|
|
2014 International Meeting
Meeting Begins: 7/6/2014
Meeting Ends: 7/10/2014
Call for Papers Opens: 10/28/2013
Call for Papers Closes: 2/11/2014
Requirements for Participation
|
|
Meeting Abstracts
Mishpat Haggojim (2 Kgs 17:33; Ezek 5:6ff) & Mishpat Laggojim (Isa 42:1): From Oppression to the Development of Early Measures for International Human Rights in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Law
Reinhard Achenbach, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
Mark Brett recently pointed out in an article in the internet that the roots of international human rights can be traced back into the ancient israelite texts of the Hebrew Bible. The term of a „Law for the Peoples“ was formulated in the Deutero-Isaianic Collection as a result of the experiences from the babylonian exile. In the first half of the 5th century B.C.E. we find a discussion about the principles of „ta nomima tôn anthropôn“ in the Greek and Persian world. The lecture will show that there was not only an „inherence“ of human rights in biblical texts, but that measures of international law have been formulated explicitly in the prophetic torah and in the Pentateuch.
|
Paul’s Final Reconciliation with the Jerusalem Leaders?
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Bartosz Adamczewski, Cardinal Stefan Wyszynski University in Warsaw
The Acts of the Apostles describes five travels of Saul/Paul to Jerusalem. On the basis of Paul’s own letters scholars usually assume that there were three Paul’s visits to Jerusalem: the ‘acquaintance’ visit (Gal 1:18-19), the ‘conference’ visit (Gal 2:1-10a), and the ‘collection and reconciliation’ visit (Rom 15:25-31). However, the recognition of the fact that the Letter to the Galatians was written later than the Letter to the Romans, as a sequential hypertextual reworking thereof, implies that there were only two Paul’s travels to Jerusalem: the ‘acquaintance’ visit (Gal 1:18-19) and the ‘collection, conference, and reconciliation’ visit (Rom 15:25-31; Gal 2:1-10). Consequently, as the letters to the Galatians and to the Philippians reveal, after the Antiochene crisis (Gal 2:11-21) and before Paul’s imprisonment and death in Rome (Phlp 1:12-21; 2:17; 4:22) there was no final reconciliation between Paul and the Jerusalem leaders. Such reconciliation was later created in an ethopoeic way by the Lucan school of theological-literary production. The recognition of this fact may be important for the preparations for the great jubilee of the Reformation (1517-2017).
|
The Pentateuch Quotations in the Kitab ‘ala’l-Tawrat by ‘Ala’ al-Din al-Baji (d. 1314)
Program Unit: Quran and Islamic Tradition in Comparative Perspective
Camilla Adang, Tel Aviv University
The proposed paper deals with the Egyptian legal scholar ‘Ala’ al-Din al-Baji (d. 1314), whose works include a tract critical of the Five Books of Moses, and especially the Book of Genesis, which the author read in one or more Arabic translations, apparently of Melkite provenance. Although the work is also known as al-Radd ‘ala’l-Yahud, it is mainly Christianity with which the author takes issue. Al-Baji's aims and critical method will be explained on the basis of a series of quotations from his tract.
|
The Posthumous Judgement in Byzantium: The Transformation of a Biblical Theme
Program Unit: The Bible in Byzantium: The Use and Abuse of Tradition
Eirini Afentoulidou, Österreichische Akademie der Wissenschaften
*
|
Conception of the World in the Last David Psalter (Pss 138–145): Outlined Depiction
Program Unit: Place, Space, and Identity in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Jean Prosper Agbagnon, Ruhr-Universität Bochum
The heading authorship and many linguistic and conceptual commonalities in the 5th Psalter of David show a planned composition recognized in the concatenation and juxtaposition, as a unity in their redaction history through numerous connection of motifs: image of God, God’s kingship, Temple thematic and theology of the poor. However, difficulties appear in assigning the genre of Ps 139 and 144, likewise structural peculiarities in Ps 139, 144 and 145. Nevertheless, the accentuations and shifting of emphases in the unfolding of the motifs, lead to a theological development: JHWH’s Kingship mentioned in Ps 138, unfolded in his worship (Ps 145) goes beyond Space-Time. JHWH demonstrates transcendence in creation and history, shows his immanence in love for his creatures, and in demanding justice. The synthesis of wisdom and priestly thought, correlated with the worldview of universal space - unlimited time, argues for a developed theology probably towards the end of the Persian period.
Taking up, that relationship to God connects closely to self-relationship and to the world, the investigation asks: are there one or multiple worldviews in the 5th psalter of David?
Applying the conception of H. Lefebvre (perceived, conceptualized and lived space), my analysis describes the images of space-time; the categories of human and world conception are then ordered accordingly.
How does David (paradigmatic figure) perceive his environment? How do these perceptions shape his conception of God? What does this mean for theology and anthropology in the 5th Psalter of David?
These inquiries show the importance of space-time for OT Theology and Anthropology and the tension in the intra-inter-textual transdisciplinary discourse on the relationship of theology, cosmology and anthropology with philosophical, psychological and epistemological insights.
|
The ger in the Damascus Document: a Rejoinder
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Kengo Akiyama, University of Edinburgh
This paper probes the status and the identity of the ger in the Damascus Document (CD). In particular, I evaluate Y. M. Gillihan's recent proposal that the ger in CD is a legal fiction (RevQ 98, 2011). Although his synchronic reading of the Dead Sea Scrolls (DSS) is tantalizing, it is in the end not persuasive. The DSS point to the simultaneous existence of two varying attitudes (i.e., integrative and exclusionary). Pace Gillihan, I submit that this phenomenon results not from the community's purported "fiction writing" but from the fact that at least two types of figures lie behind the term ger in the DSS. Within the course of its semantic evolution--beginning in the earliest stratum of the Hebrew Bible (HB) and culminating in the later established meaning as "proselyte" in rabbinic literature--the word ger has designated different figures in ancient Judaism. Given the diversity of referents associated with ha-ger in the HB, one should anticipate that his status in the DSS would likewise be diverse or perhaps in a state of flux. Most texts refer to the ger who is a proto-proselyte (viz., more integrated than the ger of the priestly view but less so than that of rabbinic literature), but a few exclusionary texts relegate the ger to someone who is "just" a temporary, gentile sojourner (viz., more in continuity withe the ger of the priestly view). In the light of this, the ger in CD is best construed as a proto-proselyte who is a real part of the community, rather than a fictional figure in their halakha who fills a scriptural-exegetical "gap."
|
Women as Leaders in the Gatherings of Early Christian Communities: A Socio-Historical Analysis
Program Unit: Apostolic Fathers and Related Early Christian Literature
Valeriy Alikin, St. Petersburg Christian University
Most studies that investigate the issue of women leading the gatherings of early Christian communities usually consider women in Pauline communities and Acts and the emphasis is made on women in leadership roles and holding various offices like apostle, presbyter, bishop. In doing this scholars consider various kinds of evidence that only implicitly refers to women conducting the gatherings of Early Christian communities. This paper focuses on presenting and analyzing the evidence in related Early Christian literature that supports the practice of women conducting and presiding at the gatherings of Early Christian communities in the second and first half of the third century. Rarely scholars adduce the pertinent evidence from the Graeco-Roman World that supports the view that women led and presided at banquets including the banquets of various associations. From social-historical point of view the local early Christian community functioned as voluntary religious association that conducted communal meals.
|
Zur Aktuellen Hermeneutischen Relevanz der Paulinischen Schriftrezeption
Program Unit: Schriftrezeption bei Paulus und in der Paulustradition: Reception of Scripture in Paul and Pauline Tradition
Stefan Alkier, Johann Wolfgang Goethe-Universität Frankfurt am Main
Ein grundlegender Zug des paulinischen Schriftgebrauchs besteht in der Aktualisierung der rezipierten Schrift durch referentialisierende und intertextualisierende Rezeptionsverfahren. So werden z.B. in Röm 4 verschiedene Texte aufeinander bezogen und in dieser intertextuell hergestellten Verknüpfung auf das diskutierte Problem argumentativ bezogen. Historisch-kritische Hermeneutik möchte hingegen den Eigensinn der Texte in ihren jeweiligen Entstehungssituationen rekonstruieren und die Texte vor Vereinnahmungen schützen, was allerdings zu einem erheblichen Relevanzverlast biblischer Texte geführt hat. Mit Hilfe der Unterscheidung von produktionsästhetischer, rezeptionsästhetischer und experimenteller Intertextualität soll der Vortrag zeigen, wie die Beachtung der unterschiedlichen Interessen an Texten und ihren gefundenen oder erfundenen Relationen die aktuelle hermeneutische Relevanz der paulinischen Schriftrezeption erhellen kann und zugleich die jeweiligen Anliegen der Relationierung von Texten kritisch zu unterscheiden lehrt.
|
“Doing What They’ve Just Been Told”: The Epistolary Function of Heb 13:17-19
Program Unit: Epistle to the Hebrews
David M. Allen, The Queen's Foundation
As part of his attempt to recreate the situation behind the epistle to the Hebrews, Barnabas Lindars famously pointed to the testimony of the thirteenth chapter and to the various situational hints or details alluded to therein. Whilst Lindars makes some mention of the role of the leaders (13.17), however, his analysis of their function and relation to Hebrews’ audience remains undeveloped; indeed, 13.17 (and potentially 13.18-19 as well) have commonly been viewed as no more than throwaway remarks or casual assertions of ecclesial control. This paper, by contrast, considers how 13.17-19 might contribute to the shape and interpretation of the epistle, and attempts to draw connections with the preceding epistolary discourse. In particular, it will explore how the exhortations to submit to the congregational leaders – and implicitly perhaps to the author – are premised both upon the prior explication of the role and character of the Son, and the warning passages relating to his sacerdotal work. This is marked by common language and themes, along with a similar paraenetic tone to that found previously in the epistle’s hortatory material. Thus rather than being an afterthought or appendix, or merely an assertion of basic leadership principles, the exhortations of 13.17-19 offer a fitting climax to the prior epistolary content, and to the filial-orientated paraenesis that it sets forth.
|
Lexical Differentiation of Singular Readings and the Greek Bible: The Awareness of the Greek Jewish Scriptural Tradition in the Apocalypse of Codex A
Program Unit: Textual Criticism: Manuscripts & Methods
Garrick V. Allen, University of St. Andrews
Every ancient manuscript contains textual anomalies that are unique to the specific manuscript. It is often assumed that these singular readings are evidence of the limitation of skilled, yet fallible scribal tradents. Singular readings provide important insight into the scribal proclivities of the tradents who manufactured a given manuscript. Many singular readings can be attributed to carelessness in copying, but some evidence intentional modification. The primary goal of this essay is to explore one aspect of the scribal profile of the scribe(s) who manufactured the text of the Apocalypse in Codex Alexandrinus: their awareness of scriptural allusions and their source texts. There are multiple tools available to measure a scribes’ awareness of the Greek Old Testament: indenting, use of diplés, textual segmenting, paragraph markers, and other physical characteristics. The 84 singular readings in the Apocalypse of Codex A provide another unexplored avenue into evaluating the scribe’s awareness of scriptural referencing and scriptural language within the Apocalypse. Select lexical additions and alterations which are not supported in any other manuscript will be evaluated to determine if these lexical modifications reflect awareness of an OG/LXX scriptural text. The following texts, and their singular readings, will serve as test cases in this discussion: Rev 11.4 (Exod 25-26; 37); Rev 11.7 (Dan 7); Rev 14.9 (2 Chr 32.12); Rev 18.12 (Sym. 1 Kings 10). Physical characteristics of the manuscript will be taken into account where relevant. This study will provide data to answer the following questions: is there evidence that the scribe(s) altered or expanded Vorlagen to create greater textual and lexical parity between a scriptural text and the text of Revelation? If so, what scribal mechanics motivated these alterations? What does this data begin to reveal to us about the profile of the scribe(s) of the Apocalypse in Codex A?
|
'Travel Narrative' and the Message of the Book of Genesis
Program Unit: Stylistics and the Hebrew Bible
Yairah Amit, Tel Aviv University
Just about the whole Torah is presented as Travel Literature. The Exodus is the story of an ongoing long journey. However, the book of Genesis is characterized as a reservoir of different, shorter literary journeys. In this paper I will describe the sub-genre of Travel Narratives in general, and the various travel narratives in the book of Genesis in particular. Moreover, I will relate to their literary function, that is, why they were preferred in the composition of the patriarchal stories, and I will also try to answer the question: What sort of travel narrative repeats itself, and why? Finally, some conclusions as to the time Genesis was edited will be considered.
|
Dionysian Elements in 2 Maccabees
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism (EABS)
Ory Amitay, University of Haifa
The last decade has seen a considerable advance in the study of the second book of Maccabees (2Mac), with the appearance of the masterful commentary by Daniel Schwartz.
In a nutshell, Schwartz argues that the information included in 2Mac 6:7 concerning Dionysian festivities in Jerusalem is untypical of official royal Seleukid religion, and makes better sense in a Ptolemaic context. It is thus claimed that this information has no basis in fact, and is rather the insertion of an author acting in the Ptolemaic sphere and influenced by it (either Jason of Kyrene or the anonymous epitomator).
In my talk I propose to counter this line of argument from two angles. First, by showing that a variety of sources (numismatic, epigraphical and even literary) show a distinct interest of the Seleukid Kings in Dionysos, predating the religious reforms in Jerusalem under Antiochos IV. This interest increased in following years, and the events of the 160’s may thus be seen as part of a process.
My second argument is that in order to understand properly the events in Jerusalem we ought to look at them not only from the Seleukid perspective, but also from that of the Jerusalemite extreme hellenizers. And while we have not access to their side of the story, various indications both from within Judaism and from without it support the hypothesis that extreme hellenizers coming from within Judaism may very well have had their reasons to adopt Dionysos and to make him an important part of their new religious life.
|
Violating the Inviolate Body, Thecla Radically Altered
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Rosie Ratcliffe, King's College - London
The story of Thecla concerns a young betrothed virgin who, upon hearing Paul preach, decides to pursue a chaste Christian life. Spurning her fiancé, and rebelling against societal norms, she finds that family and society contrive to put an end to her life. She is thrown into the arena to be burned and to face the wild beasts. However, through miraculous interventions, Thecla triumphantly overcomes the many ordeals that are sent to challenge her. The climax of the story sees Thecla don male apparel and receive Paul’s blessing to “Go and teach the Word of God.” It is not surprising that this text has been seized upon by scholars keen to highlight exemplary women and their important roles in early Christianity.
However, in a culture of honour and shame, this elite virgin bears the ultimate humiliation through the exposure of her body. At one point she is tied naked by the legs between two bulls in an arena of fully clothed men and women: no aspect of her body is veiled from sight. There is no escaping the violent and hostile treatment that Thecla is subjected to. Anyone who reads the text participates in gazing upon a tortured, naked, sexualized woman. Within this paper I will explore how the Acts of Paul and Thecla is highly androcentric and marginalizing in its treatment of Thecla. I will then go on to provide a fresh analysis of the distinctive Christian message conveyed by her presentation. My reasons for exploring this come from a deep suspicion that a text that presents a woman’s body in what is essentially a voyeuristic and, indeed, pornographic, way assumes a male gaze at variance with a female view of a woman who is seen to be empowered and liberated.
|
The Material Reconstruction of 4QSongs of the Sageb (4Q511)
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Joseph L. Angel, Yeshiva University
Shortly after the publication of DJD VII, Hartmut Stegemann recognized that the state of the material remains of 4Q511 are such that they allow for the arrangement of many of the fragments in their original order within the scroll. He published some initial observations in 1990. The project, however, was never completed.
In June, 2013 I came to Göttingen for a research stay as a fellow of the Humboldt Foundation. I attempted to reconstruct 4Q511 utilizing the methods developed by Stegemann and practiced today by his students at the Qumranforschungsstelle. The major findings are as follows:
(1) 4Q511 was at least two meters long and contained at least sixteen columns of writing.
(2) Fragments representing material from fifteen out of the sixteen reconstructed columns can be arranged in their original order.
(3) Columns contained at least 25 lines, yielding a minimum column height of about 17.5 cm.
(4) The composition contained in 4Q511 is not simply identical to the composition preserved in 4Q510, as scholars have assumed generally. It is more likely that they represent differing recensions of the same work or two different works, one of which has depended on the other, or both of which have depended on a common source.
Since the discussion must be limited, the presentation will focus on two items. First, how did I determine finding 1, 3, and 4 listed above? Second, the ultimate test of the validity of a proposed reconstruction is whether or not the resulting text makes sense. I will discuss one clear case where continuous text from separate fragments has been restored: from the bottom of the eighth reconstructed column, represented by frg. 30, to the top of the ninth column, represented by frgs. 44-47. I contend that the restored text constitutes a sectarian interpretation of Isa 40:12-13.
|
Too Good to Be True? The Female Pronoun for God in Num 11:15
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Nicholas Ansell, Institute for Christian Studies, Toronto
Given the sustained attention shown to issues of gender in the Hebrew Bible over the last forty years, it is remarkable that the prima facie presence of a female pronoun for God in Num 11:15 has received so little recognition—despite the reference in v.12 to a maternal role for God that Moses is all-too-keen to avoid for himself. Although it was accepted by Rashi and Nachmanides, the arguments against a female pronoun today appear formidable. Some assume that the final consonant of the standard male pronoun—aleph-tav-he—has simply been lost, leaving us with what looks like the standard female form. Others point to the male grammar of the rest of the sentence as evidence that a female reading is unnatural in the extreme. The most common explanation, reflected in the lexica, is that the female-looking pronoun is actually a rare male form. Among the six or seven other examples of this alleged phenomenon is the use of the same pronoun to refer to Moses in Deut 5:27. But while the Masoretes suggest a vowel pointing that compensates for a ‘missing’ final consonant in most of these texts, the fact that they did not do so for Num 11:15 or Deut 5:27 should give pause for thought. This paper will argue that the female pronoun in Num 11:15 not only deliberately punctuates the male grammar of the sentence but functions as a catchword that allowed those who are being cited in Deut 5:27 to use Moses’ earlier rhetoric against him. If both passages allude to the maternal role that Moses is initially determined to avoid, then the female pronoun for God in Num 11:15 may finally be given the attention that it deserves.
|
Hellenistic Influence on the Design and Use of a Jewish Apocalyptic Site of Pilgrimage?
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Hugo Antonissen, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
This lecture aims to interconnect a number of textual, archaeological and cultural data. The textual data concern the shape and the function of the city described in Aramaic New Jerusalem (2Q24, 4Q554, 4Q554a, 5Q15 and 11Q18), written down in the second quarter of the first century B.C.E. The archaeological data are related to Hellenistic Alexandria in the first decade of the third century BCE. The cultural data are drawn from the Greek symposium tradition. The city textually described consists in an enormous number of identical modules, arranged in square insulae, i. e. well defined enclosed fields of space with four entrance gates. The manuscripts focus on twenty-two beds, eleven locked/lockable windows and a canal/gutter. The Largest Peristyle in Alexandria is organized in the same way. Its units are identified as andrones, rooms containing sofa's and designed in order to arrange symposia. The Aramaic text suggest symposia linked activities in the insulae. Phrases like "in the rooms of joy" (11Q18 18: 6) and "they eat/will eat and they drink/will dr[ink .] (11Q18 25: 6) fit well in this perspective. The outer gutter on the side of the sofa's or the windows (4Q554a II 8) can be connected with the cleaning of the rooms once the symposium was over. The regular design of the city in the Aramaic text with its refined hippodamic ground plan, its insulae and its enormous number of identical modules does not seem to be meant for normal habitation on the one hand. On the other hand its shape is neither in contradiction with a purely military nor with a pilgrimage site. If one accepts the latter possibility then Jerusalem in its post-apocalyptic capacity was not a normally inhabited city and the pilgrims did not only come to Jerusalem to worship but also to participate in symposia.
|
Between Jesus and Paul: John's Bethsaida Disciples
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Mark Appold, Truman State University
The Fourth Gospel is the only biblical text that connects the five most prominent disciples of Jesus with Bethsaida, an Iron Age capital city which centuries later during the Herodian period emerged as a small culturally diverse fishing village on the north shore of the Sea of Galilee. Although the site had slipped from historical view by the 4th century CE, its location, discovered some twenty-five years ago, has led to significant archaeological discoveries and material finds that have helped to contextualize and to clarify the Galilean period of these five disciples, two of whom had earlier been followers of John the Baptist. These Jesus followers were Peter and Andrew, the two sons of Zebedee --James and John, and finally, Philip. In sync with the crucifixion of Jesus and the resurrection appearances, all five of the Bethsaida disciples left their homes and their work in the Galilee and relocated in Jerusalem. There, James the Elder was the first to be martyred, Peter and John assumed early leadership roles in the emerging Jesus community, while Philip and Andrew engaged in mission outreach. With increasing tensions between the Hellenists and the Hebrews and social/religious disruption in Jerusalem, the remaining four moved into the Diaspora and became known for their foundational contributions to the early Church. The aim of this study is to give a brief portraiture of each of th e five Bethsaida disciples and to document their contributions during the so-called oral period of the early Church, demonstrating how they, prior to Paul, moved out into the Hellenistic-Roman world with a kerygma shaped by their earlier association with the historical Jesus. In doing so, they set the patterns for resolving disputes and for formalizing essential teachings and practices for the next generation.
|
"Blind but Seeing"? Illusioned Sight or Disillusioned Blindness in Biblical Narratives and Saramago's Blindness
Program Unit: Science Fiction and the Bible (EABS)
Paraskevi Arapoglou, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki
The motif of blindness and its symbolism has played a significant role in biblical narrative causing much discussion among scholars. The aim of the proposed paper is to apply an alternative reading on Jose Saramago's Blindness by taking into account biblical narratives which evolve around the physical marker of blindness (e.g. John 9, Matthew 15:13-14, Luke 6:39-40) or the symbolic use of it (e.g. Mark 8:14-26). We will try to approach this motif by tracing intertextual connections between the different narratives and to examine whether this affliction, as it is described and experienced, works as a literary topos, both in the New Testament's texts as well as in this specific Saramago's work of fantasy. An effort will be made to clarify if the narrative element of blindness serves as an interpretative clue which will provide further insight and understanding of both texts. We will argue that by applying a combined form of intertextual comparison, literary criticism, and post-structural hermeneutics the two texts can get into dialogue that will bring new light to the symbolic content of blindness and sight. The questions that will be addressed are: 1) what is the true m eaning and reason of "blindness" in both texts?; 2) who are the ones that are really blind and what they represent in each text?; and finally, 3) how the biblical texts interrelate with Saramago's work and whether each one can elucidate the other?
|
“Oh, that I had in the desert a lodging place for travelers,” the Prophets and the City
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Rami Arav, University of Nebraska at Omaha
*
|
Rituals at the Kingdom of Geshur
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Rami Arav, University of Nebraska at Omaha
The little known, kingdom of Geshur, flourished during Iron Age II, (10th – 8th centuries BCE) and was situated at the east side of the Sea of Galilee. Excavations at Bethsaida carried out since 1987 revealed monumental buildings including the largest and the best preserved city gate ever found in the Southern Levant, as well as an extraordinarily preserved palace and a storage building. These are among other discoveries that suggest that this town was the capital city of the kingdom of Geshur.
The remarkable state of preservation enables us to explore the installations that served for religious rituals performed at the city gate. Clearly, during the biblical period city gates served as the heart of the political, economy and religious life of the city. The excavations unearthed five high places located in different spots at the city gate and are divided into three different categories. Two high places have steps leading to a podium and two high places were dubbed by us “direct access high places” for lack of steps or rampart leading to the podium. One high place located at the back of the gate was designated for sacrifice. There were seven steles scattered evenly at the city gate, a pair flanking the entrances and an iconic stele situated at the top of one of the stepped high place. The significance of these discoveries cannot be exaggerated. Despite the fact that high places are mentioned very frequently in the Bible, very few were discovered and often times found destroyed without recognition. This presentation will be illustrated with Power Point presentation.
|
Israel and Phoenicia Relations during the Days of Jeroboam II: The Archaeological Evidence
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible/Old Testament/Ancient Israel Studies (EABS)
Eran Arie, The Israel Museum, Jerusalem
In recent years the settlement pattern of southern Phoenicia during the Iron Age IIA has been discussed extensively. Settlement consisted of larger cities located along the coastal strip or in the fertile Acco plane, while in the highland areas there were medium-size fortresses that served to protect the border with the northern Kingdom of Israel. The Arameans, under Hazael, who had wrought destruction on numerous Israelite sites also put to the torch the Iron IIA settlements in southern Phoenicia. The destruction layers visible at Dor, Shiqmona, Tell Abu-Hawam, Tel Keisan, and Horvat Rosh Zayit bear testament to this devastation. However, while the destroyed Israelite sites were quickly rebuilt and reached their zenith during the reign of Jeroboam II, southern Phoenician sites during this period underwent a completely different process. In southern Phoenicia three main factors must be noted during the Iron IIB: (1) The Phoenician fortresses disappear. (2) Archaeological evidence from both Dor and Horvat Rosh Zayit show that they became Israelite sites instead of Phoenician. (3) Iron IIB occupational gaps were observed at Tell Keisan and Tell Abu-Hawam, and Achziv was either abandoned or drastically reduced in size. Therefore, it appears that the only southern Phoenician settlements to preserve their former identity during the Iron IIA to Iron IIB transition where Shiqmona, Atlit and Acco. These dramatic changes must reflect the might of Jeroboam II, who in the first half of the 8th century BCE ruled the northern Kingdom of Israel for over 40 years, and established Israel as the new dominant regional power following the defeat of Aram-Damascus by the Assyrians. That is, the Israelite territorial expansion under Jeroboam II, previously documented in the northeastern part of his kingdom, can now be shown to also include part of the area once under Phoenician rule in the Iron IIA.
|
Replacement Theology and Opposition to a Jewish Commonwealth, 1947–1987
Program Unit: Anti-Semitic Readings of the Bible
Yaakov Ariel, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
The establishment of the state of Israel in 1948, and the ongoing Arab-Israeli conflict stirred strong reactions in the Christian world. The varied opinions often related to different readings of the Christian sacred scriptures and pointed to a strong correlation between holding to Christian supersessionism and negative attitudes towards Israel. Churches and theologians did not recognize the Jews as heirs to biblical Israel and viewed Judaism as obsolete would not accept the right of Israel to exist. While many Christians have developed a moderately critical view of Israel, more hostile opinions are still grounded in Replacement Theology.
|
Jesus and the Devout Psalmist of Psalm 22
Program Unit: Study of the Historical Jesus (EABS)
Ville Auvinen, Theological Institute of Finland
As his last words – according to Mark – Jesus quoted the first verse of Psalm 22: “Eloi, Eloi, lema sabachthani?”. Why did Jesus choose this sentence? Does it express profound anguish, as the words as such would denote, or does it have an even hopeful aspect? The verse, taken as a separate sentence, has a very hopeless tone. To be forsaken by God is, at least for a devout Jewish man, the most dreadful fate he can imagine. Nevertheless, the reference to the first verse of the Psalm can be understood in another way. At least for the reader – or the listener – of Jesus' shout, the reference may create an allusion to the whole psalm. Psalm 22 as a whole is strictly a twofold prayer. In the first part the praying man does not seem to have any hope, but he is already as good as dead. But then, suddenly, there is a total change of mood, and the latter part of the Psalm is an overflowing thanksgiving, because God after all heard the pleas and did not forsake the praying man. Did Jesus – by quoting the first verse – still hope that God would act with him in the same way he acted with the psalmist? There is another synoptic saying, in Luke 18:7, which might be based on Psalm 22 and which might be an elaborated version of an authentic saying of Jesus. In this passage Jesus teaches about the certainty that God will answer to the pleas of his chosen ones. If Jesus taught – using Psalm 22 as an example – about how God answers and takes care, would he have forgotten this teaching, when he quoted the first verse of the Psalm on the cross?
|
A Question of Reflection: Three Models of the Woman at the Window
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Orit Avnery, Shalem College and Shalom Hartman Institute
Three women are presented by the biblical window: the mother of Sisera in Judges, Michal in the book of Samuel, and Jezebel in the book of Kings. In my lecture, I will focus upon the similarities and differences between these three women, comparing and contrasting the function of the window scene within their stories. Through this study, I will attempt to explain why the motif of the woman at the window is used in each of their stories. Three different models, I will propose, are presented to us through these stories. These models are crucial for the understanding of the relationship between the narrator and the woman portrayed, her fate and her sphere of action. To this end we will explore the three stories through a synchronic lens, focusing on each story and its own symbolic interpretation of the figure of the woman at the window.
|
The Seventy Bulls Sacrificed at Sukkot (Num 29:12-34) in light of a Ritual Text from Emar (Emar 6, 373)
Program Unit: Israel in the Ancient Near East (EABS)
Noga Ayali-Darshan, Bar-Ilan University
The paper deals with the seventy bulls offered at Sukkot according to Numbers 29—a number unparalleled in any other Israelite festival for which no persuasive explanation has been adduced to date. In light of the a ritual from the ancient Syrian city of Emar (Emar 6, 373:36-38), it is suggested that the custom reflects an ancient Levantine tradition of sacrificing seventy sacrifices to the seventy gods—the whole pantheon—during the New Year celebration. The evident transformation of the seventy gods into seventy nations by biblical scribes may explain the late rabbinic midrashic tradition according to which the seventy offerings made at Sukkot correspond to the seventy nations.
|
“The Jews” in the Liturgical Texts of Orthodox Holy Week
Program Unit: Bible in Eastern and Oriental Orthodox Traditions
Michael G. Azar, University of Scranton
Commemorating the final days and hours in the life of Jesus, Great and Holy Week stands as one of the most ancient and solemn weeks of the liturgical year. The liturgical hymns, in accordance with the gospel readings upon which each day is based, comprise sober reflections on the betrayal and desertion of Jesus by his disciples. With these reflections come, in varying degrees, ethically problematic rebukes of “Jews.” The Jews and Jewish characters of the New Testament are primarily, but not exclusively, presented as negative paradigms: They are associated with Judas; they are reviled as lawless; they are berated for rejecting Jesus.
Though many Western churches have removed from their liturgical texts such denouncements of Jews, they remain in the Holy Week texts of current Orthodox practice. The purpose of this paper is to analyze the rhetorical function of the “Jews” (or “Judeans,” as some recent translations have chosen) in the Holy Week services as practiced in contemporary Orthodox churches. Bearing in mind the thematic context of each day of Holy Week, this task will be pursued primarily in two ways: 1) by examining the place of the “Jews” (ioudaioi) in the chosen biblical passages in light of modern scholarship and 2) by examining how the liturgical hymns and verses use, mold, and interpret those passages. Special consideration will be given to patristic readings of the Jews in the New Testament and the ways in which those readings surface in the liturgical texts, with particular focus on the rhetorical function of the “Jews” in the formation and delineation of Christian identity. A concluding analysis will consider the ethical quandary in which these liturgical texts find themselves and possible solutions.
|
Stereotyping Exegesis: The Johannine Jews in Ancient and Modern Commentary
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Michael G. Azar, University of Scranton
Prior to WWII, Johannine scholarship devoted little time and attention to the gospel’s portrayal of the Jews. Even in the immediate aftermath of the war, when historians and theologians of the Jewish-Christian relationship frequently and increasingly raised critical issues regarding the gospel’s distinct portrayal, Johannine scholars rarely took up the subject. After the 1960s, however, the Fourth Gospel’s Jews became, and continue to be, a key feature of Johannine scholarship. This paper, in part, considers the historical, political, and theological motivations that have influenced these developments over the last fifty years. More specifically, this paper examines closely one key feature of Johannine scholarship on the gospel’s Jews: the frequent rejection of the entire Christian interpretative tradition as invariably hostile. Scholars of the last few decades frequently cite the internecine Wirkungsgeschichte of the Johannine Jews as the key reason why one now should direct critical attention toward John’s portrayal. Nonetheless, despite the central and motivating role that the Wirkungsgeschichte plays in these investigations, scholars frequently generalize and stereotype the entire Wirkungsgeschichte as uniformly negative, rather than investigate its diverse aspects closely. Recognizing the important place that the Wirkungsgeschichte must hold in examinations of the Johannine Jews, this paper questions the reasons for and effectiveness of such totalizing of the gospel’s Wirkungsgeschichte and considers the potential fruit that an analysis of the Fourth Gospel’s early reception in particular can offer to contemporary scholarship on the Johannine Jews as well as the Jewish-Christian relationship more broadly.
|
Logion 7 in the Gospel of Thomas: A Rhetorical/Structural Approach
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Constantine Babalis, Université Concordia
Numerous scholars facing logion 7 of the Gospel of Thomas consider that it includes a homoioteleuton. Others have approached the logion inter-textually, finding resolution for the “lion” motif and the enigmatic ending of the saying in the Coptic text of Plato’s Republic 588A-598C (NH VI, 5). In this paper I propose a synchronic reading that focuses on the rhetorical/structural analysis of logia 7-11, which have the notion of “oneness” as its central theme. According to scholarly consensus, Gos. Thom. implicitly or explicitly express the idea of reunification with the divine. It is my contention that this motif is the key to unraveling the ambiguity of saying 7.
|
Hearing the Apocalypse in Franz Schmidt’s Das Buch mit Sieben Siegeln
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
Joel Bacon, Colorado State University
In June of 1938 the Vienna Symphony premiered an oratorio by Franz Schmidt, Das Buch mit sieben Siegeln. A large-scale setting of text from the Book of Revelation, its powerful depiction of the end of days seems remarkably prescient in historical context. Although the composer could not have known how quickly war would develop, there are indications that he intended his work to present a timely message to his audience. On the occasion of the premiere, Schmidt commented: “It would be my greatest reward if this musical setting would bring today’s listener closer in spirit to this matchless poetry, whose relevance after eighteen hundred years is as great as the day it was written.”
Schmidt’s musical setting—now recognized as one of the great oratorios of the 20th century—is like the biblical libretto itself: a richly symbolic text for a volatile and dangerous time. Key to understanding Das Buch mit sieben Siegeln is hearing how the composer uses leitmotivs, orchestration, and other devices to give a sense of progression to the opening of the seals. Building to the seventh seal, Schmidt presents the final aria of the Lord as a deeply satisfying resolution to the musical, spiritual and political challenges of the apocalyptic vision.
|
Isaiah 10:16-19 and the Compositional History of the Isaianic Prophecies
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible/Old Testament/Ancient Israel Studies (EABS)
Csaba Balogh, Protestant Theological Institute of Cluj-Napoca
Recent studies on the history of composition of the Book of Isaiah generally recognise the secondary character of Isa 10:16-19 in relation to the prophecy against Assyria. It is generally presupposed that these verses elaborate on the famous anti-Assyrian pericope, Isa 10:5-15. Verses 16-19 are most often dated to the seventh century when the book of Isaiah was subject to a major re-edition, the so-called Assyrian redaction, or - more rarely - to the exilic period when the entire book underwent another process of re-reading. Deriving vv. 16-19 from either the late Neo-Assyrian or the Babylonian era involves, however, several difficulties and needs to be reconsidered. While accepting the secondary character of Isa 10:16-19 on its current location, this study proposes a different interpretation and date for this text and assigns it a basically different role in the compositional process of the prophecies in its context than it has so far been proposed.
|
Rebuilding the New World: Three Visions of The New Testament and Economics in 16th-Century Latin America
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Gregory A. Banazak, SS. Cyril and Methodius Seminary
When the first Christian evangelizers arrived in the New World, they viewed the reconstruction of the indigenous people's economic lives as part of the justice required by evangelization. Yet their knowledge of economics was limited by their mainly theological and canonical education as well as by the undeveloped state of the science of economics. Given this, and given the fact that they saw the Bible as a source book of all truth, they naturally turned to Scripture in their attempts at economic reconstruction. There they found what they regarded to be a vision of the economy from the perspective of the early Christians, a vision which directed their attempts at the economic reconstruction of the New World. In our presentation we will examine the interpretation of this vision as found in the book of Revelation, the Acts of the Apostles, and the Pauline Corpus by three different evangelizers: the early Franciscans who worked in Mexico City; Vasco de Quiroga (1470?-1565), the first bishop of Michoacán, Mexico; and Bartolomé de Las Casas (1474-1566), author, bishop, and community leader in Mexico, Central America, and South America. We will examine how their interpretation of the early Christians' views on the economy impacted local indigenous communities. Finally, we will draw conclusions about the value of Scripture for economics, criteria for discerning the truth of an interpretation of the early Christians' approach to the ancient economy, and the importance of considering the practical impact of one's interpretation of the relationship between early Christianity and the ancient economy.
|
Das Hohelied - eine Allegorie? Am Beispiel von Hld 8,5
Program Unit: The Song of Songs: Literal or Allegorical?
Gianni Barbiero, Pontificio Istituto Biblico - Roma (Italy)
The Song of Songs: An Allegory? The Case of Ct 8,5-6
It is typical of the Canticle that the initiative in love belongs to the woman, something that leaps to the eyes right from the beginning of the poem. This characteristic is confirmed in a paradigmatic way in the epilogue, 8,5cde: “Under the apple tree I awakened you, there your mother travailed, there she travailed and gave you to the light”. According to the MT, it is the woman who is speaking here. This is not compatible with an allegorical interpretation of the Canticle where the woman represents the human and the man the divine part of the amorous relationship. For the Old Testament, the initiative in love cannot come from man but from God.
It is significant that the Syriac version changes the gender of the suffixed pronouns so that the man becomes the subject of “awakened”. This interpretation follows the allegorical scheme according to which the initiative in love belongs to God. The ‘stage directions’ of Codex Alexandrinus and Codex Sinaiticus of the LXX have the same aim. It is thus no wonder that those modern translations which interpret the Canticle allegorically follow the Syriac version (cf. Robert-Tournay).
Despite the dominant allegorical tradition in medieval Judaism, the MT, as it has been handed down, speaks in favour of the poem’s original sense being literal. That does not remove the theological, transcendent dimension of human love, as the following verse demonstrates: “Love is a flame of Yah” (8,6). In the light of the preceding verse, it is not the love between God and man which is a “flame of Yah” but the sexual love which is involved in procreation.
|
Terms in the Bible and Their Incarnations during the Days of Second Temple, Mishnah and Talmud, and the Middle Ages
Program Unit: Judaica
Elinoar Bareket, Achva Academic College
In the Bible we meet a number of terms that are repeated in various forms, to a point where they become termini technici. This is especially true in terms related to the root Q-D-SH exemplified by holy convocation; the holy city; the Holy One. Similarly, the root O-H-L seems to refer to a related group, a people or a nation in the expressions "tabernacle of the congregation"; "to your tents O Israel"; "the tents of Kedar". Likewise, the root B-H-R is so used as a technical term in "Jerusalem which I have chosen"; "my servant whom I have chosen"; "my people, my chosen". These terms continue to be employed in different variations among the educated elite in later periods of the Second Temple, the Mishnah and the Talmuds. Echoes are also found in correspondence from the Cairo Genizah in the period of the Geonim. In each period, however, these terms undergo changes. At times the changes are significant when the meaning of the term is actually reversed, such as in the case of 'Am ha-Arets (the people of the land), and at times they are minor, in accordance with the spirit of the period and the needs of the elite class. I shall explore the social meanings of some of these terms, according to the Bible, and to show how they were transformed in everyday life in the social systems in the Jewish societies of the Mishnah and the Talmuds in Late Antiquity, and Jewish societies of the 11th century CE reflected in documents from the Cairo Genizah.
|
The Making of a Charismatic Leader: The Case of the Apostle Paul
Program Unit: Authority and Influence in Ancient Times
Jack Barentsen, Evangelische Theologische Faculteit
The paper argues that Paul's status as charismatic leader resulted from his successful negotiations in Corinth to regain his apostolic founder's role, as he was serving in Ephesus. It is thus no surprise that Paul's status as apostle appears quite uncontested in correspondence related to Ephesus (Ephesians, 1 Timothy). Arguing from current research on charismatic leadership, I demonstrate that the process of charismatic leadership attribution often occurs within the career of the leader as followers observe successful crisis leadership. This suggests that Paul probably did not gain charismatic status until after he had left Corinth, but that this most likely occurred during the later stages of his Ephesian ministry. This uncontested apostolic leadership status is reflected in correspondence relating to Ephesus. This analysis has important implications for the traditional trajectory from charismatic to institutional church development in Pauline circles.
|
Biblical and Patristic Authority Use in Saint Clement of Rome
Program Unit: The Reception of the Scripture in the Patristic Exegesis (II-VIII centuries) (EABS)
Alexandru Atanase Barna, Universitatea din Bucuresti
The lecture aims to emphasize how the use of biblical texts in St. Clement of Rome's Epistle can be understood as an appeal to a new type of authority. The author observes that between the Saint Clements's patristic authority and the authority of biblical text quoted inside his Epistle is a mutual sustaining. The text shows that St. Clement uses different levels of argumentation, each with its level of authority, in order to convince the Corinthians about his message. Those levels of authority are: the authority of Old and New Testament, the authority of common church prayer and spiritual life and his own authority as a leader of the church in Rome and follower of the Apostles (42, 61). The author observes that St. Clement uses typological constructions (e.g.:37.3) in which he develops different Old and New Testament schemas. Seen from the perspective of authority, those typologies are built and used as a new type of authority based on the way the biblical quotations, scenes and images are understood together with a quotidian experience of the church members, as also with a very common experience. The second part of the lecture aims to show a unitary way to read and understand the types of authority used by Saint Clement in his text. Old and New Testament are read in the light of a new historic (5) or quotidian (6) experiences, or as recent experiences of holiness in the church. The textual authority is taken-over (mimetai, 17.1) by the church authority confirmed in a prayer and peace experience (63), completely different from the political authority which generates suffering (45). For St. Clement, the unity between those different types of authority is assured by the authority of Jesus Christ, the Savior.
|
The Reuse of Ezekiel 20 in the Composition of Ezek 36:16-32
Program Unit: Prophets
Penelope Barter, University of St. Andrews
The Reuse of Ezekiel 20 in the Composition of Ezekiel 36.16–32
|
The Apostolic Fathers in the Great Uncial Biblical Manuscripts
Program Unit: Textual Criticism: Manuscripts & Methods
Dan Batovici, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
This paper offers a discussion of the significance of the presence of a number of less expected books in two of the great uncial biblical manuscripts, namely that of the Epistle of Barnabas and the Shepherd of Hermas in Codex Sinaiticus, and of 1 and 2 Clement in Codex Alexandrinus. Based on reception-historical considerations, it is argued, using the tripartite model proposed by the late F. Bovon, that these texts should be regarded as "useful for the soul" rather than "canonical".
|
Clement of Alexandria's Use of the Psalms as Authoritative Texts
Program Unit: Biblical Interpretation in Early Christianity
Dan Batovici, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
Notoriously, Clement of Alexandria uses texts from the Scripture along with Greek pagan texts, as well as various early Christian texts along with New Testament texts, "as expressions of a single divine voice, the discourse of God’s own speech" (Dawson); scholars are however generally quick to explain that all these texts are not held in the same esteem, but indeed used hierarchically: (what is good of the) the pagan literature and philosophy at the bottom, the Hebrew Bible as intermediary and the emerging New Testament as the pinnacle of divine expression (Cosaert). Yet when scrutinized closely, the third segment showed considerable variance, as there seem to be a number of non NT early Christian texts more important than at least some books of the NT (Brooks). On its part, this paper aims to revisit the evidence for the middle segment, and to put forward a clearer image of Clement’s use of the Psalms and the authority they enjoyed with this early Christian author in relation to other varieties of authoritative texts, Jewish, Christian or pagan.
|
Exodus 4:24-26: The Genesis of the "Torah" of Circumcision in Post-Exilic Discourse
Program Unit: Israel and the Production and Reception of Authoritative Books in the Persian and Hellenistic Period (EABS)
Michaela Bauks, Universität Koblenz - Landau
A text like Ex 4:24-26 shows in the literary context of chapter 4 some interesting insights for the legitimation of circumcision in the post-exilic discourse. Originally concerned with a blood ritual in a healing context, the small text is reused in the post-exilic discourse within a broader reflection on Mosaic Torah precepts concerning the offering of firstlings and their substitution by circumcision. Rabbinic texts (see Ned. 32a) proof a controversial discussion about the interpretation of this text due to its high quantity of gaps, but transmit clearly that it presents “the imperative of circumcision” as a Jewish ritual, which do not admit any delay since the day of Moses.
|
One, two, or three. . . ? The Confusion of the Trees in Genesis 2–3 and Its Hermeneutical Background
Program Unit: Stylistics and the Hebrew Bible
Michaela Bauks, Universität Koblenz - Landau
The crucial point in Gen 2-3 concerning the number of the trees in the midst of the garden was explained a long time by different strata within the narrative. Lastly some colleagues have defended - for good reasons - the literary unity of the text and have transferred the problem of the number of the trees in considerations about tradition history. But the problem is more complicated because the tree of life is traditionally a Sapiential term concerning the knowledge of the sage with a positive connotation. Therefore, I suggest that the indetermination concerning the trees in Gn 2-3 is an important stylistic element and takes functional significance for the interpretation of the text oscillating between different conceptions of life.
|
Dating Texts to the Persian Period: The Case of Isa 63:7–64:11
Program Unit: Persian Period
Richard Bautch, St. Edward's University
This study approaches the prayer in Isa 63:7–64:11 form critically and divides the text into seven sections. The subsequent analysis focuses on the Deuteronomistic language that pervades the text. Many sections feature terminology having to do with wrongdoing and retribution, and other expressions indicative of Deuteronomistic thought are attested as well. The terminological expressions differentiate themselves into strata or compositional layers that correspond roughly to the preexilic, exilic and postexilic periods. That is, the prayer dates to the 6th century B.C.E. with select sections more representative of the centuries prior and subsequent. The findings show that Deuteronomistic language (and by analogy the lexemes of other traditions such as P) can serve as the key to a more nuanced dating of a text such as Isa 63:7–64:11. The prayer in Trito Isaiah can be dated not simply to the Persian period but through it constitutive parts to earlier and later points within the epoch.
|
Deterior ac decolor aetas: Die Alttestamentliche Geschichte als vier Zeitalter der Menschheit im Cento Probae
Program Unit: The Reception of the Bible in Greco-Roman Tradition
Martin Bazil, Charles University in Prague
m alttestamentlichen Teil ihres umfangreichen Vergilcento versucht die spätrömische christliche Dichterin Proba eine Synthese zweier Geschichtskonzeptionen: der Geschichte der ersten Menschen nach dem Buch Genesis und der Erzählung von den vier Zeitaltern der Menschheit nach der vor allem durch Hesiod und Ovid verkörperten Tradition. Vor allem drei Abschnitte – das Leben im Paradies (Cento Probae, Vers 160-171), das Leben auf der Erde nach der Vertreibung der Protoplasten aus dem Paradies (Vers 276-284) und die Katastrophen nach dem Tode Abels (Vers 290-306) – zeigen klare Parallelen mit dem traditionellen Vorstellungsgut. Der Sinn einer solchen Synthese scheint der Versuch zu sein, eine Kluft in der historischen Identität der gebildeten christlichen Römer zu überbrücken.
|
Reading Cultural Memories in the Royal Psalms through the Lens of Wilfred Owen's "Anthem for Doomed Youth"
Program Unit: Writings (including Psalms)
David Beadle, University of Exeter
This paper supports the view that most of the royal psalms were either composed or substantially edited within post-monarchic com munities. However, scholars such as John Day who hold that it is most "natural" to assign a monarchic date to the royal psalms are correct that many royal psalms look like royal ritual texts. The paper therefore addresses the question as to why these psalms are written and presented as though they are archaic texts for use in royal rituals. Wilfred Owen's "Anthem for Doomed Youth," is used as a comparative example of remembered ritual presented as ritual text. Owen's poem is presented as though it is an early twentieth century English funeral liturgy, but it is in fact employing funerary images in a very different discursive context. Owen reifies culturally recognised symbols of innocent, early twentieth century English religiosity, enabling him to feed into wider discourses about English experiences of war. Drawing on ritual theorists (including Maurice Bloch, Catherine Bell and Roy Rappaport) to discuss particular examples of ritual performative practice represented in royal psalms, it is proposed that such textual representation of royal ritual is an effective and affective means of cultural discourse, because of the power of ritual language (and the sensoria this language evokes) in creating its own realities, authority and hierarchies. This representation of ritual reifies and reinforces cultural memories of the power and divine favour of monarchy, but is sometimes used also to critique, break apart and challenge these memories.
|
Additions and Omissions in Jeremiah’s Speech in Jeremiah 7
Program Unit: Editorial Techniques in the Hebrew Bible in Light of Empirical Evidence (EABS)
Uwe Becker, Friedrich-Schiller-Universität Jena
In Jer 7 unterscheiden sich MT und LXX in einem wesentlichen Punkt: Die LXX bietet einen kürzeren Text, der die Rede Jeremias (noch) nicht am Tempel lokalisiert. Gewöhnlich nimmt man an, die kürzere LXX-Fassung biete zugleich auch die literarisch ältere Gestalt der Erzählung (so z.B. E. Tov und H.-J. Stipp). Dann hätte man in der LXX einen „empirischen“ Beleg für eine literarkritische Operation im masoretischen Text. Diese communis opinio wird im Lichte eines neuen redaktionsgeschichtlichen Vorschlags zur Genese von Jer 7,1-15, der die Parallelüberlieferung Jer 26 einbezieht, kritisch bewertet: Es scheint, als stelle die LXX in Jer 7 eine gegenüber dem MT insgesamt jüngere literarische Stufe dar, in der die Vorlage bewusst gekürzt worden ist. Der Vortrag versteht sich deshalb als ein Plädoyer für eine differenziertere Sicht der Jer-LXX, die keineswegs durchgehend die ältere Textfassung widerspiegelt.
|
A Little Child Shall Lead Them: The Birth Narratives In Matthew’s Gospel as A Critique of Timocractic Leadership Approaches in the First Century
Program Unit: Authority and Influence in Ancient Times
Corné Bekker, Regent University
An observed repetitive-progressive pattern of the terms used to describe the leadership of Jesus in Matthew 2, points towards the author’s clear intention to remind the first readers of the Gospel that the honorable birth and promised leadership of Jesus take place in dishonorable and adversarial contexts. Matthew makes use of recitation, thematic elaboration and recontextualization of prophetic texts in the Hebrew Bible to present Jesus as the counter image of the prevalent timocratic leadership preferences in the Mediterranean world of the first century. The infancy narratives in Matthew’s Gospel present Jesus, in stark contrast to Herod the Great, as the promised leader whose leadership is marked by: (a) divine legitimacy, (b) kenotic lowliness, (c) a determined focus on followers, and (d) transformative presence. Matthew’s presentation of Jesus as the child leader who will shepherd his people, provides his first readers with a clear alternative in the conceptual construction and praxis of leadership in contrast to that of the “Herods and Ceasars” of their world.
|
Worship the Lord in the Beauty of Holiness: The Role of Aesthetics and Beauty in the Israelite Cultic Ritual System
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Daniel Belnap, Brigham Young University
Though God, like other ancient Near Eastern deities is described as one who is “beautiful," the Hebrew Bibles suggests that an appreciation of this beauty was an important element of the Israelite cultic system. Among the functions of the priestly clothing, is the explicit mention in Exodus 28:2, in which the clothing items are to be for “glory and beauty” (tipharah). This is reinforced in other biblical texts, particularly, both Chronicles and in the Psalms, where the performance of cultic ritual is summarized as worshipping in the “beauty of holiness” (hadarah), and in at least one reference (Psalm 27:4), the psalmist speaks of his desire to behold the ‘beauty’ (naam) of the Lord in order to inquire of God. These and other references suggest that aesthetic appreciation may not just be an byproduct of ritual, but an important part of the overall performance. Thus, this study will explore what it may mean to worship the beauty of holiness, and the necessity of beauty, or pleasing aesthetics in the rites of worship of the ancient Israel.
|
God’s Hesed in Felipe Godínez’s Biblical Dramas
Program Unit: The Bible in the Iberian World: Fundaments of a Religious Melting Pot (EABS)
Miguel A. Beltrán Munar, Universidad de las Islas Baleares
Felipe Godínez, priest, doctor of theology and dramatist, was tried by the Inquisition for Judaizing in his everyday-life, and convicted through an auto de fe in 1624. He was accused of introducing a Jewish conception of God’s essence and linking the relationship to the chosen people to the Ancient Testament notion of berit. In his theology, in his sermons, and, most importantly, in his dramatic output, especially in his two biblical dramas El arpa de David, now lost, and La reina Ester. What makes Godínez singular in the context of the Spanish Golden Age is that he justified theologically his everyday Judaizing, and translated his theology into artistic expression in his Comedias. We will try to prove in this paper that one of the main claims against him in the process, concerning God’s lack of freedom to break the promises He made to Israelites, to give them his help and assistance, was essentially true, as can be demonstrated by means of a detailed exposition of the notion of berit in one of Godínez’s later work, Las lágrimas de David, a rewriting of his earlier Comedia in which the conception of forgiveness is related to the biblical notion of ?esed.
|
Constructing and Remembering Ancestors: Genealogies in Chronicles, Negotiating the Seen and Unseen in the Mnemonic Landscape and Cross-Cultural Considerations
Program Unit: The Bible in the Twenty-First Century: Politization of Bibles and Biblization of Politics (EABS)
Ehud Ben Zvi, University of Alberta
This paper approaches the genealogies of Chronicles from a perspective informed by social memory, discusses the negotiation between the seen and unseen in the mnemonic landscape evoked by 1 Chr 1-9, which needless to say raises issues of gender, and concludes with a discussion of both cross-cultural considerations that underlie much of our approaches to the topic and their implications.
|
Re-negotiating a Putative Utopia and the Stories of the Rejection of Foreign Wives in Ezra-Nehemiah
Program Unit: Chronicles and Utopia (EABS)
Ehud Ben Zvi, University of Alberta
This paper argues that later than the putative time of the stories and from the perspective of readers who identified, at least to a large extent, with the characters of Ezra and Nehemiah evoked by these books, the stories of the rejection of the foreign wives in E-N contributed to the construction of not only an image of an utopian 'pure' Israel and a memory of a ‘memorable’ attempt to implement it, but also as a reminder that implementing ‘utopia’ ran, not surprisingly, into problems. These stories served, at least for some ancient readers, a ground on which they could (safely) explore (perceived to be) utopian 'purifying' constructions and their unfeasibility (both basic and contingent) and thus contributed to their ability to re-negotiate the boundaries and even character of their ‘utopia’ as well. Considerations about how reading E-N in a way informed by Chronicles contributed to this process will also be advanced.
|
Reticent Apocalypticism in the Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Jonathan Ben-Dov, University of Haifa
Basing itself on the still valuable study by Collins (1984), the paper will address two currently relevant issues. Attention shall first be given to the status of natural science in apocalypticism and in the DSS. This element was not counted by Collins among the characteristics of apocalypse, but should really be considered as such based on more recent finds. The second topic is the role of apocalypticism in the DSS in general. Collins was right to point out the down-playing of apocalypticism in Qumran literature. I aim to support this idea by adducing recent studies on the apocalyptic voice in the Book of Jubilees and in the DSS. The texts of the Yahad should be read as an attempt to limit and contain the apocalyptic imagination, rather than to amplify it.
|
The Greek Particle Hoti in Jn 10:26: A Proposal for an Alternative Translation
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Glyssie Mills Berberian, St. Sarkis Armenian Church
In John 10:26, the traditional English translation of the Greek particle hoti has been 'because', but does this translation choice fit the context best? This paper suggests that it does not and it explores another. While most uses of this particle do indicate a causal force, other instances require a resulting nuance such as 'so that' or 'consequently'. Some insight into John's meaning may be found in an examination of Aramaic usage of 'ci'. The history and the influence of current English translations on other translations will be investigated as well as the theological implications of the translation choice.
|
Tsedaqa and the "Community of the Scribes" in Post-Exilic Pentateuch: A Didactical Perspective
Program Unit: Israel and the Production and Reception of Authoritative Books in the Persian and Hellenistic Period (EABS)
Kare Berge, NLA University College, Bergen
The late, probably post-exilic Deut 4 (vv. 1-8) and 6:20-25 combine teaching / learning, Torah, and righteousness (tsaddiq, see v. 6). A comparison between the social and judicial laws (Prozessrechte) in Deuteronomy with the similar laws in the Covenant Code (Ex 22:26 // Deut 24:13; Ex 23:7-8 // Deut 16:19; see 25:1) also demonstrates that there is a special concern in Deut to combine laws and the notion of righteousness (tsedaqa, tsaddiq, tsedeq). This concern appears also in the general description of the people in Deut 9:4-5, and in 33:21, both probably very late texts.
This occupation with learning and rightheousness (tsedaqa) seems to be a central concern in the “final” edition of the Pentateuch (see Deut 18:19; in my reading also in Ex 9:29). We are here talking about “Torah-didacticism” in part defined by the word tsedaqa (and cognates).
This paper investigates the position of the terms tsedaqa / tsaddiq / tsedeq in the “Torah-didacticism” of the so-called final edition of the Pentateuch. The central issue in my paper is the relation between didacticism—a term used and defined by modern scholarship, but not very much subject to critical investigation—and the notion of righteousness. It is a common feature in ancient law-texts to combine wisdom and law. Another and not so much investigated area however is Deuteronomy’s utopian vision of Israel as a community of “learned scribes” studying the Book of the Torah of Moses (see my article about this in JHS 2012). The combination of (“democratized”) learning, law and righteousness appears as a new-comer in (post-) exilic biblical literature. In this paper, I will explore this combination with special regard to "didacticism," also seeking a social-historical setting for this didactical concern with tsedaqa.
|
Jesus, Maria, und die Apostel in der Kirchengeschichte des Nikephoros Kallistou Xanthopoulos: Ein Beitrag zur Spätbyzantinischen Bibelhermeneutik
Program Unit: The Bible in Byzantium: The Use and Abuse of Tradition
Albrecht Berger, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
*
|
A Rare Guest: The Messiah's Role in the Meal of the World-to-Come as Imagined by Jewish Apocalyptic Authors
Program Unit: Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha
Claudia D. Bergmann, Universität Erfurt
Jewish apocalyptic texts feature a number of blueprints for the world-to-come, one of them being the idea that the world-to-come will include an unendling feast prepared for the righteous. This meal may include phantastic foods such as manna, fruits from the Tree of Life, and Leviathan and Behemoth. It may take place at a meaning-laden location such as the reopened Garden Eden or the Mountain of God. Occasionally, a special guest is present at the table, the Messiah.
This paper will discuss the roles attributed to the Messiah in texts such as 1 En 62, 2 Bar 29, and 1 QSa 2. It will attempt to answer the question why the Messiah does not take a more prominent role in the Jewish apocalyptic literature imagining the meal in the world-to-come, a fact that is often surprising to people reading these texts with a New Testament background.
|
Grammar of Death in the Psalms
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible/Old Testament/Ancient Israel Studies (EABS)
Daniel Berkovic, Evandeoski Teološki Fakultet
Grammar of Death in the Psalms
relative to verbs of motion
The Psalter is a considerably more emotionally salient biblical book than any other part of the Scripture. Examining the emotional states of the Psalmist, his personal religious experience, and the way it is expressed in psalmodic literature is the objective of this paper.
The Psalmist often finds himself in emotion-inducing situations, which give rise to intense emotional stimuli. The way he speaks of his personal and religious experience is parrhetic, unhindered and direct (cf.parrhesia). He speaks openly of his displeasure (fear,resentment,anger), or pleasure (joy,hope,gratification). His reaction to mortal dangers and the fear of death is particulary fascinating.
The core of the Psalmist's emotional state is apprehension and unease in relation to his destiny. Existentialist anguish can be found in a number of Psalms, and not only within the lament group (cf.Pss 13; 22; etc.). His unease can be easily traced even in Psalms of confidence (cf.Pss 11; 16; etc.).
Several factors form the pretext to thanatophobic overtones. One is the threat from his pursuers and enemies, whoever they may be (cf. Pss 13; 18). Another is the Psalmist's mortal fear of being abandoned by God. This he regards as a death sentence. The Psalmist's anguish becomes an important leitmotif.
SUMMARY: The Psalmodic language of death carries a specific linguistic representation. While death is the ultimate cessation of motion, the dynamics of the linguistic representation of the Psalmist’s thanatophobia is anything but static. It is comprehensively conveyed by motional grammar and verbs of motion. Death is presented as departure; in directional terms it is downward movement (either to dust or to the Pit). In emotional terms it is physical and mental (psychomotor) agitation.
Finally, the Psalmist's experience is inherent to his piety, which is more than 'cultic mode of speech'.
|
The "Fourth Philosophy" and (Non)Violence
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism (EABS)
Fernando Bermejo-Rubio, Universidad Complutense de Madrid
What Flavius Josephus called "the Fourth Philosophy" is a hotly-debated issue. Although the historian established an explicit link between the movement founded by Judas the Galilean (and Saddok the Pharisee) and the revolt leading to the Jewish War, he tells nothing about the outcome of the insurrection or about the fate of its instigator(s). Uncertainty arrives to such a point that it has been recently argued that the Fourth Philosophy (and Judas' figure) might have been nothing but Josephus' concoction. But even when the existence of the Fourth Philosophy is assu med, the scanty evidence available allows scholars to take the most disparaging views, to the extent that there is no agreement about its nature and methods. According to some scholars, it was a violent ideology leading to armed revolt; according to others, it endorsed a kind of pacific resistance. My paper aims at reassessing the evidence concerning the Fourth Philosophy in the first half of the first century, and at shedding light on the variegated character of Jewish anti-Roman resistance.
|
The Process of Deification of Jesus and the Theory of Cognitive Dissonance
Program Unit: Psychological Hermeneutics of Biblical Themes and Texts
Fernando Bermejo-Rubio, Universidad Complutense de Madrid
The logic of the process through which the Jewish preacher Jesus the Galilean was exalted and even turned into a godlike figure by some trends in the Nazarene (later, Christian) sect, has been a hotly-debated subject in the last decades. The theory of cognitive dissonance (advanced by Leon Festinger) tackles the logic involved in the reactions of an individual or a group within a context of frustrated beliefs. Whilst this theory has been applied by several scholars (J. Gager, U. Wernick, D. Aune.) to the study of early Christianity, as far as I know it has not been specifically applied to the discussion about the process of deification of Jesus. My paper would explore the possibility that the theory of cognitive dissonance (which entails the concoction of several ra tionalizations and the need of reinforcing the group in order to reduce dissonance) might shed some light on the process which led most Christians to consider Jesus as a divine object of worship.
|
“Encyclopedic” Glosses in the Pentateuch
Program Unit: Editorial Techniques in the Hebrew Bible in Light of Empirical Evidence (EABS)
Christoph Berner, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
Among critical scholars, the existence of explanatory glosses in the Pentateuch has been widely acknowledged. As a rule, however, these glosses are identified and described by means of literary (diachronic) analysis, while the empirical evidence and technical aspects are frequently neglected.
The main section of this paper explores two cases of “encyclopedic” glosses (i.e. glosses explaining certain realia) in Exod 16:36 and Num 13:33aß which are (still) missing in certain textual traditions (4QpaleoExodm; LXX). In order to determine the original place and function of the two brief additions (marginal gloss / interlinear gloss / interpolation within the main text), special attention is paid to their syntactic structure and how they are related to their present context. As a result, it becomes clear that the two glosses have a distinct literary character and reflect different scribal techniques. The paper concludes with a brief outlook on a third test case in Exod 9:31-32 which represents yet a further version of an “encyclopedic” gloss and thus highlights the obvious complexity of the phenomenon.
|
The Poetry of the Qumran War Scroll (1QM)
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Moshe J. Bernstein, Yeshiva University
The so-called War Scroll (1QM) was one of the first seven scrolls discovered in Cave 1 at Qumran in the late 1940s. It describes the forty-year war that the Qumran sectarians believed would take place between the forces of good and evil in the eschatological era. Partly a military manual describing how the war should be fought and partly a theological tract justifying it and predicting its results, 1QM has long been considered one of the core documents reflecting the ideology and beliefs of the Qumran community.
There is one aspect of this text, however, that has been largely overlooked since its publication, and that is its poetic aspect. There is a series of prayers that are interspersed in the latter half of the text, and large segments of them (particularly in columns 10, 12 and 14) are often laid out as poetry when translated. It is clear that some of these passages share many of the characteristics of biblical and later Hebrew poetry (although there is certainly no agreement regarding what constitutes poetry in post-biblical Hebrew literature), and although some attention has been paid to the prayers in which they appear, much less has been paid to the literary features that make us think of them as poetry.
This paper initiates a study of these poetic passages in 1QM (and parallel textual witnesses when relevant) that will focus on their literary aspects. It will discuss the issues involved in the characterization of this material as poetry and present a close analysis of some of the poetic material.
|
Kenosis or No Kenosis? That's the Question
Program Unit: New Testament/Early Christianity/Rabbinic Studies (EABS)
Dorothea Bertschmann, University of Durham
The term ‘kenosis’ has long been associated with the interpretation of Philippians 2: 5-11, inspired by the phrase in v.7 ‘he emptied –?????se? – himself’. While ‘kenosis’ has often been explored from a doctrinal angle (the paradox of a self-emptying divinity), Pauline scholarship of recent decades has brought back ethical readings of the Philippian hymn (cf. particularly the work of Stephen Fowl): Christ embodies the binding ethical paradigm, the ‘lordly example’ (Hurtado) for the believers. This new emphasis encouraged some scholars to read Paul’s statements in Phil.3:2-11 as describing his own kenosis, which he in turn commends to the Philippian believers. Paul, it is argued, follows the two stage descent we observe in Christ’s case, foregoing privileges and accepting suffering and death. This reading has been fruitfully used by scholars who see Paul protesting against status and honour thinking among Greco-Roman elites rather than being preoccupied with Jewish circumcision (Wright, de Vos, Oakes, Cotter, Perkins); however, although he views Christ’s pattern as ethically binding, this paper argues that Paul does not talk about his own kenosis in Phil 3:2-11- the parallels with Phil 2: 6-11 are simply not strong enough. The way Paul shapes his argument in 3: 2-8 makes it clear that Paul much rather polemically discards than humbly renounces his Jewish privileges. This paper will suggest that while the conformity theme emerges later on (v.10f.) this is not the second step in a seamless downward movement. Instead conformity is dependent upon, though not in parallel, with a fundamental dichotomy between ‘my righteousness’ and ‘the righteousness of the law’. Exploring how these two levels might hang together will shed some new light on the still lively debate between the New Perspective and its recent critics.
|
Dispersing Blame: Strategies for Survival in Jeremiah, Lamentations, and Psalm 137
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible/Old Testament/Ancient Israel Studies (EABS)
Miriam J. Bier, London School of Theology
This paper reads Psalm 137 as survival literature, working with the rubrics of remembrance and imprecation. It looks to Kathleen M. O’Connor’s reading of Jeremiah as survival literature, and Tod Linafelt’s reading of Lamentations as survival literature, and highlights the different configurations of blame in each of these biblical books. These configurations (emphasizing human responsibility, and divine culpability in interaction with human responsibility, respectively) allow a community to reflect upon, and begin to make meaning out of, the experience of exile. The paper then examines Psalm 137, noting that in contrast to Jeremiah and Lamentations, there is no mention of human responsibility or divine culpability. The absence of any clear human responsibility (contra Jeremiah) or divine culpability in interaction with human responsibility (contra Lamentations) leaves the way open for the exercise of remembrance and imprecation as ways of “surviving” exile.
|
John 6:51c-58 and Docetism
Program Unit: Johannine Literature and Docetism (EABS)
Reimund Bieringer, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
The literary-historical provenance of John 6:51c-58 has long been disputed. Was it added by an ecclesiastical redactor or was it an integral part of the gospel from the beginning? Does its content, esp. its understanding of sarx harmonize with the remainder of the fourth gospel? In this paper we shall discuss the meaning of sarx in 6:51c-58 in comparison to the other occurrences of the word in 1:14, 3:6 and 6:63. We shall critically examine the hypothesis that 6:51c-58 is intended as an anti-docetic teaching. For this purpose we shall also compare 6:51c-58 to the preceding bread of life discourse.
|
The Bible and the Martyrs of Lyons and Vienne
Program Unit: Biblical Interpretation in Early Christianity
Jeffrey Bingham, Wheaton College (Illinois)
Invited
|
The Septuagint, the Church Fathers, and the “Hebraica Veritas”
Program Unit:
Elisabeth Birnbaum, Katholisch-Theologische Privatuniversität Linz
The question whether the Septuagint contained the true and unaltered word of God was of utmost importance for the Early Church. Early Christians lived in a Greek-speaking world. They spread the Gospel in Greek, they wrote letters and homilies in Greek and based their doctrine on a Greek translation of the Scripture. Unfolding the story of Jesus of Nazareth, the gospels use quotations, testimonies and prophecies from the Septuagint. But the text of Septuagint sparked also controversies, since it differed from the Hebrew considerably. So Rabbinic Judaism, in the first case, looked at the Septuagint with suspicion. When Jerome, too, opted for the “Hebraica veritas”, he drew enormous criticism. The problem was twofold: Firstly, in order to understand the Hebrew Bible, one had to study the Hebrew language. Relying on Jews and Jewish expertise, however, seemed not to be without risk for a Christian exegesis. Secondly, crucial doctrines of the Church and their interpretation relied on the Septuagint translation, Isaiah 7 just being one famous example. The lecture exposes the theological premises, problems and consequences of the (sometimes bizarre) dispute about the "true" text.
|
The Female Lover of the Song of Songs, the Church Fathers, and What’s Love Got to Do with It?
Program Unit: Biblical Women in Patristic Reception
Elisabeth Birnbaum, Katholisch-Theologische Privatuniversität Linz
*Her name is Sulamith, she is the “beloved”, the “dove”, the “fairest among women”. For today’s biblical scholars she is a self-confident woman, in love with her friend. In the perspective of Ambrose, Origen and Gregory of Nyssa, however, she is the church, or the individual soul, longing for God. The paper unfolds the reasons for and the consequences of these interpretations. What would happen if the female lover of Song of Songs were not a woman who loves a man, but a human being who loves God? Why is it that allegoric readings have been rejected harshly at least after Herder? Two contrasting consequences seem to be feared: a) Allegorical readings mitigate and depreciate erotic love. Thinking of erotic love in other ways as of sexual love between two human beings seems to neglect and tame human sexuality for the sake of piety. b) Allegorical readings mitigate and depreciate the sanctity of God. At the end of the 19th century, Christian D. Ginsburg asked with sheer embarrassment: „Would not our minds recoil with horror were we to hear a Christian using it … to illustrate the love of Christ for his Church?“ But even more recent, Duane A. Garrett maintains: „Sexual language should not be brought into the vocabulary of worship and devotion ….“. So the main question is: Does an allegoric interpretation always mean to despise either eroticism or spirituality? In other words: What’s love got to do with the allegorical readings of the Song of Songs?
|
Glimpses of American Religious Romanticism from the Great War
Program Unit: Bible and Its Influence: History and Impact
Mark Blackwell, Francis Marion University
“You who fought for France with a mystic passion,
Soaring fierce and lonely above the thunder,
Fiery one, aggressor in fifty combats,
Ever the bravest;”
This verse from Paul Mowrer’s eulogy to American aviator Kiffin Rockwell reveals currents of religious romanticism emerging during the Great War. Religious thought, predominantly shaped by Christianity, induced Americans to perceive the “call to arms” as an opportunity for faith in action on the world stage. This paper draws upon private sources (diaries, letters, and remembrances) which impart biblical and religious imagery surrounding combatants in the Great War toward exploring the links between warfare, religion and an emerging American consciousness in the twentieth century.
|
Souls under the Altar: Early Chiliast Interpretations of Rev 6:9-11
Program Unit: Biblical Interpretation in Early Christianity
Craig Blaising, Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary
In keeping with the session theme on martyrdom, this paper will focus on early chiliast interpretations of Revelation 6:9-11. The paper will examine how this passage was used to support the view that martyrs ascended to heaven at death and how that interpretation was coordinated with chiliast readings of Revelation 20 as teaching a future millennium on earth.
|
Did Paul Have a “Policy” Regarding Financial Support?
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Thomas R. Blanton, IV, Lutheran School of Theology at Chicago
In a 1979 article, Wilhelm Pratscher argued that although Paul unequivocally asserted that he had a “right” to economic support from the communities to which he preached, under certain circumstances, he saw fit to waive those rights and rely on self-support through manual labor. There were two conditions under which Paul would characteristically waive his “right” to support: 1) he did not accept support from communities in which he was currently working, but received donations after he had moved to another region; and 2) he did not accept support when he feared doing so would be used as grounds to undermine his credibility as an “apostle.” There are two problems with this view: 1) it is likely that Paul did in some cases accept support from communities in which he was currently working (probably even in Corinth; cf. Rom 16:23); and 2) judging from 1–2 Corinthians, his legitimacy appears to have been undermined due to his failure to accept support, not his acceptance of it. The paper offers a new proposal concerning Paul’s economic “policy” that takes into account his early training as a missionary-tradesman under Barnabas in Antioch, as well as his flexible and evolving attitudes regarding the acceptance of hospitality in Corinth. (Proposal submitted for second project.)
|
Biblical Allusions and Sources in the Gabriel Vision
Program Unit: Reception of Scripture in Second Temple Literature
Amanda M. Davis Bledsoe, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
The somewhat recently discovered Gabriel Vision is a Hebrew text, which in format closely resembles the Dead Sea Scrolls, with the exception that it is written in ink on stone rather than on parchment or papyrus. Reconstruction and interpretation of this fragmentary text has led to significant debate among scholars. Controversy has primarily centered around Israel Knohl’s hypothesis that the Vision describes a messianic figure, the Danielic “Prince of Princes,” who is killed and resurrected on the third day. Although most scholars disagree with Knohl’s interpretation of the text, nearly all agree that the Gabriel Vision does exhibit striking similarities with the book of Daniel (e.g., John Collins, Matthias Henze). It has even been suggested that the biblical book served as the primary source for the Gabriel Vision and that it is the key to understanding the overall message of the text (so, Daewoong Kim). In this paper, I will examine the purported parallels between the Gabriel Vision and the book of Daniel, as well as identify allusions to several other biblical texts. It is my conclusion that Daniel was but one among several texts used or known by the author of the Gabriel Vision. Further, some of these other texts have even stronger links to the Vision than does Daniel and when brought into discussion can improve our understanding of this enigmatic text.
|
The Earliest Persian Period Prophetic Texts
Program Unit: Persian Period
Joseph Blenkinsopp, University of Notre Dame
After a statement about the material available for dating biblical prophetic texts in the early Persian period, i.e. through the reign of Darius I, there follows a critical discussion of recent and not so recent redactional studies of Isaiah 40-55 which displace essential parts of this text from the late Neo-Babylonian period to the early years of the reign of Darius I, or later. It will then be necessary to consider how these proposals fit with the chronological data in Haggai, Zechariah 1-8, Ezra, and non-biblical sources, especially the Bisitun Inscription.
|
The Psychospiritual Importance of Being Earnest: Why Did the Disciples Worship Jesus So Early after the Resurrection?
Program Unit: Psychological Hermeneutics of Biblical Themes and Texts
Kamila Blessing, St. John's Episcopal Church (Wilmington, NC)
The gospels contain numerous passages where the disciples fail to understand Jesus’ teaching. The common interpretation of such passages is that (1) the disciples are ignorant of Who is before them because they are so earth-bound in their thinking; the reader is supposed to recoil from their reaction and acknowledge the Passion; and (or) (2) the disciples did not want to deal with the implications of what they had heard, particularly about Jesus’ impending death; the reader is supposed to affirm the resurrection. The one thing that can be said about the disciples is that they are earnest in such faith as they have.
A closer look at these passages in the total context of the gospel and of the human psyche presents another, larger meaning for them. According to Psychiatrist Milton Erickson, any person – bound up in his own concept of the world – can be brought to what he calls the “creative moment.” If something occurs that temporarily disables all of the person’s usual responses, suddenly a new response can come about, on a different conceptual level, and bearing sometimes blinding new insights. This is the essence of metanoia! I propose that in the gospel story: (1) the disciples begin in a truly earth-bound state of understanding, but earnestly seeking Jesus’ teaching on an emotional and intellectual level. This state of things is the necessary “ground” for what follows. (2) The resurrection appearances stun them into an inability to voice the usual responses of fear, unbelief, or any purely intellectual response. They are suddenly completely open to perceptions never before encountered and to Jesus as unique – indeed, divine. Hence the sudden and early worship of Jesus by his earliest disciples – and the psychospiritual importance of being earnest.
|
The Glory of God and the Praise of Men: Textual Variants in Phil 1:11 and Reception in the Early Church
Program Unit: Textual Criticism: Manuscripts & Methods
Isaac Blois, University of St. Andrews
Most scholars working on Philippians try to stay out of the thorny textual issues involved in the manuscript evidence for 1:11 (some notable exceptions are Schenk, Reumann, J. M. Ross, Silva). The problem emerges from the conclusion of Paul’s introductory prayer for the congregation with a pseudo-doxology (eis doxa kai epainos theou). It has been pointed out that the second of these two terms (epainos – “praise”) is seldom used for praise to God in the New Testament (only in Eph. 1:6 and, possibly, here), corresponding to its use in the old Greek versions of the Hebrew Bible, where it is almost always used in reference to a human as its object (cf. Preisker, TDNT 2:586). The manuscript tradition of this verse provides alternate readings (specifically, adding the term moi in F, G, and Ambst., or emoi in P46 – “praise to me”) that, while not possessing strong merit externally, do corroborate this linguistic evidence in addressing who it is that Paul envisions receiving praise at the eschatological judgment.
While the purpose of this paper is not to argue for the P46 reading as original, what it does attempt to do is to set up a plausibility structure for why such a reading would have been acceptable within early theological trends of the Christian communities. In order to do this, I will first explore the ways in which Paul follows the trajectory of the LXX use of epainos for divine approval of human actions in the Philippians epistle itself, and then, second, I will demonstrate how this theme was taken up and developed by certain early church writers among the Apostolic and Church Fathers.
|
The Rhetorical Roles of Prayer in the Book of the Twelve: Prophetic Cry and Theodicy, Communal Lament, and Penitence
Program Unit: Prophets
Mark Boda, McMaster Divinity College/University
This study investigates the role of prayer forms in the rhetoric of the Book of the Twelve, focussing attention on the use of the cry of the prophet on the one hand and that of the community on the other. The cries of the prophet to the deity occur throughout the Book of the Twelve at several intervals (e.g., Amos, Habakkuk) where they are linked to the development of theodicy, while the cries of the people to the deity (e.g., Joel, Jonah) are linked to the development of penitence. The introductory pericopae in Zechariah represent a key point in the collection where the two prayer forms intersect, suggesting a relationship between these two themes as key to the message of the collection as a whole.
|
Polemical Uses of the Bible in 17th-Century Inquisition Trials of "Judaizers"
Program Unit: The Bible in the Iberian World: Fundaments of a Religious Melting Pot (EABS)
Miriam Bodian, University of Texas at Austin
Certain defiant, educated "judaizers" tried by early modern Spanish and Portuguese inquisitorial tribunals defended their belief in "The Law of Moses" on the basis of key verses from Scripture, making use of the Vulgate Bible. In prosecuting these cases, inquisitors and prisoners alike found themselves resorting to the classical Jewish-Christian polemical arguments over Scripture that had been sharpened over the course of centuries. But the ground had shifted. By the seventeenth century, certain "judaizers" were able to challenge orthodox Catholic interpretation of Scripture with new confidence, enjoying support from humanist and Protestant biblical scholarship. They challenged the accuracy of the Vulgate, either in a general way or in respect to certain verses. They were confident that a literal (or "simple") reading of Scripture was the most reliable, and rejected as far-fetched elaborate christological readings of historical narratives. Their idea of what "rational" meant with regard to Scripture drew from the contemporary discourse of natural reason. In this paper, I would like to examine closely the lengthy arguments made in 1645 by a defiant "judaizer" who had lived for several years in a Dutch Jewish community, as well as the 33-page reply to those arguments by an inquisitorial "qualificador" (expert theologian) in Lisbon. The paper will explore the profound differences in how the defendant and the qualificador understood the nature of Scripture. It will explore which scriptural sources the two participants in the "debate" viewed as important, and how these sources did or did not conform to sources marshalled in earlier polemics. Although the paper can cover only limited ground, it is hoped that it will also offer an example of how Inquisition material can profitably be used for biblical research.
|
Isaac's Blood, Abraham's Joy: Pseudo-Philo and the Akedah
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible/Old Testament/Ancient Israel Studies (EABS)
Tavis Bohlinger, University of Durham
How does Pseudo-Philo present the Akedah, and what does this disclose about Jewish interpretation of Israel’s foundational narrative in the 2nd Temple Period? Pseudo-Philo's haggadic retelling of Israel’s scriptures is one of the earliest and most important examples of Jewish interpretation of Scripture from Early Judaism. The Akedah, Abraham's offering of Isaac (Gen 22), is referenced and elaborated upon at three critical junctions in Pseudo-Philo’s narrative. These include Balaam’s sacrifice (18.1–6), Deborah’s song (32.1–4), and the song of Jephthah’s daughter (40.2). An additional allusion to the Akedah in the speech of Kenaz (27.6, 12) further demonstrates the importance of the scriptural narrative to Pseudo-Philo. At each of these points, the faithfulness of God to disobedient Israel is anchored in the promises to the ‘fathers.’ This paper will explore the key motifs of 'covenant', 'sacrifice', 'blessing' and ‘mercy’ as expounded in Pseudo-Philo’s Akedah references, thereby shedding light on his hermeneutical logic. I will propose that the Akedah functions as a hermeneutical key for Pseudo-Philo and lays the foundation for his understanding of God’s mercy as rooted in the ‘fathers’ due both to their blameless character and to their obedient acquiescence. This paper will serve to reframe the discussion of the Akedah in Pseudo-Philo by moving it beyond the traditio-historical analyses of Daly, Davies-Chilton, Hayward, Levenson and Fisk into the sphere of theological interpretation of the text in its own right.
|
Constantine and the Jewish “Prophet” Who Predicted the Overthrow of Rome
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
Douglas Boin, Saint Louis University
“‘Memphis’ and ‘Babylon’ have received a just reward for their wayward worship, left desolated and uninhabited, together with their gods,” the emperor Constantine said in 325 A.D. Scholars who diverge about the significance of Rome’s first Christian ruler are surprisingly unanimous in their interpretation of this passage; Constantine is stating that he saw military action in Egypt and Mesopotamia (Barnes 2011, 51–52; Lenski 2012, 60; Potter 2013, 223). This paper suggests an alternate reading. To fourth-century Christians, “Memphis” and “Babylon” were not places on a map. They were theological code words, drawn from a forged “prophecy” which had been circulating two centuries earlier among Jewish dissidents who were seeking the overthrow of Rome and a return to the Jewish homeland. This text, known today as the Fifth Sibylline Oracle, has never been recognized as a relevant to our understanding of Constantine's speech. Here, I draw upon biblical scholarship in the field of “apocalyptic literature” to provide historical context for it and for the rise of apocalyptic language in fourth-century Rome. A study of this latter phenomenon—which exposes serious rifts within the empire’s Christians about how or whether they would accommodate to mainstream culture—has been under-appreciated by historians interested in the religious transformation of the Roman Empire.
|
Sabbath Observance, Sabbath Innovation: The Hasmoneans and Their Legacy as Interpreters of the Law
Program Unit: Law and Narrative (EABS)
Francis Borchardt, Lutheran Theological Seminary, Hong Kong
Both 1Maccabees and 2Maccabees portray the Sabbath law as a central point of contention during the struggle over Judean law and tradition in the second century BCE (e.g. 1Macc 1:41-50; 2Macc 6:4-6). The Hasmonean family in particular is at times highlighted as holding the Sabbath in high regard (2Macc 5:27). In every available source, there is no question of the commitment to the inherited traditions concerning the Sabbath. However, in two passages, 1Macc 2:29-41 and 9:43-53, the Hasmoneans are portrayed as acting in a way not supported by any extant writings associated with Judean legal tradition: they engage in battle on the Sabbath. 1Maccabees presents this as innovation on the part of the Hasmoneans. Josephus, who summarizes these events based upon 1Maccabees, even recognizes this decision as the basis for normative practice (Antiq. 12.272-277). 2Maccabees makes no such notice. As several scholars (e.g. Bar-Kochva, Doran) have pointed out, this event could hardly have been the first time in Judean history the issue arose. Yet, the report in 1Maccabees becomes the basis for law. This paper will try to solve the problem of how such a "late" narrative text comes to be regarded as law by Josephus. In doing so it will examine the interplay between 1Maccabees, 2Maccabees, and Josephus, and the various Sabbath texts in the inherited legal tradition.
|
Anti-Semitic Exegesis of the New Testament 1900–1945 in Transnational Perspectives: From Rudolf Kittel (1853–1929) to His Son Gerhard (1888–1948)
Program Unit: Anti-Semitic Readings of the Bible
Lukas Bormann, Friedrich-Alexander-Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg
In 1912 the community of German Jews sued Theodor Fritsch (1852–1933), the editor of the “Handbook of the Jewish Question”, for defamation of the Jewish religion and also for blaspheming the God of both Jews and Christians. The Royal Court of Saxony asked the outstanding Biblical scholar Rudolf Kittel (1853–1929) to give a final report about the issue. Kittel came to the conclusion that Fritsch was either mentally ill or morally insane. However, in 1943 the Tuebingian Theological Faculty presented a report to the German high court for finance about the question of whether the Bible should be seen as contradicting the “views of the German people”. In this report the dean of the faculty Artur Weiser (1893–1978), assisted by his colleague Gerhard Kittel (1888–1948), the son of Rudolf Kittel, quoted extensively from the “Handbook of the Jewish Question”, now published by the SS, as a reliable scholarly source. What happened between 1912 and 1944 in German Biblical scholarship that the anti-Semitic exegesis of an outspoken political and racial anti-Semite and non-academic figure such as Fritsch came into use by leading Biblical scholars? And particularly, what led to the radical change in opinion between the generations of father Kittel and his son Gerhard? In my paper I will also deal with certain transnational aspects of the topic, particularly the German-British and also German-American scholarly networks in these times.
|
Schriftgebrauch im Kolosserbrief und Epheserbrief
Program Unit: Schriftrezeption bei Paulus und in der Paulustradition: Reception of Scripture in Paul and Pauline Tradition
Lukas Bormann, Friedrich-Alexander-Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg
Der Kolosserbrief enthält weder Zitate aus dem Alten Testament noch erwähnt er biblische Personen oder Ereignisse. Das ist im Epheserbrief anders. Insbesondere in paränetischen Kontexten greift dieser z.B. die Tradition des Judentums des zweiten Tempels auf (vgl. Kol 3,18–4,1 mit Eph 5,31/Gen 2,24 und Eph 6,2f./Ex 20,12), nach der die Ethik aus dem Dekalog abzuleiten ist (z.B. Philo, Dec 106-120; Jos, Ant 3,90-93). Die vergleichende Analyse des Schriftgebrauchs in diesen beiden Schriften der Paulustradition ist besonders aufschlussreich, insbesondere unter der Annahme, dass der Epheserbrief in weiten Teilen vom Kolosserbrief literarisch abhängig ist.
|
The Meaning of 1 Kings 19 in the Vienna 2554 Bible Moralisée
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Culture
Anne-Marie Bos, Titus Brandsma Instituut
Bible moralisée is a medieval genre of presenting biblical stories in a serial of paired miniatures: one miniature depicts an element of a biblical story; the other miniature presents a typological reading of that element of the story in the perspective of the Church. To each miniature, a written commentary explicates the depicted typological interpretation. In contrast to the genre of the biblia pauperum, a bible moralisée primarily depicts and interprets stories from the First Testament.
The best known illuminated manuscript of this genre is the Vienna 2554 Bible Moralisée (Vienna, Österreichische Nationalbibliothek, Codex Vindobonensis 2554). This short paper shall focus on the story of 1 Kings 19, as presented in this manuscript. We will look at the paired miniatures and ask ourselves what those pictures present to us. What kind of biblical spirituality is presented here? Is the typological interpretation relevant to us today?
|
Psalm 23 as an Intertext: A Text between Proverbs and Jeremiah
Program Unit: Writings (including Psalms)
Phil J. Botha, University of Pretoria
Psalm 23 is probably the best known and most loved psalm because of its easily imaginable ?connections with David, the father of psalmody. However, its careful parallel construction ?and multiple intertextual connections with all three segments of the Hebrew Bible suggest ?that it is the product of an accomplished post-exilic theologian rather than a shepherd king. In ?this paper the less well-known connections with Proverbs and Jeremiah will be investigated in ?order to attempt to substantiate the thesis that the theology of Ps 23 in its present shape was ?inspired inter alia by the book of Proverbs and that it in turn also served as a source for parts ?of the book of Jeremiah. Whether it represents a chokmatic revision of an earlier composition ?or the original genius of a wisdom composer will be tabled for discussion. ?
|
Transcriptional Probability in the Recent Text-Critical Debate on Mk 1:1
Program Unit: Textual Criticism: Manuscripts & Methods
Max A. Botner, University of St. Andrews
Among the text-critical issues perennially debated is the question of whether or not ???? ?e?? (“Son of God”) belongs in Mark 1:1. While English scholarship has typically operated under the assumption that ???? ?e?? belongs in the text, this trend may be shifting. Since 1991, the majority of text-critical studies on Mark 1:1 have strongly argued in favor of the shorter reading. In addition, two of the most renowned commentaries on Mark’s Gospel now advocate the shorter reading. An examination of the recent studies in favor of the shorter reading indicates that their conclusions are all highly dependent on two assumptions surrounding transcriptional probability: 1. the assumption that a scribe would not omit the nomina sacra in the first verse of Mark, and 2. the assumption that a text lacking ???? ?e?? is theologically harder, and, therefore more preferable, than a text including it. This paper tests both these assumptions against the most recent evidence. It begins by pointing out that early scribal activity is characterized by a strong proclivity towards omission. Then, it adduces a large sample of scribal omissions of the nomina sacra in the opening verses of New Testament documents (both in Mark’s textual tradition as well as in the tradition of other NT documents). Finally, it examines the theological function of Mark’s opening in patristic citations. A thorough analysis suggests that the presence or absence of ???? ?e?? had no discernible effect on the significance of Mark 1:1 for these sources. As a result, it is concluded that neither assumption should remain decisive for making a text-critical decision on Mark 1:1. This, in turn, leads to the conclusion that the longer reading is more likely to be the initial.
|
Relics of Biblical Kingship between Jews and Christians in Byzantium
Program Unit: The Bible in Byzantium: The Use and Abuse of Tradition
Ra’anan Boustan, University of California-Los Angeles
*
|
What Shall We Remember, the Deeds or the Faith of Our Ancestors? 1 Maccabees 2 and Hebrews 11
Program Unit: Epistle to the Hebrews
Christian Brady, Pennsylvania State University
Similarities are often noted between the final exhortation of Mattathias to his sons (1 Macc 2:49ff) that they "remember the deeds of the ancestors" and the admonition of the author of Hebrews that his audience should consisder the "faith of our ancestors." In this paper I will offer not only a close (albeit abridged for time) reading of the two passages, but suggest that the author of Hebrews 11 was influenced by 1 Maccabees 2 and did so on the assumption that his audience would know the passage. Thus Hebrews 11 should be read against 1 Maccabees 2 and in so doing interesting similarities and contrasts emerge.
|
The Passover Sacrifice: From "House" to "Company"
Program Unit: Judaica
Itzhak Brand, Bar-Ilan University
The focal point of the Passover Sacrifice, as prescribed in the Bible, is the house. This is true for the first Passover in Egypt(Exod. 12:3–4)as well as of the Law of the Passover Offering for the generations—“It shall be eaten in one house: you shall not take any of the flesh outside the house…” (Exod. 12:46).
The biblical requirement that the Passover Sacrifice be eaten “in one house” and the ban on taking the meat outside the house are unequivocal. Nonetheless, the mishnaic Sages interpreted these verses differently. According to their exegesis, the Passover Sacrifice may be eaten outside the house—in the courtyard or garden—and even in two or more houses. The Sages converted the “house” into a “company” and rules that the obligation is to eat the Passover Sacrifice in a single company, from which the meat may not be removed.
The Sages expressed their treatment of a “company of people” as a “house” in two laws with spatial aspects. According to one of them, any meat from a Passover Sacrifice that has been removed from the company may not be eaten—just like the meat of offerings that have been taken outside the Temple or Jerusalem. According to a second law, the company is obligated to demarcate the space in which it will dine and set it off as a “closed area.”
What is the significance of the substitution of a “company” for a “house”?
The most obvious answer is the change in the conception of the Passover Sacrifice. The Passover Sacrifice as performed in Egypt was an offering meant to avert the “Destroyer,” and this deliverance is focused on the “home.” For the Sages, by contrast, the Passover Sacrifice is a “family feast,” which is eaten specifically in a “company.”
|
Who Are hoi archontes? Semasiological Mechanisms at Work in the Exegesis of 1 Cor 2:6-8
Program Unit: Hellenistic Greek Language and Linguistics
Teodor Brasoveanu, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
In 1 Cor 2,6-8 Paul continues the treatment of sophia begun in 1 Cor 1,21.24. Both verses 6 and 8 have Paul mentioning hoi archontes tou aionos toutou and attributing to them a type of wisdom which finds itself in stark contrast to God’s wisdom. In the research history, this passage has been usually interpreted with reference to spiritual powers, to human rulers, or to both of them. While in the classical and Hellenistic periods the noun archon indicates a human agent (cf. e.g., governor, ruler, commander, magistrate), I argue that it could accommodate the meaning of spiritual powers due to the fact that its lexical semantic domain included power in various forms of expression. Initially, through metonymy, one of the mechanisms of semasiological change, archon got the meaning of ruling authority. Afterwards, through generalisation, spiritual entities were incorporated in the semantic domain of archon on the basis of the power that is wielded by them in a specific area of authority. Although the evidence for this meaning is slim before the second century (cf. LXX, Dn 10,13), it should not be ignored. Moreover, there is an incompatibility between the present evil aion (cf. Gal 1,4) together with its representatives (cf. 1 Cor 1,20; 2,6.8; 3,18) and God’s economy of salvation (cf. Rom 12,2; 1 Cor 7,31). While in 1 Cor 2,8 the aorist estaurosan qualifies hoi archontes as the human agents involved in Christ’s crucifixion, the recurrent genitive phrase tou aionos toutou points to a nexus between these archontes and Satan, ho theos tou aionos toutou (cf. 2 Cor 4,4). Given these arguments, my hypothesis is that Paul makes use of the noun archon as an umbrella term which may refer to everyone who deliberately or unconsciously opposes God and his economy of salvation in the present aion.
|
Exordia in Acts 24 and in Roman Legal Papyri
Program Unit: Graeco-Roman Society (EABS)
Dimitri Bratkin, Saint Petersburg State University
The study of the book of Acts against its Roman legal background has shown numerous parallels between the text of Acts and the juridical documents (protocols, commentarii/hypomnematismoi) from Roman Egypt. However, there is w hat looks like a striking difference between the narrative of Paul's trial in Acts 24 and that of the legal protocols. Acts has the exordia written down carefully, while the protocols would normally omit this part of the forensic speech. An ingenious attempt was made by Bruce Winter to explain this through the so-called N-documents. This does not seem entirely convincing. We have a direct parallel to exordia in Acts 24 in P. Flor. 61 (85 CE), and presumably in P. Paris 69 (232 CE) and P. Mert. 26 (274 CE). These suggest that at least on some occasions exordia could have been recorded and incorporated into the protocols and thus preserved in writing.
|
The Strugatskys, the Sarakshians, the Fans, and the Gospels
Program Unit: Science Fiction and the Bible (EABS)
Dimitri Bratkin, Saint Petersburg State University
The brothers Arkadi (1925-1991) and Boris (1933-2012) Strugatsky were perhaps the most influential SF novelists in the former USSR and the entire Russian-speaking part of the world. Strugatskys were interested in three main topics (social fiction, utopia, and the conflict between the human protagonist opposed to an antihuman force). These would overlap in the recurrent plot of the 'progressor' (= an advanced Terran whose aim or task is to guide/force a backward alien society towards their good as foreseen by the Terrans). I am going to study the novel 'Inhabited Island' (1969, ET 'Prisoners of Power' Macmillan, 1979).
My paper is to study the following: 1. Messianic motifs and overtones in the novel. 2. The contemporary 1960-70 setting of the novel. 3. The fan fiction (so far, a closed series of 12 novels printed in 2010-2013 and a number of Web-based texts), reportedly under the general supervision of Boris Strugatsky. This corpus provides us with an analogy of a palpably fictitious Messianic tradition developed, rearranged and rewritten two generations after the original text was composed, in a different setting and by the authors of different (sometimes, entirely opposite) standing in a post-Communist setting. Arts and humanities (Biblical studies included) are deplored for not being able to provide an experimental base for any of their scholarly hypotheses and theories. However, the Sarakshian saga may be seen as a sort of a parallel to the development of the messianic literary tradition.
|
The Latin Vision of Ezra
Program Unit: The Reception of Classical "Text" in the Greco-Roman World
Jan N. Bremmer, Rijksuniversiteit Groningen
In 1984 a new and much better manuscript of the Latin Vision of Ezra was discovered, which has now shown that its original Greek text was probably written in the earlier second century, most likely in Egypt, as it is not that far in time from the Apocalypse of Peter, with which it shows a close relationship. In my paper I will compare Ezra’descent with those of other descents as analysed by Martha Himmelfarb in het Tours of Hell, but pay more attention to the Orphic tradition in which these descents are standing. I will look at several aspects, such as the frst-person singular, narrative, the question/response structure with the demonstrative pronouns, the grouping of the sinners and the measure-for-measure patters of the punishments. In other words, I hope to show that the Vision displays all the characteristics of an early tour of hell.
|
Male Royals and Their Ethnically Foreign Mothers: The Implications for Textual Politics
Program Unit: The Bible in the Twenty-First Century: Politization of Bibles and Biblization of Politics (EABS)
Athalya Brenner, Tel Aviv University & Universiteit van Amsterdam
The ancestry of male Judahite (and at times also Israelite) royals is set out in Samuel-Kings and Chronicles in detail. The main events and assessments of a king are most often delivered through a formula. Such formulas often include, for instance, not only a monarch's genealogy on his father's side, but also on the mother's side. And the mother may be a foreigner even if, perhaps even more so, when the genealogy on the father's side is clearly Davidic.
This phenomenon, or some instance of it, may echo historical facts. However, beyond possible historicity, the question remains: what are the political and religious issues at stake, in a textual culture that alternately rejects and accepts ethnic exogamy? An analysis aimed at discussing this phenomenon in the light of memory and identity studies will follow a presentation of the relevant cases.
|
A Suitably English Abraham
Program Unit: Bible and Empire
Mark G. Brett, Whitley College, University of Divinity
Following the legal abolition of slavery in the British Empire in 1833, the morality of colonization became a focus of attention in some circles. William Penn’s example was much discussed in the new Australian colonies, and the peaceful example of Abraham was celebrated in literature supporting the cause of emigration, as for example in The Emigrant’s Friend (1848). The Colonial Office in London took a number of humanitarian initiatives, supporting the Treaty of Waitangi (1840) and requiring evidence of treaties with “Aboriginal Natives” in the Letters Patent of 1836 that established the colony of South Australia. Nevertheless, John Batman’s attempt at a treaty in Victoria was deemed unsuitable. This paper examines the fate of humanitarianism in light of the biblical models adduced at the time.
|
Samuel's Shadow: The Rhetoric of Changing Leadership under God
Program Unit: Authority and Influence in Ancient Times
Mark G. Brett, Whitley College
Michael Walzer has recently suggested that there is surprisingly little political material in the Hebrew Bible if we define “politics” as necessarily including public deliberation, disagreement, negotiation and compromise (In God’s Shadow, 2012). One might expect, for example, the authority of tribal elders to be exhibited in these ways, but the tribal elders in Israel play an insignificant role in the eyes of biblical narrators. Divine initiatives seem to overwhelm merely human deliberation.
This paper re-examines the books of Samuel in light of Walzer’s argument, and in particular considers the possibility that the character of Samuel misrepresents divine intentions, e.g., he does not appear to evaluate proposals for the transition to kingship in light of Mosaic law, and the basis for Saul’s rejection is ambiguous at best. Yet Samuel’s shadow side is itself shadowed by Davidic and Deuteronomistic narrators as the transitions in Israel’s social identity are renegotiated.
|
Jacob's Ladder in Contemporary Sculpture
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Culture
Christopher R. Brewer, University of St Andrews
Jonathan Borofsky (b. 1942) is an American artist best known for his wall drawings, installations and public sculptures. His “Walking to the Sky” (Nasher Sculpture Center, USA, 2005), previous versions of which have been permanently installed in Germany and France, is most often seen as “a compelling tribute to the power of our aspirations and the resilience of the human spirit.” I shall argue, however, that the work might be seen as an example of the ladder-to-heaven motif (Genesis 28:12), pointing beyond "our aspirations and the resilience of the human spirit" to the divine.
|
The 'Obedience of Faith' in Romans
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Mary T. Brien, St. Patrick's College, Ireland
The phrase ‘the obedience of faith’, which has generated volumes of scholarly debate, is unique to Romans. Its occurrence in Rom 1:5 and 16:26, in prologue and epilogue respectively, is significant. By bookending the phrase, Paul makes a statement about its encompassing importance. Because the meaning of the phrase is teased out in various ways throughout the Letter, it is obvious that ‘the obedience of faith’ is part of the literary and structural interweave. Some have argued that it represents the kernel of Paul’s message. The ambiguity of the Greek phrase is paralleled by the ambiguity of another phrase, pistis Christou, cherished by Paul and equally the subject of endless debate (Rom 1:17; 3:21-26; Gal 2:16-22; Phil 3:9). Reading both beleaguered phrases as complementary offers one satisfactory interpretation of Paul’s apologetic in Romans. The ‘obedience of faith’,becomes intelligible when vitally linked with ‘the faith of Christ’(subjective genitive), who walked in radical self-emptying, who ‘was humbler yet, even to accepting death’ (Phil 3:9). An unintended corollary follows: An exegetical platform is provided from which the authenticity of the doxology (16:25-27) and the integrity of the sixteen-chapter version of Romans can both be strongly supported.
|
Who's Afraid of ’eshet Medanim (Prov 21:9): Is She a "Contentious Woman" or ’eshet Midianim Practicing Magic and Divination?
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Wisdom
Ora Brison, Tel Aviv University
In this paper I propose a different interpretation for a particular type of woman: the ’eshet medanim portrayed in four different verses in the book of Proverbs - 21:9; 21:19; 25:24; 27:15.
Even though she is not mentioned in the chapters describing the "strange” or "foreign” woman (??? ???/?????), she probably belongs to the category of the negatively portrayed women discussed in the book of Proverbs. The figure of ’eshet medanim has not yet received full attention in biblical research.
I suggest that the Massoretic reading (Qere) of the proverbs referring to ’eshet medanim as a Midianite woman might be an echo of or an allusion to a specific biblical type of a "foreign" woman.
There are several episodes in the Bible relating to Midianite women associated with cultic practices. For that reason, I would like to suggest that hidden in the substrata of these proverbs one may sense concern and possibly even anxiety relating to this type of "foreign" woman.
This attitude can be possibly understood as rising from the historical biblical memory of past traditions associating Midianite women with magic and divination that were generally also linked with idolatry. My interpretation will be demonstrated by presenting the stories of two Midianite women Zipporah (Exod. 4:24-26) and Cozbi (Num. 25:6-9), and one story of a Kenite (a Midianite tribe) woman, Jael (Yael) (Judg. 4:17-21; 5:24-27). Such an interpretation could shed new light on the depiction and stories of Midianite women in the Bible and add to the body of collected knowledge about the complex nature of Midian-Israel interconnections
|
Structural Analysis of the Apocryphon of James and Its Inferences on Martyrdom
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Joseph E. Brito, Université de Montréal
Up to the present, the Apocryphon of James (Ap Jas) has mainly been studied with a view to uncovering its Gnostic teaching and/or its Valentinian influences. As a result, scholarly research has often neglected the important literary elements that provide clues for the reconstruction of both the community’s socio-historical milieu and its beliefs and practices. For example, a structural analysis of the Ap Jas allows us to identify a parallel construction based on opposing expressions found in 6.1-20 that focuses on the theme ‘martyrdom’. The block in rich in dichotomies such as “kingdom of God” vs “kingdom of Death”, “fear of death” vs. “belief in the cross”, and “revealed” vs. “election”. Closer analysis reveals that this passage parallels the section 3.33b-34a. An analysis of the Maxi-structure of the Ap Jas can therefore shed light not only on the question of martyrdom, but also on its understanding of salvation.
|
Impact of Septuagint Intertextuality: A Comparison of Selected Psalms in Hebrew and Greek
Program Unit: Septuagint Studies
Alma Brodersen, University of Oxford
Diachronic intertextual references are an important and often the only source of information for dating and interpreting texts in the Hebrew Bible. Regarding the Septuagint, intertextual references may also be important for dating and interpretation, but there is an additional question: Does the Septuagint translation refer to the same texts as the Hebrew original? In other words, did the translators recognize and repeat intertextual links in the Hebrew text, or does their translation remove, add, or change intertextual references? And how does intertextuality in the Septuagint affect the dating and interpretation of both the Hebrew and the Greek texts?
This paper will take examples from Psalms 146-150 / 145LXX-150LXX to show how these questions may be answered. The selected psalms are likely to be late texts which directly refer to a variety of earlier texts in the Hebrew Bible. Such references can be shown in the Hebrew Masoretic text form as well as the Hebrew Judaean Desert Scrolls. However, the Septuagint does not simply refer to the same texts as the Hebrew text forms but shows significant differences in its intertextual references. This paper will present specific examples for such different intertextual references and their relevance for the overall interpretation of Psalms 146-150 / 145LXX-150LXX. The first part of the paper will focus on intertextual references in the Hebrew text forms of Psalms 146-150, the second part on intertextual references in the Greek Psalms 145LXX-150LXX, and the third part on a comparison of both. The paper will then provide an outline of the consequences of such a comparison both for the interpretation of the Hebrew and the Greek texts on their own and for their relation to each other.
|
The Meaning of "Pistos" in Heb 2:17 and 3:2: "Faithful" or "Trustworthy"?
Program Unit: New Testament/Early Christianity/Rabbinic Studies (EABS)
Jaroslav Broz, Univerzita Karlova v Praze
The majority of versions translate the Greek adjective "pistos" in Hebr 2:17 and 3:2 as "faithful", while its another lexical meaning "trustworthy" is possible in the given context. The paper examines the question not only as a problem of philology and of semantics, but takes into consideration the biblical context of Numbers 12:7 and the whole concept of the Christ's priesthood in the Epistle. Finally, two main intepretative approaches are possible. On the one hand Christ's faithfulness to God can be understood as a moral virtue during the earthly period of his career. On the other hand the glorified Lord is presented to the faithful ones as God's trustworthy messenger and revealer of the divine truths. The one or the other choice influences the understanding of the concept of Jesus' priesthood in the Epistle.
|
Exegesis of Ps 99:5 in Byzantine Hymnography
Program Unit: Biblical Interpretation in Early Christianity
Bogdan G. Bucur, Duquesne University
Reference to the divine throne are oft-recurring in Byzantine hymnography. It has been occasionally noted in scholarship that such references constitute a Christian counterpart to Jewish merkavah mysticism. Less attention has been given to the footstool of the divine throne, even though the exhortation in Ps. 99:5 ("Exalt the Lord our God, and worship at His footstool, for He is holy!") constitutes the key-verse of several Byzantine festal hymns. In my presentation, I intend to present some examples of hymnographic exegesis of Ps. 99:5, and discuss their liturgical context, hermeneutical presuppositions, and theological intention.
|
Apocalyptic Imagery in Clement of Alexandria's Portrayal of Saintly Elders and Perfected Gnostics
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
Bogdan G. Bucur, Duquesne University
Scholarship has generally neglected the rich apocalyptic traditions inherited and reworked by Clement of Alexandria. Nevertheless, his detailed description (ascribed to an earlier generation of charismatic teachers) of the multi-storied spiritual universe and of the associated experience of a "real" angelification offers the proper framework for Clement's notion of theosis and his ideal portrait of the perfected Christian.
|
Jonah and His God: Reflections on the Literary Structure and the Theology of the Book of Jonah
Program Unit: Prophets
Walter Buehrer, Ruprecht-Karls-Universität Heidelberg
The book of Jonah is theologically a very rich story about a prophet, the prophet's relation to God, and God's relation to his creation. The question is whether this richness is due to the redaction-history of the book with (many?) different authors or is the result of one single author's discussion with the prophetic tradition. In the first part of the paper I will show that the book of Jonah most probably is a literary whole (including the psalm of Jonah in chapter 2). In the second part I will examine the different appellations of God in the book. I will demonstrate that they are very consciously chosen in each position: They express the dynamic relation between God and his vis-à-vis (Jonah, the sailors, the people of Niniveh). This relational approach can show that Jonah, like his "predecessors" Elijah and Jeremiah, despairs of his prophetic appointment and experiences his God as increasingly distant.
|
The Relative-Dating of the Eden Narrative Gen 2–3
Program Unit: Pentateuch (Torah)
Walter Buehrer, Ruprecht-Karls-Universität Heidelberg
The present study tries to investigate the methodological presuppositions for a relative-dating of Old Testament texts. With Gen 1-3 as test case the study works with one of the most important texts in classical pentateuchal scholarship. Recent European scholarship tends more and more to post-date the non-priestly Eden narrative through comparison with priestly, deuteronomic-deuteronomistic and late wisdom texts. The present study, however, argues for a pre-priestly date of Gen 2-3 because of the lack of clear textual references to priestly texts. Furthermore, an influence of Gen 2-3 through deuteronomic-deuteronomistic and late wisdom texts cannot be proven. In fact, the often used lexical comparisons are not as conclusive as often thought.
|
"Terminum Figat": Remarks on a Difficult Phrase in the Eucharistic Prayer of the Traditio Apostolica
Program Unit: Bible and Syriac Studies in Context
Predrag Bukovec, University of Vienna
The Traditio apostolica (TA) is among the first-rate sources for the study of Early Christian lit-urgy and ecclesiastical law. Ironically, our knowledge about that Church Order itself is very limited – not even its title is authentic. Due to the fact that the attribution to Hippolytus of Rome has been abandoned in recent research, all assumptions concerning date, localization and authorship are questionable again. On the other hand, unexpected possibilities arise from this situation, which allow us to find solutions not imagined before. In my contribution, I would like to attend to the crux interpretum of the anaphora TA 4. First, an analysis of the complex text-critical stratification can render the problem more precisely. Because an adequate interpretation of the phrase "terminum figat" seems impossible, potential parallels will be introduced in order to classify the exact tradition of the descent of Christ we have in TA 4. Especially the Syrian texts have some striking similarities to the former "Roman" prayer. The results – though only a detail from the enigmatic TA – fit well in the actual tendency to locate this influential Church Order in the Christian East.
|
Wisdom Appealing to a Philosophical Mystic: Meister Eckhart’s Reading of Wisdom of Solomon
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Wisdom
Christoph Bultmann, Universität Erfurt
James Barr, in his book of 1993, Biblical faith and natural theology, strongly emphasized the theological significance of Sapientia Salomonis. While biblical scholars generally agree that this post-canonical treatise on the double theme of the creation and the exodus, as well as several other topics, ought to be assigned its proper place in any discussion of the work of Israel’s sages, there is room for exploring in greater detail the kind of religious knowledge which the author(s) of this book wanted to communicate to their audience(s). The proposed paper will be designed to address one stage in the reception history of Sapientia Salomonis, namely the interpretation of a number of quotations (‘auctoritates’) from this book by Meister Eckhart (d. 1328) in his Expositio Libri Sapientiae (annotated Latin/German edition in Lateinische Werke, vol. 2, 1992, 301-634). Eckhart, who figures prominently in the history of Christian mysticism, must have felt particularly close to the ‘wisdom’ of Sapientia Salomonis, and it may perhaps not be mere coincidence when his interpretation of Sap Sal 11.27 Vulg. (‘qui animas amas’): ‘amas animas, non opus extra’, came to be listed for condemnation by the Catholic church in 1329 (Const. ‘In agro dominico’, 19). Eckhart’s philosophical exegesis of the biblical wisdom text can be regarded as an intriguing challenge to biblical interpretation even today (see also the chapters ‘Eckhart’s Latin Works’ by Alessandra Beccarisi and ‘Meister Eckhart’s Latin Biblical Exegesis’ by Donald F. Duclow in the recent Companion to Meister Eckhart, ed. by Jeremiah M. Hackett, Leiden: Brill 2013, 85-123 and 321-36).
|
Die Konkurrenz zwischen Schenute und Mittelägyptischen Anachoreten in der Arabischen Vita des hl. Paulus von Tamma
Program Unit: Bible and Syriac Studies in Context
Dmitry Bumazhnov, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
Der hl. Paulus von Tamma war ein mittelägyptischer Anachoret, der wohl am Ende des 4. Jh. lebte. Von ihm sind eine Reihe asketischer Werke in koptischer Sprache und darüber hinaus hagiographisches Material überliefert. Die längre Fassung der vor wenigen Jahren herausgegebenen arabischen Vita des Paulus beinhaltet eine Episode, die ganz klar auf eine Konkurrenzsituation zwischen dem berühmten Archimandriten des Weißen Klosters Schenute von Atripe und seinen Klostermönchen einerseits und den Wüstenanachoreten andererseits schließen lässt. Im Vortrag wird ein Versuch unternommen, die betreffende Episode der Paulusvita in der Geschichte des ägyptischen Mönchtums des 4.-5. Jh. zu kontextualisieren.
|
Everything in Its Place: Space and Community Restoration in Zechariah’s Vision Cycle
Program Unit: Place, Space, and Identity in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Mette Bundvad, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
In this paper I explore the spatial features of the vision cycle in the book of Proto-Zechariah (1:8-6:8). Spatial language and imagery are prominently present in these visions. The introductory complaint in 1:11-12 that the world remains at peace, unchanged, and that Yahweh must therefore still be angry with Jerusalem, serves as a provocation which initiates the vision cycle’s exploration of Jerusalem’s restoration. This restoration is primarily depicted in spatial terms, through the contrasting motifs of spatial movement and standstill.
I argue in this paper the visions skilfully use their imagery to manipulate the audience’s expectations towards the spatial reality of their community. They claim that Yahweh is already present in Jerusalem and that a radical reestablishment of the community is underway. This reestablishment takes the form of a spatial reordering – the borders of the Jerusalem community are negotiated, the exiles are enticed to return, and evil is expelled from the land. I further suggest that the vision cycle is built so as to reinforce on an overall, structural level the message in the individual visions regarding the spatial reordering.
My paper makes use of Henri Lefebvre’s discussion of space as spatial practice (perceived space), representations of space (conceived space), and spaces of representation (lived space) to discuss the relationship between the space constructed in the visions and the experienced space of the prophet’s audience. This focus on the interaction between visionary space and community space makes the paper a particularly good fit for the section theme “’This World’ and ‘Other Worlds’ in Ancient Spatial Perceptions/Conceptions.
|
Life of Adam and Eve in the Romanian Lands: A Closer Look at Textual History and Idiosyncrasies
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Silviu N. Bunta, University of Dayton
coming soon
|
The Allegory as Exegesis Paradigm in Rabbinic Literature and in Greek Culture
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Onita Burdet, Universitatea Babes-Bolyai, Cluj-Napoca
The topic of this paper is allegory and allegorical method as they have been developed in the analysis of Old Testament texts by the Rabbis. Our research hypothesis is that allegory and allegorical interpretation as used by the rabbinic tradition and by Philo of Alexandria are strongly related to Homeric allegorical exposition. The Jews in Palestine interpreted the Scripture by focusing mostly on the literal meaning, while Jews in Egypt and Alexandria mostly focused on the allegorical meaning. This phenomenon was generated within the Diaspora which, at the time, strived to blend Greek philosophy concepts with Jewish teachings in a religiously syncretistic manner, by using allegorical interpretation. Thus, ancient Jewish texts made use of allegory to enhance the dramatic effect of a situation or to transmit an ethical-religious message. Similarly, Homer and Greek mythology made use of allegory to transpose systematized information from the field of exact sciences (such as medicine, nature sciences etc.). In this context, a central question arises: What is the difference between allegory and allegorical exposition in the rabbinic literature and in rhetoric in general? In order to provide an answer to this question, we will approach several texts taken from works which are exponential for Judaism (Midrash, Zohar) and for Ancient Greek literature (Iliad and Odyssey).
|
The Man Whose Way Is Hid: Job’s “Subversive Lament” in 3:20-26
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Wisdom
John Burnight, University of Northern Iowa
A number of interpreters have noted the peculiarity of some of the language with which Job finishes his opening cri de coeur in chapter 3, particularly Job’s emphasis on his lack of “rest” and “quiet.” Building upon Dell’s classification of the genre of Job as parody, this paper provides an examination of how the Joban poet uses terminology and motifs drawn from other biblical texts to present Job as “misusing” the form of a lament in vv. 20-23, setting up a powerful critique of divine promises and governance in vv. 24-26. This intertextual reading can help to illuminate the seemingly odd terminology and imagery in these verses.
|
Gnosis and Revelation(s)?
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
Dylan Burns, Universität Leipzig
Gnosis and Revelation(s)?
|
Itur in antiquam silvam: Chopping Down Trees in Christian Latin Literature
Program Unit: The Reception of the Bible in Greco-Roman Tradition
Philip Burton, The University of Birmingham
Trees in the Bible have rich set of symbolic meanings. In some writers they are associated with longevity, strength, and blessing; other writers emphasize their links to the relations of the nations, their almost overweening size, and the paradox that something so apparently permanent can so easily be brought low, either by human action or divine. Greek and Roman traditions are no less complex, but in different ways. Trees can be emblems of the tamed or untamed worlds, either serviceable to man or outside human control; they can serve as proxy humans. At the same time, there is in Latin literature at least a tradition of amused condescension towards more tradition forms of dendrolatry.
Christian Latin writers inherit all these various traditions. Working outwards from the description of Martin’s felling of the miraculous pine in Sulpicius Severus’ Vita Martini, this paper investigates some of the ways they negotiate these traditions. At stake here is the wider question of the relationship of Christian literature to its traditional counterpart, and how far it could claim to be its inheritor, fulfilment, or replacement.
|
Expenditure Patterns, Resource Needs, and Church Leadership in the Pauline Churches
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Bruce Button, North-West University
This paper relates to the SECOND PROJECT of of the section.
It is widely held that there were a number of people in the Pauline churches whose wealth and social status was significantly higher than that of the majority of the members of the church communities. It is further deduced that the churches were dependent on these wealthy people for meeting places and other benefits that they could provide. As a result, the wealthy became patrons of the churches and exercised leadership on the basis of their wealth and social status.
This picture is, however, called into question by the work of Friesen and Longenecker, who have developed an "economy scale" that can be used to profile the economic levels of the Pauline Christians. When their scale is applied to the New Testament data regarding the Pauline churches, it appears that the sharp binary distinction of wealthy patrons vs. the remaining members — who, by implication, were poor and dependent — is difficult to sustain.
This paper will seek further insight into the economic profile of the Pauline churches with a view to testing the widely-held position that leadership in the churches was exercised by wealthy patrons on the basis of their wealth and social status. The approach is to consider possible expenditure patterns for known leaders — and others — in the Pauline churches, and to relate these patterns to the resources needed by the communities (including such items as food for the common meal, meeting places, money for travelling, etc.). This comparison will provide insight into patterns of dependence and interdependence within the communities; it will help to show whether the communities were characterized by a one-way dependence on wealthy patrons, or by a greater degree of interdependence whereby people other than leaders contributed significantly to the material needs of the congregation.
|
Philo on the Sun and the Garment Taken in Pledge
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Gábor Buzási, Eötvös Loránd Tudományegyetem
During his intellectual expeditions into the depths of Scripture Philo often brought to light doctrines that seem to be marginal or even contradicting the surface of the literal sense. The doctrine of the Sun as an image of God was one among them. The Bible makes it very clear that any comparison of the invisible Deity to anything visible is utterly dangerous and strictly forbidden; the Sun is specifically mentioned in the list of objects forbidden (cf. Dt 4:19). At the same time, it is precisely the similarity between the most eminently visible entities and the invisible First Principle, which, in the wake of Plato’s analogy of the Sun (Republic VI), had become a central metaphor in the philosophical tradition of Hellenism.
Philo speaks about the Sun and its God-like character in various contexts: my paper focuses on a passage in On Dreams (I 72-119). Starting from a passing reference to the greater luminary immediately preceding Jacob’s dream of the heavenly ladder (Gen 28:11), this section evolves into a small treatise on the Sun, made up of a series of interpretations of Biblical passages. The one Philo spends most time on explaining (92-114) contains a Mosaic regulation concerning garments taken to pledge, notably that they are to be returned before the Sun goes down (Ex 22:26-27). This is an opportunity for Philo to go beyond his general claim that the Sun’s similarity to God is in fact a genuinely Mosaic doctrine. I will argue that at this point Philo underscores this claim with an almost revolutionary zeal: denying people their due share of logos equals to condemning them to an intellectual darkness deprived of the light of God. Logos turns out here to include the proper interpretation of Scripture, which must not stop at the surface of the literal sense.
|
A Gnostic Critic of Modernity: Hans Jonas from Existentialism to Science
Program Unit: Judaica
Jonathan Cahana, Aarhus Universitet
While considerable attention has been devoted to Hans Jonas’s philosophy in general and to the impact of Gnosticism on his philosophy in particular, there are still two relatively untrodden avenues of research in this latter direction. The first comprises of Jonas’s attempt to disqualify Existentialism as philosophically flawed by recourse to Gnosticism; the second relates to Jonas’s later use of gnostic myth to criticize modernity. This paper will thus demonstrate how Jonas developed these interrelated arguments to consequently become a reluctant gnostic critic of modernity.
It is well-known that Jonas employed Gnosticism to reveal the nihilism which lurks within Existentialist philosophy. This paper, however, will demonstrate how Jonas used the same means to expose that Existentialism was also philosophically flawed, and thus, ethics aside, cannot function as a viable option for the thinking person. Gnosticism, argued Jonas, is able to lay bare both the hidden metaphysical premises of an apparently non-metaphysical philosophy as well as its internal discontinuity. Gnosticism might have been raw and fantastic, but at least philosophically consistent. Existentialism, on the other hand, for all its intricacy, fails to stand up to its own challenge. Furthermore, this paper will also delineate how the discoveries from Nag Hammadi gradually refined Jonas’s argument regarding Gnosticism. At this later stage he argued that Gnosticism still had a system of checks and balances that guarded it from the danger of utter nihilism which lurks not only in Existentialism, but also in modern science and modernity in general. The intricacy of gnostic myth as attested by the newly discovered texts revealed this phenomenon to be confronting its own moral implications and guarding itself from utter nihilism. On the other hand, Jonas argued, as both Existentialism and modern science lack this protection mechanism, they still have something to learn from ancient Gnosticism.
|
What Does Frankfurt Have to Do with Alexandria? Adorno's Culture Industry and the Conspiracy of the Archons in Gnosticism
Program Unit: New Testament/Early Christianity/Rabbinic Studies (EABS)
Jonathan Cahana, Aarhus Universitet
Theodor Adorno and Max Horkheimer, the founders of the Frankfurt School, delineated the concept of “the culture industry” in their immensely influential writing The Culture Industry: Enlightenment as Mass Deception. In this book, they described an all-powerful system which constructs an illusory notion of reality and thus guarantees the subjects’ continued subjection to the capitalist system out of what the people are led to believe is their own free will. The system is all around us but at the same time invisible, since it itself accounts for what is considered true or real. Most attempts to break the premises of this system are negated before even attempted, since “[T]he need which might resist central control has already been suppressed by the control of the individual consciousness.” Moreover, this system also has a mechanism to subsume subversive elements; such elements are “gathered together as culture and neutralized.”
But what happens if we counterpoise this system with the no less systematic and overarching conspiracy of the archons in early Christian Gnosticism? Could (mid-twentieth century) Frankfurt have anything to do with (2-3rd century Alexandria)? This paper will present a comparison of the two concepts, underlining both similarities and differences and using each one to throw additional light on the other phenomenon. It will be seen that both the Frankfurt and the gnostic school of thought (or hairesis) attempted to dismantle a system of mass deception by underscoring how and to whose benefit this system functions. Whether this system is a divine or human construction will be seen to be less essential. The resulting portrait of the gnostics as ancient cultural critics, on the one hand, and the possible metaphysical premises lurking behind the materialist culture industry, on the other, could be proved crucial, and would serve as the focus of this paper.
|
Who Has No Excuse in Rom 2:1? The Role of 'Homo Generalis' in the Interpretation of Paul
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
William S. Campbell, Prifysgol Cymru, Y Drindod Dewi Sant - University of Wales, Trinity Saint David
The paper discusses the implications of the generalisation of 'anthropos' in Pauline interpretation.
|
From Pickaxe to Pixel: Digital Data Management in the Elah Valley Archaeological Visualization Project
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical Studies, Early Jewish and Christian Studies (EABS)
Robert R. Cargill, University of Iowa
This paper details the data management process for the databasing of geospatial and geometric archaeological data and the visualization and databasing of the 3D, real-time digital model of the archaeological site of Tel Azekah, the surrounding Elah Valley, the ancient border between Judah and the Philistine city of Tel es-Safi/Gath, and the objects yielded by these sites.
|
Strong and Weak Criteria for Identifying Post-Priestly Texts in the Pentateuch
Program Unit: Pentateuch (Torah)
David M. Carr, Union Theological Seminary in the City of New York
In recent years there has been a sea-change in how many scholars identify post-Priestly Pentateuchal texts, which are defined here as Pentateuchal texts seen to post-date the joining of Priestly and non-Priestly strands. Whereas earlier generations of scholars tended to see only isolated parts of the Pentateuch, say Genesis 14 as post-Priestly, more recent treatments by Levin, Otto, Achenbach, Nihan, Römer, and Berner (among many others) have ascribed far larger sections of the Pentateuch (and Hexateuch) to post-Priestly author/scribes. This paper attempts to advance the discussion by examining first those additions to the Pentateuch/Hexateuch that can be identified as post-Priestly by virtue of the fact that they are documented additions to existing manuscript tradition for the Pentateuch. Building on this, I will list what I take to be the strongest examples of post-priestly additions embedded in all of our manuscript traditions to the Pentateuch. These then provide criteria for finding other potential post-Priestly portions of the Pentateuch and help differentiate levels of probability in the identification of such materials.
|
Abraham the Patriarch of Philo’s Ideal Contemplative Life
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
J. Owen Carroll, University of Aberdeen
In De Abrahamo, Philo recounts the patriarch Abraham’s spiritual journey through allegorical exegesis of the Biblical text. This paper will seek to explore the vital role of contemplation that Philo gives to Abraham’s spiritual journey while at the same time attempting to identify the object of Abraham’s contemplative practice.
I would propose that the object of Abraham’s contemplation varies according to the stage of spiritual journey he is situated in. Firstly, Abraham’s contemplation is focused on the natural created order. Secondly he dwells on the inner workings of his own soul. Thirdly, due to an understanding initiated by his theophanic experience, his contemplation is focused on the character and nature of God himself.
Each stage of contemplative activity reveals, according to Philo, a spiritual dynamic that is taking place within the soul of the patriarch. Essential to this process is Philo’s insistence that God is intimately involved in the cleansing of Abraham’s soul and his progression towards virtue. Philo’s in-depth description of Abraham’s contemplative activity (throughout the stages of spiritual progression) seems to indicate that he expects this process to be a normative experience for the Jewish people, an experience that culminates in the vision of God.
|
The Chosen One in the Genesis of Mary: A Masterplot Methodology
Program Unit: Methods in New Testament Studies
M. L. Case, The University of Texas at Austin
In this paper, I propose a new methodology centered on masterplots to explore connections between texts categorized under the rubric of New Testament studies and materials drawn from their religious and cultural settings. I define masterplots as common interpretive frameworks (plots) frequently used to frame different narratives according to preexisting patterns. Masterplots connect with our deepest values, fears, and wishes, which accounts for their power and repeated usage. They can be overtly or covertly employed, often influencing reader without them realizing it and can travel across cultures or be specific to a particular culture. My proposed method allows me to bring together a new set of narratives than when I look strictly at how one text draws directly from another text. By identifying the particular masterplot used by a group of texts and analyzing how they adapt that masterplot, I can consider the different focus of each narrative. Using the steps I outline in this new method, I examine the Protevangelium of James alongside the birth narratives of Samson, Samuel, and John the Baptist. All four share a similar masterplot, which I label The Fulfillment of Righteous Destiny masterplot, though each alters it slightly. By tracking these changes, I can then ascertain the emphasis of each narrative. In the case of the Protevangelium of James, the results indicate Mary as the primary focus of its masterplot and thus lead me to use an alternative name of the text, The Genesis of Mary. This study demonstrates the effectiveness of my masterplot method to engage with a broad range of narratives in a fresh and informative way.
|
Mapping Restoration through Constructivist Law in Ezra-Nehemiah and Ezekiel
Program Unit: Israel and the Production and Reception of Authoritative Books in the Persian and Hellenistic Period (EABS)
Jeremiah W. Cataldo, Grand Valley State University
This paper will argue that in Ezra-Nehemiah and Ezekiel, the concept of *torah* took prominence over *tsedeqah* as a foundational component in social identity formation. The former was constructivist, the intent of which was to define the main attributes of a "restored" society, particularly in the area of social group boundaries, and to redefine the dominant distribution of authority that preexisted the arrival of the immigrants (*golah* community). The law legitimated attitudes of prejudice, which can be seen in the biblical focus on intermarriage and intergroup social relations, but for the purpose of controlling the definitive qualities of a new, idealized social-political normative. Consequently, in this literature *tsedeqah* reflected little more than the individual's or group's actions that were in line with and supportive of that idealized normative.
|
Who Was Crucified and Where? The Case for Kaikos in Rev 11:8
Program Unit: Textual Criticism: Manuscripts & Methods
Jeff Cate, California Baptist University
The identification and interpretation of the “great city” mentioned in Revelation 11:3-14 has been the subject of much debate. In verse 8, the location is metaphorically referenced as Sodom and Egypt, which are prophetic allusions to wickedness and idolatry and not geographical markers. More specifically, the city is identified as “where even their Lord was crucified,” which makes historical reference to what seems to be Jerusalem and the death of Jesus. Such an identification, however, does not fit well with other details in the context. The manuscript evidence for these last six words in Greek is very limited since only four manuscripts (p47, 01, 02, 04) prior to the ninth century provide evidence for the wording, and yet these four witnesses have three different readings. This paper proposes a conjectural emendation for the accidental transposition of two letters in the text of Codex Sinaiticus which may resolve the geographical tension in the passage. Instead of reference being made to the crucifixion of Jesus in Jerusalem, reference would be made to an otherwise unknown execution of a Christian in Rome named Kaikos. The name Kaikos has connections back to the region of Asia Minor and Pergamum specifically, and the reference would then be similar to the mention of Antipas as a martyr in 2:13. The “great city” in 11:3-14 would then be Rome, not Jerusalem.
|
A Theology of the Land in Ezra-Nehemiah: Perspectives from the Pentateuch
Program Unit: Comparative Studies of Literature from the Persian and Hellenistic Periods
Ntozakhe Cezula, University of Stellenbosch
This paper will investigate how identity formation in Ancient Israel - on account of a creation theology - is reflected in the Pentateuch, and how this feature of the Pentateuch influenced the views that are expressed in Ezra-Nehemiah on the issue of land. In doing so, the study will interpret the views in Ezra-Nehemiah as re-interpretations of the Pentateuchal theology of creation. The study will also show how this dynamic view of how post-exilic literature re-interpreted earlier authoritative material can serve modern-day post-colonial/-apartheid discussions on reconstruction (particularly in African contexts).
|
Rahab as Harlot and Prophetess in 1 Clement
Program Unit: Apostolic Fathers and Related Early Christian Literature
Lung Pun Common Chan, Chinese University of Hong Kong
The overarching purpose of the paper is to examine how 1Clement received, created and impacted the Rahab traditions in patristic texts. In 1Clement 12, Rahab is positively depicted both as a harlot (vv.1-6) and as a prophetess-like woman (vv.7-8). The former image is traditional while the latter one is innovative and first-hand in the Rezeptionsgeschichte. The twofold images of Rahab are investigated in a twofold outline of this paper. At first, the paper argues that "rabbinic exegetic tradition" (cf. Hanson 1978) could not explain Clement's creative treatment of the Rahab theme. Neither Heb. 11:31 nor James 2:25 expresses such an prophetess-like image. It is plausible that the Christological "prophecy" found in this woman (1Clem. 12:8) was inspired by a Christian intertextual reading of Josuha (Chapter 2 & 6) and Mt. 1:1-17. From 1Clement onwards, Rahab's scarlet began to symbolize "the blood of the Lord" and this innovative symbolization impacted the patristic reception (e.g. Justin, Dial. 111). Furthermore, the biblical Rahab tied tightly to the idea of "redemption" (1Clem. 12:8) and this redemptive sign evolved further in the Christian tradition (e.g. Cyprian, To Magnus 4). In the second part of the paper, it traces the development of Rahab as harlot. Unlike Mt. 1:5, Rahab is nowhere in 1Clement portrayed as a mother (and a wife). Instead Rahab as harlot was uncritically (but not passively) received in 1Clement. Indeed the canonical tradition was uncritical to Rahab as a prostitute (Jos. 2:1; 6:17, 25; Heb. 11:31; James 2:25). Even Mt. 1:5 is silenced at this point. Comparatively, in 1Clement, this harlot could be perceived with a positive note (cf. 1Clem. 55:3). This paved way to Origen's positive reception of Rahab as harlot in his homily (Jos. hom. 7:5). Only after the year 250 (or later) Rahab was depicted as a repentant woman.
|
Interfacing Apocalyptic with Magic in the Coptic Gospel of the Egyptians, the Apocryphon of John, and the Coptic Apocalypse of Paul: Religious Experience at Nag Hammadi
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Lung Pun Common Chan, Chinese University of Hong Kong
Was apocalyptic de facto Christian “magic” in the context of Coptic Christianity? With this question in mind, this paper examines (one kind of) religious experience(s) at Nag Hammadi. Christian apocalypses present “striking parallels with the techniques, formulas and motifs of magical revelation,” but interestingly “omit references to the preparatory ritual techniques” (Aune 2006). The present paper focuses on the Gospel of the Egyptians, the Apocryphon of John, the Coptic Apocalypse of Paul to re-examines how apocalyptic and magic traditions interact in the Nag Hammadi library. After identifying “apocalyptic” traditions behind all three texts, it focuses on certain magical Coptic texts (e.g. Berlin 954, Berlin 5565, Berlin 8313, Berlin 8314, etc.), to surmises the existence of typical Egyptian magical formulas in the Coptic Gospel of the Egyptians. Likewise, the Apocryphon of John can be understood as a revelatory magic, which incorporates a list of magical names and a secret dialogue on the soul (Davies 2005). The Coptic Apocalypse of Paul, in turn, condemns magical enchantments. Last, in light of ritual theory, the paper illustrates how apocalyptic traditions were received and contextualized at Nag Hammadi through magical ritual experiences.
|
Reflective Transformation Imaging and the Recovery of an Ancient Manuscript of Romans 4–5
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical Studies, Early Jewish and Christian Studies (EABS)
Randall D. Chesnutt, Pepperdine University
Greek majuscule MS 0220, a vellum fragment acquired in Egypt in 1950, preserves a partial copy of Romans 4:23-5:13 from the late third or early fourth century. Although the recto was quite legible and was published by William H. P. Hatch in 1952, the verso was degraded and illegible. In 2005, in the only published attempt to decipher the verso, Donatella Limongi made great progress but was able to read with confidence only about half of the inscribed area. Today, using Reflective Transformation Imaging (RTI) developed by Bruce Zuckerman at the West Semitic Research Institute at the University of Southern California, it is possible at last to recover most of the previously illegible Greek text on the verso of this earliest extant manuscript of Romans 4-5.
The purpose of this presentation is: (1) to describe the imaging techniques and demonstrate the Inscriptifact software that has made it possible both to decipher the previously illegible verso and to elucidate some obscure parts of the recto; and (2) to report on the scribal characteristics, paleographical affinities, and text-critical significance of the manuscript thus recovered, including its nomina sacra and its bearing on a textual variant in Romans 5:1.
|
Postcolonial Nationalism: (Neo)colonialism in Ezra, Malaysia, and Hong Kong
Program Unit: Postcolonial Studies
Philip Chia, Chinese University of Hong Kong
*
|
Translation of ‘Pistis’ and Its Cognates in Pauline Epistles
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Varghese P. Chiraparamban, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
The standard translation of ‘pistis’ is faith. However, it is not easy to find a single definition of faith. The philosophical language of the medieval scholastics paved way for a western understanding of faith implying a specific quality of intellectual assent (T. Aquinas). In theological circles, it is raised to transcendental realm by associating it with reason. In popular usage it can mean belief without evidence or proof. Christian faith then seems to be open to criticism as a leap in the dark.
In this paper, we examine whether Paul’s use of ‘pistis’ is open to the above definitions of faith. Background studies (Lührmann, 1973; Lindsay, 1993) show that Paul was influenced by the LXX use of ‘pist’- words in relational sense. Our observation that ‘pistis’ and its cognates are frequent in Romans and Galatians, where Paul quotes Hab 2:4 and Gen 15:6, strengthen this argument. In these passages, the sense of trusting is most noticeable. This paper argues that Paul does not make a significant shift in the meaning of ‘pistis,’ rather gives it a central place which becomes decisive in the human relationship to God. In Pauline letters ‘pistis’ is relational (something that happens between persons), not an idea that one holds as true. By using philological analysis, this paper shows that ‘pistis’ or ‘pisteuo’ has a theocentric focus, even when used as absolute, meaning ‘trust in God.’ When theological discussion has moved away from the core meaning of trust, faith became something irrational and vague, so opening the door to its misunderstanding as ‘belief without evidence’ or ‘blind belief.’ ‘pistis’ and its cognates are therefore best translated as ‘trust.’ The Bible’s relational understanding of ‘pistis’ as trust in God gives us a more reliable guide than faith to the meaning which Paul’s readers would have imputed to the term.
|
The Old Testament in the Letters of St. Ignatius of Antioch
Program Unit: The Reception of the Scripture in the Patristic Exegesis (II-VIII centuries) (EABS)
Ilie Chiscari, Romanian Patriarchate Printing Press
It is generally considered that St. Ignatius of Antioch manifests only a scant inter est or little familiarity with the corpus of writings today designated as 'Old Testament'. His Letters present only three direct quotations from the Old Testament (Prov 3:34 in Eph. 5.3; Prv 18:17 in Magn. 12; Is 52:5 in Tral. 8.2), for paraenetic purposes, and few allusions to various themes characteristic to the Jewish Bible. All these create the impression of an indirect contact with the Old Testament, intermediated by some New Testament writings that Ignatius knew or by the oral tradition. However, we cannot suspect Ignatius for sharing the Gnostic view that the Old Testament could be ascribed to a different god than the God of the New Testament. He proclaims the importance of the Prophets "because they made their proclamation looking toward the gospel and hoped in [Jesus] and awaited him" (Philad. 5.2); he clearly knows and alludes to the 'proof from prophecy' principle (Smyrn. 5.1). Also, the enigmatic passage of Philad. 8.2, "For I heard some say, 'If I do not find (i t) in the archives, I do not believe (it to be) in the Gospel' and when I said 'It is written', they answered me, 'that is just the question'", reflects a specific hermeneutic of the relationship between the Old and the New Testament. Ignatius seems to have little use for the concept of an authoritative Scripture. For him, the real criterion for the validity of the Gospel was not the Old Testament, but the Christian community's contemporary experience of Jesus Christ. In conclusion, my paper aims to analyse the presence of the Old Testament's elements in the Letters of St Ignatius of Antioch and to identify his specific view on the importance of the Jewish Scriptures for the Christian doctrine and practice.
|
Is the LXX a Translation or a Greek Targum?: LXX Psalm 54 as a Test Case
Program Unit: Septuagint Studies
P. Richard Choi, Andrews University
Unfair criticisms have been leveled against the LXX translations of the Hebrew text by many. Some translations are too loose, some are too literal, some are ridiculous, and some are flat out wrong – so goes the criticism. Some scholars even wonder whether the LXX translators understood Hebrew very well. Others have tried to emend the Greek text based on the Hebrew, and vice versa. These criticisms are based on the assumption that the LXX is a translation of the Hebrew text. This paper challenges this assumption. It argues that the LXX is possibly the earliest extent form of a “Targum” – a Greek Targum. This paper uses LXX Psalm 54 as a test case to show that (1) the LXX was meant to be read alongside the Hebrew text, (2) each word was translated so as to function as an interlineary unit within which the interpretation occurred, and (3) the primary tools of interpretation were the Greek tenses, moods, and cases, which Hebrew lacked. The LXX translator freely gave each Hebrew word he was translating Greek grammatical features that the Hebrew naturally lacked. He did this with great subtlety and skill. He sometimes intentionally deviated from the Hebrew text, as in v. 22a, and on other occasions he even changed the tenses, all in an effort to instruct the reader on how to understand the Hebrew. This paper challenges the variants suggested by the BHS apparatus as being based on the assumption that the LXX Psalm is a straight translation of the Hebrew. The very literalistic style of the LXX translation of Psalm 54 notwithstanding, the translator offers an exciting interpretation of the text as a portrayal of the Psalmist’s inner psychological struggles.
|
An Excuse or a Reality?
Program Unit: Pentateuch (Torah)
Sik Ping Choi, Bible Seminary of Hong Kong
God invited Moses to take up the mission to lead the Israelites to exodus. At the beginning, he tried to find excuses not to take up the task. One of the reasons is that he was a poor speaker by saying that he was heavy in lips and tongue (Exod. 4:10). Can this be the reality?
When Moses encountered Pharaoh and requested the release of the Israelites, he was rebuked by Pharaoh. The worst was that Pharaoh misread Moses’ intention as helping the Israelites to find excuse not to work diligently, and thus increased the workload of the Israelites. As a result, the Israelites suffered and blamed Moses for the sufferings. Moses felt despaired and complained that God should not ask him to execute such a difficult task. His reason was that he was “uncircumcised of lips” (Exod. 6:12; 30) which is different from the expression used in the preceding chapter that he was heavy in lips and tongue. Would these two expressions have the same meaning? Why did he use this expression? Would it be a euphemism or something else?
Circumcision is an important theme in the plagues narrative. It is a ritual for requesting an acceptance from God. Those who have circumcised are appropriated in participating the Passover and escaping from slaughter. Therefore, I would argue that when Moses said he was uncircumcised of lips, he just wanted to say that he was not the appropriate person to take up the mission. Perhaps the reason was due to his past bad experience as mentioned in chapter two that he had been rejected by his people. Moreover, I suppose the use of the expression is probably a polite way to say no and to avoid upsetting God.
|
“And I Will Raise Up for Myself a Faithful Priest” (1 Sam 2:35): The Appropriation of This Text in the Epistle to the Hebrews
Program Unit: Epistle to the Hebrews
Philip Church, Laidlaw College
Hebrews 2:17 refers to Jesus as a “merciful and faithful high priest,” an expression that NA28 identifies as an echo of 1 Sam 2:35. While an isolated echo is only faintly heard, the volume is enhanced if it can be established that it does not stand alone. While on the face of it Heb 3:1-6 compares Jesus and Moses, the six-fold repetition of the word oikos (“house”) indicates a sub-theme concerning house (temple)-building, including an echo of the “sure house” that Yahweh will build for the faithful priest of 1 Sam 2:35. The perfect active participle of dierchomai (“to pass through”) in Heb 4:14 is usually read as a claim that Jesus ascended through several layers of heaven before reaching the dwelling place of God, where he remains. The idea of layers of heaven seems foreign to Hebrews, and an adjectival perfect participle normally describes a present state or activity rather than some anterior activity. A more suitable background to the expression is seen in the use of the Hithpael of halak (“to walk about”) in the Hebrew Bible to refer to the activity of priests in the temple and tabernacle, and in the Dead Sea Scrolls to refer to the activity of priestly angels in the heavenly temple. In several key texts, including 1 Sam 2:35, the LXX renders this form of the Hebrew verb with dierchomai. This verb in Heb 4:14 is a third echo of 1 Sam 2:35, where it describes the activity of the faithful priest “moving about” in the presence of Yahweh. This cluster of echoes indicates that in Hebrews Jesus is thought of as the promised faithful priest of 1 Sam 2:35, ministering in the presence of God in the heavenly temple.
|
The Reception History of Exodus 24: Ritual Readings
Program Unit: Reception of Scripture in Second Temple Literature
Lisa J. Cleath, University of California-Los Angeles
This paper explores the reception history of Exodus 24:3-8 in biblical literature, with a view towards illuminating the ritual use of text readings in post-monarchic contexts. The intertextual allusions to Exodus 24 within their ancient near eastern ritual contexts reveal an oral component of the process of Second Temple scripturalization. Exodus 24:3-8 is the first passage according to the internal chronology of the Pentateuch which features a ceremony in which a textual Torah artifact is read aloud to a group, and Joshua 8:30-35, 2 Kings 23:1-3, and Nehemiah 8:1-12 all seem to echo the reading ceremony in Exodus 24. These texts exhibit a post-monarchic interest in textual authority, and Joshua 8 and Nehemiah 8 specifically take up the Persian interest in Mosaic authority. Making use of ritual theory and comparative evidence, this study focuses on the unique features of the Exodus chapter that are paralleled within the ritualized readings, including the language used to describe the physical presentation of the book, the people's reception of and responses to the reading, the appeal to Mosaic authority in the reading, and naming of the document. While these reading ceremonies have frequently been named "covenant (renewal) ceremonies," they have not often been interpreted in light of Exodus 24. Further evidence in Jubilees demonstrates the prominence of Exodus 24 and textuality in the Second Temple Jewish imagination, supporting the influence of this portion of the Sinai pericope in Israelite cultures. By analyzing the parallels and differences in these ritual readings, this project will aim to shed light on the ritual role of written texts in ancient Israel and the gradual development of authoritative texts leading into the Second Temple Period.
|
The Decalogue as the Prohibition of Theft
Program Unit: Pentateuch (Torah)
David J. A. Clines, University of Sheffield
The thesis of this paper is simple: all the Ten Commandments are, in one way or another, commandments against theft.
Why does one of the Commandments (the tenth) proscribe a mental act, coveting—unlike all of the other commandments, which concern observable external actions? We should see this as the last and greatest commandment, for it addresses the impulse that lies at the heart of all that is forbidden in the Decalogue: the desire to acquire what belongs to someone else.
Thus adultery is the theft of another man’s property, false witness robs another of innocence or reputation, the dishonouring of parents robs them of their right to respect and support. The commandment against murder proscribes the theft of a life, viewed as God’s property (rather than that of the murdered person).
Breach of the Sabbath commandment is a theft of time that belongs to the deity. By declaring the Sabbath holy, God has staked his own claim to it and made it his property (‘holy’ means ‘belonging to the deity’). Worshipping other gods apart from Yahweh robs Yahweh of the worship he regards as his due.
If this is indeed the programme of the Decalogue, to prohibit theft, what does that tell us about the framers of the Decalogue? They are persons who have something to lose from theft, that is, they construct themselves as persons of property. They do not here think of themselves as a community of brothers (as in the Covenant Code), they are not concerned with responsibility to others, and they have no sense of collectivity.
|
What Does Aaron Do the Help? Re-evaluating the Role and Function of Aaron in Num 12:1-16
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Kirsi Cobb, Cliff College
The harsh punishment of the female culprit in a text that in its final form seems to assume the culpability of both the female and male perpetrators has for some time puzzled biblical commentators. How can Miriam and Aaron rebel against Moses (Numb. 12:1-2) and only Miriam be punished (Numb. 12:10)? Some have suggested that Aaron was not an original part of the story or that his role as the high priest had a bearing on the narrative. Others have claimed that Aaron acted merely as Miriam’s helper and thus spared her fate.
This paper will argue that through the means of deconstructive critique Aaron could be perceived as establishing a moment of indecision in the text where two opposed readings become equally possible. In the character of Yahweh we see portrayed the mode of autocratic paternal reign that insists upon order and hierarchy, dooming the female perpetrator to disease and banishment (Numb. 12:10, 14). However, this neatly ordered structure is disturbed in the character of Aaron who shows allegiance to the female instigator (Numb. 12:11), even pleading for her innocence whilst persuading Moses to heal her (Numb. 12:11-12). Moreover, although Aaron is presented as the paradigmatic priest (Numb. 12:10-12), he problematizes the distinction between the offices of a prophet (Numb. 12:6), priest (Numb. 12:10) and that of Moses (Numb. 12:7-8) due to Yahweh’s confirmation of Aaron’s oracular function (Numb. 12:6) as well as Yahweh’s ability to commune with equal clarity with each of these offices both in Numbers 12 and the book of Numbers at large (cf. Numb. 18:8). Answering the question ‘what does Aaron do to help?’, it is claimed that within Aaron we are provided with a glimpse of an alternative authority structure of shared, multifaceted leadership based not upon hierarchy but allegiance with the female.
|
The Gender of Cooking in Mishnah and Babylonian Talmud
Program Unit: Early Judaism and Rabbinics (EABS)
Aryeh Cohen, American Jewish University
One often assumes that in late antiquity and the middle ages the kitchen was the domain of women. To a large extent this is borne out by the scholarship and supported also within the corpus of rabbinic literature. M Ketubot (5:5) lists a woman’s obligations to her husband:
The first of these labors listed are those involved in food preparation.
Given this context, one might assume that the Rabbinic discussion of the laws of cooking on Shabbat would be directed mainly at women. If this was one’s assumption, however, one would be severely off the mark.
In this paper I will argue that the Talmud privileges male cooking on or for Shabbat since it is a festival occasion. Women are assumed to do the quotidian cooking, and appear in many legal and narrative contexts as the preparers of food for domestic consumption. However, in the stories and laws of cooking about Shabbat in Bavli Shabbat, women are almost completely absent. I will suggest a reason for this, borrowing an insight from barbecue studies where several scholars have pointed out that in festival settings, “women tend the food while men tend the fire.” I claim that this is mirrored in Bavli Shabbat wherein women are absent from cooking, and in Mishnah and Bavli Kodashim where Temple ritual (which is basically public butchering and cooking) in total is the province of men.
|
"I set my mind . . ." (Qoh 1:12) Structure and Meaning in the Reflective Passages in the Book of Qohelet Nava Neriya-Cohen
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Wisdom
Naava Cohen, Bar-Ilan University
The book of Qohelet touches on a wide range of topics and comprises diverse literary patterns. Notwithstanding this stylistic diversity, scholars have discerned within the book two main literary patterns: a collection of proverbs and exhortations on the one hand and reflective passages formulated as a first-person monologue on the other. The author also incorporates three lyrical poems into the narrative sequence: the character of life and nature (1:3-11), the poem of ‘times’ (3:1-9) and the allegory of old age (11:7-12:7).
As early as 1974, J. Coppens proposed to discern the phases of the book’s redaction by distinguishing between the three aforementioned principal literary patterns. Coppens notes that the reflective passages manifest a content driven process, yet he accords this no further elaboration beyond a brief remark. Over the years, scholars scrutinized the reflective passages. Some scholars suggested criteria for their categorization; some addressed their rhetorical facets; while others sorted them into sub-genres. However, they have not hitherto been researched from a content and structural perspective as an independent composition.
In this paper I will seek to exposit the content and the method of the reflective passages distribution throughout the book of Qohelet as an independent composition. I will argue that the exposure of their order and content are key to revealing the fundamental premises formulated in the main body of the book. I will begin by defining the indicators that delineate the reflective passages in Qohelet. I will then describe their content and the method of their distribution throughout the book. Finally, I will show the connection between the content and order of the reflective passages and the conception of "World Order" in the book of Qohelet.
|
The Romanian Septuagint Translation Project: Ten Years for the Rebirth of a Discipline (2002–2012)
Program Unit: Septuagint Studies
Stefan Colceriu, Institute for Linguistics of the Romanian Academy
After ten years of hard work, in 2012, a group of fifteen independent biblical scholars provided the Romanian culture with the first scientific and philologically accurate translation of th e Septuagint into Romanian. The project was undertaken by the New Europe College. Institute for Advanced Study from Bucharest (NEC), a member of the EURIAS network, and was coordinated by three of the best philologists and theologians in the country. As a result, eight volumes were released comprising the whole corpus of the Septuagint, according to Rahlf's edition. Each biblical book is thoroughly introduced and a rich apparatus of philological, theological, historical, and anthropological notes accompanies almost every verse. Our paper aims at exposing the reasons and the consequences of this important and unique project in Romania. Although the LXX is the textus receptus of the Orthodox church, its translation tradition suffered considerably within the last seventy years, when the official translation combined the Greek (LXX) and the Hebrew (MT) originals. On the other hand, a scientifically annotated translation of the Septuagint had never before been released in Romania. Thus, the Romanian Septuagint project represents a necessary act of reparation to a venerable tradition. At the same time, our enterprise serves as a model of collaboration between specialists of various disciplines (theology, philology, history) and religious confessions (Orthodox, Catholic, Protestant) from Romania and abroad (mainly from France and from U.S.A.). It should be stressed, however, that the translation is not an ecumenical, but an academic one. The emulation it brought about is now visible within the Romanian culture: the first proper translation of the Hebrew Bible is in preparation, several New Testament translations are on the way, as well as a reevaluation of the apocrypha. The study of biblical languages (Hebrew, Greek, Latin, and Coptic), hosted by NEC, is on the rise.
|
The Judeans in Mesopotamia during the Persian Period as Reflected by the Clay Tablets
Program Unit: Judaica
Andrea Colella, Universität Wien
Over time different archives were discovered in Mesopotamia, in which clay tablets were well conserved. They are very important because they relate to Judeans, who had lived in Mesopotamia during the Persian period. The oldest source refers to the Judean King Yoyakin, who was deported to Babylon after the fall of Jerusalem and lived at the Babylonian court. Other tablets (5th cent. B.C.E.), like the one of the Murashu archive, were mostly written in order to register economical transactions. These sources are very precious, especially because they offer a view on the presence and the situation of the Jews in the Diaspora in the Persian period, from which we have few sources. After a brief overview on this material I shall focus on the personal names, which could be a precious source relating to the identity, religious habits and the relations between the imperial power and the minorities.
Can we assert a link between the names on the clay tablets and the names in the Hebrew Bible? Are there theophoric elements, which are not present in the Hebrew Canon (especially in the Book of Nehemia and Ezra)? If yes, what could that mean?
|
Comparative Eschatology: Paul’s Letters and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Adela Yarbro Collins, Yale University
In this paper I will argue that early Christian texts are not unique in expressing a partially realized eschatology. I will analyze and compare passages from the undisputed letters of Paul with passages from the Hodayoth and other passages in which language of resurrection is used.
|
The Genre Apocalypse Reconsidered
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
John J. Collins, Yale University
The Genre Apocalypse Reconsidered
The Apocalyptic Imagination, first published in 1984, was conceived as a complement to Apocalypse. The Morphology of a Genre (1979). The earlier project was an attempt to define the genre apocalypse, not to give a full account of its history or relation to other literature. This paper will review the debate about the definition of the genre as it has unfolded over the last thirty years and clarify how the diachronic study of the Jewish apocalypses was intended to complement it.
John J. Collins, Yale.
|
Abandoning the Quest for the Historical Teacher: History and Narrative in the Qumran Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Matthew A. Collins, University of Chester
The “Quest for the Historical Teacher” has a history as long as scrolls scholarship itself. Ever since the discovery of the Pesher on Habakkuk (1QpHab) within the very first batch of scrolls recovered from the Qumran caves, attempts have been made to shed light upon the historical personages presumed to lie behind such sobriquets as “the Teacher of Righteousness” and “the Wicked Priest.” While some have endeavoured to uncover the actual identity of the Teacher, most have accepted his probable absence from our wider sources and have focused instead, not on his name, but on simply trying to reconstruct as clear a picture of the historical Teacher as possible. The past two decades, however, have seen the rise of a more critical approach to our reading of “history” in the texts, raising serious questions about our ability to recover any useful historical information from the scrolls. This paper suggests that the Teacher of the texts must first and foremost be understood as a literary construct; there are, in fact, multiple literary Teachers to contend with in the scrolls, which should make us wary of any attempt to straightforwardly extrapolate historical realities from the passages in question. Instead we should acknowledge a clear and critical distinction between the literary Teacher(s) we are presented with in the texts and the historical Teacher we are attempting to recover. The scale of this gulf between the Teacher(s) of the texts and the Teacher of history leads in turn to the proposal of this paper that it is perhaps time to finally abandon the Quest for the Historical Teacher.
|
A Victorian Jael
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Colleen Conway, Seton Hall University
In Virginia Morris’s study of women killers in Victorian fiction, she argues that novelists of the subject often focused on “the ambiguous guilt and radical daring of women who chose to act for themselves.” As these violent women struck out against their male oppressors, they became characters in “part of a larger, legitimate gender battle—a power struggle between men and women—rather than simply individual examples of depravity or immorality” (Double Jeopardy: Women Who Kill in Victorian Fiction, 3). Much of Morris’s analysis fits well with the Victorian Jael created by John Byrne Leicester Warren (aka Lord de Tabley) in his dramatic poem 1873 poem, “Jael.” The poem is an extended monologue that relates Jael’s post-murder perspective as she “begins to think it over.” Such introspection results in an exploration of her motives that is both harshly critical of her act and sensitive to her socially inscribed gender role. The poem depicts Jael’s murderous blow as an impulsive and violent protest against her constricted role as wife and mother. At the same time, it undercuts the masculinity of Heber and Barak, suggesting that such weak men are as much to blame for Sisera’s death as Jael herself.
|
Exegetical Commentaries as a Prerequisite for the Formulation of “Theologies” of the Septuagint
Program Unit: Septuagint Studies
Johann Cook, Universiteit van Stellenbosch
The time has come for dealing with other issues than text-critical ones in Septuagint studies. Introductory questions, such as the provenance of individual books, is one appropriate example, another is hermeneutical issues, like the formulation of “theologies” of the Septuagint. In a main paper presented at the IOSOT congress in Ljubljana in 2007, I suggested that a number of methodological issues should be dealt with in this regard. A prominent one is the role of exegetical commentaries of individual books in this process. This paper will focus on the LXX of Proverbs and will deal with the following aspects:
• Reference to the criteria of the SBL commentary series,
• The textual base for this commentary, i.a. the option to deal with the Old Greek text instead of one or more mss,
• The significance of the translation technique followed by the translator,
• A pilot study of Proverbs 8 to determine the role of wisdom in LXX Proverbs,
• An example of the formulation of a theology of LXX Proverbs with the commentary of Prov 8 as point of departure.
Johann Cook, Dept of Ancient Studies, University of Stellenbosch
|
Burgeoning Holiness: Fecundity Let Loose in Ezekiel 34–36
Program Unit: Prophets
Stephen Cook, Virginia Theological Seminary
Burgeoning Holiness: Fecundity Let Loose in Ezekiel 34–36
|
Repetitions in 2 and 3 John
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Malcolm Coombes, Trinity Theological College (Auchenflower)
Abstract of Proposal for Paper Presentation
SBL International Meeting
Vienna, July, 2014
(Revd Dr) Malcolm Coombes
Name of Paper: Repetitions in 2 and 3 John
Repetitions have often been observed in the Johannine literature. Their role in the Gospel of John and 1 John has particularly been noted, however 2 John and 3 John still warrant further exploration. In 1 John repetitions are used to define small subunit structures, i.e. they have a structural role. As well as providing rhetorical effect, they also serve to guide the flow of thought through 1 John, and they emphasise particular features within each subunit. As well as being able to identify poetic structures in these 1 John subunits (such as parallelisms, antitheses, chiasms, longer inverted parallel structures), there are also prosaic elements which also gain emphasis, even though they are not necessarily part of the repetitious structures in the subunit. This paper attempts to analyse the repetitious structures of 2 and 3 John along the same lines of analysis as has been undertaken for 1 John. It is found that the structures of 2 and 3 John show similarities (and also some differences) to 1 John. Some of the poetic structures are present as well as the prosaic elements. This analysis demonstrates a structure for these letters (as it does with 1 John). This structuring process, including paying attention to the prosaic elements, acts to emphasise the central concerns of the letters. It is thus concluded that 2 John 7-8 forms the central focus for 2 John and 3 John 5-10 forms the central focus for 3 John. This is significant as scholars are often puzzled in finding the main theme of, or prime reason for, these two small letters.
|
Rediscovering Religion in Metropolis: The Dispositif as a Reading Strategy
Program Unit: Bible and the Moving Image
Laura Copier, Universiteit Utrecht
This presentation will focus on the concept of the dispositif in relation to Fritz Lang’s 1927 film Metropolis. The term dispositif is derived from the apparatus theory, pioneered by Jean-Louis Baudry in the early 1970s. Apparatus theory is grounded in the notion that cinema’s technological base (appareil de base, all the machinery necessary to produce and to screen a film) is an ideological construct. Even though Baudry’s analysis, firmly rooted in Marxist theory, might still be relevant within the larger field of classic film theory, the concept has undergone some significant changes in the last 25 years.
Tom Gunning’s 1986 intervention via his now famous coining of the term “cinema of attractions” and the role dispositif plays in his assessment of Early Cinema, has given new meaning to the disposif as a tool for analysis. In short, Gunning’s definition of the dispositif of the cinema of attractions hints to the fact that the interrelationship between a technology, a specific film form and a specific spectator can and should be historicized.
Frank Kessler, in his 2006 appropriation of the term dispositif, proposes to retool the term in order for it to be a heuristic tool. As he argues, “a historical analysis based on the concept of the dispositif re-interpreted in a pragmatic perspective could actually take into account different uses of one and the same text within different exhibition contexts, or different historical framings” (Kessler, “The Cinema of Attractions as Dispositif”, 2006: 61).
Taking my cue from Kessler, I will argue that in the case of the restored 2010 version of Lang’s Metropolis, the configuration of technology, text and spectatorship, results in a rereading of the film’s obvious religious themes, characters and imagery, within a contemporary context.
|
Making Strange the Bible: Historical Criticism and Science Fiction
Program Unit: Science Fiction and the Bible (EABS)
Collin Cornell, Emory University
Critical biblical scholarship has since the early modern period re-contextualized the Bible to the situations that produced it, thereby “making it strange” to contexts of contemporary use. Theological students often experience this defamiliarization as perplexing. This paper, however, advocates for the theologically positive application of historical criticism on analogy with the eros of reading science fiction. If, following the work of Darko Suvin, Simon Spiegel, and others, science fiction can cause pleasure and generate new insights by introducing the strange into the familiar, historical criticism can do the same for the Bible.
|
Biblical Insertions in Panegyric on Saint Basil the Great (Gregory the Theologian)
Program Unit: The Reception of the Scripture in the Patristic Exegesis (II-VIII centuries) (EABS)
Ioana Costa, University of Bucharest
The panegyric Gregory the Theologian wrote for Basil the Great three years after his death is probably a revised and amplified version of an oration. Structured on a natural biographical thread that highlights the encounter of the two saints, the text includes biblical insertions, in a delicate equilibrium with the references to the heritage of the classical culture, mostly in the opening part, devoted to their studies in Athens. The classical hints are predominantly literary and mythological, but the etymological perspective is also present, in a skilful and subtle manner. The biblical mentions or allusions, on the other side, are multifarious, both in content and place of insertion. An inventory of these elements interwoven in the Panegyric on Saint Basil the Great is expected to widen its significance.
|
The Kingdom of Heaven Is Like a Mustard Tree
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
J. R. C. Cousland, University of British Columbia
The Gospel of Matthew relates that the kingdom of heaven is like a grain of mustard seed: “it is the smallest of all seeds, but when it has grown it is the greatest of shrubs and becomes a tree, so that the birds of the air come and make nests in its branches” (Matt 13:32).
Though it is certainly familiar, this metaphor is far from perfect. Even in the ancient world, few would have described the bush as a “tree,” and it is certainly questionable whether the mustard bush’s branches were actually strong and stable enough to allow birds to make nests in them. Various reasons for this identification can be proposed. Perhaps the simplest is that Jesus (or the author of Q) simply chose an imperfect metaphor. Given that the small size of the seed was proverbial, he described the bush as a “tree” to develop the theme of contrast. Alternately, the reference to the tree could be regarded as an allusion to the “world tree” of Ezekiel, Daniel, and the Psalms. Other scholars regard the bush as being a parody or burlesque of the “world tree,” while others yet discern an anti-imperial focus.
This study wishes to propose an additional reason why the mustard bush has been described as a tree.
|
Cosmological Imagination in Ancient Teleological Ethics
Program Unit: Place, Space, and Identity in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Eric Covington, University of St. Andrews
One of the principle distinguishing factors between ancient schools of philosophy was their imagination of the structure and order of the cosmic space surrounding them. Their unique conception of space also resulted in a distinctive notion of the role and purpose of humanity within that broader cosmology. This paper proposes to examine how two central philosophical schools of the first century ancient world integrated their view of human ethics with their imagination of cosmic space. First, we will examine the Epicureans, who held to a version of Democritus’ atomistic theory in which the whole of the cosmos is composed of tiny particles of matter. While typically, these particles move mechanistically downward within a void apart from the influence of the deities, they could also move in a “swerve,” which is an unpredictable movement to the side that ultimately breaks any sense of deterministic fatalism. This imagination of their own particular cosmos—-which interestingly could be held while simultaneously allowing for the possibility of an infinite number of worlds-—resulted in the view that freedom from pain and worry was the ultimate goal of the human life. Next, we will examine the Stoics, who held to a radically different cosmology, in which the cosmos is a single, living entity composed of an active and passive force that is shared by everything in the cosmos. This vision of their world resulted in a stark, deterministic view of the events of the cosmos, in which the goal of human life becomes action in accordance with nature. Finally, the paper will briefly conclude with a few suggestions for how these findings could be useful for further study within biblical literature, particularly highlighting the need for integration between conceptions of cosmic space and individual ethics in the early Christian community.
|
The Teleological Ideology of the Artemisian and Roman Imperial Cults in Ancient Ephesos: Implications for Further Understanding Early Christian Eschatology
Program Unit: Early Christianity (EABS)
Eric Covington, University of St. Andrews
Within the multivalent religious world of ancient Ephesos, two cults stand above the others in importance to the Roman capital of Asia twice named neokoros: the cult of Artemis and the Imperial Cult. Each cult was deeply intertwined within the fabric of the ancient city, architecturally as well as ideologically. By examining the remnant myths and stories associated with these two cults, we will seek to determine a certain element of the philosophical ideology under-girding each group: namely, the representation of the telic ideal of their respective adherents. Concerning the Artemisian Cult, we will pay particular attention to how mythic stories like the birth of Artemis influenced social memory, conceptions of the identity of the polis, and the status of individuals within the polis. Particularly, we will examine how the prevailing myths of the cult sought to influence the conceptions of the purpose and goal for its adherents. Then, we will similarly examine the myths told within the Imperial Cult, identifying the teleological ideology expressed by the imperial mythology. The ideological representation of the cosmic order in light of imperial dogma also had important implications for understanding the plan and purpose of the polis. Intriguingly, these two cults were not mutually exclusive of each other in ancient Ephesos, with the two ideologies demonstrating some overlap, as evidenced by the wardens of the Athenian mysteries self-designating as philosebastoi. In conclusion, this paper will briefly reflect on the implications for understanding early Christian eschatology in light of the teleological conceptions of these two prominent ideologies. In this conclusion, focus will be placed on the Pauline and Johannine traditions associated with Ephesos and how they offer a similar, and yet distinct telic ideal for the adherents of their own writings.
|
The Phenomenon of Narrative Exchange: Isaac/Ishmael and Jesus/Substitute in Islamic Exegetical Tradition
Program Unit: Quran and Islamic Tradition in Comparative Perspective
Ryann Elizabeth Craig, Catholic University of America
The exchanges of Ishmael for Isaac and a substitute for Jesus highlight the historical development of the phenomenon of narrative exchange in the Islamic exegetical tradition through the substitution of key figures. The Quranic account of Abraham’s testing (Q 37.100-109) leaves the sacrificial son unnamed, just as the ambiguous phrase in the crucifixion account, wa-lakin shubbiha lahum (Q 4.157), left exegetical space for reading a substitute on the cross. This paper explores the contextual frame in which the development of character substitutions mirrored that of narrative exchange in evolving Islamic thought, in light of Islam’s changing relationship to compilations of biblical lore and other “Jewish” sources.
The isra’iliyyat and qisas al-anbiya’ narratives provided foundational material in early Islam. These sources significantly shaped Muslim consciousness vis-à-vis its Abrahamic brothers. In sources utilizing prophetic folklore, the identity of Abraham’s sacrifice was not resolved for roughly two hundred years, and the trajectory of accepting or rejecting Isaac follows the same path as that of the appropriate use or dismissal of Jewish contributors. Yet for the substitute of Jesus, the trajectory of narrative exchange is largely dependent on proponents of Jewish sources, and developed in approximately the same timeframe.
By exploring the historical development of character substitution in the stories of Abraham’s sacrifice and Jesus’ crucifixion, this study follows the thought of those who accepted or rejected the Muslim converts (former Jewish rabbi) Ka’b al-Ahbar (d. 654) and (arguably Jewish) Wahb bin Munabbih (d. 732). The result of this development was the normalization of Ishmael (against Ka’b and Wahb) and acceptance of the substitute for Jesus (in agreement with Wahb). These exegetical narrative exchanges trace the historical development of the Islamic relationship to Jewish lore, illustrating that influence of Jewish narratives was dependent on the contextual frame of a developing, distinctively Islamic identity.
|
Threshold Bodies: Covenants "Between the Pieces" in the Bible and Ancient Near East
Program Unit: Ancient Near East
Cory Crawford, Ohio University
The two covenants “between the pieces” narrated in the Bible (Gen 15 and Jer 34) are almost always understood in light of the rather more familiar framework of action that plays on the semitic idiom emphasizing the action of cutting (indeed, whence the idiom derives) – as evidenced in the covenant of circumcision (Gen 17) or the treaty of Sefire. Too often the analysis of Gen 15 and Jer 34 concludes by evoking the connection with the act of cutting or of sympathetic magic, wherein the fate of the sacrificial victim becomes the fate of the covenant makers should they break the agreement.
What is less frequently discussed, and what makes these ceremonies unique, is the spatial relationship they establish between victim and participant. I argue in this paper that, understood against the backdrop of similar acts reported in Hittite ritual texts and Greek historiography, these covenants evoke the military trope of trampling one’s enemy known from ancient Near Eastern iconographic as well as textual traditions. Thus in addition to the Hittite and Greek texts mentioned, one finds a trampling of corpses in ancient Near Eastern historiography as well as in early visual records such as the Stele of the Vultures, the so-called Standard of Ur, and the Stele of Naram-Sin.
In both Genesis 15 and Jer 34 the authors utilize much more than the act of cutting – they rely on the spatial arrangement of the victim’s corpse as well as on the hierarchical positioning of head and feet in conveying their message. The particular spatial arrangement of the corpses creates a threshold that enables the transition of status to be visualized. Drawing out these connections helps the reader to understand better the nuances of the individual texts under consideration in their broader setting.
|
Ways of Knowing in the Gospel of John: An Analysis of the Translation of Oida and Gignosko in Wulfila's Gothic New Testament
Program Unit: The Reception of the Bible in Greco-Roman Tradition
Robert Crellin, Greek Bible College, Athens
The Gothic New Testament, translated in the fourth century by bishop Wulfila, presents a potentially invaluable source of information regarding how the NT was understood in the early church. This is particularly the case where the translation does not follow the Greek exactly, but shows variation from the original. It is in these cases that questions of interpretation come clearly to the fore. One notable area where this may be seen is in the translation of concepts of 'knowing'. While Greek uses two principal verbs for 'knowing' and 'coming to know', namely oida and gignosko, Gothic uses at least six: witan 'to know', kunnan 'to know', ufkunnan 'to recognise', fraþjan 'to understand', magan 'to be able to' and leisan 'to know through learning'. The most important distinction is that between witan and kunnan. Evidence is presented accounting for the difference between these verbs with reference to the distinction between knowledge by acquaintance and knowledge by description (Russell, B. 1917. "Knowledge by acquaintance and knowledge by description" Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 1910-11), a distinction which is not matched by that existing between ??da and ?????s??. On some occasions gignosko is also translated by fraþjan 'to understand', e.g. Jn 8:27, 10:6, where the knowledge referred to corresponds to another kind of knowledge, namely knowledge by inference. Yet in Jn 8:43, where the EVV from at least the KJV translate with 'to understand' vel. sim, the Gothic does not translate this way, but rather translates with kunnan implying knowledge by acquaintance. This paper sets Wulfila's translation choice in this case in the context of the broader themes and goals of the Gospel of John, seeks to explain how the different translations have developed, and explores the exegetical implications which follow in both cases for the passage in which this verse sits.
|
A Commission “Great” for Whom? A Postcolonial Contrapuntal Reading of Matt 28:18-20
Program Unit: Postcolonial Studies
Darren Cronshaw, University of Divinity
Arguably the foundational text of the modern missionary movement, the so-called “Great Commission” of Matthew 28:18-20 has been criticized by postcolonial theologians for its use in legitimizing colonial oppression. However, in its original setting this text was, ironically, subversively anti-imperial in Warren Carter’s account; the Empire could not keep Jesus dead and Jesus commissions the disciples to a worldwide totalizing mission in subversive parallel and contrast to Rome’s control. This paper offers a postcolonial reading of Matthew 28:18-20 by examining selected contemporary readings in a polycolonial context. With a particular focus on its reception history in South Asian contexts, I will explore the effect of “Saidian” contrapuntal reading by several South Asian writers, a missiologist and another biblical scholar, in exploring whether and for who the commission is “great” or not? William Carey used Matthew 28 as a proof-text in his detailed “Enquiry” and appeal for Christians to engage in foreign mission, prompting the modern missionary movement. R S Sugirtharajah critiques Carey’s use of Matthew 28, which he says was reactivated to bolster colonialism, and that while Carey opposed Indian social evils he ignored the evils of colonial oppression. George M Soares-Prabhu offers an intertextual reading of Matthew 28 alongside a Buddhist Mahavagga mission text, which draws attention to the missioner and the people they are sent to. Saugata Bhaduri, an Indian scholar with a Hindu background, emphasizes the polycolonial context of Bengal and the unintended consequences of Carey's promotion of vernacular literature. Matthew 28:18-20 concludes the Gospel of Matthew as well as opens up the future mission of the disciples. Unfortunately colonialism had a distorting affect on mission and the interpretation and application of Matthew 28.
|
What Were the Stringed Instruments of Hab 3:19?
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
David Z. Crookes, Independent Writer
Although i (the square root of minus one) was generally accepted as a mathematical fact before the middle of the nineteenth century, Cambridge University regarded i with incredulity until well into the 1880s. In a different corner of the academic vineyard, Biblical scholars of my own vintage were taught to disbelieve in Hebrew numerical alphabets. Many of us will recall one dismissive sentence: ‘This usage is not Biblical; the first traces of it are found on Maccabean coins’ [J Weingreen, A Practical Grammar for Classical Hebrew (Oxford, 1959), 2]. A few of us will also remember how John McLeish restated the old orthodoxy [Number (London, 1991), 95]: ‘Some historians even ask how the Jewish nation survived for 15 or 16 centuries in spite of having no system of written numerals: the first Hebrew numerals known appear on coins of the Hasmonean dynasty in the 2nd century.’ Well, well! Orthodoxies crumble like the works of Ozymandias. Thus chemists have stopped believing in phlogiston, while anatomists have stopped believing in vestigial organs. For their part, more and more Biblical scholars have come to accept that the Hebrew alphabet possessed two numerical forms: one having the values 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 200 300 400, and the other having the values 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22. It is convenient to name these two forms, after the values of their final letters, respectively as ‘the 400 alphabet’ and ‘the 22 alphabet’.
[text truncated]
|
The Activity of God, Christ, and the Spirit: A Proposed Foundation for a Theology of Gender
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Kenneth L. Cukrowski, Abilene Christian University
Because of the diversity of portrayals of the feminine within Scripture and because these portrayals reflect various social constructions of gender emanating from the specific cultural environments found within the biblical text, it is difficult to imagine Scripture contributing much to a theology of gender. This paper, however, proposes the theology of gender based on the activity of God at creation, Christ in redemption, and the Spirit in gifting the church. Based on Genesis 1 and 1 Corinthians 11:7-10, 11-12, an examination of God’s activity in creation shows an emphasis on equality and mutuality in terms of identity and function of males and females. A study of Galatians 3:28 and its Old Testament context (Joel 2:28-32) reveals the results of Christ’s work in redemption: an equality of identity in Christ independent of age, gender, class, and ethnicity. Finally, the activity of the Spirit, focusing on Acts 2 and 1 Corinthians 12, demonstrates that the Holy Spirit gifts all humanity, and those gifts are not distributed based on gender. Thus, rather than an obstacle, Scripture offers a constructive theology of gender when viewed through the lenses of the activity of God, Christ, and the Holy Spirit.
|
A Proposed Allusion to Euripides' Ion in Luke's Infancy Narrative
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Kenneth L. Cukrowski, Abilene Christian University
One of the most intriguing aspects of the infancy narrative in Luke is the three-fold repetition of the description of the infant Jesus wrapped in swaddling cloths and lying in a manger (Luke 2:7, 12, 16). Why would the author emphasize such a description in his retelling of the birth? Many commentators point to Isaiah 1:3 as the source of Luke’s allusion. This paper proposes an allusion to Euripides’ Ion, in which the identification of Ion as a son of the god Apollo is connected to cloths left with the infant Ion. The body of the paper examines the plausibility of such a claim, by noting other allusions to Ion in Luke-Acts, namely Acts 21:39 and Ion 8, and examining the function such an allusion would have. Richard Hays’ multiple tests for echoes within Scripture provide the structure and the main questions for my discussion of this proposed allusion to Ion. In the end, I contend that an allusion to Ion offers an important possibility to explain the three-fold allusion to the babe wrapped in swaddling cloths and lying in a manger.
|
Is the Servant of YHWH Also a Witness?
Program Unit: Prophets
Giovanna Czander, Dominican College
The witness motif in the prophets makes important theological use of the laws of testimony. In Second Isaiah, the witness motif is mostly applied to Israel as a people. Virtual trials in Isa 40-48 aim at shaping Israel’s identity as adequate eyewitness, trial witness and testifying witness for Yhwh. The subsequent chapters in Isaiah shift the focus to the mysterious figure of the “servant of Yhwh.” Is there continuity between these two groups of oracles? Is the character of Israel as witness (in its various roles) connected to the servant of Yhwh? Is the servant of Yhwh also a witness? Whether the servant is understood as a group or as an individual, Second Isaiah seems to indicate that this servant is in fact meant to embody all the roles of a witness as indicated in the Torah’s laws of testimony, and additionally to become a very unique type of witness, one who is willing to give testimony through his suffering for the sake of his people.
Based on a canonical reading of the text, the paper (1) argues for continuity and a strong connection between the oracles devoted to the trials (Isa 40-48) and those devoted to the suffering servant (Isa 49-55); and (2) proposes a wider vantage point for the concept and roles of witnesses stemming from the laws of testimony and in light of the oracles of Second Isaiah.
|
Multiple Melchizedeks in the Books of Jeu and Pistis Sophia
Program Unit: Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha
Kasper Dalgaard, Københavns Universitet
The Books of Jeu and the Pistis Sophia are both sterling examples of how later traditions reuse sacred texts and traditions in their compositional techniques. One example, but perhaps the most intriguing within these often overlooked early Christian writings, is the manifold Melchizedek-traditions we find harmonized by the redactors of the texts. While these Melchizedek-figures ultimately derive from the text of the Hebrew Bible (Gen 14:18-20; Ps 110:4) and the New Testament (Heb 7), their guises within these two 3rd-century texts reflect how the redactors compiled numerous traditions together through their unique reading strategies.
In order to reveal the intertextual techniques at work within these two texts, this paper will identify and detail the existence of twelve distinct Melchizedek-traditions within the chapters of the Books of Jeu and the Pistis Sophia. The content of these traditions and the functions ascribed to Melchizedek are often surprising, distinct, and even self-contradictory (ranging from a Melchizedek described as the supreme god to a more servile Melchizedek who functions merely as a low-ranking member of the cosmic hierarchy) and their differences and quantity further reveals how frequently the Melchizedek-figure was reused and rethought in antiquity.
The key aspects of each tradition and the combined effect of the redactors' work will in this paper be used to situate the Melchizedek of the Books of Jeu and the Pistis Sophia within the Melchizedek-traditions of Second Temple Judaism and later times (including the Melchizedek-traditions found in Genesis, Songs of the Sabbath Sacrifice (4Q400-407; 11Q17; Mas1k), 11QMelchizedek, Philo of Alexandria, 2 Book of Enoch, Hebrews, Josephus, and the Melchizedek-Tractate) comparing their interaction with, and reuse of, sacred texts and traditions, their reading strategies, and their compositional techniques.
|
Two post-Homeric Greek Literary Genres: Alexandrian Epic, and the ‘Ideal Love Novel’
Program Unit: The Reception of Classical "Text" in the Greco-Roman World
Georg Danek, University of Vienna
Homer remained, throughout antiquity, an unquestioned authority for defining Greek cultural identity. This universal truth comes true even for two literary genres that aim at overcoming, and replacing, the dominating role of the Homeric epics: Hellenistic epics, and the ‘Ideal Love Novel’. Alexandrian poets propagated the end of ‘old poetry’, pronouncing the dogma of ‘big poem, big evil’, but still composed extended epic mythological narratives which, by definition, evoke Homeric language, style and narrative technique. I will show that Callimachus in his Hecale, and Apollonius in his Argonautica, use almost identical methods for reaching the same goal, namely opposing and replacing the Homeric model: Callimachus seems to oppose the Homeric model in every single aspect of his poetry. Apollonius, on the contrary, appears to stick to his model very closely, but uses Homeric formulaic diction without producing formulas, and transports the well-known Homeric heroes into a very un-heroic modern world.
The ‘Ideal Greek Love Novel’ aims at creating, for the first time in Greek literature, extended prose narratives based on purely fictional plots. Apart from historiography, the Homeric epics appear to be the most important model for guiding the readers of this new genre towards the right interpretation of its meaning. Chariton, our first extant author, intersperses his narrative with a vast number of Homeric verses so as to remind his readers of the fact that his plot is a variant of the Big Story of the Trojan War, resulting in an Odyssean Happy Ending. Heliodorus in his Aithiopica, on the other hand, offers an incredible quantity of verbal citations of, subtle allusions to, and learned discussions of Homeric passages, so as to show that his masterpiece is worthy of rivaling its primary source of inspiration, the Homeric epics.
|
Hannah as David’s “Spiritual Mother” in the Book of Samuel
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible/Old Testament/Ancient Israel Studies (EABS)
Ruth Danino Lichtenstein, Oranim Academic College and Ohalo College
While the book of Samuel opens with Samuel’s birth, Hannah plays a central role in the story. Her portrayal as an exemplary figure suggests that the reader is meant to identify her “double” in the text as a whole. She is presented as an ordinary woman of faith who initiates a transformation in her life by turning directly to God in a vow. As is well known, her hymn is a secondary addition to the narrative, which contributes greatly to the shaping of her character. Her two prayers contain a full circle of turning to God: from request (1 Sam 1:11) to thanksgiving (1 Sam 2:1-10). She is transformed from being an agent of her own change of fate into a woman of wisdom, leader, and prophetess. As such, she delivers eternal truths about God and His ways to those on pilgrimage.
Who is Hannah’s “mirror image” in the book of Samuel? While two of the recurrent roots used in the story of Samuel’s birth—??"? and ??"?—appear to link key figures in the book—Saul, Jonathan, and Nathan—to Hannah, it is David, whose name is not linked with the opening narrative, whose character most closely resembles hers.
Like Hannah, he turns to God in prayer when in distress and gives thanks for God’s intervention. Like her, he also presents his life experience as the basis for insights into God ways, stresses that those of faith must act righteously. Like her, he is a person of prayer, a poet, wise man, and prophet. The book thus marks him out—primarily at the end of the narrative—as the person who takes Hannah as his role model and imitates her behaviour.
|
The Use of Computational Linguistics to Identify the Different Families of the Arabic Gospels Translations Preserved in the Manuscripts’ Tradition
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical Studies, Early Jewish and Christian Studies (EABS)
Elie Dannaoui, University of Balamand
Several attempts were made to study the linguistic features of the Gospels’ Arabic translations in order to identify the different textual traditions. The majority of these projects use verbal agreement between texts to define their identities. In some cases, other techniques were used on a reduced scale in analyzing selected texts. The limitations of these attempts reside in the fact that the study used a small number readings selected from few manuscripts and was not formalized or automated.
In our paper we present an automated linguistic corpus processing platform for Arabic manuscripts texts. All transcribed texts are subject to a morphosyntactic annotation. Lexical, grammatical and inflectional properties (tense, grammatical mood, grammatical voice, aspect, person, number, gender and case) are associated with the annotated text. These linguistic properties allow the system to perform complex searches based on abstract representations of a specific word, sentence, paragraph, syntax and occurrence…
In order to formalize all possible verbal tokens, we defined a taxonomy of inflectional classes for Arabic verbs. This taxonomy allows the system to encode simultaneously in the lexical representation three variations: inflectional, morphophonemic and orthographic.
|
The Events Grammaticalized by Tithemi and Tithemi Compounds in the Septuagint and New Testament
Program Unit: Hellenistic Greek Language and Linguistics
Paul Danove, Villanova University
Tithemi and its twenty compounds grammaticalize ten distinct events n the Septuagint and New Testament. This paper resolves the occurrences of tithemi and its twenty compounds according to the event that they grammaticalize and proposes procedures for deriving nine of the events from one base event through incremental changes in the conceptualizations of the events. The discussion then summarizes the relationships among the events and proposes a further basis for relating the events.
|
Involving Undergraduates in Narrative/Character/Rhetorical Studies of the Gospel of Mark: Paper Projects
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Paul Danove, Villanova University
This paper discusses the manner in which I develop paper projects on the Gospel of Mark for undergraduate classes. After outlining the exegetical methods that I use in my own research, the paper considers the manner in which I formulate paper projects that use similar methods to study one or more passages in the Gospel of Mark. This formulation requires an address of three questions: what is a feasible outcome for students who have no knowledge of Greek and no necessary knowledge of the content of the Gospel of Mark beyond that presented in class; which analytical tools are necessary to assist the students; and which design of the project best meets the expected competencies of students. The presentation will include examples of the guidelines for paper writing and the analytical tools designed for specific papers.
|
The Calendrical Framework of the Priestly Flood Story in Light of a New Akkadian Text from Ugarit (RS 94.2953)
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Traditions in the Biblical World and Beyond
Guy Darshan, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
The only Priestly pre-Exodus narrative to be framed in explicitly chronological terms is the Flood account. Here I would like to suggest that P may be based in this unique case on earlier models that were in possession of a precise temporal framework in light of a recently published Akkadian text from Ugarit (RS 94.2953) and Berossus’ version of the Flood story.
|
Biblical Elements in the Archaeology of Jewish Diasporas in the Roman Empire
Program Unit: Reception of the Bible in Jewish, Early Christian and Islamic Art
Nora David, University of Vienna
The question of Jewish (self-)identification in the diasporas of antiquity is a methodological core point of archaeological and historical research. The use of Biblical tradition is one of the most important elements oft his identification. Although verbatim quotations are rare in archaeological context in the diaspora, some phrases, names, and motifs turn up at different points of the Roman Empire. This paper aims to examine these occurrences, and analyzes their significance in the identification of finds as Jewish.
|
Individuals or Communities? – Jews in the Danubian Provinces of the Roman Empire
Program Unit: Archaeology and Diaspora Judaism
Nóra Dávid, University of Vienna
Larger Jewish communities are known from several provinces and cities of the Roman Empire (e.g. Rome, Asia Minor). We read in written sources and on inscriptions about their synagogues, religious hierarchy, etc. Otherwise, from other provinces (e.g. Pannonia, Moesia, etc.) we have only sporadic literary sources and archaeological finds mentioning or connected to Jews. Based on them the historical reconstruction is more than difficult. A basic question of the research is, if it is possible to reconstruct any history/ies of Jewish community/ies, or we can speak only about Jewish individuals turning up in some settlements of the Roman Empire. In order to be able to come to conclusions, this paper focuses on some methodological questions of Jewish diaspora studies, such as identification of finds as Jewish, group of finds as connected to one community, Jews in Roman legislation, etc. Besides the methodological questions an overview of the most important finds is also needed, and will be done in this presentation.
|
Moses on Screen From Cecil B. De Mille Until Today
Program Unit: Bible and the Moving Image
Klaus Davidowicz, Universität Wien
With the impending release of Ridley Scott's own cinematic version of the Exodus, this paper offers a critical survey of cinematic representations of Moses since the seminal contributions of Cecil B. DeMille.
|
"Macht den Tempel wieder rein. Laßt uns Makkabäer sein!" Der deutsche Zionismus und die Makkabäer
Program Unit: Reception of the Bible in the Sign of World War One
Klaus Davidowicz, Universität Wien
Im 19. Jahrhundert wurde Chanukka, das Fest, das Jahrhunderte lang eher ein Nischendasein im jüdischen Festtagskalender geführt hatte, wurde in den zionistischen Strömungen in Österreich und Deutschland geradezu „wiederbelebt.“ Der Sieg des traditionellen Judentums gegenüber dem assimilierten hellenisierten Judentum wurde im Zionismus zu einem Symbol nationaler Befreiung. In Wien wurde am 20. Dezember 1883 die erste zionistische Makkabäerfeier durch die Studentenverbindung „Kadima" ins Leben gerufen. In den zionistischen Jugendbewegungen in Österreich und Deutschland wurde durch ihre Chanukka-Feiern als „Chag ha-Makkabim" (Fest der Makkabäer) oder „Chag ha-Chaschmonaim" (Fest der Hasmonäer) ein bewusster Kontrapunkt gegen die seltsame Verschmelzung von Weihnachten und Chanukka als „Weihnukka" der assimilierten jüdischen Bürgerhäuser gesetzt. Die Instrumentalisierung der Makkabäer im Zionismus sollte seinen Höhepunkt im Ersten Weltkrieg finden. Martin Buber (1878-1965) politisierte Chanukka 1914 in seiner Rede „Die Tempelweihe“ sogar so weit, indem er den Weltkrieg mit dem Krieg der Makkabäer verglich. In dieser Rede, die er bei einer zionistischen Chanukka-Feier gehalten hatte, bezeichnete Buber die Teilnahme am Weltkrieg als eine befreiende national-jüdische Erfahrung. So schrieb Heinrich Loewe (1869-1951): “Wenn wir als Bürger unseres Vaterlandes kämpfen, so leuchtet uns die Tapferkeit unserer Ahnen, der Todesmut der Makkabäer, der Riesenkampf eines Bar-Kochba und der Heldentod Hunderttausender unseres Volkes in allen Zeiten als glorreiches Beispiel voran!“ (Jüdische Rundschau 9. Jahrgang, Nr. 32, S.344) Der Vortrag wird anhand der zionistischen Artikel, Gedichte und Reden wie der Kampf der Makkabäer in der Zeit des Weltkrieges symbolisch herangezogen wurde und dass dennoch auch diese patriotischen Zionisten nicht vom Antisemitismus verschont blieben.
|
Capistrano's Anti-Semitism
Program Unit: Anti-Semitic Readings of the Bible
Klaus Davidowicz, Universität Wien
John of Capistrano (1386 - 1456) is an enigmatic figure. He was a famous preacher and theologian, but also a feared inquisitor and fanatical anti-Semite, so that he is known as the "Scourge of the Jews." The lecture describes his life and his anti-Semitism, but also the historical impact of Capistrano. In Austria, Germany, Hungary or Croatia, there are altars, statues and churches named after him.
|
Israel as an Ethnos: A Historical Approach
Program Unit: Anthropology and the Bible (EABS)
Philip R. Davies, University of Sheffield
Ethnicity is a term rather too loosely used these days to designate different kinds of groups identities, for example, racial, physiognomic (e.g. Caucasian, black) and sometimes religious (e.g. Jewish). For the historian, anthropologist and archaeologist a fairly precise definition is desirable, one that does not merely identify a distinct social group, but does so on the basis of agreed criteria.
My own definition derives from a historical perspective and recognises that the recognition of ‘ethne’ in antiquity was occasioned by the breakdown of national identities and the emergence of transnational ones (i.e. empires). The clearest examples available to the biblical scholar are the Roman empire and, to a lesser extent, the Achaemenid empire. Ethnicity is in these circumstances a useful tool in determining those populations governed by customs that offer a basis for the settlement of legal disputes. Where the participants behave according tom the same norms, legal administration can usually be left to such groups, a policy that nevertheless entails recognition of a leadership of such groups and an authorised structure of judges and courts which would, ultimately, have the authority of the emperor or imperial law to support its work. Hence, with the advent of the sovereign state in modern times, ethnicity is neither necessary nor useful, and tho is why the word has shifted towards genetic or religious categories. For the biblical scholar, two aspects of ethnicity are particularly important. One is the book of Ezra, in which the concept is applied very clearly (but this does not guarantee the historicity of the figure of Ezra!); the other is the search for an ‘ethnic’ Israel in the pre-monarchic and monarchic periods, where, in my view, the term has no useful application at all: ‘Israel’ can only be either a political or (less probably) a tribal designation.
|
"From Dead Works and Faithfulness Toward God": The Ethical Problem of Hebrews
Program Unit: Epistle to the Hebrews
Phillip Davis, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
In 1992 Thomas Schmidt argued that 'moral lethargy' might comprise an overlooked problem for the audience of Hebrews, alongside problems of persecution or social pressure. Schmidt's short but dense article appears to have gained little traction, but his observations on the moral language of Hebrews deserve a second look. Since Schmidt's article, it has become all the more typical to understand some sort of persecution or social pressure from without as the main problem faced by the audience. This study, however, returns to Schmidt's thesis and seeks to show that whatever the outside danger might be, the author of Hebrews describes the right and wrong responses to that danger in moral terms. The paper first overviews the moral language of the exhortation passages, especially in connection to apostasy. Although it may, upon first glance, appear that sin and unbelief or unfaithfulness are simply descriptors of apostasy, such a conception flattens out the author's treatment of the problem. Next, the paper examines the positive and negative exemplars in Hebrews. On the one hand, the author connects faithfulness with positive ethical terms and describes it with examples of obedient actions and righteous behavior. On the other hand, the author describes falling away with negative ethical terminology and connects it with disobedient actions and behavior. This analysis shows that despite Hebrews' paucity of specific moral directives, it makes up for in its thoroughly ethical substructure. Finally, the paper concludes by showing how the foregoing observations help better explain both the need for 'discernment of good and evil' (5:14) and the function of a divine discipline that leads to 'peaceful fruits of righteousness' (12:11).
|
Victory through Defeat: Giving Meaning to the Believer’s Death on the Battlefield in Islamic Ascetic Literature Compared to the Christian “Acta Martyrum”
Program Unit: Quran and Islamic Tradition in Comparative Perspective
Ignazio De Francesco, Pontifical Institute for Arabic and Islamic Studies
This paper examines what is presumably the most ancient Muslim ascetic work which deals with the theme of “holy war,” the Kitab al-Jihad by Abd Allah b. al-Mubarak (d. 797). In the Kitab al-Jihad, the value of death itself emerges as a deep inspiration for the believer and the true objective to strive for on the battlefield. This aspect is – to a certain extent – quite puzzling, when we consider the general nature and “institutional” goals of military effort in Islam: defeating the enemy and emerging victorious. Without rejecting these secular aims, the ascetic warrior nevertheless reverses the perspective: real triumph is achieved only with personal “defeat,” the death at the hands of the enemy. The aims of the Islamic state as such have little to do with this profoundly individualist vision, which is more centered on the warrior’s intentions and personal devotion than on military strategy and obedience to a superior. This intriguing reversal of meaning concerning the military effort challenges the widely-accepted idea of the irreconcilable difference between the martyrs in jihad, who sacrifice their lives just for the advance of Islam, and Christian martyrs of the first centuries, who voluntarily suffer death just as a testimony of faith and refusal to give up their religion. In the passionate search for a final encounter with God, animating ascetics from both sides, several ideas present in Ibn al-Mubarak’s Kitab al-Jihad can be compared to what we find in the Christian “Acta Martyrum.” This literature will thus be used in comparison to Ibn al-Mubarak’s work, specifically taking into account the Syriac acts of the martyrdom of Shemon Bar Sabbae (d. 339), bishop of Seleucia-Ctesiphon killed during the persecutions of Shapur II.
|
A Lion Figurine from the ‘City of David’?
Program Unit: Iconography and Biblical Studies (EABS)
Izaak J. de Hulster, University of Helsinki & Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
Figurine fragment D2/21036 from Shiloh’s City of David excavation is one of the smallest figurines found during this excavation. As it is only a fragment, one of the questions concerns the identification of what it represents; could it be a lion figurine? If so, to what extent is it a unique piece? What light do the fragment’s size, its material, and its find context (Area D2, stratum 8) shed on these issues? What can be said about its date based on its find context and its iconography?
|
Listening to Textual and Contextual Echoes in Mk 10:42-45
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Alberto de Mingo Kaminouchi, Alphonsian Academy
“Echo” is a useful metaphor for exploring Mark. My approach presupposes that this Gospel retains features of oral literature, among them the use of modulated repetitions that give coherence to the narrative, but my goal is to go beyond literary criticism of these “textual echoes” to study the “contextual echoes” that resonate with the reader’s social experience.
The best explanation of why Mark was so well received by early Christians (to the point of eliciting two “expanded versions” we now call Matthew and Luke) is because it sounded true as a portrait of their Jesus. Mark was produced and was recognized as canonical in a Tradition that was much more than “Oral tradition”, understood as a transmission of pieces of information. “Tradition” here names a set of beliefs and practices that defines a way of life. Mark resonated with this lived experience.
The purpose of this paper is to reflect on how students can deepen their reading of Mark by “listening” to a text resonating with other passages in Scripture and with Tradition. I have chosen Mk 10:42-45 because these teachings are extremely rich in textual and contextual echoes.
Concretely, I want students to work out on the connections of 10:42-45 with its dramatic counterpart in 10:35-41; to relate 10:32-45 to the previous two repetitions of the pattern “passion prediction - disciples’ failure - Jesus’ teaching” (8:31-9:1; 9:30-50); and to listen to other textual echoes inside Mark (6:14-29; 15:1-15; etc.) and in the Old Testament (Dn 7, 9-14; Is 52,13-53,12; etc.). But I also want the student to go out from the world of the text to the worlds behind and in front of the text. Mark’s contextual echoes resonate with practices of the Church as an alternative polis that challenges the powers of the world.
|
Spiritual Hermeneutics and Biblical Spirituality as a New Approach in New Testament Studies?
Program Unit: Methods in New Testament Studies
Pieter G.R. de Villiers, Universiteit van die Vrystaat
This paper will, firstly, evaluate the pioneering and much discussed work in Biblical Spirituality of Sandra Schneiders (The Revelatory Text) in which she presented her approach in terms of contemporary hermeneutics (a.o. Ricoeur and Gadamer) and methodology as well as her exegetical work (Written that you may believe) which illustrated the application of her hermeneutical strategies and methodology to John’s Gospel. It will then compare this work with the equally groundbreaking, but own approach to Biblical Spirituality of Waaijman who, more comprehensively, utilized hermeneutical insights of Buber and Levinas in addition to those of Ricoeur and Gadamer to develop a spiritual hermeneutics as a model of Biblical interpretation. The hermeneutical and methodological aspects of their work will be compared and evaluated. Two specific examples from the exegetical work of both these scholars will then be analyzed in order to determine in what ways they enrich and move New Testament hermeneutics forward, offer new perspectives on the methodological understanding of New Testament exegesis and contribute towards decoding the meaning of Biblical texts. Finally the paper will evaluate the scientific character of these approaches within New Testament Studies as an academic enterprise.
|
Psalm 146 in the Messianic Apocalypse (4Q521) and Other Second Temple Literature
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Willem J. de Wit, Evangelical Theological Seminary in Cairo
Part of a larger project on Psalm 146 and its reception, this paper will focus on the quotation of Psalm 146:7-8 in the Messianic Apocalypse (4Q521). By way of comparison, attention will also be paid to the Septuagint translation of Psalm 146 and to the allusion to Psalm 146:3-4 in 1 Maccabees 2:62-63. The paper will pose the question of what happened to the meaning of the Psalm in these texts. Has it been enriched, changed, limited, made more specific, made more general, etc.? Has this stage of reception of the Psalm led to insights that may still be relevant for readers of the Psalm today?
Attention will be paid, for example, to the fact that the Divine Name is prominently present in Psalm 146 but absent in 4Q521. Moreover, the general statements about the LORD (possibly remembering his past actions) in the Psalm are set in a future context in 4Q521. And does the reference to God's anointed one (Messiah) in 4Q521 mean that Psalm 146 is read in a messianic way? Is there any indication that he is the actor through whom God will perform his deeds? Moreover, while the Psalm is about praising God "as long as I am still there" and only speaks about the LORD himself as being king forever, 4Q521 expresses the hope that the Lord will give life to the dead and that he will honor them upon the throne of an eternal kingdom (the exact meaning of the phrase being debated). Is this the beginning of a rereading of the Psalm that includes the perspective of eternal life, as later famously expressed by Isaac Watts: "And when my voice is lost in death, Praise shall employ my nobler powers; My days of praise shall ne'er be past"?
|
Miracles and Miracle Stories: Towards a New Interdisciplinary Approach
Program Unit: New Testament/Early Christianity/Rabbinic Studies (EABS)
Willem J. de Wit, Evangelical Theological Seminary in Cairo
Biblical scholarship has been accused of being blindfolded by naturalism and therefore being unable to accept what Biblical texts so clearly say, namely that miracles have happened. Biblical scholars may object that it is not first of all naturalism but rather the nature of the Biblical texts themselves that make them cautious to accept miracle stories at face value as reports of actual events: in the texts one can find multiple layers of meaning and signs of a complex history of tradition. This paper will call for a deeper dialog between Biblical Studies and philosophical theology regarding miracles, using insights from intercultural studies regarding the function and acceptance in various cultures today. The hope is that this paper will be the beginning of a workshop or research group on a new paradigm of reading miracle stories, a paradigm that does not escape the question of many readers of the Bible whether the miracles happened or not, but that neither stops at that question. Further research may also include the question how Biblical miracle stories influence the choice of readers to accept or reject stories about miracles today.
|
Seal and Seal Impressions Iconography, Archaeological Evidence, and the Old Testament
Program Unit: Iconography and Biblical Studies (EABS)
Robert Deutsch, Independent Scholar
The silent iconographic evidence from the Iron Age II Period (Late 8th-Early 6th century BC), depicted on the Hebrew seals and seal impressions (in contrast to the vociferous epigraphic discoveries), is often illuminated by the archaeological finds as exposed in the excavations. The Old Testament provides additional information in understanding the silent iconography. The paper will focus on a specific iconography and will point on a particular motif in light of the recent archaeological finds from the City of David in Jerusalem and the biblical source.
|
Deciphering Provenanced Epigraphs with the Aid of Unprovenanced Material
Program Unit: Epigraphical and Paleological Studies Pertaining to the Biblical World
Robert Deutsch, Independent scholar
The extensive excavations in Judah, and especially in Jerusalem yielded a relatively large number of inscribed artifacts from the Iron Age II Period, late 8th through early 6th century B.C.E. Among the epigraphic materials, the personal seals and seal impressions are important extra biblical sources which in some cases seal owners can be identified with Old Testament figures. As it happens, the finds are often fragmentary or in poor state of preservation, which makes the reading difficult or impossible. In this respect the significant corpus of unprovenanced epigraphs kept in public and private collections are of help. In some circumstances they may be critical in deciphering fragmentary epigraphs from controlled excavations. Several such cases were identified by the author and will be presented.
|
The Use of Stylistic Features in OG Job and Their Function: An Example in Job 5, 6–7
Program Unit: Septuagint Studies
Marieke Dhont, Université Catholique de Louvain
Scholars characterize the language of the OG version of the book of Job as a very 'free' translation in 'good' Greek, attesting to an evident effort at literary style. When a translator claims some 'freedom' in the way in which he handles his source text, as seems to be the case with the OG translator of Job, literary motivations are likely to be able to explain certain translational differences. What precisely the aspects of this 'literary character' of OG Job are, and how they relate to the Hebrew text, has not yet been studied systematically. In this paper, I aim to demonstrate the way in which the translator rendered his Vorlage in such a way that the result attests to OG Job being a literary creation in its own right, using Job 5,6-7 as an example.
OG Job 5,6-7 contains a number of deviations when compared to the Hebrew of the MT. From the viewpoint of the use of stylistic features (i.e. identifiable characteristics that lend the text a certain ornatus), one observes that certain features of the Hebrew are retained (e.g. the chiasmus), lost (e.g. the anaphora) or altered (e.g. the parallelism), while new ones are being introduced (e.g. the epiphora). I discuss these features individually, before demonstrating how they interact with one another. Next, the use of these features in the OG as an aspect of the translation technique is shown to interact with other aspects of the translation technique of OG Job examined by scholars such as C. Cox. I then look at what effect these features bring about – ultimately asking if, and if so in what way, the effect of their use in the Greek text differs from that of the Hebrew.
|
Recovering both Scripture and Sacrament Together: Post-Reformation Theologies of a Polyvocal and Hybrid Nature
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
Colby Dickinson, Loyola University Chicago
The nature and function of biblical texts, both within the Church and society on the whole, were significantly altered during the immediate (post)Reformation period, most notably through the Protestant adherence to the doctrine of sola scriptura—a notion that strove (and still strives in many ways) to be independent of a larger, interpretive tradition behind it and yet which must exist in (political) tension with ecclesial and theological traditions. What I want to focus on in this paper is the manner in which both sacrament and scripture, as perceived through various, relevant historical transformations and permutations from this period in history onward into the modern era, are capable of resisting their pseudo-universal application, often applied through monolithic, normative definitions of each as entirely self-referential (and therefore exclusive) religious apparatuses. Accordingly, I want here to present a certain geneaological reading of intertwining (mis)readings of both scripture and sacrament from the Reformation (in its Lutheran and Reformed versions, and with Catholic counter-Reformation impulses accompanying them) into the modern era where they are still utilized as normative measures by ‘defensive’ ecclesial formations. What I want to move toward, rather, is how we might be capable of viewing both as deposits of a ‘dangerous memory’ that Christ embodies for the community of believers (Metz) and which therefore functions in an opposing manner to any direct (modern) claims toward normative universal claims—as instead then polyvocal (scripturally) and hybrid (sacramentally) entities that actually undermine any monolithic sense of religious identity formulated in relation to them.
|
The Contribution of Mishnaic Hebrew to Biblical Hebrew Philology
Program Unit: Judaica
Haim Dihi, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
In my lecture I will discuss two verbs that appear in the Bible only rarely: hagmi'ini (Genesis 24:17) and watte'ar (Genesis 24:20). These verbs occur more frequently in Mishnaic Hebrew and are not restricted in their meaning to their biblical context. As a result of their more widespread usage in Mishnaic Hebrew, their meanings in their respective biblical contexts are clarified beyond a shadow of doubt. In my lecture, I will show how we can correctly interpret the respective biblical verses on the basis of the usage of these verbs in Mishnaic Hebrew. Understanding these two difficult biblical lexemes according to their more widespread usage in Mishnaic Hebrew is further supported by the Held method, both as regards the immediate context of these verses, and their wider context. In the first example, the main evidence is found in Rabbinic Hebrew. In the second example, etymological evidence is also forthcoming from the ancient Semitic languages, but Rabbinic Hebrew provides the main semantic evidence. Rabbinic Hebrew was first used to interpret difficult words or hapax legomena in the Bible by some medieval grammarians. Rabbi Saadia Gaon (882-942 CE) authored a book called Kitab al-sab?in laftáh, which clarifies the interpretation of eighty-five rare biblical terms by utilizing Rabbinic Hebrew. This book was written as part of his polemic against the Karaites: Saadia wanted to prove that the Oral Torah was indispensable for understanding the Written Torah and to show that Rabbinic Hebrew has the same holy status as does Biblical Hebrew. After all, both languages are employed to convey the words of the Living God.
|
Apocalypticism in Late Antique Christianity: Major Issues
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
Lorenzo DiTommaso, Concordia University - Université Concordia
Apocalypticism in Late Antique Christianity: Major Issues
|
The First Disciples of Jesus: The Case for Literary Awareness of Early Gospel Traditions in Jn 1:35-51
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Toan Do, Sacred Heart School of Theology
Background: All four gospels report JBaptist had disciples; but John is more explicit by mentioning Andrew and the unnamed disciple (John 1:35-40). In the Synoptics, Mark 1:16-18 has Simon Peter and his brother Andrew follow Jesus nearby the Sea of Galilee. Luke 5:1-11 (cf. 6:12-16) omits entirely the identity of Andrew as Peter’s brother, and replaces instead James and John as the two sons of Zebedee. Matthew 4:18-22 is similar to Luke, in that Simon is the first called disciple but, unlike Luke, Andrew is here identified as Peter’s brother.
Objectives: John presents Andrew as a more important figure than his depiction in the Synoptics (John 1:35-51). In this lengthier story John mentions five characters: the unspecified disciple, Andrew and his brother Simon Peter, Philip, and Nathanael. More particular is the presentation of the first two disciples (1:35-40), namely, the unnamed disciple in 1:35-39 and Andrew with an explicit identification in 1:40. John hints that these first two disciples originally belong to JBaptist (1:35), that after they have heard JBaptist proclaiming Jesus as the Lamb of God (1:36) they follow Jesus (1:37), and that all this happens within the third day (1:35).
Conclusion: If Harold W. Attridge’s “genre bending” merits validity, John’s presentation of Jesus’ first disciples seems to have bended the Synoptic call of Jesus’ first disciples and thus displays a clear awareness of these Gospel traditions. While the Synoptics pay more attention to Peter, James, and John as prominent representatives of the West, the Fourth Gospel focuses on Andrew and the unnamed disciple as the top tier of Jesus’ followers. Seen from this viewpoint, John’s Gospel presents its own story of the first disciples that is both distinct from and, at the same time, dependent on earlier Christian traditions.
|
A Jewish "Atlas Marianus" from the 18th Century?
Program Unit: Judaica
Karoly Daniel Dobos, Pázmány Péter Katolikus Egyetem
The humorous Anti-Christian satire of Jonah ha-Cohen Rapa (17th-18th century), entitled "Pilpul al zeman, zemanim, zemanehem" ("Argument on Festival Times, their Festivals") and written at the turn of the 17th and 18th centuries, contains a description of thirteen European sanctuaries devoted to the Virgin Mary. A really atypical thing to find in a Jewish text! More than a century ago, in the first and last published scholarly paper dealing with this phenomenon, the Hungarian-born scholar, Samuel Krauss tried to identify the sanctuaries enumerated in Jonah Rapa's text. In my lecture I shall try to correct Krauss' identifications in some points. More important, I shall attempt to answer two interrelated questions: First, why was the topic of Catholic Marian devotion important in a polemic context? Second, how can the precise identification of the shrines help us to determine the date of publication of the text? Indeed, as I shall demonstrate the precise date of the text by Jonah ha-Cohen Rapa is still a matter of debate.
|
Algsandar-I Kilisayig: an Unlikely Anti-Hero and the Curious Borrowing of a Syriac Word
Program Unit: Bible and Syriac Studies in Context
Vicente Dobroruka, Universidade de Brasília
Some (late) Persian apocalyptic texts labelled Alexander the Great with the epithet kilisayig, likely “the ecclesiastical” (Algsandar i-Kilisayig, with variations in the spelling of both names). This epithet is intriguing for two reasons: first, Alexander never had anything to do with the Church for obvious chronological reasons; and secondly, and more importantly here, because kilisayig together with its variants is not a Middle Persian word. It appears to be a corruption of “ecclesiastical” and has been duly translated so by most scholars (Gignoux, Cereti, Shapira). This paper discusses the likelihood that the epithet derives from a process of borrowing a Syriac term (in which case the epithet would come from Greek via the Syriac kelesa). It also considers if another, less-travelled path might be the correct one, taking us back to the Avestan word k’r’sa. Both paths have been suggested in earlier publications, but have not yet been set against a background of considering the role of aversion or hatred against Alexander. Beyond these specific questions, the paper considers the broader issues of the role and extent of contacts between Zoroastrians and Eastern Christians as well as the use of an Avestan word, that might be much older than Alexander and his “misdeeds” (from a Persian perspective), namely the role of the common root *PIE. If we are dealing with a borrowing from a Greek loanword into Syriac and further into Middle Persian, the epithet “the accursed” (-gizistag) for Alexander is easily explained: he is the then-current evil ruler of the Greeks at the time of the composition of the late Persian apocalypses (e.g., the Zand-‘ Wahman Yasn). Yet the ZWY also shows that there are many redactional layers. His “cursing” may have much older roots.
|
Interpreting Hebrews 3–4: Identifying the Issues and Trends in Contemporary Scholarship
Program Unit: Epistle to the Hebrews
Susan Docherty, Newman University
There has been a marked upsurge in scholarly interest in the Letter to the Hebrews over the past two decades, resulting in the publication of several influential monographs examining key aspects of the epistle’s theology. One of the sections of the text which has benefited most from this renewed attention is chapters 3-4. This paper will survey some of the most significant recent studies of these two chapters of Hebrews, attempting in particular to identify the core issues with which contemporary commentators are wrestling and any common trends in interpretation and emphasis. Areas for consideration include: analyses of the exegesis of the Old Testament in Hebrews chapters 3-4, drawing on publications such as Enns (1993), Allen (2008), Docherty (2009), and Steyn (2010); new investigations of the possible use of a Joshua typological scheme by Ounsworth (2012) and Whitfield (2013); the presentation of the figure of Moses in these chapters (Docherty, forthcoming); significant studies of the motif of ‘heavenly rest’, including those by Laansma (1997), Wray (1998), Gleason (2000), and Calaway (2013), and, focusing specifically on parallels between the understanding of this term in Hebrews and Philo, Svendsen (2009); the christology of this section of the epistle, especially as this is expressed in the discussion of the faithfulness of Jesus (Richardson, 2012); and the value of the application of new tools such as socio-rhetorical analysis for an understanding of these passages (for example, deSilva 2000).
In addition, due account will be given to the treatment of Hebrews 3–4 in two substantial commentaries published in this century, by Koester (Anchor Bible, 2001) and by Cockerill (NICNT, 2012).
|
Die Prophetia Jeremiae ad Pashur in der Koptischen und Äthiopischen Kirche
Program Unit: Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha
Jan Dochhorn, Aarhus Universitet
Die Prophetia Jeremiae ad Pashur in der koptischen und äthiopischen Kirche
|
Die Auseinandersetzung mit Exegetischen Traditionen des Zeitgenössischen Palästinischen Judentums
Program Unit: Schriftrezeption bei Paulus und in der Paulustradition: Reception of Scripture in Paul and Pauline Tradition
Jan Dochhorn, Åarhus Universitet
Ausgehend von einer zunächst unscheinbaren Aussage in Röm 8,20, die auf eine auch andernorts bezeugte Interpretation von Gen 3,16 zurückgeführt werden kann, soll dargelegt werden, wie stark gerade der Römerbrief auch in Passagen, die keine expliziten Schriftbezüge aufweisen, durch exegetisches Wissen bestimmt wird, das auf der Arbeit mit der hebräischen Sprache beruht.
|
The Holy Man in the Courts of Rome: Late Ancient Conceptions of Ascetic Authority and Roman Law
Program Unit: Bible and Syriac Studies in Context
Maria E. Doerfler, Duke University
The recognition that ascetics wielded considerable worldly influence is scarcely a new insight to scholars of late antiquity. Already Peter Brown in his seminal 1971 article on the Holy Man drew attention to the unique position ascetics occupied vis-à-vis their communities: set apart from society, they enjoyed a privileged vantage point with regard to its problems; having renounced all claim to worldly power, they could speak with the authority of heaven.
Yet even in the Christian East, the setting of Brown's original article, ascetic authority took on a variety of guises, appearing differently in the urban contexts of Antioch and Edessa than in their rural surroundings. The Canons ascribed to Rabbula of Edessa, for example, contain guidance for local clergy and monastics, including the famous bnay and bna¯t qya¯ma¯, with regard to their involvement in disputes or legal affairs. The canons' prohibitions and regulations provide readers with a glimpse into the role these Christian "professionals" assumed amidst Edessa's urban society, much of which seems to have revolved around exercising functions frequently associated with Roman law.
The canons do not forbid or even discourage service as arbiters, or even as advocates, as long as the suits in which they are involved were conducted justly, without resorting to bribery or receiving bribes, and without unseemly amounts of violence. Indeed, the depiction of judicial responsibility and the concomitant hazards ascetic judges might be facing coheres well with the kind of legal and judicial ethics Christian leaders elsewhere in the Roman Empire sought to inculcate in their subordinates.
This paper accordingly plans to offer a glimpse at the intersection of Roman law and Christian practice in the Syrian realm, with an eye towards the complex and multifaceted nature of ascetic authority in these settings.
|
"Oral Law" in Philo's Spec. Leg IV 149-150
Program Unit: Midrash, Halakhah and Reception
Bernhard Dolna, International Theological Institute
In Spec. Leg IV 149-150 Philo states that the commandment “You shall not remove your neighbor’s landmarks which thy forerunners have set up” (Deut. 19:14) does not only apply to boundaries of land in order to eliminate covetousness but also to the preservation of ancient customs (ton archaion ethon). Later in the text he equates these customs with the unwritten law (agraphos nomos). - The term agraphos nomos is usually understood exclusively as equivalent to “natural law” or the “law of nature” (nomos physeos), common to humanity qua humanity, what is considered to be in contradistinction to the law of separate political entities, which differ from city to city and country to country. However, precisely this interpretation raises questions since the consensus respecting the Greek frame of reference on Philo’s part when he uses the term agraphos nomos was never unanimous. This paper tries to prove that the term agraphos nomos in Spec. Leg IV 149 refers to the Jewish unwritten traditions and it introduces a method that avoids categorizing Phil?’s statements in dichotomous terms as necessarily either Hellenistic or Jewish. Reading Spec. Leg IV 149-150 as a reference to what eventually came to be termed Oral Law does not exclude Greece literal and philosophical texts and vice versa. Hence it is necessary to address both the background of Jewish sources and references from the Hellenistic-Greek Culture and to bring them into relationship with Philo's biblical text adaptations. - That is what should be attempted in this presentation.
|
Did Moses Speak on His Own Authority? Some Observations about Philo's Use of the Septuagint in Vita de Moses
Program Unit: Reception History of Jewish Scriptures in Graeco-Roman Egypt
Bernhard Dolna, International Theological Institute
In Philo’s description of the prophecy of Moses one can find different text variations to the Septuagint text of Ex (14, 11-13; 16, 19; 16, 25; 32, 27…). Philo defines the prophetic statements there as spoken by Moses own authority, as a divine strength (“enthusiasm“) took hold of him. The textual variants will be presented, examined and questioned (are there textual variants to the Septuagint? other traditions…?). In most of his other writings, when Philo treats the subject of prophecy, he is very accurate with the use of the text of the Septuagint, but in these passages he seems not to adhere to this principle. And paradoxically these deviations are found in the treatise, in which he writes a hymn to the edition of the Septuagint and its exact and inspired translation of the Hebrew (Chaldean) text into Greek, - A paradox which needs to be resolved. In this presentation some interpretations perspective and resulting issues will be addressed.
|
Social Memory and Valentinian Ritual in the Coptic Apocalypse of Paul
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Michael S. Domeracki, Rice University
This paper combines a traditional historical and text critical approach with contributions from social and collective memory theory, along with ritual studies through the cognitive analysis of Harvey Whitehouse. It intends to show that the Coptic Apocalypse of Paul is an integration of the memory of Paul and his ascent in 2 Cor. and contemporary Valentinian ritual practices. While in 2 Cor. 12 Paul recounts in the third person his ascent to the third heaven, the Coptic Apocalypse of Paul continues the Paul’s story describing his progression through to the tenth heaven. Most interestingly, the narrative shifts from third person to first after Paul leaves the third heaven. This is not only a clear reference to the third person account of 2 Cor., but also an indication of the liturgical nature of the text: while reciting the visionary tale in the first person the audience now becomes Paul himself and ascends through the upper levels. This paper focuses, on the one hand, on how the memory of Paul is structured in the text for broad acceptance of Valentinus’ teachings and the validation of non-bodily ascent practices; on the other, on how the text imagines Paul as a mystical guide through the heaven.
|
Shades of Irony in the Anti-language of Amos
Program Unit: Prophets
Bill Domeris, South African Theological Seminary
The language of Amos represents a wonderful mixture of humour and threat, sarcasm and irony, hyperbole and prediction. Holding the fabric of this conversation together is his place within the prophetic minority – the Yahweh-only party. Making use of socio-linguistics, and my previous published work on Jeremiah, I take a closer look at the implications of such a group and their recourse to anti-language, over-lexicalisation, insider-humour and all the shades of irony one might expect.
Typically of an anti-society group, Amos makes use of such insider-humour, redefining the boundaries of his alliance; type-casting the perceived enemies (the rich and powerful) and creating connections with other threatened groups (the poor and oppressed). Typically of an anti-language, Amos exaggerates the differences between insider and outsider, speaking in shades of irony of ‘ivory houses’, ‘the cattle of Bashan’ while appealing to his successful attempts to save the rich from the wrath of God.
In reading Amos, we fall victim to the power of his rhetoric – seeing the rich and powerful as the enemies of society – destructive and wholly evil, and ultimately doomed. In the process we accept this view of a divided society with clear boundaries and obvious evils. But was this in fact the case? I suggest that Amos has presented us with a classic caricature of his society – exaggerating the depiction of the ‘enemy’ and their manifold sins. The rhetoric is persuasive but it allows no shades of grey – only the starkly polarised colours of black and white, rich and poor, oppressors and oppressed. Instinctively, as anti-language is intended to do, we are compelled to side with the poor. We are drawn into the world of Amos, and his anti-society, quickly accepting his definition of society, his depiction of reality, and his stark caricature of the rich.
|
Resistance…from the Margins: Reading the Book of Jeremiah through a Post-colonial Lens
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Jerome N. Douglas, Valley Forge Christian College
How would a post-colonial reading of the Book of Jeremiah enhance the interpreter’s understanding of the text? Some of the research on this book has discussed the question of an historical Jeremiah. Others have approached the text viewing the prophet as a literary figure. Still other contributions to this field have endeavored to examine the historical communities that produced and interpreted the text. Consequently much of the scholarship has not fully considered an examination of the Book of Jeremiah through the lens of a post-colonial reading. Given the interaction between the margins (the colonized) and the center (the imperial power), what would be the impact of reading the text from the perspective of the marginalized seeking to maintain their distinct social and spiritual domain in a landless existence under the rule of a colonial power, a reading from “below” rather than “above”? What would be the fruits of giving a robust consideration to the impact of subjugation by an imperial power upon a (now) colonized people, in terms of its displacement, dislocation, and decentralization and the response from the colonized (or powerless)? This paper will address these questions; it will examine selected texts from Jeremiah chapters 26- 52 to demonstrate how Jeremiah and/ or the people, from a position of marginalization, quietly resist the full impact of the imperial power to create empowerment in a powerless context.
|
A Cognitive Linguistic Case Study of the Hebrew Root Qn’ (to be jealous of, zealous for)
Program Unit: Emotions and the Biblical World (EABS)
Bart Dubbink, Theologische Universiteit Kampen voor de Gereformeerde Kerken
The topic of ‘God and emotions’ has been highly debated in Biblical scholarship, especially from a theological point of view. In the past decade, some Old Testament scholars have adopted a cognitive linguistic approach, frequently arguing that the theological perspective in previous research often has blurred the linguistic data.
Since the critique of previous research focuses on the disadvantages of a theological perspective, a more thetic, linguistic description of the subject ‘God and emotions’ is still lacking. Besides, since cognitive linguistic studies focus on emotion categories like ‘anger’ and ‘joy’, the meaning and conceptualization of particular Biblical Hebrew emotion words often remain unclear. The cognitive linguistic onomasiological study of the topic ‘God and emotions’ needs to be complemented with a semasiological approach.
In this paper, a semasiological approach to Biblical Hebrew emotion words is presented and applied in order to describe the semantic components of divine emotions. The focus is on the Hebrew root qn’ (to be jealous of, envious of, zealous for), which occurs 85 times throughout the Hebrew Bible (42x with a human subject, 43x with a divine subject)
First, the need for a particular cognitive linguistic semantic theory to (emotion) words – the theory of the prototype scenario – will be explained. Second, the value of this approach for describing the aspects (e.g. gender) of divine emotions will be analyzed by means of a case study of the Hebrew root qn’. The case study will show that the cognitive linguistic theory of the prototype scenario, when applied to particular emotion words, produces both linguistic and theological clarity with respect to the topic of ‘God and emotions’.
|
Heavenly Perfect Bodies: Biblical Discourse and Desire for Bodily Sameness
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Zorodzai Dube, University of Pretoria
Informed by psychoanalytic views of Michael Foucault, Simone De-Beouvoir, Henry-Jaques Sticker, David Mitchell, Sharon Snyder, Lennard Davis, Rosemarie Garland Thomson and others, the presentation investigates biblical motifs that see humanity as moving towards an inevitable culmination of history, in which, all humanity will be clothed with new perfect bodies, without deformity. The presentation argues that such teleological oriented theological discourses feeds into the treatment and perception given to disabled people as incomplete and precarious. As evidence, examples will be drawn from the Bible and the church tradition.
|
Cosmogony as an Absolute Beginning: Ancient Egyptian Concepts and Their Biblical Adaptations
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Traditions in the Biblical World and Beyond
Iryna Dubianetskaya, European Humanities University
In the ancient Near-Eastern texts, the importance of the First Event is enormous. Personal divine creator(s) or the proto-elements of creation define the shape, structures and the destiny of the world and the relationships of its inhabitants. Cosmological prologues may be added to texts of various content, from sacred hymns to wisdom texts to dynastic chronicles to magical healing spells and so on. This is because the life, development and death of everything that exists have been defined by their beginning. Heiopolitan, Hermopolitan, Theban, Memphite and some other cosmological traditions of ancient Egypt tell their own stories about zep tepi, the moment between non-existence and the first throb of the cosmic pulsation, which set in motion the sacred mechanisms of the universe. The Hebrew Bible is very receptive to many of Egyptian concepts. Biblical authors may transform them, re-write them anew to adapt them to different theological world-views, but they are still attracted to them. Although Egypt might be portrayed as a religious and ideological arch-enemy of the Israelite people, Biblical cosmogonies, which lie at the very centre of the Biblical concept of the world, draw on the Egyptian ideas about the subject of the great beginning. The paper examines these multi-dimensional relationships between the texts of the two cultures.
|
The Use of the Formula Mikan Amru in the Halakhic Midrashim
Program Unit: Midrash, Halakhah and Reception
Alexander Dubrau, University of Tübingen
The study of the exegetical terminology (termini technici) in the halakhic texts of Tannaitic literature dates back to the 19th century period of the “Wissenschaft des Judentums” and has generated new impulses in the second half of the 20th century as well as in the research of the past decade. Following these lines of research, this paper is focused on a historical-systematic study of the widespread Tannaitic formula mikan amru (the Sages said from here) in context of its variants such as amru or amru hahkamim. The importance of the formula mikan amru resides both in its exegetical-midrashic and halahkic-authoritative origin (its Midrashic and Mishnaic form). Regarding the history of research, the paper discusses a number of texts, each of which is examined in relation to three aspects: 1) Does the formula mikan amru in the Halakhic Midrashim function mainly as exegetical justification or does it serve primarily as a quotation formula for mainly Mishnaic and Tosefta units? 2) What is the role of the text quoted by mikan amru in its context in the Halakhic Midrashim? 3) Is it possible to define the origin of certain traditions quoted by the formula in the Halakhic Midrashim? Beyond its basic concern with philological-exegetical and historical-literary insights into the rabbinical use of terminology, and thereby a better understanding of the development of Tannaitic text layers, this paper intends to contribute to the research of early rabbinic individual terms and of exegetical textual formulations.
|
You Did Not Spit on Me (Gal 4:14): Suffering and the Rhetoric of Cursing in Galatians
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
John Anthony Dunne, University of St. Andrews
In scholarship on Galatians the meaning of Paul's "weakness in the flesh" (Gal. 4:13) has been variously interpreted as either a disability or an illness of some kind. As Paul recounts his initial visit with the Galatians he states that they did not "spit at him," which metaphorically refers to rejection, but here in this context is linked to spitting at evil spirits that may accompany disability or illnesses. In my paper I will argue that Paul's "weakness" was the result of persecution (and so could be related to disability or illness that resulted from persecution), but the main focus will be on the rhetoric of cursing (cf. 1:8–9; 3:1; 3:10–14; 4:29–30; 5:10, 12) and blessing (4:15; 6:16) in the letter. I think that a fruitful way to read this cursing language is in relation to the suffering and persecution mentioned throughout the letter, including the suffering of Christ on the cross. Ultimately, it will be argued that Paul is trying to rhetorically shape things so that the Galatians do not perceive their own suffering or Paul's suffering as a curse. This is because the Messiah endured the curse (3:10–14). Just as the Galatians did not spit on Paul when he first arrived but rather identified with him in his feeble state of weakness, so now Paul is calling the Galatians to endure their suffering (cf. 3:4; 4:29) in solidarity with him (4:12) and to remember the blessing (4:15) they had when they communed with the suffering Paul.
|
Suffering in South Galatia: A Neglected Aspect in Determining the Destination of Galatians
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
John Anthony Dunne, University of St. Andrews
One of the central debates in reconstructing a Pauline chronology is the date and intended destination of Paul's letter to the Galatians. Many arguments have been leveled for either North or South Galatia, each with earlier and later versions of the proposal. An under-appreciated factor in this discussion is the emphasis on suffering and persecution in Galatians. When this feature of Paul's letter is recognized, a strong case emerges for the South Galatian hypothesis. Leaving aside the question of date, this paper will demonstrate how Paul's ministry among the Galatians in weakness (cf Gal 4.13) was remembered as a dangerous mission among the cities of Derbe, Lystra, Iconium, and Pisidian Antioch. This will be seen in Acts 13-14; 2 Tim 3; and The Acts of Paul and Thecla.
|
Exemplars of Suffering and Death in the Epistle to the Hebrews
Program Unit: Epistle to the Hebrews
Bryan R. Dyer, McMaster Divinity College
This paper examines the use of exemplars in the Epistle to the Hebrews to show how its author created models worthy of emulation within contexts of suffering and death. Like many Greco-Roman, Jewish, and Christian authors before him, the author of Hebrews utilized the rhetorical device of exempla to strengthen his argument and exhortation. Three groups of exemplars surface in Hebrews—each defined by near-death experiences, endurance in suffering, and faithfulness to God. The first group, figures from Israel’s past (11:2–40), connected the recipients of the epistle to their ancestors in God’s family who were plagued by affliction in the face of death. These figures acted in faith in times of difficulty and faced death with the assurance of God’s promise and hope beyond this life. The second group consisted of the community themselves as the author recounts their own faithfulness during a time of suffering in their past (10:32–36). As similar afflictions continued to plague their community (12:5–11; 13:3, 13), the author encourages them to demonstrate the same attitudes and behavior that marked their previous ordeal. The third exemplar is Jesus Christ, who faced the same and even more severe trials, yet modeled endurance and obedience to God (2:9–18; 4:15; 5:1–10; 12:2 –3; 13:12). Jesus’ endurance in suffering and obedience to the point of death provides a model of behavior for the community. They are to look to his example in such times and not be afraid to follow him—even if it means affliction, shame, and possibly death. By presenting these exemplars the author offers hope beyond death, honor in the midst of public shame, and a model of behavior in times of struggle. The author’s use of exemplars, it is argued, tells us something of the problem being addressed in the epistle.
|
Reception History, Open-Ended Interpretation, and Freedom of the Reader
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
Oliver Dyma, Eberhard Karls Universität Tübingen
The analysis of reception history shows us different ways of reading texts within the canon. The different ways of dealing with a text, its features and problems, demonstrate that interpretation is not just dependent on the text but no less on the reader and his or her questions, and presuppositions. In contrast, some concepts of canonical interpretation seem to deduce the meaning mainly from a text itself and its intertextual relations within the canon. Thus, the role of the reader is not appropriately assessed which would emphasize that interpretation is open-ended. This is not only a question of literary interpretation but also of the theological status of the reader as a subject in the conception of revelation.
|
“Surely this great nation is a wise and discerning people!” (Deut 4:6): Israel from the other Nations’ Perspective in the Book of Deuteronomy
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Law
Ruth Ebach, Eberhard Karls Universität Tübingen
In large parts of Deuteronomy, Israel is idealized as “contrast-society” to other nations and groups. This paper especially focuses on the post-exilic redactional layers of Deuteronomy, which deal with this contrast in a very special way. Because of the expected interpretation by the others as their own success and strength in Deut 32:26-27, Jhwh declares not to destroy his own people. This wrong interpretation is contrasted by Deut 29:21-28: The foreigner, coming from a distant country, will interpret Israel’s destruction in just the right way. In these verses, Israel is described from the others’ perspective. This change of perspective can also be illustrated in Deut 4. The paper will demonstrate that especially in Deut 4:6-8 this view as external and neutral perspective is used to solve inner-Israelite conflicts regarding the relation of prayer and law. By regarding Israel as a great nation on account of their extraordinary wisdom, the other nations support the construction of an Israelite identity.
|
Religion as Recontextualization in Selig Schachnowitz’ Im Schatten des Weltkriegs (1915)
Program Unit: Reception of the Bible in the Sign of World War One
Eva Edelmann-Ohler, Eidegenössiche Technische Hochschule Zürich
In Selig Schachnowitz’ text Im Schatten des Weltkriegs religion and biblical references play an important role in interpreting war and its circumstances. The four little novellas (Der Prophetenbaum, Judel, der kleine Makkabäer, Unter Rennenkamps Fahnen, Auf der Lichtwiese) show how thus war is relieved of the cruelty of everyday warfare: By transposing wartime events in a system of divinely ordained meaningfulness the war is transformed from human contingency to a divine coherence. The four novellas give an example of a literary recontextualisation, which uses the biblical references as a narrative for the war to reduce the terror of war and to make these events part of the familiar world of Jewry.
|
". . . And justice looks down from heaven" (Ps 85:12): Personifications in the Psalms and Their Reception in Christian Tradition
Program Unit: Metaphors in the Hebrew Bible/Old Testament and Their Reception
Sigrid Eder, Catholic University of Linz
Personification is the act of attributing human characteristics to non-living things. This attribution of human properties to inanimate or abstract entities functions as a subtype of (verb) metaphor. Thus forming part of metaphorical language, personifications produce special dynamics, mainly when verbs which are more literally used for human or animal actions or noise are used within the metaphorical construction, i.e. “The wind began to scream”. This example already leads us to the book of psalms which is full of figurative language including a huge amount of personifications. Within these metaphorical utterances, terms of nature are used, e.g. “The mountains leaped like rams, the hills like lambs” (Ps 114:4), but also abstract terms, e.g. “Righteousness will go before him, and will make a path for his steps” (Ps 85:14). After a general overview of the personifications in the psalter, a number of specific phrases will be analyzed with the aim to investigate the special dynamics of verb metaphors. The methodological background of this research are the guidelines of the metaphor-analysis proposed by Ruben Zimmermann and the conceptual blending theory of metaphor applied to biblical texts by Pierre van Hecke. Finally, examples will be given as to how these analyzed personifications in the psalter are used and reused in Christian literature.
|
Pointed Obfuscation: A 'Bagginsian' Reading of 1 Cor 8:8b
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Ben Edsall, University of Oxford
1 Cor 8:8b is typically taken by scholars to indicate that idol food in itself is adiaphora. On this view Paul presents a statement that it is completely inconsequential whether or not one eats idol food at all. Only in the context of harming another community member is this a problem. Upon closer examination, however, it becomes clear that the ‘adiaphora’ reading is not supported by the logic of the statement itself. In fact, Paul’s statement logically leaves open the opposite result of the two addressed. Therefore, while affirming that not-eating does not a lack, he leaves open the possibility that it could bring abundance and while affirming that eating does not cause abundance, he leaves open the possibility that it could bring lack. This outcome of his logic, it will be argued, is in keeping with his argument as a whole in 1 Cor 8:1–11:1 and is part of his careful rhetorical strategy in which he addresses the main question only after a careful discussion of underlying issues. Paul’s statement here, then, with its deliberate initial ambiguity, resembles the famous statement by J.R.R. Tolkien’s Bilbo Baggins (hence, with tongue in cheek, ‘Bagginsian’) that ‘I know half of you half as well as I would like and I like less than half of you half as well as you deserve’. Paul’s statement, then, is a pointed obfuscation, the point of which is not evident until the whole has been heard.
|
Judith's Genealogy: Subverting a Strict Theology of Retribution and Forging a New Identity in the Post-Exilic Era
Program Unit: The Bible in the Twenty-First Century: Politization of Bibles and Biblization of Politics (EABS)
Helen Efthimiadis-Kei, University of KwaZulu-Natal
This paper takes its cue from genealogical theorists who argue for the subversive and rebellious functions of genealogies within political contexts. Drawing upon Van Henten’s view of Judith as an alternative leader to Moses and the author’s own work on Judith, the paper argues that Judith’s genealogy not only legitimates her as savior of her people, but also legitimates her deconstruction of the strict Deuteronomic/retributional theology which her people clearly espouse. Judith’s subversion of this law enables her not only to rise above the Judaean’s mentality and become their savior, but also frees God from the strictures which this law imposed on divine behavior. In the process, this wise woman teaches the faithful (but fearful) post-exilic community to think differently about themselves and their God, and to stand up and be counted in the face of various challenging, life-threatening situations.
|
“To Us, the Word ‘Today’": The Double-Logos of Heb 4:12-13
Program Unit: Epistle to the Hebrews
Rebekah A. Eklund, Loyola University Maryland
The concluding clause of Hebrews 4:13 (pros on emin o logos) has long puzzled exegetes. Modern English translations almost unanimously opt for some variation of “to whom we must render an account” (NRSV; cf. KJV: “with whom we have to do”). Although it is difficult to trace this interpretation back to its origins, it appears as early as the late fourth century in a homily of Chrysostom, and later interpreters read the Latin of the Vulgate in this way (“ad quem nobis sermo”). Other patristic commentators—notably Clement of Alexandria and Origen—treated the logos christologically: reading through John’s lens, they saw the logos as the incarnate Word of God, that is, Christ. This interpretation has largely fallen out of favor, despite the efforts of James Swetnam to revive it, given that Hebrews equates Jesus with the Son and the high priest, not with the logos. Most are content to opt for treating the final clause as human responsibility to respond to the living Word of God (v. 12) by giving an account of ourselves back to God. This interpretation, however, is forced to treat the nominative o logos at the end of v. 13 as an object, and it mutes the repetition of o logos, which clearly brackets vv. 12-13. I propose that the logos of v. 13 is the living word of v. 12 (specifically, “Today, if you hear his voice…!”; Heb. 4:7-8), which is addressed to and penetrates its hearers (cf. Heb. 4:2) and demands a response of obedience (ch. 4) and perseverance (ch. 6). Thus a more satisfactory translation, in a loose paraphrase, might be: “And there is no creature hidden before this living, piercing word, but all are naked and laid bare to its eyes, concerning which, this word (Today!) is spoken to us.”
|
Post-War Symbols of Victory and of Submission
Program Unit: Israel in the Ancient Near East (EABS)
David Elgavish, Bar-Ilan University
Following a war the leaders of the combatant sides were wont to perform acts that symbolized the new situation that was created in the wake of the war. In the ancient Near East and in the Hebrew Bible the victors would document their triumph and the defeated their surrender by means of actions that epitomized their new situations. The defeated would don sackcloth, bind themselves with cord, while the victors would erect monuments of triumph, spread salt on the defeated city or change its name. The victors would hang the defeated or their heads in public areas and document these images in carved reliefs that were erected in significant places. At the same time, some triumphant leaders would treat the defeated honorably, such as King Ahab of Israel, who took the defeated Aramean king Ben Hadad onto his chariot.
In my remarks I shall lay out a catalogue of the above-mentioned symbolic acts, examine how widely they were used. I will seek to establish a hierarchy of such acts in order to obtain a scale of values by which to assess their relative power and by that means to determine whether the acts were chosen with regard to their suitability to a particular event. Finally, I will investigate whether it is possible to classify the various symbolic acts chronologically and geographically, in order to obtain a list of symbolic acts organized according to time and place for the ancient Near East.
|
Tensions in the Prophetic Mainstreams: Abraham, Moses, Jesus
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
J. Harold Ellens, University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
This paper address the new initiative in Israelite theological formation effected by Moses, in contrast to the radically different theological construct found in the Abrahamic narrative. Without attempting to establish chronological priority for the two traditions, it is my intent herein to demonstrate the high level of tension between them. It is my further intent to describe the way in which this tension shaped apocalyptic ideology in the exilic and post-exilic eras. This presentation demonstrates the way this pervasive tension is manifested in the life and ministry of Jesus and was the issue between him and the Pharisees and Scribes that ultimately led to his apocalyptic demise.
|
Psalm 1 Through a Psychological Lens
Program Unit: Psychological Hermeneutics of Biblical Themes and Texts
Jay Harold Ellens, University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
This paper addresses the issue of how a psychological hermeneutic compared with a theological hermeneutic illumines the interpretation of Psalm 1
|
The Flood as a Period of Muhammad's Life
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Traditions in the Biblical World and Beyond
Orhan Elmaz, University of St. Andrews
Irving Finkell - curator in charge of cuneiform inscriptions on tablets of clay from ancient Mesopotamia at the British Museum recently dicovered a Sumerian "Ark tablet". This featured the news at the beginning of 2014 in several newspapers and a documentary about it will be broadcasted on Channel 4 in the UK in August 2014 while his book about it is to be published in September 2014. The proposed paper will look at how the narrative of Noah's Ark and the flood myth is told in the Qur'an and what function it serves when considering that the revelation of the Qur'an was a historical process which is inseparable from the events in the life of Muhammad.
|
It’s all Eve’s Fault: The Evolvement of a Written and Visual Interpretive Tradition
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Culture
Yaffa Englard, University of Haifa
Eve figures prominently in paintings, reliefs, mosaics, church-wall murals, print forms, book illustrations, and—as noted by Katie Edwards in her recent book Admen and Eve: The Bible in Contemporary Advertising—in modern advertizing designed to “tempt” (female) consumers to buy the product in question. Generally speaking, Eve appears in visual representations as a negative figure beguiled by the serpent and occasionally even being identified with it, imposing her will on Adam and tempting him to eat from the forbidden fruit. This characterization is not based on Genesis 3 but rather on an exegetical tradition that first appears in ancient Jewish literature, was passed on through Christian patristic writings through to the medieval period, and has now been inherited by modernity/postmodernity.
Through the generations, Jewish and Christian exegetical traditions have attributed responsibility for the “fall” in the Garden of Eden primarily to Eve. This dominant interpretive tendency whose mark is still visible today, adduces Eve as primarily to blame for (the) “original sin” and its consequences. Herein, an apologetic is customarily made on Adam’s behalf and Eve directly blamed as being easily seduced, lustful, alluring, and solely responsible for the sin—and thus also the exile from the Garden of Eden, human suffering, and death. In this lecture, I endeavour to concretize the way in which these exegetical traditions are exemplified in medieval art, which can be understood as a visual interpretation of the biblical text and illustrate the influence they have exerted on art through to the twenty-first century.
|
Midwives and Gynecology in the Jewish Society in Roman Palestine
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Yael Epstein, Bar-Ilan University
It is now a well-established fact that women practiced medicine in the ancient world. The woman physician was called medica or iatrine and the midwife was called maia. The iatrine and the midwife along with a number of linguistic variants on these terms, all appear regularly in a range of literary, epigraphical and papyrological sources, as scholars have repeatedly observed. However, after reviewing the literature one can conclude that barely any research was done on the midwives and their practices in the Jewish Society.
In this paper I will explore the midwives and gynecology in the ancient Jewish society of the land of Israel in the period 70AD- 400AD and especially their reflection in the literature of the Judaic Sages of the Talmud and Mishnah period.
I will discuss the differences between the man physician and the midwife in the ancient Jewish society. Moreover, I will examine the religious aspects of being a Jewish midwife. The midwife was not a religious profession, but had religious values in the Jewish society.
Additionally, I will present the social status of the midwife in the Jewish community of Roman Palestine in the relevant period (looking on the Ancient Jewish rabbinic literature and Archeological excavations). In this regard I will explore the different names the midwife was called in the Jewish ancient sources and how it was related to their social status.
|
A Survey of Old Testament Pseudepigrapha in the Ethiopian Manuscript Tradition
Program Unit: Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha
Ted Erho, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
A Survey of Old Testament Pseudepigrapha in the Ethiopian Manuscript Tradition
|
Nebuchadnezzar, the Lord of the Wild Animals: Understanding One of the Characteristics of JerMT in light of Dan
Program Unit: Prophets
Johanna Erzberger, Institut Catholique de Paris
The special characterization of the role of Nebuchadnezzar in the MT version of the book of Jeremiah has long since been recognized as one of its outstanding characteristics. Nebuchadnezzar’s presentation as the Lord of the animals (Jr 27:6; 28:14), which only occurs in the MT, has been discussed as one of the particularities of the characterization of the Babylonian king in this version of the book of Jeremiah. Nebuchadnezzar’s presentation as the Lord of the animals has not yet been thoroughly discussed in the light of its only other occurrence in another late biblical book, in which Nebuchadnezzar plays a central role, in Dan 2:38. Nebuchadnezzar’s presentation in the book of Daniel sheds light on the significance of Nebuchadnezzar’s (and Babel’s) specific characterization in the MT towards the LXX version of the book of Jeremiah and, consequently, on one of those versions major differences.
|
The Edessan Martyrs Guria and Shmona
Program Unit: Bible and Syriac Studies in Context
Mats Eskhult, Uppsala Universitet
Among the small hidden pearls in Syriac literature are the stories about Guria, Shmona, and ?abbib, who suffered martyrdom in Edessa in the wake of the Diocletian persecution. The text about ?abbib, published in 1865 by W. Wright, tells that this martyr was buried in the same grave as Guria and Shmona, whose martyrdom was at this time known solely from a short Greek version. In 1896, however, F. Conybeare published a translation of a longer Armenian version, and in 1899 Ignatius Ephraem Rahmani published a Syriac version from a 15th century manuscript found at St Mark Monastery in Jerusalem. This edition led to a thorough discussion among philologists. In 1911 E. von Dobschütz published an extensive study, on the basis of which he concluded that the Syriac text was to be considered the original, and that the Armenian was translated from a Syriac, not Greek, manuscript. The St Mark manuscript von Dobschütz considered to represent a revised version of the mid-fourth century original, which he, besides, thought to be very much influenced by the established forms of martyr biographies. F.C. Burkitt in the introduction to his edition, in a work called Euphemia and the Goth and published in 1913, takes a more positive attitude towards the historicity of the story. He removes a few inconceivable details while pointing to a number of particulars that grant reliability to the narrative at large; also, the few biblical quotations, mostly from Matthew Ch. 10, agree rather with the Old Syriac version than with the Peshitta. The paper will discuss the arguments of the different opinions.
|
The Meaning of Heaven in 1 Enoch 1-36: A New Interpretation
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Philip Esler, University of Gloucestershire
Heaven plays an important role in the Book of the Watchers (1 Enoch 1-36), embracing the place (and its architecture), important characters (God, angels and Enoch); and the role the place and these characters play in the narrative. In current scholarship it is almost universally agreed that the terrestrial model for the portrayal of the Enochic heaven is the Jerusalem temple and its priests. In this paper it will be argued that not only is there no evidence in 1 Enoch 1-36 for this view, but that it is falsified by significant textual details. Instead, it will be proposed that the source for the portrayal of heaven is actually the court, courtiers and palace of Persian and Hellenistic monarchies. This view will be illustrated with respect to the remains of one palace in particular. It will be suggested that the current but untenable temple and priesthood model arises from a scholarly perspective inappositely valorizing a religion ("Judaism") as the crucial identity in play. Instead, it will be argued, the actual identity operative in the work is a (more encompassing) Judean ethnic identity whose members (including the author and audience) were familiar with the political realities of ancient Near Eastern and Hellenistic multi-state monarchies.
|
Two Iconographical Examples of Sun-Disc Connections to the Development of Jewish Beliefs in Angels
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Annette Evans, Universiteit van die Vrystaat
The name Israel suggests that El, the oldest Semitic term for God, may have been the original God of early Israel, but by the eighth century BCE El had been equated with Yahweh. Along with the name, Yahweh inherited various traits of El. Iconography of that time demonstrates that both Israel and Judah took for granted that other deities besides Yahweh existed, and many seals testify to the fact that the state religion of Northern Israel, i.e. “official” Yahwism, was affected by the prevalence of solar symbolism. The celestial-solar character of deities was often emphasised by the addition of solar discs (Mullen 1980:84). This paper presents two examples of polytheistic iconography relating to the theme of transcendent messenger activity in the Bible, one dating to about 900 BCE, the other to the Ptolemaic period. The first example is of an ostrich with a sun disk at the neck. Such images of ostriches, representing “The Lord of the Ostriches” appeared on scaraboids in Israel and Judah at the time of transition from the tenth to the ninth century. In Palestine ancient Egyptian motifs with solar connections such as uraei and falcons were virtually omnipresent by c. 925 BCE (Mullen 1980:84). Such concepts of divine mediation continue into the Ptolemaic age. For instance the second example, a Gnostic gem dated to ca. 200-100 BCE, provides evidence of solar motifs from Egyptian religion which facilitated concepts of Jewish angelology. The god Bait seated on a throne (representing Horus the falcon) has a sun-disk and uraeus on his head. It is proposed that these motifs provided the foundation for the conceptual changes in Jewish angelology which eventually led to the ancient world’s accounting of divine mediation from God to mankind.
|
The Geographical Structure of Amos 1–2 as a Rhetorical Tool in Ethical Criticism Directed at Israel
Program Unit: Authority and Influence in Ancient Times
Erik Eynikel, Universität Regensburg
The order of the oracles against the nations in Amos 1-2 has puzzled biblical scholarship. Why, e.g., are Assyria and Egypt not included? is it because of historical reasons (these superpowers were dormant at the time of Amos)? In this paper I will argue that the geographical order of the oracles is "chiastic". Alternatively a northern and southern, western and eastern nation is mentioned with two or three crimes for which they are condemned. Amos concludes his oracle in 2,6 ff. with a full blow agains Israel, which is situated in the middle of the "map" drawn by the previous oracles (the oracle against Judah is clearly an addition). The prophet uses a rhetorical strategy that we find also elsewhere with prophets: let the sinners condemn themselves. Nathan e.g. used it in his condemnation of David in 2 Sam 12. Here in Amos 1-2 the reaction of Amos' audience is not recorded but we may well assume that they enthusiastically agreed with the condemnation of Israel's neighbors; ... until it was their turn to be confronted with their crimes. We see that the prophet, who has no power or might, can only rely on the authority he received from God (but that can not be controlled; the false prophets also speak in the name of God), his persuasion, his rhetorical skills and the purity of his ethical arguments.
|
The Man from Arimathea
Program Unit: The Bible in the Twenty-First Century: Politization of Bibles and Biblization of Politics (EABS)
Charlotte Faber, Universiteit van Amsterdam
Ravelry is an international knitting and crochet forum with over 3 million members. There are many groups on the forums about more than just knitting or crochet. From perusing the forums, I have learned a lot about US members’ culture and daily living and the large role of the different churches in this respect. I remember one thread in particular where the complaint was that the church had no role model for a functioning family. This is true, because the Holy Family as depicted in tradition is a model of a dysfunctional family. A poor, inept father who is too old to beget a child by his young wife, a mother who has a very strong fixation on her son and an child who ends up on a cross between other felons with his relatives looking on from afar. Not to mention John 3:16.
How did we get to this Family? It seems to be there from the beginning of the gospel of Matthew with its genealogy. That list starts out as proof of Joseph’s royal descent and then seems to annul its conclusion about Jesus by the bump in the road that casts doubts on Jesus parentage from both sides. This genealogy, together with Luke’s can be held responsible for a lot of suffering today as the outcome of its reading through the centuries. Here, I am going to focus on the father, whose role is so minimal after a grand opening.
|
God-Fearers and the Cult of Theos Hypsistos at the Synagogue in Çatiören
Program Unit: Archaeology and Diaspora Judaism
Mark R. Fairchild, Huntington University
A synagogue at Çatiören in Rough Cilicia has a lintel with two objects
etched upon it. Centered in the middle of the lintel, a menorah is easily
identified. However, the object on the right is not easily determined.
The object could be a lulav. But if so, this would be a unique depiction
of the lulav. This paper will argue that the object is more likely Zeus'
thunderbolt. Assuming that this is correct, we must ask the question of
why the thunderbolt has been etched upon a Jewish synagogue? Is this
evidence of syncretism with Jews and Gentiles who have found a common
religious baseline and who have joined together in fellowship? The cult
of the Highest God (Theos Hypsistos) was prevalent throughout Anatolia and
this presentation will suggest that devotees of Theos Hypsistos worshipped
together with Jews at this synagogue in Çatiören.
|
Biblical (Theological) and Legal Implications of the Practice of Male Circumcision in South Africa
Program Unit: Male Circumcision: Between Controversy and Tradition (EABS)
Elelwani Farisani, University of South Africa
This paper discusses male circumcision. It focuses on both the theological and legal implications of the practice of male circumcision in South Africa. Traditional male circumcision in South Africa is practiced among several tribes, including amaXhosa, baPedi, baTswana and vhaVenda. The paper focuses on the amaXhosa in the Eastern Cape, baSotho in the Free State and the people of Limpopo (baTsonga, baPedi and vhaVenda). The practice of traditional circumcision is done in such a way that young men are removed from their usual environment to a secluded area, normally referred to as the initiation school, where they undergo the rite of passage into manhood. During that period the young men are taught how to behave as matured adults when they return to their communities. The actual cutting of the foreskin is just one of the things that the young men go through while in seclusion. The paper has five sections. First, it deals with the procedure and purpose of male circumcision. Second, it discusses Biblical justification for the ritual of Circumcision. The third focus is the legal implications of the custom of traditional circumcision. Fourth, the paper deals with issues of contextualization and circumcision. And, finally, the paper deals with the role of African Biblical hermeneutics in dealing with the issue of traditional circumcision.
|
Neue Studien zum syrischen Oktoechos
Program Unit: Bible and Syriac Studies in Context
Maher Farkouh, Universitaet Rostock
Der Vortrag widmet sich dem Problem des Oktoechos und den Kriterien, nach denen die westsyrischen liturgischen Melodien auf seine acht Kategorien verteilt sind. In diesem Zusammenhang stellen sich eine Reihe von Fragen: Weisen die acht Kategorien die Charakteristika von Tönen auf? Wodurch ist ein Ton charakterisiert? Lassen sich auf die acht Kategorien überhaupt musikalische Kriterien anwenden? Welche anderen Kriterien könnten dem Oktoechos zugrunde liegen?
Zur Beantwortung dieser Fragen sollen exemplarisch die vier Madroshe des Beth Gazo herangezogen werden. Die strukturale Analyse der Melodien zeigt, dass es für die acht Töne keine allgemeingültigen musikalischen Kriterien gibt. Die mündliche Überlieferung bestätigt damit die aufgrund der Manuskripttradition aufgestellte These, dass der Oktoechos eine Anordnung der Melodien nach dem Kirchenjahr ist und dem liturgischen täglichen Gebrauch dient.
|
Rahab in Patristic Exegesis
Program Unit: Biblical Women in Patristic Reception
Anneliese Felber, Karl-Franzens Universität Graz
*Rahab, the harlot of Jericho, was highly appreciated in the Early Church. The Church Fathers often used her as an example to illustrate various theological truths and spiritual interpretations. The paper will focus on her as symbol of the church; first of all, the house of Rahab is a type of the church and symbol of church unity, and the fact that she and her family were saved also pointed to the inclusion of the gentiles into the church. The red cord which Rahab had to hang from the window plays a very important role in Rahab’s salvation; in typological interpretation it is a symbol of salvation through the blood of Christ. Therefore the story of Rahab (Jos. 2; 6:17.22-25) is compared to the great deeds of the God of the Israelites, who saved Noah in the ark and led his people out of Egypt.
|
Talking about the Human Body in the Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Clarisse Ferreira da Silva, Universidade de São Paulo
In the Hebrew Bible, Leviticus, Numbers and Deuteronomy, more than any other books, legislate on the human body, defining who was found worthy of belonging to the chosen people and how to continue or become pure in order to participate in the cult. Sex, clothes, food, and some types of diseases were some of the elements which determined people’s cultic and social status within the group, even if one should be put to death, expelled, underwent purification rites etc.
In general, the sectarian Dead Sea Scrolls, irrespective of their origins, whether from multiple groups or from a single one, display the same perspective on how their authors perceived the bodies of the members of their community (or communities). We can cite three of their central documents, the Damascus Document, the Rule of the Community and the Rule of the Congregation, as texts especially concerned about how community members should behave in order to be exemplary not only of an elite group, but also of the embryonic future Israel that would be beginning with them. “Unworthy” bodies were not permitted to stay among the holy community and were subjected to a series of penalties depending on the gravity score of their trespasses. These offenses were, naturally, judged on the basis of the peculiar criteria of the Community’s rules. Bodies were supervised not only by the Community’s leadership but also by each member who should denounce his (and her?) fellow member. The theme of the human body deals with issues such as gender, sex, being pure or impure. Having in mind the Dead Sea Scrolls mentioned above, we propose to debate some of their rules and passages which show how their authors viewed these issues.
|
The Shiloh Theophany (1 Samuel 3) in View of Recent Research
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible/Old Testament/Ancient Israel Studies (EABS)
Ruth Fidler, University of Haifa
Samuel's initiatory prophetic experience narrated in 1 Samuel 3 has already endured much scholarly debate. Not the least of the issues addressed is the experience reflected in this narrative and the reason for, or purpose served by, its ambiguous representation. Is it a dream (vv. 3—4), an incubation scene (v. 3), a waking revelation (vv. 6—10), or a bit of each? Should 1 Samuel 3 be read as a prophetic call narrative or as an account of the peaceful transfer of leadership? Is this leadership conceptualized as primarily priestly or prophetic? Recent papers of the SBL PTAC section argue that (1) Samuel's identity as a prophet (????) resulted from editing (DtrH) of a prior Samuel narrative that featured an early form of priest-visionary (Marvin A. Sweeney, 'Samuel's Institutional Identity in the Deuteronomistic History', 2011); (2) The main objective of 1 Samuel 3 was "to lay the foundation to [Samuel's] prophetic reputation", so YHWH could then use him as an agent provocateur ; a rather sinister role that has a complex relation with the Deuteronomic concept of prophecy, exemplified in Deuteronomy 18 and 28 (Serge Frolov, '1 Samuel 1—8 The Prophet as Agent Provocateur', 2011); (3) "Samuel’s failure to recognize Yahweh’s voice leads Eli to authorize the word against his house and to accept his overthrow" (Stephen C. Russell, 'Samuel’s Theophany in its Ancient Context', 2013). I propose to examine the bearing of these findings on those of my earlier work regarding 1 Samuel 3, namely that it depicted a waking experience, with features of dream accounts and incubation rituals all carefully manipulated to highlight Samuel's progress from a "boy" to a Moses-type "trustworthy prophet" (Numbers 12:6—8).
|
Ho Hebraios in Polychronius' Commentary to Jeremiah
Program Unit: The Reception of the Scripture in the Patristic Exegesis (II-VIII centuries) (EABS)
Mariachiara Fincati, Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore
The paper will present an investigation on the Commentary to Jeremiah which appears in codices as being the work of John Chrysostomus. The commentator, who is thought to be Polychronius of Apamea (+ 430), a member of the Antiochene school, frequently makes references to the Hebrew text in order to explain difficult passages of the Septuagint. He often quotes the text of "the Hebrew", but it rarely matches the actual Masoretic text. Some readings ascribed to the Hebrew are to be analysed, but first of all their very text must be established, since no reliable edition of the Commentary exists: volume 64 of the Patrologia Graeca contains the (diplomatic) edition published in 1623 by Michele Ghislieri, but it is totally useless, since two commentaries to Jeremiah ascribed in manuscripts to John Chrysostomus are mixed together. Once the text has been established, the aim is to define whether divergencies of "the Hebrew" from the Masoretic text were only due to the commentator's scarce mastery of the Hebrew language or "the Hebrew" does rather constitute an autonomo us source; in this case the possibility must be explored that the Hebrew was a kind of Aramaic Targum available in the Syriac area, similarly to "the Syrian" (ho Syros).
|
Exegetical Perspectives on MT-Jer 1 and LXX-Jer 1
Program Unit: Texts and Contexts of Jeremiah: The Exegesis of Jeremiah 1 and 10 in light of Textual and Reception History
Karin Finsterbusch, Universität Koblenz - Landau
In Jeremiah 1, i.e. in the beginning of the book of Jeremiah, the textual differences between LXX and MT are striking: According to LXX-Jer 1 (and its Hebrew Vorlage) the book contains first and foremost words of God spoken through Jeremiah. According to MT-Jer 1, however, the book presents itself as words of and about Jeremiah. MT-Jer depicts itself as a narrative about the prophet Jeremiah. LXX-Jer (and its Hebrew Vorlage) wants to communicate the word of God through the mouth of the prophet. Furthermore, the two versions describe opponents and the target audience of the prophet different. This presentation will argue that protomasoretic redactors changed the profile of the book deliberately.
|
Varying Levels of Communication: Their Importance for the Structure of the Book(s) of Jeremiah
Program Unit: Prophets
Karin Finsterbusch, Universität Koblenz - Landau
Varying Levels of Communication: Their Importance for the Structure of the Book(s) of Jeremiah
|
The Apes and the Sabbath Problem in the Quran
Program Unit: Quran and Islamic Tradition in Comparative Perspective
Reuven Firestone, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion (California Branch)
According to the Quran, God raised the mountain above the Israelites when establishing the covenant with them (2:63, 93; 4:154). In the latter version God says, “We said to them, ‘Do not transgress the Sabbath’ as We made a firm covenant with them” (la ta'du fi'l-sabt wa'akhadhna minhum mithaqan 'alizan). Yet in the very next verse (4:155) it states explicitly that they did indeed break the covenant. In the earlier version (2:65), presumably directed to a Jewish audience, the Quran has, “Certainly you know of those among you who transgressed the Sabbath when We said to them, ‘Become apes, skulking.’” This obscure reference is filled out somewhat in 7:163-66, where the inhabitants of a town by the sea “become apes, skulking” after having somehow broken the Sabbath in relation to fishing – the actual transgression is not specified. Still elsewhere, God curses “People of the Book” by making some of them into apes and pigs. Scholars have searched in vain for a pre-Islamic tale that may have informed these Quranic references. This presentation will re-consider the motifs of covenant, Sinaitic revelation and Sabbath observance in Jewish, Christian, and emergent Islamic practice in order to offer a different explanation.
|
Reception of Jeremiah 1 in Early Christian Literature
Program Unit: Texts and Contexts of Jeremiah: The Exegesis of Jeremiah 1 and 10 in light of Textual and Reception History
Georg Fischer, Leopold-Franzens-Universität Innsbruck
The early Christian reception of Jeremiah 1 shows some interesting features. The New Testament alludes to it a few times, picking up on the prophet’s commissioning to many nations and the persecution of God’s speaker. Among the Church Fathers, the interpretations of Origen, Jerome and Theodoret are prominent. In addition to other special traits, they all seek to bring out God’s patience, and apply several elements of Jeremiah’s vocation to Jesus
|
Xenophon and the Ancient Economy
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
John T. Fitzgerald, University of Notre Dame
Xenophon of Athens (ca. 430-354 BCE) was among the first Greek writers to give significant attention to the economy. In addition to writing the Oeconomicus, he also wrote Ways and Means (Poroi), a work that addressed the ongoing financial crisis in Athens following its defeat in the Peloponnesian War. This paper will give attention to some of the key aspects of Xenophon’s economic thought in his various works.
(This paper is for the first project.)
|
Power Politics, Biblical Hermeneutics, and the Widening Gap between the Rich and the Poor in the US
Program Unit: Bible and Its Influence: History and Impact
LeAnn Snow Flesher, Graduate Theological Union
In 1979, after Jimmy Carter’s failed attempt to end the tax exemption of Christian schools established by white southerners after desegregation, Paul Weyrich met with Rev. Jerry Falwell, to discuss creating the “Moral Majority.” Weyrich, former Republican senatorial aide, saw the Moral Majority as means to appeal to ordinary voters by pitting conservative Christians against liberals committed to equal rights. In an article titled “Building the Moral Majority,” Weyrich named those who support desegregation of schools and social gospel, ‘enemies of family and society.’ Simultaneously, he described his coalition as those who ‘subscribe to moral principles, rooted in authentic Gospel;’ and partnered with electronic preachers “…not ashamed to pronounce the Bible unerring truth.”
After the dissolution of the Moral Majority in the late 80s, Pat Robertson, failed presidential candidate, shifted gears, creating the Christian Coalition. Robertson looked to the political arena for leadership tapping Ralph Reed, head of the College of Republicans as director. Reed and others deflected attention away from national fiscal concerns assuring religious conservatives of support on ‘family values.’
Recently, Mark Chaves has noted, while liberal mainline denominations are declining in the US, religious liberalism is not. Simultaneously, those most active in congregations are theologically conservative. Consequently, those most organized have been wooed by the GOP to vote their party based on a social issues platform. A vote for the GOP is also a vote for fiscal conservatism, and a vote for the ever widening gap between the rich and the poor. This paper will show how religion, the Bible, and theology have been used by US politicians to organize the religious socially conservative masses to vote against their own best interests with regard to US economic policies.
|
“Behold, I’ll Be Back”: Terminator, the Book of Revelation and the Power of Sequels
Program Unit: Bible and the Moving Image
Michelle Fletcher, King's College - London
Terminator 5 is currently being filmed, thirty years, and three sequels after Cameron's The Terminator first appeared in cinemas. Through three decades of change, Terminator's apocalyptic visions of the end of the world, good vs. evil, and humans vs. other have not lost their appeal. There is now a range of scholarship available examining how The Terminator and Terminator 2: Judgment Day use material from the book of Revelation, but focus on the later instalments of the series is lacking. Therefore, this paper proposes to build on this previous Terminator scholarship in two ways. First, it will focus on the repeated use of themes and images from the book of Revelation within all four Terminator films in order to examine how they have developed since The Terminator's 1984 inception. This discussion will highlight how the blurring of categories, dialogue with the past, and confusion of good vs. evil have heightened as the franchise has progressed. Secondly, it will use this exploration of the use of apocalyptic themes in the Terminator films in order to re-read the text of Revelation itself. For example, the character of the Terminator will be bought into dialogue with the Son of Man figure, and the relocation of film scenes will be compared to Revelation's use of the Hebrew Bible. This will suggest fresh interpretations for the text of Revelation, demonstrating how its use of images and motifs is more akin to Terminator sequels than The Terminator itself. Ultimately, it will demonstrate that the enduring appeal of the Terminator franchise and the book of Revelation is not their presentations of the future, but rather their dialogue with the past.
|
The Gospel of John, Greco-Roman Rhetoric, and Patristic Exegesis
Program Unit: The Reception of the Bible in Greco-Roman Tradition
Hans Foerster, Universität Wien
The influence of Greco-Roman rhetoric on patristic exegesis has been
studied extensively. The approach of the first interpreters of Christian
Scripture was to use the existent philological methods of the time as one
way to interpret a text. In this context the biblical texts to be
interpreted had also been put into relation with other Greek and Latin
texts, which had been studied in schools of rhetoric using the same
methods. This comparison influenced also the perception of the text or
texts at hand. However, one of the basic questions to raise is how this
exegetical approach of patristic times – in case of this paper to the text
of the Gospel of John – might have shaped the perception of the text and
if this might have, in consequence, also influenced the interpretation of
the text in specific ways.
|
Jewish Place after the Temple: Rabbinic Theory of Spatiality in Late Antiquity
Program Unit: Place, Space, and Identity in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Charlotte Elisheva Fonrobert, Stanford University
Diaspora studies has fruitfully investigated the ways diaspora communities have arranged themselves in new and different environments, have imported old maps only to superimpose them onto new landscapes, etc. Much of this has been aimed at questioning a nationalist paradigm, according to which a coherent collective identity is entirely dependent on territorialism. From this same (nationalist) perspective, in a Jewish cultural context diaspora has often been understood to equal no-place: Jewish place in the diaspora is properly in its sacred texts, in study, in learning; in utopia (the messianic future) and – so the nationalist thinking goes, a collective identity can properly be established only in a place of one’s own conceived of as territory. In the absence of sovereign control over one’s own territory, a collective does not properly (or coherently) inhabit an identity. Alternately, the romantics (Heinrich Heine, and following him, George Steiner a.o.) have valued that model, only positively considering textuality as homeland.
However, in this paper I discuss briefly that the rabbinic sages of the Mishnah and beyond precisely refused this alternative and developed a theory of diasporic spatiality by ritualizing the residential community, thus making possible 'Jewish place' in diaspora. This approach is diasporic by virtue of insisting on the inherent multi-dimensionality of space.
|
Reading the Talmudic Account of Human Creation: A Feminist Commentary
Program Unit: Early Judaism and Rabbinics (EABS)
Charlotte Elisheva Fonrobert, Stanford University
This paper is part of the ongoing larger project of writing a commentary to the Babylonian Talmud. My paper will present the talmudic discourse on the creation of the human being and the role gender plays in this. The goal is two-fold: on the one hand, the paper will show the variety of rabbinic interpretations of Genesis 1, and in particular, the tension between Genesis 1 and 2. The Babylonian Talmud produces one extended discourse, that stitches together a variety of sources and allusions to late antique inter texts. Second, the paper discusses the variety of gender theories that the talmudic text in particular proposes.
|
Olympic Gifts for YHWH? Origins and Affiliations of the Greek Burnt Offering
Program Unit:
G. Forstenpointner, University of Veterinary Medicine, Vienna
T?s?a, the so-called “Olympian Sacrifice“, is a common feature of ancient Greek religious activity, involving the ceremonial slaughter of animals, followed by sacred meals. The central act of this custom is the ritual burning of bovine or caprine thighs (µ???a) and hips/tails (?s???). Despite more than two hundred years of learned debate, modern scientific opinion has not taken full advantage of the abundant archaeozoological data. Carefully excavated layers of sacrificial remains from the Artemision of Ephesos, dating back to the Protogeometric period, have provided the opportunity for a reassessment of the Greek ritual of burnt offering, based on detailed archaeozoological analysis and referring to all available literary and iconographic sources. Synthesis of this evidence clearly indicates a sacrificial tradition of burning cut-out caprine and bovine thigh bones (ossa femoris, patellae), wrapped in two-ply omental fat (????? d?pt??a) and the likewise defleshed caudal part of the dorsal spine (ossa sacralia, caudalia, maybe including the last vertebra lumbalis). This interpretation has been fostered by experimental attempts. The archaeozoological evidence does not support proposed connections between “Olympian sacrifice” and the Central European—in particular Alpine—tradition of burnt offering, the latter being characterized by burning of the victim’s head and feet. However, similarities in ritual practice between Jewish sacrifice, especially sacrifice on behalf of a priest's institution (Leviticus 8:22-8), and Greek ??s?a are evident, even if not yet confirmed by archaeozoological records. Obeying divine orders, a ram’s whole intestinal fat, including the kidneys, its fat tail and the right hind-limb had to be burnt on the altar. Further investigations in sacrificial residuals might help to clarify possible coincidences in the origins of Western Semitic and Greek burnt offerings.
|
The Exegesis on the Soul in Its Fourth-Century Context: The Ascent of the Soul and the Pachomians
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Kimberley Fowler, University of Manchester
The Exegesis on the Soul (ExSoul) allegorizes the degradation of the human soul, personified as a foolish daughter, whose transgressions cause her to be cast out of her heavenly Father’s home to the earth below. In recent years, scholars have considered afresh the possibility that before the Nag Hammadi Codices (NHC) were concealed, Pachomian monks residing near to the discovery site utilized the documents for spiritual edification. Emphasis on spiritual rebirth through transcendence of the flesh is one feature that fourth-century monastic literature and the NHC share; this is particularly true of ExSoul, with its vivid portrayal of Soul’s fall and re-ascent to glory. For Pachomian monks, the soul’s ascent from the physical body to its rightful home with God constituted the ultimate spiritual experience, and as such this paper argues that ExSoul’s poignant account of the necessary steps to achieve this state of perfection – heartfelt repentance and union with the saviour, Christ – would have had particular appeal to a Pachomian readership. This shared emphasis on the soul’s ascent thereby offers further support for a monastic readership of the NHC.
|
Revisiting Zadok and the Zadokites in Bible, Qumran, and Rabbinic Literature
Program Unit: Judaica
Harry Fox, University of Toronto
After Zadok, the most important priest at the start of the Davidic line of monarchs, Bnei Zadok were mentioned in the biblical book of Ezekiel. The Dead Sea Scrolls mention Bnei Zadok and in the Pharisee-Sadducee debates of the rabbinic sages we find Zadok. There have been numerous discussions of the identity of these figures. My contribution is not through its reevaluation so much as via the introduction of a late Second Temple figure named Zadok into the above list of sources. Traditionally the Zadok of the Sadducees became linked to the Zadok of Avot deRabbi Natan in which such a personality is introduced alongside Boetheus as disciples of Antigonus Ish Soho. This in turn reopens the question as to whether the Dead Sea Scrolls and the Sadducees of early rabbinic texts returned to the same Second Temple personality or whether their traditional perspective of the Davidic Zadok still hold true. What this paper will introduce is yet one more Second Temple Zadok into the above mix. It will then speculate as to the probability that the disparate groups of Second Temple Judaism all had the same person in mind and if so why. What do conflicting claims and traditions of these various groups tell us about the reliability of tradition within the various groups? Which literary form proves to be most reliable: attestations to named sources; late legends, (that is, where they form part of longer stories) or legal material. Priestly genealogical lists will also be consulted.
|
Phoenician Metal Bowls: A Study about Their Complex Composition and Iconography
Program Unit: Iconography and Biblical Studies (EABS)
Philipp Frei, Universität Bern - Université de Berne
There’s hardly a nation in antiquity as popular for its trading ability and artisanship as the Phoenicians. The Old Testament as well as the Greek poet Homer prove the fame of the Phoenicians as skilled craftsmen. Especially the metal platters/bowls are outstanding. From the 9th to 6th century B.C. they are widely spread in the whole Aegean Sea and the Near East, from Italy to Mesopotamia. Besides the large amount of ivories these metal bowls form the most important corpus of Phoenician Iconography in the Early Iron Age. Furthermore, because of the far-reaching trade network of the Phoenician merchants they end up in the Mediterranean West, where they had influence on the pictorial art of other cultures, such as Early Greece or Etruria. For all the diversity of the motifs only few studies about the Phoenician metal bowls were published: Apart from some short early articles there is only one monograph (by Glenn Markoe 1985), which is rather a catalogue than an iconographic analysis. A characterization of the Phoenician art proves to be difficult, because it was influenced by the dominating powers of the Near East and Ancient Egypt, so that antithetic motifs and styles were combined to a whole. This study tries to give a first input for further research of the complex iconography of the Phoenician metal bowls by analyzing the compositions of the bowls: Do any kind of composition schemata exist? Can groups or types be formed? Are there possibilities for new approaches of dating? These and other questions are to be examined.
|
The Reception of Biblical Characters in Richard Beer-Hofmann's Works
Program Unit: Modern Jewish Receptions of the Bible
Sarah Freiman-Morris, Tel Aviv University
*
|
Sorting in the Motif Repertoire of the So-called Cuboid Incense Burners (7th–4rd Cent. BCE)
Program Unit: Iconography and Biblical Studies (EABS)
Christian Frevel, Ruhr-Universität Bochum
After introducing the object class and the find distribution of the cuboid incense burners. The paper will discuss the iconography from the Late Iron Age to the beginning of the Hellenistic period. Parallels, continuities and discontinuities to other iconographic traditions will be discussed. Though almost every item has a design of its own there are motif parallels not only in the group itself (e.g. Tell el-Farah/Tell Halif, Gezer/Ashdod) but also with seal impressions of Samaria and the coin imaginary of the so called Philisto-Arabian coins and the Samarian coinage of the 4th cent. BCE. Strikingly the parallels to the Samarian coinage are much more prominent than to the Philistian coinage although there are almost no cuboid incense burners from the Persian province of Samaria but some in the coastal area and in Idumea. Although a mere Hellenistic date and distribution of some of the cuboid incense burners would allow Greek influence, too, such a characteristic is missing within the group. The motif repertoire has some ‘persianisms’ and parallels to Phoenician motifs, but remains different in terms of selection and constellation of motifs. The paper discusses regional aspects, a tendency of iconic ‘profanization’, and some peculiar motifs within the group. By this also the question of an attribution to a religious or ethnic background will be raised.
The paper is co-authored by Katharina Pyschny (Ruhr-Universität Bochum)
|
The Postponed Pesach and the Wood-Gatherer: Aspects of Legal Hermeneutics and Literary History in Num 9:1-14 and 15:31-36
Program Unit: Law and Narrative (EABS)
Christian Frevel, Ruhr-Universität Bochum
Although the alternation of law and narrative is a distinct characteristic of the book of Numbers, it is striking that only two festivals are integrated in the narrative setting of the book: The Pesach in Num 9:1-14 and the Sabbath in Num 15:31-35. While the Pesach is celebrated explicitly by all Israelites before the departure from Sinai, keeping the Sabbath is recounted merely in an implicit way in the story of the condemnation of the wood-gatherer. But both narratives are connected by including a particular addition or innovation. In both instances a decision is adjourned for a short time, since the existing regulations are obviously incomplete (Num 9:8; 15: 34). Therefore there is need for further provision. The following decision is based on an additional revelation by God to Moses (Num 9:9; 15:35). Both cases are legal applications, in which an innovative aspect is included. Following Simeon Chavel and others both cases form a coherent group with Lev 24:10–23; Num 27:1–11. Although similarities between these texts obviously exist, the cases have differences in particular in terms of legal hermeneutical and literary history. The same holds true if one considers the passages on the Pesach and the Sabbath alone. The paper discusses the literary history and the legal hermeneutics of these passages against the background of the alternation of law and narrative in the book of Numbers in general.
|
Das Bildungsprofil des Paulus und seine Schriftauslegung
Program Unit: Schriftrezeption bei Paulus und in der Paulustradition: Reception of Scripture in Paul and Pauline Tradition
Jörg Frey, Universität Zürich
Vor dem Hintergrund konkreter Beispiele für Methoden der Auslegung und Inhalte der Schriftargumentation, wie sie antike Quellen den Pharisäern zuschreiben, lassen sich wesentliche Charakteristika der paulinischen Schriftrezeption gut verstehen. Ein Ausblick auf deren Verhältnis zum Umgang mit der Schrift in der rabbinischen Literatur erhärtet die Einordnung des Paulus in das Milieu palästinisch-jüdischer Schriftgelehrsamkeit.
|
Does the Deuteronomic Kingship Law (Deut 17:14-20) Deconstruct Leadership? A Perspective from a Democratic Angle
Program Unit: Authority and Influence in Ancient Times
Johanna Friedl, Universität Wien
The Deuteronomic Kingship Law (Dtn 17:14-20) has been well-researched and consensus has been reached that its scope differs from that of other perspectives on kingship in the Bible. Its relation – or lack of it – to kingship as presented in the Deuteronomistic History or the Psalms has been the subject of quite a number of articles and monographs, and it is agreed upon to a great extent that kingship is democratised through the use of the term "brother" in this law (Dtn 17:15; 20). What, however, are the implications of the theological concepts underlying this term in its application to the kingship context as presented in its Deuteronomic form? Although the Kingship Law has typically been treated along historical lines as a result of its often simultaneously shedding light and casting shadows on our reading of the Deuteronomistic History, this paper will be focusing on a lexemic approach to the text with, in addition, specific attention to two theological constructs "endemic" to the Book of Deuteronomy, namely Cult Centralisation and, understood in a particular way, also Privilegrecht. These two constructs are powerful Deuteronomic instruments of persuasion and as such worthy of our attention within this particular leadership context.
|
Hannah’s ‘Hard Day’ and Hesiod’s ‘Two Roads’: Poetic Wisdom in Philo’s De Ebrietate
Program Unit: Reception History of Jewish Scriptures in Graeco-Roman Egypt
Courtney Friesen, University of Oxford
In his exegesis of Hannah’s alleged drunkenness in De ebrietate 150, Philo quotes five lines from Hesiod’s Works and Days (287, 289-92) in order to explain Hannah’s response to her accuser: “No, sir, I am a woman for whom the day is hard” (1 Sam 1:15). These popular Hesiodic verses contrast the difficulty of the road to virtue with the ease of the road to wickedness. On Philo’s reading, the misperception of Hannah’s “hard day” by her critic illustrates the moral lesson of Hesiod, namely, that fools consider virtue to be beyond attainment. In the context of recent interest in the ways in which Philo’s literary methods converge with those of other ancient readers, especially Alexandrian scholars, this study situates Philo’s application of Hesiod’s didactic poetry within its wider history of interpretation. As early as Plato and continuing through Philo’s time, Hesiod’s two roads was frequently cited in philosophical discourse and debate over the nature of virtue. Moreover, in a move strikingly akin to Philo’s reading of Hannah, an Alexandrian commentator on Euripides cites Hesiod’s two roads in order explain the sufferings taken on by a tragic heroine in her pursuit of virtue. Philo’s use of Hesiod in Ebr. 150, therefore, functions as evidence not only of his extensive knowledge and appreciation of classical poetry, but also of his affinity with its associated tradition of interpretation. The originality of Philo’s appropriation of this oft-cited passage is thus to be located in his creation of a dialogue between Hesiod’s didactic poetry, on the one hand, and the biblical tradition, on the other, in which both voices converge around the same ethical lesson.
|
Prospects and Perils in Pauline Epigraphy
Program Unit: Pauline Literature (EABS)
Steven J. Friesen, University of Texas at Austin
Over the last several years I have worked on three inscriptions that have become a part of the secondary literature on Paul’s assemblies for all the wrong reasons—the Erastus inscription that allegedly informs us about social stratification in the Corinthian assemblies, the Junia Theodora inscription that allegedly informs us about female leadership in the Kenchreai assembly, and the customs house inscription that allegedly informs us about the social profile of the Ephesian assemblies. In this paper I use these examples of bad epigraphic interpretation to develop suggestions for better practice. A more robust use of inscriptions in Pauline studies will require us to pay more attention to the artifacts themselves. It will also require us to recognize the institutional imperatives and individual desire that tend to hijack our interpretive projects.
|
The Economics of the New Testament Interpretation: Invisible Hands at Work
Program Unit: Political Biblical Criticism
Steven Friesen, University of Texas at Austin
Are there unacknowledged economic ideologies that shape western New Testament scholarship at the disciplinary level? This paper proposes an answer to that question by examining the economic assumptions of four “Introduction to the New Testament” textbooks that are used widely in North America. The textbooks claim to represent the consensus of specialists and the books overtly embrace a variety of theological orientations, including one that claims not to be theological. In spite of this diversity, analysis shows that all four textbooks hold several standard capitalist truths to be self-evident: that religious phenomena are not affected by economic factors; that competitive markets are the arbiters of value; that private ownership of property is a universal fact; and that entrepreneurial individual agency is available to all people throughout history. As a result, in their treatment of economic issues in the New Testament, the four introductory texts are fairly homogenous, isolating religious phenomena from economic influence and ignoring most economic passages in the New Testament. When they do address economic topics, the discussions quickly shift from materiality and objects to interiority and ideas. Moreover, traditional historical-critical methodologies appear to be the means by which the textbooks accomplish these complementary tasks of obliteration and diversion. So, this systemic description of mainstream western New Testament studies suggests that as a discipline, our productive efforts are guided by unacknowledged forces that encourage us to recast Christian origins in our own capitalist image.
|
Malbim’s Interpretation of the Division of the Kingdom Narrative (1 Kgs 12:1–24)
Program Unit: Judaica
Amos Frisch, Bar-Ilan University
The lecture focuses on the commentary by R. Meir Leibush Malbim (1809–1879) on one incident—the division of the kingdom. I begin from the notion that we need to take a direct look at the text and focus on a single, complete passage, rather than citing scattershot examples from all over the commentary.
The fundamental principle behind Malbim’s exegesis of this story is binary opposition. Throughout he contrasts two types of monarchy—“limited” and “unlimited.” From time to time he supplements this binary opposition with other pairs of contraries: two types of prophecy, distinguished by the possibility that the prediction will not come to pass (v. 15); two groups among the northern tribes—the educated stratum and the people at large (v. 16).
I will examine additional facets of his commentary on this story and see how they fit in with the fundamental idea: providing a legal and halakhic background to the events, distinguishing among near synonyms, exposing the characters’ motives, clarifying the meaning of the terms applied to the characters, and dealing with redundancies and contradictions.
All of these are meant to serve what I see as the overarching goal of Malbim’s commentary—demonstrating the thematic and formal perfection of the biblical text.
|
Enochic Writings and Genesis
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Ida Fröhlich, Pázmány Péter Katolikus Egyetem
The story of the Watchers related in 1En 6-11 is generally regarded in scholarly opinion as an interpretation of Gen 6:1-4. The early dating of the Qumran Aramaic fragments containing chapters 1-36 of the Enochic collection leads one to suppose that the Enochic narrative tradition is earlier than the end of the 3rd century BCE, and could go back even centuries earlier. References to Gen 1 in 1En 1-5 reflect a highly sophisticated relation between Genesis and the earliest Enochic writings. Thus, finding a linear linkage between these two traditions is unsuccessful. It can be supposed that the Enochic narrative on Shemihazah and his companions is a narrative of its own right on the origin of the evil, contained in 1En 6-11 with its commentaries, while Gen 6:1-4 and Enoch 1-5 reflect an ongoing theological controversy on cosmology and the origin of the evil between authors and redactors of the Enochic writings and those of Genesis.
|
The Etiological Foundation of Passover and Massot in the Book of Jubilees
Program Unit: Law and Narrative (EABS)
Ida Fröhlich, Pázmány Péter Katolikus Egyetem
Jubilees’ narrative culminates in the revelation of the feasts of Pesah and shabbath. Events of the exodus from Egypt are not detailed in the narrative, and some events are referred to in the legal part only. On the other hand the narrative is enlarged upon a new element, namely that of the working of Mastema and its demonic hosts. Mastema is not an independent power, its working is subordained to divine will actuated by angelic mediation.
The law of the feast of Passover (without the mention of Massot) follows the narrative of the exodus from Egypt, without a reference to etiological elements of the biblical narrative. While Pesah in Exodus is definitely a memorial day (cf. Ex2:14) Jubilees refers to it as an immanent law, an eternal decree engraved upon the heavenly tablets, ordained forever (cf. Jub 49:8). Pesah is here a ritualization of an immanent divine law a propos of a divine rescue from a demonic invasion, that of the killing of the firstborn (Jub 49:2), a ritual that is to be kept in the future as a protection against demonic plagues (Jub 49:15). In Jubilees’ narrative Pesah is juxtaposed with another immanent law, that of the Shabbat existing from the creation (cf. Jub 2:17-33). Keeping this law following the entering the Promised Land will be the means for Israel for a gradual purification from sins – at the same time a process of riddance from Mastema and its impure demonic host.
|
The Anti-Semitic Reception History of the Hebrew Bible in the 20th Century
Program Unit: Anti-Semitic Readings of the Bible
Russell E. Fuller, University of San Diego
The Anti-Semitic Reception History of the Hebrew Bible in the 20th Century
The 20th century included the highpoint of the influence of National Socialism in Germany as well as the sharpened awareness of the repercussions of anti-semitism in general and theological anti-semitism in the reception of the Bible in particular. Although these chronological boundaries are somewhat arbitrary in the study of the history of these phenomena, this paper will explore selected examples of the anti-semitic reception of selected passages from the Hebrew Bible and the explicit historical and cultural contexts in which they were and perhaps still are found.
|
Keep Justice! (Isa 56:1): Thoughts Regarding the Concept and Redaction History of a Universal Understanding of Sedaqa
Program Unit: Israel and the Production and Reception of Authoritative Books in the Persian and Hellenistic Period (EABS)
Judith Gaertner, Universität Osnabrück
The opening of Trito-Isaiah unfolds a concept of sedaqa which in its universal orientation is unique for the Old Testament. It is unique, because it unfolds the meaning of a universal understanding of sedaqa without hesitation and with full consequences. This perspective is explored in view of the individual at its limits. The perspective of belonging to the nation of God is exemplarily for all humankind opened up for foreigners and Eunuchs, the ones at the boundaries of the community. Central condition is a life lived in accordance to sedaqa. The text shows a reciprocal approach to this condition. Foreigners and Eunuchs who practice sedaqa by keeping the Sabbath and holding fast the covenant are thereby ritually integrated into the nation of God. The outcome of this is that the house of YHWH is called a house of prayer for all people (Is 56:7).
On this background the paper will focus on two questions. First, a central aspect of the paper will focus on the question of the understanding of sedaqa, which is a main topic in the whole of the Book of Isaiah. Here, it will be of main interest which concepts of Proto-Isaiah and Deutero-Isaiah are received, continued and modified. Second, the significance of the redaction history of Is 56:1-8 as the opening of Trito-Isaiah will be analyzed. What is the intention of a text which shows such an exposed understanding of sedaqa regarding the composition of the whole Book? In order to answer this question it will be necessary to take into consideration not only questions of redaction criticism regarding Trito-Isaiah but also regarding the whole of the Book of Isaiah.
|
Revisiting Eschatological and Apocalyptic Motifs in the Gospel of Thomas
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
André Gagné, Concordia University - Université Concordia
Revisiting Eschatological and Apocalyptic Motifs in the Gospel of Thomas
|
Ezra Ibn Allah: An Allusion to the Second Temple
Program Unit: Quran and Islamic Tradition in Comparative Perspective
Abdulla Galadari, Masdar Institute
Q. 9:30 is the only passage in the Quran that mentions the term “Ibn Allah,” which is understood as "Son of God." The passage states, “The Jews say, 'Ezra is Ibn Allah'; and the Christians say, 'The Messiah is Ibn Allah.' That is their statement from their mouths; they imitate the saying of those who disbelieved [before them]. May Allah kill them; how deluded they are.” Early Muslim exegetes understood that the Jewish community does not claim that Ezra is the Son of God, and so they suggest that the circumstances of revelation is when a Jew or a group of three Jews come to Muhammad making this statement. Some classical exegetes suppose that there was perhaps a Jewish sect that made this claim. Al-Maqdisi (d. 966) states that Palestinian Jews made such a claim, while Salih al-Hashimi (d. 1269) gives this mythical sect a name, calling it “al-Mu’tamaniyyah,” and goes on to state that Christians borrowed the concept of the Son of God from them. Beyond Muslim literature, there is no evidence that Jews claim Ezra is the Son of God. With the emergence of Western scholarship on this topic, it has been suggested that it is perhaps a misreading from apocryphal works. This paper argues that the term “ibn” is rooted in the word “bny,” which means to build. The biblical book of Ezra uses this term and its morphological permutations, including the term “ibn” to mean building the Second Temple. It is argued that the passage may be understood as the Jews stating Ezra is the Temple of God (an allusion to the Second Temple) and the Christians state that the Messiah is the Temple of God (an allusion to the Bodily Temple as in the Gospel of St. John).
|
Lc 24 Reconsidered: The Figure of Ghost in the Postclassical Greek Literature
Program Unit: Graeco-Roman Society (EABS)
Israel Muñoz Gallarte, Universidad de Córdoba (España)
The ways the figure of ghost appears in a wide range of ancient literary works and authors in a discursive way or another, depending on the concepts and the worldview of a given culture have already drawn scholarly attention. However, scholarly research tends sometimes to rationalize the transmitted texts in order to fit them into our current cultural parameters. Therefore, the aim of this paper is to offer a new approach regarding the passage of Lc 24, 36-44, taking into account new insights regarding the figure of ghosts in Greek folklore.
|
How to Study the Septuagint: Greek Church Fathers and Manuscripts of the Catenae in Vetus Testamentum in the Austrian National Library
Program Unit: The Bible in Byzantium: The Use and Abuse of Tradition
Ernst Gamillscheg, Österreichische Nationalbibliothek
*
|
Action and Counter-Action: Michal, Abigail, and Bathsheba
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Kirsten H. Gardner, Fuller Theological Seminary (Pasadena)
Michal, Abigail and Bathsheba’s stories are examined with a particular focus on narrative agency along a literary continuum of action and counter-action as it elucidates the theological concept of the “God who acts.” This paper highlights the pivotal role of female biblical characters in displays of counter-action, which in turn serve to propagate the narrative plot. If action, as portrayed in speech and physicality, represents the narrative thrust that is often, but not always, aligned with the male protagonist’s goals, then the counter-action is that action which opposes the protagonist.
The three female characters exhibit limited narrative presence, yet despite their respective roles as supporting characters, each demonstrates literary agency in distinct acts that oppose their male counterparts. When Michal helps David escape she defies Saul’s intended murder. Later she confronts David’s hubris in her speech. Abigail counters Nabal’s actions when she supports the future King David; yet, she also opposes the imminent bloodshed. Bathsheba confronts David and later she counter-acts Adonijah’s scheming. Not only do these acts constitute a literary witness to women confronting male power and aggression, but in each of these cases the narrated purposes of God are being promoted in the very wake of these displays of female agency.
In confronting and opposing the prevailing power structures, aggressions, and schemes, female counter-actions deconstruct the actions of the male protagonists. Thus, a reading of the historical narratives along a continuum of action and counter-action demonstrates not only that human agents are used to advance the plot along the stated intent of God, but also that female literary agency emerges with efficacy to bring about said plot changes by utilizing narrated opposition to patriarchy, male dominance, and male aggression.
|
Imagery of Early Christian Rituals in the Greek Physiologus
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Zbynek Garsky, University of Bern
Why is a pelican symbol of Christ and what has to do a unicorn with the Virgin Mary? Answers to questions like these can be found in Physiologus, a short Greek work most likely written in the second half of the 2nd century AD in Alexandria. It is the earliest allegorical interpretation of nature with respect to biblical motifs and Christian theology, which was widely used from ancient times (e.g. by Clemens of Alexandria or Origen). In Middle Ages, the flowering time of Christian allegory, the work was translated into almost all cultural languages and from this moment on it circulates in the new form of so well known bestiaries across the world until today (see e.g. J. L. Borges’ “The Book of Imaginary Beings” or J. K. Rowling’s “Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them”).
In this paper I will focus on the imagery of early Christian rituals (esp. of the eucharist and baptism) as they are found in allegorical interpretations of beasts in the Greek Physiologus and trace the way of selected motifs from the New Testament to this first Christian interpretation of nature in context of early Christian literature and theology. A special attention will be given to the pelican, which is one of the most famous symbols of the eucharist, and to impressive baptismal imageries in the chapter on the eagle, on the snake and in some other chapters.
The aim of the analysis is to explore the theological roots of the ritual imagery of Physiologus and to show that this work of early Egyptian Christianity is anything but ‘unsakramental’ as argued by E. Peterson (1959).
|
The Use of Bible Quotations in Byzantine Documents: A Text Pragmatic Approach
Program Unit: The Bible in Byzantium: The Use and Abuse of Tradition
Christian Gastgeber, Österreichische Akademie der Wissenschaften
*
|
Hebrews 3–4 and Critical Spatiality
Program Unit: Epistle to the Hebrews
Gabriella Gelardini, Universität Basel
The Book of Hebrews depicts a world of dynamic interrelationships between physicality, perceptions, rhetorics, and actions. This paper examines Heb 3–4 through the lens of critical spatial theory.
|
Pre-Eternity or Creation: A Comparative Study of al-Ghazali and Maimonides
Program Unit: Quran and Islamic Tradition in Comparative Perspective
Hadi Gerami, Institute of Imamite Studies, Tehran
Throughout the Middle Ages, a cultural cross-fertilization of ideas among Muslim, Jews, and Christians took place. Among these groups, the question of how the world had been created drew philosophers' and theologians' attention. The question of whether the world was pre-eternal or created was a crucial debate in medieval philosophy. There is no doubt that al-Ghazali and Maimonides were among the most important contributors to this debate in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries. These two figures criticized earlier philosophers and offered some counter-arguments, considering the question from their particular standpoints. Whereas al-Ghazali, the prototype of an anti-falsafa Muslim scholar, challenges Avicenna's proofs in the field, Maimonides, as a Jewish philosopher, proves that the pre-eternity of the world is invalid in a different way. Even though both scholars have refuted the idea of pre-eternity, what are the differences and similarities in their argumentations? Has each of them been influenced by his counter-part? What was the impact of their religious affiliation on their argumentation?
|
Herders Kritik an der Allegorischen Auslegung des Hoheliedes: Ein Kritischer Blick auf eine Folgenreiche Schrift zum Hoheliedverständnis
Program Unit: The Song of Songs: Literal or Allegorical?
Meik Gerhards, Universität Rostock
Herders Schrift „Lieder der Liebe. Die ältesten und schönsten aus Morgenlande“ (1778) gilt weithin als wichtiger Schritt für die allgemeine Durchsetzung eines nichtallegorischen Ver-ständnisses des Hoheliedes. In der Tat hat Herder, dessen Einfluss auf die Entwicklung der Bibelkritik kaum zu überschätzen ist, heftige Kritik an „willkürlichen Hypothesen“ über eine moralische, politische oder theologische Intention des Hoheliedes geübt. Dass er aber zugleich die „Pedanten und Wortkrämer“ kritisiert, die eine allegorische „Anwendung“ der Liebesgedichte „untersagen“, wurde wenig beachtet. Offensichtlich war die Wirkung von Herders Schrift auf die Hoheliedexegese einseitig. Der Vortrag sucht die Argumentation des zweiten Teils des Buches nachzuzeichnen und zu fragen, von welchen Voraussetzungen Herders Votum für ein nicht-allegorisches Verständnis geprägt ist und welche Perspektiven sich aus der kritischen Beschäftigung mit Herders Schrift für die heutige Hohelied-Exegese ergeben.
It is widely granted that Herder’s book „Lieder der Liebe. Die ältesten und schönsten aus Morgenlande“ (1778) was an important step for the common acceptance of the non-allegorical understanding of the Song of Songs. Herder, whose influence on the development of biblical criticism can hardly be overestimated, was indeed a passionate critic of “arbitrary hypotheses” about a moral, political or theological intention of the Song of Songs. That he also criticized those “pedants and hairsplitters” („Pedanten und Wortkrämer“), who prohibit an allegorical application of the love lyrics, was hardly recognized. Obviously, the influence of Herder’s book on the exegesis of the Song of Songs was onesided. The presentation seeks to trace the argumentation of the second part of the book and to query, on which assumptions Herder’s vote for a non-allegorical understanding depends and which perspectives arise from the critical study of Herder’s book for the present exegesis of the Song of Songs.
|
Is There Philosophy in the Hebrew Bible? An Introduction to Recent Affirmative Conceptions
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible/Old Testament/Ancient Israel Studies (EABS)
Jaco Gericke, North-West University (South Africa)
While various sub-disciplines in philosophy play an important role in some areas of biblical scholarship, it is still controversial in many circles to suggest that there is actually philosophy in the Hebrew Bible. The popular consensus carried over from twentieth-century biblical theology holds that many classical and contemporary philosophical concerns, concepts and categories are to be seen as being essentially alien to so-called “Hebrew thought.” However, over the last decade or so, the idea that the biblical texts do in fact have philosophical content appears to have made a strange return in the writings of a small number of Hebrew Bible scholars and philosophers. In this paper, an introduction to some representative perspectives on the matter is provided (e.g. Thomas Thompson, James Crenshaw, Phillip Davies, Yoram Hazony, Jaco Gericke, et al.). Feedback is also given on the relevant related ideas that lie behind recent conferences in Jewish philosophy and philosophy of religion that focused on the Hebrew Bible. The findings are then put into context by identifying some historical precursors and forerunners thereto and by considering possible future prospects for the concept of “biblical philosophy”. It is concluded that while an increasing number of biblical scholars and philosophers today agree that one may speak of “philosophy” in the Hebrew Bible, there appears to be little consensus as to the definition, sense, nature, type, form, contents, scope, location and relevance thereof. This should, however, be expected, given that the viewpoints discussed form part of a larger philosophical turn in research on the Hebrew Bible where a plurality of convergences and divergences is to be expected.
|
Philosophical Interpretations of Qohelet: A Brief Historical Overview
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Wisdom
Jaco Gericke, North-West University (South Africa)
When one looks at the history of interpretation of the Hebrew Bible's wisdom literature, the Book of Qohelet (Ecclesiastes) has tended to attract more philosophical readings than any other canonical text. One reason for this phenomenon is surely the book's own quasi-philosophical nature and the way in which possible parallels to its thought can easily be found in the views of both ancient and modern philosophers and philosophies. However, since most commentaries on Qohelet that do note philosophical perspectives in the reception history tend to be limited either to providing a short overview of failed attempts at finding alleged Greek philosophical parallels or to proposing (post-)modern philosophical counterparts and heirs, a history of philosophical interpretations of Qohelet that includes it all and that spans the entire period of the book's reception does not currently exist. This is the gap this paper seeks to fill, albeit ever-so briefly. Starting with possible philosophical responses to Qohelet in the Apocrypha and early Jewish and Christian philosophical commentaries, the discussion moves on to early and late modern comparative-historical attempts to relate the book to Greek/Hellenistic philosophy before finally concluding with 20th and 21st century trends seeking to clarify the text from various fashionable philosophical perspectives (e.g., inter alia, pragmatism, existentialism, nihilism, structuralism, hermeneutics, post-structuralism, deconstruction, post-modernism, philosophy of religion, critical theory, social philosophy, etc.)
|
Thus Saith the Scribe: The Scribal Composition of the Book of Jeremiah
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible/Old Testament/Ancient Israel Studies (EABS)
Justus T. Ghormley, University of Notre Dame
It is a tenet of biblical studies that the Hebrew Bible is—to different degrees—the product of scribal creativity. Yet, the creative techniques through which scribes composed this Bible are not fully understood. This paper addresses this gap in our understanding by analyzing how scribes expanded the book of Jeremiah through the practice of duplication. As is well known, Jeremiah survives in two dramatically different forms: a shorter – and presumably older – version known primarily from the Septuagint, and a longer – and arguably later – version witnessed by the Masoretic Text. A comparison of these two versions reveals that scribes frequently expanded the book through duplication: scribes would lift a set of verses already found in Jeremiah and copy them elsewhere in the book thereby creating a doublet. These doublets provide us with an opportunity to study the various ways scribes “copied” their master texts. An analysis of the doublets found in the later version of Jeremiah demonstrates that scribes enjoyed a range of creative license when duplicating. At times, scribes would produce a nearly identical copy of the original verses. At other times, scribes would adapt, enlarge, interpret, and/or paraphrase their source. Significantly, the earlier version of Jeremiah, itself, appears to be in part the product of a similar process of duplication. This version is already replete with doublets of comparable size and tenor. This paper analyzes and compares both sets of doublets – those of the earlier version of Jeremiah and those of the later version– in order to understand more fully 1) the techniques through which Jewish scribes expanded and adapted their scriptural texts and 2) how scribal treatment of the text of Jeremiah changed over time.
|
Biblical Learning in Byzantium: The Exegetical Didaskaliai in Context
Program Unit: The Bible in Byzantium: The Use and Abuse of Tradition
Antonia Giannouli, University of Cyprus
*
|
Waters from Waters: Division, Definition, and Parallelism in Genesis 1–3 and Plato’s Sophist
Program Unit: Literary Features – Fact or Fiction (EABS)
Twyla Gibson, University of Missouri
A significant development in ancient studies has been the growing recognition of the pervasive presence of parallelism and chiasmus in Gilgamesh, Homer, Plato, the Book of Genesis, and other important early texts. Though progress has been made in identifying parallel and chiastic organization, much work remains to be done. Using as a case study a comparative analysis of Genesis 1–3 and Plato’s Sophist, I present a prototype Virtual Research Environment for the identification of parallelism and chiasmus in classical Greek and Hebrew texts. I use this computer interface as well as information theory and methods to demonstrate that the tacit order of the topics in the narrative in Genesis 1–3 is a near identical match with the topics in the series of definitions presented by explicit instructions in Plato’s Sophist, thereby adding weight to reports of early commentators such as Aristobulus (Clement of Alexandria, Stromateis I. 22), Origen (Contra Celsum, IV. 39, VI. 19), and Eusebius (Praeparatio Evangelica, VI.7) who said that Plato borrowed Hebrew precepts and transferred them into his system. Eusebius quotes Numenius, “For what is Plato, but Moses speaking in Attic Greek?” Focusing on the division of waters, I present text analyses of three other similarly organized passages to show that when different texts are lined-up in parallel and ideas in corresponding categories cross-referenced and brought into dialogue, an array of new information about the meanings of concepts is opened. Words and ideas that seem ambiguous in one text are often given fuller treatment in other contexts; this new information is then available to enrich interpretation. I argue that these findings have major implications for understanding what ancient texts meant to the cultures and societies that produced them, and for re-evaluating both the history of their reception and their continuing influence.
|
The Greek Key: New Technologies for the Analysis of Rhetorical Figures in Classical and Biblical Texts
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical Studies, Early Jewish and Christian Studies (EABS)
Twyla Gibson, University of Missouri
This paper describes a prototype Virtual Research Environment (VRE) for the study of rhetorical patterns in classical Greek and biblical texts. The project is currently in development and supported by the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada (SSHRC). The VRE incorporates digitized manuscripts and textual content available online, open source tools, as well as commercial software such as Logos. I present a case study that compares rhetorical figures (parallelism and chiasmus) in Plato’s Sophist with similar patterns in the Book of Genesis. Sequences of topics in several branches of the Platonic definition of techne (art, craft, technique, and the root of our own word, “technology”) set forth via explicit instructions in the Sophist are delineated and then used as a framework, template, or basis of comparison with the organization of topics and ideas in Genesis 1-3. This exercise shows that the serial ordering of the topics in the two narratives is nearly identical. These exemplary texts illustrate the potential for the prototype VRE to assist with the identification of rhetorical forms that operate in and across a number of philosophical, religious, literary, and cultural texts. The case study also shows how new techniques for visualizing and organizing textual data have the potential to: reveal previously undetected patterns and connections among passages, books, and collections; help users mine and extract new information from texts; and generate fresh insights about literature that has had a central and enduring influence on our scholarly traditions. The demonstration highlights how new technologies can help scholars pursue old questions in innovative ways, and how digital techniques raise novel questions that cannot be addressed using more traditional methods.
|
Authority and the Shema: The Significance of the Distinctive Characterization of the Scribes in the Plot of Mark
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Jen Gilbertson, University of St. Andrews
While scholars may accurately categorize the scribes as a component of the Jewish leadership united in its opposition to Jesus in Mark’s Gospel, too often they overlook Mark’s treatment of the scribes as a distinct group which plays an important role in introducing and developing the themes of the narrative. Therefore, the aim of this study is to illustrate how the Markan placement and characterization of the scribes contribute to our understanding of Mark’s Gospel. A comparison with Matthew and Luke highlights Mark’s strategic placement and depiction. In Mark, the scribes are Jesus’ only consistent opponents, appearing at crucial moments in all three major sections of the narrative, thereby connecting the Galilean ministry with the travel narrative and the Passion Narrative. Their appearances in the opening chapters of the Gospel introduce the theme of the source of Jesus’ authority, a controversy which runs throughout the gospel, climaxing in the dialogue with a single scribe over the greatest commandment in chapter 12. This theme is developed through allusions to the Shema, first introduced in 2:6 by the scribes themselves, who are regarded as the teachers of the law. The Shema is further alluded to by Jesus’ use of hearing imperatives and his interest in the state of the heart (especially in 7:1-23), and is developed in detail in 12:28-40, including the only citation of the introductory phrase of the Shema (Deut 6:4) in the New Testament and a unique emphatic repetition of the command to love God (Deut 6:5). Thus, the characterization of the scribes in Mark serves both to connect the segments of the narrative, and to develop a key theme.
|
Introduction: Antisemitism, Antijudaism, and Other Terms
Program Unit: Anti-Semitic Readings of the Bible
Susanne Gillmayr-Bucher, Catholic-Theological Private University of Linz
In this brief introduction we will discuss various terms which are used to designate denigration, hatred, and persecution of Jews and Judaism.
|
Juxtaposition and the Elisha Stories: Editorial Arrangements Shaping Ideology
Program Unit: Literary Features – Fact or Fiction (EABS)
Rachelle Gilmour, University of Sydney
This paper examines the use of juxtaposition to create ideology, focusing on the Elisha cycle as a case study. It proposes that through careful juxtaposition and arrangement, the meaning of the final from could be shaped from existing traditions with minimal editorial work. In the case of the Elisha cycle, there are many elements within the stories that reflect negative aspects of Elisha’s character, and positive aspects of the Omride kings. Yet, overall, most readers agree that the ideology is pro-prophetic. We will investigate three ways in which this result is achieved. Firstly, the corroboration of ideas and motifs in adjacent episodes creates themes. For example, in the Elisha cycle, the theme of the word of Elisha is created by the juxtaposition of several stories where this element appears, albeit in minor ways. Similarly, themes are created around the danger of death to children, the provision of food and conflict with Aram. These themes highlight the miraculous power of Elisha in each of these areas. Secondly, messages in tension with the overall ideology are juxtaposed with episodes which ‘correct’ or nuance them. A story where Elisha’s powers are not entirely effective, for example 2 Kings 3, is surrounded by outstanding examples of the power of his word. Thirdly, the juxtaposition of the Elisha cycle with the Elijah cycle and the Jehu narrative further enforces the pro-prophetic position.
|
From the Pythia to Cassandra: The Ambivalent Authority of Greek Prophetesses
Program Unit: The Image of Female Prophets in Ancient Greek and Jewish Literature
Manuela Giordano, University of Calabria
The paper will sketch the portrait of prophetesses in ancient Greek sources with a particular attention on the Pythia. The portraits will be set in their historical context, with a focus on fifth-century Athens, so as to allow us to better assess the issue of gender and authority with relation to prophecy. A brief outline of women’s position in ancient Greek culture will be given, particularly highlighting the fact that women were barred from public spaces and that subsequently their voice had no authority whatsoever and was not even supposed to be heard., a model in relation to which the role of the Delphic prophetess seem to stand in blatant contrast. The oracle of Delphi - to which the Pythia gave voice- was an absolutely central institution in ancient Greece and beyond, and the prophecies of Apollo, uttered through the Pythia’s voice, were eminently pivotal in ancient Greek politics, warfare and myth. The influential and authoritative voice of the Pythia therefore stands out as particularly significant and a set of informative questions may be asked. First of all the issue of sexuality, as in the case of the Pythia a particular relation can be seen between her virginity and her mantic speech. The question of authoritativeness will come equally to the fore, as Delphic traditions suggest a tension between Apollo and the Pythia in terms of prophetic authority. This is also conducive to exploring the question of mythic taxonomies in our sources, with an attention to normalization in Athenian versions, as in the portrait of the Pythia in Aeschylus’Eumenides. A countering example could eventually be tackled in the feature of Cassandra as a frustrated prophetic voice, where the warping of her prophetic gift seems to stand in relation to her untamed female voice.
|
Introduction to LXX Micah
Program Unit: Septuagint Studies
W. Edward Glenny, University of Northwestern - St. Paul
This paper is a summary of some introductory issues related to LXX Micah. Important introductory issues are the book’s literary structure, key words and themes, language, content, and theology. Also important is the translation technique employed and what we can learn about the date and place of translation from the translation technique. Finally I hope to discuss briefly the reception history of the book.
|
1 Peter 2:13-17 and the Date of 1 Peter
Program Unit: Catholic Epistles
W. Edward Glenny, University of Northwestern - St. Paul
1 Peter 2:17 contains the only mention of the emperor in 1 Peter (“Honor the emperor”). Some contend that this command fits best in an historical context in which the recipients of 1 Peter are experiencing some form of imperial persecution and in which they are to resist imperial demands. Others argue that this command would not have been included in 1 Peter if the imperial cult were widespread or if intense persecution of Christians had broken out. The purpose of this paper is to consider the Sitz im Leben of this command and then to discuss the implications of that Sitz im Leben on our understanding of the date of 1 Peter.
|
The Apocalypse and the Scholar: Assessing the Contribution of John J. Collins to the Study of Apocalypticism
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Matthew Goff, Florida State University
Collins’ work on apocalypticism has been so foundational that it is more often cited than critically examined. Collins in 1979 in Semeia 14 put forward essentially a form-critical approach to apocalypticism. The project is one of delineating the literary form of the apocalypse and its constituent parts. The focus is on the identification of literary features of texts more than their cultural contexts. Thus this volume not only has Jewish apocalypses, but also gnostic, Persian and rabbinic ones. Form-criticism as an intellectual endeavor in biblical studies stalled in the 1980s, due to the subjective and arbitrary nature by which form-critics divided up biblical texts. Collins’ seminal book The Apocalyptic Imagination (1984) is a product of this period but moves beyond the form-critical approach of Semeia 14. In this volume form-criticism delimits the object of study, being used to identify which ancient Jewish texts are apocalypses, but the study of each apocalypse is thoroughly historical-critical. While the book is incredibly helpful in this regard, one should note the tension between, one can say, where the book begins and where it goes. The modern (and subjective) delineation of the literary category apocalypse, while valid, means one should be cautious regarding how to understand the apocalypses historically in relation to one another, a network of texts often simplistically referred to as the “apocalyptic tradition.” Positing connections between specific writings should not be presumed on the basis of their classification as apocalypses. Some apocalypses have a close relationship they don’t share with other apocalypses (e.g., 2 Baruch and 4 Ezra). Collins’ justly deserves his reputation as an important scholar of apocalypticism, but one should keep in mind the tension between the form-critical classification “apocalypse” and the historical-critical approach to apocalypticism.
|
Monstrous Exegesis in the Book of the Watchers
Program Unit: Reception of Scripture in Second Temple Literature
Matthew Goff, Florida State University
While it is common for scholars to understand the Enochic Book of the Watchers as refashioning some form of the scriptural flood story, a key implication of this perspective is often not stressed—that Watchers transforms the gibborim of Gen 6 into cannibalistic giants. As is well-known, the phrases describing the gibborim (they are “of old” and “men of renown”) can reasonably be understood as positive descriptions, giving a brief impression of legendary warriors of a by-gone age. Watchers refashions the sons of the angels in a profoundly negative way, in part because this change solves an exegetical problem evident in Genesis itself—how to understand the relationship between the sons of the angels (6:4) and the rise of evil that led to the flood (6:5). The nature of their crimes, killing and eating humans, and the emphasis that the giants drank their blood (1 En. 7:5), can be understood at least in part as reflection upon Genesis 9, which states that in the post-flood world humans may eat the flesh of animals but not their blood and they may not murder other humans. The prohibition against eating blood in Genesis 9, the association the chapter makes between eating blood and murder, as well as the whole issue of bringing up the consumption of meat in the first place, all take on additional significance if one imagines the antediluvian crisis in the manner described in the Book of the Watchers. There is an exegetical logic to this composition’s transformation of the legendary gibborim into monstrous cannibals.
|
“They Shall light Your Laws for Jacob”: The Urim and Thummim in the Dead Sea Scrolls and Second Temple Literature
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Liora Goldman, University of Haifa
The biblical texts refer to the Urim and Thummim on five occasions, the term Urim also occurring twice on its own. These appear to have been holy lots in the high priest’s breastpiece whereby he inquired of God concerning whether to engage in war, how to allot the tribal inheritances, and how to identify figures chosen by God. No physical description of the Urim and Thummim is given, the manner in which the inquiry was made is not elucidated, nor do we know what happened in those matters that did not receive a clear answer. Some of the scrolls answer several of these questions by reworking the biblical material. Four scrolls reveal that the king was expected to make military decisions, including whether to go out to war in historical time or in the eschatological war on basis of the high priest’s inquiry of God via the Urim (4Q376, 4Q522 9 ii 10–11, Temple Scroll 58: 15-21 and Pesher Isaiah[4Q161] 8-10:25-29). Josephus’ Ant. 3.214-216 and three scrolls (4Q376, 4QTestimonia and Pesher Isaiah [4Q164] 1:5) indicate that the answer to the high priest’s inquiry was conveyed through light—via the twelve stones on his breastplate and the two onyxes on his shoulders. The Apocryphon of Moses also implies that the high priest went outside to the assembled people so that they could understand from the light glowing from the stones that God had given His answer. In this lecture, I shall review these texts, also adducing my interpretation of a pesher on Isaiah 11 and Deut 33:10 in Pesher Isaiah[4Q161]8-10:25-29, according to which the chieftain was required to turn to the high priest before going out to fight the eschatological war.
|
A New Source of Information on Amarna Monotheism
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Traditions in the Biblical World and Beyond
Orly Goldwasser, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
In this lecture, I will present a new perspective vis-à-vis Amarna monotheism, which emerges from a previously overlooked source — the Egyptian classifier system. The essence of Akhenaten’s religious beliefs has been the subject of much discussion and debate since the end of the 19th century, beginning with Petrie’s depiction of the Aten as “the energy of light” to the most recent contributions of Hornung, Assmann, and others. One of the central issues in this regard is the “degree” of monotheism (i.e. monotheism versus henotheism and monolatry) attained by the Amarna practitioners. This matter has major ramifications for the question of the relation between Atenism and the religion(s) of the Hebrew Bible. Until now, attempts to answer this question have made use of two types of data. 1. Textual material: Texts relating to Amarna doctrine 2. Iconographic and archaeological material: The two-dimensional representations of the Aten and the royal family, the idiosyncratic representations of the king and queen in three dimensional art, as well as other archaeological finds, have been studied as instances of “self representation,” and their possible ideological and religious meanings have been considered. By researching all occurrences of [DIVINE] classifiers, among others, in the corpus of the Amarna texts, I believe I may be able to shed a new light on Akhenaten’s belief system, and on the much-debated question — is the Amarna religion a leap from polytheism to exclusive monotheism, or is it merely a case of monolatric praxis?
|
The Definition of Lexemes according to the Diccionario Griego-Espanol del Nuevo Testamento (DGENT)
Program Unit: New Testament/Early Christianity/Rabbinic Studies (EABS)
Damaris Romero González, Universidad de Córdoba (España)
Bilingual dictionaries, especially those devoted to translate ancient Greek terms into a modern language, do not distinguish usually between ‘meaning’ and its translation in a given context. This option forces the readers either to infer the meaning from a given of translations or just to choose one or another. In order to avoid this lack of objectivism, we consider to offer a paraphrase that contains the whole semes that should compound the meaning of a lexeme. However, this procedure needs a rigorous method that allows researchers to elucidate which components should be included in the definition and, if it is possible, to establish different structures depending on each grammatical category. Following one of these methods of semantic analysis, the Diccionario Griego-Español del Nuevo Testamento (DGENT) brings the users a constant reflection on the sense of the definition and its components. Therefore, the aim of our paper is, firstly, to explain the theory followed in the elaboration of DGENT, taking onto account also other theories, in order to observe its improvements and/or deficiencies in the field of modern lexicography. Secondly, we will try to illustrate this theory through several examples from a given semantic field.
|
“For the Law Was Given through Moses; the Grace and the Truth through Jesus” (Jn 1:17): Anti-Semitic Readings of Hebrew Scripture in Early Christianity in the Context of Rabbinic Thought
Program Unit: Anti-Semitic Readings of the Bible
Eveline Goodman-Thau, Hermann-Cohen-Akademie
In our paper we will explore the meaning of Covenant (Hebr. Brit) in the New Testament as compared to the way Rabbinics understand this term. The tension between the notion of “Law” vs. “Grace and Truth”, will be traced through the way Jews and Christians during this period viewed Moses and Jesus as the two central figures representing “Covenant”, link between Man and God in the light of the establishment of the “New Covenant”. In addition, we will trace Anti-Semitic readings in later periods to see how the idea of the “New Israel” runs in this way like a red thread through Christian Theology, throughout the ages.
|
The Grapes of Wrath: Why the Anger?
Program Unit: Prophets
Leeor Gottlieb, Bar-Ilan University
Isaiah 63:1-6 is an exceptionally dramatic and colorful prophecy which depicts a victorious hero returning from an epic battle, who – in this context – is presumably none other than God. The images and alliterations throughout this prophecy paint a striking red color in the minds of its readers. The color red is alluded to in three ways:
1. The reference to Edom is a deliberate wordplay on the color red, just as Bosrah is an intentional allusion to the grape harvest.
2. The metaphor of the winepresser conjures the image of red wine.
3. The totality of the hero’s victory is expressed primarily through the gory red stains of blood on his clothes.
This graphic description and the vivid bloody hue accompanying it in the prophecy serve to illustrate God’s rage against an unnamed enemy. Moreover, the passage leaves the cause of this unbridled fury blurred, forcing scholars to struggle both with the identification of this enemy and with the grievous crime which must have been committed to warrant such a zealous prophetic response.
In this paper, I will analyze the meaning of the enigmatic word h?mws? (v. 1) and demonstrate how – coupled with the colorful wine imagery – it can help us reveal the vanquished adversary’s identity and the historical and geo-political conditions under which this prophecy was composed.
|
Treading the Circle Deftly and Warily: The Problem of Dating New Testament Documents
Program Unit: New Testament/Early Christianity/Rabbinic Studies (EABS)
Thomas Goud, University of New Brunswick
The dating of ancient documents is more art than science, but at times it appears to verge on conjuring. The principal reason for such divergence is that different criteria for determining the date are accorded significantly different weight. Too often an a priori decision is made about the date of a document and then the criteria which support that position are foregrounded; arguments are sometimes marshalled against the contrary evidence and approaches, or in some cases such material is simply ignored. There is an inevitable circle in the reasoning from various criteria to date and back again. That cannot be helped, but what can and must be done is “to tread that circle deftly and warily.”
This paper will use the Letter of James as a case study to explore the methodological problems involved in dating ancient documents. Arguments have been made for dates as early as the 30s and as late as the 150s. This paper is not aimed at advocating a particular date—that has been done many times—but at elucidating the assumptions and practices of those who have done so. Without explicit and self-aware consideration of such assumptions and practices there is nothing to be done but to end up caught in a vicious circle.
|
Jesus and the Samaritan Woman as Scriptural "Proof" for Apartheid
Program Unit: Bible and Empire
Moritz Graeper, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
In my paper I would like to show how the interpretation of John 4 became a typical example of colonial and racist readings of New Testament texts in South Africa during the 20th century. At the inter-racial church gathering in Johannesburg in 1954, W.H. du Plessis spoke as one of the delegates of the Dutch Reformed Church (Nederduitse Gereformeerde Kerk). In his "Practical Suggestions for Co-Operation in Extending the Kingdom of God in Multi-Racial South Africa" he argues with characteristic binary categories such as non-European/European, not yet ripe/ripe, old religion/Christianity. The "well of Samaria" becomes his leading metaphor for the legitimacy of ethnically separate churches. In a first step, the paper introduces du Plessis' argumentation and puts it into the context of other Apartheid readings of New Testament texts. His use of John 4 can be read as an exemplification of the rather subtle racism based on scriptural "proofs" during Apartheid. Secondly, I will focus on John 4 and try to develop an understanding of its possible original meaning and function within Johannine theology in order to assess du Plessis' conclusions. Finally I would like to reflect upon the hermeneutical presuppositions necessary for du Plessis' interpretation of John 4. Interestingly du Plessis' argumentation does not draw reference to the key texts of pro-Apartheid New Testament exegesis, namely Acts 2 and 17. The proposed paper will add to a better understanding of how almost any biblical text, regardless of its supposed historical intention, can be (mis)used as an argument for colonial, oppressive, and racist policies in church and society.
|
Serach Bat Asher and Pharoah: The Survivor as Witness in Midrash and Art
Program Unit: Judaica
Naomi Graetz, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
From the beginning of time when God either exiled his creation or destroyed their world there was always someone left behind as a surviving witness, starting with Cain. Noah survived to build a new world after the flood, Abraham survived Nimrod's fire in the midrash, Isaac the Akedah, and Lot's daughters the destruction of Sodom. Dinah, the only survivor of Shechem had a baby Asenat, who, according to the midrash, married Joseph. Despite there being no surviving witnesses (Exodus 14:28) Pharaoh, according to the midrash, survived the Crossing of the Sea (Exodus Rabbah, The Mekhilta De Rabbi Yishmael and Pirkei De Rabbi Eliezar and Otzar Hamidrashim). Presumably the artists who depicted the biblical scenes in the Sarajevo and Mainz Haggadot were influenced by the midrash. The ultimate survivor who bears witness is Serach, daughter of Asher who in midrashic sources (BT Sotah, Genesis Rabbah, Ecclesiastes Rabbah, Pirkei deRabbi Eliezer, Mekhilta de-Rabbi Ishmael, Masekhta Vayehi Beshalah, Petihtah) survives from the time of Joseph's death, reincarnates herself as the wise woman in 2 Sam 20, and is still around in rabbinic times (Pesikta de-Rav Kahana), perhaps never dying, having entered the Garden of Eden alive (Otzar Hamidrashim). The artists who depict Serach follow her throughout these stages of her life—including one which depicts her skull. For the sages she serves as a witness, exemplifying the people of Israel who in Zechariah 3:2 appear as "a brand plucked from the fire" and in Jeremiah 31:2 as "the people escaped from the sword". Serach, an example of a constant survivor, is a figure that holds out hope to the dispersed Jewish nation. Even though God has exiled them, He will ultimately redeem these survivors.
|
An Un-original Poet? The Use and Re-use of Metaphors in Psalm 144
Program Unit: Metaphors in the Hebrew Bible/Old Testament and Their Reception
Alison Gray, Westcott House, Cambridge
Psalm 144 provides one of the richest texts for a study of inner-biblical metaphor reception in the entire Psalter. Frequently described as a ‘patchwork’ or ‘anthology’, it draws its ideas and phrases predominantly from Psalm 18, but reverberates with discernible echoes from Psalms 8, 33, 39 and 104. The author of Psalm 144 has suffered considerable disrepute in the past for his liberal ‘borrowing’ of such words and phrases, being labelled as ‘kein origineller Dichter’ (Jeremias). An examination of how the poet has brought particular word-pictures into dialogue, masterfully interwoven with his own blend of words, suggests otherwise.
The interpretation of the psalm is complicated by its unusual form: it divides into two unequal sections of a very different character, style and form, leading to strong doubts about its original unity. A closer look at the relationships between the words, pictures and their previous conceptual associations will not only shed light on the author’s message but will also suggest an explanation for the psalm’s current structure.
The task of interpreting instances of inner-biblical reception of metaphors in biblical poetry is a complex one. It involves a consideration not only of the ‘mental frames’ evoked by particular words within a ‘word-picture’, and the interactions between these words and pictures within the textual unit, but also of the conceptual associations that such word-pictures bring from their previous literary or liturgical context(s). It then remains to interpret the result of this new constellation of images and their messages. This paper aims to demonstrate the ways in which the author’s re-use of words and pictures from other psalms reveals his reflection on his current situation, and how a blend of modified ‘word-pictures’ from the past has been re-framed to form a unique, distinctive and compelling message of hope.
|
Between Bible and Liturgy: Cyrillona as Exegete in the Memra on the Pasch
Program Unit: Bible and Syriac Studies in Context
Carl Griffin, Brigham Young University
Cyrillona (fl. ca. 396) is one of the earliest Syriac Christian authors whose writing survives and one of the first expositors of the Separated Gospels. Among his five extant works are three paschal poems that explore the sacramental and symbolic significance of the words and acts of Jesus at the Last Supper.
Of these, perhaps the most exegetically striking is Cyrillona’s memra On the Pasch of Our Lord (Pasch). Robert Murray wonders if Pasch “might be called a midrash on John 14-16”—a suggestion worthy of examination. Certainly Pasch contains the earliest substantive Syriac exegesis of key Christological texts from John 12 and 15. But Cyrillona roves far from the Gospel of John in his consideration of Christ’s passion and resurrection, of the endowment of the Holy Spirit, and of the Eucharist.
My paper will examine the exegetical character of Cyrillona’s Pasch and particularly his exploration of the Johannine symbols of the vineshoot and grain of wheat. I will discuss how his symbology is distinctive not only for its length and detail, but for its originality. I will also discuss the probable liturgical context of this memra and it’s importance to the author’s exegesis, transforming Pasch into a true “catechesis in images” (Theodor Bolger).
|
The Role and Function of Sedaqah and Torah in the Introduction to the Book of Isaiah (1:1-2:5)
Program Unit: Israel and the Production and Reception of Authoritative Books in the Persian and Hellenistic Period (EABS)
Alphonso Groenewald, University of Pretoria
The fate of the people of Judah depends upon their hearing and obeying the word of Yahweh and the Torah of God (1:10). The well-being of the city, as well as world peace, can only be realised through obedience to Torah. The fate of the nations is decided by their hearing and obeying the Torah (2:3-4). Judah and the city can be saved from destruction only if they practice justice and righteousness (1:16-17; 27-28). If they do not listen to the Torah, deliverance will be possible only after the bitter experience of disaster (1:24-28). Chapter one leaves us unprepared for the text we encounter in 2:2-4. The idea that the Zion who is described as rebellious, unrighteous and unclean in chapter 1, may be the Zion to which all the nations will stream in order to receive the Torah, seems totally impossible. From this perspective it is no longer disastrous political decisions that provide the central target of prophetic condemnation, but rather an indifference to Torah and righteousness.
|
Metaphors of Purity/Impurity in the Book of Lamentations
Program Unit: Metaphors in the Hebrew Bible/Old Testament and Their Reception
Marianne Grohmann, University of Vienna
This paper focusses on the purity/impurity system as one aspect of the manifold metaphors in the book of Lamentations. It analyzes these metaphors both as aspects of inner-biblical reception of Priestly writings and Ezechiel, and in examples of further interpretation in rabbinic literature and medieval Jewish commentaries.
|
The Expulsion of Ishmael Narrative: Boundaries, Structure, and Meaning
Program Unit: Stylistics and the Hebrew Bible
Jonathan Grossman, Bar-Ilan University
Scholars generally draw a distinction between the story of Ishmael's expulsion in 21:7 (or 8) and the first verses of the chapter, which tell of Isaac's birth (21:2-6 or 7). This division is also related to the accepted notion that Isaac's birth account is attributed to P, while the story of Ishmael's expulsion is considered a non-P source. As a result, few have discussed the overall structure of the chapter. My lecture will propose that chapter 21 in its entirety should be considered a single literary unit (regardless if it is the result of creative redaction or the story in its original form) of a chiastic structure, which generates thematic and linguistic contrast between Isaac's entrance into Abraham's household, and Ishmael's dismissal from it. In light of the narrative's structure, the significance of the double rejection Ishmael experiences will also emerge - for he is first rejected by his father (21:14), and then by his mother (21:15). The doubly abandoned figure is "gathered" anew through the blessing of God, who opens Hagar's eyes (21:19), and thus the narrative can be read as the story of Ishmael's rebirth, one that occurs outside Abraham's household. I will present the story's structure as a springboard for its objectives and its place within the Abraham Cycle.
|
Pig Bones and the End of Iron Age Israelite Ethnicity
Program Unit: Anthropology and the Bible (EABS)
Philippe Guillaume, Universität Bern - Université de Berne
Pork consumption by the Philistines has long been identified as the origin of the biblical taboo.
Other traits such as undecorated pottery, four-room pillared houses and collared-rim jars are
reluctantly abandoned as ethnic markers of an Proto-Israelite ethnicity in the Iron Age I. The
difference in the proportion of pig bones retrieved from Israelite and ‘Philistine’ sites represents the
last clue for the existence of a distinct Israelite identity before the campaign of Pharaoh Shishak in
the Levant, but a recent article by L. Sapir-Hen, G. Bar-Oz, Y. Gadot and I. Finkelstein in ZDPV 129 (2013) rings the death bell for this last marker of proto-Israelite identity. This contribution offers a comprehensive multicausal scenario for the emergence of the pork taboo in Persian Yehud which renders the notion of ethnic boundaries in previous periods irrelevant, although there are good reasons to expect the search for an Israelite ethnicity in the Iron Age to
continue unabated.
|
Comparing the Syriac and Arabic Chronicles of Barhebraeus: The Question of Intended Audiences
Program Unit: Bible and Syriac Studies in Context
Dibo Habbabe, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
In the Middle Ages especially, historiography was a significant literary genre in Syriac. The thirteenth-century Syriac writer Barhebraeus composed three sizeable chronicles: two in Syriac, one dealing with secular, and one with ecclesiastical history, and one on secular history in Arabic. The secular chronicles extent from the beginnings of humankind to the thirteenth century. In the estimation of some, Barhebraeus composed his chronicle at the request of Muslim scholars of Maragheh, the capital of the Mongol Empire, where Barhebraeus spent his last days. Others think, Muslim scholars had asked him to translate his Syriac chronicle in order to provide speakers of Arabic with access to the historical information his Syriac work offered. A thorough review of the chronicles in both languages reveals numerous differences with regard to their informational value. For some, the differences in content of the Arabic text are due to differences in the intended audience. The Syriac chronicle may have been composed for a Christian audience with language skills in Syriac, while the Arabic one may have been composed for Muslim readers. Other scholars emphasize instead the considerable influence exercised by the different sources that entered into the compositions. Based on a comparative method of research, this paper asks why Barhebraeus did not include more of the information of the Syriac chronicle in the Arabic one, especially concerning the political and social evolution of Eastern Christian communities. Did he change his method because of the changes in intended audiences? Is the Arabic chronicle indeed a “review” of the Syriac one? In this way, the paper contributes to deepening our insights into the history of the Eastern Christian churches, especially during Barhebraeus’ own period, which was marked decisively by the end of the crusades and the beginning of a new wave of Asian invasions.
|
Reception of Jewish Scripture in Graeco-Roman Egypt: The Papyrological Evidence
Program Unit: Reception History of Jewish Scriptures in Graeco-Roman Egypt
Noah Hacham, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
More than 50 Jewish papyri from Graeco-Roman Egypt contain biblical texts - most in Greek, few in Hebrew. This lecture will present them, and characterize broad aspects of the various conclusions that can be drawn from these findings. This presentation is part of a research project "A collection of texts on Jews and Judaism on perishable material from Egypt: 530 BCE to 650 CE" conducted by Prof. Tal Ilan and Noah Hacham.
|
Reception of Scripture in Second Temple Diaspora Literature
Program Unit: Reception of Scripture in Second Temple Literature
Noah Hacham, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
The paper will deal with the following questions: Which books of the Bible were known to Diaspora Judaism of Second Temple period? Was their Scripture similar to that of the Jews of the motherland? Can we know what kind or degree of holiness they ascribed to both the original Hebrew text and the translated text? How did they use and interpret them? Was written Scripture their basis of authority?
|
Eve: The Prophetess Who Wasn't There
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Zohar Hadromi-Allouche, University of Aberdeen
Several female prophets are mentioned in the Bible. Hardly any of these is acknowledged by medieval Islamic sources as such. At the same time, Muslim tradition recognizes some other women as prophetess. Perhaps most intriguing of these is Eve, the first woman. Eve is often presented in Jewish, Christian and Muslim sources in a negative light, as a temptress and cause of the expulsion from Paradise. While her image in medieval Islamic sources is more complex that that, still one wonders how did this unique Islamic view of Eve emerge?
I argue that this was the result of developments concerning matters which did not relate directly to Eve as a character in Islam, and/ or were not necessarily intended to glorify Eve's image. These matters include, for example, (a) theological discussions regarding the definition of a true prophet, (b) inter-religious polemics and even (c) limiting women to the domestic sphere.
My paper will trace the emergence in Islam of the idea of feminine prophecy, and how themes such as the above have led to the emergence in Islam of Eve and other women as prophetesses. At the same time, it will also consider to what extent the emergence in Islam of this idea has contributed towards a more flexible image of Eve and other women.
|
Constituting the Sense of Community in the Post-Exilic Period
Program Unit: Israel and the Production and Reception of Authoritative Books in the Persian and Hellenistic Period (EABS)
Maria Haeusl, Technische Universität Dresden
The paper examines parts of the theological discourse in post-exilic Israel, and compares which resources are used in order to constitute the sense of the community. Biblical texts from the post-exilic period show that Torah is highly relevant for legitimating the sense of community in this time. But the sense of community is not exclusively based on and transmitted by the Torah. Especially the late texts of Isaiah do not refer to Torah but use other figures to constitute the sense of community. The paper will compare Torah-orientated texts and non-Torah-orientated texts.
|
The Biblical Laws of Asylum between Mediterraneanism and Postcolonial Critique
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Law
Anselm C. Hagedorn, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin - Humboldt University of Berlin
The paper investigates the international context of biblical law by looking at the stipulations regulating asylum (Exod 21:12-17; Deut 19:1-13) and comparing them with Greek legal inscriptions (e.g. IC IV 41, IV.6-10; IC IV 72 I.39-44; IG VII 4251). It will be shown that the biblical concept is closer to Mediterranean regulations than to ancient Near Eastern concepts so that it might be possible to integrate the biblical legislation into a Mediterranean legal koiné. In a further step the ancient concepts from Greece and the Hebrew Bible are subjected to a postcolonial critique investigating whether the ancient laws of asylum can contribute to the current discourse about migration and asylum.
|
Participation by Faith: An Exegetical Examination of 1 Corinthians
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Jeanette Hagen, University of Durham
Despite the growing consensus that participation, rather than justification by faith, is the centre of Paul’s theology, there remains a lively debate which has generated additional questions such as: how to interpret the genitive construction pistis christou, and how do we understand divine and human agency? In each of these debates, the crucial question is: What does Paul mean by faith? Yet, this is the question that has been either overlooked, too narrowly focused (e.g. the question of pistis christou), or misconstrued. It is the aim of this paper to refocus these debated issues around the central question of what Paul means by faith, as well as explicating how faith connects a believer to Christ. Examining 1 Corinthians (thus taking the discussions outside the contested terrain of Galatians, Philippians and Romans), I will show the parallels between 'believing' and 'boasting' (1 Cor 1-2), and the combination of subjective and objective aspects of faith (1 Cor 15). Faith is here shown to be an active, self-involving dependence on Christ, and thus common to both justification and participation in Christ. Questions of agency find resolution in that while faith is shown to be a self-involving, active response, it is not an independent operative power within the believer; the power of God always precedes the faith by which one subjects oneself in a fully dependent relationship to Christ. It will furthermore be shown that the objective genitive reading of pistis christou corresponds with what Paul means by faith in the broader context of his theology.
|
Discussing the Future of SBL IM Synoptic Gospels Section
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Sakari Hakkinen, Diocese of Kuopio, Finland
Welcome to an open discussion concerning the future themes of the SBL International Meeting Synoptic Gospels Section. In the next years we plan to have one or two special sessions dedicated to themes suggested by the participants. So far disability and/or healing has been proposed. What do you think of this theme? Do you have plans to do research on healing in the Synoptics or some theme close to it? What themes are you interested in? Join us for the discussion and tell us about your own research plans on the Synoptic Gospels.
|
Wisdom vs. Happiness in Ben Sira
Program Unit: Bible in Eastern and Oriental Orthodox Traditions
Garegin Hambardzumyan, University of Sheffield
In this paper Garegin Hambardzumyan elaborates on the main subjects of the Book of Sirach. The scope of Sirach is very broad. It covers a large variety of topics, including exhortations on prudence and self discipline (chs. 18-23), praise of wisdom (ch. 24), biographical narratives about the ancestors of Israel (chs. 44-50), etc.. There have been many disputes in regards to the most important theme of this wisdom book. Some have said that Ben Sira singles out wisdom as the primary subject of his book, others in contrary argued that it is rather the fear of the lord that stands as the key theme of Ben Sira. This paper presents a fresh approach to the study of this book asserting that happiness is the most fundamental theme of Ben Sira. For the examination of this matter Rev. Hambardzumyan uses as his main reference Yakob Nalean’s commentary (18th c.), in particular the chapters which discuss the above mentioned issues.
|
The oldest inscription in Aramaic Script in Switzerland?
Program Unit: Archaeology and Diaspora Judaism
David Hamidovic, Université de Lausanne
A graffito on wall plaster has been discovered during a salvage excavation (June-August 2011) on the shores of Lake Geneva in Nyon (VD), Switzerland. The wall plaster in red-ocher is common to the Roman discoveries of old Nyon, the Roman colony named Noviodumum. The inscription does not seem to be a Latin inscription. It may be Aramaic cursive letters. The close comparison with other Hebrew and Aramaic inscriptions may give a palaeographical date: 1st-2nd century CE. But several hypotheses of decipherment are available. If this identification is right, it would be the oldest inscription in Aramaic script discovered in Switzerland.
|
Reading Ezek 36:16-38 in light of the Book
Program Unit: Prophets
Tobias Häner, Universität Augsburg
Reading Ezekiel 36.16-38 in Light of the Book
|
Philia as Agape: The Theme of Friendship in the Gospel of John
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Takaaki Haraguchi, Tohoku Gakuin University
The theme of friendship plays an important role in John. In the whole narrative, the verb phileo occurs 13 times. In NT the verb agapao is usually employed to express the idea of love. In John 5:20; 16:27; 20:2 agapao and phileo are used interchangeably.
In the Farewell Discourse Jesus teaches his disciples that the highest form of love is to lay down one’s own life for his friends (15:13). The ideal friendship to die for one’s friends is cited as an illustration of true love.
In the dialogue between the risen Lord and Peter by Lake Galilee Christ asks him three times if he loves him. In the first two questions Jesus uses the verb agapao (21:15, 16), while he uses phileo in the third question (21:17). Peter responds in the affirmative, using phileo each time (21:15, 16; 21:17). Here phileo and agapao are used interchangeably, for the highest form of friendship is equal to self-sacrificing love.
This peculiar emphasis on friendship was understandable in the situation the John’s community was placed in. After the resurrection and ascension of Jesus the community was left behind in the hostile world. Those who professed Jesus as Messiah had been expelled from synagogues (9:22, 34; 16:2). Those abiding in Jesus (13:1; 15:9-10) were hated by the world (15:18-19). They were persecuted by the Jewish majority (15:20-21). The solidarity among the believers was crucially important in this situation. The community members were reminded by the Spirit of truth (15:17, 26; 16:13) to keep the Commandment to love one another by laying down their own life on their brothers’ behalf (13:34-35; 15:13-17).
|
Arousing Emotions to Decenter the Self: Ancient and Contemporary Selves
Program Unit: Emotions and the Biblical World (EABS)
Angela Kim Harkins, Fairfield University
Emotions are strategically aroused during the performance of various religious practices that trigger a decentering process. In this state of liminality in which cognitive processes are suspended, the individual enters into a heightened state of receptivity that allows for transformative processes to take place. This study examines the instrumental role that emotions play in the practice of Jewish penitential prayer in light of contemporary models of the embodied mind that seek to understand the phenomenon of religious experience from a neuroscience perspective. Modern approaches to religion that use bio-cultural models tend to presume and prioritize the palliative and therapeutic effects of religion, but ancient experiences of religion do not manifest the same concerns. The growing body of literature examining religion and contemporary studies of cognitive processes shows a marked orientation to understanding the decentering processes that underlie the cultivation of the self, understood distinctly as an agentive self in a modern context. This study is interested in exploring the distinct limitations of the heuristic models of the self and subjectivity that contemporary neuroscience offers to scholars of ancient Judaism.
|
Paul and the Ambiguities of Graeco-Roman Honorific Culture: Intersections of the Inscriptional, Iconographic, and Monumental Evidence
Program Unit: Pauline Literature (EABS)
James R. Harrison, Sydney College of Divinity
The paper explores the difficulties of penetrating the dynamics of the reciprocation of honour in the Roman Empire. Whether it was Roman rule of the barbarians in the Latin West, the ruler’s handling of public challenges to his honour, or competition between the local elites in the Greek East, the rituals of ‘honour’ and ‘dishonour’ were subtle and complex. Such studies give us acute insight into the agonistic culture of the first-century AD and the social problems that the apostle Paul faced in redefining for his converts the operations of reciprocity, boasting in ancestral and personal achievement, and handling social dishonor.
However, in coming to grips with the ambiguities of Graeco-Roman honor, attention must be paid to the interaction and interrelation between the inscription and the iconography of the monument, as well as its place within the city’s sacred space. Honorific inscriptions also should understood within the dominant eulogistic conventions of the day if social historians are to fathom what might make the inscription distinctive and historically revealing, as opposed to stereotypical.
Three case studies spanning the Latin West and the Greek East will be investigated:
(a) the triumphal inscriptions, monuments, and iconography of the Romans at La Turbie (Monaco, France) and Susa (south of Turin, Italy) involving barbarian conquests and treaties;
(b) the inscription of Cornelius Gallus at Philae (Egypt), and its relation to the Augustan obelisks at Rome and Julian boasting culture;
(c) the ‘honour’ and ‘dishonor’ of the epigram accorded to Nikias, an agonothetes, by his fellow officials at Isthmia.
The paper argues that these documentary texts throw light on Paul’s understanding of ethnic relations and the ‘indebtedness of love’ to the socially marginalised, his teaching on justification and glory in a Gentile context, and the role of ‘honour’ and ‘dishonor’ in the believer’s life.
|
Circumcision as Marital Boundary Marker: Male and Female Jewish Identity in Egypt
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Rebecca Harrocks, King's College - London
James Dunn’s landmark 1982 lecture on the New Perspective on Paul marked a fresh consideration of the traditional Jewish customs of Sabbath observance, circumcision and food regulations, in that they now came to be regarded in terms of Jewish ‘boundary’ or ‘identity’ markers, delineating the people of God socially and religiously. Nowhere were these boundary markers more significant for Jewish identity than in the Diaspora.
Circumcision played a crucial role in the maintenance of the Jewish community boundary. Not only did it act as the final barrier between the status of God-fearer and full proselyte for men, but it marked with whom a Jewish woman was permitted to procreate, in order to maintain the purity of her people. Therefore, circumcision was not only a boundary marker for male Jews, but also for female Jews, an aspect which is not often considered.
My paper will consider the significant role which circumcision played in maintaining Jewish identity by investigating its role in intermarriage, with focus on the Jewish community at Alexandria from 323 BCE to 117 CE. Not only is this the Diaspora Jewish community from which we have the greatest amount of surviving evidence, but Egypt was associated with circumcision to a degree second only to Israel: circumcision was practiced by some Egyptians, though for different and uncertain reasons, and some even believed that the practice originated in Egypt.
This paper will provide an exploration of how circumcision contributed to both male and female Jewish identity in a significant Diaspora community during the period in which the early Church emerged. Both the rarity of intermarriage and the usual requirement of circumcision for Gentile men marrying Jewish women emphasise the indivisibility of circumcision and Jewish self-identity.
|
The Question of the Prologue’s Unity and Integrity: Historical Arguments and a New Approach
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Stan Harstine, Friends University
One of the classical concerns for Johannine studies since A. von Harnack’s 1892 article has been the unity and integrity of the Prologue. This paper first describes the parameters of the historical discussion identifying eight categories where scholarship has focused arguments on this question. This historical research provides the foundation for the second segment of the paper, proposing a new methodological model for this question; one that incorporates suggestions made by many scholars but thus far pursued by none–the relationship between the themes presented within the Prologue and their function within the text of the Gospel. The third segment describes this new method of reading, which I call the Helical Method, based on a synchronic approach to the text. This two-prong method examines eight individual themes from the Prologue as they develop within the text and whether the intersection of these various themes amplifies segments of the Gospel. The final segment of the paper examines one of these themes to demonstrate how a theme can attract additional meaning and attention in its appearances throughout the Gospel. This study in textual readings and oral presentation techniques is designed to address Harnack’s proposal and determine whether the Prologue functions as an interpretive guide for the larger text of the Gospel.
|
Iconicity of the Psalms
Program Unit: Metaphors in the Hebrew Bible/Old Testament and Their Reception
Friedhelm Hartenstein, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
The paper focuses on the interaction between exegetical and iconographical methods for a better understanding of the pictorial language of the Psalms. It starts with an evaluation of the two poles of the metaphorical process in cultural symbolism (following an often overlooked key text from Paul Ricœur): The „living“ metaphor (semantical innovation) on the one hand, and the symbol on the other hand (as a conventional metaphor rebound to a broader symbolic system). The paper thus demonstrates how the cosmological symbolism of temple and world, life and death, is forming the basic conceptual background for most of the Psalms (examples from Ps 72; 126; 27; 65; 36; 63; 17; 88). It shows further that within this framework God as king is a central or a a root metaphor expressing relations between YHWH and men. Notions like „seeing the face of God“, „searching shelter“ in his vicinity, „nourishing the soul/life“ with fullness and benevolence near YHWH are all part of one spatially structured imagery of the enthroned God in his residence. Ancient Near Eastern pictures help a lot to gain a better understanding of the images involved. Finally the paper asks how semantic innovation is to be described within this context of metaphors grounded in the worldview of temple symbolism. Psalms in this respect could be read as generating – within their specific limits – a remarkable broad imagery between creative poetry and conventional prayer.
|
The Martyrdom of Polycarp: A ‘Martyrdom according to the Gospel' beyond an Imitation of the Christ of the Gospels
Program Unit: Biblical Interpretation in Early Christianity
Paul Hartog, Faith Baptist Theological Seminary
Traditionally, when scholars have interpreted the Christological themes embedded within the Martyrdom of Polycarp, they have emphasized Jesus Christ as a martyrological example to be followed. This approach is rooted in the phrase “a martyrdom according to the Gospel” (Mart. Pol. 1.1; 4.1; 19.1; 22.1) and has led to collecting numerous parallels with the Gospel passion narratives. For example, Polycarp enjoyed a last supper before his arrest on the “day of preparation,” was betrayed by a household member, was interrogated by a “Herod,” entered town on a donkey, etc. No doubt, a mimetic theme of imitatio Christi courses its way through the Martyrdom. But there are other Christological strands that weave their way throughout the Polycarpian account, and some of them echo biblical imagery beyond the Gospel narraties. Various Christological titles include Lord, Christ, Son, Teacher, King, Master, Savior, Shepherd, and Eternal High Priest. The King (9.3; 17.3; 21) superintends all events, and the Lord specifically chooses those who suffer and are martyred according to God’s will (20.1; cf. 2.1; 7.1; 14.2; 15.1) and sovereign design (6.2; 12.3). The narrative expressly refers to those who are “elect,” a notion connected not only with those divinely chosen for salvation (16.1-2; 22.1; 22.3) but also those divinely chosen for martyrdom (20.1; cf. 6.2; 14.2). In this paradigm, Jesus Christ is not merely the object whom the believer intentionally follows (by imitating Gospel details), but he is also the subject who directs all human affairs (18.3), including martyrdom (14.2). Trust in this Christologically-focused sovereignty helps form a distinctive sense of “nobility” and composure within the narrative (2.1; 2.2; 3.1; 3.2) and stands in contrast with the approach of Quintus in chapter 4.
|
Inconsistency in Pesher and Hypomnema
Program Unit: Reception of Scripture in Second Temple Literature
Pieter (Barry) Hartog, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
Inconsistency is a major trigger for interpretation, and it is not surprising that ancient commentators directed much effort to its explanation (as do their modern colleagues). Broadly defining inconsistency as “contradictions in the base text as perceived by the commentator,” I offer some comparative insights into the explanation of inconsistency in the Qumran Pesharim and Greek hypomnemata on Homer’s Iliad.
First, I discuss the role of the commentator, arguing that inconsistency is not an objective characteristic of a text, but is determined by the commentator and his assumptions about the text and its meaning. Second, I introduce the principles for dealing with inconsistency in the Iliad hypomnemata (athetesis, literary critical principles) and the Pesharim (atomization and re-contextualization). Third, I offer some conclusions, referring to Philo along the way, and try to contextualize those within the broader framework of recent comparative studies of the Pesharim and the Greek tradition of commentary writing.
|
‘Jewish-Sufi Dialogues’ in Ayyubid and Early Mamluk Cairo? The Maimonidean ‘Way of Piety’ and the Mystical Tradition of Islam
Program Unit: Quran and Islamic Tradition in Comparative Perspective
Dirk Hartwig, University of St. Andrews
The philosophical works of Moses Maimonides (d. 1204) have already been successfully contextualized with the preceding Jewish, Christian, and Islamic traditions (cf., e.g.. H.A. Davidson, J.L. Kraemer, S. Stroumsa, O. Leaman, K. Seeskin, A.L. Ivry). However, the mystical treatises of Maimonides’ descendants, all written in Judeo-Arabic, have not been studied with comparable diligence. Yet, previous scholarship has argued convincingly that there has been intellectual exchange between the Islamic mystical tradition (Sufism) and what seems to be its Jewish coinage, which flourished mainly under Maimonidean patronage. While Sufi tendencies in these Maimonidean works, especially "The High Ways of Perfection" by Abraham Maimonides, have been repeatedly mentioned by scholars of the Jewish mystical tradition, most notably Gershom G. Scholem, scholars have not considered these Jewish pietistic-mystical texts to be part of the intellectual legacy of Sufism. In light of the interior and exterior transformation process and the complex interdependence of Judaism and Islam, the proposed paper will deal with the terminology describing this Pietist movement which "was not a marginal sect, for it enjoyed widespread popularity under the leadership of the greatest political and religious figure of the time, Abraham [Maimonides])" (P. Fenton). A more specific question to be dealt with in order to address uncertainties about the cultural/religious identity of this pietist group is to what extent it is appropriate to speak of this specific form of Jewish mysticism as "Sufi-like mysticism" (e.g. E.R. Wolfson, C. Sirat), "Jewish piety of the Sufi-type" (e.g. S.D. Goitein, M. Loubet), "Jewish Sufi-Dialogue" (e.g. D. Lobel), or even more nuanced as "Jewish Sufism" (E.P. Fishbane, P.S. Alexander, P.B. Fenton, N. Ilan, N.Ch. Hofer).
|
Whose World? Whose Time? A Text World Theory Examination of the Style and Message of Gen 1:1–2:25
Program Unit: Stylistics and the Hebrew Bible
Elizabeth Hayes, Fuller Theological Seminary (Pasadena)
This study is both a response and homage to Paul Werth and his imaginatively titled 1995 essay, "How to Build a World (in a lot less than six days, and using only what is in your head)". The ‘world-building’ creation accounts in Genesis 1.1-2.25 are one of the most examined and beloved sections of the Hebrew bible, thus this section is a good choice for an analysis using Werth’s categories and method. Questions addressed include, “How does the reader navigate through the text?” and “What is the nature of the conceptual ‘world’ that is built up as the text is read?” In this study, the paired narrations are examined for ‘World Builders’ (time, location, characters and objects), ‘Function Advancing Propositions’ (event processes, relational processes and mental processes), and ‘Sub Worlds’ (those worlds create by modal shifts and terms from the semantic fields of seeing, hearing and knowing). Further insights are gleaned from the work of Peter Stockwell (Cognitive Poetics) and Joanna Gavins (Text World Theory). Werth’s conceptually based Text World theory is both broad enough to encompass cognitive linguistics and conceptual blending, yet narrow enough to create a succinct account of the text of Genesis 1.1-2.25. While such a study will not solve theological dilemmas, it will provide insight into the intersection between stylistics and meaning, revealing contours of the text and message.
|
Scripture Proclaimed the Gospel Beforehand: Apocalyptic Hermeneutics in Paul’s Letter to the Galatians
Program Unit: Schriftrezeption bei Paulus und in der Paulustradition: Reception of Scripture in Paul and Pauline Tradition
Richard B. Hays, Duke University
Trotz der berechtigten Aufmerksamkeit für die Situation in den galatischen Gemeinden müssen, ausgehend von den theologischen Aussagen im Präskript, gerade auch die konstruktiven hermeneutischen Grundannahmen und Methoden ermittelt werden, die den paulinischen Schriftgebrauch in diesem Brief bestimmen. Auswahl, Auslegung und Verwendung der zitierten Schriftworte lassen dabei auf ein apokalyptisch geprägtes Schriftverständnis schließen.
|
Joseph in the Syriac Tradition: The Character of the Sources
Program Unit: Bible and Syriac Studies in Context
Kristian Heal, Brigham Young University
Over a dozen Syriac texts from late antiquity retell the story of Joseph in whole or in part. In this paper I discuss the character of these sources, including their relationship to the Peshitta, inter-textuality, generic features, exegetical approaches, narrativity, treatment of characters, and literary style. Through this exposition it will not only be possible to better appreciate the variety and consistency of the Syriac Joseph sources, but also to more clearly view them in relation to other late antique treatments of Joseph in Jewish, Christian and Islamic sources.
|
The Syriac Corpus and Syriac Studies
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical Studies, Early Jewish and Christian Studies (EABS)
Kristian Heal, Brigham Young University
The BYU-Oxford Syriac Corpus project aims to assemble and annotate a comprehensive corpus of Syriac literature. Thus far, over seven hundred texts comprising six million words have been added to the corpus. However, before the project is completed, many thousands of additional texts, comprising tens of millions of words, need to be added to the corpus; and these texts then need to be proofed, linked to a dictionary, and grammatically analyzed. This paper seeks to answer the question of how this (and similar large-scale corpus projects) can be utilized by researchers while in preparation. In particular, the paper will discuss how existing digital humanities text analysis tools can be utilized to conduct research in historical linguistics, lexicography, history of ideas, prosopography, historiography, biblical studies, inter-textual studies, and authorship studies.
|
The Aaronic Blessing (Numbers 6): Its Intention and Place in the Concept of the Pentateuch
Program Unit: Persian Period
Raik Heckl, Universität Leipzig
The paper shows how the Aaronic Blessing of Num 6 can be seen as a step on the way to the canonization of the Torah. The text witnesses like almost no other how the priestly theology intended an answer to the deuteronomical and deuteronomistic concepts. It will be described how these last authors of the Pentateuchal composition aimed at a theological synthesis of traditional religion and different theological tendencies in order to create a document that could be most acceptable in Ancient Judaism.
|
"Behold King Solomon . . ." Traces of Reception-History within the Song of Songs?
Program Unit: The Song of Songs: Literal or Allegorical?
Nina-Sophie Heereman, Ecole Biblique
What is King Solomon doing in the Song of Song? Not only is the Song fictionally attributed to King Solomon, he also features several times within the work. Modern exegesis has offered three basic explanations: 1) H. Ewald’s Hirtenhypothese or Love-Triangle, which sees King Solomon as an intruder into the romantic and faithful love of a shepherd girl and her shepherd boy; 2) K. Budde’s theory (based on W.G. Wetzstein’s Syrische Dreschtafel) of an upwards or downwards travesty as part of a marriage festivity rite (or, in another form, on the model of Greek bucolic); or 3) a Solomonic allegorizing redaction (O. Loretz; W. Rudolph), in which all mentions of the fabulous King are seen as glosses to be deleted from the “original" text. The Love-triangle theory has largely been abandoned. The travesty theory, it will be argued, lacks historical credibility. If an allegorizer has therefore been at work, then these “glosses” or insertions must be treated as signs of inner-biblical exegesis and interpreted accordingly. In line with M. Fishbane’s work, which emphasizes that the movement from traditio (handing down) to interpretation of the traditio begins within the Scriptures (i.e. inner-biblical exegesis, re-written Bible, Fortschreibung, etc.), it will be argued that the appearance of Solomon in the Song has to be read in the light of the pre-existent, written traditum of Israel. As such the ascription of the Song of Songs to King Solomon might already be witness to inner-biblical reception history.
|
The Husband’s or Father’s Authority to Annul His Wife’s or Daughter’s Vows: CD XVI:6–12; 4Q416 (4QInstrb) 2 IV:6–11 and 11Q19 (11Q Temple-a) LIII:16 – LIV:3
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Paul Heger, University of Toronto
Before approaching the interpretation of the CD rule, seemingly conflicting with the other two writings, the study analyzes meticulously the relevant biblical verses, their common foundation, with particular attention to the different meanings and functions of the terms (both in Hebrew) ??? “vow” and ???? “oath.” Whereas “vow” relates, according to my understanding of the biblical rule, to positive commitments, namely to do something, “oath or pledge” relates to negative commitments, namely to avoid doing something. The rabbis, however, claim that both terms are employed for negative and positive commitments; their differentiation relates to the manner of pronouncing either of them, and establishes the efficacy or ineffectiveness of the expressed commitment. The study affirms that the Qumran writings adhere to the simple meaning of the biblical text.
The conscientious analysis of the CD text demonstrates that it is not in conflict with the other writings, since the limitation of the husband’s authority to annul his wife’s oath in vv. 10-12 does not relate to ????? ??? ?? ????? Torah decrees, as are vv. 8-9, but to specific ????? ???? rules of the Community’s Covenant, to which women may or may not be obligated. Logical considerations supported by other rules substantiate the proposition.
|
Why the Ethiopic Bible Is Not a “Minor Version”
Program Unit: Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha
Martin Heide, Philipps-Universität Marburg
Why the Ethiopic Bible is not a “Minor Version”
|
Religiöse Traditionen in der Judenfeindschaft der Neuzeit
Program Unit: Anti-Semitic Readings of the Bible
Johannes Heil, Hochschule für Jüdische Studien
Dass die mittelalterliche Judenfeindschaft wesentlich religiös geprägt war und die christliche Exegese der Bibel dabei einen bestimmenden Anteil hatte, steht ausser Zweifel. Diskutieren mag man über den Anteil und die Rolle anderer Faktoren wie Politik, Gesellschaft und Wirtschaft. Der Vortrag befaßt sich mit der Langzeitwirkung der mittelalterlichen Gemengelage. Angesichts der in der Neuzeit voranschreitenden Prozesse von Entsakraliserung und Säkularisierung stellt sich die Frage nach der religiösen Prägung von Judenfeindschaft nach 1500. Dabei werden zwei gegenläufoge Punkte besonders profiliert: Die Radikaliserung von Judenfeindschaft durch den Wegfall unmittelbar religiöser Momente einerseits und die strukturell religiöse Anlage von judenfeindlichen Denkformen wie Wagners "Erlösungsanisemitismus" oder der "Protokolle der Weisen von Zion" andererseits.
|
Leitwörter and Rhetorical Trajectories in Psalms 42–49
Program Unit: Writings (including Psalms)
Samuel Hildebrandt, University of Edinburgh
Over the last decades, both rhetorical criticism and interpsalmic exegesis have established themselves as vital strategies in the interpretation of the Psalms. My paper combines these two approaches and demonstrates that structures of persuasion exist not only within the discourse of individual psalms, but also among adjacent poems. As part of a larger project which seeks to outline the rhetorical shape and function of Pss 42-49, I will focus here on three particular Leitwörter which serve both to unify the collection and to advance its rhetorical purpose. These reoccurring lemmata are ydh (Pss 42/43, 44, 45), ?r? (Pss 46, 47, 48), and yr? (Pss 46, 47, 49).
Interpsalmic exegesis has been criticized for over-reading thematic or semantic links and for attributing too much significance to what could simply be a coincidence in the arrangment of the Psalter. What is needed, therefore, is not only to identify such links, but also to demonstrate their potential significance. This evaluation must be performed first within the boundaries of their own composition and only in a second step within the discourse that emerges between adjacent poems. As a model for this procedure, my paper begins by situating and assessesing these three Leitwörter within their respective compositions. As I will argue, all three are crucial in their own poems, as indicated, for instance, by their frequency and placement. Moving toward a unified reading of Pss 42-49, I will proceed from this evidence and demonstrate the ways in which these lemmata connect and progress these seven poems rhetorically. Since many studies and commentaries stop at the identification of these semantic connections, the rhetorical interplay and function of these Leitwörter has been overlooked thus far.
|
The Indirections of Quoted Speech in the Rhetoric of Jer 6:16-21
Program Unit: Literary Features – Fact or Fiction (EABS)
Samuel Hildebrandt, University of Edinburgh
While there are many studies on the phenomenon of quoted speech in prophetic texts, no effort has been made to integrate insights from quotation theory into the discussion. Since the quoted words of people, kings, and prophets are commonly taken to offer direct access to what these audience members actually said and believed, most of the scholarly attention has been devoted to the socio-historical dimensions behind the text. As a result, the device of quoted speech has not been analyzed for its own sake or on its own terms but primarily in the service of other interests, such as the study of prophetic conflict or popular theology.
In this paper I argue that the use of quoted speech as an avenue to the mind of the prophetic audience rests on a misunderstanding of what quotation is and what questions it is capable of answering. Properly understood, quoted speech is an inherently context-bound device which consists of a subordinate inset and a governing frame. While the inset appears to offer a syntactically and deictically independent reproduction of “what the people really said,” and while traditional grammars have fostered the strictures of this one-to-one correspondence between form and function, in reality, the hierarchies in the frame-inset relationship constitute an intricate guise for authorial montage and manipulation. Hidden beneath the conventional conception of objective reporting, authors “frame” not only their quoted subjects, but also their audiences to whom they direct these strategic speech events. Drawing from the work of M. Sternberg, G. Lane-Mercier, and D. Tannen, this paper unpacks the mechanics of indirection which govern quoted speech and demonstrates its usefulness for rhetorical, polemical, and ideological strategies. As a practical complement, these insights are applied to the quoted speech in Jer 6.16-21.
|
The Appropriate Leader: A Biographical-Narrative Reading of Matt 3:1–4:11
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Daniel Hjort, Lund University
The influential scholar Ulrich Luz rejects the view of the Gospel of Matthew as an ancient biography, since he does not find any information about the education or the development of Jesus in the narrative from chapter 3. This conclusion does not give a fair description of neither ancient biographies in general nor the Gospel of Matthew in particular. Matthew actually deals with the development of Jesus and picks up an important theme in ancient Greek biographical writing.
This gospel gives a portrait of Jesus Christ, who is the good leader of Israel (2.6, 9.36, 23.10). A biographical-narrative reading of Matthew, which takes the biographical genre seriously and pays attention to the narrative development of the story, sheds light on the presentation of Jesus as a good leader. In ancient Greek biographies which give portraits of a good leader the education of the protagonist is sometimes underlined (e.g. Philo’s Moses and Plutarch’s Numa) and sometimes lacking (e.g. Isocrates’ Evagoras and Xenophon’s Agesilaus). The important theme in ancient biographies seems to be to show the reader that the leader was prepared and appropriate for the leadership position, because of his virtues. This is exactly what we find in the section of Matthew’s story between the birth of Jesus and the beginning of his public career. In 3.1–4.11 the author shows the reader that Jesus has virtues such as righteousness, obedience, and self-control. This section also underlines the preparation of Jesus through the influence from John the Baptist and the empowerment of the Spirit. In this way the Gospel of Matthew conforms to ancient Greek biographical writing, though from a Jewish perspective, when it deals with the preparation of Jesus for his leadership and underlines his virtues before he begins his ministry.
|
"Micah the Morashtite was prophesying in the days of Hezekiah . . ." (Jer 26:18): The Redaction of the Books Jeremiah and Micah
Program Unit: Prophets
Yair Hoffman, Tel Aviv University
In the story of Jeremiah's trial, Jer. 26, the prophet "Micah The Morashtite" is mentioned, and the elders quote a specific prophecy ascribed to him, which is found indeed in The Book of Micah: "Zion shall be plowed a field and Jerusalem shall become a heap of ruins and the Mount of the House a forest heights" (Jer. 26:18; Mi. 3:12). This is a unique phenomenon, since in no other prophetic book a fellow prophet is mentioned by name and quoted nearly literally. Hence, this occurrence raises some questions, such as: Were the elders, or the author, or yet a later editor of the story familiar with all the prophecies of Micah? Or just with this prophecy? Did any of them have a written or an oral text of this prophecy? I'll examine these questions, showing that none of the options they suggest provides a satisfactory answer to them. Consequently, the following new option would be examined, which could elucidate more adequately this phenomenon: It was a deuteronomistic editor who appended this prophecy to both books, Jeremiah and Micah,
|
Uriel Birnbaum "In Gottes Krieg"
Program Unit: Reception of the Bible in the Sign of World War One
Daniel Hoffmann, Heinrich-Heine-Universität Düsseldorf
Uriel Birnbaum 1921 in Wien erschienenes Buch In Gottes Krieg ist ein frühes Zeugnis für eine moderne jüdische Kunst, die in der Auseinandersetzung mit der Moderne im biblischen Judentum neuen künstlerischen Ausdruck sucht. In 240 Sonetten deutet er das Erlebnis des Ersten Weltkriegs als Gericht Gottes. Anders als bei den Expressionisten zerfällt für ihn die grauenvolle Wirklichkeit des Krieges nicht in fragmentarische Verse, sondern er baut in der strengen Form des Sonetts eine Einsicht von der wirkenden Gegenwart Gottes im Krieg auf. Das Motto aus dem Prophetenbuch Jona, geworfen zu sein in das Herz der Meere, verleiht durch seine Anspielung auf die Rettung Israels am Roten Meer die Zuversicht, dass das Gericht ein rettendes sein wird. Aus dem lyrischen Werk wird so eine religiöse Botschaft.
Uriel Birnbaum "In God's war", 1921 published in Vienna, is an early reference to modern Jewish art, which searches new artistic expression in its engagement with modernity in biblical Judaism. In 240 sonnets Birnbaum interprets the experience of the First World War as a judgment of God. Unlike the expressionists he does not decompose the horrible reality of war in fragmentary verses. In the strict form of the sonnet he is building an insight of the presence of God acting in the war on. The motto of the prophet Jonah, to be thrown into the heart of the seas, gives in its allusion to the salvation of Israel at the Red Sea the confidence that the judgment will be a saving one. It is a religious message that emerges from the lyrical work.
|
The Man Whom Sorrow Named His Friend: Jeremiah and the Weeping God
Program Unit: Emotions and the Biblical World (EABS)
Jack Holloway, Regent University
The book of Jeremiah is one filled to the brim with suffering. Accepted by many is the portrait of Jeremiah as a weeping prophet, but acknowledged by few is that Jeremiah was serving a weeping God. This study analyzes the prophet Jeremiah and the suffering he encountered because of his people. With this analysis, the author claims that throughout the book, the prophet is giving voice to YHWH’s suffering. The passionate God of Israel was unveiling his own turmoil through Jeremiah. Furthermore, the theology of a suffering God in the book of Jeremiah presents a tremendous critique to our culture that praises impassibility and demeans emotionality. The book of Jeremiah praises vulnerability, both in the human Jeremiah and in his God.
|
‘Blessings of Breasts and Womb’: God’s Compassion and the Construction of Masculinity
Program Unit: Biblical Masculinities
Alan Hooker, University of Exeter
In Biblical Hebrew, the terms for compassion (racham) and womb (rechem) are closely related. Given that the latter term is connected with motherhood and the female body in the Hebrew Bible, the question for this paper is whether God’s acts of compassion through these connotations undermine his masculinity and/or maleness. Texts such as Deut. 4.31, 2 Kgs. 13.23, and Jer. 13.14 treat compassion and destruction (shachat) dichotomously, with the use of destructive force arguably underscoring the deity’s powerful masculinity.
Does God’s masculinity subside in the face of his compassionate acts, or do they implicitly reconfigure masculinity itself, as I shall argue? Within God’s destructiveness, his shachat, there lies a paradox: on the one hand the forcefulness of this act highlights his warriorlike masculinity, but on the other, it can be used to destroy and diminish God’s people, which problematizes the discourses surrounding the fertile covenant promise that Israel will increase in number. In a number of texts, it is precisely God’s compassion which ensures the growth of the people and the inheritance of land (Isa. 14.1, Jer. 31.20, Ezek. 39.25).
There is arguably then a connection between God’s virility, often assumed to be masculine or male, and womblike compassion; see especially Isa. 46.3-4. Therefore, I intend to show that God’s compassion is indeed part of gendered discourse, but that these discourses actually challenge and reconfigure hegemonic perceptions of maleness and masculinity and help construct God’s wombed textual body.
|
Gender and the Characterizations of Children as Agents in Ancient Apocryphal and Hagiographical Texts in the Christian and Islamic Traditions
Program Unit: Families and Children in the Ancient World
Cornelia B. Horn, Catholic University of America
This paper examines the characterizations of John the Baptist, Jesus, and Mary as children in selected apocryphal and hagiographical texts in ancient Christian and early Islamic sources. The data in the early Syriac and Arabic traditions, which offers the most suitable basis for a comparative approach to these two religious cultures in context, allows one to discern how gender stereotypes intersected with ideas about active and passive characterizations of children in relationships to their parents and other adults with whom they interacted.
The paper argues that in a way that is similar to how modern mass media aim at shaping children’s perceptions of themselves and of the roles into which society expects them to grow, ancient religious literature that was produced to be both “useful and entertaining” reached out to the children in its audiences with the goal of promoting models for imitation. Whereas stereotypes for girls hardly ever left the realm of presenting the child as being obedient and docile, depictions of boys in these ancient religious texts moved about in a somewhat wider spectrum of characterizations. On the one hand, ideals of the male child also included promoting the child as a passive person. On the other hand, when the needs of the community’s current or future well-being required it, boys could be shown as resisting and actively overcoming adults’ preconceived expectations. Discerning the extent to which any of these characterizations and stereotypes still influence communities, in which these ancient religious texts continue to be consumed, and their attitudes towards children is a task of significant relevance in the modern world.
|
Encounters between Animals and Saints in Syriac and Georgian Texts
Program Unit: Bible and Syriac Studies in Context
Cornelia Horn, Catholic University of America
Animal-human interaction is part of the core of human culture and comprises a vast subject of human history. Part of that history includes the role of animals in religious symbolism. Animals have been sources of food, companions, and competitors to humans, but also are a symbolic canvass on which humans have depicted their struggle to understand and control the forces of nature. This complex interaction of animals as a source of life and a companion on the one hand and as a manifestation of untamed nature on the other have given animals an ambivalence which lends them to being incorporated into religious symbolism.
Over the past decade, scholars of culture and religion have intensified their efforts and taken into view the relationships between humans and animals. Their studies have included historical dimensions of this relationship in cultures of the past. Some research has been conducted that addresses human-animal interactions in European settings, and to some extent also in the Ancient Near East. Yet comparable studies are still a desideratum for the Eastern Mediterranean in late antiquity and the early medieval period.
This paper begins to address representations of human-animal interactions in literature at the intersection of extra-canonical and hagiographical texts in Syria and the Caucasus. It explores the symbolic value of these interactions with attention to dimensions of the sacred and how it is represented and controlled by humans or animals, or both, in interactions with one another. The paper studies aspects of the literary and rhetorical function of the representation of the approach of animals and humans to one another. At the same time, it considers questions of the ecological and economic relevance of the animal-human relationship in the given cultural setting of a text.
|
Dates and Dumbness in Ezekiel
Program Unit: Prophets
Frank-Lothar Hossfeld, Rheinische Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität Bonn
Dates and Dumbness in Ezekiel
|
Mishpat Usedaqah and the Torah
Program Unit: Israel and the Production and Reception of Authoritative Books in the Persian and Hellenistic Period (EABS)
Walter J. Houston, University of Manchester
The linkage of mishpat and sedaqah, either with the copula or as a parallel word pair, is widely recognized to be a hendiadys referring to justice toward the poor, with some of the connotations of ‘social justice’ in English. It is frequent in the Prophets and the Psalms, but it is extremely rare in the Torah, with only one precise attestation (Gen. 18:19; but Deut. 33:21 is close), even though many of the laws of the Torah have the manifest object of encouraging the practice of justice for the poor and people of weak social standing. Why is this? It will be argued that the expression refers primarily to the responsibility of the ruler, and that although certain writers after the fall of the native monarchies, represented, e.g., in Ezekiel, extended it to individual patronal responsibility, the association with kingship was too strong for the expression to be acceptable in a document representing the official commitments of the leaderships of the Israelite (Judaean and Samarian) communities under Persian rule.
|
The Armenian Version of the Apocryphal “Questions of the Queen of Sheba and Answers by King Solomon”
Program Unit: Bible in Eastern and Oriental Orthodox Traditions
Vahan Hovhanessian, Cardiff University
The presentation will explore the Armenian version of the apocryphal “Questions of the Queen of Sheba and Answers by King Solomon” preserved in many Classical Armenian manuscripts. This apocryphal document is based on the biblical story of the Queen of Sheba’s visit to King Solomon, inquiring about his wisdom, which is referred to in 1 Kings 10 and 2 Chronicles 9. The biblical narrative, however, does not record the dialogue between the two monarchs and the nature of the Queen’s questions and Solomon’s answers. It is in the Arabic, Armenian, Greek, Hebrew and Syriac versions of the apocryphal “Questions” that we find the text of an elaborate interrogation of King Solomon's faith and knowledge by the Queen of Sheba. What are the unique characteristics of the Armenian version of the “Questions?” How does it differ from the other versions? And, how does it contribute to the scholarly research of this apocryphal document will be the questions tackled in the presentation.
|
The Voice of David in Irenaeus’s Interpretation of the Psalms
Program Unit: Biblical Interpretation in Early Christianity
Mark Allen Howell, Dallas Theological Seminary
Scholarship in recent years has commented on the significance of the Psalms for early biblical interpretation (Kannengiesser), while lamenting the paucity of work in this area (Tanner). This is especially true in the second century, exemplified by the light treatment of the Psalms for understanding Irenaeus’s interpretation and argumentation. Modern interpreters of Irenaeus often reduce the Psalms to a pastiche of proof-texts that simply provide emphasis. This presentation begins to reassess the function of Psalms in Irenaeus, and finds a much greater depth of interpretive complexity. By examining the voice of David as a key witness for Irenaeus, we find many direct speech introductions to Psalms that add to the Psalms polemical impact. David is often portrayed by Irenaeus as an authority on key arguments. He is the recipient of special revelation regarding the Son, because “the framer of the universe made a promise to David” of an eternal king. (Adv. haer. 3.10.3). While there have been focused treatments like Psalm 21 by DeAldema, or Psalm 2 and 109 from Basevi, these lack interaction with broader themes for Irenaeus’s use of Psalms. Understanding Irenaeus’s holistic use of Psalms in this and other ways, contributes to Irenaean studies and the history of interpretation by demonstrating the very different relationship the writers of the second century had with the Psalms - a relationship that affected how they read the rest of scripture.
|
Mind the Gap! Why New Testament Scholars Rarely Ride on the Canonical Train
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
Sandra Hübenthal, Universität Basel
Looking around one easily gets the impression that »canon« is en vogue. Nevertheless, this does not apply to theology in general. While scholars from the Old Testament department and their colleagues from Systematics either get along pretty well on the subject or argue adamantly, the voice of their New Testament colleagues is rarely heard. It is difficult to meet someone in New Testament studies who works in this field beyond canon-intertextual readings on the reception of Israel’s Scriptures in the New Testament, not to mention how hard it is to find a New Testament scholar who would describe himself or herself as »working canonically«. In this paper, a New Testament scholar explores why this is the case. The starting point is the question what New Testament scholars understand when they hear »canon« and why – according to their self-understanding – the journey of the »canonical train« leads into a somewhat difficult or even dangerous direction. Eventually it will also be clarified why for New Testament scholars it might make more sense to change trains and get on the »cultural studies train« that travels into the direction of collective mnemonic landscapes and calls at the stations social, collective and cultural memory.
|
Teaching Mark as Collective Memory
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Sandra Hübenthal, Universität Basel
Read through the hermeneutical lens of social memory theory, the Gospel of Mark can be regarded as an artifact of collective memory. While recalling the Jesus story from their memory and experiences, the "Mark People" also disclose their self-understanding and grant insights into their processes of identity construction. The way Jesus is remembered as teacher and healer, in parables and miracles, beginning with his baptism and ending without appearance stories does not go without reason. Hearers and readers of Mark’s Gospel are prone to ask themselves what the founding story has to say about Jesus and about those who remember him. They might even ask themselves how they are supposed to tune in.
As Biblical scholars today, we are both readers and teachers. Thus, we might add the question of how these new hermeneutical insights on the Gospel of Mark can inform our teaching. The paper will explore these questions from the perspective of a Markan scholar who sometimes suffers from being an expert for university didactics, too – especially when it comes to didactic reduction and the choice of certain a Gattung or pericopae.
|
King David's Exposure while Dancing: A Queer Reading of 2 Samuel 6
Program Unit: Biblical Masculinities
Karin Hügel, University of Amsterdam
According to the Hebrew version of the transport of the ark to Jerusalem in 2 Samuel 6, King David is so scantily dressed that he publicly exposes himself while dancing before G*d (hwhy). David's wild, gay and possibly sexual conduct can evoke associations with the behavior of gay persons of today. Queer readers may identify with David and like him turn their backs on dominant rulers – like the members of Saul's dynasty – if they are not respected because of their queer way of life, but persecuted – as David was persecuted by King Saul. Such an interpretation implies that G*d (hwhy) is on the side of persons like King David, who – from the point of view of other people as well as of David's wife Michal – behave in a strange fashion, thus act queerly
|
Making Priests: Early Christian Reception of a Biblical Notion
Program Unit: The Reception of the Bible in Greco-Roman Tradition
David Hunter, University of Kentucky
The aim of this presentation is to investigate the manner in which a variety of early Christian writers appropriated the language and imagery of the Old Testament priesthood in the making of a Christian "priesthood." In the third century it became common for Christian writers, such as Cyprian and Origen, to adopt the language of priesthood in their exposition and defense of Christian leadership. Regulations regarding clerical conduct, including the prohibition of second marriages to clergy, reinforced and relied on this rhetoric of priesthood. My examination will extend into the fourth century. I will argue that new Christian practices, such as the requirement that the wives of clergy be married as virgins and the prohibition of sexual intercourse to higher clergy in the west, continued this tradition of appropriating biblical regulations to develop new models of ecclesiastical authority.
|
The Number of Generations of Jeconiah’s Descendants in 1 Chr 3:17-24
Program Unit: Persian Period
Sunwoo Hwang, Chongshin University
The significance of Jeconiah’s genealogy (1 Chr 3:17-24) lies in the fact that it provides a clue for determining the possible earliest time (terminus a quo) of the composition of Chronicles. Since Jeconiah’s descendants are the last generations of the people who appeared in Chronicles, the date of the last generation of Jeconiah is terminus a quo of the composition of Chronicles. In order to determine the date of Jeconiah’s last descendant, we must figure out who the last descendant of Jeconiah is and the number of generations between Jeconiah and his last descendant. In addition, after we discover the number of the generations of Jeconiah’s descendants, we need to find out the most likely span of one generation of Jeconiah’s descendants. This article will explore three crucial issues in searching for the date of Jeconiah’s last descendant, which will, in turn, shed the light on the terminus a quo of the composition of Chronicles. The first issue is whether the Hebrew word, ’asir, of 3:17 is a personal name, “Assir” or a common noun meaning “prisoner”. If the former is supported, one generation is counted but if the latter is supported, ’asir just functions as a modifier. The second issue is the identification of the seemingly fragmented genealogy, “sons of Rephaiah, sons of Arnan, sons of Obadiah, sons of Shechaniah” in 3:21b. To reveal the relationship between this genealogy and its previous genealogy is an essential task for investigation. The third issue is the explanation of “six” at the end of 3:22. This issue concerns whether the “six” refers to the number of the sons of Shechaniah or not.
|
Alternatives to the “Text as Mirror” Approach: Reassessing the Gendered Rhetoric of 1 Timothy
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Susan E. Hylen, Emory University
The reconstruction of the opponents of 1 Timothy has played an important part in our understanding of the letter’s gendered instructions. Interpreters have understood the instruction to women to be silent (2:11-12) as evidence that women are speaking publicly. They have understood the description of the freedoms of young widows (5:13) as criticism of the autonomy unmarried women were finding in the church. Interpreters see the instructions given by the author as a window into events taking place in the recipient church.
In this paper, I offer two alternative ways of understanding the function of the prescriptive language of 1 Timothy. I use the first parallel (a portion of Livy’s History) to suggest that exhortations to modesty could function as criticism of the opponents’ viewpoints. The allegation of immodest women casts aspersions on the opponents regardless of the behavior of the women. The second (Plutarch’s Advice to Bride and Groom) suggests that household order could serve as part of the on-going cultivation of a virtuous life. The cultivation of virtues will help the readers avoid potential problems that could otherwise arise.
These two options are not identical, but neither one assumes that the instructions of 1 Timothy must be directed toward an existing conflict over the behavior of women. 1 Timothy might also address a real conflict and employ gender stereotypes to paint a negative portrait of the opponents. On the other hand, it may simply acknowledge potential problems that it addresses through the cultivation of standard virtues. Either way, the rhetoric is not necessarily designed to constrain women who found liberation in the Christian message. Instead, it may use gender norms to blame opponents or to motivate virtue.
|
On the Mathematical Methodology for the Gospel of John
Program Unit: Methods in New Testament Studies
Woosik Hyun, Hoseo University
By what logic could Johannine community have developed the unique Christology? Regarding Cantor-Bernstein theorem, this interdisciplinary approach addresses a mathematical reflection on the identification methodology in the Gospel of John. The results show that the logic of identification between God, Jesus, and Johannine community could be valid by a modern mathematical method.
|
“With What Shall I Come Before the Lord?” Israel’s Return to YHWH or Rivaling of YHWH in Mic 6:3-5, 6–7?
Program Unit: Stylistics and the Hebrew Bible
Maricel Ibita, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
In comparison to the other so-called eighth century prophets, literary studies on the book of Micah dealing with its wordplay, rhetoric, and drama have just recently flourished. While newer commentaries have touched on its poetry (F.I. Andersen & D.N. Freedman, 2000; P.P. Jenson, 2008), the “two sides of the same coin” of biblical poetry has not yet been thoroughly explored, viz., “pervasive parallelism and metaphor” (A. Berlin, 1997). This research attempts to fill in this gap by examining the pericope of the so-called ryb metaphor in Micah 6:1-8. In Micah 6:3-5, YHWH as a sovereign suzerain king expresses his disappointment in vassal Israel through the historical recall of the exodus and the promise of the land (see M.Z. Brettler, 1989). While seemingly silent at first on YHWH’s accusations, the corporate response of Israel to the complaints of the deity centers on the different offerings they could give, culminating in child sacrifice (Micah 6:6-7). Do these words embody a passionate collective remorse or is this a case of buying off the deity and rivaling the “saving acts of the Lord”? To answer this tricky question, this research will first consider looking at the metaphor YHWH IS KING from the perspective of conceptual metaphor theory, specifically blending theory (M.T. DesCamp and E. Sweetser, 2005). Afterwards, it shall analyze the poem by employing the complementary insights of Adele Berlin on the aspects of parallelism, viz., grammatical, lexical, phonological and semantic (2008), and of Robert Alter on intensification and narrativity (2011) to see how the rhetorical questions, puns, repetitions, hyperbole, etc. in the text demonstrate the complex relationship between YHWH and Israel. Finally, it is hoped that the exploration of this text by focusing on metaphor and parallelism will help the readers understand it better and respond to it in a more relevant way.
|
“My People, What Have I Done to You?” Exploring the Reasons for, and Expressions and Consequences of, YHWH’s Overt and Covert Emotions in Micah 6–7
Program Unit: Emotions and the Biblical World (EABS)
Maricel Ibita, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
Contemporary literary studies on the book of Micah deal with its wordplay, rhetoric, drama, and poetry, but there is still a lacuna regarding its use of metaphors, and even more so, regarding the emotions one can detect in the metaphors for YHWH-Israel relations. These chapters seem to depict YHWH as a sovereign suzerain king with Israel as vassal and their complex relationship (see Marc Zvi Brettler, 1989). Thus, this investigation will first analyze the metaphor YHWH IS KING from the perspective of conceptual metaphor theory, specifically blending theory (Mary Therese DesCamp and Eve Sweetser, 2005). This metaphor will serve as the backdrop for investigating the reasons for, expressions and consequences of YHWH’s emotions for Israel, especially anger, in Micah 6-7 (See Deena Grant, 2009). More particularly, it examines the text for possible socio-cultural clues underlying the contradicting range of YHWH’s characteristics: from the ability to protect and nurture to YHWH’s capacity to destroy. The acknowledged Mediterranean values of dyadism, patron-client relationship and honor and shame are conjectured to provide hints to a deeper understanding of the changing overt and covert emotions of YHWH in Micah 6-7 (see Saul Olyan, 1996; T.R. Hobbs, 1997; Bruce Malina and John Pilch, 1998).
|
"No one comes to the Father except through me” (Jn 14:6b): Revisiting an Alternative Hermeneutics for Exclusive Texts in the Fourth Gospel
Program Unit: Methods in New Testament Studies
Ma. Marilou S. Ibita, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
In addition to providing a hermeneutical framework for the contributions in Anti-Judaism and the Fourth Gospel (Bieringer, Pollefeyt and Vandecasteele-Vanneuville, 2001), the editors also proposed an alternative hermeneutical approach that recognizes the anti-Jewish elements in the text but attempts to go beyond them. This approach recognizes anti-Jewish elements in the FG, holds that these are unacceptable from a Christian point of view and acknowledges that there is no convincing way to reinterpret them in ways that could save the core message of the FG. Nevertheless, it also considers the alternative world projected by the text and its “inclusive horizon” (Ricoeur, 1976; Schneiders, 1991). The editors’ applied the approach to Jn 8:31-59. However, the editors’ post-conference proposal of the alternative hermeneutics did not have much impact in the reviews and in the ensuing literature on Johannine anti-Judaism. This paper attempts to critically revisit the proposed alternative hermeneutics and to investigate what it has to offer the interpretation of anti-Jewish texts like those in John’s Gospel. By way of example, I will examine this approach with regard to a text considered as the basis for exclusive Christian claims (Reinhartz, 2011), namely "No one comes to the Father except through me” (Jn 14:6b). Recent publications on Johannine meals (Smith, 2003; Kobel, 2011) do not deal with this Christocentric text. I argue that the exclusive words in Jn 14:6b need to be understood in light of the Greco-Roman symposium which aims to consolidate group identity. Yet, while the common identity of the Jesus-believers in John may be affirmed, the dangerous potential of Jn 14:6b for Christocentric supersessionism remains. In light of this observation, I will investigate how the hermeneutic proposed by Bieringer, et. al. can help discover the alternative world projected by this text and how it can contribute to Jewish-Christian dialogue.
|
"Do not worry…?" (Matt 6:25) Exploring Gender, Economics, and Ecology in Matt 6:25-34
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Ma. Marilou S. Ibita, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
The “pervasive androcentricism” (Anderson, 1983) of Matthew’s Gospel challenged men and women biblical scholars (Levine, 2001) resulting in feminist readings using various methodologies and hermeneutical approaches. Apart from androcentricism, other questions such as power relations (West and Dube, 1996), location (Bird, etc., 1997), and ethnicity (Levine, 1996; Pui-lan, etc., 2004) were also considered. However, David Sim’s (2011) concise summary of the current state of research in Matthew states that feminist criticism is “an underrated and underrepresented method.” I argue in this paper that this lacuna is obvious in the Sermon on the Mount scholarship, particularly in a feminist ecological and economic reading of Mt 6:25-34 due to: (a) insufficient narrative-critical study that shows closer integration of the Sermon on the Mount with the rest of Matthew’s narrative (Anderson, 1983, 1996); (b) inadequate discussion of the gender aspect of the activities mentioned in Mt 6:25-34 from a first century CE setting in Roman Palestine; and (c) the limited exploration of the economic aspect of the activities mentioned in the text. Consequently, despite the increasing number of ecological interpretations of this passage (e.g., Leske, 2002; Bauckham, 2009; Tsalampouni, 2011), the consideration of gender seems limited to passing comments that say that sowing and reaping are men’s work while spinning is the job of women while the economic aspect and its impact on ecology is not fully integrated. Using narrative criticism, social-scientific criticism and gender-criticism with particular attention to gender, ecology and economics, I will demonstrate that exploring these aspects in relation to sowing, reaping and spinning as well as the more general human activities of eating and drinking and wearing of clothes results in a more gender-inclusive and economically-informed interpretation of an ecological reading of this text that can help readers respond to the ecological and economic anxieties of our day.
|
Geography and Identity: Spatial Word Pairs in John and the Question of Docetism
Program Unit: Johannine Literature and Docetism (EABS)
Joan Infante, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
The Fourth Gospel has been considered to be a spiritual gospel that has a negative view of the world. At the surface level, this notion can be easily attributed to the gospel’s use of contrasting word pairs like “not of this world” – “of this world” or “above” – “below” (8:23). The first part of the pair is associated with the divine Creator and the second with creation that is either separated from or is at enmity with God. Might this dichotomy between the “above” and the “below” have contributed to a Johannine spirit Christology that favored docetism? Does Käsemann’s (1968) proposition that John is naively docetic in nature find support in John’s bipartite cosmological language?
In this paper, we shall explore the Johannine spatial cosmological word pairs and their function in the gospel through narrative-critical and spatial point of view analyses in conjunction with the insights of Pennington (2004) in his analysis of OT cosmology. We will demonstrate that the Johannine word pairs “not of this world” – “this world” or “above” – “below” cannot be interpreted as promoting the spiritual with a concomitant denigration of the material. And consequently, they cannot be considered as docetic markers.
|
Talking about Biblical Emotions: Methodological Issues
Program Unit: Emotions and the Biblical World (EABS)
Anke Inselmann, Universität Augsburg
Talking about emotions of biblical times seems to be quite difficult: Looking at emotions in a literary presented way, there is no methodology of exegesis established yet. That is connected to different factors. To mention only some aspects briefly: Emotions belong to abstract concepts. Therefore, words or terms expressing feelings are harder to describe than other lexeme classifications, especially concrete ones, for emotions refer as well to subjective experience as to language conventions. Besides that, they may encounter in explicit terms but also in paraphrases, in a descriptive manner. That bears two risks: on the one hand of over-interpretation, and on the other hand of a too restricted semantic view of the phenomenon. Though modern psychology is defined as the science or the study of the mind and the behavior, its usefulness for exegetical studies is disputed very controversial. By the way, in both disciplines there is no consent whether emotions are predominantly influenced by culture or should be understood as invariable psychological factors, as "anthropological constants". But this is important for interpreting affects in literary contexts. Interestingly enough there seems to be not only a gap between the cultures, there has even been a sophisticated and subtly diversified discourse of affects in Antiquity as well as in our times. This contribution is going to point out some problems, considerable aspects and chances talking about affects in literary sources of the Antiquity. Some interesting results of the contemporary emotional psychology will be brought up for discussion.
|
Pauline Pastoral Anthropology in St. Polycarp of Smyrna
Program Unit: The Reception of the Scripture in the Patristic Exegesis (II-VIII centuries) (EABS)
Mihoc Ioan, Universitatea Eftimie Murgu din Resita
In his 'valuable' - as Irenaeus calls it (Adv. Haer. III.3.4) - Letter to Philippians, Poly carp of Smyrna clearly alluded to Pauline Epistles, such as Romans, 1 Corinthians, Galatians, Ephesians, and 1, 2 Timothy. Moreover, the passage from Phil 3:2, with its reference to Paul's 'letters' in the plural, seems to suggest that Polycarp knows of a collection of Paul's letters. Especially, Polycarp mentions Paul in three contexts in this letter (3:2; 9:1; 11:2-3). Each mention of Paul's name begins a cluster of Pauline citations and allusions (explicitly from 1 Tim. 6:10; 1 Tim. 6:7; 2 Tim. 4:10), which means that Polycarp consciously seeks to imitate the literary style and ethical example of Paul. He is conservative in that he makes reference to traditional material, but he is neither non-creative nor unoriginal because he applies such traditional material to the situation caused by the sin of Valens and the resulting social disorder. His Epistle is intended to encourage the Philippians to live according Christian virtues, and he recalls mainly those which contribute to the unity of community. In fact, his Letter is a powerfully creative response to the rhetorical situation that he faced. Likewise the Apostle Paul, Polycarp is concerned about 'wrong' teaching and practice, and he made unity and reconciliation his primary goals. In spite of the use of strong language about his adversaries, Polycarp gives no indication of separation. Although his list of errors is quite scathing, he calls for moderation and repentance, denoting episcopal care in the manner of Pastoral Epistles. In this respect, we think that Polycarp has much to tell us about the early reception of at least some of Paul's Letters. To be sure, he is a more important theologian than some modern scholars have allowed.
|
Framing Supersessionism in the Early Church: The Interpretation of the Hardening Tradition (Jes 6, 9-10) in the Second-Century Christian Literature
Program Unit: The Reception of the Scripture in the Patristic Exegesis (II-VIII centuries) (EABS)
Alexandru Ionita, Ecumenical Research Institute, Lucian Blaga University
The second Century is clearly seen today as a period of partition between Judaism and Christianity and in this process without doubt that religious identity matters played a crucial role. This papers aims to show how the 2nd Century Christian interpretation of the ‘hardening tradition’ (Jes 6) has setup the so called ‘theology of substitution’ of Israel by the Church (Supersessionism), which remained so influential in the following centuries. Instruments like Biblia Patristica give us a short list with occurrences of the prophetic text in the Christian literature of the 2nd Century, but there are many other indirect references and allusions to this text, which played a fundamental role in the Jewish-Christian debates of that time. Taken the chronological close of the Apostolic Fathers with the earlier writings gathered as the ‘New Testament’ and their influence in the upcoming generations of Christian theologians this paper intends to highlight the pivotal role of these early authors for the Eastern Christian tradition and its theology about Israel.
|
“I wrote three wooden tablets and left them as knowledge” (Zostrianos, NHC VIII, 1, 130): The Art of Memory and Ecstatic Experiences in Platonizing Sethian Treatises
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Eduard Iricinschi, The Van Leer Jerusalem Institute
Modern commentators remarked that the celestial journeys presented by the Nag Hammadi Platonizing Sethian treatises were meant for the ritual enactment of celestial ascent. But how did the readers of these Sethian texts remember the characters, places, divine hierarchies, luminaries, aeons, and the aeonic copies which populated the celestial and supra-celestial regions described by Sethian texts such as Zostrianos and Allogenes the Stranger? How did the religious experience encrypted in the narratives of these texts translate in the reader’s reception? Sethian authors often depicted their texts as coming from sacred books, written by those who received their revelations, and placed on mountains. The art of memory, initially presented in Rhetorica ad Herennium (3.16-24), a work written in the first century BCE and attributed to Cicero, instructed ancient rhetoricians to increase their mastery of artificial memory by associating a fixed series of backgrounds or places with various series of images or objects, subject to change and adaptation. This paper argues that the creation of the celestial and super-celestial worlds Zostrianos travels to, as well as their recreation through reading and further ritual enactment could have not taken place without help from the art of memory. As such, it suggests that readers of Zostrianos and Allogenes the Stranger memorized the narrative and spatial trajectory of the heavenly trips in minute details, using the art of memory. Its mnemonic devices allowed the readers to internalize the narrative of ecstatic travels, and reproduce this experience in a ritual setting.
|
Jude, Enoch, Incarnation, and Deviation through Three Canonical Frameworks
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
David R. Jackson, William Carey Christian School, Australia
Jude’s citation of 1 Enoch 1:9 as prophecy in a context affirming the incarnation of Jesus as God raises a conundrum. In this paper we explore the hypothesis that more than one canonical framework may be involved in Jude’s rhetoric, as opposed to the proposition that the citation of apocalyptic texts constitutes evidence that there was, as yet, no clearly differentiated canonical framework in the early Church. A brief exploration of the impact of the Jewish Revolt and the shift from Palestinian-Jewish to Patristic-Gentile perspectives on the understanding of the Epistle of Jude further highlights the relevance of canon as ‘the primary context’ for a community’s understanding of this intense epistle.
|
‘Cosmic Bully’ or ‘?’: The Book of Job as Mashal
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Wisdom
David R. Jackson, William Carey Christian School, Australia
In his 2011 commentary on Job 38-42 (Word Biblical Commentary 18B), David Clines has masterfully demonstrated the ambiguities of the conclusion to Job’s suffering as expressed in Job 42:6. Clines concluded that the Book of Job reveals Job as a hero who will not bow to God as ‘cosmic bully’ (pp.1217ff.). Significantly, the one thing on which all the characters in the drama of Job agree is the aseity of God. Job’s comment that God ‘has made me a mashal to the peoples’ (Job 17:6) may reflect more than an offhand remark. In this paper we explore the possibility that the ambiguity Clines has so effectively analysed, may be a deliberate rhetorical device in keeping with the extensive use of irony and sarcasm throughout the work, designed to provoke the reader/ audience to choose their own conclusion.
|
Matthew's Women as Designated Outsiders— Or Were They Insiders?
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Glenna S. Jackson, Otterbein University
I have argued that the roles of women in Matthew's narrative are dependent upon their gender; i.e., the plots would not work with men as the key players. For example, the mention of women in the genealogy as well as the story of the Canaanite woman as a proselyte are dependent on the tradition that only the females of enemy tribes could convert to ancient Judaism; the story of the hemorrhaging woman is dependent on her menses; the narrative of the women at the tomb is dependent on their role as caretakers of dead bodies. In this paper, I will argue that their very outsidedness is what makes them insiders in the kindom that Matthew envisioned Jesus to inaugurate. [This paper would fit best in the Special Themes session.]
|
A Sibylline Oracle on a Cologne Papyrus?
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism (EABS)
Deborah Jacobs, Freie Universität Berlin
Originally a Graeco-Roman genre, Sibylline Oracles are a collection of oracular utterances written in Greek hexameters ascribed to the Sibyls, prophetesses who uttered divine revelations in a frenzied state. Fourteen books and eight fragments of Sibylline Oracles have come down to us. These are a collection of utterances that were composed or edited under various circumstances, probably between the 2nd century CE and the 6th century CE. The original Sibylline Books that Jews and later on Christians used to write the Sibylline Oracles are now lost. Therefore, evidence for the sibylline genre outside the collection is virtually none-existent. However, in the 1920s a papyrus was discovered in Oslo (P. Oslo II 14) whose content Wilhelm Crönert identified as sibylline. Unfortunately, the papyrus was too damaged to reconstruct a conclusive text. Thanks to the edition of a newly discovered Cologne Papyrus (P.Köln Inv. 20380) at the hands of Michael Gronewald containing the same text, new light can be shed on the circulation of sibylline material in Hellenistic Egypt. In my paper I aim to analyse possible parallels between the Oslo/Cologne papyri and the Third Sibylline Oracle.
|
The "Narrative Parable" in Northern France in the 11th–13th Centuries
Program Unit: Judaica
Jonathan Jacobs, Bar-Ilan University
The "narrative parable" is a brief fictional narrative plot whose role is to clarify a different matter that is essentially similar. Narrative parables are to be found in ancient Babylonian and Egyptian literature, as well as in the Bible. Rabbinic literature of all genres dating to the early centuries of the Common Era offers thousands of examples. The gospels, too, include dozens of narrative parables.
In the generations following the Talmudic period, Jewish scholars generally preferred to cite existing rabbinic parables. Later on, Jewish philosophers in Islamic countries, including Saadia Gaon, Maimonides, and Ibn Daoud, started to propose their own. To date, no study has yet examined the parallel phenomenon in the countries under Christian influence. Rashi, in his Commentary on the Pentateuch, mentions more than forty parables, all taken from rabbinic literature. Rashbam's Commentary on the Pentateuch offers no narrative parables at all. Other disciples of Rashi, including R. Joseph Kara, R. Joseph Bekhor Shor, R. Eliezer of Beaugency, and others, present their own narrative parables in addition to those appearing in rabbinic literature. In my lecture I will present the original parables of Northern France in the 11th-13th century, categorize them, and address the reasons for the return of the narrative parable to exegetical literature on the Bible specifically during this period and in this region.
The importance of this research pertains to two main areas:
a. Study of Medieval biblical exegesis – offering an understanding of the motives of the commentators of Northern France, who were disciples of Rashi; and
b. Study of Hebrew literature – filling in information about the narrative parable in a region and during a period which has not been addressed in any prior research.
|
Noah’s Flood Calendar (Gen 7:10–8:19) in the Septuagint
Program Unit: Septuagint Studies
Helen R. Jacobus, University College London
This paper proposes that the different dates and chronology in the sequence of events in the account of Noah’s Flood in the LXX and MT/SP are not variants due to scribal errors. As is well known, the text in the LXX is similar (not the same) as the MT/SP. For example, in the LXX the rains begin and the ark comes to rest on the 27th of the months in question, and the MT/SP these events take place on the 17th of the months concerned. Also, in the LXX the mountain peaks appear in the 11th month and in the MT/SP the mountain tops are visible in the 10th month. I will discuss some of the key differences between the two accounts and outline a theory that separate calendars are being referenced. The presentation will put forward a new interpretation of how one of the elements of the Deluge in the LXX should be read in order to support this hypothesis. It will draw on other accounts of the Flood in post-biblical literature in the discussion.
|
How Was the Hebrew Text of Jeremiah 1 Translated into Greek?
Program Unit: Texts and Contexts of Jeremiah: The Exegesis of Jeremiah 1 and 10 in light of Textual and Reception History
Norbert Jacoby, University of Koblenz-Landau
In the last decades, several studies argued that isomorphism was the basic norm of the Greek translator of Jeremiah (each morpheme of the source text is represented in the target text). However, in some cases, the translator tried to interpret the text using the rich semantic and grammatical possibilities of the Greek language. This presentation will argue that the translation of Jeremiah into Greek was done with remarkable consideration and that the translator did not deviate substantially from his Vorlage although sometimes going beyond isomorphism in his approach.
|
Paul and Imperial Armour: Re-imagining Imperial Cuirassed Statues in 1 Thess 5:8
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
David Janssen, University of Divinity, Melbourne
This paper will explore the social impact of Roman Imperial statuary on the early Christian community of Thessalonica, giving specific consideration to the cuirassed statue type and Paul’s rhetorical use of armour language in 1 Thessalonians 5:8. In general, honorific statues of the imperial family were deployed by the provincial cities of the Roman Empire (rather than imposed from above) to embed themselves within an imperial patron-client relationship with the emperor. Though the imagery was often diverse and complex, a key pattern of imperial portraiture accentuated the patriarchal protectiveness and security provided by the Emperor with corresponding feelings of security and gratefulness on behalf of the population. The use of cuirassed statues—an emperor or victorious general in parade amour—reflects a particularly vivid iconographical representation of patriarchal protectiveness through a graphic representation of power and victory. Defeated and subjugated enemies of Rome, trophies, and potent mythological images of divine beings were inscribed on the cuirass to enhance the sense of a divinely sanctioned peace secured for the cities of the empire. In the context of a provincial capital like Thessalonica, the use of armour language by Paul in 1 Thessalonians 5:8, it will be argued, represents a contrasting vision to this imperial typology. The deployment of armour language by Paul, in part, represents the rhetorical use of vivid speech (ekphrasis) to recreate before the eyes of his listeners a new image of the cuirass consistent with their lived experience in a provincial capital of the Roman Empire. The themes of faith and love (and salvation), which Paul inscribes on his armour, redirects them to consider the death of Jesus as a counter-sign of victory and triumph—their savior and benefactor—thereby reinforcing an important set of alternative values for the guidance and support of the fledgling community of faith.
|
The Structure of Gen 2:9–3:24
Program Unit: Literary Features – Fact or Fiction (EABS)
Robin Jarrell, Independent Scholar
The narrative conversation in Genesis 2:9-3:14 between the Serpent, Eve, Yahweh, and Adam forms various detailed, complex, symmetric Antimetabole-type and chiastic structures replete with word-play and punning.
One such example (above) begins with “Out of the ground the Lord God made to grow every tree that is 1) pleasant to the sight and 2) good for food” which may be paired with its corresponding verse in 3:6 “So when the woman saw that the tree was 1) good for food, and that it was 2) a delight to the eyes ….” 2:9 contends that every tree created by God is (first) pleasant to look at, and (second) good for food. Its corresponding chiasmus reverses these qualities: the Woman’s referenced tree (of the Knowledge of Good and Evil) is (first) good for food and (second) a delight to gaze upon. There are approximately 20 such associations (reversed word order, matching and repeat words, word associations) in the passage. Interesting combinations that invite closer analysis include:
lü`obdäh ûlüšomräh (2:15) | lišmör ´et-Deºrek (3:24)
`árûmmîm (2:25) |`ê|rummìm (3:7) | Kî|-`êröm(3:10) | Kî `êröm (3:11) [ A pun with `ärûm (3:1)?]
Bütôk haGGän(2:9) | Bütôk-haGGän (3:3) | Bütôk `ëc haGGän (3:8)
In this paper, I will examine the overall thematic structure of the passage in terms of the location(s) of specific plays on words and their relationship to one another. I will discuss the implications for reading the text in terms of how the authors/redactors of Genesis may have structurally underscored polemical relationships between all four characters. I will also discuss how this reading specifically affects the roles of women (i.e., Hagar, Samson’s mother) portrayed later in the Hebrew Bible.
|
Jeremiah 1 in Early Jewish Literature
Program Unit: Texts and Contexts of Jeremiah: The Exegesis of Jeremiah 1 and 10 in light of Textual and Reception History
Alex Jassen, New York University
This paper examines the interpretative afterlife of Jer 1 in early Jewish literature. It employs a comparative approach to trace the history of reception of the portrait of Jeremiah in Second Temple period texts and rabbinic literature. Emphasis is placed on the early Jewish interest in the lineage of Jeremiah, both as articulated in Jer 1 (son of Hilkiah) and as created in midrashic texts (Jeremiah as a descendent of Rahab the prostitute). Early Jewish texts also reflect an interest in the circumstances surrounding Jeremiah's conception, birth, and prophetic identity. These themes are examined both as responses to exegetical issues found in the text of Jer 1 and as part of broader themes regarding early Jewish conceptions of the identity of Jeremiah, the nature of prophecy, and destruction of the Jerusalem temple
|
Taking the Reader into Utopia
Program Unit: Chronicles and Utopia (EABS)
Matthias Jendrek, Theologische Fakultät Paderborn
If “discontinuity between the portrayal of that [the] society and the author’s present situation” marks utopia, as Steven J. Schweitzer puts it in his dissertation on “Reading Utopia in Chronicles”, the discontinuity or estrangement between the society (or history) depicted in the text and the present situation of the reader has to be even greater. On the other hand, the prayer texts of Chronicles bridge the boundaries between Israel’s past and an ideal reader’s present.
Donald F. Murray has shown in a study of 2000 that “the envisaged readers [of 1 Chronicles 16] are encouraged to anticipate a happy future that will replicate a utopian past”. This holds true not only for the “psalm” of 1 Chronicles 16 and other prayer texts such as 2 Chronicles 20:6–12, but also for all texts in Chronicles referring back to the prayer texts. Of several ways of referral, the phenomena called “abbreviations” and “unrecorded prayers” are most interesting regarding prayer in Chronicles. Both phenomena act as hypertexts. This implies that they are intertextual links between their context and the “utopian” prayers. Thus, they transport the “utopian force” of passages like 1 Chronicles 16 to other parts of Chronicles. They facilitate identification of the ideal reader with the (utopian) past presented in the text. In other words, abbreviations and “unrecorded prayers” enable identification of the present of the texts and the future the texts develop – which, in turn, forms the present of the reader.
As Murray identified what he calls “revival motif” being a central part of the theological message of especially the prayers in Chronicles, acting as counterpart to the “retribution” theme, the conclusion is that this “revival motif” is the “estranging” or utopian part of the account in relation to the ideal reader of Chronicles.
|
How to “Hammer in” a Message: The “Grotesque” of 2 Chronicles 20
Program Unit: Writings (including Psalms)
Matthias Jendrek, Theologische Fakultät Paderborn
The story of Jehoshaphat’s victory over the Moabites and Ammonites, told in 2 Chronicles 20, bears features of a grotesque, judges Klaus Seybold in a monograph of 2006. He names exaggeration and pointed emphasis on a single message as key examples. He concludes that the grotesque impression is the result of predominant theological presentation, vanquishing the proper “geschichtsbezogene Erzählkunst” (history-related art of narration).
In opposition to that, the “grotesque” features of 2 Chronicles 20 are not side effects of the presentation of theological thought, but a means to convey exactly this message: “Confess (the name of) the Lord (2 Chronicles 6), and you will be safe.”
The Jehoshaphat story is closely linked with the account of Asa, fighting “Zerah the Cushite” in 2 Chronicles 14. Raymond Dillard claims in his commentary on 2 Chronicles that the two stories form a chiasm. The Asa story itself quotes rather directly from 1 Samuel 17, namely, from the narration of David fighting Goliath. This story bears the same features Seybold identifies as “grotesque” as 2 Chronicles 20 does. Thus 1 Samuel 17 acts as hypotext to 2 Chronicles 14. As 2 Chronicles 14 and 20 are closely related, it is possible to extend the intertextual link between 1 Samuel 17 and 2 Chronicles 14 to 2 Chronicles 20.
This leads to the conclusion that the “art of narration” employed in 2 Chronicles 20 is not in decline, as Seybold rates it. On the contrary, reduction, simplification and hence intensification contribute to the overall impression of Chronicles as “paraenesis”. The grotesque becomes a rhetorical means to transport a theological message.
|
The Wisdom of the Sons of Korah in Psalm 46
Program Unit: Writings (including Psalms)
Dae Jun Jeong, Wycliffe College
Among the authors of the Psalms, the sons of Korah are interesting to us, because the name, Korah, makes us think of the incident of Num 16, revolt of Korah, Dathan and Abiram.
There eleven chapters in the Psalms that are written by the sons of Korah (Ps 42, 44~49, 84, 85, 87, 88). Although we do not know exactly the mind of the descendants of Korah when they wrote and sung those psalms, it is manifest that Korah psalms have distinct features comparing with other psalms, such as the ones that depict God.
In this paper, I will search the literary structure of this psalm. It will be helpful to find the author’s intended meaning for several words and to solve translational problems in vs. 4. After this, I will connect this psalm and the revolt of Korah, their ancestor, because no one can ever consider the sons of Korah and the rebellion of Korah in Num 16 separately.
Results of these studies may help us understand the mind of the psalmist regarding this psalm and lead us to the world of wisdom of God’s people whom wanted to overcome their deep sorrow as singing this psalm.
|
Did God Make a Model of Job’s Family as an Ideal Family to His People?
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Wisdom
Dae Jun Jeong, Wycliffe College
A great shock, when we read the book of Job, is that Yahweh gave Satan permission to kill Job’s sons and daughters. Most scholars have insisted that the fourth disaster depicts the death of all Job’s children in Job 1:19. However, the author of this book is extremely careful in approaching this thing. The author chooses the word meaning children carefully, because the readers can understand this word with another meaning. Also, the author seems to show his or her intention by using literary structures in this book. Most scholars have agreed that the book of Job has notable literary structures. Among literary and intentional characteristics of the book of Job, the most prominent feature is repeated contents as a parallel structure in the first and the last parts of the book. The prologue and the epilogue of this book make the skeleton of certain functions. So, the structure, namely the framework, shows the author’s special intention to readers of this book.
In my opinion, the prose parts of this book, the framework, seem to show the positive changes of Job’s family as an ideal family. It also means Job’s children did not die in the fourth disaster. To support my assertion, first, I will discuss the meaning of the word na‘ar in Job 1. Secondly, I will explain the special structure of the framework. It is helpful to understand why the word na‘ar means servants in Job 1:19. Third, I will compare between the stories of Job and Abraham. These two families had similar experiences such as ‘loss of family members.’ The result of this study will not only reveal the author’s ultimate purpose of this structure in the book, but also help us know what an ideal family Yahweh wants.
|
Othering in the Book of Nehemiah
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible/Old Testament/Ancient Israel Studies (EABS)
Kristin Joachimsen, The Arctic University of Norway
The paper deals with the complexity of the identity discourse in the Book of Nehemiah, which takes place in an imperial, a regional and a local context: The book is situated in the Achaemenid Empire, which was characterized by fluid boundaries as regards ethnicity, religion and politics. The Persian kings are safeguarding both the interests of the Achaemenids and the Yehudites, while Nehemiah is an imperial official as well as a repatriate Yehudite. Also, a distinction is made between the people of Yehud and those who do not belong to this community, expressed as an opposition between Nehemiah and his allies- and neighbouring peoples like Samarians, Ashodites, Arabs, Moabites and Ammonites. The paper is based on a close reading of the confrontations between Nehemiah and Sanballat the Horonite and Tobiah the Ammonite, who were leaders of the opposition to his rebuilding of Jerusalem (Neh. 2:10, 19-20, 3:33-35, 4:1-5; 6:1-9, 17-19; 13:4-9, 28-29). This confrontation will be analysed as a process of othering, where the “other” is needed in the story in order to mark the boundaries of Israel. Attention will be paid to degrees of otherness. As others have noted before, in a process of “othering”, the “other” might not be a contrastive “other”, but can be a “proximate other” in relation to a construction of oneself. The “proximate” other might be threatening as it might concern groups that share some sort of similarity with oneself. Focus will also be put on multi-cultural dimensions of the identity formations, including the notion “intersectionality”, which highlights how individuals and groups have more identities and loyalities. In the book of Nehemiah, Sanballat and Tobiah are tied to the Yehudite leadership, who also belongs to Nehemiah’s allies. As such, multiple, overlapping and crossing identities and loyalities are put in play.
|
Who Has Died in 1 Cor 11:17-34? The Lord's Supper in Corinth Revisited
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Linda Joelsson, Abo Akademi University
Many scholars have made estimations of the significant number of the population suffering from starvation during the time of the writing of 1 Corinthians. Yet, it is habitually taken for granted that verses 11:17-24 refer to some of the wealthier members of the believers' assembly in Corinth who had died because of the problem of ”unworthy behavior” in relation to the Lord's supper. Although common, this interpretation has a weak foundation in the text. The issue of the letter is that Corinthian Christ-believers split in to fractions, with some eating their own lavish meals while other sit hungry (11:21). This problem would by no means be solved by the injunction that the wealthy eat ”at home,” before the celebration of the Lord's supper, as the established but somewhat creative interpretation goes (cf. 11:34). On the other hand, if those of lesser means are encouraged to go into the houses where the Lord's supper is celebrated, as Ma. Marilou S. Ibita (2005) suggests, and the wealthier are exhorted to wait and share (11:33), this would make a significant difference to the present situation of scarcity and malnutrition of the Corinthian poor. Scarcity and malnutrition can be lethal conditions. According to Paul's rhetorical argument, the Lord's supper is a celebration of the death of Jesus, until he comes, and therefore no one should despise the lesser members of the ”church or God” (11:22). Thus the meaning of discerning the ”body of the Lord” may be to recognize its lesser members (cf. 11:29) in the distribution of a scarce food supply.
|
Jesus' Lowliness as a Pastoral Resource: A Psychological Approach to the Seemingly Humble Descent of Christ
Program Unit: Psychological Hermeneutics of Biblical Themes and Texts
Linda Joelsson, Abo Akademi University
We often emphasize Jesus' divinity, but he emphasized his lowliness, or his capacity to identify with the lowly. ”Whoever receives one little child like this in my name receives me” (Mt 18:5). As a prophet who eventually lost everything – honor, shame, and even life – he became a no-body. Only later he recovered his position in the eyes of his followers, who believed that God had raised him from the dead. A senior member of the parish where I serve recently approached me with a question: ”If Mary became pregnant by means of rape by a Roman soldier, what are the losses to us as Christians?” My answer was: ”None – if such a lousy start could turn out this great, we should but marvel.” Since psychological exegesis is concerned with the care of persons, an angle of exploration is how biblical interpretation may contribute to collective and individual health. I will not take a stance concerning the truth of Jesus' descent, but discuss some theological and pastoral implications and indicate the possible relevance of a seemingly humble descent for Jesus' theology. Let us for example imagine that the child in Capernaum, whom Jesus called for and placed before the disciples, was one who by others were called a ”bastard” (cf. Mt 18:2). The following account in Matthew is notably the urgent call that all abuse stop immediately (Mt 18:6-10), and the unsurmised and unsurmountable worth of the hundredth sheep (18:12-14). I will also show that the angelic message to Mary (Lk 1:26-38) remains relevant by means of the psychological concept of disassociation. The subject is uncomfortable to speak about, but I believe that Jesus' incitement to identification with the lowly has accomplished great things in history so far.
|
Intertextuality in 1 Cor 15:54-55: A Call for Comfort or Admonition?
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Steffen Jöris, RWTH Aachen University
In 1 Corinthians 15, Paul reaffirms the belief in the resurrection of Jesus, which also functions as a justification for the Christian faith. Towards the end, he describes the victory over death through Jesus, which includes the saying ‘Death is swallowed up in victory. O death, where is your victory? O death, where is your sting?’ in 1 Cor 15:54-55. It is well known that this saying alludes to Isa 25:8 and Hos 13:14. The function of this intertextual reference remains dubious however, especially since there seems to be no explicit reason why Paul might want to combine these two OT passages. This paper argues for a deliberate intertextual allusion that takes the context of Isa 25:8 and Hos 13:14 into account and shows that Paul’s theological interpretation of the resurrection has a twofold nature that is both comforting and admonishing.
|
What is S? Deconstructing and Constructing Conceptual Foundations
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Jutta Jokiranta, Helsingin Yliopisto - Helsingfors Universitet
"Serekh ha-Yahad" is both an ancient title and a modern construct. This paper seeks to show the ways in which our modern
conceptualization of "S" needs to be deconstructed as regards to
perceiving "completeness" as a guiding principle. What is S and what is not S is by no means clear when manuscript evidence is carefully examined. Deconstruction helps us to start investigating the manuscript plurality and variation in new ways, but constructive new models to think with are needed in order to proceed and pay attention to the ways both ancient scribes and people and modern scholars might perceive conceptual categories organizing their view of the world and information available to them.
|
Authorization of Torah in the Persian Period and Chronicles: Are There Any Connections?
Program Unit: Comparative Studies of Literature from the Persian and Hellenistic Periods
Louis Jonker, Universiteit van Stellenbosch
The weight of the debate on the Persian imperial authorization of the Torah is shifting towards a position where it is generally accepted that the promulgation and acceptance of the Pentateuch as Torah happened in the Persian period and was most-probably influenced by some imperial pressure, but that the primary need arose from the Yehudite community itself. Jean-Louis Ska (Introduction to Reading the Pentateuch, 2006, p. 226) summarizes this position as follows: "The primary purpose of the Pentateuch, for whoever reads it as a whole, is not to regulate life within a province of the Persian Empire but to define the conditions of membership in a specific community called ‘Israel.’ .... The internal justifications are therefore dominant. .... Instead of letting itself be assimilated or become just another province in the vast Empire, Postexilic Israel wanted to safeguard its identity. Persian politics gave it the opportunity to do this." Does this view bring Pentateuch studies and studies on identity negotiation in Chronicles within hearing distance?
|
The Textual Criticism of Ethiopic Obadiah: Issues of Method in the Identification of Families and Their Singular Readings
Program Unit: Textual Criticism: Manuscripts & Methods
Garry Jost, Marylhurst University
My research is part of the Textual History of the Ethiopic Old Testament Project (THEOT), whose work has included a study on the Ethiopic book of Obadiah. An electronic base text was produced from Bachmann’s edition of Obadiah, and then transcriptions were made of 33 manuscripts. This is substantially more than previous studies on the Ethiopic book of Obadiah, and most of these manuscripts have never been transcribed or studied before. Two databases were produced to characterize the textual variations in the manuscripts (one based on verse divisions; the other on smaller textual units), which formed the basis for identification of manuscript families and analysis of those families.
This presentation highlights the methodological approach for this study. Rigorous procedures were in place to ensure accurate transcription of manuscripts. The shared variants were analyzed and entered into a database. I wrote computer scripts to 1) calculate percentages of agreement between each manuscript and each other manuscript, 2) color code ranges of percentages, 3) generate a dendrogram (a statistical tool based on hierarchical clustering) to identify the families, 4) determine which readings are best able to identify a manuscript’s family, 5) determine the “family profile” for each manuscript, and 6) identify which manuscript best represents each family.
Application of this methodology will be demonstrated for the 33 manuscripts transcribed for Obadiah. Application of this methodology enabled us to identify and analyze the following families: Oldest Attested Text (traditionally referred to as “Old Ethiopic,” but this title is problematic), Transitional Texts, Standardized Texts, The Modern Textus Receptus Text, and Non-Indigenous Text. One aspect of the study involves an analysis of the effect of the size of the textual unit (full verses vs. smaller textual units) on family identification.
The presentation will end with a brief discussion on future directions for my research.
|
Orthodox Bible in Oral Tradition among South Slavs Slavonic Apocrypha and Folk Religiosity
Program Unit: Bible in Eastern and Oriental Orthodox Traditions
Ljubica Jovanovic, Vanderbilt University
The love story between Joseph and his wife Aseneth was the creation of Hellenistic imagination about the life of this acclaimed patriarch and beloved son of Jacob, and his Egyptian wife (Gen 41:45). Catalogued by biblical scholars among Pseudepigrapha under the name “Joseph and Aseneth,” this romance was a part of sacred texts among Eastern Churches, with the major manuscripts preserved in Armenian and Slavonic.
Two fifteenth century manuscripts in South-Slavonic translation are regarded by majority of scholars the best witnesses of the story’s Greek original and closest to the Hellenistic tale. In one of the manuscripts (Slav. 306) it is included in the collection of Vitae making it a part of the Orthodox Holy Tradition. The Slavic Orthodox literary heritage was inclined to keep biblical, apocryphal, and pseudepigraphal material alongside each other in the same collections.
The literary heights of which the South Slavonic “Joseph and Aseneth” copies were product, was short living. With the firm establishment of the Ottoman Empire in the area literacy declined, but the textual tradition found its way into oral tradition and was transmitted by illiterate Slavic speaking people of Balkans.
In this paper I will focus on the preservation and dissemination of the South-Slavonic “Joseph and Aseneth,” in folk literature on the example of their love story, “Lines on the Palm of the Hand” recorded at the end of nineteenth century in vicinity of Mostar (Herzegovina).
|
Collecting Transcripts of Serbian Apocryphal Tradition
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Tomislav Jovanovic, University of Belgrade, Serbia
The challenges in collecting and publishing a corpus of a language specific manuscript tradition are rarely discussed at the conferences. The unstable political history of the Balkans in the last centuries has caused the destruction, loss, and dispersion of many manuscripts both in the original languages and in translations of the area. Sometimes locating the transcripts and obtaining their images met with inconceivable obstacles. This presentation will focus on the research on the state and preservation of the manuscripts of Serbian apocryphal biblical traditions.
Having in mind the importance of the Serbian apocryphal tradition in the mosaic of the broader apocryphal literature in Slavonic, I have spent the last two decades in searching for the Serbian transcripts of the biblical Apocrypha and providing digital copies of them. For example, the complete short version of the Hellenistic tale in Greek, Joseph and Aseneth, is preserved only in the Serbian South Slavonic redaction, “The Life and Confession of Aseneth,” and the apocryphal life of Righteous Job is known mainly from its Serbian manuscript tradition. In the process some of the individual manuscripts have been published with a translation in modern Serbian.
However, my wish is to publish, in edited volumes, all the biblical apocrypha in the Serbian tradition. This collection of all texts in one place not only will facilitate scholars of apocrypha but also will make possible the study of the whole corpus in its geographical and literary context of the medieval Serbian literary tradition.
|
Biblical Exegesis in Frederich Nausea’s "A Sermon of the Sacrami[n]t of the Aulter"
Program Unit: The Biblical World and Its Reception (EABS)
Gergely Juhász, Liverpool Hope University
The little-known Catholic Reformer Frederich Nausea (1480-1552) was archbishop of Vienna between 1541 and 1552. He is mainly noted for his attempts to reconcile Protestants with Catholicism, for advocating the reintroduction of married clergy in the Roman Catholic Church as well as communion under both species for the laity and for his role at the Council of Trent, where he eventually met his death. His exegetical scholarship, however, remains mainly unresearched. In 1531 Nausea published in Cologne his Anonymi Philalethi Eusibiani in vitas, miracula, passionesq[ue] Apostolorum Rhapsodiæ, a collection of lives of the apostles (including Paul and Barnabas), “which may be regarded as the first attempt at a collection of apocryphal literature” (Wilhelm Schneemelcher, “On the History of Research into the Apocryphal Literature” in New Testament Apocrypha, Vol. 1, ed. by Wilhelm Schneemelcher and Robert McLachlan Wilson, Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox, 2003, p. 66). The following year his Latin commentary on Tobit came out. His later works, too, reflect his interest in biblical exegesis, not in the least due to its polemical force in debates with Protestants.
This paper examines Nausea’s biblical exegesis John More’s English translation of Nausea’s sermon on the Eucharist (A sermon of the sacrami[n]t of the aulter, London: Rastell, 1533), and argues that Nausea’s use of exegetical arguments published in the context of the Marburg Colloquy (1529) and the literary debates around the Eucharist among Protestants reflect only a partial understanding of the subtleties of the positions within Protestantism and were thus quite ineffective as apologetic means.
|
Matthew’s Source(s) for the Passage in 13:10-17: Mark and Q, only Mark, or Another Source?
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Chang-Wook Jung, Chongshin University
Many scholars claim that Matthew depends on Mark not only for the parable of the soils in 13:3-9, but also for the passage in Mt 13:10-15 placed between the parable and its interpretation. It is suggested that Matthew reconstructs the passage with remarkable freedom, though he relies on Mark’s parallel passage in 4:10-12. It has to be pointed out, however, that there are many differences between Mt 13:10-15 and the parallel passage in Mk 4:10-12. In addition, some instances of minor agreements occur in Mt 13:10-11. It is also remarkable that Matthew’s fulfillment quotation of Isaiah 6:9-10 in 13:14-15 betrays the peculiar features different from the fulfillment quotation in other parts of the Gospel. A better explanation of the differences between two texts is, therefore, that Matthew was not dependent on Mark, but had another source in hand for these verses.
Another problem revolves around vv.16-17, whose parallel verses are not found in Mark, but only in Luke 10:23-24. D.A. Hagner posits that Matthew utilizes the so-called Q for vv. 16-17, though arguing for Matthew’s dependence on Mark for the rest of the passage. In contrast, Mark Goodacre postulates that Matthew does not depend on Q for vv. 16-17; Luke lapses into “editorial fatigue” for the parallel verses in Lk 10:23-24 while editing Matthew. As a result, Q is not required for the passage. In response to Goodacre's argument, Delbert Burkett claims that Luke preserves the more original form of the sayings derived from Q. Which one is correct?
This study will investigate the minor agreements and the differences between Mt 13:10-17 and the parallel passages in Mark and Luke and attempt to determine whether Matthew was dependent on Mark and the so-called Q or another source.
* My paper will fit best the first session.
|
Cognitive and Rhetorical Function of Narration: Hebrews 3
Program Unit: New Testament/Early Christianity/Rabbinic Studies (EABS)
Saara-Maria Jurva, University of Eastern Finland
Hebrews 3 renarrates the story of Israelites in the wilderness. Why this emotionally appealing story appears in the middle of the theological argumentation? How does the author thereby try to affect his audience? In this presentation I will analyze emotions in Heb 3:7–19 as cognitive expressions. I will concentrate on the renarrated story and its function as a part of the author’s persuasive strategy. To this end, I will apply deixis analysis of emotions and modern argumentation analysis. My deixis analysis of emotions combines traditional deixis analysis (Karl Bühler) with emotional deixis (Robin Lakoff) and emotional structures of stories (Patrick Hogan). Moreover, I will ask their function in the argumentative structure (Stephen Toulmin). Emotions motivate people to change their thoughts, values, and behavior. Stories affect emotions. Therefore to study argumentation, one must study stories and emotions. The uses of demonstratives are sometimes emotional. Moreover, narrative time and narrative place are emotional and are connected to neurological process of attachment. In Heb 3 there are lots of references to time, place and persons. My claim is that every reference carries an emotional meaning and is meant to affect the listener’s emotions. In order to concretize the analysis, I will use the diagram familiar from traditional deixis analysis. Understanding how the author manipulates emotions (pathos) does not suffice; one must perceive his reasoning (logos) as well. Toulmin’s model for argumentation analysis will show the argumentative “logic” of emotional structure of the section. The emotional structure of the discourse in Heb 3:7–19 serves the author’s argumentation. The most powerful way to convince the audience is not by cold logic but by telling a story that impacts on their emotions. The retold wilderness experience is an example how to do it.
|
Reading Mark with Marx? Fernando Belo Revisited 40 Years After
Program Unit: Political Biblical Criticism
Brigitte Kahl, Union Theological Seminary in the City of New York
Belo’s “Materialist Reading of the Gospel of Mark ”was published in Paris in 1974. Deeply steeped in the political context of post-68 and pre-89 Western Europe, it was a groundbreaking intervention into the established academic paradigm of ‘value-neutral’ historical criticism in Biblical Studies. Belo, whose circle at that time included Michel Clévenot and Georges Casalis, drew his theoretical framework from an early “bricolage” of today highly acclaimed authors like Althusser, Lacan, Kristeva, Barthes, Deleuze, Balibar, apart from the three “classics”—de Saussure, Freud, and Marx. His work anticipated a wide range of later developments towards ideology-critical, socio-historical, empire-critical, and post-colonial approaches, as well as literary criticism, intersectionality, and cultural anthropology. Yet despite its intellectual sparkle, it never really “arrived” in the academia.
What, at that time and through the lens of an Eastern European context, was the peculiar liberative force, persuasive power and subversive agency of that project ? What were its shortcomings – and how was it disseminated outside the official academic discourse in informal and grass-root groups? From a US-American perspective 40 years later, what is Belo’s lasting impact and ongoing challenge for biblical interpretation today?
|
Sennacherib's Campaign against Judah: A Source Analysis
Program Unit: Bible and Empire
Dan'el Kahn, University of Haifa
The biblical story of Sennacherib's campaign against Jerusalem has been discussed in numerous publications. The majority of scholars concur with the suggestion of Stade, that the narrative was constructed by two different sources: a chronistic record labeled 'A', and two prophetic stories labeled 'B'1 and 'B2'. Stade's hypothesis was further refined by Childs. The Stade-Childs hypothesis has been challenged during the last decades by the Synchronic school. Smelik claimed that there is only one source, and that the repetitions are a literary device to amplify the message of the story. Evans has systematically shown that Stade's division is artificial.He suggested identifying different sources, but he did not pursue his findings. Independently, Young has forwarded a different division based on literary grounds. The works of Smelik, Evans and Young (and many others) ignore historical diachronic considerations. Smelik dates the whole text to the Persian Period (5th century). Young dates his two sources very close to the events (701 BCE). Diachronic studies clearly show that there are different strata, composed in different periods for different purposes..
I will reassess the narrative using combined research methods (historical, literary, syntactic, intertextual, and evolution of religious ideas), in order to identify different strands which are intrinsically interwoven.
I suggest identifying three main literary strands from different historical periods, carrying different messages to their audience:
1. The original sayings of Isaiah from the days of Sennacherib's siege (701 BCE);
2. The decade following the Murder of Sennacherib (681–671);
3. The Babylonian siege on Jerusalem in ca. 588 BCE.
Finally, the Deuteronomist incorporated the story from Isaiah in the Book of Kings making a few minor changes to the Isaiah text.
|
"Will Not Be Found" (2 Pet 3:10): The Previous History of the ECM Conjecture
Program Unit: Textual Criticism: Manuscripts & Methods
Bart Kamphuis, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam - VU University Amsterdam
The New Testament text as established by the UBS committee contains only one conjecture, namely Clericus' proposal for Acts 16:12. The ECM of the Catholic Letters introduces a second emendation into the modern critical text. In 2 Pet 3:10 ouch is added to heurethèsetai: on the day of the Lord the world and everything that is done on it "will _not_ be found." The editors point at Coptic and Syriac manuscripts that have an equivalent of their Greek proposal. Neither the ECM nor publications discussing the ECM conjecture refer to the Dutch scholar who proposed to read ouch heurethèsetai as early as 1853. This paper traces the history of 'will not be found' from Jan Hendrik Holwerda's _De betrekking van het verstand tot het uitleggen van den Bijbel_ until today.
|
Ideas of the Holy
Program Unit: Israel and the Production and Reception of Authoritative Books in the Persian and Hellenistic Period (EABS)
Dolores Kamrada, Pázmány Péter Katolikus Egyetem
To interpret the concept of Torah and that of Sedaqa, it appears worthwhile to place them within a wider context of religious notions in the different traditions of the Hebrew Bible. That kind of analysis may help to shed light on the similarities and differences between the two notions and to try to answer such questions as why the right hand of God is associated with the concept of righteousness. Although the semantic development of Torah and that of Sedaqa can be traced in the biblical texts, the possible cultic and/or mythological background of these two notions can be perceived even in texts from the post-exilic era.
|
Prophetic Christology in Luke and John? Elijah and Elisha Traditions as a Case Study
Program Unit: The Relation Between Luke’s and John’s Gospel (EABS)
Christos Karakolis, University of Athens
This paper will act as an introduction to the workshop dealing with the methodological frame, within which the contact points between Luke's and John's Gospel could be explained. The reception and use of the Elijah and Elisha narrative cycle by the two Gospels will serve as an example. The dependence of Luke and John on these specific OT traditions for unfolding their narrative christology will be examined; On the one hand, the Lucan Jesus bears concrete prophetic traits that remind the gospel's audience of Israel's greatest prophets, Elijah and Elisha, while at the same time demonstrating Jesus as being greater than them. On the other hand, John draws upon the same OT traditions in order to reveal the unbridgeable gap between Jesus and the two aforementioned prophets, thus stating that Jesus' words and deeds can only be understood as God's direct life-giving activity. Finally, the following questions will be addressed: (a) Did the two Gospels share a common oral tradition or are their common elements due to a more complicated interdependence of early Christian traditions? (b) Can we indeed discern common patterns of OT usage in the two Gospels? (c) What are the theological implications of such usage for the Christological discourse of the two Gospels?
|
Envious Brothers Evolving into Enemies of Christ's Cross: Paul's Rhetoric against His Rivals in the Letter to the Philippians
Program Unit: Authority and Influence in Ancient Times
Maria Karyakina, St. Petersburg Christian University
In his letter to the Philippians, Paul uses specific strategy against his personal rivals. Paul believes his leading position within Christian group is authorized by God. The apostle argues that any attempt to challenge his status (i.e. his honor) is in fact rivalry against the only honor bestower – God. Questioning God's line of authority within the in-Christ community, Paul's opponents jeopardize the group's unity and sustainability. It turns out that challenging Paul, they work against the Christian group's interests. These rivals are pictured by Paul against the community, and further, outside this community and finally, opposite to God himself. «Selfish brothers» become enemies of Christ.
|
The Traditional Ethiopian Commentary on 1 Enoch 24–25
Program Unit: Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha
Daniel Assefa, Capuchin Franciscan Institute of Theology
The Traditional Ethiopian Commentary on 1 Enoch 24-25
|
The Contribution of the Georgian Latal-Lectionary to the Creation-Narrative
Program Unit: Septuagint Studies
Albert ten Kate, Orientalist and Minister of the Protestant Church
In its creation-narrative (Genesis 1,1-2,4) the Latal-Lectionary, edited by Daneli et alii in 1997, shows many textual particularities. It is very different from the main Georgian manuscript traditions, as edited by Gigineishvili et alii(1989). Where available, the Sinai-manuscript 34, dating from 10-11th. comes near. It sometimes looks as an abridged form of the Septuagint version.
However, how are all these particularities to be explained? We’ll compare them not only to the other Georgian traditions, but also to all other versions: Hebrew, Aramaic, Greek, Latin, Syriac, Armenian, Coptic, Ethiopian, old-Dutch and also to Lectionaries in that versions. After all, this comparison will reveal that the judgment of M. Tarchnishvili in his Geschichte der kirchlichen georgischen Literatur p. 324 about the value of lectionaries for the textcritic of the Bible has to be revised.
|
Empirical Evidence for Minor Additions in Samuel-Kings
Program Unit: Editorial Techniques in the Hebrew Bible in Light of Empirical Evidence (EABS)
Tuukka Kauhanen, Helsingin Yliopisto - Helsingfors Universitet
This paper presents cases of minor additions in the major Hebrew and Greek textual traditions in Samuel-Kings. Special emphasis is put on the methodology of using indirect evidence (such as quotations by patristic authors) as well as incomplete witnesses (fragmentary texts). Each case presented will be complemented with typologically similar cases of possible additions in which empirical evidence for a shorter text has not been preserved.
|
Did Paul Plan to Escape from Roman Prison? (Phil 1:19-26)
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Mark J. Keown, Laidlaw College
First, in 1:19 he states that “this will turn out for my soteria, which may indicate his expectation of release. Secondly, in v. 22, he tells the Philippians that the outcome of his situation involves his choice (aireo), a choice he will not make known to them (gnorizo). While some soften Paul’s language here to “prefer” and “know”, I will demonstrate that this is flawed. Finally, in v. 25 Paul states that his confidence (pepoithos) and certainty (oida) of his release to come to Philippi.
A variety of solutions have been proposed for this dilemma including: this is after the trial; Paul has received news of his release; he is considering suicide or voluntary death; he has received a word from God; his language is speaking of his preference not choice; he is being rhetorical to demonstrate that he puts the Philippians ahead of his own needs; he is considering bribery.
I will argue that the dilemma in the text may be equally well resolved if Paul has a plan of escape in place if the trial goes unfavourably. This not only satisfies the demands of the text, but can be supported with other arguments including: escape was well known and plausible (if dangerous); Paul has used escape before (2 Cor 11:32); Paul has friends on the inside (Phil 1:13; 4:22); he is sending Timothy and Epaphroditus away from the situation (Phil 2:19, 23, 25); and he himself is certain that he is coming soon (Phil 1:24-26; 2:24).
|
“Docetic” Origins: An Inquiry into the Johannine Literature and the Writings of the Apostolic Fathers
Program Unit: Johannine Literature and Docetism (EABS)
Taras Khomych, Ukrains'kyy Katolyts'kyy Universytet
Many a scholar of early Christianity has tended to recognize the difficulty in tracing the origins of the so-called “Docetism” or “Docetic tendencies”. More recently, however, Guy Stroumsa, in his own JECS 2004 article and in a ZAC 2007 article co-authored with Ronnie Goldstein, claimed to have found the “very historical core of Docetism” in a particular Jewish interpretation of Genesis 22 (the binding of Isaak) and of Psalm 2 (the vain plot against the Messiah), which influenced the understanding of Jesus’ suffering on the cross. In his reconstruction Stroumsa (together with Goldstein) suggests three phases in the development of the Docetic teachings: (1) the rejection of the idea of Christ’s suffering on the cross, (2) broadening of the Docetic attitudes to include also the very idea of incarnation, and finally (3) the Docetic influence on the early Christian understanding of martyrdom. Although attractive in many respects, this theory is not entirely convincing as it relies mainly on the relatively late sources, namely the Nag Hammadi writings from the third or fourth centuries CE plus a few other records of the late second- and early third-century Christian authors. At the same time, this interpretation fails to engage the earliest Christian texts which have been interpreted as referring to the “Docetic tendencies”, such as the Johannine corpus (e.g. 1 John 4:2-3; 2 John 1:7) and the writings of the Apostolic Fathers (especially Ignatius’ Letter to the Smyrneans 2-3 and Polycarp’s Letter to the Philippians 7.1). The purpose of this contribution is to confront Stroumsa’s interpretation with the earliest Christian evidence, which emphasizes the ideas of incarnation and martyrdom, and which does not seem to support the three-fold development theory mentioned above.
|
Responses to Miracles and the Synoptic Problem
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Jordash Kiffiak, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
Whereas earlier studies discussed emotional responses to miracles monolithically—i.e. all are seen as expressions of Wunder—a meaningful pattern emerges across the Synoptic Gospels when a distinction is made between amazement and fear/being troubled. The latter is characteristic in what can be termed epiphanic episodes. Amazement is typical for exorcisms and healings. Analysis of characters and setting confirms the differentiation. In private settings established followers are afraid or troubled at special revelations of Jesus' transcendent nature. In public settings characters relationally more distant to Jesus are amazed at his healing power. The Synoptics have a common distribution pattern for the types of miracle stories. In the first half of their narratives, two or three epiphanies of Jesus, interspersed within the mass of other miracles, reach a peak in the transfiguration. At the end of the narratives are a few (or one) miracle stories, all being epiphanies—Jesus' resurrection appearances and related angelophanies. Interestingly, the patterns of differentiation of miracle types and distribution hold true for a diverse body of material: stories in the triple-tradition, double-tradition, special Lukan, special Matthean, shared Luke-Mark and shared Matthew-Mark material. Surprisingly in John too, though emotional responses are rare, a similar correspondence between characters, settings and types of miracles and a comparable distribution pattern are found. Could common patterns of story-telling, incorporated in an earlier phase of the Jesus tradition, be exerting a sustained influence on the said diverse body of material in the Synoptic Gospels?
|
Responses to Miracles in Mark and Linguistics
Program Unit: Hellenistic Greek Language and Linguistics
Jordash Kiffiak, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
Linguistic analysis of various characters' responses to miracles in Mark helps to bring into focus the text's understanding of the miraculous and its portrayal of Jesus' identity. Previous research has considered the responses in terms of form and narrative criticism. This paper examines the phenomena also with respect to discourse analysis and semantics. The prominence of a response in a given miracle story is analysed, noting background/foreground distinctions as well as prominence among mainline events. Such discourse features as forward-pointing devices (e.g. the historical present), redundant nominal clauses and development marking (d?) are considered. In addition the components of responses are studied—seeing, emotional, verbal, physical and reporting elements. The analysis demonstrates the need to distinguish semantically between amazement and fear/being troubled. The latter is reserved primarily for responses to the most significant miraculous occurrences—Jesus' calming of the storm, his walking on water, his transfiguration and the angelophanic episode pertaining to his resurrection. The study lends support to the categorisation of these episodes as epiphany stories. Amazement is characteristically present in the remaining miracle stories. In the epiphany stories the transcendent aspect of Jesus' identity is most clearly revealed and, thus, the more extreme reaction is depicted.
|
Levirate Marriage: Deuteronomy 25:5-10 and Its Precursors in Leviticus and Numbers
Program Unit: Pentateuch (Torah)
Benjamin Kilchör, Evangelische Theologische Faculteit
In this paper I propose that Deuteronomy 25:5-10 has precursors in Leviticus and Numbers. The levirate marriage picks up the topic of the right to an inheritance of daughters (Numbers 27:1-11) and the related problem that when a daughter marries, the inheritance of her father might switch to another family (Numbers 36:6-12). Furthermore, within the Decalogue orientation of the Deuteronomic law, Deuteronomy 25:5-10 is related to Deut 5:21a and picks up the prohibition of Leviticus 20:21: While it is generally forbidden to take the wife of the brother because this would dishonor him, in the special case of Deut. 25:5 it is even commanded to marry the wife of the brother to preserve his name.
|
Christ Typology in Toni Morrison’s “The Bluest Eye”: Understanding the Bible's Impact on African-American Literature and Identity
Program Unit: New Testament/Early Christianity/Rabbinic Studies (EABS)
Heerak Christian Kim, Asia Evangelical College and Seminary
Bible as literature has had a profound impact on literatures of diverse cultures from all over the world. Perhaps, due to the nature of African-American history, the Bible has had a profound impact on African-American literature. Bible motifs, particularly of slavery, suffering, and salvation, are often interwoven into the very fabric of the African-American fiction, especially in characters and the narrative plot. This is certainly the case with Toni Morrison’s first novel, “The Bluest Eye” and its main character, Pecola Breedlove. Hailed as autobiographical in nature and as the purest embodiment of Toni Morrison’s personal Weltanschauung, “The Bluest Eye” is a window into the impact of the Bible not only on African-American culture but also on a historically significant figure, Toni Morrison, who is the first Nobel Prize Winner in the African-American community. The protagonist, Pecola Breedlove, who encapsulates Toni Morrison’s own personal experience in universalizing terms, in fact, is a type of Christ. In this paper, I compare the life of Pecola Breedlove and the life of Jesus of Nazareth. In particular, I focus on how motifs of slavery, suffering, and salvation in Pecola Breedlove correspond to similar motifs in the life of Jesus of Nazareth as represented in the four Gospels. Through this comparative study, I will illustrate in concrete terms how the Bible has had profound impact on African-American literature and on Toni Morrison, a very important figure in the history of Western civilization.
|
A Reading of the Farewell Discourse (FD) Regarding Its Chiastic Structure as a Key to Some Aporias
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Sang-Hoon Kim, Chongshin University and Seminary
John is written with plain expressions and an easier vocabulary. However, no other book in the NT could be compared to John due to its complexity, both in its styles and structures. Its complexity of styles, repetitions, duplications, and seemingly distracted structures have steadily confused the readers.
From the modern-linear perspective, its complex phenomena are supposedly caused by historical strata (or literary seams) by means of redaction, addition, and revision through many generations, which is assumed by that the literary matrix of writing an ancient text like John, regarding formulating its structure-styles, is the same as one in our modern days. Based on this sense, Johannine aporias are treated as signs of multi-revisions.
In FD, aporias have been also considered. Particularly, there are repetitive expressions both in John 14 and 15-16, arising of the question in terms of how the repetitions and duplicated contents occur. In 14:31, the conversation of Jesus would be over when Jesus says “Get up, let’s go from here,” but why is another discourse presented in John 15-16? Additionally, what is the function of John 17? These aporias are related to the issues of structures and styles in John, leading us to support either the side of undermining the unity of John or one of respecting an authorial (John’s) way of literary composition.
Bultmann, Stagg, Painter, Boyd, and others have negative views that there is no organized structure and designed arrangement in FD. On the other hands, O’Day, Segovia, and those scholars who consider a chiastic structure such as Brown, Keener, Ellis, and Brouwer have observed certain traits of the literary construction.
If it is approved that FD reflects a chiastic structure, how could it help to solve those aporias? Additionally, can we relate the structure of FD to the whole structure of John?
|
Synoptic Cocktails: The Strong Medicine in the Passion Offerings
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Ian Kinman, Fordham University
In all four Gospels offerings of wine are integrated into the crucifixion narrative, but only in Mark and Matthew do these offerings involve a wine-based cocktail. In Mark, Jesus is offered wine mixed with myrrh prior to the crucifixion (Mark 15:23), while in Matthew, the pre-crucifixion cocktail changes to wine mixed with gall (Matt 27:34). Most scholarly work on these two passages attempts to harmonize the different wine cocktails in these two synoptic pericopes by prioritizing one account over the other (cf. Raymond Brown), and/or referring to scriptural precedents or (potentially anachronistic) rabbinic traditions. This paper argues, however, that a single Semitic source likely underlies both versions of the story, and that the wine cocktail offered to Jesus prior to his execution on the cross reflects medicinal and pharmacological traditions of the Hellenistic world.
|
Receiving Vergil in the Roman Empire
Program Unit: The Reception of Classical "Text" in the Greco-Roman World
Angela Kinney, University of Vienna
This paper will discuss reception of the Virgilian corpus in the later Roman empire through late antiquity. The methodology of Virgilian references in prose literature will be a special topic of consideration. When is direct quotation (as opposed to allusion) considered appropriate, even aesthetically preferable in Latin prose? Case studies from pagan and Christian authors will be analyzed. Finally, a couple newly discovered Virgilian quotations in Jerome's translation of the Latin Bible will be presented and discussed.
|
Socrates and Matthew’s Jesus: A Study in Greco-Roman Resonances
Program Unit: The Reception of Classical "Text" in the Greco-Roman World
Robert S. Kinney, University of Bristol
What significance is there to the apparent resonances between Matthew’s presentation of Jesus as a teacher in his Gospel and ancient presentations of Socrates in, for example, Xenophon’s Memorabilia? The Socrates of Xenophon and Plato taught in distinctive ways that seem, on the surface, to correspond to the Jesus of Matthew. This paper will identify resonances and evaluate them for the strength of the correspondence, with the hope of contributing to a larger discussion about the work of the Matthean editor. Issues of didactic authority and the organization of educational communities will be among those considered.
|
“They shall die by sword, by famine, and by pestilence” (Jer 21:9): An Analysis of the Reception of Three Biblical Metaphors in Visual Art from Early Modern Times
Program Unit: Metaphors in the Hebrew Bible/Old Testament and Their Reception
Sara Kipfer, Universität Bern
In depictions from early modern times referring to 2Sam 24 and 1Chr 21 usually a triad has been visualised: a scourge or flagellum representing pestilence, a skull representing famine and a sword representing war (sometimes also stalks of wheat for famine). This triad of sword, famine and pestilence occurs frequently in Jeremiah and Ezekiel (see Jer 14:12; 21:7.9; 24:10; 27:8.13; 29:17.18; 32:24.36; 34:17; 38:2; 42:17.22; 44:13; Ez 5:12.17; 6:11.12; 7:15; 12:16 a.o.) and reflects three aspects of the divine punishment: The sword represents a political disaster, the famine stands for a natural catastrophe and the pestilence refers to a lack of health of the individual.
This paper puts up for discussion whether visual metaphor exists or not. It aims however to demonstrate, that the visualisation of the triad of sword, famine and pestilence is conceptual and categorical. The triad was often represented in visual art from the early modern period and used to visualize divine punishment but also forgiveness and reconciliation (e.g. in the Church of St. Charles Borromeo in Vienna with frescoes from J. M. Rottmayr depicting St. Charles Borromeo begging the Holy Trinity to end the plague).
|
Intersecting Legal Traditions in the Nabataean-Aramaic Texts from Nahal Hever?
Program Unit: Ancient Near East
Sigrid K. Kjær, University of Texas at Austin
Previous scholarship on the Nabataean-Aramaic and Arabic/ANA in the legal texts from Nahal Hever has mainly focused on the Aramaic legal tradition as an over-arching phenomenon, allowing for only limited influence from local legal traditions. A comparison of the vocabulary appearing in Nahal Hever, Mada’in Saleh and in some instances in Ancient North Arabian rock inscriptions with the Aramaic of the Elephantine legal texts reveals a more complex situation. To some extent, the loanwords appearing in the Nabataean-Aramaic legal texts are restricted to specifically legal terms, as opposed to ‘everyday’ vocabulary. On the basis of these observations, I will suggest that the legal tradition found in Nahal Hever is an intersection of a local “Arabian” tradition and the Aramaic legal tradition. Thus, we find two independent legal traditions represented in the texts.
|
Ezekiel 35:1–36:15: The Idea of the Mountains in the Book of Ezekiel
Program Unit: Prophets
Anja Klein, Edinburgh University
Ezekiel 35.1–36.15: The Idea of the Mountains in the Book of Ezekiel
|
Reflections on an Edition of Ethiopic Ezekiel: Agenda for the Future
Program Unit: Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha
Michael Knibb, King's College - London
Reflections on an Edition of Ethiopic Ezekiel: Agenda for the Future
|
Did Solomon of Israel and Huram of Tyre Share a Common Torah? Recasting International Diplomacy and the Jerusalem Temple’s Construction in Chronicles
Program Unit: Comparative Studies of Literature from the Persian and Hellenistic Periods
Gary Knoppers, Pennsylvania State University
Chronicles redefines the relationship between Solomon of Israel and Huram (Hiram) of Tyre from that of cooperative equals (a parity treaty in Kings) to that of happy unequals (Solomon as a generous, but authoritative suzerain and Huram as his loyal client). Even more fascinating is the melding of the Tabernacle and the Temple in the international diplomatic correspondence between the two leaders. The choice of building materials and furnishings reveals an impressive acquaintance with the legislation governing the construction of the Tent of Meeting in Exodus. Given that both Solomon and Huram actively participate in the effort to make the Temple more Tabernacle-like, the narrative raises questions about the international status of the Torah in the alternative reality Chronicles creates.
|
Byzantinisches Christentum und Islam: Überlegungen zum Transfer Biblischer und Christlicher Glaubensinhalte in Spätantike und Frühmittelalter
Program Unit: The Reception of the Bible in Greco-Roman Tradition
Johannes Koder, University of Vienna
Thema des Beitrags ist die Vermittlung von Wissen über biblische Glaubensinhalte und christliche Kultformen von Byzantinern an Araber, im Osten des Byzantinischen Reiches und in arabischen Herrschaftsgebieten. Hierbei wird das Augenmerk auf konkrete Möglichkeiten, wie öffentlich wirksame kultische Handlungen, Kontaktorte (insbesondere Heiligtümer und Pilgerstätten) und das soziale Milieu einzelner Informanten gerichtet. Der chronologische Schwerpunkt liegt hierbei in der Zeit der Entstehung des Islam, also im frühen 7. Jahrhundert, als der byzantinische Kaiser Herakleios (ca. 575-641) politisch aktiv war und der Prophet Mohammed (ca. 570-632) seine religiösen Aktivitäten entfaltete.
Anschließend werden kurze Überlegungen zum christlich-muslimischen Dialog zwischen Byzantinern und Muslimen angestellt, wobei hier die frühen Phasen im Kontext der „Abbasidischen Renaissance“ bzw. der „Makedonischen Renaissance“ im 9. Jahrhundert den Ausgangspunkt bilden.
|
Luke’s Representation of Paul as Interpreter of the Scriptures in the Book of Acts
Program Unit: Schriftrezeption bei Paulus und in der Paulustradition: Reception of Scripture in Paul and Pauline Tradition
Bart J. Koet, Universiteit van Tilburg
Die Apostelgeschichte zeichnet ein hoch differenziertes Bild des paulinischen Auftretens in verschiedensten Kontexten – sei es in einer jüdischen Synagoge Kleinasiens oder auf der Agora Athens, vor dem Hohen Rat in Jerusalem oder beim römischen Statthalter in Cäsarea. Diese Darstellung ermöglicht es zu prüfen, wie in lukanischer Sicht die jeweilige Kommunikationssituation, in der Paulus seinen Sendungsauftrag zu erfüllen sucht, den Rückbezug auf die Heilige Schrift beeinflusst.
|
Ezekiel 34 and 37: The Current State of Research
Program Unit: Prophets
Michael Konkel, Theologische Fakultät Paderborn
Ezekiel 34 and 37: The Current State of Research
|
What’s in a Name? A New Look at the Midrashic Significance of 'Rizpah, Daughter of Ayah' in 2 Samuel 21
Program Unit: Literary Features – Fact or Fiction (EABS)
Ekaterina Kozlova, University of Oxford
While agreeing with the intuition of other scholars that Rizpah’s name is crucial for her appearance in 2 Sam. 21 this paper will take a different route in investigating its symbolism. Against the theories offered before it will argue that ritspah bat ’ayyah – a glowing coal, a daughter of light/ lamp - taps into the registry of ominous cross-cultural idioms related to endangered heirs and confronts David regarding his breach of an oath given to Saul to protect his male descendants (1 Sam. 24:21-22). Since the focus of the vow exacted from David addressed the perpetuity of Saul’s house formulated as his seed and his name, concepts that in their socio-religious significance overlap with those subsumed under the glowing coal metaphor its violation is exposed by Rizpah’s extended vigil. Overlaid with ritspah bat ’ayyah, a double cryptonym for annihilated offspring, the mount-side solitary mourning implicates the king in the Sauli-cide, and thus in the act of oath breach, becoming an impetus to take measures against punitive cataclysms on David’s own house and a second wave of penal plagues on his nation. In support of this reading the paper will consider: 1.) the development of 2 Sam. 21:1-14 around the issue of remnants and broken oaths; 2.) glowing coals as a cross-cultural cipher for endangered heirs in ANE; 3.) archaeological evidence on the cultic significance of lamps; and 4.) the Deuteronomist’s use of the ner ideology in connection with David and his dynasty. Thus it will be argued that in the precarious matter of regal succession in 2 Sam. 21:1-14 the use of ritspah bat ’ayyah - a fossilized formula for heirs/ remnants in jeopardy – is uniquely correlated with the concerns of the Gibeonite episode and thus is not accidental.
|
‘A Woman Will Encompass a Man’: A Ritual Response to the Babylonian Crisis in Jeremiah’s Poetry (Jer 31:22b)
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Ekaterina Kozlova, University of Oxford
This paper will focus on the enigmatic statement in Jer. 31:22b - ???? ????? ???. Against the diverse readings of vs. 22b it will suggest that this clause is a stanza that belongs to the funerary stratum of the restoration programme in Jeremiah’s wider context and in the Book of Consolation in particular. More specifically, it will be argued that the cryptic ???? ????? ??? may refer to a funerary rite of circumambulation performed by Rachel around her posterity poetically cast as a dead child.
This reading will emerge when the following issues are given consideration: 1.) compositional structure of Jer. 31:15-22 that calls for a rhetorical correlation of vs. 15 and 22b; 2.) the meaning of ‘a new thing’ identified with provisions for the journey home, i.e. ???? and ???, not the statement in vs. 22b; 3.) Jeremiah’s use of ‘metaleptic’ traditions – the figure of Rachel and the location of her grief - that exacerbate the poignancy of its presentation of crisis and demand strong mortuary responses; 4.) the use of ??? in Qoh. 12:5 and its comparability to Jer. 31:15-22; 5.) the kinaesthetic nature of grieving process and ANE evidence for funerary dances; and 6.) archaeological evidence for women involved in music production and its possible connection to funerary dances. Since Jeremiah’s presentation of Judah’s collapse is marked by a rampant violation of Judah’s dead it will be shown that the prophet’s ‘mortuary’ agenda seeks to override these desecrations and through Rachel’s ritual circumambulations salvages and posthumously confers honour on the dead nation.
|
Reception and Interpretation of Greek Psalm 90[91]:11-13 in the NT and by Christian Writers
Program Unit: Biblical Interpretation in Early Christianity
Thomas J. Kraus, Willibald Gluck Gymnasium
Greek Psalm 90 [91 according to the Masoretic Text] is an astounding text. But it is not the text only that is so outstanding, it is its extraordinary transmission and reception history as witnessed by a vast variety of archaeological objects. Moreover, Vv. 11-12 are cited in Luke 4:10-11 (par. Mt 4:6] by the "diabolos" but not V. 13 (with the four animals). This paper sheds light on the various approaches of (early) Christian writers and their interpretations of Greek Psalm 90:11-12 [and 13] in Luke 4:10-11 and how they dealt with 90:11-13 (!) as a unity.
|
Towards a More Magical Text? Septuagint Psalm 90 in relation to Hebrew Psalm 91
Program Unit: Septuagint Studies
Thomas J. Kraus, Willibald Gluck Gymnasium
Greek Psalm 90 is the most attested Biblical text, even far ahaed the Lord's Prayer, when it comes to archaeological objects with verses from this psalm and with an apotropaeic function. Interestingly, its Hebrew equivalent was already predestined to function as such, i.e., as a protection against all sorts of evil and was (officially) defined that way. But what about the relationship between the Hebrew and the Greek version of the psalm? In this paper I opt and argue for a clearly identifiable tendency of intensifying and clarifying certain aspects of the Hebrew version in the Greek version so that LXX-Psalm 90 had eventually become the ideal magical apotropaeic text, as which it functions up to the present.
|
Synagogues as Thirdspace in Josephus’ Bellum Judaicum
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Andrew R. Krause, McMaster University
One of the enduring issues relating to the reconstruction of various ancient Jewish institutions, including synagogues, through the writings of Flavius Josephus has been that of methodology. While many scholars speak of synagogues as being portrayed ‘as they were’ by the historian, others speak of idealized and rhetorically-shaped versions of such institutions. However, current spatial theory provides a new way of combining these two tendencies. According to the Thirdspace theories of Edward Soja, all spaces are experienced as a trialectic of space ‘as it is’ (perceived or firstspace), its ideal (conceived or secondspace), and the combined experience of both actual and ideal space (lived or thirdspace). This paradigm allows the scholar to map the interface between the actual and the ideal in such a way as to embrace and understand both aspects. Using this theory, I will analyse various texts that provide potentially relevant data for the study of ancient synagogues. Firstly, I will address the synagogue of Caesarea Maritima narrative in B.J. 2.285–92. This synagogue was experienced as bound space at both the community and geo-spatial levels, as the Syrians transgressed both the synagogue itself and the entire Land of Israel through their incursion of the synagogue in this medial city. Secondly, I will discuss the more complicated issue of intercultural ideals (i.e., secondspace) in the use of the term 'hieros' for synagogues in numerous texts (B.J. 4.407–8; 6.122; 7.44–45, 143–44) as a case in which Josephus is using the ideals of his Roman readers rather than his own ideals. Thirdspace theory illuminates the relationship between the space as it was, the space as conceived, and the space as it was experienced, all of which allows for greater understanding of both Josephus’ truth claims and his rhetorical shaping of this history, thus eschewing simplistic, purely historicised readings.
|
Chapter 21 of the Gospel of John as an Ecclesiological Relecture of John 1–20 in the Community of the Beloved Disciple
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Janusz Krecidlo, Uniwersytet Kardynala Stefana Wyszynskiego
John 21 is characterized by many stylistic patterns not found in John 1 – 20. There is a significant narrative disruption between the two units as well. Why and when, then, chapter 21 was added to the already finished Gospel? The aim, the nature and the time of this addition is still debated and a satisfactory explanation has not been given yet. My purpose is to show the pragmatic strategy of the author in adding John 21 to chapters 1 – 20 and to demonstrate what impact it has for the interpretation of the Fourth Gospel. By examining main narrative features I will show that chapter 21 is narratively cohesive with the rest of the Gospel. The cohesion is based above all on the fact that despite the previous conclusion of the Gospel in 20, 30-31 and the differences in style and wording the narration of the 21 chapter is put by the author as a continuation and finalization of the whole narration. Further I want to demonstrate in which way the motifs from chapter 21 interact intertextually with Joh 1 – 20. By means of the technique of relecture I will demonstrate how the author of Joh 21 repragmatizes and recontextualizes the massage of Joh 1 – 20. My conclusion is that the chapter 21 was written on the last phase of the development of Johannine community when its members wanted to be implanted in the stream of the so-called “Great Church” under the leadership of Peter. The repragmatization of the message of Joh 1 – 20 that can be detected in the chapter 21consists above all in directing the Christological orientation of the corpus of the Fourth Gospel towards its ecclesiological understanding.
|
Remembering the Past: Classical Greek Culture in the Dionysiaca of Nonnus of Panopolis
Program Unit: The Reception of Classical "Text" in the Greco-Roman World
Nicole Kröll, The University of Vienna
The aim of this contribution is to highlight how Nonnus of Panopolis inserts topographical sites, historical persons and mythological characters that are typical for the classical and Hellenistic Greek culture into his Dionysiaca. Through the mirror of late antique epic, special attention will be paid to the relationship between Greece and the Eastern Mediterranean world. By implementing various poetical techniques, as it will be argued, Nonnus absorbs and transforms outstanding events and traditions of the Greek past into his own late antique era and thereby participates in the shift of Greek culture towards the East.
|
Bibelrezeption im Heiligen Land: Der Beitrag der Proskynetaria ton Hagion Topon
Program Unit: The Bible in Byzantium: The Use and Abuse of Tradition
Andreas Külzer, Österreichische Akademie der Wissenschaften
*
|
Seed, Syntax, and Solecism in Rom 9:7
Program Unit: Hellenistic Greek Language and Linguistics
Raju Daniel Kunjummen, Moody Theological Seminary–Michigan
In Romans 9:7, almost all English versions follow the KJV, agreeing with the Vulgate. The translation is problematic, because it reverses the referential scope of sp??µa and t???a, contradicting 9:8. NRSV’s, “and not all of Abraham's children are his true descendants,” either ignores the placement of sp??µa and t???a, or admits of a solecism, of p??te? being attributive to t???a. However, the verse can be understood without entertaining a semantic anomaly or solecism, merely by construing the syntax differently.
Pauline usage of sp??µa in Romans 9:7-8 refers to Hebrew ????? as occurs in the patriarchal promises. The contextual argument is that the promise applies to a narrower subset than the totality of Abrahamic (or Israel’s) descendants. Interpretation of the clause structure of Rom 9:7 is constrained by the masculine plural p??te? in the middle, which cannot be attributive to either sp??µa or t???a since they are both neuter. This requires p??te? to be a subject with the same antecedents as in v. 6, and ?t? was read causally.
The issue has a simple and grammatical resolution by taking the ?t? of 9:7 as complementizer, not causal. Secondly, the sentence should end with ?ß?a?µ, and the verbless clause p??te? t???a go with what follows. Resultant translation of 9:6c-8: “For not these, all who are part of Israel, are Israel; nor is it that they are the offspring of Abraham. All are children, but, ‘In Isaac your offspring shall be called.’ That is, not these, the children of the flesh, are the children of God, but the children of the promise are reckoned for offspring.” The scriptural citation in the passage is no more abrupt than elsewhere in the Pauline corpus. This reading deserves consideration since it relieves the passage of the glaring anomaly noted above.
|
Worldwide Athletes of Christ? Associations of Athletes and Performers, and Translocal Links in the Early Christian Movement
Program Unit: Graeco-Roman Society (EABS)
Dominika Kurek-Chomycz, Liverpool Hope University
The significance of voluntary associations and the way in which they functioned in the Roman Empire for the study of early Christianity has in the last decade received considerable scholarly attention. Richard Ascough already in his 1997 JECS article questioned the widespread assumption concerning the alleged contrast between the supposedly localised nature of associations as opposed to the translocal character of nascent Christianity. While attested in the case of some other voluntary associations, a clearly translocal character seems to have been typical of two professional groups in particular, namely athletes and performers, both of which in the Imperial period were often referred to as “worldwide” (?p? t?? ?????µ????). Even though this has been noted by Ascough and others, the similarities and differences between those associations of ‘global players’, to use Onno van Nijf’s helpful term, and early Christian communities, have not been fully explored. Building on the work of classicists and historians of antiquity, and especially van Nijf’s suggestion to interpret the associations of performers and athletes against the background of ‘ancient globalisation”, in the present paper I propose to examine the translocal character of these associations in some more detail. In the second part of my presentation I consider its potential for our understanding of the development of the early Christian movement as attested in the NT writings, with a focus on the Pauline literature and Acts of the Apostles. While my main interest is in the translocal aspect, I suggest also that epigraphical and papyrological evidence pertaining to the associations of performers and athletes sheds light on some other aspects of the Pauline letters, Paul’s theatrical and athletic metaphors more specifically.
|
The Way of War: Julius Wellhausen in Wilhelmine Germany
Program Unit: Bible and Its Influence: History and Impact
Paul Michael Kurtz, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
“War is what makes nations,” added the Bismarckian Julius Wellhausen to the second edition of his ambitious Israelitische und jüdische Geschichte nigh two decades before the onslaught of the First World War. Though not nearly as overt as Alfred Bertholet’s Religion und Krieg and Altes Testament und Kriegsfrömiggkeit, Otto Eissfeldt’s Krieg und Bibel, Hermann Gunkel’s Israelitisches Heldentum und Kriegsfrömmigkeit im Alten Testament, or Rudolf Kittel’s Das Alte Testament und unser Krieg, Wellhausen’s academic oeuvre—as with those of many German mandarins—beat the early drums of nationalism nonetheless, instruments crafted already in German Romanticism. His colleague and confidant Ulrich von Wilamowitz-Moellendorff could even recall Wellhausen’s later grief for having no son to sacrifice upon the altar of war. Exploring his affinity for a “heroic” book of Judges, a distaste for “late Jewish” texts especially marked by aversion to combat, and a description of war transitioning from the province of religion to that of civil society, this paper will analyze the chauvinistic dimensions of Wellhausen’s monumental Prolegomena zur Geschichte Israels, “Israel,” and Israelitische-jüdische Geschichte and situate his historiography in fin-de-siècle Germany, a context characterized by international exchange and national jingoism alike. Through the topic of war particularly, this study will engage Wellhausen’s more implicit assumptions of religion and state more generally, the two being tightly bound together. Beyond that philhellenism which prevailed throughout Wilhelmine Germany, the paper at hand will demonstrate how concerns of the present made their way into portrayals of the past, how Israelite history became a German one writ small.
|
"I will make of you a great nation” (Gen 12:2): The Place of Keturah and Her Sons in the Divine Promise to Abraham
Program Unit: Pentateuch (Torah)
John Kwofie, Duquesne University
The Book of Genesis has two descriptions of Keturah in a passage where she is featured (Gn 25:1-6). She is referred to as "wife" of Abraham in Gn 25:1 but one of the "concubines" in Gn 25:6 (cf. 1Chron 1:32). Abraham, in his old age and after the death of Sarah, had six sons with her. Keturah is brought into the narrative in a passage that looks like a redactional addition and then hurriedly disappears. She says nothing and does nothing in the text. The Keturah’s pericope covers only six verses in the book of Genesis yet she bore six children with Abraham. We have some questions to ask: Who was Keturah and why is she insignificant in the narrative? What explains this near-disinterestedness in Keturah and her sons? What is their place in the divine promise made to Abraham (Gn 12:1-3)? How do we read this unit in the wider context of the stories of the patriarchs and matriarchs? The expression “sons (descendants) of Keturah” is strange as it defies the norm of patriarchal society where the defining genitive is the name of the father. I am interested in knowing how she and her sons were given gifts and sent forth to the east “to the land of Kedem, away from his son Isaac” (Gn 25:6).
Literature on Keturah and, indeed, on the passage Gn 25:1-6 is quite scanty; thus justifying the need for this study. By means of a narrative critical method, I shall investigate the artistic structure of the text, its message and the response it asks of the reader. I will also give attention to form and redactional matters. I am of the opinion that historical critical considerations must merge with narrative critical applications for an understanding of an ancient text.
|
Problems of the Comparative Study between Job and Deutero-Isaiah
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Wisdom
Ji Seong Kwon, University of Durham
Biblical scholars have produced a variety of arguments in terms of the literary relationship between the book of Job and the second part of Isaiah, so-called Deutero-Isaiah. The general methodology in such a comparative study has usually been the intertextual study between corresponding texts considering many verbal and thematic similarities, which has been more prevalent than before, since Michael Fishbane’s book, Biblical Interpretation in Ancient Israel, introduced the methodology to biblical scholarship. In the inner-textual study which by and large relies on the linguistic affinities, verbal patterns and unique terms widely gathered from parallel verses have been proposed as definite evidence by which the two books have a distinctive relationship in the Hebrew Bible. However, the specific literary association between texts would principally be founded upon several misconceptions. Firstly, based on the formal theory of intertextuality, scholars have addressed the literary dependence by saying that the earlier book has directly influenced the writing of the later book throughout the process of the author’s literary edition. Secondly, the author utilized as the origin of similarity the Israelite’s literary tradition such as the wisdom tradition and prophetic tradition. These assumptions, as I suppose, have restricted understanding the nature of resemblances in texts and the genuine relationship between texts. Accordingly, although, in recent decades, scholars have identified the distinctive relationship between Job and Deutero-Isaiah with numerous verbal parallels and common themes, their claims to address the distinctive relationship seem to be doubtful. Thus, my claim in this paper as an alternative of previous researches is that those resemblances between two biblical materials are produced by and originate from the shared ideological and cultural background from various oral and written texts.
|
Understanding the Scribal Culture in the Wisdom and the Prophetic Traditions
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible/Old Testament/Ancient Israel Studies (EABS)
JiSeong Kwon, University of Durham
Biblical interpreters have observed broad linguistic resemblances and even striking verbal parallels between wisdom literature and prophetic literature. They have mostly interpreted the cause of affinity in the perspective of literary ‘dependence’ between texts and frequently have emphasized the mutual influence of literary traditions, both the wisdom and the prophetic traditions. However, this method seems to depend on several misconceptions, namely, that different social contexts and literatures in the Hebrew Bible were produced by separate professional groups in Israelite society such as priests, sages and prophets. Other than this conventional explanation, as the new method in understanding the social context, Egyptologists and Assyriologists have noticed ‘scribes’ as a literate elite class who were involved in writing and preserving ancient texts. And, biblical scholarship in recent times has increasingly considered the significance of a Jewish scribal class, educated and intellectual elites as the major origin of biblical materials. Furthermore, several scholars such as Philip R. Davies, David M. Carr and Karel van der Toorn (Davies 1998; Carr 2005; Toorn 2009) have accepted the significance of Jewish scribal culture in comprehending the production of biblical materials. This new model of scribal culture to explain the origin of biblical literature, however, has not been widely accepted. Most biblical scholars have explained the shared ideas between biblical materials with conventional assumptions of form criticism. Therefore, in this paper, using the example of linguistic similarities between Job and Deutero-Isaiah, I will examine the importance of understanding the Jewish scribal culture in the wisdom and prophetic contexts, and then will present several problems which the conventional model has.
|
A Community and a City: Ephesus, the First One, but How Long? The Portrait of Ephesus according to Rev 2:1-7
Program Unit: Early Christianity (EABS)
Michael Labahn, Martin-Luther-Universität Halle-Wittenberg
Every narrative develops its own geographical agenda and its own cultural code. This is also true with regard to the seven cities of the communities addressed by the seven messages in Revelation 2-3. Ephesus is presented according to the narrative setting, which means that it is portrayed as the place where a Christian community lives and acts; Ephesus is, even more than that, presented according to the reasoning of a heavenly / godly perspective.
Interestingly enough, the main and most important city of the Roman province of Asia is mentioned in first place, but important data from ancient cultural encyclopedia are not included neither with regard to the city itself nor to the Christian community.
The paper will address the narrative portrait of the city via the message to the Christian community in Ephesus and ask for the place in the narrative world. It seems that not only the city is mentioned first among the seven cities in Rev 2-3, but it seems to be that the self-understanding of its community is of high self-estimation which is put under severe critique. If the first love is missing, the community will lose its counterpart in heaven which comes along with a loss of salvation (2:5). It might be asked if this is also an indication that the city of Ephesus with all its power is also an entity in quest. Further, the place of those who will conquer is a better place compared with Ephesus, it is the tree of life in Paradise (2:7). Again, the meaning of Ephesus is taken into question.
|
Tracing the Source of the Flood: The Development of Jewish Nilotic Perspectives in Ptolemaic and Roman Egypt
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Nathalie LaCoste, University of Toronto
This paper investigates Jewish understandings of the source of the Nile flood. Through an analysis of three Jewish Exodus narratives composed in Egypt (Artapanus’ On the Jews, the Wisdom of Solomon, and Philo of Alexandria’s Life of Moses), I will demonstrate how the Jews developed unique perspectives on the Nile’s origins in Ptolemaic and Roman Egypt. Despite the fact that all three texts were composed by Jews, each text approaches the Nile’s flood differently. Artapanus’ On the Jews, preserved by Eusebius, attributes the rise of the Nile waters to Moses. The Wisdom of Solomon describes the flood’s “life-giving” waters as originating from a “perrenial spring” (Wisdom 11.6). Moreover, in Life of Moses, Philo describes the necessary appeal to the divine in ensuring a quality flood (Mos. 1.6), a popular Egyptian belief, and explains that the cause of the flood can be attributed to the meeting of two streams and the increased winds that prevented the river water from flowing easily into the sea (1.114).
The perspectives of Artpanus, Wisdom of Solomon, and Philo share similarities with Greek and Egyptian ideas, but ultimately show that Jews developed their own conceptions of their surroundings based on their personal experiences living in the land of Egypt and through their cultural interactions with neighboring peoples. In other words, the Jews used their environment—both physical and cultural—as inspiration when constructing their own ideas about the Nile and specifically the origins of the flood. It was both the experiences of living in Egypt as well as the adoption of the surrounding beliefs that enabled the development of a distinctive Jewish-Egyptian identity.
|
The Rise and Fall of the Imperial Cult Temples at Ephesos
Program Unit:
Sabine Ladstätter, Austrian Archaeological Institute
At Ephesos, two monumental sites are associated with the worship of the Roman emperor. The first is a large terraced area erected on mighty substructures to the west of the Upper Agora. In the center of the terrace a temple, completely destroyed today, once stood. This area is generally identified as the imperial cult temple for Domitian and subsequently for the Flavian dynasty. A second, massive cult area was erected during the course of the second century to the north of the Harbour Baths. The identification of this structure as the provincial temple for Emperor Hadrian in the guise of Zeus Olympios is primarily based on the dating of the architectural decoration and the colossal scale of the temple. For both the so-called Temple of Domitian and for the so-called Olympieion, however, decisive evidence for a secure identification as imperial cult temples is so far lacking. In recent years, extensive geophysical surveying has been carried out at both sites. Furthermore, excavations on the terrace of the so-called Temple of Domitian have brought new evidence to light, particularly regarding the destruction of the temple and the altar, and the late antique usage of the area. The results support the assumption that the area was deliberately destroyed. Subsequently, prestigiously equipped buildings were set up on the former terrace, the function of which has not been unequivocally clarified. Their installation, however, is clearly Christian.
In the presentation, all of the known imperial temple sites at Ephesos will be introduced in relation to each other, and the indications for their identification will be critically evaluated. In addition, the results of the surveys and excavations will be presented and the consequences for the construction, usage, and also the destruction and transformation of the temples will be discussed.
|
Bet Ha-Midrash, Its Significance for the Development of a Rabbi-Seminary in Vienna
Program Unit: The Reception History of the Bible in the Wissenschaft des Judentums of the Viennese Bet Ha-Midrash
Peter Landesmann, Universität Wien
The so-called "Bet Ha-Midrash" was founded in 1863 at the suggestion of Rabbi candidates, who came to Vienna after their orthodox yeshiva studies in the eastern parts of Europe. They wanted to obtain the PhD at the Vienna University, but at the same time they wished also to receive modern instructions on Judaism.This conflict between "orthodoxy" and "reform" characterizes the development of this institute.
|
Seers, Fictions, and Other World(s)
Program Unit: Science Fiction and the Bible (EABS)
Francis Landy, University of Alberta
At a class on Kabbalah I gave at our synagogue the other week someone got very offended when I described apocalyptic as ancient science fiction. I was trying to make the point that science fiction in our world occupies the same niche as apocalyptic, as the revelation of strange worlds, and hence of the strange possibilities that open up to the human mind- or time-traveller. I was influenced by Jeffrey Kripal’s argument in Authors of the Impossible (2010) and Mutants and Mystics (2011) that the paranormal is enacted in story, and that the sacred is displaced into different kinds of alternative reality. The person who objected was incensed because science fiction is “fiction” and the ancients really believed in their otherworldly adventures. Irrespective of the truth of this assumption, it raises the question of the relationship of fiction and reality, as well as the past and the future. Laura Feldt, in her wonderful book on the fantastic in biblical narrative, has argued that fantastic stories, particularly the Exodus and the Elijah-Elisha narratives, disorient the reader, and are there for the sake of the future, their re-enactment and recapitulation. They are the future in the past. Through fiction we have the opportunity of inhabiting other, and often counter-intuitive, realities which may seem more true than our everyday lives. We learn to live in these fictional worlds, as Thomas Pavel has shown, through a process of bringing to bear our empirical knowledge and gaining insight from those worlds. A reader of fiction is suspended between belief and disbelief, hesitates as to what is veridical. Science fiction may be a metaphor for the mind, for the limitless possibilities of human imagining, just as the biblical writers stretch the boundaries of the possible and irretrievable.
|
Stichometry as a Useful Tool in Reconstructing the Original Disposition
Program Unit: Methods in New Testament Studies
Friedrich G. Lang, Evangelical-Lutheran Church of Württemberg
The paper is supposed to summarize and discuss the methodological presuppositions and implications of the stichometrical approach.
Some astonishing proportions found by chance are listed at the beginning: units of the same size in terms of Nestle25-lines e.g. in Acts 7, or Mk 3:7-8:21 as one third of Mark’s Gospel, or the “golden ratio” between Mt 5-7 and 8:1-9:34. How is an ancient author able to realize such proportions?
The rediscovering of the “stichos” is reported in a second step: the definition of a unit of 15 syllables as the standard measure in ancient Greek prose, its function for publishers and libraries, and esp. its use in rhetorical instruction and in literary production.
By counting the “stichoi” of New Testament writings it was discovered that the authors often used a modulus of 8, 13, 21, or 34 “stichoi”. These numbers belong to a sequence called Fibonacci series today. It was already known by ancient mathematicians. The ratio of two successive numbers is approaching the “golden ratio”.
Some astonishing examples may prove how the stichometrical analysis confirms the outline found by thorough analysis of contents. The disposition of the seven writings with a total sum of more than 1000 “stichoi” (Mt, Mk, Lk, John, Act, Rom, Rev) is discussed in detail. Their overall modulus is 34 “stichoi”, what is demonstrated in the size of the main parts. Four times the prologue has exactly this size, in John and Romans it’s divided in parts of 13 and 21.
Thesis: The authors of the New Testament elaborated the disposition of their writings very carefully. In terms of aesthetics most writings can be regarded as “high literature”.
|
‚Nützlich‘ in den Richtigen Händen: Schriftrezeption in den Pastoralbriefen
Program Unit: Schriftrezeption bei Paulus und in der Paulustradition: Reception of Scripture in Paul and Pauline Tradition
Markus Lang, Universität Wien
Der Schriftrezeption kommt bei dem Versuch, einen vermutlich innergemeindlichen Konflikt durch die Betonung einer institutionell verfassten Gemeinschaft mit klarer Rollenverteilung zu lösen, nur eine sekundäre Rolle zu. Obwohl ein durch das „Alte Testament“ geprägter Gedankenhorizont vorliegt und die „Lehre“ mehrfach betont wird, steht die autoritative Funktion der „paulinischen“ Tradition im Zentrum der Argumentation; ihr wird die Autorität der Schrift bei- bzw. untergeordnet.
|
Thoughts on a Tradition History of the Flood Story
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Traditions in the Biblical World and Beyond
Martin Lang, Leopold-Franzens-Universität Innsbruck
The Flood Story as preserved in and transmitted by the Hebrew Bible might be understood as a product of cultural contacts and cultural transfer, that is of reception and adaption. The plot itself is considerably older and shows within the Mesopotamian literary tradition signs of changes within it chronological transmission. The paper will point out that and how during the longue durée of the Mesopotamian written tradition, meanings and perceptions of these texts had changed, were creatively adapted and enriched with new symbolism and also showing sign of intertextuality. Finally they were embedded into new contexts.
|
Rewriting the Heritage of the Other: Antisemitic Readings of the Exodus Narrative
Program Unit: Anti-Semitic Readings of the Bible
Armin Lange, University of Vienna
Rewriting the Exodus Narrative was one of the main means to anti-semitic polemics in pagan Greco-Roman literature from Manetho to Tacitus and beyond. The Jews were ridiculed as godless lepers and worse. In this way, anti-semitic authors tried to implant into the Jewish cultural memory and the extra-Jewish recognition of Judaism an inacceptable component. They intended to destroy Jewish identity both inside and outside Judaism by way a destructive form of antisemitic intertextuality. Not only this strategy but also many of the anti-semitic topoi of pagan Greco-Roman literature continue to have an effect as of today.
|
Between Messiah and Halakhah: Jeremiah 33:14–26 and Its Reception in Judaism and Christianity
Program Unit:
Armin Lange, Universität Wien
The reception history of the Bible is among the richest treasures in the cultural history of the world. It illuminates how sacred texts acquire new meanings when they are read in the ever changing cultural contexts of their interpreters. But next to these treasures of meaning, the reception history of the Bible is coined by hermeneutic conflict between religious and denominational communities. In my opening address I will illustrate both aspects of the Bible’s reception with the example of the Two-Covenants-Prophecy in Jer 33:14-26. As a Masoretic long text, the Two-Covenants-Prophecy is itself already a part of the reception history of the book of Jeremiah. It interprets the metaphor that shepherds will herd their flock in Jerusalem once again (Jer 33:12-13) as a promise of an unbroken rule of the royal house of David and of an unbroken priestly service in the Jerusalem temple. Ancient Jewish interpretations understood the Two-Covenants-Prophecy as an eschatological and Messianic promise. The emergence of Christological interpretations of the Two-Covenants-Prophecy in late ancient Christian literature led to an interpretative shift in Judaism. Rabbinic literature discusses the Two-Covenants-Prophecy only with regard to the eternal covenant of circumcision and the eternal existence of the Torah.
|
Halakha and Narrative in Leviticus Rabbah
Program Unit: Midrash, Halakhah and Reception
Gerhard Langer, Universität Wien
Leviticus Rabbah has been described by Burton Visotzky as a miscellany of rabbinic tradition, which differs from the mainly halakhic midrash Sifra. But Leviticus Rabbah is not entirely haggadic. It uses halakhic questions and topics very often in combination with narratives to illustrate the right behavior or encourage a certain practice. In a case study and close reading of a chapter in Leviticus Rabbah I will illustrate the hermeneutics of Leviticus Rabbah, its special focus on rabbinic learning and teaching and the meaning of halakhic commandments in the context.
|
Severus' Allies in the Halls of Power: The Case of Anti-Chalcedonian Great Chamberlains
Program Unit: Bible and Syriac Studies in Context
Tuomo Lankila, University of Jyvaeskylae
Since Constantine, it was known that palace eunuchs meddled in ecclesiastical affairs. When the Christological controversies kindled a new combative spirituality, the eunuchs as a group of high-ranking social outsiders strengthened their cohesive spirit-of-corps with an ecclesiastical partisanship opposed to the dominant stand in the capital. Struggling against Chalcedon, the Miaphysite party under Severus enjoyed support from this lobby inside the imperial court. Seemingly all great chamberlains ("foremen of the sacred bedchamber") of the era were inclined towards Miaphysite convictions, some quite zealously. Despite recent advances in studying late antique eunuchs and new interpretations of the historical, social, and theological contexts of the Christological controversy, much research is necessary to engage different sub-fields in dialogue with one another. Eunuchs were loyal servants, but it was not always clear to whom. Seeing them as brave warriors for the true faith might be misleading when the ruler was giving in to heretics. Things were not easier when the emperor ruled by proxies and through obscure insinuations. Could it ever be wiser to follow the empress’s contradictory commands? When one’s own ecclesiastical leaders did not seem to understand the real conditions that prevailed in the halls of power and instead pursued stubborn and self-destructive policy, things were not any easier. Powerful eunuchs did not simply enforce other people's will. Heading a distinct administrative branch and power structure, a eunuch-chamberlain was bound to have his own agendas. The prosperity of Empire and Church, as well as his own safety, could depend on a chamberlain's ability to choose correctly. This paper deals with three individuals who coped with these problems under different conditions, characters and fates: Misael, Amantius, and Narses. They had in common holding a position at the highest level of the court hierarchy. They also deeply engaged in the service of Miaphysite Christianity.
|
The Anthropology behind the So-called Thomasine Tracts of Nag Hammadi
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Lautaro Roig Lanzillotta, Rijksuniversiteit Groningen
The current paper is a continuation of a work in progress on the anthropological framework of the Nag Hammadi treatises. Having studied Valentinian and so-called Sethian works, it is time now to focus on the texts of the so-called Thomasine tradition.
|
The Cosmological Framework of the Coptic Apocalypse of Paul (NHC V,2)
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
Lautaro Roig Lanzillotta, Rijksuniversiteit Groningen
The Cosmological Framework of the Coptic Apocalypse of Paul (NHC V,2)
|
Alcimus’ Last Command: History and Propaganda in 1 Macc 9:54
Program Unit: Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha
Daniel Lanzinger, Rheinische Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität Bonn
The note of 1 Macc 9:54 that the high priest Alcimus ordered the destruction of the wall of the inner temple court is taken by most scholars as a description of a historical event. This paper, however, suggests that the note should rather be read as part of a pro-Maccabean propaganda which serves to defame Alcimus. It is argued that, in a historical perspective, not Alcimus but Judas was responsible for serious damage at the temple precinct as a result of his unsuccessful military operation against the Seleucid Acra (6:18–54). The author of 1 Macc tries to downplay this event and to villainise Alcimus by calling destruction what was actually restoration. The paper ends with a comparison to two other passages in 1 Macc (4:44–46 and 5:55–62) which shows that the suggested understanding of 9:54 fits well the strategies of legitimisation and delegitimisation that can be found throughout the book.
|
"Fear of Yahweh" and the Transcendence of Human Finitude in Proverbs 1–9
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Wisdom
Phillip Michael Lasater, Universität Zürich
Bracketing Proverbs 1–9 are two statements about yr’t yhwh, identifying it as "the beginning of knowledge" and "the beginning of wisdom." Amid the descriptions of wisdom in Proverbs 1–9, the bookends of this textual unit suggest that divine wisdom is accessible to people through—that is, beginning with—yr’h.
Near Eastern and Greek cultures begin interacting prior to the Hellenistic period and continue doing so thereafter. Thus, it is noteworthy that both Plato and Aristotle claim that the "beginning of philosophy" (arche philosophias) is the passion of "wonder" (thauma), apparently agreeing that this pursuit of wisdom pushes people toward, if not a religious transcendence, then at least a significant contemplative transcendence of human finitude. According to Plato and Aristotle, for the life of the mind, fulness lies beyond the everyday boundaries of concrete human experience: a fulness inseparable from a sophia whose arche is thaumazein.
Remarkably, the producers of the Septuagint translated a number of yr’-cognates not only with cognates of phobeomai, but also with cognates of thaumazein, interpreting yr’ as relevant to the semantic domain of "wonder" and even applying it to knowledge content in LXX Ps 44:5. This fact raises questions about wooden translations of yr’h as phobos in intellectual contexts such as Prov 1:7; 9:10: arche sophias phobos theou. Conceptually and linguistically, this bracket around Proverbs 1–9 appears comparable to the idea in the Western philosophical tradition that the arche philosophias is thauma. This paper argues that, just as the pursuit of wisdom leads to transcending human finitude for Plato and Aristotle, it involves access to divinely-rooted wisdom for the scribes behind Proverbs 1–9. In Proverbs 1–9, then, wisdom is an abstract, non-human focus of contemplation and study that is accessible within the world but that clearly transcends it.
|
The Egyptian Midwives: Lost Traditions and Suppressed Perspectives in the Genizah
Program Unit: Early Judaism and Rabbinics (EABS)
Moshe Lavee, University of Haifa
The Cairo Genizah preserved a reservoir of lost aggadic traditions. As the canonization of aggadic Midrashim continued well into the second millennium, some aggadic works were lost in transmission, and did not made it to the printed editions of the 16th century and on. However, in many cases the lost midrashim we find in the Genizah can be tagged as 'more of the same'. They rarely contain a novel perspective, different than those preserved in more canonized works.
In this paper I intend to present a fragment of a lost Midrash containing a fairly early rabbinic tradition that conforms to the Septuagint against the Massoratic text: The Egyptian midwives who saved the Israelites babies. As presented in the Genizah fragments, the tradition seems to reflect the concept or actual social group of 'God-Fearers', and to go against the tendency to merge the otherness of women and gentiles.
Tracing the history of this neglected tradition in later Jewish works the text demonstrates a case of a virtual loss of a perspective and not only an accidental loss of a tradition. I will point out some other cases in which medieval anthologies and Genizah fragments preserve rabbinic perspectives that are not part of the "Jewish collective memory" as shaped by the most canonical representations of rabbinic Literature: The Babylonian Talmud and Rashi's commentary.
This special Genizah fragment, that also has unique features in terms of its style and form, preserved early traditions. These traditions echo Second Temple Literature and give stronger voice to positive representation of women and non-Jews. It demonstrates images of blurred boundaries. As such it may be seen as a peeping window to perspectives that precede the process of dominantization of later rabbinic perceptions.
|
Reception of Jeremiah 10 in Rabbinic Literature: Jeremiah as an Inversion of Jesus
Program Unit: Texts and Contexts of Jeremiah: The Exegesis of Jeremiah 1 and 10 in light of Textual and Reception History
Moshe Lavee, University of Haifa
Some of the rabbinic interpretations of Jeremiah 10 belong to a wider nexus of rabbinic traditions positing Jeremiah at the crossroad of the split of Judaism and Christianity. Jeremiah utter identification with his mission of rebuke, to the extent of praying against the divine atonement and forgiveness for the sins of Israel made him a rabbinic icon of the concept of the continuous choice of Carnal Israel. Jeremiah is depicted and the benefactor of Israel the bride, who advices her husband, the Lord, to keep on punishing her, as an evidence for His lasting love for her; as a priest who is about the give the water to an adulterous wife, and find out that the women is his beloved mother; as collecting, kissing and caressing the scattered fingers and limbs left on the ground where the people of Israel made their ways to Babylon. In this paper I intend to show that the figure of Jeremiah in some of these rabbinic traditions echoes some elements from the life of Jesus, implying for an inversive portrayals of two rebels who protested against an ill society, yet their protest led to different models of identity. These traditions should be read against apostolic teachings that regard Jeremiah as a type and model of Jesus.
|
First Corinthians 14:33b and Its Implications for the Text-Critical Problem of 14:34-35
Program Unit: Textual Criticism: Manuscripts & Methods
Alesja Lavrinovica, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
The famous "biblical" verses that silence women in the churches, namely 1 Cor 14:34-35, are found in all the extant New Testament manuscripts. Yet textual critics still debate the authenticity of these verses. Already J. Weiss (1910) observed that verse 33b has "doceo" in vg and ??????? in G. Weiss also pointed out that verse 33a is a self-contained statement without 33b and that the repetition of ?? ???? ?????????? in 33b and 34 does not read smoothly. In addition to the observations of Weiss, the method of transcriptional probability (G. Fee, 1987; P. B. Payne, 2009) undermines the authenticity of verses 34-35 in 1 Corinthians 14. The present study aims to contribute to the ongoing text-critical research on the question of the authenticity of 1 Cor 14:34-35 by focusing particularly on the problem of the connectedness of 1 Cor 14:34-35 to its preceding context, that is, verse 33b. The claim of this paper is that verse 33b is most likely a connecting element which was created for the insertion of verses 34-35 between 14:33a and 36. The paper presents the actual external evidence of the oldest and the most relevant manuscripts (P46, ?, A, B, Fuldensis, D, F, G, ms. 88* and P123) that contain 1 Cor 14:33b-35 and shows that verse 33b in none of them is seen as belonging to verses 34-35. Scribes would consider 33b to be a part of 33a. Manuscripts ?, A, B, Fuldensis, D, F, G, ms. 88* clearly read 1 Cor 14:34-35 as a separate paragraph. P46 and P123 are damaged and require reconstruction. In those manuscripts, where verses 34-35 are found after verse 40, 33b is left with 33a. Thus verse 33b proves to be a key to the text-critical analysis of 1 Cor 14:34-35.
|
Freud as Jesus Redux
Program Unit: Psychological Hermeneutics of Biblical Themes and Texts
Raymond J. Lawrence, College of Pastoral Supervision and Psychotherapy
I will build on Donald Capps' seminal work, Jesus as Village Psychiatrist, in which he attempts to show that Jesus' healing work, the so-called miracles, were dynamically similar to the healings performed later by Freud. I will examine select material from the Gospel texts and select texts from Freud that demonstrate the parallel. The historical data shows a profound and widespread sexual conflict in the early disorganized Jesus movement, not dissimilar to that experienced in the Freudian movement. Both Jesus and Freud focused more on dynamics within the psyche rather than specific behavior. Thus hate precedes in import murder, and lust, adultery. (cf Matthew 5:21-22; 27-28).
|
Building for Heaven on the Earth: An Examination of the Verb bnh in Genesis
Program Unit: Place, Space, and Identity in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Arie C. Leder, Calvin Theological Seminary
Examining the depictions of world formation and cultural development in Philo and Mesopotamian cosmologies Jürgen Ebach (Weltentstehung und Kulturentwicklung bei Philo von Byblos) argues that Genesis 1-11, in contrast to Philo’s depictions of human cultural development in terms of progress, depicts human cultural activity (Cain’s building of a city, Noah’s construction of the ark, Noah’s viticulture and the tower of Babel) in a way that emphasizes diminishing of life because humanity asserts independence from heaven, rather than growth toward fullness. Key features of Genesis 1-11’s description of human activity are depicted with the verb bnh (Cain, Noah’s altar, Babel). Scholarship has also argued that Genesis 11:27-12:9 should be read in the light of the tower of Babel episode (e.g., Awabdy, 2010), often with reference to the repetition of šm. Klingbeil (2004) calls attention to Abraham’s building an altar in the context of the Babel narrative, but focuses on the altar (mzbh) and not the verb bnh.
This article will examine the use of bnh in pre-patriarchal and patriarchal narratives and argue that the patriarchal building of altars depicts a world formation and human development that conforms to the demands of heaven and so presents a theme that stands in opposition to the diminishing of life that proceeds from cultural efforts of human autonomy on the earth.
Literature mentioned in the abstract (only presented for this purpose, not to be published with abstract):
Awabdy, Mark A. “Babel, Suspense, and the Introduction to the Terah-Abram Narrative.” JSOT 35.1
(2010): 3-29.
Ebach, Jürgen. Weltentstehung und Kulturentwicklung bei Philo von Byblos. Ein Beitrag zur
Überlieferung der biblischen Urgeschichte im Rahmen des altorientalischen und antiken
Schöpfungsglaubens. BWANT 108. Stuttgart: Kohlhammer, 1979.
Klngbeil, Gerald A. “Altars, Ritual and Theology—Preliminary Thoughts on the Importance of Cult and
Ritual for a Theology of the Hebrew Scriptures.” VT LIV.4 (2004): 495-515.
|
Revisiting the Tower of Babel from a Postcolonial Perspective
Program Unit: Postcolonial Studies
Archie Chi-Chung Lee, The Chinese University of Hong Kong
This paper intends to re-read Gen 11:1-9 from post-colonial perspective of Hong Kong and to construct the meaning of the three short speeches that begin with “let us...” (havah n...). The first one accounts for the plight of a people in migration, seeking to settle down in a different cultural environment of Shinar (“let us make brick…” 11:2). The third quotation, “let us go down and mix”, is clearly from God(s) who descended to make a stop of the building project of a city and a tower that reaches heaven. What is proposed in this paper is that the second “let us...” (havah n...) comes from the empire builders who force the new settlers to hard labor for empire building and to enforce the empire’s one language policy. What God(s) did was therefore an act of termination of the twofold project of the empire builder as it is introduced in the first verse "one language" and "same acts/projects". The story is told from the perspective of the migrants who are to liberate from the oppressive power of Babel (Babylon) in its single language policy and empire building ambition.
|
Multiple Originals Hypothesis on Transliteration
Program Unit: Textual Criticism: Manuscripts & Methods
Sang-Il Lee, Chongshin University
Scholars have held an orthographical view of transliterated variants in the Four Gospels. They have tried to single out “the correct spelling” from “corrupted spellings” and “the right spelling” from “erroneous spellings” on the basis of the assumptions that the correct spelling is the original spelling and that the single correct spelling has temporal priority. “The single original” hypothesis has functioned as a criterion for textual criticism. From the perspective of linguistics, however, the transliteration leads to phonological variants due to four linguistic factors. This requires multiple originals hypothesis in transliteration and reconsideration of criteria of textual criticism.
|
No Nation or Race! But, a Top-Dog in the Headquarters: Considerations on Early First Millennium Scribal Expertise in the Levant
Program Unit: Israel in the Ancient Near East (EABS)
Reinhard G. Lehmann, Johannes Gutenberg University of Mainz
The paper will deal with some more recent ideas on ethnicity, script, and scribal practice in the early first millennium BCE Levant. Methodological points will be discussed and epigraphical finds will be shown that seem to contradict ideas of nationally or ethnically confined script typologies or scribal habits.
|
“Receive the Widow Judith, Example of Chastity”: The Figure of Judith as a Model Christian in Patristic Interpretations
Program Unit: Biblical Women in Patristic Reception
Outi Lehtipuu, University of Helsinki
In the preface of his translation of the Book of Judith, Jerome exhorts his readers: “Receive the widow Judith, example of chastity, and with triumphant praise acclaim her with eternal public celebration. For not only for women, but even for men, she has been given as a model by the one who rewards her chastity, who has ascribed to her such virtue that she conquered the unconquered among humanity, and surmounted the insurmountable.” Prior to Jerome’s time, the reception of the Book of Judith was rather limited but those patristic writers who refer to its heroine praised her as a perfect model for all, but especially for women and even more particularly, for widows.
The most elaborate early interpretation of Judith is found in Ambrose’s writing On Widows (De viduis) where she is acclaimed not only for her chastity and proper conduct but also for her bravery and other manly virtues.
In this paper I discuss the different aspects and characteristics of the Biblical Judith as they are perceived in the writings of Ambrose, Jerome and other early Christian authors, including Clement of Alexandria, Tertullian, Methodius, and Basil of Caesarea. I show how Judith is used as a rhetorical tool in teaching what the proper place and conduct of women, especially widows, is within the early Christian movement.
|
The Study of Midrash with Abraham Epstein (1841-1918)
Program Unit: The Reception History of the Bible in the Wissenschaft des Judentums of the Viennese Bet Ha-Midrash
Tirza Lemberger, Universität Wien
Abraham Epstein, a rabbinical scholar born in Volhynia, settled in Vienna after closing the extensive businesses of his father. This allowed him to research and study extensively Midrashic manuscripts. Thanks Epstein’s several important medieval midrashim are known today. Epstein did not shy away from scholarly conflict when his own opinion differed from others. The topics he researched range from Midrashim up to the story of Eldad haDani, an adventurer claiming to be a descendent of the 10 lost tribes. Epstein’s life time achievements shed new and Jewish reception history of the Bible. Selected examples of his work will be discussed in this paper.
|
Aram and Ethnicity
Program Unit: Anthropology and the Bible (EABS)
Niels Peter Lemche, University of Copenhagen
What did the term “Aram” mean to the people of Syria speaking Aramaic? In the Sfire inscriptions from the 8th century BCE, we find references to a number of Syrian states such as Bit-Gusi, Bit-Salal, KTK, Arpad, but also “all of Aram.” Does Aram here have the connotation of being an ethnic term, or is it referring to something special. It seems that “all of Aram” here simply includes every Aramaic state not specifically named in the listing of Syrian states. If this is the case, being an Aramean is not just somebody who speaks Aramaic but the term seems with being confined to a minor unity to embrace all of Syria. It thus makes it possible that “Aram” is a generic term including ideas of ethnically coherence and identity. It thus opens up for a renewed discussion about ethnic and political identity in the pre-classical ancient Near East.
|
Looking at Kuntillet ‘Ajrud through the Lens of Visual Culture Studies
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Joel LeMon, Emory University
This paper presents theoretical and methodological reflections on the intersection of iconographic analysis and ritual studies of the ancient Levant. As a case study, the paper revisits the rich artistic assemblage at Kuntillet ‘Ajrud to demonstrate the complexities of (1) reconstructing ritual practices through images and (2) interpreting images in light of ritual practices. The paper takes up David P. Morgan’s notion of “religious ways of seeing” to determine whether such viewing practices might have applied to the images found at the site. In sum, the paper highlights how these “ways of seeing” shape our understanding of the composition history of the images at Kuntillet ‘Ajrud as well as their function(s) and meaning(s).
|
The Death of Moses Re-told in Midrash and Music
Program Unit: Judaica
Helen Leneman, Independent Scholar
Moses’ death scene is re-imagined in a variety of ways in rabbinic midrash and in musical settings. Two Jewish composers, of the 19th and 20th century, incorporate rabbinic midrash in their librettos, portraying a Moses who is not ready to die and who argues eloquently with God. The first composer I will discuss is Marcus Hast, a chazzan in Victorian London who wrote a secular oratorio called The Death of Moses in 1893. The other composer is Kurt Weill, whose lengthy 1937 opera The Eternal Road features a death scene for Moses. The librettos of both works, based on several rabbinic midrashim, acquire great poignancy and depth through the music. In both settings, the Shema prayer is included. Traditionally a Jew’s last words before death, it is included in other musical works about Moses by Jewish composers or librettists. The inclusion of this prayer merges the past and present, myth and reality.
The death of Moses was a major theme in Romantic and post-Romantic literature. George Eliot wrote a poetic narrative ‘The Death of Moses’ (1908) which quotes some of the same midrashic sources found in these librettos. Rainer Maria Rilke’s Der Tod Moses (1922) also quotes these sources. And one of German Pastor Dietrich Bonhoeffer’s final poems, smuggled out of a concentration camp before he was hanged by the Nazis, was ‘Der Tod des Mose’.
Musical excerpts will be played.
|
Bringing Zipporah Out of the Shadows in Two 19th-century Operas
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Helen Leneman, Independent Scholar
Moses’ wife Zipporah is largely silent in the Bible but finds her voice in several musical works I explored for my newest book.
In the Bible, Zipporah is not even mentioned among the seven daughters, but only when her father gives her to Moses in marriage. Zipporah is named and presented as Moses’ wife only three times (Ex. 2.21, 4.25, 18.2). In Exodus 18.27, Moses says farewell only to his father in law, not to Zipporah. The reader does not know if she stayed with Moses or returned home. And no one will ever know this, but librettists and composers addressed this gap in a variety of ways.
Anton Rubinstein in his 1891 opera introduces Zipporah at the well as a vivacious spirit who, it is suggested, is hoping to find a suitor. It is an interesting way to ‘set up’ the subsequent encounter with Moses. She is an alto, a lower and richer female voice standing for either age or seductive qualities. Zipporah has an active role throughout the narrative of the Exodus in this opera.
In Lorenzo Perosi’s 1901opera, the librettists gave the figure of Zipporah, and her relationship with Moses, much greater importance than the Bible did. A passionate soprano, she is a romantic partner to Moses.
In Exodus 2. 20-22, Moses stays the night, is married to Zipporah, and they have a son. This kind of biblical telescoping of events is not found in opera librettos. If anything, the telescope is reversed and far more details are offered than can even be imagined between the lines of the biblical text.
Musical excerpts will be played.
|
Simply “Redundant”? The Discourse Function of Apekrithe Kai Eipen (“he answered and said”) in John’s Gospel
Program Unit: Hellenistic Greek Language and Linguistics
Mavis M. Leung, Evangel Seminary (Hong Kong)
he purpose of this paper is to analyze the discourse function of the phrase apekrithe kai eipen in John’s Gospel. This phrase is used more than 30 times to introduce a number of reported speeches in the Johannine narrative. Most of the occurrences are present in the dialogues between Jesus and the disciples or potential believers (e.g., Nathanael, Nicodemus, the Samaritan woman, the crowd, and Thomas) or in the interchanges between Jesus and his opponents. In the majority of the cases, “Jesus” is the verbal subject of apekrithe kai eipen. Regarding the instances of apekrithe kai eipen in this Gospel, a number of modern English Bible versions include only one verb and leave out the other verb in their translations. The implication of these translations is that the verbal combination apekrithe kai eipen is mere pleonasm and has no pragmatic purpose within John’s literary scheme. Building on the studies of Stephen H. Levinsohn and Steven E. Runge, this paper will show that the seemingly “redundant” phrase apekrithe kai eipen carries out certain pragmatic functions in the Johannine narrative. More specifically, it serves to introduce the important speeches that expound theological truths to the addressees or counter the criticism from them. The result of this paper will have implications on how to translate apekrithe kai eipen in John’s Gospel.
|
The Postposing of Topical Subjects in Luke-Acts and John
Program Unit: Hellenistic Greek Language and Linguistics
Stephen H. Levinsohn, SIL International
When a comment is made about a topic that is identified by a noun (phrase) and the topical subject follows the verb, its default position is after any pronominals and before other arguments or adjuncts (e.g. Lk 1:32: kai dwsei autw kurios ho theos ton thronon Dauid...). Topical subjects are almost never postposed in Matthew (once), Mark (twice) and Revelation (once), but over 80 are found in Luke-Acts and John. In the majority of narrative instances, postposing the subject selects from the cast of active participants the one who is the center of attention for the next part of the story (e.g. the centurion, rather than Jesus, in Lk 7:6; Paul, rather than Barnabas, in Ac 15:36; Peter, rather than Jesus, in Mt 14:29). This is particularly evident in John when the postposed subject is immediately followed by kai plus a description of the next event performed by that subject (e.g. the woman, rather than Jesus or the disciples, in 4:28). A topical subject may also be postposed to mark the end of their involvement (e.g. the angels in Lk 2:15; those who worship the beast in Rev 14:11; compare Mk 8:12, where sjmeion is postposed at the end of Jesus’ speech). When the subject of an ACTIVE verb is postposed, the event concerned is usually in chronological sequence with the last one described, whereas placing the subject before the verb would have signalled a switch of attention, but not chronological sequence. However, when a topical subject is postposed in a STATIVE clause, thereby violating the Principle of Natural Information Flow, prominence is given to the focal constituent that immediately precedes the subject (e.g. pleious tesserakonta in Ac 23:13).
|
Eight Constraints on the Interpretation of Lk 17:11-19
Program Unit: Methods in New Testament Studies
Stephen H. Levinsohn, SIL International
The NIV presents Jesus’ healing of the ten lepers in nine sentences, each in the simple past, so that none of them particularly stands out, apart from the background comment ‘he was a Samaritan’, which is attached to the end of the seventh sentence with ‘and’. Two inter-sentential conjunctions are used: the reorienter ‘now’ (11), which leads the reader both to expect changes in the scene and to find some connection to the context; and ‘then’ (19), which suggests that Jesus’ concluding words represent a new point in the story—the climax, perhaps. In contrast, the Greek text imposes a number of constraints on interpretation that mark certain events in the story as more significant than others and tend to confirm Michael Wilcock’s contention that “the healing of the ten lepers … sums up the whole of what Jesus is saying both to his disciples and to the Pharisees in the section from 16:1 to 18:14”. They include an imperfect in 17:11, a genitive absolute in 12, a continuative relative clause in 12, the combination of egeneto and a temporal expression in 11 and 14 to introduce the specific circumstance for the following foreground events, the positioning of the background comment at the end of 16, the combination of apokritheis and eipen in 17, the naming of Jesus only in 17, and the use of the ‘distinctive’ connective de only in 15 and 17. These constraints lead the reader to ground the pericope in the events that were described before it, to concentrate less on the healing per se and more on the response of the Samaritan leper (15-16), and to take particular note of Jesus’ authoritative pronouncement (17-18).
|
Paul's Inspired Vision for the Corinthians in 1 Cor 12–14: To Become an Inclusive, Mutual, Loving, and Prophetic Community
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Soeng Yu Li, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
In 1 Corinthians 12-14 Paul clarifies and corrects the Corinthian misunderstandings concerning the pneumatika. Scholarship is mainly concerned with interpreting Paul’s answer for the present Corinthian situation. In this view, chapters 12-13 offer a general discussion of the pneumatika and chapter 14 offers specific regulations concerning prophecy and glossolalia. A neglected question is from which perspective does Paul formulate his response and how does this perspective influence or shape his understanding of community? This paper will argue that Paul’s answer is given from an eschatological perspective. His answer is not meant for a community living in the present, but for a community living in the present towards the eschaton. This means that Paul has a certain understanding of how an eschatological community should be. This is revealed to him by God. In this case we can speak of an inspired vision, i.e., a future-oriented dream of God for a community that transforms the present divided community into a real community. By focusing on the future-oriented and transformative aspects of the text we will identify the pointers of Paul’s inspired vision in 1 Corinthians 12-14. Given that the three chapters contain transformative and future-oriented principles pointing towards the vision means that these three chapters are constitutive in Paul’s argumentation. Therefore, we agree with some scholars who demonstrated that chapter 14 also contains several principles that resume some themes of the previous two chapters (e.g., Aguilar Chiu, 2007, 195-201, 295-315). Besides a contribution to the coherence of Paul’s argumentation, this paper will also contribute to Paul’s understanding of community. Thus, this paper will demonstrate that Paul’s argumentation in 1 Corinthians 12-14 contains an inspired vision that is meant to transform the present exclusive, individualistic and glossolalic community into an inclusive, mutually loving and prophetic community on its journey towards the eschaton.
|
Ritual as a Basis for a Comprehensive, Ideal Geo-Taxonomy and Mapping of Sacred Space in Mishnah
Program Unit: Place, Space, and Identity in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Jack N. Lightstone, Brock University
One requisite of a community’s social construction of reality is a shared mapping of “space” that the community “inhabits”. Such a mapping both reflects and reinforces other structured realms of their socially constructed reality. And, as Mary Douglas has argued, it is in the “fit” experienced across those realms—including the realm of shared ritual practice--that members of the community gain a compelling sense of the “given-ness” of that reality. Mishnah, authored and promulgated by the nascent rabbinic movement c. 130 years after the destruction of the Judean Temple State by Rome, is a study of an ideal and utopian system of Torah-law, in which a Temple State still (again?) operates, and by means of the rituals of which an ideal taxonomy and mapping of space and territory takes place--- as an ordered place and, as it were, in which the rabbinic student of Mishnah lives “imaginatively”. This paper explores the relationship between utopian legal constructs in Mishnah and its ideal mapping of space, with special attention to the example of Mishnah, Tractate Kelim 1:6 to 1:9a.
|
Inalienability – The Reason for a Literary Device?
Program Unit: Stylistics and the Hebrew Bible
Rosmari Lillas, University of Gothenburg
For citizens of the United States of America and individuals interested in the formulations of the Declaration of Independence the word ‘unalienable’ is presumably familiar: “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights …” In linguistics a near-synonym to unalienable, inalienability, is used, which refers to a genitive construction in which the object is inalienable to the subject, e.g., ‘the man’s arm’ in which the arm is constantly possessed, i.e., is inalienable to the man, as opposed to ‘the man’s book,’ in which the book is not inalienable to the man.
In Biblical Hebrew genitive constructions exist in the form of construct relations, but in some cases two nouns with an intervening waw such as e.g. ‘giving you a future and a hope’, ‘sealing vision and prophet’, ‘ask from me dowry and gift’, would also seem to induce a reinterpretation as a regular construct relation despite the intervening particle. The question is of course why these kinds of combinations, by some considered a literary device exist. There are similar combinations in Akkadian (e.g. ‘arms and battle’; ‘flint and knives’; ‘a sceptre and justice’), according to Wasserman, who suggests that the reason for the existence of these combinations is that they represent inalienability. This paper explores the possibility that analogous word-pairs in the Hebrew Bible also disclose inalienable relations, investigates this notion by looking at over 600 examples of noun combinations in the Hebrew Bible, and discusses inalienability as the reason for the existence of this peculiar literary device in Biblical Hebrew.
|
Spaces of Identity: Real and Imagined Spaces and Social Identity Formation in Philippians
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Kar Yong Lim, Seminari Theoloji Malaysia/Malaysia Bible Seminary
The recent publication of "T&T Clark Handbook to Social Identity Formation in the New Testament", edited by J. Brian Tucker and Coleman A. Baker, brings together a compendium of essays investigating the formation of social identity among the early Christ-movements. In this excellent volume, much emphasis of the social identity formation theories focuses on inter- and intra-groups social relations. Yet one area that remains to be considered in greater depth is the relationship between space and identity formation. This paper attempts to highlight how a consciousness about spatial assumptions, spatial metaphors and symbolic boundaries could play significant role in the formation of social identity of the early Christ-movement. Using Paul’s epistle to the Philippians as a test case, this paper examines Paul’s choice of spatial language such as imprisonment (Phil 1:12-14), kingship (2:5-11), astrological (2:16), and political (3:20) metaphors. By employing what Edward Soja describes as "Thirdspace" in which the combination of actual lived spaces and textual analyses of imagined and figurative spaces are investigated together, this paper aims to demonstrate how spatial analysis further contributes to the understanding of social identity formation of the Christ-movement in the city of Philippi.
|
Intertextuality, Method, and Memory: Conceptualizing Paul’s Use of Scripture
Program Unit: Schriftrezeption bei Paulus und in der Paulustradition: Reception of Scripture in Paul and Pauline Tradition
David Lincicum, University of Oxford
Unter dem Titel „Intertextuality, Method, and Memory: Conceptualizing Paul’s Use of Scripture“ wird die – innerhalb der neutestamentlichen Wissenschaft wesentlich von Richard Hays angestoßene – Debatte um das Konzept der Intertextualität evaluiert. Wenn nämlich dieser Zugriff auf das Phänomen der Schriftrezeption durch andere Wege der Analyse von Zitaten und Anspielungen ergänzt wird, lassen sich zusätzliche Einsichten gewinnen. Insbesondere sorgen wirkungsgeschichtliche und gedächtnisgestützte Verfahren dafür, dem drohenden Übergewicht einer reinen Text-Orientierung entgegenzuwirken.
|
For the Love of God (Parents) and Country: Nationalism in American Children's Bibles
Program Unit: The Bible in the Twenty-First Century: Politization of Bibles and Biblization of Politics (EABS)
Benjamin Lindquist, University of Chicago
Though ostensibly set in the distant, biblical past, the mutability of children’s bibles provides an opportunity for writers, illustrators, and their publishers to reflect and comment on their own contemporary context. Invariably, children’s bibles contain the ideology of the people and nations who produce them. These bibles demonstrate a direct articulation of ideology, accessible to both children and their parents. My paper will explore how national ideology becomes embedded in children’s bibles, with the contention that the desires of adults are encoded in what they transmit to their children. Specifically, I will look at nationhood and nationalism as made manifest in American children’s bibles from the nineteenth century, focusing on families and genealogies as a means of exploring the relationship between religion and the nation state.
Children’s bibles provide a particularly fertile ground for investigating the relationship between religion and the state. While contemporary children’s bibles increasingly attempt to represent pluralism as an ideal, I want to argue that many children’s bibles from the nineteenth century provide a model of an idealized Christian state. Though the phenomenon is certainly not limited to children’s bibles, one often finds therein an analogy between the nation and God’s chosen people of the Old Testament. These children's bibles present the child’s obedience to God as analogous to obedience towards parents, community leaders, and, finally, the nation. The church ostensibly produces obedient citizens and thus the authors of these texts draw a correlation between state and church. Through the genealogical representation of families, my paper will explicate the ways in which these bibles attempt to educate children not only into faith but also into society.
|
Believing in Jesus: A Johannine Theology of Faith
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Dennis R. Lindsay, Northwest Christian University
Believing in Jesus is integral to the explicit missionary program of the fourth gospel, as stated in Jn. 20:31, and this theme permeates the gospel. John’s gospel accounts for over one third of the occurrences of the verb pisteuein in the entire New Testament, and no other biblical author, including Paul, makes more frequent use of the verb. This frequency of usage, coupled with the fact that John employs only the verb pisteuein and never the substantive pistis, suggests a very intentional and distinctive Johannine theology of faith.
This paper examines John’s use of faith terminology, along with related terms and concepts, with a view to identifying the theological heritage of pisteuein in the Johannine corpus. In particular, we shall explore and demonstrate John’s dependence upon the concept of the ’aman word group in the Hebrew scriptures for his usage and understanding of pisteuein, and consequently for his theological understanding of ‘faith’, in contrast to a purely secular Hellenistic understanding and usage of the Greek terminology. We shall further compare John’s usage to that of other New Testament authors in order to determine the fourth gospel’s contribution to and place within a biblical theology of faith.
|
"And he took off his clothing..." (1 Sam 19:24) Nudity in Ancient Media (Images & Texts)
Program Unit: Iconography and Biblical Studies (EABS)
Florian Lippke, Bible+Orient Museum Freiburg CH
The importance of garments and gowns is not a modern phenomenon. Therefore the relevance of textile traditions (considering their presence and absence) can be traced over many thousands of years. The present paper starts investigating the most reduced level in the taxonomy of clothing, which is in a way the opposite of splendid textile usage: Nudity. Regarding ancient media both texts and images can be used as sources in order to establish a careful interpretation of different "nudities". Focusing on iconography three main lines of visual nudity can be identified: a. sacred nudity (cult), b. nudity as a sign of social or military inferiority and c. athletic-aesthetic nudity (nearly exclusively in the later epochs). The presented images are to be compared with relevant passages taken from the Hebrew Bible as a 1st Millennium BCE composition. Examples for both texts and images are provided - scenarios of a historical development are discussed. Complex constellations will also be taken into account: The connotation of nudity changes dramatically throughout the Metal Ages. Furthermore traditions of increased attestations of showing and hiding nudity in the same epoch are to be analyzed.
|
Rahab the Harlot as Perfect Servant in the First Letter of Clement
Program Unit: Biblical Women in Patristic Reception
Tsui Yuk Louise Liu, Chinese University of Hong Kong
This paper aims at exploring the reception of Rahab in the first letter of Clement (1Clem 12), especially how Rahab is set as a role model of a perfect servant. In listing “those who perfectly served his magnificient glory” (1Clem 9.2), Rahab is placed at the end of the list – Enoch (1Clem 9.3), Noah (9.4), Abraham (10), Lot (11) and Rahab (12). The very ending position of Rahab could be simply due to the chronological order, but it could also be because of her role modeling (1Clem 55.3). Same as the major biblical tradition (Jos 6.17, 25, Heb 11.31, Jam 2.25 except Matt 1.5) Rahab is introduced as “Rahab the harlot.” The name “Rahab the harlot” is often perceived as a “label,” “evil, distinguishing name,” or “evil career” (e.g. Lockyer, 131). In 1Clement, however, we could see another face of Rahab the harlot. That Rahab as a harlot could be properly associated with lust (cf. BT Megillah 15a). But as a harlot, a particularly humble feminine career, Rahab is highlighted here as “hospitable” (1Clem 12.3). This matches the depiction in Chapter 12. Right at the beginning, 1 Clement has attributed the cause of her salvation to her faith and hospitality (1Clem 12.1). Whereas Enoch is characterized as “obedien[t]” (1Clem 9.3), Noah as “faithful” (1Clem 9.4), Abraham as “faithful” and “obedient” (1Clem 10.1), Lot’s “hospitality” and “godliness” is underlined (1Clem 11.1). In this way, a “faith[ful]” and “hospitable” Rahab (1Clem 12.1, 3) appears to be carrying all good features of the aforesaid examples. She has the faith just like Enoch, Noah and Abraham. At the same time, she has the hospitality comparable to Lot. In this way, placing Rahab the harlot at the end of the list brings the role modeling of a perfect servant to a climax.
|
“Larger than Life” but Not Docetic: Revisiting John’s Portrayal of Jesus
Program Unit: Johannine Literature and Docetism (EABS)
William Loader, Murdoch University
This paper will review the contribution of authorial creativity in the rhetorical development of fictional dialogues and monologues in the fourth gospel and its tradition. When authors thus knew that they were employing careful techniques to put Jesus on stage, as it were, as a spokesperson for their beliefs about Jesus, creating a Jesus who was “larger than life”, did they intend docetism? This paper will examine what evidence we have pointing to their intent, arguing that it shows that docetism was not intended, though the resultant creation rendered a docetic hearing possible. The paper will also review what evidence, if any, is to be found in the text of antidocetic concerns, concluding that none is unambiguously antidocetic.
|
Some Ways of ‘Doing’ Biblical Theology: Assessments and a Proposal
Program Unit: Biblical Theology
Darian Lockett, Biola University
Biblical Theology is a much talked-about enterprise pursued with little agreement on method or goal. Biblical Theology’s lack of definition is out of proportion to the potential importance of its findings both for the academy and the church. Rather than offering a new definition of Biblical Theology, this paper sketches a framework for such a definition by describing various theories and practices of “whole Bible” Biblical Theologies published since 2000. Using the categories developed in Understanding Biblical Theology (Zondervan, 2012), this paper categorizes a range of recent offerings by plotting them on a spectrum extending from more historical to more theological. Noting especially how each work settles issues of historical diversity versus theological unity, the descriptive versus prescriptive nature of the discipline, whether Biblical Theology is an academic or ecclesial discipline, and especially the kind and degree of unity/disunity between the Old and New Testaments, this paper will isolate the weaknesses of each work. Here a pervasive weakness surfaces, namely, the failure to consider the canon as a criterion for Biblical Theology. Upon isolating this and other shortcomings, the paper will conclude by arguing for a broader, more eclectic approach to Biblical Theology—one that balances both historical and theological concerns as a fitting way forward.
|
Exorcism and Emotions in the Gospels
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Torsten Löfstedt, Linnaeus University
Several passages in the Gospels speak of Jesus, in the context of healing someone or delivering someone of an evil spirit, being angry. To some translators and commentators (and even some copyists) his anger is difficult to motivate and out of character, and they suggest that Jesus was sorrowed rather than angry. I suggest on the basis of modern-day parallels that in the context of exorcisms anger is intelligible. In some cultures today heightened emotion is considered necessary for an exorcism to be plausible and effective and I consider it likely that when the Gospels speak of Jesus' anger they reflect the circumstances around his exorcisms accurately. It is easy to overanalyze words spoken in anger, however, and I argue on the basis of both New Testament passages and modern-day parallels that one should be careful about assuming that when Jesus displays anger at something that he necessarily considered it a supernatural agent. The demonic was not clearly defined, and in both healings and exorcism it was not unusual for the healer to express anger at the personified ailment. Anger is a social emotion that will normally be directed at an agent felt to have moral responsibility. Because of the emotional intensity involved in an exorcism (as in other forms of faith healing), personification of the patient's condition is expected.
|
The Slavonic "Solunskaja Legenda" ("The Legend of Thessalonica") as a Work Translated from Syriac
Program Unit: Bible and Syriac Studies in Context
Basil Lourié, Scrinium
The "Solunskaja Legenda" is a short legendary account about the creator of the Slavic alphabet named Cyril who was not, however, the brother of Methodius. Instead, he was a man of Cappadocian origins educated in Damascus and living in Alexandria. He accepted in a revelation the ordinance to go to the Slavs to convert them to Christianity and give them the alphabet. He became able to fulfill the ordinance due to the miracle which remains obscure because the relevant part of the text contains a series of incomprehensible words. I propose to read these words as a Slavic transcription of a difficult Syriac phrase related to accessories for writing (sharpened reed pens); the number of these pens will be the same as the number of letters of the alphabet created by Cyril. The "Legend" has apocalyptic overtones. It must be analyzed in connection with other data supporting Vaillant's hypothesis that the earliest layer of the Slavic literature was created by "unorthodox" Syrians before the brothers Cyril and Methodius.
|
What Have the Romans Ever Done for Us? Postcolonialism, Mimicry and Hidden Transcripts in the Book of Revelation
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
U-Wen Low, Melbourne College of Divinity
This paper examines and discusses Stephen D. Moore’s suggestion that that the use of Imperial themes and motifs in Revelation create a self-perpetuating cycle that lead to one Imperial power being replaced by another. This paper presents an alternative reading of the book of Revelation: firstly acknowledging as significant the text’s status as apocalyptic literature, written as a device of inspiration and subversion against reigning powers. Such literature is shown to deliberately employ imperial themes and motifs in order to subvert imperial rule; it serves as fantasy, exposing the ‘hidden structures of false power’ and suggesting an alternative. This leads to a reading of the text using Scott’s theories of hidden transcripts. As a hidden transcript, the text serves as an anti-authoritarian device that reflects popular feelings toward an oppressor through symbolism and codes. It represents a community’s secret longing for a day of victory over their oppressors; ultimately, the inversions and mimicry of the text serve to equalise and level class structures rather than reverse. In order to facilitate a reading that truly represents this and allows the text to speak for itself, this paper suggests an understanding of the book of Revelation as a dramatic work grounded in the performance art of the Roman Empire. This paper engages as an example Revelation 5 in the manner of a recitatio of the early Empire, highlighting the discontinuity between what is seen and heard, before further exploring the ramifications of such a reading. Though in its early stages, such a reading of Revelation returns an ambiguity and depth to the text that certain postcolonial methods are lacking, whilst acknowledging its impact as a complex literary work that seeks not to provide answers, but rather a vision of hope that stands as an alternative to the forces of empire surrounding it.
|
A Biblical Name with Somber Overtones
Program Unit: Epigraphical and Paleological Studies Pertaining to the Biblical World
Meir Lubetski, City University of New York
Within the corpus of biblical names, we find the name ????? the father of Nehemiah (Neh 1:1). Scholars explain ????? as Hakkeh le yah, meaning “hope or wait for God. However, the diacritical changes, the insertion of the letter ? and the added preposition le plus the striking conversion from the root Hkl to the root Hk(k)h, is unwarranted. Furthermore, the assumption that the root Hkl never existed in biblical Hebrew is mistaken as well.
Accordingly the presentation will offer an alternate approach. It will demonstrate the existence of hkl as an integral part of biblical verbal vocabulary. In fact, it is also attested in extra-biblical onomastics as hkl and hklyhw, respectively. Additional sources from literary texts will be quoted to establish the independent meaning of the root hkl as part of biblical PNs. Finally, the paper will highlight the fascinating role of colors in Hebrew biblical names, an unfamiliar, yet an enriching aspect.
|
John's Baptism in the light of the Syntax and Structure of John 1
Program Unit: Hellenistic Greek Language and Linguistics
Albert Lukaszewski, Independent Scholar
The Gospel of John has long been recognized as having pericopae re-arranged out of what would seem their expected order. It is further clear that the first chapter includes material in common with the Synoptics. However, the Fourth Gospel re-purposes this material to suit the editorial needs of the book, needs very much independent of those in the Synoptics. This re-purposing has consequences for the
Gospel writer's portrayal of John's ministry. The present paper considers this re-purposing in the light of the structure of John 1 and how this textual context impacts on the syntactic force of the prepositional phrase in John 1:26.
|
The Imagery of the Feast in Karen Blixens Short Story Babettes Feast
Program Unit: Metaphors in the Hebrew Bible/Old Testament and Their Reception
Øystein Lund, MF Norwegian School of Theology
This paper will explore the biblical roots of the image of the feast in Karen Blixens short story Babettes feast. This short story makes use of a number of biblical motives and metaphors.
The paper will sort out how the plot of the short story resembles biblical stories of feasts, including allusions to Isa 25:6 and other Hebrew Bible stories that mention the motif of meals. The paper will also include a treatment of 1 Enoch 62.13-14 and 2 Bar 29:1-8 and how these texts draw the picture of the meal as an eschatological symbol.
The texts of Luke 14:7-24 and 15:11-32 are also key to a proper understanding of Babettes Feast. This paper seeks to explore how different images of the Feast in biblical texts make the necessary backdrop of an informed reading of Babettes Feast.
|
How (or Why) Does a Text Become Scripture? In Jewish, Christian, and Derived Traditions
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
Edmondo Lupieri, Loyola University of Chicago
This contribution aims at showing some ways according to which a written text becomes, or does not become, Scripture in a given group. Only examples from Jewish, Christian, and derived traditions will be analyzed, since those are the traditions the author is familiar with, but the supposition is accepted that analogous mechanisms can be active in similar processes in different religious realities. This paper will examine examples of two major categories of cases. In the first category are the cases in which there is already a set of writings which are considered Scripture by different groups or sub-groups of people belonging to a certain religious complex (in such a way that they all consider themselves to belong to a specific tradition, distinct from other ones). Two examples will be briefly described, to see which authority, and in which ways, can decide which texts are Scripture and which are not. In the second, larger category the author will try to analyze what can happen when a new text becomes recognized as Scripture—or fails to do so. Also in these cases the aim is to identify authorities and mechanisms that allow such recognition.
|
Defining “Docetism?” A Scrutiny of Sources
Program Unit: Johannine Literature and Docetism (EABS)
Ines Luthe, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
The term “Docetism” refers to attempts of denying Jesus Christ´s real incarnation, or somehow obscuring the reality of his suffering at the cross. Attempts to define the phenomenon of Docetism more precisely encounter grave difficulties in ascertaining the nature of Docetism itself. Broadly speaking, the definitions nowadays present a range between maximalist approaches, as will be shown with reference to Ferdinand Christian Baur and Peter Gemeinhardt, and minimalist definitions, as represented by Peter Weigandt and his followers.
The earliest voices of docetic and especially anti-docetic argumentation from which we might elicit a definition are colored by polemical aims, inconsistent and contradictory, but nevertheless worthy of being scrutinized anew. This paper intends to open a new way of understanding within the struggle of defining Docetism by listening to different source texts. Therefore, a few examples of both primary sources and secondary sources wil be given: The Third Letter of Serapion which speaks about suspicious docetic tendencies in the Gospel of Peter in comparison with the Gospel itself; Clement of Alexandria where the term he hairesis ton doketon probably occurs first (Strom. VII,108,2) in comparison to Ignatius of Antioch who uses the phrase tò dokein (Trall 10; Smyr 2,2; 4,2), and the study of Hippolytus (Haer. VIII). Because several writings from the Nag Hammadi corpus have been understood as prime witnesses – though rather late – to docetic tradition, we will end with the Apocalypse of Peter (NHC VII,3).
By way of conclusion, the analysis of some early sources with recent research history in mind gives evidence to reason that it is indeed no coincidence that there are many definitions of “Docetism” in recent research. It is not only true that different definitions rely strongly on different sources, but this somehow amorphous shape of “Docetism” is also rooted in docetic thinking itself.
|
Working with Few Data: Possible Contributions from Deaf Studies to the Study of the Biblical World
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
William John Lyons, University of Bristol
For many, it is a truism that the first mention of deaf people using sign language in the ancient literature is that by Plato in his Cratylus, usually dated to his middle period in the early 4th century BCE. Even mentions of deaf people themselves before this time are relatively few and far between, providing little information about the causes and implications of their condition, their possible social locations, and their ranges of interactions with the wider hearing community and any other deaf people around them; left to simply contemplate such levels of evidence, we might even feel moved to ask
whether a signing 'Deaf community' could even have existed in these early
periods? We should note, however, that working with few data is in
fact the norm for those wishing to study the history of the Deaf communities of the past. With any records and accounts generally being recorded by non-community members--i.e., the hearing--getting at the kinds of details about lived Deaf experience that would illuminate this area of the ancient world requires different tools and assumptions not generally present within biblical scholarship. In this paper, we survey the possible ways in which contemporary scholarship on Deaf spaces may allow greater insight into the lives of those whose communicative experience was primarily visual and allow us to build the fullest possible picture of the way that a 'Deafhood' was both experienced and regarded in the ancient world.
|
The Synoptic Problem Reconsidered: Two Shipwrecked Gospels (SBL 2012)
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Dennis R. MacDonald, Claremont School of Theology
MacDonald offers an alternative reconstruction of Q and an alternative solution to the Synoptic Problem: the Q+/Papias Hypothesis. To do so, he reconstructs and interprets two lost books about Jesus: the earliest Gospel, which was used as a source by the authors of Mark, Matthew, and Luke; and the earliest commentary on the Gospels, by Papias of Hierapolis, who apparently knew Mark, Matthew, and the lost Gospel, which he considered to be an alternative Greek translation of a Semitic Matthew. MacDonald also explores how these two texts, well known into the fourth century, shipwrecked with the canonization of the New Testament and the embarrassment at outmoded eschatologies in both the lost Gospel and Papias’s Exposition.
|
Situating the Aramaic Texts from Qumran: Language and Socio-Historical Settings
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Daniel Machiela, McMaster University
This paper will address broadly the issues of language and socio-historical setting for the Aramaic texts from Qumran. Should these texts be considered a distinctive corpus within the broader scope of the writings composed or preserved around Qumran? Why were they written in Aramaic? It will be argued in this paper that the question of language is best answered in tandem with the overall profile of topics and scenarios addressed in Aramaic works like Daniel, Aramaic Enoch, the Visions of Amram, Tobit, and the Genesis Apocryphon. Building on the observations of other scholars, this profile points to a body of literature with recurring themes addressed to an international Hellenistic-period audience, both within and outside of the land of Israel.
|
Territorializing Space and Imagination: Uses of Roman Imperial Urban Ideals and Iconography to Imagine Right and False Teaching in Emergent Christian Discourse
Program Unit: Place, Space, and Identity in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Harry O. Maier, Vancouver School of Theology
This paper uses the tools of social geography as well as iconographical study of Roman imperial visual culture to explore ways in which early Christ followers used texts to create spatial imagination as means of regulating belief and practice. It builds on the theorization of territoriality as developed by the social geographer David Sack to observe how emergent Christianity classified, represented and regulated divergent belief by associating it with unregulated domestic life. Sack defines territoriality as “the attempt by an individual or group to affect, influence, or control people, phenomena, and relationships, by delimiting and asserting control over a geographical area.” The essay investigates the territoriality advanced by the Pastoral Epistles, Irenaeus’ account of the household activities of the Valentinian teacher Marcus in local households, and the letters of Ignatius of Antioch, to explore how texts created imagined space by configuring allies and opponents as occupants of viewable and hidden spaces. The visible household was associated in Roman and Greek social imagination with good civic order and hidden space as unregulated places of vice. The paper will demonstrate how Roman imperial funerary and honorific iconography as well as that imagery found on imperial monuments themselves represented imagined spaces of domestic and civic unity and concord, and offered visual resources for early Christian writers to invite their listeners to imagine idealized space and its opposite. Through vivid imagery based on recurring imperial urban iconography and ideals associated with rightly governed households, early Christians created textual spaces to invite their listeners to imagine and to place themselves within. Texts thus drew on “this world” to create “other worlds” to configure allies and opponents as embracing or rejecting communal ideals and beliefs.
|
“Lift Up Your Eyes and Look Around!”: Point of View in Prophetic Speech
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible/Old Testament/Ancient Israel Studies (EABS)
Michael P. Maier, Pontificia Università Gregoriana
Isaiah 60 is one of the most picturesque visions of the Bible: the eschatological pilgrimage of the nations to Mount Zion, illuminated by the glory of God. Its great importance for Jewish and Christian theology however contrasts with the impression of mediocre literary quality. The chapter is a speech, directed to Jerusalem. But who speaks? According to G. von Rad it is divine speech. But this literary form “is not consistently realized” since God is mentioned sometimes in the first, sometimes in the third person. It therefore seems mandatory to distinguish several speeches (God’s, the prophet’s, a part with a mixture of both voices) or different literary layers (a basic text and editorial expansions). This paper tries to explain the peculiarities of Isaiah 60 by a different methodological approach. Indeed, this text may be considered a narration, not of passed, but of future events, and be studied with the tools used for narrative texts. In order to understand prophetic speeches such as Isaiah 60 it is particularly important to analyse their point of view. Change of grammatical person, instead of indicating change of speaker, may express a change of perspective. God says “I” when telling the events from his point of view, and “He” when assuming the perspective of another figure. This change is most conspicuous when Zion is commanded to lift up her eyes and to see the multitudes flowing towards her (according to F. Stenzel she is the “reflector” the narrator uses in order to tell the events from a different point of view). The narrative analysis sheds light even on other phenomena (e.g. the change between “to go” and “to come”) and reveals that what up to now is considered lack of artistry, in reality is a literary technique that contributes to the richness of prophecy.
|
Sonship in 1 Peter
Program Unit: Catholic Epistles
Matthew R. Malcolm, Trinity Theological College (Perth)
It has long been recognised that Israel is a "controlling metaphor" for the renewed people of God in 1 Peter. Recent research has debated the most significant OT background in the service of this metaphor, with proposals including Psalm 34, Isaiah, Zechariah, Malachi, and the exodus period. I find the latter proposal to be worthy of further consideration, and in this context seek to explore the significance of the theme of sonship in 1 Peter. I suggest that this theme has been underplayed, and seek to explore how and why 1 Peter utilises this image of the "rebirthed inheritor." I propose that the image of "rebirth into an inheritance" in 1:3-4 is fleshed out with the four familial metaphors of "obedient children," "callers on a father," "brotherly lovers," and "newborn infants" in 1:14-2:3; and that this imagery is pertinent because the recipients are to consider their identity to be informed by the Son whom God called out of Egypt.
|
Structure and Theme of 1 Corinthians
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Matthew R. Malcolm, Trinity Theological College (Perth)
Over the last century there has been a large number of new proposals concerning the structure of 1 Corinthians, including a flurry of contributions in the last few years. These include suggestions of compilation (Weiss 1910, Schmithals 1973), deliberative rhetoric (Mitchell 1991), ring composition (Bailey 2011, Milinovich 2013), Jewish argumentation (Ciampa and Rosner 2006, 2010), and kerygmatic argumentation (Malcolm 2013), among others. Many proposals bring associated claims of a central theme for the letter, whether “unity,” “holiness,” or something else. It seems timely to review these contributions, consider areas of emerging consensus, and reflect upon the significance of these issues for the current study of the letter and Paul.
|
The Ordeal of the 'Wayward Wife' (Sotah) in Sifre Numbers 12: A Study of Hermeneutics, Law and Redaction
Program Unit: Midrash, Halakhah and Reception
Paul Mandel, Hebrew University Jerusalem
During the 'Ordeal of the Suspected Wayward Wife (Sotah)’ to be performed in the Temple (described in Numbers 5), the charge of the priest to the woman (vss. 19—20) includes both the possibility of her innocence and her guilt, in that order. While Scripture leaves no choice to the woman but to perform the ritual in order to test her innocence, rabbinic law prescribes an additional stage in the process, wherein the woman is urged to confess to her act of infidelity, thereby freeing her from continuing the ritual and from the consequent threat of death. These verses are interpreted in the halakhic midrash Sifre Numbers (piska 12) to imply that ‘poteah bah lizekhut,’ usually understood to mean “[one] begins with [an assumption of] innocence', appealing to the woman to continue the ritual if she knows she is innocent of any wrong-doing. This understanding, while seemingly based on the order of the priest’s charge in the verse, contradicts the following passages in the midrash, where instructions are given that may lead to the woman’s admission of guilt (and subsequent cessation of the ritual). The difficulties of this passage have not been fully explained by Talmudic commentators to this passage. Based on a previously published study of the use of the word patah in Tannaitic literature, I propose that the phrase poteah lezechut be interpreted here, as elsewhere in the Tannaitic corpus, as a formal legal term used for the exoneration from punishment of those accused of capital crimes. This interpretation solves the crux in the midrash, pointing to an unusual method of legal hermeneutics and revealing a novel style of redaction of the halakhic midrash, with ramifications regarding relationships between the views of Rabbi Akiva, Rabbi Ishmael and Rabbi Judah the Prince as recorded in parallel passages.
|
John the Baptist’s Diet Reflected His Preferential Option for the Poor
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Merrilyn Mansfield, The University of Sydney
This paper will outline the evidence that John the Baptist had a preferential option for the poor. It will particularly focus on John’s diet as indicative of his attitude towards poverty.
James Kelhoffer has argued that ‘Mark 1:6c cannot ipso facto be assumed to portray John as a poor wilderness dweller or an ascetic.’ Kelhoffer stated that locusts were permitted as part of a Jewish diet in Lev 11, and were included in the diets of other ancient people, being consumed by poor and wealthy alike. He concluded that locusts were therefore not just the food of necessity for Bedouins and other poor people but were also consumed by the wealthy.
This paper agrees with Kelhoffer that locusts were consumed in antiquity by wealthy and poor people alike, but it will provide alternative readings for two texts that Kelhoffer has used to support his argument, and argue instead that these texts provide evidence that locusts were regarded as the food of the poor.
This paper will then ask whether John the Baptist would consume locusts if he knew them to be part of the diet of the wealthy when Jesus remembered that John taught people to eschew luxurious lifestyles (Q 7:24-25). Jesus identified himself as a glutton and a drunk, a description entirely centered on food and drink, but these were characteristics that he did not associate with John the Baptist.
When John sent his disciples to Jesus to ask if he was the ‘expected one’ Jesus responded by echoing a number of prophecies from Isaiah including that the ‘good news’ would be preached to the poor. It is therefore likely that John the Baptist’s diet cohered with his own teachings about poverty, with Jesus’ recollections of him, and with those with whom he associated.
|
Bethany beyond the Jordan Is Not in Batanaea
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Merrilyn Mansfield, University of Sydney
John the Baptist’s location has been debated again in Johannine studies following the publication of Rainer Riesner’s article that aired the centuries old arguments of John Lightfoot and C.R. Conder who argued that Bethany beyond the Jordan, mentioned once in the Gospel of John (1:28), was located in the lower south western corner of Batanaea, just east of the most southern point of the Sea of Galilee. This was the area of Bashan according to the Hebrew Scriptures (Deut 3:10; Josh 13:11). This view has been taken up by a number of scholars since Riesner’s paper was published.
This paper will address significant problems with Riesner’s claim that Bethany beyond the Jordan was situated in Batanaea. It will counter pivotal points in Riesner’s research – to do with time in John 1-2 and 11, the persons and places in John 1, and the claim that Bethany beyond the Jordan was a safe haven for Jesus.
This paper will also provide other compelling evidence that the area known as p??a? t?? ???d???? ‘beyond the Jordan’ was synonymous with ‘across/beyond the Jordan’ in John 3:26 and 10:40, and will argue that this locale was on the south eastern side of the Jordan River. John the Baptist was often associated with locations in the south – the ???µ?? ‘wilderness’ (Mark 1:4), t? ???µ? t?? ???da?a? ‘the wilderness of Judea’ (Matt 3:1), and p?sa? t?? pe??????? t?? ???d???? ‘all the country around the Jordan’ (Luke 3:3), as well as in Aenon near Salim and Machaerus. John the Baptist was also closely connected to the Jordan River which stretched with its subsidiaries from the Sea of Galilee to the Dead Sea. This extensive southern activity enhances the conclusion of this paper – that Bethany beyond the Jordan was also situated in a southern locale.
|
Empire’s Over-exertion in the Vow to Identity Secrecy: A Postcolonial Reflection on Esth 2:10
Program Unit: Bible and Empire
TK Mapfeka, King's College - London
One of the many difficulties associated with reading the story of Esther is how to make sense of the image of a devout and model Jew, Mordecai, who willingly gives away in marriage a Jewish girl under his care to a non-Jewish man. As the story now stands, the fact that Esther was not known as a Jewish girl seems to have played in her favour. It is my submission that when read in the context of the grip of a powerful empire, the vow to identity secrecy of Esther 2:10 (repeated in 2:20), shows Mordecai succumbing to the pressure that demands identifying with the powerful overlord in order to survive. By use of textual disparity and plot inconsistencies, I wish to show how the shadow of the empire dictates not only the interpretation of biblical narratives but also the manner in which biblical traditions were shaped and formed. I will argue that the vow to identity secrecy represents the zenith of cultural subjugation by the powerful empire on a powerless colony and that its inclusion and emphasis serve to illuminate the power relations obtaining at the expense of the clarity of the story plot. It is my contention that biblical narratives, as exemplified in the story of Esther took unusual turns as per the dictates of empirical hegemony and, as such, cannot be read adequately independent of such fundamental dynamics.
|
Gender, Body and Language in the Bible: The Case of peh (mouth)
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Adi Marili, Bar-Ilan University
How gender was perceived in the Bible demands a sophisticated and indirect approach. Gender and the definitions of the 'manly' and 'womanly' are established by cultural and social manners. Those definitions reflect a society’s outlook. Since we cannot observe an ancient society directly, how can we discover its ways of thinking?
We can do so if we believe that language is a window on thought. Semantic Anthropological methods may afford us such a window. Language, as a system of signs which enable the representation of inner thoughts and ideas, openly expresses patterns of thought and indirectly reveals some of the thinking that underlies figurative expressions. Therefore, in my research I examine the representation in language of parts of the most basic and richest source of figurative expression - the human body. The human body may symbolize abstract ideas because the carnal is so very close to people.
In this paper I examine the linguistic representation of the human mouth (peh) in the Hebrew Bible. The investigation focuses on the usages of ‘mouth’ and on its functional capabilities, in particular those attributed to males and those attributed to females. One finds that both the masculine mouth and the feminine mouth have speaking and eating capacities (while the male mouth also possesses the capacity to breathe), and both are subject to a higher authority. Yet, while the manly mouth can often enjoy complete autonomy, except when it is controlled directly by the deity, the womanly mouth must always be supervised by a patriarchal authority. Such observations enlightens us regarding the understanding and social construction of gender in the culture reflected in the biblical text.
|
Die Symbiotische und Perichoretische Funktion des Inspirierten Textes: Die Begegnung der Heiligen Schrift mit den Kirchenvätern in der Kirche
Program Unit: The Reception of the Scripture in the Patristic Exegesis (II-VIII centuries) (EABS)
Adrian Marinescu, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
Die Beziehung zu Gott bestimmt das Leben der menschlichen Person. Für die Kirchenväter ist die Heilige Schrift (byblos) eine göttliche und personale Realität, von der sie sich stets „ernährt“, die sie zu vertiefen sich bemüht haben und an Hand deren sie die Wahrheit (kanon tes aletheias) überprüft haben. Die Heilige Schrift hat ihre Bildung geprägt und sie ins praktische Leben eingeführt, aber sie ersetzt nicht Christus, indem ihr die direkte Erfahrung Gottes und der göttlichen Wahrheiten, die die Kirchenväter bekannt haben, fehlt. Die expliziten Autoren des patristischen Textes sind vor allem Leser des Wirkens Gottes in der Welt und in diesem Sinne auch Leser der Bibel. Der implizierte Autor des inspirierten Textes lässt diesen auf sich wirken und so einen Dialog mit dem Leser entstehen. Person bedeutet Energie (energeia) und Geist (pneuma) und der interpersonale Dialog vermittelt diese Energie und diesen Geist. Der inspirierte Text bietet uns jedes Mal neue Sinngehalte (logoi), d.h. neue Perspektiven, was seinen personhaften, d.h. lebendigen Charakter zeigt. Durch den inspirierten Text (hai hagiai graphai) spricht Gott immer öfter zu uns und wir vertiefen uns immer mehr in die Worte und Sinngehalte Gottes. Deswegen ist es ein Proprium der Methode bei den Kirchenvätern hinsichtlich der Rezeption des biblischen und patristischen Textes, das bereits in den ersten christlichen Jahrhunderten zu finden ist. Die Interpretation der Bibel bei den Kirchenvätern hat eine liturgische Orientierung und findet in einer Liturgie statt, deren Kernpunkte Anamnese und Epiklese sind, um die personale Anaphora zu erreichen.
|
Liturgical Teaching and Reader-Oriented Rhetoric in Deuteronomy
Program Unit: Law and Narrative (EABS)
Dominik Markl, Pontificio Istituto Biblico
While the Sabbath and the festivals are treated in core sections of Deuteronomy’s legislation (Deut 5:12-15; 16:1-17), a final commandment on a ‘feast’ is given at the end of the book (Deut 31:9-13). After having written down the ‘Torah’ of Deuteronomy (31:9), Moses hands it to the Levites and the elders of Israel and commands them to assemble Israel in every year of remission at the festival of booths to read the Torah of Deuteronomy in public. Thus, this festival is to become the stage for the public reading and collective learning of Deuteronomy’s torah, which is in itself shaped as a great liturgy, i.e. the making of the Moab Covenant. The purpose of the assembly of the festival of booths is to re-enact both the foundational ‘assembly’ of the making of the Horeb Covenant (cf. qhl in Deut 4:10; 5:22; 31:12) and the Mosaic ‘teaching’ of the Moab Covenant (cf. lmd in Deut 4:1, 5; 5:1, 31; 6:1; 31:12f). Through intertwining legislation on liturgy and the narrative of its origin at Horeb (Deut 4; 5), Deuteronomy specifies its own liturgical character.
Deuteronomy not only presents the proclamation of its Torah in a liturgical setting, but it also provides a paradigm of liturgical rhetoric and teaching. Gerhard von Rad was the first to emphasize the importance of ‘this most haunting “today” that is the common denominator of the deuteronomic preaching’, which he believed to be deeply rooted in Israel’s cult (‘Das formgeschichtliche Problem des Hexateuch’, 1938). As the second part of this paper will show, the different references to ‘today’ in Deuteronomy are deliberately intermingled in complex ways so that the ‘today’ of Moab is both grounded in the day of Horeb (e.g. Deut 5:2f) and reaches the ‘today’ of the readers (e.g. Deut 6:24; 34:6).
|
Some Problems Related with the New Edition of Vol. III "Apocalypses" of "Antike Christliche Apokryphen"
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
Christoph Markschies, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin - Humboldt University of Berlin
Some Problems Related with the New Edition of Vol. III "Apocalypses" of "Antike christliche Apokryphen"
|
Women Praying or Prophesying: The Problem Created in 1 Cor 11:2–16 and Its Solution in 14:34–35
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Jill E. Marshall, Emory University
The apparent contradiction between First Corinthians 11:2–16 and 14:34–35 has produced numerous exegetical solutions and rigorous hermeneutical debates, especially in feminist interpretation. In this paper, I propose a new way to view the relationship between these passages. I argue that the difficulties and ambiguities in 11:2–16—in vocabulary, syntax, logic, and subject matter—stem from Paul’s ambivalence between his overarching argument in First Corinthians for an interdependent communal body and an ingrained cultural bias toward gender differentiation and hierarchy. Since the argument is unclear, the passage creates a problem that requires his return—the issue of women “praying or prophesying” in the assembly. The arguments in 12:1–14:33 about spiritual gifts, the community as body, and inspired speaking in the assembly provide perspectives that allow the cognitive and rhetorical space for Paul to move from the conflicted argument in 11:2–16 to the silencing of women in the assembly in 14:34–35. The topics of women and inspired speaking when the community gathers, therefore, are intertwined in this letter and its historical situation in Corinth.
|
The Persona of the Sibyl in the Sibylline Oracles
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Jill Marshall, Emory University
The Sibyl is one of several composite and legendary female prophets that occupied the imaginations of Greek and Roman authors from Heraclitus to Pausanias and beyond. Her role in this large body of literature develops three rhetorical topoi that are key to her characterization: 1) her frenzied mental state during prophecy, 2) her sexuality, and 3) divine force and violence upon her. These three topoi, along with traditions that trace the Sibyl’s origins to primeval history and to specific locations in Greece, Asia Minor, or Italy, are the building blocks for creating the believable persona of the Sibyl in the Jewish (and Christian redacted) Sibylline Oracles. For the Jewish and Christian oracles, as in classical Greek and Latin traditions, the Sibyl is a female character whom male authors use to think about other topics. While classical authors use her to consider how the gods interact and communicate with humans, Jewish diaspora authors use her as the ultimate “Other” who could voice eschatological prophecy from an outside culture. In the process, they redefine unsuitable aspects of her character—her origins and source of inspiration—to make her a prophet of the true God and place her in biblical history. They retain the violent, sexual, and mad parts of her person because they are integral to prior rhetorical imaginings of her character. This paper examines the Sibyl’s character and rhetorical power in the Sibylline Oracles by analyzing the rhetorical topoi and her image-creation, especially in her self-descriptions that punctuate the revelations in the books.
|
The Peril of Paulinising Jesus: An Informed Review of the Synoptic Last Supper Accounts
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Mary J. Marshall, Murdoch University
The disparity between the Johannine and synoptic chronologies of the Last Supper has been satisfactorily resolved via Colin Humphreys’ theory of a Wednesday evening meal: John’s chronology is confirmed as consistent with the official Jewish calendar, with Jesus dying on Nisan 14, and the Passover falling on the Sabbath the following day. Hence, Jesus’ death coincides with the slaying of the Passover lambs, and his resurrection occurs on the first fruits festival, Nisan 16. John’s account therefore coheres with Paul’s identification of Christ as the paschal lamb (1 Cor 5:7), and as the first fruits of those who have died (1 Cor 15:20). The synoptic chronology is also endorsed, with Jesus following the pre-exilic Israelite calendar and commemorating the Passover on the true anniversary of the event. Problems remain, however. This theory implies that it was not Jesus’ intention to be viewed as the Passover sacrifice. Moreover, although Paul provides the earliest record of Jesus’ Last Supper sayings (1 Cor 11:23–25), his account overlooks the key motifs of the eschatological banquet and the restoration of Israel, by omitting the kingdom saying, and ignoring the presence of the Twelve. I therefore contend that Jesus’ intentions and actions can be discerned only through enlightened exegesis of the synoptic accounts of the meal. This paper draws on background from relevant Dead Sea Scrolls to show the plausibility of the concept that an alternative calendar was followed, and that the Last Supper was held in the home of an Essene Jerusalemite. I will argue that the synoptic accounts of the occasion are historically feasible and that insightful interpretations of the bread, cup, and kingdom sayings point to the occasion as a Passover celebration: a farewell meal at which Jesus authorised his successors, inaugurated the renewed covenant, and looked forward to the messianic banquet.
|
A Jewish Building in Limyra
Program Unit: Archaeology and Diaspora Judaism
Martin Seyer, Austrian Archaeological Institute
During the 2012 excavation season in Limyra, an ancient city in the south-west region of Lycia in Asia Minor, a building remarkable in many respects was discovered. Although only a small part in its north-east area could be brought to light so far, a few elements suggest that the edifice was used as a public building for the Jewish community of this city; maybe it was even her synagogue.
In its north-east corner one room was equipped with precious materials such as marble wall revetment and windows with glass of at least four different colors. Moreover, a square water basin was built in supplied by collected rainwater, which was channeled through a terracotta pipe into the basin. Some elements suggest that the basin was used for bathing.
The entry to the building led from the main street into a vestibule, which was originally partially open at the front. Its original floor cannot be ascertained, yet at a later period, it was raised to its current level by means of secondarily used stone slabs and pillars, which were deliberately broken for this purpose. The two slabs are chancel screens decorated with images of a menorah, with one of them additionally displaying a shofar, the other a lulav.
The unusual appearance and the fittings of the building, as well as the chancel screens raise the question of the structure’s function and meaning. Although this cannot be answered with certainty after the first excavation campaign, the combination of the different features suggests that the building has to be connected with the Jewish community of Limyra. The chancel screens – even laid down for secondary use – indicate that a synagogue was once located in the immediate vicinity; therefore it is not improbable that the building was itself this synagogue.
|
From Chaos to Coherence and Back: Some Thoughts on The Phenomenon of Harmonization in the Bible and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Corrado Martone, Università degli Studi di Torino
Emanuel Tov defines the phenomenon of harmonization text as follows: "scribes adapted many elements in the text to other details in the same verse, in the immediate context or in a similar one, in the same book and in parallel sections elsewhere in the Bible."
Elsewhere Tov says that "The different types of textual harmonization have in common the fact that they bring elements of the text into harmony with each other."
This is true for a clearly traceable history of a given text, and this is not always the case for the Hebrew bible.
This paper addresses the question whether we may always be sure that a difficult text is more ancient (or original) than a clear one. That a consistent reasoning is less ancient (or original) than a contradictory one. What if the accidents of textual history would have made some texts more difficult and contradictory over the centuries?
Examples will be given from the biblical and so-called parabiblical literature from Qumran as well as from other forms of Second Temple exegetical literature. Such examples will help investigate the possibility to find remains of more ancient text-forms in allegedly harmonistic passages.
|
Sarna and the Nemha Bible: The Politics of Biblical Translation among India’s Adivasis
Program Unit: Bible and Its Influence: History and Impact
Elsa J. Marty, University of Chicago
Tension between religious communities often arises with regard to rituals and cultural practices, but a recent case from India illustrates that the translation of sacred texts can also be a source of controversy. In 2000, the Bible Society of India published a translation of the Bible in the Kurukh (Oraon) tribal language. Known as the Nemha Bible, it translated the Hebrew word ra‘anan (green and verdant) as “sarna” (tree, grove of trees). While in terms of lexicography this is an accurate translation, it later became the object of great controversy, because Sarna is also the name of the traditional tribal religion still practiced by many adivasis (tribal people) in this region. In the fall of 2008, Sarna adivasis staged massive protests in response to the use of the word “sarna” in Deuteronomy 12:2, wherein God commands the Israelites to destroy the sites of Canaanite idol worship. Sarna adivasis read the verse as a call for Christians to destroy their religion. In this presentation I propose that the Sarna adivasi leaders used the controversy as a social and political tool to strengthen their sense of cultural and religious identity and make specific political demands. This incident demonstrates that the act of translating the Bible not only affects the Christian community for whom it is intended, but it also impacts members of other neighboring religious communities.
|
In an Ant’s School of Wisdom: A Holistic African/South African Reading of Prov 6:1-11
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Wisdom
Madipoane Masenya, University of South Africa
Committed to an ethic of industry, also, possibly persuaded by the precarious context of the production of the text of Proverbs, the wisdom teacher persuades his (male)students to watch and learn from an ant (namala),an insect. The namala can be regarded as one of the lowest members of the created species. Apart from the optimistic wisdom mentality embedded within Proverbs6:1-11, noteworthy is also an inter-connectedness between human beings and nature. The latter reveals the holistic outlook which typified biblical Israel, including the members of the post-exilic community in Yehud. Research on the wisdom underlying both the Hebrew Bible proverbs and selected African (Northern Sotho) proverbs, has revealed apparent resemblances between Israelite and African world views. If Proverbs6:1-11 is read from an African-South African holistic point of view, which insights might be gained from the text regarding the interconnectedness between human beings and Earth? Could the insights gained prove helpful in an unequal context such as present day South Africa? The preceding questions among others will form the core of the contents of the present paper
|
Bible-Consciousness and/or Biblical Criticism in Africa: What’s Going On?
Program Unit: Political Biblical Criticism
Madipoane Masenya, University of South Africa
That Christianity (and its sacred texts) is showing significant growth in Africa, particularly Africa, South of the Sahara, is well-documented. Also, the mushrooming of charismatic and neo-Pentecostal churches (and their unique interpretative strategies) on the African continent is a fact. That Biblical Studies as a discipline (and its focus on biblical criticism) is losing popularity within educational settings is also a harsh reality. Within the latter settings, some of the scholars choose to fore ground contextual approaches in their biblical scholarship. Within the broader Bible-conscious interpretative landscape, biblical criticism seems to remain a foreign concept and/ or exercise. The following questions are worth asking: Within a biblical criticism-unconscious context, one which sets great store by reader-friendly and many a time spiritually-focused bible interpretations, does and can biblical criticism have a place? If so, what is its meaning and more importantly, what is its role? The preceding questions among others, will form the main core of the present paper
|
The Portrayal of Cyrus and Moses as Royal Figures in Exodus and the Cyrus Cylinder
Program Unit: Ancient Near East
Danny Mathews, Pepperdine University
Most comparative studies of the Cyrus Cylinder deal with explicit references to Cyrus in the Chronicler's History (e.g., 2 Chronicles 36:22-23; Ezra 1:1-4; 6:1-6) and Deutero-Isaiah (Isa 44:28-45:3). Neglected is an implicit comparison of Cyrus with Moses through the use of common royal motifs.
This paper will list and analyze the royal motifs common to Moses and Cyrus to argue that both accounts use the basic sequence of the corvée, cry of the people, divine commissioning of the king as the agent, and "friend," of the deity, liberation of the people by leading a vast army, and restoration/construction of a sanctuary for the deity. In addition, the paper will note an additional royal motif mentioned in a recently identified cuneiform fragment that includes new material to the cylinder (in the British Museum, BM 47134 [1881,0830.656]).
This paper will discuss the implications of these shared motifs for a revised view of Moses as a royal figure as opposed to the common view of Moses as “prophet” and for understanding better the rhetoric and composition of the Pentateuch.
|
Absent Fathers, Fictive Kin: Repairing and Masking the Failure of Masculinity
Program Unit: Families and Children in the Ancient World
Steffan Mathias, King's College, London
Idealized imprints of genealogy, reproduction and fertility abound in the Hebrew bible, from the promises of descendants to Abraham in Genesis, to the edicts to pass down torah to one’s children in Deuteronomy. The valorization of women’s fertility has been well documented and critiqued by some feminist scholars; this paper seeks to widen the field and explore how men’s reproductive prowess is normalized, and how failures in masculinity are concealed and reimagined. The text suggests a norm in which lines of descent from male generation to male generation are maintained, and the passing on of ones name appears as a kind of continuation after death. Male non-production poses a threat to this chain, and destruction of offspring is cast as a threat in the afterlife (Isaiah 14:9-22, Jeremiah 11:19). Failures to reproduce are repaired by mechanisms such as levirate marriage (Deuteronomy 25:5-10, Genesis 38, Ruth) and the erection of monuments (2 Samuel 18:18) or reconfigured in striking ways, such as YHWH’s promise to the eunuch (Isaiah 56). Drawing on Lee Edelman’s notion of ‘reproductive futurism’ and the resulting embrace in queer theory of ‘failure,’ this paper will emphasize how biblical ‘failures’ in masculinity are concealed and corrected, as well as being projected onto female characters and subjectivities. This will add additional critical lenses for thinking about masculinity, reproduction, and perpetuation of the male name in biblical texts, and will offer opportunities to further resist the coercion of biblical women into maternal roles.
|
Double-plotting in the Garden: Stylistics of Ambiguity in Genesis 2–3
Program Unit: Literary Features – Fact or Fiction (EABS)
Karalina Matskevich, University of London
The garden narrative in Gen. 2-3 exhibits a series of dualities, evident at the level of the plot, particular characters of linguistic and conceptual organisation (cf. Yahweh and the serpent, male and female, tree of life and tree of knowledge, good and bad, life and death). However, this organising principle of duality is always moderated, made less clear-cut through use of different perspectives, polysemy, word-play, irony, and repetitions. Thus, the opposition 'male and female' is undermined by the ambiguity of the term ha'adam, which stands both for 'man' and for 'human being'. The existence of the two trees is put in question when each one of them is described as the tree 'in the middle of the garden' (Gen. 2.9; 3.3). The discourses of Yahweh and the serpent both contradict and correspond to each other: they operate with the same set of concepts (the pairs of 'all trees' and 'one tree', 'eat' and 'not eat', 'die' and 'not die'), and although the serpent's point of view is subversive, Yahweh seems to corroborate it in Gen. 3.22, saying that ha'adam has become like him, 'knowing good and bad'. Yet if, in the view of both Yahweh and the serpent, the forbidden knowledge makes ha'adam godlike, in the eyes of the human couple it only makes them see each other's nakedness (Gen. 3.7). Looking at stylistic and structural features of the narrative of Gen. 2-3, the paper argues that its persistent ambivalence stems from the double perspective of Yahweh, who prohibits the tree of knowledge and yet creates the woman and serpent whose actions lead ha'adam to eat from the tree. The paper proposes to read the narrative as an interaction of two opposing plots, in which the acquisition of knowledge is as pre-determined by Yahweh as it is forbidden by him.
|
Formulae and Literary Structure in Ezekiel 34–37
Program Unit: Prophets
Tyler Mayfield, Louisville Presbyterian Theological Seminary
Formulae and Literary Structure in Ezekiel 34–37
|
Script to Scripture: Multivalent Textuality
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
John Mc Carthy, Loyola University Chicago
This paper argues that, within the Christian tradition, a fundamental distinction needs to be observed between the Bible as a written text and the Bible as scripture. After discussing the kinds of textuality associated with the Bible in most contemporary scholarly study as well as the more robust theory of textuality characteristic of hermeneutical investigation and well-articulated by the work of Paul Ricoeur, the paper presents an analysis of the phenomenology of textuality appropriate to the Bible as scripture. This phenomenology draws on the work of Paul Ricoeur but reorients it by taking seriously the observation of Wilfred Cantwell Smith that scripture is better understood as an adverb than as a noun. This phenomenological reflection identifies scripture as a particular kind of elective intentionality directed to a text, rather than as a characteristic of or within a text. Combining the robust hermeneutical analysis of textuality with the phenomenology of scripture, the paper explains three kinds of textuality that are simultaneously present in the Bible by describing the characteristic spatiality of the various “worlds in front of text.” By grafting a phenomenological analysis of scripture onto the more conventional textual analysis of the Bible, the argument better locates the kinds of scholarly study appropriate to the Bible as scripture.
|
Assessing and Applying Mark’s Use of Transliterated Aramaic
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Timothy F. McCauley, University of Notre Dame
That the Gospel of Mark stands at a crossroads of orality and literacy is by in large taken as fact. As a result, the presence of transliterated Aramaic words and phrases in his Greek text presents us with a hermeneutical problem: why does Mark labor to include what appears to be aural extravagance within a literary landscape? This paper evaluates the presence of transliterated Aramaic words and phrases in the textus receptus of Mark’s gospel and proposes a methodology for assessing their literary and rhetorical value. Emphasizing the simple yet remarkable fact that Mark’s text is, indeed, text we will propose criteria by which we may evaluate and categorize the instances of transliterated Aramaic based on their speaker, their context, and whether or not the evangelist translated the Aramaic for his intended audience. Our conclusions will be aimed at formulating a workable hypothesis under which the above problem may be appropriately addressed. Finally, we will briefly attempt to justify our conclusions in light of contemporary Marcan scholarship.
|
Incarnational Linguistics: An Analysis of the Christology of the Pre-Chalcedonian Fathers
Program Unit: New Testament/Early Christianity/Rabbinic Studies (EABS)
Timothy F. McCauley, University of Notre Dame
This paper proposes a methodology based on the principles of linguistics under which the Incarnational Christology of the Pre-Chalcedonian fathers may be evaluated. This methodology emphasizes the differences between translation and transliteration, as well as the significance of the oral, aural, and visual values of given letters. Then, via an analogous evaluation of text and its transmission, we will demonstrate a process by which the various theories promulgated in the early Patristic period may be succinctly and definitively judged according to these established principles of linguistic evaluation.
|
Annihilation and the Prophetic Books
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Albert McClure, University of Denver
Stating that most prophetic books have as one of their thematic structures a movement from judgment—often times against foreign nations, but also against Israel and Judah—toward salvation is banal. In these prophetic texts god’s judgment is expressed in a number of different ways, e.g., oracles against the nations. One form of prophetic judgment that has as yet not been catalogued by biblical scholars is annihilation. Annihilation can be distinguished from genocide in that genocide constitutes the annihilation of a specific people group, e.g., Edomites, while annihilation constitutes the destruction of all living things. The prophetic texts about annihilation do not conform to a specific genre, but are connected by similar terms and phrases, and most of all, by a description and/or threat of annihilation. There are ten annihilation texts in the Hebrew prophets: Isa. 10:23, 24:17-23, 28:22, 34:1-4, Jer. 4:23-26, 25:28-33, Amos 7:4-6, Zeph. 1:2-2:3, and 3:8. Some of these texts have been grouped together before, but all ten texts have never been considered part of the same prophetic phenomenon. Annihilation texts can be further subdivided into two categories: (1) annihilation of all creation and (2) annihilation of all living things. The difference between category (1) and (2) is that ‘all creation’ includes a destruction of things such as “the heavens,” “the earth,” and/or “the sun, moon, and stars.” Category (1) includes Isa. 24:17-23, 34:1-4, Jer. 4:23-27, and Zephaniah 1:2-2:3. Category (2) includes Isa. 10:23, 28:22, Jer. 25:28-33, Amos 7:4-6, and Zephaniah 3:8. Yet, annihilation texts are always negated in the final form of the text. Annihilation is always averted. The negation of such a heinous judgment fits with the thematic movement from judgment toward salvation often used in the prophetic books, mentioned above.
|
The Syro-Phoenician Woman of Mark 7 and the Canaanite Woman of Matthew 15: Two Readings of What Could Have Been Taking Place
Program Unit: Psychological Hermeneutics of Biblical Themes and Texts
Heather McKay, Edge Hill University
In order to contrast a psychological reading of the nature of the event and of the woman with a theological reading, Matthew’s version needs must be laid alongside Mark’s, for working solely from the text, Mark does not present a theological view although Matthew does. Commentators, as is expected, present the theological reading or may give both readings when commenting on Mark’s version. The psychological reading presented here is based upon ‘normal’ psychology, although expressed and, rather more exactly, displayed, via the field of rhetoric. Admittedly, this would be unexpected from an unfamiliar woman conversing with a renowned, if ‘wayward’, teacher. The woman rejects the subordinate position allotted to her by her 'inferior' status, ethnicity and gender offering a deflecting riposte to unsettle her superordinate opponent.
|
Transmission of Original Sin in Classical Judaism
Program Unit: Judaica
Tirzah Meacham, University of Toronto
Signs of original sin which transfers guilt and punishment from generation to generation are not infrequent in the Bible and in rabbinic literature. S. Levy claims that principles of original sin existed in the corpus of Jewish texts including the Bible but in normative Judaism they did not develop in the same manner as Christianity. This paper will examine the criteria used by Augustine to explain the transfer of original sin through Adam and criteria used by the rabbis to explain the transfer through Eve. 1) In the Bible there are verses which express the transfer of sin from fathers to children and verses which make a connection between the human situation and sin, as if sin is the natural consequence of being born of woman. Although it is possible to understand these verses as a tendency to sin and not that in each person there is sin from the time of conception, other verses emphasize that humans do carry such a tendency. 2) In rabbinic literature and also in the Bible, human beings do not die free from sin rather sin itself is considered to cause death.
The Garden of Eden story, particularly as interpreted in rabbinic literature, indicates that Eve brought sin into the world and through her it was transmitted to all subsequent generations of humanity. This is similar to Augustine's description of how original sin became embedded in Adam and was transferred through him to all subsequent generations. In both cases the source of the sin is located in the generative organs. In Christianity baptism removes the stain of original sin from each individual in the subsequent generations while in Judaism giving of the Torah on Mount Sinai removed the stain of Eve’s sin from the Jewish people.
|
The Christian Reception History of the New Testament
Program Unit:
Martin Meiser, Universität des Saarlandes
In ancient Christianity, the New Testament has been the base for both dogmatic and moral teaching. The enculturation of the New Testament in an intellectually sophisticated milieu, however, raised questions not only of reception but also of technical exegesis. The history of ancient anti-Christian polemics reveals an increasing Biblical knowledge on the side of the adversaries. Therefore, Christian apologetics had to cover not only moral behaviour but also the wording of the Scripture itself. The fruit of these developments is a Christian exegesis, based on ancient philology on Homer, reliable for questions and doubts of careful readers, divergent interpretations made by so-called heretics, and anti-Christian attacks.
|
The City of Ephesus in Early Christian Literature
Program Unit: Early Christianity (EABS)
Martin Meiser, Universität des Saarlandes
“Ephesus: Amazonum opus, ciuitas in Asia ubi requiescat beatus euangelista Iohannes” (The Venerable Bede, CCL 121:171). Surprisingly, the Venerable Bede combined pagan (Plinius, Nat. Hist. 5.115) and Christian motives in this description. How did ancient Christian authors perceive this metropolis of both emperor’s cult and Christian faith? Are there differences with regard to the perception of the non-Christian cults, before and after 325 CE? The paper will deal with ancient commentaries on Acts, Ephesians, and Revelation; in addition, ancient writings on Christian history also will be studied.
|
Reception of Jeremiah 10 in Early Christian Literature
Program Unit: Texts and Contexts of Jeremiah: The Exegesis of Jeremiah 1 and 10 in light of Textual and Reception History
Martin Meiser, Universität des Saarlandes
The History of Ancient Christian reception of Jer 10:1–16 has its starting point very early; especially the contrast between the claim of deity and the wish for abolishment of these beings enables Christian authors to anti-heretic or anti-pagan polemics. Possible allusions to Jer 10 in the New Testament are based on functional analogy: In Rom 1:22 the dullness of idolatry, in Rev 15:3-4 the superiority of God is emphasized. Irenaeus, haer. 3.6.1 uses Jer 10 for anti-Gnostic polemics; Jeremiah’s wish for abolition is one of many clarifying additions of the Holy Scripture marking so-called deities as not really being of divine quality. Not polemics but piety is the main point of Origen’s allegorical interpretation of Jer 10:12.13 in Jer. hom. 8. However, later authors repeat the polemical line of interpretation, e.g. Jerome, in Ier. 2.85–90 (in anti-heretical context), Augustine, en. Psalm 98.2, who sees Jeremiah’s wish for abolition fulfilled in present times, in the deceasing of paganism, Theodoret of Cyrus, whose polemics are directed against astronomy and astrology, and Cassiodor’s comment on Ps LXX 113:12-16. On the other hand, Olympiodorus‘ Christological and moral exegesis, aside from any actual polemics, repeats Origen’s way of interpretation.
Concerning Jer 10, issues of textual criticism are not debated in the commentaries of Theodoret and Olympiodorus. Jerome’s general thesis of the superiority of the Hebrew text precludes in most cases (also in the case of Jer 10) modern debates on the superiority of the Vorlage.
|
Matthew 25:31-46: Queering "Caritas Christiana" through "Caritas Romana"
Program Unit: New Testament/Early Christianity/Rabbinic Studies (EABS)
Luis Menéndez-Antuña, Vanderbilt University
Matthew 25:31-46 describes the core of Caritas Christiana. Postcolonial and Empire Studies attentive to the relationship between Christianity and the Roman Empire have cast opposite ethical evaluations of this pericope, considering it either an instance of resistance literature (Warren Carter) or as complicit with Empire (Musa Dube). More recently, Fernando Segovia has analyzed such disagreements and, skipping to grant a final conclusion, closely underscores textual ideological tensions. In the present paper I expand the debate on the emancipatory potential of Matthew by analyzing and comparing artistic representations of Caritas Christiana and Caritas Romana. My contribution proceeds in two steps. First, I diagnose the problem by showing how opposite ethical and political evaluations find expression in two contemporary strands of interpretation: whereas liberationist approaches emphasize the identification of the "son of man" with the "poor," conservative renderings focus on the notion of the "son of man" as the judge and the idea of the American nation as "Christian" and "righteous." Such diagnosis calls, in my view, for creative ways to deconstruct the aforementioned tensions both at the textual and the history of interpretation levels. In the second part, I suggest a way out of such interpretative impasse. Here I pursue a constructive move in deconstructive fashion by arguing that the ethical standards set up in Matthew 25:31-46 as "Caritas Christiana" (feeding the hungry, clothing the naked...) are ironically best fulfilled in its original context and in the history of interpretation by non-Christian sources such as the myth of Pero and Cimon. Using as an example Renaissance paintings of both textual traditions (Caritas Christiana vs. Caritas Romana) I offer a queer reading of graphic representations in order to suggest a deconstruction of the dichotomies imbedded both in the text, and in the history of its interpretation.
|
A Revelation against Empire: A Material Reading of Liberationist Approaches to the Apocalypse of John
Program Unit: Political Biblical Criticism
Luis Menendez-Antuna, Vanderbilt University
The interpretation of the Apocalypse of John has a long tradition of emancipatory readings. In this tradition, the book Revelation is considered as a charter document for the unsettlement of the status quo in the Roman Empire with crucial consequences for a politics and ethics of resistance in the present imperial context. The present paper compares three liberatory readings in dialogical fashion to compare their materialist frameworks. Alan Boesak’s reading envisions a Christian document that poses believers with material stark choices (the New Jerusalem or Babylon); Pablo Richard sees in Revelation an invitation to leave behind the contemporary material idolatries; and Elizabeth Schüssler-Fiorenza understands the book as a template against Kyriarchy. These scholars and their respective geopolitical contexts (Africa, Latin-America, the United States of America) are brought together in dialogue with three objectives in mind: 1) relate their hermeneutical strategies to their geopolitical context, 2) identify the main trends in the materialist models deployed, and 3) relate their respective materialist assumptions to the way they emphasize or downplay textual elements in Revelation.
|
Thinking Resistance in the Age of Empire: Ethical Evaluations of the Apocalypse of John
Program Unit: Bible and Empire
Luis Menendez-Antuña, Vanderbilt University
Historical-critical, Literary, and Socio-Scientific Studies have approached the political import of Revelation in the past by introducing the category of “Empire” at the center of analysis. The Roman Empire functions as the backdrop of Christian formation, as a cultural signifier against which Revelation’s political proposal is defined. Ideological criticism typically goes a step further by assessing Revelation’s resistant strategies in terms of the present context. Furthermore, Postcolonial and Queer Criticism apply a hermeneutics of suspicion which divests Revelation of its potential radical ideology.
The present paper surveys how these different approaches have evaluated the political impact of Revelation in the past and the strategies they follow to bring such conclusions to the present. Despite the central role that the Roman Empire plays in all these approaches, hardly any attention has been paid to present imperial formations. “Empire” is a central category of analysis in Postcolonial and Queer Criticism, but it almost exclusively refers to the “Roman Empire.” The question of “North-American Empire,” that is, of the proper contextualization of the contemporary geopolitical context in which the text is appropriated, is dismissed.
I shall proceed in two steps: First, I survey “ethical evaluations” of the book of Revelation in terms of Empire presenting scholarly interpretations that either term Revelation as literature resisting Empire or complicit with Empire. Second, I contextualize such ethical evaluations in the context of the present Empire in order to put forward an emancipatory reading.
|
Tendencies in the Reception of the Book of Leviticus in Second Temple Literature
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Sarianna Metso, University of Toronto
Leviticus is one of the most often-quoted books among the Second Temple writings, and an examination of the interpretive techniques used by Second Temple writers reveals considerable freedom in combining legal discourse with other modes of discourse, such as wisdom and apocalyptic. This tendency of breaking genre boundaries is visible in the Dead Sea Scrolls, but it is indicative of broader currents of interpretation in Second Temple literature, attested also in Ben Sira, Baruch, and 1 Enoch, for example. This paper examines instances of creative reception of Leviticus passages in the Scrolls and broader Second Temple literature, where Leviticus is used as a source text in discussions that stand outside the legal genre.
|
The Manly Wrath of God
Program Unit: Emotions and the Biblical World (EABS)
Maria Metzler, Harvard University
My paper examines the representation of Yhwh’s wrath in the Hebrew Bible in comparison to the way angry gods are depicted in ancient Greek and Mesopotamian texts. Whereas the Bible features a male god exclusively, in other ancient literature we find descriptions of both male and female deities in states of rage. In Aeschylus’s Eumenides, for example, vindictive anger is personified as the Furies, a grisly hunting party of desolate female spirits. I will examine the characterization of male and female divine wrath in selected texts, tracing any differences in the way this anger is triggered, manifested, or appeased depending on the gender of the deity. I will also consider whether these deities’ wrath is expressed differently depending on the gender of the god or human who provoked them. In this respect, it may be significant that the biblical God is only able to direct his anger towards humans, since as a (more or less) solitary deity, he is not presented as engaging in emotionally charged relationships with other gods. On a broader level, I look at metaphors used to describe the enraged deities. Are males or females more frequently imagined as a warrior, animal, spurned lover, avenging parent? Based on the conclusions drawn from this comparative investigation, I will return to the biblical text and discuss to what extent Yhwh’s wrath may be said to be distinctively masculine. Scholars have noted ways in which the God of Israel appears to have absorbed or incorporated characteristics of lost female deities. If it is possible to delineate the contours of female divine wrath, I will also consider whether the male deity of the Hebrew Bible has taken on any aspects of rage that can be regarded as distinctively feminine.
|
"I seek my brethren" (Gen 37:16): The Writer Ya`akov Yehosua (1905–1982) and His Memories Regarding the Old Sephardi Community in Jerusalem
Program Unit: The Bible in the Iberian World: Fundaments of a Religious Melting Pot (EABS)
Alisa Meyuhas-Ginio, Tel Aviv University
Ya`akov Yehoshua was born in the Yemin Moshe Quarter of Jerusalem and was brought up in Egypt. Therefore he was fluent in the Arabic language. When he was sixty years old, he started to publish a series of books entitled in Hebrew: Childhood in old Jerusalem, and in Ladino: Ninez en la vieja civdad de Yerushalayim: descripciones de vida sefaradia en el siecolo passado. In his books Ya`akov Yehoshua described the way of life of the old sephardi community in Jerusalem: family life, festivities, houses, patios and market places. He also described the Rabbis of the community. The importance of his writings consists in the testimonies and memories coming out of the sephardi community: the way the sephardim saw themselves.
|
The Calling of a Prophet: Jeremiah 1:4-19 as Discussed by Shmuel Yerushalmi (Kreuzer) in His Me’am Lo’ez – A Hebrew Commentary on the Book of Jeremiah, Jerusalem, 1987
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Alisa Meyuhas-Ginio, Tel Aviv University
Rabbi Shmuel Yerushalmi (Kreuzer) (1921-1997), a disciple of Lithuanian Yeshivot in Jerusalem, translated from Ladino into Hebrew, the Me’am Lo’ez - the commentaries on thirteen books of the Hebrew Bible, written by ten different authors, in the years 1732-1899; thus bringing the said commentaries to the attention of the contemporary Hebrew-reading public, no longer familiar with Ladino. Moreover: Rabbi Shmuel Yerushalmi wrote his own commentaries on the rest of the books of the Hebrew Bible, not discussed by the Ladino scholars, following the same method and sources used by those Ladino commentators.
Shmuel Yerushalmi elaborated on Jeremiah, 1:1 discussing the prophet’s place of birth: Anathoth; not Jerusalem; thus he could preach to his contemporary Jerusalemites. Yerushalmi next dealt with the prophet’s father: H?ilki’ah, who – according to RaDak (Rabbi David Kimhi (c.1160-c.1235) - was the high priest who discovered the Book of the Law (the Torah) in the Temple, in the days of king Josiah (2 Kings, 22). Following Rashi (Rabbi Shlomo Yitzh?aki (1040-1105), Shmuel Yeruslami wrote that the Prophet Jeremiah was a descendant of Rahab, the harlot of Jericho: she whose life had been sinful - repented; her descendant Jeremiah was to reproach his contemporary Judean people, who were descendants of honest and decent parents, yet their everyday doings were evil. Because of his just deeds, the reign of Josiah was the time when three prophets were active: Jeremiah, Zephaniah and H?uldah. Yerushalmi elaborated on Jeremiah’s hesitation to accept his calling: “Ah, Lord God! Behold, I cannot speak for I am a child (Jeremiah, 1,6)” and the Lord’s reassuring answer.
Jeremiah was to preach not only to the people of Judea, but also to the Gentiles.
|
'I Am a Christian Woman!': Social Identity in the Passion of Perpetua
Program Unit: Apostolic Fathers and Related Early Christian Literature
Paul Middleton, University of Chester
Many New Testament texts suggest that Christian identity modifies or even replaces prior social identity markers. Early Christian communities created new relationships based on fictive kinship rendering familial identity redundant (Mk 3.35), and blood relations a potential source of hostility (Mk 13.12). Moreover, gender identity may also be subsumed within the greater category of 'Christian' (e.g. Gal. 3.28). In this paper I will demonstrate that the Passion of Perpetua follows this agenda, creating new Christian identity at the expense of Perpetua’s prior identities as wife, daughter, and mother, each of which appears to be incompatible with her identity as a Christian martyr. However, the text’s handling of her identity as a woman is more complex, culminating in her prison vision during which she is transformed into a male warrior and overcomes an adversary who represents Satan. Many commentators from Augustine onwards have read this gender-transforming vision as an indication that in order to be victorious over Satan, the final hurdle Perpetua must overcome is her identity as a woman. However, I will argue Perpetua’s female identity is not in fact obliterated by her Christian confession. When she conquers Satan through her martyrdom, she does so by her confession as a ‘Christian woman’.
|
Saintly Lives and Holy Deaths: Martyr-Saints in the Book of Revelation
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
Paul Middleton, University of Chester
The figure of the martyr is often held to be the ultimate paradigm of Christian discipleship; the one who is prepared to follow the Lamb wherever he goes (Rev. 14.4) to the point of giving up her life for the sake of the gospel. Rudimentary martyr devotion in early Christianity prefigures the more elaborate Cult of the Saints which developed in later centuries, and it is therefore unsurprising that most of the early Christian figures remembered as ‘saints’ were also ‘martyrs’. While ‘the saints’ in the earliest Christian documents refer to the people of God as a whole, the term came to be associated with a subset of Christian individuals who led particularly ‘saintly’ lives or exhibited ‘holy’ deaths. In this paper, I will argue that the development towards a more technical and exclusive usage of ‘saint’ is anticipated in the Book of Revelation, where already ‘saints’ are ‘martyrs’ and ‘martyrs’ are ‘saints’.
|
Biblical Interpretation in the Dialogue with Trypho by Justin the Martyr
Program Unit: The Reception of the Scripture in the Patristic Exegesis (II-VIII centuries) (EABS)
Alexandru Mihaila, Universitatea din Bucuresti
In the Dialogue with Trypho, a Jew, Justin the Martyr developed th e Christian biblical interpretation already used in the New Testament and the Apostolic Fathers. The present paper proposes to investigate the hermeneutic principles that underlie his writing and to draw some general conclusions about the early Christian biblical exegesis. Regarding the biblical textual witnesses Justin conferred the only authority to the Septuagint, rejecting the Hebrew text. Within the Old Testament, the principle of selection came to the fore, i.e. the preference for the prophetic utterances against the cult regulations. Justin the Martyr also applied typological and allegorical exegeses that competed with the literally interpretation of the prophetic texts.
|
Scriptures' Interpretation by the Author of Barnabas' Epistle
Program Unit: The Reception of the Scripture in the Patristic Exegesis (II-VIII centuries) (EABS)
Delia Mihaila, Universitatea din Bucuresti
This study discusses the means of interpretation of the Holy Scriptures by the au thor of Barnabas' letter. The author asserts a unity between the Old and New Covenant which lies in the spiritual dimension of the Law. However, it is the New Covenant that brings the true perspective of the Law's interiorization for those believing in the Cross and Resurrection of Jesus Christ. Hence, the New Covenant fulfills the Old one, and the central hermeneutical key is an Christological one. Concerning hermeneutical methods, it seems the author has mainly an allegorical thinking. Even with typology, although the use of the term typos is rather a technical one, allegorical elements are blended. The scarce use of the term parabole has also an allegorical, hidden meaning.
|
Early Christian Commentators on the Book of Acts
Program Unit: The Reception of the Scripture in the Patristic Exegesis (II-VIII centuries) (EABS)
Justin A. Mihoc, University of Durham
The Book of Acts can be seen as neglected by early biblical exegetes, despite its importance to the history of the early Church and its status in the biblical canon. In the Patristic period, the only complete (and extant) commentaries on the book are a series of 55 homilies by John Chrysostom, a Latin versified baptismal commentary by Arator, and a commentary by Bede the Venerable. Despite the existence of various other fragments and homilies on Acts by other authors, the three abovementioned are the only Patristic writers who left us an interpretation of the entire book.
Of them, the homiletical commentary of John Chrysostom is the most extensive and provides the earliest attempt to offer a full treatment of this canonical book. Chrysostom himself begins his first sermon on Acts by saying that ‘to many persons this Book is so little known, both it and its author, that they are not even aware that there is such a book in existence.’ (In Acta Apostolorum 1; PG 60.13) His words show how little this book was known in those first centuries, and might explain the apparent neglect of it.
My paper attempts to offer an exploration of the early commentaries of Luke’s second book, showing its early reception and explaining its use in the Early Church.
|
The Pre-Existence of the Church in the New Testament and Early Patristic Thought
Program Unit: Biblical Interpretation in Early Christianity
Justin A. Mihoc, University of Durham
In the first chapters of Acts we are presented with the story of the infant Church, a narrative that reminds the reader of the Genesis story, one that shows the Spirit creating again. I will argue that Luke has consciously composed his narrative with the Genesis account in mind, with a desire to convey the history of the early days of the Church in Jerusalem as the New Creation. This later developed into the idea of her being pre-existent in God’s mind, the fulfillment of Creation and its ultimate goal.
The Church as being in the mind of God from the Creation, and even its existence before that, is an idea found in early Christian Fathers, such as Origen, the author of the Shepherd of Hermas, and with strong echoes in Rabbinic Judaism. My paper will focus on exploring the Book of Acts as a witness to this idea, bidding to show how Luke has shaped his narrative as a history of beginnings, indeed a new Creation story.
Both Christian and Jewish sources will be taken into account in an attempt to discover how this underexplored idea is both rooted (or hinted at) in the Scripture and also influenced early Christian theology and the doctrine of the Church. This interpretation, although having had a limited influence, is significant in understanding early attempts to explain the role and function of the Church in a time when Christians were still a long way from determining their identity as the New Creation.
|
When and How Does Slavery End? A Case Study in Multivalence within the Pentateuch
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
Matthias Millard, Kirchliche Hochschule Wuppertal/Bethel
When does slavery end? In the individual 7th year, in the general 7th or the 50th? Different answers within different texts - and what is the message of the Pentateuch and the Canon? The answer given will take special care not only of the historical development of the question, but also of the compositional place in which the texts are arranged.
|
Invasion of the Body Defilers: Impurity and Contagion in Leviticus and Science Fiction
Program Unit: Science Fiction and the Bible (EABS)
Eva Miller, University of Oxford
My paper would examine the concept of impurity and its creation and spread in Leviticus and compare this to depictions of plague, outbreak, and contamination in science fiction. Leviticus treats impurity as something that is real an d bodily manifested and its effects as potentially deadly and community-destabilising, just as science fiction treats invisible or fantastical notions (invented diseases, psychic plague, possession) as real and dangerous. I would compare Levitical models of impurity to the 'classic' model of zombie outbreak (as exemplified in, e.g., the works of George Romero), invasive transforming aliens in works such as Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1956), The Thing (1982), and Star Trek: The Next Generation, demon possession in the television series Supernatural, and the representation of decay and entropy in horror stories of H.P. Lovecraft and William Hope Hodgson. This comparison poses various questions: where does impurity come from? Do SF works differ from Leviticus in figuring impure contagions as alien rather than as a natural result of contaminating human bodily processes? How is contagion imagined to spread physically-through contact, penetration, proximity? Does an actor need to commit a wrong (moral or technical) to incur contagion? In what instances can a wrong committed by one actor come to impact a wider community? And, ultimately, what is it about the concept of impurity and contagion that makes it so compelling to ancient Israelites and modern SF authors alike?
|
The Intersection of Orality and Style in Biblical Hebrew
Program Unit: Stylistics and the Hebrew Bible
Cynthia L. Miller-Naudé, University of the Free State - Universiteit van die Vrystaat
Beginning in the 19th century, biblical scholarship examined the orality of biblical texts as part of an attempt to discern the oral traditions that lie behind the written text, on the one hand, and the Sitz im Leben (‘life setting’) of the biblical traditions, on the other (Gunkel 1930/1967; Morag 1969). Oral features were identified within a variety of genres, including narrative (Niditch 1996), prophecy (Culley 2000; Nissinen 2000), and the Psalms (Culley 1967). More recently, attention has shifted to the role of oral tradition and scribal activity in the composition and editorial shaping of the biblical text (Polak 1998; Millard 1999).
In this paper we explore various aspects of orality in Biblical Hebrew as a function of various kinds of “style” (see Coupland 2007). We are particularly interesting in attempting to differentiate oral features as representative of the idiolect of individual speakers/writers/editors as opposed to oral features that are related to the rhetorical features of oral language (or “formulaic style” [Polak 2013]).
|
Examining the Cartography of Cosmic Law in Psalms
Program Unit: Israel and the Production and Reception of Authoritative Books in the Persian and Hellenistic Period (EABS)
Mary Mills, Liverpool Hope University
This paper emerges from the concept of law and righteousness as joint principles of ordering cosmic space. The pragmatic face of this alignment is found in imagery of weather, agriculture and social order, hence nature and society provide the practical sites of cosmic order. Exploration of this framework contextualises a moral anthropology which draws on the symbiosis between natural and human worlds and which in turn promotes discussion of cosmic order as that which gives meaning to experiences of chaos. The paper explores these views with reference to aspects of cartography which offer a reading lens for interpreting the spatial poetics of Psalms
|
Mountain and Valley as Sites of Ritualised Death
Program Unit: Place, Space, and Identity in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Mary Mills, Liverpool Hope University
The paper explores the spatial mapping of four HBOT passges in which the death of humans is presented in a ritualised style: Genesis 22, Judges 11, Joshua 7 and Jeremiah 7:30ff. In each passage the theme of sacrifice shapes the story-telling, a mode which touches on human desire for favourable relations with the deity. Interpretive tools for the study of texts are drawn from the work of Rene Girard and Bruno Latour. While mainstream commentary focuses on the role of human beings and their fate in these passages this paper examines the manner in which human use of mountains and valleys imposes on inanimate sites the identity of death-dealer, both literally and symbolically.
|
Apocryphal Tradition in Medieval Bulgaria: Adaptation or Deviation?
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Anissava Miltenova, Bulgarian Academy of Sciences
In 1960ties and 1970ties some Slavic scholars associated the concept of apocryphal works and elements with the well-known precepts of Bogomilism as an ideological and social tradition that contradicted an ‘official ideology’. This understanding later has been fully revised as a result of the establishment of the medieval literary process as a mixture of canonical, quasi-canonical, and non-canonical elements (Alexander Naumov, 1976). The relationship among these elements, is simultaneously much more complicated and much more homogeneous than it was thought to be only ten-fifteen years ago.
The presentation poses some questions about the correlations and similarities among apocryphal, exegetical, and catechetical medieval literature in the context of Mediterranean World and their reception in Medieval Bulgaria (10th–14th cc.). Examination both of the history of the texts and of their perception provide a basis for a general concept that the prevailing part are works (original ones as well as translations) which convey the Christian creed in a manner accessible for newly baptized peoples. Some of Slavonic non-canonical compilations (i.e. historical and apocalyptic works, 11th–13th c.) gave utterance of political ideas and protuberances of political thinking, especially during periods of crucial historical events, invasions, wars and conquests.
Finally, the author tries to make a survey of the chronology and sources of translated and original texts which should be termed as parabiblical literature (Emmanuel Tov, 2002) or paratextual literature (Armin Lange, 2010). These texts functioned in the medieval Bulgarian written tradition after a continuous evolution, after having spread throughout the Middle East, Georgia, Armenia, the Byzantine provinces, and Southern Italy. Translations from Byzantine Greek to Old Church Slavonic were transmitted to medieval Russia, Serbia, Croatia and all over the Balkan Peninsula. In this sense medieval Bulgarian literature is a mediator for all Orthodox Slavic literatures in the passing through them the apocrypha.
|
Rhetoric of Circularity and Biblical Paradox
Program Unit: Methods in New Testament Studies
Richard K. Min, University of Texas at Dallas
Circular rhetoric found in various biblical paradoxes is the main topic and theme of this paper. In our scholarly tradition, any circular logic or circular rhetoric has been considered logically invalid or as nonsense. Biblical scholarship is no exception, which has caused a devastating impact and damage by ignoring any circular rhetoric frequently found in the Bible. However, there has been a renewed interest due to the innovative approach by Kripke in the study of paradox and rhetoric of circularity, and its application to biblical paradox by Min. This new paradigm is the primary critical method in this paper, to understand and analyze biblical paradox of circularity in New Testament Studies. This paper explores and presents this new paradigm as a critical method in understanding and analysis of biblical paradox and circular rhetoric in the Bible. Selected biblical examples in the Bible are presented and analyzed, mostly from the gospels. Based on these concrete examples, the current study provides a promising new prospective and paradigm, with many groundbreaking results toward a new critical method in the study of biblical paradox and circular rhetoric. A few noteworthy features in biblical paradox including the rhetoric of circularity, nonmonotonicity, and modality are noted and discussed. On the mystery and supremacy of Jesus Christ, two noteworthy Christological examples are presented and analyzed. The first example is the claim by John the Baptist in John 1:15 and 1:30 in the primitive Christianity. The second example is the case of Melchizedek in Hebrews 7 in the light of Psalm 110.
|
Rhetoric of Circularity and Biblical Paradox in Jn 1:15 and 1:30
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Richard K. Min, University of Texas at Dallas
The study of paradox has been one of the most misunderstood or neglected areas in contemporary biblical scholarship for the latter half of the 20th century. However, there has been a renewed interest due to the innovative approach and breakthrough pioneered by Kripke in the study of paradox of circularity, and its application to biblical paradox by Min. This paper presents and extends this new perspective and paradigm of circular rhetoric and its interpretive validity for the case of the mystery of Jesus Christ by John the Baptist in John 1:15 and 1:30 in the primitive Christianity. Some well-known examples of biblical paradox of circularity are surveyed and analyzed. Two proof methods in John 8:12-20 are analyzed and discussed to establish the exegetical basis and validity of circular rhetoric and interpretation. A few noteworthy features in biblical paradox including the rhetoric of circularity, nonmonotonicity, and modality are noted and discussed. One similar and parallel example on biblical paradox in the contemporary New Testament scholarship is found in the work of Cullmann on the two-stage coming of the Kingdom of God, expressed in temporal-modal logic of “already” and “not yet” in tension (Luke 17:20–30), in the framework of the salvation history. The current study provides a promising new prospective and paradigm, with many groundbreaking results toward the study of Johannine literature in the light of biblical paradox and circular rhetoric.
|
A New Interpretive Paradigm for Melchizedek in Hebrews 7
Program Unit: New Testament/Early Christianity/Rabbinic Studies (EABS)
Richard K. Min, University of Texas at Dallas
The study of paradox has been one of the most neglected areas in contemporary biblical scholarship for the latter half of the 20th century. However, there has been a renewed interest due to the innovative approach and breakthrough pioneered by Kripke in the study of paradox of circularity, and its application to biblical paradox by Min. This paper presents and extends this new perspective and paradigm of rhetoric of circularity and its interpretive validity for the case of Melchizedek in Hebrews 7. Some well-known examples of biblical paradox of circularity are surveyed and analyzed. Two proof methods in John 8:12-20 are analyzed and discussed for the biblical basis and validity of circular rhetoric and interpretation. A few noteworthy features in biblical paradox including circularity, nonmonotonicity, and modality are noted and discussed. One landmark example on biblical paradox in the contemporary New Testament scholarship is found in the work of Cullmann on the two-stage coming of the Kingdom of God, expressed in temporal-modal logic of “already” and “not yet” in tension (Luke 17:20–30), in the framework of the salvation history. The current study provides a promising new prospective and paradigm, with many groundbreaking results toward the study of Hebrews with respect to biblical paradox and circular rhetoric.
|
The Reception of Apocryphal Traditions in the East-Syrian Tradition of Scriptural Exegesis: Bar Sarošwai on Melchizedek
Program Unit: Bible and Syriac Studies in Context
Sergey Minov, Freie Universität Berlin
This paper discusses an unpublished fragment from the now lost book of questions-and-answers on Scripture by Sabrišo bar Sarošwai, an East-Syrian scholar from the tenth century. This fragment, preserved in a florilegium in manuscript Cambridge, University Library, Oo. 1. 29, f. 270b, addresses the question of the genealogy of Melchizedek. In his dealing with this issue, Bar Sarošwai provides the names of Melchizedek's parents as well as some additional extra-canonical information on this scriptural figure. The paper presents the text and addresses the question of the material's relation to the previous tradition of treating the figure of Melchizedek in Syriac literature. The paper also addreses the general problem of handling apocryphal material in the East-Syrian tradition of Scriptural exegesis.
|
All But an “Emotion”: Compassion between Divine Attribute, Body Part, Pathos, and Virtue
Program Unit: Emotions and the Biblical World (EABS)
Francoise Mirguet, Arizona State University
Through the example of pity and compassion, the paper will study the limitations and relative inadequacy of the category “emotion” when working with ancient Jewish texts, in Hebrew and in Greek. The different terms usually translated by “compassion” (rachamim or chesed, sumpatheia or eusplagchnia) and “pity” (eleos and oiktos) hardly overlap with the modern concept of “emotion.” Rather, they refer to a bodily organ where intense emotions are felt, a favorable stance almost exclusively divine, a human pathos (not quite corresponding to our “emotion,” as shown by Konstan, 2006), or a nascent virtue. The paper will briefly retrace how a Greek pathos, pity (eleos), is introduced in the Greek translation of the Hebrew scriptures, where rachamim is primarily a divine stance towards vulnerable human beings; how eleos becomes a quality both divine and human; how eleos is reinterpreted according to Hebrew categories, and how, in parallel, a Hebrew word, chesed, is reinterpreted according to the Greek term (Joosten, 2004). In Judeo-Hellenistic texts, this lexical possibility, expanded by other lexemes (including the root splagchn-, which may copy the embodied rechem), gives rise to “something” close to our compassion (for example, Josephus), sometimes evoking our empathy (Testament of Zebulun), or interpreted as a virtue (for example, Philo), which may be given a divine model (Letter of Aristeas). What we call today “emotion,” therefore, may not have been the same “thing” (and certainly not always an emotion) throughout its development, even if this process exhibits continuity. In fact, the very shifts undergone by the notion (from body part to divine attribute, from divine attribute to human response, etc.) may have contributed to semantic expansion. This diversity, in turn, calls for our flexibility in using and combining methods.
|
The Images and the Light: Deciphering the Metaphysics of Thomas 83
Program Unit: Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha
Ivan Miroshnikov, University of Helsinki
As Peter Nagel puts it, Thomas 83 “ist ebenso tiefgründig wie unverständlich.” It seems that the Coptic text is incomprehensible because it is corrupt. The text makes much more sense if we emend it according to the proposal of Berliner Arbeitskreis für koptisch-gnostische Schriften. The content of the emended saying may be divided into four statements: (1) there are visible images; (2) the light of the visible images is concealed in them and, therefore, invisible; (3) the light of the father will be visible; (4) the image of the father will be concealed by his light. Thus Thomas 83 clearly opposes the divine image with the mundane ones. The images that are visible to the human being are the images in Platonic sense, i.e. the objects present in the phenomenal world. The idea that there is light within the phenomenal objects would not be confusing for the readers of Thomas, since a number of Thomasine sayings teach that the light is already present in the world, and yet no one can see it. The “image of the Father” is most probably the image of God lost by the humanity after the Fall. The light that will conceal the image is Adam’s splendor that the righteous ones will regain in the last times. When saying 83 points out that the Father’s image will be concealed in the Father’s light it seems to describe the blinding radiance of the righteous. The point is that the light will be so bright that it would be impossible to see anything else.
|
Longing for Israel's Restoration: The Eschatological Reading of Genesis and Exodus in Ancient Egyptian Judaism
Program Unit: Reception History of Jewish Scriptures in Graeco-Roman Egypt
Ulrike Mittmann, Universität Osnabrück
In Egyptian Judaism of the Hellenistic era, the Books of Genesis and Exodus rank among the most received books. This is due to the fact that both books focus on Egypt when dealing with the formation of the people of Israel: They tell about Jacob’s entering the land with his family and about the Exodus of Israel as a nation that has emerged from Jacob’s 12 sons.
For Jews, Israel’s Exodus from Egypt is the primeval event which in terms of salvation and election constitutes the relation between God and his people Israel. Thus the Exodus is the main point of reference for Israel’s eschatological hopes in all layers of the Hebrew Bible and in Early Judaism. That eschatological expectations were tense among the Jews of Egypt is due to the fact that life in the Diaspora per se yielded the question of Israel’s future irrespective the social, economic and cultural conditions under which Jews in Egypt organized their lives. The eschatological restoration of the 12 tribes is one of the central theological issues in Jewish scriptures of the Hellenistic period, and the figures on which these scriptures focus are the patriarchs and Moses. Of course, there is much variety in how this referential literature is fashioned. Several examples from different times and backgrounds (e.g. Demetrios, SapientiaSalomonis, Joseph und Asenet) will be presented and interpreted in order to show, that the Reception History of the Books of Genesis and Exodus is shaped by an eschatological yearning that binds together the Jews of Egypt and works as a marker for Jewish identity in Hellenistic-Roman times.
|
The Use of "Content and Context Related Criteria" in the Characterization of the LXX Translation Technique of the Second Book of Reigns
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible/Old Testament/Ancient Israel Studies (EABS)
Lisa Hui, Université Catholique de Louvain
The present research paper investigates the Greek translation of the Second Book of Reigns from the perspective of the methodology of content and context related criteria newly developed within the context of the Louvain school of Septuagint studies and textual criticism (Ausloos and Lemmelijn). The paper begins with a brief review of the contemporary research on the translation technique of LXX Reigns, followed by an exposition of the characteristics of the translation of the Second Book of Reigns employing the content and context related criteriology. By means of illustration of concrete examples in ????????? ?', we can have a better understanding of the translator's character in terms of his literalness, freedom, faithfulness and creativity as he renders his Hebrew Vorlage into Greek. Where the Septuagint differs from the Masoretic Text, the current investigation of the LXX translation technique enables us to distinguish between deviations in the Greek text which are to be attributed to a different Hebrew Vorlage and deviations which are attributable to the translator's creativity. The aim of this paper is to present a draft of the picture of the translation character as manifested in ????????? ?'. This can then serve as a piece of the puzzle of the LXX translation technique of the four Books of Reigns, a project which the candidate is striving to accomplish in her doctoral research.
|
The Stereotype of a Pharisee: A Case Study of the Development of Group Identity among Early Jesus Followers
Program Unit: Psychological Hermeneutics of Biblical Themes and Texts
Jarek Moeglich, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
Assumptions:
1. The verbal expressions illustrate the “state of mind” of the early Jesus-followers and allow us insights into their stereotype of a Pharisee.
2. The Gospel of Matthew was written ca. 20-30 years before John.
3. The authorship of the gospels should be assigned to certain groups rather than to single individuals (Hübenthal, 2012).
4. During the time between these two gospels, a significant development in the group identity of the Jesus followers’ took place.
Raimo Hakola (2008) studied the stereotype of a Pharisee in the Gospel of Matthew. He applied the social identity theory of Henry Tajfel (1981).
In my paper I intend to broaden Hakola’s approach and study the development of the stereotype of a Pharisee in the New Testament and compare it with the writings of Flavius Josephus.
I use the methods of psycholinguistics: vocabulary frequency analysis and the analysis of semantic fields in order to establish the stereotype of a Pharisee in the Matthean and Johannine Gospels and in Flavius Josephus.
The working hypothesis is that the stereotype of a Pharisee changed between the Gospel of Matthew and the Gospel of John because the Jesus-followers developed a stronger identity based not on contrast but on positive identification. The gospel of Matthew is a witnesses of the period when Jesus-followers were at the stage of feeling threatened by the Pharisees (cf. the strongly negative vocabulary and expressions used), while the Johannine gospel illustrates the views of the Jesus followers who did not needed any more such a stereotype because they had developed their own positive identity. In this part, I shall apply social identity theory.
The texts of Flavius Josephus help us to understand how Pharisees where seen by an (at least alleged) insider. In term of psychological research, Flavius Josephus’ texts function like “a control group.”
|
Between Tanakh, Quran, and Tafsir: Examining Two Shared Stories of David and Solomon
Program Unit: Quran and Islamic Tradition in Comparative Perspective
Khaleel Mohammed, San Diego State University
The Tanakh and the Quran share many narratives, among them certain stories relating to David and his son, Solomon. But whereas the Tanakh’s presentation of its stories is in a generally detailed, chronological format, the Quran only summarizes or refers to specific aspects of the greater narrative(s). This would seem to indicate that the Quran presupposes that its readers are aware of the general details of a story, or have access to such. I argue that over the period of time, certain developments in Islamic theology clashed with the Quran’s presuppositions, and led to the eschewal of certain earlier assumptions or exegetical material. In this presentation, I would like to examine excerpts from two narratives: Q. 38:21-25, which refers to David’s being forgiven for some error, and Q. 27:44 which refers in the most truncated way to an aggadic story of the encounter between Solomon and the queen of Sheba. Several researchers have covered some exegetical material regarding David’s error. There has been no previous in-depth examination of Q. 27:44 and how its exegesis might have changed over time. Here, I will examine the works of select exegetes from the classical to the modern period, charting the changes in interpretation and examining the possible reasons that precipitated such change.
|
Solomon and the Queen of Sheba in the Quran: A Mystical Reading
Program Unit: Quran and Islamic Tradition in Comparative Perspective
Adnane Mokrani, Pontifical Institute for Arabic and Islamic Studies & Pontifical Gregorian University
Narratives constitute about a quarter of the total number of verses in the Quran. They are especially important because of their rich mythical and symbolic nature, much appreciated and developed by Sufis, and relatively neglected or misinterpreted in other currents of Islam. We find the story of Solomon and the Queen of Sheba in the Sura of the Ants (Q. 27:15-44), in one section not repeated elsewhere in the Quran. The analytical method applied in this paper is based on the symbolic parallels to discover semantic structures that go beyond its appearance. This reading finds its confirmation in the interpretation of the same story by the Sufi Master Rumi (d. 1273) in his major work the Mathnawi (IV, 845-1044), which is considered by some to be a “Persian Quran,” a kind of spiritual commentary on scripture. This paper illustrates the spiritual richness of the story, as a common Abrahamic heritage, in its Quranic version and Sufi interpretation. Bilqis (the name of the Queen of Sheba in the Islamic tradition) for Rumi is nothing more than a symbol of the human soul in its journey towards God, and her magnificent throne is none other than the temptation of selfishness and the fire of the power of this world. The move from the throne of Sheba to the Throne of God represents symbolically the initiatory journey from the individual self to the Universal Self. The story also emphasizes the artistic dimension of religion, considering arts and aesthetics as an authentic expression of the religious experience and the best instruments to communicate divine matters.
|
The Dynamics of Meanings and the ‘Kingdom of Heaven’ in the Gospel of Thomas
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Petru Moldovan, Independent Scholar
The aim of this paper is to underline the dynamics of connections and plural interpretations in the Gospel of Thomas, having as starting point the analysis of the concept “Kingdom of Heaven” as it appears in Logia 3, 22, 49, 82, 107 and 113 in the Gospel of Thomas (NH, II, 2) as well as the text as a whole. The paper’s main purpose is to highlight the combination of historical and exegetical research in understanding the Gospel of Thomas. My focus is in part directed towards deciphering the text’s organization and the manner in which the intra-textual analysis of Logia 3, 22, 49, 82, 107 and 113 can shed light on the theme of the ascension of the soul. It is only through an unbiased reading of the complex network of themes developed in the Gospel of Thomas that one can have a better understanding of the multiple meanings encapsulated into one Logion. In other words, one should read the Gospel of Thomas as a unitary whole. This type of approach not only opens new avenues of research on the Gospel of Thomas, but can also provide new solutions to old interpretative problems with this text.
|
Teaching the Most Difficult Text in the Gospel of Mark: Mark 9:42-50
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Francis J. Moloney, Australian Catholic University
Contemporary readings of the Gospel of Mark reject an older view that Mark was primarily an editor of sources that came to him, and that he at times lost control of these sources (Rudolf Bultmann). However, problems remain. There are several texts in the Gospel of Mark that continue to puzzle most interpreters, both in terms of their function within the narrative as a whole, and what they mean in themselves. One of the most puzzling of these in 9:42-50: “Readers may well feel slightly bewildered after a first glance at these verses” (Denis Nineham).
To communicate the significance of the passage the teacher must locate them within the narrative and attempt to explain the history of the juxtaposition of apparent unrelated of statements from Jesus. They deal with “scandalising” (skandalise) even one of “these little ones” (hena ton mikron touton) (v. 42), the violent elimination of parts of the body that “cause you to sin” (skandalize se) (vv. 43-47), a chain of sayings that seem to be linked by the catchwords “fire” and “salt” (vv. 48-50b), closing with a recommendation to be at peace with one another (v. 50c).
On the basis of an explanation of this juxtaposition the teacher should address the intrinsic worth of the passage (if it has such) within the narrative logic of the Gospel. Finally, in an attempt to break out of the limitations of a printed text, in recognition of the oral origins and reception of this text, and the Gospel of Mark, some suggestions will be made concerning the oral performance of Mark 9:42-50.
|
Trajectories through Early Christianity: Attitudes toward the Temple of Jerusalem in the Apostolic Fathers
Program Unit: New Testament/Early Christianity/Rabbinic Studies (EABS)
Mina Monier, King's College - London
This paper aims to investigate the variety of Christian attitudes towards the Temple as found in the late first and early second century writings of the Apostolic Fathers. I will argue that these attitudes were based on the formative theology of the different early Christian trajectories emanating from the earliest Jesus movement which left no single unified Orthodox attitude. The Temple of Jerusalem represented a critical problem to the different Christian groups in terms of their identity and relationship to the Jewish roots of Christianity, which was a central problem in the literature of the Apostolic Fathers. It is beyond the capacity of this paper to investigate the origin and nature of all Temple attitudes in the Apostolic Fathers so I will focus on specific texts, namely the Epistle of Barnabas, 1Clement and, briefly, Ignatius of Antioch. In each text I will explain the Temple notion, its place in the text's theological framework and the historical situation it reflects. The study will provide three entirely different attitudes coming from three different backgrounds. That is, Alexandria, Rome and Antioch respectively. These text were chosen because they are theologically independent, contemporaneous (around the end of the first century) and extremely different in their opinions regarding the Temple. These different attitudes should show that the Temple was a central theme in the struggle of Christian identity that required serious endeavours to form an early Catholicism by reconciling some of these attitudes as in Luke-Acts.
|
A Platonic Reading of the Narrative of the Man Born Blind in John 9
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Wooil Moon, Seoul Theological University
This paper explores the narrative of the man born blind in John 9 from a Platonic view of the human being. It uncovers echoes of Plato in the narrative and explains how the evangelist innovatively restates those Platonic fragments. It also discusses whether the narrative has a function to defend the divine humanity of Jesus and his friends against Philo of Alexandria and his peculiar concept of Israel, “the race who sees God.” Sandra M. Schneiders praised the narrative as “a literary masterpiece and highpoint of Johannine theology” (2002: 189-209). For Schneiders, the “original Sitz im Leben” of the narrative is the post-Easter sacramental initiation of the Johannine community. Both the blind man and Jesus are named “anthropos” and the man applies the divine formula “ego eimi” to himself as soon as he washed in Siloam (v. 9). The congenital blindness of the man signifies the “universal congenital incapacity for divine life,” and “ego eimi” represents the divine identification of the Johannine community. Drawing on Schneiders’s observation, this paper further examines the philosophical environment with which the narrative interacts. Philo’s idea of Israel and its ante-texts will be particularly considered because Wayne A. Meeks effectively argued that the Johannine Son sent by the Father radically stands against Philo’s idea of Moses who as the divine viceroy exclusively mediates humans and God in the Sinai theophany (1976: 43-67). According to Meeks, the argument, “seeing God is impossible” (John 1:18; 6:46) and “one who hears the word has eternal life” (John 5:24), is irreconcilable with Philo’s Israel, the God-Seer.
|
A Pro-Circumcision Paul against Periah
Program Unit: Male Circumcision: Between Controversy and Tradition (EABS)
Asha Moorthy, Columbia University
Classically, it has been held that the Apostle Paul opposed the rite of circumcision and thereby departed radically from the Judaism of his day. In order to appreciate the contours of Paul’s invectives against circumcision, however, it is critical to understand particular aspects of the practice during the apostle’s own time. This includes consideration of the physical dimension of the rite. Yet, in New Testament studies, attention to the physical aspect of circumcision has often been neglected.
In an effort to better address this topic, this paper will seek to examine the question of how circumcision was historically performed. A case will be made that among Jews of Paul’s day, not one but two forms of circumcision were conducted – milah and periah. It will be argued, moreover, that in Gal 5 and Phil 3, Paul expresses objection to the more radical of these two procedures, periah, which he considered to be a form of mutilation.
In addition, it will be suggested that it was only following the popularity of the gospel of Christ and influx of Christ believing Gentiles into and alongside Jewish communities that the rabbinic authorities officially defined circumcision to be periah. It will be ventured, moreover, that with a rise in the practice of periah, Roman tolerance for circumcision waned and the rite was ultimately limited or banned.
Finally, thoughts will be offered regarding the modern practice of circumcision and contemporary efforts to proscribe the rite. This paper will argue that Paul would have been in partial favor of such efforts not because he dismissed the rite of circumcision but rather because he opposed the dominant form of circumcision currently practiced, that is, periah.
|
Prepositional Irregularities in the Book of Revelation: A Second Language Acquisition Approach
Program Unit: New Testament/Early Christianity/Rabbinic Studies (EABS)
Laurentiu Mot, Institutul Teologic Adventist
Error Analysis is one of the major preoccupations of Second Language Acquisition. It is a method whereby the source of a linguistic irregularity is identified and the irregularity is explained. The source or cause of the peculiar Greek of Revelation received two types of explanations: linguistic and non-linguistic. In the first category there are basically two orientations. The most appealing explanation seems to be the Semitic transfer, which means that John’s peculiar Greek had Aramaic, Hebrew, or both as the primary cause of it. The second explanation is the Greek hypothesis, which professes that John’s Greek has parallels in the Greek writings, and as such, is Greek in use. The question of this research is what is the source of Revelation’s prepositional irregularities? The paper discusses the usage of prepositions such as e??, e?, e?, µeta, ap?, and ep? in the book of Revelation, the NT, and the Greek language at large. Here too, the Semitic explanation predominates in literature. However, unclear terminology and inaccurate methodology were two factors that led to the conclusion that the source of the irregular prepositional use in Revelation is mainly Semitic. Therefore, this paper uses the terminology of Second Language Acquisition and its findings drawn from empirical studies about linguistic transfer and facilitation from the mother tongue into the second language. In light of Second Language Acquisition there seem to be strong arguments that confirm the Greek hypothesis and infirm the Semitic explanation as to John’s peculiar use of prepositions.
|
Are Women Incapable to Lead States? Reconstructing a Deuteronomistic Athaliah in the South African Political Context
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Ndikho Mtshiselwa, University of South Africa
Angie Motshekga, is reported to have said; “South Africa is not ready to have a female president...” Such a statement was uttered by the president of the Women’s League of the ruling party, the African National Congress (ANC). Perturbing about her statement is the fact that it presumes that South African women are presently incapable of leading their country as president. Also, given the attractive literature on women empowerment in South Africa, Motshekga’s view comes both as a disappointment and a disempowering factor. As such, this paper investigates an empowering possibility that the Deuteronomistic Athaliah in 2 Kings 11 could provide to the women of South Africa. In doing so, Athaliah is elevated from the negative light in which she is presented by the patriarchal Deuteronomistic historian. Drawing from a reconstructed Athaliah as well as from the leadership of selected women politicians, the present paper ultimately argues that women are capable of leading South Africa as president.
|
Rivalling Royal Wives: Illustrating the Hebrew Bible from Some Old-Babylonian Letters
Program Unit: Israel in the Ancient Near East (EABS)
Monika Cornelia Müller, Kirchliche Hochschule Wuppertal/Bethel
Studies focussing on royal women in the Hebrew Bible often refer to parallels in the letters written by king Zimri-Lim’s daughters to their father based on the first publications of these letters. Yet nowadays not only the details of the living conditions of women within old-Babylonian royal households but also the wording of some of these letters have to be revised in the light of more recent studies of the material from Mari.
This paper discusses the rivalry of royal women with the help of select passages from the Mari letters. In comparing letters and stories, it bears the formal aspects of each genre in mind and distinguishes between historical facts and rhetorical devices designed to persuade the addressee. In 1Kgs 1 and 2, the only instance of direct rivalry among David's wives, the opposition between Bathsheba on the one hand and Abishag and Haggit on the other is only hinted at with minimalistic literary means. Similarly 1Sam 18:17–28, which has long been understood in the light of the rivalry between Kirum and Šimatum, does not convey any active competition between the two sisters, and a thorough literary analysis proves the Merab tradition to be a later addition to align this story with the Genesis traditions about Rachel and Leah. Finally, passages from Inib-šarri’s and Naramtum’s letters help us understand some details in the books of Kings that have previously escaped the attention of most biblical scholars.
|
An Israelite Savior for Israelites: Tobit’s Angelic Deliverer and Second Temple Hopes for the Angel of the Lord
Program Unit: Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha
Phillip Muñoa, Hope College
Several Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha texts bear witness to a trajectory that envisions a heavenly savior in human form. Chief among these texts should be the oft overlooked Tobit, a late third century BCE writing whose charming story of undeserved suffering has usually been identified as its focal point. Escaping the notice of interpreters has been the book’s groundbreaking adaptation of Israel’s Angel of the Lord tradition. Tobit profoundly engages this tradition with an extended angelic appearance that borders on a fully human incarnation. The Angel of the Lord makes its first appearance as a human in the Torah, but these accounts are brief and leave the angel’s human condescension relatively undefined and mysterious. Tobit extends these Torah materials by radicalizing the angel’s human appearance with a distinct ethnic profile. Now for the first time the Angel of the Lord appears as a simple Israelite with a nearly seamless human experience. Tobit also subjects the angel’s saving mission, often central to its Hebrew Bible tradition, to speculative development. Here the angel as an Israelite informs, empowers and delivers in ways that address the righteous suffering of a few non-descript Israelites. Close examination reveals that Tobit’s angelology does not stand alone but gives fuller expression to the type of mediatorial speculation found in several other Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha traditions. Yet, while these other texts do express in sometimes startling ways the beliefs of some Jews in the Angel of the Lord’s saving appearances, only Tobit asserted that God’s chief heavenly agent undertook a redemptive mission as a common Israelite among Israelites.
|
Reading the Scripture according to Its Nature
Program Unit: The Reception of the Scripture in the Patristic Exegesis (II-VIII centuries) (EABS)
Adrian Murg, Universitatea Aurel Vlaicu Arad
In my paper I'm trying to outline the Fathers' conception about the nature of the Scripture and the rules for reading it dictated by this very nature. Accordingly, the study falls into two major parts: the first one is dedicated to what the Fathers thought about the Bible and the second to things the reader must do for the Bible to achieve its goal in his life.
The ancient Christian writers saw the Scripture as a form of incarnation of the divine Logos (Origen, St. Maximus). Consequently, reading the Bible was considered a means of communion with Christ, closely related to the eucharistic communion. The Bible proclaims the mystery of Christ and aims to make Christ present in the midst of the Christian community and in the human soul as well (St. Athanasius). The Scripture relates to Christ as the shadow to the real object: the two are inseparable and the shadow announces the presence of the object. The Bible is a way opened for the believer, leading him to Christ (St. Ephrem, St. Makarios, St. John Chrysostom, etc.). The Bible is also seen as a concession made by God to man's incapacity of understanding the mysteries of the divine world. In order for us to reach the goal for which we were created, God provided us with his assistance. A part of it is the Scripture through which, in human words known to us, God reveals himself and addresses us. Human language, being created, is unable to express the eternal and transcendent realities of the divine world. But the grace which accompanies the biblical word by means of inspiration produces in the soul of he who receives it within the Church an understanding beyond words, understanding which is participation in these realities.
|
Paul's Position on Circumcision in Dialogue with Josephus's Advisors to King Izates
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Mark D. Nanos, University of Kansas
Paul's objection to the circumcision of non-Jews turning to God in Christ has been conceptualized in terms of a binary relationship between works and faith. This contrast has been developed and understood to characterize the difference between Judaism, which Paul supposedly left, and Christianity (however labeled), which he promoted. Following a discussion of relevant features arising in Josephus's account of several Jewish teachers' views on circumcision of the non-Jew Izates, includig his mother and other characters in the story, a comparison will be drawn with Paul's teaching of non-Jews. Several central translation and interpretive decisions in Pauline studies will be challenged and new alternatives proposed, including the topics of "faith" for pistis (and faith "alone" too), "works of law" for ergon nomou, and the relationship between circumcision and Torah-observance, among others.
|
Paul's Leadership Terms: A Study of the Use of Agape in 1 Corinthians
Program Unit: Authority and Influence in Ancient Times
Alexander Negrov, University of Durham
This paper will analyze the use of agape in 1 Corinthians and trace its relevance to the leadership themes within 1 Corinthians. Special attention will be given to six core themes of leadership: mission, vision, values, strategy, empowerment and engagement. In 1 Corinthians Paul places a great deal of his emphasis on relational leadership that places God and people at the center of thinking and actions.
|
Entering through the Eye of the Needle: The Renouncement of Possessions and the Authority of Jesus in the Gospel according to Matthew
Program Unit: Authority and Influence in Ancient Times
Marius J. Nel, Stellenbosch University
The aim of this paper is to analyse the manner in which the authority of Jesus is described in terms of his control as leader over the possessions of his followers in the Gospel according to Matthew. In Matthew Jesus is depicted as an authoritative leader who not only commanded that his followers sell or abandon their possessions (19:16-29), but who also utilised the possessions of others for his benefit (21:1-8). The language, expression and rhetoric of Jesus as it is presented by the author of Matthew will be compared to analogous commands of Hellenistic (e.g. wandering Cynic and Stoic preachers) and Jewish (e.g. those Qumran community) leaders in order to determine the control they had over the possessions of their respective followers. The paper will specifically examine the depiction of the authority of Jesus in Matthew in regards to those who heeded his call to renounce their possessions (4:18-22), as well as for those who decline to do so (19:22). The following questions will also be addressed. In which socio-political context did the demand for the renouncement of possessions normally occur in the ancient world? What type of leaders made these demands and what were the underlying social function and goal behind them? Were they general demands or only addressed to selected potential followers? It will be argued that for Matthew the demand to relinquish all possessions and to follow Jesus served to emphasise his ultimate authority as a leader to a specific group of his followers.
|
The LXX and the Case of the Missing Foreskins
Program Unit: Male Circumcision: Between Controversy and Tradition (EABS)
Karin Neutel, University of Groningen
In a culture where male circumcision is the norm, foreskin can become a curiosity; a source of repulsion, but also of humour and wordplay. This is evident in the Hebrew Bible, where several instances of metaphorical prepuces occur. Moses complains of his lack of persuasiveness due to ‘foreskinned lips’ (in Ex 6:12). In Jeremiah, those who do not listen to the word of the Lord are said to have ‘foreskinned ears’ (Jer 6:10). Serving the Lord, on the other hand, is equated to circumcising ‘foreskinned hearts’ (Deut 10:16). These cases suggest that while foreskins were seen as cumbersome and redundant, they were also ‘good to think with’. It is striking, then, that in the LXX translation of these passages the foreskins are missing. Literal references do occur in the Greek text, but figurative foreskins have disappeared. This paper will explore this phenomenon, taking wider approaches to metaphor and physicality in the LXX into account, as well as the presence or absence of similar metaphors in the Dead Sea Scrolls and other contemporary Jewish sources.
|
Inserting David: Royal Dynamics in Ezekiel 34 and 37
Program Unit: Prophets
Madhavi Nevader, University of Oxford
Inserting David: Royal Dynamics in Ezekiel 34 and 37
|
Messenger as Agent of Transformation in the Bible and Diola Religion: A Postcolonial Perspective
Program Unit: Political Biblical Criticism
Aliou C. Niang, Union Theological Seminary in the City of New York
Religious messengers have the power to effect change in society and innovate--for good or ill. In spite of the historical and cultural distance that separated them, the religious messages of the Apostle and Aline Sitoé Diatta, a West African Diola religious leader, depict them in such a role. This paper reads the poems of Aline Sitoé Diatta who inspired a communion of equals under the watchful eyes of imperial France. A critical analysis of three of her poems and Gal 3:28 will show how radical Pauline echoes of freedom are enshrined in her thoughts.
|
The Apocalypse of Thomas: A Text with Many Faces
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
Tobias Nicklas, Universität Regensburg
The Apocalypse of Thomas: A Text with Many Faces
|
The Process of Ethnogenesis in Palestine: Whose Task Was It?
Program Unit: Anthropology and the Bible (EABS)
Lukasz Niesiolowski-Spanò, University of Warsaw
Social studies and anthropology, based on ethnographical research, take for granted the role of the large popular groups in defining ethnicity. Self-definitions of the group, as well as definition by others, are interpreted as the issues regarding large groups. The paper aims to argue for the key-role of the elite groups in the self-identification and ethnic creation. The small groups of the elite, by defining its own “ethnicity” decided for larger groups. This hypothesis will be tested and illustrated by the case processes of ethnogenesis in Iron Age Palestine.
|
The Madrasha: Didactic Poem, Historical Ode, or Hymn?
Program Unit: Bible and Syriac Studies in Context
Rebekka Nieten, Freie Universität Berlin
When Ambrose of Milan (339-397) provided a definition of hymns as “praises of God with song (hymni laudes sunt Dei cum cantico),” his views of the hymn were similar to the perspectives offered in Greek-speaking antiquity. Yet in Ephrem the Syrian’s madrashe one discovers hardly any such glorifications.
The Syriac madrasha as a poetical form features an ample variety of different topics. On the one hand, it presents, illustrates, and explains Christian doctrine and defends dogma against perceived attacks of the heretics. On the other hand, it describes or alludes to historical events. The madrashe for the dead that are part of the East Syriac Liturgy of the Hours, which are ascribed to Ephrem, do present themselves in the form of hymns. Nevertheless, they offer rather lyric reflections on death, which one may characterize as praises only with difficulty.
This paper traces the characteristic form of the Syriac madrasha, which was of great significance for and influence upon the Byzantine kontakion. It spells out what made it so attractive for ancient hearers and readers.
|
Ezekiel 34-37 and Leviticus 26: A Re-examination of their Relationship
Program Unit: Prophets
Christophe Nihan, Université de Lausanne
*
|
John the Baptist in the Fourth Gospel: Ideal Witness to Jesus, God, and Man
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Rivka Nir, Open University of Israel
As against the standpoint that the fourth Gospel tends to downplay John and subordinate him to Jesus, I seek to prove that this Gospel highlights his importance, presenting him as the reliable witness to the messianic identity of Jesus. By qualifying him as someone who is 'sent' from God and 'comes' (1:6-8), two verbs associated with the divine Jesus, and as 'a man', the Gospel makes John the only reliable human witness to both aspects of the messiah - his divinity and his humanity. John's reliability unfolds against the backdrop of a theatrical trial court discussing the 'case' of Jesus. At its first session (1:1-18) John is called to testify to Jesus' divine identity as 'logos' and to his humanity as 'the Word became flesh'. The second session (1:19-28) aims to establish John's reliability as witness and lays the ground for the third in which he is asked to point at the 'defendant' and identify him explicitly (1:29-34). By designating him 'the Lamb of God' and 'the Son of God', John describes the two facets of Jesus' identity and affirms his status as the witness who proclaims the essentials of Christology. The trial ends with the defendant's acquittal and triumph over his prosecutors: John's disciples follow Jesus and thereby lay the foundation for the nascent church (1:35-37). As reliable witness, John's last direct testimony addresses his parallel activities with Jesus (3:22-36) by contrasting his baptizing with water and the supremacy of Jesus' baptism with the Holy Spirit and the promise it already embodies in the present. Whereas scholarship widely holds that the fourth Gospel conveys an alleged polemic between the Christian community and John's disciples, I hold that the high-ranking status this Gospel assigns to John, as Jesus' reliable witness, is what conversely occasioned the need to distinguish between the two.
|
New Aspects of the Red Heifer Dispute in light of Halakhic Midrash
Program Unit: Midrash, Halakhah and Reception
Vered Noam, Tel Aviv University
The fundamental controversy between the Pharisaic/Rabbinic and the Sadducee/Sectarian stances regarding the preparation of the Red Heifer has stimulated much scholarly consideration. However, most of the discussion had to do with the degree of purity required for the participants, whereas other aspects of the rite, such as the details regarding the sprinkling of the blood and their significance, were not adequately explored yet. The lecture will address these facets of the dispute.
|
Inclusio in Genesis 28 and 32 — Synchronically and Diachronically
Program Unit: Stylistics and the Hebrew Bible
Urmas Nõmmik, University of Tartu
In synchronic studies, the argument of some structural literary feature is frequently used to support the claim of literary integrity of the text under discussion. On the level of the end-text, it is quite often true, also from the diachronic point of view. But if competing literary features are observed in one text, the question is provoked, whether a single authorship can be proved for all those complicated macro-structures. The paper will briefly discuss two prominent examples from the book of Genesis, the Bethel-episode in Gen 28:10-22 and Jacob’s nightly combat in Gen 32:22-32. The focus is set on the feature called the repetition of words and phrases or Wiederaufnahme, called also inclusio or envelope structure, sometimes even with chiastic nature. This will show that without further observations, the argument of a literary feature can be used to favor both the unity as well as the disunity of textual layers in these passages. The positive effect of additional (mostly comparative) analyses can still be demonstrated. The paper will end with a brief discussion on the question whether a diachronic picture of Hebrew literary features can be achieved, and what could be the use of it.
|
Discussion on a Ruler’s Fundamental Corruptness in the Wisdom Literature, Job 29–31 as an Example
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Wisdom
Urmas Nõmmik, University of Tartu
Job’s avowal of innocence in the book of Job, chapters 29-31, has been ascertained as the culmination of Old Testament ethics. Its significant role within the structural framework of the book has been recognized forevermore. Almost a hundred years ago, Morris Jastrow Jr. suggested the idea that these chapters have plausibly not been part of the original poem of Job. In recent decades, some scholars, like Victor Maag, Wolf-Dieter Syring and Otto Kaiser, have followed the idea in a more differentiated way. After the emergence of the new redaction historical model of the book of Job in Germany in the 1990s and 2000s (Markus Witte et al.) it is appropriate to ask whether Job’s soliloquy should be considered as of an autonomous origin, added later to or written later for the book of Job. Besides literary, redaction and form critical observations, the paper will draw attention to implications that affect our understanding of the Jewish society of the Second temple period in religious sociological terms, particularly during and after the transition from the Persian to the Hellenistic period. The main reasons for this are: firstly, the viewpoint of the poem’s author permits titling it as "The poem about the innocent suffering of a noble king", and secondly, the polemic against the idea of a ruler’s fundamental corruptness that reveals itself within several extrapolations in Job’s and Elihu’s speeches. One has here a representative of intensive discussion on the essence of piety in light of social stratification.
|
Has Scientific Biblical Research Categorically Acknowledged Feminist Themes and Methods? A Review of Feminist and Traditional Exegesis Done on the Letter of Jude
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Lilly Nortje-Meyer, University of Johannesburg
The Letter of Jude is not one of the most influential books of the New Testament, although in the last couple of years some important publications have been produced. Traditional research based on the historical-critical methods focused mainly on the identity of the author, the identity and teachings of the opponents and the relationship of Jude with 2 Peter 2. In comparison, very few publications based on a gender-critical approach have seen the light. In this paper I will on the one hand review critically the themes and methods of publications done by female authors and publications based on a gender-critical approach to the Letter of Jude; and on the other hand compare it with publications based on historical-critical methods and whether they acknowledged the research based on gender exegesis. A logic outcome of the paper will be an evaluation of the achievements of gender studies in recent years and the contribution feminism has made to biblical studies.
|
Deification in Romans 8
Program Unit: New Testament/Early Christianity/Rabbinic Studies (EABS)
Mathias Nygaard, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
The thought of salvation as deification has often been seen as a result of mystical ’Hellenistic influences’ on early Christian thought, or as an overly Platonic interpretation of the Christian message. However, the notion of deification is now back in the game as a valid critical interpretation of the Soteriology of the Pauline literature (Cf. B. C. Blackwell, M. Gorman, and M. D. Litwa). A major reason for this comeback is the fact that the rejection of the Hebrew/Hellenistic dichotomy is finally being absorbed in earnest among exegetes. To a number of scholars this has opened the way to modes of reading that for a period have been falsely rejected as too Hellenistic for the rabbinically educated Paul of Tarsus. Interestingly E. P. Sanders in his celebrated works on Paul argues that a participatory soteriology can be considered a center of Paul’s thought. He has declined to speculate on what Paul means by this ’participation’ but others, notably Richard Hays, have come to his aid suggesting that a credible answer can be found in Patristic sources. In this article I argue that ‘deification’ is preferable to ‘participation’. Further, that it is a credible critical interpretation of Paul’s thought, not only of its reception in later theologians. This I do through a display of the following images associated with deification in Romans 8: a) immortality, b) glory, c) likeness, d) adoption/sonship, e) participation in divine ethical attributes, f) like knows like arguments, g) power over evil. The results for Pauline interpretation is to bypass the old and new perspectives by means of an older perspective which is able to sustain a number of Pauline paradoxes in a creative tension.
|
Understanding the Lord’s Prayer from a Discourse Perspective
Program Unit: Hellenistic Greek Language and Linguistics
Jan H. Nylund, Lund University
The perhaps most well-known section of the New Testament is the Sermon on the Mount in Matthew 5-7, the first of five discourse units in the Gospel of Matthew. At the centre of the Sermon on the Mount we find the most famous prayer of the New Testament, the Lord’s Prayer. This paper argues that the Lord’s Prayer is best understood from a discourse perspective. Rather than approaching the Sermon on the Mount from the traditional atomistic perspective of Form Criticism, where each text unit is thought to have had a separate existence and then been brought together to reflect the perspective of a “Matthean community,” this paper argues that the Lord’s Prayer is best understood when the Sermon on the Mount is perceived of as a coherent and structured unit whose totality interrelates with the each part of the Prayer.
The analysis of the Lord’s Prayer in the context of the Sermon will be approached first from a bottom-up co-textual analysis that brings attention to each level of rank ranging from the ranks of the word, phrase, sub-clause and clause to those of the paragraph, the chapter, the whole Sermon and the Gospel of Matthew as a totality. A top-down analysis is then applied, where the analysis first takes into account the whole Gospel of Matthew as the makro-level discourse unit whose totality provides the greater context for the Prayer. From there the analysis again moves down through the ranks back to the level of the word. It will be argued that this approach brings to the reader a well-founded basis for understanding and interpreting the Lord’s Prayer, demonstrating that the Prayer is not just inserted into the context of the Sermon but coheres with and relates to the Sermon and the Gospel of Matthew as a whole.
|
Jesus, an Exorcist Such as Solomon?
Program Unit: Study of the Historical Jesus (EABS)
Jennifer Nyström, Lunds Universitet
The idea of a Solomon-shaped Jesus originates from an article written by Loren Fisher in the late 1960's. Since then, there seems to be a presumption in scholarship that: (a) Solomon is considered to be the exorcist par excellence; (b) the link between Solomon and Jesus is found in their common title "Son of David"; resulting in (c) the assumption that Jesus was formed by a Solomonic typology in his exorcistic activity. This paper investigates the credibility of the assumption; if and in what ways the historical Jesus was considered by his contemporaries to be exorcising in a manner resembling Solomon's. Special focus is laid upon words and deeds describing the two exorcists' techniques. Initially, primary sources containing evidence of Solomon as an exorcist will be discussed. These texts are presented in three categories depending on their dating; before, during, and after the life of Jesus, in order to analyse the development of a Solomonic typology. Then, the exorcistic activity by the historical Jesus is methodically examined by applying the authenticity criteria. In this paper, I will exemplify this by using the story of the Syro-Phoenician woman. By connecting the Solomonic texts with the historical Jesus, I will argue that the established apprehension is wrong; the contemporaries cannot have interpreted Jesus' exorcisms as Solomonic. The idea of Jesus as a Solom on redivivus has to be abandoned.
|
Bodily Transformation in Phil 3:21 and in Funerary Inscriptions from around Philippi: A Case Study in the Analytical Impact of Epigraphic Imagery
Program Unit: Pauline Literature (EABS)
Peter Oakes, University of Manchester
Discussion of early Christian texts on post-mortem or post-parousia existence has sometimes underestimated the degree of continuity with ideas in the surrounding culture because scholars have tended to neglect imagery in epigraphy, especially when depicted pictorially rather than in words. This illustrated paper offers a case study based on Paul’s promise that Christians will undergo bodily transformation into the likeness of Christ’s glorious body (Phil. 3:21). This is compared with imagery of bodily transformation in epigraphy, from the territory of Philippi and its surroundings, depicting post-mortem heroization or divinisation of the dead.
|
Schriftrezeption im 1 Thessalonicher und im Philipperbrief
Program Unit: Schriftrezeption bei Paulus und in der Paulustradition: Reception of Scripture in Paul and Pauline Tradition
Markus Öhler, Universität Wien
Da die beiden Briefe weder Schriftzitate noch deutlich erkennbare Anspielungen enthalten, gilt es einerseits zu prüfen, wie weit Schrifttraditionen dennoch im Hintergrund der Schreiben stehen, etwa so, dass die Argumentationsstränge schriftheologisch begründet erscheinen. Andererseits soll geklärt werden, welche Rückschlüsse auf die ethnische Zusammensetzung der Adressatengemeinden oder die historische Situation, in die Paulus jeweils hineinspricht, das Fehlen expliziter Schriftbezüge zulässt.
|
Paul’s Use of Koinonia and Its Cognates in light of Documentary Sources
Program Unit: Hellenistic Greek Language and Linguistics
Julien M. Ogereau, Macquarie University
This paper consists of the summary of a comprehensive survey of the terms koinonia, koinonos, and koinoneo, in some 370 papyri and 100 inscriptions dating from V B.C.E. to VII C.E. It seeks to address a lacuna in modern scholarship, which has so far concentrated its attention on the use of the terms in literary sources and on their supposedly intrinsic theological significance, especially in Pauline literature (cf. Groenewald 1932; Campbell1932; Seesemann1933; Endenburg1937; Hainz 1981; and Baumert 2003).
Recognising the methodological problems and ideological leanings associated with earlier research, this study investigates a broad spectrum of primary material (i.e., papyri and inscriptions) from the perspective of the lingua franca of Paul and his communities. Leaving aside basic semantic and etymological questions, it focuses on the pragmatic usages and contextual connotations of these cognates in a wide range of documentary contexts, such as civic or religious decrees, commercial or marriage contracts, property leases, etc.
Thereby it purports to broaden current philological understandings of the terms, draws attention to unsuspected or overlooked connotations, and highlights potentially relevant examples vis-à-vis Paul’s letters.
|
The Importance of Papyrological Sources in Understanding Paul’s Koinonia with the Philippians
Program Unit: Graeco-Roman Society (EABS)
Julien M. Ogereau, Macquarie University
The purpose of this article is to illustrate the relevance of papyrological material in the study of the language of the New Testament and of the social context of the early Christian communities. More specifically, it endeavours to illuminate the socio-economic dimension of Paul’s koinonia with the Philippians (cf. Phil. 1:5, 4:15) by adducing a number of papyrological documents in which koinonia, and its cognates koinonos and koinoneo, convey the sense of partnership or association in some economic enterprise. It also establishes a close semantic equivalence between koinonia and societas (partnership), which allows a reconsideration of Paul’s relationship with the Philippians from a Roman socio-economic and legal perspective. This leads the author to conclude that Paul’s koinonia consisted of a societas unius rei (i.e., societas evangelii), whereby Paul supplied the ars and opera (skill and labour), while the Philippians contributed the pecunia (funds) to ensure the progress of his mission.
|
Image, Imagery, and the Imaginary: Re-imagination and Synecdoche as a Prophetic Tool in Daniel 2
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Funlola Olojede, University of South Africa
Literary analyses have recognised the prevalence of imagery and in particular of metaphors in the book of Daniel. This paper shows that the author of Daniel 2 not only employed metaphors to describe King Nebuchadnezzar’s vision of the night but he also strategically used synecdoche to underscore the personal nature and the urgency of the message in line with some known prophetic utterances (2:38//2 Sam 13:7; Ezek 22:24). While the colourful image in the vision took the form of a man, its parts (body-parts) represented imperial kingdoms, but only the head had a double referent – King Nebuchadnezzar as well as his kingdom, Babylon. It is argued that the use of synecdoche in 2:38 was a deliberate strategy on the part of Daniel not merely to point to the king’s pre-eminence among the imperial rulers but to capture his attention. However, in the light of the reception of Daniel in both Christian and Islamic traditions as a prophet, it is argued that Daniel’s re-imagination and interpretation of the king’s dream served not just to confirm him as a wise man in Babylon but to introduce him as a prophet.
|
Analyzing the Syriac Abbreviation System in a Caucasian Context
Program Unit: Bible and Syriac Studies in Context
Alexey Ostrovsky, National Center of Manuscript Studies (Tbilisi)
Abbreviation systems constitute an important part of writing systems in late Antiquity and the Middle Ages. They can share common features and be connected genetically, as is the case with the Greek and Armenian ones, or they can differ quite essentially, as the Greek and Georgian ones do. Since abbreviation systems are usually quite stable, studying them sheds light on possible connections between different writing systems and their influences on one another. This paper analyzes features of the Syriac abbreviation system and the chronology of their developments in connection with the Georgian and Armenian scripts in order to trace possible lines of influence and impact of the Syriac system on the Caucasian writing systems.
|
Searching for Continuity: Laws and Narrative in Deuteronomy
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Law
Simone Paganini, RWTH-University Aachen
The laws-corpus in Deuteronomy shows a differentiated diachronic development. The final structure of the book maintains, however, a depth significance, if one analyses and understands the work in its synchronic dynamic. This dynamic is definitively characterized by a mixture of laws and narrative. Only by searching the continuity between the narrative frame and the juridical parts is it possible to identify the hermeneutical approach of the book as a whole.
|
The law of the Temple Scroll
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Simone Paganini , RWTH-University Aachen
The last part of the Temple Scroll proposes a big range of laws which are also be found in the Book of Deuteronomy. A comparison between the two works shows not only that the authors of 11Q19 rewrite the biblical legislation in a personal and indicative way, but also that they postulate a different hermeneutik to understand the significance of the old deuteronomic laws in a new context and with a new backgound.
|
L'apocalypse de Judas
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
Louis Painchaud, Université Laval
L'apocalypse de Judas
|
Blessing and Praising the Name of God from the Moment of Creation
Program Unit: Reception of Scripture in Second Temple Literature
Mika Pajunen, University of Helsinki
There seems to be a relatively wide spread tradition in the late Second Temple period, particularly in psalms and prayers that humanity was at the moment of creation presented with an obligation to bless the name of God (e.g., 1Q34, 4Q381 and 4QBerakhot). Although this tradition is not explicitly present in the creation accounts of Genesis, it probably derives from the establishing of the Sabbath day described in Genesis 1, or so it is apparently understood at least in the Book of Jubilees (2:21). But amidst this rather wide held view that the formation of liturgy goes back all the way to the creation, there are different interpretations of the details, such as to whom this command to bless God was intended to (cf. 4Q370, 4Q381, Jubilees, Sirach) and on how such blessings were apparently meant to be carried out in practice (e.g., 4QBerakhot). This paper will investigate the birth and transmission of this tradition and its influence in compositions from the late Second Temple period. There are different stages in the transmission of traditions and this will be demonstrated in this case by analyzing 4QBerakhot more closely. The creation traditions are used extensively in 4QBerakhot, far more than has been previously recognized, but they are used partly through later traditions that have already rewritten and reinterpreted the Genesis accounts, such as Jubilees. Thus, by taking the different sources into account, it is possible to analyze the roots of the tradition, the reception and interpretation of it, as well as some of the early reception of these further traditions. This not only reveals something about the processes of transmission and their mechanics but offers insights into developments that may have had practical consequences for some liturgies of the late Second Temple period.
|
The Reception of the Pentateuchal Festival Laws in Ezra and Nehemiah 8
Program Unit: Law and Narrative (EABS)
Juha Pakkala, University of Helsinki
This paper investigates the reception and use of the pentateuchal festival laws in the book of Ezra and Nehemiah 8. A comparison between the pentateuchal laws and the passages in Ezra-Nehemiah provides significant information about the use of the Pentateuch in the contexts where Ezra-Nehemiah was written. The comparison shows that the pentateuchal laws used by the author(s) of Ezra-Nehemiah may differ considerably from the MT, LXX and SP versions. This is particularly evident in Neh 8:13-18, which seems to refer to details concerning the celebration of the Sukkoth that are not preserved in any of the known versions of the Pentateuch. The heavy editing in Ezra 6:19-22 implies that there were varying positions on who should be included in the celebration of the Passover.
|
Jeremias Klage in der Moderne: Werfels Jeremia-Rezeption
Program Unit: Modern Jewish Receptions of the Bible
Lukas Pallitsch, Universität Wien
*
|
The Past and the Future of the Evangelic Magi and Their Star
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Traditions in the Biblical World and Beyond
Antonio Panaino, University Bologna
The presence of the Magi in the famework of Jesus’ Nativity is one of the most important example of religious intercultural relations, which was deeply used by Christian propaganda in order to promote the diffusion of the new religion among Oriental peoples, in particular in Iran. In this relation the subject of Jesus’ polymorphism in the meeting with the Magi and its Mazdean background will be dis¬cussed in the light of some Late Antique iconographical cycles and according to few very fitting Byzantine, Syriac Armenain and Mediaeval sources (like Marco Polo).
|
"Paul Unchained": The Case of the Pauline Catena Manuscripts
Program Unit: The Reception of the Scripture in the Patristic Exegesis (II-VIII centuries) (EABS)
Theodora Panella, University of Birmingham
Catenae are manuscripts that contain the biblical text and a commentary which c onsists of patristic quotations forming a kind of exegetical chain. Catenae seem to have played an important role in the theological and exegetical discussions in the East and West from the fourth century onwards. However, they have rarely attracted scholarly attention. Most of the material remains unpublished, with little in the way of critical texts. Regarding the catenae on the Pauline epistles, in particular, there is no thorough examination of the manuscript tradition and the patristic material that is preserved in them. Furthermore, their biblical quotations have not been taken into consideration when reconstructing the textual history of the New Testament. Part of the problem is the volume of material and the complex interrelationship between biblical text and commentary as well as different types of catena. Catenae also have their own exegetical value and should be regarded as part of the history of interpretation of the biblical text, although scholarship has not fo cused on the criteria that their compilers applied when gathering their material or on the major exegetical trends that they may represent. Recent work on other biblical books by Dorival (1986-95) and Lamb (2013) has paved the way for my own study of the Pauline catenae, for which a critical study is long overdue. The use of electronic tools and databases now makes a scholarly edition possible, along with the assessment of their biblical text within the transmission of the New Testament as a whole. The purpose of the paper is to present the methodology of my work on Pauline Catena manuscripts and to report on an even more ambitious project, the COMPAUL project, which is investigating the earliest surviving commentaries on the Pauline Epistles both in Latin and Greek.
|
Illustrating the Meaning of the Word Anataxasthai in Lk 1:1 through a Semantic and Pragmatic Investigation
Program Unit: Hellenistic Greek Language and Linguistics
Kyriakoula Papademetriou, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki
The exact meaning of the word anataxasthai in the prologue of Luke’s Gospel remains uncertain and can only be indirectly assumed. The paper discusses the meaning of the word on the basis of the attestation of the word in ancient texts and documents and making use of the resources of the modern Linguistics. A refined understanding of the meaning of the word is suggested through an analysis of the semantic relations of the word diachronically and synchronically and through a pragmatic approach of the word regarding Luke’s use of it in the socio-historical circumstances of his writing: According to these, Luke refers to the written notes that were circulating in the communities of the early Church about Jesus and he declares the intention to serve the same tradition in his own narrative way.
|
Titian's "Cherry Madonna" as an Interpretation of Lk 1:5-80 and 2:1-40
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Culture
Michael Patella, Saint John's University School of Theology-Seminary
The Evangelists show a delicate balance in the relationship between Jesus Christ and the John the Baptist. In the four Gospels, John’s own explanations within the narrative establish his diminishing role in the face of Jesus’ rising prominence; such is the divine plan. While all the Gospels include John’s dialogue with the people, only Luke lays out the relationship between the Baptist and Jesus in the infancy accounts. The stories of Elizabeth and Zechariah, counterpoised with those of Mary and Joseph, provide a rich theological background to the unfolding of the gospel narrative. The Christian Tradition in both East and West has maintained the distinction between the missions of Jesus and John, and perhaps nowhere is this more evident than in the art Luke’s Gospel has inspired.
In Titian’s “Cherry Madonna,” currently on display in Vienna’s Kunsthistorisches Museum, we can see one such example of a visual interpretation based on Luke 1:5-80 and 2:1-40. This paper will examine how Titian interprets the ministries of Jesus and John through his juxtapositioning of Joseph and Mary with Zechariah, and the two infants with each other. The discussion will focus special attention on Titian’s employment of cherry sprigs and how the piece in general coheres with the Gospel of Luke.
|
The Disciples in Oz: The Acts of Peter and the Twelve as a Critique of Mysticism
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Stephen J. Patterson, Willamette University
The Acts of Peter and the Twelve is a composite text incorporating older traditions grounded in the experience of mysticism. But in its current iteration, the Acts are actually critical of mystical journeys and juxtaposes mysticism with service to the poor. What, then, is such a text doing in the Nag Hammadi Library?
|
The Reception of the Decalogue in Graeco-Roman Egypt
Program Unit: Reception History of Jewish Scriptures in Graeco-Roman Egypt
Sarah Pearce, University of Southampton
|
'Like a Monster, He Swallowed Me Up': The Place and Function of the Tannin-Motif in Jeremiah 51, 34–44
Program Unit: Prophets
Eric Peels, Theologische Universiteit (Apeldoorn)
Among the Old Testament oracles against the nations, Jer. 50-51 stands out as the longest and possibly the most horrifying one. These chapters portray Babylon as the ultimate enemy of YHWH and his people Israel, a portrait that contrasts with its positive role as God's agent in earlier parts of the book. The oracle offers a kaleidoscope image with its ever repeated message of doom by divine vengeance, culminating, inter alia, in the characterisation of Nebuchadrezzar as tannin, 'monster/dragon' in Jer. 51, 34. The contrast with the title 'my servant', given to this king in other texts (Jer. 25, 9, Jer. 27, 6 and Jer. 43, 10), can hardly be stronger. The motif of the devouring dragon seems to recur in Jer. 51, 44, which has led some scholars (Aitken, Carroll, Holladay, Van Hecke) to conclude that Jer. 51, 34-44 form a separate unit in the structure of Jer. 50-51. In my paper I deal with two issues, both concerning the place and function of the tannin-motif in Jer. 51: a) to what extent is the dragon motif present in the section of Jer. 51, 34-44, and b) what is the contribution of the dragon motif, with its strong associative effects, to the overall-message of the oracle against Babylon?
|
Agathós and Cognate Words in the Greek-Spanish Dictionary of the New Testament
Program Unit: Hellenistic Greek Language and Linguistics
Jesús Peláez, Universidad de Córdoba (España)
This paper aims to show the consistency of the semantic analysis method applied to the redaction of the entries of the Greek-Spanish New Testament Dictionary, indicating the different stereotypes used when defining the grammatical categories of noun, adjective and verb.The definition of the adjectives agathós, agathopoiós, aphilagathós, the nouns agathosýnê and agathopoiía, and the verbs agathopoiéô and agathourgéô will be presented displaying common and different elements to finish comparing them with the proceedings to define these grammatical categories in Bauer-Danker (BDAG)Low-Nida Dictionaries. This paper will also show how the semantic method applied to these categories is systematically applied to the rest of the lexemes of the same grammatical categories in the published fascicles of the Greek-Spanish Dictionary of the New Testament.
|
The Peace Vision of the End of Days in Isa 2:2-5 and the Peace Vision in Mic 4:1-5
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Yitzhak Peleg, Beit Berl College
The 'vision of the end of days' appears twice in the Bible: in Isaiah 2:2-5 and Micah 4:1-5. Similarities in topic, structure and language support the assumption of a literary connection between the two, i.e. one prophet was familiar with and even quoted the other, though not by name. The question therefore arises: Who quoted whom? In this paper I claim that Isaiah quoted Micah, while changing the vision in accordance with his own ideas. Regarding the question: Is the message of Micah’s vision one of 'separatism' or 'tolerance'? I prefer the 'tolerance' one: 'For let all the peoples walk each one in the name of its god…' (Mi. 4:4).
The story of The Peace Vision of the End of Days not only enables, but even encourages two readings. In my discussion of the biblical text I focus on tendencies revealed by these readings. The text in its current form is at the center of my interest as a reader.
The difficulty in defining the vision’s message stems from the double meaning borne by several of the formulaic expressions appearing in the vision:
The expression 'In the (end of the?) days to come' may be understood as referring to the distant future or to the near future. The Torah which goes out of Jerusalem may be the Torah of Moses, or a specific Torah (the Torah of peace, for example).
The expression “He will teach us of his ways” may also be understood in two ways: either God will teach the peoples some of his ways or he will teach them all of his ways.
[text truncated]
|
Women of the Bible in Early Byzantine Religious Poetry: The Case of Romanos
Program Unit: The Bible in Byzantium: The Use and Abuse of Tradition
Leena Mari Peltomaa, Österreichische Akademie der Wissenschaften
*
|
The Sura of the Ant: A Literary Analysis of Sura 27
Program Unit: Quran and Islamic Tradition in Comparative Perspective
David Penchansky, University of Saint Thomas (Saint Paul, MN)
Many of the lengthier suras of the Quran appear to contain disconnected passages, sometimes linked through its poetic structure, sometimes not. Sura 27, the Sura of the Ant, is a mid-length sura (93 verses). I will focus particularly on the first 44 verses, which recount two narratives, one concerning a few scenes in Moses' career, the other about Solomon. In the middle is the strange story of the ant, which gives the sura its name and somehow shapes the whole. A tiny ant fears that Solomon’s armies will trample her and her community. She shouts an alarm, which the great king hears and understands. It amuses the king, bringing him to laughter. The ant narrative does not correspond to any Solomonic narrative in the Bible, but everything else in this sura concerning Solomon and Moses does. I shall explore how the ant provides the interpretive link for the whole sura. This paper (part of a larger work in which I use methods derived from literary criticism to interpret the Quran) will explore this link as a means to access the sura’s meaning. What, if any, is the rhetorical difference between Quranic stories that overlap the Bible, and those that do not?
|
The Words of the Luminaries as a Meditation on the Exile
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Jeremy Penner, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
The Words of the Luminaries is a weekly liturgy that surveys Israel’s history from creation to the Babylonian exile. The impression gained from the extant material, however, is that within this survey the author tends to emphasize the Exodus and Monarchy while glossing over stories from the period of the Patriarchs and Judges. The reason why is because of the typological richness of these stories: the Exodus is a story of redemption, rebellion, and spiritual discipline, and as such a malleable paradigm in which to fit Israel’s current state of exile and in which to contextualize the reason for penitential prayer; the story of Israel’s monarchy is seen in Words of the Luminaries as a past political utopia that will once again be restored in the future eschaton. This paper will demonstrate that the author has artistically woven together a number of scriptural passages tied to these episodes in Israel’s history to craft an extended meditation on the exile and its present-day effects, and to demonstrate that God continues to fulfill scriptural promises to Israel in spite of these exilic difficulties.
|
The Aramaic Imagination: New Challenges and New Data for Conceptualizing the Apocalypse from Aramaic Dream-Vision Literature
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Andrew B. Perrin, Trinity Western University
Scholars have increasingly recognized that the preponderance of formal apocalypses and apocalyptically oriented literature that has come down to us from ancient Judaism was penned in Aramaic not Hebrew. Statements of this kind may be found as early as the Uppsala conference on apocalypticism in 1979 and as late as the Enoch Nangeroni meeting in Milan in 2012. John J. Collins’ The Apocalyptic Imagination represents an important waypoint along this journey in the quest for the ancient Jewish apocalypse. However, because the majority of the Aramaic Dead Sea Scrolls were not critically published until relatively recently (DJD XXXI, 2001; DJD XXXVII, 2009), Collins explanation of the origins and development of the apocalypse could not fully account for or integrate much of this Aramaic apocalyptic heritage. Of the diversity of ancient Jewish and Christian texts treated in The Apocalyptic Imagination, the Enochic tradition and Daniel 2-7 were the only representatives of what is now recognized as a much larger constellation of some thirty Aramaic works attested in the Qumran collection. Among these is a cross-section of nineteen Aramaic texts that have a penchant for dream-vision revelation. This paper proposes that the new data brought by these Aramaic dream-visions engenders at least three insights into the origins and development of the apocalypse. These include: (i) revisiting the idea of the inception of the apocalypse/apocalypticism in the dream-vision form; (ii) tracking the early growth of apocalyptic dream-visions within other literary genres; and (iii) recognizing the surge of evidence for apocalypses with a strong priestly bent. As such, this study may be seen as response to Collins’ more recent assertions regarding the need for genre boundaries to be organic and accommodating of new evidence.
|
Viewing Tobit through the Lens of the Aramaic Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha
Andrew B. Perrin, Trinity Western University
The debate over Tobit’s compositional language was invigorated by the discovery of Aramaic and Hebrew copies of the work in Qumran cave four. The emerging scholarly consensus, however, is that Tobit’s literary-linguistic makeup is best accounted for by its origination in the Aramaic language. The now widened corpus of some thirty Aramaic texts available among the Qumran collection allows for a fresh opportunity to re-read Tobit with an eye for aspects of the book’s message that come into sharper relief when contrasted and compared with its closest counterparts in the Aramaic Dead Sea Scrolls. This exploratory study charts a course through the book of Tobit and picks up on a number of theological and literary features that it shares with Aramaic writings including, but not limited to, the Aramaic Levi Document, the Testament of Qahat, the Visions of Amram, the New Jerusalem text, the Aramaic Enoch traditions, and the Genesis Apocryphon. Five points of correspondence with the aforementioned writings will be described: (i) the preference for first-person voices, (ii) ancestral instruction on Israelite religious duties and observance, (iii) insistence on endogamous marriages, (iv) eschatological outlooks of a “new” Jerusalem, and (v) the awareness of idioms and motifs drawn from dream-vision traditions. Tobit may be viewed as an important representative of the Aramaic heritage of ancient Judaism, since in it we find the confluence of several key components of the thought world of the broader Aramaic corpus of which it was an essential part.
|
Now 105 Years and Counting: “The Rapture” – Further Aspects of the Afterlife of the Scofield Reference Bible
Program Unit: New Testament/Early Christianity/Rabbinic Studies (EABS)
Hilary Perry, University of Sheffield
It is now 105 years since the publication of the original Scofield Reference Bible in 1909. This paper makes comparisons between the very popular second edition of 1917, which is almost identical to the 1909 edition, and revised editions published in 1967 and 2003. It focuses on the treatment in all three versions of the subject of “the Pretribulation Translation of the Saints" or “the Rapture”. It notes the increased incidence of references to these subjects in the later editions, and, in particular, the use of the term ‘Rapture’. It relates this phenomenon to the works of modern pretribulational writers and their opponents. This paper complements my earlier paper on the treatment of the subject of Israel in the three editions, which I presented at the EABS conference in Leipzig in 2013.
|
What's Cooking in Biblical Hebrew?
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible/Old Testament/Ancient Israel Studies (EABS)
Kurtis Peters, University of Edinburgh
Already in 1961, James Barr had pointed out the misguided use of etymology as determinative for word meanings. He rightly criticized the biblical theology movement for making inappropriate linguistic use of biblical terms. However, not only theologians took notice of Barr’s arguments. In fact, the following years and decades showed clearly that lexical semantic theory needed a proper articulation in biblical studies. How ought we to study words? For Barr, a structuralist approach was the only proper one. This meant that a word’s meaning was equivalent to the word’s use in a text – a mantra taken up by Clines’ recent Hebrew dictionary. The study of lexical semantics, however, has progressed considerably in the past few decades, though this has received little comment in biblical scholarship. In this paper, I suggest an updated, in this case cognitive, semantic method that faithfully accounts for word meaning in Biblical Hebrew. This method, dependent upon Ronald Langacker’s “Cognitive Grammar,” has been partially explored by some biblical scholars, particularly Ellen van Wolde and Stephen Shead, but remains somewhat inaccessible because of its technical nature. In the interest of accessibility, I intend to advocate a simpler starting point, focusing on what Langacker calls Profile-Base-Domain relations. To illustrate these relations, I will explore verbs of cooking in Biblical Hebrew. This exploration will enable a more critical eye to the claims of earlier structuralist semantics – ie. meaning is in the language system itself – and will suggest that meaning can only be found in the mind of the language users. To demonstrate this theory I will therefore look equally at biblical Hebrew texts as well as archaeological data in order to discover what ancient language users thought about cooking and therefore what their cooking words mean(t).
|
Wenn wir die Heilige Schrift des Alten Bundes Aufschlagen: Aspekte Biblisch Legitimierter Kriegsrhetorik im Ersten Weltkrieg am Beispiel der Hirtenbriefe von Fürstbischof Leopold Schuster, Diözese Sec
Program Unit: Reception of the Bible in the Sign of World War One
Edith Petschnigg, Karl-Franzens-Universität Graz
Wie kein anderes Buch erwies sich die Bibel über nahezu alle Epochen hinweg als kulturprägend, als Kulturgut par excellence, als das Buch der abendländischen Kultur. Bis weit ins 20. Jahrhundert hinein gehörte das Wissen um biblische Geschichten und Gestalten, die Verwendung biblisch geprägter Worte und Redewendungen, ja ein gewisser „Bibelton“ zum allgemeinen Bildungsgut. Es verwundert daher nicht, dass biblische Texte, Themen und Metaphern auch im Zuge des Ersten Weltkrieges Eingang in die Kriegsrhetorik und -predigt fanden. Auf Seiten aller kriegsteilnehmenden Staaten stellten Kirchen und Religionsgemeinschaften ein konstitutives Element im Kriegsgeschehen dar. Besonders der Hebräischen Bibel bzw. dem um einige griechischsprachige Schriften erweiterten Ersten Testament kam bei der Kriegsdeutung eine Schlüsselstellung zu. Am Beispiel der Hirtenbriefe Fürstbischof Leopold Schusters (1842–1927), der von 1893 bis 1927 der Diözese Seckau vorstand, wird der Beitrag der Rezeption alttestamentlichen Texte, Themen und Metaphern im Verlauf des Ersten Weltkrieges nachgehen, diese exemplarisch analysieren und in den Kontext der Kriegstheologie des österreichischen Episkopats stellen.
|
Can a Text Bleed? Docetism and Textuality in John’s Gospel
Program Unit: Johannine Literature and Docetism (EABS)
Christina Petterson, Newcastle University, Australia
As many scholars have pointed out, John’s gospel emphasises to great extent the humanity of Jesus in John’s gospel. Not only are physical features emphasised (tiredness, thirst, emotions), but also the use of sarx as indicator of the human realm, and then, of course, the challenge to Thomas in chapter 20. This paper seeks to combine such an emphasis on the physicality of Jesus in John’s gospel with the references to writing and eyewitness (19:35, 20:30-31 and 21:24-25) in the gospel text. While these instances of writing and eye witnessing perhaps are intended to narrow the gap between events and narrative, they instead draw attention to the gap, thus drawing attention to the mediatory nature of the gospel text. In this paper, I want to examine the possibility that what is regarded as docetic about Jesus in John’s gospel could be the attempt by the author of the gospel to wrestle with a written text, and his reflections on the implications of presenting a textualised Jesus.
|
Embodying the Flesh of the Fourth Gospel
Program Unit: New Testament/Early Christianity/Rabbinic Studies (EABS)
Christina Petterson, University of Newcastle
This paper examines the concept of sarx in the narrative of John’s Gospel. While the term is traditionally coupled with pneuma as constituting one of the basic dualisms in the gospel text, it is particularly the relationship to the body (soma) of Jesus that will be the focus of attention here. Soma in John is not used in a collective sense (as in Paul) or in a ‘quotidian’ sense (as in the gospels), but is used in reference to Jesus’ dead (19:31.38.40 and 20:12) and resurrected body (2:21). Sarx, on the other hand, is used in a sense similarly to Paul’s mythological-cosmological understanding of sarx as negative (3:6; 6:63; 8:15), with the exceptions of 1:14 and the ‘Bread of Life’ discourse (6), where sarx is regarded as the embodiment of salvation. It is precisely this particular feature of sarx as embodiment that is of interest here, and what, if any, the relation to the understanding of Jesus’ body in the fourth gospel is.
|
What Does 'Israel' Refer To? Ethnogenesis, Socio-Political Organization, and Identity
Program Unit: Anthropology and the Bible (EABS)
Emanuel Pfoh, National University of La Plata-CONICET
If «Israel» refers to a particular people around 1200 BCE, considering its naming in the famous Victory Stele of Pharaoh Merneptah, can we know about the ethnicity of this people? When addressing «Israel» as a kingdom in the Iron Age: what kind of kingdom, of socio-political organization is this? A ‘national state’? A patrimonial kingdom? Something else? Does this kingdom share a socio-cultural background with the kingdom of Judah? This last question is key to find out how both kingdoms are related in the biblical narrative (why Judah is identified with Israel?) but also outside of it, in the realia of the history of ancient Palestine. This is the kind of problematizing questions through which the historiography of ‘ancient Israel’ advances and formulates new visions and perspectives on the remains, archaeological and textual, of an ancient past. The key to any of these approaches and questions rests not on the nature of the data under analysis and interpretation but rather on the different epistemological grounds on which our historical reconstructions can be based: how we understand the Bible as related to history, and therefore, ancient Israel, and how we use it for history-writing. Debating such epistemological issues could certainly enhance our understanding of the historical referents of «Israel» in first-millennium BCE Palestine.
|
"Just as the Holy Spirit Says": Hebrews 3:7–4:11 and the Spirit's Promise of Rest
Program Unit: Epistle to the Hebrews
Madison N. Pierce, Durham University
Hebrews 3–4 has often been studied for its introduction of the wilderness generation or pilgrimage motif, for its use of the OT, and for the typological development of rest. These features are all significant and certainly warrant future investigation, but Heb 3:7–4:11 begins with one of the features unique to Hebrews in the NT—the Spirit speaking Scripture, which is rarely more than a passing mention in previous studies. Since the author very carefully selects his speakers (e.g., the anonymous speaker in Heb 2:5 who sets up Christ as the ideal representative of humanity), this choice must be explored. This, and the Spirit’s other quotation in 10:15, are the only times that the community is directed addressed. In this carefully crafted “word of encouragement,” this is not incidental.
Further, studies that do mention this often limit the role of the Spirit in this passage to speaker of Psalm 95, but it seems reasonable to extend his agency. This paper will argue that it is grammatically plausible that the author envisioned the Spirit as the primary divine agent until 4:11. If the Spirit’s agency is extended, then he is one who becomes angry with the wilderness generation and swears they shall not enter his rest (as the first-person references in the quotation suggest). His extended agency will be demonstrated through lexical connections between the quotation and subsequent development by the author in chapters 3 and 4, through linguistic discussions of “participant reference”—identifying agents by noting typical language usage, and through thematic connections in the remainder of Hebrews (e.g., 10:29) and other literature (e.g., Isaiah 63).
|
‘Abstain from Every Form of Evil’: How the Thessalonians Inadvertently Quenched the Spirit
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Edward Pillar, Prifysgol Cymru, Y Drindod Dewi Sant - University of Wales, Trinity Saint David
Paul’s warnings and encouragements in 1 Thess. 5:19-22 concerning the activity of and responses to the activity of the Spirit amongst the believing community in Thessalonica can appear at first glance to be straightforward counsel concerning the prophetic gift. It could further be suggested that the newly established believing community was perhaps the diametrical opposite of the charismatically-obsessed community in Corinth. The fact that Paul has to challenge the Thessalonians in 1Thess 5:19-20 is clear evidence that they are treating the prophet with profound suspicion and according to Paul are consequently, intentionally or otherwise, ‘quenching the spirit.’ In this paper we shall first survey various scholarly perspectives concerning 1 Thess 5:19-22. But we shall also offer and explore the hypothesis that the Thessalonians are only inadvertently ‘quenching the spirit’ due to their determination to be faithful to the ‘living and true God.’ 1 Thess. 1:9 makes clear that the Thessalonians had turned from the idols that would have dominated and dictated every aspect of life in the city and in doing so have gained a widespread reputation. Not only so, but their response to the gospel that God had usurped the power of imperial rule in the subversive raising of Jesus from the dead also involved a profound rejection of an imperial ideology that was in part justified and emphasised by the prophetic word of Jupiter (Virgil Aeneid 1:286). We shall thus consider the possibility that the Thessalonians, having previously allowed their lives to be dictated to and directed by the ‘spiritual utterances’ of idols and imperial rulers are now only inadvertently ‘quenching the spirit.’ Paul thus encourages them to discern and ‘hold onto the good’ whilst abstaining from the evil that continued to surround them and dominate their culture.
|
BRICS: Prosperity in Africa?
Program Unit: Political Biblical Criticism
Miranda N Pillay, University of the Western Cape
According to a 2011 survey (by the Pew Research Centre on Christians in Africa) nine out of ten Christians believe that “God would grant prosperity to all believers who have enough faith”. The emphasis on faith makes prosperity discourse plausible amongst Christians and sanctifies economic hierarchy of wealth over poverty. A lack of faith is often cited as the reason why Christians are not getting the returns allegedly promised in the Bible. Proof texts – plucked out of their literary and cultural contexts – give the impression that prosperity theology is firmly grounded in Scripture. In the context of ‘emerging economies’ wealth creation and prosperity are appealing concepts in African societies. The South African government is sold on the idea that its BRICS membership holds prosperity for the country’s poor and unemployed. While some economists think that South Africa’s BRICS membership (in partnership with Bazil, Russia, India, China) makes very little commercial sense, others have observed that South Africa’s inclusion is an astute political move giving China an economic foothold in Africa. Moreover, South Africa’s inclusion is significant because it has transformed this economic block into a truly global entity and South Africa serves as a gateway for BRICS trade and investment into the resource-rich nations of Africa. Is this yet another ‘scramble for Africa’ guised as a ‘win-win’ concept? Is BRICS Africa’s new hope for prosperity? Is an increase in manufacturing goods the answer to Africa’s hunger and poverty; or is it another opportunity for instant gratification and ‘get rich quick’ opportunities for a selected few? In the light of these questions and the observation that material prosperity is believed to be a sign of God’s blessing for many Christians in Africa, the prophetic call for a ‘theology of enough’ is an urgent one.
|
Reception of the Bible on Late Antique Textiles
Program Unit: Reception of the Bible in Jewish, Early Christian and Islamic Art
Renate Pillinger, Universität Wien
This article demonstrates that the number of Late Antique textiles with explicitly Christian themes is comparatively small in relationship to the total number of finds. Among these, narrative (cyclical) illustration), such as the life of Adam or David, are particularly rare. Nonetheless they portray interesting insights on the scriptural understanding of the individual textile bearer or commissioner, some with especially magnificent biblical illustrations. As with other art forms, images from the Old Testament predominate, and the story of Joseph occupies a special position. The life of Jesus is dominated by the New Testament narrative and is supplemented with many noncanonical stories.
|
Local Patriotism in Jewish Antiquity: Is the Egyptian-Jewish Joseph & Aseneth a Response to the Judaean Book of Judith?
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism (EABS)
Meron M. Piotrkowski, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
An affiliation of the Egyptian Jewish-Hellenistic (perhaps Oniad) composition Joseph & Aseneth with the Book of Judith of Judaean origin, which was apparently written in support of the Hasmonean dynasty, has hitherto never been suggested. It is quite revealing however to read these two books against each other and at the backdrop of a competition between the Jews of Judaea and those of the (Egyptian) Diaspora. I argue that the pro-Oniad J & A constitutes a response to the pro-Hasmonean Book of Judith. Putting this hypothesis to work can not only explain J & A’s beclouded purpose but it can also elucidate some obscure details and can clarify its similarities with the Book of Judith: for example the notion that a woman is the hero(ine) in both stories. If the Book of Judith was written for the purpose of glorifying the Hasmonean dynasty and their heroic actions of ridding Judaea of the Seleucid domination and purifying the Jerusalem Temple, then J & A, I contend, was written in response to it; as if to say that the Jews of Egypt too have their heroes and also a Temple (when conceding Bohak’s interpretation of J & A). J & A accordingly, constitutes an expression of self-confidence on behalf of Egyptian Jewry vis-à-vis their Judaean co-coreligionists. But it might also, more particularly, be interpreted as a competition between loyalists of Onias’ Temple and loyalists of the Jerusalemite Temple. On a much broader level this paper aims at exploring the relationship between the Jews of the Diaspora vis-à-vis those of Judaea.
|
Al-Ya'qubi and the Influence of the Arabic Cave of Treasures
Program Unit: Quran and Islamic Tradition in Comparative Perspective
Marcel Poorthuis, University of Tilburg
The exegesis of the Quran has stamped a whole range of Islamic literature, not only the tafsir, but also the world chronicles and the Stories of the Prophets (Qisas al-Anbiya'). It is remarkable, however, that a major Christian "Rewritten Bible," the Syriac Cave of Treasures, has exercised a considerable influence upon Islamic authors as well. This does not mean that they all could read Syriac, nor that they used the Christian Arabic reworking of the Cave of Treasures, the Book of the Rolls. The source of the influence of the Cave of Treasures upon Islamic authors is most probably the historian al-Ya'qubi, who translated the Syriac text into Arabic, while removing - so he thought - all Christian elements from the work, harmonizing the text with Quranic quotations. The Dutch scholar J. Smit, disciple of the famous Arabist De Goeje, pointed this out exactly one hundred years ago. He did not trace the subsequent influence of this Islamicized Cave of Treasures, however. Still, it can be proven that the famous author al-Tha'labi in his Qisas al-Anbiya' unconsciously absorbed some remaining Christian elements from this document. My paper focuses upon the themes of the body of Adam and of the war between the sons of Seth and the daughters of Cain.
|
'A star shone forth in heaven': St. Ignatius of Antioch as Interpreter of the Gospel
Program Unit: The Reception of the Scripture in the Patristic Exegesis (II-VIII centuries) (EABS)
Dumitru Popoiu, Johann Wolfgang Goethe-Universität Frankfurt
The seven epistles St. Ignatius wrote on his road to Rome are witness of the living faith of the second Christian generation. Ignatius explicitly denied his equality with the Apostles and wrote pastoral letters on behalf merely the authority of a future martyr. His most important challenges were not for the 'Godbearer' the future torments and death, but the docetist and judaizing interpretations given to the Gospel. This paper focuses unto the three most important passages concerning how Ignatius interprets the Gospels. In Eph. 19-20 he focuses the 'oikonomia' of incarnation, which more than a simple historical act, it involves the whole kosmos to a threefold mystery, 'wrought into the Silence by God'. This event is actualized in the Christian celebration of Eucharist. The second text (Tral. 9) focuses on the historicity of the birth, passions and resurrection of Christ as contemporary to Pontius Pilatus (cf. Magn. 11). Finally, the third passage (Smyrn. 1-3) broadens the latter image into a dogmatizing formula of the divine humanity of Christ, as springing from David´s seed, but Son of God too, 'according to the will and power of God'. Recollecting the testimony which Luke gives of the appearances of Jesus to the apostles in Jerusalem (Luke 24, 34-47), the Syrian bishop underlines the substantiality of Resurrection as the motivation for the courage manifested in preaching Christ until death. The literal and occasional typological exegesis of the biblical school of Anthioch may find its roots in the Ignatian struggle to confirm the verity of the Gospels. His theology amounts to something more than a scientific discourse: it is existential. Instead of resolving to merely search for Christ "in the archives", he chooses to confess the Christian truth and faith as the righteousness manner in which a community may pray (Phil. 8:2).
|
The Sound Pair R-a-H and Y-R-a (Sight and Fright) in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Stylistics and the Hebrew Bible
Bezalel Porten, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
While poetic word pairs are a recognized literary feature, sound word pairs are largely unrecognized. In a 2003 study I discussed the pair ShWB-YShB in Jeremiah. I should like to present here the occurrences of the pair R-a-H and Y-R-a (Sight and Fright) in three tales where divine appearance leads, directly or indirectly, to human fright — Abraham (5 episodes), Isaac (1 episode), and Moses (10 episodes). The pair appears as inclusion and Leitwort motif in the Abraham and Moses tales, creating drama and highlighting crescendo. The Isaac episode is a deftly structured double a-b-c unit that is a malleable replay of Abraham’s encounter with Abimelech.
|
Pauline Techniques of Interweaving Scripture into His Letters
Program Unit: Schriftrezeption bei Paulus und in der Paulustradition: Reception of Scripture in Paul and Pauline Tradition
Stanley E. Porter, McMaster Divinity College
Die Vielfalt an Formen und Methoden, mit denen der Apostel die Heilige Schrift in seinen Briefen zur Sprache bringt, hat in der exegetischen Forschung eine nach wie vor offene Diskussion ausgelöst, nach welchen Gesichtspunkten solche Formen und Methoden im Einzelnen erfasst und voneinander unterschieden werden können. Für das Fachgespräch ist daher eine Verständigung über die anzuwendende Begrifflichkeit und Kriteriologie unverzichtbar.
|
Joshua 5: Between ?aralot and ?erev Shelufah
Program Unit: Law and Narrative (EABS)
Peter Porzig, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
Israel has just entered the Promised Land, and one of the first things the Israelites do is celebrating pesa? - in the present text after circumcision and before Joshua's encounter with the "commander of the army of the Lord". The somewhat peculiar sequence of events connects the chapter closely to Pentateuchal commandments and stories, as well as at the same time it preludes a hardly less important, yet future, festivity: the next pesa? will be celebrated no earlier than under king Josiah (2 Kgs 23). In the paper, I would like to present a close reading of Joshua 5 in its various contexts, with a special focus of its relationship to law and narrative.
|
Jonah’s Prayer and the Post-Exilic Editing of the Psalter
Program Unit: Writings (including Psalms)
Henk Potgieter, University of Pretoria
It has long been recognized that there is a close relationship between the prayer of Jonah (Jonah ??2:3-10) and certain psalms. The precise nature of these connections has not been defined ?satisfactorily, however. In this paper it will be argued that Jonah’s prayer is not simply a ?separate psalm which was borrowed from another collection and inserted into the narrative of ?this prophetic book. It can also not be described as a haphazard collection of citations from ?different psalms. It will be argued that it is a very precise composition made by someone or by a ?group of persons with the express purpose of creating links to certain psalms in order to ?propagate specific theological views. As such it reflects the editing activity of a group of post-?exilic theologians who sought to establish connections between the Psalter and other segments ?of the Hebrew Bible. The nature and theological implications of the similarities between the ?prayer of Jonah and the psalms with which it correlates will be investigated.?
|
Church Lectionaries as Biblical Theology
Program Unit: Biblical Theology
Frederik Poulsen, Københavns Universitet
Many problems within the field of biblical theology remain unsolved. For Christian interpreters, an enduring issue concerns the relationship between the Old and New Testaments. Despite the numerous moves which have been made to express the relationship (the oneness of God, a unified salvific history, or the scheme of prophecy-fulfillment, of law-gospel, and of letter-spirit), none of them has been made absolute. The relationship remains a complex one. Central to the church lectionaries is the juxtaposition of smaller sections from both testaments. Rather than approaching the relationship between the testaments on a general level, the lectionaries invite reflection on the relationship between discrete passages and on separate theological themes. In order words, the relationship between the testaments must be determined from passage to passage, from Sunday to Sunday. The paper explores the hermeneutical implications of doing biblical theology within the context of the church lectionaries and offers an example from a given Sunday to test the potentials of this approach.
|
Biblical Interpretations of Isa 42:1-9
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible/Old Testament/Ancient Israel Studies (EABS)
Frederik Poulsen, Københavns Universitet
The nature of the servant and his task in Isaiah 42:1-9 remains ambiguous. Several proposals concerning his identity have been voiced, including Cyrus, a Davidic Messiah, the prophet, and the people of Israel. Central to his task is the promotion of justice (mispat) whose content has received an abundance of scholarly interpretations. Some argue that the servant is a king who proclaims edicts or establishes true religion, whereas others argue that he is a wandering missionary who preaches salvation to the whole world. A closer look at the biblical interpretations of this passage reveals a series of subtleties. The Septuagint version explicitly identifies the figure with Jacob and Israel (v. 1). At the same time, the portrait of him has apparently been harmonized in light of the messianic oracles of Isaiah 1-39. For instance, “the coastlands wait for his torah” in v. 4 is rendered as “nations will hope in his name” (cf. LXX Isa 11:10; 26:8). In the New Testament, vv. 1-4 is cited in Matt 12:18-21 as a reflection of Jesus’ public ministry. The textual form, however, fits neither the MT nor the LXX and some of the variants may stem from Matthew’s own exegetical activity to shape the portrait to fit his overall theological concern. The paper will examine the biblical interpretations of Isaiah 42:1-9 and consider in what manner the later reception of the passage may help us to interpret the figure and his task.
|
The Pedagogy of Transfiguration in Mark´s Gospel
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Dr. Cosmin Pricop, University of Bucharest
This presentation will attempt to show the key role of the Transfiguration Story in the pedagogy of Mark´s Gospel, concerning the special relationship between Jesus and his apostles. It will be also emphasized the link of this biblical story with the story of Baptism, as well as their role in the evolution process of the concept of "identity" related to the person of Jesus.
|
Toward a Methodology for Analysis of the Patristic Exegesis of the Bible
Program Unit: The Reception of the Scripture in the Patristic Exegesis (II-VIII centuries) (EABS)
Cosmin Pricop, Universitatea din Bucuresti
This presentation will focus on the need to identify a possible me thodology for the analysis of the various patristic exegesis of the Bible. Can this great patristic legacy be systematized in a unitar way? Are there some specific features to be identified?
|
Light Shines in the Darkness: Resonance between Matthew and John
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Duane A. Priebe, Wartburg Theological Seminary
It is fascinating to see how the Gospels use the same material to tell very different stories and to paint different portraits of Jesus. There is also a resonance between the portraits of Jesus in Matthew and John using very different material. This also suggests a question beyond the boundaries of this paper: what does it mean to read the four Gospels together in their present sequence, taking seriously the differences between them. A theme common to Matthew and John is directly stated in John (1:4-5, 9-11, and 3:19): the light came into the darkness of our world, but people loved darkness rather than light. As in Jewish traditions, this language can be associated with the creation of light on the first day, as well as with the contrast between being blind and seeing. It frequently hovers between physical and metaphorical meanings.
Matthew 4:12-9:34 portrays Jesus’ teaching and activity in terms of light dawning for those living in darkness and the shadow of death in Galilee of the Gentiles. This unit ends with healing two blind men, an exorcism, and the Pharisees’ accusation that he casts out demons by the prince of demons. Matthew repeats a variation of the story of the healing of the two blind men in Matthew 20:29-34, just before Jesus’ entry into Jerusalem. Matthew then develops the hostility of the chief priests and elders in Jerusalem and the blindness of the scribes and Pharisees (Mat 23). Yet his death in a world shrouded in darkness opens the graves of the saints and the centurion’s vision of the truth.
This theme is anticipated in the story of Jesus’ birth (Mat. 2), and it illuminates Matthew’s vision of the disciples’ mission.
|
Reconstructing Reality: “This World” Re-created, Re-interpreted and Re-lived in Psalms 135 and 136
Program Unit: Place, Space, and Identity in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Gert Prinsloo, University of Pretoria
“This world” can often be a harsh reality. How do people cope with these harsh realities? In this paper it is argued that a spatial reading of Psalms 135 and 136 illustrates the poets of these poems’ ability to imagine “another world” (or maybe rather “an other world”) where they reconstruct reality by re-interpreting and re-applying the historical traditions of ancient Israel in new circumstances. They thus create a new lived experience of “this world.” Confronted by a harsh “Firstspace” (to use terminology coined by Edward Soja) these poets imagine a new “Secondspace” dominated by YHWH as creator and savior which enable them to experience their “Thirdspace” as a life of faith worth living. In my spatial reading of the two poems attention is paid to the poems as ‘twin’ psalms, their function in their immediate context and the broader context of Book V of the Psalter, intertextual links between the two poems and other ‘historical’ psalms conspicuously present in Books IV and V of the Psalter (cf. Pss 105, 106, 107, 108, 135, 136), and Israel’s historical traditions as described in the Pentateuch and the Former Prophets.
|
Bible Reception in Islamic Art
Program Unit: Reception of the Bible in Jewish, Early Christian and Islamic Art
Stephan Prochazka, University of Vienna
*The paper will mainly deal with Islamic miniature painting of the Late Middle Ages and Early Modern Age. As Koranic manuscripts have never been illustrated the examples presented will be taken from other religious manuscripts, particularly the so-called “Stories of the Prophets”. On the one hand, these stories indirectly reflect the reception of the Bible through the Koran as the main themes are based upon the Muslim Holy Book. On the other hand, the numerous versions of these stories contain many details which are not present in the Koran itself. These are mostly taken directly from the Bible but often also reflect apocryphal ideas and concepts, which are sometimes also found on the paintings. Another and completely different field of Bible reception in Islamic art can be found in the realm of popular culture belonging to the 19th and 20th centuries. Themes taken from the Bible via the Koran have for long been popular subjects of glass paintings and posters, which sometimes are still sold on markets through the Middle East and North Africa.
|
Turning Consolation on Its Head: Sampling the Impact of Jer 38:32 LXX on the Formation of Early Christian Thought
Program Unit: Epistle to the Hebrews
Alexander Prokhorov, University of Aberdeen
The paper examines some of the theological consequences of a translation error in Jer 38:32 LXX (31:32 MT). The Old Testament phrase comments on Yahweh’s reaction to the failure of the Israelites to maintain loyalty to him. Although one can never be absolutely certain about the Vorlagen of the Greek translators, it is probable that in this case the Vorlage was identical to the MT consonants and that a translation error can be identified. Whereas the MT text of the phrase in question corresponds to the general tone of the Book of Consolation by attributing to Yahweh a positive attitude to the Israelites, the Old Greek text depicts Yahweh in an opposite manner, viz. as being no longer concerned with the lapsed community. The subsequent endorsement of the Greek translation of that particular phrase by the author of the Epistle to the Hebrews (8:9) contributed to the development of a polemical strategy of using texts of the Hebrew Bible as arguments against Judaism. While later stages of this phenomenon, represented by Acts 7 and multiplied in patristic exegesis, are well known, the present case offers an opportunity to get a better glimpse of an earlier phase of this polemical trend.
|
A Sixth-Century-BCE Enlightenment? Evidence of Cuneiform Royal Inscriptions
Program Unit: Ancient Near East
Alexander Prokhorov, University of Aberdeen
A significant transformation of the ancient Near East royal propaganda seems to have occurred in the sixth century BCE. Compared to representative samples of earlier imperial texts, specimen of the newer variety exhibit a striking rethinking of the salient items at the core of propagandistic presentations. Several imperial inscriptions of various provenances and historical periods display one common feature: they portray the pre-eminence of the king’s persona by focusing on the king’s intrinsic qualities, rather than extrinsic events. This suggests that the transformation in question conceivably originated in Neo-Babylonia and was inherited by its great successor, Persia. What may be provisionally called “a sixth-century-BCE enlightenment”, if plausibly proven to have been the case, is likely to have important implications for the study of both the Hebrew Bible and the New Testament. First, taking Gerstenberger’s view (2002: 169-187) as a point of departure, one may explore new aspects of the influence of the vocabulary of the ancient Near East royal propaganda on the presentation of Yahweh’s image in the Hebrew Bible. Second, a key aspect in the presentation of Jesus in the New Testament, viz. that of peace-bringing kingship (e.g. Luke 19.35ff), may be traced not merely to the prophetic ideals of the Hebrew Bible but also to the ancient Near East cultural environment as the original context of such ideas. Third, the cultural and cultic irregularities, which upset the Neo-Babylonian Empire towards the end of its existence, may be conceived of as part of a wider intellectual phenomenon.
|
Early Byzantine Residences in Ephesos
Program Unit:
Andreas Pülz, Austrian Academy of Sciences
Extensive excavations in the area between the harbor street (Arkadiane) and the Church of Mary at Ephesos brought to light numerous buildings already in 1900. These are chiefly very richly appointed peristyle houses, comparable in architectural type to the well-known imperial-period terrace houses in the center of the city. Recent geophysical surveys have demonstrated that these structures are not individual dwellings, but rather a comprehensive multi-unit development that forms, along with the Church of Mary and the so-called Byzantine palace, the center of late antique Ephesos.
|
Darstellungen aus dem Alten und Neuen Testament auf Frühbyzantinischen Pilgerampullen
Program Unit: Reception of the Bible in Jewish, Early Christian and Islamic Art
Andreas Pülz, Austrian Academy of Sciences
Wie im griechisch-römischen Heidentum der Antike, dem Judentum oder dem Islam spielt auch im Christentum das Pilgerwesen eine wesentliche Rolle. Die Motivation für die Wallfahrten war der Wunsch, durch das Aufsuchen der heiligen Gräber oder Gedenkstätten eine besondere Nähe zu Gott bzw. den verehrten Heiligen und Anteil an den Gnadengaben zu erlangen. Daher nahm man vielfach auch Amulette oder organische Substanzen, die durch den Kontakt mit den Reliquien als segensspendend galten, mit nach Hause. Diese Eulogia wurden in der Regel in Ampullen aufbewahrt, deren beidseitiger bildlicher Schmuck sich nicht nur auf die jeweiligen Pilgerorte bzw. auf einen speziellen Heiligen bezog (vgl. die Menasampullen). Vielmehr ist eine Reihe von Pilgerfläschchen erhalten, auf denen sich alt- und neutestamentliche Motive finden. Der Bezug der gewählten biblischen Themen zum jeweiligen Pilgerort ist aber heute in vielen Fällen nur mehr schwer zu erkennen.
|
Writing Genealogies, Constructing Men Lineage in the New Testament and Roman Times
Program Unit: The Bible in the Twenty-First Century: Politization of Bibles and Biblization of Politics (EABS)
Jeremy Punt, Stellenbosch University
The role of genealogies became ambivalent in imperial times. Claims to agnatic lineage were increasingly challenged so that the respectability of relatives, paternal, maternal and by marriage, within the household came stronger into focus. Notwithstanding an increasing ambivalent role, genealogies were still invoked, and played a much less ambivalent role in the construction of masculinity. Within this socio-political context, the genealogical tenor within the NT is reconsidered beyond the gospels’ grounding of Jesus genealogies in Abraham (Mt 1:1) or Adam (Lk 3:34-38), or Abraham’s centrality in Hebrews’ genealogy of faith (Heb 11:8-19). This paper explores the increasingly complex interplay between genealogy, masculinity and power in a few NT texts with reference to the imperial context.
|
Biblical Reading in Alban Berg's Wozzeck: Music Enacting Interpretation
Program Unit: Bible and Its Influence: History and Impact
Hugh S. Pyper, University of Sheffield
Alban Berg's opera Wozzeck is widely regarded as one of the most important works of the 20th century and in particular as a uniquely successful example of the work of the Second Viennese School. For biblical scholars, the fact that the 3rd act begins with an extended scene where a character reads from the Bible is of particular interest. In this paper, the way in which Berg differentiates between the setting of the text and the setting of the character's interpretation will be explored. The argument will be made that musical form and musical intertextuality and allusion contribute to illustrating and subverting the cultural trope of the solitary biblical reader. This in turn throws light on the cultural and musical milieu of Vienna after the First World War and raises questions about the effect of these on the perception of the Bible. The reactions of music critics then and now to this scene are themselves an intriguing pointer to shifting attitudes to the Bible.
|
An Unfair Generosity! A Ontextual Reading of 1 Kings 17
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Brigitte Rabarijaona, Université de Genève
The Hebrew Bible describes the widow as the weakest in the society. And yet, in the story of Elijah, it is a widow who is assigned, in the name of God, to feed the prophet in a time of famine. We may find here the image of the generosity of the widow, as many commentators think, but beyond that, once she gives her last survival resource, she is obliged to become dependant on Elijah and his promise of miracle. In the name of religion and culture, the woman is deprived of her independence. How to understand such narrative that reflects our current context in which the weakest are forced to abandon their last resources to stronger? This paper proposes a socio-historical reading of this story in order to understand the political, social, and religious issues behind the composition of such text.
|
Iconography and Ritual: Motif Transfer between the Levant and Greece
Program Unit: Iconography and Biblical Studies (EABS)
Ursin Raffainer, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
Towards the end of the 8th century B.C.E. potnia theron images occur for the first time in the Aegean. There, the potnia theron motif is often used for Gorgo but also as a winged goddess, usually identified with Artemis. Many votive offerings show this motif and in one instance it is even used as the central part of a pediment. Chronologically the motif is mainly used in the archaic period, but also appears in later times. It is communis opinio that this image was imported from the Eastern Mediterranean, although the Greek adoptions seem to merge different predecessors. Astarte-images are often mentioned as one of the main models, but the image of domination of animals in the ancient Near East occurs mainly with male figures and seems to be used as an apotropaion in some instances. But the custom to use Gorgos as apotropaia on entrances, buildings and altars in Greece has others predecessors as well. In the ancient Near East Humbaba- and Bes-masks seem to fulfill similar roles and the iconographic parallels are evident. The archaic Artemis and her sanctuaries, where this iconography appears, can be linked to initiation rituals. It seems, that Artemis and Gorgo played prominent roles in rituals that were concerned with aristocratic youths entering into the society of the adults, the ruling class in archaic poleis, certainly one of the most important moments in the lives of those concerned. The goal of this paper will be to examine some potential iconographic predecessors and role the personae behind these images played in archaic Greece. With this as base, it should be discussed if the images where the only items imported or if certain ideas attached to them in the Eastern Mediterranean played a role for their adoption into the Aegean world.
|
Shining Like Stars: Bodies of Light in Second Temple Literature and Science Fiction
Program Unit: Science Fiction and the Bible (EABS)
Rebecca Raphael, Texas State University
This paper compares the concepts and functions of bodies of light in Second Temple apocalypses and contemporary science fiction. In several Second Temple apocalypses, a body of light is presented as a future form of embodiment available to the righteous. Texts from Daniel, 4 Ezra, 1 Enoch, and 1QS shall be examined in order to determine the nature and qualities of the bodies imagined. In order to assess its value for these texts, one must consider both the qualities attributed to the light-body and features by which it differed from a standard (normate) body. To this ancient Judaic conceptualization, I shall compare the use of light-bodies in recent science fiction. Focusing on functional correlates, i.e. examples in which the light-body represents a desirable transformation (the Star Child of _2001: A Space Odyssey_; extremely advanced aliens in _Star Trek_; regeneration in _Doctor Who_), one can explore the persistence of this concept. To that end, discussion of the limitations of light-bodies in science fiction shall help sharpen our understanding of their function the meaning in both the ancient and modern contexts. Throughout, the paper shall historicize the concept of what a (any) body is, and also engage underlying issues of metaphor and representation.
|
The Whole Body: On Terms of Embodiment in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Rebecca Raphael, Texas State University
The past decade has been particularly fruitful in scholarship on disability in the Hebrew Bible and related texts (Avalos; Olyan; Raphael; Schipper). This line of research requires an historicist study of the indigenous concepts of embodiment per se. As Dale Martin argued with respect to Hellenistic culture and Greek terms (1999), one must take care not to attribute the Cartesian opposition of material body versus non-material spirit to ancient texts. To that end, this paper will survey Hebrew terms and their concepts, including flesh, form, appearance, life, spirit, and others. In the interests of brevity and thoroughness, the focus will be on material from Leviticus, but that discussion shall be placed in the context of other texts and Ancient Near Eastern cultural history. Overall, the significance of physicality and the materiality of spirit shall be shown, in contrast to post-Cartesian notions. Further, the implications for studies of bodily norms and non-norms, especially the disabled body, shall be discussed.
|
The Bible in Byzantine-Jewish Relations: A Problematic History
Program Unit: The Bible in Byzantium: The Use and Abuse of Tradition
Claudia Rapp, Universität Wien
*
|
The Short Yiqtol in the Book of Psalms
Program Unit: Writings (including Psalms)
Cristian G. Rata, Torch Trinity Graduate University
The last few years has seen the publication of two major monographs (by John A. Cook and Jan Joosten) about the verb in Biblical Hebrew. At the same time, Alexander Andrason has published several important articles that deal with the most important verbal forms of Biblical Hebrew (yiqtol, wayyiqtol, and qatal).
Andrason analyzes the verbal system of Biblical Hebrew in light of grammaticalization, and he calls his approach “the second generation,” as he seeks to go beyond the grammaticalization approach (first generation) pioneered by John Cook.
While none of these works focus on the Hebrew verb in poetry, they all make significant contributions to our understanding of the verb in Biblical Hebrew.
This paper will take into consideration the insights of these scholars, point some of their shortcomings, and specifically analyze the usage of the short yiqtol (including the wayyiqtol) in the book of Psalms. The intention is to contribute to a better understanding of the finite verb in classical Hebrew poetry, especially as it pertains to the use of the yiqtol.
|
Emperor Cult in Private Dwellings: Ephesos and Beyond
Program Unit:
Elisabeth Rathmayr, Austrian Academy of Sciences
The paper will address archaeological, epigraphic and literary evidence concerning Emperor Cult in private dwellings. The topic will be approached by these and other questions: How were Roman Emperors venerated in private dwellings? Were there special loci within the dwellings where the cult actually happened? Was only the household involved or people from outside as well?
|
The Look of a Goddess: Considerations about the Seal Impressions Representing Female Deities from the Ancient City of Avaris
Program Unit: Iconography and Biblical Studies (EABS)
Chiara Reali, Universität Wien
A newly excavated area of the modern site of Tell el-Dab?a, known for having been the ancient capital city of the Hyksos Dynasties, supplied the research with a large number of cretulae , bearing seal impressions. These sealings were recovered in a settlement district of the city, also equipped with storage compartments, that was likely in use during the whole 15 th Dynasty and whose last occupation levels seem to date back to the late Second Intermediate Period (first half of the 16 th century B.C.). Motifs and iconographies among these seal impressions vary enough, interchanging pure Egyptian or Levantine designs with heterogeneous solutions, which are typical for the Middle Bronze Age. Besides some royal names, the rest of the impressions show: floral motifs; red crowns of Lower Egypt; smA-tAwy designs, symbol of unification of Upper and Lower Egypt; Horus eyes; formulae ; human, royal and divine figures; animals and mythical creatures. Regarding the iconography of deities, the cretulae documented thus far, showed a higher percentage of impressions bearing the iconic or symbolical representation of a goddess as compared to the impressions depicting male deities. The 60% of the represented divine beings is feminine, alternatively showing Egyptian or Levantine features. According to the iconography, this ensemble of goddess images can be easily split into two main groups, having clearly distinctive main traits. This subdivision concerning the goddess iconography is well- established in the study of 2nd millennium B.C. stamp seals and it consists of two subclasses, gathering respectively the design of the “nude standing goddess” and the “Hathor symbol”. Within each group, however, several appearances of the goddess are reflected by slight nuances and variation on theme/s, which seem to deserve a closer look.
|
Bitter Water, Purifying Water, Drinking Water: A Wet Reading of Numbers
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible/Old Testament/Ancient Israel Studies (EABS)
Anthony Rees, Charles Sturt University
Water is a major concern of the biblical material. We encounter primeval waters, mysterious rivers and springs, mists in the air, wells, mythical floods, and so on. All this in the first book!
This paper examines 3 distinct types of water in Numbers: the bitter waters of Num 5, the purifying waters of Num 19, and the drinking water provided in Num 20. It traces the various anxieties around these three types of water, and how they might contribute to a ecological understanding of Numbers.
|
‘…As an ox licks up the grass of the field’: Ecological Imperialism in Numbers
Program Unit: Postcolonial Studies
Anthony Rees, Charles Sturt University
The opening four chapters of Numbers are comprised of a census, and then a marching formation for the people of Israel as they set out from Sinai and head towards Canaan. Two things are assumed: travel, and military engagement. In chapter 22, the Moabites are anxious about the advancing Israelites, particularly in light of their recent victories. An ecological simile is used: ‘The horde will now lick up all that is around us, as an ox licks up the grass of the field.’
This paper examines the ecological implications of Israel’s imperial march, both through their travel, and through the practice of warfare. Using the work of Alfred Crosby, this paper will consider the biological and ecological component of colonial occupation, both in Numbers, and beyond.
|
Object-Relations Theory and Children: A Winnicottian Reading of Ps 127:3-5
Program Unit: Families and Children in the Ancient World
Melissa L. Reginelli, Vanderbilt University
In Psalm 127:3 children are called “a heritage from the Lord,” and “a reward.” The following two verses go on to describe children as “arrows in the hand of a warrior” (v. 4) and that with which a man fills his quiver (v. 5). On the surface, some may question the ethics and efficacy of comparing children to arrows or to any object intended for violence. In contrast, this paper follows psychoanalyst D.W. Winnicott’s object-relations theory in order to argue that Psalm 127:3-5 advocates for a greater sense of love and respect for children by engaging them in object-relations. Object-relations theory posits that individuals relate to objects by first discovering them, then attempting to destroy them, and lastly loving them more if the objects survive (Winnicott: 2005, 115-124). Psalm 127 introduces, or discovers, children in v. 3 by portraying them as objects, specifically “a heritage from the Lord” and “a reward.” In v. 4 the text then attempts to destroy the concept of children by instrumentalizing them as arrows, which are intended to cause and undergo destruction. Rather than destroying them, though, v. 5 claims, “they [children] will not be put to shame when they speak with their enemies in the gate.” Regardless of whether the children confront their enemies at their own gate and successfully defend themselves (cf. Alter: 2007, 450), or the children traverse to their enemies’ gate and successfully defeat them (cf. Gen.22:17, Jud.5:8-11), the children ultimately receive a substantial blessing by surviving the attack. Thus, the discovery, attempted destruction, and resulting survival of children in Psalm 127:3-5 completes the process of object-relations. Read through this lens, the existence of object-relations in the text presents children as a strong and capable entity intended to receive love and respect.
|
David: The Fantasy Priest King of Psalm 110
Program Unit: Writings (including Psalms)
Stephen Breck Reid, Baylor University
Psalms scholars have long associated 1 Chronicles 16 and the Psalter. But new research on Chronicles may shed further light on Books IV and V of the Psalter. Steven Schweitzer uses utopian literary theory to illuminate Chronicles.Among other issues, he argues that Chronicles has presented the temple cult through a utopian lens. The Chronicler creates a cultic utopia populated with priests, Zadokites and Levites.
These same players shape Books IV and V of the Psalter. The superscriptions of David depict a vulnerable king, a metaphor that calls into question the Persian hegemony. Psalm 110 contains a Davidic superscription. It also has explicit references to the priesthood of Melchizedek. This juxtaposition is best understood in light of utopian literary theory which will illuminate how Psalm 110 creates a pastiche of David and Melchizedek as a counter-discourse to the Persian royal theology/ideology. If one understands David as a participant in the plot of Psalm 110 and also the reference to the priestly tradition of Melchizedek, we recognize that the editor has transformed David of the superscription into a priestly alternative to the colonial power.
|
Can One See Bil'am (Balaam) as the Personification of Nevi-Emet?
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Azila Talit Reisenberger, University of Cape Town
Initial reading of the narrative depicting Bil'am ben-Beor in the book of Numbers, gives the impression that Bil'am is of less ability to communicate with the Divine than his she-ass.
Yet, many rabbinical commentaries compare Bil'am to Moses. It is easy to read the comparison as an extreme polarity between the two characters: the first, who is considered as "The Prophet of all Prophets" (Moshe Rabeinu), while the other is a man who is reprimanded by his she-ass.
The paper analyses the Narrative of Bil'am and shows how it fits with the teaching of what 'True-Prophecy' is supposed to be and to embody according to the Hebrew Bible.
|
Amplification of the NT in the Homerocentona: Nonnos and the Gospel of John
Program Unit: The Reception of the Bible in Greco-Roman Tradition
André-Louis Rey, Université de Genève
Both the paraphrase of the Gospel of John in Homeric verse of the Nonnian school and the Homerocentra or collections of chapters of the History of Salvation made up by combining together original lines of Homer’s Iliad or Odyssey constitute a rewriting of the New Testament that tries to bring together the contents and message of the new Christian Religion with the classical form of Homeric verse.
This paper intends to show the different techniques used by the authors of these works ; the authorship problems will not be specifically dealt with, but it can be assumed that the cultural context of origin of these attempts to a synthesis between two most revered traditions of the Late Roman World is to be found in the controversies about the status of pagan letters that were vivid in the IVth and Vth Centuries AD.
Through a few examples, we shall see the implications of two different rewriting techniques, the paraphrasis and the cento, for the reelaboration and amplification (as well as diminution, of course, mostly in the case of the Homeric centones) of the original NT (and occasionally apocryphal) data. Words and themes present in the original Scripturary material are substituted or expressed by different materials, or left aside, whereas the homeric words and expressions, or, in the case of the centones, whole lines or groups of words more or less adapted to their new situation in the text, bring along with them some intertextual references . The resulting hybrid texts do not only add poetical and rhetorical elements and effects to the NT subject-matter but are able to imply and express theological interpretations related to it.
|
A Dwelling Place of Demons: Apocalypticism in the Dead Sea Scrolls
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Bennie H. Reynolds III, Millsaps College
One finds a proliferation of transworldly beings in Jewish literature of the Hellenistic period. This development is not limited to apocalypses and apocalyptic texts, but it is particularly pronounced in these texts. Indeed, interest in angels and demons as well as the geography of heaven and hell is often considered a quintessential feature of apocalypses and apocalyptic texts. Several theories have been offered to explain the use of angels and demons in apocalyptic texts and these theories are not all mutually exclusive. In this paper I consider subsets of both the data and the theories used to explain them. I examine the function of malevolent spirits in sectarian texts from Qumran in light of modern sociological theories about apocalypticism. I emphasize the role of dualism in the authors’ ability to reconceive existing cosmological/metaphysical concepts in innovative ways.
|
Echoes of Scripture in Byzantine Political Identity
Program Unit: The Bible in Byzantium: The Use and Abuse of Tradition
Meredith Riedel, Duke University
*
|
The Unique Contribution of Iberia to Bible Translation
Program Unit: The Bible in the Iberian World: Fundaments of a Religious Melting Pot (EABS)
Ian D. Ritchie, Wycliffe College
Although the church permitted no translations of the Bible into Spanish in the Medieval period, Jewish translations of the Hebrew Bible carried the unique lifeworld of Al Andalus. A history of the translation and interpretation of Isaiah 11 is particularly in structive of a key role Andalusian lifeworld played in the infusion of a differently balanced sensorium in the leading intellectual culture of the Middle ages, influencing many other cultures in Europe through Bible translations of the16th century and later. Ibn Ezra and Rabbi David Kimhi's translation/commentaries on Isaiah, marked by the flavours, accents and metaphors of the Andalusian lifeworld, were later transferred to southern France. Copies may have been known to Casiodoro de Reina, (1520-1594) the Hieronymite monk of Seville turned Protestant whose Spanish Bible translation has had a great influence from his time to our ours. In 1552 the Inquisition burned him in effigy in Seville, but his translation was published in 1569. Whether or not de Reina was directly influenced by the Jewish commentators, Martin Luther's German Bible of 1545, and the Dutch Statenvertaling translation of 1637, show marks of Andalusian sensorium. Academies of southern France may have been key conduits for the transmission of the old Andalusian lifeworld, for many Jewish scholars fled there. David Martin, educated in Montauban and Nimes published a French translation in 1702 reflecting this same tradition. Notably absent was any impact on English translations, until the Jubilee 2000 translation, itself a translation of de Reina's Spanish Bible. Anthropological research by Constance Klassen et. al. on the shifting sensorium suggests that the Iberian peninsula was the last part of Europe to experience the shift toward the visual mode of knowing observed in the 19th century. Our research suggests the same, emphasizing the importance of this study for translators.
|
The Stranger in the Biblical Law Codes
Program Unit: Pentateuch (Torah)
Johannes Unsok Ro, International Christian University
There is an emerging tendency to view the core part of Covenant Code (CC) as derived from the monarchical period between the ninth and seventh centuries. However, the concerns of the three biblical law codes (CC, Holiness Code [HC] and Deuteronomic Code [DC]) for the stranger are very similar. The subject of the “stranger” was a burning problem not only in CC, but also in HC and DC. The authors of the three law codes share the same awareness of the seriousness of the issue even though there is slight variation in tone. The difference seems to be more related to the respective authors’ internal perspectives on the stranger than to external socio-economic changes. In CC, the term for “stranger” is used as a synonym for poor (Exod. 22:24), widows (Exod. 22:21-22) and orphans (Exod. 22:21-22). In HC (Lev. 19:10), the “stranger” is also juxtaposed with the poor one. The social status of the “stranger” in DC is not drastically changed. The “stranger” is considered as equal to orphans, widows, hired servants and Levites. Most of the regulations related to the “stranger” in the three law codes have to do with protection.
That the socio-economic settings of the three law codes relating to the “stranger” are similar seem to render improbable the assumption that there are chronological gaps of centuries between the respective law codes. In our view, the theme of the “stranger” in the biblical law codes can be synchronously understood. It must have been an urgent problem for the Judean communities in Persian era Palestine because of massive number of returnees from Babylonian exile.
|
Balaam's Fourth Oracle
Program Unit: Septuagint Studies
Jonathan Robker, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
Balaam's fourth oracle (Num 24:15-24) presents one of the most difficult texts in Numbers from a text-critical standpoint. Much of this difficulty stems from the variants present in the LXX text, some of which can neither be satisfactorily explained as translational freedoms reflecting a text similar to MT nor as corruptions caused by misreading a text similar to MT. This variance remains particularly poignant, as LXX-Numbers generally reflects the strict translation of a Vorlage essentially identical to MT. More importantly, the LXX version of this pericope has left a unique mark in reception history, since its version is presupposed by the gospel of Matthew. However, no later Hebrew text identically matches LXX's presupposed Vorlage. This variation in the reception of the text may reflect the recensional development of Num 24:15-24 away from a text similar to, yet distinct from MT, toward a text in the proto-Masoretic tradition. This paper will treat the variations between the LXX and MT (and other relevant traditions and reception such as Qumran) and reflect upon the possibility of reconstructing a Hebrew Vorlage of LXX that was distinct from MT for this passage. Finally, parallels between reception and recensional history will be considered.
|
Jewish Artistic Trends from Pompeii
Program Unit: Archaeology and Diaspora Judaism
Samuele Rocca, The Neri Bloomfield School of Design and Education – Haifa
Epigraphic data shows that there was a tiny Jewish presence in ancient Pompeii. But, is this evidence also reflected in art that can be considered "Jewish"? In this lecture I shall discuss two objects that can be related to a Jewish presence in the city on the eve of the eruption of the Vesuvius in 79 CE. The first object is a gladiator helmet depicting a palm tree. The second object is the well known fresco depicting the Judgment of Solomon. It seems to me that these two objects reflected the two different trends which made up Jewish art in Classical Antiquity. The first trend, exemplified by the gladiatorial helmet, is a symbolic trend, which originated in Hasmonean and Herodian Judaea. Indeed, in Judaea already at the end of the second century BCE is possible to discern a local artistic production much influenced by a strict interpretation of the Second Commandment. This trend, with some exception shall continue till the destruction of the Second Temple and afterwards in Late Antiquity. It seems, however, that another artistic tradition developed in the Greek Diaspora, mainly in Alexandria. This artistic tradition, much different from the artistic tradition of Judaea, had been identified by Kurt Weitzman and Bezalel Narkiss. Accordingly, it seems that Alexandrian Jews probably for the first time created a Biblical iconography. This was expressed in illuminated manuscripts. Much later these images formed the basis of early Christian iconography, found for example in the wall frescoes of the Catacombs in Rome. Possibly, the wall painting found in Pompeii and depicting the Judgment of Solomon reflects this trend.
|
The Submerged Female
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Sandy Rogers, Universität Leipzig
A frequent question regarding Genesis 34 is how to understand the nature of the sexual encounter between Dinah and Shechem. In a society in which the majority of rapes continue to go unreported and in which survivors of rape who do report are often shamed, many feminist scholars have argued that Genesis 34:2 clearly refers to an act of rape by current definitions. Other scholars have pointed out the ambiguities of the text or even argued that the violence committed against Dinah was that done by her brothers against the people of Shechem. Popularly, the events depicted in Genesis 34 were rewritten by Anita Diamant who portrayed, though not with scholarly vigor, the relationship as a consensual romance. Both historically and in some contemporary scholarship, Dinah is still blamed for the events because of the only action she takes in the story-having gone out to visit the women of the region. Other scholars argue that the text is best understood, at least from its own perspective, from a group rather than individual ethic. It is with this last group that this paper is most closely aligned. Through an examination of the language used, particularly the verbs in 34:2, and comparison with similar or related narratives and laws, this project will establish that, for the narrator, the question of Dinah's personal consent or fee lings following the sexual encounter are entirely irrelevant to what is a male story. From a post-modern feminist perspective, the real horror of Genesis 34 is not whether Dinah was raped or that further violence was carried out, including violence against women, in her name, but that she is not expected to have a voice or bodily autonomy in the first place.
|
Theodicy & Protest, Can They Walk Together? Hebrew Bible Texts versus Christian Biblical Theology
Program Unit: Biblical Theology
Dalit Rom-Shiloni, Tel Aviv University
Theodicy and protest are often regarded as antonyms. Thus, for instance, Renkema leaves Lamentations out of the theological deliberations of theodicy. Brueggemann polarizes theodicy and protest along “testimonial” and “counter-testimonial” reflections, and Dobbs-Allsopp distinguishes “theodicy” from “anti-theodicy.” My study focuses on the conceptual congruities and distinctions between justifications of God, mostly formulated by historiographers and prophets, and protests against God, articulated by poetic and other non-prophetic voices in communal laments.
I argue that justification and protest belong to a single framework of deliberation within the “problem of theodicy” (R.M. Green), that should be termed “theodical discourse.” All participants are genuinely motivated to look for justifications of God; both approaches seek to reconcile distressing realities with assumptions about the divine. A study of Jeremiah 21:1-7 and Lamentations 2 will illustrate the limits of traditional theodicy for understanding the issues raised in these passages.
This discussion highlights the problem of terminology in the study of Hebrew Bible Theology. As a Christian theological concept (from Leibnitz, 1710 to the present), “theodicy” does not seem to account for the diversity suggested by Hebrew Bible texts. Thus, a re-conception of this theological negotiation is required, to encompass doubt and protest as well as justification of God in a unified “theodical discourse.”
|
“In the Day I Freed Them from the Land of Egypt”: A Non-Deuteronomic Phrase within Jeremiah's Covenant Conception
Program Unit: Prophets
Dalit Rom-Shiloni, Tel Aviv University
This paper is part of a larger study on Priestly traces in Jeremiah, and it presents the creativity of bringing diverse pentateuchal references together to enforce the prophetic message. Five prose passages in Jeremiah specify the constitutive event of the God-people relationship by the formulae: “in the day I freed them from / I brought them out of / I took them by the hand to lead them out of the land of Egypt” (Jer 7:22; 11:4, 7; 31:32; 34:13). These formulae recall obliging the people to the divine covenant through specific commandments. Yet there is no mention of the revelation event at Sinai (or the Deuteronomic, Horeb). Rather, the prophecies draw on the Exodus as the actual event when commandments were given to the people and their obedience was demanded. This paper argues for the non-Deuteronomic roots of these Jeremian formulae. Tracing their stylistic origins, leads to exposing a Priestly phraseological basis and thus possibly a Priestly covenant conception. The latter are intertwined with Deuteronomic covenant phrases and conceptions within one and the same prophetic passages. This tendency to harmonize diverse pentateuchal traditions has far reaching implications for the study of both Jeremiah and the Pentateuch.
|
The Pentateuch in the Former Prophets
Program Unit: Comparative Studies of Literature from the Persian and Hellenistic Periods
Thomas Römer, Université de Lausanne
There are several allusions to the Torah of Moses or Moses in the Former Prophets. It has often been argued, in the context of the Dtr History hypothesis, that these references refer to the book of Deuteronomy. Many of these texts may however already presuppose a (Proto-) Pentateuch in relation to which they want to define the Former Prophets as "deutero-canonical". If this observation is right, the references to Moses and his Torah should accordingly be dated later.
|
The Use of Ps 2:7 in Early Christian Literature
Program Unit: Biblical Interpretation in Early Christianity
Timothy B. Sailors, Eberhard-Karls-Universität Tübingen
The importance of Psalm 2.7 in early Christianity is evident from its citation in several, often otherwise unrelated works of early Christian literature (for example, in the Epistle to the Hebrews 1 and 5, in 1 Clement 36 and in the Acts of the Apostles 13). The utilization of this Psalm in these diverse contexts has been the subject of a recent book by S. Janse (Leuven 2009), who investigated Jewish and Christian uses of the entire Psalm up through the writings of Justin Martyr. The most notable use of Psalm 2.7 is in the stories of Jesus' baptism and transfiguration (compare too 2 Peter 1, fragments of so-called 'Jewish-Christian' gospels and the Apocalypse of Peter 17). Most of these narratives, however, present a conflated text of Psalm 2.7 and Isaiah 42.1 (along with Deuteronomy 18.15 in the case of the Transfiguration). Taking into account the composite nature of these citations (both source-texts of which were also used in early Judaism; see, for example, the use of Psalm 2.7 in 4QFlor 10–14), and extending the investigation beyond Justin to include slightly later texts (such as Pseudo-Clementine Homilies 3.53) and later texts that preserve earlier material (such as Apostolic Constitutions 2.32), this paper is able to better situate the place of Psalm 2.7 — and its conflated form — within early Christianity. An understanding both of the origin of this composite text and just how these early Christian authors used this conflation of the Psalms and the Prophet to express their christological beliefs and to bolster these beliefs among their audiences is only possible by investigating the entire breadth of texts in which it is utilized. This paper offers a compendious presentation and assessment of this very evidence.
|
The Royal Psalms and Papyrus Amherst 63
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Traditions in the Biblical World and Beyond
Reettakaisa Sofia Salo, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
The first translations of the Papyrus Amherst 63 were published in the 1980s. These Aramaic texts in Demotic script provide interesting insights into the syncretistic religion of Aramaic-speaking groups in the 4th century BCE Egypt. While the Hebrew Bible scholars have been discussing the relationship of Pap. Amherst 63 12:11-19 and Ps 20 ever since, the direction of the generally accepted influence or dependency between the two remains disputed: Pap. Amherst 63 12:11-19 and Ps 20 have many interesting semantic and structural parallels but both also contain their own distinct material, so-called Sondergut. Particularly worth of noting is that the Aramaic text doesn't mention a king. The royal psalms 18, 20 and 21 have sometimes been treated as a redactional unit in the first book of Psalms because of their language and motifs. Still the psalms 18 and 21 have mostly been neglected in the controversy about Ps 20 and Papyrus Amherst 63. The aim of this paper is to combine these two issues and ask, whether comparing the kingship motifs of Ps 20 with the royal psalms 18 and 21 gives new insights into the Judean kingship ideology and into the relationship, dating and traditions of Ps 20 and Papyrus Amherst 63. It seems that the Vorlage of Ps 20 and Pap. Amherst 63 12:11-19 was an originally Aramaic text from the North and was first adapted to the traditions of Judean kingdom in the Neo-Assyrian period. In the postexilic period Ps 20 went through the same process of the democratization of the royal ideology as the neighboring psalms. The later formation of the Vorlage was different in Egypt.
|
"Ein Hauch von der Ewigkeit des biblischen Buches": Joachim Prinz' biblische Geschichten für jüdische Kinder
Program Unit: Modern Jewish Receptions of the Bible
Dorothea M. Salzer, Universität Potsdam
*
|
Qohelet and Gilgamesh: A New Look
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Traditions in the Biblical World and Beyond
Nili Samet, Bar-Ilan University
More than a century of comparative research of the Book of Qohelet in light of Ancient Literature has yielded dozens of studies pointing to parallels between Qohelet and Mesopotamian, Phoenician, Egyptian and Hellenistic texts. However, upon closer examination, many of these alleged parallels turn out to be too general to offer evidence of literary dependence. The Gilgamesh epic is a striking exception: two different passages in Qohelet show undeniably significant similarities to parallel passages from the Gilgamesh literature. The aim of this paper is to re-examine the relation between the Gilgamesh tradition and the book of Qohelet. I will show that the version of Gilgamesh used by the author of Qohelet is not identical to any Gilgamesh recension known to us today. Consequently, I will attempt to locate this unique and currently unknown Gilgamesh version, and to trace its adaptation in the Hebrew Book of Qohelet. This analysis, in turn, will bear on the broader issue of using comparative data as a basis for dating biblical texts.
|
Non-Pentateuchal Judaism and Its Festivals
Program Unit: Law and Narrative (EABS)
Harald Samuel, Georg-August-Universitat Goettingen
Despite the frequent prophetic criticism concerning Israel’s handling of its feasts and the Sabbath, the Biblical portrayal is to a large extent that of a community acquainted with the (Pentateuchal) festival laws. The rhetoric of criticism actually presupposes a profound knowledge about the festivals on the side of those criticized.
However, besides this portrayal, some short notes have survived within the Biblical books that give voice to a minority report: acquaintance with the same feasts but a diverging approach to them. The present paper traces these relics of a different tradition and compares them with extra-biblical attestations for Sabbath and festivals in communities of Judaean origin. The question then arises how the Biblical prescriptions and (non-Biblical?) reality interrelate.
|
Johannine Scholarship in Japan, Now and Then
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Kei Sasaki, Hokkaido University
At SBL’s 2012 International Meeting in Amsterdam, I presented a paper analyzing Johnannine scholarship in the past 20 years in Japan. In this paper, I pointed out the scantiness of the achievements in this field, especially those using new literary methods. One of the reasons is that Japan has such a small Christian population that we Japanese only have a fragile “infrastructure that supports biblical studies” (H. Avalos). Of course, this situation has not changed so dramatically in the last few years, therefore, I would like to supplement the list of works from my previous presentation.
In 2013, one of the most prominent Japanese NT scholars, Kenzo Tagawa, published his own translation of the Fourth Gospel with extremely detailed notes in one volume of his own NT translation series, which could be called a commentary of the Gospel because it is almost 800 pages. He wrote, “For the time being, in Japanese society, no other scholars [than himself] show any sign of or ability for analyzing linguistic (Greek) characteristics of the Fourth Gospel. But I, as one of the more minor Johannine scholars, must dare to reply to his many challenging arguments.
His method is very classical and critical-historical “literary criticism,” according to which he explains the historical process of the formation of the Fourth Gospel, featuring fully the so-called “churchy editor(s).” Consequently, he categorically seems to reject any new literary methods, which try to regard the Gospel as a united whole in some sense. His method of research of the Gospel is not only his own inclination, but also that of the entire Japanese Johannine or biblical scholarship itself. In my opinion, we should reexamine this inclination, as a chronic pattern, thus taking a simple book review into the larger arena of Japanese society.
|
Doubled Request and Doubled Refusal: The Verb Patsar in Biblical Narrative
Program Unit: Literary Features – Fact or Fiction (EABS)
George Savran, Schechter Institue of Jewish Studies
Despite the reticence of biblical narrative to lay bare the inner life of its characters, various words and techniques hint at inner motivations and intentions. One such phenomenon is the case of the double request in the sequence “request-refusal-request”. Most requests in biblical narrative are met with immediate acceptance or refusal, without much attention to the emotional situation underlying the text. But in a number of instances we find the unusual situation of an offer being made and refused, only to be followed by a repetition of the offer together with the verb patsar, “to urge” or “to press”. In most cases this is met with accession by the one who had previously refused, but in a few instances there is a second refusal. The pattern assumes a change of attitude on the part of the offerer or the recipient (or both). The verb patsar intimates an understated emotional reaction which must be unpacked in order to grasp the dynamics of the interchange. What is the emotional state of the offerer that causes him to press his point, and what internal change has taken place in the recipient which leads him to accept the offer? This pattern of refusal with the verb patsar imputes to the character under consideration greater emotional depth and a more subtly nuanced persona. It occurs twice in Gen. 19, once with Lot as the offerer and a second time with him as recipient. Other cases to be discussed are Jacob and Esau in Gen. 33, Saul and his retainers in 1Sam. 28:23, as well as situations where the urging is met with a second refusal, such as Absalom and David in 2Samuel 13:25, and Elisha and Naaman in 2Kg. 5:16.
|
A Song in the Feminine/Masculine Form: Gendered Language for Israel in Song of Songs Rabbah
Program Unit: Metaphors in the Hebrew Bible/Old Testament and Their Reception
Nicholas Schaser, Vanderbilt University
The Hebrew Bible employs the metaphor of a woman in labor to describe Israel in exile (e.g., Isa 26: 17-18; Jer 4:31; Micah 4:9-10). Song of Songs Rabbah develops this imagery by comparing Israel’s captivity and release to a woman who receives the “burden” of pregnancy and then “discharges it” (Cant. R. 1:5). Using what Janet Soskice calls a “modeling simile” (1985: 59), the midrash states that just as a woman is eventually unable to become pregnant, ultimately Israel will be delivered from its current captivity (post-70 exile), “never to be enslaved again.” This metaphoric association equates pregnancy/childbirth with the vicissitudes of exile and the instability of foreign domination. The female metaphor “is exploited to portray political and religious behavior in sexual terms, terms which threaten the entire social and cosmic order” (Shields: 2004, 114). The text then dissolves the resulting image of a postmenopausal woman with exclusively male-gendered language. Referring first to the song (shirah) Israel sings in Exod 15:1, the passage concludes, “In this world, because their pains are like those of a female in childbirth, [Israel] sings a song before God in the feminine form (shirah), but in the world to come, because their pains will not be those of a woman in childbirth, they will sing a song in the masculine form (shir), as it says, 'In that day, this song (shir) shall be sung to the Lord'" (Isa 26:1). The midrashic move to the masculine shows that chaos and instability are not represented solely by female performance (pregnancy/childbirth), but by femaleness itself, which becomes not merely “marginal to the symbolic order” (Moi: 2002, 165), but absent from it. This interpretation of Scripture’s female metaphor reinforces the “gender-asymmetry” in rabbinic culture (Boyarin: 1993), limiting femininity as temporal and countering it with an eternal masculinization of Israel.
|
Canonical Approaches, New Trajectories, and the Book of Daniel
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
Jordan M. Scheetz, Tyndale Theological Seminary (Netherlands)
This paper briefly outlines the origins of canonical approaches including James Sanders, Brevard Childs, and Rolf Rendtorff, before turning to the canonical approach of John Sailhamer. Points of contrast between Childs, Rendtorff, and Sailhamer are made in relation to their proposed canonical texts and the development of these canonical texts. Although they all rely to a greater of lesser extent on the text of BHS, Sailhamer’s approach lends itself to exploring LXX texts, including their different early orderings exactly because of their early pre-Masoretic origins. Moving beyond these earlier approaches, the book of Daniel becomes a test case, critically challenging the assumption that BHS or even Baba Batra 14b represents the (earliest) canonical form of the Hebrew Scriptures. The point is not the rather historically dubious position that the placement of Daniel is to be here or there, but that thematic considerations and not the date of composition have led to its various placements, what I have called elsewhere canonical intertextuality.
|
Reflecting on Jesus’ Teaching on Forgiveness from a Positive Psychological Perspective
Program Unit: Psychological Hermeneutics of Biblical Themes and Texts
Eben Scheffler, University of South Africa
In its quest for a non-medical, pro-health approach to psychotherapy, positive psychology surprisingly focusses on concepts that are biblical and specifically present of the teaching of Jesus of Nazareth. In this paper, (1) the teaching of Jesus in the synoptic tradition will be compared to recent positive psychological approaches (e g Mccullough). Attention will be given to the (2) contexts of forgiveness (interpersonal and/or political), (3) the (philosophical) positive or negative judgement on forgiveness as a positive notion (e g the Buddhist concept of karma, Arndt, Deridda, Wolterstorff), (4) the (perceived) positive role of forgiveness in psychotherapy, (5) the “techniques” or method of forgiveness when the latter seems difficult and (6) the relation between forgiveness and religion or spirituality.
|
The Sensuality of the Song: A Bridge between 'Literal' and 'Allegorical' Interpretations?
Program Unit: The Song of Songs: Literal or Allegorical?
Annette Schellenberg, San Francisco Theological Seminary
The question of whether the Song is about human love/desire or about the love/desire in the divine-human relationship lets emotions run high – at the beginning of the reception history of this text as similarly again in recent scholarship. This paper will reflect on what is at stake with the alternative of “literal” - “allegorical” and then draw the attention to the sensuality of the Song. This sensuality is one of the most important characteristics of the text and helps to understand why the Song is read so differently. A variety of ancient texts show that in antiquity sensual language was employed both to describe the relationship among human lovers and to describe the relationship between the divine and humans. Furthermore, sensuality is crucial in most intimate experiences – which are crucial both in human love/desire and in (some) humans’ encounter with the divine (as indicated, for example, in the significance of sensual aspects in ancient Israel’s cult). Despite these overlaps, of course, for every text one can and should ask how it was meant originally. In the case of the Song, this paper will argue that the Song originated as text describing human love affairs. Nonetheless, at the same time it will be argued that to judge an interpretation with regard to the alternative of “literal” or “allegorical” only is one sided, as an “allegorical” interpretation paying attention to the sensuality of the Song might do more justice to the text than a “literal” that does not.
|
Madrasha and Surah: Common Characteristics between the Historical Ode and the Hymn
Program Unit: Bible and Syriac Studies in Context
Stephanie Schewe, Freie Universität Berlin
According to the Syriac madrasha, which can be either an historical ode or a hymn, it is to be clarified if there are similar forms in the Qur'an that allow for an equivalent distinction of the surah. Passages in the Qur'an that refer to historical reports are to be differentiated from hymns for the sake of glorification that appear in early Meccan surahs. The comparative approach leads to the question of how the recitation was executed. There are obviously differences within the same form of a madrasha. This aspect has to be determined for the qur'anic context first by analyzing its language and secondly by examining its recitation. The Qur'an emerged in Late Antiquity. As a consequence similarities and influences between the Oriental-Christian and Islamic traditions provide the framework for further research.
|
Biblical Imagery in the Homiletic Writings of a Constantinopolitan Patriarch in Exile: The Case of Germanos II (1223-1240)
Program Unit: The Bible in Byzantium: The Use and Abuse of Tradition
Elisabeth Schiffer, Österreichische Akademie der Wissenschaften
*
|
Viktor Aptowitzer: Tradition, Haskalah and Wissenschaft
Program Unit: The Reception History of the Bible in the Wissenschaft des Judentums of the Viennese Bet Ha-Midrash
Lawrence H. Schiffman, Yeshiva University
This paper will examine the personal and corresponding intellectual biography of Viktor (Avigdor) Aptowitzer, showing that even as he moved to Vienna and became a scholar in the post-enlightenment academic mold, he retained his close connection to traditional Jewish scholarship. His work, therefore, reflects the knowledge of a traditional talmid hakham as well as that of a Wissenschaft scholar. He maintained aspects of his East European background while adopting the model of modern, West European scholarship. An important example is his religious Zionism and commitment to teaching in modern Hebrew. ? Indeed his crowning achievement, the publication of most of Sefer Ra'avyah, may be seen as an affirmation of the synthesis of traditional Torah scholarship of the highest level with the historical and philological achievements of the Wissenschaft des Judentums.
|
The Reception of the Jewish Scriptures in the Dead Sea Scrolls and Rabbinic Literature
Program Unit:
Lawrence Schiffman, Yeshiva University
The tradition that we term "biblical," namely those books that eventually ended up in the canon of the Hebrew Bible, was formative for the development of Second Temple Judaism as well as rabbinic faith, practice and literature. Whatever may have been the understanding of canon among the various groups of Second Temple and early rabbinic Jews, these particular books took a leading role in shaping Judaism. This paper will investigate the manner in which the various genres and classes of literature of Second Temple and Rabbinic Judaism preserved and transmitted the Bible, and how they understood the text, canon, authority and function of these books. Further, we will discuss the role of the biblical heritage in emerging Jewish ritual and law.
|
Augustine’s Reception of Jacob the Trickster (Gen 30:37-43)
Program Unit: The Reception of the Bible in Greco-Roman Tradition
Karin Schlapbach, University of Ottawa
Augustine discusses Jacob, a genetic engineer avant la lettre, in various works. He takes particular care to prove Jacob’s honesty and goes to some lengths to justify every single element of his actions (e.g. Quaestiones in Heptateuchum 93). If Jacob was successful in manipulating the colour of his cattle (Genesis 30.37-43), he nevertheless stayed within the boundaries assigned to nature by God, who is the only creator (City of God 12.26: non facit nisi summus Deus).
This paper will examine in particular the function of the episode of Jacob’s sheep in Augustine’s account of the relationship between body and soul at De trinitate 11.2.5. In this passage Augustine discusses the ‘traces’ of the trinity in sense perception, more precisely vision. The threefold pattern that he identifies in vision consists of res (the object), imago (the imprint on the sense organ and the resulting perception) and voluntas (which unifies the former two). The third element, voluntas, receives the most detailed treatment. The example of Jacob’s sheep serves to depict it as an active force that acts upon matter and is able to transform it. The paper will show that this entails not only a slightly different account of sexual desire than Augustine is usually credited with. More importantly, the example draws attention to a material expression of the unity of the triad identified in vision. In short, Jacob’s experiment shows the way to the visible traces of the trinity in the material world.
|
The Rise and Fall of the Notion of “Spätjudentum” in Biblical Scholarship
Program Unit: Anti-Semitic Readings of the Bible
Konrad Schmid, University of Zurich
In early to mid-20th century biblical scholarship, the notion of “Spätjudentum” (“Late Judaism”) was well regarded as a designation for the Second Temple Period. Nowadays, “Spätjudentum” is usually considered to be—at least implicitly—a supersessionist Christian term, but it was also used by Jewish scholars. This paper will explore the origins of the term in the 19th century, the usage during its heyday, and the circumstances for its abandonment.
|
How to Identify a Persian Period Text in the Pentateuch?
Program Unit: Persian Period
Konrad Schmid, University of Zurich
Dating Pentateuchal texts is a very contested and debated subject. In European scholarship it is a commonplace to locate some text portions of the Pentateuch in the Persian period. Some scholars even think that the vast majority of the Pentateuch should be assigned to that time. Outside Europe, especially in Israel and North America, there is a strong tendency to minimize the dating of texts to the Persian period. Scholars point out that there are no Persian loanwords in the Pentateuch and argue that the parameters of linguistic dating are not in favor of a Persian date for Pentateuchal texts. This paper will explore the force and the limits of these arguments and try to sketch out some methodological guidelines, illustrated by text samples, on how to identify Persian period texts in the Pentateuch.
|
Music and Exegesis in Franz Schubert’s Oratorio "Lazarus": A Happy Liaison?
Program Unit: Bible and Its Influence: History and Impact
Eckart David Schmidt, Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz
Franz Schubert (1797-1828), one of the greatest Viennese composers, is known best for his song cycles, his symphonies and works for piano and chamber ensembles. Like so many of his large scale works, his Biblical oratorio, sometimes called „Sacred Opera“, titled „Lazarus oder die Feier der Auferstehung“ remained a fragment. He composed it in 1820, but it was first performed not until 1865. It depicts Lazarus’ death and burial in some length, but breaks off before Jesus’ arrival. Therefore, Lazarus’ resurrection itself is lacking, too, ironically defying the work’s optimistic subtitle. The libretto used is not the Biblical text (as e.g. in Mendelssohn’s oratorios) but a freely dramatized version by August Hermann Niemeyer (1754–1828). On top of the biblical figures Niemeyer invented further personae: Nathanael, Jemina, and a Sadducee named Simon.
It has often been discussed why Schubert’s work lacks Lazarus’ actual resurrection, without ever finding a conclusive answer.
The paper proposed intends to take a wider focus. It will investigate both Niemeyer’s dramatization of the Biblical story and Schubert’s music in the light of recent narratological analyses of the Biblical text. How are we able to understand Niemeyer and Schubert’s reading of the Biblical story? For a fair investigation, exegesis and theology of the early 19th century will be included in the discussion.
|
"Gott" in der Juditerzählung: Rezeption und Adaption der LXX-Erzählung in der Vulgata-Übersetzung des Hieronymus
Program Unit: Septuagint Studies
Barbara Schmitz, University of Würzburg
„Gott“ kommt als handelnde Figur in der Juditerzählung nach der Fassung der Septuaginta nur ein einziges Mal vor: In Jdt 4,13 wird beschrieben, dass Gott die Stimme seines zu ihm schreienden Volkes gehört und seine Not gesehen hat. Dies ist der zentrale Vers der Juditerzählung in der Septuaginta, in der – unter Einspielung von Rettungsterminologie aus der Exodusüberlieferung – die Erhörung Gottes für die Leser angezeigt wird. Für die Figuren der Handlung hingegen ist diese Erhörungsnotiz gerade nicht ‚hörbar’; im Gegenteil: Die Not wird sich in der Juditerzählung sogar noch steigern. Daher geht es in der Septuagintafassung der Juditerzählung daher um die Frage, wie sich die Rettung des Volkes konkret vollziehen wird.
Anders verhalten sich die Dinge in der Vulgata-Übersetzung des Hieronymus: Anders als in den altlateinischen Fassungen fehlt in der Vulgata-Übersetzung des Hieronymus genau dieser so wichtige Vers: Der Hinweis auf das Sehen und Hören Gottes ist – offenbar – gestrichen.
Aufgrund dieses Befundes wird im Zentrum des Papers die Frage stehen, wie „Gott“ in der Vulgata-Übersetzung präsentiert wird und welche konzeptionellen wie theologischen Implikationen sich mit diesen offensichtlichen Veränderungen verbinden.
|
Materializing German Old Testament Exegesis: The Social Historical Method in the Work of Willy Schottroff
Program Unit: Political Biblical Criticism
Susanne Sholz, Southern Methodist University
This paper posits that the social historical method has been particularly popular among post-Holocaust, post-1968, liberation-theological oriented, feminist, and politically left-leaning German exegetes because it has enabled them to resist and to offer alternatives to the socio-political, economic, and religious status quo in German theological and exegetical discourse. The work of German Old Testament professor Willy Schottroff (1931-1997) illustrates this dynamic, which traces its roots back to Gerhard von Rad and the Confessing Church during the Nazi-era. To Schottroff, the social historical method is a historical approach that recognizes its hermeneutical interests in favor of justice and “die kleinen Leute,” i.e., the disempowered and oppressed. It exposes a traditionally defined historical criticism as endorsing the status quo in society, politics, economic, and religion. As such, the “sozialgeschichtliche” approach must be understood as a contribution towards the development of a Lederhosen hermeneutics.
|
Tarif in the Digital Age
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical Studies, Early Jewish and Christian Studies (EABS)
Sara Schulthess, Université de Lausanne
The notion tarif, often translated as “falsification” or “corruption” of the Scriptures, is an important theme in the Islamic polemic discourse against Christianity (and Judaism) and has been playing a significant role in the interfaith encounter and dialogue since the beginning of Islam. This theory, which refutes the authenticity of the Biblical text used by Christians, has adopted the new developments of the textual criticism discipline in the Western Universities since the 19th century. The raise of the digital age leads to a renewal of the classical polemic issue of the ta?rif: today we can observe an increase in the number of websites, blogs and forums specializing in New Testament textual criticism, with the aim to demonstrate the ta?rif. This can be related directly to the revolutions taking place within the discipline of New Testament textual criticism itself: the digitalization of manuscripts and online access to images, scientific and amateur networks, collaborative works, etc. The ta?rif websites are in fact using information, which can be found on websites for New Testament textual criticism and are sometimes interacting and collaborating with the latter. They also develop a typical rhetoric: frequent use of manuscripts images, references to well-known, but also controversial researchers in the field of the New Testament textual criticism, as for instance Bart Ehrman, dissemination of the notion of authorship, use of videos, etc.
What is the significance of this new phenomenon? Does this “online polemic” show new arguments? How will it influence the discipline of New Testament textual criticism, as well as the interfaith dialogue?
|
Origen's Curious Translation of Prov 2:5
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Wisdom
Zoltan Schwab, University of Durham
The tradition of the spiritual senses has been an inspiration for major recent theological endeavours (like that of Karl Rahner, Hans Urs von Balthasar, and Sarah Coakley).
Many consider Origen as the “founding father” of this theological tradition. He found substantial biblical evidence for the existence of a spiritual sensation in Prov. 2:5, which, according to him, speaks of a 'divine sense.' However, this rendering differs significantly from both the MT and the LXX, which speak about 'knowledge of God.' Therefore, a venerable theological tradition seems to stem from a rather “idiosyncratic” reading of the biblical text.
This paper investigates how the translator of Origen’s text might have arrived at his/her translation. My conclusion is that although it cannot be accepted as a good translation of the Hebrew, it grasps important elements of the deeper theological structure of Prov. 2; thus, it represents a possible interpretation of the text.
|
Josephus’s Bible, His Readers, and His Sources
Program Unit: Reception of Scripture in Second Temple Literature
Daniel R. Schwartz, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
Despite Josephus’s claims about his studies as a youth in Jerusalem, and despite his claim that being a priest qualified him as an expert in the Bible, in recent decades scholars have expressed doubts about Josephus’s early knowledge of the Bible. Comparison of Josephus's Judean War, of the 70s, to his Jewish Antiquities, of the 90s, of which the first half is a paraphrase of the Bible, has led such scholars to infer that Josephus in fact had little knowledge of the Bible prior to his arrival in Rome. However, given the important role of Greek editors in the production of the Judean War, editors who strove to make the book meet the expectations of Greco-Roman readers, it is difficult to draw conclusions about Josephus’s interest in the Bible at that stage of his life. Investigation of reflections of the Bible in Josephus’s Life, which—although released in the 90s—seems to be based on a manuscript produced in the late 60s or early 70s, and which appeared without the benefit of editing by others, can therefore be an important supplement to similar inquiries that focus on the Judean War. Moreover, the fact that the Life was directed, at least originally, to a Jewish readership, can allow us a better understanding of the way Josephus took the Bible for granted when writing for insiders, as opposed to the way he related to it explicitly when writing for a Greco-Roman audience. This will, in turn, suggest a way of differentiating between passages in Antiquities meant for Gentiles and passages written originally with only Jewish readers in mind.
|
Isaac's Blessings to Jacob: Relationship and Meaning
Program Unit: Literary Features – Fact or Fiction (EABS)
Sarah Schwartz, Bar-Ilan University
Isaac’s blessings in Genesis 27:28-29 and 28:3-4 differ in language, style, and content. The former blessings relate to economic prosperity and power, while the latter relate to land and offspring, and are defined by Isaac as “Abraham’s blessing” (28:4).
The diachronic approach relates each text to a different source while the synchronic approach claims that the blessings were formulated by one author. The synchronic approach indicates that either the two passages represent different formulations of Isaac’s post-factum selection of Jacob, or the blessing in Genesis 28 expresses Isaac’s selection of Jacob, while the blessings in chapter 27 relate to the birthright. While chapter 27 indeed relates to the birthright, the notion that the blessings do not include a facet of selection is hard to accept – specifically due to the background of Isaac’s preference of Esau (25:28).
This lecture will introduce an innovative interpretation of the nature and meaning of Isaac’s blessings, and the relationship between the two episodes. My analysis is based on a literary study of the blessings with specific attention to stylistic features and context. I will demonstrate how the varying nature of the blessings reflects Isaac’s plans regarding the inheritance of each of his sons, in light of the causal link between the two episodes.
The blessings in chapter 27 are birthright blessings, reflecting the notion that both sons are included in the chosen family. The blessings in chapter 28 are the blessings of Abraham which reinforce Isaac’s perception that Esau might not be an heir. Therefore, while Esau is not overtly rejected, Jacob is distinctly chosen as an heir by Isaac, in view of the consequences of Esau's blessing, and Jacob's departure from Canaan.
The relationship between the blessings also sheds light on the reconciliation between Jacob and Esau later in the narrative (Gen. 33:1-16, 37:6-8)
|
After Exile, Under Empire: Utopian Concerns in Chronicles
Program Unit: Chronicles and Utopia (EABS)
Steven Schweitzer, Bethany Theological Seminary
As I have argued in previous publications, the book of Chronicles creates a better alternative reality, a utopia, to its present context in its depiction of Israel’s past. The function of the exile and the Persian monarchs are two concerns that the Chronicler must address in creative ways to promulgate his unique vision for Israel’s vision. Understood through a utopian lens, both concepts provide the Chronicler with an opportunity to redefine two critical pieces of Israel’s heritage: the devastation of the exile and the failure of the Davidic dynasty.
|
Teaching Science Fiction and Theology: Reflections and Possibilities
Program Unit: Science Fiction and the Bible (EABS)
Steven Schweitzer, Bethany Theological Seminary
In fall 2013, I taught a new graduate seminar for the first time, “Science Fiction and Theology.” The course discussed several SF films and television series: Star Wars, Star Trek, the Matrix trilogy, Battlestar Galactica, Firefly, and more. A wide range of theological issues and biblical connections raised in these examples of SF were examined: the nature of humanity; construction and experience of the Divine; relationships between nature and humanity, nature and the Divine, and humanity and the Divine; role of culture; gender; religion; rituals; perceptions of reality; the problem of evil; violence; use and abuse of technology; function of mythology; the concept of shalom and the creation of alternative futures; and the quest for meaning. In addition to classroom discussion, students wrote three essays and one final research paper. In this paper, I will reflect on the process of teaching this varied material—both pedagogically and in terms of its content—and student interaction and responses, providing concrete examples from the course. The depth and scope of theological investigation made possible through careful analysis of these selections from Science Fiction open up many possibilities for future research, teaching, and pedagogical considerations.
|
Anti-Judaism in Patristic Exegesis
Program Unit: Anti-Semitic Readings of the Bible
Ludger Schwienhorst-Schönberger, Universität Wien
To understand Antijudaism in Christian Theology and Church History it is necessary to realize how patristic exegesis works. Interpretation of the Bible was the kernel of patristic theology. It is a widespread opinion that exegesis of the Church-Fathers was intrinsically antijudaistic. The paper wants to enlighten an obvious and complex issue. What is and what is not „antijudaistic exegesis“?
|
Das Hohelied - Wörtlich oder Allegorisch? Zu einer Neu Aufgebrochenen Diskussion
Program Unit: The Song of Songs: Literal or Allegorical?
Ludger Schwienhorst-Schönberger, Universität Wien
In der jüdischen wie in der christlichen Tradition wurde das Hohelied beinahe durchgehend in einem allegorischen Sinn als ein Gedicht über die Liebe zwischen Gott und seinem Volk bzw. zwischen Christus und seiner Kirche verstanden. Die moderne historisch-kritische Exegese hat diese Deutung als falsch verworfen. Sie sieht im Hohelied die poetische Verdichtung erotisch-sexueller Liebe zwischen einem Mann und einer Frau. Noch bis vor wenigen Jahren galt diese Position als unumstößlich. Doch inzwischen ist der Konsens zerbrochen. Einige neuere Forschungen behaupten, dass die engen sprachlichen und motivischen Verbindungen vor allem zu prophetischen Texten darauf hindeuten, dass hier metaphorische Rede zweiten Grades vorliegt. Demnach geht es im Hohelied - wie die jüdische und christliche Tradition behaupten - um das Verhältnis zwischen Gott und seinem Volk. Der Vortrag will die Pro- und Contra-Stimmen zu Wort kommen lassen und in die Diskussion einführen (Vortrag auf Deutsch mit englischem Handout oder umgekehrt).
Weitere Referentinnen und Referenten:
Meik Gerhards: Herder und die Anfänge der historischen Kritik. Kritische Überprüfung zu einem folgenreichen Umbruch in der Exegese des Hoheliedes
Nina-Sophie Heereman: "Behold King Salomon ...!" (Song 3:11). Are there traces of inner-biblical reception history in the Song?
Gianni Barbiero: Das Hohelied - Eine Allegorie? Am Beispiel von Hld 8,5
Annette Schellenberg: The sensuality of the Song - a bridge between 'literal' and 'allegorical' interpretations
|
The Song of Songs as Lady Wisdom’s Poem for Solomon
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Wisdom
Kathleen Scott Goldingay, Fuller Theological Seminary (Pasadena)
Is the Song of Songs a manifestation of Lady Wisdom? Could the poem’s voices include personified Wisdom speaking with Solomon and Jerusalem’s Daughters about the stronghold of desire and the agony of love? The paper will analyze these questions from several angles. On the basis of a Hebrew translation that considers adding the voice of Lady Wisdom to those of the two young lovers, the daughters of Jerusalem, and/or Solomon, it will ask whether there are then phrases or words that are more straightforwardly interpreted. Second it will analyze the role that places (i.e. home, city) and motifs (wildlife, vineyards) play in the poetic language to glean any relevant metaphors, allegories, or symbols for wisdom. Are there associations or phrases that clearly relate to other wisdom literature, particularly Lady Wisdom’s personification? Third it will offer a reading analysis with various lines assigned to different characters (Lady Wisdom, Young Girl, Young Man, Solomon or a King, Jerusalem’s Daughters). Are there alternate/additional clearer meanings or plots to be identified if lines are assigned to different characters? Do the places and motifs used help clarify who is speaking? Finally some further questions will be considered: If she can reasonably be assumed as the poet, what might Lady Wisdom be conveying? Is the use of poetry significant to the meaning? Does the analysis point to the Song of Songs being reasonably included in Wisdom Literature? Is any resulting thesis that includes Lady Wisdom more plausible than a thesis that the poem portrays erotic love or that it is an analogy for God’s love?
|
The Figure David and His Importance in Ezekiel 34–37
Program Unit: Prophets
Franz Sedlmeier, Universität Augsburg
The Figure David and his Importance in Ezekiel 34-37
|
From Nebuchadnezzar to Antiochus: On the Reception of Daniel in LXX, Qumran and Targum Jonathan
Program Unit: Reception of Scripture in Second Temple Literature
Michael Segal, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
This paper will trace the reception and development of traditions that originate in the book of Daniel, which draw an analogy between Nebuchadnezzar and Antiochus. Sources to be investigated include the Old Greek version of Daniel, 4QApocryphon of Jeremiah, and Targum Jonathan to the Song of Hannah (1Sam 2:1-10).
|
Answered Lament: The Scriptures and the Gospel in Romans
Program Unit: Schriftrezeption bei Paulus und in der Paulustradition: Reception of Scripture in Paul and Pauline Tradition
Mark A. Seifrid, Southern Baptist Theological Seminary
Der Vrotrag geht darauf ein, in welcher Weise Paulus im Römerbrief – im Kontext seiner Präsentation des Evangeliums für Juden und Griechen für eine Gruppe von Christusgläubigen, die ihm weithin unbekannt ist – die Schrift und die Christusbotschaft einander interpretieren lässt. Um eine zirkuläre und so letztlich willkürliche Verhältnisbestimmung zu vermeiden, lohnt ein Rückgriff auf das klassische Modell von Verheißung und Erfüllung.
|
Midrash>Tosefta>Mishnah: General Theory of Relationship
Program Unit: Midrash, Halakhah and Reception
Friedman Shamma, Schechter Institut Jerusalem
Much of regnant scholarship during the 20th century gave Mishna (=M) primacy over Midrash Halakha (=MH) in many senses – derashot appearing in both were borrowed M ? MH; most laws originate through legal principles and are expressed abstractly in M, subsequently to be supported by derashot; literary parallels between M and MH are either independent of each other, or M is primary. Much of this however can be reversed or refined. We will touch upon these issues, while investigating deep-structure literary dependences between discrete passages of M/MH, and M's creative reshaping. Overlap relativity between the corpora and specific passages will be examined as 'curved spacetime".
|
The Emperors and the Enslaved: Sacrifice in Second-Century Ephesos
Program Unit: Early Christianity (EABS)
Katherine A. Shaner, Wake Forest University
Second-century CE Ephesos teemed with both images of the Emperor and bodies of enslaved persons. This presentation investigates the interchange between imperial authority and enslaved work in the religious imagination throughout the city. Beginning in the late first and early second centuries, architecture, public art, and inscriptions throughout Ephesos display a rhetoric of imperial authority. Sacrifice, in particular, emerges as one rhetorical subject that helps to reinforce this authority. Yet depictions of sacrifice and regulations about its mechanics mask a fuller historical picture of the roles enslaved persons took in sacrificial rites. This presentation analyzes on the one hand the so-called Parthian reliefs with an eye toward depictions of enslaved women and men. The imperial sacrifice/adoption cycle scene, in particular, instrumentalizes sacrificial personnel suggesting that the imperial men at the center of the scene orchestrate the ritual participants as extensions of their own religious power. On the other hand, inscriptions regulating sacrifices in the city deploy a different picture of what such practices should look like: ritual specialists, many of whom were enslaved, teach elite males who hold honorific priesthoods how to sacrifice. Pitting these two portraits of the proper performance of sacrifice against one another reveals a contestation around the role of enslaved ritual specialists in Ephesos.
|
The Wayward Wife (Num 5:11-31) in Latin Late Antiquity
Program Unit: The Reception of the Bible in Greco-Roman Tradition
Danuta Shanzer, Universität Wien
This paper relates to a larger historical project of mine about Late Antique and Early Medieval ordeals. It is about narrative, exegesis, textual criticism, transmission and reception. I will be concentrating on Numbers 5.11-31, the Ordeal of the Bitter Waters, and examining its fortuna in the Late Antique and Early Medieval West. The wayward wife of Numbers 5 is a familiar (though much disputed) figure in Judaism. And Mishnah Sotah and other dependent rabbinic exegesis have been extensively studied. Not so much the Greek reception (aside from Philo and Josephus). The Latin tradition is both remarkably limited and largely ignored by scholars. Only one Christian exegete spends time on it, only one surviving biblical epic poet dramatized it. No Late Antique Latin author, it would appear, mentioned the Vulgate spiritus zelotypiae (Nm. 5.14). But the OLB variants (which are significant and interesting) can be captured through the lemmata of Augustine’s Locutiones and Questiones Numerorum, and were defended by Cassiodorus. And two apocrypha, the famous Protevangelium Jacobi and the less well-known Liber de ortu beatae Mariae (a.k.a. Gospel of Pseudo-Matthew) both transmit versions of the ordeal. Some debates originating in the rabbinic exegesis may have occasionally made their way over to the Latin West. And it is here that I hope to make a contribution by studying textual transmission as well as narrative transformation both to shed light upon the reception of the Bitter Waters Ordeal itself and on the some of the few texts that discussed or deployed it.
|
The Anarchistic Philosophy of Don Isaac Abarbanel
Program Unit: Judaica
Amnon Shapira, Ariel University of Samaria
There is a marked positive tradition in Judaism in relation to a king in Israel, but along with this tradition is another voice, which negates the monarchy and prefers community over state. I have written a book on this topic (Jewish Religious Anarchism) and here I will present one of its chapters.
Abarbanel (1437-1509) served as state treasurer of Spain. After the expulsion from Spain (1492) he found refuge in Italy, where he also served in high-ranking economic positions. It seems that this life history brought him to write his known commentary on the Bible, in which he sharply criticized monarchical rule in Israel. A number of researchers (such as Leo Strauss and Warren Harvey) claim that Abarbanel was "the most definitely anti-political Jewish thinker of the Middle Ages and the Renaissance," as he opposed the centralized state in principle and suggested instead the democratic republic, such as that of Napoli.
In his commentary he probed the sin of "the generation of dispersion" and found that it was the sin of one human ruling over another. His viewpoint was: if humankind would receive the power to rule, they would never be satisfied with what they had and would always strive to increase their power and to gain control over others. Later in the century his contemporary, Rabbi Ovadia Sforno, who studied in Rome University, wrote a commentary on the Bible, in which his view negated in principle the sovereign state. Recently, in a doctoral dissertation, written by Menachem Ratson (of the Department of Politics and Government at Ben Gurion University of the Negev), it was proven that Rabbi Abraham ibn Ezra (1089-1164), a Spanish sage who wrote a comprehensive commentary on the Bible, also espoused an "anarchistic" position, by negating in principle the centralized rule of a king.
|
Bless You! Mission as Blessing in the Letter of 1 Peter
Program Unit: Catholic Epistles
David M. Shaw, University of Exeter
One of the debates in modern 1 Peter scholarship has focused on the nature of the church's stance towards the world that the letter's author proposes. This was most starkly presented in the now infamous Balch-Elliott debate during the 1980's. Balch suggested that the Haustafel presented in 1 Peter was a move towards assimilation with the greater culture which in turn assisted the church in its wider witness. Elliott, focusing on the language of paroikoi and parepidemoi, argued almost the exact opposite; that such language was designed to develop a sense of corporate identity in order to resist any social pressure to assimilate. This debate within Petrine scholarship has since moved on to ask questions concerning how passive or active the church ought to be with regard to its mission in the world, e.g, Volf's "Soft Difference," Green's notion of "holy engagement," and Tárrech's "attractive community" ideal, to name but a few. And whilst it is unsurprising that many of the aforementioned articles interact with 1 Peter's theme of "doing good" (see 2:12-15, 20; 3:11-13; 4:19, etc.), one significant o mission in the discussion has been any talk of blessing, i.e., "bless, for to this you were called, that you may obtain a blessing" (3:9 ESV). It is towards this gap in the discussion that this paper seeks to make a contribution. Underlying the importance of 3:9 is its placement within the conclusion of the Haustafel that is addressed to the whole church (3:8ff). By utilizing insights from Social Identity Theory and the current missional theology conversation, I suggest that more than simply "doing good", Peter is calling on the Anatolian churches to actively seek the blessing and prosperity of their unbelieving neighbors-even as they face opposition from them-regardless of whether or not they convert to the faith.
|
Prophecy, Power, & Law: From Moses to Moses
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Richard Sherwin, Bar-Ilan University
Moses is the only lawgiving prophet in the Tanach. All subsequent prophets critique what they see as divinely revealed failures of the Israelites to fulfill their obligations of covenant with Gd according to Moses' laws. In addition, some consider Israelite failures as contributing to the various historical national crises --resulting in catastrophe or salvation -- of their time and place.
Since both Moses' laws and the prophetic messages claim their authority and powers from the same Gd, any conflicts between them may reveal interesting differences existing within the community's understanding of its customary behavior as covenanted with Gd and as sufficient for Divine favor, help, and salvation. The later prophets, or the Tanach's representation of them, show some also considered the contexts -- social and legal -- into which their prophecies and critiques would be understood. So there is always a query as to how much of the divine message the individual prophet has modified to his perception of what the people will willingly hear.
The prophets and prophecies I wish to discuss are: Bilaam, Elijah, Elisha, Jonah, and, tangentially, some aspects of Jesus prophecy.
|
Ideology of Separation in the Abraham Narrative
Program Unit: Stylistics and the Hebrew Bible
Zvi Shimon, Bar-Ilan University
Biblical scholarship has traditionally explained the role of "rejected" characters in Genesis in etiological terms. The Lot narrative and the birth of his offspring Moab and Ben-Ammi are understood as etiological narratives geared towards explaining the source of the two neighboring Transjordanian nations - the Ammonites and the Moabites. Esau's character is understood as explaining the roots of the southern Edomite nation. This paper proposes that ideology and not etiology is the key to understanding Genesis's references to characters identified as eventually pertaining to different non-Israelite nations. An ideology of separation and a desire to distinguish clearly between populations living in proximity with the Israelites underpins these narratives. The paper will focus on the role of some of the "non-Israelite" characters interspersed in the Abraham-Lot narrative including Terah and Lot and his offspring in light of this ideology of separation and distinction. The paper will claim that the Abraham-Lot narrative is best understood in ideological terms. Moreover, this ideological perspective can provide an explanation for the intriguing inclusion of Terah's journey within the Abraham narrative. This journey which opens the extended Abraham cycle of narratives and which seems to parallel and foreshadow Abraham's calling and journey is not merely part of an itinerary tracking Abraham's progress towards the land of Canaan; rather, it is motivated by an ideology of separation underlying the Genesis narrative in general, and the Abraham-Lot narrative, in particular.
|
John's Ethics Revisited
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Sookgoo Shin, University of Cambridge
With a recent publication of Rethinking the Ethics of John (ed. Van der Watt and Zimmermann), John's ethics has finally received its due attention from Johannine scholars. Scholarly interest on John's ethics is, however, quiet recent and just emerging that there is no consensus either on the appropriate method or the appropriate subject matter including the definition of 'ethics'. To further our understanding in John's ethics, we cannot simply borrow the meaning of ethics from a dictionary or modern ethical textbooks because they do not fully take into account of the unique genre and theological/christological foundations upon which the Gospel of John was written. Thus I suggest the definition of ethics as follows: "the conscious outworking of one's worldview (which influences one's thinking, attitude, and thus behaviour towards God and other human beings) that is defined and transformed by one's personal encounter with Jesus Christ and the Christ event, and which further enables one to imitate Jesus." In this definition we are faced with two important questions; (1) how does John shape his readers' worldview?; (2) what are the essential ethical traits that John wants his readers to embody? In this paper I will argue that John uses the literary device, misunderstanding, especially in chs.1-12 to challenge the readers to come to terms with the identity of Jesus and to reevaluate their old religious convictions in light of new insights gained from the Johannine characters' misunderstandings of Jesus' words (2:20; 3:4, 9; 4:10-15; 4:31-34;6:32-35, 52,etc.). Then I will further investigate how one's transformed worldview enables one to imitate Jesus largely in three aspects (love/unity (13:34-35; 17:11); missions (17:18; 20:21); one's response to the State (18:36)).
|
Double-voiced Words on the Davidic Kingship under the Imperial Control
Program Unit: Bible and Empire
SuJung Shin, Independent Scholar
In exploring the complexity of the topic of the Davidic monarchy and the empire in the Deuteronomistic History (DH), this paper visualizes the interrelations of space, time, social context, characters and readers in the DH through the process of “dialogization.” In this paper, the main question is not what the DH as a singular utterance from the speaker’s perspective may have addressed to the audience under the condition of the Babylonian exile; rather, the question is how the participation of the audience helps to reconceive an utterance that is continuously double-voiced and multi-voiced in the midst of the Babylonian imperial control.
The audience’s everyday life would be extensively shaped by the social and political hardships of community suffering an identity crisis under the thumb of empire. Some might hope that a Davidic ruler as a political leader would soon save their community, and that the glory of the Davidic kingship would ultimately return to Judah. Other exiles might want to remain in the land of Babylon and learn how to live peaceably rather than in collision with the Babylonians. Many who remained in Judah would still suffer every day from the ruins of the war and the devastations of the “promised” land without enough food, clothing, shelter, and, most of all, without hope of recovery. Others in Judah might desperately wait for the restoration of the land and of the kingdom. Still others might be content to subsist in a colony without presence of the noble class. This paper examines how the search for and creation of communal identity relates to the polemical notion of monarchy and empire, given the absence and promises of the Davidic monarchy in facing the imperial control.
|
Ta tou theou vs. ta ton anthropon: Apocalyptic Discourse as Social Discourse in Mark
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Elizabeth Shively, University of St. Andrews
Most critical scholars who analyze social dimensions of the Gospel of Mark’s apocalyptic discourse employ social scientific models to locate Mark’s first-century audience, and claim that the gospel was written to those suffering social marginalization under ruling elites. Alternatively, this study employs literary analysis and metaphor theory to investigate how apocalyptic discourse functions as persuasive rhetoric to shape the identity of a community. I argue that the rhetoric of the narrative intends to combat the danger of misunderstanding Jesus’ call to discipleship and consequently becoming alienated from him and his true followers.
Rather than reading the text as a reflection of the social status of the intended audience, I look for the nature of the ideal audience produced by the narrative. I do this in three steps: (1) I consider how the narrative describes discipleship in terms of family/household-terminology, which implies a restructuring of this social concept in Mediterranean antiquity. I demonstrate that this familial metaphor and its rhetoric is set within the framework of apocalyptic discourse. (2) I demonstrate that the climax of the pericope 8:27-33 (ta tou theou vs. ta ton anthropon inpired by Satan) functionally and rhetorically structures Mark 8:27-10:45. Throughout this unit, apocalyptic discourse functions through narration and characterization to encourage certain attitudes and behaviors among those who wish to belong to Jesus’ fictive kinship group. (3) I consider hermeneutical implications of the relationship between the world of the narrative and the world in front of the narrative.
|
Did Peter Speak Hebrew to the Servant? A Linguistic Examination of the Expression 'I do not know what you are saying' (Matt 26:70; Mk 14:68; Lk 22:60)
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Eran Shuali, Université de Strasbourg
In response to the servant’s accusation that he is one of Jesus’s men, Peter utters, according to the three Synoptic Gospels, the words: I do not know what you are saying. In this paper, I first wish to closely examine the pragmatic function of this expression in the Gospels and its different forms in the Greek of the Evangelists. Subsequently, I will study the parallel expression found in the rabbinic literature (m. Šebu. 8:3, 6; t. B. Qam. 7:3; 8:2, 3). Based on this data, I will then put to the test three hypotheses pertaining to the origin of the Greek expression of the Gospels: Was it an idiomatic expression in Koiné Greek introduced by the authors of the Gospels? Was it a literal translation of the Hebrew expression attested in the early rabbinic sources? Does it derive from an Aramaic expression that may also have been behind the Hebrew expression known to us? Finally, I will try to show that the second of these hypotheses is the most plausible, i.e., that the above mentioned words spoken by Peter most likely reflect a Hebrew expression.
In the light of this observation, I would like to conclude by reconsidering some of the most debated questions relating to the Synoptic Gospels and their historical background: Was Hebrew used as a spoken language in the First Century AD? Which languages were used by the historical figures portrayed in the Gospels and on which occasions? What was the nature of the traditions about Jesus and his disciples that have been gathered by the authors of the Synoptic Gospels? And in which ways have they reworked these traditions?
|
Ancient Scribalism: Re-imagining of the Micah Prophecies
Program Unit: Prophets
Anna Sieges, Baylor University
From the time of Bernhard Stade, scholars generally have recognized Mic 1–3 as the earliest unit in Micah. For many years scholars conceived of this unit as originating with the eighth century prophet while the remainder of Micah belonged to later centuries. Hans Walter Wolff was the first to suggest deuteronomistic updates to Micah 1–3 as a project of the exilic period. Later scholars such as James Nogalski, Aaron Schart and Jakob Wöhrle have followed Wolff’s observation of a deuteronomistic layer in Micah 1–3 and suggested redactional models of their own. These redactional models lack a substantial consideration of ancient scribal practices. This paper will consider the prophetic and scribal groups that formed Micah 1–3. It will argue that there are two primary levels in Mic 1–3. The earliest level dates to the time of Micah (eighth century) and his prophetic cohort (1:8, 10–15*, 2:1–11, 3:1–12). After the destruction of Jerusalem, Micah’s eighth century prophecy that Jerusalem would be destroyed (cf. Mic 3:12) received renewed interest and was reinterpreted by deuteronomistic groups who completed the second level of Mic 1–3 by attaching a new introduction to the collection of Mican sayings (1:1, 3–7, 9, 12b, 13b, 16). These updates reframe Mic 1–3 by suggesting that Micah’s prophecies were the correct prediction of Jerusalem’s destruction in 587 BCE. This evaluation of the process by which Mic 1–3 was formed will take into account the most recent scholarship on ancient scribal practices. It will incorporate Jörg Jeremias, David Carr, and Karel van der Toorn’s recent work on scribalism in the Hebrew Bible. By considering these valuable contributions to scholarly understanding of ancient scribalism, the paper will shed new light on the process by which Mic 1–3 was formed and add to the ongoing conversation about the redaction of Micah.
|
"Practise these things by day and night!" Pistis as Attitude between Paul and Hellenistic Philosophy
Program Unit: Graeco-Roman Society (EABS)
Suzan Sierksma-Agteres, University of Groningen
Whereas pistis (belief, conviction) is often assumed to be only a technical, low-level epistemological category in ancient philosophy, the notion of pistis also plays a significant role in the central endeavour of philosophical schools throughout the Hellenistic age, that is, gaining a good fundamental attitude or êthos. Epicureans, for example, envisage knowledge and understanding as subservient to character transformation driven by a firm conviction (pistis bebaios). A remarkably similar position is taken up by Cicero, who deems it the task of philosophy to offer a certain kind of knowledge which he names confidence (fidentia). Reversely, the preacher’s or teacher’s êthos is constitutive for his trustworthiness or credibility. In Aristotle’s Rhetoric, êthos is considered the most persuasive of the three kinds of proof (pistis). The Stoics focus on the personality of the wise, the ultimate example of a reliable (pistos) person. Thus, in this interplay between êthos and pistis, a common concern present in diverse Hellenistic schools can be distinguished. It is precisely in this life-transforming aspect, that Hellenistic philosophy and the Pauline letters share a common ground. Moreover, it is through this shared vocabulary that we may understand Paul’s use of pistis in a less cognitive or fideistic light. By discussing Pauline pistis in view of the ancient philosophical understandings of êthos, this paper aims to contribute to the mapping of the intellectual landscape inhabited by both early Christianity and Hellenistic philosophy.
|
Text und Textgeschichte des Buches Josua (LXX) im Spiegel der altlateinischen Kirchenväterzitate und Textzeugen
Program Unit: Septuagint Studies
Marcus Sigismund, Protestant University Wuppertal
Als zumeist unmittelbare Übersetzung aus dem LXX-Text sind die altlateinischen Zitate der Kirchenväter neben den spärlichen Überresten der handschriftlichen altlateinischen Überlieferung wichtige Zeugen der Textgeschichte des Buches Josua. Insbesondere die patristischen Zitate ermöglichen es, für verschiedene Lesarten chronologische und geographische Ankerpunkte der Verbreitung zu setzen, und so vielfach wichtige Indizien für die textgeschichtliche Verortung von Varianten und in weiterer Konsequenz von Textformen zu sammeln. Sie erweitern dabei das von griechischen Kirchenvätern gebotene Zeugnis in nicht geringem Maße.
Der Beitrag möchte diese Möglichkeit an einigen typischen Beispielen aufzeigen und hiervon ausgehend textgeschichtliche Folgerungen diskutieren. Diese betreffen zum einen die Charakterisierung der sog. ägyptischen Rezension, als auch das Verhältnis dieser Textform zur syrisch-antiochenischen Rezension, in der dem altlateinischen codex Lugdunensis traditionell eine herausragende Zeugenstellung beigemessen wird.
|
Slave Manumission and Social Power: Recovering the Political Subtext of Jeremiah 34
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Law
Edward Silver, Wellesley College
The three corpora of manumission laws in the Pentateuch attest to an implicit legal controversy over the superordinate authority by which a contract of debt servitude is dissolved. The Covenant Code grounds this authority in the microeconomy of the family and the patriarchal head of household. The Holiness Code and the Deuteronomic law each in its own way repositions this power in relation to temple institutions and bureaucratic structures. This essay posits that we have in Jer 34 the trace of a third way of conceptualizing this legal authority, one that grounds the transition of status from slave to free in the sovereign will of the monarch. Considering a range of comparative classical and ancient Near Eastern evidence, and critical political theorizing on slavery, I argue that the historical event which lies at the root of this episode involved the assertion of sovereignty by a newly crowned king through the exercise of a power to dissolve slave contracts. The core motivation behind Zedekiah’s derôr was not ethical or pragmatic, as have been variously claimed. Rather, it was a means of declaring a new political order and redefining the basis for political association more generally. By analyzing the rhetorical structure of the Jeremian oracles which are embedded within the densely layered text of Jer 34 and by coordinating these with the prophet's theorizing on kingship and social power elsewhere in his poetry, it is possible to recover some of the lost juridical and sociopolitical context for an historical event which has been thoroughly reframed in the canon-formation process.
|
Epictetus and Paul: Listening to the Voices
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Margaret G. Sim, SIL International
Literature on the use of diatribe in the Graeco-Roman world is well known. I build on this to examine the use of representation of the thoughts of others, real or imputed, and how this is marked or implied in the text.The Letter to the Romans will be examined alongside the Discourses of Epictetus as recorded by his disciple Arrian. In the Corinthian letters it has been recognised that Paul regularly reflects the beliefs of others to which he himself does not subscribe. The interpretative challenge is to identify whose voice we are hearing and the implied author's response to that voice.The editor of the Discourses frequently adds quotation marks to make such representation clear bu in the original text such aids were lacking. I suggest that by listening to the representation of different 'voices' in the Discourses we may identify interpretative strategies which work well in our anaysis of Romans.A modern theory of communication called Relevance Theory will be adduced to give support to this study but jargon will be avoided.
|
Conditional Clauses in Koine: A Fresh Approach
Program Unit: Hellenistic Greek Language and Linguistics
Margaret G. Sim, SIL International
Work on conditional sentences in Koine has focused largely on syntax in identifying 'types' of condition using either temporal forms or moods to elucidate the relationship between protasis and apodosis. Recent linguistic approaches to conditionals in English (Noh 2000) have taken account of the role of metarepresentation in the construction of the protasis in particular, giving a more satisfactory and unified account of widely differing types of 'if' clause. I propose to demonstrate the relevance for exegesis of such an approach in linking syntax with inferences by drawing out the metarepresentation implicit in conditionals in the Koine. Porter (1992) has suggested that a 'more flexible approach' is needed and I hope to provide this. Examples will be drawn from the New Testamet and also pagan Greek.
|
Paul’s Christos Ontology: The Theological Significance of Sun-, Sug- and Sum- Prefixes in Romans
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
William A. Simmons, Lee University
Throughout his epistle to the Romans, Paul advances a new ontological reality in Christ. He accomplishes this by skilfully employing a number of prefixes (e.g. sun, sug, and sum) that define the faith-union of the believer with his/her Lord. All of this constitutes a theological solidarity whereby the faithful are drawn into the identity and experiences of Christ. Thus for Paul, the end time community constitutes a new ontological reality in the midst of falleness. As such it recapitulates the suffering ~ death ~ glory paradigm of Jesus in the here and now (Rom 6:4-14, 8:17 & 29-30, 12:2). Moreover, this “already” of the Kingdom has more work to do, not only in the life of the Church, but also in the very fabric of existence as a whole. This is true because Paul sees the eschatological gift of the Spirit (Rom 8:23; cf. also vs. 14-17) as setting in motion a theological trajectory that will ultimately affect the entire cosmos (Rom 8:18-22).
|
International Law as a Political Phenomenon: Legal Autonomy at Elephantine and Yehud in the Persian Period
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Law
Brandon J. Simonson, Boston University
The unified administrative practices of the Persian king Darius, while wide-reaching, primarily encompassed the realm of tribute collection, leaving most legal matters in the hands of the local authorities. This paper examines international law as a political phenomenon during the height of the Persian Empire, using extant texts including the documents from Elephantine and the Hebrew Bible, in order to make conclusions about the legal autonomy of each community. Royal law in the Persian Empire, according to Pierre Briant, should be read within the realm of politics. In the analysis of the political nature of Persian royal law, this paper considers the legal and political theory of Giorgio Agamben, primarily Agamben's work on the sovereign. It is concluded, consequently, that locally prevailing law was allowed to flourish in these contexts and, following Briant, that no single legal paradigm was applied to every nation by the Persians. As long as political loyalty was maintained, provinces would retain the ability to make and enforce law. The extant literature from Elephantine and Yehud demonstrates this legal autonomy when analyzed together: each locality develops laws in accordance with both local and neighboring traditions. Specific examples of differences in each location's treatment of criminal law during this time illustrate the distinct trajectories each community took after being granted a degree of legal autonomy by the Persian Empire. Ultimately, the relationship between Persia and its surrounding territories was guided by a political imperial mandate, but legal matters were handled on a case by case basis according to the prevailing legal traditions of local authorities.
|
Wisdom in the Q Tradition
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Thathathai Singsa, University of Melbourne
What does Q say about Wisdom and what is the relationship between Jesus and Wisdom in this tradition?
It is necessary to discuss the following texts: Q 7:18-35 (Lk 7:18-35//Mt 11:2-19); Q 11:49 (Lk 11:49//Mt 23:34); Q 13:34-35 (Lk 13:34-35//Mt 23:37-39); Q 10:21-22 (Lk 10:21-22//Mt 11:25-26) and Q 11:31 (Lk 11:31//Mt 12:42). The particular texts of Q 7:18-35 (Lk 7:18-35//Mt 11:2-19) and Q 11:49 (Lk 11:49//Mt 23:34) are of most importance for determining the figure of Wisdom in this source.
The study will conclude that the Q tradition witnesses a major development in the inclusion of Sophia in the Christian tradition. The figure of Wisdom emerges as a central character in the Sayings Source. She is the one who sends the prophets, including John the Baptist and Jesus. Sophia adopts a motherly, protective role for her ‘children’ as they, like her in the past, experience rejection and opposition. Q demarcates strongly between the identities of Wisdom and Jesus; Jesus is perhaps her greatest representative since he is greater than John the Baptist, Jonah and even Solomon. In this capacity Jesus also shares a special relationship with God the Father, and in some respects he plays some of the roles traditionally attributed to Wisdom. So in presenting Jesus in this way the Q tradition was itself moving towards a Wisdom Christology, but this is not certain. As far as we can reconstruct this source, Q betrays strong Wisdom influences but not yet a clear Wisdom Christology. Once Sophia became associated with the Jesus tradition, further developments would follow. Since Mark never refers to the person of Jesus as ‘Wisdom’, it may have been developed by one of his redactors, Matthew.
|
The Reception of the Hebrew Bible/Septuagint in Patristic Bible Interpretation (2nd–8th Centuries)
Program Unit:
Agnethe Siquans, Universität Wien
Biblical interpretation is a central feature of patristic literature. Commentaries, homilies, letters, moral and systematic treatises and others are full of biblical quotations and allusions and argue on the basis of scriptural texts. Christian writers are convinced of the unity of the Christian Bible including the New Testament. Their interpretation of the Hebrew Bible/Septuagint intends to prove this unity as well as the fulfilling of the biblical prophecies in Christ and the Church. Therefore, finding, establishing, and interpreting intertextual connections and correlations between Old and New Testament texts, interpreting scriptura per scripturam, is one of the most widely used methods of patristic interpretation. This lecture will exemplarily elucidate this method, its process and its theological implications.
|
Excavating Bethsaida: Archaeological Documentation of Religious Life
Program Unit: Ancient Near East
Ilona Skupinska-Lovset, Uniwersytet Lódzki
Since the commencement of the scientific excavation in 1987, Bethsaida
rose to become one of the most important archaeological sites which is
investigated at present. While exploring the tell which was inhabited at
least from the early Bronze Age (3050 BCE - 2700 BCE) to the Middle Ages
(ca. 500 - 1500 CE) various remnants of human activities have been
disclosed. They reflected not only the daily survival of the inhabitants
but have in cases brought an insight into the religious life of the
community or its single representatives. Most striking was the discovery
of the cult place at the city gate, dating to the Iron Age and connected
with the city of Geshur. The question of interpretation of the cult place,
one of the best preserved in the region, and the kind of offerings
performed here is still discussed, as Rami Arav proposes a water ceremony
instead of the commonly accepted incense ceremony. Close to the altar,
inside the city gate, liturgical vessels have been found. Some were
inscribed carrying a symbol very similar to the sign of the Phoenician
goddess Tanit.
In the Persian and the subsequent Hellenistic and Roman periods close to
the Iron Age high place a sanctuary with a temple of the Phoenician type
was constructed. Terracotta figurines discovered during excavations in the
temple area together with remains of solid inventory such as a basin with
a channel for leading away the fluids, a possible offering place and
ceremonial benches suggest such identification. An analogy may be found in
the Phoenician city of Tyre.
The usage of the same area for apparently religious purposes through such
an extended period of time indicates a tradition in the interpretation of
this specific spot as holy.
|
How Differently We See the Lady: A Psychological Profile of Ruth in Christian and Judaic Tradition
Program Unit: Psychological Hermeneutics of Biblical Themes and Texts
Cecilie Skupinska-Løvset, Akershus University Hospital - Norway
The story of Ruth is a high drama that tells a story of kindness, sacrifice, dependence and selflessness. Looking at this story through the prism of psychological profiling a few tips and strategies that may help researchers better understand the character of Ruth come to mind.
People are complex. They have many different factors that make up their personality such as emotional, attitudinal, and behavioral response patterns. But when it comes to the study of a biblical character, the way the narrative portrays their deeds is key. The words chosen to describe the figure in question can some times change how one sees and understands their deeds.
|
A Prophet Contest: Jeremiah 28 Reconsidered
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible/Old Testament/Ancient Israel Studies (EABS)
Klaas Smelik, Universiteit Gent
Where chapters 26 and 36 of the book of Jeremiah describe how the prophet's life is threatened, in chapter 28 it is his honour and his credibility that are at stake. Chapter 28 is an important chapter in the book of Jeremiah because it embarks on the difficult problem of how to make a distinction between true and false prophecy. The authors want to convince the readers that listening to the wrong prophet will lead to the complete destruction and disappearance of the kingdom of Judah. In chapter 28, they do this in a very intriguing way. They postpone the outcome of their story deliberately in order to mislead the readers. Not to deceive them but in order to teach them not to put their trust in a prophet who enjoys temporary success by prophesying what his audience wants to hear. Special attention will be paid to the literary structure of Hananiah's prophecy in verses 2-4 and that of his second prophecy in verse 11, to the ambiguities in Jeremiah's reaction in verses 6-9, and to the difference between the MT and the LXX in regard to the designation of Hananiah, in the MT as 'nabi', in the LXX as 'pseudoprophetes'. Also the question as to why Jeremiah does not react after Hananiah's second prophecy will be discussed. This investigation will contribute to a better understanding of the relationship between narrative art and ideological message in the book of Jeremiah.
|
In Search of Real Circumcision: Ritual Failure and Circumcision in Paul
Program Unit: Male Circumcision: Between Controversy and Tradition (EABS)
Peter-Ben Smit, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam
In this paper, I discuss Paul’s remarks about the circumcision of the male foreskin from the perspective of the study of “ritual failure.” This approach, which originates from the broader field of ritual studies and ritual criticism, which is slowly making an impact on the study of the New Testament, has not been used in relation to these texts yet, even though they clearly discuss something, i.e. circumcision, that constitutes a flawed or deficient ritual for Paul. This paper will argue that Paul does not so much abolish circumcision, as it is often (popularly, but also scholarly) thought, but rather argues for a different understanding of what real circumcision is, something that had, indeed, roots in early Judaism as well, which is (yet another) reason to frame the debate on circumcision in Paul’s letters emphatically as intra-Jewish. Thus, a changed ritual praxis, in the sense of the performance of an identity, is the result is the result of Paul’s thinking and writing, not its abolition; identity also continues to be carved into the flesh, only in a different way.
|
Canonical Exegesis in Theory and Practice: A Comparative Approach
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
Peter-Ben Smit, VU University Amsterdam/Utrecht University
By a variety of canonical exegetes, such as Childs, Sanders, Stuhlmacher, and Ratzinger, the canon is appealed to as a hermeneutical tool. This paper asks the question: how do these exegetes understand the notion of "canon" precisely and how is it reflected in their actual exegesis of texts. By relating the canonical theory of these scholars to examples of their exegetical practice light is shed on both their understanding and use of the canon in exegesis and by comparing them to one another, additional insight is gained in the functioning of the canon in four distinct canonical approaches. The paper will use examples from the exegesis of the canonical Gospels of the four scholars to compare their exegetical practices to one another.
|
Concentration on the Divine and Divine Inspiration in the Arts: St. George, St. Luke, and St. Jerome at the Kunsthistoriches Museum, Vienna
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Culture
Lyndsey Smith, University of York
Exodus 20:4 declares that "Thou shalt not make to thyself a graven thing, nor the likeness of any thing that is in heaven above, or in the earth beneath, nor of those things that are in the waters under the earth." In direct contrast to this biblical precedent, however, throughout the centuries Christianity has enjoyed a near obsession with the creation and veneration of artistic works that depict the holy, saintly, and sacred in a variety of mediums and stylistic trends. The focus of this paper will be upon the theological considerations of concentration on and inspiration from the Divine depicted within the arts. Analyzing the differing artistic standpoints and examining the stylistic and iconographic contexts an d details will reveal how the artists simultaneously acknowledged theological debate concerning the making of images and promoted the status of artist and the depiction of the holy as part of religious veneration. Specifically to the nature of this conference's venue, I will highlight those images which exemplify the arguments within this paper, namely: the St Gregory with Scribes ninth century ivory tablet, St Luke Painting the Madonna by Jan Gossaert (c. 1515 - 25), and the St Jerome painting by Guido Reni (c. 1634 - 35), all belonging to the Kunsthistoriches Museum in Vienna. While seemingly on different ends of the spectrum due to differences in artistic medium, it is rather the subject matter that is focused on within this paper, as St Gregory, St Luke and St Jerome were all involved in a series of events that are to be considered both as concentrating on, and being influenced by, the Divine, aptly captured by their respective artists.
|
Under Construction: The Making, Masking, and Maneuvering of a Judean Political Activist in Daniel 1
Program Unit: Bible and Empire
Terry Ann Smith, New Brunswick Theological Seminary
As a critique of cultural and ideological hegemony, the book of Daniel has earned its reputation as resistance literature, placing in full view the social and historical conditions attending imperial domination and subjugation. In Daniel 1, the marginalization of Jewish identity and religious heritage brought about through imperial domination and cultural assimilation together with the possible complicity on the part of Jewish officials and religious leaders gives rise to a dissenting voice, Daniel, an exiled Judean living and working in a foreign court. This paper examines the genesis of Daniel as a political activist, from his earliest defiance as a youth to his subversive critique of imperial oppression and condemnation of Jewish religious leadership. In Daniel 1, the protagonist Daniel emerges as a herald of social change and transformation, contesting hegemonic power and the dominant religious authorities of his day. In this, Daniel resembles contemporary political activists, such as W. E. B. DuBois, Malcolm X, and Nelson Mandela, whose refusal to bow to aggressive imperialistic systems of aggression and discrimination would allow others to stand.
|
Imitation of “We” Passages in Acts? Canonical Influence and the Narrator of the Acts of John
Program Unit: Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha
Julia Snyder, University of Edinburgh
This paper explores an instance of “canonical influence” on the interpretation of extra-canonical texts through an evaluation of scholarly hypotheses regarding the internal (first person) narrator of the Acts of John. It will be argued that the typical scholarly characterization of internal (first person) narration in the Acts of John as “sporadic” constitutes a misreading of the text that results from the influence of scholarly study of the canonical Acts of the Apostles on interpretation of the Acts of John. Questions of literary dependence, genre, and the motivation for employing internal narration will also be considered in the same light.
|
Biblical Criticism in the light of a Program of Decolonisation
Program Unit: Political Biblical Criticism
Gerrie Snyman, University of South Africa
This paper will focus on the role of Biblical Criticism when a decolonial perspective is utilised as a discursive model within the South African context as part of the Global South. The question is whether there is a place for Biblical Studies if the decolonial critique of Christianity’s role in coloniality is as radical as Ramon Grosfoguel, Maldonado-Torres and Walter Mignolo portray it. For example, what will a decolonial reading of the Book of Esther entail, or is reading the Biblical text anathema within decolonial critique? The paper will proceed as follows (with the Book of Esther as the object of research): (a) exploration of the meaning of “coloniality” and the “decolonial turn”; (b) decolonialty’s radical critique of Christianity’s role in proclaiming “universality” in its various guises; (c) a search for a role for the biblical scholar (in my case, Old Testament scholar) in terms of (i) a non-universal Christianity and (ii) over against a provincialized Eurocentric perspective on what constitutes the discipline properly (iii) within a specific geographical space in the Global South.
|
“Utopia where it is to be hoped the coffee is a little less sour"? Dr Who’s “Utopia” and Chronicles
Program Unit: Chronicles and Utopia (EABS)
Gerrie Snyman, University of South Africa
In the third series of Dr Who, in the third episode titled “Utopia” the antagonist (Yana) defines utopia at the insistence of the hero, Dr Who, as “We can't know. A colony, a city, some sort of haven? The Science Foundation created the Utopia Project thousands of years ago to preserve mankind, to find a way of surviving beyond the collapse of reality itself. Now perhaps they found it. Perhaps not.” Here, utopia is some kind of ideal state people can escape to in the face of a pending catastrophe, but it is always elusive since it is a construction of the human genius.
Utopia as a heuristic key for reading Chronicles presupposes an apocalypse the Chronicler needs to escape from as well as a story world into which he can escape. In that story world, for example, one finds inclusivity with an Israel comprising the twelve tribes as well as the sojourners of the land, and continuity from the early beginnings up to the Davidic dynasty (Japhet).
But utopia implies the lived reality in the world of text production is something quite different. If the utopian picture of Yehudite history entails unity, grandeur, comprehensiveness, and kingship, the lived reality is apparently disunity, poverty, dullness, gloominess and no kingship.
This paper Chronicles will be read with the notion of utopia as exploited in Dr Who. The paper will start with a reflection on the meaning of utopia in Dr Who, followed by a critical engagement with the Chronicler’s story in terms of utopia. The paper will then enquire into the lived reality within the Chronicler’s world of text production in order to delineate socio-historical aspects that may help the reader to draw a link between utopia, pending apocalypse, and the lived reality of the Chronicler.
|
Allusions to Ritual in Pauline Calendric Texts in light of the Gospel
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Mxolisi Michael Sokupa, Helderberg College / Stellenbosh University
There are some Pauline texts that allude to calendric ritual (Rom 14:5, 6; Gal 4:10; Col 2:16, 17). The aim of this paper is to examine these texts in light of the gospel message as presented in the Pauline writings. These texts relate to the Old Testament calendars that gave structure to the religious experience of the people of God. The gospel in Pauline writings is presented in a theological transition between an old system that is represented by old religious symbols and rituals and a new system that is represented by new symbols and rituals. It is in this context that this paper seeks to understand the relationship between the Gospel and the allusions to calendric rituals. Ritual theory and Biblical typology will be among the methods that will be combined in this investigation in an attempt to understand the calendric rituals in the light of the Gospel. This study will be of benefit to communities that face a similar type of transition when they are confronted with the Gospel message.
|
Josephus and Christ in Ben-Hur
Program Unit: The Reception of the Bible in Greco-Roman Tradition
Jon Solomon, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
Despite its Christian emphasis, the 1959 version of Ben-Hur derives to a large extent from the life and works of Josephus. The author of the original novel, General Lew Wallace, had begun writing a novel in 1873 about an ancient Jew, using the life of Josephus (Roman prisoner, shipwrecked, freed) as a template for the life of Judah Ben-Hur, including Simonides, the name of Josephus’ son, as the name for Judah’s faithful slave. Josephus also describes in some detail the career of Judas of Galilee, and in the novel Judah’s aspirations lead to becoming an anti-Roman soldier like Judas, who is mentioned in the novel several times. The major events in the 1959 film still echo the life of Josephus, and, like Judas of Galilee, Judah still represents an anti-Roman Zealot in his initial quarrel with Messala and post-chariot race conversation with Pontius Pilate.
As a result of a discussion about religion with Robert Ingersoll in 1876, Wallace changed the course of his novel by making the young Jewish rebel an eyewitness to the passion of Christ, also inventing their fictional encounter at a well in Galilee. For almost two decades Wallace would not grant anyone permission to dramatize his work for fear they would disrespect the image of Christ, and this stipulation was continued by his son Henry Wallace when he sold the screen rights to Erlanger twenty years later. Erlanger insisted upon the same when MGM made the first film version in 1925. Producer Irving Thalberg in turn insisted on showing Christ’s hand and arm in the film, and this tradition was adapted for the 1959 film, where a powerful scene takes place at the well, the camera featuring the bewildered expression of the Roman centurion who gazes into Jesus’ face.
|
The Text of Philemon in 9th-Century Greek Manuscripts
Program Unit: Textual Criticism: Manuscripts & Methods
Matthew Solomon, New Orleans Baptist Theological Seminary
This paper will present a detailed analysis of the fourteen 9th-century continuous text Greek manuscripts that contain Paul’s epistle to Philemon. The analysis will be both palaeographical and textual in nature. Full palaeographical details will be provided on each manuscript. Also, full quantitative analyses will be done in order to determine textual relationships among the 9th-century manuscripts of Philemon and relationships to earlier and later manuscripts. Based on preliminary research, these manuscripts seem to mark a transition in the textual history of Philemon, being mixed in both textual character and palaeographical details. Manuscripts to be analyzed include: 010, 012, 018, 020, 025, 044, 0150, 0278, 0319, 33, 1424, 1841, 1862, and 1900. The results of the study will be compiled into a preliminary textual apparatus, which is part of a larger PhD dissertation on the textual history of Philemon.
|
The Spatial Imagery of Gehenna in Geographical and Cognitive Terms
Program Unit: Place, Space, and Identity in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Alexey Somov, Institute for Bible Translation, Russia/CIS
As George W. E. Nickelsburg puts it, in some Jewish texts (e.g., 1 Enoch 1-36) the imagery of the otherworld is “this worldly.” Upon resurrection, the righteous will be transferred to the holy place (1 En. 25:5–6),which can be interpreted as Jerusalem located on a holy mountain at the center of the world (1 En. 26:1–3).In contrast, the wicked will be punished after the final judgment at the cursed valley and this will be the place of their final habitation (1 En. 26:4–27:2). Geographically, this place reminds us of the valley of Hinnom to the west/south of Jerusalem. Later, this became the image of Gehenna, the place of final destiny and punishment for the wicked, i.e., hell. Lloyd R. Bailey proposes that such a transformation of the meaning of Gehenna is due to the geography of the holy city. Bailey also suggests that Gehenna may have been assumed to be the entrance to the underworld. This paper supports the idea that this imagery is indeed connected with the geographical spatial difference between Jerusalem and the valley of Hinnom, and argues that the difference between the two is also cognitive in nature. I will use the Cognitive Metaphor Theory developed by G. Lakoff and M. Johnson in order to demonstrate that this difference is expressed by two cognitive image-schemes: 1) “center and periphery” -- Jerusalem as the center of the world and Gehenna as the place outside its walls; and 2) “up and down” -- Gehenna is beneath the walls of the holy city located at the high place and can thus represent a lower level world (the underworld). These image-schemas indicate the opposition between the sacred and the cursed realms in Jewish and early Christian texts.
|
Parallel Syntagma in a Documentarizing Reading of 1–2 Chronicles
Program Unit: Writings (including Psalms)
Buyoung Son, University of Sheffield
This paper examines the patterns at the macro-level found in the depiction of kings in 1–2 Chronicles and makes an attempt to apply narrative film theory, cognitive film semiotics in particular, to the understanding of those patterns in this biblical narrative. The alternating and contrasting depictions of kings in 1–2 Chronicles contribute to several macro-level patterns. They might helpfully be explained by the concept of Parallel Syntagma, among Grande Syntagmatique. This intra-filmic device is recognized as a filmic grammaticality by which the filmmaker ensures that his/her intention of the narrative could be recognized by the spectator viewing a film straight through.
In reading the narrative, also, it is highly likely that readers employ a documentarizing reading strategy for 1-2 Chronicles. According to cognitive film semiotics, a narrative documentary film claims to be read in the deictic relation to its external spatio-temporal context, though it does not mean that the film actually tells about extra-filmic reality. In its original social context, the intended reader (audience) may have been conscious that 1-2 Chronicles had been given specifically to him/her, as a documentarizing reading was triggered by an operation as an interactive motion of external and internal actants. Thus, acknowledging the effects of Parallel Syntagma in a documentarizing reading of 1-2 Chronicles as suggested by cognitive film semiotics will help us comprehend the narrative better with hitherto unexplored and useful insights.
|
Colliding and Colluding Contexts: Reading Elijah’s Concept of Land through My Multi-focal Lens as a Southeast Asian Migrant in Aotearoa/New Zealand
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Angeline M.G. Song, University of Otago
The clash between Ahab and Elijah in the ‘Naboth’s Vineyard’ narrative of 1 Kings 21 is a good model of the King-Prophet confrontation over land management, says Brueggemann. When I first read the narrative, however, I thought that Naboth was a fool for disobeying a powerful King. My family also has had inherited land taken off them, but their response had been one of economic pragmatism coupled by a communitarian ideology. I was therefore unable to relate the prophet’s message to contemporary life. It is only whilst living in Aotearoa/New Zealand as a first generation migrant and reviewing the text through the lens of a different socio-political context, that I gained a real insight into Naboth's and Elijah’s concept of land as a covenantal gift and inalienable inheritance. The paper also suggests that counterpointing the two readings may be helpful in negotiating a way forward.
|
Before Nero’s Death: Reconsidering the Date of the Book of Revelation
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
Young Mog Song, Kosin University
In recent times, most exegetes regardless of whether one is conservative or liberal agree with the late date of the book of Revelation, namely around AD 95-96 under Domitian. Without exception, these scholars interpret Revelation in the light of the Domitianic persecution. However, several scholars insisting on the early date of Revelation have produced a totally different voice against this dominant phenomenon. Of course, the Neronian persecution between AD 64-68 comes to the fore to them. Then, few questions naturally arise on the date and its related interpretation: What is correct argument between the early and late date in terms of the internal and external(esp. Irenaeus, Eusebius) evidences? What is the significant difference in interpreting Revelation when one chooses one option? If the role of the emperor Nero or Domitian provides the absolute clue for the historical background of Revelation, what is the function of the unbelieving Jews called the synagogue of Satan(Rev. 2:9; 3:9) as another important persecuting power in Asia Minor? How is the teaching of the Nicolaitans(Rev. 2:15) as a threatening syncretistic heresy to the first recipients related with the persecution by the emperor? This paper is aimed at searching the date of the book of Revelation. When the external evidence is not certain, the date should be determined particularly by examining closely the internal evidence. In order to investigate the date of Revelation, firstly the external arguments are analyzed critically. Then, an exploration about the internal arguments is done. Finally, interpretive implications of the early date are scrutinized in connection with the role of the unbelieving Jews and the Nicolaitans. Through this study, the early date of AD 66 between the great fire in Rome and Nero’s suicide on the basis of the external and internal evidences and its interpretive implication are suggested.
|
Jesus, Mediator of the New Covenant, Ultimate Wasta? Hebrews Read against the Backdrop of Arab Middle Eastern Mediation
Program Unit: New Testament/Early Christianity/Rabbinic Studies (EABS)
Ekkardt A. Sonntag, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam
The Epistle to the Hebrews paints a vivid picture of Jesus as the supreme mediator between man and God. Interpreters have drawn on several different hermeneutical frameworks in order to interpret this picture, some emphasising gnosticism, others Alexandrian wisdom theology or the Old Testament traditions as a background. Recently, David deSilva has fruitfully drawn on greco-roman patronage for his interpretation. The sociology of patronage in antiquity can only be accessed through what deSilva calls 'socio-rhetorical' analysis. So this study will attempt to use the concept of wasta as a reading environment, a contemporary form of patronage ubiquitously present in the Arab Middle East, which is accessible through first hand experience and thus increasingly growing research by cultural anthropologists as well as sociologists and political scientists. Such a reading will not only add new colour to the interpretation of Jesus as mediator in Hebrews, but will also enrich any form of dialogue between Western and Middle Eastern readers of the Epistle and even Christian-Muslim dialogue on issues like the God-Sonship of Jesus. The study will first give a brief overview of the wasta phenomenon. It will then discuss how some main points in Hebrews' presentation of Jesus as mediator of the new covenant resonate with the wasta practice. A reading of Heb 3.1-6 as an exemplary pericope will be attempted, viewing it against the background of wasta sociology as it was described earlier. Topoi such as 'Son', 'Priest', but also aspects of the argument like 'honour' will appear in a new light. The study will thus add colour and (inter-)cultural depth to understanding Hebrews' presentation of Jesus as the mediator who establishes the better relationship to God than all former mediators.
|
How to Profit from a Prophetess: A Guide to the Rabbinically Perplexed
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Adrian Spunaugle, University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
Scholars interested in the status of women in the ancient world have not neglected their roles in the Talmud. Though many suggestions have been put forth, few have addressed the female prophets known from the Hebrew Bible. Seven women are labeled as prophetesses in bT Megilah 14a, only three of which are noted as such in the Hebrew Bible. Throughout the Babylonian Talmud, the rabbis not only add four women to the list, but also neglect others who are recorded in the biblical text. The women selected are all shown to provide salvation for the nation of Israel, and therefore are treated as the only biblical heroines. As these women feature in a corpus that typically abstains from treating individual females, their multiple appearances indicate they serve a greater purpose than as casual biblical characters. The argument presented in this paper is that the rabbis utilized the female heroes of the Hebrew Bible to exemplify the proper attitudes and behaviors expected of a pious human being.
|
The Treaty Besieged
Program Unit: Bible and Empire
Adrianne Spunaugle, University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
The matter of suzerain-vassal and adê treaties throughout the ancient Near East has been of considerable interest within biblical studies, with scholars such as Weinfeld and Steymans paying special attention to the relationship of the adê treaty of Esarhaddon and Deuteronomy 28. However, the physical threat implicit in the curse sections of these texts is often glossed over in favor of their religious significance. I address this issue in these texts, paying particular attention to the tacit threat of siege warfare for the vassals of the Neo-Assyrian empire. Those curses of the adê treaty of Esarhaddon and of Deuteronomy 28 that depict hardship topoi specifically are used to denote siege warfare, such as cannibalism, famine, disease, and general hardship. These are compared with the reality of siege warfare, the assault strategy of choice in the ANE. The unifying theme between these two texts is siege warfare, which causes the two treaties to appear dependently linked. Defeat in war was the primary form of punishment for breaking a covenant agreement, either with a deity or with another individual or country, and siege warfare was one of the primary forms of warfare in the ANE during the NA empire.
|
Disability in the Ancient World: Chrysostom's Views
Program Unit: Healthcare and Disability in the Ancient World
Hennie Stander, University of Pretoria
It is very difficult to determine what percentage of the population in the ancient world was disabled. However, Chrysostom said that life abounded with people who were maimed. But one should bear in mind that there is no generic word in Greek or Latin that fully corresponds with the English word “disability”. One should therefore be careful not to make anachronistic assumptions about disability, and one should not approach the subject from a modern perspective or use modern medical categories of impairment to discuss the disabilities of the ancients.
In this paper we will examine Chrysostom’s views on disability. However, in order to grasp Chrysostom’s views on disability, one should also understand the world in which he lived. Ancient communities acted brutally towards deformed children. It will be shown that a disabled person had no status at all in ancient communities. People with physical abnormalities were often subjected to even mockery.
As expected, disability has also raised numerous theological questions, and we will explore how Chrysostom dealt with these questions. Throughout all centuries the question was asked whether God caused disability or not. Some saw disabilities as sin. Chrysostom also had to answer the question how God can be called just and good if everybody does not suffer the same punishment for the same sins.
In this paper we will also explore the position of the disabled within the Church.
|
Liturgical Division of the Torah as the Unit Delimitation Tool: Preliminary Remarks
Program Unit: Pentateuch (Torah)
Teresa Stanek, Uniwersytet im. Adama Mickiewicza
Beside of oldest division known as petucha and setuma, the book of the Torah was divided (in a few variants) for the purpose of liturgical reading in synagogue. Those divisions are considered to be late, and by scholars quite often recounted as more or less accidental. In consequence, they do not awaken much interest in biblical scholarship. The concept behind the Palestinian order sometimes is the subject of interest of Christian scholars, but the Babylonian order (according to my knowledge) is treated only homiletically.
In my opinion the Babylonian order is purposeful, both on the level of the parashot and the aliyot. This division offers interesting concept, particularly on the didactic but also on the theological level. Up to now I analysed seven parashot (ca. 15-20% of the Torah) from the literary and theological point of view (Bereshit, Gen 1:1-6:8; Lekh Lekha, Gen 12:1-17:27; Shemot, Ex 1:1-6,1; Va’era’, Ex 6:2-9:35; Bo’, Ex 10:1-13:16; Jithro, Ex 18,1-20,23; Mishpatim, Ex 21:1-24:18). Those analysis prove that this division is carefully thought out.
In the proposed paper I would like to present general structure some of those analysed parashot from the literary point of view and underline the message they convey. In my opinion this division can very well serve as the unit delimitation tool.
|
Wider eine Unkritische Allegorische Lektüre des Hohenliedes durch Exegeten: Eine Auseinandersetzung mit Ludger Schwienhorst-Schönberger und Meik Gerhards
Program Unit: Intersectional Feminism(s)
Thomas Staubli, Université de Fribourg - Universität Freiburg
Phillys Trible, Athalya Brenner u.a. haben vor dreißig Jahren die Texte des Hohenliedes als «female voices» erkannt und damit einen neuen Blick auf die Gedichtsammlung ermöglicht. Othmar Keel ist es ungefähr gleichzeitig gelungen, dank Auswertung der levantinischen Ikonographie den Metapherncode der Lieder zu knacken. Diese epochalen Leistungen werden zur Zeit auf fragwürdige Weise zurückbuchstabiert. Meik Gerhards glaubt aufweisen zu können, dass das Hohelied nur als allegorisch zu lesende Gedichtsammlung Eingang in den Kanon fand und darlegen zu müssen, dass es auch so gelesen werden müsse. Das tut Ludger Schwienhorst-Schönberger, indem er, inspiriert von prophetischen Gott-Hure-Allegoresen, erneut patriarchale Muster in die Hoheliedtexte hineinliest.
Solches Vorgehen wird weder dem heutigen exegetischen Stand gerecht, noch den Bedürfnissen der Rezipientinnen und Rezipienten an der kirchlichen Basis. Diese neopatriarchale Offensive in der Exegese ist für die jüngste Zeit beispiellos und ruft nach einer kritischen Debatte.
|
The Iconographic Program of the Outer Citadel Gate of Samal (Zincirli Höyük) and Its Relevance for Ancient Levantine Poetry
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Thomas Staubli, Université de Fribourg - Universität Freiburg
The first analysis of the iconographic program of the orthostats in the outer citadel gate of Samal (9-8th cent. BC) offers insight to the formal principles of one of the key works of ancient Levantine art and the possibility of comparisons with formal principles from Levantine legal texts and poetry. We find parallelism, inclusion, chiasm as the main stylistic elements. Among the motifs we encounter a banquet scene, a procession, musicians, warriors, heroes, wild animals, hybrid beings, goddesses and gods in telling constellations.
|
Speaking in Tongues or Making Noises? Reexamining 1 Corinthians 14
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Jacek Stefanski, Major Seminary of the Diocese of Kalisz, Poland
Much has been written about the phenomenon of "speaking in tongues" as it is discussed by St. Paul in 1 Cor. 14. There is disagreement as to whether St. Paul is referring to human languages or something else. While many attempts have been made to clarify this issue, very little attention has been given to the light which the Old Testament and Patristic sources can shed on the subject. The purpose of this paper is to take a new look at these sources and examine the manner in which they can help us understand what exactly "speaking in tongues" meant and what implications it may have for us today.
|
Observations on Genesis 1–11 as the Canonical Ouverture to the Group Genesis–Kings
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
Julius Steinberg, Theologische Hochschule Ewersbach
Many efforts have been spent on the questions of origin and redaction of Gen 1-11, often focusing on the tensions within and disruptions between the individual sections. Canonical approaches, in contrast, make room for a fresh view on the overall communication process that takes place when reading Gen 1-11 and the following as a unity. In my contribution I want to present mainly literary-structural observations that show that Gen 1-11 was deliberately composed as a prologue to the ‘primary history’, i.e. the books of Genesis to Kings. The results of the synchronic study can be used, in turn, for addressing the diachronic questions from a new perspective.
|
The Pauline Epistles in the Writings of Origen and the Misuse of Patristic Evidence
Program Unit: Textual Criticism: Manuscripts & Methods
Matt Steinfeld, University of Birmingham
The lack of exhaustive comparative models derived from collations of manuscripts and Patristic citations keeps us from a most accurate understanding of the relationship between Patristic Citations and the manuscripts of the Greek New Testament. Only complete understanding of affinities of the extant manuscripts and their relation to each other can one make decisions as to how a Father fits into the transmission history of the Greek New Testament. An understanding of the transmission history of the Greek New Testament but gives proper explanation to the manuscript traditions of the Church Fathers based on their relationship to individual manuscripts. Until this type of comparative system can be established, it is necessary that Patristic citations are treated descriptively instead of comparatively. Premature application of statistical analysis leads to a misrepresentation of Patristic Citations which adversely affects our understanding of the Greek New Testament. This paper will focus on Origen of Alexandria's use of the Pauline Epistles and how the misuse of Patristic citations can lead to false assumptions of the early New Testament text.
|
The Biblical Canon and Its Impact on History: An Inquiry on the Books of Chronicles
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
Georg Steins, Universitaet Osnabrueck
The poor image of the Books of Chronicles in a part of Old Testament studies (namely from Julius Wellhausen to Othmar Keel) is based on a historically one-sided evaluation of these scriptures. With an ongoing formation of a canon of Biblical books the relationship of history and biblical text is being turned: It is no longer actual history that is the deciding factor for that which is delivered, but rather tradition establishes a reality of its own, a reality of a second order. It is the canon which increasingly distinguishes what is "historical" for a given community. In the Bible there is no better example for this "canonical inversion" (G.St.) than the "historiography" of the Books of Chronicles. Whoever starts any interpretation of the Bible with history starts from the wrong end.
|
The Reception of the New Testament in Rabbinic Literature
Program Unit:
Günter Stemberger, Universität Wien
In modern research, as most prominently in two volumes by Johann Maier, rabbinic knowledge of and reactions to writings of the New Testament, were reduced to an absolute minimum. This has changed in recent years, especially with books on Jesus and the Gospels in the Talmud by Peter Schäfer and Daniel Boyarin, Schäfer’s The Jewish Jesus, or Holger Zellentin’s Rabbinic Parodies. The by now widely accepted thesis of a much longer redaction history of the Bavli and the growing research into the social and religious history of Babylonia and, more generally, religious interaction in Late Antiquity, greatly contributed to this development. The lecture will summarize these developments and evaluate recent theories.
|
Biblical Motifs in Jewish Art of Late Antique Palestine
Program Unit: Reception of the Bible in Jewish, Early Christian and Islamic Art
Günter Stemberger, Universität Wien
Several mosaic floors of late antique synagogues in Palestine present biblical scenes, most prominently the Aqedah (Gen. 22) in Hammat Tiberias, Sepphoris and Beth Alpha. Other mosaics in Sepphoris depict the announcement of Isaac’s birth, the investment of Aaron as high priest and the sacrificial cult; the floor of the synagogue of Meroth most probably presents David with Goliath’s weapons. Daniel in the lion’s den is depicted several times. This repertory has been considerably enlarged by the excavation of the synagogue of Khirbet Hamam. The paper will present the evidence and discuss the iconography as well as the meaning of this selection of biblical scenes within the context of late antique Palestinian Judaism.
|
Biblical Women in Jewish-Non-Jewish Relations: Early Silent Films
Program Unit: Bible and the Moving Image
Frank Stern, Universität Wien
After 1900, in the first two decades of film production Jewish film topics were of mainstream interest in the cultural metropolis of Vienna. Most of these films either dealt with the Jewish experience through history or Biblical stories that were put on the screen for the first time. The biblical women and men became living moving images and part of modern visual culture. Due to the shifts in the role of gender and women after the fin-de-siècle and with reference to psychoanalysis women were at the center of these fiction films. The paper discusses a number of these films with relation to Jewish-non-Jewish relations and the role of the representations of biblical women as the new femme moderne.
|
Prophecies of Salvation: A Personal Exegesis in Music
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Max Stern, Ariel University Center of Samaria
Inspired poets, preachers, statesmen, social critics, political activists, and moralists, the Prophets were men in whom the Divine light of Eternity was refracted through the voice of man. They not only addressed the ills of their own generation but voiced visions which have given a direction to history. This presentation focuses upon the author's cantata Prophecy for the End of Days for narrator, chorus, glass harps, percussion, shofar, string orchestra and the Bedouin folk-instrument rebaba. It voices visionary messages of hope and salvation. But in the last of days it shall come to pass, that the mountain of the house of the Lord shall be established in the top of the mountains, and it shall be exalted above the hills; and people shall flow unto it. All nations will embrace ideals of morality, justice and brotherly love - and find fulfillment and peace therein. Come, and let us go up to the mountain of the Lord, and to the house of Jacob; and he will teach us of his ways, and we will walk in his paths (Isaiah 2:2-3; Micah 4:1-2).
|
The Upper Agora at Ephesos: An Imperial Forum?
Program Unit:
Dirk Steuernagel, University of Regensburg
Previous scientific research has viewed the Upper Agora as dedicated to provincial administration and the imperial cult, initiated in the proto- or early Augustan period, and based on models like the imperial fora in Rome. The overall architectural layout and functional determination of the area would thus have been conceptualized and implemented by central authorities. But there are some facts which do not fit this hypothesis. The question of chronology is crucial in this regard. For instance, the temple located on the long axis of the square, which probably was dedicated to the imperial cult or to deities with particular affinity to the ruling dynasty, was not among the first buildings erected on the spot, as it has often been assumed, but may be the last one. Consequently, the definitive appearance of the Upper Agora, circulating in the guise of well-known ground-plans, seems to have a rather complicated history. Obviously, it did not go back to imperial will alone (or to that of the emperor’s local confidants). A new research project argues that, on the contrary, the Upper Agora emerged from a long-term formation process in which various actors, pursuing different goals, may have played a role.
|
Raising the Dead as Political Provocation
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Margot Stevenson, Independent Scholar
Despite the Johannine tendency to distance Jesus from political militancy (6:15; 18:36), John’s Gospel lends itself to a “political” hypothesis about the trial of Jesus.
This hypothesis takes as its starting point the Roman crucifixion. The historical fact of the crucifixion indicates that Jesus’s alleged crimes were messianism – the claim to be a king - and political sedition.
The trial by the Jewish Sanhedrin in the Gospels, on this view, is either fictitious or highly exaggerated. The “Jews” are depicted as guilty of a vast miscarriage of justice. The political hypothesis corrects for such anti-Jewish polemics. Roman treason penalties, rather than theological foul-play, were responsible for Jesus’s death.
After reviewing the evidence in John for this hypothesis (e.g. debates over the historical veracity of the Johannine Sanhedrin trial; the question of Roman collaboration in Jesus’s arrest), I investigate the raising of Lazarus from such a political (and post-colonial) standpoint.
Narratively, Lazarus is linked to a double political sedition charge against Jesus. The Lazarus miracle (“sign”) is the immediate provocation for Jesus’s arrest by the Jewish Sanhedrin on grounds that Jesus is a false prophet, guilty of “deceiving the crowds.” (7:12b; 11:47-48)
The Lazarus miracle prompts the crowds, too, upon his entry into Jerusalem, to hail Jesus as King, an acclamation chiefly at stake in the Roman trial. (12:12-13,17-18)
I sketch the Roman cultural setting of the Lazarus controversy, by tracing the false prophet charge – “Jesus is deceiving the crowds”—through three different sites: Deuteronomy, John’s Gospel, and Josephus.
Thereby, a bigger drama unfolds. The false prophet, on the Roman imperial stage, is characterized as a “public enemy,” implicated in treason and magical deceit. The raising of Lazarus (I suggest) casts Jesus in such a role.
|
Moses as Therapon (Heb 3:5)
Program Unit: Epistle to the Hebrews
Gert J. Steyn, University of Pretoria
The unknown author of Hebrews uses the hapax legomenon therapon in his reference to Moses as a “servant” when he contrasts Moses with Jesus in Heb 3:1-6. Moses was faithful as a servant in all God’s house, whereas Christ is faithful as a son over God’s house. The term therapon is known in the LXX (especially in Exodus) and has also been associated with the priests of Asclepius and those of the Pharaoh. Several questions arise: Why did the author of Hebrews choose this particular term? How did it differ from similar terms in the same semantic domain? Are there any implied connotations with cultic service in the sanctuary by using this term? Is there any evidence through the author’s choice of this term of closer alignment with an Egyptian setting? The paper intends to investigate these questions against the background of the usage of this term in Greek literature as well as against the literary context of the book Hebrews.
|
Jeremiah 10:1-16 MT versus LXX Text Critically
Program Unit: Texts and Contexts of Jeremiah: The Exegesis of Jeremiah 1 and 10 in light of Textual and Reception History
Hermann-Josef Stipp, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
This paper reviews the textual attestation of Jer 10:1–16, paying particular attention to new data that broadens the criteria which so far have been brought to bear on the passage: elements of the pre Masoretic idiolect in the Masoretic pluses.
|
Debora, Hulda, and Innibana: Thoughts on the Constructions of Female Prophecy in the Ancient Near East
Program Unit: The Image of Female Prophets in Ancient Greek and Jewish Literature
Jonathan Stökl, King's College - London
In this paper I will study female prophecy in three biblical texts, Jdg 4-5, 2 Kgs 22 and 2 Chr 34 and in a number of letters from Mari. The focus will be on how female prophets are constructed in the various texts in their contexts. For the scholar of the ancient Near East, Hulda looks like a familiar character, but with several twists, particularly in the construction of her authority. Debora's combination of 'judge' and prophet is even more 'peculiar'. In particular the construction of the position of women in society in the pericope is rather ambiguous, including that of Debora herself. As I will argue, this ambiguity is characteristic of Second Temple construction of female prophecy.
|
Son of David or Kingdom of God (Mk 12:35-37)
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Robert F. Stoops, Jr, Western Washington University
Jesus’ rejection of the Son of David title in Mark 12:35–37 should be taken seriously as a reflection of the author’s view. Without the parallels in Matthew and Luke, it is unlikely that anyone would argue that Mk 12:35–37 constitutes a qualified endorsement of the title. Nevertheless, that remains the dominant reading of the passage. The author of Mark (or Jesus) is usually understood to accept the title while correcting a commonly held expectation of a militant messiah from the line of David. However, the surviving evidence does not support the claim that Son of David had either widespread use or a definite meaning among Jews prior to its adoption by Christian groups. Starting without that assumption leads to a simpler interpretation of Mk 12:35–37: the teaching attributed to the scribes is being rejected. The reasons for Mark’s dismissal of a Davidic messiah can be found in the scriptural sources that play the most important roles in the Gospel. Mark’s eschatology and Christology are primarily informed by utopian strands of the biblical tradition that anticipate the direct rule of God rather than a theocracy mediated by a human king. The author relies heavily on Exodus traditions, especially as they were reinterpreted in late-exilic and post-exilic prophets. Mark shares their expectation of God’s direct rule on earth and, therefore, has no place for a messiah modeled on David. The Son of David title not only distracts attention from the Son of God and Son of Man, it distorts the author’s understanding of the Kingdom of God. Matthew and Luke “correct” this aspect of Mark’s Christology by modifying Mark’s wording and adding traditions that clearly establish Jesus’ identity as the Son of David.
|
Canon and Canonical Commentary
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
Terje Stordalen, Universitetet i Oslo
Christian Protestant tradition tends to identify the canon simply with the holy text. Other denominations and book religions recognise canonicity also outside of the holy text. Scholars need concepts of canon, canonicity, and canonization that take heed of this situation. One way to explore canonicity beyond even the Protestant type of holy text, is to map the interaction between canon and canonical commentary. This presentation sketches such interaction historically in three different “strong” scriptural canons (the ancient Hebrew Scriptures, the old Confucian Five Classics, and the European Bible with the gloss). A taxonomy is proposed, taking the canon, the commentary, and the canonical community as primary constituents of a canonical ecology. Further, by way of examples the presentation points to typical biblical canonical dynamics, namely those of associative harmonisation and of expanding orthodoxy. The presence of these dynamics in canonical ecologies pose a challenge to, say, biblical studies taught in institutions and cultures that recognise some sense of canonicity or classical value in biblical texts. So, what would be a defendable critical canonical approach to biblical literature? Scratching the surface of this profound question, this proposal points first to the option of an archaeology of canonicity in the text, and secondly to a notion of custodianship of biblical literature that is focused upon public and humane concern.
|
Worlds that Cannot Be: Is Thomas More’s Utopia Modern?
Program Unit: Chronicles and Utopia (EABS)
Terje Stordalen, Universitetet i Oslo
This presentation addresses the presumption that modernist utopias function as blueprints for political (i.e. «realistic») action, whereas pre-modern utopias are usually non realistic -- either in general or in their imagination of available resources, political solutions, etc. For this reason ancient utopias are thought to be less relevant for modern (political) reflection. While there seem to be “realistic” as well as “fantasmatic” utopias in modern as well as ancient literature, I wish to focus one aspect of “unreal” utopias (like the one in Genesis 2–3). They are “worlds that cannot be”, or what Fritz Stolz called “Gegenwelten” (counter-worlds). And it is as such that they perform their utopian agency. Close reading of (continuous versions of) Sir Thomas More’s Utopia, locating this text in its medieval and renaissance background, reveals that its utopian blueprint is not as “realistic” as is implicitly claimed by those taking this text as a breakthrough for the modern. In some respects, the society of the island of Utopia is indeed “a world that could not be” according to the moral and geographical presumptions of Thomas More’s time. This has implications for calculating the rhetorical force of the novel. The presentation deals with various editions of Sir Thomas More’s Utopia, also considering medieval concepts of Paradise, especially as documented in the so-called “mappae mundi” (world maps), and further even reflecting on biblical and ancient passages on paradise gardens / islands that fed into these mappae mundi.
|
Using the Bible to Legitimize Byzantine Warfare
Program Unit: The Bible in Byzantium: The Use and Abuse of Tradition
Ioannis Stouraitis, Universität Wien
*
|
False Prophets, Sons of Belial, and Sins unto Death: First John’s Reading of Deuteronomy 13 as Eschatological Halakha
Program Unit: Catholic Epistles
Daniel R. Streett, Durham University
Because 1 John never directly quotes the Old Testament, it is often asserted that letter offers no real insight into the way that early followers of Jesus read their Scriptures. More recently, however, scholars (e.g. J. Lieu) have questioned this consensus by pointing to the extensive use of OT concepts, images, and symbols. In this paper, I supplement this challenge by proposing Deuteronomy 13 as the key subtext for the letter’s treatment of community opponents. Deut 13 describes “sons of belial” who go out to deceive their fellow Israelites by enticing them to transgress the covenant through idolatry. The text commands that such false prophets be put to death without mercy. I argue that 1 John 2:18–24 and 4:1–6—the key opponent passages—apply this OT text eschatologically in order to shape the community’s own response to the secessionist crisis. Special attention is paid to a) elements in the text of Deut 13 which may have suggested an eschatological understanding of the text, b) the relationship between the Deuteronomic subtext and the puzzling and abrupt injunction against idolatry which concludes the epistle (1 John 5:21), and c) the way that Deut 13 may inform our understanding of a classic exegetical crux, namely the “sin unto death” (1 John 5:16–17).
|
Philo, Festivals, and Participation in the Divine in Hellenistic Judaism
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Daniel R. Streett, Durham University
Festivals were commonly viewed in the ancient Mediterranean as an opportunity for humans to participate in the life of the gods, who are perpetually feasting. Thus Plato (Laws 653d) says that festivals are a gift from the gods, allowing humans “to be made whole again” by “participating in the festivals alongside the gods” (suneortazein en tais eortais meta theon). The concept of divine mimesis is used to explain the banqueting, liturgy, leisure, and reenactment of divine exploits that accompanied festivals in the Hellenistic world.
In this paper, I examine Philo’s interpretation of the Jewish festivals in light of this tradition. Special attention is paid to: a) the ways in which Philo attempts to distance Jewish feasting from Greek feasting by characterizing the former as askesis, b) Philo’s use of rewritten bible traditions in his descriptions of the festivals, c) Philo’s numerological understanding of the festal calendar, especially in relation to other Hellenistic numerological thought, and d) the possible relationship between Philo and apocalyptic traditions (such as Jubilees) in which Israel’s festivals are depicted as having a heavenly pre-existence, so that Israel’s festival observance is understood as imitatio angelorum.
|
Israel’s Restoration and YHWH’s Honor Before the Nations
Program Unit: Prophets
John Strong, Missouri State University
Israel’s Restoration and Yhwh’s Honor Before the Nations
|
Apocalyptic and Time: Reflections in Honor of John Collins
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Loren Stuckenbruck, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
John Collins' work on the much debated label "apocalyptic" has opened up and shaped the fields of Second Temple and biblical studies during the last three decades. For instance, spatial and, with it, sapiential dimensions are now regularly being taken seriously as a way to re-explore texts previously subjected to a myopic focus on time and eschatology. At the same time, it is precisely the understanding of time in Second Temple literature that stands in danger of being overlooked, as if the discourse about eschatology in relation to "apocalyptic thought" is simply oriented towards the future. The resulting assumption has led many biblical (especially New Testament) scholars to distinguish Jesus and Paul from Judaism by maintaining that the early Christian movement involved a breakthrough in the understanding of time that superceded anything thought possible within a non-Christian Jewish context. The paper problematizes this assumption and calls for a reconceptualizing of the temporal dimension of "apocalyptic", while noting some of its implications for contextualizing claims associated with the Christian movement in the first century.
|
The Ethiopic Text to the Book of Parables Chapter 37
Program Unit: Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha
Loren Stuckenbruck, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
The Ethiopic Text to the Book of Parables Chapter 37
|
Ezekiel Meets the Matrix! Dystopian Identity Politics in a Virtual World
Program Unit: Science Fiction and the Bible (EABS)
Carla Sulzbach, McGill University
Obvious and tantalizing connections can be made between biblical narrative and science fiction, both being filled with otherworldly beings, travel between earthly and heavenly realms, mind bending, temporal displacements, and supernatural occurrences. The Book of Ezekiel is rife with imagery that could be and has been construed as “proof for intelligent life in the universe.” Especially the appearance of the divine chariot has invited creative minds to shout “UFO!” In this paper I want to look at a different angle and address the aspect of social criticism that is representative for a subgenre within science fiction. The latter chapters of Ezekiel speak of a renewed earth populated with a very peculiar society. This is generally understood in utopian terms, as a blissful return to Edenic conditions with an end to war, disease, with peace and prosperity ruling forever and ever. It is especially instructive to read this alongside some well-known sf and alternate society examples that deal with isolated or larger redesigned, and rather dystopian, societies – be they Stepford Wives, Invasion of the Body Snatchers, 1984, the Matrix, or some outstanding Star Trek episodes (in all its incarnations) that deal with stagnated controlled societies without free will. Ezekiel’s end-scenario displays elements similar to all these. In this paper I will explore what this means in the religious context of Ezekiel as opposed to the contemporary secular stories.
|
The Canonical Function of Psalm 24 and Isaiah 33
Program Unit: Writings (including Psalms)
Philip Sumpter, University of Gloucestershire
Scholars have long noted a generic connection between Psalm 24 and Isaiah 33: both texts appear to have drawn on a now lost liturgical ritual associated with the temple in order to render a new message. Yet how are we to gauge that new message? Over the last few decades there has been an increasing awareness that often latterly textualized Biblical traditions received their form and function within the context of a broader literary whole, relating to that whole in various ways. The argument of this paper is that Ps 24 and Isa 33 not only draw on a common generic source, they have also received a similar canonical function within the context of their respective books, the first book of the Psalter and the book of Isaiah. This thesis will defended by describing how this ancient liturgical pattern has now been rendered according to a similar eschatological schema in both texts, and how these texts now function as summaries and hermeneutical horizons within their respective literary contexts for the material that both precedes and follows them. In conclusion the question will be raised as to the relation between cultic experience and canonical form.
|
A Comparison of Childs' Exodus and Isaiah Commentaries: Continuity and Change
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
Philip Sumpter, University of Gloucestershire
A common misconception of the development of Brevard Childs’ thought is that he first started out as a historical critic, interested only in diachronic questions, and later took a more theological turn, eschewing diachronic analysis to focus exclusively on the final form of the text. This view, however, misunderstands the way Childs’ appreciation of the final form was grounded in a certain kind of diachronic consideration, one which factored the reality of the theological source of the tradition into his appreciation of its nature. It was this that led to his later development of final-form interpretation. My thesis is that the real development in Childs' thought involves less an abandonment of the uncertainties of speculative reconstructions in favour of the church’s traditional and apparently more objective text than a growing appreciation of and confidence in talking about the ontological reality of God as a factor in the Bible’s creation. This thesis can be illustrated by comparing the only two full-length scholarly commentaries written Childs, both of which roughly bracket his career. His first commentary on Exodus was written during the 1970s, before he had even coined the term “canonical approach,” the second commentary on Isaiah was written in 2002 towards the end of his life, at a time when the term “canonical” had started to become problematic for him. This paper will demonstrate that in both commentaries Childs worked with the same exegetical logic. The difference is that in the latter commentary Childs’ relative decrease in confidence about the reliability or usefulness of diachronic reconstruction is accompanied by an increase in his confidence in using theo-ontological categories to describe the forces at work in the production of the text. For Childs, factoring in this theological dimension has hermeneutical consequences.
|
The Significance of Sight Terms in Genesis
Program Unit: Literary Features – Fact or Fiction (EABS)
Talia Sutskover, Tel Aviv University
In this paper I aim to show how terms of the semantic field of Sight stand out in the book of Genesis; they are constantly found in openings, turning points, and as constituents in place-names and personal names. Terms of the Sight field are shown to enhance cohesion between the narratives in Genesis, and the understanding of one of its central themes.
The deployment of the field of Sight in the narratives shows that in the beginning of times frequent instances of seeing take place between God and humans, and as the sections of Genesis progress, god gradually becomes a hidden director of human behavior. Divine sight gives way to human sight, not as an act of punishment as can be seen in the Prophets, but it is interpreted as a gradual divine tendency, or perhaps, choice.
It will be shown that Sight may occur as sensory and concrete, but also abstract signifying insight and understanding. In Genesis 1-11 seeing is at its lowest levels, i.e. humans engage in seeing the sensory world around them, and their insights are also connected with sensory sight. As the narratives advance, there is growing sight that involves insight and awareness on the part of human beings. Visual perception becomes more and more abstract and related to God by some of the characters. All in all, the field of Sight is shown to shape the history of major and secondary characters, traits of character, and outward appearance.
|
The Feet of Jesus Anointed by Different Women in Luke and in John
Program Unit: The Relation Between Luke’s and John’s Gospel (EABS)
David Svärd, Lunds Universitet
There are significant differences between the anointing episodes in Luke 7:36-50 and in John 12:1-8, and the relation between them has been much debated. I propose that the episodes testify to a similar Christological emphasis as well as a different one which may indicate that one or both evangelists were aware of the work of the other.
There is reason to assume that the Lukan as well as the Johannine anointing stories are meant to confirm the messianic identity of Jesus. They both differ from the Markan and Matthean accounts in singling out Jesus’ feet as the object of the anointing. This is due to a common emphasis on Jesus’ messiahship as inherently being servanthood, as the feet represent servants. One important difference between the episodes is that in Luke a sinful woman anoints Jesus while in John the pious Mary performs the act. The latter corresponds to Mark and Matthew and confirms that Jesus is the Messiah of the faithful Jews. The former shows that Jesus is the Messiah even for sinners and outcasts – a Lukan theme.
These corresponding and differing details of the anointing episodes should be interpreted Christologically and the inclusion of them by the respective evangelists may indicate Luke’s awareness of John’s Christological feet emphasis or vice versa.
|
Hiding in Plain Sight: The Advantages, Responsibilities, and Complications Involved in Using Embodied Performance to Explore Mk 15:40-42 with Students
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Richard Swanson, Augustana College (SD)
When Jesus dies near the end of Mark’s Passion story, the storyteller points to women, many of them, who are standing nearby and watching. We had not seen them before. Where did they come from? Responsive and responsible interpretation will have to consider this surprise.
Silent reading allows the women simply to pop up once Jesus is fully and finally dead, and interpretation based on silent reading is generally not too surprised by their sudden appearance.
Solo performance of Mark’s Passion story is (at least potentially) more likely to surprise students, since it provides an opportunity for the performer to discover that he is surrounded by a crowd of women. Many performances of Mark’s Passion story, however, treat the mention of these surprising women as a quick throw-away line, one extra detail to be included before turning to the “real” business at hand: honoring Joseph of Arimathea and his courageous act of burying Jesus.
Embodied performance by an ensemble, because of its unique demands and difficulties, creates a more promising and productive situation for interpreters, teachers, and students: the women (who have NOT been visible up to this point) must be discovered, and must be discovered to have been present all along, always and from the very beginning in Galilee. This mode of analyzing the text draws students into the surprise that makes this story work. It has implications for the way Mark’s entire story must be interpreted.
This presentation will explore ways that embodied ensemble performance can function in teaching undergraduate students to interpret the gospel of Mark. Embodied ensemble performance affords a particularly good way for students to learn to consider the role of surprise in this most surprising gospel.
|
Gog And Magog In Literary Reception History
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Anthony Swindell, University of London
This paper will look at the literary reception of Ezekiel’s prophecies concerning Gog and Magog, encompassing the use of the material in medieval European literature and folklore and in works by Dickens and Tolkien. It will examine the usefulness of modern theories about rewriting and intertextuality in relation to this literary afterlife.
|
Jesus, Totem, and Taboo
Program Unit: Psychological Hermeneutics of Biblical Themes and Texts
Kari Syreeni, Abo Akademi
What do the crucifix and the totem have in common? Ideologically, both artifacts point to the central symbol of the respective faith systems, a symbol which indicates social identity. Like the totemized object, Christ is believed to be both the originator of a group of people (the new Adam, the firstborn from the dead, etc.), and a living spiritual entity. There is an intimate relationship between Christ and the community of believers – the “Christians” (Acts 11:26), the “body” of Christ (1 Cor 12). The present paper examines some core elements in the early Christians’ symbolic imprinting on the Christ figure: the apocalyptic vision, the stigma of crucifixion, baptism in Jesus’ name, the Eucharistic meal. It is argued that much of the development of Christology reflects this totemic relationship which, in various ways, seeks to fulfill the ultimate desire by renegotiating the ancient taboo (Gen 2:16-17; 3:4-5). No matter how uneasy as a logical construct, the combination of Jesus’ humanity and deity makes an attractive psychological appeal: God became man that man might become God.
|
Jews on Demotic Papyri and Ostraca from Egypt
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism (EABS)
Zsuzsanna Szántó, Eötvös Loránd Tudományegyetem
The Jews of Greco-roman Egypt were full members of the Greek social class, thus they are mostly attested on Greek and, to a lesser extent, on Aramaic papyri and ostraca. However, especially in the countryside, they were living among Egyptians, and had some social interaction with the natives. Consequently, we meet some Jews in the contemporary Demotic sources. The aim of this paper is to give an insight into the nature of the Demotic material attesting Jews of Egypt, and to show through two examples how it enlarges our knowledge of them. The first one is a Demotic attestation of Dositheos son of Drimylos, the renegade Jew of the Third Maccabees, and the second one is an ostracon from Tell el-Yehudieh with names of Jewish builders.
|
The Appointed Time Has Grown Very Short: Paul’s Apocalyptic Expectations and Nero’s Rise to Power
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
James D. Tabor, University of North Carolina at Charlotte
In the letter of 1 Corinthians Paul confidently refers to the “impending distress,” declaring “the appointed time has grown very short.” Based upon this imminent apocalyptic expectation of Jesus’ Parousia, he advises his followers to “remain as they are”—whether married or unmarried, circumcised or uncircumcised, slave or free—since “the form of this world is passing away.” Paul was utterly convinced that all states of life were soon to be reserved in a cosmic overturn he and his followers were already beginning to experience—making irrelevant every status quo, whether based on gender, ethnic identity, or social power. This paper explores Paul’s expectations in the light of his understanding of Daniel 12, Isaiah 24, and Micah 7 (LXX) as evidenced by linguistic and thematic links, and set against the background of the demise of the dysfunctional Julio-Claudian imperial family as Nero and his mother Agrippina achieved power in 54 CE.
|
Manifestations of Royal Ideology in Hittite Rituals
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Ada Taggar-Cohen, Doshisha University
As is well known to those who study Hittite texts, they all originate from royal archives, reflecting the concerns of the ruling elite and the Hittite royal administration. In many cases, Hittite rituals found in those texts also fall under the category of administrative texts, since they were prepared and copied for administrative use, prescribing the enactment of the rituals whenever time demanded their performance.
In this paper I will first try to define the category of royal ideology relating to Hittite cultural texts, and then present the cases showing the manifestation of royal ideology in such categories as hierarchical performances, level of purity prescribed to the performance of rituals, and the use of cloths and specific instruments. Most crucial in hierarchical performance is the relativeness of royalty to the divine presence, in contrast to other participants in the rituals. This paper will relate to textual evidence, but for illustrative purposes will also use some Hittite artifacts demonstrating royalty in ritual contexts.
|
Connecting Threads: Isaiah 48–49 as One Literary Unit
Program Unit: Prophets
Hagit Taragan, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
Chapters 48–49 of Deutero-Isaiah demonstrates the prophet’s way of deriving the most from a “scarcity of materials” According to most researchers, these two chapters reflect two separate periods in the lives of the people and the prophet (The prophecies of chapter 48 were spoken in Babylon, while those of chapter 49 were uttered in the land of Israel). The assumption is that the returning exiles were addressed by the prophet in Babylon in order to encourage their journey. Consequently, they could relate to his words upon reaching the land of Israel. Therefore, the prophet made deliberate use of literary flashes and linguistic terminology with which they were already familiar. In addition, these two chapters embody the complete set of ideas of the entire collection: 1. The standing of God (creation, glory) 2. The notion of a chosen entity (the people of Israel, the messenger, the servant of God). 3. Family relations (God, Zion and the people of Israel) 4. The Exodus as an analogy to the return from Babylon and the joy accompanying the creation and redemption.
. The aim of this lecture is to prove the continuity of the work and the importance of using materials the audience is familiar with, in the design of messages. At the same time, it is acknowledged, that each word appearing in the text sometimes harbors additional meanings. Therefore, the position, the grammatical form, the lexical surroundings and the association which these conjure are highly significant. In fact, all of these factors operate in the entire collection of prophecies in Isaiah 40-66.
|
Gender Matters in the Patristic Exegesis of the Resurrection Narratives
Program Unit: Biblical Women in Patristic Reception
Andrea Taschl-Erber, Universität Graz
*The Easter accounts of the gospels presenting women as the recipients of the first commission to announce the resurrection seem to have caused gender trouble for patristic exegetes, since this portrayal stood in contradiction to the dominant gender constructions and power structures in a patriarchal setting. Several examples of patristic readings show the strategies that were developed in order to maintain the established gender roles where women were forbidden to teach. Pejorative gender stereotypes discredit the apostolic testimony of the women at the tomb that is seen as a compensation of Eve’s disobedience or representing the church’s apostolic mission. A special focus will be laid on the moralistic and typological interpretations of the noli me tangere. Especially the Latin fathers’ readings contributed to the image of the Magdalene as sinner in the Western tradition. However, there are also scholars standing out from the mainstream exegesis.
|
". . . To the Third and Fourth Generation . . ." (Deut 5:9)
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
Johannes Taschner, Independent Scholar
2014 as a year of memory throughout Europe shows again how the effects of the two World Wars of the last century are still to be traced up until our days. This is true for the political level as well as the level of personal relationships. How can the canon of the bible help us to understand our history and presence we live in from a theological point of view?
|
The Son of Man in the Gospel of John
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Vladan Tatalovic, University of Belgrade
After very brief comments on still existing approaches to the “Son of Man” problem in the latest scholarship, the presented exposition firstly delineates the relevance of such a research in the Gospel of John, allowing its margins to bear some reflections on putting this exegetical problematic in the focus of the Eastern Orthodox tradition. Further on, beating the drum for its central attempt – to read all the twelve Son of Man sayings in the context of a synchronic approach to the Gospel of John and thus to come out with the significance of this expression for Johannine Christology – it calls for a modification of usual atomistic approach in hitherto interpretations under the similar title. For, only after the recognition of place and function of these logia within the Gospel’s literary body, as it is further argued, they are to be more correctly put in a comparison with those relevant passages that eventually echo attributes of the Son of Man figure in Jewish tradition (Daniel 7, 1 Enoch 37-71, 4 Ezra, 2 Baruch) and early Christian literature (Synoptic Gospels Acts, Revelation). Conclusion runs as follows: the endeavour of reading John’s Son of Man sayings on a synchronic level shows more clearly unique meaning of 'Son of Man' as a revealing figure, whose appearances in the narrative flow of the Gospel may also reflect its significant role within the Johannine community.
|
Bible and Isra'iliyyat in Early Biographies of Muhammad
Program Unit: Quran and Islamic Tradition in Comparative Perspective
Alfons Teipen, Furman University
The early biographical traditions on the life of Muhammad as recorded in texts of the eighth and ninth century CE -- the Sira of Ibn Ishaq (d. 767), the Kitab al-Maghazi of al-Waqidi (d. 822), and the first two volumes of the Kitab al-Tabaqat al-Kabir of Ibn Sa'd (d. 845) -- convey a cohesive picture of the contours of Muhammad’s life and the emerging Muslim community. Yet, upon close inspection, small but sometimes significant differences between these sources can be detected, pointing to different assessments and valuations of Christian and Jewish scriptures. These differences allow for a critical analysis of the narratives' Sitz im Leben, as they provide insight into the conceptualization of revelation, authority, and scripture as conceived by their eighth and ninth century collector-authors. Whereas the earliest extant biography, the Sira of Ibn Ishaq, acknowledges Torah and Gospel as legitimate sources of religious knowledge, the later biographies of al-Waqidi and Ibn Sa'd insinuate that the integrity of Jewish and Christian scriptures is seriously compromised. Thus, Ibn Ishaq frequently refers to the power of Torah, its foreknowledge in general, as well as its foretelling of Muhammad in particular. Later biographies, however, curtail this literary role of Torah: in al-Waqidi, while Jews frequently swear “by the Torah,” on the whole they are less knowledgeable of true religion. Rather, it is the pre-Islamic pagan Arabs who are more knowledgeable. Biblical-prophetic foreknowledge and Jewish-Christian legitimation of authority in earlier biographies is replaced by Islamic authority that not merely supersedes, but occasionally elides biblical authority in later biographies. Furthermore, biblical authority as embodied in institutions and religious political leaders (e.g. the Negus of Abyssinia, Heraclius) becomes Islamic authority in later biographies. This paper suggests that these differences can be attributed to historical developments in late Umayyad and early Abbasid times.
|
“No longer will anyone say that I am crazy” (Sib. Or. 3.817-818) Female Prophets and Disbelief in Their Messages in Ancient Greek and Jewish Texts
Program Unit: The Image of Female Prophets in Ancient Greek and Jewish Literature
Hanna Tervanotko, University of Helsinki
The function of Jewish female prophets remains unsettled. Only four women are portrayed as prophets (Miriam, Deborah, Huldah and Noadiah) in the Hebrew Bible and very little concerning the messages they deliver is known. Merely the message delivered by Huldah is preserved in 2 Kgs 22:15-17 (2 Chr 34:23-28). The later ancient Jewish texts continue dealing with women accessing divine messages with polemics. While more texts attest to women appear to receive divine messages, e.g., Miriam in Liber Antiquitatum Biblicarum and the figure of Sibyl in the Sibylline Oracles, their transmissions of these allegedly divine messages are not believed.
Female prophets are also known in ancient Greek texts. The most prominent example is the Pythia of Delphi who appears as one of the most respected prophets of ancient Greek world. Her messages are generally not contested. Meanwhile, the figure of Cassandra is treated in mixed ways in the texts. While her prophecies appear truthful, she is not believed in the ancient Greek texts. Rather, she is accused of being crazy (e.g., Trojan Women, 169-173, 307-308).
In this paper I will compare the Jewish and Greek female prophets analyzing what is the interplay between gender and disbelief in their prophetic messages. In particular I will ask what influences the depiction of female prophets as unreliable and sometimes insane figures.
|
Flesh and Body in the Gospel of John
Program Unit: Johannine Literature and Docetism (EABS)
Christos Theodorou, Eberhard Karls Universität Tübingen
The key objective of the paper is the explanation of the relationship between flesh and body in the Gospel of John, in order to contribute to the debate on the traits, that could be defined as Docetic, in the Johannine Christology. According to the different passages of the Gospel of John, the body and flesh of Jesus show either divine or human contradictory features, either before or after his Resurrection. Jesus seems to have a divine body that should not be touched (John 20:17) and is comparable to the Temple (John 2:21). It is invisible in the midst of his enemies (John 8:59), able of walking on water (John 6:19) and through locked doors (John 20:26). His enemies fall when Jesus speaks (John 18:6). Jesus’ divine flesh descended from heaven in order to give eternal life (John 6:51-56). The statement about the Word becoming flesh (John 1:14a) is related to the revelation of Jesus’ divine glory (John 1:14b) and to the human sphere, because the flesh is thought of in contraposition to the divine sphere (John 1:13; 3:6; 6:52.63; 8:15; 17:2). Jesus also has a human wounded body (John 20:27) that should be buried (John 19:38.40; 20:12), and is also able to eat after his Resurrection (John 21:13.15). Jesus seems be thought of, in the Gospel of John, both as Docetic and as real man. The paper highlights how the contradictory features of Jesus’ body and flesh allow the reader to see in the real man Jesus his divine glory in the perspective of a present Eschatology.
|
Archaeological Research in Former Concentration Camps: Heritage — Remembering, Commemoration, Learning
Program Unit: Anti-Semitic Readings of the Bible
Claudia Theune-Vogt, University of Vienna
Contemporary archaeology, especially contemporary archaeology of the time of National Socialism and the Second World War, is focussing a rather short period in time. But this archaeology is getting more and more important, because only a few survivors of the concentrations camps are still alive, who can bear witness of the terror of the Nazi regime in general and in particular of the terror in the concentration camps. Concentration camps are archeological sites which were crime scenes - places where a terrorist dictatorship with a racist ideology degraded people to inferior beings. They were forced to slave labour, they were tortured and murdered. Archaeologists have to become active participants in preventing such cruelties from being repeated. The excavated concentration camp crime scenes can serve as memorials for the victims, they can warn and admonish. They can help to teach young people about National Socialism, especially when they lack a direct connection to this periods via parents or grandparents. Archaeological research offers the opportunity to provide artifacts and objects to the memorials and museums to create or enhance places of learning and remembrance.
|
Deuteronomy and the Passover Lamb: A Case of Semantic Overloading?
Program Unit: Pentateuch (Torah)
Christopher J. Thomson, Tyndale House (Cambridge)
It is commonly supposed that Deut 16:7 contradicts Exod 12:9 as to the mode by which the Passover lamb was to be cooked. This paper challenges that assumption and argues that whereas Exod 12:9 specifies that the lamb was to be roasted, the relevant verb (B-SH-L) in Deut 16:7 simply has the general sense “cook.” The alternative interpretation “boil” arises from an unwarranted “overloading” (to use James Barr’s term) of the semantic value of the word with contextual associations in cases where cooking in liquid is clearly in view. Such “overloading” leads even those who argue that the word means “cook” in Deut 16:7 to accept the meaning “boil” elsewhere. However, a thorough study of the relevant passages demonstrates that there is no instance in biblical Hebrew in which the more specific meaning is required, and some in which it would be incongruous. Thus although b. Ned. 49a attests to later diversity in the way in which the verb was used, its description of the superordinate sense as the biblical meaning appears well-founded.
|
Doing a PhD in Jewish Literature in Ancient Times: A Midway between Digital and Classical Resources: The Case of the Edition of the Ottiyot of Rabbi Akiba
Program Unit: Digital Humanities in Biblical Studies, Early Jewish and Christian Studies (EABS)
Apolline Thromas, Université de Lausanne
Nowadays, a PhD student is led by the digital technologies. The actual connected world should be a precious allied to him, however there is still a need for progress, especially in the field of Ancient Jewish Literature. Indeed, numerous documents or resources are not easily reachable online and results lack consistency.
Regarding Rabbinic Literature, the major part of digitalized open sources comes from Israeli’s websites, involving that the user has to be fluent in Modern Hebrew (for example: mechon-mamre.org). Usually, the origin of the manuscript used is not even mentioned. If the student wants to know where the sources comes from, he or his university often has to provide a financial subscription, frequently expensive. That is why the student is pushed to do his researches with classical tools: paper editions, indexes, concordances, etc. This is an obvious lost of time.
If the student has to consult a precise Hebrew manuscript, for instance The Ottiyot of Rabbi Akiba, he will be confronted with a major issue. Hebrew manuscripts are not indexed the same way even in an unique catalogue: sometimes with the Hebrew title, sometimes in translation or some other times in different transliterations. A standardisation of the results would be a better solution than compiling all the catalogue elements.
At the end of a PhD based on a text edition, the crucial question is: how will you publish it? Digital option would be the more efficient way, nonetheless it subsists a lack of formation for social sciences students. Therefore, the most of this production is made by paper edition, which means a partial spreading.
To resume, the aim of this paper is to show how a contemporary PhD student, with a classical biblical formation, has to juggle between classical resources and digital data and to point progress to complete.
|
The Dionysian Clubhouse of C. Fl. F. Aptus and Other Baccheia in Asia Minor
Program Unit:
Hilke Thür, Austrian Academy of Sciences
The house of Aptus on the first view is a luxurious town villa of an upper class Ephesian. Architecture, design and embellishment demonstrate that the owner used the house as a clubhouse of the Dionysian association presided over by him as a priest. The lecture will focus on the special installations in his house and compare them with other clubhouses in the Eastern Mediterranean.
|
Divine Violence Caught on Camera: Negotiating Text and Photography in Broomberg and Chanarin’s Holy Bible
Program Unit: Bible and Visual Culture
David Tollerton, University of Exeter
In June 2013 the London-based artists Adam Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin published Holy Bible, a reprint of the King James Bible with superimposed images taken from the vast photography collection held at the Archive of Modern Conflict. The pairing of (literally) underlined biblical passages with graphic, surreal and disturbing images is consciously intended by the artists to reflect the Israeli philosopher Adi Ophir’s perception of the Bible as both a record of divine violence and a foundation for the oppressive actions of modern governments. This paper will respond to Broomberg and Chanarin’s work by addressing a number of key questions that emerge from encountering Holy Bible. These include: What methods guide the various pairings of image and text, and can broad patterns be discerned across the span of the book as whole? Might Holy Bible positively aid scholars within the academy currently thinking about the depiction of violence in biblical literature? Or might Broomberg and Chanarin’s alignments of text and image be too easily dismissed as a form of selective proof-texting? Finally, how should we make sense of suggestions, raised in media sources such as the BBC and Guardian newspaper (UK), that this is a blasphemous artwork? Holy Bible is one of the most provocative interfaces between the Bible and visual culture to have emerged in recent times and it will be argued in this paper that grappling with its strange and unsettling dynamics is a valuable task for those concerned with the relationship between violence, art and the biblical.
|
Priestly Narration on Mosaic Identity of the Jewish People in the Hellenistic Time
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Sladjana Tomic-Mirkovic, University of South Florida
A very Hellenistic idea that different ethnic groups should come together and unite in order to liberate themselves from Hellenistic imperialism is at heart of the authorized theology of the office of High Priest in Jerusalem of the time. When liberated these different groups should create a new state evoking the United Kingdom of the King Solomon, because they all share a common progenitor, their culture hero Moses.
This paper traces the development of priestly theory on the Mosaic identity of the Jewish people by taking a closer look into the selected narratives of the books of the Kings, Chronicles and Maccabees in Greek. It argues that Ptolemaic High Priests claimed the chain of tradition to Moses through the kings David and Solomon. They are responsible for underlining the link between Exodus tradition and the building of the Temple in Jerusalem (2 Chr 6:1-12). They validated their interpretation as the only true one by relating the stories of Moses as a cultural hero to the law-giving event on Sinai (2 Macc 2:23-32).
|
Ezekiel 36:23c–38 in the Structure and Composition of the Book
Program Unit: Prophets
William Tooman, University of St. Andrews
Ezekiel 36.23c–38 in the Structure and Composition of the Book
|
The Tower of Babel story, Assyria and the anti imperialist message
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Traditions in the Biblical World and Beyond
Benjamin Toro, Universidad de Concepcion
Studies about Genesis 11. 1-9 consider several approaches that underline generally theological interpretations of this story which apparently would have been written during the Exile in Babylon. Nevertheless, in this paper, we would prefer to analyse a new historical interpretation about the original meaning that this story had for the Israelite people when they were under the control of the Neo-Assyrian Empire. Thus, the classical story of the "Tower of Babel" was a dissembled critic against the Ancient Near Eastern concept of imperialism developed by Assyria and perpetuate afterlife in the Biblical world.
|
The Textual History of the Torah in the Second Temple Period
Program Unit: Reception of Scripture in Second Temple Literature
Emanuel Tov, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
This paper focuses on the textual development of the Torah in the period after the appearance of the earliest evidence of the Torah text in 250 BCE. The many branches of the Torah are described as found in biblical manuscripts, translations, tefillin, and rewritten Bible compositions. An attempt is made to describe their development, and attention is also directed to the sacred and authoritative status of these texts.
|
Old Latin Readings (Beuron 91–95) Reflecting Greek Lexical Variants in III–IV Reges
Program Unit: Septuagint Studies
Julio Trebolle, Universidad Complutense de Madrid
The Old Latin version (OL) represents a pre-Lucianic Greek text, very close to the Original Greek (OG) version, which was based on a Hebrew text different from that of the Masoretic tradition and which quite frequently agrees with the Qumran text of Samuel. This textual filiation is the grounds for the critical value of the OL text.
The present paper is part of a larger study on the contribution of the OL in order to reconstruct the OG text of III-IV Reges. Cases in which the OL reflects apparent “additions” of its Antiochean Vorlage were analyzed in a previous paper. In such cases the B text contains kaige “additions” or corrections to the OG text, while the Antiochian text conveys the OG reading to which the kaige reading was juxtaposed.
This paper discusses cases of lexical variants in the OL (34 in kaige section and 8 in non-kaige section) that contribute to recognize the pre-Lucianic reading and reconstruct the corresponding OG text.
|
Catholic Anti-Semitism from the Reformation until the 19th Century
Program Unit: Anti-Semitic Readings of the Bible
Wolfgang Treitler, Universität Wien
Catholic Anti-Semitism developed step by step from the early Christian writings of the Gospels and the Church Fathers, and it reached one of his peaks in the Middle Age at the Fourth Lateran Council (1215) and its aftermath. It was passed on by Catholic representatives and theologians as well as by preachers. There are three men that cannot be ignored in this respect:
Pope Paul IV (1476-1559) forced the Jews in his bull "Cum nimis absurdum" to live in ghettos, and he renewed the command of the Fourth Lateran Council that forced the Jews to wear specific clothes when appearing in public.
The famous and notorious preacher of the Augustine Order, Abraham a Sancta Clara (1644-1709), identified the Jews with Judas Iskariot and preached against both full with hatred. To him Jews were “stubborn people” and “outrageous beasts” like the traitor of Christ.
The founder of the "Wiener Kirchenzeitung", Sebastian Brunner (1814-1893) preached and wrote against Jews, the Talmud, and what he called "the Jewish hatred of the Cross". He strongly opposed the political emancipation of the Jews. Later the National Socialists considered him one of the important men of their own anti-Semitic tradition.
|
"Dieses Land Frisst Seine Bewohner": Das Gerücht von Num 13:32 in Aharon Appelfelds Roman Der Mann, der Nicht Aufhörte zu Schlafen
Program Unit: Modern Jewish Receptions of the Bible
Wolfgang Treitler, Universität Wien
*
|
"Gottes-Rede" in the Gospel of John
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Veronika Burz-Tropper, Universität Wien
The proposed paper will present the project “Gottes-Rede im Johannesvangelium” (by 23th of June funded by the Austrian Science Fund FWF as Hertha-Firnberg-Project at the University of Vienna). “Gottes-Rede” – that is Theo-logy in the strict sense of the word – has come less into view in New Testament scholarship compared to Christology, ecclesiology and pneumatology, soteriology and eschatology. The project focuses on the Fourth Gospel as an example for a specific New Testament document and its statements on God.
My main research questions are: What does the Gospel of John say about God? This means: What does Jesus as “the only one who is God” say about God in the Gospel of John? Which images, motifs and tradition can be depicted? Which general aspects can be summarized in a synthetic approach analyzing (ho) theos in the Gospel of John?
For this purpose the Gospel’s present final form will be analyzed. The last verse of the Prologue (John 1:1-18) explicitly reveals Jesus as the exegete of the Father: “No one has ever seen God, (the) only one who is God, who is in the bosom of the Father, he reported/interpreted/revealed.”. Assuming that the prologue functions as opening of the Gospel and therefore decidedly gives a reading guide, the words of Jesus concerning God ought to be examined, since they work on an intratextual level.
In the paper I will present my motivation for choosing the Forth Gospel for a study concerning Theo-logy as well as the state of research in the johannine God-theme. Furthermore I will elaborate my methodical approach and my research questions as well as the aims and the expected benefits of the project that should result in a full and synthetic view of “Gottes-Rede” in the Gospel of John.
|
What’s in a Name? Epigraphic Evidence of Anthroponyms and the Reconstruction of the Socio-Cultural Context of the Pauline Communities
Program Unit: Pauline Literature (EABS)
Ekaterini G. Tsalampouni, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki
Anthroponyms are a fascinating and quite valuable piece of epigraphic evidence and their significance has been highlighted by historians of the ancient world and epigraphists. They give evidence for the origins, the status, the family history, and the social expectations of those who bear them. Moreover, they contribute to the reconstruction of social networks and of the micro-history of particular ancient urban communities. Despite their importance, it seems that the knowledge resulting from their study has not been adequately employed in the discussion of the socio-cultural context of the Pauline communities. In the present paper the possibility of their utilization and the methodological issues closely related to it are discussed. In the first part of the paper the potential as well as the limits of this kind of epigraphic evidence will be dealt with. A particular emphasis will be laid on the methodological framework within which the epigraphic testimony of personal names should be processed when venturing any reconstruction of the socio-cultural landscape of the Graeco-Roman towns. In the second part the insight gained from this methodological discussion will be applied to particular epigraphic instances and an attempt will be made to demonstrate through them how the anthroponymic information harvested from these inscriptions can contribute to a better understanding of the local context of the Pauline communities.
|
Ark of Salvation or a “Ship of Fools”: A Catholic/Protestant Debate in De Jure Praedae (1606) of Hugo Grotius
Program Unit: The Bible in the Iberian World: Fundaments of a Religious Melting Pot (EABS)
Sofia Valdez Tuma, New University of Lisbon
The jurist Hugo Grotius (1583-1645) is often regarded as one of the founding fathers of International Law, and of the First Dutch Empire in the seventeenth century. He first develops his natural rights and contract theories in On the Law of Prize and Booty (De Jure Praedae), and publishes its twelfth chapter as Mare Liberum (The Free Sea) in 1609. Legal scholarship considers this treaty a response to a set of eminently practical problems faced by the Dutch East India Company. This paper argues that the purpose of the Dutch jurist is deeper than a merely legal and economic dispute between the Dutch and the Portuguese (at that time under the Spanish Crown). It is, in fact, a theological treaty that
promote the Protestant faith against the Catholic one. Following his arguments, the Portuguese merchant ship Santa Catarina is, indeed, a “Ship of Fools”, a symbol quite common in early-modern iconography. It is related to the Biblical “foolish virgins” (Mt 25: 1-13), and serves to parody the “Ark of Salvation”, as the Catholic Church was styled. This paper intends to analyze the interpretation of the Bible in a legal work, and the reason why we may say that Grotius’ work became one of the most effectives of the Protestant Reformation.
|
How Is Justice Referred to Faith? Some Reflections on the Term Dikaios in New Testament Writings
Program Unit: Israel and the Production and Reception of Authoritative Books in the Persian and Hellenistic Period (EABS)
Christina Tuor, Universität Basel
Taking the question of an interrelationship between the concepts of justice and torah, this paper examines anthropological aspects. The writings of the First Testament include the idea that those living their life by Torah are righteous (hebr. zaddik). Pious and righteous are interchangeable terms here. The righteous man is one who fulfils God's commandments (e.g. Psalm 37, 30f.). Righteousness similarly implies reciprocity: he who follows God's decrees will be made righteous (e.g. Ez 18.9). At the same time, however, he also exercises righteousness vis-à-vis fellow humans.
In Hellenistic Jewish texts, "dikaios" corresponds to zaddik. What characterises this – obedience of Torah and hence righteousness – is denoted appropriate behaviour towards God and mankind, but using two different terms: piety towards God and righteousness towards humans. These nuances arise since Hellenistic Jewish writers are developing the significance of the human behaviour required by Torah in a non-Jewish discourse. This influences the understanding of righteousness and what is presented as Torah.
The establishment of a reciprocal relationship between obedience to Torah and righteousness in human behaviour is based, in my opinion, on legal positivism – on the assumption that there is a legislator behind every law. Ever since Solon, this basic understanding that the legislator's voice can be heard in the law, has been a precondition for the interpretation of law (C. Vismann). Hellenistic Jewish authors make extensive use of this understanding with their reference to Moses.
Following on from the Hellenistic Jewish discourse on righteousness as a basic ethical principle (even a cardinal virtue) required by Torah, the mutual relationship between righteousness and faith is to be examined in New Testament writings like Romans and James. Not least, Pauline expressions like "dikaiosyne theou" and "dikaios ek pisteos" are of interest here.
|
Flavius Josephus in the Slavic Realm
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Michael Tuval, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
Coming soon
|
Feminist Interpretation: The Unreachable Model for Ecological Hermeneutics?
Program Unit: Methods in New Testament Studies
Tomasz Twardzilowski, Cardinal Stefan Wyszynski University in Warsaw
During last decades, a number of new methods and approaches have been applied to the interpretation of the Bible. One of them is ecological hermeneutics. This new approach seems to resemble feminist interpretation. Norman Habel has argued that a radical ecological approach to the text involves a basic hermeneutic of suspicion, identification and retrieval. He has observed that this progression bears obvious similarities with feminist interpretation. He has indicated only one difference, namely that of the point of view. However, the differences between the two approaches are more numerous, and they should be properly analysed. This paper aims at answering the following questions: What is ecological hermeneutics? Is it an approach, a method, or indeed hermeneutics as Habel understands it? Does it have a truly scholarly value, or is it only a product of a subjective reading of the text? Finally, possible consequences (both positive and negative) of the ecological reading of the Bible will be presented.
|
The Cry of Stones (Lk 19:39-40) from the Perspective of Ecological Hermeneutics
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Tomasz Twardzilowski, Cardinal Stefan Wyszynski University in Warsaw
The pericope about Jesus' entry to Jerusalem is present in all canonical Gospels. However, the Lukan text has some specific features. In his own material, which does not have parallels in other Gospels, Luke introduced a citation about the cry of stones. This paper evaluates various interpretations of Lk 19:39-40 from the perspective of critically controlled ecological hermeneutics. What is the meaning of the citation in the original context of Hab 2:11? What meaning is given to it by Luke? Is it possible that he wanted to highlight the importance of non-human beings in the praise of the Lord? Do the ‘courageous stones’ stand in opposition to timorous disciples, who ran away scared, when Jesus was betrayed? What could be the implications of Lk 19:39-40 for Luke’s original audience and for modern readers? All these questions should be analysed in a critical way, against the background of the literary structure and theological themes of the Third Gospel, and in the context of modern interest in ecological issues.
|
The Apocalypse of Paul (NHC V,2): A Blueprint for Valentinian Ecstasy?
Program Unit: Nag Hammadi and Gnosticism
Matthew Twigg, University of Oxford
Numerous passages in Valentinian texts testify to ambitions of mystical ascent to the Father in the here and now, yet they are agonizingly opaque regarding how the experience was imagined to take place. This paper proposes that the Apocalypse of Paul was a Valentinian description of such an experience. But more than this, it suggests that the Apocalypse of Paul was designed as a blueprint for Valentinian ecstatic ascent to the Pleroma. Using the Gospel of Philip and the Excerpts of Theodotus to articulate the Valentinian notion of ascent through the heavenly Temple, the paper examines specific features of the text and narrative of the Apocalypse of Paul which indicate such a purpose. Its pseudepigraphy coupled with a de-historicized narrative, its lack of descriptive detail, its allusions to ritual performance, and its language, are all analyzed in light of the text’s proposed function: to provide an experiential blueprint for ecstatic ascent into the heavens. In this way, the Apocalypse of Paul helped to culturally and theologically shape the Valentinian’s expectations and subsequent experience, as well as providing pedagogical assurance in the face of a potentially traumatic and dangerous event.
|
A Literary Fugue in Leviticus 25–27: Sabbaths, Servitude, Covenant, and Redemption
Program Unit: Law and Narrative (EABS)
Shani Tzoref, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
In his comprehensive monograph, The Jubilee from Leviticus to Qumran (VTSup 115; Leiden: Brill, 2007), John S. Bergsma describes a shift in conceptions of the Jubilee year, from the Pentateuch’s socio-economic legislation to eschatological/messianic representations in Second Temple writings. Bergsma notes in passing that Lev 25 lends itself to such eschatological interpretation, but does not expand upon this observation. The current paper extends some of the lines of inquiry raised in Bergsma's work: the significance of sabbatical legislation within the Covenantal construct of Israel's exclusive servitude to God; the relationship of Lev 25 to sabbatical laws in Deuteronomy; and the relationship between Lev 25 and presentations of the Jubilee year in Ezekiel, Isaiah, and Jeremiah. In particular, I examine the use of the word ??? in Lev 25-27, proposing that the use of the root ??? in Lev 26 offers insights into the significance of the sabbatical legislation in ch. 25 and may shed light on the redaction history of these chapters.
|
Images of Ritual and Worshippers – To What Purpose?
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Christoph Uehlinger, Universität Zürich
Ritual providing an essential framework governing the social life of people, and their socially modelled interaction(s) with deities, one may legitimately ask why ritual performances and performers of rituals should be represented in images, thus producing a kind of doubling of reality. I shall frame the problem in theoretical terms, discuss some explanations given in previous scholarship, before discussing some striking examples from the Southern Levant and drawing my own, tentative conclusions.
|
Genesis 22 with Rushkoff and Auerbach
Program Unit: Science Fiction and the Bible (EABS)
Frauke Uhlenbruch, University of Derby
Erich Auerbach describes the Bible as a text that subjects its reader tyrannically. At the same time its stories are fraught with implicit background that is not externalized. Auerbach claims that Biblical stories, such as the binding of Isaac, do not court the reader’s favour; they demand the reader’s subjection to the text and the shaping of her life around it. “If we refuse to be subjected we are rebels”, he writes.
This paper summarises Auerbach’s analysis of Gen 22 in which he shows the story’s implicitness, its mysterious placelessness, which is at the same time totalizing. The paper then engages with Douglas Rushkoff and Liam Sharp’s reading of Gen 22 in the graphic novel “Testament”. The graphic novel turns the biblical story into a Science Fiction narrative, with 3-dimensional characters, a contemporary plotline, dialogue and images. If we follow Auerbach in seeing Akedah as a vague and implicit story demanding interpretation and subjection, the graphic novel seems to respond to this demand, filling the biblical story’s void, transforming it into a Science Fiction piece. It would seem as though “Testament” subjects itself to the Bible. However, the graphic novels rebels on several levels. In its structure it rebels against linear storytelling: the biblical story and its parallel, set in a dystopian near-future, exist simultaneously. On the level of plot, Rushkoff’s protagonists are dissidents who rebel against the status quo. Is “Testament” rebelling against “what’s there” in the Bible or is it rebelling with the Bible?
This paper highlights Rushkoff’s and Sharp’s interpretive moves and discusses whether an act of interpretation is an act of subjection to the Bible or an act of rebellion against it, and whether the Bible’s potential to become a meaningful SF narrative is inherent in it or in its interpreter.
|
Empirical Evidence for Scribal Additions in the Scrolls, the MT, the SP, and the LXX
Program Unit: Editorial Techniques in the Hebrew Bible in Light of Empirical Evidence (EABS)
Eugene Ulrich, University of Notre Dame
Given the post-Qumran knowledge that the MT is no longer the center of the Hebrew Bible textual world, all serious study must compare the witness of the Scrolls, the MT, the SP, and the LXX with an egalitarian approach. Each at times shows "original" readings, and each at other times shows scribal additions sparked by a variety of motives, such as clarification, additional information, or routine phraseology.
This paper will examine readings in the Scrolls, the MT, the SP, and the LXX in which one tradition exhibits a gloss or minor addition not contained in another tradition, in order to discover the scribe’s motive and the technique employed. The results may inform the question whether similar glosses or additions can be detected in passages where no textual evidence of the earlier, non-glossed reading is preserved.
|
The Proverbs Tradition in Late Second-Temple Judaism
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Wisdom
Elisa Uusimäki, Helsingin Yliopisto - Helsingfors Universitet
The purpose of this paper is to reconsider what constitutes the Proverbs tradition in the late Second Temple literature, and to examine those texts that are of primary significance for the understanding of its status and role. The Wisdom of Solomon shows that the Proverbs tradition and the figure of Solomon had a Nachleben in Greek-speaking Judaism, where it became merged with the influence of Hellenistic philosophy. Fresh Hebrew evidence for the tradition is provided by the Dead Sea Scrolls. In addition to the Book of Proverbs manuscripts (4Q102–103, 103a), two wisdom texts make prominent use of Proverbs 1–9. In 4QWiles of the Wicked Woman (4Q184), the passages on the evil women have been reworked in order to solve the question of righteous sin (Michael Lesley 2012), while a ”Torah-adjustment” to the instruction of Proverbs can be observed in 4QBeatitudes (4Q525) (Elisa Uusimäki 2013). Thus, all the aforementioned compositions reused and added something new to Proverbs. They enhanced the gradually increasing authority of Proverbs; the source was regarded as worth interpreting to a contemporary audience, in both Palestine and the Diaspora. On the other hand, they should also be included in the Proverbs tradition in an era when there was no fixed canon and the status of the ketuvim was in a state of flux. Finally, the focus on Proverbs 1–9 in 4Q184 and 4Q525 might suggest that this unit was circulating as a study tool of some sort.
|
The Tradition of the Book of Daniel in Early Christianity, in the light of Iconography Contribution: A Methodological Proposal
Program Unit: Iconography and Biblical Studies (EABS)
Celeste Valenti, Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore (Milano)
Although the influence of the Book of Daniel in the development of Middle Judaism and Early Christian thought is unanimously admitted, the topic seems problematic primarly by reason of the text structure, which redaction is cronologically stratified and which unitary circulation has often been called into question. Moreover, in the matter of the method adopted, the research has so far been conducted by exclusively considering the literary evidences, which have revealed a clear preponderance of the so-called “eschatological sections” of the Book, at the expense of “narrative chapters” (the most attested passages concerne “the Son of Man” – Dn 7,13 –; “the Kingdom of God” – Dn 2,44 – and the “tribulation” – for example Dn 9,27 –; among the other contributions, see R. Bodenmann, Naissance d’une Exégèse. Daniel dans l’Église ancienne de trois premiers siècles, Tübingen 1986). The exam of coeval iconography allows a considerable extention and a substantial redefinition of the scenario, showing the widespread circulation of figurative subjects and themes signally ascribable to the “narrative sections” of the Book (chapters 3,6,13,14). The evidence, on the one hand, underlines the necessity to call into discussion the remarkable predominance of “eschatological” passages in Early Christian reception, which must have more likely included every section of the text; on the other hand, the analysis of iconographic exegesis highlights the coexistence of different hermeneutic techniques concerning the same Book. If literature approaches “prophetic” materials is an allegorical way (this perspective is necessarily required by the passages nature, since they refer to future), iconography adopts typological hermeneutic, connecting the history of Daniel and his companions narrated in First Testament to passio Christi and to martirial experiences of communities.
|
Strong Women Confront Helpless Men
Program Unit: Midrash, Halakhah and Reception
Shulamit Valler, Jewish History University of Haifa
In this lecture I will discuss the midrashim that evolved around Deborah and Jephthah's daughter, two women involved in the war stories of the book of Judges.
In the Hebrew Bible the roles and the images of these two women are entirely different than in the midrashim. The midrashic commentators, however,structure those images in a way that shows their similarities. In so doing,they express an interesting worldview concerning everything connected with
the female image and role, as against those of the male. I shall try to show the differences between the Hebrew Bible and the Midrash in the midrashists’perceptions of Deborah and Jephthah's daughter, beginning with the Bible.
|
Paragraph Division in the Acts of Codices Sinaiticus and Bezae
Program Unit: Textual Criticism: Manuscripts & Methods
Ronald van der Bergh, University of Pretoria
This paper investigates paragraph divisions in the Acts of the Apostles of Codex Sinaiticus and Codex Bezae Cantabrigiensis. The need for such an inquiry is evident in the degree of difference between the paragraph divisions in these two manuscripts. In its extant portions of the Acts of the Apostles, Bezae contains circa 225 instances of paragraph division, indicated by ekthesis. In these same portions of Acts (1:1-8:29a, 10:14b-21:2a, 21:10b-21:16a, 21:18b-22:10a, 22:20b-22:29a), Sinaiticus contains circa 234 paragraph divisions, indicated by both ekthesis and the use of the pa????af?? (i.e. the “paragraph-marker”). The paragraph divisions of the two manuscripts agree in only 104 (or less than 50%) of these cases. This paper will consist of two parts: First, an overview of the grounds for paragraph division in each of the manuscripts will be given. These grounds for paragraph divisions will be sorted into categories deduced from an analysis of the start of each paragraph in the respective manuscript (e.g. narrative shift of time, narrative shift of place, introduction to direct speech). In the case of both Sinaiticus and Bezae, the paper will clearly show that scribes relied on specific key terms when deciding on new paragraph divisions in the text. The second part of the paper will consist of a short comparison and reflection on the differences in paragraph division between these two manuscripts. Despite the differences between them, the analysis will demonstrate that both manuscripts used similar and “consistent” criteria for paragraph division.
|
The Spirituality of “Seeing God” in the First Epistle of John
Program Unit: Johannine Literature
Dirk van der Merwe, University of South Africa
Apophatic theology and cataphatic theology occur both in the corpus Johanneum to describe the character of God. Apophatically the Gospel, as well as the first epistle of John, state that “nobody has ever seen God.” While cataphatically, Jesus teaches in the Gospel that “Whoever has seen me has seen the Father” and in 1 John we read that after the parousia has taken place “What we do know is this: when he is revealed, we will be like him, for we will see him as he is.” This essay focusses on the cataphatic phrase “we will see Him as he is” (1 Jn 3:2). This investigation is, due to the variety of interpretations of this particular phrase as well as the spirituality which it could have evoked among the readers of this epistle. In order to get more clarity the investigation starts to investigate what the seeing of a divine being in the Graeco-Roman world meant and comprises of. The same applies for Judaism and the New Testament. This phrase is then, with this inter-textural background in mind, investigated in its immediate linguistic, literary, historical and Johannine eschatological contexts.
|
Authority and Influence in Biblical Texts: A Summary
Program Unit: Authority and Influence in Ancient Times
Jan van der Watt, Radboud Universiteit Nijmegen
An overview of the papers read at the two meetings of this unit will be given followed with group discussion
|
“Get the Picture?” Apocalyptic Literature Viewed in an African Artistic Context
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
Hans van Deventer, North-West University (South Africa)
Images of an apocalyptic nature are foreign to many of Africa’s mythologies. Sure, there are stories in which mythic animals appear, but these cannot be group together under a common rubric such as apocalyptic images. The traditional African worldviews were much more interested in the here and now of everyday existence. The introduction of the Bible to the African continent led to transactions taking place between traditional and new ideas. In some instances the traditional was allowed a level footing with what was view as essentially a superior culture. In many cases, however, the European culture overran and undermined traditional African views.
This paper investigates how apocalyptic literature was, and is received in the (South) African context. The focus specifically falls on representations from the book of Daniel in works of art. By studying this medium of communication I wish to draw attention to how on the one hand traditional mythologies informed an understanding of a foreign concept such as apocalyptic literature. On the other hand I wish to establish how this medium of expression borrowed from the very culture that presented these new ideas in order to come to grips with a new phenomenon.
|
"Trial by Fire?" The (Re)Use of Some Joban Metaphors in Medieval Theology and Art
Program Unit: Metaphors in the Hebrew Bible/Old Testament and Their Reception
Pierre Van Hecke, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
In the Low Countries of the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries, a very particular iconography of the Biblical figure of Job emerged, namely one in which Job carries a burning fire in one of his hands. The origin and meaning of this motif is still unclear, and therefore the motif has often been overlooked or has not been correctly recognized. In this presentation, it will be shown that this iconography should be understood against the background of the early and medieval Christian commentaries and theological literature, in particular the 'Moralia in Job' by Gregory the Great. This literature creatively interpreted and (re)used some of the Joban metaphors having fire or light as source domain. This lecture will trace the long and winding journey these biblical metaphors have made through centuries of theological literature, ultimately finding their way in late-Medieval art. It will be demonstrated that in different contexts the same imagery may acquire very different meanings, which may at times be remote from the meaning they had in the original biblical text. This shows not only the creativity of the later authors reusing existing metaphors, but also the flexibility and richness of the metaphors themselves.
|
Men of All Languages Will Take Hold of a Jew: Authority Claims in Zechariah 8
Program Unit: Authority and Influence in Ancient Times
Hans van Nes, Evangelische Theologische Faculteit, Leuven
Zech 8, the final chapter of what has traditionally been called Proto-Zechariah, depicts the restoration of Jerusalem and culminates in a global motivation to pilgrimage to Jerusalem. The final verse promises that any Judean will be encircled by ten pilgrims from different nations and tongues, who will humbly grasp the hem of his garments and like novices they will beg him for permission to follow him. ‘For’, they shall argue, ‘we have heard that God (Elohim) is with you (plural, i.e. with your people)’. Evident as the phrase ‘God with you/us’ may sound today, is a rare Hebrew expression, certainly with the name Elohim, which is fitting in this universalist setting. It is not the only instance where this notion of ‘God with someone’ yields submission and acknowledgment of authority and leadership. Yet it may be the only place where it happens through a vision of universal acknowledgment of the authority of the Judeans, because reportedly, God is with them. This paper investigates the notion that ‘God is with us/you’ as powerful rhetoric to exercise authority and leadership both in this passage and in similar instances outside Zechariah.
|
How Jesus Was Identified as the Coming Lord
Program Unit: Psychological Hermeneutics of Biblical Themes and Texts
Bas van Os, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam
The identification of Jesus as the Coming Lord is a very clear and early indicator of divine status attributed to Jesus by some of his earliest followers. In this paper I will argue that this identification is likely to have been made first in Palestine in the immediate aftermath of the crucifixion. Next, I will draw on the Role Theory and Coping Theory to show how both the historical Jesus and his earliest followers may have contributed to this identification.
|
No Performance Criticism without Narrative Criticism
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Geert Van Oyen, Université Catholique de Louvain
Many are the books that explain the obvious traces of oral transmission in the years that precede the writing of the text of Mark’s gospel. But since we lack clear information about the concrete circumstances of this oral transmission and about the concrete way the gospel was performed as a whole in this pre-textual stage, the value added by performance criticism and by “performing” the gospel nowadays is most of all pastoral and catechetical. In this paper it is argued that in order to perform the gospel, one first has to do narrative criticism of the text, because it is through insight in story and discourse that the performer can prepare the oral performance. This becomes especially visible in those passages where the "subtext" cannot be found at first glance or where the interpretation depends on the understanding of the whole of the gospel. By looking more closely to some examples in Mark that may give rise to plural interpretations – for instance the round characterization of the disciples; Mark 14:36; 15:34; 15:39; 16:8 – we will examine the possibilities for performance and ask the question of the validity of different performances of the same text. In doing so, we hope to contribute to the issue of "performance as test of interpretation" (D. Rhoads).
|
Aspects of the Translation Technique of Peshitta Ezekiel
Program Unit: Bible and Syriac Studies in Context
Herrie van Rooy, North-West University (South Africa)
The editor of Ezekiel in the Leiden Peshitta, Martin Mulder, described the translation technique of Peshitta Ezekiel as literal. Translation technique is important for understanding a translation, but it involves a variety of aspects. In some aspects a translation may be literal, such as regards word order. In other aspects, such as the translation of rare words, it may be free. This paper will study three issues in this regard, namely the translation of hapax legomena and other rare words, the rendering of questions and the rendering of Hebrew infinitives with the preposition b. With regard to rare words, contextual interpretations play an important role, but translations may also be based on etymological interpretations and the imitation of the sound of the Hebrew. As far as questions are concerned, questions introduced by particles for why, when, who, and what did not cause any problems for the translator. However, as Syriac does not have particles introducing yes/no questions, the translator usually rendered rhetorical questions by corresponding statements. As far as the infinitives are concerned, the Peshitta of Ezekiel tends to render them by participial phrases. This investigation indicates that one has to be very careful about generalizing as far as the translation technique of Ezekiel is concerned.
|
Prophets and Prophecy in Second Temple Judaism
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Donald Vance, Independent Scholar
This paper explores the role of prophets in Jewish life during the Second Commonwealth and the place prophecy had. The relationship of prophets and prophecy to apocalyptic and to the burgeoning sects and groups of Judaism in that era will be explored with a view of elucidating the different paths that Rabbinic Judaism and Early Christianity took vis-à-vis prophecy. The thesis of the paper is that Christianity’s acceptance of prophecy as real and that there were genuine prophets active in the Church had a profound effect on the theology and sociology of the early Church but also on nascent rabbinic Judaism as it reacted against the claims of the Early Church.
|
The Relationship between Law and Prayer in Habakkuk’s Discourse on the Chaldeans
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Law
David Vanderhooft, Boston College
Terminology appropriate to legal discourse appears in key passages in the book of Habakkuk, especially in chapters 1 and 2. Several commentators have recognized elements of this discourse, but they have not fully illumined the forensic nuances of such language or its centrality for the argumentative purpose of the book as a whole. At the heart of chapters 1 and 2 is the prophet’s tokahat, a legally actionable claim against the deity, and the deity’s response to this claim. These both involve assessment of Chaldean imperial depredations. Meanwhile, the third chapter of Habakkuk appeals especially to the language of prayer, in its superscription (tplh), colophon (lmntsh bngynwty), in its use of slh, and in its mode of direct discourse to the deity. The paper argues that the deliberate connections between the two parts of Habakkuk (chapters 1-2 and chapter 3) assume the logical correlation between the legal language and the prayer, and that the book as a whole responds to a fundamental problem in the interpretation of imperial power.
|
Aspects of Rendering the Sacred Tetragrammaton in Greek
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible/Old Testament/Ancient Israel Studies (EABS)
Pavlos Vasileiadis, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki
The proper name of God ???? (YHWH) is given particular distinction throughout the Hebrew Scriptures in comparison to appellations or titles attributed to him. Nevertheless, the pronunciation of the biblical name of God became a persisting taboo. Biblical interpretations, philosophical influences, and religious ordinances within Judaism and subsequently Christianity silenced the utterance of the name. The earliest indications of non-pronouncement of the divine name par excellence among Jews appeared in the 3rd–to–2nd century B.C.E. By the 3rd century C.E. the utterance of the sacred Tetragrammaton had become a capital offence. It is generally held that the name “disappeared” for some centuries before its being rediscovered by Renaissance humanists.
This article attempts to demonstrate that, despite the religious inhibitions, the Tetragrammaton remained an “effable name,” namely, utterable, at least in some circles. A more systematic investigation of the various Greek renderings of the Tetragrammaton is attempted. These renderings are found in amulets, inscriptions, literary works, etc., dating from as early as the first Christian centuries until today. It will be shown that some forms of the Tetragrammaton were actually accepted and used more widely in the Greek religious and secular literature since the Renaissance and especially during the Modern Greek Enlightenment. Also, it will become sufficiently clear that there is no unique or universally “correct” rendering of the Hebrew term in Greek. Of special note are two Greek reconstructions of the Tetragrammaton, one as was heard and written down by a Greek-speaking author of an “adversus Judaeos” work in the early 13th century in South Italy and another one written down at Constantinople in the early 17thcentury—both of them presented for the first time in the pertinent bibliography.
|
Learning through Prayer: Sirach 23:1 in the Context of Hebrew Wisdom and Patristic Interpretation
Program Unit: The Reception of the Scripture in the Patristic Exegesis (II-VIII centuries) (EABS)
Catalin Vatamanu, Universitatea Alexandru Ioan Cuza
The first prayer of Ben Sirach (Sir. 22:27-23:6) is characterized by the request adressed to God to guide his thoughts, words and deeds. Sirach reffers to God as a very familiar person, „Lord, father, and sovereign ruler of my life". The understanding of the divine fatherhood in Sirach 23:1.4 is enlightened by Sirach 4:10, 51:10, and by many other sapiential texts of Hebrew literature. This terminology influenced the Liturgy of Early Church and, also, we see that the Fathers of the Church emphasizing that the essential way to know God is the prayer.
|
Science Fiction, the Bible, and the Narrative Method
Program Unit: Science Fiction and the Bible (EABS)
Harold Torger Vedeler, Central Connecticut State University
Science fiction and religion differ from the practice of science in two important ways: first, effective scientific research is based on observation and interpretation, while science fiction and religion make extensive use of narratives. Second, science fiction and religion both alter and even suspend empirical laws in order to make thematic points. Science fiction does this by either extrapolating known physical principles in hypothetical directions or by rewriting them entirely to achieve a particular effect. In religion, the process takes the form of miracles or divine beings with magical powers that can violate the laws of physics.
I propose that science fiction and the Bible are subordinate to what we may call the “narrative method.” In science, facts are paramount and the system is open-ended, in that any hypothesis can be disproven should enough empirical data appear supporting an alternative explanation. There are no final conclusions, only tentative ones. In the scientific view of the world, events play out following natural laws and without conscious direction, and the scientific method is designed to evaluate these laws and explain how they work, not to give them meaning.
In the narrative method, facts are secondary to story. Since a story closed-ended, its facts need only to be internally consistent rather than having to accommodate all empirical laws. Only information which is relevant to the story’s plot and theme is important. In the case of the Bible and science fiction, the physical universe is highly fluid, not only allowing for the miraculous, but frequently requiring it. As a result, both biblical and science fiction texts using the narrative method are less likely to be accurate representations of the empirical world, but at the same time are able to provide thematic meaning in a way that texts using the scientific method cannot.
|
Peter’s Use of Anantirretos (Acts 10:29) and the Phenomenon of “Emergence” in the Leadership Philosophy of Margaret Wheatley: An Ancient-Future Clue to Leading in the Church?
Program Unit: Authority and Influence in Ancient Times
Jan Venter, Radboud University Nijmegen
In this part of the dialogue between Peter and Cornelius, Peter uses this singular word to define his reaction to the supernatural revelation that brought him to the house of Cornelius. In the unfolding narrative several religious and cultural taboos were broken and Peter finds himself in a strange place, with people he does not know and still without an idea of what will be happening next; “I ask therefore for what intent ye have sent for me?”
The development of Quantum Theory in Physics (and all its derivatives) was a revolutionary step forward in the way physicists viewed and interacted with their object of study. The notion that, on subatomic level, matter and energy have the properties of both waves and particles represented an absolutely new way and birthed a completely new science. In fact, a fundamentally new way to view reality. From these principles and phenomena Margaret Wheatley developed her leadership philosophy in an interdisciplinary “crossover” from pure science to social science, in a sense a “quantum leap” of it’s own.
“Emergence” forms one of the key facets of her leadership philosophy. Emergence is the surprising capacity we discover when we connect within and between systems. New systems come into being and completely new properties and capacities appear mysteriously and unpredictably in the process. The emergent properties are not present in the individuals in the system or the system itself. “An emergent world welcomes us as conscious participants and surprises us with discovery. Our plans are nothing to what the world so willingly gives us.” (Wheatley, 1996. P 75)
This paper explores a possible interdisciplinary connection between the events in the narrative and the phenomenon of emergence as employed by Wheatley. Do we perhaps find in this connection an ancient clue to the modern challenges of leadership?
|
Blessings and Curses in the Primeval History (Genesis 1–11): Stylistic Patterns and Their Ideological Motivation
Program Unit: Stylistics and the Hebrew Bible
Karolien Vermeulen, University of Antwerp
In the Hebrew Bible, blessings and curses are prominently present. As Anne Marie Kitz points out in her recent work 'Cursed Are You: The Phenomenology of Cursing in Cuneiform and Hebrew Texts' (Eisenbrauns, 2013), curses play a vital role, for all members of ancient society, in coping with life. Likewise, blessings serve to protect the beneficiaries from possible evil. The efficacy of both actions is best illustrated by the euphemistic use of the blessing when relating the cursing of God (e.g. in the story of Naboth and Ahab, 1Kgs 21:13).
Following the work of Kitz, I will argue in this paper that the composers of the biblical text were influenced by the ideology underlying blessings and curses when making stylistic choices with regard to them. A case study of the verbs "barakh," "to bless," and "'arar" and "qalal," both "to curse," in Genesis 1-11 will make this clear.
In this passage, several stylistic patterns can be distinguished for the occurring blessings and curses. These patterns can be subdivided into individual, that is, typical of curses or blessings only, and relational forms, that is, connecting both actions with one another. Furthermore, patterns may be consistent throughout the passage or transforming. Especially the latter is of interest here. Whereas previous research suggests that blessings and curses follow typical, even stereotypical, features (the features referred to do not necessarily coincide with the features as addressed in this paper), this paper will argue that also the deviations from the pattern are ideologically motivated and thus, equally important as the pattern itself.
|
Sansinnayv (Song 7:9) and the Palpal Noun Pattern
Program Unit: Writings (including Psalms)
Eran Viezel, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
The word sansinnayv (Song of Songs 7:9) is a hapax legomenon and there is no scholarly consensus about its meaning. sansinnayv belongs to the class of noun pattern termed palpal. In my paper I will maintain that some of the words of the palpal noun pattern share a common semantic characteristic. This characteristic enables us to determine the precise meaning of the word sansinnayv.
|
Interpretation in the Church as Fundamental Principle of Patristic Exegesis
Program Unit: The Reception of the Scripture in the Patristic Exegesis (II-VIII centuries) (EABS)
Marian Vild, The Romanian Academy, Iasi branch
This paper aims to explore the ecclesial nature of patristic exegesis , which is often overlooked by the modern readership. The awareness of belonging to the Body of Christ and the mission of preaching the Word for the edification of this Mystical Body are tightly linked to one another in patristic thought. Thus, whereas the first part of the study analyzes some of texts of the Fathers whereby the ecclesial framework of the Scripture's reading and interpretation is illustrated, the second part focuses on specific aspects of patristic exegesis that best exemplify the ecclesial nature of their interpretation. John Chrysostom considers that the Church keeps together faith and kerygma, thing that can be easily noticed about the Fathers, who did not interpret and preach the Scripture for academic or didactic reasons, but put exegesis into the service of Christian life. Therefore, these authors did not use a double hermeneutic - one for specialists and one for people of God. In Irinaeus' view, the Scriptures are trees full of fruit in the Garden of Eden, i.e. in the Church. Tasting the Scriptures' fruit with an uplifted mind leads to heresy. Only the ecclesial framework of the Scripture's interpretation can guarantees an edifying exegesis. Furthermore, a large part of the patristic exegesis consists of homilies - sermons held in the church for the congregation. The superficial manner in which the Fathers sometimes approached certain biblical texts, while focusing much more on others, highlights the pastoral purpose of their exegesis. They interpreted the biblical texts that were the most relevant for the spiritual needs of their audience. Consequently, in patristic thought, the aim of exegesis does not limit to "intentio auctoris", but has in view the "acquisition of virtue", as Gregory of Nyssa expresses it. Patristic exegesis is simultaneously "in Ecclesia" and "pro Ecclesia".
|
The Foundation of East Syrian Monasteries on Private Landed Estates in the Late Sasanian and Early Islamic Periods
Program Unit: Bible and Syriac Studies in Context
Cynthia Villagomez, Winston-Salem State University
In the late Sasanian and Early Islamic periods, established East Syrian monasteries in the Church of the East in Iraq and Iran gained financial security through generous endowments of money and landed property given to them by wealthy lay, ecclesiastical and monastic patrons. However, in addition to this patronage of existing monasteries, other important patterns of monastic financial security helped to secure economic stability within East Syrian monastic networks during the sixth and seventh centuries. This paper will examine the prevalence of the establishment of monastic communities on the private landed estates of founders. The main argument the paper develops is that economic stability and self-sufficiency on such monasteries allowed the founders more power to organize and maintain monastic communities engaged in the care of orphans and the education of youth. One case-study that will be discussed in greater depth is the monastery of Babai the Great.
|
An Isma'ili Reading of Prophetic Stories: Ja'far b. Mansur al-Yaman's Attempt
Program Unit: Quran and Islamic Tradition in Comparative Perspective
Roy Vilozny, The Hebrew University & Tel Aviv University
In my talk, I will try to demonstrate how the Isma'ili author and missionary Ja'far b. Mansur al-Yaman (d. c. 960) makes use of biblical quotations to explain the secret dimension of the prophetic role in human history. According to him, it is only in light of the Isma'ili cyclical vision of the history of humanity – from the creation of the first man to the end of time – and the complex structure of the universe, that one is able to decipher the hidden aspect of the prophetic mission. I will base my presentation on an analysis of selected paragraphs from the Sara'ir al-nutaqa' and Asrar al-nutaqa' (both titles can be translated as "The Secrets of the Speaking Prophets") which are attributed to Ja'far. The two texts provide an esoteric, Isma'ili interpretation (ta'wil) of prophetic stories and are exceptionally rich in biblical quotations and pseudo-biblical references. Unlike other Islamic sources that use biblical quotations for polemic reasons, the author of these texts interprets passages from the Bible and Gospels as legitimate parts of a universal esoteric truth, consciously avoiding the usual accusations of falsification ascribed to Jews and Christians.
|
The Impact of Christian Philanthropy on Roman Welfare
Program Unit: Early Christianity and the Ancient Economy
Mihai Vinatoru, Orthodox Faculty of Theology, Bucharest
By studying the works of Seneca, Cicero, Plutarch and other ancient authors, we can outline the general cultural context that existed in the Roman Empire during the birth and spread of Christianity. In a world dominated by social inequality, very limited access to scientific knowledge and large discrepancies between rich and poor, as the Greco-Roman world of the first century was, the care for poor people was hardly a priority for the Empire. The welfare of the city and its inhabitants seems to be weighted from a socio-political perspective, lacking the humanitarian dimension. There are several programs in progress such as the “frumentariae” and “alimenta”, used by the State to provide food at discounted prices or even for free but their target was not especially towards poor people. The paper will also tackle the patrona-client relations existing inside the roman society, to grasp a better understanding of the motivations behind private and public charity. From a biblical perspective, the material in Luke-Acts will be used to provide insights regarding the expansion of Christianity in the Greco-Roman world and the realities the first Christians encountered. I suggest the inclusion of this study in the first project of this section, as it involves a study of major aspects of the economy in the ancient world, especially the Roman Empire.
|
St. Luke and the Johannine Tradition regarding the Passion Narratives
Program Unit: The Relation Between Luke’s and John’s Gospel (EABS)
Mihai Vinatoru, Orthodox Faculty of Theology, Bucharest, Romania
The synoptic gospels are not a monolithic body in comparison with John. A careful reader is able to spot several pericopes that contain unexpected differences among the first three evangelists and visible similitudes of some of them with the fourth. Luke agrees with John against both Matthew and Mark, suggesting that a relationship of some type exists between these two gospels. This may indicate a dependence of John upon Luke, although the textual evidence against such a hypothesis are consecrated and generally accepted by modern biblical scholars. The fact that Luke agrees closely with Matthew and Mark in those pericopes that he shares only with them, but deviates from their traditions in the direction of the Johan’s account in almost every pericope that he shares with all three of his co-evangelists would seem to suggest that this is a critical problem that should be re-examined. The case study of this research paper is focused on the Passion Narratives as reported by both Luke and John, compared to Matthew and Mark. This fragment include 25% of the pericopes Luke has in common with the other two synoptic authors and at the same time a large number of the Lukan divergences from the Matthean/ Markan traditions and the Lukan agreements with John against Matthew/ Mark occur in these passages. The suggested solution for this tension is a certain familiarity of Luke with some form of the developing Johannine tradition or even to his acquaintance with an early draft of the original Gospel of John.
|
Luke 10 as Meeting Point of the Synoptics and Vorlage for John 11–12
Program Unit: The Relation Between Luke’s and John’s Gospel (EABS)
Vadim Wittkowsky, Theological Seminary of Russian Methodist Church
1. Luke 10:25-42 can be reasonably understood as a Lukan dialogue with the Jewish Christianity, whereby vv. 25-29 arose mostly on the base of Matt 22:35-40 (known to Luke along with the parallel pericope Mark 12:28-34).
2. What the Lukan nomikos is quoting, is de facto Matt 22:37.39 as „the (Jewish-Christian) Law“, which concurs with the claim of Matthean Sermon on the Mount (Matt 5:17): Jesus is giving to his people the “completed” version of the Torah, obviously represented in the form of the Gospel of Matthew itself.
3. Martha and Mary in Luke 10:38-42 are allegories of Jewish and Pagan Christianity, which are mediated through the names of both persons known to Luke as (at least supposed) authors of both Gospels, which he used in his own book: Matthew and Mark.
4. A comparison between Luke 10 und John 11-12 shows that John had no common source with Luke but used Luke itself, whereby he geographically rightly understood the Lukan description of the journey to Jerusalem and corrected his own narrative following specific features of Lukan Gospel (a second Bethany on Jesus’ way from Galilee to Judaea in John 1:28, cf. “the same place” in John 10:40-42 just before turning to Lazarus and both sisters – already known to John’s reader from Luke and Mark – in John 11:1).
5. Mary, Martha, and Lazarus are allegorical figures in John too (correlating with Lukan view on Mark and Matthew and with the “Lazarus’“ – i.e. Luke’s – Gospel itself), which testifies that the author of the Fourth Gospel understood the allegorical character of Luke 10:25-42 and thus the hidden sense of this passage.
|
Mark Used Q, Luke Used Matthew: Reconstruction of a Lost Source and Its Problems (A Response to Dennis R. MacDonald)
Program Unit: Synoptic Gospels
Vadim Wittkowsky, Theological Seminary of Russian Methodist Church
In his new book “Two Shipwrecked Gospels” (SBL 2012) Prof. Dennis MacDonald tries to reconstruct a lost source behind the three Synoptic Gospels, which is “Q-like” but not Q of IQP. Indeed it is plausible that Mark, Matthew and Luke share an earlier source, and still more plausible that Luke used Matthew. But how can we be sure about the reconstruction of this lost book? Several years ago Q was reconstructed by Ron Price (USA) on the same premises: Mark (and not only Matthew and Luke) used Q, and Luke used Matthew (and not only Mark and Q). However, his reconstruction looks like very different.
Not only sources of the New Testament authors are important for a reconstruction but also their purposes by writing/compiling books about Jesus. One main problem is that we cannot know what purpose had an author absolutely unknown to us. Certainly there are more problems because we can know neither the real extent of a lost source nor its exact wording.
Must we remain sceptical? It seems to be a sound way to deal with the Synoptic Problem in two methodological steps: firstly, we have to bring forward solid arguments for certain chronological order and relationships of existing and lost texts; secondly, we have to find portions which belonged originally to a lost source rather than to be invented by Mark, Matthew or Luke. It would be enough for understanding Synoptic Gospels on the level we really need.
Critical comments to some points of reconstruction of Dennis MacDonald will be added.
|
Who Wrote Q? The Sayings Document (Q) as the Apostle Matthew's Private Notebook as a Bilingual Village Scribe (Mk 2:13-17; Matt 9:9-13)
Program Unit: Gospel of Mark
Benedict Viviano, Université de Fribourg - Universität Freiburg
This paper is of an exploratory character. It is interested in Q as a source for information about the teaching of John the Baptist and Jesus. It studies the use of private notebooks in Judaism, the nature of Q in modern scholarship, the call of Levi-Matthew, different kinds of scribes, Levitical education, the logia in Papias and Matthew's rewriting of Mark 2:13-17. It concludes that Matthew/Levi was a bilingual scribe who listened to speakers in Aramaic and took his notes in Greek. These Greek notes of the bilingual scribe became the basis for the earliest elements in Q.
|
The Two Arabic Scriptures: On the Literary Entanglement of the Quran and the Bible in Arabic
Program Unit: Quran and Islamic Tradition in Comparative Perspective
Ronny Vollandt, Freie Universität Berlin
The Quran and the Bible in Arabic may be called “entangled.” On the one hand, the Quran recollects many biblical narratives that were available orally to the Prophet; on the other hand, the emergence of the Muslim scripture as a distinct and noticeable book presented an impetus to Christians to submit their own to writing in the form of biblical translations into Arabic. This entanglement can be also seen in various other aspects. Some translators clearly shaped their translations according to the linguistic precedents of the Quran. It is not uncommon to find Quranic vocabulary and proper names in Arabic Bibles. Such instances constitute an almost conscious inter-textual allusion to the Quran, the revealed text of the religious majority. One of the most conspicuous examples is encountered in the Joseph narrative in an anonymous translation of the Pentateuch (based on the Peshitta), preserved today in Ms. Sinai, Ar. 2; here, the Arabic of Gen. 37:9 is strikingly similar to the Quranic version in Q. 12:3. In my contribution here, I attempt to gather and analyse similar examples in Ms. Sinai, Ar. 2, as well as other translations of biblical portions in Arabic, of both Christian and Jewish provenance.
|
Emotions and Genres
Program Unit: Emotions and the Biblical World (EABS)
P. von Gemünden, Universität Augsburg
Is there a relationship between the textual presentation and evaluation of emotions and the genre(s) in which they are presented? This question will be examined by focusing on narrative and admonishing texts from the wisdom tradition, especially the Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs.
|
Is Scripture Sacred at Qumran?
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Hanne von Weissenberg, University of Helsinki
The past decade or so has witnessed a change in the way scholars attempt to reconstruct the process that culminated in the emergence of the Hebrew Bible. Many of the assumptions and theories that long remained unquestioned are now under detailed scrutiny. This has furthermore resulted in a change in preferred vocabulary, and concepts such as "sacred" or "authoritative" texts or "S/scripture" are used for texts that were gradually gaining a "special" status in the late Second Temple period, instead of Bible or canon. This paper concentrates on the concept of "sacred texts" or "sacred scripture". Catherine Bell reminds us that "'Scriptures' as sacred texts vary widely in terms of cultural constructions of textuality as well as their cultural understandings of sacrality." Importantly, nowhere in the Dead Sea Scrolls, are texts explicitly referred to as "sacred". How appropriate, then, is it to link the attribute "sacred" to certain texts in a pre-canonical period, in a historical setting where the term was not used by those living, writing, and reading theses texts? If applied, what is the phenomenon we as modern scholars are attempting to identify? In addition, what can we know about how texts became "sacred" and what qualities or properties of a text are described with this concept in the late Second Temple period? This paper will approach the issue by combining textual and historical data with theories of "sacred" developed in Religionswissenschaft.
|
Neither Circumcision nor Uncircumcision Counts for Anything: Reading Gal 5:6 from the Perspective of the Challenge Posed by Traditions and AIDS Pandemic in South Africa
Program Unit: Male Circumcision: Between Controversy and Tradition (EABS)
Lubunga W'Ehusha, University of KwaZulu-Natal
Each year a number of young boys die in South Africa from complications related to ritualistic male circumcision. This situation has often raised fierce debate between the tribes who traditionally practice it to prepare teens to adulthood and the state on the one side, and vis-à-vis other tribes who do not practice male circumcision in the country. Even within the tribes that hold on to this rite of passage people are questioning if they should not leave the traditional way of doing male circumcision to opt for a more modern and hygienic manner through health facilities. But, for custodians of the culture male circumcision would lose its significance if rituals and all the cultural practices accompanying the rite are removed. Some Christians have joined the debate by interpreting male circumcision as an outdated Mosaic Law for Old Testament people not rule Christians today, while the advocates of male circumcision hold to it as the mark of their cultural identity and covenant with God.
The New campaign launched by the Government of South Africa requesting male circumcision as a means to curb HIV infection has rekindled the controversy, bringing new arguments to the debate. One should remember that HIV is a very sensitive issue in South Africa as more than 5 million people live currently with the virus and HIV-related diseases remains the major cause of death among children and adults. The present essay intends to bring into dialogue the above text of Galatians and the cultural context of South Africa by answering the question, does male circumcision count for anything?
|
Neither Circumcision nor Uncircumcision Counts for Anything: Reading Gal 5:6 from the Perspective of the Challenge Posed by Traditions and AIDS Pandemic in South Africa
Program Unit: New Testament/Early Christianity/Rabbinic Studies (EABS)
Lubunga W'Ehusha, University of KwaZulu-Natal
Each year a number of young boys die in South Africa from complications related to ritualistic male circumcision. This situation has often raised fierce debate between the tribes which traditionally practice it to prepare teens to adulthood and the state on the one side, and vis-à-vis other tribes which do not practice male circumcision in the country. Even within the tribes that hold on to this rite of passage people are questioning if they should not leave the traditional way of doing male circumcision to opt for a more modern and hygienic manner through health facilities. But, for custodians of the culture male circumcision would lose its significance if rituals and all the cultural practices accompanying the rite are removed. Some Christians have joined the debate by interpreting male circumcision as an outdated Mosaic Law for Old Testament people that should not rule Christians today, whereas the advocates of male circumcision hold to it as the mark of their cultural identity and covenant with God. The New campaign launched by the Government of South Africa requesting male circumcision as a means to curb HIV infection has rekindled the controversy, bringing new arguments to the debate. One should remember that HIV is a very sensitive issue in South Africa as more than 5 million people live currently with the virus and HIV-related diseases remains the major cause of death among children and adults. The present essay intends to bring into dialogue the above text of Galatians and the cultural context of South Africa by answering the question, does male circumcision count for anything?
|
The Rhetorics of/on Female Prophets in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: The Image of Female Prophets in Ancient Greek and Jewish Literature
Marie-Theres Wacker, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster
Seven different female prophetic figures or groups are mentioned in the Hebrew Bible: Miriam, the most prominent one (Ex 15:19-21; Num 12; 20:1-3; 26:59; Deu 24:8-9; 1 Ch 5:29; Mic 6:4), Deborah (Jdg 4-5), Huldah (2 Ki 22/ 2 Ch 34), Noadiah (Neh 6:14), the woman prophet mother of Maher-shalal-hash-baz (Is 8,1-4), the women prophets viewed and accused by Hesekiel (ch. 13), and the women prophesying at the end of the days according to Joel (ch. 3). Starting from the fact that, in the Hebrew Bible (as in Ancient Near Eastern literature) prophecy is a specific form of communication between God(s) and humans, using humans as “mouth” of his/her God, the paper asks for the “speech acts” of female prophets: are female prophets represented as speaking, and in case if, how is their rhetoric presented compared to male prophets? Which forms of nonverbal communication are connected to them, and again: are they different in comparison to their male colleagues? To sharpen textual perception, some selected positions of traditional exegetical research on female prophets (among them Wellhausen school, school of history of religion [“Religionsgeschichtliche Schule”], Scandinavian school [cultic pattern]) will serve as background.
|
Likening God to the Disabled Servant: Toward an Interpretation of Two Prominent Corporeal Spaces in Second Isaiah
Program Unit: Place, Space, and Identity in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Eric Wagner, Catholic University of America
Spatial theory and disability studies stand to overlap in numerous ways, not least of which may be in studying the corporeal spaces (body parts, composition, and meaning) of abled and disabled persons. Within biblical studies, the corporeal spaces in Second Isaiah emerge as a potentially potent source for a productive investigation of this sort. The body of the Servant in Isa. 53, for example, has been recently identified by Jeremy Schipper as one that should be considered disabled. Interestingly, the corporeal space of this character is readily and diversely referenced (face, mouth, hand, etc.) throughout the whole of Second Isaiah. Furthermore, no two bodies are referenced with more frequency or diversity than those of the Servant and God. Based on these observations, the present study argues that Second Isaiah invites a comparison between the corporeal space of the Servant and the corporeal space ascribed to God. The richness of such a comparison is further amplified when all of the lexical references (hands, eyes, etc.) to these two corporeal spaces appearing in Second Isaiah are identified and compared in terms of Henri Lefebvre’s three-fold categorization of space (perceived, conceived and lived). While not exactly equated, the comparison of the corporeal spaces of both characters is striking. As a result, the question posed near the outset of Second Isaiah, ‘To whom might you liken God?’ (Isa. 40.18), meets with an answer that is heretofore overlooked (or rejected) by most scholarship: Liken God to the disabled Servant.
|
Einführung in die Schlussdiskussion
Program Unit: Schriftrezeption bei Paulus und in der Paulustradition: Reception of Scripture in Paul and Pauline Tradition
J. Ross Wagner, Duke University
Ausgehend von den Beiträgen innerhalb dieser Unit wird zunächst dargelegt, welche Schlussfolgerungen sich allgemein für die Schriftrezeption bei Paulus ziehen lassen. Anschließend werden jene Punkte benannt, an denen weiterer Klärungsbedarf besteht. Auf dieser Basis wird ein Rundgespräch die Tagung auswerten.
|
Paul and Children: Problems in the Paradigm and Program of Paideia and Progress in 1 Corinthians
Program Unit: Families and Children in the Ancient World
Elizabeth Waldron Barnett, United Faculty of Theology
The appearances of children in Paul’s writings are taken to be largely metaphorical. These are conventionally interpreted through the lens of the ancient moral philosophers and models of paideia. Children are widely imaged in biblical commentary instrumentally as metaphors of ‘spiritual’ educational progress, often bearing the pejorative association of ‘failure to progress’ or as the example of what should be ‘put off’ or ‘left behind’ in the pursuit of ‘spiritual maturity’.
This paper challenges assumptions of reading Paul’s ‘children’ only as educational instruments, cautioning against over-reading Western Enlightenment childhood aspirational values, and offers alternative models from the Pauline corpus for recognising children through a more nuanced and multivalent socio-historical lens.
From this I propose a more subversive reading of some of the main ‘childhood’ texts, both for Paul’s first century cultural context and for our own, which I suggest offer a greater congruence with Paul’s cruciform and revealed gospel and the broader discursive intent of 1 Corinthians.
|
"Now, Always, and unto the Ages of Ages": The Politics of Time in the Roman Imperial Cults and 1 Peter
Program Unit: Catholic Epistles
Wei-Hsien Wan, University of Exeter
Beginning with the reign of Augustus (31 BCE), cults devoted to the Roman empe ror and the imperial family spread rapidly to the Hellenistic communities of Asia Minor. Sown into the religiously diverse soil of Roman Anatolia, these cults were already firmly established throughout the region by the middle of the first century CE, and exercised decisive influence on the sociopolitical and religious ethos of the land. The present study surveys the perception of time in the imperial cults so as to bring into sharper focus the discourse of time in 1 Peter. Whereas the practices of the imperial cults framed history in terms of the accomplishments of Augustus and his successors, 1 Peter proposed an alternative paradigm, drawn from the traditions of Israel, which reconfigured time around the revelation of God in the person of Jesus of Nazareth. The meaning of time past, present, and future must, in the author's view, be defined in relation to the suffering and glorification of Jesus, for only then can the pattern and goal of history be properly understood. Alt hough scholars have traditionally been divided as to the stance of 1 Peter toward the Roman Empire as a whole, I will argue in this paper that, since configuring time is an inherently sociopolitical act and an apparatus of power, the author of 1 Peter, by virtue of this reordering of time, participated in the competing discourses of time in Anatolia-the dominant voice in which was, of course, that of Rome. The paper thus offers a perspective on the political stance of 1 Peter that avoids the established alternatives of pro- or anti-Empire, and explores instead its voice within the context of a sociopolitical contest for the meaning of time.
|
My Heart Poured Forth Understanding: Fourth Ezra’s Fiery Cup as Hierophagic Consumption
Program Unit: Apocalyptic Literature
Meredith Warren, University of Ottawa
This paper argues that 4 Ezra 14 represents the climax of the sensory revelations experienced by Ezra, and as such, that this is the episode which finally facilitates Ezra’s understanding of divine wisdom. The ingestion of the fiery cup (14.38–41) allows Ezra for the first time to understand divine revelation without an angelus interpres. Tasting, as opposed to seeing or hearing, represents a more direct interaction with the sense-subject, that is, with the divine realm (Lieber 2006).
Ezra’s revelations escalate throughout the text, from hearing, to seeing, and finally to tasting. The first three episodes are only auditory. In the pivotal fourth episode, Ezra at last sees a vision of a woman, with whom he also converses; Uriel describes how Ezra experiences this revelation “as far as it is possible for [his] eyes to see, and […] as much as [his] ears can hear” (10:55–56). Episodes five and six extend these visual qualities using language that emphasizes the visuality of these experiences: “and I looked, and behold…” (11:2, 3, 5, 7, 10; 13: 3, 5, 8, etc.). In each of episodes one through six, however, Ezra is incapable of making sense of what has been revealed to him. It is only when Ezra tastes heavenly food in the final episode, the cup filled with the fiery liquid, that he is able to transcend mortal understanding.
I argue that 4 Ezra 14:38–41 participates in the hitherto undefined literary trope of hierophagy—-food given by an immortal to a mortal which transforms the eater in some way. The narrative depiction of the transformation of Ezra’s understanding from mortal to heavenly engages a literary trope that communicates the ramifications of eating other-worldly food. In tasting the divine liquid, Ezra surpasses ordinary hearing and sight, and consumes God’s meaning directly.
|
The Potency of Writing: Caves and Curses in the Ancient Levant
Program Unit: Epigraphical and Paleological Studies Pertaining to the Biblical World
Jody Washburn, University of California-Los Angeles
There is abundant evidence—ranging from the execration texts in Egypt or the Kassite kudurrus in Mesopotamia to the Sotah ritual described in Numbers 5—for an ancient Near Eastern belief in the potency of written words. While the corpus available for analysis in areas like Egypt or Mesopotamia is significantly more substantial, the nature of the southern Levantine evidence makes it indispensable in a careful study of how non-royal people living in the ancient Near East viewed writing. Especially useful for this purpose are cave inscriptions such as those found at Khirbet Beit Lei, Khirbet el-Qom and Ein Gedi. Because they are not monumental inscriptions conveying an ideological agenda, cave inscriptions potentially represent more closely the thinking of everyday people living in the Levant during the 1st millennium BCE. Studying these inscriptions as both archaeological artifacts and as inscribed texts allows for a nuanced approach to the data appreciative of the similarities in formulae such as curses or prayers, but mindful of the unique context in which they were found. Data as varied as letter formation and size, line or word spacing, position of inscriptions, incised marks not forming any identifiable letter, related archaeological finds, socio-political context of the surrounding area at the approximate time of the inscription, and linguistic analyses of the textual content should be viewed together. The cave inscriptions from these three sites, when studied holistically in consultation with other Levantine funerary and cultic inscriptions, provide evidence outside of literary, cultic or monumental texts for a belief in the efficacy of written words. This power, which could be unleashed by any writer, was apparently especially useful for refugees and for those seeking to protect their own perpetuity or that of a relative.
|
The Defiled Temple in the End Time and Community Identity
Program Unit: Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Cecilia Wassen, Uppsala Universitet
Several of the documents from Qumran portray the Jerusalem temple and its priesthood as defiled, which in part belongs to the characteristics of the present evil age (e.g., CD 4:17-18; 5:6-8). The defilement of the temple is also a recurrent theme in some apocalyptically oriented writings in the Second Temple Period (e.g., Jub 1:10; TLev 9:9-10; 14; Pss.Sol 1:8; 2:3). In my paper I will first situate the criticism of the priesthood and the temple in the sectarian writings against the background of temple imagery in Jewish apocalyptic writings in general, analysing the apocalyptic overtones in the discourses. Second, I will examine what these kinds of accusations aim to do to the audience’s self-perception and identity formation as an end time community, in particular in light of the common employment of the temple as a metaphor for the community. For this I will utilize social identity approach, particularly social categorization theory.
|
Biblische Reminiszenzen auf Byzantinischen Siegeln mit Metrischen Inschriften
Program Unit: The Bible in Byzantium: The Use and Abuse of Tradition
Alexandra Wassiliou-Seibt, Österreichische Akademie der Wissenschaften
*
|
Finite Infinity: The Sea in Ecological Perspective
Program Unit: Hebrew Bible/Old Testament/Ancient Israel Studies (EABS)
Rebecca S. Watson, University of Cambridge
This paper explores the paradox that, within the Bible, although the sea is often understood as infinite, this is counterbalanced by many, often indirect, acknowledgments that it is also subject to effects from other agents. The apparent boundlessness of the sea can lead to a perception that it is capable of functioning as a ‘cosmic dustbin’ absorbing limitless waste (something which is related to the terracentric conception of space which regards the sea as ‘away’). This is found both in the Bible and in our mistreatment of the sea. Nonetheless, the Bible counters this with sometimes quite audacious statements of the sea’s malleability and vulnerability to other agencies, such that it may be dried up, frozen, stirred up, muddied and so on. In many of these passages, the relation of the sea as we would conceive it to the waters thus described may be questionable, but nonetheless, there is also an aspect in which we may learn from the conceptuality present here in acquiring a proper sense of the sea’s subjection to influence from other forces and agents. The most striking statements of the sea’s vulnerability relate to scenes of judgment in which it, like the rest of creation, is subject to divine wrath and terror at Yahweh’s coming. Such judgment passages reflect a notion of creation which sees everything, not only as subject to God’s rule, but as intimately interconnected and sharing the same future including the fate of bearing the consequences of human action. This hardly needs to be translated into modern terms for its pertinence to be seen.
|
Psalm 88: A Psalm without Hope?
Program Unit: Psychological Hermeneutics of Biblical Themes and Texts
Rebecca S. Watson, University of Cambridge
Psalm 88 is well known as the darkest in the entire psalter, although there is some debate over whether the affliction it describes is literal, metaphorical or cultic, and whether it reveals any glimmer of hope, or only unrelieved gloom. This paper first explores a typical theological reading of Psalm 88, acknowledging also the more positive perspective that a contextual reading, taking into its account its position between Psalms 87 and 89, might afford. The majority of the paper will then seeks offer a psychological interpretation of the Psalm, using the linguistic software LIWC (Linguistic Inquiry and Word Count) developed for used in social psychology. This method seeks to uncover psychological aspects of language use in the psalm that may reveal something of the cognitive and emotional processes operating at a subconscious level within it. The aim is to show how psychology may offer a distinctive perspective on this psalm, not in downplaying the psalmist’s suffering and anguish, but in highlighting aspects in which (s)he is still emotionally connected to others and seeking hope.
The psalm is revealed as intensely relational, yearning for resolution on a personal level, but simultaneously acknowledging the unequivocal nature of the suffering experienced. The psalmist does not show himself to be angry (this, rather, seems to be the part of Yahweh) or even greatly anxious about his fate, but he is deeply saddened, grieving chiefly for lost connectedness with his god and his fellows more than for any physical effects he may be suffering. He speaks from conviction, holding fast to the positive qualities of God and even presenting himself as petitioning the deity, whilst in stating unequivocally how Yahweh has caused his sufferings and actively persecuted him, there may be an implicit demand for restitution.
|
Canon Hermeneutical Considerations for Knotting Biblical Books by the Same or Similar Text Forms: The Example of the Psalter (2 Samuel; Psalms 18, 96, 105, and 106; and 1 Chronicles 16)
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
Beat Weber, Theologisches Seminar Bienenberg (Switzerland)
Note: The paper will be read in German language, but the handout will be availabe in English translation.–
Among the forms of textual references between biblical books (intertextuality, allusions etc.) are also “double figures”. This expression refers to texts that appear in the same or similar form in two (or more) books. Unlike most of the “usual” intertextualities, which will often only be noticed by hearers/readers, who are familiar with the traditions, such relations are evident. They should be highlighted prior to any other form of textual relations, because such cardinal knots between Bible books set impulses that might control the reading and understanding in terms of the interrelation of the authoritative writings of the (later) Bible canon.
This thesis will be considerered canon-theologically with the Psalter, for it has strong references back to Torah and Nebi’im in its structure and layout. The focus will be on two knottings: 1) the double tradition 2 Sam 22 // Ps 18 (in association with other phenomena), which inscribes the Psalter a book overarching analepsis (flashback) to the books of Samuel. 2) Psalms 96; 105; 106 are (partial) included in 1 Chr 16 with minor modifications and arranged to form a new song (collage). Judging from the “head position” of the Psalter overviewing the Ketubim, we seem to find an overarching prolepsis (flashforward) to the books of Chronicles. If this is correct, the Psalter is both analeptically (Sam / Nebi’im) and proleptically (Chr / Ketubim) knotted. It is denotative that canon-theologically the backward connection is produced in the front parts (Books I-III), the forward one in the later parts (Books IV -V) of the Psalter.
|
“But do you know what that verse means?” “No, Miss, I just wanted to draw a star”: Doing Contextual Bible Study with Children
Program Unit: Bible and Its Influence: History and Impact
Tiffany Webster, University of Sheffield
As part of my PhD I sought to explore how children growing up in ex-coal mining communities interpreted Biblical texts and whether, when prompted, they would be able to draw interpretive connections between their shared cultural heritage and a variety of carefully themed Biblical verses. I therefore wanted to capture the contextual exegetical voice of children growing up in a once heavily industrialised working-class area in an informal accessible way. The purpose of such a project was to creatively emphasise the involvement of the self in the process of hermeneutical interpretation and to effectively explore whether children, when pushed to contextually interpret a text, were able to reveal any new interpretive possibilities of the Bible.
From November 2013 – March 2014 all Year 7 pupils (aged 11-12) began exploring and interpreting a selection of 22 Biblical verses through the medium of stained glass windows. Each pupil was asked to create two windows: the first being one that interpreted their chosen verse from their own perspective, and the second being one that interpreted this verse in light of their shared cultural heritage of coal mining.
This paper will focus on the most prominent outcomes of this area of my research along with the numerous methodological issues that arose throughout the project. I will specifically focus on the following five areas: 1. How to explain ‘interpretation’ to children and the problematic necessity of ‘meaning’; 2. The popularity of particular verses and images and possible reasons for their attractiveness to children; 3. A selection of questions that the children asked and the discussions that followed; 4. Coping with disengagement or disinterest and the validity of ‘fake’ interpretations; and finally, 5. The stretching of interpretation – how far is too far?
|
When the Workers in the Vineyard Meet the Workers of the Coalface: How the Method of Contextual Bible Study Can Be Used to Re-read New Testament Texts
Program Unit: Methods in New Testament Studies
Tiffany Webster, University of Sheffield
This paper focuses on how Contextual Bible Study (CBS) – a method ripe for greater use in New Testament Studies – can be critically refined and methodologically streamlined to successfully foster new ways of reading and interpreting New Testament texts.
This paper will begin with a critique of the current methodological practices and trends of CBS, followed by an introduction to how my own research has thus far reflected upon and revised the theoretical, methodological and practical realities of such an approach, primarily by drawing upon existing practices in sociological and anthropological qualitative and fieldwork-based studies. This will include an overview of my current research in which I have been exploring a selection of specially chosen Biblical passages with a group of coal miners in South Derbyshire, UK. The participants in this study have been collectively exploring a variety of Biblical passages that closely relate to their unique profession and cultural heritage. Of the ten texts explored throughout the duration of this CBS project, the group’s examination of The Workers in the Vineyard produced a particularly interesting and surprising array of readings, for example the group were eager to relate the workers’ experiences of ‘fair pay’ to their own experiences of contract disputes. The main emphasis of this paper will therefore be on this culturally-embedded reading of Matthew 20:1-16.
By paying close attention to both methodological considerations and real examples of contextual Biblical interpretations this paper seeks to illustrate the vast potential of CBS to not only enhance Matthew studies but also New Testament studies as a whole. This paper will ultimately show how a rigorous methodologically focused CBS program can provide an exciting opportunity for New Testament texts to be seen through fresh eyes and thus paving the way for the emergence of new, previously unseen, interpretations.
|
Musical Ritual as Rhetoric in Early Christianity: A Mechanism of Recruitment
Program Unit: Ritual in the Biblical World
Jade Weimer, University of Toronto
This paper will examine the relationship between musical ritual and methods of recruitment in early Christianity. Several scholars have made vital contributions to our understanding of recruitment practices in early Christ-following communities including Phil Harland and Denis Duling, who argue that early Christian authorities employed various forms of rhetoric to promote their theological framework. They also argue that these same authorities made attempts to disparage other groups (both Jewish and Greco-Roman) in order to make their group/association sound more appealing. This debate often centered on theological and doctrinal issues but I argue that ritual practice also played a key role in various forms of recruitment. There are two ways in which musical ritual was utilized as a tool of recruitment. First, musical practices were analyzed in text through discourse on music and song. Second, music was used as a direct recruitment tactic through the appropriation of melody and and the use of disparaging lyrics against others. Clement of Alexandria, for example, recognized the emotive power of music and made a clear attempt to articulate the “best” forms of musical expression in his writings. He made sharp and often disparaging references to Greco-Roman musical practices, which functioned as a rhetorical device to do precisely what Harland and Duling argue. The direct usage of music as rhetoric is much more difficult to locate but there are several key examples which date to the 4th century where recruitment becomes an internal battle within the Christian tradition. This is best exemplified by the musical compositions of the Syrian bishop Ephraem who wrote hymns and employed choruses of virgins and young boys to combat Bardesanes’ so-called heresy.
|
What Makes an Israelite an Israelite?
Program Unit: Persian Period
Kristin Weingart, Eberhard Karls Universität Tübingen
For Julius Wellhausen the exile marked a decisive turning point in the construction of Israelite collective identity: Israel went into exile as a people and retur ned as a religious sect. This assessment which was taken up by many exegetes and historians of Israel led to the definition of post-exilic Israel as a religious community, a Kultgemeinde, based on a shared faith, adherence to the law etc. While there is a growing number of critical voices the concept of a Kultgemeinde is still quite common place in OT exegesis and is supposed to be found in a number of Persian period texts. The paper will look at the criteria that different Persian period texts provide for belonging or not belonging to Israel. It will try to show that the boundaries of Israel as a collective entity were indeed in dispute within Persian period Yehud triggered by the question of the Israelite-ness of the populace in the area of the former Northern Kingdom. But while there was no consensus regarding their status the same underlying criteria for defining an Israelite is used either to include or exclude the Samarians from Israel - not the religious requirements of a Kultgemeinde but the social construction of a common descent that finds its expression in the system of the twelve tribes of Israel and that the different texts have to grapple with in order to apply it to the position they try to establish.
|
"A Dream Not Interpreted Is Like a Letter Not Read" (bBer 55a): Isaac Abravanel on Dreams and Dream Interpretation
Program Unit: Judaica
Kristin Weingart, Eberhard Karls Universität Tübingen
Don Isaac Abravanel (1437-1508) - the great Jewish Bible commentator and philosopher of the late Middle Ages - discusses the phenomenon of dreams on two occasions, in his commentary on Genesis 37-50 as well as his commentary on Maimonides' Guide of the Perplexed. Using a wide array of different opinions and reflec tions on dreams from scripture, Rabbinic literature and Aristotelian philosophers he tries not only to explain the nature of dreams and to answer the question wether they can be used as a means of divination but also to integrate the different accounts and opinions that lay before him into a consistent theory. The paper will outline the main points of Abravanel's treatment of dreams, give an overview over the sources he used and show why dreams and dream interpretation were so important to him.
|
Two Exegetical Perspectives on Jer 10: MT and LXX
Program Unit: Texts and Contexts of Jeremiah: The Exegesis of Jeremiah 1 and 10 in light of Textual and Reception History
Richard D. Weis, Lexington Theological Seminary
*
|
The Elimination of Jesus: A Legal Instance of International Cooperation
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Law
John W. Welch, Brigham Young University
All accounts of the trial of Jesus assume some level of interconnectivity between Jewish and Roman interests in the elimination of Jesus. Seeing this international dimension throughout the sequence of proceedings against Jesus reveals this as a rare international legal proceeding from antiquity. Comparative legal studies, narrative analysis, and alliance theory will be used as lenses through which to detect the international norms that should be understood as being depicted, explicitly or implicitly, in the various accounts of the trials leading to the execution of Jesus. Of particular interest will be the ways in which international legal relations, the ius gentium, and the right of self-government of the erstwhile foreign communities, operated in the early Roman Empire. The elimination of Jesus cannot be fully understood without recognizing that the Romans and the Chief Priests cooperated with each other, in effect as allies, not only at procedural and administrative levels but also in substantive legal respects. These parties are consistently depicted as working separately while promoting their mutually recognized distinct interests. For example, dangerously threatening miracle-working would have been of concern both to the Romans and the Chief Priests, thereby drawing together these otherwise antithetical parties. The breadth of antipathy against such kakon or malum made the charge that Jesus was a kakopoios a compelling meeting place for the urgencies created by both Jewish and Roman legal sensitivities. Other shared legal concerns also bonded Jewish and Roman interests potently enough to forge and define this unprecedented alliance. In the four New Testament gospels and the Gospel of Peter, the tri-lingual inscription on the cross ultimately punctuates the fundamental international qualities that are communicated by the narratives of these legal proceedings against Jesus. One wonders why his case was seen and portrayed this way.
|
Divine Body: Where Is God in God’s Kingdom?
Program Unit: Place, Space, and Identity in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Karen Wenell, University of Birmingham
When compared with the centralised model of sacred space (camp and tabernacle, land and temple), the Kingdom of God appears unstructured in its description and orientation. Whereas God’s presence is particularly located in the holy of holies in the central model (with places for priests, Levites and ordinary Israelites), the Kingdom does not designate an ideal segregation of space, or work according to a system of ritual purity and ‘sheer difference’, as for instance in J Z Smith’s analysis of the maps of Ezekiel 40-48. And yet, definitions of sacred space, whether focussing on the more ontological ‘irruption of the sacred’ (Eliade) or the human systemisation of space (Smith), are viewed in connection with the divine, and clearly the Kingdom, belonging to God, fits this definition. If we understand the Kingdom as a mythical (sacred) space of orientation (Tuan), rather than according to Dalman’s ‘divine rule’ definition, we may consider the type of spatial thinking associated with the Kingdom, and also where God is placed within it. Or, to put the question another way, we may investigate the difference God makes to the Kingdom’s construction (Latour).
|
The Catchword Phenomenon in the Book of Twelve (LXX) – Absent or Different?
Program Unit: Canonical Approaches to the Bible (EABS)
Heiko Wenzel, Freie Theologische Hochschule Gießen
The study of the Book of the Twelve has seen several landmark contributions over the last few decades. James Nogalski’s two volumes on Literary Precursors and Redactional Processes in the Book of the Twelve drew attention particularly to the catchword phenomenon in the Masoretic tradition. These studies also survey how these Hebrew catchwords had been rendered in the Greek and in the Latin translations. He concludes “that the translators exhibit no cognizance of these words as a unifying technique in the compilation of the Book of the Twelve.”
This paper engages this conclusion on three levels: first, the methodological reflection discusses the implications of the order of the Minor Prophets in the Septuagint which differs to some degree in the first six books from the Masoretic tradition. This phenomenon opens the possibility to evaluate every thesis or conclusion by comparing how it fares in both halves of the Book of the Twelve. Second, as a result of the different order several connections are hardly defensible, other come to the fore in cases when the Greek rendering can be described as concordant. Finally, the results of a survey on the important “neighbors” in the Greek order (Micah / Joel; Joel / Obadiah; Jona / Nah) are presented to evaluate the thesis that the catchword phenomenon in the Book of Twelve (LXX) might not be absent but simply different.
|
The Sources for Theology Proper in Recent Old Testament Theologies or Histories of Old Testament Religion
Program Unit: Biblical Theology
Heiko Wenzel, Freie Theologische Hochschule Gießen
The last few decades saw significant shifts in scholarship on the Hebrew Bible / Old Testament with their ramifications for various religious and theological questions: the diversity of approaches has increased, so have the available (literary and material) sources of the Ancient Near East and their scholarly discussion. Publications in the field have discussed for example the relationship between Old Testament Theology and History of Religion or Unity and Diversity (see the respective volumes of Jahrbuch für Biblische Theologie). In addition, the significant discussion on Jewish and Christian perspectives of the Hebrew Bible / Old Testament affects any theological reflection. Unfortunately, the variety of diachronic and synchronic approaches has not always facilitated fruitful dialogues between these approaches.
This paper reflects on the implications for theology proper by focusing on the sources for theology proper and on their methodological penetration. In particular, this investigation discusses possibilities of how the various approaches in their diversity contribute to the reflections on theology proper. It discusses the necessity of this variety in light of older approaches to Old Testament theology in general and to theology proper in particular.
|
First Clement and Rebellious Corinthian Women
Program Unit: Apostolic Fathers and Related Early Christian Literature
Martin Wessbrandt, Lunds Universitet
The identity of the perpetrators in Corinth that the author of 1 Clement is turning against has been, and still is, a much discussed question in the research concerning the letter. In this paper I will discuss one such proposed solution that was offered by Elisabeth Schüssler Fiorenza some years ago in her already classic volume, In Memory of Her. According to Fiorenza it was wealthy women who acted as patrons in the congregation that had exerted their power to depose the presbyters. Fiorenza is able to make a significant argument for this viewpoint, particularly pointing to verses neglected by other scholars that imply that there were women with control in Corinth, threatening the domination of patriarchy there.
While accepting many of Fiorenza’s findings in the text, I however find reason to question the conclusions drawn from these about the historical circumstances of the conflict. At least since William Wrede’s Untersuchungen zum Ersten Klemensbrief (1891) there has been a scholarly camp which holds that the author of 1Clement had limited knowledge of what was actually going on in Corinth. Instead, he used other sources in composing his letter. In this paper I argue that the author of 1 Clement was imitating Paul and was drawing much inspiration in his writing from Paul’s first letter to the Corinthians. Influenced by that letter, rather than by knowledge of actual circumstances, the author assumed that women were part of the problem in Corinth and therefore especially had to be corrected (e.g. 1 Cor 11:3-16; 14:33-36). This assumption was probably further strengthened by the fact that there were troubles with “disorderly” and “rebellious” women in other parts of the movement of Christ-believers at the time (cf. the Pastoral Epistles). Women were becoming the usual suspects when strife and disorder appeared among the Christians.
|
Leadership in Times of Crisis: Nahum as Master of Language and Image
Program Unit: Authority and Influence in Ancient Times
Willie Wessels, University of South Africa
The prophet Nahum acted in a time of crisis for the people of Judah. They were threatened and dominated by the Assyrians as the world power. This dominance left the Judean people dismayed and discouraged. In this time of crisis Nahum addressed the people of Judah with a strong worded message of encouragement and motivation. As a master of rhetoric and image, Nahum attempted to install trust in YHWH as the Sovereign power and also appealed to the imagination of the people to perceive the victory that YHWH will achieve on their behalf. Nahum also used metaphors effectively to create insight in the powerlessness of the Assyrians as opposing power both to YHWH and the people of Judah. A final aspect to be treated in this paper is to illustrate how Nahum as leader in his society used language and image effectively to create a reality check for the people of Judah and the enemy of how pride will be turned to humiliation through the intervention of YHWH.
|
Festival Calendars in the Hebrew Bible (Exodus 23; Deuteronomy 16; Leviticus 23) and Their Relation to the Narrative Context
Program Unit: Law and Narrative (EABS)
Karl William Weyde, Det Teologiske Menighetsfakultet
The paper first discusses how the three so-called pilgrimage festivals (Exod 23; Deut 16) are connected to significant events in the biblical narratives of Israel’s early history: The Festival of Unleavened Bread/Passover relates to the Exodus from Egypt (Exod 12–13), the Festival of Harvest/the Festival of Weeks relates to YHWH’s Revelation on Mt. Sinai (Exod 19–20), whereas the Festival of Ingathering/the Festival of Succoth relates to the inauguration of the First Temple (1 Kgs 8). Only on this occasion, did the Exodus from Egypt come to an end and reach its “destination” (cf. 1 Kings 6:1). In fact, this view of the itinerary is already expressed in the “Song of Moses” (Exod 15:17). The composition of the Exodus narrative, from Exod 12 through 1 Kgs 8, is anchored to these three festivals.
Second, the extended festival calendar in Lev 23, which includes all the festivals in the seventh month, not only relates to the report in Num 10:10 but also explains why the Day of Atonement has a central position in the Pentateuchal narratives (Lev 16). Moreover, the detailed prescriptions for the Festival of Harvest in Lev 23 reflect the importance of this festival, which is attested in Deut 26. Thus, the festivals influenced the formation of the narratives in the Pentateuch and the Deuteronomistic History. The festivals also became significant parts of these narratives.
Finally, the significance of the festivals in the shaping of the biblical narratives also appears in reports on other events: Turning-points in the people’s history were connected with festival celebrations (Josh 5; 2 Kgs 23; 2 Chr 30; Ezra 3; 6; Neh 8).
|
Constructing the Moral World of the Synoptic Gospels: 'The View from the Street'
Program Unit: Graeco-Roman Society (EABS)
Gerry Wheaton, Seminario ESEPA, Costa Rica
Among the most exigent priorities of the Synoptic Gospels is the moral formation of new Christian communities in early imperial, urban settings. At the center of this transformation is the moral concept of devotion to others even at one’s own expense, a concept poignantly instantiated in the “love command”, the metaphor of servitude (Mark 10:43-44), and the prioritization of the weak, the poor and the marginalized (e.g., Luke 14:12-14). An important dimension to the contemporary understanding of this priority of the Evangelists is reckoning with the points of tension with the “popular morality” of Greco-Roman society.
In sketching the moral world of the New Testament, scholars have commonly focused on the elite sources of thought (e.g., the Hellenistic schools of philosophy) to which ordinary people “in the street” had little direct access, and neglected the wide array of economic, social and political forces that shaped and reshaped individual moral outlook in ways at once more subtle and more powerful than the influences of the philosophical schools. Utilizing literary evidence as well as recent studies of daily life and popular morality in early imperial Rome, the present work will isolate and examine three vectors of moral influence upon the outlook of the “ordinary” city-dweller: the dynamics of neighborhood associations (renewed under Augustus), the culture of euergatism, and the growth of social mobility in the early empire with the concomitant yen for economic and social advancement. I conclude by forming an imaginative sketch of the struggles of Quintus, a fictional freedman, textile dealer and member of a Christian house church, as he negotiates his aspirations for Roman citizenship and membership in the Equestrian order in the light of the concept of “costly devotion to others” that lies at the center of the morality of the Gospels.
|
‘Contemporary Theory of Metaphor’ and the New Testament: Elements of a Method of Metaphor Analysis
Program Unit: Methods in New Testament Studies
Gerry Wheaton, Seminario ESEPA, Costa Rica
New Testament scholarship has been slower than its Hebrew Bible counterpart to appropriate the fruit of several decades of work in the “Contemporary Theory of Metaphor” (CTM). Yet metaphors, both novel and conventional, proliferate throughout the Gospels and other New Testament documents and the frequent lack of methodological rigor in metaphor analysis has often issued in incomplete or even wholly inaccurate and misleading interpretations. The present work seeks to redress this circumstance by showing how CTM may be appropriated to illuminate in more precise, accurate fashion a novel metaphor in a New Testament document.
Though today a vast and multidimensional field, three facets of CTM may be isolated as among the most important factors in New Testament metaphor analysis. These are the metaphorical entailment potential within a given culture, the invariance principle, and the identification of the main meaning focus of a novel metaphor. Each of these principles will be described and exemplified using the novel metaphor Discipleship is Slavery in the Gospel of Mark. In the process, I will also highlight the way in which novel metaphor is commonly deployed to foster defamiliarization and reconceptualization of an otherwise well-known idea.
|
Hebrews and Zechariah
Program Unit: Epistle to the Hebrews
Bryan J. Whitfield, Mercer University
The post-exilic writings collected in Zechariah attracted many apocalyptic readers of scripture in the Second Temple period. But apart from examination of the relationship of Zechariah to the Synoptic passion narrative, relatively little work has explored the significance of Zechariah for the New Testament. One exception to that neglect, the collection of essays The Book of Zechariah and Its Influence, contains papers from a 2002 Oxford colloquium. That collection, however, contains no treatment of Zechariah and Hebrews.
The omission may not be too surprising, given the paucity of explicit citations. Yet connections between Zechariah and Hebrews are not absent. Both Daniel Stökl and I have argued that Zech 3 and its interpretation in Second Temple Judaism provide a significant context for understanding Heb 3 and 4 and the portrait of Jesus as high priest. This paper, however, will move beyond that previous work to explore a range of connections between Zechariah, its interpretation in Second Temple Judaism, and Hebrews. Both Hebrews and Zechariah share connections to Yom Kippur and to the fast day Tammuz 17. The language of the “great high priest” recalls the “great priest” of Zech 3:9, and Zechariah speaks of a priest on or beside the throne (Zech 6:13). The language concerning the Branch (Zech 3:8; 6:12) influences the language and argument of Heb 7:14-17. The phrase “the spirit of grace” (Heb 10:29) recalls Zech 12:10. Finally, Hebrews 13:20 stresses the blood of the covenant (Zech 9:11) and the image of the shepherd (Zech 13:7).
|
Figurative Story and Critical History: Judging the Case of Judg 9:8-15
Program Unit: Metaphors in the Hebrew Bible/Old Testament and Their Reception
Jon Whitman, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
In the history of biblical reading, few metaphorical passages have provoked such intriguing critical commentary as the story of the talking trees in Judges (9:8-15). The story, which is repeatedly called a fable (fabula) in Christian interpretation, conspicuously raises for Christian commentators pressing questions about the role of fabulous dialogue in a text-the text of sacred Scripture-that they themselves regard as the discourse of truth. In investigating questions of this kind, such interpreters repeatedly tend to explore not just the significance of this specific passage in Scripture, but the status of figurative language itself. From late antiquity to the modern era, the story of the talking trees becomes a critical test case in the history of interpretation. In this paper I would like to offer an overview of this broad critical movement while focusing on the period in which it acquires perhaps its most fascinating form: the late Middle Ages. In the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries, in contexts ranging from theological investigations to mythographic treatises, Christian commentary on the story increasingly suggests fundamental issues in the treatment of imaginative language: 1) the controversial concept of the "literal" sense of Scripture; 2) its potential relation to a "literary" sense of the text; 3) the broader relation between scriptural and literary texts at large; and finally 4) the complex interplay between factual and fabulous modes of expression. During the course of its critical treatment, the story in Judges 9 eventually helps to promote self-conscious theoretical inquiries into the poetics of Scripture and the aesthetics of metaphor at large. In the end, the very effort to judge the tale of the talking trees is a far-reaching testimony in its own right.
|
Persecution of Jews according to Archeological and Literary Sources in Late Antiquity
Program Unit: Anti-Semitic Readings of the Bible
Gudrun Wiener, University of Vienna
Literary sources report about destructions of synagogues and Jewish communities and other forms of persecution in Late Antiquity. This presentation will ask how the archeological report relates to this evidence. Next to burn- and destruction-layers in synagogue sites, the reuse of Jewish items in other contexts as well as the remodeling of Jewish symbols will be considered.
|
Anti-Jewish and Antisemitic Aspects in Protestant Readings of the Hebrew Bible from the Reformation Era until the 19th Century
Program Unit: Anti-Semitic Readings of the Bible
Christian Wiese, University of Frankfurt
This paper will explore anti-Jewish and antisemitic elements in the Protestant exegetical tradition since the Reformation period and contextualize them within the history of Christian images of Jews and Judaism from the 16th to the 19th century. The focus will be on an interpretation of Martin Luther’s polemical refutation of Jewish exegesis of the Hebrew Bible that led him to his violent anti-Jewish writings, on an analysis of the use of the Hebrew Bible in the theological and social denigration of Judaism in the early modern period and finally on the image of Judaism constructed by the emerging modern Protestant biblical exegesis in the 19th century. The long and differentiated history of the anti-Jewish tendencies inherent in the Protestant appropriation of the Hebrew Bible as the Christian “Old Testament” and the negative depiction of parts of the biblical tradition as “Jewish” will be discussed in terms of their religious roots and their political effect on debates regarding the position of the Jewish minority within Christian society. The paper will culminate in a systematic analysis of the different categories of anti-Jewish assumptions dominating the Protestant exegetical and theological discourse by the end of the 19th century and their impact on and links to the phenomenon of modern antisemitism.
|
Die Schrift als Fundament der Brieflichen Kommunikation des Paulus mit den Korinthern
Program Unit: Schriftrezeption bei Paulus und in der Paulustradition: Reception of Scripture in Paul and Pauline Tradition
Florian Wilk, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen
Die paulinischen Ausführungen in den Korintherbriefen erwachsen durchweg aus einer Auslegung biblischer Texte im Lichte der Christusbotschaft – auch wenn dieses Fundament in verschiedenen Briefteilen auf je andere Weise sichtbar wird. Es ist deshalb darzulegen, wie die Differenz der Erscheinungsweisen durch traditionelle Vorgaben, thematische Besonderheiten, Eigenarten der Gesprächssituation und spezifische Mitteilungsabsichten bedingt wird.
|
Martyrdom and Dynasty: The Folktale Tradition of Simon’s Wife in Context
Program Unit: Hellenistic Judaism
Julia Wilker, University of Pennsylvania
In his account of early Hasmonean rule, Flavius Josephus includes the story of the death of the wife of Simon (AJ 13.228-235, BJ 1.57-60), often overlooked by modern scholarship. According to Josephus’ account, the Hasmonean Simon, two of his sons and his wife fell victim to a plot by his own son-in-law, Ptolemy, son of Abubus, who attempted to take over the rule. While Simon was killed instantly, Ptolemy tortured Simon’s widow and the two sons up on the wall of his fortress when John Hyrcanus approached with his army. Despite the torment and her suffering, Hyrcanus’ mother repeatedly expressed her willingness to die for the Hasmonean cause and bravely encouraged her son to continue the fight. The story transcends common categories: While the language, motifs and narrative structure correspond closely to that of famous martyrdom stories (most prominently the mother of the seven martyrs in 2Macc 7 and 4Macc 8-17), the wife of Simon suffers torment and is eventually killed not by a gentile tyrant but by a fellow-Jew and a member of her own family. As an account on inner-dynastic strife the story employs common Hellenistic tropes of rivalry, conspiracies and violent death within ruling families of the surrounding, non-Jewish kingdoms. In the version presented by Josephus, the story finally shows characteristic features of a folktale tradition that was deliberately left out of semi-official accounts such as 1Maccabees. This paper argues that the story can be dated to the early years of John Hyrcanus and serves a prime example for popular legends of the early Hasmonean period. In its ideological background, its narrative structure and intended message it thus represents the fusion of Hellenistic and Jewish traditions and tropes but also gives insights into popular traditions not preserved by the core texts of Hasmonean self-presentation.
|
“Let all the people say, Amen!” Traces of Redaction in the Book of Psalms
Program Unit: Writings (including Psalms)
David Willgren, Lunds Universitet
The study of the composition of the Book of Psalms has gained much scholarly attention since the groundbreaking dissertation by Gerald H Wilson in 1985. One of the clearest signs of redaction was the addition, or use, of four doxologies in Pss 41, 72, 89 and 106. They all share a number of features, but not two are identical. As they are considered to belong to the very latest stages of redactional activity, dividing the Book of Psalms in five parts, often interpreted as an intended allusion to the Torah (thus, the collection being, in some sense “David’s Torah”) they are important for any understanding of the intention behind the final collection of the Book of Psalms. One aspect that has not yet been thouroughly studied, though, is the presence of the double Amen-sayings in all but one doxology (Ps 106:48). As double Amen-sayings are very rare in the Old testament (only three attestations outside the Book of Psalms), but common in the DSS material, as in the Gospel of John, this paper will focus on the function of the Amen-sayings in those texts in order to shed light on the possible rationale behind the redactor’s use of the double Amen in the final shaping of the Book of Psalms.
|
A "Frozen" Colophon in Psalm 72?
Program Unit: Textual Criticism: Manuscripts & Methods
David Willgren, Lunds Universitet
The colophon in Ps 72:20 has long been puzzling psalm scholars. It reads ??? ????? ??? ?????? (the prayers of David, son of Jesse, are ended), and as such, it raises a number of questions. The first observation to be made is that the word ???? is used, not ????. That this is a potential problem is clear already in the LXX, where ???? is corrected to ?´µ???. Secondly, the claim that the prayers of David are ended is not true in a literal sense since there are several psalms attributed to David after Ps 72. Thirdly, Ps 72 is not attributed to David but to Solomon. Fourth, the colophon is placed after the doxology concluding the second book in the Book of Psalm, and the last, perhaps most puzzling observation is that the colophon is placed in the midst of the collection often identified as the Elohistic Psalter (Pss 42–83). To solve these difficulties, a number of suggestions have been presented, but I will in this paper suggest that a neat solution is provided if the problem is approached with insights gained from research on scribal habits and material culture. Departing from scholars as e.g. H. Gamble, W.A. Johnson and E. Tov, I claim that the colophon of Ps 72 is likely to be understood, not as the conclusion of a collection, but as a frozen scribal colophon, originally inteded to “close” the scroll. A direct analogy to such a fixation of a colophon is then found in the Sumerian Temple Hymns.
|
Die Suche nach dem Ort in der Chronik - Eine U-topie? (The Search for the Place in Chronicles - A U-topia?)
Program Unit: Chronicles and Utopia (EABS)
Thomas Willi, University of Greifswald
In der chr Neuerzählung, des Weges, wie David die "Stätte" für den Tempel zu Jerusalem gefunden habe, lebt in später judäischer Perspektive die altisraelitische Tradition vom Suchen und Finden der "Stätte" bzw. des je und je sich enthüllenden "Ortes" der Gottesgegenwart wieder auf. Ziel schon der Einheit 1Chr (11f.) 13-17 - die vorausblickend auf 1Chr 21 gelesen werden muss - ist der maqom, der "Ort". Die Frage stellt sich: Ist denn Jerusalem schon, oder wird es erst durch den künftigen Einzug Gottes in sein Heiligtum (2Chr 6,40-7,3) zu dem Ort?
Die von Chr angestossene Suche nach dem "Ort" oszilliert zwischen "Utopie" und "Topologie", zeitigt eine ungeahnte Nachgeschichte und gewinnt in der jüdischen Gebetsliturgie einen prominenten Stellenwert.
|
Oral and Literary Aspects in the Chronicles Account of Josiah’s Passover
Program Unit: Law and Narrative (EABS)
Joshua E. Williams, Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary
The account of Josiah’s Passover celebration within Chronicles contains clear references to legal material contained in the Pentateuch. Although there are likely numerous factors that influenced the particular shape of the narrative in which this legal material is adapted into this narrative, this paper proposes to analyze factors that may result from the intersection of orality and literacy. Although it has been common for scholars to assume that an oral mindset dies out when the material is set into writing, it is more likely that there exists a spectrum of features within texts that reflect oral and literate mindsets. This paper proposes to identify where along this spectrum the Chronicles account of Josiah’s Passover falls. Four aspects of the narrative will be analyzed in order to fix the narrative’s position within the spectrum: 1) the attitude towards writing and written material, 2) the existence of pluriformity from the parallel account in Kings and its possible causes, 3) the existence and nature of intertextual connections to other material, and 4) the presence or absence of narrative contextualization such that the account is closely integrated within the larger framework of Chronicles. By situating the narrative along the spectrum between orality and literacy, the paper is intended to help explain the presence of certain narrative features and explore how this narrative was intended to be received by its ancient audiences.
|
The Nature of Chronicles as a Literary Work: A Look at the Temple Craftsman
Program Unit: Comparative Studies of Literature from the Persian and Hellenistic Periods
Joshua E. Williams, Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary
The paper addresses the issue concerning what role oral and/or literary factors played in the production of Chronicles’ description of the temple craftsman Huram-abi (2 Chronicles 2:12–13[13-14]). It begins by examining the parallel description found in 1 Kings 7:13–14 in order to determine if the Kings passage served as the Vorlage for Chronicles in this description. It then examines the role that other traditional material, especially material preserved in the Pentateuch, may have played. It demonstrates that the material in Pentateuchal texts regarding the tabernacle has played a formative role in the passage. It then evaluates how the tabernacle material’s influence on the Chronicles passage reflects the dynamics of oral and/or literary features.
|
Paul's Prison Ministry
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Wendell Willis, Abilene Christian University
Paul’s Prison Ministry
The fact of Paul being in Roman imprisonment is well established in his writings, and the topic of frequent research. However, the focus has mostly been on where he might have been in prison, at what times, and the possible relationship of his imprisonment to his citizenship referred to in Acts). In this study I focus rather on what he did while in prison to advance his mission. We know from Philemon of one believer by name, whom Paul converted while in prison.
In Philippians Paul makes three references to his status in chains, two of which are really allusions. In 2:25-30 he refers to the visit of the Philippian Christian, Epaphroditus, who ministered to Paul while he was in prison. In 4:22 he mentions in closing contact with “Caesar’s household,” also while he is in prison (without stating how this was done). But the most full reference is in 1:12-14 (still brief) where Paul describes contact with the “praetorian guard,” that allowed him to proclaim the gospel.
Two specific questions are addressed in this study. How was Paul’s imprisonment related to his apostolic mission, and why did he specifically relate it, as he does, to his Philippian church? The reference in chapter one shows that Paul saw his being in chains as not a hindrance to his mission but an opportunity. As to why he recounts this to the Philippians, I argue this is another, although small, indication of how much Paul takes into account the status of Philippi as a Roman colony in this letter.
|
Chronicles and Utopia, Likely Bedfellows? Kingship as a Test Case
Program Unit: Chronicles and Utopia (EABS)
Ian Douglas Wilson, University of Alberta
In recent years a number of scholars have utilized concepts and theories of “utopia” to study 1-2 Chronicles and Chronistic historiography. In this line of inquiry, scholars such as Joseph Blenkinsopp, for example, have understood Chronicles to have been an “ideal counterreality” to the Judean literati’s perceived sociohistorical reality in the fourth century BCE. From a heuristic standpoint, this is an interesting and perhaps fruitful approach to certain types of literature in the Bible. In this paper, using Israelite kingship as a test case, I will assess the use of utopia as a concept specifically for historical-critical studies of Chronicles and Yehudite historiography. I will argue that, although thinking with “utopia” is probably helpful for studies of prophetic literature or other types of texts, it has less import for studies of Chronistic historiography in ancient Yehud. Doubtless, Yehudite literati read Chronicles alongside the authoritative books of Samuel-Kings, and this, I submit, ultimately problematizes understandings of Chronicles as utopian historiography; the obvious (and necessary) intertextual and counterbalancing relationship between Chronicles and Samuel-Kings, especially with regard to the monarchy and kingship, precludes seeing Chronicles as a truly utopian work in its primary sociocultural context.
|
The End of the "Emerald" Rainbow
Program Unit: New Testament/Early Christianity/Rabbinic Studies (EABS)
Ross E. Winkle, Pacific Union College
In Rev 4:3 translations typically indicate that John saw a rainbow (iris) surrounding God’s throne that looked like or resembled an “emerald” (from the dative of smaragdinos, the adjectival form of the noun smaragdos, the latter being a lithic term typically translated as “emerald”). But comparing a rainbow to an emerald appears oxymoronic: why would John have portrayed a polychromatic, iridescent image as resembling a monochromatic emerald? I intend to demonstrate that in Rev 4:3 smaragdinos should not be translated as “emerald.” Some contemporary gemologists have concluded, based on Hellenistic gemological accounts, that the Greek lithic noun smaragdos should not be narrowly defined as an emerald but rather a green stone. Others, including linguist Alois Vanicek more than a century ago, have similarly asserted that the term cannot refer to the emerald that we are familiar with. Confusion over how to translate the Greek term goes back even to the LXX, since even ancient Greek translators were sometimes confused over the meaning of Hebrew gemological terms. This helps explain why in the LXX: (1) smaragdos and another gemological term (sardion) translate the same Hebrew gemological term; and (2) smaragdos itself translates two separate Hebrew terms. I would contend that John was influenced by one of the prior Hebrew terms translated by the LXX with smaragdos, and in Rev 4:3 he is consequently not attempting to refer to the modern emerald but rather to a particular quality of a certain Hebrew gemstone, that is, its ability to shine, gleam, glitter, or flash. This conclusion would solve the problem of the oxymoronic “emerald” rainbow and expand the lexical range of the adjective smaragdinos.
|
The Pauline kanôn: With Special Reference to 2 Corinthians
Program Unit: Paul and Pauline Literature
Sean F. Winter, University of Divinity, Melbourne
Paul refers to his ?a??? in two (or possibly three) of his letters (Gal 6:12; 2 Cor 10:13, 15; cf. the variant in Phil 3:16). The usage in 2 Cor 10:12–17 is especially puzzling to commentators. In this paper I argue that greater attention to the nuances of Paul’s usage in Galatians helps us to understand the possible signification of the occurrences in 2 Corinthians. The similar epistolary contexts of the two letters (conflictual situation, the presence of ‘opponents’ in the community, Paul’s apostolic self-defense) suggest the possibility of an equivalent sense for Paul’s appeal to a ?a??? in each case. While in Gal 6:16 the term is clearly linked to the response of the Galatian Christ-believers to Paul’s proclamation of the new creation (see Gal. 6.15), most commentators read 2 Cor 10:13, 15 with reference to either the geographical or specifically apostolic aspects of Paul’s ministry in Corinth. In contrast to these views, I argue that the Pauline ?a??? in Corinth is primarily the Pauline gospel itself (see 2 Cor. 10.14, 16), understood as the key criterion against which the behaviour of Paul’s opponents, Paul’s apostolic ministry, and the response of the Corinthian Christ-believers, is to be judged. Thus, the term in 2 Corinthians 10.13, 15 should not be translated ‘field’, nor understood only with reference to Paul’s foundation of the Corinthian Christ-assembly. Instead it refers to a Pauline version of what later become known as the ‘rule’ of faith, by means of which the actions of Paul, his opponents and the Corinthians can be appropriately judged.
|
O sententiam necessitate confusam! (Tertullian, Apol. 2.8): A Disillusioned Look at Pliny, Ep. 10.96-97
Program Unit: Graeco-Roman Society (EABS)
Stephan Witetschek, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
A small part of the younger Pliny's correspondence with the Emperor Trajan, Epistles 10,96-97 has acquired great significance in the study of early Christianity, especially with regard to the question of persecutions or other pressure from outside. In some sectors of scholarship, these two letters are even considered to be the necessary precondition for the writing of 1 Peter and/or Revelation. This paper is intended to offer a more sober interpretation of the two letters within the context of Book 10 of Pliny's letters. This includes a reassessment of the question whether Trajan's reply qualifies as a "rescriptum" in the technical sense, i.e. as establishing a new legal situation. At the same time, the role of “soft” factors in the situation of Ep. 96 needs to be reassessed.
|
Jesus the Sage and His Provocative Parables
Program Unit: Study of the Historical Jesus (EABS)
Ben Witherington, III, Asbury Theological Seminary & St. Andrews University
In the last 30 years of New Testament scholarship about the historical Jesus and his teachings and ministry, one of the most fruitful avenues of study that has shed increasing light on the actual historical character of Jesus and his ministry is evaluating Jesus as a sage, a conveyor of godly wisdom, and evaluating his parables, aphorisms, and riddles as early Jewish wisdom speech. This paper further explores this trajectory of New Testament scholarship, focusing both on the issue of the character of sapiential language and how it should and should not be evaluated, and the unique use of that language by Jesus to talk about God’s coming eschatological Dominion or Kingdom. While previous Jewish sages had told parables about God’s eternal kingship or reign, before Jesus’ time, apparently none had used wisdom speech to describe God’s current in-breaking eschatological work of salvation among God’s people. And yet Jesus offers up a sort of revelatory wisdom that is not self-evident. He is not drawing wisdom from the analysis of nature or human nature (like e.g. the writers of Proverbs), but rather from God’s special revelation about his salvific purposes for humankind. Jesus then was an apocalyptic sage, much like Daniel, offering a wisdom that God had to reveal or else it could not be known, even through detailed study of nature and human nature.
Focusing on Mark 4 and the parable of the sower, this paper reveals how ancient parables work, and what they tell us about Jesus’ teaching ministry, and indeed his own intentions and self-understanding.
|
Legal Metaphor in the Book of Job
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Wisdom
Emily Worsley, Memorial University of Newfoundland
This paper will examine the function of legal metaphor in the Book of Job. Many scholars have drawn attention to the use of legal language in Job, as the text makes use of ryb language common in other biblical texts. It also uses defensive and judicial imagery throughout the narrative which seems to fit with a legal metaphor. Some have assigned Job the category of “lawsuit drama.” In order to discern where Job fits in the legal tradition this paper will employ a comparative approach, looking at key features of legal metaphor in the Hebrew Bible, with special attention to ryb instances. While I do not think that Job ultimately fits into any “ryb genre” (nor should it be considered a lawsuit drama), it does contain a curious amount of legal language and metaphor which requires further attention. I will look at how Job differs from what has typically been considered legal or lawsuit texts from both the biblical and Ancient Near-Eastern tradition. While Job does not fit into the category of most legal texts or lawsuit dramas, as has been proposed, it does quite successfully use this category as an educative tool. My assertion is that although Job uses legal metaphor and has features in common with other these other texts, the way in which Job uses them is highly unconventional and therefore deserving of special attention. Job does not use legal metaphor to make causal claims or proscriptions. Rather, the Book of Job uses legal metaphor as a template to transcend these traditional categories and world views.
|
Hosea in Holy Wedlock: An Enneagram Analysis
Program Unit: Psychological Hermeneutics of Biblical Themes and Texts
Ruthanne Wrobel, Independent Scholar
As a dedicated prophet of the Lord, residing in the Northern Kingdom of Israel, Hosea strongly denounced societal corruption and religious apostasy. Suddenly, his prophetic mission took an unforeseen turn, through marriage to Gomer, a woman who would abandon her husband, family and faith. Emotional extremes in this story of love lost, found, forsaken and forgiven have perplexed scholars and readers for generations. This personality profile, based on the Enneagram, examines the relationship between the prophet, Hosea, and his wayward wife, as expressed in Hosea chapters 1 to 3. From an Enneagram perspective, Hosea aligns with most biblical prophets as an exemplar of a highly principled type One, an upright champion of integrity and propriety. Within a One, a relentless critic works to police personal oversights and point out others’ mistakes. United in holy wedlock, this censorious type One (Hosea) clashes with his wife, a dramatic, romantic type Four (Gomer). Seeing things differently, imaginative Fours yearn to express themselves in contradictory, unconventional ways. Needing to feel special and unique leads them to bend or ignore rules of ordinary, polite society. Through countless studies of relationship dynamics, psychologist Helen Palmer, uncovered volatile emotional lives among One-Four couples. She described cycles of push-pull tactics that are confusing and heart-wrenching to both partners as Ones criticize and Fours over-dramatize (Palmer, 1995, 263). Yet, for Enneagram authors, Don Riso and Russ Hudson, Ones and Fours have much to learn from each other. Through opening the heart to compassion, Ones learn to trust intuition rather than rules, while Fours find beauty in the sanctity in divine Love with a higher purpose. (Riso, Hudson, 2000, 321, 325). Reviewing Hosea’s marital woes through the lens of the Enneagram holds promise for comprehending the course of love in this story, specific, universal, troubled and true.
|
Stroking the Flame: How Hosea’s Words Ring True for Leonard Cohen
Program Unit: Biblical Characters in Three Traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam)
Ruthanne Wrobel, Independent Scholar
The story of Hosea’s marriage to Gomer is an eloquent account of courtship, marriage, broken promises and redeeming love. The crises in Hosea’s life were both personal and political; as the Lord chose to love his people, so the prophet remained loyal to his wayward wife. The great divide between man and woman, the joyous dance of desire followed by dark nights of censure and solitude are striking themes in the writings of Hosea. Parallels are ever present in his world between hearth and home, earth and heaven. His words testify to the writer’s passage through a literary landscape where autobiography meets allegory, where historical prose becomes poetry. How Hosea’s marital relations as symbolic, prophetic actions were perceived in his day cannot be known, but their legacy and reception history traverse the ages. Current expressions of Hosea’s creative influence resound through the words of Canadian poet and songwriter, Leonard Cohen. At the heart of Cohen’s opus is the task of recording one man’s struggles in matters of the heart. For over five decades, this self-styled prophet of pain and pleasure has tracked his relations in love with various companions. Through listening and close reading, this literary study examines passages from Hosea and Leonard Cohen, artists whose compositions transcend barriers between private and public, sensual and sacred, personal experience and cosmic catastrophe. Sounds are as important as imagery in these texts. As wedding bells, shouting crowds, alarms, drums and thunder assault the ears, “every heart” longs for love, but “like a refugee.” (L. Cohen, “Anthem,” 1992.) The ring of truth in Hosea’s voice may be amplified anew through the chords and refrains of a modern master of soulful tunes.
|
Is Belief Knowledge or Experience? A Comparative Analysis of the Works on Ethics by al-Makki and Bahya Ibn Baquda
Program Unit: Quran and Islamic Tradition in Comparative Perspective
Saeko Yazaki, University of Glasgow
This paper examines the important concept of knowledge found in Qut al-qulub (“The Nourishment of Hearts”), an early Sufi guidebook on mysticism and morals by Abu Talib al-Makki (d. 996), and al-Hidaya ila fara'id al-qulub (“The Right Guidance to the Religious Duties of Hearts”), a Jewish classic on ethics by the Andalusian jurist Bahya Ibn Baquda (d. after 1080). In the Sufi tradition, two types of knowledge ('ilm and ma'rifa) are often discussed. The former designates acquired, intellectual knowledge, while the latter signifies gnosis or mystical knowledge which is bestowed through first-hand experience of God. In general, Ibn Baquda seems to differentiate between these two terms in accord with their general use among Sufis. Both al-Makki and Ibn Baquda state that 'ilm is "the life of hearts," and regard ma'rifa as the goal of the path to the Divine. Throughout both works, the importance of the true understanding of the essence and meaning of God, tawhid, is emphasized. This paper goes on to examine two other concepts, reason and nafs (self or soul), as the paths to acquire the experiential knowledge of tawhid, and identify where this putative parallel breaks down. In the Qut al-qulub, reason is described as twofold. It can be useful and harmful, since reason belongs to this world, with nafs and Satan. This is significantly different from what Ibn Baquda believes. To him, reason is vital. Humans are rational beings and he insists that the basis of the heart's obligations lies in reason, and uses nafs interchangeably with the heart, as opposed to the body. Through an exploration of rational knowledge and experiential knowledge, this paper discusses the meaning of faith in the two influential books on ethics and spirituality in their respective traditions.
|
The Fiery Ordeal: An American Anabaptist Reads 1 Peter with Egyptian Christians
Program Unit: New Testament/Early Christianity/Rabbinic Studies (EABS)
Joshua Yoder, Evangelical Theological Seminary in Cairo
For Egyptian Christians, the reference in 1 Peter 4:12 to a “fiery ordeal” has taken on very concrete significance. On 14 August 2013 crowds of men attacked Christian churches across Egypt, looting and burning them. The attacks represented a reprisal for the removal of President Mohammed Morsi by the Egyptian military, in which Christians were seen as playing a key role, and a reaction to the violent dispersal of pro-Morsi protesters who had occupied public squares in Cairo and its environs. Dozens of churches across the spectrum of Christian traditions--Orthodox, Catholic and Evangelical--were damaged, and some were completely destroyed. Christians’ homes, businesses and property also suffered attacks. Several people were killed in the violence. The Egyptian churches seem to have heeded the admonition offered in 1 Peter that “those suffering in accordance with God’s will” should “entrust themselves to a faithful Creator, while continuing to do good” (4:19). Christians have not retaliated, but have instead expressed their readiness to suffer if necessary. This paper is an exercise in contextual hermeneutics. It examines how, on the one hand, the advice of 1 Peter and its theology of suffering has influenced the decisions Christians have made in response to the attacks as well as their understanding of and attitude toward their circumstances. On the other hand, it examines how the situation of the Egyptian churches has influenced their reading of 1 Peter. Finally, the use and understanding of 1 Peter in the author’s own Anabaptist tradition, with its theology of the cross, provides a comparative contextual reading. The paper closes with an assessment of the insights the process has yielded into the dynamics, advantages, and pitfalls of contextual interpretation.
|
One Stone, Seven Eyes: What Did Zechariah Mean?
Program Unit: Ancient Near Eastern Iconography and the Bible
Jonathan Yogev, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
The image of the stone that has seven eyes, which appears in Zech 3:9; 4:10, has puzzled many scholars. Some say it is a plummet, building block or a special jewel. Others say that the seven eyes are seven jewels, seven planets or just a symbolic image. The interpretations are many. Is it possible that the image of the stone was based on known iconography from the time and place of Zechariah? In my paper I deal with these varying interpretations, and suggest that the most reasonable solution may be based on images from Babylonian cylinder seals.
|
Numerical Sayings in the Literatures of the Ancient Near East, in Hebrew Scripture, and in Rabbinic Literature
Program Unit: Judaica
Shamir Yona, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
Numerical sayings are among the most well-known and most frequently attested rhetorical devices in the literatures of the ANE, Hebrew Scripture, and Rabbinic Literature. These patterns include pairs of incrementally ascending numbers such as two - three, three- four, and the like as well as the phenomenon of texts which are made up of a stereotypic number of units such as the Ten Commandments (Exodus 20 ; Deuteronomy 5). The stereotypical numbers of units serve a mnemonic purpose. Numerical patterns are found also in the literatures of the ancient Near East such as the Aramaic Proverbs of Ahiqar. Rabbinic Literature attests to a variety of usages of numerical patterns. First and foremost, in the Ethics of the Fathers we have frequent use of numerical sayings, as, for example, in the opening lines of the First Chapter: "They [the people of the Great Assembly] said three things: Be deliberate in judgment; raise up many disciples, and make a fence around the Torah." At the beginning of the second chapter of the Ethics of the Fathers Rabbi Judah the Patriarch is quoted as saying, "Look upon three things, and you will not fall into sin". The third chapter also opens with a similar statement attributed to Akabya son of Mahallel. A similar use of a numerical pattern is found in the words of Rabbi Simeon in Avot 4:13 while most of the sayings in Avot, Chapter 5 are built upon numerical patterns of descending numbers (to be contrasted with the ascending patterns known from Hebrew Scripture). In our lecture we shall survey the use of numerical patterns in Hebrew Scripture and cognate literature and concentrate on the development of such patterns in Rabbinic Literature.
|
Syntactic Defamiliarisation and the Chiastic Structure of Prov 1:20-33
Program Unit: Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Wisdom
Bálint Károly Zabán, Hungarian Reformed Church
Scholars have remarked upon the difference between the language employed in the poetry of the Hebrew Bible and its prose. In terms of grammar a couple of variations may be mentioned that are characteristic of the poetic genre. These are the less frequent usage of the definite article, the object marker, the relative pronoun and the wayyiqtol verb-form. Sappan went as far as to say that one may talk about a Dialectus Poetica separate from the standard language of Biblical prose. It is not necessary to hold such an exaggerated view to notice these variations. Watson, in his well-known manual on Hebrew poetry, enumerates nineteen characteristics or indicators of the poetic genre. These indicators in poetic texts are often explained as the defamiliarisation or foregrounding of the language.
The different defamiliarised aspects of Hebrew poetry may be grouped on the basis of the level of language they affect. Some of these may pertain to sound, words, and form of words and others to the ordering of words. Therefore, one may suggest a four-fold classification of poetic aspects on the grounds of phonological, lexical, morphological, and syntactic considerations. The lexical and morphological defamiliarisation concerns the choice of one word over another or one form over another, whereas the syntactic defamiliarisation is concerned with the arrangement of words in a certain way.
This paper retains a two-fold scope. First, to offer a brief presentation of syntactic defamiliarisation within the Hebrew poetic text of Proverbs 1:20-33 by highlighting and explicating the unmarked (or standard/non marqué/unmarkierten), marked (marqué/markiert, that is the departure from what is standard) and canonical (or predominant) order of clause constituents. Second, to argue that on the basis of the results of this presentation it is possible to offer some further evidence regarding the chiastic arrangement of Proverbs 1:20-33.
|
The Artemision in the Roman Era: New Results of Research within the Sanctuary of Artemis
Program Unit:
Lilli Zabrana, Austrian Archaeological Institute
After the Temple of Artemis in Ephesos lost its religious significance, the famous sanctuary fell victim to extensive stone robbery and had long since been forgotten. The foundations, covered by 8 m high earth levels, were rediscovered in the year 1869. In the following 125 years of research, the legendary temple of Artemis was always the focus of archaeological fieldwork, while the once densely built up sacred enclosure remained unexplored. In the year 2009, a project was initiated that focuses on the only still visible Roman structure within the area of the Artemision, which surprisingly was never examined in the past. The project concentrated at first on basic building-specific questions concerning function, dating, and history of use. The function of the building, which is southwest of the temple and often called the “Tribune,” could finally be clarified. Due to close typological parallels as well as equipment and furnishings, the building can be identified as a Roman odeion, a building type known as a venue for musical contests. The existence of such competitions as part of the holy games for Ephesian Artemis is testified by inscriptions mentioning victories of competitors at the musical contests of the Artemisia. Besides focusing on the building itself, the project aims to enlarge the research priority to include the history of Roman use of the entire sacred area.
|
Paul and the Pauline Letters in Islamic Polemical Works
Program Unit: Quran and Islamic Tradition in Comparative Perspective
Vevian F. Zaki, Freie Universität Berlin
Islamic polemical works against Christianity from the ninth to the fourteen centuries refer to al-Tawrat, al-Zabur, and al-Injil as the Quran considers them inspired books. Paul and the Pauline letters, although not explicitly mentioned in the Quran, are also referred to in these polemical works to a much lesser extent. This paper sheds light on the picture of Paul as he is envisioned in Islamic polemical works. It then examines some features of citations taken from his letters and the purposes they served in these works.
|
The Concretization of Metaphors and Metaphoric Language in the Hebrew Bible
Program Unit: Metaphors in the Hebrew Bible/Old Testament and Their Reception
Yair Zakovitch, Hebrew University of Jerusalem and IDC Hertzliya
One of the notable motives behind biblical interpretation is the desire for concretization. This aspiration has many expressions, such as the titles of psalms that connect them with specific events in the life of David, such as Psalms 3, 34; names that are given to anonymous characters, such as the name given to Samson’s mother, Tzlelponi (BT Baba Bathra 91a); or in giving a concrete interpretation to an abstract term, such as “terror”, eimah, in Exodus 23:27, which is interpreted in the next verse with tzira’, “hornet” (see also Deut 7:20; Josh 24:12).
In many cases where a metaphor is concretized, a story is expanded. The metaphor for human suffering, “sinking into slimy clay” (Ps 40:3 and 69:2, 15) inspired the description of Jeremiah who, having been thrown into a pit, begins to sink into the mud (Jer 38:6). The metaphoric expression in the moral of Jotham’s fable, “may fire issue from Abimelech and consume the citizens of Shechem and Beth-millo . . .” (Judg 9:20), is interpreted by an entire scene that was added to the story of Abimelech, the burning of the tower of Shechem (ibid., 46-49).
Metaphor concretization, a widespread phenomenon in the Bible, continued into Second Temple Period literature, New Testament, midrash, and Jewish art.
The lecture, in which I will discuss a variety of examples, shows how the impulse for concretization crosses borders of genre and time, and that, in fact, there is no difference, in this regard, between inner- and extra-biblical interpretation.
|
Architecture, Space, and Liturgy: Reflections on Results from Kinneret Regional Project's 2010–2013 Excavations in the Byzantine Synagoue at Horvat Kur (Galilee)
Program Unit: Judaica
Jürgen K. Zangenberg, Universiteit Leiden
Between 2010 and 2013 and under the auspices of Kinneret Regional Project (www.kinneret-excavations.org), a team from Bern, Helsinki and Leiden Universities, joined by Wofford College in 2012, has been excavating a synagogue from the Byzantine period at the ancient village site of Horvat Kur, a hill located ca. 2 km west of the Lake of Galilee. Though only partly preserved, the building shows a number of unique features, like the first "Seat of Moses" ever found in situ in the north of Israel, an enigmatic, decorated basalt stone table, two very different coin deposits and a quite unusual architectural layout. The paper will present the latest results of the excavations at Horvat Kur, including results from the 2014 study season targeting at the preparation of the final report about the finds and findings in the synagogue building and its surroundings.
|
Trial, Divine Knowledge, and Providence: A Reading on the First Part of Maimonides’ Interpretation of the Binding of Isaac
Program Unit: Judaica
Ying Zhang, East China Normal University
Maimonides’ interpretation of the Akedah (the Binding of Isaac) in the Guide of the Perplexed III 24 concerns both the issue of trial and the truth of prophecy. It can be seen that, for Maimonides, the issue of trial is closely related to divine omniscience, which, together with divine omnipotence, belongs to his treatment of providence (III 8-24). According to Maimonides, the meaning of the Akedah does not consist in God’s testing Abraham so that He become to know his faithfulness and obedience, nor does it inform the future reward of Abraham. Rather, it aims at making "our" religious community known the limit of fearing God. By transferring the subject of knowing in trial from God to human, Maimonides consciously avoids the deficiency of divine knowledge implied in the external meaning of the biblical texts. In contrast to this exoteric reading of the Akedah, Maimonides’ theoretical discussion of divine knowledge (III 16, 19-21) appears more obscure. On the one hand, he attempts to refute the opinion of some philosophers that God lacks the knowledge of human individuals, which is based on the fact that good men suffer and evil men prosper. Furthermore, Maimonides asserts that divine knowledge is beyond human apprehension, since God’s knowledge is His essence, which cannot be understood by human intellect. On the other hand, Maimonides’ support for the omniscience seems not without any reservation, for he insists that God’s knowledge of all the beings does not abolish their nature, i.e. their possibilities to be produced or not. Nevertheless, by stating that neither the opinion of the philosophers nor “our” opinion can be demonstrated concerning the issue of divine knowledge, Maimonides prudently set a limit on human reason. It is in this sense, he is said to be the true defender of both the Law and philosophy.
|
Archaeological Evidence of Private Worship and House Cult in Terrace House 2
Program Unit:
Norbert Zimmermann, Austrian Academy of Sciences
In the seven peristyle houses that form the insula of Terrace House 2, a broad variety of different evidences for private worship and house cult has been uncovered. The documentation extends from architectural settings like cult rooms and cultic niches with paintings or statuettes, and small finds like little altars and images of deities to ritual objects like thymiateria and deposits of offerings. This rich material will be discussed in its character, in the topography of the houses and in the role they played in the inhabitant’s’ life.
|
Genesis 38:1-11 – Story of Sibling Rivalry?
Program Unit: Pentateuch (Torah)
Yisca Zimran, Bar-Ilan University
Gen 38:1-11 describes the period between the birth of the three sons of Judah and the departure of his daughter-in-law Tamar from his home. The verses encompass Er’s marriage, his death, the request that Onan enter into a levirate marriage, the death of Onan, and the fear that Shelah will die prematurely. As a rule these verses are perceived as exposition, of secondary importance to the story of Judah and Tamar that extends from verse 12 to 30 in the same chapter.
My lecture focuses on verses 1-11 as an independent unit. I will present the plot of the unit, the relationships between the characters, and the worldviews that dictate their actions. For this purpose I will draw a comparison between this story and other biblical stories that belong in the literary genre of Sibling Rivalry. These stories, dealing with the struggle of brothers to establish their status in the paternal home, all follow an identical literary pattern. I will point out the similarities and differences between Gen 38:1-11 and stories of sibling rivalry. I will also demonstrate how these similarities and differences shed light on the plot of the story and facilitate a more accurate interpretation of the verses. This analysis of Gen 38:1-11 will illuminate aspects of the story which are not usually emphasized, thus reinforcing the premise that this unit also stands by itself.
|
The Nature of the Septuagint Version of the Book of Leviticus
Program Unit: Septuagint Studies
Moshe A. Zipor, Bar-Ilan University
This paper describes the characteristics of this corpus, its language and its translation techniques, which move between literal and free renditions, following various textual or exegetical traditions, sometimes keeping stereotypic equivalence, and in other cases seeming to find bizarre solutions to the Hebrew text. For example, the same Hebrew term kil'ayim appears thrice in one verse, but is translated in three various ways. Similarly, the verb ??? whenever it comes together with the noun ??? is contextually rendered in various meanings. In some cases we find adaptation of the halacha and in others we find an anti-halachic tendencies. Here and there the translator neglects the text ad loc. and refers seemingly to the text of Deuteronomy instead. We shall demonstrate various peculiarities of this translation and offer to them a due explanation. The paper concludes with consideration of the text-critical value of this corpus with due illustration.
|
The Earliest History of Israel?
Program Unit: Israel in the Ancient Near East (EABS)
Wolfgang Zwickel, Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz
Manfred Görg proposed to read the name Israel on a broken Egyptian inscription (ÄA 21687), which is now in the stores of the New Museum in Berlin. New research in recent years has confirmed this reading, although the writing of the name is different from that in the Merenptah inscription. Some hints demonstrate that this inscription is older than the 'Israel stela' of Merenptah and can likely be dated to the early 13th century BCE. The paper will present some ideas about such an early beginning of a group called Israel and about the way it was established.
|
Family Ties and Literary in the Book of Genesis
Program Unit: Stylistics and the Hebrew Bible
Anne-Laure Zwilling, Centre Nationnal de la Recherche Scientifique & University of Strasbourg
Brothers are an important feature of the book of Genesis, and familial and brotherly relations play an important part in the book. The literary dimension of the sibling relationship, and the family nexus, have often been explored for each of the narratives found in the book. However, the literary organisation of the topic of family in the entire book remains to be examined. As regards families, the different stories of Genesis refer to one another, creating thus a complex and dynamic pattern of relationship. Bonds and enmities, rivalry and solidarity, secrets and treasons, split and reunion. a lot is happening. The intertextual references take part in depicting and establishing the family network, and this in turn provides a certain picture of the family. This presentation aims at exploring the links established between the different family narratives in the book of Genesis, and studying how this literary construction establishes a certain definition of families and family relationship.
|
| |
|
|