, 2:7). Human life is the most precious entity, and it is preserving life itself that is important, not satisfying a mythical effect of a crime.. A soul is not an abstraction but a living human being. The biblical political view addresses concrete human actions. Crimes must be addressed to preserve justice, not to preserve an abstract equilibrium
Third, the biblical sense of faith in the future is contrasted with the Greek fear of the future. The Greek fear is expressed in the story of Oedipus, whose father Laius fears that he will be overcome by his son and he attempts to kill him. The outcome is tragic, leading to incest between Oedipus and his mother, which though not intentional, becomes a pollutant in Thebes. The Biblical view is very different, embracing the future and preserving and fostering the continuity of a family and of a society. This is true even when such continuity is occasioned by an action which ordinarily would not be condoned, such as purposeful incest of Lot’s daughters with him, with the goal of preserving the human species.
|
The Place That the Lord Your God Will Choose
Program Unit: Book of Deuteronomy
Magnar Kartveit, School of Mission & Theology (Misjonshogskolen i Stavanger) (Norway)
The phrase "The place that the Lord your God will choose" is the standard text in the masoretic text of Deut 12:5.11.14.18 etc., while the Samaritan Pentateuch reads "The place that the Lord your God has chosen." This phrase is almost exclusively found in Deut 12-26, which is supposed to be the oldest part of Deuteronomy. If parts of Deuteronomy has a Northern origin, do chapters 12-26 also come from the north? And if so, does the masoretic text reflect the original reading of the phrase mentioned? This presentation will discuss this question and present possible answers.
|
Talkative Bodies: Slaves as Gossipers, News Bearers, and Fortune-Tellers in New Testament Texts
Program Unit: Gender, Sexuality, and the Bible
Marianne Kartzow, Universitetet i Oslo
Although characterized as bodies or things, enslaved persons seem to play several important roles in the social fabric of the ancient Mediterranean world. Slaves position at the bottom of the ranking system, - at times outside all human classifications, - gave them access to news and information that privileged persons needed to survive. Recent theories of intersectionality insisting that gender, sexuality, social class, ethnicity, and age mutually construct each other may help interpreters to read New Testament texts on slaves dealing with storytelling, information management and gossip in new ways.
|
Consuming Jesus—Receiving Eternity: Meal Elements of Special Quality in Johannine Communities
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
Vojtech Kaše, University of Helsinki
Drawing on some theories and concepts from symbolic anthropology and ritual studies, recent scholarship on early Christian meal practices has paid considerable attention to their function by formation of early Christian identities. The goal of this paper is to complement these insights by using some cognitive theories of ritual, enabling to analyze meal practices on the level of psychological mechanisms underlying their cognitive processing. The hypothesis is that these mechanisms were in some extent responsible for formation of interpretation of meal elements as disposing special quality, which can be documented in early Christian sources of different provenience since the end of the first century (e.g. Did. 9:5; Ign. Smyr. 7, Eph. 20; Just. 1 Apol. 66). It will be argued that formation of these interpretations was driven by cognitive mechanisms responsible for evaluation of ritual efficacy, activated in the meal context by invention of social restrictions (restrictions of participation and presiding) in the processes of ritualization. From this perspective, conceptual blending of meal elements with Jesus and their ingestion with gain of eternity in John 6 will be analyzed as reflecting this interpretation in given community and thus comparable to extant alternatives.
|
The Traditional Ethiopian Commentary on the Animal Apocalypse of Enoch
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Daneil Assefa, Capuchin Friary, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia
The Animal Apocalypse (1En 85-90), an interesting piece of 1Enoch, has been the occasion of various scholarly discussions. Among others, the following questions are very much debated: In which socio-historical context was the Animal Apocalypse written? What was the purpose of writing the Animal apocalypse? Which community was responsible for the text? The aim of this paper is however not to deal with these legitimate and important issues. The focus would rather be on the reception of this text in an Ethiopian context. Based on Ge'ez and Amharic commentaries, this paper will deal with the way that the Animal Apocalypse is read and interpreted in Ethiopia.
|
Collyridian Déjà vu Part Two: Male and Female Altar Priests
Program Unit: Maria, Mariamne, Miriam: Rediscovering the Marys
Ally Kateusz, University of Missouri - Kansas City
This paper follows my recent research (JFSR 29.2) where, based on the markers of priesthood associated with the Virgin Mary in the oldest nearly complete Dormition manuscript, I argue that some early Christians probably believed that Mary had been a Eucharistic priest. Here I propose a defense for Michel van Esbroeck’s translation of the Last Supper scene in the oldest Life of the Virgin manuscript. Van Esbroeck insisted that the Last Supper’s Eucharistic ritual could only be translated as a scene where first Mary sacrificed and then Jesus sacrificed. Some early Christian iconographical and literary artifacts provide similar or close depictions of male and female co-priests, a pattern consistent with van Esbroeck’s translation.
Both Stephen J. Shoemaker and van Esbroeck agreed that the Life of the Virgin was probably written by the monk Maximus the Confessor (580 – 662) in Constantinople. The first artifact will thus be the mid-sixth-century apse mosaics above the altar in San Vitale in Ravenna, which depict Emperor Justinian holding up the platen and Empress Theodora holding the chalice, with her women standing nearby. These mosaics are followed by artifacts that illustrate the antiquity and geographical dispersion of co-priesting in some Christian circles. An imperial co-priesthood in Constantinople, for example, is buttressed by the custom of Pulcheria and her brother Theodosius II in the altar area of Hagia Sophia, where Pulcheria’s women similarly stood with her, and Pulcheria’s portrait similarly hung above the altar. The imperial tradition is also seen in the Samagher reliquary box and the Martydom of Matthew. Artifacts of early Christian co-priests are found in the Acts of Philip, the Sahidic Statutes of the Apostles, the Didascalia, and a Callistus catacomb fresco. The oldest surviving account is Ireneus’ description of Marcus and a woman performing the Eucharistic ritual in second-century Gaul.
|
Defending a Day of Idleness: The Sabbath between Romans and Rabbis
Program Unit: Sabbath in Text and Tradition
Sarit Kattan Gribetz, Fordham University
Despite the Roman Empire’s official policies tolerating the observance of “ancestral rites” by those within its territories, there was no shortage of polemics launched against the Jews and their Sabbath, much of it preserved in Greek and Latin literary and satirical sources and later Christian texts. Agatharchides of Cnidus, Apion, Seneca, Persius, Tacitus, Juvenal, Martial, Dio Cassius, Plutarch, Frontinus, Rutilius Namatianus, Pseudo-Ignatius, and the fifth-century author of the Brevis Expositio in Vergilii Georgica, all mock the Sabbath or express skepticism about its observance. Given the widespread polemics against the Sabbath found in Greek and Roman texts, one might ask: are there rabbinic sources that betray awareness of these polemical ideas, and that attempt to argue against such views?
I have identified several instances in which rabbinic narratives about the Sabbath gain new meaning when understood as responses to specific polemical ideas popular in Greek and Roman literature of the period. Genesis Rabbah 11 and Bavli Shabbat 119a-b, both of which preserve extended narratives about the Sabbath, contain stories about the deliciousness of Sabbath food and drink, the pleasant aroma of the Sabbath, the strategic benefit of Sabbath observance in military contexts, and the unwitting observance of the Sabbath by a Roman elite (none other than the father of Jerusalem’s governor, Tinneus Rufus, as he resides in the afterworld!). These stories – which are typically told in the form of a dialogue between a rabbi and a Roman official – are best understood as responses to accusations that Sabbath food was cold and tasteless, that Sabbath observers omitted unpleasant odors, that the Jews owed their many military defeats to their senseless idleness on the Sabbath, and warnings to fellow Romans not to join the Jews in the celebration of the Sabbath.
These rabbinic passages are not addressed at the rabbis’ Greco-Roman interlocutors, however. They are directed, instead, at other Jews, encouraging them to remain (or become) pious Sabbath observers despite critiques from outsiders. The passages identified, then, are instances of internal rabbinic engagement with others: counter-polemics formed in the context of external polemics against Jewish practice but directed inward to encourage more vigilant observance by Jews.
|
The Holiday of Every-Day: Reflections on Philo's Festival Manual
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Sarit Kattan Gribetz, Fordham University
In Book Two of his Special Laws, Philo presents his readers with a “festival manual,” a list of ten holidays, their origins, and the practices associated with each one. Philo begins with a festival he calls the “every day,” about which he muses: “if all the powers of the virtues remained in all respects unsubdued, then the whole time from a man's birth to his death would be one uninterrupted festival, and all houses and every city would pass their time in continual fearlessness and peace, being full of every imaginable blessing, enjoying perfect tranquility” (Spec. 2.41). To Philo’s great disappointment, most men and women find themselves too occupied with mundane matters to turn each day into a festival. Only “practitioners of wisdom” are able to shun market places, council halls, and courts of justice to commune, instead, with the moon, sun, and stars and to contemplate from this philosophically-elevated vantage point the world’s true powers. “These men,” Philo writes, “pass the whole of their lives as a festival… So that the whole circle of the year would be one festival.” The first half of this paper analyzes Philo’s detailed exposition of this “everyday” festival; the idea of elevating the quotidian to the sacred through philosophical contemplation; possible sources and parallels for Philo’s notion of an everyday-festival; the intriguing relationship Philo presents between space, place, and time; and the role that this meditation on time plays in framing Philo’s larger project.
In the remainder of the festival manual, Philo proceeds to outline the other nine festivals in order of their frequency and calendrical placement: the Sabbath, the day of the new moon, three festivals related to Passover, Pentecost, Rosh Hashanah, Yom Kippur, and the Feast of Tabernacles. The festival manual can thus be read as a kind of a prosaic calendar – a meditation on the Jewish week, month, and year – and provides a view into the organization of Jewish diasporic time as Philo imagines it. Through Philo’s descriptions of each festival, however, Philo also imprints universal cosmic-natural time and Jewish historical time onto the days of the Jewish calendar. The second half of this paper thus explores Philo’s festival manual as an example of how cosmic and historical time become integrated into and enacted through a community’s calendar.
|
Solomon at Gibeon: How the Comparison between the Accounts in Kings and Chronicles Contribute to Our Understanding of the Formation of the Book of Kings
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Shira Katz, University of Haifa
In this lecture, I shall compare the parallel accounts of Solomon at Gibeon in 1 Kings 3:4-15 and 2 Chronicles 1:2-13 in order to identify the source that lay before the Chronicler. I start by presenting the prevalent scholarly view arguing that Chronicles constitutes a reworking of Samuel-Kings, and the divergences between the narratives in these two sets of texts directly reflect the Chronicler’s agenda. Chronicles is therefore regarded as secondary version of the Deuteronomistic History's narratives. I then discuss the story of Solomon at Gibeon as a test case for an alternative understanding of the relationship between Chronicles and Kings. The general structure of the story is similar in the two versions. A thorough analysis of several of the disparities suggests that the text that lay before the Chronicler differed from the text of Kings known to us today. In the case of Solomon at Gibeon, Chronicles is based on an earlier edition of the book of Kings.
I proceed to considering the various layers of the story in the extant version of Kings, identifying three strata: a) an ancient story composed at the beginning of the monarchy; b) a Deuteronomistic editing of this source, dated to the end of the First Temple period; and c) the final reworking of the story by a scribe in the spirit of the Deuteronomist school during the Babylonian exile. My assumption is that the Solomon in Gibeon story known to the Chronicler consisted only of the first two strata.
In conclusion I present a broader offer, according to which in some cases Chronicles preserves an edition of the Book Kings different from the one known to us today. At least one more literary stage in the development of Kings took place between these two editions- a layer containing additions and changes characteristic of the Deutronomistic School was added.
|
The Text-Historical Position of Lucifer of Cagliari in Samuel-Kings
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Historical Books
Tuukka Kauhanen, University of Helsinki
The quotations by Lucifer of Cagliari (ca. 360 CE) are the most important pre-Vulgate Latin witness for the text of Samuel-Kings. While a thorough text-critical analysis of these quotations is still a desideratum, the surveys done so far clearly demonstrate that Lucifer is neither a witness for the kaige text, nor for the Lucianic text. Lucifer’s quotations provide an uncontinuous text in Latin. Is it, nevertheless, possible to determine which textual group or family of Greek manuscripts they are closest to? What special issues have to be taken into account when using this kind of indirect and uncontinuous evidence in establishing its putative Greek Vorlage and, ultimately, the oldest attainable Greek text?
|
The Good Man Jesus and Philip Pullman’s Use of Sources
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Thomas Kazen, Stockholm School of Theology
Although Philip Pullman’s The Good Man Jesus and the Scoundrel Christ (2010) did not claim to reconstruct a historical figure it caused quite some stir when it appeared. Two conspicuous traits of Pullman’s novel are his blending of sources and his use of extra-canonical and legendary material. Interestingly, similar tendencies have been found in historical Jesus research. When source material is limited scholars as well as authors of fiction seek to extend their database. This paper points out some similarities and differences between Pullman and historical Jesus scholarship.
|
Apocalyptic Class Politics in Herodian Judaea: Rethinking the Socioeconomic Contexts of the Psalms of Solomon, Testament of Moses, and Parables of Enoch
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
G. Anthony Keddie, University of Texas at Austin
With the Psalms of Solomon, Testament of Moses, and Parables of Enoch, Judaean apocalypticism takes on three different literary genres, messianisms, and eschatologies. All three pseudepigrapha, however, converge in their rhetoric of class exploitation. The contingency of human mortality on material means of subsistence is a major theme in these non-sectarian apocalyptic discourses, as the “difficulty of poverty” (Pss. Sol. 16.14) is cast variously as a punishment for sin, marker of righteous perseverance, and sign of the end times. For the most part, scholars have either overlooked the significance of socioeconomic exploitation in these texts or have taken it as an accurate indication of widespread socioeconomic oppression under the Herods. However, many historians and archaeologists have argued in recent years that the evidence does not support the familiar scholarly theory of sweeping socioeconomic oppression under the Herods. What, then, is the language of socioeconomic inequality doing in these texts? My thesis is that each text employs the rhetoric of class exploitation in order to wage a political critique, portraying poverty as the fault of rulers and their supporters who allegedly become wealthy through processes of deception and consumption that impoverish the “righteous.” I make my argument in three sections. First, I engage with recent scholarship that destabilizes the picture of a hyper-exploitative socioeconomic situation in the Herodian period. Second, I advance particular Herodian date ranges for the three texts in question. Third, I closely examine the ways that wealth and poverty are linked to consumption and deception in crucial passages (Pss. Sol. 4:6-22; 5:8-17; 16:12-15; T. Mos. 7:1-10; 1 En. 46.4-8; 53:1-6; 63:1-12) in order to demonstrate that these “revelations” of structural inequality do not reveal or reflect, but refract, the particular social and economic relations in Herodian Judaea. These critiques, written by disenchanted scribes of considerable means, were not aimed at the liberation of the poor, but at the propagandistic delegitimation of political authorities with whom they vied for power.
|
A Demon after God's Own Heart: 'Absalom, Absalom!' as Biblical Interpretation
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Kyle Keefer, Converse College
Just as the title of William Faulkner’s novel Absalom, Absalom! alludes to David’s cry over his son in 2 Samuel 18:33, so also the characters in the book parallel those in the Succession Narrative of 2 Samuel 9-20. These similarities between the biblical text and Faulkner’s novel have been noted often and are patently obvious to any reader of Faulkner who has even basic familiarity with 2 Samuel.
Literary critics, however, have made surprisingly few attempts to explore the dynamics of the relationship between the Hebrew Bible and the novel. Some investigations, such as Ralph Behrens’s influential study from 1974, have cogently argued that Faulkner uses the biblical story to comment on Southern society. This line of criticism views the downfall of the Davidic kingdom (more specifically the “Beth David”) as a precursor to the crumbling of the Old South and its various social structures. Most treatments of the novel, however, either ignore the biblical connections or see them as a skeletal framework on which Faulkner built his narrative.
My paper will explore only one of the many intertextual connections between Absalom, Absalom! and the Succession Narrative—namely the characterizations of David and Thomas Sutpen as flawed patriarchs. I am not interested in simply drawing parallels between the two, but rather I wish to argue that Faulkner’s portrayal of Sutpen evidences a complex reading of the Davidic narrative and that, conversely, the Succession Narrative proleptically “reads” Thomas Sutpen with a similar complexity.
As a side note, drawing on the work of Robert Alter, I will devote a small portion of my paper (separately or interspersed with my main argument) to a comparison of Faulkner’s interpretation of Samuel with those of biblical critics and literary critics. Part of my argument is that Faulkner’s nuanced view of the character of David overlaps strikingly with biblical literary criticism (late 20th century in particular). Furthermore, the lack of attention to the biblical echoes in Absalom, Absalom! stems from literary critics’ lack of familiarity with biblical criticism.
|
Miracles: Philosophic and Historical Plausibility
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Craig Keener, Asbury Theological Seminary
This is the 2014 Annual Lecture for the Institute for Biblical Research.
|
David's Swan Song: Psalm 144 and Its Place in the Shaping of the Psalter
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Hubert James Keener, Wheaton College (Illinois)
Since Gerald Wilson published his groundbreaking dissertation in 1980, Psalms scholarship has focused much of its attention upon questions of the significance of the final shape of the Psalter, both for Second Temple readers and for contemporary readers. Nevertheless, as this paper will argue, Psalm 144 has not received due attention corresponding to the pivotal role it plays as a) part of the frame of the book of Psalms and b) part of the conclusion of the body of the Psalter. The paper begins with a brief survey of the history of scholarship, highlighting ways in which Psalm 144 has been overlooked at times as a key psalm in the final form of the Psalter. From there, I highlight several ways in which Psalm 144 plays a key strategic role in closing out the book of Psalms: 1) As the final Davidic psalm and 2) as the final royal psalm, it represents the last words of the Psalter addressing questions concerning the status of the literary figure of David and the status of the Davidic royal line. 3) As a quasi-catena that adapts and draws upon material from several other psalms that precede it in the Psalter (Pss 8, 18, 33), it rounds out the end of the Psalter by revisiting themes from early in the Psalter. 3) In light of the frequent juxta-position of royal and wisdom psalms at the “seams” of the Psalter elsewhere, it may be read in connection with Psalm 145, a wisdom psalm, as part of a final “seam” that brings the body of the book to a close and paves the way for the concluding Hillel (Pss 146-150). It will be argued that, by overlooking the key role Psalm 144 plays in the macro-structure of the Psalter, Wilson (and others) have subtly misconstrued the final form of the Psalter as “muting” the royal frame and downplaying the (presumably failed) Davidic covenant. A proper appreciation of the role of Psalm 144 shows how the final form of the Psalter strategically brings the body of the book of Psalms to a close by allowing David to speak one last time, reminding the reader that the Davidic covenant is not defunct, despite evidence to the contrary.
|
The Role of Small Forms within the Thematic Discourse of Pirqei deRabbi Eliezer
Program Unit: Midrash
Katharina Keim, University of Manchester
It is misleading to classify Pirqei deRabbi Eliezer (PRE) as a Midrash. If a text like Bere’shit Rabbah is taken as a paradigm of midrashic form then PRE does not belong to this genre, despite the fact that it is, like Bere’shit Rabbah, structured in some sense by the text of Genesis and Exodus. Bere’shit Rabbah is constructed out of a series of lemmata + comments where the lemmata follow the order of the biblical text, and form the skeleton of the work. If they are removed the work collapses into a heap of disjointed statements. PRE, however, is not in the lemma + comment form. It does shadow the content of Genesis and Exodus, but only in a general way, and sometimes it takes the biblical material out of order. It is as much structured by external lists as it is by the Bible – the Ten Trials of Abraham, the Ten Descents of the Shekhinah, though only eight appear in the extant work, and the Berakhot of the Amidah, though, again, not all of these appear in the text as we now have it. PRE is better classified as a series of thematic discourses, in which Genesis-Exodus suggests the themes, or, to look at it in a different way, provides pegs on which to hang certain pre-determined themes. This paper will look specifically at the role of small forms in creating coherence within the thematic discourses which go to make up PRE. It will concentrate on classic small forms such as meshalim, ma‘asim, lists, and petihot. It will show that, although these small forms are well-attested in classic Rabbinic literature, they are, in fact, used in PRE in a distinctive way, thus, once again, highlighting its innovative literary character.
|
The Competitive Textualization of the Jesus Tradition John 20:30–31 and 21:25
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Chris Keith, St. Mary's University (Twickenham)
This paper will argue that John 20:30–31 and 21:25 attest a competitive textualization of the oral Johannine gospel tradition, whereby the author of the Fourth Gospel intentionally moves the tradition into the manuscript medium in order to rival extant textualized versions of the Jesus story. By building critically upon the prior work of Thatcher, and also by giving attention to elements within the narrative of the Fourth Gospel, I will argue that John 20:30–31 and 21:25 constitute underappreciated indications of the Fourth Gospel’s knowledge of the Synoptic Gospels, which are the only certain prior Jesus books.
|
Synoptic Questions: Intertextuality, Stemmatology, Archetype
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Werner Kelber, Rice University
This presentation will be a response to the previous papers concerning the Synoptic Problem and ancient media culture.
|
Toward a Media-Sensitive History of Early Christianity
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Werner Kelber, Rice University
This paper discusses early Christian traditions and the beginnings of the Jesus movement in the context of ancient communications media. The first part focuses on the material and technical aspects of the verbal arts in antiquity. Among the features explored are oral and scribal word processing, scribal activism, the performative, recitational function of chirographs, the behavior of the early papyrological tradition, and more. The second part explains how media technologies mobilize the human sensorium and cognitive faculties. Among the features to be explored are the emotive powers of speech and acoustic apperception, interior visualization, and a range of mechanisms generated by the ars memoriae. The third part seeks to develop the oral-scribal-memorial-performative paradigm in distinction from the classic historical, documentary model which is perceived to be entrenched in typographic modes of thinking.
|
Philosophy, Science, and Christian Belief
Program Unit: Westar Institute
John C. Kelly, University of Nevada, Reno
*
|
A Discipline by Any Other Name? Intertextuality, Inner-Biblical Exegesis, Echoes, and Allusion
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Joseph Ryan Kelly, Southern Seminary
Signs are arbitrary, or so modern linguistics teaches us. What difference does it make if we frame the discussion of literary influence in terms of "intertextuality," "inner-biblical exegesis," "echoes," or "allusions"? A discipline by any other name—it is all the same, right? A survey of the trends in works loosely associated with one another through this complex web of terminology suggests otherwise. I draw attention to the theoretical distinctions between these various modes of scholarly discussion while assessing the value of this work within our discipline and how it promises to contribute to (or distract from) larger, interdisciplinary interests. Despite the linguistic realities we have learned from the modern study of the linguistic sign, I argue that our language has a practical impact on the nature of our discussion inasmuch as it motivates or discourages our attention to important critical questions. I propose that we can unite our common interests around one particular model that would provide cross-disciplinary theory and terminology for the general interest in literary influence within biblical studies.
|
Amos and Wisdom
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Rainer Kessler, Philipps-Universität Marburg
Half a century ago, in his book “Amos’ geistige Heimat” (1964), Hans Walter Wolff observed a vast amount of wisdom elements in Amos. He explained these as biographical: for him Amos was one of the wise men of the town of Tekoa. Scholarship since then has become more sceptical. It has been demonstrated that it is nearly impossible to reconstruct the biography of a prophet. However, Wolff’s observations on the text remain valid. This paper tries to explain them not through the biography of the prophet, but through the biography of the scribes, who wrote down the words of Amos.
The social transformation, which began in the eighth century BCE provoked a threefold response. First, prophets criticised social injustice, and these words were subsequently written down. Second, the codification of the law and the redaction of law codes began (Covenant Code). And third, wisdom traditions were collected and redacted (Prov 25:1). The scribes who wrote down prophetic oracles, who codified and redacted laws, and who collected and redacted proverbs, were perhaps not the same people. However, they shared the same scribal education (see van der Toorn and Carr). Furthermore, they shared the same fundamental theological ideas in face of on-going social transformation, namely an “option for the poor and weak” and the conviction that the development towards class stratification is against the will of God. My paper will demonstrate this by comparing oracles from the book of Amos with selected proverbs from the book of Proverbs.
|
Sacrifice on the Cross or Offering after the Cross? The History and Significance of a Key Issue in Hebrews’ View of the Atonement
Program Unit: Hebrews
Michael Kibbe, Wheaton College Graduate School
All explorations of Hebrews’ view of the “atonement” begin with an answer to this question: does the sacrificial imagery in Hebrews depict a literal process that begins with (but quickly moves on from) Jesus’ death on the cross, or does it entail a metaphorical unpacking of the cross itself? In other words: did Jesus offer himself literally on the cross and metaphorically in the heavenly sanctuary, or did the sacrificial sequence begin on the cross but climax with a literal offering in heaven?
This paper explores two facets of the history of this question. First, it offers a brief history of the debate in four stages: 1) Faustus Socinus’s De Jesu Christo Servatore (1578) provides the earliest explicit affirmation of the “literal process” view; 2) the Reformed tradition strongly opposed Socinus on both exegetical and theological grounds (e.g., Turretin, Owen, Bavinck); 3) from the mid-18th century to the mid-19th century, both “literal process” and “metaphorical” views enjoyed significant scholarly support, with the former holding a slight edge; 4) recent decades witnessed the near disappearance of the “literal process” view, up until its recent resurgence thanks to the work of David Moffitt.
Second, I explore the relationship between this issue in Hebrews’ atonement theology and three other issues: penal substitution, the ascension, and the humanity/deity of Jesus in Hebrews. First, I note that no proponent of the “literal process” view finds room for penal substitution in Hebrews—certainly Jesus did not enter the heavenly sanctuary in our place, but rather quite the opposite: he did so in order that others could follow in his steps. Second, I suggest that while one rarely finds mention of Jesus’ ascension in atonement literature, and certainly the “metaphorical” reading of Hebrews eliminates such a possibility, the “literal process” view offers a way of bringing ascension and atonement together. Third, in keeping with Socinus’s anti-Trinitarian stance, I have yet to find a scholar who sees in the divinity of Jesus—however defined—a significant element of “literal process” atonement theology in Hebrews.
|
Spiritual and Transformative Connections: Women’s Stories of Ecofeminist Activism and Artistic Expression
Program Unit:
Jeanette Larino Wooden Kiel, California Institute of Integral Studies
*
|
"Wild Animals Shall Devour Them": Rewilding in the Bible and Today
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Micah D. Kiel, Saint Ambrose University
Rewilding is a movement within ecology that attempts to integrate conservation biology with wildlands and wildlife conservation. Rewilding efforts across the globe create large swaths of connected ecosystems, where all flora and fauna, especially megafauna, are free to live and interact in the way that natural selection has caused them to evolve symbiotically across the eons. There are several biblical texts that interface with the idea of rewilding in interesting ways. In Amos 2, for instance, God pronounces that the work of humanity will return to wildness; cultivated places will become a “forest” and the wild animals will return. In a different way, the Wisdom of Solomon, in its opening chapters, presumes the inherent good of the created order: “the generative forces of the world are wholesome, and there is no destructive poison in them” (1:14 NRSV). In the next chapter, the author subverts the idea of exploiting the created order because anything that is weak is useless (2:11). Scripturally speaking, both from God’s point of view (as represented by the text) and from the perspective of the ethical demands on humanity, there is inherent worth in letting creation alone, to “let it do its thing” without human intervention, which is the very ideological underpinning of the rewilding movement. These connections will be explored and evaluated exegetically, historically, and theologically.
|
The Bible as Psychological Object: Sacred Text, Holy Object, Boundary Marker
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
D. Andrew Kille, BibleWorkbench
Years ago, Paul Pruyser of the Menninger Foundation wrote about an illustrated children’s Bible that served him and his siblings as a “transitional object,” an external bearer of significant psychological energy and an important part of his own development process. While much attention has been given to the psychological factors at play in the creation, transmission, and interpretation of the Bible as a text, the psychic import of the Bible as a physical object remains relatively unexplored. This paper will look at how the Bible as a physical object and/or a mental image functions psychologically to construct identity, behavior, and ritual, with special reference to the King James Only movement in Protestantism and the ritual use of the Bible in African exorcism rituals.
|
Habakkuk, Man of Joy? The Reception History of the Book of Habakkuk in the Korean Church
Program Unit: Asian and Asian-American Hermeneutics
Baek Hee Kim, Brite Divinity School (TCU)
This paper investigates the reception history of the book of Habakkuk in Korean Christianity and analyzes how the first text, Habakkuk’s original message, has changed into a quite different text in the Korean religious culture. This project sets forth with the problem that the use of the book of Habakkuk in the Korean church has been highly selective. Various forms of reception of Habakkuk, including sermons, devotional and Bible study materials, and popular Christian songs, are exclusively based on two small portions (Habakkuk 2:4b and 3:17-19) of the whole corpus. Habakkuk’s anger and complaint, which are prominent in the book, have been excluded in a narrow focus on faith (2:4b) and joy (3:17-19). By utilizing insights from Reception History, this paper 1) examines how the Korean church has emphasized, modified, or omitted the message of Habakkuk; 2) demonstrates that the Korean Protestant Church has interpreted the book of Habakkuk at an individual and a generic level and has emphasized soteriological, Christological, and evangelical understanding of the text with particular attention to joy and thanksgiving; 3) discusses socio-political and cultural factors that stimulate the interpretation and the impact of the reception in Korean society. This investigation, consequently, argues authoritarian and dictatorial regimes in the 1960s and the 1970s were significantly influential in the production and development of the abstract, individual, and evangelical reception of the book of Habakkuk in the Korean church, and this reception has eventually resulted in a passive social engagement of the Church in Korean society.
|
Identity, Koinonia, and Moral Formation in Philippians in the Urban Context of Roman Imperialism
Program Unit: Polis and Ekklesia: Investigations of Urban Christianity
Duk Ki Kim, Daejeon Theological University
It is interesting to note that koinonia motif for group identity cohesion (Phil. 1:5-7, 2:1, 1:27-30, 3:10, 4:1-4, 4:14-15) was entangled with Stoic sense of moral formation for individual identity cohesion such as self-sufficiency (4:11-2), self-mastery (3:7-14, 4:8-9), and the famous stoic distinction (1:10) between ta diapheronta (things which matter) and ta adiaphora (things which do not matter). Thus it is so worthwhile to explore how both rhetoric of koinonia and Stoic sense of moral formation together are intended to enhance creative Christian identity even in the cultural convention in which Roman civilizing ethos of friendship is allied with political strategy of incorporating provinces into Roman political system. We also ask why these seemingly contradictory exhortations are necessitated and what kind of Roman imperialism these ethical teachings most likely function to cope against. These critical questions for de-colonial interpretation are raised to develop another ‘critical re-imagination', being inspired by Kahl’s reinterpretation of Galatians against Roman imperialism.
For the sake of an advanced inquiry into those questions, this research critically evaluates not as much Campbell and Tucker’s micro-level of identity formation study as Perkins and Revel’s macro-level of this study to answer the question of Paul’s identity politics facing Roman imperialism in Philippian province. This critical review is designed to examine the issue of how micro-level of identity formation to overcome inner conflict of political hegemony is related with macro-level of social identity to solve outer conflict with Roman political domination and imperial ideology of Romanization. This critical reflection on recent trend of identity formation study highly convinces us to presuppose that Christian identity politics of koinonia in Philippians’ urban setting is embattled against Roman identity politics of Romanization in Philippian urban life due to its imposed urbanism on Philippian rural natives. In this sense, this study argues that Stoic sense of moral formation is shaped to create Christian identity in the midst of Romanized urban setting against imperial ideology of urbanism, while Paul’s rhetoric of koinonia alongside with Paul’s other political rhetoric such as 'politeuesthai'(1:27-30) and ‘politeuma’ (3:27-30) is a kind of anti-imperialistic strategy for disseminating ‘hidden transcript’ of anti-urbanism. Thus, for this research project was raised three interrelated questions in detail as follows: (1) How does Paul’s rhetoric of koinonia and Stoic sense of moral formation suggest new social identity to especially Gentile Christians of Philippian community in response to Roman typical imperialistic urbanism? (2) How can these ethical exhortations effectively enhance Christian social identity in the reference of Roman imperialistic urbanism, once these are compared with Roman typical friendship motifs in Cicero’s De amicitia, Stoic sense of moral formation in Cicero’s De finibus and Seneca’s De Tranquillitate animi? (3) How can Philippian Christians create new political identity to construct reconciliatory political ethos so that both Paul’s rhetoric of koinonia and his stoic sense of moral formation attempt to transform Romanizing political ideology and urban social convention?
|
Poetic Skills in Juxtaposed Poems: A Communal Lament (Isa 63:7–64:12) and a Divine Oracle (Isa 65:1–16)
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Hee Suk Kim, Chongshin Theological Seminary
This paper attempts to delve into the artistic, poetic imagination displayed in a communal lament in Isaiah 63:7-64:12 in its literary and thematic association with a divine oracle in Isaiah 65:1-16. First of all, the structure and poetic devices used in the former are studied in depth, in order to explore on the way the poem, Isaiah 63:7-64:12, constitutes a communal identity of Israel. How the poetic skills help to define the relationship between the communal character of the poem and the listener YHWH should be paid special attention to. Linguistic, thematic, and structural analyses are pursued for this purpose. Second, then, the specific poetic skills employed in Isaiah 63:7-64:12 are once more considered in terms of how they contribute to the establishment of literary and thematic structure of Isaiah 65:1-16, in which a divine oracle is delivered in a form of negative response to the communal lament in Isaiah 63-64. In other words, the poetic elements in the communal lament make crucial contributions to the way the divine oracle gives an answer to the lament. In this regard, this paper argues that a particular manner of poetic imagination is operative in the two texts and is of important service to a more advanced understanding of Isaiah 63-66 as a literary whole.
|
Literary Functions of the Themes Related to Proverbs 1–9 in the Context of Prov 22:17–24:34
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Hee Suk Kim, Chongshin Theological Seminary
This paper purports to read Prov 22:17-24:34 in its literary and thematic connections with Proverbs 1-9. Several sets of verses in this passage, such as 22:17-21; 23:15-19, 26-28; 24:3-9, 13-14, 33-34, employ words and concepts that present similarities with the texts of Proverbs 1-9. Therefore, a question should be raised to understand the purpose of this connection between Prov 22:17-24:34 and Proverbs 1-9. A research is made in the following procedure. First, what texts are in connection with Proverbs 1-9 and how close are the literary and thematic connections? Second, what texts are not in connection with Proverbs 1-9 and what themes are they dealing with? Third, how do the texts in connection with Proverbs 1-9 help to construe the structure(s) and the message(s) of Prov 22:17-24:34 in literary and/or thematic senses? Fourth, what implications do this study carry as Prov 22:17-24:34 is located bewteen Prov 10:1-22:16 and Proverbs 25-29? Finally, an attempt is made to explore on the hermeneutical role(s) of this passage in the larger context of the whole book of Proverbs. My contention is that there is a textual intention in terms of literary and thematic format as Prov 22:17-24:34 repeatedly juxtaposes the texts apparently connected with Proverbs 1-9 and the texts in little connection with it.
|
Well-Being in Positive Psychology and Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Hyun Chul Paul Kim, Methodist Theological School in Ohio
This study analyzes interdisciplinary correlations between the fields of positive psychology and Hebrew Bible. Human well-being and flourishing will be critically examined through the literature of positive psychology, specifically the work of Daniel Gilbert, Christopher Peterson, Martin Seligman, and others, and through the following Hebrew Bible texts and concepts: Psalms 1, 23, 46, Ecclesiastes 1-3; shalom/wholeness/well-being; ashrei/happiness; and, beracha/blessing. The presentation interprets the challenges and potentials of this unique interdisciplinary approach for both fields and for the practice of ministry.
|
"When Even the Gods Do Not Know": The Dream as a Means of Divination Favored by the Gods
Program Unit: Prophetic Texts and Their Ancient Contexts
Koowon Kim, Reformed Theological Seminary in Seoul
This paper deals with El’s dream in KTU 1.6 iii, examining the role of a dream in Ugaritic mythological literature. Like the dreams of Kirta and Dani?lu, El’s dream too is the result of incubation, but it differs from them in several aspects. First of all it is a symbolic as well as a psychological dream, whereas the dreams of Kirta and Dani?lu are message dreams. The need for interpretation of symbolic dreams is obviated by the binary structure of interpretation that El imposes on dream divination. In addition, in this case, dream as a means of divination is further complicated by the fact that El is a deity, whereas Kirta and Dani?lu are humans. This raises many interesting questions, such as: ‘Why would a deity like El ever need divination?’ ‘What is the literary purpose of portraying El resorting to dream divination in the mythological story?’ This paper investigates several literary aspects that revolve around El’s impetrated dream in the Baal Cycle and suggests some implications for the significance of dream divination in Syria-Palestine.
|
Children of the Dry Bones: Metaphor as the Logic of Hope
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible and Cognate Literature
Soo Kim, Claremont Lincoln University
The present study starts from the question of how to more fully appreciate the given metaphor. Then, it recognizes the two presuppositions. First, metaphor is an expressive force (Bar-Efrat) to require both cognitive thought and the expressive medium within the given text (Eva Kittay). Second, metaphors soon extend their scope to other texts through the intertextual interactions by the users. The term ‘users’ refers to all possible agents of the text including blood-flesh authors, editors, compilers, transmitters, scribes, implied author, the narrator, characters, literary audience, implied audience, and later groups of the audience and readers throughout ages. As Claudia Bergann asserts, the awareness of these diverse users helps us modern readers appreciate both the original realm of the scope of the metaphor and the new ways of reality from which the metaphor has produced.
The Dry Bone Vision in Ezekiel 37 as a case study of this examination is worthwhile: 1) a visionary setting as a good preparation of the metaphoric presentation; 2) various mediators in the disputative communication among YHWH, prophet, and the literary audience; 3) sharing perceptions of the exiles’ reality through the metaphor ‘dry bones’; 4) the radical solution for the exiles as resurrection; and 5) a tall order to fill the gap between the divine solution and the human condition. My agenda for this last task is to see the earlier generation of the exile (the literary/immediate audience of the text) as the human scapegoat and to see the later generation (one of the implied audience groups) as the ‘resurrection of the dried bones’ via YHWH’s adoption of the children of the dried bones.
Once the users affirm the legitimacy of the metaphor, they begin to seek the proper logic to fulfill the prophecy within their context. The first context to examine is its intertextuality, which exists between the Ezekiel text and the legal text of the scapegoat in Leviticus. In terms of the componential semantics (Kittay and Andrea Weiss), four categories of the (human) scapegoat metaphor will be examined: 1) “bear the sins” of the whole community (??? ???) as reparation; 2) be “sent away” (???) alive into the wilderness (‘cut-off’ land, ??? ???); 3) be abandoned to “rot away” there (pine away, ???); and 4) never return (???). Furthermore, the narrative pattern of generational differences as the solution for the scapegoat metaphor is also evident in the cases of Joseph and his two sons in Genesis and the first and second generation in Numbers, which show the differing treatment of God regarding the later generation.
With the help of the cognitive approach of the metaphor theory, intertextual theory, and the componential semantics study, we see that, once the metaphor is established, it works as the stepping stone of the new logic, i.e., the logic of the hope to come back to the Promised Land even in the face of the death of the literary audience.
|
Reading the Parable of the Father and Two Sons in Luke 15:11–32 from a Perspective of Divided Korea: Seeking a Model of Reconciliation
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Yung Suk Kim, Virginia Union University
This paper seeks to explore a model of reconciliation between two states in divided Korea, based on insights drawn from the parable of the Father and Two Sons in Luke 15:11-32. Korea is the only country in the world still divided for more than half a century. Since its division in 1953 after the Korean War (1950-53), the two states have been in constant rivalry and conflict with no hopes of reconciliation. A majority of Christians in South Korea take right-wing ideology that demonizes North Korea with the logic of an “either/or” stance: “Take a free, democratic, capitalist system or stay dead.” This parable demonstrates a number of insights and challenges to Christians in Korea and people involved in this conflict. In the parable, the father as a protagonist seeks the restoration of his family by risking his honor and taking the role of mother who cares for both children without favoritism. Since the parable is open-ended, readers wonder whether these sons/brothers will reconcile as the father wishes.
|
Mastery Learning: A Pedagogy for Leveraging Technology in Teaching NT Greek Grammar
Program Unit: Global Education and Research Technology
Harold A. Kime, Lancaster Bible College
Mastery learning differs from traditional learning approaches in that its goal is for students to master content rather than simply being exposed to it. Subjects are divided into small discrete sequenced units that can be easily learned. Students progress from unit to unit only by demonstrating mastery of the prior unit. This mastery approach is self-paced, allowing students to repeat learning and assessment activities until they demonstrate mastery. Thus, the learning process is very individualized.
This session will describe an implementation of this approach in teaching Greek grammar both in the traditional classroom and online. Tools designed assist students in acquiring, understanding, and retaining basic vocabulary, morphology, and syntax will be demonstrated. These tools include video lectures, creative drill and practice, and motivational translations in the form of stories. Methods for assessing performance and tracking progress will be explained including how to automate quizzes and minimize manual grading. The role of the teacher as coach and motivator will be clarified as will the methods that can be used to provide motivational feedback and encouragement. Though face-to-face class time is minimized and computerized tools replace traditional instruction, the role of the teacher will be shown to be much more than that of a grader.
Finally, the session will provide statistical results from a pilot program run in 2013 and will provide both positive and negative insights gained from the study. For instance, we will discuss how well a self-paced course fit into a fixed academic schedule, how well students adjusted to an open-ended process, and to what extent the results demonstrated improvement in student outcomes. We will provide recommendation for those who would consider implementing a mastery learning approach.
|
Re-reading Poverty Proverbs within the Bena Tanzanian Context / among the Bena of Tanzania
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Lechion Peter Kimilike, The Open University of Tanzania, Iringa
African biblical scholars have to recognize the importance of the role culture plays in biblical interpretation if Christianity and its sacred texts are to be authentically African. First, cultural resources can liberate biblical interpretation from expert ideological dominance by creating critical reading masses. Second, such an approach empowers the community for transformation from the reality of multifaceted injustices such as poverty. Third, African biblical hermeneutics create room as an equal for a fair dialogue with mainstream interpretive methods in biblical studies. In this paper I seek to model the preceding aspects through interpreting several proverbs on poverty in the book of Proverbs using my cultural context, that of the Bena people of Tanzania. The reading is deemed transformational because the named cultural context is holistic, something akin to the ancient Israelite one. Such a home grown holistic cultural setup has been argued to be inherently life-giving and life-sustaining with a potential to transform the well-being of humanity for sustainable development. In short, the reading of poverty proverbs seems to go beyond a stance of pure self-interest by challenging the victims to be involved in the eradication of poverty in their communities. Such a reading can be a helpful contribution to the integration of Wisdom Literature with various African contexts.
|
Reframing the Apocryphon of John: 'Christianizing' Revisions in the Long Recension
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Brad F. King, University of Texas at Austin
Comparison of Ap. John's two recensions reveals not only that the editors of the long version were well acquainted with the practical and ideological conventions of proto-canonical Christian literature, but also that they were engaged in the same conversations that shaped and reshaped the face of Christian religiosity in third- and fourth-century Egypt. Thus, I argue that the long version (NHC II,1 and NHC IV,1) of the Apocryphon of John represents a more recognizable and popular form of Christian religiosity than does the shorter form of the tractate (NHC III,1 and BG 8502,2). I demonstrate that the longer version is suffused with revisions and expansions that reframe the tractate in accordance with the scriptural and scribal practices of a specifically Christian literary culture and emphasize the Christological traditions that Ap. John shared with better known (and more accepted) examples of Christian literature—especially as one finds in the Gospel of John.
|
Endings and the End: The Gospel of Mark and the Gospel of Judas
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Karen L. King, Harvard University
The paper will consider how the endings of the Gospel of Mark and the Gospel of Judas can be understood in light of the prophecies of salvation contained within them. I propose their structural and thematic similarities point toward a connection between the literary form of the “open ending” and these gospels’ particular religious messages and aims. The narrative form of the suspended ending seems particularly fitted to apocalyptic messages in which the End suspends quotidian time but leaves open the potential for readers to enact an eternal but not-yet, future Ending by themselves becoming authors and characters in the stories they write. Although no character within the Gospel of Mark or the Gospel of Judas is saved, thwarting the expectations of readers potentially provokes them to author a “better” ending, not only literarily but more existentially by writing themselves into the story and fulfilling in their own lives the prophecies of salvation given by Jesus. To do so, however, they would be compelled to engage the particular religious message of each gospel, to convert to its point of view and accept the “corrections” each so forcefully demands.
|
Inventing "Martyrdom" and Re-imagining Social Relations
Program Unit: Inventing Christianity: Apostolic Fathers, Apologists, and Martyrs
Karen L. King, Harvard University
Examination of select literature from second and third century Egypt shows that Christian responses to the violence aimed against them offered a number of possibilities for the imagination of re-ordered social relations. Some, like Tertullian, involved reinscribing Roman violence in their fantasies of end times, as Kimberly Stratton has shown. Others, such as the Martyrdom of Perpetua, disembed believers from natal families and re-embed them in the family of God, an imaginary with significant implications for restructuring social relations. Yet others, however, seem to have attempted to devise more or less radical ways to think themselves outside the Roman script of torture, truth, and justice. Two such works are The Testimony of Truth and 1 Apocalypse of James. Clement of Alexandria’s notion of the gnostic martyr can be considered in this light as well. The paper will discuss the implications of this varied literature for the Christian invention of “martyrdom” and the re-imagination of social relations.
|
Twenty-First Century Messianic Judaism: Evangelical and Post-Evangelical Trajectories
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Mark S. Kinzer, Messianic Jewish Theological Institute
As the recent volume edited by Rudolph and Willitts demonstrates, established stereotypes of Messianic Judaism have become gross caricatures of the movement as it really is in the 21st century. While large segments of the movement remain a subset of the evangelical church in modes of piety, practice, and theology, a significant portion has moved into new and uncharted terrain. They seek earnestly for Jewish authenticity and communal involvement, scholarly depth, and serious engagement with the full spectrum of the Christian world. In this paper I will summarize what Introduction to Messianic Judaism tells us about these developments, and assess their significance for the future of the movement as a whole.
|
Ancient Scribal Practices and the Order of the Double Tradition in Matthew
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Alan Kirk, James Madison University
Analysis of synoptic source relationships in the framework of ancient compositional practices has relied mainly upon the literary practices of elite Greco-Roman circles for its comparative material. Though well-documented and illuminating, these are only part of the spectrum of expert writing practices in antiquity, and important aspects of the synoptic gospels and synoptic relationships resist explanation on the Greco-Roman authorial model. This paper widens the field to incorporate what, for lack of a better term, might be called ancient scribal practices, understood as including the activities of ancient grammarians and scholars in the cultivation and transmission—including source utilization—of cultural texts of various sorts. It draws upon Michael Haslam’s analysis of source utilization in Apollonius Sophista’s Homer Lexicon to illuminate the intractable problem (for the 2DH) of the ordering of the double tradition in Matthew, making additional reference, time permitting, to Diogenes Laertius’ use of Favorinus and to evidence from some ancient florilegia. Matthew’s ordering of Q material is shown to be completely intelligible and in accord with ancient practices. This neutralizes a key line of criticism of the 2DH.
|
Idealized Human Figures and the Synoptic Jesus
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
J. R. Daniel Kirk, Fuller Theological Seminary
Recent approaches to the Christologies of the New Testament have made wide-ranging appeal to ascriptions, actions, or attributes attributed to Jesus that elsewhere are described as the exclusive purview of Israel’s God. In light of these, it has often been argued that "the earliest Christology was already the highest Christology." My paper will demonstrate that application of such divine characteristics to humans occurs with some frequency across various Jewish traditions, to those whom I term “idealized human figures.” In theorizing the category of “idealized human figures,” Gospel studies are offered an alternative to God-of-Israel Christologies, theios aner Christologies, angelomorophic Christologies, and Galilean peasant Christologies. This study will demonstrate the plausibility of idealized human Christology as a description of the Jesus of the Synoptic Tradition through a discussion of Mark’s son of humanity sayings and Matthew’s water-walking episode (Matt 14:22-33).
|
Towards a New Understanding of Biblical Narrative Composition and Transmission: The Contributions of Cultural Memory Studies and of the Folklorist R. Bottigheimer
Program Unit: Orality, Textuality, and the Formation of the Hebrew Bible
Patricia G. Kirkpatrick, McGill University
The area of memory studies has attempted to introduce some important distinctions when speaking about memory of historical events and the way it operates especially when conveying national identity. This paper will suggest ways in which memory studies compliment folklore studies in the manner by which it describes oral transmission and the implications this has for biblical studies.
The stunning arguments of the folklorist Ruth Bottigheimer are little known in the world of biblical studies where form critical arguments of oral composition and transmission once dominated the theoretical reconstructions of Biblical narratives. A prolific writer her latest book Fairy Tales: A New History, details the evidence for overturning some common assumptions about orality and written stories. But it is the assertions in her 2010 article entitle ‘A New History for Fairy Tales’ which is perhaps most helpful for our understanding of how ancient tales were transmitted. Specifically her evidence based assertions that European (i) literary texts preceded folkloric oral performances of tales, (ii) printed texts underlie oral performances. Finally with regards to transmission European tale history refutes every claim that a given fairy tale descended unchanged from an ancient past through repeated oral tellings in an imagined and invented history.
These are significant findings and claims which do impinge on how we use folklore studies in understanding the biblical text. This paper focuses on the Jacob cycle of tales in Genesis.
|
Joshua (and Caleb) in the Priestly Spies Story and the Appearance of Joshua in the Priestly Source
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Itamar Kislev, University of Haifa
Scholars agree that it is relatively simple to distinguish between the priestly and non-priestly materials in the story of the spies in Numbers 13-14. It is generally acknowledged that the passages in which Joshua and Caleb appear together do not belong to the non-priestly thread, where Caleb appears alone. Yet to deduce from this that the passages in which both characters appear are therefore part of the priestly thread is not so simple. Quite a few scholars have suggested that in some cases the references to Joshua together with Caleb are not part of the original priestly account. There are good reasons to believe that this is indeed the case, and that in fact all of the passages in which the two men appear together are secondary in their context. The question thus arises whether these passages are part of a late stratum in the priestly source or whether they belong to a redaction of the combined account. This in turn has bearing on the portrayal of the figure of Joshua and the determination of its initial appearance in the priestly source.
|
Akkadian Demonology and Hebrew Theology: A Phenomenological Approach
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Anne Marie Kitz, Holy Apostles
As recently as 2008 scholarly investigations into the existence of demons in the Hebrew Bible have concluded that many if not all subordinate supernatural beings operated in opposition to Yahweh. Therefore, the inference that Israel embraced theology while Assyria and Babylon accommodated an elaborate world of demons has remained firmly intact.
The present paper will address this issue through an examination of one, exemplar Akkadian ‘demon’, the rabi?u. Although this being is generally one member of a much larger collective of related creatures, an analysis of the Semitic root rb? reveals important characteristics indicative of such entities. Of these features the most significant are: 1) good and evil reflexes; 2) a high degree of mobility; 3) temporary periods of activity; 4) and oppositional stances directed toward human targets rather than governing deities. One of the principal phenomena that distinguish the rabi?us and its fellow supernatural entities is their association with wind.
Not surprisingly, the Hebrew Bible is not without such comparative beings. The most obvious example is the rûa? yhwh/elohîm. The same may be said of the mal’akîm. Both have positive and negative designations and both are associated with wind generated by Yahweh. Like the rabi?u, the mal’ak has a corresponding human counterpart. Since the rabi?u and mal’ak are engaged by royal courts, it is likely they occupied the same position in the courts of the great deities.
These correspondences demonstrate that the writers of the Hebrew Bible conceived and expressed the activities of Yahweh in much the same way as other ancient Near Eastern cultures. Therefore, the reputed theological gap between the behavior of Akkadian and Hebrew deities may not be as gaping as previously assumed.
|
Litigation and Feud: Conflict Settlement in the Law and in the Psalms
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Klaus-Peter Adam, Lutheran School of Theology at Chicago
Rarely explicitly mentioned, enmity and hatred are significant categories of biblical law. I propose that enmity is a social construct that underlies much of biblical law. The paper argues on the basis of a description of the distinct forms of conflict settlement behavior between enemies in biblical times. For instance, it illuminates the nature of enmity in biblical Israel as a relationship between two individuals in a kin-based society. A conflict between two opponents in ancient Israel would regularly be transitive, in the sense that a conflict naturally affected other members besides the two individuals, foremost the kin but also the friends of those who were engaged in a conflict with an opponent. Another characteristic marker of private disputes was their intrinsically public character. In general, the mechanisms of conflict settlement between two private enemies followed a given pattern, that in detail still allowed for variations. Based on these and on other features of conflict settlement, I attempt to buttress the hypothesis that enmity between two adversaries was a social status that included certain legal ramifications. More specifically, I suggest that conflict settlement in Israel exhibited some of the core characteristics of what historians of the Middle Ages and of early modern time, as well as anthropologists have called feuding behavior. As a consequence, I suggest that a strict alternative between ‘forensic’ litigation and feuding behavior in Israel would be misleading.
On a methodological level, the paper’s main intention is to juxtapose the results on enmity in Israelite law with the picture of enmity that is derived from the complaints of individuals in the Psalter. The paper seeks adequate ways to hypothesize the nature and the procedural aspects of conflict settlement patterns on the basis of laws in the collections from the Pentateuch and on the basis of selected examples from the first and second collections the Psalms of David, Psalms 3-41, 51-71. A fresh look at the supposed forms of litigation and feud between enemies in the Psalms will include a critical review of earlier twentieth century legal interpretation of individual complaints. The combination between the results from the two distinct sources of the Psalter and of legal collections will be supplemented by a comparative sideways look on mechanisms of conflict settlement between private opponents in other Ancient Mediterranean societies.
|
Jewish Exegesis as Help and Hinderance in Origen's Peri Pascha
Program Unit: Jewish-Christian Dialogue and Sacred Texts
Richard F. Klee, University of Notre Dame
Writing from two cities known for the interweaving of Christian and Jewish peoples and traditions, Origen of Alexandria, later of Caesarea, provides Jewish exegesis of the Exodus and Passover as both a model for and a stumbling block to the Christian development of a celebration of Jesus' death and resurrection. This paper examines the ways in which Origen is indebted to Jewish interpreters of Exodus, whether such debt was incurred in personal contacts with contemporary Jews, and his unique claim regarding the enduring value for Christians of liturgical rites in Exodus. It also attends to the polemic in which Peri Pascha, Origen's treatise on the Passover, was written, and whether there is evidence that Origen described or proposed specific Christian acts to counter popular Jewish festivities.
|
Animals and Humans in Gen 1:26–28: New Insights from an Iconographic Turn
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Johannes Kleiner, Emory University
The interpretation of Gen 1:26-28 has sparked lively debate among scholars regarding the nature of the human-animal relationship envisioned. Why are humans called to ??? animals? What is the nature of the action characterizing the inter-species relationship? Past approaches seem to focus largely on the human relationship to land animals, even though Gen 1:26 and 28 deliberately refer to the entire animal kingdom, water- and air-creatures included. They have also largely ignored the wealth of iconographic representations of animals and the human-animal relationship.
I argue that a too narrow a focus on land animals as animals, sidelining the important symbolic value of animals evident in much ancient Near Eastern iconography, loses sight of important nuances of meaning present in the text. Iconographic data suggests that animals have a wide variety of symbolic values. Among those, the deity-animal nexus is especially well attested. Animals are associated with different deities or some/one of his/her aspects. I propose that the command to ??? deliberately tries to evoke human superiority over deities and other numinous forces signified by animals. The text is not so much about actual human animal relationships, but tries to position humans vis-à-vis animals as symbols. This offers a new avenue to understand the inclusion of the entire animal kingdom in Gen 1:26-28.
|
Problematizing Psalms and Proverbs: Extended Allusions in the Book of Job
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Jonathan G. Kline, Harvard University
This paper presents two case studies of extended allusion in the book of Job in order to illustrate the profound and subtle ways in which this book engages with earlier textual traditions from ancient Israel. In the first case study, I examine a complex of allusions in Job to Ps 8:5. Although the reference to this text in Job 7:17–18 is well known, this is one of only several places in the book where Job and his friends allude to Ps 8:5 in order to carry out their debate concerning the nature of suffering and God’s treatment of the righteous and the wicked. By means of its extended allusion to Ps 8:5, the book of Job at times seems to affirm and at other times problematizes that text’s traditional conception of humankind and its relationship to the deity.
My second case study examines the way in which Job and his interlocutors debate the veracity of a group of texts from Proverbs that use the image of the lamp of the wicked being snuffed out as a metaphor for the unjust’s being overtaken by divine retribution (Prov 13:9b; 20:20; 24:20). Bildad affirms this traditional doctrine through an allusion to the second half of Prov 13:9 (Job 18:5–6), and in response Job questions the retribution theology of Proverbs by punning on this statement by Bildad (Job 21:17). This sets the stage for a brilliant retort from Eliphaz (22:17–18), who rebuffs Job by punning on the first half of Prov 13:9 in order to declare that Job’s objection to Bildad is without merit.
These two case studies highlight the kinds of rhetorical virtuosity that the book of Job employs as it interacts, sometimes rather subtly, with antecedent traditions from ancient Israel in order to produce its profound theological discourse.
|
"I Pour out My Soul within Me" (Ps 42:4): Khirbet Qeiyafa, Libations, and the Power of Ritual
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Gerald A. Klingbeil, Andrews University
The discovery of two unique IA IIA libation vessels found in a cultic context at Khirbet Qeiyafa, Israel, invites careful consideration of the function and role of libations within the larger ritual and cultic complex of Israelite religion. Textual, iconographic, as well as archaeological data underline the importance of libations in the ancient Near East. In biblical texts libations often seem to have functioned as “envelopes,” highlighting the larger ritual complex. They may assume in a symbolic way the role of sacrifices when a specific cultic space (such as a sanctuary or a temple) was not available. The unique twin-cup shape of the Khirbet Qeiyafa libation vessels invites the researcher to reflect on specific dimensions of libations—both at Qeiyafa and in the larger context of Israelite religion. The discovery may provide a helpful corrective in the discussion of continuum of Israelite religion, including also key categories such as public vs. private (or personal) or official vs. folk religion.
|
The Reflexes of Rhetoric: The "Canonical" Rhetoric of the Tel Dan Inscription as a Clue to Understanding the Development of the Biblical David Narrative
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Andrew Knapp, Eisenbrauns
I have two objectives with this paper. First, I will demonstrate that the Tel Dan Inscription displays certain features of a royal apology, a text composed to defend the legitimacy of a ruler who achieved the throne in some atypical fashion. But why should the Tel Dan Inscription, a victory inscription erected far from Damascus, be concerned with defending the Aramean king’s legitimacy? I suggest that although the text may not have been commissioned in order to justify his reign, it may have drawn from a “canon” of royal rhetoric employed by this king (presumably Hazael)—and, by virtue of his strange accession, this canon likely focused on legitimating his rule.
In the second section I consider the ramifications of this idea for the development of the biblical narrative(s) about David. Although I am ultimately unconvinced that a royal apology (the so-called “History of David’s Rise”) underlies the David narrative in 1-2 Samuel—at least, not in such a way that it can be isolated through literary criticism—it is difficult to deny that a vast amount of material in Samuel has a defensive posture. I propose that the same phenomenon witnessed in the Tel Dan Inscription may, mutatis mutandis, have occurred during the growth of the biblical text. Traditions exonerating David of the many suspicious crimes committed during his rise doubtless circulated during his reign and became part of his standard rhetoric. The tradents of the biblical text, whether aware of the charges against David or not, then drew upon this standard rhetoric, leaving traces of the apology so frequently discussed in the secondary literature.
|
The Neo-Babylonian "Empire" and Arabia
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Ernst Axel Knauf, Universität Bern - Université de Berne
This contribution tries to place the Arabian politics of the Neo-Babylonian kingdom into a double perspective. The first perspective involves what can be determined from Arabian sources and second, what can be determined from a world system viewpoint. There is more to this than just Nabonidus' well-known interest in dominating Arabian trade. The Bible even offers some contributions to this topic.
|
The Spirit and the Bible in Alexandria: Cyril and Didymus
Program Unit: Development of Early Christian Theology
David Kneip, Abilene Christian University
One is not surprised to find a patristic figure like Cyril of Alexandria calling the Bible "the logia of the Spirit"; indeed, he and many other early Christian thinkers held strong views of the Holy Spirit's role in the creation of the Jewish and Christian scriptures. However, individuals like Cyril did not merely assert this belief; they also assumed it, so that it emerged from their writings in sometimes surprising ways. This paper will demonstrate some of the ways that two important ancient Alexandrians -- Cyril of Alexandria and Didymus the Blind -- understood and expressed their beliefs about the Holy Spirit's work in inspiring the Bible, especially as it shapes their interpretations of the Bible itself. Some of these methods include explicit statements about that theological position, while others involve more indirect expressions that assume that position, like both writers’ somewhat unusual use of the term *pneumatophoros* to describe the writers of scriptural texts that point to Jesus. Further, the paper will show that the writers express their beliefs in different ways, including using literary devices, theological formulae, and scriptural citations. This paper will contribute to early Christian studies in at least three ways: by illuminating early Christian attitudes about the Spirit and the Bible, by building a fuller picture of the thought of two specific early Christian thinkers, and by strengthening scholarly understanding of Christian Alexandria and the beliefs about the Spirit found therein.
|
The Northern Context of the Law-Code in Deuteronomy
Program Unit: Book of Deuteronomy
Gary N. Knoppers, Pennsylvania State University
It has been long recognized that Deuteronomy evinces a strong emphasis on Israelite identity and the solidarity and kinship shared by all members of the larger Israelite community. My paper deals with the two sets of directions about public liturgies that bracket the central law collection of Deuteronomy (12:2–26:15). Each of these two sets of instructions about Israelite conduct upon entering the land remands the Israelites to the area of Shechem. The first set of instructions (Deut 11:26–30), which preface the introduction (Deut 11:31–12:1) to the central law-code (Deut 12:2-26:15), consists of public pronouncements of blessings and curses validating God’s covenant with Israel, which the Israelites are mandated to deliver on Mt. Gerizim and Mt. Ebal. The second, longer and more complex set of instructions following the conclusion to the law code (Deut 26:16-19) also mandates pan-Israelite ceremonies at Mt. Gerizim and Mt. Ebal (Deut 27:1–26). This set of detailed instructions about public liturgies includes directions about six tribes standing for the blessing of the people upon Mt. Gerizim and the other six tribes standing on Mt. Ebal for the curse (Deut 27:11-13). Directions about future public liturgies at Mt. Gerizim and Mt. Ebal frame, therefore, the laws of the covenant, which constitute the heart of the Deuteronomic presentation.
At least equally important, this second set of instructions mandates the inscription of “all the words of this torah” upon large stones and the construction of an altar made of whole stones upon which burnt offerings and offerings of well-being are to be presented on Mt. Gerizim (so SP; MT Mt Ebal; Deut 27:2-8). I will argue that Judean and the Samarian communities within the late Persian and early Hellenistic periods could read the relevance of the altar instructions of Deut 27:5-7 in their own distinctive ways and still lay claim to the authority of the text of Deuteronomy that they both shared. In other words, the instructions about public sacrifices in the Shechem area lent themselves to multiple readings. Whether the Gerizim altar is construed as the central altar alluded to in Deut 12:2-32 (so the Yahwistic Samarian community) or as a one-time communal act upon entering the land (so the Yahwistic Judean community), the text of Deuteronomy privileges the northern area of Shechem. The foundational importance of northern Israel to Israelite identity is, therefore, not simply an abstract theological tenet, but also something embodied within the instructions of Deuteronomy itself.
|
The Wonderful Adventures of the Nile Goose
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Ido Koch, Tel Aviv University
Scholars have conducted lengthy discussions over the banquet scenes depicted on the ivory plaques from Late Bronze Age Megiddo and Tell el-Far’ah (S). Among the studied subjects were the Egypto-Levantine style, the representations of the main images, and the archaeological context of the items. This paper will deal with a unique and unparalleled feature of the Levantine banquet scenes - the appearance of waterfowls, shown in the preparations for the feasts. The sole domesticated waterfowl in the Ancient Near East was the goose, which was bred and consumed in Egypt and was frequently depicted in Egyptian art. A re-examination of faunal assemblages from the Levant has revealed the previously unnoticed evidence for goose breeding in Canaanite sites during the Late Bronze Age. Thus, the historical and cultural background for the consumption of waterfowls in Canaan is explored, shedding new light over the Egyptianization of the Canaanite elite and its perception of the Egyptian culture. Moreover, the context of the goose keeping in Canaan, its consumption in the local banquets and its depiction in contemporary art is a unique meeting point of iconography, archaeology and historical-cultural theories.
|
Cornelius’ Obeisance to Peter (Acts 10:25–26) and the Judea Capta Coins
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Michael Kochenash, Claremont School of Theology
Commentators typically explain Cornelius' unusual actions upon Peter's entry into his house by suggesting that Cornelius mistakes Peter for some sort of divine or angelic figure. A survey of Lukan characters explicitly encountering actual and perceived divine and angelic figures suggests that a different explanation is in order. I argue that the word-picture presented by Luke - that of a Roman soldier down in a position of submission to an upright Judean man - is best understood within the context of Roman semiotics of power. The discourse of Acts 10:25-26 presents a juxtaposition of the kingdom of God with the Roman Empire. Luke's first word-picture - a Roman on the ground before a Judean - would have contrasted starkly with Roman imperial semiotics, particularly as manifested in the Judea Capta coins (many of which presented an upright Roman soldier next to a seated, defeated Judean). Luke's second word-picture - that of Peter raising up Cornelius from the ground - completes the juxtaposition. In the semiotics of the kingdom of God, outsiders have a status equal to insiders ("God shows no partiality"). This rhetorical move anticipates the visual program under Hadrian in the 120s. Acts 10:25-26 - in the middle of the Cornelius episode - is located at a critical spot within the narrative of Luke-Acts, at the beginning of the inclusion of Gentiles into the kingdom of God. A Roman centurion is the first Gentile to be brought into the kingdom of God. The account of this expansion contrasts sharply with the Roman practice of expanding and conquering the Gentiles (ethne/gentes). The interpretation I am proposing disambiguates Luke's attitude toward Rome: Luke is not "anti-Roman;" instead, he advocates the kingdom of God as Rome's rival.
|
"Now Is the Judgment of This World" (John 12:31): Apocalyptic Perspectives on the Judgment Theme in John's Gospel
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Craig Koester, Luther Seminary
God's response to problems of evil and injustice is an important theme in apocalyptic texts. Writers assume that a just God will not allow the perpetrators of sin and evil to continue indefinitely, but will hold them to account. Some scenarios envision a final judgment in which God judges the wicked and vindicates the righteous. Others anticipate the eschatological defeat of Satan, who is the principal agent of evil. Although John's gospel is known for its emphasis on judgment and salvation occurring in the ministry of Jesus, the writer retains the basic contours of apocalyptic thought. The categories of judgment against the sinful and the final defeat of Satan persist. And because injustice continues after Jesus' ministry has ended, the gospel relates judgment in the present to a future "last day."
|
Dreaming about Clergy
Program Unit: Prophetic Texts and Their Ancient Contexts
Bart Koet, Universiteit van Tilburg
The passio Perpetuae is the one of all the Acts of the ancient Christian martyrs that has drawn the most attention in recent scholarship. One of the obvious reasons for this is the fact that a large part of this text is presented as a diary of the martyr Perpetua, a woman who died at the beginning of the third century. In the diary Perpetua describes her experiences in the prison. What makes passio Perpetuae more special is that a large part of the text is said to be based on Perpetua’s own notes in the days of her captivity (3-10). Equally exceptional is the fact that in the diary part of the text, Perpetua tells extensively of her dreams and as such it is also one of the oldest “dream journals” of the world. In her diary Perpetua describes four visions. Thus, it is not unexpected that in recent years quite a few of secondary literature appeared about this passio. However, the passio is not only a window to visions on dreams in early Christianity, it is also a window on Christian communities themselves. Perpetua gets in the prison some help from deacons and in her dreams she has an encounter with clergyman she knew. In this paper I will deal with the question: Is there a relation between the person in the story and those in the dreams, focusing on a special group, the clergy.
|
Ezekiel 40–48 and P: Questions and Perspectives
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
Michael Konkel, Theologische Fakultät Paderborn
The relationship between Ezek 40–48 and the priestly source (resp. the priestly texts of the Pentateuch) is still a matter of debate. While traditionally Ezek 40–48 is seen as a predecessor of P, recent studies assert that Ezek 40-48 presupposes P. The paper will present a diachronically differentiated view on the topic, and will focus on the question, how the 'Torah of the temple' (Ezek 43,12) worked as an counterpart to the Tora from Sinai in the Persian period.
|
Jesus as the Royal Messiah and the Ambivalence of His Reception in Israel in Matthew and John
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Matthias Konradt, Ruprecht-Karls-Universität Heidelberg
In Matthew’s Gospel, Jesus is remembered as the humble king of Israel, the son of David, who is sent to the lost sheep of Israel. His ministry, however, evokes ambivalent reactions: while the crowds gradually develop the insight that Jesus is the messianic son of David, the Jewish authorities react with firm and resolute rejection. With regard to the relationship between Matthew’s Jesus story and John’s Gospel on this topic, one can observe not only some agreements in narrative details – as for example in the story of Jesus’ entry into Jerusalem (Matt 21:1-17; John 12:12-19) –, but also a basic convergence in the overall approach of conveying the ambivalence of Jesus’ reception “by his own people” during his earthly ministry. At the same time, however, each evangelist develops this overall approach in a characteristic manner. This paper combines an analysis of the presentation of Jesus as the Messiah of Israel and of his ambivalent reception with a reflection on the social situations of the Matthean and the Johannine groups which manifest themselves in the specific way in which the Jesus story is told.
|
Ekklesia as a Jewish Synagogue Term: Some Implications for Paul’s Socio-religious Location
Program Unit: Paul within Judaism
Ralph Korner, McMaster University
*
|
Biography, History, and the Genre of Luke-Acts
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Zachary L. Kostopoulos, Saint Louis University
Biography, History, and the Genre of Luke-Acts
|
But What Do We Call It? Crises of Categories and the Secret Revelation of John
Program Unit: Westar Institute
Maia Kotrosits, Denison University
*
|
Diaspora Theory and the End of "Early Christianity" and "Early Christian Identity"
Program Unit: Redescribing Christian Origins
Maia Kotrosits, Denison University
The study of "early Christianity" has been haunted by the rather significant problem that the term "Christian" barely occurs in New Testament literature, and only occurs in non-canonical texts dated from the late-first and early-second centuries and beyond. Many scholars acknowledge there is no "Christianity" functioning per se for writers of the New Testament, but have used terms like "proto-Christian" that suggest the inevitable development of the term, and imply a coherent phenomenon with obvious and distinct theological content. Yet there have been hardly any constructive alternative suggestions for the problem of "what to call it." This paper outlines recent developments within diaspora theory -- particularly the work of Stuart Hall, Grace Cho and Brian Keith Axel -- to propose an alternative, non-teleological, and non-essentializing lens through which what we call "early Christian" literature might be read.
|
Abraham’s Burial (Gen 25:9): An Idyllic Burial or a Dispute over Inheritance?
Program Unit: Genesis
Ekaterina Kozlova, University of Oxford
Abraham’s death and burial notice in Gen. 25:9 featuring the presence of his two sons, Isaac and Ishmael, is traditionally understood as a scene of reconciliation between the brothers in the patriarch’s family. Source-critical approach in both older and more recent scholarship capitalizes on the presence of Ishmael in Gen. 25:9 and argues for an ‘ecumenical’, ‘universalist’ vision of the Priestly writer’s theology which presents Abraham as a ‘mixed ancestor, a patron who has been claimed and revered by different tribal, ethnic and religious groups.’ Against these readings this essay will attempt to show that the inclusion of Ismael’s appearance in Gen. 25:9 is not an attempt to represent long awaited harmony in the household of the pious and now deceased Abraham, but an attempt to deconstruct such monolithic representation and possibly point out the legal ramifications of his exogamous marriage to Hagar. Since ancient Israel and cognate cultures recognized the obligation of burying one’s deceased parents and providing them with post-mortem maintenance as legal expectations of an heir the deposition of Abraham’s remains to the grave by Isaac and Ishmael might signify that the issue of inheritance is revisited by the brothers. Ishmael is a first born by birth, and Isaac is a first born by Abraham’s (and divine) ordination and thus is Ishmael’s supplanter. With Abraham’s death Ishmael might just as well seek to seize the status of an oldest son and its benefits by administering the duty of an heir for his deceased father. What some envision as an idyllic burial scene might in fact be a ‘dispute over inheritance’ scene. This reading can emerge after considering the following: 1.) the compositional strategy in the Abraham narrative that consistently arranges Ishmael materials within the accounts of blessing and inheritance distribution (Gen. 17, 21, 25); 2.) the function of oracles annunciating the birth of a hero in the Hebrew Bible and their resolution at the end of the hero’s cycle (Gen. 16); 3.) the systematic representation of Ishmael as a decidedly disowned low status son before Gen. 25 ; 4.) the shifting of generations in Gen. 25 that records Ishmael’s own burial beyond the family tomb of Machpelah and the relegation of his descendants to the area beyond Abraham’s ancestral land-holding; 5.) biblical and extra-biblical practices that connect the deposition of ancestral bones to the ground with one’s exercise of hereditary claim to that land.
|
J. J. Wettstein: New Sources, New Problems, New Possibilities for Digital Research
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
Jan Krans, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam - VU University Amsterdam
Johann Jakob Wettstein (1683-1754) worked almost all his life toward the publication of his landmark 1751-52 edition of the Greek New Testament.
In recent years, a large number of previously unknown sources on and by Wettstein has come to light, scattered over libraries in Europe, that shed new light on his life and his New Testament project. This paper explores the diversity of these sources, their genres, their connections, their state of conservation and accessibility and the like. Starting from the idea that the collection offers an excellent opportunity for mapping a single scholar’s projects and international networks over time and space, it asks what challenges and possibilities for international digital research the collection entails and drafts some desiderata concerning the necessary digital infrastructure and collaboration across traditional scholarly boundaries.
|
NA28 and Conjectural Emendation
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Jan Krans, VU University Amsterdam
For NA28, it was decided to omit all explicit references to conjectural emendations from its apparatus. This paper discusses that decision in the light of several elements: the nature and development of the conjectures collection in previous Nestle editions; the role of conjectures in present-day NT textual criticism; current research into the history of (NT) conjectural emendation.
|
Synagogues as Thirdspace in Josephus’ Antiquitates Judaicae
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Andrew R. Krause, McMaster University
One of the enduring issues relating to the reconstruction of ancient Jewish institutions, including synagogues, through the writings of Flavius Josephus has been that of methodology.
While many scholars speak of synagogues as being portrayed ‘as they were’ by the historian, others speak of idealized and rhetorically-shaped versions of such institutions. However, current spatial theory provides a new way of reconciling these two tendencies. According to the Thirdspace theories of Edward Soja, all spaces are experienced as a trialectic of space ‘as it is’ (firstspace), as imagined (secondspace), and as the lived experience of both actual and ideal space (thirdspace). This paradigm allows the scholar to map the interface between the actual and the ideal in such a way as to embrace and understand both aspects as they are inscribed in the authors’ rhetoric. Most scholars undertaking rhetorical criticism of Antiquitates judaicae have noted the centrality of the ancestral customs and Law as a new constitution within Josephus’ rewriting of Judaism to fit a decentred, Temple-less context. I will argue that a critical spatial awareness of Josephus’ rhetoric illustrates that Josephus often presents the synagogue as a necessary, trans-local home for the practices in the Law and customs. I will begin by outlining the spatial importance of the synagogue in Josephus’ presentation of various Roman acta in books 14 and 16, which combine both perceived and idealized aspects of the Jewish institution. Following this, I will analyse the narrative of the Dora synagogue (A.J. 19.300–11) as a test case, arguing that Josephus presents the synagogue as a protected and ideologically-central institution within Judaism as he envisions it. Ultimately, I will show that this way of reading allows for a welcome remedy to the anti-spatial and anti-material nature of much rhetorical criticism of such classical sources.
|
The Book of the Torah in Joshua 1 and 23 and in the Deuteronomistic History
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Joachim J. Krause, Eberhard Karls Universität Tübingen
For the longest time, Joshua’s first farewell address reported in Josh 23 was held to be homogeneous and secondary, a literary unit inserted in the course of a Deuteronomistic reworking of the Deuteronomistic History (DH) and its original composition of the Joshua story. The recent analysis of Th. Römer, however, has called into question both assumptions. Römer is able to distinguish two layers within the chapter, the first of which belongs to the original composition of the DH. Subsequent analyses by E. Blum and others have confirmed the general observation: The scenario of a complete conquest of the land as presented by the first layer is contradicted by the caution against remaining peoples voiced by the second.
But where does the book of the Torah, introduced so prominently in v. 6, belong? Despite other differences, current hypotheses of the formation of the DH almost unanimously agree that references to the book of the Torah, including Josh 23:6, must be regarded as secondary additions. Followed by many, R. Smend attributed these references to a reworking of the DH concerned with observation of the law (“DtrN”). More recently, A. Rofé proposed to explain them as “nomistic corrections” inserted by pious students from the late Persian or early Hellenistic period. Either way, the book of the Torah is considered a secondary element.
Contrary to this opinio communis, I will argue the case for the book of the Torah as an integral component of the first layer to be found in Josh 23. In my view v. 6, just like most other references to the book of the Torah, is an indispensable element of the DH from its beginning. Without that book, the DH’s double aetiology?Israel winning and losing the land?is simply not comprehensible to its hearers or readers respectively. This argument requires us to analyze Josh 23 in the context of the DH (Deut 1–2Kgs 25), beginning with Josh 1:7–9.
|
Introduction
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Jutta Krispenz, Philipps-Universität Marburg
While prophecy has been looked at as one of the theologically most important parts of the Hebrew Bible, the so-called wisdom texts were perceived as reflecting an almost secular view: not clearly distinguished from wisdom literature in Mesopotamia and Egypt as it was, it could not testify for the most peculiar traits of religious thought in ancient Israel. Although studies pointed to traces of wisdom thought in prophetic writings, there seemed to be no reason to put much weight on those traces.
Recent studies by K. van der Toorn and D. Carr have now changed the way we look at the development of biblical literature. Instead of a multitude of groups with different ideological orientation we should think of only the scribes as the authors of all the biblical texts. A class trained by a common curriculum, who transmitted ancient texts, rewrote them and produced new texts. Wisdom texts like the Book of Proverbs would then be the closest we get to the curriculum the scribes went through. These texts would form the ideological starting point for all the other texts in the HB.
One interesting question would then be: How did wisdom – thought influence the prophetic tradition in the course of time? The Book of the Twelve is a very good text sample to ventilate that question, since its writings span over the complete time of prophecy. Another question is: Can we find any reactions on prophetic thought in wisdom texts?
|
Theodicy, Wisdom, and Prophecy in the Book of Habakkuk
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Thomas Krüger, Universität Zürich
Habakkuk confronts God with the prevalence of violence and injustice in the world. He complains that under these conditions every effort to restore justice is doomed to failure. God announces a Chaldean invasion in order to judge and punish the wrongdoers. However, the invaders turn out to be wicked themselves. Once again, the prophet complains about that. In his answer, God asserts that wrongdoers will in the long run have no success but will be punished by their victims or by God, whereas "the just shall live by his faith". In his final prayer, Habakkuk asks for a catastrophic theophany in which God tramples down the nations and saves his people. - In this particular manner the Book of Habakkuk discusses the problem of theodicy, which is a pivotal issue in wisdom texts like Job and Qoheleth. Habakkuk advances a solution which combines ideas that are characteristic for the prophetic stream of tradition with those that are typical of wisdom thinking. - In my paper I will try to locate the Book of Habakkuk more precisely in the development of prophetic and wisdom traditions in the Hebrew Bible.
|
“A Certain Sinner Fell into the Hands of Deceptive Teachers”: An Exegetical Enquiry into Origen’s and Ambrose’s Allegorical Reading of the Parable of the Merciful Samaritan
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
Aaron Kuecker, LeTourneau University
Origen’s homilies on Luke are a study in patristic attention to the various senses of Scripture. Origen oscillates between literal, moral, and allegorical reading strategies, frequently attending to several senses simultaneously within any given pericope. However, upon reaching the parable of the merciful Samaritan, Origen plunges headlong into a famous allegorical reading that gives no attention to the literal sense or even to the moral sense that the text itself seems to offer the reader. Origen’s allegorical reading, followed closely by Ambrose, became widely prevalent in patristic interpretation of Luke, almost as though the easy identification of Jesus with the Samaritan were too self-evident to allow for other readings. Yet the allegorical interpretation of the parable has been received by modern interpreters with robust critique and quaint amusement.
This paper offers an exegetical investigation of the readings of the parable of the merciful Samaritan offered by Origen and Ambrose, arguing that their allegorical interpretation is borne out of close attention to the literal sense of Luke’s Gospel as a whole. The argument will proceed along two tracks that demonstrate the centrality of the literal sense of Luke’s Gospel for this allegorical reading. (1) The first line of enquiry will attend to Luke’s narrative characterization of the Most High. Attention to Luke’s portrayal of Most High – especially as described in Jesus’ teaching in the Sermon on the Plain – will reveal that Jesus’ parabolic response to the lawyer in Luke 10:25-37 cuts remarkably close to Jesus’ teaching about God’s identity and life throughout the Gospel. Moreover, by claiming that followers of Jesus can participate in Jesus’ identity as Son of the Most High as they follow the Most High in practices of enemy love, generosity, and mercy, Luke creates a clear equation between the life of the Most High, the life of Jesus, and the practices of Jesus’ followers. Thus the Gospel, in its literal sense, offers itself without protest to the allegorical readings given by Origen and Ambrose, at least in terms of reiterating the basic content of the Gospel – the identity of God made known in Jesus by the Spirit. (2) The second line of enquiry will sample readings from Origen and Ambrose on early sections of Luke, demonstrating that their reading of the literal sense of the text is concerned most basically with testifying to the identity and character of God. Their exegetical attention to God’s identity makes the allegorical sense of the merciful Samaritan a natural outgrowth of their theological reading of the plain sense of Luke’s Gospel.
The paper will conclude by suggesting ways that the relationship between these allegorical readings of Luke 10.25-37 and Luke’s attention to the identity and character of the Most High, the Son of the Most High, and the Spirit could function as a test case for considering the exegetical viability of particular allegorical readings.
|
The Most High Went Down to Jericho: The Merciful Samaritan and Luke’s Characterization of God
Program Unit: Gospel of Luke
Aaron Kuecker, LeTourneau University
This paper will examine the extent to which Luke’s parable of the merciful Samaritan can be interpreted as a narrative characterization of God that functions within Luke’s wider plotline to invite Luke’s hearers to share in practices central to God’s identity and life.
The central argument of the paper is the claim that the parable of the merciful Samaritan gives climactic expression to Luke’s characterization of God in the first half of the Gospel. Analysis will begin with Jesus’ description of the Most High as one who is “merciful” and “kind to the ungrateful and wicked” (Luke 6.35-36). These claims about the identity of the Most High clarify and develop Luke’s telling of God’s identity and character in earlier sections of Luke and their significance in the wider narrative is amplified by the fact that it is the mercy, enemy love and radical generosity of the Most High that forms the orienting clue for the practices of Jesus’ followers. We learn from Luke that followers of Jesus who practice mercy, enemy love and radical generosity can themselves be filially related to God as sons and daughters of the Most High, an identity for which Jesus, the Son of the Most High (Luke 1.32), is the prototype. This nexus of identity-related concerns – Luke’s deliberate characterization of the Most High, Jesus’ exemplary life as the Spirit-empowered Son of the Most High, and the potential that Jesus’ followers can be sons and daughters of the Most High – suggests that Luke thinks the primary human vocation is to be like God, sharing in God’s life of mercy, radical generosity, and enemy love. With this data in view, I will offer a reading of the parable of the merciful Samaritan through the lens of Luke’s characterization of God, arguing that by virtue of its narrative context and its emphasis on mercy, enemy love and radical generosity, the parable both reflects the life of the Most High and functions to invite hearers to share in the life of God through practices central to God’s identity.
The narrative links between the parable of the merciful Samaritan and Luke’s characterization of God offer several promising leads for Luke’s broader vision of salvation. First, the presence within this parable of numerous themes central to Luke’s overall project (wealth and possessions, the proper place and interpretation of Torah, enemy love, and relations between Israelites and non-Israelites), suggests that discussions of Luke’s ethics must be grounded in Luke’s primarily theological vision of human life. Second, this reading suggests that Luke’s vision of salvation might be more aptly described by participatory notions of salvation wherein Jesus’ followers can share in Jesus’ exemplary sonship, resulting in both filial relation and human transformation. Finally, this reading hints that the free-wheeling allegorical interpretations of the parable offered by patristic commentators may, in light of a close narrative reading of Luke’s characterization of God, have greater exegetical validity (of a certain sort, at least) than is sometimes granted.
|
Wisdom, Pedagogy, and the Divine Manipulation of Time
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
James Kugel, Harvard University (retired); Bar Ilan University
One of the most characteristic features of apocalyptic literature is its tendency to organize time into periods, sometimes of fairly long duration: the “Four Kingdoms” and "Seventy Weeks" of Daniel; the “Apocalypse of Weeks” in 1 Enoch; the visions of 2 Baruch, 4 Ezra; and so forth. The very fact of the eschatological orientation of these texts would seem to be the reason for their interest in time and its subdivisions: a writer looking forward to the Endzeit will obviously be concerned about how far away it is, as well as how it may make sense of recent or not-so-recent history.
Yet this may not be all there is to this feature of apocalyptic writings; rather, it seems to be rooted in something still more basic in the “wisdom mentality,” with which apocalyptic writings are frequently associated This pedagogical aspect of time will be explored in a number of wisdom-inspired texts that display no obvious interest in apocalyptic eschatology.
|
Thomas and the Synoptics: What Do We Mean by ‘Primitivity’?
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Chris Kugler, Duke University
What do we mean by “primitivity” in Gospel tradition? As we study the Synoptics comparatively, we are soon pressed to postulate sources. Once we have done this, on the majority 2ST, we proceed on the assumption that Mark should be more "primitive" in every detail in the parallel accounts. In other words, if Mark is an earlier text, it cannot be that Matthew and/or Luke would ever admit of earlier, more primitive material in the triple tradition. Though without stating as much, this seems to be an implicit denial of the vitality of oral tradition in the late decades of the first century. Moreover, this itself has been one of the main arguments for Q. If Luke, as the Q theory argues, ever shows a more "primitive" account in material common to himself and Matthew, this tells against the Farrer theory and in favor of Q. If Luke ever seems to be earlier, despite if he is often demonstrably dependent upon and/or later than Matthew, this one example of “alternating primitivity” eliminates the possibility of Matthean dependence completely. Likewise, this same argument has been hugely influential in discussions of the Gospel of Thomas. It is often said that because Thomas appears to be more primitive in certain Synoptic material, he cannot have been dependent upon the Synoptic Gospels. Two basic assumptions are operative at this point. (1) If a text is demonstrably dependent upon another text in several places, it should never demonstrate earlier traditions elsewhere. (2) Primitivity is reflected in a poorer use of Greek, a shorter text, and/or the lack of scriptural proof texts. In my paper, both through comparing Thomas with certain synoptic passages and through comparing the Synoptics themselves, I will demonstrate that (1) is flatly inaccurate and methodologically flawed, while (2) is imprecise and misleading. I will argue that there is nothing problematic about a text being dependent at many points upon another text, thus establishing a source, while also possessing traditions which either seem to be or in actuality are older traditions. Moreover, I will give suggestions and examples as to what should and should not count as “primitivity”, so as to sharper our categories for using this helpful source-critical tool.
|
A Sovereign or a Servant of God? How a Diachronic Reading of the Story of Rebecca Amplifies the Matriarchal Strength and Independence
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Gili Kugler, Tel Aviv University
In my paper I will focus on the biblical story about Jacob and Esau’s family, examining the contribution of the diachronic approach of the text to our understanding of the authors’ social and gender perspectives.
The story of Jacob and Esau is embedded within an editorial framework that highlights the idea of the ancestors’ relationship with God. By the historical-literary analysis of the text I will show a disparity in the portrayal of Rebecca, the wife/matriarch, as a result of the tension between the story in its socio-familial level and its ideological reworking in the current text.
Gender scholars draw attention to the central role Rebecca plays in the story of the patriarchs. They all read, however, Genesis 25 and 27 together, and place Rebecca’s actions in ch. 27 under the shadow of God’s promise, as says Tammi Schneider: “The description of Rebekah and her actions show that she is a strong, decisive individual chosen by the Israelite Deity to bear and ensure that the correct child inherits the Deity’s promise” (Schneider, 2008).
I would like to demonstrate that Rebecca as a “strong, decisive individual” can be adduced only by reading the text diachronically. While in the familial narrative in ch. 27 Rebecca is depicted as serving a key and exclusive role in determining her offspring’s future, in the ideological editing of the story in ch. 25, she becomes an unwitting tool in God’s plan. Only by detaching the story of the blessing from its theological justification are we able to recognize what Susan Niditch observes: “one… might ask if women were not also responsible in shaping such tellings” (Niditch, 1998).
The conclusions of this case study may help in revealing the literary and social role of women and other minor characters that drive the biblical plot.
|
“Homosexuality Is Unafrican and Unbiblical": Examining the Ideological Motivations to Homophobia in Sub-Saharan Africa—The Case Study of Uganda
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Kuloba W. Robert, Kyambogo University
There is no doubt that homosexuality existed in pre-colonial Africa as also in the Bible world. However, the iconographic representation of homosexuality today as unafrican and unbiblical begs for a deeper investigations and analyses. Significantly, the antipathy against homosexuality in Sub-Saharan Africa is polemicized as bulwark of African cultural and biblical imperatives. This antipathy has crystallized into several legislations and incrimination acts in some countries, which in the Ugandan context was codenamed “Christmas Gift to Ugandans” by the national assembly speaker. My study situates homosexuality in the context of hybridity of African and biblical traditional values. Using cultural and biblical hermeneutics and sociological approaches, the study interrogates cultural nuggets of human sexuality in African and biblical contexts. The study explores the following questions: If homosexuality was in Africa, as also the Bible world, what is then ‘unafrican’ and ‘unbiblical’ about homosexuality? How should the African reader of the Bible to day respond to the reality of homosexuality and the concepts of inalienable rights in a globalised—African society?
|
A Rock in the Tides of History: Julius Wellhausen, Hermann Gunkel, and the Academic Enterprise
Program Unit: Metacriticism of Biblical Scholarship
Paul Michael Kurtz, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
“More chaos than creation,” spurned liberal Bismarckian and old guardsman Julius Wellhausen the ambitious new venture of Hermann Gunkel’s Schöpfung und Chaos in Urzeit und Endzeit. Whereas practitioners of biblical scholarship and historians within the discipline have often juxtaposed these figures as personal foes or intellectual adversaries, the difference between them proved rather typical within the greater social and cultural shifts of Wilhelmine Germany at the fin de siècle, as Fritz Ringer’s The Decline of the German Mandarins and Suzanne L. Marchand’s German Orientalism in the Age of Empire have eloquently illustrated. Reinterpreting the historiography—and even hagiography—of Gunkel and Wellhausen, this paper will employ their famed dispute as a concrete case study to launch a greater discussion of the larger intellectual landscape of biblical scholarship in the final decades of the nineteenth century, a period marked by that “Second Oriental Renaissance” which yielded new materials and methods alike. Indeed, the endeavors of a younger generation, especially those of the so-called religionsgeschichtlicher Schule, met considerable resistance from the firmly established order, an older generation of scholars who largely eschewed comparative study and deployed their institutional powers to preserve the status quo. The neoromantics may have won the day, but the battle was certainly hard-fought. Frequently confined to professional margins, many turned to alternative publications and public audiences to support their researches and livelihoods alike. Engaging private correspondence and open publications, this essay explores the structural forces that guided academic discourse almost a century and a half ago – forces transformed but no less active today.
|
Examining Distinctive Relationships between Job and Deutero-Isaiah
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
JiSeong James Kwon, University of Durham
Up to recent times, biblical scholars claiming the distinctive relationship between the book of Job and the book of Deutero-Isaiah have mainly focused on linguistic similarities. Using a set of the same subject-matters and terms, they have at least proposed the intentional or unintentional reference between texts as the appropriate way to explain these stylistic and thematic similarities. The claim is either that the final editor of the book of Job, who was much aware of the texts of Isaiah 40-55, utilized it in the context of Job, or that Deutero-Isaiah knew the work of Job and directly responded to it. However, the concept of the literary dependence between texts seems to have potentional problems and has not been appropriately examined. Therefore, it is necessary to investigate detailed cases supporting the literary relationship if this relationship is to be upheld.
For this purpose, I apply some tests to types of resemblances and show that the supposed links between them do exist in some cases. If proposed resemblances imply either that the authors of Job knew Deutero-Isaiah or that Deutero-Isaiah knew the work of Job, how can it be proved? If it is possible to demonstrate that the types of resemblances between the two books are such that they have a distinctive literary dependence, we must show that there are real affinities between the two books in terms of identical ideas and that the verbal connections are using precise analogies in the terms, motifs, and themes. Furthermore, it should be demonstrated that the literary links are neither prevalent verbal expressions nor well-known subject-matter that any biblical texts are likely to contain.
|
A Rhetorical Analysis of Paul’s Use of Prolambano and Ekdechomai (1 Cor 11:21, 33)
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Oh-Young Kwon, Whitley College
This paper argues that Paul rhetorically uses the two words – prolambano (‘to take first’, v. 21) and ekdechomai (‘to wait for’, v. 33) in the literary context of 1 Corinthians 11.17-34 to challenge the inhospitable atmosphere of the Christ-believers’ meal at Corinth and to encourage them to exercise the Lord’s hospitality at their table fellowship.
These two words, as argued, play a significant role in Paul’s rhetorical strategy in this particular passage that can be understood as a deliberative discourse in which Paul’s argument is drawn from ‘contradiction’. Paul cleverly uses prolambano before ekdechomai and after his description of the Lord’s Supper so as to attack the Corinthian Christians’ inappropriate practice of it and to motivate them to exhibit the love and hospitality of Christ towards one another, especially given the distinctive multicultural context of first century Corinth.
|
The Wisdom Category: Ancient Tradition or Modern Invention?
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Will Kynes, Whitworth University
When did the Wisdom category arise? Since categorization is a form of interpretation, understanding when and how the category arose will shed new light on the category’s effect on the interpretation of its contents. The origins of this classification of Proverbs, Job, and Ecclesiastes is a “grey area” in biblical scholarship, though there is a widespread view that “vestiges of early nomenclature of this material as ‘wisdom’ goes back to patristic times” (Dell 2013). These “vestiges,” to which scholars appeal for early evidence of the category, include Josephus’s mention of four books in the Hebrew canon that contain “hymns to God and instructions for people on life” (Contra Apionis 1.8), Origen’s comment that biblical wisdom expresses the “basic principles of true philosophy” (Comm. Cant. Prologue), and the Vulgate division libri didactici. On closer examination, however, if this evidence reflects an early Wisdom category, its contents and definition differ significantly from the current category. This draws the value of these references as proof texts for ancient conceptions of Wisdom into question. If, for example, Josephus is referring to Psalms, Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, and Song of Songs, thereby omitting Job while including two books that are generally excluded from the modern Wisdom category, is it legitimate to find in his comment proof for the antiquity of that category? This raises questions for the category’s ancient pedigree. Might Wisdom instead be a modern invention, something that “first emerged in the scholarly world” (von Rad 1970; cf. Weeks 2010)? If so, an investigation of whether modern emphases (such as rationalism, empiricism, humanism, and universalism) may have influenced (and potentially distorted) the category’s development and subsequent interpretation is needed.
|
Reorientation in Responsibility for the Ark: The Levites’ Role in Deuteronomistic History
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Antje Labahn, Kirchliche Hochschule Wuppertal/Bethel
Within the books Samuel–Kings, the Levites appear just three times: 1Sam 6:15; 2Sam 15:24; 1Kön 8:4. In these rare occurrences, the Levites are active in carrying the ark. Such a statement is quite surprising since in the context it is the duty of other personnel. Diachronic analyses show that these three little remarks originated somewhat later. According to such a late Deuteronomistic portrait, the Levites take over the role now. Due to a reorientation in responsibility for the ark and its content the Levites are put into that particular role. This paper analyzes the role of the Levites in reflecting on nomistic implications which were linked with the group in various traditions.
|
Between Those on High and Those Below: Gender and Servitude at the Boundaries
Program Unit: Slavery, Resistance, and Freedom
Gail Labovitz, American Jewish University
There are multiple stories, in both the Palestinian and Babylonian Talmuds, featuring a female slave belonging to Rabbi Yehudah haNasi (commonly known as Rebbe), the patriarch of the Palestinian Jewish community in the late 2nd-early 3rd century c.e. The slave is never named; rather, she is always and only identified in relation to the man who is her owner and master. What the character (or characters) does have however, in many though not all of the stories, is a voice and an opportunity to speak – something that is often not true in stories about (named) male slaves. On the other hand, the persons to whom she speaks are not her master, who never figures entirely directly in the narratives. Much, then, is intriguing about this recurring pairing, of a man of highest social standing and a character who ought to be doubly marginalized by gender and servitude. In this paper, I will argue that boundaries, literal and figurative – crossing them, maintaining them, helping or hindering others to move across them – are a common theme to these episodes.
For example, an obvious mystery about this woman (or women) is that of her national origin. In a story that appears only once, in the Palestinian Talmud (yBer 3:4, 6c), she deflects a man's sexual advances by likening herself to an animal and thus a sexual encounter with her to bestiality. For the analogy to fulfill its rhetorical purpose, the woman must be identifying herself as non-Jewish and the man as Jewish, bound by Jewish law. Yet she is also capable of bolstering her case by quoting the Scriptural prescription of capital punishment for one who commits bestiality. The resulting image, then, is a woman who places herself at one and the same time as non-Jew (slave, beast) and Jew (familiar with Jewish Scriptures, seeking to observe Jewish norms of sexual behavior).
Another intriguing trait attributed to this woman or women is knowledge of Hebrew linguistic terms that rabbis, the supposed masters of Scripture and the "Torah" in its broad sense, themselves are seeking to understand but do not. In both the Palestinian and Babylonian variants of this episode, she seemingly uses the terms casually, in the course of her ordinary speech; the rabbis do not directly present their question to her (or to Rebbe through her). How and why she is familiar with these terms is not explained. One theory is that the slave woman is positioned at a boundary between non-Jewish origins and affiliation with Jewish tradition and knowledge superior even to that of the rabbis. Through these examples and others, this paper will explore the paradox of a female character who is both outsider and at the center of Jewish Palestinian rabbinic society, subordinate and speaking subject, straddling boundaries both "literal" and figurative.
|
“Physical” Education: Metaphors of the Body in Ben Sira
Program Unit: Senses, Cultures, and Biblical Worlds
Nathalie LaCoste, University of Toronto
One of the best resources for Jewish educational practices in the Hellenistic period is the book of Ben Sira. This book of instruction provides insights into the role of education and how it functioned for Jews living both in Palestine and the Diaspora. In this paper, I will examine some of the bodily aspects of education, mainly movement and discipline, and their appearance in two common conceptual metaphors used in Ben Sira: education as a journey and education as discipline. This will be followed by a discussion of the figure of Sophia as the embodiment of education in Ben Sira.
My approach builds upon the methodological foundation laid by George Lakoff and Mark Johnson concerning the construction of meaning and the use of conceptual metaphors (Metaphors we Live By). I will also engage with discussions on embodiment and ways of viewing the self within an environment in an attempt to better understand the function of these physical metaphors and the role of Sophia in the book of Ben Sira (Johnson, The Meaning of the Body; Csordas, Body/Meaning/Healing).
Through an investigation into the use of physical metaphors (education as journey and as discipline) and the embodiment of education developed through the figure of Sophia, I will demonstrate how Jewish education was more akin to Greek models in terms of its physicality and bodily involvement than has previously been acknowledged. This is not to say that the study of sacred and authoritative texts was not important; it was certainly of primary concern to Ben Sira. Yet, by focusing entirely on the intellectual teachings of Jewish education, we perpetuate the incorrect notion that Jewish education did not involve the body. This paper, therefore, will illuminate the importance of the body for Jewish educational practices resulting in a better understanding of the physical aspects of Jewish education.
|
Textual Transmission of the Greek New Testament: The Case of Beratinus 1 (GA Phi.043) and Beratinus 2 (GA 1143)
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Didier Lafleur, Institut de Recherche et d’Histoire des Textes
Beratinus 1 (GA Phi.043) and Beratinus 2 (GA 1143) are two famous luxury purple manuscripts currently housed by the Albanian National Archives (Tirana). Beratinus 1 is an uncial codex dated from the 6th c. and only contains parts of Matthew and Mark Gospels ; its text, classified as Byzantine by the Alands, was only known through Pierre Batiffol’s publication (1868). Beratinus 2 is a minuscule manuscript dated from the 9th c., and contains the four Gospels : its text was never studied or published despite its strong similarity with GA 565, a “Caesarean” text-type witness.
At first these two manuscripts were briefly described by Anthimos Alexoudis during the last quarter of the 19th century but this survey was the first and the last as nobody, except Batiffol, carried on the research afterwards. Because Albania remained isolated for decades, the textual transmission of these manuscripts was never studied. During the 1970's Johannes Koder and Erich Trapp brought fresh overview on the Greek manuscripts housed in Tirana but without the purple codices which were then considered as lost. Recently, the publication of Roderic L. Mullen (2003) and Daniel B. Wallace's digital preservation campaign for Greek New Testament manuscripts (CSNTM) emphasized afresh these two highly valuable codices.
This paper will focus on the textual transmission of Beratinus 1 and Beratinus 2, exploring their variant readings and textual features in the way to assess their peculiar text-type. Only based on autopsy of the documents, the survey offers fresh and new supplementary data over an unpublished textual transmission of the Greek New Testament.
|
The Academy vs. the Grassroots: Cognitive Dissonance on Interfaith Dialogue
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
Carol Schersten LaHurd, Lutheran School of Theology at Chicago
A glance at the expanding AAR/SBL offerings on religious pluralism suggests that many, if not most, academic types welcome interreligious dialogue and relations. But is that posture shared in mosques, temples, synagogues, and churches? Many scholars view as central the question: How can one both commit to a specific religious tradition and affirm other ways of relating to ultimate reality? What if clergy and lay persons outside the academy ask instead: How can I protect my family from those different and possibly hostile? Or, how far must I take the biblical command to love the neighbor? Or, why doesn't the larger culture recognize the needs and values of my tradition? This paper will explore potential ways to navigate some of what may divide the grassroots and the academy on issues of interreligious dialogue and relations.
|
Penitence in Nehemiah 9: Symbolic Language and Social Transformation
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Donna J. Laird, Drew University
Nehemiah 9 is one of the clearest and earliest examples of penitential prayers in the Hebrew Bible. Rodney Werline has shown penitential prayers build on Deuteronomistic theology: a broken covenant results in exile and only repentance can bring deliverance. In the aftermath of the exile penitential prayers became institutionalized as the proper means to express repentance. Mark Boda suggests the prayers were intended to bring an end to the devastating effects of the fall of the state: either to captivity, oppression, or the sorry condition of Palestine. Yet we might ask why, after the punishment of exile, penitence was embraced to facilitate this goal? What social and cultural conditions would lead the community to embrace self-criticism over past events as a means of seeking economic or political restoration? How did penitential logic come to resonate with post-exilic audiences? In this paper sociological and psychological studies are used to map the concepts of guilt, shame, and national trauma and to assess the role each plays in such prayers. Using the work of Pierre Bourdieu on ritual and symbolic language this paper then explores how the prayer and the community covenant with which its linked construct categories to redefine the social order and provide a framework for the social (re)construction of the community. It also evaluates who stands to benefit from the commitments made. In particular it considers how the text navigates the competing interests of the empire, the cultural producers responsible for this text, and its recipients.
|
Exegesis and Empire in Byzantium: Insights from New Testament Catenae
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
William Lamb, Westcott House
Catenae marginales were a familiar device for interpreting the Bible in the Byzantine world. Marked out by a distinctive ‘geography’ of the page, these commentaries present the biblical text embedded within a ‘chain’ or anthology of scholia and extracts from the writings of a diverse range of commentators from the first six centuries of the common era. While some scholars have referred to the 'doctrinal neutrality' of these texts, more careful study suggests that their exegesis served to impose greater constraints on the contours of doctrinal debate. Drawing on the insights of Michael Maas, I will argue that the recording of ‘differences of opinion on the same questions’ in a catena, far from constituting a polyphony of independent and unmerged voices, in fact created ‘a staged conversation’ that served to underline and reinforce the orthodoxy of the imperial state church.
|
Commentary or Scripture? The Ideology of Rewritten Bible
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
David Lambert, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
This paper examines a moment of robust biblical interpretation but one which existed prior to commentary as a form, namely the genre of Rewritten Bible in the late Second Temple period. Many scholars seeing a widespread unanimity already in this period about the status of Scripture and seeking to ease the apparent divergence between this early form of biblical interpretation and later manifestations tend to treat Rewritten Bible as, more or less, a particular form of commentary. This paper will argue that the difference between Rewritten Bible and later forms of commentary is not formal alone. It relates to the very ideological construction of the status of Scripture and its uses. By looking at a moment before commentary, by denaturalizing commentary as the dominant form of biblical interpretation, this paper hopes to shed further light on the contingent practices by which the commentary form configures Scripture and what alternatives might have existed, even as it charts early developments that paved the way for that form. The focus will be on considering this series of questions in the context of the Book of Jubilees, but some attention will also be paid to Pesher Habbakuk and rabbinic midrash as points of comparison.
|
Toward a New Philology of the Everyday
Program Unit: Philology in Hebrew Studies
David Lambert, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
Philology remains associated, rightly or wrongly, with the arcane, with the search for a resolution to the rare word, the hapax legomenon or its near equivalent. The philologist is called in when a normal or natural understanding of the language fails to produce verifiable meaning. And, so, the tools employed by philologists are often highly specialized, comparative Semitic data, epigraphy, and the like. All of these approaches still have their uses, though they have exhausted themselves, perhaps, in some measure. But, there is still a vast trove of data yet awaiting sufficient critical consideration. I have in mind precisely those everyday, common terms whose meanings, we are assured, are comprehensible readily enough, whose dictionary definitions are known to all students of biblical Hebrew. What has stood in the way thus far of their adequate assessment relates to another ongoing concern with the state of philology, the need to take into fuller account its origins as a modern Western science with all of the implications of that position. What is lacking is greater critical awareness of the cultural presuppositions with which we as contemporary readers render words. This paper will focus on instances—the definition of lev and the meaning of “love” in the Hebrew Bible—where a rather large chasm separates contemporary understanding from ancient context, where, in particular, we can see modern Western notions of the subject shaping our assessment of biblical terms.
|
Ritual, Media, and Conflict in Pauline Communities
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Jason T. Lamoreaux, Texas A&M University
This paper will explore the intersection between ritual, physical media, and the conflict that arises in various Pauline communities. The ritual context of Pauline communities was diverse and each city provided a different set of images associated with rituals, whether those images were statuary, temples, reliefs, coins, etc. This study will construct a model of ritual and media and then apply it briefly to a select few contexts, particularly involving Corinth and Philippi, in order to demonstrate its usefulness for evoking new questions for the interpreter as well as providing intriguing answers surrounding intra-community and inter-community conflict.
|
I Love to Tell the Story: The Narrative Subversion of the Bible's "Grey" Texts
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Jeffrey S. Lamp, Oral Roberts University
Norman Habel, in his book An Inconvenient Text, describes an ecological hermeneutic that grants interpretive priority to two passages in the New Testament: Romans 8:18-27 and Colossians 1:15-20. Noting that the Bible presents conflicting depictions of the relationship between God and human beings on the one hand and Earth on the other hand, Habel argues that these two passages provide a lens through which to construct a green reading of the Bible over against those texts that present a more grey, that is non-green, viewpoint on that relationship. Central to this approach is the selection of texts that correlate to the view of God as seen in Jesus Christ, a view that sees God suffering in solidarity with both human beings and Earth in anticipation of their final liberation from corruption.
This paper draws on Habel's approach to suggest two hermeneutical considerations that would complement Habel's approach. First, Habel's paradigm of green vs. grey texts will be expanded to suggest that within Scripture itself there are texts that intentionally subvert other texts. Habel's approach seems to suggest that two competing pictures exist alongside one another in the Bible, and that green interpreters are to choose the green texts as a matter of preference. The suggestion of this paper is that this choice is made in Scripture itself, with green texts arising to subvert the grey texts.
Second, the paper suggests that this subversion exists in significant measure in a series of narrative threads that weave their way through the canon. One prominent narrative thread draws on christological categories to present a subversive counter reading to grey texts. In agreement with Habel, Christ represents a decisive shift in the narrative that reshapes Scripture's grey traditions.
|
Muslima Theology and Relational Qur'anic Hermeneutics
Program Unit: Qur’anic Studies: Methodology and Hermeneutics (IQSA)
Jerusha Tanner Lamptey, Union Theological Seminary in the City of New York
This paper explores a novel hermeneutical approach to the Qur'anic text, which I have termed Muslima theology. Drawing resources from the approaches of Muslim women interpreters of the Qur'an and from the method of semantic analysis of Toshihiko Izutsu, Muslima theology aims to articulate and then employ a hermeneutical approach that focuses on exploring and explicating-rather than disentangling-the Qur?an's complex, relational web. This particular hermeneutical approach arises out of concern with the manner in which the Qur'an's provocative complexity and ambiguity has been reduced and silenced through other historical and contemporary interpretative approaches. In this paper, I also aim to draw attention to the intimate connection between hermeneutical strategies and underlying conceptual frameworks. Hermeneutical approaches do exist in a vacuum; they arise-whether implicitly or explicitly-from the manner in which we conceive of the subject of interpretation. This is particularly evident in interpretations related to topics of human difference, such as sexual and gender difference, and religious difference. Many hermeneutical approaches to these topics have been premised upon a particular view of human difference as being demarcated by clear-cut, static boundaries. This has led to methods that seek to inscribe such boundaries on the Qur'anic text and thereby result in 'readings' that perpetuate notions of inherent and absolute evaluative distinctions between groups of people. Such inherent and absolute distinctions have then, far too frequently, become the willing handmaidens of injustice.
|
The Self-Similar Koran
Program Unit: Linguistic, Literary, and Thematic Perspectives on the Qur’anic Corpus (IQSA)
Giuliano Lancioni, Università degli Studi Roma Tre
The Koran is self-similar: it proclaims itself to be so (if this is indeed the meaning of kitab mutašabih, xxxix:23, and mutašabihat, iii:7) and the huge amount of Koranic passages which appears to be more or less similar to each other is a fact that stands out even in a first cursory reading. The exegetical genre mutašabihat al-Qur'an has made of this very fact its specific object of study and, in some cases (al-Kirmani, al-Garnati) even the key to unveiling the hidden meanings of the Koran. Whatever it is, the Western scholarship on the Koran itself has faced this evidence in a plurality of approaches (Bell, Wansbrough, Neuwirth), while never denying it. Nevertheless, in both domains none has ever tried to quantify objectively the extent of the phenomenon: in fact, no independent measure of the degree of similarity of the text has been provided yet, which makes room for arbitrariness in this matter. This paper aims to fill this gap in the independent assertion of the self-similarity of the text by devising a number of objective metrics in order to evaluate it outside any ideological or wishful attitude. In order to do so, our strategy is to capitalize on general-purpose similarity devices, not especially tailored to the text under examination, in order to maximize the validity of results. In particular, we test various variants of the well-known Levenshtein algorithm (a general-purpose similarity metrics first introduced in information theory by Vladimir Levenshtein in 1965) on the Koranic text in several segmentations (graphical words, morphemes, lemmas). More sophisticate approaches involve shading the level of similarity in word substitutions according to the graphical and phonetic distance of substitutes and assigning different scores to additions and deletions according to generally known variant phenomena in Koranic manuscripts. The results of different setups of the algorithm are tested against reasonably comparable texts (in particular, the Arabic version of the Diatessaron, which is not too removed in time, language and character from the Koran, while removing the inherent similarity embodied in the very definition of synoptic evangels), in order to show the statistical significance of the similarity results.
|
The Benefits Outweigh the Costs: Human Obedience and Divine Blessing in 2 Cor 6:1–7:2
Program Unit: Second Corinthians: Pauline Theology in the Making
Christopher D. Land, McMaster Divinity College
Although most interpreters regard 2 Cor 6:11–13 as part of an appeal for mutual affection, numerous signals indicate that this passage concerns divine provisions that enable obedience in the midst of difficulty (cf. 2 Cor 1:3–11). In this paper, I will argue that this preoccupation begins already in 6:1 and continues unabated all the way through the exhortations in 6:14–7:1, demonstrating that this understanding of Paul’s concern is better able to account for the wording of 6:11–13. Specifically, I will argue that: (1) the expression to stoma hêmôn aneôgen pros hymas invokes the exemplary model that Paul and Timothy have provided by their willingness to speak boldly to the Corinthians despite the risk of causing offence; (2) the expression hê kardia hêmôn peplatyntai, like the similar expression in Ps 118:32 LXX, describes the divinely bestowed encouragement that has enabled Paul and Timothy's costly obedience; (3) the expression ou stenochôreisthe en hêmin refutes the claim that Paul and Timothy are unfairly restricting the conduct of the Corinthians; (4) the expression stenochôreisthe en tois splanchnois hymôn proposes instead that the Corinthians are being constrained by their anxieties (i.e. they are too timid to obey God’s commands); and (5) the phrase tên autên antimisthian does not mean ‘the same thing as a fair exchange’ but rather ‘the same fair exchange’ and it refers, not to mutual affection, but to an exchange involving human obedience and divine encouragement/salvation. With these points in place, 6:1–7:2 unfolds seamlessly as a scripturally-grounded appeal for separation from idolatry—a costly obedience which some of the Corinthians are strenuously resisting as an unfair restriction that will no doubt ruin them (7:2; cf. 1 Cor 8:1–11:1).
|
Blurred Lines: Apocryphal Additions to New Testament Manuscripts
Program Unit: Gospel of Luke
Brent Landau, University of Texas at Austin
One of the most enduring legacies of François Bovon's scholarship is his insistence on placing canonical and apocryphal Christian writings in conversation in a range of creative ways. Among my earliest memories of working with him at Harvard was his presentation in his Christian Apocrypha course of apocryphal traditions contained in NT manuscripts, especially the Freer Logion (found between Mark 16:14 and 15 in Codex Washingtonianus) and the "Zion Gospel" edition manuscripts (containing readings from Jewish-Christian Gospels in marginal notations). In this paper I build upon Bovon's foundation by examining three other cases of apocryphal material found in NT text-critical variants: 1) the description of Jesus' resurrection found between Mark 16:3 and 4 in the Old Latin Codex Bobiensis; 2) the additional charges leveled against Jesus in Luke 23:2-5 found in several Latin witnesses; and 3) the elaboration of the crowd's reaction to Jesus' death in Luke 23:48 according to Syriac and Latin manuscripts.
|
On Lips and Tongues in Ancient Hebrew: A Semantic Analysis
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Yael Landman, Yeshiva University
The semantic range of co-meronyms safah 'lip' and lashon 'tongue'
developed throughout the history of Ancient Hebrew. Both words
underwent semantic widening based on their physical and spatial
properties (e.g. their line- or wedge-like shape) and on their shared
function as articulators. From Biblical Hebrew (BH) to Mishnaic Hebrew
(MH), safah primarily underwent semantic narrowing, whereas lashon
underwent both narrowing and widening. In BH, safah may refer to a
lip, to a language or speech, or to an edge. In Late Biblical Hebrew
(LBH) and MH, safah means 'lip' and 'edge'. In BH, lashon may refer to
a tongue; to a language or nation; or to a bay of water, a bar of
gold, or a flame. In LBH, lashon means 'tongue' and 'language'; in MH,
lashon may refer to a tongue, a language, speech, and to tongue-shaped
things (bodies of water and pieces of material). This paper argues
that by the time of MH, safah had undergone semantic narrowing, losing
its meanings related to the lip's association with talking, and so
should not be translated 'speech' in ambiguous contexts (e.g. tTa'an
3:12). It further argues that the semantic widening of lashon to
include the meaning 'speech' began to take place in BH in the context
of words from the realm of deceit, in phrases such as lashon
medabberet gedolot (Ps 12:4). The redundancy of collocating 'tongu'?
('the body part with which one speaks') with verbs of saying
('speaks') led to abridgment of phrases such as "lashon medabberet X"
to "leshon X." The absence of verbs in phrases such as leshon shaqer
(Pr 6:17); leshon tarmit (Zeph 3:13); and leshon mirmah (Ps 52:6)
created an environment where lashon could be construed as 'tongue' or
'speech', and this ambiguity led to the semantic widening of 'tongue'
to 'speech'. By the time of MH, lashon with the meaning 'speech,
utterance, statement' had grown common. Finally, this paper
demonstrates that the mapping of co-meronymns safah and lashon onto
bodies of water is a productive phenomenon cross-linguistically, and
suggests avenues for further research.
|
Prophecy and Alterity in Isaiah's Oracles against the Nations
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Francis Landy, University of Alberta
Metaphor is a device for transferring one conceptual field onto another, so as to create a network of correspondences, as classically formulated by Baudelaire. It crosses the gap between remote entities, thereby unifying the poetic world. I am interested in metaphor as a technique for producing strangeness, making the real unreal. In Isaiah’s Oracles against the Nations, the primary metaphor is Israel as an Other, as one of the many nations under God’s judgement or solicitude. Thus the Oracles against the Nations section is framed by units concerning the fate of Israel and Judah. Moreover, Jerusalem itself is the subject of one of the oracles, “the burden of the valley of vision” in ch. 22. On the one hand, the mirroring effect contributes to a dialectical process whereby the entire world is unified under the divine aegis, programmatically announced in 2.2-4 and completed at the end of the book. On the other, it destabilizes the foundational difference between Israel and the nations, exemplified by the apotheosis of Zion. I will look at some of the images and wordplays through which this process of mirroring and estrangement is accomplished. Examples will include the oracle concerning Moab in chs.15-16, in which prophetic sympathy establishes a metaphoric link between the prophet himself and the subject of his grief. The difference and likeness between Israel and the nations is, however, correlated with another constitutive component of the poetics of Isaiah: the difference between the language of this world, characterized by its lack of comprehension of true values, and the clarity of the new age. The prophet, as the harbinger of the new age, cannot but speak in a language, which, for all its appearance of explicability, points to a surplus or a trnnscendence of meaning. The prophet himself then is a figure of estrangement, mediating between the self and the other, Israel and the nations, this world and the future utopia.
|
The Mythical and the Mystical: Rivers in Psalm 93
Program Unit: Bible, Myth, and Myth Theory
Francis Landy, University of Alberta
Psalm 93 has long been a battleground between those who think it represents the Chaoskampf and those who think that it is demythologized. In this paper I want to sidestep this discussion, with its roots in the theological assumption that the Hebrew Bible adopts and/or reacts against the polytheistic myths of its neighbours, to show how the mythological is transmuted in the poetic and ultimately mystical imagination. If, as Wendy Doniger shows, myths are foundational for any culture, and are valuable precisely because they may be repeated and interpreted in many different ways, then the poetic reconfiguration of myth gives us insight into how poets used and reused inherited materials. The deep past is relived in the present, and becomes the basis for an experience of transcendence. In Psalm 93, the voices of the rivers and sea may evoke a primeval rage against creation, but they are heard through the voice of the poet, as part of, or a metaphor for, his celebration of the divine enthronement. The poem describes a trajectory from the transcendent realm, apparently immune to the violence of the waters, to the immanence of God in the Temple and in his ‘edot, his “testimonies,” which may refer either to phenomena or to the text which testifies to God’s presence, injunctions, and deeds. I will proceed through a close literary analysis, paying attention to metaphors, alliterations, anaphoras. My object will not be just to show how the poetic world is created through these devices, but how they can suggest a supralinguistic realm and experience. For example, the aquatic noise of vv.3-4 gives way to the tranquillity of v.5. Similarly, the concatenated parallelisms and alliterations of v.1, with its assertion of divine power, are subsumed in the silence suggested by the extreme brevity of v.2.
|
Reading John from the Margins: Finding Jesus in the Judean Voice of John's Gospel
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Peter Lanfer, University of California-Los Angeles
The Dead Sea Scrolls present a complex picture of the diversity of Judean Judaism in the first century CE. While there is little evidence of any direct influence or dependence between the Fourth Gospel and the scrolls, both preserve the writings of communities standing at odds with Jerusalem-centric Judaism. This paper will examine the Gospel of John within the context of peripheral sectarian movements emerging in Judea in the first century CE with particular attention to eschatological expectations for the coming messianic age and the role of Jerusalem in shaping these emergent communities.
|
The Text of Jeremiah in the Damascus Document
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Armin Lange, University of Vienna
Attested in several manuscripts in the Kairo Genizah and the Qumran caves, the Damascus Document (D) is one of the best preserved sectarian texts from Qumran. Its extensive employment of Jewish scriptures allows for unique insights into which text(s) of the biblical books the Qumran community employed. This presentation will ask in how far D employed one or more texts of the books of Isaiah and Jeremiah and in how far it altered its quotations and allusions of these books textually.
|
Introduction to the THB Project
Program Unit:
Armin Lange, Universität Wien
The Textual History of the Bible (THB) is a new multi-volume reference work to be published in the years 2015 and 2016 by Brill publishers (editor in chief Armin Lange; volume editors Russell E. Fuller, Matthias Henze, and Emanuel Tov). The THB is going to be a unique resource which will cover in volumes 1 and 2 the Hebrew Bible and its deuterocanonical writings. For each biblical and deuterocanonical book all its ancient texts and versions will be discussed in individual entries. Volume 3 will be dedicated to the history of the text critical scholarship as well as all remaining issues of textual criticism from paleography and codicology to linguistics and hermeneutics. Volume 4 will contain in addition to indices and appendices a list of all important manuscript and information about them. The panel will present preliminary results and overviews into the research on the Textual History of the Hebrew Bible and its deuterocanonical writings and in all their texts and versions.
|
Polycarp and Polemo: Christianity at the Center of the Second Sophistic
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Andrew Langford, University of Chicago
The early Christian figure most intimately associated with Smyrna is Polycarp, the ?p?s??p?? of the local church (MPol 16.2). Polycarp participated in the burgeoning epistolary culture of the early Christian movement, evidence of which are the letter he received from Ignatius and the one he sent to the Philippians. He also famously died in Smyrna, an event immortalized in the Martyrdom of Polycarp (MPol). Remarkably, the sophistic and early Christian elements of late ancient Smyrnean society have rarely been brought into conversation. With the exception of a handful of scattered comments in the secondary literature, MPol, which is the focus of the present study, has not been examined in light of the Second Sophistic. This essay seeks to demonstrate the rich interpretive payoff of such an examination, and proceeds in particular through a comparison with Polycarp’s most illustrious Smyrnean contemporary, the famed sophist Polemo, who lived from c. 88-144 CE. We will argue that at a number of points the narrative depiction of Polycarp’s martyrdom is informed by the language and narrative patterns of biblical texts while simultaneously engaging in an idealized negotiation with the conventions, values, and expectations characteristic of the Second Sophistic. Exploring the presence of this studied negotiation of Christian fidelity vis-à-vis the various aspects of elite Smyrnean sophistic culture yields insights into the depiction of Polycarp hitherto unappreciated by scholarship on MPol.
|
The Jerusalem Temple as a Sacralized Landscape of Violence
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Tim Langille, University of Pittsburgh
This paper explores the relationship between trauma, violence, memory, and place (both homeland and diaspora) in Josephus’ Jewish War. More specifically, I look at Josephus’ representation of the destruction of the second temple in Jerusalem as a sacralized landscape of violence that is absent physically but present textually. I consider the ways in which sacralization involves a violent past, its persistence in the present, and its connection to sacred place and space. Violent and traumatic pasts can be affectively and symbolically linked with sacred sites and, in the case of Jewish War, the violence itself makes the site sacred (Stier and Landres 2006). Within this framework, I regard Jewish War as a history of mourning that precipitates cultural bereavement and ritualized mourning (Connerton 2011). By remembering the temple through a history of mourning, Josephus makes the temple a sacralized landscape of violence that is ‘undestroyable’ as it lives on and perseveres in Jewish memory and ritual.
Through this analysis, I engage the following theoretical issues: (1) the affectivity of the memory of a sacralized landscape of violence; (2) historical time vs. liturgical time (when does history become liturgy?); (3) the reconstruction of sacralized space in the homeland through human mobility and a text produced in diaspora; (4) notions of third-space in a text written for Palestinian Jews, Diaspora Jews, and Romans. In sum, this paper focuses on the sacralization of a destroyed Jerusalem as a memorial space and the reading and performance of Jewish War as a ritual pilgrimage into the past guided by the text for displaced people in diaspora/exile.
|
Reading Biblical Commentaries in Context: The Role of Community and Culture
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Scott M. Langston, Texas Christian University
Based on the idea that the production of commentaries is a community activity, as well as an individual one, this paper will examine the role of community and culture in shaping and influencing biblical commentaries. Commentaries are written for and on behalf of particular communities that have specific needs, agendas, and concerns. This paper, therefore, will explore how specific communities and their needs, agendas, and concerns influence the writing of commentaries, including the types of materials that are included and excluded, how they are analyzed, what portions of the biblical text are stressed, and how those texts are related to contemporary issues (social, political, theological, and so on). Commentaries can also function as mouthpieces for particular communities to engage and debate other communities. The commentary, therefore, can become more an expression of the community and its culture and less an explication of the biblical text. In other words, the commentary reflects the community just as much and even more than the biblical text. The influence of communities in shaping commentaries will be demonstrated by comparing (as time will permit) particular commentaries on Joshua from different time periods. For example, the appearance of archaeological and historical data in commentaries on Joshua, the manner in which this data has influenced these works, and how the needs and concerns of different communities have shaped this data will be addressed. Communities that may be considered include various academic (such as historical critics, archaeologists, literary critics, feminists, liberation scholars, etc.), religious (such as Jewish, Christian, denominational groups, ministers, laity, etc.), and economic (publishers, consumers, etc.) circles, as well as certain groups that have been excluded or have not participated in the production of commentaries (such as artists, Native American Christians, etc.).
|
Locating the Female Body in the Childbirth Metaphor
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible and Cognate Literature
Karen Langton, Brite Divinity School (TCU)
A childbirth metaphor requires an image/concept of childbirth. Additionally, an image/concept of childbirth requires a female body. The female body present in the text, either directly stated or implied in the background, is required for the metaphor to “work”. The vocabulary, the actions, and the emotions evoked by the metaphor are grounded in the imagined physical presence of a female body in childbirth. Therefore, any theoretical analysis of the childbirth metaphor must account for the physical presence of the female body in the text. Unfortunately, some scholars simplify interpretations of the childbirth metaphor into one word such as “crisis”, “horror”, or “creation” to name a few. Some interpretations completely ignore that there is a reference to childbirth, and therefore, ignore the female body present in the text.
Interpretations that try to find thematic unity across metaphors that are deemed identical eliminates ambiguity suggesting that all childbirth metaphors are homogenous. The result is that the female body is lost. In fact, childbirth metaphors are diverse in language, image, and context. Using an approach that includes conceptual metaphor theory and conceptual blending theory, I will show how my approach to metaphor theory locates and brings into the conversation the physical presence of the female body in the text. In particular, I will focus on the childbirth metaphors in Isaiah 40-55. I will show how a childbirth metaphor, and therefore the female body, cannot be simplified to one word or one image, but is a theme with many threads that extends across the text. Without recognizing and naming the real physical presence of the female body in the text, the meaning of the text itself is lost.
|
Against the Gods: Rereading Luke 1:78–79 and 2:32–35 as Implicit Polemic against Sun Worship
Program Unit: Gospel of Luke
Gregory R. Lanier, Cambridge University
The imagery of visitation, heavenly anatole, epiphany, and light in Zechariah’s Benedictus and Simeon’s speeches in Luke 1–2 have long stimulated scholarly debate. The common conclusion is that these texts are drawn from the Hebrew Bible and refer to a human Davidic messiah figure, nothing more. This paper proposes a different approach to reading these texts that positions them against both an OT-Jewish and a Greco-Roman background: namely, that of sun worship. First, the historical development and religious distinctives of sun worship will be traced from the ANE to the Greco-Roman era. Second, this paper will suggest a reading of Luke 1:78–79 and 2:30–35 that sees them as simultaneously borrowing concepts from the worship of Helios-Apollo while turning them against themselves, through applying such solar imagery to Jesus. Approaching these texts as an implicit polemic against Hellenistic sun worship brings coherence to otherwise puzzling features. It also echoes a similar polemical pattern seen in the Hebrew Bible, wherein sun worship is categorically prohibited while solar imagery is directly applied to Yahweh; in other words, Luke’s use of the OT in these texts goes well beyond simple Davidic allusions. This paper aims in part to contribute to the ongoing imperial cult discussions in Lukan scholarship by noting the connections between sun worship and caesar worship.
|
“Speak, Hannah, and Do Not Be Silent”: Speech and Action in Pseudo-Philo’s Presentation of Hannah’s Prayer
Program Unit: Speech and Talk in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Benjamin J. Lappenga, Dordt College
Interpreters have long noted the expanded role of female characters in Liber Antiquitatum Biblicarum. It is hardly surprising, then, that in Pseudo-Philo’s narrative the speeches of women are often expanded from the Biblical Vorlage. Yet the intriguing movement from Hannah’s misinterpreted silent prayer in 50.5 (“Hannah did not want to pray out loud”) to her bold declaration in 51.5 (“I will speak my words openly”) invites closer scrutiny. In this paper, I examine three rhetorical features in the wider narrative of L.A.B. that illumine the interpretation of the Hannah story. First, the public prayers of key individuals are regularly designated as the reason for God’s merciful action on behalf of the people (e.g., Moses [12.10], Phinehas [47.3]). Second, the prayers of these individuals are accompanied by a public demonstration of zeal (smashing the tablets, slaying Jambres, etc.). Third, just prior to the Hannah episode, Pseudo-Philo exploits the language of “zeal” (zelo/zelus) to show that only rightly-directed zeal (not wrongly-directed “jealousy”) renders prayer efficacious (47.1-3). I argue that when the Hannah episode is read in light of these strategies, Peninnah’s “zealous” taunting (zelans improperet [50.5]) is a foil indicating that Hannah’s commendable act of zeal is her very act of praying silently (at the risk of public ridicule). Her private gesture contrasts with the public demonstrations of figures like Moses and Phinehas, but remarkably Hannah’s prayer is accepted as the accompanying act for the people’s prayer (populus oravit pro hoc [51.2]). I conclude that this vicarious action helps explain Hannah’s expanded role as paradigmatic of all Israel and clarifies why the prophecy concerning Samuel’s birth is initially hidden from her (50.8).
|
Epistemological Reciprocity in the Gospel of John
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Kasper B. Larsen, Aarhus Universitet
Mutual immanence, between Jesus and the disciples on the one hand, between the Father and the Son on the other, is a recurrent and well-studied motif in the Johannine farewell discourses (e.g., Dodd, Segovia, and Scholtissek). Reciprocal structures, however, permeate the Gospel in several dimension, not only in its language of eternal life and ethics. In terms of reciprocal epistemology, the Shepherd Discourse offers a principle—“I know my own and my own know me (10:14)—that the Gospel elaborates upon and illustrates on several occasions (e.g., 1:42, 47; 3:3; 4:18, 29; 10:15, 27; 20:16, 27). This presentation contains a survey of the motif in the Gospel of John, a discussion of its exegetical implications, and a comparison with other reciprocal epistemologies in Greco-Roman narrative and philosophy (‘like is known by like’), Jewish covenantal thinking, and early Christian texts.
|
The Rest of Mark: The Marking as Unfinished and the Finishing of Mark
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Matthew D. Larsen, Yale University
Genetic criticism has opened up new questions about the complexity, fixity, and openness of texts. Sean Gurd’s recent book, Work in Progress, has shown the relevance of these questions to the texts of classical antiquity, showing the relative openness of texts as well as literary collaboration. In effect, he opens up new questions about what it means to write a text and to use another’s text in antiquity. In this paper, I apply these ideas to the study of the Synoptic Gospels and ask the question, “What is the Gospel of Mark?,” by interrogating the subject in literary compositional terms. I situate the Gospel of Mark, particularly its reception among its earliest readers, in the milieu of textual genetics of the ancient Greco-Roman literature, investigating Mark’s creation and the composition of its textuality. This paper will first offer examples of ancient Greek and Roman authors discussing texts in more finished versus less finished terms, noting a cultural assumption among ancient writers that some works, even published works, were less finished and less authored than others. Secondly, it will show that some early Christian writers perceived Mark’s Gospel as less finished than the other Gospels: Papias, Luke, and Irenaeus. Thirdly, it will suggest that the Gospel of Matthew may be read as an effort to finish and re-author Mark. Similarly, the longer conclusion to Mark’s Gospel (16:9–20) may also be construed as a finishing of Mark, rather than as a forgery, as James A. Kelhoffer has argued. In this way, I hope to offer a more textured view of the creation and reception of Mark’s Gospel, to rethink it’s relationship to Matthew’s Gospel, to challenge the dominant view among New Testament scholars that early Christian texts were “completed, closed texts,” and to consider the Synoptic relationships from a different perspective.
|
The Periergazomenoi of Paul’s Thessalonian Christ-Group (2 Thess 3:6-15)
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Richard Last, Queen's University
In 2 Thess 3:6-15 Paul turns his attention to members of the Thessalonian Christ-group whom he calls periergazomenoi. He describes their behavior as eating meals for free at the expense of socially-superior affiliates who foot the bills. In commentaries and social histories, the participle, periergazomenoi (2 Thess 3:11), is unanimously regarded as ‘being busybodies’, and is explored in the context of ancient philosophical discourses attesting to he polypragmon and polypragmosyne. Curiously, these analogies often neither use Paul’s language nor take place in social settings similar to 2 Thess 3:6-15 where food and money are central. Since periergazesthai could mean a variety of things, each dependent on the setting, including ‘haggling,’ ‘investigating,’ and ‘belaboring,’ this paper asks what it meant at meals and when property or money was involved, as in 2 Thess 3:6-15? It analyzes data from the 4,000 occurrences of periergazesthai (and cognates) in literary, papyrological, and epigraphic sources from IV BCE – IV CE. In light of this new evidence, the ‘busybody’ rendering is ruled unlikely. The most fitting meaning in 2 Thess 3:11 is ‘hagglers.’ This generates new questions about money, economic status, and banqueting practices in this early church.
|
Gods and Game-Givers in the Pompa Circensis: Ritual and Remembrance
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Jacob A. Latham, University of Tennessee, Knoxville
The pompa circensis, a Roman procession which conducted the gods from the temple of Jupiter Best and Greatest through the Forum and Velabrum to the Circus Maximus was something of a bi-polar ritual with centers focused on the praeses ludorum, the president of the games, and the gods. On the one hand, the immensely popular chariot races in the Circus Maximus attracted enormous crowds, offering an unparalleled opportunity for public munificence and political patronage. On the other hand, the procession “functioned” as a means to transport the gods, made present in various ways, to the Circus Maximus where they would enjoy the games alongside their fellow Romans.
This synchronic bifurcation in ritual performance matched a similar diachronic one in representation/remembrance. The earliest commemoration of the circus procession from the late republic represented both the gods and the officials in charge. During the empire strategies of representation and remembrance shifted in “official,” that is imperial, imagery, which depicted only the (mostly imperial) gods. After the so-called third century crisis, which apart from the regions directly affected by warfare was really was a crisis of the imperial court and its culture, representations of the circus procession focused on the game-giver, whether emperor or aristocrat.
This shift in remembrance corresponds to later a shift in the performance of the pompa circensis and a later transformation of religious culture as the stuttering process of Christianization of the Roman empire starting in the fourth century surprisingly slowly began to weed out the traditional gods, eventually leaving only images of the emperor and the religiously innocuous Victory.
|
Teaching at the Intersection of Biblical Studies and Academic Writing
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Benjamin Laugelli, University of Virginia
For the last two years I have taught a first-year writing seminar in the Department of English at the University of Virginia. The seminar is comparable to those offered in many Liberal Arts Colleges. The course teaches principles of academic argument by means of several short papers related to the course theme, "Monsters in the Bible and Film." In the course students write essays about biblical texts that feature monsters and about films that allude to these biblical texts and their themes. Teaching the course presents me with a double challenge. I have to teach principles of academic argumentation to students who have been trained primarily to compose essays for standardized tests. And I have to teach students with little to no formal training in biblical studies how to read and write about the Bible in an academic context.
To accomplish these goals I have developed a way to use one of the course writing principles to help students approach the book of Job and its monsters. This allows me to illustrate the writing principle in the course of modeling a critical reading of the book of Job. The writing principle I teach in conjunction with Job is called a problem frame. The problem frame offers students a tool to use in structuring the introduction of an essay. It allows students to position or frame the essay's main claim as the resolution to a problem that readers care about. The principle is usually the most difficult for students to understand and incorporate into their writing. To teach the problem frame I argue in class that it is possible to consider the book of Job as addressing two related problems: how to understand both the nature of genuine piety and the character of a god who permits innocent suffering. The paper illustrates how mapping the problem frame onto the book of Job allows me to accomplish two learning objectives. First, I am able to model for students an important writing principle that helps them craft claims their readers will find significant and relevant. At the same time, using the problem frame in relation to Job gives me a tool to train students to recognize the ways in which biblical books advance their own tendentious claims and arguments.
|
Classical and Biblical Canons and the Scholarship of Ptolemaic Alexandria
Program Unit: Book History and Biblical Literatures
Timothy Michael Law, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
In the first century CE, Quintillian reflects at least one attitude towards canon formation, basing his selection of works more on prioritization than exclusion and admitting that those left out are still worth consideration. In this paper, I discuss the famous Library of Alexandria and ask how its scholars contributed to the process of canonization of classical literature from the third century BCE. Although Aeschylus, Sophocles, and Euripides were already famous in Athens, what role did the textual scholars and the prestige of the Library play to secure their place alongside Homer and Aristophanes as classics of Greek literature? Conversely, why did these emerge instead of others like Choerilus, Phrynichus, Pratinas, and Agathon? I will then explore how the canonization of classical texts relates to the canonization of biblical literature in the following centuries. Importantly, I query whether the binary inclusion/exclusion is already determinative for evaluating religious literature in Hellenistic antiquity. I will finally consider the origins of the Septuagint for two reasons: The translation is a product of this era of textual scholarship in Ptolemaic Alexandria, and the assumption that religious motivations explain its origins still permeates discussions of the Bible’s canonical and textual histories. I question whether the translation might be nothing more than a product of the literary culture of Alexandria, rather than a project related to early Diasporic ambitions to affirm the “authority” of the Torah.
|
Wordplay in Malachi
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Sheree Lear, University of St Andrews/University of Pretoria
Karl William Weyde (amongst others) has identified two puns in the book of Malachi: pene-’el in Mal 1.9 and‘er woneh in Mal 2.12. Both of these puns play on proper nouns found in other texts of the Hebrew Bible: pene-’el on the the place-name Peniel in Gen 32.31 and ‘er woneh on the name of the sons of Judah, Er and Onan, whose narrative appears in Gen 38. Both of these puns on proper names he argued to be allusive, drawing to mind the narratives in which these proper nouns are found. These narratives in turn enhance the meaning of Malachi. In this paper, I will discuss these two examples of wordplay and describe three more examples that can be found in the book of Malachi:’ayeh kebodî in Mal 1.6 on ’î kabod in 1 Sam 4.21, marpe’ biknapeha in Mal 3.20 on terapeynâ kanpêhen in Ezek 1.24, and bat ’el nekar in Mal 2.11 on bat batûel ben na?or in Gen 24.47. Four out of the five examples are plays on a proper noun and all five allude to other texts or stories in the HB. Arguing that wordplay is a preferred compositional technique of a scribe who wrote Malachi, I will demonstrate how the diachronic aspect of each case of wordplay (allusion) enhances a synchronic understanding of the text. I will show how wordplay can be indicative of the scribe's hermeneutic (how he read older texts) and of the scribe's communicative goal.
|
The Assembly, the People, the Uterus, and the Land: A Feminist and Postcolonial Deconstruction of the ‘Israelite’ Subject in Conceiving the Sacred Spaces of Deut 22:13–24:4
Program Unit: Postcolonial Studies and Biblical Studies
Bernon Lee, Bethel University (Minnesota)
Bridging the emancipatory interests of feminist and postcolonial criticism, this paper defines and interrogates subjectivity (Israelite and male) in a select series of rulings from Deuteronomy 22:13-24:4 on marital and sexual misbehavior (22:13-29 and 24:1-4) and the constitution of Israel’s Assembly (23:2-9). Uncovering a rhetoric forging correspondence across exclusive spaces (the Assembly, ‘Israel,’ the uterus and the land), the paper proceeds by underscoring weaknesses, specifically, in the rationale(s) for the exclusion (and inclusion) of specified ethnic groups from the Assembly (Deut 23:2-9). The consequent disintegration of ‘Israel’ as subject along with the authority of the Mosaic voice in prescription spreads to infect readerly perceptions of the prescriptive subject’s moral authority—already vulnerable given its preponderantly masculine interests —in proximate, surrounding, legislation on sexual and marital propriety (Deut 22:13-28 and 24:1-4). The deconstructive, critical gaze, thus, disarms the analogical matrix that undergirds the rhetoric of exclusion in securing the sacred spaces of the laws, rendering the analogies arbitrary and the boundaries porous. In such manner, in feminist and postcolonial hands, the rhetoric by analogy across Deut 22:13-24:4 is reversed, undoing the paradigm of ethnic and sexual supremacy in its conception of sacred spaces.
|
An Asian Feminist Reading of Philippians with the Method of "Continental Self-Reference"
Program Unit: Asian and Asian-American Hermeneutics
Lee, Jae-Hee, Brite Divinity School (TCU)
This paper presents an example of an Asian Feminist biblical reading of Philippians espousing the method of "continental self-reference" claimed by Sugitharajah. For Sugirtharajah, the ultimate goal of postcolonial biblical criticism is "establishing a competing theoretical ground of multi -religious discourse," not to oppose but to decenter the Bible, Christianity, and Western-oriented theoretical ground. "Continental self-reference" refers to an intentional practice of shifting the point of reference towards the historical experiences of Asia, Africa, Latin America, Oceania, and so on to construct a postcolonial discourse. Sugitharajah believes that reading a biblical text with or through Asians' historical experiences, cultural frames, sacred texts, and the like could disentangle the hidden power relations and ideologies of the biblical text.
Paul’s interesting exhortation to Euodia and Syntyche in Philippians generated different imaginations among feminist biblical scholars. Most of them, however, focused on either the identification of the women or the relationship between the women and Paul. In fact, these approaches dismiss a significant body of Philippian church, that is, the Philippian women believers. Although the sociopolitical and cultural context of the early Korean Christian women is not identical to Philippian church, their historical experiences offer an insight to understand the power dynamics and exhortation in Philippians differently. The early Korean Christian women were initially evangelized by Western women missionaries whose number was increased in Korea as the number of Korean women believers increased and The Korean women soon actively participated in missionary works along with the Western women missionaries. But they also experienced conflicts with Western women missionaries because of a different view and standpoint in regards how to respond as Christian women to Japanese imperial domination. Returning to the Philippian church, it is likely that the presence of two women missionaries in Philippi was a consequence of the presence of the significant numbers of women believers in Philippian church. Paul’s exhortation to the women missionaries may reflect the conflicting atmosphere among the Philippian women believers who had diverse even conflict views from the women missionaries and /or Paul in regards how to responds to the suffering that was caused by the Roman imperial power as Christian women.
|
Ecological Collapse and Nebuchadnezzar's Loss of Humanity
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
James Lee, International Theological Seminary
The description of Nebuchadnezzar in Daniel Chapter 4 as a ruler over human beings and wild animals is an allusion to Jeremiah 27 and 28, and is also reminiscent of Adam and Noah who were given authority over all creation. However, Nebuchadnezzar’s transformation exemplifies the loss of his privileged status due to his hubris. His sovereignty over the subjects in his kingdom is not absolute but contingent on his recognition of an authority greater than he. Nebuchadnezzar’s metamorphosis is played out in two ways. First, all the animals and birds flee from his rule. Second, he himself turns into a beastly figure. His ordeal demonstrates that the boundary between humans and animals is not so fixed but fluid. As Nebuchadnezzar’s loss of humanity is preceded by the ecological collapse in his kingdom, the text gives a new insight into the relationship between humans and nature. While the text seems to advocate a hierarchical relationship between humans and other creation, it shows that human identity is very fragile. Without the presence of nature, bestiality can easily take over humanity in a person.
|
A Crasis Rule in the Septuagint and the Zenon Archive
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
John Lee, Macquarie University
This paper investigates crasis of kai with the first person singular pronoun (ego, etc.). The investigation finds that the presence or absence of crasis is not haphazard but exhibits a pattern determined by the semantic value of the combination. The study starts from the LXX Pentateuch and other LXX books, then is widened to texts of the Zenon Archive and other papyri, where the pattern is found to be confirmed. It appears that a ‘rule’ was in operation in Greek of the Ptolemaic period. Further investigation needs to be done to establish whether the ‘rule’ operated earlier and later in ancient Greek or changed between eras.
|
The Portrayal of Ritual in Genesis 48
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Kerry Lee, Independent Researcher
The events of Genesis 48, especially verses 8-12, are sometimes understood as a legal ritual of either adoption or legitimation. This identification has sometimes been made based on a form-critical comparison with the events in Genesis 27, at other times on linguistic parallels with supposed adoption or legitimation rituals hinted at in Genesis 30:3 and 50:23 (the link being “knee” imagery). Neither of these comparisons has proven compelling in the long term, even though, arguably, the plainest sense of Genesis 48 seems to involve some change in the status of Ephraim and Manasseh vis-a-vis Jacob. Part of the problem, I argue, is that the ritual is most evident when the chapter is read as a unified whole, but a holistic reading of Genesis 48 has been resisted on diachronic grounds, which have an admittedly strong grounding in commonly observed unevennesses in the text. This paper proposes a set of synchronic solutions to the text’s uneven features, using pragmatics, ritual theory, and structural comparisons with other texts. These synchronic solutions do not necessarily rule out the likelihood that the text is a composite of some sort (though they do obviate many of the traditional diachronic proposals), but they do show that the final authorial hand consciously put his received materials together in a coherent and intentional way that, when read together, strongly suggests an adoption ritual. I do not suggest that the ritual portrayal of events and statements in Genesis 48 reveals some kind of actually practiced adoption ritual in ancient Israel (which goes beyond what can be known from this text alone). Rather, I simply suggest that these events and statements are identifiable by the implied reader as ritual-like and concerned with Jacob’s adoption and blessing-as-heirs of Joseph’s sons.
|
A Signature Feature of a Women's Indigenous Lyrical Tradition: Matriarchal Freedom Influencing Biblical Texts and Culture
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Nancy Lee, Elmhurst College
This paper will respond to Carol Meyers’ assessment that there was a women’s ‘gender-specific’ tradition related to music performance in biblical culture reflected in some biblical texts and in archaeological evidence, as well as to her larger challenge of the use of the term ‘patriarchy’ to describe ancient Israel. Specifically, this paper, using an oral poetic, indigenous/feminist post-colonial approach, presents wide-ranging evidence in the Hebrew of several lyrical texts to propose there was a signature feature of a women’s lyrical tradition, either forgotten, suppressed, or neglected. The presentation will compare several lyrical texts associated with women to demonstrate there is a distinctive, pervasive, and consistent syllable sound repetition pattern in the Hebrew employed across biblical texts and genres (for example, in the Song of Hannah—I Sam 2:1-9; in the Song of Songs, and in the Song of the Sea, in antiphony). This sound pattern is distinguished from a consistent, identifiable syllable sound pattern associated with male lyrical tradition, also across genres, yet both found in apparent ‘call and response’ dynamic in lyrical texts. This proposed women’s lyrical signature, found also embedded in prophetic books, such as Isaiah and Micah, may be a key to assessing women’s compositional contributions and influence in and on biblical texts where women were mostly unattributed, and of course where it is not possible nor necessary to determine the identity of composers. In sum, this paper will agree with the critique of the use of ‘patriarchy’ across the board to describe ancient Israel, as a contemporary stereotype, and instead finds that women in the ancient indigenous culture had a more significant role as singers and lyrical prophets, as evidenced in the Hebrew, than the final written canon might lead one to believe.
|
A Signature Feature of Women's Lyrical Tradition in the Bible
Program Unit: Performance Criticism of the Bible and Other Ancient Texts
Nancy C. Lee, Elmhurst College
In previous work using an oral poetic methodology, I have argued that there is a distinctive, pervasive, and consistent sound pattern in the Hebrew across biblical texts and genres associated with women’s performance: in a text explicitly attributed to a woman (in the Song of Hannah), in texts assumed to represent a woman’s or women’s voices (in the Song of Songs), and further, the sound pattern is embedded in a number of prophetic books where I propose that women prophets’ voices are unattributed. This indigenous signature of women lyricists, I have proposed, is distinctive from the men’s typical sound pattern more often identifiable with parallelism. In this paper I will show the proposed women’s signature sound pattern as it appears in the Song of Hannah, Song of Songs 1, and compare the feature as it appears in the Song of Deborah and Barak in Judges 5, where the Hebrew additionally conveys a female and male voice in dialog or antiphony. (An additional example will be shown from the Psalms.) This analysis is not interested in the historic identity of singers, or questions of dating, but based on evidence in the Hebrew, proposes that portions of the song composition in Judges 5 indeed come from a women’s lyrical tradition, and portions are from a male lyrical tradition, rooted in the oral traditional culture.
|
Symbols of 'Syriac' Origin in St. Yared's Deggwa
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Ralph Lee, Holy Trinity Theological College, Addis Ababa
The Deggwa is an Ethiopic hymnbook with origins in the sixth century CE, and attributed to St Yared who developed the Ethiopian liturgical-musical tradition. This paper analyses the symbolism as it is applied in the Deggwa, comparing it with themes found in the early Syriac writing of Ephrem and Jacob of Serugh. The similarities in the symbolic approach to the interpretation of Scripture raise important questions about the nature of the relationship between Early Syriac and Ethiopic Christianity.
|
Linguistic Identity of the Jerusalem Church: A Sociolinguistic Approach
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
Sang-Il Lee, Chongshin University
Many scholars have assumed that Aramaic-speaking Jewish Christianity has developed into Greek-speaking Jewish Christianity, and Greek-speaking Jewish Christianity into Greek-speaking Gentile Christianity. This is based on the four long-standing presuppositions about the linguistic situation of the first-century Roman Near East: (i) Jews spoke Aramaic, whereas the Gentiles in the New Testament literature spoke Greek; (ii) Palestinian Jews spoke Aramaic, whereas Diaspora Jews spoke Greek; (iii) Palestinian Jewish Christians spoke Aramaic, whereas Gentile Christians spoke Greek; and (iv) Palestinian Christian communities in Jerusalem used Aramaic, whereas the Gentile Christian community used Greek.
From the perspective of the sociolinguistic data from Jewish networks in the first century BC, however, recent archaeological evidence shows that the linguistic milieu of first-century Palestine and the Roman Near East was bilingualism in vernacular languages and Greek.
The sociolinguistic approach to the linguistic milieu sheds fresh insights into the linguistic identity of the Jerusalem church. The linguistic situation of the Jerusalem church was bilingual in Aramaic and Greek. The ‘Hebrews’ were Aramaic speakers including bilingual speakers who could speak Aramaic as their matrix language and Greek as their embedded language. The ‘Hellenists’ were Greek speakers including bilingual speakers who could speak Greek as their matrix languages and vernacular languages (usually, Aramaic) as their embedded language. This means that the Jerusalem church was not Aramaic-speaking Christian community but bilingual Christian community. This paper will focus on the linguistic identity of the Jerusalem church from the perspective of sociolinguistic studies.
|
Bilingualism of Jews in Early Roman Antioch
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Sang-Il Lee, Chongshin University
Most scholars have assumed that Jews in Early Roman Antioch were considered to be Greek-speakers. Aramaic among Antiochene Jews gave way to Greek and Greek was used by Antioch Jews. Recent archaeological excavations, however, show that the linguistic milieu of Early Roman Syria was bilingual in Syriac and Greek. And the Jewish community of Early Roman Antioch was also bilingual/trilingual in Aramaic, Syriac, and/or Greek depending on their social levels. From the perspective of sociolinguistic method, linguistic milieu of Early Roman Antioch, successive immigration and periodic connection with Jerusalem imply that most Antiochene Jews were bilingual/trilingual in Aramaic, Syriac, and/or Greek. This paper applies sociolinguistic method to analyzing the linguistic milieu of Antiochene Jews in Early Roman Syria, as I suggested in my publication(Jesus and Gospel Traditions in Bilingual Context [BZNW 186; Berlin: de Gruyter, 2012]). The study of bilingualism sheds new insights into the Jewish community in Antioch.
|
Slavery, Gender, and Social Death
Program Unit: Slavery, Resistance, and Freedom
Carolyn S. Leeb, Valparaiso University
The intersection of gender, status, and role is nowhere more evident than in those Hebrew Bible texts which reflect the experiences of captive populations from Judah. Their captivity feminizes them, whether by actual castration or by virtual emasculation, by denying them the autonomy which is the signal characteristic of the ancient world’s construction of masculinity. Judah as a collectivity, as well as individuals among the conquered community, are gendered “female” by becoming dependents. Although they often filled important and influential roles in the royal administration/household, they are never fully members of it and can never aspire to head households of their own. Orlando Patterson (Slavery and Social Death) defines slavery not by an economic model focused on whether an individual can be purchased, but by focusing on power. The absolute power of the master means that those he controls have forfeited their essential identities and are socially dead. The intersection with gender is heightened by the recognition that marriage in the ancient world, in which women are “given” and “taken” to build up their husbands’ households, is itself a form of social death. In the mirror-image books of Daniel and Esther, captive men and women are separated, not only by the empire to serve its interests, but even by the biblical writers to serve theirs. Although captive populations may fill important roles within the dominant polity, and despite the muting of explicit language of slavery, the evidence of social death is inescapable.
|
Form Follows Function: A Calligraphic Approach to Oral Performance in Northwest Semitic Epigraphs
Program Unit: Performance Criticism of the Bible and Other Ancient Texts
Reinhard G. Lehmann, Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz
In the West Semitic epigraphic remains of the first millennium BCE, there were three ‘systems’ in use to cope with what we call word (or lexeme) bounds: the use of graphic separation marks between words (dividing dots), lexemic delimitation by simple space, or to totally ignore word bounds (scriptio continua). But there are also Northwest Semitic Epigraphs that run in a mixed mode, i.e. either omit expected delimitation marks or interrupt a seeming continuous line (scriptio continua) by unexpected spaces.
Such mixed mode is mostly considered mere sloppiness of a scribe. Instead of blaming the scribes for something we do not yet fully understand, however, it will be shown that such phenomena are a layer of low-level supra-segmental graphic delimitation. This does not primarily care for lexemic word bounds, but is the unintentional ‘background radiation’ of the oral performance that lies behind the text. Some simple rules will be discussed that give hints to meter, prosody and breath units, or, in general, to the oral process (orality) and audibility (aurality) of tales and songs as they might have been performed in ancient times.
|
"Blessed Be He": Benedictions, Prayers, and Liturgy in the New Rhetoric Garb of Late Midrashic Traditions
Program Unit: Midrash
Lennart Lehmhaus, Freie Universität Berlin
Earlier scholarship on liturgy, prayer and minhag was very much focused on studying only the immediate context of those subjects in the Jewish prayer books (siddurim). Some studies also mined rabbinic literature and Geonic responsa for relevant liturgical Halakha and for `reliable ´historical information. However, this strict separation or seclusion began to disintegrate and former academic boundaries became blurred in the last decades. This holds true not only in case of the recent interest in the interplay between Midrash and Piyyut. Moreover, also the later midrashic traditions seem to be an important source for the formation of prayers, liturgy and minhagim. In Pirke de-Rabbi Eliezer, as recent studies have shown, provides the text some etiological narratives to authorize certain rituals (The chair of Elijah during the brit mila/ the Havdala/ Rosh-Chodesh ceremonies etc.). Additionally, quotations or allusions to the benedictions of the Amidah are integrated into the text’s discourse as summarizing and concluding devices for a discussion or a chapter. Also in Tanchuma and other homiletical Midrashim one finds a variety of similar phenomena.
This paper addresses the interweaving of prayers, benedictions and other liturgical elements with the narrative framework of one specific tradition. Seder Eliyahu Zuta (SEZ), as well as its fellow-text called Seder Eliyahu Rabba (SER), is a fascinating rabbinic work that was most probably composed in the Gaonic period (9th-10th c.). The texts display a unique, though hybrid, character between a moral guidebook for righteous conduct and learned exposition (i.e. Midrash).
In Seder Eliyahu one finds the rhetoric usage of modified prayers and benedictions (Birkat ha-Tora/ Pesukei de-Zimra/ Qaddish-doxology etc.) as literary devices, deeply interwoven with its textual and discursive context. Several passages about blessings and prayers establish a strong connection between the liturgical sphere and the ethical agenda of the text. Moreover, the possible functions of such passages in an inclusive discourse of instruction shall be discussed. This might help to understand the role of midrashic traditions in the formative period of rabbinic culture and Jewish liturgy.
|
Who Has the Right to Be Called a Christian? The Politics of Inventing Christian Identity in Tertullian’s On the Prescription of Heretics
Program Unit: Inventing Christianity: Apostolic Fathers, Apologists, and Martyrs
Outi Lehtipuu, University of Helsinki
“What have heretics in common with Christians?” famously asks Tertullian in his On the Prescription of Heretics. A short answer would be: a lot. Despite vigorous claims to the contrary, diverging early Christian groups were not that distinctive. They all shared a common cultural vocabulary that made it hard for the outsiders to differentiate between them. Often, it was not easy for the insiders, either.
A group’s identity is based on its distinctiveness; on the idea that “we” are different from the rest. The more a group resembles another group from which it wants to distinguish itself, the bitterer the conflict and the harsher the polemic. This kind of dynamics can also be discerned in Tertullian’s On the Prescription of Heretics. In this paper, I will analyze how Tertullian sets boundaries and what his criteria of belonging are. Tertullian uses two main strategies. First, he claims that his rivals are outsiders; even though they call themselves Christians, they are counterfeit. Second, because they do not belong, they have no right to the apostolic tradition and to read Christian scriptures.
The struggle for the right to call oneself Christian was to a large extent a struggle over who has the right to represent the apostolic legacy and to appeal to Scripture. An essential part of my analysis is to show how Tertullian interprets passages from the epistles of Paul and the Gospels and how he claims his opponents (wrongfully) interpret the same passages. According to Tertullian, those who share the true faith should refrain from getting involved in debates with those who only interpret Scripture according to their delusions. What he fails to see, however, is that in this respect, his opponents do not differ from himself. Even though Tertullian claims to represent the only rightful legacy to the apostolic tradition, so do his opponents, too.
|
Relics? What Relics?
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Mary Joan Leith, Stonehill College
Relics played a substantive role in late antique Christian spirituality and identity politics no less than in claims to power; this is a topic that merits ongoing inquiry. Might the current scholarly spotlight on relics, however, also distort our perception of religious experience and praxis in the period in which the importance of relics was growing? Our research has led us to look more closely at the interaction of church and imperial dynamics in the city of Rome from the late fourth to the mid-fifth century in the light of the “relic question.” We suggest that the understanding of the role relics played in the city of Rome has been somewhat oversimplified and, in many cases, the later significance of relics has been overlaid on early fifth-century Roman churches. We propose some avenues of inquiry with regard to relics that may lead to a more nuanced appreciation of their role [or the lack thereof] in fifth-century Rome by focusing on a specific test case, the church of Santa Sabina.
|
‘Tangible Darkness’: On the Meaning of Exod 10:21–29 in the Literary Context of the Plague Narrative and the Cultural-Historical Background of the Ancient Near East
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Bénédicte Lemmelijn, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
The so-called Plague Narrative in Exod 7–11 offers a fascinating story, the literary and theological content of which still challenges its readers today. One of the puzzling issues in this story pertains to the meaning of the Plague of Darkness at the end of the narrative.
In this respect, the present contribution will propose a specific interpretation of the ninth plague, stating that this plague (originally set as the final one) actually functioned as the absolute climax of the whole series.
To that end, it will first present the Plague Narrative in its literary context (1). Thereafter, it will focus on Exod 10,21-29 as a crux interpretum from a literary, redactional and text-critical perspective (2). Subsequently, it will succinctly explore the meaning of light and darkness in the Old Testament and the Ancient Near East (3). And finally, against this background, it will interpret the plague of palpable darkness as a very serious crisis in basic existential trust (4).
|
Child Sacrifice and the Personhood of Children in Ancient Israel
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
T. M. Lemos, Huron University College
This paper will explore the question of whether or not children were considered persons in ancient Israel. My discussion of personhood will draw upon anthropological treatments of this concept and will consider whether or not children were accorded a status of social recognition and significance, whether or not they were considered to have agency in legal or social contexts, and whether or not killing them was seen as murder. The paper will focus upon the practice of child sacrifice, examining whether it would have been possible for Israelites to recognize infants as persons but to sacrifice them nonetheless or if in fact debates over child sacrifice in ancient Israel reflected differing stances on the question of whether children were persons. Since the evidence seems to indicate that it was only infants and toddlers rather than older children who were sacrificed, the paper will consider whether the personhood of children took on a graduated form in ancient Israel. Finally, the status of children will be compared to that of other subordinated classes, particularly women and slaves, in order to ascertain how the personhood of children related to that of other social groups.
|
The Voices of Pharaoh’s Wife, Daughter, and Mother in 19th Century Oratorio and Opera
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Helen Leneman, Independent Scholar
The biblical Pharaoh is depicted as a ruler standing defiantly alone against Moses and his God. Several 19th-century musical settings add surprising dimensions to the story by including women at Pharaoh’s side.
In his 1841 oratorio, Adolph Marx gives both Pharaoh and his queen lovely and appealing music to sing, which makes the listener feel sympathy for these characters. The most unique feature of this oratorio is the presence of Pharaoh’s mother, who dispenses advice to a youthful Pharaoh. She recalls the might of the Hebrew God— a fascinating touch and interesting gap-filling.
In Anton Rubinstein’s 1891 opera, both music and text add great poignancy to the moment when Pharaoh’s daughter (Asnath) finds the baby Moses, making her a woman of flesh and blood. Later in the story, Asnath argues with her father. In the biblical account, she has no role after finding the baby Moses. In this retelling, she reminds her father that he need only give in to Moses’ demands in order to restore peace to Egypt and win his people’s blessing. Asnath’s plea is sung to lyrical, poignant music, suggesting that she retains a lingering affection for the man she saved as an infant. The feelings of Pharaoh’s daughter towards the adult Moses have never been explored in later retellings. Here, the music intimates deep feelings on her part.
One of many interesting creative additions to Rossini’s 1818 opera Moses in Egypt is the relationship between Pharaoh’s queen (Amaltea) and Moses, whom she supports against Pharaoh.The queen plays a similar role to that of Asnath in Rubinstein’s opera, arguing Moses’ case before Pharaoh.
Musical excerpts will be included, illustrating how the female presence in these works alters the tone of the narrative.
|
The Golden Calf: Musical Frenzy in Two 20th Century Operas
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Helen Leneman, Independent Scholar
Composers of every era and nationality seemed to relish depicting an orgy before the calf, using unusual percussion, rowdy dance music and jazzy rhythms. The people’s fear, leading to a frenzy of idol worship, is brought to life vividly and even shockingly in these musical retellings. Operatic retellings of the scene leading up to the Golden Calf incident, and the incident itself, convincingly portray the mood of the Israelites after Moses’ long absence. Musical devices project the terror, insecurity, and doubts the people are experiencing. This is an amplification of a few biblical verses which hardly mention the people’s feelings. The expansion makes their desperate turn to an idol more understandable.
Kurt Weill employs rapid, highly rhythmic and pulsating jazz-like sounds, with insistent drum, to accompany the people dancing around the golden calf, in his 1937 opera The Eternal Road.
In Arnold Schoenberg’s 1957 opera Moses and Aaron, the Dance of the Golden Calf is generally considered the climax of the opera. To echoes of jazz and dance rhythms, the scene runs the gamut from drunkenness and dancing, through the fury of destruction and suicide, to the erotic orgy which concludes it. The music is probably the most accessible in the opera. Schoenberg seems to have imagined, in this scene, the furthest extremes of unchecked idolatry. It is a blatant representation of what can go wrong when the masses are misled by an overly simplistic message. Schoenberg (and Weill) chose to show explicitly what the Exodus text barely suggests, perhaps predicting what could happen to a society without God or morality.
Musical excerpts will be played.
|
Function and Effect of Melito’s Peri Pascha
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Marcie Lenk, Shalom Hartman Institute
What is the function and effect of the virulent anti-Judaism of Melito’s Peri Pascha?
Judith Lieu has noted that the violence of Melito’s Peri Pascha is violent language – we have no evidence of or call to violent actions here.
Lynn Cohick points out that many of the first scholars to examine Peri Pascha were minimally, if at all, interested in the homily’s anti-Judaism, and that the discovery of the ancient synagogue of Sardis in the early 1960s inspired scholars to take a fresh look at Peri Pascha. Alistair Stewart Sykes even posits that Melito was Jewish, leading to an interpretation of Melito’s anti-Judaism which is akin to interpretations of John’s anti-Judaism – that this was an argument among Jews about who actually carried the mantle of Judaism.
Recent scholars such as Lieu have argued that since the synagogue only goes back to the fourth century, interpretation of the second century homily cannot presume a Jewish community of such power and influence. Cohick even argues that the evidence connecting the Melito of our Peri Pascha to Melito of Sardis is shaky. Adding to the confusion, there is no direct reference to Jews in the homily. The invective is directed to Israel, which might be understood as biblical Israel, contemporary Jews or simply a foil for Christian belief.
Given the uncertainty (at best) of the evidence that Peri Pascha can be used to reconstruct a rivalry between Jews and Christians in second century Sardis, this paper will explore the reception history of Peri Pascha and compare the rhetoric in this text to other early Christian anti-Jewish texts, looking particularly at its function as a Paschal liturgy.
|
Reflections on Scribal Revision in Akkadian Texts
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Alan Lenzi, University of the Pacific
Imagine an ancient Babylonian scribe who composes a new text and another who carefully transcribes a previously existing text verbatim to another tablet. Somewhere between these two ideal scribal activities is “revision”—an activity in which a scribe transmits an already-composed-text to another tablet but also makes textual alterations so that the result of his actions is a recognizably different text. In this contribution to the session, I will argue that “revision” implies a fundamentally comparative project for the modern scholar between the text of interest and a known or presumed text that is chronologically prior. As with other comparative endeavors, this literary comparison is fraught with difficulties though it also offers interesting returns. In light of what we know about Mesopotamian scribalism, I think it is safe to assume that scribes did not always intend to copy texts faithfully. But how do we identify elements of textual revision? How do we keep ourselves from inventing data through the projection of our own literary expectations? How do we interpret revisions within a text once they are plausibly identified? And what do our interpretations contribute to the broader work of ancient cultural recovery and reconstruction? Drawing on examples of well-attested Akkadian shuila-prayers and the several textual witnesses to the ritual for replacing the head of the lamenter’s kettledrum, I will demonstrate what we can learn about revision when we are on the firmest of textual ground, that is, when we have two actual texts to compare and, as in the case of the ritual for the kettle drum, when we possess unambiguous dating of each textual witness. A final example from Ludlul bel nemeqi Tablet IV will illustrate the potential problems in the comparative endeavor, even when two similar texts exist.
|
Identifying Inner-Biblical Allusions: Problems and Promise in the Historical Psalms
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Jeffery M. Leonard, Samford University
The phenomenon of inner-biblical allusion holds unique promise for tracing the growth of the biblical literature and the development of Israel’s religious outlook. Using the lens of inner-biblical interpretation, scholars have made great strides in recent years in locating corpora such as Deutero-Isaiah, the Book of the Twelve, various psalms, and even narrative passages within the larger biblical narrative. For the promise of inner-biblical allusion to be fully realized, though, one must first overcome two fundamental problems of method, namely determining how textual allusions are to be confidently identified in the first place and then how they are to be evaluated in terms of their direction of dependence. What evidence is needed to establish a link between one biblical text and another text or tradition? And if a link between texts can be established, what evidence is needed to ascertain the direction of the textual or traditional influence? While these questions are not easily answered, their methodological importance is such that they cannot be easily sidestepped without jeopardizing the value of inner-biblical allusion as an area of research. In this study, I consider issues of method by examining the allusive techniques of three historical psalms: Psalms 78, 105, and 106. Using these psalms as a proving ground, I argue for a set of principles that can guide the search for textual allusions and help to establish the direction of their dependence.
|
Judah Bookends: The Priority of Israel and Literary Revision in the David Narrative
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Mahri Leonard-Fleckman, New York University
It is often assumed that David ruled Judah before he ruled Israel. In the past decade, literary historians have gone further, proposing that the oldest material in the David narrative in 1-2 Samuel is focused on Judah alone. This early David lore would have no connection to Saul, or to David’s rule over Israel. In this scheme, the material focused on Israel would only be added after the fall of the northern kingdom, at which point Judah would claim the identity of Israel. The difficulty with this reconstruction is that in the David narrative, Judah plays an active role only in 2 Sam 2:4a and 19:9b-20:13, in narrative bookends that are dependent on the surrounding material. In contrast, the vast majority of the David material is focused on David’s rule of Israel alone. Building from the evidence, in which core material about David is concerned with his rule of Israel from Jerusalem and his connection to Hebron, the logical conclusion is that these stories were written about “Israel” yet from a Judahite perspective. Therefore, the fascinating question is not whether Judah saw itself as bound up in the story of David as king of Israel during the existence of the northern kingdom, but why. The goal of this paper is to propose a new framework for the literary history in 2 Samuel. I propose two phases of development: the primary phase, beginning prior to the fall of the northern kingdom, is concerned with the story of David as king of Israel. The secondary, likely late monarchic phase incorporates Judah into the narrative and alters the narrative framework to David as king of Israel and Judah. I will argue that the biblical portrait suggests a reconsideration of the political landscape of the early monarchy, defined by David’s rule of Israel alone.
|
Mighty (S)words: Protective and Apotropaic Uses of the Qur'an
Program Unit: The Qur’an: Manuscripts and Textual Criticism (IQSA)
Francesca Leoni, Ashmolean Museum, University of Oxford
From excerpts appearing on small amulets worn on a daily basis to lengthier selections inscribed on large banners carried in battle, Qur'anic passages figure prominently on objects that are not directly related to orthodox religious practice. Along with attesting to the piety of users and makers, these verses are intentionally selected to imbue the objects with the protective powers of the most potent resource for Muslims: God's own word. Specific chapters and prophetic figures occur repeatedly. In addition to the Ayat al-kursi (Qur. 2:255), by far the most frequently quoted Qur'anic verse, and larger sections of the Surat al-baqara, passages from the Surat al-'imran (chapter 3), Surat al-kahf (chapter 18), Surat al-naml (chapter 27) that stress God's absolute power or invoke the mediation of powerful intercessors such as Solomon, 'Ali, and Muhammad, form the verbal repertoire decorating these varied items. In this paper I plan to analyse a selection of items-including personal ornaments, talismanic shirts, arms/armours and banners-and reflect on the enhanced meaning, function and status that Qur'anic passages and religious invocations lent to them. This body of material forms one of the categories of an ongoing research project that will mature in a large loan exhibition at the Ashmolean Museum planned for the late 2016.
|
The Spirit, Ecclesial Traditions, and the Role of the Communion of the Saints in Interpreting Scripture: Acts 15 as a Case Study
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Brian LePort, Trinity College - Bristol
The Spirit, Ecclesial Traditions, and the Role of the Communion of the Saints in Interpreting Scripture: Acts 15 as a Case Study
|
Ritual and Esotericism in Joseph and Aseneth
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Rebecca Lesses, Ithaca College
This paper analyzes two aspects of the early Jewish novel, “Joseph and Aseneth”: the transformative ritual process of lament and mortification through which Aseneth becomes fit to encounter a “man from heaven,” and the esoteric knowledge and transformed status that is granted to her through this encounter and her continuing access to heavenly secrets through her relationship with her brother-in-law Levi. The paper will discuss how these two aspects are woven into the usual romantic plotline of the ancient Greek novel, as well as considering the affinities of the novel with ancient rituals known from the Greek magical papyri and from the Hekhalot literature. Finally, the paper will examine whether the ritual process and esoteric knowledge gained from the encounter with the angel reflect practices known to us from other sources in Egypt of the first few centuries C.E.
|
Review of James Davila, Hekhalot Literature in Translation
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Rebecca Lesses, Ithaca College
Review of James Davila, Hekhalot Literature in Translation
|
Wartime Rape in Judg 5:28–30: Discussing “Women” as a “Seriality” with Jael, Deborah, and Sisera’s Mother
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Anne Létourneau, Université du Québec à Montréal
In this paper, I intend to explore how femininity is defined through sexual violence in Judg 5:28-30. After the vivid description of Jael murdering Sisera in a nomadic setting (Judg 5:24-27), the reader of the Song of Deborah witnesses Sisera’s mother looking out her palace window (v. 28). The woman anxiously awaits for her son to return. In the company of her wise princesses, she finds comfort in the idea that Sisera is not home yet because he is too busy plundering a defeated army of their women – the word ra?amataîm “uteruses” is used – and their precious fabrics (v. 30). The Canaanite women’s words are very troubling from a feminist point of view. They use sexist “slang” to designate other women, reducing them to their sexuality/genitalia. All women are potentially war captives, depending on who wins the war. This raises an array of questions regarding the unity of the category “women”. There is no “natural” solidarity between women whose other affiliations, including ethnicity and class, need to be accounted for. In order to do so, I wish to examine Judg 5:28-30’s Biblical definition of feminine gender through the concept of “seriality” instead of “identity”. This notion allows us to think “women” as united passively to one another through their material environment and the material effects of other people’s actions, including enforced heterosexuality, and more specifically, rape (Young, 1994, 724 and 728-731). I will demonstrate how fruitful this concept can be to study the patriarchal constraints that shape the category “women” in the episode of Sisera's mother, while keeping in mind the diversity among women as individuals. Borrowing from the recent contribution of Delvaux (2013) on gender as seriality, I will also investigate the political resistance to male domination it can avail, exemplified by Jael in Judg 5:24-27, the “uterus” who violently “rapes” general Sisera.
|
Hosea's Exodus Mythology within the Book of the Twelve
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Mark Leuchter, Temple University
The Book of Hosea is saturated with references to the Exodus, which some scholars have viewed as rooted in the Exodus as a "charter myth" for the northern state and its cult. Yet a closer examination of Hosea's oracles reveals that Hosea's Exodus mythology carries a unique valence tied to a different tradition of discourse regarding the Exodus. This tradition developed alongside -- and in opposition to -- the northern state's "official" version of the Exodus myth. Hosea's Exodus mythology draws from pre-state concepts regarding the national "Urzeit" regarding the settlement of the highlands in the Late Bronze - early Iron Ages. This mythology, which long accompanied northern Levite criticism of the dominant state cult systems, is echoed in many pivotal prophetic works throughout the Book of the Twelve, positioning the prophets therein as the inheritors of an ancient ideology long antedating the rise and fall of the monarchy and its cultic institutions.
|
Text and Praxis: Embracing Tensions, Engaging Life
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Barbara Leung Lai, Tyndale University College and Seminary (Ontario)
At the intersection of biblical studies and pastoral care, this pager emerges from a new reading strategy employed for Ecclesiastes (reading "cross the grains"), leading towards the book's meaning-significance as appropriated in pastoral care and mentorship. Rooted in the rubrics of "text and praxis," and the postmodern orientation of "life-text," I aim at expounding on a much-needed window of perception for pastor-mentors. In that, embracing co-existing tensions is a way of engaging in one's "text-of-life." This path is healthy and vibrant, and one that requires the engagement of the “self.”
|
The Neo-Babylonian Empire: The Imperial Periphery as Seen from the Center
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Yuval Levavi, University of Vienna
The paper mines the vast cuneiform evidence from sixth-century Babylonia for information on the form and the aims of the Neo-Babylonian imperial rule over its western provinces, in particular, northern Mesopotamia. Even though much new data that hitherto has not been considered in this context can be brought to bear on the issue, direct evidence is scarce and will be supplemented by a model for the structure of Neo-Babylonian domination in the imperial periphery.
This model draws on the rich information concerning state institutions and resource extraction by the state in the imperial centre. Two Key issues need consideration. First is the extent to which Neo-Assyrian structures and institutions were simply adopted by the Babylonians after the fall of Assyria, which determines whether or not the Neo-Assyrian state archives can serve as proxy data for the Neo-Babylonian case. Second is the diachronic shift in Babylonian imperial rule that one can posit tentatively on the basis of our current knowledge of the data. According to the typology proposed by Bonney and Ormrod, until ca. 570 BCE, Babylonian imperial rule in the Syrian and Levantine periphery can be conceptualized primarily as a straightforward exploitative tributary regime. However, there seems to have been a shift toward more sustainable resource extraction through the creation of stable pockets (‘colonies’) of Babylonian presence in the periphery from the final decade of Nebuchadnezzar’s reign onward.
|
Early Deuteronomy: Its Size and Its Setting
Program Unit: Book of Deuteronomy
Christoph Levin, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
The shape of Deuteronomy changed considerably throughout the course of its transmission in the Second Temple period. This paper will approach the question of the character of Deut 12-26 as a whole by examining the stages of literary growth in the center section of the book that deals with the prescriptions for the practice of law (Deut 16:18 – 21:9). This literary analysis will provide a basis for developing a hypothesis about the scope, the sources, the setting, and the purpose of the original text of these chapters, and for Urdeuteronomium as a whole.
|
“And There Was Peace between Israel and the Amorites” (1 Sam 7:14): Israelites and Canaanites in Late Iron I
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Yigal Levin, Bar-Ilan University
At the end of the story of Samuel’s victory over the Philistines in 1 Sam. 7, we are told that “The towns that the Philistines had taken from Israel were restored to Israel, from Ekron to Gath; and Israel recovered their territory from the hand of the Philistines; and there was peace between Israel and the Amorites” (verse 14). The idea of “peace” between Israel and “the Amorites” in this context is surprising, and has been understood in different ways by different commentators. This paper suggests that the reference refers to such “Amorite” (a.k.a. “Canaanite”) towns in the northern and central Shephelah such as Gezer, Beth-shemesh, and Tell Aitun (Eglon?) and reflects the relationship between the emerging late Iron I period Israelite polity represented by the Samuel narrative and the “Canaanite” cities in the Shephelah vis-à-vis their relationship with the Philistines, as reflected in both the biblical text and in the material culture of the region.
|
Correcting the Restorations of Temple Scroll (11Q19) 2:8–9
Program Unit: Qumran
Bernard M. Levinson, University of Minnesota-Twin Cities
The poor state of preservation of the opening column (col. 2) of the Temple Scroll (11Q19) makes it difficult to determine the column’s original width. As a result, judging precisely how much text should be restored at the beginning and at the end of each line poses a challenge for any reconstruction, as a contrast of the two major restorations by Yigael Yadin (1977-1983) and Elisha Qimron (2010) makes clear. Even when they agree on the biblical text to be restored, they disagree on where the line-breaks should occur. The issue of contrasting restorations becomes acute at lines 8 and 9, where the preserved text, which reworks Exod 34, points to an interpolation of material corresponding in part to Deut 7. The column’s author, however, does not strictly follow the MT and also makes some additions of his own, which has led Yadin and Qimron to diverge in their restorations of the lacuna in line 9. Yadin relies on the extant example of theonymous attribution in another column of the scroll (52:4–5) and reconstructs accordingly at 2:8–9; while Qimron’s reconstruction does not suggest theonymy. The fragmentary condition of the column and the divergence in restorations has led me to work on a new reconstruction, with special focus on 2:8–9. This new reconstruction, which corrects existing proposals, is based upon direct examination of the manuscript itself (Accession number: H95.57.23A) at the Shrine of the Book. Two major methodological controls were employed: (1) detailed analysis of syntax, to assess the viability of the existing proposals; and (2) the use of digital restoration techniques, which works with the scribe’s own hand for the reconstruction of line length. Although the primary focus of this analysis is upon 2:8–9, additional minor corrections to col. 2 will also be provided. The final results confirm the Temple Scroll’s sophisticated techniques for constructing its claim to divine authority already in the opening column.
|
"As Though You Yourself Came Out of Egypt": Exodus Terminology in the Book of Ezekiel
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Risa Levitt Kohn, San Diego State University
Ezekiel is the first biblical prophet since Moses to see visions of Yahweh outside of Israel. The prophet and his contemporaries, by virtue of their dislocation from Israel, had to rethink traditional notions of kinship in order to remap their newly formed communities. It is little surprise then that we see, among the exilic prophets especially, allusions to Israel’s first wandering and return with Moses and Pharaoh recast to become ciphers of the savior and the enslaver in a new and contemporary context. However, unlike other exilic prophets, careful examination of the prophet’s (re)use of traditional Exodus terminology helps to illustrate that Ezekiel does not in fact envision a ‘Second Exodus,’ nor are his frequent analogies to the exodus tale simply allusions to Israel’s treasured past. Rather, this detailed examination suggests that the prophet casts his current audience as the exodus generation. According to the prophet, the wandering and rebellion did not end, as they do in Israelite Torah tradition, upon entry into the land. As a result, the current exile does not simply recall the travails of the exodus from Egypt; instead, it is an extension of that initial event.
--
|
Our Contemporary Template
Program Unit: Jewish-Christian Dialogue and Sacred Texts
Andrew Zack Lewis, Regent College
Since at least Gregory the Great, writers have been drawn to the book of Job to explore their own sufferings, whether physical ailments, social ostracism, or emotional pain. Both Jewish and Christian writers have used the book of Job as a template in order to explore difficult episodes in their own lives. This paper will survey some of these autobiographical works (including the Christian Soren Kierkegaard and the Jewish Franz Kafka), culminating in a comparison of two strikingly different recent films—The Tree of Life and A Serious Man—that use Job as template to explore, in part, the filmmakers' Christian and Jewish backgrounds, respectively. In so doing, I will explore a few important distinctions between Jewish and Christian interpreters when reading Job as a sacred text.
|
“Anger Is a Shameless Dog”: Wrath in the Preaching of John Chrysostom
Program Unit: Social History of Formative Christianity and Judaism
Blake Leyerle, University of Notre Dame
According to Aristotle’s influential formulation, it is ignoble not to show anger when insulted by an inferior— a conviction that rested, in turn, upon a long literary tradition devoted to the exploration of heroic wrath. The connection between anger and domestic and civic violence, however, made the emotion a subject of on-going ethical reflection. Christian preachers were also constrained to consider the nature and appropriateness of anger because of its presence in the scriptural record, where not only humans give way to anger, but even God experiences and expresses wrath. John Chrysostom, the great fourth century preacher, often addressed the topic of anger. His thought on this emotion is, as Francis Leduc has demonstrated, complex and cannot be adequately treated in a single paper. Here, I propose to address just one, but arguably central, aspect of his thought, namely his fascinating recasting of the emotion. Instead of being an expression of status and power, public displays of anger are presented as shameful and weak. This reformulation is expressed succinctly in a telling shift of metaphor: in place of the heroic lion, Chrysostom substitutes the shameless dog. Such recasting leads to some exegetical contortion when he addresses scriptural passages where biblical heroes appear to react to a slight (directed either at themselves or at God) with hot anger, as, for example, when Jesus curses the fig tree or Phineas kills the Israelite man and Midianite woman. Carefully, Chrysostom reworks the emotional tenor of the stories. Jesus blasted the fig tree, not in anger at the lack of figs, but as a lesson to the disciples about his control over nature. Phineas acted not out of anger, but out of grief. Indeed, reading backwards from the fact that God rewarded him with ordination, this bloodshed should be understood as a sacrifice, equivalent to the ready obedience of Abraham. By elucidating this aspect of Chrysostom’s view of anger, this paper makes a contribution to our understanding of his overarching program of ethical and cultural reformation.
|
A Quantitative Future for Theological Inquiry? Problems and Possibilities
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
James Libby, McMaster Divinity College
If the history of Biblical criticism in the last two centuries can be compared to a fugue in three parts, then the first part (ad fontes!) would doubtless be source and text criticism, the second part historical criticism (especially in its formgeschichte and redactiongeschichte varieties) and the third part a pastiche of social-science semiotics, including, without limitation, socio-rhetorical and reader response methodologies. We inquire here whether a fourth, largely unwritten counterpuntal might exist, specifically, whether there might be a quantitative future for theological inquiry. Beyond Augustine’s plaintive cry that it be so, and in spite of embarrassingly insular inaugural attempts at quantification (which somehow managed to be both positivistic and naïve!) we submit three reasons for exploring just such a future. First, an historical and cross-disciplinary review reveals, somewhat uncomfortably, that ours is one of the few remaining academic disciplines (if we are to extend the musical metaphor) where quantification is not a central voce in the fugue. Second, recent developments in linguistics, and in particular the functional schools, have provided the prospective quantitative Biblical researcher with a far richer set of language phenomena to measure than that provided by traditional grammar. Third, mature techniques in quantification (such as inferential statistics and causal modeling) are now capable of speaking to long-standing textual and contextual issues in our discipline. Our inquiry concludes with worked examples.
|
Participating in the Life of the Triune God: Reconsidering the Trinitarian Foundation of 1 Peter’s Missional Identity
Program Unit: GOCN Forum on Missional Hermeneutics
Kelly Liebengood, LeTourneau University
Scholars and practitioners alike increasingly are pointing to 1 Peter as a fruitful and formative text for better understanding the mission of the church, especially as the church finds itself living out its calling in a post-Christian context. The growing body of research on the missional identity of the church in 1 Peter has tended to focus on one of three themes: (a) the place of suffering and social ostracism for those who are faithfully engaged in God’s mission for the world; (b) the function of the Old Testament (and Israel’s story) in understanding the identity and mission of the church; and/or (c) the way in which Christology undergirds and informs the church’s understanding and practice of its mission. While these lines of inquiry have been helpful in clarifying the nature and focus of the church’s mission in the world, there has been inattention to the more foundational claims made in 1 Peter, which ground the mission of the people of God in the life and activities of Father, Son, and Spirit. That is to say that recent reflection on the way in which 1 Peter informs the mission of the church has not been sufficiently Trinitarian. In this paper, I will highlight the way the letter’s prescript (1.1-2) puts forth the Triune life of God as the grounds, means, and model of the church’s mission for the world, and how the opening themes of the prescript reverberate throughout the rest of letter. In the end I seek to demonstrate that 1 Peter does not ground the mission of the church merely in terms of Christology, or even the story of Israel (as is often suggested), but rather that the mission of the people of God is rooted more foundationally as participation in the life of the Triune God.
|
Fertility and Fragility: Ephrem’s Discourse on Virginal Bodies
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Julia Kelto Lillis, Duke University
Like many Christian authors of the fourth century, Ephrem the Syrian exhibits a fascination with virginity, especially female virginity, as an idea and ideal. Whether he is dwelling on the virginity of Mary, of ascetic Christians of his own day, or of other beings and entities, he employs a rich and multi-faceted vocabulary replete with references to reproductive bodies. Two poles emerge from Ephrem’s virginity discourse: he tends to concentrate on either virginity’s fertility or virginity’s fragility. This pattern cuts across many of the writer’s works, including the two parts of his corpus in which virginity figures most prominently—the Hymns on Virginity and Hymns on the Nativity. In centering on these two aspects of virginity, Ephrem stands apart from contemporary extant authors, particularly from those writing in other linguistic milieux around the late ancient Mediterranean.
While several early Christian writers stress virginity’s fragility by warning women of the perils that confront the dedicated virgin or by commenting on the problem of whether virginity can be proven by medical examination, Ephrem has a pronounced interest in linking such issues with Old Testament scriptures. Concerns about virginity’s precariousness and verifiability are refracted through biblical narratives about lost virginity and biblical models for ascertaining women’s chastity. Ephrem’s emphasis on fertility is even more striking and distinctive. Whereas many late ancient authors conform to modern readers’ expectations by constructing definitions of female virginity that foreground inexperience with sexual intercourse or intactness of sexual organs, Ephrem highlights the inherently barren quality of virgins’ wombs. For Ephrem, virginity is a state of sterility that by nature cannot produce new life—yet in Christ’s conception within Mary and in the life of Christian faith, God transforms virginity into a state of fecundity. My paper seeks to elucidate Ephrem’s fundamental meaning(s) for female virginity through consideration of these two discursive poles and their relationship to one another.
|
Climate Change and Modern Liberation: Ethics in Noah and Exodus
Program Unit: Bible and Film
Ingrid E. Lilly, Pacific School of Religion
Darren Aronofsky’s Noah takes up the modern issues of overpopulation and climate change. Ridley Scott’s Exodus will retell the Bible’s most famous story of liberation (December, 2014). A human-caused flood and emancipation from slavery, these two multi-million dollar Hollywood Bible movies of 2014 will entertain us with ancient and sacred tales brought to life by ethical issues of the modern world.
What elements of each film put ethics on display? Do ethics spring from the biblical texts, or are they creatively spun as innovative elements of the story? In the case of Aronofsky’s Noah, aspects of Enoch’s Watchers and Hinduism’s primordial flood myth amplify the environmental theme already present in the Genesis text. To what extent does Aronofsky's Judaism impact his script and direction? What does Ridley Scott have in store for us?
This paper will analyze the interpretive, biblical, and non-biblical resources marshalled for creating the ethical ethos in Noah and Exodus. Some commentary will be then be possible on the heart-beat of biblical interpretation in American culture, particularly the state of progressive, ethically oriented interpretations of the Bible.
|
Rock Giants, a Magic Stone, and Many Destructions of the World: Extra-Biblical Literature in the Noah Movie
Program Unit: Genesis
Ingrid Lilly, Pacific School of Religion
While the Noah movie hewed to numerous details of Genesis 6-9 for its filmic version of The Flood, even the most committed literalist would have to add some detail. The Genesis Noah never speaks before or during the deluge, for example. While some have called Aronosky’s additions fantasy or imagination, the film-maker did extensive research into post-biblical tradition (Enoch, Jubilees, Rabbinic tradition) and may have drawn on his enthusiasm for the flood stories of other cultures (Ila, Noah’s step-daughter is named after a Hindu flood character, for instance.) This paper will discuss the extra-biblical ‘citations’ and ‘allusions’ in Aronofsky’s Noah, showing how they have been interpreted and then whether and how they make meaningful contributions to his retelling of The Flood for today.
|
Biopolitics in the Trial of Jesus
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
Sung Uk Lim, Vanderbilt University
This paper explores the biopolitical dimension of the trial of Jesus in John 18:28-19:22 from the Agambenian perspective of “bare life.” According to Giorgio Agamben, bare life, namely, “life exposed to death” through sovereign power, operates in the “state of exception.” The state of exception is a state wherein the threshold between the juridical order and anomie, or that between an insider and outsider of the juridical order becomes blurred as a result of a law that is suspended from its effectiveness yet is effective in its suspension. Jesus can be interpreted as a bare life in a zone of absolute undecidability in which both the Jewish and Roman laws simultaneously are operative and are in void. More specifically, Jesus is an insider in both the Jewish and Roman worlds on the grounds that he is subject to both the rules of Judaism and the Roman Empire. But at the same time, Jesus is an outsider from both the Jewish and Roman worlds explicitly because his kingship goes beyond both earthly rules (18:36; cf. 8:23; 17:14, 16). Paradoxically, Jesus is simultaneously an insider in and an outsider from each of the Jewish and Roman reigns. That is to say, Jesus lives in both of the reigns, while at the same time belonging to neither of them. It follows from this that Jesus stays in an in-between zone between insider and outsider. My contention, therefore, is that Jesus is such a liminal character—an unfixed and unfixable character in a zone of uncertainty—that he subverts the sovereign power of the Jewish and Roman worlds based on hierarchical dualism.
|
Toxic Translations: The Extensive Use of Sexual Anachronisms in 1 Corinthians 6
Program Unit: LGBTI/Queer Hermeneutics
Kjeld Renato Lings, Other Sheep Europe
The apostle Paul is often said to express anti-gay sentiment in 1 Cor. 6:9 by means of the Greek terms malakoi ("softies") and arsenokoitai ("male-liers"). However, the juxtaposition of these two words has no precedent in Greek or Hellenistic erotic literature. In Greco-Roman times, sexual expression followed well-defined rules within hierarchical social structures. Most same-sex relationships between males conformed to the paiderastia pattern, involving an adult male (erastes) and a teenage boy (eromenos). Taken in isolation, the meaning of malakoi is relatively easy to establish due to frequent occurrences in ancient writings, but the exegesis of arsenokoitai is made difficult by extremely few occurrences (cf. 1 Tim. 1:10). At present there is no academic consensus. Perhaps arsenokoitai refers to men who practised abusive sex or engaged in illicit activities connected with the lucrative sex trade.
Many English versions of the Bible misinterpret Paul's Greek original and mistranslate malakoi and arsenokoitai accordingly. The use of anachronistic language is widespread with post-biblical terms and phrases such as sodomites, perverts, homosexuals, people who practise homosexuality, and men who have sex with men. These choices are deeply problematic for several reasons: (a) 1 Cor. 6 has no links with the story of Sodom and Gomorrah, (b) Paul never uses the term sodomite, (c) only in fourth-century patristic literature does sodomite begin to take on a sexual sense, and (d) not until the Middle Ages does it denote "person practising homoerotic sex." Similar considerations apply to "perverts." The modern phrase "men who have sex with men" connotes equality and so does "homosexuals," coined in 1869 in a European context. Moreover, today "homosexuals" applies to persons of both sexes, whereas arsenokoitai refers exclusively to males.
In this passage, most English versions of the Bible display weak translation procedures based on incomplete literary analysis. In addition, the anti-gay bias may be ideologically motivated. In a 2000-year old text, the presence of post-biblical and modern sexual language is not only unfortunate and contentious but may be characterized as toxic. Millions of Bible readers around the world are influenced by the particular versions of the Bible they habitually use. As translators speak of "homosexuals" in 1 Cor. 6:9, the outcome in numerous Christian churches is predictable in the form of hostility towards LGBT people. The dire religious, political, social and psychological consequences of anti-LGBT campaigns orchestrated by powerful Christian circles are in the news on a regular basis. In summary, English Bible translators would be better advised to err on the side of caution.
|
Parrhesia in Valentinus' Fragments and Three Nag Hammadi Texts
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Paul Linjamaa, Lunds Universitet
In two of the seven fragments of Valentinus of Alexandria we encounter the word "parrhesia", often translated as free, fearless or bold speech. Ismo Dunderberg, the only scholar discussing Valentinus' use of the term at any length, has suggested that Valentinus was inspired by the image of the fearless philosopher in dispute with worldly authority. In my paper I expand upon Dunderberg's work and argue that parrhesia should not be restricted to a form of speech. Parrhesia was the stabile and firm disposition that came from possessing rest (mton) and firmness of heart and mind. Furthermore, I discuss three Nag Hammadi texts from this perspective and argue that parrhesia was used in the struggle against cosmic powers, powers that are depicted as sleepless, in constant motion and trying to hinder and harm humans. In this context parrhesia was the stabile demeanor that kept the cosmic powers at
bay.
|
May Contain Nuts and B.S. (Biblical Studies): The Politics of Academic Legitimacy Online and the Need to Properly Theorize the Category “@%!#*! Loonie”
Program Unit: Blogger and Online Publication
James Linville, University of Lethbridge
Blogging provides many biblical scholars with a simple and fast way of presenting their academic views to a general public, even if there is little prestige or formal recognition for serious, academic posts. The benefit seems to lie in the quick networking of ideas and the building of relationships between scholars. The medium also allows scholars to easily play the role of accessible public intellectual, something badly needed in a world that has devalued advanced education.
The Internet’s lack of censorship guarantees a high level of academic freedom but it also subjects scholars to an equally high level of non-academic freedom. Not only is there a complete lack of peer review, the likelihood that any serious post may attract unwanted attention from those with no understanding of the subject matter or fringe theory or doctrine to promote is very real. With most bloggers allowing readers some freedom to comment without moderation, discussions can be easily sidetracked into tangential or completely off-topic exchanges that can get acrimonious very quickly. Disallowing or vetting comments also smacks of censorship and may actually play into the hands of those who see critical scholarship as a self-absorbed ivory tower or even conspiracy against the “Truth.” This paper, then, offers a critical examination of how scholarly bloggers assert the validity of the academic study of the bible, their own academic legitimacy. It also examines the “othering” of non-mainstream theorists, religious fundamentalists, anti-intellectualists, purveyors of alternate histories, internet “trolls”, and assorted “dilettantes” and “crackpots”, and attempts to gauge the impact this may have on the practice of biblical scholarship and its reception by a wider audience.
|
In Search of the Biblical Flintstones? Some Thoughts on Creationism, Academic Freedom, and Scholarly Obligation
Program Unit: Metacriticism of Biblical Scholarship
Jim Linville, University of Lethbridge
In early 2014, the famous science educator, Bill Nye, debated Ken Ham, the founder of Kentucky’s (in)famous Creation Museum. This event provided Ham with publicity and badly needed donations and earned Nye criticism for giving the impression that creationism was even worthy of scientific debate. In this paper I argue that secular biblical scholars should be at least as engaged in countering creationism, as are some scientists.
Creationist objections to evolutionary and other sciences are not based on science but religion. What is really at stake is not the integrity of science but whether the creationists’ reading of the Bible is internally consistent and reasonable, let alone being the default mode of understanding it. Allowing scientists to carry the burden of refuting creationist claims presents the Bible to the public from polarized parties, neither of which are likely to give much heed to critical Bible research. Biblical scholars are much better trained than scientists in the calling the hermeneutics of creationists into question.
Creationists also confront other Christians who maintain that evolution and an earth billions of years old are compatible with their faith. This directly affects some biblical scholars, as a number of Christian colleges are now enforcing compliance with a creationist doctrine. Non-religious biblical scholars should also defend their Christian counterparts against violations of ideals of academic freedom in Christian schools, even if, in the end, they may part ways on a number of issues, including whether “theistic evolution” makes sense.
Since publically refuting creationism is not likely to convince many creationists to rethink their views, biblical scholars should direct their engagement with creationism to those who may be sitting on the fence, or have a curiosity about the Bible but no direct familiarity. Besides helping to defend science education from creationists, biblical scholars could also take the opportunity to the legitimacy and relevance of biblical scholarship in the public eye and combat the impression given by many noted science advocates that the Bible and religion is worthy only of denigration and not of serious inquiry as products of human culture.
|
Prostitution, Promiscuity, or Apostasy? The Offense, Its Consequences, and the Meaning of znh in Lev 19:29
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Hilary Lipka, University of New Mexico
Generally, Leviticus 19:29 is understood as a warning to fathers not to desecrate their daughters by making them prostitutes. Yet is the issue really about prostitution, or does znh denote something else? This paper will contend that there is good reason to question the traditional understanding of znh as the act of prostitution in this context. Two other possible interpretations of znh will be considered: engaging in sexually promiscuous behavior and participating in non-Yahwistic religious practices. Once the nature of the daughter's problematic behavior has been determined, several other issues raised by this text will be addressed. In what way is the daughter desecrated? How much blame is attached to the daughter, and how much to the father? What threat does such behavior pose to the land, and what are the consequences? Lastly, this paper will address the question of how this admonition fits into the larger context of Leviticus 19 and its concern with achieving and maintaining holiness.
|
Ramat Rahel in the Persan Period: Between Archaeology, History, and Text
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Oded Lipschits, Tel Aviv University
The renewed excavations at Ramat Rahel and the final publication of the architecture and finds from previous excavations at the site have made it possible to reevaluate the archaeology of the site and its significance vis-a-vis the political history of Judah as a province in the Achaemenid Empire. This paper will present the finds from Persian period (5th-3rd century BCE) Ramat Rahel, and will demonstrate how Ramat Rahel reached its zenith during the Persian period, serving as an imperial administrative center, and as the residency of the Persian governor.
|
A Garrulous Prophet of Self-Restraint: Speech and Talk in Hermas
Program Unit: Speech and Talk in the Ancient Mediterranean World
B. Diane Lipsett, Salem College
The Shepherd of Hermas features a talkative protagonist also said to exemplify core virtues of self-restraint (enkrateia) and manliness (andreia). Discussions of virtue in the text frequently focus on speech: for instance, true and false words, true and false prophecy, and slander (katalalia). A divine revealer invokes the gendered stereotype of the talkative woman, telling Hermas: “[your wife] does not restrain her tongue, but uses it to perpetrate evil. But when she hears these words she will control it and receive mercy” (Vis 6.3). Yet it is the manly, self-controlled Hermas who is garrulous throughout. At times, the divine revealers with whom Hermas converses claim that his loquacity marks him as shameless (anaides), crafty (panourgos), and brazen (authades). Undeterred, he asks more questions, and certain dialogue markers repeat: “‘Why,’ I said?” (diati phemi). The Shepherd of Hermas thus activates speech conventions relating to gender and virtue, recalling ancient moral philosophers such as Plutarch, Philo, Theophrastus and others on garrulousness versus circumspection. Yet the text also disrupts such understandings in its favorable evaluations of its chatty protagonist. Other speech protocols are brought to bear, particularly modes of speech that characterize visionaries, disciples, and penitents. Attention to the status level implied by the work’s style and social concerns further nuances an analysis of speech and talk in this widely read second-century tale.
|
Brick Making in Ancient Egypt and Exod 5:1–12
Program Unit: Egyptology and Ancient Israel
Robert J. Littman, University of Hawaii at Manoa
In Exodus 5: 1-21 the pharaoh oppressed the Israelite slaves by refusing to provide straw for them to make bricks, but requiring them to find their own straw. He did not reduce the quota of bricks. This edict is better understood through a knowledge of mud brick engineering in ancient Egypt.
To the reader unfamiliar with mud-brick, it might seem the simplest of construction material to prepare. However, the collection of the straw was not as easy a task as it might seem, because the mud-bricks required a particular type of straw that was gleaned from the fields.
An examination of mud-brick production in ancient Egypt and ancient Israel can help us place the biblical passage in context. The author of this paper is currently excavating the Greco-Roman Egyptian city of Thmouis (Tell Timai) in the Nile Delta in Egypt. Tell Timai is covered with acres of mud-brick buildings. We are actively engaged in the production of mud-brick to use in restoration and reconstruction of ancient mud-brick houses, to conserve areas where mud-brick structures were collapsing. In two days in 2013, we produced almost 2000 bricks, the same number produced by Egyptian overseers in Egyptian records We imitated the production method of mud-brick structures in ancient Egypt from the 4th millennium BCE to the first millennium CE. Extremely fine particles of chaff were required to make durable bricks a success, attested to by the enduring edifices at Tell Timai. We experimented in making bricks without straw chaff. These turned out to be fragile and broke easily.
One of the only depictions of mud-brick production, is found in the tomb of Rekhmire (15th century BCE) during the 18th dynasty (ca. 1450 BCE). The tomb paintings depicts an Egyptian overseer, watching as captured prisoners, Nubians and Semites prepare mud brick and construct buildings. These are not Israelites, but depict the same type of construction described in Exodus.
In Egypt, as well as the Levant, the wheat was available only at harvest time. This created a serious hindrance in the construction process, since the bricks could be produced only during the dry season. Construction with bricks took place throughout the year. Thus, chaff was collected and stored to make sure it was always available.
If pharaoh did not supply the Israelites with straw, presumably from his storage units, then the search for the right chaff would have been almost impossible, which is exactly the point of the story. The ancient reader or listener who lived in a society where making of mud-brick was common, would know about the difficulty of gathering chaff, a fact that is lost on the modern reader of Exodus. Thus pharaoh oppressed the Israelites by keeping the quota of bricks the same without providing the materials so necessary to produce them, which materials the Israelites could scarcely obtain for themselves.
|
“You Shall Be as Gods!” Naassene and Simonian Types of Deification
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
M. David Litwa, University of Virginia
So-called Gnostic soteriologies contributed heavily to the construction of Christian theories of deification in the second century CE. But unlike their proto-orthodox counterparts (e.g., Justin, Theophilus, Irenaeus), the study of distinctly Gnostic forms of deification is rarely a topic of independent investigation. This paper explores two forms of deification preserved in the Sondergut of Hippolytus’ Refutatio: those of the Naassenes and the Simonians. Naassene and Simonian theories of deification are studied with particular attention to how they relate to contemporary proto-orthodox forms of deification in (1) the use of biblical texts (e.g., Ps. 82), (2) the role of Savior figures, and (3) visions of the afterlife. This study is part of a larger project of exploring second century Christianity in all its richness and variety. It indicates that Naassene and Simonian thought may feature more embedded Christian elements than previously observed.
|
‘Be Imitators’: The Role of Exemplars in Greco-Roman Historiography and Luke-Acts
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Kenneth Litwak, Asbury Theological Seminary
*
|
Offering of Isaac and Its Reception: Mediating Children and Sacrifice in Early Judaism and Early Christianity of Isaac
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Tsui Yuk Louise Liu, Chinese University of Hong Kong
Offering of Isaac is sometimes understood as an example of child abuse by the standards of modern morality (e.g. Dawkins 2006). Whether child abuse or ancient psychological experience of childhood trauma is a proper description of the legend needs further examination. However, the corresponding masoretic narrative (Gen 22:1-19MT) as well as septuagintal (Gen 22:1-19LXX) definitely concerns the childhood Isaac. Apart from “son,” Isaac is called “boy” (na?ar [Gen 22:12MT] or paidarion [Gen 22:12LXX]). Besides Isaac, Abraham also brings “two boys” (š?nê n?‘araw [Gen 22:3MT]) or “two boy-servants” (duo paidas [Gen 22:3LXX]).
As one of the representatives of early Judaism, Flavius Josephus seems to reflect a contemporary awareness of the moral problem of child sacrifice. In his retelling of Abraham’s sacrifice of Isaac, Isaac is no longer a child but a 25-year-old man. Even those side-characters like “two boys” or “two boy-servants” implicitly grow up and become “two home-servants” (duo oiketon [Ant. 1.225]).
Instead of forcing the boys grow up, the Epistle to the Hebrews (as one of the representatives of early Christianity) just omit all the wordings like “boy” or even “son” which may cause any child-association. In this way, the narrative of faith is preserved with deliberate moralization.
|
The Figure of Sarah in Abr. 245–254
Program Unit: Women in the Biblical World
Atar Livneh, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
The paper focuses on Philo’s interpretation of the account of Sarah’s search for a child through Hagar in Genesis 16 as an act of wifely love and self-sacrifice that exemplify the matriarch’s spousal virtues adduced at her burial. This encomium—which also lauds Sarah’s loyalty to her husband through good and bad and the fact that she accompanied him on all his journeys—reflects contemporary Roman conceptions regarding the ideal wife, demonstrating striking resemblances with Latin literature and epitaphs—particularly with the so-called Laudatio Turiae. At the same time, the passage also evinces Philo’s familiar with Jewish exegetical traditions—as, for example, in his presentation of Sarah as seeking to realize the divine promise that Abraham would have many descendants by ensuring that he begot an heir from his own loins.
|
Metaphor and the Eunuch in Isaiah 56
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Stephen Llewelyn, Macquarie University
“I am just a dry tree.” In Isa 56 a eunuch figure is implored not to utter these words. Perhaps it should not surprise that the ancient eunuch remains mute in modern commentary. We bring to the text a new methodology which reverses this. It is one which plots how (conceptual) metaphor is informed by and speaks back to, both consciously and unconsciously, intertexts. The eunuch is found to be operative in the metaphorical construction of meaning in the final redactional form of Isaiah. He has an intertextual voice which projects a conceptual metaphor of eschatological significance among both the final texts of Isaiah and the Torah. By the conceptual metaphor the text addresses both a (tangible) problematic social group and an (abstract) eschatological question. Neither the eunuch nor Israel can bring about its own fertility and longevity. Rather the LORD will restore both the name of the eunuch and Israel.
But of particular interest is that three key motifs which factor in the construction of the metaphor in Isa 56(–66) are prefigured in Isa 54–55. First: Just as the barren woman of Isa 54 (an echo of Sarah) is granted children, so the eunuch is promised “a monument and a name better than sons and daughters” (Isa 56:5). Second: Isa 55:1–2 portrays an invitation to metaphorical eating quite similar to that in Isa 56:9 where all beasts are addressed. And third: Both the figurative tree and the eunuch shall be/have “an everlasting sign/name that shall not be cut off” (Isa 55:13/56:5).
The postulates of a Second and Third Isaiah require us to see this intricate metaphorical continuity as a matter of mere literary influence. We find this explanation unsatisfactory and therefore question the worth of a neat redactional break after Isa 55.
|
The “Third” Gender in the Figurative Language of Ben Sira
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible and Cognate Literature
Stephen Llewelyn, Macquarie University
Like a eunuch lusting to violate a girl is the person who does right under compulsion. (Sirach 20:4) he sees with his eyes and groans as a eunuch groans when embracing a girl. (Sirach 30:20)
Within the Hebrew Bible eunuchs are met as persons associated with the royal household and court. Their loyalty and training even permitted some to attain high office. However, with the rise of legalism this ‘third’ gender was excluded from membership in ‘the assembly of the Lord’ (Deut 23:2). Voices were raised against their exclusion (Isa 56:3-4 and Wisdom of Solomon 3:14) but clearly the status of this ‘third’ gender had changed. In the case of Ben Sira the eunuch has become a figure of speech employed rhetorically to effect a negative comparison; indeed one that sets out unfortunately to evoke a comical image that plays on ‘his’ sexual ambiguity. The present paper will explore Ben Sira’s use of the eunuch simile in terms of contemporary theories of metaphor and gender (queer theory), and will ask what has changed in the author’s social context to have caused this.
|
Why Have We Stopped Reading James, Peter, and Jude Together? Tracing the Early Reception of a Collection
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Darian Lockett, Biola University
As an academic discipline, Biblical Studies has traditionally taken up the tools of history and social context in an effort to situate and understand the texts of the New Testament. For over three-hundred years the historical-critical method has lead a majority of interpreters to read the Letters of James, Peter, and Jude in isolation from each other as discrete bits of communication between an individual author and a general audience. Yet, both the manuscript tradition and the history of interpretation indicate these letters have been read together as a rough collection. Eusebius is an early voice describing them as a specific collection (Hist. Eccl. 2.23.25) and Augustine seems to have read these letters as bearing a coherent apostolic theology (De fide et operibus 21). Two questions arise from this: When and why did these letters cease to be read together? The issue at hand is whether these letters should be read in isolation from each other, taking their individual historical situations as the guiding principle for their interpretation, or whether their literary and theological placement within the New Testament specifically and within the Christian canon generally should constitute the context within which they are interpreted. This paper outlines the early reception of James, Peter, and Jude (and 1—3 John) as a collection and reflects on the hermeneutical implications for reading these letters together.
|
Emotions in the 'Shepherd of Hermas': The Case of Epithymia
Program Unit: Social History of Formative Christianity and Judaism
Hermut Loehr, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
As former investigations already demonstrated, the mandata of the “Shepherd of Hermas” can be addressed as the earliest example of coherent Christian moral instruction based on a systematic (although rudimentary) anthropolocial reflection. The chapters can justly be labeled as the first Christian handbook on moral matters.
The paper investigates the function of epithymia / epithymein in this context. What are the concepts linked to the lexemes and their contexts? Which (different) translations follow from this? Which are the value systems inscribed in the mandata? In which way the notion of epithymia / epithymein refers to contemporary moral thought (esp. Plutarch)? In which way it is related to the gender difference?
The paper thus furthers our understanding of the perception of emotions in developing Christian moral thought.
|
Sub-creation and Procreation as the Imago Dei: Tolkien and Genesis in Dialogue
Program Unit: Genesis
Shelley Long, Claremont Graduate University
In J. R. R. Tolkien’s poem Mythopoeia, he proclaims that, as humans, “We make still by the law in which we we’re made.” In other words, just as God created humanity in the divine image, so too, we have the ability to create, or rather sub-create. When Tolkien made this claim, he was referring to his own craft of inventing fantasy literature, of forming words that take their reader into another time and place. He believed that the secondary world—the imagined world—had great power and could transport truth into the primary one. Tolkien himself was a master of sub-creation. He established Middle-earth and its originator, Illúvatar, who conceived the Valar, some of whom shaped their own creatures. The poetic paradigm of a Creator giving life to other creators is not unique to Tolkien’s stories. In many ways, his literary sub-creation and its constructed world mirrors the cosmic origin myth of Genesis 1-5, its pro-creators within, and authors without. This paper will explore the rich analog of Tolkien’s sub-creation and its philosophical underpinnings in relationship to the makings of the story of Adam and Eve and their maker. It will highlight the garden as a secondary world of faërie and Eve as the first procreator and mother of life. The intertextual dialogue will also spawn a reexamination of the terminology used for creation (bara?, qanah and yalad) in Genesis 1-5 and its interrelationship with knowledge, sight, and speech.
|
Forming the Cross in Pompeii: Unity and Diversity in the Symbolism of Four First-Century Artifacts of Jesus-Devotion
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Bruce Longenecker, Baylor University
Arguably the earliest surviving Christian art can be found in the material record of Pompeii, destroyed by the eruption of Mount Vesuvius in 79. This presentation will (1) feature four neglected artifacts from Pompeii that depict the cross of Jesus’ death (with occasional gestures to Ostian artifacts as historical analogies), (2) demonstrate stable and diverse features within Pompeian formations of Jesus’ cross, (3) articulate the symbolic and religious functions of the cross within the Pompeian context, and (4) propose implications regarding the character of Jesus-devotion in the town. Although the cross came to prominence as a Christian symbol in the wake of Constantine, it has a foothold within the material remains of the second and third century (despite some claims to the contrary). But the neglected evidence of Pompeii (of which four artifacts are presented here) moves the timeline for artifacts of Christian symbolism of the cross into the last half of the first century.
|
Powerful Imaginaries: Visual Rhetoric and the Politics of Representation in Pauline Studies
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Davina C. Lopez, Eckerd College
This paper will appraise recent trajectories in Pauline studies through exploring intersections with the “visual turn," wherein I will front methodological concerns in the use of images for interpretation. To be sure, there has been a growing interest in using visual representation in Pauline studies over the last several decades. Part of this interest is associated with “Paul and Empire” scholarship and follows Paul Zanker’s seminal work on the “power of images” in the Augustan age. Beyond the promises and pitfalls of this particular instance, images are used in Pauline studies in several critical and interrelated ways: as background material for texts, as exegetical illustrations of theological concepts, as correlates for ideas, as historical evidence for the realia of the ancient world. In all such uses, though, words still reign supreme as something distinct from, and more important than, pictures -- even as words are “visual” in their own right, reading is a form of looking/viewing, and pictures are fundamentally malleable modes of communication. Thus I will observe how, and to what scholarly ends, unstable images are used to stabilize Paul, his work, his world, and his theology.
|
Justin Martyr as an Early “Western” Witness to the Synoptic Gospels
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Peter E. Lorenz, Fuller Theological Seminary (Northwest)
The “Western” character of Justin’s synoptic gospel sources is sometimes cited in introductory texts as a basic fact of New Testament textual criticism, e.g. Vaganay and Amphoux (1991; 47, 96) and Metzger and Ehrman (2006; 178, 277, 308), yet subsequent research has continued to cite Bousset’s 1891 study in support of this claim. New methods published in The New Testament in the Greek Fathers series suggest that a critical reevaluation of Justin’s relationship to the “Western” text is overdue. I will illustrate by examining two texts that have often been considered the most assuredly “Western” of Justin’s gospel parallels, i.e. 1 Apol. 16:10; 63.5, cited in Munier’s edition (2006) as “Lc 10, 16 (cod D)” and 1 Apol. 17.4, cited in Munier as “Lc 12, 48 (cod D).”
|
A Land Measured Out: Pauline Expansion between Population and Territory
Program Unit: Postcolonial Studies and Biblical Studies
Timothy Luckritz Marquis, Moravian Theological Seminary
Paul’s plan for spreading his movement finds at least two major expressions in his letters: the gaining of followers as a population (see, for example, 1 Cor 9) and the acquisition of apportioned territory (2 Cor 10 and Rom 15). In discerning the distinct emphases of these rhetorical strategies, the intersections of various postcolonial theories and studies of biopolitics reveal how Paul’s rhetoric of land acquisition, though based in echoes of prophetic scripture, emerged in imitation of Roman rhetorics of domination (in terms of the “shifting borders” of Rome’s traditional purview, as well as controversies over land distribution) while reorienting categories of individualism and economics. While the mission language of the Palestinian Jesus movement (perhaps echoed in 1 Cor 9) advocated moving from village to village, while accepting support, as a way of uniting communities through the message of God’s empire, Paul’s deployment of the same language led him to engage heads of households (Chloe, Stephanas, etc.) and, thus, potential patrons and the economic entanglements they brought. Foucault’s work on sovereign power over territory and biopower over populations (and their overlaps with disciplinary regimes over individuals) offers a lens for reading the interactions among diverse Pauline tactics, while appropriation by (and resistance to) Foucault’s theories of administration and territory among postcolonial theorists (such as Edward Said and Dipesh Chakrabarty) helps us better parse out the relationship between traditional issues of individual, ethnicity, and community in Paul’s thought. I show how Paul emphasizes the sovereignty of God as alternative to empire by shifting focus to God’s action on the level of territory. While Paul’s attention to population reflects attempts at local and internal administration, territorial disputes indicate questions of power within the international movement (that is, among apostles) and at the global, cosmic level (in competition with Rome).
|
Joseph Smith as a Narrator in the Joseph Smith Translation
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
Jared W. Ludlow, Brigham Young University
Joseph Smith’s work on the Bible, often referred to as the Joseph Smith Translation or Inspired Version, introduced many doctrinal emendations to the text. Since these changes were done randomly to verses throughout the Bible, there was not an overall program of rewriting the Bible, but simply introducing usually minor changes to the text. Occasionally, however, these changes affected the narrative reading of the text. Sometimes the Joseph Smith Translation is given from the perspective of the narrator of the story so as narrator it reveals things about a character’s feelings or thoughts that otherwise would not be known. For example, in JST Mark 10:31-32, it adds the detail that Jesus said this “rebuking Peter.” Thus it gives the motivation behind Jesus’ dialogue with Peter. In another instance, the JST moves some of the feelings of Jesus as related in the Bible to the apostles: “And the disciples began to be sore amazed, and to be very heavy, and to complain in their hearts, wondering if this be the Messiah. And Jesus knowing their hearts, said to his disciples, Sit ye here, while I shall pray. And he taketh with him, Peter, and James, and John, and rebuked them, and said unto them, My soul is exceeding sorrowful, even unto death; tarry ye here and watch (Joseph Smith Translation, Mark 14:36-38). The JST radically alters what was happening and who was feeling what at the Garden of Gethsemane. This paper proposes to look at examples like these to see when and how the Joseph Smith Translation acts as a narrator within the stories of the Bible. Depending upon the number of instances, it may be restricted to the New Testament or even a smaller unit like the Gospels.
|
The Hebrews Papyri from Oxyrhynchus
Program Unit: Hebrews
AnneMarie Luijendijk, Princeton University
This paper examines the three Hebrews papyri found at Oxyrhynchus text critically and in their socio-cultural context.
|
Towards an Evolutionary Account of the Formation of Christian Identity
Program Unit: Redescribing Christian Origins
Petri Luomanen, University of Helsinki
Highly developed evolutionary accounts of the formation of Christianity are rare. Perhaps the most developed one – although very abstract – is still Gerd Theissen’s Biblical Faith: An Evolutionary Approach (1984). Rodney Stark’s The Rise of Christianity comes close to explaining the success of Christianity as social ”evolution” – but lacks the theoretical evolutionary backing since Stark himself supports Intelligent Design. David Sloan Wilson’s Darwin’s Cathedral offers some interesting comparisons but falls short as an overall description. The present paper develops and evolutionary approch to explain the formation of Christian identity, by drawind on Theissen’s Biblical Faith and A Theory of Primitive Christian Religion. The paper argues that Christian identity needed four cornerstones to take shape: ritual, ethos, narrative, and doctrine. In contrast to Theissen’s ”semiotic cathedral” the paper argues the a better metaphor for Christian identity (that is not T’s main topic) is tent, with its lightness, movability and connotations to Israel’s sacred past as well as to early Jesus movement.
|
Judaism and Anti-Judaism in the Protoevangelium of James, the Infancy Gospel of Thomas, and the Gospel of Pseudo-Matthew
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Petri Luomanen, University of Helsinki
The Protoevangelium of James, the Infancy Gospel of Thomas and the Gospel of Pseudo-Matthew are related documents – Pseudo-Matthew incorporating traditions both from Prot. Jas. and Inf. Gos. Thom. The paper analyzes Judaism and anti-Judaism in these three related documents by focusing on (1) the role of Jewish individual characters and Jewish people as insiders or outsiders in the narratives of the three gospels, (2) the texts’ relation to Jewish scriptures, Jewish law and practice, and Jewish beliefs (= indicators of Judaism; cf. Luomanen, Recovering, 2012). The paper argues that although Jews are characterized in friendly terms in Prot. Jas — there is no indication of clear anti-Judaism — Prot. Jas. nonetheless exemplifies Christian supersessionism and ignorance of real-life Jewish belief and practice. Thus, despite its seeming innocence the narrative world of Prot. Jas. is a seedbed for open anti-Judaism, as can be seen in the way how its characterizations are further developed in Ps.-Mt, together with traditions from Inf. Gos. Thom.
|
Visual Rhetorics: Visual Ethics?
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Susanne Luther, Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz
Based on the definition of the progymnasmata and Quintilian this paper focuses on the rhetorical technique of ekphrasis and the specifics of its application in New Testament texts. New Testament passages are analyzed in an exemplary manner concerning their ability to create images and hence associations in the reader’s mind. On a linguistic-rhetorical level the central focus of the investigation is on the question of how techniques of visual rhetorics, especially ekphrasis, are employed in the New Testament writings as conveyors and reminders of ethical teaching. On a theological level the paper seeks to establish that a pivotal function of ekphrasis in the New Testament can be found in its visual form of pedagogy: it mediates ethics in a descriptive, non-imperative way, e.g. through providing visual examples or reminders of ethical models which encourage the reader to reflect on ethical norms and principles and constitute a specific ethical competence. Hence “ekphrastic ethics” can be located at the crossroads of narrative ethics, implicit ethics and visual rhetorics.
|
The Structure of James: New Light on an Old Question?
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Susanne Luther, Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz
The question of the structure of James’ literary composition has been extensively discussed in the epistle’s history of interpretation and has led to a variety of suggestions; theories concerning the structure and form of the epistle have in turn informed investigations e.g. into the matter of genre, audience and other aspects central to the interpretation of the text. As against the diverse approaches to the question of structure this paper puts forward the thesis that focussing on one central, overarching topic of the epistle allows clarification of the question of internal coherence. As will be illustrated exemplarily a thematic approach based on the topic of speech-ethics – i.e. ‘the evil of the tongue’ – can help clarify the overarching structure of the epistle and hence shed new light on an old question.
|
The "I Am" Sayings and the Concept of Time in John's Gospel
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Grant Macaskill, University of St. Andrews
This paper will examine the Gospel of John as a work influenced by apocalyptic imagery and thought, focusing particularly on the concept of time that characterizes the gospel and approaching this specifically in terms of the “I am” sayings. These sayings, which occur in both predicated and non-predicated form, together constitute one of the key devices by which the christology of the gospel is developed. They are generally understood with reference to the statements of Isaiah 41:4 (??? ?e?? p??t??, ?a? e?? t? ?pe???µe?a ??? e?µ?) and 43:10 (??a ???te ?a? p?ste?s?te ?a? s???te ?t? ??? e?µ?), rather than Exodus 3:14, but the ??? e?µ? form has an affinity with reflections on the temporal significance of the divine name disclosed to Moses. This is already seen in Isaiah 44:6 and 48:12 and emerges further in post-biblical Jewish texts, such as Targum Pseudo-Jonathan Ex 3:14 (and T.P-J Deut 32:39). John’s strategy of identifying Jesus by means of the divine name fits into a broader pattern in the New Testament (cf 1 Cor 8:6, Phil 2:9), but the closest parallel to this specific example lies in John’s Apocalypse, where the titles used of Jesus parallel those used of the Lord and appear to be derived from the name of Exodus 3:14, read in relation to the Isaianic “I am” statements: “the Alpha and the Omega, the First and the Last” (Rev 1:8 and 22:13), “the one who was, and is, and is to come” (Rev 1:8, 4:8). As in Revelation, the temporal dimensions of the name are made explicit in the Fourth Gospel, most obviously in John 8:58 (“Before Abraham was, I am”), requiring the reader to reflect on the temporal significance of the identification of Jesus. By examining the biblical and postbiblical texts that reflect such speculation about the divine name, I will argue that the key to the “Name Christology” of the Fourth Gospel and the Apocalypse lies in a concept of divine “presence” that transcends time but that accommodates itself to its strictures. Jesus is identified with (or as) the divine presence or glory, in all of its temporal manifestations, but in a way that demands of the reader reflection on the specific temporality of the Incarnation (John 1:14). A proper recognition of this allows a more nuanced understanding of what this particular apocalypse means for the history of Israel and the covenants, problematizing some accounts of Johannine theology. The findings concerning “Name Christology” will also have significance for other parts of the New Testament, notably the Pauline texts: proper sensitivity to the pattern of identifying Jesus with the divine name highlights problems with apocalyptic readings of Paul that sever the Christ event from the history of Israel and the covenants, but also challenges simple “salvation-history” approaches.
|
Intertextuality in Mark 11–12
Program Unit: Markan Literary Sources
Dennis R. MacDonald, Claremont School of Theology
Mark 11–12 is a clever rewriting of the lost Gospel (Q or Q+) modeled after sections from Homer's Odyssey. The proposed paper will begin with evidence that the author was indebted to the lost Gospel (which I prefer to call the Logoi of Jesus). It then discusses Mark's reliance on Od. 6-7 for the triumphal entry and Od. 22 for the cleansing of the temple.
|
Do We Have the Opening of the Urdeuteronomium?
Program Unit: Book of Deuteronomy
Nathan MacDonald, University of Cambridge
In this paper I will contest the claim that Deut 6.4-5 is the opening of the Urdeuteronomium. Drawing on T. Veijola’s proposal for a Bundestheologische Redaktion I will demonstrate that there are grounds for thinking that the Shema did not belong to the earliest version of Deuteornomy. I will then offer some brief suggestions about the earliest framing of the Deuteronomic law.
|
Priestly Prerogatives in Numbers 18 and Ezekiel 44
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
Nathan MacDonald, University of Cambridge
The instructions about priestly dues in Ezekiel 44 and Numbers 18 overlap to a significant degree, and this suggests that a literary relationship exists between the two texts. Wellhausen argued that since Numbers 18 distinguishes sharply between the dues owed priests and those owed to Levites, it must be a later composition than Ezekiel 44 which Wellhausen argued had first introduced the distinction between clerical ranks. This perspective has been championed by many scholars since Wellhausen’s time, mostly recently by Achenbach in his exhaustive redaction-critical analysis of the book of Numbers.
Such reconstructions of the compositional history need to be re-examined and, I will argue, the reverse position taken: Ezekiel 44 presupposes and utilizes Numbers 18. To substantiate this argument I will proceed in three steps. First, I will demonstrate that Numbers 18 is a compendium of pentateuchal instructions about priestly and levitical dues. The composer of Numbers 18 utilizes numerous Pentateuchal texts, and other parts of the Pentateuch provide all the necessary textual pieces by which the compendium on priestly dues in Numbers 18 could have been compiled. Second, I will show Numbers 18 was interpreted in Ezekiel 44, and how certain features of Ezek 44.28–31 can only be explained as exegetical reuse of Numbers 18 and other pentateuchal texts. Conversely, I will argue that it is difficult to see how the writer of Numbers 18 could have written what he did on the basis of Ezekiel 44. Third, I will argue that the position advocated by Wellhausen and Achenbach cannot explain why the instructions on priestly dues originated, whilst a reason lies immediately to hand if we recognize that Numbers 18 was the earliest list of priestly emoluments.
|
Re-collection of Tourah Codex V, Didymos, and Its Codicology
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Roger T. Macfarlane, Brigham Young University
P.BYU-Didymos is an essentially unknown portion of the Tourah Codex Didymos, discovered in 1941 and now disseminated into several collections worldwide. Because it has not been published beyond a record on Trismegistos, few scholars know anything at all of this important holding in the University Library at Brigham Young University. The Library acquired one signature of the Tourah Codex V in the 1980s. A single leaf from the same codex was acquired soon afterwards. The Librarian purchased the text knowing it contained part of Didymos the Blind’s Commentary on the Psalms.
The Tourah Horde was discovered in 1941. Like much of the rest of the discovery, Codex V was immediately dismantled and scattered. This Turah Codex is comprised of 22 signatures. The publication of P.BYU-Didymos will revise substantially what is known about the structure the Codex V. For instance, where all scholars since Groenewald have assumed that signature ? (eta) was a quaternion, it turns out to be a quinion. And because nearly five decades have passed since it has been raised in print, the question about the internal leaves of ?? (iota stigma) must be clarified and restated. One signature is still at large, its location unknown to the general scholarly community (I believe). Reckoning these numbers, Groenewald and the scholars at Cologne, whence the primary of impulse for editing the text of Codex V emanated in the 1960s and beyond, calculated the total pages of text at 353. As it turns out, the publication of P.BYU-Didymos will push that number upward by 16 pages, as Groenewald’s numbers are one signature short.
Reviewing the holdings of Codex V in signatures scatteed between Geneva, Cairo, Cologne, London, and Provo, I hope to make new sense of the work’s codicological structure.
|
Defining Israel and Dealing with the Outside World in the Aramaic and Sectarian Texts from Qumran
Program Unit: Qumran
Daniel A. Machiela, McMaster University
As part of an ongoing project focused on the Aramaic texts from Qumran, this paper will examine and compare views of the true Israel and outsiders in a cross-section of Sectarian Hebrew literature from Qumran (e.g., the Serekh texts, War Scroll, and Hodayot) and Aramaic texts (e.g., Tobit, Testament of Qahat, and Genesis Apocryphon). The Sectarian Hebrew scrolls typically define the true Israel as a relatively small, circumscribed group. The Aramaic texts, however, often reflect a much broader construal, and portray idealized Jews interacting, cautiously but successfully, with the foreign ruling power structure. Though the sectarians presumably kept, copied, and read the Aramaic literature, these two very different approaches to Israel and outsiders speak to deeper differences between the two clusters of texts, and the Jewish groups behind them. The more open outlook of the Aramaic texts - especially when read against the Sectarian writings - help us to better situate the Aramaic texts within Second Temple period Jewish history and society, carrying further the work of Milik, Segert, Bickerman, Wacholder, Dimant, Tigchelaar, and others, who hold the Aramaic writings to be both non- and pre-Sectarian. It may also help us to better address the reason these texts were composed in Aramaic, and not Hebrew. At the same time, we are confronted with the interesting question of what the sectarians took away from a group of texts that in ways espoused views divergent from their own.
|
Seeing a Way in the Wilderness: Visually Oriented Rhetoric in Hebrews 3–4
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Scott D. Mackie, Independent Scholar
In the last two decades, scholars of classical literature and ancient philosophy have increasingly recognized and fruitfully explored the “vision-centered” perspective which is evident in a variety of contexts in Greco-Roman life and literature. Of particular interest to this essay is the manner in which Greco-Roman authors and orators responded to this predominant visual orientation by appealing to the visual imaginations of their audiences. This they accomplished primarily by the rhetorical practices of ekphrasis and enargeia, vivid descriptions of subject matter that not only engaged their audiences’ visual imaginations, but were reputed to possess the power to emotionally transport them into the midst of the scene being described. The author of the Epistle to the Hebrews was by all appearances well-versed in these visually oriented rhetorical techniques. Throughout his “word of exhortation” he deploys vivid ekphrases of his subject matter, with the apparent intention of stirring the visual imaginations of the addressed Christian community and substantively involving them in the sacred drama being described. Hebrews 3–4 is representative of this effort. After beginning with an exhortation to “visualize” Jesus, “the apostle and high priest of our confession” (3:1; cf. 2:9; 12:2), the imagery of building households reminds the community of their role and responsibilities as members in the “household” of God (3:2-6). Interspersed throughout 3:7–4:13 are texts imbued with vivid emotional and embodied texture, which effectively transport the community into the midst of Israel’s wilderness wanderings. In contrast to Israel’s failure to cross the Jordan and enter God’s “rest” (3:19; 4:6-11), the community’s confident entry into the promised land and God’s eschatological rest is enacted through the exhortation of 4:14-16, as the community mimetically follows Jesus in his ascent into the heavenly sanctuary. This succession of pictorial tableaux will help the community re-envision their conditions of suffering – as befitting a pilgrimage of faith – and the benefits of maintaining an enduring commitment to Jesus and his “household.” Reinforcing the visual orientation of this passage are four calls to exercise faith-informed sight. In addition to the programmatic call to visualize Jesus in 3:1, the author’s exhortation to “look closely” at their fellow “siblings” in 3:12 heightens awareness of their interdependence and mutual responsibility while wandering in the wilderness. They are also told in 3:19 that they can “see” Israel in the wilderness, and in 4:11-13 that they are standing under the gaze of the all-seeing God. This visually attentive reading of Heb 3–4 does not diminish the importance of aural/oral elements in the text (cf. 3:5-7, 15-16; 4:2-8, 13-14). Rather, it acknowledges that the two senses function in a complimentary manner, as the veracity of the aural/oral elements is at least partially confirmed by sight. Like Israel in the wilderness, the community has seen God’s works and heard his words for “forty years” (2:4; 3:9-10). However, the author of Hebrews is confident that his “word of exhortation” will help effect a different outcome this time.
|
Ptolemaic Politics and the Performance of Ezekiel’s Exagoge
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Jonathan MacLellan, The University of Texas at Austin
Scholars regularly debate whether Ezekiel the Tragedian’s Exagoge was written for performance, and if so, in what social settings. This debate usually focuses primarily on formal aspects of the tragedy, with scholars sometimes concluding that it was not staged because of its divergence from Aristotelian theory and Classical precedents, or because its speeches are more “descriptive” than “performative” (Rozik 2013). We argue, however, that the question of the Exagoge’s performance cannot be decided according to formal qualifications alone, especially given our limited knowledge of the conventions of Hellenistic tragedy. Instead, building on recent studies by Pierluigi Lanfranchi (2006) and Rachel Bryant Davies (2008), who view the tragedy as performable in association with the Judaean Passover festival, we call particular attention to the social and political functions that such a performance would have had in Ptolemaic Alexandria. Drawing on theories of performance and practice, and in particular, Catherine Bell’s understanding of “redemptive hegemony” as the way that practices simultaneously convey an understanding of the ordering of power in society and a vision for strategic empowerment (Bell 2009), our paper consists of two major sections. In the first, we survey an array of epigraphic, literary, and other forms of evidence indicating that theatrical performances were highly politically significant in the Hellenistic period, often functioning as propaganda for the Hellenistic royal dynasties. In the second, we interrogate the ways that the performance of the relations of “King Pharaoh” to the Hebrews and Egyptians in the Exagoge, and the figurations of God, Moses, and the phoenix as kings, reflect and critique the Ptolemaic kingship through the same performative medium usually exploited as a means of royal acclamation. Bell, Catherine. Ritual Theory, Ritual Practice (2d ed.; Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2009). Bryant Davies, Rachel. “Reading Ezekiel’s Exagoge: Tragedy, Sacrificial Ritual, and the Midrashic Tradition,” GRBS 48 (2008): 393-415. Lanfranchi, Pierluigi. L’Exagoge d’Ezéchiel le Tragique: Introduction, texte, traduction et commentaire (Leiden: Brill, 2006). Rozik, Eli. Jewish Drama and Theater: From Rabbinical Intolerance to Secular Liberalism (Chicago: Sussex, 2013).
|
Dreams and Love Stories at the Tomb: An Early Endymion Sarcophagus from Asia Minor
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Sarah Madole, CUNY Borough of Manhatten Community College
Illuminated by the moon-goddess, Selene, and by flickering torchlight, the theme is love, sleep, and the realm of dreams, and the setting is the dead of night. According to one mythological tradition, which had its roots in western Asia Minor, the moon-goddess was beset with the affliction of Love. As a cure Selene induced the mortal Endymion, her beloved, to drink a potion that resulted in eternal sleep, which can be understood as a metaphor for death. On one of the earliest Roman sarcophagi to carry this imagery, which has been associated with the workshops of Ephesos, the sculptor has depicted an overturned jar, recently emptied of its contents, in order to provide an even more immediate temporal setting for the scene. This pastoral idyll and dreamscape is juxtaposed with the stark brutality depicted on the sarcophagus short sides, where animals engage in a violent combat, also interpreted as a metaphor for death.
This paper offers a new reading of this dynamic funerary iconography. The ancient observer may have recalled the violent agon of Love, the battlefield depicted in romantic epics, and in more accessible forms of popular entertainment (e.g., pantomime), which may have inspired this mythological and agonistic pairing on the Endymion sarcophagus. In the so-called novels Erotic machinations often transpired under the guise of darkness at all-night religious festivals and in dreams. The sarcophagus imagery can be “read” in light of such literary sources, in which dreams relate to the liminal world and combat acts as a metaphor for love; these are complimentary approaches to the theme of death. The ritualistic function of the sarcophagus is strengthened by the iconography depicted on the fourth panel: garlands, bucrania and libation bowls, implements used in commemorative contexts at the tomb. Unlike the baroque compositions of the later Endymion sarcophagi manufactured en masse in Rome, this early example invites the quiet contemplation of a broad spectrum of human experiences, utterly suitable for a funerary monument intended for repeated viewing by the survivors of the deceased.
|
A Call for Interdisciplinary Historical-Methodology in the Study of Ancient Israel
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Aren Maeir, Bar-Ilan University
The study of “Ancient Israel” is a dynamic and multi-faceted research endeavor, which is a field that has in the recent past, and is still going through major transformations. This is due, to a large extent, to methodological developments and new data from the various sub-fields which contribute to the understanding of “Ancient Israel”. These developments and data derive from, e.g., the various branches of biblical research, the wide-ranging spectrum of ancient Near Eastern philology, and the ever-growing database and more exact analytic perspectives of the full-range of modern archaeological research.
The enormous breadth of knowledge, methods and perspectives which are encompassed in this cannot be overstated. Gone are the days of the polymath scholars who can fully-control the entire gamut of relevant research – at least while staying fully aware of the latest developments and perspectives in all these various subfields.
Time and again, attempts to generate understandings of “Ancient Israel” – particularly those of broad synthetic scope, are the work of scholars whose expertise lies in one or two of the specific facets of this broad spectrum of knowledge – but at the same time, not being fully up-to-date, and sufficiently “in control” of other aspects of the relevant knowledge base and analytical toolbox. Just as one would not accept a physicist who uses outdated chemistry or biology, so, a Biblicist who is not up-to-date in the minutiae of archaeology (or vice-a-versa), is not be accepted. These lacunae clearly have an effect on the robustness of attempted interpretations.
In light of this situation, I believe it is imperative to see more inter-disciplinary collaborative efforts in the study of “Ancient Israel” – so that a more complete and up-to-date panoply of methodologies can be brought to the forefront in such studies. Just as most modern “hard science” is carried out using inter- and multi-disciplinary team perspectives, similar approaches are needed in the study of “Ancient Israel” as well. Similar to the inter-disciplinary research that is seen more in more in archaeology, a desideratum should be that we see more and more multi-disciplinary teams joining together in the study of “Ancient Israel.”
In this lecture I will attempt to bring some examples of some problematic interpretations due to lack of broad enough perspectives, as well as some which attempt to bridge some of these difficulties.
|
Were Sacrifices Offered at Qumran? The Animal Bone Deposits Reconsidered
Program Unit: Qumran
Jodi Magness, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
Most scholars agree that the Qumran sect refused to participate in the cult in the Jerusalem temple because they considered it polluted, and awaited the day when they would gain control of the temple and offer sacrifices according to their own interpretation of biblical law. In the interim, the members of the sect constituted themselves as a temple and considered participation in their communal meals as a substitute for participation in the temple sacrifices. In this paper I wish to challenge this view (which I also endorsed until now), in light of a reconsideration of the animal bone deposits from Qumran. Roland de Vaux found deposits concentrated in the open air spaces, mainly on the northwest and southeast sides of the site, that is, in the vicinity of the two dining rooms (L77 on the south and L120-123 on the north). The bones that were analyzed belonged to sheep and goats, lambs or kids, calves, and cows or oxen. The bones had been taken apart and the flesh was no longer attached to them when they were collected. De Vaux concluded that the bones must be the remains of meals, since all were clean but some were charred, indicating that the meat was boiled or roasted. They were placed on the ground between large potsherds or inside jars and covered with little or no earth.
Most scholars including de Vaux reject the identification of the animal bone deposits as sacrificial debris because there are no remains of an altar at Qumran, and sectarian literature provides no clear indication that members offered animal sacrifices outside the Jerusalem temple. According to this view, the sect did not reject animal sacrifices altogether but refused to participate in the cult in the Jerusalem temple because they considered it polluted. However, deposits of animal bones and pottery mixed with ash representing sacrificial refuse and consumption debris are characteristic of ancient sanctuaries around the Mediterranean world and Near East. Published descriptions of deposits from other sanctuaries leave little doubt that the animal bone deposits at Qumran are indeed sacrificial refuse, including consumption debris associated with sacrifices. Furthermore, records from Roland de Vaux’s excavations suggest that in Period Ib (first century B.C.E.) an altar was located in an open air space on the northwest side of the site. The possibility that animal sacrifices were offered at Qumran is supported by legislation in sectarian works and in non-sectarian works that were considered authoritative by the sect. This evidence suggests that the sect observed the laws of the desert camp with the tabernacle in its midst (a more accurate analogy than to a substitute temple), including offering animal sacrifices as mandated by biblical law.
|
Counterintuitive Mischwesen: A Cognitive Approach to the Iconography of Hybrid Creatures
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Brett E. Maiden, Emory University
In The Savage Mind, the anthropologist Claude Lévi-Strauss famously suggested that animals are “good to think.” This paper argues that hybrid animals, or Mischwesen, are equally good, if not better, to think—especially when it comes to the domain of religion. The material evidence from the ancient world is replete with visual images of hybrid monsters, composite demons, and mixed divine beings. In recent years, biblical and ancient Near Eastern scholars have increasingly turned to the rich iconographical record to trace the diachronic development of religious concepts, as well as the cultural mechanisms that facilitate the spread of certain visual motifs (discussed extensively by Othmar Keel and Christoph Uehlinger). One area that has not yet been explored, however, is the role that cognitive mechanisms play in the process of cultural transmission. This paper fills this gap by considering the iconography of hybrid creatures in Egyptian and Mesopotamian art from the perspective of two current cognitive frameworks: Dan Sperber’s epidemiological approach to cultural representations and Pascal Boyer’s theory of minimally counterintuitive concepts. Utilizing these theories, I suggest that culturally-specific depictions of hybrid animals—no matter how fantastic—exhibit a core set of properties, which helps to account for their stability across geographical and temporal distances. Overall, this paper demonstrates that an informed understanding of human cognition offers a fresh interdisciplinary lens on the Mischwesen iconography of the ancient Near East.
|
The Rhetorical Hermeneutics of Topoi in Sociorhetorical Interpretation: Burke Reading Augustine Reading Genesis
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Steven Mailloux, Loyola Marymount University
In The Rhetoric of Religion (1961) Kenneth Burke provides a logological reading of Augustine’s Confessions and the first three chapters of Genesis. In so doing, Burke argues that we can learn a great deal about humans as symbol-using animals by closely examining the rhetorical texture of theological discourses in narrative form. That is, Burke proposes a kind of theotropic logology--words about words about God. As he does this through a reading of Augustine and Genesis, he completes a move begun in A Rhetoric of Motives (1950), transforming an Aristotelian system of topics into his own theory of terms. In this paper I will work out the implications of this transformation, examining the rhetorical application of his interpretive theory of terminology. Then I will compare (what might also be called) Burke’s rhetorical hermeneutics to the use of topics in Socio-Rhetorical Interpretation, noting the latter’s explicit referencing of Burke and its implicit relationships to Burke’s theotropic logology of terms as topics.
|
Identity: Borders and the Praxes of Being in Christ
Program Unit: Postcolonial Studies and Biblical Studies
Simon Mainwaring, The School For Ministry, San Diego Episcopal Diocese
This paper is interested in exploring the relationship between the ancient rhetoric around identity found in the undisputed epistles of Paul and current day attempts to negotiate migrant and borderland identity in the global village. Using postcolonial theory as a lens through which to analyze both, these ancient, and postmodern praxes of identity formation and re-formation, I will explore how the motif of ‘being in Christ’ offers a conceptual and theological framework for resisting hegemonic and colonial structures of identity imposition.
Paul’s letters will be mined for the ways by which they are suggestive of practices within Pauline communities that coalesce around issues of identity. Specifically, a number of themes related to the concept of ‘being in Christ’ will be explored: how identity as it relates to the Lordship of Christ and the lordship of Caesar is negotiated, how a kenotic ethic of relationally in community life might offer a postcolonial strategy within a colonial landscape, and how ambiguity is embraced in identity formation within Pauline communities that hybridizes but does not obliterate previous identities.
Patterns of praxes among migrants and those who straddle a borderland between the global north and south will be studied in terms of how postcolonial concepts of resistance to hegemonic power can be seen to be exercised in lived realities. Postcolonial theory has been critiqued for being too abstracted from the political realities of its application in society. This paper will offer a response to such critiques by directly analyzing studies of migrant and borderland praxes through the lens of postcolonial theory and then bring those praxes into conversation with the communities of the ancient apostle Paul.
In closing, this paper will ask how these ancient and postmodern postcolonial practitioners might offer a fertile ground for biblical studies to engage with the struggles that millions face in relation to their identity in today’s world.
|
Biblioblogging: A Bridge for Church and Academy
Program Unit: Blogger and Online Publication
Kimberly Majeski, Anderson University (IN)
The relationship between the academy and church can be tedious. For those of us who have studied and prepared in the service of the church it can be discouraging to find resistance from many within Christendom to our scholarship. It becomes crucial for us to find ways to break down barriers that exist for so many Christians who baulk at biblical scholarship and favor only a devotional approach to scripture. Since the twenty minute sermon is no longer the platform for deep biblical exposition, perhaps a newer frontier is biblioblogging and social media. This paper will address the “why” and “how.” Why is it important for us to forge new methods of connection with persons in the church who wish to grow in their faith and knowledge; how do we create an effective online presence of resident theologian in effort to equip and inspire the church while maintaining the interest and integrity of the academy. Topics such as cultural literacy, sexy leads, further study links, online partnerships, accountability, blog etiquette and ethics will be explored in detail.
|
Virgins of a Virginal Paradise: The Use of Synecdoche in Surah Rahman
Program Unit: Linguistic, Literary, and Thematic Perspectives on the Qur’anic Corpus (IQSA)
D.S. Adnan Majid, University of California-San Diego
Nowhere in the Quran is the imagery of heavenly virgins and sex arguably more explicit than in Surah Rahman, where mention of the qa?irat a?-?arf (55:56) and the ?ur maq?urat (55:72) is followed by the refrain "lam ya?mithhunna insun qablahum wa la jann" (55:56 & 74). This is most apparent in the translation of Hilali and Khan, where the verse is rendered, "no man nor jinn ya?mithhunna (has opened their hymens with sexual intercourse) before them." Though one aim of this imagery may be to stir believers' sensual desire for paradise, I argue that the imagery also serves a deeper literary effect - one of synecdoche where the greater paradise itself assumes virginity. This interpretation lies in an analysis of the recurrent theme of dualism that pervades Surah Rahman and its jarring absence in the verses concerning heavenly females. For instance, not only is the chapter's most famous refrain, "fabi ayyi ala'i rabbikuma tukaddhiban," addressed to the dual, the chapter presents two easts, two wests (55:17), and two seas (55:19). For the God-fearing, there are two gardens (55:46) besides which are two others (55:62). In the first pair of gardens (fihima) are two flowing springs (55:50), and in them both (again fihima) are fruits, two by two (55:52). Yet when the subject of the verses shifts to the heavenly females, the gardens lose their dual nature and suddenly become feminine themselves with the use of the adverbial fihinna. I argue that this sudden shift in the garden's grammatical character introduces an intentional ambiguity into the Quran's text, for the feminine object of ya?mithhunna now may refer to either of two feminine antecedents - 1) the females or 2) the gardens in which they reside. I further argue that application of the verb ya?mith (the imperfect of ?amatha) to the gardens (jannat) is fully consistent with the classical usage of the term - Edward Lane records in his lexicon the statement "ma ?amatha dha l-marta'a qablana a?ad" ("No one touched this place of pasturing, or this pasture, before us") (Book 1, p 1878). The chapter's imagery of virginal females thus serves as a synecdoche, a reference to the virginal nature of paradise itself, and shows that the Quran's use of imagery is intentioned and far more complex than the media hysteria over "72 virgins" or misinterpreted "grapes" would suggest.
|
Herem: Post-colonial Critique, Genocide, and the Politics of Reading?
Program Unit: Postcolonial Studies and Biblical Studies
Robert D. Maldonado, California State University - Fresno
The ban has had a long history of problematic interpretation ranging from not noticing that it might be problematic, endorsing as properly divinely sanctioned, through various applications to indigenous or differently religious peoples. Post-colonial perspectives, particularly in the explicit foregrounding of contexts of the exercising of imperial power and in the critique of simplistic and reductionist binaries, bring valuable lenses through which to re-examine the herem and its history of interpretation and application. This paper argues that a post-colonial optic problematizes the politics of reading Joshua to such an extent that renders a decision about the meaning of the text difficult if not impossible. This deep ambiguation of these texts casts the issues back into the contemporary world with renewed sensitivity to the dynamics of imperial power, its problematic implications for identities, and the impossibility of binaries to accommodate adequately such fraught circumstances. Not incidentally, this intensifies the need to attend to the politics of our readings of the traditions that have contributed to the dynamics of our contemporary worlds (and continue so to do) and the readings of those dynamics themselves. The final section of the paper examines herem in connection 1) to the paradoxical blotting out of memory of the Amalekites (Exod 17:14) which is to be delivered in the hearing of Joshua and its subsequent trajectory into 1 Samuel and the rise of monarchic institutions in Israel, and 2) with the conquest/conquista of the western hemisphere by European imperial powers.
|
Teaching Upper Division Writing through Literature of the New Testament
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Robert D. Maldonado, California State University - Fresno
For 23 years I have been teaching a Literature of the New Testament course within a Philosophy Department at a Comprehensive Public University. Passing this course with a C or better satisfies the university requirement for upper division writing. This requirement across the university also is a concern for being a bottleneck for student graduation success. More than half of my students are first generation college students and my university is a federally designated Hispanic Serving and Asian American Native American Pacific Islander-Serving Institution. This context and the pedagogical challenges that go with it have forced me, especially within the last decade, to rethink how I can utilize Biblical Studies to maximize the environment in which my students can learn. To that end, I have focused on getting the students to think about reading as the flip side of writing, that the things they have to do in order to read/interpret texts are similar to the things they have to put in texts for their future readers. I divide the course traditionally into letters (Pauline) and narratives (gospel), focusing the letters of Paul, however, on the rhetoric of his suasion relative to goals of his letters and on the gospels relative to the meaningful structure given by their narrative construction. As a related experience, I share the writing pedagogical strategies I employ in an intensive summer version of the course which focuses on the Jesus story in Gospel and Film. Here I explore with the students how the particular versions of the tradition history within the Gospels as well as in the ongoing film tradition demonstrate the reading/writing strategic relationship between the particularity of expression and meaning. This again utilizes the conceptualization of reading being the flipside of writing and getting the students to think about how the particularity of their expression in their own writing makes a difference for meaning. Along the way, students seem to learn even more about Biblical Studies than they had in my previous more traditional iterations of the course.
|
Oral Law and the ‘Adoption’ of the Adoption Formula in Biblical Literature
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Alice Mandell, University of California-Los Angeles
The adoption formula in biblical texts has been discussed primarily in relation to the dynastic promise to David whereby members of the Davidic line derive legitimacy as the adopted sons of YHWH. The claim to divine paternity is a well-established phenomenon in ANE literature that finds parallels in royal propaganda and commemorative texts from all periods. The adoption formula is typically approached as a textual tradition that finds its way into Israelite literature from Mesopotamian legal traditions—the assumption being that this was a textual borrowing. However, as will be demonstrated, the adoption formula was essentially an oral formulation that was incorporated into a plurality of genres that include legal, narrative, liturgical, and prophetic texts. I first examine the use of this oral formula in Mesopotamian texts and then discuss its various reformulations in biblical literature. I argue that these reconfigurations of the adoption formula in biblical literature did not draw upon one particular written law or textual usage, but rather upon the general knowledge of this formula in Israelite culture. The adoption formula was widely known as an oral formulation linked to family law, replete with the associations of familial obligations, feuds, and inheritance that were a part of daily Israelite life. This formula was then re-contextualized in biblical literature as a metaphor for YHWH’s adoption and consequent rejection of the Israelite monarchy and Israel as a whole.
|
Responding to the Search for Women's Voices in the Psalms
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Carleen Mandolfo, Colby College
This paper will respond to the preceding papers given in the session.
|
Thysia, Hestiatoria, and Macellum: The Example of Thasos
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Jean-Yves Marc, University of Strasbourg
The resumption of excavations in the monumental center of Thasos in 1996, helped to uncover a vast commercial complex consisting mainly of several porticoes and colonnades extending southeast and southwest of the political agora . Among these architectural entities , we recognized a food market. The discovery of a building so specifically Roman is, in itself, a surprise in Macedonia and Achaia, where evidence for these buildings is quite rare. At Thasos, we are fortunate to have a stratigraphic context, with levels of occupation in different phases of development of the building. The vast abundance of animal and fish remains, and evidence for butchering and leather work corroborate the interpretation of the building as a place that welcomed, at least in part, a meat market and probably fish. At Thasos, the thysia on the altar, the banquet at the hestiatorion, and the sale of meat in the macellum are articulated in a clear system, which reflects the interdependence of these different components.
|
The Forum at Philippi in the Roman Imperial Period: The Evolution of a Civic Center
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Jean-Yves Marc, University of Strasbourg
The Forum at Philippi was not built on the site of the city’s Hellenistic Agora. Rather, the Forum was built as an entirely new project in the imperial period, with two major phases during the reigns of Claudius (41-54 CE) and of Marcus Aurelius (161-180 CE). At the height of its development the Forum occupied 10% of the city’s surface area and spread across successive terraces. The terraces were separated by the Via Egnatia, which served as the colony’s decumanus maximus, and the upper terrace was devoted to temples while and the lower terrace was given over to civic architecture and space. In spite of the fact that the Forum was an entirely new project, its architecture, design, and building techniques present a paradoxical combination of imported Roman and local Hellenistic features. This paper explores the reasons for these surprising developments by comparing them with other Roman colonies in the provinces of Achaia and Macedonia, and with local developments in Thessaloniki and Thasos.
|
Queer(ing) Children of God: Sideways Angles on a Pauline Metaphor?
Program Unit: LGBTI/Queer Hermeneutics
Joseph A. Marchal, Ball State University
The figure of the child features prominently, not only in contemporary religious (often right-leaning) settings, but also (and perhaps surprisingly) in queer, not (exactly) religious studies. While Lee Edelman’s bold anti-social thesis and J. Halberstam’s reflections on queer cultures’ “stretched-out adolescence” are both provocative in their own ways on the subject, Kathryn Bond Stockton’s sideways looks at the “queer child” present some of the most extensive considerations of the strangeness of children, historically, rhetorically, and even theoretically. Using Stockton’s view of this kind of “growing sideways” (as opposed to up, or any other directions), then, allows this paper to re-evaluate the function of fictive kinship in the assembly communities that received Paul’s letters. Though I aim to resist the infantilizing rhetorics of letters like 1 Corinthians, in keeping with both feminist and queer approaches to the letters, I also insist on an altered focus specifically on the terms for children, rather than those for siblings (or “brethren”) more prominent in Pauline epistles and interpretations. From this vantage point it becomes easier to recognize how the letters try to suspend, but cannot quite seem to let go of hierarchical families, patriarchal prerogatives, or continued claims of inheritance. By restaging the potential traffic between these biblical and queer settings, this paper demonstrates what peculiar things happen to the delays or deferrals characteristic of queers and to the critique of reproductive futurism when one encounters rather ancient communities already in strange relations to concepts of gender and generation, family and the future. Contemporary apocalyptically-tinged claims about such figures can be matched, albeit dissonantly, by such audiences living in a liminal, “already, but not yet” shaped by apocalyptic figurations (including of them as children). Rather than proceeding through vertical structures of power or more linear conceptions of time, this analysis can tip both of these overloaded ideas on their side and provide new angles on how, in spite of and through Pauline rhetorics, the assemblies developed, subsisted, and operated “sideways.”
|
Working with the "Notes on the Masorah Parva" Section of BHQ
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
David Marcus, Jewish Theological Seminary of America
This is the third section of the workshop on the Masorah Parva. It will concentrate on the "Notes on the Masorah Parva" Section of BHQ. This presentation will give some background on this section of BHQ, including its design and how notes were selected for elaboration.
|
Who Are ‘Your Fathers’ in Deut 30:5? On Narrative Frame Breaks, Reader Communication, and Pragmatics in Deuteronomy
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Dominik Markl, Pontificio Istituto Biblico
The meaning of the reference to Israel’s ‘fathers’ in Deuteronomy has been intensely discussed, especially by Thomas Römer (OBO 99) and Norbert Lohfink (OBO 111). Yet, the significance of the reference to ‘your fathers’ in Deut 30:5 (and v. 9) has not been fully appreciated. Although both authors in their analyses principally agree that the fathers who had ‘possessed the land’ should be identified with the Moab generation, whom Moses addresses in Deuteronomy, they do not reflect on the narrative frame break due to this identification. How can the addressed audience (‘you’) be identical with their own fathers (‘your fathers’)? And what significance does this obvious contradiction have? This paper will argue that this (potential) frame break is a key technique of the reader communication and pragmatics of Deuteronomy’s exilic or post-exilic form. Deut 30 addresses readers who have experienced Exile and are supposed to re-establish ‘Israel’ in the promised land. It is they who are meant to make a decision between life and death (Deut 30:15-20) and thus (re-)enter the Moab covenant that Moses urges ‘Israel’ to enter in Deut 29-30. This observation will be contextualized with other instances of potential frame breaks that are employed to serve reader communication in Deuteronomy.
|
Inscribing Power: Curse Tablets and Temple Building in the Corinthian Sanctuary of Demeter
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Jill E. Marshall, Emory University
After the Roman colonization and resettlement of Corinth (44 B.C.E.), cultic activity was slow to return to the Sanctuary of Demeter on the north slope of Acrocorinth. In the mid-first century C.E., the earliest activities were ritual practices involving terracotta lamps and inscribed lead tablets in a small room on the lower terrace. The tablets, recently published by Ronald Stroud in Corinth 18.6 (2013), record petitions of women and men to various gods (Demeter, Hermes, Ananke), target opponents or unrequited loves for “binding” or “destruction,” and request justice from the gods. The tablets include linguistic and graphic strategies that were common in magical tablets and papyri and thought to address the gods in their languages—voces magicae, invocative formulae, jumbled letters or obscure ways of writing, and rhythmic and supplicatory language. About a quarter of a century after this ritual activity began, new building occurred in the sanctuary precinct. The Roman inhabitants of Corinth built three small temples on the upper terrace and a staircase and entrance to the terrace. One of the temples had a mosaic floor dedication that named a temple-warden and a “priestess of Neotera.” In this paper, I analyze these two activities, temple building and curse tablets, as distinct methods of inscribing power—religious, social, and/or political—in the Sanctuary on the slope of Acrocorinth. In this sanctuary, disempowered individuals used obscure ways of speaking and writing to demonstrate their power to communicate with gods and acquire divine action. At the same time, prominent individuals with political power shaped the spatial orientation and architecture of the Sanctuary. I investigate the potential tension between the two activities and the resulting views of Demeter cult and communication with human beings and gods.
|
The Violence of Prophecy: Female Prophets and the Force of Gods and Men
Program Unit: Society for Ancient Mediterranean Religions
Jill E. Marshall, Emory University
In ancient Greek and Latin texts, inspired prophecy, especially when voiced by a woman, can be a violent process. Literary depictions of institutional oracles (Delphi, Dodona, Didyma) and extemporaneous prophecy (Cassandra, Sibyl) include elements of violence upon the prophet. In the case of oracular institutions, male inquirers sometimes threaten, assault, rape, or kill a priestess who refuses to prophesy or who gives unfavorable oracles. In Sibylline traditions and legends about Cassandra, violence upon the prophet more often comes from the god who inspires her. The god causes the Sibyl’s body to burn, shatter, or be whipped. In this paper, I gather and interpret narratives in which female prophets are assaulted or forced to prophesy by inquirers or gods. In reading this material, I ask historical, literary, and religious questions: In terms of oracular prophets, is there a historical change in how they or the institution is viewed that allows an increase in violence? What does violence reveal about the religious function of the oracle? Do authors use violence to comment on how prophecy works (theologically, socially, or politically) or is the focus more on a character, place, event, or time period? How are the assaults by men related to depictions of prophecy as a god violently taking control of the body? Fear of vulnerability is central to the impulse to seek oracular aid, and this fear leads to violence—whether by taking the process in one’s own hands or imagining the prophet as the vulnerable body upon which the god works.
|
Hospitality: The Nexus between Law and Love
Program Unit: Bible and Ethics
Mary J. Marshall, Murdoch University
The significance of relationships in the Hebrew Bible is revealed in the Decalogue (Exod 20:1–17; Deut 5:6–21) in that the commands include both Israel’s obligations toward God, and individuals’ obligations toward one another. Underlying these commandments is the belief that maintenance of their social structure depended on love of God, and loving care of each other. The frequent references to the Israelites’ liberation from slavery suggest that their obedience to the law is a response of gratitude and love. There are also many reminders that they were strangers in Egypt and this factor is employed in enjoinders to care for resident aliens, as well as the needy. Clearly, there are strong links between law and love in the Hebrew Bible, as emphasised in the commands to love God (Deut 6:5) and neighbour (Lev 19:18). The complementarity of the concepts is demonstrated by reviewing the ethic of hospitality in section 2. The term hospitality is defined as love of strangers, and used to refer to provision of sustenance, shelter, and clothing to those from beyond one’s normal social group, without any expectation of reciprocity. I will discuss Abraham and Job, and show that by the first century CE, hospitality such as theirs was an indicator of righteousness, i.e. of obedience to the law. Section 3 then considers relevant New Testament texts, particularly focusing on Jesus’ summary of the law (Mark 12:29–31); his friendship with toll collectors, regarded as regenerate in view of their hospitality; and his radical call to love of enemies (Matt 5:43–48; Luke 6:27–36). To conclude, I will consider the references to loving one’s neighbour as fulfilment of the law (Rom 13:8–10; Gal 5:14; Jas 2:8), and comment on the failure of early Christians to attain the standard of hospitality advocated by Jesus.
|
Eucharistic Liturgies and the Historical Jesus: A Plea for Realism
Program Unit: Anglican Association of Biblical Scholars
Mary J. Marshall, Murdoch University
*
|
Restraining Allegory: A Newly-Discovered "Antiochene" Criticism
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
Peter Martens, Saint Louis University
This paper will examine the discussion of allegory in a new recension of Adrian's "Introduction to the Divine Scriptures," of which I am a co-discoverer. Unlike the textus receptus of this treatise which devotes only a few lines to allegory, this newly-discovered recension contains a lengthy account of the trope of allegory, including Paul's use of the term in Galatians 4. My paper will examine Adrian's account of allegory, focusing on how he restrains its presence in Scripture: it is only one of 22 scriptural tropes, and Paul's use of allegory is, in fact, to be properly classified under a different trope. This paper will position Adrian's assessment of allegory in the larger "Antiochene" tradition - esp. Theodore of Mopsuestia's writings.
|
Out with the Pedagogue, in with the Person: Making Biblical Studies Relevant in the Millennial Classroom
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Erica L. Martin, Seattle University
Current research on the Millenial demographic sitting before us in our undergraduate classrooms offers clear (if sometimes distressing) conclusions: the hierarchal professor-student relationships and utilitarian “knowledge for knowledge’s sake” approaches of yesteryear simply do not work with this crowd. This presentation will engage the attendees in a review of Prof. Christy Price’s “Five R’s for Engaging the Milennial” (Relevance, Rationale, Relaxed, Rapport, and Research-Based Methods) and model specific examples of ways we can create active learning experiences in our Religious Studies classrooms. The focus: making the learning experience matter to and intrigue the students while promoting relaxed and personal interactions between all members of the Learning Team, professor included! Bring your smart phone, iPad, or other device and your experience in the Millenial classroom.
|
Vaginal Polemics: Mary’s Body as the Field of Conflict in Muslim-Christian Debate
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
Erica L. Martin, Seattle University
Muslim and Christian texts agree about Mary’s virginity, but differ markedly in discussion of Mary’s vagina. Matthew and Luke are quite circumspect regarding the mechanism of the conception and delivery; in Luke, the angel reassures Mary (and the audience!) that the conception is not achieved in the usual manner but a function of the Holy Spirit “overshadowing” her. The Protevangelium of James unambiguously denies that Jesus came into contact with Mary’s vagina at either conception or birth. The Qur’an, however, depicts the conception as explicitly vaginal and describes a painfully normal birth. This paper analyzes representations of Mary’s vagina in the New Testament, Protevangelium, Qur’an, and related texts in order to illuminate the difference between Christian and Muslim accounts of Mary’s vagina and discuss the texts’ usage of Mary’s body as a tool of argumentation in the larger Christological debate.
|
Legitimating Rhetorical Situations in the Epistles of Acts 15:23–29 and First Peter
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Troy Martin, Saint Xavier University
First Peter is rarely compared to the letter from the Jerusalem Assembly in Acts 15:23-29 even though Peter is presented as participating in the authorship of both and Silas (Silvanus) is also somehow involved with both. This paper investigates the rhetorical exigences that prompted the writing of both letters and discovers that in spite of some obvious differences, there are some interesting similarities that inform some long-standing interpretive problems associated with both these letters.
|
Sixteenth-Century Spanish Translations of the Qur'an: The Almonacid de la Sierra Atelier
Program Unit: The Qur’an: Manuscripts and Textual Criticism (IQSA)
Nuria Martínez-de-Castilla-Muñoz, Universidad Complutense de Madrid
Thirty five copies of the Qur'an and of the tafsir -eleven of them being translations into Aljamia- were found in a trove located within a house in an Aragonese town which had not more than 1600 inhabitants in the 16th century. Thanks to a thorough study of these translations, we can state that with a single exception they were closely related between themselves: the copyists, the ornamentation, the paper or the textual family. These similarities induce us to put forward the hypothesis that they were produced within a very short time span, in the same area, in order to be sold to neighbouring Muslim communities lacking the expertise required for the transcription of the texts they needed.
|
Jewish and Christian Readings of the Exodus and the Issue of Assimilation
Program Unit: Jewish-Christian Dialogue and Sacred Texts
Safwat Adel Marzouk, Anabaptist Mennonite Biblical Seminary
The memory of the exodus of the Israelites from Egypt centers on their delivery from slavery, oppression and persecution. This paper will propose that another interpretive tradition of the exodus from Egypt has figured in both Jewish and Christian circles. Various ancient and modern, Jewish and Christian interpreters have read the exodus from Egypt as a way of resisting assimilation. Origen of Alexandria (3rd century CE), Maimonides (12th century CE), Mendelssohn (19th century), and Diana Lipton (2008), to name a few, have interpreted the exodus tradition in a way that considered Egypt as a threat to the Jewish or the Christian identity not because of oppression but because of idolatry. According to these interpretive moves, Egypt in the exodus tradition stands in for any power that attempts to submerge the other under its hegemony. Focusing on two samples of the aforementioned interpreters, this paper will analyze where Jewish and Christian interpretations converge and differ from one another in their reading of the exodus as a resistance to the phenomenon of assimilation. While Egypt in the book of Exodus for these interpreters stands in for something else, Egypt for me as a Christian Egyptian reader of the book of Exodus is an other that is within. Recognizing this otherness within me in the process of reading of the exodus traditions as a Christian Egyptian and keeping the political facet (being an Egyptian) in tension with the theological facet of my identity (being a Christian) seeks to offer a complex interpretation that engages critically with the phenomenon of assimilation without creating a binary opposite. This Christian Egyptian approach should have implications for Jewish-Christian dialogue. In an interreligious dialogue we are called not to portray the other as a threat, a notion that forces us either to assimilate or expect the other to assimilate or instigates literal/virtual violence, rather to accept the other tradition as a gift.
|
The Dynamic Polarity between Justice and Mercy in the Gospel of Matthew
Program Unit: Bible and Ethics
Jens-Christian Maschmeier, Ruhr-Universität Bochum
In New Testament scholarship it is undisputed that righteousness/justice and mercy are theological key terms in the Gospel of Matthew. Surprisingly however, the interrelation between these terms has never been subject to an in depth inquiry. In my paper I will argue that justice and mercy constitute a dynamic polarity that is constitutive of the matthean understanding of God’s dealing with man and man’s dealing with God. Starting point is the parable of the unmerciful servant. It will be shown, that Matthew conceives justice and mercy as two modes of divine action towards man that structure the relationship between God and Man as reciprocal: Man is obliged to imitate God’s mercy towards himself –the eschatological forgiveness of sins – in his social relations (imitatio Dei). If man fails to do so, God will act as judge (cf. Mt 5:7; 7:1f.). The God-man relation unfolds between the two poles of divine justice and mercy and characterizes this relationship as vivid and dynamic. For man God’s mercy becomes the criterion of justice respectively of the “overflowing righteousness” that is the condition for entering the kingdom of heaven (Mt 5:20). Thus in the Gospel of Matthew mercy has to be understood within the framework of the act-consequence nexus: Divine mercy doesn’t replace justice, but is the precondition of a new beginning in the God-man-relationship that unfolds anew between justice and mercy. In other words: The attempts to identify justice/righteousness with mercy undermines their polarity as well as the dynamic reciprocity of the God-man-relationship. In addition I will argue that Matthews understanding of mercy is shaped by the Hebrew hesed. In the Old Testament hesed denotes i.a. God’s compassionate loving kindness that culminates in his readiness to forgive sins (cf. Ex 34:6) and that aims at a new reciprocity between God and man. For man this new reciprocity implies a righteous way of life and doesn’t exclude God’s recompensation of sins. This understanding of hesed is the basis on which Matthew illustrates God’s eschatological forgiveness of sins, which the members of the ekklesia are supposed to imitate.
|
Wisdom and Wisdom Meets: Navigating Ancient Israelite Wisdom through African Eyes
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Madipoane Masenya (Ngwan’a Mphahlele), University of South Africa
For an average African biblical scholar, the Christian Bible seems not to be regarded as a book to be locked inside academic board rooms and classrooms only. It is the people’s book. Is it any wonder that particularly in a context like Africa, South of the Sahara, one in which the Christian religion has revealed significant growth through the years, scholars have become fascinated or rather been drawn to contextual readings of biblical texts? Such readings, while not neglecting the contexts of the production of biblical texts, foreground the significant role which readers play in the production of texts. Some of the contents of the Hebrew Bible in particular, be it ancient Israelite wisdom, rituals and customs, have revealed apparent resemblances with their counterparts within various African settings. This has been attested to by many an African biblical scholar, including wisdom scholars. This paper will investigate what basically happens when wisdom traditions from different cultural contexts, far removed from each other in time, meet.
|
What of the Problematic Norm? Rereading the Book of Ruth within the Mongo Women’s Context
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Madipoane Masenya (Ngwn'a Mphahlele), University of South Africa
Like in many an African community, or dare we say, a global community, heterosexual marriage (and its package) has been, and continues to be the norm. Embedded within many a union, is the challenge of problematic masculinities. The Mongo women in the Equatorial region of the DRC, appear to be no exception to the norm. The importance attached to heterosexual marriage within African cultures, a particular mainly androcentric biblical hermeneutic,the global hetero-normative culture together with the Mongo women’s poor socio-economic condition, all seem to work together towards the perpetuation of the ideology of “(heterosexual) marriage as norm.” Given the notion of dangerous masculinities prevalent within such unions and the observation that marriage has become a risky business in the context of the HIV and AIDS pandemic as well as the observation that the book of Ruth in the Hebrew Bible also seems to perpetuate the "marriage-as-norm" ideology, how may the be re-read within such contexts? The preceding question will form the main focus of our paper
|
Review of Jared Calaway, The Sabbath and the Sanctuary
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Eric F. Mason, Judson University
Review of Jared Calaway, The Sabbath and the Sanctuary
|
The Covenant with Assyria in Isaiah 28
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Nathan Mastnjak, University of Chicago
This paper will address the enigmatic “covenant with death” in Isa 28:15, 18. It will argue against the currently favored understanding of this metaphor as a reference to Judah’s reliance on Egypt for protection from the Assyrians at the end of the 8th century. The metaphorical resonances of “death” and “sheol” in biblical and NWS literature suggest a figure of great strength and appetite. These resonances conflict with the perspective on Egypt in Isa 30, 31 as too weak to help. The metaphor of personified death thus better fits a reference to Judah’s treaty with Assyria earlier in the 8th century, and this interpretation enables a unified reading of Isa 28:1-4, 7-22.
|
Gendering Reproduction: Reassessing Deut 25:5–10 in Light of Discourses of Sexuality
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Steffan Mathias, King's College, London
Interpretation of the law of “levirate marriage” (Deuteronomy 25:5-10, in which a widow is to produce a child with the brother of the deceased husband, with related narratives in Genesis 38 and Ruth) generally identify the passages as either a form of inheritance law, as economic protection for the widow, as a method to perpetuate the life of the deceased, or as a mechanism to ensure descendants to carry out ancestral rites. This paper seeks to go further and ask how this particular law reflects discourse around masculinity and sexuality. By widening the ‘canon’ with which Deuteronomy 25:5-10 is compared to include narrative and prophetic texts (such as the promise to the faithful eunuch in Isaiah 56, or the widow of Tekoa in 2 Samuel 14:1-7), we will explore the way aspects such as reproduction and afterlife are gendered. This paper will argue that masculinity is constructed around the creation of male progeny, and failures to perform this function of masculinity are masked through mechanisms such as levirate marriage, which repair these failures and exploit women’s sexuality. Drawing on the work of Judith Butler and Michel Foucault, we can uncover how Deuteronomy 25:5-10 retains ancient discourses of sexuality, and how male sexuality is regulated. This will allow us to think about how these particular aims (inheritance, economic protection, perpetuation of the deceased’s name) can be understood as symptoms of Ancient Israelite constructions of gender, offering new perspectives on legal texts which have often become stifled and restricted by the generations of research on them, without uncritically disregarding more traditional methods of criticism.
|
Foreshadowing and Realization: Key Elements in John’s Narrative Construction
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Mark Matson, Milligan College
For a number of Johannine scholars, the combination of aporias and temporal disjunctions (whether proleptic or analeptic) in John’s gospel point to either the later editing of sources, or to the (perhaps more than one) revision of the gospel story by the final author. I suggest that most or all of these should be more appropriately attributed to John’s narrative interest in developing a well-structured and coherent story.
In this paper I would like to explore one fairly narrow aspect of this issue, that is the role that proleptic introductions of, and subsequent rehearsals by, key characters provides in the narrative structure of the Fourth Gospel. In particular I will examine the importance and function of the following narrative linkages: John the Baptist’s interactions with Jesus, the periodic appearances of Nicodemus, the identification of Judas as one who will betray, and the role of Mary and Martha and the anointing of Jesus’ feet. In each of these there are “out of sequence” prior announcements or repeated features that realize or fulfill previous announcements. This pattern of announcing and revisiting certain characters in the gospel story seems integral to the development of the gospel story, and thus should influence how we see John functioning as composer.
|
'Who Really Cares That Paul Was Not a Gender Egalitarian after All?' Thinking through the Question with the Unveiled Corinthian Women Prophets
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
Shelly Matthews, Brite Divinity School (TCU)
The influential work of Dale Martin on the question of androgyny in the ancient world has caused many subsequent scholars to affirm his view that Paul was not a gender egalitarian. Many have also adopted his view that, once Paul’s position is ascertained, one may conclude with confidence that the baptismal formula of Gal 3.28 did not promote social equality or the disruption of hierarchy in any way.
Focusing on the prescriptions concerning veiling in 1 Corinthians 11.2-16, this paper will argue that such Paul-centered scholarship leaves many important questions concerning the experience of others in the Corinthian community unasked. For example, if early Jesus believers did not experience their worship as a disruption of hierarchy, what prompted the Corinthian women prophets to resist the ideology of veiling? It will also argue that a more nuanced understanding of egalitarian and utopian impulses in social movements is required, lest ancient movements be unfairly held to impossible standards in order to be recognized as such. Finally it will show how arguments concerning ancient androgyny are often rife with category confusion. For example, while scholars of ancient androgyny acknowledge, in theory, the fluidity of the categories male, female, sex, sexual difference, gender, man and woman, their arguments concerning the absence of egalitarian effects in ancient androgyny require them to revert to conceiving of sexed bodies as fixed and stable in some essential way.
|
They Were Not Mainly "Peasants": Towards an Alternative View of Village Life in Greco-Roman Palestine and Egypt
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Sharon Lea Mattila, University of Chicago
It has been very common in research on the Greco-Roman world to assert that very few people existed in between the elite based in the cities on the one hand, and a homogenous mass of self-sufficient “peasants,” living just at or slightly above subsistence-level after taxes were paid, on the other. Market exchange was peripheral and, indeed, inimical to the “peasant” mode of existence, which was largely self-provisioning with barter having been the preferred means of exchange when any trade did take place. Two scholarly constructs in particular have given rise to this conventional view—(1) the (Karl) Polanyi–(Moses) Finley paradigm; and (2) the essentialist social-scientific concept of the “peasant” as a distinct socioeconomic and cultural human type. In this paper I survey scholarly critiques of both these constructs and show that anthropological field work has in fact revealed the following to be the two fundamental characteristics of agrarian societies actually studied on the ground: (1) marked socioeconomic inequalities within village communities, which are key to understanding their internal dynamics; and (2) a multiplicity of economic strategies employed by rural people in order to procure their livelihood, which include combining the cultivation of holdings with tenancy and wage labor, and/or with small-scale commerce and commodity production, as well as working in the transportation of goods, all of which involve market participation and not just production for self-use. I then survey data from Greco-Roman and Early Byzantine Palestine and Egypt— archaeological, documentary, and literary—which strongly suggest that the same two fundamental characteristics of agrarian societies were predominant in the villages of the ancient world as well. Some of the data from Palestine that I present will soon appear in “Inner Village Life: A Diverse and Complex Phenomenon,” in Galilee in the Late Second Temple and Mishnaic Periods: Volume 1: Life, Culture, and Society (ed. David A. Fiensy and James Riley Strange; Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press, invited essay, forthcoming). To provide one example from the Egyptian data, whose analysis is part of a larger comparative ongoing project that I am undertaking, a private-land register of 216/17 CE from the village of Philadelphia shows that, while absentee urbanite landowners from both Alexandria and the metropolis of Arsinoe did own significant quantities of land near the village, it was the villagers themselves who owned the majority of it. The land in the hands of the villagers was furthermore very unequally distributed among them. One can estimate the net product of each holding in grain equivalent after subtracting taxes and seed grain, and then incorporate a conservative estimate for the basic subsistence requirements for a family of four in grain equivalent. The result is that the villagers’ holdings varied from one tenth that required for subsistence to almost 35 times subsistence-level (a factor of 350!), with a graduated range of sizes in between these.
|
At the Intersection of Written Text and Oral Performance: There and Back Again
Program Unit: Performance Criticism of the Bible and Other Ancient Texts
Kathy R. Maxwell, Palm Beach Atlantic University
Performance critics face an intriguing conundrum: we study texts composed for performance that were eventually written down. This paper will explore the intersection of oral and written texts, particularly Hebrew Bible/LXX citations in the Gospels prefaced with the formula, “It is written,” and will suggest that we adjust our understanding of ancient and modern hermeneutics in light of this intersection of media.
First, we must examine and compare assumptions made by print and rhetorical cultures. Both cultures make use of written texts, leading to the application of modern concepts to the ancient rhetorical culture. Accurate communication is important in a rhetorical culture, but word-for-word repetition may not be necessary. Perhaps we must broaden our understanding of what is “written”: a “written text” may still be in flux. Second, the questions we ask often spring from print culture assumptions and may be alien to an ancient rhetorical culture. When we consider the nature of a rhetorical culture, our questions begin to change.
Finally, the paper will consider examples of quotations in the Gospels prefaced by the “It is written” formula. The possibility emerges that “It is written” did not necessarily denote a word-for-word quotation. If the formula instead signaled the re-performance of ancient and revered words, how did previous performances influence the author, text, and audience? What freedom did the author feel to enact a new re-performance? In what ways do performance and re-performance collide… or merge? Viewed as a re-performance of a performed and written text and guided by the rules of a rhetorical culture, we see the authors not only “quoting” an old text but, through re-performance, evoking memories and provoking response to God’s continued action in the lives of God’s people.
I am not suggesting that modern interpreters adopt this ancient hermeneutic, at least not wholesale. As we compose texts as participants in our own culture, citation is important, as is intellectual property, and historical and literary contextual study. If, however, our goal is to understand the process by which ancient texts came to be, with an eye toward performance, interpretation, and formation, we are well-served by studying that process on their terms, rather than our own.
|
A Poet’s Performance: Persona Criticism and Royal Ideology in the Psalter
Program Unit: Performance Criticism of the Bible and Other Ancient Texts
Nathan Maxwell, Palm Beach Atlantic University
This paper advances the thesis that persona-critical analysis may function as an essential, fruitful sub-method of performance criticism. The utility of persona-criticism is particularly evident in the analysis of psalms and their ancient enactments. The selected examples for this paper (Pss 89 and 101) illustrate how significant performance criticism may be to understanding the Psalter’s poetry. The paper will develop the primary thesis in three stages: theoretical, historical, and canonical.
The first step is to describe and justify persona criticism as a relevant hermeneutical tool for ancient Near Eastern poetic texts. The underlying theory is that the speaker or speakers in a given psalm are correctly identified as literary personae (and are therefore distinct from the historical author). The postmodern theory and consequent methodology may be related to ancient poetic texts by establishing the aspect of poetic voice as a phenomenon of poetry. This phenomenon is demonstrable not only in the Hebrew Psalter, but in other Northwest Semitic, Akkadian, and Mesopotamian texts as well.
The paper then considers how poetic persona functions in the performance of a psalm. While recognizing that the Psalter has more than one historical backdrop (cultic and exilic), the focus here is on the temple’s celebration of the royal throne – hymnody performed in the animation of monarchy. The intersection of persona and performance teases out an interesting discovery: royal psalms like Pss 89 and 101 do not merely demonstrate but formulate royal ideology; singing the psalm shapes the king.
Psalms 89 and 101 are finally recast in their canonical setting, functioning as a “royal envelop” of sorts for the enthronement series (Pss 96-99) that plays a central role in the theology of the Psalter. Within their literary setting Psalms 89 and 101 continue to realize their formative capacity, reshaping kingship and, in doing so, reorienting the canonical Psalter’s audience in a coordinated effort to address the problem of exile.
|
The Gnostic Background of Plotinus’ Last Words
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Zeke Mazur, Université Laval
Plotinus’ last words before his death––something to the effect of “to try to lead the god in us back up to the Divine in the All” (Porphyry Vita Plotini 2.25–27)–– has been the subject of several problematic attempts at interpretation, and it remains in need of a satisfactory explanation. This paper will offer a new perspective by noting a substantial parallel between this deathbed utterance and two Gnostic comparanda: [1] certain Valentinian death rituals of “redemption” (apolutrosis) described by Irenaeus Adversus Haereses I.21.5, in which the dying aspirant is supposed to announce the return of his or her “inner human being” to its pleromatic origin ; and [2] the account of the ultimate phases of the visionary ascent in the Platonizing Sethian tractate Allogenes (NHC XI,3), 61.4–14, in which we find the ultimate vision of the Unknowable separated into two phases, the first subjective, in which the vision is said to be of the transcendent principles “within [the] self,” and the next objective, in which the vision is of [ii] homologous principles “within the All.” This parallel suggests a Gnostic context (broadly speaking) for Plotinus’ enigmatic deathbed utterance, and is consistent with the working hypothesis that Plotinus had emerged from an Alexandrian Gnostic background in his youth.
|
Papyri, Collections, and the Antiquities Market: A Survey and Some Questions
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Roberta Mazza, University of Manchester
In recent years the publication and in some cases public exhibition of papyri, originally from Egypt, transmitting glamorous lost ancient texts, have stirred polemics on their provenance and acquisition circumstances. The Artemidorus papyrus, the Gospel of Judas codex, the so-called Jesus wife papyrus, and more recently the London Sappho papyrus and the Green collection papyri have been presented in the media as surrounded by an allure of mystery, which has intrigued the wider audience, but in fact has more to do with the scarcity or quality of information given on their purchase.
The aim of this paper is to provide a wider context for these famous cases. I will survey post-1951 (the year of the issue of the Egyptian law n. 215 on the protection of antiquities) acquisitions of papyri by both private collectors and public institutions in order to discuss questions and problems relating in particular to three areas: public access to data on the acquisition of papyri, publication and professional association policies, and academics’ communication with the media.
|
Dismantling Patriarchal Ideology: In Search of Methodologies for Searching the Scriptures in the African Contexts
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Dora Rudo Mbuwayesango, Hood Theological Seminary
Dismantling Patriarchal Ideology: In Search of Methodologies for Searching the Scriptures in the African Contexts
Dora Mbuwyesango
The elephant in the room in biblical Studies in Africa is patriarchy. Patriarchy is at the root of the oppression and marginalization of different segments of African populations. The majority of biblical scholars in Africa are male and many of them do not want to get rid of patriarchy. They focus on methodologies that address imperialism while emboldening patriarchal ideology. Patriarchy and imperialism are one side of the same coin. As long as male African biblical scholars continue to focus primarily or only on imperialism, academic biblical studies will continue to be irrelevant and even worse, complicity in the continuing oppression and marginalization of people based on gender and sexuality. There is a need to develop methods or perspectives of critiquing both biblical and African patriarchy.
|
Ephesians, Braided Narrative, and Ritual Pattern
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Stephen McBay, University of Manchester
The authorship and purpose of Ephesians are among the most debated issues in NT studies. This paper resulted from the study of braided narratives across Pauline texts, and it is consistent with the works of Geertz, Turner, Strecker, and DeMaris. When following this innovative methodology that traces braided narrative, a new reading of Ephesians emerged. It is a reading that speaks directly to those contested historical and theological issues.
This new reading is not arguing that an actual ceremony occurred beyond the performance of the letter being read aloud before many assemblies. This paper foregrounds the ritual pattern in the epistle that is revealed when the braided narratives are traced across the letter’s exousiological passages. That ritual pattern presents a cosmological model aiming to inspire a particular sense of the divine, a certain sort of devotional mood in the letter’s first audiences. If Ephesians is read attentively for exousiological language, as a ceremony, two facts become plain. First, the writer of Ephesians knew how the principalities and powers passages bound together Paul’s revelatory story-telling, like his Damascus Road experience and his direct paraenesis concerning the everyday life of the assembly – the writer expanded the binding pattern to shape the entire work. Second, Ephesians is a ceremonial text wherein a patterned ritual is spoken out as it is read and heard.
The author of Ephesians took Pauline internarrativity and ‘wrote it large’ in order to structure a letter that contains an apostolic commissioning ceremony. Just as Paul was called and commissioned (not converted), so too are the saints recognized as already being with God but then called for re-tasking, just as Paul was. The ceremony is not announced to the audience but arises as the order and substance of the principalities and powers passages are revealed: a preparatory Eucharist, then the commissioning, and finally an investiture. The letter is clearly divided by theological and practical content at the second or central cardinal moment of the veiled ritual. That central moment is the reason for the letter: “the holy ones of Ephesus” are commissioned into Paul’s apostolic ministry.
|
Male Gender Variance (and Prophecy!): The Subtext to Gilg VI: 42–78
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Kathleen McCaffrey, Independent Scholar
This paper identifies puns and metaphors in the bridegroom tales of the sixth tablet of the Gilgamesh Epic, which communicate an unexpected subtext to Gilgamesh’s response to Ishtar’s marriage proposal. The wordplay is further analyzed with gender theory, yielding new information about male gender variance in the ancient Near East.
|
From Exclusion to Healing: Disability and Purity at Qumran
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Albert McClure, University of Denver/Iliff School of Theology
The topics of healing and disability have become useful categories of investigation for scholars of ancient Jewish literature (e.g., Hogan [1992], Avalos [1995], and Abrams [1998]). The Qumran texts, too, have lent themselves to studying disability in Second Temple Judaisms (see especially Dorman [2007]). Yet, no scholar has specifically discussed the meaning(s) of the exclusions of persons with disabilities by the Qumran community, nor why a person with a disability, seeking healing, might join a community with such strict regulations concerning persons with disabilities. What, then, does the exclusion of disabled persons produce, on the one hand, for the Qumran community and, on the other hand, for the disabled persons who are part of that community? Following this line of reasoning we may think of the Qumran community as a social body focused on producing certain things through their religious laws. My thesis is that exclusion of persons with disabilities at Qumran produces (1) divine presence and authority for the sectarians, and (2) healing for the disabled sectarians. First, I will demonstrate how exclusion of sectarians with disabilities produces purity that allows for divine presence, atonement of sins, and revelation at Qumran. Secondly, and utilizing insights from John Pilch (2000), I will explain how the exclusion of persons with disabilities fosters healing for sectarians with disabilities by explaining how the sectarians: (A) provide ‘personal and social meaning’ for persons with disabilities, (B) effect behavioral transformation that mirrors a particular society’s conception of health, and (C) offer a ‘new or renewed’ reason to live for those with disabilities.
|
Modern Theory, Ancient Statuaries: What Figurine Aesthetics Can Tell Us about Religious Community-Making at Sumer
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Lauren K. McCormick, Syracuse University
Instead of personally being present in a temple, ancient Sumerians placed mass-produced figurines there, to stand on their behalf in a deity’s perpetual presence. In his 1936 article “The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction,” Walter Benjamin argued that mechanically reproduced art led to “production of the masses.” Mechanically reproduced art had the ability to congeal multitudes by presenting them with an image they would encounter repeatedly, come to identify with, and ultimately connect with one another through. Might the Sumerian figurines have served in a similar capacity, as images that created a mass through their own mass production?
Benjamin contrasted film with paint to argue there were two kinds of art: art with cultic value and art with exhibition value. In this project, I will explore Benjamin’s idea that exhibition art is a technology of mass identity formation by taking paint and film as analog for personal and vicarious temple attendance at Sumer. I will unpack the figurines as culturally encoded objects and use them to show contra Benjamin that cultic and exhibition art values can coexist, but beyond fine-tuning Benjamin, my goals are: 1) to apply contemporary aesthetic theory to Sumer’s ancient figurines, so as 2) to bring ancient art into the conversation about technology’s ability (or inability) to build genuine community through the production of images.
|
Apocalyptic Satire? Genealogies of Parody and Wishful Readings of Revelation
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Patrick G. McCullough, University of California—Los Angeles
A number of scholars turn to the categories of “satire,” “parody,” or “irony” as a means of explaining the Book of Revelation’s distasteful (to us) use of violent fantasy. For example, David Barr writes, “John does not imitate the Roman imperial system so much as he makes a burlesque of it, a parody, a radical inversion of roles and power.” According to Harold Maier, Revelation uses “irony and parody to champion resistance to empire” and such features “may help Christian communities feel less at home in the American Rome.” Indeed, such articulations of Revelation as satire or parody appear largely driven by a modern desire to make this ancient text ideologically palatable. Alternatively, some have offered nuanced proposals on the relationship between Revelation and Rome, while still accepting “satire” or “parody” as operative categories in the work (e.g., Stephen D. Moore, Greg Carey). As yet, however, very little attention has been given to a discussion of what we mean by “satire” or “parody.” In this presentation, I offer a Foucauldian-inspired genealogy of satire and parody in their ancient and modern contexts, demonstrating their fluid complexity in antiquity and ideological deployment in contemporary settings. Taking up Roman exemplars of satire (e.g., Lucilius, Horace, Persius, Juvenal), I examine the relation between the satirist and society, how satirists typically shaped their genre, and its roots in Greek Old Comedy. In our modern context, one finds a rather unreflective use of the category “satire” or “parody”—from public figures as diverse as Jon Stewart and Robin Thicke—as a means by which one escapes criticism. This paper offers a comparative analysis of Revelation’s features that are purportedly “satirical” with the discursive strategies of ancient Roman satirists. While limited similarities may be seen here, typical scholarly uses of this category for John’s Apocalypse more closely resemble an uncritical popular usage offering the author a “pass” on his most disturbing language. If Revelation’s fantasies are mockery and not misogyny (for instance), then John is a champion of resistance and not simply (for progressive Christian scholars) an unfortunate inclusion in the canon. Rather, I argue, John should be seen as participating in Roman cultural discourse, negotiating his place within a complex arrangement of social interactions and power dynamics with the best discursive tools he had. Indeed, such discursive practices are not unlike Roman satirists, who came from divergent social backgrounds but often sought to define and defend true Romanness with their rhetorical jabs. In the final analysis, the categories of “satire” or “parody” cannot be employed to frame John as a champion of anti-imperial resistance nor can it offer him immunity from modern critical eyes. My presentation thus promotes more precise and responsible usage of these categories in the interpretation of John’s Apocalypse.
|
Financialization and the Emerging Monopoly on Public Discourse: A Biblical Perspective?
Program Unit: Economics in the Biblical World
Charles McDaniel, Baylor University
Financialization has come to dominate public discourse just as finance capital has come to dominate the globalized capitalist economy, another stage in the shift of values away from Abrahamic traditions and their scriptures. Fuller critical awareness of this public discourse, and how it exacerbates the impact of neo-liberal economics, may lead biblical scholars to new questions for their continuing encounters with biblical texts concerning economic relations.
|
Rewriting the Matriarch: Reading Sarra in the LXX
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Joseph McDonald, Brite Divinity School / TCU
It is a favorite pastime among scholars who work with “rewritten” scriptural materials to pronounce on which texts truly merit the label. Although Géza Vermès included some targumim in his description of “Rewritten Bible” when he coined the term, most subsequent critics have left translations entirely out of account. In studies of Second Temple treatments of biblical figures or stories, the Septuagint is often ignored completely except in places where its tradition departs significantly from that which became the Masoretic Text. But translation, at least as conceived in literary disciplines outside of biblical studies, is never anything but an act of “rewriting.” Even in cases such as Genesis, where the LXX offers a reasonably “literal” or “quantitative” rendering of something approximating a proto-MT, the lexical and syntactic features of the Greek draw on a pool of cultural data, encoded in language, that is irreducibly distinct from that of its Vorlage. In this paper I seek both to enter the LXX more firmly into the conversation on rewritten scripture and to suggest an alternative approach to reading rewritten materials, pursuing these issues through a narrative-critical reading focused on Sarra, a figure whose characterization in the LXX has been little studied. My reading highlights a variety of pressures on Sarra’s individuation that emphasize her utility to the fulfillment of the divine promises. Along the way, I discuss a number of literary features unique to the LXX, such as lexical motifs and a cluster of ambiguous gender notes, in a bid to demonstrate that rewritten compositions, even translations such as the LXX, merit literary consideration on their own terms. Even basic misunderstandings, I argue, can contribute to thematic links within a translation that increase literary cohesion and interest. More broadly, I suggest that a narrative-critical approach, with its insistence on considering the linear sweep of a narrative, allows a version’s distinctive features to emerge more clearly than in traditional models that emphasize small-scale synoptic contrasts. In this way, narrative-critical methods may also have something to offer to the comparative enterprise that motivates many investigations into the rewritten materials.
|
Sarra's Faded Portrait in LXX Genesis
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Joseph McDonald, Brite Divinity School / TCU
Aside from work on figures such as Judith or Susanna, who lack an extant Hebrew precursor, extended studies of women characters in the Septuagint are few. What investigations do exist tend either to concentrate on narratives that feature significant disparities in the text histories of their respective Hebrew and Greek traditions, such as Esther, or to draw out themes associated with women in the LXX over against their analogues in the MT. These predilections are a corollary of the most common approach to “rewritten” scriptural materials, which highlights textual differences through near-context synoptic comparison. This paper explores an alternative approach, employing a narrative-critical perspective that foregrounds the literary characterization of Sarra in LXX Genesis. I contend that Sarra’s individuation and agency are persistently undermined in the LXX, and consider whether this may amount to a narratorial tendency that restricts Sarra’s initiative while emphasizing her resemblance to Abraam.
In addition to offering a sustained reading of Sarra in the LXX, my work serves two broader aims. First, I argue that an approach that respects the integrity of the LXX as a narrative allows its distinctive features to emerge more clearly. The linear demands of narrative-critical reading curb an atomizing impulse, found in much scholarly work that seeks to compare the ancient versions, towards minute juxtaposition and contrast of the MT and the LXX. Thus while a recent article uses a tiny piece of Sarra’s narrative data to bolster a thesis that LXX Genesis depicts women as “more active” than their MT counterparts, my analysis shows that Sarra, considered holistically as a character, is in fact more passive, even inert. Second, by taking the Greek narrative seriously, I advocate for a recognition of the independent humanistic value of the LXX, which is too often treated as a derivative work whose only relevance is to illuminate the text that became the MT.
|
Warrior-Men and City-Women: The Implications of Military Imagery in the Song of Songs
Program Unit: Gender, Sexuality, and the Bible
Geoffrey D. McElroy, University of Texas at Austin
The depiction of the desire between the two lovers in the Song of Songs seems contrary to understandings of desire elsewhere in the Hebrew Bible as primarily male, dangerous, and something to be controlled. Feminist scholarship the Song has generally interpreted these more egalitarian constructions as liberating. Representative of this viewpoint is Phyllis Trible, who once lauded the Song as having “no male dominance, no female subordination, and no stereotyping of either sex” [Phyllis Trible, “Love’s Lyrics Redeemed,” in God and the Rhetoric of Sexuality (Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1978), 161].
While such egalitarian constructions of desire are present in the Song, it is not free from other gender constructions originating within its greater cultural milieu. The Song employs metaphorical imagery rooted in ancient Near Eastern war language that undermines the egalitarian and equitable portrayals of love between the man and woman. The paper will begin by exploring the construction of the man as a warrior-king in chapters 3 and 5, drawing on the work of Mark W. Hamilton on the royal body in ancient Israel. Next, in connection with Cynthia R. Chapman’s work on gendered war language, I will connect the warrior-king motif to architectural imagery in the Song that describes the woman as a city to be conquered (4:4, 6:4, 7:5, 8:8–10). Furthermore, the imagery of the warrior-man and the city-woman undermines the potentially liberating aspects of the Song, closing with the woman still unable to tend her own vineyard (1:6; cf. 8:12).
|
'The Impious Will Not Rise in the Judgment': Defending the General Resurrection from Ps 1:5
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Thomas McGlothlin, Duke University
Psalm 1:5’s claim that the impious will not rise in the judgment can easily be read as a denial of the general resurrection and judgment. Indeed, from the Mishnah to Thomas Aquinas we see a consistent discomfort with this possible interpretation. One common solution among Christians, found from Clement of Alexandria onwards, is to read Psalm 1:5 alongside John 3:18, which declares that unbelievers are already judged by their unbelief; thus, they will be resurrected, but not to judgment. This simple solution is complicated when Psalm 1:5 is also read alongside John 5:29, according to which evildoers will be raised to a resurrection of judgment (in contrast to those who have done good, who will be raised to the resurrection of life). Struggling with these competing claims, Latin writers of the fourth century (Lactantius, Hilary, Ambrose, and Ambrosiaster) developed a model that was systematized by Gregory the Great: Apostles and other “super” Christians are not judged but rather sit in judgment; other, more sinful Christians are judged, some being acquitted by their works of mercy (sheep) and others condemned (goats); and non-Christians are condemned without trial (Psalm 1:5). With the spectacular exception of John Scotus Eriugena (according to whom no one will be ungodly in the eschaton), almost all subsequent Latin interpreters adopted this framework. Byzantine interpreters were equally zealous to defend the general resurrection, but they were less uniform in how they did so. Nevertheless, they occasionally matched the Western framework remarkably closely. For example, the emperor John VI Cantacuzenos reproduced Gregory the Great’s schema, even employing identical prooftexts. Psalm 1:5’s apparent denial of a key doctrine thus generated a theologically productive tension, and its reception history serves as a barometer of developing eschatology and possibly East-West exegetical interaction.
|
Knowing the Color of One's Bread: How Forms and Types of Bread Reflected and Created Ancient Social Structures
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Andrew McGowan, Yale Divinity School
In Juvenal’s Satires (5.74-5) a diner in a socially-mixed gathering is chided by a server for choosing from the wrong bread platter; the offender should have known to pick an inferior bread to pick from its colour, relative to his modest status. While bread was a staple throughout the ancient Mediterranean, its forms and substances varied, and its significance as a marker of status likewise, according to three factors in particular: the species of the grain used; the fineness of the grind and the amount of sifting applied; and the presence or absence of leaven. The first and last are somewhat familiar from biblical texts; the juxtaposition of wheat and barley is an ancient commonplace, and a negative concern about leaven is familiar. The issue of leaven however is potentially misleading, since leaven was generally desirable, and the rising process time-consuming and hence expensive. Each of these three factors will be discussed here, in relation to a set of ancient Jewish, NT and early Christian texts.
|
Can University Walls Keep Out the Internet?
Program Unit: Metacriticism of Biblical Scholarship
James F. McGrath, Butler University
The statement of purpose on the website of Moody Bible Institute begins, “To maintain continuity and consistency with its heritage, Moody Bible Institute requires all faculty and administration to agree with, personally adhere to and support the school's doctrinal statements.” Similar statements can be found at other schools reflecting the perspective of conservative Evangelicalism. The rationale for this was presumably clear, once upon a time. By requiring such conformity, the school could attempt to keep (or when necessary, eject) outside its walls those whose dissenting viewpoints could potentially flourish and spread in the absence of such strictures. The statement goes on to reject academic freedom not only for professors and administrators, but also students. The aim is to have the institution pass on doctrines from faculty to students without distraction or disagreement.
This paper will explore whether, in an era of blogs, podcasts, YouTube videos, and a variety of other websites and online sources, and a cacophony of scholars, apologists, and other voices calling out for attention, the rationale for the sectarian educational institution is fundamentally undermined. When wi-fi and 3G signals cannot be easily blocked, nor the URLs of all opposing viewpoints censored effectively, can any school offer to shield its students from liberalism and secular scholarship? And if not, then how might we expect the rationales and character of conservative Christian higher education to change in the coming years in response to this free flow of information online?
|
This Is Not the Bible: Disclaiming Scripture in Aronofsky’s “Noah”
Program Unit: Genesis
Cameron McKenzie, Providence University College
On February 27, 2014, Paramount Pictures added the following disclaimer to the marketing materials for the soon to be released Darren Aronofsky film, “Noah”: “The film is inspired by the story of Noah. While artistic license has been taken, we believe that this film is true to the essence, values, and integrity of a story that is a cornerstone of faith for millions of people worldwide. The biblical story of Noah can be found in the book of Genesis.” From its emergence in the late 19th century until the present day, cinema has embraced the Bible and its treasure trove of narrative gems. These cinematic re-visionings of the Bible, from the sword and sandal epics of Hollywood’s golden age to the digital spectacles of the 21st century, all promise to expand our understanding of these old stories, such that the Bible becomes more than we imagined. The results are frequently less than satisfying and often controversial. Drawing on the history of the reception of the Bible on film, emerging data on the status of biblical literacy in North America, the increasing radicalization of the religious right, and with particular reference to Aronofsky’s film, this paper will respond to the question of why such a disclaimer was deemed necessary for this film, at this time.
|
Where Is Shi*? The I-zebel (Jezebel) Passages as a Post-post-Dtr Layer in Kings
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Steven McKenzie, Rhodes College
All of the references to Jezebel in the Hebrew Bible occur in five contexts in the book of Kings: the introduction to Ahab (1 Kgs 16:31), the Mount Carmel story in 1 Kings 18 (vv 4, 13, 19), Elijah’s flight to Mount Horeb (1 Kgs 19:1, 2), the story of Naboth in 1 Kings 21 (vv 5, 7, 11, 14, 15, 23, 25), and the account of Jehu’s revolt in 2 Kings 9 (vv 7, 10, 22, 30, 36, 37). This paper will present evidence for the secondary nature of these texts and examine the methods used in evaluating that evidence in order to address the questions under consideration in this session about textual revision.
|
Auspices for the Achievement of a Working Knowledge of Biblical Hebrew
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Tracy J. McKenzie, Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary
This paper will contain essential elements of achieving a working knowledge of biblical Hebrew. More than the ability to reach academically bound students, teaching Hebrew to future congregational leaders demands factors that compel self-initiated student participation from the first day of class and beyond. Moreover, the paper will discuss a strategic grammatical, syntactical, and lexical minimum through which a student can have success in translating a text. Finally, it will propose a realistic goal for the acquiring and appropriation of a working knowledge of biblical Hebrew and how that supports the ongoing use of it in congregational leaders’ professional lives.
|
Constructing a Culprit: Early Christian Depictions of Their Persecutors
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
James McLaren, Australian Catholic University
One of the earliest recorded accounts of Christians being subject to violent attacks relates to the events in the aftermath of the fire in Rome in 64 C.E. Although an officially sanctioned punishment, Nero’s decision to hold the Christian community accountable for the massive destruction that had swept through much of Rome is presented by Tacitus as an exercise in public relations. In the centuries that follow the event does not feature as part of the Christian account of its origins. However, in this paper it will be proposed that the legacy of the public mutilation of Christians in Rome in 64 C.E. did have a profound impact on the way Christians constructed their accounts of who acted as their primary opposition, namely, members of the wider Jewish community. Employing the ‘what if’ approach which is commonly used to analyse the historical significance of major military campaigns and battles we will explore the impact of the violence that was perpetrated. It will be contended that the deliberate and consistent depiction of various individuals and groups from among the Jewish community as the people that actively opposed Jesus and his followers in the gospels, Acts and other later writings is directly linked to the responses to the events in Rome.
|
Specters of Mark: Re-imagining the Second Gospel's Ending with Derrida's Messianic
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Peter N. McLellan, Drew University
The Gospel of Mark’s ending not only serves as an enigmatic conclusion to an equally enigmatic narrative, but it also, through its notably absent resurrected body and invitation to return to a narrative past, presents an opening for re-conceptualizations of the messianic and justice. Engaging primarily with Jacques Derrida’s Specters of Marx, this paper will explore the potentialities opened by the Markan narrative’s ending for reimagining concepts of presence. Of interest, first, for this paper is the extent to which Jesus’ body is constructed as an entity of the past, dead and gone. Here, mourning, loss, and a focus on what was reinforce Jesus’ death. The narrative’s movement toward absolute loss, however, is interrupted by the absence of Jesus’ raised body. It is in this moment his figure, as a specter, becomes ever more active. That is, the ghostly body’s vitality and activity is announced only in its absence. In fact, the messenger’s invitation to follow Jesus to Galilee heightens this discontinuity and introduces a severe temporal disjunction by invoking the narrative past and exploring the uncertainty and hopefulness of a future. At this point Derrida’s messianic figures prominently in this paper’s analysis. While the other three Gospels privilege the presence of a material body, a Derridean analysis of this passage allows for an expanded notion of what a body might look like and, more importantly, opens the possibility for the immanence of justice-to-come. In other words, the women at the tomb are called to return to the events expressed earlier in the narrative, at the very moment they are called to look for their savior through the promise of a future meeting. And while Derrida’s famous prayer, “Come!” is replaced by an injunction to “Go!” in this passage, the openness to a messiah who refuses to conform to an ontological presence allows for the very imminence of a future yearned for.
|
Paul and the Mommy Wars: Reading Paul's Maternal Metaphors in Contemporary American Context
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Jennifer Houston McNeel, Union Presbyterian Seminary
It is rather remarkable that in his seven undisputed epistles, which are often described as androcentric, Paul employs maternal imagery six times. Three of these six occurrences are particularly noteworthy in that Paul describes himself as a mother to one of his church communities. In Gal 4:19 Paul states that he is again suffering the pain of childbirth with the Galatians. In 1 Thess 2:7 says that he cares for the community like a wet nurse feeding her own children. And in 1 Cor 3:2 Paul again takes the role of nursing mother, admonishing the Corinthians about their lack of readiness for solid food. Maternal imagery in which Paul is not the mother is also employed in Rom 8:22; 1 Cor 15:8; and 1 Thess 5:3.
The experience of writing a dissertation on Paul's maternal metaphors during the phase of my life in which I myself became a mother has led to many reflections on what motherhood means in my own context and how this idea of motherhood relates to Paul's idea of motherhood as expressed in his metaphors. Motherhood in my own (American) context can, of course, be defined in many ways, but in recent decades has often been portrayed in popular media through the lens of the "mommy wars." The term "mommy wars" defined narrowly refers to the supposed conflict between working mothers and stay-at-home mothers. However, the term is also used more broadly to refer to all the parenting decisions and values mothers might disagree about as well as conflict over the basic idea of what a mother is and how she ought to think and behave. In my paper, this conflict surrounding motherhood will be explored through reference to popular culture, traditional media, and the online world of blogs and social media.
Motherhood in Paul's context can in many ways be considered very different from my own. This context will also be explored through historical research and reference to ancient literary works. Five themes related to motherhood will be explored: (1) status inconsistency; (2) conflict; (3) choice or lack thereof; (4) self-denial and suffering; and (5) the authority-nurture balance. Exploration of these themes in ancient and modern contexts will bring contemporary images of motherhood into conversation with Paul's maternal metaphors, highlighting both similarities and differences between these two contexts. I will consider both what Paul's text brings to bear on evaluations of contemporary motherhood, and what the contemporary context brings to a reading of Paul's letters.
In addition to historical and cultural research, the paper will also reflect on the experience of writing about maternal imagery while becoming a mother. Related to the question of what I knew about motherhood while writing on Paul's metaphors is the question of what Paul might have known about motherhood as a first century male. And what are the implications for me as a reader if I have more direct experience with this subject matter than Paul himself?
|
The Hexaplaric Sources of Job: A Comparative Analysis
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
John D. Meade, Phoenix Seminary
The hexaplaric fragments of Job are found in various Greek, Syriac, Latin, and Armenian sources. This paper will provide a comparative analysis of the chief witnesses to the hexaplaric fragments of Job, namely, the Syro-hexapla and the Greek catena tradition. The results of this study will help to determine the provenance of each source and evaluate the textual quality of the hexaplaric fragments preserved in both sources. An analysis of the internal evidence of these sources is important for establishing the history of the Hexapla for the book of Job and perhaps for other books.
|
Qur'anic Hermeneutics and Islamic Philosophy: A Study of Ibn Sina's Commentary on Surat al-Falaq in Comparison with His Philosophical Writings on the Problem of Evil
Program Unit: Qur’anic Studies: Methodology and Hermeneutics (IQSA)
Sayeh Meisami, University of Toronto
Ibn Sina was not a systematic exegete; yet, his interpretations of selective verses from the Qur ?an in the context of his philosophical writings together with his independent commentaries on a few chapters from the Qur ?an provide a good reason for examining the exegetical aspect of his work. In his approach to Qur ?anic concepts, images, and terminology, Ibn Sina utilizes a discourse very similar to that of his philosophical treatises. Philosophical hermeneutics of the Qur ?an in the classical period has three major characteristics that I would like to show through analysing Ibn Sina's approach. First, it falls under the category of symbolic interpretation (ta ? w?l) rather than technical/linguistic exegesis. Second, it makes a selective choice of Qur ?anic passages in consistency with philosophical doctrines. Third, it is primarily interested in metaphysical and moral issues, and for the most part disinterested in sectarian biases.
In this paper, I will examine Ibn Sina's interpretation of surat al-Falaq (Q: 113) with two goals in mind. First, I hope to elucidate the hermeneutical methodology adopted by Ibn Sina, which in turn will also throw more light on philosophical approach to the Qur ?an as described above. Second, far from claiming to solve the problem of authorship with regard to the Qur ?anic commentaries by Ibn Sina, the paper investigates the consistency between the philosopher's understanding of evil, as well as the discourse used in his interpretation of al-Falaq, and the treatment of the same issue in both his major and minor philosophical writings such as al-Shifa, al-Naj?t, al-Ish?r?t wa al-tanbih?t, al-Ta? liqat, Ris?lat al-fi ? l wa 'l-infi ? ?l, and al-A??awiyah fi 'l-ma?ad. Apart from primary philosophical sources and the two editions of Ibn Sina's commentary on al-Falaq by ?Abd al-Ra?man Badawi and ?asan ?A?i, the paper also benefits from major secondary literature on Ibn Sina's Qur ?anic hermeneutics including the work of Peter Heater, Lois Gardet, Daniel De-Smet, Meryem Sebti, Muhammad Abdul Haq, S. M. Hojjati-Jarrah, Jules Janssens, J. Michot, ?Ali A?ghar ?ikmat, Mesut Okumus, and Mohammed Zine. Looking into Ibn Sina's commentary and in response to the secondary literature mentioned here, I would like to conclude that although the commentary on al-Falaq does not include all the arguments that Ibn Sina presents in his philosophical treatises on the problem of evil and does not go through the technical details of the issue with respect to different meanings, and types of evil, the difference in scope and technicality can be explained based on the difference between two genres of writing rather than the existence of two different authors.
|
The Political Institutionalization of Rape: Ezekiel 23 and Dalit Women
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Monica J. Melanchthon, United Faculty of Theology
The caste system is permeated by a ‘culture of violence’ against Dalit women. Dominant caste men grow up in a culture that reinforces in them daily their caste privilege and socio-economic power over Dalit women, and thereby their rights over Dalit women’s bodies per se, as well as their right to utilize these bodies as means by which to punish both Dalit women and men transgressors of the ‘natural’ caste and gender hierarchies. This in turn, reproduces the gender and caste divisions on which these same forced practices of discrimination and sexual violence are based. The Indian state bolsters this system by its failure to adequately investigate and prosecute sexual violence against Dalit women, sending a message of impunity to male actors in sexual crimes against these women. This selective tolerance by state authorities of sexual violence against socially excluded Dalit women effectively legitimizes this violence against Dalit women as a group, by subverting the democratic rule of law to the rule of caste. This paper seeks to analyze and interpret Ezekiel 23: 22-34 against this background using the tools of feminist hermeneutics.
|
Surviving Words: A Dialogical Reading of Jeremiah 36
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Cesar Melgar, Graduate Theological Union
Jeremiah 36 is a key passage that has given scholars plenty of material to approach their questions regarding the source material of this book, comparative approaches with 2 Kgs 22, and anthropological data regarding writing and the relationship of prophets and scribes in the ancient Near East. In this essay, I adopt a dialogical reading of this chapter that sets it in conversation with other passages that inform us about the power of the words of Yahweh in this prophet’s message and in other prophetic traditions. This type of reading also explores the different voices that influence the development of this drama and how they push each of the actors to an interpretive posture that will determine their destiny. My argument is that in Jeremiah 36 the words of Yahweh constitute the driving force of the entire drama where each scene, from the recording of the words on a scroll to the burning of the scroll by the political elites to the re-recording of the former words, constitutes a hermeneutical response to these words and it situates the actors to a place in history as a consequence of their interpretation. In the process this chapter also illuminates how an obedient hermeneutic becomes the deciding factor, because these words prove to be unapologetic about their demands for obedience. I will develop this thesis by summarizing some key theoretical frameworks from the works of Bakhtin and Barthes. Then I will apply these notions to my close reading of Jeremiah 36. The conclusion will highlight that this chapter is a fundamental passage to the question of hermeneutics in the book of Jeremiah and for that matter in other biblical traditions, because the immortal words of Yahweh demand for an obedient interpretation.
|
The Founding of the Temple in Ancient Egypt and Israel
Program Unit: Egyptology and Ancient Israel
Ash Melika, California Baptist University
The religious culture of ancient Near Eastern civilizations was highly technical and expressive. In the case of ancient Egypt and Israel, we are faced with two cultures that had great religious ingenuity, and had reached such an eminent state, for the most part, independently of one other. The cult rituals undertaken in both countries demanded a sacred structure, specialists, and high revenue. In the course of this paper, I will describe and investigate the religious symbolism behind the founding of Egyptian cult temples of the New Kingdom (c.1550-1070 BC) and the First Temple of ancient Israel. Specifically, I will focus on the foundation ritual stages as it relates to the king and his relationship with the concept of 'order'. Consequently, reference will be made to the affinities and dissimilarities between both cult rituals (ancient Egypt and Israel) and their underlying rational. I will also apply anthropological material from ritual studies as to shed light on the ‘meaning’ of such rituals. This paper, however, is aimed at being illustrative, rather than all-inclusive analysis of the subject matter.
|
Aspects of Absence: A Dialogue on the Divine in the Megilloth
Program Unit: Megilloth
Brittany N. Melton, University of Cambridge
This paper aims to present a more nuanced understanding of the purview of perspectives in the Hebrew Bible concerning the theme of divine absence by facilitating an intertextual discussion among the Megilloth. Such an inquiry arises not only by means of contrast between this collection and the remainder of the canon, but each of the Five Scrolls invites one to examine divine absence. The case for the theme of divine absence in the Megilloth is made stronger by aligning these texts side by side. This paper is concerned with discerning the differences between each voice as it expresses divine absence. There is a theme to their conversation, but not a unity to their voices.
The perspective of each book with regard to divine absence will be discussed as follows: The literary absence of the divine name from Esther and Song of Songs results in the expression of ambiguity in one but curiosity in the other. Lamentations on the other hand deals explicitly with the literal absence and abandonment of God initially following the Babylonian destruction of Jerusalem. The people are left paralyzed, pleading for restoration and trying to understand how they can be the people of God after YHWH has abandoned them. Lament over the abandonment of God is not only heard in Lamentations, but also through the voice of Naomi in the book of Ruth. The separation between God and humanity is distinctly expressed by Qoheleth’s emphasis on divine transcendence, leading to questions about God’s involvement with humanity. Most notably God does not speak in any of the Five Scrolls, deeming divine silence the paramount intertextual issue for discussion. Certainly the Megilloth provide a wealth of various perspectives from which to discern the multi-dimensional theology of the presence and absence of God in the Hebrew Bible.
|
Scenting Saintliness: The Ailing Body and the Desert Community in Christian Hagiography
Program Unit: Senses, Cultures, and Biblical Worlds
Peter Anthony Mena, Drew University
In the introduction to her translation of Pseudo-Athanasius’s Life and Activity of the Holy and Blessed Teacher Syncletica, Elizabeth Castelli notes that the saint’s “illness and eventual death became a special form of ascetic practice—the endurance of illness.” While The Life of Saint Syncletica is not unusual in its depiction of a saint suffering illness, it is remarkable for its potent descriptions of disease and the ensuing bodily decay she endures and the concomitant vivid descriptions of visual and olfactory assault. In her later analysis of the text, Castelli demonstrates its challenge to “binary oppositions as the producers of…cultural meanings and practices,” because the Life does not polarize body and soul, but rather, blurs their distinctions, their roles, and their goals. More recently Derek Kruger and Virginia Burrus have each heeded Castelli’s call for anti-dualistic readings of this text and demonstrated the materiality and likewise instability of text and flesh, spirit and logos.
Suzanne Bost has shown the use of illness and disease by Chicana feminist writers and artists in order to demonstrate the ways in which “corporeal upheaval” is a challenge to the “individuality and predictability (indeed, the identity) of identity.” By bringing these scholars into conversation, this paper argues that the fifth-century hagiographical Life and Activity of the Holy and Blessed Teacher Syncletica describes an ascetic subject that is relational to its desert environment and community. Syncletica’s holiness is determined not simply by the very vivid descriptions of her ailing and decaying body and the pain inflicted upon her, but also by her students and fellow ascetics who suffer with her and attempt to care for her. As such, it can only be described in concert with these relational aspects and then only characterized by its permeability, relationality, and precariousness. Reading this hagiography along with Bost’s analysis of Chicana feminist literature and the work of more recent scholarship on this text allows for a different interpretation of the function of illness and disease: not as the opposite of health and wellness, nor simply as a rhetorical tool for describing the ascetic subject, but instead an understanding of subjectivity hinged on the materiality of the body and its interaction with its environment, its community.
|
Stylistic Preposition/Case Alternation in Lk 1:55 and the Original Language of the Magnificat
Program Unit: Jewish Christianity / Christian Judaism
Hugo Mendez, Yale University
Several writers have championed a Jewish-Christian origin and line of transmission for the Lukan canticles, citing their Semitic poetic characteristics among other factors (C. Westermann, R. E. Brown, P. Benoit). Unfortunately, no consensus yet exists on the original language of these hymns, whether Hebrew (direct translation) or Greek (imitation/LXX pastiche). Stephen Farris characterizes this debate as a choice between “translation Greek or imitation translation Greek.” This study will examine a particular poetic device not yet catalogued in previous studies of the Semitic characteristics of the Magnificat. The final couplet of the hymn, v. 55a,b, juxtaposes equivalent preposition/case constructions in an appositive relationship: pros + accusative and simple dative. Although this alternation has historically been treated as a syntactic anomaly, I have argued it represents a conscious expression of poetic style. A particular device of Semitic poetry, the use of “reversed ballast prepositions,” provides an analogy to the phenomenon observed in vv. 54-55. In this device, the first colon employs a “heavier” variant, or synonym, of a preposition in the second colon. To compensate, the second colon takes additional elements. The LXX utilizes both pros + accusative and simple datives as equivalents of bound and free prepositions with Hebrew verbs of speaking. An attempt to imitate or translate a reverse ballast construction could employ both constructions, though admittedly, neither the Hebrew prepositions, nor their Greek equivalents, are ever juxtaposed in this manner. This presentation will weigh arguments in favor of either translation or imitation as the likely origin of this device in the Greek of Luke. Attention will be given to the treatment of reverse ballast prepositions throughout the LXX psalter, the perception of such alternations as a form of poetic style by the LXX translators, and the use of a related device in vv. 46b-47 of the same hymn (stylistic tense shifting). The study will note a reluctance to apply the expression “imitation translation Greek” to the phenomenon.
|
The Queer Art of Biblical Reading
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Luis Menéndez-Antuña, Vanderbilt University
Biblical art, as many scholars have argued, not only is inspired by the biblical world but it is a cultural force that re-interprets the biblical text. Pictorial representations usually have an ideological agenda of their own (in terms of gender, sexuality, class, race, nationality, etc.), sometimes reinforcing the status quo, sometimes challenging it, but always altering the way we look back at the biblical source. In the present paper I put in dialogue two paintings in order to show how their respective sexual ideologies deconstruct each other, and to illustrate the ways in which such deconstruction invites a radical reading of the biblical text.
First, I offer the example of Saint Martin of Tours as a paradigm of “Christian Caritas.” His story as narrated by biographers in the fourth century and portrayed later in the seventeenth century by Van Dyck is inspired by Matthew 25:31-45. The painter advances a visual representation of Christian moral excellence, producing a cultural product that represents a dominant tradition in Christian social and personal ethics. Second, I introduce the story of Pero and Cimon as a “counter-text,” as an example of a pagan source that deconstructs and queers such mainstream moral tradition. The pictorial representation of this myth by Rubens in the seventeenth century offers a sample of “Caritas Romana” that challenges traditional dichotomies between eros and agape, and calls for a queer reading of Matthew 25:31-45.
|
The Understanding and Reception of the Bible in the General Public of Mainland China: A Survey on the "Bullet Curtain" of the 2013 TV Miniseries The Bible
Program Unit: Ethnic Chinese Biblical Colloquium
Zhenhua (Jeremiah) Meng, Nanjing University
not available
|
My Mother, My God: A Woman's Voice in Psalm 22?
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Esther Menn, Lutheran School of Theology at Chicago
This paper will explore how parts of Ps 22 can be read in the voice of a woman.
|
Reading between the Lines: Deciphering Differences in Donatist and Catholic Rites
Program Unit: Contextualizing North African Christianity
Jane Merdinger, Independent Scholar
This paper will examine similarities and differences in Donatist and Catholic rites. Baptismal rites will constitute the primary focus, but eucharistic practices will receive attention as well. I shall argue that superficially Donatist and Catholic rites appear to be the same, but on closer inspection, disparities in intent become discernible.
My proposed avenue of inquiry has already begun to yield results. In forthcoming conference proceedings, I demonstrate that around 400 CE Donatists emphasized the pre-baptismal rite of exsufflation for ex-Catholics converting to Donatism. Though Donatists also exorcised such candidates in accordance with tradition, they concentrated on exsufflation because of its humiliating effects. They deemed punitive measures necessary to expunge the sin of traditio, inherited by Catholics during Diocletian’s persecution. In contrast, Catholics did not utterly debase their candidates. I discovered that the intent behind Donatist exsufflation differed significantly from its Catholic counterpart due to Donatism’s radically dissimilar ecclesiology.
Maureen Tilley’s research on Donatism has shifted emphasis away from social-political analysis (Frend, Tengström) toward greater awareness of theological issues. However, scholars have failed to capitalize on Tilley’s suggestions and continue to insist that Donatist theology and Catholic theology were essentially the same (Gareth Sears, Brent Shaw). My paper will redress this lacuna by close examination of baptismal texts and occasional remarks about the Eucharist. Primary sources will include: Cyprian’s letters; Optatus’ de Schismate Donatistarum; Augustine’s contra epistulam Parmeniani, contra litteras Petiliani, and contra Cresconium (treatises that preserve extensive verbatim arguments from Donatist leaders themselves); African canons and decrees (Munier, CCL 149); and the Theodosian Code. Anthropological categories will frame my arguments (Mary Douglas, Evans-Pritchard). Secondary sources will include works by Maureen Tilley, Brent Shaw, Robert Markus, James Alexander, W.H.C. Frend, and Alexander Evers.
|
Commentary Writing as Zombie Apocalypse
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Christopher Meredith, University of Winchester
The idea of a commentary tradition can be read as a kind of zombifying process of multiplication, feeding and 'abjectification' of the biblical corpus. Feeding on and reproducing the Bible, but also working as the return, the revisiting to the Bible of parallel forms of itself. It is thus something of an abject configuration at the heart of the field. Commentary writing, like the zombie apocalypse, is the return of what's been buried, and the staging post for the academic community's own dead to re-enter the fray. As such the commentary represents an undead return that is as much about illuminating the identificational boundaries of the current cultural construction we call 'Bible' as it is about 'supplementing', attacking, or nourishing ourselves on the text. The zombie commentary doesn't simply reproduce itself, it serves to reproduce particular ideological configurations that allow the idea of Bible to function and to go on functioning. So, what would a stabilised zombie apocalypse look like, an abject revisiting that had become the norm, never winning, never limping back to the grave? And how does the landscape of commentary writing look any different? And why is that in the Biblical scholar's interest? (Because I suspect it is!)
|
Passwords on the Banks of the Thames: Doris Salcedo’s Shibboleth
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Christopher Meredith, University of Winchester
Late in 2007, London’s Tate Modern opened an exhibition called Shibboleth. Created by Columbian sculptor Doris Salcedo as part of The Unilever Series, Shibboleth took the form of a dramatic rift in the floor: the first work, as the gallery themselves said, to ‘intervene directly’ in the fabric of the building. Shibboleth ran the full 167m of the Turbine Hall, beginning at one end of the concourse as a hairline crack before opening up into a violent fissure that zigzagged across the room and vanished under the far wall, like an earthquake’s scar, or, as the New York Times suggested, like ‘a fissure brought on by prolonged drought’. The work took more than a year to produce and over five weeks to install, and was by all accounts quite stunning, undermining the grandeur and stability of the space by apparently attacking its foundations, along with everything the foundation of the modern gallery or museum suggests. The Powers that Be were understandably reluctant to reveal how the effect had been achieved without literally undermining the structural integrity of the 1947-built power station in which the work was housed, inciting wild theories from the national press. The Guardian even dispatched a team of architectural engineers to SE1 to explain how the trick had been done. Salcedo was adamant in pointing the media back to the question of meaning over manufacture: "what is important is the meaning of the piece”, she insisted. “The making of it is not important." Shibboleth’s undermining of modernist foundations obviously succeeded on a profound level; how else could it have triggered such an intense public need to understand the mechanisms behind the phenomenon—to ‘close the breach’, so to speak, in pragmatic comprehension?
This paper explores Shibboleth in light of its conspicuously biblical title, and, in turn, uses the popular and critical brouhaha surrounding the piece to interrogate the original tale in Judges 12. Judges’s story of the fleeing fugitives contextualizes Salcedo’s undermining of the gallery-as-stage, bringing into focus the political possibilities of the image of the ‘breach’ and critiquing the tacit allegiance that runs between intelligibility and legitimacy, both in human politics and cultural discourse. In particular, the subversive power of ‘not-knowing’ is explored by both works and points to the ways in which responding to ‘the crack’ between categories by recourse to ‘meaning’ can prove fatal. The paper argues that this is the same breach that Bible and Gallery must negotiate. Indeed, the aporia Salcedo stages in the Turbine Hall between experience and exhibit opens up the relationship between the Gallery and the Bible in interesting ways. Is the Bible another civic edifice Salcedo wishes to rupture? If so, does her Bible/Gallery of ‘cracked’ foundations undermine the austerity of these archetypal modernist edifices, or does Salcedo re-enforce them? Reading with Kristeva, we might suggest the structural abjection Salcedo’s work enacts merely serves to re-enforce the austerity of the idea ‘Bible’, founding another shibboleth at the banks of the river, albeit Thames not Jordan.
|
The Yahad as a Religious Emotional Regime
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Ari Mermelstein, Yeshiva University
The role of emotion in religious experience was emphasized by some of the formative works on religious experience, including those of James and Otto. These writers described religious emotion as a personal and subjective phenomenon, inaccessible to empirical inquiry. However, scholars in disparate disciplines increasingly describe emotions as a tool through which the self navigates its social environment. Religious emotion, therefore, is not a private matter but an experience of reality linking the individual, his or her religious community, and the values and symbols—the myths, collective memory, and material context—that constitute that community. Religions, like other collectivities, constitute what has been labeled an “emotional regime,” one in which patterns of appropriate emotion are communicated and enforced by means of various social, material, and symbolic elements.
As this paper will demonstrate, the model of a religious emotional regime has tremendous explanatory power within the context of the Yahad’s religious experience. Various texts from the Community Rule and Hodayot attempt to calibrate sectarian emotions of love, hate, fear, disgust, and shame, using them to structure the sectarian’s social relations and attitude toward the group’s symbolic world. The sectarian was instructed where and how to direct his love, hate, fear, joy, shame, and disgust. His emotions were bound up in beliefs about covenant, purity, and God, symbols whose meaning could not be divorced from sectarian social life. These emotions were taught, enforced, and reinforced through rituals, both occasional and regular; sectarian attitudes toward material goods; and the symbolic significance of ritual purity. The cumulative effect was to construct a comprehensive religious emotional regime in which the group’s social relations, meetings, meals, and rituals were invested with emotional significance.
|
Which Types of Knowledge Do the Parables of Jesus Presuppose?
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Annette Merz, University of Tilburg
Jesus is one of the earliest known Jewish teachers who extensively used the parable genre to convey the message of God’s imminent kingdom and its consequences for people’s lives. Redactional features in the Synoptic Gospels notwithstanding, it is possible to reconstruct the field of current images and motives, stereotyped agents, metaphors, plots etc. he used to communicate the new insights of his apocalyptic world view to his audience, consisting of ordinary people and religious professionals alike. The lecture will provide a (preliminary) comprehensive overview over the different types of knowledge the parables of Jesus presuppose to serve as a basis for comparison with rabbinic parables in a later stage of the NWO-funded research project „Parables and the parting(s) of the Ways“ (based at the Universities of Utrecht and Tilburg). Central questions that will be asked are: What kind of every day knowledge or specific Galilean local knowledge is mirrored in Jesus‘ parables and which areas/aspects of life are tellingly absent? To what extent is the practice of the Jesus movement (a group of wandering charismatics, a liberation movement within the Pax Romana) reflected in the parables? Besides the imagery from socio-economic realities the parables of Jesus also draw upon Scriptural knowledge and Biblical semantic fields, which will also be included in the synopsis.
|
The Letter of James and the Teachings of Jesus: Which Jesus Tradition Is Referred to by James?
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Annette Merz, University of Tilburg
In this lecture I will examine two possible ways the intertextuality between the letter of James and the Jesus tradition can be evaluated. Does the evidence support the hypotheses that James makes use of oral Jesus tradition (mainly) independent of written sources as is often supposed? If so, the letter should get more attention from scholars interested in the historical Jesus (myself included) than usually is the case. Or must we assume that the rhetorical purpose of the letter is to give reading instructions and interpretations for understanding the teachings of Jesus as laid down in the Gospels, especially in the Gospel of Matthew? In this case the intertextual references in James would function with respect to Matthew in a similar way as the references to Pauline utterances in the deutero-Paulines function with respect to the authentic letters of Paul (see: A. Merz, Die fiktive Selbstauslegung des Paulus. Intertexuelle Studien zur Intention und Rezeption der Pastoralbirefe, Göttingen 2004). The way intertextual allusions are couched and integrated into the letter of James and presuppositions are handled may help to decide the issue.
|
Bellowing Buffalo and Other Grammars
Program Unit: Sacrifice, Cult, and Atonement
Naphtali Meshel, Princeton University
The notion that rituals, like natural languages, are governed by implicit, rigorous rules led scholars in the last century, harking back to the early Indian grammarian Patañjali, to speak of a "grammar", or "syntax", of ritual, particularly sacrificial ritual. Despite insightful examples of ritual complexes that follow hierarchical rules akin to syntactic structures in natural languages, and ambitious attempts to imagine a Universal Grammar of sacrificial ritual, no single, comprehensive "grammar" of any ritual system has yet been composed.
The first part of the paper will outline such a "grammar." Centering on S—the idealized sacrificial system represented in the Priestly laws in the Pentateuch—it will be demonstrated that a ritual system is describable in terms of a set of concise, unconsciously internalized, generative rules, analogous to the grammar of a natural language. Despite far-reaching diachronic developments, reflected in Second Temple and rabbinic literature, the ancient Israelite sacrificial system retained a highly unchangeable "grammar," which can be abstracted and analysed in a formulaic manner.
The limits of the analogy to linguistics will be stressed: rather than categories such as syntax and morphology, the operative categories of S are abstracted inductively from the ritual texts: zoemics—the study of classes of animals used in ritual sacrifice; jugation—the rules governing the joining of animal and non-animal materials; hierarchics—the tiered structuring of sacrificial sequences; and praxemics—the analysis of the physical activity comprising sacrificial procedures. The problem of meaning in non-linguistic ritual systems will be addressed briefly.
In the second part of the paper, the explanatory power of the “grammar” of S will be assessed by examining its applicability to other ancient Near Eastern ritual systems, primarily as represented in northwest Semitic ritual texts; and to South Asian ritual systems, primarily as represented in the Apastamba Srauta-sutra.
|
The Perils and Virtues of Laughter in the Works of John Chrysostom
Program Unit: Social History of Formative Christianity and Judaism
Clair Mesick, University of Notre Dame
John Chrysostom’s stance on laughter is forceful but complicated: laughter functions both as a tool of the devil to infiltrate and corrupt society and a valuable weapon against the seductions of wealth and status. In this paper, I explore Chrysostom's multifaceted discourse about laughter as it plays out throughout his homilies. First, I demonstrate how Chrysostom decries inappropriate laughter; not only is laughter itself a sin, but it also inculcates vice and impedes virtue in others. Second, I outline the virtues of laughter, showing how Chrysostom exhorts his congregation to deride wicked and wealthy things and even allows for some degree of joyful laughter. Finally, I address Chrysostom’s pastoral response to anxiety about laughter. On the one hand, Chrysostom summons multiple rhetorical techniques to assuage his congregants’ anxieties about pagan mockery; on the other, he mobilizes these same social anxieties to dissuade them from pursuing immoral or inappropriate courses of action. Ultimately, I argue that Chrysostom's diverse discourses on laughter contribute to his social and ethical project. Right laughter identifies one as Christian, elevates the soul above temptations and traumas both, and serves as a strategy to disrupt and transform pagan society.
|
The Burden of Proof: Methods in Explaining the Redactional Evidence of the Serekh ha-Yahad
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Sarianna Metso, University of Toronto
The variants in the twelve, possibly thirteen, manuscripts of the Community Rule (1QS, 4QSa-j, 5Q11, 11Q29[?]) found at Qumran illuminate the editorial processes of ancient Jewish Scribes of the Second Temple period, and much attention has been given to explaining the differences between the S manuscripts and the developmental processes of the document. This type of analysis is often supplemented by the content analysis of the text, relying on internal indicators in the text. Less frequently, however, is a third type of comparison brought into the discussion pertaining to the redaction of S, namely the parallels attested in other, often fragmentary, Qumran documents. This paper is an attempt to bring the evidence from manuscripts such as 4Q502, 5Q13, and 4Q265 into the discussion, and to reflect on the methodological limits and possibilities they present.
|
Beruriah, Rabbinic Authority, and Rhetoric of Space in Midrash Mishle 31
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
David D. Metzger, Old Dominion University
A door bolt: Rabbi Tarfon rules it impure, but the Sages rule it pure. And Beruriah says, "Remove it from this door and hang it on another." On the Sabbath, these matters were related to Rabbi Judah. He answered, "Beruriah said well." —Tosefta Kelim Bava Metzia 1:6. The only Talmudic woman to be admired for her learning, Beruriah is understandably an important touchstone in the study and development of Jewish discourses about gender and Rabbinic learning (Rubenstein 1999, Adler 1988, Baskin 2002). Yet, little scholarly attention has been paid on the function of the Beruriah as a topos for authority in the imaginary economy of the Talmud and early midrashic collections (Hartman and Buckholtz 2011). This presentation will focus on one of the most famous stories related to the Beruriah figure: the story of how Beruriah informs her husband that their two sons have died (Midrash Mishle 31). In fact, Midrash Mishle 31 is dominated by the story of R. Meir and Beruriah’s loss of their two sons. And the story itself is dominated by place and space. The story takes place in their home. R. Meir’s concern is “Where are my sons? I checked this place, that place. Where are they?” There is a place (the children’s room) where their bodies are. And there’s the discursive place (for their children) for the answer to R. Meir’s question (Where are the kids?); the place for answer is constructed by way of a halakhic question that Beruriah asks her husband: “Someone left something on deposit with me some time ago. Must I return it?” Examining this story from the standpoint of a rhetoric of space--which not only identifies place with physical location but also with symbolic location (a place in a halakhic question)—will extend our understanding of the role that the Beruriah figure plays in construction of Rabbinic authority. Following the tri-partite delineation of space found in the work of Claudia Camp, Flanagan, LeFevere, and Soja, this presentation will show how the Beruriah makes a space where the internal and external discursive spaces for midrashic commentary and the Torah might be anchored. For example, this story is situated in a discussion of the question, “What is a capable wife?” There are some interesting turns in the frame, as well: a verbal play between the statement that “Her worth [the capable wife’s] is far beyond that of rubies [peninim] because she had been in the innermost (lifnai lifnim). The Torah is also associated with “the capable wife.” So, there is a possible that the discursive properties of the proof texts in chapter 31 assume the places and spaces associated with the capable wife, which may in turn be associated with the positioning of loss within R. Meir and Beruriah’s household.
|
From Praxis to Text: The Scripturalization of Priestly Ritual in the Mishnah and Invoking the Divine Name YHWH
Program Unit: Social History of Formative Christianity and Judaism
Anthony R. Meyer, McMaster University
The Mishnah's focus on the Temple and priestly ritual is one of early Judaism's enduring puzzles. Why should the rabbis record in detail priestly, sacrificial, festival, and purity regulations pertaining to a Temple that has been destroyed for over a century? Scholars have proposed various explanations for this content, ranging from the simple preservation of tradition to more elaborate ideas involving collective memory and response/reactions to the loss of the Temple. In this paper, related specifically to priestly ritual, I will explore the references to invoking the divine name YHWH (cf., m. Yoma 3:8, 4:1-2, 6:2; m. Tamid 3:8, 7:2; m. Sota 1:4, 7:6; m. Sukka 4:5; m. Berakot 9:5). The use of the divine name draws our attention as it is highlighted, for example, by the repetition of formulaic expressions after its invocation (e.g., "And they respond to him, “Blessed is the name of the glory of his kingdom forever and ever," m. Yoma 3:8, 4:2, 6:2). To what extent do these references reflect the memory of Second Temple practice? How far can the historicity of these references be confirmed or disputed? What other exegetical and/or theological ends might they serve? By reflecting on what scholars have called the "scripturalization of the cult" (i.e., cultic praxis recorded in written/stylized form and later exegetically developed) I hope to shed light on the use of the divine name in the Mishnah.
|
The Syriac Gazetteer (www.syriaca.org/geo): A New Reference Work for the Geographic Environment of Middle Eastern Christianity
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
David Michelson, Vanderbilt University
Ever since Athanasius extolled Christian monks for transforming the desert into a city, scholars have debated the role of geography in the history of Christianity. This presentation introduces a new reference work, The Syriac Gazetteer (www.syriaca.org/geo), designed to facilitate the geographic study of Christianity in the Middle East. The Syriac Gazetteer is one of a series of collaborative open access tools published by Syriaca.org: The Syriac Reference Portal. In this paper, the editors of Syriaca.org will discuss the methodology behind The Syriac Gazetteer, demonstrate its features, and solicit contributions from scholars and the heritage communities. The Syriac Gazetteer currently contains articles about more than 2400 places. This is the first modern reference work aimed at preserving the geographic memory of the Syriac heritage communities (e.g. Chaldean, Assyrian, Aramean, Maronite, Keralite, etc.). The selection criteria of “places relevant to Syriac Studies” include places named in Syriac texts (such as ?arqel - ????), places interesting to historians who work on Syriac texts (such as Dura-Europos), and places where scholarship on Syriac is being produced (such as Japan). There are no temporal or spatial boundaries for The Syriac Gazetteer, which collects places relevant to any period of history useful for Syriac studies, from places mentioned in the Peshitta version of Genesis to places founded recently, and from ancient Edessa to Mongol-era outposts in China and diaspora communities in the United States of America. At least in theory, any type or size of place could be represented in The Syriac Gazetteer, from large empires to single churches or a particular named city gate. Maps are provided for places whose location is known, but the gazetteer also includes places which are not located or even locatable. Note to program chairs: The Syriac Gazetteer will be published at http://syriaca.org/geo in April 2014, before that time it can be viewed privately at http://lib7.library.vanderbilt.edu:8080/exist/apps/srophe/geo/about.html
|
Using Linked Open Data to Explore Manuscript Collections: A Case Study from Syriaca.org
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
David A. Michelson, Vanderbilt University
One scholarly benefit of the emerging field of Digital Humanities is the possibility of applying information technologies developed for the world wide web to traditional research questions in the humanities. This paper explores the use of a Linked Open Data model (LOD) by Syriaca.org: The Syriac Reference Portal to build a manuscript union catalogue linking together various Syriac manuscript catalogues. LOD is a set of “best practices for publishing and connecting structured data on the Web.” Syriaca.org is a collaborative online reference tool for Syriac studies. As a born digital reference work, Syriaca.org relies on XML encoded data (describing manuscripts using the TEI guidelines) and a Linked Open Data framework in which conceptual entities (such as persons, places, manuscripts and texts) are linked together using URIs (Uniform Resource Identifiers) and RDF (Resource Description Framework). The advantages of the LOD data model for publishing information about manuscripts include robust ability to link manuscripts with named entities or concepts (such as authors, scribes, or locations) and the ability to explore these connections through a knowledge graph. This paper will demonstrate how Syriaca.org has used all of these technologies in its effort to create a union catalogue for Syriac manuscripts.
Note to Unit Program Chairs (Not for Publication in the Final Abstract):
The presentation will include a demonstration of the relevant technologies based on the current state of our research. We are hesitant to include a link in the abstract that may be superseded by the date of the conference. For your reference at present, a working RDF demo can be found here: http://pipsqueak.atlantides.org/srpdemo1/persons/13.html and a public archive of our Syriac manuscripts in TEI P-5 XML is published here: https://github.com/srophe/manuscripts
|
Is God Fickle? The Theological Significance of Interpretive Conundrums in YHWH’s Judgment on the Elide Priesthood (1 Samuel 2–3)
Program Unit: Bible and Ethics
J. Richard Middleton, Northeastern Seminary at Roberts Wesleyan College
The oracle against the house of Eli (1 Samuel 2:27-36), followed by the account of Samuel’s rise (chapter 3), is riddled with interpretive conundrums.
Eli is informed that his priestly line will be cut off and a new line initiated, although the house of his ancestor had been chosen to be priests “forever” (2:30) While this switch from unconditional to conditional election affirms YHWH’s justice, other interpretive conundrums are not so obviously theological.
Utilizing diachronic reconstruction, some take the mention of one of Eli’s descendants begging for bread (2:36) as presaging Ezekiel’s demotion of Levites to the status of temple assistants, and it is typical to view the promised replacement priestly line as alluding to Solomon’s choice of Zadok. Yet in the text’s narrative world it is more obviously Samuel who is the replacement priest, since he ministers before YHWH wearing an ephod as Eli’s apprentice in the Shiloh temple (2:11, 18; 3:1).
But even in the text’s narrative world there are strange shifts in God’s promises, which can confuse the attentive reader. The promise (now reneged on) that the original priests would “go in and out before” YHWH (2:30) is modified to say that the new priest would “go in and out before” YHWH’s anointed (2:35). And the promise of a “trustworthy” (ne’eman) replacement priest (2:35) is never fulfilled in the Samuel narrative. Instead, the fledgling priest Samuel becomes a “trustworthy” (ne’eman) prophet (3:20) and the Elide line never actually ends (even Zadok is arguably an Elide).
Is God fickle, reneging on promises and constantly changing course? Instead of resorting to a diachronic (behind-the-text) resolution of these difficulties, this paper will read the oracle against the Elide line and the account of Samuel’s rise as a coherent narrative that articulates a profound discernment of the relationship of YHWH’s justice and mercy at the time of Israel’s momentous transition to the monarchy.
|
Satan’s Hordes and God’s Vigilantes: Mobs, Martyrs, and the Legitimation of Christian Violence
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
Paul Middleton, University of Chester
In the early Christian Martyr Acts, violence against the Church comes from both the apparatus of the State and mob action. While the authors of martyrologies invariably attribute all persecution to the inspiration of Satan, this is particularly the case when they recount acts of uncontrolled rage of both pagan and Jewish crowds against the Christians. In both the Martyrdom of Polycarp and the Martyrs of Lyons, mob action against the Church is especially pronounced, and this Satan-inspired violence functions as a means of reinforcing group boundaries: Christians endure violence while non-Christians inflict it. However, by the end of the fourth century this position is reversed when Ambrose of Milan resists a command by the Emperor Theodosius that the Christians should pay reparation to the Jews of Callinicum after a Christian mob had destroyed a synagogue. Ambrose argues that God would approve of the destruction of ‘a house of impiety’, and threatens that he would be willing to undergo martyrdom in defence of this violence. The arguments employed by Ambrose effectively sanctioned future mob violence against Jews in the Empire. This paper examines the development the legitimation of Christian violence, arguing that conflicts against the Donatist and other ‘heretical’ groups eventually resulted in Christian identity being reinforced through inflicting rather than enduring violence.
|
Grace Goes to the Market
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
Nestor Miguez, Instituto Universitario ISEDET
The Pauline doctrine of grace, especially as it is formulated in the letter to the Romans, has been the center of many hermeneutical efforts and theological works, mainly in the tradition of the Reformation. Yet, little attention has been paid to its political and economic overtones and consequences. What challenges pose the idea of a justice through grace for the Roman Empire, its ideological, cultural and political framework? And in what ways does it question the ideology and economic and political practices of today's globalized Empire?
The economic and cultural policies of the Roman Empire were based in a timocratic ethos. Honor and merit were the core of a political career, the cursus honorem. The quest for riches was mandatory for whoever aspired to a significant place in society, since there were economic demands and standards for anyone who wished a certain reputation and social recognition, since honor was certainly related to wealth. Therefore, the idea of a social order, of a certain way of life in which the ideal is egalitarian, justice is distributed freely to everyone, there are no merits or honors to be gained, and money cannot earn any prestige, is not only foreign to roman ideology, but was destructive of its foundational believes and power structure.
In that context, to propose an ethics of salvation, an understanding of the works of God as totally gratis is certainly counterhegemonic. Where merits do not count, where there is no need of any power to access to plenitude, where life does not depend on wealth, where no one is excluded because of social, gender or ethnic distinctions, where anyone, and not only the Caesars, can be a son (or daughter) of God, the whole of the imperial world system is called to question.
Paul’s teachings about a justice that is thorough faith, that require no particular status, no special merit, has, then, in that society, a strong prophetic significance. Grace as an open possibility for a new life, as the way in which a new community is build, as the power to transform lives polluted by disgrace into instruments of justice is a dangerous novelty. Vice versa, grace can never be an attribute in a value system that treasures ambition, competition for wealth and merits, and in which the right of the powerful is the supreme law.
In a time in which the “free market” (in which nothing is free) is postulated as the only valid economic system, unregulated and unlimited, through which every aspect of life, and even the exploitation of nature is governed, and which is sustained by the use of the violent power of imperial armies, the implications of Paul’s understanding of grace as the way of God´s justice in Christ are a powerful critique of the world system.
My presentation will deepen in this concept and explore the prophetic meaning of grace in this world system of accumulation and exclusion, of violent impositions and unregulated power.
|
The Empire as Local Context
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Nestor Miguez, Instituto Universitario ISEDET
The tension between the local site and what might be called the global context must be taken into account in the hermeneutical task. This is especially true in the situations in which, through economic, political or armed power, the imperial condition shades the local context with the presence of the global. Contextual hermeneutics tend to emphasize the immediate situation, the cultural milieu, the socio-political circumstances in which a text has been woven. And this is certainly necessary. But in times when Empires force their demands, ways and power over the local, the ethos of the foreign, the pressure of imposition introduces the need to consider its incidence in the construction of any given text. The text will clearly express the local, and the local concern, but also will show in which ways that location is affected by the presence of what is beyond the visible context. In some cases this can be clearly appreciated; in others, it takes a more careful and detailed analysis to perceive that the local is also the global.
Most biblical texts have been written or composed under Empires. It is clearly the case of the New Testament. The texts express and narrate thoughts and stories in which the influence of the imperial condition is always to be considered, sometimes clearly expressed, in other times as powers that move behind the scenes, but that totally condition the events and the ways they are written. But it is not only the writing; also the reading under imperial rule shows this tension between the local and the global. Post-colonial and narrative hermeneutical theories have helped us to see the incidence of the reading context in the interpretation of the text.
In the Lucan account of Paul’s dealing in his missions in Philippi and Thessalonica we have two texts that clearly illustrate how the global is present in the local. In both cases Paul and his companions face the wrath of local authorities, accused by a third party. In the first case, the owners of a slave girl “when they brought them [Paul and Silas] before the magistrates, they said, ‘These men are disturbing our city; they are Jews and are advocating customs that are not lawful for us as Romans to adopt or observe’." (Acts 16, 20-21). In Thessalonica, some Zealous Jews, according to Luke’s narrative, “dragged Jason and some believers before the city authorities, shouting, ‘These people who have been turning the world upside down have come here also, and Jason has entertained them as guests. They are all acting contrary to the decrees of the emperor, saying that there is another king named Jesus’." (Acts 17, 6-7). In both cases we can see how the imperial contexts is brought to play a decisive role in the narrative of a local incident.
In my presentation we shall examine these verses as representative of this tension, and also how the fact of the global Empire of today conditions our reading of the texts.
|
Liturgical and Iconographical Reception of Acts 1–5
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Justin A. Mihoc, University of Durham
The first chapters of Acts tell the story of a ‘new Genesis’, the history of the first days of the Church in Jerusalem, under the leadership of Peter and the Apostles. This story, unique within the writings of the New Testament, is the only canonical testimony we have about the life and organisation of the nascent Church, and is generally the basis of all early Christian interpretations of the Jerusalem church. The reception, both literary and artistic, of this text was until recently largely neglected, and continues to be insufficiently explored.
In my paper, I aim to present the way in which the Lukan picture of the Jerusalem community, as depicted in Acts 1-5, was received in early Christian art and worshipping practice, focusing on the iconographical and liturgical Wirkungsgeschichte of the canonical text. Significantly, the apparent little textual reception of Acts 1-5 in the first centuries will be supplemented by an examination of other aspects of reception to show a clearer picture of the significance and use of the biblical text in the Early Church.
|
Bridging the Chasm: Crossing Social Boundaries with Lazarus and Luke
Program Unit: Gospel of Luke
Amanda C. Miller, Belmont University
The parable of Lazarus and the rich man in Luke 16:19-31 is one of this Gospel’s starkest examples of status reversal, enacting the beatitudes and woes of Luke 6:20-26. The rich man is condemned in the afterlife, while the poor man is welcomed by Abraham, with no chance of this chasm being crossed from either direction (16:26). Such a radical inversion carries a strong message for any in positions of privilege, but the parable also implicitly considers how such reversal might be avoided through following Moses and the prophets (16:29-31). This paper will explore the ethical implications of the parable within its literary and historical contexts.
I will argue that one of the hallmarks of Lukan ethics, as urged implicitly in Luke 16:19-31 and explicitly elsewhere in the Gospel, is community interaction and especially table fellowship among groups that are diverse in social status, ethnicity, religious background, and socioeconomic level. The chasm between Lazarus and the rich man is immovable and uncrossable in the afterlife, but only because the rich man refused to cross that divide in this life. Luke urges his reading communities to address this division in their present lives.
I will first compare the Lukan parable to contemporaneous fables of reversal from Aesop and Lucian, in order to demonstrate the fundamental difference in Luke’s take on stories of afterlife reversal: he uses this literary device to advocate a changing of the status quo, rather than its maintenance. I will then discuss the imagery of table fellowship and social interaction in the parable itself, particularly the opening scenes of life in this world. Finally, I will survey explicit instructions for table fellowship found in the rest of the Gospel and demonstrate how they influence the interpretation of Luke 16:19-31. Texts to be discussed will include references to Jesus eating with people from all over the social hierarchy (from “tax collectors and sinners” to Pharisees and teachers of the law) and his extended teachings on table fellowship in Luke 14:1-24.
|
“All the City Was Shaken”: Women’s Speech and Ancient Political Discourse in the Acts of Paul and Thecla and 1 Corinthians
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
Anna Miller, Xavier University
In the Acts of Paul and Thecla, the women of Antioch greet Thecla’s release by the Roman governor with a shout praising God so loudly that “all the city was shaken by the sound.” This shout concludes Thecla’s trials before the city, trials marked throughout by the vocal participation of women in the public sphere. During her time in Antioch, Thecla herself becomes a public speaker, an apostle whose authority springs in part from her self-baptism before the gathered city. This paper investigates the ways in which the author of the Acts of Paul and Thecla unsettles the conventions of ancient political discourse by envisioning women as public speakers in the civic context. The presence of women as vocal participants in civic politics contributes to the author’s portrayal of Thecla as a leader in the Christian ekklesia. However, the author’s rhetorical construction of women as political participants, even leaders, differs sharply from those of the Apostle Paul in 1 Corinthians, who also mobilizes political discourse in his arguments regarding women’s speech. In this letter, Paul reinforces the gendering of speech according to Greek political discourse in such a way that he undermines the full participation of women in the Christian community. This paper will suggest that Paul and the author of the Acts of Paul and Thecla are both engaged in a debate over women’s authority that is deeply influenced by civic political discourse and the transformative promise of Christian baptism. If these authors deploy Greek democratic discourse towards different visions of women’s participation in Christian communities, they also both witness the potential of this discourse to facilitate radical equality—especially when combined with a baptismal understanding that itself undermines the fixity of gender constructions in the ancient world.
|
The Kingdom of God in Samuel
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
Geoffrey Miller, New York University
This paper argues that the idea of the kingdom of God in Samuel has a distinctive political and theoretical content: it refers to theocracy -- political rule by God's representative on Earth. The Bible compares and contrasts theocratic rule with three other forms of national government: confederacy (discussed in Judges), military rule (discussed in Joshua and Judges) and monarchy (discussed in Samuel and Kings). The Bible sees much of value in theocratic rule but ultimately concludes that it is not suitable for governing an independent nation due to problems such as procedures for succession, the authenticity of the leader's connection with God, and the inability of the theocratic ruler to develop strong and durable institutions of national governance.
|
The Veil of Ignorance in Biblical Covenants
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Geoffrey Miller, New York University
Philosophers in the Western tradition have developed the idea of the social compact as a mechanism for identifying just political arrangements. To deal with problems of disagreement among the parties, these theories present the parties as negotiating under conditions of ignorance about their future endowments. The requisite knowledge conditions are obtained either by positing a state of nature ( e.g. Locke and Rousseau), or, in the modern form, supposing that the parties are shielded by a "veil of ignorance" (Rawls). This paper will argue that three of the great biblical covenants create knowledge conditions that are remarkably similar to those used in the later philosophical tradition, by shielding the covenanting parties from information about future endowments. These are the covenants with Noah, with Abraham, and (most important of all) the covenant on Sinai. The other great biblical covenant -- the covenant at Shechem involving the people and Joshua -- does not have this feature, since the people are at this point acutely aware of their allocations in the Promised Land. The Bible dispenses with the veil of ignorance in this context for reasons also understood by Rawls and others -- that distributions which are fair ex ante must also be accepted ex post if the people are to be induced to buy in to the social compact.
|
Suffering as a Component of the Mission of God
Program Unit: GOCN Forum on Missional Hermeneutics
James C. Miller, Asbury Theological Seminary
The call for papers for this session requests studies exploring the relationship of suffering to the mission of God. “Suffering” is not a singular entity in the biblical texts. Its causes and its nature, as well as the appropriate responses envisioned, vary widely across canonical writings. This study examines one particular thread of texts in the biblical narrative concerning suffering – those that locate it within the mission of God and God’s people. I argue that although the mission of God, in its broadest terms, consists of bringing blessing to the nations and to creation itself, this blessing for others often arises paradoxically through suffering born by God’s people. The paper begins with a brief review of the mission of God based on the opening chapters of Genesis. Then, in order to establish my thesis that suffering serves as an important theme within the mission of God across multiple portions of the Grand Narrative of Scripture, this paper examines selected portions of the so-called “Servant Songs” of Isaiah (chs. 50, 52-53), the mission of Jesus and Jesus’ missional relationship with his followers in the Gospel of Mark (chs 3, 6, 10), and the missional links between Jesus, Paul, and the Philippians in Paul’s letter to that community (chs. 1-4).
|
Imitatio Romuli and the Semiotics of Mark’s Rousing Ending at 16:8
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Richard C. Miller, Chapman University
The Markan fabulist has provided a tremendously vivid, apropos ending at Mark 16.8. One thus may suitably explain the accretions, whether Mark’s short and long endings or the postmortem accounts in Matthew and Luke, as opportunistic expansions at the end of the scroll, a quite common scribal phenomenon in the transmission histories of ancient literature, in these instances providing super-mundane, epilogical content extending the Markan narrative. As is particularly visible in the Romulean apotheosis traditions deployed in Roman imperial propaganda, post-translation appearances, speeches, ascensions, and eyewitness testimonies became optional appendages to the “translation fable” convention. Thus, while the fabulist provides an evocative, even profound ending at Mark 16:8, albeit abrupt —indeed, such awkward, abrupt endings were all too common in classical literature—ancient readers would not have perceived an ending this rousing as the narrative’s ne plus ultra; the invocation of the Romulean “translation fable” in the final sentence itself invited accretion.
|
Transcendent Rivalitas and the Gospels as Counter-imperial Tracts
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
Richard C. Miller, Chapman University
While the recent upsurge in political readings of the New Testament has beneficially alerted the discourse to the imperial language of these ancient documents, such as provided by Richard Horsely, John Dominic Crossan, and various postcolonial theorists, such interpretations appear to overlook the ascetic, other-worldly disposition of the early Christian movement(s), often yielding reductionistic, specious conclusions. The four Gospels, as fabulous compositions, rendered their Xristos as the transcendent king, not a mundane opponent of the political structures of the day. This paper endeavors to sophisticate the language and comprehension of the political edge of these ancient disruptive texts, ultimately comprehending their semiotic appeal as analogue and metaphor toward an ascetic cultural revolution in classical mediterranean civilization. Imitatio Romuli, a master-trope in the Gospels finding its fullest expression in Luke-Acts, served not as direct political opposition to Rome, but as a strategic ploy signaling the transcendent exaltatio of the etiological founder of a new, supreme order.
|
The Pedagogical Performance of Sapiential Literature in the Ya'ad Movement
Program Unit: Performance Criticism of the Bible and Other Ancient Texts
Shem Miller, Florida State University
This paper discusses educational performance in the Ya?ad movement through an analysis of one example of instructional poetry from Dead Sea Scrolls called “Wiles of the Wicked Woman” (4Q184). In the Qumran community, oral performance was prescribed for all members for the purpose of memorization and instruction of Torah and non-Torah traditions. Although it is impossible to know which non-Torah compositions were performed, there are several aspects of 4Q184 that situate it in a context of oral performance. Its literary styling, which contains highly perceptible parallelisms, repetitive expressions, lists, and a dense saturation of word pairs, aids oral recitation and memorization. Words such as heart, mouth, lips, and ears, moreover, all intimate an environment of oral performance. Lastly, similar to Proverbs, the motifs of the wicked woman and the correct path are dramatically effective pedagogical aids, which promote the values of the community and the formation of sectarian subjectivity. These data collectively demonstrate that “Wiles of the Wicked Woman” could have been performed as a part of the oral-written education curriculum in the Qumran community.
|
The Visible Song of Scribal Performance in Biblical Poetry from the Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Orality, Textuality, and the Formation of the Hebrew Bible
Shem Miller, Florida State University
Preserved among the Dead Sea Scrolls lies a fascinating assortment of stichographically arranged texts. Instead of the typical scriptio continua, scribes have set a handful of lyric passages of biblical poetry into lines of verse by means of added spaces. Stichography, however, is more than a graphical representation poetic structure; it is a scribal practice that reflects the interface between oral performance and writing, which took place in the Ya?ad movement. The scribe from Qumran, in the words of A. Doane, is a special kind of speaking performer who incorporates his understanding of a designated register of utterance into a written copy. Stichography, furthermore, presents what K. O’Keeffe calls a “visible song” because it renders poetry more convenient for recitation and memorization. Although it is unclear how stichographic poetry may have been used by the Qumran community, its oral-written textuality suggests a setting of oral performance. The extent of the corpus, physicality of certain MSS, and intense variation of stichographic arrangements, moreover, supports this social setting.
|
The Memory of Phinehas: Rabbinic Rhetoric of Priestly Violence (Session 3)
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
Yonatan Miller, Harvard University
Perhaps the preeminent exemplar of extolled extra-judicial violence in the Hebrew Bible is Phinehas. Lauded by God for his lethal zeal and blessed with covenants of peace and eternal priesthood, Phinehas continues to loom large in the ancient Jewish imagination. These post-biblical treatments of Phinehas oscillate between emphatically literal embraces of violence and suppressive, quietistic re-readings of the narrative.
Previous studies of the Nachleben of Phinehas have attempted to ground the later literary memories of his actions in concrete historical circumstances. The case of Philo of Alexandria is emblematic of this approach. Philo was particularly enamored of Phinehas' violence, leading some scholars to argue that extra-judicial lynching was part of the normative Jewish legal practice in Alexandria. Recent years, however, have seen a growing skepticism about the use of post-biblical Jewish literary texts for positivistic historical inquiry. Rather than leading to “dead-end criticism,” this skepticism allows for texts to be studied as products of authors or authorial schools embedded in discrete cultural contexts; their identity–or aspired identity–is refracted through their textual production.
If physical violence is a touchstone of particular significance for group identity, the rhetoric of violence serves a similar function. Narratives of violence offer a stylized and highly charged venue for creating new realities and power structures; they are “a kind of theater, where we collaborate in reinventing ourselves and authorizing notions, both individual and collective, of who we are” [1]. These texts thus enter the power-politics of identity formation in an acute sense.
In this paper, I examine the memory of Phinehas' violence in rabbinic texts, how rabbinic writers construct the rhetoric of violence through the text, and the attendant consequences for rabbinic identity formation. I argue that the memory of Phinehas' violence is appropriated as a "theater" for self-expression, with the rabbis reformulating and appropriating the story with an eye toward both past and present. The biblical narrative is presented as an elaborate rabbinic tableau, replete with retrojected rabbinic institutions and argumentation. More importantly, the narrative of Phinehas' violence is brought into the sphere of halakhah and rabbinic law-making as a legal precedent – this despite the lack of prescriptive language in the biblical episode. By bringing Phinehas' ostensible vigilante slaying under the aegis of rabbinic law, the rabbis reinforce their imagined jurisdiction over capital crimes and show further biblical precedent for their authority over matters of ritual law.
In addition to these decided departures from the biblical narrative, the rabbinic renditions of Phinehas' violence display a remarkable degree of continuity with the biblical tradition. Through such moves as disparaging Moses and questioning the priestly pedigree of Phinehas, the rabbis appear to play with priestly violence in the same fashion as the biblical writers themselves – as a rhetorical vehicle for legitimating the fundamental substructures of the writers' religion.
[1] M. Jackson, The Politics of Storytelling (Copenhagen: Museum Tusculanum Press, 2002), 16.
|
An Eye-Tracking Analysis of Students’ Ability to Read Biblical Hebrew
Program Unit: Applied Linguistics for Biblical Languages
Cynthia L. Miller-Naude, University of the Free State
The orthography of Hebrew differs significantly from the orthography of the Latin alphabet. First, it is written from right to left, rather than from left to right. Second, the Latin alphabet is linear, with consonants and vowels having equivalent representational space on the line. The Hebrew alphabet differentiates consonants, which are large letters, from vowels which are superimposed as small marks below or above the consonants. These two features mean that the eye movements required to read Biblical Hebrew differ significantly from those used in reading a Latin alphabet. Furthermore, the Hebrew alphabet requires the reader to interpret the orthography in a variety of ways in order to read correctly. First, the consonants that may function as matres lectiones must be interpreted within the context of the word as either consonants or vowels. Second, the shwa vowel point must be interpreted within the syllable structure of the word as either silent (ending a syllable boundary) or vocal. Third, the qamets must be interpreted within the syllable structure as either representing /o/ in closed, unaccented syllables or /a/ elsewhere. Sixth, dagesh may signal either a doubled consonant (dagesh forte) or a plosive rather than a fricative consonant (dagesh lene); readers must interpret its function within the context of the word. Additional hurdles for reading the biblical text involve the accentual system that is superimposed upon the text and the ketiv-qere variants indicated in the text. Reading Hebrew thus requires the reader to be able to interpret a dramatically different orthography in sophisticated ways.
Eye-tracking technology allows researchers to see exactly what students are focusing on when they read Biblical Hebrew—for example, how long they look at an orthographic feature or whether their eyes regress to a previous feature. It is therefore possible to ascertain the eye movements that fluent speakers of Biblical Hebrew use to interpret the orthography as opposed to the eye movements used by beginning students.
In a series of experiments undertaken at the University of the Free State in collaboration with our colleague T.R. Beelders (computer science), we used eye-tracking technology to examine South African students’ progessive ability to read Biblical Hebrew. The home languages of these students are Afrikaans, English or Sesotho. Three groups of Biblical Hebrew students (20 first years, 15 second years and 6 third years) viewed texts shown individually on an eye-tracker. In the first part of the experiment, they read an Old Testament text (Deuteronomy 31:24-28) in the language of their choice (Afrikaans, English or Sesotho) out loud. In the second part of the experiment, they all read the same text from the Hebrew Bible out loud. The analysis focuses upon the students’ progressive ability to vocalise the Hebrew text and to interpret its orthographic features.
|
Medieval Muslim Intertextuality: Ibn Taymiyya’s Commentary on Whose Daughter Moses Married
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
Younus Mirza, Allegheny College
A common view in scholarship of the Qur’an and Bible is that medieval Muslims did not engage the Bible and it is only in modern times that scholars have employed intertextuality. However, with the increased study of Muslim-Christian-Jewish relations we are discovering that many influential and mainstream Muslim scholars did engage the Bible. Furthermore, scholarship on the Qur’an and Bible has asserted that Muslim exegetes missed the biblical subtext of many qur’anic passages, not realizing that the Qur’an was in dialogue with the Bible. In this paper, I will demonstrate that medieval Muslim exegetes did engage the Bible and biblical literature to answer exegetical questions related to the Qur’an. Specifically, I will examine the exegetical writings of the great theologian, jurist and qur’anic exegetic Ibn Taymiyya on the question of whose daughter Moses married. Ibn Taymiyya challenges a dominant opinion, supported by the influential qur’anic exegete al-Tha‘labi, that Moses married the daughter of the qur’anic prophet Shu‘ayb. Through the tools of hadith criticism, Ibn Taymiyya determines that there is no prophetic hadith on the topic and that Companion traditions state that it was Jericho. Ibn Taymiyya buttresses his opinion by turning to the Bible by explaining that the opinion of Jericho is supported by the Torah and Gospels in the possession of the Jews and Christians of his day. Additionally, Moses could not have married Shu‘ayb’s daughter because he was an Arab prophet and thus spoke Arabic. Moses, in contrast, spoke Hebrew and they could not have communicated as they do in the Qur’an without a translator. Thus, through Ibn Taymiyya’s discussion, we see a unique attempt to use the Bible as a source to answer a qur’anic exegetical question. Ibn Taymiyya does not see a conflict between the relevant biblical and qur’anic passages but rather views them as describing the same historical event.
|
Reading Mark 10:1–12 in Egypt: Marriage and Divorce
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Annelies Moeser, Brite Divinity School (TCU)
Scholars traditionally have approached Jesus’ teaching on divorce in Mark 10:1-12 by seeking to understand it within the cultural context of the historical Jesus, the author of Mark, or the original audience. While numerous proposals for Mark’s provenance exist, discussion generally has been limited to Rome, Syria, and Palestine, most often within the framework of Palestinian Judaism and recently, compared to Roman law.
However, in pursuit of establishing provenance, scholars have paid much less attention to the reception of Mark’s gospel in Egypt. This paper does not argue Mark’s gospel was produced in Alexandria. Rather, this paper explores the possibilities for reception of the gospel in the unique cultural context of first and second century Egypt by putting papyrological evidence concerning marriage and divorce into conversation with the Markan material. The approach is similar to Sjef van Tilborg’s Reading John in Ephesus in which he asked whether cultural symbols in the gospel would have seemed similar to (“resonated”) or different from Ephesian culture as seen in inscriptions.
I consider some aspects of the diversity and complexity of the Egyptian context concerning marriage and divorce. This includes discussion of women’s ability to initiate divorce and their rights to remarriage (e.g., CPJ, vol. 2, no. 144/ BGU 1102; or BGU iv 11103) in contrast with the gospel’s assumption that men initiate divorce and Jesus’ prohibition on remarriage. Jesus’ citation of Gen 1:27; 5:2 is contrasted with the phenomenon of brother-sister marriage. The inability of Roman soldiers in Egypt to contract legal marriages also forms part of the cultural context in which Mark is heard. I argue that there are significant differences between the assumed context of the gospel and that of Egypt, positing that these differences may have posed a challenge to some readers and have influenced the reception of Mark’s gospel.
|
From Open Resistance to Hidden Power: Genette’s ‘Metadiegetic Assessment’ as Key to the ‘Metaleptic Collapse’ of the Kingdom of God in Luke into the Quiet Subversion of Empire in Acts (Acts 1:1–14)
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
David P. Moessner, Texas Christian University
Interpreters of Luke and Acts often wonder why Jesus’ powerful manifestations of “the finger of God” against the “kingdom of Satan” (e.g., Luke 11:17-22), or demands requiring wholesale relinquishing of possessions and control of others (e.g. Luke 14:25-33; 19:1-10) are trans-muted in the Acts to voluntary sharing of house and possessions and the apparent gentrification of those of “means” who join the faith and continue their positions of influence in Roman society (e.g., Acts 4:36-37; 17:4).
Acts 1:4b-5, functioning as metalepsis (cf. Quintilian, Inst.8.6.37-38), provides an important clue to the seeming disparity in the exercise of power between Luke and Acts as the primary level of Jesus’ actions and teachings of the Gospel is transferred and continued in the sequel volume. In the midst of the narrator’s ‘metadiegetic assessment’ (G. Genette) “of all that Jesus began to enact and to teach” (1:2) Jesus himself interrupts this characterization and speaks directly to the apostles of volume one. Through this recapitulatory prooimion in an unprecedented “voice-over,” an author strangely interrupts his/her narratorial voice with the voice of the leading character of the previous volume to echo his speech to the same major characters of the closing narration of Luke 24:49a. In Greek narrative rhetoric the message is clear: Jesus will continue “to act and to teach” in the continuing story. Acts 1:4b-5 thus forms the indispensable bridge between the two volumes as it collapses the world of Jesus and the world of the apostles’ sending into one.
To be sure, the audience of Acts now understands that the power of the Kingdom of God in these acts that follow is the same—the newly enthroned reign of God through Messiah Jesus—(Luke 24:49-51). Yet it also becomes clear that the media and modes for that power have shifted dramatically from an incarnated “Son of God” (Luke 1:34-35) to weak and disloyal followers (e.g., Acts 5:1-11; 6:1) who can, from time to time, show signs of that power but who remain flawed and miss the greater demands of justice prominent in Jesus’ words and deeds (e.g., Peter and the Gentiles, Acts 10:1—11:18). Now in the actions of muted witness, the assault against the power of the Tempter that controls all the kingdoms of the earth (Luke 4:5-8), the claim that Jesus “the Christ,” and not Caesar, is the “the Lord,” “the Savior” (Luke 2:11) of every nation, is diluted and dispersed throughout many cities of empire. Nevertheless, by the time Paul reaches Rome and proclaims “the Kingdom of God” without hindrance to “all” about “the Lord, Jesus Messiah,” the echo of the metaleptic collapse of Jesus’ teaching and enacting with Jesus’ primary witness is also clear enough. Jesus, not Caesar, is the Lord of all (Acts 1:3-5?28:30-31).
|
Although He Was the Son: Reevaluating Supersessionist Accounts of the Christology and Soteriology of Hebrews in Light of Jesus’ Perfection
Program Unit: Hebrews
David Moffitt, University of St. Andrews
Recent work on the logic and practice of sacrifice as depicted in the Pentateuch as well as work on later Jewish purity rituals suggests that conceptions of atonement that limit the meaning of the term to the realm of sin/moral infraction are far too reductive. Atonement has as much to do with matters of ritual purification as with matters of moral infraction. The restoration of communion between humanity and God sought via the process of Jewish ritual codes and blood sacrifice was designed to address the fracture in that relationship by dealing with the twin problems of human sin and human mortality. Atonement, that is, required forgiveness and purification. This finding bears on one of the knottier problems in the interpretation of Hebrews. What does the author mean when he says that Jesus, although he was Son, suffered, and, after he was perfected, became the source of eternal salvation/the high priest of Melchizedek’s order (Heb 5:8-10)? What sense does it make to say that the heavenly Son was perfected? The answer lies in the recognition that Hebrews’ language of perfection verges into the semantic field of ritual purification. Thus, the Son’s perfection entails the purification of Jesus’ humanity. Although as Son he had no need to offer a sacrifice for the forgiveness of his sins (cf. Heb 4:15), his being made like his brothers and sisters in every other respect meant that his humanity was subject to mortality. Hebrews’ priestly Christology and corresponding sacrificial soteriology are, therefore, worked out in a temporal, linear scheme wherein Jesus’ humanity was made perfect/pure after his death. Only then was he able to enter God’s pure and holy presence as high priest. Such a conception, I argue, implies challenges to supersessionistic accounts of Hebrews’ Christology and soteriology.
|
Everything under Control: Hegemonic Masculinity in Matthew 2
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Kendra Mohn, Brite Divinity School (TCU)
This paper engages concepts from gender and masculinity studies in the context of Matthew 2, specifically the concept of hegemonic masculinity as it relates to this chapter’s portrayal of male figures. The analysis includes both the ambiguous characterizations of Joseph and the wise men, whose masculinity intersects with other marginalized aspects of their identity, as well as King Herod, whose power and status render him a candidate for a more idealized understanding of masculinity. Building specifically on Colleen Conway’s conceptualization of hegemonic masculinity in the Greco-Roman world, this paper argues that the writer of Matthew introduces King Herod as the logical, potential hegemonic male at the beginning of the story, only to expose his inadequacy and record his defeat. Herod’s emotional reactions, lack of control over the visiting wise men, and his death all point to his inadequate execution of the masculine ideal. King Herod’s defeat, however, does not necessarily signal a defeat for hegemonic masculinity, but points to God as the one who demonstrates the kind of control, both personal and political, that is integral to the ancient masculine ideal.
|
The African Bantu Concept of Obuntu in the Theology and Practice of Bishop Desmond Tutu and Its Implications for African Biblical Hermeneutics
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Aloo Osotsi Mojola, United Bible Societies
This paper will explore the meaning and implications of the African Bantu concept of Obuntu, and especially as it has been understood by Bishop Desmond Tutu of South Africa in his theology and practice. The powerful influence and impact of this concept in his life and work will be discussed. The paper will also explore how this concept might provide a hermeneutical key for African Biblical hermeneutics or the interpretation of the Bible in Africa, and especially in exploring the urgent and important issues of sexuality, masculinities, HIV and AIDs among others in Africa.
|
The DOR of King Hezekiah: An Unusual Occurrence of the Word DOR in Isa 38:12
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Paola Mollo, Università di Pisa
"The language of poetry is a highly complicated sign structure, and the complex structure of a poem enables it to communicate more information than a non-poetic text can provide" (B. Ilek). For this reason, when a scholar who deals with biblical lexicography tackles a literary and poetical text from the Hebrew Bible, he/she not only has the now commonly performed task of investigating words starting from their use in language (sentence and discourse), but also has to analyze them as words of literary language, using a special lens, taking into account their elements of poetry and literature: sound, rhythm, expressivity, images, ambiguity, irony, characterization, atmosphere, convention, invention, mimesis, etc.
This paper aims to penetrate the "language of the poetical language" of Isa 38:9-20, a text also known as "the psalm of Hezekiah", king of Judah. In this lyric poem the king recounts in the first person a particularly difficult moment of his life: illness. In the initial verses the word DOR occurs within a sequence of negative feelings and images, as a symbol of the forthcoming death of the ruler. But, what is this mysterious DOR "about to be plucked up and removed" - according to Hezekiah's words? His generation? His home? His very life? Ancient and modern translations provide different interpretations of this issue. This is due, in my opinion, to the ambiguous, unconventional and creative use in this "psalm" of the word DOR.
Thanks to this example of "unusual” occurrence, the present paper contributes to the knowledge of the meaning of the word DOR and, at the same time, provides a specimen of lexicographic study applied to the language of poetry.
This study integrates three critical tools of analysis: lexicological-linguistic, stylistic-literary and textual. Information about syntagmatic and paradigmatic relationships, patterns and combinations in which words are used arises from the lexicological-linguistic analysis. Literary elements (e.g. context, structure, sound, intertextuality, expressivity) governing lexical and linguistic choices are highlighted in the stylistic-literary analysis. Finally, the textual analysis illustrates – especially in ancient translations - how the meaning of this passage and of this specific occurrence of DOR have been recognised and transmitted in different ways in biblical languages.
|
The Final Appearance: Characters in John 20 (and 21)
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Francis J. Moloney, Australian Catholic University
Applying narrative theory to the Johannine use of characters, several elements come together in John 20, and the appendix of John 21. Characters who have appeared earlier in the narrative reappear with significant roles: Simon Peter, the Beloved Disciple, the disciples, Mary Magdalene, and Thomas. It would appear that these “final appearances” enable the storyteller to bring closure to the characterization of these important players in the story, and use them to “carry the message” of the Gospel. Such does not appear to be the case. All characters are subordinated to another “voice” in the story: the narrator in 20:9 and in 20:30-31, especially when vv. 30-31 are read/heard in close conjunction with v. 29. Indeed, because Simon Peter and the Beloved Disciple return home in 20:10, not yet knowing the Scripture (v. 9), John 21 is added to the story to determine their respective roles.
|
The Rhetoric of Narrative in Acts 8:26–40: Ramifications of the Baptism of the Ethiopian Eunuch for the Author of Luke-Acts
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
David G. Monaco, Pontifical College Josephinum
In the introduction to his work Narrative as Rhetoric, James Phelan discusses the multileveled narratives of stories and speaks of a “multilayered” experience of literature. In the New Testament, the story of Philip and the Ethiopian eunuch is a singular example of the accuracy of his insights. The author of Acts seems to be using the story to argue for an inclusive, as opposed to an exclusive, emphasis on the part of the early Christian community. Both are legitimate and time-honored perspectives within the biblical tradition the author inherited, but the rhetoric of the Acts story pushes the reader/hearer to engage his/her cognitive abilities, ethical values, and emotions in order to opt for the former over the latter. The baptism of the Ethiopian eunuch by the evangelist Philip presents the reader of the Acts of the Apostles with a powerful text of liberation, fulfillment of promise, and boundary breaking. As the conclusion of the eighth chapter of Acts, the author uses it to demonstrate how the early community, most notably its Hellenistic Jewish element, should respond to persecution, death, and potential defeat not by retreating into itself, but by moving forward into mission. Given that the preceding chapter chronicles the death by stoning of one member of the community followed by a persecution against and dispersal of the church in Jerusalem, one might see the tale of the Ethiopian eunuch as proof of the famed final version of the quote often attributed to Tertullian: “The blood of martyrs is the seed of Christians.”
|
Past the Post? The Slight Rise and Precipitous Decline of Postmodernism in Biblical Studies
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Stephen D. Moore, The Theological School, Drew University
[The following abstract is submitted for consideration for the "open session for papers that explore the potential and impact of new developments in philosophical thought and critical theory on biblical studies and biblical texts."]
Postmodernism's heyday in biblical studies was characterized by an identification of postmodernism not just with poststructuralist theory but also with ideological criticism and even with liberation hermeneutics. This “big tent” version of biblical postmodernism was epitomized by The Postmodern Bible and The Postmodern Bible Reader, and it attempted to position liberation hermeneutics, in all its variations, under the postmodern canopy. This paper will reflect on the broader cultural moment that impelled that bold gesture. It will also reflect more generally on the subsequent fate of postmodernism in biblical studies and the academy at large. Even today, the term “postmodernism,” not least as used in biblical studies, tends to plaster over significant differences. It is a term of homogenization, of oversimplification. It is a polemical term, on the one hand, a crudely constructed target. It is a rallying cry, on the other hand, or a banner under which to march—or was a banner or rallying cry, at any rate. As a concept, postmodernism has been leaking energy for quite some time. Biblical scholars attuned to developments in critical and cultural theory have all but ceased to apply the postmodern label to their projects, mirroring the situation in literary and cultural studies in which “the postmodernism debate” has receded into the past and been replaced a proliferation of studies in the “what was postmodernism?” or “after postmodernism” mode. This paper will ponder the brief but instructive history of postmodernism in biblical studies, from its modest heyday in the 1980s and 1990s to its unlikely present in which the term is far more likely to be found in the title of an evangelical work than in a work informed by poststructuralist (or post-poststructuralist) theory, on the one hand, or ideological criticism or liberation hermeneutics, on the other.
|
More Than a Feeling: Affect Theory and Biblical Studies
Program Unit: Bible and Emotion
Stephen Moore, Drew University
Few developments in recent literary and cultural studies have generated as much interest as affect theory. Affect theory emerged partly in reaction to, and from dissatisfaction with, the classic poststructuralist preoccupation with language and, by extension, with cognition. Affect theory grapples instead with the pre-processed sensory encounter with the world prior to conscious cognition, linguistic representation, or even identifiable emotion. Yet affect theory is also preoccupied with emotion, and emotion is a remarkably underanalyzed topic in biblical studies, given that emotions swirl and eddy so powerfully and so patently through most biblical texts. This paper explores the potential intersections of affect theory with biblical studies in general and selected New Testament texts in particular.
|
From the Fords of the Jordan to the Valley of Sorek: Ethnic and Tribal Boundaries in the Book of Judges
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
Stewart Moore, Yale University
Reconstructions of the emergence of Israel in the twelfth and eleventh centuries BCE rely more and more on archaeological data and less and less on the biblical materials. While reviewing the biblical account with a critical eye is both necessary and salutary, there may remain some accurate memories of the “time of the judges” in the monarchical Book of Judges. This paper will use the anthropological and sociological study of ethnicity alongside archaeological studies of the highlands to investigate with which groups proto-Israelite groups were in relation, and the nature of that relationship. It is necessary to use the biblical materials to reconstruct ethnicity, because it is becoming increasingly clear that Iron Age archaeology preserves extremely little that would count as an ethnic marker. If the color of the thread in the fringe of your garment could assign you to one group or another, the fact that both groups use collared-rim jars might count for little. In this perspective, it appears that the boundary between proto-Israel and the “Canaanites,” marked by worship of Baal, is indeed a product of northern monarchical circles of the ninth century BCE, and does not represent an accurate memory of Iron Age I. However, other boundaries appear more credible. The two most strongly-drawn boundaries in the older material of Judges are those between the proto-Israelites and the Ishmaelites, and between the proto-Israelites and the Philistines. Relations with both these groups are complex, showing both positive and negative possibilities. Yet when we turn to the boundaries among proto-Israelite tribes, we see they are drawn in precisely the same way, with classic markers like dialect and economic niche being used to distinguish them. Nor is the relationship between tribes any less complex than that between ethnic groups. Intermarriage between tribes seems as notable as that between ethnicities. More vividly, the practice of herem is used only against fellow tribes in Judges, not against other ethnicities. Herem as a practice appears to be a marker of proto-Israelite identity in Judges, as an essential part of holy war ideology. This may account for the disappearance of the mysterious tribe, Meroz, which is cursed for failure to fight in the Song of Deborah. The appearance of this practice in the Mesha Stele indicates the existence of a time when the Moabites might have constituted a proto-Israelite group, which instead eventually became distinguished on the basis of the god of tribal allegiance. This points to YHWH-devotion as the confederating principle among the tribes that would eventually become Israel.
|
The Mysteries and 1 Cor 15:29: Comparative Methodology and Contextual Exegesis
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Terri Moore, Dallas Theological Seminary
The Mysteries and 1 Cor 15:29: Comparative Methodology and Contextual Exegesis
|
Pleading for Exclusive Allegiance: Ephraem of Nisibis’ Polemics against Plurality and Liberality within His Own Congregation
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Robert J. Morehouse, Saint Leo University
In fourth century northern Mesopotamia, Ephraem of Nisibis strove to effectively admonish his congregants against Manichaean teaching and practice. Ephraem composed hymns, which he taught to his congregation. Their polemics reveal Ephraem’s genuine concern that his audience was far too familiar with Manichaeism, being taken in by its piety and its simple religious economy. His prose refutations against Manichaeism appear to have been intended for a more educated audience, but also betray his fears about the influence of Manichaeism on the ninety-nine percent. Ephraem makes generous concessions about the devotion and charity of his opponents, acknowledging that they pray and fast earnestly, that they care for the sick and even perform miracles, including healing the sick. In general his remarks about their behavior and character are quite positive. However, his counter claim is that their good deeds are a ploy. They are the sheep’s clothing that the wolves wear to deceive his flock, whom Ephraem fears are far too easily taken in. He warns his audience fiercely that while the Manichaeans’ deeds may appear fine, their teachings are poison that will ultimately kill any who continue to imbibe it. This paper focuses on Ephraem’s efforts to condition the mind of his congregation against Manichaeism in spite of the apparent laudability of the sect. It demonstrates that Ephraem’s interest, or at least his rhetoric, was not focused on a battle of elites, but instead on the hearts and minds of his listeners, which he was striving to win for Nicean orthodoxy, and thus to guide to true salvation, as he saw it.
|
Circumcision of the Spirit: Type and Pneumatology in Cyril of Alexandria
Program Unit: Development of Early Christian Theology
Jonathan Morgan, Toccoa Falls College
For students of Christian theology, Cyril of Alexandria is perhaps best known for his doctrine of Christ. This reputation is due to his role in the Christological debates of the fifth century that led to the Councils of Ephesus and Chalcedon. Further, scholars have noted that a robust Christo-centrism undergirds his biblical exegesis and theology. Cyril’s pneumatology, however, has not received the scholarly attention it deserves, in spite of the fact that the Spirit is essential to Cyril’s narrative of salvation. From the original gift of the Spirit at creation (Gen 2:7), to the loss of the Spirit in the Fall (Gen 3), culminating in the redistribution of the Spirit through the risen Christ (John 20:22), pneumatological concerns permeate Cyril’s thought. While references to the Spirit are scattered throughout Cyril’s corpus, some of his most revealing pneumatological insights are found in his interpretations of biblical passages relating to circumcision. For Cyril, the Jewish rite of circumcision was a shadow of a New Testament reality that tells us a great deal about the Spirit’s role in God’s saving economy, and how the Spirit’s relationship to the Father and the Son demonstrates the inseparable operations of the three Persons. In this paper I will explore important circumcision passages in Cyril’s biblical commentaries where he develops his doctrine of the Holy Spirit, and put forth some possible implications of Cyril’s pneumatology for Christian theology.
|
To Err Is Human . . . To Correct Divine? Paired Stories of Divine Responses to Human Error in Graeco-Roman and Christian Literature
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Teresa Morgan, University of Oxford
This paper builds on my recent work on divine-human relations in Greek and Roman popular wisdom to discuss stories in Graeco-Roman and Christian (with reference also to some Jewish) sources in which God or the gods correct human mistakes in religious ritual or understanding. I am interested here less in narratives about deliberate disobedience or sin, than in those of what we might call ‘honest mistakes’ in religious thought or action. Greek and Roman wisdom literature, such as fables and chreiai, offers a number of such stories, which have gone almost unnoticed, but which attest a widespread sense that the gods are keenly interested in human beings’ understanding, as well as honouring them. I pair some of these stories with Christian stories of divine responses to human error, exploring their similarities and differences. I then consider what such stories tell us about the negotiation of orthodoxy and orthopraxy in different religious groups, and reflect on the relationship between these and more familiar narratives of sin, repentance, and conversion.
|
Chippings from the Laughterless Rock: Popular Perceptions of Demeter and Her Cult
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Teresa Morgan, University of Oxford
Demeter, Kore, the Eleusinian Mysteries and other cults of the goddess are the theme of a number of proverbs, gnomic sayings, fables, and other fragments of ‘popular’ Greek wisdom which circulated, in some cases over centuries, round the Greek-speaking Mediterranean. This paper builds on the methodology I have developed over the past decade for studying Graeco-Roman popular mentalités, which, I argue, enables us to use such material as a source for religious thinking below the level of socio-intellectual elites. Approaching Demeter, Kore, and their cults through popular genres opens up a distinctive and largely unexplored perspective on the goddesses which can be fruitfully, and sometimes surprisingly, juxtaposed with elite accounts and material evidence.
|
Scriptural Apotropaism in the Matthean and Lucan Temptation
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Michael Morris, Trinity College - Dublin
The Matthean and Lucan Temptation narratives (Matt 4:1-11; Lk 4:1-13) portray an exchange between Jesus and Satan in which passages from Deuteronomy and Psalm 91 are invoked. The role played by these Scripture citations in the pericope is often interpreted by comparing the dialogue to models of rabbinic disputation. However, a fresh perspective on the function of the scriptural quotations in light of the Dead Sea Scrolls may be in order.
I analyze, in two sections, the use of Scripture in the Matthean and Lucan Temptation together with apotropaic traditions at Qumran. I first consider the function of Psalm 91. Given the broader first-century association of Psalm 91 with the ability to “ward off” demonic evil, it is unusual that the gospel text attributes the psalm to Satan. Some scholars, for example Matthias Henze, have noted in passing that Satan “inverts” the typical meaning of the psalm. Drawing upon passages which have not been considered within this discussion, I examine the “inversion” theory alongside the larger background of Qumran anti-demonic techniques. A passage from 11QApocryphal Psalms is given specific attention. Second, the quotations from Deuteronomy are assessed in comparison to the apotropaic use of Scripture in early Jewish practice. Here, the nature of “the Law” in the Damascus Document is particularly revealing.
The results of my paper are two-fold: (1) the likely presence of analogous demonological features in Dead Sea Scrolls texts and in the Temptation pericope is demonstrated, and (2) the purpose of the Hebrew Bible quotations in the pericope are put into sharper focus.
|
Power Play: Jesus, the Hemorrhaging Woman, and Defining Disabled Identity
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Michelle J. Morris, Southern Methodist University
In the course of this paper, I will use disability studies to read the story of the hemorrhaging woman recounted in Mark 5:24b-34 in a manner that challenges typical readings of this passage. To begin, I will use the social model of disability studies to distinguish between the woman’s impairment and her disabilities. Then, extending the work of Candida Moss on this passage, I will argue that Jesus' insistence that the woman announce her cure was his attempt to take his power flow back, which may or may not have served the woman well.
|
The Natural and Supernatural, Ceremony and the Heart: Spinoza’s Use of the Psalms
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Jeffrey Morrow, Seton Hall University
Although Baruch Spinoza’s Tractatus Theologico-politicus is a work of political philosophy, it contains a good deal of biblical interpretation, and, in fact, a significant portion of Spinoza’s text is devoted to biblical exegesis. Spinoza even devotes an entire chapter (his seventh) to the issue of method in biblical interpretation. Spinoza attempted to place exegesis on a firm methodological footing by borrowing a methodological framework from the sciences and the discipline of history. One of the portions of the Bible from which he draws is the Book of Psalms. In particular, throughout the first, third, fifth, sixth, tenth, and seventeenth chapters of his Tractatus Theologico-politicus, Spinoza examines and utilizes a number of Psalms: 15, 33, 40, 51, 73, 88, 89, 104, 105, 135, 139, 143, 145, 147, and 148. He uses these Psalms within an apologetic framework, in defense of his political philosophy. In some instances, the Psalms serve to naturalize what was often considered supernatural among Jews and Christians. In other instances, they serve to support one or more aspects concerning Spinoza’s concept of God. Chief among these uses to which he puts the Psalms, is his use of Psalm 40 in his fifth chapter on the role of religious ceremonies within the Bible. He uses Psalm 40 to deemphasize the importance of external ritual, following a long history within the Protestant Reformation. This serves an important function within his overall political philosophy, wherein he asserts the authority of the state on all matters pertaining to the public realm, including religious ceremonies and rituals. This paper will thus examine Spinoza’s use of the Psalms in this foundational work of modern political philosophy, situating it within Spinoza’s seventeenth century socio-political context.
|
A Monster in Paradise
Program Unit: Gender, Sexuality, and the Bible
Holly Morse, University of Oxford
For those who are familiar with story of Adam and Eve from its incarnations in popular culture, the narrative is likely to come with a horror story gloss, where the talking snake is really the Devil in disguise, and the first woman, Eve, is his dangerous, but irresistibly seductive accomplice. To put it differently, for many readers there are monsters that inhabit Paradise, taking the form of satanic reptiles and grotesque femininity. In this paper I am particularly interested in exploring the latter gendered aspect of monstrosity that creeps into the Garden story when encountered by later readers. Thus, I consider two specific aspects of Eve’s transformation by her interpreters: the first focuses on the development of a tradition that constructs her motherhood as horrific and bestial by elaborating on her relationship with the serpent. Secondly, I direct attention to the construction of a perhaps more insidious, though less fantastical Kristevan abjection of Eve by her male interpreters, who present her labouring and fecund body described in Gen 3:16 as a source of monstrous otherness. I then conclude by reflecting on the roots these interpretations have in the biblical text, and by confronting Yahweh Elohim’s problematic complicity in the establishment of a savage chauvinism in Eden. Ultimately, my own aim is to reread the characters of Eve and God, using feminist eyes to look through the lens of patriarchal rewritings back onto the biblical text, and thus adopt a mode of metacommentary to critique Gen 2—3, as well as its interpreters.
|
Negotiating Disclosure
Program Unit:
Candida Moss, University of Notre Dame
*
|
Christ as Cosmic Victor and Emetic: Salvation in the Letter of the Churches of Lyon and Vienne
Program Unit: Texts and Traditions in the Second Century
Candida R. Moss, University of Notre Dame
This paper will explore the models and imagery of salvation in the Letter (Martyrdom) of Lyon and Vienne. It will investigate both the cosmic battle trope and the ambiguous role that the martyrs play alongside Jesus as actors in their own salvation. It will argue that ideas about cosmic battle combine with medical imagery to produce a complicated vision of salvation that both pre-dates the Christus Victor models ascribed to later Patristic authors and develops and augments the notion of cosmic victory found in Revelation.
|
Umayyad Legitimacy and the Commemoration of bani Isra’il at al-Haram al-Sharif in Jerusalem
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Heba Mostafa, University of California, Berkeley
The commemorative practices undertaken by the Umayyad ‘Abd al-Malik b. Marwan on the site of the Haram al-Sharif (former Temple Mount) in Jerusalem has been the focus of intense scholarly attention in recent decades. Their significance is enhanced by their association with specific events relating to the People of Israel (bani Isra’il) in Quranic narratives. These narratives are fasicnating due to their close association with the mediation of divine authority within architectural space. This included a group of ma?arib (commemorative structures) mentioned in the Quran that include the mi?rab Da’ud (Qur’an 38:23-26), the mi?rab of Mary (Quran 3:37) and the mi?rab of Zakariyya (Quran 3:39). A common feature of these Quranic narratives is their evocation of some form of divine communication, such as the endowment of the right to rule (khilafa) to David within his mi?rab. This paper will explore these commemorative practices in the context of Umayyad legitimizing efforts.
|
The Four Lands of Mesha: An Analysis of Transjordanian Geography
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
David Z. Moster, New York University
The Mesha Inscription, commissioned by Mesha, king of Moab in the mid-ninth century BCE, contains a wealth of geographic information. According to the legible lines of the text, there were three “lands” within Moab itself: the land of Madaba, the land of Ataroth, and the land of Dhiban. The goal of this study is to understand what Mesha means by this terminology. What was and what was not the land of Madaba? What was and what was not the land of Ataroth? What was and what was not the land of Dhiban? A fourth land, what I shall call “the land of Horonaim,” is not present in the text but can be hypothesized for the last three lines, which are almost entirely broken. This leads to a fourth question, what was and what was not the land of Horonaim?
This study attempts to demarcate the basic areas of these four lands and to place them within the greater context of Transjordanian geography during the biblical period. Because the borders of the lands are not described with any detail in the Mesha Inscription, the observations made here are by definition conjectural. However, the underlying premise is straightforward: geographical regions tend to correspond to the natural features of the land. This premise would have been especially true for Mesha's Moab, which was bordered by the Dead Sea in the west, the Arabian Desert in the east, and cut into subsections by deep and wide east-west wadis and canyons.
|
Sight and Sightlessness: An Evaluation of the Exegetical Diversity of Samson's Blindness
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Vincent Moulton, Temple University
Interpreters have offered numerous readings of Samson's blindness. For example, they have associated it with divine retribution, his nazirite vow, his lust for Philistine women, feminization, infantilization, powerlessness, forced labor, spiritual insight, faith development, and so on. Nevertheless, the text itself only confirms that the Philistines captured Samson and gouged out his eye(s). The text provides no explanation for why his captors removed his eye(sight). This paper will explore exegetical strategies and assumptions about disabilities that allow interpreters to portray Samson’s blindness as more than sightlessness.
|
Rhetorical Space as an Analytic Lens for Interpretation
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Roxanne D. Mountford, University of Kentucky
Prior to the publication of The Gendered Pulpit: Preaching in American Protestant Spaces, the concept of “rhetorical space” was used to refer to the conditions surrounding speech acts. For example, in Rhetorical Spaces: Essays on Gendered Locations, feminist philosopher Lorraine Code theorizes the geography of argument in this way, noting that “the very possibility of an utterance counting as ‘true-or-false’ or of a discussion yielding insight” depends on one's location (x). She uses the example of women attempting to have “productive public debate about abortion in the Vatican in 1995” (x). Code calls this phenomenon “rhetorical space,” which rhetoricians in turn recognize as “the rhetorical situation.” It is a familiar observation in rhetoric, stretching back in its most basic form to the early Greek concept of nomos, traditionally translated as “custom” or “law” (Kerferd 112). Aristotle suggested that a rhetor must modulate his speech for the old, the young, and for women, groups whose beliefs create an exigency that must be accounted for in the invention process. Particular traits presumed to adhere to these groups offer “cues” for how one must argue, act, or even be. But in The Gendered Pulpit and in projects that later drew on it (see Buchanan; Marback), rhetorical space is theorized as the material conditions surrounding speech acts that affect how an audience encounters a rhetorical event. The Gendered Pulpit, of course, uses women ministers and their preaching as the focus of analysis, revealing along the way that rhetoric has a long history of presuming—or in fact upholding the status of—male rhetors. As conversations about the “ground” for rhetorical performance have progressed, rhetors have even begun to question the extent to which a subject can exist apart from its ground (Rickert). Arguably, this conversation is deeply important for biblical interpretation, since early Christian writing now circulates well outside the material/cultural conditions in which it was produced and received, prompting biblical scholars like Marcus Borg to reinterpret texts in a way that recaptures the “ground” of their being. This paper updates the concept of rhetorical space and proposes it as lens for understanding early Christian texts.
|
Ancient Household Codes as Model for Present-Day Communities of Character (in Africa)?
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Elna Mouton, Stellenbosch University
On the implied rhetorical function of Ephesians 5:21-6:9.
In a world characterised by numerous expressions of power abuse, how and where would people of moral character be formed – people with the identity awareness, vision and integrity of God’s alternative kingdom as embodied in and through Jesus of Nazareth?
It is believed by Christian narrative ethicists that communities of moral discernment and character (such as households, churches, schools) can serve as powerful social networks in providing the stability and security where people learn to become accountable readers of scripture, and to live wisely in the world of biblical narratives. In such communities people are encouraged to live faithfully and intelligibly according to biblical perspectives on God and humanity, i.e. in continuation with the implied rhetorical effect of these texts (ES Fiorenza). Through the transformative encounter between the living God and people, it is believed that these ancient texts have the potential to continue to (re)shape people’s memory, imagination, language, and behaviour in present-day contexts.
However, since Christianity’s foundational documents originated from within patriarchal societies, deeply influenced by the hierarchical ethos of empire, communities of character today are profoundly challenged to be transformed into safe spaces where open, critical-constructive conversation on gender and bible can take place. A major challenge for such discourse would be whether and how the biblical documents themselves provide a hermeneutical lens through which they may be re-read today – even against their patriarchal grain and history of interpretation.
The paper explores the dynamic of ancient households in general, and NT household codes in particular, and their relevance for faith communities today. It focuses on the proposed world (P Ricoeur) opened up and mediated by the reconfigured household code of Ephesians 5:21-6:9, representing a network of relations among household members which ancient (and post-colonial African?) audiences were/are invited to adopt.
|
Ancient Activists: Using Modern Analogues to Teach the Biblical Prophets
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Clinton J. Moyer, Wake Forest University School of Divinity
This presentation proposes engaging the biblical “writing prophets” alongside familiar modern voices that seek to drive social change in a manner analogous to what we encounter in the biblical context. Two examples are particularly instructive. First, Martin Luther King’s oratory provides an opportunity to consider standardized language, rhetorical tropes, and the exploitation of communal narratives as important items in the prophetic toolkit. Second, selected poems by Wendell Berry highlight the power of poetic speech to express profound truths about a specific issue.
The primary pedagogical purpose of such an approach is to address the potentially challenging balancing act that exists in a first-time academic introduction to the writing prophets. On the one hand, one must provide an adequate foundation in the cultural context and historical circumstances within which biblical prophecy emerged. But undue insistence on the ancient Near Eastern background of biblical prophecy, without sufficient regard for its content and expressive nature, can reduce the genre to a complex of arcane divinatory or ritual components, which both “others” the material and obscures its rich literary sophistication. On the other hand, overemphasis on its distinctive stylistic and ethical power, at the expense of sustained consideration of the surrounding ancient Near Eastern environment, risks reinforcing the assumption of some kind of Yahwistic monopoly on “real” prophecy, and also may unduly weight its relevance for a modern audience over the significance of its original context.
The two examples presented demonstrate that this approach brings students into more immediate contact with the sociohistorical context of biblical prophecy, by helping them to reimagine the prophets as real human individuals addressing social concerns relevant to their own experiences, rather than as vaunted, quasi-magical, and often largely inaccessible figures. This in turn enables students to retain a remarkable degree of detail as they digest the biblical prophetic corpus, and brings into sharper focus elements in this literature that are both ancient and familiar, such as advocating for the marginalized in society. Thus “demystified,” the prophets take on a new accessibility, and students encounter both ancient and modern voices with new eyes.
|
Is Ben Sira among the Pseudepigrapha? Attribution and the Myth of the First Jewish Author
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Eva Mroczek, Indiana University (Bloomington)
In a literary culture of pseudepigraphic or anonymous authorship, Ben Sira is considered to be the first named Jewish author, marking a watershed in the history of Jewish literature. In this paper, however, I argue that this uniqueness has been overstated, and has kept Ben Sira from participating in fruitful conversations in Pseudepigrapha studies about the development of textual traditions and authoritative figures in Jewish antiquity.
First, I show that besides the use of his own name, nothing marks the tradent of Ben Sira as an “author” in any modern sense: he draws on conventional and stylized language to place himself in a chain of inspired, ideal teachers. He presents his persona as an ideal scribe, a gleaner following his predecessors, and a channel for the great sea of revealed wisdom that neither begins nor ends with his own individual creativity, but enables its own future expansion. The sense of Ben Sira as an individual authorial personality, I argue, is shaped by the modern scholarly desire to categorize texts based on recognizable bibliographical principles, and on our interest in individual historical biography. It is also coloured by the Greek translation of 50:27 and the translator’s prologue, rather than the Hebrew witnesses, where Ben Sira’s individuality and connection to a “book” are far less clear. Second, I argue that the set of traditions called “Ben Sira” seems to have gone through similar kinds of expansive development as traditions related to Enoch, Solomon, or other pseudepigraphic heroes. Moreover, in rabbinic reception, “Ben Sira” is both an amorphous textual tradition and a generative ideal character around whom new wisdom sayings accumulate—becoming, in a sense, a pseudepigraphic figure himself.
Despite the use of his name, then, the production, transmission, and reception of Ben Sira as text and a tradition is hardly different from that of those literatures and heroes typically included in the study of pseudepigraphic literatures. Placing these materials in conversation with one another can both enrich our understanding of the history of text production and authorial attribution in early Judaism, and trouble our conventional ways of categorizing our sources.
|
The Byzantine Text of Revelation
Program Unit: Novum Testamentum Graecum: Editio Critica Maior
Darius Müller, Protestant University Wuppertal/Bethel
As it is well known the textual history of the book of Revelation exhibits many peculiarities when compared to all other writings of the New Testament. This especially relates to the so-called Byzantine text, which is separated into two families according to Josef Schmid: the Koine-Text K (MK) and the Text of the Commentary of Andrew ?? (MA). This phenomenon not only provides some troubles for Textual Criticism, furthermore it is very fascinating in text historical and theological perspectives, which I would like to demonstrate with some examples from our Wuppertal database of test passages being completed this year.
|
Literary Growth and Theological Development in Joshua 23
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Reinhard Müller, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
This paper investigates the logic and literary coherence of Josh 23. It demonstrates that this chapter contains different ideas of covenant theology as well as different concepts of the conquest. Based on these observations it can be concluded that Josh 23 was in all likelihood written by more than one author. The paper shows how the probable literary growth of the chapter is related to later stages in the composition of the book of Joshua.
|
The Anti-idolatry Polemic in OG Habakkuk
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
James A. E. Mulroney, University of Edinburgh
The OG translator of the Twelve used the word phantasia in Hab 2:18-19 to distinctly mark the nature of this rebuke against idolatry. The word is unique to the Twelve (also Hab 3:10; Zech 10:1), and also used by the author of Wisdom of Solomon. Outside of the Septuagint it has a very lively use within heady philosophical debates, beginning with Plato and most notably in the Stoa. Its use and meaning developed up until the Neoplatonists, and was translated and reformulated by Augustine and Christian medieval thinkers (i.e. Aquinas). In the occasion of the Twelve, it connoted particular ideas related to the nature of mental images and the divine, which, by consequence, also bore upon how to understand an idol-sculptor’s ability to craft a god. Use of this word by the translator of the Twelve not only pointed out the folly of idolatry, but undermined contemporary philosophical ideas concerning the reality and nature of the divine. By using the technical jargon of the day the translator cleverly addressed these things.
|
Offering Sacrifices and Ransoming Temples: Cyprian, Paul, and Care for the Poor and Captive
Program Unit: Contextualizing North African Christianity
Edwina Murphy, Morling College and Macquarie University
Cyprian believed that the Scriptures spoke directly to Christians living in third-century Roman North Africa. The ways in which he appropriated them to address the challenges facing his flock give us an insight into how theology, text and context are interwoven in his biblical interpretation. Cyprian’s preoccupations as bishop, therefore, provide a useful lens through which to study his use of Scripture.
One of Cyprian’s dominant pastoral concerns was care for the poor and captive. A number of recent studies have examined the early church’s teaching on this subject. In addition, there has been a revival of interest in the reception of Paul. As a contribution to both these fields, and the study of early North African exegesis, I examine all the quotations of and allusions to the canonical Paul in Cyprian’s exhortations to care for the poor and captive. I also consider how Cyprian used Paul to qualify his teaching on almsgiving and to warn against the dangers of wealth.
|
“Is This the End of Everything?” Aronofsky’s Noah among Apocalypses
Program Unit: Genesis
Kelly J. Murphy, Central Michigan University
You don’t have to look very far to find the Apocalypse—from zombies in Sprint commercials, Harold Camping’s failed predictions, to a plethora of Hollywood films that focus on the impending end of the world. The apocalypse is all around us. As is often observed, popular culture regularly reflects larger societal concerns; based on many recent films, from the on-screen adaptation of Cormac McCarthy’s The Road, to 2012, Warm Bodies, or Aronofky’s Noah, it appears that Americans are obsessed about imaging the end, in varying guises. Yet though we might frequently speak of “end of the world” films and literature, apocalypses are about both fear and hope, endings and beginnings. This paper will contextualize Aronofsky’s film Noah alongside other recent apocalyptic films and literature, especially those with strong Noah allusions. The paper will examine the ways that various contemporary popular culture apocalypses draw on Noahic imagery, and will also explore the way that contemporary pop culture mirrors ancient apocalyptic texts by both expressing overarching societal fears/anxieties and exploring the rhetoric of hope and new beginnings.
|
“Open Your Hand to the Poor”: The Afterlives of Biblical Polyvocality on Poverty
Program Unit: Poverty in the Biblical World
Kelly J. Murphy, Central Michigan University
As is often the case with any number of subjects, the Hebrew Bible contains many voices on the topic of the poor. For example, the book of Deuteronomy repeatedly affirms care of the stranger, widow, and orphan, stressing the need to safeguard these economically disadvantaged members of ancient Israelite society. Yet while Deut 15:4 claims that there will be “no one in need among you because the LORD is sure to bless you,” Deut 15:11 follows this statement by declaring, “there will never cease to be some in need on the earth.” Additionally, while texts such as those found in Proverbs often place the blame for poverty on the victim, there are also an overwhelming number of texts that more promisingly articulate community and/or state responsibility for people’s economic sufficiency found throughout the Torah, the so-called Deuteronomistic History, the Psalms, and the Prophets. Drawing on anthropological, historical, and sociological studies, this paper will examine the original contexts of select Hebrew Bible texts that address poverty and what historical circumstances might have led to the present polvocality. From the biblical texts and their original contexts, the paper will then explore how later thinkers and communities, ranging from Rashi to Veggie Tales and beyond, have used or rejected these key texts on poverty and collective responsibility in order to better understand their continuing pertinence today.
|
A Marriage of Law and Love: A Exploration of a Dialogue between Ruth and Paul
Program Unit: Bible and Ethics
Meghan Musy, McMaster Divinity College
The book of Ruth is a well-loved story in the Hebrew Bible that is often cherished for Ruth’s loyalty and Boaz’s nobility. A critical reading of the well-loved book of Ruth raises questions about the ways in which the characters break cultural norms as well as the rhetorical purpose of such an artfully constructed piece of literature. Previous scholarship has highlighted feminist critical issues within this narrative, gleaned the text for its theological and moral import, and addressed the spatial aspects of the narrative. The narrative continues to stir intrigue for canonical readers of the Hebrew Bible as it creates tension between the hesed of the characters and the torah of Yahweh (e.g., Deuteronomy and Ezra). The actions of Boaz and Ruth, which are described as being motivated by hesed on the horizontal plane, could be interpreted as breaking Yahweh’s prescriptions and prohibitions, particularly in regard to foreignness. Thus, their horizontal hesed undercuts their hesed toward Yahweh. On the contrary, this paper will carefully explore the ways in which Yahweh’s laws are leveraged within an ancient Israelite community to enact hesed within the community and towards Yahweh. Then, it will explore Ruth’s marriage of law and love in light of Paul’s rhetoric of law and grace.
|
Topographies of Person: Mapping Ancient Characterization in the Gospel of John
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Alicia D. Myers, Campbell University Divinity School
This presentation will offer a literary-rhetorical method for understanding characters in the Gospel of John based on the examination of rhetorical and classical literatures. The multiplying collection of publications on characters and characterization in the Gospel of John in recent years demonstrates the pressing interest in this topic. Yet, while increased attention has been given to the subtle nuancing of Johannine characters, little has been given to how ancient Greco-Roman models of characterization can help our understanding of the Fourth Gospel’s own cast. This is surprising given the emphasis on the performance and construction of identities that dominate classical literatures. Gender theorists, for example, have established the persistent evaluation of one’s “character”—in this case, sex—based on the adherence to or deviance from expected norms. Gauging an elite male’s walk, dress, speech, and habits, therefore, enabled one to argue whether he was indeed “masculine,” or if he drifted into the troubling waters of “effeminacy.” Exploring the terrain of classical rhetorical and contemporaneous literatures, we find a number of well-established locations, or topoi, from which a person can be constructed, understood, and judged by both his/her creator and their audiences including: gender/sex, age, ethnicity and ancestry, socio-economic class, friends and fortune, manner of death, and children. Rather than acting as a strictly-adhered-to paradigm, these topoi reflect the general “places” from which ancients constructed and performed their own characters on a daily basis, especially the male elite. As such these topoi provide the building blocks of ancient characterization practices, acting as comparatives for our study of the cast of John as well as other New Testament writings, even—and perhaps especially—when the characters these authors craft stray from the expected norms.
|
Authorship of 1 Peter as Witnessed by the Epistle to the Hebrews
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Liz Myers, Independent Scholar
Although authorship of 1 Peter by the apostle Peter was largely uncontested in the history of interpretation, challenges in recent centuries have led to the current majority opinion that the work was written by a pseudonymous author sometime after Peter’s death. While plausible counter-arguments have been advanced for Petrine authorship, with the exception of the author’s claim in 1 Pet 1:1 and an appeal to biblical inspiration and inerrancy, the evidence offered in support of Petrine authorship is no more conclusive than the evidence for pseudonymous authorship. Hence resolution of the authorship issue stands at a scholarly stalemate, with the perceived authenticity and historical context of 1 Peter uncertain. This paper seeks movement toward a resolution by summoning the previously unheard witness of a document that might contain the earliest recorded interpretation of 1 Peter, namely, the Epistle to the Hebrews. An earlier study has demonstrated through the use of probability theory that literary dependence between 1 Peter and Hebrews is highly probable and that the author of Hebrews is more likely to have borrowed from 1 Peter. Thus the author of Hebrews is qualified to offer testimony regarding authorship of the letter. Following a brief review of the case for intertextual borrowing, this paper shows how Hebrews bears witness to the authorship of 1 Peter through a trail of clues about how the author regards his sources. The trail begins at Heb 1:1–2 and passes through OT citations as well as references to other messages that were “spoken” or still “speak” to the audience. From these clues emerges a profile of characteristics that the author associates with his sources. The paper then shows how the document 1 Peter fits the profile and qualifies as a “spoken” message which the Hebrews’ author understands as having come through the apostle.
|
Assessing the Direction of Intertextual Borrowing between New Testament Books: A New Methodology and Application to 1 Peter and Hebrews
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Liz Myers, Independent Scholar
The curious presence of numerous verbal and conceptual parallels between NT documents raises the intriguing possibility of intertextual borrowing by the NT authors. If parallels between NT books can be shown to exhibit conclusive evidence of intertextual borrowing, in one direction or the other, then there are potential implications for dating, authorship, and background of thought, as well as for exegetical study of the interdependent books. While the most famous cases of NT intertextual borrowing involve the Synoptic Gospels, Ephesians and Colossians, and 2 Peter and Jude, perhaps the most elusive case involves 1 Peter and Hebrews. Despite numerous striking parallels between these books, the history of investigation has shown little support for literary dependence, let alone a likely direction of potential borrowing. The analysis methods, however, have proved neither comprehensive nor systematic, and results have been inconclusive. This paper presents the second phase of a two-phase research project that seeks to discern what kind of relationship might be indicated by the literary parallels between 1 Peter and Hebrews. The first phase, which was presented last year, has already demonstrated a high probability of literary dependence between these books using an assessment methodology based on probability theory and literary indicators. The second phase now follows with the obvious question, “who is most likely to have used whom?” Following a brief review of the case for literary dependence, this paper shows how the likelihood of a particular directional scenario between two interdependent documents can be assessed by examining intertextual parallels for evidence of appropriate indicators and applying probability theory to the data in a controlled manner that ensures a meaningful result. Application to 1 Peter and Hebrews shows that the author of Hebrews is more likely to have borrowed from 1 Peter. The paper closes with a preview of selected implications.
|
Apocalyptic Power; Dystopian Hope: John of Patmos and Paul the Apostle in Conversation with Young Adult Fiction
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Jacob D. Myers, Emory University
Dystopian milieus dominate contemporary young adult (YA) literature. Whether by zombies, aliens, war, or oppressive political regimes there is an unquestionable backdrop of gloom and hopelessness suffusing these narratives. Nevertheless, amidst such despairing circumstances, what these narratives hold in common is a kernel of hope that even in these darkest of days human freedom will triumph over the direst of circumstances.
Contemporary YA fiction continues the narrative trajectory of economic and political dystopias à la London, Huxley, Orwell, and Bradbury, but with a hopeful twist. In recent years, rampant dictatorial or harrowingly gruesome displays of power are vanquished by characters who lean into an active, hopeful resistance (e.g., The Hunger Games Trilogy, The Divergent Trilogy, The Host, The Maze Runner Trilogy and The Legend Series). Each of these bestselling YA novels departs from the dystopian genre by gesturing to a supreme hopefulness in the midst of oppressive displays of power. What does this tell us about life in early 21st century popular culture? Are things really as hopeless as they seem? How do these themes compare with the apocalyptic hopes expressed in the Bible?
In this essay I begin with an analysis of contemporary YA dystopian fictions, highlighting the motifs of hope and freedom vis-à-vis power and oppression as typically expressed in the dystopian genre. Next, I examine the theme of apocalyptic power in the Book of Revelation and in Paul’s letters, showing the theological undercurrents at work therein. Lastly, I employ these literary and biblical insights to address the dystopian concerns of our age, which bolsters a kerygmatic theology of power vis-à-vis the current cultural realities.
In John’s apocalyptic vision we see power expressed in terms of Christ’s resurrection. Power is embraced by believers inasmuch as they participate in Christ’s radical witness and resurrection (Rev. 7:13-17, 20:4-5). Like the slaughtered lamb that now lives, John’s community is empowered to participate in the death-defying power of resurrection. This is how God defeats Death and Sin, and in John’s apocalyptic vision believers are given the means by which to challenge the oppressive structures of Rome. Likewise, the Apostle Paul’s letters are teaming with discourses concerning power (1 Cor. 15; Rom. 6:9-13, 8:10-11; Gal. 1:1-5). To his churches he offers an apocalyptic eschatology that is far removed from modern interpretations that see Paul’s concern to be exclusively upon individual sin and the afterlife. In Paul’s apocalyptic imagination the present age has been invaded by God’s age, the worldly cosmos has been overtaken by the Divine. He calls upon his beleaguered and contentious followers to rise up against the powers and principalities of this age and lean fully into God’s age here and now.
Contemporary YA novels feature protagonists who display courage, strength, perseverance, and most of all hope against impossible odds. These narratives render a hopeful disposition in the midst of dystopian conditions. Placing such texts in conversation with biblical expressions of power can shed new light on the biblical witness vis-à-vis popular culture.
|
Reading Revelation Economically: An Ancient and Modern Critique of Oppressive Economics
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Jason A. Myers, Asbury Theological Seminary
The thesis of this study is that the self-sufficiency of Laodicea as expressed in economic terms is characterized in Revelation as capitulating to the economic practices of the Roman empire that are also under judgment. It will be argued that both inner textual references within Revelation and intertextual references from the Hebrew prophets combine to offer a prophetic critique of Laodicea in Rev 3:14-22. Inner textually, the economic critique of Rome in Rev 18 functions as a future point of warning for the church at Laodicea. However, intertextually this critique is not the apocalypticist’s alone, rather the author draws upon the prophetic critiques of the Hebrew prophets to provide a negative evaluation of Laodicea’s current position. Scholars have often identified intertextual references such as Hos 12:8 and Zech 11:5 in Rev 3:17, however most have missed a possible reference to Jer 5:27. Furthermore, the contrast with the other churches addressed in the first three chapters identifies economic affluence as a sign of consorting with the empire and thus standing under the coming judgement.
|
Use of the Hebrew Bible in Writing Ancient Israel’s History: Agreements and Parameters among Non-minimalists
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Lawrence Mykytiuk, Purdue University Main Campus
In the absence of consensus on using the Hebrew Bible in writing history, this paper attempts a summary overview of representative publications by 24 non-minimalist scholars of the Hebrew Bible since 1992. It seeks to define parameters within which the various positions fall and especially areas of agreement (often qualified and non-majority).
The 24 scholars whose work is considered are: J. Maxwell Miller, John H. Hayes, Megan Bishop Moore, Lester L. Grabbe, James Barr, Bob Becking, Amihai Mazar, Hans M. Barstad, Ronald S. Hendel, Mark S. Smith, Anthony J. Frendo, Andrew G. Vaughn, Baruch Halpern, Nadav Na'aman, Israel Finkelstein, Robert D. Miller II, H. G. M. Williamson, Craig G. Bartholomew, Iain W. Provan, V. Philips Long, K. A. Kitchen, Jens Bruun Kofoed, James K. Hoffmeier, and Richard E. Averbeck. Their methodologies usually permit or promote a positive view of historicity in the Hebrew Bible.
This paper has been developed from my three articles in _Journal of Religious & Theological Information_ (2010-2013) that introduce and sample methodological positions and developments for writing ancient Israel’s history in the era of biblical minimalism. These articles are a “first pass” over the literature, seeking to track directions of scholarship within the field
|
Working with the Masorah Parva of BHQ
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Daniel Mynatt, University of Mary Hardin-Baylor
This is the second section of the workshop on the Masorah Parva. It will concentrate on the mechanics and editorial principles of the Masorah of BHQ, and how it differs from BHS.
|
Response to Sarah Pearce
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Hindy Najman, Yale University
Response to commentary on De Decalogo which is pre circulated by Sarah Pearce.
|
Philo's Pedagogical Aspiration and Allegorical Project
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Hindy Najman, Yale University
Philo of Alexandria develops a way of reading Mosaic Torah in order to guide his students towards a life endowed with reason and virtue. This is achieved through Philo's "higher" or "allegorical" readings of the Greek Scriptures (reflected both in his allegorical treatises and in his exposition of the law). This paper considers the pedagogical dimension of Philo's interpretation, and the contextualization and transformation of the Law of Moses throughout his corpus. Attention will also be given to his conception of curriculum, which illuminates the path of becoming soul or mind alone and of returning to the Cosmos Noetos.
|
Religious Diversity and Political Power at Philippi (I–II CE)
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Laura Nasrallah, Harvard University
This paper investigates the social, religious, and political contexts of the Philippians who would have first received Paul’s letter. The first focus is on religion, gender, and power: religious diversity at Philippi included cults associated with the empress Livia, an association for Silvanus which seems to have been all male, rock-cut relief of which many represent Artemis, among other cults known through epigraphic and archaeological evidence. The second focus is on imperial power and punishment and discipline: Paul refers to himself in chains and to the praitorion; what are the likely civic and political contexts from which the Philippians would have understood Paul’s self-presentation as political prisoner?
|
How Do Paul’s Letters Matter for Political Philosophy?
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
Laura Nasrallah, Harvard University
“Paul” has been used by recent political philosophers as a figure whose idea of “messianic time” may prove liberatory or redemptive for late capitalist society. This paper asks how and whether several interpretive contexts may be fruitfully combined to see how not only “Paul,” but Paul’s letters and the communities to which he wrote, may be a fruitful place for such political work. These interpretive contexts include New Testament scholars’ work on Paul and Stoic (materialist) cosmology, Marxist materialist readings of Paul’s letters, the materialist turn in the study of religion and history, and feminist philosophers on matter (such as Jane Bennett and Karen Barad). The paper asks: How/can these contexts, all of which attend to matter or materialist concerns, be fruitfully combined for an interpretation of Paul’s letters? How might such a combination contribute to a historically sensitive reading of Paul’s letters that contributes to their use in contemporary political debate?
|
Oral Performance or Public Reading? The Oral Delivery of New Testament Writings in Early Christianity
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Dan Nässelqvist, Lund University
Most introductions to the New Testament mention that, during the first centuries C.E., New Testament writings were commonly delivered orally in a community setting and experienced through hearing. How these delivery events are envisioned differ, however. Whereas older scholarship took for granted that texts were read aloud in a community setting, a growing interest in orality has lead others to conclude that oral delivery regularly involved semi-dramatic performances of a memorized text. The result is a situation in which there are two mutually contradictory descriptions of how New Testament writings were orally communicated in early Christianity: public reading from a manuscript and oral performance from memory.
This paper analyses public reading and oral performance with the help of ancient sources that describe oral delivery. It indicates the differences between the two and demonstrates that both were common types of oral delivery during the first centuries C.E. It also explores how some literary genres are connected to a specific delivery type as well as certain settings. Finally, it compares the results to evidence from early Christian sources and draws a conclusion about which delivery type was regularly used for New Testament writings.
|
“The Rest of the Story”: Joshua 23 and the Compositional History of Deuteronomy–2 Kings
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Richard D. Nelson, Southern Methodist University
Diachronic methodologies clarify the place and purpose of the penultimate chapter of Joshua. Israel’s military hero looks back at Yahweh’s gifts and warns of future challenges. Joshua’s career is correlated with the farewell of Moses in Deuteronomy 34 and that of David in 1 Kings 2:1 – 9. The confident outlook of 21:43-45 must now be modified to take into account the rest of the story as it will unfold in Judges and Kings and in the experience of the original readership in the neo-Assyrian period. The author challenge was to restate and recast the mixed and complex ideology inherited from the book of Deuteronomy. The emergence of a different pattern of leadership leads into the perilous situation of the book of Judges. Three reviews of Israel’s story so far lead into three motivated exhortations, about pagan gods, alien nations, and covenant violation. The threat of perishing from the land increasingly dominates Joshua’s rhetoric as he moves through his speech. Destruction and exile are a real possibility, but still only a possibility. In contrast, Joshua’s second farewell in Joshua 24 encompasses the entire horizon of Genesis to 2 Kings 25. It provides advice on how read a book of national glory and victory against the reality of defeat, devastation, and deportation.
|
The Qur'anic “Vision Pericopes” in Light of a Christian Apocrypha
Program Unit: The Qur’an and the Biblical Tradition (IQSA)
Paul Neuenkirchen, Ecole Pratique des Hautes Etudes
In this paper, I will look into two rather mysterious and elliptic passages of the Qur?an – Q 81, 19-25 and Q 53, 2-18 – which both contain the description of a vision. Although these pericopes have not been linked one to the other by medieval Islamic exegetes, orientalists have long made the connection between these narrations which inspired many ascension (mi?raj) stories that were written posterior to the composition of the Qur?an. The first pericope, Q 81, 19-25, tells of the “words of a noble messenger” and moves on to saying that the “companion” “saw him at the clear horizon”. Similarly, the second pericope found in Q 53, 2-18 describes a double vision that the “servant” or “companion” had, in which he first saw “a possessor of great strength” at the “highest horizon” before seeing him again “by the lote tree”. The evident allusiveness of both the actors involved in these verses as well as the general setting and action have led many qur?anic exegetes to diverging interpretations, as my analysis of over ten of the oldest tafasir will demonstrate. I will in turn argue that a Christian apocrypha called the Ascension of Isaiah, can help us better understand the aforementioned pericopes by shedding light on the identity of the protagonists, on the location of the vision, on its purpose, etc. The Ascension of Isaiah was composed around the 3rd or 4th century A.D. in Greek and the only Semitic language in which this apocrypha is known to us is in geez or classical Ethiopic, a language into which it was translated around the 5th century A.D. I will try to show how this particular version might have come to Arabia during Prophet Mu?ammad’s time by looking into the “circumstances of the Revelation” genre (asbab al-nuzul) and how it possibly served as a canvas to elaborating his own vision and ascension story in the Qur?an.
|
A Cosmopolitan Community: Paul’s Eschatological Ideal in Its Jewish Context
Program Unit: Paul within Judaism
Karin Neutel, University of Groningen
The community ideal expressed in Paul’s well known formula ‘there is neither Jew nor Greek, neither slave nor free, nor male and female’ (Gal 3:28) is often seen as unique and distinct from wider first-century thought. There are, however, many links to be observed between this declaration of unity and ideas about community found among Paul’s Jewish contemporaries, such as in the Sibylline Oracles, and in the works of Josephus and Philo, most particularly in their descriptions of the Essenes. These authors shared the belief, widely accepted in Antiquity, that differences between members constitute an obstacle to harmony within a social group.
This paper will show how Paul’s ideas about unity are related to Jewish social thought of the period, and can be seen as a form of Jewish cosmopolitanism. In founding communities, Paul put into practice an eschatological ideal based on the cosmopolitan mood of the first century. This cosmopolitan outlook had implications for ethnicity, as well as for other aspects social status, such as slavery. As Paul’s letters show, the implementation of this ideal in concrete communities, which were only intended to cover the time until the parousia, led to a great deal of social tension.
|
Beyond the Textual Palimpsest: The Qur’anic Community's Design of a Rhetorical Image of the Divine—Challenging the “Identity Documents” of Arab Late Antiquity: Poetry, Aggadah, and the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: International Qur’anic Studies Association (IQSA)
Angelika Neuwirth, Freie Universität Berlin
The lecture approaches the relation between the Qur’an and earlier traditions from a new vantage point. It intends to trace the epistemic innovation of the Qur’an, understanding the text as the outcome of an extended process of debate - a debate not, however, constituted by isolated textual fragments from earlier traditions but a debate which the Qur’an conducts with entire genres (poetry, 'vernacular' stories of prophets) and, moreover, with liturgically staged Biblical texts. The lecture intends to survey the successive stages of the community’s approach to poetry and the two contrasting manifestations of the Bible, the “interpreted Bible” (which may be summarized as Aggadah) and the Hebrew Bible, without losing the text's rhetorical dimension out of sight. Based on a strictly diachronic reading of the Qur’anic text, the lecture will exemplify the stages in the community’s theological development by discussing some key texts from the Meccan as well as the Medinan periods.
|
Rethinking the Radius of Qur’anic Philology: The Qur’an and Its Late Antique Milieu
Program Unit: Philology in Hebrew Studies
Angelika Neuwirth, Freie Universität Berlin
The Qur’an until now has not been acknowledged as part of the Western canon of theologically relevant knowledge – although it is obviously a text that no less than the Jewish and Christian founding documents firmly stands in the Biblical tradition. Indeed, it seems to be the very fact of this close relationship that kindled the present controversy over the status of the Qur’an: either as a religiously genuine attestation of Biblical faith, a Fortschreibung, a ‘continuation’ of the Bible, or as a mere imitation, a theologically diffuse recycling of Biblical tradition. To tackle the problem of the current disarray in Qur’anic studies we have to pose some principal questions (inspired by the American scholar Sheldon Pollock’s recent assessment of the contemporary situation of philology): First: can we afford to study the Qur’an exclusively on the basis of its written textual appearance, hoping thus to uncover its historically founded “true meaning”? Second: Are we entitled to completely detach it from the responses of its recipients that it has attracted through history? Third, and most importantly: can we “erase ourselves from the philological act” ignoring the intellectual challenges we are exposed to in our own cultural milieu? The paper seeks to answer these questions by studying the Qur’an not as an auctorial compilation but as a polyphone text reflecting a communication process where not only the nascent Muslim community expresses itself but Jewish and Christian voices are equally audible. It is through their debate that the identity of the new community will emerge.
|
Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy: Making Sense of the Ezekiel of Ezekiel 40–48
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
Madhavi Nevader, University of St. Andrews
The putative connections between the figures of Moses and Ezekiel in Ez 40-48 have long determined the manner by which the role of Ezekiel is determined in the book's final Temple Vision. But to which Moses is this exilic prophet comparing himself? Moses the prophet, Moses the priest, or Moses the Law-Giver? The paper will address the strength of argument for each of these various roles as the institutional (and literary) link between both figures, but will offer that, upon closer analysis of the material, not only is the Moses-Ezekiel connection tenuous, but that the reformulation of royal theology in the Temple Vision provides a more coherent backdrop against which to understand the function and status of Ezekiel than an appeal to Sinai. If Ezekiel and Moses are birds of the same feather, it is only because of the tar and feathering tendencies of a later tradent of their independent theological traditions.
|
"Pray God and Keep Walking": Exile and the Gendering of Religion
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
Madhavi Nevader, University of St. Andrews
Many see the rise of monotheism in the exile as the deathblow levelled against the Judahite goddess, at best reduced to the agential child of Yhwh, at worst silenced altogether. In the paper, I argue that this religious trajectory is too simplistic and needs careful reconsideration. By exploring the relationship of three exilic communities (Egypt, Babylonia, and Judah) to the dominant Judahite goddess (be she the Queen of Heaven, Anat-Yahu, or Asherah), I suggest that feminine aspects of Judahite religion played a major role in the experience of exile. Whilst, therefore, the exile may have been the crisis of Yhwh religion, it may, by contrast, have been a time of great vibrancy for ‘female aspects’ of Judahite religion.
|
Embodied Techniques: The Formation of the Maskil’s Self in Liturgical Performance
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Judith H. Newman, University of Toronto
The term “performance” can be understood as an umbrella term for a number of methodological perspectives related to embodiment including perception, affect, memory, language, and ritual. My paper will evaluate recent trends in embodied cognition as they may shed light in particular on the role of the maskil in relation to the transmission of tradition within the Qumran Yahad. How can we understand the construction of the Self in relation to this figure? What kinds of Qumran “Self” have been proposed and how do our own (embodied) conceptions about the nature and function of the texts shape our analysis?
|
George Watson's "Christ the Light of the World": Allegory and Apologetics in Newtonian England
Program Unit: Christian Theology and the Bible
David Ney, Wycliffe College
Little known Oxford cleric George Watson was a decisive influence on two of the most important figures in eighteenth-century Anglicanism--George Horne and William Jones of Nayland. Both Horne and Jones acknowledged their indebtedness to Watson and, in particular, to his 1749 sermon on Psalm 19, "Christ the Light of the World." My paper has three objectives. First, it defines the apologetic context of Watson's sermon as one in which the book of nature was given priority over the book of Scripture. I maintain that this disequilibrium can be attributed to the rise of the new Newtonian apologetic, which emphasized that "The heavens declare the glory of God" without the mediation of Scriptural words. Second, my paper outlines how this apologetic altered the interpretation of Psalm 19 in the first half of the eighteenth century. Third, it argues that for Watson the allegorical method—and specifically his assertion that the “Sun” referred to in Psalm 19:4-6 is Christ himself—is far more than a mere literary device. For Watson, allegory is what enables the meaning of the book of nature to be refracted through the book of Scripture, and the meaning of the book of Scripture to be refracted through the book of nature. Far from demanding that natural objects be cast away, Watson’s hermeneutic makes them indispensable to the contemplation of divine things. It is, therefore, a fitting hermeneutic for our modern empirical context.
|
An African Understanding of Pneumatology in Acts of the Apostles
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Sam Ngewa, Africa International University, Kenya
An African Understanding of Pneumatology in Acts of the Apostles
|
Bible after Gunshots: African Biblical Hermeneutics as Postwar Hermeneutics?
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Kenneth Ngwa, Drew University
“The ultimate expression of sovereignty resides, to a large degree, in the power and capacity to dictate who may live and who must die.” So writes the political theorist, Achille Mbembe, defining what he calls necropolitics. The quintessential space where necropolitics takes place is the theater of war – civil and/or national. The trauma of the postwar community requires reflections beyond the (violent) expressions of sovereignty; the postwar space requires critical reflections on the very constructions of the notion of sovereignty itself and its public manifestations. This paper contributes to that discussion by examining the relation between two key tools of sovereignty in post-independence Africa: the gun and the Bible. As symbols of power, the Bible and the gun enable their users to participate in African necropolitics, claiming and deploying specific forms of authority to critique, determine, or regulate the very basic character and structure of human existence, life itself, lived out within histories, cultures, and policies that have identifiable economic, political, and spiritual practices and legacies.
|
Breaking Bruised Reeds and the Battle with Beelzebul: Jesus’ Exorcisms and the Coming of the Kingdom of God in the Gospel of Matthew
Program Unit: Matthew
Jesse Nickel, University of St. Andrews
All three Synoptic Gospels record the accusation made against Jesus that it is through being in league with Beelzebul, the archon of the demons, that Jesus is able to exert his mighty power over the evil spirits he encounters (Mt. 12.22-32 // Mk. 3.19b-30 // Lk. 11.14-23). In all three, Jesus responds with familiar words about kingdoms divided against themselves and the binding of the strong man. However, the pericope takes on added significance in its Matthean context, due to (1) the immediately preceding citation from Isaiah 42, which speaks of the servant neither ‘break[ing] a bruised reed or quench[ing] a smouldering wick’ (12.18-20); and (2) Jesus’ statement that his exorcisms point to the presence of the kingdom of God (12.28). Using this pericope as a starting point, in this paper I will explore the connection between Jesus’ exorcisms and the inauguration of the kingdom of God in Matthew, in the context of the eschatological expectations of second-Temple Judaism. Although the portrayals of eschatological events in Jewish writings from this period are diverse, one of the nearly unanimous expectations was that the arrival of the kingdom of God would entail the violent destruction of all the enemies of God and/or his people (cf., e.g., Dan. 7; 1 En. 85-90; 1QM). I will discuss how this component of second-Temple Jewish eschatology was represented and manifested in the kingdom-ministry of the Matthean Jesus, particularly in terms of Matthew’s emphasis on Jesus’ Isaianic servant identity. I will argue that, counter to many of his Jewish contemporaries, who expected that the arrival of the kingdom would involve a holy war waged by the faithful against their Gentile oppressors, Jesus understood himself to be prosecuting the expected eschatological battle in his encounters with evil spirits – the true enemies of God and his people. With these mighty deeds, Matthew demonstrates that the anticipated victory which would attend the inauguration of the kingdom of God was being won.
|
Martin Luther King Imagining Paul
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
Valerie Nicolet-Anderson, Institut Protestant de Théologie, Paris
In 1956, Martin Luther King Junior delivered a sermon entitled "Paul's Letter to American Christians" to the congregation of Dexter Avenue Baptist Church in Montgomery, Alabama. In this sermon, King declares it matters that he can "imagine the Apostle Paul writing a letter to American Christians in 1956 A.D". The letter then addresses several central themes of Martin Luther King's struggle. In particular King insists on the responsibilities laid upon American Christians; for example, the fact that they have a moral duty not to be conformed to the spirit of this time. He argues for economic responsibility and ends his letter with a call to end segregation, without the use of bitterness and with no fear of persecution. In King's mouth Paul becomes a powerful ally for change. Building on Jay Twomey's work concerning King's use of Paul,1 I would like to explore the necessity of "imagining Paul" in King's discourse. How is Paul conjured in King's message, and more broadly why does Paul seem to surface again and again, when political struggle is rife (as he does now, in various continental philosophers' works)? Starting with Martin Luther King's use of Paul, I am interested in seeing what it means to imagine Paul today, why it is Paul indeed that needs imagining and what strategies are used to imagine Paul in King's use of him. Imagining Paul constructs a certain reality and a certain understanding of the world. At the same time, this also connects to an interest in what this type of imagining does to our reading of Paul: is it perhaps time to accept that in Pauline studies, we need to give as much room to "thinking with Paul" as to trying to understand what Paul means?
|
Philo's Rationalisation of the Jewish Law in Greco-Roman Context
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Maren R. Niehoff, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem
This paper examines Philo's explanations of Jewish customs in his treatises on the Decalogue and the Special Laws, which are part of his later works written with special attention to Roman discourses. It is argued that Philo constructs Jewish law along the lines of contemporary Stoic notions. His interpretation is a landmark in the history of Judaism and throws significant light on the earliest rabbinic law codex, the Mishnah.
|
The Alimentary Encounter of Cultures in Greenland
Program Unit: Islands, Islanders, and Scriptures
Flemming A.J. Nielsen, Ilisimatusarfik (University of Greenland)
When Christianity, a agricultural religion of Mediterranean origin, came to Greenland in 1721, its representatives faced an Arctic, semi-nomadic culture subsisting on sea mammals, fish, reindeer, birds, seaweeds and a few species of edible Arctic plants and berries. Soon, a written Greenlandic language began to evolve, and inevitable problems concerning the rendering of Biblical plants, animals and foodstuffs such as curds, cakes, bread, grapes, figs and lentils appeared. Based on an outline of such translational problems and ways of solving them in the Greenlandic Bible, I intend to reflect on some of the implications of this alimentary encounter as regards the change of a shamanistic culture, the development of Greenlandic Christianity and the coexistence of the aboriginal Inuit people and the immigrating Europeans. In the pietistic spirit of Lutheran-Evangelical protestantism of the day, the immigrating state church of the then Danish-Norwegian empire taught its new Inuit parishioners and their shamans how to live Christian ritualized everyday lives with new eating habits, fixed meal times and several daily prayers to the Christian God.
|
Ezekiel’s Torah and Moses’ Torah: Parallel Legal Traditions in Post-monarchic Israel
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
Christophe Nihan, Université de Lausanne
In the contemporary discussion, the relation between Ezekiel’s final vision in ch. 40-48 and the pentateuchal legislation often tends to be construed as a linear one, with scholars arguing either for Ezekiel’s dependence on the pentateuchal traditions or, conversely, for the derivation of pentateuchal laws from materials found in Ezekiel. Based on a close reading of various ritual laws found in Ezek 44-46 (especially about sacrifices, feasts, and priestly duties), the present paper will argue that such models may be too simple to account for the available evidence, and that it is possible to identify a typology of four distinct scenarios: (a) Ezek 40-48 drawing on pentateuchal materials; (b) pentateuchal laws deriving from Ezek 40-48; (c) parallel adaptation in Ezekiel and the Pentateuch of shared legal traditions; and (d) separate legal development in Ezekiel and the Pentateuch. These findings call in turn for a more complex and more dynamic model that envisions the parallel formation and transmission of legal traditions associated with the authority of Moses and Ezekiel during the post-monarchic period.
|
Akkadian Love Poetry and the Song of Songs: New Sources, New Perspectives
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Martti Nissinen, University of Helsinki
Sources of Akkadian love poetry have come to our knowledge relatively late. To date, the corpus comprises eighteen texts, only six of which were published before 1987, another six texts between 1987 and 2001, and the remaining six texts in 2008–9. Nine texts are of Old Babylonian origin, while the rest of the material dates to the Middle Babylonian, Middle Assyrian, Neo-Babylonian and Neo-Assyrian periods. Particularly noteworthy are the well-preserved tablets from the Schøyen collection published by Andrew George in 2009 (CUSAS 10 8–12).
Cultural parallels to the Song of Songs have been mostly, and rightly, sought from Egyptian and Sumerian sources. However, the growing number of Akkadian love poems has increased the significance of the Akkadian sources, not only as further representatives of the common Eastern Mediterranean tradition of love poetry, but also as important parallels to the Song of Songs. This paper argues that (1) the form and content of the Akkadian love poems belong to the same stream of tradition of love poetry as the Song of Songs; (2) both the Akkadian poems and the Song of Songs have a scribal origin and both were used for educational purposes; and (3) since sacrality is a category of emplacement rather than an essential quality of the text (J. Z. Smith), love poems, whether Akkadian or biblical, should not be characterized as either “sacred” or “secular.”
|
Ishmael and the Question of Universal and Particular
Program Unit: Genesis
John T. Noble, Huntington University
Comparing the Priestly and non-Priestly Ishmael passages, one observes that P has recast the promises that Ishmael receives in non-P, so that Ishmael is more explicitly excluded from God’s covenant with Abraham, on the one hand, in Genesis 17; but P also comprehends Ishmael through identification with the fertility blessing, invoking the divine injunction to all humanity at creation and to Noah to “be fruitful and multiply” (Gen 17:20), on the other hand. P’s emphasis on fertility also relates to Ishmael’s own participation, though he is non-chosen, in circumcision as the sign of the covenant.
Ishmael’s role in the Abrahamic covenant, therefore, is ambiguous: he is excluded from the Abrahamic covenant in P just as much as in non-P, yet P includes Ishmael in many of the related promises and blessings and seems to find a place for him in the Abrahamic family. Any consideration of the patriarchal figure of Ishmael, then, must confront a problem of categorization insofar as he is simultaneously excluded and blessed.
This paper uses Ishmael as a test case for universalism and particularism in the Hebrew Bible. At issue in the scholarship—and usually neglected, surprisingly—is the usefulness and applicability for ancient biblical authors of these theoretical concepts that have only developed within the last two centuries. Are the rubrics of universalism and particularism useful for the study of biblical writings? Ishmael presents a helpful model for assessing the relevance of these questionable, somewhat unstable concepts for ancient texts.
|
Maleness, Memory, and the Matter of Dream Divination in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Prophetic Texts and Their Ancient Contexts
Scott Noegel, University of Washington
In this presentation, I bring together four seemingly disparate topics that I contend are reciprocally illuminating for the study of dreams and dream divination in ancient Israel. The first, is a relationship between gendered constructions of Israelite diviners and beliefs concerning fertility and pollution. The second is an association of dreams with male fertility. The third topic, is a perceived connection between memory and masculinity. The fourth, is the role of the heart as an organ for recording dreams. As I shall argue, the four topics are mutually defined by conceptions of maleness, which in turn, inform the Israelite dream experience, its import, and narratives concerned with dreams.
|
Reading the Dance of Herodias' Daughter (Mark 6:14–29) as 'sasa' (a Samoan Dance)
Program Unit: Islands, Islanders, and Scriptures
Vaitusi Nofoaiga, University of Auckland
This paper offers a reading of the dance by Herodias’ daughter in Mark 6:14-29 as a siva sasa or ‘a dance to strike’. The word sasa means ‘to strike’, and it is the name for a Samoan dance performed by both males and females. In this dance, hand movements depict everyday activities. The sasa dance will be the hermeneutic tool to interpret the event of Herodias' daughter’s dance which culminated in the death of John the Baptist. From this hermeneutic, I consider this daughter’s dance as a ‘dance to sasa (strike) John the Baptist.'
Sasa has a leader called a faaluma. His or her role is to remind the dancers of the story they are telling, and tell the audience the everyday activity danced by the performers. From this lens, I look at the Markan narrator as a faaluma.
Sasa has a beginning called faatalofa or amataga, a middle as autu, and an end as faatofa or faaiuga. Through this lens, I interpret the telling of the dance in Mark 6:14-29 as a sasa unit. It has amataga, autu, and faaiuga.
Sasa has its own features that make the whole dance a unit. It has a faasologa (progression), tagata auai (characters), mea tutupu (events), as depicted in the taga (actions) of the dance. I call these features the anofale (innertexture) of the sasa. Through this lens, I will interpret how Herodias' daughter’s dance is a sasa (striking dance).
Sasa belongs to a social and cultural context. Thus, I will also focus on analysing this text’s social and cultural texture (gagana faaagafesootai) as a unit revealing how the event of the daughter’s dance depicts honour and shame.
|
Powerful Public Performances and Literary Subversion of Social Reality in the Early Christianity: The Case of the Apostle John in the Artemision (Acts of John 37–47)
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Paulo Nogueira, Universidade Metodista de São Paulo - Brasil
The Apocryphal Acts of the Apostles offer modern readers numerous embarrassing accounts of miracle performed in public spaces of the ancient cities, such as amphitheaters, pagan temples and even in the forum romanum. Traditional exegetical and historiographical approaches are not comfortable in reading such texts, considering them as historical inaccurate or as popular bizarre legends.
In this paper, we propose a way of reading this kind of narrative by means of the contemporary concept of fictionality, as elaborated by W. Iser, among others. Based on such a perspective, the fictional literary narrative is understood as a powerful way of subverting and manipulating the social order and its perception of reality, horizontally reorganizing what is vertically given in the official discourses. In that perspective, these fantastic accounts of the Apocryphal Acts are daring Early Christian literary experiments by means which they project their own values and social perspectives.
We intend to approach these presuppositions in one narrative regarding literary manipulation of one of the most impressive public spaces of the Ancient World: the Artemision, a central place of public display of social identity in Roman Ephesus. According to Acts of John 37-47 the apostle not only disrespectfully challenged the sacred place of the Ephesians but also destroyed it. That narrative might be perceived as absurd even by the most faithful Christians in the second century, unless they are somehow aware of the imaginative experiment it represents. Finally, we shall compare that fictional account with another one which proposes a different fictional view of the reality in relation with this sacred place: the description of the procession of the goddess Artemis in the novel of Xenophon of Ephesus, Anthia and Habrocomes.
|
Oral or Written Poetry in Job, or Both?
Program Unit: Orality, Textuality, and the Formation of the Hebrew Bible
Urmas Nõmmik, University of Tartu, Estonia
Hebrew biblical poetry features different poetic profiles. The basic authors of the Dialogue of Job, among others, reveal a distinct balanced poetry. This is characterized by bicola relatively equal in length and combined with parallelism, sound patterns, etc., and of stanzas which in the framework of one speech tend to follow a similar matrix. Those who have studied colometrical patterns in Ugaritic and Biblical poetry have underlined the significance of a balanced colon-length if texts are written in scriptio continua. The paper seeks to ask whether the phenomenon of balanced bicola and stanzas does maintain any further-reaching significance. Examples from the speeches of Eliphaz and Job do help, firstly, to summarize observations on scribal techniques against the backdrop of balanced poetry and its seconding features, and, secondly, to evaluate the probable clues that hint at the principles of oral performance and composition behind such writing techniques. The paper supports the view that a speech had to be composed orally before it was written down, and a special training was needed to do that. One of the aims of scholars who deal with the textual shape of the Hebrew Bible is to track the principles of textual composition, at least for certain literary layers. A close examination of the interchange of oral and written components in the process of the formation of Hebrew biblical literature might be of help. The paper prepares a series of text-critical studies on the Book of Job which should contribute to the question how the results of literary criticism (Literarkritik) relate to the textual evidence.
|
The Phenomenon of Royal Lore in Ancient Israel
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Urmas Nõmmik, University of Tartu, Estonia
During the history of the study of the Hebrew Bible, the argument for oral tradition behind many biblical texts has played a significant role. An earlier romantic understanding of a very long oral tradition (particularly concerning the patriarchal narratives) preceding its gathering and recording by court scribes has nowadays been changed. In many scholarly circles a skeptic position concerning the historical value of much of the legendary material in the Bible is dominating. The paper will not oppose this understanding but will draw attention to the phenomenon of royal lore which can be traced in the narratives about kings and also about patriarchs. The raison d’être of this lore is to construct and maintain the identity of the king; this is why the focus of such traditions is not on etiologies or local sagas but on actions and situations which normally fill the life of kings and queens. Deep engagement in retaining power and overcoming all kinds of threats as well as decisive acting and mutual relationship to one’s own nation can be detected in older narrative layers in the court traditions of Judah and Israel. With the help of a brief structural comparison of three Biblical stories—the earliest layers in the Balaam episode (Numbers 22-24), in the story of Athaliah and Joash (2Kings 11) and in the account of Rebekah’s and Jacob’s intrigue (Genesis 27)—a connection to the oral court lore can be maintained. By also mentioning a link to the inscription of Idrimi, the king of Alalakh, an international touch of such lore will be considered. A short summary of observations on the relationship of the oral tradition and the writing techniques of the court scribes will round up the paper.
|
The Bodmer Papyri as Collection: Thoughts on Late Antique Libraries
Program Unit: Inventing Christianity: Apostolic Fathers, Apologists, and Martyrs
Brent Nongbri, Macquarie University
One way to begin exploring interaction among the variety of Christian authors and texts in late antique Egypt is by looking at Christian libraries. The so-called Bodmer papyri are a group of classical and Christian texts on papyrus and parchment that appeared on the Egyptian antiquities market in the 1950s. According to one theory, these manuscripts are the remains of a Christian monastic library. Another theory prefers to interpret these texts as coming from non-monastic educational setting in which both Christian and classical texts were studied. This paper reviews arguments about the scope and provenance of Bodmer papyri and attempts to contextualize the find among other late antique caches of manuscripts.
|
What Can We Know about P4, P64, and P67?
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Brent Nongbri, Macquarie University
The papyrus fragments of Luke and Matthew designated as P4, P64, and P67 have been subject to intense study by both biblical scholars and papyrologists since the 1990s. Discussion has centered on two issues: 1) What is the date of the fragments—are they a product of the first century, as a few fringe voices have argued, or are they more likely of the late second century, as a consensus holds, or should we entertain the possibility of a fourth century date, as one palaeograpaher has recently argued? 2) Did the fragments come from a single codex, and if so, what sort of codex was it? This paper attempts to shed light on these questions by scrutinizing the history of the publication and interpretation of these fragments, highlighting especially some neglected palaeographical assessments and raising questions about the alleged provenance of the Philo codex in which the fragments of Luke (P4) were found.
|
A ‘Story-Formed Community’: The Bible and Politics at Ebenezer Baptist Church
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Kristopher Norris, University of Virginia
This paper analyzes the biblical hermeneutics that animate and inform the political church practices of Ebenezer Baptist Church in Atlanta, the former parish of Martin Luther King. I argue that Ebenezer embodies what Stanley Hauerwas calls a “story-formed community.” That is, Ebenezer integrates both the scriptural narrative and its history of involvement in the civil rights movement into its identity and practice, shaping its particular mode of political engagement.
The paper draws on ethnographic-style research conducted at Ebenezer, investigating the political practices of the congregation. I discovered that church leaders employ scriptural narratives, specifically Jesus’ preaching in Nazareth in Luke 4:16-21 and the crucifixion passages, to inspire and form the church’s model of political engagement. Ebenezer interprets Jesus’ recitation of Isaiah in Luke 4 as a social mandate for all of Jesus’ followers today. Taking this mandate to bring material good news to the poor and oppressed seriously, as actions that the church is called to actually accomplish on earth, requires partnerships with others, including the government, church leaders reason. They understand this passage to call for a more porous church and world distinction, allowing for collaboration with political agencies. At the same time, Jesus’ execution at the hands of the state for his opposition to Roman rule informs a posture of “over-againstness” to the political powers, willing to engage and partner but always wary to maintain a prophetic distance. Claiming that the civil rights movement was primarily a spiritual movement, one that drew heavily from these same passages, Ebenezer remembers these narratives weekly in its corporate worship and allows them to inspire and shape congregational involvement in politics.
Ebenezer’s hermeneutics lead it to strike a balance in political activity. Jesus’ social mandate—that it interprets as the church’s ongoing mission—calls it to partner with government agencies through its new Martin Luther King Sr. Community Collaborative to provide social services to the neighborhood, support policy issues from the pulpit on occasions like “Healthcare Sunday,” and invite political leaders like presidential candidate Barack Obama to its pulpit. On the other hand, they are moved by the force of the crucifixion story to protest unjust policies of the state and engage in certain ecclesially-based projects that avoid collusion with political authorities.
|
The Text, Discourse, and Verb in the Song of Hannah (I Sam 2:1–10)
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Tania Notarius, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
The Text, Discourse, and Verb in the Song of Hannah (I Sam 2:1-10) [Session three: Linguistic Analysis of TAM system]
This short ten-verses poem reveals a difficult textual picture, due to significant differences between versions and multiple inner-biblical parallels, particularly to Psalm 113. The discursive analysis of the composition allows for dividing it into two main parts (vv. 1–5 and vv. 6–10). The division into two parts correlates with certain qualities of the verb system and has historical-typological implications. In this paper I will demonstrate how meticulous textual and philological analysis, combined with a sound approach to poetic discourse, contribute to the strict semantic analysis of TAM system, produced in correlation with the the historical-linguistic axis, and allow for extensive generalization about the text, linguistics, and history of this text.
|
The Sin against the Spirit
Program Unit: Development of Early Christian Theology
R. Steven Notley, Nyack College
The Matthean account of “The Sin Against the Spirit” (Matt 12:31-32) and its synoptic parallels (Mark 3:28-30; Luke 12:10) preserve a dominical saying that is best understood against the background of emerging Jewish notions regarding the holy spirit during the final decades of the Second Temple. Equally important for an understanding of our saying is the idea of the gradation of sin and its punishment, which is witnessed in Jewish literature from the third century B.C.E. (e.g. 1 Enoch) to the second century C.E. (e.g. Seder Olam Rabbah). We will briefly trace these two interwoven developments to find that our saying accords well with religious expressions of emerging Judaism during the final days of the Second Temple.
|
Did Paul Conceive of Such a Thing as Judaism?
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Matthew Novenson, University of Edinburgh
Despite the vast secondary literature on Paul and Judaism, the only instances of the word “Judaism” (Ioudaismos) in the New Testament are at Gal 1:13-14. What is more, recent scholarly discussion has suggested that even here there may be no such thing as “Judaism.” Some recent interpreters have proposed that the ancient Greek word Ioudaismos is not “Judaism,” a system of religious beliefs and practices, but rather “Judaizing” or “Judaization,” a verbal noun signifying the adoption of Jewish ancestral customs by non-Jews (see especially Mason, as well as Cohen, Boyarin, and Schwartz). In this paper, I consider the evidence in the Pauline letters pertinent to the question whether Paul conceived of such a thing as Judaism. Such evidence includes not only the one-off appearance of the word Ioudaismos but also several passages where Paul might (or might not) be understood to comment on the religious practices of his non-Christian Jewish kinfolk (e.g., Gal 1; 2; Rom 2; 9-10; Phil 3). Of particular interest is the question whether Paul attributes to non-Christian Jews the view that a person is justified by works of the law. This paper suggests that most of the passages often taken to represent Paul’s assessment of Judaism do not in fact do so, and moreover that, because of Paul’s unusual apocalyptic situation, there is actually nowhere that he articulates an assessment of Judaism as such, that is, the religion of non-Christian Jews viewed as a discrete phenomenon.
|
Luini Bernardino at the San Diego Museum of Art: Salome, Modesty, and Vanity
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Ela Nutu, University of Sheffield
There has always been a relationship between the Bible and Art, a two-way vista for exchange; interpretative co-dependency. Most twentyfirst-century audiences will have inherited the concept of Salome as the young woman whose ‘dance of many veils’ leads to one man’s infatuation and another man’s decapitation. Yet, this image has less to do with the brief note on the dance that one finds in the Bible and more to do with the Salome’s artistic afterlives, especially those emerging from fin-de-siècle and Decadent European traditions. By looking afresh at depictions of Salome that do not openly represent her as a femme fatale, readers of the Bible can be challenged into re-assessing their own understanding of the story of the Baptist’s death and the role that the young woman plays in it. This paper examines Luini Bernardino’s visual interpretations of Herod’s stepdaughter in light of the biblical text. How did the painter imagine the woman? Was this in step with other 16th century Italian artists?
|
A Prophet in the Sage's House
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Ryan O'Dowd, Chesterton House, Cornell University
A Prophet in the Sage's House
|
Holy Writ or English Lit?
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Ryan O'Dowd, Chesterton House, Cornell University
Is the Bible the stuff of great literature? Answering in the negative, T.S. Eliot once remarked that, “[t]he persons who enjoy these writings solely because of their literary merits are essentially parasites…” and, he adds, “are merely admiring it over the grave of Christianity.” Eliot is not alone in thinking that the Bible attained high literary status only because it was read for so many centuries as the word of God. Nor that scholarly reading of the Bible inevitably turns to parasitism. This talk explores the tension between the ethos of the secular academy and the task of the Christian scholar, asking whether it is possible, or even ethical, to read Scripture as anything but divine revelation.
|
The Role of Experience in Proverbs and Ecclesiastes
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Philosophy
Ryan O'Dowd, Cornell University
There are obvious differences in the way Proverbs and Ecclesiastes depict the acquisition of wisdom and knowledge. The method in Proverbs involves hearing, keeping, and treasuring the traditions passed down from the sages and/or parents. Wisdom exists independent of the mind and has to be learned or received as fact. In Ecclesiastes, however, Qohelet’s approach to learning relies almost exclusively on a subjective and empirical method. Wisdom results in the mind as a result of sensory experience, analysis, and validation. This common way of differentiation the epistemologies in these two books, while true in many ways, tends to oversimplify the roles of experience and authority in both books. This paper will explore some of the more nuanced ways experience plays a role in biblical wisdom.
|
Resurrection or Destruction? Social Identity and Time in Philippians 3
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Matt O'Reilly, University of Gloucestershire
Insights from the field of Social Identity Theory have been increasingly utilized as tools for interpreting the letters of Paul in recent years, especially Romans, 1 Corinthians, and Galatians. While some attention has been given to identity formation in Philippians, much work remains to be done, not least with regard to diachronic processes in identity formation and maintenance. The present paper aims to shed light on Paul's identity forming strategy in Philippians by considering the role of eschatology, and in particular the expectation of bodily resurrection, in relation to group identity and behavior. The article will draw on the work of M. Cinnirella, who has proposed a modification to the concept of possible selves to include future possible social identities. According to his model, social identity and behavior are influenced by an individual's perception of past and possible future group memberships. In light of Paul's evaluation of his Jewish identity as a hindrance to knowing Christ in his resurrection (Phil 3:7-11) along with his positive evaluation of future bodily transformation (Phil 3:21), Cinnirella's "temporal perspective" has potential to advance our understanding of Paul's attitude toward bodily resurrection by analyzing its role in Paul's identity forming strategy. I will argue, first, that Paul sets forth two possible future group identities: one characterized by bodily resurrection and glory, the other by destruction and shame; second, Paul offers a negative evaluation of his past confidence in his Jewish identity and construes it as a hindrance to the positively valued resurrection in Christ; third, that this construal of the past and vision of the future functions to maintain the salience of the Philippians' Christ oriented identity; and, fourth, provides an interpretive framework for understanding Paul's ethical expectations throughout the letter.
|
Status and Afterlife: An Illustrated Statistical Analysis of Terminology and Imagery in Funerary Epigraphy in the Territory of Philippi
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Peter Oakes, University of Manchester
This papers analyses and illustrates text and imagery on gravestones in and near Philippi from the first century BCE to the third century CE. Frequency of various terms and images is considered, especially those that have been used in discussion of ideas of afterlife. The meaning and significance of the terminology and imagery is explored by contextualising the Philippian epigraphy in relation to other examples from Roman Macedonia. The paper argues that previous discussion of the significance of funerary epigraphy has been seriously skewed by reliance on corpora of published inscriptions lacking in consideration of imagery.
|
The Imperial Authorities in Paul's Letter to Predominately Greek Hearers in a Roman Colony
Program Unit: Polis and Ekklesia: Investigations of Urban Christianity
Peter Oakes, University of Manchester
In Philippians, the Roman authorities are rendered powerless. They have no say in the fate of even their own prisoner, Paul. The authority of their head is eclipsed by that of Jesus. Even at the heart of their life a community of Jesus' followers has been established. This paper explores the nature of the imperial authorities in the colonial situation of Philippi, the non-Roman identity of most of the expected hearers of Paul's letter, and how the rhetoric of the powerless authorities plays out in the text written for them.
|
The Semitic Rhetoric of Surat al-Nisa’ 153–162 Imparts Meaning to Shubbiha in Aya 157a
Program Unit: Linguistic, Literary, and Thematic Perspectives on the Qur’anic Corpus (IQSA)
Rick Oakes, North-West University (South Africa)
The Arabic term shubbiha appears only once in the Qur’an, yet it is upon this term that the Muslim denial of the crucifixion of Jesus is based. J.J Sanders states that the notorious wa lakin shubbih lahum is ‘a sentence which no one quite knows how to translate.’ Edinburgh’s Emeritus Professor Carole Hillenbrand thinks that it very well may be the most obscure phrase in the Qur’an. Much ink has been spilt discussing how medieval mufassirun explained shubbiha. When Zamakshari’s exploration of the grammar proved unfruitful, he returned to reporting the same kind of substitution legends that all other mufassirun use to explain the meaning of shubbiha. Explaining the meaning of obscure terms by resorting to storytellers who fabricated legends that they attributed to their pious ancestors imposes meaning upon the text, rather than extracts meaning from the text. It is isegesis, rather than exegesis. While mufassirun explain one verse at a time, an examination of the paragraph as a whole reveals that the whole paragraph concerns the Jews, and their iniquity in particular; it lists fifteen of their transgressions. Substantial inter-textuality can be found both with Sura 2 and with Chapter 7 of the Acts of the Apostles. Every phrase in ayas 153 to 155 of Sura 4, except the first and the last, are found in Sura 2, which is named “The Cow”, because it contains a narrative about the golden calf. Likewise, five of the phrases in ayas 153 to 157 are found in Stephen’s speech to the Jewish leaders, which Luke records in the fifth book of the New Testament. An important theme that dominates every phrase of the aya 157b inclusio points to the proper, but not traditional, translation of shubbiha. Neither the Arabic text nor any English translation makes the structure of this paragraph clear, but recent scholarship is demonstrating that Semitic rhetoric is often the key that unveils the unexpected meaning of the Qur’anic text, oftentimes in the form of Ring Composition. This paragraph, however, features a series of five conditional terms that introduce lines of thinking that are antithetical to a narrative by Mu?ammad, two narratives by the Jews and two religious judgment narratives. These five rebuttals are the story behind the story; they form the storyline that differentiates Islam from Judaism. While substantiating the concept of the inimitability (I‘jaz) of the Qur’an, the resulting meaning will come as a surprise.
|
The Sixth-Century Opposition to Child Sacrifice: Emerging Moral Sensibility or Response to Trauma?
Program Unit: Biblical Literature and the Hermeneutics of Trauma
Margaret S. Odell, Saint Olaf College
Historians seeking to reconstruct the practice of child sacrifice in ancient Israel must account for the 7th–6th century critiques of Jeremiah and Ezekiel, who stand out as isolated voices denouncing it. On one hand, these denunciations indicate that Jeremiah and Ezekiel were reacting to actual practice; on the other, the specific contours of that practice remain unclear. Were they condemning a longstanding normative practice whose deep psychic and spiritual impulses were never entirely suppressed? Although such a claim has been persuasively made in recent years (so Levenson , Stavrakopoulou, Noort), it falters on the lack of evidence that children were sacrificed in Israel as a strictly Yahwistic rite. Rather, historical reports of child sacrifice suggest it was more closely tied to international concerns: one historical report situates it in the context of treaty violation (2 Kgs 3:23), while Ahaz and Manasseh, the two Judean kings who are condemned for the practice, are also condemned for their foreign alliances (2 Kgs 16:3; 21:6 ).
|
Paul and Maccabean Politics
Program Unit: Function of Apocryphal and Pseudepigraphal Writings in Early Judaism and Early Christianity
Gerbern S Oegema, McGill University
In this paper I would like to contribute to the discussion on “Paul and Politics” by focusing on his Letter to the Galatians and his adaptation of Maccabean politics. Whereas it is clear that Paul’s main focus in his interpretation of Scripture is his belief in Jesus Christ as the Saviour of all of humanity and that this Christology clearly defines his hermeneutic, it is also beyond doubt that he had a Jewish background and that he had received a Jewish and Greek education, which included exposure to, knowledge of and practice in contemporary Jewish biblical interpretation. This Jewish background was very much influenced by the theology and ideology of the Maccabees and their successors, especially, but not exclusively in Paul’s pre-Christian years. I intend to argue in this paper that Paul 1) during his pre-Christian life had been influenced by the Maccabean ideology of a zeal for God and His Torah, 2) knew the history of the Maccabees and probably also the books of the 1 and 2 Maccabees, 3) very well knew the meaning of the expression “zeal”, 4) was a member of a movement in the Judaism of the first half of the first century CE, which had been influenced by that zeal, 5) was not a member of the anti-Roman Zealot movement, 6) still during his Christian life had been influenced by the Maccabean historiography to the extent that he understood his own life anti-thetically to the zeal for God and was able to portray in a transformed way from it, 7) because he knew the religious zeal for God so well, he fought even harder against the “Judaizers” in Galatia, who wanted to introduce again exactly that, what Paul had come to reject, namely circumcision.
|
Sarah in Exile: The Conceptualization of a Deported Woman in the Book of Tobit
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
Manfred Oeming, Ruprecht-Karls-Universität Heidelberg
In the Book of Tobit the exile is seen as the basic situation of the Jewish people. A return from Nineveh to Israel is only a vague hope for the far future. Also for the female hero of the book - Sarah from Ecbatane a city of Media - the situation of exile in a non-Jewish environment is the framework for all her live. The question for a pious woman in the eastern diaspora is not so much where Judaism can be lived – she has no alternative-, but how? Which elements of the Jewish identity can be and must be realized? Sarah is a model for the conceptualization of the exile; her virtues include constant prayer, obedience to the parents, study of the Mosaic torah, endogamy, and fertility. The main question from a methodological point of view is if one can see here a difference between the destiny of a woman and a man because Sarah is clearly portrayed in close parallel to Tobit and to Job.
|
Open Questions in the Reconstruction of History from Ramat Rachel
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Manfred Oeming, Ruprecht-Karls-Universität Heidelberg
*
|
The Social Location and Composition of the Early Christians in Philippi
Program Unit: Polis and Ekklesia: Investigations of Urban Christianity
Julien M. Ogereau, Macquarie University
Drawing from the seminal work of E. A. Judge, W. A. Meeks, and others, on the social pattern of the first Christians, this paper explores the social location and composition of the earliest Christian community at Philippi. It adduces and analyses both internal and external evidence that might shed light on the question, and discusses the methodological difficulties in ascertaining more precisely the social identity of Paul’s first disciples.
Special attention is given to the business language of Philippians 1:1–12 and 4:15–20, which is examined in the light of papyrological and epigraphic sources, as well as to the epigraphic and archaeological material found at or near Philippi.
Following a detailed assessment of Paul’s usage of economic technical terminology (and its conformity with documentary sources), and an evaluation of the audience’s potential response to Paul’s economic discourse, it is concluded that the first Christian community at Philippi was primarily composed of members of the urban plebs media, a highly mobile, most likely free (or freed), economically independent and entrepreneurial ‘middling class’ that populated Roman provincial cities.
|
Discerning Migrant Rhetorics and the Messiness of Diaspora Space
Program Unit: Bible and Cultural Studies
Margaret Aymer-Oget, Interdenominational Theological Center
This presentation will focus particularly on issues of pedagogy when engaging labor, migration, and biblical studies.
|
Honorary Ethnics: Contesting and Subverting Christian Stigma through the Construction of Ethnic Identity in 1 Peter
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Janette H. Ok, Princeton Theological Seminary
This paper examines why the author of 1 Peter chose to use emphatically ethnic language to describe the communal Christian identity of his addressees. I focus on the role of stigma in 1 Pet in light of Erving Goffman's seminal study on stigma. Goffman identifies three types of stigma: (1) physical “abominations” or deformities; (2) “blemishes” of individual character; and (3) tribal stigmas of race, nation, and religion that can typically be passed from generation to generation. I focus on the tribal forms of stigma—that of race, nation, and religion—because I am exploring why the author of 1 Pet chooses to use ethnic language as a means to construct Christian identity when Christians are already stigmatized for what Goffman would call their blemishes of individual character, i.e., for their superstition, criminality, and anti-social, religiously exclusive atheism. I argue that the author of 1 Pet constructs Christian identity along explicitly ethnic lines as a strategy to contest and reappropriate the stigma associated with being “Christian” and to reduce the temptation for Christians to revert to their former identity. If Christians understand themselves as being people who possess not only a new present-day identity but also a new lineage through the blood of Christ, they will see an enormous distinction between being a Christian and not having been one. Although they have abandoned their old lineage, they are not left without one. Rather, Christians now possess a separate system of honor and distinct cultural identity that enables them to subvert the stigma imposed upon them by the dominant culture.
|
Trouble Getting In: Third John in Light of Greco-Roman Associations
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Ryan Olfert, University of Toronto
Socio-historical scholarship on 3 John produced by Abraham Malherbe, Bruce Malina, Raymond Brown, Elisabeth Schüssler Fiorenza, among others has problematized theological difference as the underlying conflict of the letter. Instead, such scholarship has sought to place the letter in the context of social practices from the ancient world, including letters of recommendation, hospitality, and patronage. While social-scientific approaches have produced insightful analyses of the letter, scholarship on 3 John has relied too heavily on a singular model of social organization: the household. Kinship relations were a ubiquitous part of the ancient world; however, over emphasis on kinship groups has led to an under appreciation of other social formations, such as philosophical schools, associations, and age-based groups. Research on associations has most often been placed alongside the Pauline ekklesia, although there have been initial forays into Johannine material by John Kloppenborg on the aposynagogos of the Gospel of John and Eva Ebel on the Johannine epistles. The ample evidence from associations shows how these groups dealt with situations of conflict, disciplined members, and practiced hospitality. In particular, associations denied entry and participation for several reasons: not paying to attend a meeting, not paying dues, introducing a motion in violation of the regulations, and not paying a contribution to introduce someone. In addition to these, another reason can be inferred from associations: that a potential recruit did not pass an entrance examination. I will suggest that this last reason is a plausible scenario for 3 John and that the presbyteros’ letter can be read as an attempt to respond to a situation where a person in his network, Demetrius, has failed to achieve membership in the group.
|
Messianic Jews and the Early Jewish Followers of Jesus
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Isaac W. Oliver, Bradley University
David Rudolph and Joel Willitts' book, Introduction to Messianic Judaism, contains a series of significant articles on the New Testament, written from a post-supersessionist perspective. The aim of this response is to critically assess how these contributions fit within the wider vision and frameworks of Messianic Judaism, Jewish-Christian dialogue, and New Testament scholarship.
|
A Gender-Sensitive Methodology in African Biblical Interpretation: Insights from the Book of Proverbs
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Funlola Olojede, University of South Africa
In recent years, African biblical scholars have called for a biblical hermeneutics that takes into account of, and is sensitive to, pressing issues on the African continent such as HIV and AIDS or poverty. This paper argues that issues of methodology in African Biblical Hermeneutics must also take seriously the question of gender in teaching and interpretation of Scriptures. Taking wisdom literature, specifically the book of Proverbs, as a point of departure, the paper points out that issues of gender are more complex than often assumed in the sense that though the book of Proverbs is generally regarded as “female friendly,” strong undercurrents of masculinities also underline the text which resonate with the African communal view of gender. Whereas the book of Proverbs is replete with feminine imagery and stereotypical female figures such as the Woman Wisdom, the Strange Woman, or the foolish woman, and the tendency in wisdom scholarship is to highlight what is arguably the feminine bias of the book, the book also contains strong portrayals of masculinities which seem to correspond to certain masculine stereotypes in Africa. The gender issues therefore need to be teased out in a way that would produce gender-balanced interpretation of Scriptures on the continent.
|
The Oral Context of Ethics in the Book of Proverbs: An African Reflection
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Funlola Olojede, University of South Africa
The tendency to relegate wisdom to the background in earlier historical critical studies of the Hebrew Bible seems to have a bearing on the reception of wisdom in African biblical hermeneutics, particularly on African wisdom ethics. The latter is a rarely researched area within scholarship. This paper argues that a comprehensive ethical reflection on wisdom in the book of Proverbs in Africa must take into account the oral context of wisdom traditions on the continent. By considering the nature of wisdom-ethical instructions in a particular African context, it will be argued that the oral setting of wisdom instructions in Africa has some telling implications for the understanding of ethics in Proverbs. The latter ethics was primarily grounded in moral teachings in ancient Israel, the primary locus of which was the family. Also, the role of women in ethical instructions in the African wisdom tradition will be examined vis-à-vis the role of women as it is revealed in the book of Proverbs. On the whole, it is argued in this paper that the wisdom embedded in Proverbs can throw a helpful light on some African wisdom traditions particularly when ethical decisions are made.
|
Making Visible Expert Thinking and Reading to Enhance Student Learning: Reading 1 Sam 1:9–18 as a Case Study
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Steven Olsen, LDS Church History Department
In the search for meaning of the biblical text, literary studies offer one of the most intriguing and rewarding approaches. How might teachers help learners develop the abilities and attitudes of close scripture reading required by literary studies? This presentation will model how a teacher might also model to their students the careful reading of biblical passages, applying several of the most common literary conventions of the Hebrew Bible to 1 Samuel 1:9-18 in order to illustrate the wealth of insight that can come from this interpretive approach to the Bible. In this presentation as I read these Biblical passages I will pause to provide pedagogical commentary on why I am reading this way and what meaning is derived from such a reading. The hope is that this modeling exercise will provide an example to other teachers of how they might make their expert thinking and reading abilities visible and explicit for their students.
|
Paul and the Philippians
Program Unit: Polis and Ekklesia: Investigations of Urban Christianity
Heike Omerzu, University of Copenhagen
This paper wants to explore the beginnings of Christianity in Philippi in light of Paul’s Epistle to the Philippians and Luke’s account in the Book of Acts. A special focus will be laid on the question if, and if so, how, the political status of Philippi as a Roman colony is reflected by the sources. Might it even have had an impact on Paul’s extraordinarily close relationship to the Christ believers in Philippi? In addition it is to be asked if Paul’s own Roman citizenship – that is only attested to by Luke – played a role in this respect or not? Did Paul, e.g., take advantage of his citizenship or did he rather renounce it? How is the political terminology and imagery in Philippians to be understood against this background? Both, Paul and Luke, reveal that Philippi played an extraordinary role in the course of Paul’s missionary activity even though they do so from very different points of departure (e.g., according to Acts there was no synagogue in the city but only a gathering outside the city walls). In this light is has to be asked if Philippi is representative of early Christian missionary activity or rather the exception to the rule.
|
An Integrative Conversation Analysis Model: Analyzing Rom 6:1–7:6 as a Test Case
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Hughson T. Ong, McMaster Divinity College
This paper analyzes the text of Rom 6:1—7:6, employing a set of discourse analytic tools used in the field of sociolinguistics. This set of discourse analytic tools integrates theories and elements of critical discourse analysis (CDA), conversational analysis (CA), and interactional sociolinguistics (IS) into a single methodological framework. All three discourse analytic tools focus on the micro-interactional features of a conversational text, which characterizes our unit of interest, as well as many other texts in the letter to the Romans, particularly with reference to Paul’s imaginary conversation partner(s) beginning at Rom 2:1. The objective is to provide a new, alternative approach to analyzing Romans, with reference to those texts that are typically identified as a Hellenistic diatribe rhetorical style (or a modified form of it).
|
A Covenant Sealed in the Core of Clay Jar: Intertextual Reconfigurations of Jeremiah in 2 Corinthians 1–7
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
B. J. Oropeza, Azusa Pacific University
It is well recognized that Paul associates the new covenant language of 2 Corinthians 3 with a term used in Jeremiah 31 (38 LXX). What is not normally recognized is how Paul may be informed by the larger discourse of the ancient Hebrew prophet that includes Jeremiah 32 (39 LXX). The sealing of an official contract as proof of the redemption of Jeremiah’s uncle’s field for a future inheritance, along with new covenant language, have significant influence on various images that Paul presents in 2 Corinthians 1–7. This includes his use of the seal of the Spirit, writing on the heart, treasure in clays jars, and the change of heart that he expects from his recipients. This paper will address how Paul adopts and reconfigures the text of Jeremiah via allusion and metalepsis both to defend against accusations and make an appeal for Corinthian reconciliation.
|
Spiritual Blindness and Wisdom Traditions in the Book of Isaiah
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Eric Ortlund, Briercrest Seminary
Spiritual Blindness and Wisdom Traditions in the Book of Isaiah
|
Causativity in the Hebrew Binyanim
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Charles Otte, III, University of Chicago
Scholars have subjected the biblical Hebrew verbal system to continuous analysis in recent decades, with scholars such as Joosten (2012) and Cook (2012) providing clear examples of vastly differing perspectives and differing linguistic frameworks. Recent discussions focus almost exclusively on questions of Tense-Aspect-Mood (TAM) to the exclusion of the stems or binyanim. The studies that have appeared have excluded approaches incorporating mainstream generative syntax in their analyses (e.g. Joosten 1998, Benton 2009, Garr 2012). My paper examines the puzzles associated with causativity in biblical Hebrew and the binyanim, working within Chomsky's Minimalist Program as it is specifically expressed through the model of Distributed Morphology. I argue that morphosyntax is the most appropriate domain for accounting for the empirical data of binyanim selection. I conclude that the architecture of Distributed Morphology provides not only the best means of accounting for much empirical data in Hebrew morphosyntax, but specifically provides a principled way of accounting for the multiple expressions of causativity within the binyanim.
|
Elijah, the Remnant, and Eating Bread in the Kingdom of God: The Miracle of the Loaves in Luke
Program Unit: Gospel of Luke
Jeremy D. Otten, Wheaton College Graduate School
The Lukan account of the feeding of the five thousand (Luke 9:10–17) showcases the author’s skills as both storyteller and theologian, for while the episode is portrayed similarly in all four canonical Gospels, the redactional decisions and subtle details added in the Third Gospel place this pericope at the convergence of two major Lukan motifs, giving it a unique flavor. First, the meal motif, which runs through Luke-Acts and connects the kingdom of God with a feast, finds major development in this messianic banquet in the wilderness. Secondly, the Elijah motif, frequently noted as important for Luke, is brought to the fore through Luke’s arrangement of the surrounding material (e.g., Luke 9:8, 19). Significantly, both motifs are strongly tied to the question of who will be included in the kingdom. By connecting this familiar narrative to such rich motifs, Luke masterfully draws deeper meaning from it: the true members of the kingdom of God are a remnant who answer the invitation of the Lord of the Banquet.
This paper will demonstrate the remnant theology developed in Luke’s account of the feeding of the five thousand in three ways. First, it will examine recent scholarship on the meal motif in Luke-Acts, highlighting significant texts. In particular it will show that Jesus speaks of the kingdom as a banquet to highlight certain remnant themes, such as inclusion to and exclusion from the kingdom (e.g., Luke 14:15–24), and the relatively few who will be saved (e.g., Luke 23:22, 29). Second, it will briefly examine the Elijah motif in Luke, showing especially the connection between Elijah and the remnant in Luke’s account of Jesus’ teaching (esp. Luke 4:25–27). Finally, it will highlight the specific details and redactional decisions within Luke 9:10–17 and its context that cause these two motifs to converge in the Lukan account of the feeding miracle. By connecting this miracle to both the figure of Elijah and to the Messianic feast, Luke depicts this wilderness meal as an antepast to the kingdom banquet, in which the few who respond to the invitation are welcomed as honored guests.
|
The Holy Spirit: Power for Life and Hope
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
C. René Padilla, Comunidad Kairós, Argentina
The Holy Spirit: Power for Life and Hope
|
De-instrumentalizing the Law: The Function of Torah Obedience within Ezekiel’s Theocentric Vision of Restoration
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
Anthony J. Pagliarini, University of Notre Dame
The account of Israel’s history in Ezekiel 20 contains three allusions to Leviticus 18:5, “You shall keep my statutes and my ordinances, by the doing of which a man shall live” (cf. Ezek 20:11, 13, 21). These allusions speak to the contingent character of blessing in the Sinaitic covenant and so establish the framework within which to understand God’s eventual punishment of a perpetually disobedient Israel. More importantly, the references to Lev 18:5 act a cipher for precisely the type of (“Deuteronomic”) arrangement that will not characterize God’s restorative action for Israel in Ezek 36-37. There, Yahweh acts for his own purposes irrespective of Israel’s obedience, and the gift of a new heart (36:26) and of the revivifying “spirit” (37:14) will make it such that Israel will, in fact, be unable to fail in her keeping of the Law (cf. 37:23). The “life” which in Lev 18:5 is the reward for obedience is here part of the gift of restoration which precedes and ensures obedience.
In the later Pauline reception of this text, the gift of the new heart permanently relativizes the function of the Law such that “the letter” will no longer be practiced (cf. 2 Cor 3:1ff. et al.) Once having achieved that for which is was the instrumental means (however inefficacious in Paul’s view), the Law rightly falls away. For Ezekiel, it is the very opposite. The gift of the new heart culminates in a vision of renewed obedience to the Torah. And since the Law no longer functions instrumentally—for all that it might have occasioned is already given—we are invited to view Torah as itself part of the content of Yahweh’s gratuitous restoration. That is to say, Torah observance is shown not to be the cause but rather the form of the those who possess the new heart and spirit of Ezek 36-37.
In this way Ezekiel provides some measure of correction to an overly mechanistic understanding of the Law characteristic of the so-called “Deuteronomic” theology. Importantly, however, Ezekiel’s emphasis on divine sovereignty and on the conception of Torah as blessing gives voice to identical but less audible elements within the Deuteronomic tradition. It is precisely this relationship that my paper will address, namely Ezekiel’s correction and adoption of material from the Book of Deuteronomy and the Holiness Code as they pertain to the understanding the role of Torah in the life of restored Israel.
|
Spiritual Tattooing and Pain in the San Francisco Bay Area
Program Unit: Violence and Representations of Violence in Antiquity
Marie Pagliarini, Saint Mary's College of California
This paper explores the role of physical pain in spiritual tattooing, and is based on interviews conducted with people living in the San Francisco Bay Area. The paper sheds light on the diverse ways that people experience the pain of tattooing as a meaningful spiritual event, and analyzes these practices from the perspective of theoretical works on religion, culture, and the body. Recent work on affect theory and how it can be useful in understanding the connections between ritual experience, emotion, and pain will be addressed. The process of acquiring a tattoo—and the pain associated with it—is as important as the material images imprinted in the body, and the paper addresses both aspects of tattooing.
|
The Stream of Interpretation in the Study of Jude
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
R. Jackson Painter, Simpson University
The interpretation of Jude has a relatively consistent history beginning with Clement of Alexandria and Didymus the Blind in the second to fourth centuries CE. Clement, Didymus, and others are already concerned with Assumption of Moses and Enoch as sources, and Didymus posits libertine, gnostic, false teachers as the opponents. At points new threads or, better, tributaries have flowed into the interpretive stream such as Jude’s relationship with 2 Peter in the Reformation period, a renewed discussion of sources of Jude in the 19th century, and recently rhetorical and literary designs, but the observations have simply entered the stream, not altered it significantly. In this paper, I will identify various elements or issues in the history of Jude interpretation and, if possible, discern where they entered this historical stream. I will close by commenting on elements in Jude interpretation that have been ignored, misunderstood, or not yet identified, which may add to, disrupt, or perhaps alter the flow of current interpretation.
|
Creating a Synthesis Out of Torah Centered and Proverbial Admonitions: The Direction and Larger Significance of the Textual Connection between 4Q185 and 4Q370
Program Unit: Transmission of Traditions in the Second Temple Period
Mika Pajunen, University of Helsinki
There are many cases in the Hebrew Bible where literary and redaction criticism has shown it plausible that the author/redactor of a text has used sources that have since been lost in the course of time. These sources may never be recovered, yet there are definite traces of them in the surviving literature. However, recent studies, for instance by Juha Pakkala, on the editing of texts in antiquity have demonstrated that there were even more radical cases of textual editing that the present methodology does not adequately account for. Such cases are typically unobservable if only the later text survives and thus are mostly unattainable, yet their mere existence challenges the current axioms of traditional exegetical methods. Thus, it is vital to analyze all existing cases of such editing practices in order to pave the way for more accurate methodological advances.
This paper will focus on a textual connection between two admonitory texts discovered at Qumran, 4QSapiential Admonitions B (4Q185) and 4QAdmonition on the Flood (4Q370). Beside the existence of this connection very little has been done to explore it and even the direction of the influence is still open. This connection will be thoroughly analyzed in order to fully appreciate its importance for understanding the purpose of the fragmentary individual texts and the applied editing practices. It will be shown that the text of 4Q370 was a source of 4Q185 that was radically edited (e.g., additions, omissions and recontextualizing can be observed) and combined with Proverbial wisdom traditions. The purpose of this editing was to create a synthesis out of the more traditional wisdom thinking and the Torah oriented deuteronomic parenesis (employed, for instance, in 4Q370), as was also done by Ben Sira in his own wisdom work around the same time period.
|
Omissions in the Transmission of the Hebrew Scriptures
Program Unit: Transmission of Traditions in the Second Temple Period
Juha Pakkala, University of Helsinki
Literary criticism (Literarkritik; source criticism) commonly assumes that editors/redactors only made additions to the biblical texts. Because of its holiness, parts of the older text would not have been omitted in the transmission. Literary critical analyses are dependent on this axiom, as they seek to reconstruct a succession of textual layers; the scholar would be able to reach the preserved older layer after the later additions are identified. Many literary critical conclusions are dependent on the validity of the axiom that nothing was omitted.
The axiom is partially substantiated by documented evidence. A review of variant versions of the same passage in the Hebrew scriptures reveals that some editors did preserve the older text very faithfully and only made additions (e.g., the MT of Jeremiah vs. the older LXX version; the Samaritan Pentateuch vs. the MT). However, these examples only provide a limited picture of the transmission.
Documented evidence from variant editions and parallel passages show that omissions also took place in the transmission of the Hebrew scriptures. Although not as common as additions, the existence of omissions challenges the axiom on which much of literary criticism has been built. While it would be hazardous to abandon literary criticism, the future challenge is to refine the methodology so that it corresponds better with documented evidence.
|
The Temple Scroll as Evidence for Paradigm Shifts in the Transmission of the Pentateuch
Program Unit: Qumran
Juha Pakkala, University of Helsinki
The Temple Scroll should be seen as part of the same literary tradition as the Pentateuch. Its compositional processes are similar, and its genre is closely related to the legal sections of the Pentateuch. Although thoroughly dependent on Deuteronomy, it is unlikely that the Temple Scroll was intended as its interpretation. Under a right historical setting the Temple Scroll could have replaced Deuteronomy (and the rest of the Pentateuch) as the most authoritative version of Yahweh’s revelation, which it was also intended to be.
The Temple Scroll implies a significant ideological paradigm shift in relation to Deuteronomy. Since it was written during the templeless time, Deuteronomy largely neglects the Temple. A product of the Second Temple period, the Temple Scroll seeks to update the divine revelation in this respect; the priestly sections of the Pentateuch may not yet have been combined with Deuteronomy. On the other hand, some details in the Temple Scroll differ from the pentateuchal laws, which could indicate a sectarian background of the document. In either case, the Temple Scroll shows how a highly authoritative document of a divine origin could have been radically revised in a substantially changed ideological setting.
|
Boundaries Crossed and Boundaries Kept at Qumran: Mutable or Immutable Ethnicity
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
Carmen Palmer, University of Toronto
Generally the Qumran community has been perceived as a sectarian community with heightened purity standards, leading to low levels of permeability toward outsiders. Certain of the texts or legal rules affiliated with Qumran legislate to keep one’s distance from Gentiles, for example CD XI, 14-15’s regulation to remain physically removed from Gentiles on the Sabbath. This paper will argue that even though the Dead Sea Scrolls (DSS) demonstrate heightened levels of purity, nevertheless Gentiles who have previously converted to Judaism are permitted in some texts as members of the community and are then perceived as Israelite “brothers.” The acceptance of these brothers is due to a notion of ethnic mutability. Qumran community members themselves have an ethnic identity comprised of the elements of a shared notion of descent, memories of and connection to a land, and various “religious” practices. The new “brothers” have taken on Israelite descent, the connection to land, and these shared religious practices. The texts in which these Gentile converts are esteemed as Israelite brothers are either from the Damascus Document (and the full text tradition of D), or other scrolls that thematically relate to this rule text. In some other DSS, however, these Gentile converts are refuted entry intro the community. In these occasions, the efficacy of the prior ethnic conversion of the Gentile is denied, presumably due to stronger purity measures and thus social closure. In fact, this more closed stream of Qumran believes that they themselves are converts who must undergo an additional “circumcision of form.” In this regard, they perceive themselves as a sort of “supra-Judean.” This stream of Qumran is observed within the Rule of the Community (1QS) and other thematically related texts. In all cases, it is the figure of the ger who represents this “convert,” whether included as Judean, excluded as “yet a Gentile,” or representing a “supra-Judean.” The ger has served as a proven harbinger in the past in the Hebrew Bible and rabbinic texts, highlighting the socio-historical shift from “resident alien” to permitted “convert,” and thus the ger continues to serve in this capacity. The paper demonstrates that some boundaries can indeed be crossed at Qumran.
|
A Unique Commentary Manuscript: GA457 and the Pauline Catena Tradition
Program Unit: Novum Testamentum Graecum: Editio Critica Maior
Theodora Panella, University of Birmingham
Catenae are manuscripts that contain the biblical text and a commentary, which consists of patristic quotations forming a kind of exegetical chain. Catenae seem to have played an important role in the theological and exegetical discussions in the East and West from the fourth century onwards. However, they have rarely attracted scholarly attention. Most of the material remains unpublished, with little in the way of critical texts. Regarding the catenae on the Pauline epistles, in particular, there is no thorough examination of the manuscript tradition and the patristic material that is preserved in them. Furthermore, their biblical quotations have not been taken into consideration when reconstructing the textual history of the New Testament. Most, but not all, catenae manuscripts have been listed by scholars over the last century. However, GA457, not identified as a commentary in the Kurzgefasste Liste, is a catena manuscript of Paul with a
unique type of commentary, which may help to illuminate the history of the genre. The paper will investigate the sources from which the commentary has been taken. It will pay particular attention to unidentified scholia and any scholia found in the wrong place. It will also look at the affiliation of the biblical text to determine whether it was copied from another catena manuscript or is a new composition. The chapter titles before each book and at the top of each page are another interesting feature. More general comments about Pauline catena tradition will be offered on the basis of this manuscript.
|
Two Kinds of Movement? An Evaluation of Recent Proposals Concerning the Classification of Movement Verbs
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Francis G.H. Pang, McMaster Divinity College
Several recent works insist that Greek movement verbs, in particular those that have a prefixed counterpart (or counterparts), can be classified into two groups according to the telicity of the action denoted by the verb. Some argue that their classifications are linguistic in nature and that they can be made to rest on linguistic factors such as grammatical aspect and/or the presence of certain co-textual and contextual elements (e.g. adverbials or arguments of the verb). Others are not as clear-cut in their descriptions, however, and so the proposed classifications sometimes contradict one another. The present study, which tests the conclusions of these recent studies, is based on the empirical evidence of a Hellenistic corpus containing half a million words. It argues that the contradictory results are due to the fact that telicity cannot be described linguistically in a systematic manner, because telicity emerges from a range of both linguistic and extra-linguistic factors.
|
Paul and the Lord’s Supper in Corinth: A Paradigm for Practical Theological Method
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Lance B. Pape, Brite Divinity School (TCU)
This paper explores 1 Corinthians 11:17-34 as a window into the theological method of the church’s first great practical theologian. In other words, it is an attempt to derive scripture’s normative force not as a function of specific judgments this passage renders vis-à-vis the issue of the Lord’s Supper, but from its capacity to function as a paradigm for practical theological method generally, and homiletics specifically. Drawing on the work of Gerd Theissen and other social historical critics, the paper develops a thick understanding of the complicated situation Paul addresses in Corinth. Specifically, the paper argues that Paul has access to two different narratives about conflict in the community, one in written form that narrates the conflict from the perspective of the social elite, and one in the form of an oral report that represents the perspective of the less privileged. In the case of the conflict surrounding the Lord’s Supper, it is clear that Paul privileges the oral report “from beneath.” With a detailed reconstruction of the crisis Paul is addressing in hand, the paper traces his use of the received tradition to creatively address the conflict. Specifically, Paul’s method is understood in terms of: 1) a descriptive moment that privileges the perspective of the socially less privileged; 2) a trusting and expectant disposition toward the narrative tradition and its capacity to address the contingencies of the moment; 3) a constructive moment characterized by a bold bid to “see as”—to see the Corinthian situation as the sight of a divine praxis; and 4) the proposal of new practice characterized by clarity and directness. These insights are appropriated for contemporary practical theological method generally, and homiletics specifically.
|
A Thabilu Update
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
Dennis Pardee, University of Chicago
Over the past decade, a scribe who worked in the Ugaritic alphabetic cuneiform writing system and who signed his name {?b?l} has been emerging from obscurity. In contrast with Ilimilku, the scribe of the large multi-columned mythological texts discovered at Ras Shamra-Ugarit, well known because he signed his works with colophons including varying numbers of data, but always his name, Thabilu worked with single-columned texts and did not add formal colophons, only his signature, attested twice, one only partially preserved. The identification of his works has proceded gradually, tablet by tablet, based on three principal criteria: (1) the signatures, (2) palaeography, and (3) one orthographic/phonetic peculiarity (the use of the {?}-sign for /?/). Thabilu preceded his more illustrious colleague Ilimilku by a generation or two, for some of his works may be dated to the middle of the 13th century, plausibly not long after the invention of the Ugaritic writing system. Probably owing at least in part to the novelty of the Ugaritic cuneiform system, Thabilu’s work is characterized by experimentation, for he wrote mythological and divinatory texts in Ugaritic, was responsible for the few known texts in the Akkadian language but in Ugaritic script, as well as for several texts in the Hurrian language, also in Ugaritic script. This update will provide an illustrated overview of the process of identification of Thabilu’s work and his peculiarities as a scribe.
|
Stand-Alone Nominalization in 1 Sam 25:26: Towards a Broader Typology of Clausal Nominalization in Biblical Hebrew
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Grace J. Park, University of the Free State
In this paper, I argue that ’ašer in 1 Sam 25:26 acts as a nominalizer, forming a stand-alone nominalization (nominalization of a matrix clause), on the basis of a broad typology of clausal nominalization drawn from recent work on the languages of Central and East Asia. This analysis results in a rather different interpretation than can be found in previous discussions of the verse. Up to now most discussions of the ’ašer clause in 1 Sam 25:26 have analyzed it as a causal clause (“since YHWH has restrained you . . .”) in relation to the following clause that begins with we‘attâ. However, such an analysis has left many investigators puzzled in that the content of Abigail’s oath makes little sense: David has not yet been restrained from shedding innocent blood and Nabal is not yet dead. In order to solve the problem, Henry P. Smith, for instance, argues that the content of the oath signaled by the oath formula in v. 26 is in fact the preceding statement in v. 25b, while P. Kyle McCarter makes a form critical argument, suggesting that v. 26 should appear in between v. 41 and v. 42. However, by analyzing ’ašer as a nominalizer that forms a stand-alone nominalization, the ’ašer clause alone (not linked to the neighboring the we‘attâ clause) can be seen as the entire content of the oath in 1 Sam 25:26. Consequently Abigail’s oath asserts that it is YHWH who sent her to David in order to prevent him from shedding innocent blood.
|
Metonymy in Q: Mothering Images of God from the Daily Lives of Women
Program Unit: Q
Inhee Park, Ewha Womans University
Recent study of oral communication environments sheds light on both the text and context of Q, that is, its theological conceptions as well as its socio-historical context. One aspect of oral performance is the use of metonymy which has a distinctive rhetorical function. In Q, metonymy establishes a particular image of God that is distinctive from that of other dominant religious groups contemporary with Q. Q describes God using the imagery of compassionate parents in combinational metonymy, rather than a stand-alone selective metaphor of father. Many concrete images from various aspects of the lived world of Q establish this image of God, in connection with Q’s oral culture. These small and commonplace images cannot represent the complete image of God in Q in separation, but rather they combine together to build the compassionate image of God that Q conveys.
This paper explores the metonymic expressions of mothering from the daily activities of women in Q (13:20-21, 12:27, 14:34, 15:8-10, 17:35) regarding female labor in ancient agrarian small village settings as an essential element to God’s image. Although Q’s representative designation for God is most often one of fatherhood, the mothering images, especially images of a mother’s caring and feeding, not only of a family but also of an entire village, are essential to the concept of God that Q conveys. Additionally, the God of Q consistently manifests as providing nourishment to beloved children, such as bread, fish, and sun and rain for farming. Also, the highlighted intimate portrayal of God as parents in Q invokes a relational image of mother to infant rather than ancient fatherhood. This metonymical use in Q of God’s caring image portrayed through the routines of nurturing, most often conducted within the scope of female daily activity, contributes to an ever-widening scope of study of the theological foundations of Christian ethics which emphasizes compassion and mercy. Also, the investigation of mothering imagery in connection with the ancient economical context of Q indicates that positive roles of woman in Q community have important theological implications, which will be helpful both for feminist theology and the study of early Christian history.
|
Bearing the Marks while Bearing One Another’s Burdens: A Womanist Political Reading of bastazo in Galatians 5 and 6
Program Unit: African-American Biblical Hermeneutics
Angela N. Parker, Chicago Theological Seminary
On March 2, 2014, Lupita Nyong’o won the best supporting actress Oscar for her portrayal of Patsey, the African female slave in the screen adaptation of Solomon Northup’s memoir Twelve Years a Slave. Since the political effects of slavery are still a “hot topic” in American culture as a result of popular movies such as “Twelve Years a Slave” and “Django Unchained,” this paper provides a Womanist political reading of bastazo in Galatians 5 and 6 as its relates to Paul’s metaphor of slavery in Galatians.
Focusing on the metaphor of slavery, this paper argues that Womanist biblical scholars can formulate a Womanist view of political activism by contemplating Paul’s metaphor of slavery to Christ as a starting point for said political activity. In traditional interpretation, scholars argue that Paul uses the word bastazo to implore the Galatians to moral and ethical obedience to Jesus. I argue, however, that by connecting Paul’s use of the word bastazo in 6:17 to its previous uses in the text, Paul actually seeks a political rather than ethical understanding in Galatians 5 and 6.
Drawing from a cadre of methodologies stemming from cultural, postcolonial and feminist studies, this paper crafts a Womanist hermeneutic of wholeness that focuses on Paul’s identification of his body bearing the stigmata of Jesus in Galatians 6:17 as a starting point to build the metaphor of the stigmatized body. However, focusing on the body of African and African American women, I construct a Womanist political body from this stigmatized body. After briefly outlining how the history of interpretation argues for identifying the stigmata as marks of slavery, this paper contends that attention to these marks along with Paul’s varying uses of bastazo in other parts of Galatians point to a political understanding of “bearing one another’s burdens.” This argument unfolds by first highlighting the political understanding of the “collection” in Galatians 2 as a political act (following the work of Sze-kar Wan). Second, this paper highlights the political understanding of “works of the law” as understood in Galatians 3:10-14. These political readings of Galatians 2 and 3 allow me to nuance the traditional ethical understanding and interpretation of Galatians 5 and 6 to a deeper political meaning that allows this paper to construct a Womanist political activist transnational effort. Just as Paul nuanced various ways to fight against the political forces of the Roman Empire, using Paul’s letters to the Galatians, Womanists can creatively construct transnational political activism to fight against neocolonialism across the globe.
|
The Priestly Polyphony: Suffering and the Day of Atonement in Leviticus 16
Program Unit: Sacrifice, Cult, and Atonement
B. J. Parker, Baylor University
As many publications within the past twenty years evidence, a renewed interest in priestly matters in general and Leviticus in particular has begun to blossom within the field of biblical scholarship. The role of the Priestly source as significant theological contributor to the Pentateuch and a move away from a flat view of ritual has opened up broad avenues of theological exploration. Despite the resurgence of interest in the vitality of the ritual world of ancient Israel and Judah, the cult has not generally been regarded as a rich source of theodicy. This study takes up questions of suffering and theodicy within the realm of the cult and argues that a polyphonic analysis of the Day of Atonement shows that the Priestly response to suffering is robust and original. A close reading of Leviticus 16 that takes seriously the theological tenor of the text as well as the historical post-exilic setting reveals three voices bound up together within the chapter: one that testifies to the experience of a dangerous deity, one that testifies to the experience and fear of chaos, and one that understands the ritual world to be a way of concretely living through the community’s greatest fears. This study will tease out these voices within Leviticus 16 in hopes of learning more about the experience of suffering in the post-exilic community as well as the theology of the Priestly contributor.
|
The Flood and the Blood: Meat-Eating in the Story of Noah
Program Unit: Meals in the HB/OT and Its World
Jonathan Parker, Berry College
Prior to the Flood, no animal life had yet been taken on behalf of humans, and yet after this event (which includes YHWH’s explicit permission to eat meat, Gen 9:3), animals very often take this sacrificial role in the HB/OT. What might a “food-reading” of this story illuminate about this pivotal moment in Israel’s worship, diet, and life with animals? In short, blood replaces flood as a means for cleansing the earth of its violence. Humans affect and participate in this (now on-going) cleansing by receiving the gift of bloodless meat-eating.
This paper will propose a final-form, food-reading of the narrative, which climaxes not in the “remembering of God” (Gen 8:1) nor his rainbow-promise not to flood the earth again (Gen 9:13) but in the smell of Noah’s sacrifice and the resulting promises of (a) perpetual agricultural life and (b) gift of meat without lifeblood (8:21-9:5). This reading has advantages in explaining (1) the purpose of the Flood’s relationship to earth and animals (not just humans), (2) the purpose of both numbers for the Ark’s animal life (i.e. the pairs and “seven pairs”), and (3) the purpose of the gift of bloodless meat-eating to all humanity (i.e. why given here and not at the start of Creation?). In the end, the Noah story maintains Israel’s categories of animal and ritual life while establishing all meat-eating (in Israel and the nations) as a kind of sacrifice, where the life of the animal is given for the life of the eater and the earth, and where YHWH watches and regards how the "lifeblood" is handled (viz. with minimal ritualization).
Reading the Noah story this way prompts important possibilities: We may discuss (a) further biblical links between Israel’s proper sacrificial system and the especial fruitfulness of the Land; or (b) further ethical applications such as the benefits of ritual slaughter (e.g. shechita) versus mechanical, non-ritual animal slaughter for environmental and public health reasons (i.e. counting the costs of “cheap meat”).
|
Genesis 49:13: Exploring the Disjuncture between Text and Tradition
Program Unit: Genesis
Julie Faith Parker, Andover Newton Theological School
The tribal sayings in the Testament of Jacob in Genesis 49 are rife with enigmas. One of these sayings describes Zebulun as dwelling by the sea (Genesis 49:13), although tradition locates this tribe inland (Joshua 19:10-14). This paper explores why Zebulun is presented as a nautical tribe by looking north to Ugarit, which had a maritime culture. Does Zebulun relate to the Ugaritic zbln in any way? This word appears in the Keret epic (KTU 1.14 – 1.16), which arguably reflects a historical overlap between Ugarit, Phoenicia, and Palestine. Is Zebulun linked to the more common Ugaritic word zbl meaning “prince”? I suggest that the only use of zbl as a verb in the Hebrew Bible (Genesis 30:23) provides a key clue. Drawing on Ugaritic and Akkadian cognates, this paper explores the shared connotations of this Semitic term to shed some light on this very puzzling verse in Genesis.
|
Click “Add to Dictionary”: Why We Need to Speak of Childist Interpretation
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Julie Faith Parker, Andover Newton Theological School
Studies of children in the biblical world are proliferating at an unprecedented rate, but language around these studies remains unclear. Some scholars speak of reading the text through the lens of “the child.” Others refer to “child-centered exploration of texts,” “child-centered biblical hermeneutics,” a “childish” reading, or a focus on those who are “not-yet-adults.” Drawing on linguistic theory (especially the work of Edward Sapir, Michael Halliday, and Ferdinand Saussure), this paper explains the need for common language to create a shared understanding of the new task at hand. I explore the history of the terms “childist” and “childism” and note the conflicting ways in which they are used. Is it workable to speak of childism as a negative prejudice (like racism) and childist as a positive lens (like feminist)? This paper offers a clear set of expectations for the term “childist.” I further explain why this term is critical to the task of scholars in the field, and urge its adoption.
|
Saved by the Book: Exploring the Christian Bible as Effective and Affective Object
Program Unit: Society for Comparative Research on Iconic and Performative Texts
Dorina Miller Parmenter, Spalding University
The Christian Bible is not only a vehicle for scriptural text and practices of reading that text, but also a powerful religious object. This presentation will examine several examples where Christians view the physical forms of their Bibles as effective miracle-working objects and vehicles for grace, and will situate those interpretations within the history of the material uses of the Bible and Christians’ perceptions of how divine power works within the material world. It will also begin to explore how “affect theory” might contribute to analyses of the Bible as a material object embedded within networks of social meaning and power.
|
The Text of Isaiah in the Damascus Document
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Donald W. Parry, Brigham Young University
This paper will examine the quotations and allusions of the Former Prophets in the Damascus Document (CD), taking into account all Qumran manuscripts of Joshua, Judges, Samuel, and Kings as well as all extant Qumran manuscripts of CD (i.e., 4Q266–273; 5Q12, and 6Q15). After examining each quotation/allusion, I will seek to determine the relative text-critical value of the same and then attempt to categorize which texts are employed in the scriptural quotations and allusions (e.g., proto/semi-Masoretic Text, pre-Samaritan Penteteuch, LXX, non-aligned, etc.).
|
Plato, the Hebrew Bible, and the Goodness of the Body
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Philosophy
Robin Parry, Wipf and Stock Publishers
It is a commonplace amongst theologians and biblical scholars that the Hebrew Bible has a very positive view of the material world in general and human embodiment in particular. This is often contrasted with the alleged proto-gnostic approach of Plato, with its supposed denigration of particularity and materiality. Bodies, on this interpretation of Plato, do not fare well. Instead, all that really matters about human beings is the immaterial soul. This common view is often accompanied by laments over Christian theology’s Platonic captivity and by calls for its liberation by means of a return to the earthy teachings of the Hebrew Bible.
This paper argues for a different interpretation of Plato and for a constructive dialogue between the Hebrew Bible’s teachings on embodiment and Plato’s philosophy in the contemporary task of constructive theology. It is argued that the Hebrew Bible can provide a fruitful corrective to some of Plato’s emphases but that Plato’s philosophy can provide a beneficial metaphysical underpinning for the Hebrew Bible’s own positive valuation of the body. While Plato was not saying the same things as the biblical authors perhaps both he and they could be hired to play for the same team.
|
Melody of a Hymn Psalm in Theophilus’ Apology
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Stuart E. Parsons, Trinity College of Florida
Psalm 32 resonates throughout Theophilus of Antioch's little argument in his first letter on behalf of the reality of God based on the testimony of creation. This psalm shapes the argument’s structure and its artistic details. But to grasp this, we must step back into the largely-oral culture of ancient Antioch. We must take more seriously dynamics of accessing Scripture from memory rather than by reading it.
Even as patristic scholarship adopts more historically-informed categories of Scripture usage, it is becoming less satisfied with merely categorizing patristic usages of Scripture and more interested in knowing in detail how particular biblical passages function in patristic writings. We can often understand the function of Scripture in antiquity by thinking about its largely oral culture. This approach parallels a similar one in NT studies, as evidenced in the work of Richard B. Hays with literary echo. At the same time, James D. G. Dunn and others are helping NT scholars look behind the prejudices of our modern, highly-literate culture to see more clearly how gospels formed in the largely-oral culture of the first century. Patristics scholarship benefits by noticing these insights arising in the NT studies guild.
We can see just how influential Psalm 32 was for Theophilus only if we look beyond the mere single quotation and two partial quotations of the psalm listed in our biblical indexes of Ad Autolycum, and consider also the numerous literary echoes of this psalm, echoes which resounded clearly for the largely-oral, ancient church of Antioch.
We must both recognize and reject the modern prejudice of our own highly literate world of assuming that in the absence of a written biblical text, not much is going on.
|
Reclaiming the Divine Feminine: Re-reception of the Holy Spirit in the Divine Economy
Program Unit: Development of Early Christian Theology
Paul M. Pasquesi, Marquette University
This paper uses cognitive linguistics to look at how early Syriac-speaking Christianity conceived of the Holy Spirit as feminine in liturgy, ritual, and prayers, how that translated into ecclesiastical roles for women, and how modern Christians could reclaim that heritage via "re-reception" in modern liturgy, ritual, and Church life. The bulk of the paper focuses on how the Syriac tradition (as well as Irenaeus) connect Spirit with Wisdom, and Son with Logos, rather than the tradition of the Apologists like Justin and Origen, where Logos and Wisdom are connected and became the dominant (masculine) paradigm. The Wisdom-Spirit paradigm is distinctive for emphasizing the role of the Holy Spirit in each aspect of the divine economy, from creation and salvation history to the incarnation, empowering, and resurrection of the Son, to the continued life of the Church, most especially in Baptism, the Eucharist, and mystical askesis.
|
Magical Miracles and Miraculous Magic: Discourse of the Supernatural in the Acts of Peter
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Shaily Shashikant Patel, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
Most scholars of ancient Christian magic characterize the distinction between magic and miracle as a rhetorical construct crafted in response to insider/outsider religious dynamics. Miracle and magic differ only in their respective contexts: miracle belongs to the realm of approved religious praxis while magic transgresses socio-religious norms. While many of these studies attend to the “constructedness” of magic in broad terms, few provide a sustained examination of such discourse in any singular text. This paper contributes to the study of magic in the Christian Apocrypha by attending to the discursive differentiation of magic and miracle in the Acts of Peter. By comparing Peter’s wonderworking activities with material from the Greek Magical Papyri, the present study demonstrates how the miracle tradition in the Acta Petri conforms closely to practices associated with ancient magic. Having established the “practical” similarity between miracle and magic in the text, the paper then articulates the discursive contours of each. In the Acts of Peter, magic is rhetorically distinguished from miracle along a number of indices, including the agency by which it operates, its overall efficacy, and finally, its larger effect. This discourse analysis will yield the conclusion that the figure of Simon Magus in the Acts of Peter is a one-dimensional literary foil designed to foreground the distinctions between magic and miracle, and simultaneously, between true and false apostolic authority.
|
The Ethics of Biblical Law
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Dale Patrick, Drake University
Abstract of The Ethics of Biblical Law
Law should be a primary locus for the study of the ethics of the Hebrew Bible. Law prescribes and proscribes actions based upon implicit or explicit ethical values and concepts. The aim of this paper is not to construct a system of ethics for Biblical law, but a reading strategy for drawing out the embedded ethics.
The legal texts which I am interested in are the legal corpora in Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers and Deuteronomy. These are imposed upon Israel as a part of the covenant between YHWH and Israel. How does this law differ from the law in force among the nations? How does its rationale stand out?
The first corpus we meet in Exodus is the decalog. What is its relationship to the other corpora? Is the series entirely deontological or does it have teleological justifications? Can we discern a scheme of human rights embedded in the prohibitions?
What sort of ethical values and concepts can be discovered in the “judgments” of Exodus 21-22? I think we find a scheme based on the rights of victims: a person should not suffer los for the action of another. If the harm was intentional, there is a penalty assessed the guilty. If the harm is against the person, the perpetrator is vulnerable in his or her person.
Other provisions of the Book of the Covenant impose protect the vulnerable and require acts of welfare of the well-to-do. The provisions are supported by rhetorical appeal to the goodwill and fear of the addressees.
These explorations should be enough to set forth a reading strategy for uncovering the ethics of the provisions of all Biblical corpora.
Dale Patrick
Drake University, Prof. emeritus
|
The Modern “Face” of Scripture: Practical Theology through Social Media
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Wendy L. Patrick, Bethel Seminary (San Diego, CA)
In our technologically-advanced society, the world is literally at our fingertips – accessible by the tap of our finger on a computer screen. Never without our Iphones, we buzz and beep our way through the day as walking “hot spots” – always connected to the global marketplace of information.
Within this virtual world of competing voices and ideas promoted through articles, blog posts, and disembodied avatars, we also find the Bible. Long touted as the world’s best selling book, in cyberspace, it is free. Not only is it free, but through the efforts of technologically-savvy evangelists, regardless of where on the globe you live, it is coming soon in every format and language imaginable to a computer near you. This paper will explore a variety of different ways in which practical theology is accomplished through social media.
As a prosecutor, having spent my career in law enforcement, I investigate and cyber-sleuth on a daily basis (I am a deputy district attorney in the Sex Crimes and Human Trafficking Division of the San Diego District Attorney’s Office). In ministry, I spend a significant amount of time online exploring and researching methods of virtual Christian outreach. This paper will incorporate my personal experience with and knowledge of a variety of online social media tools, as well as a review of relevant scholarship, into the discussion of the modern relationship between the Bible, and engaging in practical theology within social media-savvy contemporary society.
|
Ostriches and Others: Disability in the Book of Job
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Kirk Patston, Sydney Missionary and Bible College
The study of otherness opens a way to read the book of Job in a way that reveals issues of relevance to disability. This paper interacts with theorists such as Kierkegaard, Buber, Barth, Bakhtin and Levinas; contemporary studies of Job by Clines, Newsom and Walton; and develops the disability readings of Job offered by Raphael and Claassens. It explores the way that divine and human relationships involve the self being over, under, against or with the other. These dynamics are highly relevant to the lived experience of disability. The prologue of Job presents a riddling portrait of otherness, including an ambiguous treatment of how God and the satan deal with each other (Job 1–2). The book then traces the way Job wrestles most creatively with divine and human others who appear to be over and against him (Job 3–26). Job longs to be with his friends and with his God. In Job 27–37 there is a revision of otherness and Job resorts to a moral vision of honour and shame that effectively objectifies the other. These chapters include some telling portrayals of disability. The divine speeches and the epilogue offer a reconfiguring of otherness (Job 38–42). There is a vision of otherness that values variety, agency, monsters, laughter, forgiveness, friendship and beauty. It pictures a world of actions for no reason. This sophisticated vision of otherness opens up valuable ways of imagining divine and human relationships that are relevant to the human experience of disability.
|
What Did John Teach Jesus?
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Stephen J. Patterson, Willamette University
If Jesus was originally a follower of John the Baptist, what the Baptist taught ought to be directly relevant to the question of what Jesus himself eventually taught. In this paper I will draw on a number of sources to reconstruct various aspects of John’s teaching. Then I will ask whether these features of John the Baptist’s teaching turn up later in the teaching of Jesus and the traditions of the Jesus movement. I will show that a Jesus movement rooted in the baptismal sects of the Jordan valley might have been much more complex and strange than we have heretofore imagined.
|
Who Are the Alloi in Jn 4:38? A Critical Review
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Priya Paul, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
One of the central points in the exegetical study of John 4:31-38 is the theme of sending and a key problem within this text is Jesus’ reference in v. 38, to the alloi who are sent to Samaria before the disciples. Though scholars have had much debate on this pertinent question, the inconsistencies evident in comprehending this dialogue of Jesus (4:31-38) in connection with the whole Samaritan episode necessitate sustained research and analysis of the meaning of alloi in this verse. For example, there is the very abrupt shift of focus in v. 38 that makes it isolated from and unconnected to the immediate context of the Samaritan episode or to a broader context of the life and mission of the Johannine Jesus. Alternatively, one is puzzled by the unmotivated change from the singular of allos in v. 37 to the plural alloi in v. 38 that affects the flow of the text both in terms of its grammar and its logic. Concerning this issue, nine different proposals are made in scholarship on the identity of the alloi. In this paper, a critical examination of the scholarship that developed over the last century on this theme is discussed and four main positions on the identification of alloi are presented: (i) people who preceded Jesus and the disciples, (ii) those who worked in Samaria in the immediate context of the Samaritan episode, (iii) during the post-resurrection period including the mission of the apostles and their successors and (iv) a perspective beyond time in a framework of eternity. An examination of these positions, reviewing the previous research from a critical stand point will demonstrate their strengths and weaknesses.
|
Is There a Trito-Isaiah?
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Shalom Paul, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
This paper will interrogate the arguments for separating the last eleven chapters of Isaiah from the preceding sixteen chapters.
|
From Exile to Executive? Social Integration and Mobility in the al-Yahudu Texts
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Laurie E. Pearce, University of California-Berkeley
New texts from al-Yahudu and environs (CUSAS 28; BaAr 6: both forthcoming) not only confirm the presence of a community of Judean exiles on the rural southern Mesopotamian landscape from Nebuchadnezzar 33 (572 BCE) until Xerxes 9 (477 BCE), they also document their immediate and on-going integration into the social and economic fabric of Mesopotamian life. Evidence of administrative titles Judeans held, of the organization of the economic institutions in which they participated, and the role a Judean agricultural community on the rural landscape played in the evolution of the land-for-service institutions that were the hallmark of Neo-Babylonian and Achaemenid economic policy makes it possible to suggest ways in which Judeans participated in and were integrated into Mesopotamian social structures. This perspective may open the door for more nuanced explorations, not only of the exilic experience, but of the forces that shaped the social and economic expectations and standing of the Judeans who returned to Judah.
The new evidence tempers the “top-down” view of Judean life in Babylonia elicited from a handful of references to the economic conditions of the Judeans in exile (e.g. Jer 29:5-6; Ezek 1:1), the names and titles of Babylonian imperial officials (including the recent identification of Nebuchadnezzar’s rab ša-reši, Nabû-šarrussu-ukin, in a document from the Ebabbar Archive [BM 114789; M. Jursa, NABU 2008-05]), and, exceptionally, the occasional Judean in high office (Neh). Explicit evidence of Judeans holding bow-lands, assuming administrative roles (e.g., dekû, “tax collector”) in the land-for-service economic, accumulating capital and goods, and conducting business in both rural and urban environments contextualizes the Judeans in socio-economic terms, and establishes a framework in which the experiences of and relationships between the Judean communities of returnees and those who remained in Babylonia may be further explored.
|
"Excellent and Profitable for Life": Philo on the Decalogue
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Sarah Judith Pearce, University of Southampton
This paper will offer some reflections on writing a new translation and commentary on Philo’s De Decalogo, itself the earliest known commentary on the Ten Commandments. Special attention will be given to Philo’s effort to elucidate the reasons for the commandments, and their benefits to the human soul and human society, with particular focus on the Fifth Commandment, situated, as Philo sees it, ‘on the borderline’ between the two sets of five commandments.
|
Pedagogical Performances: Fluid and Shifting Recognition and Embodied Knowledge Creation in the Classroom
Program Unit: Bible and Cultural Studies
Heike Peckruhn, University of Denver
This paper engages questions of decolonizing pedagogies and multiple identities in classrooms twofold: A theoretical conceptualization of identity as fluid performance that depends on shifting recognition; an analysis of embodied performative teaching strategies that emphasize decolonizing knowledge formation. Race, gender, and sexual orientation appear in the classroom attached to bodies of teachers and students. Queer and Critical Race theories inform us that socialization into certain social locations—and therefore into certain embodied performances—is a significant factor in this appearance. I argue that identity markers such as race, gender, and sexual orientation are recognized performances influenced by classroom context and dynamic. Thus, bodies in the classroom may be perceived incongruent or even in contradiction with one’s self-identification or physical features, and perceptions may change with classroom dynamics or other factors. Embodied teaching strategies are one tool allowing for these kinds of performances to emerge as material for classroom analysis.
|
Priestly Influence in the Early Development of Fixed Daily Prayer
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
Jeremy Penner, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
Mishnah Tamid 5.1 is usually marshalled as confirmation that the general practice of fixed daily prayer originated within the daily priestly service of the Jerusalem temple prior to its destruction in 70 CE. While this passage is obviously much later, scholars argue that a number of excerpted texts from Second Temple times such as, e.g., the Nash Papyrus, indeed verify the antiquity of Mishnah Tamid’s assertions. This paper will 1) re-assess the evidence presented when defending the historical veracity of m. Tamid 5.1, 2) problematize the hypothesis that the fixed daily prayer originated as a priestly practice within the sacrificial service, and 3) present a more nuanced model of the development of fixed daily prayer and priestly involvement in the establishment of this practice.
|
"What Flows from the Breast Is Milk, and Milk Is the Food of Babes": Infancy and Maternity in Gregory of Nyssa's Homilies on the Song of Songs
Program Unit: Gender, Sexuality, and the Bible
John Penniman, Fordham University
Drawing upon Michel Foucault’s discussion of pastoral power as “the power of care”—that is, as a power in which salvation is “first of all essentially subsistence”—this paper explores one early Christian discussion of pastoral care as a kind of salvific and transformative feeding of infants: Gregory of Nyssa’s Homilies on the Song of Songs. In order to neutralize (or, in his words, purify) the highly erotic content of the Song of Songs, Gregory’s interpretation muddles the sexually-differentiated bodies of the bride and the bridegroom and presents them instead as the malleable raw material of a program for Christian formation—a program in which the relationship between bride and bridegroom is reconfigured first and foremost as that of an infant at its mother’s breast. Gregory’s exegesis hinges upon Song of Songs 1:2 in which the bride paradoxically praises the “breasts” of the bridegroom for being “better than wine.” In this, Gregory perceives an allusion to the pastoral milk described by the Apostle Paul in 1 Corinthians 3. For Gregory, only if the bride is understood as a child in need of its mother’s milk can we fully grasp the deeper message of the Song, participate in its pedagogical program, all the while avoiding the titillating words on the surface of the text. Yet the bride’s body remains fundamentally unstable throughout the Homilies: first taking the shape of a specifically male infant, then becoming a sheep in the flock of the shepherd, and finally reaching her ultimate form when the bridegroom “enhances” her appearance when she is “adorned with the fountains of good doctrine signified by her breasts.” This final transformation is instigated when the bridegroom reciprocates the praise first offered to him by the bride: “Your breasts are better than wine” (Song of Songs 4:10). With the bridegroom’s astonishment at his bride’s form, the erotic seems to have slipped back into Gregory’s interpretation at the precise moment when the once-infantile bride becomes a maternal figure capable of nourishing others just as the bridegroom had once nourished her. Thus, the figure of the bride in Gregory’s Homilies becomes a particularly evocative example of the symbolic power of infancy in the early Christian imagination. The power of feeding and being fed functions here as a mechanism for safeguarding the “children” of the Christian community and for ensuring their proper growth into motherhood. The symbolic power of childhood in Gregory’s Homilies resonates with Foucault’s discussion of pastoral care. It also reflects Roman imperial-era values concerning the formative power of maternal milk and the necessity of protecting children from “bad wet-nurses.” The bride’s transformation from infant to mother thus serves as the means by which Gregory measures the growth, maturity, and legitimacy of Christians and offers a striking example of how the Pauline notion of “infants in Christ” came to function in late antiquity.
|
Mosaics from a Fifth-Century Syrian Church
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Michael Peppard, Fordham University
In late 2013 Fordham University (New York) acquired through donation a group of nine mosaics from the heir of a private collector. Under the curatorship of Jennifer Udell and the directorship of Gregory Waldrop, the mosaics are to be installed in the Fordham Museum of Greek, Etruscan and Roman Art. On this panel, I will explain the provenance work that I did during the summer and fall of 2013 on behalf of our museum, prior to acceptance of the donation, which led to more detailed understanding of the ancient and modern histories of these mosaics. To the extent permitted by my university’s legal counsel, I will summarize the legal due diligence performed by our lawyers, through independent expert counsel, and my own correspondence with senior colleagues abroad. Finally, I will describe lessons learned about the publicization of new acquisitions and the interacting roles of “new” and “old” media in the process.
|
The Greek Translator’s Portrayal of Aaron in Exodus 32 and Other Relevant Contexts
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Larry Perkins, Trinity Western University
In various ways the translation of the Golden Calf narrative (Exodus 32) differs from MT. Some of these alternations may be attributable to the translator’s Hebrew Vorlage, but others more probably arise from the translator’s perspective. Within the Greek translation Aaron carries more responsibility for Israel’s transgression. In this paper I document the various strategies used by the translator to express Aaron’s profile in Ex 32. Dozeman in his commentary on the Hebrew text affirms that Aaron is not a heroic figure in this chapter, but neither is he a villain. Does the Septuagint version of this story support this evaluation? If as proposed by Findlay the translator of Numbers 16-17 “exhibits a distinctly pro-Aaronide ideology,” does the Exodus translator in chapter 32 display the same tendency? I propose that characterization may be another means by which to evaluate the translator’s approach to his task. I conclude with some observations that might point to the translator’s motivation for his characterization of Aaron.
|
Sin and Otherness in the Johannine Epistles
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Pheme Perkins, Boston College
An investigation of the rhetorical use of hamartia in 1 John shows significant divergence between the epistles and Gospel of John in their use of a shared symbolic language. A comparison of the treatment of sin and otherness in the Johannine literature as well as related apocalyptic and gnostic examples suggests varied approaches to normalizing Christian identity at the end of the 1st and early 2nd cent. It confirms the view that the epistles are independent of the gospel as we know it.
|
The Dreamer’s Historiography: Visionary Outlooks on the Course and Configuration of History in the Aramaic Texts from the Judaean Desert
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Andrew B. Perrin, Trinity Western University
Vaticinium ex eventu dream-visions that dovetail the past, present, and future into a coherent, unfolding series of events permeate the Aramaic Dead Sea Scrolls. This trait rests on a simple epistemological presupposition: there is an expansive divine plan for human history, from start to finish. What is needed is a means of accessing that plan. Through special revelation, knowledge of the course and configuration of history is attainable. In relating this privileged information, then, authors engage in a type of mantic historiography that explains the passage of time and provides models for anticipation of the future. Through symbolic and dramatic depictions, the authors of the Aramaic texts selectively order and evaluate aspects of the world’s timeline from the antediluvian days to the eschatological culmination of history. This paper charts a course through the some nineteen dream-vision texts among the Aramaic Dead Sea Scrolls corpus and picks up on permutations of this historiographical mechanism in 1 Enoch, the Book of Giants, the Genesis Apocryphon, 4QFour Kingdoms, 4QAramaic Apocalypse, and the New Jerusalem text.
|
Relevance Theory in the Performance of Revelation 17–19
Program Unit: Bible Translation
Peter Perry, Lutheran School of Theology at Chicago
Relevance Theory (RT) is a cognitive theory of communication that provides a framework for understanding how people decide what is more or less relevant in a given context. Translation, broadly conceived from a RT perspective, is a communication event in which a speaker/writer attempts to maximize the replication of the cognitive effects of a prior communication event while minimizing the processing effort by new hearer(s) in a different language. Performance is translation in that it shares the goal of replication of cognitive effects; but while translators may desire verisimilitude above other goals, performers may have differently prioritized communicative objectives. Neither translation nor performance can exactly replicate the contextual effects of a prior communication event; both are new events in new cognitive environments. Or, in other words, both are interpretations.
Performance of a text provides Biblical translators an opportunity to explore the effectiveness of verbal and non-verbal cues (e.g. gestures, tone, visual formatting) to maximize cognitive effects and minimize processing effort for a specific audience. The performance of Revelation 17-19 offers a unique window into the cognitive effects of ambiguity and delayed processing, emotion and tone, space and distance that guide word choice, syntax and visual formatting of a written translation. The non-verbal cues of performance (gestures, tone, and movement) correlate to the visual cues of a text (font style, size, formatting) in maximizing desired cognitive effects while minimizing processing effort.
|
Canonical Apocrypha
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Richard I. Pervo, Saint Paul, Minnesota
This paper proposes to address the canonical/apocryphal discussion through passages in the generally sober and didactic Gospel of Matthew that exhibit features typically labeled “apocryphal.” These range from the sublime (2:1-12) to the embarrassing (27:62-66; 28:11-15; others include 2:13-15, 19-23; 2:16-18; 14:28-32; 17:24-27; 27:52-53).
The general narrative trend in Early Christian Literature was to view gospels as biographies and fill in gaps. This process begins with Matthew and Luke. Gap-filling and amplification do not result from any “apocryphal” impulses. Apologetic narrative that makes Jews or other opponents into crude villains is typically, but not exclusively, apocryphal. Luke and Acts supply examples. Use of symbolic narrative is also an apocryphal characteristic with roots in the canonical tradition. In the case of Matthew these features of popular narrative may be intended to appeal to the “little ones.” None of these features is inherently “heretical” or “deviant.” In apocryphal narratives they may predominate.
|
An Odd Couple: Apuleius' Metamorphoses and the Acts of Thomas
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Richard I. Pervo, Saint Paul, Minnesota
Few works seem at first sight less parallel than Apuleius’ Latin novel and the Syrian story of Judas Thomas. Each is a religious novel (although the sincerity of the Metamorphoses is disputed), but one elevates The Egyptian gods toward the apex of a polytheist pantheon while the other is distinctly (if not orthodoxly) Christian. Behind the Metamorphoses evidently stands a comic novel; AThom is heir to gospels and Acts. Yet: both have an apparently picaresque structure that is actually more complicated. Both have an inserted fairy-tale that transpires as an interpretive key. Both are dualistic and contrast beastly bodies to pure souls. Is there more? Tune in, listener, for some more surprises.
|
The Christology of the Phoenix in 1 Clement
Program Unit: Texts and Traditions in the Second Century
Janelle Peters, Emory University
In his discussion of the phoenix, Clement assures us that this Christological sign happens while all are watching, though the witnesses are all those who live in eastern climes, that is, Arabia. His credulity is in sharp contrast with the first extensive discussion of the phoenix in Greco-Roman literature, which allows Herodotus to doubt the testimony of the Egyptians. This is perhaps a function of the possible occurrence of a phoenix in LXX Job 29:18. The belief that the phoenix belonged in Scripture may also be found in Tertullian’s attempt to read the word “date-palm” with the homonym “phoenix” (f?????) in LXX Ps 91:13. However, Clement’s description of the phoenix is still more Herodotean than Roman in that it emphasizes the foreignness of the event. Roman authors such as Manilius and Claudian had already subsumed the phoenix into authentically Roman experience. Clement and the church of Rome thus want the church of Corinth to believe the witness of foreigners, even those associated with a foreign temple. The lengthy description of the phoenix’s life cycle suggests that Clement does not want the reader to simply take the phoenix as a pagan symbol whose mere presence could signify resurrection, as found in the art of the catacombs. Clement’s interest is clearly on the visibility and discernible nature of this sign, which is available to even the gentiles on purely naturalistic terms. In his choice between competing accounts of the phoenix’s genesis, Clement chooses the tradition that explicitly states that the phoenix is born from a worm emerging from the elder phoenix’s corpse. In fact, he aggrandizes this tradition much in the same manner as 3 Baruch. The worm underscores that the outsiders acknowledge a paradoxical sign?a lowly creature resurrected and exalted?just as Christians do. Christological logic is good Roman logic.
|
Permanent and Temporary Ethnicity in the Esther Scroll
Program Unit: Megilloth
Janelle Peters, Lake Superior State University
This paper will argue non-Jewish ethnicity is a construct and Jewish ethnicity a permanent identity in the Esther scroll. In a book of reversals, Esther throws Persian national identity into jeopardy by her participation in the king’s court. When Esther enters the harem, she, along with all the other virgins who have been selected on the basis of their beauty, undergo a beauty ritual “with cosmetic burner” (2:12). She does not risk her life to maintain ostentatious kashrut observance like Daniel or Judith. This is a reassurance of the possibility of renewal of national commitments in those who appear to have abandoned Jewish customs. Appearances, as Mordecai’s rejection of the salve of new clothes indicates, deceive. Esther’s selection as queen completes the loosening of Persian national identity begun with the international furor over Vashti’s refusal to appear at Ahasuerus’ party. According to Herodotus, the Achaemenid kings chose their queens from among the seven families who had helped Darius defeat Pseudo-Smerdis and assume the Persian throne. Esther’s genealogy proves that, though she may descend from Jewish royalty, she does not derive from Persian stock, let alone Persian elite. Despite Persian expansionary policies that led to campaigns against Greece, Ahasuerus offers Esther hyperbolic permission to administer to half the Empire. The marriage of Esther results in a wholesale remission of tribute remission that Haman unsuccessfully attempts to correct in the particular case of his own ethnicity. That Persian national identity may be unmoored finds confirmation in the inability of Ahasuerus to reverse his edict authorizing the genocide of the Jews on the 13th of Adar. Esther is naturally Jewish and artificially Persian. As with the Greek gymnastic educational system, being Persian is no permanent identity. Haman, meanwhile, is the prophet of Jewish particularity.
|
The Early Christ-Movement from a Cultural Evolutionary Perspective
Program Unit: Redescribing Christian Origins
Anders Klostergaard Petersen, University of Aarhus
Recent years have witnessed a revival of cultural evolutionary perspectives of different types among which the most famous one is perhaps the stage theory espoused by the late Robert Bellah. Contrary to previous forms of cultural evolution which had their heyday form 1840 to 1920 (with a hideous political aftermath in the late 1930.s and early 1940.s), recent ones are characterised by a close reliance on current cognitive science. Additionally, exponents of this type of thinking are also keen to point out that the discussion of evolutionary questions have a bearing with respect to the aesthetic domain only (i.e. cultural and social complexity). They do not pertain to the spheres of truth and ethics. In this manner, some of the ideologically problematical aspects of previous types of evolutionary thinking are conceived to have been decisively abandoned. In the present paper I shall take a look at the early Christ-movement and discuss to what extent we may benefit from cultural evolutionary perspectives in explaining not only the emergence of this religious current but also its persistence in terms of longevity. I shall have recourse to a variety of theories pertaining to cultural evolutionary matters such as, for instance, the ones advocated by Merlin Donald and by Alexandra Maryanski and Jonathan Turner.
|
Saving Kinship: Clement of Alexandria and Reproduction
Program Unit: Inventing Christianity: Apostolic Fathers, Apologists, and Martyrs
Taylor G. Petrey, Kalamazoo College
This paper examines the landscape of early Christian debates about the body, sexuality, reproduction, and gender in Clement of Alexandria. Clement has occupied an important place in the study of ancient discourses of kinship, ideologies of sexuality, and gender. In part, his value lies in his preservation of so many different voices in his own writings, revealing the diversity of early Christian thought on these contentious issues. Why exactly was Clement interested in preserving the family relationship, against encratite and other rival who imagined new utopias? This paper considers how Clement has been written into the history of sexuality, and suggests that a history of kinship beyond metaphor is necessary to properly understand the context of Clement’s writing.
|
The Dream of Hebrew FrameNet: Biblical Hebrew xalam
Program Unit: Global Education and Research Technology
Miriam R. L. Petruck, International Computer Science Institute, Berkeley
Founded by Charles J. Fillmore, the FrameNet project (framenet.icsi.berkeley.edu) has been building a unique knowledge base that maps meaning to form through the theory of Frame Semantics (Fillmore 1975, 1985, etc.). FrameNet (Ruppenhofer et al. 2010), a corpus-based computational lexicography endeavor, is the most sophisticated instantiation of Frame Semantics, at the heart of which is the semantic frame, i.e. a schematic representation of an event, situation, state of affairs or object, which facilitates inferences about participants and objects in and across situations and events. Documenting its findings with corpus evidence, the project’s goal is to provide a body of semantically and syntactically annotated sentences from which reliable information can be reported on the valence descriptions, i.e. semantico-syntactic combinatorial possibilities of each item analyzed. Since its establishment in 1997, FrameNet has inspired the development of analogous resources in many languages, including Japanese (Ohara et al. 2004), Spanish (Subirats 2009), German (Bourchardt et al. 2009), Chinese (You et al. 2007), Brazilian Portuguese (Salomão 2009), and Swedish (Borin et al. 2010), some well-established projects, with new efforts underway for French (frenchframenet) and Korean (Park et al. ms.), as well as plans laid for Slovenian (Lönneker-Rodman et al. 2008) and Modern Hebrew (Petruck 2009). The current work proposes developing Biblical Hebrew FrameNet (BHFN) with the same conceptual and computational apparatus that the original FrameNet used (Fillmore and Baker 2010), and illustrates the basic building blocks of the project, i.e. frames, frame elements, lexical units, with the Biblical Hebrew verb xalam – ‘dream’ and its nominal counterpart xalom – ‘dream’ as in vayaxalom yosef xalom (and-he-dreams Joseph dream) – ‘And Joseph dreamed a dream’. The presentation also highlights the benefits of developing BHFN, from the perspective of linguistic semantic analysis and language pedagogy, as well as that of Biblical Hebrew studies more generally.
|
Polylogia in Matt 6:7 within the Framework of Graeco-Roman and Jewish Discussions on Verbosity
Program Unit: Speech and Talk in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Daniele Pevarello, Trinity College Dublin
The Gospel of Matthew introduces the Lord’s Prayer with the invitation not to “heap up empty phrases as the Gentiles do” (Matt 6.7) and avoid pagan verbosity (Gr. polylogia). Referring to evidence of lengthy recitations of divine names in pagan ceremonials and the use of glossolalia in spells from Graeco-Roman magical papyri, commentators have understood these verses in the light of Jewish and Christian criticism of pagan rituals. Pagan texts from the ancient Mediterranean, however, contain numerous instances of analogous warnings against verbosity. In these sources, talkativeness is portrayed as a sign of intellectual and moral depravity. Drawing on evidence from Hellenistic moral philosophy, in particular Pythagorean and Platonic sources and popular morality, but also from Second Temple Judaism, this paper interprets the reference to verbosity in Matt 6.7 within the framework of ancient Mediterranean ideas of brevity as a mark of wisdom and moral excellence. It will be shown that the othering of the Gentiles as verbose in Matthew mimics similar arguments in contemporary Graeco-Roman debates. Finally, the paper will also consider the reception history of Matthew’s treatment of verbosity in patristic authors, showing how the connection between verbosity and vice on the one hand and brevity and virtue on the other later becomes central in discussions on authority, status and ministry in the early Church.
|
A Failure to Interpret the Signs: The Crowd's Ironic Appeal to Psalm 77 in John 6:31
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Zack Phillips, Duke University
In John 6:31, a crowd cites Scripture to justify their demand for a sign from Jesus: "Our fathers ate manna in the wilderness, just as it is written, 'He gave them bread from heaven to eat.'" Scholarly discussion has tended to focus on the particular form of the scriptural citation, and few studies have considered how the quotation functions within the larger context of John 6. This paper examines that function. It argues that John deploys not only Psalm 77:24 (in 6:31) but also the whole of Psalm 77 (in chapter 6) in order to dramatize the failure of Jesus' interlocutors to read his "signs" precisely because they cannot "read" their scriptures. By invoking a Psalm that indicts Israel’s failure to believe in God’s signs as evidenced by their demand for manna, these interlocutors ironically reenact their psalmic "fathers'" history of faithlessness.
The first part of the paper analyses the pertinent textual dynamics of the Psalm itself. Through a close-reading of the text, it seeks to demonstrate that, unlike the Exodus tradition, the Psalm foregrounds the people's sinfulness more than God's graciousness. It highlights the way in which the entire psalm is framed as a "parable" in which what is to be "understood" from the recital of Israel’s history — and, particularly, from the manna incident — is Israel’s failure to remember God's "marvels" so as to sustain their faith.
In the second part, the paper examines the extensive verbal echoes to the Psalm in John 6. By means of these echoes, John maps the faithlessness of Jesus' interlocutors onto that of the psalmic "fathers." Indeed, by having the interlocutors themselves invoke the Psalm to justify their demand for manna, they betray their misreading of the Psalm. By doing so, they inscribe themselves into its history of faithlessness in the face of God's "marvels." Chapter 6, then, clarifies and brings to climax the drama that unfolds in chapters 1-5. It is because they cannot read the "signs" that are Israel’s scriptures (appropriated by Jesus) that "the Jews" cannot read the "signs" that Jesus performs.
|
"Resurrection, Kingship, and Decrees of the Emperor": Recipe for an Inevitable Thessalonian Collision
Program Unit: Formation of Luke and Acts
Edward Pillar, University of Wales, Trinity Saint David
When Paul visited Thessalonica (Acts 17) he carefully argued and stressed over a period of several weeks, the necessity of the resurrection of Jesus from the dead. While the initial response was the encouraging persuasion of some who joined Paul and Silas, there were others who violently accused the apostles of ‘acting contrary to the decrees of the emperor and announcing another king named Jesus.’ All this is perfectly clear from the text, and 1 Thessalonians 1:9-10 has often also been used to help in the analysis and possible identification of the ‘decrees of the emperor’ that the apostles have been acting against. However, in this paper we shall discuss the proposal that 1 Thess. 1:9-10 provides evidence that it is precisely Paul’s stress on the necessity of the resurrection that itself gives rise to a belief in ‘another king named Jesus.’ This is where Acts 17 may possibly be said to lean on the text of 1Thessalonians 1 for the vital coupling of resurrection and kingship which necessarily leads to the ‘acts contrary to the decrees of the emperor’ and to some measure usurps and negates his power.
|
Materiality and the Entanglement of Memory: Observations on David in Ziklag
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Daniel Pioske, Georgia Southern University
This paper seeks to contribute to the ongoing discussion surrounding the relationship between cultural memory and the biblical narrative by exploring those biblical texts that locate David in the city of Ziklag during his early career as outlaw and Philistine vassal (1 Sam 27 - 31). In response to a number of studies that connect the list of locations that receive booty from David’s retaliatory attack on the Amalekites (1 Sam 30) to an 8th-7th century BCE setting, this paper considers the site of Ziklag itself (Tell esh-Shari’ah/Tel Sera‘) and its Iron Age remains. The argument of this paper is twofold. First, this study contends that the biblical stories that attest to David’s activity in Ziklag resonate best with an Iron I-IIA archaeological context, and thus, much like the description of the Philistine city of Gath in Samuel, preserve references to an era that precedes the Iron IIB period. In light of the late Iron Age context for other Davidic tales within this collection of stories, however, the second argument of this paper is that the description of David’s life on the southern fringe of Judah demonstrates a form of “entangled” memory, or the interweaving of older and more recent cultural recollections within a certain ancient account. A leading cause of this entanglement, my argument will run, is the material presence (and absence) of places themselves when certain stories were recounted within a community. This paper then concludes with a reflection on some implications of this phenomenon for an understanding of ancient Hebrew scribal craft and the Iron Age past represented in the Hebrew Bible.
|
Shadowy (Nine) Saints: Moving beyond Medieval Hagiography and Positivistic Historiography
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Pierluigi Piovanelli, University of Ottawa
The figures of Zä-Mika'el Arägawi and his companions – the late fifth and early sixth-century ascetics from the Byzantine Empire who would have contributed to the "second evangelization" of Aksumite Ethiopia – have played a significant role in both memorial and historiographical discourses about the origins of Ethiopian Christianity. Identified initially as Dominican friars from Rome, it took a certain amount of time for Western historians to realize that Ethiopian sources depict them as contemporaries of King Kaleb and his second expedition against Himyar. Positivistic historiography saw them as Syrian refugees and Syriac-speaking missionaries, who were responsible for the introduction of monophysitism in Ethiopia and, eventually, the translation of the Holy Scriptures from Greek into Ge'ez. In recent years, however, various elements of such a reconstruction have been legitimately called into question. In our presentation, we would like, first, to introduce the new elements that emerge from a fresh and more exhaustive re-examination of the medieval and modern Lives of these shadowy saints, and, second, to recontextualize their presence and religious role, if any, in the world of late antique Aksum, in order to, third, propose a new working hypothesis about the historical origins and the development of Ethiopian monasticism and hagiographic literature.
|
The Use of Priestly Legal Tradition in Joshua
Program Unit: Joshua-Judges
Pekka Pitkänen, University of Gloucestershire
This presentation will look at how priestly legal materials can be seen to have been used in Joshua. This includes the allotment of towns of refuge, levitical towns, the concept of centralization of worship (Joshua 22:9-34) and the Passover. The argument will be that priestly material has been incorporated into a Deuteronomic framework and that Joshua can be seen at least in a sense to be a first document that explicitly combines Priestly and Deuteronomic legal materials and mediates between them. In this, Deuteronomic legal materials can be considered as encompassing priestly materials from an interpretative perspective, in line with the narrative order of Priestly and Deuteronomic materials in the Pentateuch. Relevant textual issues will also be taken into consideration, such as with the portrayal of the Passover in Joshua.
|
Is Luke's Gospel Bios or History? A Critique of Richard Burridge
Program Unit: Gospel of Luke
Andrew W. Pitts, McMaster Divinity College
Due largely to the pioneering work of Richard Burridge, the majority of scholars understand the Third Gospel, along with the other Synoptics and John, firmly within the Greco-Roman biographical tradition. Burridge makes an important contribution in gathering together many "detection" criteria and makes a fairly compelling case that the Gospels share several literary features in common with the Bios of the ancient world and other works in antiquity, but it remains inadequate for establishing whether Luke’s Gospel (or any writing in question) is Bios or history since "subjects of verbs" functions as Burridge's primary "disambiguation" criterion. After a sustained critique of subjects of verbs as a disambiguation criterion (especially it relates to distinguishing Bios from history), I put forward several new or previously underdeveloped criteria designed to disambiguate Bios from history. I argue that these features situate Luke comfortably among the Greek histories rather than the ancient Bios, as Burridge proposes.
|
Stylistics and the Pastorals: A Reconsideration of the Linguistic Arguments for Pseudonymity
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Andrew W. Pitts, McMaster Divinity College
A significant consensus among New Testament scholars recognizes some level of pseudonymity within the Pauline canon. Far and wide, most scholars of Paul at the very least view the Pastoral letters as deutero-Pauline. They typically base this evaluation on comparative linguistic data, but they almost always do so apart from serious linguistic methodology designed to interpret this data. In this paper, I show that the linguistic assumptions used to formulate criteria for pseudonymity in Paul are at best linguistically naïve. I attempt to draw attention to the implausibility of these criteria by testing them against several well-established linguistic diagnostics drawn from socio- and corpus linguistics. I then seek to develop a more stable methodological environment for interpreting stylistic dissimilarity within the Pauline corpus. I argue that when we calibrate the historical expectations created by the external evidence with sound methodology that linguistic variation in the Pauline corpus, especially the Pastorals, is more convincingly accounted for through register variation than author variation.
|
From Knowing to Unknowing: Apophatic Readings of Scripture in a Context of Hyper-Diversity
Program Unit: Anglican Association of Biblical Scholars
Vincent Pizzuto, University of San Francisco
*
|
The Place of the Spirit in Origen's Taxological Grammar of Participation
Program Unit: Development of Early Christian Theology
Kellen Plaxco, Marquette University
Terms related to “participation” (metoche, methexis, participatio), as well as the “image” metaphor based on Genesis 1-2 that exploits such terms, animate Origen’s theology and psychology at a deep level—almost always sensed if not always seen. The appropriation of participation as a philosophical concept is nearly as complicated, wide-ranging, and promising as Plato’s influence in late antiquity. I focus in this presentation on the function of participation in Origen’s model of the trinity in Commentary on John 1-2, and the implications of that model for Origen’s pneumatology. Concentration on this text discloses the decisive role of participation in Origen’s anti-modalistic polemical theology. My reading explains Origen’s use of participation in terms of the Stoic “cognitive impression” (phantasia kataleptikê) mediated by Philo. It also compares Origen’s ordering of the cosmos with gradation schemes in Cicero, Seneca, and Numenius. This comparison affords a glance at Origen’s exploitation of non-Christian schemes of gradation to go beyond them and develop his own version of a graded cosmos: God’s divinity is mediated through the Son, the chief participant, to all creatures, the chief of whom is the Holy Spirit. Origen developed this grammar of participation as an anti-monarchian trope because participation distinguishes the Son and Holy Spirit from the Father. However, Origen’s taxological grammar of participation generates a theological taxonomy. Origen holds that any participating entity is by definition distinct from and inferior in the relevant sense to that in which it participates. Origen’s use of participation in his Commentary on John is symbiotic with a taxological ordering (taxis) of the trinity. The symptoms of such ambiguities become especially evident in Origen’s low pneumatology.
This “taxological” account of participation in Origen’s Commentary on John helps to explain the ambiguities of ontological status apparent in Origen’s early theology of the trinity. As is well known, access to On First Principles is clouded by Rufinus’s corrections and the potential overstatements of Origen’s critics. With Origen’s taxological grammar of participation in view, we can revisit On First Principles to assess some of the evidence of a “taxological trinity” controversially alleged of Origen by his critics. The model that emerges in Commentary on John 1-2 is apparent in some of these “problem fragments” as an anti-modalistic tool; it is also apparent if we peer just beneath the surface of Rufinus’s version of the text. I will not go so far as to argue that Origen never developed his formulation of the application of participation to the Son and Holy Spirit. However, a significant shift in terms of Origen’s grammar of participation is improbable given what appears in Against Celsus and later books of the Commentary on John. In the final analysis, I hope to have demonstrated that Origen’s taxological use of participation played a significant role in his early, influential model of the trinity, and created problems in pneumatology resolvable only by significant renovation of some of Origen’s ontological commitments.
|
From Polytheism to Christianity in Egypt: A Peaceful or Violent Transition in Late Antiquity?
Program Unit: Society for Ancient Mediterranean Religions
John Pollini, University of Southern California
From Polytheism to Christianity in Egypt: A Peaceful or Violent Transition in Late Antiquity?
|
Memory, Morality, and Social Justice: The Construction of Communal Identity in the Thought of Hermann Cohen
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Alisha Pomazon, St. Thomas More College
In "Religion of Reason Out of the Sources of Judaism," Hermann Cohen elucidates his vision of social justice and a united humanity by asserting that the virtues of God form the basis of morality and action in the world. In order to make this argument, Cohen focuses on the corpus of Jewish sources, including texts, memories of past events and visions of the future. In particular, Cohen looks to the biblical Books of Leviticus, Amos and Ezekiel, as well as the Mishnah tractates Avodah Zarah and Sotah, because these texts connect visions of the messianic future with remembrances of the past, while grounding moral behavior in the present. In making this argument, however, Cohen reworks the memories of the Exodus, the construction of the Love Command, and transforms the ten virtues of God as presented in Avodah Zarah and Sotah into four key virtues of morality for action in the world. In doing so, Cohen creates a new vision of social justice that relies upon an “ancient” vision of how be and act in the world. More importantly, we can see that what Cohen chooses to “remember” in his ideas about morality and social justice results in the construction of an identity that he wants the Jewish community to be and become as his Religion of Reason sets the program for Jewish thought and the establishment of Wissenschaft des Judentums in the twentieth century. In this paper, I seek to explain Cohen’s arguments about the connections between morality, social justice and Jewish education. I will do so by using the foundational ideas of Cultural, Social and Collective Memory theories, as these theories help clarify how Cohen’s political and social contexts aid him in his quest to form a collective identity for Jews in Germany by transforming memories of tradition.
|
Visions of the End: On Death and Animated Dreams in Tertullian and Perpetua
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Ross Ponder, University of Texas at Austin
After being arrested and jailed with other Christians in 203, Vibia Perpetua a young matron requested a dream-vision (visio—a technical term for a prophetic dream) to determine their fate. Perpetua saw a dream-vision confirming their impending deaths: a bronze ladder reaching up to the sky where a grey-haired man offered her cheese in a paradisal garden. Scholars often use this literal stairway to heaven in order to characterize early Christian martyrdom in North Africa as apocalyptic ascent (Balling 1994, Frankfurter 1998, Moss 2012) or to attribute such prophetic utterances, however tangentially, to the renewal movement of the ‘New Prophecy’ (Butler 2006). While neither disputing the presence of apocalyptic features in the martyrologies of North Africa nor this region’s emphasis on prophecy, I contend that such descriptions tend to be homogenizing and imprecise. Instead, this paper further nuances the debate by critically analyzing oneirology in Tertullian’s De anima and the function of dream-visions in the Passion of Perpetua and Felicity. Both documents, composed in the first fifteen years of the third century, reveal discursive practices marking boundaries around Christian identity in Roman North Africa (Rebillard 2012). Tertullian, arguing against Platonic notions of the soul, developed a tripartite taxonomy of dreams according to his Stoic view of the soul: dreams can be sent by a god, demons, or emanate from the soul itself (De Anima 42-57; Nasrallah 2004). Tertullian’s oneirology, as such, can be called ‘animated dreams’ because of the close relationship between the soul (anima) and dreams. By comparison, dream-visions in the Passion of Perpetua and Felicity lend authority to the text—placing it alongside the “examples of ancient faith” (vetera fidei exempla; 1.1)—and train martyrs to die for God in the arena. Comparing Tertullian’s oneirology to the dream-visions of Perpetua and her companions, rather than fitting a form critical definition of apocalypse or adherence to a single group identity (Montanism), illuminates some third century debates of Christians with their many identities regarding prophecy, death, and dreams.
|
Blood, Sweat, and Smears: Bodies Portentous, Bodies Politic
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Michael Pope, Brigham Young University
The sweating and bleeding of statues were ominous phenomena in Roman religion. Whether the statues were of gods or men, their bodily secretions reflected or portended discordant violence that threatened the stability of the body politic. Teratological topoi naturally found their way into political rhetoric as useful devices for statesmen to denigrate their opponents. Cicero, for example, regularly compared his legal and political opponents to monstra et prodigia. The logic was simple: if these men were embodied portents of divine anger, the people and state had an interest in cleansing their misdeeds or, more violently, in cleansing these ominous bodies from the state. Lucretius, I argue, makes use of these topoi in a manner comparable to Cicero. Perhaps in a moment of frustration, Lucretius admits that his Epicurean project of demilitarizing Rome’s internecine discord must necessarily fail because some Roman men will not accept his peaceful message. As he does elsewhere in the poem, Lucretius falls back upon religious language and imagery to voice his resentment, though he, of course, views religion as misleading and a threat to people’s peace both individually and corporately. In recognizing the limitations of his healing philosophy, Lucretius relegates incorrigible Romans to the status of portentous religious miasma by cursing them to sweat out their blood in their ambitious struggles for power. He execrates them to become bodily instantiations of the omens that portend civic strife, the civic strife which they themselves are actually fomenting by their uncurbed appetite for domination. This radical embodying in human flesh of teratological signs altogether comports with Lucretius’ Epicurean doctrine: there is no metaphysical forcing itself upon us or investing us; if we suffer here and now it is because we make ourselves suffer in the physical bodies that delimit our human experience. We risk becoming our own monstra.
|
John’s Gospel and the Criteria for Authenticity
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Stanley E. Porter, McMaster Divinity College
The criteria for authenticity traditionally used in historical Jesus research have fallen on hard times. Some continue to bolster them, while others either attempt to modify them or outright reject them. Where does this leave John’s Gospel? Similar criteria have not been consistently used in study of John’s Gospel—in most cases there being the presumption that John’s Gospel is not historical, or not historical in the same way as the Synoptics. After summarizing the state of research regarding the criteria, this paper attempts to bring John’s Gospel within the fold of criteria-based discussion of all four Gospels. This requires, if not entirely new criteria, at least newly refashioned or reconceptualized criteria that can address issues particular to John’s Gospel. The results of such reconfiguration are analyzed and tested against past research and future prospects.
|
Publishing and Provenance: Museums, Collectors, and Scholars
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Timothy Potts, The J. Paul Getty Museum
This presentation addresses the evolution during the past twenty years of U.S. museum practice and policy regarding the collecting of antiquities, and the parallel debate over the ethics of publishing “unprovenanced” (or “poorly provenanced”) artefacts and inscriptions. Central to these discussions has been the question of a nexus between acquiring (whether by museums or individuals) and publishing such material on the one hand, and the ongoing looting of sites in crisis regions like Iraq and Syria on the other; and whether, assuming such a nexus can be demonstrated, it outweighs the scholarly responsibility to record and make accessible important new data.
|
Both Free and Literal: A New Approach to a Theology of the Septuagint
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Patrick Pouchelle, Université de Strasbourg
The quest for a theology of the Septuagint (LXX) is mainly based on comparing LXX with the Masoretic Text. However, this method seems to have reached an impasse. Indeed, whereas some scholars think it is possible to detect some theological motivated differences between LXX and MT owing to the cultural background or the religious belief of the translators, others find this farfetched and argue that it was the “Vorlage” which, in fact, was different from the MT. In a nutshell, the former say “LXX Theology” when the latter reply “old Hebrew variants.”
In order to avoid this difficulty, I would suggest a new approach: studying the Hebrew words or expressions which are differently rendered when they are related to God. For example, the Hebrew expression “shalach yad (to extend one's hand)”, is rendered by “ekteinô tên cheira” when it is the hand of a human and by “apostellô tên cheira” when it is the hand of God. Another example is “mashal (to rule),” which corresponds to “despozô” when God is subject and “archô” otherwise. These choices are not owing to a different “Vorlage,” since the Greek words and expressions semantically correspond to the MT.
This approach could shed light to some theologically motivated lexical choices in the LXX. A Hebrew word or expression could be differently rendered if it is used in relation to God. In this case, we can assume that the translators follow their “Vorlage” almost literally. However, they were free to choose the word or expression that better fits their conception of God. Studying such choices, particularly in their Greek background, could lead to new discoveries about the so-called theology of the LXX. It is the aim of this paper to give the foundation of this method as well as to present its first results.
|
“A Nation from Afar, a Nation Whose Language You Do Not Understand”: The Theme of the Alloglot Invader in Biblical Prophecy
Program Unit: Speech and Talk in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Cian Power, Harvard University
This paper investigates a repeated theme in biblical prophecy and related literature: the coming of a nation from afar that speaks an unintelligible foreign language. Passages in Isaiah (28:11; 33:19), Jeremiah (5:15), Ezekiel (3:5–6), and Deuteronomy (28:49) refer to such a nation in their threats and predictions. This paper investigates the dynamics of this threat, arguing that it draws its rhetorical force from the situation of utter powerlessness at the hands of an enemy that it invokes, as well as from the violation of Israel’s territorial boundaries that it implies. This paper forms part of my broader research into biblical attitudes towards language and linguistic diversity.
The paper focuses on several terminological and conceptual features shared among these threats, including: the persistent anonymity of the foreign nation in question; the description of its language with words implying speech impediments (“stuttered”, “heavy,” and “deep”); the link between not understanding (shama’) a foreign language, and not heeding (shama’) Yahweh’s prophetic word; and the strong association of the unintelligible language with ferocity or brutality (suggesting something like the Greek notion of barbarity).
On the basis of an analysis of these features, I offer a tentative reconstruction of the history of this Israelite prophetic tradition, in relation to changing historical conditions. At an early stage, the theme appears to have been well-developed and widely known, but in its latest attestation, in Ezekiel, the alloglot nation plays a unique role, serving not as an enemy but an obedient foil for Israel’s stubbornness. I relate this dramatic shift to the new situation of the exile, in which Judaeans live in close proximity with speakers of foreign languages.
|
The Pride of Babylon in Isaiah 47 in Light of the Theory of Self-Conscious Emotions
Program Unit: Bible and Emotion
Antony Dhas Prakasam, Catholic University of America
To my knowledge the psychological theory of Self-Conscious Emotions (SCE) has not been applied to biblical texts on pride. This paper intends to look at the pride of Babylon in Isaiah 47 from the perspective provided by SCE espoused by psychologists J. L. Tracy, R. W. Robin, and J. P. Tangney. According to these psychologists, pride is an important self-conscious emotion, and is elicited when evaluating oneself on the basis of one’s achievements. The theory of SCE argues that pride is not a single, unified construct. Psychologists distinguish the pride that results from a specific achievement (e.g., I won because I practiced) from pride in one’s global self (e.g., I won because I’m always great). They call the former authentic pride and the latter hubristic pride. In terms of causal designation, attributing positive events to internal, unstable, controllable causes (e.g., effort) should lead to authentic pride, whereas attributing those same events to internal, stable, uncontrollable causes (e.g., ability) should lead to hubristic pride. Authentic pride leads to pro-social behaviors (e.g., cooperation, helping, or altruism), while hubristic pride tends toward to anti-social behaviors (e.g., harming, non-cooperation, abuse, or harassment).
Based on this theory, this paper analyzes the dynamics of the pride of Babylon in Isaiah 47 as a self-conscious emotion. It argues that Babylon had the right to authentic pride for her military might, and science of omens and astronomy. She became hubristic because she thought these achievements were internally stable and uncontrollable by anyone. The hubris of Babylon led her to become oppressive. Divine intervention described in Isaiah 47 in the form of deprivation of Babylon’s throne, land (exile), and the sources of her security, is to be understood as de-securitization and destabilization of Babylon. Since everything Babylon counted as stable and uncontrollable (leading her to hubristic pride) is rendered unstable and controllable, Isaiah 47 can be read as a call to authentic pride.
This approach differs from the traditional viewpoint of the Church Fathers and modern exegetes, which used Babylon as a hermeneutical tool to identify the enemies of God, sowed seeds of suspicion against any form of pride, and categorized the divine intervention in Isaiah 47 as evidence of the humiliation and reversal of fortune of the prideful. Finally, this paper opens the possibility of applying the theory of SCE to other biblical texts on pride.
|
Artificial Intelligence and Data Mining Methods for Ethiopic Textual Criticism
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
James Prather, Abilene Christian University
This paper will explore the ways in which modern software can aid the difficult and tedious work of textual criticism from start to finish, using Ethiopic as an initial and primary test case. The methods, algorithms, and data structures will be discussed along with early alpha results. The first step is using Optical Character Recognition (OCR) to scan the manuscripts and digitize each character, learning and refining its accuracy as it is fed more data. This will allow for the data to be processed through advanced algorithms in a technique similar to modern data-mining. Finally, after scanning multiple manuscripts, the system can assert various levels of comparison. The final result will present the trained Ethiopic scholar with credible text-critical choices which will allow more time for higher-level work.
|
Another Brick in the Wall: The Intertwining of Biblical and Qur'anic Exegesis in Islamicate Midrash
Program Unit: The Qur’an and the Biblical Tradition (IQSA)
Michael Pregill, Elon University
In their currently extant forms Pirqe de-Rabbi Eliezer and Targum Pseudo-Jonathan seem to date to the period after the Arab conquests. The place of these late midrashim in the history of the development of Jewish exegesis of the Bible has only begun to be properly appreciated. These midrashim are of interest to scholars of the Quran and Islam because they have frequently been cited as the source of traditions that supposedly “influenced” Quranic versions of biblical narratives.
Bakhos, Sacks, and Adelman recently aim to correct this anachronistic approach to Pirqe de-Rabbi Eliezer in particular, investigating its particular literary qualities, compositional artistry, and place in its historical context. Yet only Bakhos investigates the links between Islamic traditions and the content of this work, the unique, presumably ‘post-Islamic’ elements which are often held in common with Targum Pseudo-Jonathan and the later recension of Midrash Tanhuma. Revisionist approaches to Targum Pseudo-Jonathan have been rare, while studies on Midrash Tanhuma’s links to Islamic tradition are nonexistent.
This paper argues for the necessity of approaching this corpus of works, here dubbed “Islamicate” midrashim, by taking both their creative adaptation of older traditions of Jewish Biblical exegesis and their engagement with contemporary Islamic exegesis of the Quran seriously. Such inquiry demonstrates that these Islamicate midrashim, which have been frequently cited as sources for the Quran, are in fact deeply informed by tafsir, which inverts the scheme of development that has so frequently prevailed since the time of Geiger. At the same time, it should be acknowledged that these Islamicate midrashim do not simply copy traditions from the tafsir, but mimic Islamic exegesis of the Quran in a subtle and discerning fashion in approaching the Bible in novel ways.
As specific example I will use a story found in the Islamicate midrashim of children who were killed during the Israelites’ bondage in Egypt by being interred in buildings as bricks, trodden underfoot in the mud pits where the Israelites fashioned the bricks, or, as in Pirqe de-Rabbi Eliezer, miraculously saved from death by angelic intervention. This gruesome tale has typically been discussed as an adaptation of older traditions from rabbinic sources or the Pseudepigrapha. However, I will show that the specific trajectory of development of this theme cannot be properly understood without reference to early Islamic traditions on the bondage in Egypt, which engage older Jewish sources specifically in the interpretation of Quranic allusions to the time of the Exodus. The dense intertwining of elements from the midrash and the tafsir represented in Jewish works such as Pirqe de-Rabbi Eliezer and Islamic works such as the Quran commentary of al-Tabari (d. 923 CE) demonstrate that neither tradition can be adequately understood in isolation from the other, and that scholars working in each field must take developments in the other seriously in seeking to untangle the complex narrative threads intertwining between Bible, Quran, midrash, and tafsir.
|
From Catechesis to Exegesis: The Hermeneutical Shaping of Catechetical Formation in Irenaeus of Lyons
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Stephen O. Presley, Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary
From Catechesis to Exegesis: The Hermeneutical Shaping of Catechetical Formation in Irenaeus of Lyons
|
Variation on Divine Involvement in the Fates of Mesopotamian and Biblical Rulers
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
J.H. Price, The Ohio State University
Instances where episodes in Samuel-Kings and Chronicles diverge with regard to the role of Yahweh in the outcome of events are well-known. The cases of Saul, Jeroboam, and Josiah are particularly striking, for the Chronicler sees Yahweh directly at work in the battlefield deaths of these kings, unlike the narratives concerning these three monarchs in the Deuteronomistic History. Different degrees of divine agency may seem contradictory, but such diversity is reflected elsewhere in ancient Near Eastern literature. Variety in the portrayal of divine roles which underlie the fate of a ruler is detectable in texts which narrate the insomnia suffered by Sargon of Akkad, the defeat of Kaštiliaš by Tukulti-Ninurta, and the execution of Nabû-zer-kitti-lišir in Elam. When taken together, these texts demonstrate that both Mesopotamian and biblical writers had freedom to conceptualize the same fate of a ruler with different degrees of divine agency, and that theological perspective and emphasis could undergo conceptual shifts in the perception of divine involvement within interpretive traditions. While one passage may depict a ruler's fate as devoid of divine involvement, another may stress that the same fate is a result of direct divine intervention. In other cases, the fate of a ruler is a result of divine sanction followed by divine involvement which is hidden behind a matrix of human activity. Attention to the breadth of this phenomenon provides empirical evidence that shifts in divine agency, such as those reflected in Samuel-Kings and Chronicles, were at home in the intellectual milieu of the ancient world.
|
Seeing Visions: The Persuasive Power of Sight in Luke-Acts
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Deborah Thompson Prince, Bellarmine University
This paper will explore the connection between the rhetoric of vision and the vision narratives in Luke-Acts. How are reports of visionary experiences employed in these texts? To what extent were rhetorical perspectives and techniques influential in the formation and/or purpose of these narratives? I propose that a close look at the vision narratives of Luke-Acts could provide insight into the rhetorical role that seeing played in ancient narratives. Luke-Acts is a particularly appropriate place to begin because of the frequency of vision reports in these two works and their apparent concern with ancient rhetorical practices. The inscribed author of Luke-Acts identifies his purpose in writing as providing a clearer and more truthful account for his audience and scholars have often identified this purpose as apologetic.
I contend that visions in Luke-Acts are central to the author’s rhetorical goals. They occur at pivotal moments in the larger narrative and function as clear and authoritative support for the author’s theological claims. Although this is evident throughout both texts, for the purposes of this paper I will focus on the central chapters of Acts (9 and 10), which present the double vision reports of Saul and Ananias and Peter and Cornelius, in order to examine how the visual clarity of these vision reports advances the author’s rhetorical purposes. Along with a close study of the biblical text, ancient rhetorical handbooks, the progymnasmata, and ancient historians will be examined for insight into ancient perspectives on the persuasive power of seeing clearly.
|
Samaritans, Galileans, and Judeans in Josephus and the Gospels
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Reinhard Pummer, Université d'Ottawa - University of Ottawa
The paper will explore the relationship between Samaritans, Galileans and Judeans in Josephus and the Gospel of John as well as other New Testament writings. Among the subjects to be discussed will be that of the Samaritan idea of the eschatological prophet, the Taheb, and its distinction from Jewish concepts of messianism.
|
Indian Women and Jainism: Toward an Ecofeminist Perspective
Program Unit:
Amanda Pumphrey, Claremont Graduate University
*
|
Postcolonial and/or Empire Studies: Birds of a Feather? Intersections and Negotiations
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
Jeremy Punt, Universiteit van Stellenbosch - University of Stellenbosch
Postcolonial theory and empire studies are often equated in biblical studies in a way that does not do full justice to either of the two as critical enquiries. Somewhat comparative, this brief investigation is interested in exploring possible hiatuses as well as intersections between the two theoretical models. Biased towards postcolonial inquiry for the reasons pointed out, the contribution shows upon the strengths of postcolonialism but with ample candour about its shortcomings. Not without ambivalence and hybridity, maybe typical of a postcolonial inclination, the conclusion stresses the value of intersections between empire and postcolonial work in biblical scholarship without denying their variances.
|
Did 1QIsaa and IQS Come from the Same Parchment Workshop?
Program Unit: Qumran
Ira Rabin, BAM Federal Institute of Materials Research and Testing
The International Qumran project conducted at the BAM Federal Institute for Materials Research and Testing in 2007-2010 aimed at establishing an optimal methodology for an accurate characterization of the Dead Sea Scrolls collection to address such questions as archaeological provenance, origin, and attribution of fragments to a specific sheet. Using equipment of a various degree of complexity we have shown that a part of the historic information stored in the material can be revealed through its proper characterization. The onsite investigation of the Dead Sea Scrolls fragments from the Schøyen collection offered the first chance to use this methodology in a field study. For the first time, we used exclusively mobile and non-invasive technology since we could not transport all of our laboratory equipment to Norway for this project. Moreover, besides the technical limitations dictated by the available equipment, we had to cope with a limited time: it was impossible to perform the number of scans required for optimal characterization of over 30 fragments within the 14 days available. Nevertheless, in the onsite study of the Dead Sea Scrolls collection in Norway we tested the reliability of the results obtained with our light, mobile lab.
This contribution presents the material study of the fragments from the Cave 1. The finds from the cave 1 in the Schøyen collection include a number of small fragments. The larger part, MS 1926 1-3, was acquired from John Trever, who most probably collected them during his first inspection or photography of the scrolls in 1948. They include uninscribed small fragments from the Isaiah scroll (1QIsaa) subdivided into three groups: repair, scroll and cover, respectively; two uninscribed fragments from 1QS and three fragments from the Genesis Apocryphon, an inscribed one and two last extant pieces from the uninscribed parchment that initially covered some of the badly damaged columns of the Genesis Apocrypon. In addition, there is a fragment MS 1909 (ascribed to 1Qsb) that was purchased from the widow of William Brownlee who received it as a gift from Archbishop Athanasius Samuel in 1973.
Our results show that the scrolls 1QIsaa and 1QS were produced in the same manner that differs greatly from the manufacture process of the majority of the scrolls. Moreover, if MS1909 belongs indeed to 1QSb we find that the parchment of the 1QS and 1QSb are indistinguishable. The close similarity, expensive materials and high quality of the production of 1QIsaa, 1QS and 1QSb suggest that they come from the same workshop. In contrast, the fragment belonging to the “repair” was produced quite differently. Similarly, two parchments of the Genenesis Apocryphon originate from two different production processes.
The contribution will discuss different production treatments in the Jewish Antiquity and their possible implications for the current debate in the Dead Sea Scrolls studies.
|
Religious Criticism and Change in the Book of Zephaniah
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Jason Radine, Moravian College
The identity of the priests and cult criticized in Zephaniah 1:4-5 and 3:4 are crucial for the question of the possible relationship between the book of Zephaniah (or portions thereof) and the so-called Josianic reform. This paper examines the research on the religious practices targeted in Zephaniah, the question of any possible difference between kohanîm and kemarîm, and proposed distinctions between possible support in Zephaniah of a Josianic military campaign on the one hand, and religious change on the other. The paper concludes with implications for the theory of a Deuteronomistic “Book of the Four” that would include the book of Zephaniah.
|
The Indonesian Muslim Responses to the Use of Hermeneutics in the Study of the Qur'an
Program Unit: Qur’anic Studies: Methodology and Hermeneutics (IQSA)
Yusuf Rahman, State Islamic University Jakarta Indonesia
The Qur'an, as the holy book of Islam, has been studied and analyzed by previous 'ulama using the normative and classical sciences of the Qur'an ('ulum al-Qur'an). In modern period, due to their discontent with this classical traditional scholarship, some modern Muslim scholars have introduced and used modern approaches, like hermeneutics and semiotics, to the Qur'an. Fazlur Rahman, Nasr Hamid Abu Zayd, Mohamed Arkoun, to name few, have used these mo deren approaches, which have been used in studying the Bible and other secular texts, in studying and interpreting the Qur'an. Many Muslims however oppose to this usage of the modern and secular approaches to the Qur'an arguing that they are incompatible with the divinity of the Qur'an. Muzaffar Iqbal in his 'The Qur?an, Orientalism, and The Encyclopaedia of the Qur?an' considers that Western approaches to the Qur'an to be based on relativistic and hermeneutical approaches which are incompatible with the divine nature of the Qur'an. The present paper, therefore, would like to discuss Indonesian Muslim responses to the use of hermeneutics in studying and interpreting the Qur'an. This paper will classify these responses into theological and polemical responses and scientific academic studies. The main sources of this paper are the published printed works of Indonesian Muslim scholars, either in the form of the books and also in the form of articles in academic journals. It will then study them historically to see the background of the writer/author of the works, the context and the purpose of these works, and the impact of these works to the general Indonesian Muslim perception of Western scholarship of Islam.
|
In Defense of Jehoiakim
Program Unit: Orality, Textuality, and the Formation of the Hebrew Bible
Jesse Rainbow, University of Houston
Jeremiah 36 strongly insinuates that in ordering the arrest of Jeremiah and Baruch, King Jehoiakim intended to subject them to the same fate as their scroll, namely, to kill them. In this paper, I reconsider Jehoiakim’s reaction and seek to redescribe it not as a rejection of Jeremiah as a prophet, nor of prophecy per se, but as a fundamental misunderstanding between the king and the prophet regarding the authority of the prophetic text as opposed to the spoken prophetic word. In other words, Jehoiakim reacted primarily to the innovative and (from his point of view) anomalous nature of Baruch’s scroll, and not, as Jeremiah 36 tendentiously argues, to the word of Yahweh to his prophet Jeremiah. In this seminal episode in the history of the textualization of the Israelite prophecy, Jehoiakim represents not evil personified, but resistance to religious innovation. In addition to enumerating the innovations of Baruch’s scroll, I demonstrate that Jeremiah 36 exaggerates the danger to the prophet and his scribe, recast Jehoiakim’s purported rage as befuddlement, and based on the named figures of the passage, suggest that Jeremiah had little to fear from within the royal chancellery. Most tellingly, the date formula of Jeremiah 35 shows that Jeremiah was once again moving about the temple shortly after the scroll-burning episode, a fact that is cleverly obscured by the arrangement of materials in the canonical Hebrew text, as part of the program of demonizing Jehoiakim.
|
Resurrecting Wounds: John 20:24–29, Trauma Theory, and the Doctrine of Resurrection
Program Unit: Biblical Literature and the Hermeneutics of Trauma
Shelly Rambo, Boston University
The event of resurrection is positioned within Christian systematic theology at the nexus of multiple doctrines—soteriology, Christology, and eschatology. Thus, theological readings of this biblical scene in John 20 often serve to confirm the nature of Christ and demonstrate the importance of belief. Reformed theologian John Calvin, for example, ties Thomas’ encounter directly to his denunciation of christological heresies; Thomas’ proclamation of belief is, according to Calvin, a biblical refutation of Arius. In this paper, I will reframe this encounter via the insights of trauma theory and an emerging approach to hermeneutics within continental philosophy identified by philosopher Richard Kearney as “carnal hermeneutics.” This hermeneutical approach takes as its starting point the problematic divisions between word and body, and language and skin, fostered by philosophical divisions between phenomenology and hermeneutics. In an attempt to bridge the two, carnal hermeneutics expands on the multiple meanings of ‘sense.’ Hermeneutics is a practice of ‘making sense’ of sense. What if, in our readings, we interpreted sensually in order to make-sense of life in the aftermath of trauma? In the case of John 20, I will reinterpret the encounter between Thomas and the resurrected Christ as an encounter between “word and skin.” Revisiting Cathy Caruth’s double-structure of the wound in Unclaimed Experience (1996) and in Literature in the Ashes of History (2013) via carnal hermeneutics, I will reflect on what this figure of “wounded return” means both for the doctrine of the resurrection in Christian thought and the afterlife of trauma.
|
Revisiting Aphrahat’s Sources: Beyond Scripture
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Ilaria L.E. Ramelli, Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore & Angelicum
The Demonstrations, or Expositions, of Aphrahat the Persian Sage, in the first half of the fourth century CE, attest to a profound knowledge of the Bible, especially the Old Testament, but are generally considered to be rather isolated within Patristic literature. For instance, they reveal no trace of the theological debates of Aphrahat’s day. However, I noticed that some Demonstrations show impressive similarities with Mara Bar Serapion’s Letter to His Son and Bardaisan, notwithstanding Aphrahat’s general lack of interest in Greek philosophy. In the case of Mara, only partially can these similarities be traced back to a common wisdom tradition. Mara’s Letter and Bardaisan’s ideas in the Book of the Laws of Countries were handed down together in the same seventh-century Syriac manuscript that collected works displaying the relation between Greek—more or less popular—philosophy and Christianity in various ways (Bardaisan was a Christian; Mara apparently was a “pagan” Stoicizing thinker, but he spoke of Jesus Christ as a parallel to Socrates and Pythagoras). It is possible, and even probable, that Mara’s and Bardaisan’s ideas were transmitted together in Syriac manuscripts already at the beginning of the fourth century. In this case, one such manuscript was available to Aphrahat, who indeed tends to group his parallels with Mara and Bardaisan in the same few Demonstrations. This research will hopefully introduce new, previously unnoticed elements in the study of Aphrahat, his sources, and his cultural context.
|
Ancient Jewish and Christian Exegeses of the “Curse of Ham”: Divergent Strategies
Program Unit: Midrash
Ilaria L.E. Ramelli, Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore
I will explore ancient Jewish and Christian interpretations of the Biblical episode of the “Curse of Ham” to show how different positions they involved with respect to its purported endorsement of the institution of slavery. Some exegetes applied this Scriptural passage to the birth of slavery as an institution, and tended thereby to legitimize this institution as grounded in a divine decree. This view paralleled the Aristotelian theorization of slavery “by nature.”
Other exegetes only gave a moral interpretation of the kind of slavery involved in this Biblical episode, and tended to understand moral slavery much in the same way as the Stoics understood it. The exegetes who followed along these lines, though, as it was the case with most Stoics as well, generally did not deem the institution of slavery illegitimate and were uninterested in promoting its abolition or at least the emancipation of as many slaves as possible.
However, both in ancient Judaism (especially Hellenistic Judaism) and in early Christianity there were ascetic groups and individuals who rejected slavery as an institution and contested its legitimacy outright. Either they disregarded totally the Biblical episode of the “Curse of Ham” or they did not consider it to be any endorsement of the institution of slavery at all. In this connection I will argue for the strong relation between asceticism and the rejection of slavery in ancient Judaism and Christianity.
|
"You Shall Write on the Stones": Deuteronomy 27 and the Inscribing of Ritual Curses
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Melissa Ramos, University of California-Los Angeles
The proposed study will examine the command given to Moses in Deuteronomy 27: 1-8 to write on plastered stones “the words of this teaching very clearly (??? ????)” within the broader context of the function of written oaths and curses in the Near East during the seventh century BCE. Particular attention will be given to the corpus of ritual oath and ritual curse texts from this period: Syrian and Mesopotamian treaty stelae, the Mesopotamian magic texts Maqlû and Šurpu, the Syrian magical plaques of Arslan Tash, and the Judean curse inscriptions of Khirbet Beit Lei and Khirbet el-Qom. The preponderance of curse inscriptions within the material record of the Near East during seventh-century suggests a strong interest in incorporating writing into ritual oaths and curses. It is within this context that Deuteronomy 27-28 is best understood as a ritual oath performance recorded on monumental stelae. Moreover, these use of ritual oath texts in display contexts (e.g., amulets or stelae) suggests that these “texts” in the Near East served not only as administrative records of rituals and treaties, but also as objects of ritual power in and of themselves. Indeed, the written record of these oath texts served not just an administrative function, but also a cultic one: writing the texts was understood to imbue them with divine power able to enforce the terms of the oath. The display of the text may also have heightened its potential to persuade the community to abide by the terms of the oath and to heed the potent threats therein. Indeed, erecting of the stones bearing the statutes of the covenant was a display of power that may also have functioned as an “integrative mechanism” to promote social cohesion and common identity.
|
Exploring the ‘Harbor (Full) of Rest’ in Ps-Macarius and Isaac of Nineveh: A Foundation for a Holistic Theology of Creation
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Susan Ramsey, Carthage College
In view of the emphasis on Eco-Spirituality for the 2014 AAR/SBL conference, my paper explores the "Harbor of Rest" theme found in Isaac of Nineveh and Pseudo-Macarius, with the aim of understanding the Macarian theology of Creation. The Macarian presentation of 'Rest' (anapausis) is deeply connected with the original state of Creation. The original ontological reality of Creation can inform contemporary thought on attitudes toward Creation and fuel active concern for the disruption of that order. Drawing upon Jared Calaway's thought, I will delineate the interconnection of Dwelling Place and Rest, which function as equivalent concepts for Macarius. Through an appreciation for the disruption of this intended integration, those who heed the ever louder groanings of Creation will receive encouragement to pursue the mending of world. The place of Rest is in fact God’s very presence and state of being, which was infused into the created order in the beginning
|
Answering Cain's Question
Program Unit: Theology of the Hebrew Scriptures
Donald Raney, Wayland Baptist University
It is one of the most well-known questions in the Bible. In Genesis 4:9 Cain asks God, "Am I my brother's keeper?" While many are familiar with the story of Cain and Abel, many do not realize that within the context of Genesis 4, God does not answer this yes-or-no question. Due to this lack of a straightforward answer, many readers have identified with Cain in assuming a negative answer. Yet a closer look at the context of the question suggests that the answer is "yes." Further, as one continues to read the Bible one continually encounters texts which seem to raise this question in ways that point to an affirmative answer. This paper seeks to show how Cain's question thus seems to serve as an introduction to one of the primary theological threads that tie the entire Bible together by exploring the ways the various parts of the Bible seek to provide an answer to the question. Beginning with an examination of Cain's question, this paper then provides a brief survey of how the various sections of the Bible offer address the issue. From the Genesis stories of actual brothers who fail to be their brother's keeper to the emphasis on brother-keeping in the Torah and wisdom literature, the consistent prophetic condemnation of the people for their failure in keeping their brother, the Hebrew Bible consistently places brother-keeping at the heart of its theological message. Along the way, the biblical texts repeatedly address the question of who one's brother is, affirming that the term "brother" is not limited to biology but encompasses all of humanity. This issue of brother-keeping is also found prominently in the New Testament and thus serves to bind the two Testaments together. It can thus be demonstrated that while Cain's question is initially unanswered, it does open a door to a central theme in biblical theology.
|
Institutional Support for Persons with Disabilities
Program Unit:
Rebecca Raphael, Texas State University–San Marcos
*
|
Mellowed with Wine: Cursed Be Who?
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Ilona N. Rashkow, Stony Brook University
Serious study of the Bible and Talmud has been the main intellectual occupation of observant Jews since the Diaspora. Humor and satire which attack that which is accepted are not be permitted in the study of religious writings. However, sensing the importance of the need for some humorous relief, certain liberties are admitted and even encouraged. Thus once a year, on Purim, it was and is permissible not to be serious and even drinking is highly recommended. Purim is a time of carnivals and masquerades, in which people are permitted to disobey the Deuteronomical commandment forbidding men to dress as women and women to dress as men. Under the influence of the Roman carnival, Italian Jews at the end of the 15th century were the first to add masquerading to the celebration of Purim, and this custom spread throughout the Jewish world. This gaiety found its expression in the “Purim spiel.” A Purim rabbi is chosen, his behavior being a caricature of the real rabbi. He gives illogical and funny “rabbinical decisions” to the great delight of his listeners, including the rabbi. However, this is for one day only; immediately afterwards, the community returns to serious studies, until the following Purim.
All rituals. including Purim festivities, serve a function and the general consensus of scholarly opinion is that they create a social bonding among the individuals who participate in them as well as those who observe them: first, by increasing people’s identity with the group (particularly while those rituals are being performed); and second, making people more likely to sacrifice their own personal resources for the group. This paper examines the festival of Purim in terms of the psychological effects of Purim festivities.
|
Politics, Patriarchy, and Power: When the Word of God Goes Wrong
Program Unit: Westar Institute
Raheel Raza, Council for Muslims Facing Tomorrow
According to activist Raheel Raza, the combination of politics, patriarchy and power is a toxic force for many Muslim majority societies. The Qur’an, as the word of God for Muslims, is difficult to comprehend as it was not compiled chronologically, but rather from longest to shortest verse. And it contains passages that can be, and have been, used to justify violence, slavery and the oppression of women. Added to the confusion is the fine line, in Muslim society, between culture and religion, which gets blurred in communities that are not literate in scripture or that lack a secular education. For the seventy-five percent of Pakastanis who are illiterate, religiosity becomes a potent force in their lives. Change and reform, urges Raza, has to come soon.
|
Prepositions in Greek Narrative: Observations about Their Function and Use
Program Unit:
Jenny Read-Heimerdinger, University of Wales, Trinity Saint David
In this workshop session we will focus on how the authors of the Gospels and Acts use prepositions not just as a means to link parts of a sentence together but also for purposes that go beyond the surface meaning of the narrative. Attention will be paid to word order, considering the place of the prepositional phrase within a sentence, and also to the possible alternatives of using a preposition or case alone (e.g. p??? a?t?? versus a?t?). The historical development of prepositional use over the early centuries CE will be taken into account in view of the frequent variation among the oldest manuscripts. Participants will have ample opportunity to be involved in the practical study of sample texts.
|
Paul's God of Peace in Canonical and Political Perspectives
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Mark Reasoner, Marian University (Indianapolis)
Paul’s phrase “God of peace” occurs four times in the uncontested letters, usually in blessings at the end of letters. The phrase is not attested in the LXX, and only rarely occurs in the pseudepigrapha, most notably in Testament of Dan 5:2. Why would Paul use the expression “God of peace” for the God he worshipped? Very similar expressions in 1 Corinthians 14:33 and 2 Corinthians 13:11 show that “God of peace” can be used not directly as a political slogan against the Romans, but rather as a slogan for what one could call the domestic politics of church life. But Paul’s phrase “God of peace” that appears near the end of 1 Thessalonians, Philippians and Romans is a hidden transcript resulting from the intersection of his scripture reading and his exposure to political propaganda celebrating the Roman peace.
|
Constituent Postponement and Defamiliarization in Biblical Hebrew Verse
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Scott Redd, Reformed Theological Seminary
This paper investigates the peculiar varieties of word order commonly exhibited in the verbal clauses of Biblical Hebrew (BH) verse. The corpus of BH verse which makes up the sample set under investigation includes to Genesis 49, Exodus 15, Numbers 23-24, Deuteronomy 32 and 33, Judges 5, 2 Samuel 1, Isaiah 40-48, Habakkuk 3, Zephaniah 1-3, Zechariah 9, Psalms 1-25, 78, 106, and 107. This corpus provides a body of verse that includes all or a large part of the corpora used in the three recent and significant analyses of BH verse: O'Connor (1980), Rosenbaum (1997), and Lunn (2010). The corpus is designed to reflect a variety of biblical texts which represent diverse periods, genres, and subjects. Occurrences of constituent postponement were culled from this sample corpus, analyzed, categorized, and evaluated. Eligible lines of verse were analyzed for particular postponement constructions, including verbal postponement (V-postponement), subject postponement (S-postponement), and object postponement (O-postponement). Lines including verbal clauses with a lexical subject, lexical object, and/or prepositional, were eligible for V-postponement. Likewise, lines with verbal clauses including a subject and object and/or a prepositional phrase (with a lexical noun), were eligible for S-postponement. Lines with verbal clause lines including an object and prepositional phrase (with a lexical noun) were eligible for O-postponement. The analysis of this corpus shows that postponement is not, by any measure, a norm in the poetry of the Bible. While the presence of postponement is not overwhelming, it does show that 1 in 6 lines of verse exhibit a word order pattern that would be highly irregular in BH prose, and this finding supports the proposal that clauses BH verse evince a relaxed syntactic constriction in the area of word order. The prevalence of constituent postponement in BH verse can be understood as a form of "defamiliarization," a concept described by Victor Shklovsky of the Russian Formalist school. In this case, defamiliarization represents a modification of the normal and predictable process of numerical regulation of verse, and as such it works with and in contrast to the regulating features exhibited in verse. To put it another way, the relaxation of syntactic constraints occurs as a natural part of the defamiliarizing tendency of verse, and it plays a complementary role to what O'Connor calls the increased syntactic constriction that is exhibited in the number of syntactic elements allowed in a line of BH verse. Therefore, constituent postponement should be understood as a function of defamiliarization common in BH verse that is triggered by and in concert with the other tropes that are common to the genre. In this study, the credibility of the linguistic dating of the BH is assumed, though the recent wave of criticism directed toward historical linguistic study of BH is recognized.
|
Telling the Truth and Shaming the Devil: The Role of Biblical Proverbial Wisdom for Inspiring Socio-political Change in African Caribbean Contexts in Postcolonial Britain
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Anthony Reddie, Bristol Baptist College
This paper will investigate the intersection between Practical theology, Black theology and Biblical studies as a means of creating an innovative and interdisciplinary approach to conscientizing ordinary Black people on the margins of British society. This approach is one I have termed a ‘Participative’ Black theology and seeks to move beyond largely theorizing to that which enables ordinary people to be active in a more praxis based approach to building theological discourse from the bottom up. Central to this work has been the place of the Bible. This participative approach to engaging with the Bible is a Black hermeneutical method that poses a number of political and polemic points about the use and abuse of Holy Scripture and Christian tradition as it collides with contemporary Black experience. This paper provides a case study in which a participative method for reading the book of Proverbs is used as a hermeneutical tool for assessing the improvisatory qualities of Black people and the concomitant cultures and spiritualities that challenge traditional, non-political approaches to Black Christian discipleship in Britain. This mode of socio-political hermeneutics seeks to create subversive and improvisatory approaches to Bible study of the Book of Proverbs as a means of mobilizing Black Christian resistance to the growing threat posed by the hegemonic tendencies of globalized White hegemony.
|
Decolonizing Daniel: A Postcolonial Interpretational Examination
Program Unit: Bible, Myth, and Myth Theory
Jonathan Redding, Vanderbilt University
Scholars of all varieties make interpretative moves according to acknowledged or ignored predispositions. Biblical studies are no exception, with laypersons and academics alike carrying religious experiences into biblical interpretation. I use this paper to argue interpretations of Daniel have been colonized by scholars discarding viable ancient Near Eastern literary connections in favor of Western Christianized notions of apocalyptic theory and theology. This paper uses post-colonial literary theories to unveil, deconstruct, and provide alternatives for said interpretative biases. I begin by establishing the problematic with a critique of certain interpretations of Daniel and summarize my use of post-colonial methodologies to critique colonized readings without lobbying for unilateral scholarly invalidation; instead, it is meant as a tool for increased interpretational polyvalence. I then consult the biblical texts and lobby for reading Daniel “backward” and keeping ancient Near Eastern literary sources like the Gilgamesh Epic and Dumuzid's Dream in interpretative sight, in addition to reading “forward” through heavily Christianized apocalyptic lenses. Conclusions offer possibilities for intertextual considerations of appropriate ancient Near Eastern sources in order to expand interpretations of Daniel and the broader apocalyptic genre.
|
Royal Edicts in Ancient Egyptian Law
Program Unit: Orality, Textuality, and the Formation of the Hebrew Bible
Donald Redford, Pennsylvania State University
"Suprema lex regis voluntas" is a statement that would have resonated with most kings who sat upon the throne of Egypt, albeit with the restraint provided by the concept of ma'at, "order, justice." Equally the phrase "suprema lex regis verbum" would have fitted into the Egyptian mind set, especially when coupled with the tenet which identified royal intelligence and utterance with creative, regulatory force. This paper will attempt to investigate "les paroles royales" in terms of which areas of Egyptian society they addressed, how they were preserved, and how they came to constitute an on-going collection of edicts. In particular we will examine such phrases as "king's-command," "king's-doctrine," "what-was-said-in-the-Majesty-of-the palace," and "(Official) statement."
|
Who Abandons Whom? God's Absence in the Rape of Dinah
Program Unit: Genesis
Leah Rediger Schulte, Claremont Graduate University
God is markedly absent in the three rape narratives in the Hebrew Bible (Genesis 34, Judges 19, and 2 Samuel 13). Drawing on methodologies from literary criticism and gender studies, this paper focuses on the rape of Dinah in Genesis 34 and analyzes a pattern of four elements in the chapter and book as a whole: God’s absence, a foreign presence, and a persistent problem that is resolved incorrectly to highlight consequences of Israel breaking her covenant with God.
First, in the chapter divisions in the Masoretic text, the Israelite deity is absent in divine name, speech or action in all of Genesis 34; however, the name of the deity appears in Gen 33:20, the final verse of chapter 33, and then the deity speaks in Gen 35:1. Since the deity is absent in the other two narrative rape chapters, yet present in the verses immediately surrounding those chapters, the absence of God becomes a key element of biblical rape.
Second, each rape contains a foreign or “outsider” presence. Dinah’s rapist is Shechem, the prince of the region, who is Hivite. The absence of God and yet presence of a foreigner highlights Israel’s abandonment of the covenant: Israel makes treaties and enters relationships with foreign nations when she should rely only on God for protection. Israel chooses the foreign presence, God exits the scene, and rape is the resulting crisis that demonstrates to Israel the extreme pain and vulnerability of breaking her covenant with the Israelite deity.
Third and fourth, there is a persistent problem presented throughout each book with an incorrect resolution that exacerbates the problem rather than solving it. The incorrect solution emphasizes how vulnerable and misguided Israel is without her covenantal relationship. The persistent problem in the book of Genesis involves marrying correct wives and relating to neighbors without relying on outside treaties for protection. There are multiple examples of this—for instance, Esau marries two Hittite women in Gen 26:34-35, and the text notes that they “made life bitter” for Isaac and Rebekah. The shocking climax of this problem-resolution tension occurs in Gen 34, when a foreign son rapes and then is allowed to marry a virgin daughter of Israel! The extreme violence that ensues as Dinah’s brothers kill the males and burn the city further exacerbates the problem.
The Israelite deity speaks in Gen 35:1 to offer a correct resolution, reminding Jacob and his household of the covenant: Jacob instructs his household to put away foreign gods (and thus foreign relations) and come with him to Bethel to build an altar to the deity there. In 35:10, the deity further reinforces the covenantal relationship by renaming Jacob “Israel.” So who abandons whom? Israel abandons her deity by relying on relations with foreigners. A virgin daughter of Israel is raped, demonstrating the extreme vulnerability of Israel without her deity and the resulting social crisis. God immediately returns to reestablish the covenant, providing a correct resolution to the rape crisis.
|
A Sixth-Century Syriac Homily on the Lord’s Prayer: Humanity’s Slavery Contract Lacks the Valid Signatures
Program Unit: Aramaic Studies
Morgan Reed, Catholic University of America
In the Syriac-speaking church tradition, St. Jacob of Sarug (? 521 C.E.) offers an interpretation of Jesus' ransom payment which has not been explored by modern scholarship. St. Jacob avoids addressing to whom the ransom was paid by suggesting that humanity's slavery to Satan is invalid because the parties who drew up the contract were not authorized to sign it. Because this homily has not yet been translated into English, I desire to offer a translation of relevant sections wherein St. Jacob connects the Lord’s Prayer to humanity's enslavement under the devil. Scholarship has addressed the conflicting theories of Origen (who is followed by Gregory of Nyssa) and Gregory of Nazianzus, but not the Syriac tradition’s treatment of this matter. I will provide an introduction and overview of St. Jacob’s use of slavery to Satan and the image of God in humanity within the broader Syriac-speaking milieu and its relevance to his argument. This paper will utilize early Greco-Roman slavery contracts (from both Greek and Aramaic sources) and relevant theological writings of the period. This research will highlight the relationship between Greco-Roman slavery contracts and St. Jacob’s use of them in his comments on the Lord’s Prayer.
|
Colonized Bodies: The Rape of Children in 4 Ezra, Josephus, and Tacitus
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Caryn A. Reeder, Westmont College
Roman victory is embodied in raped children in 4 Ezra 10:20-21; Josephus, J.W. 7.380-382; and Tacitus, Agr. 30-31, Ann. 14.31, 35, and Hist. 4.14. This paper examines, first, the construction of young children and adolescents (male or female) as appropriate sexual objects in the context of Roman understandings of childhood, gender, and sexuality. Second, the paper explores the historical and rhetorical rape of children as a strategy of war and colonization in the Roman Empire. Third, the paper analyzes the exploitation of the rape of children in the service of protest against Roman rule in Judea and Britain in the speeches of Boudicca and Calgacus in Tacitus’s writings, Eleazar in Josephus’s Jewish War, and Ezra in 4 Ezra. The sexual objectification of children in Tacitus (the colonizer), 4 Ezra (the colonized), and Josephus (the colonized living under the aegis of the colonizer) reveals both shared conceptions and distinctive ethics of childhood and sexuality.
|
An (Is)land of Grapes, Pomegranates, Figs, and Cassava
Program Unit: Islands, Islanders, and Scriptures
Anthony Rees, Charles Sturt University
A repetitive theme of the Numbers wilderness narrative is the complaint about the lack of certain types of food. The Israelites fondly remember the luxurious cuisine of Egypt: the melons, cucumbers, leeks and meat (Num 11). The land flowing with milk and honey is also pictured as a land of figs, pomegranates and grapes (Num 13). All of that is in stark contrast to the limited diet available in the wilderness, where manna is a constant, and boredom an ever present reality. This paper explores the way in which the food of the islands is imagined in the Pacific context. Are the staples of the pacific diet, cassava, taro and coconut the equivalent of manna? Or are they the fig, pomegranate and grape of the Pasifika imagination? Are the fruits of the islands the imagined fruit of the promised land, or the despised manna of the wilderness? And how does this attitude to food reflect the imagined relationship between people and land?
|
Gender, Ethnicity, and Power: Rethinking the Rhetoric of Paul’s Enslavement to All
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Jon Mark Reeves, Texas Christian University
New Testament scholars have approached the rhetoric of Paul’s self-enslavement to all people (1 Cor 9.19-23) with a variety of methods, with perhaps the most well received argument coming from Dale Martin, who compared the Pauline metaphor with the popular rhetorical topos of the enslaved leader. Typically, this line of research has viewed the metaphor as having a rather positive rhetorical effect, namely to function as a means of building community between Paul and the church at Corinth. For various reasons in the interpretive guild, however, gender and race/ethnicity, as explicit areas of critical inquiry, have mostly not been attended to in studies of this metaphor. My paper will examine this Pauline text at the place(s) where cultural constructions of gender and ethnicity intersect. Using a rhetoric of inquiry as my primary lens, I argue that Paul’s metaphorical enslavement to all is best read while considering the rhetoricality of the constructions of gender and race/ethnicity operating in the rhetorical fabric of the Pauline text, in the rhetorical topos of the enslaved leader, and in some contemporary interpretations. My thesis is that the metaphor of enslavement to all operates on and perpetuates an implicit understanding of kyriarchical social relationships grounded in gender(ed) inequalities and racial/ethnic difference.
|
Slavery, Flight, Pursuit, and Punishment during the Third Dynasty of 'Ur'
Program Unit: Slavery, Resistance, and Freedom
J. Nicholas Reid, University of Oxford
After considering the difficulty of defining the term 'slave' in Ancient Mesopotamia in general and numerous attempts to approach the problem, this paper argues that the study of flight and the related means of coercion presents a way forward to understanding slavery during the Third Dynasty of Ur (ca. 2100-2000 BC). These examples of individual rebellion and the consequences faced give insight into questions relating to social status from the perspectives of members of the non-elite and elite society. The study also reveals what might be the earliest attestation of the concept of reform through caging.
|
Beyond Religion: Directions for Research Following Nongbri's Before Religion
Program Unit: Religious World of Late Antiquity
Nathan Rein, Ursinus College
Brent Nongbri's 2012 Before Religion takes aim at the well-worn generalization that religion is a "universal phenomenon," a natural and ubiquitous facet of human experience. Nongbri's work is one a cluster of recent historical works informed by sophisticated theoretical critiques of the so-called sui generis model of religion. In this regard, Before Religion follows a pattern that has recently become increasingly well-established. This paper sketches some of the main contours of this emerging pattern, exemplified in work by Nongbri, Bill Cavanaugh, David Chidester, and Brad Gregory. Following this sketch, I raise for discussion some questions about the theoretical and historiographic implications of this research and point out some possible directions for future exploration, in particular: what accounts for the continuing appeal of the "religion" discourse in historiography, and what lessons can be drawn from a diachronic comparison of the application of this critique?
|
The Son of God—Hit and Miss
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Adele Reinhartz, Université d'Ottawa - University of Ottawa
Adele Reinhartz will discuss the historical Jesus and film giving special attention to Roma Downey's and Mark Burnett's recent movie "Son of God."
|
Prospective: Continuity and Change
Program Unit:
Adele Reinhartz, Université d'Ottawa - University of Ottawa
*
|
Building Eve: Temple-Oriented Jewish and Christian Interpretations of the First Woman
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Jacob Rennaker, Claremont Graduate University
The character of Eve receives little attention in the Hebrew Bible, disappearing almost completely after Genesis 4. However, this did not prevent early Jewish and Christian interpreters from drawing upon her story to understand the world around them. A number of these interpreters recognized temple imagery in the creation of woman, and that paradigm appears to have influenced their interpretive framework. I will demonstrate this by first examining Gen. 2:21-22 for conceptual connections to the Israelite tabernacle and temple. Building upon this paradigm, I will then go on to illustrate how early Jewish and Christian interpreters viewed Eve and her daughters in light of the tabernacle and temple by following this thread through several traditions.
|
Temple Voices in Conflict and Chorus: A Comparative Approach to Temple Imagery in Genesis 1–3 and the Enuma Elish
Program Unit: Genesis
Jacob Rennaker, Claremont Graduate University
Recent studies comparing the creation accounts in Genesis and the Enuma Elish have focused on the creation story of Genesis 1, leaving Genesis 2-3 out of the conversation. However, as several Second Temple authors observed, temple imagery permeates both creation narratives and suggest a closer conceptual connection between the two than is commonly recognized. When the temple imagery of Genesis 1-3 as a whole is brought into dialogue with the temple imagery of the Enuma Elish, several significant points of comparison emerge that would otherwise remain unnoticed: the relationship between females and temples, humanity’s cultic responsibilities, the place of sexual relations in regard to temples, and gradations of sacred space within temples, to name a few. This study is not concerned with determining the historical relationship between these two texts; rather, it will demonstrate that a focused, temple-oriented conversation between Genesis 1-3 (as a whole) and the Enuma Elish serves to more clearly define the views put forth in each text regarding the concept of “temples.”
|
Character and Point of View: The Beloved Disciple as Test Case
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
James L. Resseguie, Winebrenner Theological Seminary
Point of view is a neglected aspect of biblical narrative criticism and studies in the Fourth Gospel. It describes the relationship between the author and his or her work, the “angle of vision” from which characters, dialogue, actions, setting, and events are presented. Point of view may also refer to the evaluative stance of the writer towards the characters and other aspects of the narrative.
This paper focuses on the ideological point of view of the Fourth Gospel, especially the norms, values, and beliefs the author displays in the development of characters and the shaping of events. The Gospel’s evaluative point of view is expressed explicitly in the Prologue with the statement that the glory is seen in the flesh (Jn. 1:14). While some characters see only flesh and stumble over Jesus’ words and actions, others see the glory in the flesh. The Beloved Disciple is a test case for this ideological point of view. He represents the ideal point of view of the Gospel, that is, the perspective the author wants the readers to adopt as their own. The implication of point-of -view analysis for further study is that it causes the critic to focus on the way a story is told and how it is presented through the eyes of characters and their actions.
|
Decolonizing Critical Pedagogies in Theological Education: The Power of the Body that Questions
Program Unit: Bible and Cultural Studies
Patrick Reyes, Claremont Lincoln University
This paper addresses the question: can critical pedagogies in theological education participate in the liberation of bodies? The paper critiques critical pedagogies that have been embraced and used by middle- and upper-class Anglo-European descended educators to hear and emphasize the contextual knowledges of oppressed others without actually disrupting the asymmetries of power between educators and learners. The paper follows decolonial theorists such as Walter Mignolo and Emma Pérez, who recognize the necessity for public intellectuals to “write” subjugated knowledges back into history. This stance of decolonial and liberative theological education draws on Nelson Maldonado-Torres’s reading of Fanon, when he claims that bodies are truly liberated only in the power and freedom to give a gift, and in this case the gift of knowledge, from the formerly oppressed to the oppressor. It is the power to question and give that the paper challenges the use of critical pedagogy in theological education.
|
Archaic Aspects of Hebrew Orthography in the Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
Eric D. Reymond, Yale Divinity School
The Hebrew Dead Sea Scrolls are more commonly associated with innovative spelling practices, but they also attest various spellings that parallel the orthographic tendencies found in ancient, pre-Exilic inscriptions. This paper explores some of these archaic spellings among the Dead Sea Scrolls. The degree to which the scribes of the Dead Sea Scrolls employed archaic spellings/morphology in their writing is a point of debate. This paper may provide some small evidence for the presence of archaic dimensions in the orthography of the Dead Sea Scrolls.
|
The Apocalyptic Framework of the Gospel of John: The Fourth Gospel's Affinity with the Jewish Apocalypses
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Benjamin Reynolds, Tyndale University College (Toronto)
Scholarly opinion on the Gospel of John’s relationship with apocalyptic literature is varied, from Frederick Murphy’s recent negative view to John Ashton’s highly positive view. While the negative view of the Gospel of John’s relationship with the Jewish apocalypses tends to be standard among New Testament scholars, no extended comparison has been made between the SBL Genre Project’s definition of “apocalypse” and the Fourth Gospel. In this paper, I will highlight the close affinity that exists between each aspect of the SBL definition and the Gospel of John. This examination will include comparisons of the following: otherworldly mediators, human recipients, mediated revelation, spatial and temporal aspects of the revelation, possible connection to crisis, and finally the encouraging of a behavioral response to what is revealed. A cursory observation indicates that the Gospel of John shares some similarities with historical apocalypses in that the otherworldly mediator descends to earth and heavenly tours are absent. However, the Gospel does not present any eschatological schema (e.g., four nations, ten ages) typical of the historical apocalypses (Daniel, 4 Ezra, Apocalypse of Weeks, etc.). The disclosed revelation in John’s Gospel, although taking place on earth, is actually more similar to ascent apocalypses in that God is seen by the human recipient (John 14:7), albeit through Jesus, the Word made flesh. If the Fourth Gospel is closely aligned with the genre of the Jewish apocalypses – however much the Gospel may bend genre (see Harold Attridge) – there is greater evidence that Bultmann was correct about the importance of an ascending and descending redeemer figure. But such a figure is more at home in Jewish apocalypticism than Gnosticism, and thus there is more work to be done on “apocalyptic” and the Gospel.
|
The Text of the Torah in the Damascus Document
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
Bennie H. Reynolds III, Millsaps College
The Dead Sea Scrolls have provided text critics with over 200 new “biblical” manuscripts, which have changed our understanding of the textual histories of most biblical books. But “biblical” manuscripts are not the only new source of data provided by the scrolls. It is now well known that many compositions, especially the so-called sectarian texts, quote and allude to scriptural texts prodigiously. In this paper I examine quotations and allusions to the books of the Torah in the Damascus Document. While it is sometimes impossible to determine whether or not the Damascus Document quotes or alludes to a base text intentionally or unintentionally or whether the writer does so based on a textual witness or from memory, this source of data provides significant insight into the histories of the books of the Torah. While passages from all books of the Torah are used, one finds a clear preference for material from Leviticus and Deuteronomy. When possible, I categorize the “biblical” text-types represented in the Damascus Document and I suggest which exegetical/hermeneutical processes might be at work in the Damascus Document’s use of scripture.
|
The Words Are Closed Up and Sealed Till the Time of the End: The Book of Daniel in Evangelical America
Program Unit: Book of Daniel
Bennie Reynolds, Millsaps College
In 2011, Harold Camping became the most recent prophet of the apocalypse to be shamed by his failed predictions of the end of the world. Some of the most important texts for Camping’s failed predictions were taken from the Book of Daniel. Many other American Evangelical groups, which shied away from or even rejected from Camping’s specific predictions, nevertheless continue to embrace his methods for reading Daniel as well his general understanding of the book’s meaning. In this paper I examine how Camping used the Book of Daniel to calculate the date of the world’s end and I outline how his hermeneutics continue to be shared and mirrored by Evangelical America. While Porphyry recognized the second century BCE context of the Book of Daniel in the third century CE, the largest group of Christians in twenty-first century America maintains that the book chronicles the days of their lives.
|
Reading Paul in Cyprian's Exhortation to Unity and Purity
Program Unit: Contextualizing North African Christianity
Helen Rhee, Westmont College
Reading Paul in Cyprian's Exhortation to Unity and Purity
|
Interpreting the Vocabulary of Commands in Koine
Program Unit: Cognitive Linguistics in Biblical Interpretation
Richard A. Rhodes, University of California-Berkeley
Some of the most important results cognitive linguistics brings to Biblical interpretation come from category theory and frame analysis, especially when coupled with an understanding of pragmatics. Applying this knowledge to the Biblical text, we discover where our translations hide distinctions (or lack of distinctions) that would have been obvious in the original language. In this paper we will look at the various Koine terms for reports of (potentially) face-threatening speech acts, with particular attention to words referring to telling people to act (or not act). These include: pa?a??????, ?p?t?µ??, d?ast????µa?, ?e?e??, d?at?ss?, ?p?t?ss?, p??st?ss?, and s??t?ss?. The effect of having a large set of such words is that the individual terms can express subtle semantic differences. A quick look at the translations of these terms shows an unevenness regarding whether the translator was reporting the act as explicitly face-threatening or not, or whether the translator makes explicit the manner of the speech act. The key problem is that Greek and English elaborate their vocabulary describing speech acts in fundamentally different ways. Greek prefers to distinguish the kinds of speech acts being performed (tell to act, tell not to act, etc.) without reference to the pragmatic effects or the manner of speaking, and uses explicit reference to fact-threats (like ??e?d???) or manner of speaking (like ?????) when those aspects of the frame are being asserted. English on the other hand prefers to make explicit the manner of speaking (mumbling, yelling, etc.) or the pragmatic effect (warn, threaten, etc.) even in neutral contexts. These mismatches can lead to misinterpretations because the translation may assert manner or threats to face that are provably absent from the original. If time permits we will make two further points: 1) some of these terms have changed meaning between LXX times and NT times and 2) this kind of problem exists even in the earliest translations, which help inform our modern translations.
|
Whose “Mercy”? What “Sacrifice”? A Proposed Reading of Matthew’s Hos 6:6 Quotations
Program Unit: Matthew
Benjamin Ribbens, Trinity Christian College
Matthew includes quotations of Hos 6:6a in Matt 9:9-13 and 12:1-8, where neither Mark nor Luke do. In both instances, Jesus speaks the words of Hos 6:6—“I desire mercy, not sacrifice”—as a response to the Pharisees, who object to what they perceive as inappropriate behavior either by Jesus or his disciples. In Matt 9:9-13, the Pharisees object to Jesus’ dining with the tax collectors and sinners; in Matt 12:1-8, they object to the disicples’ plucking grain on the Sabbath.
Matthew’s double inclusion of Hos 6:6 raises the question of how the Hosea citation functions in the two Matthean contexts—i.e., what do “mercy” and “sacrifice” represent in these controversy stories. Most scholars identify “mercy”—either in the sense of human compassion or of covenant faithfulness—as that which the Pharisees lack and which Jesus has. “Sacrifice,” then, as the counterpoint to “mercy,” represents that which the Pharisees are committed to instead of “mercy” and is typically identified as strict adherence to the law that lacks “mercy.”
These proposals regarding the meanings of “mercy” and “sacrifice” are not without their shortcomings, which raises the possibility of another reading argued in this paper. In Hos 6:6, “mercy” is the covenant faithfulness of Israel directed toward God that will heal them of their moral sickness. Matthew employs Hos 6:6 in a similar manner. In Matt 9:9-13, “mercy” is the covenant faithfulness that the tax collectors and sinners direct toward Jesus who speaks the divine “I.” Likewise, in 12:1-8 it is the covenant faithfulness of the disciples directed toward Jesus. In each passage, “sacrifice” actually designates the sacrificial system, although for different reasons in each passage.
|
The Function of the Heavenly Cult in Hebrews and Its Predecessors
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Benjamin Ribbens, Trinity Christian College
An increasing number of scholars have connected Hebrews to the mystical texts of Second Temple apocalyptic literature. These works have drawn implications from the mystical texts in terms of Hebrews’ Christology and the mysticism of believers, including their progression into the Holy of Holies. This paper will highlight a different aspect of the connection between Hebrews and mystical texts: the role and function of the heavenly sanctuary and cult.
Several texts, including 1 Enoch 14, Jubilees, Songs of the Sabbath Sacrifice, and Testament of Levi, discuss (to varying extents) a heavenly temple where an angelic priesthood performs a heavenly cult. This heavenly praxis often plays an important function as it relates to the earthly cult. This paper examines the relationship between the heavenly and earthly cults in these mystical texts and then offers a proposal for how this background may explain how Hebrews relates Christ’s heavenly cult to the levitical earthly cult.
|
Destroying the Judean Temple on Elephantine: An Act of Religious Persecution?
Program Unit: Society for Ancient Mediterranean Religions
Carl R. Rice, North Carolina State University
In 410 BCE, the temple for YHW built by a Judean garrison on Elephantine Island in southern Egypt was raided and destroyed by the local population. This paper will explore the motivations for this attack, analyzing extant evidence to determine whether it was an act of religious persecution. Utilizing a series of Aramaic documents, written in the aftermath of the temple’s destruction and found chiefly in the Jedaniah Archive, it will re-create a narrative of events and address these questions. I will argue that the destruction of the temple was in fact an episode of religious persecution, in which the local Egyptian religious community targeted the Judean community for attack. By examining this episode as an instance of religious persecution, I hope to uncover a more nuanced understanding of the socio-cultural and religious milieu of fifth century Elephantine. This analysis will show that the study of religious persecution is a useful category of historical analysis and will consider some of the possible implications of such an analysis for the study of Egypt in the Achaemenid period.
|
The Quest for a Core: Law and Social Location
Program Unit: Book of Deuteronomy
Sandra Richter, Wheaton College (Illinois)
Agricultural law holds a primary place in what has long been identified as the "core" of the Book of Deuteronomy. Laws regarding planting and harvesting are imbedded in economy and therefore reflect significantly upon social formation. Moreover, as specific modes of production leave their record in material culture, cultivated crops leave their record in the soil. This paper will explore the intersection between current evidence involving cultivation in the Central Hill Country during the Iron I, Iron II, and Persian Periods with the legal strictures of Deuteronomy, asking if the social location of this text may be narrowed based upon its agricultural imperatives.
|
The Rhetorical Function of "Until This Day" in Deuteronomy and Comparative Semitic Literature
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Guy L. Ridge, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion
The phrase ?ad hayyôm hazzeh occurs throughout the Hebrew Bible in a variety of contexts. Its six occurrences in the Book of Deuteronomy provide the interpreter with an excellent cross-section of its various usages in Biblical Hebrew. While recent scholarly work has compared the biblical use of this phrase with parallels in ancient Greek literature, parallel formulas in Semitic languages have been neglected. This paper uses the six occurrences of ?ad hayyôm hazzeh in Deuteronomy as a baseline for comparison with semantically parallel phrases in Akkadian and Aramaic. Although these parallel phrases occur in different genres and contexts, they all exhibit one distinct similarity with the use of ?ad hayyôm hazzeh: each phrase is often employed for the rhetorical purpose of using the past to persuade the audience to perform a specific action in the present. In light of the reviewed evidence, it seems that the phrase “until this day” was a rhetorical device used in Akkadian and Aramaic over a long period of time (ca. 1950-400 BCE). The authors of Deuteronomy are likely aware of this convention when they employ the phrase, especially in examples of direct address.
|
A Tale of Two Families: “This Generation” and the True Children in Matt 12:38–50
Program Unit: Matthew
Susan M. Rieske, Wheaton College
Scholars have long puzzled over the multiple occurrences of the phrase “this generation” in the sayings of Jesus recorded in the gospels. Consensus on its meaning and significance, however, is still lacking. The purpose of this study is to examine one Matthean pericope in which it is found, Matt 12:38-50, focusing on the generation’s relationship to the Sign of Jonah, the return of the unclean spirit, and the depiction of Jesus’ true family. I argue that when viewed against an apocalyptic background, it becomes apparent that the phrase carries distinct filial connotations, describing an evil spiritual family that persecutes the elect during the time of eschatological tribulation. Here, as in other uses in the narrative, Matthew is setting up a deliberate contrast between two families with differing spiritual responses: one represented by the “generation” and the other by the true children of the Father. By writing these antagonists and protagonists into his eschatological drama, Matthew’s gospel fits directly into the stream of Jewish apocalyptic literature which saw the coming tribulation as a time of intense conflict between evildoers and the righteous, groups differentiated not only by their works but also by their ultimate destiny.
|
Invitation and Character Identification in Luke's Parables: Imagining and Constructing Alternative Worlds of Possibility
Program Unit: Gospel of Luke
Matthew Rindge, Gonzaga University
This invited paper explores the rhetoric of invitation and character identification in four Lukan parables: the "Rich Fool" (12:16-20); "Father and Two Sons" (15:11-32); "Shrewd Manager" (16:1-8); and "Lazarus and the Rich Man" (16:19-31). Luke’s teaching about wealth and possessions has received ample attention; this paper seeks to illuminate the rhetorical strategies employed in Luke regarding these motifs. The paper argues that Luke’s parables operate on three related levels, inviting characters within the parables, characters in Luke’s narrative, and readers/hearers of Luke/Acts to transform their use of wealth and possessions by imagining and constructing alternative worlds of possibility.
|
Bitten, Branded, and Bought: Apple's Logo in the Biblical Narrative and Popular Culture
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Charles M. Rix, Oklahoma Christian University
Bitten. Branded. Bought. The image of a bitten apple brands one of the most profitable corporations in the world: Apple Corporation. The bitten apple immediately recalls the biblical story of Eve's encounter with the garden fruit and its ensuing consequences. However, the evolution of this iconic symbol in popular culture from Ron Janoff’s original 1977 design of a bite out of a "rainbow apple" with its colors placed in the wrong order, to its present flexible and universal "monochromatic apple" reveals a logo more at home in humanitarian themes of hope, inclusion, and resistance to totalizing structures and systems. Drawing on Emmanuel Levinas’s phenomenology, “the face of the Other,” and Mikhail Bakhtin’s literary theories of imagery and centripetal and centrifugal forces, I suggest that the cultural development of the Apple logo illuminates centrifugal forces within the biblical garden narrative that resist and destabilize culturally constructed sameness. Therefore, across current cultures, as well as the biblical garden and ensuing narratives, humanity is continually spun “elsewhere” towards “the Other” in ever changing directions. As such, the biblical image of a bite from the fruit of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil shifts away from being a snapshot of humanity tripped up by its desire and instead suggests moments when humanity (every increasingly enabled by personal computing) awakens to hope in its own potential and its recognition and responsibility to “the Other.”
|
Who Are the Strangers in the Covenant Code?
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
Johannes Unsok Ro, International Christian University
In our view, “Judean community” is a less accurate term than “Judean communities” to describe the social or demographic internal situation of Judean society in Persian era Palestine.
These communities were not so much geographically or physically bounded, but rather mentally or psychically walled, since the members of the respective communities had to inhabit the same territory. Thus the communities could not be completely closed. In this sense, perhaps “communal network” would be a more accurate substitute for the word “community.” The members of the respective communities had to interact daily in order to survive and prosper, employing and being employed / providing and receiving compensation. Probably, the fact that the “stranger” issue is so frequently mentioned in the Covenant Code and other Biblical Law Codes reflects the contemporary Zeitgeist of post-exilic Judean communities. Multiple Judean communities coexisted side by side and this social environment necessarily caused most Judeans belonging to different communities to be strangers to each other.
|
The Structure of Post-exilic Judean Society according to the Biblical Law Codes
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Johannes Unsok Ro, International Christian University
The dating and the historical background of the Covenant Code (CC) are much debated. CC has long been regarded as the oldest law code in Israelite history. However, in our view, it would be more appropriate to refrain from using labels such as J, E and JE for the characterization of the pre-priestly Tetrateuch and, accordingly, reconsider the dating and historical background of CC. Regarding the final stage of the composition, our contention is that CC derives from Judean society in Persian era Palestine. The main purpose of this article is to indicate several pieces of evidence that support this hypothesis. The biblical law codes each reflect the specific perspectives of the communal networks in Judean society of Persian era Palestine. Since no subgroup in Palestine occupied an overpowering position, the law codes were simply juxtaposed, under the political pressure of the Persian empire, in order to shape a document of consensus.
|
From Bitter Sorrow to Exultant Joy: First Samuel 1–2 from a Cognitive Linguistic Perspective
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Elizabeth Robar, Tyndale House (Cambridge)
The text of 1 Samuel 1-2 will be used to exemplify an understanding of the biblical Hebrew verbal system from a cognitive linguistic perspective, that is, giving priority to how humans think and communicate the shape of their thoughts through language. Verbal alternation (to create a discourse structure) and anomalous verbal forms will be analysed to expose the grammatical features underlying our intuitive exegesis of the text. The role of tense, aspect and modality will be placed within a larger framework of discourse flow and structure, all in the service of the narrative's underlying purpose.
|
Georges Rouault's Le Christ et Mammon in the San Diego Museum of Art: The Aesthetics of Social and Economic Justice
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Daniel Rober, Fordham University
The French painter Georges Rouault is widely regarded as one of the most important Christian religious painters of the twentieth century, particularly in the Roman Catholic tradition. This paper analyzes one of his works in the San Diego Museum of Art dedicated to the theme of Christ, Le Christ et Mammon. It seeks in particular to probe their relationship to issues of theological aesthetics and social justice. Through an analysis of Rouault's artistic and religious context, an in-depth discussion of the painting, and an application of recent theories in theological aesthetics concerned to analyze art in terms of justice issues, it argues that Rouault's painting sends an important message about social justice, particularly on issues such as marginalization in the service of the rich that are trenchant to the San Diego and southern California region.
|
Darkened, Senseless, Foolish Minds
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Erin Roberts, University of South Carolina
In Romans 1:18-32 and 7:7-25, Paul sets forth the extreme state of Gentile immorality. The Gentiles do not recognize the one true god and are thereby plunged into the depths of wrongdoing. Paul associates their extensive deviance with their darkened, senseless, foolish minds; these minds are locked into a depraved trajectory leading only to death. Recent scholarship has explained how and why Paul connects sinfulness with mental events (passions and desires), and has successfully situated Paul’s position within the discourse of Hellenistic moral philosophy and psychology (Stowers; Wasserman). My paper takes a similar methodological path, and approaches Paul’s account of sin and wrongdoing through comparison with philosophical discourse roughly contemporary with Paul. Rather than focusing primarily upon the problem of the passions, though, my paper shows that comparison with philosophical connections between epistemology and ethics provides a fuller understanding of the kinds of mental events that Paul sees as being morally problematic.
A preliminary survey of the ways that Stoic and Epicurean discourse connects epistemology with wrongdoing (sin, hamartia) shows that there are (at least) three types of ways that humans can make moral mistakes: 1) wrong beliefs about the goal of life, which lead to problems concerning the recognition, acquisition, and aversion to good and bad; 2) passions or affections, which distort a person’s ability to judge between true and false impressions, even if that person have a proper view about the goal of life; 3) failure to withhold assent, which results in the application of unconfirmed evidence to the decision making-process, causing unwarranted mistakes about the truth of impressions. When approaching Paul with these types in mind, we are able to see that Paul not only assumes a very close connection between wrongdoing and the passions, but also with a set of cognitive mistakes that bears a meaningful resemblance to epistemological problems discussed by the philosophers: 1) lack of knowledge concerning the goal of life or the ultimate good; 2) failure to recognize right and wrong, and to tell good from bad; 2) knowledge of how to do what is good and avoid doing what is bad. Exploring these shared points of interest between Paul and philosophical discourse will help us gain a clearer understanding of Paul’s identification of sin as a problem of the mind, a problem that, once unwound and examined closely, contains failures of knowledge in addition to the problem of the passions.
|
Explaining the Purpose of Paul’s Letters through Searle’s ‘Speech-Acts’ and Jauss’ ‘Horizon of Expectations’
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Paul Robertson, Colby-Sawyer College
This paper contends that the best way to understand the literary form of Paul’s letters is to closely read them in light of their social purpose, and to compare this intersection of form and purpose with other texts and socio-literary activity with similar goals in the ancient Mediterranean. The contention that form and purpose are inextricably linked arises John Searle’s work on ‘speech-acts’, Hans Robert Jauss’ ‘horizon of expectations’, and the work of Ralph Cohen. All three thinkers provide a framework for situating Paul’s letters within their wider socio-literary milieu, and imply that certain literary expectations existed as pan-Mediterranean phenomena instead of distinctly Greek, Jewish, or Christian.
To apply these theories, I will focus on Paul’s statements of ethical exemplarity and authority as pertaining to his attempted group formation. Many scholars have read Paul’s statements about his divine mission and aspirational Christian groupness (e.g., Galatians 3:28-29) as novel literary and social phenomena. Yet an attention to other thinkers, writing in both Greek (Epictetus, Philodemus) and Latin (Seneca), demonstrates how similar literary content, such as ethical exemplarity, religious claims, and attempted groupness, was joined with similar literary form (cf. Cohen and Jauss esp.), such as extended semi-formal prose with defined addressees, use of authoritative quotations, and the use of argumentative examples.
While not directly related to Appraisal Theory, my over-arching argument and the work of Searle, Jauss, and Cohen is fundamentally concerned with the act of persuasion. If we understand the social purpose of a given thinker or writer, in this case Paul, we can further conclude on the who, what, and how of this persuasion. As Searle and Jauss note, these three elements are fundamentally interwoven, and carried expectations of particular types of literary form. I thus hope to not only illuminate Paul’s thought and literary style, but also uncover a general socio-literary mode of persuasion that existed across the ancient Mediterranean and cut across different ethnic, cultural, and linguistic groups.
|
Biblical Myth and “The Encyclopedia of Early Earth” (2013): Modernity and Retelling in the Graphic Novel
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Paul Robertson, Colby-Sawyer College
Just released on December 3, 2013, Isabel Greenberg’s “The Encyclopedia of Early Earth” re-tells many biblical stories in the context of its wider romantic narrative, with tales ranging from the Tower of Babel (The bird god: “This is HUBRIS! You know how I feel about hubris.”) to the story of Noah (“The ark was a horrible place. It was cold and cramped and eerie and animal noises would fill the vessel at all times.”). The book was highly acclaimed upon release, landing on Time Magazine's list of the Top 10 Fiction Books of 2013 and widely reviewed in literary publications ranging from "Slate" to "The Guardian".
In this paper, I discuss “The Encyclopedia” in light of both its biblical content and its appeal in modernity. Fundamental to any mythological re-telling is the negotiation between staying true to the original story and importing modern relevance. I will thus be looking to the fundamental question of why certain elements were included while others were not with reference to post-modern literature and globalization, how the biblical stories that were included differ from the “original” text, and what this difference and narrative innovation suggests about the relation between biblical texts and the graphic novel medium as it stands today.
With particular attention to reception theory and the ‘horizon of expectations’ as originally developed by Hans Robert Jauss, I will argue that certain aspects of the core narrative must remain in place (e.g., nature of conflict and resolution; relative geo-spatial orientation), while others are fully available for modification, innovation, or elimination altogether (e.g., characters and especially their personalities and relationships; absolute temporal and geographical limits). The reason for particular types of elements being retained while others are discarded or modified, I suggest, stems not only from the obvious desire to make the story relatable in a different time, place, and culture, but also arises from the particular post-modern and globalized media culture present in current Western society. This culture de-emphasizes, for example, locative and ethnic identity in favor of contextually contingent and negotiated identity particularly subject to change, but only within a given framework of familiar, Western values. I will thus read two episodes from the text in light of both reception theory and my own theorizing, namely the stories taken from "The Book of Genesis" and "The Book of Jonah". I will conclude by pointing to other re-tellings of biblical stories, such as the Hollywood movies "Noah" (March 28) and "Exodus" (December 12) to be released this year, and forward some predictions about the likely nature of their narrative innovations along these same lines.
|
Greek Syntactic Analysis for Humans (“Does This Analysis Make My Text Look Fat?”)
Program Unit: Global Education and Research Technology
Jonathan Robie, B-Greek: The Biblical Greek Forum
By exposing the internal structure of a text, syntax trees represent important elements of meaning, and can be used to explain difficult constructs, teach Greek reading skills or for syntactic queries. But the phrase-structure syntax trees most widely used in biblical studies are redundant, complex, based on theories that are no longer widely accepted, and poorly model the function of the Greek verb. We combine the strengths of dependency grammars and phrase structure grammars to create a more flexible and powerful model.
We use a hybrid approach. Some features of Greek syntax, such as Noun Phrases and Prepositional Phrases, neatly fit traditional phrase structure categories. Verbs do not. We represent verbs and their relationships with phrase structures in terms of a verb's arguments.
We have created an analysis using this model, based on the Global Bible Initiative (formerly Asia Bible Society) Greek New Testament syntax trees from biblicalhumanities.org (a phrase structure treebank) and the PROEIL treebank of the New Testament created by Dag Haug (a dependency structure treebank).
Using Koine Greek texts, we present new ways to visualize the structure of Greek syntax that are simpler and more closely fit the language. Users can examine texts directly, choosing whether to highlight phrase structure (our Phrase View) or verbs and their relationships to surrounding constituents (Verb View). The same model can be used to better support syntactic queries and for teaching the Greek language.
|
What Is Ecofeminism? Memorable Ideas in an Ongoing Conversation (1972–Present)
Program Unit:
Sarah Robinson, Claremont Graduate University
*
|
The Many Facets of Balaam
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Jonathan Miles Robker, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
Who was Balaam and what did he do? Ancient Near Eastern texts – particularly the Bible, but also a text from Tell Deir Alla – proffer a number of answers to this question: God’s instrument, Israel’s archenemy, prophet, seer, one who blesses, one who curses, charlatan. Yet it remains difficult to satisfactorily interpret how all of these images relate to on another: are some biblical texts familiar or unfamiliar with others? Are the biblical texts familiar with the text from Tell Deir Alla? Is the text from Tell Deir Alla familiar with some biblical text? Does any text about Balaam allude to any other text about Balaam? Due to a paucity of explicit literal overlap among the texts – beyond the name Balaam – it is difficult to ascertain conclusively what, if any, relationships between these texts can be identified. The texts considered come from the biblical books of Numbers, Deuteronomy, Joshua, Judges, and Micah, as well as the Aramaic text from Tell Deir Alla. This paper will offer Balaam as a test-case and reflect on what evidence exists for the reconstruction of textual allusions reflecting the various permutations of the literary figure Balaam and their tradition history. Further, the impact of such reconstructed relationships on dating the various versions of Balaam will be considered in the larger framework of the literary development of the biblical texts.
|
The Kings and Reigns of Jehu's Dynasty
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Historical Books
Jonathan Miles Robker, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
A number of recensional elements reflecting different stages of textual history can be identified in the text of 2 Kgs, particularly in the various Greek versions of the text (4 Reigns) and some daughter translations. These can be seen due to the various versions of the text that we have in, i.e., the kaige text of Vaticanus, the manuscripts of the so-called “Lucianic Recension”, the quasi-Hexaplaric text of Alexandrinus, and – not least of all – the Masoretic Text (unfortunately, the remains from Qumran are insubstantial for 2 Kgs). Some of these recensional matters reflect scribal activity beyond the “edition” of the “Endtext”, even into the Roman period and the Common Era. The identification and removal of later recensional material can aid in reconstructing the Old Greek of 2 Kgs, which in turn can aid in the reconstruction of its Vorlage. Since this Vorlage and the reference texts of the later recensions apparently remained distinct from MT in several cases, they can be used to identify scribal activity within the Hebrew textual tradition. This paper will consider some text-critical problems from 2 Kgs 9-14, (specifically from the narratives about the reigns of Jehu and his dynastic successors), reconstruct the various stages of textual activity from the time of the Old Greek, and reflect on the literary growth behind the oldest reconstructable text, once the later recensional elements have been removed.
|
Methodological Issues in the Identification of Biblical Sites: The Case of Geshur
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Nicolae Roddy, Creighton University
The identification of Bethsaida (formerly et-Tell) as the capital of the biblical city of Geshur has been met with widespread tacit acceptance among scholars, reinforced most notably by Bethsaida’s chief archaeologist, Rami Arav (2004) and Nadav Na’aman (2012). Recent articles by Juha Pakkala (2010; 2013) have called this identification into question by claiming to reveal a number of methodological flaws that implicate this interpretation. This paper will: 1) analyze and evaluate the arguments on both sides of the debate; 2) locate the problem within the framework of the Bible’s unique cultural influence, affecting scholarly presuppositions about the Bible’s reliability as a historical source, and 3) suggest a set of criteria that might serve as a model for evaluating the strength of claims concerning the identification of biblical sites along a relative scale. The paper is not intended to discourage speculation in correlating biblical toponyms with archaeological sites, only to call attention to the need for increased scholarly accountability and transparency when doing so. In the interest of transparency, this abstract is being submitted by a seventeen-year co-director and area supervisor for the Bethsaida Excavations Project, who on the basis of the (lack of) evidence, does not accept the identification of Bethsaida as the capital of the Geshurite kingdom and therefore will not be arguing for such.
Arav, Rami (2004). “Towards a Comprehensive History of Geshur,” Pp. 1-48 in R. Arav, R. Freund (ed.) Bethsaida, A City Near the Northern Shores of the Sea of Galilee, vol. 3., Kirksville, MO: Truman State University Press.
Na'aman, Nadav (2012). “The Kingdom of Geshur in History and Memory,” SJOT 26:1, 88-101.
Pakkala, Juha (2010). “What Do We Know about Geshur?,” SJOT 24:2, 155-173.
_______ (2013). “The Methodological Hazards in Reconstructing the So-called Kingdom of Geshur,” SJOT 27:2, 226-246.
|
The Text of 1 Pet 4:16 in Nestle 28
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Peter Rodgers, Fuller Theological Seminary (Pasadena)
At 1 Peter 4:16 Nestle 28 prints the reading merei rather than onomati, the reading of Nestle 27. The judgment in favor of merei as respresenting the original/initial text of 1 Peter 4:16 reflects the choice of the Editio Critica Maior, which is the result of the application of the Coherence Based Genealogical Method. This paper challenges this judgment, arguing that onomati is what the author of 1 Peter wrote. This is based on several considerations. 1) Superior manuscript support for onomati. 2) Internal criteria: onoma is a key word in this section, whereas merei never occurs elsewhere in 1 Peter. 3) The temple imagery of 1 Peter, present in this passage, and the recurrent expression in the scriptures of Israel that refers to the temple as a place for God's name to dwell, points to onomati as the reading that best fits the broader narrative focus of the letter.
|
"On Gar": Dialogue in LXX Isaiah and Rom 1:18
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Daniel Rodriguez, Universiteit van Stellenbosch - University of Stellenbosch
The 'gar' in Romans 1:18 has long been a problem for interpreters. Calvin (1568) said it was unclear and modern scholars like Ward (1997) and Campbell (2009) suggest that Romans 1:18-32 is not Paul's voice. Campbell (2009) argues at length that Romans 1:18-32 is Paul's impression of a Jewish-Christian opponent with whom the apostle dialogues throughout the letter in a style that some call "Socratic". However commonly used Greek lexical and grammatical resources state that 'ga'r is a particle that logically connects one thing to another. BDAG's lexicographic description is three-part: 1) marker of cause or reason, 2) marker of clarification, and 3) marker of inference. This has led some scholars to dismiss Campbell (2009) on linguistic grounds.
However, such dismissals are premature because not all the lexical data has been accounted for. Despite the rich polysemous descriptions that lexica like BDAG and Liddell Scott offer for the particle, there is a rhetorical function that ?a? performs which our lexica have neglected. This function is one that I am tentatively calling speaker switching. In a speaker switch, the particle ?a? does not logically connect a speaker's prior argument with supporting information introduced by ?a?. Rather, in these cases, ?a? in its postposition begins a new clause in the mouth of a new or another speaker. In these cases, ?a? may still make logical connections, but not necessarily.
Evidence for speaker switching ?a? is found in Euripides' The Bacchae and in the Bible in LXX Isaiah. A handful of examples from both texts will demonstrate this function and an updated lexicographic description of the particle will be offered. Based on this usage-based explanation of ?a?, the famous occurrence of the particle in Romans 1:18 will be reconsidered. It will be shown that the linguistic arguments against Ward and Campbell's view of Romans 1:18-32 are unfounded. Actually, a usage-based approach to ?a? demonstrates the plausibility of the particle in Romans 1:18 signaling the presence of a new voice.
|
Mary, Model of Obedience: Exegetical Comparison of Lk 1:26–38 and Q. 19:16–22
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
Maria Enid Rodriguez, The Catholic University of America
A comparison of the accounts of the Annunciation in the Gospel of Luke (1:26-38) and in the Qur’an (Surah 19) reveals points of convergence and divergence that correspond to the interpretations of Mary in Catholic and Islamic traditions. In particular, this paper seeks to analyze the manner in which Mary’s response to the angel Gabriel in both accounts shapes the respective traditions. This paper will first present an overview of Luke 1:26-38 highlighting key points in the narrative pertaining to Mary. Then it will take a brief look at how Mary’s “Let it be done” (Fiat) in the Lucan Annunciation has influenced Mary’s role in Catholicism as an ideal disciple, a model of obedience, and a new Eve. The paper will continue with a presentation of Q. 19:16-22, indicating the similarities and differences between the Qur’anic and Lucan Annunciation stories regarding Mary. With an emphasis on the absence of an explicit Fiat as found in Luke, Mary’s role as understood in the context of Q. 19 demonstrates her significance as a model of obedience and submission to God. Finally, the paper will address the similar missions of the Lucan Mary and the Muslim Mary; namely, to be messengers of God’s word and provide examples of how to give oneself completely to God.
|
Explorations in the Pluri-significance of the Offering in 2 Corinthians 8 and Related Texts
Program Unit: Second Corinthians: Pauline Theology in the Making
Calvin J. Roetzel, Macalester College
Drawing on Marcel Mauss’s work on ‘gift exchange’ I plan to explore the offering in Paul's broader social and theological agenda. The agenda has much to do with the Gentile Mission, the end-time unity of the elect, Jew and Gentile categories and relationships, Gentile reciprocity for the gift of “spiritual blessings” from Jerusalem, united support for the Spanish mission, and fear of shame and humiliation if the gift is refused. Paul’s plea for support and prayers for the success of the offering was, therefore, much more than a simple request for a donation. In fact, it was a brilliant stratagem, if I am correct in my conception. It is possible that Paul and the Jerusalem core had very different perceptions of the offering’s symbolic value. These explorations, if credible, would lend support for my view that 2 Cor. 8 was first in importance and literary priority, and that 2 Cor. 9 was an apt closure even if a bit dreamy.
|
The Reproof in Matt 18:15–17 as Reintegrative Shaming and the Prayer in Matt 18:18–20 as a Ritual of Reintegration
Program Unit: Matthew
Rikard Roitto, Stockholm School of Theology
This paper uses a) contemporary research on shame and b) ritual theories to argue that Matt 18:15-20 reflects a procedure of reintegrative shaming followed by a ritual of reintegration in the form of a prayer that “loosens” the sinner from sin. The meaning of the promise that God will listen to prayers in v. 19 is debated, as is the meaning of “bind” and “loose” in v.18. Although some argue that vv. 18-20 are barely connected to the previous instruction to reprove a sinning brother in vv. 15-17, recurring catchwords and sentence structures indicate that the Matthean redactor intended vv. 15-20 to be read as a unit, and thus the prayer in vv. 18-20 to follow up on the reproof-practice in the previous verses. If so, the prayer is a reintegrative ritual that publicly loosens the sin from the sinner who has listened to the reproof and the power to bind and loosen is power to remit sin, not merely the authority to make halakhic decision valid in heaven. This interpretation, I argue, makes sense in the light of several ritual theories. I argue a) with the help of research on shame, that the reproof procedure in vv. 15-17 is optimized to be “reintegrative” rather than “disintegrative” shaming; b) with the help of the ritual form hypothesis (Lawson & McCauley) that the Matthean community indeed believed that their prayers could have the power to bind or loosen sin; c) with the help of Jens Schjødt’s taxanomy of rituals that the ritual is best understood as a crisis-ritual, which moves the patient from a negative to a neutral state; and d) with the help of Roy Rappaport’s distinction between “self-referential” and “canonical” (theological) information in rituals that the ritual both sent self-referential information about the communal status of the patient and canonical information about the empowered and forgiving/forgiven nature of the community.
|
Perception of Risk in the Sermon on the Mount
Program Unit: Cognitive Science Approaches to the Biblical World
Rikard Roitto, Stockholm School of Theology
The Sermon on the Mount (SM) alters the perception of risk in several ways as a strategy to convince its audience that it is worthwhile to take the risks involved in practicing the dangerous ethics of the sermon. This paper discussed how contemporary research on the perception of risk can help us understand a) how and whether the SM convinces its readers, and b) what effect the SM might have had on the Matthean community. There are several competing research paradigms in research on the perception of risk: behavioural economics, psychometrics, cultural theory of risk, and the Social Amplification of Risk Framework (SARF). All these models help us understand different aspects of how the SM might have functioned to alter perception of risk among its hearers in the Matthean community.
|
Inventing Tradition in Thessalonica
Program Unit: North American Association for the Study of Religion
Sarah Rollens, University of Alabama
The socio-ethnic constitution of the Thessalonian ekklesia is notoriously difficult to pin down, but one consistently argued position is that the group was comprised largely of Gentiles. The only passage that presents a problem for this theory is 1 Thess 2:14-16. Rather than focus on philological and theological issues to identify whether this passage is “Pauline” or not, this paper treats 1 Thess 2:14-16 as an “invented tradition” (à la Eric Hobsbawm and Terence Ranger) in the letter which links the social experience of the Thessalonians to the nascent ekklesia in Judaea. Instead of acting as a mouthpiece for Paul’s theology concerning Jews, the point of this passage may instead be to invent a coherent “past” for the Thessalonians, who may have had few other social features in common upon which to base their group identity. By appropriating an “already in place” framework for identity (Deuteronomistic theology) and by connecting the Thessalonians’ experience to both the ekklesia in Jerusalem, as well as to past prophets, 1 Thess 2:14-16 attaches the Thessalonians to an identity that extends beyond their local group. If the passage is not an interpolation, then we see even more clearly how Paul does not simply “found communities,” but rather brings these group identities into being through the process of writing and negotiating their concerns. This is in fact the strategy of social formation that we see in numerous other cross-cultural cases, wherein mediating intellectual figures align the interests of a diverse constituency into a coherent ideological framework.
|
Reflections on Q and Scribalism
Program Unit: Q
Sarah E. Rollens, University of Alabama
An increasingly popular social identification for Q’s authors is that they were (perhaps formerly) some sort of scribal or administrative figures. This follows from observations about the content and form of the text. This identification nevertheless remains difficult to flesh out. While there have been some noteworthy studies that try to outline the variety of scribes and their roles in antiquity, many of their typologies are at odds with one another, and importantly, few have considered the social experiences of different kinds of scribes. This paper explains that there are many challenges to the identification of the Q people as scribes, stemming from several interrelated factors, including (1) the lack of clear evidence for education or formal training of these figures, especially when considered in all their varieties, (2) the fact that it interrupts idealized views of oral tradition being the driving force of the movement, and (3) the fact that scribes appear to have been figures of ambiguous social location, a realization which defies our attempts to sort Graeco-Roman society into neat horizontal categories. By recognizing the challenges inherent in studying scribes thus far, though, we can work towards a new understanding of how their social experiences may have affected the composition of Q.
|
Freedom of Religion and Academic Freedom: Symphony and Cacophony in Confessional Higher Education
Program Unit: Metacriticism of Biblical Scholarship
Christopher Rollston, George Washington University
The American Association of University Professors (AAUP) has described and defined the basic contours of academic freedom within higher education. This definition is careful, refined, and reasonable. Included within the AAUP framework are statements regarding the proper contours of, and the necessity of, due process (including the appeal process). Many institutions, including some confessional ones, have used the AAUP statement as a benchmark within faculty handbooks. Confessional schools, however, will sometimes have dogmatic claims to which faculty must subscribe (either in writing or orally). Furthermore, within some confessional schools, religious dogmas are often understood to trump all things, including academic freedom. Some of these confessional schools have something called faculty-tenure and some do not. Moreover, some of these confessional schools will hold Regional Accreditation (e.g., SACS, NCACS, WACS), some will hold accreditation with the Association of Theological Schools (ATS), some will hold both, some will hold neither. Within this presentation, it will be suggested that accrediting organizations begin to delineate two primary categories of accreditation, namely, "Signatory to the AAUP Statement on Academic Freedom" and "Non-Signatory to the AAUP Statement on Academic Freedom." This sort of "truth in advertising" will be useful for faculty, staff, students, administrators, and trustees, as well as the academic schools of higher education of which they are a part.
|
Joshua 23 and Its Place in the Book of Joshua
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Thomas Römer, Université de Lausanne
Joshua’s first farewell speech in Josh 23 has been the subject of renewed scholarly attention. This text is significant because of its many parallels with other key passages at the end of the book of Joshua and the beginning of Judges, such as, e.g., Josh 21:43-45, Josh 24 and Judg 2-3 (Judg 2:11-3:6 in particular). This observation suggests, in turn, that Josh 23 played a strategic role in the “book-ending” of Joshua and the transition from Joshua to Judges. In dialogue with other recent studies, the present paper will revisit some central aspects of the composition of Josh 23, with a focus on three issues: (a) the compositional unity/disunity of that chapter; (b) its relation to Josh 21-24 and Judg 2-3; and (c) the relation betwen Josh 23 and 24 and the transition between Joshua and Judges. The paper will argue that the revisional layer of Josh 23 is preparing the book of Judges, as part of the same (dtr) library. Josh 24, however, seeks to define the relation between Joshua and Judges quite differently.
|
The Revelation of the Divine Name to Moses and "Mnemohistory"
Program Unit: Orality, Textuality, and the Formation of the Hebrew Bible
Thomas Römer, Collège de France - Université de Lausanne
The non-priestly and priestly stories in Exodus 3:1-4:18 and 6:2-8 agree on the idea that the name of the God of Israel was not revealed to the Hebrews before the time of Moses. In the context of the construction of the Pentateuch both texts underline somewhat differently Moses’ role as mediator, who after the fall of Jerusalem becomes a substitute for royal mediation (although the royal image of Moses was already invented in the seventh century BCE). Both texts are not older than the sixth century, but they may conserve the historical memory that Yhwh has not always been the god of “Israel”.
|
Space, Place, and the Race for Power: Rabbis, Demons, and the Construction of Babylonia
Program Unit: History and Literature of Early Rabbinic Judaism
Sara Ronis, Yale University
In this paper, I examine how the Babylonian rabbis “thought with” demons in order to organize their environment and imbue with them with larger spatial meanings. The rabbis of Sasanian Babylonia lived in both urban and rural environments. Not simply collections of homes and fields, these environments were central to rabbinic identity formation. Michel De Certeau distinguishes between place – a point on a map – and space, place as it is lived and experienced by those who inhabit and pass through it (1984). The Babylonian rabbis produced space through legal discourse, and demons were an important part of this legal construction of place as space.
Through close readings of the Babylonian Talmud in conversation with the Palestinian Talmud, I demonstrate the centrality of demons to rabbinic legal constructions of their environment. The rabbis overlay their landscape with visible and invisible dangers that only they were qualified to control. I argue that the Babylonian rabbis used demonic presence and absence in order to prioritize urban living, and to construct themselves as the true experts in dealing with demons in opposition to their Palestinian rabbinic colleagues.
“Thinking with” demons gives these rabbis control—control over their competition with their Palestinian counterparts, control over the physical world through rabbinic law, and control over other people within their religious group through claims to elite status. Through their discussions of demons, the rabbis used rabbinic law to construct themselves as an urban religious elite with the power to impose their imaginings on the community and their environment.
|
Virginity, Sexual Violence, and the Sabbath: The Sabbath as a Day of Ideal Behavior
Program Unit: Sabbath in Text and Tradition
Michael Rosenberg, Hebrew College
Rabbinic literature provides and intimates a variety of models for thinking about the Sabbath, including such well known paradigms as the Sabbath-as-Tabernacle, the Sabbath as a day of refraining from labor, and the Sabbath as a day of cultivating human relationship with the divine. In this paper, I will articulate another model implicit in a number of rabbinic passages: the Sabbath as a day on which it is possible to hold humans to a higher standard than is normally feasible. That is, many rabbinic laws about the Sabbath are best explained as attempts by rabbinic legislators to encourage a standard that, ideally, they would maintain at all times, but which, in a concession to realities such as communal pressures and human nature, they limit specifically to the Sabbath. Following a brief framing of rabbinic laws around healing and participation in athletic events as manifestations of this model of the Sabbath, I will turn to a difficult passage in Tractate Ketubot of the Babylonian Talmud in which the rabbis, in my reading, attempt to discourage male sexual aggression specifically on the Sabbath. In the broader of context of this particular tractate, this pericope reflects a rabbinic wrestling with male sexual aggression. It consequently also reflects a use of the Sabbath as a point in time in which to live by a legal standard that, ideally, the rabbinic authors would want at all times, but which, for reasons to be explored, they cannot or will not impose at all times.
|
Giorgio Agamben and Philology as Paradigmatology: The Case of Laughter in Genesis
Program Unit: Philology in Hebrew Studies
Bruce Rosenstock, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
In a little-known but very suggestive work, The Signature of All Things: On Method (2008), Giorgio Agamben describes a method of philological analysis that draws from sources as diverse as Plato, Paracelsus, J. W. v. Goethe, Aby Warburg, Walter Benjamin, and Michel Foucault. My presentation will describe the philological method proposed by Agamben and offer an example of how it might be applied to the Hebrew Bible. I will suggest how laughter in Genesis functions in much the same way that Agamben says "homo sacer" does, as a "paradigm whose role is to constitute and make intelligible a broader historical-problematic context."
|
Paul and the Law in 1 Corinthians
Program Unit: Scripture and Paul
Brian Rosner, Ridley Melbourne
Paul’s letters present both negative critique and positive approval of the law. How this tension is resolved distinguishes studies of Paul and the law. This paper looks at the relatively neglected evidence in 1 Corinthians, both what Paul says about the law and what he does with it. The subject is opened up with a study of Paul’s apparently paradoxical words in 1 Corinthians 7:19, a verse described by James Dunn as “very instructive” for debates about the law. Attention is also paid to Paul’s famous missionary strategy in chapter 9 (“all things to all people”), where he claims to be able to live both under the law and outside the law, depending on his context, and Paul’s use of Torah, especially Deuteronomy, in various parts of the letter for Christology and ethics. The tension between Paul’s negative evaluation and positive appropriation of the law in the letter can be resolved by recognizing that Paul reads the law not as ongoing legal demand, but as prophecy of the gospel and as wisdom for living.
|
Explaining the "Turning Point" in Muslim Biblical Scholarship: Why Did al-Biqa’i Decide to Use the Bible to Interpret the Qur’an?
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
Samuel Ross, Yale University
In the judgment of many observers, the extensive and multi-faceted engagement with the Biblical text of the controversial MamlÅ«k exegete, historian, hadith scholar, and poet, IbrahÄ«m ibn Ê¿Umar al-BiqÄÊ¿Ä« (d. 885/1480) appears to mark a turning point in Muslim exegetical history. Prior to him, Muslims almost never consulted the Bible to interpret the Qur’an. In the five centuries following his death, the practice would eventually become ubiquitous.
How and why did this shift take place? What were BiqÄʿī’s motivations for turning to the Bible, a practice sufficiently controversial in his day as to merit his lengthy treatise in defense of doing so? Despite excellent studies by Walid Saleh, Li Guo, and Eric Ormsby, the study of BiqÄÊ¿Ä« is still in its infancy and many such important questions remain unanswered.
My paper attempts to advance our understanding of Biqa’I’s motivations for employing the Bible by situating his approach within the Mamlūk intellectual and literary milieus in which he operated. I note potentially influential developments in other Islamic sciences and in Arabic literature, consider the example of his teachers and other commentators whom he quotes, and explore the potential impact of changing relations between the Christian and Muslim worlds. In so doing, I seek to enrich our understanding of this turning point in Muslim exegetical history and to explore whether some of these explanatory factors remain relevant for explaining the near omnipresent usage of the Bible by exegetes today.
|
The Divergent Battle Language in LXX-Judges: Polemeo and Paratasso
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
William A. Ross, University of Cambridge
J. A. L. Lee’s 1970 doctoral thesis, A Lexical Study of the Septuagint Version of the Pentateuch, remains a landmark in LXX studies, and its conclusions have largely come to be taken for granted. As some have observed, however, Lee’s methodology remains undeveloped, despite its potential for shedding light on the translation and dating of LXX books. The task of comparing LXX Greek with contemporary Koine documentary evidence in papyri and inscriptions, moreover, has been greatly simplified since Lee’s work due to the development of searchable electronic databases, now populated with even more evidence than Lee had at hand.
Following up on the author’s previous work in this area, then, this paper will pursue lexical study, specifically in the double-text of LXX-Judges (A & B). The two texts present a unique avenue for comparison against contemporary Koine usage in that their lexical stock in large part can be aligned and contrasted. Where a single Hebrew lexeme is consistently translated with different Greek lexemes in the A and B texts of Judges, research in documentary evidence can shed light on the reason for the alternative renderings. The focus of this paper will fall on just such a situation in the translational choices for battle language in the A and B texts. In A, polemos and polemeo occur 14x and 31x, respectively, whereas in B only 3x and 7x. Conversely, in B parataxis and paratasso occur 17x and 24x, respectively, while in A only 1x and 6x. In battle contexts, 40 out of 52 instances of either lexeme is directly substituted by the other in the opposing text (in most of the remainder, polemos/polemeo occurs in both texts). This paper will therefore pursue the textual, chronological, and/or literary light shed by research in Koine documentary evidence upon the apparent lexical substitution of these words and their respective texts.
|
Midwives, Mimicry, and Multivalence: A Postcolonial Analysis of Identity Politics in Exod 1:17–19
Program Unit: Postcolonial Studies and Biblical Studies
Federico A. Roth, Azusa Pacific University
It is customary for postcolonial biblical critics to dismiss the book of Exodus as the tale of a tyrannical and genocidal deity. This paper attempts to correct such an impulse by redeploying the postcolonial approach in a way that seeks to more authentically realize the field’s great multidisciplinary potential.
Especially with regard to identity ideology and formation, the discussion offers a critical rereading of the story’s introductory narratives (Exod 1). I argue that the early stories of Exodus go beyond a simplistic caricaturing of the evil empire set against the valiant midwives. The opening of Exodus offers greater complexity insofar as it initiates a reassessment of human existence as impacted by the forces of estrangement and exclusion. Of primary importance is the Pharaoh-midwives interchange which forms the climax of the chapter (1:17-19). Methodologically, the paper employs a mélange of critical approaches ranging from linguistic, to literary, and chiefly, postcolonial. Homi Bhabha’s analysis of identity formation via the categories of mimicry, ambivalence, thirdspace, and hybridity offer especially illuminating insights that form a counterweight to the rigid identity politics of empire under the Pharaoh of 1:8. A pair of hybridic human figures frustrate Pharaoh’s collectivist and intransigent identity politics. In Shiphrah and Puah difference is recast as an element to be celebrated and cultivated, not rejected and reviled. Thus, the mimicking resistance of the midwives in Exod 1 promotes the virtue of conceiving identity as a pliable, polyvalent, variable reality to be sought after by all parties caught in the dehumanizing discourse of colonial subjugation.
|
Baptist Influence on the Johannine Jesus
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Clare K. Rothschild, Lewis University
This paper analyzes the Fourth Gospel’s depiction of John the Baptist and his followers as a lens through which to understand the Johannine presentation of Jesus. Scholars such as Raymond Brown have inferred several dialectical engagements between John’s gospel and late first and early second century followers of the Baptist. This paper pursues these and other possibilities with the aim of understanding how the Johannine Jesus—representing an amalgam of influences—incorporates engagements with contemporary followers of the Baptist as an important factor.
|
"Who Sinned?" The Man Born Blind, Sin, and the Physiognomic Conciousness
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Robert M Rowland, Claremont Graduate University
The Bible has been the most influential book in Western culture, and has shaped our views of many social and cultural norms. It has been referenced in regards to sexuality, gender, and race, just to name a few. However, more recently studies have come to the fore which look at how the authors of the Bible construct notions of disability, and how the biblical authors' perception of disability has influenced modern views of how we understand not only who is disabled, but how we as a culture interact and treat those who have impairments.
In this presentation I will be looking at one small part of the Bible, the story of "the man born blind" in the Gospel of John. It is a very well-known story even today, and the ways in which the author of the gospel constructs a narrative around this healing story continues to resonate in modern society. Taking a transdisciplinary approach between biblical studies and disability studies, I will look at how the author pulls upon a well known "physiognomic consciousness" to talk about the intersection of sin and disability in the ancient world. Physiognomy, the idea that an outward appearance is controlled by interior forces, created a widely known concept that a person with impairment must be evil or sinful in the ancient world. This had many implications for the author of the gospel, but also for his community who would have had to reconcile the concept of sin leading to disability, but also to Jesus' rebuttal and revision of it with his own potentially problematic understanding of the man's impairment. The author takes the idea and runs with it, weaving together a story which is keenly representative of the theology of the fourth gospel. Through this investigation potential alternative understandings of disability in narrative and in lived realities can be explored.
|
The Neglected Texts in the Oxyrhynchus Papyrus of Philo
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
James R. Royse, Independent Scholar
One of the earliest witnesses to the text of Philo of Alexandria is the remains of a papyrus codex from Oxyrhynchus, dated to the third century. These remains are divided among Oxford, Copenhagen, and Florence, and have been published as P.Oxy. 9.1173, 11.1356, 18.2158; P.Haun. 8; and PSI 11.1207. Despite the damaged condition of the folios, sufficient text survives to allow identification of (at least some of) the original contents. Fragments of six of Philo’s extant works are found, and provide important textual evidence. Of particular interest is the fact that some fragments of an otherwise completely unknown work are preserved. (Indeed, there is some evidence that more than one
such work is involved.) These fragments have been almost entirely neglected in Philonic studies.
The folios containing this unknown work (or works) are found in Oxford and Copenhagen. This paper will report on what can be read of these fragments, based on a fresh examination of the material. Despite the limited amount of text that remains, these fragments still preserve very interesting material, including some quotations from classical writers. And there is the striking coincidence, discovered many years ago by Ludwig Früchtel, that a citation from Philo as found in a manuscript of the Sacra parallela overlaps a text now preserved in one of the folios in Oxford.
|
The Text of Philo’s De Decalogo
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
James R. Royse, Claremont, CA
This paper will examine the manuscript evidence for Philo’s treatise De Decalogo. Particular attention will be given to the oldest manuscript, Vaticanus gr. 316, which was investigated by Cohn only after the publication of the critical edition of De Decalogo. Although Cohn devoted an article to this ms., he seems to have concentrated on its text of the works in Cohn-Wendland vol. 5, for which he could still cite the ms., rather than on its text of the already edited works. Thus, a more detailed look at that ms. is warranted.
Another area of emphasis will be the evidence supplied by various collections of extracts and by citations in the catena on Luke by Nicetas. This secondary evidence often provides valuable readings.
|
The Renewed Perspective: Post-supersessionism: A Hermeneutical Course Correction 1700 Years in the Making
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
David Rudolph, Messianic Jewish Theological Institute
In the late fourth century Jerome wrote to Augustine, “While they desire to be both Jews and Christians, they are neither one or the other”. This was the culmination of a reading strategy that excluded Jewish identity from the ekklesia and severed the vital link between Torah observant Jesus-believing Jews and Gentile Christians. After the fourth century there is little mention in Gentile Christian literature of Messianic Jewish communities like the kind Jerome described until the eighteenth century, and it is only with the emergence of a new school of thought in the late twentieth century, sometimes referred to as “post-supersessionism”, that the Gentile wing of the ekklesia is beginning to reconsider its strategies for reading the Scriptures of Israel to better understand the Israel of the Scriptures. While there were precursors to this renewed perspective, Introduction to Messianic Judaism presents an historically grounded and theologically nuanced approach to interpreting New Testament literature that preserves, affirms and celebrates Jewish identity alongside non-Jewish identity in the Messiah. This New Testament vision of a multi-ethnic ekklesia reflects a renewed perspective on Jewish identity that posits: (1) God’s covenant relationship with the Jewish people is past, present and future, (2) The Jewish people have a distinctive role and priority in God’s redemptive plan through the Messiah, (3) By God’s design and calling, there is a continuing distinction between Jew and Gentile in the ekklesia today, and (4) For Jews, this distinction takes the shape of Torah observance as an expression of covenant faithfulness to the God of Israel. This paper will present examples of interpretations of New Testament passages from this renewed perspective that are discussed in the second half of Introduction to Messianic Judaism
|
Reading Paul in (Institutional) Context: What Differences Does It Make?
Program Unit: Paul within Judaism
Anders Runesson, McMaster University
*
|
Reconsidering the Discourse Function of the Greek Perfect: Romans as a Test Case
Program Unit: Applied Linguistics for Biblical Languages
Steven E. Runge, Logos Bible Software and University of Stellenbosc
Porter (1989, 2009) has associated the Greek Perfect the frontground plane of discourse the action based on its marked aspect. Although there is a typological correlation of Perfect aspect with the marking an action as particularly relevant, the Perfect is most often associated with salient offline material. These findings were preliminarily corroborated in Runge (2013), which described the discourse function of the Greek Perfect indicatives in Luke's gospel. The study found that the majority of Perfect indicatives (44/60) conveyed offline material which was relevant to a mainline assertion. The Perfect either immediately preceded that to which it was relevant, or it followed in a syntactically or logically dependent clause. The only clearly mainline instances of the Perfect indicative in Luke were found at the beginning of reported speeches that responded to the preceding speech or situation. Only this minority of instances (16/60) could possibly be construed as accomplishing the frontgrounding function Porter asserts. The goal of the present study is to test these findings on a non-narrative corpus, one which is essentially monologic in nature. The Perfect indicatives found in the SBLGNT text of Romans will be classified based on their grounding role and contribution to the discourse. Parameters for distinguishing offline Perfects from mainline uses will also be proposed.
|
Principles for Understanding the Function of Redundant Forms of Direct Address
Program Unit:
Steven E. Runge, Logos Bible Software & Stellenbosch University
One often finds semantically redundant forms of direct address (e.g. ""brother"") in the NT epistles. Although use of these forms by NT writers represents a pragmatic choice there is little discussion of what motivates their use or of their exegetical value. Most descriptions treat them as structural markers of discourse units, corresponding to paragraph boundaries. However, many vocatives in the Greek NT text occur within paragraphs or even clauses, calling the traditional account into question. This presentation introduces linguistic principles which can explain the use of direct address in the GNT and its function within the larger discourse. Representative examples from the Pauline corpus are used to illustrate the exegetical value of redundant forms of direct address. Participants will then have an opportunity apply these principles in small groups to the instances found in the epistle of James.
|
Psalm 139 and Its Affects
Program Unit: Bible and Emotion
Erin Runions, Pomona College
A methodological paper introducing Affect Theory and exploring its potential intersection with Biblical Studies, with particular application to Psalm 139.
|
Waterlings from Water: Exploring a Cosmological Reading of “Living Water” in John 4:4–42 amidst the Braided Rivers of Canterbury, Aotearoa New Zealand
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Kathleen Rushton, Catholic Institute of Aotearoa New Zealand
Previously, I have argued that the cosmological horizon of the prologue of the gospel of according to John and that of readers informed by twenty-first century cosmologies and evolutionary biology may meet to inspire a transforming spirituality and ethical action in the urgent ecological concerns of the present day. The prologue espouses a cosmology, which evokes biblical and Hellenistic cosmologies, to set forth its own cosmological framework of the interconnection of the divine, the cosmic, the flesh (sárx) and “all things” (pánta) as a framework for the rest of this gospel. This paper extends that theological, cosmological, rhetorical reading to the “living waters” of Jn 4:4-42. My interpretation is set within contemporary approaches of ecological hermeneutics. However, I understand a wider cosmological framework is necessary for John’s gospel and for my earth-quake affected context of the Otautahi Christchurch, Aotearoa New Zealand. To counter anthropocentric and Christocentric readings which accentuate redemption and tend to separate this from creation and the cosmic, I use a hermeneutical lens from the French philosopher, Rémi Brague’s study of ancient and medieval cosmologies. This lens 1) articulates the link between cosmology and the human person; 2) considers “the world” as the resting place for humanity; 3) links cosmology to wisdom; and 4) leads to contemplation (theoria) as the precursor to ethical action. This paper aims to contribute to building a bridge between contemporary cosmological and scientific understandings of water and aspects of Johannine water symbolism. “Living water” is considered in the light of the Sheckem being an area of conflict related to water, an early Christian fresco, the Jacob traditions and two terms used for water: “still water” (Jn 4:11-12 phrear) and “living water” as from a spring (vv. 6, 14 pege). My hope is to offer a scriptural voice among the many voices raised in my province of Canterbury, Aotearoa New Zealand where water “rights,” access to water, its use and storage are contested.
|
Where Does the Bible Come From?
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Ruth Finnegan, The Open University
Where does the Bible come from? In what mode does it exist? Simple and all too familiar questions but leading us into profound questions of our era. This paper will survey the scope and intent of some of the many well-worn and illuminating theories of the Bible's origin and existence, relating them in particular first to the writer's background in a Presbyterian Ulster childhood, biblically text-rooted Quaker school, Oxford classical studies, and the experience of living and learning as an anthropological participant in four continents of the oikoumene, that beautiful Greek word for the inhabited world, and, second, to the wonderful life and learning of Werner Kelber. The final part of the paper ventures into uncharted and somewhat dangerous territory.
|
Insecurity, Wrath, and the God of Hope: Reading Paul’s Apocalyptic Gospel in the Roman World
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Scott Ryan, Baylor University
This presentation represents an interdisciplinary approach that seeks to explore the anxieties that plagued those in the Greco-Roman world of the first century CE and the way in which Paul’s gospel in Romans might offer hope and assurance to early Christian groups in this context. In contrast to the peace and prosperity proclaimed in Roman propaganda, life for many in the first century was not utopian. Rather than peace and security, evidence from the material world reveals that many maintained anxiety over the suprahuman realm. In order to explore this aspect of the ancient world, this presentation will utilize archaeological findings from the towns of Pompeii and Herculaneum – two locations buried under volcanic ash from Mt. Vesuvius in 79 CE – in order to provide insight into life in an urban Roman context. Inscriptions, graffiti, and shrines reveal that warding off evil served as a prominent concern in day-to-day life. For example, phallic symbols, mosaics of dogs, and shrines to a number of deities can be found in households, businesses, and liminal spaces such as entryways in order to repel evil and bring good luck. This material offers a helpful lens through which to read Paul’s letter to the Romans with respect to hope and the defeat of cosmic forces. The apostle’s apocalyptic gospel in Romans provides a counter to such anxieties over the suprahuman in the ancient world. Paul indicates that Sin and Death enslave humanity (Rom 3:9-20; 6:1-23; 8:18-30) and cosmic forces seek to draw people away from the love of God (Rom 8:31-39); however, according to Paul, God’s action in Jesus’ death and resurrection liberates humanity from captivity to these oppressive forces and empowers to live in light of God’s ultimate victory in the future (Rom 3:21-26; 5:1-21; 6:15-23; 8:9-17; 16:20).
|
Teaching Tanakh, New Testament, and Qur'an to Undergraduate English Majors and Elective Students
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
Roberta Sabbath, University of Nevada, Las Vegas
Today, students at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas (UNLV) are fascinated with a literary comparatist approach to the three sacred Abrahamic texts. Learners vary from those who have never read any of the sacred texts, to those who have gone through primary and secondary education in sectarian schools, to students who have continued to study the works even past their high school matriculation. Most students are immersed in popular culture, whether movies or written texts, that draw heavily on sacred text and on mythology. So they are fascinated with the themes and characters that show up outside of the classroom in these cultural productions. Traditionally the Bible as Literature class has included the Tanakh or Hebrew Bible and the New Testament. This is the first class at our university to incorporate all three Abrahamic sacred texts as part of the curriculum. Students have been enthusiastic as they approach the readings and analysis.
Teaching the three sacred texts as literature using a comparatist methodology has many advantages. Students learn ways to think of the intersections of the three sacred texts instead of the divergence that these three texts usually bring up. The experiential nature of the teaching classroom allows for students to voice their questions and share their epiphanies as the curriculum roles out. The methodology draws on structural and formal ways that students have likely experienced through their secondary and undergraduate education: close reading; literary theory including gender, class, race, social, economic, and historical; textual criticism incorporating historical, anthropological, and cultural contexts that determine the production of these texts.
The curriculum builds around the historicity of the divine and its connection to literary production. Beginning with the introduction of the Paleolithic and early Neolithic worship of the goddess, curriculum develops through the multi-layered ideas of divinity expressed in the Tanakh, incorporating the diverse epistemological lenses; New Testament curriculum builds on the evolution of ideologies expressed through the literary language of the Tanakh, morphing into New Testament expression and ideology; once students have arrived at the study of the Qur’an, they have a rich tool kit with which to examine its literary richness, including canonicity, historical context, literary traditions, and, key, the biblical subtexts that inform so much of Qur’anic expression.
Two works have been especially helpful in guiding the development of this course: Gabriel Said Reynolds The Qur’an and Its Biblical Subtext (Routledge 2010) and John C. Reeves, ed., Bible and Qur’an: Essays in Scriptural Intertextuality (SBL 2003). However, many essays regarding all three sacred texts reflecting the most recent biblical and Qur’anic research are interwoven into the class as each student is assigned a different essay to summarize for the class, related to each the three sacred text. Student work also incorporates a comparatist paper and is presented to the class. Classroom pedagogy makes considerable use of online resources including interlinear translations of all three sacred texts, historical artifacts and art as well as biographies and literary works associated with the sacred texts.
|
Israel and the Angels: Emulation, Rivalry, and Embodiment
Program Unit: Midrash
Steven Sacks, Cornell College
Head of a session entitled "Israel and the Angels: Emulation, Rivalry and Embodiment." In Midrash and related literatures, Israel (both patriarch and nation) exhibits a complex relationship with angels, characterized by emulation in divine service, rivalry in worship, and even shared embodiment in the divine throne. This panel will explore the rabbinic conception of Israel's national and angelic identities, and address the relationship among the nation, patriarch and heavenly beings.
|
Revisiting 2 Samuel 10: Old Greek vs. "kaige" in Codex Vaticanus
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Richard Saley, Harvard University
Those holding that the "kaige" section labeled "beta-gamma" by Thackeray (2 Sam 11:2 - 1 Kgs 2:11) actually begins at 2 Sam 10:1 give the lack of the historical present in chapter 10 as one of the reasons. A computer driven study of all of the verbs, in all of the manuscripts utilized by the Larger Cambridge Septuagint, for all of 2 Sam 1:1 - 1 Kgs 2:11 casts doubt on the suitability of this criterion for 2 Sam 10.
|
The Hebrew Bible in the Jewish Enlightenment: A Case Study
Program Unit: History of Interpretation
Dorothea M. Salzer, Universität Potsdam
In 1816, Immanuel Moritz Neumann – schoolmaster at the Königliche Wilhelmsschule in Breslau – published the first part of his "sefer torat ha-elohim", an abridged version of the Hebrew Bible. The book was intended to be the textbook for teaching religion and Hebrew at this very school. One may understand "sefer torat ha-elohim" as the practical realisation of Neumann’s more theoretical considerations about the use of the Hebrew Bible in schools and synagogues he had published only one year earlier in 1815. In this study, he argued strongly for the compilation of a crestomathy of the Hebrew Bible, thus, putting the study of Hebrew in the established context of teaching and learning of ancient languages like Latin and Greek.
Against this background, the paper will present Neumann’s book as part of a new genre of Jewish literature: Biblical storybooks for children. These were created by maskilic pedagogues in order to introduce Jewish children to the Hebrew language (see, for example, Peter Beer’s "toledot jisra'el", 1796). Within this genre, "torat ha-elohim" represents a rather unusual example, for it uses the actual Biblical text rather than paraphrases of the Biblical accounts. Special attention will be given to the poetic strategies and techniques used by Neumann to shorten and to reinterpret the Hebrew text.
|
Priests and Levites in the Book of Joshua
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Harald Samuel, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
There is a broad consensus in biblical scholarship that the book of Joshua contains valuable historical information. The question remains, however, about what. The manifold propositions for historical localisations, e.g., of the geographical lists, show the difficulties implicated in direct historiographical interpretation. Literary historical analyses, which faded into the background in recent years, are naturally no less controversial.
The long known problems notwithstanding, I will argue in favour of the primacy of a literary analysis. Despite the uncertainties in many details, some tendencies of development can clearly be shown, which are of importance for the question of the inner coherence of the so called “Deuteronomistic History” and which may enlighten the topic of priests and Levites as well: Initially, the cultic personnel in the book of Joshua play only a minor role, although a basic affinity to Deuteronomic positions can be discerned. The final form, however, is characterised by substantial priestly-Aaronic revisions that show close connections to late Fortschreibungen in the book of Numbers.
These results do not allow for a direct grasp of history: Literary historical analysis certainly “is not enough,” yet it fosters insight into the Trägerkreise standing behind the textual development, their interests and interplay of forces. Unsatisfying as this may be, due to the historicising mantling of the biblical texts, there is no other way into the history of “Israel” if we want to employ these texts as sources.
|
Persuasion Strategies in Letters and Prayers from the Ancient Levant
Program Unit: Israelite Religion in Its Ancient Context
Paul Sanders, Protestantse Theologische Universiteit Amsterdam
In the ancient Near East, supplicants formulated letters and prayers with specific purposes. They wanted to convince the addressees and to change their minds, irrespective of whether the addressees were human or divine. This paper describes the conspicuous similarities between the ways in which people tried to convince superiors in their letters, and the persuasion strategies of their prayers. The textual evidence is taken from the Levant including the Hebrew Bible. The paper shows some innovative implications for the interpretation of the Biblical prayers.
|
Colometric Divisions: Which One Is Best?
Program Unit: Masoretic Studies
Paul Sanders, Protestantse Theologische Universiteit
Virtually all editions of the Hebrew Bible have special layouts for poetic sections such as the book of Psalms. The blank spaces and line breaks indicate a division of the text into cola. In the Dead Sea Scrolls and the oldest codices of the Hebrew Bible, colometric layouts are common for Psalms, Job 3:3–42:6, and Proverbs, but also for Exodus 15:1–19, Deuteronomy 32:1–43, Judges 5, 2 Samuel 22, and 1 Chronicles 16:8–36. Although scholars like Mordechai Breuer and Dominique Barthélemy suggested that these ancient colometric divisions should be studied more extensively, most scholars and editions - including BHQ - disregard them completely.
This paper shows that it is useful to compare the oldest colometric layouts of the Hebrew Bible, because they reflect the exegetical insights of the ancient scribes. The copyists made conscious decisions when distributing the text over the lines. When their divisions differ from each other, it is often possible to explain the divergences and to draw exegetical conclusions. The paper is based on a thorough analysis of all the colometric divisions in the oldest medieval codices (Aleppo Codex, Leningrad Codex, Cairo Codex, Damascus Pentateuch, the Babylonian Ketuvim codex Ec1) as well as some of the Dead Sea Scrolls.
|
Why the Torah Is Not a Theological Document: Pentateuchal Composition as Scholarly Collection
Program Unit: Book History and Biblical Literatures
Seth L. Sanders, Trinity College - Hartford
Contrary to previous attempts to explain the Pentateuch's editing through analogy with Mesopotamian literary works such as the Gilgamesh epic, the Pentateuch does not formally resemble any standard Babylonian literary text. While Babylonian narratives are coherent, with events happening only once, the Pentateuch is distinctively incoherent, with many key events happening in two or more incompatible ways. By contrast, the Pentateuch's clearest formal features are most strongly analogous to ancient Near Eastern scholarly collections, which often include variant versions of "the same" contents. While the Pentateuch's thoroughgoing interweaving of preexisting literary compositions has no real 'empirical models' in the sense of direct pre-Hellenistic Near Eastern parallels, it was most plausibly produced through a set of text-building moves parallel to those of contemporary first-millennium scribal cultures. The striking differences result from the different source materials Judean scholars drew on and the distinctive literary values they applied, values that are themselves clues to the nature of Pentateuchal composition. The Pentateuch stands in sharp contrast to its Judahite building blocks, which do resemble other Near Eastern literature, and its Jewish descendants, which struggle to make coherent theological claims out of their interweaving. The deliberate and non-hierarchical juxtaposition of incompatible legal and literary claims about God and the order of the universe make the Torah a scholarly collection, not a theological document--but one that was intended for a public rather than a court.
|
The Primeval History and Ancient Hebrew Philology in the Persian Period
Program Unit: Philology in Hebrew Studies
Seth L. Sanders, Trinity College - Hartford
It has long been noted that biblical authors did not typically sign their work. Most worked as participants in a stream of tradition that is to us frustratingly fluid, where contributors anonymously reshaped existing texts. While most major works of biblical literature are products of this anonymous, fluid "authorship," from the narratives of Samuel to the prophecies of Isaiah, the Pentateuch is the most challenging because it also breaks with it. The Primeval History of Genesis 1-11 is a clear example of how the Pentateuch departs from this common biblical mode of transmission. Here one previously reshaped, complete and coherent strand has then been taken and interwoven with another, sharply different but coherent strand. While literarily obvious, this departure has never been satisfyingly theorized as philology: what new kind of textual transmission does it represent? What history of text-building and reading practices was it part of?
The goal of this panel is to find ways to answer Sheldon Pollock's call: "If we are ever to make an argument for philology’s disciplinary identity, coherence, and necessity, it must be now." This paper responds with evidence addressing a rather large gap in his paper: his histories of European, Indian and Chinese philology begin in the early modern period. But what did philology look like in the ancient world? How did people make sense of texts in the Persian period, for example?
Interestingly, the earliest ancient Near Eastern evidence of a signature--a claim of individual participation and responsibility via the writing of one's name--is Jewish, occurring in Persian-era legal documents. And it is connected with a strikingly new image of verbatim textual transmission, which can be tracked across different first-millennium Near Eastern scribal cultures. This paper will examine some contrasting attitudes toward textual transmission in biblical narrative with further external evidence from the Persian period to suggest a picture of the Primeval History, and perhaps the Pentateuch, as the product of a historically distinctive type of ancient Hebrew philology.
|
The "Religious" and "Secular" Meanings of "Playing Indian": An Assessment of Brent Nongbri's Before Religion
Program Unit: Religious World of Late Antiquity
Kathleen M. Sands, University of Hawai'i
In this paper, I accept but also extend Brent Nongbri's characterization of the modern western concept of religion. In addition to the private, interior, voluntary, and apolitical concept of "religion" that he traces, I contend that the modern west also has produced a generic notion of religion that exerts hegemonic power in the public sphere. The key to this power, I'll suggest, is that this generic notion of religion can either be recognized as religion or can be subsumed into the secular according to the interests and opportunities of dominant groups. As an illustration, I examine the historical tradition of "playing Indian," in which Euro-Americans have ingested (what they take to be) Native American spiritual practices into their own (Euro-American) national ethos. Thus Native American spiritual practices have appeared as "secular" (when performed by Euro-Americans), as "heathenism"or "primitive religion" (when performed by Native Americans), or as the purest form of generic religion (when contemplated by moderns as an object of nostalgia).
|
Beggar at the Banquet
Program Unit: Meals in the HB/OT and Its World
Michael Satlow, Brown University
Rabbinic literature contains stories of beggars who show up at banquets and other feasts. These stories, which use luxurious feasting as sites for thinking about social justice, reveal a variety of rabbinic tensions. Using these stories as a point of departure, this paper will investigate how rabbis articulate the tension between wealth, its proper use, and poverty.
|
Transaction or Relationship? Toward a Model of "Popular Piety"
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Michael Satlow, Brown University
How are we to understand the relationship between the religious understandings and prescriptions of "specialists" and everybody else? Building on Stanley Stower's model, developed in his essay, "The Religion of Plant and Animal Offerings Versus the Religion of Meanings, Essences, and Textual Mysteries," I will propose a way of understanding this relationship, particularly as applied to the rabbis and other Jews in late antiquity.
|
Creation as Cosmic Temple, Part II
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Stanley Saunders, Columbia Theological Seminary
This presentation, the second of two-parts (the first given by William P Brown), explores the matrix of associations between creation, “heaven and earth,” temple, Jesus, the body of Christ, and the new heaven and earth in the New Testament materials, focusing on the ways this material opens up fresh lenses for reading the story of creation in the NT. The NT writers do not often speak explicitly of “creation,” but they develop strong links between the “temple”—a homologue of “creation” in the Hebrew Bible —and Jesus, the church, and the new creation. This presentation focuses especially on the ways the eschatological visions of such diverse writers as Matthew, John, Paul, and the seer of Revelation draw upon creation (and fall) and temple motifs. Even after its destruction by the Romans, both Christians and Jews continued to affirm ideal images of the temple as creation (or creation as temple). This matrix of associations constitutes a cord with many strands that runs through much of the biblical canon, from Genesis to Revelation, as well as through early Jewish writings and into the early Church. The prevalence of these associations across such a wide range of materials challenges the “anthropocentric” lens through which modern Christians usually read the biblical stories of creation and redemption, highlights the widespread and enduring hope among early Christians for the redemption of the whole creation, and establishes a fresh hermeneutical lens for reading the New Testament in light of our environmental crises today. As time allows, the presentation will also include images from Christian art and architectural decoration that confirm the persistence of this matrix in Jewish and Christian imagination at least until the 13th Century CE.
|
Sarah Grimké’s and Elizabeth Cady Stanton’s Reconceptualizing of the Genesis Creation Accounts
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Deborah Niederer Saxon, University of Colorado-Colorado Springs
This presentation provides a nuanced account of similarities and differences in two women’s readings of Genesis, one during the first half of the nineteenth century and one near the very end of it. Sarah Grimké, the older of the two sisters so recently given new life in Sue Monk Kidd’s The Invention of Wings, worked tirelessly for both racial and gender equality in the first part of the nineteenth century, solidly grounding her arguments specifically in her interpretation of Genesis in her 1838 Letters on the Equality of the Sexes. Using the philosophical language of Enlightenment ideals, she argues that both man and woman were created equally in the image of God, were equally culpable in the fall, and are equally subject only to God himself. God has given dominion to humans over other creatures (not to men over women nor to humans over other humans). The hermeneutical stances in Stanton’s Woman’s Bible, published in 1895, reveal both interesting contrasts and comparisons. While Grimké struggles with certain passages outside Genesis, she sees the main issue with regard to the use of the Bible to support oppression as one of simple misinterpretation due to problems of translation. Stanton, however, allows for the possibility that Genesis is a myth comparable to those of other cultures. She also notes the fact that there are two creation accounts, not one (the latter not nearly as helpful as the first). Moreover, she comments on the plural nature of “Elohim” and constructs the divine itself in feminine terms. In her introduction, she states that “the Bible cannot be accepted or rejected as a whole, its teachings are varied and its lessons differ widely from each other.” Nonetheless, Grimké’s and Stanton’s interpretations of the first creation account are strikingly similar in many respects. Both invoke Enlightenment principles, and each emphasizes that both men and women are created in the image of God, that Adam is equally or even more culpable, and—using speech act analysis worthy of modern linguists—that God’s pronouncement to Eve is a prediction rather than a curse. This paper highlights the significance of these astute analyses and their meaningful contributions to the movement for women’s equality.
|
The Care of the Self in the Gospel of Mary
Program Unit: Maria, Mariamne, Miriam: Rediscovering the Marys
Deborah Saxon, University of Colorado-Colorado Springs
The Gospel of Mary represents its central figure in terms of what Michel Foucault calls the care of the self--as a strong, courageous, unwavering woman. While other ancient texts also depict women in this manner, the Gospel of Mary provides a remarkable contrast in at least two ways. Some non-Christian Greco-Roman texts portray women in terms of the care of the self, but they usually conform to the status quo and serve to uphold Roman ideals of modest and self-denying behavior for women. Lucretia, who commits suicide after being raped, provides a good example. In the Gospel of Mary, however, Mary transgresses such norms, boldly speaking up to and exhorting male apostles who fear persecution. Other Christian texts also represent women who transgress societal ideals of modesty in terms of the care of the self, but most often, these texts depict women in the role of martyrs. The case of Perpetua illustrates this well as she rejects her roles as wife and mother in the process of facing torture. Therefore, while they may speak and act boldly, ultimately, these women achieve high status only when they are willing to subject their bodies to suffering and death. Thus, the Gospel of Mary provides a remarkable example of a woman depicted in terms of the care of the self, who speaks and acts boldly without actually subjecting herself to martyrdom. Such a text provides insight regarding possible roles for women in the early Christianities--roles that provide a much needed contrast to those promoted by "proto-orthodox" communities.
|
Twin Introductory Psalms for Each Book of the Psalter
Program Unit: Theology of the Hebrew Scriptures
Todd A. Scacewater, Westminster Theological Seminary
Those studying the 'shape and shaping' of the Psalter have focused on both titles and content to determine editorial intent. Many have seen a general progression from the Davidic monarchy in Book I to the post-exilic period in Book V, although the details are debatable. One problem has been the subjectivity of discerning which features of the Psalter should determine its theological message.
While Wilson initially focused on psalm titles to discern editorial intent, there are other internal evidences of structure. One that has been overlooked is the coherence and cohesion between the first two psalms in each book (i.e., they together tell a coherent story and share linguistic feature that signal this coherence). Psalms 1-2 are often considered purposefully juxtaposed as a theological introduction to the Psalter, and Pss 42-43 obviously belong together. But Pss 73-74; 90-91; 107-108 have slipped under the radar. In fact, these sets of psalms evidence enough coherence and cohesion to suggests editorial intention.
The present thesis is that, rather than only seeing Pss 1-2 as twin introductory psalms to the entire Psalter, we should see the first two psalms of each book of the Psalter as twin introductory psalms for the books they begin. The theme for each book can be derived from these two introductory psalms, and the rest of the psalms in each book fit the proposed theme. The theme of each book also suggests a story, much as Wilson originally argued (although he has since modified his argument) and as others have seen also. This story is the story of Israel, from the Davidic monarchy, to exile, to the post-exilic situation in which hope for the revival of the Davidic throne drives every pious Israelite, including the final redactor(s) of the Psalter.
|
Prefixed Verb Forms in Phoenician: “Injunctive” yaqtula and “Energic” Forms?
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
Aaron Schade, Brigham Young University Hawaii Campus
The purpose of this paper will be to explore the difference in usage between prefixed verb forms in Phoenician inscriptions. I will begin by examining the syntax and pragmatic functions of jussive verb forms, the genres in which they occur, and how they are situated within a text. I will then discuss the usage of other prefixed verb forms, particularly in conditional clauses, and I will explore the possibility of the occurrence of “Injunctive” yaqtula and “energic” forms in Phoenician. In this paper I will suggest that in situations dealing with condition and possibility, rather than witnessing indicatives used in modality, these might be forms related to earlier cognate languages that typically pertain to volition, remnants of which that may find parallels in the use of the Hebrew cohortative. I will draw from several examples in efforts to paint a plausible scenario of the use of these “Injunctive” forms in Phoenician inscriptions.
|
Is Rom 8:19–25 Truly a Green Text? An Ecofeminist Critique
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Leah D. Schade, Lutheran Theological Seminary at Philadelphia
In his seminal book An Inconvenient Text: Is a Green Reading of the Bible Possible?, Norman Habel has argued that Romans 8:19-25 should be categorized as a “green” text. He states that Creation is actually the key character which faces the future together with humanity. Recognizing the portrayal of Creation in feminine terms as a woman in labor, Habel sees Paul’s depiction as pointing to “a deeper movement taking place in the ecosystems at risk” that anticipates a new future emerging from Creation’s travail. Other scholars of this text, including Byrne and Kehm, align with a positive ecotheological reading of Romans 8, agreeing that while Creation shares in humanity’s present sufferings, the promise of new birth outweighs the current travail.
An ecofeminist reading of Romans 8, however, problematizes such a positive interpretation. Applying a feminist hermeneutic of suspicion, it is worrisome that Paul equates Creation with a travailing woman because it leads to many questions. By whom is she impregnated and was it with her consent? With what has she been impregnated? Who will mid-wife Creation? Does she travail alone? Is Creation, like woman, only a vehicle for the male god’s summoning of the androcentric human race? Is Earth only a vessel to receive humanity and give birth to a “new creation” while requiring her own sacrifice?
From an ecofeminist perspective, Creation appears to be subject to patriarchal domination and the sins of the "male" children of God who have transgressed her, raped her, and left her to give birth without any assistance or concern for her future. And as Keller reminds us, "No birth is assured" (Face of the Deep, 226). Further, women sometimes die in childbirth. Given the state of Earth with her waters poisoned, body drilled, and mountains cut away by extreme energy extraction, not to mention the massive extinctions of so many of her other-than-human children, and her rising “fever” of climate change, we cannot help but wonder if Earth is destined for this same fate.
Yet Robert Jewett points out that the personification of Creation may have been influenced by Roman depictions of Earth as a female figure awaiting a “magical new world ushered in by a triumphant god (common in the militaristic mythology of Caesar Augustus),” (Romans: A Commentary, 512). Further, he suggests Paul’s parallel depiction actually offers a critique of the illusion of the golden age of Caesar’s deliverance-via-conquest. Thus this paper makes the argument that, with this historical context in mind, ecofeminists and ecotheologians may not only embrace Romans 8:19-25, but, in fact, may utilize it to critique the contemporary militaristic and corporate mythology of salvation through Earth’s violation.
|
Possession by Pelicans: Legitimate Land Acquisition by Non-human Animals in Isaiah 34
Program Unit: Postcolonial Studies and Biblical Studies
A. Rahel Schafer, Andrews University
In contrast to the illegitimate means of land acquisition that colonial powers often espoused during their global domination, the Old Testament contains various passages that portray non-human animals as legitimately possessing the land when humans leave. Throughout the Pentateuch, non-human animals inherit the land when the humans and domestic animals are sent into exile. Rather than simply describing survival in the land, words of possession, joy, dwelling, making homes, and resting are used for the wild non-human animals in relationship to the land. In Isaiah 34, God gives non-human animals the land as an inheritance after Israel’s sin/exile, using very similar language to Israel’s inheritance of the land from the Canaanites. The words carry covenantal connotations, privileges usually reserved for Israel. Implications for postcolonial analysis include questioning the absolute and often violent application of the creation mandate in Gen 1:26-28. Perhaps non-human animals were the first indigenous “persons” to be illegitimately dispossessed of their land?
|
Divine Wrath and Human Zeal: Numbers 25:11–13 and Its Context Reconsidered
Program Unit: Pentateuch
Kirsten M. Schäfers, Ruhr-Universität Bochum
Num 25 must be considered a lynchpin of recent proposals on the diachronic growth of the book of Numbers. Against this backdrop, the literary (dis-)unity of the chapter as a whole has gained much interest. As far as Num 25:11–13 is concerned, the extant studies were mainly devoted to the literary and historical place of the covenant of priesthood granted to Phineas. At the same time, literary-critical and motif-historical examinations of the concepts of divine wrath and (human) zeal have seldom been at the center of the argument. Taking into account the ancient versions of the Septuagint and the OT Peshitta, the paper will explore the variant shape of the Hebrew consonantal text in order to illuminate the subtle polydirectional shifting of hierarchy between Moses and Phineas. These findings are corroborated: first, by the analysis of the divine speech’s function in the context of Num 25; second, by elaborating the motif-historical potentials of the motifs “divine wrath” and “(human) zeal”.
|
Cult and Priests in Malachi
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Aaron Schart, Universität Duisburg-Essen
Since Malachi is the last writing of the Book of the Twelve, it has the final word within the chain of the prophets. In its second disputation speech (Mal 1:6-2:9) the writing is concerned with the critique of priests and the cult. This passage is unique within the Twelve in several respects, it does allude to late Priestly material in the Pentateuch, it does presuppose tensions between priests and Levites that do not exactly match similar ones in other books, e.g. Pentateuch and Ezekiel, and it gives an intrinsic form of critique: cultic activities are not criticized because they foster or at least disguise moral transgressions, but because they are not an adequate expression for the homage to God.
As Jakob Wöhrle has proposed, the original layer of this speech was aimed at the food offerings (minhah) by lay people, only a later redactor brought in the sacrifice of animals, the priests, and the Levites.
The paper will explore how these findings affect the understanding of cult within Malachi and the Book of the Twelve as a whole.
|
Eve Is Life! The Bible and Bioshock
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Linda Schearing, Gonzaga University
This presentation explores the role of Eve and the Bible in the video game series Bioshock vis a vis reception criticism. Bioshock is the story of Eden--a secular Eden gone terribly wrong. While the presentation examines the various ways in which the game uses the Genesis creation story, its main focus is on the character of Eve. In the biblical text Eve is named the “mother of all living.” In Bioshock, Eve is life in a literal sense. The resulting objectification of Eve is extreme in its portrayal (you get Eve in a hypodermic needle with an apple on it) and interesting in its implications.
|
The Library of Caesarea, Manuscript Production, and the Institutional Shaping of Origen’s Legacy
Program Unit: Book History and Biblical Literatures
Eric Scherbenske, Independent Scholar
Origen’s role in the development of the library of Caesarea is well-known. Upon moving to Caesarea in 231/232, Origen assiduously collected, edited, and published works that contributed greatly to the holdings of the library there. His monumental Hexapla, prepared and housed thereafter in Caesarea, is illustrative: this multi-volume work could scarcely have been distributed widely in its complete form and few could have seen it in its entirety outside of Caesarea. Nevertheless, this work was known beyond Caesarea thanks to the work of dissemination by Origen’s successors, Pamphilus and Eusebius, who figure prominently in numerous manuscript colophons that reference his Hexapla. Pamphilus and Eusebius were thus instrumental not only in building up the library’s holdings through acquisition, transcription, and composition, but also in using the library to promulgate Origen’s legacy as a textual critic through the dissemination of manuscripts dependent on the Hexapla. Euzoius (bishop of Caesarea ca. 376-379) similarly preserved Origen’s legacy by transferring his works onto parchment. Shortly afterwards, around the turn of the fifth century, the archetype of a tenth-century scriptural manuscript, Codex von der Goltz (Gregory-Aland 1739), was produced, which transmits strong evidence linking its production to the library of Caesarea. Among the many important features of this archetype are its text and paratexts: it offers some of the earliest evidence for the extensive deployment of scholia that prominently feature Origen; its text of Paul was deliberately collated and corrected against Origen’s and, in the case of Romans, reconstructed from Origen’s lemmata in his commentary on this epistle.
In this paper I ask what this codex, when viewed among the other aforementioned examples, can reveal about manuscript production at the library of Caesarea—particularly the production of its archetype during the height of the Origenist controversy. I argue that this lost archetype of Codex von der Goltz reveals a fascinating glimpse of the library of Caesarea as an institution of manuscript production for shaping Origen’s legacy. Evidence that the library possibly served as an institutional mechanism for rehabilitating Origen through manuscript production can be seen in (1) the numerous extant witnesses to this archetype and (2) the subsequent deployment of its scholia into catena manuscripts, as J. Neville Birdsall and Caroline Hammond Bammel respectively elucidated. This archetype also reveals problems of considering scriptural text apart from exegetical paratexts. The text of the Pauline epistles was, in fact, either taken from, collated with, or corrected to the text of Origen’s exegetical works. Scholia drawn from earlier exegesis circumscribed and mediated the scriptural text (itself authenticated by Origen’s exegesis) before being redeployed back into catenae of exegesis. This multidirectional movement between scripture and exegesis (even from exegetical lemmata to scriptural text) demonstrates the profound interdependency of scripture and interpretation—and the possible institutional utilization of such. Given the labor involved, such collection, compilation, and dissemination of this archetype can hardly have been arbitrary and likely speaks, I argue, to a deliberate utilization and deployment of the library of Caesarea’s institutional means of manuscript production to shape Origen’s reception.
|
"I Know That My Redeemer Lives": Death and Resurrection in Job
Program Unit: Jewish-Christian Dialogue and Sacred Texts
Kathryn Schifferdecker, Luther Seminary
Themes of life and death abound in the book of Job. To take just one example, Job’s statement, “I know that my Redeemer lives” (Job 19:25) has been interpreted through the centuries (most famously by Handel) as a prophecy of Christ’s resurrection. While it is likely that Job 19 speaks of vindication in this life rather than the next, the movement of the whole book of Job is indeed a part of that trajectory in the Hebrew Bible that leads eventually to Jewish and (later) Christian belief in the resurrection of the dead. This paper will trace that movement of the book from death to life, situate it within its context in the Hebrew Bible, and relate it to later New Testament texts that speak of resurrection.
|
Metaphors in the Book of Proverbs and at Qumran: The “Strange Woman” and 4Q184
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Bernd Schipper, Humboldt University Berlin
This paper addresses the literary relationship between 4Q184 and the book of Proverbs. In contrast to previous research, this paper demonstrates that 4Q184 depends not only on Prov 7 but also on Prov 9, 5, and 2. Given that these four texts (Prov 2, 5, 7, and 9) belong to three different literary layers in the redaction of Prov 1–9, the demonic female of 4Q184 thus appears in a new light. Even though 4Q184 presents an ontological metaphor, the shift in meaning from a structural metaphor to an ontological understanding of the female figure can already be found in Prov 1–9. A closer look at the literary formation of Prov 1–9 shows that the paradigmatic shift from a female figure (the “strange woman”) to a counter-principle of personified Wisdom (“Dame Folly”) is already evident in the redaction of Prov 1–9. Therefore, in its demonization of “Dame Folly,” 4Q184 does not present a completely novel concept, but rather one that is connected to the shift in the understanding of the female figure produced by the final redaction of Prov 1–9.
|
The Motif of “Seven Years of Famine” in an Egyptian Text from the Persian Period: Papyrus Berlin 23071 VSO and the Joseph Story
Program Unit: Egyptology and Ancient Israel
Bernd Schipper, Humboldt University Berlin
The motif of “seven years of famine” belongs to a set of motifs that connects the Joseph story strongly with Egypt. It can be found in combination with the river Nile, with one of Pharaoh’s dreams, and with a “wise man” on the so-called “famine stela” from the Ptolemaic Period. Whereas previous research argued on the basis of this stela that the literary motif found its way from the Joseph story to the Egyptian text, a newly discovered papyrus from the Berlin collections suggests another possible explanation. This paper will first describe this papyrus and compare it with the inner-Egyptian tradition that is attested in the “famine stela,” papyrus Berlin 23071 VSO, and other texts from the Late Period. It will then discuss the significance of this papyrus for interpreting the Joseph story as a text that refers in many ways to Egypt and that should be understood as a “diaspora novella.”
|
After a Decade of Disability Studies in SBL
Program Unit:
Jeremy Schipper, Temple University
*
|
Origen and P.Grenf. 1.5
Program Unit: Greek Bible
Francesca Schironi, University of Michigan
In this talk I would like to discuss P.Grenf. 1.5, a fragment from a papyrus codex containing Ezekiel 5.12-6.3, and put it into its historical and cultural contexts. This papyrus from the latter half of the third century CE has been neglected by scholars (both papyrologists and scholars of Greek Bible); however, because it shows significant textual differences from the Septuagint and because it carries the critical signs used by Origen, this fragment is very important for the reconstruction of Origen’s work on the Bible. In my talk, I will first briefly compare the data offered by P.Grenf. 1.5 with two important witnesses of Origen’s Hexapla – the Cairo-Genizah Palimpsest (7th century) and the Mercati Palimpsest (9th-10th century) ¬– to address the debated question of where Origen used his critical signs: whether in the fifth column of the Hexapla, or in a separate edition containing the Greek text only. In the second part of my talk, through a synoptic analysis of P.Grenf. 1.5 and the Codex Marchalianus (Vat. Gr. 2125), a 6th century CE codex of the Septuagint preserving Origen’s critical signs, I will show that P.Grenf. 1.5 better preserves the original system invented by Origen for his edition of the Septuagint; and, consequently, that it has a unique value for the study of Origen and his work on the Septuagint. Finally, I will put P.Grenf. 1.5 in its historical and cultural context, studying it against the testimony of Jerome and of what we know of the editorial work by Pamphilus and Eusebius at Caesarea.
|
How to Make a Giver Cheerful: Motivating the Corinthian Believers for the Collection
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Thomas Schmeller, Goethe-Universität Frankfurt am Main
In 2Cor 8-9 Paul lists many different reasons why the Corinthian believers should take part in the collection for Jerusalem: the example of the Macedonians, the model of Christ, the grace of God, the lack of a fair balance between the congregations and several others. The present paper tries to find out how these motivations relate to each other and to their context. Have they been put together at random or is there some link (rhetorical, literary, theological) between them? How should one deal with the obvious tensions among them? In which way do they reflect the situation of the Corinthian congregation and/or of Paul?
|
Conceptual Profiles and Redactional Updating in Isaiah 40–66
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Konrad Schmid, Universität Zürich
This paper will examine concepts of redaction in Isaiah 40-66, with a special emphasis on Isaiah 63-66.
|
Women, Witness, and Endings: Intercalation in Mark 5 and Implications for 16:8
Program Unit: Speech and Talk in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Mary K. Schmitt, Princeton Theological Seminary
In the latter half of Mark 5, one finds a common Markan narrative device: intercalation (5:21-43). The story about Jairus’ daughter is interrupted by the story about the hemorrhaging woman. The technique of intercalation here is effective because it allows time for the first story to reach its crisis, namely the death of Jairus’ daughter, during the intervening period of the second story concerning the hemorrhaging woman. However, while the juxtaposition of the two narratives serves to create an appropriate time lapse, the intercalation results in a jarring contrast between the two narrative endings. The first story, the healing of Jairus’ daughter is a public event – Jairus approaches Jesus in a crowd, the mourners at Jairus’ house, etc. – that ends with Jesus commanding those present not to tell anyone what has occurred. The intervening story of the healing of the hemorrhaging woman occurs without anyone else knowing the woman was healed; yet, Jesus insists that he discover who touched him, and the story ends with the woman telling everything. The juxtaposition of the two stories results in a tension between Jesus’ command to those at Jairus’ house not to speak and Jesus’ insistence that the woman make known her healing. In this paper, I will demonstrate the tension between silence and speech in the endings of the intercalated stories of Mark 5; then I will argue that the fundamental tension between the endings of the two intercalated narratives points up a larger tension between silence and witness in the gospel of Mark. In addition, I will draw upon the tension between silence and witness in Mark 5 to examine the narrative ending to the gospel (16:8): the tension between witness and silence in Mark 5 prepares the reader for tension with regard to speech and silence at the end of the gospel.
|
Representations of War and Warfare in Ancient Israelite and Judean Glyptics and Other Small Arts
Program Unit: Warfare in Ancient Israel
Ruediger Schmitt, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
Different to Assyria with its large repertoire of-war-related representations in monumental art, war and warfare in Iron Age Israel and Judah only occurs in miniature art, predominantly in glyptic arts, but also on a fragment of wall painting and on other genres of small arts. The aim of the paper is to give an overview on warfare-related motifs on Iron Age Seals and related arts (chariots, horses, king smashing enemy, siege scene etc.), a comparison with related motifs from Assyria, and an investigation in the functions of Iron Age glyptic arts for official and royal representations of power. It will be shown that Iron Age II Israelite and Judean representations of war and warfare were strongly influenced by Aramaic and Assyrian art, but also still show some Egyptian influence. An imprtant question is how and how far Assyrian royal war idelogy had an impact on Israel and Judah. (cf. R. Schmitt, Bildhafte Herrschaftsrepräsentation im eisenzeitlichen Israel, AOAT 283, Münster 2001).
|
God as a Protagonist in Esther MT and Esther LXX
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Barbara Schmitz, Universitat Wurzburg
The Hebrew version of the Book of Esther is the only book within the Bible which not even once uses the word “God” or any other term referring to God. In this version God neither appears as a protagonist, nor is he mentioned on the level of the narrator or on the level of the other protagonists. The question regarding God ´s action within the narratives of Esther is much discussed and earned the Hebrew version the reputation of being a “god-less” book. Therefore it does not come as a surprise that it was for a long time disputed whether the Book of Esther should be part of the Biblical canon or not.
Things are quite different regarding the Greek version of the Book of Esther (B-text): In this version one finds many references to God, like prayers in times of need and pleas for his saving intervention.
Because the question regarding God is of great importance for the interpretation and theology of the Book of Esther, I will take a fresh look at it and compare the Hebrew version with the Septuagint version of Esther. Is there really silence of God and about God in the Hebrew version of the book? I will discuss this question especially regarding EstMT 4:14; 6:1 and 3:12: Do they refer to God after all?
In comparison, the longer Greek version (B-text) seems to be a text which contains many passages referring to God: Not only does one find long prayers in the middle of the book, but there are more than fifty references to the God of Israel, using terms like “kyrios”, “king”, “pantocrator”, “helper” etc. Are those references intended to fill the interesting and surprising gap of the Hebrew version? In order to answer this question I am going to analyse narratologically the text passages in which God is the protagonist and those in which other protagonists are speaking about God.
This narratological approach leads to a differentiated view regarding the portrait drawn of God within the two versions of the Book of Esther and reveals the specific idea of God in each of both versions.
|
Biblical Studies Is Feminist Biblical Studies, and Vice Versa
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Susanne Scholz, Southern Methodist University
This paper posits that feminist biblical studies is not merely a specialized area of research in the discipline of biblical studies but must be understood as the very heart of the field. In other words, the Hebrew Bible is about feminism and feminism is about the Hebrew Bible. Feminist biblical analysis is not merely an add-on topic within the traditional field of biblical studies but at the very center of the scholarly endeavor that critically examines and evaluates biblical texts and their interpretations. Three sections elaborate on the conceptualization of biblical studies as feminist biblical studies, and vice versa. One section discusses how Carol Meyers’ challenge to using the word of “patriarchy” in descriptions of ancient Israel strengthens and weakens feminist analysis within the field of biblical studies. Another section engages the work of Elisabeth Schüssler Fiorenza to deconstruct dominantly practiced versions of biblical scholarship that still marginalize feminist biblical scholarship. A final section indicates the breadth and depth of feminist biblical studies as an international, interreligious, interracial, and intercultural movement that does not only speak from the recognition of oppression, androcentrism, and the place of gender discrimination but also provides critical insight into the structures of domination within the intersections of race, class, physical abilities, colonialism, and heteronormativity due to providing intellectual support to and theoretical rationale for global struggles for justice.
|
Deuteronomy in the Samaritan Tradion and the Northern Origins of Deuteronomy
Program Unit: Book of Deuteronomy
Stefan Schorch, Martin-Luther-Universität Halle-Wittenberg
The suggestion that Deuteronomy is of northern origin or at least very strongly influenced by traditions from Northern Israel has been advanced over a long period and by numerous important scholars, e.g. Adam C. Welch, Albrecht Alt, Gerhard von Rad, and Moshe Weinfeld. The paper will give this problem a fresh look, from the perspective of the Samaritan Pentateuch and its textual history. It will be shown that the Samaritan text, as against the Masoretic text of Deuteronomy, preserves a number of textual variants, which shed new light on the origin and the history of the Book of Deuteronomy and provide additional support for its origin in the North.
|
The Omrit Settlement Excavations: The First Two Seasons
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Dan Schowalter, Carthage College
Excavations of the temple complex at Omrit in northern Israel took place from 1999-2011, and the first volume of the Final Report on the Temple Excavation will be published in 2014. At the same time, a new team of researchers has started the Omrit Settlement Excavations.
|
The Annihilation of the Egyptian and Neo-Assyrian Armies: Inner-Biblical Typology?
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
David. B. Schreiner, Asbury University
Israel’s victories over Egypt at the Red Sea and the Neo-Assyrian army at Jerusalem represent two of the greatest military victories in ancient Israelite history. They are classic underdog stories that, above all, testify to the faithfulness and might of Yahweh. Yet the relationship between these two events may go beyond mere testimony. There is reason to believe that the biblical writers who fashioned the accounts of 701 BCE did so in a manner to communicate their conviction that the victory over the Neo-Assyrian army should assume its place alongside other salvific events that were critical components to the community’s self-identity. This paper will propose that the account of the annihilation of the Neo-Assyrian army is an inner-biblical typology best understood in light of the annihilation of the Egyptian army at the Red Sea.
This paper will first discuss the six points of connection between the two narratives, which range from historical, thematic, to syntactical. It is proposed that these points of contact cooperate to encourage a cognitive connection between the two narratives. In turn, Michael Fishbane’s methodology for inner-biblical exegesis is invoked, and it is suggested that his category of inner-biblical typology properly characterizes the relationship between the two military accounts. Ultimately, the annihilation of the Neo-Assyrian army is understood by the biblical writer to be the next, great victory and foundational moment in Israel’s history. Interestingly, the nuances of the annihilation account of the Neo-Assyria army also suggest a perceptual shift within the community, for the substantiation for salvation in 2 Kings is tied to the might of Yahweh and the Davidic dynasty.
This paper concludes with some reflections on what this proposal means for understanding the boundaries of Israel’s pre-exilic historical work. It is suggested that something akin to Schmid’s “Moses Story” may be more appropriate than the traditional confines of the Deuteronomistic History.
|
Reading Biblical Texts through the Lens of Resilience
Program Unit: Biblical Literature and the Hermeneutics of Trauma
Robert Schreiter, Catholic Theological Union
While much has been made of the role of resistance as a means of coping with traumatic experience, attention to resilience--the long-term capacity to sustain one's humanity in the midst of dehumanizing factors in the traumatic experience--has not been as well documented and studied. Recent interdisciplinary work on the topic of resilience provides an opportunity to bring these new understandings to bear upon readings of the biblical texts of trauma and exile. This presentation will utilize especially texts from Jeremiah to explore the development and sustaining of resilience among a traumatized people. Understanding how resilience aids in the negotiation of and healing of trauma aids constructive theology in understanding the pedagogy of interiority and the power of founding narratives to foster social solidarity.
|
Tag, You're It: Creating a Richly Annotated Coptic Digital Library
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
Caroline Schroeder, University of the Pacific
The study of Coptic literature faces a number of challenges, even in the digital age. Pressing concerns even in 2014 include the fragmentation of manuscripts in libraries across the globe, the need for editions and translations of even classic texts, and our continued need for more knowledge about the language itself (its grammar and syntax but also its usage on a popular level), to name just three. Using a developing Coptic digital library known as Coptic SCRIPTORIUM, this presentation will discuss best practices for annotating (often called “tagging”) a Coptic digital library for research into these issues and will present sample research questions that will be studied using the corpus. By Fall of 2015, the Coptic SCRIPTORIUM digital library will have published select texts of Shenoute, Besa, the Sayings of the Desert Fathers, and the New Testament; it will be working on integrating Coptic papyri from the open-source papyrology digital collection at papyri.info, as well. The presentation will address part-of-speech, named entity, language of origin, and biblical citation tagging as well as metadata (including the challenges in using standards for repositories and Coptic manuscripts).
|
Persian-Period Religious Depictions of Kingship in the Nehemiah Memoir
Program Unit: Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah
Lucas L. Schulte, University of La Verne
This paper proposes that religious depictions of kingship within sections of the book of Nehemiah generally attributed to the Nehemiah Memoir fit within the context of Persian-period inscriptions. An increasingly popular theory within Nehemiah scholarship is that the Nehemiah Memoir was originally void of religious language, and that later redactors added theological language to the book of Nehemiah after the Persian Period. Yet previous scholarship of Nehemiah lacks a systematic examination of Persian-period royal inscriptions. This paper will examine religious depictions of Persian kings in royal inscriptions dating to the Persian Period from two nations adjacent to Judah: Egypt and Babylon. The religious depiction of the Persian king, Artaxerxes, in sections of Nehemiah that most likely originate in the Nehemiah Memoir matches the religious depiction of Persian kings as found in inscriptions within the adjacent nations of Egypt and Babylon dating to the Persian period: namely, that the Persian king is supported by the local deity and is heir to the local dynasty. Rather than the popular theory that religious language within the book of Nehemiah post-dates the Persian period, this paper demonstrates that religious references in the book of Nehemiah to divine authorization akin to those within datable texts found in Babylon and Egypt most likely date to the Persian period, due to a shared Sitz in der Literatur.
|
Reflections of Seven Years of Teaching Biblical Hebrew in Biblical Hebrew
Program Unit: Applied Linguistics for Biblical Languages
Brian Schultz, Fresno Pacific University
The movement to use Communicative Language Teaching, also known as the “oral” method, to teach the biblical languages is growing, even if only among a minority of instructors of the biblical languages. Early adopters have done so out of a desire to apply proven language-learning principles from the field of Second Language Acquisition, including research on reading in L2 which documents the importance of spoken language as key for developing fluency in reading. Even if no institution to date runs a full biblical language program using the “oral” method, several have been offering beginner and intermediate levels of one or both of the biblical languages for several years. These provide a unique opportunity to reflect on the institutional pragmatics of adopting the “oral” approach to teaching the biblical languages, as well as provide a an early assessment, even if still somewhat premature, of its merit. This paper will share reflections on one such institution that has implemented the “oral” approach to its biblical Hebrew courses for the past seven years, and how it has led to student demand for a more robust biblical Hebrew program
|
Roman Money in Rabbinic Literature
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Nathan Schumer, Columbia University in the City of New York
The field of Roman economic history has changed radically in the past twenty years, presenting compelling and exciting new views of the Roman Empire. Unfortunately, for disciplinary reasons, rabbinic literature has not been part of this broader conversation on the Roman economy, despite the fact that rabbinic literature preserves unique, idiosyncratic views of Roman economic life. My paper uses rabbinic literature to explore provincial, subaltern views of the Roman economy, focusing on the rabbinic depiction of Roman money. This paper demonstrates the potential for rabbinic sources to shed new light on the Roman economy.
I begin with an exploration of rabbinic conceptions of coinage and their significance for Roman monetary history by looking at Mishnah Baba Mezia 4.1 and its parallels in the Tosefta and the Talmud Yerushalmi. These texts concern exchange between different forms of money, especially the relationship of gold coins to silver coins. The first section of the paper historicizes rabbinic conceptions of Roman money, showing that the rabbinic texts document the transition from silver coinage in the high imperial period to gold coinage in the later Roman Empire.
Having demonstrated that rabbinic literature responds to changes in Roman monetary policy, I use rabbinic literature on Roman money as serious evidence to respond to a longstanding debate about the nature of Roman money between chartalists and metallists. Chartalists argue that money is fiduciary and has no intrinsic value, aside from the fact that the state recognizes it as money. Metallists argue that money has intrinsic value, because of its precious metal content and it originated in the private sector, not with the state. I demonstrate that rabbis, like many provincials, seem to articulate a more metallist conception of money, because they had less trust in the Roman state (even though they maintain some chartalist elements). The Roman state, on the other hand, seems to be somewhat more chartalist in its outlook. This reading of the text demonstrates how rabbinic concepts of money can provide a rare window into how provincials understood the Roman monetary regime, and inform scholarship on the Roman world.
|
Working Memory and Scribal Process in PsT of Didymus the Blind
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Gregg Schwendner, Wichita State University
The scribe of PsT wrote in a cursive script. As a consequence of this and of the excellent state of this 6th century papyrus’ preservation, the scribal process can be observed in PsT in finer detail than is usually possible, especially pertaining to the ductus litterarum.
Among his habits are: 1. the use of different letter shapes (especially final-nu) to mark a pause, grammatical or rhetorical; 2. the use of enlarged letters for new sections of text, but also sometimes to mark the end of a pause; 3. spaces between words in pausa are also observable; 4. the columns of PsT are very wide, so the scribe freqeuntly, measurably re-aligns his baseline to keep it from skewing too far upwards or down; 5. where the scribe re-inks his pen can be followed with unusual clarity.
Heretofore, current theories of how working memory (also called short-term memory) function have played almost no role in the various accounts scholars give for scribal process in Antiquity. This lack has fueled a pointless debate about dictation theory, and occasionally a distorted emphasis on the purely visual component of this process. Taking advantage of the unusual amount of data available from the PsT, I will demonstrate how what is called the “phonological loop” in working memory plays an important role, viz., how its relatively small buffer of between one and ten words restricted the copying process.
A prior consideration, however, has to do with the oral nature of the PsT. It is uncontroversial that the text was dictated by Didymus to a stenographer and then converted to scriptio plena. It was not edited for publication, but used “as is,” perhaps in Nitrian monastic community. I assume, therefore, that the text is made up of the “intonational units”, sometimes called “idea units”, unrevised, as Didymus spoke them. An average obtained by Chafe for lectures is 7.3 words per intonational unit, only slightly more than the 6.3 words average for conversation (Chafe-Danielewicz, 1987). “The length or duration of the units fits the acoustic short term memory of the performer, or in other words, the ability to process linguistic expressions as wholes, which is determined by an “auditory buffer” of two to three seconds (Bakker, 1997, citing Chafe, 1994, p. 58). Finally, a correspondence can be demonstrated between the prosody of Didymus’ lecturing style and the way our scribe has chunked the text into his working memory in order to transcribe it.
The results of this research will offer something new in the study of orality in Greek and to the role working memory plays in scribal practice.
|
The Problem with Categories: A Conversation with Karen King’s What Is Gnosticism?
Program Unit: Westar Institute
Bernard Brandon Scott, Phillips Theological Seminary
*
|
How Did the Conclusions of the Jesus Seminar Change the Philosophical and Theological Outlooks of the Participants?
Program Unit: Westar Institute
Bernard Brandon Scott, Phillips Theological Seminary
*
|
Completing the Prophetic Process in the Third Edition of Exodus: A New Theory on the Origins of the Ten Plagues Insertions
Program Unit: Transmission of Traditions in the Second Temple Period
John Screnock, University of Toronto
Since the discovery of the Dead Sea Scrolls, the early revision of Exodus, found in the Samaritan Pentateuch, 4QpaleoExod-m, and related manuscripts, has been the subject of extensive study. This edition of Exodus makes numerous insertions, where text from a parallel passage is used nearly verbatim. These insertions have been described in various ways; descriptions typically focus on insertions stemming from Deuteronomy or insertions taken from within the Ten Plagues narrative (inserted elsewhere in the same narrative). As a result, most previous theories cannot account for all of the insertions in the third edition of Exodus.
In this study, I examine all of the evidence in the Ten Plagues narrative and bring it to bear on the current discussion, proposing two new theories. First, I suggest that there are at least two distinct phenomena at work. Second, focusing on one phenomenon--the insertions in the Ten Plagues narrative--I suggest that a concern to portray the complete process of prophecy (as defined by Deuteronomy 18) is the reason for the insertions.
My second thesis has interesting possible implications for the place of the third edition of Exodus in the late Second Temple period. The third edition's bent on presenting the complete process of prophecy--including both God's giving the prophecy, and the prophet delivering it--wherever the phrase "thus says the Lord" occurs, implies that books in the Former and Latter prophets are inadequate in their portrayal of prophecy. Thus, the third edition of Exodus may have been created or adopted by groups like the Sadducees or the Samarians in order implicitly critique non-Torah books.
|
Free Will and Ascetical Labor: How Babai the Great Fixes the Platonic Conception of the Soul
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Jason Scully, Seton Hall University
In his commentary on Evagrius’s Gnostic Chapters, Babai the Great, the Syriac-speaking abbot of the monastery of Mount Izla from 604-628, adopts a Platonic conception of the soul indirectly via Evagrius’s Gnostic Chapters. In this paper, I will argue that Babai reinterprets and fixes perceived problems with this conception of the soul in order to make it better suited to withstanding criticism from his anonymous polemical opponents, who say that the human soul is not inherently evil.
The assumption of Babai’s unnamed opponents is that evil cannot arise from something that is inherently good, so the obvious existence of evil in the world implies that creation itself, and the human soul in particular, is inherently evil. In order to make sure that his Platonic conception of the soul could successfully withstand this criticism, Babai introduces free will as the source of evil and as an explanation for why the soul produces passions that disrupt its natural harmony. Free will directs anger and desire towards either virtuous ends that help stimulate spiritual knowledge or else towards evil ends that cause distraction in the soul and hinder the attainment of spiritual knowledge.
Furthermore, in order to convince his readers that the three parts of the soul (rational, irascible, and concupiscible) are devoid of any evil, Babai shows how all three parts can overcome distractions and work towards virtuous ends instead of evil. According to Babai, ascetical labor trains the will to direct the soul towards activities that lead to spiritual knowledge of God, which enables the soul to return to a harmonious state of undisturbed contemplation called spiritual knowledge.
|
“Wandering Arameans?” Interrogating Identity in a Diasporic Society: Dalitness in Indian Hyphenated Americans
Program Unit: Asian and Asian-American Hermeneutics
J. Jayakiran Sebastian, Lutheran Theological Seminary at Philadelphia
The emergence of Dalit theology in India in the early 1980’s set in motion major questions regarding identity, conversion, the nature of hyphenated existence, and the persistence of discrimination and caste prejudices. In the last thirty years, a lot of work and numerous publications have led to the reconfiguration of the theological landscape in India and the recognition and interrogation of privilege in theological discourse and ecclesial realities. Opportunities opened up by the software boom and the technology service sector in the 1990’s enabled many Indians, including Indian Christians form a Dalit background, to come to the United States, either for shorter-term assignments or for a longer duration, and offered up the possibility of a “fresh” start in a new context, where the prejudices of the past, reinforced by geographical location, may or may not play a role in the construction of the human subject. Using the “wandering Arameans” concept from Deuteronomy 26:5, a phrase problematized and interrogated by the pioneer of Dalit theology, Arvind P. Nirmal, in his programmatic article signaling the birth of Dalit theology, this paper will seek to read this from a postcolonial perspective in the context of migration, new identity-formation, the reality of being overtaken by the past in a new context, and the affirmation or disavowal of one’s roots.
|
Sex on the Brain and Prisons for the Body: Resisting Racialized Gender Stereotypes and the Gospel of John
Program Unit: African-American Biblical Hermeneutics
Love L. Sechrest, Fuller Theological Seminary (Pasadena)
In Black Sexual Politics, Patricia Hill Collins describes the ways that racial stereotypes perform differently when applied to men and women, and concludes that while race affects black people profoundly, the effects of racism on blacks are differentiated by gender. Collins’ description of two common racialized stereotypes, the Jezebel and the Criminal, are fruitful for engaging the text and interpretations of two episodes in the gospel of John. Readings of Jesus’ encounter with the Samaritan woman in John 4:1-42 frequently interpret the female character through the lens of the hyper-sexed Jezebel, an interpretation that is at odds with the use of the betrothal type scene in this passage. The ancient addendum to John in 7:53-8:11, Jesus’ encounter with the woman caught in adultery, acts likewise as a metaphor for racialized stereotypes about blacks as oversexed criminals. Intertextual allusions in this scene to the Susanna story in the additions to Daniel have implications as well for normative notions of innocence, judgment, and mercy vis-à-vis contemporary society.
|
Confession and Deception in Josephus' Samaritan Ethno-geography
Program Unit: Josephus
Chris Seeman, Walsh University
Josephus deploys an array of conflicting ethno-geographical descriptors in his portrayal of the Samaritans in the Antiquities: Chuthaeans, Medo-Persian colonists, expatriate Jerusalemites, Shechemites, Sidonians at Shechem. While some of this shifting nomenclature may reflect divergence among Josephus’ sources, the polemical intent of their conflation has long been recognized. By generating inconsistent testimony concerning their ethno-geographical origin, Josephus develops the theme of Samaritan duplicity. By imputing deception to Samaritan self-identification, Josephus seeks to discredit the claim that they descend from Ephraim and Manasseh. They are geographically “out of place” (unlike Judeans, whose ethnonym corresponds to their place of residence and authenticates their possession of the only legitimate cult center). Thus, geographical markers contribute to Josephus’ project of reinforcing the coherence of Judean identity at Samaritan expense.
This paper examines Josephus’ use of ethno-geographical confession and deception in his account of Macedonian rule. Specifically, it considers the role of the ruler (Alexander the Great, Antiochus IV, Ptolemy VI) as witness and umpire in Judean-Samaritan “identity politics.”
|
A World of Feeling: The Affect of Lars von Trier and Biblical Apocalyptic
Program Unit: Bible and Film
Robert Paul Seesengood, Albright College
According to John Collins (The Apocalyptic Imagination), the sine qua non of biblical apocalyptic is not eschatology; instead, apocalyptic must be a mediated revelation of the "real" world. Seers' visions unveil the true way that the cosmos functions. The paper will combine Affect Theory (particularly as per Eve Sedgewick) and an Auteur approach to the work of Lars von Trier read against the canonical Apocalypse of John. While von Trier's Antichrist (2009), Dogville (2003) and Melancolia (2011) explore themes that intersect with biblical apocalyptic in obvious, theological and cosmological ways, other films - such as The Idiots (1998), Breaking the Waves (1996), and Dancer in the Dark (2000) which explore social organization and The Kingdom (1994) which probes the limits of technology – engage themes also central to biblical apocalyptic. The Revelation to John describes the coming erasure of the present world because of its decaying social, economic and technological structures, all of which are rotting with human selfishness and moral vacancy. Revelation's visions – and von Trier's films - provoke instant affective response in the reader – revulsion, terror, anger, and in resolution, joy and release. These sensory responses, I will argue, are not devices to supplement "meaning," but are, themselves, the critical, central point. The sense of shock, terror, passion, lust, etc. awakened in the viewer/reader is, in itself, the core meaning. The universe and human society are affective agents. Any cognitive engagement of them without the sensual and the affective is partial, is occluded. Both Von Trier and John work to reveal this affective quality to the world by means of their apocalyptic spectacles.
|
Old Greek and Theodotion to Daniel 8
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Michael Segal, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
This lecture will assess the contribution of the Old Greek and Theodotion versions for the text-critical analysis of the apocalypse in Daniel 8. Based upon a comparison with MT (and other versions, including Qumran scrolls, where relevant), we will attempt to identify the underlying Vorlage of each Greek version, and the theological-exegetical motivations and translation technique employed by each of the translators. Furthermore, this paper will attempt to demonstrate the nature of the literary relationship between OG and Theodotion in this chapter.
The discussion will primarily focus on 8:10-13, which has been recognized as one of the most textually difficult passages in the book, offering a new assessment of the transmission and translation of these enigmatic verses.
|
Kabbalistic Sex: Literature into Ritual
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Marla Segol, State University of New York, Buffalo
This paper will theorize the manner in which the Zohar, a medieval Jewish form of imaginative literature, is used as a source for ritualized sexuality among historic and contemporary practitioners of kabbalah, loosely conceptualized. I will begin with Zohar III 17 and III 42, interpreting the Song of Songs, and examine its enaction in Moshe Cordovero’s 16th Century Sefer Gerushin, and Or Yakar (Precious Light). Finally, I will compare these 16th century accounts to its presentation in contemporary self-help literature on Kabbalah and sexuality such as the Kabbalah Center’s Kabbalah on Sex: Make Love, Make Light, and the "Sex: the Secret Gate to Eden." In exploring later applications of the models of sacred sexuality articulated in the Zohar I will seek to better understand how and why imaginative literature can play the role of sacred discourse in non-institutional esoteric religion, questioning common understandings of ritual as the enaction of sacred discourse.
|
Drama in the Biblical Studies Classroom: Using Role Plays to Understand History, Do Theology, and Teach Hermeneutics
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Eric A. Seibert, Messiah College
This paper demonstrates how role plays are an effective pedagogical tool that can be used in the biblical studies classroom for diverse purposes. As a form of experiential learning, role plays actively involve every student in the classroom and generate a high degree of affect which significantly aids in learning and retention. The take only a limited amount of class time to facilitate and provide a welcome alternative to traditional modes of instruction.
Three role plays, each with different functions, will be discussed. Using a hypothetical scenario in which students grapple with God’s decree to kill Canaanites (Joshua 6-11), one role play is designed to help students think theologically about God’s character. Another role play invites students to imaginatively relive the tense situation when Jerusalem was besieged by the Assyrians (2 Kings 18-19), thereby enabling students to understand the hard choices Israelites were facing and the ramifications of those choices. A third role play involves the intentional misuse of verses from Proverbs to illustrate an important hermeneutical principle, namely, that proverbs should be read as general guidelines and principles, not as promises from God.
To illustrate how role plays actually work in the classroom, all attendees will have the opportunity to participate in one role play during this presentation (no theatrical experience needed!). Although this will be facilitated in an abbreviated fashion due to time constraints, it will give participants a feel for how these work and what can be accomplished with this instructional technique.
During this presentation, some attention will be given to how to create role plays, and practical suggestions will be offered for how to facilitate and process them in class. Suggestions will also be made about other passages of Scripture that would work well in this engaging and participatory format.
|
Resurrecting Early Christian Lives: Digging in Papyri in a Digital Age
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
Philip Sellew, University of Minnesota-Twin Cities
Papyri allow us to retrieve not only lost literary works and heretical gospels but the everyday writings of Greco-Roman Egypt: letters, contracts, homilies, census returns, petitions, school exercises. There are hundreds of thousands of such fragments in the Oxyrhynchus collection alone, and publishing them is a painfully slow process.
Building on our experience crowd-sourcing transcriptions of the Oxyrhynchus material in Greek on the Ancient Lives website, our team is examining a range of documents offering evidence about the rise of Christianity. Based on the transcription pipeline we built for the Greek crowd-sourced fragments, we are developing a transcription tool for Coptic, used alongside Greek in the early Christian period. This new pipeline will allow us to crowd-source unpublished texts from Oxyrhynchus and other large collections in Coptic as well as Greek. We will also complete a web-based curation interface allowing scholars to edit the results of the crowd-sourced transcriptions. This corpus of digital information, linked to each fragment, will significantly increase the rate at which fragments are published and will expedite meaningful searches across all fragments. We will then combine the crowd-sourced data in Greek and Coptic with data from customized searches across already extant databases of papyrus texts in Greek and Coptic. These new tools will allow our team to look in more detail than ever before at the complex networks of Christian identity and authority in the early church, and to examine how early Christians saw their new religion as part of their other identities (e.g., Greek culture, Egyptian ethnicity, Roman citizen, freedman, merchant, monk).
Our transcription pipeline, curation interface, and search tools will be transferable to many other humanities projects. Both our tools and our results, enabled by well-tested large-scale crowd-sourced transcriptions, will be made available to other developers and scholars.
|
Human Mortality as Part of the Natural Process of Human Life (Gen 1:1–3:24)
Program Unit: Genesis
Kyong-Sook Seo, Brite Divinity School (TCU)
Death, it seems, is one of the great taboos in our culture. Most people consider the subject of death unmentionable and want to disguise the very fact of death by using a euphemism such as “gone up to heaven,” or “pass away.” To be sure, some Hebrew Bible texts convey the expression of anxiety toward death. On the other hand, many texts relating to death seem to reveal that ancient Israelites accepted death as human destiny without anxiety. Therefore, the question this paper addresses is how the ancient Israelites thought of death as acceptable.
According to the creation story, human beings are made of the dust of the ground as all living creatures. In other words, the earth is the extended body of human being. In this light, the creation story is revealing and suggests a profound statement about human identity that human beings are inseparably connected with the earth. Intrinsic to this worldview is human connectedness to, and dependence on the earth or the natural world as a whole, demonstrating the human bond to the earth from which we come, to which we go. If the Hebrew Bible presents the ancient Israelites’ awareness of the interconnectedness between humans and the earth or dust, the possibility is that some ancient Israelites accepted mortality as human destiny and as God’s original design for human beings in that dust symbolizes human mortality. If the immortality is intended for human beings, why does God need to expel the first human couple from the garden when God envisions the possibility of their immortality? God’s reflection in Gen 3:22-23 presupposes the idea that immortality is not God’s design for human beings. This paper will examine the creation story (Gen 1:1-2:3) that demonstrates the interconnectedness between humans and the earth and also discuss the passages in Gen 2:4-3:24 that imply death as a natural part of human life.
|
The Battle of Ramoth-Gilead and the Fall of the Omride Dynasty
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Omer Sergi, Tel Aviv University
As evidenced by archaeological finds as well as extra-biblical documents, under the Omride rule Israel became one of the most powerful kingdoms in the southern Levant, exerting regional hegemony in both cis- and trans-Jordan. Yet, Omride rule came to an abrupt end after less than half a century. Joram, the last Omride king, was defeated in the battle of Ramoth-gilead fought against Hazael, king of Aram-Damascus. Consequently, Jehu, son of Nimshi, a senior officer in the army of Joram, usurped power in a bloody coup.
The historical discussion about the fall of the Omrides was focused on Jehu's revolt but overlooked the event that enabled it—the battle of Ramoth-gilead. The Omride defeat in Ramoth-gilead marked a major change in the regional power-balance, as it led to the rise of Aramaean Hegemony, which replaced the former Omride hegemony. Thus, examining the circumstances behind the battle of Ramoth-gilead may also shed light on its political consequences, namely the fall of the Omride dynasty.
Three historical sources depict the battle between Joram and Hazael in the Gilead—two of them embedded in the biblical historiographic literature (2 Kings 8:28–29; 9:14–16) and one an extra-biblical document (the Aramaic Inscription from Dan). An additional prophetic story (1 Kings 22:1–38) tells about the defeat of an Omride king on the battlefield of Ramoth-gilead, but it is not clear to which historical event, if any, it refers. In this presentation I shall re-examine these sources in order to shed some new light on the battle within its historical context. Consequently I shall demonstrate that the Omride rule was weakened much before this battle and in this respect–the rise of the Aramaean hegemony during Jehu's reign was the outcome of historical process that has begun already during the Omride reign.
|
A Sign in the Dark: Moses's Cushite Wife and Boundary Setting in the Book of Numbers
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Ron Serino, Texas Christian University
Sitting at one of the primary intersections of gender and ethnicity in the book of Numbers is the figure of the Cushite woman, Moses’s wife, in Numbers 12. Who is this Cushite woman, and why does she materialize seemingly out of nowhere, only to disappear as fast as she appeared? In order to explore the ways that gender and ethnicity were used to define boundaries and construct identity in post-exilic Judah, this paper will focus on the role that the Cushite woman plays in the narrative of Numbers and the ideology behind her enigmatic, unique portrayal.
Employing Julia Kristeva’s concept of abjection, I propose that the Cushite woman is the pivot point that the post-exilic, priestly redactors of the book of Numbers utilize to accomplish three of their primary goals in rewriting Exodus: alienate the Midianites, alienate women, and alienate Moses. Who better to accomplish these goals than the Midianite wife of Moses?
Drawing upon the research and proposals of Mary Douglas, Claudia Camp, and Cheryl Exum, this paper will demonstrate that all foreign women in the book of Numbers are not created equally. Just as Camp finds circles drawn increasingly tighter around those authorized to be priests, I will explore the ways that Numbers carefully constructs degrees of difference for foreign women. Foreigners are welcome, but they are not to come too close – principally, they are not to threaten Israel’s land (including the proper worship of Israel’s God). Just how close is too close, and who is excluded at what times and why? It seems to me that the Cushite woman holds the key to unlocking this mystery in the book of Numbers. She is a sign in the dark.
|
Seeing Rape and Robbery: Harpagmos and the Philippians Christ Hymn
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Katherine A. Shaner, Wake Forest University
In the first century, images of imperial figures subduing foreign, sexualized women were installed throughout the civic spaces of the Roman Empire. The well-known reliefs on the Sebasteion in Aphrodisias are just one example. Such images were not only on permanent display in cities but also circulated in various ways, on coins and through traveling artisans. Images like these dominated the visual fields of ancient people. This presentation sets the Philippians Christ hymn (Phil 2:5-11) in the context of this visual culture and rhetoric of Roman military conquest, by examining the Sebasteion reliefs. Methodologically, I argue that reading the Christ hymn in conversation with the visual rhetoric of these reliefs (which depict Roman emperors violently subduing nations depicted as women) significantly shifts the interpretative framework for the hymn. The use of sexualized women’s bodies to depict conquered peoples suggests a particular context for the term _harpagmos_ in Philippians 2:6. Rather than the NRSV translation as “something to be exploited,” _harpagmos_ can be understood as “rape and robbery.” Thus in its presentation of Christ, the hymn simultaneously draws on and critiques Roman practices of subjugation.
|
Mormons and Midrash: Narrative Expansion as Interpretation in Mormonism and Early Judaism
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
Avram R. Shannon, Ohio State University
The Bible is a book which is ripe for interpretation, and throughout history, various groups and communities have interpreted the biblical text, according to their needs and understanding. One of the most intriguing ways in which this interpretation happens is through the expansion of the biblical narratives. These expansions often work to make the biblical stories into a form which is more familiar to the culture of producer, or which better fits the theological and cosmological framework of those producing the expansions. Expanding the narrative of the Bible causes the original text to be read within confines of the narrative expansion—in other words, the narrative expansion is read as part of the original biblical narrative.
Both rabbinic Judaism and Mormonism have traditions of narrative expansion on the biblical text. The Sages of ancient Judaism produced scriptural commentary called midrash, which provided interpretive expansions to the scriptural narrative. It was early Judaism’s belief in continuing tradition which created space in their biblical interpretation for narrative expansion of the biblical text. Many centuries later, Joseph Smith’s New Translation of the Bible added not just doctrinal interpretations, but also narrative expansions. The space for doing so in Mormonism was created by the concept of continuing revelation. In both early rabbinic Judaism and Mormonism, the idea of a continuing refinement of divine communication, either through tradition or through revelation, created a space for expansion of the biblical narrative.
This paper proposes to use a specific biblical example, the story of Adam and Eve, to explore the nature of narrative expansion in rabbinic Judaism and in Mormonism. For this project, I will be comparing Genesis 2:15-3:24 to Bereshit Rabba 14-21 and Moses 3:15-5:15. Because of its foundational status, and relatively spare language, the story of Adam and Eve provides fertile ground for narrative expansion in both rabbinic Judaism and the Joseph Smith Translation of the Bible. In addition, the story of Adam and Eve shows how narrative expansion can be a powerful tool for theological interpretation, as the midrash and the Joseph Smith Translation takes the original biblical narrative in radically different ways.
|
Dancing Voices, Embodied Interpretations: Experiencing Gen 22:1–20 through the Medium of a Choreographic Exegesis
Program Unit: Islands, Islanders, and Scriptures
Jacob Sharon, Luther College
Throughout history, artistic interpretations of Genesis 22:1-20 have tried to capture and translate the raw emotions simmering beneath the surface of this text. Bodies arrested by visual artists and emotions frozen on the canvas permit us to venture into the textual crevices to reclaim the narrative's affective power. Could movement and dance achieve an analogous effect in retelling this narrative and bringing to the surface those silent and invisible forces that are often left out, silenced, or intellectualized in scholarly and even artistic interpretation? The dancing body then, would transform into a text that moves and emotes as it retells the story through a kinetic medium. In dance, voices are seen and felt. The body in motion decenters the written and spoken word. The emotions of the characters, both visible and invisible, are brought to light as readers experience a choreographic exegesis. Dancing voices and embodied interpretations perform, resist, and challenge us to engage visually with narrative perspective, to feel the narrative emotions corporeally, and to see the silences as the written word leaps out of its textual medium and performs before us.
|
Gender and Subjectivity in Jeremiah 44
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
Carolyn J. Sharp, Yale Divinity School
Analysis of Judean constructions of gender in the exilic and early post-exilic periods faces enormous challenges. In study of the biblical prophetic corpus, scholars must work deftly at the nexus of several lines of inquiry. Interpretation of material finds, literary-critical analysis of relevant biblical texts, cultural analysis of the ancient social landscape, and alertness to the contextual norms and assumptions influencing the contemporary interpreter: all are essential to shed light on the ways in which femininity and masculinity were constructed by Judean scribes. Foundational to the present paper are two convictions: first, that reading practices produce meaning through our construals of the interplay between what a text says and what it suppresses; and second, that sophisticated ideological-critical awareness is crucial for sound interpretation. This paper will focus on two textual sites of inquiry: the hyperbolically dramatized agency of rebellious women in Jeremiah 44 and the distortions and near-silence of Jeremiah on the subjectivity of women otherwise. Foregrounded here will be exploration of textual indices (or the lack of same) regarding ways in which the book of Jeremiah works to gender male and female bodiedness, discursive power, and relations of domination. The scribalization of gendered understandings of subjectivity in Jeremiah 44 will be theorized, then, as revealing (some) functions of gender in biblical discursive formations that seek to control desire and conflict in communal life in diaspora. These textual explorations and theoretical soundings will guide us toward critical reflection on the methodological pitfalls and possibilities that confront our attempts to map gender in and through an ancient text such as Jeremiah.
|
Papyrus Bodmer III in the Critical Apparatus of NA28: Proposed Emendations to the Apparatus Based on the Original Text
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Daniel B. Sharp, Brigham Young University Hawaii Campus
In the summer of 2013, in connection with the Martin Bodmer Foundation, I oversaw the taking of digital photographs of Papyrus Bodmer III. PBodmer III, a Coptic version of the Gospel of John and the first four chapters of Genesis, has been known to scholars since 1958 through the transcription provided by Rodolphe Kasser but the Bodmer Foundation has never before made a complete set of images of this manuscript. Access restrictions and the lack of available images have forced most scholars working with PBodmer III to rely on the transcription of Kasser, although Kasser himself recognized the flaws of this early transcription. I have used the new digital photographs, mentioned above, to produce a new transcription of PBodmer III.
The purpose of my paper is to evaluate the accuracy of the citations of PBodmer III in the critical apparatus of the 28th Edition of the Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece using this new transcription and photographs. PBodmer III is cited by NA28 as a primary witness to the Greek text. Preliminary results show that while the majority of citations reflect the actual text of PBodmer III, there are several inaccurate citations. They also suggest that at no time has anyone working on the NA editions consulted the original PBodmer III manuscript because in every instance where Kasser’s 1958 transcription is inaccurate, the NA28 cites Kasser over the actual text. In addition, there are also instances where PBodmer III is an important witness to a reading but not cited.
This paper will present a summary of my findings of where the NA28 needs to be emendated. It will also give suggestions of important passages in John where PBodmer III may confidently be used as a witness for a reading where it is not currently cited. Since this paper will deal with the Gospel of John, it is important not only as an evaluation of NA28 but also of relevance to the upcoming critical edition of John. The IGNTP will also be using Coptic texts in its critical apparatus but, as of the time of this proposal, has been unable to gain access to this important witness in the Bodmer collection.
|
The Politics of (the) God(s): Divine Partiality and Particularity in Acts and in Ancient Historiography
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Scott Shauf, Gardner-Webb University
The understood nature of the divine’s relationship to the peoples of the world was of fundamental political importance in ancient historiography. Ancient historiographical narratives had political events as their primary plots, and almost all ancient historiography portrayed divine involvement in these events. The manner and extent of such divine involvement varied widely among historians, however. Two important facets of such variation are: 1) the relative partiality/impartiality with which the divine is seen acting towards different peoples; 2) the particularity of the deities portrayed. The presentation of Acts in regard to these points is illumined by situating Acts in the context of other ancient historiographical works.
In Greek and Roman historiography, there is near unanimity in seeing the gods as acting impartially. To whatever extent the divine is given a role in history, the divine acts impartially toward all groups and individuals. Moreover, these historians are consistently unconcerned about the particularities of the portrayed divinities, most often referring to the gods namelessly or else as a group, and the gods are always shown acting in accord. This does not imply uniform treatment of all peoples by the gods, as chance and fate are important divine principles, and some peoples are favored due to their virtue. Such favor is a product, however, of principles of divine action that apply to all. The politics of the gods are thus characterized primarily by impartial justice, with elements of chance and fate mixed in.
In direct contrast to these points are the particularity and partiality of the divine in biblical and traditional Jewish historiography. The divine in biblical and Jewish historiography is the God of Israel, a designation denoting both the particular divine identity and the divine partiality displayed toward Israel. The politics of God are centered on God’s relationship with Israel, other peoples being of only instrumental value in that relationship. There are Jewish historians, however, most notably Josephus and Philo, who attempt to bridge the Greco-Roman and Jewish traditions of historiography, thus in a number of ways moving the portrayal of God toward impartiality and non-particularity.
Acts, while firmly rooted in the Jewish tradition in the portrayal of God, nonetheless displays a similar concern. Acts’ strategy, however, is quite different from that of Josephus and Philo. The God of Acts remains firmly tied to Israel, in some ways showing a narrower partiality than is typical in Jewish historiography, as God’s special presence with Christians is emphasized. God is nonetheless given a greater interest in other peoples than in most Jewish historiography. The distinctiveness of the Acts portrayal can be summed up as a strong particularity of the divine combined with a sense of divine partiality expanding to encompass the peoples of the world, but never reaching the point of a broad divine impartiality. The politics of Acts are thus an inclusive sectarianism, remaining tied to God’s relationship to a particular people, even while other peoples are called to join this people.
|
The Onomastica in Earliest Christianity
Program Unit: Function of Apocryphal and Pseudepigraphal Writings in Early Judaism and Early Christianity
Frank Shaw, Independent Scholar
In the Function of the Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha Section of the 2012 SBL Annual Meeting I offered a background and history of the Judeo-Christian onomastica, originally composed during the Second Temple period as Greek works intended as commentary on the Septuagint. Then presented were the ideas that (1) these name lists should be considered as a largely ignored part of the Pseudepigrapha, and that (2) there appears to be evidence that writers of certain New Testament books (as well as their recipients) had these name lists at their disposal and used them in some of their compositions. Further research supports the latter idea. Citation from the onomastica are best known from patristic sources. Working backwards in time, I present evidence that helps establish a chronological chain of continuity of the use of these name lists, from their heavy utilization among church fathers such as Jerome and Eusebius, who are known for having composed their own editions of onomastica, back to Josephus and Philo. This supports the notion that the people who wrote and received certain NT documents were established in the practice of employing these name lists. Evidence for this thesis is both textual and linguistic. Seeing that the onomastica are the world’s first biblical commentaries/dictionaries, this is important, and it again shows how these primary sources, still heavily overlooked in modern biblical studies, have significant academic potential.
|
Crossing the River When We Come to It: The Euphrates as a Temporal Marker in Second Temple Judaism
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Shayna Sheinfeld, McGill University
Numerous geo-political landmarks mentioned in Jewish scripture and other ancient sources are known as existing geographic locations. In the Second Temple period, however, some of these landmarks take on a significance that is more temporal than geographic. While they may retain their association with the original physical locations, this literal meaning is overshadowed in certain texts by a symbolic meaning, namely, as a temporal marker of the eschaton. Their reinterpretation provides commentary on the new social and political situations that Jews found themselves in during Second Temple times.
Beginning in Genesis as one of the four branches of the river that issues forth water to the Garden of Eden, the river Euphrates functions in biblical texts as a geo-political border: it delineates the boundaries of the land promised to Abraham and his descendants and it demarcates the border of the Babylonian exiles, separating those who remain in the land from those in exile.
After the destruction of the Second Temple, however, the Euphrates transforms into a border separating the eschatological future from the crisis of the present. This transformation is reflected in the pseudepigraphic works of 4 Ezra and 2 Baruch, where the eventual restoration of the full community of Israel is imagined through both a physical and temporal crossing of the Euphrates. In 4 Ezra, the lost tribes of Israel must negotiate an 18-month journey across the Euphrates to present themselves before the messiah. 2 Baruch reaches across the Euphrates to the lost tribes by means of an epistle in order to tell them of the loss of the temple and warn them to continue their Torah observance. Both works build upon prophetic texts in imagining an idealized future and a restoration of all of Israel, but move beyond the utopian future to map the temporal qualities of the end times. This paper will explore the presentation of the Euphrates as a border that indicates temporal proximity to the eschaton and to the lost tribes in 4 Ezra and 2 Baruch.
|
How Do the Gentiles Become “Acceptable”? Dektos as an Interpretive Key to Luke-Acts
Program Unit: Formation of Luke and Acts
Pamela Shellberg, Bangor Theological Seminary
Although well established that Luke’s writings show signs of Isaianic influence, there has been limited scholarly attention given to Luke’s specific understanding of the word dektos (Isaiah 61) and none to the relationship between the words dektos and katharizo. However, the strength of Luke’s presentation of the deliberations among Jewish Christians concerning the place of Gentiles in believing communities (Acts 10–15) depends on these two very words. In this paper I will clarify the relationship between the two words and elucidate Luke’s particular understanding of dektos.
Katharizo, “to make clean,” is uniquely articulated in the Third Gospel through multiple references to lepers. Departing from rhetorical appeal to physiognomic markers, Luke creates literary and theological associations between the lepra-afflicted in the gospel and the Gentiles whose hearts are cleansed in Acts. Paired with the rarely appearing dektos, katharizo becomes identified with an Isaianic understanding of God’s favor. Luke establishes cleansing as a sign of divine power and prerogative, and the means by which Gentiles have become dektos—“acceptable”—to God (Acts 10:35).
Analyses of the two places in Luke-Acts where there is a proximate pairing of katharizo and dektos indicate that Luke locates the issue of Gentile acceptability within a symbolic field marked out by Luke 4 and Acts 10. The gateway to that symbolic field is dektos, and its boundaries are established by Luke’s use and interpretation of five Isaiah passages in which it is found.
|
Jesus as a Still Life with Oysters and Lemon: The Writing of Mark Doty and Biblical Studies
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Pamela Shellberg, Bangor Theological Seminary
In the book Still Life with Oysters and Lemon (Boston: Beacon Press, 2001), the poet Mark Doty offers a series of exquisite reflections on memory, intimacy, attention, and perception occasioned by his love affair with 17th century Dutch still life paintings. He writes of Osias Beert, a still life painter most well known for his paintings of oysters: “this is a testament to falling in love with light, its endless variation, its subtlety and complexity. I try to imagine coming to this kind of knowledge, a very specific, long practice of perception alloyed with a knowledge of materials-how to commingle oils and pigments just so, to the right texture, how to apply them in particular layers so as to translate this knowledge of the appearance of a particular gleam into paint” (page 16). In this paper, the Dutch still life painters, as seen through the eyes of Mark Doty, are compared to the gospel writers and Paul, artists with verbal oils and pigments, and a capacity to layer meanings so as to translate their knowledge of the gleam of God into text. Doty’s descriptions of the artists’ medium, the styles of individual painters, and their shared purpose of solving the problem of painting the light are drawn upon to describe the work of biblical studies. Thinking about biblical writers as still life painters—and biblical texts as still life paintings—opens up the metaphoric medium in which the texts are rendered, revealing the writers’ exegetical methods as well as their unique aesthetic sensibilities. And, insofar as the discipline of biblical studies, like the discipline of the still life painters, is one of cultivating long practices of close attention, the biblical texts—like still life paintings—give access to the interiority of the gospel writers and Paul, and an intimate view of their poetic effort to paint the glinting mystery of their religious experience.
|
Prolegomenon or Conclusio? Cyril of Alexandria, Robert Lowth, and the Ideology of Commentary
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Charles E. Shepherd, University of Durham
In a post-Reformation context of biblical interpretation, a shift has taken place in the nature of commentary. Whereas many patristic and medieval commentaries regarded biblical explication as standing within a wider, previous, and always-attendant theological reflection, in a post-Reformation context, the role of commentary was severely narrowed to function as prolegomenon, taking upon itself an increasingly apologetic role. Part of this shift included the substitution of the sensus literalis for the sensus historicus; while the former was flexible enough to include broad and diverse theological reflection, the latter became the basis from which any reflection would commence. Yet the sensus historicus is itself subject to numerous cultural forces and ideological presuppositions. As an exemplar of a practitioner unknowingly operating in this latter mode, the commentator (and Bishop) Robert Lowth produced a work of commentary-turned-apologetic, in his 1778 Isaiah. Seen from within Lowth’s context (and this only with the advantage of hindsight), his commentary represents an ideological mode of engaging the biblical texts that is not simply part of a diffused notion of sola scriptura, but part of a much broader cultural and ideological shift toward apologetics. Contrasted with Lowth is Cyril of Alexandria, for whom the task of explicating the biblical text is one that is always already situated within a broad and generous theological framework. Here, there is no felt need to subject Isaiah to quasi-apologetic ideological influences, for Cyril comments, at numerous junctures, on the difficulty and opacity that attends writing a theological commentary. For Cyril, explicating the text was something that came at the end of a long process of (self-)critical reflection. Alongside their respective ‘Introductions’, this paper will observe how each handles the opening chapter of the book of Isaiah, and what tacit assumptions attend each reading.
|
Must Textuality Eclipse Orality? Revisiting Isaiah’s Progressive ‘Kanonbewußtsein’
Program Unit: Orality, Textuality, and the Formation of the Hebrew Bible
Charles E. Shepherd, University of Durham
As contemporary scholarship on Isaiah has grown in appreciation for the contribution of redaction criticism, so has it come to focus upon the progressive, and increasing, role of textuality in the book’s formation. The rendering of past tradition (whether oral or textual) as sacred ‘Scripture’ holds special import for literary approaches to the book of Isaiah. In particular, for Brevard Childs (frequently in response to von Rad) the eclipse of orality by textuality was a significant – if not indispensible – component to his own canonical approach. What remained significant for Childs, then, was not an originary context of orality, but the transformation of prior oral tradition into a recontextualized, and thereby texualized, witness. This paper will note Childs’s various assumptions regarding the composition of Deutero-Isaiah (and Trito-Isaiah), and how these assumptions relate to a wider concern with the priority of textualized tradition. For Childs, the progressive development of a book was a fundamentally literary activity. Yet by placing Childs’s assumptions within a contemporary discussion of the development of Deutero-Isaiah, the eclipse of orality by textuality needs to be questioned. In fact, this paper will suggest that an appreciation of aspects of orality could strengthen some of Childs’s central, canonical, concerns.
|
Inner-Biblical Exegesis and Intertexts
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Michael B. Shepherd, Louisiana College
Analysis of inner-biblical exegesis ordinarily involves examination of the intertextual relationship between two texts within the biblical corpus. This analysis usually results in some sort of conclusion about what the dependent text has done with the source text. But in many cases there is an often overlooked intertext that serves as a bridge between the two texts. Such an intermediary text reads the primary text in a manner similar to the way the tertiary text reads it and supplies a missing link in a very subtle yet identifiable manner. This paper will present several examples of the phenomenon and offer suggestions for interpretation. The direction of dependence between texts of this kind will not be as important and the direction in which these texts were meant to be read by those who gave them their final shape. Examples include but are not necessarily limited to: (1) Gen 3:1, 14–15; Isa 27:1; 65:25 (2) Exod 15:2; Isa 12:2; Ps 118:14 (3) Exod 32:20; Deut 9:21; 2 Kgs 23:4, 6; 2 Chr 15:16; 30:14; 34:4 (4) Deut 17:14–20; 1 Sam 8; 1 Kgs 1–11 (5) Judg 4–5; Ps 68 (6) Isa 59:21.
|
History, Historical, Historiography: The Fourth Gospel’s Use of Dialogue as Window to the Past
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Beth M. Sheppard, Duke University
In this paper focus falls on the role of dialogue in Greco-Roman histories. First, how and when conversation rather than either orations or straight narrative is used by ancient historians for communicating information to their audiences is examined. Then the verbal exchange between Livia and Augustus concerning the conspiracy of Cinna Magnus (as found in Cassius Dio and Seneca) is employed as a foil for examining Jesus’ conversation with the Samaritan Woman in John 4. A survey of modern classical scholarship’s varied assessment of the historicity of the Cinna conspiracy follows to demonstrate that impasses about the historical nature of dialogical accounts of the past are not unique to the field of Biblical Studies. Concluding observations about the limits of the particular modern method that tends to result in inability to achieve consensus are presented and suggestions about alternate modern historiographical methods that may offer a way forward are raised.
|
Biblical Archaeology as Biblical Theology: G. Ernest Wright’s Construction of Rigid Ethnic Boundaries in the Ancient Past and the Mid-Twentieth Century
Program Unit: Metacriticism of Biblical Scholarship
Brooke Sherrard, Iowa State University
American biblical archaeologists in the mid-twentieth century found themselves working in the politically charged atmosphere of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. While many of them, like William Foxwell Albright and G. Ernest Wright, argued that scholarship could successfully be separated from politics, others, like Millar Burrows and Paul Lapp, adopted pro-Palestinian political positions and argued that scholarship and politics were necessarily intertwined. Through extensive study of these archaeologists’ published writings and letters, I have come to the conclusion that the main difference between the two camps lay in their scholarly worldviews, specifically what they believed about cultural interaction. The archaeologists who envisioned the ancient world’s ethnic boundaries as rigid and impermeable — e.g., Albright and Wright — were also in favor of the establishment of a Jewish state at mid-century. Archaeologists who envisioned the ancient world as replete with cultural change and interchange — e.g., Burrows and Lapp — opposed its establishment and argued that Jews and Palestinians could coexist in the region. In this paper I focus on the way Wright’s blend of biblical archaeology with biblical theology aided the rigidification of difference between ancient Israelites and ancient Canaanites he produced in his writings. This argument is established through reference to two of Wright’s most well-known books, The Westminster Historical Atlas to the Bible (1945), co-written with Floyd Filson, and The Old Testament against its Environment (1950). I further argue that this rigidification of difference had implications for Wright’s understanding of his own context. Wright, operating under the aegis of archaeology as a scientific endeavor, castigated colleagues in the American Schools of Oriental Research for mixing politics and scholarship when they adopted pro-Palestinian positions while he, when adopting stances favorable to Israelis, masked the political nature of his decisions with the rhetoric of objectivity and neutrality. This section of the paper is supported by the large volume of letters produced in 1968 after four ASOR members, including Wright’s beloved Ph.D. student, Lapp, signed a letter protesting the Israeli military’s plan to route a parade through parts of recently occupied East Jerusalem. Lapp was well known for his support of Palestinian rights, support that was as grounded in his scholarly methodology as Wright’s support for a Jewish ethno-national state was in his. Lapp rebelled against Albright and Wright’s epistemology by insisting knowledge was relative and political. As he explored in his published book of lectures, Biblical Archaeology and History (1966), he believed archaeological data were necessarily interpreted, and that interpretations differed depending on one’s subjectivity. Through this discussion of the differences between Wright and Lapp, I establish that not all biblical archaeology was inherently Zionist, as some scholars have argued.
|
Timely Visions of Humanity in Jub. 5:1–13 and 23:26–31
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Aaron Sherwood, Alliance Theological Seminary
An interpretive change that the author of Jubilees makes to his Genesis source is, at certain moments, the conjunction of present and urzeit, looking forward to the eternal implication of immediate events. In two instances, in 5:1–13 and 23:26–31, this includes the presentation of a united humanity comprising both Jews and non-Jews, and in the first case represents a moment of endzeit wird urzeit with the primeval deluge being connected to the eschaton. Several early Jewish traditions anticipate the restoration of humanity and even the nations’ participation in Israel’s worship, blessings and heritage (e.g. 1 Enoch 10:16–11:2; Tobit 13:5–11; 14:3–11; Sib. Or. 3:772-–95), but these moments in Jubilees are all the more remarkable in that such a “positive” approach runs counter to the otherwise vitriolic orientation toward the nations throughout the rest of the book. Accordingly, this phenomenon deserves a deeper investigation.
|
The Restoration of Humanity in Tob 14:3–11: Text Recensions and Incongruous Theology
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Aaron Sherwood, Alliance Theological Seminary
The textual history of Tobit is a complex one, but scholars’ acceptance of the long recension in light of the Qumran evidence only displaces the problem of the book's ending to being on of theological coherence: Why does the story of a righteous, individual Diaspora Jew, with tribal and familial emphases throughout, end with a vision of all humanity? Scholars including I. Nowell, D. McCracken, J. Cousland and A. Portier-Young contribute much toward the answer, in terms of identifying the comedic and mythical nature of the narrative. However, fully understanding the twist that ends Tobit and discovering whether its theology is consistent overall requires recognizing the presence of a neglected, Hellenistic Jewish (biblical) narrative-theological principle regarding humanity, generally. Namely, the author of Tobit sharpens his focus upon Jewish piety and importance by invoking its intended telos of the cosmic, eschatological restoration of humanity within the particular scope of the worship of Israel’s God.
|
The Mestizo Bible of Diego Durán
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Yvonne Sherwood, University of Kent at Canterbury
Homi Bhabha, the thinker who could be said to have colonised the field of postcolonial studies, writes of the strange ‘pressure’ of the ‘adversarial’ acting ‘constantly, if unevenly, along the entire boundary of authorization’. This pressure is overtly performed within the Hebrew Bible. The outside is always inside. The others are already there, before us, from the beginning. Genesis is full of twins, other brothers, doubles, surrogate families born of Egyptian slaves. The constant complaint of an always unrealised orthodoxy is that Israel is syncretised, mestizo, creol: never purely itself. In Christian tradition, the tension between ‘inside’ and ‘outside’ is massively complicated by attempts to clarify the degree of relation between the Old and New Testaments, somewhere between typological twinship and absolute enmity. The Old Testament foreshadows Christian time but is also of a time before the Christian: a temporally foreign space.
These ambiguities were amplified in the little-known biblicised ethnographies of Diego Durán: The Book of the Gods and Rites (1574-1576) and A History of the Indies of New Spain (1581). A Dominican descended from a converso family and an immigrant to Mexico by the time he ‘acquired his second teeth’, Durán read Indian rites through the dense web of the Bible (predominantly the Hebrew Bible: Christianity’s intimate-foreign space). Unlike writers of the high Victorian empire, well-practised in turning the Bible into a bland ‘icon containing civilizing properties,’ Durán produced an excruciatingly detailed mapping of Indian practices and myths onto biblical texts. He was drawn to stories of migration, diffusion (Exodus and Babel), and twins who do not understand one another (Esau and Jacob). Above all he was drawn to Israel as a figure of a mixed people, a threatened people, and a people infinitely hard to place.
|
‘Sans Papiers’: The Problems That Pre-modern Gods and Empires Experience in Actualizing Claims to the Land
Program Unit: Postcolonial Studies and Biblical Studies
Yvonne Sherwood, University of Kent at Canterbury
The question posed by this paper is: ‘How (on earth) did pre-modern powers and empires transfer gifts of land from paper to earth, or facts on the ground?’ We curiously over-exaggerate the powers of pre-modern Gods, Bibles and Empires and falsely retroject a now lost universality or absolute sovereign political power. But powers, even (especially) theological powers, are dependent on technological and transport infrastructures. Without the resources of international law, maps, printing presses, satellites, nation-states, passports, borders and ‘papers’, the pre-modern forces that we imagine as most bombastic and secure, such as the Spanish Empire and the Bible, were insecure about the processes—as well as the justice—of giving themselves gifts of land.
The best that pre-modern gods and texts could do was write, by hand, in the presence of an angel or a notary. In the book of Jubilees, where everyone is frantically writing, Noah produces a document clarifying the land gift to Shem, Ham and Japheth in the presence of an angel. But the words don’t stick and civil-fraternal war and land disputes result. The world-gorging Papal Bull of Alexander VI (1493) famously ‘gave, granted and assigned’ ‘firm lands’ to Ferdinand and Isabella. Less famously, it ended by worrying about the difficulty of distributing news of the gift and making it take to the land. The notorious Requerimiento attempted to actualise the biblical gift of Canaan/New Spain by reading extracts from the Vulgate in the presence of a notary before the ‘Indians’. But the bizarre ritual was besieged by attacks on the justice and the efficacy of the process. This paper explores the internal weakness of pre-modern colonial land-claims, prior to indigenous resistance. It ends with a reading of Francisco de Vitoria, the bridge between pre-modern land claims and modern international law.
|
You Can’t Get a Sage to Do a Prophet’s Job: Overcoming Wisdom’s Deficiency in the Book of Job
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Martin Shields, University of Sydney
You Can’t Get a Sage to Do a Prophet’s Job: Overcoming Wisdom’s Deficiency in the Book of Job
|
Evidence of Market Economy and Economic Rationality in the Gospel of Luke: Initial Proposal
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Seungwoo Shim, Brite Divinity School (TCU)
In this paper, I argue that presentations of economic issues in Luke’s Gospel provide evidence of advanced economic features of the Roman economy in terms of its economic development. More concretely, I argue that the advanced economic features of the economy consist of two aspects: (1) the economy operates to some extent in accordance with economic principles and rationality centering on economic optimization--the maximization of profit and/or the minimization of cost; (2) the economy assumes to a considerable degree aspects of a market economy.
This paper lies basically in an extension of the post-Polanyi and Finley debate. Polanyi and Finley underscore the concept of economic substantivism that regards an economy as neither independent nor autonomous but as embedded in the society as a whole. Later, many scholars, such as Keith Hopkins, Joseph Manning, Ian Morris, Walter Scheidel, and Peter Temin, have challenged their view, admitting that Polanyi and Finley underestimated too much the significance of a market economy and the performance of the ancient Roman economy (for example,). Therefore, these scholars direct their attention to economic factors in themselves rather than anthropological or cultural factors. Furthermore, their critical reflections on previous scholarship lead them to note diverse and dynamic aspects of the Roman Economy, beyond the traditional image of a self-sustaining agricultural economy.
Within this perspective, this paper proposes some evidence of advanced economic features of the Roman economy by taking Luke’s Gospel as a test case. First, I briefly examine some selected passages in Luke that I argue inscribe aspects of a market economy. In the instruction on lending money (6:34-5), I address the issue of financial business in the Roman world including the scholarly debate on the existence of financial markets. In the parable of the rich fool (12:13-21), I explore the issues of inheritance, storage and inventory, land, and investment. In particular, I argue that the scene reveals the motive of profit more strongly than the more conventional claim that leisure or ease determines the rich fool’s actions. Second, I briefly review some selected passages in Luke to identify evidence of economic principles and rationality that primarily focus on economic optimization including profit maximization and/or cost minimization and some economic principles alternative to profit maximization. In the discourse on watchful slaves (12:35-48), I examine the issues of principal and agents, moral hazard, a monitoring system such as surprise visits and harsh penalties, and personal management.
|
Redemption from Satan, Sin, and Death: Mark 10:45b and Its Relationship to Images of Redemption in Hebrews
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Elizabeth Shively, University of St. Andrews
Scholars have debated the authenticity and unity of Mark 10:45; however, its biggest conundrum lies in the meaning of lutron in v. 45b. Most views are reductionistic and do not seek the term’s best sense within the context of Mark’s whole narrative. Essential to its meaning is its fit within Mark’s presentation of the conflict between the Spirit-filled Jesus and Satan. First, I show that the background of the word lutron allows for the audience to expect a plural connotation in Mark’s context: liberation from captivity and ritual expiation. Second, through analysis of Mark’s symbolic world, the narrative, and intertextual echoes, I demonstrate that cosmic conflict runs throughout the whole narrative and governs all other conflicts. Third, I look at how development of statements and themes about Jesus’ “coming” throughout the narrative inform Jesus’ mission statement in 10:45. The narrative’s unfolding presentation impacts the meaning of the ransom saying in 10:45b: Mark portrays a multi-faceted redemption through Jesus’ death and resurrection, in which Christus Victor is the leading idea bound with liberation from the guilt of sin. Finally, I look at how the writers of Hebrews develop a multi-faceted redemption by presenting Jesus as the one who has come both to take away sin and to destroy the works of the devil. I highlight the similarities and differences of these writings with Mark in outlook and theology, in order to demonstrate that my reading of Mark is not an anomaly and to show how these ideas are expanded in other 1st c. Christian contexts. In the process, I reconsider the significance of patristic interpretations that employ such texts in their readings of the ransom saying (e.g., Heb 2:14).
|
Spirit in Romans: Its Significance for a Multi Ethnic Ecclesiology in Asia
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Zakali Shohe, Trinity Theological College, India
Spirit in Romans: Its Significance for a Multi Ethnic Ecclesiology in Asia
|
The Dual Textual History of the Song of Habakkuk in the Ethiopic Manuscript Tradition
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Shaun Short, George Fox Evangelical Seminary
The Song of Habakkuk occurs not only within the Minor Prophet manuscripts of the Ethiopic manuscript tradition but is also present as the Eleventh Biblical Canticle within the Ethiopic Psalter. The goal of this study is to comprehensively compare the textual histories of the Song of Habakkuk in both these manuscript types. We identified and gathered manuscripts that represent the entire chronological range within the Minor Prophet text and the Canticle text. Subsequently we transcribed more than thirty manuscripts of the Psalter text and thirty manuscripts of Habakkuk chapter 3 from our Minor Prophet manuscript collection, (these were used for the Textual History of the Ethiopic Old Testament Project). For both manuscripts types we identified family traditions and their date ranges and thereafter generated lists of characteristic readings for each family.
In this presentation we will seek to answer a number of questions related to textual issues. To what degree does the text preserved in Psalter manuscripts undergo revision across the centuries, or does this happen at all? What elements of comparison and difference become evident between the development of the Song of Habakkuk in the Canticle text and the text of the Minor Prophet manuscripts? Is it apparent that the textual history of the one text in some way affects the textual history of the other text, or does this not occur at all? These are the significant questions that we will uncover in our examination of the dual textual history of the Ethiopic Song of Habakkuk.
|
Nuptial Imagery, Christian Devotion, and the Marriage Debate in Late Roman Society
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Karl Shuve, University of Virginia
In his groundbreaking monograph The Cult of the Saints (1981), Peter Brown shattered the perception that devotion to the relics of holy Christians was a “vulgar” or “popular” phenomenon, demonstrating the manifold ways in which the religious “elite” participated in a massive cultural transformation that positioned the dead bodies of saints as the link between heaven and earth. In this paper, I would like to attempt a similar re-thinking of a central aspect of early Christian devotional practice, although one that runs in the opposite direction. By the late fourth century, nuptial imagery had become ubiquitous in Christian discourse as a means of conceptualizing union with God. In modern scholarship, this discourse is imagined as the province of the philosophical elite, who alone possessed both the education and the leisure to pursue contemplation of the divine. The noted medievalist Ann Matter, for example, traces the veritable explosion of early medieval Latin commentaries on the Song of Songs to the “rarified intellectual atmosphere” of Origen’s Alexandria, which was disconnected from the concerns of ordinary Christians. But this is to overlook the way in which nuptial imagery, in general, and the Song of Songs, in particular, became bound up with debates over the goodness of marriage and the appropriateness of chastity in fourth-century Italian society, which cut across our imagined binaries “popular”/“elite”,“lay”/ “clerical”. Advocates of the ascetic life, like Ambrose and Jerome, used the image of the “bride of Christ”, which had long been used to describe the church’s unwavering fidelity to Christ, to connect the spiritual purity demanded of all Christians with the physical integritas of consecrated virgins, rendering soteriology unintelligible outside of a worldview that idealized asceticism. I will offer a re-reading of Ambrose’s On Isaac or the Soul, traditionally identified as the founding text of Western mysticism and esotericism, as a salvo in the war over marriage and virginity, which was deliberately composed in multiple registers in order to appeal both to his congregation and episcopal colleagues and which portrayed salvation and sanctification in unambiguously ascetic terms. It forms part of an on-going, and not always cordial, dialogue with his parishioners over the place of marriage in the church and society at large.
|
Job's Religious Position and the Nature of His Conflict with the Friends: A New Understanding
Program Unit: Wisdom in Israelite and Cognate Traditions
Avi Shveka, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
The aim of this lecture is to present the outline of a research project in progress on the book of Job, to be published by both of us as a series of papers, currently in different stages of publication or preparation.In this project we suggest a new understanding of the religious and moral positions of Job, and of the nature of his conflict with his friends. It is commonly believed that in the later stages of the dialogue, Job no longer believes in God’s providence in the world or in the existence of divine justice. Accordingly, it is assumed that the conflict between Job and his friends reflects the different opinions they have on these matters. In our opinion, these assumptions are incorrect; Job’s religious position is more complex than commonly presented, and the argument between him and his friends is not so much about facts – relating to the ways of God or of the world – but about the proper, or improper human attitudes towards the reality of the world. In order to establish these claims we focus on chapters 21 and 25-27 of Job and reinterpret them. As part of this discussion we claim that the third cycle of speeches is not textually corrupted, as commonly assumed, but rather stands in its original form. What seem to prove the damaged state of this cycle are, in fact, literary devices that serve the argumentative structure of the book. The reason that most scholars reject the attribution of the chapters 26-27 to Job is, in our view, precisely the fact that Job's position was not hitherto understood properly.
|
“Then Was Fulfilled”: Jeremiah, Zechariah, and the Death of Judas in Matthew
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Catherine Sider Hamilton, University of Toronto
How is the death of Judas in Matthew’s Gospel to be understood? By the traditional reading, Judas’ death is damning: his suicide enacts his self-exclusion from the salvation promised in Jesus (cf. Gundry 1994). More recently, scholars have sought to rehabilitate Judas. Far from cementing his condemnation, Judas’ death is a sign of his repentance, even nobility, and points toward redemption (Klassen 1996; Whelan 1993). The readings are coherent but mutually contradictory, finding in Matt 27:3-10 on the one hand sin and condemnation; on the other, sin and salvation. Is it possible to find an approach that does justice to what is convincing in both readings? This paper proposes that Matthew’s use of Scripture is illuminating for the debate. Matt 27:9-10 comments on the episode in a quotation from Zechariah attributed (famously) to Jeremiah. Scholarly attention has focused on the problem of (mis)-attribution. This paper argues rather that the “mistake” is useful: in calling up both Zech 11 and Jeremiah, Matthew sets the death of Judas within a particular scriptural history. Scholars note in 27:3-10 points of contact, brought to the fore by Matthew’s reference to Jeremiah in 27:9, with Jer 18, 19 and 32 (Brown 1994; Davies and Allison 1997); Gundry (1975; 1994; cf. Senior 1985) draws attention, persuasively, to Jer 19 in particular. This paper undertakes a close reading of these chapters together with Zechariah 11 to find in the conjunction an emerging theme: the land and its fate; defilement, exile and the hope of return. Against this scriptural background, I hope to show, Judas’ death unfolds as a story of defilement – “innocent blood” – and its consequences, a story set within Israel’s larger story in which both devastation and hope, and indeed restoration, may, in the blood of Jesus, be true.
|
“The Wife of Uriah” (Matt 1:6): Innocent Blood, David’s Sin, and the Problem of Exile in Matthew’s Genealogy
Program Unit: Matthew
Catherine Sider Hamilton, Wycliffe College, University of Toronto
Matthew’s genealogy is, a recent monograph states, one of the most vexed areas of interpretation in NT studies (Hood 2011). This paper proposes that Matt 1:6—a vexed passage within a vexing genealogy—offers a way in to the question of meaning in the genealogy and indeed in the Gospel. The verse is generally read against the background of the series of four women who punctuate the genealogy in Matt 1:1-6. Alone among the women, however, Bathsheba is not named. Current scholarly consensus finds significance in the omission, an emphasis on Uriah signaling the Gospel’s interest in the gentiles (Gundry, 1994; Carter 2002; Hood 2011). Davies and Allison (1997, cf. Carter 2002) point also, without elaboration, to “the sin of David, who had Uriah killed.” This paper begins from Davies and Allison’s suggestion to argue, first, that the significance of “the wife of Uriah” lies not primarily in her relation to the other women of the genealogy but in her relation to David. The phrase calls up 2 Sam 11-12 and the story of David, Bathsheba and Uriah -- and David's sin -- there told. Second, the paper traces commonalities between Matthew’s interest in David and the wife of Uriah, and interest in David and “the blood of Uriah” in early Jewish texts from CD to the rabbis, to argue that Matt 1:6 raises the spectre of “innocent blood” and the problem of exile, locating the birth of Jesus, David’s son, in relation to Israel’s fate and Israel’s hope. The primary focus, that is, is not the gentiles. Matthew’s phrase, “the wife of Uriah,” sets the Gospel narrative from its beginning against the backdrop of exile and return, under the rubric of innocent blood.
|
Scribalism and the Micah Prophecies: A Fresh Look at the Formation of Prophetic Literature
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Anna E. Sieges, Baylor University
From the time of Bernhard Stade, scholars generally have recognized Mic 1–3 as the earliest unit in Micah. For many years scholars conceived of this unit as originating with the eighth century prophet while the remainder of Micah belonged to later centuries. Hans Walter Wolff was the first to suggest deuteronomistic updates to Micah 1–3 as a project of the exilic period. Later scholars such as James Nogalski, Aaron Schart and Jakob Wöhrle have followed Wolff’s observation of a deuteronomistic layer in Micah 1–3 and suggested redactional models of their own. These redactional models lack a substantial consideration of ancient scribal practices. This paper will consider the prophetic and scribal groups that formed Micah 1–3. It will argue that there are two primary levels in Mic 1–3. The earliest level dates to the time of Micah (eighth century) and his prophetic cohort (1:8, 10–15*, 2:1–11, 3:1–12). After the destruction of Jerusalem, Micah’s eighth century prophecy that Jerusalem would be destroyed (cf. Mic 3:12) received renewed interest and was reinterpreted by deuteronomistic groups who completed the second level of Mic 1–3 by attaching a new introduction to the collection of Mican sayings (1:1, 3–7, 9, 12b, 13b, 16). These updates reframe Mic 1–3 by suggesting that Micah’s prophecies were the correct prediction of Jerusalem’s destruction in 587 BCE. This evaluation of the process by which Mic 1–3 was formed will take into account the most recent scholarship on ancient scribal practices. It will incorporate Jörg Jeremias, David Carr, and Karel van der Toorn’s recent work on scribalism in the Hebrew Bible. By considering these valuable contributions to scholarly understanding of ancient scribalism, the paper will shed new light on the process by which Mic 1–3 was formed and add to the ongoing conversation about the redaction of Micah.
|
The Origin of Political Agency in I Samuel 8
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
Allan Silver, Columbia University
The Hebrew bible knows political rule only among pagans until I Samuel 8. Religious and secular scholars have subtly asked whether Israel errs in its stunning, amazingly successful demand for kingship. Machiavelli correctly, though reluctantly, understands that Moses’ leadership is not political. In the intensively contested political theology of 17th century England, only Hobbes raises the core question from the perspective of political theory– how is legitimate political agency possible in “God’s “reall, not metaphorical kingdom”? Gideon’s men are politically naïve--they do not acclaim a king, but a dynastic war lord. Israel’s demand for kingship, however, is a daring, sophisticated and creative response to an urgent succession crisis of authority for which it is not responsible. The narrative elides God’s and Samuel’s contributions to the crisis, for which they offer no solution. For example, the problematic length of Samuel’s leadership, key to the crisis, is unrecorded although some such information is given for all preceding charismatic leaders. Israel neither usurps God’s sole authority to authorize charismatic leadership nor acclaims a king, and it knowingly accepts Samuel’s account of kingship’s powers (mishpat ha-melekh). It seeks a new institutional regime occupying a new political space in which, for example, kingship and prophecy reciprocally imply each other. The narrator of I Samuel 8, a seminal political theorist, interprets the very origin of the distinction between sacred and political authority.
|
Theorizing with the Text and Theorizing in the Text: Judges 9 and the Adequacy of Charismatic Authority for the Study of Biblical Israel
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
Edward Silver, Wellesley College
Despite its broad influence on the field, Max Weber’s discussion of charismatic authority presents the historian of ancient Israel with some significant difficulties. As some Marxist scholars have noted, charisma is particularly difficult to operationalize; unlike traditional and rational claims to authority, Weber left its social basis critically under-theorized. At times, he attributed its manifestation to external social upheaval, while elsewhere he rooted it in some luminous quality inhering in the individual social actor. For the biblicist, the problem is compounded by Weber’s synthesis of textual evidence. His model combined the spontaneous forms of social authority described in the Book of Judges with the more subtle manifestations of critical power evident in prophetic literature. The basis for this combination was, in Weber’s thought, an evolutionary attitude toward the religion of ancient Israel—one that strikes the contemporary reader as anything but value-free. The present essay addresses this theoretical problem by considering Israelite authors’ own discourse on non-traditional/non-rational claims to domination. In particular, it approaches the discussion of Abimelekh’s seizure of power described in Judges 9 as a generalizable discourse on the nature of social power. Approaching both Yotham’s parable and the narrative portrayal of Abimelekh as examples of indigenous political theorizing, we may come to understand how the biblical authors themselves comprehended the social ground for and the practical limits of charismatic authority. The resulting discussion may be juxtaposed with Weber’s original presentation in order to develop a more properly critical theoretical tool for historical and sociological analysis.
|
Onomatopoeia in the Book of Jeremiah: Embodied Verbal Performance and the Text that Resists Interpretation
Program Unit: Writing/Reading Jeremiah
Edward Silver, Wellesley College
This essay considers the deployment of onomatopoeia as a literary device in the Book of Jeremiah. It connects this figure of speech with the invocation of materiality and the description of bodily performances elsewhere in the book. It is significant that onomatopoeia presents words for which the vocal expression of their phonic character is directly connected with their meaning. This physical, iconic association between sign and meaning structurally resembles prophetic action scenes in which the prophet’s bodily performance directly signifies. Both of these assert—in direct contrast to other, more arbitrary forms of oracular discourse—a direct, material correlation between the thing being signified and the verbal signifier. They are a literary counterpart to other iconic deployments of the body in the Deuteronomic tradition, at once constraining the interpreting subject and re-grounding the act of interpretation. In this way, the use of onomatopoeia in the Book of Jeremiah worked to create a prophetic text whose meaning would remain stable in the face of trauma, social dislocation, and political upheaval.
|
Judaeans under Persian Labor and Migration Policies
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
Jason M. Silverman, Universiteit Leiden
The use of forced migration and forced labor by the Achaemenids has received almost no scholarly attention, despite hints that both were widely used strategies. Moreover, the implications of these strategies for the Judaean populations within the empire has also gone mostly unnoticed. To understand the relations of these two neglected issues it is necessary to reconstruct both some of the historical evidence for their use and their likely sociological impacts within the Persian Empire with (ethnic) populations at large. Since this would be a major undertaking, this paper primarily seeks to determine on the basis of sociological models of forced labor and migration what kinds of impact on Judaeans can be expected from a few Persian case studies, and which of these impacts are likely to be directly visible within literary traces (i.e., the Hebrew Bible). This discussion will proceed under three headings: building projects, military colonies, and the organization of minority (work) groups. The implications of these results for further research are then suggested.
|
"They Took and Made Their Own": Imperial Policy and Local Law Regarding Theft in Persian Egypt
Program Unit: Egyptology and Ancient Israel
Brandon J. Simonson, Boston University
During the campaign of Cambyses and the subsequent Persian conquest of Egypt, there was a drastic change in the political environment of the land as Egypt yielded its imperial authority to Persia. Locally administered laws, however, largely remained in place, as Persian authorities adopted prevailing Egyptian law to govern the newly conquered communities throughout its territory. To demonstrate the acceptance and utilization of locally prevailing Egyptian law during the Persian period, this paper examines local records of theft in an imperial context, specifically the records as they appear in the Elephantine papyri and in the Demotic and Aramaic legal traditions. Crimes related to theft are well documented in legal traditions throughout the ancient Near East and Egypt and provide insight into realities throughout both locations during this time. In this analysis of theft as it is documented in the Elephantine papyri, the Aramaic terms used to describe theft and their Egyptian parallels are considered. Demotic antecedents to the Aramaic terms and formulae demonstrate the function of Egyptian law in this community during the Persian period, which also has implications on the function of law in ancient Israel at this time. The unique ties between the Jewish garrison at Elephantine and the Jews living in the province of Yehud allow this study to offer a portrait of how local law in Yehud may have endured through Persian rule. It is concluded that Persian administrators did indeed take local Egyptian law and make it their own, enforcing locally prevailing law at Elephantine. Ultimately, the legal documents of the community at Elephantine demonstrate continuity in the Egyptian legal tradition.
|
The Eschatological Kerygma of the Early Qur'anic Surahs in Light of Syriac Literature
Program Unit: The Qur’an and the Biblical Tradition (IQSA)
Nicolai Sinai, Oxford University
Among the different topics treated in the Qur'an, eschatology - i. e., statements pertaining to the end of the world, the Resurrection (al-qiyama), the "Day of Judgement" (yawm al-din), and otherworldly rewards and punishments - is particularly fundamental. Not only is the idea of an ultimate reckoning invoked throughout the entire Qur'an, but many of the briefest surahs (for instance, Q 77-92, 95-96, 99-104, 107, and 111) are almost exclusively dominated by eschatological motifs, an observation which is plausibly taken to indicate that eschatology constitutes the first major subject of the Qur'anic proclamations. Following in the footsteps of Tor Andrae, my paper proposes to examine the numerous overlaps between the early Qur'anic kerygma and Syriac eschatology, as expressed in the sermons attributed to Ephrem and Jacob of Serugh. Particular attention will be devoted to similarities in literary form, such as the marked taste for symmetrical juxtapositions which is observable both in the Qur'an and the Syriac homiletic tradition. Finally, some pertinent differences - such as the fact that the Qur'an presents itself as divine discourse rather than human homiletic discourse - will also be duly highlighted.
|
The Rhetoric of the Apocalypse of John: Through the Lens of Vision-Reports
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Rebecca Skaggs, Patten University
Over the years, many scholars have acknowledged the importance of the ‘seeing/hearing’ motif in understanding the Apocalypse. Several questions emerge: is there a pattern which sheds light on what John is trying to convey? How do the auditory and visual experiences relate to one another? Does what is heard add to, or interpret, what is seen, and vice versa?
Some scholars (cf., Caird and Sweet) suggest that the hearing/seeing represents ‘the inner reality’ that is, the spirit and essence of what John sees. Ressequie agrees that the hearing uncovers what is hidden, its inner nature, thus placing ‘the seeing in a new perspective’. Still other scholars consider the audio/visual motifs as merely characteristic of apocalyptic genre.
In Revelation, there are forty-six seeing/hearing analogues. In all but eight, the vision comes first, followed by the audition. What is heard adds to understanding what is seen, yet it does not change the meaning of either analog (for example, in the list of seals [ch. 6], the audio/visual components are mutually complementary).
In contrast, there are only eight examples of the hearing coming before seeing. In each of these, what is heard is reinterpreted by what is seen. The classic example of this is: John hears the lion, and then turns and sees the sacrificed Lamb (Rev. 5). What is seen broadens the reader’s understanding, and opens the way for new perspective. The analysis of the eight passages exhibiting this ‘hearing/seeing’ pattern (1:10-16; 5:5-6; 9:1-4, 4-11, 16-19; 11:15-18; 19:1-20; 21:9-27), shows that significant argumentation is embedded within the vision. In each such case, the images dominate and are given direction and interpretation by embedded propositions (cf., Humphrey, Voice, pp. 28, 155, and 200). Taken together, these messages give insight into the rhetorical nature of the Apocalypse.
|
The Audio-Visual Motif in the Apocalypse of John
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Rebecca Skaggs, Patten University
Many scholars over the years have acknowledged the significance of the ‘hearing/seeing’ motif for understanding the Apocalypse. Little consensus in this, however, has been achieved. Some scholars (i.e., Caird and Sweet) suggest that the hearing represents ‘the inner reality’, the spirit and essence of what John sees. Resseguie agrees and holds that the hearing uncovers what is hidden, the inner nature, thus placing ‘the seeing in a new perspective’. Still others consider the audio/visual effects as merely characteristic of Apocalyptic genre.
Without doubt, the ‘hearing/seeing’ construction is significant. In fact, an exploration of this phrase throughout the text indicates that the author uses multiple patterns. The question is: do these variations indicate differing meanings, are they alternative ways of saying the same thing, or, is there one predominant meaning?
The use of these patterns is important: out of forty-six analogues, only eight have the vision following the audition. Hence, the author is not using these motifs randomly. Further, Edith Humphreys has recently argued that vision reports in particular include embedded argumentation; when the hearing is first, the images dominate and are given direction by these propositions (Voice, pp. 28, 155, 200).
This study will consider these various patterns and suggest some interpretative possibilities for understanding the Apocalypse.
|
Toward a Theory of Character for Interpreting the Gospel of John
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Christopher W. Skinner, Mount Olive University
Attempts at interpreting the characters of the Fourth Gospel are fraught with difficult questions: How do characters within John's story relate to reality, if at all? Do understandings of character within contemporary literary studies hold any value for reading the Gospel of John? What are we to make of anonymity as it applies to John's characters? Do historical individuals stand behind these literary figures? This paper will address these and other questions, explore obstacles to arriving at a theory of character, and suggest a way forward for interpreting the characters of the Fourth Gospel.
|
Who Speaks for (or Against) Rome? Acts in Relation to Empire
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Matthew L. Skinner, Luther Seminary
Despite the many references Acts makes to the officials, geography, and social realities of the Roman Empire, imperial-critical approaches to this book are still trying out various hypotheses for how best to analyze its sense of its relation to the empire. While the range of scholarly options represents a familiar collection of methodological varieties, it also has been influenced by the recently dominant view that Acts carves out an accommodationist position toward Rome, as well as by complexities and inconsistencies in the narrative’s depictions of the gospel’s effects on society and the conflicts that arise. This paper will review some of the claims that have recently been staked regarding how to understand the book’s relation to empire and offer proposals for advancing the discussions, taking scenes involving Roman officials as test cases.
|
Panem et Circenses: The 99% in Heliodorus' Aethiopica
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Svetla Slaveva-Griffin, Florida State University
Heliodorus’ Aethiopica is known as the last of the ancient novels which embodies both the quintessential features of its literary genre and a fully embossed picture of the political, social and ideological life of late antiquity. While many of the literary merits of Heliodorus’ talent have long been praised, his attitude towards religion, specifically Christianity, in the novel still remains an enigma. This paper examines Heliodorus’ portrayal, and thereby view, of religion on behalf of and with the help of the 99%.
The Aethiopica is a novel built upon polarities, co-existent and yet mutually destructive. One of these polar axes is the relation between the top 1% and the remaining 99%, otherwise known respectively as the pepaideuomenoi and the hoi polloi. For Heliodorus, the former is a stabilized group of characters including himself, the Egyptian/Greek philosopher Calasiris, the coming of age protagonist Chariclea who undergoes the process of becoming educated in the story, and the exotic but nonetheless venerable group of the Gymnosophists. These characters dispense knowledge about higher realities or symbolically represent the gods, as in the case of Chariklea, from the temple of Apollo in Delphi, through the temple of Isis at Thebes, to the sacred grounds of Helios in Ethiopia. The recipients of this knowledge and experience are the hoi polloi whom Heliodorus makes collectively one of the characters in the novel. They act on and react to all religious events in the story, either by gaping with religious awe or asking themselves how it is possible gods to act like humans. Their awareness of the divine unites their constantly changing identity from Egyptian bandits, to Greek worshippers, to barbarian fanatics. One of the persistent questions Heliodorus masterfully explores in the Aethiopica then is what happens when the minds of the pepaideuomenoi meet the eyes of the hoi polloi.
|
The Place, Space, and Politics of Wonders and Signs in Acts
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Matthew Sleeman, Oak Hill Theological College, London
Geography and politics, power and space, are intimately interwoven, both in Acts and in wider human life. This paper explores how Acts uses ‘wonders and signs’ to project both its political and its spatial vision. As deeds of power, wonders and signs provide impetus for an assertion of political reach; how and where they occur structures such politics. This paper brings Henri Lefebvre's concern for spatial politics, particularly his notion of 'the right to the city' to bear on Acts, casting signs and wonders in a new light which integrates them within political and spatial readings of Acts. Such a reading helps make sense of the episodic and uneven recounting of signs and wonders within the narrative. As this paper shows, where and how signs and wonders are performed and perceived provides insight into their meaning and their contribution towards the political space Acts ascribes to the Jesus movement. This narrative assertion is resolutely located within both Jerusalem and empire but is not contained by either of these orderings of political space. Instead, the territoriality cast by signs and wonders contributes towards a third-spatial reading of Acts. Neither narrowly territorial nor merely spiritualised, nor even the sum of these two aspects, signs and wonders evoke an eschatological political space which is both territorial and spiritual, and more – signs and wonders uphold the fulfilment of the political agenda of Acts as underpinned by Christological fulfilment of Israel’s scriptures, a mission that includes the nations, and the hope of the resurrection of the dead, plural. This in turn problematises and reorders the critical spatial theory that engenders such readings. Simultaneously, this also opens up and provokes new readings of what Acts as a whole communicates to Theophilus and other readers / hearers.
|
On the Trial Trail with Paul (Acts 21–28): Place, Space, and Rhetoric Imprisoned but Unhindered
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Matthew Sleeman, Oak Hill Theological College, London
Space and rhetoric cohere in the final narrative quarter of Acts. Paul is imprisoned and, when he speaks, it is typically to make his defence. Read individually, sequentially, and cumulatively, Paul's defence speeches – embedded within the unfolding narrative – generate rhetorical and spatial climaxes for Acts as a whole. This paper uses Henri Lefebvre’s spatial politics to explore the formative contributions of Paul's bi-culturalism, his assertion of his gospel's 'right to the city' (both in Jerusalem and beyond), and its thirdspatial impetus afforded by the eschatological hope of the resurrection of the dead asserted before Jew and Gentile alike. In Acts 21-28 this space comes under rhetorical and physical attack, and its (re)production requires sustained embodiment and articulation. Thus, in this often neglected section of Acts, the narrative productions of space begun in earlier chapters continue apace and acquire maturing and new forms. Rhetorical developments through repetition, triangulation and interruption occur within both set speeches and in more dialogical encounters. Taken together, such elements demonstrate how space and rhetoric produce and depend upon each other in these final chapters of Acts. The reading pursued here takes new direction from my previous work on Acts 1-11. It also shows how spatial theory both informs our reading of these chapters and how the text of Acts in turn restructures spatial theorisation. In this latter reflexive turn, this paper illustrates the potential of what I term Critical Spatial Theory 2.0 (as in Gert T.M. Prinsloo and Christl M. Maier, eds., Constructions of Space V: Place, Space and Identity in the Ancient Mediterranean World [New York: Bloomsbury, 2013]) and highlights the need for ancient texts to inform modern theory.
|
Convivial Justice—Meals with Meaning in Early Christianity
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
Peter-Ben Smit, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam
*
|
Contemplating the Bible: Meditation in the General Education Bible Course
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Brian Albert Smith, Messiah College
The authors of Cultivating the Spirit (Astin et al., Jossey-Bass, 2011) found that “contemplative practices enhance student’s spiritual growth and development.” Faculty who teach in faith-based schools will find this particularly interesting, as many of the founding institutions of those schools may stand in tension with the traditions from which meditative and contemplative practices come. Additionally, the students of these schools may be unfamiliar with, or even hostile to, such practices. This situation can be further complicated by a course in biblical studies, as students in faith-based institutions are often suspicious of the academic study of spiritual matters to begin with.This project will examine the effect of a contemplative/meditative component on students in the general education biblical studies course at Messiah College. The objectives of the course are concerned with the various components of biblical study, including the development of the text and basic hermeneutical methodologies. The course enjoys a varied reputation among students, particularly as the course exhibits the perennial tension between faith and the academy.
I will be using two forms of meditation in two separate sections of this course to determine 1) the effect of meditation on student experience in general, and 2) whether the particular kind of meditation will affect the student’s experience. For the first section I will use the Christian practice of lectio divina, and in the other I will use simple mindfulness with the possible addition of a devoted commitment to learning. The contemplative methodologies will be necessarily simple, and our assessment will focus on student self-reporting, with a secondary consideration of academic performance.
This is an initial step toward determining whether the use of contemplation in the Christian liberal arts context of Messiah College can enhance student experience and learning in our general education biblical studies course. The results of this beginning experiment will certainly be of use to educators in similar contexts.
|
What Difference Does Difference Make? Q’s Place within Christian Origins in Recent Research
Program Unit: Q
Daniel A. Smith, Huron University College
With the possible exception of the larger question of Q as the source of the Double Tradition agreements between Matthew and Luke, probably the most debated issue pertaining to Q is the question how it fits (or does not fit) within Christian Origins. Contested issues relate to the documentary status of Q and its compositional history (and what that represents); its failure (?) to show an interest in the death and resurrection kerygma typically held to be universal among early Christian groups; the taxonomy of Q in relation to the categories of "wisdom" and "apocalyptic"; and Q's status among its authors and original recipients, and in the study of Christian Origins. The present study tracks the reception of the notion of Q's "difference" in recent scholarship, engaging questions about Q's genre, community origin and orientation, and religious and rhetorical perspectives.
|
The Fall and Rise of Eutychus: The Church of Paul and the Spatial Habitus of Luke
Program Unit: Space, Place, and Lived Experience in Antiquity
Eric C. Smith, Iliff School of Theology
This paper will read Acts 20:7-12 as Luke’s imaginative reconstruction of Pauline liturgical space, informed by the habitus of Luke and his Christianity. It will plumb Luke’s spatial imagination for clues about his own context, and what he thought was the case about the context of Troas in Asia Minor in the middle of the first century.
Scholars have long noted that the tale of Eutychus’ fall from the window in Acts 20:7-12 might have been borrowed from similar stock stories in other literatures and adapted for the purposes of Luke’s text in Acts. It is unlikely that the account comes from an eyewitness or even a second- or third-hand tradent of the event (and in any event the first and third persons are muddled in the passage, leaving its relationship to the composition history of Acts similarly unclear).
The story as it is found in Acts, then, is probably an adaptation by Luke of an existing narrative. This casts the myriad details of domestic and liturgical space into an interesting light. Luke describes a third-story room, which probably suggests a tenement hall as a setting. A group of people had “met to break bread.” The room is outfitted with many lamps—a beguiling detail. The gathering provided an occasion for Paul to speak (or, possibly, the other way around), and the room was so crowded that Eutychus was perched in a window. Here is a rich collection of details about Christian worship in the time of Paul, from which we might be tempted to glean data about urban Christianity, the size of Christian communities, the location of worship, and other aspects of early Christianity.
If this narrative is a stock story in Christian clothing, though, then we must rethink what kind of information is available in it. If Luke is providing details—what he imagines are Christian details—for this pre-existing story, then we must take them as evidence of Luke’s own time, not of Paul’s time. Here, Bourdieu’s habitus provides a framework for thinking about the way Luke imports 8th- or 9th-decade details into a 5th- or 6th-decade scene. The spatial logic of the scene in Troas is native to Luke’s community, and it is the habitus of that community’s worship that informs Luke’s (re)construction of Paul’s visit in Asia Minor. The expectations, experiences, and modes of conduct for Luke’s community and his kind of Christianity find literary expression in Acts 20, where they are imported into a Pauline scene to further Luke’s own rhetorical purposes.
|
The Supposed Mesopotamian Background of the Tower of Babel
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Eric Smith, Nebraska Christian College
In 1943 Samuel Noah Kramer published a fragment of the Sumerian myth Enmerkar and the Lord of Aratta in which he claimed a Sumerian parallel to the Tower of Babel story contained in Genesis 11: 1-9. His claim was based on translating a difficult passage as indicating a time when all nations spoke one language. Although Kramer's interpretation was critiqued by the eminent Sumerologist Thorkild Jacobsen as early as 1946, Kramer's interpretation made its way into biblical scholarship. Along the same lines, E. A. Speiser, in his influential Anchor Bible commentary of 1964, claimed mesopotamian background to Babel in Enuma Elish. This paper provides an overview of the history of the discussion followed by a critique of Kramer's and Speiser's original arguments. I then propose Gilgamesh and Huwawa as a neglected parallel to the motif of making a name.
|
Ecclesiastical Politics and the Transmission of Early Christian Literature: Origenism and the Gospel of Truth
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Geoffrey Smith, University of Texas at Austin
Ancient authors claim that apocryphal texts contributed to the popularity of the Origenist “heresy” in fourth- and fifth-century Egypt. In his festal letter of 401, Theophilus of Alexandria rails against Origenist ideas and urges Christians throughout Egypt to reject Origen and all “apocryphal Scriptures” advancing his teaching. That Shenoute associates Origenist themes with “apocryphal books” in Against the Origenists suggests that non-canonical writings continued to play a role in Origenist debates well into the fifth century. On the basis of these and other polemical reports, scholars have occasionally suggested that among the assortment of largely apocryphal texts discovered at Nag Hammadi are examples of the kinds of non-canonical writings that could have participated in the Origenist controversy. In this paper I hope to strengthen further this connection by offering new evidence to suggest that the Gospel of Truth, an apocryphal text from Nag Hammadi, participated in the Origenist controversy in late antique Egypt. On the basis of a detailed comparison between the two versions of the Gospel of Truth—a nearly complete Lycopolitan copy from Codex I and a highly fragmentary Sahidic copy from Codex XII, of which I offer a fresh reconstruction—I will argue that the version from Codex XII underwent an anti-Origenistic ideological redaction. Sometime in the fourth or fifth century an anonymous editor removed elements of the text that could be read in support of the Origenist “heresy” in order to produce a theologically acceptable version of this compelling homily on the gospel.
|
Contesting the Gift of Gnosis in 1 Corinthians
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Geoffrey Smith, University of Texas at Austin
An early generation of commentators conceived of the controversy over knowledge in Corinth as a showdown between Paul and the Gnostics. Yet on account of a heightened awareness of the anachronism of positing the existence of Gnostics in the first century, coupled with doubts surrounding the “dubious” category of Gnosticism more generally, recent studies attempt to treat Corinthian gnosis without recourse to Gnosticism. Nonetheless, certain aspects of the controversy remain underappreciated or little understood. This paper highlights the importance of viewing gnosis as one of the charismata practiced within the community and attributes the rhetoric of certainty espoused by the Corinthian “knowers” to the influence of sophists upon first-century Corinthians. This paper also attends to the complexities of the apostle’s critical response by demonstrating that Paul’s own understanding of knowledge emerges out of both the stock polemics of philosophers against sophists and epistemological currents within Second Temple Judaism that predicate true knowledge upon God’s knowledge of his people. This paper hopes to demonstrate that while Paul does not reject the gift of gnosis per se, he does contest the modes of knowledge valued by the Corinthian knowers.
|
The Transforming Image of the Ideal King: Paul’s Apostolic Defense (2 Cor 2:14–4:6) in Light of Greco-Roman Political Ideology
Program Unit: Second Corinthians: Pauline Theology in the Making
Julien C. H. Smith, Valparaiso University
In 2 Cor 2:14-4:6, Paul defends his apostleship by claiming that the transformation of the Corinthians into the glorious image of Christ constitutes the evidence for the legitimacy of his own ministry. Although the contours of this argument are well understood by scholars, the royal imagery which Paul deploys to great rhetorical effect has received insufficient attention. By setting this argument within the context of ancient Greco-Roman political discourse, this paper endeavors to explain the function of a crucially important royal image: the ideal king who transforms his subjects by his radiant presence. A number of fragmentary treatises by Neopythagorean political philosophers portray the ideal king as one who, through the divine virtue inherent in his person, inculcates virtue in his subjects by his sheer presence. Similar notions appear in a diverse array of writers such as Xenophon, Plutarch, and Philo. Indeed, Philo’s portrayal of Moses (Vit. Mos.) as the quintessential king who reflects the divine image is strikingly similar to Paul’s use of Exodus traditions depicting Moses as reflecting God’s radiance (Exod 34:29-35; 2 Cor 3:7-15). In characterizing Moses as a royal figure whose glorious ministry resulted in the law’s inscription on tablets of stone, Paul implies a fortiori that Christ is truly the ideal king whose surpassing glory results in the law’s inscription on human hearts, in fulfillment of the prophetic promise (Jer 31). Paul’s claim that he and his audience are transformed into the image of the Lord even as they behold his glorious presence (2 Cor 3:18) relies upon the ancient Mediterranean stereotype of the ideal king as one who inculcates virtue. Primarily, the paper aims to show the manner in which Paul’s defense of his ministry builds upon his audience’s cultural repertoire of political ideology; in so doing, this paper further intends to address the wider question of Paul’s christology, in which the importance of Christ’s royal identity remains a contested issue.
|
Feminist Intertextual Explorations: Mary as Intertextual "Signifier" in the Protevangelium of James
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Kay Higuera Smith, Azusa Pacific University
The task of interrogating our own assumptions about gender in the biblical tradition continues to be a critical one. One example is that of the treatment of the character of Mary in the Protevangelium of James. There, images associated with the prophet Samuel surround the birth and childhood of Mary. However, not enough attention has been paid to the sociological and historical elements that led to the production of that particular pairing of signifiers. I argue that this and other intertextual treatments of women in antiquity, such as that in Pseudo-Philo’s Biblical Antiquity, are important apologies for the significant agency and authority wielded by those ancient women, including Mary, the mother of Jesus.
|
Questions about Boundaries
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Mark Smith, New York University
The parameters for the data included in dictionaries constitutes an interesting problem. Dictionaries have specific design features that underutilize contextual data or make cultural assumptions. Some of these, along with examples, will be explored in this paper.
|
Systemic Oppression and Kingdom Rhetoric: Reading Matt 25:1–13 as an African American Female
Program Unit: African-American Biblical Hermeneutics
Mitzi J. Smith, Ashland Theological Seminary/Detroit
I propose to read Matt 25:1-13, the story of the ten virgins, through an African American hermeneutical lens. I will draw from Frederick Douglass’s autobiography My Bondage My Freedom, Fannie Lou Hamer’s biography entitled This Little Light of Mine, and from the contemporary stories of three victims of “Stand Your Ground” laws, namely Trayvon Martin, Jordan Davis, and Melissa Alexander. This parable of the ten virgin servants is sandwiched between two other slave parables—the parable of the unfaithful slave (24:45-51) and the parable of the talents (25:14-30)—where God/God’s Kingdom is compared to a slave master (kurios). Some of the master’s slaves fail to meet the demands of their master who presides over and operates within the unjust and inhumane system of slavery. The ten virgins can be understood as servants of the bridegroom, the kurios. The patriarchal slave owner holds a position of authority and power over his slaves within an unjust system that expects extraordinary and inhumane diligence and servility, and punishes those who fail to comply. Similarly, African Americans have found themselves at the mercy of unjust systems with shifting, exacting, and death-dealing expectations and consequences. When African Americans have failed to meet unjust, systemic expectations, which can change at a whim to either ensure their submission or their death for noncompliance, they are blamed and punished. When God is likened to a patriarchal slave master in a sacred text, many readers find it difficult to critique the unfair demands of the system and the oppressive depiction of God. Musa Dube and Lynne Darden have argued that in Matthew the colonized have internalized their colonization. And uncritical readers will be persuaded to do the same in the name of the Kingdom of heaven.
|
Sleeping with the Enemy? Esther, Judith, and Comfort Women
Program Unit: Exile (Forced Migrations) in Biblical Literature
Daniel Smith-Christopher, Loyola Marymount University
Although dated late into the Persian (and perhaps even Hellenistic) periods, the stories of Esther and Judith share significant tropes of women in the bed-chambers of Imperial Authority. Drawing on the literature dealing with Korean Comfort Women, this study will propose that there are disturbing elements to the stories of Esther and Judith, despite the fact that these two stories are often contrasted. It is proposed that we may be learning more in these stories than simply a reflection of Israelite attitudes toward women.
|
Coda: Psalms 146–150 as the Conclusion of the Psalter
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Michael Snearly, Red Hill Church, San Anselmo, CA
Coda: Psalms 146–150 as the Conclusion of the Psalter
|
Inspired Sages: Massa' and the Confluence of Wisdom and Prophecy
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Mark Sneed, Lubbock Christian University
Assuming that the scribes who composed and placed the book of Proverbs in its final form were trained within the same scribal matrix as the authors/redactors of the Book of the Twelve, how could we prove this? In a paper presented in Chicago at the SBL national conference, Bernd Schipper demonstrated that Jeremiah and Proverbs allude to the same passages in Deuteronomy and share the same scribal technique (exegesis), though the respective interpretations are theologically distinct. This paper will similarly attempt to demonstrate that a common scribal matrix underlies the superscriptions found in Prov 30:1a; 31:1; Isa 13:1; 14:28; 30:6; Hab 1:1; Zech 9:1; 12:1; Mal 1:1. Prophetic scholars usually view the word massa’, when used as a superscription in the prophetic books, as a technical term that designates a particular prophetic genre or book. It apparently has a specific meaning that eludes us but in general means a pronouncement or oracle, implying oracular inquiry (literally “to lift up”). Yet, it is also found in two superscriptions in Proverbs, and many wisdom experts find them (and the content of Agur’s oracle) problematic, often resorting to taking the term as a place name for an Arabian territory. Prophetic scholars also seem to find them problematic, resorting also to taking the term as a place name or assuming that its meaning is different in Proverbs. This paper will argue, instead, that the superscriptions reveal that the word is a scribal technical term for a specific genre that connotes divine inspiration, which was obviously not perceived as incompatible with the wisdom “tradition.” The ancient scribes apparently did not make the distinctions we modern scholars assume.
|
Are You Out of Your Mind? Madness and Demon Possession as Stigmatizing Categories in the New Testament
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Anna Rebecca Solevag, School of Mission & Theology (Misjonshogskolen i Stavanger) (Norway)
This paper explores madness and demon possession as stigmatizing categories in the Greco-Roman world. In the NT, accusations of madness and demon possession are used as rhetorical invective against Jesus and Paul (among others), who fervently defend themselves against these accusations. These illnesses or afflictions thus seem to be stigmatizing categories of disability. Drawing on ancient medical texts, as well as other discourses involving madness and demon possession, this paper will discuss how, why and by whom these labels were used. Although demon possession is often thought to be the NT understanding of what we today would call mental illness, I question such a simplified juxtaposition. Firstly, I argue that demon possession is only found in the gospels, whereas Paul seems to engage in a more learned, “medicalized” discourse of madness. Secondly, I argue that neither demon possession nor madness neatly map onto modern, Western culture’s category of mental illness or mental disability. There is, nevertheless, some commonality between the ancient and modern categories in their use to stigmatize individuals by assigning them to these categories.
|
Listening for the Voices of Two Disabled Girls in Early Christian Texts
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Anna Rebecca Solevag, School of Mission & Theology
This paper is an attempt to listen for the voices of two girls we encounter in early Christian narratives. The first is the demon-possessed daughter of the Syrophoenician woman in Mark 7:24-30. The second is the lame daughter of Peter the Apostle in the apocryphal Acts of Peter (Cod. Berol. 8502.4). From the perspective of intersectional disability studies, I will use these stories as a starting point to explore the everyday life of girls with disabilities in early Christianity. In the patriarchal (or kyriarchal) culture of Greco-Roman society, a disabled girl was multiply disadvantaged, due to gender, age and disability. A disabled girl’s experience, and her possibility of autonomous agency depended on several factors, including ethnic, economic and social status and the severity (and socially perceived nature) of her disability.
In the two stories, the girls are silent and their range of movement is limited—they stay within the house. However, they have strong spokespersons in their parents, who negotiate healing (Syrophoenician woman) or defend their place in the Christian community although not healed (apostle Peter). Behind the stories we may glimpse early Christian communities struggling with the everyday challenge of caring for disabled children and trying to understand theologically how disability, suffering and healing should be understood within the Christian faith. Both parents exhibit, firstly, a strong love and concern for their disabled child, and, secondly, an effort to negotiate the meaning of their child’s disability.
|
“It Is Just the Way It Was Back Then”: Cultural Assumptions about War and Rape and Their Interpretive Consequences
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Elna K. Solvang, Concordia College - Moorhead
This paper examines the narrative of Absalom’s public rape of David’s concubines (2 Samuel 16:21-23). It explores the sanctioning of these rapes within the biblical narrative, the acceptance by biblical interpreters of this behavior as normative in ancient times, and contemporary connections to the use of rape as a tool in civil conflict.
|
A Postcolonial Feminist Contemplation of Translation, Performance, and Identity
Program Unit: Bible Translation
Althea Spencer Miller, Drew University
This paper, as part of the Bible Translation and Nida Institute session on Performance, Translation and Identity, will address identity issues regarding performance and translation, from a postcolonial feminist perspective.
|
Competing with the Competitors: Jewish and Christian Responses to Popular Entertainment
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Loren R. Spielman, Portland State University
This paper addresses early Patristic and Rabbinic criticism of Roman entertainments during the first three centuries of the Common Era. The theater and amphitheater, which functioned as popular forums for political and social expression in the life of the Late Antique city, presented serious challenges for Jewish and Christian scholars who eschewed more traditional avenues towards the establishment of personal authority. Both groups launched into invective in order to reign in what they considered unacceptable, even sinful, behavior in the wider Jewish and Christian communities. Modern scholarship has often construed Patristic and Rabbinic censure of spectacle entertainment as practical responses to the popularity of games amongst their constituents. But a closer look at the rhetoric about theaters and spectacles demonstrates the important role this discourse played in determining the boundaries of their respective corporate identities. Comparing the early Rabbinic dicta regarding spectacles contained in the Mishnah, Tosefta and Mekhilta de R. Ishmael with the writings of Tertullian and Tatian, this paper demonstrates that Christian and Jewish exegetes, working from a common Biblical tradition, injected their own interests and anxieties into their opposition to popular Roman entertainments. Despite the many similarities between their approaches, Christian and Jewish discourse about spectacles ultimately moved in slightly different trajectories. While Christian criticism depicted Roman spectacles as idolatrous snares for recent converts, early Rabbinic criticism of Roman spectacle was fueled more by the sort of intellectual snobbishness that characterized most contemporary pagan critics of theatrical lewdness and arena violence. In charting these divergent strategies towards sport and spectacle among religious experts, this paper suggests that elite attempts to critique and control the behavior of the urban masses in Late Antiquity often reveal more about the critics than they do about the crowd.
|
The 2013–2014 Seasons of Excavations at Huqoq in Israel’s Galilee
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
Chad Spigel, Trinity University
Co-Authored by: Jodi Magness, Shua Kisilevitz, Benjamin Gordon, Matthew Grey, and Chad Spigel.
Since 2011, excavations at Huqoq in Israel’s Galilee have brought to light remains of a Late Roman-Byzantine (fifth-sixth century) village and monumental synagogue building. In this paper, we present the discoveries of the 2013-2014 seasons: houses and food preparation areas in the nineteenth-twentieth century village (abandoned in 1948) which overlies the synagogue; one or two large domestic structures in the ancient village; and the synagogue building, which is decorated with figured mosaics. So far, the mosaics uncovered in the east aisle include scenes depicting the exploits of the biblical hero Samson, and a panel with episodes that may be related to the Maccabean martyrdom traditions.
|
The Holy Spirit as Witness of Jesus to, in, and through the Disciples in the Gospels of Matthew and John
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Judith Stack-Nelson, Hamline University
The memory of Jesus' teaching on the Holy Spirit as empowering Christian witnessing power is discernible in both the Gospel of Matthew and in the Gospel of John. This witness is understood to be initially to those around Jesus: John the Baptist perceives the lighting of the Holy Spirit on Jesus as indicative of his sonship and authority to pass on the presence of the Holy Spirit; Peter’s confession of Jesus as the Christ, the Son of the Living God is a revelation engendered by God’s spirit. But the Holy Spirit was also understood to witness to Jesus through the disciples after Jesus’ death. John explicitly connects the witness of the Spirit with the witness of Jesus’ followers (“the Spirit of truth…he will bear witness about me and you also will bear witness” Jn 15:26-27) and Jesus’ commissioning of the Apostles in Mt to make disciples and baptize is in part in the name of Holy Spirit, the spirit of Jesus, whom they understand to be with them eternally and to be “God with us,” a commissioning analogous to Jesus imparting the Holy Spirit to the Apostles in John 20.
|
Many Shall Come from East and West: Matthew 8:11–12 and Psalm 106 LXX
Program Unit: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity
Carolin Stalter, Heidelberg University
Many scholars assume that the “many” (p?????) in Matt 8:11 refer to gentiles from the nations who are promised a seat at the table with the patriarchs. Other scholars point to Israelite scriptures and interpret Mtt 8:11 in a Diaspora context which speaks of Jews who are gathered from many different directions.
Based on the interrelation between Mtt 8:11 and Ps 106:3LXX this paper attempts to introduce a new accent into this debate. Ps 106LXX mentions the “redeemed of the Lord” who are gathered from various geographic directions. The vast majority of scholars identify this group exclusively with Israel. The metaphoric images in the Psalm, however, speak against such a simple group definition. Should the hypothesis of a mixed group of Jews and gentiles in Ps 106LXX prove true, this would have important ramifications for the understanding of the logion in Mtt 8:11-12.
|
Does Context Matter in Theological Interpretation? Some Observations in Connection with Bultmann’s "Theology of the New Testament"
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Angela Standhartinger, Philipps-Universität Marburg
Many interpreters argue that Bultmann is a systematic but not a contextual theologian. His Theology of the New Testament seems to be the best proof for this thesis. Written during and shortly after World War II, its main parts contain ideas that he had already published in 1930. So Bultmann’s Theology of the New Testament seems to be proof of the possibility of theological interpretation without context. But in addition to the continuity in Bultmann’s interpretation, there are some small but none the less important changes that reflect Bultmann's experience as a critical intellectual in Nazi-Germany. Furthermore, writing this Theology of the New Testament at that time in German history is in itself the outcome of contextual reflection. And thereby Bultmann formulates more implicitly than explicitly one of the most crucial questions in New Testament theology today: Is there a message that is beside or beyond all contextuality of the biblical writings that reaches human existence today? How could this message, or to take up Bultmann's term, the kerygma, address concrete human beings in their concrete historical contexts? And beyond Bultmann, one has to ask if this message must or can be always the same, or if it is necessarily multiform, just as human beings and their socio-historical contexts are multiform.
|
Teaching Paul with the Godfather
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Jason Staples, Wake Forest University
Helping introductory students understand the social world and theological system of the apostle Paul is always one of the most daunting tasks of any introductory Bible or New Testament class. One of the primary difficulties is helping students grasp Paul’s terminology, a job made more challenging by theological presuppositions and definitions many students bring into the course.
One effective introduction to the covenantal (patron-client) thought world and terminology of Pauline literature can be found in the first scene from the classic film, The Godfather. In this scene, Amerigo Bonasera petitions Vito Corleone for “justice” in the wake of a crime committed against his daughter. Bonasera’s offer to pay for this favor angers Corleone for the disrespect implied in such a request, as Bonasera is “afraid to be in [Corleone’s] debt.” Only after Bonasera asks “in friendship” (that is, having given a pledge of loyalty) does Corleone grant the favor, explaining, “Some day … I will call upon you to do a service for me. But until that day, please accept this justice as a gift on my daughter’s wedding day.”
I typically introduce the concept of patronage, allegiance, and exchange and then show five-minute scene, which gives a poignant demonstration of quite Pauline definitions for terms and concepts such as favor (?????), allegiance/faithfulness (p?st??), justice, gift, friendship, and reciprocity, while also highlighting the grave and fearful obligation the client now feels to his benefactor. The concepts of reciprocity and obligation reflected in this scene also nicely set up a discussion of Pauline ethics, allowing students to view such relational obligations (and therefore Paul’s own understanding) from outside a typical western/American perspective.
|
Daniel as Wisdom in Action
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Andrew Steinmann, Concordia University Chicago
Daniel as Wisdom in Action
|
Against Nature
Program Unit: LGBTI/Queer Hermeneutics
David Tabb Stewart, California State University - Long Beach
When Paul asks, “Does not nature [physis] teach you?” (1 Cor 11:14), one wonders, what indeed does nature teach? This paper takes up the several instances from Paul, Philo and the rabbinic Tannaim where certain behaviors are nature-taught, “according to nature” (kata physin), “analogous to nature,” “respect the law of nature,” or are “against nature” (para physin). These usefully contrast with physis representing gender, ethnic, angelic, or divine “essences.” Three notorious Pauline cases concern men not wearing long hair as nature-taught; grafting branches on to trees—something para physin—as a metaphor for conversion (Rom 11:21-24); and alleged same-sex behaviors of women and men as unnatural (Rom 1:26-27). Philo, with respect to sexual relations, uses para physin and similar language to refer to crossbreeding animals, bestiality, menstrual sex, barren heterosexual marriages, pederasty, and androgyny. Mishnaic sources recognize androgyny and genital differences as part of the given order of things. Nevertheless, standard commentaries on Romans 1:26-27 conflate the representations of these sources, dispatch or ignore what is inconvenient, and usually conclude that Paul “clearly” refers to “homosexual relations.” But does the semantic field of “nature,” then, refer to the natural world’s earth, air and biota? Or does it refer to an imagined social order? If Paul uses Philo as a resource, how does that influence his understanding of “nature?”
|
Anomalous Rhyme-Words in the Qur'an and Their Implications
Program Unit: Linguistic, Literary, and Thematic Perspectives on the Qur’anic Corpus (IQSA)
Devin Stewart, Emory University
End-rhyme is one of the most regular features of Qur'anic style, and this fact has enabled scholars to use rhyme as a tool for analysis of the Qur'anic text. Rhyme was a principal criterion used by the medieval Muslim scholars called “the Counters” (ashab al-'adad) to determine the placement of verse-divisions throughout the Qur?an and the number of verses in each surah. In Volksprache und Schriftsprache im alten Arabien (1906), Karl Vollers used the rhymes of the Qur?an to argue that the text in an Arabic with strong colloquial features, and one might counter his work using nearly the same method: a great deal of Arabic grammar and syntax can be deduced merely from an examination of the Qur'an’s end-rhymes. Medieval Muslim scholars such as Ibn al-Sa'igh al-Hanafi explained that the exigencies of end-rhyme caused deviations from the ordinary rules of Arabic grammar and style to occur in Qur'anic verses. Drawing on Voller’s work, Angelika Neuwirth’s discussion of rhyme in Studien zur Komposition der mekkanische Suren (1981), exegeses of al-Tabari, al-Tha'labi, al-Zamakhshari, and others, but also on independent examination of the Qur'anic text, this study addresses rhyme-words that are anomalous in their passages in the Qur'an. They either do not rhyme with adjacent verses in passages where rhyme appears regular or do not have the appropriate morphological or metrical form to create satisfactory parallelism with adjacent rhyme words. The study attempts to provide explanations for these apparent deviations from regular rhyme, an exercise that reveals a number of features of Qur'anic Arabic in general and suggests specific readings of verses in question. Some features of this nature that have been observed in scholarship to date include the following: 1) The subjunctive verbs yahura (84:14) and azida (74:15) must be read yahura and azida to conform with the rhyme in the surrounding passages, proving the existence of the subjunctive mood in Arabic, even if we come to the Qur'an with some skepticism about its conforming to the rules of classical Arabic as recorded in the grammar books. 2) It is known that hamzah is dropped or assimilated in many circumstances. The fact that the rhyme in Surat Maryam is regularly –iyya and –ayya implies that shay'an must be read as shayya, ri'ya as riyya, etc. [Since the rhyme is more frequently –iyya than –ayya, one might even suggest the reading shiyya for shay'an, in keeping with the pronunciation in many Arabic dialects, but this might be going to far.] 3) The word khati'ah must be read khatiyah to rhyme with bi-n-nasiyah, nadiyah, az-zabaniyah in Q 96:15-18. 4) In a number of cases, words must be combined to form one final rhyme-word that has a single accentual contour: ma-hiyah (101:10); ma-laha (99:3); awha-laha (99:5); ?arrafaha-lahum (Q 47:6). The following are examples of analyses that have not been touched on, to the best of my knowledge, in scholarship to date. 1) The fact that a verse with the rhyme-word al-dhikra is followed by the verse yaqulu ya laytani qaddamtu li-hayati in Surat al-Fajr
|
Text-Linguistics and the Hebrew Psalter
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Joshua E. Stewart, Luther Rice University
Text-linguistics is devoted to an analysis of a complete text as the object of linguistic study. This approach attempts to describe the internal language-related mechanisms that enable a text to exhibit cohesion, coherence, and function in such a way that the intention of the author is conveyed. The Hebrew Psalter contains its own unique way of conveying the intended meaning of an author. Psalms scholars have employed many different literary and linguistic techniques in their quest for the discovery of meaning in individual psalms. In this paper I will show that the use of a particular text-linguistic method will address the many unusual or unexpected clause constructions in the Psalter.
The method begins at the level of clausal syntax and moves to how these clauses are used to develop the thought and movement of the text as a whole. By creating a database of clause types and structures one may easily note intentional movement within any particular psalm. One of the goals of this research is to discover to what extent the TAM of poetry differs from that of prose. My working thesis is that by examining the frequency and distribution of finite clauses in a psalm one can determine the function of the clauses, how they contribute to the movement of the psalm, and begin to describe the TAM system in the Psalter. Applications and observations of this method will be given from selected psalms in Book Two of the Psalter.
|
Fallen Angels, Bastard Spirits, and the Birth of God’s Son: An Enochic Etiology of Evil in Gal 3:19–4:11
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Tyler A. Stewart, Marquette University
Scholars consider Galatians 3:19–4:11 a key text for understanding Paul’s view of “the law,” but much about it remains obscure. In this passage Paul engages and reworks Jewish narratives for the purposes of his Christological argument, but makes not appeal to the Adam cycle. The absence of Adam is surprising when compared to the similar argument in Romans, which explicitly employs the Adam cycle to argue for the provisional role of the Law in a world dominated by sin. In this paper I suggest that the Enochic etiology of evil, particularly as it appears in the book of Jubilees, can illuminate Paul’s argument in Galatians 3:19–4:11. First, I call attention to the pervasiveness and malleability of the etiology in Second Temple Judaism, especially as it appears in Jubilees, Qumran sectarian documents (1QS, 1QM, CD), and Philo. Second, I show how the Enochic etiology provides new insight into Galatians 3:19–4:11 and its exegetical difficulties. Most notably, the etiology sheds light on the ambiguous role of angels (3:19), the significance of Christ’s birth “from a woman” (4:4), the meaning of the much debated phrase ta stoicheia tou kosmou (4:3, 9), and the significant attention given to legitimate sonship (4:5–7). I conclude by arguing that these connections reframe the “transgression” that makes the law a provisional necessity (3:19) and the danger of returning to the law as an enduring necessity (4:8–11), drawing attention to the cosmic redemption that occurs in Christ.
|
What Paul Scholarship Can Learn from North African Reception?
Program Unit: Contextualizing North African Christianity
Todd D. Still, Baylor University
What Paul Scholarship can learn from North African Reception?
|
Reconsidering the Assumption of Moses
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Ryan E. Stokes, Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary
Jude 9 refers to a time when the archangel Michael disputed with the Devil about the body of Moses. Commentators commonly suppose that Jude in this passage cites a lost text known as the Assumption of Moses, in which Michael and Satan contend with one another following the death of Moses regarding the postmortem fate of Moses or of his body. A comparison of Jude 9 with certain earlier biblical and extracanonical texts suggests, however, that the disagreement between Michael and the Devil to which Jude refers is not one that took place after Moses’ death. Nor did it pertain to Moses’ postmortem fate. Rather the dispute took place during Moses’ lifetime and concerned whether Moses should be put to death or allowed to live. The tradition that Michael and the Devil disagreed about Moses after his death and the various accounts of this disagreement, on the other hand, seem to have arisen later as (mis)interpretations of Jude 9.
|
The Transmission of Manuscripts and the Genetics of Texts: A New Critical Electronic Edition of Wolfram von Eschenbach's Parzival
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
Michael Stolz, University of Bern
The discussion on the New Philology triggered by French and North American scholars in the last decade of the 20th century emphasized the material character of textual transmission inside and outside the written evidences of medieval manuscripts by downgrading the active role of the historical author. However, the reception of the ideas propagated by the New Philology adherents was rather divided. Some researchers questioned its innovative status (K. Stackmann: “Neue Philologie?”), others saw a new era of the “powers of philology” evoked (H.-U. Gumbrecht).
Besides the debates on the New Philology another concept of textual materiality strengthened in the last decade, maintaining that textual alterations somewhat relate to biogenetic mutations. In a matter of fact, phenomena such as genetic and textual variation, gene recombination and ‘contamination’ (the mixing of different exemplars in one manuscript text) share common features. The paper discusses to what extent the biogenetic concepts can be used for evaluating manifestations of textual production (as the approach of ‘critique génétique’ does) and of textual transmission (as the phylogenetic analysis of manuscript variation does). In this context yet the genealogical concept of stemmatology – the treelike representation of textual development abhorred by the New Philology adepts – might prove to be useful for describing the history of texts.
The textual material to be analyzed will be drawn from the Parzival Project, which is currently preparing a new electronic edition of Wolfram von Eschenbach’s Parzival novel written shortly after 1200 and transmitted in numerous manuscripts up to the age of printing (www.parzival.unibe.ch). Researches of the project have actually resulted in suggesting that the advanced knowledge of the manuscript transmission yields a more precise idea on the author’s own writing process.
|
Gender, Animal, Sacrifice: Domestication and the Daughter of Jephthah
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Ken Stone, Chicago Theological Seminary
Feminist scholarship has long asked about the role played by gender in the death of Jephthah’s daughter. As numerous commentators note, the daughter of Jephthah is given as a burnt offering to YHWH while Isaac is spared such a fate by divine intervention and animal substitution. Thus the sacrifice of Jephthah’s daughter raises questions about the relationships among sexual difference, animal difference, and human sacrifice in the Bible. My paper explores these questions in dialogue with feminist scholarship, the interdisciplinary literature emerging from the “animal turn” in the humanities and social sciences, and the theory of Israelite sacrifice proposed by Jonathan Klawans. The daughter of Jephthah is but one of several women in biblical literature whose fate involves an association with domesticated animals. Attention to both the gendered structure of biblical households and the dynamics of the domestication of “companion species” (Donna Haraway) is crucial for understanding their stories. Klawans’ symbolic theory of sacrifice proposes analogical relations between Israelites and the domesticated animals they cared for, and God and the Israelites who desired God’s care. Perhaps against Klawans’ intentions, his theory also helps us understand child sacrifice as a problematic but logical consequence of metaphors that structure biblical symbolism and biblical sacrifice. By virtue of their continued existence in the realm of the domesticated after marriage, however, daughters/women remain more vulnerable than sons to a potentially animalized fate. I argue that the interrelations among gender, animal, and sacrifice should all be taken into account if we want to understand how a young woman can be turned into a burnt offering.
|
‘The Matter of a Dead Animal’: Derrida, Klawans, and the Chimera of Biblical Sacrifice
Program Unit: Reading, Theory, and the Bible
Ken Stone, Chicago Theological Seminary
In The Animal That Therefore I Am, Derrida briefly reflects on Cain, Abel, and “the matter of a dead animal,” that is, “a tamed, raised, and sacrificed animal.” His reading is embedded in a longer section on the Chimera, a mythical beast who combines features from several animal species in a single body. Chimera is killed by Bellephron and Pegasus, who in some traditions are half-brothers sired by Poseiden and who therefore reconfigure boundaries distinguishing humans, animals, and gods. My paper uses Derrida’s framing of the biblical story to ask whether “biblical sacrifice “ – that is, the collection of biblical texts that represent sacrifice (several of which are reviewed in the paper) – is not itself “chimeric” in nature. Although sacrifice is easily taken as a practice that functions to distinguish humans from animals, biblical sacrifice simultaneously (1) produces divisions among animals (by making some animals available for sacrifice and other animals unavailable), (2) produces divisions among humans (by distinguishing humans who can sacrifice from those who cannot), and (3) blurs lines between humans and other animals (by raising possibilities for child sacrifice and identifying certain animals as appropriate substitutes for humans who might otherwise be sacrificed). Moreover, Jonathan Klawans has argued for a symbolic theory of Israelite sacrifice as a ritual process that draws analogies between, on the one hand, domesticated animals and Israelites and, on the other hand, Israelites and God. Klawans articulates these analogies with biblical passages that use relations between domesticated animals and humans as metaphors for relations between humans and God. Perhaps against Klawans’ intentions, his theory also helps us understand child sacrifice as a logical consequence of analogies that structure biblical sacrifice. Rather than simply reinforcing a solid boundary between human and animal, biblical sacrifice, like the Chimera and her killers, simultaneously assumes, undermines, and redraws lines among humans, animals, and the divine.
|
The Macro-structure of the Megilloth
Program Unit: Megilloth
Timothy J. Stone, Eastern University
This paper explores the macro-structure of the Megilloth in the Masoretic tradition within the context of the Writings as a whole. I propose that the canonical ties that bind the Megilloth together come primarily from outside the Megilloth—from the other books in the Writings that border on the collection. Ruth, Song of Songs, and Ecclesiastes each are more strongly connected to Proverbs than to the other books of the Megilloth. Likewise, Esther’s connection to Daniel is greater than its connection to Lamentations. Although the connections are not as strong, the Megilloth is bound together in a chiastic structure where Ruth is the opposite of Esther, Song of Songs the opposite of Lamentations and Ecclesiastes is not paired with any other book and in this manner forms the center of the structure (Ruth A, Song B, Ecclesiastes C, Lamentations A1, Esther B2). If the web of connections explored in this paper are valid, then one conclusion that can be drawn is that the Megilloth was not viewed as an independent collection, as it later came to be understood, but rather as an indivisible part of the Writings. Another conclusion would be that each book in the Megilloth has at least one or more relationships with other books in the Writings as a whole. None stands alone.
|
Love One Another and Love the World: The Love Command and Jewish Ethics in the Johannine Community
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Beth M. Stovell, Ambrose Seminary
The development of the “love command” in Jesus’ teaching and its implementation in the early Christian community as a social boundary marker has been the topic of much discussion. Many locate this development within the Johannine corpus, particularly in the Johannine epistles, and argue that the “love command” functions in an exclusive fashion, reinforcing group identity. Yet one may ask whether these formulations have adequately considered the social context of the perpetuation of the “love command” in the Johannine community, particularly in relation to the ethics of the Jewish mission. Using conceptual mapping theories developed by Giles Fauconnier and Mark Turner, this paper examines the conceptions of love, the Law, and boundary line formation in Jewish literature of the Second Temple period to understand the social phenomenon occurring in the early Johannine community depicted in the “love command” in Johannine literature.
|
Why Expert versus Non-expert Religion Is Not Elite versus Popular Religion: The Case of the Third Century
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Stanley Stowers, Brown University
In scholarship, “expert/non-expert” often gets melded with “popular/elite” and the various ways that the latter categories have been understood. The third century provides evidence to illustrate why the categories should not be confused, the problems with “popular/elite” and the utility of “Expert/Non-expert.”
|
Of Gods and Kings: Early Judaism, Ruler Cults, and Paul’s Polemic against Semasmata in Acts 17:23
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Drew Strait, University of Pretoria
Of Gods and Kings: Early Judaism, Ruler Cults and Paul’s Polemic against Semasmata in Acts 17:23
|
A School of Paul? The Use of Pauline Texts in Early Christian Schooltext Papyri
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Jennifer Strawbridge, University of Oxford
Early documentary papyrological texts are rarely cited in modern scholarship and when cited, are used primarily for biblical textual criticism. Early Christian schooltext papyri, in particular, are overlooked. Yet, these texts offer an exceptional glimpse of the Pauline epistles in an educational setting and of the intersection between biblical texts and everyday life. Of the small number of extant early Christian school exercises (before the fourth century), as many as one-third include extracts from the Pauline epistles. Of these few surviving texts, the majority are excerpts from Romans 1. This paper proposes to examine the use of Pauline texts in ancient school exercises, investigating what these school exercises might disclose about the connection between the Pauline letters and early Christian pedagogy and formation. Utilizing a methodology employed by ancient historians who study literate education and best attested in the works of Teresa Morgan and Raffaella Cribiore, this paper explores the role of material evidence in reconstructing ancient education. In the process, the question will be addressed about whether the presence of Paul’s letters within this documentary material might confirm the presence, as suggested by some scholars, of a School of Paul or simply offer a clearer picture of the early ordering of the Pauline epistles and the place of the Roman letter.
|
Philo’s Exegesis of the Biblical Festival Laws: Arithmology, Askesis, and Imitatio Dei
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Daniel R. Streett, Durham University
Festivals were commonly viewed in the ancient Mediterranean as an opportunity for humans to participate in the life of the gods, who are perpetually feasting. Thus Plato (Laws 653d) says that festivals are a gift from the gods, allowing humans “to be made whole again” by “participating in the festivals alongside the gods” (suneortazein en tais eortais meta theon). The concept of divine mimesis is used to explain the banqueting, liturgy, leisure, and reenactment of divine exploits that accompanied festivals in the Hellenistic world.
In this paper, I examine Philo’s interpretation of the Jewish festival laws in light of this tradition. Special attention is paid to: a) the ways in which Philo’s exegesis of the festival laws attempts to distance Jewish feasting from Greek feasting by characterizing the former as askesis, b) Philo’s use of rewritten bible traditions in his exegesis of the festival laws, c) Philo’s numerological understanding of the festal calendar, especially in relation to other Hellenistic numerological thought, and d) the possible relationship between Philo and apocalyptic traditions (such as Jubilees) in which Israel’s festivals are depicted as having a heavenly pre-existence, so that Israel’s festival observance is understood as imitatio angelorum.
|
Y-H-W-H: Four More Letters in Search of an Etymology
Program Unit: Philology in Hebrew Studies
Adam Strich, Harvard University
In this talk, adapted from my forthcoming dissertation, I shall investigate an issue that has proven to be as tempting to biblicists as it has been vexing—that of the etymology of the divine name Yahwe(h)—applying to it an an eclectic set of investigative tools borrowed, not only from traditional philology, but also from synchronic and diachronic linguistics, as well as extralinguistic historical inquiry. I shall take as my starting point the theory, first proposed by Joannes Clericus in 1696 and, in no small part due to its adoption and elaboration by the recently deceased Frank Moore Cross, widely accepted today, that Yahwe(h) is a causative of haya(h) ‘to be’. Cross, in fact, argued that yhwh still served as a verb in the archaic clause yhwh ?b’wt yšb hkrbym (1 Sam 4:4; 2 Sam 6:2). While I agree with the formal component of this analysis, I take issue with the semantic: as I argued when this consultation met last year, Biblical Hebrew has two verbs haya(h) synchronically:3 the widely recognized grammatical verb and a lexical verb meaning ‘to fall’. Picking up now where I left off then, I shall argue that Yawe(h) is actually a causative of the latter. Thus, Cross’s cryptic clause, which is said in 2 Samuel to be the “name” of the ark, would mean something like ‘he sends down the heavenly armies while he is seated upon the cherubs’. I shall situate my reading of this sentence within a constellation of images found in certain archaic biblical poems, which speak of Yahweh riding into battle on cherubs as the heavenly bodies join rank behind him and the stars stream down to fight his enemies. The golden cherubs on top of the ark are the counterparts of the cherubs in these early poems; Yahweh is thought to sit on the cherubs on the ark, and so when the ark is carried into battle, the deity himself enters the fray, enacting the march of the divine warrior described in the poetry.
|
“Le style, c’est l’homme”: The Use of Literary Stylistics in the Defense of Lukan Authorship of Hebrews—A Critical Assessment
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Phillip Strickland, McMaster Divinity College
“Le style, c’est l’homme”: The Use of Literary Stylistics in the Defense of Lukan Authorship of Hebrews—A Critical Assessment
|
Your Name Shall No Longer Be Jacob, but Refugee and Indentured Laborer: Insights on Genesis 27–31 from the Study of Forced Migration
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
C. A. Strine, University of Sheffield
The patriarch Jacob is a refugee from the threat of violence who receives asylum. Once accepted for asylum, Jacob works as an indentured labourer with limited rights. Jacob hardly acquiesces to this situation and chooses to employ subversive techniques in order to dupe his domineering host into an agreement from which he benefits financially. To be sure, this is an atypical summary of the narrative in Gen 27–31, but it simply foregrounds the basic plot of these chapters: Jacob flees Trans-Jordan in fear of physical harm from Esau (Gen 27:41-45), seeks refuge with his maternal uncle Laban who immediately puts him to work (Gen 29:15), only to have this ‘employer’ take advantage of his precarious situation to extort him. Jacob subsequently proves himself to be a cunning trickster, using Laban’s ploys against him so that he leaves his time in asylum at Haran very wealthy (Gen 30:25-43). Viewed from this perspective it is clear that the Jacob narrative requires the interpreter to employ socio-scientific research on involuntary migration, studies on the relationships between dominant hosts and marginalised labourers, and investigations into the role of trickster narratives among migrant groups in order to grasp the text’s meaning. Scholars have, nevertheless, not taken this approach to Gen 27–31. In this paper, I shall draw on the latest research about forced migration, James C. Scott’s treatments of the everyday dynamics between dominant powers and subaltern workers, and studies on the role of trickster narratives (e.g., Niditch, Smith-Christopher) in order to offer a fresh interpretation of key passages within Gen 27–31. The profile of Jacob that emerges—one that resembles forced migrants from other cultures—reveals a deep connection between the patriarchal narrative and the lived experience of involuntary migration. I shall outline, therefore, a few areas in which future research into the patriarchal narrative can benefit from sustained engagement with the socio-scientific study of forced migration.
|
Variations on a Myth: The Myth of Return in Ezekiel and the Pentateuch
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
Casey Strine, University of Sheffield
The myth of return—an expressed desire to return to another geographic place in which the community historically resided—is common among all migrant groups, but especially prominent among involuntary migrants. Though Ezek 40–48 is not generally called a myth of return, especially when taken together with Ezek 37–39 it plays this function. The same is true of various texts in the Pentateuch: one immediately thinks of Jacob’s time in Haran or Joseph’s time in Egypt, but one might also consider the portions of Exod (esp. chs. 1–15 in their final form) and Deuteronomy (e.g., a Torah to observe in the land that YHWH will give to Israel). In this paper, I shall lay out the rationale for reading Ezek 40–48 and several texts from the Pentateuch in this way and, subsequently, argue that all of them share the concern to maintain communal bonds among a marginalised group that is at risk of assimilating into a host population and losing its distinctiveness.
|
Initiative and Agency: Towards a Theology of the Megilloth
Program Unit: Megilloth
Megan Fullerton Strollo, Union Presbyterian Seminary
The Megilloth have received little attention in the realm of biblical theology for several reasons: a putative historical framework, minimal (or nonexistent) references to the Deity in the various books, and the sense among certain scholars that this is a tenuous literary designation in the first place. However, recent developments in literary criticism and the ongoing debate between theology and anthropology provide grounds for reconsidering the Megilloth as theology. Mark McEntire’s recent monograph, Portraits of a Mature God, argues that the God represented in the later biblical books merits greater consideration. This paper will seek to demonstrate that the Megilloth represent a critical grouping for theological inquiry.
This paper will examine the Megilloth in the context of biblical theology. We will consider how a theology of the Megilloth might be constructed and what purpose it would serve in the larger field. Finally, this paper will provide some initial examinations of the texts which highlight the theological suppositions therein.
The most prominent theme in the Megilloth is the tension between divine agency and human capacity. In the Megilloth, the human characters in the story take control of their own lives, partnering with the cosmic creation and assuming God-like roles at times. The humans may be the protagonists of the Megilloth, but that does not make these books any less “theological.” A theology of the Megilloth will begin to consider how this seemingly distant God and the faithful individuals in these works continue to partner in creation. And it will begin to embrace an idea of biblical theology that considers the link between divine action and human agency in this neglected corpus.
|
After Exile in Isaiah and the Twelve
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Jacob Stromberg, Duke University
As Ronald Clements has argued, the Babylonian exile and return from it have become unifying themes in much Old Testament literature, especially the prophets. Most of the prophetic books have been shaped to look forward to restoration after exile. This paper will seek to illuminate how these hopes of restoration were received in the post-exilic period, and how this reception made itself felt on the post-exilic shape of Isaiah and the Twelve. Focusing particular attention on Isaiah 40-66 and Haggai-Zechariah, I will argue that in both texts one may discern an initial perception that such prophecies of restoration were being fulfilled in the early period after Cyrus’ edict. I will also argue that, as events progressed, it became clear to the editors of these texts that this period had not been the time for restoration, or at least not the time for the full restoration that had been spoken of by the prophets of old whose words are cited.
While much has been written on the nature of this process from an etic (‘outsider’) perspective – such as those theories appealing to cognitive dissonance and the failure of prophecy –, this paper also seeks to illuminate the emic (‘insider’) view on this critical turning point. I argue that the problem of prophetic fulfillment in this period was handled by a native logic that involved reading the relevant prophetic texts together with passages from the Pentateuch that were seen to provide a satisfying rationale as to why full restoration had not yet materialized. Attention to this process illuminates (1) the critical hermeneutical role assigned to a nascent scriptural corpus as interpretive context, and possibly indicates (2) a feature of Isaiah and the Twelve that is crucial to understanding how they held together in a meaningful way as books for their earliest readers.
|
Ezekiel: A Disciple of Isaiah
Program Unit: Book of Ezekiel
John T. Strong, Missouri State University
In this paper, I will argue that Ezekiel inherited and consciously carried forward the theological and prophetic legacy of Isaiah, which stood in opposition to the prophecies of Jeremiah. I base my thesis on three points. First, the role of Egypt as a weak and theologically inappropriate ally for Judah, a theme that is found in both prophets’ oracles. Second, Assyria was used prominently in both Isaiah and Ezekiel, albeit in different, yet compatible, ways. In Isaiah, Assyria is an enemy that overstretched its rightful authority due to arrogance. In Ezekiel, Assyria is a symbol of strength and pride that has been shamed. Third, the theme of hybris found in Isa 7:7–9, which is the basis of Isaiah’s advice to Ahaz, is found also in Ezekiel’s condemnation of Tyre (Ezek 26–28*). Ezekiel’s continuation and development of Isaiah’s prophecies, it will be proposed, was the result of his inheriting Isaian traditions, which were supportive of Zion traditions, and which were therefore preserved and studied in the Jerusalem temple. These traditions stood in contrast to the Deuteronomic traditions defended by Jeremiah at the time of Josiah’s death (e.g., Jer 7 and 26). Here I will draw upon and hope to present further support of the recent research by Dalit Rom-Shiloni, which places Ezekiel and Jeremiah in opposition to one another.
|
The New Text of the Catholic Letters in NA28: Some Examples
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Holger Strutwolf, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
While the apparatus of the whole NA was revised and corrected, the text of the Catholic Letters was changed according to the new insights that were won by the Edito Critica Maior of the Catholic Letters. This paper will discuss passages where the text of Neste/Aland 27 has changed in the 28th edition (2 Pet 2,18/22: ??t??/??????; 3,6/2-4: d?? ??/d????; 3,10/48-50: ??? e??e??seta?/e??e??seta?) and will also explain the text critical reasoning behind these decisions. By doing so it will also discuss the aims and the limits of the Coherence-Based Genealogical Method in the process of text critical reasoning.
|
The ECM of the Gospel of Mark: Work in Progress
Program Unit: Novum Testamentum Graecum: Editio Critica Maior
Holger Strutwolf, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
While the work on the ECM of Acts has reached its final stage, the work of the Institute for New Testament Textual Research on the edition of the Gospel of Mark has already begun and has made good progress. The paper will report on the state of the preparations for this edition. It will also show the selection of manuscripts that are being fully transcribed and collated for the ECM of Mark and discuss methodological problems that have to be faced, e.g. how to deal with the synoptic problem while producing an edition of the oldest canonical Gospel. The paper will also give some information about tools and methods to identify manuscript clusters and families.
|
Apocalypticism in Second Temple Judaism
Program Unit:
Loren Stuckenbruck, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
*
|
Rethinking Suspicion of Isa 65:8–25
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Daniel J. Stulac, Duke University
Ecological hermeneutics is often defined according to suspicion, identification, and retrieval. The reader routinely cuts behind the anthropocentric text in order to identify with Earth community and retrieve its subjugated voice. Many believe that such methodology best supports behaviors that capably confront our ongoing ecological crisis. This paper offers a canonical reading of Isaiah 65:8-25 that calls that methodology into question. Close inspection of the passage in light of its placement within the larger biblical book reveals its focus on right eating. Theocentric, anthropocentric, and ecocentric interests blend so that Earth enjoys no autonomous voice apart from its interdependency with humans and God. This claim contrasts with two essays published in The Earth Story in the Psalms and the Prophets (2001), one by Anne Gardner and another by John Olley. Both authors attempt to isolate Earth voice in Isaiah 65 according to the eco-hermeneutic sketched above, leading to vague conclusions regarding humans’ transformed participation in Earth community. By contrast, this essay argues that Isaiah 65’s natural, theocentric-anthropocentric-ecocentric weave presents not an ecological liability, but a resource. The passage (in its canonical form) envisions human flourishing in an agro-ecosystem without fear of ecological catastrophe. A hermeneutic that attempts to cut behind the text’s anthropocentrism is ultimately hamstrung by its incapacity to reckon with the text’s concrete concern for humanity as it is interdependently linked with Earth and God.
|
How Did I Come to This? The Season of Writing for Chinese Churches
Program Unit: Ethnic Chinese Biblical Colloquium
Chloe Sun, Logos Evangelical Seminary
not available
|
The Exodus Motif: Is It the Way Out?
Program Unit: Jewish-Christian Dialogue and Sacred Texts
Jesper Svartvik, Lund University
One of the most important shifts in Christian theology is the move away from supersessionism, which either argues or simply takes for granted that Christianity has replaced Judaism, that the Church is the “new Israel”, and that Israel theologically has ceased to exist. In post-Nostra Aetate times Christians seek new ways to present Christianity that do not demean Judaism and Jews. A second important development in Christian theology is the growing awareness of the role of religion in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. This conflict is polarizing Christianity in a way that seems to lack contemporary parallels. Is there a way out of this conundrum? What role does the Exodus motif play? Contextual theology in the Holy Land is different from most other liberation theologies in the sense that for Palestinians it is difficult to perceive and apply the Exodus motif as a truly liberating paradigm because it is the master story of the political other, i.e. of Israeli Jews. There are two obvious alternatives, both of which are less than satisfactory: (i) The first option is simply to ignore the Exodus motif in particular and the entire Hebrew Bible in general. In other words, some choose not to use one of the most powerful discourses in the biblical texts. This alternative is part of a larger theological choice, i.e., the decision not to read the Hebrew Bible at all – because it is understood as being the Bible of the Hebrew-speaking Bible readers, i.e., Israeli Jews, the political antagonists. Although the decision not to read the Old Testament is quite understandable in the political situation, the result is a neo-Marcionite hermeneutics, which cannot but be described as a digression from Christian theology that emphasizes that the Christian Bible consists of two parts, and that both these parts are of importance to Christians. (ii) The other option is to read the Old Testament texts, again, in a supersessionist way, in which the Church is the new Israel, leaving no theological space for the Jewish people post Christum. Although this certainly is in continuity with traditional theology, it is, nevertheless, a kind of theological teaching of contempt that most Christian churches seek to avoid. (iii) Is there a tertium datur, which avoids the pitfalls of both the neo-Marcionite non-reading and the triumphalistic supersessionist reading of the biblical texts? How might such a third way be articulated? This paper seeks to advance Christian thought and action for the two major theological challenges facing contemporary Christian theology in the Holy Land: The need to find ways to articulate Christian theology (a) that does not condescend to the principal theological “Other” in Christian theology, i.e., the Jewish people and the Jewish faith, and (b) that addresses the role of religion in the most well-known political conflict in post-World War II times in which religious discourses play various and prevailing roles. In short, the focus in this paper is the interplay between contextual theologies and theologies of religions.
|
Transaction or Transformation? Early Christian Theologies of Reconciliation
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Jesper Svartvik, Lunds Universitet
The doctrine of justification has been called the articulus stantis et cadentis ecclesiae, often proclaimed as being not only essential to Christian belief but also exclusively Christian. Hence, its development is instrumental for a better understanding of early Jewish-Christian relations, as the Christian movement gradually began to articulate its own technical terminology. This paper traces this development from the inner-Jewish theologies of atonement in the New Testament, via the statements in the writings of the Apostolic Fathers’ statements about it being anexichiastos (“inscrutable”) and aprosdoketos (“unexpected”), and also the patristic concepts oikonomia, sarkosis and theosis, and finally to subsequent theories of violence as a necessary condition for reconciliation, to what Edward Irving once called the “stock-exchange divinity”. The paper will discuss Michael Gorman’s concepts cruciformity and cosmoformity, as well as Darrin W. Snyder’s main proposal in his tome Atonement, Justice, and Peace, and also the dialectics of Good Friday and Easter Day in early Christian thought. Although the focus in this paper is Jewish-Christian relations in antiquity, the paper will, by way of conclusion, also pose the following question: is death penalty a punishment or a crime? What difference does the answer to that question make for Christian theologies of the death of Jesus?
|
Romans 7:7–25 and a Pauline Allegory of the Soul
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Hans Svebakken, Loyola University of Chicago
Two distinct lines of contemporary research into Romans 7:7-25 fruitfully explore key aspects of the passage, but they have not fully engaged one other. One line of research focuses on allusions to the story of Adam and Eve in Genesis 2-3, addressing related questions, such as whether the “I” (ego) of the passage speaks in the character of Adam or Eve (e.g., Stefan Krauter in ZNW 99 [2008]), or how the prohibition of desire in Romans 7:7 (ouk epithumeseis) might represent a version of the command issued to Adam and Eve in Paradise (e.g., Jan Dochhorn in ZNW 100 [2009]). Another line of research focuses on the discourse of moral psychology, addressing related questions, such as which philosophical perspective (Stoic or Platonic) the passage represents, or precisely what moral condition it describes (cf. the respective positions of Troels Engberg-Pedersen and Emma Wasserman). This paper proposes an interpretive framework capable of accounting for and integrating the respective insights of both lines of research by reading the passage in light of Philo of Alexandria’s allegory of the soul, which treats the story in Genesis 3 as a story about moral psychology. The paper has two basic parts. Part one posits the existence of a Pauline allegory of the soul by first identifying the characteristic features of Philo’s allegory then noting analogous features in Romans 7:7-25. Part two explains how attributing a rudimentary allegory of the soul to Paul not only solves specific exegetical problems but solves them in a historically plausible way: comparing Paul's approach to Genesis with a contemporary Jewish exegete versed in ancient philosophy, not with later Christian theologians articulating a doctrine of original sin (e.g., Augustine).
|
Veiled Woman in the Rhetoric of Paul (2 Corinthians 3–4): Gender Slander of Judean Superapostles in Corinth
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Diana M. Swancutt, Boston University School of Theology
This multi-axial paper uses ethnicity studies, gender analysis, postcolonial theories, and insights from James Scott, Dale Martin, and Troy Martin to offer an interpretation of Paul's "veiling" of Moses (2 Cor 3-4) as a gendered shaming devise of any form of Jewish gospel (for the 'nations') other than his own. I argue that Moses, and by extension the Mosaic covenant, is rendered woman/effeminate in Paul's discourse in order--greater to lesser--to emasculate his former "Hebrew" rivals in Corinth and to virilize his own authority before a community that has charged him with being weak and uneducated.
|
Swords into Plowshares or Plowshares into Swords? Isaiah and the Twelve in Intertextual Perspective
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Marvin Sweeney, Claremont School of Theology
Scholarly discussion of the synchronic and diachronic formation of the Book of Isaiah and the Book of the Twelve Prophets has begun to recognize the intertextual relationships between these two major prophetic books. Indeed, the Book of the Twelve Prophets appears to be formulated in part as a response to the Book of Isaiah. This paper examines that interrelationship by focusing on the famous “swords into plowshares” passages in Isaiah 2:2-4; Micah 4:1-5; Joel 4:9-13; and Zechariah 8:20-23 in relation to the expectations of future judgment and restoration in their respective books. Examination of these passages will demonstrate a major debate between Isaiah and the Twelve on the issue of the future of world peace and the political constitution of Israel. The Book of Isaiah envisions a process whereby the ideals of the “swords into plowshares” passage will be realized when both the nations and Israel suffer judgment on “the Day of YHWH.” The Book of Isaiah envisions the passing of Davidic kingship as Israel at large is granted the eternal covenant, King Cyrus of Persia is selected as G-d’s messiah and Temple builder, and ultimately YHWH is recognized as the true king at the end of the book. The Book of the Twelve envisions a process whereby the ideals of the “swords into plowshares” passage are realized when a new Davidic king rises to defeat the nations that threaten Israel who then ultimately recognize YHWH by the end of the book.
|
Isaiah 60–62 in Intertextual Perspective
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Marvin A. Sweeney, Claremont School of Theology
Isaiah 60-62 is a well known crux interpretum in discussion of the compositional history of the book of Isaiah. Although it is included in the chapters assigned to Trito-Isaiah, its affinities with the work of Deutero-Isaiah, including the so-called Servant Songs, have prompted scholars to present a number of hypotheses. Some identify these chapters as part of the work of Deutero-Isaiah; others to argue that there is no Trito-Isaiah and that Isaiah 56-66 as a whole must be considered as an extension of Isaiah 40-55; and still others argue that Isaiah 60-62 constitute part of a redactional stratum that edited Proto- and Deutero-Isaiah into a sixth century edition of the book. This paper argues that intertextual considerations aid in settling the debate. It begins by considering the current state of intertextual studies, including the degree to which intertextual relationships may be the result of intentional authorial citation or allusion and the result of reader-oriented association. It then considers the intertextual links to other elements of the book of Isaiah, such as the royal oracles in Proto-Isaiah and the Servant Songs in Deutero-Isaiah, as well as its intertextual links with books such as Haggai, Zechariah, and Ezra-Nehemiah. As a result of these considerations, the paper argues that Isaiah 60-62 deliberately cites and reconceptualizes earlier Proto- and Deutero-Isaian texts. The result is a servant figure who is not a king, but is instead a priest from the Jerusalem Temple who gives expression to the concerns of the late-sixth century edition of the book as well as its final late-fifth century form.
|
Josephus 'On Stage': Pity as the Goal of the Judean War and Greek Tragedy
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Sören Swoboda, Friedrich-Schiller-Universität Jena
While the discussion on how to classify Josephus' works within ancient historiography is not new and attention is increasingly being paid to the genre of 'tragic history', more recently there have been attempts to draw parallels between the Judean War and Greek tragedy (e.g. Chapman [1998]; Feldman [1998/2006]). Following a sociological definition of "Hellenism", my paper argues not only that optimal conditions existed in Flavian Rome after 70 A.D. for Josephus to give his account of the Jewish War characteristics of the tragedy, and that a sustainable bridge can be constructed from Aeschylus, Euripides and Sophocles to Josephus via the Exagoge of the Jewish tragedian Ezekiel, but also that the Judean War ultimately pursues the same goal that the influential theory of the Aristotelian Poetics defined for the tragedy and that was already named by Gorgias of Leontini: Pity is to be aroused by scenes that cause horror. In discussing this theory of tragedy, which is controversial in the details, this paper presents arguments for the new thesis outlined above, which is based on the observation that Josephus' horrific representation of suffering is without parallel in the context of Greco-Roman historiography, that he embeds the motif of pity in the work in various ways, and that in the proem he himself problematizes the classification of the account as historiography by justifying the pathetic elements, which precisely ancient historians like Polybius criticized as being only suitable for the tragedy. With reference to the key text Ant VIII 127–129, this paper concludes that the intent of the Judean War to sketch the Jewish people as inherently noble and not at fault for the insurrection is also to be understood against the background of the theory of tragedy, according to which pity can only result through the staging of a "tragic hero".
|
The Change in the Reception of the Old Testament Apocrypha (Deutrocanonical) in the Coptic Church
Program Unit: Function of Apocryphal and Pseudepigraphal Writings in Early Judaism and Early Christianity
Hany N. Takla, St. Shenouda the Archimandrite Coptic Society
The Coptic Church has recognized the Old Testament Apocrypha books as part of the Bible Canon at least since the time Athanasius, AD 328-373, as seen in his39th Festal letter. These include Tobit, Judith, I and II Maccabees, Wisdom of Solomon, Wisdom of Ben Sira, Baruch, Letter of Jeremiah, and the additions to both Esther and Daniel. Athanasius did not include the two Maccabees books in his list of the so-called books for profitable reading, which further added the Didacalia and the Shepherd of Hermes. Baruch and the Letter of Jeremiah were always appended to Jeremiah, and the additions of Esther and Daniel were already integrated in their respective books. Further, in the Medieval works of Abu al-Barakat and Michael of Damietta the III Maccabees was added. The order of these books in the canon is not precisely known, based on the survived Coptic manuscripts, as there is no complete manuscript of the Coptic bible ever produced (Takla 60). A more precise order is found in Arabic manuscripts in circulation in Egypt, though none of them contains the entire bible canon either. The first printed edition of the Arabic bible to circulate in Egypt was a 3-volume edition published in Rome in AD 1672, based on Vatican manuscript of Syrian origin. The order of these books, except for III Maccabees, was same as in the Latin Vulgate. The text of the historical books of the Apocrypha were reproduced in manuscript form in several copies found in the Patriarchal Library (Macomber). The Arabic version of KJV was translated in Arabic in Beirut in 1863, these books were not included. Meanwhile in Egypt, the Anglican Church was growing in influence with the Coptic Church since 1815, being the primary supplier of printed biblical editions to the Coptic Church, which was still using manuscripts. In 1895, the Roman Pope installed a patriarch in Cairo, regarding him as the successor of Apostolic See of Saint Mark. Interestingly enough he was called by the same name as that of the then Patriarch of the Coptic Church. In 1911, Cyril V, the Patriarch of the Coptic Church, ordered the removal of these books from the canon (Meinardus 54). More than a decade earlier, this attitude change can be observed in a AD 1900 manuscript in the collection of the St. Shenouda the Archimandrite Coptic Society (ML.MS.24). This paper will discuss the evidence found in this manuscript and argue that both the 1985 ordination and the persistent and growing influence of the Anglicans in Egypt contributed to the 1911 decision. References: + Macomber, W. F. Final Inventory of the Microfilmed Manuscripts of the Coptic Orthodox Patriarchate, al-Azbakiyah, Cairo. 2 volumes Provo: Brigham Young University, 1990. + Meinardus, O F. A. Christian Egypt: Faith and Life. Cairo: AUC Press, 1970. + Takla, H. N. An Introduction to the Coptic Old Testament. Los Angeles: St. Shenouda the Archimandrite Coptic Society, 2007 (= Coptica 6, 2007)
|
Forgiveness as the Image of the Merciful and Just God
Program Unit: Bible and Ethics
Luke Ben Tallon, LeTourneau University
When Moses hears the extended proclamation of the divine name in Exodus 34 it appears that both mercy and justice are characteristic of the Lord God. The Lord shows mercy, but does not neglect justice. To be godly would seem to involve both traits and that seems to be the pattern in Israel’s ethics, instantiated in the injunction of Micah 6:8 “to do justice, and to love mercy, and to walk humbly with your God.”
When we enter, however, into the ethical exhortations of the New Testament, we find a strange pattern exemplified in Colossians 3:1-17 and Luke 6:20-38. In the former passage, the Colossians are exhorted to bear God’s image (as revealed by Jesus Christ) by forgiving just as the Lord has forgiven them. In the latter passage, followers of Jesus are challenged to be the Most High’s children by being merciful just as their Father is merciful. In both passages, explicit mention of justice is noticeably absent.
So, what has happened? The difference between Exodus and Micah on the one hand and Paul and Luke on the other cannot be explained simply in terms of new ethical instructions because the ethic of the latter passages is explicitly connected to imitatio Dei. Several interpretive options present themselves. Marcion and no small number of contemporary readers simply posit a change in God (or God’s characterization). This interpretation stumbles upon the common concern of these two authors, though expressed in different ways, to present Jesus Christ’s work as the continuation of the work of the God of Israel. Moreover, it overlooks a tendency within Israel’s scripture, notably in the Book of the Twelve, to reference or highlight only the first portion of the divine name in Exodus 34.
Another option is to present forgiveness as a two-step process: first God’s concern for justice is satisfied by punishing the wicked and then God is enabled to be merciful in forgiveness. This option has been chosen by most interpreters and ethicists as it appears to cohere with Paul’s understanding of the work of Jesus Christ. However, the texts in Luke and Colossians raise the possibility of another interpretation: merciful forgiveness is itself just. We will explore this possibility by beginning with the narrative soteriology of Luke-Acts. Attention to the Lukan account of how Jesus’ work of forgiveness answers the concerns for justice in the songs of Luke 1-2 opens into a similar reading of Paul’s understanding of forgiveness in Colossians. God’s forgiveness—the very definition of merciful justice and just mercy—serves as the ethical pattern for his children, created to bear his image and likeness.
|
Reading Philippians from the Perspective of a Political Prisoner Waiting for a Sentence to Death
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Elsa Tamez, United Bible Societies
I propose to analyze the text of the Letter to the Philippians from the perspective of a political prisoner who is waiting for a sentence to death. This involves studying the conditions of the prisons in the Roman Empire, charges, censorship, and all the risks posed by writing letters or other documents from the prison. There are risks to both authors and recipients. Take into account the chains as locus theologicus affects exegesis and hermeneutics of the Letter. I believe that the experiences of prisoners of antiquity as contemporary prisoners are key to understand Philippians. On the other hand, when read letters from prison of Bonhoefer, Frei Betto, Karl Gaspar, Mandela, Martin Luther King, Ingrid Betancourt and other, there are several constants like joy, management of time, life and death, inner strength, enhanced dignity, concern deep by family and friends, etc. This leads us to propose a new literary genre in the typology of letters in the Roman epistolography which would be: Letters from prison. This proposal calls into question the widespread proposal see in Philippians a “letter of friendship”.
|
Identity Issues in the Translation of the Performance of Sign Language
Program Unit: Bible Translation
Elsa Tamez, United Bible Societies
As part of the joint Bible Translation and Nida Institute session on Performance, Translation and Identity, this paper will address identity issues relating to the translation into sign language, both from a Performance Criticism point of view as well as from the perspective of the deaf community itself, in the Latin American context.
|
Reading the Creation Story (Gen 1:1–2:4) as Haka Taparahi (Maori Posture Dance)
Program Unit: Islands, Islanders, and Scriptures
Don Tamihere, Te Rau Theological College
Haka Taparahi is a form of Maori dance that is designed to capture and express deep emotion and powerful spiritual energy. From the steady vibration of the hands, the adoption of strong posture forms, powerful breathing and loud rhythmic and syncopated chant, Haka Taparahi seeks to communicate word through all the senses. Utilised as an approach to interpreting and communicating scripture, Haka Taparahi allows for a dramatic re-enactment of the emotion and spiritual energy that is often perceived as being within the biblical text, but is somehow not able to be communicated through words alone. When applied to the Creation Story of Genesis, the Ngati Porou classic Haka Taparahi Ruaumoko allows potential for the expression of the energy and spiritual power inferred within the story - from beginnings in void and darkness (Heb. tohu vebohu), through the hovering of the Spirit on the face of the deep (Heb. ruach merakefet), to the culmination of the creative act. This paper will explore Hebrew concepts present within Genesis 1:1-2:4 in relation to the classic haka Ruaumoko written by The Rev. Mohi Turei c.1870. The paper will culminate with a performance of Ruaumoko.
|
The Identity of the Virgin Mary in the Qur'an
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
Rami Tanous, University of Toronto
The Qur'an refers to the Virgin Mary (Ar. Maryam) as "sister of Aaron" (Q 19.28), "daughter of 'Imran" (Q 66.12), and also as the daughter of the anonymous "wife of 'Imran" (Q 3.35-36). Historically, Western scholars understood these Qur'anic references to conflate Virgin Mary with Miriam (Ar. Maryam), the sister of Moses and Aaron, who is also identified in the biblical narrative as "Miriam the prophetess, the sister of Aaron" (Ex 15:20) and as one of "the children of 'Amram" (Syr. 'Amran) along with Aaron and Moses (1 Chr. 6:3). Thus, Joseph Henninger refers to this "confusion" as "a huge historical error," and Arthur Jeffery calls it a "well known confusion." This "classical" view has been challenged by two prominent contemporary interpretations that renounce this notion of "confusion" in the Qur'anic texts concerning Mary's genealogy. Roberto Tottoli suggests that these Qur'anic texts offer a typological framework, similar to the one applied by the Church Fathers. These texts, he argues, utilize Miriam, the sister of Aaron and Moses, as a type of Mary, the mother of Jesus, by conflating both figures. The second interpretation, forwarded by Suleiman Mourad, argues that the terms "daughter" and "sister" in reference to Mary as "daughter of 'Imran" and "sister of Aaron" should not be understood in the Qur'anic context literally as referring to a direct child or sibling, but rather metaphorically, much in the same way Matthew's Gospel refers to Jesus as "the Son of David, the Son of Abraham" (Mt 1:1). This latter interpretation has received wider acceptance in contemporary scholarship. My paper endeavors to challenge the basic assumptions, premises and arguments of Tottoli's and Mourad's interpretations of these Qur'anic references. Tottoli's claim that the Qur'an utilizes typology analogous to the church fathers will be examined against the criteria of what constitutes 'valid' typology within the patristic framework. This will be followed by a re-examination of the references used by Mourad within their broader Qur'anic context. This analysis will demonstrate that both these interpretations of Mary's genealogy in the Qur'an are not tenable.
|
Mapping the Religious History of Latium: The Challenges and Potentiality of Constructing a Database of Religious History
Program Unit: Cognitive Science Approaches to the Biblical World
Frederick S. Tappenden, McGill University
While scholarly research on the world’s religious traditions—ancient and modern—is both rich and extensive, there has yet to be any kind of rigorous synthesis that collects the breadth of such information and makes it readily accessible to researchers interested in cross-cultural and long-term patterns of religiosity. In the hopes of filling this niche, the Cultural Evolution of Religion Research Consortium has embarked on a seven year Database of Religious History (DRH) project that will collect information on religious traditions spanning time and space, histories and cultures. This paper explores the potential of the DRH for the study of antique biblical religions, with specific emphasis given to the religious history of Latium (ca. 1000 B.C.E.–1500 C.E.). After first providing a general introduction to the DRH as a whole, I will explore the pragmatic and conceptual challenges that emerge when collecting and quantifying information for historically conditioned religious traditions. Specific attention will be given to the process of capturing both long- and short-term religious variety and variation (e.g., periodization, tradition demarcation, etc.). Finally, this paper will conclude by offering critical reflection on how the DRH can (a) bolster the study of early Christian groups within the context of comparative antique religions, and (b) inform both historical and cognitive studies of religion that concern the investigation of so-called “past minds.” In particular, the ability to locate ancient religious expressions within the context of broader patterns of religious thought and practice is an exciting prospect that brings both qualitative and quantitative potentialities.
|
Hylotheism—Life as a Slide Show
Program Unit: Westar Institute
Jarmo Tarkki, California Lutheran University
*
|
Questioning the Legitimacy of Sacrifice in Israelite and Hindu Tradition
Program Unit: Sacrifice, Cult, and Atonement
Jason R. Tatlock, Armstrong Atlantic State University
Sacrifice, specifically human sacrifice, is a divisive topic that has often been utilized as a characteristic of the so-called "other." As such the practice has been marshaled forth in propagandistic and ethnocentric attempts to describe foreigners. The British addressed the practice and explained that it corresponded to an unenlightened worldview. This paper is not primarily about discussions on the legitimacy of sacrificial rituals as described by outsiders, although reference will be made to the pressure placed by the British to end certain rites; instead focus will be trained on internal debates concerning the continuation of practices formerly accepted by some adherents to early Israelite religion and Hinduism of the modern period. An examination of the ways that debate within Indian culture played out in the twentieth century will provide points of correlation with Israelite struggles to purge human sacrificial rites from the repertoire of rituals, a process that gained momentum in the Babylonian period.
|
A New New Testament
Program Unit: Westar Institute
Hal Taussig, Union Theological Seminary in the City of New York
Over the past century and a half, numerous lost scriptures have been discovered, authenticated and celebrated. These are not the work of shunned sects or rebel apostles, nor are they alternative histories or doctrines. They were part and parcel of the vibrant conversations that sparked the rise of Christianity. In fact, many of these documents were every bit as important to shaping early Christian communities, practices and beliefs as those we have come to call the New Testament. Yet they are rarely heard in contemporary churches. Hal Taussig argues that we have a great deal to gain by bringing rediscovered documents back into conversation with the traditional New Testament, and hearing, once more, the fuller range of voices that formed the early Christian chorus.
|
Questioning the Category of Gnosticism for the Re-writing of the History of Early Christianity: An Appreciation and Extension of the Work of Karen L. King
Program Unit: Westar Institute
Hal Taussig, Union Theological Seminary in the City of New York
*
|
"Tabitha, Arise": Late Antique Sarcophagi, Christian Philanthropy, and the Iconography of Tabitha Raised from the Dead
Program Unit: Art and Religions of Antiquity
Catherine C. Taylor, Brigham Young University
Sarcophagi provide us with a rich source of late antique Christian iconography. This paper examines the iconography of Acts 9:36-41, particularly as depicted in three fourth-century sarcophagi housed today in the Musée de l’Arles Antique, the Assunta Cathedral in Fermo, Italy and the Church of Ste. Madeleine, Saint Maximin, France. The iconography of the narrative of Peter in Tabitha’s house has traditionally been used to highlight the experience of widows in the early Church or to illustrate charitable love within early Christian communities. However, little attention has been given to the reception of early Christian sarcophagi and Patristic texts that position the iconography of the Petrine miracle and the household of Tabitha within the context of death and idealized memorial. In fact, these sarcophagi demonstrate that late antique Christians used the story of raising Tabitha from the dead, not only as a trope of salvific memorialization, but also as a model for a new kind of philanthropic Christian household. Additionally, this paper contributes new material concerning patronage by late antique Christians, particularly the literate female devotee, as displayed on the Saint Maximin sarcophagus in tandem with the Tabitha scene. By associating Tabitha visually with widows, the poor, the foreigner, this paper will show how the reception of her benevolent acts became a standard for female patronage and philanthropy.
|
Is Israel a Missionary Failure? Isaiah's Servant of Yahweh and a New Telling of the Missio Dei
Program Unit: GOCN Forum on Missional Hermeneutics
Derek W. Taylor, Duke University
This paper offers a reading of Isaiah’s servant of Yahweh as a means of clarifying the missional nature of divine being. In so doing it offers a constructive challenge to a certain narrative-missional reading of the biblical story that has become commonplace. This common reading unfolds progressively and sequentially, running from creation to Israel to Jesus to the church. That this story encompasses the entire biblical narrative gives it obvious utility for discussions of missional hermeneutics. But it has a serious problem. The first half of the paper articulates this problem theologically; the second half turns to Isaiah’s servant of Yahweh texts as a means of problematizing the standard Missio Dei story and suggesting an alternative. First, the problem: the sequential telling of the story reads Israel as a failure. Such a reading has become commonplace (even if only implicitly) in contemporary attempts to read the Bible as an overarching story of God’s mission. N.T. Wright and Michael Goheen are briefly considered as leading examples. Such thinkers see the exile not merely as punishment for Israel’s unfaithfulness, but as punishment for Israel’s missionary failure. This subtle difference is significant, for it implies that Jesus is the necessary next step beyond Israel as the one who successfully embodies her missionary mandate. This common reading of the biblical story undermines a robust missional theology because it implies that the community’s participation is not integral to God’s mission of redemption. At the story’s key moment the human community appears dispensable and God acts alone. Divine-human participation becomes a subsidiary aspect of the doctrine of God. The second half of the paper turns to Isaiah’s servant of Yahweh. It makes two key points. First, these texts problematize the notion that Israel is a missionary failure by suggesting that Israel’s eschatological and universal mission is a specifically exilic discovery rather than the foundation upon which the exile can be conceived in the first place. The exile lays the groundwork for the emergence of a centrifugal conception of mission. Therefore it is difficult to read the transition from Israel to Jesus with the sequential neatness that characterizes many tellings of the Missio Dei story. Second, the diasporic movement from near to far (and the suffering and vulnerability characteristic of this movement) are not antithetical to mission. Contrary to the obvious implications of the standard Missio Dei story, suffering, vulnerability, and diaspora should not be conceived as punishment but as the necessary form of faithful participation in God’s mission of redemption. In conclusion I suggest that we can still read the Bible as an overarching story of mission, but that we should do so retrospectively, in light of Christ, and that we should acknowledge the specifically theological nature of our reading. When we do, Israel’s exile is no longer a problem in our telling of the story, but a resource for our articulation of a missional conception of God and the church’s participation in God’s missionary work.
|
The Archaeology of Cult of Ancient Israel’s Southern Neighbors and the Midianite-Kenite Hypothesis
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Juan Manuel Tebes, Pontificia Universidad Católica Argentina
The Midianite-Kenite hypothesis, the idea that the pre-Israelite roots of Yahwism can be traced back to the tribes living in the arid belt to the south and south-east of Palestine, has a long pedigree in biblical scholarship and until these days remains as one of the most authoritative explanations for the dawn of the cult of Yahweh. Analyses supporting this view, however varied, generally agree in three main points. First, they assume that the influence of the southern cultic practices on Yahwism occurred during a restricted period of time, generally dated to the Early Iron Age. Second, they see the origins of Yahwism through the lenses of diffusionist perspectives, characterizing this process as a movement or migration of one or a few determined groups, being them Israelites or Midianite-Kenite groups, to Canaan. And third, adequate analyses of the archaeological evidence of the arid areas to the south of Palestine are lacking. In this article I will turn the interpretation of the epigraphic and archaeological evidence upside down. Instead of looking to the (mostly biblical) evidence on the origins of the cult of Yahweh and assuming its origin lies in movements of people from the southern regions to Canaan in the Early Iron Age, I will focus attention on the history of the cultic practices in the Negev, southern Transjordan, and northern Hejaz during the entire Iron Age as they developed inside the framework of the local sociopolitical and economic processes, and how this information is related to the religious practices known in Judah and Israel during the biblical period, providing new light on the prehistory of the development of the cult of Yahweh. I will evaluate the evidence not as a single, exceptional event, but as long-term process within the several-millennia history of cultic practices and beliefs of the local peoples.
|
The Reception and Adaptation of 1 Cor 7:1–16 in Selected Ethiopic Literature: A Study in Biblical Reception History
Program Unit: Ethiopic Bible and Literature
Meron Tekleberhan, Ethiopian Graduate School of Theology
This paper will offer a diachronic study of the reception and appropriation of 1 Corinthians 7 in the Ethiopic Pauline Andemta commentary, in Mare Yishaq, the Ethiopic Treatise of Asceticism by Isaac of Nineveh, and the Fetha Negast, the Ethiopian Church’s legal code . The study will utilize literary modes of interpretation to assess the continuity and discontinuity between the selected Ethiopic materials and source materials to establish the degree of adaptation and indigenization that accompanied the Ethiopic reception of biblical and patristic materials. The paper will begin with a brief reflection on the theoretical basis of Reception History and how it pertains to the study of Ethiopic materials. The second part of the study will offer an overview of the history of transmission of the biblical and patristic materials to be discussed. In the third section the paper will make use of literary modes of interpretation to identify the use of biblical and patristic materials in: the Geez and Amharic translations of 1 Corinthians 7, in the Pauline Andemta commentary, the Mare Yishaq, and Fetha Negast. In conclusion the study will identify key paradigms governing the reception and adaptation of 1 Corinthians as a minor contribution towards establishing models for Ethiopic interpretive traditions.
|
The Armenian Textual and Interpretive Traditions of Philo’s De Decalogo
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Abraham Terian, National Academy of Sciences / Armenia
The major thrust of this paper is to underscore the Armenian variant renditions of the Greek text of Philo’s De Decalogo. Although Cohn accounts for these variants in the apparatus criticus of his edition of the Greek text, he does not seem to allow the Armenian text any favorable reading to help emend likely corruptions in the Greek. There are instances where Colson has rightly questioned certain of Cohn’s readings of the Greek text. Taking up these instances as initial cases for consideration, the paper assesses the validity of Cohn’s other, possibly questionable readings. It concludes with a brief reflection on the Armenian text’s outright departures from the original Greek, with some remarks on the Armenian reception history of this work of Philo.
|
Jews and Christians in John Moschus
Program Unit: Early Jewish Christian Relations
Ulla Tervahauta, Helsingin Yliopisto - Helsingfors Universitet
This paper discusses Christian and Jewish co-existence in Byzantine Palestine from the point of view of John Moschus in his Meadow. Moschus’ work suggests co-existence and co-operation of Jews and Christians in everyday life. Yet although Moschus’ stories tell of shared life, they also portray violence that stems from the friction between the two communities. This paper analyses two themes, co-existence and violence. First, a comparison is made between John Moschus and his view of Jewish-Christian relations, and Jewish-Christian relationships as evidenced in sources and scholarship on earlier centuries. The relationship between Judaism and Christianity in the first centuries CE has traditionally been seen as that of Christians growing apart from Judaism and being driven out of the Jewish community, but the view has been challenged in many recent studies. Second, violence in a story of children play-acting Christian liturgy is triggered when a rabbi’s son converts to Christianity and refuses to continue Jewish way of life. A “private” decision has communal consequences and leads to public violence as the father tries to have his son murdered in public baths, and eventually, Christian mob lynches the father. Public and private mix in this account of violence that is inspired by biblical models.
|
Levites as Diviners?
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Hanna Tervanotko, University of Helsinki
Recent studies on priests and Levites in the texts of the Second Temple era emphasize the so-called ”magnetic quality” of their priesthood (Stone 1988; Angel 2010; Samuel 2013). Apart from their priestly functions, the priests and Levites also feature prominently in other roles, such as those of a sage and judge. It has been acknowledged that the foundations of these different roles can be traced in the Hebrew Bible.
Less attention has been dedicated to the portrayal of Levites as diviners (i.e., individuals specialized in getting to know the divine will). Yet various literary traditions of the late Second Temple period, e.g., the Aramaic Levi Document and Jubilees, refer to the members of the Levite family as characters that access divine revelations in different ways. The Levites receive visionary dreams and they participate otherworldly journeys. The Levites are also known to encounter divine beings (Tervanotko, forthcoming). Thus, the connection between the Levites and divination demands clarification.
In this presentation I focus on some of the key passages of the Hebrew Bible where Levites appear to inquire the divine will: e.g., Deut 33:8 portrays Levi as a figure that possesses urim and thummim and in Judg 18:5-6 the Levite priest inquires the divine will. The Levites’ connection with divination is strengthened by Judg 17:3-5; 18:14, 17-20, 24, 27 that suggest the Levite priest used ephod and teraphim in his function. After analyzing these passages I draw some conclusions concerning the development of the portrayals of the figure of Levi and the Levites.
|
On Keeping a Lamb Four Days: Mišmeret in Exod 12:6
Program Unit: Cultic Personnel in the Biblical World
John Tracy Thames, Jr., Johns Hopkins University
The prescription in Exodus 12:3-6 requiring each paternal household to select and keep a kid four days prior to slaughtering it as a paschal sacrifice is an enigmatic episode without parallel in other biblical accounts of the Passover. A pure, one-year old, male kid is taken on the 10th of the first month and it becomes a mišmeret until its sacrifice on the 14th. For centuries the Rabbis quarreled over the enduring applicability of that unique ordinance as well as its meaning. It is the latter question that comprises the focus of the present discussion. In an attempt to discern the significance of the four-day enclosure of the kid, I set out upon three avenues of investigation. The first is a philological assessment of the only term in Exodus 12:6 that hints at a description of the rite: mišmeret. Analysis of usage of the word in P and Ezekiel reveals a nuance that suggests a manner of treatment for sacred objects, indicating an otherwise unrecognized status afforded to the soon-to-be sacrificial animal. The second avenue is comparative. Several festival texts from Emar (zukru, shorter zukru, and the six-month ritual calendar) prescribe a ritual action that may be translated as ‘confining’ an animal prior to slaughter. As translation of the term is debatable, I make a contribution to its appropriate understanding before assessing the value of the Emar texts as comparanda for the Passover instructions in Exodus. Finally, a third avenue is followed to a position from which the broader perspective of ritual theory may help to elucidate the problem of the enclosed animal. I draw perspectives from Victor Turner and Mary Douglas to appreciate the liminality of the animal in this state and its transformation into a sacred object prior to its sacrifice.
|
So What's the "Problem"? Reframing the Question of the Relationships between the Gospels
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Tom Thatcher, Cincinnati Christian University
This paper will introduce the session by setting broad parameters for the discussion of the relationships among the Gospels in terms of ancient media culture. Historically, questions surrounding the "Synoptic Problem" have been conceived primarily in literary terms, with focus on the relationships between the print texts of Mark, Matthew, and Luke. Recent research on the workings of, and interfaces between, memory, orality, and writing in antiquity has raised a number of fresh perspectives on ways to approach the problem. After briefly reviewing the traditional approaches to the Synoptic Problem, the paper will restate the essential questions in terms of oral-memorial processes and the relationships between "tradition" and writing in antiquity. The remaining papers in the session will apply these broad methodological concerns to more specific problems in the study of the Synoptics.
|
Self as Other: Gender Reversal and “Re-reversal” as a Coping Mechanism in the Prophetic Marriage Metaphor
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible and Cognate Literature
Rannfrid Thelle, Wichita State University
In this paper, I explore some of the mechanisms of the instances when Israel’s poets, prophets, and spokespersons use the marriage metaphor to describe and accuse themselves and their own behavior. I analyze the use of the metaphor in three texts: Hosea 1-3, Jeremiah 2-4, and Ezekiel 16, focusing on the last text. The structure of the metaphor is hierarchical, gendered, and mirrors patriarchal power relations; therefore these texts identify the community (including the prophets and writers themselves) as female. Identifying apostate Israel with a straying wife embodied prevalent attitudes about women and marriage in ancient Israel, and afforded an appropriate vehicle for portraying Israel’s breach of the covenant with God.
This use of the metaphor also simultaneously opens up a number of options for the community’s self-identification. By taking the metaphor seriously, and examining more closely the behavior that Israel is accused of in the texts in question, I show that although the prophets’ community may identify itself first as female, a reversal takes place when it realizes that a bad woman is described in terms of male behavior. This recognition must pose a challenge to the community that is meant to identify with the wife in the metaphor. Whereas the initial shift in identification that the male elites might make to the husband in the metaphor, they might in turn be troubled by the portrayal of the “bad” woman as exhibiting male behavior. The gender-reversal entails the emasculation of God. In yet another step, however, a re-reversal takes place, when God indicts the wife, who is punished for her behavior, and “put back in her place,” so to speak. Her shaming and dishonoring of husband God (through behavior most often attributed to men) is punished by violence, exposure, and public shaming, in a re-reversal through which the community may again identify with the suffering and abused wife. This dynamic might perhaps best be described as a coping strategy. In making my argument, I use a combination of metaphor theory, gender theory, and the psychological concepts of identification and defense mechanisms/coping strategies.
|
“Ktistes” (1 Pet 4:19) in Light of the Numismatic Record
Program Unit: Biblical Lexicography
Michael P. Theophilos, Australian Catholic University
One of the early modern scholarly endeavors to grapple with, and incorporate, critical numismatic material into the emerging discipline of Greek lexicography, was that of Passow’s Wörterbuch der griechischen Sprache (Göttingen, Germany: Vandenhoeck and Ruprecht, 1912-1914). A decade later, the pioneering linguistic work by F. Preisigke and E. Kiessling, also drew on numismatic material, as did its revisions and supplements (Wörterbuch der griechischen Papyrusurkunden mit Einschluss der griechischen Inschriften, Ausschriften, Ostraka, Mumienschilder usw. aus Ägypten (3 vols. Berlin: Erbe)). Although later studies have occasionally drawn on the material evidence of the numismatic record (with some notable exceptions), characteristically this material is neglected in technical discussions of Greek lexicography. With the recent publication of Wolfgang Leschhorn’s Lexikon der Aufschriften auf griechischen Münzen, scholars have been provided with a rich resource of organized and dated possibilities. “ktistes” (1 Peter 4:19) is a New Testament hapax legomenon, and is characteristically translated “creator” in modern English versions (ASV, CEB, CJB, RHE, ESV, GW, GNT, HCSB, KJV, NAS, NCV, NIV, NKJV, NRSV, YLT [however cf. “maker” BBE, WYC; “who made you” NLT]). Attention to the numismatic record illustrates that, given the context of the passage, the author of 1 Peter may have had a particular aspect of the semantic domain of this word in view. Coinage throughout the entire breadth of the Mediterranean world, including Asia Minor, Greece, Italy, Egypt and Judea, amply attest to the use of “ktistes”, not in the traditional sense of the Judeo-Christian category of ontological “creator”, but rather with reference to political function. This paper is part of a larger project entitled, Numismatics and Greek Lexicography, which explores the implications of the numismatic material for contributions to lexicography, particularly as it pertains to linguistic features of post-classical Greek.
|
Christ, the Seed of Abraham
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Matthew Thiessen, Saint Louis University
Within his larger argument regarding the way in which gentiles can become descendants of Abraham through the pneuma, Paul asserts that Christ is the seed of Abraham. In doing so, he makes much of the fact that the promise refers to a grammatically singular sperma, not plural spermata (Gal 3:16). Modern interpreters frequently conclude that Paul’s reading is contrived, since the word sperma often functions as a collective singular. In fact, in Genesis 12-26 Abraham’s sperma appears to refer to his uncountable offspring, not to one specific descendant. Other interpreters try to mitigate the force of this accusation by noting that Paul identifies Christ with sperma of Abraham on the basis of 2 Samuel 7:12, which refers to David’s singular, messianic seed. Paul thus connects David’s promised seed, the Messiah, to the promises God made to Abraham because of the multiple references to seed in the Abraham Narrative.
In this paper I argue that Paul connects the Davidic seed of 2 Sam 7:12 to the Abrahamic seed of Genesis 15, not only on the basis of the linking word sperma, but also on the basis of the phrase “one who comes out of you,” which is virtually unique to these two passages in Jewish scriptures. These connections between Genesis 15 and 2 Samuel 7 suggest that the narrative and promises of Genesis 15 are of critical importance for Paul’s argument that gentiles enter pneumatically into Christ and thus become genealogically descended from Abraham.
|
Topos as a Heuristic Construct for Reading Ancient Moral and Religious Texts
Program Unit: Rhetoric of Religious Antiquity
Johan Thom, Universiteit van Stellenbosch - University of Stellenbosch
Using carefully selected texts from the Hellenistic Greek popular philosophical and religious corpora, Hellenistic Judaism, and the New Testament, my paper will address questions regarding the form(s) and function of topos in ancient moral and religious texts, the role it plays in a text’s communication strategy, and how insight into topoi contributes to the interpretation of texts.
|
Practicing Porneia: Inappropriating 1 Cor 6:9–20 for Erotic Justice
Program Unit: Paul and Politics
Eric A. Thomas, Drew University
As an act of resistance to the ways that some biblical texts are used to authorize the hateful, unjust and even violent treatment of queer people, as an African American same-gender-loving man, I plan to assess the text of 1 Cor 6:9-20 from the point of view of the socially vulnerable members of the mid-1st century assembly at Corinth. I argue that: (1) Paul’s mandate that the members shun porneia addressed the powerful. However, because (2) the socially vulnerable, even if they had the will to comply with Paul’s message, would not necessarily have the agency to do so given the sexual “duty” that slaves especially owed to their owners, and that (3) this message can be appropriated as a counter-discourse that seeks to figure the ekklesia as an erotically just place for everyone. In the ancient context, this reading imagines what the powerless of the church at Corinth might say in response to Paul if they could speak for themselves. In the contemporary context, this reading “talks back” to Western society’s often un-interrogated homophobic discourse. My approach to this text is queerly feminist in that it is informed by Joseph A. Marchal’s call for improper relations with Pauline letters, Elisabeth Schüssler-Fiorenza’s emancipatory-radical democratic paradigm, particularly her model of the ekklesia of wo/men and Audre Lorde’s “uses of the erotic” as a practice of justice-making. Marchal suggests that interpretations that seek to naturalize and normalize queer subjects should be deemed “inappropriate” in favor of arguments that thoroughly interrogate the intersecting dynamics of power and privilege. Adding to these methods, I attempt to complement Marchal’s adjectival use of “appropriate” by also making it into a verb, to take (appropriate) what is useful from the text, disqualify what is not (inappropriate), and propose (re-appropriate) a not-yet-seen vision of the ekklesia of wo/men and queer people.
|
How We Think They Thought: Cognitive Anthropology, Ritual Studies, and the Study of the Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Religious Experience in Antiquity
Samuel Thomas, California Lutheran University
The title of this paper is a riff on Maurice Bloch’s book, How We Think They Think: Anthropological Approaches to Cognition, Memory, and Literacy. Bloch’s chief assertion is that non-linguistic forms of knowledge are central to the operations at work in human experience and culture. Of course, the advantage of ethnographers and psychologists is that they study living people and have access to non-textual forms of communication, ritual enactments, social patterns, etc.—dimensions of culture available to scholars of ancient religions only (or mostly) in textually mediated forms. This paper will discuss three particular examples from the Hodayot, the Songs of the Sabbath Sacrifice, and the Songs of the Sage, asking: can the fields of anthropology, cognitive linguistics, and performance and ritual studies provide heuristic frames for a better understanding of religious experiences in antiquity? What are the benefits and limits of such approaches? How might they illumine the nature of religious experience as expressed in these Qumran texts? And how might they change “how we think they thought”?
|
Travels of a Church Mother: Egeria’s Interpretation of Genesis
Program Unit: Recovering Female Interpreters of the Bible
Emily Thomassen, Trinity Christian College
Egeria’s pilgrimage to the Holy Land took place only fifty years after Constantine’s reign. Her travel account is the earliest surviving work of its kind. While interpreting biblical texts, Egeria described her travels to the Holy Land with vivid attention to detail. This paper will focus on Egeria’s commentary on Abraham, Lot, and Lot’s wife in the region of the Dead Sea, Melchizedek in the region around Jerusalem, and Abraham, Jacob and Rachel at Charra (Haran). Egeria’s travel account sheds light on biblical interpretation and early Christian pilgrimage and worship during the fourth century. Based on Egeria’s work it can be seen that women studied and interpreted the Scriptures and were given a recognized leadership role within the early church.
|
Using the Aural/Oral Approach to Biblical Greek in Asia: A Case Study from Hong Kong
Program Unit: Applied Linguistics for Biblical Languages
Glen L. Thompson, Asia Lutheran Seminary, Hong Kong
Hong Kong is the home to more than two dozen seminaries, and their students normally begin their theological studies with educational levels equivalent to those in the US. Despite this, seminary students as a whole have been singularly resistant to (or unsuccessful at) developing more than the most rudimentary skills in either of the biblical languages.
After receiving training from the Biblical Language Center, Asia Lutheran Seminary (Hong Kong) inaugurated its own one-year intensive program in oral/aural Koine Greek in 2012. While seeking to incorporate the pedagogical strengths of BLC with its own regional student body, ALS developed its own one-year program for Asian students. The program includes both intensive face-to-face session and distance Skype-meetings. After one year, students are able to begin exegesis of the Greek text of John’s Gospel. Since intensives sessions are held between normal seminary semesters, students from other institutions can enroll without impeding their other coursework.
The presentation will document the initial two cohorts who have graduated from the program, highlighting pedagogical strengths and weaknesses to this approach that have come to light in the Asian context. Specific attention will be given to how the methodology has impacted 1) students whose native language is non-European and different from that of the instructors; 2) younger vs. older students; and 3) attrition and success rates among the language learners (as compared to traditional programs). New written and visual materials developed at ALS to enhance the “living language” experience will also be discussed, as well as the question of what types of traditional resources (grammars, morphologies) have been used to support the learners during and after the course. Finally, the presentation will describe ALS’s attempts to create a culture of biblical language learning both as an institution and among its program alumni.
|
Digital Biblical Hebrew Vocabulary Learning Using ANKI
Program Unit: Global Education and Research Technology
Jeremy Thompson, Logos Bible Software
Despite recent advances in understanding how learners acquire vocabulary many instructional materials for biblical languages still include little more than lists of words with features that are especially problematic in light of these recent advances. In this paper, I will demonstrate a newly developed approach to Biblical Hebrew vocabulary learning that incorporates modern insights from second language vocabulary acquisition using ANKI. I will begin by outlining some helpful principles for second language vocabulary teaching and learning based on research in second language vocabulary acquisition. These principles include limiting the size of sets of vocabulary, the use of images, and spaced repetition, among others. I will briefly comment on how current approaches to vocabulary instruction in biblical languages fare in light of this research. While there have been some advances made by those pursuing a communicative method for biblical language instruction, many instructional materials remain problematic. Furthermore, some advances made by incorporating communicative methods may also turn out to be problematic in the end, such as the neglect of the potential value of a learner’s first language (L1) in instruction. Finally, I will demonstrate how the principles outlined in the first part of the paper have been incorporated into a set of ANKI flashcards for a first year course in Biblical Hebrew. ANKI is an open source, cross-platform flashcard program, which makes it appealing from a global education perspective.
|
Overlooked Presuppositions in the Deuteronomistic History
Program Unit: Deuteronomistic History
Richard Jude Thompson, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
Recent work done on Noth’s DH has complicated the simplicity of his original hypothesis. Instead of a single author, Dtr, the DH has a school of hypothesized authors and editors that consist of at least DtrG, DtrN, DtrP, DtrB, DtrL, Dtr1, Dtr2, and DtrH. Instead of a unified history, diverse interests appear to characterize each author of the work. Instead of a simple retrospective work done in the exile in Babylon, the work appears to have originated with the revolutionary reform of Josiah in Jerusalem in the seventh century b.c.e. Instead of advocating a return to Mosaic law, it visualizes a new, imperial relationship with yhwh. Instead of furthering the ideal of the “ten words” and the rule of law, it projects an ideology of military aggression that tramples on the “ten words.” Along with the single-author and multiple-redactor model, the layer model suggests that it went through at least three changes in time and place.
This analysis has both provoked and overlooked further questions about the DH and its hidden presuppositions. Scholars have not questioned the nature of the exact “law” that caused the exile of the nation. Scholarship has not investigated the extrabiblical source of the rational advance and the political and cultic centralization of the Josianic age. Scholars have not questioned the transformation of a local god in Jerusalem into an imperial god, who ordered the annihilation of the Canaanites. Nor do analyses of the DH question the self-proclaimed authority of the nebi'im as spokespersons for yhwh and as authors of the DH. Nor have scholars questioned the source of the presupposed international legal warrant of the god yhwh to give Canaan to his followers. The most recent studies of Römer, Otto, and others, however, have pointed the way to a possible solution in the Neo-Assyrian empire.
|
Did Jesus, in the Memory of His Earliest Followers, Ever Nurse the Sick?
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Steven Thompson, Avondale College
Did Jesus, in the memory of his earliest followers, sometimes administer basic nursing care to the sick, rather than always healing them miraculously and instantly? The widespread and almost unchallenged assumption in scholarship is that the Synoptic Gospel accounts of Jesus’ healings are to be read and understood as miraculous in nature, followed nearly always by instant recovery. While the Synoptic healing pericopes remain under intense scholarly scrutiny, the possibility that Jesus sometimes provided basic nursing care for the sick is hardly mentioned in recent literature. When mentioned, it is typically denied. This paper will report the results of a fresh examination of Synoptic Gospel passages. It will then suggest that in the memory of his early followers, Jesus on occasion provided basic nursing care to the sick. These passages will be viewed from the perspective of two social/cultural contexts. The first is the Jewish background of Jesus and his earliest followers, and the attitudes current in second temple Judaism towards treatment of the sick. This includes the Essene “healing community” of the Therapeutae, the practice of bikkur cholim (visiting the sick) and expectations that a messianic “Son of David” would bring the healing promised by the Prophets. The second perspective from which selected Synoptic Gospel healing passages will be read is the post-New Testament history of the Jesus movement. The paper will argue that the deep and widespread commitment of early Christians to treating the sick, which led to the establishment of hospitals, was prompted largely by the example of Jesus, providing on occasion basic nursing care, and was also the early Christian response to the Gospel Commission.
|
Jesus and Early Life Stages according to Luke: Expressing Jewish Male Formation and Gendering Using Greco-Roman Human Development Terms
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Steven Thompson, Avondale College of Higher Education
Twentieth-century studies of Greek and Roman constructs of childhood have weathered a period during which the very existence of this stage of human development in Greco-Roman consciousness was questioned. An equally sceptical view about the very existence of the construct "adolescence" as separate stage from “youth” has marked some scholarship of the same period. But a revolution in understanding the Greek and Roman constructs of childhood and adolescence has occurred during the past three decades. The findings of both literary and social historical investigations have exposed the inadequate foundations of these earlier dismissive views, and have provided sufficient evidence to support the view that the constructs “childhood” and “adolescence” were current and well-established in Greco-Roman minds and literature. This paper will apply these new perspectives to the sketch of the birth, childhood and adolescence of Jesus in the Gospel according to Luke. The paper takes the position that Luke was well informed about both the Greco-Roman culture of his day as well as the Jewish subculture. It will suggest that Luke, in his brief references to Jesus’ birth, childhood and adolescence, attempted to communicate to Greco-Roman readers, in terms they could understand, that the Jewish Jesus underwent the sort of physical and social development appropriate to a Jewish male of his era. The paper will conclude by suggesting that one of Luke’s motives was to counter initial attempts to “heroize” the child Jesus that survive in later Gospels. Luke’s counter-strategy was to attribute to Jesus what his Greco-Roman readers would recognize as a normal, non-heroic Jewish childhood.
|
The Rhetoric of Ambiguity in 2 Thessalonians
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Trevor Thompson, University of Chicago
John Chrysostom, in his fourth homily on 2 Thessalonians, addresses the identity of t? ?at????. He asks, “Why do you suppose Paul presents it so obscurely?” Chrysostom notes that some identify t? ?at???? with the grace of the Spirit while others connect t? ?at???? with Roman rule, the position Chrysostom favors. According to Chrysostom, Paul deliberately speaks covertly and dimly. Building upon Chrysostom’s observation of intentional ambiguity in the text, this paper will offer new solutions to classic interpretative cruces in 2 Thessalonians. The Greco-Roman rhetorical theorists offer the vocabulary and conceptual framework for interpreting 2 Thessalonians in this light. The temple in 2 Thess 2:4 can be understood as a homonymy (?µ???µ?a) referring on the one hand to the temple in Jerusalem and the other hand to a metaphorical use for God’s people. In addition, the multiple references to the opposing person/figure in 2 Thess 2:3-12 seem to be an instance of deliberate polyonymy (p??????µ?a). Far from clarifying the identity of the person/figure mentioned, the multiple descriptors multiply possible identifications. Further, ?? d?? ?µ?? (2 Thess 2:2) is syntactically ambiguous in meaning (“a letter supposedly [but not truly] from us” or “a letter as [truly] by us”) and in syntax (s??ta???). These intentional ambiguities serve the goal of the pseudepigrapher to avoid anachronism by allowing multiple interpretations.
|
The Role of the Gentiles in the Cult of YHWH in the Concluding Chapters of the Book of Isaiah and the Book of the Twelve
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Lena-Sofia Tiemeyer, University of Aberdeen
The correct worship of YHWH and the role of the Gentiles in that worship are two interconnected concerns in the final part of the book of Isaiah. This dual focus is especially prominent in Isa 56:1-8; 61:5-6 and Isa 66:1-24, three texts which are situated in strategic places in the beginning, in the centre, and in the end of Isaiah 56-66. These three texts do not express a united message, however. Instead, they disagree as to whether Gentiles can participate in the worship of YHWH and, if so, to what extent. The final part of the book of the Twelve attests to the same concerns and the same ambivalence. Zech 2:11; 8:22; 14:16-21; and Mal 1:11 speak of the participation of the Gentiles in the worship of YHWH. In contrast, Hag 2:20-23; Zech 1:15; 14:12 etc. articulate hostile attitudes towards the Gentiles. This paper investigates whether the shared emphasis on the cult, as well as the shared ambivalence towards the Gentiles’ role in that cult, in the concluding chapters of both the book of Isaiah and the book of the Twelve is historical, i.e. reflecting different viewpoints at different times in post-exilic Yehud, or whether it is a shared literary strategy which expresses the motives and concerns of the final editors of the two textual corpora, or both.
|
Biblical Studies and Digital Storytelling
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Nicole Tilford, Georgia State University
Educators have traditionally relied upon written assignments and exams to assess student comprehension. This paper explores how teachers might instead use “digital storytelling” to assess student progress in a biblical studies classroom. Simply put, digital stories are short videos that use audio narration, music, still pictures, and video clips to tell a personal story or describe a historical or cultural phenomenon. This medium is becoming increasingly popular among educators because of its ability to test student comprehension, practice research skills, and increase digital literacy in a manner that is fun and engaging for students.
This paper shall assess the benefits and challenges of using digital storytelling in the biblical studies classroom. In particular, we shall consider how the medium can be used to trace the reception history of important biblical figures. We shall argue that digital stories provide a more appropriate medium for analyzing the reception history of a biblical figure than traditional forms of assessments, since they can display a broader range of source material and thus more accurately represent the variety of mediums in which the reception history of a biblical figure manifests itself (texts, two-dimensional and three-dimension art, music, and oral narratives). Examples for the paper will be drawn from two recent undergraduate liberal arts classes in which students traced the reception of such figures as Jesus, Jezebel, Hannah, Priscilla, and Sarah.
|
The Syncretistic Mind of Early Christianity
Program Unit: Cognitive Science Approaches to the Biblical World
Nicole Tilford, Georgia State University
Syncretism is a cross-cultural phenomenon. As it has been traditionally understood, syncretism occurs when the cultural values of one group impose themselves upon the belief system of another group. Each group is thought to be self-contained and unadulterated prior to the melding. By such a definition, Christianity has often been understood as a “pristine” cultural system that became “polluted” over time by non-Christian beliefs. Cognitive scientists have challenged this understanding. Syncretism, they argue, is not the blending of two separate, self-contained cultural systems but a selective blending of an infinite number of conceptual structures. By such a reading, no culture exists in a pure, unadulterated form; rather, religious traditions are constantly transformed by new data, and each community must negotiate between multiple conceptual frameworks as it formulates its beliefs.
This paper shall consider how cognitive models might enhance the study of ancient syncretism. By way of example, I shall focus on early Christian syncretisms involving Lady Wisdom. A semi-divine figure from the biblical book of Proverbs, Lady Wisdom was a popular image in early Christianity: to some, she was a type for the mother of Jesus; to others, she was the Holy Spirit or the Christ Logos. Such diversity of interpretation was possible, even within a single community, because early Christians simultaneously blended ideas from multiple Greco-Roman, Jewish, and Christian conceptual frameworks. This paper shall use the syncretisms of Lady Wisdom to reexamine the nature of ancient syncretism and explore the challenges of applying modern cognitive models to the study of ancient religion. Questions to be considered include: How does one recover the cognitive frameworks of ancient communities? How does the elite provenance of our sources bias our access to the cognitive frameworks of non-elite Christians? Can universal models even be applied to specific historical circumstances?
|
Tripartite Baptism: A North African Anomaly?
Program Unit: Contextualizing North African Christianity
Maureen Tilley, Fordham University
Much of the quarrel between Catholics and Donatists revolved around their respective theologies of the sacraments. As the fourth and early fifth centuries progressed each group diverged from the other, especially on the validity of the sacrament of Baptism.
This paper traces one of the roots of the schism between the two groups to a baptismal controversy that was evolving out of the pseudo-Cyprianic corpus. In De rebaptismate,a little studied anonymous treatise, the author addresses the question of what actually constitutes Baptism: is it the water bath alone or is it the entire nexus of rituals. The pseudo-Cyprianic emphasis on anointing as integral to the baptismal rite may help explain how and why Catholics and Donatists evolved separated theologies of Baptism.
|
Empire by Subordination and by Invitation? Conflicting Political Visions in Amos 9
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Political Theory
Daniel C. Timmer, University of Sudbury
This paper integrates a literary-historical analysis of the book of Amos with political analysis of ancient states and their formation. It focuses on the curious description in Amos 9:11-12 of the eschatological integration of non-Israelite polities in the restored Davidic kingdom that uses both “possess” language (evocative of the description of Israel’s initial possession of Canaan by force in the Book of Joshua) and the phrase “over whom [YHWH’s] name is called” (which refers to YHWH’s ownership of his covenant people and never to military conquest). This tension is investigated by analyzing the passage in light of the politics of ancient empires, particularly their formation through subordination (S. Howe ) or invitation (C. B. Champion ) of communities, their subsequent control of the same through political sovereignty (M. Doyle ), and the role of religion in the process (S. Grosby, M. Fales, M. Zehnder). This focused analysis is then integrated into a larger perspective on the whole book, noting the absence of agency by Israel/Judah against non-Israelite states in chapters 1-2 before bringing the conclusions into dialogue with ancient Near Eastern prophetic depictions of utopia (E. Ben Zvi).
|
Religious Justifications and Condemnations of International Violence in Nahum: Contradiction or Paradox?
Program Unit: Warfare in Ancient Israel
Daniel C. Timmer, University of Sudbury
This paper examines how the book of Nahum represents violence in two very different ways. The first is its presentation of Neo-Assyrian violence, which is excessive in scope and degree, motivated by pride, and based on allegiance to gods who cannot justifiably motivate war. It is therefore culpable. Paradoxically, Assyria violence will be punished through a second kind of violence, exercised (ultimately) by YHWH (C. Crouch). This representation of violence is presented as acceptable because it frees Judah and many other nations from Assyrian oppression and violence (3:4, 19) and because Assyria is uniquely YHWH’s enemy (1:2, 8, 11). After examining these and other features of the book’s two perspectives on violence, the paper uses postcolonial and political insights to examine the presuppositions that allow such a distinction, the significance of the implicit non-participation of Judah and her king in violence against Assyria, and the significance of YHWH’s liberating not only Judah but non-Israelite polities as well from the Assyrian empire’s grasp.
|
Roman Diet and Meat Consumption: Reassessing Elite Access to Meat in 1 Corinthians 8
Program Unit: Social Scientific Criticism of the New Testament
Philip Tite, University of Washington
A persistent exegetical tradition exists that links the Pauline controversy over the consumption of idol meat, especially in the Corinthian correspondence, to social and economic assumptions about the Roman world. Specifically, there is the assumption that access to meat was limited to the elite within the Roman world. The lower classes are seen as only having access to meat through public religious festivals or as derivative through cultic sacrifice by means of the marketplace (though again largely limited to the wealthy), resulting in the classic view that non-elites were sustained on a diet of legumes, grains, and wine. Roman access to meat along such class demarcations, furthermore, is founded upon an economic dichotomy of elite and non-elite (i.e., poor or slave classes). These assumptions arise not only in scholarly treatments of the Corinthian context but also within numerous introductory textbooks, thereby perpetuating these views for future scholarship. This paper challenges these social assumptions regarding meat consumption in, especially, Corinth by engaging recent scholarship that re-evaluates roman diet in regard to access to meat and other animal products. Specifically I will draw upon methods in archaeological science (especially stable isotope analysis) as well as literary reassessments by ancient historians. What arises is a new picture of Roman diet, wherein meat consumption was not limited to the elite, but was prevalent in nearly all levels of Roman society. With this updated view on Roman dietary practices in mind, Paul’s comments in 1 Corinthian 8 relating to “idol meat” and the social situation in the Corinthian church must be re-evaluated.
|
The Sons of Jacob and the Sons of Herakles
Program Unit: Bible, Myth, and Myth Theory
Andrew Tobolowsky, Brown University
It is not, and probably will never be, possible to suggest the existence of a genealogical relationship between biblical myths about the patriarch Jacob and his children and the Greek myth about Herakles known as the Return of the Herakleidae. However, it is not necessary to identify such a connection to pursue a very useful analogical comparison.
There are a number of surface similarities between the biblical narrative of Jacob and his sons and the Return myth. This Greek myth, which became in time the etiological myth for the foundation of most of the major city states in the Peloponnese, begins with the establishment of a territorial birth right by a patriarch, includes an exodus of several generations, and ultimately results in the conquest and settlement of Argos, Corinth, Sparta, Messene and Elis by different Herakleid descendants. The parallels with the biblical conquest and settlement myths are obvious. They are also very useful.
One of the greatest challenges facing biblical studies, in my opinion, is the absence of evidence for the aggregation of myths in biblical literature. Unlike the Greek world where we can, in many cases, trace the appearance and disappearance of elements of a narrative over time, all biblical literature comes to us in the same collection, an aspect which I think significantly limits our ability to map development. True, various parts of biblical material appear to come from disparate times, but their shared end, in my opinion, keeps us from making over much of this fact. In such contexts, from the perspective of myth theory, older material is better understood as being employed, than being preserved.
Pursuing analogical comparison with similarly aggregative myths like the Return therefore serves the purpose of plumping out our stores of evidence for the creation of models of myth aggregation. Biblical scholars are, I think, in need of additional perspectives from which to revisit certain base assumptions of how the Jacob narrative was formed, and this is what Return narratives offer.
It certainly seems to be the case that all five of the major city-states which were eventually encompassed in Return myth had some role in the development of the aspects of the narrative related to them. And, it seems that the relatively open framework, the genealogical idea of the sons of Herakles of which there are approximately 100 in one place or another, served consistently as a platform for the continued growth of the tradition.
In our field, we tend to understand the 12 sons of Jacob and the 12 tribes of Israel as an organic, unitary and even possibly authentic tradition of a sociopolitical phenomenon of great antiquity. Comparison with Return myth offers us the opportunity to question this and other assumptions through an analysis of the evidence-rich development of a similar project, in a similar context, at a similar time. The light this can shed on biblical myth is vital to our understanding.
|
The Voice and Person of the Prophet in the Book of the Twelve
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Colin Toffelmire, Ambrose University College
Recent research into form and genre in the Book of the Twelve (e.g., by Schart, Sweeney, Nogalski, Bulkeley) raises the question of the nature, role, and function of the prophetic figure in the corpus. The current consensus is that the Book of the Twelve appears to be a literary product brought together with care and artistry, and not a hodge-podge of originally oral material now clustered together in loose collections. Given this shift in perspective, questions arise as to the importance and role of both the prophetic persona and the prophetic voice in the Book of the Twelve. Each of the books in the corpus is aligned with some figure, and in some cases information is provided about this figure. Also, each book in the corpus (with the possible exception of Jonah) presents a first person singular voice that speaks as a representative of YHWH – a prophetic voice. In some cases recent research has focused on this prophetic persona, exploring the function of the figure created in some of the prophetic books in the Twelve. In other cases research has focused on the prophetic voice divorced from any specific historical or narrative figure. This paper brings together these two streams of research, exploring the question of prophetic voice and prophetic figure. I will argue that the presentation of the prophetic voice as belonging to an authoritative prophetic figure is an integral feature of the various books within the Twelve, and creates a situational context that simultaneously ties the prophetic book to an authority in the past and allows for the possibility of continued reuse of the prophetic books in public (possibly liturgical?) readings. By speaking with the prophetic voice, later readers and re-readers are able to take on, in some way, the mantle of the prophetic figure as the text is re-appropriated in new situations and times.
|
Synchronic Trends in the Book of the Twelve
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Colin Toffelmire, Ambrose University College
Synchronic Trends in the Book of the Twelve
|
Job and Jewish-Christian Relations: A Response
Program Unit: Jewish-Christian Dialogue and Sacred Texts
David C. Tollerton, University of Exeter
This paper will respond to some of the latest developments witnessed in the interface between interpretation of the Book of Job and contemporary Jewish-Christian relations. It will consider some of the ways in which readings of Job have been influenced by interactions between Jews and Christians, and weigh up the value of this biblical tale as a resource for ongoing interfaith dialogue.
|
The Primary Translations of the Hebrew - A Synthesis
Program Unit:
Emanuel Tov, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
There are not many comparative descriptions of the primary translations of the Hebrew Bible, and the preparation of the THB provides a unique opportunity
for a comparative analysis. Points for comparison are inter alia: the background of the translation and its historical background; the number of the translators and the
relation between them; revisional activity in the translations; cooperation between the translators; differences between the translations; exegetical approaches
and theology; approaches towards the Hebrew base text; state of preservation of the translations; text-critical value for the study of the Hebrew text.
|
“Priest of the Uncircumcised”: Melchizedek and the Gentiles in Hebrews and Beyond
Program Unit: Social History of Formative Christianity and Judaism
Philippa Townsend, Ursinus College
Issues of genealogy and descent weave through Jewish debates about the second temple and its priesthood. In this paper, I argue that the centrality of genealogy to the Jewish priesthood should be understood within the context of the deep and multivalent connections between sacrifice and kinship in the ancient Mediterranean world. As Nancy Jay and others have demonstrated, sacrificial initiation and participation established intergenerational continuity between men, functioning to regulate and index patrilineal descent and establish lines of inheritance. The significance of the various discursive associations between sacrifice and descent was not static, however, and could be deployed in myriad ways.
Scholars who have focused on Christian texts about sacrifice and priesthood have paid less attention to questions of descent, perhaps because of the perception that these issues quickly became irrelevant to early Christians. Focusing on the changing representations of the figure of Melchizedek, from the New Testament book of Hebrews through later Christian and Jewish sources, I make the case that the discursive connection between sacrifice and kinship construction is central to views of sacrifice in formative Christianity as well as Judaism.
Traditionally, scholars have argued that the reason Hebrews emphasizes the mysterious origins of Melchizedek, the enigmatic priest “without father, without mother, without genealogy,” is in order to legitimate Jesus’s priesthood despite the fact that he lacked the necessary priestly descent from Levi. In this paper, I consider the issue from a different perspective: rather than downplaying physical ancestry in order to legitimize Jesus as high priest, I suggest that Hebrews is arguing for the legitimacy of Jesus as high priest in order to downplay the importance of physical ancestry. Jesus’s priesthood functions in the text to charter a new people, whose legitimacy lies precisely in the obscurity of their genealogical origins. Hebrews thus deploys traditional sacrificial logic in new ways in order to establish legitimacy and inheritance on grounds other than birth and descent. Although the current scholarly consensus is that Hebrews is a Jewish text, I argue that this strategy would have been particularly useful for gentile Christians who had no recognizable ancestral claim to the inheritance of Abraham. Later Christian writers who draw on Hebrews use the figure of Melchizedek much more explicitly to legitimize gentile claims to the inheritance of Israel, and references to Melchizedek in rabbinic texts can also be interpreted as responding to this Christian strategy.
Examining the changing textual representations of the enigmatic priest Melchizedek allows us then to trace an ongoing debate among Jews and Christians about the importance of physical ancestry and descent in the legitimation of religious communities, and demonstrates that the malleable discursive association between sacrifice and kinship played a fundamental role in both Christian and Jewish discussions of sacrifice in late antiquity.
|
"Where Do I Live?" The Significance of New Testament Land / Earth Texts in the Palestinian-Israeli Conflict
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Michael Trainor, Australian Catholic University
Land is significant for those who live in the Palestinian Territories and Israel. It is also essential for those Christians who see the resettlement of Jews to the land which God promised as a precursor for the coming of the Messiah and their eventual welcoming of the Saviour. This paper enters into this discussion from a perspective of how the land can be understood in the New Testament. A study of some key New Testament ‘land’/’earth’ texts primarily from ecological and justice perspectives gleaned through the principles enunciated in the Earth-Bible Project offers a template for creative interreligious dialogue. This is especially pressing in the light of the current geo-political tension experienced by those living in Israel and the Palestinian Territories.
|
Early Christian Mysticism, Angelomorphic Identity, and the Shepherd of Hermas
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Franklin Trammell, Rice University
This paper argues that the Shepherd of Hermas transmits a tradition which is best understood within the context of early Jewish and Christian mysticism. Importantly, Hermas’ tradition can be shown to be directly traceable to the Jerusalem Church as its precedent is found in the sayings source Q. It therefore represents one of the oldest forms of Christianity that can be recovered. It is argued that the Shepherd of Hermas contains all of the distinctive features of early Christian mysticism while at the same time revealing its antiquity relative to other forms.
|
Crossing and Uncrossing the Jordan: Rivers as Liminal Space in Israel's Collective Memory
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Linzie M. Treadway, Vanderbilt University
Rivers play a symbolic role in the story of Israel’s formation as a people found within the Hebrew Bible. From the primeval period to the return from exile, Israel’s history and understanding of themselves as a people with shared identity and collective memory is tied to their interaction with rivers. The Hebrew authors tell Israel’s story in a way that not only involves rivers, but is actually constructed within, beyond, and across them. At each point of Israel’s progression into an integrated people, the community encounters a river, and this literary use of rivers shapes the very foundation of how Israelite literature tells the story of its beginnings and evolution into “Israel.” This is especially true for the Jordan, which demarcates the threshold between the idea of a promise and the fulfillment of covenant. The Jordan is “liminal space,” the threshold between two points of existence, with regard to both physical location and development in identity. Crossing the river actually transforms the Israelites--emotionally, spiritually, and culturally (even physically?)--into a new people. Ancillary texts also exhibit certain individuals appropriating and utilizing the symbolic power inherent in the Jordan, thus augmenting the idea that this symbolic understanding was widespread in Israelite cultural memory.
|
War and Peace in Canaan: Teaching Old Testament Geography and Politics through a Classroom Game
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Charlie Trimm, Talbot School of Theology (Biola University)
The sheer number of city and nation names in the Old Testament is overwhelming to the average student. Basic competency in these areas can be attained through frequent use of pictures and maps in classroom discussions, map exercises as homework exercises, and required memorization of important locales. As helpful as all these methods are, they leave the student with mainly a surface knowledge of the topic and how it relates to helping us understand why events happened as they did in the Old Testament.
One activity I have done to help the students “feel” how the geography of the land of Canaan affects politics is through a semester-long classroom game. The students are divided into six groups, and each group is assigned a city in Canaan/Syria, representing a small kingdom in the time when the empires were weak (approximately 1000-800 BCE).
After the groups write a paper on the history of their city, the game takes about ten minutes a week of in-class time. The beginning turns are very simple: each city has a certain number of trade points they can trade with each other (mutual trading and trading at a distance result in greater rewards). All discussion is completed via texting. Subsequent turns introduce more complexity, including the ability to attack and control colonies and eventually to directly attack other cities. The finale is a simulation of an attack by Assyria. Not only is the game a fun part of class that many student look forward to, it helps the students viscerally learn the connection between geography and politics, and events in the game usually roughly follow how events happened in Old Testament times. This paper will present the basics of the game and various ways to adapt it to the classroom.
|
Stealing the Gate: Another Reading of Samson’s Escapade in Judg 16:1–3
Program Unit: Joshua-Judges
Charlie Trimm, Biola University
The story of Samson stealing the gate from Gaza and carrying it to Hebron is a strange part of an already bizarre cycle of stories. This paper will argue that the story must be read from a martial perspective in light of the previous story about the Judeans. The narrator mocks the Gazans’ ability to defend their own city, as they apparently must be told that Samson is in their city and they are oblivious to Samson taking the gate that they are watching. In an ancient city, the weak point of the fortifications was always the gate. When Samson took the city from Gaza, he has effectively conquered the city, fitting in well with the violent conflict between Samson and the Philistines. However, his deposition of the gate in Hebron potentially expands the conflict. The Judeans had recently handed Samson over to the Philistines, and now Samson challenged them to join him in his campaign against the Philistines. With Gaza defenseless (as proved by the gate lying before them), Judah would be able to march to Gaza and overthrow their rulers. However, their lack of response indicates that it is not only Samson who is resisting the will of God, but also Judah. YHWH was to be the ruler of Israel (as Gideon recognized in Jdg 8:23), not the Philistines. However, the Judeans emphasize the rulership of Philistia over them when they refuse to help Samson (Jdg 15:11), rejecting YHWH’s desire that his people be free of their oppressors. This is further emphasized in the context of Judges as a whole, when the first chapter recounts that the Judeans had conquered Gaza (1:18). This strange story was included in the Samson story to show that it was not only Samson who was failing YHWH’s call, but to emphasize that it was also Judah and the rest of Israel, leading up to the extreme cases of failure in the final chapters of Judges. This interpretation might also have implications for the compositional history of Judges, as it provides further evidence for putting Judah in a negative light.
|
The Organization of the Fishing Industry in Documentary Papyri
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Facundo Daniel Troche, Alma Mater Studiorum Università di Bologna
Today, when we read a fishing story in ancient texts such as the gospels, we may tend to imagine an industry with the characteristics of the modern free-market. But in antiquity the right to fish on a given bank, marsh, or river was strictly controlled. The state, a temple, or a private owner leased fishing rights through contracts, and the lessees’ activities were supervised to ensure that the lessor received his or her due. Fishing supervisors (epiteretes) could form partnerships and sign a tax-farming contract with the holder of the rights, offering guarantees and securities. They kept records of the revenues and sent periodical reports to the authorities.
The fishing industry in the Roman Empire was a highly complex activity that created significant social tensions, and considerable profits for both tax farmers, and fishermen. Through an analysis of documentary papyri and ostraca, this paper will expose some aspects of the organization of the fishing industry in Egypt, will shed some light on the ways in which the state and the elites exercised their control over this activity, and will conclude by reflecting on some of the implications studying ancient fishing has for the study of the Jesus movement.
|
Open Doors: The Legacy of an Ending
Program Unit: Formation of Luke and Acts
Troy Troftgruben, Wartburg Theological Seminary
By most standards, the two most provocative endings in the New Testament are the original ending of Mark’s Gospel (16:1-8) and the ending of the Acts of the Apostles. That these two endings both feature such distinctive openness may be more than mere coincidence.
The use of Mark’s Gospel by the Third Evangelist suggests that Mark’s ending was, in fact, known to the author of Acts. These two endings, furthermore, share intriguing parallels that may imply a relationship of literary influence: distinctive openness, unfulfilled promises, and the role and work of witnesses. Even more, concluding theological emphases in each ending draw attention to how divine activity from throughout each narrative may continue beyond their respective endings. The two endings, finally, entail contrasting images of witness that feature both dissonance as well as resonance with each other. While I am not the first to notice a potential relationship between these two endings (the homiletician William Brosend suggests it in “Means of Absent Ends,” 1996), these and other features merit further exploration of the idea. The commonalities between the two endings imply that the provocative nature of Mark 16:1-8 may have constituted a legacy worth imitating by other ancient authors.
Writing about the ending to Mark’s Gospel, the late Donald Juel observed: “No point in a story is as significant for appreciation and interpretation as its ending. (“Disquieting Silence” 1994). The fact that his words characterize both the ending of Mark and the ending of Acts so well suggests an area worth further consideration.
|
Having Our Cake and Eating It Too: The Conflicted Interests of Readers in Ancient Narrative Endings
Program Unit: Ancient Fiction and Early Christian and Jewish Narrative
Troy M. Troftgruben, Wartburg Theological Seminary
Frank Kermode has famously observed that “narrative fictions” use closure to satisfy a pervasive human desire for meaningful order in a chaotic world (Sense of an Ending, 1967). With regard to ancient narratives and readers, Kermode’s idea is accurate in many respects, but it is actually only one side of the coin.
I wish to argue that the interests of ancient readers in closure seem to have been broader than Kermode’s generalizations would portray. The manuscript and reception histories of several prose fiction, epic, and New Testament writings, in fact, suggest contradictory readerly interests in closure. For instance, among ancient novels the lion’s share of known narratives offer resounding closure (e.g., Chariton’s Chaereas and Callirhoe), and yet some of the most popular novels display counterintuitive features of openness (e.g., Achilles Tatius’s Leucippe and Cleitophon). Similarly, while some epic narratives offer greater degrees of closure (e.g., Homer’s Odyssey), those with less seem to have been more widely read (e.g., Homer’s Iliad). Among New Testament writings, later writers frequently append additional marks of closure to several writings (e.g., Mark’s Gospel, Paul’s Letter to the Romans), but at the same time early reception history shows signs of distinctive appreciation for the endings that reflect openness (e.g., Mark’s Gospel, the Book of Acts). Thus, in interesting ways, the reception histories of several significant narratives reflect competing interests on the part of readers in both closure and openness. From the happy endings of certain novels, to the ending that “leaves the reader athirst for more” (John Chrysostom, on the end of Acts, Hom. Act. 55), I wish to argue that the interests of ancient readers seem to have been broader than simplistic generalizations assume . While reasons for these interests are a matter of speculation, the messiness of reception history reveals an intriguing contradiction in the minds of ancient readers: longing for one thing and yet attracted to the other, wishing to ‘have our cake and eat it too.’
|
The Annual Half-Shekel Contribution and the Connections between Diaspora Jewish Communities
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Jonathan Trotter, University of Notre Dame
During at least the last 150 years of the Second Temple Period, the practice of making annual half-shekel contributions to the Jerusalem temple is a well-established phenomenon among Jewish communities throughout the Diaspora from Babylon to Alexandria to Asia Minor to Rome. Perhaps initiated under the Hasmoneans near the end of the second century BCE, the eventual widespread popularity of this practice provides a good example of both the interconnectedness of Diaspora communities and the dissemination of information between these congregations. This paper will attempt to bring together some of the evidence, primarily from the writings of Philo and Josephus, of how the half-shekel contributions of Diaspora Jews and the associated pilgrimage practices would have provided one context within which Diaspora Jewish communities were enabled to maintain relatively regular contact and exchange with one another. Focusing on two specific examples, it will be suggested that significant interaction likely took place (1) in the initial collection of the funds, which at times were gathered at central regional depositories, and (2) within the convoys of pilgrims from the Diaspora to Jerusalem, which included envoys selected to carry offerings for the temple.
|
The New Testament Text of Didymus the Blind in Tourah Codex V: Pss 26:10–29:1
Program Unit: Papyrology and Early Christian Backgrounds
Michael R. Trotter, Brigham Young University
In 1941 a large cache of papyri preserving the writings of Origen and Didymus the Blind were discovered in Turah, Egypt. 43 years later 22 signatures from the Turah papryi containing Ps. 26:10–29:1 from Didymus the Blinds’ commentary on Psalms were acquired by Brigham Young University. These signatures remain unpublished at present. In an effort to assist in the publication of these papyri this paper seeks to examine Didymus’ use of the New Testament quotations found in this hitherto unpublished section and to build upon the foundation of the New Testament exegesis of Didymus established by Dr. Bart Ehrman and others. In addition to providing an inventory of all New Testament quotations and significant textual variants used by Didymus in this section of his commentary, I will also analyze how Didymus used the New Testament to support his interpretation of the Psalms. The New Testament quotations brought forward in this paper will shed greater light on the Alexandrian New Testament text that Didymus utilized as well as give us a clearer picture of Didymus as a New Testament exegete.
|
Commenting on the Book of Joel
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Ronald L. Troxel, University of Wisconsin-Madison
Sustained commentary on the Book of Joel appears first in the patristic era commentaries by Ephrem of Odessa (ca. 370), Theodore of Mopsuestia (ca. 380), Jerome (ca. 400), Cyril of Alexandria (ca. 425), and Theodoret (ca. 430). Most remarkable is Jerome's expansive exposition that vociferously disputes Jewish interpretations. Equally, his willingness to allegorize (a notable departure from Ephrem and Theodore) is striking by dint of the grounds he lays for it in Joel 1:2's distinction between its audience as the "elders" and the "inhabitants of the land." He considers the latter group restricted to a mundane, historical reading, while the former group is suited to hear "deeper meanings" in the text.
An intriguing counterpoint is offered by the medieval Jewish commentaries on Joel by Rashi (1040-1105), Ibn Ezra (1089-1164), David Kimchi (1165-1235), and Judah Abarbanel (1437-1508). All wrote in Hebrew, in Europe, setting aside homiletic midrash in favor of a linguistic and contextual approach adopted by Jewish scholars in the ninth to eleventh centuries from the analytic approaches to grammar, lexicography, and literature practiced by Islamic scholars. Although these commentators still cited interpretations preserved in the Talmud and Midrashim, their inquiries were driven more by linguistic and literary concerns, the very type of "mundane" reading that Jerome disparaged.
This paper will explore the roots of these different approaches to writing commentary and the ideological commitments that served as norms for these commentators.
|
Christians, Sabbateans, and the Dead Sea Sect: A Comparative Case Study in Jewish Sectarian Logic
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Jeffrey Trumbower, Saint Michael's College (Vermont)
This essay compares Christianity and Sabbateanism in their earliest manifestations. Like Jainism and Buddhism, they are two species that comprise a genus, that genus being Jewish messianic movements that spawned durable new religions. Of all the Jewish messiahs over the centuries, only two, Jesus of Nazareth (ca. 4 BCE – ca. 30 CE) and Sabbatai Tsvi (1626-1676), left a legacy of new religious communities that ultimately diverged from their Jewish roots to form a new religion. Analyzing how that process unfolded in each case raises intriguing questions and provides insights that might not arise from studying just one in isolation. A third Jewish movement of a similar nature, namely the ancient Dead Sea sect, will be added to the mix to illuminate aspects of Jewish sectarian logic across time and space, even though this movement did not spawn a new religion and was not focused on a messiah who had arrived.
|
It’s Affordable: The Cost of Civil Litigation in First-Century Roman Corinth
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Luke Tsai, Dallas Theological Seminary
It’s Affordable: The Cost of Civil Litigation in First-Century Roman Corinth
|
Translations of Difficult Hebrew Words: Evidence from Septuagint Jeremiah
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Miika Tucker, University of Helsinki
The Greek translation of Jeremiah has been described as a literal and isomorphic translation. These characterizations are usually derived from the translation's use of standard equivalents and quantitative equivalency, which are more or less an easy or mechanical means of translating. To identify a more creative aspect in such a translation, it is necessary to look at the renderings of Hebrew words or expressions that the translator did not understand or that were difficult for him to understand. This type of difficulty demands a more creative solution than just a simple standard equivalent. Guessing from the context or etymological renderings are two of the possible solutions to such problems. This paper examines several such cases in Greek Jeremiah in an attempt to further characterize the translation and to better understand the translator’s means of working.
|
The Burnt Child Loves the Fire
Program Unit: Psychology and Biblical Studies
Adam N. Tune, Catholic University of America
A Burnt Child Loves the Fire:
A Psychological Interpretation of Divine Deception
The idea of “divine deception” is present in both Isa 6:10-12 and 1 Kgs 22:19-23. In these texts, Yhwh induces a false belief in the minds of his people. Although scholarship has written on this topic and these passages many times, there has yet to be given a satisfactory answer as to why God would choose to involve himself with this kind of behavior. I attempt to give my own answer by employing a discipline that has not been used before with regards to this topic—human psychology.
My analysis will be presented in three stages. First, I will examine the vocabulary of the text in order to show that God does in fact deceive his people. I will then use the science of psychology to support the text’s claim. Second, I will provide examples of many scholarly opinions regarding these two specified texts and illustrate how writers have failed to address Yhwh’s behavior. I will again employ the discipline of human psychology to posit that the reluctance by scholars can be attributed to a certain “truth bias.” In my final section, I will use the research of those who have written on the psychology of deception to offer an answer to the question: “Why does God deceive?”
|
Reading Pauline Concept of Hyiothesia in Conversation with the Indonesian Concept of Pela Gandong
Program Unit: Asian and Asian-American Hermeneutics
Ekaputra Tupamahu, Vanderbilt University
The unique Pauline term hyiothesia, sonship, appears three times in the epistle of Romans (8:14-26 and 9:4-15), two other times in Gal. 4:5 and Eph. 1:5. It does not appear in either LXX or other Hellenistic Christian or Jewish literature. The feminine noun hyothesia is very likely a compound word of hyios (son) and thesis (position, situation). This paper will focus on the usage of this term in the epistle of Romans. The exact meaning of this word is debated among New Testament scholars. Is this word referring to the status/position of a son, or a process of positioning to be a son (adoption)? Some, like Eldon Epp, James Scott, and Douglas Moo, maintain that the idea of “adoption” is behind this noun. Others, like Brendan Byrne, think that this noun is not about the act of adoption, but the status of sonship. What I will try to do is to bring the Indonesian concept of pela gandong, a cultural notion of brotherhood/sisterhood (note that in Indonesian language there is no strict distinction between female and male noun) relationship among villages, to this conversation. The brotherhood/sisterhood interrelationship (pela gandong) has become a sort of cultural paradigm for an interreligious relationship especially in the province of Maluku. By putting hyiothesia and pela gandong in conversation, I will show that the concept of the children of God in Pauline theology, especially in Romans 8:14-26 and 9:4-15, does not become more exclusive after the coming of Christ. It is rather being broadened by Paul. Thus, Pauline concept of children of God is more embracing, rather than excluding. The advent of Christ and the justification of people through the life and death of Christ, for Paul, are not intended to create an elite group of people in the kingdom of God. It goes rather the other way around; it opens new doors for the inclusion of other people in the family of God.
|
Self-Reflexive Ontogenesis in Plotinus, Gnostic Sources, and the Chaldaean Oracles
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
John D. Turner, University of Nebraska - Lincoln
As part of a wider project to survey the various ways that Gnostic sources may have influenced certain distinctive features and images of Plotinus’ thinking, I would like to consider some ways in which the Valentinian Tripartite Tractate and perhaps even the Chaldaean Oracles may have been among these influential sources, despite their absence from the list of the mostly Sethian apocalypses named in Porphyry’s Life of Plotinus as circulating in Plotinus’ circle. While there are obvious points of contact between Plotinus and the Sethian treatises that circulated in his circle, such as the Being-Life-Mind triad and their common use of an auto-generational scheme of the spontaneous, non-deliberative procession from and contemplative reversion of a subordinate principle toward its prior principle, the Tripartite Tractate and the Chaldaean Oracles, from which these features are absent, also bear a number of significant similarities with Plotinus’ thought, particularly as developed in Ennead VI, 8 [39], “On free will and the will of the One,” whose importance has been either ignored or simply eclipsed by the fact it was written immediately after what is arguably Plotinus’ greatest work, Ennead VI, 7 [38], “How the multitude of the forms came into being and on the Good,” which largely corresponds with the view of the majority of his treatises, namely, that the making of the cosmos occurs neither in time nor by deliberative thought, but spontaneously and intelligibly in such way that a single enfolded totality of necessity becomes unfolded in time and space so that what is, in reality, all together can be experienced sequentially as a “this after this.” But Ennead VI, 8 turns this model inside out, by putting such anthropomorphic features as will and freedom before any spontaneous necessity or intellect in a way that strikingly resembles features of the Tripartite Tractate and even the Chaldaean Oracles and by giving daring expression to what elsewhere in his work appears to be the purest, apparently impersonal unity, the One, which here seems to appear virtually as a personal God. Here, the One makes itself, it is exactly what it wishes to be, loves itself, is ruler of and cause of itself, and having brought itself into being, exists by and for itself; in short, it is entire will. Besides the fact that in both Ennead VI, 8 and the Tripartite Tractate, ontogenesis occurs through directly willed self-reflexive activity, Ennead VI, 8 also shares some noticeably personalizing features with both the Tripartite Tractate and the Chaldaean Oracles in their common emphasis on the self-reflexive and even self-constitutive role of the divine will and love, which raises the question of the influence of these two sources at this unique point in the course of Plotinus’ thought.
|
The Temple Scroll as Prequel and Interquel
Program Unit: Qumran
Shani Tzoref, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
Borrowing terminology related to narrative sequence from contemporary media studies, this paper proposes that we re-think our understanding of the Temple Scroll as a “Re-make” of Deuteronomy, and to conceptualize it instead as a sort of “Interquel” or “Spin-off”.
This suggestion builds upon the analyses of Bernard Levinson and Hindy Najman concerning the literary paradigm of “Mosaic Discourse” in antiquity, and the more precise designation of the Temple Scroll as “Pseudo-God” (as per Moshe Bernstein; similarly, Michael Fishbane). As biblical scholars have long recognized, a reader of the Pentateuch would be hard-put to determine exactly what was revealed "at Sinai" besides the Decalogue (and even what is meant by “at Sinai”: where/when/how/by whom?). I suggest that the Temple Scroll can be seen as offering a resolution to that significant exegetical crux: it presents itself is the transcript of the Torah that was spoken to Moses at Sinai. It is thus a sort of prequel to Deuteronomy, similarly to the way in which James Kugel has described Jubilees ch. 23 with respect to Psalm 90: it presents itself as the “prior” text to which the chronologically later scriptural text is referring.
This proposal re-configures the question of whether and how the author of the Temple Scroll intended to replace or supplement the Pentateuch, and specifically the book of Deuteronomy. As in Cana Werman’s discussion of the “poetics” of the book of Jubilees, we would need to suppose some degree of cognitive dissonance on the part of the author, and to see the text as folding in upon itself in some degree. This should not be surprising, as the problem is inherent already in the book of Deuteronomy, for any reader that sees this book as both recapitulating the story of Sinaitic theophany and having itself been part of the content of the content of that theophany.
|
Prophet vs. Prophet: Prophecy in Question
Program Unit: Textual Criticism of the Historical Books
Frank Ueberschaer, Universität Zürich
Many texts within the Hebrew Bible contain prophetic content, and there are also many texts that investigate the phenomenon of prophecy itself. This paper deals with 1 Kings 13, which is one of the most puzzling texts in this context. It will argue that the story about the man of God from Judah, the sacrificing king and the old prophet from Israel is first and foremost a challenge to the phenomenon of prophecy as such, and only to a lesser extent a story about true and false prophecy.
This new approach to the text and its message is fundamentally based on a close consideration of the textual witnesses and the textual history of 1 Kings 13 as represented in MT, LXX, Peshitta and the Vulgate. Thus this paper will reveal the connection between textual criticism and textual interpretation and show how a detailed text-critical analysis forms the basis for a persuasive interpretation of the passage.
|
The Legitimating Function of the Sarah/Hagar Allegory in Gal 4:21–30: Insights from Social Identity Theory
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Bernard Ukwuegbu, Seat of Wisdom Seminary
Paul begins his Galatian Correspondence by railing against his opponents for insisting that the Galatians must become Jews in order to be Christians by accepting the obligations of the law (1-2:14). For Paul, such a demand stems from a feeling of Jewish ‘cultural superiority’ and an exaggerated emphasis on the privileges of the Jews with regard to access to salvation. Today, this is comparable to an approach to mission built on an inferior assessment of the cultural values of the ‘evangelized’ and to an ecclesiological model that emphasizes uniformity rather than appreciating the richness in diversity.
Against such a monolithic understanding of the Christian faith, Paul proposes a vision of different communities of those ‘in Christ’ living alongside each other and bound together by their common faith in what God has done in the risen Lord. Starting with an appeal to the common faith in Jesus Christ professed by members of the new community (Jews and Gentiles alike) as regards the means of salvation (2:15-21), Paul retells the story of God’s dealings with his people as grounded in the Abraham tradition (3:1-18). He highlights that it was because of his faith that God granted his promises of blessings and righteousness to Abraham and continues to grant same to those who believe after the manner of Abraham. While the Law has had a purpose, Paul insists that this has ceased with God’s immediate intervention in human history “in Christ” (3:19-25); and goes ahead to describe the characteristics of the community of those “in Christ” (3:26-29).
In continuation of his legitimating agenda, Paul in 4:1-30 sharpens the contrast between the status of his “in Christ” community and that of those championed by his opponents. This contrast begins with an example from everyday experience of maturation (4:1-2), continues with a theological application of this example in relation to the changing of the ages (4:3-7) and becomes finally earthed in a discussion of the Galatians’ own situation in relation to the eschatological era that has now come into effect (4: 8-11; 12-20).
For Paul’s legitimating project to be complete, however, he must reverse the terms of the constitutive biblical texts supposedly used by his opponents. He must contrast the Promise to Genealogy; and there is no story more inherently exclusionary than the text of Abraham, his two wives Sarah and Hagar, and their respective children, the one included and the other excluded (Gal 4:21-30). Reading this allegory with insights from the Social Identity Theory, this essay shows how Paul, by attributing to his “in Christ” community the free status of the child born of Sarah as opposed to the slave status of the child born of Hagar, infused them with a positive self-identity as against the negative identity he ascribed to the out-group.
|
Who Sacrifices? Christian Experts and the Redefinition of Religion
Program Unit: Social History of Formative Christianity and Judaism
Daniel Ullucci, Rhodes College
The rise of Christianity and the end of sacrifice in the ancient Mediterranean represents a radical shift in religious praxis and power. Attempts to account for this change have often employed overtly theological models in which sacrifice is ‘replaced’ by more ‘spiritual’ religion. This paper attempts to explain this shift in a wider context. The competitive success of Christianity in the fourth century is not the success of one religion (Christianity) over another (traditional Greek and Roman religions). Rather, the rise of Christianity represents a redefinition of what religion is (this could as be called a repackaging or rebranding). It is also a shift from one type of religious expert to another. This paper seeks to illuminate this shift by showing that the way Christian literate experts of the third and fourth centuries redefine sacrifice parallels the way they redefine the category religion itself. It posits that Christian positions on sacrifice must be understood as part of a competition to define what counts as religion. One part of this change is a shift from localized authority to universalizing authority. The paper proposes that current research in network theory can help us understand why the universalizing strategies of Christian experts were successful in bringing about a change in the definition of religion and sacrifice at a particular point in the history of the ancient Mediterranean.
|
In Honor and Dishonor: Differing Receptions of Paul’s Spectacle Metaphors in 2 Corinthians 4 and 6
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
James Unwin, Macquarie University
Modern scholarship has tended to read the peristasis catalogue in 2 Cor 6:3-10 as a re-emphasis of previous catalogues, attaching a similar irony to 6:3-10 that is present in the previous catalogues of the Corinthian correspondence. On this reading, Paul continues to challenge his critics, and their (more typical) conceptions of honour, by paradoxically commending himself as a d??????? (and his d?a????a) through recounting his hardships. However, in this paper, I will seek to stress the differences of 2 Cor 6:3-10 from its earlier counterparts, especially 4:8-9. These differences point to a shift in the tone and mood in the second half of the letter fragment (2 Cor 2:14-7:4) that is not often adequately emphasised. The emergence of contrasting spectacle images in these catalogues will confirm this shift. The appropriation of spectacle imagery by Seneca and Juvenal provide examples of elite representations of soldier/gladiators within discussions on honour and dishonour, and will offer a context for imagining the differing receptions of the spectacle metaphors adopted and adapted in both catalogues contained in 2 Cor 4 and 6. Having shifted the grounds for judging his appearance through the appropriation of shameful metaphors in the first part of the letter fragment, Paul adopts in the second half more honourable representations in an appeal for reconciliation with his critics.
|
Explicit and Implicit Religious Knowledge in the Study of Early Christianity
Program Unit: Redescribing Christian Origins
Risto Uro, University of Helsinki
Biblical scholars and historians of religion have usually built their critical analyses on literary documents, mostly written by religious experts or at least by those who belong to the educated elite. Literary documents, as it would seem, reflect what the cognitive scientists call explicit (or reflective) religious knowledge in contrast to implicit knowledge, the latter being largely unconscious and based on the intuitive (automatic) mechanisms of the human mind. During the last two decades, the cognitive science of religion has made a powerful case for the view that the analyses of explicit beliefs or interpretations of religious practices stored in the form of language (in texts, ethnographic reports, etc.) should be complemented with the growing body of knowledge about the psychological processes explaining religious phenomena. Many cognitive scientists of religion argue that the intuitive mental processes are much more important for understanding religion than the explicit interpretations of religious concepts and practices. On the other hand, a number of cognitive scientists challenge this view and claim that the dominant pattern of cognitive science has an “isolated mind” bias. This paper discusses the problem of how a biblical scholar can navigate through the different theoretical positions competing in the field of cognitive science. Three approaches to explicit and implicit religious knowledge are examined: 1) a dual-process model of religious thought, which emphasizes an interaction of reflective and intuitive mental processes in the production of religious concepts (Pyysiäinen, Tremlin); 2) implications of the cognitive challenge to cultural anthropology (Bloch); and 3) integrative (cultural evolutionary) approaches which claim that the cultural transmission of religious concepts are dependent on both intuitive cognitive biases and cultural learning biases (Henrich et al.). The relevance of these theoretical discussions to biblical studies is discussed with special reference to early Christian rituals.
|
The Money of the Kingdom: Economic Conflict and Social Relations in Halvor Moxnes' Better Gospel
Program Unit: Gender, Sexuality, and the Bible
Leif Vaage, University of Toronto
In this paper I take up Halvor Moxnes' interpretation of the Gospel of Luke regarding social conflict and economic relations in order to pose a narrower question, namely: How would an alternative economy actually be practiced? I will consider specifically the social problem of money, with a critique of the third evangelist's own seemingly double message: "You can't live with it, you can't live without it."
|
The Prevalence of Psalm 118 in the New Testament: A Canonical and Wirkungsgeschichtliche Explanation
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Ian J. Vaillancourt, University of Toronto
Psalm 118 is the most quoted psalm in the New Testament, with up to sixty relevant passages quoting from as many as eighteen verses of the psalm, depending on one’s view of allusions and echoes. Although the question of why this is the case has been broached by many, conclusions have often been tentative. Since the rise of higher critical methodologies, historical criticism and form criticism have focused on the question of origins in the Psalter, with no clear consensus with regard to Psalm 118. For example, Brunson reports twenty-six distinct theories about the cultic origin of the passage from a form-critical perspective! Although the present study does not want to discount the gains that other interpretive methodologies have made, it will explain the prevalence of Psalm 118 in the New Testament from an Old Testament perspective, using the canonical and Wirkungsgeschichtliche approaches. A look at the psalm in canonical perspective will show that the final redactors of the Psalter interpreted it eschatologically, as they looked forward to a future deliverance by a Davidic king. Further, a study of the Wirkungsgeschichte of the psalm will show that it was extensively quoted in Jewish literature in association with the Davidic king, and that it was recited annually at each of the major Jewish festivals. This not only brought it into an eschatological milieu, but also meant that it was in the minds of the common Jewish person leading up to the first century. Therefore, when the various New Testament authors sought to speak meaningfully about Jesus the Christ who fulfilled the Old Testament hope, they appealed to this well-known psalm that had come to be so associated with the eschatological Davidic king.
|
De Templo Ezechielis, et ejus interpretationi literali: A Commentary of Ezekiel by António Vieira, S.J.
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Ana Valdez, Yale University
In his magnum opus – 'Clavis prophetarum' – António Vieira, S.J. (1608-1697) analyses the Christian hope for the establishment of the divine kingdom on earth, while building and developing a particular interpretation of the concept of “Fifth Empire”. Aware that the time of the end could not happen before all the people on earth joined under God, Vieira undertakes in the 'Clavis' a detailed review of how and when that process would take place by commenting upon biblical passages and the work of famous exegetes. At the same time, Vieira shows particular concern with the Jews, a people he describes as the bearers of the ‘Old Alliance’ by opposition to Catholics, the people of the ‘New Alliance,’ and thus, already part of the People of God.
Vieira’s 'Clavis prophetarum' is an eschatological treatise, in which the author engages on a thoroughly exegesis of the most important authors and biblical passages concerning his topic. In what is today Book II of the 'Clavis,' Vieira writes four treatises that describe with care and precision the last things to take place before the end of time could happen. One of those treatises is 'De Templo Ezechielis, et ejus interpretationi literali' in which Vieira comments the description of the Temple made in Ezekiel. Vieira is mainly interested in analyzing the question of the ’sacrifices’, and in particular how God commanded the ancient sacrifices, similarly to how Christ commanded the Eucharist.
In this paper we will analyze Vieira’s commentary on Ezekiel in this treatise in the 'Clavis prophetarum,' and in particular the topic of the sacrifices. This theme is essential to understand how the Portuguese Jesuit placed the Jews in the broader context of salvation, and will allow us to question what ‘universal religion’ meant for Vieira, while being guided by the author through the opinion of some of the most important early modern commentators. By doing this, it will then be possible to obtain a more complete view of how Vieira divided mankind – Catholics, infidels, gentiles, and Jews – and on how such categories impacted his “Fifth Empire” scheme. Furthermore, it will be possible to discuss how such interpretation of the book of Ezekiel could have been read by Vieira’s confrères in Rome, for whom he wrote the 'Clavis prophetarum,' and how it could have underlined the polemical tone of this work.
|
New Arrivistes in the Context of Older Traditions: New Religious Movements and the Weaving of Christ Cult Groups into a New Religion
Program Unit: Redescribing Christian Origins
Gerhard van den Heever, University of South Africa
This paper explores the comparative-theoretical framework for theorising early Christian origins from a different angle. This paper argues that the study field of New Religious Movements (NRMs) constitutes a perfectly good comparative field of examples with which to imagine the formation of Christ cult tradition trajectories, also while the study of NRMs integrates all the investigative foci of other studies of Christian origins. New Religious Movements are so well documented for our contemporary times, and yet curiously little is made of the fact that there were NRMs in antiquity as well, indeed, that early Christianity itself appeared on the scene very much in a similar manner (or at least in a very comparable manner). It is my claim that such a study remains a desideratum.
New religious movements is a phenomenon associated with the influx of migrant, diaspora groups and so they appear in literature often as subsets or splinter group versions of other precendent identity formations and traditions. As such very few of NRMs are actually new, since most often they are religious new arrivistes from older religions with longer histories in their contexts of origin, and thus are new manifestations of older, “foreign,” traditions adapting shape and organisation, practices and discourses to communicate in a new environment. These processes of manifestation are contingent upon specific social, cultural, and political factors and often accompany big shifts in social discourse.
It is my purpose to show and argue that the life cycle of NRMs as young religions follows the same broad pattern as we can establish for the development trajectory of early Christianities: innovations wrought by a charismatic figure (like the apostle Paul, in the aftermath of his own charismatic experiences); a schismatic group or groups form that exist in tension with its “parent”, which tensions grow so serious as to lead to schism or breakaway (Paul’s inability to erect his cult groups in the bosom of the synagogue, so to speak, with simultaneously a difficult relation to the Graeco-Roman society his groups existed in); shifting shape as they attract adherents and grow; external forces threaten the initial tenuous stability (e.g., in Paul’s case other apostles, more traditional representatives of the “homeland tradition”); a mythological historiography is constructed and existing religious elements reused (which is why early Christian cult groups qua organisation, practices, and mythical narratives looked recognisably similar to both Jewish groups and pagan cults); the rapidity of the innovations introduced renders the nascent novel religion visible; and because NRMs appear initially as so novel and exotic they are seen as dangerous or evil cults (a topos in the first few centuries of pagan polemic against Christianity). Socially (in the mode of ritual, organisation, and even doctrines) NRMs look just like the older religions out of which they were crafted. In fact, from a certain perspective it might even be maintained that the NRM is the latest phase of the old religion, or at least one strand of it, a strand differently contextualised, deterritorialised, and reterritorialised.
|
"Somaticising Practices": Relocating Epiphany in the Making of Early Christianity
Program Unit: Greco-Roman Religions
Gerhard van den Heever, University of South Africa
The phrase “somaticising practices” intends to convey that those practices flowing out of and
in turn constructing discourse/s as the institutionalised ways of knowing the world, are not disembodied, abstract or coincidental functions. Practice, as body-in-action, and religious discourse are mutually constitutive. Instead, “somaticising practices” implies that discourse/s as ways of knowing the world are not only encapsulated in sets of linguistic representations but are also, and sometimes primarily – in all the senses of the term, mapped onto the body “as a map of the cosmos”, such that habitus (understood here as habituated, incorporated rule conformance) comes to manifest the way we know the world.
The early Imperial period saw tremendous changes in the religious and cultural landscape of the circum-Mediterranean, one aspect of which was the emergence of embodied religious discourses alongside, complementary to, and sometimes in opposition to cultic religiosity. One example of a new religious discourse formation was the appearance of Christ cult groups with their characteristic anti-cultic stance. By focussing on the example of the rhetoric of the Letter to the Colossians, it is argued that a prescribed authorised set of habituated practices constitute the epiphany of the divine. As such it constitutes a major shift in the religious imagination, but one also that demonstrates the formation of earliest Christianity as a religious discourse with its own broad identity-in-the-making.
|
The Challenge of Better Understanding Discourse Particles: The Case of Laken
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Christo H. J. van der Merwe, Universiteit van Stellenbosch - University of Stellenbosch
If we consider how laken has been treated by BH scholars and how it is sometimes translated, it is understandable why Bazzanella (2006:452) observes that when translating discourse particles “where ‘a substantial amount of inferencing over and above their decoding’ is required, there are two main risks – over- and under-determination.” The crux of the problem revolves around two questions: 1) Does laken has one core semantic value as, e.g. BDB (1909) and Jenni (2000) asserts, or more then meaning, as, e.g. HALOT (1999:532) implies. 2) If and how could the conventionalized pragmatic dimensions of a discourse particle be described and categorized?
Nemo (2006:375) states that discourse particles “since the late sixties has become the cradle of contemporary linguistic semantics, and in a unique window onto both the complexity of language construction and interpretation and the understanding of what meaning is about.” It is therefore hypothesized in this study that the wealth of modern linguistic studies of discourse particles and markers provides the key to answer the two questions that have been raised above. Although we focus in this study on laken, the ultimate goal is to lay a foundation that could be used in the analysis and description of the other discourse particles in Biblical Hebrew.
For these purpose our paper is organized as follows: We commence with postulating our view of language and human communication as well as our view of discourse markers as we have learned from, for example, Fischer (2006). Secondly, we postulate a model of how discourse particles that occur in written texts work and how the different meanings they appear to have, needs to be understood. In the light of this model, a possible procedure for analyzing discourse particles is formulated as a working-hypothesis. This working-hypothesis is then used to describe laken.
|
"Don’t Waste Old Filing Cards!" Plutarch’s Technique of Hypomnematic Composition
Program Unit: Corpus Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Luc Van der Stockt, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
After some preliminary remarks on “classical hermeneutics, intertextuality, and the philological method,” I interpret Plutarch’s "hypomnemata-statement" in De tranquillitate animi 464E: “From the notes I took on my own behalf, I picked up and gathered what is relevant for the theme of tranquillity of mind.” I will illustrate how "clusters of parallels" can put us on the track of those notes. As personal meditations, they were Plutarch’s own construction and, so to speak, the quasi literary deposit of his own train of thought. The interpretation succeeds in explaining the many instances of repetition in Plutarch’s immense œuvre (imitatio sui), and in explaining how Plutarch recycles the (literary and philosophical) tradition (Quellen) in his construction of personal philosophical and religious themes through the use of his hypomnemata. This hypomnematic technique of composition may offer New Testament scholars a new perspective on the creative ways of using traditional material in the late 1st cent. AD. As an illustration I will briefly present the hypomnema on “music as a way to the divine” (De superstitione, § 5=Quaest. Conv. IX, 14=Suav. viv. Epic., § 13-14).
|
Assyrian Tales at Elephantine
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Karel van der Toorn, Universiteit van Amsterdam
The Aramaic Judeans of Elephantine are better known for their archives than for their library. But among the texts discovered on the island is one substantial piece of literature and the Aramaic version of a historical inscription. The one is the Story and Sayings of Ahiqar (TAD C1.1), the other the Behistun (Bisotun) Inscription by Darius I, King of Persia (TAD C2.1). The fragments of the Tale of Hor son of Punesh (TAD C1.2) are too mutilated to reconstruct an intelligible version of the story.
When in the early 1980s transliterations and translations of the Amherst Papyrus no. 63 became available, it took not long before scholars drew the conclusion that it was a collection of liturgical and literary texts from a community closely related to the Arameans from Syene and the Judeans from Elephantine. An Aramaic version of Psalm 20 provides a link with the Hebrew Bible. The most substantial literary text of pAmherst 63, however, is the Tale of Two Brothers dealing with the conflict between Sarmuge (Shamashshumukin) and Sarbanabal (Assurbanipal) (pAmherst, XVII 5-XXII 9). On account of the long relations between the Syenian Arameans and the Elephantine colony (witness the presence of Ps 20 in pAmh 63), it may be assumed that the Judeans on the island were familiar with the Sarbanabal story.
The paper probes the Assyrian background of the texts and traces their literary lineage.
|
Psalm 20 and the Amherst Papyrus: A Documented Case Study of a Text in Transit
Program Unit: Hebrew Scriptures and Cognate Literature
Karel Van der Toorn, Universiteit van Amsterdam
The greatest handicap for biblical scholars studying the phenomenon of textual revision is the fact that they work with a textus receptus, the earlier stages of which have not been preserved. Mostly owing to material circumstances, there are no cases of ancient Hebrew literature that parallel the Gilgamesh Epic, for which Assyriologists can compare the Old Babylonian, the Middle Babylonian, and the Neo-Assyrian versions, without forgetting the Sumerian antecedents. There are two types of exception to this rule. The one is the case of inner-biblical revision where the one text is more or less clearly based on another, earlier one. Bernard Levinson has discussed various examples from the legal materials of the Bible. The second case occurs where by good fortune we possess one text in two different stages of transmission. The difference between the Masoretic text of Jeremiah and the one from the Septuagint/Qumran offers a fine example. The case of textual revision I would like to present falls in the second category but is also more complex. When transliterations and translations of parts of pAmherst 63 became available in the early 1980s, one of the great discoveries was the existence of an Aramaic text closely resembling Psalm 20. Opinion was divided as to the chronological priority of the one or the other text. There is a difference in language (Hebrew v. Aramaic); in theology (different gods); and possibly in the form of transmission. Since the Amherst papyrus is written in Demotic characters it apparently represents a transcript by an Egyptian scribe of an oral transmission by a speaker of Aramaic. But there can be no doubt about the connection between the Hebrew and the Aramaic psalm. I will suggest a likely setting and background of the Amherst version of Psalm 20, discuss chronological order, and illustrate some of the forms and techniques of revision on the basis of a comparison of the two texts.
|
“The Most Important Thing Is for Us to Be Together”: Interrogating Just Cause Notions of Retribution and Revenge as a Result of the Pains Inflicted Due to Rape—Using Biblical Narratives as Reflection
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Charlene van der Walt, Universiteit van Stellenbosch - University of Stellenbosch
In the global arena, South Africa has the highest statistics for sexual violence for a country not at war. It is estimated that one in nine women who are raped in South Africa go on to report the incident to the police. Of these only 4% are successfully prosecuted and less than half of 1% of perpetrators will serve any jail-time. The rape survivor is often acquainted with the perpetrator as the crime is frequently committed by a relative, family member or friend. Entire households, families and communities are affected by these intimate crimes. In order to critically reflect on the communal consequences of rape and sexual violence within a community the story of the Rape of Tamar as found in 2 Samuel 13:1-22 serves as the basis for a contextual Bible reading exercise within diverse faith communities in South Africa. The Biblical text hereby becomes a reflective surface that helps faith communities to engage with ideologies of male dominance and the rampant culture of violence that is prevalent in South Africa. The aim of the paper is to Interrogate just cause notions of retribution and revenge as a result of the pains inflicted due to rape that often becomes apparent in the response of contemporary South African readers to the trauma suffered by Tamar in the Biblical narrative. Without negating the unspeakable pain inflicted on the survivors of sexual violence the paper speaks hope in longing for creative communal spaces where the restoration of human dignity for perpetrators and victims become possible.
|
Isaiah 11:6–8 as Hyperbolic Blessing
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Joshua J. Van Ee, Westminster Seminary California
The present examination of Isa 11:6-8 is part of a larger work on creational imagery concerning animals in the Bible and ANE. Isaiah 11:6-8 has had a significant influence on the interpretation of Gen 1:28-30. Many commentators, especially those dealing with Genesis, reason that the image of animals and humans at peace in Isa 11:6-8 originates in creation descriptions and thus makes explicit what is implicit in Gen 1:28-30. Nevertheless, there is no consensus on the interpretation of Isa 11:6-8 or the source of its imagery. Instead commentators offer a wide variety of possible understandings - realistic, metaphoric, allegorical, or hyperbolic - and a number of origins for the description.
A close reading of Isa 11:6-8 in its larger context of verses 1-9 will question any creation ties. The focus of the imagery is not on a restored creation but the absence of divinely implemented curses. It is a portrayal of blessedness through the removal of the curse of devouring animals. However, in distinction from similar blessings elsewhere in the Hebrew Bible, the animals themselves are not removed. Instead, in a unique hyperbolic turn, the animals formerly feared by humans are described as domesticated, providing a poignant image of safety and security.
|
Metaphors of Illness and Fear
Program Unit: Metaphor in the Bible and Cognate Literature
Pierre Van Hecke, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
In Job 3:25, the protagonist of the book exclaims that what he feared most has befallen him, referring to his present state of affliction, including his illness. In this presentation, the relation between fear and illness and in particular the similarities and differences in their metaphorical description throughout the Hebrew Bible will be analyzed and systematically presented.
|
Characterization in Josephus
Program Unit: Josephus
Jan Willem van Henten, Universiteit van Amsterdam
In general terms, the Jewish historian Josephus, working in Rome in the first century CE and supported by the Flavian dynasty, attempts to inculcate what he sees as the correct interpretation of the devastating conflict between Rome and the Jews (66-73/4 CE) as well as a fair view of the Jewish people and its way of life, beneficial to Jews and non-Jews alike: living in line with Jewish customs would result in a morally good life and the proper attitude (eusebeia) towards the God of Israel, who in turn would reward it by happiness. This mission is reflected in all four of Josephus' works in the ways in which persons are characterized, in particular Jewish and non-Jewish leaders. The analysis of characterization in this paper is set up around four leading questions: (1) Who characterizes, i.e., the narrator, or speaking and focalizing characters? (2) How are persons characterized, i.e., direct and indirect characterization? (3) What is the focus of characterization, i.e., virtues, deeds, etcetera? (4) To what effect, what is the result of Josephus’ characterizations for his narratees?
|
Second Maccabees as Literature: The Perspective of Time
Program Unit: Pseudepigrapha
Jan W. van Henten, Universiteit van Amsterdam
This paper will focus on the “how” instead of the “what”, i.e., the way the story of the liberation of the Jewish state is told in 2 Maccabees from a narratological perspective. Recently a tool has become available that is also relevant for scholars focusing on ancient Jewish narratives: the Studies in Ancient Greek Narrative series (Leiden: Brill, 2004 and later; main editor Irene J.F. de Jong). Follow the lead of this series I will analyze time as a narrative tool, taking the entire narrative of 2 Maccabees as a coherent unity and identifying the narrator with the compiler of this unity. I will focus on the awareness of time in the narrative (including time markers), on the order (prolepsis and analepsis), on the rhythm of the narrative (acceleration, slowing down) as well as on the frequency of the events told (repetition, summary, ellipsis). I will give a survey of the various usages of time in 2 Maccabees and highlight some of the relevant passages.
|
The Explicit Anti-Pagan Polemics of 1 John
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
George van Kooten, Groningen University
The apparently sudden and unexpected invective against “the idols” at the very end of 1 John (5.18-21), which scholars have generally found rather puzzling, makes sense when attention is paid to the occurrence in this letter of the notion of being begotten from God. This notion seems to root in Greek mythology where it is applied to the generation and birth of the many gods engendered by Zeus, such as Athena and Hermes - a view which is then also adapted and applied to (particular) human beings. The author of 1 John applies this notion both in his Christology and anthropology, just as the author of the Gospel did. It seems that this mythological terminology was very suitable to describe the relation of the only-begotten Son to his Father, and his epiphany in this world, and did indeed appeal to pagans, the only undesirable effect being that in Greek mythology the epiphany of gods on earth did not necessarily imply their enduring incarnation. It is over this side-effect of Greek mythology that controversy arose in the Johannine community between the incarnationalists and those pagan converts who thought true incarnation as irrelevant, leading the incarnationalists, as both 1 John and 2 John attest, to raise the incarnation to the level of explicit confession (1 John 4.2-3 and 5.6). It is argued that what had remained only an implicit competition between Christ and the pagan gods in John’s Gospel, in the mode of a kind of quiet supersessionalism of the pagan gods, now becomes an explicit polemic which highlights the differences between Christ and the pagan gods by characterising the latter as idols, contrasting them with the true God and those begotten from him, and by warning against them in the very last words of the letter: “Little children, keep yourselves from the idols”.
|
The Rhetorical Function of Hezekiah’s Poem Isa 38:10–20
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Archibald van Wieringen, Tilburg School of Catholic Theology
Isa 38:10-20 is a poetic text within the narrative context of the chapters 36-38. Firstly, I wish to deal with the poetic structure of this poem. How are the actors and the reader shaped by the poetic features of the text? Secondly, I wish to examine the relation between the poetic text of Hezekiah’s writing and the narrative context. What is the interaction between the poetic features of Isa 38:10-20 and the narrative context of the chapters 36-38 both regarding the actors and the reader?
|
The Surplus of a Combination of Cognitive Linguistic Approaches to Grammar and Meaning
Program Unit: Cognitive Linguistics in Biblical Interpretation
Ellen van Wolde, Radboud Universiteit Nijmegen
The separation of grammar and semantics, a prominent feature of classical linguistics, is considered incorrect and counterproductive in cognitive linguistics. In this paper I intend to show the value of the combination of cognitive construction grammar (Stefanowitz and Gries) and cognitive grammar (Langacker) for explaining grammar and meaning in Biblical Hebrew. The former (construction grammar) offers a model for the analysis of grammatical and lexicographical collocations and collostructions, the latter (cognitive grammar) a model for the analysis for meaning compositions that stand out in encyclopaedic frameworks. The combination of the two enables us to explain the niph'al constuction of fientive verbs as expressing middle voice (cf Kemmer, Jenni) used in HB texts to express actions performed by one and the same subject (the super- and subsubject), and not by an external subject (as in passive voice). In this paper I will focus on the niph'al of the verb bara' and demonstrate that this grammatical construction does not express a passive voice and that God is not the external subject of the action, with great consequences for the understanding of the meaning of this verb's usages in the Hebrew Bible.
|
Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, A Reader's Edition
Program Unit:
Donald Vance, Independent Scholar
*
|
Carl Theodor Dreyer’s 'Blade af Satans bog' (1921) and Unrealized 'Jesus of Nazareth' (1950)
Program Unit: Bible and Film
Caroline Vander Stichele, Universiteit van Amsterdam
This paper offers a comparative analysis of two works from the Danish filmmaker Carl Theodor Dreyer (1889-1968): the first episode of Dreyer’s silent film 'Leaves from Satan Book' (Blade af Satans bog, 1921) about the betrayal and arrest of Jesus and the corresponding scenes in the script of his unrealized film 'Jesus of Nazareth' (1950). The paper focuses on the representation of Jesus and Judas in those scenes and situates them in the larger context of each work as well as in the larger context of Dreyer’s work as a whole.
|
Cult, Divination, and Prophecy in Psalm 77 and the Book of Habakkuk
Program Unit: Israelite Religion in Its Ancient Context
David Vanderhooft, Boston College
The permeable boundaries between cultic practice, mantic divination, and prophecy have long preoccupied students of the religions of ancient Western Asia. Within ancient Judah, these overlapping spheres do not separate neatly according to genres. Thus, Psalm 77 and the prophetic Book of Habakkuk share a rather impressive range of lexical and thematic links connected to these spheres. Scholars have noticed these links in the past, yet an explanation of how to understand their significance—not just which text is dependent on the other—remains elusive. Was the prophet drawing on well-known cult liturgical traditions or texts? Or did the psalmist follow an interpretive and rhetorical template already adumbrated within the ambit of prophecy? Or do the two texts show clear affinities because of their familiarity with a common, and relatively old, strategy for interpreting the relationship between calamity and cosmogony? Both texts, I will argue, presume that divinatory inquiries could be made within cultic contexts, and that their surprisingly similar poetic conclusions about Israel's Divine Warrior function, effectively, as responses to divination.
|
When Is a Text Not a Text? Early Gospels as Material Culture
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Erin K. Vearncombe, University of Toronto
A woman, banished to a brothel, is saved from assault because she wears a gospel on her chest. A man is prevented from an immoral lifestyle because he wears a gospel under his clothes; a prostitute demands he not touch or approach her, seeing in him “a great mystery.” A scroll inside of an amulet quotes the first line of each canonical gospel and several psalms in a text that, read line by line, makes no literal or “literary” sense. Gospel texts, in these and other instances, are not texts at all, but objects: objects with prophylactic, apotropaic or saving power. This paper challenges the issue of textuality in gospel research, applying recent methodological work in materiality and material culture to fascinating interactions with the gospels as physical objects. In cases where text is not a vehicle for knowledge or influence, attention to materiality highlights the significance of text as object in ancient approaches to “the gospel.”
|
A New Command: Philo as Lawgiver and Interpreter in the Case of the Egyptian Blasphemer
Program Unit: Philo of Alexandria
Horacio Vela, University of Notre Dame
Many studies of Philo have shed light on his portrayal of the Mosaic law as the divinely ordained law of nature. Yet like other ancient Jewish authors, Philo is a witness to other views which attribute the law to Moses himself rather than divine origins. In Mos. 1.1, Philo notes that some regard Moses as a legislator while others deem him a mere interpreter of the laws. Furthermore, in Hypoth. 8.6.9 Philo argues that whether Moses crafted them on his own or was guided by a daemon, the laws were nevertheless worthy of praise. In this paper I would like to examine the peculiar case of the Egyptian blasphemer (Mos. 2.192-208). Philo argues that Moses offers a new command in light of a new situation (cf. Mk. 10:5) through the guidance of God. Philo’s wrestling with this biblical scene and his rationalization of the law against blasphemy reveals the diverse portraits of the law and Moses which he has inherited. The tensions and ambiguities in these traditions allow Philo to serve as both lawgiver and interpreter of piety both for his Jewish community and for the Greco-Roman world.
|
Is There a Place in the Inn? Some Reflections on How to Take Care of Q
Program Unit: Q
Joseph Verheyden, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
The paper wishes to address two issues. First, I will briefly revisit some earlier attempts at giving Q a place in the earliest develoment of Christian theology. Then it will explore some of the (perceived) difficulties scholars have had with Q, dealign more specifically with three categories: the status of Q, the things it says,the things it does not say.
|
Reading the Bible in the Company of an Uncomfortable Guide: Musings in the Margins of Some Essays of Franco Moretti
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical, Early Jewish, and Christian Studies
Joseph Verheyden, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
This paper will explore some possible ways for applying certain topics in comparative literature and literary history addressed by the Italian literary scholar and (neo-)Marxist critic Franco Moretti to interpret biblical texts and writings. Such topics that will be dealt with are that of fear, moving literature, contrastive characters (all from his older works) and the concept of distant reading (in works of a more recent date). It will be argued that these theoretical reflections, which Moretti studied and illustrated from the (primarily: modern) novel and the short story, can be made to use also in discussing biblical stories and writings in ways that may enrich or add to more commonly used exegetical approaches and may help to diversify or broaden certain perspectives.
|
Hands, Heads, and Feet: Body Parts as Poetic Device in Judges 4–5
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Karolien Vermeulen, University of Antwerp
The story of Yael and Sisera abounds in the use of body parts, both in its prosaic and poetic version. Previous studies have paid attention to the possibly metaphorical role of certain body parts in Judges 4-5, functioning as images of power (Assis 2005) or sexual euphemisms (Fewell & Gunn 1990, Reis 2005). This paper proposes a different view, arguing that the hands, heads and feet form a poetic device an sich. This device is characterized by its willful exploitation of space: bodily space (with oppositions such as up-down and left-right), interpersonal space (connecting different characters) and literal space occupied by words in verses and phrases (with the opposition first-last). The paper will address each of these types of space and illustrate them with examples from Judges 4-5. In addition to these characteristics, attention will be paid to the effect of the device. A comparison between the prosaic and poetic account of the story will show that the use of body parts, like other poetic devices, generates different effects, thus creating different reading experiences. Moreover, although the feature is present in both versions, it is in the poetic section that it is used to its full extent. There the spatial characteristics of the feature are played out on each level, maximizing its effect and adding to the overall poetic character of the passage.
|
The Asklepieion Becomes a Healing Locus Sanctus
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Gary Vikan, Gary Vikan Consulting, LLC
Healing is healing, to a Christian of the 5th century as to a polytheist of a century earlier. Doctors were fine, up to a point, but often divine intervention was required. The intent of this paper is to compare and contrast, from the supplicants' point of view, the healing rituals and associated material culture of the late ancient Asklepieion and the early Christian healing Locus Sanctus. The ingredients include pilgrimage, incubation, dream-inducement and dreams, divinely empower healing media (e.g., dirt), cult images, and votives - and, of course, healing miracles. There are elegant points of continuity on the spot, as on the south slope of the Acropolis, where after more than eight centuries of supernatural healing, an Asklepieion is destroyed only to be reborn a few decades later in the service of the healing holy twins, Kosmas and Damianos; the snakes are gone but the healing spring remains as does the stoa for incubation. But more often, holy places emerged anew on the Christian landscape, thanks to miracle-working holy men and women, either living or dead, though the reality on site seems to have remained remarkably similar - and not so different from what happens at Chimayo and Lourdes nowadays.
|
Holy Hunters in Early Medieval Syriac Monastic Texts
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Cynthia Villagomez, Winston-Salem State University
The sacralization of landscapes and societies in early medieval Syriac monastic texts often involves cases of monastic saints and their animal companions initiating the hunting of dangerous wild animals and evil people. This paper will present case examples of holy human and animal hunters with a special focus on the imagery of the aristocratic hunt. I argue that the Syrian holy men and their animal companions are presented as successful hunters who achieve miraculous success in their divinely-inspired hunts, which pave the way to the conversion of unbelievers and serve as a marker for the establishment of peaceful, sacred abodes.
|
Positive Portrayals of Persian and East Syrian Christians in the Ethiopian Synaxarium and the Law of Kings
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Cynthia Villagomez, Winston-Salem State University
The Ethiopiac Synaxarium and The Law of the Kings demonstrate a strong interest in and affinity with martyrs and monastic saints in the Church of the East. These late medieval texts were initially translated from Arabic into Ethiopic about a century prior to the translations of the ascetical treatises of St. Isaac of Nineveh and John Saba.
This paper focuses on positive perceptions of saints of the Church of the East in the Ethiopic Synaxarium and The Law of the Kings by looking at the Ethiopic receptivity for East Syrian monastic and hagiographical traditions. Furthermore, the apologetic acceptance of these traditions involving saints who do not follow Miaphysite theology is examined in terms of the proximity of the Church of the East communities to members of the Syrian Orthodox Church.
|
The Valentinian Dynamic of Holiness: New Perceptions of the ‘Spiritual’, ‘Psychic’, and ‘Material’ Bodies
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Eunice Villaneda, California State University - Long Beach
The misclassification of the Valentinians as a gnostic sect led to the perception of their interchangeability with other ancient Christian sects. This research presents the Valentinian dynamic of holiness which reveals the existence of five states in Valentinian bodies. This dynamic overturns the notion that Valentinians were hostile toward their bodies.
Jacob Milgrom’s dynamic of holiness in Leviticus lead to the belief that persons and objects are subject to four states: holy, common, pure, and impure. Pure things can be holy or common and common things can be pure or impure. The holy however, cannot come into contact with the impure. Holiness and impurity are “mutually antagonistic” and they seek to extend their influence and control the other two categories: the common and the pure.
My Valentinian dynamic includes five states: the holy, common, unholy, pure and impure. This is reflected in the Valentinian ‘spiritual’, ‘psychic’, and ‘material’ bodies. The ‘spiritual’ body is holy and pure, the ‘psychic’ body is common and unstable, and the ‘material’ body is unholy and impure. This dynamic provides an understanding of the degrees of holiness in Valentinian bodies and demonstrates that the ‘spiritual’ and the ‘material’ are two opposite components that cannot come into contact. The ‘psychic’ body chooses to unite itself with the ‘spiritual’ or ‘material’ body, thus adopting its pure or impure state.
Tracing the boundary shifts within this dynamic reveals the separation of the holy ‘spiritual’ from the common and unholy. Valentinians, believed in a co-existing between the ‘spiritual’, ‘psychic’, and ‘material’ bodies with the intent of the eventual annihilation of the ‘material’ world which is accomplished through the acquisition of knowledge. This dynamic demonstrates Valentinian perceptions of the bodies and the ‘material’ world and their ever-shifting boundaries that reveal their ultimate reality.
|
White Lies and Diplokardia: Early Christian Literature and the Limits of Hypocrisy
Program Unit: Ethics and Biblical Interpretation
Richard B. Vinson, Salem College
In the New Testament and early Christian literature, “hypocrisy” in its various forms and its cognates are consistently condemned but rarely defined or illustrated: “hate all hypocrisy and everything unpleasing to the Lord” (Did 4:12; Barn 19:2) exemplifies how broad the term can be. The paper’s first task is to describe the term’s range of meaning, focusing on texts using it in ways that are more than simply mud-slinging. Next, the paper will test and attempt to refine the range of meaning by using characters in narratives as examples of what hypocrisy does or does not look like in the minds of early Christians. Finally, the paper will reflect on how this material might be useful for ethical discourse, especially if (as Kurzban argues) hypocrisy is inevitable, given a non-unified, modular mind.
|
Reenchanting the Qur'an: Hermeneutical Applications of the Ash'ari Concept of God's Eternal Speech
Program Unit: Qur’anic Studies: Methodology and Hermeneutics (IQSA)
David R. Vishanoff, University of Oklahoma
One prominent movement in modern Qur'anic hermeneutics has been to disenchant and historicize the Qur'an so that it can be subjected to the same kinds of critical, historical, and literary readings as other texts. Even among historical and literary critics, however, the idea of an eternal and heavenly Qur'an persists. For some, acknowledging a transcendent dimension to God's speech serves to deflect traditionalist criticism but has little impact on interpre tation. Nasr Hamid Abu Zayd and Abdullah Saeed, for example, both affirm the "orthodox" notion of a suprahistorical Qur'an, but regard it as unknowable and thus hermeneutically irrelevant. For others, however, the distinction between a heavenly and an earthly Qur'an enables crucial hermeneutical moves. Already in the fourth/tenth century the theologian Abu Bakr al Baqillani employed the Ash?ari distinction between God's eternal speech and its temporal expression in Arabic to open up a hermeneutical space within which a flexible process of interpretive reasoning could take place. A similar distinction between a suprahistorical Qur'an and a historical Umm al-Kitab was advanced by the modern Syrian Mu?ammad Sha'rur, but he used this distinction for a somewhat different purpose: it allowed him to classify Qur'anic teachings that fit his own modern liberal values as eternal and objective while declaring other parts of the Qur'an to be subject to historically contingent human reas oning. More recently a young Indonesian scholar, Aksin Wijaya, has revived Mohammed Arkoun's distinction between revelation, the Qur'an, and the ?Uthmanic codex in order to differentiate between the essence of the Prophet's message, which is eternal and independent of historical context, and the linguistic and cultural baggage that make up 50 and 70 percent, respectively, of the oral Arabic Qur'an and the written Arabic text. This allows him to argue for the hermeneutical neutralization of what he and many other Indonesians regard as foreign and specifically Arab cultural values expressed in the Qur'an. Some earlier scholarship on modern Qur'anic hermeneutics has argued that the Mu?tazili doctrine of the created Qur'an is, potentially, a key to modern and postmodern historicizing interpretation. The examples presented in this essay demonstrate, however, that the Ash'ari distinction between God's eternal speech and its historical expression in the words of the Qur'an has also found a new lease on life in the service of equally revisionist and historicizing hermeneutical approaches to the Qur'an.
|
Rivals, Opponents, and Enemies: Three Kinds of Theological Argumentation in Philippians
Program Unit: Polis and Ekklesia: Investigations of Urban Christianity
Samuel Vollenweider, Universität Zürich
This paper deals with the question of the boundaries that Paul is drawing in Philippians. Apart from the identification of different kinds of "opponents," what deserves attention is the manner in which Paul is arguing with regard to these boundaries. It will be argued that in Philippians at least three kinds of "opponents" have to be taken into consideration, and that Paul is shaping his arguments quite specifically with regard to each borderline.
|
Beyond Expectation (2 Cor 8:5): The Macedonians’ Generosity in light of Paul’s Rhetorical Strategy
Program Unit: Second Corinthians: Pauline Theology in the Making
Thomas A. Vollmer, Cincinnati Christian University
This paper investigates the manner in which Paul builds the reputation of the Macedonians as a motivating factor to enlist the Corinthians to support the collection for the Jerusalem church. Paul focuses attention on the extreme nature of the Macedonians’ poverty all the while pointing out that in spite of their poverty they gave beyond his expectation. Generally speaking, this passage is understood as the way in which Paul encourages the Corinthian church to participate in the collection, but that approach leaves open the question of how the Macedonians fit into his rhetorical strategy. By appealing to Gary Fine’s work on reputation building and reputational entrepreneurship, I am going to show how Paul appeals to reputations in order to convince his target audience to partner with him. I propose that Paul acted as a “reputation entrepreneur” in 8:1-5 in how he presents the Macedonians' extreme poverty in contrast to the wealth of their generosity. His argument reaches its climax with the statement that the Macedonians’ giving was beyond his expectation, for it included both financial giving and the giving of themselves. The zenith of Paul’s reputation building occurs in 8:9 where Jesus Christ becomes the quintessential example of true giving. Paul rhetorically constructs an argument based on the reputations of others to substantiate his request for the Corinthians to give both financially and of themselves in similar fashion.
|
Temple Children: Children, Sex, and the Rhetoric of Sacred Space
Program Unit: Gender, Sexuality, and the Bible
Robert von Thaden, Jr., Mercyhurst University
Children, actual and metaphorical, are used in arguments regarding the proper sexual use of the body in both 1 Corinthians and the apocryphal Acts of Thomas along with the metaphor of THE BODY (corporate and individual) IS A TEMPLE. Since the Acts of Thomas reconfigures arguments found in 1 Corinthians a similar rhetorical strategy in each should not come as any great surprise. In each text the reader/hearer is invited to understand proper sexual comportment through the rhetorical construction of the body as sacred space and the conceptual characters of children are deployed to solidify the arguments. Using the tools of conceptual blending theory I show how the fertile images of temples and children can serve to bolster sexual ideologies at odds with one another.
In 1 Corinthians 6:19, Paul uses the metaphor THE BODY IS A TEMPLE at the end of an argument that aims to show the Corinthians why porneia is the worst of all bodily sins (6:12-20). In 7:2 Paul shifts gears and begins to explain to the audience what sexual behavior is permitted. In 7:12-16 Paul argues that Christ believers ought to stay married to their unbelieving spouses. This, however, flies in the face of the logic of the sanctified body Paul's argument in 6:12-20 creates. In order to cement his case against divorce, and explain how the scenario in this instance is different from the sin of porneia, Paul resorts to the Christ community's evaluation of the holiness of the children of such unions: far from being unclean, they are holy. This rhetorical move deploys actual children in order to encourage the Christ believer in a mixed marriage to stay within that union and, presumably (given 7:2-4), continue normal sexual relations.
In the far more radical sexual ideology found in the Acts of Thomas 12 Jesus, in the form of Thomas, teaches a young engaged couple to practice sexual chastity so that they might become holy temples. It is the recitation of the horrible cares and worries actual children cause that serves to bolster the text's ascetic rhetoric. In other words, the trouble actual children cause is used in the Acts of Thomas 12 to argue against the consummation of a marriage, which in turn allows the couple to become pure temples. As Jesus/Thomas teaches: "But if you obey and preserve your souls pure to God (i.e., remain chaste), there will be born to you living children, untouched by these hurtful things, and you will be without care, spending an untroubled life free from grief and care, looking forward to receive that incorruptible and true marriage, and you will enter as groomsmen into that bridal chamber full of immortality and light" (cf. Wis 3:13b-4:9). Although similar imagery is used in 1 Corinthians and Acts of Thomas each text uses it for its own idiosyncratic rhetorical ends.
|
The Power of Pictures: The Somatic Power of Temple Images
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Robert von Thaden, Jr., Mercyhurst University
Images are powerful. Images are efficient. Images are also difficult to control. They have the power to evoke a range of emotions and they prompt the retrieval of different background information – and this is why the same image can be used to support different rhetorical goals. This paper will explore Paul's use of the metaphor THE BODY IS A TEMPLE in 1 Corinthians and demonstrate how this Pauline rhetorical picture is reconfigured to support the radical sexual ideology found in the apocryphal Acts of Thomas. So powerful is the image of embodied temples, I argue, that the Acts of Thomas can deploy it (along with other echoes of Paul's teaching) to argue for a sexual logic at odds with that is expressed in 1 Corinthians itself.
To do this, I will draw on tools from both conceptual integration theory (also called blending theory) and socio-rhetorical interpretation. The resources found in these interpretive analytics enable exegetes to practice a "full bodied" mode of analysis. Edward Slingerland argues that the cognitive science behind conceptual integration theory fosters "an intellectual environment where bracketing our human disposition toward dualism may finally be a real, rather than merely notional, possibility for us." Along similar lines, Vernon Robbins argues that socio-rhetorical interpretation strives "to nurture a 'full-body' mode of interpretation, rather than to continue a tradition of mind-body dualism in interpretation." Recognizing the embodied and dynamic realities of human cognition gives biblical scholars the ability to analyze persuasive arguments from an angle other than that of cold, propositional logic. This is crucial because, as Antonio Damasio argues, "Emotion, feeling, and biological regulation all play a role in human reason. The lowly orders of our organism are in the loop of high reason." Mental pictures prompted by linguistic cues are so powerful (and unpredictable) precisely because they have the ability to evoke and provoke memories, emotions, and actions in the hearer/reader.
|
The Fifth Edition of the United Bible Societies' Greek New Testament
Program Unit:
Florian Voss, Deutsche Bibelgesellschaft
*
|
Nature’s Concern in the Law of Warfare: An Ecological Reading of Deut 20:19–20
Program Unit: Ecological Hermeneutics
Lubunga W'Ehusha, University of KwaZulu-Natal
The aim of this paper is to contribute to the ongoing debate among African theologians about addressing ecological problems on our continent. The rhetorical question, "Are trees in the field human beings that they should come under siege from you?" in the Deuteronomistic Law of Warfare (20:19) brings to the fore the significance of the conservation of nature in God’s economy. In fact the text puts a ban on destroying the environment even in time of war. This is vital on the African continent as many conflicts and civil wars are characterized by massive deforestation and destruction of the ecosystems. This Deuteronomistic Law constitutes, therefore, a biblical resource for eco-theologians to defend nature against its predators and to teach people about the significance of the preservation of the ecosystem. To achieve this goal, this paper firstly discusses the context of this law in Deuteronomy. Secondly, it analyses the text in the light of ecological concerns then and now. Thirdly, it concludes with the question of how this Law can be used to address the current ecological crisis.
|
Paul and the Prophets: Paul’s Use of Scripture in 1 Corinthians 1–4
Program Unit: Scripture and Paul
Erik Waaler, NLA University College
There are different theories of Paul’s attachment to Scripture in 1 Corinthians. It has been suggested by Yongbom Lee that First Corinthians mirrors the Pentateuch, and that the first part mirrors Genesis. This paper discusses the basis for such a conclusion and suggests that a conclusion to the matter should be based on the actual use of Scripture in this part of the text. The discussion takes its departure from implicit and explicit verbal parallels between this text and the Old Testament, which primarily are texts from the prophets. It goes on to evaluate more implicit intertextuality, such as echoes, thematic and structural elements. It discusses whether the structure is based on the Pentateuch and/or an epistolary form, in order to evaluate whether we speak of a parallel to the Pentateuch and/or a particular Pauline epistolary form. The discussion ends with an evaluation of the impact of the use of the Old Testament on the interpretation of this part of First Corinthians.
|
The Coherence Method and History
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Klaus Wachtel, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
The categorical distinction between manuscripts as artifacts and the texts they carry is a cornerstone in the theoretical framework of the Coherence-Based Genealogical Method (CBGM). As a consequence a textflow diagram shows a structure that integrates states of text and must not be confused with an outline of actual historical procedures or a stemma of manuscripts. The structure reflects the degrees of agreement between texts (pre-genealogical coherence) and philological assessment of the relationship between the variants found in them (genealogical coherence). Abstracting from the relationship between actual manuscripts has been criticized as unhistorical. However, the ability of the CBGM to cope with contamination hinges on this abstraction.
|
A Green Apocalypse: Comparing Secular and Religious Eschatological Visions of Earth
Program Unit: John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
Robby Waddell, Southeastern University
Post-apocalyptic dystopias have captured the attention and imagination of our present culture—dominating at the box office and populating the best-seller lists. Packed with religious overtones, the secular eschatologies undergirding these stories combine a mixture of both hope and despair. One part fantasy and one part science-fiction, post-apocalyptic dystopias may contain zombies, vampires, aliens, or artificial intelligence, for example World War Z, District 9, the Matrix trilogy, or iRobot. What these popular stories share is a pessimistic outlook, rooted in the assumption that if humanity stays on its present trajectory then a collapse of the status quo—societal and ecological—is unavoidable. A cataclysmic event, often spelling disaster for the environment, is therefore an essential element to the backstory of any post-apocalyptic tale. Various causes of the catastrophe include the usual suspects: global pandemic, overpopulation, climate change, nuclear holocaust, and so on. Hence, it is not uncommon for the setting of a post-apocalyptic story to be depicted as a veritable wasteland. In these stories, the presupposed ecological tragedy may have severely altered the environment, but it has not annihilated it. In fact, what has happened is that the apocalyptic catastrophe has neutralized the ecological threats that were the original catalysts for the devastation in the first place. The environment receives an opportunity to rebound once its abusers have faced judgment. In other words, Earth may get beaten black-and-blue, yet the final effect is a green apocalypse—an event that rids Earth of its destructive inhabitants or at least counterbalances their negative effects, giving the global ecosystem a chance to renew.
In this paper, I will offer readings of four apocalyptic stories—two modern films (Elysium and Wall-E) and two ancient stories (1 Enoch and Revelation). My approach to these films and texts utilizes elements from a method of ecological hermeneutics that has been developed by Norman Habel and others from the Earth Bible team. While ecotheology and ecohermeneutics may overlap with one another, they are nevertheless quite distinct. It is my hope that these ecological readings with their attention to the concept of a green apocalypse may be useful in the further development of an ecotheology.
|
Apocalipsis Verde: Eschatological Hope for Earth in Post-apocalyptic Films and Ancient Apocalyptic Texts
Program Unit: Bible and Film
Robby Waddell, Southeastern University
Post-apocalyptic dystopias have captured the attention and imagination of our present culture—dominating at the box office and populating the best-seller lists. Packed with religious overtones, the secular eschatologies undergirding these stories combine a mixture of both hope and despair. One part fantasy and one part science-fiction, post-apocalyptic dystopias may contain zombies, vampires, aliens, or artificial intelligence, for example World War Z, District 9, the Matrix trilogy, or iRobot. What these popular stories share is a pessimistic outlook, rooted in the assumption that if humanity stays on its present trajectory then a collapse of the status quo—societal and ecological—is unavoidable. A cataclysmic event, often spelling disaster for the environment, is therefore an essential element to the backstory of any post-apocalyptic tale. Various causes of the catastrophe include the usual suspects: global pandemic, overpopulation, climate change, nuclear holocaust, and so on. Hence, it is not uncommon for the setting of a post-apocalyptic story to be depicted as a veritable wasteland. In these stories, the presupposed ecological tragedy may have severely altered the environment, but it has not annihilated it. In fact, what has happened is that the apocalyptic catastrophe has neutralized the ecological threats that were the original catalysts for the devastation in the first place. The environment receives an opportunity to rebound once its abusers have faced judgment. In other words, Earth may get beaten black-and-blue, yet the final effect is a green apocalypse—an event that rids Earth of its destructive inhabitants or at least counterbalances their negative effects, giving the global ecosystem a chance to renew.
In this paper, I will offer readings of four apocalyptic stories—two modern films (Elysium and Wall-E) and two ancient stories (1 Enoch and Revelation). My approach to these films and texts utilizes elements from a method of ecological hermeneutics that has been developed by Norman Habel and others from the Earth Bible team. While ecotheology and ecohermeneutics may overlap with one another, they are nevertheless quite distinct. It is my hope that these ecological readings with their attention to the concept of a green apocalypse may be useful in the further development of an ecotheology.
|
The Bible, Power, and Wealth in Africa: A Critique of the Prosperity Gospel in Sub-Saharan Africa
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Robert Wafawanaka, Virginia Union University
This paper seeks to provide an assessment of the dynamics of wealth, power, and poverty in Africa through a critique of the Prosperity Gospel in Sub-Saharan Africa. While the notion of the Prosperity Gospel is on the rise in Africa, it is ultimately a display of power dynamics between wealthy and charismatic preachers, versus poor and vulnerable church members. The paper will offer a brief analysis of the connection between prosperity teaching in the United States as background to the Prosperity Gospel in Africa. To understand the biblical perspectives on material wealth better, the paper will explore several biblical texts that are favored by prosperity preachers. It will also offer a holistic approach to material wealth through a study of the proper and improper uses of material resources in the context of the biblical agrarian economy. Ultimately, this paper seeks to highlight the danger of the Prosperity Gospel in impoverished contexts like Africa. It argues that the Prosperity Gospel is counter to the true biblical teaching on material wealth or the Gospel message concerning wealth and prosperity.
|
The Curse of Election: A Postcolonial Saidian Reading of Genesis 18–19
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Robert S. Wafula, Drew University
The Rwandan genocide of 1994, the recent Darfur genocide in South Western Sudan, and the Kenyan 2007-2008 ethnic killings following a disputed presidential (just to name a few), convince us that ethnic violence is perhaps one of Africa’s enduring problems. How can biblical scholarship enter into the ongoing debate for a solution to this problem? What are the methodological tools that can help us appropriate biblical texts to address ethnic violence? Is there any correlative relationship between ethnic violence and biblical texts? Reading Gen. 18—19 through the lens of Edward Said’s Orientalism Theory, this paper seeks to engage the above questions. It is my contention that crimes against humanity committed through ethnic violence have their basis in ethnic identity construction that feeds on the idea of differentiation to justify violence—an idea that has roots in biblical texts.
|
The New Testament and the Septuagint
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
J. Ross Wagner, Duke University
The New Testament and the Septuagint
|
Retrospective: An Analysis of Topics, Methods, and Contributors from 1881 to the Present
Program Unit:
Barry Walfish, University of Toronto
*
|
“As a Deer Longs for Flowing Streams”: Animals and the Ecological Criticism of the Psalms
Program Unit: Book of Psalms
Artnur Walker-Jones, University of Winnipeg
The Psalter contains numerous references to animals, yet there is limited discussion of them and their stories in Psalms studies and, in fact, in biblical scholarship generally. Interpreters typically treat animals as mere metaphors for, or background to, human stories. Handbooks about biblical plants and animals tend to be limited to rather basic biological information and discussions of biblical references. Even where animals are used as metaphors, however, the metaphors must map onto experiences with real animals in order to be perceived as true. There is a growing body of literature in the Humanities and Sciences about the interdependence of species, especially in Cultural Criticism, Zooarchaelogy, and Evolutionary Ecology. Particular passages from the Psalter (Pss. 42:1; 59:6, 14) show how this wealth of information could enrich the interpretation of the Psalms. The modern, increasingly urban, Western world is unique among human cultures in its lack of lived experience with real animals and its anthropocentrism, which has facilitated exploitation of Creation and other creatures. Interpreters’ lack of attention to animals in the Psalter reflects this Western, anthropocentric worldview, and greater attention to animals and other parts of Creation in the Psalter reveals a worldview closer to contemporary Aboriginal worldviews. This paper shows that the use in Psalms criticism of the burgeoning information from Cultural Criticism, Zooarchaeology, and Evolutionary Ecology could lead to a more accurate understanding of the Psalter’s worldview and provide more biocentric and theocentric interpretations for Jewish and Christian environmental ethics.
|
The Book of Judith in Syriac
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Erin Galgay Walsh, Duke University
This paper grows out of a long-standing project translating the books of Judith and Esther for publication, and it seeks to assess the significance of Judith for understanding the Peshitta. The Syriac of the Book of Judith exists within the tradition of the Peshitta, and there are extant fragments of the Syro-Hexaplaric version of Judith. Additionally, a single 18th century manuscript of a later revision of the Peshitta translation survives in the library of the Malankara Catholic archbishop in Trivandrum (Kerala). After a brief summary of the manuscript history, this paper will survey translation features that reflect a critical engagement with the themes of gender and sexuality in the biblical text. Specifically, efforts of translators to tone down the vividness of the Greek vocabulary when the rape of Dinah is recounted in Jdt 9:2 will be examined, along with the treatment of Judith’s character and sexuality. The final scene of celebration in Chapter 15 shows some curious features of Syriac translation practices, and the rare instance of the phrase “noble women” (rawrbanyata) of Israel points to the extent of deliberation on the part of the translators. In light of reflections about the character of the translation, the reception history of Judith among Syriac Christians will be the prime focus for consideration. One area of interest is the nature of the Book of Women, a manuscript collect to which the earliest (6th century) manuscript of Judith belongs. Some reflection will be given to how this context frames the book of Judith. One question that will be asked is what features of the biblical text were of primary interest for Syriac speaking readership. While the relatively rare reflection on the text concentrated on the historicity of the events and figures, some attention was paid to the character of Judith as a model of bravery. The legacy of Judith within the marriage rites of the Syrian Orthodox liturgy, recently observed by Sebastian Brock, deserves greater reflection as the impact and legacy of Judith within the Syriac speaking realm is assessed.
|
How Fictional Recontextualization in Film Might Raise Historical Issues
Program Unit: Historical Jesus
Richard G. Walsh, Methodist University
Richard Walsh will discuss the historical Jesus and film, giving special attention to the South African 2006 movie "Son of Man" by Mark Dornford-May.
|
Q and the 'Big Bang' Theory of Christian Origins
Program Unit: Q
Robyn Faith Walsh, Brown University / University of Miami
This paper revisits the question of the dating of Q. Traditional approaches to the social context of Q’s composition claim it was written before the Jewish War by communities of Jesus followers, scribes or redactor(s) invested in documenting the teachings of Jesus. I propose that such approaches are based on ambiguous evidence and are informed by scholarly imagination about the so-called origins of early Christianity. Features of this scholarly imagination include that the early Jesus movement grew rapidly, was well established institutionally and its followers comprised relatively cohesive communities. Elsewhere, this has been called the “Big Bang” theory of Christian origins. This Big Bang theory is largely based on the origin story for early Christianity constructed by Acts.
More plausible than the pre-War compositional theory is that Q was written post-War by an author interested in exploring the life of a notable Judean figure whose wonderworking and deuteronomistic teachings had particular purchase after the destruction of the Temple. This would place Q among a class of literate specialists constructing and exchanging lives of Jesus post-War, like the gospels writers. This proposed literary network for Q does not rely on assumptions about Q’s social context, but utilizes known data (other extant stories about Jesus) and corresponds with what we know about ancient writing practices—namely that the composition and exchange of texts was an activity of literate, elite cultural producers. This alternative approach also challenges a number of problematic, yet pervasive, theories for understanding the social world of Q and other the first-century texts, including: the notion and reliability of oral tradition; Q’s associations with the Historical Jesus; and that texts are composed by or for communities, which has a troubling association with Romantic-era thinking.
|
The Literary Environment of John and the Influence of German Romanticism
Program Unit: John, Jesus, and History
Robyn Faith Walsh, Brown University
This paper reexamines how contemporary studies of the Gospel of John, and the New Testament more broadly, continue to reinscribe terms and typologies that are heavily influenced by Romanticism. Chief among these is the concept of “community” which is rooted in certain anti-Enlightenment notions of a cohesive Volk, inspired by the Geist of a group’s oral teachings. To assume that sources like the gospels emerged from the folk speech of established early Christian groups, or simply reproduces the interests of a community, presumes a social environment for the production of this literature that, among other issues, agitates against what is known about ancient Mediterranean literary practices—namely that the composition and exchange of texts was an activity of the literate elite. Scholarly focus on communities has had enormous implications for John, which, historically, has been treated as “other” in scholarship on the gospels, given its seemingly more esoteric qualities. By placing John properly within a social network of ancient authors, his writings are understood as no less historical than any other life of Jesus. Moreover, reconsidering John’s social environment refocuses our attention properly on the author, his strategic choices and how we might class his writing within a more comprehensive field of Greco-Roman literature on the teachings and wonderworking of prophetic figures.
|
The Passion and Atonement of Christ in Kierkegaard’s Communion Discourses
Program Unit: Søren Kierkegaard Society
Sylvia Walsh, Stetson University
Although the suffering, death, and atonement of Christ are mentioned numerous times in Kierkegaard’s authorship, it is primarily in his discourses for the communion service on Fridays that the passion and atonement of Jesus Christ are addressed. Five of the thirteen communion discourses published by Kierkegaard focus specifically on the death and atonement of Christ, although all of them are intimately related to that event. This paper examines the communion discourses with an eye toward showing how Kierkegaard views the events leading up to Christ’s crucifixion; the responsibility of the whole human race, not merely the contemporary generation (especially the Jews), for this historical event, which for Kierkegaard is not merely past but a present event in which every human being participates as an accomplice; the inability of a human being to do anything at all to atone for his/her own sin; the atoning significance of Christ’s death as a sacrifice for his crucifixion and for the sins of each person individually, not humanity in general; and the substitutionary manner in which Christ’s death makes satisfaction for a multitude of sins and provides a hiding place for them. Since for Kierkegaard the communion discourses constitute the final telos and unifying element of his authorship as a whole, his reflections on the passion and atonement of Christ in them indicate the importance of this crowning event for his authorship and understanding of Christianity.
|
Garden of Eden: Peripheral or Central?
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
John Walton, Wheaton College (Illinois)
Although there are no direct parallels to the story of the Garden of Eden in the literature of the ancient Near East, some motifs are found that offer possible more limited parallels. Some of these motifs connect to a place that is at the periphery of the cosmos (e.g., Dilmun) while other motifs reflect a cosmic centrality (cosmic tree). In this brief presentation we will survey the connections and seek to determine whether the Garden of Eden in the ancient Israelite view is central or peripheral in the cosmos.
|
Reading J. B. Lightfoot Reading Acts
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Steve Walton, St. Mary’s University, Twickenham
The art of commentating has never been more debated: the variety of commentary series and different approaches espoused by these series is bewildering for the beginner, and sometimes even for the more experienced scholar. What is important in biblical commentary? In particular, in Acts, where should a commentator focus—on text, history, narrative, classical parallels, characterisation, theology, etc., etc.? What can we learn from the major commentators of the past about the art of commentary on Acts?
J. B. Lightfoot, Lady Margaret Professor of Divinity at Cambridge in the 1870s, and later Bishop of Durham, is recognised as a master commentator on the Pauline letters and the Apostolic Fathers. The recent remarkable rediscovery of some 1600 handwritten pages of Lightfoot’s writings from the 1870s includes 21 chapters of commentary on Acts. The publication of this material later in 2014, under the editorship of Ben Witherington III and Todd Still, will allow scholars to engage for the first time with his work on Acts. This intriguing discovery is the first major published commentary material by Lightfoot on a narrative book. It is of great interest because it not only contains Lightfoot’s notes and commentary on Acts 1–21, but also introductory essays, including one on the art of commentary on the Bible as a divinely inspired book.
This paper will use Lightfoot’s newly-published work on Acts 1–21 as a window into the art of biblical commentary. It will locate Lightfoot’s work in the history of Acts (and wider NT) scholarship, identify and assess the central concerns and issues in Lightfoot’s work on Acts, and ask what we have to learn as modern scholars—and commentators, in particular—from his approach, questions, focus, and decisions. This will be accomplished through careful engagement both with Lightfoot’s statements of his principles and aims of approach, as well as by examining his handling of particular passages in Acts in comparison with other commentators (of his own and other periods).
|
The Depiction of Adam in the "Cave of Treasures"
Program Unit: Syriac Literature and Interpretations of Sacred Texts
Tammie Wanta, University of Pennsylvania
It is widely acknowledged that Cave of Treasures contains a vast array of extra-biblical lore, and that this material is particularly concentrated in the stories of the biblical forefathers. In the past, many have been interested in the sources of these narratives, and much has been done to identify and chart parallel traditions. Although this approach has value, it can obscure how the various traditions function in their larger literary context. In this paper, I examine the depiction of Adam in Cave of Treasures with special attention to claims about his creation, his appointments, and his knowledge. I argue that although the text draws on a rich stream of living biblical tradition, this material cannot be properly assessed outside of the larger literary work. Drawing attention to the literary function of these claims about Adam, I aim to clarify how some Syriac-speaking Christians in the sixth century might have thought about the first man.
|
The Jesus Movement as a Jewish Sectarian Movement: The Gospel of Mark as a Case Study
Program Unit: Construction of Christian Identities
Tim Wardle, Furman University
It has become commonplace in monographs and articles detailing the rise of the early Christian movement to identity early Christianity as a Jewish sect. Rarely, however, is this claim accompanied by any substantial discussion of Jewish sectarianism or evaluation of the specific ways in which early Christianity may rightly be determined to be sectarian. This paper intends to do both. Building on the work of scholars like Shaye Cohen and Al Baumgarten, the first half of this paper both explores the contours of Jewish sectarianism in the first centuries B.C.E. and C.E. and examines how Bryan Wilson’s sociological work on protest movements and Lester Grabbe’s more recent work on Jewish sectarianism can further nuance our understanding of Jewish sectarianism during the rise of the early Christian movement. The second half of the paper will focus more narrowly on the gospel of Mark and investigate how closely this particular early Christian text lines up with what is known of sectarian Judaism in the first century C.E.
In particular, I will survey those elements in Mark that most often characterize Jewish sectarian groups— negative appraisals of the Jerusalem temple and its leadership, differing interpretations of the Jewish law, and strict demarcation between insiders and outsiders—and argue that Mark displays similar tendencies to contemporary Jewish sectarian groups. In conclusion, I will discuss some of the implications of seeing Mark as a Jewish sectarian document and offer a rationale for describing the broader early Christian movement in similar terms.
|
"Seeing" the Temple: Teaching the Gospels and Acts through Virtual Tours
Program Unit: Academic Teaching and Biblical Studies
Tim Wardle, Furman University
Aside from physically taking students on a travel study program to New Testament sites, images of material culture, discussions of archaeological sites, and virtual reality tours become crucial avenues for illuminating the biblical texts and helping to create a world of context for undergraduate students. One set of activities that I use to illuminate the first century Jewish religious world, and the importance of the Jerusalem temple at the center of that world, is through a combination of the Virtual World Project, a visual simulation model of the Herodian Temple Mount jointly produced by the Urban Simulation Team at UCLA and the IAA, and Jerusalem.com’s (anachronistic but engaging) virtual tour of the Western Wall.
Bringing these virtual reality tools into the classroom serves several pedagogical purposes. First, they are visually appealing. Our technologically savvy students appreciate the use of various forms of interactive media in a classroom setting, and any way of grabbing their attention is a positive. Second, “seeing” the Jerusalem temple in this visual format enables them to better “see” the temple in the gospels and Acts. Discussions of Jesus’ demonstration of the temple and the events of his last week in Jerusalem in Mark 11-13, or the continual presence of the disciples in the temple courts in Acts 3-5, make more sense to students once they can visualize the importance of the temple in first century Jerusalem. It helps the material “stick.” Third, for those inclined toward the “flipped classroom” or some form of blended learning, having students view these virtual tours before coming to class allows for a fuller classroom discussion. And if “homework” involves taking virtual tours, students are more likely to do it.
|
The Coherence of Paul’s Theology of the Law in Romans 2–3: A New Proposal
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
James Ware, University of Evansville
More than three decades after E.P. Sanders’ famous study, the most perplexing question regarding Paul’s theology of the law remains Paul’s apparent disjunction of the law from the gracious framework of the covenant and its promise of divine mercy. Paul’s portrayal of the law as demanding an obedience impossible for human beings to fulfill has seemed to many interpreters to be both incoherent and profoundly un-Jewish, involving a fundamental misunderstanding of the covenantal context of the law in ancient Judaism, or else a rejection of the covenant altogether. In Sanders’ portrayal, Paul’s statements concerning universal sinfulness are also “remarkably inconsistent,” and at several places Paul assumes the normal Jewish view that the law within the context of the covenant is fulfillable. Paul’s apparent inconsistency
is at the heart of Sanders’ famous charge that Paul’s theology of the law is confused and discordant, not proceeding logically from plight to solution, but illogically “from solution to plight.”
Sanders, Heikki Räisänen, and others have pointed especially to Romans 2-3 as an obvious fault line of this inner contradiction within Paul’s thought. Indeed, the apparent antinomy between Paul’s teaching of justification by works in Romans 2 and his theology of justification by faith in Romans 3 has long vexed interpreters. How can the apostle declare that “the doers of the law will be justified” (Rom 2:13) and yet assert that “by the works of the law no flesh will be justified” (Rom 3:20)? How can Rom 2:10 promise glory, honor, and peace “to everyone who does good,” while Rom 3:12 affirms that “there is no one who does good”? None of the solutions proposed has provided a convincing resolution of this question, which is in many ways at the heart of the problem of Paul and the law.
The solution, I propose, lies within a new assessment of the Jewish and covenantal context of Paul’s thought, in light of a widespread feature of Jewish covenant theology hitherto unrecognized by Pauline specialists. This paper will demonstrate, first, the presence of this feature of covenantal thought in Paul’s Jewish Bible, at Qumran, and in a wide variety of Jewish texts, and, second, its importance in Romans 2-3. In so doing this study offers a fresh proposal which will shed light on the coherence of these chapters, illumine Paul’s thought as a whole, and point toward a solution to the fundamental problem of Paul and the law.
|
'Leaving and Cleaving': Genesis 2:24 on Marriage, Gender, and Ethnicity
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Megan Warner, King's College - London
Recent trends have seen a shift in focus among exegetes interested in issues of human sexuality and same-sex relationships from texts such as Genesis 19 and Leviticus 20 to the creation narratives of Genesis. Of these, Gen 2:24 has received particular attention, with some arguing that the verse establishes heterosexual marriage as a biblical norm. Reception of Gen 2:24 in the New Testament (Matt 19:5; Mark 10:8; Eph 5:31) highlights the element of gender in the marriage context, but this paper asks to what extent gender is a focus of Gen 2:24 itself. The literary context of Gen 2:24 is inherently concerned with gender, chronicling as it does the very beginnings of gender as a phenomenon. Scholarly consensus, however, understands Gen 2:24 to be an editorial addition. Does Gen 2:24 share the concerns of the narrative to which it has been added, or might it be reflective of its own concerns? Building upon a study of the distinctive verbs used in the verse, the paper argues that the primary engagement of Gen 2:24 is not with issues of gender, but of ethnicity, and in particular Persian period pre-occupations about inter-marriage.
|
A Biographical Sketch of François Bovon
Program Unit: Gospel of Luke
David Warren, Faulkner University
A biographical sketch of the life and scholarship of François Bovon.
|
My Flesh Is Meat Indeed: Theophagy and Christology in John 6:51c–58
Program Unit: Meals in the Greco-Roman World
Meredith Warren, University of Ottawa
This project argues that John 6:51c–58 makes christological rather than eucharistic claims. While scholars have often viewed the “Bread of Life Discourse” as a later addition of sacramental theology to John’s supposedly anti-sacramental gospel, I propose that the narrative of consumption in this pericope functions to make Jesus “equal to God.” Two major themes converge in this section that support this conclusion: the pointed concern with Jesus’ identity and John’s use of sacrificial language.
John 6:51c–58 comes on the heels of a statement made about Jesus’ human parentage in John 6:41–51b, making divine/mortal identity a logical context in which to understand his statements about eating his flesh and drinking his blood. Further, throughout John there exists an overriding concern with Jesus’ divinity and humanity. The moment when Jesus exhorts those around him to eat his flesh and drink his blood is when Jesus identifies himself with the God who put him on earth to die a sacrificial death.
This death, too, is evoked in Jesus’ words in John 6:51c–58. John's use of 'didomi + hyper' here alludes both to Jesus’ death on behalf of others, and to the representation of this death as sacrifice. In almost all uses found in the New Testament, the phrase is used to connote Jesus’ expiatory death on the cross, not in a eucharistic context, but in a sacrificial one (e.g. in particular Eph. 5:2). This section represents a literary performance of a ritual meal which is not the eucharist. Instead, John 6:51c–58 references the cultic meal that establishes the hero cult, and as such, establishes the hero’s association with his divine patron (cf. Nagy, 1979). Jesus’ death associates him with the idea of the Hellenistic hero (Wills, 1997); I argue that the narrative-level consumption of his flesh in a sacrificial context indicates his divinity.
The series of statements in John 6:51c–58 therefore bring about the identification of Jesus with God because of shared cultural expectations in the ancient Mediterranean world about the nature of the divine-mortal relationship. As in the cultural milieu in which he wrote, for John, sacrifice is not complete without the meal it includes—a meal that identifies Jesus with God. In John’s gospel, the glorification, death, and sacrificial consumption of Jesus are intimately connected; John 6:51c–53 is the locus of that interconnection.
|
The (Im)purity Level of Communal Meals within the Qumran Movement
Program Unit: Qumran
Cecilia Wassen, Uppsala Universitet
It is commonplace in Qumran scholarship to assume that the sectarians ate communal meals in a state of ritual purity. Josephus’ claim that the Essenes purified before meals and approached the dining room “as if it were some (kind of) sanctuary” (J.W. 2.128) has been particularly influential for such a reconstruction. A key sectarian text for this reconstructed scenario is 1QS 6:16b-21b, which lays down the rules for gradual access to ‘the purity of the many’ and ‘the liquid of the many’ as a part of the admission process. These terms are usually understood as references to the food and drink of communal meals, but this is debatable. I will argue that communal meals are not necessarily implied in the term ‘the purity,’ ha?ahorah, and that a low level of impurity was allowed at regular, communal meals. This paper has three parts: (a) an examination of the term ha?ahorah and its relation to food, (b) a survey of sectarian instructions about meals (e.g., 1QS 6:2b-6 and 1QSa 2:17-22), and (c), an analysis of texts that indicate that a low grade of impurity was acceptable at communal meals (e.g., 4QTohorot A [4Q274]; 4QInstructionsc [4Q514]).
|
Gods, Religions, and Divine Exceptionalism: The Case of So-Called Idolatry
Program Unit: North American Association for the Study of Religion
Emma Wasserman, Rutgers University
This paper explores the promises and perils of using gods and non-obvious beings as critical categories of analysis with particular attention to idolatry discourses in early Jewish and Christian literature. I will engage with critics and detractors of the category of religion such as Talal Asad and Timothy Fitzgerald, as well as the important contributions of Hans Penner and Stanley Stowers that seek to constructively re-theorize religion as an analytic category. For instance, Stowers distinguishes religion as sets of interlinking social practices that make reference to or imply central roles for gods and other non-obvious or normally non-observable beings. This theory uses the distinctive empirical status of gods and non-obvious beings as the primary criteria for classification but posits virtually nothing about their possible significance or meanings in any given context, even less relative to human activity writ large. This paper will seek to test two hypotheses: first, that such a theory helpfully clarifies the comparative dimensions of critical analysis; second, that it can weather the strong criticisms posed by figures such as Assad, Fitzgerald, and Brent Nongbri.
|
Historical and Philological Correlations and the CBGM
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Tommy Wasserman, Orebro School of Theology
In a crucial article, the inventor of the Coherence Based Genealogical Method (CBGM), Gerd Mink, explains that there is a circular argument typical of textual criticism: “Witnesses are good because of their good variants. Variants are good because of their good witnesses.” Mink suggests that this circularity cannot be avoided, but has to be controlled. This paper explores various ways in which such control is exerted in the CBGM and offers examples of how results can be at least partially correlated to historical and philological observations.
|
From Demythologizing to Narrative?
Program Unit: Theological Interpretation of Scripture
Francis Watson, Durham University
Rudolf Bultmann's reception in the English-speaking world has been dominated by the post-War demythologizing controversy, generated by a single article. The recovery of the concept of narrative through Hans Frei and others has led to the demise of the demythologizing project and, with it, Bultmann's reputation as a major theological thinker. In response to this (non-)reception of Bultmann, this paper will make two rather different moves. First, it will attempt to situate the original demythologizing article in the historical context of an apparently triumphant Third Reich. Second, it will ask whether demythologizing has any ongoing significance in a world of plural narratives.
|
The Principle of Universality in Sociolinguistics with Reference to Acts 22:2
Program Unit: Biblical Greek Language and Linguistics
Jonathan M. Watt, Geneva College
The application of modern linguistics to ancient languages, and to the living situations that once supported them, necessitate assumptions about the nature of language, the human mind, and the force of contextual influences. The principle of universality involves assumptions about commonalities that exist (or allegedly exist) between different speakers, languages and cultures. While theorists differ as to exactly what kinds of extensions can be made from one language community to another, some degree of consistency or universality is the default position in linguistics. Although the ‘father of universality’, Joseph Greenberg, published Universals of Grammar in 1963, he was hardly travelling solo. The very conception of an International Phonetic Alphabet (IPA) involves the reach for a limited inventory of sound features applicable to every natural language. Noam Chomsky’s Universal Grammar (1965, 2007) argued for universality in syntax, while Bernard Comrie (1981) did so with typology. Leonard Talmy argued similarly in the field of cognitive semantics (2000, 2006; also, Anna Wierzbicka, 1996) while Stephen Krashen (1982) and others have sought for commonality in second language development; Steven Pinker’s Language Instinct (1994) connected the idea with evolution. The list is extensive because the factor of ‘cognitive hard-wiring’ in the human brain seems to necessitate some degree of commonality between communication systems.
Cross-linguistic and intercultural studies on their part may focus on the uniqueness of a speech community (e.g. Paulston, Kiesling and Rangal, 2012) but they too search for commonality of features. Eugene Nida’s development of translation theory was an exercise in human commonality despite surface differences, though Brown and Levinson’s ground breaking study on Politeness (1978, 1987) put it right into the subtitle: “Some universals in language usage.”
So with today’s theoretical tools being used to study yesterday’s speech communities, this paper aims to identify some of the principles of universality as they relate specifically to sociolinguistics, and to Acts 22:2, with its overt (if brief) mention of code-switching. In order to do this, this paper first surveys theorists who have articulated principles of universality (e.g. Greenberg) in order to identify some of their assumptions and goals. Second, it identifies an analogous set of principles articulated by certain pioneering sociolinguists (e.g. Haugen, Hymes, Ferguson). Third, the paper shows how concepts such as code-switching and language ideology, despite certain risks in application, may contribute to our exegetical understanding.
____________________
|
Shaping Biblical Law for Oral Performance and Aural Reception
Program Unit: Orality, Textuality, and the Formation of the Hebrew Bible
James W. Watts, Syracuse University
Recent studies have demonstrated the role of orality in the publication, preservation and transmission of ancient written texts. That accords with the Hebrew Bible’s explicit descriptions of the oral performance and aural reception of written law (Exodus 24; Deuteronomy 31; Joshua 23; 2 Kings 22-23; Nehemiah 9). Therefore analysis of the form and content of biblical law should consider how its written form has been shaped intentionally for oral performance and aural reception. The systematic formulation of ritual instructions in Leviticus requires such analysis just as much as does the hortatory rhetoric of Deuteronomy. Consideration of the effect of repetitive formulas and systematic presentation on a listening audience provides illuminating insight into the overall structure of Leviticus as well as into particular rhetorical features of its chapters and verses. However, other features of the book that would be imperceptible to a listening audience would nevertheless be very evident to scribes memorizing the book’s contents. Biblical legislation therefore contains clear evidence of being shaped intentionally for oral use by expert sages as well as for aural reception by lay audiences.
|
There and Back Again, A Jesus Tale: The Poetics of Apologetic Reversal
Program Unit: Markan Literary Sources
Joel L. Watts, University of the Free State - Universiteit van die Vrystaat
This paper examines the presentation of Jesus’s entry into Jerusalem (Mark 11.1–17) via mimesis. Rather than rewriting previous works or seeking to capitalize upon the positive image of a previous generation’s prophet as Mark has before, I propose our author is exploiting an apology of reversal in this pericope. This repetition, aptly named the “mimesis of the other,” is a repetition to dominate (Nesteruk 2013). The author of the Gospel of Mark presents Jesus in such a way as to refute a particular image by first imitating that image and then altering the aftermath. We discover this image through intertextuality; we discover the repudiation through other devices concealed in the text. I propose a reading of Mark 11.1–17 where the author uses existing literary material of recent historical actions to present Jesus as one who has entered Jerusalem quite contrary to the manner of the Egyptian (BJ 2.263–65) and Simon bar Giora (BJ 4.570-84). I will use the “mimesis of the other” to propose a reason why Mark may have used at least two scenes from Josephus’s Bellum Judaicum (2.263–65; 4.570-84) to judiciously craft this anticlimactic scene. By using “mimesis of the other,” our author is establishing Jesus against familiar motifs of rebels and dictators who attempted to wrest Jerusalem away from the Romans. This paper will presume a post–70 Sitz im Leben as well as knowledge of Josephus’s earliest works by the author of GMark. I will work, based on these presuppositions, towards establishing a literary relationship between these two texts transcending intertextuality to one utilizing structure, geography, and character movement so that we clearly see not just mimicking, but an intentional reversal serving as an apologetic device.
|
The Meaning of the Minor Judges: Understanding the Bible’s Shortest Stories
Program Unit: Joshua-Judges
Kenneth C. Way, Talbot School of Theology
The notices about the so-called “Minor Judges” (Judg 3:31; 10:1-5; 12:8-15) are strategically arranged in the literary structure of the book of Judges. They are therefore “minor” only in the sense that they are shorter than the other stories, but their selective thematic emphases (especially on foreign deliverers, royal aspirations, outside marriages, “Canaanization,” etc.) indicate that they are included with editorial purpose. The minor judges therefore have major importance for understanding the theological message of the book.
|
Inhabiting the Book: The Qur'an and Space in Mamluk Religious Architecture
Program Unit: The Qur’an: Manuscripts and Textual Criticism (IQSA)
Peter Webb, University of London
Islamic art has proven a taxing subject for the academy. Although pre-modern Arabic writers were surrounded by art, design and ornament, they rarely wrote about it; the study of Islamic art accordingly developed as a Western discipline, but scholars faced difficulties in reconciling Islamic art with their familiar models of European art theory, and so the connections between images, text and meaning in pre-modern Islamic lands remain obscure. As an introduction to a new collaborative project that aims to develop deeper appreciation for iconography and semiotics in medieval Islam, this paper explores how Qur'anic inscriptions and related symbols gave meaning to Mamluk religious architecture. My project is inspired by Mamluk Cairo's literate, bibliophilic and perhaps even bookaholic society. Given the widespread love of books, can we explore whether Mamluk-era scholars interacted with buildings in a manner akin to how they, as readers, interacted with books? As a book's bab (chapter) connotes the division of ideas, did a building's bab (door) represent the threshold of a new exegetical experience which invited visitors to inspect inscriptions (zahir) in order to realise hidden (batin) meanings? This highlights the value in approaching space and literacy together to probe architectural aesthetics by 'reading' buildings. I begin at the front door. A comparison of elaborate madrasa portals, sabil-kuttab facades and Qur'an manuscript frontispieces will reveal the universe of symbols shared between the arts of the book and buildings, both of which also borrow from esoteric and mystical disciplines. Moving inside, and using the Ghuriyya complex as a case study, I will analyse the selection, positioning and rendering of Qur'anic inscriptions to interrogate the role of religious text in constructing religious space. The marshalling of Qur'anic iconography in architecture transformed buildings into complex texts - a fitting status considering how often the Mamluk world is called a 'civilisation of the book'.
|
Justice without Mercy or No Justice without Mercy? Comparing 1 Peter and James
Program Unit: Bible and Ethics
Martin Webber, Evangelische Theologische Faculteit
Both the First epistle of Peter and the Epistle of James evoke, in their own ways, the concepts of justice and mercy. For example, 1 Peter never urges the action of acting mercifully on his readers, reserving it exclusively for God (1 Pet 1:3); the readers only have been shown mercy (1 P 2:10). Yet James demands it actively of his readers (Jas 2:13). Similarly both have different foci on future and present judgment (e.g. 1 Peter 2:11, 18; 4:17 cf. Jas 1:10-11; 3:1; 5:1-5, 9). A third point of comparison is how they perceive justice can or will be achieved. The author of 1 Peter apparently focuses indefinitely on the future (??????, 1 Pet 5:10, cf. 5:1) for the readers, while that of James is ambiguous over the timing and method (Jas 2:12-13 and see above references). Where do their exhortations fit on the landscape of early Christian ethical instruction?
This study will try to answer the above questions and tensions, taking into account the ethical approaches of both letters, with particular attention to how the perceived social position of the readers may have influenced each author’s presentation. Relationship to and valuation of the Old Testament, prominent in the appeals of both, will also be evaluated.
|
Cultivating the Spirit: "Safe Space in the Classroom"
Program Unit: Teaching Biblical Studies in an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Context
Jane S. Webster, Barton College
Cultivating the Spirit: How College Can Enhance Students' Inner Lives, by Alexander W. Astin, Helen S. Astin, and Jennifer A. Lindholm (Josey-Bass, 2010), demonstrate statistically that college students who engage questions of “spiritual quest” (identity, meaning, and purpose) have a higher degree of success across the board. It is in the best interest of the institutions of higher learning, therefore, to create opportunities for students to engage these questions, one of which is in the religious studies classroom. This paper will describe a research study conducted at Barton College 2013-2014: three religion majors and one faculty member gathered student opinion about “safe space in the classroom,” generated several strategies of implementation (e.g., norm setting, metacognition, peer-assessment, and trust development), and measured the impact in a preliminary way.
|
The Senses, Volatile Bodies, and Clement of Alexandria’s Paidagogus
Program Unit: Social History of Formative Christianity and Judaism
Phillip Webster, University of Pennsylvania
In the Paidagogus, Clement of Alexandria describes the senses as doorways to the soul. Through sight, smell, and taste, indulgence can come into the soul and displace reason from it, at least according to Clement. In this paper, I aim to explore some of the consequences of thinking about the senses in terms of their affect upon the soul. To begin, by holding up a wounded soul, damaged by an over-indulgence caused by the senses, Clement is able to frame his many denunciations of luxurious living in practical and objective terms rather than as apodictic commands. For example, instead of condemning overeating or the consumption of luxurious foods by fiat, Clement informs his audience of the acute effects of overeating upon the soul. Inspired by the work of Elizabeth Grosz, I will show how this network of connections between the senses, the soul, and the normative ideal of self-control expresses a notion of materiality and corporeality that defies the entrenched mind-body dualism of modernity. More importantly for my purposes, by examining this network of connections that Clement claims exists between senses, the soul, and self-control, my paper will shed light on the type of body Clement’s discursive field would provide for his ancient Christian subjects.
|
Clement of Alexandria and the Appearance of the Virtuous Soul
Program Unit: Religious Competition in Late Antiquity
Phillip Webster, University of Pennsylvania
Whatever his exact social position, Clement of Alexandria positioned himself among the elite of Alexandrian society through his mastery of "classical" texts and authors. Unmatched in the breadth and quantity of their citations of ancient philosophers and poets, Clement's writings mark a high point in the competition over the possession of Greek knowledge at the end of the second and beginning of the third centuries. Given his extraordinary command of ancient sources and his position as the first major Christian thinker to incorporate Greek philosophy into Christian thinking, Clement has often been studied in the context of this elite battle over knowledge. An important, yet understudied, aspect of Clement's writings, however, is his very direct attempt in the Paidagogus to manage bodily manners, habits, and appearance. In this paper, I aim to explore Clement’s efforts to manage the appearance of his audience. Clement’s strategy is to contrast artificially crafted physical beauty with the beauty of the virtuous soul. According to Clement, simple, unadorned appearance signals the presence of a virtuous soul. Although he may have still been writing to the rich and the elite, Clement’s denunciations of jewelry, cosmetics, and expensive hairstyles offer a mode of religious living accessible to the non-elite. Clement's attempts to manage the appearance of the body therefore provide a rich field for investigating how Clement's aims extended beyond the games of the literary elite and intersected with the religious worlds of the illiterate.
|
A Call to Consider the Potential of Contextual Bible Study as the Basis for a New Form of ‘Biblical Therapy’ through Reimagining the Final ‘Action Plan’ Phase: An Experimental Work in Progress
Program Unit: Bible and Practical Theology
Tiffany Webster, Sheffield Institute for Interdisciplinary Biblical Studies
This paper examines a suggested modification of the ‘Action Plan’ phase of Contextual Bible Study (CBS), which traditionally advocates the development of a practical plan whereby CBS participants can transform their immediate circumstances through direct community action. This paper contends that this requirement restricts CBS to contexts in need of major community-wide transformation, namely those labelled ‘marginalised’ or ‘oppressed’. By critically amending this final stage to include non-confessional therapeutic psychological transformation as an end in itself, the process’ inclusivity, and subsequently scope, can be broadened.
This paper proposes that CBS can be methodologically and ideologically streamlined to solely focus upon psychological transformation, primarily through non-confessional encounters with the Bible in an art therapy inspired setting. In support of this proposition, an experimental case-study will be briefly examined which illustrates how this modified process has already been utilised in fieldwork centring upon a group of British coal miners who have recently faced the collective trauma of mass involuntary redundancy.
During the ten month facilitated CBS program in which the coal miners participated, they began using the sessions to ‘work-through’ the trauma of losing the vocation that undeniably came to form their identity. This paper specifically explores the group’s readings of Jeremiah 18:1-12 and Job 17:1-16, which inspired the participants to begin openly reflecting upon their current feelings of indignation, insignificance, injustice and betrayal, along with coming to terms with their ‘limbo-like’ identity status and the impact the closure of their colliery has had upon their lives.
By critically refining current CBS practices and integrating them with the relatively nascent concepts of ‘Biblical counselling’ and socially-engaged scholarship, this paper will highlight the exciting potential of CBS as a solely therapeutic process. This could then ultimately lead to CBS becoming a prominent contributor in the area of interdisciplinary and collaborative medical humanities.
|
Why Is There So Little Wisdom Influence?
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Stuart Weeks, University of Durham
Much ancient “didactic” literature was written with the intention that it should shape and enhance the discourse of those who read and learned it, so allusions to, or even citations from such literature in other texts should not surprise us (although we should be wary of imbuing them with too much, or at least with the wrong sort of significance). It is more astonishing, in fact, that so few claims of “wisdom influence” on other biblical literature involve the specific citation of wisdom texts that are known to us, and this raises questions about the early date and central educational role attributed to parts of Proverbs in particular, both by earlier presentations and by some recent research.
|
Spirit (Ling), Holy Spirit, and the Cultural Identity: In the Context of Chinese Christianity
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Hua Wei, Huaqiao University, China
Spirit (Ling), Holy Spirit and the Cultural Identity: In the Context of Chinese Christianity
|
Una Voce Dicentes: The Ritual Significance of Singing with One Voice in Early Christian Assemblies
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Jade Weimer, University of Toronto
The practice of singing in early Christian assemblies was an integral ritual exercise that served several important functions. Singing was a component of communal worship and a mechanism of divine communication. It was also used as a tool of pedagogy to impart religious knowledge to members of the assembly. Finally, the practice of liturgical singing was used by various church fathers from the second century onward to define an evolving ‘Christian’ identity. Some of these early church fathers articulated explicit tenets regarding the ‘correct’ form of musical engagement, which often centered on the concept of ‘singing with one voice’. Patristic sources including Ignatius, Origen, and Clement of Alexandria all stressed the importance of singing with a unified voice. Even Paul refers to praising/glorifying God ‘with one mouth’ in his letter to the Romans. There are two main explanations for this emphasis in early Christian liturgical singing. First, some of these early Christian authorities associated harmonious vocal arrangements with the 'immoral practices' of their Greco-Roman neighbours. Second, the practice of singing in unison served as an ideal model that simultaneously instilled and reflected social unity and cohesion among all members of the assembly. Therefore, the practice of ‘singing with one voice’ in early Christ-following assemblies played an important role in the attempt to formulate a Christian identity and strengthen the social bonds of the group.
|
Physis (Nature) and the Lawfulness of Change in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Philosophy
Joshua Weinstein, Shalem College, Jerusalem
Since the Greek term physis (nature) in not translated into Hebrew until the medieval coinage of ???, the question arises what sense of how things happen is at work in the Hebrew Bible. A rather lazy occasionalism – God does everything – is proposed by some Biblical authors, but this is not a widely accepted position. Too many other moral persons appear on the Biblical stage covenanting with, disobeying and surprising God. A far more prevalent option gives primacy to the moral law of justice and contract. Even the stars and the sea keep to their appointed places and functions by law and covenant. Some texts also see God as bound by this same law (????, ????,????). A third position needs to be taken seriously as well. Many biblical authors assume what might be called a law of universal gravitation: all things fall, collapse, fail. All things move in a vertical dimension in which upward means success, stability and power (???, ??? , ??? , ??? , ??? , ??? , ??? , ???) while downward means failure, collapse and dissolution (??? ,??? ,??? ,??? ,???). Not only is it an open question if any given person, word/thing (???) or the world as a whole will move upward or downward, but it is assumed that, absent a countervailing reason, everything will fall. Death, defeat, falsification and dissolving into liquid chaos are some special instances of falling; in particular, one can fall without dying (and vice versa). Can anything be said about the relations among these three positions? First, as noted, God seems at times under the moral law. Furthermore, though God’s role is usually that of up-holder, certain passages make best sense in the context of the possibility that God might himself fail. If this is so, then the most general problem regarding the laws of change in the Bible is: Can the Torah fall? Or is gravity subject to moral constraint? Though extremely difficult to judge, the answer to both questions seems to be “No.” The resulting stand-off, however, leaves God (and others) with considerable freedom of action.
|
Jeremiah - A Textual History
Program Unit:
Richard Weis, Lexington Theological Seminary
Since the publication of the fragments of Jeremiah manuscripts from Cave 4 at Qumran re-opened the question of the relations between the text form of the book found in the Masoretic Text and related witnesses and the text form found in its Old Greek translation, the book of Jeremiah has been the site of a vigorous discussion of the relation of the book’s textual and literary histories. Thus the interpretation of the book’s textual history is far more consequential for the exegesis of the book than was presumed for the first three quarters of the twentieth century, or than is typical for other books of the Hebrew Bible. Through a survey of current options in the understanding of the textual history of Jeremiah, and consideration of concrete examples, this paper will suggest how contemporary exegesis of Jeremiah might take better account of the textual history of the book.
|
Biblical Metaphors of God as "Other"
Program Unit: Israelite Prophetic Literature
Andrea Weiss, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion (New York Branch)
The Hebrew Bible employs an array of metaphors when speaking about and to God. The biblical authors drew upon many facets of their physical environment and lived experiences as they constructed metaphors to try to explain who God is and how God operates in the world. Throughout the Bible, particularly in poetry, metaphor becomes a means to span the chasm between the known--one's own world--and the unknown--the Divine. Surveying the variety of metaphors for God shows that some biblical texts depict God as a human being engaged in human types of roles and responsibilities, such as God as parent, husband, shepherd, or king. Other biblical passages conceptualize God as animals, concrete objects, meteorological phenomena, and the like. Do the human metaphors for God differ in meaningful ways from the non-human metaphors? What does it mean for a writer or speaker to envision God more like one's self, in a human guise, versus as "other," through non-human analogies? This paper will explore these questions in an attempt to better understand biblical metaphors of God as "other."
|
Biblical Ethics: Lies and Misleading Truths
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible and Philosophy
Shira Weiss, Yeshiva University
Despite the bible's prohibitions against lying (Ex. 20:12, Lev. 19:11, Prov. 6:17), there are many instances in biblical narrative in which deceptive means are used to achieve a desired end. Are lying and deception antithetical to truth and righteousness in the bible? Or do instances of apparent lying and deception by biblical figures reflect a different understanding of biblical truth and justice?
|
Isaiah and the Twelve: A Case Study Based on the Children's Names in Isa 7–8 and Hos 1–3
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
Kay Weißflog, University of Halle
To give children strange symbolic names is an important feature in the so-called Isaianic Denkschrift (Isa 6–8) and in the first three chapters of the book of Hosea (Hos 1–3) as well. The children are called Shear-jashub (Isa 7:3), Maher-shalal-hash-baz (Isa 8:3), or Jezreel, Lo-ruhamah and Lo-ammi (Hos 1:4.6.8). What evidence can these names give us about the literary history of the prophetic books in which they are used? This paper argues that there is a close literary historic relationship between both texts. Hos 1–3 not only seems to be a figurative narrative introduction of older anonymous, possibly Hoseanic, records (in Hos 2* and 4–12*). But also it establishes a correlation between different and originally independent collections of growing prophetic literature by imitating the symbolic act of naming children in Isa 7–8.
|
Angst and Anticipation: Situating Iron Age Realities and Post-exilic Expectations in the Book of Zephaniah
Program Unit: Economics in the Biblical World
Eric L. Welch, Pennsylvania State University
Many scholars recognize that the book of Zephaniah, which likely reached its final form in the Persian Period, contains material first composed during the Iron Age. This extended process of textual formation offers a unique case study of the scribal cultures responsible for the text’s conception and formalization, especially when considering the economic worlds experienced by scribes before and after the Exile.
This paper will explore how select portions of Zephaniah 2 dating to the Iron Age found resonance with later Persian Period scribes and their audiences due to similarities in regional economic conditions. Using literary, lexical, and archaeological evidence, I will briefly demonstrate how Zephaniah’s oracle against the Philistines reflects authentic Iron Age socio-economic circumstances, namely those of the changing economy of the 7th century B.C.E. This paper will then consider how those Iron Age concerns took on new meaning in the context of the Persian Period economy, when they were incorporated into hopes of economic restoration. As the focal point of this analysis, I will consider the scribal cultures responsible for Zephaniah’s formation, with specific attention on scribal culture and its function in the context of recently depopulated and repopulated agricultural economies.
|
The Grammar and Meaning of the Leviticus Texts on Same-Sex Relations Reconsidered
Program Unit: Biblical Law
Bruce Wells, Saint Joseph's University
This paper argues that the texts in Leviticus (18:22 and 20:13) prohibiting sex between men have traditionally been misinterpreted. The main crux in the texts is the phrase "mishkebe isha," which is usually translated, "as one lies with a woman." I will raise two arguments against this understanding. First, Biblical Hebrew, in order to convey the meaning "as one does X," typically employs either the particle "ke" with an infinitive construct (e.g., Judg 14:6; 2 Sam 6:20) or the word "ka'asher" followed by a finite verb form (e.g., Jer 19:11; Amos 9:9). Second, the phrase "mishkebe isha" functions as an adverbial accusative complementing the verb "shakab." A study of how "shakab" is used in the Hebrew Bible shows that “mishkebe isha” in the Leviticus texts is most likely an adverbial accusative of location and not manner (the traditional understanding seems to assume that the phrase describes the manner of the lying down). A literal translation of the phrase would be “on the beds of a woman/wife.” I will argue that the prohibitions seek to prevent sex primarily between married men, though some unmarried men may be included as well. By considering the one other biblical text (Gen 49:4) and the one Dead Sea Scrolls text (1QSa 1.10) that use a masculine plural form of “mishkab” (as the Leviticus texts do), I will seek to demonstrate that “mishkebe” should be understood as an abstract plural meant to convey the sense of lying-down zone or sexual domain. Thus, the basic rule prohibits lying down with a man who is considered the sexual domain of a woman/wife. I will also attempt to show how this prohibition fits in with the other regulations on sexual behavior in this part of the Holiness Code.
|
Not Twelve, But Five: Theorizing Christian Practice in the Second Century
Program Unit: Redescribing Christian Origins
Heidi Wendt, Wright State University Main Campus
This paper explores a new dimension of practice-centered approaches to theorizing competition between second-century experts on Christ. In particular, I propose that our evidence for Christians in this period arose from and is best understood within a particular social context: the provision of specialized knowledge and services by experts who were largely self-authorizing and thus responsible for generating their own legitimacy (e.g., diviners, initiators, astrologers, magi, doctors, and some philosophers). Although these actors might differ with respect to skills, to ethnicity, to understandings of certain practices, and to social formations, I argue that they participated in a common class of activity whose dynamics are illuminating of the diversity apparent in our Christian sources.
After outlining the characteristics of this class, I then survey the range of practices (myth-making, numerology, textual divination, prophesy, initiation, purification, healing, exorcism, writing, etc.) that occurs in Irenaeus’ polemical descriptions of second-century figures and groups in order to demonstrate affinities not only between rival Christians, but also between Christians and purveyors of other kinds of specialized offerings. Attention to practices enables us to filter this wider class of activity for different but non-essential relationships between its participants (e.g., between intellectualizing religious experts and philosophers, or between varieties of initiators) without needing to introduce such problematic categories as Judaism, Christianity, Gnosticism, orthodoxy, and heresy, among others. Rather, in the absence of these distinctions, the practices of a writer-intellectual such as Irenaeus have more in common than not with those of the 'heretics' whom he disparages, as well as with the practices of non-Christian specialists who employed similar skills to distinguish and promote their own forms of expertise.
|
Ritual, Order, and the Construction of an Audience in 1 Enoch 1–36
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Rodney A. Werline, Barton College
While 1 Enoch 1–36 contains multiple traditions and has obviously passed through several editorial stages, a concern for order consistently runs throughout the text. Among the many strategies that the authors use to address this problem stands ritual action. Ostensibly, ritual establishes an atmosphere for a scene and assists in the flow of action. However, ritual holds a much more important place than simple dressing. Ritual theorists such as Maurice Bloch, Roy Rappaport, Catherine Bell, and Talal Asad have demonstrated that ritual establishes social order and roles. Rappaport, for example, asserts that a fundamental feature of ritual lies in its ability to establish a social contract and obligation—those who submit to the ritual also submit to the culture. Similarly, both Bell and Asad have emphasized that ritual enacts social relationships and is power. These anthropological observations can cast new light on the place of ritual in 1 Enoch. First, the opening of the apocalypse constructs its audience through the ritualized actions and speech of a testament scene. Through this, the audience members become the recipients of a tradition with all the social status and moral obligations that entails. Second, the text ritually constructs the figure Enoch as one who “approaches” the heavenly throne, as one who functions as intercessor, and as one who is privy to various kinds of divine wisdom. As the model for those connected to this literature, the ritual construction of Enoch reinforces their own ritual construction and thus extends the significance and power of ritual. Through such an analysis, this paper offers new suggestions about the social significance of the inclusion of ritual within texts.
|
The Psalms of Solomon and the Aesthetics of Performance
Program Unit: Performance Criticism of the Bible and Other Ancient Texts
Rodney A. Werline, Barton College
The Psalms of Solomon consists of a collection of psalms that most likely originated in Palestine sometime during the early decades of Roman occupation of Palestine, and were probably updated during the reign of Herod the Great. Recent analysis suggests that the authors were from a scribal class that was in conflict with the Jerusalem priesthood. The group refers to itself with terms such as “pious ones” and “the righteous,” and they seem to have gathered in synagogues where the psalms may have been performed (cf. Pss. Sol. 10:7; 17:16, 43, 44). Given this historical and social setting, this paper has two basic aims. First, the paper briefly identifies and analyzes specific performative features of the psalms that suggest that the psalms were indeed performed orally, and thus should not be understood as individual and private meditative reflections. Among many textual features, these especially suggest performance: the use of Gerichtsdoxologie (cf. Ps. Sol. 2:15; 3:5; 4:8; 8:7, 23, 26; 9:2; cf. Ezr 9:15; Dan 9:7; Tob 3:2; Pr Azar 1:4; Bar 1:15; 2:6; 1QS I, 25b–26; 4Q504 1–2, VI, 3); references to confession (Ps. Sol 15:2); reflection on significance of performance of psalms (Pss. Sol. 3:1–2; 15:3; 16:5–11); blessing and cursing (e.g., Pss. Sol. 4:6–7, 14–22; 9:11; 10:8; 12:4–6). Second, the paper argues that the performative features of the psalms function to give shape to what Roy Rappaport calls “socially approved sentiments” (such as “seriousness, solemnity, reverence, submission”). Following Rappaport’s understanding of the aesthetics of ritual, but also supplementing it with Talal Asad, Catherine Bell, Angela Kim-Harkins and others, the paper argues that the psalms are constructed in such a way so as to generate and guide group and individual emotional responses to national disaster, attitudes toward opponents, and the struggles of the pious life. This ability to manage experience through ritualized expression in turn gives rhetorical power to the discursive elements of the psalms. In this way, the psalms, according to Rappaport’s notion of performance, make “the reasons of the heart one with the reasons of reason.”
|
Is Qumran a Library?
Program Unit: Book History and Biblical Literatures
Ian Werrett, Saint Martin's University
The scholarly attempt to identify the scrolls recovered from Khirbet Qumran as a library is, at first blush, a deceptively simple task. On the one hand, any large collection of literary texts, be they private or public, can rightly be called a "library." On the other hand, the term "library" can also be pressed into service to describe a location, room or building which houses literary texts for reference and reading. In the following discussion, I will consider the Dead Sea Scrolls’ potential status as a library by subjecting the material culture from Qumran to the four criteria that are employed in the fields of Classical Studies, Near Eastern Archaeology and Library Science to identify potential libraries in the Greco-Roman world: (1) the presence of inscriptions identifying an ancient structure as a library; (2) references to libraries in the historical sources; (3) the discovery of books and scrolls at ancient sites; and (4) architectural features matching those of known libraries from the ancient world.
|
Heart Speaks to Heart: Cardinal John Henry Newman and the Exegesis of the Heart
Program Unit: Homiletics and Biblical Studies
Nicholas R. Werse, Baylor University
Cardinal John Henry Newman is remembered as one of the greatest preachers of the 19th century. His influence is unrivaled as he drew enormous crowds to hear his Sunday afternoon sermons at St. Mary’s at Oxford. Yet many historical accounts of his preaching style reveal what may be labeled as serious defects by modern standards. Eye witnesses report him as having little biblical exegesis, reading from a manuscript with his eyes down, speaking quickly in a monotone voice broken up by long pauses and occasionally not even being loud enough to reach everyone in the room. The question raised, therefore, is: What made John Henry Newman such a great preacher? I propose a paper exploring the historically preserved comments of his listeners and textual analysis of his sermons, arguing that one of the chief characteristics that granted Newman such power from the pulpit was not his ability to exegete and exposit a biblical text, but rather his ability to exegete and exposit his audience. Newman’s homiletical exegesis of his audience appears to have taken place on two levels: the general and the particular. Through exploring his audience on a general level Newman was able to link with concerns and experiences of his audience to the broader human experience, which is also observed in the text. By exploring this common level of human experience in both his audience and the text, Newman was able Bible became an exposition of them as well. Newman pushed the practical implications of his general analysis into the realm of the particular by laying claim to his audience as individuals. He did this by working out the application of his homilies in the day to day and often routine experiences and customs of his listeners. It was his artful interweaving of the two levels of audience analysis that ranked Cardinal John Henry Newman as one of the 19th century’s greatest preachers.
|
When Redactional Alterations Disrupt Intertextual Citations
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Nicholas R. Werse, Baylor University
Numerous textual features of the Hebrew Bible complicate the modern identification of intertextual citations and allusions. I propose a paper exploring the ways in which subsequent redactional activity in a text may obfuscate the presence of intertextual citations. This paper will proceed in two steps. First, the paper will explore the preliminary methodological considerations necessary to identify intertextual citations within a redactional model of textual development. Such a model relies upon evidence that a given text has developed over a period of time as subsequent generations of scribes developed and altered an earlier text. Intertextual citations, therefore, may take place on any redactional strata in the history of the text’s development. It follows, therefore, that an earlier redactional layer may contain an intertextual citation that is obfuscated by subsequent redactional activity. The process of identifying intertextual citations within redacted texts, therefore, must first begin with a careful literary critical (Literarkritik) analysis of seams in the final form of the text which would indicate redactional activity. Once the redactional layers are identified, intertextual investigations would then proceed across each redactional layer, not across the final form of the text. The second part of this paper will demonstrate this process using Amos 9:11-15 as a textual example. I will argue for literary critical seems partitioning Amos 9:12a and 13ab-b as later redactional insertions into the text. I will then demonstrate that Amos 9:13ab-b interrupts an earlier intertextual citation found in Amos 9:13aa and 9:14aa of Jeremiah 30:3. To my knowledge, this intertextual citation consisting of a direct quote of ten Hebrew words, has yet to be recognized by commentators and textual investigators.
|
The Selective Use of Pseudophrophetes in Jeremiah LXX
Program Unit: International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies
Nicholas R. Werse, Baylor University
Jeremiah LXX is approximately 1/6 shorter than the Jeremiah MT causing scholars to posit later expansions to the MT textual tradition. In the case of Jeremiah LXX’s use of “pseudoprophetes” (Jer LXX 6:13; 33:7, 8, 11, 16; 34:9; 35:1; 36:1, 8), however, the LXX must be concluded to preserve an interpretive expansion of the Hebrew Vorlage since Biblical Hebrew has no formal equivalent term for identifying false prophets. The challenge emerges in deciphering the purpose of this translational expansion in light of the vast number of instances in which Jeremiah LXX represents a false prophet with the common term “prophetes.” Features such as the proclamation of peace and the characteristic of dealing falsely are common to all of the “pseudoprophetes” passages, yet must be ruled out as the determining factor warranting the translational expansion on account of their appearance elsewhere in the text of Jeremiah without the designation “pseudoprophetes.” Furthermore, the identification of the key characteristic(s) that warranted the LXX use of “pseudoprophetes” instead of the more common “prophetes” is complicated by the disparate genres and settings in which the term is employed. This paper will argue that Jeremiah LXX makes use of the appellative “pseudoprophetes” only to designate false prophets condemned for trivially treating the Babylonian led “destruction” of the Lord’s people which was proclaim by Jeremiah to be divinely commissioned judgment. This one feature sets the “pseudoprophetes” apart from every other denounced “prophetes” in Jeremiah LXX. After briefly situating this study in the broader field of both Jeremian studies and Septuagint studies, this argument will proceed in two parts. First, the textual survey will reveal that trivializing the Babylonian “destruction” of the Lord’s people is the primary accusation against the “pseudoprophetes” in each passage in which the term is used. In the conflict narratives, the message of the “pseudoprophetes” revolves around their trivial response to the Babylonian “destruction” of the Lord’s people. In chapter MT 26 (LXX 33), they react to the proclamation of the 597 BCE deportation as divine judgment and in chapters MT 27-29 (LXX 34-36) they respond to the experience of the forewarned punishment. In each case, the “pseudoprophetes” trivialize Jerusalem’s defeat. This is the link between the conflict narratives and the prophetic oracle of Jer 6:13-15 in which the “pseudoprophetes” are condemned for their response to the “destruction of my people.” In each instance these prophetic voices “treated the destruction of my people with triviality” (6:14), Second, this study will end with an analysis of prophecy in Jeremiah LXX, demonstrating that this unique accusation appears nowhere else in the text, thus enabling this study to conclude that this accusation is the unifying textual feature of the “pseudoprophetes” passages.
|
The Reception of Hebrews’ Doctrine of the High Priesthood of Christ in First Clement
Program Unit: Hebrews
Martin Wessbrandt, Lunds Universitet
The earliest evidence of reception of the epistle to the Hebrews is found in the letter known as 1 Clement. Although 1 Clement does not explicitly refer to Hebrews or its anonymous author, it contains multiple quotations and allusions to the letter, making it apparent that the author of 1 Clement had knowledge of it. The most important point of contact between the two is found in 1 Clem. 36:1-6, in which the author praises Christ, the heavenly high priest, and quotes a number of verses from Hebrews 1.
Famously, Hebrews is the only text in the NT that clearly teaches the doctrine of the high priesthood of Jesus; a fact that alone makes it interesting that this idea is picked up in 1 Clement. Moreover, 1 Clement transforms the doctrine, disconnecting it from Hebrews’ central ideas of Jesus’ priestly self-sacrifice and entrance into the celestial sanctuary, and instead focuses solely upon Christ’s role as mediator between the earthly and the divine. This change in focus has caused some notable scholars, such as Ernst Käsemann and Gerd Theissen, to suggest that 1 Clement did not in fact receive this doctrine from Hebrews but learned of it some other way.
Rejecting their view, I will in this paper turn attention to how the reception of this doctrine from Hebrews is conditioned by the general theology of 1 Clement. My hypothesis is that the author of 1 Clement’s take on matters relating to soteriology, christology and theology proper can help to explain why he would stress some aspects of Hebrews’ teaching on this concept while omitting others. Rather than being interested in biblical theology and the fulfilment of Old Testament promises, a major concern of the author of 1 Clement is how a transcendent and almighty God can communicate with finite beings. Hebrews’ doctrine of the high priesthood of Jesus helps him to answer that question.
|
Between Text and Trauma: Reading the Epilogue of Job with People Living with HIV
Program Unit: Biblical Literature and the Hermeneutics of Trauma
Gerald O. West, University of KwaZulu-Natal
For more than fifteen years the Ujamaa Centre has worked with support groups of people living with HIV. We work within a See-Judge-Act process, analysing our social life from the perspective of the marginalised (See), reflecting on what prophetic/liberatory resources there are in the Bible to engage this social life (Judge), and then planning particular interventions/actions that transform social life. Because our starting point is ‘from below’, we have done our work in the area of HIV and AIDS with those who are HIV-positive, privileging their epistemological perspective. This privilege is extended both to their analysis of their social life and to their apprehensions of the Bible.
In a long a slow process, following the contours of the epidemic, we have worked our way through various gospel texts and have found ourselves journeying with Job. We began our work with Job with Job 1:21, a text every HIV-positive person is familiar with. But we then turned to a less familiar text, Job 3. Reading Job 3 together revitalised the trauma of being HIV-positive and (at that time) the trauma of impending death. Reading Job 3 also validated this trauma, and offered resources for healing. Because of the stigma associated with HIV, validation is a vital element in the process of healing. Drawing on the specific range of trauma theory that has enabled the work of our sister organisations, the Sinomlando Centre for Oral History and Memory Work in Africa and the work of the Institute for Healing of Memories, this paper reflects on our journey with Job, and where we have ended up, having come, finally, to Job 42.
|
Language Learning as Spiritual Formation: Teaching Hebrew in a Seminary Context
Program Unit: Applied Linguistics for Biblical Languages
Travis West, Western Theological Seminary
Eight years ago Tom Boogaart brought a group of students from Western Theological Seminary to Israel to take Randall Buth’s Living Biblical Hebrew course in the hope of learning how to implement the Total Physical Response pedagogy at WTS. After returning and immediately implementing the curriculum, which underwent four straight years of complete revisions (we were “building the plane while flying it”), we finally discovered a curriculum that worked in a seminary context which prioritizes pastoral formation and developing a distinctly Reformed theological identity. Every aspect of the course—from the syllabus, to the grading system, to the textbook, to the assignments, to the in-class experience—has been designed to link language learning with spiritual formation.
The course’s central spiritual practice is internalizing the Word, beginning with the Shema (Deut. 6.4-9). Once learned, grammar instruction utilizes analysis of familiar words/phrases, instead of the traditional method of rote memorization of paradigms in the abstract. Another major feature of the year-long curriculum is an enactment the
students develop and perform of the Binding of Isaac, Genesis 22.1-14, in Hebrew. In this exegetical assignment the students interpret the drama through performance criticism.
Every year this experience opens students’ eyes to the nuances of the Hebrew text and the artistry of the narratives, and changes their relationship with the book they will spend their professional lives teaching and preaching from. Other assignments include praying prayers and singing songs, which become a part of the students’ devotional lives.
In this session Travis West and Tom Boogaart, who together have developed the curriculum along with colleagues and students at WTS, will demonstrate several teaching methods employed in the course—from introducing vocabulary, to drilling verbs, to teaching songs—and discuss the challenges involved in transforming a Hebrew class into a
dynamic formational experience.
|
Compassion and Its Role in Moral Formation: The Interplay between the Narrative of Mark’s Gospel and Contemporary Moral Philosophy
Program Unit: Bible and Emotion
Gerry Wheaton, Seminario ESEPA, Costa Rica
Moral transformation forms a central priority in the Gospel of Mark. While the author reserves the most important teaching about this dimension of discipleship for chapters 8-10, the depiction of Jesus’ life and ministry throughout the early chapters of the Gospel furnishes a crucial foundation for the shape of the moral life he urges upon his disciples in chapters 8-10. Among the most notable aspects of Mark’s depiction of Jesus is compassion. Both explicitly and implicitly, compassion is repeatedly made the basis of Jesus’ engagement with others.
I will argue that the second Gospel foregrounds the compassion of Jesus in this manner because of the crucial role it plays in the morality outlined more expressly in Jesus’ corrective instruction to his disciples in later chapters. I suggest that the cultivation of a compassionate outlook upon others represents an important part of Mark’s conception of moral transformation. Understanding of this dynamic relationship between emotion and morality in the Gospel of Mark may be strengthened, clarified, and refined through reference to several recent philosophical studies on the topic. Drawing particularly on the work of Zygmunt Bauman, Arne Vetlesen, and Martha Nussbaum, I will contend that the robust morality of costly devotion prioritized in Mark’s Gospel does not originate in reasoned judgmement but in emotional participation with the Other. It is only through development of an emotional attitude toward the Other, an outlook that resists the objectification of the Other, that genuine moral action can take root and flourish.
|
She Had It Coming: Violence, Victim Blaming, and Revelation's Great Whore
Program Unit: Feminist Hermeneutics of the Bible
Karri L. Whipple, Drew University
The smoldering and charred remains of the Great Whore receive few sympathetic gazes from Revelation or its later interpreters. Embodying the Roman Empire, Babylon is depicted as deserving the violence committed against her. In short, this Whore had it coming. Yet while the oppression and exploitation of Rome cannot be denied, through the critical lens of victim blaming this paper seeks to critique the method by which and the body upon which John forms and executes his desire for liberation. I hold that the text constructs Babylon as a particularly deserving victim of violent destruction, not only because she represents an oppressive empire but also because she is a queer figure, wholly city and wholly woman, who refuses to comply with the moral and social constructs deemed normative. The work of Judith Butler and Michael Foucault aids this effort, highlighting how Babylon’s queer performativity is dangerous – destabilizing and challenging to the normative through the characters she embodies and the power she wields. Thus, John’s vision and the blame he places on her both voyeuristically illuminates and violently suppresses Babylon’s queer power in an effort to reinforce and re-inscribe normativity within his community.
The imperative to challenge the victim blaming perpetuated by this text and its later interpretations stems from contemporary realities of how victim blaming is used to justify the physical, emotional, spiritual, and sexual assault of queer bodies. This paper will specifically place in dialogue the victim blaming used to justify “corrective rapes” of black lesbians and queer-identified women taking place in South Africa in dialogue with the victim blaming undergirding Revelation 17-19. This dialogue hopes to highlight how threats to society are often placed upon sexualized queer bodies and how the unexamined victim blaming of these figures both in biblical texts and in societies manufacture cycles of violence that help to fuel our present rape culture.
|
Dueling Images: Visual and Verbal Competition in John’s Apocalypse
Program Unit: Rhetoric and Early Christianity
Robyn J. Whitaker, University of Chicago
*FOR THE SUBSECTION: “Rhetorics of Vision and Visual Rhetorics: Ekphrasis and Beyond”
The ancient debate over whether sculptors or poets could best depict the gods was captured by writers as varied as Plutarch, Dio, Lucian, and Philostratus. This debate epitomized a larger contest between word and image, between the verbal and the visual, and between the orator and the craftsman. At the heart of the playful and agonistic interchange between the verbal and visual lies ekphrasis, a rhetorical form that is verbal in medium and visual in effect.
The identification of certain New Testament passages as ekphrasis has burgeoned in recent years. Moving beyond an analysis of ekphrasis as a form, this paper offers examples from the visions of the Apocalypse to argue that John’s appropriation of visual language and use of ekphrasis is both agonistic and pedagogical. John’s condemnation of plastic images as idolatry as well as his polemical parallelism declares the Christ-cult victor over imperial cult. But what attitude toward the visual and verbal does John encourage? An analysis of his use of visual and verbal media indicates an implicit argument that verbal revelation is superior to visual and the visual cannot be trusted.
|
Pushing the Boundaries: Dürer’s Apocalypse Woodcuts as a New Form of (Visual) Commentary
Program Unit: Use, Influence, and Impact of the Bible
Robyn J. Whitaker, University of Chicago
Published in 1498, Albrecht Dürer’s Apocalypse woodcuts are particularly fascinating for the questions they raise about biblical use and reception. Dürer’s artistic credentials are undisputed: he is widely recognized as having established a new woodcut style; he enjoyed fame and imperial patronage; and his images had an enduring effect upon biblical iconography. Dürer as biblical exegete, however, is a more nebulous character. He self-published the Apocalypse taking advantage of the cutting-edge technology of the printing press. In so doing he was free from the constraints of ecclesial authority or patronage. Furthermore, Dürer arranged his fifteen woodcuts as a visual story separated from and preceding the biblical text. His unprecedented arrangement differed from the conventional manuscripts of both medieval and early printed editions of the Bible in which an illustrator supplied the requisite images to accompany the text.
In this paper I argue that Dürer’s great innovation places him in the role of both biblical editor and commentator. As such he pushed the boundaries of both visual exegesis and ecclesial interpretive authority thereby challenging traditional understandings of each. Both aspects of his innovation will be considered when analyzing his impact on biblical interpretation in the context and theological debates of the reformation period.
|
To Submit or Not to Submit: Irenaeus' Text of Gal 2:5 and Its Role in His Portrait of Paul
Program Unit: New Testament Textual Criticism
Benjamin White, Clemson University
This paper explores Irenaeus’ reading of Galatians 1-2 in relation to Acts 15. The chief section is Adv. Haer. 3.12.15-3.13.3, but others are relevant, including those where Irenaeus ties Paul to the author of Acts (Luke, in his view). Irenaeus’ text of the Pauline Epistles tends towards “western” readings and in Gal 2.5 it apparently lacked the crucial ??d?, such that Paul does submit to the Jerusalem apostles. Tertullian and Jerome would later comment that the manuscript evidence for Gal 2.5 was remarkably split here. A number of other interesting textual differences occur in Irenaeus’ narration of Gal 2.12-13. Irenaeus’ manuscript of Galatians, then, provided a much less antagonistic portrayal of Paul and the Jerusalem church, helping him to bring Paul’s epistle together with Acts to portray a significant degree of early apostolic unity. Aside from describing the numerous places where Irenaeus’ Galatians diverges from NA28, the paper points toward a larger problem in Pauline Studies: manuscripts used by modern Pauline scholars as data for the “historical” Paul already participate in a robust second-century debate over whether “Paul alone knew the truth.” The manuscripts are not innocent of the heresiological debate between Irenaeus and Marcion (and others). In addition to textual issues, the paper tracks the portions of Gal 2.1-14 that Irenaeus conveniently forgets (e.g. – Paul’s rebuke of Peter). The paper shows how Irenaeus has been able to forge a unified portrayal of Paul and the Jerusalem church through the citation of a tendentious manuscript tradition, while ignoring those places in the text that are not so helpful. Paul was at the same time “the Apostle” and just one voice in the wider apostolic tradition. Finally, the paper suggests that, like Irenaeus, Paul’s interpreters, whether ancient or modern, only know him through their traditions (combinations of ideology and material texts).
|
Shuffling the Deck: A Re-examination of the Tiers Two and Three in the Ugaritic Pantheon
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
Ellen White, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
Since the publications of Mark S. Smith and Lowell K. Handy, there has been an almost universal understanding of the tiers for the pantheon/ divine council in Ugarit. As compelling as their arguments are several questions still remain regarding tiers two and three. Two of these remaining questions compel an answer. The first is in regards to the highly populated second tier, the 70 great gods. The function and power of these gods vary widely across the tier and yet they are all put together on one. The diverse population is not a challenge for the structural metaphors use by both Smith and Handy, but it is an issue if one is interested in structural function. The second open question is similar in that the representative deity of tier three, Kothar wa-Hasis, is often depicted as having skills that the tier two deities do not. Again, in using metaphor this is not problematic, particularly Smith’s family metaphor. However if one uses a functional understanding it is problematic to have more powerful deities placed on a lower level than less powerful beings. This paper is a reexamination of the structure of these tiers by focusing on the function of the characters. By exploring the roles the various deities fill, one can gain further insight into the structural understanding presented in these texts and the diversity found in the divine realm. The intent is to provide a more detailed framework for understanding the structure and therein add a new avenue of exploration for these texts.
|
Inventing the “Clobber Texts”: Biblical Interpretation and Modern Sexual Identity
Program Unit: LGBTI/Queer Hermeneutics
Heather White, New College of Florida
My paper traces the mechanisms by which a set of familiar “clobber” passages—particularly I Corinthians 6:9 and Romans 1:26-27—shifted meanings over the twentieth century and came to point increasingly to same-sex sexuality. Current debates over the interpretation of these texts tend to bypass the history of interpretation to focus instead on contentious questions of original meaning and modern relevance. My paper, instead, traces the changing meanings of these texts in translations, commentaries, and interpretive references to highlight both the malleable hermeneutics and the changing terms in the text itself. Conservatives and liberals alike, I show, have authorized quintessentially modern views of sexuality as they have also re-authored the Bible itself.
|
Changing Patterns of Access and Use in the Ostia Synagogue: New Evidence from the UT Excavations
Program Unit: Archaeology of Religion in the Roman World
L. Michael White, University of Texas at Austin
Originally excavated from 1961-1964, the Jewish Synagogue at Ostia, port city for ancient Rome, is one of the oldest known Synagogues in the Roman world. Yet since its initial discovery, much has changed at Ostia. Beginning in 2001-02, a team from The University of Texas has conducted a thorough reexamination of the Synagogue complex, including a GIS survey, masonry and architectural studies, new excavations, and extensive analysis of material remains (both previously and newly discovered). Having now completed five seasons of excavation and four seasons of research in the Ostia archives, the UT•OSMAP project offers fresh perspectives on the site-formation and construction techniques in the Synagogue complex and its relation to the burgeoning extra-mural district of the Porta Marina. Two principal results of the work so far reveal evidence for a substantial ground raising project of the mid-2nd cent. CE on which the complex was constructed, and rising pavement levels contiguous to the Via Severiana. Taken together these findings yield a new base chronology and phasing for the Synagogue complex ranging from the 3rd to 6th cent. CE. The main phase of renovation, when the monumental Torah Shrine was added, belongs to the late 5th cent. After a review of this evidence, the present report will examine implications for different patterns of access and spatial use in the four main phases of the history of the complex.
|
The Ironical Man of John 3: Nicodemus, Rhetoric, and Ancient Stock Characters
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Michael Whitenton, Baylor University
Scholarship on the enigmatic Fourth Gospel rages on and shows no signs of abating. The Gospel that thrives upon ambiguity and double meaning has drawn attention from most approaches represented in our field. However, when it comes to the characterization of Nicodemus—a well-worn topic indeed!—a lamentable desideratum is that, even in performance-critical readings, ancient rhetorical theory has gone almost entirely ignored. In an effort to fill this lacuna, I approach the characterization of Nicodemus in John 3 from the vantage point of its oral-aural performative and rhetorical context. By doing so, I hope to shed new light on the perennial problem of the characterization of this (in)famous “leader of the Jews.” The paper will develop in the following manner: I begin by attending to stock characters in ancient drama theory, focusing particularly on Theophrastus’s hostile and disingenuous “ironical man," to which Nicodemus bears striking resemblance. Next, I detail the use of ambiguity and latent meaning (a figure called, "emphasis") in ancient rhetorical theory, which encouraged a person to couch a response to an opponent in ambiguity in order to increase both plausible deniability and the power to convince. Within this context, I will offer a performance-critical reading of John 3:1-15, in which I argue that Nicodemus would have been viewed by informed audience members as a hostile and suspicious character, similar to Theophrastus’s “ironical man,” rather than as a “secret” or “imperfect” believer or seeker. Moreover, the Johannine Jesus’ response suggests that he too understood Nicodemus as duplicitous. However, given the aim of "emphasis" and related figures, there is ample reason to infer that Nicodemus’ later actions suggest that audience members were meant to deduce that Nicodemus was ultimately convinced by the rhetorically savvy response he received by the Johannine Jesus (cf. 7:50-51; 19:39).
|
Designing Hebrews: A Proposal for Its Rhetorical Structure
Program Unit: Hebrews
Jason A. Whitlark, Baylor University
In this study we sketch a new proposal for the arrangement of Hebrews, one that attends closely to ancient rhetorical theory and practice and that has clear implications for the genre and purpose of Hebrews. We begin by briefly surveying the theory of arrangement and its four major components, exordium,narratio, argumentatio, and peroratio. We then argue that analysis of arrangement should begin with argumentatio, since it was the one required component of the speech, and since it had objectively recognizable kinds of materials found nowhere else in the speech.
Both in ancient theory and practice, the argumentatio consisted of proofs enlisted in support of a deliberative, judicial, or epideictic thesis or theses. Our study analyzes the entire speech and identifies not one, but five, sections where enthymeme and example, the two kinds of logical proof prescribed forargumentatio, are employed. These materials are enlisted toward deliberative theses, and are by definition argumentatio. What is initially surprising is their distribution in five sections. It raises the question, does this speech have a five-part argumentatio, and if so, is there a precedent for such a structure in ancient theory and practice?
Further, we identify five intermittent sections of exposition, consisting wholly of epideictic amplification, that are interspersed among these five sections of hortatory argumentation. Exposition was the kind of material normally found in the narratio--particularly epideictic exposition. And indeed, epideictic exposition in the form of amplification was a subtype of narratio prescribed by several theorists and employed in the speeches of Cicero. These materials fit the theoretical descriptions of narratio, and resemble in their content narratio in extant speeches, but seemingly depart from convention in being distributed throughout the speech in five sections. Here again, the question must be asked, is there a precedent for such a structure--a five part narratio distributed among a five argumentatio--in ancient theory and practice?
As it turns out, there is. Virtually every theorist from the time of Aristotle to Anonymous Seguerianus prescribes in the case of complex or lengthy arguments the use of the 'disjointed narratio'--a narratio that is distributed piecemeal throughout the argumentatio, so that individual units of exposition are paired with individual sections of argumentation.
In short, because our analysis of Hebrews does not go in search of a conventional schema of exordium, argumentatio, narratio, and peroratio, but instead begins with certain controls (such as identifying the kinds of specific materials respectively prescribed for argumentatio and narratio), we arrive at a seemingly unconventional--and yet, in actuality, common--manner of arrangement. In five consecutive sections of the body of the speech, narratio in the form of epideictic amplification gives way to argumentatio in the form of deliberative enthymeme and example. Such arrangement, moreover, has important implications for genre and purpose. Deliberative enthymeme and example were only prescribed for deliberative speeches. So, too, the mixture of epideictic and deliberative argumentation. These considerations by themselves strongly suggest Hebrews is primarily a deliberative speech.
|
The Poetry of Acts in Action
Program Unit: Performance Criticism of the Bible and Other Ancient Texts
Matthew G. Whitlock, Seattle University
Acts of the Apostles contains several passages that commentators have categorized as liturgical or poetic. These passages, usually communal prayers or speeches that quote poetry from the Greek bible (LXX), have long been labeled and analyzed under the lenses of source and form criticism. However, rarely do commentators explain what makes these passages liturgical. Few studies consider how they were composed and performed. Using these passages as the content, and John Miles Foley’s work on oral poetry as the framework (Immanent Art and How to Read an Oral Poem), this paper considers how first-century Christian poetry was composed for performance. More specifically, this paper argues that the first-century Christian poetry in the Greek New Testament followed a multilingual poetics, involving grammatical and semantic parallelism, terse sentence structure, formulas, codes, and figurative language from Hebrew poetry (via the Greek bible), and appeals to tradition. These features—or in Foley’s words “keys to performance”—allowed speakers, poets, and communities to compose and perform poems and prayers from a common register and, in some cases, in unison (Acts 4:24). This multilingual poetics produced not only profound and common meaning, but also profound and unique art.
|
The Acts of the Apostles: A Minor Literature
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Matthew G. Whitlock, Seattle University
The concept of a minor literature, coined by theorists Deleuze and Guattari, provides a helpful framework for considering Acts as a political literature. A minor literature, according to Deleuze and Guattari, deterritorializes language, connects immediately to politics, and produces a collective and revolutionary enunciation. This paper considers how Acts functions as a minor literature. Acts assembles a variety of voices, languages, and texts to deterritorialize the language of empire and produce a new collective and revolutionary voice. In particular, this paper focuses on the first characteristic of minor literature: the deterritorialization of language. Whereas the unique language of Acts—namely its semitisms and septuagintalisms—has been analyzed for the sake of identifying forms and sources, rarely has the language been analyzed for its function. This paper accordingly analyzes the function of the semitisms and septuagintalisms in Acts, demonstrating how the Greek of Acts, in Deleuze and Guattari’s words, stutters. Semitic and septuagintal structures are not simply the products of bilingual interference or the sloppy assemblage multilingual sources; rather, they—just as in other minor literatures—are the products of aesthetic and political stuttering, a special genre of multilingualism that recent studies in post-colonial linguistics support. It is through this stuttering that the boundaries of language are challenged, turned upside down, and deterritorialized. While Virgil composed a major literature in a “state language” to support the empire, Luke composed a minor literature as a “foreigner in his own language” to deterritorialize the empire. This paper argues that the language of Acts, not merely the message of Acts, is political. The subtleties of the political message of Acts, in other words, are not just found in what it means, but in how it means.
|
Paul and the Hermeneutics of Law and Love in Rom 13:8–10
Program Unit: Bible and Ethics
Sarah Whittle, Nazarene Theological College (England)
In Rom 13:8-10 Paul cites a series of commandments from Deuteronomy’s Decalogue and claims that they are summed up in the saying “Love your neighbour as yourself” (Lev 19:18). This is in order to demonstrate that the one loving the other has fulfilled the law. Exactly what law is in view and how Paul might understand it to be fulfilled are contested—as indeed is the issue of why that might even matter for Gentiles in Christ. The idea that Lev presents a re-statement of the Ten Words has been noted--going back to Leviticus Rabbah. In addition, the term ‘neighbour’ is a feature of all three representations of the commandments. But Paul’s summarising of the Decalogue by means of Lev 19:18 has no precedent.
While the influence of Jesus Tradition may be present, this paper will propose that the construction has to do with Paul as reader of Scripture—specifically, Deuteronomy. This will be demonstrated by looking at the law through Paul’s rewriting of the covenant renewal text of Deut 30:11-14 in Rom 10:6-8, where obedience to the commandments is transposed to a confession of faith in Christ. Paul’s use of ‘to fulfil’ and ‘to do’ in relation to law suggest that these categories are important and distinct; and three times Paul omits the verb ‘to do’ from the cited text. Moreover, in Paul’s fulfilment language, agape comes from the Spirit. The result of this is not that that the moral demands of the law no longer have a role. Rather, Paul’s reading of Scripture leads to a retrospective declaration of law’s fulfilment for those who by means of the Spirit love the other.
|
The Iberian Author Ahmad b. Qasim al-Hajari (d. after 1642) on Reading the Bible
Program Unit: Qur'an and Biblical Literature
Gerard Wiegers, University of Amsterdam
In his polemical KitÄb nÄá¹£ir al-dÄ«n Ê¿alÄ l-qawm al-kÄfirÄ«n (The Supporter of Religion Against the Infidel) the Morisco Aḥmad b. QÄsim Al-ḤaǧarÄ« devotes consierable space to the fact that he had made an intensive study of the Bible, both the Old Testament (which he had consulted in Arabic an Spanish) and the New Testament texts. In my paper, I will describe the backround of his Biblical studies and argue that they can be related to his upbringing and studies in Christian Spain, his office of translator and secretary at the court of Mulay ZaydÄn, sultan of Marakesh, from about 1608 onwards, and his extensive travels in France, the Netherlands and Egypt, during which he had discussions with important figures he met. Above all, his views are, I argue, related to his experiences in Granada, where he was consulted about the discovery of the so-called Lead Books found on the slopes of the Sacromonte.
|
“God Smiles on Some Projects": Ingenuity and Disingenuity among Life of Brian's Auteurs
Program Unit: Bible and Film
Hans Wiersma, Augsburg College
2014 marks the 35th anniversary of the release of Monty Python's Life of Brian. Since the film's appearance, members of the comedy troupe have provided elucidations and clarifications regarding their creative process. From the initial working title (“Jesus Christ: Lust for Glory”) to later explanations regarding deleted characters and scenes (including scenes featuring “Otto, the Jewish Nazi”), the film-makers have, over the interceding decades, provided a trove of commentary concerning their handiwork.
Perhaps foremost in the public record of Pythonite reflections on Life of Brian are the many attempts to defend the film against charges of blasphemy, heresy, and ridicule of the Christian Lord and Savior. For example, in a widely viewed 1979 appearance on a British late-night talk-show (still viewable on youtube), an Anglican bishop accused Monty Python of making fun of the crucifixion; Python member John Cleese offered that the film is (instead) about “closed systems of thought.”
Elsewhere, however, Monty Python has revealed that, in preparation for the film, troupe members did their homework, including reading up on then-current historical Jesus research. Since then, Biblical scholars such as Philip Davies and James Crossley have noted deep parallels between the varieties of Jesus’s produced by the “Real Jesus” questers and Life of Brian’s depiction of the Not-The-Messiah.
The application of the strategies of “Auteur Theory” to the interpretation of Monty Python’s Life of Brian will prove revealing. Francois Truffaut’s insistence that a deep analysis of “authorial signature” is a legitimate approach to understanding a film’s meaning provides both promise and challenge when considering the ingenuity and, perhaps, disingenuity of the six creative minds that brought Life of Brian into the world.
|
What Is Strangled? The Cultural Resonances of “Strangled” Meat in Acts, the Mishnah, and the Ancient Mediterranean
Program Unit: Social History of Formative Christianity and Judaism
Jonathan P. Wilcoxson, University of Notre Dame
The so-called Jerusalem council first reported in Acts 15:20 proscribes pnikton for all gentile Christ-followers. While the term’s basic meaning, “what is strangled” or “suffocated,” is clear enough, its significance in the decree has presented interpreters with significant difficulty. Quite what it prohibited and why it did so remains a matter of debate. This paper seeks to move beyond the stymied attempt to isolate a single biblical legal basis for the prohibition, suggesting not only that distinct exegetical threads from prophetic material as well as the Torah became interwoven, but also that they should be viewed as part of a larger, variegated and surprisingly rich cultural tapestry. Particularly, attitudes toward animal slaughtering and preparation, reflected not only in m. Hullin and other rabbinic legal material but also a diverse array of other sources, from Philo to late antique Christian homilies and from attic vase paintings to Athenaeus, show that, though “strangled” could be applied variously, negative associations made it a prime tool for social “othering” and the construction of identity. This powerful socio-cultural background spurred quasi-technical uses of pnikton within Greek and Jewish systems of ritual purity. They also provide clues for our understanding of Acts and other Jewish and Christian prohibitions of “what is strangled.”
|
Contemporary Echoes of Early Christian Arabic Approaches to the Qur'an
Program Unit: Qur’anic Studies: Methodology and Hermeneutics (IQSA)
Clare Wilde, University of Auckland
From its revelation to the contemporary period, the Qur'an has been engaged by Christians. While most Christians (and other non-Muslims) who have attempted to study the Qur'an have relied upon translations, Christian Arabs could read, or hear, the Qur'an in the language of its revelation. Nevertheless, early Christian Arabic texts (such as those of Theodore Abu Qurra or a unique manuscript, Sinai Ar. 434) indicate that Christian Arabs were eager to engage not just the text of the Qur'an, but also Muslim interpretations (especially in the realms of theology - kalam - and exegesis - tafsir).
Early Christian Arabic texts have a variety of estimations of the Qur'an. It is variously approached as a Christian heresy; the text of the 'new Jews' (i.e. Muslims); an immoral, misogynistic tome; a burhan (proof) for Christian truths; as well as a corruption (by later Muslims) of the original message given to Mu?ammad. And, early Christian Arabic texts, have, in turn, influenced the approaches to the sacred text of Islam by later generations, both Arabophone and non-Arabic speaking. For example, in medieval Europe, the Latin translation of the Qur'an circulated along with a Latin translation of the polemical Hashimi-Kindi correspondence.
Employing examples from sources as diverse as recent Vatican documents, the Danish Cartoon controversy and three polemical western media productions (Fitna, Obsession and The Innocence of Muslims), this paper explores the extent to which contemporary western approaches to the Qur'an echo or diverge from the understandings of its first Christian Arab auditors. Particular attention is devoted to the extent to which Christian theological concerns can be separated from other elements in these responses to the Qur'an. For example, secular, liberal discourse debates the values of religious tolerance, religious freedom and freedom of speech. Early Arabophone Christians, however, had to reframe Christian triumphal theology, not just in the light of their subjugation to their Muslim overlords - but also in the face of their (re-)equation with 'vanquished' Judaism (as both Christians and Jews were equally 'protected' peoples under Islamic rule). In the light of the vastly different situations of early Arabophone Christians and their contemporary western, secularized counterparts (Christian or other), how might we account for the echoes of early Christian Arabic approaches to the Qur'an in contemporary western discourse on Islam?
|
Holy Fire, Divine Encounter: The Consecration of Space in Two Biblical Narratives
Program Unit: Sacrifice, Cult, and Atonement
Henrietta L. Wiley, Notre Dame of Maryland University
This paper considers biblical representations of Yahweh’s ritual agency through fire, especially in the consecration of sacrificial space in Leviticus 9-10 and 1 Kings 18. How do these stories understand the nature of altar fire, both legitimate and illegitimate? This paper proposes that altar fire is both instrument and index of Yahweh’s active ritual presence as experienced in Israelite cult, emphasizing the deity’s role in consecrating the holy place and legitimizing sacrifice.
|
Were There Marcionites in North Africa? Tertullian’s Rhetorical Construct of Heretical Identity
Program Unit: Inventing Christianity: Apostolic Fathers, Apologists, and Martyrs
David E. Wilhite, Baylor University
Since Tertullian wrote a major work “Against Marcion,” it is plausible to assume that Marcionites resided in North Africa. However, upon closer inspection of the sources, there is no credible evidence that corroborates such a presupposition. In fact, Epiphanius (Pan. 42.1.2) does not list Africa among the provinces where Marcionites can be found, and Optatus of Milevis (1.9) claimed Marcionites were “unknown in Africa” (cf. Augustine, Ep. 118.2.12). With other sources indicating no Marcionite presence in the region, it is worth revisiting Tertullian’s treatise with a view to understand what role “Marcion” (not Marcionites) plays in his works. I will argue that Tertullian’s “Marcion” is a rhetorical construct, used to discredit other opponents as “Marcionites.” By binding all who misread the scriptures to this heretical identity, Tertullian rhetorically draws a boundary around his own group’s orthodox identity.
|
John's Gospel and Jewish Apocalyptic: Some Recent Trends and New Possibilities
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Catrin Williams, Prifysgol Cymru, Y Drindod Dewi Sant - University of Wales, Trinity Saint David
TBA
|
Violent Reconciliation—A Mystery in Ephesians: Jesus' Death as the Provision for Ethno-Racial Reconciliation in Eph 2:16 and the Background
Program Unit: Disputed Paulines
Jarvis J. Williams, Southern Baptist Theological Seminary
Thesis: In this paper, I will argue that Ephesians 2:16 presents violence (i.e. the death of Jesus) as the provision for ethno-racial reconciliation and forgiveness between Jews and Gentiles and that violence as the provision for ethno-racial reconciliation between Jews and Gentiles is part of the mystery of which Ephesians 3 speaks.
Arguments: I will offer four arguments to support this thesis. First, Gentiles were excluded from the ethno-racial promises that God gave to Jews in the Hebrew Bible. Second, God instituted Torah as a dividing wall between Jews and Gentiles to separate them and to keep them from mingling with one another. Third, Jesus' violent death for others destroyed the dividing wall of Torah between Jews and Gentiles. Fourth, Jesus' violent death as the solution to ethno-racial hostility and as the provision for ethno-racial reconciliation echoes the cry of of the seventh son in 2 Maccabees 7:32-38 when he, his brothers, and mother violently died to reconcile God to the nation.
Method: First, I will briefly discuss the controversial issue of ethnicity and race in antiquity to clarify how I will use the phrase ethno-racial throughout the paper. Second, I will discuss the Greco-Roman and Jewish background behind Ephesians 2:16. I will especially discuss Greek, Roman, Jewish, and Christian texts that were contemporary with or that predate Ephesians in order to highlight the ethno-racial hostility between Jews and Gentiles. Third, I will discuss violence, martyrdom, and Torah-observance in early Judaism to highlight that in many early Second Temple Jewish texts, the solution for ethno-racial division between Jews and Gentiles was strict Torah-observance, violence by means of war (1 Maccabees), or martyrdom (2 and 4 Maccabees). Fourth, I will discuss violence as the provision for ethno-racial reconciliation between Jews and Gentiles in Ephesians 2:16. Fifth, I will offer a brief comparative analysis of early Jewish, Roman, and Greek texts and Ephesians 2:16.
Conclusion: The above arguments and method will help support the thesis that Ephesians 2:16 presents violence (i.e. the death of Jesus) as the solution for ethno-racial reconciliation and forgiveness between Jews and Gentiles and that the idea that violence is the provision for ethno-racial reconciliation between Jews and Gentiles is part of the mystery of which Ephesians 3 speaks.
|
Competing African-American Hermeneutics of Liberation: What Hath Martin Luther King, Jr.'s Hermeneutic to Do with James Cone's Hermeneutic?
Program Unit: African-American Biblical Hermeneutics
Jarvis J. Williams, Southern Baptist Theological Seminary
Purpose: In this paper, I will provide a comparative analysis of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.'s hermeneutic of liberation with Dr. James Cone's hermeneutic of liberation with the intent of answering the question which hermeneutic of liberation liberates African-Americans.
Method: My method will be the following. First, I will selectively highlight places in King's speeches and sermons from the New Testament where he employed a hermeneutic of liberation. Second, I will selectively highlight places in Cone's major writings on the New Testament where he employed a hermeneutic of liberation. Third, I will set King and Cone in conversation with each other to see where they either agree or disagree.
Conclusion: The above method will seek to answer the question which one of the two hermeneutics of liberation liberates African-Americans.
|
Dying to Save: Child Sacrifice and Martyrdom in Harry Potter and The Hunger Games
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Jeffrey Williams, Brite Divinity School
This paper explores the theme of child sacrifice in two of the most successful book and film series in contemporary popular culture: Harry Potter and The Hunger Games. Although child sacrifice is essential to the plots of each series, it has received scant attention on the part of scholars of religion, popular culture, or childhood studies. However, critical reflection on children as sacrificial objects in these series can provide a richly textured understanding of the presentation of children in general and of child sacrifice in particular in contemporary popular culture. The paper argues that while both series critique sacrificial systems involving children and recognize children’s agency to respond to unjust and violent systems, the series also reinscribe child sacrifice as a source of social change and transcendent meaning by veiling certain forms of child sacrifice under the cover of voluntary martyrdom.
|
Aspects of Orality and Literacy in the Solomonic Narrative of Chronicles: The Role of Tradition
Program Unit: Orality, Textuality, and the Formation of the Hebrew Bible
Joshua E. Williams, Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary
Chronicles is a written text, yet it originates from a primarily oral culture. It reflects a mindset that lies somewhere upon the continuum between orality and literacy. Scholars examining oral art have argued that one distinction between narrative art that reflects a more oral mindset from one that reflects a more literate mindset is the role of the larger cultural tradition. They argue that oral narrative art functions to provide only references to the larger traditional material, which the audience knows very well. The oral work is not viewed as an independent artifact, but a sampling and retelling of the larger tradition. Chronicles introduces material that requires some background information (for instance, the mention of Pharaoh's daughter in 2 Chr 8:11) since a context for the material is not provided in Chronicles itself. The question arises as to the source of the information: Is it derived from previous texts, such as Samuel-Kings, or from the larger tradition? In order to provide hints for answering the question, this paper will analyze the Solomonic narrative in Chronicles (2 Chronicles 1-9), and where possible the parallels in Samuel-Kings, in order to determine 1) if the passage contains material that requires background information, but such information is not provided from any possible sources of Chronicles, in particular, Samuel-Kings and the Pentateuch and 2) whether or not Chronicles provides contexts for gaps that exist in these same possible sources. The study should result in a better understanding of where this section of Chronicles falls on the spectrum between orality and literacy and provide further clarification for the relationship between Chronicles and Samuel-Kings, as well as other biblical material.
|
“Are You, or Have You Ever Been a Gnostic?” Caricatures, Blacklists, and Understanding the Aspirations and Lives of Real People
Program Unit: Westar Institute
Michael A. Williams, University of Washington
*
|
Water Symbolism in the Book of Isaiah
Program Unit: Book of Isaiah
John T. Willis, Abilene Christian University
In the Book of Isaiah, water plays a major role in communicating numerous religious and spiritual concepts. Citing only a few texts, water is a symbol of: (1) the wicked (57:14-21); (2) Yahweh's power (27:1; 40:12, 15); (3) divine punishment (8:7-8; 28:2, 17; 30:12-14, 19-20); (4) protection from threats(4:5-6; 42:14; 54"9-11); (5) deliverance from enemies (10:24-26; 51:9-11); (6) Yahweh's blessings (30:23-25; 55:1, 10-11); 58:11; (7) Judah's leaders as providers of proper sustenance for the well-being of Yahweh's people (3:1; 32:2); (8) Yahweh's forgiveness (44:22).
|
Prophetic Literature as Metahistorical Discourse: Rethinking the Prophetic Book vis-à-vis Ancient Judean Historiography, with Kingship as a Test Case
Program Unit: Historiography and the Hebrew Bible
Ian Douglas Wilson, University of Alberta
In recent years, historical-critical studies have moved away from understanding prophetic literature as a direct point of access to ancient Israelite prophetic activity and actors, and toward understanding it as a collection of literary artifacts, *books* to be analyzed within their postmonarchic discursive context(s). With this in mind, I want to rethink the sociocultural function of the prophetic book, a uniquely Judean literary phenomenon, in relation to Judean historiography in the postmonarchic era. Since prophetic literature has an express interest in the interrelationship between Israel’s past, present, and future, one may ask: Did Judean literati consider prophetic books to be, in some sense, historiographical or (perhaps better) metahistoriographical? If so, how did they contribute to Judean conceptualizations of history, its emplotment, and Israel’s/Judah’s place within it?
In this paper, I plan to explore some of the issues related to these questions. In particular, I will take a look at the problematic issue of kingship in ancient Israel, and how prophetic literature takes part in the process of remembering this political institution. The prophetic book, I argue, served as an outlet for the obvious tensions in Judah’s social memory of its monarchic past. During the postmonarchic era, primarily within the confines of the late Persian period, the prophetic book became “good to think with” for the Judean literati. It gave them a means to explore sociopolitical realia under Persian imperial rule, in terms of their diverse memories of kingship past and idealistic images of kingship future. This, in turn, fueled the ongoing (re)formulation of Judean identity in a postmonarchic, imperialized world. My paper will thus make a contribution to our understandings of ideological and sociocultural history in ancient Israel, specifically in its postmonarchic era, and to our knowledge of prophetic literature and its (meta)historiographical dimension.
|
The Female Rite of Wearing a Veil in 1 Cor 11:2–13
Program Unit: Latter-day Saints and the Bible
Lynne Hilton Wilson, LDS Stanford Institute
Among the rites of investiture in early Christianity is the predominantly female rite of wearing a veil. The Apostle Paul's theological explanation for female veil wearing (1 Corinthians 11:2–13), highlights the woman’s veil as an expression of female empowerment or “authority/exousia.” It appears that the Corinthian saints struggled with this “paradoseis/ ordinance/tradition” (KJV, NIV, 1Cor11:2) because when Paul wanted to correct a misconception whenever he said, “but I would/ thelõ de” (1Cor 11:3; 7:32; 10:20; 14:5; 1Thes 4:13; etc.).
Rather than merely restating the dress code on veiling, Paul laid out the doctrinal background underlying the imagery. He began with the order of creation from the Garden of Eden. God was the "kephale" meaning source or origin of Christ, who was the source of man, who was the source of woman. Paul taught that God’s glory (referring to man) should pray unveiled; and by the same token, humanity’s glory (referring to woman) should commune with God veiled (1Cor 11:7).
The early church interpreted the relationship between Adam and Eve typologically. The Edenic couple typified Christ and his Church—the Bridegroom and Bride. In this typological scenario, Eve (or the Church) worked through the mediator Adam (or Christ). In either a symbolic or literal interpretation, Paul described this empowering veil as a sign of unique female authority to pray and prophecy (1Cor 11:5). By wearing the veil or “power on her head” female saints could interacted with angels (1Cor 11:10).
Paul concluded by emphasizing that men and women are completely interdependent—woman was created from man, while man is born of woman (1Cor 11:11-12). In this regard we see an equal status between men and women in their relationship with the Lord. Their relationship focuses on their union with each other and God.
|
What Makes a Man? The Construction of Biblical Masculinity in Contrast to Boyhood
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Stephen M. Wilson, Duke University
Recent years have seen a marked increase in scholarly attention to the depiction of masculinity in the Hebrew Bible. One of the most common assumptions in biblical masculinity studies is that manhood is a cultural performance, and the unifying feature of that performance is the avoidance of feminization. In short, to be a man in the Hebrew Bible means not to be a woman.
My paper challenges this claim, and instead demonstrates that biblical masculinity is constructed primarily in opposition to boyhood. My argument begins with a review of anthropological literature on masculinity and maturation rites as well as psychological research on gender development in boys, both of which support the claim that manhood is primarily displayed through differentiation with boyhood. Applying this insight to the Hebrew Bible reveals that the general avoidance of the society of women on the part of many adult male biblical characters is not a result of the fear of feminization—as has often been argued by scholars. Rather, this avoidance derives from a fear of infantilization, since one of the typical features of the biblical depiction of children is their close association with women.
My case for viewing biblical masculinity as something defined vis-à-vis boyhood then turns from the theoretical to the specific by examining concrete examples from the Hebrew Bible. The first kind of evidence I treat relates to shaming acts and words designed to emasculate an individual man in the Hebrew Bible, such as Isa 7:20, Judg 6:17, and 1 Sam 26:15. I demonstrate that these actions achieve their desired result by infantilizing the object of derision. Second, I discuss the narrative of Gideon’s son Jether in Judg 8. This tale of a boy’s trepidation at performing a characteristically manly deed—i.e., taking an enemy’s life—shows clearly that the key to manhood and performing masculinity in the Hebrew Bible is demonstrating that one has transitioned out of childhood.
The paper concludes by emphasizing the need in biblical masculinity studies for further research on the differences between manhood and boyhood—and on how a boy becomes a man—because it is in the proof of maturation that masculinity is performed and displayed in the Hebrew Bible.
|
Love Conquers All: Song of Song 8:6b–8:7a as a Reflex of the Northwest Semitic Combat Myth
Program Unit: Ugaritic Studies and Northwest Semitic Epigraphy
Aren M. Wilson-Wright, University of Texas at Austin
The Song of Songs does not explicitly refer to the god of Israel under the name Yahweh or any other epithet. The noun šalhebetyâ in Song 8:6 may contain a shortened form of the tetragrammaton, but scholars debate the interpretation of this difficult term. In this paper, I go beyond šalhebetyâ to suggest that Yahweh is present in the Song in the form of love. Drawing on Calvert Watkins’ work on inherited formulae, I argue that Song 8:6b-8:7a utilizes language and imagery from the Northwest Semitic combat myth to identify love with Yahweh as the victorious divine warrior. As part of this argument, I identify four inherited formulae in the Hebrew Bible, the Baal Cycle, and later Christian and Jewish literature: ‘Leviathan, the fleeing serpent, the twisting serpent’, ‘rebuke Sea’, ‘prince of the Sea’ and ‘strong as death’. Within the Song, the phrase “strong as Death” connects this passage with the Ba‘al Cycle, while the references to mayim rabbîm and neharôt evoke scenes of mythic combat from the rest of the Hebrew Bible. By way of conclusion, I demonstrate the importance of this reading for interpreting the adjuration refrain in Song 2:7; 3:5; and 8:4 and the phrase ‘sick with love’ in Song 2:5; and 5:8.
|
Chanting down the New Jerusalem: Performing Revelation Calypso Style
Program Unit: Bible Translation
Marlon Winedt, United Bible Societies
This paper as part of the Bible Translation and Nida Institute symposium on Translating for Performance and Performing for Translation will address theoretical and practical considerations in performing a passage from the Book of Revelation for a specific modern audience. The paper will focus on a notion of Caribbean identity as linked to orality and the place of Scripture use within the Caribbean basin. Particularly a link will be made between a concept of Creolité, - as introduced by Edouard Glissant - and orality as hermeneutical lens through which Scripture can be presented as performance in the contemporary regional heteroglossic setting. Specifically, attention will be given to the interplay between the New Jerusalem (chapter 21) as contrasted to the destruction and doom of Babylon (18); thus respectively a contrast will be presented between solidarity and community on the one hand, and oppression and fragmentation on the other hand within the Caribbean reality.
|
Stolen Vineyards, Failed Messengers, and Corrupt Leaders: Considering the Literary Relationship between Mark’s Parable of the Wicked Tenants and 2 Kgs 9:14–26
Program Unit: Markan Literary Sources
Adam Winn, Azusa Pacific University
The relationship between Mark 12:1-12 and Isaiah’s vineyard song has long been recognized by Markan interpreters. Yet, few interpreters have noticed the striking details that are shared between Mark’s parable of the wicked tenants and the account of Jehu’s rebellion in 2 Kings 9. These details include messengers who are sent but do not return, the killing of a significant messenger, the removal of Israel’s corrupt leadership, and restoration of a vineyard to its owner. In this paper, I will argue that Mark’s parable of the wicked tenant includes a creative imitation of 2 Kings 9:14-26.
|
Paul and Roman Law: The Luck of the Draw
Program Unit: Book of Acts
Bruce W. Winter, Macquarie University
However great the Roman Law was in deem to be with its protocol, Acts shows that there could be a major discrepancy between protocol and politics by those administered. Examining court cases at Philippi, Thessalonica, Corinth and Caesarea Maritima demonstrates the lack of consistency in the courts in the Roman East but Luke concludes by stressing there was de facto no legal impediment in Roman Legal proceedings cited in Acts to being a Christian.
|
Paul’s Ethics and Paul’s Experience: Law and Love in Galatians
Program Unit: Bible and Ethics
Sean F. Winter, University of Divinity, Melbourne
Paul’s assertion in Gal 5.14 that love of neighbour is the fulfilment of the law is rightly explored in relation to his subsequent proposal that mutual bearing of burdens ‘fulfils the law of Christ’ (Gal 6.2). This paper explores the relationship between law and love in Galatians, taking into account statements in Paul’s other letters (Rom 13.8–10; 1 Cor 9.21) as well as Jewish and Greco-Roman evidence for the collocation of the terms. I argue that law, love, and their implied relationship are, for Paul, recast under the pressure of Paul’s christology, but also in the light of Paul’s own experience. Scholarship on Paul’s ethics has not given sufficient attention to the ways in which Paul’s account of his own experience of Christ’s love and his consequent re-negotiation of relationship to law affect his ethical instruction to the Galatians. In particular, I shall propose that Paul’s language in Gal 2.20–21 (‘death to the law’; ‘living by Christ’s faithfulness’; Christ’s self-giving love) provides a strong basis for Paul’s later statements about law and love in the letter and illuminates the possible connotations of the phrase ‘the law of Christ’.
|
Global Hebrew Learning: Gathering Evidence for Persuasive Facilitation
Program Unit: Global Education and Research Technology
Nicolai Winther-Nielsen, Fjellhaug International University College Denmark
The European Union project EuroPLOT (http://www.eplot.eu/home) from 2010 to 2013 developed a persuasive learning technology, which supports learning of Biblical Hebrew from a corpus of the Hebrew Bible (http://bh.3bmoodle.dk/). The project developed the Windows PC software PLOTLearner in order improve learning for students in a global setting without reliable and affordable internet connections. For the West, there is now a platform independent online solution, the Bible Online Learner (http://bibleol.3bmoodle.dk/).
Our vision is that Hebrew teachers use this technology for their Hebrew classes. The new learning technology offers an interactive display of the grammar and glosses of the Hebrew text, and generates grammar and translation exercises automatically. Teachers have access to full statistics on learning progress for exams, and they can monitor each learner’s progress on a daily, weekly or regular basis. Based on accuracy and speed as well as details on mistakes, the technology offers feedback for each individual, and learner can improve on performance or ask for facilitation of how to improve exercises on grammar, vocabulary, and translation.
Thanks to our European Union funding and the German Bible Society, we can offer this open source technology for free in Asia, Africa, and South America, where interest in Biblical languages is high, but teaching material, instruction and training is scarce, and cutting-edge pedagogical technology for training of language skills otherwise non-existent. However, even free and advanced software does not distribute automatically. Prestigious universities and prominent teachers must promote the system, before the global teaching community will discover the technology.
The paper will report on our strategy to improve the technology for fellow teachers. In the Spring of 2014 both of us have been involved in supervising online learners using the technology at Malaysia Baptist Theological Seminary. We explore the needs for support and what material is available online as free download, focusing on an Asian setting, and its usefulness for Chinese learners. In the Autumn of 2014 a teaching assistant will gather data on 500 learners in the Lutheran Church in Madagascar, using the system in an entire undergraduate and graduate education. Also in the Autumn, we will implement the technology in an 80 hours Hebrew blended learning course at the Fjellhaug International University College in Copenhagen. Our goal is to explore the use of persuasive feedback, when monitoring student performance, and to enhance persuasive ability and motivation through exercises, teaching material and virtual environments.
Our primary goal is to develop a new teacher course based on our empirical data. We will also join projects aiming at further developing our statistical module for self-adaptive individual learning, and we want to develop modules for gamification, collaboration and visualization of big data. We will continue cooperation with the Eep Talstra Centre for Bible and Computer and use their leading corpus of the Hebrew Bible for developing the next generation of recommender technology with enhanced support for persuasive learning.
|
On the Way to Hierocracy: The High Priest in the Books of Haggai and Zechariah
Program Unit: Book of the Twelve Prophets
Jakob Wöhrle, Carl von Ossietzky Universität Oldenburg
The books of Haggai and Zechariah are important documents of the early postexilic time. Investigating the redaction history of these two books gives insights into political, social and cultic developments of this time. The paper will focus upon the political concepts and especially upon the political role of the high priest on different redactional levels of the books of Haggai and Zechariah. It will show that the circles behind these books, at first, opted for the restoration of the Davidic kingdom and thus for the sovereign leadership of a secular ruler. Then, however, they preferred a diarchic political concept with a rather weak secular ruler and a priestly ruler at his side. In later times, they even promoted a hierocratic concept with hereditary leadership of the high priest. The paper will explain the concrete depiction of these different political concepts within the books of Haggai and Zechariah as well as the historical and social occurrences, which finally led to the earliest formulation of a hierocratic concept in Israel.
|
Rabbinic Practices of (Bible) Reading: Unlinking the Written and the Oral
Program Unit: The Bible in Ancient (and Modern) Media
Rebecca Scharbach Wollenberg, Oberlin College
Contemporary scholarship often treats allusions to ‘reading’ the Bible in classical rabbinic traditions as evidence that late antique and early medieval rabbinic culture valorized the written word as a source of religious knowledge and authority. This argument assumes, of course, that the rabbinic terminology which contemporary scholars typically translate as ‘reading’ the Bible (that is, ?????) refers to a practice of literacy roughly equivalent to our own, in which meaning (and thus new information) is derived from written signs by those who decipher them. And yet, this vision of rabbinic textuality is belied by a careful survey of tannaitic and amoraic descriptions of classical rabbinic modes of engaging with the written text of the Hebrew Bible. For while late antique and early medieval rabbinic authorities were aware that some of their contemporaries decoded unfamiliar written text for information, they themselves rejected this mode of engaging with written text as an alien—and even illicit—behavior embraced primarily by gentiles and heretics. Indeed, reading as we know it is not even given a name in classical rabbinic literature—but is referred to instead by means of a series of varied and ad hoc descriptions of the physical acts associated with literacy (such ‘gazing at a book’).
Meanwhile, the classical rabbinic terminology which we so often translate as (Bible) ‘reading’ refers to a very different mode of engaging with written signs. The rabbinic term ????? (kri’ah) designates the practice of reciting a precise oral formula from memory—with or (more often) without reference to a physical text. This vocalized biblical formula might be recited in conjunction with the written consonantal text (in ritual performances, for instance) but it was not derived from it. Thus, the sanctioned rabbinic mode of engaging with written text did not pull meaning from written words but rather brought memorized words into a temporary (and often uneasy) relationship with a set of written signs. Far from elevating the written text of the Hebrew Bible to a uniquely authoritative status, the rabbinic mode of engaging with written text threatened to render the consonantal transcript of the Hebrew Bible a secondary, and even superfluous, witness to the Sinaitic revelation and allowed a community that was increasingly uncomfortable with their written record of revelation to marginalize this written record in favor of a more culturally appealing iteration of the biblical revelation: a memorized oral Bible.
|
Does Hebrew ha’eben haro’šah (Zech 4:8) Have Anything to Do with Akkadian libittu mah?
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Al Wolters, Redeemer University College
The enigmatic expression ha’eben haro’šah in Zech 4:8 has been explained in
many different ways. Since the work of Petitjean (1969) it has been widely assumed that it should be understood in the light of the Akkadian expression libittu mah?ritu, “first (former) brick,” which is found in two inscriptions having to
do with the rebuilding of temples in Mesopotamia, and which is said to refer to a brick ritually removed from the old temple which is subsequently included in the foundation of the new one. Among the scholars who have adopted Petitjean’s proposal are Lipinski (1970), Petersen (1974), Halpern (1978), Carol and Eric Meyers (1987), Laato (1994, 2010), Wolters (2000), Boda (2004), VanderKam (2004), Willi-Plein (2007), Fried (2010). However, even if we do not go so far as to suggest that the supposed libittu mah?ritu ritual was actually part of an “invented
tradition” (so Dalley), there are decisive arguments against the view that it provides the key to understanding the biblical expression.
First of all, it should be noted that libittu does not mean “stone” (though biblical scholars have often translated it that way), but rather “brick,” specifically a sundried brick, as distinct from a kiln-fired brick (agurru). This is significant, because these sun-dried bricks, “[u]nlike stones or baked brick...cannot be salvaged from
old buildings” (Ellis). The view that it was a brick retrieved from the old temple therefore cannot be maintained.
Secondly, the key passage to which scholars refer for the view that the libittu mah?ritu represents a brick from the old temple which is included in the foundation has been misinterpreted. It is found in a Hellenistic inscription from Warka, describing a ritual to be performed by the kalû or lamentation priest at the refounding of temples, where we read that the builder (in Ellis’s translation) was
to “remove the first brick and put it in a restricted place.” The verb translated “remove” is idikku, from dekû, and should here be translated “lifted,” referring to the lifting of the brick from a brick-mold, not from the ruins of the old temple. The
reference is to the fresh brick ceremonially prepared by the king at the refoundation of a temple, a well-known aspect of Mesopotamian religion.
In addition, the Warka text describes a ritual in which the “first brick” is set apart for separate worship as the new temple is being built. There is nothing corresponding to this in the Zechariah text mentioning ha’eben haro’šah. The likelihood therefore is that Zechariah’s “stone” has nothing to do with the Mesopotamian “brick.” Instead, it should probably be read as ha’eben haro’š (with the anomalous final he to be attached as the article with the following te?šu’ot), and refers to the “primary stone(work)” represented by the foundation wall of Solomon’s temple, on which Zerubbabel’s temple was to be built (so Galling).
|
“Babes in Christ”: The Vulnerability of Infancy
Program Unit: Children in the Biblical World
Carla Swafford Works, Wesley Theological Seminary
It has long been noted that the infancy metaphor in 1 Cor 3:1-2 appeals to the Corinthians’ lack of maturity. They are acting “childish” by bickering with one another and by boasting in their perceived wisdom. It is undeniable that the Corinthians need to act more mature. Along with the necessity of cognitive development—to display the “mind of Christ” (2:16)—Paul is calling for behavior that is not foolish. The image of suckling children, however, is multi-faceted. This paper highlights another facet of the infancy metaphor: vulnerability. The metaphor not only connotes a lack of maturity, but the image also conveys the Corinthians’ state of vulnerability and even peril if they continue in such stunted growth. The need for maturity is urgent. The normal timeframe for “babes” to grow up is a luxury that the Corinthians do not possess. The “Day” is coming (3:13-15). This world is passing away (7:31). Yet, the Corinthians are still living as those in the “flesh.” There are risks involved in continuing to live as infants. To demonstrate the vulnerability inherent in the metaphor of infants, the essay considers evidence from the ancient world—particularly the needs of childcare and the reality of high infant mortality rates, the use of the metaphor by other ancient writers, and the eschatological language that surrounds Paul’s use of the metaphor in 1 Corinthians.
|
Populist Features in the Gospel of Matthew
Program Unit: Ideological Criticism
Bruce Worthington, University of Toronto
With the breakdown of the modern western state apparatus, and the subsequent universality of global capital, we are witnessing a sharp increase in North American and Western European populism, perhaps best seen in the dialectic between Occupy Wall Street supporters, and Tea Party adherents in the United States (these are two sides of the same coin). The phenomenon of populism is hardly new; rather it indicates a breakdown in the state apparatus, a breakdown that is necessary for political change (early examples include the "populares" of the second Roman Imperial Triumvirate, 43-33 BCE). The phenomenon of populism indicates a popular contestation of authority on behalf of the "people" against the "elites", elites who are often perceived as depriving the popular majority of certain rights, privileges, identity, and political voice.
Relying specifically on the philosophical approach of Ernesto Laclau and his work "On Populist Reason", this paper charts the manner in which crowds function as an emerging political actor in the Gospel of Matthew, particularly as contested space between the authority of Jesus and the failed Temple authorities. The common Matthean depiction of the crowds as fickle: sometimes following Jesus (Matt. 4:25; 8:1; 9:8; 9:33) and sometimes in opposition (Matthew 27:45), can be responsibly compared to other depictions of populism in the ancient world (The Gracchi Brothers, Gaius Marius, Sulla, Publius Clodius Pulcher etc.), and indicates the contested support of people(s) living in the wake of a significant political breakdown. Thus, Matthew’s depiction of the crowds as “sheep without a shepherd” is consistent with a populist notion that sees elites (Temple authorities) as depriving the people of identity, prosperity, and some degree of political sovereignty. In the end, the Gospel of Matthew illuminates both the success and danger of populist approaches: their ability to be swayed by free bread, and their eschewal of due process in favour of a hasty political choice—let his blood be on our heads!
|
Land Entry and Possession in Origen's Homilies on Joshua: Deep Reading for Christian Life
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
Lissa M. Wray Beal, Providence University College
Land Entry and Possession in Origen's Homilies on Joshua: Deep Reading for Christian Life
|
The King on the Cross: Irony and Hidden Transcripts in John’s Crucifixion Account
Program Unit: Jesus Traditions, Gospels, and Negotiating the Roman Imperial World
Arthur M. Wright, Baptist Theological Seminary at Richmond
This paper will argue that the Fourth Gospel presents the crucifixion of Jesus (John 19:16b-37) in such a manner that ironizes the Roman imperial meaning of the cross. Irony is employed throughout the Gospel, and I will argue that in this scene we see the evangelist employing it as a strategy for negotiating life in the empire.
I will briefly sketch the significance of Roman crucifixion, which extended far beyond a torturous means of execution. Crucifixion shamed and humiliated the victim, stripping them of dignity as it killed them. Symbolically, it annihilated the victim, expressing the empire’s ability to deal in ultimate terms with threats to Roman hegemony. Furthermore, it served as a deterrent to other would-be dissidents and trumpeted Roman domination and imperial power, reminding all provincials of their subject status.
My paper will include brief definition and description of irony and a brief discussion of James C. Scott’s model of hidden transcripts. Scott’s model will help me to make my argument that irony is a strategy of imperial resistance, even though it is not overt or violent opposition.
I will then move into a discussion of how the Fourth Gospel contests and ironizes the imperial meaning of Jesus’ death on the cross. The Johannine crucifixion account presents Jesus ironically as king, his crucifixion (his “lifting up”) as the means by which he draws all people to himself, and the cross as the place where he establishes a new family of God. The inscription on the cross functions not as a warning, but rather as a worldwide proclamation of Jesus’ sovereignty. Furthermore, with his death, Jesus completes the work that the Father has given to him to do. As the sole master of his life and death, he lays down his life willingly. In spite of the violence inflicted by the agents of Rome, Jesus’ death proves life–giving and leads others to belief. The imperial meaning of the cross is subverted, disrupting public transcripts of Roman sovereignty and domination. The two opposed meanings of the cross—the imperial one and the ironic Johannine one—coexist within the narrative: Jesus’ death is an experience of shame, humiliation, and defeat, yet it is also his moment of enthronement, glorification and supreme triumph. If I have time, I will briefly point to how Jesus’ burial reaffirms these claims.
Finally, I will explain how the Fourth Gospel mimics aspects of Roman imperial power even as it ironizes the meaning of the crucifixion. For example, in the presentation of the cross as Jesus’ return to God, Jesus imitates the apotheosis of Roman emperors as he is “lifted up” to heaven. John presents Jesus’ sovereignty in contrast to the emperor’s, and God’s power as an alternative to Rome’s. Finally, the Gospel envisions an empire of God that extends across the entire world. Thus, the Gospel does not merely contest imperial power but adopts the language of empire in order to overpower Rome.
|
Glyptics during Israelite Emergence: Continuity and Discontinuity
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Laura Wright, Johns Hopkins University
In the period that corresponds to Israelite emergence during the LB IIB/Iron I transition, a common narrative of discontinuity has been told in the southern Levant. Israel’s rise is often correlated to changes in settlement patterns in the hill country during the Iron I, and radical discontinuity in the southern coastal plain is attributed to Philistine arrival. However, a complex story of continuity across this transition has emerged in the ceramic corpus wherein Late Bronze Age traditions are shown to persist into the Iron I. Unfortunately, the glyptic traditions have not yielded a similarly complex story. Instead, a story of discontinuity has been told in which new glyptic forms emerge in the LB IIB/Iron I transition, depicting a distinct, local tradition. This paper will examine these local traditions and show how continuity does exist across this transition. In order to demonstrate this continuity, scarabs of the LB IIB will be examined alongside stamp seals.
|
Apocalyptic as Sudden Fulfilment of Divine Promise
Program Unit:
N.T. Wright, University of St. Andrews
*
|
Bible Translations as a Knowledge Base for Data-Mining
Program Unit: Global Education and Research Technology
Andi Wu, Global Bible Initiative
When translating the Bible, the translators produce particular renderings of the knowledge embodied in the original Hebrew and Greek texts, thus subconsciously creating a knowledge base which provides a valuable resource for data-mining. In this presentation, I will demonstrate how this knowledge base can be used to tap into the brains of those translators and acquire lexical knowledge of the Bible.
In order to use translations to obtain knowledge of the source texts, each of the translation texts must be aligned to the original texts to establish links between the original words and translation words. In Global Bible Initiative (formerly Asia Bible Society), we aligned a number of English, Chinese and Japanese translations by automatic alignment followed by manual checking. Once the alignment data is available, many interesting discoveries can be made. I will discuss two projects where we acquired valuable lexical knowledge through data-mining.
In the first project, we automatically created a probabilistic synonym database by calculating the semantic spaces of words and their overlaps, where the semantic space of each Hebrew and Greek words is filled by the translations of this word. If two words are synonyms, their semantic spaces will overlap. The size of overlap determines the degree of synonymy between these two words.
In the second project, we automatically created a senses database by clustering the translations of different versions. Given two instances of the same word, if most translations use the same word to translate them, they probably have the same sense. Inversely, if most translations use different words to translate them, they probably have different senses.
The knowledge acquired by data-mining is not perfect yet, but it has already proved useful in computer applications. It can also serve as a good basis for lexical research by scholars.
|
Archaeology and the Literary Purposes of 1 Sam 13:19–22
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible, History, and Archaeology
Jonathon Wylie, University of Wisconsin-Madison
1 Sam 13:19-22 indicates that the Philistines banned metallurgical activity in Israel in order to prevent the Israelites from making metal weapons. The text makes three explicit claims: (1) that there was no smith in Israel during the time of Saul; (2) that there was neither sword nor spear in Israel except those owned by Saul and Jonathan; and (3) that the Philistines charged a PYM for certain metallurgical services. I evaluate these claims by bringing them into dialogue with the archaeological record and show that the text’s assertion of a historic Philistine monopoly on metallurgy is highly exaggerated. I suggest, therefore, that the significance of 1 Sam 13:19-22 is not primarily archaeological but literary. While 1 Sam 13:5 depicts the Philistines as more numerous than the Israelites, and 13:17-18 portrays them as fearsome, 13:19-22 presents them as unjust oppressors. All this combines into an image of the Philistines as unfairly advantaged against the Israelites. As the biblical account of the battle of Michmash proceeds, we find that 1 Sam 13:19-22 anticipates 1 Sam 14:20b, where we read that the great confusion inflicted by Yahweh and Jonathan caused every man’s sword to be against his fellow. Since 1 Sam 13:19 claims that the Israelite army had no swords, we are led to interpret 1 Sam 14:20b as meaning that every Philistine’s sword was against his fellow. Thus, 1 Sam 13:19-22 develops an image of the Philistines as fearsome and oppressive, while setting them up to look preposterous in the following chapter.
|
The Natural World and Time in Ancient Jewish Apocalyptic Literature
Program Unit: Wisdom and Apocalypticism
Jackie Wyse-Rhodes, Emory University
In 1 Enoch 80, near the end of The Book of the Luminaries, “the days of the sinners” are characterized by changes in the natural order. The years grow shorter; seeds sprout late; rain is withheld; the sky stands still; fruit appears late, if at all; the moon changes the order of its appearance; the heads of the stars stray from God’s command. This depiction of the natural world as out-of-sync with the passage of time and seasons is at odds with other apocalyptic portrayals of nature as inherently orderly and reliable (cf. 1 Enoch 2-5). Book two of the Sibylline Oracles and 4 Ezra 5 narrate natural disasters in a similar vein. In 4 Ezra 7:39-44, at the day of judgment, the sun, moon, stars, clouds, lightning, wind, water, and air will not exist any longer; in this case, the end of time may also mean the end of the natural world. In such apocalyptic texts, the natural world is linked with time as well as space. Whether acting in its expected orderly manner, or serving as a disorderly sign of impending judgment, nature is presented not just as a collection of things, but also as a series of processes whose functionality can serve as a barometer for the well-being of the cosmos as a whole, including that of humanity in the coming final judgment. In fact, in 1 Enoch 100, angels, heavenly bodies, and meteorological elements are portrayed as God’s informants regarding humankind, and elements of the natural world are depicted as God's instruments for exercising judgment. This paper will explore how the natural world functions as a way of "telling time" in ancient Jewish apocalyptic literature, especially in 1 Enoch: in the past, the natural order swore an oath to keep the cosmos intact (1 Enoch 69); in the present, the natural world's orderly behavior makes it a model for erring humankind (1 Enoch 2-5); in the future, nature will participate in the final judgment (1 Enoch 100). In the meantime, the natural world is also shown to be a major subject of the secret knowledge revealed to Enoch during his heavenly journeys – knowledge which he is ultimately instructed to disseminate among those who dwell upon the earth.
|
Rethinking Paul’s Sexual Ethics within the Context of HIV/AIDS: A Postcolonial Afro-Feminist-Womanist Perspective
Program Unit: African Biblical Hermeneutics
Alice Yafeh-Deigh, Azusa Pacific University
This paper uses a postcolonial afro-feminist-womanist hermeneutical lens to explore ways in which1 Corinthians 7, the paradigmatic and most extended discourse on Christian marriage, sex, and sexual ethics, could serve as a theological and hermeneutical starting point for thinking about the global HIV/AIDS pandemic, women's susceptibility to it, and issues surrounding women’s struggle for health and well-being. Taken at “face value,” Paul’s assertions that spouses have shared ownership of each other’s body, that spouses should maintain an active sex life, that the only exception to refraining from sex within marriage is for the purpose of prayer, that the decision to refrain from sex must be agreed to mutually, and that spouses could refrain from sex only temporarily (cf.1 Cor 7:4-5), are intrinsically problematic, if not outright dangerous for women in their fight against HIV/AIDS. This is because, within the context of HIV/AIDS epidemic, Paul's hermeneutics of shared ownership of the spouse’s body denies Christian women unilateral decision-making power over sexual health decisions. However, this paper argues, the exception (1 Cor 7:5) carved out to allow spouses to refrain from sex for the purpose of prayer, though not empowering women to act unilaterally without the consent of the male spouse, could open up new avenues for thinking about the complex realities that surround HIV/AIDS and allow for new possibilities for contextualized exceptions that are emancipating sexually, socially, economically, morally, and spiritually.
|
Vision and Re-envision: Re-tracing the Social Justice Relationship between Hannah and Mary’s Songs
Program Unit: Intertextuality in the New Testament
Alice Yafeh, Azusa Pacific University
In Samuel studies, the Song of Hannah (2:1-10) is often characterized rather flatly, as a unit that, in one direction, closes the Hannah narrative, and in another, moves to create hopeful anticipation for a coming king (v. 10). Intertextually, it is regularly related to Mary’s Magnificat (Luke 1:46-55) on the basis of reversal themes, given that both songs highlight the overturning of expected norms. As in Hannah’s personal narrative, in Jesus God overturns a variety of status quo realities to usher in a unique “kingdom.”
The duo of papers proposed here examine both songs more closely to uncover the specific nature of the points of contact between them. The paper(s’) aims is to reveal that Hannah’s Song is a more intricate literary work than is usually thought. We learn first, that it is governed by chiastic structures meant to establish the divine agenda as explicitly social in nature. Moreover, Hannah’s Song creates anticipation and expectation for a promise via its shift to the future imperfect tense (vv. 9-10). Because the first pair of Israelite kings (Saul and David) fail so spectacularly as justice-making monarchs, the anticipation of the Song persists beyond the immediate narrative of 1 & 2 Samuel.
The Magnificat picks up on the unrealized promise for social revolution, arguing –similarly—that the coming one will play a uniquely justice-making social role. Working from this analysis of social justice, Mary’s Song will be examined to show that its author recognizes the explicitly social dimensions of Hannah’s Song in order to use them as a springboard for framing the Jesus narrative in the remainder of Luke. For Mary, Hannah’s song has been prophetically realized. God’s apocalyptic in-breaking into the cosmos in the events of the child she is bearing has ushered in an eschatological age characterized by wide-range social justice and social transformation. Mary’s song makes this claim through the use of prophetic aorists. In Jesus God “has.” The onus is now on Jesus’ ministry to serve as evidence of Mary’s claim and thus give credence and legitimacy to her prophesy.
Accordingly, the realized promise articulated in the Magnificat gives the Gospel of Luke an orientation and vision for Jesus’ ministry, which serves as the final, climactic, divine act of social justice. This gives primacy to the Magnificat, over and against the inaugural speech in Nazareth (Luke 4: 14-21), which is usually seen as the formal start of Jesus’ ministry.
In the end, the Magnifcat—working from the Song of Hannah—paints Jesus as the exemplary version of a socially just ruler that Hannah envisions.
|
The Influence of Ezekiel 40–48 on 1 En. 14:8–25
Program Unit: Mysticism, Esotericism, and Gnosticism in Antiquity
Inchol Yang, Claremont Lincoln University
Insofar as the throne vision in 1 En. 14:8-25 so clearly recalls previous biblical descriptions, interpreters have simply focused on texts of the throne vision. However, with the understanding of Enoch’s role as a priest, more interpreters have come to recognize that the throne vision of 1 En. 14:8-25 reflects Ezekiel 40-48. Although they suggested the relationships between Ezekiel 40-48 and 1 Enoch 14, they failed to explain why the author of 1 Enoch introduces the throne vision, namely, the heavenly temple vision in the wake of the narrative about the fallen Watchers’ petition (1 En. 13:3b-7). Before Enoch was taken to heaven, the Great Holy One commanded His four archangels to destroy Shemihazah and his associate (1 Enoch 10-11). Yet the author of 1Enoch suddenly shifts his concern to Enoch as an intercessor for the Fallen Watchers (1 En. 12:1-13:7). Then, as Enoch recites the memorandum of their petition, he sees visions in his dreams, in other words, the throne vision (13:8-16:4). Since Enoch ascended to heaven, readers never hear the Fallen Watchers’ voices. This narrative sequence must have reflected the author’s intent.
In this paper, I argue that the throne vision in 1 Enoch not only follows the structure of Ezekiel 40-48, but also reflects Ezekiel’s theology for the new Temple. From Ezekiel’s perspective, the prerequisite conditions for the new Temple are the purification of abominations in it: “the house of Israel shall no more defile my holy name, neither they nor their kings, by their whoring, and by the corpses of their kings at their death” (Ezek 43:7). Thus, after Ezekiel introduces the corpses of Gog’s soldiers (Ezekiel 38-39), he proceeds to the next narrative of his entrance to the new Temple. In a similar vein, with Ezekiel’s theology in mind, the author of 1Enoch constructs the sequence of events. The Fallen Watchers who were proud of their knowledge and power tremble before Enoch’s command from the Great One. After Enoch’s journey to the house in the heaven, they disappeared (1 En. 21:10). This paper proceeds in five stages. First, on the basis of critical notes, it translates the throne vision (1 En. 14:8-25). Second, it examines the literary form and setting of the throne vision within the larger literary framework of the Book of the Watchers (1 Enoch 1-36). Third, it identifies and examines genre and language. Fourth, it investigates the setting in which the text was written, to which it is addressed, and in which it functions. Finally, it draws conclusions concerning Ezekiel’s temple theology in 1 Enoch.
|
Salomania in Text, Canvas, and Stage: Where Does Bernardino’s Salome Belong?
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Art
Angela Yarber, Wake Forest University
In San Diego’s Museum of Art hangs a portrait of a woman whose reputation has evoked controversy for centuries. Luini Bernardino’s Salome utilizes his famous Luinesque style as this seemingly wanton woman gazes downward, a wasp of hair grazing her right shoulder. Missing is the severed head of John the Baptist on a bloody platter. Gone is the seductive dancing body portrayed by later artists depicting the dancing daughter. Where exactly does this portrait fit within Salome’s expansively scandalous oeuvre of paintings, choreography, operas, and theatre?
Somewhere between text and canvas exists a misunderstood little girl who danced at a dinner party and whose reputation has been maligned on canvas, stage, and popular culture. This paper exegetes this often misinterpreted text, comparing scripture to artistic and choreographic portrayals, seeking to discover whether Bernardino’s portrait of Salome coincides best with the text or with other artistic depictions of the dancing decapitator.
|
Salvation by Water? First Peter 3:20–21 in Augustine and the Latin Tradition
Program Unit: Contextualizing North African Christianity
Jonathan Yates, Villanova University
1 Peter 3:18-22 has been described as the clearest statement in all of the New Testament of exactly how the earliest Christians viewed baptism and its effects. This paper will not test that assertion; rather, it will seek to elucidate the role that a portion of this passage played in the theological and sacramental thinking of early North African Christianity.
In particular, it will focus on the following lines from vv.20-21: “… the patience of God kept waiting in the days of Noah, during the construction of the ark, in which a few, that is, eight persons, were saved through water. Corresponding to that, baptism now saves you—not the removal of dirt from the flesh, but an appeal to God for a good conscience—through the resurrection of Jesus Christ …”
Outside North Africa, these verses generated comment from westerners such as Irenaeus, Hilary of Poitiers, Filastrius of Brescia, Jerome, Rufinus of Aquileia, and Pseudo-Rufinus. These two verses were also repeatedly referenced by two (or three if one includes Pseudo-Cyprian) of North African Christianity’s most important writers: Cyprian and Augustine. Cyprian invoked these verses a handful of times in at least three letters and Augustine referenced them no less forty-five times in more than twenty different compositions—including his Letter 164 to his fellow North African bishop, Evodius of Uzalis.
Questions that this paper will pursue include: How did these authors (esp. Cyprian and Augustine) understand the claim that salvation comes “per aquam”? How did they understand the explicit link (it is called an “antitype” in the Greek) Peter made between baptism and the Noah story? What, if any, relevance did these verses have for the so-called Donatists and/or in the Donatist Controversy?
|
Fishers of Men: Divine Discipline as Fishing Metaphor in the Hebrew Bible and Ancient Near East
Program Unit: Assyriology and the Bible
Tyler R. Yoder, The Ohio State University
Biblical prophets employ an array of different imagery to announce looming divine retribution. On no less than three different occasions (Amos 4:1-3; Habakkuk 1:12-17; Ezekiel 12:9-16) a prophetic message of judgment incorporates metaphors appropriated from the fisherman’s social milieu, a curious Israelite phenomenon in light of both its general suspicion toward the sea and the inconspicuous societal role it appeared to play. Why then did biblical prophets conceive of retribution and exile in such terms? Is it mere stylistic variation? A resolution emerges after these references are together viewed through the lens of fishing imagery and situated within their broader historical and political contexts. The signaling of divine justice through the use of fishing imagery is a feature much more at home in Mesopotamian literature, correlating generally with the more prominent economic and cultic role of fishing there. Though literary examples span Mesopotamian history (3rd millennium BCE through the Neo-Assyrian period), attestations burgeon between the reigns of Tiglath-Pileser III and Esarhaddon, at which time Assyria’s renewed expansionistic interests led to more regular interactions with the Levant and Assyrian royal inscriptions revived this imagery, frequently imbuing martial exploits of subjugation and forced migration with fishing metaphors. The prophets thus preserve a shared reality by framing the prospect of covenantal retribution and exile—concepts that were reified through historical experiences—within fishing metaphors that resemble those propagated by the Assyrians themselves. These images, entrenched in realia, ironically resemble the imagery applied to Assyrian kings within their own inscriptions, likening them to fishermen who subjugate and capture foreigners with their net. The chronological and literary propinquity of these fishing metaphors support this concept of shared reality and provide an explanation both for their appearance in the Hebrew Bible as well as their dynamic rhetorical effect.
|
A Novel Take on John’s Apocalypse: A Proposed Movement from an Island-Inspired Revelation to an Island-Inspired Reading
Program Unit: Contextual Biblical Interpretation
Gosnell Yorke, Northern Caribbean University
John’s Apocalypse occupies a unique position in the New Testament canon not only because of its literary genre or Gattung but, for purposes of this presentation, because it can rightly claim, perhaps, to be the only Book whose provenance is Island-spired. Unlike Titus, the Pastoral Epistle, for example, which locates its recipients on Crete, another island which is associated with a Book within the New Testament canon, John, as author and one who was under severe existential stress at the time, locates himself on Patmos, about thirty-five miles off the coast of modern Turkey. Patmos was an island to which the Romans, in the exercise of their imperial power and prowess, often banished those adjudged to be criminals and who were then forced to work, against their wills, in the mines and quarries to be found there. Further, Patmos was a rocky island immersed in, and surrounded by, the Mediterranean Sea (see Rev. 1: 9-11) which the Romans, in their imperialistic pretensions, were known to refer to as Mare nostrum (our Sea). Given John’s contextual location, perhaps it is not without significance that sustained use is therefore made of marine and/or aquatic and associated symbolisms or imagery throughout the Book in the presentation of its apocalyptic message (see, e.g., 1: 15b; 4:1-6; 5:13; 6:12-14; 7: 1-2, 14-17; 8: 8-10; 10:1-8; 12: 13-18; 13: 1; 14:2, 7; 15: 2; 16: 3, 20; 17: 1; 18:18-19, 21; 19: 6; 20: 13; 21: 1; 22:1-2, 14). It will be suggested that much of this island-inspired and aquatic language resonates with life in the Caribbean of some 16 million inhabitants which, in spite of its postcolonial push towards greater self-determination, is still very much enmeshed in the vice-like grip of imperial forces— be it European or North American in origin or, more recently, rather Asian in complexion as in the case of China. In addition, our multilingual, multiracial, multi-religious and rainbow-like Region is an integral part of the community of nations and therefore is not and cannot be entirely immune to the global reality and the on-going ecological challenge induced by climate change. For this reason, the Church in the Caribbean is summoned to articulate an ecologically relevant theology which seeks to address this fauna-and flora-threatening phenomenon. In the recent volume (2013) for which I provided the Foreword, to wit, A Kairos Moment in Caribbean Theology (Pickwick Publications), that was precisely the contention of one of its contributors. This contention, it will be argued, is entirely congruent with the present preoccupation of international bodies such as the United Nations in which the issue of anthropogenically induced and earth-endangering climate change ranks high on the agenda. This preoccupation is best demonstrated, perhaps, not only in having the United Nations designate 2014 as the International Year of Small Island Developing States (SIDS) but also by the 26 Articles and 2 Annexes of the 1992 United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC).
|
Correspondence between the Acrostic Structure and Lineation in Lamentations
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
May Young, Trinity International University
Scholarship on Lamentations has continually recognized the presence of its prominent acrostic structure as well as its peculiar lineation. Exploration of these poetic features in this Old Testament book has contributed greatly to our understanding of this poetic text. However, analyses of these features have not investigated how or if these features display correspondence with one another on a structural level. Just as visual devices, e.g., choice of color and lineation, do not operate independent of one another, but work in correspondence with one another to enhance the overall structural aesthetics of the visual piece, e.g., a painting, in the same way, it would be reasonable to assume that correspondence between literary devices also enhances the structural aesthetics of a literary piece. This paper will provide a brief summary of scholarship on the acrostic structure and lineation in the book of Lamentations and will argue that correspondence between these devices not only exist, but work together to highlight significant section breaks in the book.
|
Correspondence between the Acrostic Structure and Lineation in Lamentations
Program Unit: Institute for Biblical Research
May Young, Trinity International University
Correspondence between the Acrostic Structure and Lineation in Lamentations
|
You Were Effeminate: Paul and the Masculinization of Gentiles in Christ
Program Unit: Pauline Epistles
Stephen L. Young, Brown University
This paper highlights the gendered nature of Paul’s discourse(s) about Gentile sinfulness and the effects of Christ-initiation for Gentiles. In short, especially because Gentiles are mastered by their passions and, accordingly, engage in excessive and vicious behaviors (e.g., Rom 1:18–32; 1 Cor 6:9–11; 1 Thess 4:4–5), Gentiles are effeminate and exist in a fundamentally servile and dominated state – but through Christ the Judean god masculinizes Gentiles, restoring their minds and capacities for virtue. In this way Paul’s mythmaking about Gentile sinfulness and the divine benefits available to Gentiles in Christ innovate within well-known Greco-Roman ideologies of powerful, active, self-mastered, rational, and virtuous masculinity versus weak, passive, passion-dominated, irrational, and vicious femininity. The paper will examine passages in Paul’s letters where the effeminate, gendered nature of Gentile sin (e.g., 1 Cor 6:9; malakoi) and the masculinizing significance of Christ for Gentiles (e.g., 1 Cor 6:9–11; 16:13; Gal 3:26–28) surface more explicitly. It will then explore how Paul’s (re)use of a decline of civilization myth in Rom 1:18–32 to represent the history of Gentile sin both specifies gender-coded transgressions and resonates with other ancient Mediterranean civilization-decline myths that culminate in gendered consequences for the cosmos. While the effeminacy of Gentiles and their masculinization in Christ is by no means Paul’s overt or consistently deliberate point, his discourses about Gentile sin and the significance of Christ for Gentiles participate within such gendered Greco-Roman ideologies.
|
When Indicatives Become Imperative: The Indigenizing Function of 1 Peter’s Uncited Use of the Old Testament
Program Unit: Letters of James, Peter, and Jude
Colin H. Yuckman, Duke Divinity School
First Peter is addressed to Gentile Christians—“elect, exiled, dispersed”--in Asia Minor. Three terms traditionally applied to diaspora Jews have been used to re-describe these scattered Christian communities. In fact, this practice of depicting the “ordeal” of Christians as if they were Jews continues throughout the letter and is deepened by extensive use of the Old Testament. Both the use of these allusions and the way they are embedded indicate a high level of intentionality and artistry. By characterizing the audience’s identity in this way, the author effectively draws their behavior towards that characterization. The letter’s many exhortations to act in a certain way are grounded in firm statements about the churches’ identity as elect in Christ, and the description of their election in Christ establishes the basis for ethical action, i.e. “doing good.” We might call this “indicatives doing the work of imperatives.” Sociological criticism in recent years has advanced our understanding of the rhetorical nuances of 1 Peter’s exhortations. Missing from those studies, however, is the application of indigenization theory, which holds promise for our understanding of how “exiled” communities negotiate the internal and external claims of their environment. By attending to both the intertextual and rhetorical clues, this paper will illustrate the way in which 1 Peter uses uncited OT references indicatively, but with imperative force, as a deliberate technique for re-indigenizing new Christians into an established non-Christian community.
|
“That the Works of God Should Be Made Manifest”: Vision and Vocation in John 9
Program Unit: GOCN Forum on Missional Hermeneutics
Colin H. Yuckman, Duke Divinity School
More so than the Synoptics, John’s gospel conspicuously integrates the horizons of divine identity and the early church’s mission. This is nowhere more evident than in the archetypal chapter 9, where a man born blind is healed by Jesus. On one level, the story portrays a sign of Jesus’ divine authority in contrast to the religious establishment of his day. At another level, the primary character in the narrative is the man born blind, clearly making Jesus secondary. As the narrative unfolds the now-sighted man and Jesus performatively switch roles, leading to a kind of soteriological exchange in which the man’s (and by Johannine extension, the community’s) vocation comes into focus. The story offers several points of consideration for the shaping of a missional hermeneutic: firstly, that salvation and vocation are ultimately inextricable; secondly, that Jesus’ identity is expressed through his disciples’ ongoing vocation; and thirdly, that knowledge of divine purpose is predicated upon participation in that purpose. These themes will be explored, with a view to the ongoing conversation about missional hermeneutics, through careful attention to John’s dialogical artistry, literary polyvalence, and freighted diction. This paper hopes to offer simultaneously a missional reading of John 9 and a synthesis of the implications of such a reading for shaping a missional hermeneutic.
|
Jonah and the Ninevites: Prophecy to Communal Outsiders in the Qur'an
Program Unit: The Qur’an and the Biblical Tradition (IQSA)
Hamza M. Zafer, University of Washington
The conceptual intersection of prophecy and community is at the core of the Qur?an's program of community formation. The text's prophetology offers a window into its communal ideology and its boundary making. In this paper, I explore tellings and re-tellings of the Jonah narrative in the Qur?an in order to highlight discrete stages in the development of a proto-Muslim religio-communal consciousness. I argue that the Qur?an deploys the figure of Jonah as a pointed statement about the communal indetermin acy of prophetic guidance and thus the universal possibility of communal election. The indeterminate communal purview of Jonah's prophetic mission explains why his figure and narrative, to the exclusion of other Biblical prophets, finds substantial mention in the Qur?anic text. Jonah's anguished excursion to the Ninevites-a community well outside the spatial and genealogical boundaries of Israel-is a typological precursor to the communally indeterminate mission of the text's prophetic addressee whose mission straddles the boundary between pre-existing soteriological communities and an emergent one. The general aim of this paper is to draw attention to a methodological flaw that constrains and misdirects analysis of Biblical narrative the Qur?an, namely the presumption that the text of the Hebrew Bible constitutes its vorlage. Studies of Jonah in the Qur?an have neglected late antique Jewish and Christian mediations of the Biblical narrative. This disregard for the contours o f late ancient interpretive thought has in turn created an oversimplified image of this complex and polemically potent Biblical figure. I set the Qur?an's rendition of the Jonah cycle against its renditions in rabbinic literature and in the writings of the Syriac fathers. I conclude from this comparison that the Qur?an's narrative divergences and idiosyncrasies are not simply misreadings of the Biblical original, as has been the operative assumption, but rather are expressions of a distinctly late ancient polemical agenda.
|
Imagining the Composition of the Temple Scroll: Literary and Manuscript Evidence
Program Unit: Qumran
Molly Zahn, University of Kansas
The composition history of the Temple Scroll (TS) has generally been approached from two different angles. Some have used the internal data gleaned from literary analysis of the main copy of TS (11Q19) to develop theories of composition similar in method and result to those proposed by source and redaction critics for the Pentateuch. Others have begun from comparative study of 11Q19 and other related manuscripts (11Q20, 4Q524, 4Q365a), using the relationships between them to postulate earlier sources or multiple recensions of TS. These two approaches are not necessarily contradictory, but they yield different types of data that do not always support one another. This paper thus asks how best to integrate the two as we seek to imagine the process by which TS came to take the form in which we now know it best. What literary features point to a complex process of composition, and how should they be interpreted? Can the manuscript evidence corroborate any particular interpretation of the literary evidence, and if not, how can the two be reconciled? I will propose that starting from the manuscript evidence and allowing it to guide our interpretation of the internal literary evidence provides the most promising approach to integrating these two sets of data.
|
More Evidence Origen Wrote to Theodore
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Michael Zeddies, University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
I have argued for Origenian authorship of To Theodore, the letter discovered by Morton Smith at the Mar Saba monastery in 1958. In light of this thesis, and of some recent work by Arthur Urbano on ancient Christian clothing, as well as other recent commentary regarding Papias, Origen, and Eusebius, it is instructive to re-examine Francis Watson’s analysis of the Mar Saba letter. I draw particular attention to Watson’s description of the secret gospel as “prurient”, and show that in contrast with Watson’s misunderstanding, the third-century philosophical milieu Origen inhabited provides a context for understanding the dress of the secret gospel’s neaniskos as that of a philosopher. I also re-evaluate Watson’s evidence that the letter’s author used Papias as a literary model, by demonstrating that Origen used Papias closely, as we see by quotations from Eusebius and elsewhere. Scott Brown and Allan Pantuck have also recently shown that the letter does not use correlative conjunctions in the manner of Papias, and I build upon this by showing instead that the letter uses these conjunctions in the manner of Origen. The thesis of Origenian authorship eliminates Watson’s argument for Smithian forgery.
|
The Use of the Hebrew Bible in the Migration Debate: Pitfalls and Challenges
Program Unit: Social Sciences and the Interpretation of the Hebrew Scriptures
Markus Zehnder, Universität Basel
While the Bible in general and the Old Testament in particular are rarely referred to in the present-day migration debate taking place in the media, politics, social sciences, and the broader public, they are often used in arguments brought up by various ecclesiastical bodies engaging in the debate. This use is understandable in light of the fact that many biblical texts do speak about migration and various types of factors that cause migration.
On the other hand, the discussion of these texts is often done in isolation from the broader framework of various disciplines of social sciences, especially sociology, ethnography, and economics. As a consequence, too often dissimilarities between the situation presupposed by biblical texts and the present situation are not given enough consideration. In addition, in a quest for straightforward application of selected biblical passages, the broader framework in which these texts are embedded is also neglected.
This paper aims at
- addressing some of the most salient misunderstandings of the biblical material relating to migration issues;
- identifying fundamental dissimilarities between the current situation and types of migration in the biblical world / ANE;
- identifying some of the crucial problems in the basic assumptions informing the current debate, as seen both from a biblical perspective and a broader social science perspective;
- pointing to positive contributions that the biblical material can make to further the discussion on migration issues and to find answers to some of the difficult and uneasy problems connected to migration.
|
The Conquest of Canaan: Reading Deut 7:1–5 and Similar Passages in the Context of Joshua-Judges
Program Unit: Joshua-Judges
Markus Zehnder, Universität Basel
Without any doubt, Deut 7:1-5 and similar passages (Exod 23:23-33; 34:11-16; Num 33:50-56) calling, among others, for the “ban” of the peoples of Canaan are widely (and understandably) seen as forming one of the greatest challenges when it comes to the ethical problems of violence in the Hebrew Bible. The present paper aims at shedding new light on these texts by investigating the relationship between the respective passages in the Pentateuch and especially by examining how these texts are used in the books of Joshua and Judges. It will be argued that (1) the deuteronomic passage is the most recent of the pentateuchal passages; (2) texts describing the encounter with the Canaanites in both Joshua and Judges do not refer to the deuteronomic passage only, but to most of the relevant pentateuchal passages; (3) the specific use of the pentateuchal passages in Joshua and Judges does not support a genocidal reading of these texts; (4) Gideon is described as the paradigmatic executor of the divine commandments concerning the treatment of the Canaanites in the book of Judges.
|
Centurion as Rank of Peace? Social and Ideological Underpinnings of a New Testament Trope
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Christopher B. Zeichmann, University of Toronto
More than anywhere else in the New Testament, the passion narrative features the military and its ensigns. Strangely, the Gospels seem deeply ambivalent about the military in this section: on the one hand soldiers mock and crucify Jesus, on the other the centurion is the first person to recognize Jesus’ divine sonship and they are not responsible for his condemnation to death. This tension is often glossed over; some scholars emphasize the latter (and so must claim that the centurion’s confession indicates something other than what it seems to), while others understand the centurion’s confession as justification or anticipation of Christian inclusion of the Gentiles (disregarding soldiers’ role in Jesus’ abuse). Instead of opting for one or the other option in this dichotomy, I would like to propose that the fundamental ambiguity of the military in the New Testament is not fully appreciated, as soldiers plainly serve disparate function over the course of a single chapter in Mark. Indeed, this tension is common in the New Testament. While common soldiers are often viewed negatively in narrative portions of the New Testament, officers of the rank centurio are uniformly depicted positively (e.g., Mark 15:39, Q 7:1-10, Acts 10:1-8, 27:1-3, 43). To explain this tension, I will draw upon papyrological evidence regarding soldier-civilian relations in the Roman Near East to discern the social structures that encouraged peasants and other civilians to perceive centurions positively and common soldiers more negatively. For example, sales typically occurred via special contract that could only be characterized as extortion and low-ranking soldiers appear to have been responsible for procuring such supplies from provincials. Officers, on the other hand – especially those ranked centurion and higher – had considerably greater agency and their individual dispositions played a larger role in their public perception; they mediated conflicts between locals, determined which regions to police for thieves, and the like. By illuminating the social conditions that cultivated such understandings of the military, we are better positioned to discern the distinctive comportments New Testament authors held toward the Roman Empire and the military more specifically.
|
The Qur'an and Rabbinic Judaism: "Mecca" and "Medina" between Palestine and Babylonia
Program Unit: The Qur’an and the Biblical Tradition (IQSA)
Holger Zellentin, University of Nottingham
This paper considers the Qur'an's evidence for rabbinic Judaism in the light of a more careful differentiation between the Palestinian and Babylonian rabbinic material. I argue that the rabbinic material found in the longer surahs at the beginning of the Qur'an (often attributed to its "Medinan" phase) reflects both Babylonian Talmudic and Palestinian Midrashic sources, while the material in the shorter surahs (often attributed to a "Meccan" phase) nearly exclusively reflect Palestinian exegetical rabbinic traditions. A double differentiation within the Qur'an and within the rabbinic sources allows for a better use of the Qur'an as evidence for Arabian rabbinic Judaism, for a more precise reading of the Qur'an's view of Judaism and its use of rabbinic material, and, last not least, for a new approach to the difficult question of the Qur'an's inner chronology that is independent of the traditional one.
|
What is P.Berol. 11710: Amulet, Apocryphal Gospel, Biblical Elaboration?
Program Unit: Christian Apocrypha
Lorne R. Zelyck, University of Alberta
Theodore De Bruyn and Thomas Kraus have recently suggested that P.Berol. 11710 is an amulet that contains an excerpt from an apocryphal gospel. This paper will present a new transcription and interpretation of the text, including a discussion of: the occurrence of the name ‘Jesus’; meaning of the name ‘Nathanael’ in amulets; the use of Greek and Coptic, nomina sacra, a staurogram, isopsephy, and ‘magical symbols’; and the influence of John 1:29, 1:49, and liturgical interpretations. It will be argued, with reference to other ‘magical’ papyri, that a ritual specialist has elaborated on biblical texts to create an apotropaic amulet, rather than preserved passages from a gospel that became apocryphal.
|
New Songs with Old Words? Formulaic Language in Psalms of Individual Lament and Similar Ancient Near Eastern Prayers
Program Unit: Performance Criticism of the Bible and Other Ancient Texts
Anna Elise Zernecke, Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz
Many biblical Psalms have phrases in common which appear in varying combinations and contexts. This phenomenon is also frequent in prayers from neighbouring cultures such as Akkadian texts from Mesopotamia, where it is no sign of literary interdependence between the prayers. The formulaic language of selected Psalms of individual lament and Akkadian prayers can be interpreted as conditioned by the formulation and performance of the texts. This can be corroborated by an investigation of the sociological background of Mesopotamian prayer texts. The information available about their formation and performance is examined to assess their value as parallels for the shaping of the biblical Psalms.
|
Echoes of Texts Past
Program Unit: National Association of Professors of Hebrew
Ziony Zevit, American Jewish University
In this paper introducing the final year of this program unit, I summarize the objectives of the unit as presented three years ago, allude to how they were realized in some of the research presented in the past, and indicate problematic areas remaining to be addressed by biblicists and historians.
|
Triplets in the Song of Songs
Program Unit: Biblical Hebrew Poetry
Sarah Zhang, GETS Theological Seminary
Studies of Hebrew poetry often (rightly) take couplets as their main object, with much less attention given to the many spirited triplets. Hence, theoretical questions concerning triplets remain insufficiently addressed: are there viable constraints that help to define triplets? How (or whether) the triplets could be classified? How do the three lines in a triplet typically interact? Given the limited space, this paper will address these questions by focusing on the triplets appeared in the Song of Songs. Plucking in turn the strings of syntactical relations, syllable counts and semantic parallelism as an echo to Benjamin Hrushovski’s proposed “semantic-syntactic-accentual” system of Hebrew poetry, this paper will detail a provisional and descriptive classification of triplets for future studies. More immediately, the findings so gleaned will be applied in determining whether Song 8:6c-f is to be read as one triplet or two couplets.
|
The Canvas of Emotion
Program Unit: Bible and Emotion
Sarah Zhang, Garrett Evangelical Theological Seminary
The tie between emotion and poetry has long been acknowledged in the field of biblical poetry. However, this established acknowledgement often assumes a layman’s understanding of emotion and lacks the theoretical depth that contemporary critical studies on the feeling brain, ethics and poetry now afford. Hence, this paper will take an interdisciplinary approach that combines congruent theoretical threads from neuroscience, ethical theories and modern poetry criticism (more specifically, “New Ethics” as it is termed recently) to examine how emotion holds the key in interpreting and applying biblical poetry. A close reading of two passages from the Song of Songs (4:1–7; 5:2–8), which have caused confusion among interpreters, will serve to illustrate the point. This reading will reveal how delight and distraught respectively constitute the canvases of the two poems, and how such emotional textures “distort” the lyrical vision/narration, in order to embody the authenticity of the felt emotions. This paper will conclude at the thought that, with the reader’s emotional participation, biblical poems facilitate the reader’s ethical formation anterior to the abstraction and absorption of thematic messages.
|
"Innovations" in Scriptural Interpretation: A Tentative Cross-Textual Reading of the Hermeneutical Practices in Maimonides and Zhu Xi
Program Unit: Ethnic Chinese Biblical Colloquium
Zhang Ying, East China Normal University
not available
|
Apocalypticism in Modern Theology
Program Unit:
Philip Ziegler, University of Aberdeen
*
|
And the Man Ate and Gave Some to His Wife!? Adam as the Original Sinner in Illustrated Children's Bibles for Young Earth Creationists
Program Unit: Bible and Popular Culture
Valarie H. Ziegler, DePauw University
I propose to examine a curious phenomenon found in illustrated children's Bibles produced by Master Books, the self-proclaimed world's largest publisher of young earth creationist literature. Master Books publications are closely associated with Ken Ham, the originator of the Creation Museum, and with his Answers in Genesis foundation, charged, according to its "1:1” motto, with defending the literal truth of the Bible from its very first word.
Few uninitiated readers of illustrated children's Bibles expect to encounter the mighty T. rex playfully romping in Eden, but lovable dinosaurs are staples of young earth creationist accounts of Genesis 1-3. What is unusual in Master Books' renditions of Eden is not the cuddly triceratops but the visual representations in which the first man appears to have taken the first bite of the forbidden fruit before handing it to the first woman. While readers might imagine that they have stumbled onto some wishful-thinking "feminist" retelling of Genesis 3:6, the reality is that Master Books authors understand the subordination of women to men as central both to God's design in creation and to Christian church and family life. In other settings, these authors do not hesitate to identify the first woman as the original transgressor, and they are only too happy to cite 1 Timothy 2:11-14 as proof that women must not hold authority over men in the church because Eve was first in the fall.
Why, then, this odd visual rendering of the primal disobedience? The emphasis upon the first man’s sin is critical to a theology that exalts men as God's regents on earth. Because God is male and created men to rule over women, "man" must be the star of the earthly drama of creation, fall, and redemption, even though that entails playing both the villain and the hero. It is the first Adam’s responsibility that sin has entered the world (Romans 5:12), and salvation requires a reversal of that sin through the sacrifice of Jesus, “the last Adam” (1 Cor 15:45). The exaltation of a male savior requires a male sinner as a fall guy, and visual representations of Genesis 3:6 can depict Adam as original sinner in ways that textual summaries dare not, given the text’s clarity that the woman was first to fall prey to temptation.
In these illustrated children's' Bibles, young readers, in short, must draw a parallel between the man who threw the human race into sin and the man whose death redeemed humanity from it. And so, in contradistinction to Genesis 3:6, Master Books' artists illustrate this connection by depicting the original disobedience ambiguously, allowing readers to blame or at least imagine Adam as the first to eat the forbidden fruit even as they are exhorted to believe in the literal truth of the Bible from its very first word.
|
How to Read Biblical Texts Ethically: The New Method of "Implicit Ethics" in Dealing with Biblical Ethics
Program Unit: Bible and Ethics
Ruben Zimmermann, Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz
The Bible is a book of ethics. Though a general consensus can usually be achieved fairly easily concerning the ethical content of individual passages or texts, it must also be recognized that no biblical book or text provides a systematic ethics in the sense of a theory of action or behavior. The concept "implicit ethics" attempts to find a certain middle ground in which attention is drawn to "ethics" - in the sense of a reflected rationale and justification for acting - in the specific form of biblical texts (e.g., as a narrative or as an epistle). In this paper I present a set of ethical perspectives with which this "implicit ethics" can be uncovered and described. As such, I am aspiring to develop a method of "ethical analysis" of biblical texts which can complement and expand the extant repertoire of methodological approaches to biblical interpretation (such as, e.g., rhetorical, socio-historical, and post-colonial exegesis). The model consciously builds upon contemporary theories in moral philosophy and current debates concerning ethics and distances itself from ultimately inadequate models such as the indicative-imperative concept. The concepts of ethical theory should be utilized as a heuristic tool for more precise ethical analysis of biblical texts for which I have developed a list of criteria which will be presented in this paper. Through a specifically ethical reading of biblical texts, biblical ethics becomes compatible with contemporary ethical discourses, both in Christian (systematic theological) ethics and in an interdisciplinary context. In this way, one ultimately gains nuanced hermeneutical categories which allow biblical ethics to contribute to current ethical debates.
|
Curse or Cry of Despair? The Pragmatics of Hoy and Implications for Bible Translation
Program Unit: Linguistics and Biblical Hebrew
Lynell Marchese Zogbo, The University of the Free State
Hoy’s categorization as a member of the class of interjections is widely accepted by Hebrew scholars, but the word itself continues to raise exegetical and linguistic issues especially in the realm of Bible translation. Believed to have originated as a death cry or lament (R.L. Smith, J.D. Watts), hoy has developed a wide range of meanings and pragmatic roles: evoking pity, being used as an attention-getter or a cry of vindication, but also more generally, expressing threat and condemnation (Slager and Zogbo). While occurring in a very well defined and restricted syntactic environment (pre-nominal, often pre-participle), hoy seems to have also developed a special discourse function as initiator of prophetic proclamations, the majority of which occur in negative contexts. This has led several scholars to posit a special literary genre, the ‘woe oracle’. In at least one instance as well, hoy can be seen to close a discourse unit. Like hinneh, this interjection also serves to signal climax or high points in discourse (Wendland).
However, besides its clear text-organizing function, hoy remains problematic in terms of its linguistic status and its possible renderings in translation. Does hoy signal a specific or several speech acts? This question is especially pertinent in West Africa where CURSE and BLESSING, expressed in formulaic language, are extremely common. In many cases, hoy is almost automatically assumed to refer to and is very often rendered as CURSE. After a brief presentation of hoy’s grammatical and discourse features, this paper will provide further reflections on the pragmatic analysis of this important marker, along with a discussion of implications for Bible translation.
|
| |
|
|